id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11457v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11457v2
|
When Do LLMs Need Retrieval Augmentation? Mitigating LLMs' Overconfidence Helps Retrieval Augmentation
| 2024-02-18T04:57:19 | 2024-06-11T08:08:47 |
Shiyu Ni, Keping Bi, Jiafeng Guo, Xueqi Cheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have been found to have difficulty knowing they
do not possess certain knowledge and tend to provide specious answers in such
cases. Retrieval Augmentation (RA) has been extensively studied to mitigate
LLMs' hallucinations. However, due to the extra overhead and unassured quality
of retrieval, it may not be optimal to conduct RA all the time. A
straightforward idea is to only conduct retrieval when LLMs are uncertain about
a question. This motivates us to enhance the LLMs' ability to perceive their
knowledge boundaries to help RA. In this paper, we first quantitatively measure
LLMs' such ability and confirm their overconfidence. Then, we study how LLMs'
certainty about a question correlates with their dependence on external
retrieved information. We propose several methods to enhance LLMs' perception
of knowledge boundaries and show that they are effective in reducing
overconfidence. Additionally, equipped with these methods, LLMs can achieve
comparable or even better performance of RA with much fewer retrieval calls.
|
[
-0.7032524347,
-0.689653933,
0.9315468669,
0.0002187312,
-0.1090941355,
0.2165706605,
-0.2398795485,
-0.8405874968,
0.0837477669,
0.4016389251,
-0.4307549298,
-0.1641925722,
-0.623305738,
0.1196579561,
-0.1516459882,
0.5892124176,
0.1339417547,
0.0933439732,
-0.7124645114,
0.0532824248,
-0.5009132624,
-0.5055894256,
-0.5665202737,
-0.5821605921,
0.3455392718,
0.418577075,
0.8457906246,
0.3584366441,
0.653191328,
0.3165605664,
-0.2851825953,
0.5843915343,
-0.522375226,
0.3355661333,
-0.2630989254,
-0.9673406482,
-0.0957522392,
-0.2344457954,
0.5830330253,
0.8620370626,
-0.1359725595,
-0.1102881134,
0.0547733717,
0.7985000014,
-1.1138130426,
-0.0395169966,
-0.7317935228,
0.0499157757,
-0.0649803951,
-0.3894872069,
-0.200461328,
-0.4550154507,
0.2552044988,
-0.6171459556,
-0.1034635454,
0.2653703988,
0.6229043603,
0.4793404639,
-0.5116665363,
-0.1261990517,
-0.8734427094,
0.7610321641,
-0.490876019,
0.6626805067,
0.8126305938,
0.2091687769,
-0.2996888459,
-0.5216092467,
-0.3613841236,
-0.5243937373,
-0.1790565103,
0.0686289594,
-0.1310629398,
0.2108814269,
0.5201830268,
0.5575851202,
-0.2185945511,
0.0127171036,
-0.4374958575,
-0.2972535491,
0.4948444366,
0.1077372134,
0.009363546,
-0.0507361665,
-0.4561272264,
0.0922437981,
-0.800340414,
-0.0593347028,
0.2666033208,
-0.1660834849,
0.539470315,
0.9065666795,
-0.2156549096,
0.5488987565,
0.0938772336,
-0.0036389022,
0.2073397934,
-0.2178722918,
-0.0006012172,
0.1070388258,
0.2557506263,
0.2479337007,
0.2801528573,
-0.1782519966,
-0.4287046492,
-0.0383034535,
0.4325184524,
-0.7908560634,
0.1039319709,
0.319671005,
-0.1225935072,
0.1195572242,
0.0390970483,
-0.3469961882,
-0.6493422389,
-0.3644968271,
0.8216363192,
-0.5968236923,
-0.2093723565,
0.1710187644,
-0.2853264511,
0.1340696365,
0.4933075607,
-0.6196032166,
0.3276860416,
0.6555015445,
0.6952059269,
-0.166227445,
-0.0031721198,
-0.5387548804,
0.1453925967,
-0.5748731494,
0.7360767126,
-0.635220468,
-0.5469201207,
-0.0876313671,
-0.2229215354,
0.044003129,
-0.7284344435,
0.5757024884,
-0.8414227366,
0.2324341834,
-0.6947010159,
-0.8947682977,
-0.311188072,
0.3408961594,
-0.4835852981,
1.0257745981,
0.0195300598,
-0.7174783349,
0.24790968,
-0.3063586354,
-0.5065418482,
0.0717599019,
-0.2515887618,
-0.0707687512,
0.4060465991,
0.3814323545,
0.0996500626,
-0.0381262898,
-0.1560902148,
-0.2258230597,
-0.5046511889,
0.6535231471,
-0.390445143,
0.345992595,
0.2099391073,
0.1067057103,
-0.2704354823,
-0.4873066843,
0.1758208871,
-0.3038937449,
-0.2181012779,
-0.7152726054,
0.0308107119,
-0.6311504841,
-0.0713108703,
0.5143905878,
-0.6535221338,
0.0173286404,
-0.7744715214,
0.0453868471,
0.6391780972,
0.2637189031,
0.4657737613,
-0.6678453088,
0.4864817858,
-0.1015683785,
0.1265150607,
0.1323180199,
-0.3444454074,
-0.8101914525,
-0.0209620316,
-0.0049687792,
0.5895084739,
-0.8604387045,
0.3344579339,
0.017863445,
-0.478374064,
-0.6283788085,
0.3110064268,
0.2597304881,
0.4286490083,
0.6552501917,
-0.1642394066,
-0.8155504465,
-0.6867838502,
-0.0845286772,
-0.1582435071,
-0.0386558324,
0.4948162735,
0.3665904403,
-0.0904009193,
0.9125037789,
-0.6925588846,
-0.4770819843,
-0.2032207698,
-0.0713566169,
-0.0002470781,
0.3476023376,
0.22092399,
-0.9454986453,
-0.0473643951,
0.0130993184,
-0.7386038303,
0.0122091034,
-0.0406469256,
-0.0274829827,
0.2726729512,
0.6567054987,
-0.8913926482,
0.2595516741,
0.1824771911,
0.1411426812,
0.4146611392,
-0.5263794661,
0.119898878,
-0.7100347281,
-0.0841672644,
-0.1419560909,
-0.1954749674,
-0.3428278565,
0.190147683,
0.0418287441,
0.3671644926,
-0.2063682973,
0.5186917186,
-0.7081457376,
-0.2034783363,
-0.4315713346,
0.4791119397,
0.1840425581,
-0.0183586683,
-0.0531206615,
0.8759111762,
0.5559533238,
-0.7421004176,
0.3677894473,
0.2414764613,
-0.4006802142,
0.6648751497,
-0.4247673452,
0.1344473064,
-0.4456925094,
0.1556546241,
-1.1849820614,
-0.148672685,
0.1100628525,
-0.6539728642,
0.4408200979,
-0.0101793138,
-0.2385168374,
-0.4137706757,
-0.4895472229,
0.3021296859,
0.4611701369,
-0.4940626025,
0.6589797735,
0.2651722729,
-0.0248677209,
-0.8163881302,
-0.8290317655,
0.114238821,
-0.0557576083,
-0.4763313532,
0.4157071114,
-0.2909755707,
-0.4093500972,
-0.0238808282,
-0.4020218551,
0.1065092757,
0.0925652683,
0.1499407142,
0.2604145408,
-0.1356654167,
0.5632691979,
-0.0859897509,
-0.0714471489,
0.2898382843,
-0.1923043579,
0.4668776095,
0.0698474497,
-0.6810541749,
-0.0263699815,
0.0737414435,
0.2798374891,
-0.3541529775,
0.8210255504,
0.538007915,
-0.5562883019,
0.0189440269,
-1.2266926765,
-0.6001740694,
-0.5083956718,
0.3139956295,
-0.330896914,
-0.9260546565,
0.6486321688,
0.0118835988,
-0.3602953553,
0.2728143632,
0.3401167095,
-0.1044574082,
0.9808701873,
0.4395285249,
-0.0611397736,
0.4663029909,
-0.0635944232,
-0.0317198299,
-1.0902336836,
-0.4766729474,
-0.4916766584,
-0.1500136107,
-0.5950501561,
-0.4642204344,
0.5437095165,
0.1087834686,
0.0639177039,
-0.0989513099,
-0.3408607543,
0.6223350763,
0.437405169,
0.6037500501,
0.5322650671,
-0.0558846816,
0.013667766,
-0.2660281062,
-0.4833535552,
-0.0349923782,
0.9902492762,
0.3091855645,
1.0704915524,
0.0926977918,
0.5112038851,
0.157132715,
0.0196998212,
-0.8691173792,
0.5691426396,
0.2054324597,
-0.7420461178,
-0.4062351584,
-0.6700729728,
-0.8576494455,
0.2118960917,
-0.4500384033,
-0.7350266576,
0.3515406847,
0.0409565307,
-0.5825340152,
0.056870643,
-0.5127993822,
0.1374855638,
-0.2165969759,
-0.4712379277,
-0.3950780928,
-0.5765603185,
0.3902573586,
-0.1738189608,
0.0011593978,
0.2238450646,
-0.4148109555,
0.3923686743,
-0.4087153673,
0.7168622613,
-0.023102887,
-0.1787628978,
0.3044237494,
0.1122161075,
0.860255003,
-0.0147187477,
-0.2235819399,
-0.3364745378,
-0.0845623538,
-0.032490585,
-1.0029848814,
0.7081140876,
-0.6194483638,
-1.0140777826,
-0.354731679,
-0.5362904668,
-0.4507572949,
-0.0083047636,
0.295981288,
0.2184235156,
0.1102468967,
0.3239190876,
0.9999801517,
-0.1206280068,
0.0468621179,
0.4675544798,
-0.3939923942,
-0.3387385905,
0.7104777694,
0.4939031303,
0.4031812549,
0.4173104167,
0.1520884484,
-0.7257228494,
-0.707147181,
-0.0170035381,
0.2493203133,
-0.8564803004,
-0.3644787967,
-0.7167884111,
-0.5388447046,
-0.3463253379,
0.1848819554,
-0.189161405,
-0.496904999,
-0.2797774673,
-0.402425766,
0.7577331662,
0.6285667419,
-0.2861766219,
0.1704718322,
-0.7805883884,
0.2310062796,
0.3722498119,
0.2432542741,
0.0494817272,
-0.7917329073,
-0.2540747821,
0.1753353775,
-0.141930297,
-0.7474820018,
0.2577805221,
0.209169969,
0.8528447747,
0.3269881308,
0.4140233397,
0.8545004725,
-0.0969365761,
0.4415309131,
-0.2746208906,
-0.8523760438,
0.52926898,
0.068093881,
0.0711962506,
0.4030332565,
0.5853167176,
-0.2623171508,
-0.6377971172,
-0.367562294,
-0.9708462954,
0.3454227448,
0.2116336823,
0.272277385,
-0.0252760258,
0.6263561845,
-0.1932349503,
0.3885527253,
-0.442160666,
-0.1458064616,
0.1341853738,
0.2238923609,
0.0028375615,
-0.5039131045,
-0.2323226333,
-0.2000262588,
0.6076077819,
-0.0266195163,
0.0264537092,
0.5422300696,
-0.2247752547,
-0.5104131103,
0.2942801118,
0.6529268026,
0.8351734877,
-0.4325838983,
0.2844513655,
0.6480666399,
-0.4429839849,
-0.0402707644,
0.0927289352,
-0.015490544,
-0.3045269847,
0.2752634585,
0.663695097,
-0.0251399186,
-0.5961818695,
0.4411103427,
0.2856635749,
0.1171658859,
-0.4462878108,
0.1818499863,
0.0047482769,
0.5868082643,
0.6974819899,
0.1093409732,
0.2960041463,
-0.5472150445,
0.3068487346,
0.8169905543,
-0.3073108792,
0.1556426138,
0.3771835268,
-0.2209698707,
-0.1183884293,
0.5274756551,
-0.1945806444,
-0.6246908903,
0.3610144556,
0.6538472772,
0.4611178935,
-0.315743506,
-0.0716331676,
0.2803671658,
0.5508845448,
-0.2923817933,
0.3016745448,
0.0632657707,
-0.880063951,
-0.7195422053,
-0.3014529347,
-0.5136287808,
0.0428717136,
-0.7949428558,
-0.0007528598,
-0.4135014713,
-0.3597665727,
-0.4887318015,
0.1998510957,
-0.3205754161,
0.3401931822,
0.0289021563,
0.9431189895,
-0.4504924119,
0.5882233381,
0.5173131824,
-0.4405935705,
-0.486594826,
-0.0242260341,
-0.192233175,
-1.0515625477,
0.5683825612,
0.0899105221,
-0.2497095019,
0.0605868436,
-0.5106505156,
-0.8331128359,
0.8575162292,
0.311986506,
-0.4939626753,
-0.0133896302,
0.0667822286,
0.6545500159,
-0.1243290454,
0.5449765325,
0.5290337205,
0.6644527316,
0.528354764,
-0.7020133734,
0.2040064037,
0.131391719,
-0.0728228986,
0.2437321693,
-0.428953439,
0.7487447262,
-0.6808409095,
-0.1197473854,
0.1005527154,
0.6710728407,
0.3384407759,
0.2419283986,
0.5257457495,
0.4254034758,
1.0031023026,
-0.0374105833,
1.0209406614,
-0.1186972708,
0.0811755732,
1.13481915,
-0.2181343585,
1.056256175,
0.6911994815,
-0.1267299056,
0.2104563564,
0.5306144953,
0.0528124608,
0.3780042529,
0.2674725354,
-0.3283457458,
-0.6610677838,
-0.5171114802,
-0.6375721097,
0.2981597185,
0.761570096,
-0.1755290776,
-0.1201269403,
0.2103176117,
-0.0874795914,
0.1953328252,
-0.2977415025,
0.8115317822,
0.3130997121,
-0.7028080821,
0.6654401422,
-0.3679478467,
0.5538778305,
-0.5957587361,
0.0609188899,
-0.3700806499,
0.2003633082,
-0.5070950985,
-1.1038279533,
0.2541116774,
-0.5215036869,
-0.0701923147,
0.2016161978,
0.9322360754,
-0.5335994959,
-0.499263823,
0.5481126308,
0.7734595537,
0.1093040928,
-0.5476118326,
-0.3915777206,
0.0347579494,
-0.1022162437,
-0.2761198282,
0.2095347792,
0.6929328442,
0.0077626766,
1.2140552998,
0.6605324149,
0.4545907676,
-0.0399511941,
0.0567889772,
1.0300309658,
-0.46828264,
-0.0035803432,
-0.9962188601,
0.2609628737,
-0.1313223988,
0.046858307,
0.9301959872,
0.5209076405,
0.7069612145,
0.2443582118,
0.7366444468,
0.1951755583,
0.5930854082,
-0.7695575356,
0.4719336629,
-0.853774488,
0.6007104516,
-0.0847647935,
-0.9910536408,
-0.2442942411,
0.662977159,
-0.5689038634,
0.3231500983,
0.5228326321,
1.1198728085,
0.1152231172,
-0.0165879335,
0.5737813115,
0.2937707305,
0.0662359223,
0.5500042439,
1.2755612135,
-0.3074193895,
0.7633146048,
-0.24545075,
0.0435017422,
-0.2968660295,
-0.6522922516,
-0.8205363154,
-0.3893955052,
-0.1182791218,
-0.3929582536,
0.2605594099,
1.0952092409,
0.4436402619,
-0.56865412,
-0.0103602912,
0.1563621163,
0.4135352969,
0.0997158587,
-0.2295419425,
0.0698748156,
-0.6500587463,
-0.4821428657,
0.4853561521,
0.1706101745,
0.3956244886,
-0.4143233597,
0.023122875,
-0.1751568019,
0.1879749596,
0.460757941,
0.1575435102,
-0.5909823179,
-0.5474683046,
0.2871618271,
-0.1847948134,
0.2714292407,
0.4668335915,
-0.8081731796,
0.4423374236,
0.5773447752,
0.7852079272,
0.4218907058,
0.2994696796,
0.6745193005,
-0.9399986267,
-0.0902126133,
0.2354224771,
0.3285263479,
0.4959711134,
-0.6822256446,
0.4436403811,
0.1293401718,
-0.6149386764,
-0.8396294117,
0.2351561338,
-0.6917728186,
-0.2204525918,
1.2096148729,
0.0698316246,
-0.028699195,
-0.2555213571,
-0.4922525585,
0.0705804899,
-0.3952151239,
0.8368690014,
0.8167668581,
-0.0742696449,
-0.3362079561,
-0.5248314738,
0.6133505106,
0.5671296716,
-0.745352149,
-0.0483079515,
0.3291498721,
0.0675632283,
0.4389434457,
0.4116437733,
0.1046713889,
0.143967092,
-0.2234230191,
-0.1727006435,
-0.0773598328,
-0.2075601369,
-0.126329422,
0.0254632458,
0.5033219457,
-0.1830521226
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11456v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11456v2
|
FactPICO: Factuality Evaluation for Plain Language Summarization of Medical Evidence
| 2024-02-18T04:45:01 | 2024-06-05T01:27:00 |
Sebastian Antony Joseph, Lily Chen, Jan Trienes, Hannah Louisa Göke, Monika Coers, Wei Xu, Byron C Wallace, Junyi Jessy Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Plain language summarization with LLMs can be useful for improving textual
accessibility of technical content. But how factual are these summaries in a
high-stakes domain like medicine? This paper presents FactPICO, a factuality
benchmark for plain language summarization of medical texts describing
randomized controlled trials (RCTs), which are the basis of evidence-based
medicine and can directly inform patient treatment. FactPICO consists of 345
plain language summaries of RCT abstracts generated from three LLMs (i.e.,
GPT-4, Llama-2, and Alpaca), with fine-grained evaluation and natural language
rationales from experts. We assess the factuality of critical elements of RCTs
in those summaries: Populations, Interventions, Comparators, Outcomes (PICO),
as well as the reported findings concerning these. We also evaluate the
correctness of the extra information (e.g., explanations) added by LLMs. Using
FactPICO, we benchmark a range of existing factuality metrics, including the
newly devised ones based on LLMs. We find that plain language summarization of
medical evidence is still challenging, especially when balancing between
simplicity and factuality, and that existing metrics correlate poorly with
expert judgments on the instance level.
|
[
0.019449072,
-0.4729481339,
0.9046056271,
0.4044113159,
-0.4534548819,
-0.1961419582,
-0.4481294155,
-0.3635982573,
0.2804256678,
0.3234244585,
-0.1173771545,
-0.7750484943,
-0.9064759612,
0.3372123837,
-0.1489076167,
1.6269725561,
-0.0929304585,
0.3181428015,
-0.3297805786,
-0.5145537257,
-0.1663386971,
-0.3261150122,
-0.1292354465,
0.0172695536,
0.5689322948,
0.3840535581,
0.6277263165,
0.6740655899,
0.8006246686,
0.3209064901,
-0.0860852972,
0.217227146,
-0.3891616464,
0.0614370145,
-0.2254371196,
-0.6768433452,
-0.4559432864,
0.1660063565,
0.3524251282,
0.599604547,
-0.2615282536,
0.0192596335,
-0.2246263772,
0.7170891166,
-0.642133534,
0.2251196504,
-0.5497954488,
0.0951885507,
-0.066999726,
-0.3526116014,
-0.2601569295,
-0.9562217593,
0.1963028163,
-0.7223672271,
0.5365246534,
0.3326309919,
0.8629573584,
0.3033008873,
-0.4749029279,
-0.6370999813,
-0.4046070278,
0.5375489593,
-0.8422736526,
0.1027695537,
-0.0400027335,
0.3231289387,
-0.2776432633,
-0.7237828374,
-0.4462878406,
-0.4166573286,
-0.3774902225,
0.4195046723,
0.0866829008,
0.100578323,
0.3954615593,
0.5157668591,
-0.48282969,
-0.1234687343,
-0.4144330919,
-0.53013587,
0.4746484458,
-0.0046533966,
0.3972870111,
-0.148652792,
-0.4508855939,
0.2213989645,
-0.7935026288,
-0.0976431742,
-0.1237486228,
0.0319523253,
-0.5138480067,
0.7895568013,
-0.1964431554,
0.2320926189,
-0.1137930229,
-0.7381472588,
0.1562008411,
-0.5400503874,
-0.0241226349,
0.1667161584,
0.7854055762,
0.7787283659,
0.0245138481,
-0.1090053767,
0.0398812778,
-0.1481268853,
-0.0602512285,
-0.7782118917,
-0.157502085,
0.492967695,
-0.4668185115,
-0.3256369531,
-0.0663886964,
-0.372553736,
-0.3918702006,
-0.0283377562,
0.0838625804,
-0.4144172668,
0.0225465503,
0.0649623424,
-0.2603920102,
-0.0878919736,
0.7339692116,
-0.4713451564,
0.510437429,
0.5667847395,
0.9378226995,
-0.407556504,
-0.1737241447,
-0.4647881091,
0.03726013,
-0.413074702,
1.196870327,
0.0009529454,
-0.2844887972,
-0.0955701917,
-0.0985879675,
-0.1870056242,
-0.4941040277,
1.0638564825,
-0.224131912,
0.3539323211,
-0.4418397844,
-0.7476431727,
-0.0875421837,
0.421790421,
-0.5433544517,
0.6132181883,
-0.2642592192,
-0.8365970254,
0.7674399614,
-0.4581278861,
-0.7068679929,
-0.0428719819,
-0.4657151401,
-0.5023420453,
0.2448638529,
0.0655593351,
0.2966100574,
-0.4166533947,
0.6348475814,
-0.1981745064,
-0.2850657403,
0.4429608583,
-0.295820713,
0.4376656711,
0.2961357534,
-0.2111642361,
0.0447727852,
-0.6888884902,
-0.3111267984,
-0.1026856452,
-0.5891962051,
-0.3066004515,
0.176408425,
-0.0371052586,
0.3282870948,
0.1597372144,
-0.5280190706,
0.0551613607,
-0.3722344339,
-0.0526440032,
0.2814633548,
0.2344868779,
-0.1199474633,
-0.5444051623,
0.0937604904,
-0.1648243368,
0.205090642,
0.0354224667,
-0.7121173739,
-0.4517716765,
-0.8143588305,
0.4510154426,
0.4833157957,
-0.6471092105,
0.4686960876,
-0.4545724094,
-0.1231474578,
-0.2344290614,
-0.1315005422,
0.5987027287,
0.8686093092,
0.2184101194,
-0.2576096356,
-0.3904128075,
-1.0457369089,
-0.4293772876,
-0.2079902291,
-0.1438767314,
0.1316244751,
0.7221520543,
0.2560464442,
0.6856172085,
-0.5670984387,
-0.2672304511,
-0.2161580324,
0.5244387388,
0.2697192132,
0.0435782447,
0.510771215,
-0.5862979293,
-0.1519036144,
-0.0147678647,
-0.8786420226,
-0.201355949,
-0.1216460913,
0.2683069706,
0.0971104205,
0.1974131912,
-0.6202385426,
0.3888072968,
0.3490954936,
0.0067725568,
0.4771907926,
-0.5679018497,
0.6130734086,
-0.6576457024,
0.2461434901,
0.0523029082,
-0.1256334931,
-0.4999088645,
-0.1163608059,
0.0489075221,
0.1941978186,
-0.4755951166,
0.3292357326,
-0.3074500859,
-0.0044816588,
-0.239142552,
0.3679850698,
-0.0217896663,
0.252782613,
0.0901022628,
0.7130504847,
0.1368971318,
-0.4340318143,
0.1142267659,
0.1347904205,
-0.397900492,
0.5887284279,
-0.7217645645,
-0.318721801,
-0.0164484922,
0.3918310702,
-0.8199234605,
-0.3679641485,
0.0514400527,
-0.4322172999,
0.0738957077,
-0.4246160984,
-0.400413394,
-0.0865272731,
-0.6840555668,
0.1910569072,
0.2180020362,
-0.1506160796,
0.1788019836,
0.3769831657,
-0.3414384723,
-0.6399865746,
-0.3482485116,
0.4555945098,
0.1530671865,
-0.3747491539,
0.1261412799,
0.024861861,
-0.3834964633,
-0.0291363876,
-0.2974937558,
-0.0662663952,
-0.030929707,
0.0655335933,
0.2999483645,
-0.2191364467,
0.1359473616,
0.3049010932,
0.1026211977,
0.3479858041,
0.3671414852,
0.0598352961,
-0.0203684252,
-0.4091875255,
-0.2618612051,
0.1136245206,
0.4996792376,
0.1849503368,
0.3755231202,
-0.0045631863,
-0.357411623,
0.148685202,
-0.5823184848,
0.0008825695,
-0.3058724999,
0.0929109901,
-0.1935486346,
-0.6925498843,
0.4096661508,
-0.2072458863,
0.1907952875,
0.6412342191,
0.6705133319,
-0.2946230471,
0.6592906713,
0.1541577727,
0.198324129,
-0.1899972707,
0.0206773505,
0.049762819,
-0.4551192522,
-0.3765721321,
-0.4179276526,
0.039008569,
-0.7475594878,
-0.5772540569,
0.6652050614,
-0.3444971442,
0.3669169545,
0.0173242502,
-0.1358362734,
0.4396954179,
0.2847316563,
0.2593019903,
0.8275879025,
-0.1632539183,
-0.1601956338,
-0.173404336,
-0.8253686428,
-0.6011272073,
1.2544088364,
0.2218818069,
0.4408103526,
0.0764240921,
0.5804368854,
0.4746245742,
0.84248209,
-0.9911239147,
0.4529096782,
-0.0572510436,
-0.8741865158,
-0.0117291119,
-0.4162709713,
-0.5565169454,
0.2421666384,
-0.6507799625,
-0.2281276584,
0.1622431725,
0.1386223733,
-0.433373183,
0.0917193145,
-0.6723728776,
0.3203006983,
-0.3159384131,
-0.2083323002,
-0.25040555,
-0.749679625,
0.8184362054,
0.0699264407,
0.4954242706,
-0.2968737483,
-0.4140479267,
0.7533893585,
-0.7860410213,
0.6030613184,
0.148231402,
0.0043324451,
0.0162474476,
-0.187843293,
0.3681069314,
0.5036923885,
0.1929357797,
0.2275822759,
0.0685198903,
-0.5480689406,
-0.7299815416,
0.7709439397,
-0.3772267699,
-0.5190566778,
-0.893030405,
-0.498436749,
-0.2470167279,
0.1742965281,
0.3224476576,
0.5163462162,
-0.6565313339,
-0.0895449743,
0.7702223659,
-0.0930000842,
-0.0323895141,
0.7475341558,
0.3137542605,
-0.6122793555,
0.6639466882,
0.1012127995,
-0.0248076823,
0.5524011254,
0.3621461391,
-0.1692557186,
-1.1196299791,
-0.3847445548,
0.3917030394,
-0.6309832335,
-0.0658758804,
-0.569111228,
-0.0114603247,
-0.2942615449,
0.0433488823,
-0.347468257,
-0.7377576828,
0.4329889417,
-0.2071180195,
0.3929688931,
0.7427229881,
-0.0996564701,
-0.0185320079,
-0.5955112576,
0.6880601645,
0.0574701577,
0.3815590739,
-0.5721098781,
-0.4530023038,
-0.2932009399,
-0.2611145675,
-0.0110720107,
-0.5862570405,
0.0419278853,
-0.0168128461,
0.4961433411,
0.6338761449,
0.3303107023,
0.3746477067,
-0.4919757843,
0.4815636873,
0.4561488926,
-0.5718404651,
0.6435984969,
-0.4211801291,
-0.0588792972,
0.8588911295,
0.510535121,
-0.3963303268,
-0.5172990561,
-0.6378911138,
-0.7856392264,
0.6064035296,
0.4760348201,
-0.4630852938,
-0.049423635,
0.2784552276,
0.2877527177,
0.3445911407,
-0.3183643818,
-0.4602962732,
-0.081243217,
-0.3990745842,
0.1426455826,
-0.407325387,
-1.0155217648,
0.0270831101,
0.4433113337,
-0.1378797293,
0.0217039939,
0.4814118445,
-0.261561662,
0.1087652147,
0.4702802002,
1.0598143339,
0.9029196501,
-0.6624798775,
0.3880529702,
0.2525244951,
-0.8506686091,
-0.027757097,
0.2269211113,
-0.231797874,
0.1739396453,
1.0240402222,
0.377577126,
0.5167651176,
-0.7260118723,
0.7094784379,
-0.364813298,
-0.2285321206,
0.071550861,
0.1290607154,
-0.2513709068,
-0.1896043122,
0.364558965,
0.3860344291,
0.5372610092,
-0.5702390075,
0.2699918747,
0.089892894,
-0.2533355057,
-0.3077087104,
0.4112728238,
0.4859633446,
0.1635187566,
-0.0818652883,
0.0842837691,
-0.0576253459,
0.729044497,
0.2585168779,
0.6775841117,
0.3183479011,
0.1385750473,
0.4317875206,
0.4354617894,
-0.2662712336,
0.2163027078,
0.1131209284,
-0.4530437887,
-0.6100251675,
0.1356588304,
-0.9182128906,
0.1690887064,
-0.4151127934,
0.2168284953,
-0.6179788113,
-0.0479533896,
0.0185771734,
0.0259455722,
-0.2264433354,
0.4366463125,
-0.3039790392,
0.9602357149,
-0.977338016,
0.5571494699,
0.6711977124,
-0.3342335224,
-0.4235283732,
0.1466536671,
0.2048096359,
-0.8702517152,
0.2803331316,
-0.1480148435,
-0.3067421615,
-0.6943583488,
-0.7095071077,
-0.7091533542,
1.0877914429,
0.2642287314,
-0.3527698517,
0.1884357631,
-0.017850576,
0.7178056836,
-0.2396788746,
0.48542732,
0.4141489863,
0.5168678761,
0.1410658956,
-0.7017255425,
0.3511301875,
-0.0943776444,
-0.3744007349,
-0.2406560481,
-0.576906085,
0.2469816655,
-0.5526306629,
-0.2442899346,
-0.0426180623,
0.6441445947,
0.5236397386,
0.7949489951,
0.2978428006,
0.3956578672,
0.6840976477,
-0.4466093481,
1.1644140482,
-0.5510816574,
0.2737924755,
1.0226740837,
-0.2758179307,
0.3663384318,
0.564864099,
-0.4122676849,
0.1620032638,
0.3677955866,
0.3384971619,
0.45598647,
0.0145256268,
-0.1942757815,
0.0285315756,
-0.1187482402,
-0.3904691041,
-0.0122965211,
0.2981052399,
-0.0945359841,
-0.3215869665,
-0.3203298748,
0.5417883992,
0.2718751431,
-0.0404528975,
0.6636107564,
0.1243354231,
-0.6596211791,
0.4841752648,
0.0083997091,
0.4886566401,
-0.7946533561,
-0.0992700532,
-0.548823595,
-0.1954646856,
-0.4640930593,
-0.7583528161,
0.2276185006,
0.3342140317,
-0.2223726213,
0.4047965109,
0.4014899731,
-0.0648102462,
-0.5491930246,
-0.0707819685,
0.3525592685,
0.2850006521,
0.3443782032,
-0.5386074781,
-0.0304887071,
-0.3528629839,
-0.219318673,
0.1819463223,
0.6890115738,
-0.1716329157,
0.6646282673,
0.7050302029,
0.5805676579,
-0.3397602737,
0.2309821099,
0.772365272,
-0.602062583,
-0.0841230527,
-0.6199724674,
0.1326513588,
-0.3938966095,
-0.6684545279,
0.8952242732,
0.9268203378,
0.2422708124,
-0.0570811778,
0.8699483275,
-0.0681021512,
0.4754772782,
-0.8735812902,
0.817831099,
-0.2491248697,
0.3351576626,
-0.0878287479,
-0.4592759311,
-0.5380877256,
0.1193018034,
-0.5205649137,
-0.1261371225,
1.0328048468,
0.4932474792,
0.0129953334,
-0.1831222028,
0.1944544762,
0.6058986187,
0.0188431311,
0.0860196501,
0.62040627,
-0.4819175303,
0.5687577724,
-0.1880303919,
-0.5401678085,
-0.5406767726,
-1.0199614763,
-0.6854798794,
-0.074792169,
-0.4541818202,
-0.2154500484,
0.3818685114,
1.0313595533,
0.5386348963,
-1.0299837589,
-0.1073983014,
0.1658233106,
0.5971806645,
-0.2995588779,
-0.1882789731,
0.5829766393,
-0.2275454998,
-0.4910666943,
0.3387493193,
0.6153190732,
-0.1413870156,
0.3096379042,
0.0257486869,
-0.2076211125,
0.2211184949,
0.5399209857,
0.3833961785,
-0.5504955053,
-0.2278965414,
-0.169285357,
-0.3371714056,
0.3141717017,
1.1122943163,
-0.382422477,
0.3729057014,
0.613653183,
0.1176950559,
0.3339675367,
0.0693061277,
0.5231149197,
-0.5397144556,
0.0018498938,
0.1457146555,
0.5255336165,
0.2321452051,
-0.1496128589,
0.4420412183,
0.5618830323,
-0.2962982357,
-0.5668874383,
-0.0331533626,
-1.2195740938,
-0.1655692458,
0.9550594091,
-0.2484810948,
-0.2928604186,
-0.5304371119,
-0.2761409879,
0.2431793958,
-0.491489023,
1.1273808479,
0.5059377551,
-0.2662775815,
0.1614807546,
-0.6554883718,
0.7683516145,
0.1446795911,
-0.8629485369,
-0.0987021998,
0.5939278007,
0.5493800044,
0.1451751143,
0.9340081215,
-0.3477271497,
0.4786167741,
-0.173817426,
0.2620911002,
0.0806501731,
-0.2121281028,
-0.2242721021,
-0.0034148928,
0.1240240559,
0.0582098849
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11455v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11455v1
|
LoRA-Flow: Dynamic LoRA Fusion for Large Language Models in Generative Tasks
| 2024-02-18T04:41:25 | 2024-02-18T04:41:25 |
Hanqing Wang, Bowen Ping, Shuo Wang, Xu Han, Yun Chen, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
LoRA employs lightweight modules to customize large language models (LLMs)
for each downstream task or domain, where different learned additional modules
represent diverse skills. Combining existing LoRAs to address new tasks can
enhance the reusability of learned LoRAs, particularly beneficial for tasks
with limited annotated data. Most prior works on LoRA combination primarily
rely on task-level weights for each involved LoRA, making different examples
and tokens share the same LoRA weights. However, in generative tasks, different
tokens may necessitate diverse skills to manage. Taking the Chinese math task
as an example, understanding the problem description may depend more on the
Chinese LoRA, while the calculation part may rely more on the math LoRA. To
this end, we propose LoRA-Flow, which utilizes dynamic weights to adjust the
impact of different LoRAs. The weights at each step are determined by a fusion
gate with extremely few parameters, which can be learned with only 200 training
examples. Experiments across six generative tasks demonstrate that our method
consistently outperforms baselines with task-level fusion weights. This
underscores the necessity of introducing dynamic fusion weights for LoRA
combination.
|
[
-0.1588031799,
-0.8563216329,
0.4035287201,
0.1378075629,
-0.3419677615,
0.4165050387,
-0.1491978317,
-0.5467118621,
0.4792521894,
0.6589500308,
-0.690541327,
-0.3997157216,
-0.6533482075,
-0.1337680668,
-0.7233797908,
0.9048522711,
-0.355317533,
-0.2594413459,
-0.0673406646,
-0.3110229969,
-0.3787820935,
-0.0332679302,
-0.453121841,
-0.7703557014,
1.0989003181,
0.2853933275,
0.6822857857,
0.6030247808,
0.5721581578,
0.4659687579,
-0.1702834964,
0.247674942,
-0.3902451694,
0.320314914,
-0.0859100446,
-0.5088422298,
-0.5131493807,
-0.3134020269,
0.8189332485,
0.9348899722,
-0.3377586007,
0.0728612691,
0.0858119056,
0.5808589458,
-0.6548619866,
-0.0092017455,
-0.6812908053,
0.2244676054,
-0.4299001992,
-0.0116552245,
-0.0339756012,
-0.1608189046,
-0.0019258766,
-0.6403505802,
-0.229348138,
-0.285782069,
0.7211923003,
0.6685723662,
-0.4161839187,
-0.0078893378,
-0.8395452499,
0.6948074698,
-0.6050345302,
-0.0021861845,
-0.0263857655,
0.5908132792,
0.044337593,
-0.7027569413,
-0.5693565011,
0.0720992684,
0.2757701576,
0.0040093311,
-0.1766461581,
-0.0500067994,
0.2740695775,
0.3589517474,
-0.2357541174,
0.4685338438,
-0.346385181,
0.1085815132,
0.6452899575,
0.3517153263,
0.3957487047,
0.0618379712,
-0.3280405104,
-0.1056507081,
-0.8703604937,
-0.1899726838,
0.4231375754,
0.4794155955,
-0.4166959524,
0.6656077504,
-0.4511756003,
1.0122773647,
0.0380664915,
-0.4416558146,
0.4953668118,
-0.2984483242,
-0.269400686,
-0.017965639,
0.8705548644,
-0.432467252,
-0.0094418544,
0.0252934508,
-0.3089060485,
-0.0106399832,
0.0238153562,
-0.5559562445,
0.0824604556,
0.0282417983,
-0.2151146382,
-0.5329005718,
-0.0996077433,
-0.6659909487,
-0.7199075818,
-0.2913385034,
0.7579720616,
-0.2460090369,
-0.1618425995,
0.0191118754,
-0.1050997004,
0.3171780109,
0.5710837841,
-0.8802238107,
0.2154971808,
0.6092869639,
0.7162652016,
-0.4058384597,
-0.5714445114,
-0.9522848129,
0.1426282674,
0.0927438363,
0.9380284548,
-0.522665143,
-0.0747200027,
0.1253820062,
-0.363406837,
-0.0741617456,
-0.7140953541,
0.2266121954,
-0.4910396338,
0.0770199746,
-0.3428040147,
-0.3784686625,
-0.0790110305,
-0.0434745289,
-0.9134324193,
0.7827156782,
0.4109567702,
-0.6738528609,
0.157515347,
-0.7397385836,
-0.8042286634,
0.459048301,
-0.4429622889,
-0.2870218754,
0.0164244715,
-0.1400784403,
0.290932864,
-0.298225373,
-0.0329117775,
-0.1869045347,
-0.4949735999,
0.1776055098,
-0.2682915032,
0.8318023086,
0.1479826123,
-0.4018187225,
0.3367985785,
-0.8095915914,
-0.0661689043,
0.2647875845,
-0.7254989743,
-0.1530196369,
0.0460159071,
-0.1826383024,
0.0148650631,
0.3526175618,
-0.2740783691,
0.2451698333,
-0.4154831171,
0.362110585,
0.6741338968,
-0.2850668132,
0.257109046,
-0.304572165,
0.5728482604,
-0.1019023806,
-0.1675706953,
0.0123717841,
-0.4937382042,
-1.0564720631,
-0.3600136638,
0.2567757368,
0.5980122685,
-1.1941777468,
0.5060085058,
-0.1926151514,
-0.6195428967,
-0.4297201037,
0.7342643738,
0.2793127298,
0.333501637,
0.0880431235,
-0.0884508416,
-0.439114511,
-0.6238982677,
-0.0431388617,
-0.0123408167,
0.1701171249,
-0.1766542047,
0.5560299158,
-0.1248043701,
0.8035727739,
-0.7321341634,
-0.4859540761,
-0.6432258487,
0.3852232695,
0.3122407794,
0.3669970334,
0.4076905549,
-0.7240921259,
-0.4266573191,
0.1320013851,
-0.7063694,
-0.2595905066,
-0.0965367183,
-0.2821519375,
-0.0123583963,
0.3940962851,
-0.6087716818,
0.0779613182,
0.9784202576,
-0.4080456793,
0.2744600773,
-0.2937880456,
-0.3382668197,
-1.2512613535,
0.0060191322,
-0.1590389907,
-0.1698999107,
-0.6470488906,
0.369110465,
-0.1540772468,
-0.1283916533,
-0.7918411493,
0.7101842761,
-0.3036010563,
-0.1045861989,
-0.5511729121,
0.3198911846,
-0.1192405745,
0.5061559081,
-0.0533854403,
0.4243738651,
0.6884335876,
-0.5716600418,
1.0082924366,
0.0235188361,
-0.6970764399,
0.5974234939,
-0.5561570525,
0.061269816,
-0.0439200401,
0.2323802263,
-0.7231736183,
-0.4107099175,
0.1101929247,
-0.0023512202,
0.0718657374,
0.1736070216,
-0.602039516,
-0.3027317524,
-0.0815334991,
0.5154622197,
0.8188989162,
-0.5296683311,
1.1100327969,
0.3023167551,
0.0590459965,
-0.5816712379,
-0.8106520772,
-0.0592379682,
-0.3574090898,
-0.5359135866,
0.5756458044,
0.0515727326,
-0.3165732026,
0.2081139088,
0.1231025085,
-0.0868515894,
0.2311403304,
0.344971478,
0.2803118527,
-0.0542481542,
0.0546319485,
0.1126055717,
-0.1655047238,
-0.2498557866,
-0.0925776213,
0.8595227003,
0.2175780833,
-0.7744931579,
-0.4468353391,
0.2677513659,
0.6257422566,
-0.3309800029,
1.0428031683,
0.8849950433,
-0.5430250168,
-0.3766273558,
-0.4407377839,
0.2250323445,
-0.5532384515,
0.4346073568,
-0.3936562538,
-0.9113816023,
0.721855104,
0.1423025727,
0.3008629084,
0.5375877023,
0.7023584247,
-0.230392158,
0.6748451591,
0.6206833124,
-0.2461222857,
0.7895833254,
-0.3107470274,
0.1564965397,
-0.6480960846,
-0.2493777722,
-0.3794282079,
-0.7460651994,
-0.3475438952,
-0.6587933302,
0.4943368435,
-0.0909036398,
-0.214248091,
0.284913063,
-0.0128968945,
0.4240772426,
0.5449759364,
-0.0066027297,
0.4959607422,
0.1863952875,
0.1231058761,
0.5014892817,
-0.6890349984,
0.0104066003,
0.6734271049,
0.1501483619,
1.1829024553,
0.257440716,
0.8205173612,
0.1878274679,
0.276848048,
-0.8826278448,
0.8693524599,
-0.5494980216,
-0.2453250587,
-0.4300166667,
-0.6035919189,
-1.1081248522,
0.3444852829,
-0.3676258028,
-0.5613932014,
-0.323040545,
0.2398032695,
-0.6546645164,
0.5898785591,
-0.4394451082,
0.45290488,
-0.2965237796,
-0.0726458356,
-0.4527014196,
-0.220056802,
0.5213292837,
-0.4261384308,
-0.0051644347,
-0.2192597985,
-0.1870043278,
0.7468444705,
-0.6636394262,
1.0528037548,
0.0295937862,
-0.5827184319,
0.3787346184,
-0.1256705523,
0.6202811599,
-0.5026672482,
0.0877496153,
-0.0184124298,
-0.3363218307,
-0.2732533216,
-0.776565671,
0.9053858519,
-0.7578162551,
-0.6260964274,
-0.2440684438,
-0.7152481079,
-0.1546498388,
0.1862778664,
0.1462650895,
0.3456611931,
0.1509577185,
0.2232266665,
0.6767239571,
-0.2558506727,
0.3722293675,
0.3805148602,
-0.1899970025,
-0.3639300168,
0.9913108945,
0.0809430555,
0.5363976359,
0.6507283449,
0.2749851644,
0.0551318005,
-0.4160306752,
-0.4673127532,
0.4117050171,
-0.7999939322,
-0.3064924777,
-0.479156971,
-0.4572685063,
-0.079398565,
-0.1373031884,
-0.417277962,
-0.2687335908,
-0.1940782368,
0.1797048301,
0.5092073083,
0.6963403225,
0.1820967346,
0.3454251289,
-0.8102975488,
0.5032273531,
0.7716445923,
0.3741291165,
0.0714845881,
-0.5228571892,
-0.288356632,
-0.1651566178,
-0.2017241865,
-0.7399466634,
0.1495241672,
0.1872872561,
0.4769434929,
0.5374546647,
-0.0958156809,
0.7151191235,
-0.4095172882,
0.6309064031,
0.4542428553,
-1.0473343134,
0.480435282,
-0.4130299389,
0.6029841304,
0.2372998446,
-0.0337419771,
-0.5645789504,
-0.2654026151,
-0.2470784485,
-0.7388349771,
0.4350963533,
0.1678375304,
0.3117706776,
0.4856701493,
0.2540909648,
0.0210175589,
0.0810975209,
-0.6305324435,
-0.2157851309,
0.1836653501,
-0.5890911222,
0.0998523459,
0.1285595745,
-0.235802412,
-0.1701351255,
0.3605751693,
-0.2416576594,
0.1162660196,
-0.4117791653,
0.0659083948,
-0.265414536,
0.0280563962,
0.4551592767,
0.4837721884,
0.1880768836,
0.1219962463,
0.5454149246,
-0.3897884488,
0.0586102232,
0.1623247117,
-0.2704152465,
-0.2044639736,
0.6479741335,
1.0107927322,
0.2825186551,
-1.0924537182,
0.1916365921,
0.2845723927,
-0.2930404842,
-0.2495868802,
0.5727835298,
0.2445790321,
0.4392239451,
0.244352892,
-0.1381130815,
-0.3017763495,
-0.6665793061,
-0.1445954591,
0.6022908092,
-0.136155203,
-0.3145197928,
0.3984837234,
0.4898747802,
-0.1661033183,
0.4633748531,
-0.0047661387,
-0.3826874197,
0.414935708,
0.4475945234,
0.8280359507,
-0.1985232234,
0.1543162763,
0.0323888958,
-0.1544329971,
-0.1191462204,
0.408758074,
0.0011992886,
-0.9072190523,
-0.8502628207,
-0.6452635527,
-0.4092197418,
0.1682844609,
-0.3164797425,
0.4327228665,
-0.3530249,
-0.0565828867,
-0.1256971955,
-0.0801932067,
-0.5830288529,
0.0395399965,
0.4447359741,
0.8174360991,
-0.8052338362,
0.9966314435,
0.8256706595,
-0.3294256032,
-0.658875227,
-0.1419725418,
0.0616615675,
-0.9483852386,
0.8773809075,
-0.2982536256,
-0.459135592,
-0.1139334217,
-0.2590025365,
-1.2757418156,
1.2607976198,
0.4133184552,
-0.3689312339,
-0.295248121,
0.2699570656,
0.3845846355,
-0.3143865168,
-0.4609526396,
0.3109940588,
0.36279881,
0.5773198605,
-1.003005147,
-0.0654554516,
-0.1399624944,
-0.1714404374,
0.3752276897,
-0.7733151913,
0.9620144963,
-0.2859929204,
-0.169639796,
0.2646924555,
0.7545882463,
0.4109869003,
-0.0864683241,
0.9076700211,
0.6975444555,
0.8674271107,
-0.1952946335,
0.8085296154,
-0.0803503171,
0.0265946146,
1.148819685,
-0.528666079,
0.9902393222,
0.3464318514,
-0.1400691271,
0.8107753992,
0.1734803766,
0.0855247378,
0.3945117891,
0.3657249808,
-0.5428975224,
-0.1900557876,
-0.2247493714,
-0.2662116289,
0.744435668,
0.2144796699,
-0.0546641089,
-0.2281107008,
0.1477991492,
0.0792375877,
-0.2001885921,
-0.3458780348,
0.5395871401,
0.0820987746,
-0.7408519387,
0.4955488741,
-0.0054912483,
0.8539985418,
-0.9834419489,
0.113246344,
-0.2648599744,
0.24317725,
-0.3206212521,
-0.8098977208,
0.158371672,
0.2961049974,
0.1280126721,
-0.2692516446,
0.7034683228,
-0.5006453395,
-0.6188651323,
0.1347394139,
0.7496849895,
-0.1061428785,
0.0576071702,
-0.501413703,
0.488199532,
0.0092810318,
-0.1114831567,
0.4895811379,
0.3066331148,
0.2091891468,
0.9806582332,
0.4360471964,
0.3147400916,
0.015255928,
0.4840909243,
1.0387648344,
-0.7248238325,
-0.3385111988,
-0.7834939361,
0.5255994797,
0.027022725,
-0.1351540983,
0.5346977711,
0.1018785685,
0.546681881,
0.1607572436,
0.7681176066,
-0.2465279698,
0.3628260195,
-0.7897184491,
0.6462917924,
-0.7984050512,
0.1786133945,
-0.2559562325,
-1.0784902573,
-0.1884448528,
0.4431812465,
0.0879568234,
0.1413335651,
0.6930840015,
0.3333391249,
0.0555858351,
-0.4171144366,
0.2925143242,
0.0610265173,
0.2964312434,
0.8648435473,
0.8214909434,
-0.2171007693,
0.6153734326,
-0.1186855435,
-0.0360204466,
-0.1548236907,
-0.9801734686,
-0.7483173609,
-0.6511617899,
-0.7208076715,
-0.2695908248,
-0.24454166,
0.9516633153,
0.7317301631,
-0.4688474238,
-0.3534069657,
0.1907298565,
0.2327968776,
-0.3963378966,
-0.1445097476,
0.2203960121,
-0.2693378925,
-1.0420796871,
0.4464418292,
0.2640069723,
0.2055020183,
-0.7329101562,
-0.1346662641,
0.1408946216,
0.0201218911,
0.6436602473,
0.3007929921,
-0.6880269647,
-0.0230844319,
-0.2783669829,
-0.05130665,
-0.1555812061,
0.808347702,
-0.9792678952,
0.0733161941,
0.8300932646,
0.7560207248,
0.2759588063,
-0.1895090491,
0.4584821463,
-0.5636921525,
0.1057785377,
-0.1297473907,
0.6069834828,
0.2095974535,
0.0375578925,
0.3241384923,
0.3019737303,
-0.034081351,
-0.7666013837,
0.4755149484,
-1.2663863897,
-0.2365331948,
1.2497762442,
0.0153180435,
-0.10001605,
0.1716251969,
-0.0323969387,
0.1997871548,
-0.1181735918,
0.624031961,
0.4896332324,
-0.1934376508,
-0.1336496323,
-0.2777502239,
0.2418001443,
0.3863108456,
-1.104675293,
-0.1201309785,
0.2123016715,
0.1292102933,
0.184552297,
0.443981111,
0.1988750994,
-0.0092711188,
-0.1756663471,
-0.0855456814,
0.0016180202,
-0.1323179007,
-0.1901296079,
0.2798041999,
0.1719055176,
0.0181859117
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11453v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11453v3
|
MatPlotAgent: Method and Evaluation for LLM-Based Agentic Scientific Data Visualization
| 2024-02-18T04:28:28 | 2024-03-19T14:44:22 |
Zhiyu Yang, Zihan Zhou, Shuo Wang, Xin Cong, Xu Han, Yukun Yan, Zhenghao Liu, Zhixing Tan, Pengyuan Liu, Dong Yu, Zhiyuan Liu, Xiaodong Shi, Maosong Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Scientific data visualization plays a crucial role in research by enabling
the direct display of complex information and assisting researchers in
identifying implicit patterns. Despite its importance, the use of Large
Language Models (LLMs) for scientific data visualization remains rather
unexplored. In this study, we introduce MatPlotAgent, an efficient
model-agnostic LLM agent framework designed to automate scientific data
visualization tasks. Leveraging the capabilities of both code LLMs and
multi-modal LLMs, MatPlotAgent consists of three core modules: query
understanding, code generation with iterative debugging, and a visual feedback
mechanism for error correction. To address the lack of benchmarks in this
field, we present MatPlotBench, a high-quality benchmark consisting of 100
human-verified test cases. Additionally, we introduce a scoring approach that
utilizes GPT-4V for automatic evaluation. Experimental results demonstrate that
MatPlotAgent can improve the performance of various LLMs, including both
commercial and open-source models. Furthermore, the proposed evaluation method
shows a strong correlation with human-annotated scores.
|
[
-0.1684458703,
-0.4107151926,
0.6965997815,
0.4317123294,
-0.4515486956,
0.4271256328,
-0.3490400314,
-0.1614500582,
0.2079385668,
0.2135676444,
-0.2617440522,
-1.0043489933,
-0.4204751551,
0.2303653061,
-0.2860758305,
0.7474584579,
-0.2162778378,
0.2691997886,
-0.7152137756,
-0.0815952346,
-0.2680712938,
-0.244702071,
-0.5208155513,
-0.3549172878,
0.2934635282,
0.2285978049,
0.6914461851,
0.8617245555,
0.7476033568,
0.3409791589,
0.3243049681,
0.3033027053,
-0.5359089971,
0.3433397412,
-0.0131763145,
-0.4520351291,
-0.4718999863,
0.2607860565,
0.5141449571,
0.5652551055,
-0.1237495095,
0.24842152,
-0.2613557875,
0.2637434602,
-0.302981168,
0.9013316631,
-0.3188199401,
0.1158270165,
0.0728284568,
-0.3307234049,
-0.4977345765,
-0.3356813192,
-0.1674454659,
-0.9608913064,
0.0932297483,
0.1170602366,
0.2902512848,
0.7057816386,
-0.3950715065,
-0.0386210531,
-0.2662121356,
0.8318194747,
-0.5864244699,
0.0453052595,
0.3857678771,
0.6409720778,
-0.2280256599,
-0.9639987946,
-0.4528821409,
-0.7600102425,
-0.0627942011,
0.3250211477,
-0.0697602108,
-0.0009270851,
0.2397668362,
-0.1359916031,
-0.6965458393,
-0.0179743413,
-0.1379391998,
-0.2998110652,
0.8910316825,
0.3909621537,
0.3512969017,
-0.1538942009,
-0.3668912053,
-0.4190190136,
-0.5369275212,
-0.1797204465,
0.1560829431,
0.1408080906,
-0.039014969,
0.722843647,
-0.0248031523,
0.473526746,
-0.5459083915,
-0.0071764146,
0.3878148198,
-0.2037940621,
0.0899375528,
0.0395323969,
0.8559405208,
0.6008732319,
0.0959345028,
-0.1274415851,
-0.2189556807,
0.2087749094,
0.1045425907,
-1.0807694197,
-0.3488769233,
0.3215335011,
-0.3226278424,
-0.4156201184,
0.0415698774,
-0.8398939371,
-0.8557628989,
-0.3626233339,
0.2742424905,
-0.3438273966,
-0.2856568396,
-0.0809141397,
-0.1561443955,
-0.0803065896,
0.8351541758,
-0.2779857516,
0.213568449,
0.9316880107,
1.1541134119,
-0.5878694057,
-0.4859497249,
-0.5364271998,
0.16780743,
-0.498576045,
0.6550854445,
-0.8417283297,
-0.6362122297,
-0.4102783203,
0.0309794713,
-0.1041326076,
-0.2915702462,
0.5526972413,
-0.1966746747,
-0.1939280182,
-0.2562767267,
-0.6589876413,
-0.2675181925,
0.1308683902,
-0.7693579197,
0.8374634981,
-0.0442734621,
-0.669188261,
0.3589142263,
-1.1420536041,
-0.1372629553,
0.389631778,
-0.5416090488,
-0.4677138329,
-0.2416063845,
0.1018708348,
0.640062809,
-0.2732501328,
0.4216752648,
-0.326044172,
-0.4659882188,
0.3115493059,
-0.3177656531,
0.3636195958,
0.2125861496,
-0.4509902894,
0.528926909,
-0.8971853256,
-0.1418931782,
0.409266144,
-0.1139736623,
-0.2015882432,
0.1470579952,
0.1311834902,
-0.0860469937,
0.0296172332,
-0.6518728733,
0.5671319962,
0.1870940328,
0.6251763701,
0.6335621476,
-0.1716484427,
0.2765150368,
-0.1699151397,
0.7359870672,
-0.3874874413,
0.0049933535,
-0.2394998372,
-0.5650373697,
-0.4143252075,
-0.8521151543,
0.2887251377,
0.2709744871,
-0.6731517315,
0.0127919996,
-0.4762252867,
-0.6862493157,
-0.4351532161,
-0.1325398982,
0.0711353421,
0.5082079768,
0.321424216,
0.0298149157,
-0.3189084232,
-0.6276939511,
0.182522133,
-0.1446345598,
-0.0747635588,
0.3230238259,
0.7942379117,
-0.4413857758,
0.9650173187,
-0.5858432651,
-0.0240561813,
-0.1486196518,
0.4886052608,
0.062047258,
0.3808141649,
0.5004711151,
-0.5904429555,
-0.3864757419,
0.1746291965,
-0.7582210302,
-0.4707885087,
-0.0862741768,
-0.0511254631,
0.0587990172,
0.5118419528,
-0.8677253127,
0.4820429981,
0.3741826415,
-0.3623062372,
0.6056120992,
-0.3371337056,
0.28453812,
-0.5629443526,
0.2640855312,
-0.130307138,
-0.4384543896,
-0.6333855391,
-0.0795584321,
0.180829972,
-0.2403626591,
-0.2323029339,
0.5429553986,
-0.2948323488,
-0.2451622039,
-0.3392715752,
0.1004318297,
0.1759392172,
0.1101618782,
0.1270152926,
0.9395874143,
0.3695054948,
0.0530978478,
0.5957186222,
0.1749395877,
-0.0631736517,
0.2730599642,
-0.680018425,
0.062329188,
-0.2791457474,
0.4847155511,
-1.0962893963,
-0.3319033682,
0.2020899057,
-0.1672095805,
0.1462003142,
-0.1844452024,
-0.5951506495,
-0.1065149233,
-0.5539826155,
0.355802983,
0.2551839054,
-0.6378981471,
0.8027943969,
0.1050460488,
-0.1862197071,
-0.5352790356,
-0.5177561045,
0.237088576,
-0.2188893557,
-0.6352130771,
0.2201705277,
-0.3142591715,
-0.3766469061,
-0.1539057791,
-0.1637166142,
0.3515031636,
0.2162326127,
0.704351902,
0.3175288439,
0.0675979555,
0.2546287477,
-0.1875359863,
-0.2757008374,
0.2211251855,
0.1002712026,
0.6345930696,
-0.4463035166,
-0.6696925759,
-0.1993759573,
-0.0204008967,
0.5877349377,
-0.2862149775,
0.2796429396,
0.5945131779,
-0.0237641428,
-0.5024381876,
-0.4110014141,
-0.0812339038,
-0.4183833003,
0.3949149847,
-0.2884478569,
-0.5357265472,
0.5173072815,
-0.3404943943,
-0.2935832739,
0.3275181353,
0.6246054769,
0.1362752169,
1.1211850643,
0.301308006,
0.2072549164,
0.0134145748,
-0.4154746532,
-0.1006640494,
-0.3777101934,
-0.2958343327,
-0.2936143279,
0.0902606919,
-0.3432234228,
-0.8295857906,
0.364705652,
-0.1825617254,
-0.1056230515,
-0.0514280722,
-0.6537047625,
0.5660710931,
0.2365906984,
-0.3889823258,
0.4340703785,
-0.2240133584,
-0.1344343424,
0.0825702175,
-0.4729443192,
-0.7132416368,
1.3048088551,
0.4609377384,
0.8886765242,
-0.0918161944,
0.6462154984,
0.5230798721,
0.598310411,
-0.6256169081,
0.7485078573,
0.2413832992,
-0.0224962961,
-0.3171552718,
-0.4908543527,
-0.9008629918,
0.7294159532,
-0.0512837097,
-0.4337573051,
0.134552151,
-0.0634223893,
-0.0689534694,
0.0037934503,
-0.7969912887,
0.9523200393,
-0.5019128323,
-0.4501682818,
-0.1311527789,
-0.5505483747,
0.2321863025,
-0.3035037518,
0.2891149223,
-0.4551256299,
-0.3765091896,
0.6914053559,
-0.4852163792,
0.7658066154,
-0.3717698455,
0.1876877546,
-0.052519042,
0.2632058263,
0.5623852611,
0.3867084682,
-0.1324609071,
0.2054762989,
0.1725901663,
-0.2245945185,
-0.4962318242,
0.8242635131,
-0.8248839974,
-0.4644353092,
-0.6983888745,
-0.8387165666,
0.0997922346,
0.079218477,
-0.3882285357,
0.0031461462,
-0.0916795805,
-0.0551300496,
0.1121110097,
-0.2397507131,
0.5416921973,
0.6080608368,
-0.6431331038,
-0.3348689973,
1.0198643208,
-0.087142162,
-0.0454478115,
-0.1983130425,
0.2045416981,
-0.2311077416,
-0.7194371223,
-0.4036144316,
0.3144102097,
-0.8472785354,
-0.3339984715,
-0.487113446,
0.0769612864,
-0.0371822603,
-0.0636902079,
-0.2776534557,
-0.5686492324,
-0.2063562274,
-0.2026401609,
0.5921007991,
0.793471396,
-0.0275683906,
0.148892045,
-0.2313209921,
0.1397582591,
0.1491774917,
0.3061425984,
-0.2434490025,
0.1635337472,
-0.020421112,
-0.1543382555,
0.0464235507,
-0.6464758515,
0.6138035059,
0.2272391468,
0.718270421,
0.2702811658,
-0.0868385509,
0.3755817413,
-0.5109794736,
0.7108238935,
-0.0145289507,
-0.9403921366,
0.4972963631,
-0.320107013,
-0.0094581442,
0.5064966679,
0.2979238033,
-0.1367072314,
-0.3142766953,
-0.2133495957,
-0.8567125201,
0.5794696212,
0.1694877446,
-0.3563344777,
0.2027430087,
0.2000100911,
0.4015721679,
0.4679135978,
-0.5915622115,
-0.0993530825,
-0.8019282818,
-0.3325459659,
-0.4296614826,
0.1611323804,
-0.5034475327,
-0.2631595731,
0.4686356485,
-0.5164389014,
0.0673236921,
0.2095950246,
-0.5018497109,
-0.0250115748,
-0.0165557135,
0.7636847496,
0.9867877364,
-0.5216243267,
0.283244133,
-0.0554103032,
-0.6178976297,
0.1547816396,
0.6312218904,
-0.049094893,
0.0355738178,
0.501578331,
0.7582586408,
-0.1613841653,
-0.939669013,
0.8628373146,
-0.2468935102,
-0.1152797341,
-0.2427301854,
-0.0659061,
0.1246334091,
0.4151473343,
0.4422188699,
-0.1688153893,
0.2212595046,
-0.0227475781,
0.0402210988,
0.6272476912,
0.0599486567,
-0.2221146524,
0.8097673655,
0.0302072335,
0.0194609109,
0.1764310598,
-0.2334898412,
-0.4278121293,
0.7117835283,
0.2498624623,
0.4966549575,
-0.2960346639,
0.5987154245,
-0.0725925565,
0.2955463231,
0.0451911017,
0.2743985355,
-0.1006419659,
-0.3154166043,
-0.7330226302,
-0.5628700256,
-0.7650393248,
-0.2104722559,
-0.2110518813,
0.1672541797,
-0.4124908447,
-0.1691984683,
0.2487202287,
0.1270310879,
-0.4382086992,
-0.1413703561,
0.1758897901,
0.7449477315,
-0.8789001107,
0.8537095785,
0.7786791325,
-0.6546896696,
-0.3979648948,
-0.4555516541,
0.0639653057,
-0.8890682459,
0.9219363332,
0.3033346832,
-0.0383939259,
-0.1261214912,
-0.7107059956,
-0.7526705861,
1.4743429422,
0.5156521201,
-0.4221763015,
0.5427151918,
0.5569266677,
0.8080157638,
-0.6937662363,
0.7259443998,
0.5064451694,
0.9008216262,
0.1158198938,
-0.5549854636,
0.2764800787,
-0.4858123064,
0.0273927357,
-0.1930991858,
-0.5292126536,
0.794519186,
0.0361485854,
-0.0843311921,
-0.2082272619,
0.3802036345,
0.3876896203,
0.4484654069,
0.4633119404,
0.3409284949,
0.8398262858,
-0.2654749155,
0.9728546739,
-0.449967891,
0.5066231489,
0.8841092587,
-0.6813644767,
0.4749328494,
0.4541585147,
-0.1047305763,
0.1865689754,
0.500883162,
-0.6610773206,
0.4279730022,
0.5084142685,
0.0091849891,
-0.2249994576,
-0.191104576,
-0.2812042832,
0.3919804692,
0.2923042476,
-0.2402448207,
-0.2346348912,
0.2409558296,
0.1088722125,
-0.0514488555,
-0.2393542528,
0.3956910372,
-0.0490479507,
-0.2534745336,
0.5655755401,
-0.1599223912,
0.2540693581,
-0.4565829933,
-0.4111424685,
-0.1747639477,
-0.0873166099,
-0.2919684649,
-0.6234259605,
-0.0451688394,
-0.1380813718,
0.2473308444,
-0.0407581627,
0.6550452113,
-0.3564604223,
-0.5356269479,
0.3556481302,
0.5099978447,
0.3372834027,
0.0392813571,
-0.6624789238,
0.4804944396,
-0.2269593924,
-0.4104921818,
0.0582026578,
0.0195341185,
-0.309497267,
1.001200676,
0.8568950891,
0.1948238164,
0.0284584127,
0.488794297,
0.8983964324,
-0.4839487076,
-0.1830155104,
-0.7697792649,
0.5272647738,
-0.3234342933,
0.2693113089,
0.7759922743,
0.7130396962,
0.1637134403,
-0.0889931247,
0.9019733667,
0.3493105769,
0.3499872386,
-0.2069002092,
0.8491569757,
-0.3093935251,
0.5162908435,
-0.1563777328,
-0.9724449515,
-0.7045294046,
0.6030620337,
-0.4623827636,
-0.0145478602,
0.6429112554,
0.7880799174,
-0.0160601698,
0.1103974134,
0.2851012349,
0.4056757689,
0.6748181581,
-0.0152859865,
1.1201514006,
0.3059282899,
0.388512373,
-0.2174432427,
-0.4723921418,
-0.2614021003,
-1.1056610346,
-1.0516818762,
-0.2579053342,
-0.394374609,
-0.0916099846,
0.0651273876,
1.0812745094,
0.5252444744,
-0.6049104333,
-0.2661259174,
-0.0420563743,
-0.0650852472,
0.0886315033,
-0.1998743713,
0.7950143814,
-0.2341407239,
-0.5761108398,
0.6369532943,
0.3731797934,
-0.040751148,
-0.4710190296,
-0.2037637532,
0.1920056045,
0.0423780829,
0.4273687601,
-0.0429717302,
-0.6483866572,
-0.0440378785,
-0.2966834605,
-0.0363573097,
0.177412793,
0.578183949,
-0.6458666921,
0.5832008719,
0.3699052334,
0.5357934237,
0.8509584069,
0.1614744514,
0.3582999706,
-0.4700264037,
0.1376932412,
0.4099878371,
0.5816948414,
0.5041220784,
-0.161045149,
0.9343112111,
0.149411425,
-0.7774618268,
-1.0621799231,
-0.2077542096,
-1.3052324057,
-0.2644601762,
1.1812839508,
-0.2672200203,
-0.2765949965,
0.1739489138,
-0.4462661445,
0.0023699726,
-0.5703340769,
0.6078296304,
0.4213614464,
-0.3724901974,
-0.0357677117,
-0.7825285792,
0.4462009966,
0.215724349,
-1.0782768726,
0.0547153987,
0.5340667963,
0.2595398128,
0.2174999267,
0.1470063329,
0.0525461994,
0.1115557477,
-0.0998912081,
0.4774485826,
-0.7518061996,
-0.0104853576,
-0.4826912284,
0.2602415681,
0.042670276,
0.1264353245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11452v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11452v1
|
AutoPRM: Automating Procedural Supervision for Multi-Step Reasoning via Controllable Question Decomposition
| 2024-02-18T04:28:16 | 2024-02-18T04:28:16 |
Zhaorun Chen, Zhuokai Zhao, Zhihong Zhu, Ruiqi Zhang, Xiang Li, Bhiksha Raj, Huaxiu Yao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have shown promise in
multi-step reasoning tasks, yet their reliance on extensive manual labeling to
provide procedural feedback remains a significant impediment. To address this
challenge, in this paper, we propose a novel self-supervised framework AutoPRM
that efficiently enhances the fine-tuning of LLMs for intricate reasoning
challenges. Specifically, AutoPRM first decomposes complex problems into more
manageable subquestions with a controllable granularity switch, then
sequentially apply reinforcement learning to iteratively improve the
subquestion solver. Additionally, we propose context-guided-decoding to avoid
reward tampering and guide the subquestion solver towards the solution of the
holistic problem. Extensive experiments show that AutoPRM significantly
improves performance on mathematical and commonsense reasoning tasks over SOTA.
More encouragingly, AutoPRM can be easily integrated with other orthogonal
reasoning pipelines.
|
[
-0.4438439906,
-0.9372440577,
0.5591080189,
0.4996189177,
0.1146598533,
0.0800565407,
-0.1947328001,
0.1218335629,
-0.0605692975,
0.8040211797,
-0.7290856838,
-0.4404343665,
-0.5219980478,
0.1785128862,
-0.1772592813,
0.7366722822,
-0.3213061392,
-0.0530233942,
-0.3130299151,
0.0988751277,
-0.062319681,
-0.5708374381,
-0.8665913343,
-0.4322127998,
0.3509026766,
0.4085218012,
0.5234655738,
0.9855100513,
0.3667075038,
0.4096478522,
0.0419618562,
0.6891309619,
-0.176991716,
0.3666640818,
-0.5765601993,
-0.2317143232,
-0.4219404757,
-0.1287187785,
0.4031428993,
0.5666307211,
-0.4544676244,
0.0101119122,
-0.0226962063,
0.2521230876,
-0.6356130838,
0.6495756507,
-0.3809327781,
0.0104908319,
0.2069438696,
-0.542817831,
-0.3400290608,
-0.0770730898,
-0.1719596237,
-0.636300087,
0.1515764892,
0.0878056809,
0.4038984478,
0.9392730594,
-0.3666012287,
-0.4281823933,
-0.6201405525,
0.8086445928,
-0.4632982612,
0.0422966108,
0.2720295191,
0.2799803019,
-0.3827968538,
-0.5739549994,
-0.3416136205,
-0.0047429544,
-0.1333884299,
0.0708325282,
0.0414992832,
0.3126687706,
0.1569552422,
0.4364204109,
-0.5277411938,
0.0085119344,
0.0883828253,
-0.3808652163,
0.7194902301,
0.5131239891,
0.2184890211,
-0.1577155143,
-0.3737139702,
-0.246405676,
-0.3624044061,
0.0656781867,
0.0998437479,
0.2639766634,
0.4022966027,
0.2999928892,
-0.3431224227,
0.8159934878,
0.2257532328,
-0.1155643463,
-0.0802394599,
-0.4123844206,
-0.2787166238,
-0.1719744802,
0.8242540359,
-0.0762675926,
0.2533848882,
0.1257673651,
-0.2005178779,
-0.1895950139,
0.1797286421,
-0.738860786,
-0.555013895,
0.1989898384,
-0.2046378404,
-0.0355806537,
-0.1803851873,
-0.3290322423,
-0.0401191451,
-0.6441985369,
0.2282473296,
-0.3537390828,
-0.1987656653,
0.4618776441,
0.2460596859,
0.3072328568,
0.668946445,
-0.842531383,
0.3756500781,
0.795909524,
0.3852543235,
-0.2711547911,
-0.4300738275,
-0.7746309042,
0.3283923566,
-0.5099995136,
0.6762830615,
-0.6144150496,
-0.2925754786,
-0.1916883588,
0.1918533742,
-0.2250642031,
-0.7005211711,
0.1027224287,
-0.3585673869,
0.1624869108,
-0.0521174856,
-0.6026886702,
-0.0159316715,
0.5943678021,
-0.2304448932,
1.0328037739,
0.0590351038,
-0.1422351748,
0.1493132859,
-0.5521653891,
-0.4228687584,
0.0880562142,
-0.2146139294,
-0.3175688386,
-0.239231661,
0.5041014552,
0.4211406112,
-0.0318652391,
0.5685608983,
-0.2430755496,
-0.052077692,
-0.1129277498,
-0.1751817316,
0.6793493032,
0.3026281893,
-0.4903382957,
0.3569480479,
-0.4849306345,
0.1992425472,
-0.1001413912,
-0.1510747224,
-0.14468804,
-0.090641886,
-0.4055981934,
0.4342080653,
0.3012090027,
-0.185495615,
0.42946738,
-0.2406544536,
0.4264528453,
0.6821433306,
0.208133921,
0.594978869,
-0.1265761256,
0.7573886514,
0.1497796178,
0.3365505338,
-0.4124992192,
-0.0949383751,
-1.0305976868,
-0.4215575159,
0.1175823808,
0.7001057863,
-0.7860962749,
0.5205245614,
0.3899200261,
-0.1026917174,
-0.3801297545,
0.3183757663,
0.6732405424,
0.5421380401,
0.7981880307,
-0.0420633405,
-0.1697199196,
-0.8554327488,
-0.4229438901,
-0.0229239929,
-0.0087327715,
0.4285039902,
0.5133133531,
-0.3866582513,
0.7697615623,
-0.5593990684,
-0.7795841694,
-0.1664564461,
0.6194336414,
-0.0376986824,
0.8835077882,
-0.054234039,
-0.485442102,
-0.3896657228,
-0.3584747314,
-0.6616119742,
-0.4108298421,
-0.5328009129,
-0.1454102099,
0.0741815194,
1.0045490265,
-0.5496349931,
0.3048948646,
0.0082453471,
-0.2248478234,
0.4632743597,
-0.6137081981,
-0.0088325897,
-0.6368362904,
-0.3974771202,
-0.0361597277,
-0.4098739028,
-0.0926533714,
0.1249921322,
0.2001576424,
0.0761149153,
-0.2112391889,
0.5135962963,
-0.6305729151,
0.173795566,
-0.3465958238,
-0.1337859929,
0.0332599357,
0.7210592628,
0.3323235512,
0.5537008643,
0.6687779427,
-0.7016096115,
0.4896864593,
0.321731627,
-0.0015630566,
0.4448800981,
-0.6508036852,
0.0432572775,
-0.1666889489,
0.4493607283,
-0.9407235384,
-0.2700867951,
0.295888871,
-0.2797202766,
0.3329344988,
-0.2958208025,
-0.6534769535,
-0.0463260524,
0.0502181612,
0.5425336957,
0.2635544837,
-0.4862250388,
0.8464157581,
0.3405556977,
-0.401796788,
-0.4189009368,
-0.6415691972,
0.0760622695,
0.0930722952,
-0.2221482992,
0.2579815686,
-0.2503547072,
-0.3102811873,
-0.0686332136,
-0.1428077668,
-0.1938273758,
-0.066313073,
0.1078971401,
-0.0810931697,
0.1958814412,
0.0738045648,
0.469617933,
-0.4652167857,
0.5007753968,
-0.4659830034,
0.360638082,
-0.2836151421,
-0.5880971551,
-0.2862944007,
0.361609906,
0.2361797392,
-0.48138237,
0.2563479543,
0.3702922463,
-0.0989151448,
-0.8619647622,
-0.4280205667,
-0.214922905,
-0.5263907313,
0.0243101139,
-0.52975142,
-1.0706679821,
0.3581359386,
-0.2313968241,
0.027392434,
0.1640396267,
0.7582650781,
-0.1276227832,
1.2914274931,
0.1649999321,
0.1060855761,
0.2044213265,
-0.459975481,
0.0334228575,
-0.5665581822,
-0.5119535327,
-0.1354555935,
0.013031112,
-0.2953420281,
-0.9006661177,
0.3894305825,
0.014228113,
-0.2588346004,
0.1401940137,
-0.7377466559,
0.5757068396,
0.5355423093,
-0.0205250885,
0.4329831302,
-0.4586102068,
-0.1727842838,
0.1125270352,
-0.8843623996,
-0.213380307,
0.6202114224,
0.2958623767,
1.0726385117,
-0.3071100712,
0.8492385149,
0.3457854092,
0.0938691497,
-0.8438181877,
0.6660819054,
0.0518825464,
-0.5415062904,
-0.587315321,
-0.5731375217,
-0.7404236197,
0.4703584909,
0.3497073948,
-0.1714570075,
0.1474556923,
0.4953654706,
-0.5549558401,
-0.0080140736,
-0.4253260791,
0.8118524551,
-0.3022882342,
-0.3752202988,
-0.1610572636,
-0.6561238766,
0.3022478521,
0.2436481565,
0.3639236391,
-0.1796970069,
-0.0443266593,
0.3644275665,
-0.892763257,
0.8514419198,
-0.3159265518,
-0.3407565355,
0.3676843345,
0.5615523458,
0.4470717013,
0.4661039412,
0.4507925212,
-0.1974843442,
0.1754211634,
-0.4536660612,
-0.8177025914,
0.7226057649,
-0.3929213285,
-0.8229291439,
-0.5942533016,
-0.9365323186,
-0.2447877526,
0.2430838346,
-0.0691101551,
0.5911226273,
0.2839082181,
-0.0356804952,
1.158251524,
-0.1260654628,
0.4037279487,
0.5766913295,
-0.2744704485,
-0.3355221152,
0.7576264143,
-0.1293785721,
0.1578550935,
0.3785589635,
0.1135490239,
-0.5791683793,
-0.5552023053,
-0.3508746028,
0.1876224726,
-0.7300713658,
-0.2754141688,
-0.7939811945,
-0.1001793891,
-0.4144586027,
-0.014438346,
-0.5045390725,
-0.2366277874,
-0.243497923,
0.004770176,
0.0895631164,
0.4538259208,
-0.2876170576,
0.123654671,
-0.4125264585,
0.7283938527,
0.6594384313,
0.2666329145,
-0.3179928958,
-0.5556352139,
0.0911688805,
-0.1644152105,
0.0638108626,
-0.3470341265,
0.5252342224,
0.1050879657,
0.5240430832,
0.148855567,
0.3598831892,
0.7853620052,
-0.4449097216,
0.4173415005,
-0.1472996622,
-1.0312001705,
0.6851388812,
-0.4827037752,
0.5670117736,
0.6389312148,
0.3465996981,
-0.1516893208,
-0.6182426214,
-0.5148953199,
-0.8747916222,
0.7259964347,
-0.1168948114,
-0.1370485574,
-0.3053160608,
0.376070112,
-0.0015988899,
-0.0368386656,
-0.4676527381,
-0.1376280189,
-0.3291404843,
-0.1636069566,
0.072353445,
-0.2086505592,
-0.2260135114,
-0.5220768452,
0.6664645076,
-0.4360670745,
-0.0641969219,
0.5172151327,
-0.4133803546,
-0.0919723213,
0.1789446026,
0.3211367428,
0.6044231653,
0.1189441308,
0.3328305781,
0.1538302749,
0.0757524744,
0.1561507881,
0.086144492,
-0.1296287924,
-0.2057996094,
0.3012270629,
0.42728737,
0.2442491204,
-0.7074221373,
0.3524139822,
-0.0795295611,
-0.5381565094,
-0.481548667,
0.4050479233,
-0.0606347509,
0.3490920663,
0.3478178382,
-0.1816110015,
0.2243070751,
-0.3451949656,
0.3780104816,
0.3079629242,
-0.2545774579,
0.0493260324,
0.6541697383,
0.0256246552,
-0.2828513086,
0.5258279443,
-0.4954863787,
-0.5779983401,
0.7010505199,
0.3531218469,
0.6196641326,
-0.3146868348,
0.3328770101,
0.310639739,
0.2306356579,
-0.2643128633,
0.3409348726,
-0.4781732559,
-0.5478447676,
-0.8976588845,
-0.5251007676,
-0.7325494289,
0.1812618226,
-0.8243576884,
-0.1493356526,
-0.7603532076,
0.3871614039,
-0.3025741875,
-0.2783295214,
-0.2595357597,
0.4920812547,
-0.0531655923,
0.7325530648,
-0.534676075,
0.8835608363,
0.5363581777,
-0.2679663301,
-0.9316647649,
-0.1822422594,
-0.1416207999,
-0.6800207496,
0.7172307372,
-0.0828139484,
-0.5408270955,
0.2224618793,
-0.6151034236,
-0.780502975,
0.6760342717,
0.1778994501,
-0.3795235753,
0.0164313782,
0.3100639582,
0.5787013769,
-0.3670705259,
0.3091866672,
0.6792277694,
0.5025013089,
0.200903222,
-0.9606451988,
-0.0089598438,
-0.1760446876,
-0.0671444982,
0.2416231334,
-0.8131341338,
0.7957351804,
-0.0345312245,
0.1363628209,
-0.1315834075,
0.6842676401,
0.4311302006,
0.2351019382,
0.6501656175,
0.608024478,
0.4986955822,
-0.1000226885,
0.6894182563,
-0.4823589325,
0.466229558,
1.4418661594,
-0.0240831301,
0.2627109587,
0.3652469516,
0.060719423,
0.4737116992,
0.6928347349,
0.0367228538,
0.5087413788,
0.4466125071,
-0.0351309367,
-0.8785785437,
-0.0337689854,
-0.1250700951,
0.6112247705,
0.5552403331,
-0.2098715752,
-0.4854022861,
0.0749723315,
-0.1375367641,
0.3494195938,
-0.4645501077,
0.8412525058,
0.0757836178,
-1.0095143318,
0.7141540647,
-0.0912129208,
0.4125084579,
-0.6090200543,
-0.2045988441,
-0.4010472,
0.3658788204,
-0.2484107614,
-0.6386864781,
0.5016992092,
-0.2690964043,
0.0080780601,
-0.9934067726,
0.743447721,
-0.7465144396,
-0.2541653216,
0.2942974865,
0.5548362732,
0.0851311237,
-0.3238679469,
-0.948069334,
-0.1998326182,
-0.2137577385,
-0.3553661704,
0.2722293735,
0.7543516159,
-0.1903637797,
1.1645823717,
0.5205804706,
-0.0967115313,
0.1249577031,
0.1339533925,
1.0062241554,
-0.789335072,
-0.5659313798,
-0.790856421,
0.1922047883,
0.0940052345,
-0.1972816586,
0.8730304837,
0.5825431943,
0.9900099039,
-0.08130458,
0.737514019,
0.1310544163,
0.6335772872,
-0.4754822552,
0.2950448096,
-0.4123670757,
0.2857144177,
0.0167932473,
-0.5778862834,
-0.3666659594,
0.789665103,
-0.4066035748,
-0.0268746037,
0.5987250805,
0.7990958095,
-0.0340027101,
-0.3740123212,
0.0728662312,
0.0382849835,
0.3837865293,
0.5985786915,
0.9721187949,
0.130605042,
0.6556025147,
-0.4742063284,
-0.2637568116,
-0.0855453759,
-0.8074312806,
-1.0164027214,
-0.3026539087,
-0.5738756657,
-0.1259018779,
-0.2138954848,
0.9076673985,
0.8460230827,
-1.0162056684,
-0.1655458659,
-0.5405907035,
0.1108739823,
-0.2478149533,
-0.3160150051,
0.218682602,
-0.966288805,
-0.7473762035,
0.6855939627,
0.6716592908,
-0.3870981038,
-0.5584959984,
-0.0571008921,
-0.1015037745,
0.0299967267,
0.4385096133,
0.3614278436,
-0.7749677896,
0.0898890942,
0.0428915694,
-0.1662033051,
-0.0157242753,
1.0141204596,
-0.7294781208,
0.5752263665,
0.4306264222,
0.7404384613,
0.8643404841,
0.306121558,
0.5538829565,
-0.5866432786,
-0.0541382879,
0.7157890797,
0.2831442058,
-0.0368763804,
-0.3785706162,
0.4633824825,
0.1164923459,
-0.7011451721,
-0.5869178176,
0.4192067981,
-0.864158392,
-0.5425539613,
1.2393807173,
-0.376804769,
-0.235852465,
-0.4430617988,
-0.2301004231,
0.0803147629,
-0.3014323711,
0.8443388343,
0.4883917272,
-0.6249727607,
-0.5351180434,
-0.143550843,
0.8004959226,
0.8839687705,
-0.9406542182,
0.1725594103,
0.6696228981,
0.2970687151,
-0.0696948692,
0.637288332,
-0.1885769963,
0.1719207764,
-0.2960247993,
-0.0837056562,
-0.6775871515,
-0.6361563802,
-0.298578769,
0.3242678344,
-0.1806824207,
-0.0784573033
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11451v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11451v2
|
SciAgent: Tool-augmented Language Models for Scientific Reasoning
| 2024-02-18T04:19:44 | 2024-02-21T03:04:49 |
Yubo Ma, Zhibin Gou, Junheng Hao, Ruochen Xu, Shuohang Wang, Liangming Pan, Yujiu Yang, Yixin Cao, Aixin Sun, Hany Awadalla, Weizhu Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Scientific reasoning poses an excessive challenge for even the most advanced
Large Language Models (LLMs). To make this task more practical and solvable for
LLMs, we introduce a new task setting named tool-augmented scientific
reasoning. This setting supplements LLMs with scalable toolsets, and shifts the
focus from pursuing an omniscient problem solver to a proficient tool-user. To
facilitate the research of such setting, we construct a tool-augmented training
corpus named MathFunc which encompasses over 30,000 samples and roughly 6,000
tools. Building on MathFunc, we develop SciAgent to retrieve, understand and,
if necessary, use tools for scientific problem solving. Additionally, we craft
a benchmark, SciToolBench, spanning five scientific domains to evaluate LLMs'
abilities with tool assistance. Extensive experiments on SciToolBench confirm
the effectiveness of SciAgent. Notably, SciAgent-Mistral-7B surpasses other
LLMs with the same size by more than 13% in absolute accuracy. Furthermore,
SciAgent-DeepMath-7B shows much superior performance than ChatGPT.
|
[
-0.0650323555,
-0.6179044247,
0.5304370522,
0.6276573539,
-0.153879106,
0.5669575334,
-0.3242995441,
-0.4225789309,
0.076390177,
0.2975548804,
-0.3404245079,
-0.3007522821,
-0.6121342778,
0.4664884508,
-0.3393478692,
0.7643762231,
0.0495640785,
0.4614739716,
-0.6096559167,
0.0550659858,
-0.2907015383,
-0.3696057498,
-0.5544670224,
-0.4691371918,
0.6232221127,
0.3862447739,
0.6718035936,
0.6114994287,
0.8772027493,
0.3968315125,
-0.0979723483,
0.1869111508,
-0.3431364894,
0.2065911144,
-0.4008360207,
-0.6202483773,
-0.5086352825,
0.0038956942,
0.3285435736,
0.967500031,
0.0883386433,
0.0132208532,
-0.3853925467,
0.0401208848,
-0.4208151996,
0.2350688279,
-0.6112125516,
-0.0905001387,
-0.1456721425,
0.000896065,
-0.4826341569,
-0.195327729,
0.0104668355,
-0.934669435,
0.4244645536,
0.1373768598,
0.3266095221,
0.4883388877,
-0.2969880402,
-0.0208812505,
-0.5587035418,
0.8118356466,
-0.5722832084,
0.6086227298,
0.3326275051,
0.2219824642,
-0.5354008675,
-0.8759342432,
-0.5159634352,
-0.4924975336,
0.1873378009,
-0.0052151489,
-0.1031006277,
-0.1118829846,
0.7242041826,
0.0615643635,
-0.5704034567,
0.0420853905,
-0.6469705701,
-0.2915263772,
0.5998336077,
0.0276705734,
0.056723915,
0.0634611621,
-0.035360463,
-0.096616514,
-0.7340660095,
-0.2998845279,
-0.1882609427,
0.0344737358,
0.4069706798,
0.8010516763,
0.1063211262,
0.5915209651,
-0.1075212881,
-0.2485522479,
0.1900435388,
-0.0953382701,
-0.1774895787,
0.3617994785,
0.5695286393,
-0.0283055827,
0.1532455981,
0.0540715493,
-0.0721554309,
0.0452166982,
0.1292717606,
-0.9574332237,
-0.5602686405,
0.0954174921,
0.219113037,
-0.3752020895,
-0.2826265395,
-0.2138233632,
-0.7275990844,
-0.2091320902,
0.1904412806,
-0.5518100858,
-0.2027894258,
0.0936287269,
-0.1869529337,
-0.2319602668,
0.7406841516,
-0.4319121242,
0.1973643899,
0.7845211625,
1.01882267,
-0.15122208,
-0.378969878,
-0.7575956583,
0.0935711637,
-0.3567017019,
1.0716453791,
-0.7620475292,
-0.726824224,
-0.606156528,
0.0577003248,
0.2995475233,
-0.3462340534,
0.4441569448,
-0.3252966106,
0.1348729879,
-0.4344877601,
-0.4366042316,
-0.0994388685,
0.0357911624,
-0.7284716964,
1.2526973486,
0.1030301601,
-0.6656736732,
0.3525840938,
-0.9064511657,
-0.4042978585,
0.5385320187,
-0.0977797657,
-0.13267456,
0.0990960672,
0.1651816815,
0.3064849973,
-0.4190407097,
0.3562774658,
-0.5841318369,
-0.4401547909,
0.3588527739,
-0.3905660212,
0.5578172207,
0.3555952609,
-0.0918446332,
0.175528124,
-0.6560218334,
-0.1034226418,
0.1738574058,
-0.0320088007,
-0.339777559,
-0.014601863,
0.0556774624,
0.1347300559,
0.3103227317,
-0.9658390284,
0.34165591,
-0.574503839,
0.7120094895,
0.5386421084,
-0.3901773393,
0.2270838469,
0.0702147707,
0.4233324826,
-0.2037675977,
-0.160925284,
-0.0622114427,
-0.3476248682,
-0.5799177289,
-0.3625996709,
0.3798937201,
0.4578059316,
-0.7409336567,
0.1653069854,
-0.1937251836,
-0.7757534981,
-0.4490290582,
0.0262782574,
0.1426726133,
0.5253503323,
0.2660692334,
0.1756019592,
-0.5282828808,
-0.652808547,
-0.2865216732,
0.0449441001,
-0.1757343262,
0.1647005379,
0.7978360057,
0.0924454704,
1.0165076256,
-0.579942286,
0.1759165525,
-0.2144533247,
0.1111544296,
0.2621061206,
0.2772033513,
0.3110738695,
-0.8906314969,
-0.3507222235,
0.3092091084,
-0.6756492853,
-0.4739060998,
0.1145727634,
0.2639945149,
0.0483950898,
0.671030879,
-0.6388180852,
0.2308340967,
0.2932088673,
-0.3895802796,
0.8101239204,
-0.2744867206,
0.0902902931,
-0.8456526399,
0.3411969244,
-0.0031040292,
-0.2612964809,
-0.6435813308,
-0.1280873269,
0.1082704887,
-0.2713863254,
-0.6069312096,
0.7678161263,
-0.2408151627,
-0.1218578145,
-0.5255974531,
0.1978922188,
0.1153374687,
0.0003381674,
0.1515499502,
1.214425683,
0.3812372983,
-0.0845720768,
0.6833212376,
0.1123166233,
-0.1452431828,
0.530736506,
-1.1335158348,
0.0429101773,
-0.0534186549,
0.3704494834,
-0.5235986114,
-0.3768964112,
-0.0571753979,
-0.3819542825,
0.0451349206,
0.1142397821,
-0.6804258823,
-0.4402677715,
-0.0053653833,
0.3539409935,
0.3127281368,
-0.5744464993,
0.7034942508,
-0.0202535968,
-0.4195723236,
-0.771671176,
-0.415699631,
0.0821768865,
-0.1046493575,
-0.5649490356,
0.1529012918,
-0.258539021,
-0.3841683865,
0.0259825923,
-0.42465204,
0.0857861787,
0.0917424858,
0.3433862627,
0.2578358352,
-0.0907974392,
0.3576761484,
0.1339204162,
-0.1543635726,
0.3090163171,
-0.031067891,
0.3484568894,
-0.5030378103,
-0.6175156832,
0.4381131828,
0.3249768317,
0.5535248518,
-0.3626180589,
0.3982803226,
0.6006519198,
-0.3550538719,
-0.0236629099,
-0.650947392,
-0.2406447977,
-0.5236302018,
0.7140657902,
-0.5648545027,
-1.0655694008,
0.3921965659,
-0.4327344,
0.242012009,
0.333370775,
0.6167932749,
-0.0659450069,
1.3559501171,
0.3784844279,
0.235832572,
0.0990568027,
-0.0618261583,
0.1932331324,
-0.5882627964,
-0.4186793864,
-0.5256679654,
-0.0003009852,
-0.0252462812,
-0.5490205884,
0.5618971586,
0.1459279209,
-0.4162985981,
0.4607383609,
-0.6902375817,
0.8601757288,
0.400729388,
-0.196094662,
0.3912181854,
-0.0269366782,
-0.3605883718,
0.0305021498,
-0.8449339271,
-0.4026655257,
0.8306543231,
0.218650952,
0.7223300934,
-0.1353079826,
0.3688512444,
0.0883729234,
0.5826299191,
-0.7312976718,
0.7038719058,
0.0067973407,
-0.5780068636,
-0.1734966487,
-0.3216276169,
-0.8150470257,
0.4596162438,
-0.0399600044,
-0.5170742273,
-0.0577938966,
0.1012419909,
-0.1388468742,
0.0590239577,
-0.7993139625,
0.7814518809,
-0.3971999288,
-0.4960069656,
-0.1866980344,
-0.5665174723,
0.275129199,
-0.2197039872,
0.3232987225,
-0.2964934111,
0.0191144757,
0.6329471469,
-0.5697749257,
0.7154846191,
0.0380291678,
0.0066117072,
-0.0149046071,
0.278511256,
0.461533308,
0.1691377461,
-0.0639506504,
0.0250200965,
0.3385190368,
-0.4305643141,
-0.7596175671,
0.9998622537,
-0.6403160095,
-0.9518105984,
-0.8403464556,
-1.0214860439,
-0.1794424951,
0.3552552164,
0.0286355671,
0.2829362452,
-0.1104954332,
0.3135100901,
0.7881006598,
0.04011878,
0.2294163108,
0.5364281535,
-0.2678075731,
-0.2800061107,
0.915412128,
-0.1036082059,
0.2997375131,
0.1119947284,
0.3762785494,
-0.2716872692,
-0.3114064634,
-0.3125943542,
0.3324605823,
-0.7845737338,
-0.3528318405,
-0.6342797875,
-0.272883594,
-0.2849588096,
-0.3175042868,
-0.2034575343,
-0.5226027966,
-0.2042636275,
0.0353888758,
0.931199193,
0.5079582334,
-0.1184530854,
0.2101935148,
-0.6169902682,
-0.0594362319,
0.0869037434,
0.1593727618,
-0.4715388119,
-0.393376559,
-0.1647827327,
0.1273742616,
-0.1099428385,
-0.6801818013,
0.3967476487,
0.107685782,
0.4233948588,
0.1470164359,
-0.2471927106,
0.614685297,
-0.6234096289,
0.6098444462,
0.1436360478,
-0.7670440078,
0.6074247956,
-0.2636547387,
0.3706651032,
0.2029850632,
0.5082169771,
-0.378170073,
-0.4077788293,
-0.691265583,
-0.4729293883,
0.4255075753,
0.1233798787,
-0.2848568857,
0.0667584613,
0.1901973188,
0.0612949692,
0.1624675244,
-0.4143375754,
0.2701358795,
-0.5830959678,
-0.1223911792,
-0.1211234033,
0.2179696709,
-0.3152417839,
-0.4421163499,
0.6711546779,
-0.3144224882,
0.0388980918,
0.1828376949,
-0.2009111196,
-0.0959590971,
0.2910121083,
0.7289551497,
0.6971537471,
-0.1295645684,
0.3551257849,
0.5102744699,
-0.8363071084,
0.0106353592,
0.5009296536,
0.2565777898,
-0.0633513108,
0.4356374443,
0.5021796227,
0.1660593748,
-1.0643125772,
0.2514032722,
0.2222264111,
-0.3296028376,
-0.1963412166,
0.2717267871,
0.3608983755,
0.2782558799,
0.3572403491,
0.07922405,
0.1090275496,
-0.1106415689,
0.0459584817,
0.4344129562,
-0.2248605043,
-0.1436379701,
0.6095267534,
0.0949794501,
-0.3701291382,
0.366183579,
-0.1661942154,
-0.646381855,
0.6772480607,
0.7813566327,
0.3806968927,
-0.3460003138,
0.0641089976,
0.0246255975,
0.2561139762,
-0.128129825,
0.4410185218,
0.1980890036,
-0.4918552041,
-1.0115704536,
-0.5263125896,
-0.6502665877,
0.0695669428,
-0.1245106086,
0.2652809918,
-0.4052309096,
-0.0209999699,
0.3889112175,
0.1715885848,
-0.5001112223,
-0.0644362494,
-0.4573208094,
1.1980112791,
-0.7688038945,
0.8112255335,
0.9708404541,
-0.2073111385,
-0.756221652,
-0.8898113966,
0.1670712233,
-0.7511525154,
0.8379728198,
-0.0612196289,
-0.2055305243,
0.0830443576,
-0.8866352439,
-0.9037221074,
1.1199723482,
0.4452919662,
-0.6299247742,
0.2110794485,
0.0723730177,
0.5841770768,
-0.2584364116,
0.421418041,
0.6245979071,
0.6205434203,
0.6878809929,
-1.082469821,
0.0525497608,
-0.5290019512,
-0.3545424342,
0.232523337,
-0.3544244468,
0.6405234933,
-0.4093648493,
0.1570089906,
-0.1001140103,
0.6723631024,
0.888961494,
0.3266157806,
0.425241977,
0.3156749904,
0.6422140598,
-0.2369861603,
0.714214921,
0.0238934737,
0.0131292948,
0.9560105205,
-0.5699334741,
0.5288633704,
0.5491646528,
-0.1817538291,
0.3323707581,
0.5220679641,
-0.406429857,
0.0942674577,
0.3085823059,
-0.4917310476,
-0.5731084943,
-0.4843080938,
-0.4158546329,
0.3452106118,
0.7165454626,
-0.0082816407,
-0.3271456957,
0.2961027026,
0.2330426425,
0.0311444327,
-0.2619858384,
0.2522146404,
0.2215259373,
-0.3284989893,
0.3686639369,
-0.0609678328,
0.3334569931,
-0.6524598002,
-0.2989673615,
0.0492557399,
0.1669051796,
-0.3299737275,
-0.8129036427,
0.0205806773,
0.0595133603,
-0.0358484425,
-0.0042558503,
0.9895380139,
-0.4532071054,
-0.833512187,
-0.3985281289,
0.4965301752,
0.4294698238,
-0.0472024642,
-0.6052626371,
0.2316099554,
-0.2648597956,
-0.1876358837,
0.2133401483,
0.4460839629,
-0.3471468985,
0.976213634,
1.0153403282,
0.2672950327,
-0.1718172878,
0.186806187,
1.0233950615,
-0.4565833211,
-0.2068077773,
-0.56104213,
0.1854967624,
-0.4107504189,
-0.1741835922,
0.8798701763,
0.4750564098,
0.6325334311,
-0.0710264668,
0.8197769523,
-0.1266633272,
0.5339127779,
-0.1307807714,
0.492398411,
-0.3423271775,
0.3288825452,
-0.1708735079,
-0.8964356184,
-0.4916330278,
0.8321117163,
-0.4376865327,
0.1509588212,
0.7947294116,
0.7649751902,
-0.2660901546,
0.2719161212,
0.1735095829,
0.2559455037,
0.5810767412,
0.5105258822,
0.8520582914,
0.049101267,
0.5055159926,
-0.2130591273,
-0.2719190717,
-0.1160902679,
-1.1544926167,
-1.0456944704,
-0.2470961809,
-0.2715221941,
-0.199028939,
-0.0600813068,
1.1263287067,
0.5550504923,
-0.5999554992,
-0.1193731874,
-0.1960244179,
0.0108072562,
-0.2039572448,
-0.239873454,
0.3702846467,
-0.1881402582,
-0.6009756923,
0.7840940356,
0.3583323061,
-0.1071986109,
-0.5784460306,
-0.0231105294,
-0.0395678207,
0.0294945072,
0.7485111356,
0.3657143414,
-0.7769176364,
-0.4202695489,
0.5034764409,
0.1687675864,
-0.2373963892,
0.9901468754,
-0.9596851468,
0.4157583117,
0.3835102916,
0.5822796822,
0.5545542836,
-0.3062420487,
0.5146281719,
-0.75766927,
0.1435000598,
0.5054934621,
0.4355090261,
0.3524145782,
-0.2329768687,
0.7091558576,
0.3139315844,
-0.6071113348,
-1.1541856527,
0.0888898224,
-1.0230919123,
-0.3414218128,
1.1781958342,
0.0111596473,
-0.1982365251,
-0.2090962678,
-0.4204275608,
0.0770337135,
-0.4652105272,
0.4695023596,
0.7759080529,
-0.2159078717,
-0.2418847382,
-0.4655383527,
0.3719376624,
0.5270231962,
-0.8938969374,
0.0275677703,
0.5286825895,
0.4686464369,
0.414458245,
0.1913560778,
-0.0489735901,
0.6069829464,
0.0252466165,
0.1352171302,
-0.7478426099,
-0.4326923192,
0.0006513187,
0.0042389515,
0.0907491595,
0.6069236398
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11447v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11447v1
|
In-Context Example Ordering Guided by Label Distributions
| 2024-02-18T04:08:10 | 2024-02-18T04:08:10 |
Zhichao Xu, Daniel Cohen, Bei Wang, Vivek Srikumar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
By allowing models to predict without task-specific training, in-context
learning (ICL) with pretrained LLMs has enormous potential in NLP. However, a
number of problems persist in ICL. In particular, its performance is sensitive
to the choice and order of in-context examples. Given the same set of
in-context examples with different orderings, model performance may vary
between near random to near state-of-the-art. In this work, we formulate
in-context example ordering as an optimization problem. We examine three
problem settings that differ in the assumptions they make about what is known
about the task. Inspired by the idea of learning from label proportions, we
propose two principles for in-context example ordering guided by model's
probability predictions. We apply our proposed principles to thirteen text
classification datasets and nine different autoregressive LLMs with 700M to 13B
parameters. We demonstrate that our approach outperforms the baselines by
improving the classification accuracy, reducing model miscalibration, and also
by selecting better in-context examples.
|
[
-0.2790504396,
-0.3391560018,
0.6379775405,
0.3581942022,
-0.3885302842,
-0.3790191412,
0.0212205667,
-0.4739668071,
-0.274258852,
0.5504701138,
-0.4012653232,
-0.5339141488,
-0.6217646003,
0.2212440819,
-0.4180837572,
1.2471095324,
0.1038949043,
0.2347356826,
-0.5521901846,
-0.2612226009,
-0.3085775375,
-0.7963927388,
-0.6761535406,
-0.3666064739,
0.3914008141,
0.4379127622,
0.4224627018,
0.8599626422,
0.4158300757,
0.2981619835,
-0.0780966729,
0.1871373206,
-0.2842229307,
0.1164068356,
0.0582630634,
-0.5929054618,
-0.0854826346,
0.2846330404,
0.3558320403,
0.7002981305,
-0.2884505093,
0.0351820178,
0.1128952503,
0.3762624562,
-0.6724683046,
-0.0015854763,
-0.5799348354,
0.1677899212,
0.2515310645,
-0.3323863149,
-0.8385507464,
-0.1984119564,
0.5503351688,
-0.4781587124,
0.0584726594,
0.4996400177,
0.4496156871,
0.3308127224,
-0.3943576515,
-0.5036532283,
-0.4646792412,
0.9417437315,
-0.8421388268,
0.2872987092,
0.4054325819,
0.2025304437,
-0.3465443552,
-0.8708843589,
-0.2173073292,
0.1717581749,
-0.2950713336,
0.0791715384,
0.0018055112,
0.0971819237,
0.3161200583,
-0.0422666818,
-0.5916423202,
0.4918979108,
0.0224400423,
0.2553333938,
0.3931832612,
-0.0121131521,
0.0743546933,
0.0105896825,
-0.4938242435,
-0.3522919714,
-0.7225376964,
0.1532569826,
0.1262067109,
0.2732337713,
-0.1077158675,
0.4750526249,
-0.1383214593,
1.0851942301,
0.1983533055,
-0.3787233531,
0.2415818274,
-0.055163417,
-0.4447080791,
0.3544691801,
0.6251952648,
0.376055181,
-0.0390308052,
-0.1597057134,
-0.3151348829,
-0.2778967917,
0.2498264909,
-0.8192461729,
-0.136702612,
0.1753619015,
-0.284630239,
-0.3047327995,
-0.0461771637,
-0.4515758157,
-0.1129426733,
-0.4449314773,
0.5841104984,
-0.2737495601,
0.4172859788,
0.1689712405,
0.1853858978,
-0.0272173714,
0.293876946,
-1.0075511932,
0.2504549623,
0.6473861337,
0.5088744164,
-0.3255408108,
-0.0847552568,
-0.4129486382,
0.2711277008,
-0.2951291502,
0.6456829309,
-0.3417817354,
-0.218105033,
-0.0771240741,
-0.3595726788,
0.0113638695,
-0.4566786587,
0.6337818503,
-0.4772662818,
0.5664231181,
-0.0173848886,
-0.8910221457,
-0.2658806443,
-0.0967552066,
-0.1753115356,
0.8816667795,
-0.2378367931,
-0.8332360983,
0.6573293805,
-0.3692362607,
-0.3538886607,
0.0042834454,
-0.3599886894,
-0.3948747814,
0.209851712,
0.2902804017,
0.9415934086,
-0.0881899372,
0.246212244,
-0.2294449657,
-0.3137707114,
0.2174222022,
-0.3726185858,
0.8796479702,
0.2924379706,
-0.3476805687,
-0.0672287866,
-0.5732890964,
0.1358946413,
-0.1958028376,
-0.264660269,
-0.8288552165,
0.3887903988,
-0.2060601562,
0.316557616,
-0.0597119965,
-0.2414221019,
0.011682393,
-0.787365675,
0.2509148717,
0.6650567651,
0.2756618857,
0.9067322612,
-0.2432631105,
0.2825026214,
-0.0637401715,
0.3209266365,
0.1957018971,
-0.5207452178,
-0.72170645,
-0.1667102873,
0.1209338382,
0.5203987956,
-0.4939486086,
0.398190856,
-0.0786193237,
-0.3110329509,
-0.1185980588,
0.0263589155,
0.5749723315,
0.865146935,
0.4273199737,
-0.0865824521,
-0.2507288754,
-0.9229592681,
-0.1337298751,
-0.2667714953,
-0.1071363986,
0.4229059219,
0.0851383805,
-0.0600029603,
0.9112122059,
-0.6006836295,
0.0015229266,
-0.1046828702,
0.2188738436,
0.4868098497,
0.3860587478,
0.6460629106,
-1.1842889786,
-0.5134577155,
-0.1266402453,
-0.6595803499,
-0.2835312784,
0.0390361808,
-0.3319180906,
0.2446794957,
0.8576267362,
-0.2048124969,
0.2804554403,
0.3685750663,
0.043546956,
0.1983068287,
-0.4349570274,
-0.4400169849,
-1.210496068,
-0.7312362194,
0.1796343923,
-0.1774512082,
-0.646928668,
-0.1476059109,
0.1408419162,
0.1315484643,
-0.4497432113,
0.5022654533,
-0.4128566086,
-0.0962239057,
-0.1067251712,
-0.0379887894,
0.0113079008,
0.3661321104,
0.1945480853,
0.4766424894,
0.389441818,
-0.873280108,
-0.3058428466,
0.1603818834,
-0.8126639128,
0.4302724004,
-0.4439851046,
-0.1112457588,
-0.3221354485,
0.2485598326,
-1.0904519558,
0.0429108962,
0.0643742085,
-0.187967658,
0.594715476,
-0.070370391,
-0.6442173123,
-0.0998477712,
0.1266056895,
0.4194175601,
0.5019958019,
-0.7548045516,
0.3180094063,
0.2614695132,
0.0233041216,
-0.8552830219,
-0.3591685295,
-0.3611893654,
-0.6419631839,
-0.0101796733,
0.7312259078,
-0.4925992787,
-0.3000923991,
-0.3680895269,
-0.1779121757,
0.0024612001,
0.0936912894,
0.1722216308,
-0.0207283888,
-0.0202229787,
0.2537600696,
0.2070107907,
0.064454861,
-0.036894355,
-0.4526821673,
0.1555612236,
0.1327118427,
-0.0530669987,
-0.1042256653,
0.238420248,
0.205747053,
0.1406714171,
0.5163057446,
0.2158111334,
-0.1907688826,
-0.6834465265,
-0.4682546556,
-0.0944088697,
-0.5582786798,
0.3289442658,
-0.2277787924,
-0.4770249128,
0.0013444445,
0.1395398229,
0.3619056046,
-0.0549391806,
0.508720696,
-0.7298343182,
1.0081027746,
0.8780630231,
-0.1116746143,
0.7128635049,
-0.2327193171,
0.1345961243,
-0.5501852036,
-0.0248672068,
-0.3330748677,
-0.2027073652,
-0.6312943101,
-0.3276798129,
0.5363261104,
0.2295121402,
-0.3535387516,
0.385628283,
-0.7099149823,
0.7996870875,
0.5973322392,
0.3696013689,
0.1873163432,
0.3831862509,
-0.4206247926,
-0.0245877728,
-1.0894415379,
-0.357927978,
0.7616347671,
-0.0267917365,
0.6419758201,
0.0641062632,
0.9450289607,
0.0897754952,
0.7191281319,
-0.660092175,
0.45807603,
-0.4243832231,
-0.5007144809,
-0.3212943375,
-0.186684832,
-1.0201518536,
0.5471966267,
-0.0967706144,
-0.9005476832,
0.2898511291,
0.0991162285,
-0.2259647995,
-0.1301665306,
-0.8903362155,
0.6311985254,
-0.3155644238,
0.1510557085,
0.2343023419,
-0.880648911,
0.188392669,
-0.0161153972,
0.4451003373,
0.0684679821,
-0.1685449928,
0.6599598527,
-0.3997960985,
0.8145705462,
0.0421794131,
0.0177252367,
0.3172349334,
0.0297898799,
0.457916528,
-0.0882013217,
-0.2273675203,
-0.3425060809,
-0.1407124698,
-0.0964060277,
-0.7941424251,
0.4875853658,
-0.8549848795,
-0.5248138905,
-0.3081889749,
-0.5485689044,
-0.425460428,
-0.1072935313,
0.9642910957,
0.712217927,
0.4095485508,
0.306447506,
0.6215661168,
-0.1738867313,
0.9400487542,
0.3813202381,
-0.0075033945,
-0.4065838456,
0.7691085935,
0.3070174456,
0.4407412708,
0.965831399,
0.3040935397,
-0.516790688,
-0.9255117178,
-0.1748605818,
0.1693057269,
-1.1566303968,
-0.3307172954,
-0.7463850379,
0.1165990904,
-0.1960480958,
-0.5193768144,
0.0657035634,
-0.1635802388,
-0.6441082358,
-0.1026701033,
0.0629581884,
0.5860259533,
0.3846328855,
0.604871273,
-0.3473796844,
0.0632118881,
0.1858083755,
0.1132654995,
0.0559555627,
-0.6710727811,
-0.1800420582,
-0.2506108284,
-0.2699870765,
-0.789046824,
0.6670628786,
0.196950227,
0.8522815704,
0.4637435377,
0.3770689666,
0.7448346615,
-0.7296223044,
0.2412133217,
0.2086145878,
-0.6341605186,
0.5154007077,
-0.2289775163,
0.1009170413,
0.5894950628,
0.7280580997,
-0.1993059516,
-0.4682084322,
-0.7204956412,
-1.0633542538,
0.6932723522,
0.3175563812,
-0.0459085442,
-0.1287686825,
0.601913929,
0.1905928552,
0.2531694174,
-1.1541458368,
-0.4645202458,
0.0194330383,
-0.3853881359,
-0.5312511325,
-0.2418492585,
0.0722182691,
-0.3833458126,
0.6691095829,
-0.1736091673,
0.1530636996,
0.2157592922,
-0.301124841,
0.3327718973,
-0.087320812,
0.6986754537,
0.7233662605,
-0.369515419,
0.0747320503,
0.1481509209,
-0.1321406364,
0.384739995,
-0.1051154062,
-0.2819111943,
-0.0414212421,
0.2397767156,
0.6122245193,
0.3769815564,
-0.4368855357,
0.4865982533,
0.0532681867,
-0.0342974663,
-0.3019690216,
0.0231160354,
-0.0398177207,
0.3339556456,
0.5522559285,
-0.2334903777,
0.4048727453,
-0.1324781775,
0.3206737339,
0.3989826441,
-0.2721913457,
0.1787475348,
0.3864178658,
-0.2599542439,
-0.4566032887,
0.440417707,
-0.1989205629,
-0.2820726037,
0.7728661895,
0.7088252306,
0.7073893547,
0.034558747,
0.2006303519,
0.1936799884,
0.1283755451,
-0.3763825595,
-0.178670004,
-0.2048825175,
-0.8667883873,
-0.2896786928,
-0.8332785368,
-0.5151977539,
-0.1014415622,
-0.7458795905,
0.3457818627,
-0.3339409232,
-0.1854354888,
0.2074031532,
-0.1387162656,
-0.4230909944,
0.5671738386,
0.0737387016,
0.5376894474,
-0.6888020635,
0.8171871305,
0.5034822226,
0.0090023931,
-0.6500011086,
0.0491756313,
-0.2330147177,
-0.5464468598,
0.8951606154,
0.2652493715,
0.1333071291,
0.1821436733,
-0.765122056,
-1.067081809,
1.0575989485,
0.2920874357,
-0.2343711257,
-0.0825864077,
-0.3008885384,
0.5198697448,
-0.8299725652,
0.2827076912,
-0.1227305681,
-0.0616280958,
-0.027609935,
-0.53951478,
-0.2507085204,
0.2357576042,
0.3177927136,
0.0228849575,
-0.4464704692,
0.5741474628,
-0.157487005,
-0.0669417083,
-0.0305341072,
0.6955586076,
0.4246989191,
0.3475396037,
0.648388803,
0.3406571448,
0.463216424,
0.0885427892,
1.2810285091,
0.0753946528,
0.2495066375,
1.3929023743,
-0.0147164697,
0.8397818208,
0.5128560662,
-0.1921645403,
0.4602559209,
1.2457075119,
0.1406980157,
0.868850112,
0.2218734175,
-0.0253278334,
-0.0681193769,
-0.0557856187,
-0.0992954224,
0.4361104667,
0.5027144551,
-0.60370332,
-0.2876958251,
0.1124541014,
-0.2142945528,
-0.1129633039,
-0.1893196553,
0.9259184003,
0.2290008962,
-0.5450361967,
0.6551660299,
-0.1383966506,
0.7534795403,
-0.3238020837,
0.0003522466,
-0.2454611808,
0.0288934913,
0.0265439712,
-0.412193507,
-0.0902005583,
-0.4499133229,
-0.4657631218,
-0.6783142686,
0.2241665423,
-0.278646946,
-0.6592913866,
0.356441319,
0.2717072368,
0.3554064631,
0.2645860612,
-0.7170496583,
-0.4484395087,
-0.053177014,
-0.4619016945,
0.6943292022,
0.4901377261,
-0.1803782731,
0.76704216,
0.342425108,
-0.2322283536,
0.1670018137,
-0.2252790332,
0.3197768927,
-0.1876218766,
-0.6395795941,
-0.9251859784,
0.1805882007,
-0.0669466481,
-0.2903651893,
0.6441055536,
0.4042250812,
1.0594915152,
-0.0298303869,
0.3024785817,
0.2813370228,
0.2937569916,
-0.6100437045,
0.4509689212,
-0.737577498,
0.2573606074,
-0.5315212011,
-1.0276507139,
-0.5515817404,
0.7769852281,
-0.3529726267,
-0.0040959758,
0.6592982411,
0.6108499765,
-0.0581430458,
-0.1004799232,
0.4990384579,
-0.0300095771,
0.1078957617,
0.3959860206,
0.478834331,
-0.3316119015,
0.5009798408,
-0.747071147,
-0.1087583005,
-0.2458824217,
-1.1510617733,
-0.7613061666,
-0.7338559031,
-0.3095048368,
-0.1806994826,
-0.1023358703,
1.1111015081,
0.9189018011,
-0.5360353589,
-0.5122275352,
-0.1484788209,
0.3575482368,
-0.2164672166,
-0.1815338135,
0.3496731818,
-0.5274954438,
-0.8999065161,
0.380877912,
0.2133670747,
0.5200791955,
0.4499186277,
0.1742988229,
-0.2851784825,
-0.055309955,
0.8585447669,
0.0795715228,
-0.8574086428,
-0.1291853189,
-0.2273686677,
-0.2334447801,
0.0829379931,
0.5908907652,
-0.6236271262,
0.3194102645,
0.4786015451,
0.6129193902,
0.5964423418,
0.1571284682,
0.5796195865,
-0.9813987613,
0.1790872365,
0.3971791267,
0.3304855824,
0.0800853297,
-0.4540787339,
0.6088939309,
-0.0992785096,
-0.5848708749,
-0.9373089671,
0.2802968919,
-0.9366003275,
-0.5503001809,
1.1536468267,
-0.1553346217,
-0.0137259634,
-0.0262906216,
0.1027160808,
0.0707212389,
-0.2751285434,
0.6387904286,
0.7652438283,
-0.5993798971,
-0.0971503034,
-0.6650734544,
0.6929081678,
0.7093854547,
-0.528790772,
-0.1844307929,
0.3692189455,
0.136720553,
0.0533240251,
0.5448868275,
0.1624664962,
-0.1362692118,
-0.5628476739,
-0.1949271858,
0.4261220396,
-0.4743013084,
-0.2567023933,
0.2454980612,
-0.0853461623,
-0.0394897014
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11443v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11443v1
|
Benchmark Self-Evolving: A Multi-Agent Framework for Dynamic LLM Evaluation
| 2024-02-18T03:40:06 | 2024-02-18T03:40:06 |
Siyuan Wang, Zhuohan Long, Zhihao Fan, Zhongyu Wei, Xuanjing Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper presents a benchmark self-evolving framework to dynamically
evaluate rapidly advancing Large Language Models (LLMs), aiming for a more
accurate assessment of their capabilities and limitations. We utilize a
multi-agent system to manipulate the context or question of original instances,
reframing new evolving instances with high confidence that dynamically extend
existing benchmarks. Towards a more scalable, robust and fine-grained
evaluation, we implement six reframing operations to construct evolving
instances testing LLMs against diverse queries, data noise and probing their
problem-solving sub-abilities. With this framework, we extend benchmark
datasets of four tasks. Experimental results show a general performance decline
in most LLMs against their original results. This decline under our scalable
and robust evaluations, alongside our fine-grained evaluation, more accurately
reflect models' capabilities. Besides, our framework widens performance
discrepancies both between different models and within the same model across
various tasks, facilitating more informed model selection for specific tasks
(Code and data are available at
https://github.com/NanshineLoong/Self-Evolving-Benchmark).
|
[
-0.2231921405,
-0.9278098941,
0.6131433845,
0.2308928519,
0.0185488984,
0.4559931457,
-0.4552820921,
-0.4785727262,
-0.0957530737,
0.3648913205,
-0.6525325179,
-0.2859304547,
-0.4982421398,
0.1653191894,
-0.561244607,
0.5690035224,
-0.0155395465,
-0.0553535856,
-0.3767663836,
-0.4034323692,
-0.4930892289,
-0.1866760254,
-0.4480594397,
-0.4563885629,
0.1577292085,
0.4281776845,
0.5376703739,
0.8166968226,
0.4465365708,
0.4654108882,
0.0849485472,
0.2622795403,
-0.539251864,
0.6007875204,
-0.3670611382,
-0.2906861305,
-0.5187797546,
-0.1179062426,
0.7730200291,
0.3874239624,
-0.2837790549,
0.4945007563,
-0.0277528875,
0.2725562751,
-0.6187810302,
0.2792481184,
-0.8858835697,
-0.1578247547,
-0.1022590399,
0.0560627952,
-0.1815863252,
-0.1030932814,
0.0802324042,
-0.3547465503,
0.070718348,
-0.0972637311,
0.5160479546,
0.4560052752,
-0.214919582,
-0.200497508,
-0.5658341646,
0.801389575,
-0.6640102863,
0.4088123441,
-0.1765672714,
0.729678154,
-0.2698246241,
-1.0804373026,
-0.3537321985,
-0.6254530549,
0.4312457442,
0.0226952769,
-0.2076883167,
-0.3491412699,
0.0088286288,
0.353769362,
-0.2852426767,
0.3984320164,
0.0007676597,
0.0650037602,
0.6710534096,
0.3981589675,
0.1577909887,
0.1512838602,
-0.4433424473,
-0.189127326,
-0.4514608383,
-0.1575947702,
0.2566161752,
0.4668051898,
-0.079689689,
0.2396102101,
-0.3539663851,
0.3364499211,
0.1682205796,
-0.0882826522,
0.5469379425,
-0.4561058581,
-0.1501004547,
-0.3237961531,
0.7772519588,
0.1848579198,
0.1692860425,
-0.2108050436,
-0.4529970288,
-0.1482051909,
0.4431437552,
-0.8020384908,
-0.053418044,
0.1061676666,
-0.4265058935,
-0.4509368539,
-0.3296118081,
-0.9856191874,
-0.5300433636,
-0.0345790982,
0.3723803759,
-0.2641531825,
-0.3880209923,
0.1599102765,
0.2026273459,
0.1058958396,
0.3394100368,
-0.6907110214,
0.3989439905,
0.5723042488,
0.5362013578,
-0.4331487417,
-0.647975862,
-0.505384028,
0.006279652,
-0.2251587659,
0.9478004575,
-0.6108652949,
-0.26273036,
-0.0600010976,
0.1493625194,
0.0225302149,
-0.8090804219,
0.5060603619,
-0.4574174881,
-0.1124831662,
-0.0569695197,
-0.4350337386,
0.0173437037,
0.2922062874,
-0.6158536077,
1.3374884129,
0.3034346402,
-0.2524930537,
0.2671805322,
-0.7438712716,
-0.1932165176,
0.296068877,
-0.3285782039,
-0.4697181284,
0.2545605004,
0.219321385,
0.3915148079,
-0.6656801701,
0.2679708302,
-0.7454246879,
-0.1713511348,
0.3490176797,
-0.4632966816,
0.4060564935,
0.2933662534,
-0.4930164218,
0.319277674,
-0.9576585293,
0.3117064834,
0.2951688468,
-0.2780530155,
0.0224112142,
0.2159454525,
-0.1210771352,
0.1932269633,
0.6591387987,
-0.3393008411,
0.4104553163,
-0.0208304115,
0.4393548369,
0.7592890859,
-0.0629074126,
0.1227333918,
-0.4033831656,
0.643872261,
-0.0860386416,
0.2623586655,
-0.175499022,
-0.1407004446,
-0.7715075016,
-0.1770887971,
0.1340331137,
0.30060184,
-0.5658181906,
0.2803921402,
-0.4111302495,
-0.6443674564,
-0.5279310346,
0.3664355278,
0.3255090415,
0.1653527468,
0.5433034897,
-0.2950225472,
-0.2996813059,
-1.0111769438,
-0.2540115416,
-0.3138526678,
0.1792617738,
0.2633218765,
0.4610783458,
-0.6200292706,
0.6937018037,
-0.1988005638,
0.1194498986,
-0.2408686429,
0.2193824798,
0.0012120343,
0.3474502861,
0.6164331436,
-0.2848539352,
-0.289316237,
0.0500050932,
-0.7062849998,
-0.6160332561,
-0.1994246244,
0.167143777,
-0.0187973436,
0.5165839791,
-0.2874593735,
-0.0038630443,
0.6597748399,
-0.1764263958,
0.8170776367,
-0.2827615738,
0.0845284685,
-0.9534782767,
-0.1382420957,
-0.1621089727,
-0.3164128363,
-0.4350149333,
0.4898814261,
0.1918196678,
0.219909057,
-0.1661001742,
0.7359133363,
-0.7899240851,
-0.3318770826,
-0.5340000987,
0.2250059843,
-0.1400653422,
0.2214966714,
-0.3912960291,
0.9439036846,
0.7162932754,
-0.5518828034,
0.5983228683,
-0.1482400149,
-0.599740386,
0.3994486928,
-0.4304510355,
0.2738144994,
0.1457664222,
-0.2556859255,
-0.7694183588,
0.1325478256,
-0.1089561731,
-0.03958508,
0.2363682538,
-0.027233148,
-0.6678866148,
-0.3380647898,
-0.2035729438,
0.4667429328,
0.2539587319,
-0.5329195857,
0.6515203118,
0.2680609226,
-0.1364057511,
-0.4579366148,
-0.5341129899,
0.1177886575,
-0.2565170825,
-0.5198196769,
0.3162006438,
-0.3093527555,
-0.315639019,
-0.0711424351,
-0.2750359476,
-0.0347452424,
0.3370085657,
0.0291453078,
-0.2312139571,
-0.3187948763,
0.2467287481,
0.0280389097,
0.0602059327,
0.1117737666,
-0.096298866,
0.6733235121,
-0.4772054851,
-0.4779318571,
-0.2129070461,
-0.0699449256,
0.8983986378,
-0.3907098472,
0.4240170121,
0.5717002153,
-0.1289876401,
-0.5985174775,
-0.8155665994,
-0.1720423996,
-0.5346140862,
0.664966464,
-0.6935719252,
-0.8507664204,
0.8011433482,
-0.5053403378,
-0.0184839331,
0.4239581227,
0.7682843804,
0.2985337377,
0.6661244035,
0.6096627712,
0.075145036,
0.5658837557,
-0.096319057,
-0.2167268842,
-0.8451477885,
-0.122567907,
-0.346748203,
-0.087447457,
-0.7778948545,
-0.6876004934,
0.1082343757,
0.1053089276,
-0.151965186,
0.4056589603,
-0.369862318,
0.3440535665,
-0.0122779552,
-0.157386452,
0.3009736538,
-0.2185404152,
-0.2569304407,
0.1801602989,
-0.5343114734,
-0.5943522453,
1.2136654854,
0.5736961961,
0.8552790284,
0.2913370132,
0.4802200198,
0.5401924849,
0.5401095152,
-0.4401380718,
0.6957574487,
0.020474216,
-0.4864105284,
-0.3976109326,
-0.4497223496,
-1.070160985,
0.6182772517,
-0.2466737628,
-0.6775637865,
0.169769913,
-0.2473305464,
-0.3178694546,
0.1454246491,
-0.5125604272,
0.8685443401,
-0.6435824633,
-0.548542738,
-0.3814368844,
-0.1929522604,
0.2069882751,
-0.5299064517,
0.1857376695,
-0.5321929455,
-0.432364583,
0.3800136745,
-0.1959403455,
0.5872024298,
-0.0147890821,
-0.2495911419,
0.3050147593,
0.1204612777,
0.4390967488,
0.1008486375,
-0.6056201458,
0.0726239756,
0.1202790439,
-0.2777858973,
-0.7905606627,
0.7418869734,
-0.7105995417,
-0.7040192485,
-0.2911424637,
-0.4992633462,
-0.2729628682,
0.3119338453,
-0.4633024931,
0.4078633785,
-0.3101039529,
0.3037230074,
0.1033863127,
-0.0989485458,
0.4204082787,
1.0569906235,
-0.4078115225,
-0.2991971076,
0.5554247499,
0.0939667374,
0.2553848624,
0.0266353581,
0.3539575934,
-0.4382661879,
-0.9850170016,
-0.3784129918,
0.0804403424,
-0.7232356071,
-0.1611312479,
-0.3521618843,
0.0352772549,
-0.4828915596,
0.2398043126,
-0.7045769095,
-0.0455562472,
-0.0654769093,
0.0694468021,
0.1360202134,
0.8662671447,
0.036716681,
0.2979201674,
-0.5344577432,
0.0181129873,
0.3741391897,
0.4855791032,
0.0341371968,
-0.7492110133,
-0.3100677729,
-0.1588457078,
-0.36712116,
-0.8257571459,
0.3100394905,
0.1466866881,
0.9949175119,
0.2720301747,
0.0752090812,
0.7816590071,
-0.5615451336,
0.4931291044,
-0.1953083426,
-0.9323224425,
0.1962170601,
-0.3852528334,
0.545322001,
0.8307002783,
-0.1207410619,
-0.1745541245,
-0.2902995944,
-0.5029758215,
-0.6120278835,
0.4774618745,
0.0823967457,
0.1568922848,
0.0730934441,
0.7029238939,
0.1224860549,
0.2699728012,
-0.8446901441,
-0.289217025,
-0.0432975367,
-0.0250470992,
-0.0699024498,
-0.3077200055,
-0.0002341647,
-0.1556184888,
0.4620486796,
-0.491887331,
0.2120393515,
-0.1132266968,
-0.1970088184,
-0.0650279671,
0.3570602834,
0.5674791932,
0.8681923151,
-0.1337893903,
0.0792180449,
0.6778092384,
-0.1046549603,
0.2287114263,
0.2465800345,
0.1778398901,
-0.353069514,
0.4775365591,
0.7259123325,
0.5302120447,
-0.836820364,
0.3884090483,
-0.2033605427,
0.0702337623,
-0.2385727614,
0.2227869332,
0.0616193563,
0.5989710093,
0.3601088226,
-0.3154237866,
0.0730540752,
-0.7777242064,
0.3929062784,
0.4259288311,
-0.0594644025,
-0.303319782,
0.3861072063,
0.1722751409,
-0.4077059925,
0.2192900926,
-0.4342677593,
-0.3064999878,
0.5873705149,
0.6711550951,
1.1100968122,
-0.502630055,
0.126156643,
0.0632707179,
0.4174396992,
-0.1216653064,
0.1190702617,
-0.1440840065,
-0.8006480932,
-0.3069776297,
-0.7049366832,
-0.5070295334,
0.4082831442,
-0.531376183,
0.185643509,
-0.3339376152,
-0.2573801875,
-0.0771050751,
0.2679724395,
-0.4361246228,
0.0929309279,
-0.0802222043,
0.8828552961,
-0.334699899,
1.1184463501,
0.8213605285,
-0.106837891,
-0.3060469925,
0.1546293795,
-0.1243771911,
-0.9670860767,
0.5010967255,
0.2130914181,
-0.489400804,
-0.1524999291,
-0.3787977397,
-1.2574921846,
1.2195564508,
0.5247750282,
-0.6250612736,
0.2667991817,
0.0811939016,
0.8644026518,
-0.7756893039,
0.5575717092,
0.5464498997,
0.4321085513,
-0.1288419813,
-0.92489779,
0.1066580862,
-0.2776144743,
0.0151184136,
0.0197945368,
-0.9732735753,
0.9112241268,
0.0384411402,
-0.3603297472,
0.2437838614,
0.6558247805,
0.19537884,
0.149003759,
0.6638380289,
0.4234106541,
0.718688488,
0.0241554547,
0.8384733796,
-0.7543848157,
0.3726022542,
1.3302755356,
-0.602427125,
0.8383389711,
0.1136252657,
-0.0261951219,
0.7468044162,
0.3976499438,
-0.2790709436,
0.285902828,
0.4750575721,
-0.1934562027,
-0.4052914381,
0.1823340505,
-0.2570262849,
0.7695913911,
0.2238609046,
-0.1492503136,
-0.4122833908,
-0.3048540056,
-0.1535698771,
0.2292729914,
-0.0578492396,
0.6370292306,
-0.1551576108,
-0.6818819642,
0.5486934185,
0.2841528356,
0.5864420533,
-0.5521305203,
0.2539399564,
-0.2221098542,
0.372259289,
0.1194010675,
-0.5233940482,
0.0952212662,
-0.1313796341,
-0.0194606893,
-0.2695114613,
0.675820291,
-0.3588805199,
-0.4298753738,
0.7142771482,
0.8334746957,
0.1681683958,
0.1747551113,
-1.1893601418,
0.5167501569,
-0.2163569182,
-0.3194074035,
0.3347866535,
0.522036314,
-0.128348276,
1.1437110901,
0.4902478755,
0.0228106715,
0.1702093482,
0.2557762563,
0.8013089299,
-0.5931102037,
-0.1956284195,
-0.9496546984,
0.1170995608,
-0.1845831573,
-0.3476429284,
0.8496897817,
0.5017123222,
0.561360836,
0.1007713825,
0.5508500338,
0.3498464227,
0.3952393532,
-0.3128148317,
0.702231288,
-0.6869142652,
0.4401474893,
-0.1659099609,
-1.0143654346,
0.0922333151,
0.4987302125,
-0.301084727,
0.4322949648,
0.630943954,
0.6950120926,
0.1191309243,
-0.2833151519,
0.4640544653,
0.438151896,
0.4193484187,
0.2448488921,
0.9776334763,
-0.3205117285,
0.3107652962,
-0.0074681323,
-0.2792635858,
-0.146132499,
-1.0865546465,
-0.7977458835,
-0.4545761645,
-0.6210759878,
-0.068803519,
0.1606173664,
0.8558446169,
0.9222348928,
-0.6329000592,
-0.5926163197,
0.043382898,
0.0121084973,
-0.3085876107,
-0.2178718597,
0.0247721318,
-0.695845902,
-0.7876523733,
0.9348207116,
0.3386822343,
0.0209853202,
-0.7106227875,
-0.103252694,
-0.1110751778,
0.2438548505,
0.607775569,
0.2609312236,
-0.6633672714,
-0.3760231733,
-0.2001759559,
0.0016536015,
0.0500426963,
0.5112448931,
-0.7084841132,
0.6277645826,
0.1357278526,
0.8595226407,
0.6278709173,
-0.0525041074,
0.4913449585,
-0.4546337426,
-0.1601550728,
0.0159452204,
0.3570738733,
0.3266171515,
-0.0193757135,
0.5248977542,
0.1346401423,
-0.7422381043,
-1.1432514191,
0.2756324112,
-0.8466005921,
-0.3395772278,
1.0980961323,
-0.0433088616,
-0.0688787326,
-0.069408901,
0.3125739396,
0.0835983455,
-0.3803563714,
0.8722078204,
0.7025582194,
-0.2595106959,
-0.3707140386,
-0.4979496896,
0.3648486733,
0.5035028458,
-1.1577628851,
0.3085552454,
0.3571907282,
0.5622044802,
0.1983506829,
0.4111015201,
-0.0355280489,
0.0613550842,
-0.0752682611,
0.1913390309,
-0.1890206933,
-0.3182547092,
-0.5790690184,
0.3799533248,
0.3417215645,
-0.0207530353
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11442v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11442v3
|
Can LLMs Reason with Rules? Logic Scaffolding for Stress-Testing and Improving LLMs
| 2024-02-18T03:38:51 | 2024-06-21T02:36:55 |
Siyuan Wang, Zhongyu Wei, Yejin Choi, Xiang Ren
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved impressive human-like performance
across various reasoning tasks. However, their mastery of underlying
inferential rules still falls short of human capabilities. To investigate this,
we propose a logic scaffolding inferential rule generation framework, to
construct an inferential rule base, ULogic, comprising both primitive and
compositional rules across five domains. Our analysis of GPT-series models over
a rule subset reveals significant gaps in LLMs' logic understanding compared to
human performance, especially in compositional and structural complex rules
with certain bias patterns. We further distill these rules into a smaller-scale
inference engine for flexible rule generation and enhancing downstream
reasoning. Through a multi-judger evaluation, our inference engine proves
effective in generating accurate, complex and abstract conclusions and
premises, and improve various commonsense reasoning tasks. Overall, our work
sheds light on LLMs' limitations in grasping inferential rule and suggests ways
to enhance their logical reasoning abilities~\footnote{Code and data are
available at \url{https://github.com/SiyuanWangw/ULogic}.}.
|
[
-0.1151528135,
-0.6425596476,
0.9175878167,
0.0454881489,
-0.4199879467,
-0.1560818553,
-0.123534143,
-0.3709798157,
-0.3215455413,
0.7238112092,
-0.6480177641,
-0.2824026048,
-0.368858546,
0.1165077016,
-0.18838498,
0.9627308846,
0.1123810336,
-0.0529271401,
-0.6874569654,
0.0443136171,
-0.374856621,
-0.5192264318,
-0.2014454752,
-0.8215104342,
0.1008397713,
0.6734805703,
0.4631032646,
0.6361364722,
0.3640610576,
0.2512141168,
-0.1392715573,
0.5769284964,
-0.2218906432,
0.2858192623,
-0.2975592017,
-0.4753212035,
-0.4354448915,
-0.1202667058,
0.3797656,
0.6039761901,
-0.3468233943,
0.052280087,
0.1506065279,
0.5656639338,
-0.4154034853,
0.132238552,
-0.8364070058,
-0.2036794275,
-0.2708325386,
-0.1275669038,
-0.5255762339,
-0.2149370611,
-0.2208615988,
-0.4614911973,
-0.0283284094,
0.2058793902,
0.9778141379,
0.4960822463,
-0.6910405159,
-0.2029760778,
-0.4247321784,
0.5367717147,
-1.0259833336,
0.4430007339,
0.1873974353,
0.2952126265,
-0.4755291343,
-0.7674907446,
-0.3780965507,
-0.2930956781,
-0.1819167882,
-0.0271021482,
-0.142936945,
0.2528070509,
0.656606853,
0.1879852563,
-0.4468494654,
-0.0079175876,
-0.2452373505,
-0.0404860601,
0.7484782934,
0.2267531753,
0.1250337809,
-0.2036785483,
-0.3871484995,
0.1487013549,
-1.127649188,
0.0246893633,
0.2722187042,
0.3151539266,
0.2347596884,
0.6285614371,
-0.377617687,
0.5379779935,
0.1494028568,
-0.3860359192,
0.0684430301,
-0.0410351306,
-0.5748436451,
0.0221424736,
0.3770842254,
0.4890439212,
0.4015566111,
-0.1608024687,
-0.2281880975,
0.285074681,
0.1028497219,
-0.9562392831,
-0.1923110485,
0.0197411813,
-0.4009850919,
-0.0430707298,
-0.0103702024,
-0.6063655019,
-0.6185665131,
-0.4214959145,
0.1756929457,
-0.5074369311,
-0.1288218349,
0.4713642895,
-0.0456230305,
0.2772412598,
0.2797113955,
-0.7636996508,
0.5677751303,
0.5414758921,
0.4424887002,
0.0316804014,
-0.1377791315,
-0.608785212,
0.2318233252,
-0.1292521358,
1.0500842333,
-0.5053110123,
-0.2395591587,
-0.1232109219,
-0.3486085832,
-0.075394012,
-0.7260014415,
0.8294421434,
-0.3673238158,
-0.0475155488,
-0.2287220061,
-0.925840199,
-0.1674121171,
0.0649771988,
-0.3174066246,
1.0314793587,
-0.0064898939,
-0.54748559,
0.4267881215,
-0.6735277772,
-0.6098489761,
0.1678943634,
-0.3967970908,
-0.0589778237,
0.1754537821,
0.1153889969,
0.4677743614,
-0.6486825943,
0.3325395882,
-0.4995937645,
-0.2653483748,
0.2472895086,
-0.151069656,
0.7077339888,
0.2845665514,
-0.5511176586,
0.1932619214,
-0.6517450213,
0.17947945,
0.1029985249,
-0.4212729633,
-0.1080432907,
0.3814589381,
-0.1325575262,
0.4294242561,
-0.3238323033,
-0.3497824073,
0.3118561208,
-0.1144299358,
0.4594683349,
0.9805344343,
-0.0531166196,
0.2556414604,
-0.3952605128,
0.334584564,
-0.0071738209,
-0.0409514569,
-0.0443195254,
-0.4386293888,
-0.7796397209,
-0.4695944488,
0.048924882,
0.5545800328,
-0.4316925108,
0.3952259123,
-0.2364627868,
-0.2650702298,
-0.2068672031,
0.4230255783,
0.2916157544,
0.5380164981,
0.2559408247,
-0.1418844759,
-0.5822541118,
-0.6980708241,
-0.4214043617,
-0.1986878961,
-0.1885647923,
0.1392375082,
0.6300147176,
-0.222460717,
0.8424307108,
-0.3830219507,
-0.1630892009,
-0.4338321984,
-0.1575738788,
0.3199379742,
0.2176547199,
0.3884427547,
-0.4750879407,
-0.050492093,
-0.1579587162,
-0.8666645288,
-0.4274421632,
-0.0409885943,
-0.1894476563,
0.1470840126,
0.8925275207,
-0.8113506436,
0.3851853907,
0.1335069835,
-0.7666828036,
0.7180984616,
-0.0263596568,
-0.2365170121,
-0.643129766,
-0.3244074881,
-0.0697689131,
-0.380974859,
-0.472728461,
0.0819107741,
-0.1157623455,
0.2118264288,
-0.2504986227,
0.5008959174,
-0.3440492451,
0.0648562685,
-0.3121983111,
0.128689602,
0.0694668517,
0.4359294176,
-0.1798496246,
0.3478849828,
0.5644263625,
-0.6569094062,
0.3665917516,
-0.0470829383,
-0.5105722547,
0.8170264363,
-0.7572741508,
0.0338431485,
-0.0397082642,
0.475653708,
-0.9053204656,
-0.5134555697,
0.1672986299,
0.0628702566,
0.0545841195,
-0.2706446648,
-0.8680510521,
-0.2394292802,
-0.0138888704,
0.22075665,
0.7203562856,
-0.6029729843,
0.902802825,
0.1539200246,
0.1010508463,
-0.2156641483,
-0.5960920453,
-0.0348512568,
-0.5224987268,
-0.7873348594,
0.1506356299,
-0.271572113,
-0.8362716436,
0.0862825662,
-0.3224667311,
-0.0070203044,
0.2205117047,
0.5593219399,
0.09795212,
-0.2164854407,
0.2503575385,
0.0356722288,
0.2421304733,
0.305213362,
-0.5261654854,
0.2873916924,
-0.5164301991,
-0.643496871,
-0.1301516294,
0.3160710931,
0.5985119939,
-0.1194080338,
0.0813932195,
0.0147389276,
-0.4567143619,
-0.6249341965,
-0.59809798,
-0.3811426461,
-0.4900396466,
-0.0787004754,
-0.6031751633,
-0.8804191947,
0.3105519116,
-0.360093236,
-0.0328915678,
0.526435554,
0.5200327635,
-0.1743107587,
0.8243021369,
0.5150692463,
0.2820983827,
0.0052928231,
0.0827578232,
0.0940065756,
-0.5966528654,
-0.1321086287,
-0.1292347312,
-0.0749789253,
-0.4529530108,
-0.2757720351,
0.3005367517,
0.2116892636,
-0.40323475,
-0.103860952,
-0.2253346592,
0.8038699031,
0.499976486,
0.2225530297,
0.4078739285,
-0.096059911,
-0.5947527885,
0.1900682747,
-0.5920628905,
-0.5648348331,
0.8307750821,
0.1268376708,
0.8279476762,
0.1937840432,
0.5121757388,
0.4237160683,
0.4328253567,
-0.6288980842,
0.7155916095,
-0.0091377804,
-0.8305763602,
-0.1739885658,
-0.4634622335,
-0.5790129304,
0.5012705922,
-0.1388539672,
-0.8022503853,
-0.0648311749,
0.1842120588,
-0.3431254625,
0.5216985345,
-0.5615434051,
0.7537679076,
-0.4716431797,
-0.3385786712,
-0.1699403077,
-0.5954813361,
0.6551510096,
0.1716688573,
0.1959200352,
-0.4944847524,
0.3079086542,
0.4492061734,
-0.5893995166,
1.127743721,
-0.080537878,
-0.1598605812,
0.4480386078,
0.2289660424,
0.4628139734,
0.0869486853,
-0.1546653658,
-0.2485332787,
-0.2044936121,
-0.5658183694,
-0.6866653562,
0.4234785438,
-0.3831677735,
-0.7636471391,
-0.3914445937,
-0.627635181,
-0.3814722598,
0.2605765462,
0.1490661055,
0.2304944694,
0.0690926313,
0.112738438,
0.7011051178,
0.504782021,
0.2616296113,
0.2582222819,
-0.0550640076,
-0.1751688421,
0.4784936011,
-0.047573816,
0.1462866813,
-0.0588096529,
0.2738636732,
-0.3485504687,
-0.5942405462,
-0.432331413,
0.3003832996,
-1.036692977,
-0.26352337,
-0.1108499989,
-0.0632853135,
-0.3473532796,
-0.1162805408,
0.0201159064,
-0.371009618,
0.0474148616,
-0.255623728,
0.512183249,
0.9449468851,
0.0206277706,
0.196902886,
-0.4616749585,
0.1083617732,
0.5061169267,
0.356998235,
-0.1676747352,
-0.6389198303,
0.0041969023,
-0.199537769,
-0.2937121093,
-0.7311435342,
-0.1760059744,
0.252379477,
0.7327301502,
0.6800334454,
0.1007269621,
0.6163278818,
-0.565793395,
0.4977255464,
0.057864707,
-1.0699107647,
0.4674333334,
-0.529961288,
-0.027621042,
0.4915673435,
-0.0231074952,
-0.4552145302,
-0.2528122962,
-0.8229932785,
-0.8956633806,
0.3797744811,
0.1636192203,
-0.1595500857,
0.1375210285,
0.6268097758,
0.0217058901,
0.1583765298,
-0.7054108381,
0.0731248781,
-0.1625683159,
-0.1927814782,
0.1112071276,
-0.126164034,
-0.3385109305,
-0.3138387203,
0.6357444525,
-0.4892710149,
-0.0168398153,
0.2087601572,
-0.2591741085,
-0.0076499125,
0.3497703969,
0.5913456678,
0.7013968229,
-0.2599156499,
0.4244169295,
0.4585370719,
-0.0131190568,
0.2416279167,
0.3150793314,
-0.1468494534,
-0.3803789914,
0.5192094445,
0.6611180902,
0.0324204415,
-0.9853955507,
0.2895358205,
0.1002257392,
-0.5035658479,
-0.1820718497,
0.2935580313,
0.1734919995,
0.5486354232,
0.2340992838,
-0.1014030203,
0.0281994268,
-0.5464888811,
0.4847920239,
0.2804426849,
-0.1646397859,
-0.1815759391,
0.7434267402,
0.1972949803,
0.1867354512,
0.535297215,
-0.2930072248,
-0.5618296862,
0.4116745889,
0.7324383259,
0.7393641472,
0.0496757589,
0.0478389077,
-0.2028127015,
0.4267117977,
-0.2117021084,
0.3891628683,
-0.151050359,
-0.7658026814,
-0.471826762,
-0.3627871871,
-0.5575169325,
0.0536129959,
-0.3006281853,
-0.0046668118,
-0.6142879725,
0.0979299173,
-0.1656010598,
-0.0519956164,
-0.5405071974,
0.4085248113,
0.3505041897,
1.0085145235,
-0.8946669102,
0.7222802043,
0.8460515141,
-0.4088203907,
-0.7117538452,
0.0299511962,
0.3088195324,
-0.6534025669,
0.6956067681,
0.2695059478,
-0.5213285685,
-0.4138698876,
-0.7573741078,
-0.5785541534,
1.0078136921,
0.6162433624,
-0.1924973726,
-0.0173195265,
0.1633862108,
0.421784997,
-0.6672400236,
0.3062890172,
0.8217037916,
0.6178398728,
0.152266711,
-0.5107815862,
0.5044869184,
-0.4641580582,
-0.3413476944,
0.0214600265,
-0.7516638637,
0.7420558929,
-0.4886905551,
-0.1696432382,
-0.0929861814,
0.7477083206,
0.5504600406,
0.4049609601,
0.8549594283,
0.7957193851,
1.1541771889,
-0.143025279,
1.0641725063,
-0.0002302882,
-0.032495141,
1.3004318476,
-0.6548752785,
0.6313400269,
0.4336361885,
0.1028669477,
0.9056894779,
0.789860487,
0.0185090341,
0.2093200982,
0.6850930452,
-0.3037215769,
-0.7839871049,
-0.3532193601,
0.0111808404,
0.4969922304,
0.4155362844,
-0.1383850873,
-0.2345002443,
-0.3591739535,
0.3408440351,
0.0586845316,
-0.2360366434,
0.470906198,
0.1712729186,
-0.5495218635,
0.5868852139,
-0.0937303305,
0.3998414278,
-0.5232685804,
-0.0341838151,
-0.3152361512,
0.5172480345,
-0.2958402932,
-0.7657704353,
-0.0397233032,
0.0401254408,
-0.0605256706,
-0.2188242227,
0.9638234377,
-0.183777526,
-0.4303747118,
0.3948521614,
0.6923210621,
0.1896337718,
-0.1143236831,
-0.3579958379,
-0.3135985732,
-0.1005885825,
-0.3609649539,
0.135283649,
0.7648758292,
-0.4444702864,
0.7901649475,
0.7016986012,
0.0273254421,
-0.0482538119,
0.1813067198,
1.0214642286,
-0.6985356212,
-0.2186600864,
-1.0633673668,
0.6568585634,
-0.1695121825,
-0.3864792287,
0.6447522044,
0.444658637,
0.6874548197,
0.1135981455,
0.9481338859,
0.0384108908,
0.1256616265,
-0.7318425179,
0.3427649438,
-0.6888503432,
0.1152102724,
-0.0779904872,
-0.5675246716,
-0.5937868953,
0.3689478338,
0.0000198425,
-0.0275221691,
0.7609210014,
0.6575918794,
-0.1758254468,
0.0574286245,
0.3293889165,
0.2691971958,
0.4536296427,
0.6314898133,
0.9992672205,
-0.0426799618,
0.7037676573,
0.0226011798,
-0.2579014599,
-0.3109732866,
-1.1437935829,
-1.1124721766,
-0.2645602822,
-0.0244913399,
-0.4285211265,
0.0376259983,
1.0422788858,
0.7410059571,
-0.552924037,
-0.4774492383,
-0.1726437211,
0.3656507432,
-0.3387944698,
-0.1894286722,
0.226762414,
-0.4873515964,
-0.192844227,
0.628198266,
0.1671470255,
-0.0166450404,
0.2430538833,
-0.254498601,
-0.0967306718,
0.5588927865,
0.677696228,
0.1862561107,
-0.7630714774,
-0.3856548369,
0.0029916475,
0.0778915063,
-0.0402684547,
1.0848125219,
-0.595063746,
0.0899683312,
0.4070909023,
0.5383122563,
0.32984972,
-0.0114521114,
0.3250662088,
-0.5642501712,
-0.0618692152,
0.034284506,
0.8149235845,
0.2268238068,
-0.2272073776,
0.7278777957,
0.4629929066,
-0.6712211967,
-0.8286240101,
0.6209314466,
-0.8457130194,
-0.3404882848,
1.3796750307,
-0.0212196354,
-0.1385638118,
-0.0123583367,
-0.1670253426,
0.0442906767,
-0.4068494737,
0.687287569,
0.7323904037,
-0.6863731742,
-0.043307554,
-0.4618139267,
0.71194911,
0.4890068471,
-1.1917475462,
0.3856651783,
0.6451376081,
0.3640937805,
-0.0749969631,
0.5280340314,
0.0976889208,
0.2430038899,
-0.1337848157,
-0.0092691574,
0.0015430306,
-0.4073430598,
-0.0788666829,
0.0104439743,
0.1359325945,
0.2286297977
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11441v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11441v1
|
InfuserKI: Enhancing Large Language Models with Knowledge Graphs via Infuser-Guided Knowledge Integration
| 2024-02-18T03:36:26 | 2024-02-18T03:36:26 |
Fali Wang, Runxue Bao, Suhang Wang, Wenchao Yu, Yanchi Liu, Wei Cheng, Haifeng Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Though Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown remarkable open-generation
capabilities across diverse domains, they struggle with knowledge-intensive
tasks. To alleviate this issue, knowledge integration methods have been
proposed to enhance LLMs with domain-specific knowledge graphs using external
modules. However, they suffer from data inefficiency as they require both known
and unknown knowledge for fine-tuning. Thus, we study a novel problem of
integrating unknown knowledge into LLMs efficiently without unnecessary overlap
of known knowledge. Injecting new knowledge poses the risk of forgetting
previously acquired knowledge. To tackle this, we propose a novel
Infuser-Guided Knowledge Integration (InfuserKI) framework that utilizes
transformer internal states to determine whether to enhance the original LLM
output with additional information, thereby effectively mitigating knowledge
forgetting. Evaluations on the UMLS-2.5k and MetaQA domain knowledge graphs
demonstrate that InfuserKI can effectively acquire new knowledge and outperform
state-of-the-art baselines by 9% and 6%, respectively, in reducing knowledge
forgetting.
|
[
-0.2449037582,
-0.5283884406,
0.6703220606,
-0.1557962596,
-0.061847087,
0.4526052177,
-0.1826301217,
-0.1891566217,
-0.0635169297,
0.674870193,
-0.3181471229,
-0.233257845,
-0.5808129907,
-0.3180242777,
-0.3624515831,
0.8533785939,
-0.3112816513,
0.142727226,
-0.7079662085,
0.1613668352,
-0.4667647481,
-0.2248812169,
-0.5544989109,
-0.9002348185,
0.0165671352,
0.7638490796,
0.5025122166,
-0.0736414567,
0.3185870945,
0.233858943,
-0.1241548955,
0.7437929511,
-0.7805547118,
-0.0378719121,
-0.1876776814,
-0.5267184973,
-0.1735917628,
-0.4431546032,
0.9995807409,
0.7963940501,
-0.062555559,
0.0812870562,
0.4634741545,
0.7250471711,
-0.7135950923,
0.2212520391,
-0.6718893051,
-0.0020843251,
-0.3106388152,
-0.1100252047,
-0.5379222035,
-0.3402578533,
0.1458144337,
-0.5172663331,
-0.2425380945,
-0.0317366607,
0.6530519128,
0.2848884165,
-0.3423430026,
-0.1922424138,
-0.9028804302,
0.542560637,
-0.8644507527,
0.6014745235,
0.3757085204,
0.3527712226,
-0.6081895828,
-0.6737080812,
-0.8576694727,
0.0012123432,
-0.2736305594,
0.0709364116,
-0.2464926541,
-0.1047124639,
0.1759184003,
0.3046619594,
-0.3507631719,
0.0972357616,
-0.0452965684,
-0.0224780217,
0.2031924576,
0.1937116683,
0.2807063162,
0.0310578719,
-0.2367161363,
0.2097185105,
-0.9671850204,
-0.0073388224,
0.3913089037,
0.1147631481,
0.0150322979,
0.5598286986,
-0.2260309756,
0.6919223666,
-0.0097185532,
-0.3058134615,
0.1338756531,
-0.198415041,
-0.1463091075,
-0.0040099546,
0.6417901516,
-0.0140303867,
0.301720202,
-0.4966054559,
0.0533034801,
-0.4300551116,
0.01878318,
-0.89731884,
-0.330537647,
0.1174272299,
-0.129777655,
-0.0931639448,
0.0891390219,
-0.7317845821,
-0.5809270144,
0.0130049074,
0.5360239148,
-0.7605490088,
-0.4049847424,
0.0052781673,
-0.3610641956,
0.1770009547,
0.1561435908,
-0.7589353919,
0.438080281,
0.546092093,
0.6917182803,
-0.1377713829,
-0.3306183815,
-0.2152867913,
0.667835772,
-0.1882123649,
0.7354468107,
-0.5594448447,
-0.3526775539,
0.1162075773,
-0.1126916409,
0.0703395531,
-0.5459065437,
0.1247841418,
-0.780706346,
0.0742774233,
-0.1089469716,
-1.0774204731,
-0.2703188956,
0.187092036,
-0.4747809768,
1.1265531778,
0.5444898605,
-0.6480306983,
0.3891434371,
-0.7492583394,
-0.4462585151,
0.3159436584,
0.0840887576,
-0.3117469549,
-0.0275599379,
0.1994130015,
0.2719577253,
-0.4754951,
0.2553878427,
-0.3668973744,
-0.3440175056,
0.5001462698,
-0.2695030868,
0.6190481186,
-0.0315368995,
0.03937383,
0.0239323247,
-0.6688298583,
0.0449739546,
0.1297015846,
-0.2435730845,
-0.5203786492,
-0.1513397992,
-0.354082495,
0.0013353246,
0.3021181226,
-0.6498186588,
0.2862609923,
-0.5717787743,
0.43155092,
0.6581232548,
0.393066287,
0.8363727927,
-0.1665006429,
0.2411497682,
0.2614760995,
0.3202782273,
-0.142024219,
-0.6108141541,
-1.0138652325,
-0.0609752387,
0.1656684875,
0.2940727472,
-1.1231434345,
0.3488896787,
-0.4307063818,
-0.6567006111,
-0.4109107554,
0.3389284909,
0.1952085197,
0.7697135806,
0.3963309526,
-0.0555512793,
-0.2163717449,
-0.6822063327,
-0.3260388672,
0.031546399,
0.0420327708,
0.1178797185,
0.5199936032,
-0.3774136901,
1.1144226789,
-0.7682282925,
-0.4374184012,
-0.312155962,
-0.3592739701,
0.4024407864,
0.3906894922,
0.126047045,
-0.516430974,
-0.731536448,
0.3636228442,
-0.7111541629,
0.2142679095,
0.115795292,
-0.3444302082,
0.0590758696,
0.484854877,
-0.6565850973,
0.2275400609,
0.4645117223,
-0.3358005583,
0.2189182639,
-0.3086388111,
-0.1090285778,
-1.1719560623,
-0.1010112837,
-0.3223863244,
-0.1576141566,
-0.8449566364,
-0.0764208138,
0.5814107656,
-0.1329419464,
-0.3501811326,
0.8283513784,
-0.3631284833,
0.4260540605,
-0.2758187354,
0.2069103867,
-0.0134056564,
0.5975244045,
-0.4322549701,
0.5025524497,
0.5439418554,
-0.6090634465,
0.2631467879,
0.3117432594,
-0.5123788118,
0.5242128372,
-0.0862316638,
0.2738103867,
-0.239749223,
0.1209540963,
-0.8823984265,
-0.3139855266,
0.4033748209,
-0.1747833341,
0.7009907961,
-0.2933958471,
-0.8072675467,
-0.3453767002,
-0.0037286156,
0.4488911629,
0.5491674542,
-0.8378000855,
0.9598817229,
0.5628382564,
0.2328757942,
-0.569178164,
-0.6568956971,
-0.0000630064,
-0.2330101132,
-0.5549376607,
0.3867600262,
0.0130650736,
-0.0981914401,
0.3707885742,
0.0589572191,
-0.1153362617,
-0.2932774127,
0.1250311881,
0.1251550168,
0.1121033579,
0.4796800911,
0.3762408197,
-0.1041997969,
-0.1681284457,
-0.8604443669,
0.553391993,
0.1563874185,
-0.6198086143,
-0.3167078495,
0.3872874081,
0.6022757888,
-0.2039792538,
0.9818503261,
0.2545305192,
-0.5687825084,
-0.5531947017,
-0.6511086226,
-0.1572922617,
-0.4852022231,
0.3613291979,
-0.3589133918,
-0.924010694,
0.3969060779,
-0.4941738844,
-0.0961415842,
0.3760543168,
0.3660078347,
-0.3006181419,
0.7060959339,
0.8209609389,
-0.2434582561,
0.5034378767,
-0.4410477877,
0.5005847812,
-0.9420804381,
-0.3080944121,
-0.0961253271,
-0.2420264184,
-0.2473579496,
-0.4434509873,
0.5014052391,
0.0625213608,
-0.2694019377,
0.2216852456,
-0.2427649647,
0.6310938597,
0.3748318255,
0.2709610462,
0.5025176406,
-0.1747085005,
-0.0309522673,
0.1655162722,
-1.1061623096,
-0.0846018121,
1.2216361761,
0.3026397526,
0.8385229111,
0.1801385134,
0.5896270871,
-0.0234546717,
0.4719070196,
-0.6913762689,
0.2720006704,
-0.1587147117,
-0.223873347,
-0.5128538609,
-0.4758078158,
-0.6256668568,
0.0380348153,
-0.0979364663,
-0.5931228399,
0.0413387306,
0.3011610806,
-0.2712753713,
0.6319687366,
-0.7692035437,
0.6473047733,
-0.0797783732,
0.0450222455,
-0.1746536344,
-0.2363848388,
0.4719730318,
-0.3931159377,
0.3221110702,
0.0696179643,
0.114754416,
0.5791606903,
-0.4117455781,
0.9444591403,
-0.2501290739,
-0.0876428857,
0.3430996239,
-0.0215802975,
0.9067419767,
0.0398277305,
0.0735238716,
0.2623594999,
-0.305606544,
-0.2073717564,
-1.0370498896,
0.7465419769,
-0.5908509493,
-0.4046109915,
0.0800407603,
-0.7568923831,
-0.5085056424,
0.2955259681,
0.2938520908,
0.3958261907,
-0.182568863,
0.0196020342,
1.0211342573,
-0.0869015083,
0.1901034117,
0.5311376452,
-0.2797760963,
-0.5868638754,
1.1534758806,
0.351870805,
0.4995612502,
0.6385080218,
0.3068521321,
-0.0842723623,
-0.4736131132,
-0.4685898721,
0.445712626,
-0.9287580252,
-0.5740887523,
-0.6061492562,
-0.3318320215,
-0.3081526756,
0.0929638371,
-0.2207556516,
-0.3066954613,
-0.1985045224,
0.0562986247,
0.5201339722,
0.9271036983,
0.4869849682,
0.4548758268,
-0.6918118596,
0.0311592408,
0.3100003004,
0.6551848054,
0.1923339516,
-0.6658558846,
-0.6838070154,
-0.1229164749,
-0.3089940846,
-0.991445601,
0.1054409444,
0.2095509619,
0.768204391,
0.5489758849,
-0.1073036641,
0.7665863633,
-0.4853504002,
0.4922552109,
0.1426321715,
-0.9608883858,
0.3466589451,
0.0107867289,
0.6315039396,
0.2466263324,
0.2976917028,
-0.6162254214,
-0.7034803033,
-0.5864353776,
-0.7388678789,
0.4410602748,
-0.0341705941,
0.1197261736,
0.2476641834,
0.419870019,
0.1253190041,
0.045837529,
-0.3881034553,
-0.2715962231,
0.0482952371,
-0.2249358147,
0.0067125638,
-0.3944904506,
-0.1036098525,
-0.3816407025,
0.8858059049,
-0.2585426569,
0.1119535416,
-0.1457691342,
-0.4497370124,
-0.2188270092,
0.0087132268,
0.200389877,
0.4442685246,
0.234001413,
0.208915621,
0.7330163717,
-0.3808574677,
-0.0300949905,
-0.1526678056,
-0.3585930169,
-0.2100248337,
0.2659826279,
0.6897572875,
0.5575242043,
-0.4679250419,
0.3043870628,
0.0914626047,
0.0241434798,
-0.4134525359,
0.0832105801,
0.4031295478,
0.4080616534,
0.2269198298,
0.106983237,
-0.0781484246,
-0.3015629053,
0.1375420392,
0.6146537662,
-0.5099808574,
0.0520152561,
0.2288070768,
-0.0532562807,
-0.2646305561,
0.7054245472,
-0.119491607,
-0.4539220333,
0.0429244824,
0.803450346,
0.7932288647,
-0.33035478,
-0.1207529679,
0.3383172452,
0.3084894419,
-0.0011930376,
0.1245162115,
-0.0132562155,
-1.0294167995,
-0.3383399546,
-0.5170894861,
-0.39691782,
-0.0370357558,
-0.1451653242,
0.3969753981,
-0.1043766439,
-0.0439750068,
-0.4786693752,
-0.3031135201,
-0.6568594575,
-0.1811428368,
-0.2069094032,
1.0279272795,
-0.6858058572,
1.2083685398,
0.222178638,
-0.4006890357,
-0.7592259645,
0.1071419641,
-0.2302801013,
-0.6195577383,
0.3277194202,
-0.2262118459,
-0.1501231194,
0.2028048187,
-0.3664353192,
-1.1731636524,
1.1752929688,
0.5611413717,
-0.1360599697,
0.0659733787,
0.4063681066,
0.2424243689,
-0.2799468637,
0.1728202105,
0.8016288877,
0.6068841815,
0.1814029664,
-0.6787739992,
-0.0112347594,
-0.2195916027,
-0.0601489507,
0.7486667037,
-0.5022267699,
0.5815309882,
-0.2125694603,
-0.2321322411,
-0.2389241904,
0.8122618198,
-0.1967531145,
-0.1214929447,
0.4049948752,
0.6559477448,
1.0283489227,
0.0357698239,
0.7943717837,
-0.2318090945,
0.1683932096,
1.1556822062,
0.0654050559,
0.7065856457,
0.6249851584,
-0.1272279918,
0.7008205056,
0.0683668703,
0.0351230428,
0.4439094663,
0.0673165917,
-0.4276473522,
-0.0787476078,
-0.0264397822,
-0.1715560704,
0.2766345441,
0.5223780274,
-0.1868075728,
-0.119864583,
0.1175275221,
0.1623720825,
-0.1019860134,
-0.0557099991,
0.9380882382,
0.1603523791,
-0.6638336778,
0.4264701605,
-0.3039525747,
0.4286223948,
-1.0203824043,
-0.2287876606,
-0.1866388321,
0.381395191,
-0.3205688298,
-0.9650769234,
0.2188309878,
-0.1533117741,
-0.2462577373,
-0.2046349198,
0.8591508865,
-0.8377524018,
-0.446233511,
0.3338020146,
0.4226098359,
-0.1107799485,
-0.1621227562,
-0.1018007994,
-0.2467137128,
-0.061607495,
0.0130672893,
0.4497458935,
0.500156045,
-0.017066054,
0.858992517,
0.5557923913,
0.0203196481,
-0.0236019902,
0.1485734433,
1.0580773354,
-0.2656532526,
-0.4009225667,
-0.9201892614,
0.6306139231,
-0.3168147504,
-0.2149560452,
0.9600545168,
0.5485938191,
0.9921856523,
-0.0584638752,
0.8124126196,
0.1633048207,
0.3005254865,
-0.5519922972,
1.1707633734,
-0.5193698406,
0.0126645118,
-0.2818771303,
-0.7089467049,
-0.3356721699,
0.0462460294,
-0.1206911355,
-0.2236614674,
0.7643205523,
0.8489738703,
0.0449582599,
-0.0827999488,
0.4295763373,
0.1722643822,
0.491089195,
0.6936711669,
0.8789997101,
-0.3121119142,
0.5889680386,
-0.4243553579,
-0.497831583,
0.0055050771,
-0.7172794342,
-0.8787296414,
-0.7666320205,
-0.0739529431,
-0.1995728314,
-0.3447625637,
0.6891994476,
0.4624198377,
-0.7260833383,
-0.3640686274,
0.0855416209,
0.4492825866,
-0.3491952121,
-0.1661184132,
0.2497277558,
-0.5039784312,
-0.6168990731,
0.5950744152,
0.4117124379,
-0.0074969763,
-0.399001509,
-0.1889385134,
0.0625976473,
0.0122176595,
0.5860252976,
0.0778604075,
-0.5169856548,
-0.2121613473,
-0.1344150752,
0.2573009133,
-0.0126319593,
1.0082776546,
-0.8349726796,
0.6579529643,
0.4423999786,
0.5425933599,
0.6945486665,
-0.5012028813,
0.6324941516,
-0.6167818904,
-0.0609955415,
0.1181165278,
0.5859177113,
0.3621756434,
-0.481855005,
0.1986977905,
0.140346095,
-0.4435494542,
-0.757240057,
0.4334463775,
-0.4805859923,
-0.304083854,
1.0251233578,
0.0412123092,
-0.0587309189,
-0.3117504716,
-0.0590795092,
0.4677559137,
-0.1958464682,
0.5681728721,
0.6320649981,
-0.1712579727,
-0.0623832494,
-0.2813457549,
0.7065582275,
-0.0324710608,
-0.8835268021,
0.0489229746,
-0.0088889254,
0.2458385974,
0.0492556877,
0.4894934297,
-0.1087029874,
-0.1468607187,
-0.0757016465,
0.0393422656,
-0.2237912118,
-0.3949581683,
-0.1767702252,
0.2719067037,
0.1729667336,
0.166751489
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11436v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11436v2
|
Pride and Prejudice: LLM Amplifies Self-Bias in Self-Refinement
| 2024-02-18T03:10:39 | 2024-06-18T04:41:07 |
Wenda Xu, Guanglei Zhu, Xuandong Zhao, Liangming Pan, Lei Li, William Yang Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent studies show that large language models (LLMs) improve their
performance through self-feedback on certain tasks while degrade on others. We
discovered that such a contrary is due to LLM's bias in evaluating their own
output. In this paper, we formally define LLM's self-bias - the tendency to
favor its own generation - using two statistics. We analyze six LLMs (GPT-4,
GPT-3.5, Gemini, LLaMA2, Mixtral and DeepSeek) on translation, constrained text
generation, and mathematical reasoning tasks. We find that self-bias is
prevalent in all examined LLMs across multiple languages and tasks. Our
analysis reveals that while the self-refine pipeline improves the fluency and
understandability of model outputs, it further amplifies self-bias. To mitigate
such biases, we discover that larger model size and external feedback with
accurate assessment can significantly reduce bias in the self-refine pipeline,
leading to actual performance improvement in downstream tasks. The code and
data are released at https://github.com/xu1998hz/llm_self_bias.
|
[
-0.353212148,
-0.3879384696,
0.6017043591,
0.4760609865,
0.0264694504,
-0.1854050457,
-0.0713706017,
-0.1677165627,
0.253793925,
0.636451602,
-0.6579419971,
-0.0715712681,
-0.5391587615,
0.3105922341,
-0.3652046025,
1.2187507153,
0.0293023642,
0.5956373811,
-0.3676002324,
0.0391583405,
-0.5881556273,
-0.6622779965,
-0.0309458692,
-0.55386585,
0.5903708339,
0.270370543,
0.4909870625,
0.7047451735,
0.3881154358,
0.2768783271,
0.1976069808,
-0.0712711513,
-0.7662782073,
0.843239069,
-0.5834105611,
-0.3072888255,
-0.2306790501,
0.0685891584,
0.5165797472,
0.1026266664,
0.3845136762,
0.3540151715,
0.5263029933,
0.9150804877,
-0.6481902003,
0.0899920538,
-0.5301896334,
-0.1259094477,
-0.3692444265,
0.2084507793,
-0.1474812478,
-0.0722215101,
-0.1612611711,
-0.1267042756,
0.6295115948,
-0.17895028,
0.6081745625,
0.5550406575,
-0.4583181739,
-0.4691165686,
-0.5928310752,
0.9299704432,
-0.4892542362,
0.1945676804,
0.0570305474,
-0.0586069338,
-0.1093326882,
-0.4657054245,
-0.4206849933,
-0.1367552429,
-0.0604892932,
0.2934954464,
0.1661467999,
0.0720585883,
0.304128468,
0.7203267813,
-0.4417473972,
0.1958390772,
-0.3598200679,
-0.134073928,
0.8568304777,
0.1069338173,
-0.0203525312,
-0.4845057428,
-0.2846227884,
0.0304960739,
-0.8337869644,
-0.3910024166,
0.4763359725,
0.116924122,
0.3358671665,
0.7518331409,
-0.1265060902,
0.1400917768,
0.3248796463,
0.0343533754,
0.0746661946,
-0.2582346797,
-0.2447441816,
-0.0714286789,
0.7771648765,
0.1327075958,
0.5278971195,
0.1071924493,
-0.2986114621,
0.1579815447,
0.3451987207,
-0.7269275188,
-0.2627880871,
0.0938697606,
-0.3276910484,
-0.0754187852,
-0.3638680577,
-0.6400003433,
-0.6512511373,
-0.1302148253,
0.4749813676,
-0.0114027904,
0.1044972688,
-0.1593034565,
-0.1211107671,
0.0558449812,
0.2813879848,
-1.0114389658,
-0.2692904174,
0.6046640277,
0.486138612,
-0.4834991395,
-0.2798464298,
-0.2702892423,
0.1886291057,
-0.3541989625,
0.716835022,
-0.084985204,
-0.5888873935,
-0.0369457863,
-0.2585722208,
0.0661114603,
-0.553838551,
0.7787821889,
-0.111684218,
0.3266927004,
-0.6141787767,
-0.4028488398,
0.1822022796,
0.0910839513,
-0.6281235218,
1.0451478958,
-0.2233996838,
-0.7935276031,
0.4396028817,
-0.2547903955,
-0.4533144236,
-0.2913009226,
-0.6424079537,
-0.41329512,
0.4126335979,
0.3966183662,
0.4924695492,
-0.5430443883,
0.2802967429,
-0.5618199706,
-0.2486910075,
0.1957036257,
-0.4644098282,
0.4336730838,
0.4785507917,
-0.5747756958,
-0.0724998713,
-0.4350931048,
-0.2641946673,
0.2282648087,
-0.2406984568,
-0.242585972,
-0.0667533129,
-0.5883305669,
0.4337357283,
0.4832222164,
-0.4462769926,
0.2027273625,
-0.2939513624,
0.1129503846,
1.0710219145,
-0.1654100567,
0.4447671771,
-0.4402042329,
0.4456893206,
-0.126603201,
0.0873532817,
-0.183461085,
-0.3704701662,
-1.1137526035,
-0.1987064183,
0.0939156562,
0.0676942319,
-0.405572772,
-0.0841270462,
-0.0881940052,
-0.2995117605,
-0.6151829958,
0.5239600539,
0.5662637949,
0.4103843272,
0.281781733,
-0.4968886077,
-0.5135878921,
-1.2433637381,
-0.7434352636,
-0.2978768349,
-0.0233707614,
0.2451043278,
0.3373690546,
-0.2655231655,
1.0210313797,
-0.2929728627,
-0.5573159456,
-0.2707751691,
0.1624858975,
0.2682772577,
0.4314254522,
0.2745391428,
-0.1118399128,
-0.4180977046,
-0.5319735408,
-0.7831610441,
-0.7028775215,
-0.1585937142,
-0.2296054363,
0.2043125033,
0.2935421467,
-0.4240809977,
0.2772751749,
0.5828528404,
-0.4096831977,
0.8518633246,
0.0903865024,
-0.0508192629,
-0.672563374,
-0.4893949628,
0.1341926903,
-0.0644222647,
-0.2154341042,
0.1110005304,
0.0455832705,
0.3290877938,
-0.0643545762,
0.6286389828,
-0.6596845984,
-0.165364325,
-0.4117197096,
0.32250911,
0.2744109333,
0.219362691,
-0.1942810118,
0.9325606227,
0.4088804722,
-0.5238901973,
0.0497234054,
0.0912152678,
-0.0454676151,
0.3849084377,
-0.3943012655,
0.1439319104,
-0.1144505665,
0.0279142205,
-1.2343862057,
-0.0523347594,
0.0117576877,
-0.4277724326,
0.3022847474,
-0.1348194331,
-0.2748465538,
-0.4705218375,
-0.30329144,
0.2037427276,
0.4944059849,
-0.8286132812,
0.6312628388,
0.2946173549,
-0.2273797542,
-0.808334589,
-1.1002156734,
-0.2171016783,
-0.19337897,
-0.647208333,
0.2307084352,
-0.172480315,
-0.5228698254,
-0.4451210201,
-0.4019030035,
0.1514283419,
-0.2713051438,
0.4073436856,
0.030833371,
0.0575773306,
0.3333666325,
0.003246347,
0.1915089041,
0.4996224642,
-0.118972443,
0.4090944827,
0.1366869956,
-0.4214997292,
0.0142850345,
0.106901966,
0.35357669,
0.0845854729,
0.2565350235,
0.3521247804,
0.3432977796,
-0.4530380368,
-1.0051169395,
-0.4815233052,
-0.485740602,
0.2828825712,
-0.633472085,
-1.0955021381,
0.3727137744,
0.102879189,
0.0497062318,
0.8538475633,
0.8654342294,
-0.1277125776,
1.0452263355,
0.488771975,
-0.1675453633,
0.3118460774,
-0.1107295975,
0.0997992679,
-0.8448661566,
0.0880337954,
-0.598387897,
-0.3210956752,
-0.7672528028,
-0.4338710308,
0.0631348267,
-0.0640348047,
-0.3044185638,
-0.0988147259,
-0.5950159431,
0.384310931,
0.7172429562,
-0.2828429341,
0.3512123823,
-0.1075551212,
-0.5129292011,
-0.5368723273,
-0.738638401,
-0.4713492692,
1.2881865501,
0.5617434978,
1.2951390743,
0.0484906062,
0.9005123377,
0.4348204434,
0.4461883307,
-0.3322374523,
0.4564984739,
-0.1422583163,
-1.0690217018,
-0.0967296436,
-0.4719651341,
-0.7536807656,
0.3940432072,
0.1119507998,
-0.3400631249,
0.4296942949,
0.4162714183,
0.0336617008,
-0.0287828483,
-0.7326809764,
0.7819051147,
-0.5393336415,
-0.9813708663,
-0.4426546395,
-0.1324368864,
0.6883211732,
-0.1826597005,
0.162623316,
-0.2876360714,
0.2174340636,
0.5324106812,
-0.1551197618,
0.9862618446,
0.0316178054,
-0.4195378125,
0.28278023,
0.5203617215,
0.5993725657,
0.2627282739,
-0.180487588,
0.2436527312,
-0.3643605709,
-0.243559733,
-0.4418787956,
1.0405300856,
-0.8430945873,
-1.2197138071,
-0.6904623508,
-0.3859035075,
-0.1894129813,
-0.099129729,
0.3383635283,
0.018260356,
-0.178822726,
-0.0987703651,
0.3925602734,
-0.17196244,
0.4715428948,
0.5175043941,
-0.5762857199,
-0.3200407624,
0.5293903947,
0.2461920977,
0.325009197,
-0.0761775076,
0.1692460924,
-0.6101865172,
-0.3088383675,
-0.3134399056,
0.5643507242,
-0.9153875709,
-0.0946367756,
-0.5459170341,
-0.1164072827,
-0.863250196,
0.1038686112,
-0.5937678218,
-0.7113788128,
-0.2508479059,
-0.0806857273,
-0.0256905481,
1.1415714025,
-0.2528919578,
0.2700476944,
-0.2233897895,
0.1245213225,
0.7908166051,
0.1552816629,
-0.1378613561,
-0.9257984757,
-0.3015448153,
-0.3094523549,
-0.7836649418,
-0.8726217747,
0.4804061651,
-0.049549982,
0.4882442057,
0.4742790759,
0.049931597,
0.585693717,
-0.3017273247,
0.9238573909,
0.0529814176,
-0.971498251,
0.2810102999,
-0.1915644854,
0.5402235985,
0.3344166279,
0.1536515206,
-0.2676061094,
-0.6943996549,
-0.529663682,
-0.6486992836,
0.4798305631,
0.2655957639,
0.1791966408,
-0.2435736954,
0.2814825475,
0.1273423433,
0.2563129365,
-1.2730036974,
-0.330039829,
-0.2844720185,
0.0431319922,
-0.0730129257,
-0.7812669873,
-0.0376493558,
0.0237302985,
0.935115397,
-0.2157336324,
0.2919349372,
0.5881063938,
-0.2208049595,
-0.0785394087,
0.297293514,
0.2353811413,
0.6028068662,
0.1243941858,
0.2534606755,
0.2615439594,
-0.3109104335,
0.0969627425,
-0.0632868111,
-0.1815148145,
0.1628703177,
0.1814631224,
0.4727307558,
-0.3711046875,
-0.4013491571,
0.4100579917,
0.0087782741,
0.1227669194,
-0.3789632916,
0.2445027679,
-0.1998178512,
0.3524799645,
0.5139863491,
-0.2070693821,
0.3511611819,
-0.3990796804,
0.1126863137,
0.5835911632,
-0.3279933333,
-0.0764915571,
0.8201633096,
0.2441274524,
0.0842374861,
0.3123886883,
-0.1651297808,
-0.4454265237,
0.3205238283,
0.6510155797,
1.1268492937,
-0.5358433127,
0.06790445,
0.4600328207,
0.4803802967,
-0.0375496186,
0.1445752382,
-0.0082359053,
-0.7752866745,
-0.8017879725,
-0.7287860513,
-0.0786815882,
0.1482203752,
-0.2364343107,
0.2532708645,
-0.2880966961,
-0.3309769928,
-0.4885080159,
-0.0986609757,
-0.4856399596,
0.3335911334,
0.1569127887,
0.5449873805,
-0.5635554194,
0.815230906,
0.3480397463,
-0.3073918521,
-0.5386141539,
0.1777425408,
0.0925861299,
-0.9255780578,
0.89083606,
0.2071495652,
-0.0728409737,
-0.2261997759,
-0.2454079241,
-1.1016360521,
0.772230804,
0.5162442923,
-0.8893233538,
-0.0339173377,
0.3312819898,
0.537579298,
-0.4219520688,
0.4477015734,
0.5738390684,
0.39838323,
-0.1389433593,
-0.9521067142,
-0.0781822354,
-0.0159647651,
0.0713439435,
-0.0039588413,
-0.8416825533,
0.856636405,
-0.2276686132,
-0.0664445013,
-0.104165785,
0.8252370358,
0.3826928437,
0.0789362192,
0.2748142481,
0.5473657846,
0.4210068882,
-0.2127060294,
0.9477327466,
-0.387691617,
0.2622881234,
1.2933784723,
-0.2961976528,
0.2972323895,
0.5981043577,
-0.0246012323,
0.5145397782,
0.3734674156,
-0.0591759905,
0.2972582281,
0.3483071327,
-0.1127439663,
-0.3232423663,
0.0703200102,
-0.3566038311,
0.3050611913,
0.2022115886,
-0.8632907271,
-0.0551364794,
-0.1353355944,
0.1250184327,
0.1286700964,
-0.441870749,
0.6261531711,
0.2038051188,
-1.0020332336,
0.4415178299,
-0.0555508994,
0.7026646137,
-0.4627149403,
0.2811568379,
-0.6087774634,
0.418868959,
-0.1784423739,
-0.7550216317,
0.2229129523,
0.0216196775,
-0.3094086647,
-0.452658385,
0.8690624833,
-0.3000193834,
-0.2295380682,
0.5287840962,
0.673181057,
0.1273107678,
-0.2851129472,
-0.8495277166,
0.1137730777,
0.3966047168,
-0.3759307265,
0.3759505749,
0.531375885,
0.0553463586,
0.8502861261,
0.2486308366,
0.1064563766,
0.3299506903,
0.1454587132,
0.7297884226,
-0.7107998729,
-0.283705771,
-1.0484511852,
0.314676106,
-0.0093187159,
-0.3584698439,
1.3970906734,
0.7004160285,
0.854696393,
-0.2455415726,
0.8767594695,
0.1782676727,
0.6469898224,
-0.3070083559,
0.4852213264,
-0.5014303327,
0.4452981353,
-0.3544456959,
-1.0217168331,
0.0941742361,
0.5440100431,
-0.6147637963,
0.4437302351,
0.6194052696,
0.8594261408,
0.3127331734,
-0.1803758144,
0.3371177316,
0.6330423355,
0.1951978505,
0.1845343113,
0.987529397,
-0.0495031551,
0.6403480172,
-0.185524106,
-0.1035721749,
-0.1358582675,
-0.7498804331,
-1.0400263071,
-0.3105108142,
-0.3231713176,
-0.5710018277,
0.1955029517,
0.5917783976,
0.6631369591,
-0.6708495021,
-0.6106590629,
-0.1616955698,
0.2593802512,
0.0942750648,
-0.2170526534,
0.0053453064,
-0.8818771243,
-0.833925128,
0.3337284625,
0.2373965383,
-0.0305457767,
-0.8309460878,
-0.194966048,
0.0905485302,
0.3058626652,
0.3618246019,
0.0607152805,
-0.7631833553,
-0.0355587825,
-0.1366266459,
-0.2827316225,
0.1898617893,
0.8350634575,
-0.876639545,
0.6367390752,
0.5800290108,
0.3214172125,
0.7415005565,
0.0191806499,
0.8086499572,
-0.7614969015,
-0.3110288084,
0.1162208617,
0.5084238052,
0.3715172112,
-0.4930835664,
0.6688809991,
0.356222719,
-1.0932732821,
-0.5419319868,
0.4429031909,
-0.2315709889,
-0.4133017957,
1.14369452,
0.1340930909,
-0.2257861793,
0.0296164751,
-0.1910373867,
0.1509400308,
-0.4367630184,
1.1190677881,
0.894921422,
-0.4123767912,
-0.0850463063,
-0.3325919509,
0.6520222425,
1.0109708309,
-0.264228195,
0.1918671727,
0.727255702,
0.2514868081,
0.3238957226,
0.4139795899,
-0.1870292425,
-0.0493652821,
-0.3089720309,
0.4291862249,
0.325234592,
-0.3613993227,
-0.5189471841,
0.1621248126,
0.3375065327,
0.1679634899
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11432v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11432v2
|
Can Deception Detection Go Deeper? Dataset, Evaluation, and Benchmark for Deception Reasoning
| 2024-02-18T02:52:54 | 2024-06-17T02:57:09 |
Kang Chen, Zheng Lian, Haiyang Sun, Bin Liu, Jianhua Tao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Deception detection has attracted increasing attention due to its importance
in real-world scenarios. Its main goal is to detect deceptive behaviors from
multimodal clues such as gestures, facial expressions, prosody, etc. However,
these bases are usually subjective and related to personal habits. Therefore,
we extend deception detection to deception reasoning, further providing
objective evidence to support subjective judgment. Specifically, we provide
potential lies and basic facts and then analyze why this sentence may be a lie
by combining factual inconsistencies and intent behind them. Compared with
deception detection, this task is more applicable to real-world scenarios. For
example, in interrogation, the police should judge whether a person is lying
based on solid evidence. This paper presents our initial attempts at this task,
including constructing a dataset and defining evaluation metrics. Meanwhile,
this task can serve as a benchmark for evaluating the complex reasoning
capability of large language models. Code and data will be made publicly
available.
|
[
-0.5000685453,
-0.6274309754,
0.7869345546,
0.1060825214,
-0.1258912981,
-0.004345092,
-0.2254051417,
-0.5866660476,
-0.3639725745,
0.6265218854,
-0.6828398108,
-0.4929831326,
-0.3651442528,
-0.1182549372,
-0.2657493353,
0.6719437838,
0.1474607736,
0.2268437445,
-0.438810885,
-0.218174234,
-0.5476492643,
-0.5307514071,
-0.3559389114,
-0.3637285531,
0.1311105937,
0.6032488346,
0.443590045,
0.3199315965,
0.4988587201,
0.2979644239,
0.4191245437,
0.2281166017,
-0.4831031263,
0.1664599627,
-0.2265753299,
-0.6400976777,
-0.0219721142,
0.1527817845,
0.274454385,
0.7282399535,
0.137340188,
0.1765253991,
-0.4123703539,
0.450591743,
-0.6925967932,
0.1513676345,
-0.1541579217,
-0.0467523746,
-0.1013922468,
0.1313777119,
-0.4623190761,
-0.422213763,
0.19150123,
-0.3548734784,
0.3004817069,
-0.0093133375,
0.7670384049,
0.1908423007,
-0.5728855133,
-0.4018375576,
-0.8710902929,
0.7156509757,
-0.4940921366,
0.4668231606,
0.3123849928,
0.492777735,
0.1621667147,
-0.7335020304,
-0.5959854722,
-0.7990095019,
-0.1995111555,
0.1040751487,
-0.207365796,
-0.0862837508,
0.5782484412,
0.4196012914,
-0.6104068756,
-0.1922540069,
0.0253078025,
-0.3377831578,
0.660943687,
0.2704506218,
0.130358085,
0.1307823956,
-0.2550641,
-0.3670645654,
-0.3312761784,
0.1871365458,
0.6379851103,
0.0424657129,
-0.188479647,
0.4968861043,
-0.5204845071,
0.3329088092,
0.1500821263,
-0.0397501402,
0.44288221,
-0.4626138508,
-0.131439358,
0.0500807874,
0.3273182511,
0.4448215663,
0.3568840623,
0.0406001098,
-0.2090909779,
0.7934867144,
0.1932211667,
-0.7824504972,
-0.3539286256,
0.16152969,
-0.7619720697,
-0.388448149,
0.2930226922,
-0.5697820783,
-0.7465925813,
-0.4939121604,
0.1978034377,
-0.4578414559,
-0.535703361,
0.5066925287,
-0.1860944182,
0.4023262262,
0.2867960036,
-0.1057547778,
0.5776870847,
0.912617743,
0.4518617392,
-0.0391872451,
-0.0939141214,
-0.5568352342,
-0.2138582319,
-0.2819229066,
0.6700990796,
-0.7077522278,
-0.0373984016,
-0.0036204213,
0.0966357589,
0.2787596881,
-0.5298106074,
1.2101291418,
-0.2482253015,
0.3711141348,
-0.2442909032,
-0.5479098558,
-0.3665071726,
0.5321524739,
-0.704408288,
0.7217951417,
0.0672161505,
-0.3920029402,
0.346575886,
-0.6099917293,
-0.6841986775,
0.0652728528,
-0.120829694,
-0.6133993268,
0.2173551321,
0.2361210138,
0.3906216919,
-0.5140493512,
0.4302948713,
-0.401532203,
-0.483481586,
0.8134673238,
-0.8004846573,
0.8595711589,
0.253447473,
-0.4720983505,
-0.3126472831,
-0.6645876169,
0.0216086842,
-0.004096291,
-0.1097971052,
-0.3205580711,
-0.2298263013,
-0.0296116434,
-0.0956984684,
0.1001261622,
-0.7323601246,
0.1938776374,
-0.2066263258,
-0.0834247172,
0.3951157629,
0.0446892865,
0.2277621478,
-0.1850881577,
0.4576128423,
0.2055182308,
0.4144479036,
-0.1465110779,
-0.3373833001,
-0.8202773929,
-0.2631916106,
0.5281028152,
0.5281655788,
-0.5863921046,
0.5745472908,
-0.3119107187,
-0.3488546014,
-0.5053336024,
-0.3845963776,
0.7027754188,
0.5104857087,
0.2506486475,
-0.1446973532,
-0.5013367534,
-1.0635718107,
-0.5522397161,
-0.0617692545,
-0.2306438684,
0.0954356641,
0.7904089689,
-0.0160129368,
0.6781134605,
-0.7737337947,
-0.3956871331,
-0.0201739743,
0.2654993236,
0.2150116265,
0.4991278946,
0.4461937249,
-1.1238571405,
-0.2075802833,
-0.2177750319,
-0.7587906122,
-0.1821257919,
-0.2130830437,
0.1363726556,
-0.1478217691,
0.4152145684,
-0.5249153376,
0.4282623827,
0.2642414868,
-0.6268322468,
0.7998312116,
0.2319451869,
0.362872988,
-0.3972726166,
-0.0501147807,
0.0790276974,
-0.2478390932,
-0.8624994159,
-0.013325044,
-0.0561257228,
-0.0096979365,
-0.2734433115,
0.4051812291,
-0.4280549884,
-0.1011141688,
-0.073249504,
-0.1957469434,
0.0752811879,
0.3855500519,
0.1482224166,
0.313800782,
0.7232955694,
-0.5313042402,
0.6515517831,
-0.0244744457,
-0.8355672956,
1.1413019896,
-0.4930985272,
-0.0242693778,
-0.1478482783,
0.3644917011,
-0.979103744,
-0.4453724623,
0.5434958339,
-0.7023639083,
0.0451224148,
-0.1715840548,
-0.387383908,
-0.1485947222,
-0.4023880661,
0.2704897523,
0.2828546166,
-0.5425854921,
0.7210018635,
0.1165848523,
0.4090932906,
-0.6467942595,
-0.8102161884,
0.2020231932,
-0.1338824034,
-0.6237987876,
0.1957837641,
-0.0514461994,
-0.5052777529,
-0.0029128527,
-0.1852785051,
0.0028705238,
0.0528490432,
0.3176992238,
-0.0315382034,
-0.1314660013,
0.2250451595,
-0.2563064992,
-0.2426667213,
0.3212503195,
0.0171908308,
0.4473983049,
-0.5508933663,
-0.6794766784,
-0.7062075734,
0.3506550789,
0.4273854196,
-0.2357682735,
0.3439662755,
0.7527650595,
-0.4770042896,
-0.0706809685,
-0.8122115731,
-0.412040174,
-0.4526125193,
0.1004951522,
-0.7195195556,
-0.5613929629,
0.4080647826,
-0.3978048563,
-0.3108707368,
-0.0091462135,
0.3579104543,
-0.0307484474,
1.2046154737,
0.3538013101,
0.1137144268,
0.1642955691,
-0.2294503897,
0.3192918897,
-0.5627429485,
-0.3384171128,
-0.3714727163,
-0.2817651331,
-0.6726250648,
-0.3348616362,
0.2552919388,
-0.2286216468,
-0.1074167192,
0.0073155682,
-0.3946186006,
0.6007074118,
0.4315162599,
0.4048353136,
0.2869159579,
-0.1966169775,
0.2713192999,
0.0278802775,
-0.1029253155,
-0.461563617,
0.9092785716,
0.4407907426,
0.6692608595,
0.1545400918,
0.2501232624,
0.5045567751,
0.3288005292,
-0.8418781757,
0.7615996599,
-0.0742362589,
-0.7053414583,
-0.2312690169,
-0.3151527941,
-0.7381060719,
0.2388089299,
0.0125349695,
-0.2996357083,
0.4316142201,
-0.212329343,
-0.0013861068,
-0.1678481698,
-0.7754940987,
0.8370289803,
-0.4661325514,
-0.3142267466,
-0.2203973085,
-0.8315868378,
0.7199394107,
0.3628622293,
0.0992953256,
-0.3224874139,
-0.1354354769,
0.5810237527,
-0.033371903,
0.9181973934,
-0.5864831805,
-0.1119273305,
0.1160550937,
0.1184777841,
0.3615801334,
0.1864420623,
0.0257504601,
0.071522817,
-0.1794167161,
-0.2279863656,
-0.8781924248,
0.5013983846,
-0.2677099705,
-0.3259162605,
-0.3716051579,
-0.348274231,
-0.5746263862,
0.0951871052,
0.0987131,
0.5438458323,
-0.33600384,
0.4267228544,
0.9598366618,
0.037132483,
-0.0247224849,
0.6181104779,
-0.0406366847,
-0.1105262488,
0.8337100148,
-0.3075392842,
-0.0371286087,
0.3767968714,
0.5881565213,
-0.5720893145,
-0.4824960828,
-0.0298968758,
0.2697937787,
-0.854592979,
-0.2255628109,
-0.1117077246,
0.1737457365,
-0.316827774,
0.1117186174,
-0.1820633262,
-0.1632932425,
0.0345492624,
-0.0314985737,
0.0265120603,
0.4213078916,
-0.0877850875,
0.1956829727,
-0.3803324401,
0.7103205323,
0.3872598708,
0.358518213,
-0.2567220032,
-0.3441906571,
0.0548242927,
0.2955063879,
0.1386541873,
-0.7078748345,
0.0737579837,
-0.0923636109,
0.4074786603,
0.4781032801,
0.2223152667,
0.4934804738,
0.0197430998,
0.6066863537,
0.1474650502,
-0.9755102992,
0.4607983828,
-0.1058138311,
0.1791080534,
0.6794464588,
0.4660257399,
-0.5170552135,
-0.0611874126,
-0.5982019305,
-0.0481055416,
0.5973716974,
0.2713704109,
0.0812496319,
0.4958348274,
0.3186399937,
0.2164494693,
0.3612028956,
-0.6676003337,
-0.2238892019,
-0.0556891859,
-0.3486638963,
-0.0387272649,
-0.0152675267,
-0.4299867153,
-0.3675246835,
0.3207516968,
-0.404037267,
0.3852531314,
0.0377375744,
-0.1931062043,
0.2210266739,
0.1049825251,
0.5304532051,
0.6212400198,
-0.0373842195,
0.2442833632,
0.0317244157,
-0.4998030066,
0.1376814544,
0.0333438702,
-0.0757145211,
-0.1595688164,
0.7369456291,
0.6889467835,
-0.0294733588,
-0.8819278479,
1.0197429657,
-0.3170326054,
-0.3610397875,
-0.4023298919,
0.0907869264,
-0.0816905499,
0.4643063843,
0.2625382245,
0.1105922461,
0.4980773926,
-0.8937422633,
0.2670836151,
0.4907423258,
-0.39189744,
-0.2088121921,
0.0571466051,
0.1661692858,
-0.1246851534,
0.6773409843,
-0.2057550997,
-0.8664780855,
0.5900928974,
0.2633653283,
0.7439526916,
-0.3323756456,
0.3132910132,
-0.0987070277,
0.4284158647,
-0.0851377174,
0.5541449189,
-0.2390518188,
-0.9061796069,
-0.3112720251,
-0.2653995454,
-0.394443959,
0.442851603,
-0.6873221397,
0.1914497018,
-0.3319674432,
0.0698744133,
0.0682353005,
0.1989871114,
-0.635217011,
0.6251323819,
0.3864737451,
0.730538249,
-0.931732893,
0.4929523766,
0.2530454397,
-0.2371443808,
-0.145922035,
0.1976359338,
-0.0329820625,
-0.7630898952,
0.5188081861,
0.5202704072,
-0.4240345359,
-0.3968786299,
-1.0939353704,
-0.3710193932,
0.6130187511,
0.4004015625,
-0.5709661245,
0.2599036992,
0.2936620712,
0.8345632553,
-0.6755942702,
0.0889223218,
1.0013229847,
0.9400316477,
0.0733481646,
-0.472689718,
0.289222151,
-0.0794851184,
-0.247542128,
-0.0323567726,
-0.5132616758,
0.8081761003,
0.0132972514,
-0.3280043602,
-0.0410568342,
0.4922657609,
0.0248451903,
0.5036845803,
0.7514574528,
0.6158679128,
0.8735514879,
-0.3815829754,
1.0723998547,
0.1813012064,
0.0699169338,
1.1849189997,
-0.4916368723,
0.4009231925,
0.0265446845,
-0.0885408446,
0.7524858117,
0.4124015868,
-0.3536605537,
0.6183577776,
0.3365447819,
-0.2868798375,
-0.5744671822,
-0.3233402371,
-0.1894373149,
0.7180509567,
0.7988137007,
-0.0813198686,
0.010972023,
0.3388363421,
-0.0754148215,
0.0661590472,
-0.27876544,
0.5830878019,
-0.2502868474,
-0.7060151696,
0.4074703753,
-0.0322696045,
0.4497309327,
-0.2804014087,
-0.2299706191,
0.0031477057,
0.5285939574,
-0.3942617178,
-1.2119182348,
0.0718855336,
-0.2184415609,
0.1719270945,
-0.1868175417,
1.0898768902,
-0.2757728398,
-0.1793442965,
0.0469723009,
0.3686947227,
0.1968550533,
-0.5242645144,
-0.8329918981,
0.184170112,
-0.0761677548,
-0.2517742217,
-0.0867072269,
0.342443645,
0.0025972463,
0.7957978845,
0.9177566171,
-0.2585442662,
-0.1796021461,
0.4824662209,
0.7873631716,
-0.4878442287,
-0.4054828286,
-0.671127677,
0.4858291745,
-0.5417798162,
-0.2822887301,
0.8387406468,
0.7154417038,
0.8757257462,
-0.1652588993,
0.874099493,
-0.03540105,
0.6134764552,
-0.5554195046,
0.1209947616,
-0.2513591647,
0.0470660478,
0.1055964082,
-0.6987717152,
-0.3423638046,
0.6517316699,
-0.3607080281,
-0.0168080851,
0.688786447,
0.6628117561,
-0.3063720465,
0.3440448642,
0.280978471,
0.0946097001,
0.3598658741,
0.5675634742,
1.2182747126,
-0.5920980573,
0.5702491999,
-0.2953027785,
-0.2801721394,
-0.4088150561,
-0.7806771398,
-0.9589771628,
-0.4739404917,
-0.3284310997,
-0.3397032022,
-0.2283537388,
0.3258487284,
0.6373613477,
-0.7496220469,
-0.1019640639,
-0.1297916025,
0.1003346443,
-0.4434078038,
-0.2970197797,
0.0993283316,
0.1319134831,
-0.5890102386,
0.5075542331,
0.0715284273,
-0.0216240343,
-0.6143177152,
-0.1302801371,
-0.1462125331,
0.1178848445,
0.5603744984,
0.0630812794,
-0.5535945296,
-0.377145946,
-0.0432691202,
0.0859258175,
0.1020321548,
1.1336070299,
-0.8353193998,
0.3725994229,
0.5066922903,
0.4539201856,
0.7858759761,
0.0943137482,
0.3278623521,
-0.8588225842,
-0.0944953561,
0.6972694993,
0.0708791465,
0.3745184541,
-0.3832170665,
0.7117145061,
0.2468447685,
-0.2963307202,
-1.1271746159,
0.5558151007,
-0.8840340376,
-0.4259879887,
0.8632510304,
-0.0828272253,
-0.2088071853,
-0.5234276652,
-0.2573524117,
0.0084049245,
-0.2646551132,
0.5339580178,
0.7831537127,
-0.4232890606,
-0.1195194647,
-0.2007267773,
0.5911432505,
0.1176153794,
-1.1317431927,
0.3378581703,
0.6768487692,
0.2870495021,
0.4877686501,
0.3382996023,
0.084013477,
0.5481498837,
0.2120041698,
-0.2779241502,
-0.0778063759,
-0.4547495246,
-0.489262104,
0.2319607586,
-0.4582088888,
-0.1532471776
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11430v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11430v1
|
EventRL: Enhancing Event Extraction with Outcome Supervision for Large Language Models
| 2024-02-18T02:41:06 | 2024-02-18T02:41:06 |
Jun Gao, Huan Zhao, Wei Wang, Changlong Yu, Ruifeng Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this study, we present EventRL, a reinforcement learning approach
developed to enhance event extraction for large language models (LLMs). EventRL
utilizes outcome supervision with specific reward functions to tackle prevalent
challenges in LLMs, such as instruction following and hallucination, manifested
as the mismatch of event structure and the generation of undefined event types.
We evaluate EventRL against existing methods like Few-Shot Prompting (FSP)
(based on GPT4) and Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT) across various LLMs, including
GPT-4, LLaMa, and CodeLLaMa models. Our findings show that EventRL
significantly outperforms these conventional approaches by improving the
performance in identifying and structuring events, particularly in handling
novel event types. The study emphasizes the critical role of reward function
selection and demonstrates the benefits of incorporating code data for better
event extraction. While increasing model size leads to higher accuracy,
maintaining the ability to generalize is essential to avoid overfitting.
|
[
-0.0898507088,
-0.7993540764,
0.5595346689,
0.1367176473,
-0.1115166917,
0.1046240702,
-0.5452781916,
-0.4317679405,
-0.0354350805,
0.3348269165,
-0.4562658072,
-0.5178898573,
-0.5462170243,
-0.042093154,
-0.2991886735,
1.366932869,
-0.1784988195,
-0.0811793506,
0.0166531783,
0.3485796154,
-0.1897356659,
-0.6524623036,
-1.3168399334,
-0.4806290865,
0.8001838326,
0.4360016882,
0.1511873007,
0.3807476759,
0.4857985973,
0.1984450519,
-0.2116290629,
0.4806284606,
-0.6807958484,
0.0828836039,
-0.1001517028,
-0.3144832253,
-0.3869079947,
-0.3056916296,
0.5443525314,
0.2632237375,
-0.5059795976,
0.0246685948,
0.0918340459,
0.4250864387,
-0.703027606,
0.4279837906,
-0.5359847546,
0.2945715487,
-0.168070361,
-0.5545412302,
-0.7790340781,
-0.3277907968,
-0.093702741,
-0.4704629481,
0.0466865785,
0.0335743874,
0.6378949881,
0.2410757244,
-0.3755143583,
-0.4125563204,
-0.7949028015,
0.8215258718,
-0.7020432949,
0.2480480373,
0.3606829643,
0.3739338219,
-0.3664022088,
-0.6940299869,
-0.4286251068,
-0.3020336032,
-0.0078901807,
0.0498395301,
0.0448677875,
0.2074152976,
0.4071709514,
-0.0571452938,
-0.5840539336,
0.4361151159,
-0.2930095792,
-0.0029445025,
0.7467509508,
0.4156402647,
0.1697775424,
-0.1166575179,
-0.1792448163,
-0.1852490008,
-0.9572758079,
0.2610577345,
0.2737123966,
0.4624971449,
-0.0151164792,
0.4361127019,
-0.1920446157,
0.4660765529,
-0.0629579723,
-0.0154270865,
0.0617460422,
-0.2199358642,
-0.1873138398,
0.3466196656,
0.6142365932,
-0.0253925547,
0.3418191671,
-0.2066918612,
-0.3061029017,
-0.3265293539,
0.241909638,
-0.800791502,
-0.3459327817,
0.2208631635,
-0.4806624949,
-0.6102619171,
0.0827303827,
-0.809831202,
-0.3802106977,
-0.2257739902,
0.3382133842,
-0.3961647153,
-0.2315376103,
0.089448005,
-0.0462743789,
0.5045241117,
0.5983859897,
-0.9725368023,
0.2058781236,
0.9222376943,
0.6148892641,
-0.8193494678,
-0.1773741692,
-1.3699748516,
0.1209800988,
-0.4001323581,
0.6071361303,
-0.5525324941,
-0.2440357506,
0.0669265985,
-0.0524012484,
-0.0066806623,
-0.4768275321,
0.5279936194,
-0.8152783513,
-0.0342295282,
0.0894132182,
-0.6408863664,
0.0660905987,
0.1127199084,
-0.50177598,
1.0802834034,
-0.0756157413,
-0.343767345,
0.3879090548,
-0.6987112761,
-0.5631421804,
0.1882440895,
-0.4121042788,
-0.5368850827,
0.2000853717,
0.3194347322,
0.5048659444,
0.1523147821,
0.4279621243,
-0.2323856056,
-0.2073755413,
0.3917621076,
-0.4097439945,
0.2524446845,
0.1850105971,
-0.3434142768,
0.4836677611,
-0.8153024316,
0.0102530466,
0.0434666835,
-0.5941824317,
-0.16689156,
0.3438248038,
0.1992789805,
0.339281708,
0.2242874652,
-0.3507237732,
0.3377872705,
-0.455739677,
0.1053957865,
0.8476143479,
0.2820593417,
0.2309481353,
-0.0912349746,
0.7308710814,
0.0016523375,
0.1471172869,
-0.2229643762,
-0.2174327523,
-0.6032733321,
-0.2780061066,
0.2542602122,
0.4231254458,
-0.9388205409,
0.2860156298,
0.0977066904,
-0.0448484384,
-0.2134196609,
0.0654929057,
0.6257964373,
0.2304173112,
0.2422774285,
-0.0445149317,
-0.9177020788,
-0.4034382403,
0.0375621021,
-0.1759618521,
0.1356917322,
-0.0266358647,
0.3840534687,
0.0240494702,
0.752227664,
-0.3834113181,
-0.2976393402,
-0.6695603728,
0.354824245,
0.2118560225,
0.3558935225,
0.1908067614,
-0.6922584772,
-0.2799299359,
0.465035826,
-0.6665394306,
-0.0074751661,
-0.2841534913,
0.1851918548,
0.6867459416,
0.5776860118,
-0.3298780024,
0.5107448697,
0.4112654924,
-0.4487830698,
0.7357889414,
-0.1563193649,
0.1454891562,
-0.6677111983,
-0.0253655519,
-0.1739744544,
-0.4502359331,
-0.5632651448,
-0.0139525142,
0.0810264573,
0.230171293,
-0.6279636025,
0.6066474319,
-0.2334084511,
-0.3865107894,
-0.4659553468,
0.0591934212,
-0.251473695,
0.564188242,
0.4064591825,
0.5677978992,
0.1710846722,
-0.6593140364,
0.3756276071,
0.2812318802,
-0.4179646969,
0.0022631229,
-0.4975296259,
0.0181717668,
0.1426486373,
0.1149658933,
-0.6107118726,
-0.1653870195,
-0.0169760566,
-0.5108505487,
0.3862236738,
-0.1538675576,
-0.3933025599,
-0.005437735,
-0.2712161541,
-0.0511761159,
0.6239165664,
-0.7818133235,
0.3791279197,
0.1165540218,
-0.3489334881,
-0.514685154,
-0.3628283143,
-0.1204994693,
-0.2392710745,
0.0904512033,
0.059894044,
0.1107346937,
-0.179807812,
0.0280610509,
-0.1500339359,
0.0275959652,
0.1319466531,
0.094815962,
0.2893425822,
-0.140359506,
0.2288260758,
-0.0630248562,
-0.041601114,
-0.0539963357,
-0.0612731166,
0.5786214471,
-0.0297225956,
-0.5672568083,
-0.4847323895,
0.2147679329,
0.0238914937,
-0.2475552708,
0.6339662671,
0.8403432965,
-0.2609756589,
-0.5103054643,
-0.3826178908,
-0.3554435968,
-0.4526181817,
0.6003608108,
-0.3351791203,
-1.2864801884,
0.3245540559,
0.0742024332,
0.0384075306,
0.1795392036,
0.6225787997,
-0.077089034,
1.2984327078,
0.5982045531,
-0.1327696592,
0.9081016779,
0.0443698019,
0.0434034243,
-0.8992936611,
-0.3312880099,
-0.3794409335,
-0.1224591285,
-0.3323495686,
-0.3944775164,
0.2246532589,
0.3302435577,
-0.1994923353,
0.1121256799,
-0.2338404804,
0.455845356,
0.4005853236,
-0.1330301166,
0.4771766365,
-0.1478413641,
0.2219949216,
-0.131142661,
-0.8201133609,
-0.4260526001,
0.9995660186,
0.2687552273,
0.9175621271,
0.0781885311,
1.0672131777,
0.3316908777,
0.202689603,
-0.6286452413,
0.3556376994,
0.015811149,
-0.1309943944,
-0.6212795377,
-0.5638688803,
-1.0310719013,
0.2418141514,
-0.0685037449,
-1.133382678,
0.0659647286,
0.1741908491,
-0.3593998849,
0.1174140796,
-0.3952612877,
0.832465291,
-0.2798460722,
-0.2181382775,
-0.3284068406,
-0.262137115,
0.3818675876,
-0.0635566115,
0.3757579029,
0.0680667385,
0.0825812891,
0.7495914102,
-0.0896028429,
0.9434202909,
-0.0147358757,
-0.2175702602,
0.117304422,
0.3129345477,
1.1246566772,
0.1937658191,
0.0054908572,
-0.4133660495,
0.0497258455,
0.08531335,
-0.7541231513,
0.5423671007,
-0.6238543987,
-0.2107134163,
-0.1856879294,
-0.3344521224,
-0.1238809749,
-0.2678298652,
-0.0158281531,
0.6365377307,
-0.2367587239,
0.1446012408,
0.8417811394,
-0.4412080646,
0.6495396495,
0.7423687577,
-0.5400034785,
-0.284604609,
1.1289788485,
-0.385610193,
0.1926365197,
0.555324316,
0.0390333012,
-0.2187418938,
-0.6686588526,
-0.2086866647,
-0.0715607554,
-0.6572371125,
-0.2970330119,
-0.7239614725,
-0.2944397926,
-0.3990570903,
-0.2511646152,
-0.4418938756,
-0.4490544796,
-0.4474264979,
-0.3671042323,
0.4359766543,
0.7625435591,
-0.1901610643,
0.3207160532,
-0.7468833923,
0.1997034401,
0.0482508987,
0.1100813076,
0.0531857647,
-0.6331076622,
-0.3309255242,
-0.5999796391,
-0.3198518157,
-0.7280472517,
0.6275520325,
0.378072083,
0.7527222633,
0.3854231536,
0.0320420004,
0.6007326245,
-0.6792657971,
0.7167018652,
0.2712568939,
-0.9478775263,
0.8220226169,
-0.2767044008,
0.1363635808,
0.2109862417,
0.194699198,
-0.7804288864,
-0.6548971534,
-0.8846065402,
-0.9033975005,
1.0718365908,
0.0224300772,
-0.2907551825,
-0.146078527,
0.1761279553,
0.0361626893,
0.225673452,
-0.9231395125,
0.1379807293,
0.3612630963,
-0.4173279405,
-0.2617183328,
-0.2196659893,
0.0266926754,
-0.049695462,
0.7244954109,
-0.2604005933,
0.0762030184,
0.0413486212,
-0.290596962,
-0.1761904657,
0.3582113385,
0.6793248653,
0.647941649,
-0.0310197938,
0.1015617102,
0.4615886211,
-0.0235278625,
-0.1371218562,
-0.0152621567,
0.1530210078,
-0.194753781,
0.8290738463,
1.0168318748,
0.6362890005,
-1.0554882288,
0.4224232733,
0.0716175064,
-0.1651574969,
-0.2898337245,
0.3676249981,
-0.1634812802,
0.7328683734,
0.3685145974,
-0.752368927,
0.2784984112,
-0.4114530087,
0.6469521523,
0.2608443201,
-0.5396415591,
-0.3563562632,
0.5200439692,
0.0522729345,
-0.2792452872,
0.4919191599,
-0.4713662267,
-0.5722019076,
0.8765130639,
0.6709156036,
0.6759581566,
-0.1588039845,
0.4406120181,
0.374252677,
0.265882194,
-0.1585370898,
0.2806656659,
-0.051116433,
-0.601944685,
-1.0083698034,
-0.9207253456,
-0.5899650455,
0.241994679,
-0.7346144915,
0.2624822557,
-0.19757393,
0.3526121974,
-0.1822526604,
-0.0266130082,
-0.38910833,
-0.1354870647,
0.3972037137,
0.7517663836,
-0.7297605276,
1.0367848873,
0.584558785,
-0.481895417,
-0.9605122805,
-0.3429741263,
0.1526761353,
-0.5602357984,
1.1567108631,
-0.1695977151,
0.1700378507,
0.1309393942,
-0.3336518109,
-0.7556135654,
0.8060648441,
0.0127917659,
-0.6260613799,
-0.0962247252,
-0.1373445094,
0.6021673679,
-0.4649608731,
0.2886901796,
0.6981610656,
0.2816827893,
0.2970348597,
-0.8288308382,
-0.0412890092,
0.2456156015,
0.1034036204,
0.3887987137,
-0.156839028,
0.5849892497,
-0.225325793,
-0.0440958776,
-0.1099732593,
0.648686707,
0.5758167505,
0.2002940923,
0.22019355,
0.1706037521,
0.6778924465,
-0.0293459259,
1.0261193514,
0.3441295028,
0.5590890646,
1.4109629393,
-0.5066876411,
1.0252094269,
0.5336578488,
-0.1376071125,
0.2373495847,
0.690505743,
0.2297603488,
0.8284907341,
0.2899659276,
-0.1510087848,
-0.4567570984,
0.1711276919,
-0.1902366281,
0.3765511215,
0.440982163,
-0.0711013004,
-0.4252694845,
0.3066208661,
-0.1526799351,
-0.1319078952,
-0.3509854078,
1.1965199709,
0.1828865856,
-0.6367695332,
0.2392577231,
-0.0581896119,
0.5833733082,
-0.6965810061,
-0.2794831395,
-0.1747340262,
0.3238180876,
-0.1554751396,
-0.6748120189,
0.3810112476,
0.1471882612,
0.1196116954,
-0.2226638496,
0.7051682472,
-0.6309551001,
-0.1220164523,
0.4648373425,
0.2986599505,
0.1763307005,
0.1417262703,
-0.5116369724,
0.505536139,
0.0827117264,
-0.6789493561,
0.5762701631,
0.6589950323,
-0.1682487875,
0.5917910933,
0.6425269246,
0.391105473,
0.0526927337,
0.2275604904,
0.6068508029,
-0.6815991998,
-0.5220557451,
-1.0405694246,
0.4274263978,
-0.2903925478,
-0.2933511734,
0.3864523768,
0.5374966264,
0.8670555949,
0.0014608818,
0.7230024934,
-0.0946841463,
0.2959241271,
-0.8744165897,
0.3233930469,
-0.4615187347,
0.2112608999,
-0.1815600544,
-0.6223766208,
-0.292267561,
0.603476882,
-0.4389507174,
-0.2461660653,
0.708977282,
0.668990612,
0.1285197139,
0.0474173501,
0.5240926147,
-0.0747279525,
0.701117456,
0.7367531061,
1.1980667114,
0.0227938481,
0.5884404778,
0.2782762349,
-0.2454879731,
-0.6236501932,
-1.0100119114,
-0.8083672523,
-0.5903613567,
-0.4750120938,
-0.0215301737,
0.520168066,
1.1646444798,
0.5892771482,
-1.090334177,
-0.2358756512,
-0.0182629935,
0.3045855463,
-0.3691764474,
-0.2330219299,
0.3318363428,
-1.0804659128,
-0.6400211453,
0.5479248762,
0.2618643939,
-0.2550624013,
0.1546602249,
-0.3399130106,
-0.044442758,
-0.1960258633,
0.8196876049,
0.4510901272,
-0.5649251342,
-0.5124718547,
-0.4085702896,
-0.1138464287,
-0.092007041,
0.7399203181,
-0.5288223624,
-0.0459379219,
0.2686551213,
0.9237929583,
0.9502981901,
-0.318148762,
0.6070083976,
-1.0535459518,
0.1095982119,
0.150053069,
0.2496241033,
-0.0945607871,
-0.4862933457,
0.702737391,
-0.1670587212,
-0.6232060194,
-0.9862274528,
0.3696589172,
-0.9188896418,
-0.2576033175,
1.462372303,
0.0329050906,
-0.1585259736,
0.0926305875,
-0.2599616349,
0.3082033098,
-0.4447963238,
0.7393544316,
0.6876792908,
-0.5110897422,
-0.5053300261,
-0.8411411047,
0.8893518448,
0.2287450731,
-1.1988935471,
0.2723122239,
0.5145276785,
0.0642239153,
-0.2657804191,
0.6511723995,
-0.1542413533,
0.4377001822,
-0.5549168587,
0.4207452834,
-0.0429030471,
-0.5046869516,
-0.7070387006,
0.1193806529,
0.2350901067,
-0.088761881
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11422v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11422v1
|
Mitigating Catastrophic Forgetting in Multi-domain Chinese Spelling Correction by Multi-stage Knowledge Transfer Framework
| 2024-02-18T01:46:46 | 2024-02-18T01:46:46 |
Peng Xing, Yinghui Li, Shirong Ma, Xinnian Liang, Haojing Huang, Yangning Li, Hai-Tao Zheng, Wenhao Jiang, Ying Shen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Chinese Spelling Correction (CSC) aims to detect and correct spelling errors
in given sentences. Recently, multi-domain CSC has gradually attracted the
attention of researchers because it is more practicable. In this paper, we
focus on the key flaw of the CSC model when adapting to multi-domain scenarios:
the tendency to forget previously acquired knowledge upon learning new
domain-specific knowledge (i.e., catastrophic forgetting). To address this, we
propose a novel model-agnostic Multi-stage Knowledge Transfer (MKT) framework,
which utilizes a continuously evolving teacher model for knowledge transfer in
each domain, rather than focusing solely on new domain knowledge. It deserves
to be mentioned that we are the first to apply continual learning methods to
the multi-domain CSC task. Experiments prove the effectiveness of our proposed
method, and further analyses demonstrate the importance of overcoming
catastrophic forgetting for improving the model performance.
|
[
0.2090892643,
-0.5497124791,
0.4966034889,
0.2157399803,
0.2475367188,
0.4654888213,
-0.0842601955,
-0.1237236038,
-0.2150804549,
0.1816730052,
-0.8056095839,
-0.428720057,
-0.5311137438,
-0.0060743187,
-0.177521199,
0.6733123064,
-0.2278206348,
-0.0953471437,
-0.1048819944,
-0.1091688722,
-0.7568145394,
-0.6716120839,
-1.2642663717,
-0.2564338148,
0.7115719318,
0.6477631927,
0.3627952933,
0.2300348133,
0.218491748,
0.1687559783,
-0.074249059,
0.6044559479,
-0.5024323463,
-0.185089156,
-0.299395591,
-0.3526368141,
-0.4164953828,
-0.1984824389,
0.957864821,
0.8376091123,
-0.4245571792,
-0.1903299391,
0.4281385839,
0.7168478966,
-0.8060570359,
0.0467705727,
-0.8906709552,
0.2391088158,
0.0125536751,
-0.2386808544,
-0.8017668128,
-0.230800584,
0.2241885215,
-0.9067988396,
0.4707356691,
-0.1126607358,
0.6301255226,
-0.1135293916,
-0.4788169861,
-0.3843445778,
-1.0025800467,
0.7564806342,
-0.5760776401,
0.3460828066,
0.3513158858,
0.3536592424,
-0.2123308033,
-0.6336013079,
-0.6710119843,
-0.2248363942,
0.341312319,
0.40871346,
0.330850929,
0.0731759146,
0.019276632,
0.127510801,
-0.5590684414,
-0.1000073403,
-0.281216532,
-0.460187465,
0.0648192018,
0.168230176,
0.4000953138,
0.1185128465,
-0.3341887295,
0.1504364759,
-0.7355766296,
0.0032798268,
-0.0041394397,
0.4712310433,
0.300883919,
-0.0334254056,
-0.0507378094,
0.3092294037,
0.0569973513,
-0.2203868777,
0.0029018652,
-0.2568905652,
0.1219782755,
0.0481100194,
0.0989454389,
-0.074916862,
0.2488854378,
-0.2569948137,
0.0040695714,
-0.0763830766,
0.5525874496,
-0.2875455916,
-0.556075573,
-0.0089576235,
-0.2029917985,
-0.1129803956,
-0.0498174503,
-0.2958009839,
-0.3128741682,
-0.1999451667,
0.7487742901,
-0.650605917,
-0.1746651381,
-0.0130914375,
0.1189795882,
-0.1349461079,
0.4320930541,
-0.9096834064,
0.0692828372,
0.5242967606,
1.0222135782,
-0.1386033595,
-0.9893105626,
-0.1128503978,
0.3985660672,
-0.4745879769,
1.0170116425,
-0.2294835299,
-0.3583658934,
0.1751531661,
0.2146061957,
-0.7803356051,
-0.5496045947,
0.5256850719,
-0.3640628755,
0.1329324543,
-0.6047825813,
-0.496109277,
-0.3780838847,
0.3948638141,
-0.477740705,
1.0199985504,
0.0876106471,
-0.5376491547,
0.4020920992,
-0.4134230912,
-0.5830367208,
-0.0755127817,
0.6790136695,
-0.580268085,
-0.2083609551,
0.1153181642,
0.4097916186,
0.1417330354,
0.2651215494,
-0.3672010005,
-0.3653825819,
0.3147612214,
-0.5270570517,
0.5473677516,
-0.0680426061,
-0.2037205845,
-0.1016941741,
-0.9266334772,
-0.0458572246,
-0.014722717,
-0.3900115192,
-0.5140089393,
0.1752792746,
-0.24992688,
0.6483187079,
0.0709624216,
-0.251740545,
0.3031929135,
-0.1614410132,
0.5130079389,
1.0922828913,
0.0723811537,
0.4992835224,
-0.5999686122,
0.2720660269,
0.4443073273,
0.5131716728,
-0.3488581777,
-0.2537891865,
-1.0912264585,
0.1287863553,
0.3190225959,
0.64037323,
-1.1567047834,
-0.1003972217,
-0.1435545236,
-0.5200068355,
-0.2791103125,
-0.1320783645,
0.2794678509,
0.6226386428,
0.4603510797,
-0.3426208198,
-0.3708304465,
-0.3928856254,
-0.3638353646,
-0.1888204068,
0.3257646859,
0.1296676248,
0.4826026559,
-0.1491513103,
0.4394052625,
-0.4730647504,
-0.7067606449,
-0.027477283,
0.1790876985,
-0.2733820975,
0.5087934136,
0.3731123209,
-0.6074674129,
-0.5717344284,
0.0413112417,
-0.5447155237,
0.1929417551,
-0.5708545446,
-0.3660981059,
0.5119303465,
0.1215246916,
-0.3296462893,
0.4090467691,
0.3626661003,
-0.22498703,
1.2126666307,
-0.5056985021,
0.5000252128,
-1.0330679417,
0.0294520799,
-0.1769680083,
0.022790011,
-0.9222157598,
-0.0151244076,
0.578128159,
0.2074638456,
-0.4540135264,
0.2652705014,
-0.4678160846,
0.4433339536,
-0.3868554831,
0.1782213897,
-0.0805986375,
0.7286314368,
-0.1823325455,
0.751789391,
0.4759266376,
-0.9308000207,
0.0210752059,
0.226630345,
0.1364389807,
0.8463072777,
0.1607235372,
0.1285341531,
0.120040521,
0.3542436659,
-0.9223579168,
0.1250341237,
0.3317718208,
-0.5517745018,
0.1799974889,
0.0679373592,
-0.5833573341,
-0.8318727016,
-0.0355285294,
0.2434137017,
0.0743281022,
-0.7215999365,
0.5537641048,
-0.1195842549,
-0.1157791391,
-0.6328603625,
-0.626329422,
0.125836134,
-0.016434988,
-0.4671552777,
0.5083860755,
-0.4130931497,
0.6203859448,
-0.0077015255,
-0.3022625446,
-0.4819627404,
0.0843430907,
0.0385487601,
0.3533890247,
-0.1574406922,
0.079235509,
0.2228466421,
-0.0296612233,
-0.1626146883,
-0.7319348454,
0.0929613709,
0.3922125995,
-0.3754210472,
-0.2733110189,
0.2162716836,
0.662928462,
0.0125707332,
0.9566518664,
0.3548058271,
-0.7323555946,
-0.5836939216,
-0.6964679956,
-0.0460547358,
-0.4027494788,
0.4077572823,
-0.2748696506,
-0.784660697,
0.8726296425,
-0.5041000843,
-0.0622507185,
0.5363464355,
0.2235277146,
0.1498678029,
0.768497467,
0.9965238571,
-0.1343898773,
0.1378619373,
-0.0635320693,
0.4038062096,
-0.8716547489,
-0.1523058861,
-0.2735866904,
0.0517046936,
-0.0015975488,
-0.243618682,
0.2562564015,
0.0952450335,
-0.3777009845,
0.4045239389,
-0.3622682989,
0.2962103784,
0.5350452065,
0.2100487649,
0.4294545054,
-0.0800446346,
-0.5892347693,
-0.1381335407,
-0.9319386482,
0.0184414554,
0.9062665105,
-0.1052340865,
0.1194311976,
-0.0330827609,
0.2964875698,
0.100208059,
0.1515346169,
-0.4190236926,
0.2437842935,
-0.4286096096,
-0.5286889076,
-0.1522002071,
-0.3696706891,
-0.5084788203,
0.3207801878,
-0.1692989618,
-0.5044340491,
0.1645262986,
0.3670984507,
-0.6544603705,
0.7920425534,
-0.4688441753,
0.8205677271,
-0.0515059121,
-0.2248156071,
-0.4010868371,
-0.4205359519,
0.4524292946,
-0.6407631636,
0.4027157128,
0.1354214549,
0.438724786,
0.5370315313,
-0.4064975679,
0.7973656654,
-0.1626872271,
-0.0677972212,
0.3626898527,
0.1343776882,
0.474740088,
-0.3671115935,
-0.096166715,
0.060114149,
-0.0665284917,
-0.4137547314,
-0.4563511908,
0.7027644515,
-0.5855154395,
-0.167937547,
-0.541267097,
-0.5278707147,
-0.2745550871,
0.2554492056,
0.2035414129,
0.2032050341,
-0.3975351751,
-0.3984514177,
0.7127774358,
-0.4250891507,
0.2961173654,
0.7890281081,
0.1423790902,
-0.3353120387,
1.2313804626,
0.7055077553,
0.6081570387,
0.2438744307,
0.1121468842,
0.0708784908,
-0.528693676,
-0.4281361997,
0.1310950965,
-0.9298071861,
-0.2222586274,
-0.7300174236,
-0.5677825212,
-0.6584532261,
-0.3677201271,
-0.4770977795,
-0.2376684695,
-0.383972019,
0.1409934312,
0.1307824701,
0.5535748601,
-0.375181675,
0.4359619319,
-0.7411643863,
0.3180746138,
0.1950799525,
0.4032357931,
0.6006786227,
-0.8205610514,
-0.6102019548,
0.109874025,
-0.7626841068,
-0.5167896152,
0.5082003474,
0.5332334638,
0.5662608147,
0.2686031461,
0.0137968883,
1.1030344963,
-0.8146517277,
0.8894031048,
0.1390187889,
-0.96102494,
0.3595497608,
-0.1518866718,
0.5495045185,
0.394404918,
0.3055903614,
-1.4108448029,
-0.3913505375,
-0.5230799913,
-1.0109202862,
0.8362758756,
-0.1215025112,
-0.087616466,
0.0920117497,
0.7009745836,
0.2531101704,
0.0038406206,
-0.6664940119,
-0.4349615574,
-0.0603591986,
0.0266605821,
0.099437058,
-0.4877572954,
0.3417283893,
-0.2125894129,
1.2755715847,
-0.1511638463,
0.1019736156,
0.1275709867,
-0.4486375749,
-0.1748046428,
0.1964698136,
0.8459886909,
0.6637033224,
0.3319677413,
-0.019097805,
0.6728636622,
-0.894397378,
0.0825707093,
-0.0552362651,
-0.1943800151,
-0.2676499784,
0.2868504226,
0.4902915657,
0.74458462,
-0.0688131154,
0.3882239461,
0.1881472319,
-0.5524886847,
-0.5592241287,
-0.296859026,
0.179818511,
0.0338930413,
0.6361833215,
0.6473634243,
0.1080667749,
-0.2306578457,
0.3835048974,
0.0355424955,
-0.4098718166,
-0.3251306415,
0.6807789803,
-0.1956480742,
0.0750506595,
0.7339908481,
-0.1328728646,
-1.0013123751,
0.5719020367,
0.6588078737,
0.8514860272,
-0.9444946051,
0.4685321152,
0.6083875299,
0.397208035,
-0.6701492667,
-0.1125563756,
0.2560091317,
-0.6844751835,
-0.4534542859,
-0.2823022604,
-0.4885942042,
-0.1634667516,
-0.3930116594,
0.3396941125,
-0.5678886771,
0.2039218545,
-0.3019454181,
-0.1654376239,
-0.4030146897,
0.1527382284,
0.268512845,
0.5366333127,
-0.805832088,
1.1020605564,
0.266610831,
-0.2839613557,
-1.2692981958,
0.0400347337,
0.2806902826,
-0.8205766082,
0.2880373597,
0.083558239,
-0.1525410414,
0.1059033349,
-0.3040810227,
-0.8703798652,
1.2446821928,
-0.0749109909,
-0.5063815117,
-0.1339264363,
0.3485164344,
0.338731885,
-0.1714782715,
-0.0072353203,
0.4346472919,
0.4512074888,
0.4660676718,
-1.067099452,
-0.1607269049,
0.0760561228,
0.0307590775,
-0.1363698989,
-0.7908504009,
1.0009459257,
-0.3830506504,
-0.3875083625,
0.2256937176,
0.6293634176,
0.147138834,
0.460116595,
0.4274564981,
0.5639579296,
1.031180501,
0.0261347108,
0.3623883426,
-0.1808369756,
0.5826452374,
0.89958781,
-0.3394916654,
0.7517066002,
-0.0202424377,
-0.1795719713,
0.5543496609,
0.6880989671,
0.0939848125,
0.4807122946,
0.0792672038,
-0.4021073282,
-0.3174360991,
0.2780064344,
-0.2620624006,
0.0820415318,
0.262611717,
0.0534395278,
-0.1060242206,
0.5505232811,
0.1769703925,
0.1866299808,
-0.560418725,
0.5694013238,
0.2128061652,
-0.5702838302,
0.6417630315,
0.0181961134,
0.856831193,
-0.5885519981,
-0.1218977645,
-0.1818018556,
0.5559446216,
-0.0943615288,
-0.3054286242,
0.3297413886,
-0.4276482761,
-0.4790213406,
0.0167353638,
0.8181678653,
-0.7182539105,
-0.6199586987,
0.3351687193,
0.1374575049,
-0.2238215953,
-0.4813776314,
-0.952170074,
-0.1713478267,
-0.0357122943,
0.2337894589,
0.2664309442,
0.6759881377,
-0.1750509292,
0.8421561122,
0.6147837043,
0.0707362965,
0.3263607323,
0.1970644891,
0.5630484223,
-0.7066752315,
-0.5943488479,
-0.6436523795,
0.4946805835,
0.3370268345,
-0.0871585459,
0.7332205772,
0.2730527818,
0.8055505753,
-0.2572441995,
0.9964478612,
0.3148558736,
0.6768749356,
-0.2894939482,
1.0794808865,
-0.4586701393,
-0.0194893628,
-0.5971356034,
-0.7545021176,
-0.7178848982,
0.4489335418,
-0.1227851659,
-0.0052010189,
1.3096300364,
0.6919088364,
0.1958580464,
0.0817479342,
0.5647221208,
0.3190211058,
0.1886758804,
1.1282644272,
0.7034566402,
-0.7355159521,
0.6705225706,
-0.4017179906,
-0.1942469776,
-0.0900658146,
-0.6433815956,
-0.640094161,
-0.9393048882,
-0.4892756939,
-0.5167274475,
0.4958868623,
0.5064533353,
0.4560644031,
-0.8583276868,
0.144726336,
0.0996438488,
0.1276703477,
-0.9141915441,
-0.1443106085,
0.6049627662,
-0.4636836946,
-0.5343081951,
0.1883713156,
0.3277472556,
-0.0783404857,
-0.0774155334,
0.0332913883,
-0.4522056282,
0.059085384,
0.7895560265,
0.4190517366,
-0.6071948409,
-0.696295023,
0.1546926647,
-0.0479692928,
0.0957459211,
0.8592239022,
-0.6140675545,
0.3860631585,
-0.1275669932,
0.5723865628,
-0.0944786519,
-0.4203451574,
0.3306804597,
-0.4826096892,
-0.1679174751,
-0.1653309762,
0.1219272986,
0.4636395276,
-0.6535714865,
0.1444232911,
0.8042933345,
-0.851254344,
-0.4409526289,
-0.134875536,
-0.8313698769,
-0.4045039117,
0.9754431248,
-0.2606967688,
-0.1866221279,
-0.2836889327,
-0.3233368695,
0.4302465916,
0.0332021043,
1.0933853388,
1.0107001066,
0.3437953889,
-0.0182997286,
-0.5942295194,
0.3572367132,
0.4035083652,
-0.3418189287,
0.350228548,
0.3732931018,
0.5573670864,
-0.1074439064,
0.787004292,
-0.1552361846,
0.4821376503,
0.0033377572,
0.3570966125,
0.2014275938,
-0.6924701929,
-0.1921963394,
0.2459840924,
0.1392512918,
0.0418284275
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11420v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11420v1
|
Rethinking the Roles of Large Language Models in Chinese Grammatical Error Correction
| 2024-02-18T01:40:34 | 2024-02-18T01:40:34 |
Yinghui Li, Shang Qin, Jingheng Ye, Shirong Ma, Yangning Li, Libo Qin, Xuming Hu, Wenhao Jiang, Hai-Tao Zheng, Philip S. Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recently, Large Language Models (LLMs) have been widely studied by
researchers for their roles in various downstream NLP tasks. As a fundamental
task in the NLP field, Chinese Grammatical Error Correction (CGEC) aims to
correct all potential grammatical errors in the input sentences. Previous
studies have shown that LLMs' performance as correctors on CGEC remains
unsatisfactory due to its challenging task focus. To promote the CGEC field to
better adapt to the era of LLMs, we rethink the roles of LLMs in the CGEC task
so that they can be better utilized and explored in CGEC. Considering the rich
grammatical knowledge stored in LLMs and their powerful semantic understanding
capabilities, we utilize LLMs as explainers to provide explanation information
for the CGEC small models during error correction to enhance performance. We
also use LLMs as evaluators to bring more reasonable CGEC evaluations, thus
alleviating the troubles caused by the subjectivity of the CGEC task. In
particular, our work is also an active exploration of how LLMs and small models
better collaborate in downstream tasks. Extensive experiments and detailed
analyses on widely used datasets verify the effectiveness of our thinking
intuition and the proposed methods.
|
[
0.1122015715,
-0.596783638,
0.7467437387,
0.1228036284,
-0.0106114093,
-0.2545174062,
-0.6335914731,
-0.4280822277,
0.0069962032,
0.4149868786,
-0.6157124043,
-0.2770264149,
-0.5230183601,
0.3167130947,
-0.2036103606,
0.8308596015,
-0.0857142583,
0.3641012311,
-0.241978392,
0.1396928728,
-0.5928655863,
-0.3938808441,
-1.0036648512,
-0.3902687728,
0.932218492,
0.4187281728,
0.7934626937,
0.5451186299,
0.3475696445,
0.3510568142,
-0.3328092098,
0.4148964584,
-0.5719979405,
-0.1442843676,
-0.2260052115,
-0.8293735385,
-0.7585631013,
-0.2782851756,
0.8363397121,
0.9633321166,
-0.2628401816,
-0.0719244182,
0.4323022366,
0.5177806616,
-0.5856533051,
0.2956529558,
-0.6416782141,
0.1488816887,
-0.1409404129,
-0.0340741985,
-0.6306035519,
-0.1246500611,
-0.1411977112,
-0.6015821099,
0.404602915,
-0.0689383373,
0.613340795,
0.1491001397,
-0.2634296417,
-0.1279838383,
-0.7901469469,
0.6769782305,
-1.0936764479,
0.0410953276,
-0.0257634018,
0.0784946904,
-0.5766597986,
-0.536651969,
-0.5078004599,
-0.2826419771,
-0.2457876503,
0.068947129,
0.0449536964,
0.3833393753,
0.3431017399,
0.6002191901,
-0.2287992239,
0.4645620584,
-0.1777386516,
-0.2572649121,
0.6270210147,
0.391835928,
0.3609531224,
0.0280694813,
0.0595031828,
0.1893527359,
-0.8462328315,
0.0729165897,
-0.0364284404,
0.455312252,
0.0041493117,
0.5485954285,
-0.1409000903,
0.7188233733,
0.1080034003,
-0.0864365324,
-0.1191903576,
-0.2834168077,
-0.4922039807,
0.070080854,
0.4561552703,
0.3077830076,
0.1627216786,
0.0869702026,
-0.418531239,
-0.129162848,
0.3482493162,
-0.5058266521,
0.032949429,
-0.0842812508,
-0.5795824528,
-0.1250570267,
0.206838727,
-0.5371147394,
-0.4713504016,
-0.621407032,
0.3080228567,
0.0880715176,
-0.1702880859,
0.1692164391,
0.2206935883,
0.1426496208,
0.6773675084,
-1.1424744129,
0.2938083112,
0.9185347557,
0.7133306861,
0.0090230601,
-0.6035844684,
-0.5186295509,
0.1202784702,
-0.5882297754,
0.5667693019,
-0.0901169255,
-0.3186022043,
0.291852504,
0.3563916683,
-0.3537869155,
-0.4850643277,
0.4920773208,
-0.3367530704,
0.0068290364,
-0.5882733464,
-0.6149773598,
-0.3820824325,
0.2530026138,
-0.742328465,
0.7607079744,
-0.1295722872,
-0.6075838804,
0.1124496013,
-0.5295062065,
-0.2092941105,
0.0437569059,
0.0488637537,
-0.2089228183,
0.3757368028,
0.2991662323,
0.6527654529,
-0.3605101109,
0.287345767,
-0.2606157064,
-0.5398225188,
0.2846468091,
-0.3362117708,
0.7258196473,
-0.0094907405,
-0.3320696354,
0.3305601776,
-0.3060151339,
-0.0126724364,
0.165218994,
-0.412253201,
-0.2436158508,
0.2269647121,
-0.356852591,
0.0317741334,
0.0182264354,
-0.3021746874,
0.1511197239,
-0.5057198405,
0.3994018734,
0.9188876152,
-0.2990732491,
0.4870464206,
-0.3346279263,
0.466532737,
-0.397842437,
0.1939663291,
-0.1522057205,
-0.1798409522,
-1.108283639,
0.0779313222,
0.3138148785,
0.4713226855,
-0.7452183366,
0.184400022,
-0.1797611713,
-0.5101571083,
-0.4090402722,
0.2699230909,
0.2311123759,
0.3403846622,
0.0779678822,
0.0444501862,
-0.4872267544,
-0.5953221917,
-0.3393670917,
-0.4473603368,
0.0008610022,
0.2217548937,
0.3417153656,
-0.1052782163,
0.5864770412,
-0.3720862269,
-0.2715614438,
-0.5894277692,
-0.2781796157,
0.2602437437,
0.3025596142,
0.4527917206,
-0.496889621,
-0.2132993937,
0.0084034605,
-0.7390488982,
-0.4778462052,
-0.3098033965,
-0.158810392,
0.427611798,
0.71122545,
-0.6790509224,
0.2129403949,
0.7248791456,
-0.350489676,
0.8180441856,
-0.2655330002,
0.1004218459,
-0.5741157532,
-0.1793290079,
-0.0737932548,
-0.0151323155,
-0.657512784,
0.2215065658,
0.0659153163,
0.2629540861,
-0.3914296925,
0.2848632932,
-0.6907538176,
-0.1821946055,
-0.3974999189,
0.355014354,
-0.0556794219,
0.2718312442,
-0.2684570849,
0.4761096835,
0.4568902552,
-0.6642996669,
0.4808006287,
-0.0717673302,
-0.0822486803,
0.1784611642,
-0.5131163597,
0.0360988192,
-0.1503794193,
0.3260536194,
-0.9949026704,
-0.1070666909,
0.3457869291,
-0.3619816005,
0.3178483248,
-0.0907784626,
-0.7646523118,
-0.2640573978,
-0.1811750829,
0.256198287,
0.1834105104,
-0.8197945952,
0.8086957932,
0.0914874002,
-0.0740538463,
-0.4662468731,
-0.7823731899,
0.1766240895,
-0.0889855102,
-1.0368169546,
0.3433246017,
0.1398183405,
-0.4801161289,
-0.050028529,
-0.0322545767,
0.4085027277,
0.2815950215,
0.1512099206,
0.5478489995,
-0.5838484764,
0.3746329248,
-0.262029916,
0.1007303745,
0.2405421883,
-0.2245772332,
0.2965961397,
0.0174393579,
-0.4422030747,
-0.335111171,
0.1042328179,
0.2550281584,
0.0473308153,
0.7984184623,
0.1935122907,
-0.4897285998,
-0.3003833294,
-0.6422634721,
-0.0830732957,
-0.4524722993,
0.5194685459,
-0.0897298306,
-0.9620271325,
0.5567108393,
0.1331082582,
0.1759159714,
0.7115267515,
0.6129404902,
-0.0745046288,
0.7521671653,
0.7434490323,
-0.243112728,
0.3660051823,
0.0376721546,
0.3168159127,
-0.7617317438,
-0.1424298286,
-0.4900630414,
-0.1689959913,
-0.6048116684,
-0.4878344238,
-0.0159173328,
0.0899357647,
-0.2079643905,
-0.01055751,
-0.0465452932,
0.3903042376,
0.1373386681,
0.0016549475,
0.2344853729,
-0.1424859315,
0.0358250886,
-0.0577645451,
-0.8963987827,
-0.5368581414,
0.6606875062,
0.501460135,
1.0215131044,
0.0151077472,
0.3948424757,
-0.0505525135,
0.2817349136,
-0.9717020392,
0.631461978,
-0.4584448338,
-0.3436326981,
-0.2518008053,
-0.250444591,
-0.6592339277,
0.6027960777,
-0.2325478047,
-0.4336564541,
-0.1103925109,
0.3805189729,
-0.437531054,
0.5953595638,
-0.7181373835,
1.0227446556,
-0.3015415668,
-0.448030293,
-0.2889249027,
-0.4204994738,
0.4332565963,
0.2570312619,
0.2821570039,
0.2198029011,
-0.0544232354,
0.5979142785,
-0.5004277229,
1.0943232775,
-0.2243702859,
-0.4756851196,
0.3580219448,
0.0180323198,
0.6201668382,
-0.1562934071,
-0.0615604222,
0.1580251455,
-0.3349124789,
-0.1955460608,
-0.5732595921,
0.7542154789,
-0.5354672074,
-0.9441857338,
-0.3524782658,
-0.4253461361,
-0.0355983265,
-0.0690472499,
-0.0325797834,
-0.0209990814,
-0.2432784438,
0.154564634,
0.4324373305,
-0.0873734802,
0.544088304,
0.5129201412,
-0.2134288549,
0.0669760108,
0.3899811506,
0.1357255578,
0.486623317,
0.3398033679,
0.1722071171,
0.0994539112,
-0.7381267548,
-0.3678316772,
0.4802192748,
-0.9013310671,
0.0736189857,
-0.4926876724,
-0.296826303,
-0.3638251424,
-0.1868151575,
-0.2423930764,
0.0073148743,
-0.5796352029,
-0.1700673997,
0.051408805,
0.7540012598,
-0.1045746952,
0.5418406129,
-0.9661561251,
-0.0132176084,
0.1242232025,
0.0953566879,
0.3968582451,
-0.6516810656,
-0.4745670259,
0.1492738724,
-0.1089074016,
-0.6197550297,
0.2560681999,
-0.0486185178,
0.7396626472,
0.2321950197,
-0.5510618687,
0.8502863646,
-0.565479815,
1.0561338663,
-0.0495613292,
-1.1496229172,
0.3253802657,
-0.2773894966,
0.1165196002,
0.0915934294,
-0.206866011,
-1.046900034,
-0.2362373024,
-0.3980709612,
-0.7638306618,
0.869830966,
0.0576046295,
-0.0309330076,
0.2418100983,
0.6702067256,
-0.1002271324,
-0.1593478918,
-0.9100946784,
0.01880683,
0.1983244568,
-0.089229323,
-0.2591744959,
-0.6624342799,
0.0104531888,
0.0411716253,
0.917511344,
-0.3359366357,
0.1632967889,
0.2914448977,
-0.1761603802,
-0.3963925838,
0.3299927711,
0.5897232294,
0.7196065187,
0.3734462261,
0.0919952467,
0.5611081123,
-0.2383482605,
-0.1927176118,
-0.1175760776,
-0.1053758636,
0.0608269945,
0.7612967491,
0.7522307038,
0.1900723726,
-0.4957567751,
0.3501465023,
0.0776372626,
0.0487283543,
-0.552547574,
0.1312041879,
0.4409354925,
0.2525393069,
0.1958813518,
-0.0486698449,
-0.0796649903,
-0.5804602504,
-0.0986107513,
0.3951708674,
-0.1327542365,
-0.2360254973,
0.3738534451,
0.1522275656,
-0.1108317524,
0.5382450223,
0.024642691,
-0.7453283668,
0.9075416327,
0.5090999007,
0.7561236024,
-0.3946523666,
-0.0312519372,
0.4433611035,
0.5255579352,
-0.6332473159,
-0.1441840678,
0.4876464307,
-0.7807748318,
-0.8646499515,
-0.1214835793,
-0.2834759951,
0.0560652837,
-0.433811754,
0.5508103371,
-0.4466112256,
0.2072279006,
-0.0915090367,
-0.1621631682,
-0.2573083043,
0.2119883001,
0.5373883247,
0.7183175683,
-0.7678751945,
0.5974374413,
0.477483511,
-0.0347092077,
-1.1971305609,
0.1588119864,
0.3158462942,
-0.7291998863,
0.6976406574,
0.0747343898,
-0.2791027129,
-0.4210822284,
-0.6224372983,
-0.6809059978,
1.1457779408,
0.2626854777,
-0.9428699613,
-0.2281276435,
0.0314298682,
0.7288050056,
-0.5543776155,
0.0387571342,
0.5039991736,
0.4815886915,
0.0293975379,
-0.9396361113,
0.2829071879,
-0.0095752636,
0.2373341322,
0.0604849271,
-0.8029984236,
1.1125477552,
-0.4397383332,
-0.1543782502,
0.352253288,
0.6740791798,
0.1574897468,
0.2098603696,
0.674244523,
0.2228143513,
0.6444783807,
-0.1751350611,
1.0488644838,
0.4324608147,
0.404702872,
1.1130595207,
-0.2537823915,
0.6599500179,
0.5672488213,
-0.2713005245,
0.3458001614,
0.7714495659,
-0.3103806674,
-0.00668944,
0.5026450157,
-0.1349355727,
-0.3840934038,
0.0501843616,
-0.0841373652,
0.4374898672,
0.3822626173,
-0.5136557817,
-0.1275248975,
-0.2441936433,
0.2469604164,
0.2302383333,
-0.9323922992,
0.5976652503,
0.1791309118,
-0.7561172247,
0.4364363849,
0.2378643006,
0.8161717653,
-0.431132108,
-0.0794377998,
-0.2361204773,
0.5573092103,
-0.5044410825,
-0.6393663883,
0.2594320774,
-0.0362240374,
-0.2048811466,
0.0098933578,
0.9089633822,
-0.4983332157,
-0.4490929246,
0.522836566,
0.2973381281,
-0.0087050134,
-0.1953989118,
-0.5390772223,
0.0948811024,
0.2643270791,
0.0447082035,
0.1837543696,
0.4769744873,
-0.1254958808,
0.5573575497,
0.4594610631,
0.3304495215,
0.0576940998,
0.3525630236,
0.6616059542,
-0.8804489374,
-0.3728014529,
-1.1256386042,
0.4896714389,
0.1603853106,
0.0252807774,
0.8054347038,
0.1988346279,
1.0163123608,
-0.3152924478,
0.6308860779,
-0.0360823534,
0.3863221407,
-0.9350942969,
0.6978517175,
-0.5832698941,
0.5157073736,
-0.2205681354,
-0.7925186753,
-0.4466440976,
0.4363329709,
-0.1661993116,
0.1349979639,
0.8668206334,
0.9491685033,
0.3384597301,
0.2879494131,
0.3094908297,
0.5200106502,
0.4737917483,
0.7546211481,
1.1180280447,
-0.4235312343,
0.4492236376,
-0.2363375276,
-0.0064353072,
-0.3656413555,
-0.8584663272,
-0.9224821925,
-0.2256036699,
-0.2469826341,
-0.2904356122,
0.0495522507,
1.1023699045,
0.2047010958,
-0.6898812056,
-0.4546722472,
0.0290749334,
0.2345054597,
-0.4387449324,
-0.2082451284,
0.3207913339,
-0.4960375428,
-0.8186583519,
0.2010603994,
0.1175467372,
-0.0117023354,
-0.1402159333,
-0.1156948134,
-0.1529870927,
-0.2289632857,
0.6728643775,
0.0284341741,
-1.093613863,
-0.4640829563,
0.09033411,
-0.2410546243,
-0.041276861,
1.1931132078,
-0.3600110114,
0.1050115377,
0.4977124035,
0.7407910228,
0.0354658403,
-0.2518035769,
0.6926093102,
-0.304359585,
-0.0278956182,
0.0203641187,
0.7303512096,
0.5968311429,
-0.6013761759,
0.5677725077,
0.2895130217,
-0.6787055731,
-0.638181746,
-0.1641746163,
-0.99376297,
-0.2357694656,
1.3452298641,
-0.4341698289,
-0.3570843339,
0.1667339206,
-0.5561219454,
0.2907651663,
-0.0562224276,
0.6415354013,
1.0422170162,
0.0177915934,
-0.2215217948,
-0.5648739934,
0.446140945,
0.7118494511,
-0.7183454037,
0.5339248776,
0.6508219242,
0.3088267744,
-0.0211379975,
0.4289788306,
-0.1563332826,
0.3701089919,
-0.0880039558,
0.0544754378,
0.1369320303,
-0.2070982456,
-0.6312797666,
-0.1752135009,
0.4666134417,
0.0331853405
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11417v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11417v1
|
LoRETTA: Low-Rank Economic Tensor-Train Adaptation for Ultra-Low-Parameter Fine-Tuning of Large Language Models
| 2024-02-18T01:20:00 | 2024-02-18T01:20:00 |
Yifan Yang, Jiajun Zhou, Ngai Wong, Zheng Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Various parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) techniques have been proposed
to enable computationally efficient fine-tuning while maintaining model
performance. However, existing PEFT methods are still limited by the growing
number of trainable parameters with the rapid deployment of Large Language
Models (LLMs). To address this challenge, we present LoRETTA, an
ultra-parameter-efficient framework that significantly reduces trainable
parameters through tensor-train decomposition. Specifically, we propose two
methods, named {LoRETTA}$_{adp}$ and {LoRETTA}$_{rep}$. The former employs
tensorized adapters, offering a high-performance yet lightweight approach for
the fine-tuning of LLMs. The latter emphasizes fine-tuning via weight
parameterization with a set of small tensor factors. LoRETTA achieves
comparable or better performance than most widely used PEFT methods with up to
$100\times$ fewer parameters on the LLaMA-2-7B models. Furthermore, empirical
results demonstrate that the proposed method effectively improves training
efficiency, enjoys better multi-task learning performance, and enhances the
anti-overfitting capability. Plug-and-play codes built upon the Huggingface
framework and PEFT library will be released.
|
[
-0.3670737743,
-0.6290498376,
0.3489539623,
0.3147041798,
-0.4818626344,
-0.160915345,
-0.4959928989,
-0.1259130836,
-0.095432438,
0.5653728843,
-0.3893281221,
-0.5354771614,
-0.4777338505,
-0.2370108217,
-0.2058816552,
0.8562867045,
-0.0553863868,
0.0268613659,
0.2402801812,
-0.173894316,
-0.1922200769,
-0.1852787733,
-0.9693652987,
-0.0170390327,
0.6928442121,
0.4051267505,
0.4319169521,
0.974404037,
0.3136417866,
0.272146374,
-0.0477667078,
0.3418965936,
-0.6991491914,
0.0278955456,
0.0279380996,
-0.568051219,
-0.7552751303,
0.0087749707,
0.9873251915,
0.6954873204,
-0.2557056546,
0.5357580781,
0.10370785,
0.8433470726,
-0.8431826234,
0.1142444015,
-0.8536071777,
-0.0037152588,
-0.072297141,
-0.1769631058,
-0.3136824965,
0.0423463434,
-0.3575749099,
-0.8190112114,
0.070907563,
0.2883307636,
0.647264719,
0.3721354604,
-0.3097613752,
0.3846751451,
-0.5451538563,
1.0270299911,
-0.5198244452,
0.5417718291,
0.2582805157,
-0.0230179951,
-0.2876676917,
-0.6061148047,
-0.2613827288,
-0.0886842534,
0.172923401,
0.0234105028,
-0.2290875763,
0.2426058203,
0.083946757,
0.2738643587,
-0.3402249813,
0.4647874832,
-0.2458302528,
0.1059276983,
0.3517142236,
0.2254064977,
0.0101224883,
0.0576031543,
-0.3958700299,
-0.1670182794,
-0.9206213951,
0.0743745193,
0.5849133134,
0.616466701,
-0.2506645024,
0.2033620328,
-0.4384362996,
0.7139860988,
0.1415891051,
0.1301742196,
-0.1397284567,
0.1880415976,
-0.5978747606,
-0.0798062757,
0.6428505182,
0.1978652179,
0.0387813784,
-0.3381405473,
-0.1687588692,
-0.3065842986,
0.0372390002,
-1.0121902227,
-0.1453658044,
0.1037714407,
-0.8867103457,
-0.5969560146,
-0.3524068594,
-0.6521042585,
-0.5030241609,
-0.3665305376,
0.5150919557,
-0.1409720331,
-0.2683677673,
0.2951297164,
0.0961419418,
0.4171403646,
0.4243790805,
-1.2114901543,
0.3930709362,
0.682731092,
0.7391667962,
0.0090845637,
-0.4564305544,
-1.0453772545,
0.032756418,
-0.442433238,
0.579044342,
-0.423830241,
-0.088787362,
-0.1861779839,
0.1960048974,
-0.3661990166,
-0.5192638636,
0.7157257199,
-0.4967029691,
0.0762996078,
-0.2104427963,
-0.0774585381,
-0.1424703449,
0.0529152118,
-0.3385686874,
1.1046355963,
0.5129184723,
-0.4412457347,
0.4205632508,
-0.7964612246,
-0.1968598068,
-0.3114556074,
0.4496374726,
-0.4855259657,
0.3572659194,
0.1446675956,
0.7157721519,
-0.6738684177,
-0.1191322505,
-0.6318977475,
-0.5873552561,
-0.0474100262,
-0.4570231438,
0.7007508874,
0.3535363376,
-0.185150221,
0.1087317467,
-1.1611301899,
-0.0213523842,
0.1443817914,
-0.4896636307,
-0.3218078017,
-0.1647295207,
0.4091078639,
0.0800777301,
0.1055145115,
-0.4109418392,
0.2554605901,
-0.3512918353,
0.4588118494,
0.8650956154,
-0.4611171186,
0.5736792088,
-0.3828401566,
0.4572020769,
-0.0263510849,
0.2278837115,
0.1025245488,
0.046081949,
-1.1323651075,
-0.6346803308,
0.7944258451,
0.162701726,
-0.2776842415,
0.1892406195,
-0.0619914941,
-0.5509610772,
-0.6855021715,
0.1819309443,
0.3419148922,
0.6140085459,
0.5871081352,
-0.134365201,
-0.5226163268,
-0.820620358,
-0.2532310486,
-0.3064141572,
-0.2306355536,
0.2421151847,
0.2025692761,
0.1596892029,
0.4095727205,
-0.4163914919,
-0.4245820642,
-0.0094788196,
0.151895836,
0.1781092584,
0.7418048978,
0.9517505765,
-0.2861061394,
-0.5299958587,
0.0479650311,
-0.2551384568,
-0.010318758,
0.0113379946,
-0.5055141449,
0.2341977209,
0.3450802565,
-0.4604173303,
-0.0969798565,
0.5915565491,
-0.4004097581,
0.131356582,
-0.4187014401,
0.0346759744,
-1.0469553471,
0.16760616,
-0.0028662831,
-0.4110386372,
-0.3851158023,
0.081083931,
0.1384900659,
-0.0765924528,
-0.2994414568,
0.4595273435,
-0.3621583581,
0.0229961947,
-0.1027569473,
-0.3756209612,
0.0558715612,
0.6037694216,
-0.0977638587,
0.7665089965,
0.5977742076,
-0.4299844205,
0.2036628276,
0.22529459,
-0.2150226235,
0.6708527803,
-0.5730737448,
0.1014997289,
-0.2661450803,
-0.0108045479,
-0.8073615432,
0.0737436116,
0.1354109049,
-0.0787014961,
0.5485978127,
-0.9318774939,
-0.2963116169,
0.3131117523,
-0.5942780972,
0.0665657371,
0.837772131,
-0.7653662562,
0.5188498497,
0.3096747398,
-0.2035575062,
-0.6044557691,
-0.4045457244,
0.0118379351,
-0.6358212829,
-0.3947401643,
0.4877234697,
0.0152021293,
0.0417867862,
-0.2725830674,
0.1059316695,
0.0501422472,
0.4735808074,
-0.1856560111,
0.1723193526,
-0.6066324711,
0.0705584362,
0.244362995,
-0.3421320319,
-0.2517901063,
-0.566601038,
0.4935198426,
-0.1273463815,
0.0356211439,
-0.1396081746,
0.2109473199,
0.9453995824,
-0.3292807937,
1.0460799932,
1.0946525335,
-0.2309295088,
-0.4418309033,
-0.4570657909,
0.0818161592,
-0.4788817167,
0.5645306706,
-0.3319082856,
-0.6566085815,
0.5596268177,
-0.3481357098,
0.0840162337,
0.4602530897,
0.6965847015,
-0.0153664732,
1.1894384623,
0.7591138482,
-0.1879856139,
0.7215910554,
-0.274050951,
-0.146027565,
-1.1638087034,
0.1176673919,
-0.6513605714,
-0.4926140308,
-0.6407786012,
-0.2726774812,
0.2919125557,
0.1017885655,
-0.5461765528,
0.2714811862,
-0.4076094329,
0.4701249301,
0.5104108453,
-0.0062728175,
0.2583256662,
0.0472715944,
0.0804777294,
0.1092343181,
-0.8033819199,
-0.1896691918,
1.2861814499,
0.4474847317,
0.7617699504,
0.1656476706,
0.4386832118,
0.1976976842,
0.1868150681,
-0.8347787261,
0.2712218463,
-0.6278933883,
-0.2124760598,
-0.3587067127,
-0.5416212082,
-0.8624756932,
0.4665322602,
-0.6082152128,
-0.72936517,
0.2937903404,
0.1950820386,
-0.5548994541,
0.3262844384,
-0.8041769266,
0.7846862078,
0.0386567377,
-0.7047638893,
-0.3039900362,
-0.222610265,
0.1787935495,
-0.1721742451,
0.043354068,
-0.5971161127,
-0.0509905852,
0.7932557464,
-0.4463601708,
0.5142861605,
-0.512858212,
0.0277718455,
-0.1922159493,
0.1096186042,
0.8712515831,
0.090876691,
-0.2902323604,
-0.071931228,
0.2088162154,
-0.5912966728,
-0.4706149399,
0.9729281068,
-1.0394691229,
-0.2062481493,
0.1479851156,
-0.6654164195,
-0.4946021438,
0.1915344894,
-0.0501705967,
0.5721192956,
-0.1414738297,
0.3651762307,
0.570395112,
-0.086654827,
0.4457172453,
0.639008224,
0.1157172844,
-0.3106634319,
0.9317417145,
0.2208591849,
-0.073080875,
0.2936219573,
0.2797946036,
-0.3851521015,
-1.0182714462,
-0.7506046891,
0.2623392344,
-0.4402832389,
-0.2999348938,
-0.4163367748,
0.2166589499,
-0.095403783,
-0.2554546297,
-0.8397791386,
-0.6379374862,
-0.3846469223,
0.3019650877,
0.5518731475,
0.3751031756,
0.1229394898,
0.5694702268,
-0.5210835934,
0.2540507019,
0.3607188463,
0.7653475404,
-0.0668792799,
-0.749499619,
-0.5160478354,
-0.0951911733,
-0.0260804109,
-0.1840560287,
0.1611951143,
0.3183509707,
0.2945984304,
0.178983748,
0.3483134508,
0.8519365788,
-0.2589088976,
0.3532153368,
0.0706987828,
-0.8148712516,
-0.1334858835,
-0.7940909266,
-0.0896170586,
0.5513216853,
-0.1016010121,
-0.3458214998,
-0.0260429233,
-0.361933589,
-0.9138454199,
0.9740618467,
0.0321408324,
0.3927510679,
0.4684524536,
0.4733217359,
0.0563971996,
0.0557626002,
-0.2426263094,
-0.1356402189,
0.0968624279,
-0.3873431385,
0.0717101991,
-0.3601647019,
-0.1161423102,
-0.3896986544,
0.9236427546,
-0.4735583067,
0.1961771548,
-0.1944712549,
-0.250538826,
-0.4412538409,
0.1699763685,
0.5257030725,
0.4104182422,
-0.4071246386,
0.0748688728,
0.4969471097,
-0.3801482916,
0.1229963005,
0.4044065475,
-0.0059266789,
-0.4610362947,
-0.1866249591,
0.7261527181,
0.2474482208,
-0.2637518048,
0.2639417052,
-0.3771027029,
-0.3016972244,
-0.1387474686,
0.3459833264,
0.1203797013,
0.4648049176,
0.1465616524,
0.2180337906,
-0.0206761528,
-0.2222687155,
-0.2158609033,
0.445084244,
-0.5756815672,
-0.2972490191,
1.0167440176,
0.2970716357,
0.008224003,
0.4292269647,
0.0744365528,
0.078293927,
0.4682262838,
0.5695836544,
0.8009522557,
0.0006083496,
0.1259653568,
0.1583518088,
0.1990973204,
-0.0842885301,
0.2175534815,
0.0299304891,
-0.5707799196,
-0.4229058027,
-0.8561902642,
-0.2710848153,
0.4130571187,
-0.5161044598,
0.5951766372,
-0.6840325594,
-0.050895445,
0.0531476028,
0.1607057601,
-0.5949169397,
0.0908377692,
0.2187204957,
0.745556891,
-0.7588928342,
0.8317407966,
0.8246014118,
-0.1662766188,
-0.6584033966,
-0.1754191071,
-0.3695013523,
-1.0415393114,
0.2309130728,
-0.3084815145,
-0.2531938553,
0.5879497528,
-0.2464132905,
-0.8762387633,
1.0455766916,
1.0513976812,
-0.1826205999,
0.0596556515,
-0.0426468514,
0.2387734354,
-0.2124385536,
0.4170177281,
0.6772493124,
0.4787932038,
-0.173479721,
-0.8946756721,
0.0795896277,
-0.1871535033,
0.1265162975,
0.3899425566,
-1.2734194994,
0.8698872924,
0.1622297615,
0.3086216152,
0.1717908531,
0.4139838219,
-0.0036000663,
-0.0427195132,
0.6171934605,
0.3802686334,
0.7525237799,
0.0392077677,
0.6212264895,
-0.4892210066,
0.718773663,
0.4706366956,
-0.031858284,
0.7598386407,
0.5634360313,
-0.5000385642,
0.2843772769,
0.543053627,
-0.0020805877,
0.4411104918,
0.237094596,
-0.0438620858,
-0.5363131762,
-0.2565897107,
-0.3071994185,
0.8108334541,
0.1966612637,
-0.5452365279,
-0.2550522089,
-0.3410495222,
0.3412602544,
-0.2833843827,
-0.5618929267,
0.4779108167,
-0.0187151376,
-0.3702430725,
1.0995382071,
0.545691967,
0.6087925434,
-0.5764787793,
0.0550324135,
-0.1536234915,
0.4352712035,
-0.1427056193,
0.0161279198,
0.1226109043,
-0.0448148288,
-0.2108609229,
-0.2976525724,
0.7753650546,
-0.5349932909,
-0.4548097849,
0.0699581206,
0.4980913103,
-0.1569596976,
-0.1704082787,
-0.755954504,
-0.1384007037,
-0.3773165941,
-0.6193962097,
0.8338856697,
0.1288405955,
0.1109964177,
0.3717747927,
0.8633210063,
0.1137434021,
-0.2534471154,
-0.0813151076,
0.926266551,
-0.3108351231,
-0.495699048,
-0.7512490153,
0.5655208826,
0.2800578475,
-0.4952758253,
0.2294784039,
0.5629990697,
0.4956158996,
-0.0394144952,
0.6778064966,
0.1735810637,
0.3356877565,
-0.8579903841,
1.1088382006,
-0.9237703085,
0.2467888147,
-0.2289579511,
-0.9840191007,
-0.4797555208,
0.6708417535,
-0.108814083,
0.0851511583,
0.4376678765,
0.6792209148,
-0.4977772236,
-0.2731250823,
0.6347218156,
0.1484773308,
-0.0624808967,
0.4568401277,
0.7161158323,
-0.5571618676,
0.5083580017,
-0.1759100258,
-0.1137071922,
-0.3479062915,
-0.9200911522,
-0.973940134,
-0.4115264416,
-0.2537092865,
-0.3008479476,
0.0906014964,
1.3150264025,
1.0934798717,
-0.6797792315,
-0.1239014342,
-0.0206937268,
0.0465198196,
-0.1545321643,
-0.1205981448,
0.6778321862,
-0.3607393205,
-0.9588167667,
0.5112537146,
0.2851316929,
-0.0904241204,
-0.1850885004,
-0.0485300794,
0.3296530545,
0.0467256792,
0.5307722092,
0.1008922458,
-0.2169487625,
-0.4008104205,
0.0979290083,
0.2539773285,
0.1038662791,
0.6999146938,
-0.6177833676,
0.2826511264,
0.4032054245,
0.471604526,
0.6795126796,
-0.0914587379,
0.650288105,
-0.6281397343,
0.4916678071,
-0.0283423867,
0.5261963606,
0.0772096664,
-0.4458202422,
0.3415136933,
0.2718358934,
-0.4173485935,
-0.9933205843,
0.0701791644,
-0.8488126993,
-0.0266008358,
1.0072413683,
-0.1376222819,
-0.3917122185,
-0.1993669271,
-0.2481078506,
0.2806314528,
-0.4113946259,
0.9333782792,
0.3847180605,
0.0149555067,
-0.3232529163,
-0.5019910336,
0.4993676543,
0.6421539783,
-0.5033179522,
0.4364338815,
-0.0215827432,
0.4220445156,
-0.5381811857,
0.5885272622,
-0.0494970791,
0.2365899682,
0.0576974489,
0.020701481,
-0.641274631,
-0.1096040085,
-0.3645117283,
0.1351534128,
0.6744065285,
-0.2985883057
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11414v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11414v1
|
Fine-grained and Explainable Factuality Evaluation for Multimodal Summarization
| 2024-02-18T01:03:25 | 2024-02-18T01:03:25 |
Liqiang Jing, Jingxuan Zuo, Yue Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multimodal summarization aims to generate a concise summary based on the
input text and image. However, the existing methods potentially suffer from
unfactual output. To evaluate the factuality of multimodal summarization
models, we propose two fine-grained and explainable evaluation frameworks
(FALLACIOUS) for different application scenarios, i.e. reference-based
factuality evaluation framework and reference-free factuality evaluation
framework. Notably, the reference-free factuality evaluation framework doesn't
need ground truth and hence it has a wider application scenario. To evaluate
the effectiveness of the proposed frameworks, we compute the correlation
between our frameworks and the other metrics. The experimental results show the
effectiveness of our proposed method. We will release our code and dataset via
github.
|
[
-0.3569100797,
-0.6590355635,
0.5678246617,
0.2775813341,
-0.3662691414,
-0.1147904843,
-0.1795192212,
-0.2946177721,
0.2270914018,
0.1235713437,
-0.4429821372,
-0.431321919,
-0.5780338645,
-0.1011454538,
-0.5105255842,
1.3204436302,
-0.0988094509,
-0.1336581558,
-0.8080135584,
-0.6005420685,
-0.5618556738,
-0.1200023741,
-0.1171381995,
-0.3314731121,
0.3853411376,
0.5979665518,
0.8014032245,
0.3578337729,
0.8143673539,
0.3494679034,
0.0478486642,
0.3598029613,
-0.5215833187,
-0.158515662,
-0.4941734672,
-0.219408676,
-0.4770793021,
-0.0143253738,
0.4511283338,
0.5291098952,
-0.1820130497,
0.3761499226,
-0.0317302682,
0.7223674655,
-0.8656755686,
0.2487072349,
-0.3012990654,
0.00595761,
0.1748488843,
-0.3000595272,
-0.3997369707,
-0.5589876771,
0.0703437403,
-0.4763940275,
0.340561837,
-0.0110246595,
0.7053941488,
0.0284850057,
-0.5826723576,
-0.4479721785,
-0.7344587445,
0.66866678,
-0.8515057564,
0.3686225712,
0.0355868563,
0.59130162,
0.2738457024,
-0.9337978959,
-0.6537866592,
-0.4005782902,
-0.3585481644,
0.4550077319,
-0.2192433029,
0.0149189075,
0.0205186158,
0.667502284,
-0.6598315835,
-0.2434099466,
-0.1635378897,
-0.2967256308,
0.3874360025,
0.2707547843,
0.1822855622,
-0.3366273344,
-0.5782250762,
0.1326894909,
-0.2648541927,
0.1331961006,
0.0518562533,
0.2480780631,
-0.6988595724,
0.6658649445,
-0.3973888755,
0.3041405678,
0.1372017562,
-0.5035669208,
0.3379231393,
-0.9375055432,
-0.1470080316,
0.0149616133,
0.5532203913,
1.1286919117,
-0.0575556345,
-0.3439855874,
-0.1071505621,
0.1936484426,
0.0525076613,
-0.9683280587,
0.0348830931,
0.3218245208,
-0.9074501395,
-0.4227552712,
0.0632503778,
-1.0042852163,
-0.338067919,
-0.1844491959,
0.3200547993,
-0.4714151323,
-0.3572947383,
-0.1062122434,
-0.4041944146,
-0.097918272,
0.5744154453,
-0.8678066134,
0.1009480208,
0.229139179,
0.9304224253,
-0.3424262106,
-0.1421592087,
-0.3997497857,
0.1690126956,
-0.0895932242,
0.8841008544,
-0.4005453289,
-0.3641869128,
-0.0340073556,
-0.1189528555,
-0.2021663934,
-0.4083010554,
0.7397460938,
-0.3672358394,
0.13209185,
-0.2143043876,
-0.3109828234,
-0.5831543803,
0.464982748,
-0.6642381549,
0.5563384295,
-0.1079663634,
-0.9224764705,
0.3801212311,
-0.73262465,
-0.4030109346,
-0.256995976,
0.1112376302,
-0.3419795334,
0.2593495548,
0.1432093531,
0.5941140652,
-0.2277849913,
0.558333993,
-0.5219563246,
-0.2889144421,
0.3998616338,
-0.8047921658,
0.263617754,
0.3663665056,
-0.1346805394,
0.2061081827,
-0.9630104303,
-0.1314895451,
-0.1153023541,
-0.3594021201,
-0.1163408011,
0.1813886613,
0.2680160999,
0.204650417,
0.2872639596,
-0.2940842509,
-0.0753112435,
-0.2987481356,
0.0627168491,
0.369710207,
0.0669116899,
0.3563490212,
-0.4812221527,
0.3813920617,
0.261762172,
0.0174885374,
-0.5092384219,
-0.0820507258,
-0.5315267444,
-0.4228646755,
0.3466558754,
0.4678850174,
-0.9600672722,
-0.1653426886,
-0.434684962,
-0.5103077292,
0.1646542549,
-0.0651124865,
0.7154138684,
0.8051276803,
0.257430464,
-0.4389836788,
-0.4346974492,
-1.0843117237,
-0.2005053163,
-0.2113680691,
0.0969736353,
0.1123483628,
0.7003144026,
-0.238310501,
1.0333877802,
-0.3900681734,
-0.0945896581,
-0.2499811351,
0.5249348283,
0.180925861,
0.5199372768,
0.7455379367,
-0.9392099977,
0.0316929929,
-0.0450356416,
-0.9301043749,
-0.0128327534,
-0.3087928891,
0.3710967302,
0.2464462817,
0.1506112516,
-0.6810032129,
0.4932828844,
0.4272186756,
-0.3510591388,
0.7451798916,
-0.2533572316,
0.6706712842,
-1.0616163015,
0.2746266425,
0.1578176171,
-0.3902848363,
-0.4732934237,
0.1472734511,
0.0569772013,
-0.1100477055,
-0.3773773015,
0.3183400929,
-0.1184095517,
-0.0987276435,
-0.1203701496,
0.4397375286,
0.282181561,
0.4279130399,
-0.1801998168,
0.6752143502,
0.0367149487,
-0.6281763315,
0.4862785041,
0.0556901433,
-0.2990167737,
0.6810671091,
-0.6525947452,
-0.432156235,
-0.3094379604,
0.4003679752,
-1.1625136137,
-0.4751539528,
0.1503599733,
-0.5612866879,
0.1602323502,
0.0234948639,
-0.3381916583,
-0.0478646047,
-0.8220416903,
0.3415689468,
-0.0974732712,
-0.4180039167,
0.5733864307,
0.0803168565,
-0.1142972484,
-0.5283637047,
-0.700619638,
-0.0493649654,
-0.2926058173,
-0.6613755226,
0.3647268116,
-0.3448723853,
-0.4088262618,
0.0702063739,
-0.2608811855,
-0.1490054578,
-0.0694071651,
0.2816206515,
0.2868150771,
-0.3587419689,
0.0861679614,
0.1067582592,
-0.1203284264,
0.0643483773,
0.3452529907,
0.0243958291,
-0.3875109255,
-0.3945160806,
-0.5256182551,
0.334707886,
0.8697501421,
-0.1279343069,
0.5003121495,
0.7630832791,
-0.2570964098,
0.3784220219,
-0.4574315846,
0.0867671669,
-0.3411501944,
0.4963495135,
-0.2123617083,
-0.4618334472,
0.699608326,
-0.3003130853,
0.0986125395,
0.5394217372,
0.707013309,
-0.113071464,
0.7852758169,
0.5740423203,
0.3880796134,
0.1625816077,
-0.0588361062,
0.1372552067,
-0.4036195874,
-0.4361484051,
-0.285017997,
0.0341172591,
-0.4900922775,
-0.1603907943,
0.3786900043,
0.0547785759,
0.4222192466,
-0.0718968809,
0.0265430007,
0.415569216,
0.3359825909,
0.0135871703,
0.4939402342,
-0.0245447345,
-0.3298594654,
-0.014943379,
-0.429459542,
-0.5612079501,
0.9701915383,
0.320171386,
0.6426007152,
0.396979779,
0.1843317449,
0.6236436963,
0.118734315,
-0.6711084247,
0.2184046805,
-0.0405461565,
-0.7569378018,
-0.0791970044,
-0.3645178676,
-0.3770979941,
0.424868077,
-0.5791123509,
-0.6246604919,
0.2571012974,
0.4069283903,
-0.4600906372,
0.028362466,
-1.1155585051,
0.8461507559,
0.0528814569,
-0.3714801073,
-0.4765353501,
-0.7411274314,
0.7993513942,
-0.0014560086,
0.4940216541,
-0.0285519939,
0.202227056,
0.5908457041,
-0.4003769457,
0.7375552058,
-0.1196884066,
-0.0267236084,
0.2175647914,
0.0673570707,
0.1833820939,
0.5069839954,
0.040768601,
0.1853394359,
0.3525917232,
-0.2108074725,
-0.9898474216,
0.6787538528,
-0.3417812586,
-0.1433241367,
-0.4087685347,
-0.6598413587,
-0.2762213647,
0.2823116481,
0.1795804799,
1.0464588404,
-0.4403551221,
0.166198194,
0.4937168956,
-0.0429222547,
0.8492537737,
0.5222930908,
-0.3276501596,
-0.6508603096,
1.0320755243,
-0.0316180177,
0.1865527928,
0.3883951306,
0.0870086625,
-0.3305669427,
-0.4676326811,
-0.669432044,
-0.0181157924,
-0.7215120792,
-0.1978607029,
-0.2675483227,
0.1736394912,
-0.3287654519,
-0.2242352515,
-0.4450470507,
-0.7573097944,
0.0916548297,
0.0444642156,
-0.0036113716,
0.5380628705,
-0.181267783,
0.2472627461,
-0.9009608626,
0.7173175216,
0.2489915937,
0.4945464432,
-0.068553932,
-0.4118917584,
-0.4444885552,
0.2788947523,
-0.5509645343,
-0.5600172877,
-0.078615956,
0.1676289737,
0.3567644954,
0.8691586852,
0.0618983023,
0.6401996017,
-0.4186674058,
0.8056536913,
0.6065438986,
-0.9223713279,
0.4201830924,
-0.3691285551,
0.3860957921,
0.7693164945,
0.0679940805,
-0.2330253273,
-0.0703575388,
-0.4172207415,
-0.7081252337,
0.7874272466,
0.4987613857,
-0.0819785744,
0.3101272285,
0.1142183915,
0.3561890721,
0.3645500243,
-0.6700698137,
-0.5081070065,
-0.4816541374,
-0.2485183179,
-0.219328925,
-0.650097847,
-0.2700693011,
-0.0280353501,
0.6250032187,
-0.1492866576,
0.1787520051,
0.11360614,
-0.3270104825,
0.0937071964,
0.4570711255,
0.9958131313,
1.0977324247,
-0.6768183708,
0.3275471926,
0.0595236979,
-0.4735834599,
-0.0402668417,
0.1503097862,
-0.1853091568,
0.3284229338,
0.7508981824,
0.6266934872,
0.3925790489,
-0.6900166273,
0.7773589492,
-0.2854294479,
-0.1702207625,
-0.0554950349,
-0.0868948251,
0.0102712605,
0.2591244578,
0.1522527337,
0.6158980131,
0.5514968634,
-0.6391720176,
0.0339107253,
0.293865025,
-0.1609557867,
-0.4105895162,
0.549270153,
0.4237175882,
0.2509257495,
0.0224515349,
-0.1635250598,
-0.061507009,
0.4441442788,
0.6085144281,
0.5965625644,
0.0713536963,
0.4842197597,
0.1542595625,
0.2922381461,
0.2857388258,
-0.0092943534,
-0.2247271687,
-0.6310451627,
-0.4803658724,
-0.3119893968,
-0.5984748602,
-0.0062231161,
-0.7604134679,
0.1433482617,
-0.1412226409,
-0.0538114943,
0.3277994096,
-0.1791733056,
-0.0249231383,
0.486164093,
0.0724535584,
0.7200421095,
-0.8340596557,
0.2252192348,
0.8567860723,
-0.5453445315,
-0.2708102167,
0.1187790558,
0.1985532492,
-0.4239053428,
0.344774276,
0.2275137752,
-0.491555512,
-0.5655211806,
-0.2849696577,
-0.7265554667,
1.1068787575,
0.5990167856,
-0.1535748243,
0.0119988257,
-0.0076988004,
0.2161267996,
-0.2291081399,
0.5467842817,
0.361420542,
0.5659967661,
0.2613967359,
-0.8267105222,
0.0385986865,
-0.4179709852,
0.0593356527,
-0.181820184,
-0.664206624,
0.3891794384,
-0.3262231946,
-0.3310107291,
-0.1410512328,
0.8162256479,
0.069704473,
0.9734982848,
0.281330198,
0.6032813787,
0.6087265015,
0.0737436339,
0.9242411256,
-0.23315759,
0.64131248,
1.1195476055,
-0.0700757653,
0.3667086363,
0.4732183814,
-0.0493193194,
0.479547888,
0.4088189602,
0.097225748,
0.6629796028,
-0.4122081399,
-0.0686366484,
-0.051652018,
-0.1573040783,
-0.3379901946,
0.6337763667,
0.1129272431,
-0.2309442014,
-0.7643405199,
0.0181760434,
0.1579295695,
0.1464536339,
-0.2914837599,
0.5294474959,
-0.090006873,
-0.5171139836,
0.6109732985,
0.3688016832,
0.4940652549,
-0.4899753034,
-0.1872002631,
-0.2513647676,
0.2742899954,
-0.5109450221,
-0.4658098519,
0.4847478569,
0.179359898,
-0.6794275045,
0.0527802482,
0.6433460116,
-0.1434749812,
-0.3172721267,
-0.1555963606,
0.3357725441,
0.1003718674,
0.2429170609,
-0.5020440817,
-0.1259254962,
-0.0557550415,
-0.1467124224,
0.1064586192,
0.4434705079,
-0.104380928,
0.6518770456,
0.4471197426,
-0.2413773686,
-0.2297204286,
0.0584449098,
0.7857576609,
-0.2820058167,
-0.3749930859,
-0.9710711837,
0.7072818875,
-0.1467950791,
-0.3277520537,
0.9248077273,
0.8566776514,
0.349265933,
-0.3047861755,
0.6086717844,
-0.2564791441,
0.4307219386,
-0.8513178825,
0.7268967032,
-0.5734502673,
0.1112247035,
-0.5678416491,
-0.7686780095,
-0.3448729813,
0.2827144563,
-0.0630724579,
0.0627878457,
1.1433676481,
0.6394512057,
-0.3342746496,
0.2635532022,
0.264623791,
0.1478920132,
-0.1046983898,
0.1247345954,
0.6531154513,
-0.3122078478,
0.4947499335,
-0.2757239044,
-0.4384163022,
-0.3965389431,
-1.0623537302,
-0.8543234468,
-0.5363302827,
-0.4128221869,
-0.2162775993,
-0.1236039251,
0.6774980426,
0.6430245042,
-0.8373552561,
0.0617465936,
0.1680059284,
0.3642849326,
-0.1264293194,
-0.2475416362,
0.4049521685,
-0.1322842091,
-0.5559170246,
0.2323473692,
0.4002025425,
0.0641326681,
-0.0234508459,
0.0312600806,
-0.2055958807,
0.3338121772,
0.8220039606,
0.0810336322,
-0.5725464225,
-0.3198842108,
-0.4683208466,
0.1456486285,
0.0346270837,
0.687477231,
-0.5003446341,
0.6373477578,
0.3325349391,
0.3547731936,
0.2957307696,
0.3410689831,
0.3547776639,
-0.6918464303,
0.250987649,
-0.3332023025,
0.356413871,
0.22581774,
-0.3614884615,
0.3309823871,
0.4075685143,
-0.2513261735,
-0.6980866194,
0.1546680331,
-1.1933649778,
-0.1826628149,
0.8904057145,
-0.34580791,
-0.0315787233,
0.0271829572,
-0.133441329,
0.2732261717,
-0.3768187761,
0.8045099378,
0.7670813799,
-0.1993931532,
0.113872163,
-0.4624333084,
0.1763517112,
0.2106104791,
-0.7831330299,
-0.0348141715,
0.851564765,
0.2791490555,
0.4576337636,
0.4932916164,
-0.2091685236,
0.5037587285,
0.0598607548,
0.1546553522,
-0.37121135,
-0.3653041124,
-0.3381941915,
0.3683963418,
-0.251781702,
-0.3135256171
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11411v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11411v1
|
Aligning Modalities in Vision Large Language Models via Preference Fine-tuning
| 2024-02-18T00:56:16 | 2024-02-18T00:56:16 |
Yiyang Zhou, Chenhang Cui, Rafael Rafailov, Chelsea Finn, Huaxiu Yao
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Instruction-following Vision Large Language Models (VLLMs) have achieved
significant progress recently on a variety of tasks. These approaches merge
strong pre-trained vision models and large language models (LLMs). Since these
components are trained separately, the learned representations need to be
aligned with joint training on additional image-language pairs. This procedure
is not perfect and can cause the model to hallucinate - provide answers that do
not accurately reflect the image, even when the core LLM is highly factual and
the vision backbone has sufficiently complete representations. In this work, we
frame the hallucination problem as an alignment issue, tackle it with
preference tuning. Specifically, we propose POVID to generate feedback data
with AI models. We use ground-truth instructions as the preferred response and
a two-stage approach to generate dispreferred data. First, we prompt GPT-4V to
inject plausible hallucinations into the correct answer. Second, we distort the
image to trigger the inherent hallucination behavior of the VLLM. This is an
automated approach, which does not rely on human data generation or require a
perfect expert, which makes it easily scalable. Finally, both of these
generation strategies are integrated into an RLHF pipeline via Direct
Preference Optimization. In experiments across broad benchmarks, we show that
we can not only reduce hallucinations, but improve model performance across
standard benchmarks, outperforming prior approaches. Our data and code are
available at https://github.com/YiyangZhou/POVID.
|
[
-0.509427309,
-0.6817982793,
0.6612510085,
-0.2376726121,
-0.3817177117,
-0.5485194921,
-0.5276197195,
-0.3986658454,
0.193524465,
0.6845251918,
-0.4541769028,
-0.4947550595,
-0.4324019253,
-0.0985542759,
0.0346389413,
0.9475319386,
0.0011389252,
0.2557097673,
-0.2835006416,
-0.1996337324,
-0.6744263172,
-0.5136039853,
-0.2726731598,
-0.2956194878,
0.4130243063,
0.3126164079,
1.0834037066,
0.7976581454,
0.7431879044,
0.2872900665,
0.3015703559,
0.619068265,
-0.4643698335,
0.1658914238,
-0.268412441,
-0.117743656,
-0.5337955356,
-0.2085094005,
0.4225845635,
0.5093073249,
-0.1932118982,
-0.0006593326,
-0.0456587635,
0.6343896389,
-0.6641516685,
-0.12223766,
-0.6798731685,
0.2022314072,
0.0512200072,
-0.4471681416,
-0.381159395,
-0.32751441,
0.2754966319,
-0.6117290854,
0.1956777424,
0.1579046845,
0.9734751582,
0.8511359096,
-0.0355503485,
-0.0020318809,
-0.7883380651,
0.745211482,
-0.6219472885,
0.4080177546,
0.5051670074,
0.2172706276,
-0.1206711009,
-0.2419218123,
-0.5905387998,
-0.1978155524,
-0.0704218,
0.0309314188,
0.258145839,
0.1603630632,
0.2145509422,
0.3488126695,
-0.7091898322,
0.2025241405,
-0.2338382304,
-0.3421040177,
0.6056770682,
0.3108217716,
0.0408244021,
-0.0384431593,
-0.1793942302,
-0.2540499568,
-0.4196505547,
-0.1776736975,
0.4123984277,
0.2534755766,
0.1545881778,
0.822227478,
0.0100612575,
1.0689300299,
0.7577380538,
-0.0327534489,
0.4887176752,
-0.0507088713,
-0.4227846861,
0.3085465133,
0.5984740257,
0.7831551433,
0.1633264124,
-0.1220984757,
-0.3370629251,
0.3964388371,
0.7246780992,
-0.7132823467,
-0.305971086,
0.3358287513,
-0.3032325506,
-0.3251799047,
0.1419039369,
-0.7575629354,
-0.7666775584,
-0.7918155193,
0.7365265489,
-0.3750576377,
-0.2666407824,
0.5392377377,
0.1832396239,
0.6483278871,
0.4286303818,
-1.1698660851,
0.0101088164,
0.6348075271,
0.5540815592,
-0.4095560312,
-0.3894178867,
-0.9246973991,
-0.032386817,
-0.4819185138,
0.654666543,
-0.6867454648,
-0.0759993792,
0.0386668369,
0.1299157292,
0.1347271353,
-0.7997816801,
0.3332578838,
-0.2703774571,
0.3772607148,
-0.2534142435,
-0.4292670488,
-0.0084606474,
0.2330909371,
-0.4670034945,
0.8561917543,
-0.0446826145,
-0.7380538583,
0.3559500575,
-0.2878504097,
-0.3181713223,
-0.0864076614,
-0.6454452872,
-0.5514018536,
0.32758376,
0.4862304032,
0.4384114146,
-0.0799412802,
0.4456038773,
-0.1873341948,
-0.4513556659,
0.0327311419,
-0.2591419816,
0.3125370145,
0.1863552481,
-0.7297463417,
0.5603985786,
-0.6249212027,
-0.1898097098,
0.0636903793,
0.175451085,
-0.2434601337,
0.1861592084,
-0.0379962064,
-0.0724257603,
0.2551853657,
-0.1655682474,
0.3357358277,
-0.4880335331,
0.2426296026,
0.9820545912,
-0.2808435261,
0.6562709212,
-0.3595670164,
0.2845505476,
0.0888149813,
0.3694308698,
0.1535660326,
-0.251721561,
-0.8209516406,
-0.0910760388,
-0.1722509116,
0.3194847107,
-0.618069768,
0.6251015067,
-0.1412959993,
-0.1201648861,
-0.7322596908,
0.0245768633,
0.1823822409,
0.6929696202,
0.4422622025,
-0.3486106396,
-0.5745095015,
-1.0222468376,
0.27259323,
-0.1115395725,
0.0290286206,
0.3871838152,
0.076767616,
-0.3510532081,
0.7046801448,
-0.6358132362,
-0.5455674529,
0.1446452737,
-0.1973624229,
0.0151892984,
0.437366873,
0.4383688867,
-0.9416190386,
-0.1035742834,
0.3013788462,
-0.7711755037,
-0.007557204,
0.0139722992,
-0.4101026356,
0.4440308511,
0.3789965808,
-0.3949345052,
0.2975382805,
0.500618875,
-0.2150429338,
0.5346258879,
-0.225306347,
0.3199181855,
-1.078943491,
-0.0571133606,
-0.0525123626,
-0.2097439915,
-0.4814751148,
0.0826334432,
-0.1583788693,
0.1340570003,
-0.4357377589,
0.3458778858,
-0.4096881747,
-0.0400498398,
-0.3540067673,
0.0964124203,
-0.0240230281,
0.5573287606,
0.5764245987,
0.6253230572,
0.7520677447,
-0.4540782869,
0.5070117712,
0.2174568772,
-0.236103043,
0.5381017327,
-0.4989430308,
0.3158053756,
-0.2857093215,
-0.1644582152,
-0.8241840601,
-0.5884005427,
0.4793770015,
-0.3224306703,
0.3815201521,
0.1117487699,
-0.0640697852,
-0.144061476,
-0.3349699378,
0.4715971947,
0.6125534177,
-0.6849449277,
0.694762826,
0.4552655816,
0.325429529,
-0.6754890084,
-0.5286764503,
-0.1089687049,
-0.2904168963,
-0.5149518847,
0.4085177779,
-0.1494680345,
-0.2630438209,
0.0480467305,
-0.2159619033,
0.1523004025,
-0.2897138298,
0.4246073067,
0.6231833696,
-0.3867796063,
0.113478452,
-0.2978786528,
0.0494092703,
-0.236608848,
-0.5693317652,
0.6813609004,
-0.3005730212,
-0.4017461538,
-0.4626405835,
0.1531897187,
0.7690786719,
-0.3789622188,
0.4921528101,
0.6536077857,
-0.3863528073,
-0.0709221065,
-0.7467284799,
-0.4359624386,
-0.4611084759,
0.3758496046,
-0.2794480026,
-0.9011561871,
0.2650954425,
0.2944429815,
0.009475383,
0.2520048022,
0.8161244392,
0.0700217932,
1.1587479115,
0.5758125186,
-0.0975876749,
0.5232805014,
-0.0589222796,
0.3057300746,
-0.6631621122,
-0.2993764281,
-0.1456950605,
-0.445800513,
-0.33354792,
-0.4702588618,
0.3169184625,
-0.0803134441,
-0.2476714551,
0.1070131958,
-1.0120418072,
0.6242256761,
0.4220431745,
0.3082413375,
0.0540005378,
0.2659233809,
0.113709718,
-0.1892527044,
-0.4254214764,
-0.4996831119,
0.9208823442,
0.1646548361,
1.0807850361,
-0.0896024406,
0.5728872418,
0.011445459,
-0.149790138,
-0.91593647,
0.429582268,
-0.2621537745,
-0.203619048,
-0.4128723741,
-0.1430490166,
-0.5826212764,
0.0862850472,
-0.3397315443,
-0.7068935037,
0.1975018382,
0.4079113007,
-0.6463540792,
0.1551057547,
-0.6479747295,
0.9304805994,
-0.4702062011,
-0.7842977643,
-0.0986864567,
-0.712552309,
0.3121644855,
0.0559322461,
-0.283662796,
0.1921250671,
0.219577238,
0.3543353379,
-0.3612229526,
0.7276080847,
-0.1593118161,
-0.2542241514,
0.0028964637,
-0.0761221498,
0.5581155419,
0.0324652269,
0.0738872364,
0.0002229442,
-0.2159830034,
-0.159780547,
-0.5842514038,
0.8656359315,
-0.9761766195,
-0.8888010383,
-0.3972575366,
-0.6223551035,
-0.2797646821,
-0.0554424711,
0.5310485959,
0.5103862882,
0.0973611921,
0.0214476325,
0.9282230139,
-0.2716975808,
0.0530980118,
0.169320941,
-0.5656747818,
-0.4187286198,
1.0353722572,
-0.1045434177,
0.2629734278,
0.3964372873,
0.1383276135,
-0.3002849817,
-0.6011823416,
-0.4949326813,
0.2620212436,
-0.4573404491,
-0.1065974459,
-0.4250883162,
-0.2172503322,
-0.5089053512,
-0.3485020995,
-0.4789175093,
0.0511857793,
-0.4186121523,
-0.0855117813,
0.2968751788,
0.4222503603,
0.0385534018,
-0.0560552999,
-0.3832766116,
0.5763844848,
0.4070701599,
0.3823644221,
-0.2052327991,
-0.6492911577,
-0.1565635502,
0.0132716401,
-0.2125240564,
-0.6350528598,
0.3248077333,
0.0686314777,
0.2951202095,
0.6195585728,
0.192076996,
1.1483727694,
-0.5161910057,
0.8144919872,
0.2609508634,
-0.7746927738,
0.6927579641,
-0.1472283453,
0.1185682863,
0.6065140367,
0.2080927491,
-0.3177486658,
-0.4212579429,
-0.16672194,
-0.6919534206,
0.686486423,
-0.0248320103,
0.035429623,
0.11555361,
0.3941063583,
0.3246587217,
0.1354189068,
-0.4002622962,
-0.0293557085,
-0.5745608211,
-0.2767019272,
-0.0610714704,
-0.0262308829,
-0.2705726922,
-0.4841046035,
0.5702545643,
-0.2094482332,
0.1469226629,
0.3668613732,
-0.0781203806,
-0.3822963238,
-0.0946872979,
0.8668094873,
0.6981392503,
-0.3511711061,
0.3436283767,
-0.1886395663,
-0.4816322327,
0.1480497867,
-0.1873181462,
-0.235492155,
-0.1671454757,
0.0911098793,
1.1782816648,
-0.2963583469,
-0.6611366868,
0.5149103999,
-0.1311461627,
-0.3838330209,
-0.262966305,
0.2876523137,
-0.2577261627,
0.3998668492,
0.1526497155,
0.2402744442,
-0.0530949272,
-0.2751322985,
0.1644153744,
0.6182245612,
-0.4493075013,
-0.340162158,
0.7674030066,
0.1078368723,
-0.305488795,
0.6719058156,
-0.0373563245,
-0.4245567918,
0.4162311554,
0.3909208477,
0.9602248073,
-0.2177751511,
0.3251910806,
0.4133518934,
0.2193967998,
-0.3196577132,
0.1074675173,
0.0744454265,
-0.9794046283,
-0.4731850922,
-0.7663940787,
-0.24443461,
0.4800147116,
-0.7041174173,
0.52748698,
-0.3841567338,
-0.1481977105,
-0.0320339836,
-0.2567481101,
-0.518455565,
0.151612848,
0.4715282917,
0.2335188985,
-0.782800436,
0.9836809635,
0.772993505,
-0.4063866436,
-0.9512521029,
0.2834242284,
0.0050561819,
-0.7639870048,
0.3490868211,
0.2322304398,
-0.3446747959,
-0.0761108249,
-0.6275802851,
-0.5191261172,
0.7841535807,
0.6435807943,
-0.9068568945,
-0.0186429769,
-0.0982824638,
0.4994625151,
-0.5360239744,
-0.1186716184,
0.4735354781,
0.5401034951,
0.2412530035,
-0.854888618,
0.0417492464,
-0.1791951507,
-0.033211384,
0.3702906668,
-0.4674931765,
0.4975999892,
-0.4069183469,
-0.0680756867,
-0.0191178415,
0.5539206266,
0.0511368439,
0.1707853973,
0.5726630092,
0.6868889928,
0.7555853128,
0.0517561249,
0.7543280721,
-0.2764449418,
0.1284558326,
1.34290874,
-0.517843008,
0.7687870264,
0.9449756145,
0.1457122266,
-0.008395575,
0.7175592184,
-0.1419403404,
0.8030112982,
0.0229250006,
0.0426084846,
-0.5456407666,
-0.2204053104,
-0.589727819,
0.5011197329,
0.031681899,
-0.2780115306,
0.1809496731,
0.178989917,
-0.3776481152,
0.2005935162,
-0.3275659084,
0.8639053702,
-0.2673902512,
-1.0431578159,
0.8977190256,
-0.3216414452,
0.6374343038,
-0.4601128995,
-0.1063651666,
-0.3381400406,
0.3224785924,
-0.4474021792,
-0.5703434944,
0.3622754514,
-0.1136768237,
-0.3122250736,
0.018005874,
0.3619597554,
-0.6883867979,
-0.3813193142,
0.1032495275,
0.0714633018,
0.1277220845,
-0.0702103972,
-0.2225089818,
0.3538006842,
0.2895278335,
0.0019374643,
0.3468897939,
0.2039286196,
-0.1066012979,
0.1057688966,
0.3789814413,
0.2104822546,
0.0291441791,
0.2745079696,
0.8352341652,
-0.4512785375,
-0.1066454872,
-0.9945080876,
0.3695861697,
0.0717745423,
-0.3477708697,
0.4746927917,
0.4293139875,
0.9400869012,
-0.2374365628,
0.579176724,
0.0780463144,
-0.1031582654,
-0.7468907237,
0.4772765338,
-0.7582978606,
0.1738194525,
-0.2961474359,
-1.2684553862,
-0.4924788177,
0.9377866983,
-0.4236721098,
-0.2934885919,
0.632142067,
1.2709710598,
-0.1312184334,
-0.2031934857,
0.4779486358,
0.2080956697,
0.1607200056,
0.6944240928,
0.8562660217,
-0.1850809157,
0.2922304273,
-0.1911894977,
-0.266132921,
-0.3563381732,
-0.7512238026,
-0.77732265,
-0.7577930689,
-0.4386187494,
-0.3845921159,
0.0711444095,
1.132250309,
0.6971648335,
-0.8077764511,
-0.1200263575,
-0.1318760216,
-0.1184129044,
-0.2378853858,
-0.1771903932,
0.4591308832,
-0.4213766754,
-0.7959692478,
0.0887660608,
0.5530921817,
0.0841660574,
-0.4708653092,
-0.5215198994,
0.1630263031,
-0.1109331176,
0.4675720334,
-0.0073219794,
-1.1083596945,
-0.5853925943,
0.3318550289,
-0.1135866046,
0.3609159589,
0.7253853679,
-0.6299485564,
0.7653430104,
0.3556193709,
0.7915574908,
0.3639757633,
0.1440856904,
0.618755877,
-0.3237938583,
0.2133237571,
0.2913048267,
0.1814903021,
0.4827023149,
-0.5349909663,
0.3259542286,
-0.0443773717,
-0.7049217224,
-0.8501595259,
0.1914991587,
-1.1471947432,
-0.2630503178,
1.1772642136,
0.4073031843,
-0.3355686963,
0.2116038203,
-0.726914227,
0.090735279,
-0.2137945145,
0.9965432882,
0.7346470952,
-0.1283038855,
-0.1038498729,
-0.269441098,
0.7117355466,
0.6240293384,
-0.4402127266,
0.1601146907,
0.8983621597,
-0.0211671349,
0.2154878825,
0.480534941,
-0.1436103731,
0.3210033178,
-0.3380767107,
0.1164177433,
-0.0577253103,
-0.61838305,
-0.5284000039,
0.1372660697,
0.1932380497,
-0.4342702925
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11409v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11409v2
|
Multi-dimensional Evaluation of Empathetic Dialog Responses
| 2024-02-18T00:32:33 | 2024-04-16T16:34:02 |
Zhichao Xu, Jiepu Jiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Empathy is critical for effective and satisfactory conversational
communication. Prior efforts to measure conversational empathy mostly focus on
expressed communicative intents -- that is, the way empathy is expressed. Yet,
these works ignore the fact that conversation is also a collaboration involving
both speakers and listeners. In contrast, we propose a multi-dimensional
empathy evaluation framework to measure both expressed intents from the
speaker's perspective and perceived empathy from the listener's perspective. We
apply our proposed framework to analyze our internal customer-service dialogue.
We find the two dimensions (expressed intent types and perceived empathy) are
inter-connected, and perceived empathy has a high correlation with dialogue
satisfaction levels.
To reduce the annotation cost, we explore different options to automatically
measure conversational empathy: prompting LLMs and training language
model-based classifiers. Our experiments show that prompting methods with even
popular models like GPT-4 and Flan family models perform relatively poorly on
both public and our internal datasets. In contrast, instruction-finetuned
classifiers based on Flan-T5 family models outperform prior works and
competitive baselines. We conduct a detailed ablation study to give more
insights into instruction finetuning method's strong performance.
|
[
-0.6787382364,
-0.8878474236,
0.6465610266,
0.1887003332,
-0.0339223407,
-0.2056415677,
-0.127244398,
-0.2991299629,
0.1345691383,
0.3025139868,
-0.5147696137,
-0.349047184,
-0.6047834158,
0.2780439258,
0.0388901941,
0.6675816178,
0.0491234474,
0.4103048742,
-0.2181408852,
-0.2462721467,
-0.2266738862,
-0.5615532398,
-0.9580953717,
-0.4470950067,
0.5789477229,
0.6997379065,
0.309940964,
0.2289098352,
0.4207676947,
0.3782802224,
-0.0316198468,
0.260358423,
-0.2317499518,
-0.0611356609,
0.399669528,
-0.1567533016,
-0.7037500143,
0.1963326484,
0.191049397,
0.6396757364,
-0.2583875358,
0.1583807468,
0.2591850758,
0.4303720593,
-0.3232045174,
-0.0551951379,
-0.1382070929,
0.3256214559,
0.6285306811,
-0.3323836327,
-0.3987623155,
-0.4432440102,
0.4352526367,
-0.2887045443,
0.1094975621,
-0.0457764938,
0.2991052568,
0.0768559501,
-0.51845783,
-0.4436036348,
-0.5413078666,
0.7360873222,
-0.5573349595,
0.3322137296,
0.5606784225,
0.1295526028,
0.3592782021,
-0.2929663658,
-0.4153796136,
-0.3517272472,
-0.0801559314,
0.5012472868,
-0.2670055926,
0.3684725761,
0.4373781979,
0.4766660929,
-0.3271273375,
0.1551769972,
-0.0423152596,
0.1560430825,
0.4902947247,
0.4730295837,
0.2670918107,
-0.0151499622,
-0.4379419982,
-0.1020748615,
0.0667000264,
0.2748591602,
0.497915566,
0.2359498888,
-0.6031472087,
0.6133636832,
0.1251514256,
0.4521601796,
0.3473369181,
0.0635629147,
0.0950659662,
-0.0990311652,
-0.2723919153,
0.0809017941,
0.6182373762,
1.0351250172,
0.5236681104,
0.1267541796,
0.1944609582,
0.1001759693,
0.4037540257,
-0.9787445068,
0.0065144715,
0.4912164807,
-0.7276613116,
-0.1868799031,
-0.0856778473,
-1.1080356836,
-0.4620207548,
-0.5151907206,
0.0442960486,
-0.388281554,
-0.3762972951,
-0.0874887258,
-0.2610164583,
0.2396098822,
0.2684421539,
-0.8789800406,
0.381264478,
0.6167107821,
0.9498672485,
0.1718247086,
-0.3516482711,
-0.6181704402,
-0.1300641596,
-0.0268635377,
0.9217181206,
-0.8306412697,
-0.5250859261,
0.0752273351,
-0.2582892478,
-0.1031826437,
-0.339230001,
0.6093395352,
0.1841130406,
0.2087217271,
-0.2878190279,
-0.663715601,
-0.1314525455,
0.6115983725,
-0.2833894193,
0.4275528789,
0.4346986711,
-0.6583464742,
0.3152394593,
-0.892653048,
-0.2251672447,
-0.2871085107,
0.012222846,
-0.3582834303,
0.3317941427,
0.3101785481,
0.6160989404,
-0.2118716538,
-0.220194906,
-0.5175579786,
-0.2820426524,
0.2746918797,
-0.5659781694,
0.4055888355,
0.1293952316,
-0.116071254,
0.0930215046,
-0.5697584152,
-0.0127605945,
-0.0609062351,
-0.1787889004,
-0.3110821843,
-0.4238940775,
-0.1297571659,
0.2352775186,
-0.0070418455,
-0.7432535291,
0.1626836658,
-0.5684319139,
0.1949314922,
0.7269856334,
0.2683253288,
0.5977483988,
-0.3013063371,
0.6924093962,
0.2204101682,
0.5876402855,
-0.370714426,
-0.4744769335,
-0.6981062293,
-0.5104290247,
-0.4986303449,
0.4227539003,
-0.0985589921,
0.4999279976,
0.0175260529,
-0.5379648209,
-0.6479381323,
-0.1859643161,
0.561483562,
0.4207628369,
0.3355691433,
-0.4346902668,
-0.1999418885,
-0.9354319572,
-0.4025070369,
0.0135264248,
-0.0254167654,
0.7219226956,
-0.0748279914,
-0.2045443058,
0.5666181445,
-0.3032234311,
-0.351772815,
-0.2579773068,
0.2976962626,
-0.0897359699,
0.2472186834,
0.468149215,
-0.4463671446,
-0.735852778,
0.2387263477,
-0.561424017,
-0.1268376708,
-0.117226027,
0.1061628908,
0.310895443,
0.1291736066,
-0.5097107291,
0.6029817462,
0.6455352306,
-0.4816167057,
0.0457887687,
-0.2497465611,
0.7140613794,
-0.9843433499,
-0.1723558009,
0.1679428667,
0.3704413474,
-0.932506144,
-0.6111323833,
-0.1087594479,
0.0166282058,
-0.4055595398,
0.6822578907,
-0.1721873581,
-0.1547109485,
0.0706993192,
0.2484704852,
0.1111152172,
0.5860178471,
-0.010133828,
0.4525260329,
0.412571013,
-0.4567765296,
0.5418324471,
0.5971192718,
-0.0952125639,
1.1075628996,
-0.532269001,
0.1991723329,
-0.0132648582,
0.2063517123,
-0.969050467,
-0.2049126923,
0.4639866352,
-0.5070358515,
0.0600691959,
-0.1103880331,
-0.1152375564,
-0.2890836,
-0.2635359466,
0.3011709452,
0.3933695555,
-0.7218872309,
0.9218578339,
-0.0007442516,
-0.3043045998,
-0.1745363027,
-0.7165622115,
-0.0539088137,
-0.4855303764,
-0.6554294825,
-0.3269042373,
-0.3483691216,
-0.4651755095,
-0.553229332,
0.1253436059,
-0.2152888626,
-0.1004861891,
0.3578226566,
-0.0680021122,
0.0106490497,
-0.1201343983,
0.178476125,
-0.3537865281,
0.3438502848,
0.3830896914,
0.6080333591,
-0.2440534085,
-0.6422725916,
-1.0768381357,
0.54382658,
0.5795676708,
-0.1516440362,
0.5612896681,
0.7036401033,
-0.0189734586,
0.2183265984,
-0.6953788996,
-0.5406800508,
-0.373313278,
0.0335858464,
-0.414329201,
-0.6691150069,
0.5481222868,
-0.0914125144,
0.0567083731,
-0.2404006571,
0.5790477991,
0.1757029593,
1.4959652424,
0.1967936158,
0.0735302418,
0.4544770122,
-0.1877526045,
0.8022698164,
-1.0256464481,
-0.2406495363,
-0.4555748403,
-0.1737480611,
-0.3667326272,
0.0129465945,
0.3096697927,
-0.2475796938,
-0.343301475,
-0.0717769861,
-0.4708074033,
0.148319602,
0.3469833136,
0.2444669008,
0.1184011102,
0.003705977,
0.0176042933,
-0.1206592545,
-0.4378471971,
-0.6279475093,
0.7955578566,
0.6904689074,
0.4890169203,
0.0806547254,
0.758736074,
-0.11199788,
0.6891738176,
-1.0228666067,
0.3120400012,
0.0364880934,
-0.1777580976,
-0.3431761265,
-0.4831666648,
-0.7942785621,
0.2862935066,
0.0676239654,
-0.8898035288,
0.073708795,
0.2657426596,
-0.5687599778,
0.1465168595,
-1.2149478197,
0.8142032623,
-0.3412365019,
-0.2162668109,
-0.2327121645,
-0.398491472,
0.0978771374,
0.0447585061,
0.3036725223,
-0.1400397569,
0.2132211477,
0.2203456163,
-0.1785850972,
0.9521419406,
-0.4220758975,
-0.2229226828,
0.0591514111,
0.2151071727,
0.2035607696,
0.0565798394,
-0.1681089103,
0.2976149321,
-0.0224450901,
-0.1780493706,
-0.8186240196,
0.5898340344,
-0.6282749772,
-0.3514628112,
-0.2058265209,
-0.4280600846,
-0.3908974528,
-0.1108670831,
0.1430742443,
0.564257741,
-0.4639038742,
0.1033140868,
0.3877753615,
-0.461394161,
0.1678694338,
0.3125938475,
0.0682446808,
-0.3650816977,
0.6526651978,
-0.2447472215,
0.4895442724,
0.169833824,
0.6020188928,
-0.1327856332,
-0.0291084945,
-0.2739694715,
0.141803056,
-0.6597734094,
-0.1643416435,
-0.8095499277,
0.0699879602,
-0.4744080007,
-0.5498188734,
-0.2548080683,
-0.0112800794,
-0.3331065178,
-0.2426777482,
0.4119220972,
0.8265916109,
-0.2478122711,
0.2835671604,
-0.9665092826,
0.1640642881,
0.2445348948,
0.5682432055,
0.2659038007,
-0.4435782433,
-0.0909158587,
0.3116267622,
-0.3389018774,
-0.553841114,
0.493322432,
0.0406919494,
0.3694461584,
0.7839980125,
-0.0311986972,
0.7583605647,
-0.3004872203,
0.8855720162,
0.4373109937,
-1.0013014078,
0.3378739357,
-0.3050542772,
0.1955490708,
0.3132781386,
0.2434979677,
-0.5229036808,
-0.4341574609,
-0.7417401671,
-0.6454969049,
0.7562896013,
-0.0291077979,
0.4752162397,
-0.2741410732,
0.2037364542,
0.1119243801,
-0.1137583181,
-0.2076160014,
-0.2559350729,
-0.2455204129,
-0.3801881373,
-0.193749398,
-0.4764026403,
-0.4050001204,
-0.1621828079,
0.0336121805,
-0.1606335789,
0.532784462,
0.2521249652,
0.3626728654,
-0.4576372206,
0.155546084,
0.6469179392,
0.3234421611,
-0.1098058671,
-0.104776755,
0.450070411,
-0.1861771792,
-0.2002585381,
-0.1346189082,
0.733997345,
-0.2880806923,
0.4416020215,
0.6329481006,
0.2325584143,
-0.4137760699,
0.8341578841,
-0.4254689217,
-0.2777000666,
-0.3715366721,
-0.1040765047,
-0.0459011421,
0.5658903718,
-0.2598908842,
-0.1503200233,
0.3110138476,
-0.2700911462,
0.0737366527,
0.2830021977,
-0.5226916671,
-0.24723804,
0.0600267164,
0.4101959765,
-0.5999379158,
0.8062982559,
0.3246248364,
-0.5230597258,
0.5250195861,
0.2839926779,
0.9524327517,
-0.6111993194,
0.2565308809,
0.3924081326,
-0.0231948365,
0.2613448501,
0.268571794,
-0.2748608589,
-0.7613188028,
0.166365087,
-0.2650212348,
-0.6106552482,
-0.1618177295,
-1.2181675434,
-0.0889871195,
-0.3762995899,
-0.1888170242,
-0.030127693,
-0.1269381046,
-0.8753033876,
0.106322825,
-0.0484399721,
0.7498550415,
-0.8848909736,
0.2078173608,
0.4228415489,
-0.4366784394,
-0.6717754602,
0.0304316171,
0.1608282775,
-0.8767405748,
0.6009020805,
0.5466308594,
-0.3557773232,
0.0251005534,
-0.3039814532,
-0.3561291695,
0.9875110388,
0.0848165154,
-0.3193009794,
0.2506957054,
0.223909542,
0.6736087799,
-0.6865572929,
0.6792110205,
0.732655406,
0.7343331575,
-0.0972652361,
-0.7859176993,
-0.2604403198,
-0.1828988343,
-0.1239678934,
0.037512403,
-0.8272376657,
0.4225832522,
-0.1674038619,
-0.0527261756,
0.2462343723,
0.0600777678,
0.1934321374,
0.6631842852,
0.5493525267,
0.4625762105,
0.396317184,
-0.0505459718,
1.2163158655,
-0.3653130829,
0.1400758624,
0.8364366293,
-0.3842735589,
0.7013447285,
0.7377041578,
0.1151090264,
0.0932007656,
0.5222001672,
0.0687821582,
0.0936686024,
-0.014656282,
-0.3057190776,
-0.1191390008,
-0.4443753362,
-0.0865851641,
0.6047471166,
0.4625994265,
-0.4590706825,
-0.0102893878,
0.2401859164,
0.0370644517,
0.0465048589,
-0.1278176755,
1.0890674591,
0.3158704638,
-0.6164513826,
0.3314649761,
-0.4062571526,
0.2948183119,
-0.2353714108,
-0.2309689969,
-0.5109531879,
0.2166072726,
-0.3294714093,
-0.8246196508,
0.1955499053,
0.22971645,
0.1202660054,
-0.5196563005,
0.1218046546,
-0.4062692821,
-0.0956815407,
0.6683955193,
0.3552425206,
0.3260803521,
0.0833547786,
-0.7594914436,
0.3227884769,
-0.1483151764,
-0.7194807529,
0.25291875,
0.6269163489,
0.4745765924,
0.6242162585,
0.4638906419,
-0.1805741787,
-0.1950143874,
0.7441610694,
0.7153853774,
-0.373136282,
-0.1817036271,
-0.5977213979,
0.7249364853,
-0.1663284749,
-0.4570211172,
0.7280263901,
0.215318352,
0.6860411763,
0.025144821,
0.6867980957,
0.3169320524,
0.6544362903,
-0.4659042358,
0.2598701119,
-0.5328761339,
0.0176665746,
-0.3524236977,
-0.9682363868,
-0.4085927606,
0.8983050585,
-0.4722597003,
0.4467715621,
0.6452439427,
0.7297776937,
-0.0474806875,
0.3970160186,
0.6803015471,
0.1644687653,
0.3536717296,
0.3742108345,
1.2015672922,
-0.0161585081,
0.1523387432,
-0.3643083572,
-0.4881614447,
-0.2968367934,
-0.7147924304,
-1.1030972004,
-0.520565629,
-0.0864704698,
-0.2735120952,
-0.3497431874,
1.1266520023,
0.3435628712,
-0.4247528911,
-0.261131376,
0.0899819061,
-0.3470320702,
-0.0710136145,
-0.239675805,
0.2715273201,
-0.2930386961,
-0.8957836032,
0.1960866749,
0.4878771901,
0.1797718406,
-0.2006804794,
-0.3225586712,
0.2636402547,
0.1523326784,
0.792216301,
-0.1765111834,
-0.7404431701,
-0.5381573439,
0.0426127203,
0.1288345307,
0.2372210026,
0.9666262865,
0.0077394499,
0.6257844567,
0.1210348085,
0.5102987289,
0.0494384468,
0.3136352897,
0.604264617,
-0.3920880556,
0.0491936989,
0.2790934145,
0.2691573799,
0.3567999899,
-0.5980672836,
0.2345572263,
-0.3781212866,
-0.7757685184,
-0.7016735673,
0.4759686887,
-0.9288890958,
0.0599777624,
1.1908271313,
-0.3939047754,
0.1561034173,
-0.1606716514,
-0.5705437064,
0.2435866594,
-0.6872243285,
0.8128664494,
0.586689055,
-0.729729414,
-0.4522241056,
-0.3608573079,
0.3785513341,
0.2154233009,
-0.7668600082,
0.2201417238,
0.6866741776,
-0.1022545323,
0.0775180161,
0.4884780645,
0.0816942826,
0.0540112518,
0.0792952999,
0.1028976664,
0.0915599987,
-0.2872174978,
-0.6479044557,
-0.0551735051,
0.0277101379,
0.0838783458
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11406v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11406v2
|
Don't Go To Extremes: Revealing the Excessive Sensitivity and Calibration Limitations of LLMs in Implicit Hate Speech Detection
| 2024-02-18T00:04:40 | 2024-02-26T16:43:37 |
Min Zhang, Jianfeng He, Taoran Ji, Chang-Tien Lu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The fairness and trustworthiness of Large Language Models (LLMs) are
receiving increasing attention. Implicit hate speech, which employs indirect
language to convey hateful intentions, occupies a significant portion of
practice. However, the extent to which LLMs effectively address this issue
remains insufficiently examined. This paper delves into the capability of LLMs
to detect implicit hate speech (Classification Task) and express confidence in
their responses (Calibration Task). Our evaluation meticulously considers
various prompt patterns and mainstream uncertainty estimation methods. Our
findings highlight that LLMs exhibit two extremes: (1) LLMs display excessive
sensitivity towards groups or topics that may cause fairness issues, resulting
in misclassifying benign statements as hate speech. (2) LLMs' confidence scores
for each method excessively concentrate on a fixed range, remaining unchanged
regardless of the dataset's complexity. Consequently, the calibration
performance is heavily reliant on primary classification accuracy. These
discoveries unveil new limitations of LLMs, underscoring the need for caution
when optimizing models to ensure they do not veer towards extremes. This serves
as a reminder to carefully consider sensitivity and confidence in the pursuit
of model fairness.
|
[
-0.4550137818,
-0.6736880541,
0.7093465924,
-0.1352032721,
0.0494841039,
-0.0719773918,
-0.2254105806,
-0.5039008856,
-0.540288806,
0.458834976,
-0.5203184485,
-0.5652703643,
-1.0333306789,
-0.0620977767,
-0.4177303016,
1.2227752209,
0.1732450724,
0.1192363501,
0.0159165766,
-0.2453612983,
-0.0371631011,
-0.4960277677,
-0.5393304229,
-0.1856022626,
0.5459055901,
0.4313175082,
0.9180518985,
0.4740768075,
0.2098407447,
0.2165984362,
-0.0750121772,
0.0114015816,
-0.8224973679,
0.4337553084,
-0.149853915,
-0.7061035037,
-0.1670961678,
0.1495382339,
0.6136308312,
0.431414932,
0.1255732328,
0.1971603185,
0.0485517792,
0.4487313926,
-0.8204143047,
-0.2656258345,
-0.8383933902,
-0.0444955267,
-0.2912156284,
0.0194252878,
-0.3928187191,
-0.3333485126,
-0.0041726436,
-0.2628624141,
0.1164682135,
0.1927189678,
0.207491979,
0.4273865223,
-0.4877101779,
-0.3582832217,
-0.7967579365,
1.1226096153,
-0.4815906584,
0.2180562168,
0.4657716155,
0.2029996365,
-0.1184102893,
-0.2270122617,
-0.640348196,
-0.416100651,
0.3863309622,
-0.133104831,
-0.5629295707,
0.2141210288,
0.5127280951,
0.2246744186,
-0.3836192787,
0.6336476207,
-0.1513825059,
-0.3291422725,
0.6392925382,
0.3203840852,
-0.0254524797,
0.0209936257,
-0.3892834187,
0.0078099626,
-0.6460697651,
0.1453593224,
0.7056609392,
0.40430969,
0.1181216463,
0.6704497933,
0.0787794217,
0.5655990243,
-0.0207050983,
-0.0959433764,
-0.0787816718,
0.3004741967,
-0.2023935467,
-0.0260799788,
0.6195248365,
0.7077810764,
0.3699449003,
-0.131467551,
-0.282099247,
0.4144830406,
0.2796004415,
-0.5333025455,
0.2137442082,
0.1809792519,
-0.0219344441,
-0.4428953528,
-0.5623921752,
-0.731549263,
-0.8175513148,
-0.2772448361,
0.3514604568,
-0.2714208961,
-0.1276343316,
-0.2861049175,
0.0194720943,
0.2161151767,
0.2819929123,
-0.4239756167,
0.4575788975,
0.653671205,
0.6342598796,
-0.3976067603,
0.075666666,
-0.5854718685,
0.0072759623,
-0.3069422543,
0.4254735708,
-0.609008193,
-0.4579141736,
-0.0445597172,
-0.3016154766,
0.1549171358,
-0.4175974131,
1.0088620186,
-0.4654945135,
-0.1943167746,
-0.1577525884,
-0.4876039326,
-0.3995723426,
0.176559329,
-0.294215858,
0.9129004478,
0.0774780139,
-0.5890467763,
0.1822070479,
-0.2024596035,
-0.1884873658,
0.0217300449,
-0.3122518957,
-0.3117467165,
0.2794747353,
-0.1278208792,
0.3800690472,
-0.3359550536,
0.2781426311,
-0.7081404328,
-0.4238477051,
0.3705919087,
-0.7391708493,
0.6653518081,
0.2223536521,
-0.6985378265,
-0.0349189863,
-0.5397804976,
-0.0892554298,
-0.0821253732,
0.042025324,
-0.3856685162,
0.0326344073,
0.1924936622,
0.3758666813,
0.0141733922,
-0.628187716,
-0.5886961818,
-0.2999945581,
0.2093770206,
1.4532535076,
-0.5071709752,
0.3684154451,
-0.7686542869,
0.6927155256,
-0.0670646578,
0.1805626303,
0.4876286983,
-0.5478523374,
-0.7156246305,
0.0066152457,
-0.302321583,
0.6399028301,
-0.2471864372,
0.390832752,
-0.2102432698,
-0.6039823294,
-0.2376592159,
0.1181484088,
0.4810806811,
0.7359078526,
0.2395902276,
0.0569423549,
-0.5215367675,
-0.9491550922,
-0.5655184984,
-0.2378497273,
0.0819663182,
0.5652993321,
0.511097908,
0.0515439399,
0.8317677975,
-0.1489982307,
-0.14196302,
0.0779013634,
0.0582611337,
-0.0427545458,
0.32108742,
0.5437434316,
-1.1297805309,
-0.4521118402,
-0.4333932996,
-0.2328683883,
-0.2385970503,
0.3999941945,
-0.0278561059,
0.3738247454,
0.3549515009,
-0.0396151021,
0.6052120924,
0.6534923911,
-0.106941849,
0.4430873692,
0.3696906269,
0.1005560309,
-0.5273873806,
-0.0908000246,
0.259840399,
-0.3820990622,
-0.7401841283,
-0.0440367647,
-0.1776625514,
0.3187614083,
-0.5526775122,
0.4718572199,
0.0583068803,
0.227788955,
-0.3787270784,
0.1170676872,
-0.3522611558,
0.2241913825,
-0.0034336224,
0.5643760562,
0.5078083873,
-0.7148007751,
0.430119127,
-0.2613292038,
-0.2085688561,
1.0577296019,
-0.1852128506,
0.1861265749,
-0.3532953262,
0.1242149398,
-1.3130533695,
-0.0939310119,
0.4637412429,
-0.4977345169,
0.1577148288,
-0.1498848945,
-0.2094652504,
-0.3611201346,
-0.5822802782,
0.3534524739,
0.6447070241,
-0.3087331653,
0.7393379807,
0.6160344481,
-0.0606034845,
-0.9841308594,
-0.8810042739,
-0.0320521705,
-0.4885233343,
-0.4465690553,
0.1458863169,
-0.3455898762,
-0.5399247408,
-0.3696281612,
-0.3581455946,
-0.0602394789,
0.0542970896,
0.8315517306,
0.1148834452,
0.1297016144,
0.0388974659,
-0.036012385,
0.1022351533,
0.3299832642,
-0.0035026495,
0.325327009,
-0.0948344991,
-0.308003217,
-0.0914275199,
0.4522052407,
0.5978259444,
0.5299245119,
0.4986136258,
0.624587357,
-0.5422915816,
-0.2208592147,
-0.9543156028,
-0.0319989771,
-0.4895262122,
0.4281715453,
-0.2945262194,
-1.1156483889,
0.5196674466,
0.1790336818,
0.0868909582,
0.4243444204,
0.5336800218,
0.0434675589,
1.1862485409,
0.674980402,
-0.2062040269,
0.2438855767,
0.3469512761,
0.1886404753,
-0.8146375418,
-0.2259169072,
-0.87606287,
-0.206855461,
-0.8029279709,
-0.4222643375,
0.5334561467,
-0.3678356707,
-0.5209750533,
-0.2053450644,
-0.4006909132,
0.5216107965,
0.2851997614,
0.375010699,
0.2247142941,
0.0992605463,
0.1577747762,
-0.5229454637,
-0.3985687792,
-0.568134129,
1.3258277178,
0.5334467888,
0.9264068604,
0.1357824206,
0.2185128927,
0.382009089,
0.5985098481,
-1.0381547213,
0.6491251588,
-0.2302680314,
-0.8752002716,
-0.3334905803,
-0.4984706938,
-0.4055355489,
-0.0173899084,
0.108195819,
-0.7496230602,
0.1827879399,
0.0774217024,
-0.4032731056,
0.5456811786,
-0.309017241,
0.2824138701,
-0.2193246931,
-0.4784123302,
-0.0439585932,
-0.6873295903,
0.4064377844,
-0.277507633,
0.6032996178,
-0.4995250404,
-0.5157260299,
0.8602015376,
0.0208363924,
1.041795373,
-0.1533408165,
-0.3909974694,
0.1254377216,
0.3073963225,
0.572262764,
-0.1980957836,
-0.4251224995,
0.1469999552,
-0.4569659233,
-0.33198753,
-0.1895366162,
0.8697676659,
-0.6603844762,
-0.6959463954,
-0.546795547,
-0.7862218618,
-0.46713534,
0.0442896709,
0.4593521357,
0.0038598233,
-0.2032850832,
-0.0772590041,
0.9014489651,
-0.2112212628,
0.1868111938,
0.5806255937,
0.0059809703,
-0.1784966588,
0.6303690672,
0.397641927,
0.5044652224,
0.0086301835,
0.0753039196,
-0.5201869607,
-0.7151542902,
-0.225898549,
-0.0264546163,
-0.9654051661,
-0.1587579101,
-0.6752941012,
-0.1194885895,
-0.6783187389,
-0.2699142694,
-0.1770996898,
-0.2625798881,
-0.2176145613,
-0.1092708781,
0.558006525,
0.7402107716,
-0.4238424897,
0.2776268423,
-0.2188662589,
0.2820038795,
0.3509105146,
0.1893316656,
-0.2918800116,
-1.1965495348,
0.2854346037,
0.1527365893,
-0.1378821582,
-0.8898844123,
0.3364701867,
-0.015306402,
0.5861162543,
0.3176898062,
0.4606497884,
0.5009410381,
-0.2753306925,
0.6341994405,
0.068655245,
-0.8674078584,
0.3710818589,
-0.3002548516,
-0.0981985033,
0.5310950279,
1.0016802549,
-0.4089316726,
-0.7433206439,
-0.4099753797,
-0.8213551044,
0.8739988804,
-0.0559488758,
0.4403680265,
0.1776114255,
0.3027442396,
0.1487023681,
0.1689667702,
-1.0278582573,
-0.7297622561,
0.0711805746,
-0.0572417565,
-0.3034416139,
-0.6048538685,
-0.5982129574,
-0.1755767167,
0.605148077,
0.0057463832,
-0.018456025,
-0.0353341848,
-0.176243186,
-0.3820019066,
0.3512079716,
0.6131317019,
0.5408630371,
-0.1712631583,
0.2922632098,
0.4001366794,
-0.5414638519,
0.2826133072,
0.0767121688,
-0.1514324546,
-0.1282385588,
-0.1117876992,
0.6748015285,
0.0495434105,
-0.7525444031,
0.7641429901,
0.0436268151,
-0.0767082497,
-0.524078846,
0.2317718118,
-0.3846356273,
0.1752694994,
0.3834212124,
0.1646493077,
0.3499538302,
-0.2233946472,
0.0708202869,
0.5833517909,
-0.5455535054,
0.0636070445,
0.6178230643,
-0.0501029864,
-0.1133976653,
0.4742515385,
-0.0266597774,
-0.6123961806,
0.5367115736,
0.57310462,
0.6892834306,
-0.5395256877,
0.1249891967,
0.2170569748,
0.4874871075,
0.228989616,
0.136280641,
-0.0623326376,
-0.7983828187,
-0.2825844586,
-0.6170474291,
-0.7218519449,
0.2770682275,
-0.7160903215,
0.1148917675,
-0.6522262096,
-0.2954404652,
-0.0311864447,
-0.0873623341,
-0.528975904,
0.2597557604,
0.7063477039,
0.7436048985,
-1.0633710623,
0.3004355729,
0.2742830515,
0.2332293987,
-0.5062545538,
-0.1901610047,
0.4823276997,
-1.1853585243,
0.5354138017,
0.3719150722,
-0.4679133296,
-0.0227644052,
-0.946344316,
-0.4562133849,
0.5509607196,
0.5685140491,
-0.6178099513,
0.0025690794,
0.3528853357,
0.3363621831,
-0.3059098423,
0.448045373,
0.7481095791,
0.6883006692,
0.2427359074,
-0.8411900401,
0.2148311734,
0.0799665898,
0.0797875822,
-0.1764136404,
-0.4805119038,
0.8796107173,
-0.1903496385,
-0.1513936669,
0.0195474643,
0.2368222028,
0.2654154599,
0.3963112831,
0.6706750393,
0.5269269347,
0.6997452974,
-0.0971972272,
1.0642998219,
0.1408543587,
-0.0172604714,
1.1168079376,
-0.3108719289,
0.5209534168,
0.352127254,
-0.1765730679,
0.2004833072,
0.5453994274,
0.1981841773,
0.1863650382,
0.4416761398,
-0.7891465425,
-0.534547627,
-0.5112697482,
-0.3578401804,
0.3329776227,
0.7317047119,
-0.3373757005,
-0.3134352267,
0.2556374371,
0.3395917416,
0.2127139717,
-0.6634112597,
0.3908554614,
0.2181502134,
-0.433316797,
0.4662615061,
0.1035347357,
1.1117726564,
-0.366917491,
0.3368550539,
0.2118013203,
0.0176745374,
-0.3118644655,
-0.9106454253,
0.2219124734,
0.2043240368,
-0.0926092789,
-0.1324367076,
0.5835463405,
-0.0857959986,
-0.1782935858,
0.4009380639,
0.224448815,
0.2668620348,
-0.3541671634,
-0.8540685177,
0.2505424321,
0.0705284253,
-0.4113064706,
0.337085098,
0.3176423013,
0.0786179453,
0.7014650106,
0.6051158905,
0.076423429,
0.3297854364,
-0.1418245435,
0.8389344811,
-0.4562734962,
-0.1369793266,
-1.0468776226,
0.3067722917,
0.071347177,
-0.3258216679,
0.7082499266,
0.3955875635,
0.8563250899,
0.3984525204,
0.8492153883,
0.1167733669,
0.7101719379,
-0.2551046014,
0.3535915017,
-0.3169930875,
0.1787463576,
-0.1861554831,
-0.7503120899,
-0.569396019,
0.5676112771,
-0.8125171661,
0.3530705571,
0.3452991247,
1.0864156485,
0.2492904961,
0.1176770627,
0.5701251626,
0.48627159,
0.2942768931,
0.7073415518,
0.8988981843,
-0.2086070031,
0.7367416024,
-0.4515027404,
-0.5167751908,
-0.1997638643,
-0.8873468637,
-0.5788843036,
-0.2412330508,
-0.2219270766,
-0.6891186237,
-0.0042887852,
0.7484614253,
0.677703023,
-0.7923454046,
-0.1580958664,
-0.0287125725,
0.2387906611,
0.2428784668,
-0.2625690103,
-0.0942011848,
-0.1201931387,
-1.0812032223,
0.1735440642,
0.2043323219,
0.2061002105,
-0.176549539,
-0.182117939,
0.0066996939,
0.1205163226,
0.377163887,
0.3541198075,
-0.7470521927,
-0.277582258,
-0.1888270825,
-0.3795638084,
-0.0720845014,
0.4277974665,
-0.5936639309,
0.3820084333,
0.1429247558,
0.449642241,
0.1764325649,
-0.2067402601,
0.3927251101,
-0.5235640407,
0.1618736535,
0.8114570379,
0.0256959815,
0.1933473945,
-0.5074013472,
0.2858173847,
0.1550528556,
-0.6850559711,
-1.1928895712,
0.4336709976,
-0.8760051727,
-0.1245879829,
1.2391257286,
-0.0728680268,
-0.2595715225,
-0.4304742515,
-0.1292106062,
0.0815175772,
-0.5204458833,
0.3719043732,
0.6842213869,
-0.2452734709,
0.0111643458,
-0.7191690207,
0.5562486649,
0.6665632129,
-0.1323368996,
0.2272969931,
0.6846697927,
0.3903442621,
0.0665100589,
0.5486550927,
-0.1161943823,
0.2895410359,
-0.1242435202,
-0.243820563,
-0.0107716313,
-0.1361931711,
-0.7099949121,
0.1799438298,
0.1500540823,
0.1184076518
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11399v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11399v2
|
k-SemStamp: A Clustering-Based Semantic Watermark for Detection of Machine-Generated Text
| 2024-02-17T22:50:38 | 2024-06-08T04:24:27 |
Abe Bohan Hou, Jingyu Zhang, Yichen Wang, Daniel Khashabi, Tianxing He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Recent watermarked generation algorithms inject detectable signatures during
language generation to facilitate post-hoc detection. While token-level
watermarks are vulnerable to paraphrase attacks, SemStamp (Hou et al., 2023)
applies watermark on the semantic representation of sentences and demonstrates
promising robustness. SemStamp employs locality-sensitive hashing (LSH) to
partition the semantic space with arbitrary hyperplanes, which results in a
suboptimal tradeoff between robustness and speed. We propose k-SemStamp, a
simple yet effective enhancement of SemStamp, utilizing k-means clustering as
an alternative of LSH to partition the embedding space with awareness of
inherent semantic structure. Experimental results indicate that k-SemStamp
saliently improves its robustness and sampling efficiency while preserving the
generation quality, advancing a more effective tool for machine-generated text
detection.
|
[
-0.4153085053,
-0.7837381363,
0.7013353705,
0.0387799442,
-0.7785272002,
0.0616308562,
0.0627969578,
-0.3026840985,
0.4278922677,
0.7189936638,
-0.4619879127,
-0.6506332159,
-0.9518502951,
0.047362823,
-0.6505172253,
0.8404121399,
0.2329069376,
-0.4222887754,
-0.3587094843,
-0.143024981,
-0.299539417,
-0.5578813553,
-0.2692858279,
0.014560583,
0.4344530404,
0.3021454513,
0.5409253836,
0.8439727426,
0.5969168544,
0.2976748049,
-0.1486678272,
0.200013563,
-0.0545679368,
0.7790361047,
-0.1001966968,
-0.12922813,
0.0756963119,
-0.3014554977,
0.750205338,
0.3549589515,
0.283231914,
0.0485943258,
0.0957375616,
0.6764392853,
-1.163656354,
-0.0311567355,
-0.99804914,
-0.1091043726,
-0.5037934184,
-0.4184730351,
-0.2976604998,
-0.0658379719,
-0.1900783628,
-0.2920638919,
0.1036494076,
-0.0246873219,
0.9427294731,
0.5946099162,
-0.3693236709,
-0.34424752,
-0.3319272399,
0.7484601736,
-0.7858195901,
0.2258318216,
0.4279919863,
0.3569553494,
-0.2501451075,
-0.8488782644,
-0.5494481921,
0.2939882874,
0.0209303088,
0.0118131358,
-0.0417981297,
-0.2978872657,
0.2498706728,
0.1896374822,
-0.4741875827,
-0.1723208129,
0.1325969845,
-0.5121289492,
0.2966017127,
0.1032133475,
0.5769308805,
-0.3310366273,
-0.5070554614,
-0.146805793,
-0.669909358,
-0.1798517853,
0.2399735749,
0.4308379292,
0.2728653252,
0.501309514,
-0.5779520273,
0.5359587073,
-0.2481217682,
0.0040639755,
0.0449522771,
-0.1584479809,
-0.0872312188,
0.0923682749,
0.6589322686,
0.4878591895,
-0.1631436348,
-0.086151883,
-0.0375283435,
0.5347037315,
0.0549981892,
-1.0910781622,
-0.0142890839,
0.0729720891,
-0.3788726926,
-0.5502681136,
0.2610875368,
-0.8371547461,
-0.6089083552,
-0.1771887541,
0.6284982562,
-0.2568078339,
-0.0611846633,
0.1202599704,
-0.5401527286,
0.1756439358,
-0.0648975968,
-0.757350266,
0.3320582807,
0.8082590699,
0.6558961272,
-0.558411777,
-0.2286070287,
-0.7138326764,
0.5164731741,
-0.1949922144,
1.3461822271,
-0.7525901198,
-0.3465055227,
-0.050009571,
0.0835426748,
0.2029984593,
-0.7095893025,
0.4175599217,
-0.5930332541,
0.1635271758,
-0.4564400017,
-0.7311784029,
0.2478510141,
0.2039338946,
-0.5600206852,
1.1792709827,
0.0908147991,
-1.0622957945,
0.8265774846,
-0.5277303457,
-0.4850346148,
0.2429594845,
-0.1361662745,
-0.7444941998,
-0.0899059996,
0.4233552516,
0.6086288691,
0.1370446384,
0.1478420794,
-0.4562326372,
-0.2297250032,
0.2148739845,
-0.1357278079,
0.4726585448,
0.2494241446,
-0.4323886633,
0.0550949387,
-0.8488676548,
0.4934463203,
0.1764916629,
-0.4430539906,
-0.6698919535,
-0.0998075604,
0.1204401478,
0.3454770446,
0.4006479383,
-0.5623962879,
-0.3798867166,
-0.2504200339,
0.4535611868,
0.7861005664,
0.4868698418,
0.3660663068,
-0.1919480115,
0.287723273,
0.2789568901,
-0.0714140981,
-0.2564709187,
-0.4932536185,
-0.7893565297,
-0.4282143414,
0.5369522572,
0.3299623728,
-0.9068596959,
0.6828576326,
-0.2148823589,
-0.6116778851,
-0.2658188939,
0.0398104116,
0.1072460413,
0.2714942992,
0.4541995525,
-0.1477373391,
-0.4485191405,
-0.9547896981,
-0.8173046708,
0.1373559982,
-0.0648291707,
0.0637843236,
0.6760644317,
-0.2497183233,
0.8381611705,
-0.6181820631,
0.0317837261,
0.0905495659,
0.1724624634,
-0.3344115019,
0.5089149475,
0.4258030355,
-0.7210720778,
-0.831548512,
-0.1304304749,
-0.4435686171,
-0.6520065069,
0.1654005051,
-0.3004307151,
0.2441140264,
0.788074553,
-0.4919823408,
0.5269885063,
0.3797879517,
-0.8164967299,
0.3494843245,
-0.0485748611,
0.4085453749,
-1.2609670162,
0.067975007,
-0.6250782013,
-0.4889649451,
-0.3956476152,
0.2962349057,
0.1885041595,
-0.3922645748,
-0.2789512873,
0.318462342,
-0.1472262293,
-0.2029925138,
-0.8141054511,
0.0952077508,
0.0839991421,
0.2671899199,
-0.0113419304,
0.5271533132,
0.302382499,
-0.5528519154,
-0.088077046,
-0.1359650046,
-0.1896811277,
0.9847021103,
-0.5151460171,
0.2736371458,
-0.1552559435,
0.1423964053,
-0.7257124782,
-0.0713076964,
0.0367428213,
-0.5827072859,
0.0390096456,
0.0108817108,
-0.663993299,
0.0849384815,
-0.5550487041,
0.026930131,
0.4587292373,
-0.4278058112,
0.2888535559,
0.4206140339,
-0.3378430903,
-0.1874707192,
-0.4583800137,
0.3114792407,
-0.4589933753,
-0.5458005667,
0.6262204051,
-0.0234635454,
-0.0077884174,
0.1513849497,
-0.1240106672,
-0.2435862571,
0.2606648803,
0.3293699026,
-0.1453235149,
0.0196513496,
-0.0384276211,
0.432002455,
-0.7472900748,
-0.2373392135,
-0.1940412372,
0.7050946951,
0.0370630883,
-0.4063696563,
-0.4597343504,
0.7755591273,
0.6829580665,
-0.1963912249,
0.5482524633,
0.6833079457,
-0.6332238317,
-0.3374458849,
-0.2877625525,
-0.3838129938,
-0.4523478746,
0.0908292383,
-0.1975326389,
-1.2338222265,
0.226493448,
-0.2910516262,
-0.1172861531,
0.6940694451,
0.4646059275,
-0.1594680697,
0.9423863292,
0.5002891421,
-0.2409688085,
0.561604917,
0.2546351552,
0.198285237,
-0.4838293493,
0.1089289561,
-0.9717911482,
-0.1729841232,
-0.4954040647,
-0.4449943006,
0.0907530636,
0.12072514,
-0.2834564745,
0.5629768372,
-0.7336440086,
0.5847062469,
0.8695439696,
0.0791711137,
0.2216534615,
0.1852419823,
0.0666113645,
-0.383764714,
-0.4599993229,
-0.5540502667,
0.7675850987,
-0.2215602696,
0.0879758745,
-0.1880427301,
1.0016204119,
0.7302333713,
-0.2503523231,
-0.2777913809,
0.6728758216,
0.1008337438,
-0.4659029245,
-0.3871234357,
-0.2414939404,
-1.0664198399,
0.3187614083,
-0.3137104511,
-0.551870048,
-0.192352131,
-0.2178156674,
0.0359205492,
0.1581394374,
-0.6248205304,
0.8070995212,
0.4118911326,
-0.111497134,
-0.2320412695,
-0.5226534009,
-0.3055995107,
-0.1755024046,
0.2116372883,
-0.3347833157,
-0.3328742683,
0.7988834381,
-0.9839558005,
0.6020783186,
-0.4555646777,
0.0782629028,
0.5291401148,
0.2586916387,
0.7086569667,
-0.3023229539,
0.2297787666,
-0.0422657654,
0.2197311521,
-0.6386784911,
-0.614872396,
0.7071451545,
-0.2252111733,
-0.3217328489,
-0.2125674933,
-0.3068324029,
-0.079969056,
0.5113270879,
0.2846626639,
0.099801518,
0.2490632087,
0.4024736881,
0.2875854075,
-0.1877664179,
0.5313331485,
0.3856196105,
0.0614741109,
-0.7078225613,
1.0831519365,
0.0135554094,
0.2330206782,
0.360948801,
0.3425763547,
-0.3298083246,
-0.4339385629,
-0.2856363952,
-0.0569495521,
-0.9004659653,
-0.4031123519,
-0.8231660128,
-0.1428910047,
-0.3885217011,
-0.4676703215,
-0.2018867135,
-0.5921131372,
0.131290853,
-0.0067640101,
0.4367186725,
0.2981993854,
-0.0519030131,
0.4103218019,
-0.6254090667,
0.3620067537,
0.4817728996,
0.1707223207,
-0.3440410495,
-0.4284216166,
-0.077536568,
-0.2354653478,
-0.3316300511,
-0.6346411109,
0.1271980852,
0.0436929427,
0.1516309679,
0.428786099,
0.2943484187,
0.5884258747,
-0.5058376789,
1.0355067253,
-0.028134305,
-1.1150096655,
0.8566613793,
-0.3856047094,
0.5710844398,
0.6522682905,
-0.1098423973,
-0.5691645145,
-0.8248416185,
-0.789444685,
-0.833461225,
0.2831356525,
0.4318216145,
0.1646168828,
-0.2943142056,
0.0625669882,
0.0672338679,
0.2380377203,
-0.7368797064,
-0.0758570582,
-0.0332166664,
-0.2806176245,
0.3087387681,
-0.5569424629,
0.2683437169,
0.1023625806,
0.815885663,
0.0184033606,
0.2376125604,
0.1451229602,
-0.0979815796,
0.1860463917,
0.449804306,
0.4979055226,
0.0191081334,
0.1694080234,
0.7515876293,
0.203918308,
-0.5315850973,
0.0991088599,
-0.1435700208,
-0.5018238425,
0.3001433611,
0.5348950028,
0.2301200777,
0.2021443248,
-0.5392854214,
0.6154721975,
0.2557358444,
-0.1527290493,
0.2584343255,
0.0847911984,
0.1855828017,
0.1840845942,
0.1401428431,
-0.1077466458,
0.3736403883,
-0.0621860474,
0.3914849758,
0.37926507,
-0.5167736411,
-0.104760401,
0.7210924625,
0.0467688143,
-0.2724733055,
0.0132209659,
-0.1810928136,
-0.7030081153,
0.6342224479,
0.6528632641,
0.8902189732,
-0.2688066661,
0.094958581,
0.3154573441,
0.2827392817,
0.1185913235,
0.4583717883,
-0.5822767019,
-0.6451199651,
-0.133238703,
-0.6483489275,
-0.2028945535,
0.1043750942,
-0.3731533885,
0.2560531497,
-0.4552882314,
-0.2687593699,
0.1281152964,
-0.1077833772,
-0.1766995937,
0.2324827462,
-0.0024630551,
0.5220867991,
-0.9327477813,
0.4705670178,
0.6162953377,
0.0539529324,
-0.2090155035,
-0.0349753127,
-0.1512673944,
-0.601188004,
0.1269117594,
0.4745248556,
-0.0568677932,
-0.0516928732,
-0.6792683005,
-0.8224926591,
1.0410910845,
0.1286592484,
-0.0437147915,
0.6096521616,
0.6127164364,
0.3376035094,
-0.0056637577,
-0.5967954993,
0.4516350031,
0.5171300769,
-0.2194714993,
-0.3145488203,
0.4883934259,
-0.3616784811,
0.1867072433,
0.6947036982,
-0.3070896268,
0.3152500093,
0.3063691258,
-0.4251155555,
0.0988330022,
0.5272898078,
0.5627095103,
0.5710624456,
0.6652934551,
0.8455960155,
0.669688642,
-0.0637508705,
0.6259711385,
-0.4442077279,
0.1144342273,
1.0013017654,
-0.2307558805,
1.0392090082,
0.8698307872,
-0.1970176101,
0.5318894982,
0.3899055123,
0.0782361925,
0.8324546218,
0.1979854405,
-0.5649732351,
-0.3853857517,
-0.3803897202,
-0.4720535874,
0.1978632957,
0.2758771777,
-0.4529253244,
-0.4014707804,
-0.1836933196,
0.247818172,
0.3536660969,
-0.156795308,
0.8622304797,
0.0548099652,
-0.4439713657,
0.0890301093,
0.1914590597,
0.6560379267,
-0.395349592,
0.1038116515,
0.1157043502,
-0.0731616244,
-0.1529185027,
-0.5573040247,
0.5490554571,
-0.0014444405,
-0.210149169,
-0.1968451142,
1.494751215,
-0.321283102,
-0.341437459,
0.0270123705,
0.3346384168,
0.3060371578,
-0.545727849,
-0.5724348426,
0.0400302522,
-0.2611146569,
-0.1205700263,
0.3314584494,
0.7388553619,
-0.0925176591,
0.3836842477,
0.8550202847,
-0.1392682642,
0.0511017665,
0.0899271145,
0.6704835296,
-0.7494975328,
-0.7805261612,
-1.0589621067,
0.3512684405,
-0.4424936473,
-0.0797188804,
0.8404692411,
0.5578305721,
0.6000488997,
-0.1344517022,
0.8776419163,
-0.0522635914,
0.4782714248,
-0.5250160694,
0.8517611027,
-0.3096302748,
-0.1526722312,
-0.7321382761,
-0.9545634389,
-0.5489738584,
0.2194402665,
-0.1389437616,
-0.1102624834,
0.813577652,
0.8954181075,
0.2026391476,
-0.0818706155,
0.6287670732,
-0.3617286384,
0.2566020489,
0.2610940635,
1.0134958029,
-0.4691374302,
0.5284576416,
-0.2604473829,
-0.0445464626,
-0.1719753295,
-0.9790244699,
-0.8812469244,
-0.8543723822,
-0.4799812138,
-0.305220902,
-0.2472971529,
0.4524983168,
0.5993691087,
-0.8141373396,
0.3985383511,
-0.2361609191,
0.0755606517,
-0.0215746313,
-0.285364151,
0.7230238914,
-0.5387109518,
-0.4094136953,
0.1977294832,
0.704737246,
0.34829849,
0.0704245046,
0.1324488223,
0.1500164717,
0.2456469089,
0.7341508269,
-0.1213200688,
-0.2956028581,
-0.3274383545,
-0.1529631764,
-0.2149599791,
-0.2840664387,
0.7818246484,
-0.5735096335,
0.2415159345,
0.6109346747,
0.8612908721,
0.4961173832,
-0.0908681303,
0.0686149895,
-0.7304365039,
0.1895989925,
-0.0591374412,
0.3611382246,
0.3323013186,
-0.3111772835,
0.3402039111,
0.5875368118,
-0.578030169,
-0.9176309109,
0.1121816114,
-0.6799163222,
-0.5484176278,
1.1070492268,
0.0333091877,
-0.4307347834,
-0.273183763,
-0.3025189638,
0.0148946401,
-0.3197675943,
0.8337560892,
0.7545841336,
0.4622789621,
0.232032612,
-0.3452342451,
0.5703416467,
0.5249006152,
-1.2074104548,
0.0367754921,
0.3997137845,
0.290928632,
0.0743620172,
0.7218266726,
-0.347402066,
0.3036642075,
0.2692926824,
0.0092265448,
0.2531383932,
-0.2318383008,
0.0230241492,
0.2466311902,
-0.0924792513,
-0.4751055241
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11398v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11398v2
|
Reasoning before Comparison: LLM-Enhanced Semantic Similarity Metrics for Domain Specialized Text Analysis
| 2024-02-17T22:46:44 | 2024-02-20T22:23:42 |
Shaochen Xu, Zihao Wu, Huaqin Zhao, Peng Shu, Zhengliang Liu, Wenxiong Liao, Sheng Li, Andrea Sikora, Tianming Liu, Xiang Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this study, we leverage LLM to enhance the semantic analysis and develop
similarity metrics for texts, addressing the limitations of traditional
unsupervised NLP metrics like ROUGE and BLEU. We develop a framework where LLMs
such as GPT-4 are employed for zero-shot text identification and label
generation for radiology reports, where the labels are then used as
measurements for text similarity. By testing the proposed framework on the
MIMIC data, we find that GPT-4 generated labels can significantly improve the
semantic similarity assessment, with scores more closely aligned with clinical
ground truth than traditional NLP metrics. Our work demonstrates the
possibility of conducting semantic analysis of the text data using
semi-quantitative reasoning results by the LLMs for highly specialized domains.
While the framework is implemented for radiology report similarity analysis,
its concept can be extended to other specialized domains as well.
|
[
-0.1090679467,
-0.537930131,
1.1116349697,
-0.1088121906,
-0.2996330559,
0.1895703226,
0.071679391,
-0.6923546195,
0.2494331449,
0.6922367215,
-0.4328327775,
-0.9281970859,
-0.5665195584,
0.4380720556,
-0.3335202038,
0.9398854375,
-0.0553817153,
0.1661610901,
-0.4801790714,
-0.2980478108,
-0.2016603947,
-0.4274675846,
-0.5862469077,
-0.5739486814,
0.5608904362,
0.0995311737,
0.8038609624,
0.5193449259,
0.8761302233,
0.3125950694,
0.1882338822,
0.1666742712,
-0.2955669165,
-0.0224845484,
-0.3076157868,
-0.2039728612,
-0.7994735241,
0.0954707637,
0.5064864755,
0.6508196592,
0.2358793169,
-0.0093575343,
-0.0718295574,
0.5405117273,
-0.399104178,
-0.0602960102,
-0.6230534315,
0.1862564087,
-0.1772185415,
-0.75357759,
-0.2672455609,
-0.378503114,
0.2615938187,
-0.8150321841,
0.3060005903,
0.0107336827,
1.1904352903,
0.2037788481,
-0.5096679926,
-0.4536885023,
-0.4750799835,
0.829518795,
-0.8425189853,
0.2400831729,
0.056206502,
0.1677173674,
0.0221100952,
-1.1742478609,
-0.7115218043,
-0.2877049744,
-0.2245782763,
0.469168663,
-0.4823205769,
0.0620532706,
0.3495692909,
0.2776815295,
-0.9788023233,
0.0598706231,
-0.0640113652,
-0.4152936935,
0.4589580894,
0.3484400809,
0.3440032601,
-0.1280366182,
-0.7253463268,
0.0459423549,
-0.7086171508,
-0.7246873379,
0.1300590932,
-0.1148781031,
0.2571150362,
0.5090869665,
-0.4500522912,
0.7196201086,
-0.2510814369,
-0.4023870528,
0.796782434,
-0.3419755101,
-0.4857515693,
0.1030436456,
0.8538883328,
0.8631262183,
0.2969738245,
-0.2299420834,
-0.1292542517,
0.3046372831,
0.212148577,
-0.7793326378,
-0.083844021,
0.1008388996,
-0.6815146208,
-0.3700955212,
-0.0822598785,
-0.5017454028,
-0.2749676108,
-0.4284360111,
0.6063194275,
-0.3358356655,
-0.1642808169,
0.4280024469,
-0.2365446985,
0.5143077374,
0.4087688923,
-0.5130550265,
0.5395320654,
0.77669245,
0.905341506,
-0.6659185886,
-0.1092636213,
-0.1832377166,
0.3705203235,
-0.3186652958,
1.1509143114,
-0.5592087507,
-0.4442664683,
-0.2123539448,
-0.1279265732,
0.0823876932,
-0.7118476033,
0.6264145374,
-0.4976493418,
0.2506401241,
0.0435318463,
-0.7392814159,
-0.1374421865,
0.6986478567,
-0.4493971169,
1.087022543,
0.27073434,
-1.0303407907,
0.6457241178,
-0.2927283347,
-0.331214875,
0.2433194667,
-0.4527870715,
-0.6017497182,
-0.1464672387,
0.0401734821,
0.4696702957,
-0.4469127059,
-0.0113898935,
-0.3216719329,
-0.2620813847,
0.2709881961,
-0.1673097461,
0.4837504625,
0.2064122409,
-0.1195525154,
0.3198433816,
-0.6570677161,
0.456567347,
-0.0417818911,
0.086264737,
-0.5141326189,
-0.3981817365,
-0.1744421721,
0.1486400366,
0.2643278837,
-0.6716203094,
0.0005816947,
-0.4248604774,
-0.0092171058,
0.3702492118,
0.1346878558,
0.3646056354,
-0.720122993,
0.6370185018,
-0.1932637393,
0.0248269774,
0.0348243341,
-0.6940950155,
-0.491162926,
-0.3798658848,
0.3595824838,
0.6889964342,
-0.5441678762,
0.2666098475,
-0.4635525346,
-0.4564580321,
-0.3722788393,
-0.2153920084,
0.4742735326,
0.9266842008,
0.4704820216,
-0.4839783013,
-0.4549771845,
-1.0699316263,
-0.4243735075,
-0.0358815193,
-0.2949309051,
0.3226044476,
0.3348999918,
-0.3704873323,
0.7175835371,
-0.8361047506,
-0.5641512871,
-0.1845262498,
0.0897586048,
0.1763588935,
0.0802703202,
0.598726809,
-0.5610950589,
-0.7376911044,
0.1729397774,
-0.9286655188,
-0.4527505338,
-0.244226709,
-0.1236486733,
0.1188693196,
0.6941117644,
-0.5496373773,
0.5338694453,
0.3534732461,
-0.2782558799,
0.4589715004,
-0.4024630487,
0.6070331931,
-1.0682269335,
0.0090184985,
-0.0807770714,
-0.3771134913,
-0.5773876905,
-0.1153280661,
-0.0818545222,
0.0742774978,
-0.3522988856,
0.7855283022,
-0.3084053397,
-0.2521792948,
-0.4606289268,
0.3684286177,
0.2854922414,
-0.0023650343,
0.3933795989,
0.5829212666,
0.5999904871,
-0.37254107,
0.3306670487,
0.292540431,
-0.1924058497,
0.6593896747,
-0.6871201992,
0.1557678878,
0.2244976759,
0.1783313602,
-0.7023612857,
0.1033364236,
0.1573012322,
-0.7297487855,
0.3095070422,
0.0423515923,
-0.4170623422,
-0.2245191336,
-0.4874679148,
0.3322418332,
0.5798345804,
-0.1438240707,
0.4030757844,
0.2979754508,
-0.2636561096,
-0.6012551785,
-0.6827329993,
0.1603908092,
-0.3327279091,
-0.5884800553,
0.7761235237,
-0.0310167968,
-0.337736994,
0.1419391185,
-0.0858605877,
-0.2379186153,
-0.1481418759,
-0.0193124413,
0.2597237825,
-0.5323678851,
0.0796620175,
0.0585200079,
-0.5544986725,
0.0347372852,
-0.3680821359,
0.1788622141,
-0.1184883788,
-0.3957094252,
-0.4444482625,
0.2591743171,
0.0931714922,
0.211149618,
0.2547936738,
0.4533551931,
-0.2647481859,
0.0488850288,
-0.4683466852,
-0.1448307186,
-0.4366656244,
0.2351562679,
-0.4472513795,
-0.9928180575,
0.353570044,
-0.2604198754,
-0.3544656038,
0.4834826589,
0.8436434865,
-0.125821352,
0.6720340848,
0.4466471374,
0.2390836328,
-0.0097169299,
0.0527955368,
0.0508816317,
-0.5808286071,
-0.2837178409,
-0.5050749183,
-0.0633753166,
-0.664655447,
-0.6655355096,
0.3783062398,
-0.2576410174,
-0.025496928,
-0.0047185696,
-0.6215067506,
0.6337313056,
0.1809280813,
-0.0541401021,
0.6266478896,
-0.0252330601,
-0.066089198,
-0.3571156561,
-0.4786779881,
-0.8041599989,
1.2689192295,
0.0879269391,
0.4507851601,
-0.0777427629,
0.8095164299,
0.3312045038,
0.4923816621,
-0.9262266755,
0.641730547,
-0.1635683775,
-0.2892617881,
-0.1689166427,
-0.4243922234,
-1.1047052145,
0.390024215,
-0.3041252494,
-0.4024383426,
-0.3778828979,
-0.2306528538,
-0.1439747512,
0.0568683445,
-0.3429211974,
0.6914551258,
-0.018976409,
0.035527043,
-0.1712530851,
-0.5520596504,
0.1917248368,
-0.3097449541,
0.0404412486,
-0.2516438365,
-0.4723808169,
0.7784281373,
-0.4656355977,
0.5145043135,
0.1438872218,
-0.0402763076,
0.2503376007,
0.1527110636,
-0.0383500718,
0.1062944233,
-0.0784336999,
0.3096987009,
0.1225452721,
-0.3719514906,
-0.8329057097,
0.9783406854,
-0.5341171622,
-0.5572344065,
-0.6652039886,
-0.3581197858,
-0.3416125774,
0.512309134,
0.1802918464,
0.4815148115,
-0.0846103504,
-0.1020668894,
0.7307544947,
-0.2945268154,
-0.0064408705,
0.8326537609,
-0.0596395247,
-0.328052789,
0.75072366,
-0.212755084,
0.2743758857,
0.7615205646,
0.3164730072,
-0.3428442478,
-0.9378221035,
-0.2378656268,
0.388964504,
-0.8154124022,
-0.526106298,
-0.6855124831,
-0.1788452268,
-0.3850485384,
-0.2811478078,
-0.1606976241,
-0.4896005988,
-0.0438184291,
-0.1844103634,
0.4132727385,
0.7502325773,
-0.0449145846,
0.1444139332,
-0.9357147813,
0.2965434194,
-0.0896402672,
0.1190727875,
-0.3682827353,
-0.5734857321,
0.0479157045,
-0.4664569497,
-0.3496604264,
-0.7288879156,
0.3758292794,
0.0276231281,
0.6667138338,
0.2199917436,
0.041262731,
0.4175209999,
-0.5666559339,
0.7314898372,
0.3118146062,
-0.9422255754,
0.5612911582,
-0.4092603028,
0.138528645,
0.4115249515,
0.5406067371,
-0.206356436,
-0.5750889778,
-0.8525340557,
-0.7291398644,
0.2503177226,
0.3509849012,
0.1630326509,
-0.190075472,
0.4842214882,
0.2868927717,
-0.1031971201,
-0.591134131,
-0.3197287619,
0.0009749815,
-0.275036633,
0.1826705933,
-0.1240566969,
-0.1553655714,
-0.1297610104,
0.3964983225,
-0.3270381093,
0.4747617841,
0.4106647074,
-0.0182881542,
0.2437942326,
0.2074943483,
0.6093223691,
0.8492449522,
0.0072319959,
0.2375758439,
0.5809938312,
-0.5508865714,
0.0223430246,
-0.2072774321,
0.0352106839,
0.2356829941,
0.8964115977,
0.4087377191,
0.1978851706,
-0.5478065014,
0.7632690072,
-0.0619749576,
-0.55926162,
-0.1558766067,
0.0159551632,
0.0859920979,
0.0935298651,
0.0498403534,
-0.0792213008,
0.4475401044,
-0.2629590631,
0.7552387714,
0.44209674,
-0.516146183,
-0.1364488453,
0.3238600492,
-0.0004084164,
-0.031024389,
0.4373712242,
0.0001693711,
-0.2712792754,
0.654106319,
0.5175939202,
0.6373793483,
-0.061567761,
0.4028641582,
0.3552590311,
-0.003665576,
0.1258930713,
0.3180454075,
0.0690658763,
-0.8276048303,
-0.5444059968,
-0.3931321502,
-0.4541769326,
0.1072975472,
-0.7765800357,
0.4511637092,
-0.4736916125,
-0.1517362148,
0.1859147549,
0.1135856733,
-0.4374123514,
0.6462875605,
0.0484371334,
0.7559499741,
-0.6963126659,
0.9551169872,
0.5695480108,
-0.2768733501,
-0.6894184947,
0.0933256596,
0.1011479124,
-0.8720089793,
0.7227270603,
0.1504748911,
-0.4291664362,
-0.1434315145,
-0.1265062392,
-0.5132953525,
1.3166882992,
0.2206150442,
-0.4265939593,
0.0692517236,
0.2764996886,
0.8636361957,
-0.4598554671,
0.5318416357,
0.6413388252,
0.3709729016,
0.4192400873,
-1.0434048176,
0.3062238395,
0.021149775,
-0.270101577,
0.183165729,
-0.3146649301,
0.4884663522,
-0.3343955278,
-0.1870830059,
0.1884212345,
0.6120862365,
0.1819588691,
0.6458016634,
0.1676790714,
0.7562718391,
0.8329956532,
0.067457132,
1.131893754,
0.053567145,
0.4547154307,
1.0716645718,
-0.6251561046,
0.5440527201,
0.283637017,
-0.1908375919,
0.5420728922,
0.4656042755,
-0.0692234635,
0.4711056352,
0.1958684772,
-0.2731795013,
-0.295956403,
-0.0285334848,
-0.5265633464,
0.304518491,
0.3249510229,
-0.376825124,
-0.4077896774,
-0.1909014434,
0.0535883307,
0.2668596208,
-0.1992345452,
1.0381945372,
0.382032752,
-0.0933556184,
0.5537962317,
-0.0036849782,
0.5201081038,
-0.6796044111,
0.0483030751,
-0.1087444946,
0.1819442958,
-0.347086817,
-1.0387042761,
0.8095778823,
-0.1221365705,
-0.1192245707,
-0.1609205455,
0.8469293118,
-0.0945703536,
-0.2483098507,
0.5463374853,
0.6353530884,
0.3261371255,
0.0808655024,
-0.9600921273,
-0.0232262444,
-0.052091267,
-0.2084883302,
0.5438537598,
0.6803360581,
-0.1914998442,
0.7085044384,
0.4229707122,
0.2724066079,
-0.3416548371,
0.3769072592,
0.8440832496,
-0.7515803576,
-0.3360010684,
-0.8353651166,
0.0252687093,
-0.361546129,
-0.4076239467,
0.7575680614,
0.7787070274,
0.8949680328,
-0.1028895453,
0.7813908458,
0.3394379318,
0.8005178571,
-0.8223759532,
0.6452518702,
-0.5910933614,
0.2869220674,
-0.5223433375,
-0.9031077623,
-0.8040139079,
0.5435225964,
-0.3658002913,
0.0212283228,
1.2589857578,
0.9944562316,
-0.0501997545,
-0.110055387,
0.6777395606,
-0.0278367847,
0.2218980044,
0.6173196435,
0.8482006192,
-0.2979693413,
0.5705435872,
0.2495802641,
-0.2559387088,
0.089195326,
-1.0257805586,
-0.9145361185,
-0.4426482916,
-0.7237043381,
-0.509896338,
-0.013114186,
0.3667829931,
0.47156775,
-0.6755676866,
0.2945064902,
0.1895675212,
0.028194081,
0.0854703858,
-0.2608333826,
0.5973385572,
-0.1832639873,
-0.4948967099,
0.1875709444,
0.6604712605,
0.0247882884,
0.0748120248,
-0.1928144693,
0.2861737609,
0.2408271432,
0.5355550051,
-0.0218355674,
-0.7235797644,
-0.4201683998,
-0.0961872935,
-0.3634251952,
0.2281573564,
1.2054539919,
-1.0400583744,
0.3313505352,
0.552536428,
0.6057680845,
0.3869944215,
-0.1437712759,
0.4453473985,
-0.4113067389,
0.0738473386,
0.5186741352,
0.0065803397,
0.434628576,
-0.3911461234,
0.4840237498,
0.3536622524,
-0.5240327716,
-0.6709934473,
0.4442178309,
-1.3178251982,
-0.2778292894,
1.2529139519,
-0.4391505718,
0.0478950329,
-0.3384370506,
-0.2022269517,
0.0450389013,
-0.095258899,
0.5201848149,
0.4265080392,
-0.6093433499,
-0.0398993678,
-0.3547577262,
0.7305939198,
0.3011308014,
-0.9977080822,
-0.4590933323,
0.1761443615,
0.6720450521,
-0.012045485,
1.1677150726,
-0.479650408,
0.2342098951,
-0.0342788808,
-0.1855068803,
-0.0038429415,
0.013174206,
-0.0718692988,
-0.0321180038,
0.00775208,
0.0542330965
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14833v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14833v1
|
CliqueParcel: An Approach For Batching LLM Prompts That Jointly Optimizes Efficiency And Faithfulness
| 2024-02-17T22:37:17 | 2024-02-17T22:37:17 |
Jiayi Liu, Tinghan Yang, Jennifer Neville
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have become pivotal in recent research. However,
during the inference process, LLMs still require substantial resources. In this
paper, we propose CliqueParcel, a method designed to improve the efficiency of
LLMs via prompt batching. Existing strategies to optimize inference efficiency
often compromise on output quality, leading to a discounted output problem.
This issue might result in reduced accuracy or outputs that are less detailed.
CliqueParcel is our answer to this challenge. While ensuring accuracy and
minimizing deviations from the original outputs (i.e., faithfulness), our
method significantly improves efficiency during inference.
To lay the groundwork, we first redefine efficiency measurements by excluding
the reduction in running time due to shorter lengths. Then, we provide a
comprehensive trade-off between efficiency and faithfulness to clarify the
nature of the 'discounted output' problem. Within the CliqueParcel framework,
we suggest multiple batching sub-methods and discuss the specific scenarios in
which they can be applied. During evaluation, CliqueParcel is tested on eight
widely recognized datasets, which can be classified into three types: reading
comprehension, open-source question-answering, and reasoning. Our experiments
explore the performance of CliqueParcel, including efficiency, faithfulness,
and the trade-off between them. This work provides novel insights into
inference efficiency and demonstrates promising performance.
|
[
-0.1639194191,
-0.563211143,
0.5123599172,
0.6010591388,
-0.4406741261,
-0.1103681326,
-0.4678338766,
0.0127935074,
0.0593181588,
0.6462986469,
-0.6129493713,
-0.4604148567,
-0.4242951274,
0.2747834325,
-0.3586568236,
0.5105930567,
0.0351942554,
0.3636772335,
-0.4236810803,
-0.0504724085,
-0.5056843758,
-0.2995962501,
-1.0535370111,
-0.2216605693,
0.4730990529,
0.3929969072,
0.5533236265,
0.9657625556,
0.1949538291,
0.2839516699,
0.0021338311,
0.6488218904,
-0.7597966194,
0.4200125635,
-0.2364242524,
-0.6435142756,
-0.3536685109,
-0.189230293,
0.6609740853,
0.6910840869,
-0.2449106574,
0.0761569962,
0.5018646121,
0.6621181965,
-0.5388714075,
0.2819001377,
-0.6787406206,
-0.1645596176,
-0.1325094551,
-0.0381795019,
-0.7241256237,
-0.7115108967,
-0.5120257139,
-0.4671560824,
0.2092349231,
0.2861448526,
0.4185428023,
0.285487026,
0.1405078918,
-0.4251601994,
-0.3079941571,
1.1850342751,
-0.8508697152,
0.4315063953,
0.1103257313,
0.2338084877,
-0.5356079936,
-0.9691647887,
-0.4126485288,
-0.2289917767,
-0.1225892603,
0.0768829584,
-0.0057821199,
0.1743444204,
0.3957414925,
0.4043660164,
-0.4456227422,
0.0682883933,
-0.0813343599,
-0.4767614007,
0.7043049932,
0.2555522025,
0.0909449682,
0.1585050225,
-0.2114564478,
-0.0380215608,
-0.6147699952,
0.0622497499,
0.198494181,
0.4102002382,
0.4603834152,
0.5527944565,
-0.2819387913,
0.7052614093,
-0.1605969965,
-0.4305507541,
-0.1738826632,
-0.5168431997,
-0.2221643478,
0.1465550512,
0.7324193716,
0.4013254344,
0.3101674318,
-0.0570070893,
-0.2128057331,
0.0776360109,
-0.0893359482,
-1.1790269613,
-0.3940080404,
0.4362018406,
-0.4192706943,
-0.0599952303,
-0.2615464926,
-0.8998600841,
-0.3641853333,
-0.510425806,
0.0265233591,
-0.4903793931,
0.3505458832,
-0.218715474,
-0.2403017282,
-0.1726309359,
0.7059593797,
-0.647133112,
0.3713157177,
0.6477084756,
1.038179636,
-0.3693188131,
-0.2258846015,
-0.8999758363,
0.1076775119,
-0.3712461293,
0.6835809946,
-0.4946165085,
-0.5847676992,
-0.1233302578,
0.0109371841,
0.1033987924,
-0.6012808084,
0.5954417586,
-0.3348027766,
-0.194978103,
-0.5582073331,
-0.7969941497,
0.1048795581,
0.0068212678,
-0.6836457253,
0.8895804882,
-0.0809198096,
-0.5825431347,
0.33356902,
-0.1275184453,
-0.4355807006,
0.0676002204,
-0.0727271736,
-0.1801093072,
0.08947815,
0.545362711,
0.4977108836,
-0.4338573217,
0.1654823273,
-0.3418462873,
-0.4824817777,
0.0976732224,
-0.5866287351,
0.7550173998,
0.2298367769,
-0.0144349616,
0.0368725099,
-0.4961261153,
0.1980984658,
-0.0454100333,
-0.4102733731,
-0.2694705427,
0.0110683655,
-0.4419735372,
-0.1884659976,
0.2347233742,
-0.4716148674,
0.3851328492,
-0.3192883134,
0.4918816984,
0.8590888977,
0.1034667864,
0.5514590144,
-0.4082706273,
0.3058753908,
-0.1333179623,
0.2404308021,
-0.441450417,
-0.4573458433,
-0.6592846513,
-0.8063955307,
0.283210665,
0.4858382344,
-0.8710225224,
0.0071390085,
-0.0969477743,
-0.3174210489,
-0.4337917864,
0.4199758172,
0.4257155359,
0.4262059331,
0.4709764123,
-0.175712347,
-0.2481401712,
-0.91595155,
-0.7201152444,
0.0711059421,
-0.031063132,
0.2414771467,
0.0800476894,
0.2418334931,
0.9786558747,
-0.5880666971,
0.0827692822,
-0.5719769597,
-0.0015936566,
0.6320678592,
0.4688534439,
0.2905459702,
-0.4541992843,
-0.5214095712,
-0.1222405061,
-0.3551419079,
-0.397519052,
-0.2592241466,
-0.2708382308,
0.2455254793,
0.4742422402,
-0.4288834631,
0.3146036565,
0.3883140087,
0.125245899,
0.6092330813,
-0.1351358742,
0.2658669651,
-0.9727771282,
-0.3420705497,
-0.1883623004,
-0.5212171674,
-0.559954226,
-0.179431349,
0.0968407169,
0.1212012693,
-0.5398296118,
0.6777073741,
-0.5649265647,
-0.064030543,
-0.2300991565,
0.1614813656,
0.2205452472,
0.4452596307,
-0.2402077466,
1.2540121078,
0.3352748752,
-0.7670892477,
0.3938824236,
0.128531605,
-0.2253388315,
0.5209515095,
-0.6345463395,
0.0346144401,
-0.2688581049,
0.4269530177,
-1.0934860706,
-0.4070348442,
0.2204063386,
-0.196849525,
0.2803350687,
-0.1793067157,
-0.4319911897,
-0.4049600661,
-0.2892935574,
0.1997900009,
0.813557744,
-0.7606416941,
0.6124281883,
-0.082640104,
-0.2660028338,
-0.7250469327,
-0.9105579257,
-0.1779977381,
-0.0086660506,
-0.636475265,
0.1830270588,
0.0527915843,
-0.2962189317,
-0.278108418,
-0.1867640167,
-0.1387987137,
-0.1563903242,
0.0123563539,
-0.0541631691,
-0.0501522943,
0.0678479001,
0.4285410941,
0.1452787519,
-0.0131819686,
-0.6761960387,
0.726151228,
0.1987434179,
-0.3220391273,
-0.7474105954,
0.2562534511,
0.2843655646,
-0.1145403162,
0.8714599609,
0.2227081805,
-0.1456094235,
-0.8203775883,
-0.6746670604,
-0.3845265806,
-0.5119739771,
0.1374540925,
-0.2264825553,
-0.573692143,
0.4578858912,
-0.3732179403,
0.3180511892,
-0.0386747606,
0.6163247228,
0.0564800687,
0.5101494193,
0.0128704701,
0.1704725325,
0.3389383256,
-0.171943754,
0.2737492919,
-0.5671046376,
-0.2346821874,
-0.5845581293,
-0.0721582919,
-0.2342036963,
-0.8138230443,
0.0976874083,
0.3309685886,
-0.067968674,
0.3302657604,
-0.28390643,
0.5724356174,
0.6310870051,
0.4810114503,
0.505499661,
0.0986281857,
-0.0208973121,
-0.1140334532,
-0.8938091397,
-0.523506701,
0.8272168636,
0.0518802106,
0.8262163997,
-0.107121706,
0.7464492917,
0.3177132607,
0.5680736303,
-0.6410698295,
0.693533659,
-0.1538699269,
-0.289655298,
-0.2960909605,
-0.7381598353,
-0.6330868006,
0.3514773548,
0.2190522552,
-0.6903545856,
0.1213344857,
0.6890720725,
-0.2201506495,
0.3216901422,
-0.6257649064,
0.8093170524,
0.0157650243,
-0.8664804697,
-0.1544200182,
-0.2881832123,
0.5765000582,
-0.0726990029,
0.2627148032,
-0.043883644,
-0.0571833402,
0.3840799928,
-0.7885738611,
0.7073543072,
-0.2069743425,
0.1083668992,
0.6545261741,
0.1713983566,
0.8315243125,
0.3239101171,
-0.3706161678,
0.0854746178,
-0.1095712259,
-0.7256147861,
-0.7424035668,
0.7852768898,
-0.2425799817,
-0.6059563756,
-0.0893825144,
-0.7061881423,
-0.2611159682,
0.291526854,
0.2365233004,
0.7328876257,
-0.2045522779,
0.0199454371,
0.6700230241,
-0.429908514,
0.6981880069,
-0.0897792429,
-0.2834706306,
-0.533857882,
0.8525011539,
0.0995316207,
0.6604257822,
0.2647128701,
0.1680102497,
-0.5526486039,
-0.6421580911,
-0.4590544403,
0.2323878556,
-0.7830876708,
-0.2721127868,
-0.6377266645,
0.224956274,
-0.5550274253,
-0.2066879272,
-0.3761783838,
-0.3188542128,
-0.240778327,
0.2625868022,
0.2228397429,
0.3855674267,
0.0896095335,
0.5242513418,
-0.7635661364,
0.0194091443,
0.3259103,
0.0415005125,
0.1392112076,
-0.472335279,
0.1156702489,
0.2211237401,
-0.1265396774,
-0.7838697433,
0.426715821,
0.255528897,
0.4876681864,
0.2489286363,
0.2680587173,
0.7855503559,
-0.5070928931,
0.8138996363,
0.1621558368,
-1.0554337502,
0.1756175756,
-0.2644764483,
0.0110356519,
0.6701883674,
0.2015876472,
-0.2329480648,
-0.2684824169,
-0.3570101261,
-0.7462219,
0.5372886658,
0.5044130087,
-0.0155909685,
-0.1521404237,
0.4675731659,
0.0929475352,
0.5470558405,
-0.3025106192,
-0.1339226663,
-0.1333047599,
-0.2655091882,
0.0438749939,
-0.2174984664,
0.0990553275,
-0.0949397981,
0.7877591252,
-0.1854086518,
0.045793023,
0.4441542923,
-0.1378927827,
0.4853709936,
0.1309935898,
0.4489552081,
0.7140243649,
0.1328220069,
0.0683238506,
0.5332916975,
-0.429556191,
0.1026313528,
-0.2617589831,
0.1009462774,
0.1828512698,
0.4451639056,
0.5046876669,
-0.0982443243,
-0.6247339845,
0.506098628,
-0.0202319212,
0.0407977365,
-0.0808236673,
0.1657623053,
0.2288779765,
0.1616109759,
0.0962300822,
0.0882721245,
0.1508646607,
-0.5398800969,
0.2752760947,
0.3609826565,
-0.0045576566,
0.2409649938,
0.5722322464,
0.0654861405,
-0.2669273615,
0.7948338389,
-0.4329797924,
-0.3767302334,
0.8216897845,
0.5100600123,
0.5059054494,
-0.4155429006,
0.1235826612,
0.3728385568,
0.2667672336,
-0.5632330179,
0.2110203356,
0.0643409342,
-0.4691111445,
-0.774794817,
-0.7790985107,
-0.4434718192,
-0.3060360551,
-0.6061294079,
0.2957451642,
-0.4185650647,
0.1015408859,
-0.3149970174,
-0.1639513671,
-0.4666512907,
0.1026079729,
-0.2381168008,
1.1997252703,
-0.6232230663,
0.750498414,
0.2187445015,
-0.090378575,
-1.0474717617,
-0.0450782999,
-0.2780483663,
-0.8388311267,
0.4077454507,
0.2548238039,
-0.0094007021,
0.149548471,
-0.5876166224,
-0.5268333554,
1.2153475285,
0.5108061433,
-0.953727603,
0.3210081458,
0.0830073506,
0.2898296416,
-0.4404522777,
0.3664970696,
0.797249496,
0.6234276891,
0.3677332699,
-0.4246937037,
0.229531154,
0.2356839031,
0.2397073209,
0.2479648739,
-0.7437004447,
0.7565116882,
-0.0921989381,
-0.2240415961,
0.2564674914,
0.8910850883,
0.4269871414,
0.5556822419,
0.3783116341,
0.4195633531,
1.1348608732,
-0.2853583694,
1.3567860126,
-0.19749102,
0.3186894059,
1.1129819155,
-0.3086419702,
0.4204975367,
0.4693352878,
-0.3438925147,
0.1979005188,
0.6014618874,
0.0209655445,
0.3493847251,
0.5793608427,
-0.2969246209,
-0.4860474467,
-0.3848205507,
-0.0384722427,
-0.2423944175,
0.2831465602,
-0.3895439804,
-0.209920451,
-0.1714533418,
0.3774074018,
0.1567818075,
-0.612750113,
0.3959427178,
0.2861397862,
-0.8577571511,
0.5151152611,
-0.2732233405,
0.2944533825,
-0.368432641,
-0.1099274009,
-0.7472711802,
0.210670352,
-0.2591353059,
-0.4348681867,
0.1897571981,
-0.2085980028,
-0.1750289947,
-0.2463408858,
0.5439475775,
-0.5333577394,
-0.5275439024,
0.0219093487,
0.319666028,
0.3750312328,
-0.1169779077,
-0.4385705888,
0.294829458,
0.222582221,
-0.1359580755,
0.1234899536,
0.3894547522,
-0.0473535955,
0.6165183783,
0.7495012283,
0.1873544157,
0.1205194294,
0.0845939144,
1.0032871962,
-0.2345145345,
-0.3196140528,
-1.1634005308,
0.3770395219,
-0.525365293,
-0.0626212209,
0.9079512358,
0.5674398541,
0.5250837207,
0.001132429,
0.7649459243,
0.2037446201,
0.3618917167,
-0.7937859893,
0.2803530991,
-0.3625104427,
0.4980396926,
-0.0845290273,
-1.2181893587,
-0.1118975133,
0.3171533048,
-0.1905711293,
-0.0945074111,
0.9544383287,
0.9806910157,
-0.0893404558,
0.2717993259,
0.2034815401,
0.4075030088,
0.3566851914,
0.4543768466,
0.6613852382,
-0.0960321352,
0.4197020829,
-0.4170018435,
-0.2976051271,
0.0541665256,
-1.0206366777,
-1.2361657619,
-0.0620358214,
-0.1510641426,
-0.5980517268,
0.423815161,
1.0789797306,
0.4800570011,
-0.8404242396,
-0.0877898037,
-0.4947350919,
0.1295366734,
-0.2688883841,
-0.2026266009,
0.3479187787,
-0.6814231873,
-0.9468072653,
0.4638225734,
0.1764995009,
-0.1819482446,
-0.105860956,
0.1644196659,
0.2496803701,
0.4646854699,
0.4310254157,
-0.048366826,
-0.5782783628,
0.0327042565,
-0.0594570637,
0.0006135493,
-0.1312996894,
0.9747815132,
-0.5025263429,
0.1095611453,
0.7539871335,
0.8261530399,
0.4159084857,
0.5062074065,
0.6419243217,
-0.6578022242,
0.3302280307,
0.2640846074,
0.4114627838,
0.3089289665,
-0.3962800205,
0.3676868081,
0.3506290019,
-0.7343706489,
-0.7966231108,
0.2991369963,
-0.842970252,
-0.5052005649,
1.2765311003,
-0.4462462068,
-0.6299368143,
0.0032774347,
-0.4320212603,
0.1702675819,
-0.8949202299,
0.3024604023,
0.5915789008,
-0.177872315,
0.0169672724,
-0.4663439095,
0.5148999691,
0.5273841619,
-0.8162192702,
0.201510191,
0.5659045577,
0.2131277919,
-0.095553495,
0.5672620535,
0.1520673186,
-0.0570811145,
0.040427912,
-0.1220824271,
-0.1433043778,
-0.3561609387,
-0.1945653409,
0.3166509271,
-0.0322769359,
-0.0922869667
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11359v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11359v3
|
Offline Training of Language Model Agents with Functions as Learnable Weights
| 2024-02-17T18:31:21 | 2024-06-07T23:49:18 |
Shaokun Zhang, Jieyu Zhang, Jiale Liu, Linxin Song, Chi Wang, Ranjay Krishna, Qingyun Wu
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Researchers and practitioners have recently reframed powerful Large Language
Models (LLMs) as agents, enabling them to automate complex tasks largely via
the use of specialized functions. To facilitate the development of LLM agents,
we present a novel paradigm of training LLM agents without modifying the LLM
weights, which is particularly useful when the LLMs are difficult or
inaccessible for modifications. Inspired by how humans continuously forge tools
to adapt to real-world tasks, rather than change our biological structure to
fit a static set of tools, we propose to progressively forge agent's functions
to better solve the downstream tasks instead of modifying the LLM weights. By
treating the functions as learnable `agent parameters' and leveraging the
fundamental idea of model training in artificial intelligence, we develop
AgentOptimizer that employs the LLM to update agents' functions and devise an
agent training algorithm with two strategies, roll-back, and early-stop, to
streamline the training process. With extensive experiments, we showcase that
the agent training paradigm could significantly improve the performance of
representative LLM agents in various downstream tasks. We also study the
behavior of the agent training regarding aspects like the learning curve and
domain transferability.
|
[
-0.2160060555,
-0.6170266271,
0.3961411715,
-0.2955737412,
-0.0299432278,
0.3473144174,
-0.3663563728,
-0.3984536529,
0.3168200254,
0.5161175728,
-0.6913526058,
0.0655979067,
-0.4106202424,
0.0315733068,
-0.283813864,
1.0188258886,
-0.1243305877,
0.3367474675,
-0.0903687775,
-0.0763103738,
0.1250255853,
-0.485193938,
-0.9579715729,
-0.6902861595,
0.4808404148,
0.3130405545,
0.5783007145,
0.8104397655,
0.2821933925,
0.4009137154,
0.1863353997,
0.0847020745,
-0.7190195322,
0.1444467753,
-0.0193777364,
-0.8043410182,
-0.6907895803,
-0.0552283376,
0.6666523218,
0.7574898005,
-0.3014327586,
0.036986243,
0.0204502344,
0.6153322458,
-0.3129576445,
0.3770714998,
-0.797360301,
0.0017726982,
-0.0477744639,
-0.39869982,
-0.451551199,
-0.3665919304,
0.0108075924,
-0.6740831137,
0.1905309409,
-0.2370743155,
0.7129123807,
0.4362055659,
-0.1610440612,
-0.1830730438,
-0.7973663807,
0.5435510874,
-0.6599687338,
0.2715318501,
0.3264095485,
0.5842704177,
-0.2044816613,
-0.745731473,
-0.2829912305,
-0.5680066943,
0.3011966348,
-0.1199395582,
0.2501609027,
0.1464983523,
0.2683250904,
0.0086776214,
-0.2737305164,
0.1165291667,
-0.1624369472,
-0.0597788431,
0.7061045766,
0.0684403479,
0.3715493083,
0.6592606902,
-0.1832859218,
-0.276761204,
-0.8117281795,
0.1703818887,
0.5838688612,
0.4616750181,
0.0872665122,
0.24500902,
-0.1560846418,
0.5261167288,
-0.0190198142,
-0.3500222266,
0.2012946457,
0.1559920013,
0.1615961939,
0.0078999763,
0.1519053131,
-0.1631381214,
0.4514628053,
-0.4793796241,
-0.5438411236,
-0.3804630339,
0.5432808399,
-0.8298456073,
-0.088498421,
0.0784814432,
-0.2515984178,
-0.3595796525,
-0.1049234867,
-0.1953419447,
-0.3748678267,
-0.425568819,
0.5658354163,
-0.3178407848,
-0.2766135335,
-0.2491459548,
-0.1072410569,
0.4017688036,
0.3672505915,
-0.8476055264,
0.3467170298,
0.479727596,
0.7539953589,
-0.0179562792,
-0.5809549689,
-0.6622685194,
0.1100393012,
-0.3112908602,
0.8020225763,
-0.3760471046,
-0.1059032381,
0.1334726661,
0.0537227392,
-0.1841686368,
-0.4528678656,
-0.0699984804,
-0.8103445172,
-0.139836058,
-0.1209403127,
-0.5535019636,
-0.1714489758,
0.3818342686,
-0.6671530604,
0.8742287755,
0.3540566266,
-0.3168185949,
0.241934225,
-0.6740908027,
-0.3945990503,
0.1931980848,
0.0836417675,
-0.5666652918,
-0.1570798159,
-0.2145871073,
0.3877336085,
-0.1622903794,
0.032377772,
-0.5761263967,
-0.3222587705,
0.2975904942,
-0.0713908151,
0.7161854506,
-0.0887420252,
-0.427767545,
0.1730466932,
-0.7617285848,
0.1051572487,
0.3390237987,
-0.5450014472,
-0.1185102537,
0.2803491652,
-0.034813147,
0.2528209686,
0.1749683321,
-0.4346256852,
0.3287507892,
-0.567568481,
0.6667170525,
0.6632956862,
-0.2612766922,
0.6099572778,
-0.5682080984,
0.6483863592,
-0.6215615869,
0.0950644687,
-0.0341758654,
-0.2501877248,
-0.8636705279,
-0.6579387188,
-0.0939856321,
0.5231994987,
-1.0002223253,
0.4439095557,
-0.3659959137,
-0.6771595478,
-0.3148152232,
0.4310968816,
0.3186194301,
0.2790395319,
0.1885186285,
-0.2375630587,
-0.333027333,
-0.3425765634,
-0.3097366691,
-0.0720034316,
0.0558815487,
0.0491591431,
0.6565756202,
-0.1077110022,
1.0973616838,
-0.4728451669,
-0.3513837755,
-0.7590665817,
0.2272514701,
-0.3198783696,
0.1218237057,
0.3622764349,
-0.6917179823,
-0.4047406614,
-0.0509148575,
-0.6387212873,
-0.2605122328,
-0.152297765,
0.1204604954,
0.2844744027,
0.9299983978,
-0.549323976,
0.1400486678,
0.1525695771,
-0.0706861839,
0.2571998239,
-0.426759541,
-0.3593820632,
-0.907235682,
0.1138875782,
-0.4441788495,
-0.6219710708,
-0.9059656858,
0.2544426322,
-0.1163721532,
-0.1155016422,
-0.7366886139,
0.7820055485,
-0.6488682032,
-0.1593927145,
-0.6888426542,
0.1301191449,
-0.1501404941,
0.705301702,
0.1263030767,
0.4917244017,
0.5442032218,
-0.5342767239,
0.4122350812,
-0.0129783079,
0.172319293,
0.3046653867,
-0.5397897959,
0.3238564134,
-0.3644482195,
0.3431951106,
-0.6217770576,
-0.0823262259,
0.3244935274,
-0.1562532783,
0.4941441119,
-0.0890235081,
-0.2833337784,
0.001901147,
-0.4727414548,
0.1842002124,
0.6000937819,
-0.3000864387,
0.8183897138,
0.3365467787,
-0.106504254,
-0.2526125312,
-0.4662231505,
-0.0939460397,
-0.2175723016,
-0.2769496143,
0.2682338953,
0.0075456086,
-0.1660335362,
-0.0237870123,
0.1321558654,
-0.215976432,
0.2118274122,
0.2510395944,
0.0182765182,
0.0262198355,
0.2292998582,
-0.191197753,
-0.1495683938,
-0.0348696485,
-0.3955458701,
0.6055036783,
-0.0553598627,
-0.2992011607,
-0.0418857113,
-0.0431641527,
0.5120264888,
-0.2792770863,
0.8227400184,
0.6658865213,
-0.324188292,
-0.6667224765,
-0.3586082458,
-0.4724408686,
-0.4906406105,
0.6467360258,
-0.2451328933,
-0.7055286169,
0.5498126149,
-0.1201077849,
0.1523614377,
0.0975613445,
0.7242960334,
0.1096935794,
0.901017487,
0.897477746,
0.1402536631,
0.7786031365,
-0.3512354791,
0.0308857784,
-0.4470244944,
-0.1640761197,
-0.3457058668,
-0.1837674081,
-0.3341600001,
-0.4993698299,
0.220575735,
-0.0688356906,
-0.2333241999,
0.3594134152,
-0.2220387459,
0.3868471384,
0.3982311189,
0.1043278128,
0.1350580305,
-0.0839662924,
0.2989674211,
0.374527216,
-0.7068561912,
-0.4863917232,
1.2912758589,
0.4258263707,
0.8194808364,
-0.049828738,
0.6607212424,
0.4367316067,
0.5709412098,
-1.0325733423,
0.6207842827,
0.16813685,
-0.5675322413,
-0.5920189023,
-0.4090820551,
-0.8781018853,
0.2003706694,
0.0310612693,
-0.5855359435,
-0.1808368117,
0.2438952029,
-0.0846269503,
0.4553620219,
-0.5651831031,
0.600689292,
-0.459913075,
-0.1844407171,
-0.1426451206,
-0.6509991288,
0.0214300584,
-0.441565901,
0.2364381701,
-0.1276366413,
-0.3357269466,
0.6551740766,
-0.8419091702,
1.0540384054,
-0.2983585596,
-0.1879503727,
0.3091906309,
0.0157724116,
0.6532151699,
-0.1708069891,
0.0818521976,
-0.0263115596,
-0.0620519221,
-0.4594906569,
-0.7589734197,
0.2993575037,
-0.9081042409,
-0.5210876465,
-0.3272423148,
-0.6909399629,
-0.1779718995,
0.3697248995,
0.1379857063,
0.4011940658,
-0.1495874375,
-0.0460217111,
0.5406351686,
0.1961122751,
0.6883518696,
0.661762774,
-0.0389293507,
-0.2935778201,
1.0582413673,
0.3040890396,
0.5671082735,
0.5910890698,
0.0904773623,
-0.2291320264,
-0.4464361966,
-0.2412554622,
0.0892004296,
-0.8201852441,
0.1006073356,
-0.4418611228,
-0.2989657521,
-0.1394122988,
-0.309989363,
-0.580804348,
-0.4255438745,
-0.2198777944,
0.1534668654,
0.3329583406,
0.6429260373,
0.0963971168,
0.4871090651,
-0.7152525783,
0.1778142303,
0.4516864717,
0.1734018326,
-0.0846318156,
-0.7020028234,
-0.4941379428,
0.1801384538,
-0.3734247983,
-0.7768179178,
0.3042787611,
0.7852881551,
0.6449628472,
0.6587111354,
0.1146837249,
0.2299211323,
-0.6226319671,
0.3226473033,
-0.1816934794,
-0.866027832,
0.230964914,
-0.2899520397,
0.1042807028,
0.4114306271,
0.4144813716,
-0.3021954596,
-0.5224782228,
-0.2256717384,
-0.8339033127,
0.9868667722,
0.1964561492,
0.3144543767,
0.5002356768,
0.5441532135,
0.1964952648,
0.3667252064,
-0.8690491915,
-0.0481650494,
-0.3181451559,
-0.1055242345,
-0.2613440752,
0.1486691087,
-0.1805598587,
-0.0847046822,
0.7983876467,
-0.4860151112,
0.2849795818,
0.0077389893,
-0.5060665607,
-0.2075930983,
0.1271545589,
0.5149430037,
0.7731785774,
-0.3169057667,
0.02580823,
0.2727007568,
-0.478379339,
0.4587396979,
0.2310920805,
-0.1761619598,
-0.357336551,
0.5860073566,
0.7176056504,
0.0925326571,
-0.9512634277,
0.3352779746,
0.0732480809,
-0.2570362091,
-0.5830745697,
0.293800652,
0.0342317224,
0.4059349,
0.3799917698,
-0.0622567199,
0.0047180001,
-0.6181738973,
0.1940203607,
0.5235580206,
-0.5439401865,
-0.4921241403,
0.4547636509,
0.2482597083,
-0.6796625257,
0.3772830069,
-0.5380603671,
-0.6605542898,
0.5632026792,
0.4479157031,
0.9946200252,
-0.184023276,
0.3636541069,
-0.2732642889,
0.3631578088,
-0.2359830737,
0.0796073601,
-0.0923970938,
-0.8502287865,
-0.2875362039,
-0.4213956296,
-0.4635616243,
-0.0484942868,
-0.448250562,
0.3870020807,
-0.4354999065,
-0.2150593251,
-0.1498271227,
-0.1489375383,
-0.3172416687,
0.1354944259,
0.2842294276,
0.6890437007,
-0.6994593143,
0.9631327391,
1.0981615782,
-0.5206704736,
-0.7741038203,
0.1439405531,
-0.0513045006,
-0.9449055791,
0.5846818686,
0.2485639304,
-0.3119931817,
0.3862706125,
-0.4816254973,
-0.8516193032,
1.1642686129,
0.6998187304,
-0.1550406069,
-0.3479793072,
0.4422217309,
0.6310801506,
-0.4006893933,
0.500297904,
0.4328959882,
0.1738653779,
0.1445486546,
-0.7478362322,
0.0888289511,
-0.3469803929,
-0.0085499417,
0.2531484962,
-0.746776998,
0.9079917669,
-0.2292709649,
0.1537609994,
-0.1122234911,
0.2238266319,
-0.0083096819,
0.1384521723,
0.5873842835,
0.3385816813,
0.53102386,
-0.0152811445,
0.8489505053,
-0.4508250654,
0.432397455,
0.9263128042,
-0.5358932614,
0.7494491935,
0.4888053834,
-0.0652390271,
0.3653700948,
0.4071724117,
0.0644028485,
0.4224844575,
0.411952287,
-0.0835442618,
-0.4410450757,
-0.087877728,
-0.1562758833,
0.6077862978,
-0.0575384013,
-0.0167207718,
-0.3606407642,
0.3249360919,
0.1802899241,
-0.0440361239,
-0.4214103222,
0.7894717455,
0.1872238219,
-0.4828815758,
0.7300776243,
0.100977838,
0.352337718,
-0.9371480942,
-0.0725653842,
-0.1199057922,
0.5092380643,
-0.0241275672,
-0.1743476689,
0.2716066837,
-0.2784198821,
0.1128903553,
-0.494700551,
0.7011324167,
-0.4211243391,
-0.3018044531,
0.4124013782,
0.6629499793,
0.1089512408,
-0.2854602635,
-0.7478556037,
-0.2484732121,
-0.2490441054,
-0.4638846517,
0.4096232653,
0.1774986982,
-0.1088188961,
1.2132234573,
0.6240110397,
0.3907344341,
-0.0178600084,
0.0205309168,
0.9529902935,
-0.4160054028,
-0.6337326765,
-0.7748706937,
0.4135836065,
0.1586943418,
-0.0855447054,
0.4991437197,
0.1567430049,
0.929236412,
-0.1745604128,
0.698127389,
-0.1237783208,
0.2978949547,
-0.493851155,
1.0590986013,
-0.7921350002,
0.2059001476,
0.0468670428,
-1.0075956583,
-0.1290155351,
0.3427886367,
-0.2884992957,
0.4345174134,
0.6673741937,
0.855622828,
0.1667927802,
-0.385915637,
0.3244613409,
0.096628584,
0.396671772,
0.3468407691,
0.8378124833,
-0.1523546726,
0.6729981899,
-0.2014242411,
-0.2277413756,
-0.3788551986,
-0.7839202285,
-1.3161063194,
-0.4978213012,
-0.3669986427,
-0.0761174485,
0.2624278367,
1.267329216,
0.9004018903,
-0.670257926,
-0.411888808,
-0.2841484547,
0.0161321349,
-0.3735708594,
-0.1685244888,
0.182221517,
-0.6568182111,
-0.6395308971,
0.3018728197,
0.222121343,
0.026730407,
-0.3564864099,
-0.4017977118,
-0.0949959084,
0.2590296268,
0.4497596323,
0.5414215326,
-0.4592455029,
-0.0781998187,
-0.0695768148,
-0.0611082427,
0.0766880363,
0.9167796969,
-0.5479707718,
0.375879705,
0.3810593486,
0.7696492076,
0.2155506313,
-0.1213799939,
0.5960881114,
-0.6265715361,
0.359288305,
0.2249193043,
0.1793372184,
0.3811793923,
-0.2138670385,
0.2279344797,
0.3327233493,
-0.499130547,
-0.8879181743,
0.1665643752,
-0.6452633142,
-0.2628493011,
1.1079460382,
-0.4053989649,
-0.249951914,
-0.3379844725,
-0.2219011933,
0.5977243185,
-0.3521486223,
0.7779952884,
0.3463648856,
-0.182874456,
-0.1871107519,
-0.4652500153,
0.7834075689,
0.2490044385,
-1.144824028,
-0.1102288589,
-0.0584990978,
0.3319618702,
-0.0645123646,
0.6744492054,
0.2127678394,
0.149132669,
0.0972394124,
0.4684795439,
-0.4825679064,
-0.3871523142,
-0.3379672468,
-0.003925127,
0.4941117167,
-0.0576395988
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11355v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11355v3
|
Natural Language Counterfactuals through Representation Surgery
| 2024-02-17T18:12:02 | 2024-05-07T17:58:17 |
Matan Avitan, Ryan Cotterell, Yoav Goldberg, Shauli Ravfogel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Interventions targeting the representation space of language models (LMs)
have emerged as an effective means to influence model behavior. Such methods
are employed, for example, to eliminate or alter the encoding of demographic
information such as gender within the model's representations and, in so doing,
create a counterfactual representation. However, because the intervention
operates within the representation space, understanding precisely what aspects
of the text it modifies poses a challenge. In this paper, we give a method to
convert representation counterfactuals into string counterfactuals. We
demonstrate that this approach enables us to analyze the linguistic alterations
corresponding to a given representation space intervention and to interpret the
features utilized to encode a specific concept. Moreover, the resulting
counterfactuals can be used to mitigate bias in classification through data
augmentation.
|
[
-0.6012709737,
-1.2107994556,
0.4488023818,
-0.2787008584,
-0.3123756051,
0.1556364596,
-0.1094835401,
-0.3327113688,
0.4265398383,
0.8731318712,
-0.7920426726,
-0.2269386351,
-0.5141947865,
0.0230801255,
-0.501711607,
1.2371896505,
-0.1066997275,
0.4264835417,
-0.3274101019,
-0.2582150996,
-0.6123636365,
-0.7826004624,
-0.2232892811,
-0.392968446,
0.301520884,
0.1446992457,
0.6859208941,
0.6252170801,
0.3122962117,
0.3664625883,
0.0095306961,
0.2253486812,
-0.456484884,
-0.0964489207,
-0.3063229322,
-0.5986819863,
0.0075396621,
0.3850806653,
0.6817825437,
0.8993509412,
-0.2605585456,
-0.0269709341,
0.0235952362,
0.6659130454,
-0.128947705,
-0.0002311178,
-0.7278909683,
0.0818100423,
-0.1462572366,
-0.3142858148,
-0.2865382731,
-0.6483659148,
0.1765796244,
-0.4243932962,
0.3718079329,
0.0745796785,
0.6501157284,
0.2633924484,
-0.564234376,
-0.3514846563,
-0.8745806813,
0.6917312145,
-0.6222752333,
0.3033459187,
0.4021927714,
0.1039877608,
-0.3753744364,
-0.2497219443,
-0.5473531485,
-0.1353982836,
-0.5801854134,
-0.333599925,
-0.5817977786,
0.154474318,
0.5026703477,
0.1960441172,
-0.6967958808,
-0.121025309,
-0.3278360665,
-0.3836601675,
0.5444990993,
-0.0295172632,
0.7454542518,
-0.1977481693,
-0.1199110225,
-0.0647583306,
-0.9117461443,
-0.2716554105,
0.4791623056,
0.315102458,
0.1112731621,
0.7879679799,
0.2346925288,
0.5911626816,
0.3226041794,
0.3264901936,
0.1821878701,
-0.190552786,
-0.4037361741,
0.3932867348,
0.4980086088,
0.1378315687,
0.1825580746,
0.2256711423,
-0.0528628416,
0.4357662797,
0.6199268103,
-0.622238636,
0.0487644859,
-0.0159246381,
-0.4772305489,
-0.2132440209,
-0.247344926,
-0.4665402472,
-0.5188501477,
-0.2318574637,
0.279399842,
-0.4851592779,
-0.129028216,
-0.0598715246,
-0.2039753646,
-0.1859415323,
0.1332801282,
-0.9172837138,
0.3733547926,
0.6084191203,
0.5572435856,
0.471718967,
0.4221064448,
-0.4418264925,
0.1355160624,
-0.6465950012,
0.6463091373,
-1.032725215,
-0.5916400552,
-0.0165566485,
0.2395381182,
-0.2835379839,
-0.6116671562,
0.3515059054,
-0.2635651231,
0.5327999592,
-0.4263827801,
-0.8544284701,
-0.5477871895,
0.2934967875,
-0.7637902498,
0.7744270563,
0.1880431026,
-0.6133076549,
0.2088658512,
-0.7858962417,
-0.3722161055,
-0.0298185423,
-0.4174646735,
-0.5251635909,
0.4405585527,
0.3473869562,
0.1162677184,
0.1080100983,
0.5684277415,
-0.2113946378,
-0.3609460294,
0.4691073596,
-0.507058084,
0.583778441,
-0.0067655118,
-0.1183293387,
0.2325883657,
-0.5637678504,
-0.5841038227,
0.0372014903,
0.0284375194,
-0.8743956089,
-0.0229334962,
-0.1654460281,
-0.053779237,
0.0908257514,
-0.9030279517,
0.4286285043,
-0.8131474257,
0.3161121905,
0.3277645111,
0.1084916964,
0.5368750691,
-0.080027245,
0.5183417201,
0.1739482731,
-0.0294280946,
-0.156076014,
-0.6499253511,
-0.5739184022,
-0.0139244068,
0.1363520175,
0.4251850545,
-1.3531075716,
0.2218098938,
-0.0375552177,
-0.4191059172,
-0.5314717889,
0.1594081074,
0.5778772235,
0.7250499129,
0.3530960977,
-0.3332025409,
-1.0233747959,
-1.0831702948,
-0.7543780208,
-0.4621998072,
0.0354894474,
0.2246785909,
0.448151052,
-0.2971598208,
1.0769779682,
-0.6438015699,
-0.4043903351,
-0.0996418968,
0.6284607649,
0.3001168072,
0.8020532131,
0.9024165869,
-0.8289937377,
-0.0230204649,
-0.046674002,
-0.6860040426,
-0.1535041928,
-0.2684600055,
0.2579059005,
0.4750596285,
0.7582009435,
-0.6647829413,
0.6999234557,
0.5930697322,
-0.5261628628,
0.4484983981,
-0.3498827517,
0.4035883844,
-0.3788624108,
-0.0122459987,
0.1693008542,
-0.2399975955,
-1.0115952492,
0.0413176864,
0.0860589221,
-0.0472334139,
-0.4190167189,
0.4622134268,
-0.177664727,
0.0217726026,
0.0003829322,
-0.157585904,
-0.1282562315,
0.3666611016,
0.3082777262,
0.7257350087,
-0.0260114111,
-0.146988973,
0.0179336797,
0.1428126097,
-0.1768427491,
0.7212654352,
-0.4550843239,
0.291628629,
-0.5056519508,
0.3859645724,
-1.1983796358,
0.0069875158,
0.605496645,
-0.4634236693,
0.1585351229,
-0.37485829,
-0.3408341408,
-0.4374754131,
-0.3168590069,
0.2388456166,
0.2476829886,
-0.2408567369,
0.6659833193,
0.3595897555,
0.0153204566,
-0.3100223541,
-0.9033998847,
0.2574466765,
-0.366920501,
-0.1196334064,
0.1875350475,
-0.1785721779,
-0.1977433264,
0.0728604123,
-0.105494149,
0.0416806228,
-0.0126428856,
0.0516894124,
0.4545784295,
-0.2078756243,
0.2995147109,
0.480830282,
0.027762495,
0.1390200853,
-0.2239425033,
0.36274454,
0.3276138604,
-0.3856298923,
-0.0533481315,
0.4410969913,
0.077638343,
-0.0193724651,
0.6953412294,
0.6667353511,
-0.6346948147,
0.0825247169,
-0.5640197396,
-0.3765490949,
-0.4802395701,
0.4282775521,
-0.2310018986,
-1.0172407627,
0.4675542414,
-0.0978969634,
0.0281637516,
0.3516982198,
0.1265956163,
-0.3334926665,
1.3295621872,
0.3480868936,
0.3130311072,
0.6477655768,
0.0415512174,
0.1555612087,
-0.7834649682,
-0.1264210343,
-0.6300308704,
-0.175089404,
-0.6710054874,
-0.6115907431,
0.4011989236,
-0.1105279326,
-0.1810951829,
0.6202214956,
-0.4105507731,
0.2850357294,
0.1860338748,
0.2474308759,
-0.0268816259,
0.1265268922,
-0.1254889667,
-0.6167839766,
-0.6403179169,
-0.635850668,
0.8851588368,
0.4804623425,
0.3867766261,
0.1929527372,
0.5276664495,
0.4523826241,
0.6664512753,
-0.614659071,
0.6289995909,
-0.7694773674,
-0.6145951748,
-0.2184546888,
-0.456120491,
-0.8544171453,
0.2868743837,
-0.4013880491,
-0.9945099354,
0.5141744018,
0.4056892991,
-0.0772642791,
0.4097985625,
-0.7944208384,
0.7203643322,
0.0449036695,
-0.1089022905,
-0.4406303167,
-0.2274496555,
0.4265130758,
-0.0637430176,
0.5783312321,
0.3346858621,
0.0197908301,
0.7984762192,
-0.4755577445,
1.2023499012,
-0.3946356177,
-0.5494607091,
0.1038296968,
0.4338416755,
0.4561223686,
-0.0349140763,
-0.0246225856,
0.2582514286,
-0.1312206537,
-0.0845029205,
-1.0653834343,
0.5535861254,
-0.5149261951,
-0.8061572313,
-0.2353620529,
-0.5137358308,
-0.4028396308,
-0.0750229582,
-0.2714214921,
0.6537837386,
-0.6601039767,
0.0695988014,
0.8075113893,
-0.5366700888,
0.4475631714,
0.4576762021,
-0.4344528913,
-0.2405636013,
0.8381211162,
0.2840017676,
0.0418922901,
0.3116291761,
0.3252469897,
-0.6635158658,
-0.4449199736,
-0.670250833,
0.023426557,
-0.7461773753,
0.16315943,
-0.6354163289,
-0.0691000298,
-0.3649375737,
0.1076672599,
-0.1086642444,
-0.3262507319,
-0.5026125312,
-0.029046841,
0.1511059999,
0.9042358398,
-0.0481655486,
0.5883868933,
-0.9115794301,
0.5774706602,
0.3820599616,
0.2660439909,
-0.1939005107,
-0.5175744295,
-0.1753472239,
0.2781070769,
0.0928088948,
-1.0894012451,
0.6310563087,
0.1272684932,
0.5775917768,
0.2782242,
-0.1318972409,
0.8415504694,
-0.5407286882,
0.8044606447,
0.2603218257,
-1.1518936157,
0.6551738977,
-0.3538700342,
0.409522891,
0.071691446,
0.2732985914,
-0.786793828,
-0.4197353423,
-0.5884087682,
-0.4740668535,
0.7684074044,
0.1523200125,
0.4413176477,
0.0409383625,
0.2786560953,
0.1639771461,
0.443104893,
-0.477809459,
-0.167516306,
-0.4746907353,
-0.3694136739,
-0.1442666203,
-0.3341814876,
-0.3625549078,
-0.2201962173,
0.5483294725,
-0.2811876237,
0.0247021038,
0.2531784177,
-0.425383836,
-0.2676039636,
0.4799034595,
0.9901691079,
0.3853082061,
-0.2785945237,
0.2271992415,
0.2068637758,
-0.5800717473,
0.1423196942,
0.027252119,
-0.2713725865,
0.3148415983,
0.5429733992,
0.8997120857,
0.2995174825,
-0.4668909609,
0.0865987092,
-0.0836385265,
-0.099038668,
0.0554285347,
-0.0863515809,
0.0299506057,
-0.0014486833,
0.5240857601,
0.2929556072,
0.3554713726,
-0.8598545194,
0.2941616178,
0.4739991128,
-0.8112327456,
-0.2601074278,
0.298370868,
0.1591351926,
-0.4223804772,
0.2535369992,
-0.0219936129,
-0.7203558087,
0.5750089884,
0.5010598898,
0.8370519876,
-0.5181336999,
0.5792968273,
0.4993215203,
0.5525625348,
0.2754057646,
0.240709722,
0.2885560393,
-0.8089430928,
-0.4126639068,
-0.1436672956,
-0.0281701013,
0.1116752848,
-0.4903739393,
-0.1031912565,
-0.5209871531,
-0.0726008117,
0.0686288252,
-0.2869052589,
-0.4278583825,
0.3687518239,
0.2016287893,
0.4667809308,
-1.0936770439,
0.7834441662,
0.877358973,
-0.2535742521,
-0.3567228317,
-0.0197536852,
0.3435492218,
-0.818590343,
0.7286117077,
-0.1055637375,
0.0302138943,
-0.4439263046,
-0.6763241887,
-0.5819801688,
0.0886128023,
0.6155114174,
-1.1720285416,
0.1889361143,
0.4921722114,
0.8635569215,
-0.4844481051,
0.4526710212,
0.6475445032,
0.5644013882,
-0.1562628597,
-0.9492679238,
0.3801626861,
0.0355308913,
0.2079701573,
0.1516866088,
0.082357794,
0.7129358053,
0.114570491,
-0.3399394155,
-0.269549042,
0.501696527,
0.1645896733,
-0.0159881581,
0.9499061704,
0.2212450653,
0.5545877814,
-0.2610274851,
0.9662364125,
0.0558595397,
0.3105314374,
0.8658091426,
0.0383692645,
0.5233166814,
0.9485626817,
-0.0750651434,
0.7648714185,
0.486620158,
0.0223413892,
0.399933964,
0.3764280081,
0.0787129551,
-0.4017859995,
-0.5193110704,
-0.1532573551,
0.509553194,
0.7725185752,
-0.3116473258,
-0.2036287487,
0.3230825961,
0.1943754405,
0.6108799577,
-0.4017575085,
0.8861139417,
0.1079427153,
-0.4707386494,
0.5112890005,
-0.1639719456,
0.6475352049,
-0.4676480889,
-0.7763110399,
-0.0537511297,
-0.0731254071,
-0.3226360083,
-0.8500828147,
0.6280687451,
-0.205570966,
-0.0445525907,
-0.3115999103,
0.770833075,
-0.8573630452,
-0.7403222919,
0.1270290613,
0.3102591634,
-0.1203137934,
0.1352557242,
-0.7347231507,
0.277572304,
0.1201781929,
-0.0210717469,
0.1512409598,
0.0884269178,
-0.5088899732,
0.5777573586,
0.7037581801,
0.2579697967,
-0.5012026429,
0.356279403,
0.7675305605,
-0.7094093561,
-0.6493598223,
-0.8782446384,
0.2290733904,
-0.2226314396,
-0.0486279391,
0.6859350801,
0.2326962799,
0.8287013173,
-0.1694307923,
0.5990892649,
0.1124293506,
0.5973914266,
-0.5314958096,
0.8095692396,
-0.5194462538,
0.552056253,
-0.5592600703,
-0.5242610574,
-0.2497654259,
0.4660025835,
-0.5498095155,
-0.0552937984,
0.5265031457,
0.7649116516,
0.0591847524,
0.2052734792,
0.2256237119,
0.3175565898,
0.3648107946,
0.2452532798,
0.7165897489,
-0.4691700041,
0.3568453193,
0.0245792121,
0.1946004331,
-0.0320895985,
-0.7515313029,
-0.9415484667,
-0.5874956846,
-0.4882106483,
-0.0341271609,
0.1572851986,
0.9053682089,
0.5407547951,
-0.972504437,
-0.1020516157,
0.0787632242,
0.4560565352,
-0.1554324329,
-0.208279714,
0.3377040327,
0.1633988917,
-0.7205481529,
0.547599256,
0.1087171882,
0.1496196389,
-0.5274959207,
0.0641587749,
-0.3774602115,
0.3493936956,
0.472936213,
0.0015793637,
-0.906588912,
-0.7250111699,
-0.1914264262,
0.15964818,
0.0939296484,
1.1648997068,
-1.0224823952,
0.6492486,
0.4607735276,
0.4614129961,
0.3242957294,
0.0058182827,
1.0802813768,
-1.1984540224,
0.0922884643,
0.0827327594,
0.3908115625,
0.5187535286,
-0.5441305041,
0.3578779399,
0.336938709,
0.2696780562,
-1.0456169844,
0.2770339847,
-0.5197886825,
-0.703803122,
0.8367579579,
-0.1553729326,
-0.2366541177,
-0.4919996858,
-0.6185417771,
0.4069297612,
-0.3448687494,
0.6083392501,
0.5710498095,
-0.0324602313,
-0.436876446,
-0.2596968412,
0.6209461093,
0.5654812455,
-0.7361724377,
-0.0229023434,
0.4383485913,
0.2221673578,
0.2695615292,
0.3993979692,
-0.1940266788,
0.0453094319,
-0.070323199,
0.0505872816,
0.0989242643,
0.2047280222,
-0.6393898129,
0.0118167205,
-0.3976049721,
-0.0656461269
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11353v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11353v1
|
Understanding the Impact of Long-Term Memory on Self-Disclosure with Large Language Model-Driven Chatbots for Public Health Intervention
| 2024-02-17T18:05:53 | 2024-02-17T18:05:53 |
Eunkyung Jo, Yuin Jeong, SoHyun Park, Daniel A. Epstein, Young-Ho Kim
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, H.5.2; I.2.7
|
Recent large language models (LLMs) offer the potential to support public
health monitoring by facilitating health disclosure through open-ended
conversations but rarely preserve the knowledge gained about individuals across
repeated interactions. Augmenting LLMs with long-term memory (LTM) presents an
opportunity to improve engagement and self-disclosure, but we lack an
understanding of how LTM impacts people's interaction with LLM-driven chatbots
in public health interventions. We examine the case of CareCall -- an
LLM-driven voice chatbot with LTM -- through the analysis of 1,252 call logs
and interviews with nine users. We found that LTM enhanced health disclosure
and fostered positive perceptions of the chatbot by offering familiarity.
However, we also observed challenges in promoting self-disclosure through LTM,
particularly around addressing chronic health conditions and privacy concerns.
We discuss considerations for LTM integration in LLM-driven chatbots for public
health monitoring, including carefully deciding what topics need to be
remembered in light of public health goals.
|
[
0.1416940242,
-0.7399280667,
0.8817017674,
0.1409585774,
0.0555493273,
-0.0469187237,
-0.3460276127,
-0.7297281623,
0.3432901204,
0.8179446459,
-0.2141376883,
-0.6742087603,
-0.3635064363,
-0.3105883896,
-0.278837353,
0.9269145727,
-0.0256177783,
-0.1264231205,
-0.2150330842,
0.0493689328,
-0.5845894814,
-0.9808679819,
-0.8744500279,
-0.4274852276,
1.0449762344,
0.2277412117,
0.5623188615,
0.3512755036,
0.3776324093,
0.1620554477,
-0.1827635169,
-0.0861017406,
-0.9319696426,
0.0895300284,
-0.219889015,
-0.5794397593,
-0.5732429624,
-0.1643757224,
0.6267753839,
0.423191309,
-0.2772992849,
0.190144822,
0.0771429241,
0.7059765458,
-0.5558220148,
0.2829589248,
-0.2798071504,
0.1948633492,
-0.1100317538,
-0.2429488152,
-0.5844768882,
-0.1868905276,
0.2524676621,
-0.1083560511,
-0.2256146669,
-0.2603134513,
0.3362467289,
0.378413707,
-0.4908539951,
-0.4192236662,
-1.1415840387,
0.7070260048,
-0.8119636178,
0.3299414814,
0.6965340376,
0.2088513821,
-0.4060043991,
-0.5346710086,
-0.1959251612,
-0.1855525225,
-0.1098558158,
0.2127079368,
-0.4724182189,
0.2257737368,
0.1134751067,
0.0672738925,
-0.3577308357,
0.2492173165,
-0.5563377738,
-0.2163615376,
0.5968831182,
0.1961936951,
0.2076549381,
-0.1706768572,
-0.3224673271,
0.427319169,
-0.5548413992,
-0.108547911,
-0.0908264294,
0.1933604181,
-0.3049457967,
0.4010267854,
0.0574581921,
0.2941524088,
-0.2179701626,
-0.2474305183,
0.2038693726,
-0.2396779209,
-0.1244937852,
0.2530919909,
0.8623196483,
0.4399771392,
0.2730155587,
-0.1675799489,
0.1441658735,
-0.153930828,
0.3400646448,
-0.906464994,
-0.1326645315,
0.4789911807,
-0.711823225,
0.0462407544,
-0.288094759,
-0.6128542423,
-0.4704040885,
-0.134853363,
0.4442953765,
-0.306448549,
-0.3252079189,
0.5084236264,
0.2517431676,
-0.1607881039,
0.453777045,
-0.7830801606,
0.5391095877,
0.7430394292,
0.8404127359,
-0.3225419223,
0.0876666978,
-0.3852775693,
0.4088346362,
-0.166507557,
0.4297161996,
-0.3606265485,
-0.6360247135,
0.097932145,
0.0392908566,
-0.101103425,
-0.6829888821,
0.1117833108,
-0.2320080847,
0.2621373534,
-0.0779569,
-0.5742682815,
0.1108622029,
0.1044433489,
-0.2760533392,
0.6395249963,
-0.0710651726,
-0.5602442622,
-0.0603638701,
-0.7170115709,
-0.4700722396,
0.1197264716,
-0.2198140919,
-0.4147145152,
0.1053632274,
0.0893307403,
0.6436859965,
-0.0090818815,
0.3173974156,
-0.2136457413,
-0.3368609548,
0.489500612,
-0.7254128456,
0.4641238451,
0.1282506585,
0.0100715449,
0.1794690192,
-0.2536775768,
-0.0906622112,
0.0202567838,
-0.3017227948,
-0.2651509047,
0.0243059061,
-0.1277632415,
0.0120747946,
0.5540295243,
-0.4390237927,
-0.0344944522,
-0.5357108712,
0.6327422261,
0.5683348775,
0.2580479085,
0.0475429893,
-0.5517641902,
0.4929104149,
0.0549691692,
0.6099572182,
-0.5965152383,
-0.3304683268,
-0.2597044706,
-0.2123628855,
0.1743586063,
0.3285453618,
0.0975273922,
0.3201430738,
-0.2745884359,
-0.3727334142,
-0.4157861471,
0.0788159296,
0.227984041,
0.3817130923,
0.3050158024,
-0.1295629591,
-0.1362314373,
-1.0142846107,
-0.1235990003,
-0.2051318586,
-0.0173878539,
0.856803894,
0.3599028587,
-0.4481348395,
0.8598746061,
-0.5940847993,
-0.457600981,
-0.2980243862,
-0.008782411,
0.2413635254,
0.2436452657,
0.3550545871,
-0.6569426656,
-0.2880147398,
-0.2975088954,
-0.3841575682,
0.1861150414,
-0.2542264163,
0.2776583135,
-0.0513792709,
0.2896500826,
-0.6311427951,
0.6765548587,
0.9406465888,
-0.0265959632,
0.4387406707,
-0.6494048238,
-0.0072967322,
-1.2790558338,
0.0924756527,
-0.0335295573,
-0.3504574001,
-0.6897113323,
-0.5849637985,
0.0270298608,
-0.2110814452,
-0.7865470648,
0.8078989387,
-0.4072035253,
0.0786456242,
-0.3822116256,
0.0011456665,
-0.2379949838,
0.0778817385,
-0.0615941584,
0.7693115473,
0.3948404491,
-0.4292018414,
-0.0196616091,
-0.0807121173,
-0.1208062917,
0.2170301378,
-0.5650550723,
0.3826647103,
-0.1290685087,
0.5078411698,
-0.9439959526,
-0.2348340899,
0.453769654,
-0.2574078143,
0.068959564,
-0.0564331636,
-0.5916856527,
-0.4987265468,
-0.0655496269,
0.3720065057,
0.4758090377,
-0.3536948264,
0.4330835044,
0.7190413475,
-0.1239932626,
-0.0388631411,
-0.7609691024,
0.202637881,
-0.4015228152,
-0.3598753214,
0.2390855998,
-0.1853563488,
-0.1397497952,
-0.11953789,
-0.2089081109,
-0.0221555457,
0.0533130318,
0.5719456077,
0.1272411197,
0.068400681,
0.6836435795,
-0.3036506176,
-0.0394108407,
0.3966375589,
0.0793037564,
0.8341385722,
-0.0708943754,
-0.4879099131,
-1.0145369768,
0.4234457612,
0.5194159746,
0.0604320951,
0.7904199958,
0.2313587815,
-0.3463510871,
0.2120455652,
-0.7011592388,
-0.3593455255,
-0.4404062629,
0.1597726494,
0.1476199776,
-1.121126771,
0.3714808822,
-0.3064453304,
-0.0587907284,
-0.0976032019,
0.5748104453,
-0.5028905869,
0.7853496671,
0.367138207,
-0.6408526897,
0.3600581884,
0.2006108314,
0.0775926709,
-0.7560523748,
-0.0911692828,
-0.1271691471,
-0.2252276242,
-0.6175511479,
-0.7310391665,
0.4497183859,
-0.233518362,
-0.1526353508,
-0.1286109686,
-0.2254364789,
0.2130459398,
0.2816277742,
0.693815589,
0.2581348121,
-0.3518526852,
0.5166230798,
-0.1816356182,
-0.5324679613,
-0.2724126577,
0.9544510245,
0.7252659202,
1.2983423471,
-0.0497664846,
1.1511405706,
0.3221453726,
0.2426433712,
-0.8368017077,
0.3762842715,
-0.0575943962,
-0.3434459567,
-0.3121729791,
-0.4080269337,
-1.4363106489,
-0.311088562,
0.0847661868,
-1.1073480844,
-0.2453934103,
0.4765816629,
-0.6618929505,
0.0201799795,
-0.5360428095,
0.5448720455,
-0.6373104453,
-0.1673166007,
-0.8061000705,
-0.5787805915,
0.0350059532,
-0.1175014898,
0.3094025254,
-0.2682366967,
0.1843654662,
0.6943549514,
-0.1080968305,
1.470607996,
0.1058049127,
-0.2142283916,
0.1953898966,
-0.2704865038,
0.4519839883,
0.1555223167,
0.1859910935,
0.304964453,
-0.0174032263,
-0.1547517329,
-0.4391285479,
0.8415936828,
-0.6928231716,
-1.1465762854,
-0.2954775691,
-0.5562093854,
-0.3307923675,
0.2052582055,
-0.4476174116,
0.3238202035,
-0.3662020266,
0.3586269021,
0.9737313986,
-0.6298176646,
0.1493463069,
0.5532669425,
-0.6599445939,
-0.0670417324,
0.4934417903,
0.0364873111,
0.5646218657,
0.3958828151,
0.7674748898,
-0.1921752691,
-0.1398398429,
0.2431837767,
0.6933865547,
-0.402346611,
0.0219104495,
-0.8627735376,
-0.5839737058,
-0.3889359832,
0.1130773127,
-0.4771474004,
0.0070368121,
-0.5612927079,
0.0818137154,
0.6394022107,
0.772983849,
-0.1882272512,
0.2139464915,
-0.8154616356,
0.457087934,
0.3520432115,
0.3062302172,
0.0630028769,
-0.1980942339,
-0.3260098398,
0.2289976776,
-0.0586669557,
-0.9786946774,
0.3376498222,
-0.1028608307,
0.45758304,
0.4405141771,
-0.0350081027,
0.5917643309,
-0.4280666709,
0.7082359791,
0.3612398207,
-0.6310225129,
0.7213771343,
-0.4724853635,
0.8202628493,
0.267049998,
0.3169001639,
-1.0942430496,
-0.4063864052,
-0.4989561439,
-0.7495697141,
0.3066783249,
-0.1384059191,
0.5339918733,
-0.3010843396,
0.1651179194,
-0.1365742385,
0.0965207592,
-0.5313050151,
-0.4036635756,
0.0983531252,
0.0125766899,
0.0552224219,
-0.683621943,
-0.3659860194,
0.0100887949,
0.0999364182,
0.1305109262,
0.2851552367,
0.3308348954,
0.2072639912,
0.0538623855,
0.5895065069,
0.5537501574,
0.6158764362,
-0.1260762215,
0.1427880079,
0.1361279488,
-0.3087093532,
-0.2030644566,
-0.2380729467,
0.1308023781,
-0.0672345832,
0.1778478771,
0.5038793683,
0.7448049188,
-0.7377631068,
0.4386869967,
0.202635929,
0.079896681,
-0.5025225878,
0.09623494,
0.7920326591,
0.1356660277,
0.1664118618,
-0.503962934,
0.0813511163,
-0.7075411677,
0.2666550279,
0.4184935689,
-0.5166409612,
-0.2156633586,
0.7266297936,
0.1159087121,
-0.3984450102,
0.4765167236,
0.4883188605,
-0.274846822,
0.3839968145,
0.7405779958,
0.4595451057,
-0.5659376979,
0.1276218742,
0.255333662,
-0.0117042176,
-0.0586559102,
0.2325769067,
0.0604060628,
-0.5791169405,
-0.4770903587,
-0.1221220195,
-0.467358917,
0.3328807354,
-0.8174527287,
-0.0850258544,
-0.3842430413,
-0.5421046019,
-0.0824225992,
-0.1663835198,
-0.7881360054,
0.0835942701,
0.4211649299,
0.853531003,
-0.5390151143,
0.9758837819,
0.05042959,
-0.0507544205,
-0.6796321869,
0.1745427102,
0.2321871519,
-1.010376811,
0.6835563779,
0.4072127342,
-0.2598872781,
-0.2331258357,
-0.3363059163,
-0.8247373104,
1.0539802313,
0.2087979615,
-0.9954208732,
0.0597628392,
0.5157444477,
0.7968885899,
-0.2603108883,
0.0968208686,
0.2098594457,
0.4764134288,
-0.0564433038,
-1.3161154985,
-0.0714032501,
0.3907280266,
0.096011363,
0.2446400374,
-1.0957384109,
0.3494261503,
-0.3269814849,
-0.4380963445,
-0.1936212778,
0.5798674822,
0.0043507777,
0.2217033356,
0.3712958694,
0.2294615656,
0.9125136733,
0.4161685109,
0.8534852266,
-0.2896512151,
0.1677659899,
1.6052525043,
-0.3364215791,
1.0188171864,
0.5252360106,
-0.0877695903,
0.2352884561,
0.2422696501,
0.1834181696,
0.276001811,
0.3559722304,
-0.5247924924,
-0.0819243491,
-0.3749484122,
-0.3774445355,
0.3774074018,
0.679905355,
-0.6756123304,
-0.2632000148,
0.2842532396,
0.3211922348,
0.0308093727,
-0.3074106574,
0.8309880495,
0.2877100706,
-0.3182481229,
0.192305088,
-0.6548460722,
0.5137842298,
-0.5887418985,
-0.167166099,
0.0628875867,
0.0023609288,
-0.0451302528,
-1.0453397036,
0.3067711592,
-0.3143587112,
-0.3121248484,
-0.3825658262,
0.8602949381,
-0.5793555975,
-0.1867664009,
0.7194442153,
0.5902796984,
0.4443919659,
-0.156205833,
-0.6945352554,
0.2380135655,
-0.1198836342,
-0.2571424246,
0.4830465019,
0.0626901984,
0.034378916,
1.0009325743,
0.6817793846,
0.3788844049,
-0.3028141558,
0.17949377,
0.6557687521,
-0.8357337117,
-0.1709676832,
-0.9439697266,
0.0811369717,
0.0927620605,
-0.0525126085,
0.6445022225,
0.6705516577,
0.4465791285,
0.1120190769,
0.8745760322,
0.4845674634,
0.703155458,
-0.5133647919,
0.9457127452,
-0.2997309566,
0.1404967159,
0.3556188643,
-0.1386829913,
-0.0986822695,
0.1561651379,
-0.5405282378,
-0.2157276422,
0.3628632426,
0.7850979567,
0.2598543465,
-0.2419824898,
0.6174483299,
0.5415949225,
0.5336208344,
0.6740041375,
0.6184669733,
0.0922754407,
0.4382597506,
-0.0852036104,
0.0085026287,
-0.3383765519,
-0.761261642,
-0.9897847772,
-0.3407959342,
-0.2577709556,
-0.2462921739,
0.300151974,
0.9740714431,
0.6260008216,
-0.5967038274,
-0.2328741252,
0.3859778047,
-0.0600736253,
0.1467011422,
-0.2784512639,
0.3347140551,
-0.0151230982,
-0.5856958628,
0.5173192024,
0.7139059901,
0.040969152,
-0.5513337255,
0.2198708653,
-0.0089425026,
-0.0165962297,
0.491850853,
0.6139437556,
-0.9119467735,
-0.503364563,
-0.1226161867,
-0.3851624727,
0.5882020593,
0.707408309,
-0.8495255113,
0.6509395242,
0.0077345977,
0.5288773775,
0.6583387852,
-0.0309628099,
0.725484848,
-0.3180182278,
-0.0703235939,
0.4359717965,
0.1741090715,
0.1442431659,
-0.7296004295,
0.2265292108,
-0.4324628413,
-0.7250341177,
-0.4327577949,
0.2032765001,
-1.0238144398,
-0.3274463713,
1.3737114668,
-0.1299692988,
-0.2920016348,
-0.2876013517,
-0.3576395214,
0.0702797398,
-0.6290191412,
0.9443145394,
0.5317895412,
-0.42187801,
-0.2619592547,
-0.8441851735,
0.5041717291,
0.1525271684,
-0.9539710283,
0.4094899595,
0.3974041939,
0.3742327988,
0.0644402131,
1.1813870668,
-0.1085955873,
0.1803028733,
-0.5507503152,
-0.1408028305,
0.3012645245,
-0.0735709965,
-0.1375108808,
-0.1476023942,
-0.1222491637,
-0.0267750006
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11349v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11349v2
|
Language Models Don't Learn the Physical Manifestation of Language
| 2024-02-17T17:52:24 | 2024-06-06T17:20:21 |
Bruce W. Lee, JaeHyuk Lim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We argue that language-only models don't learn the physical manifestation of
language. We present an empirical investigation of visual-auditory properties
of language through a series of tasks, termed H-Test. These tasks highlight a
fundamental gap between human linguistic understanding and the sensory-deprived
linguistic understanding of LLMs. In support of our hypothesis, 1. deliberate
reasoning (Chain-of-Thought), 2. few-shot examples, or 3. stronger LLM from the
same model family (LLaMA 2 13B -> LLaMA 2 70B) has no significant effect on
H-Test performance.
We bring in the philosophical case of Mary, who learns about the world in a
sensory-deprived environment as a useful conceptual framework to understand how
language-only models learn about the world (Jackson, 1986). Our experiments
show that some of the strongest proprietary LLMs stay near random chance
baseline accuracy of 50%, highlighting the limitations of linguistic knowledge
acquired in the absence of sensory experience. Our code and data are available
at <github.com/brucewlee/h-test>.
|
[
-0.1527692378,
-1.0010250807,
0.6708100438,
0.2204390168,
-0.1655702293,
0.2000437677,
-0.2213793099,
-0.7426413894,
0.1888720095,
0.2271697521,
-0.4370865226,
-0.2943839729,
-0.4547116756,
0.0169041101,
-0.3653858304,
0.5120822787,
-0.000972587,
-0.1753054708,
-0.2157179862,
0.0115674939,
-0.0497499146,
-0.2905449271,
-0.2257774472,
-0.3364779353,
0.5977267027,
0.4152198434,
0.4575746953,
0.7705948353,
0.5069855452,
0.2020458281,
-0.2779291868,
-0.0975451171,
-0.4675215185,
0.0460507683,
-0.0930762514,
-0.5026978254,
-0.2363735884,
0.1668985784,
0.712977767,
1.0879870653,
-0.0154504851,
0.1854534745,
-0.0765334442,
0.5247799754,
-0.6765304208,
0.2163872719,
-0.8393450379,
0.1861116737,
-0.1174222454,
-0.1294122189,
-0.5024372339,
0.109857589,
0.1104301959,
-0.4224470556,
0.2981008291,
0.3507570028,
1.2740522623,
0.3759550154,
-0.6776040196,
-0.0712918118,
-0.8030303121,
0.8354389071,
-0.4406846762,
0.8034183383,
0.6426489353,
-0.0114770988,
-0.0267214719,
-0.3375235796,
-0.6926429272,
-0.8412926197,
0.2858558297,
0.1735013276,
-0.0646474659,
0.0531787314,
0.4979705811,
0.3345139623,
-0.5155488849,
0.1865145266,
-0.5804303288,
-0.0606919378,
0.4065321982,
0.0042727515,
0.3044655919,
-0.366345793,
-0.5647947788,
-0.1605621874,
-0.7800616622,
0.1495703459,
0.1889101118,
0.1066036597,
-0.393199712,
0.7137952447,
0.0811181441,
0.6641088724,
-0.2575295568,
-0.541957736,
0.1706300378,
-0.0106492685,
-0.3233369887,
-0.3159239292,
0.6841341257,
-0.0827899203,
0.3234017193,
-0.1706407815,
-0.2430245131,
0.3433913291,
0.2145586759,
-0.3958628476,
-0.2504368722,
-0.214661628,
-0.3822272718,
-0.1734571606,
-0.0292185452,
-0.3971939981,
-0.3611345887,
-0.2275545597,
0.3551362455,
-0.2655591965,
-0.5227953792,
0.0802622065,
-0.3519966304,
0.0918276757,
-0.0152855506,
-0.9070745111,
0.5870150328,
0.5042541623,
0.4043997228,
-0.190970242,
-0.6292442679,
-0.1654112637,
-0.2217009217,
-0.4502363205,
0.783310771,
-0.4489701092,
-0.2993480265,
-0.2592662871,
-0.0331289135,
-0.1144943759,
-0.8816251159,
0.2648448944,
-0.2837736011,
-0.1935064793,
-0.578410387,
-0.45223701,
-0.2163874507,
-0.0934427381,
-0.3172793388,
0.7625473142,
0.1665282398,
-0.4746452272,
0.6103641987,
-0.2387758642,
-0.2531110644,
0.0736777931,
-0.5436621904,
-0.1395914555,
0.5499553084,
-0.2055290043,
0.0776103511,
-0.1739182025,
0.295955807,
-0.6499209404,
-0.6681850553,
0.4373571873,
-0.4403525591,
0.6617814302,
0.1025675312,
-0.4496755302,
-0.2241493315,
-0.8874240518,
-0.2795015275,
0.4944716394,
-0.4138637483,
-0.2665895224,
0.186181739,
0.0659504086,
0.3052350581,
-0.0153183006,
-0.7072241306,
0.1140528917,
-0.4818286598,
0.0941623151,
0.7025454044,
-0.3330960274,
0.4838799536,
-0.3907209635,
0.6202343106,
0.2226698548,
0.0199452732,
-0.116395615,
-0.5924179554,
-1.1324695349,
-0.289242655,
0.0115596112,
0.4568694532,
-0.4375998378,
0.1225677431,
-0.0379385203,
-0.3668344021,
-0.5463540554,
0.3801836967,
0.5241671801,
0.625079155,
0.0718722567,
-0.4487861991,
-0.5795306563,
-1.1218430996,
-0.4852046371,
-0.5930203199,
0.1674439609,
0.3830341995,
0.7828364968,
-0.204904452,
0.6725664735,
-0.2659653723,
0.0640808344,
-0.1704824269,
0.0224093124,
0.123237431,
0.0881448314,
0.3974545002,
-0.4943166971,
0.135105595,
-0.1618201137,
-1.0708940029,
-0.3172472119,
0.0916838497,
0.178453669,
0.1776884347,
0.1912495047,
-0.6184571385,
0.6533489823,
0.7163108587,
-0.657525003,
0.6535996199,
-0.1538318992,
-0.2221325487,
-0.4503805041,
-0.211470291,
0.1117019653,
0.1200115159,
-0.5071220994,
0.1739580333,
0.1766522825,
-0.0763377994,
-0.5740295649,
1.0022782087,
-0.4737250209,
-0.4018463194,
-0.5397601724,
0.0169164129,
0.0022749151,
0.7114009857,
0.2384892255,
0.5488138199,
0.5808830857,
-0.8658557534,
-0.0754896626,
0.0278311875,
-0.4370743036,
0.3549363911,
-0.5287406445,
0.0928045362,
-0.1043948308,
-0.2807816565,
-0.8087413907,
-0.274572432,
0.315444231,
-0.311429441,
0.0850073323,
0.1250027716,
-0.4216282666,
-0.3780226409,
0.1659510285,
0.4193784595,
0.9534021616,
-0.5308061242,
0.3621591628,
0.4722017944,
0.0964744911,
-0.2358256876,
-0.8950390816,
0.0344354138,
-0.0468550473,
-0.4775189757,
-0.0592265278,
-0.1137355641,
-0.8568012714,
-0.1548440456,
-0.4005174637,
-0.3198597431,
0.3696493506,
0.6241368651,
0.1326665729,
-0.2908128202,
0.2847195864,
-0.1858336926,
0.132050544,
0.2964870632,
-0.0311120804,
0.2610367537,
-0.1606743336,
-0.8680674434,
-0.58199507,
0.0327992104,
0.5908075571,
0.0119088925,
0.45914644,
0.24537763,
-0.3674274981,
-0.1450196803,
-0.598418951,
-0.2119485587,
-0.4318175018,
0.3714860678,
-0.6159481406,
-0.7284270525,
0.4081264436,
0.1619646996,
-0.4168677926,
0.2728366554,
0.5555264354,
-0.4627314508,
0.7402232289,
0.621609509,
0.1736594737,
0.405189395,
-0.1632901877,
0.1739262044,
-0.8493673801,
-0.1776840538,
-0.4561507106,
-0.3260107934,
-0.5418986082,
-0.0604139045,
0.3083131313,
0.0690222532,
-0.3944535851,
0.1182479188,
-0.0136379329,
0.3038079441,
0.7447354198,
0.3338476717,
0.4482451379,
0.2211174071,
-0.214379862,
-0.3063062429,
-0.6691225767,
-0.446305871,
0.880384326,
0.4489065111,
0.9070954919,
-0.0619944744,
0.6396247745,
-0.0936837494,
0.0836114362,
-0.8603175282,
0.5965744853,
0.3141096532,
-0.5059664249,
-0.0484398082,
-0.463537991,
-0.9464890361,
0.4816634953,
-0.0664971992,
-0.6241549253,
0.3445835114,
0.128151238,
-0.0523522161,
0.3967188001,
-0.6624607444,
0.6400437951,
-0.5113652349,
-0.3245284855,
0.0926054269,
-0.1961796284,
0.6958398819,
-0.1575202197,
0.5232688785,
-0.1990117878,
0.0018833353,
0.7640809417,
-0.1404968649,
0.9383101463,
-0.0444191881,
-0.3456936181,
0.2088054121,
0.3752188385,
0.1832066178,
-0.1169881895,
0.1748700291,
0.0367055759,
-0.378993541,
-0.7467887998,
-0.5238960981,
0.3593640029,
-0.6254745722,
-0.615531683,
-0.4405253232,
-0.6555977464,
-0.1463689804,
0.0658963174,
0.1672569364,
0.1889537722,
-0.2916581929,
-0.0528772958,
0.4801249504,
-0.3495880067,
0.2275094241,
0.7039985657,
-0.5477716923,
0.0347435549,
0.8534731865,
0.0783896521,
0.5030874014,
0.1312083006,
0.3486017883,
-0.0377849005,
-0.4441143572,
-0.0282900929,
0.5190711617,
-0.7032893896,
0.4837392569,
-0.4969809055,
-0.057057362,
-0.1848933399,
0.1833046377,
-0.2776817381,
-0.2092763931,
-0.2294987142,
-0.2759091556,
0.1372833848,
1.1194865704,
-0.0836921856,
0.1495913714,
-0.573145628,
0.6244317889,
0.460352242,
0.0843064189,
0.0844705701,
-0.8688169718,
-0.1342734694,
0.3322214186,
-0.2885779738,
-0.8768515587,
0.3939585984,
0.2729700208,
0.3967502117,
0.4813921452,
-0.2859337926,
0.8381624222,
-0.334253788,
0.7690398693,
0.0969552845,
-1.0209650993,
0.5789494514,
-0.3500586748,
0.4877277315,
0.230908215,
0.114107281,
-0.3439359963,
-0.6930114627,
-0.8621757627,
-0.4609748125,
0.4388459623,
0.0326706171,
0.1687839478,
-0.3056281805,
0.259968102,
0.0870231092,
0.1407017112,
-0.9934698343,
-0.1097023636,
0.0646012872,
0.1277199239,
-0.2093318403,
-0.3628477752,
0.1252149642,
-0.7447413206,
0.264639616,
0.0267776381,
0.2158599198,
0.1860856712,
-0.4078248441,
-0.3639321625,
0.094282642,
0.7019357085,
0.8776745796,
-0.249491483,
0.4708751142,
0.237075448,
-0.5032504201,
0.2041684687,
-0.4631750882,
-0.2175690979,
0.0093954178,
0.8202530742,
1.047311902,
0.6526753902,
-0.9656646252,
0.5268537998,
0.1096268222,
-0.3663156927,
-0.3630875945,
0.0839047357,
0.1876552701,
0.1878115088,
0.2194360793,
0.2233477384,
-0.1225295067,
-0.8292409182,
0.1460886151,
0.3134731948,
-0.5103191137,
-0.6867260337,
0.6521759033,
-0.083617799,
-0.4014177024,
0.7615110874,
-0.3845390081,
-0.5098770857,
0.7486515045,
0.6569417715,
0.6895188093,
-0.0307927281,
0.1094234511,
0.1055648699,
0.5792644024,
0.0270822123,
0.7366600633,
-0.1061982438,
-0.9693080187,
-0.3333921134,
-0.7104496956,
-0.415165484,
-0.0550341494,
-0.5573990345,
-0.0357307196,
-0.52778548,
-0.0607493632,
-0.3851840496,
-0.1632234454,
-0.8960268497,
0.0986460745,
0.277028501,
0.9146177173,
-1.0478935242,
0.7299948931,
0.2868273258,
-0.5499962568,
-0.8496282101,
-0.2018074542,
-0.0808594078,
-1.0239374638,
1.2771995068,
-0.1105963513,
-0.0208374579,
-0.1319863796,
-0.5378499031,
-0.7271918058,
0.6929293871,
0.6187892556,
-0.5996181965,
-0.0096608549,
0.1757935286,
0.5146704316,
-0.0668763593,
0.3289526701,
0.4100764692,
0.5761272311,
-0.0677194893,
-1.1350368261,
-0.2420330942,
-0.1465994269,
-0.071650818,
-0.0640350133,
-0.4798028767,
1.0295718908,
-0.5501001477,
-0.3172159493,
-0.0130489934,
0.5623856187,
0.5651085377,
0.3678640127,
0.3954250216,
0.9569126368,
0.7859808803,
-0.0506289676,
1.4278006554,
0.0536920018,
0.3391915858,
0.8629515171,
-0.5316809416,
0.9942880273,
0.6678983569,
-0.2498494387,
0.3903794587,
0.6228501201,
0.1474886239,
0.3868816197,
0.4615468681,
-0.146638751,
-0.4366619885,
-0.26078403,
-0.2010311037,
0.8342972994,
0.2103900313,
-0.4335247874,
0.0512616895,
0.1321806908,
-0.0956137925,
0.1095867157,
-0.0027359049,
0.55756253,
0.6062240005,
-0.364854753,
0.9836610556,
-0.3822867274,
0.6379228234,
-0.3152422011,
0.0635130629,
-0.1702314764,
0.0143191963,
-0.0076709823,
-0.3875114024,
0.2341341823,
-0.0182076655,
-0.1001062617,
-0.2848233581,
0.6219550967,
-0.2809233069,
-0.5877477527,
0.5668256283,
1.0676785707,
0.4158920646,
-0.0322545171,
-0.5051569939,
0.3036298454,
-0.2962722182,
-0.2916878164,
0.2455783933,
0.3152780235,
0.1501772106,
0.8807854652,
0.600140512,
0.4898173809,
0.2853141427,
0.2142778784,
0.3885347545,
-0.9971185923,
-0.0402098261,
-0.9406102896,
0.0515026934,
0.3541426957,
-0.3948810995,
0.6629312038,
0.3802905679,
1.0417752266,
-0.2318880409,
0.5929363966,
0.3331434429,
0.2565436959,
-0.6483290792,
0.6791943312,
-0.7674673796,
0.1556157172,
-0.2426501662,
-0.8383678794,
-0.128879115,
0.6940532327,
-0.283541292,
0.127499029,
1.0595709085,
0.7453294396,
-0.1579870731,
-0.1832257807,
0.7212008834,
0.5726985931,
0.0048219343,
0.6152786016,
1.3600043058,
-0.3489976823,
0.0405410118,
-0.2725816369,
-0.1937315315,
0.0414312482,
-0.5594417453,
-0.9731480479,
-0.5044338107,
-0.2411106378,
-0.1477561742,
0.0344961546,
0.8153281212,
0.7818219066,
-0.3693053424,
-0.6631166935,
-0.1814872324,
0.1770217568,
-0.1864933521,
-0.1764636785,
0.0716597736,
-0.2575964928,
-0.4698440433,
0.7351405621,
0.3889628351,
0.1307908148,
-0.382733196,
-0.1981531084,
-0.0973987356,
-0.1479346305,
0.549621284,
0.3812484741,
-1.240496397,
-0.3168512881,
0.2830232382,
-0.0691743866,
0.0968321636,
0.5138032436,
-0.9595100284,
0.2166463584,
0.4104000628,
0.5335069895,
0.2254830003,
-0.330170989,
0.2993800044,
-0.4231321812,
0.3732744455,
0.1415314227,
0.6342740059,
0.1719138026,
-0.002228529,
0.173236832,
0.7792742252,
-0.2756884694,
-0.8529839516,
0.5384106636,
-1.052942276,
-0.3016097248,
1.2886334658,
0.1719218791,
-0.6330265999,
0.0074143885,
-0.0593870357,
0.1620806605,
-0.067054309,
0.8433815837,
0.7226449251,
0.0289968289,
-0.3286613226,
-0.8948789835,
0.2180411518,
0.6036596298,
-0.5232971311,
-0.2238755524,
0.2315849662,
0.341473788,
-0.0050804527,
0.8347089887,
0.2482218593,
0.3032250404,
0.2003929913,
0.2266144156,
0.040671505,
-0.5513372421,
-0.4637100399,
0.0564061925,
0.4455027282,
-0.1009043157
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11347v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11347v1
|
PhaseEvo: Towards Unified In-Context Prompt Optimization for Large Language Models
| 2024-02-17T17:47:10 | 2024-02-17T17:47:10 |
Wendi Cui, Jiaxin Zhang, Zhuohang Li, Hao Sun, Damien Lopez, Kamalika Das, Bradley Malin, Sricharan Kumar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Crafting an ideal prompt for Large Language Models (LLMs) is a challenging
task that demands significant resources and expert human input. Existing work
treats the optimization of prompt instruction and in-context learning examples
as distinct problems, leading to sub-optimal prompt performance. This research
addresses this limitation by establishing a unified in-context prompt
optimization framework, which aims to achieve joint optimization of the prompt
instruction and examples. However, formulating such optimization in the
discrete and high-dimensional natural language space introduces challenges in
terms of convergence and computational efficiency. To overcome these issues, we
present PhaseEvo, an efficient automatic prompt optimization framework that
combines the generative capability of LLMs with the global search proficiency
of evolution algorithms. Our framework features a multi-phase design
incorporating innovative LLM-based mutation operators to enhance search
efficiency and accelerate convergence. We conduct an extensive evaluation of
our approach across 35 benchmark tasks. The results demonstrate that PhaseEvo
significantly outperforms the state-of-the-art baseline methods by a large
margin whilst maintaining good efficiency.
|
[
-0.249278605,
-0.6387748122,
0.8454239368,
0.4736594558,
-0.4422231317,
0.0369591117,
-0.186117053,
0.1026937738,
-0.3222008646,
0.2201918215,
-0.9879371524,
-0.5226983428,
-0.1520391405,
0.6947227716,
-0.2263777107,
0.4800878763,
0.0579071715,
0.0782824233,
-0.3954632282,
0.0677024573,
-0.6758626103,
-0.0334413499,
-0.9354199767,
-0.2770624757,
0.2964371741,
0.6881784797,
0.2413321137,
0.5139677525,
-0.2194810659,
0.4085856676,
-0.2786240578,
0.4199476838,
-0.3517650366,
0.7302021384,
0.0933961719,
-0.1886788905,
-0.0312052947,
-0.5874029994,
0.8078706861,
0.525175631,
-0.1683930457,
-0.2955600023,
0.188631922,
0.4692917466,
-0.4552835226,
0.1239528432,
-0.545463264,
0.0262904167,
0.1580019891,
-0.2948447466,
-0.4478432536,
-0.6278231144,
0.2498633415,
-1.0871691704,
0.2584534585,
0.363096267,
0.317583859,
0.2442161292,
-0.3357031941,
-0.4423727393,
-0.3588897586,
0.8075187206,
-0.6357153654,
0.2696620226,
-0.1049427316,
0.1839989126,
-0.7966200113,
-0.2935071588,
-0.6255941391,
-0.2580249608,
0.176431343,
-0.1040122807,
0.0912847444,
0.2936169505,
0.0900032595,
0.1320891529,
-0.6683860421,
0.3196606636,
0.2896139026,
-0.0964681059,
0.2708063424,
0.2861219049,
0.5043861866,
-0.2966261506,
-0.1866768301,
-0.1466064453,
-0.5777618289,
0.174399808,
0.1448638886,
0.4161256552,
-0.044194106,
0.1706418842,
-0.2566203177,
0.6948231459,
0.2273398936,
-0.2655856907,
0.0383222066,
-0.3300598264,
0.0657772571,
-0.0332581326,
0.7903751731,
0.1987323165,
-0.2229194045,
-0.170130372,
-0.2996622026,
-0.4619331956,
0.0307595506,
-0.8296021819,
0.3921142817,
0.4782163501,
0.1158089712,
-0.1916594654,
-0.3377968967,
-1.2141062021,
-0.4791164994,
-0.4527736008,
0.3886708617,
-0.3641232252,
0.1814518869,
0.0740219951,
-0.0244848598,
0.164238885,
0.6425205469,
-0.8823491335,
-0.0919657424,
0.7727822661,
0.8383021951,
-0.0619678907,
-0.2814798951,
-0.9404022098,
-0.0926601514,
-0.380020678,
0.670240581,
-0.7288485765,
-0.796546042,
0.3301677406,
-0.043744348,
-0.0802267566,
-0.3487141132,
0.7816013098,
-0.3988699615,
0.5176951289,
-0.4761565328,
-0.3737741411,
-0.0273721255,
0.0148136141,
-0.2484866232,
1.216697216,
0.3316725492,
-0.3624343574,
0.3443875611,
-0.7613660693,
-0.5206119418,
0.5411757827,
-0.1265175492,
-0.258726567,
0.2417136133,
0.4336172342,
0.45868662,
-0.8482775092,
0.5499178767,
-0.0223362166,
-0.3039215505,
0.0188467186,
0.0884010419,
0.5989948511,
0.1940159202,
-0.6030446291,
0.5045531988,
-0.6884068251,
-0.2325774878,
0.155372858,
-0.2216040194,
-0.5285061002,
0.1326132864,
-0.3875321746,
0.0346999615,
0.1249351576,
-0.5186735988,
0.3652948141,
-0.5142990351,
0.4886712432,
0.8651151061,
0.046547018,
0.6621197462,
-0.1132316142,
0.7987213135,
-0.2316120267,
0.4669466615,
-0.5682855844,
-0.3741234243,
-0.6861795783,
-0.4272505045,
-0.0117733106,
0.5869381428,
-0.9854320288,
0.7456528544,
-0.2030762434,
-0.0332276039,
-0.4767606854,
0.2943219543,
0.3711123466,
0.7734892368,
0.2008511871,
0.0729445145,
-0.2497075796,
-0.7668801546,
0.0447590649,
0.1707922518,
-0.0348051302,
0.3163389266,
0.2946393788,
-0.3539501727,
1.0063009262,
-0.222925514,
0.1980076134,
-0.4669074416,
0.1538284272,
0.3152419627,
0.3439891934,
0.4171625078,
-0.5833723545,
-0.4581906796,
0.0518540069,
-0.797482729,
-0.5910515785,
-0.290040195,
-0.2965017855,
0.2257909775,
0.3965271413,
-0.3701432943,
-0.3010645807,
0.4026438296,
-0.2181813866,
0.2997172177,
-0.4100168049,
0.3405149281,
-1.2903428078,
-0.0826376677,
0.0737930611,
-0.0617423393,
-0.7717739344,
0.2790591717,
0.082096599,
-0.537060976,
-0.384950459,
0.9403358698,
-0.5727494955,
0.2426336855,
-0.0740477219,
0.3881892264,
0.0472279415,
0.3562677205,
-0.4459873438,
0.8112584949,
0.770242095,
-0.6129333973,
0.295899719,
0.2098771185,
-0.1859379411,
0.7444655895,
-0.7317578793,
0.375918597,
-0.5504007339,
0.3368937075,
-0.9675589204,
-0.2828219831,
0.2514587939,
0.0628148988,
0.421826154,
-0.0802464709,
-0.6068091989,
-0.4271108806,
-0.6687682867,
0.5038875937,
0.4734168351,
-0.8223790526,
0.6893100142,
-0.0985970944,
-0.3137171865,
-0.5031538606,
0.1598388106,
0.0240159575,
-0.3183048666,
-0.6888203621,
0.0631161556,
-0.44856444,
-0.1162493676,
-0.5511375666,
-0.0702895373,
0.3974311948,
0.1010277048,
0.0218393803,
0.179084003,
0.094930999,
0.0076853121,
0.5778520703,
-0.1023382396,
-0.1288542449,
-0.4547928572,
0.8417784572,
0.1897788942,
-0.0609297156,
-0.5448712111,
0.5199716091,
0.4201408625,
0.0471674837,
0.3466672599,
0.1362492144,
-0.0453274511,
-0.8428794742,
-0.4182700217,
-0.1277098209,
-0.6090952754,
0.2572899759,
-0.5008434653,
-0.9134989977,
0.3802959025,
-0.21336779,
0.2491098344,
0.2030255944,
0.3292431831,
0.2639143765,
0.957947135,
0.4619794488,
-0.0046546324,
0.5322348475,
-0.0414052457,
0.0854377225,
-0.784332633,
-0.3861072361,
-0.8122410178,
0.0460761338,
-0.2505288422,
-0.4822156131,
0.6847611666,
0.2061607838,
-0.1679706573,
0.2759917378,
-0.603823185,
0.5289612412,
0.6664088964,
-0.0268181507,
0.1936759353,
-0.090890497,
-0.3258825243,
0.0175712444,
-0.8742503524,
-0.2981137633,
0.8840262294,
0.0043953257,
0.4894886911,
-0.1303202659,
0.7246119976,
0.2199146301,
0.025545314,
-0.6868667603,
0.6981061101,
0.0048974357,
-0.2144283801,
-0.4071692228,
-0.6148909926,
-1.0126515627,
0.4128033221,
-0.0172874201,
-0.5644302368,
0.2623108923,
0.2003744394,
-0.3110869527,
-0.1653137803,
-0.6179314852,
0.8758869767,
-0.1037389338,
-0.1266602576,
-0.0181861818,
-0.5555517673,
0.1651940197,
-0.3896876276,
0.5361911654,
-0.2038481832,
-0.2348079979,
0.3826577961,
-0.4935264587,
0.6647126079,
-0.1305351853,
-0.2491950691,
0.1350973696,
0.1733559668,
0.6662544012,
0.3714004457,
-0.2075629681,
-0.2198932022,
-0.2597051263,
-0.380250901,
-0.5337352157,
0.8322702646,
-0.4952415526,
-0.3612269461,
-0.3162338436,
-0.4604047537,
-0.2923760116,
0.2063782364,
0.4412024021,
1.0832977295,
-0.1989719272,
-0.1417795122,
0.8979484439,
-0.5709343553,
0.8188163638,
0.5116793513,
-0.0041008582,
-0.5701025128,
0.7496285439,
-0.5860195756,
0.280847609,
0.5744131207,
0.4834955931,
-0.3104651868,
-0.6358833909,
-0.702732563,
0.3543760777,
-0.7225405574,
-0.2198958099,
-0.5552674532,
0.389952749,
-0.4580269158,
-0.6004173756,
0.074635461,
0.121853441,
-0.4519841373,
0.4410678744,
0.1989186555,
0.4707003832,
0.152430445,
0.3802159727,
-0.6276730895,
0.3326559365,
0.552514255,
-0.0364583582,
-0.0987021104,
-0.5071623921,
0.0911142901,
-0.103226319,
-0.2165743113,
-0.744833827,
0.3434036076,
0.4139870405,
0.6161634326,
0.3127462864,
0.2338576019,
0.4405903518,
-0.6302719116,
0.73573488,
0.161992833,
-1.0951648951,
0.7323743105,
-0.5317600369,
0.7743999362,
0.6450687051,
0.4321992993,
-0.7397847772,
-0.4227670133,
-0.2705232799,
-1.0527275801,
0.8546253443,
0.0893396065,
0.2122335881,
-0.0628931597,
0.6606231928,
0.3677123189,
0.3650969267,
-0.2988452613,
-0.2844846845,
0.1141835749,
-0.4247513711,
-0.0597634763,
-0.3131730556,
-0.2371233553,
-0.25641644,
0.6959761381,
-0.532948494,
0.1917780191,
0.1857265383,
-0.1803514212,
-0.3057487011,
0.4696053565,
0.9055894613,
0.5283166766,
0.1211396605,
-0.3060352206,
0.2640436292,
-0.3193665445,
0.283893913,
0.3329396844,
-0.6350361109,
0.0967985839,
0.2627955675,
0.865296185,
0.625798285,
-0.7970527411,
0.4744899273,
-0.1484458596,
-0.0828214809,
-0.1173903793,
0.2328495234,
-0.3350639343,
0.3595469892,
0.6224668026,
-0.3964018524,
0.2723889351,
-0.4979656339,
-0.1234374568,
0.4031299651,
0.0696607307,
-0.3543379605,
0.7901529074,
0.5196968913,
-0.6242021918,
0.4291651845,
-0.5630143881,
-0.6828878522,
0.4399363101,
0.4855335355,
1.2938396931,
-0.3719711304,
0.449565351,
0.3521729112,
0.0717717633,
-0.304638952,
0.3224286139,
-0.1925087571,
-0.4398446381,
-0.4519287646,
-0.809920609,
-0.5291290879,
-0.1446835846,
-0.0837157667,
0.4303048551,
-0.5512185693,
0.3016404212,
-0.4140419662,
-0.0776269734,
-0.3986031711,
-0.0833556354,
0.0454376526,
0.5468839407,
-0.4292888939,
0.5707849264,
0.484891355,
0.1117068976,
-0.4334150553,
-0.1826039702,
0.1498308331,
-0.7751569152,
0.3629853129,
0.2887354493,
-0.115114145,
0.179645434,
-0.454300046,
-0.7299332023,
1.0210766792,
0.505328238,
-0.7791393995,
-0.1644408852,
-0.0333431475,
0.2700356245,
-0.5412673354,
0.2521645725,
0.3431824744,
0.3572276533,
0.3788089454,
-0.8031885624,
0.1591668278,
0.0883799195,
0.3993121982,
0.5118698478,
-0.5785834789,
0.4550153613,
-0.0343353674,
-0.3471522629,
0.1678916216,
0.4995221496,
0.3140063286,
0.2201105356,
0.7214557528,
0.4049214721,
0.7033000588,
-0.1708067358,
1.0949651003,
-0.4170036316,
0.1549604684,
0.7633363605,
-0.1976981014,
0.2881742716,
0.2763587236,
0.1145466864,
0.4423004389,
0.6808080673,
0.4265831113,
0.5301890969,
0.2359290421,
-0.7227327824,
-0.0969115496,
-0.1149383336,
-0.1933502257,
-0.1811044216,
0.0881102234,
0.0153335342,
-0.3148661852,
0.1728047132,
0.2825313509,
0.0066806041,
-0.3267241418,
0.7098219991,
-0.0239041485,
-0.7705187201,
0.595813632,
-0.2063884437,
0.7880948782,
-0.7177705765,
0.1739208698,
-0.6321737766,
-0.1667102873,
0.2114214599,
-0.1200743541,
-0.3296593726,
-0.138037324,
0.1753065586,
-0.5010076761,
0.1642157286,
-0.4562633634,
-0.2995624244,
0.1266711056,
0.0814725608,
-0.1473807693,
-0.0058146473,
-0.6848020554,
0.1508844644,
-0.0172798242,
-0.2062260211,
0.2260815948,
0.685967803,
0.1394203901,
0.7346020341,
0.5771272779,
-0.1543090194,
0.1457204372,
0.1911942065,
0.7886348367,
-0.512722671,
-0.4220463932,
-0.6552316546,
0.530644238,
-0.1587429941,
-0.8635002375,
0.56175071,
0.37697348,
0.417489022,
0.0903691724,
0.5338065028,
-0.0068096737,
0.2606410086,
-0.6747834682,
0.0618140809,
-0.8029042482,
0.1844257861,
-0.4388601184,
-1.304202199,
-0.147865966,
0.2551894486,
0.0710496008,
-0.1243244857,
0.8873815536,
0.8195958734,
0.2372385859,
0.0665073991,
0.259694308,
0.0807913914,
0.3676100671,
0.5079033971,
0.6008574963,
-0.173001036,
0.2138846219,
-0.2162721753,
-0.3755522072,
-0.32590276,
-0.9673629403,
-0.9630593657,
-0.8432828188,
-0.2924834788,
-0.0101480493,
0.1347397417,
1.2938158512,
0.5599143505,
-0.6663225889,
-0.3142901659,
-0.2357636541,
0.0981162786,
0.1184518561,
-0.1918297708,
0.0604044087,
-0.8727706671,
-1.0554081202,
1.0475547314,
0.4614351392,
0.0002458069,
-0.3108619452,
-0.1773958504,
0.0822800621,
0.1063459963,
0.8188825846,
0.4212386906,
-0.6104217172,
-0.1986259967,
0.1845588684,
-0.0556776747,
-0.1670465022,
1.011190176,
-0.5009034276,
0.7898254991,
0.7365894914,
0.7360624075,
0.2379289865,
0.0814189687,
0.9326604009,
-0.7034167647,
0.2207888514,
0.3058495224,
0.3889456093,
0.4517043233,
-0.3558951914,
0.2091193497,
0.3050678372,
-0.6812778711,
-0.8428294659,
0.1623415202,
-1.0678077936,
-0.4742156565,
1.3076865673,
0.2400948703,
-0.3211807013,
-0.1472004056,
-0.2390605509,
-0.0290525425,
-0.960696578,
0.7303993106,
0.4859024584,
-0.0297857877,
-0.1942154616,
-0.6237280369,
0.5785527825,
0.5359413624,
-0.9844089746,
-0.1386400014,
0.7026010752,
0.0792623758,
-0.2051585019,
0.5099635124,
0.3480279744,
0.1054855809,
-0.3893392384,
0.1273893118,
0.1062277406,
-0.4323987365,
-0.8800878525,
0.1250632107,
0.1038078368,
0.0900535583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11324v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11324v1
|
EVEDIT: Event-based Knowledge Editing with Deductive Editing Boundaries
| 2024-02-17T16:34:50 | 2024-02-17T16:34:50 |
Jiateng Liu, Pengfei Yu, Yuji Zhang, Sha Li, Zixuan Zhang, Heng Ji
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The dynamic nature of real-world information necessitates efficient knowledge
editing (KE) in large language models (LLMs) for knowledge updating. However,
current KE approaches, which typically operate on (subject, relation, object)
triples, ignore the contextual information and the relation among different
knowledge. Such editing methods could thus encounter an uncertain editing
boundary, leaving a lot of relevant knowledge in ambiguity: Queries that could
be answered pre-edit cannot be reliably answered afterward. In this work, we
analyze this issue by introducing a theoretical framework for KE that
highlights an overlooked set of knowledge that remains unchanged and aids in
knowledge deduction during editing, which we name as the deduction anchor. We
further address this issue by proposing a novel task of event-based knowledge
editing that pairs facts with event descriptions. This task manifests not only
a closer simulation of real-world editing scenarios but also a more logically
sound setting, implicitly defining the deduction anchor to address the issue of
indeterminate editing boundaries. We empirically demonstrate the superiority of
event-based editing over the existing setting on resolving uncertainty in
edited models, and curate a new benchmark dataset EvEdit derived from the
CounterFact dataset. Moreover, while we observe that the event-based setting is
significantly challenging for existing approaches, we propose a novel approach
Self-Edit that showcases stronger performance, achieving 55.6% consistency
improvement while maintaining the naturalness of generation.
|
[
-0.1216944009,
-1.1680366993,
0.9007154107,
-0.0879792869,
-0.0487504005,
0.0609942004,
-0.2618528306,
-0.6315199733,
0.0509810969,
0.1311382949,
-0.6365994811,
-0.5893029571,
-0.5601659417,
0.1174445897,
-0.1487443,
0.5776962042,
-0.3358562887,
-0.4646778107,
-0.5379714966,
-0.280615747,
-0.5123047233,
-0.4752476811,
-0.6334571838,
-0.0470534377,
0.34383443,
0.4709065557,
0.7662709951,
1.1040741205,
0.3777012825,
0.167750001,
-0.438262701,
0.4388563037,
-0.2556330264,
0.2563251853,
-0.5855711699,
-0.4121764004,
-0.8552236557,
-0.0379552394,
0.6786252856,
0.6522695422,
0.1161635667,
0.1644348949,
0.1329092085,
0.6308351755,
-0.855985105,
-0.0836204216,
-0.8095980287,
0.0228613541,
-0.2033486515,
0.1358476281,
-0.1343878359,
-0.1157441437,
-0.0013164907,
-0.8452200294,
0.023868138,
-0.2713171244,
0.6441245675,
0.5795458555,
-0.3392057121,
-0.0594529696,
-0.8603000641,
0.4363800883,
-0.7421276569,
0.6386635303,
0.3178631961,
-0.3494030535,
-0.3187488914,
-0.6374925971,
-0.7401573062,
0.317620039,
0.2210669369,
-0.0192470141,
-0.3596735895,
0.1196201816,
0.4291831255,
-0.0918059275,
-0.1482299119,
0.1743758023,
-0.1192878634,
0.1014606655,
0.7713378072,
0.2165593058,
0.1558903903,
-0.1858923882,
-0.113407135,
0.2295516282,
-1.1453104019,
0.0466102175,
0.3390799165,
-0.1522617042,
0.050910674,
0.4743806422,
-0.4237727821,
0.6906953454,
0.340660274,
0.0740775391,
-0.0561091304,
-0.2447053939,
-0.1554098129,
0.2531374097,
0.5168704391,
0.8170288801,
0.0925796852,
0.0378706008,
0.1999792308,
-0.1242311448,
-0.016116906,
-0.4691349566,
-0.0387334675,
0.3453734517,
-0.3125232458,
-0.3248593807,
-0.3230488896,
-0.6081638336,
-0.4769748449,
-0.3560958803,
0.3447204232,
-0.3030647635,
-0.0762066394,
0.0475057401,
0.081038028,
-0.1664547622,
0.5663317442,
-0.3743231297,
-0.0323538072,
0.670709312,
0.4481421113,
0.1311651319,
-0.3644444644,
-0.5306880474,
0.4851633012,
-0.3370488286,
0.6179019809,
-0.9190783501,
-0.1788715571,
-0.2593911588,
-0.1955715269,
0.0723012611,
-0.0760247856,
0.6130533218,
-0.6744412184,
-0.085862197,
-0.3538376689,
-0.9942626953,
-0.1182707772,
0.2894210517,
-0.5611355901,
0.9550855756,
-0.3644419611,
-0.7293042541,
0.5368501544,
-0.4955082834,
-0.3199270964,
-0.2402133048,
-0.0910300836,
-0.2380104661,
0.1209974736,
0.396228075,
0.1572182328,
0.1597727984,
0.582224369,
-0.3976354003,
-0.0771670565,
0.3500134349,
-0.3804421425,
0.4577093124,
-0.0419778004,
-0.4271160662,
-0.1282015741,
-1.2499010563,
-0.1904883385,
-0.1089382097,
-0.1575133353,
-0.6966312528,
0.3429858088,
-0.5658458471,
0.3187729418,
0.3070127666,
-0.757202208,
0.6174512506,
-0.252612859,
0.253888011,
0.7254991531,
0.3851343989,
0.4244728684,
0.0824548975,
0.4645142853,
0.0232221633,
0.1301995218,
-0.1782475561,
-0.4298343956,
-0.643951118,
0.1244728267,
0.5362690091,
0.6728323102,
-0.5207368731,
0.2804522216,
-0.010238166,
-0.393165797,
-0.6961398125,
0.1716797203,
0.2661247253,
0.7847300768,
0.4118711352,
0.2343285382,
-0.8684830666,
-0.6845796108,
-0.7815800905,
-0.2009840608,
0.3909807801,
0.0245533735,
0.2949592471,
-0.1325466484,
1.1210142374,
-0.6075550318,
-0.1219590604,
-0.1226113588,
0.1920215786,
0.1147565916,
0.5626841784,
0.2280565351,
-0.5849381685,
-0.2733939588,
-0.2570874989,
-0.7747113109,
-0.3939264417,
-0.4438076317,
-0.1459670663,
0.3908188939,
0.748775661,
-0.5263748169,
0.8827812672,
0.3593088686,
-0.6002221107,
0.4815484583,
-0.2852691412,
0.3295456767,
-0.7632927895,
-0.1475015581,
-0.3870638907,
-0.133965686,
-0.5155543685,
-0.1400970817,
0.2826953232,
0.3339443803,
-0.3171071112,
0.7124655247,
-0.3151447773,
0.3939628899,
-0.2429326326,
0.3570354581,
0.2758255899,
0.3717041314,
0.1085015237,
0.2802066207,
0.279771179,
-0.5748392344,
0.2727349997,
0.6796123981,
-0.2165961862,
0.8380382061,
-0.4444570839,
0.3080987334,
-0.252294749,
0.2125360966,
-0.6685658693,
-0.0117086302,
0.2054362446,
-0.2330809981,
0.0563001558,
-0.3912569284,
-0.2658352256,
-0.0433737896,
-0.2870464325,
0.6264220476,
0.192316249,
-0.4210659266,
0.5647496581,
0.192551598,
-0.3372910321,
-0.8326019645,
-0.6970062852,
0.4300426245,
-0.224207148,
-0.7680144906,
0.4943197668,
-0.0806219429,
-0.7517551184,
0.4640818834,
-0.2862562239,
0.0174566749,
0.1860390604,
0.2044697553,
0.2120425105,
0.0460106917,
0.3511647284,
0.3793742657,
-0.0881097764,
-0.0144088045,
-0.2883621454,
-0.2794589698,
0.1655259877,
-0.5274733901,
-0.5075490475,
0.2448751032,
0.4178209305,
-0.362229377,
0.7144914865,
0.2391752154,
-0.6335403323,
-0.1274365485,
-0.9366878271,
0.095559828,
-0.3679748774,
0.3351868391,
-0.6356027722,
-0.8592048287,
0.777972579,
0.1259903312,
0.0500824228,
0.8111707568,
0.1667617559,
-0.1919029504,
0.7429257631,
0.5465518832,
0.4153984189,
0.0722779036,
0.0832558274,
0.2000450492,
-1.2231075764,
-0.0932865813,
-0.279307574,
-0.558080554,
-0.2976544797,
-0.4578472674,
0.4878061712,
0.5251531601,
0.053573817,
0.1595822126,
-0.1676151454,
0.5884786248,
0.4669501483,
0.0344670303,
0.8095501661,
-0.6300954819,
0.0030778944,
-0.3101183176,
-1.0047324896,
-0.417119652,
1.1191226244,
0.2677102387,
0.8095642924,
-0.1020948663,
0.7283722162,
0.3577805161,
-0.031775292,
-0.1564814448,
0.3239554763,
0.2504329979,
-0.7111268044,
-0.5479261279,
-0.1646952927,
-0.5708448291,
-0.069273591,
-0.2848200798,
-0.8896068335,
0.7347790599,
0.5157141685,
-0.6250545382,
0.786218822,
-0.3627935946,
0.9714581966,
-0.127752617,
-0.8423469067,
-0.2898751497,
-0.6300621629,
-0.0084386133,
-0.1185783073,
0.5981563926,
-0.1937179118,
0.0259925742,
0.7739132047,
-0.3751569092,
0.8631795645,
-0.1361160576,
-0.2974442542,
0.6590874195,
0.5785223246,
1.055531621,
0.4214302003,
-0.2091953456,
0.0030830156,
0.0426344164,
0.1800975949,
-0.688601017,
0.5223365426,
-0.4959448278,
-0.6845937371,
-0.0448744707,
-0.6141679287,
-0.2753539383,
-0.0288044289,
0.2337595522,
0.7545307279,
-0.466282934,
-0.0815011561,
0.6353980303,
-0.2081837058,
0.5270758867,
0.4353968501,
0.0085410746,
-0.2362455577,
0.3408704102,
0.4040121138,
0.1651608646,
0.438467443,
0.0936817825,
-0.1638915092,
-0.5119469762,
-0.6069190502,
-0.1159523204,
-0.9152192473,
-0.3096577227,
-1.1042094231,
0.0063444083,
-0.3220568895,
-0.5592005253,
-0.5804958344,
-0.9371758103,
-0.1207292303,
-0.329881072,
0.5528019071,
0.7514491081,
-0.820864737,
0.119666867,
-0.9187278748,
0.3243806958,
0.3170119524,
0.5668102503,
-0.0881307721,
-0.3850732148,
-0.3000979424,
0.1513733268,
-0.1050416753,
-1.0190688372,
-0.0784911662,
0.2570300996,
0.4830809832,
0.2088333815,
0.1802097857,
0.7181421518,
-0.5802387595,
0.666752696,
-0.31288445,
-1.2995775938,
0.8259217739,
-0.4044998586,
0.3441284895,
0.7321494222,
0.0494918637,
-0.834177196,
-0.6604211926,
-1.1333961487,
-0.7945709825,
0.5479192138,
0.1398957968,
-0.2361600399,
-0.1015864313,
0.6545824409,
0.1763678193,
0.2594451308,
-0.5751655698,
-0.1009333804,
0.2215848714,
-0.186259985,
0.3713562489,
-0.7166334987,
-0.0066636922,
-0.4215792418,
0.9595103264,
0.1504677683,
-0.1480708867,
0.7244167328,
-0.4656778276,
-0.3615276814,
0.4882397354,
0.5345848799,
1.1903079748,
-0.3352323472,
0.3303120136,
0.6507953405,
-0.1939456165,
0.1630877703,
0.1124771684,
-0.4239035249,
-0.1201727241,
0.5905455947,
0.6978153586,
0.2863638401,
-0.4642413855,
0.3511969149,
0.1811260879,
-0.1324430555,
-0.0565031059,
-0.0198614933,
0.0531359352,
0.4166136086,
0.1673568934,
0.0160706267,
0.1121642664,
-0.2214603722,
0.3520551622,
0.1811414212,
-0.4137993753,
-0.3744378388,
1.0115032196,
0.4675012231,
-0.1104141399,
0.5170672536,
-0.4099825919,
-0.6367422938,
0.5703542233,
0.2555237114,
0.9352889061,
-0.2603863478,
-0.1280270368,
0.4990149438,
0.5303353071,
0.3890242577,
0.2423808426,
0.1352231205,
-0.9192448854,
-0.9136207104,
-0.4283986092,
-0.4102959037,
0.269770056,
-0.3295190334,
0.3188024759,
-0.1894159168,
0.0362881497,
-0.1664741933,
-0.2905324101,
-0.7006188035,
0.1904252768,
0.3393909037,
1.1041828394,
-0.6142727137,
0.5052292347,
0.7512398362,
0.0650611669,
-0.4816429317,
-0.2251034528,
0.1660809964,
-0.3333489597,
0.4204895496,
-0.193169713,
-0.0386518687,
-0.0275209919,
-0.3859899044,
-1.0137687922,
0.7085998058,
0.0592200235,
-0.8158170581,
-0.1717468202,
0.117672421,
0.2931404114,
-0.2632867396,
-0.0852264091,
0.7176883817,
0.7940350175,
-0.1919253767,
-0.8141543269,
0.1575376242,
0.0510735586,
-0.4545131624,
0.2608574033,
-0.4314248562,
0.4428396821,
-0.2467537075,
0.1053524539,
-0.328332752,
0.6494488716,
-0.1578925401,
0.3484050035,
0.4687868059,
0.912044704,
0.673979342,
-0.0202615615,
0.5865285397,
-0.3793797195,
0.1947465241,
1.6266232729,
-0.2673859596,
0.4756594002,
0.4209703505,
-0.0341714174,
0.6317136884,
0.316536814,
0.1563403755,
0.2986485362,
-0.1755633652,
-0.1123644933,
-0.4760211408,
0.0289680138,
-0.2116367519,
0.7018085718,
0.3995189667,
-0.0376989916,
-0.2728476226,
0.0358613022,
0.4261455536,
0.1526838541,
-0.3439183831,
0.8026701808,
-0.0577831157,
-0.7356696725,
0.0724069551,
0.1339834332,
0.1475708336,
-0.3414160013,
-0.2512291968,
-0.0116992947,
0.1476650238,
-0.1637715697,
-0.9867922664,
0.6348026395,
0.0985645801,
-0.236472398,
-0.1839920282,
0.983499527,
-0.5778902769,
-0.4698037505,
0.0640730858,
0.643181622,
-0.4139767885,
-0.1935145408,
-0.4761912227,
0.3318809569,
0.049534969,
-0.5693445802,
-0.2113108188,
0.8978887796,
-0.1736938357,
0.3731743991,
0.3992455304,
0.0856543258,
-0.0917606056,
-0.2465396821,
0.4741120636,
-0.789537549,
-0.6778339744,
-1.1601032019,
0.8585186601,
-0.17162925,
-0.3451853693,
0.4956672788,
0.4208238721,
0.736371696,
0.2808191776,
0.8944327235,
-0.2340406328,
0.3802664578,
-0.5337321758,
0.3728689849,
-0.4120613933,
0.1041299254,
-0.4962366223,
-0.8513358235,
-0.2995766401,
0.2970677316,
-0.372541815,
-0.4749476612,
0.5951684117,
0.3543128669,
0.0349086151,
0.0967006087,
0.1113576889,
0.5536181927,
0.1869862527,
0.5566017032,
0.9950482845,
-0.3388335705,
0.2759817541,
-0.4258999825,
-0.2702867687,
-0.1524823606,
-1.4269750118,
-0.815525651,
-0.6725354195,
-0.7516593337,
-0.215534538,
0.3057176769,
1.1148115396,
0.2393516153,
-0.4323613346,
0.2567411959,
0.046379853,
0.4824776053,
-0.4255596697,
-0.1561177969,
0.6821778417,
-0.1331252307,
-0.5483201742,
0.5186091661,
0.4332655072,
-0.1124959365,
0.2918511331,
0.3396697342,
-0.569491446,
0.2317447513,
0.4680659473,
0.2201732397,
-0.4180171192,
-0.712123096,
-0.3040547371,
0.1557793766,
0.0868996233,
0.4759676456,
-1.0009357929,
0.6540770531,
0.3671767414,
0.8680635691,
0.4008100331,
0.0187123008,
0.6929938793,
-0.7917686701,
0.1480799615,
-0.0271697398,
0.3769660294,
0.2023335993,
-0.7590931654,
0.690310657,
0.4013805389,
-0.4857621789,
-0.6606080532,
0.2983799577,
-0.772103548,
-0.2480594367,
1.1219501495,
0.0565999188,
-0.1225601137,
-0.024807252,
-0.104252547,
0.4431623816,
0.0563011765,
0.7712904215,
0.8887688518,
-0.2934485376,
0.1403988302,
-0.4486024082,
0.7847560644,
0.3808774352,
-0.619592011,
0.4106610119,
0.6830494404,
0.1482494324,
-0.0080779921,
0.4197889268,
0.0817202181,
0.361222446,
-0.1026644558,
0.3283055425,
-0.4264578819,
-0.4907062054,
-0.1679574996,
-0.0260636825,
0.0363503546,
0.0829217285
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11297v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11297v1
|
MMMModal -- Multi-Images Multi-Audio Multi-turn Multi-Modal
| 2024-02-17T14:37:38 | 2024-02-17T14:37:38 |
Husein Zolkepli, Aisyah Razak, Kamarul Adha, Ariff Nazhan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Our contribution introduces a groundbreaking multimodal large language model
designed to comprehend multi-images, multi-audio, and multi-images-multi-audio
within a single multiturn session. Leveraging state-of-the-art models, we
utilize the SigLIP encoder for visual inputs and the Whisper Encoder for audio
inputs. Notably, this multimodal large language model is bilingual, proficient
in understanding both English and Malay simultaneously. We proudly unveil two
versions of this model: TinyLlama with 1.1B parameters, and Mistral with 7B
parameters. With its ability to navigate diverse modalities and languages, our
model represents a significant advancement for the Malaysian context and
beyond.
All models released at
https://huggingface.co/collections/mesolitica/multimodal-malaysian-llm-65c6f893e03f78fa9e5c8859
|
[
-0.518311739,
-0.8919714093,
0.4756983221,
0.582752049,
-0.1840297282,
-0.3732005358,
-0.262545079,
-0.6282764673,
0.2723096907,
0.4099286497,
-0.8320963383,
-0.3013134599,
-0.7962856293,
-0.0322940461,
-0.0142256403,
0.6140048504,
0.1622278094,
0.4741106033,
-0.0924521163,
-0.5342113376,
-0.5908735991,
-0.3006253839,
-0.5173422694,
-0.2899715304,
0.4428472519,
0.3673044145,
0.9914273024,
0.4369797707,
0.5879356861,
0.326274246,
-0.0290910918,
0.2129320949,
-0.210672453,
-0.0151751116,
0.1117440388,
-0.539812088,
-0.6720695496,
-0.2838155925,
0.8286688328,
0.7096791267,
-0.0501571596,
0.3410517275,
-0.1104812995,
0.3300856352,
-0.5082332492,
0.5497041941,
-0.2828977108,
-0.0000925768,
-0.0676392764,
-0.275536567,
-0.3749120533,
-0.0753148645,
0.0110263126,
-0.5779386163,
-0.4525202513,
-0.0491839573,
0.5374542475,
0.2671189904,
-1.0402475595,
-0.5694374442,
-0.8115603924,
0.7785260081,
-0.7204035521,
0.8367152214,
0.3109682202,
0.4682879448,
0.1038519219,
-0.714055419,
-0.6588510871,
-0.2728484571,
0.1056410298,
0.0817782208,
-0.0158069674,
0.0339547917,
0.1168028638,
0.3332636654,
-0.5121284723,
0.1638583988,
-0.4379332662,
-0.2562726736,
0.4989953041,
0.3637492359,
0.5622311234,
-0.414903909,
-0.4669822454,
-0.070477657,
-0.7205021381,
0.0951769724,
0.1749618948,
0.2895833254,
-0.6411927938,
0.877425909,
0.2116654515,
0.6437674761,
-0.1127490699,
-1.0516403913,
0.2607238889,
-0.5571299791,
-0.3240734637,
-0.0705317035,
0.9714230299,
0.5033254027,
-0.1732116938,
0.2803219557,
-0.1656187922,
0.1454345584,
-0.2229057103,
-0.8788391948,
0.0674887374,
0.1336384118,
-0.7502575517,
-0.0465384983,
-0.1893572062,
-0.7324411273,
-0.3398096859,
-0.3825473189,
0.7561255097,
-0.6086069942,
-0.8508628011,
0.378141582,
0.1675081998,
0.272551775,
0.440166384,
-0.9079503417,
0.1229135022,
0.3689333498,
0.8238582015,
0.1167336628,
-0.5012639761,
-0.1879178137,
0.2973899245,
-0.2118076384,
0.4660659432,
-0.6988488436,
-0.6386390924,
0.092050679,
0.1576831788,
-0.1778431684,
-0.3876653612,
0.4217808843,
-0.4978715181,
0.3533513844,
-0.2041130662,
-0.0809073374,
-0.5741606355,
0.201757744,
-0.9988008738,
0.8338191509,
-0.0396071151,
-0.5705332756,
0.3599110544,
-0.9025901556,
-0.387078464,
-0.2616005838,
-0.104433246,
-0.1085232049,
0.1228162348,
0.4227175713,
0.6900551915,
-0.2749703228,
0.2665690482,
-0.3974253237,
-0.053904701,
0.2436376065,
-0.5624836683,
0.740308702,
0.2230783552,
-0.1309039146,
0.2552196085,
-0.7450196743,
-0.3250395358,
0.3457655013,
-0.402302295,
-0.0991707221,
-0.2464809716,
0.7797611952,
0.6460306048,
0.3991874456,
-0.2917939425,
0.2714125216,
-0.1795346588,
0.452026993,
0.6608487964,
-0.1140801311,
0.6260946393,
-0.3573440909,
0.7354934812,
0.3544512987,
0.243048206,
-0.823464036,
-0.7035709023,
-0.7064321041,
-0.6679836512,
0.0814432353,
0.24171637,
-0.905058682,
-0.2362551987,
-0.2810177505,
-0.4134944379,
-0.8572440147,
0.1788239777,
0.3433035314,
-0.0111927651,
0.2165116817,
-0.1729032695,
-0.687046349,
-0.9826803803,
0.3097412884,
-0.3127022982,
0.0912876204,
0.5445437431,
0.4590898454,
-0.8249512911,
0.5308950543,
-0.1443971246,
-0.4956191778,
-0.4073041081,
0.1607969552,
0.1252888888,
0.3563198447,
0.8755446076,
-0.9953288436,
-0.2667095959,
0.1309031695,
-0.7627245784,
0.1049438864,
-0.1897630394,
0.2508578897,
0.1888840497,
0.5931580067,
-0.8422583342,
0.0481098443,
0.9278059006,
-0.2043219209,
0.6643604636,
-0.0928023085,
0.4516786933,
-1.3643622398,
-0.1533293277,
0.064800106,
-0.2709407508,
-0.3428671956,
0.6360619664,
0.1876078099,
-0.0658505782,
-0.6981258392,
0.5729100704,
-0.6461164355,
0.0464339405,
-0.3529539704,
-0.1772620231,
-0.0937622637,
0.5165979266,
0.0938302353,
0.7386583686,
0.8211402893,
-0.6268061996,
0.499281466,
0.1697300375,
-0.2039953172,
0.5942878127,
-0.7810947895,
-0.1453921795,
-0.1060695201,
0.1067078337,
-1.1468503475,
-0.4999540746,
0.0340890922,
-0.2413053364,
0.508566618,
-0.3470912278,
-0.6854951978,
-0.2427722812,
-0.2588326931,
0.6363794208,
0.2778267264,
-0.6164301038,
0.9651754498,
0.586971879,
-0.3574369848,
-0.2416281551,
-0.6385021806,
0.1331981719,
-0.2492342144,
-0.7232427001,
0.0443668626,
-0.2025736272,
-0.1120923683,
-0.2103652656,
0.1489784122,
-0.1848227084,
-0.2836406529,
0.7201517224,
0.4169276655,
-0.6907374263,
-0.031401705,
0.1702513248,
-0.0543203577,
0.0371369198,
0.0257890616,
0.7691991329,
-0.4448997974,
-0.5915543437,
-0.6420759559,
0.5649268031,
1.1335673332,
-0.1965196431,
0.7394307256,
1.0778063536,
-0.4511716664,
0.4060410857,
-0.5814036727,
-0.0745385289,
-0.5222700238,
0.5447465181,
-0.9004510045,
-1.0789631605,
0.4863727689,
-0.0879376978,
-0.0369664207,
0.537866652,
1.1455919743,
-0.2062166929,
1.3644281626,
1.0787484646,
-0.1568633616,
0.237941727,
-0.1775657088,
0.0427367762,
-0.5858043432,
-0.5171688199,
-0.1449719965,
-0.0244576279,
-0.6557900906,
-0.5551782846,
0.5800987482,
-0.1289494336,
0.074069269,
0.2257783413,
-0.0608599521,
0.2374789417,
0.535586834,
0.1283287555,
0.4923322797,
-0.2455699146,
-0.3765953481,
-0.435470283,
-0.666015625,
-0.543381393,
1.130005002,
0.6832590699,
1.0631989241,
0.4626424313,
0.279173702,
0.0096765719,
0.0237370916,
-1.0339951515,
0.6440853477,
0.2786610723,
-0.7439371347,
0.0615091287,
-0.1619429439,
-0.8125154972,
0.5820752978,
-0.2951171398,
-0.4544008076,
-0.0043512965,
-0.1092882231,
-0.1674821079,
0.2741011083,
-0.9133294821,
0.7826895118,
-0.117980212,
-0.0282899775,
-0.4556340873,
-0.5911934972,
0.881711185,
-0.0863840133,
0.4923601747,
-0.1278932095,
-0.2356625199,
0.5440504551,
-0.0693634003,
0.7126305699,
-0.1146074012,
-0.3085742891,
0.0404176414,
0.2964160442,
-0.1893041283,
0.2059459239,
0.3651990891,
0.2407758683,
0.3701271117,
-0.2563456297,
-0.2730885148,
0.7300717831,
-0.9258642793,
-0.2572609484,
-0.1908568442,
-0.6218861938,
-0.2073523551,
0.1853126734,
0.0659239367,
0.6481457949,
-0.3581355512,
0.223140806,
0.4220532775,
-0.3142784238,
0.5836723447,
0.5874095559,
-0.7414118052,
-0.36598441,
0.752210319,
-0.1504674554,
0.2598379552,
0.3042041957,
-0.0270760581,
-0.5783618093,
-0.2556791902,
-0.5446796417,
0.4832294583,
-0.6809759736,
0.0649338663,
-0.9925962687,
-0.019930521,
-0.4450785816,
0.1029784977,
-0.5801650286,
-0.3910852373,
-0.2731739283,
0.1931189746,
0.0377042778,
0.8905828595,
-0.2219012976,
0.5181102157,
-0.8428912759,
0.8815070391,
0.6131644845,
0.0895261168,
0.002187649,
-0.7335030437,
-0.2394000739,
0.3001168668,
-0.3009295166,
-0.8024038076,
0.4124731123,
0.2979710698,
0.3697003722,
0.8258630037,
-0.6132239699,
0.9038587213,
-0.7673172951,
0.8111855984,
0.540035069,
-0.7631701231,
0.4767925739,
-0.48326388,
0.5985692143,
0.0838601962,
0.6535459757,
-0.6649397016,
-0.0634657517,
-0.3856135607,
-0.6313576102,
0.5726020336,
-0.2206111848,
0.1339905262,
0.2427419722,
-0.2411700189,
0.3511965871,
0.2391483337,
-0.9278524518,
-0.2448056638,
-0.233314991,
-0.1266222149,
-0.02199688,
-0.7189298868,
-0.108194679,
-0.4347655177,
0.5759398937,
-0.2712170184,
0.5676208735,
-0.3339707553,
-0.4749343395,
-0.1189167649,
0.2939388156,
0.8150891662,
0.5274085402,
-0.1880776733,
0.1851207614,
-0.0366107151,
-0.6619980931,
0.1667970568,
-0.0862611085,
0.3167842031,
0.1982174963,
0.4997788966,
0.7728687525,
0.6161262393,
-0.7381758094,
0.6437969208,
-0.1075760797,
-0.0566613413,
-0.2434806675,
-0.1902940571,
0.4832589924,
0.4432699084,
0.4370567203,
0.1701679528,
0.199625954,
-0.7573019266,
0.0239299685,
0.4243033528,
-0.1506912112,
-0.623303771,
0.9015830159,
-0.0802523792,
0.0672137886,
0.1654343307,
0.0485262051,
-0.3200289011,
0.3039512336,
0.7698913813,
0.5909341574,
-0.4336535931,
0.2005022317,
0.427387774,
0.6191799641,
-0.0576373339,
0.4487628043,
-0.0531395003,
-0.6768189073,
-0.5488829613,
-0.6598697305,
-0.5384537578,
0.1794243753,
-0.8189778328,
0.195770368,
-0.3638930321,
-0.2952201962,
0.2808649838,
-0.2907996476,
-0.7944988608,
0.1178913191,
0.4061750472,
0.7368097305,
-0.934483707,
0.9316681623,
0.9220682383,
-0.5143755674,
-0.6188340187,
-0.3052853644,
0.3203615546,
-1.0084216595,
0.612896204,
0.3267013133,
-0.2528631985,
-0.2883960605,
-0.6081852317,
-0.8133519292,
0.9214226007,
0.3054959774,
-0.4505950511,
-0.0140148988,
0.2502646744,
0.3326880634,
-0.3691863716,
0.4583237767,
0.4593239725,
0.539738059,
0.1024526805,
-1.3957521915,
-0.306622535,
-0.3928588033,
0.0620497353,
-0.0038912529,
-0.7453233004,
0.7412618995,
-0.3950671554,
-0.1463186145,
0.1317823529,
0.7656764984,
0.2164087296,
0.2598687112,
0.4549840093,
0.4881593883,
0.2794127762,
-0.0964977145,
0.9219964743,
-0.0171694309,
0.0656669959,
1.047134161,
-0.0594453625,
0.9360553622,
0.6247551441,
-0.3060908616,
0.1124920547,
0.5698090792,
0.2942994535,
0.5003672242,
-0.7142000198,
-0.2341428548,
-0.1977636069,
-0.4138201475,
-0.6352820992,
0.9482780695,
0.6399280429,
-0.1430124193,
-0.1409933418,
0.6170725822,
-0.0570801236,
-0.1831152737,
-0.4316560924,
0.6779751182,
0.2185151577,
-0.0608253554,
0.548525095,
0.442898035,
1.15635252,
-0.6887850761,
0.1105924919,
0.095357798,
-0.0312317684,
-0.0890595317,
-0.7556290627,
0.126005888,
-0.4823948443,
-0.1081364676,
-0.2070539296,
0.7841688991,
-0.6320182681,
-0.6287649274,
0.3143517375,
0.7368439436,
-0.0614714772,
-0.1089799851,
-0.8102636337,
0.3572443426,
-0.0916969478,
-0.1107937098,
0.142012164,
0.4493479133,
0.1816283762,
0.8348191977,
0.5936570764,
-0.0706357807,
0.3639461398,
0.2844828665,
0.7194618583,
-0.6945701838,
-0.5758748055,
-0.8663377166,
0.3740038574,
0.3752377629,
-0.2477407306,
0.7667704821,
0.5608289242,
0.658280313,
-0.4288328588,
0.4041643739,
0.1530336291,
0.1705528498,
-0.6568972468,
0.7136361003,
-1.0558723211,
-0.160272643,
-0.3855645359,
-0.8307883143,
-0.1698731035,
0.6364277601,
0.0764397085,
0.108789064,
0.5563033819,
0.9559993744,
-0.3646107018,
0.156124711,
0.5552074909,
0.3514725566,
0.1669917107,
0.5810511708,
1.0512447357,
-0.585429728,
0.305036813,
-0.2024046481,
-0.1484361291,
-0.3978088498,
-0.6037537456,
-1.0010683537,
-0.9658434391,
-0.1206573844,
-0.1359893829,
-0.489238292,
1.0450185537,
0.9594481587,
-0.5968125463,
-0.3465388715,
0.7104260325,
-0.0748339444,
-0.0011091327,
-0.235948801,
0.0945612118,
0.0731986761,
-1.0099873543,
0.441680491,
0.8469432592,
0.3011378944,
-0.7797937989,
-0.2201721668,
-0.3071034849,
0.0791286752,
1.0977450609,
0.0878188908,
-0.8471651077,
0.1961451024,
0.0012529994,
-0.3790643811,
0.1759779602,
0.6854259968,
-0.4846159518,
0.4987920225,
0.1128304303,
0.4630847871,
0.8256140351,
-0.7694112659,
0.3994942009,
-0.4223407209,
0.76636976,
0.046036806,
0.7750208378,
0.4090116024,
0.0086431131,
0.2188367099,
0.147962153,
-0.2399620563,
-0.7947022915,
0.2617453635,
-1.5310584307,
-0.1613769829,
1.2114325762,
0.3220665455,
-0.2626315951,
-0.0064906832,
-0.5626431704,
-0.06236526,
-0.1261465698,
0.4562335312,
0.8078779578,
0.4783167243,
-0.669305861,
-0.7262735963,
0.0043816539,
0.3572796583,
-0.6033865809,
-0.6273359656,
0.7352148294,
0.2296287566,
0.145547092,
0.8791117668,
-0.4545871019,
0.5610917211,
0.0822287798,
0.0156860203,
-0.0164076108,
-0.5781723857,
-0.2778645456,
0.2792265713,
0.1602763087,
-0.2475861609
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11296v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11296v1
|
Dissecting Human and LLM Preferences
| 2024-02-17T14:34:31 | 2024-02-17T14:34:31 |
Junlong Li, Fan Zhou, Shichao Sun, Yikai Zhang, Hai Zhao, Pengfei Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
As a relative quality comparison of model responses, human and Large Language
Model (LLM) preferences serve as common alignment goals in model fine-tuning
and criteria in evaluation. Yet, these preferences merely reflect broad
tendencies, resulting in less explainable and controllable models with
potential safety risks. In this work, we dissect the preferences of human and
32 different LLMs to understand their quantitative composition, using
annotations from real-world user-model conversations for a fine-grained,
scenario-wise analysis. We find that humans are less sensitive to errors, favor
responses that support their stances, and show clear dislike when models admit
their limits. On the contrary, advanced LLMs like GPT-4-Turbo emphasize
correctness, clarity, and harmlessness more. Additionally, LLMs of similar
sizes tend to exhibit similar preferences, regardless of their training
methods, and fine-tuning for alignment does not significantly alter the
preferences of pretrained-only LLMs. Finally, we show that preference-based
evaluation can be intentionally manipulated. In both training-free and
training-based settings, aligning a model with the preferences of judges boosts
scores, while injecting the least preferred properties lowers them. This
results in notable score shifts: up to 0.59 on MT-Bench (1-10 scale) and 31.94
on AlpacaEval 2.0 (0-100 scale), highlighting the significant impact of this
strategic adaptation. Interactive Demo:
https://huggingface.co/spaces/GAIR/Preference-Dissection-Visualization Dataset:
https://huggingface.co/datasets/GAIR/preference-dissection Code:
https://github.com/GAIR-NLP/Preference-Dissection
|
[
-0.7384765744,
-0.3901016116,
0.5123393536,
-0.0660066828,
-0.0888027698,
0.1338589489,
-0.3738789558,
-0.5820636153,
0.0653003529,
0.2358042598,
-0.3616957366,
-0.3390348256,
-0.5422360301,
0.0427645184,
0.0187709853,
1.216344595,
-0.048112236,
0.0454641245,
-0.2060304731,
-0.349960357,
-0.345194608,
-0.7377868891,
-0.4871276915,
-0.6511999965,
0.8982059956,
0.4899786711,
1.080478549,
0.6306894422,
0.4250008166,
0.2455458343,
-0.1396055967,
-0.0024674428,
-0.5311830044,
-0.1372888833,
-0.3808217943,
-0.4321886897,
-0.703961432,
0.3382393718,
0.2892604768,
0.638895154,
-0.0370963179,
0.2097872943,
0.2060638815,
0.9292213917,
-0.5732152462,
-0.1015338972,
-0.537778616,
-0.0141345952,
-0.0754500553,
-0.1896342784,
-0.2652487457,
-0.2987493575,
0.3681404591,
-0.4559158981,
0.0431803241,
0.1181199551,
1.0009595156,
0.3849971592,
-0.6729867458,
-0.0698351189,
-0.5578836799,
0.9069339037,
-0.5275324583,
0.3059822619,
0.4934143126,
0.2947715223,
-0.0792159215,
-0.1430566758,
-0.4382772446,
-0.1843027174,
-0.1405710131,
0.0659809783,
-0.167272374,
0.2087305635,
0.1756625772,
0.2554474771,
-0.6403023005,
0.5059454441,
-0.1266827583,
-0.3423165679,
0.8112831712,
0.257829994,
0.2087132931,
-0.2319601178,
-0.2240951955,
-0.3792782426,
-0.7489612699,
0.3332293332,
0.5654415488,
0.1670759022,
-0.193177551,
0.5415887833,
-0.3149836957,
0.6610150337,
0.1825609654,
-0.2111675888,
0.2551917732,
-0.0308266189,
-0.2505040169,
-0.0698092729,
0.8803718686,
0.900868237,
0.449252069,
-0.0668731704,
-0.1683994234,
0.2130030543,
0.2798503935,
-0.5975740552,
-0.0149449687,
0.149518162,
-0.4582667649,
-0.3456766307,
-0.123494029,
-0.5216038227,
-0.547273159,
-0.7370432019,
0.2854625583,
-0.186796844,
0.1391317397,
0.4571843147,
-0.0571231842,
0.3771543801,
0.4102684557,
-1.1931225061,
0.3144108653,
0.717232883,
0.6716619134,
-0.3675279617,
-0.2288158685,
-0.3147251308,
-0.0479008369,
-0.127943337,
0.6925972104,
-0.3413317204,
-0.5027602315,
-0.5130833983,
-0.1654019952,
-0.008245388,
-0.509517312,
0.6003943682,
-0.3940618336,
0.206673786,
-0.5944437981,
-0.3483292162,
-0.2139566541,
0.2906523943,
-0.5396314263,
0.5809507966,
0.098245196,
-0.6605173945,
0.6014842987,
-0.6853884459,
-0.1809722036,
-0.371134907,
-0.1688625067,
-0.2464893162,
-0.0483438931,
0.2847497165,
0.341263622,
-0.2281046808,
0.2595941722,
-0.6875957847,
-0.338352859,
0.4587779045,
-0.3390043676,
0.592551887,
0.3456767499,
-0.1982846111,
0.4168741405,
-0.5653870702,
-0.0774923936,
0.1456159353,
-0.3681691289,
-0.2953322828,
0.0661373511,
-0.1799702346,
0.2235304564,
0.2508589923,
-0.2545125782,
0.2113927156,
-0.3995227218,
0.5090657473,
1.0840730667,
-0.0870887935,
0.7447903156,
-0.607848525,
0.4540604353,
-0.2111726999,
0.409963578,
0.5084603429,
-0.1456147283,
-0.912312448,
-0.2021027952,
0.20797728,
0.2532271445,
0.01934232,
0.4835832417,
-0.3731532395,
-0.3746670783,
-0.6015130281,
0.2113482058,
0.2588582039,
0.5614315867,
0.2528522611,
-0.2971388698,
-0.5049441457,
-1.2433835268,
-0.1941073984,
-0.3263470829,
-0.1492550224,
0.4040986598,
0.2840613425,
-0.1837566197,
1.0620949268,
-0.5726057291,
0.0481807217,
-0.1278308034,
-0.1380355805,
0.1372991055,
0.2864108086,
0.8666111827,
-0.7458083034,
-0.5572468042,
0.0580012277,
-0.390206188,
0.0396892056,
0.070095025,
-0.4061345458,
0.1286791712,
-0.0039100787,
-0.4217457771,
0.2986284792,
0.4596284032,
-0.1411670595,
0.5129834414,
-0.0522514433,
0.1968567222,
-0.7974331379,
0.0702773333,
0.1890552938,
-0.2844446599,
-0.356918484,
0.0105992267,
-0.0673737973,
0.4671679437,
-0.4376834333,
0.6430187225,
-0.1995464116,
-0.2770580351,
-0.2050362974,
0.0480455495,
0.2898559272,
0.4708974063,
0.2923320234,
0.7742344737,
0.1277958453,
-0.4503448606,
0.2158574611,
0.4556552172,
-0.2374161184,
0.3655016124,
-0.7244206667,
0.3951146901,
0.071541287,
0.189288497,
-0.843131125,
-0.3983820975,
0.4107074142,
-0.3569025099,
0.1178996563,
-0.2811273634,
-0.2712792158,
-0.107317023,
-0.6064836383,
0.1736807525,
0.5769454837,
-0.4747108519,
0.2144693434,
0.3822835088,
-0.2233146131,
-0.6736834645,
-0.6324285269,
0.0420290641,
-0.6107461452,
-0.5444356799,
0.2139226794,
-0.4670759141,
-0.50279212,
-0.268393904,
-0.1466215104,
0.2331530154,
0.3800106645,
0.4574401379,
0.7246739268,
-0.0028785479,
-0.0093291178,
-0.112989895,
-0.1456227154,
-0.0663581267,
-0.0278625395,
0.5080654621,
-0.4669142962,
-0.4387189746,
-0.2132733762,
-0.0233786684,
0.5320973396,
-0.1985799521,
0.4662142992,
0.2805025876,
0.0057022846,
0.2940097749,
-0.4349110126,
-0.2491669953,
-0.4359611869,
0.1730726957,
-0.2675467134,
-1.0595886707,
0.3499672413,
0.2287524641,
0.0912899449,
0.3928430676,
0.7605900764,
-0.4170871675,
1.0932711363,
0.3559134603,
-0.5200266242,
0.4051074088,
-0.0004139323,
-0.0654790029,
-0.9120427966,
-0.0253116153,
-0.4972626269,
-0.6845197082,
-0.5653096437,
-0.0835769475,
0.4043458104,
-0.0041047097,
-0.4980267584,
0.0109972293,
-0.5091785789,
0.5350447297,
0.2655168474,
0.1912399679,
0.2279649079,
-0.0170778409,
-0.0748413131,
-0.0770850852,
-0.3399075568,
-0.8619786501,
1.1884331703,
0.5178797841,
0.8466296792,
0.1734266132,
0.641281724,
0.1879378408,
0.1849781573,
-0.9781221747,
0.3787561655,
-0.0681552067,
-0.5964968801,
-0.4311846197,
-0.3115137517,
-0.8044456244,
0.3079946339,
-0.3171667755,
-0.8279358149,
0.2254468352,
0.356788516,
-0.6649432778,
0.0473394208,
-0.6698437929,
0.7942084074,
-0.6821356416,
-0.4637863934,
-0.2368039787,
-0.92102772,
0.2342466861,
-0.1226683781,
0.1416017264,
-0.358456105,
0.0931594819,
0.5617534518,
-0.1772893667,
0.8876203299,
0.0391097404,
0.0407412685,
-0.0006017622,
0.0865072533,
0.2759223282,
0.0886884853,
-0.3165740669,
0.0992710888,
-0.0384767614,
-0.2546627223,
-0.5731318593,
0.5865975022,
-1.122107625,
-0.7947418094,
-0.419306457,
-0.5219391584,
-0.3867028356,
0.0150549263,
0.0519455969,
0.1003457084,
-0.2990846038,
0.00594192,
0.5119076371,
-0.1832587421,
0.1222962812,
0.4770308733,
-0.2955496609,
-0.1310853213,
0.6587585211,
-0.1852745414,
0.5358595848,
0.2919334471,
0.4809182286,
-0.5557612181,
-0.5303741693,
-0.3682049513,
0.126881972,
-0.6536373496,
0.0236867331,
-0.4521200955,
0.0160129238,
-0.1650315374,
-0.350086689,
-0.2243555933,
-0.4182974696,
-0.4841825664,
-0.4172488451,
0.4056373239,
0.4967397451,
-0.0530603826,
0.3661217988,
-0.5538069606,
0.1921306998,
0.4048957527,
0.2574225962,
-0.0959449187,
-0.7634845972,
-0.0443893932,
0.3222410679,
-0.3205293715,
-0.4719671607,
0.3511562943,
0.0473834686,
0.5211890936,
0.5428126454,
-0.008652498,
0.7805074453,
-0.2399130911,
0.5452123284,
0.2205974609,
-0.8116289377,
0.3709633946,
-0.3274416327,
0.0000856862,
0.8137459755,
0.518039763,
-0.6225592494,
0.019625254,
-0.2583767474,
-0.5524016023,
0.7235081792,
-0.2499170452,
0.0529202856,
0.1700310707,
0.4249343872,
0.3399620354,
-0.0298158973,
-0.6827731729,
-0.0668649375,
-0.2584001124,
-0.0757891834,
-0.2737885416,
-0.3145688176,
-0.5054226518,
-0.3008681238,
0.4221876562,
-0.2027971298,
-0.2006669343,
-0.0546488091,
-0.1869330555,
-0.0522457808,
0.6263631582,
0.6094812751,
0.6157391071,
-0.5903963447,
0.202836588,
0.2021013796,
-0.1127658561,
0.4404523671,
-0.2367809862,
-0.0169263221,
-0.5626441836,
0.1662309766,
0.8715771437,
0.1596976966,
-0.5355825424,
0.3644246459,
-0.1463758647,
-0.214324221,
0.0799447745,
0.2547596693,
0.3693570197,
0.157739684,
-0.0616144575,
0.2905781865,
0.2433343977,
-0.4611769021,
-0.0980595052,
0.431432426,
-0.3465090394,
-0.4658159614,
0.4609020948,
0.1612800062,
0.0714254379,
0.3632824421,
-0.1944933087,
-0.3271940947,
0.2899767458,
0.1612576097,
0.629432261,
0.0748779327,
0.2410533279,
0.1282595545,
0.0344029218,
-0.0907102376,
-0.0460557938,
0.0692978725,
-1.1013528109,
-0.2113489807,
-0.7212709785,
-0.4423587918,
0.0209322143,
-0.8778512478,
0.3266555071,
-0.5112672448,
-0.3574644327,
0.2079699039,
-0.0623994619,
-0.7187076807,
0.1086250842,
0.196485281,
0.6012709141,
-0.6766594052,
0.7802727818,
0.7533197403,
-0.4543685913,
-0.8125939369,
-0.1562568247,
0.3863496482,
-0.936252296,
0.6339488626,
-0.0333231278,
-0.1322215647,
-0.2799892724,
-0.4192027748,
-0.6268817186,
1.0082932711,
0.6970097423,
-0.7943656445,
-0.0857217163,
0.301312089,
0.6250495315,
-0.1964552253,
0.2781982124,
0.7612660527,
0.5386845469,
0.0059216148,
-1.0014176369,
-0.1120935008,
0.1788842082,
-0.165616706,
0.0819358826,
-0.8676444888,
0.6616207957,
-0.3177290559,
-0.0425285175,
-0.0723474696,
0.170710519,
0.3424136639,
0.2222386748,
0.6674064398,
0.3983982205,
0.6349201202,
0.1079632193,
1.0174466372,
-0.1153607741,
0.2695685327,
1.2173349857,
-0.5515483618,
0.7320780158,
0.6955659389,
-0.3735845089,
0.2705827951,
0.9469301105,
0.1861805618,
0.4274998009,
0.1953564882,
-0.0454593562,
-0.3674736321,
-0.1860204339,
-0.2068472207,
0.7460491657,
0.0680044964,
-0.1325968951,
-0.0661554039,
-0.2803503871,
-0.0087422812,
0.0636468679,
-0.0860325769,
0.8078613281,
0.12182796,
-0.6219416857,
0.5497723818,
-0.0624064915,
0.680867672,
-0.5677474141,
0.2521638274,
-0.2376140803,
-0.0852931142,
-0.4097726047,
-0.8866838813,
0.1164510623,
-0.0037595672,
-0.3506770134,
-0.2422674447,
0.6151534915,
-0.1058748439,
-0.0414047651,
0.2848657072,
0.4637823105,
0.1405526847,
-0.1240110174,
-0.7244843841,
0.1357996166,
0.2712989151,
-0.3457509577,
0.7691547871,
0.0264222343,
-0.4092624187,
0.6634153128,
0.6944472194,
0.06579151,
-0.246322751,
0.2800263762,
0.8672300577,
-0.5537573099,
-0.2470284253,
-1.0198738575,
0.3906530142,
0.0588550083,
-0.2475475669,
0.5154826045,
0.569263339,
0.7288357615,
-0.013557489,
0.8632341623,
0.2295551151,
0.3824866712,
-0.5460557342,
0.8097358942,
-0.5061352253,
0.3405278325,
-0.1632275134,
-0.8423088193,
-0.0756135657,
0.5778290033,
-0.5571647286,
-0.0328888856,
0.3027577698,
0.6898877025,
0.0184101388,
-0.22617127,
0.3267941177,
-0.1922874451,
0.4112295508,
0.5895130634,
1.0613566637,
0.1685217619,
0.2438830733,
-0.1814750731,
-0.2722193897,
-0.3567753732,
-0.8870406151,
-0.7446926832,
-0.266028285,
-0.1703396887,
-0.0436416417,
-0.0673201904,
1.2352679968,
0.6908996701,
-0.7330067158,
-0.3181237578,
0.315197587,
0.0894883275,
0.1943581402,
-0.1344840974,
0.2088778019,
-0.0698614344,
-0.5613772869,
0.1999476403,
0.2583438754,
0.2485204339,
-0.1279183477,
-0.525180161,
0.0662461147,
-0.0219959486,
0.4641394317,
0.3214880824,
-0.8124317527,
-0.715870738,
0.1099717692,
-0.2867641449,
0.3514512777,
0.4998672605,
-0.4622685015,
0.4120692909,
0.2802000642,
0.5050376654,
0.4786092639,
0.1333829612,
0.6197393537,
-0.4668345451,
0.1347445101,
0.0702687129,
0.5288920999,
0.3273953795,
-0.4251311421,
0.5376058221,
-0.0679314137,
-0.7439457774,
-0.5678227544,
0.252394259,
-1.2052057981,
-0.1130627096,
1.0841835737,
-0.0169905145,
-0.0241086055,
0.1309402436,
-0.4569090903,
0.1153507531,
-0.5326420069,
0.899369061,
0.8301304579,
-0.4622752666,
0.1577909589,
-0.538328588,
0.5384166241,
0.4460932016,
-0.6327405572,
-0.0694619492,
0.5774845481,
0.6618478298,
-0.0600767396,
0.4578488767,
-0.1698909104,
0.1836343259,
-0.5256527662,
0.3178109825,
-0.0504023619,
-0.0376989357,
-0.5119937062,
-0.2716431916,
0.6417144537,
-0.1145808175
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11295v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11295v3
|
OneBit: Towards Extremely Low-bit Large Language Models
| 2024-02-17T14:26:57 | 2024-05-22T03:55:10 |
Yuzhuang Xu, Xu Han, Zonghan Yang, Shuo Wang, Qingfu Zhu, Zhiyuan Liu, Weidong Liu, Wanxiang Che
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Model quantification uses low bit-width values to represent the weight
matrices of existing models to be quantized, which is a promising approach to
reduce both storage and computational overheads of deploying highly anticipated
LLMs. However, current quantization methods suffer severe performance
degradation when the bit-width is extremely reduced, and thus focus on
utilizing 4-bit or 8-bit values to quantize models. This paper boldly quantizes
the weight matrices of LLMs to 1-bit, paving the way for the extremely low
bit-width deployment of LLMs. For this target, we introduce a 1-bit model
compressing framework named OneBit, including a novel 1-bit parameter
representation method to better quantize LLMs as well as an effective parameter
initialization method based on matrix decomposition to improve the convergence
speed of the quantization framework. Sufficient experimental results indicate
that OneBit achieves good performance (at least 81% of the non-quantized
performance on LLaMA models) with robust training processes when only using
1-bit weight matrices.
|
[
-0.6319988966,
-0.6795790195,
0.5900178552,
0.2056125104,
-0.6662666202,
-0.0065339785,
0.0949727595,
-0.3069295585,
0.2744471729,
0.6183394194,
-0.4839133918,
-0.3900550604,
-0.4695853591,
-0.2755176127,
-0.521779716,
0.380095005,
0.2857516706,
0.0833388269,
-0.087260142,
-0.1278108209,
0.0858683214,
-0.6553760171,
-0.6419980526,
-0.1406966001,
0.1485704482,
0.2132189572,
0.8587132096,
0.9215055108,
0.5953292847,
0.178589642,
-0.3097637594,
-0.3903898597,
-0.2704043686,
-0.1448382884,
0.2681843936,
-0.7068850994,
-0.7536274791,
-0.0795355365,
0.9336209297,
0.970698595,
-0.3269259334,
0.6397019625,
-0.3706381321,
0.7509355545,
-0.7247972488,
-0.2846625745,
-0.4418316782,
0.2006653547,
-0.0768474117,
-0.0216100402,
-0.3920251727,
-0.2905379534,
-0.1193992123,
-0.4313792884,
0.1255696714,
0.4058553874,
0.6734673977,
0.2417945862,
-0.3494690657,
0.1878652424,
-0.7520816922,
0.8596466184,
-1.0557311773,
0.5129250288,
0.2519674599,
0.1228224561,
0.1320049912,
-0.4824505746,
-0.5154252648,
0.0712163672,
0.3416460156,
-0.5774254799,
-0.5956190228,
0.3711161017,
0.2753099799,
0.3797069788,
-0.5624624491,
0.1383154988,
-0.4278907478,
-0.2684881389,
0.369133532,
0.2690223753,
-0.1209331602,
0.1029970571,
-0.546433866,
-0.0617829673,
-1.1287745237,
-0.1506588757,
0.6441219449,
0.3627947867,
-0.020477917,
0.2429355085,
-0.0596708022,
0.7746651173,
-0.0622915439,
-0.1866672039,
-0.1508152187,
-0.0336513408,
-0.4755283296,
0.2602930665,
0.7339974046,
-0.1222902462,
0.0321712717,
-0.0629282966,
-0.3791862726,
0.2006461471,
0.2025731355,
-1.2155772448,
-0.0655371398,
0.137411952,
-0.9070189595,
-0.1698679328,
-0.339638561,
-0.346010834,
-0.305685848,
-0.0711782575,
0.7360665798,
-0.4173749089,
-0.2907999754,
0.4467778802,
0.3038051128,
0.2081398666,
0.3192605078,
-0.8336865902,
0.6297528744,
0.5500144362,
0.7999852896,
0.1741256863,
0.2548638284,
-0.2228016108,
-0.0365660489,
-0.6035184264,
0.38512218,
-0.3989073038,
-0.2184705585,
-0.2831675112,
-0.4765819311,
0.6091935635,
-0.573882103,
0.0006151272,
-0.6578517556,
-0.4204069376,
-0.058719676,
-0.5438349843,
-0.1728003323,
0.2544490099,
-0.9079491496,
0.5622597337,
0.2070243657,
-0.5454541445,
0.1760809124,
-0.430603981,
-0.3160696924,
0.0517391451,
0.017228527,
-0.4168745577,
0.5729560256,
0.0465211049,
0.4863453209,
-0.702690959,
-0.1061922461,
-0.4083685279,
-0.7773940563,
0.1513534933,
-0.8794483542,
0.8817913532,
0.4561764598,
0.1204314008,
-0.296988219,
-1.0726754665,
0.228870526,
0.2534346879,
-0.5469405055,
-0.0580339655,
-0.1546822637,
-0.0659703538,
0.1541209668,
0.3636945784,
-0.7083958983,
0.3489612639,
-0.5480052233,
0.5384902358,
0.7273437381,
-0.0705812871,
0.4997949004,
-0.0803625882,
0.9651491642,
0.0097565344,
0.3602633178,
-0.3018192351,
-0.0121973753,
-0.9044017792,
-0.4033513069,
0.7172272801,
0.2331973314,
-0.4616476297,
0.2697347105,
-0.492346853,
-0.3072037399,
-0.8185017705,
0.1479950994,
0.2815819383,
-0.1178135425,
0.141852513,
-0.3070731759,
-0.5560997128,
-1.0824501514,
0.2249271572,
-0.4307442009,
-0.1677379459,
-0.1814725399,
0.3274821341,
0.0020602345,
0.9445975423,
-0.2944858372,
-0.0023759266,
-0.2113818228,
-0.0148505587,
0.0988271981,
0.6148740053,
0.3017013669,
-0.6397708654,
-0.2266546786,
-0.3942389488,
-0.314352423,
0.2991836965,
0.2045522928,
0.06436795,
0.2758267522,
0.4742710888,
-0.2512178123,
0.5301343799,
0.7663908601,
-0.2566004694,
0.2404450476,
-0.1271345764,
-0.1904405504,
-0.812833786,
-0.0492154881,
0.0145563586,
-0.6960978508,
-0.3997575939,
0.0357677899,
0.0986543819,
-0.1271869987,
-0.7914779186,
0.4498764575,
-0.3340227902,
-0.1242059991,
-0.2360254973,
-0.198145777,
0.0708165392,
0.4793431759,
-0.1671947986,
0.7825131416,
0.6006275415,
-0.7204378843,
0.3464771509,
0.1041802466,
-0.3962416053,
0.4376021922,
-0.6912611127,
0.0366214179,
-0.155681178,
0.1158366725,
-0.9914733171,
0.2327592671,
-0.2084044367,
-0.3954519629,
0.4323812127,
-0.4226959646,
-1.0545369387,
-0.1107086167,
-0.5444509387,
0.5665407777,
0.6470636725,
-0.5063323975,
0.4867151082,
0.4010256231,
0.0098159527,
-0.2131356597,
-1.1112062931,
-0.0478687361,
-0.2177501619,
-0.554032743,
0.1434227526,
-0.0788268074,
-0.0701335743,
-0.059965156,
-0.3058261275,
-0.1157092601,
0.2078153491,
0.1082716212,
0.2855041027,
-0.3456059992,
0.457819432,
-0.0499742255,
-0.1631199718,
0.0690199584,
-0.3712079227,
0.6871021986,
-0.2636558414,
-0.2407930642,
-0.137516275,
0.4151380062,
0.2854914665,
-0.2565512359,
0.8602702022,
0.540189743,
-0.4805699885,
-0.2137951851,
-0.5040845275,
-0.1703200936,
-0.4883991778,
0.2971475422,
-0.4960726202,
-0.9698760509,
0.486761421,
-0.3695761263,
-0.2430154532,
0.1185534373,
0.3379694521,
0.0612003356,
1.3324981928,
1.1607029438,
-0.1757979393,
0.4519926012,
-0.5334863663,
0.3110889494,
-0.9710612893,
0.3056142032,
-0.4737857878,
-0.2862777114,
-0.6570785046,
-0.3031351268,
0.5188395381,
0.2973667085,
-0.580698669,
0.4424204826,
-0.5614429116,
0.4740902781,
0.5965641141,
0.3045208454,
0.196829617,
0.1309635788,
-0.0839681029,
0.1967408955,
-0.9532522559,
-0.7956354022,
1.1360054016,
0.6573134661,
1.1664842367,
0.3422980607,
0.766048491,
0.1585150212,
-0.041575931,
-0.6910258532,
0.7727521658,
-0.2255700529,
-0.8254095912,
-0.4379161298,
-0.5728069544,
-0.7412759066,
0.1475325078,
-0.1816847771,
-0.9056946039,
0.0304354206,
0.2051776946,
-0.7710765004,
0.5125539303,
-0.5482367277,
0.7666918039,
0.0526571423,
-0.2784330249,
-0.1871311814,
-0.6913747787,
0.3424236774,
0.0301424805,
0.2243123949,
-0.3005761802,
-0.397416532,
0.9323062301,
-0.528155148,
0.7918723226,
-0.115986675,
-0.4140534699,
0.4339086115,
0.630549252,
0.5336292982,
-0.0199766997,
-0.0683799237,
0.2023563832,
0.440874666,
-0.6503795385,
-0.3968496621,
0.5550114512,
-0.5719887614,
-0.3837530315,
-0.0087457532,
-0.4004471302,
-0.3522039652,
-0.1061124206,
0.279594481,
0.5179617405,
0.1516382247,
0.095276989,
1.1451872587,
-0.2340715826,
0.506747365,
0.4884730279,
-0.2674955428,
-0.2597952783,
1.042745471,
0.1649103612,
0.4970438778,
0.6054894924,
0.0888902918,
-0.0983305573,
-0.6355968118,
-0.3030396402,
0.2285969257,
-0.9807440042,
-0.5083857775,
-0.2978871763,
0.0220590476,
-0.4534111321,
-0.1080956534,
-0.8520848751,
-0.7542642355,
-0.2395290881,
0.0643068328,
0.1155002415,
0.564804852,
-0.0042432072,
0.9377893806,
-0.8998438716,
0.1705724001,
0.2085085809,
0.7357401848,
0.1259319335,
-0.7589303851,
-0.5976435542,
-0.3135864139,
-0.2845615149,
-0.6350340247,
0.282787919,
-0.019125713,
0.1987713426,
0.577439189,
-0.0589290485,
0.5594516993,
-0.3602794409,
0.7311326861,
0.2628592849,
-1.2921917439,
0.4781681299,
0.1817453355,
0.4179170132,
0.5481407642,
0.6428537965,
-0.2744913101,
0.0300910287,
-0.6070716977,
-0.908672452,
0.6648378968,
-0.1641919613,
0.3584682345,
0.1288969666,
0.3141235113,
0.0756416321,
0.5063739419,
-0.8000186682,
-0.4950020313,
0.2513897419,
-0.261564821,
0.2564869225,
-0.5166583061,
0.2518462539,
-0.0069929133,
0.8278116584,
-0.1827011704,
0.6552653313,
-0.1323760599,
-0.1724436879,
-0.315526247,
0.2406221479,
0.2626914382,
0.6009116173,
-0.3834839463,
0.300247103,
0.069286108,
-0.2810301781,
0.5638588071,
-0.1239893809,
-0.0698711574,
-0.1528597921,
0.3868129551,
0.9163290262,
0.0555880927,
-0.7066127658,
0.6077852249,
0.0253401063,
0.0015576393,
-0.1034351289,
0.0554449409,
-0.0662873387,
0.2331956923,
0.2468920201,
-0.3906877041,
0.3144953251,
-0.4784880877,
-0.0961498767,
0.653955996,
-0.3465032876,
-0.404648751,
0.6172235608,
0.0691353083,
-0.0383251645,
0.5312108397,
-0.5932140946,
-0.4429238737,
0.4234948158,
0.4939026237,
0.6213450432,
-0.0414402261,
-0.0950414911,
0.368776679,
0.5930843353,
-0.1381602287,
0.3157608807,
-0.1902716756,
-0.6233936548,
-0.631023109,
-0.872018218,
-0.3592973351,
0.0432662927,
-0.4863332808,
0.2389328331,
-0.7247825265,
-0.2926952541,
-0.1316950619,
0.2637719214,
-0.6182789803,
0.3078538179,
0.6587911844,
1.0192234516,
-0.6418246627,
0.8441170454,
0.6478027105,
-0.308729887,
-0.7379904985,
-0.4529630542,
-0.1904490292,
-0.7015587687,
0.5254788995,
0.0185074415,
0.137345776,
0.4360592961,
-0.980987668,
-0.9897520542,
1.0170154572,
0.8349881172,
-0.8971294165,
-0.1974453181,
0.3966385424,
0.1325228661,
-0.1256839782,
0.1528749019,
0.5576083064,
0.3302425742,
0.132632181,
-0.7895982862,
0.1762613207,
0.2223379761,
0.3614097238,
0.5843709111,
-0.7297397852,
1.0701853037,
-0.1064504236,
-0.3389772773,
0.1053671241,
0.4994262159,
0.067603752,
-0.1894251257,
0.4058835208,
0.7627493143,
0.4351359606,
0.1572015882,
0.9644753933,
-0.5581478477,
0.4574133754,
0.7706050873,
-0.1074470431,
0.8562520146,
0.6955395341,
-0.7350283861,
0.1589705795,
0.3899462521,
0.2112514824,
0.2446558625,
0.6734119058,
-0.4378059804,
-0.6399930716,
-0.0025050631,
0.2135500312,
0.405652076,
0.2402777672,
-0.1540133059,
-0.2465949506,
0.2496414483,
-0.0596353933,
-0.1914203763,
-0.6670075655,
0.4969433248,
0.0462234579,
0.1141555384,
0.8282869458,
0.3099846244,
0.9105740786,
-0.7028212547,
-0.1064154059,
-0.1956893951,
0.0513984114,
0.073080942,
-0.3495410383,
-0.0659834817,
-0.1127615049,
-0.2215193063,
-0.1104403287,
0.6178560853,
-0.2278813273,
-0.6974821091,
-0.0506315306,
0.427996695,
0.2100084275,
-0.5160727501,
-0.3166581094,
0.5943737626,
-0.1769960672,
-0.4419690967,
0.4115960896,
0.463866055,
0.0434263945,
0.9760683775,
0.3102600574,
0.3367009163,
0.2618182302,
-0.3548792005,
0.7644542456,
-0.851117909,
-0.3103010058,
-0.900256753,
0.1698835343,
0.6408118606,
0.0096600214,
0.4040269554,
0.597713232,
0.7498915792,
0.1825727522,
0.5879591703,
0.0462448336,
0.3219670057,
-0.548178196,
0.5198976398,
-0.624774456,
0.4972696602,
0.1187047064,
-0.7631587982,
-0.2576363087,
0.6720601916,
0.242113024,
0.1364676952,
0.3641374111,
0.727883637,
0.0282426998,
-0.4268758893,
0.8493805528,
0.0506062172,
0.2170992792,
0.7288042307,
0.4966103733,
-0.7169081569,
0.6680545807,
-0.4972204864,
-0.0483522154,
-0.1919978261,
-0.8960133195,
-0.6664966941,
-0.4247047901,
-0.4602602124,
-0.158445403,
-0.2092228234,
1.3081837893,
1.1546940804,
-0.469948709,
-0.153700918,
-0.0580211133,
-0.0880063623,
0.2326669246,
-0.1881615072,
0.1734030396,
-0.1656593531,
-0.5402942896,
0.1405956447,
0.3058488667,
0.3971467614,
-0.9375130534,
-0.034560848,
-0.0896069035,
0.5363522172,
0.6183166504,
-0.0356505103,
-0.3766185641,
0.0557920448,
-0.2010976225,
-0.1313132644,
0.1296715289,
0.6990267634,
-1.2337040901,
0.2083696425,
0.2254520208,
0.5005395412,
0.6217516065,
-0.2122978568,
0.1172886565,
-0.9828712344,
0.292006582,
0.3331657052,
0.2259261459,
0.3087878823,
-0.1559299231,
0.4717824459,
-0.1159352288,
-0.3288884759,
-1.0107798576,
0.167175591,
-0.8796523213,
-0.3591507971,
0.9556948543,
-0.1625189781,
-0.6811621785,
0.5664277673,
-0.0049741114,
0.0989097655,
-0.3262856007,
0.3151314855,
0.6618064642,
0.0707998723,
-0.2513823509,
-0.5597066283,
0.0323640481,
0.2977281511,
-0.4702835679,
0.0416351147,
0.2934987545,
0.2525486946,
0.2151228935,
0.6442456841,
0.0114193782,
0.1303904355,
0.3734847903,
0.5895329118,
-0.1383411586,
-0.2343289405,
-0.8504625559,
0.1225278452,
0.4936382771,
-0.243689701
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11291v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11291v2
|
Puzzle Solving using Reasoning of Large Language Models: A Survey
| 2024-02-17T14:19:38 | 2024-04-20T07:04:28 |
Panagiotis Giadikiaroglou, Maria Lymperaiou, Giorgos Filandrianos, Giorgos Stamou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Exploring the capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) in puzzle solving
unveils critical insights into their potential and challenges in AI, marking a
significant step towards understanding their applicability in complex reasoning
tasks. This survey leverages a unique taxonomy -- dividing puzzles into
rule-based and rule-less categories -- to critically assess LLMs through
various methodologies, including prompting techniques, neuro-symbolic
approaches, and fine-tuning. Through a critical review of relevant datasets and
benchmarks, we assess LLMs' performance, identifying significant challenges in
complex puzzle scenarios. Our findings highlight the disparity between LLM
capabilities and human-like reasoning, particularly in those requiring advanced
logical inference. The survey underscores the necessity for novel strategies
and richer datasets to advance LLMs' puzzle-solving proficiency and contribute
to AI's logical reasoning and creative problem-solving advancements.
|
[
-0.281316489,
-0.9922615886,
0.9226979017,
0.1789770871,
-0.0007376233,
0.2688791454,
-0.3775484562,
-0.4277209938,
-0.086640738,
0.3946620524,
-0.8169272542,
-0.3966335654,
-0.7808286548,
0.371347636,
-0.3962245882,
0.4361928105,
-0.0150141669,
0.1357165873,
-0.6005600691,
0.1689977795,
-0.5260451436,
-0.499132961,
-0.7117825747,
-0.5057929754,
0.6505898237,
0.4762474298,
0.5176361203,
0.5585058331,
0.6377756,
0.3374781013,
-0.379640609,
0.5291109085,
-0.4204398692,
0.2669383883,
-0.1506886631,
-1.0430580378,
-0.276276648,
0.0598293245,
0.3028574586,
0.7952834964,
-0.2204717845,
0.200363934,
-0.3728912473,
0.5968113542,
-0.2741792798,
0.4557172954,
-0.7764489055,
0.224361673,
-0.3883167505,
-0.0193342268,
-0.3899022639,
-0.3057409823,
-0.0217146296,
-0.6536278725,
-0.0662793219,
0.2677705288,
0.3803733885,
0.5645866394,
-0.4729039669,
-0.4588598013,
-0.7784180641,
0.7142951488,
-0.769075036,
0.1422257125,
0.2762515545,
0.0990923345,
-0.5374292731,
-0.3911213279,
-0.5542684197,
-0.3335573673,
0.2225447744,
-0.1136451662,
-0.2484495342,
-0.2047413439,
0.7516694069,
0.221823439,
-0.5257119536,
0.4178435802,
-0.185940668,
-0.0020435443,
1.0285135508,
0.6072851419,
0.3367946744,
0.0171214342,
0.2347874939,
-0.0379290432,
-0.866324842,
0.0514246039,
0.1954467893,
0.0892326012,
0.0928289518,
0.6855685115,
-0.1485268921,
0.7808102965,
-0.2194560766,
-0.1663106382,
0.0750824958,
-0.166344136,
-0.028092552,
-0.1927770376,
0.6687377691,
0.1763993055,
0.486644268,
-0.0596812405,
-0.3670777977,
-0.0734084696,
-0.1325851232,
-0.3804198205,
-0.2533355951,
0.1007442996,
-0.3602099419,
0.1012057289,
-0.3553240001,
-0.4123872519,
-0.8184143305,
-0.4468655586,
0.4025623798,
-0.1376431286,
-0.4117665291,
0.3608891368,
-0.2599383295,
0.3185732365,
0.6043872237,
-0.5952053666,
-0.0060277362,
0.9415482283,
0.5408120751,
-0.0795864984,
-0.0238554776,
-0.3596189022,
0.0104194162,
-0.5262280703,
0.7854962945,
-0.7100932002,
-0.3403777182,
-0.0744924173,
-0.1300439388,
-0.0056323628,
-0.9372388124,
0.5905607343,
-0.3843647242,
-0.0256478097,
-0.4414838552,
-0.6145489216,
-0.286637336,
0.5759643316,
-0.7685490847,
0.7439625859,
-0.2477727234,
-0.3843238652,
-0.1017053574,
-0.6930912733,
-0.6250029206,
0.1534887403,
-0.3483680487,
-0.2435091585,
0.3894398212,
0.2642901838,
0.522993207,
-0.8221831322,
0.3502831757,
-0.2757987976,
-0.2429567575,
0.4242406487,
-0.3665159047,
0.7755771279,
0.2391236424,
-0.1972776502,
0.110569343,
-0.605416894,
0.000545554,
0.5995444655,
-0.0759097785,
-0.1263242364,
0.4658241272,
-0.2908603549,
0.3527261317,
0.3927548528,
-0.3715564311,
0.562903583,
-0.1585302949,
0.6918669939,
0.6068382859,
-0.2181084156,
-0.0280064438,
-0.403210938,
0.5989158154,
0.1494541019,
-0.0941615403,
-0.0960895121,
-0.6821792126,
-0.7851148248,
-0.1234790757,
0.1717563719,
0.7183756232,
-0.6721920967,
0.3349092305,
-0.1566406488,
-0.6637685895,
-0.4792826176,
0.0721767917,
0.2383842468,
0.3421414495,
0.1572249532,
0.0291237496,
-0.4967886806,
-0.8346855044,
-0.3329119086,
-0.1901973039,
-0.140008539,
0.4804081917,
0.72912395,
-0.1877048314,
0.6963775158,
-0.5372963548,
-0.1137624085,
-0.3952174783,
0.2655563653,
0.3243122995,
0.247649014,
0.0335783772,
-0.7661079764,
-0.2222145051,
-0.1452817023,
-0.8555564284,
-0.2073189318,
-0.1161160767,
0.3800897896,
0.2360000759,
0.747866869,
-0.858809948,
0.2512276173,
0.3242383599,
-0.3006035686,
0.5773663521,
-0.1090545431,
0.067915976,
-0.7585886121,
-0.0941781476,
-0.0351399407,
0.1288129389,
-0.4491468072,
0.1340460628,
-0.2532567084,
0.0501643196,
-0.1183420792,
0.2665509582,
-0.7198359966,
-0.0187645424,
-0.0542684533,
0.2052855641,
-0.3530297875,
0.204369545,
0.117608048,
0.4920298159,
0.5293708444,
-0.2785096169,
0.7048098445,
0.1058050692,
-0.5663362145,
0.3940261006,
-0.6898474693,
0.3001175821,
-0.345585674,
0.2552113235,
-0.9939120412,
-0.2289215773,
0.1842716783,
-0.3086492121,
0.1298550516,
0.1784860194,
-1.0179681778,
-0.4787530005,
0.0769947693,
0.5733239055,
0.5340169072,
-0.1844190806,
0.6171771288,
0.3834295869,
-0.0811092928,
-0.4170332253,
-0.6115486622,
0.4669292569,
-0.3224034309,
-0.6741373539,
0.108405292,
-0.3023230433,
-0.5381391644,
-0.1456199437,
-0.1728778183,
0.1299189627,
0.3217580318,
0.035468597,
0.0546964966,
-0.129827559,
-0.0178124979,
-0.3163952231,
0.0195101555,
0.5294609666,
0.0888786614,
0.5070316195,
-0.175358668,
-0.6748529673,
-0.2382980287,
0.4879559577,
0.6000162363,
-0.5789483786,
0.5273948312,
0.2374225855,
-0.4604697227,
-0.2097107172,
-0.6607019901,
-0.1698864102,
-0.4122113883,
0.6305598617,
-0.4755071402,
-1.2639240026,
0.686045289,
-0.3314611614,
0.0154281305,
0.1747372746,
0.8152831793,
-0.1368192732,
1.3151911497,
0.2979739904,
-0.15843153,
-0.0097545991,
-0.1086518019,
0.5137037039,
-0.6460594535,
-0.6412093043,
-0.719992578,
-0.4863876104,
-0.3385086954,
-0.6099134684,
0.4110206962,
0.0458583832,
-0.2720447779,
0.01123174,
-0.4754619598,
0.5228179097,
0.4435130954,
-0.0811229944,
0.5559176207,
-0.3047813177,
0.1032179445,
0.1011258513,
-0.7216629982,
-0.2856850624,
0.988008976,
0.2377782762,
0.8253046274,
0.2456843257,
0.4636053741,
0.0576850884,
0.0251863133,
-0.9471198916,
0.8771231771,
0.0968972445,
-0.8667652607,
-0.4143073559,
-0.574416101,
-1.0620186329,
0.1413474828,
-0.2354192138,
-0.8909543157,
-0.3801518679,
-0.0330640748,
-0.0986204743,
0.44858706,
-0.3795295954,
0.6590390205,
-0.4413357973,
0.1033998728,
-0.4605366886,
-0.5903525352,
0.5957419872,
0.0012407814,
0.2928681076,
-0.2281259,
-0.1081762537,
0.634526372,
0.0137922158,
0.6969221234,
0.1895626485,
-0.4001851678,
0.276637435,
0.3001395166,
0.5311261415,
0.0144683011,
0.0320438743,
0.1050532609,
-0.0435754322,
-0.2230882794,
-0.6656241417,
0.5470395088,
-0.6600488424,
-1.2553768158,
-0.5527374148,
-1.1143574715,
-0.3268817961,
0.0901699662,
-0.0408910438,
0.186719045,
0.1044565588,
0.3341875672,
1.0055879354,
-0.0171432216,
0.4182989895,
0.4802974761,
-0.1613520086,
0.0290678367,
0.8297990561,
0.2395822406,
-0.0099212993,
0.415048629,
0.0617881566,
-0.2239458859,
-0.9823608398,
-0.1382201761,
0.2456734329,
-0.6408967376,
-0.0199612528,
-0.3134818673,
-0.4039314389,
0.0051623923,
0.0772028714,
-0.2114642859,
-0.3099816144,
-0.2772293091,
0.2260278165,
0.2008628994,
0.8446455002,
0.1929655224,
-0.0836191177,
-0.7060472369,
0.3164612651,
0.4227266014,
0.1062239707,
0.1334993243,
-0.2444541752,
-0.0472409539,
0.0140048489,
-0.0332289897,
-0.8584819436,
0.0312467553,
-0.2308915406,
0.6817288995,
0.1988289058,
-0.0274932291,
0.5968055129,
-0.5589801073,
0.8566892743,
0.0160356928,
-0.7910027504,
0.3704081178,
-0.4845362604,
0.3872155249,
0.0622442998,
0.4469913542,
-0.6170771718,
-0.1585818231,
-0.3531757295,
-0.5908071995,
0.489898026,
0.1366734207,
-0.1965936571,
0.0498915054,
0.5170564651,
-0.3051092625,
0.2754462957,
-0.5867121816,
-0.2420909256,
0.419605881,
-0.2662920356,
-0.1270461828,
0.0090625556,
-0.2971372902,
-0.5073384047,
0.4466219544,
-0.0681170374,
0.148715198,
-0.1098344401,
-0.1929406971,
-0.2036926895,
0.2371614873,
0.7539214492,
0.734652698,
0.0978685319,
0.0056797741,
0.2470873594,
-0.093313396,
0.2555692196,
0.0381411277,
-0.036380142,
-0.3768854439,
0.5439893603,
0.5751709938,
-0.2938700616,
-1.1665821075,
0.2787054181,
-0.1266403943,
-0.4444336295,
-0.2941383719,
0.3837849796,
0.6450558305,
0.5283697248,
0.4481643438,
-0.1240747049,
0.0487028249,
-0.5169027448,
-0.3413023651,
0.7813070416,
-0.0424715988,
-0.1919797808,
0.5693022013,
0.0104976725,
-0.6625401378,
0.9304412603,
-0.1849902421,
-0.4866521358,
1.0329110622,
0.6013557911,
0.7145396471,
0.066798225,
0.03857214,
0.0445493013,
0.6300895214,
-0.2900617421,
0.3886450231,
0.1155305877,
-0.8075971007,
-0.6536210775,
-0.1691108197,
-0.4666985869,
0.4171924591,
-0.3405430317,
0.0425918475,
-0.438819766,
0.0835727379,
-0.0897446349,
0.0599619448,
-0.539304316,
-0.0131950462,
0.6384063363,
1.1787059307,
-0.6585906148,
0.4825561047,
1.0023069382,
-0.1883024126,
-0.8013785481,
-0.1522263885,
0.2977816761,
-0.6050769091,
0.5384775996,
0.095908381,
-0.0645298585,
-0.1025446653,
-0.9393508434,
-0.8021177053,
1.0200784206,
0.5296972394,
-0.7358838916,
-0.1981296986,
0.3656818569,
0.5325815082,
-0.4400206506,
0.3209226429,
0.8775660992,
0.684827745,
0.1034467071,
-0.9554054141,
0.0530515164,
-0.3918604553,
0.0058551207,
0.2338250577,
-0.8078000546,
0.8348532915,
-0.1323416978,
0.119430989,
0.159628883,
0.5977470875,
0.6091914773,
0.3636870384,
0.5872148275,
0.8697080016,
0.8037565351,
-0.2812458277,
0.6086537838,
0.0064486153,
0.1062945575,
0.8798299432,
-0.4517940283,
0.6776303649,
0.3706026673,
-0.1472214311,
0.5350831747,
0.6569209099,
-0.1262235045,
0.0872382745,
0.72618258,
-0.1805672348,
-0.8082489967,
-0.1759617031,
-0.2441642582,
0.6129986644,
0.7272483706,
0.1513020247,
-0.2274580002,
-0.2134826779,
0.0746563971,
0.2102034241,
-0.6213489175,
0.6868007183,
0.2388177663,
-0.8678718209,
0.4749183953,
0.0932742804,
0.5376237631,
-0.4987692833,
-0.1657408178,
-0.1141842455,
0.0291888267,
-0.1475512087,
-1.01278162,
0.1062905714,
0.0213054679,
-0.1751796603,
-0.0974365771,
0.439486742,
-0.3946604431,
-0.4221254885,
-0.0126005821,
0.7794904113,
0.0982417762,
-0.065838106,
-0.7113246322,
0.2099283785,
-0.0065383511,
-0.2272478044,
0.3070914149,
0.6722765565,
-0.3871358633,
1.1854554415,
0.5091525316,
-0.0822388381,
0.0027553039,
-0.1193123609,
0.8024629951,
-0.9746831656,
-0.1700870395,
-0.9265186787,
0.4693495333,
-0.0082424814,
-0.3323017955,
0.6442010999,
0.476441294,
0.7364838123,
-0.1395881176,
0.6385953426,
0.0002347006,
0.2437951863,
-0.5156624317,
0.5747870803,
-0.5649490952,
0.2561642826,
-0.1980337948,
-0.7717086077,
-0.4781811833,
0.4883690774,
-0.3034039438,
-0.0537243672,
0.59245646,
0.9134985209,
0.1272677332,
0.2228315771,
0.1703958064,
0.3965939879,
0.4385572076,
1.1070867777,
1.2694743872,
0.0226678066,
0.387098819,
0.1568571776,
-0.0718336031,
-0.1467119455,
-0.9528849721,
-1.193092823,
-0.6018989086,
-0.3804179728,
0.0376225524,
-0.1712433547,
1.04918468,
0.3581390679,
-0.6602192521,
-0.3399959505,
-0.0300729349,
0.4209695458,
-0.1720715314,
-0.1538926512,
0.0598692223,
-0.2594790459,
-0.7367630005,
0.5833429098,
0.2373475432,
-0.2792664468,
-0.4076474905,
-0.014010096,
-0.2964124978,
0.3564778864,
0.653208673,
0.3157375455,
-0.9888579845,
-0.2448985428,
0.1674662083,
0.0740659982,
-0.125393942,
0.8454959393,
-0.6380088925,
0.2739546299,
0.6819901466,
0.8477605581,
0.4419736564,
-0.2476724833,
0.3008056879,
-0.3400137126,
0.0014886649,
0.4842802286,
0.4276672006,
0.1737163365,
-0.2178903669,
0.4787859917,
0.2173858881,
-0.5828925371,
-0.9442413449,
0.4229616523,
-0.8896914124,
-0.4056231081,
0.9034858346,
0.0242674667,
-0.1880049258,
-0.0235608593,
-0.1090077609,
0.0008476413,
-0.064589791,
0.8025776744,
1.0415680408,
-0.4077589512,
-0.4385662377,
-0.4456064999,
0.3592908084,
0.5807803273,
-0.8122115135,
-0.0112010967,
0.6559956074,
0.0772946104,
0.106078811,
0.3682098091,
-0.0608460307,
0.2994379997,
-0.3585699797,
-0.1694809645,
-0.282784313,
-0.47915411,
-0.4405489266,
0.2553330362,
0.1889166683,
0.4413921535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11282v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11282v1
|
Grammaticality illusion or ambiguous interpretation? Event-related potentials reveal the nature of the missing-NP effect in Mandarin centre-embedded structures
| 2024-02-17T13:43:39 | 2024-02-17T13:43:39 |
Qihang Yang, Caimei Yang, Yu Liao, Ziman Zhuang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In several languages, omitting a verb phrase (VP) in double centre-embedded
structures creates a grammaticality illusion. Similar illusion also exhibited
in Mandarin missing-NP double centre-embedded structures. However, there is no
consensus on its very nature. Instead of treating it as grammaticality
illusion, we argue that ambiguous interpretations of verbs can best account for
this phenomenon in Mandarin. To further support this hypothesis, we conducted
two electroencephalography (EEG) experiments on quasi double centre-embedded
structures whose complexity is reduced by placing the self-embedding relative
clauses into the sentence's subject position. Experiment 1 showed that similar
phenomenon even exhibited in this structure, evidenced by an absence of P600
effect and a presence of N400 effect. In Experiment 2, providing semantic cues
to reduce ambiguity dispelled this illusion, as evidenced by a P600 effect. We
interpret the results under garden-path theory and propose that word-order
difference may account for this cross-linguistic variation.
|
[
0.0870553553,
-0.9329710007,
0.6189851165,
0.4221558273,
-0.3742316961,
-0.3672319055,
-0.0444919765,
-0.4455257952,
0.4950503111,
0.0673143938,
-0.304086864,
0.0340438113,
-0.5596905947,
0.0693720728,
-0.2771883011,
0.2931657434,
0.1430412233,
0.1371209621,
-0.039739456,
-0.0865188837,
-0.4008559883,
-0.6547276378,
-0.4095363915,
-0.4025582373,
0.2949301302,
0.0866412222,
1.0880317688,
0.4712229669,
0.0688245818,
0.2687884569,
-0.4683754444,
-0.0208130833,
0.1006664857,
-0.3003954589,
-0.2300416678,
-1.0212312937,
-0.4757477939,
-0.0651949272,
0.7251687646,
0.9307038784,
0.0477205813,
-0.3581979871,
0.1132236049,
0.867493093,
-0.7464039922,
0.1549029648,
-0.4139255285,
0.4724747837,
-0.0482357182,
-0.0653647631,
-0.3273276091,
0.2199307978,
0.203037113,
-0.1960491985,
0.1076993793,
0.0074055451,
1.1770395041,
0.0457774401,
-0.4756295383,
-0.0153279677,
-0.5489362478,
0.4366842508,
-0.5251803994,
0.28024894,
0.154543519,
-0.0259563699,
-0.3774662614,
-0.4173825979,
-0.9259728193,
-0.3747551441,
-0.4598598778,
0.3391979635,
-0.3649542034,
0.4041777551,
0.1497751921,
0.3957785964,
-0.6671308875,
-0.0063584205,
-0.1504177004,
0.0521740802,
0.2696253061,
-0.0474019274,
0.6186592579,
-0.8657228351,
-0.3430733085,
0.267967999,
-0.9256330729,
0.2448763251,
0.4019089639,
0.2283796668,
0.0373427346,
0.7974351645,
-0.0365171619,
0.7345985174,
0.265578866,
0.5116744637,
0.2383087724,
-0.2620709538,
-0.4215092361,
0.3588030934,
0.6901808381,
0.2467165887,
0.129771769,
-0.0230802018,
0.0342917852,
0.3097863495,
0.0577013753,
-0.0403772518,
-0.2606294751,
0.1781354547,
-0.4500436485,
-0.0111120949,
0.4246946573,
-0.5140769482,
-0.1512052715,
-0.1026863158,
0.2717443705,
-0.2390885651,
-0.7424790263,
0.3286946118,
-0.4618579745,
0.4868739247,
0.0928747803,
-0.800559938,
0.2722704113,
0.6492259502,
0.6345790029,
0.0797368661,
-0.5575336218,
-0.1292318106,
0.06454698,
-0.424878031,
0.6134443283,
-0.5332323313,
-0.2502806187,
-0.1437491626,
0.1971508861,
-0.3908565044,
-0.4942361414,
0.2179105431,
-0.1967556328,
0.6844779849,
-0.2549774647,
-0.4008396864,
-0.3517649472,
0.104937546,
-0.5147502422,
1.057412982,
-0.0241666101,
-0.4326846302,
0.312323451,
-0.2220717072,
-0.4834071994,
-0.0405565947,
-0.6855911613,
-0.2323808819,
0.5354600549,
0.0430618189,
0.2644945085,
0.2230024487,
0.1843170375,
0.0795451999,
-0.4832022488,
0.3938104212,
-0.5725185871,
0.8864774704,
-0.2703038156,
-1.0213241577,
-0.1697013229,
-0.6452277899,
0.0635058805,
0.1808722764,
-0.1043152139,
-0.6576429605,
0.1944014579,
0.0237474162,
0.3380867541,
0.1658759415,
-0.403093189,
0.1561282575,
-0.7643641233,
0.3538343906,
0.5355648398,
0.0487535186,
0.5802319646,
-0.1605629921,
0.4823195636,
0.2923488915,
0.1051999554,
0.2010106444,
-0.8633628488,
-0.7800325751,
0.2060877383,
-0.217027843,
0.6570166945,
-0.5366435051,
0.4373646975,
-0.0252664592,
-0.0833152905,
-0.3308553398,
-0.3419277072,
0.6116035581,
0.1770444661,
0.1443493217,
-0.1291252077,
-0.4481130242,
-1.1599484682,
-0.8203060031,
-0.4313359857,
0.1626279354,
0.2479613423,
0.2320296317,
0.1751082242,
0.8772626519,
-0.5521785021,
-0.1396582276,
-0.3442920148,
0.0302085746,
0.3888403177,
0.3459861577,
0.7463170886,
-1.263948679,
-0.2435209453,
-0.1322450638,
-0.6239224672,
-0.0803646222,
-0.628097713,
0.0681843087,
0.4419344664,
0.4077084959,
-0.9220497012,
0.723811686,
0.1979033798,
-0.6144310236,
0.6214272976,
-0.3678804338,
0.1979775429,
-0.7131599188,
-0.2936876118,
-0.0205812324,
-0.0651282966,
-0.7743877172,
-0.0509103239,
0.3258287609,
0.3413484097,
-0.4679192007,
0.1900663078,
-0.8515009284,
-0.3090806603,
-0.3832961321,
0.5488277674,
0.2642572224,
0.543961525,
0.1257052124,
0.4693835974,
0.4448134899,
-0.6089863777,
0.0465785377,
-0.0453897975,
-0.2043265551,
0.4333533347,
-0.4952974916,
-0.1492429674,
-0.5124655366,
-0.1653259993,
-1.0731310844,
0.0736700669,
0.6264014244,
-0.596062541,
0.3390136957,
-0.1243033409,
-0.2064307034,
-0.1964398772,
-0.0633112267,
0.3620868325,
0.3701103628,
-0.4643174708,
0.504101932,
0.092273742,
0.3290438056,
-0.613107264,
-1.0517686605,
0.2681185305,
-0.2523495257,
-0.4507835805,
0.440184176,
0.2826575339,
-0.6451710463,
0.2568843663,
-0.2394573838,
-0.1124533191,
0.1710830778,
0.3612757921,
0.1194137111,
-0.4215353131,
0.3236531317,
0.0916426554,
0.3580940366,
0.4217490554,
-0.221885711,
0.3521116674,
-0.2161355019,
-0.3382885456,
-0.6368730664,
0.3768417537,
0.5828567743,
-0.0061875135,
0.7613527775,
0.0431720391,
-0.551374197,
0.0895103663,
-0.1982186884,
0.2861794531,
-0.5149092674,
0.5116173029,
-0.6545327902,
-0.4999611974,
0.3892966211,
0.3359070122,
-0.405413866,
0.7601405978,
0.1678645611,
-0.2278818786,
0.822856009,
0.260891825,
0.1441536099,
0.8060539365,
-0.0966301337,
0.3325047195,
-0.985209465,
-0.3918020129,
-0.31794554,
-0.0277597122,
-0.5968459845,
-0.1518686265,
0.3102835417,
0.3828388155,
-0.0541040525,
0.2528444827,
-0.4155573249,
0.4861030877,
0.3244775534,
0.2913217247,
0.101780884,
-0.2177636474,
-0.0964248553,
-0.22158584,
-0.9551643133,
-0.3529230356,
0.5349440575,
-0.1546494216,
0.0974064991,
0.398386687,
0.4050388634,
0.1224804819,
-0.3064945638,
-0.7236282825,
0.5654315352,
-0.120305948,
-0.4471668601,
-0.2292329669,
-0.2647531331,
-1.2317154408,
0.7930538058,
-0.2748101354,
-0.9094694853,
0.3032344878,
0.2826726139,
-0.2634552419,
0.2275288999,
-0.8679345846,
0.8889158964,
-0.4293737411,
-0.3645800054,
-0.2423627824,
-0.5434773564,
0.3539661169,
0.4581328928,
0.2556586564,
0.072878316,
0.0999850854,
0.377478838,
-0.4294818044,
0.7614155412,
-0.2668857276,
0.1658581644,
0.37224406,
0.0549083762,
0.442486912,
-0.0538635813,
0.2292529196,
0.0562807173,
-0.3708610237,
-0.5823830366,
-0.9017491341,
0.5459084511,
-0.6597977877,
-1.1316583157,
-0.6145517826,
-0.1705054194,
0.1062649116,
0.3392010927,
0.4096001089,
0.4190368652,
-0.1703476161,
-0.3431868255,
0.4241921306,
-0.3560578823,
0.6064754128,
0.2016483992,
-0.1227930635,
-0.0633260384,
0.3212349713,
0.2997495532,
0.548601687,
0.5903798342,
0.357552886,
-0.0851296708,
-0.2971603274,
-0.4223464429,
0.4246526361,
-0.5232504606,
0.5874313116,
-0.509624362,
-0.083615154,
-0.619695425,
-0.0824106187,
-0.3425885737,
-0.772033453,
-0.5758457184,
-0.2224330306,
0.0523199067,
0.8111309409,
-0.0745950937,
0.3272124827,
-0.7447061539,
0.3111379743,
-0.0830579251,
0.0464452095,
0.1156591102,
-0.5515300035,
-0.0753579959,
0.2203458101,
0.1302021146,
-1.0724490881,
0.2190632373,
0.3195878565,
0.7134675384,
0.5709378123,
-0.2306528389,
0.9188731313,
-0.6577078104,
1.0691617727,
0.334194243,
-1.0321989059,
0.6058468223,
-0.239828214,
0.5717976093,
0.0382214673,
0.001989336,
-0.7275319695,
-0.5006449223,
-0.8226761222,
-0.9969378114,
0.5018676519,
0.3968437612,
0.0809205696,
-0.1935789287,
0.7422137856,
-0.098646462,
0.0239821132,
-1.1931631565,
-0.7005562782,
-0.2935614884,
0.1742422432,
0.1058565229,
-0.3914224803,
0.2472604513,
-0.1986511946,
0.3054808974,
0.3467710912,
0.459854424,
0.7470961213,
-0.1307424605,
-0.0464291535,
0.2163985521,
0.5746189952,
0.6703537107,
-0.0159330573,
0.4513517618,
-0.1414981931,
-0.3970750272,
0.0265234951,
-0.3041508794,
-0.1051501185,
0.3048756421,
0.5640033484,
0.5877354145,
0.3780768216,
-0.2294960618,
0.6822154522,
0.0988745987,
0.1384585202,
-0.6835916638,
0.1459230036,
-0.1203401461,
0.3319137692,
0.3605060279,
0.2513985038,
0.1011844501,
-0.8590651751,
0.0705415159,
0.4355178177,
-0.4629278481,
-0.5145218372,
0.6460715532,
-0.317574501,
-0.5461145639,
0.582226038,
-0.1295684874,
-0.9083461761,
0.9174413681,
0.382155925,
0.9292633533,
-0.257891506,
0.0281529892,
0.1855066419,
0.7862528563,
-0.1484691054,
0.6221421361,
0.1015996411,
-0.7920879126,
-0.1824108958,
0.0150728729,
-0.0350710973,
-0.1792164445,
-0.9054911137,
-0.0285688974,
-0.0971224904,
0.0659276471,
-0.0087989187,
-0.5963543653,
-0.2090023607,
0.2222269922,
0.137528941,
0.5029992461,
-1.1115974188,
0.8563917279,
0.8134745955,
-0.3031869531,
-0.7403943539,
0.2337973118,
-0.0192448366,
-0.4993626773,
0.3856146038,
0.1839770526,
-0.3209413886,
-0.461750716,
-0.224215433,
-0.9707699418,
0.7364105582,
0.064950645,
-0.3687929511,
-0.1551606506,
0.538843751,
0.6945952773,
-0.0265858155,
-0.0458059274,
0.4151376188,
0.381721139,
-0.1696640104,
-0.9008353949,
0.0930862576,
-0.1447393,
0.035403721,
0.428538084,
-0.7823450565,
1.0444321632,
-0.0021142233,
-0.4867291749,
-0.0903622732,
0.6578852534,
-0.1239020154,
0.1776058525,
0.476411283,
0.2567389607,
0.6272284985,
0.0099001415,
0.9953154922,
-0.0948522761,
0.2782896459,
1.1537901163,
0.0421525314,
0.7240635157,
0.7666643262,
-0.3665831685,
0.5327445269,
0.4988749623,
0.3249756396,
0.5916709304,
0.2150165141,
0.0210858788,
-0.1027468666,
0.2682431936,
-0.2104811817,
0.7007545829,
0.5909403563,
-0.4209662974,
0.0232474338,
-0.0621569566,
0.0776674077,
0.2632188201,
-0.5146946907,
0.1477082074,
0.3890549242,
-0.696837008,
0.4618809819,
-0.0313110538,
0.3638376296,
-0.3215661347,
-0.2167626619,
-0.2554519475,
0.1368037015,
-0.3938732147,
-0.6314637065,
0.5265469551,
-0.3690315783,
-0.0647035092,
-0.1936232895,
0.5530928373,
-0.331910044,
-0.1711489409,
0.4155727923,
0.5569568276,
0.2461294532,
-0.2161328197,
-0.5625034571,
-0.5527668595,
0.0080636255,
-0.4204581678,
0.0369664393,
0.6572213173,
-0.0318622589,
0.1128428131,
-0.0354675911,
0.3239105642,
0.3958721757,
-0.1965052336,
0.467278868,
-0.9251331687,
-0.6950829029,
-1.0961939096,
0.3049770296,
0.0136907054,
-0.4715881348,
1.0192840099,
0.4767409563,
0.831282258,
0.0903242826,
0.4199689627,
-0.1640207469,
-0.2298230678,
-0.6035565138,
0.6244937778,
-0.679330647,
0.263502419,
-0.5512877107,
-0.8356896639,
-0.5511167049,
0.7319318652,
-0.4032096267,
-0.1426190436,
1.0602270365,
0.7617073059,
0.0995520949,
0.1825333983,
0.4774695039,
0.6047636867,
-0.1470262855,
0.6413224339,
0.9996688962,
-0.4836017191,
0.1603066176,
-0.1784757078,
-0.3271529973,
-0.0386317186,
-0.5596311092,
-0.7406362295,
-0.6159721017,
-0.2961614132,
-0.2881391346,
0.1049964651,
0.7607489228,
0.1174021512,
-0.4480341971,
-0.2828561664,
-0.5045398474,
0.3271606863,
-0.5536971688,
-0.2901855409,
0.8449353576,
0.144679293,
-0.7276142836,
0.5293056369,
0.4413661361,
0.3041450381,
-0.0855022371,
0.4950023293,
-0.5628538728,
-0.075750947,
0.5031965375,
0.2849607766,
-0.8959128857,
-0.5921353102,
0.0386228412,
-0.1309990734,
0.505854249,
0.5648225546,
-0.7612707615,
0.3941024542,
0.3176338971,
0.0906038359,
0.2537561655,
-0.1525571644,
0.5851425529,
-0.6329183578,
0.3808293343,
0.0266988985,
0.6586455703,
0.0011514972,
-0.865077436,
0.236493513,
0.5272690058,
-0.1034284458,
-0.6038079858,
0.4613442421,
-0.8986570835,
-0.6892139912,
1.3410692215,
-0.077011928,
-0.4833477139,
-0.1790908724,
-0.1144781187,
0.2929827869,
0.1573597342,
0.98747015,
0.7935095429,
-0.5618245602,
-0.1396111101,
-0.2867125273,
0.257409215,
0.9449095726,
-0.4819462895,
-0.1390567869,
0.6797827482,
-0.0355008021,
0.1089155078,
0.3562170267,
0.0795325637,
0.5274330378,
0.2002906799,
0.0093324929,
0.2320225239,
-0.2829420567,
-0.6587893963,
0.3368269205,
0.1570921093,
-0.4326402247
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11281v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11281v3
|
Can Large Multimodal Models Uncover Deep Semantics Behind Images?
| 2024-02-17T13:41:44 | 2024-06-20T13:12:31 |
Yixin Yang, Zheng Li, Qingxiu Dong, Heming Xia, Zhifang Sui
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Understanding the deep semantics of images is essential in the era dominated
by social media. However, current research works primarily on the superficial
description of images, revealing a notable deficiency in the systematic
investigation of the inherent deep semantics. In this work, we introduce
DEEPEVAL, a comprehensive benchmark to assess Large Multimodal Models' (LMMs)
capacities of visual deep semantics. DEEPEVAL includes human-annotated dataset
and three progressive subtasks: fine-grained description selection, in-depth
title matching, and deep semantics understanding. Utilizing DEEPEVAL, we
evaluate 9 open-source LMMs and GPT-4V(ision). Our evaluation demonstrates a
substantial gap between the deep semantic comprehension capabilities of
existing LMMs and humans. For example, GPT-4V is 30% behind humans in
understanding deep semantics, even though it achieves human-comparable
performance in image description. Further analysis reveals that LMM performance
on DEEPEVAL varies according to the specific facets of deep semantics explored,
indicating the fundamental challenges remaining in developing LMMs.
|
[
-0.4994065762,
-0.5616723299,
0.7178673744,
0.0520495176,
-0.2579162419,
0.0528546199,
-0.4202712774,
-0.6028823256,
-0.4833778143,
0.3770011663,
-0.7960067987,
-0.7253337502,
-0.6931757331,
-0.0851536542,
-0.1410396248,
0.7269628048,
-0.1864641011,
-0.0347023904,
-0.3877470195,
-0.2797165215,
-0.5088730454,
0.0041249343,
-0.0907029435,
-0.1280629337,
0.6064180136,
0.1989499629,
0.837741971,
0.4551635683,
1.099856019,
0.3027172387,
0.0634129122,
0.1135389581,
-0.4467153847,
0.0265685041,
-0.3205333948,
-0.0146955689,
-0.340228945,
-0.0131019522,
0.7540594339,
0.5663142204,
0.2015021294,
0.1849672198,
-0.1262794584,
0.8525789976,
-0.9518393874,
0.3416567743,
-0.716580689,
0.1586325318,
-0.3272863328,
0.0343697928,
-0.127679795,
0.064960815,
0.3844449222,
-0.4895901084,
0.2150477171,
-0.3506320417,
1.0644052029,
0.5190860033,
-0.6086410284,
-0.0304806586,
-0.4708479345,
0.7386699319,
-0.6602298021,
0.6075692773,
0.2791594267,
0.6588144302,
0.1422489285,
-0.9097302556,
-0.5990040302,
-0.4085680842,
-0.0383492634,
0.1232378334,
-0.1873072088,
0.1822555214,
0.3465053737,
0.6250291467,
-0.3571219146,
0.0829267949,
-0.3332926333,
-0.2441876382,
0.4367727339,
0.2799060643,
0.318151921,
-0.3339141011,
-0.6113755107,
-0.1314285845,
-0.5758998394,
-0.023666203,
-0.1605017036,
0.0001810945,
-0.2161906064,
0.6861490011,
-0.4267933667,
0.2452233732,
-0.4796610177,
0.0840372667,
0.480610013,
-0.7917242646,
-0.328294456,
-0.3636884987,
0.636115849,
0.8180226088,
0.4444352388,
-0.1855904609,
-0.1620333344,
0.3117474616,
0.1459889412,
-1.1742824316,
-0.1314087361,
-0.0812215209,
-0.6477468014,
-0.0569025315,
-0.0516978875,
-0.6607447267,
-0.7203010917,
-0.3672223687,
0.5194142461,
-0.4207045138,
-0.4459227622,
0.0688664615,
-0.1005763784,
0.5972397923,
0.2987744212,
-0.3743000329,
0.1279967129,
0.7489287257,
0.8593560457,
0.1709192693,
-0.5311424732,
-0.2674423158,
-0.0029127807,
-0.5412846804,
0.6178020239,
-0.5515868664,
-0.0555030033,
-0.0402672216,
0.2458554953,
0.1556536406,
-0.2806824744,
0.6958029866,
-0.6014591455,
-0.2773611248,
-0.3506544828,
-0.5267014503,
-0.1610220671,
0.3794561028,
-0.6600468159,
0.472103864,
-0.1900006682,
-0.8167199492,
0.685108304,
-0.5299470425,
-0.2855916619,
0.150616318,
-0.3258721828,
-0.1171548441,
0.2584285736,
0.3730541468,
0.7449554801,
-0.3500041664,
0.2071508467,
-0.6160015464,
-0.3701877296,
0.5097644925,
-0.5418050885,
0.217618525,
0.2240460068,
-0.3679524362,
0.1518120617,
-0.5214456916,
-0.0273998566,
-0.0240343567,
0.0014436798,
-0.2100110948,
0.051828716,
0.0899512768,
0.3519516885,
0.1184775084,
-0.5684865713,
0.010233161,
-0.0118308282,
0.6115620732,
0.8178792,
-0.4202581346,
0.4100421667,
0.2303729504,
0.232660234,
0.0626748577,
0.0737218484,
-0.5325039625,
-0.2110880762,
-0.5415979028,
-0.4696210921,
0.236350745,
0.1312013417,
-0.7719306946,
-0.0190443452,
-0.56260252,
-0.4536218345,
-0.7634023428,
0.2256056964,
0.5711326003,
0.3843466938,
0.5134103298,
-0.2876150012,
-0.0917488933,
-1.4938434362,
-0.1559625417,
0.2484136075,
-0.0744221732,
0.4934203327,
0.8096471429,
-0.6721915603,
0.4600812793,
-0.18860057,
-0.5603213906,
0.1908483207,
0.2391931713,
0.0389841571,
0.1022693813,
0.3530259132,
-0.6751314402,
-0.2004300058,
0.1777859181,
-0.8690457344,
0.264728725,
0.0888055861,
0.0023578205,
0.074956663,
0.4453800917,
-0.7604443431,
0.5681735873,
0.4115335345,
-0.354888469,
0.2965367734,
-0.3491659164,
0.4072856009,
-0.6453986168,
-0.0206507053,
0.066379115,
-0.0443263575,
-0.0840910226,
0.3747248054,
0.419577837,
-0.0317011513,
-0.4275391698,
0.339681685,
-0.7236128449,
-0.4278196692,
-0.2220203578,
0.1233376935,
0.0485161804,
0.1863818318,
0.1505381316,
0.5779857039,
0.8769801259,
-0.1629320681,
0.4494194984,
-0.050735794,
-0.6237231493,
0.6216397285,
-0.7824859619,
0.0967724025,
-0.340692699,
0.564142108,
-1.2313700914,
-0.6257333159,
-0.1699185222,
-0.3324612677,
0.1841961443,
-0.3092640042,
-0.5330676436,
-0.3656944036,
-0.35329023,
0.6293677688,
0.416893363,
-0.4410450757,
0.6722792983,
0.1910904199,
0.1690773666,
-0.6739225388,
-0.7358336449,
0.4557473361,
-0.0754318088,
-0.946412921,
0.3893771768,
0.1886260659,
-0.2286296785,
0.1275308281,
0.134079203,
-0.0453473963,
-0.1298877448,
0.4245972335,
0.1464446187,
-0.4382475317,
0.419392854,
-0.2899110615,
-0.1093662456,
0.0259799622,
-0.0748283342,
0.2099414915,
-0.6919429302,
-0.3957695365,
-0.6114395261,
0.181246534,
0.7606794834,
-0.4851275384,
0.38860026,
0.9845272303,
-0.2966496646,
0.1643734276,
-0.7244647145,
0.0113425395,
-0.4102375805,
0.5264127851,
-0.6229568124,
-0.7519900799,
0.3616681695,
0.0856450126,
-0.2319733053,
0.6132126451,
0.576356411,
-0.0990073904,
0.9398810267,
0.3416441381,
0.2794250548,
-0.0434488878,
-0.3434232473,
-0.3288994133,
-0.8348311782,
-0.3966731429,
0.0109089818,
-0.5357055068,
-0.7497990131,
-0.654008925,
0.1031171456,
-0.2885816097,
-0.276812017,
0.1054097116,
-0.3680508137,
0.6696646214,
0.3642573655,
0.1455878764,
0.2286130339,
-0.0715339705,
0.0914717764,
-0.2270617485,
-0.0668435395,
-0.4474063516,
0.9814319015,
0.6634224057,
0.9177767038,
0.168562755,
0.171647355,
0.2103744447,
0.1265526414,
-0.7089523673,
0.5284754634,
-0.4376451075,
-0.7493312359,
-0.0231155194,
-0.3461982608,
-0.9090358019,
0.41766873,
-0.2078080624,
-0.4270743132,
0.0599043518,
0.0968137905,
-0.373770535,
0.1327003986,
-0.6820163131,
1.2079771757,
-0.467817843,
-0.5332167745,
-0.5209533572,
-0.8395611048,
0.4718317688,
0.2118027508,
0.307734102,
-0.564304769,
-0.3357079029,
0.4454086125,
-0.0896776095,
0.7712606788,
-0.2493965477,
0.0380252004,
-0.0228719357,
0.0439237915,
0.0424224138,
0.0595469214,
0.3391095996,
0.3601971865,
0.0532608591,
-0.5975264311,
-0.3866436779,
1.0004074574,
-0.7580868602,
-0.1311673373,
-0.1241797581,
-0.4317516088,
-0.2281466424,
0.0606741831,
0.2371382266,
0.6125187874,
-0.1978352815,
0.6410531998,
0.4514856637,
-0.367005229,
0.4480445683,
0.1215096116,
-0.0961579159,
-0.3280627728,
0.7162058353,
-0.0667887032,
0.1672444046,
0.3603827953,
0.2343621552,
-0.5399670005,
-0.6315915585,
-0.6420897245,
-0.0227753986,
-0.9657738805,
-0.135058865,
-0.5645647645,
0.0144894356,
-0.243258059,
0.0747838542,
-0.4296017289,
-0.1579193175,
0.0540294312,
-0.0624019764,
0.1915241629,
0.7311295867,
0.052069243,
0.0022392871,
-0.7139287591,
0.5547061563,
0.5393410921,
0.6274815798,
0.0841948688,
-0.3869160712,
0.0793498531,
0.1460985392,
-0.1275052726,
-0.539286077,
0.002256697,
0.3977734745,
0.4161993563,
0.4912832379,
-0.2425068468,
0.9773398638,
-0.5671209097,
0.733787477,
0.188713938,
-0.7329878211,
0.5018202662,
-0.4020079076,
0.4329883456,
0.6828796864,
0.2924250364,
-0.3862504959,
0.1003286019,
-0.4174138904,
-0.9368090034,
0.1360020638,
0.2777003646,
0.5616284609,
-0.0087721506,
0.0853711516,
0.0810970366,
0.0733319744,
-0.6283100843,
0.3978049457,
-0.3951118588,
-0.0646608397,
-0.1627273858,
-0.1684902906,
-0.0330830663,
-0.2902001441,
0.0912265405,
-0.0933705717,
0.0764506087,
0.1621664017,
-0.3815301955,
0.1082261503,
0.2513464987,
0.487930119,
0.7959041595,
-0.2397927195,
0.6008813381,
0.0437419228,
-0.1716800481,
-0.2420480102,
0.2766897976,
0.4008370638,
-0.2720810771,
0.9300471544,
0.9652006626,
0.2609859407,
-0.792142868,
0.879388988,
-0.2509494126,
-0.0500258915,
-0.2799476981,
-0.2804446816,
0.2702947557,
0.3791272044,
0.3761192262,
0.0165041424,
0.3794141412,
-0.7445664406,
0.1989290565,
0.7399773002,
-0.6113207936,
-0.3675349355,
0.5068911314,
0.1709646285,
0.2430384606,
0.7190833688,
0.0610706545,
-0.2496532053,
0.5213236213,
-0.0860029534,
0.7119486928,
0.3077942431,
0.0555917285,
0.1381866187,
0.3165280521,
0.2150124907,
0.0748222321,
-0.2698771656,
-0.5872914195,
-0.7722135782,
-0.5500055552,
-0.0403599329,
0.1988869309,
-0.3968346417,
-0.0208633505,
-0.1827786863,
-0.1137695163,
0.5745523572,
-0.338801831,
-1.1569107771,
0.1859991997,
0.4390996993,
0.7931147218,
-0.4988134801,
0.5462611914,
0.5765910745,
-0.6086504459,
-0.5709980726,
-0.1170911491,
-0.0391815118,
-0.8904500008,
1.065030694,
0.6004240513,
-0.1981814355,
-0.2402599603,
-0.6932395101,
-0.4845961034,
1.1406909227,
0.2403495759,
-0.4387266934,
0.0418327749,
0.1671812534,
0.6247919202,
-0.2711572349,
0.4401280582,
0.2641622126,
0.603890419,
0.3585856557,
-0.8896933198,
0.0538429394,
-0.2049485892,
0.1497627348,
0.0116028562,
-0.3063170314,
0.838157773,
-0.488560468,
-0.2966733277,
0.2086672187,
0.4625043869,
-0.1407480836,
0.3931399584,
0.4225109816,
0.6185516715,
0.4174688756,
-0.1092203408,
1.3168406487,
0.179452002,
0.3165302575,
0.9669616818,
-0.359623313,
0.8679739237,
0.2444267422,
-0.1116257384,
0.3529784083,
0.68565768,
-0.0239563696,
0.5189657211,
0.1438173056,
-0.099018164,
-0.6501889825,
-0.1459075063,
-0.6424982548,
0.5735749602,
0.3586349785,
-0.5404183865,
-0.5280534029,
0.1539439261,
-0.3037956655,
-0.048557926,
-0.4762370288,
0.815467298,
0.096195817,
-0.4369177818,
0.5492740273,
-0.3115986288,
0.6101027727,
-0.2559505701,
-0.0614126585,
-0.1313081533,
0.6615115404,
-0.1318801492,
-1.3263714314,
0.1067092568,
-0.1901386231,
0.045818191,
0.0271716546,
1.0289735794,
-0.2177615613,
-0.4612345099,
0.3905031085,
0.3972651362,
0.1264101416,
-0.3752546906,
-0.6389383078,
0.0739802867,
-0.5832913518,
-0.0360743701,
0.2032005787,
0.6272253394,
-0.1131386161,
0.6455975771,
0.4855566323,
-0.3017805815,
0.0873553678,
0.2402006239,
0.8155941367,
-0.6491636038,
0.0192476995,
-1.1955494881,
0.5844722986,
-0.3193194568,
-0.2909493744,
0.6744489074,
0.3081218302,
0.7566540837,
-0.2568550706,
0.647003293,
0.0734201893,
0.0015374799,
-0.5570068359,
0.5028833747,
-0.8007602692,
-0.1187448129,
-0.5578696728,
-0.8270871639,
-0.2804921865,
0.4883763194,
-0.4256004989,
-0.0208441764,
0.5080397129,
0.7342830896,
-0.4246642888,
-0.1003518403,
0.4434988201,
0.210017845,
0.047327742,
0.614094615,
1.5753958225,
-0.1440110654,
0.5540517569,
-0.3032379746,
-0.2803484797,
-0.0392531157,
-1.1113747358,
-0.9160120487,
-0.5487499833,
-0.1836005449,
-0.2079261541,
0.1444010586,
0.5204472542,
0.8779742122,
-0.5075134635,
0.1389517039,
-0.0433812216,
-0.1068324968,
0.0396252386,
-0.1520844698,
0.4619754255,
-0.1815062165,
-0.38563779,
0.1969497502,
0.3554424942,
-0.20295991,
-0.4590035379,
-0.0991621241,
0.078469947,
-0.1110326573,
0.879824996,
-0.1762586236,
-0.9706578255,
-0.3641251326,
0.0778720528,
-0.0850521177,
-0.0200288631,
0.8261092901,
-0.6055306792,
0.5136067867,
0.5733079314,
0.8401986957,
0.6269030571,
-0.1433003396,
0.0963403136,
-0.7089292407,
0.01287264,
0.0883266926,
0.5106379986,
0.6611374617,
0.1338712275,
0.5607606173,
0.1529375166,
-0.5735194087,
-0.624402225,
0.4162881076,
-1.0970789194,
-0.5248017311,
1.2566200495,
-0.0819759145,
-0.1377160102,
0.2710265815,
-0.215461269,
-0.1164524555,
-0.2095822841,
0.4451446235,
0.6023856997,
0.1273679137,
-0.5144779682,
-0.8197824955,
0.3323982358,
0.0106305424,
-0.5820008516,
0.2249100059,
0.897321403,
0.2284489572,
0.1900832057,
0.5505142808,
-0.2067849636,
0.4274036288,
-0.1492120922,
0.0417168066,
-0.0962419957,
-0.222792536,
-0.0693666339,
0.1505683064,
-0.0482207686,
-0.3272730112
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11279v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11279v1
|
Multi-Perspective Consistency Enhances Confidence Estimation in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-17T13:37:39 | 2024-02-17T13:37:39 |
Pei Wang, Yejie Wang, Muxi Diao, Keqing He, Guanting Dong, Weiran Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In the deployment of large language models (LLMs), accurate confidence
estimation is critical for assessing the credibility of model predictions.
However, existing methods often fail to overcome the issue of overconfidence on
incorrect answers. In this work, we focus on improving the confidence
estimation of large language models. Considering the fragility of
self-awareness in language models, we introduce a Multi-Perspective Consistency
(MPC) method. We leverage complementary insights from different perspectives
within models (MPC-Internal) and across different models (MPC-Across) to
mitigate the issue of overconfidence arising from a singular viewpoint. The
experimental results on eight publicly available datasets show that our MPC
achieves state-of-the-art performance. Further analyses indicate that MPC can
mitigate the problem of overconfidence and is effectively scalable to other
models.
|
[
-0.2324538976,
-0.3620426655,
1.019723177,
0.5223467946,
0.1884083152,
0.1427631527,
-0.3597829044,
-0.3357078135,
0.0287127774,
0.0837805942,
-0.2268107384,
-0.6468471289,
-0.8628281355,
-0.0304995868,
-0.1033048406,
0.6455155611,
-0.1034681275,
0.1068365499,
-0.4907510281,
-0.2063785642,
-0.1285786778,
-0.6846472621,
-0.4445614517,
-0.3108495474,
0.7152431011,
0.300101608,
0.6436530948,
0.3699348271,
0.2790836096,
0.3022582233,
-0.0851397365,
0.5239672661,
-0.2891156375,
0.1644210964,
-0.23677136,
-0.3483852744,
-0.4751768708,
0.1413629353,
1.1405103207,
0.6076991558,
-0.4431319237,
-0.178547591,
0.4794200361,
0.6509036422,
-1.3841694593,
0.4753667116,
-0.5690669417,
-0.1933326125,
0.1013283581,
0.1750038862,
-0.7260434031,
-0.3062304854,
0.1612284034,
-0.3309889138,
-0.2318419665,
-0.3007543385,
0.4648167789,
0.2361237556,
-0.5919945836,
0.2948136926,
-0.8615618944,
1.0465078354,
-0.8718993068,
0.7498403192,
0.4333978295,
0.0816833749,
-0.3506763875,
-0.0738635883,
-0.6664806008,
-0.1638976783,
0.074011907,
0.3310087025,
0.2068656534,
0.0557615384,
-0.0044622668,
0.0201154575,
-0.232655853,
0.0291929692,
0.2037871927,
-0.3291535079,
0.4983434379,
-0.1398720592,
-0.2587243915,
-0.0339148715,
-0.2747053206,
0.0383881256,
-0.5821472406,
0.1688832492,
0.2789008021,
0.1853727847,
-0.0166130774,
0.4518894255,
-0.248945564,
0.5598161817,
-0.0127627766,
-0.7525731921,
0.4110486209,
-0.2863712013,
-0.1629850566,
-0.0115408031,
0.5011749268,
0.3644483387,
0.212045297,
0.1605487019,
0.0794525445,
-0.0521179177,
0.2891134918,
-0.5030210018,
-0.1723427773,
0.4857030809,
-0.1397865862,
-0.0760566369,
0.1976937354,
-0.5984851122,
-0.6956545115,
-0.2418910265,
0.4462457299,
-0.3177680671,
-0.6153550744,
-0.0431912392,
0.2604891658,
0.1876830012,
0.5934094787,
-0.6012609005,
-0.0089127766,
0.8842128515,
0.9748620391,
-0.1740502119,
-0.6844451427,
-0.3193019927,
0.4796569943,
-0.5292448401,
0.6080393195,
-0.3509190679,
-0.1806443632,
-0.061821539,
-0.0539720282,
-0.358315438,
-0.2223988473,
0.3355992734,
0.0841201991,
0.3183755577,
-0.372592479,
-0.6218897104,
-0.1703271568,
0.876385808,
-0.3638997376,
1.0585957766,
-0.2252494097,
-0.9633007646,
0.3394851387,
-0.215745762,
-0.1508957297,
-0.5994623899,
-0.492985785,
-0.5529210567,
0.2221450806,
0.4217427969,
0.4165629745,
0.0030603544,
0.3268832862,
-0.5495057106,
0.0407703742,
0.3850462139,
-0.5583386421,
0.468888551,
-0.0890139639,
-0.1694410592,
0.1389328688,
-0.6509051323,
0.1665781289,
-0.2458996922,
-0.3361851275,
-0.5386706591,
0.2162738591,
-0.4577216804,
0.4865054488,
0.3502298594,
-0.7236104608,
0.0602044202,
-0.4062264264,
0.1116416007,
0.9125413895,
-0.0113292998,
0.2059628814,
-0.1272436082,
0.2330458462,
0.5602107048,
0.2678466141,
-0.1770321578,
-0.5849643946,
-0.7637401819,
-0.3685788214,
0.17581366,
0.5204539895,
-0.3960867822,
0.5146117806,
-0.2189327925,
-0.4554493427,
-0.3938095868,
0.2019560486,
0.6250405312,
0.5298904181,
0.2490895689,
-0.4284600317,
-0.4559160471,
-1.0430091619,
-0.4462133348,
-0.3650839329,
0.0020003875,
0.272421658,
0.332087338,
0.0147284521,
0.6852927804,
-0.3813100159,
-0.1044215262,
-0.0949816704,
0.1687995791,
0.0967522636,
0.8325227499,
0.4438101053,
-0.7501312494,
-0.6616919041,
-0.0690596178,
-0.6849916577,
0.4887369573,
-0.0452499278,
-0.2175063342,
0.5084977746,
0.2756073475,
-0.4961400032,
0.2343484908,
0.8629500866,
0.0393858068,
0.3240128458,
-0.4260766506,
0.3908105493,
-1.2701530457,
-0.1648218185,
0.3664119244,
-0.2913262248,
-0.4775931537,
-0.1400252879,
0.4226000607,
0.5072316527,
-0.1710192859,
0.1779967397,
-0.5266382694,
0.1717123985,
0.0162251759,
0.2608559132,
0.2832666337,
0.5276130438,
0.0955824852,
0.6445842385,
0.8020837307,
-0.2881965637,
-0.098137781,
-0.068540886,
-0.3364824653,
0.8823612332,
-0.3142165244,
0.2005149424,
-0.4815467596,
0.4231200516,
-1.2376564741,
-0.3268885911,
0.1982375681,
-0.4802262187,
0.5288848877,
-0.2882502377,
-0.3001572192,
-0.1590743512,
-0.4152613878,
0.2173406184,
0.1150108725,
-0.6162477136,
1.0836809874,
0.5490755439,
-0.1364074498,
-1.0878423452,
-0.6976217031,
0.0850975141,
0.1601061225,
-0.5275155306,
-0.2127484381,
-0.2448505163,
-0.3126514554,
-0.4880945981,
-0.4134577513,
-0.1663522869,
-0.0879298374,
0.3484798968,
0.3011416793,
-0.1277362108,
0.1449335665,
-0.168691054,
0.0473602787,
0.0518894829,
-0.5926610827,
0.3398937285,
-0.2470992059,
-0.6574510932,
-0.5898308158,
0.3951614797,
0.7348479629,
-0.1843909174,
1.3299876451,
0.0331020206,
-0.4118342698,
0.1131977439,
-1.0594054461,
0.2981550992,
-0.3987526298,
0.3445782363,
-0.4098740816,
-0.6606377363,
0.7161406875,
0.0577128716,
0.0567636937,
0.2331180274,
0.5368746519,
0.016797401,
1.230140686,
1.0167609453,
-0.4480701089,
0.2859501839,
0.0701545253,
0.2075334787,
-0.6873341799,
-0.6939588189,
-0.5863747597,
-0.1152288094,
-0.4358052611,
-0.5773397684,
0.5968107581,
-0.030227419,
-0.3666909933,
0.1137949973,
-0.1414584219,
0.4840050042,
0.4174127877,
0.1028397009,
0.6223245263,
-0.1012299508,
-0.2673108578,
-0.2923468947,
-0.5104407668,
-0.2271377444,
1.0362110138,
0.590313077,
0.7724601626,
0.3896560371,
0.5854836106,
-0.3751954138,
0.3522077203,
-0.617211163,
0.0685086846,
0.0403652787,
-0.8666830063,
-0.3337782919,
-0.6080598831,
-0.151363641,
0.5914255977,
-0.185529083,
-1.0040476322,
0.4987503588,
0.4630233943,
-0.4990303814,
0.3842773438,
-0.7579774261,
0.8362868428,
-0.1065637991,
-0.5445337892,
-0.2256067693,
-0.6999235749,
0.3863096237,
-0.2320779264,
0.0683716461,
-0.1969405264,
-0.064039208,
0.1921664625,
-0.1409366727,
0.8890072703,
-0.1096612588,
-0.549021244,
0.1207399815,
0.0334599055,
0.7854520679,
0.1936104894,
-0.2771682441,
0.150510788,
-0.2118919045,
-0.4730997682,
-0.691020906,
0.9516837001,
-0.7151585817,
-0.6164479852,
-0.4478522539,
-0.6617231965,
-0.7380334735,
0.0831014737,
0.1208333001,
0.3144108355,
-0.2608993948,
0.3691394031,
0.78714782,
-0.081977807,
0.3145873249,
0.479603976,
-0.0443542115,
-0.3338236511,
0.3131350279,
0.3232964575,
0.6039963961,
0.3678663969,
0.1359280348,
-0.4155749381,
-0.5065736771,
-0.3796225786,
-0.0262677018,
-0.5931552052,
-0.3274261951,
-0.8532800078,
-0.417834729,
-0.8131653666,
0.1587738246,
-1.0463649035,
-0.1675160676,
0.3393072486,
-0.0783841461,
0.2098479569,
0.5187200904,
-0.2217086852,
0.206277281,
-0.6452684402,
0.1151778474,
0.2883245945,
0.610268414,
0.0895057619,
-0.4922682345,
-0.195182085,
0.2425156385,
-0.0652336329,
-0.5273728371,
0.2254106998,
0.2018606812,
0.6649202108,
0.3651752472,
-0.0469954684,
0.6831693649,
-0.3785348535,
0.4995324016,
0.3430281281,
-1.1179254055,
0.3949469626,
-0.3126985133,
0.4069090486,
0.7021482587,
0.5550200939,
-0.5647366047,
-0.6826162338,
-0.4666807652,
-0.6639233232,
0.3770089447,
0.1512637585,
-0.1610488296,
0.2135066241,
0.2588782907,
-0.1017660648,
0.4481176734,
-0.7925524712,
-0.2492365837,
-0.4679168463,
-0.3047164679,
-0.4250973761,
-0.4721186757,
-0.3583414853,
-0.237275809,
0.7730028033,
-0.3294326663,
-0.382668376,
0.4471848607,
0.1737757921,
-0.2030179948,
0.3481751382,
0.6858074665,
1.0068743229,
-0.1722459495,
0.5123003125,
0.2789416909,
-0.4263387024,
0.1051580608,
0.0076581668,
-0.1814748347,
-0.2957300544,
0.2520703375,
0.3658291399,
0.2404644191,
-0.3540236652,
0.7447410226,
0.081282191,
0.048242569,
-0.5555210114,
-0.1746867448,
0.2879880667,
0.3589471281,
0.1128351465,
0.405081749,
-0.147337988,
-0.641397357,
0.0439291038,
0.5265809894,
-0.2139981091,
-0.0209908802,
0.3859341741,
-0.0925564766,
0.1539542377,
0.4031780064,
0.11267557,
-0.5693656206,
0.4355399609,
0.4523976743,
0.6613582969,
-0.5704096556,
0.214526087,
0.4147583842,
0.4267756343,
-0.7519249916,
0.1864375025,
0.2324884385,
-1.2051385641,
-0.7717155218,
-0.4561624527,
-0.5209619403,
-0.0396111086,
-0.5473508239,
-0.1896041781,
-0.6256891489,
-0.1138757318,
-0.1673447192,
0.0490730256,
-0.2131383568,
0.0764603615,
0.2487722188,
0.7209652662,
-0.8275001049,
1.3135646582,
0.3689937294,
-0.3243259192,
-1.2363394499,
0.2893398106,
0.3963215947,
-0.6108945608,
0.0303033851,
0.2439864129,
-0.6621325612,
-0.2594485879,
-0.7111307383,
-1.1005928516,
0.7932245135,
0.4782347977,
-0.6643793583,
0.2843645215,
-0.0685021579,
0.5102655888,
-0.6250125766,
0.0007217412,
0.5266304612,
0.6954345107,
0.2014950812,
-1.0896971226,
-0.2763679922,
0.0475284643,
0.0846173987,
0.0779416859,
-0.6877397299,
0.8297654986,
-0.2659406662,
0.0168664791,
0.1146924123,
0.7746717334,
0.6084720492,
0.1355475336,
0.7311161757,
0.45646137,
0.9338085055,
0.0649902746,
0.9374890924,
-0.2427626252,
0.5489093065,
1.6513605118,
-0.4160887599,
1.113014698,
0.6146531701,
-0.0525727533,
0.6316581964,
0.2885171771,
0.1637332886,
0.3557673693,
-0.2627621293,
-0.26862216,
-0.7657458186,
-0.1598195732,
-0.2257211357,
0.483635962,
0.1361612529,
-0.3059293628,
0.0060010301,
-0.1840021014,
0.2312950194,
0.4613728225,
-0.3405554295,
0.4916240573,
0.1411125213,
-0.648604095,
0.3656207025,
-0.0663429722,
0.6813545823,
-0.5168882012,
0.2170076966,
-0.14283517,
0.7578200698,
-0.1385268569,
-0.901330173,
0.0806543082,
-0.3333373368,
-0.3629959226,
-0.1131729782,
0.5636432767,
-0.8803476691,
-0.7731054425,
0.4316990376,
0.8031321168,
-0.0241827965,
-0.5119488835,
-0.457949549,
0.0443343669,
-0.0500071272,
-0.089791283,
0.2622348666,
0.5213453174,
0.1457976252,
0.735200882,
0.3008544743,
0.0977501944,
-0.0427534953,
0.1750216633,
0.6026699543,
-0.3622121513,
-0.3768819571,
-0.9829718471,
0.5043692589,
-0.4402480721,
-0.2646462321,
1.0894608498,
0.5704427361,
0.9456361532,
0.0497905836,
0.6403304338,
0.1989011765,
0.7782534957,
-0.2655716836,
0.7825436592,
-0.6085273623,
0.1773028374,
-0.5304306149,
-0.8026416898,
-0.5061975121,
0.8518750072,
-0.1834873706,
0.0856806487,
0.6529686451,
0.8408882022,
-0.038283322,
-0.0669004023,
0.473454684,
0.5221680403,
0.1698610634,
0.4538451135,
0.8097670078,
-0.2638889849,
0.3375873566,
-0.6232098341,
-0.3099113703,
0.2451317757,
-1.2077208757,
-0.7966693044,
-0.4980071783,
-0.2981888056,
-0.5745696425,
0.101124987,
0.9396541119,
0.9389049411,
-1.0344549417,
-0.1738798767,
0.0785986334,
0.2099292278,
-0.4071381688,
-0.1051132977,
0.1189735085,
-0.1573973,
-0.7910683751,
0.3493581116,
0.5879521966,
0.0286617223,
-0.7123246789,
-0.0001491265,
-0.5109628439,
0.1567794979,
0.4939570725,
0.1630338281,
-0.7991424799,
-0.817489922,
-0.1598348618,
-0.2774437666,
0.4826804101,
0.7558385134,
-0.5003323555,
0.3647806346,
0.3428048193,
0.4748966098,
0.1376247406,
0.3079737425,
0.9006330371,
-1.054756403,
0.4054169357,
-0.018955797,
0.487754494,
0.6376956105,
-0.59772259,
0.3200722039,
0.0880272016,
-0.35991925,
-0.6653630733,
0.3224578798,
-0.974522233,
-0.222615093,
0.9122220874,
-0.5468303561,
-0.1061120331,
-0.1687940359,
0.2154358327,
0.0950205922,
-0.5080090165,
0.9148050547,
1.0226393938,
0.0048667509,
-0.1896631569,
-0.4519387782,
0.3608520329,
0.4917042851,
-0.7670914531,
0.428455621,
0.5321463943,
0.469284147,
0.5734704733,
0.5638653636,
-0.2101695836,
-0.2376578599,
-0.0984338447,
0.0559839234,
0.2735908628,
-0.9519236684,
-0.3453857601,
0.3567562699,
0.1993803531,
-0.014780608
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11271v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11271v2
|
MONAL: Model Autophagy Analysis for Modeling Human-AI Interactions
| 2024-02-17T13:02:54 | 2024-03-30T22:05:59 |
Shu Yang, Muhammad Asif Ali, Lu Yu, Lijie Hu, Di Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC
|
The increasing significance of large models and their multi-modal variants in
societal information processing has ignited debates on social safety and
ethics. However, there exists a paucity of comprehensive analysis for: (i) the
interactions between human and artificial intelligence systems, and (ii)
understanding and addressing the associated limitations. To bridge this gap, we
propose Model Autophagy Analysis (MONAL) for large models' self-consumption
explanation. MONAL employs two distinct autophagous loops (referred to as
``self-consumption loops'') to elucidate the suppression of human-generated
information in the exchange between human and AI systems. Through comprehensive
experiments on diverse datasets, we evaluate the capacities of generated models
as both creators and disseminators of information. Our key findings reveal (i)
A progressive prevalence of model-generated synthetic information over time
within training datasets compared to human-generated information; (ii) The
discernible tendency of large models, when acting as information transmitters
across multiple iterations, to selectively modify or prioritize specific
contents; and (iii) The potential for a reduction in the diversity of socially
or human-generated information, leading to bottlenecks in the performance
enhancement of large models and confining them to local optima.
|
[
-0.3611516356,
-0.8703382015,
0.4122222066,
-0.2057854533,
0.105323419,
0.0766163915,
0.1653593779,
-0.6333705783,
0.2227057219,
0.484901458,
-0.5951089859,
0.0344700441,
-0.4404315352,
-0.1241524369,
-0.5234315991,
0.8467917442,
0.2699612081,
-0.117460452,
-0.2077932805,
-0.0062302561,
-0.36150226,
-0.7841055393,
-0.5587329865,
-0.4186832309,
0.6948446631,
0.1730022132,
0.7839108109,
0.7902712822,
0.4059052169,
0.4294531941,
0.256688714,
0.1138914824,
-0.4746585488,
0.2608560324,
-0.3068820834,
0.0051366515,
-0.5626017451,
0.3945177197,
0.6193454862,
0.7583321929,
-0.1624549627,
0.4886616766,
0.3545506597,
0.8106889725,
-0.8177876472,
0.2682802081,
-0.5413596034,
0.1102577522,
-0.1413835436,
-0.0008776585,
-0.2523491681,
-0.0167850237,
0.1428348869,
-0.5509917736,
-0.1697968543,
0.207580626,
0.4984340966,
0.6292995811,
-0.4083449841,
-0.3717938364,
-1.0494035482,
0.6461633444,
-0.7629141808,
-0.1133213118,
0.4656902552,
0.1745496094,
-0.0726870298,
-0.5032462478,
-0.5668844581,
-0.3274736702,
-0.1812642217,
0.119512029,
-0.3896954656,
0.2294958532,
0.3663007021,
0.2777072787,
-0.4601333141,
-0.0070257368,
-0.6562741995,
-0.3033048213,
0.9468889236,
0.5031947494,
0.4354700744,
-0.4736736715,
-0.2772915065,
0.0766785294,
-0.2720796466,
-0.037957076,
0.6979442239,
-0.2010101229,
-0.0087282835,
0.7339629531,
-0.1841210872,
0.5474425554,
0.1107657403,
0.3092748821,
0.0591445379,
-0.354550004,
-0.4704885185,
-0.221762374,
0.9204400182,
0.2721609175,
0.2063715607,
0.2088741958,
-0.077091068,
0.005941784,
0.4846297503,
-0.7340509892,
-0.6397386193,
0.1856921464,
-0.8784318566,
-0.5545427203,
-0.0184720363,
-0.6054241061,
-0.5528630018,
-0.4952312708,
0.4345873296,
-0.2246875316,
-0.36966452,
0.1704421043,
-0.1129107475,
0.1121170595,
-0.0125780739,
-0.7175659537,
0.2249276787,
0.2440974265,
0.6634001732,
-0.0456157848,
-0.4049397409,
-0.2914834917,
0.5033879876,
-0.1855104715,
0.584898591,
-0.3785043359,
-0.253870815,
-0.4065128863,
-0.0644523799,
-0.1821646988,
-0.6523957253,
0.0382356867,
-0.3993868232,
-0.0505252853,
-0.5096664429,
-0.6852891445,
-0.4075695276,
0.1303705275,
-0.8173241615,
0.695012033,
-0.0383868255,
-0.7482435703,
0.167603448,
-1.0179841518,
-0.4907232523,
-0.025167821,
-0.1462474465,
-0.3141296506,
0.019865334,
-0.0551064648,
0.5025359392,
-0.2968193889,
0.5862603188,
-0.6768121719,
0.1561603993,
0.4368509352,
-0.5974800587,
0.9394362569,
0.5268191695,
-0.3265650868,
0.2684896588,
-0.6164944172,
-0.3040655255,
0.185079217,
-0.1082693413,
-0.3299725652,
0.3743957281,
-0.1733556092,
0.2712230086,
0.3426357508,
-0.3610872626,
0.1536054462,
-0.0211983714,
0.9793711901,
0.8463130593,
-0.0623441301,
0.4326609969,
-0.5994572043,
0.4275182784,
0.1062380373,
0.5825299025,
-0.3166951239,
-0.3752499819,
-0.699424088,
-0.1045355648,
0.0936157554,
0.4241999388,
-0.3437062502,
0.5015300512,
0.2542777658,
-0.1587774456,
-0.40900141,
0.1787799299,
0.2717337906,
0.4747060835,
0.2953260839,
-0.441277951,
-0.3459812701,
-1.2937217951,
-0.2026680857,
-0.2390666604,
0.0228659175,
0.4125601351,
0.6082215309,
-0.4324298799,
1.0179852247,
-0.2167979777,
0.0499763265,
-0.2485072613,
0.442443192,
-0.3693433106,
0.7194557786,
0.6401626468,
-0.5077188611,
-0.0745607018,
-0.3633677661,
-1.0646580458,
-0.0295466315,
-0.2050653398,
-0.2532534599,
0.0124881361,
0.2796223462,
-0.4898790419,
0.6866750121,
0.2181743085,
-0.3253328502,
0.6503292918,
-0.4358491004,
0.0412115976,
-0.605682075,
0.3256920278,
-0.2393744141,
-0.2033382654,
-0.7211124301,
-0.0142086092,
-0.0752402171,
-0.3657529056,
-0.0738819912,
0.563532114,
-0.5761416554,
-0.3839003742,
-0.307061553,
-0.1545713246,
0.2058572322,
0.2492589355,
-0.2948620319,
0.5943382382,
0.3679275215,
-0.5366969109,
0.3391393721,
0.0900881961,
-0.2282015085,
0.1736549139,
-0.7985935211,
0.2010867447,
-0.2497209162,
0.3610160053,
-1.1970502138,
-0.5783330798,
0.6345108747,
-0.3592342734,
0.121532917,
0.0482771471,
-0.4870769978,
-0.4733616114,
-0.0930896103,
0.7872084975,
0.4379853606,
-0.2696560025,
0.8778626919,
0.7328031659,
-0.2354495674,
-0.2285642326,
-0.535312295,
0.0688405931,
-0.3489927351,
-0.7896087766,
-0.1169064045,
-0.3671503067,
-0.4955036342,
0.0233878121,
0.0539773442,
-0.069170557,
0.2851644456,
0.3138793111,
0.4577970207,
0.1019111425,
0.0228151008,
0.0922663882,
-0.1241974756,
0.5093566179,
-0.4799211919,
0.3633509874,
0.010279296,
-0.3613598049,
-0.8650997281,
0.4255450368,
0.8115536571,
-0.3628391922,
0.6431372762,
0.4833674133,
-0.2625066936,
-0.0323398896,
-0.7007015944,
-0.1333682388,
-0.5077531338,
0.0381861962,
-0.0519221909,
-0.470159173,
0.6446816325,
0.167622745,
0.0453864709,
0.5155941248,
0.5709990859,
-0.2998086214,
1.0866237879,
0.306052655,
-0.5202081203,
0.3704954982,
-0.5307102799,
0.0479039773,
-0.7573017478,
-0.0575138405,
-0.0695893317,
-0.5038409233,
-0.2426228374,
-0.3926690519,
0.4027302563,
-0.2371280342,
-0.4628557861,
-0.1030848399,
-0.5713120699,
0.3730297387,
0.5278350115,
-0.0430208668,
0.0863228813,
-0.1667057574,
0.0924744532,
0.2296133339,
-0.8048839569,
-0.3277110457,
1.0323967934,
0.4138171077,
0.9307205081,
-0.2640027702,
0.4573225379,
0.7848260999,
0.0788939968,
-0.5563119054,
0.4236233532,
-0.0876943171,
-0.8783131838,
-0.2214972228,
-0.4975272119,
-0.9145005345,
0.1093072593,
-0.1453660876,
-0.5750261545,
0.291151613,
0.5008454323,
-0.7898410559,
0.2922853231,
-0.6291571856,
0.8901947737,
-0.4245510697,
-0.4982059598,
-0.6586777568,
-0.6817046404,
0.6118189096,
-0.0470585786,
0.510836482,
-0.2886655629,
0.3361789584,
0.6470364332,
-0.4201649427,
1.0103577375,
-0.1065764651,
-0.0610946529,
0.6130415797,
0.2255620807,
0.3925945759,
-0.02642278,
-0.033143729,
0.1635342687,
-0.0073381597,
-0.4419597685,
-0.3637881875,
0.4457224011,
-0.866722703,
-0.5120990872,
-0.3655796349,
-0.7775529027,
0.3000037074,
-0.0045108777,
0.2025179267,
0.6340461373,
0.0240170881,
0.013344219,
0.4354068041,
-0.377625823,
0.4038473666,
0.2735847235,
-0.1313912421,
-0.2266136408,
0.8510041833,
0.2936115861,
0.3701045513,
-0.3598561883,
0.3692498505,
-0.0962179303,
-0.3490380049,
-0.4712469578,
0.2550880313,
-0.3400876224,
0.0086549427,
-0.6289349198,
-0.5005666018,
-0.2991046011,
0.0035128426,
-0.4346661568,
-0.3294156492,
-0.3823309541,
0.1093211696,
-0.0878988951,
1.1187511683,
-0.4860097766,
0.2418245673,
-0.6914397478,
0.4958277345,
0.4037961662,
0.0823638812,
0.3814455867,
-0.2102296948,
-0.3007982373,
0.192958653,
-0.3614262938,
-1.0735682249,
0.3598099351,
0.0626485646,
0.5811116695,
0.7047562003,
0.176859647,
0.5921232104,
-0.2400270402,
0.6887157559,
-0.0289091803,
-1.0274149179,
0.5366588235,
-0.7075180411,
0.1462434083,
0.3263503015,
0.188127026,
-0.3308719099,
-0.2884991765,
-0.6564254761,
-0.8270348907,
0.720646143,
0.4404574037,
-0.0107786451,
0.0566233359,
0.5917052031,
-0.0564106219,
0.3827379048,
-0.7338997126,
-0.2387198955,
-0.2103761733,
-0.0442654863,
0.2740991712,
-0.4029082358,
-0.1670672297,
-0.4076221287,
0.6167149544,
0.0891472772,
0.176188156,
0.2340919226,
-0.1250276715,
-0.2614441216,
-0.1393116713,
0.1961531192,
0.4993539751,
-0.0399786569,
0.0143544441,
-0.2075860798,
-0.2440305799,
0.1765472293,
0.1332067549,
-0.1957226396,
-0.5663830638,
0.2014859617,
0.4784437716,
0.0411158875,
-0.6688969731,
0.174136281,
-0.0732541531,
-0.121655196,
-0.7519002557,
0.3042070866,
-0.0660471469,
0.5230600238,
0.2346431762,
0.1233691797,
0.608669281,
-0.7555968165,
0.1398941129,
0.7103481889,
0.0249096081,
-0.4030669332,
0.8334186673,
0.2946271598,
-0.1165426522,
0.800914824,
-0.3866911829,
-0.3745265305,
0.8923000693,
0.0786000565,
0.9362077713,
-0.364500612,
0.2306113243,
0.5243968368,
0.3250223696,
0.1135435626,
-0.0353855342,
-0.2882539332,
-0.7300264239,
-0.2657127976,
-0.5181678534,
-0.058800824,
0.3547436297,
-0.8679133654,
-0.1860619038,
-0.4449317753,
-0.292535603,
0.2913626432,
-0.161698699,
-0.5877425075,
-0.0573980138,
0.4507723153,
0.2687829137,
-0.7144327164,
0.8250722885,
0.4583474994,
-0.3496187329,
-0.7191463113,
-0.0074611804,
0.2561866343,
-0.569311738,
0.5973325372,
0.1707640886,
-0.2022453994,
0.0124118086,
-0.60034585,
-1.1627401114,
1.0253206491,
0.1259950548,
-0.5809745193,
-0.3481184542,
0.1280196607,
0.2937534153,
-0.592064023,
0.2262348235,
0.7406044006,
0.6165078878,
-0.0453516766,
-0.6926480532,
-0.072066389,
-0.4516621232,
-0.0445867963,
0.0184806492,
-0.8105350733,
0.9974865913,
-0.1378421038,
-0.1952988952,
0.209115088,
0.420802772,
-0.1352957785,
0.4688866735,
0.7854471207,
0.3910337687,
0.7052577138,
0.5166513324,
0.872163713,
-0.4917447269,
0.4480578303,
1.133431673,
-0.436401546,
0.2695804834,
-0.0586162768,
-0.0849713832,
0.4181591272,
0.6240982413,
-0.1141875386,
0.1193999574,
0.2109974921,
-0.0220591668,
-0.4053292274,
0.1818319112,
-0.0903500468,
0.6315649152,
0.5598919988,
-0.5261517763,
-0.068657741,
0.2161149085,
-0.167949751,
-0.4180168211,
-0.1345807463,
0.8249633312,
-0.1572760642,
-0.5305570364,
0.4781205356,
-0.2033691406,
0.1193073615,
-0.3361693323,
0.1636198163,
-0.1058768556,
0.0028150119,
-0.0154367909,
-0.3806711137,
0.5656758547,
-0.0844230726,
-0.3131968081,
-0.0473285578,
1.0562521219,
-0.2671477497,
-0.4665263593,
0.6352415085,
0.5506207943,
0.1673144698,
0.0009887475,
-0.974653542,
0.0103766844,
-0.0212479793,
-0.4092822969,
0.3058706224,
0.1187224016,
0.1489671022,
0.7986719608,
0.6569979787,
-0.154698357,
0.1363257468,
-0.2234875262,
0.889990449,
-0.771281004,
-0.5120941401,
-0.9686922431,
0.5185578465,
-0.2114579678,
-0.0069127213,
0.5950967073,
0.5486677885,
0.5656071305,
0.1390107125,
1.1648877859,
-0.1529871076,
0.2826482356,
-0.3327649236,
0.9559594989,
-0.7266237736,
0.2977705002,
-0.1655021608,
-0.6702768803,
0.4634681642,
0.7034549117,
-0.3513950408,
0.0427162945,
0.3416175246,
0.4788963199,
-0.2661576271,
0.1096458137,
0.3230969608,
0.5760595202,
0.1358305663,
0.3123636544,
1.2545022964,
0.0074693044,
0.1682121456,
-0.2764904499,
-0.3445956409,
-0.3230869174,
-0.587802887,
-0.962683022,
-0.6891220212,
-0.1236024499,
-0.212293461,
0.0887000039,
0.8849628568,
1.0178463459,
-0.4251337051,
-0.5381756425,
0.0656210631,
-0.1022079512,
-0.0057987934,
-0.1766193658,
0.0115109887,
-0.5119771957,
-0.4131330252,
0.3137765825,
0.3616144359,
-0.0351012312,
-0.7925240397,
0.1853658408,
-0.07660909,
0.4636532962,
0.7003625035,
0.3498290479,
-0.6658278108,
-0.1515775919,
-0.2157412171,
0.0921001583,
0.0417241342,
1.1170783043,
-0.7658740282,
0.6044365764,
0.2931925654,
0.4016043246,
0.4042807519,
0.3063263297,
0.6162634492,
-0.1227077916,
0.031797424,
0.064122282,
0.3799563944,
0.1065835133,
-0.6077273488,
0.3091777265,
0.2005363107,
-0.9949324131,
-0.5005223751,
0.4953200817,
-0.6591815352,
-0.5323596001,
1.0174146891,
-0.1011114046,
-0.2971307933,
-0.2342822701,
-0.1999215335,
0.3480146527,
-0.3717806935,
1.1946202517,
0.6422183514,
-0.4379930794,
0.1037025824,
-0.8450297713,
0.4534667134,
0.3567051888,
-0.963439405,
0.4326416254,
1.037741065,
0.4144248664,
0.0786574855,
0.6625486612,
0.1287181079,
0.1240606308,
-0.1350810081,
-0.0983305797,
-0.161400333,
-0.6311731935,
-0.2658873498,
0.0188997034,
-0.2720840573,
-0.0991202891
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11260v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11260v1
|
MoRAL: MoE Augmented LoRA for LLMs' Lifelong Learning
| 2024-02-17T12:25:31 | 2024-02-17T12:25:31 |
Shu Yang, Muhammad Asif Ali, Cheng-Long Wang, Lijie Hu, Di Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Adapting large language models (LLMs) to new domains/tasks and enabling them
to be efficient lifelong learners is a pivotal challenge. In this paper, we
propose MoRAL, i.e., Mixture-of-Experts augmented Low-Rank Adaptation for
Lifelong Learning. MoRAL combines the multi-tasking abilities of MoE with the
fine-tuning abilities of LoRA for effective life-long learning of LLMs. In
contrast to the conventional approaches that use factual triplets as inputs
MoRAL relies on simple question-answer pairs, which is a more practical and
effective strategy for robust and efficient learning. Owing to new data
settings, we introduce a new evaluation benchmark namely: Life Long Learning of
LLM (5L-bench) encompassing a newly curated dataset of question-answer pairs,
and a set of evaluation metrics for rigorous evaluation of MoRAL in open-book
and closed-book settings. Experimental evaluation shows (i) LLMs learn fast in
open-book settings with up to 30.15% improvement in "RA" for Phi-2-2.7B
compared to closed-book (for models fine-tuned with MoRAL); (ii) MoRAL shows
higher performance improvement for models with a greater number of parameters;
(iii) MoRAL is robust to catastrophic forgetting offering better knowledge
retention compared to baselines.
|
[
-0.1336911619,
-0.8688459396,
0.4104388058,
0.0452578999,
-0.3406448364,
0.3017935455,
-0.4494377077,
-0.3434818685,
-0.1119769737,
0.5943020582,
-0.3262744844,
-0.3881452978,
-0.6260131598,
-0.1282903403,
0.1665889472,
0.9673368335,
0.215401426,
0.2358967364,
-0.2444269955,
-0.5630973577,
-0.648884654,
-0.4143559337,
-0.8259296417,
-0.3097055852,
0.7018416524,
0.5043867826,
0.4623572826,
0.4048551619,
0.2762042582,
0.2942780554,
-0.077931501,
0.5860264897,
-1.0193918943,
0.2014709115,
-0.4123409688,
-0.5026502609,
-0.7811113596,
0.0452735759,
0.5735193491,
0.6582428813,
-0.245729059,
0.2087989599,
0.3975504637,
1.0059254169,
-0.8124123812,
0.0329222009,
-0.7185234427,
-0.0727833062,
0.1590660661,
-0.3704024255,
-0.5402390361,
-0.6288256049,
-0.0336160995,
-0.6690611243,
-0.488369137,
0.0557903014,
0.3166922331,
0.3920711577,
-0.4932937622,
-0.3664209545,
-0.6098073721,
1.2537113428,
-0.5450537205,
0.4382758141,
0.3722462654,
0.2007783353,
-0.1723632365,
-0.1614665389,
-0.2830730379,
-0.1514942348,
0.4622729719,
0.2952156663,
0.2911917865,
-0.1375148892,
-0.034390375,
0.4015010297,
0.1148043498,
0.140629828,
-0.3334105909,
0.0782901347,
0.7789321542,
0.1614996046,
0.0486668907,
-0.0573638715,
-0.5351996422,
0.0484576412,
-0.7441011071,
0.143459931,
0.2955098152,
0.081589669,
-0.1146983728,
0.4999896586,
0.089701049,
0.5912896395,
0.133387953,
-0.582731545,
0.2103155106,
-0.1601206213,
0.0762528181,
-0.1252856702,
0.5202392936,
0.5156088471,
0.7962307334,
-0.0028612874,
-0.1905532628,
-0.4223545492,
0.1393877715,
-0.6130133271,
-0.086242713,
0.0054450408,
-0.3888763487,
-0.2512768805,
-0.2124338895,
-0.6653789878,
-0.5138424635,
-0.5358847976,
0.6149097681,
-0.697437048,
0.0506995469,
0.447588414,
0.3124608696,
0.3077457845,
0.6146749854,
-0.7354137897,
0.1915881038,
0.6312470436,
0.7204879522,
-0.4618294835,
-0.2307394296,
-1.0871765614,
0.3628738523,
-0.2525333166,
0.6783820391,
-0.6358035803,
-0.5568659902,
-0.2193534076,
-0.1506738514,
-0.1735141277,
-0.5719932914,
0.6187428832,
-0.5032919645,
0.0743195117,
-0.287324667,
-0.5453856587,
-0.2087415904,
0.1477344036,
-0.542737186,
1.1468271017,
0.1649139225,
-0.4095700383,
0.3643217981,
-0.9017776847,
-0.3655695319,
-0.0126661165,
0.1217674091,
-0.3968555331,
0.1090424955,
0.1413784623,
0.667096734,
-0.1480206847,
0.3787404299,
-0.5637806058,
-0.5278136134,
0.2360933274,
-0.5704906583,
0.8034512401,
-0.0432364643,
0.0422105826,
0.0549250133,
-0.9018166661,
-0.0133000305,
0.048474215,
-0.8473141193,
-0.5551480055,
0.3436341286,
-0.1740856171,
-0.1143435463,
0.4626071453,
-0.4818338752,
0.2564176917,
-0.3076288402,
0.3469632268,
1.1843380928,
0.1541430056,
0.3230205476,
-0.5884812474,
0.2595041096,
0.0193253253,
0.3062187731,
0.1844370067,
-0.4831851423,
-1.0577903986,
-0.3947634399,
0.082268931,
0.7081042528,
-0.6855620146,
0.616910696,
-0.452270478,
-0.367869854,
-0.3162341714,
0.5908085704,
0.2831738889,
0.4395081699,
0.5469254851,
-0.2959376276,
-0.2368777692,
-0.396897316,
-0.4410186112,
-0.2082432956,
0.2155864239,
0.5333672762,
0.6166214943,
-0.2293356806,
0.8218862414,
-0.3419146538,
-0.1126025766,
-0.0823347643,
-0.0547819622,
0.360116154,
0.4559460282,
0.4423120022,
-0.7431498766,
-0.5753454566,
0.0291856658,
-0.8319029808,
0.2141838819,
0.1309101135,
-0.1565130502,
0.0812693089,
0.4109772146,
-0.0407117754,
0.0834641978,
0.3327553868,
-0.2170156538,
0.4891447425,
-0.4270020127,
-0.0173915327,
-1.1658508778,
-0.1952767521,
-0.2571623921,
-0.4724150598,
-0.3187364042,
-0.0092651993,
0.0567821264,
0.0858220682,
-0.5933309793,
0.8216679096,
-0.2780406177,
-0.0361027829,
-0.1437840313,
0.2055536807,
-0.2419634163,
0.5118481517,
-0.2453495562,
0.9588688612,
0.5350980759,
-0.730602324,
0.4290978611,
0.3318791986,
-0.4258214533,
0.8876048923,
-0.5424556732,
0.2626930773,
-0.0296360329,
0.127932027,
-0.4055440128,
-0.1104490012,
0.1342943311,
-0.1545838118,
0.0435692854,
-0.0135848662,
-0.4018682241,
0.0507540591,
-0.5286226869,
0.3970188797,
0.7639300823,
-0.5688064694,
0.9389619231,
0.1796207428,
-0.2602433562,
-0.6954641938,
-0.4204254746,
-0.0946450233,
-0.3688411713,
-0.4609564543,
0.0379799381,
-0.5034274459,
-0.2804519534,
-0.0784285888,
-0.0966228768,
0.1213621795,
0.4393323362,
0.1550644189,
0.2675124407,
-0.3494127691,
0.242616713,
0.1633780301,
-0.2178350836,
-0.1509378552,
-0.1995082796,
0.3112517893,
-0.4882492125,
-0.297521472,
-0.0650784448,
0.245326668,
0.6907357574,
-0.3188034594,
0.9080805779,
0.5440862775,
-0.1688128859,
-0.213886261,
-0.60566324,
0.108406581,
-0.4973169565,
0.2574853897,
-0.2797656059,
-1.0308805704,
0.4330892861,
-0.2335674018,
0.206197679,
0.3712173998,
0.6079676151,
-0.386536926,
0.3369998932,
0.7569835186,
-0.1394020468,
0.5186109543,
-0.1381716579,
0.1320293397,
-1.1446441412,
-0.1441045702,
0.0161214359,
-0.231221199,
-0.5038241744,
-0.5911923647,
0.6815817952,
0.5530557036,
-0.4597019255,
-0.0525292456,
-0.1062574312,
0.676192224,
0.4159419835,
0.4941157103,
0.6357063055,
0.0040499629,
0.0203549042,
0.2164607346,
-0.612477541,
-0.4514435232,
1.4941804409,
0.2533471286,
0.8655288219,
0.2426992655,
0.8154534698,
0.4641155303,
0.4729122818,
-0.8283064365,
0.648039937,
-0.517003715,
-0.3905676901,
-0.3076435924,
-0.3478526771,
-0.6416468024,
0.1045409292,
-0.3001438677,
-0.6147451401,
0.2096392512,
0.1073906273,
-0.5736783147,
0.3110763133,
-0.5491581559,
0.3591798246,
-0.5652030706,
-0.7306966782,
-0.5499863625,
-0.482789278,
0.2314580083,
-0.4992056787,
0.2438752353,
-0.3553393781,
-0.298393935,
0.8528818488,
-0.080371432,
0.9498225451,
-0.0827543288,
-0.2483700365,
0.27030316,
-0.188128531,
0.5393113494,
0.1316908002,
-0.4096031189,
0.0936802998,
-0.0403882638,
-0.6571577787,
-0.4797523618,
0.7087146044,
-0.8204275966,
-0.5498263836,
-0.3599886596,
-0.7175797224,
-0.5911256075,
0.0933464766,
-0.1651324928,
0.3760691583,
-0.2240473181,
0.560768187,
0.9113699198,
-0.471878767,
0.2630222738,
0.5536866188,
-0.1705092937,
-0.6672439575,
1.0861377716,
-0.0615779944,
0.5733250976,
0.2616092265,
0.4245379865,
-0.2151386589,
-0.513450861,
-0.2355148345,
0.3874976039,
-0.9562186003,
-0.076049231,
-0.559556663,
-0.1611743122,
0.0597107336,
-0.4853528142,
-0.3020035326,
-0.2106767148,
-0.4166507721,
0.1032642126,
0.5918815732,
0.591237545,
-0.1351806074,
0.1596731246,
-0.7741770744,
0.523188591,
0.6124646068,
0.3866203725,
-0.1171325669,
-0.6550847888,
-0.2111830562,
0.1332497746,
-0.290979296,
-0.3973378837,
-0.1335437,
0.7256447673,
0.4743393064,
0.2769749165,
0.0684255883,
0.6385018826,
-0.5103722811,
0.5599731803,
0.1597153246,
-0.890839994,
0.3428514302,
-0.5026238561,
-0.05755255,
0.7143596411,
0.2835726142,
-0.1698836535,
-0.0328758508,
-0.2435827553,
-0.5963513255,
0.3858753145,
-0.045707006,
0.3308423162,
0.1801706851,
0.5259212852,
0.4667120278,
0.101506941,
-0.7707709074,
-0.0868323371,
-0.0024021855,
-0.2751610875,
-0.306755662,
-0.4205088615,
-0.0678761378,
-0.5227705836,
0.727391243,
-0.4454464912,
0.0934301242,
-0.2000318021,
-0.2515571415,
0.0357869491,
0.3980185986,
0.3927742243,
0.7763445973,
-0.4091688395,
-0.1961863339,
0.4831655324,
-0.3682737052,
0.1767230034,
-0.2551163137,
0.094288215,
-0.5125963092,
0.4499759376,
0.6377563477,
0.5463604927,
-0.6540998816,
0.3924816251,
0.2398724109,
0.0259072352,
-0.3760636747,
0.6038957834,
0.2430752963,
0.3034286201,
0.3401036859,
0.1412122697,
-0.3058787286,
-0.7222670317,
0.1712423116,
0.2400687933,
-0.2730041444,
-0.0571547635,
0.4314399362,
0.5564354658,
-0.2048513442,
0.3795217276,
-0.0162299164,
-0.4186653793,
0.2758639157,
0.4343220294,
0.6389245987,
-0.3629756272,
0.0676293075,
0.3023306131,
0.0520128794,
-0.041501835,
0.4784035683,
-0.2132958323,
-0.8277180791,
-0.5051054955,
-0.9052972794,
-0.4703609347,
-0.1142879203,
-0.8242855668,
0.250895679,
-0.4714560509,
0.1753645986,
-0.4285493493,
-0.0095842788,
-0.4298085868,
0.2162665576,
-0.1637846529,
0.7592887878,
-0.6680877805,
0.95605129,
0.4782066345,
-0.1388056576,
-0.246639356,
-0.0247623138,
-0.3315321505,
-1.075330019,
0.5900546312,
-0.0150830578,
-0.5280286074,
0.3575819731,
-0.5543142557,
-0.6851625443,
1.277910471,
0.5325091481,
-0.5258544087,
-0.0149748772,
-0.10085807,
0.379229635,
-0.4041035771,
-0.0327777863,
0.3611933589,
0.4338567257,
-0.1071139276,
-0.6684116721,
-0.3709176779,
-0.0153340613,
-0.3165282905,
0.0925053582,
-0.8705548048,
0.7143400311,
-0.3608105481,
0.1384999156,
0.2581839859,
0.7433301806,
0.5452778339,
0.2688750327,
0.6138051748,
0.3841411173,
0.9231140018,
0.0770471692,
0.9800038934,
-0.394633919,
0.609134376,
1.0647574663,
-0.3042030334,
1.0690985918,
0.4288066328,
-0.1435147077,
0.6153165698,
0.4853831828,
0.0371869728,
0.4007830322,
-0.1440998018,
-0.3014504015,
-0.7790602446,
-0.1168497056,
-0.3548015654,
0.3332364857,
0.582873106,
-0.1045141891,
0.0287157595,
0.2044200152,
-0.064937681,
0.1104088277,
-0.4546036422,
0.5693566203,
0.4150596857,
-0.367784977,
0.7321315408,
-0.0552427173,
0.810485661,
-0.5103863478,
0.014888539,
-0.1432184428,
0.3231269717,
-0.079574734,
-0.7438842654,
-0.0169262551,
0.0793430209,
-0.0868318155,
-0.1594019681,
0.5725952387,
-0.2552596033,
-0.6889947057,
0.4519577324,
0.6078794599,
0.0416008607,
0.2084259242,
-0.8662873507,
-0.1866853386,
-0.1602944583,
-0.1336594373,
0.1955497712,
0.2534795105,
-0.0686879009,
1.1016776562,
0.6964775324,
0.0677997023,
0.1206413805,
-0.1727287322,
0.8190879822,
-0.6792048812,
-0.3360601068,
-0.6844036579,
0.4987270832,
0.1258563399,
-0.3990585804,
0.5727075934,
0.4316455424,
0.7498681545,
-0.066775091,
0.6726288795,
0.1748600751,
0.3777416646,
-1.0306414366,
0.7445869446,
-0.8473305702,
0.2263862193,
0.0200694352,
-1.1102571487,
-0.025977483,
0.4275571406,
-0.5893989801,
0.3387702405,
0.7746341228,
0.3758323193,
-0.3542775512,
-0.1359046698,
0.5614436269,
0.3425858021,
0.1055767834,
0.8607254028,
0.8704327345,
-0.3801423609,
0.128155306,
-0.0959326476,
-0.1300328374,
-0.3594841361,
-0.8899081349,
-1.058347106,
-0.3859632015,
-0.3037449419,
-0.0238173697,
0.4638529718,
0.936814785,
0.5267696381,
-0.7683393359,
-0.1335487366,
0.1342158169,
0.109585844,
-0.1073633581,
-0.1252335757,
0.5291665196,
-0.1705717295,
-0.7290912271,
0.5600486398,
0.5251932144,
-0.2827703953,
-0.2606865466,
-0.4720476866,
-0.1966849416,
0.3169839084,
0.8456048369,
0.0532018542,
-0.7895576954,
-0.5305449367,
-0.1773906946,
0.0802418143,
0.2544365227,
0.5833619237,
-0.6098045111,
0.4542486966,
0.125970155,
0.8910002708,
0.1328896582,
0.1625523716,
0.4170259535,
-0.2725902498,
-0.0793360174,
0.2833937407,
0.3545721173,
0.3556624353,
-0.3528008461,
0.5905818343,
0.378033489,
-0.5520395637,
-0.5775851607,
0.2446043342,
-1.2337129116,
-0.0668330342,
1.2745170593,
-0.2886658013,
-0.1952973455,
-0.2433965951,
-0.1716700792,
0.0208765846,
-0.4156958163,
0.624612093,
0.686339736,
-0.0499268547,
-0.0611449108,
-0.6882091165,
-0.0769038498,
0.6488178968,
-0.88667202,
-0.0585039258,
0.364202708,
0.5637074709,
-0.118599236,
0.3911414742,
-0.0797028914,
0.3340213299,
-0.5289456844,
-0.1789901406,
-0.182973966,
-0.3416994512,
-0.3284290135,
-0.0050118235,
0.2161713392,
0.0311904978
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11254v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11254v2
|
C-ICL: Contrastive In-context Learning for Information Extraction
| 2024-02-17T11:28:08 | 2024-06-24T08:34:56 |
Ying Mo, Jiahao Liu, Jian Yang, Qifan Wang, Shun Zhang, Jingang Wang, Zhoujun Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
There has been increasing interest in exploring the capabilities of advanced
large language models (LLMs) in the field of information extraction (IE),
specifically focusing on tasks related to named entity recognition (NER) and
relation extraction (RE). Although researchers are exploring the use of
few-shot information extraction through in-context learning with LLMs, they
tend to focus only on using correct or positive examples for demonstration,
neglecting the potential value of incorporating incorrect or negative examples
into the learning process. In this paper, we present c-ICL, a novel few-shot
technique that leverages both correct and incorrect sample constructions to
create in-context learning demonstrations. This approach enhances the ability
of LLMs to extract entities and relations by utilizing prompts that incorporate
not only the positive samples but also the reasoning behind them. This method
allows for the identification and correction of potential interface errors.
Specifically, our proposed method taps into the inherent contextual information
and valuable information in hard negative samples and the nearest positive
neighbors to the test and then applies the in-context learning demonstrations
based on LLMs. Our experiments on various datasets indicate that c-ICL
outperforms previous few-shot in-context learning methods, delivering
substantial enhancements in performance across a broad spectrum of related
tasks. These improvements are noteworthy, showcasing the versatility of our
approach in miscellaneous scenarios.
|
[
-0.5059816837,
-0.9665845037,
0.412843734,
-0.1166702062,
-0.3807475865,
0.2337834537,
-0.2846371233,
-0.5808336735,
-0.1250528693,
0.1443846673,
-0.4904565811,
-0.7305548787,
-0.2568500042,
0.1095238626,
-0.3652096689,
1.0124922991,
0.0273483694,
0.2986235917,
-0.224647209,
-0.1315523237,
-0.2935594618,
-0.3436235487,
-0.6711688042,
-0.4060830176,
0.4506419003,
0.9472779632,
0.0905056521,
0.3101041019,
0.4622325003,
0.1434325725,
0.0784083977,
0.2464936674,
-0.5821405649,
-0.0743835643,
-0.2573945522,
-0.3647329807,
0.0936475247,
-0.0631141439,
0.6682732701,
0.6358950734,
0.1551997364,
0.2077949494,
0.5801395774,
0.3596810699,
-0.7924060225,
0.196488753,
-0.973557353,
0.0158420689,
-0.3461616933,
-0.3586079478,
-0.5831978917,
-0.1345491856,
0.1832302213,
-0.6135163903,
0.0485767759,
0.0921031982,
0.936439395,
0.1361598372,
-0.4153808057,
-0.4786827862,
-0.4530887306,
0.9406821728,
-0.8638042808,
0.3511729836,
0.2002364695,
0.4704117477,
-0.1313574463,
-0.6888810396,
-0.7504569292,
-0.3633070886,
-0.3219214678,
0.1023350805,
0.1298844963,
-0.0440975092,
0.45936203,
-0.0024895046,
-0.1355825514,
0.3522090018,
-0.2655022144,
-0.0262973458,
0.268279165,
0.1519301236,
0.2001844496,
-0.0111908345,
-0.5261284709,
-0.0357245021,
-1.273342371,
0.1945521981,
0.0643957183,
0.6160789132,
-0.4353318512,
0.5403674841,
-0.1230522022,
0.5029606223,
0.2892792225,
-0.3701623976,
0.1898731291,
0.0219955333,
-0.2741651237,
0.1885586083,
0.4932703376,
0.2873740792,
-0.1728105992,
-0.1321102232,
-0.0640567541,
-0.1551512331,
-0.2627447248,
-0.9253799319,
-0.1532216221,
0.0294330325,
-0.501395762,
-0.0814742595,
0.0325838514,
-0.8662565947,
-0.232099399,
-0.4639733732,
0.3438474536,
-0.4313235879,
0.0535336323,
-0.4549500048,
-0.0729428679,
0.5535522699,
0.4435473979,
-0.4442996681,
0.4680422544,
0.4368251562,
0.6199170351,
-0.6142197251,
-0.1699325293,
-0.9642598629,
0.1667749584,
-0.2047749162,
0.786744535,
-0.5388137698,
-0.2739332914,
-0.0019566813,
-0.2613588274,
0.1678977013,
-0.8979483843,
0.2951915264,
-0.5346198678,
0.0199563876,
-0.2303065211,
-0.6698493361,
-0.0707142726,
0.5856660008,
-0.3552451134,
0.8240278959,
0.0794420093,
-0.8494964242,
0.3960876167,
-0.643142283,
-0.286095947,
0.2896603942,
-0.7183567286,
-0.4734120965,
-0.38520509,
-0.0286257062,
0.5439659953,
-0.2117501199,
-0.0484978668,
-0.6431755424,
-0.6531977654,
0.3059628606,
-0.3289818764,
0.8798185587,
0.1853239387,
-0.5964946747,
-0.1788699925,
-0.8714436293,
-0.093454428,
-0.0822361484,
-0.449233681,
-0.4231468141,
-0.1110237092,
-0.0919802263,
0.5290864706,
-0.0801047981,
-0.5919733644,
0.0978651792,
-0.5505712628,
-0.0818424523,
0.4511250556,
0.2773878872,
0.4835653305,
-0.163783744,
0.4725604653,
0.4533989131,
-0.1450648606,
-0.1878727227,
0.0715572014,
-0.7732508779,
-0.41636464,
0.1404382437,
0.6654084325,
-1.2011220455,
0.060079027,
0.0655195788,
-0.2320525348,
-0.2211875319,
0.2913227081,
0.6033529639,
1.1738963127,
0.5558098555,
-0.060496904,
-0.4928977191,
-0.855630517,
-0.20647493,
-0.0473250933,
0.1601831317,
0.6763705611,
0.3631798625,
0.0505704209,
0.9840161204,
-0.4332197905,
-0.1926233619,
-0.3227910995,
0.1228721812,
0.2651581168,
0.4125409722,
0.3990806937,
-0.8563694358,
-0.7375213504,
-0.0587634891,
-0.7546485662,
-0.0560927838,
-0.2650647163,
0.0678875372,
-0.0523876436,
0.7808178663,
-0.2970235944,
0.4097265601,
0.079951033,
0.0629020408,
0.6425145864,
0.1901460886,
0.0260671936,
-0.8928713799,
-0.1000095382,
0.2583724856,
-0.1997474879,
-0.4876151979,
0.2156709433,
0.2728110552,
0.0709521547,
-1.1050684452,
0.8098838329,
-0.6000639796,
-0.0137306601,
-0.1948547363,
0.3160275221,
-0.1794429421,
0.4638952017,
-0.0378820486,
0.7601294518,
0.6540287733,
-0.8722106814,
-0.0653014407,
0.1483789533,
-0.198156938,
0.7314189672,
-0.0436278321,
0.169855237,
-0.2014564872,
0.1493374556,
-0.8961017728,
-0.164480418,
0.4760959446,
-0.1686363965,
0.5479409099,
-0.1654442847,
-0.3395831883,
0.1058078632,
-0.3958804011,
0.4727326632,
0.2077070177,
-1.0581016541,
0.3754290342,
0.1924234331,
-0.0525536276,
-0.7897297144,
-0.7789440751,
0.0327502228,
-0.5296049118,
-0.0029906337,
0.5757128,
-0.3815607131,
-0.5931657553,
-0.1473775357,
0.0295697954,
-0.3705197573,
0.294462204,
0.1725854725,
0.4210413396,
-0.2623780668,
0.2276193798,
0.0717651248,
0.0944176242,
-0.2104928493,
0.1366969794,
0.1977681518,
-0.1260026991,
-0.4867184758,
-0.599395752,
0.353651017,
0.0245552789,
0.1384765804,
0.3869615197,
0.3577668667,
-0.6115515232,
-0.3482609689,
-0.4283094406,
-0.2865526974,
-0.4118479788,
0.2194008529,
-0.4704121053,
-0.7243556976,
0.2704246342,
-0.3636497557,
0.0176699497,
0.2149028778,
0.1522501409,
-0.3459327817,
0.8124064803,
0.6127721667,
-0.0920038894,
0.604191184,
-0.361641705,
0.2363534719,
-0.8783337474,
-0.1418815404,
-0.5639256239,
-0.0810255781,
-0.3976359665,
-0.0052037467,
0.4183759987,
0.4435250759,
-0.297770083,
0.1050031856,
-0.0492828377,
0.6869784594,
0.2989059985,
0.4422361851,
0.2754099071,
-0.0108947409,
-0.3368276954,
-0.2049269378,
-0.4815276563,
-0.6196194887,
0.7711405158,
-0.0032457272,
0.7230625749,
0.1223344952,
1.0715304613,
0.0526584536,
0.8290830851,
-0.9033384919,
0.4746189415,
-0.2153353989,
-0.2523236871,
-0.1371994764,
-0.1475990266,
-0.6278502345,
0.2252066582,
-0.4685731232,
-0.8943119049,
0.3397526145,
0.402263999,
-0.3973684311,
0.2111492008,
-0.7413194776,
0.6136800647,
-0.1712830365,
-0.5724100471,
-0.0715044737,
-0.8196197748,
0.479631722,
0.1019988284,
0.2505936027,
0.2097955793,
-0.0725468025,
0.2338118851,
-0.0482779257,
0.994520843,
-0.1739641577,
0.1520028263,
0.3422313035,
0.2540715933,
0.6158258915,
0.0771928132,
-0.2792598307,
-0.0723501742,
-0.2564100027,
-0.2056114525,
-0.5815982819,
0.7117089033,
-0.3738563359,
-0.4312133193,
-0.1339724511,
-0.2032148093,
-0.1880333722,
0.1874539107,
0.3383413851,
0.646597743,
-0.25774014,
0.3493317664,
0.5326120853,
-0.2730442584,
0.7253731489,
0.4375565648,
0.1435899287,
-0.2463217378,
0.8053150177,
-0.1245992705,
0.2872699201,
0.6871013045,
0.1240549237,
-0.2478469461,
-0.7352156043,
-0.2514913082,
0.0397914499,
-1.1405694485,
-0.4271008968,
-0.577052772,
-0.163832441,
-0.1533002108,
-0.2828900218,
-0.0333392806,
-0.1941796094,
-0.7583855391,
-0.0389146358,
-0.391407758,
0.3348551691,
0.1734862179,
0.2979499996,
-0.6482139826,
0.3687931597,
0.156546846,
-0.1153442711,
-0.0319917537,
-0.3127812445,
-0.2172783464,
-0.1479551047,
-0.6013910174,
-0.968300581,
0.3596155047,
0.3695464432,
0.7742977142,
0.5071316361,
-0.0227664597,
0.8838844895,
-0.3031276166,
0.9274043441,
0.2345758229,
-0.8452832103,
0.4724795222,
0.0531807058,
0.1618653685,
0.8404031992,
0.4785301089,
-0.203526035,
-0.3401531279,
-0.808273375,
-0.7564778328,
0.5890402794,
-0.1132432595,
-0.1497849375,
-0.2609538436,
0.5388790965,
0.2686668932,
0.0587529875,
-1.0425397158,
-0.360630095,
0.0925888196,
-0.3980905116,
0.1473603845,
-0.130388096,
0.0201328918,
-0.0132198427,
0.8898929954,
-0.5476545095,
-0.1846639365,
0.3789007366,
-0.5855478048,
0.1371924281,
0.5344592333,
0.4391547441,
0.773735702,
-0.1097791195,
0.4692661464,
0.6484228969,
0.0714823678,
-0.0275716614,
0.0967572555,
-0.2965748012,
-0.1049077809,
0.3957234621,
0.3912455142,
0.3704405129,
-0.792229116,
0.785849154,
0.0055230586,
0.1503562629,
-0.4127499759,
-0.0341592319,
-0.1089717746,
0.4347684681,
0.4445143342,
-0.0836108252,
0.5205407739,
-0.617202878,
0.4273756444,
0.530600965,
-0.5521170497,
-0.0968125463,
0.2261013985,
0.0266147126,
-0.3672689795,
0.6302855015,
-0.4597768486,
-0.2531315386,
0.722884059,
0.8802943826,
0.7575425506,
0.128728956,
0.0328672603,
0.6175717115,
-0.1206170171,
0.249299109,
0.0566365048,
-0.3717935085,
-0.8325663805,
-0.1472216994,
-0.094110623,
-0.4881869853,
0.2492644191,
-0.6199109554,
0.7183123827,
-0.4099420905,
0.2964110076,
-0.0014214336,
0.0301143788,
-0.9019117951,
0.2321888655,
0.1987961084,
0.9898326397,
-0.6907263994,
0.9586106539,
0.4720795453,
-0.4370760322,
-0.7484997511,
0.3200880587,
0.2590230107,
-0.4418504238,
1.1425163746,
0.2971319854,
-0.3278075159,
-0.0120481746,
-0.9241064191,
-0.4863186777,
1.1806617975,
0.4998597503,
-0.8337064981,
0.1248435453,
-0.2846433222,
0.3708993793,
-0.8445706367,
0.4853933752,
0.3680372834,
0.1796620339,
0.0844059661,
-0.4622285366,
0.0273957271,
0.0672882795,
-0.3364925981,
-0.0962772146,
-0.5399093032,
0.6260029078,
-0.3202470243,
-0.4398059547,
0.0789717808,
0.6359961629,
0.6317603588,
0.536385715,
0.7039173841,
0.1648620218,
0.639279902,
0.234032467,
0.8622909188,
-0.0043453607,
0.2551756203,
1.645455718,
-0.5202223063,
0.9687148929,
0.8002460003,
0.1075434759,
0.5645293593,
0.6812886,
0.2086647004,
0.6349061131,
0.2511098981,
-0.5455036759,
-0.201910302,
-0.2481700182,
0.1096887216,
0.4165174961,
0.5579075217,
-0.2238965034,
-0.5430653095,
0.0177120604,
-0.176674962,
0.1795752347,
-0.1601513773,
0.982009232,
0.2539056242,
-0.5711660981,
0.3711985648,
-0.3101116419,
0.7423740625,
-0.336424619,
-0.8052208424,
-0.0992443785,
0.0564055368,
-0.2441337854,
-0.5758164525,
0.1411510557,
-0.0548157506,
0.049692709,
0.0203475337,
0.8202458024,
-0.6038706899,
-0.0755296573,
0.4314276278,
0.2758677602,
0.3786310554,
0.2376694083,
-0.848187685,
-0.2705464363,
-0.0120977471,
0.2210849673,
0.2860171199,
0.2120514959,
-0.0552591868,
0.5039480329,
0.3401330411,
0.0783045366,
-0.1294196099,
0.1565728933,
0.8882117867,
-0.7217529416,
-0.4042669833,
-0.9969747663,
0.6728628278,
-0.3277323246,
-0.2982897162,
0.4835325181,
0.8048760891,
1.1240853071,
0.0848982558,
0.8494254947,
0.0720092058,
0.6600208879,
-0.7837812304,
0.0867319554,
-0.4443178475,
0.5325676203,
-0.2992961407,
-0.8193333149,
-0.5213490725,
0.2522627413,
-0.065264672,
-0.2382920682,
0.953789711,
1.0287240744,
-0.3029942513,
-0.3196486235,
0.4342243671,
0.2513693273,
0.5535736084,
0.5483777523,
0.942555666,
-0.3956625164,
0.6398667097,
-0.5086913705,
-0.2311834544,
-0.1752384603,
-1.1924399137,
-0.7925900221,
-0.4483739138,
-0.4872177839,
-0.2822751701,
0.0337803736,
1.3417608738,
0.7592203021,
-0.8330917358,
-0.1618617028,
0.0249158442,
0.3596652448,
-0.112103045,
-0.2849281132,
0.3807064593,
-0.4772082269,
-0.6590742469,
0.6880110502,
0.3619899154,
0.1319031715,
0.0378769748,
-0.1052298844,
-0.3193973899,
-0.313852787,
0.5404136777,
0.4232864976,
-0.7296859026,
-0.4597627223,
-0.3587918878,
-0.1266960949,
0.4434704781,
0.8303777575,
-0.7917029262,
0.3378281593,
0.3925243914,
0.7248749733,
0.6809954643,
-0.0252025854,
0.1358710974,
-0.9392729402,
0.1652289778,
0.2297283262,
0.4304329455,
0.5778941512,
-0.6167470813,
0.2646923065,
0.0518989153,
-0.2510553002,
-0.563208878,
0.3064706624,
-1.0511411428,
-0.3568547964,
1.2304629087,
-0.3430261016,
-0.1182531863,
-0.1638353914,
-0.3718262613,
0.3379450142,
-0.2817353308,
0.758687377,
0.5065701604,
-0.39779526,
-0.290941149,
-0.3582975268,
0.405752182,
0.0205455739,
-1.0802258253,
-0.3427096605,
0.4931144118,
0.4765788615,
-0.0287413765,
0.5559238791,
-0.1826943308,
0.3008252084,
-0.3448721468,
-0.0240230113,
0.2530093789,
-0.299000144,
-0.5712508559,
0.2253838629,
0.3480292857,
-0.17146492
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11253v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11253v3
|
Aligning Large Language Models by On-Policy Self-Judgment
| 2024-02-17T11:25:26 | 2024-06-25T13:39:52 |
Sangkyu Lee, Sungdong Kim, Ashkan Yousefpour, Minjoon Seo, Kang Min Yoo, Youngjae Yu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Existing approaches for aligning large language models with human preferences
face a trade-off that requires a separate reward model (RM) for on-policy
learning. In this paper, we present a novel alignment framework, SELF-JUDGE
that (1) does on-policy learning and 2) is parameter efficient, as it does not
require an additional RM for evaluating the samples for on-policy learning. To
this end, we propose Judge-augmented Supervised Fine-Tuning (JSFT) to train a
single model to act as both a policy and a judge. Specifically, we view the
pairwise judgment task, choosing the better response from a response pair, as a
special case of the instruction-following task. The resulting model can judge
preferences of on-the-fly responses from current policy initialized from
itself. Experimental results show the efficacy of SELF-JUDGE, outperforming
baselines in preference benchmarks. We also show that the rejecting sampling by
itself can improve performance further without an additional evaluator.
|
[
-0.4014125466,
-0.3869408667,
0.5819888711,
0.1094195545,
0.129340753,
-0.1741161644,
-0.6071624756,
-0.0114513515,
0.27068609,
0.650732398,
-0.5030765533,
-0.0363075063,
-0.5007390976,
-0.2878079116,
-0.0095034735,
1.2028958797,
0.129063651,
0.0405851826,
-0.2387308627,
-0.2196376622,
-0.4761582911,
-0.2319390476,
-0.6564975381,
-0.441203922,
0.545958221,
0.6115966439,
0.8905507326,
0.8734763265,
0.2913076282,
0.3763295412,
0.1427893937,
0.1738001108,
-0.2644074559,
-0.0181553829,
-0.7537910938,
-0.2019556463,
-0.453366518,
0.113651365,
0.4387473762,
0.5608074665,
-0.325335443,
-0.047454685,
0.1231445968,
0.65647614,
-0.698838532,
0.0181765445,
-0.5166925788,
-0.1107594967,
0.0905343667,
-0.0919447616,
-0.4421815872,
-0.2831231654,
0.2845924497,
-0.6991044879,
-0.0662473366,
0.1295235008,
0.8425805569,
0.5112515688,
-0.5345801711,
0.0252760015,
-0.3272247314,
0.9424369335,
-0.6346706152,
0.4561674595,
0.5573222637,
0.3581357598,
-0.0561860837,
-0.297642529,
-0.5092008114,
-0.2483261824,
-0.3576061726,
0.1474690437,
0.1483804733,
0.2384612411,
-0.0471738093,
0.1992833018,
-0.5534952283,
0.5416147113,
0.0360480584,
-0.1295263916,
0.6942387223,
-0.0797637105,
-0.0002432087,
-0.1837748587,
-0.4822593629,
-0.3351529241,
-0.4224495292,
0.1536926925,
0.5987864733,
0.7334891558,
-0.0501051955,
0.4033440053,
-0.6573600769,
0.860288322,
0.5793467164,
0.1273345649,
0.2171759903,
0.0479600467,
-0.2213587016,
0.2462611496,
0.8438538313,
0.4211822152,
0.1894260198,
-0.1760866344,
-0.3761641979,
0.0952354744,
0.5347394347,
-0.6740046144,
-0.293674618,
0.0369990431,
-0.3848010898,
-0.4617076218,
-0.1088372245,
-0.7233524323,
-0.4026382267,
-0.6748645902,
0.622271955,
0.0671992749,
-0.1728002578,
0.2473633289,
0.0912390947,
0.1490605921,
0.3562832475,
-1.4907374382,
0.2810210586,
0.8094877005,
0.4349535108,
-0.2374794483,
-0.4632385373,
-0.8287600279,
0.0472600274,
-0.3055688739,
0.7418201566,
-0.6341192722,
-0.115823634,
-0.1354465336,
-0.0084732436,
0.0831299126,
-0.2782151699,
0.3748084605,
-0.453035593,
0.3111955523,
-0.425673902,
-0.5447226167,
0.0688583925,
0.4128316939,
-0.5748116374,
0.9336582422,
0.1686252654,
-0.4983968139,
0.6871964931,
-0.5536382198,
-0.4234803021,
-0.1645977646,
-0.4305408895,
-0.3282220364,
0.0104325982,
0.5310822725,
0.4854967594,
-0.1396857202,
0.5363939404,
-0.5658733845,
-0.2419743836,
-0.1051536873,
-0.4479323328,
0.566975534,
0.2947597504,
-0.4347204566,
0.2473498583,
-0.6923977137,
0.1776758432,
-0.008372956,
-0.4735887349,
-0.4093408585,
0.092747815,
-0.1475770324,
0.2194705755,
0.4516994953,
-0.5698877573,
0.5638142824,
-0.6299691796,
0.2206461877,
1.1481056213,
-0.402238667,
0.7272569537,
-0.212391749,
0.2992493808,
-0.4221126735,
0.1678302735,
0.0328334682,
0.0822546333,
-0.7765423656,
-0.0883254409,
0.6087943316,
0.2934155166,
-0.385976851,
0.6404933333,
-0.3032380641,
-0.2726431787,
-0.8478788137,
0.1815734655,
0.7244067788,
0.3937840462,
0.4893158376,
-0.3772585392,
-0.2414696515,
-0.9318572879,
-0.5348132849,
-0.1499728709,
0.2237170488,
0.1991976947,
0.0967375934,
0.0899856612,
1.1173163652,
-0.4910548031,
-0.1502579153,
0.0159156565,
-0.0050696903,
0.0316729993,
0.8044568896,
0.5208576918,
-0.6535450816,
-0.5179247856,
0.3089883327,
-0.4221605957,
-0.1051154658,
-0.1135416627,
-0.1669706702,
0.2092364877,
0.3718520105,
-0.1617393196,
0.1517575383,
0.5846149325,
-0.4961543679,
0.3241913915,
-0.3694776297,
0.3714160323,
-0.8046108484,
-0.1326837987,
0.0949298888,
-0.5352255106,
-0.3817954361,
0.2275933027,
0.2028685212,
0.4086846411,
-0.1738494784,
0.7426084876,
-0.1854408979,
-0.0864310786,
-0.5935541987,
0.0137688275,
0.1383619756,
0.7946195006,
0.1066179425,
0.7677531242,
0.2478520572,
-0.5065184832,
0.2200160623,
0.3702248335,
-0.4049251974,
0.781815052,
-0.4285528362,
0.1229679212,
-0.0801552236,
0.1133349016,
-0.8710274696,
-0.3038977981,
0.0473556519,
-0.183345139,
0.4594549537,
-0.3897514641,
-0.333330065,
-0.2849143147,
-0.1092450917,
0.1775375158,
0.1824114025,
-1.1248669624,
0.5378415585,
0.345772475,
0.0269400459,
-0.7557998896,
-0.6525512338,
-0.3715071976,
-0.1470568627,
-0.1518178731,
0.4675841928,
0.0497731045,
-0.0468956865,
-0.0104720145,
-0.2624723017,
0.1625764072,
0.2533477843,
0.0700933188,
0.2377496511,
0.0288427733,
0.3148137629,
0.313924402,
-0.1731635332,
-0.1597034782,
-0.3158052564,
0.5113291144,
-0.3147609532,
-0.4911683798,
-0.4244307876,
0.1261804104,
0.2516618967,
-0.4397741258,
0.4689723551,
0.1928881258,
0.058523152,
-0.0912082121,
-0.6299916506,
-0.2133425325,
-0.5530497432,
0.1757521331,
-0.5203408599,
-0.9402906299,
-0.0185439922,
-0.034199845,
0.1605399847,
0.4335980713,
0.5658736825,
-0.0322148278,
1.2845972776,
0.4726291895,
-0.4357735217,
0.7239058018,
0.0582628846,
0.2488790751,
-0.5388270617,
0.0599499084,
-0.5063784719,
-0.3213002384,
-0.7726614475,
0.1210132763,
0.1875488609,
-0.0428130664,
-0.7853402495,
0.3951568902,
-0.6303778291,
0.6639993787,
0.8337842822,
0.1506880969,
0.1338365525,
-0.2409386784,
-0.2322300375,
0.1636421233,
-0.5331220031,
-0.3480894268,
1.1062556505,
0.1685895473,
0.8675944209,
0.0524584465,
0.8025086522,
0.2480360568,
0.0433234721,
-0.544244051,
0.3629031181,
-0.3413945735,
-0.5386396646,
-0.4795844853,
-0.4116794467,
-0.8288216591,
0.5120998621,
-0.37070629,
-0.8268693089,
0.1070135608,
0.6311400533,
-0.684786737,
0.1844479591,
-0.8468233347,
1.2748435736,
-0.662968874,
-0.5404521227,
-0.3833714426,
-0.7595717907,
0.1511451006,
0.1660959423,
0.1832429767,
-0.1846793145,
0.3611829281,
0.5239596367,
-0.3503240943,
0.6818038225,
-0.4119000137,
0.0210477728,
-0.0803028792,
0.0671594888,
0.5312455297,
-0.1468211412,
-0.1339095235,
-0.2713868022,
0.1712474227,
-0.3916459382,
-0.7661649585,
1.0368205309,
-0.7873580456,
-0.7792231441,
-0.3805383444,
-0.4999040961,
-0.5360724926,
0.2207209319,
-0.2174548209,
0.2991136611,
-0.1537873447,
-0.0525816828,
0.365150243,
-0.0802539289,
0.2355959415,
0.641035676,
-0.6523558497,
-0.3548838198,
1.1240622997,
-0.0931800008,
0.5441531539,
0.4569884837,
0.6357675195,
-0.42444098,
0.0128574567,
-0.7073046565,
-0.0296724197,
-0.4502808154,
-0.2028916627,
-0.4445047677,
0.1754827648,
-0.5883939266,
-0.3400946558,
-0.665086925,
-0.4923433065,
-0.0911515877,
-0.0680063441,
0.3389171064,
0.4699481726,
-0.1077542529,
0.6590583324,
-0.4004042149,
0.0924508795,
0.6185308099,
0.621198535,
-0.0749202743,
-0.6076991558,
-0.149741739,
0.0213429518,
-0.376806438,
-0.3186861575,
0.1456870884,
-0.0272741932,
0.4865077436,
0.6908308268,
0.1102451012,
0.9415284395,
-0.4658128917,
0.5126131773,
0.2121839672,
-0.9029949903,
0.6236391068,
-0.2409616858,
0.2464160472,
0.9916175604,
0.1827475727,
-0.4848176539,
-0.2286022007,
-0.4799541235,
-0.5566883087,
0.9169038534,
-0.3271248937,
0.1321799606,
0.0027770202,
0.2435910255,
0.1435452402,
0.2681243718,
-0.5795432925,
-0.0938786864,
-0.2310763896,
-0.3907421231,
-0.1135407016,
0.2284799814,
-0.0863248557,
-0.4358854592,
0.8431528807,
-0.5701030493,
-0.0546570681,
-0.1439822465,
0.0198935177,
-0.0842247009,
0.4445229471,
0.0737308636,
0.2027515024,
-0.1573082507,
0.1273740381,
0.0535268262,
0.3748258352,
0.2018336803,
0.2008407861,
-0.1423298717,
-0.7331594825,
-0.0843020603,
1.0623675585,
0.5622367263,
-0.5734467506,
0.8240689635,
0.0923746899,
-0.1439572722,
0.1505761445,
0.3212243319,
-0.1628362387,
0.4198841751,
-0.2403173447,
0.1356825531,
0.1909131557,
-0.4796455503,
0.1631622463,
0.7248438597,
-0.5425834656,
-0.0258029215,
0.7551367283,
0.0383845717,
-0.0523011833,
0.2972795069,
-0.4048457742,
-0.6030320525,
0.300234586,
0.6245532632,
0.5613085032,
-0.2756408751,
0.2571901381,
0.2691978812,
-0.0146124549,
-0.4406490624,
0.1353689581,
-0.3231576681,
-0.9783858657,
-0.4134670496,
-0.7846961021,
-0.4217588603,
-0.170800373,
-0.8196325898,
0.1422472298,
-0.5000681281,
-0.0426182337,
0.1598761678,
0.0068234708,
-0.6922446489,
0.2862357199,
-0.0135645596,
0.5495321751,
-0.9056139588,
0.9558591843,
0.5829411149,
-0.3164871633,
-0.9990743995,
0.0048104986,
0.1254020333,
-0.9026652575,
0.3336966038,
0.2350993454,
-0.1168442294,
0.0787579864,
-0.4143561125,
-0.9769234061,
0.6365389824,
0.3789629936,
-0.760052979,
-0.0519358627,
-0.3489126861,
0.4417111874,
-0.1579478085,
0.31741485,
0.8928274512,
0.6019044518,
-0.0966330543,
-1.0281836987,
-0.0868792236,
0.1237053797,
-0.0359991193,
0.5692081451,
-0.94941926,
0.4973143041,
-0.0397857241,
0.1323381662,
-0.0376728699,
0.7501914501,
-0.0854098797,
0.028834261,
0.8745503426,
0.8179884553,
0.5614233613,
0.0615785494,
0.9668530226,
-0.2284512818,
0.5056983829,
1.5757570267,
-0.3559425473,
0.8719733953,
0.5442113876,
-0.2664467394,
0.5302983522,
0.417067498,
0.0115994867,
0.8289717436,
-0.0289168581,
-0.001350675,
-0.6393431425,
-0.0919575989,
0.0137643674,
0.7833066583,
-0.0077384487,
-0.1832727939,
-0.2368522584,
0.1034219116,
-0.081663996,
0.5532178283,
-0.5454702973,
0.8504320979,
-0.3430417478,
-1.3824852705,
0.2391566634,
0.190296039,
0.6488816142,
-0.4529148638,
0.1468403488,
0.0532207228,
0.3555773497,
-0.1823214293,
-0.8421296477,
0.090941973,
-0.1677807868,
-0.1586971879,
-0.4598261118,
0.4496235549,
-0.6940841079,
-0.2394436896,
0.3545686901,
0.2162754685,
-0.1225699931,
0.0599806271,
-0.7019953132,
-0.1871921122,
0.0169704836,
-0.3529918194,
0.5356351733,
0.0583010279,
-0.2421498448,
0.3463522494,
0.4493696392,
-0.099126786,
-0.127000466,
0.2089148462,
0.7460439801,
-0.5568248034,
-0.8016217947,
-0.7683866024,
0.2257072479,
-0.1119909361,
-0.3625382781,
0.443046242,
0.5118998885,
1.2140436172,
0.230025664,
0.7451317906,
-0.0859776363,
0.6784942746,
-0.5798373222,
0.5981174707,
-0.7850534916,
0.0162994284,
-0.1310033053,
-0.5200728178,
-0.0870643333,
0.7977257371,
-0.5739408135,
0.0485222563,
0.2801373005,
0.8566295505,
-0.2341877818,
0.0745560378,
0.2619128525,
-0.095000796,
0.2546498179,
0.3686065674,
0.4849478006,
-0.0906771272,
0.1332620531,
-0.3418424129,
-0.220801726,
-0.2634993494,
-0.6338743567,
-0.8341904879,
-0.4567623138,
-0.0442880616,
-0.2639496028,
0.0629599616,
1.6730214357,
0.7551336884,
-0.8848974705,
-0.1237373874,
-0.0734795108,
-0.0061045638,
-0.5074928999,
-0.164893508,
0.4577397704,
-0.722682476,
-0.8698730469,
0.6201415658,
0.2257971466,
-0.1985425204,
-0.2476904839,
-0.3820166886,
-0.2864112556,
-0.0018108202,
0.336202383,
0.3908975422,
-0.9155186415,
-0.6546318531,
-0.457770139,
-0.2638972998,
0.1936473399,
0.6970019937,
-0.9018224478,
0.7961537242,
0.1541922092,
1.000341773,
0.6688678861,
0.1916231662,
0.5963133574,
-0.6331928372,
0.0119759832,
-0.0668719411,
0.3870439827,
0.1346552968,
-0.3376298249,
0.3683411777,
-0.1609000564,
-0.8610078096,
-0.6799071431,
0.3389452994,
-0.9450492859,
-0.2057969719,
0.9405295253,
-0.0594396368,
-0.1427469403,
0.2750133574,
-0.2580282688,
0.1699443609,
-0.5162282586,
0.7600298524,
0.5106127262,
0.0204820279,
0.0419126675,
-0.2526587248,
0.4349952042,
0.8806918263,
-0.66521734,
0.0895150006,
0.4346874356,
0.2823235989,
-0.0685031042,
0.6909153461,
0.2207235694,
0.3141820133,
-0.3663676977,
0.1992777437,
0.0472347923,
-0.5256483555,
-0.6354176402,
-0.106059134,
0.3181245029,
-0.3327296674
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11251v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11251v1
|
LLM can Achieve Self-Regulation via Hyperparameter Aware Generation
| 2024-02-17T11:18:22 | 2024-02-17T11:18:22 |
Siyin Wang, Shimin Li, Tianxiang Sun, Jinlan Fu, Qinyuan Cheng, Jiasheng Ye, Junjie Ye, Xipeng Qiu, Xuanjing Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the realm of Large Language Models (LLMs), users commonly employ diverse
decoding strategies and adjust hyperparameters to control the generated text.
However, a critical question emerges: Are LLMs conscious of the existence of
these decoding strategies and capable of regulating themselves? The current
decoding generation process often relies on empirical and heuristic manual
adjustments to hyperparameters based on types of tasks and demands. However,
this process is typically cumbersome, and the decoding hyperparameters may not
always be optimal for each sample. To address the aforementioned challenges, we
propose a novel text generation paradigm termed Hyperparameter Aware Generation
(HAG). By leveraging hyperparameter-aware instruction tuning, the LLM
autonomously determines the optimal decoding strategy and configs based on the
input samples, enabling self-regulation. Our approach eliminates the need for
extensive manual tuning, offering a more autonomous, self-regulate model
behavior. Experimental results spanning six datasets across reasoning,
creativity, translation, and mathematics tasks demonstrate that
hyperparameter-aware instruction tuning empowers the LLMs to self-regulate the
decoding strategy and hyperparameter. HAG extends the current paradigm in the
text generation process, highlighting the feasibility of endowing the LLMs with
self-regulate decoding strategies.
|
[
-0.236075744,
-0.7147518992,
0.4647564888,
0.4138894081,
-0.2037092149,
-0.2024380267,
-0.2829638422,
-0.228438735,
-0.1033655107,
1.0218547583,
-0.4720699489,
-0.2949432433,
-0.4055289924,
0.4595880806,
-0.2398632914,
1.044783473,
0.0069086971,
-0.4003191888,
-0.1465150863,
0.2044531256,
-0.5274792314,
-0.5818157196,
-0.5658528805,
-0.3067173064,
0.45510903,
0.2233630866,
0.7564539909,
1.6178445816,
0.3634492755,
0.3790695071,
0.1658658236,
0.4369969368,
-0.5066382885,
0.3412873447,
-0.2491715848,
-0.4596825838,
-0.4950753152,
-0.0612183027,
0.5572717786,
0.0310917832,
-0.3111960292,
0.3116806448,
0.4825057089,
0.6720642447,
-0.8540068269,
0.0503933206,
-0.8745235801,
0.0651405305,
-0.1303748637,
-0.8090810776,
-0.6270465851,
-0.0941850096,
-0.4050104618,
-0.535789907,
0.2529300749,
0.1960947663,
0.720664382,
0.6180374026,
-0.3196836114,
-0.3341064453,
-0.7569806576,
0.5690909624,
-0.781511724,
0.1928847432,
0.7150316834,
0.0360674337,
-0.2427368909,
-0.4584214687,
-0.3003739715,
0.312507242,
-0.1366381049,
0.1304252297,
-0.2096254379,
0.1622324288,
0.1893257201,
0.2902426124,
-0.1101614758,
0.0847957581,
-0.0314491317,
-0.4281004667,
0.3355164528,
0.3782889843,
0.086151056,
-0.6872577071,
-0.2779028416,
0.1860851943,
-0.6835685372,
-0.1986906826,
0.3549680412,
0.225792706,
0.0789249912,
0.4451349676,
-0.1518987864,
0.8574974537,
0.3576339483,
-0.0815637484,
-0.2626132965,
-0.3314786255,
-0.4293976724,
0.2216716558,
0.9242116809,
0.1862250119,
0.2544765174,
0.1281548738,
-0.4152037501,
-0.2613062859,
0.6650925279,
-0.6627131701,
-0.1849940717,
-0.1314934194,
-0.329035908,
-0.3309457898,
-0.3637387455,
-0.7171609402,
-0.148892045,
-0.3221486509,
0.62240237,
-0.1425819844,
0.1667368114,
0.3092841506,
0.2171034664,
0.1387467831,
0.0041715833,
-1.4898538589,
0.1884727329,
0.453171432,
0.7218866944,
-0.1189796329,
-0.580516696,
-0.39684847,
0.759192884,
-0.5168630481,
0.5161565542,
-0.2205296159,
-0.5326371193,
0.1505796909,
-0.3021224737,
-0.0189669728,
-0.4549785852,
0.3482193351,
-0.6697669029,
0.0367622524,
-0.3113202751,
-0.6917964816,
0.2632505,
0.1797149181,
-0.4664893448,
0.938283205,
-0.008271398,
-0.7323726416,
0.2135313898,
-0.2079014629,
-0.4691728652,
0.2210528255,
-0.4590145051,
-0.4745414853,
0.2217343152,
0.3114879727,
0.5891873837,
-0.4250152707,
0.0036644563,
-0.0218210388,
-0.1447152048,
0.07198219,
-0.6987757683,
0.4088470042,
0.2842568755,
-0.4308494925,
0.0727595389,
-0.8126401901,
0.4402396679,
-0.0688710362,
-0.9568283558,
-0.126134783,
0.1387149543,
-0.38070786,
0.1711032391,
0.4565419555,
-0.2706123888,
0.086461328,
-0.2654651701,
0.5561784506,
0.9864203334,
0.3581735194,
0.1849749088,
-0.4132676125,
0.491304189,
-0.2809208632,
0.1844958961,
-0.4371229708,
0.0232201219,
-1.0138351917,
-0.2970129848,
0.0735774115,
0.5178271532,
-0.4418101609,
0.8743271232,
0.1973487437,
-0.2935054302,
-0.6721027493,
0.6451773643,
0.5587564111,
0.6509581804,
0.3791406751,
0.2149314284,
-0.3959428072,
-0.6639037132,
-0.2577473819,
-0.0333847366,
0.2380802631,
0.3875194788,
0.1568971574,
-0.0327076763,
0.7009731531,
-0.4746799469,
-0.4207387865,
-0.2858846486,
0.1422666907,
0.1185440049,
0.6747735739,
0.0699402541,
-0.3610503078,
-0.4820168018,
-0.0052639022,
-0.8198934197,
-0.2024841607,
-0.4334752262,
-0.498090446,
0.1475922316,
1.0252437592,
-0.3855146468,
0.1759352684,
0.4272125661,
-0.317726016,
0.7429314852,
-0.9579454064,
0.0420198292,
-1.1444664001,
-0.3367046714,
-0.1316818595,
-0.2942081392,
-0.2100426108,
0.2009393275,
0.4405476749,
0.10909421,
-0.3387456238,
0.1838540584,
-0.6637852788,
0.1349960268,
-0.7913067937,
-0.4245450795,
0.0142563451,
0.4394551218,
-0.1799970418,
0.9719893336,
0.8379141688,
-0.9496920109,
0.2613621354,
0.3491158485,
-0.4233474135,
0.162221998,
-0.9017506242,
0.0226268787,
-0.0463625304,
0.2771385908,
-0.59160465,
-0.4692842066,
0.0822248831,
-0.0391463786,
0.1481823623,
-0.099318184,
-0.6333471537,
-0.2657002807,
0.3040681481,
0.2957844734,
0.7606772184,
-0.6438891888,
0.4735655785,
0.0759553239,
-0.0201146752,
-0.3420535326,
-0.7088626623,
0.1560831815,
-0.2027001828,
-0.0476496182,
0.136472702,
-0.1808672249,
0.240638122,
-0.3075798154,
-0.0093738334,
0.2535640895,
-0.1407966763,
0.2039040476,
0.2079045922,
-0.1079530269,
0.0611713752,
0.3707977533,
-0.1467827111,
0.182668075,
-0.5383273363,
0.4740643501,
0.2046197653,
-0.2156404108,
-0.5670205951,
0.3319745958,
0.553517282,
-0.7090898752,
0.2952209711,
0.4554410279,
-0.0828340501,
-0.6627371907,
-0.3792084157,
-0.1014070064,
-0.6764788628,
0.1657016575,
-0.4838305116,
-0.9710181355,
0.247457996,
-0.1231497526,
0.0295623038,
0.1695288271,
1.1177943945,
-0.0866606757,
1.1362985373,
0.8021336794,
0.1790051162,
0.392116785,
0.0047032745,
-0.1377630979,
-0.7786755562,
0.150221765,
-0.4809291363,
-0.1585201919,
-0.8642662764,
-0.230403915,
0.5297784209,
-0.0574998632,
-0.2000516951,
0.2004573643,
-0.6059751511,
1.0025279522,
0.6310756207,
0.1325897574,
0.1823875755,
-0.2085597664,
-0.1246650666,
-0.0378829762,
-0.9110555053,
-0.5288783908,
0.9852035642,
0.2287730426,
1.1685454845,
-0.1624867469,
1.0879315138,
0.4692310989,
-0.2632810473,
-0.5977518559,
0.6078388095,
-0.1554054916,
-0.5851991773,
-0.4288554788,
-0.447674185,
-0.9844428897,
0.103670381,
-0.2118962854,
-0.5061277151,
0.0626352131,
0.6438319683,
-0.627671659,
0.1113070175,
-0.5214527845,
0.5989237428,
-0.262075901,
-0.6739788651,
-0.2758735418,
-0.3526159525,
0.0674617067,
-0.1865363717,
0.1246044338,
-0.1419304907,
-0.1682359278,
0.5400555134,
-0.1175535917,
1.0078332424,
0.1280067116,
-0.4828265309,
0.4219246507,
0.5338342786,
0.7004215717,
0.1575630307,
-0.0974309519,
-0.3056021035,
-0.0750492066,
-0.6174652576,
-0.6566485763,
0.9785043597,
-0.8662446737,
-1.1494991779,
-0.0796467587,
-0.724993825,
-0.2820937037,
0.5953056812,
0.6866144538,
0.4363001883,
0.0159126334,
0.0092836851,
0.7669340372,
0.0844786316,
0.6568701863,
0.5338714719,
-0.1552254409,
-0.5325549841,
1.0908778906,
-0.0436341353,
0.3858858347,
0.4196184576,
0.5579015017,
-0.2714158297,
-0.552113235,
-0.6728807688,
0.1775294989,
-0.5930042863,
-0.3463118672,
-0.5139248967,
-0.1617825478,
-0.4109919071,
-0.379295975,
-0.37329638,
0.0967916027,
-0.5551502705,
0.0167254135,
0.0747723877,
0.9739941955,
-0.1207084283,
0.5572681427,
-0.8518858552,
0.3713457584,
0.6001610756,
0.4669381082,
-0.1199293584,
-0.5298379064,
-0.6172724962,
-0.175015375,
-0.3508500159,
-0.7921555638,
0.4252391756,
0.3261508942,
0.3196126223,
0.3364113271,
0.1046213433,
0.432156682,
-0.8315860033,
0.5085116625,
0.0128406929,
-1.2312110662,
0.5419241786,
-0.5569701791,
0.6156741381,
0.3563065231,
0.2429955453,
-0.3338615596,
-0.6301660538,
-0.1171936542,
-0.4924294055,
0.6759083271,
-0.0045683272,
0.6619375348,
-0.2931050956,
0.6212634444,
0.1453439742,
0.0221694149,
-0.634025991,
0.0883417875,
-0.4547277093,
-0.1920625418,
-0.1211456284,
-0.207806021,
-0.2449193597,
-0.1329176575,
0.4983096421,
-0.3246692717,
0.0976826847,
0.3682752252,
0.2089540958,
-0.401878655,
0.3630772531,
0.1686732471,
0.5086102486,
0.1187779456,
0.4691029787,
-0.0890630484,
-0.0793132707,
0.4099330902,
-0.3870230317,
-0.3242512345,
-0.418893218,
0.2480795085,
0.9353559613,
0.1680794656,
-0.2937244475,
0.1295792758,
-0.0467882641,
-0.4291354716,
0.153167516,
0.7719963193,
-0.0313129351,
0.1623489559,
0.0866539702,
-0.1609967351,
-0.1569566131,
-0.0803067759,
0.2330009639,
0.2287898064,
-0.2861140668,
-0.10125532,
0.8076273799,
0.31069839,
-0.3681288958,
0.3640110493,
-0.050924778,
-0.0822014064,
0.401435107,
1.2515920401,
0.8147858977,
-0.108340323,
0.2548690736,
0.2801541984,
0.3145030737,
-0.111219503,
0.1983958185,
-0.2961158752,
-0.7906784415,
-0.4879409671,
-0.8554130197,
-0.1720634997,
0.1041612998,
-0.7644118071,
0.0602192134,
-0.6774851084,
-0.1688936949,
0.0304105431,
-0.4138379693,
-0.3150738776,
0.3526965082,
-0.1132379919,
0.8129446507,
-0.4261284173,
0.8921279311,
0.6368060112,
0.0005117785,
-0.6134657264,
0.3008234501,
-0.2631521523,
-0.9723134041,
0.2633439302,
-0.0694473982,
-0.3673734665,
0.6644761562,
-0.4330945909,
-0.8089408875,
0.8544733524,
0.4213359058,
-0.6064011455,
-0.2715577483,
0.1936111152,
0.6769433618,
-0.2861457467,
-0.3899356723,
0.5119994283,
0.3705402911,
-0.1719716936,
-0.6155777574,
0.1624168009,
0.0357577503,
0.106379047,
0.4493435025,
-0.9975872636,
0.5790969729,
-0.2904396355,
-0.2064443976,
-0.0623872206,
0.9898095131,
-0.1249931976,
-0.2689084113,
0.2181165367,
0.3620109558,
0.3518157899,
0.5282021761,
0.8565428853,
-0.8499338031,
0.22164841,
1.2010240555,
-0.0256259982,
0.754960537,
0.3481823504,
0.088351056,
0.1653610319,
0.3346522152,
-0.1319622844,
0.3288249373,
0.1775612533,
-0.3253751397,
-0.8065739274,
-0.0218457431,
-0.0816646889,
0.8804969192,
0.2381116897,
-0.5356231332,
-0.2896193862,
-0.0645817518,
0.0794388354,
0.4084434509,
-0.3976049125,
0.9047804475,
-0.2628282607,
-0.9218848348,
1.0553077459,
0.2149382532,
0.4852740467,
-0.8276764154,
0.2265096605,
-0.025337005,
0.1210875362,
-0.0611501858,
-0.6374461055,
0.1867651641,
0.1181406379,
-0.3554779291,
-0.577876091,
0.676371336,
-0.5047345161,
-0.3768203855,
-0.0031642111,
0.8216695189,
-0.2634752095,
0.21143426,
-0.6432644129,
0.0816199854,
0.09467832,
-0.309204489,
0.4615602791,
0.5686447024,
0.2625025213,
0.6526832581,
0.5137958527,
0.3452362716,
0.2876098156,
-0.2327525318,
0.536781311,
-0.8728893399,
-0.7696983814,
-0.9950643778,
-0.2089259028,
0.5715495944,
-0.6082819104,
0.9574916959,
0.3653196096,
0.8176936507,
-0.0800377876,
1.0593287945,
0.1570969969,
0.2561324239,
-0.6636055708,
0.8474800587,
-0.4707409143,
0.0417336263,
0.1308939308,
-0.5242296457,
-0.0038031244,
0.1057754159,
0.0100915711,
-0.0596789494,
0.3411357403,
0.8024154902,
0.0235534534,
-0.111366123,
0.6587028503,
0.1824999601,
0.2574088573,
0.2394781262,
0.5132384896,
0.0790322274,
0.600502193,
-0.137690708,
-0.3262058794,
0.0738086998,
-0.8383541703,
-0.8969630003,
-0.420496285,
-0.038644217,
-0.168867439,
0.1522542983,
0.943558991,
0.7252272367,
-0.4582445621,
-0.6150391698,
-0.5253254175,
-0.0515412241,
-0.2405992448,
-0.1630478203,
0.2169403881,
-0.9192635417,
-0.7203339934,
0.4596737027,
0.519218564,
0.252694279,
-0.5657038093,
-0.1817946881,
-0.0053367019,
0.7048248053,
0.5550636649,
0.3574388325,
-0.4233218431,
-0.0784051493,
-0.0034405107,
-0.5681929588,
0.1558679342,
1.1513725519,
-0.5357072353,
0.6788312793,
0.3285986781,
0.8727334738,
0.159401387,
0.0185889322,
0.6664284468,
-0.7116357088,
-0.4736162126,
0.0081429733,
0.108648859,
-0.0065564224,
-0.7022322416,
-0.1423495412,
0.0233370606,
-0.9859347343,
-0.4525533617,
0.5150025487,
-0.4623868763,
-0.2484670877,
1.2278013229,
-0.1254546046,
-0.5196201801,
0.2166816294,
-0.3921380937,
0.4452396929,
-0.2800208926,
1.1142258644,
0.7421171665,
-0.562603116,
-0.2264557481,
-0.2398424596,
0.797719121,
0.7285404205,
-1.013310194,
0.7314396501,
0.5776548982,
-0.0528675616,
-0.2720128,
0.5795437098,
0.0302898064,
0.2747519612,
-0.1334715188,
-0.0472453572,
-0.2689834237,
-0.5146780014,
-0.1752648056,
0.2192804366,
0.0986562073,
-0.0962907225
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11243v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11243v1
|
Can Large Language Models perform Relation-based Argument Mining?
| 2024-02-17T10:37:51 | 2024-02-17T10:37:51 |
Deniz Gorur, Antonio Rago, Francesca Toni
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
Argument mining (AM) is the process of automatically extracting arguments,
their components and/or relations amongst arguments and components from text.
As the number of platforms supporting online debate increases, the need for AM
becomes ever more urgent, especially in support of downstream tasks.
Relation-based AM (RbAM) is a form of AM focusing on identifying agreement
(support) and disagreement (attack) relations amongst arguments. RbAM is a
challenging classification task, with existing methods failing to perform
satisfactorily. In this paper, we show that general-purpose Large Language
Models (LLMs), appropriately primed and prompted, can significantly outperform
the best performing (RoBERTa-based) baseline. Specifically, we experiment with
two open-source LLMs (Llama-2 and Mistral) with ten datasets.
|
[
-0.2604762614,
-0.8767427206,
0.740572691,
0.0848919675,
-0.3793633282,
-0.331961453,
-0.3176369965,
-0.5436829329,
-0.06935893,
0.7179309726,
-0.541208446,
-0.4069050848,
-0.7102944255,
0.1227226257,
-0.3240227103,
1.0454218388,
-0.0219079126,
0.1034469381,
-0.3458755314,
-0.502923727,
-0.5329524875,
-0.8167824149,
-0.7758529186,
-0.6409775019,
0.5559527278,
0.4872125983,
0.8399261832,
0.6134670377,
0.4539262056,
0.3378507495,
-0.0979728773,
0.2488385588,
-0.2315305471,
0.5579356551,
-0.5410461426,
-0.5927730203,
-0.4788080752,
-0.0761091411,
0.4175893366,
0.3547753096,
-0.27446419,
-0.02789432,
-0.2511665225,
0.479360342,
-0.5277593136,
0.0586257651,
-1.0997531414,
-0.2377194613,
-0.2669754326,
-0.2725563049,
-0.7048454285,
-0.1000443995,
0.015102027,
-0.1174159199,
-0.1164925098,
0.2426629215,
1.1929931641,
-0.0324468203,
-0.2584877908,
-0.7203394175,
-0.6496728659,
0.8288531303,
-1.0382428169,
0.0314427242,
0.3958778083,
0.2134385556,
-0.2737793922,
-0.5267910361,
-0.4670282006,
-0.241944924,
-0.1830365062,
-0.2996256351,
-0.4470406175,
0.0026248239,
0.4507484734,
0.4923073053,
-0.3714841604,
0.3852894902,
-0.1573759466,
0.141083464,
0.3738228083,
0.2282436192,
0.2418665737,
-0.5710461736,
-0.4338308871,
0.0393941589,
-0.8885164261,
-0.2571187317,
0.208842054,
0.3118367195,
-0.1925757229,
0.6904507279,
0.0906129181,
0.8340139389,
-0.1105154604,
0.0576863736,
-0.303360045,
0.1156459302,
-0.3789785802,
-0.1499872953,
1.1019023657,
0.1919506341,
0.6057543755,
0.0054240213,
-0.1344224215,
0.2286990881,
-0.1045235619,
-0.8899658918,
-0.3585012853,
0.2330904752,
-0.4608418941,
-0.1624563783,
-0.1189794838,
-0.900873065,
-0.6162868738,
-0.3252237141,
0.2568543851,
-0.248832345,
-0.3543887436,
0.0291562844,
-0.0378004722,
0.3467920721,
0.2757615447,
-0.8201493621,
0.3783831894,
0.9300750494,
0.9470552206,
0.0817947686,
0.0495374799,
-0.8604476452,
0.2556532621,
-0.234976545,
1.2870160341,
-0.9042943716,
-0.2575541437,
0.0502366871,
-0.3956085443,
0.0468928516,
-1.050475359,
0.8294231892,
-0.8146148324,
0.2065892369,
-0.0879793093,
-0.7208931446,
-0.0484160483,
0.4127270579,
-0.726986289,
0.7269044518,
-0.0768978149,
-0.6235617995,
0.0889881402,
-0.4748644829,
-0.4466990232,
0.0254819039,
-0.3641091585,
-0.539073348,
0.1435878426,
0.291249454,
0.6433188915,
-0.9316228628,
0.3782559335,
-0.570002377,
-0.0218067784,
0.4800001085,
-0.2203071117,
0.7394673824,
0.1971551925,
-0.1772395819,
0.2487638891,
-0.6135201454,
-0.0289034545,
0.2108509243,
-0.2279995829,
-0.5965708494,
0.3492017984,
-0.2468914837,
0.3424739242,
0.0761108249,
-0.3503702879,
0.2967274189,
-0.3711218238,
0.75574404,
0.6933254004,
0.2645603716,
-0.030641824,
-0.2763587236,
0.5104466081,
0.1044078544,
-0.3717905879,
-0.4014159441,
-0.6255245209,
-1.0048042536,
-0.2776539922,
0.4557056427,
0.5643439293,
-0.1332996637,
0.3638629019,
-0.4998045862,
-0.1767973453,
-0.3817136288,
0.3178447783,
0.2946298122,
0.3052195013,
0.3520646989,
-0.0771181956,
-0.7625377774,
-0.8763456345,
-0.2394804507,
-0.5190308094,
0.0912322477,
0.477333039,
0.1880258024,
-0.4488695264,
0.980655551,
-0.4741637409,
-0.2619490027,
-0.3254989982,
0.4692611396,
0.3372792602,
-0.0960352644,
0.3568255901,
-0.4623846412,
-0.5234902501,
0.2955107987,
-0.9675098062,
-0.3176104128,
-0.0212287791,
-0.0514626168,
0.3429425955,
0.5375865102,
-0.8808856606,
0.0629962236,
0.4875838161,
-0.2191462666,
0.5111952424,
-0.014855748,
-0.083245419,
-1.2791450024,
0.0261644349,
0.1879487485,
-0.3574107885,
-0.4908716977,
0.1381676644,
-0.101221852,
-0.2354086637,
-0.1329392493,
0.5698084831,
-0.3055808842,
0.1587515026,
-0.6295441985,
0.03790766,
-0.1910524964,
0.2455114871,
0.2540534139,
0.4791931212,
0.3193513751,
-0.4964738786,
0.3727217913,
0.2325188667,
-0.2500433624,
0.5946395397,
-0.6590396762,
0.1942035854,
0.03798135,
0.1785116047,
-1.0774588585,
-0.3596071601,
0.0730378032,
-0.3443922997,
0.224525243,
-0.5581858754,
-0.3257990479,
-0.0185115915,
-0.1089349389,
0.273391515,
0.3275811076,
-0.6101344228,
0.7233475447,
0.4476664066,
-0.4942647517,
-0.6981784701,
-0.4778292775,
0.3929003179,
-0.5447279811,
-0.5566769838,
0.1458635926,
0.2250228822,
-0.7204756737,
0.3249502778,
0.3320401311,
-0.0616956353,
-0.2254063487,
0.4966760278,
0.2985731959,
-0.2677114606,
0.203549251,
-0.4904205501,
-0.2051452994,
0.3370598555,
0.1799253225,
0.6098365784,
0.0288947728,
-0.2493781,
-0.2144606858,
0.5750969052,
0.8152516484,
-0.1355092973,
0.6986473203,
0.010331084,
-0.4317378402,
-0.4993879497,
-0.7226359248,
-0.0833804756,
-0.4711180329,
0.1926095039,
-0.3146226704,
-1.0057325363,
0.5132123232,
-0.3053864837,
0.3522002995,
0.4903566241,
0.7946794033,
0.1660377085,
0.8149031401,
0.2493588328,
-0.6233862638,
0.245143652,
-0.019996671,
0.3182204962,
-0.6754929423,
0.1146377027,
-0.6882189512,
-0.0814194828,
-0.4088932276,
-0.4342739582,
0.0671092719,
0.1348866373,
-0.2309700102,
0.2161289901,
-0.0974547043,
0.303630501,
0.16267851,
-0.1558354348,
0.4893877506,
0.2033543438,
0.0572111011,
-0.1324166954,
-0.5226857662,
-0.7217161059,
1.1018047333,
0.5160284638,
0.7612102628,
0.2177649438,
0.5039097667,
0.4556818902,
0.953422606,
-1.0482144356,
0.766639173,
-0.1184259877,
-0.8006857634,
0.0182853267,
-0.6691730022,
-1.0303912163,
0.3237970769,
-0.4024695158,
-0.5856335163,
-0.1173229665,
0.1549517363,
-0.1956664026,
0.5608475208,
-0.6144677997,
0.6509797573,
-0.3338858783,
-0.4697902203,
-0.4765422642,
-0.0925751999,
0.6303847432,
0.050956279,
0.3880868852,
-0.1544670463,
0.3021360636,
0.8330820203,
-0.5060645938,
0.5314154625,
-0.1028672978,
-0.1487756073,
0.599298358,
0.0711136162,
0.6072619557,
-0.053861469,
-0.3082684278,
-0.0504757054,
-0.4170878828,
-0.0880030096,
-0.7453967333,
0.9357442856,
-0.6369560957,
-0.9635773301,
-0.5067132115,
-0.3945822418,
-0.3382357955,
-0.0472349189,
-0.1701691598,
0.3162070513,
-0.0590616874,
0.3497179151,
0.5488879681,
-0.0122362655,
0.3679976165,
0.5372496843,
-0.2380725592,
-0.6720852256,
0.7814306021,
-0.1241646335,
0.0100556724,
0.3763651848,
0.4979779124,
-0.3317922056,
-0.5757703185,
-0.410847038,
0.461170882,
-0.7641196847,
-0.5147511363,
-0.7153080702,
-0.2002567947,
0.0228541065,
0.1678909659,
-0.1258561164,
-0.2247297168,
0.0945248455,
-0.0358983986,
0.4985276163,
0.8495510221,
0.1930793077,
0.1672013253,
-0.8123087883,
0.2883247137,
0.5938423872,
0.2752612531,
0.233786568,
-0.3922016323,
-0.007509273,
-0.2176548839,
-0.4272993803,
-1.0537670851,
0.2573066354,
0.2156132609,
0.319028616,
0.6701933146,
0.0526258089,
0.8024115562,
-0.5440478921,
0.6412808895,
0.1681786776,
-0.7893723845,
0.4686360359,
-0.5626650453,
-0.141193077,
0.2869269848,
0.3646895289,
-0.2585097551,
-0.0185020138,
-0.6038196683,
-0.8484470248,
0.5994339585,
-0.0592936948,
0.0416629314,
-0.1357731521,
0.4848532379,
-0.1844217032,
0.0412715897,
-1.1861306429,
-0.0390125252,
0.3996105194,
-0.1618357301,
0.0529381707,
-0.5203957558,
-0.1931798905,
0.0459486619,
0.5604947805,
0.1146154702,
0.200385958,
-0.0874736086,
-0.0147761535,
-0.5026292801,
0.6779420972,
0.4147980809,
0.6184534431,
-0.1236674041,
0.2852310538,
0.2590569258,
0.0701548383,
0.3390321434,
0.0582175404,
0.0137124127,
-0.0068047852,
0.4542060196,
0.8049397469,
0.2399082929,
-0.9088972807,
0.4191904664,
0.0394426025,
-0.1916226745,
-0.1933068484,
-0.0204658359,
0.4223834276,
0.1280169338,
0.2725448012,
-0.2667544484,
-0.1265908629,
-0.9123771191,
0.1383241713,
0.9227932096,
-0.1092808098,
-0.1064397171,
0.451069057,
0.0868266597,
-0.428475976,
0.5995779037,
0.1477401406,
-0.6542186737,
0.1717434824,
0.623750031,
0.5973578691,
-0.0849581957,
-0.0553837754,
0.2488967329,
-0.025533814,
-0.050439734,
-0.0287151895,
0.0217193682,
-0.7055616975,
-0.6567254066,
-0.6075592041,
-0.8051603436,
0.6956760287,
-0.5666117072,
0.3609566391,
-0.638686955,
-0.2647130489,
0.1565382332,
0.0723271221,
-0.2534481287,
0.1150122359,
0.1158126742,
0.5746005774,
-0.8325676918,
0.7552841902,
0.991266489,
0.0121567529,
-0.596837163,
-0.0283071883,
-0.2126050144,
-0.3073523641,
0.6839451194,
0.1565099955,
-0.2350040227,
-0.4146673679,
-0.4492361546,
-0.4321050048,
0.6079454422,
0.6395244598,
-0.3638885319,
0.1845357269,
0.2281363457,
0.6061803699,
-0.4027160406,
0.3272036016,
0.1640639007,
0.4274426401,
0.0494670197,
-0.6197190285,
0.000190999,
-0.2686263323,
-0.3380846083,
0.3969459832,
-0.6214035749,
0.9474434853,
-0.016589921,
-0.2144229114,
-0.0047153961,
1.0165734291,
0.6005474329,
0.2533859611,
0.6100404859,
0.9360484481,
0.5890657306,
0.0440023579,
0.8985211849,
-0.2867668867,
0.1547232121,
1.1494452953,
-0.5543268323,
1.4228773117,
0.2798703313,
-0.1593012661,
1.1280030012,
0.4122527242,
0.1056226417,
0.1162016019,
0.2402193248,
-0.3349379599,
-0.7199601531,
-0.0474453866,
-0.178255707,
0.2465932816,
0.7734745741,
-0.4641735852,
-0.3387211859,
-0.4493657649,
0.3294762969,
0.3823924065,
-0.2833931744,
0.7675728202,
0.3684485853,
-1.1268419027,
0.6449142098,
0.2596613467,
0.6022289395,
-0.72984308,
-0.176144138,
0.1235769466,
0.454669714,
-0.2316854298,
-0.7120211124,
0.0572176985,
0.3197368979,
-0.3130919933,
0.1390830576,
0.9030601382,
-0.2290763706,
-0.2712085843,
0.4511988461,
0.5951703191,
-0.1516577154,
0.1123248041,
-0.5932621956,
0.1114637554,
-0.1635984182,
-0.3190472126,
0.5222324133,
0.4073283076,
-0.2471242696,
0.7884706855,
0.5748170018,
0.2093518525,
-0.1187671348,
-0.2452244014,
1.0381953716,
-0.6189021468,
-0.1612849087,
-1.2659976482,
0.2035509646,
-0.3008512557,
-0.0982539281,
0.7683785558,
0.4920608401,
0.417735517,
0.0141393701,
0.8485654593,
0.04393306,
0.6335261464,
-0.604393065,
0.2608565092,
-0.192085579,
0.2297125161,
-0.161180526,
-0.8689866662,
-0.37875247,
0.8347702622,
-0.4841950536,
-0.0298098195,
0.5406811237,
0.7897028923,
-0.2280778587,
0.1108338237,
0.0730322599,
0.1626094133,
0.5936644077,
0.8537356257,
0.9610298276,
-0.2293589413,
0.5476693511,
0.2851600945,
-0.2136767954,
-0.1941487491,
-1.0535305738,
-1.3443638086,
-0.280626595,
-0.3552469611,
-0.4356073141,
0.130940184,
1.1886700392,
0.7296411395,
-0.9687560797,
-0.5809039474,
-0.1459904313,
0.0501789115,
0.1686103642,
-0.1757030636,
0.2835244834,
-0.3908784091,
-0.592220664,
0.449405551,
0.1422661692,
-0.2957355976,
-0.3054678142,
-0.130807668,
-0.3893145919,
0.3656128943,
0.5827730894,
0.4625369012,
-0.7231017947,
-0.1352888048,
-0.3888833523,
0.1366550326,
0.1663620621,
1.01518929,
-0.6891163588,
0.2194019407,
0.489382416,
0.6496792436,
0.283326,
0.3880645633,
0.6975208521,
-0.6382419467,
0.007053819,
-0.0531587601,
0.6480999589,
0.4833142161,
-0.0395798348,
0.3760392368,
0.068782039,
-0.7994568348,
-0.9701245427,
0.4203695357,
-0.9200102091,
-0.2635966837,
1.5689254999,
-0.401584506,
-0.045432698,
-0.133815974,
-0.3061394989,
-0.0686783642,
-0.3263822198,
0.7317407131,
1.0607112646,
-0.1541392356,
-0.3232726753,
-0.4871648252,
0.4743348062,
0.5562439561,
-0.8810552955,
0.6628245711,
0.5731936097,
0.1783027649,
0.3061679006,
0.4199639857,
-0.1764800102,
0.0034279111,
-0.4066369832,
-0.4402275383,
-0.0093251634,
-0.1794588268,
-0.3244648576,
0.7882321477,
0.5910731554,
0.3092424572
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05561v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05561v1
|
Detecting a Proxy for Potential Comorbid ADHD in People Reporting Anxiety Symptoms from Social Media Data
| 2024-02-17T10:32:43 | 2024-02-17T10:32:43 |
Claire S. Lee, Noelle Lim, Michael Guerzhoy
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL
|
We present a novel task that can elucidate the connection between anxiety and
ADHD; use Transformers to make progress toward solving a task that is not
solvable by keyword-based classifiers; and discuss a method for visualization
of our classifier illuminating the connection between anxiety and ADHD
presentations.
Up to approximately 50% of adults with ADHD may also have an anxiety disorder
and approximately 30\% of adults with anxiety may also have ADHD. Patients
presenting with anxiety may be treated for anxiety without ADHD ever being
considered, possibly affecting treatment. We show how data that bears on ADHD
that is comorbid with anxiety can be obtained from social media data, and show
that Transformers can be used to detect a proxy for possible comorbid ADHD in
people with anxiety symptoms.
We collected data from anxiety and ADHD online forums (subreddits). We
identified posters who first started posting in the Anxiety subreddit and later
started posting in the ADHD subreddit as well. We use this subset of the
posters as a proxy for people who presented with anxiety symptoms and then
became aware that they might have ADHD. We fine-tune a Transformer
architecture-based classifier to classify people who started posting in the
Anxiety subreddit and then started posting in the ADHD subreddit vs. people who
posted in the Anxiety subreddit without later posting in the ADHD subreddit. We
show that a Transformer architecture is capable of achieving reasonable results
(76% correct for RoBERTa vs. under 60% correct for the best keyword-based
model, both with 50% base rate).
|
[
-0.7044855952,
-0.9674288034,
0.9092613459,
0.0418553986,
-0.0025736517,
0.2641783953,
0.1809595376,
-0.5100547075,
0.8302762508,
0.0856826156,
-0.7963237762,
-0.5383119583,
-0.8919324875,
-0.4691931605,
-0.6083306074,
0.7829692364,
-0.2004932016,
0.2534981966,
-0.1071410552,
0.1682398468,
-0.4622211456,
-0.4604764581,
-1.266010046,
-0.3495359123,
0.3843171,
0.370421797,
0.7608632445,
0.6245540977,
0.6623554826,
0.1390391588,
0.0167278554,
0.0897885039,
-0.0351026542,
0.0386797711,
-0.2432826012,
-0.2474176288,
-0.6875100136,
-0.1191218421,
0.1685756296,
0.3783877194,
-0.1611043215,
0.4015547335,
0.0220610611,
0.4071823359,
-0.4101831913,
-0.0914984569,
-0.4079332948,
0.2511702776,
-0.1470459998,
-0.3579815924,
0.0022921157,
-0.0807828531,
-0.4503103197,
-0.4624587297,
0.827198863,
0.1625715643,
0.7166298628,
0.6124731302,
-0.7095653415,
-0.3546791673,
-1.0405516624,
0.3390261233,
0.2149012238,
0.4955021143,
0.442158401,
0.3755174279,
-0.0791577771,
-0.8666522503,
-0.7142834067,
0.1125284433,
-0.1969146281,
0.1583653092,
-0.5126293898,
-0.0775893033,
0.2636115253,
0.3611781895,
-0.823166132,
-0.095885098,
-0.5906568766,
-0.2992050946,
0.5715965033,
0.2450839132,
0.4648863375,
0.1085894555,
-0.397418648,
-0.1810196638,
-0.1064223349,
0.292960912,
0.2602079511,
0.0604878478,
-0.116405338,
0.3819837868,
0.504571259,
0.1606972069,
0.6097347736,
0.0201121587,
-0.0298522413,
0.2751126587,
0.2509965599,
0.4451026618,
0.4346626401,
0.5124565959,
0.1002897471,
0.002198166,
-0.0007717758,
0.8057506084,
0.6514139175,
-0.4751707911,
-0.3334752023,
0.4244926274,
-0.6613858342,
-0.0347214192,
0.0708258376,
-0.9424183965,
-0.7657285333,
-0.2325464934,
0.5448393822,
-0.2883412838,
-0.228267327,
-0.1367034912,
-0.2591972649,
-0.0203022659,
0.2755768299,
-0.7219703197,
0.7735133767,
0.8276436329,
0.9676718116,
-0.6170274019,
-0.0969502106,
-0.3544549048,
-0.1492271125,
-0.3461325169,
1.126079917,
-0.2586325407,
-0.4554207027,
0.0785200447,
0.1259385198,
-0.4567518532,
-0.6627881527,
0.9931228757,
-0.6663419008,
-0.1944302469,
0.1186840236,
-0.4367949069,
0.0650560856,
0.1021470726,
-1.0056313276,
0.9241562486,
0.2288049012,
-0.6778465509,
0.1990414709,
-0.5302200317,
-0.6334549189,
0.1093452126,
-0.0004517776,
-0.3291642666,
0.0427415445,
0.0922864825,
0.1793709099,
-0.1437676847,
0.3688041568,
-0.4408575296,
-0.5662808418,
0.4659773707,
-0.2955992818,
0.5029853582,
0.3071477413,
-0.1108707711,
0.0058629843,
-0.6330490708,
-0.1405619532,
-0.0609313622,
-0.1181353554,
-0.4033152163,
-0.0235678982,
0.0592781529,
0.4079937339,
0.2742823362,
-0.5573320389,
0.0144252423,
0.3048399985,
-0.0375108272,
0.8143063784,
0.4478319287,
-0.151892662,
-0.6782305241,
0.7248183489,
0.3584992588,
0.3874909878,
0.2786799967,
-0.632653296,
-0.6847639084,
-0.5763252378,
-0.3078950346,
0.4328584075,
-0.5957562923,
0.4940420985,
-0.2591144443,
-0.4629449844,
-0.6696252227,
-0.0800351277,
0.0935100093,
0.4579969943,
0.7774532437,
-0.2621376216,
-0.6002920866,
-0.729717195,
-0.3508044481,
-0.1038787141,
-0.1707461774,
0.1154479533,
0.3301412761,
-0.6570173502,
0.4129868746,
-0.8671581149,
-0.716766417,
0.2792314887,
0.5414888859,
0.0507023372,
0.3745266199,
0.3523810804,
-1.0475612879,
-0.6843540668,
0.0423663147,
-0.1213744655,
0.1391684413,
0.1973950714,
-0.1949487478,
-0.1500675231,
0.9209164381,
-0.9034599662,
0.4399421811,
0.4303432405,
-0.3340287805,
0.1520916224,
0.0407900363,
0.0435004868,
-1.2198574543,
0.2076959163,
0.1691975892,
-0.0538452044,
-0.6977124214,
-0.2170221806,
-0.2215517908,
-0.1006487533,
-0.059158098,
0.3612680137,
0.2778573036,
0.3277991414,
-0.3243652284,
-0.14977099,
-0.245756641,
0.5714291334,
-0.0422283225,
0.386470437,
0.713368237,
-0.4947360158,
0.4001571834,
-0.0897072628,
-0.0556595922,
0.6723182201,
-0.3432401121,
0.1785616726,
-0.4802400768,
0.2120022029,
-1.5653207302,
-0.5140554905,
0.3634923398,
-0.6363514066,
0.3401989341,
0.2013922483,
-0.1917841882,
-0.7700960636,
-0.3940680623,
0.3007006049,
0.4041219652,
-0.6064764261,
0.8635448813,
0.5467571616,
0.0327465199,
-0.3213526309,
-0.4343375564,
-0.430147469,
-0.5525774956,
-0.2540185452,
0.7680469155,
0.0096509904,
-0.1693379879,
0.4205684364,
-0.6012515426,
-0.4675670564,
0.1077952385,
0.4952032566,
0.0906125754,
0.0083286753,
0.4542736411,
0.0430146642,
-0.1252185106,
0.355319798,
-0.137196064,
0.7693610787,
-0.114743121,
-0.4502846599,
-0.5752418041,
0.3499324024,
0.7513901591,
0.1039508432,
0.5966582298,
1.0319066048,
-0.6128354669,
-0.3532708883,
-0.3776246905,
-0.3110818565,
-0.4756966233,
0.1125545204,
-0.3144789338,
-0.6238030195,
0.7461568713,
-0.0876767114,
-0.5393949747,
0.5002679229,
0.254879117,
-0.2172517031,
1.4806921482,
0.7931580544,
0.1258606613,
0.366736412,
0.0378775746,
0.5333787799,
-0.5670050383,
-0.1269998997,
-0.357180506,
-0.6466957331,
-0.9956910014,
-0.3270881474,
0.5222302675,
-0.397675842,
-0.2208059281,
0.1039048508,
-0.3879578114,
-0.0074583138,
0.6179563999,
0.4369511008,
0.1193165109,
0.2223275006,
0.0422466733,
-0.091542542,
-0.4425988197,
-0.2820315957,
0.9103211761,
0.2779866755,
0.7827136517,
0.1545127034,
0.401671499,
0.9922670126,
0.8382695913,
-1.1174541712,
0.4349377155,
-0.429174602,
-0.7238458991,
0.052699402,
-0.2366579175,
-1.0055036545,
-0.2489701658,
-0.0907869637,
-0.9750976562,
0.4382666349,
0.3289448023,
-0.5086615682,
0.0529236458,
-0.6035594344,
0.9353479147,
-0.1887509674,
-0.2664001584,
-0.3080859184,
-0.8199356198,
0.4456398785,
-0.6208587885,
0.226122424,
0.0361708403,
0.2657199502,
0.8800060749,
-0.3156944215,
0.5166438222,
-0.0239922982,
0.0536985248,
0.4863600135,
-0.0142272245,
-0.0706455261,
-0.2367247194,
0.3641683757,
-0.1180863976,
0.0095630633,
0.0343272313,
-0.8678523302,
0.8424791098,
-1.0085568428,
-0.6923541427,
-0.4886685014,
-0.4182770252,
-0.5030711293,
0.0717578903,
0.1843984425,
0.175954327,
0.0841661394,
0.1735556722,
0.6232150793,
0.3688761294,
0.1561590433,
0.49327299,
0.0624118634,
-0.3001855612,
0.8600423336,
0.051196266,
-0.3244139552,
0.5439509153,
0.2497768551,
-0.3997606933,
0.1229615957,
0.2286207527,
0.3185002506,
-0.7342302799,
-0.1077335998,
-0.4694282115,
-0.4193534553,
-0.5310218334,
0.0007583529,
-0.3715092838,
-0.4149198234,
-0.1886942387,
-0.3148573041,
0.1954907775,
0.5207310915,
-0.1652287692,
0.4917367101,
-0.5236281753,
0.5166302919,
0.6367236376,
0.265075773,
0.3289822936,
-0.3061268628,
-0.1356722116,
0.000477607,
-0.8191792965,
-0.7961626053,
0.4093439281,
0.0595308766,
0.4511092007,
0.8188142776,
0.3317989707,
0.8998094201,
-0.1513990909,
0.4874638319,
0.0510192811,
-0.7831034064,
0.3792344034,
-0.0033347574,
-0.2357205749,
0.3482811749,
1.2802988291,
-0.7392077446,
-0.2200746238,
-0.7811791301,
-0.8539637327,
0.7306370139,
0.0787099749,
-0.1117280722,
-0.0957650244,
0.1467365921,
-0.4483177066,
0.0553678647,
-0.4643194675,
-0.6259102821,
-0.1998256594,
-0.4416971207,
-0.0802624673,
-0.132845968,
-0.3508055508,
-0.2225046158,
0.5630387068,
-0.0250940435,
0.4995801151,
0.3538147807,
0.3449545205,
-0.5692529082,
-0.019548662,
0.2493643016,
0.3731524348,
-0.5371258259,
0.7839888334,
-0.2502157986,
-0.8470234871,
0.2965951264,
0.4396358728,
0.2328486443,
0.1563322693,
0.4396271408,
0.5895963907,
-0.2684431076,
-0.5601376295,
0.5934176445,
-0.3620434403,
-0.0615127683,
-0.5570164323,
0.1590615213,
-0.0869903043,
0.2724177837,
0.5933356285,
0.4440099001,
0.2229969054,
-0.6636503339,
0.4507390261,
0.4262241721,
-0.663631916,
-0.5999752283,
0.8813615441,
-0.2146435827,
-0.8814057708,
0.4060959518,
-0.1148970947,
-0.5135250688,
0.8484771252,
0.469930172,
0.9761360288,
-0.7363915443,
0.2440080643,
0.2356427312,
0.1486489475,
0.1077094823,
0.2044446021,
-0.071524322,
-0.8503382802,
0.3332488239,
-0.5299469233,
-0.1925996542,
0.5915753841,
-1.0503530502,
0.4232799411,
-0.2899629772,
-0.7837721705,
0.3935107291,
0.0006801159,
-0.6071733236,
0.3396245539,
0.2115534544,
0.6343547702,
-1.2949033976,
0.5778406262,
1.2859523296,
0.0258998275,
-0.6253550649,
0.7593390942,
0.0707603693,
-0.6060352921,
0.3350049853,
0.283592701,
-0.4524436593,
-0.0650722608,
-0.427996397,
-0.9530326128,
1.0038598776,
-0.1051369607,
0.0359098129,
0.277009964,
0.1937758923,
1.147072196,
-0.3712439537,
-0.0473947674,
0.4088105559,
0.4025967717,
0.3087739944,
-0.5604712367,
0.10809201,
-0.5365353823,
0.0075256326,
-0.0051405984,
-0.6507937312,
1.1421643496,
0.0484830178,
-0.4688218832,
-0.2152142227,
0.2878730893,
0.1324266195,
0.7134038806,
0.5881183743,
0.4978948832,
0.9238211513,
0.0808128566,
0.9541282654,
-0.9026629925,
0.2765082419,
0.9237704277,
-0.3169912398,
0.6962028146,
0.6209542155,
-0.0852236822,
0.4664851427,
0.5656670332,
0.1630841643,
0.5126487613,
-0.1955943853,
-0.4983876646,
-0.2689614594,
-0.6621358991,
-0.2244907767,
0.3785998821,
0.8205177784,
-0.2287612259,
-0.2269642651,
0.020744402,
0.1822251379,
0.0285706297,
-0.28618294,
0.4070912302,
0.0461837538,
-1.0353384018,
0.4447190464,
0.237258181,
0.1427704245,
-0.4456375837,
-0.0025848087,
-0.3032078147,
0.7670027018,
-0.1775913984,
-0.6525900364,
0.636932373,
-0.2406521887,
-0.1517337263,
-0.263394922,
0.9108237624,
-0.4112570286,
-0.3977560401,
0.4294818044,
0.6460928321,
-0.0204545148,
-0.0684615746,
-0.293943882,
-0.2906585634,
-0.4341990948,
0.0016538033,
0.083882384,
0.1494773179,
-0.4626964033,
0.6052912474,
0.4475238919,
-0.1299899071,
-0.1077095419,
-0.1864197254,
0.9054906964,
-0.1823115349,
-0.3284880519,
-0.8170881271,
0.1949367672,
-0.0084982105,
-0.2387852371,
0.8123027682,
0.4733096957,
0.5868142843,
-0.2557351589,
0.560885489,
-0.2287866473,
0.5800662637,
0.0549851544,
0.4829747379,
-0.8665460348,
0.0156860724,
0.0169758536,
-0.4872309864,
-0.4173119366,
0.5613068938,
-0.3128124774,
-0.0861346126,
1.0926244259,
0.9198654294,
-0.2853351831,
-0.018799711,
-0.1378542036,
0.1952059716,
0.3272042871,
0.4357388616,
0.720733583,
-0.3157634735,
0.4193278551,
-0.3454377949,
-0.1912670732,
-0.3495881259,
-0.3147389889,
-0.8913503289,
-0.5900614858,
-0.6051297784,
-0.5002864599,
0.1275255084,
0.8481689095,
0.4747473001,
-0.7983443141,
-0.135631606,
-0.2353616059,
0.674146235,
-0.7764594555,
-0.3489449024,
0.5904974937,
0.0580242611,
-0.6326438189,
0.0147412056,
-0.2776199281,
0.1534804702,
-0.0233664531,
0.3816280961,
-0.1923535913,
0.1132626384,
0.303597331,
0.1228924468,
-0.184545204,
-0.2462287992,
0.1000196785,
-0.1844373792,
0.0753188282,
0.7624425292,
-0.4080186486,
0.2780843377,
0.3149756193,
0.2905366123,
0.4236297607,
0.5078377128,
0.0687293857,
-0.78855896,
-0.2317136824,
0.0986044481,
0.2379423827,
0.0940932557,
-0.6457474828,
0.2735232413,
0.6001716852,
-0.3064669967,
-0.5646739602,
0.0128163509,
-0.9041261673,
-0.1761012524,
0.9243602157,
-0.0475805365,
-0.3000751138,
-0.2904978096,
-0.1717076749,
0.31267941,
-0.3456170857,
1.3379356861,
0.6161056161,
-0.5207743049,
0.1815624982,
-0.3976596892,
0.6120066047,
0.0991168916,
-0.6462903023,
-0.5469657183,
0.1747856289,
0.0763941184,
0.5880339742,
0.4938090742,
0.2085235566,
0.4002900124,
0.1144817173,
-0.0778369606,
0.1968088895,
-0.4605992138,
-0.2975692451,
0.3977761269,
-0.3118859828,
-0.4659135938
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11218v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11218v2
|
Controlled Text Generation for Large Language Model with Dynamic Attribute Graphs
| 2024-02-17T08:14:37 | 2024-05-24T04:56:41 |
Xun Liang, Hanyu Wang, Shichao Song, Mengting Hu, Xunzhi Wang, Zhiyu Li, Feiyu Xiong, Bo Tang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Controlled Text Generation (CTG) aims to produce texts that exhibit specific
desired attributes. In this study, we introduce a pluggable CTG framework for
Large Language Models (LLMs) named Dynamic Attribute Graphs-based controlled
text generation (DATG). This framework utilizes an attribute scorer to evaluate
the attributes of sentences generated by LLMs and constructs dynamic attribute
graphs. DATG modulates the occurrence of key attribute words and key
anti-attribute words, achieving effective attribute control without
compromising the original capabilities of the model. We conduct experiments
across four datasets in two tasks: toxicity mitigation and sentiment
transformation, employing five LLMs as foundational models. Our findings
highlight a remarkable enhancement in control accuracy, achieving a peak
improvement of 19.29% over baseline methods in the most favorable task across
four datasets. Additionally, we observe a significant decrease in perplexity,
markedly improving text fluency.
|
[
-0.0269483756,
-1.1495393515,
0.4998259842,
0.3236469626,
-0.1875538826,
0.3526838422,
-0.349054575,
-0.2554379702,
-0.0058113742,
0.6785731316,
-0.6188480258,
-1.0024646521,
-0.4949909151,
0.2998497784,
-0.350687474,
1.0621142387,
-0.0665822253,
-0.3114160895,
-0.1428774297,
0.0741248131,
-0.6253190041,
-0.3463617265,
-0.8476275802,
-0.4972778261,
0.7839497328,
0.3027435243,
0.9314474463,
0.7497370243,
0.4927297235,
0.2778422236,
-0.1861444414,
0.5083448291,
-0.6347519159,
0.4262083471,
-0.1090154871,
-0.4100705087,
-0.8133289218,
0.1051585227,
0.602322042,
0.2483987361,
0.0103445593,
-0.3129040897,
0.0519354343,
0.3960646391,
-0.4413451254,
0.2398919612,
-0.7409208417,
0.0589004196,
-0.1207271591,
-0.3069500625,
-0.7295016646,
-0.3752791584,
-0.0978194401,
-0.4850565791,
-0.1663296819,
-0.0675356761,
0.8499895334,
0.2651932836,
-0.8789360523,
-0.3276486099,
-0.6562923193,
0.9408305287,
-0.8665323853,
0.095942229,
0.2646154463,
-0.0121770408,
-0.5168199539,
-0.9392552376,
-0.622679472,
-0.6049120426,
-0.1984062642,
0.2665427923,
-0.1668748409,
0.3931028843,
0.1707830429,
0.2856266201,
-0.4281858802,
0.4504928589,
0.3576470912,
-0.1976162344,
0.8259924054,
0.4831945002,
0.3823117018,
-0.4209590256,
-0.2593691945,
-0.1287276745,
-0.8960012794,
-0.1841417253,
0.4099920392,
0.2909002006,
0.1339263767,
0.5352255106,
-0.0170534886,
0.633208096,
0.1526704729,
-0.2834355235,
0.1399706602,
-0.2559674382,
-0.1633570492,
-0.0484339632,
0.9691470861,
0.2733704448,
0.1063431799,
-0.0938947275,
-0.275349766,
-0.081234552,
0.3269895315,
-0.8402655721,
-0.3298291862,
0.3048151135,
-0.3070799112,
-0.9657575488,
-0.3139024973,
-0.5149519444,
-0.5390947461,
-0.108072646,
0.1392417103,
-0.608464241,
-0.1578824073,
-0.0571413748,
0.2135881037,
-0.0601258427,
0.3463847339,
-0.5067067742,
0.0139068821,
0.3055680096,
0.8169270158,
-0.6602592468,
0.1075550839,
-0.5064437985,
0.4639295936,
-0.3747138977,
0.6338669062,
-0.7663238049,
-0.4243268967,
0.1435391307,
-0.2533504367,
0.0532942526,
-0.3400710225,
0.488804847,
-0.5507036448,
0.2656140625,
0.0402007401,
-0.5818251967,
-0.0766489133,
0.4554878473,
-0.7904805541,
1.1970171928,
0.094059296,
-0.767490685,
0.3339331746,
-0.5918352604,
-0.6592638493,
0.2474188656,
-0.2003658265,
-0.6393576264,
-0.0743170008,
0.0184642319,
0.532725811,
-0.2564972937,
0.3909646571,
-0.1309740245,
-0.0308232829,
0.5253310204,
-0.367090106,
0.4848318398,
0.2649843693,
-0.2906494439,
0.3652083576,
-1.0040149689,
0.3004882932,
-0.0617810823,
-0.6860163808,
-0.282279253,
0.3215116262,
0.202201277,
0.0993026569,
0.200094074,
-0.2834925652,
0.2431509793,
-0.1149984375,
0.3923116922,
0.6024079323,
0.1713809073,
0.3549188673,
-0.2042692155,
0.5933439732,
0.0461196899,
-0.2333603352,
-0.0560536087,
-0.1517923474,
-0.6782495379,
-0.4629706144,
0.1831959486,
0.5959606767,
-0.9623214602,
0.9556446671,
-0.1780434102,
-0.5008102655,
0.2582890391,
0.0099028936,
0.3324481547,
0.3314916193,
0.0779081807,
-0.1599762589,
-0.1491311491,
-0.6843621731,
-0.1871446669,
-0.2808639705,
-0.1808064878,
0.5116811991,
0.279404074,
-0.1686062068,
0.8550159931,
-0.8568713665,
-0.2937639356,
-0.6141153574,
0.5623415112,
-0.0760662779,
0.5017787814,
0.8103260994,
-0.6617236137,
-0.5636575222,
-0.01765511,
-0.3963793814,
-0.5981610417,
-0.4184121192,
-0.3915053308,
0.2089429051,
0.5527171493,
-0.5552538037,
0.2646855414,
0.6391124129,
-0.2962257266,
0.7611999512,
-0.1797061563,
0.2446576655,
-1.1418793201,
0.1139288545,
0.0641539246,
-0.4719743729,
-0.8839271665,
0.1159789488,
0.0738727301,
-0.0149272205,
-0.4014400542,
0.3623944819,
-0.1379101425,
0.7312783599,
-0.4898521304,
0.0796272978,
-0.0052474313,
0.3819139898,
-0.0136827528,
0.6914268732,
0.3440978229,
-0.6652958393,
0.4962356687,
0.3268515766,
-0.2064822912,
0.635003984,
-0.6225069761,
0.1147819161,
-0.0020434661,
0.4162949622,
-1.0009175539,
-0.3875730932,
-0.1014880165,
-0.1975971162,
0.5212538242,
0.364770025,
-0.7884085178,
-0.3614281416,
-0.1751893759,
0.0457701124,
0.4247590601,
-0.1234349832,
0.5903283954,
0.1765122861,
-0.1739683747,
-0.1564649642,
-0.7292746902,
0.2277644724,
-0.3210446537,
-0.5143552423,
0.4956139326,
-0.0484440513,
-0.0801846907,
-0.1834990531,
0.2127503008,
-0.06681896,
0.0872963741,
-0.0325511135,
0.023405252,
0.0177144557,
0.6454579234,
0.3671491146,
0.0526838303,
-0.0164975654,
-0.0608137138,
0.7655169964,
0.3497222066,
0.0945075825,
-0.3022539616,
0.2076585442,
0.5559335351,
-0.4416339993,
0.8187832832,
0.4951406121,
-0.1407588422,
-0.5912367105,
-0.1295877248,
-0.0802229717,
-0.5569292307,
0.7390100956,
-0.2820604742,
-0.9692033529,
0.6830075979,
-0.1959819794,
0.0716490075,
0.2332267761,
0.7316867709,
-0.0272151511,
1.2736978531,
0.652862072,
0.0994434953,
0.6883141994,
0.0670374036,
0.2620975077,
-0.3651505411,
-0.0972068608,
-0.2867885232,
-0.4999819994,
-0.9847174287,
-0.2318435907,
0.5765513778,
-0.0509517081,
-0.4021632373,
0.0860882699,
-0.4125190377,
0.3493535519,
0.2967921495,
0.5192072392,
0.3481914401,
-0.1461768299,
-0.1047610193,
-0.1355627179,
-0.6315907836,
-0.5556951761,
0.7958424091,
0.2914267778,
1.0444170237,
0.0372812562,
0.3206747472,
0.4591712952,
0.3878824711,
-0.7574927807,
0.7668631077,
-0.5880250335,
-0.4286615252,
-0.2732506692,
-0.5438687801,
-0.6340687275,
-0.0785929933,
-0.4971201718,
-0.5825482011,
-0.3219205141,
0.3242013454,
-0.0775851756,
0.3491386771,
-0.4085938931,
0.4989646077,
-0.3655507565,
-0.5114627481,
-0.2850907743,
-0.2664676607,
0.4725209475,
-0.3447335064,
-0.2335639894,
-0.0551314205,
0.0062292623,
0.660780251,
-0.4457931817,
0.8484344482,
0.1260826886,
-0.4029999077,
0.3846416473,
0.3856761158,
0.8874911666,
-0.2442699969,
-0.2706842721,
-0.1507864445,
-0.3382754624,
-0.1591176093,
-0.4358148277,
0.9100976586,
-0.5310744643,
-0.5962480307,
-0.2692623436,
-1.1510944366,
-0.2127529979,
0.5605641007,
0.0823928043,
0.2085749209,
-0.187734589,
0.4044212401,
0.7809672356,
-0.8293440938,
0.2225484848,
0.3143300712,
-0.2011972815,
-0.5036527514,
0.5810518861,
0.0863850117,
0.6316857934,
0.3589751422,
0.3206461966,
-0.129397586,
-0.5859383345,
-0.1487796903,
0.2498314083,
-0.4887865484,
-0.4779190123,
-0.6764631867,
-0.3088364899,
-0.4456547499,
-0.2124496102,
-0.1348381937,
-0.2721187472,
-0.4952135086,
-0.3207930028,
0.8019920588,
0.8569877148,
0.2349409908,
0.8849312067,
-0.6944858432,
-0.0379111543,
0.043116007,
0.5073491931,
-0.0739375353,
-0.2699165046,
-0.1921527535,
0.0158623643,
-0.6422018409,
-1.0708749294,
0.5621840954,
0.2605444193,
0.2474504411,
0.436144799,
0.1862068325,
0.4551187158,
-0.5170896053,
0.9581353068,
0.1998824626,
-1.0275745392,
0.5004170537,
-0.7433483601,
0.3875928521,
0.1960092187,
0.2096828222,
-0.4615926445,
-1.0279811621,
-0.3126765192,
-0.9099671841,
0.6339806318,
0.4190438986,
0.3904687464,
-0.0693667978,
0.4964639544,
0.0147269489,
0.2995326519,
-0.8074654937,
-0.1777390093,
-0.1059504673,
-0.5643163919,
0.2483337075,
-0.3324296176,
0.0129687497,
0.04837377,
0.564637959,
-0.0747366175,
-0.0920997038,
-0.2262857854,
0.0179992616,
-0.0495140739,
0.3142630756,
0.3598205447,
0.3186659217,
-0.1240978017,
0.3247570693,
0.1424983442,
-0.6219736338,
0.09269315,
-0.1831965446,
-0.4378414154,
-0.2077218592,
0.2649610639,
0.7190976143,
-0.0494124442,
-0.5083576441,
0.2977219522,
0.205667451,
-0.1200343668,
0.022864433,
0.3607753813,
-0.0938061178,
-0.0773660317,
0.2374677062,
-0.5082536936,
-0.2239896804,
-0.2871416509,
0.3536514342,
0.4918165505,
-0.2971308827,
-0.1351255924,
0.8610116839,
0.3718029261,
-0.029814722,
0.537828207,
-0.0585419573,
-0.6027833223,
0.4982438684,
0.8196496367,
0.7583009601,
-0.218469888,
0.4201748371,
0.3271326423,
0.2412267178,
0.2372957021,
0.1983517855,
0.1939556897,
-0.7407603264,
-0.4813105762,
-0.4814605713,
-0.2264677882,
0.5121413469,
-0.269528389,
0.5039973259,
-0.4187610745,
-0.3478015065,
-0.1970754564,
0.1865005642,
-0.3391648233,
0.4606341422,
-0.1384109259,
0.9041754007,
-1.0197291374,
0.7936831117,
0.6022199392,
-0.4864849448,
-0.8416297436,
0.0639646947,
-0.192167744,
-0.3890727162,
0.6782171726,
-0.060082335,
-0.0556148253,
0.2814373076,
-0.9037983418,
-0.7019569278,
1.2041012049,
0.1060601249,
-0.2994866073,
-0.0175479241,
0.4633608758,
0.8002889752,
-0.2959711552,
0.2454019785,
0.6263322234,
0.6481692791,
0.2779195905,
-0.7418565154,
0.2340738624,
0.0455014072,
0.1700998694,
0.1689819545,
-0.6822654605,
0.7265070081,
0.1707261652,
-0.2872853577,
0.1316319108,
0.8277227283,
0.2368231267,
-0.1032793447,
0.4839390814,
0.378131628,
0.7867900133,
-0.230980441,
0.8803527951,
-0.3556148112,
0.1504320353,
0.9277602434,
-0.4582815468,
0.4431071579,
0.174872756,
0.0438904725,
0.7099867463,
0.3837107718,
0.0535179228,
0.4317140877,
0.3430605233,
-0.4080775082,
-0.352230221,
-0.308711648,
0.1579864472,
0.4789863527,
0.3169899285,
-0.6356703043,
-0.213728413,
0.0928824991,
0.4623249471,
0.2490615845,
-0.2984539866,
0.7611196637,
-0.1779492497,
-0.4444562495,
0.4105854928,
0.1352698207,
0.6126174927,
-0.8851242065,
-0.0258189756,
-0.286488831,
0.2518236935,
-0.2531636357,
-1.0028214455,
0.0486189835,
0.232600987,
-0.0306884032,
-0.4920696318,
0.9256694317,
-0.7950049043,
-0.5583711267,
-0.1599706709,
0.2461108416,
-0.1258282661,
0.2182426006,
-0.3810454905,
-0.0304199941,
0.0590516292,
-0.5120183825,
0.0528386831,
0.6717384458,
-0.3571499586,
0.5971577168,
0.4393524528,
0.4819739461,
-0.0801939964,
-0.1281853169,
0.9318322539,
-0.5831664801,
-0.5472281575,
-0.706346333,
0.5889249444,
-0.1995162964,
-0.0330247656,
0.6999092698,
0.3960499465,
0.5008944273,
0.0396113433,
0.9889180064,
-0.3639425337,
0.3037986457,
-0.5564261079,
1.1183731556,
-0.4318479896,
0.0999843776,
-0.2671144605,
-0.6743191481,
-0.8410884142,
0.4321222603,
-0.3124184012,
0.0747825652,
0.7663719654,
0.9330278039,
0.1229021326,
-0.3538810313,
0.3164993525,
0.5734898448,
1.0551191568,
0.4027010202,
0.5150806904,
-0.0547677167,
0.4304563403,
0.0269368552,
-0.3917195201,
0.0808558017,
-1.3371603489,
-0.9759856462,
-0.3313771188,
-0.4317060113,
-0.5579353571,
-0.2156127095,
0.7916696072,
0.2853577733,
-0.8010682464,
-0.0131838797,
-0.33033517,
0.1436691731,
-0.0580218881,
-0.3183697462,
0.5693532825,
-0.3146511018,
-0.8268005252,
-0.0268062092,
0.2069098502,
0.0643881634,
-0.3242691457,
-0.0295911264,
-0.095805414,
0.4032380581,
0.7471627593,
-0.2229872346,
-0.3713209033,
-0.6794665456,
-0.0521141253,
-0.4908732176,
-0.028361924,
0.9390278459,
-0.6201248765,
0.3417550921,
0.7616446018,
0.2923667133,
0.1387490779,
0.098487474,
0.754950583,
-0.936303854,
0.0029372911,
0.2299949676,
-0.0738821104,
0.2173787504,
-0.4232798815,
0.1363366097,
0.0831651911,
-0.6408592463,
-0.7769867182,
0.6183021665,
-0.9681229591,
-0.259493649,
1.4393742085,
-0.1433819532,
-0.1553632915,
0.3008882999,
-0.3827771842,
0.5852062702,
-0.2737447619,
0.9172044396,
0.6285983324,
-0.2679004371,
-0.0750904456,
-0.0212463811,
0.6288443804,
0.1231656298,
-1.1270301342,
0.2323241383,
0.9332863688,
0.1027266383,
-0.087376833,
0.3642492592,
-0.2056988478,
-0.0954107493,
-0.3707357645,
0.1964665204,
-0.1125513092,
-0.121993944,
0.0358003713,
0.0373745151,
-0.0647526607,
0.1689387858
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11217v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11217v1
|
Asclepius: A Spectrum Evaluation Benchmark for Medical Multi-Modal Large Language Models
| 2024-02-17T08:04:23 | 2024-02-17T08:04:23 |
Wenxuan Wang, Yihang Su, Jingyuan Huan, Jie Liu, Wenting Chen, Yudi Zhang, Cheng-Yi Li, Kao-Jung Chang, Xiaohan Xin, Linlin Shen, Michael R. Lyu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
The significant breakthroughs of Medical Multi-Modal Large Language Models
(Med-MLLMs) renovate modern healthcare with robust information synthesis and
medical decision support. However, these models are often evaluated on
benchmarks that are unsuitable for the Med-MLLMs due to the intricate nature of
the real-world diagnostic frameworks, which encompass diverse medical
specialties and involve complex clinical decisions. Moreover, these benchmarks
are susceptible to data leakage, since Med-MLLMs are trained on large
assemblies of publicly available data. Thus, an isolated and clinically
representative benchmark is highly desirable for credible Med-MLLMs evaluation.
To this end, we introduce Asclepius, a novel Med-MLLM benchmark that rigorously
and comprehensively assesses model capability in terms of: distinct medical
specialties (cardiovascular, gastroenterology, etc.) and different diagnostic
capacities (perception, disease analysis, etc.). Grounded in 3 proposed core
principles, Asclepius ensures a comprehensive evaluation by encompassing 15
medical specialties, stratifying into 3 main categories and 8 sub-categories of
clinical tasks, and exempting from train-validate contamination. We further
provide an in-depth analysis of 6 Med-MLLMs and compare them with 5 human
specialists, providing insights into their competencies and limitations in
various medical contexts. Our work not only advances the understanding of
Med-MLLMs' capabilities but also sets a precedent for future evaluations and
the safe deployment of these models in clinical environments. We launch and
maintain a leaderboard for community assessment of Med-MLLM capabilities
(https://asclepius-med.github.io/).
|
[
-0.5185607076,
-0.3172434866,
0.3790483773,
0.2794058323,
-0.0832406953,
0.2992965579,
-0.7361844182,
-0.6479341984,
-0.02634505,
0.611664176,
-0.4242650867,
-0.5615752339,
-0.6049547791,
0.1288202256,
-0.2519543171,
0.8862775564,
0.2224420607,
0.525660038,
-0.2459438145,
-0.4398560822,
-0.2399257571,
-0.508087337,
-0.5071663857,
-0.2456749231,
0.5099000931,
-0.0113668842,
0.5681009889,
0.2787504196,
0.7067340612,
0.2556093931,
-0.0831898451,
0.1840189248,
-0.0634873882,
0.1860559732,
-0.3243769407,
0.0645490587,
-0.5621604323,
0.020759074,
0.7900613546,
1.1001642942,
-0.2259428948,
0.3974079788,
0.0311006773,
0.8142104745,
-0.8215902448,
-0.0400462784,
-0.4192562401,
-0.1411221623,
-0.2305931449,
0.0454369299,
-0.3837908804,
-0.4267486036,
0.0463043042,
-0.5898420215,
0.012664156,
-0.1265542656,
0.665371716,
0.387745738,
-0.7303396463,
-0.2246209234,
-0.6117893457,
0.4553344548,
-0.4241983294,
0.5608126521,
0.2047838569,
0.8537474275,
-0.0082351863,
-0.776696384,
-0.130858928,
-0.4982934892,
0.3249517679,
0.2059724182,
-0.1665372699,
-0.1137305424,
0.0132556222,
0.2306683511,
-0.5521916747,
0.1711825579,
-0.7266300917,
-0.1421252191,
0.7064595222,
0.3347042203,
0.0999025032,
-0.0604918897,
-0.5308410525,
-0.0143506303,
-0.7646840811,
0.0692531988,
0.0779561549,
0.0738354549,
-0.0921655446,
0.4343753159,
-0.0671818033,
0.5178575516,
-0.3417509496,
0.205325827,
0.496607691,
-0.3466983736,
-0.2147492766,
-0.2158420384,
0.9243884683,
0.301289171,
-0.1184155643,
-0.1061832309,
0.047353901,
0.482234776,
0.6214655042,
-0.7656390071,
-0.3529312313,
0.257373929,
-0.6136935949,
-0.3921939135,
-0.104885079,
-0.7497084141,
-0.6078531146,
-0.1070541292,
0.2184385657,
-0.5914811492,
-0.436543256,
0.2309313864,
0.0624730885,
-0.4449369907,
0.3175396323,
-0.4430491328,
0.6981995702,
0.7995957732,
0.2793198526,
-0.4555960596,
-0.220767349,
-0.1570181698,
0.0166801233,
-0.4165299535,
0.837156713,
-0.9422466159,
-0.3758573234,
-0.1188805327,
-0.0350331627,
-0.204279229,
-0.8842998743,
0.7943482399,
-0.1845457703,
-0.0974630043,
-0.2126266062,
-0.5542424321,
-0.2949158251,
0.2234600484,
-0.573461175,
0.7794598341,
-0.1568279117,
-0.3776047826,
0.5445817709,
-0.8150504827,
-0.2830124199,
0.0949302316,
-0.476624161,
-0.5164294243,
0.201621756,
0.0393110439,
0.290558815,
-0.7792951465,
0.3302600384,
-0.6242489815,
0.0084561612,
0.7058769464,
-0.4390500188,
0.8265385628,
0.4797877967,
-0.0313554518,
0.4788974226,
-0.8573979735,
0.273430407,
-0.1473370492,
-0.3722088039,
-0.2081498504,
0.0667115375,
0.4220640659,
0.2756063938,
0.1046294719,
-0.568887949,
0.1215480119,
-0.109571211,
0.5624991059,
0.4294036925,
0.0248613358,
0.054779686,
-0.3512899578,
0.526249826,
-0.2195346206,
0.4745452702,
0.0363068283,
-0.5610979795,
-0.104448691,
-0.9391466975,
0.4657533765,
0.2070730031,
-0.4285641015,
0.5437128544,
-0.2206871212,
-0.8776639104,
-0.6668302417,
-0.1517706811,
0.5142323971,
0.2481873184,
0.2858557403,
-0.3864712119,
-0.1946177632,
-0.9583892822,
-0.3918561935,
0.1971460283,
-0.1700433791,
0.3622966111,
0.4702341259,
-0.5518324375,
0.2970377803,
-0.2917437851,
-0.2892710268,
-0.0430569947,
-0.1271085292,
0.2323663533,
0.5616719723,
0.345641017,
-0.5930589437,
-0.2614722848,
0.0559943542,
-0.633939147,
-0.1045142561,
0.2787698805,
0.2326832414,
-0.0196789987,
0.3431890011,
-0.4317540228,
0.1723170727,
0.9139072299,
-0.7724779248,
0.7272022963,
-0.6242013574,
0.3622878492,
-0.7358018756,
0.6746991873,
-0.1751469523,
-0.2233683169,
-0.4913921654,
0.4798925519,
0.3662805259,
-0.4025630951,
-0.0251628291,
0.4411494732,
-0.4566545784,
-0.2293877006,
-0.0641134605,
-0.0483288467,
-0.0615776815,
0.1313840002,
-0.0777372122,
0.1799217761,
0.7073255777,
-0.496556282,
0.1575203389,
0.0364471078,
-0.4187958837,
0.5795314908,
-0.4264146686,
-0.1718339324,
0.3220235109,
0.3588035405,
-0.721992135,
0.1524084955,
0.018953342,
-0.5953387618,
0.223581031,
-0.0789719224,
-0.7360522151,
-0.5992000699,
-0.2298493981,
0.6535744667,
0.4938401878,
-0.09980122,
0.4745903015,
0.5637516379,
0.0914667249,
-0.4203438461,
-0.1839707792,
-0.0282003041,
-0.1106209308,
-0.5674650073,
0.0630145818,
-0.3296021521,
-0.1829889268,
0.0108464835,
-0.2800152004,
-0.2472229153,
0.3476364613,
0.5858647823,
0.4951575696,
-0.3249736726,
0.2500648201,
0.0515242927,
-0.3851487935,
0.1390599012,
0.0157887749,
0.4089760482,
-0.2755866051,
-0.9017433524,
-0.2527672946,
0.2265889943,
1.0089342594,
-0.552754581,
0.2726101577,
0.5311763287,
-0.5838900805,
0.1042934731,
-0.7233883142,
-0.2375475615,
-0.3936075866,
0.534995079,
-0.308811307,
-0.637675643,
0.4787872136,
-0.1842504144,
0.1092654541,
0.494875282,
0.7511472106,
-0.1500481963,
0.7771798968,
0.1211262792,
0.2176153213,
-0.1024892256,
0.0038108074,
-0.2063344866,
-0.9361996651,
-0.2378311157,
-0.4281065464,
-0.2672151923,
-0.4894177914,
-0.8604488969,
0.8512395024,
-0.1466602832,
-0.3135098815,
-0.1337781847,
-0.6850643754,
0.0799552798,
0.1144859269,
0.2518258393,
0.4698494673,
-0.1304712147,
-0.1898488551,
-0.1662584841,
-0.4476245344,
-0.3652532399,
1.679816246,
0.6263964176,
0.5106032491,
0.116307497,
0.335142374,
0.1919178963,
0.5520707369,
-0.4532625675,
0.3865452707,
-0.5363050699,
-1.098706007,
-0.150406152,
-0.3000392616,
-1.1970857382,
0.6023638248,
-0.710605979,
-0.5761617422,
0.0404777266,
0.0299803279,
-0.671394527,
0.1983744651,
-0.3022623956,
1.0578848124,
-0.0933568701,
-0.1834014356,
-0.7348052263,
-0.6171147823,
0.2453560233,
-0.2068848461,
0.3977992833,
-0.5659823418,
-0.589394927,
0.5112388134,
-0.3220131993,
0.5984368324,
-0.1406501234,
0.3169511855,
-0.1262603998,
0.1676493585,
-0.0489238612,
0.0939464644,
0.0052088937,
0.4280388951,
0.3851555586,
-0.3478400111,
-0.3286849856,
0.5809218287,
-0.7328287959,
-0.0399185941,
-0.3866461813,
-0.4531832933,
-0.593223989,
0.2347391397,
0.2658626139,
0.771381855,
-0.2436464578,
0.3586345613,
0.6550884843,
-0.3600394726,
0.111832954,
0.9022902846,
-0.4072949886,
-0.5603222251,
0.8982824087,
-0.1345170736,
0.2180592269,
-0.0075334562,
0.2503408492,
-0.2504344881,
-0.7877620459,
-0.5962272286,
0.2591458559,
-0.4972732067,
-0.1222792938,
-0.6942164302,
-0.1261478364,
-0.0354622304,
-0.2137696296,
-0.9019073248,
-0.2681944072,
0.195778966,
0.4088701606,
0.0910545662,
0.7320760489,
0.0906689614,
-0.318254292,
-0.7974337935,
0.2283165008,
-0.0558054335,
0.4058076739,
-0.149827376,
-0.220203504,
0.0581422262,
-0.3223291934,
-0.2847375572,
-0.8107873797,
0.1968412399,
0.0285420995,
0.8718085885,
0.5795449018,
-0.0195767265,
0.3971912861,
-0.5869449973,
0.4741995037,
0.5083547831,
-0.8987846375,
0.2609115541,
-0.4480592608,
0.1611947566,
0.8461980224,
0.1721276939,
-0.4942505956,
-0.6429885626,
-0.771068573,
-0.872025609,
0.2427574098,
0.2659433484,
-0.3773160279,
0.1792073101,
-0.009761354,
0.2215331495,
0.4677219689,
-0.4982331395,
-0.348698318,
0.1070301458,
-0.2739936113,
-0.1512161195,
-0.0373932682,
-0.5080831647,
-0.4483380914,
0.3610694408,
-0.0669107437,
0.2254658937,
0.097321406,
-0.0187287517,
0.1508350223,
0.3806440234,
0.7730355263,
0.7999631763,
0.0381942354,
0.2677130401,
0.2645698786,
-0.6249471903,
-0.0403125323,
0.2417840958,
0.4625294805,
-0.1411557496,
0.4223947823,
0.0967286155,
0.5480434299,
-1.0786684752,
0.7513364553,
0.0072577763,
0.0405864045,
-0.4245255589,
-0.1518611759,
0.2420003265,
0.4211116135,
0.4010246098,
0.7543492317,
0.3291462362,
-0.5017116666,
0.3287620544,
0.4227969646,
-0.5941882133,
-0.3482071459,
0.7832401991,
0.3037732542,
0.1084889323,
0.3603930175,
-0.1059131846,
-0.2203087211,
0.6705806851,
0.3986229002,
0.6503683329,
-0.4674523473,
-0.213077873,
0.3751037717,
0.3550786078,
0.1060122102,
0.2305719554,
0.0021554453,
-0.4502979219,
-0.2575592697,
-0.4917327762,
-0.235517025,
-0.1485987902,
-0.9617805481,
0.2870257795,
-0.6893738508,
-0.4098411202,
0.3378262818,
0.0024990006,
-0.5772014856,
0.1409712732,
0.3897747695,
1.0487287045,
-0.7392001152,
1.0859905481,
0.8356211185,
-0.0574974082,
-0.4229724407,
-0.258538872,
0.0876199454,
-0.9242865443,
0.5844660401,
0.0752527192,
0.0596373379,
-0.4750292897,
0.0304267406,
-0.71355474,
0.9582617283,
0.4978545308,
-0.437384516,
0.1055194065,
-0.2157149911,
0.778821528,
-0.536634922,
0.2584778965,
0.3458597064,
0.50487113,
0.0220374707,
-1.4175109863,
0.3430939019,
-0.4696374834,
-0.1508258581,
0.0394327492,
-0.4655069411,
0.8314100504,
-0.2534421384,
-0.0782075226,
0.1844885796,
0.0812999383,
0.4792954028,
0.4289821982,
0.4308983684,
0.436180532,
0.8252410889,
-0.0895697102,
1.2112058401,
-0.6088963747,
0.3687369227,
0.9043439627,
-0.2761732042,
1.0524377823,
0.1728010327,
-0.2867057323,
0.3487394452,
0.4832562208,
-0.1869856417,
0.3780230582,
0.2204762399,
-0.316166997,
-0.4874686003,
0.1701426208,
-0.7692849636,
0.3167742193,
0.5655841827,
-0.4587783813,
-0.0558786653,
0.16471003,
-0.0113975704,
0.1215713993,
-0.4402051866,
0.58522439,
-0.0413931571,
-0.3994256258,
0.7105734348,
-0.1958403736,
0.3267280757,
-0.6845939755,
0.2872739732,
0.3758329749,
0.464659065,
-0.323530823,
-0.5323070884,
0.4329125285,
-0.2809996903,
-0.0315620229,
0.0933958367,
0.5424225926,
-0.2273367196,
-0.680441618,
0.3917354941,
0.2428412437,
0.0768689513,
-0.2369452417,
-0.7862358093,
0.3928720951,
-0.2840805352,
0.1250547618,
0.1922485381,
0.166320309,
0.0500142723,
0.9635588527,
0.5856369734,
0.3560809791,
-0.101700671,
-0.1299923956,
0.951589942,
-0.4895765781,
-0.4698111415,
-0.7955220938,
0.5482730269,
-0.1784570962,
-0.409750551,
0.6749665737,
0.9300714731,
0.2944765985,
0.0326347873,
0.590352118,
0.2004236579,
0.604388833,
-0.1901807338,
1.1647844315,
-0.6895397902,
0.2772620618,
-0.2167609036,
-0.5716862679,
-0.322804898,
0.4187402725,
-0.3778360486,
-0.1531107873,
0.9883081317,
0.2905040085,
-0.0164884198,
0.130182907,
0.5532360077,
0.216189906,
0.1622342616,
0.7001598477,
0.9083643556,
-0.1512898207,
0.4046085477,
0.1562841088,
-0.4003148973,
-0.2944042087,
-0.4084405601,
-0.9482678771,
-0.6384564042,
-0.421272397,
-0.3408749998,
0.1003403068,
1.1088535786,
0.8757907748,
-0.7328219414,
-0.2853126824,
0.333529979,
-0.1253609508,
-0.5582385063,
-0.0833754763,
0.3156697154,
-0.1016101092,
-0.284381777,
0.546051681,
0.5305358171,
-0.3798939288,
-0.4281792939,
0.1887748539,
0.3753132522,
-0.0629615262,
0.5509902239,
0.1522769481,
-0.8403159976,
-0.0231858417,
-0.374594599,
-0.3141703904,
0.0985240638,
1.0809223652,
-0.6251464486,
0.6271865368,
-0.0249453373,
0.6474743485,
0.4282513559,
-0.4887610674,
0.4396722913,
-0.1110964864,
0.0434640571,
0.656332314,
0.4263855815,
0.0967765301,
0.1204435304,
0.4261702597,
0.2098848969,
-0.4065703154,
-1.0485931635,
0.1029886603,
-1.1305841208,
-0.599440515,
1.1393973827,
-0.2378538102,
0.0068094498,
-0.3782190979,
-0.0195469819,
-0.1168900132,
-0.2960575819,
0.674906075,
0.1900330037,
-0.1751668155,
0.2688190341,
-0.8736270666,
0.5814373493,
0.3691766858,
-0.8740781546,
0.1095474735,
0.5025968552,
0.7365899086,
0.1644768119,
0.7146754861,
-0.5059692264,
0.5410984755,
0.056133233,
0.2947584987,
-0.2468334734,
-0.2000173628,
-0.3969072402,
0.5459802151,
0.0373480543,
-0.1795028746
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11208v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11208v1
|
Watch Out for Your Agents! Investigating Backdoor Threats to LLM-Based Agents
| 2024-02-17T06:48:45 | 2024-02-17T06:48:45 |
Wenkai Yang, Xiaohan Bi, Yankai Lin, Sishuo Chen, Jie Zhou, Xu Sun
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Leveraging the rapid development of Large Language Models LLMs, LLM-based
agents have been developed to handle various real-world applications, including
finance, healthcare, and shopping, etc. It is crucial to ensure the reliability
and security of LLM-based agents during applications. However, the safety
issues of LLM-based agents are currently under-explored. In this work, we take
the first step to investigate one of the typical safety threats, backdoor
attack, to LLM-based agents. We first formulate a general framework of agent
backdoor attacks, then we present a thorough analysis on the different forms of
agent backdoor attacks. Specifically, from the perspective of the final
attacking outcomes, the attacker can either choose to manipulate the final
output distribution, or only introduce malicious behavior in the intermediate
reasoning process, while keeping the final output correct. Furthermore, the
former category can be divided into two subcategories based on trigger
locations: the backdoor trigger can be hidden either in the user query or in an
intermediate observation returned by the external environment. We propose the
corresponding data poisoning mechanisms to implement the above variations of
agent backdoor attacks on two typical agent tasks, web shopping and tool
utilization. Extensive experiments show that LLM-based agents suffer severely
from backdoor attacks, indicating an urgent need for further research on the
development of defenses against backdoor attacks on LLM-based agents. Warning:
This paper may contain biased content.
|
[
-0.1697869301,
-0.8348699808,
0.5889533162,
-0.1762403399,
0.1735049635,
0.1200210229,
0.2627259195,
-0.7330177426,
-0.0355225839,
0.9988010526,
-0.6742005944,
-0.7279170156,
-0.3022595346,
-0.0656621754,
-0.4597298801,
0.8403519988,
0.1918471307,
-0.0386529043,
-0.147413224,
0.3044606447,
-0.4676008523,
-0.8563864231,
-0.6597517133,
-0.2285580486,
0.8829295635,
0.3650134504,
0.8330613375,
0.2663542926,
0.5051699281,
0.3770179152,
0.2988034785,
-0.270968914,
-0.487514019,
0.4579827487,
-0.3740317523,
-0.5495401025,
-0.6525119543,
0.0525196269,
0.0346553549,
0.0896105245,
-0.0115753431,
0.1364030838,
-0.1571059078,
0.573652029,
-0.7064873576,
-0.1402014792,
-0.7371699214,
0.0727808401,
-0.1721633226,
-0.4598624408,
-0.6732238531,
-0.383327812,
-0.2740590274,
-0.1486050189,
0.1149696484,
0.0371952243,
0.5415927768,
0.3767315745,
-0.4897625446,
-0.3168717921,
-0.4139890969,
0.3814228773,
-0.4547902346,
0.2052690089,
0.4016577303,
0.513686657,
-0.5489199758,
-0.519538343,
-0.3731076121,
-0.3771001697,
-0.1099904552,
0.1125228629,
-0.4127777815,
0.0496718325,
0.0909351856,
0.0959330052,
-0.7135017514,
0.3617790639,
0.0539635941,
-0.3472553492,
0.8497729897,
0.4257642329,
0.4172432125,
0.2430516332,
-0.4085730016,
-0.1904690862,
-1.1071308851,
-0.1597748101,
0.7599765658,
0.2256856561,
-0.0797622651,
0.7095201015,
-0.0332434475,
0.245010823,
-0.0646278039,
0.1251778901,
-0.1243029162,
-0.2859978676,
-0.10224206,
-0.044409927,
0.4765723348,
0.4607107341,
0.1708130836,
-0.4648056924,
-0.4286449254,
-0.1962060481,
0.5427529812,
-0.4910684824,
0.2707258761,
0.5481312275,
-0.2849119008,
-0.8269333243,
-0.0579042137,
-0.7701050043,
-0.511070013,
0.5300643444,
0.4429003298,
-0.0677272528,
-0.0650990531,
-0.2965763807,
0.0113984365,
0.5861115456,
0.2208526582,
-0.596811533,
0.4642781317,
0.9321147203,
0.573274672,
-0.1361938417,
-0.4534404278,
-0.6149680018,
0.5292080045,
-0.282797128,
0.7006645203,
-0.2791642845,
-0.6266880035,
0.2678456604,
0.1103048399,
0.0643480644,
-0.5504229665,
0.0962082595,
-0.9080902934,
0.0143581741,
-0.0607716218,
-0.187962696,
-0.1767742485,
0.641651392,
-0.6037658453,
0.599619031,
-0.0834078416,
-0.7733591795,
-0.0391342416,
-0.4234243035,
-0.457893461,
-0.0546463765,
-0.1104013994,
-0.262511611,
-0.0243299697,
-0.080687575,
0.388789922,
-0.1176483929,
-0.3164897859,
-0.3834244609,
-0.3061721623,
0.7612048984,
-0.4716998637,
0.6583234668,
0.0904214457,
-0.2291494608,
0.1792909354,
-0.4731957316,
-0.0457713008,
0.1553230286,
-0.1037065536,
-0.1033378094,
-0.1449875236,
-0.2025872916,
0.2352392823,
0.5474020839,
-0.5254493952,
0.1228491515,
-0.4411216378,
-0.0064029177,
0.9769610167,
0.3730711639,
0.3400865197,
-0.4375550449,
0.767683804,
0.0624698773,
0.5486100912,
-0.0633741543,
-0.4146897793,
-0.2066572905,
-0.0799271837,
-0.1323565543,
0.8039464951,
-0.7407274246,
0.3049043715,
0.3783535361,
-0.5986490846,
-0.0562185831,
-0.1255571246,
0.4629181921,
0.3688779175,
-0.0229763966,
-0.0984362215,
-0.0081219692,
-0.5746864676,
-0.4522645473,
-0.2094769925,
0.0684765577,
0.3149876893,
0.6642692685,
-0.7410261631,
0.8447380066,
-0.6111738682,
-0.1976172626,
-0.1439213455,
-0.4853286743,
0.0697628856,
0.5526522994,
0.6389626861,
-0.5494267344,
-0.2092552632,
-0.0413028859,
-0.7438467741,
-0.1350021362,
-0.0005505616,
-0.2375395298,
0.4354588091,
0.5153268576,
-0.9013748765,
0.7006217241,
0.3923054636,
-0.3237126768,
0.543130219,
-0.0185303427,
-0.3574040234,
-0.9491560459,
-0.1156212091,
-0.2134597749,
-0.2413518578,
-0.6921878457,
0.3050682843,
-0.1826332659,
-0.3909429312,
-0.6429246664,
0.6190610528,
-0.1792036295,
-0.3939258158,
-0.2519584596,
-0.114982456,
0.0167888142,
0.4063176811,
-0.2614722848,
0.8310526013,
0.6046202779,
-0.3528289795,
0.6833680272,
-0.0482272469,
0.2398130298,
0.1713669747,
-0.4494212568,
0.5422812104,
0.2266595215,
0.3735131025,
-0.8007705808,
-0.1667313576,
1.0094784498,
-0.6856456995,
0.5139211416,
-0.1090779305,
-0.5626744628,
0.0020537844,
-0.6980444193,
0.0577804185,
0.1674155146,
-0.4904078245,
0.6430843472,
0.3120507598,
-0.1003645435,
-0.7889939547,
-0.7287240028,
0.1703397185,
-0.3710958362,
-0.8144744635,
-0.203482762,
-0.080453679,
-0.62953192,
-0.0607454777,
-0.2727484703,
-0.0505604781,
0.4735643566,
0.4885014594,
0.1366298199,
-0.0938026458,
-0.1569490433,
-0.1616239548,
-0.4167320132,
0.4672747254,
-0.1472492069,
0.4342544973,
-0.0025283967,
-0.723284483,
-0.3657245338,
0.7108935714,
0.4844883084,
0.0187062826,
0.7925587296,
0.2097622752,
-0.2988000214,
-0.1913623214,
-0.473693341,
-0.5660758615,
-0.5758243799,
0.3338242769,
-0.3357238173,
-0.3351934254,
0.5762524009,
0.107867837,
0.0040529096,
0.0955839977,
0.613088131,
-0.0754123554,
0.8672876358,
0.7596688271,
-0.1160931513,
0.2739058435,
-0.2147219926,
0.0072994707,
-0.4143820107,
-0.4141420424,
-0.4191362858,
0.1273568869,
-0.8190549016,
-0.1177965701,
0.1516390294,
-0.4346843064,
-0.0779858902,
0.140775919,
0.0561668463,
0.4340593815,
0.3863961101,
0.1473893821,
0.3131650388,
-0.1737867594,
-0.0073706936,
0.3509447277,
-0.5044234991,
-0.5707750916,
1.1823413372,
0.585121572,
1.3066136837,
0.2970370948,
1.0042417049,
0.6088804007,
0.2871925533,
-0.6415243149,
0.6840949059,
0.2862367332,
-0.7033330202,
-0.3010767102,
-0.234943077,
-1.0719293356,
0.3194205761,
0.2589702606,
-0.7872501612,
0.1463781297,
-0.0063251806,
-0.0734684095,
0.1871572882,
-0.7195808887,
0.8487563729,
-0.5937124491,
-0.537556231,
-0.1321368366,
-0.7499645352,
0.211587429,
-0.2684311271,
0.1639828682,
-0.0757888705,
-0.0564204752,
0.2396160513,
-0.6527011991,
1.0844236612,
-0.0446754694,
-0.4774860442,
0.1966065466,
0.2430386245,
0.683606863,
0.3464746475,
0.0419500694,
0.3460463285,
-0.0372981653,
-0.476878494,
-0.4581800997,
0.6082465649,
-0.6124178767,
-1.0573072433,
-0.7638014555,
-0.4048808515,
-0.2096810639,
0.1811181307,
0.38236323,
0.1638238281,
-0.0099789286,
-0.2322820127,
0.3013709188,
-0.313016057,
0.4584912658,
0.8137993217,
-0.1046060398,
-0.1135557368,
0.8892276883,
-0.0581727289,
0.3877521753,
0.4260553122,
0.1999944448,
-0.2720388174,
-0.6953306198,
-0.2195913941,
0.2784712315,
-0.802352488,
-0.3079673946,
-0.2824476361,
-0.195993945,
-0.7439072728,
-0.0183708686,
-0.3406440616,
0.0675586239,
-0.2925026715,
-0.0582808293,
0.3801293671,
0.7845462561,
-0.194160983,
0.4144784212,
-0.8126848936,
0.0892405808,
0.345748961,
0.0911146998,
-0.0470505953,
-0.0112320501,
-0.4283491671,
-0.1584067494,
-0.4309656918,
-1.1979285479,
0.5641530752,
-0.4337840378,
0.7296647429,
0.4875829816,
0.2808975577,
-0.0456092618,
-0.2442045957,
0.5942099094,
-0.1189882457,
-0.6029424071,
0.4474926293,
-0.298591882,
-0.2661066353,
0.2821907401,
0.2009259164,
-0.374374181,
-0.5765860081,
-0.51435709,
-0.8993700743,
0.4808214307,
0.2491270006,
0.0168404765,
0.1108756661,
0.2033416182,
0.1898135543,
0.4735145271,
-0.5731293559,
-0.1384519935,
-0.0495427884,
0.2180966288,
0.018331008,
-0.219838202,
-0.3153535724,
0.4650725722,
0.597350657,
0.0118663767,
0.0024024101,
0.1142622456,
-0.2719854116,
-0.2555422783,
0.2844401896,
0.4596885443,
0.401363939,
-0.1923398972,
0.211682573,
0.1054669544,
-0.7106203437,
0.0916431323,
0.0988702774,
-0.1264370531,
-0.334064424,
0.4084301293,
-0.0131075121,
-0.0932107121,
-0.6993638873,
0.5497415066,
-0.2601391971,
0.3904893398,
-0.7426868677,
0.0368237421,
-0.2399976104,
0.6669521332,
0.3124328256,
-0.1874112189,
0.1379610896,
-0.8298174739,
0.1910464317,
0.6012628078,
-0.2664634585,
-0.3505225778,
0.2178011984,
0.3003626168,
-0.4587516487,
0.4067178667,
0.0889314339,
-0.6404384375,
0.8238298893,
0.5999047756,
1.2130875587,
-0.3146807849,
-0.1482315361,
-0.6408941746,
0.7044726014,
0.4033778906,
0.3100796938,
-0.002451705,
-0.8815437555,
0.0776335597,
-0.1789975166,
-0.8443835974,
0.1666362435,
-0.40596053,
-0.0174171329,
-0.4909213781,
-0.1489065588,
-0.4577057362,
0.1140365824,
-0.1855552942,
0.0428990386,
0.2759972811,
0.7788988352,
-0.6380445957,
0.7631473541,
0.4888481796,
-0.3618098497,
-0.3772897422,
0.4589567184,
0.2217429876,
-0.8469350338,
0.624794066,
0.181107536,
-0.5776849389,
-0.2497910112,
-0.664124608,
-0.5974817872,
0.9995059967,
0.3033943474,
-0.2651627064,
-0.0182457417,
0.2592916787,
0.3230805695,
-0.2985323966,
-0.0751248971,
0.5508770943,
0.462344259,
-0.0343878679,
-0.3605784178,
0.1939320862,
-0.1814555824,
-0.3646120727,
0.023186693,
-0.6849488616,
0.881711483,
-0.1789139509,
-0.1276487708,
0.1179465279,
0.2665434778,
0.3909953535,
1.0203639269,
0.161199972,
0.3671095967,
0.4206837714,
0.1885461062,
1.03980124,
-0.2259002477,
0.1025628,
0.9533295631,
-0.667221725,
0.5194667578,
0.4565095901,
0.0864698812,
0.1349015385,
0.6581220031,
-0.2521345317,
0.3065314889,
0.3115903437,
-0.2459816784,
0.0743088499,
0.0594260059,
-0.5843501091,
0.3852817714,
0.4300027192,
-0.1131764576,
-0.1599200517,
0.036803443,
0.2353210002,
-0.0703438297,
-0.3404205739,
0.6897659898,
0.1670836955,
-0.1229895055,
0.065555647,
-0.007133293,
0.4042699933,
-0.5948885679,
0.1168092266,
-0.3545516431,
0.252560854,
-0.3289049566,
-0.776101768,
0.2824314535,
0.0256533716,
0.088635698,
-0.1179997846,
0.965703249,
-0.0127273081,
-0.0340534337,
0.6696019173,
0.4486531913,
0.3612856567,
-0.3936011493,
-0.5197161436,
0.0378738716,
-0.3836007714,
-0.4673634171,
0.5221171975,
0.2714347243,
-0.0979615301,
0.9041326642,
0.7868555784,
0.157028839,
0.1426467597,
0.0335514732,
0.9620039463,
-0.9119004011,
-0.6752266288,
-1.0989204645,
0.1020839214,
-0.027904978,
0.2475476712,
0.9926097393,
0.5876258612,
0.6362390518,
-0.0353079475,
0.647344768,
0.5229181051,
0.3457961977,
-0.6287164688,
1.0408560038,
-0.4077885449,
0.6222388744,
-0.2791815698,
-0.5391435027,
-0.0145205716,
-0.1782481223,
-0.3279070258,
0.1349144727,
0.6087372899,
0.9996112585,
0.4649214149,
-0.154405728,
0.4077104032,
0.275978148,
0.5289164186,
0.4142230153,
1.2633947134,
-0.0848688409,
0.7409211397,
-0.2362989336,
-0.0259347111,
-0.4840781987,
-0.6030917764,
-1.0290648937,
0.0212740581,
-0.1419543177,
-0.6154900789,
0.3719822466,
0.455774039,
0.353561461,
-0.6245166063,
-0.341181308,
0.1110163406,
0.6754844189,
-0.0011691332,
-0.1906545013,
0.029251935,
-0.1051424816,
-0.2981747389,
0.4563432634,
0.2745409608,
0.154322058,
-0.4298732281,
0.019639384,
-0.0292804074,
0.1922646314,
0.2557182014,
0.4928409755,
-0.5462788939,
-0.3939873278,
-0.1804781407,
-0.3735767603,
-0.2039341033,
0.658750236,
-0.5535804033,
0.0133697083,
0.4323792458,
0.4745706022,
0.2134678066,
-0.0126680247,
0.6635497808,
-0.8131377697,
0.3281104863,
0.3669131398,
0.1821807325,
0.1172790378,
-0.9725679755,
0.4924862385,
0.2317164242,
-0.4436273873,
-0.9970733523,
0.7641470432,
-0.7542221546,
-0.4511021376,
1.0253384113,
-0.0975453258,
-0.6184230447,
-0.3083871901,
-0.1449380815,
0.1652835906,
-0.5771661401,
0.6821318865,
0.234911561,
-0.2630389035,
0.059655264,
-0.491891861,
0.3383080661,
-0.191560775,
-0.9488773346,
0.0140465181,
0.2585862577,
0.2895530462,
0.0993725359,
0.2866021991,
-0.1356775314,
0.4166444838,
0.269533664,
-0.1306093335,
-0.1963856965,
-0.3375312984,
-0.5309767127,
0.2635696828,
0.0289499555,
-0.6152724028
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12399v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12399v2
|
Turn Waste into Worth: Rectifying Top-$k$ Router of MoE
| 2024-02-17T06:23:27 | 2024-02-21T13:33:12 |
Zhiyuan Zeng, Qipeng Guo, Zhaoye Fei, Zhangyue Yin, Yunhua Zhou, Linyang Li, Tianxiang Sun, Hang Yan, Dahua Lin, Xipeng Qiu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Sparse Mixture of Experts (MoE) models are popular for training large
language models due to their computational efficiency. However, the commonly
used top-$k$ routing mechanism suffers from redundancy computation and memory
costs due to the unbalanced routing. Some experts are overflow, where the
exceeding tokens are dropped. While some experts are vacant, which are padded
with zeros, negatively impacting model performance. To address the dropped
tokens and padding, we propose the Rectify-Router, comprising the Intra-GPU
Rectification and the Fill-in Rectification. The Intra-GPU Rectification
handles dropped tokens, efficiently routing them to experts within the GPU
where they are located to avoid inter-GPU communication. The Fill-in
Rectification addresses padding by replacing padding tokens with the tokens
that have high routing scores. Our experimental results demonstrate that the
Intra-GPU Rectification and the Fill-in Rectification effectively handle
dropped tokens and padding, respectively. Furthermore, the combination of them
achieves superior performance, surpassing the accuracy of the vanilla top-1
router by 4.7%.
|
[
-0.6462548375,
-0.7379534245,
0.2284980267,
-0.1896000206,
-0.48097983,
0.1918524355,
-0.2185564637,
-0.0809977725,
0.1756635755,
0.4007139802,
-0.39924106,
0.0978058577,
-0.695643425,
-0.3101789057,
-0.4437144399,
0.9997930527,
0.3050108552,
-0.1022593752,
-0.2651840448,
-0.1214473099,
-0.8627673984,
-0.2664793134,
-0.8291806579,
-0.546005249,
0.5192346573,
0.4975960255,
0.6699635983,
0.6395365,
0.2312459797,
0.4505466819,
-0.1495452821,
0.2592621744,
-1.073920846,
-0.07977321,
-0.2468776107,
-0.3496074975,
-0.5090836287,
-0.3372223079,
0.4578620791,
0.6674048901,
-0.5640137792,
-0.1703995913,
-0.0511441194,
0.8495205641,
-0.8947370052,
-0.0504526272,
-0.8638268113,
-0.0752116516,
-0.482503593,
-0.4338981509,
-0.4313009381,
-0.2065037936,
-0.1327937245,
-0.7082921863,
0.4350796044,
0.1760289669,
0.8471018672,
0.57113868,
-0.1133536026,
0.1910058558,
-0.7286638021,
0.8687517643,
-0.7109605074,
0.6388916969,
0.3826173544,
0.3162855804,
-0.0535933636,
-0.2844031751,
-0.4021931291,
0.335757792,
-0.1427882314,
-0.00923735,
-0.440563798,
0.0511468872,
0.0094029428,
0.8020836711,
-0.1401821077,
-0.0622902885,
-0.690359056,
0.0273274817,
0.6820937395,
0.1472086012,
0.2969421148,
0.4127117097,
-0.2564221919,
0.085800156,
-0.9282550812,
-0.1611458063,
0.2736528814,
0.1748531461,
0.3266245425,
0.2975075245,
-0.2903651893,
0.5566962361,
0.5893244743,
-0.2113746405,
0.2607587278,
0.0777549297,
-0.3050733209,
0.0679022819,
0.2447350472,
0.2930592597,
0.3175753057,
-0.5983756185,
-0.2588563859,
-0.5686991811,
0.7520141006,
-0.8515511155,
-0.6783192158,
0.053171996,
-0.2628224194,
-0.1284395158,
-0.3845647573,
-0.6610361934,
-0.2269727737,
-0.3402086794,
0.547878921,
-0.3807065487,
-0.9135227203,
0.1929314733,
-0.0210284051,
0.0270581264,
0.4612801969,
-1.1588001251,
0.3261304796,
0.9595993161,
0.9004525542,
0.0005842699,
0.1183168739,
-0.4668967128,
0.0503238514,
-0.4521293342,
0.7017410398,
-0.3550118208,
-0.6696277261,
-0.1749316156,
-0.3565010726,
-0.2460126728,
-0.7595482469,
0.4847358465,
-0.6977965236,
0.0838112906,
-0.528208375,
-0.543717742,
-0.4444723129,
0.2851816118,
-0.5982824564,
1.0453106165,
0.1878399998,
-0.9182020426,
0.2660700083,
-0.486887902,
-0.3199281693,
0.3923079371,
0.0443817563,
-0.3504179418,
0.2319119424,
0.2513856888,
0.2870357931,
-0.1097795963,
0.2270599753,
-0.1362520456,
-0.4571425021,
-0.0514507666,
-0.4685851932,
0.6805667877,
0.3211794198,
-0.1586571038,
0.1144798398,
-0.9805064797,
-0.0056988546,
-0.0955714732,
-0.3569648862,
-0.5996373296,
-0.0192355942,
0.0562740043,
0.0462548435,
-0.0076348591,
-0.8445910215,
0.1776279807,
-0.5389920473,
0.7184592485,
1.0984482765,
-0.1639197469,
0.4379276037,
-0.3408662677,
0.216875121,
-0.0495575219,
-0.0332955644,
-0.0011534085,
-0.7484736443,
-1.114505291,
-0.5737514496,
0.1260859519,
0.4609622061,
-0.7097166181,
0.069540523,
-0.488448143,
-0.5533664227,
-0.8489398956,
0.0695393458,
0.5500300527,
0.840709269,
0.4435724318,
-0.2551209033,
-0.0801665187,
-0.7684919834,
-0.0952538699,
-0.1036989465,
-0.0349102989,
0.3737013936,
0.0993635729,
0.0329525582,
1.0164664984,
-0.5651465058,
-0.1919004321,
-0.0186168421,
0.0463799052,
0.1066935807,
0.853984952,
0.4502003789,
-0.6381593347,
-0.3057458401,
0.1246323362,
-0.2734387815,
0.0329152048,
0.2211025357,
-0.386423409,
0.135677889,
0.3889891505,
-0.85308218,
0.3666423559,
0.2062295824,
-0.037349537,
0.0837235823,
-0.2166203707,
0.3003906906,
-0.912786603,
0.1806817055,
-0.262181282,
-0.1787931323,
-0.4796493948,
0.3140922785,
-0.2382202744,
-0.2840982676,
-0.129419893,
0.7526558638,
-0.1649336368,
0.0776315406,
-0.2706435025,
-0.2890293002,
-0.0375023857,
0.6085005403,
-0.1574964374,
0.9018230438,
0.2771762013,
-0.5074683428,
0.2476549894,
-0.0432198532,
-0.1313271523,
0.6091652513,
-0.5760161877,
0.2905730605,
-0.251309514,
-0.1722091436,
-1.5036792755,
-0.2071674317,
0.3609357178,
-0.4998808503,
0.6075457335,
-0.4530047178,
-0.2821353078,
-0.2042082548,
-0.0264973175,
0.8314219713,
0.7535527349,
-0.5778734088,
0.6455513835,
0.5488305688,
-0.5760467649,
-0.7261453271,
-0.8298047781,
-0.0567647777,
-0.0271591749,
-0.5834851861,
0.3247252405,
-0.1262032241,
0.1524184346,
0.1172253564,
0.0191611685,
-0.332044214,
0.0888240337,
0.1769583821,
-0.0514364243,
-0.2792260051,
0.1365612447,
0.1607720107,
-0.5281437635,
-0.0386175327,
-0.2009262145,
0.6386175752,
0.0035139497,
-0.6574344635,
-0.4808112085,
0.4553774893,
0.7549797893,
-0.2057664394,
0.7316890955,
0.5669996738,
-0.6003829241,
0.2354339957,
-1.0388054848,
-0.1252868623,
-0.5182728171,
0.4213329554,
-0.4393001199,
-0.7389677763,
0.4860684872,
-0.0387478806,
0.5216889381,
0.4105860591,
0.4983232319,
0.0601064414,
0.7809002995,
0.6924760342,
-0.3437386751,
0.2642214298,
-0.2794144452,
0.6992320418,
-0.6667711735,
-0.4364626706,
-0.4158358574,
-0.3918398023,
-0.3174760044,
-0.3434488177,
0.2773952782,
0.3100040257,
-0.3378358185,
-0.0896974057,
-0.5614735484,
0.4899048507,
0.7710151672,
0.2167334408,
0.2028446347,
0.1833404303,
-0.1201769561,
-0.0563106462,
-1.1005791426,
-0.13996391,
0.8800227046,
0.3660601079,
0.8074206114,
-0.0193510167,
0.5363816023,
0.2378135324,
0.6313174367,
-0.5425873995,
0.5097030401,
-0.1252935827,
-0.4763414264,
-0.3742312491,
-0.4404728711,
-0.6866466999,
0.4547379613,
-0.1818358153,
-0.5039432645,
0.2527271509,
0.6381838322,
-0.4725010693,
1.1268781424,
-0.4542203248,
0.5843725204,
0.0857446119,
-0.2936060727,
-0.5160461664,
-0.0806576684,
0.4295055568,
0.114373982,
0.2401322275,
0.1418278664,
0.0359913372,
0.3686602116,
-0.8081977367,
0.6382552981,
-0.2545881867,
-0.2854370773,
0.0626314282,
0.16310139,
0.3962108791,
-0.2342128307,
-0.0055097654,
0.3547383845,
-0.6812261939,
-0.6264678836,
-0.485578686,
0.8737262487,
-0.9407842159,
-0.5692427158,
0.025679132,
-0.479124099,
-0.0224333834,
0.1379198879,
0.4406948388,
0.6711965799,
0.2444949001,
0.1616020799,
0.8922397494,
-0.1501736045,
0.3712158799,
0.2380368412,
0.0704007521,
-0.8763911724,
1.1062868834,
0.2757802904,
0.1983305663,
0.3480059803,
-0.0341236852,
-0.1085215434,
-0.7254627347,
-1.0500081778,
-0.0570149757,
-0.4276444614,
-0.3944444656,
-0.7022535205,
-0.3702447414,
-0.0786201283,
-0.4531268775,
-0.9324664474,
-0.4357711971,
-0.2094006538,
-0.25551036,
0.4670587182,
0.5125145912,
-0.0881505534,
0.5853464603,
-0.7371096015,
0.0401303358,
0.3484422863,
0.5875071883,
0.6911905408,
-0.6107144952,
-0.3666346073,
0.0057528596,
-0.3266063333,
-0.3666061759,
0.3354450762,
-0.0151757477,
0.5785787702,
0.835129261,
-0.0561862439,
1.081389308,
-0.7013152838,
0.5915955901,
0.2370445877,
-0.6894724965,
0.1174275875,
-0.3059914112,
0.0653073713,
0.4932860732,
0.3438320756,
-0.4408102036,
-0.3469413519,
-0.4224337041,
-1.1491856575,
0.6519700289,
0.3069916666,
0.1668703407,
-0.171492666,
0.4502666593,
0.2409565449,
0.2564095259,
-0.3656251729,
-0.3565453291,
-0.2922561765,
-0.1262121052,
0.1817538589,
-0.45423311,
-0.057378687,
-0.2000737935,
0.9772161841,
0.3876523376,
0.2867032886,
-0.1168347448,
-0.0237362403,
-0.5322082043,
0.3309521675,
0.6892663836,
0.9198310375,
-0.2989072502,
-0.2199397087,
0.2401639521,
-0.2499457151,
0.0946639627,
-0.0728477314,
-0.5348635316,
0.1392299831,
0.2350964695,
0.8120714426,
0.5006347299,
-0.317273587,
0.4101321697,
0.1776167452,
-0.0652493685,
-0.0046885675,
0.0948658735,
0.0238588266,
-0.0300316215,
0.6245965958,
0.5329417586,
0.228465274,
-0.0980203748,
0.1564659029,
0.4315961599,
-0.1390399933,
-0.0994982943,
0.6353516579,
0.7715085745,
-0.5005751848,
1.0400283337,
-0.0016495415,
-0.6483457088,
0.2597551346,
0.3522443771,
0.8586748242,
-0.1855659783,
-0.2488193214,
0.6582479477,
0.1788801849,
0.061257422,
0.0074463109,
-0.0890084207,
-0.5109346509,
-0.6613385677,
-0.3492582142,
-0.172120437,
0.1028578132,
-0.8815487027,
-0.1067877114,
-0.3695468605,
-0.1518587023,
-0.4493474662,
-0.3394395709,
-0.5195703506,
0.1373282522,
0.1118264571,
0.819265008,
-0.8135777116,
0.4874024689,
0.5541858077,
-0.2975757718,
-0.454731673,
-0.3064401746,
-0.206127286,
-0.834949851,
0.704667449,
0.0298391562,
-0.2538377643,
0.1042724922,
-0.1332364082,
-0.9144587517,
0.9542768598,
0.2984882295,
-0.8191657066,
-0.0045816521,
0.0732988268,
0.1596936882,
0.1188543588,
0.5706045032,
-0.0741327703,
0.0847144052,
0.1593670249,
-1.1691009998,
0.0004514848,
-0.4253358245,
0.0392958932,
0.6049082279,
-1.1184383631,
1.2873049974,
-0.2019061297,
-0.2962002754,
0.2035357952,
0.7290373445,
0.3315053284,
0.3170585334,
0.6414546967,
1.278798461,
0.8938624263,
-0.0479601771,
0.830277741,
-0.3991045952,
0.4587094486,
0.8100627065,
0.1789672226,
0.9942178726,
0.3907271922,
-0.1656026989,
0.4569882154,
0.5393291712,
0.4378973246,
0.9412226677,
0.3640388846,
-0.3507420421,
-0.4968503416,
0.3643011451,
-0.7244704962,
-0.0418772846,
0.2461136431,
0.0236632619,
-0.6311739683,
0.1698732823,
0.3187076151,
-0.2164594829,
-0.8217381239,
0.7394373417,
-0.1795484573,
-0.7129488587,
0.6697363257,
0.2082219124,
0.7709217668,
-0.3552493751,
-0.1873244047,
-0.5979194045,
0.4626107514,
-0.1341676116,
-0.6411866546,
0.1635727286,
-0.0537429154,
-0.4014267623,
-0.3463729918,
0.818189621,
-0.6429942846,
-0.5490105152,
-0.0459344573,
0.2025746405,
0.3811365664,
-0.1568575054,
-0.3838817179,
-0.0938111991,
-0.1735496819,
-0.0178195927,
0.437833041,
0.5878276229,
0.1419317573,
1.0868939161,
0.6346957684,
0.0652647465,
0.3809672594,
-0.0037581301,
1.2401554585,
-0.4028848112,
-0.535336256,
-0.8770547509,
0.6408230066,
0.0001450887,
-0.382363528,
0.3133664727,
0.8365688324,
1.1598316431,
-0.2079744637,
0.5264773965,
0.1766923517,
0.4568988383,
-0.608150661,
0.9904372096,
-0.6295145154,
0.1540535241,
-0.1166400164,
-0.6036674976,
0.0503186584,
0.7772094607,
0.0332186818,
0.1075048447,
0.0132166641,
0.7105518579,
-0.3980932236,
-0.1007442772,
0.331997782,
0.1213243082,
0.2465224862,
0.6725104451,
0.4808499813,
-0.3875955045,
0.5727050304,
-0.2649557292,
-0.289753288,
-0.5396745205,
-0.7341505885,
-0.8264312148,
-0.3217725456,
-0.5460912585,
-0.0851241872,
0.2023720741,
0.7619039416,
1.165128231,
-0.7967758179,
0.1028952226,
-0.1636618227,
0.0972072631,
-0.1237457693,
-0.2854092419,
0.4329472482,
-0.4401988089,
-0.6329076886,
-0.0079828147,
0.3428576887,
-0.3924658597,
-0.3847812116,
-0.1303216815,
-0.0644484013,
0.066687718,
0.6637999415,
0.2558622062,
-0.9856759906,
-0.319368273,
-0.2846485674,
0.0820560753,
0.1815011501,
0.9188030362,
-0.7964775562,
0.4941758513,
0.6314326525,
1.3177288771,
0.3372610211,
0.157057777,
0.5276914835,
-0.7209628224,
-0.1697652042,
0.04555678,
0.4415296614,
0.321089983,
-0.5611067414,
0.5316072106,
0.4513634443,
-0.5939611793,
-0.8575784564,
-0.1545282751,
-0.9210740328,
-0.0594126619,
0.7772257924,
-0.3435474336,
-0.0450876392,
-0.1723121107,
-0.4339937568,
0.0208605565,
-0.5564473867,
0.9218419194,
1.0080554485,
-0.0133473333,
-0.5161320567,
-0.4977585375,
0.1583558619,
0.5754498839,
-0.4457955062,
0.1229438484,
0.4651278853,
0.6759067178,
0.2607265413,
1.0407482386,
0.0048392634,
0.1501698941,
0.0487963222,
0.0537257642,
-0.5969865322,
-0.2683390975,
0.1823593676,
0.178831473,
-0.0110080028,
-0.6603196263
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11203v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11203v1
|
Exploring ChatGPT for Next-generation Information Retrieval: Opportunities and Challenges
| 2024-02-17T05:44:40 | 2024-02-17T05:44:40 |
Yizheng Huang, Jimmy Huang
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The rapid advancement of artificial intelligence (AI) has highlighted ChatGPT
as a pivotal technology in the field of information retrieval (IR).
Distinguished from its predecessors, ChatGPT offers significant benefits that
have attracted the attention of both the industry and academic communities.
While some view ChatGPT as a groundbreaking innovation, others attribute its
success to the effective integration of product development and market
strategies. The emergence of ChatGPT, alongside GPT-4, marks a new phase in
Generative AI, generating content that is distinct from training examples and
exceeding the capabilities of the prior GPT-3 model by OpenAI. Unlike the
traditional supervised learning approach in IR tasks, ChatGPT challenges
existing paradigms, bringing forth new challenges and opportunities regarding
text quality assurance, model bias, and efficiency. This paper seeks to examine
the impact of ChatGPT on IR tasks and offer insights into its potential future
developments.
|
[
-0.3342725635,
-0.6863829494,
0.5155056119,
-0.121209383,
0.0214541927,
0.3629088998,
0.121425651,
-0.559864521,
-0.151154384,
0.1787448525,
-0.3690464199,
-0.2209457457,
-0.6508327723,
0.036920879,
-0.6909223199,
1.2293992043,
0.0890954733,
-0.2589477003,
-0.1030600145,
0.2103013396,
-0.6152701974,
-0.9544816017,
-0.755010426,
-0.3394647837,
0.2666090429,
0.4258187711,
0.8128005862,
0.0396337621,
1.0574575663,
0.2457243055,
0.0715349019,
-0.0940285102,
-0.388576597,
0.2254620641,
0.2104631811,
-0.4589893222,
-0.1947690547,
0.2156987935,
0.6308004856,
0.3054665923,
-0.241307646,
-0.1313585788,
0.1644672453,
0.8701357245,
-0.4360952377,
0.5336912274,
-0.8949253559,
0.2467335314,
-0.5191745758,
-0.3932777941,
-0.37423262,
-0.5648503304,
0.6402127743,
-0.663749516,
0.3891844153,
0.152853027,
1.0621805191,
0.249532938,
-0.3908786476,
-0.3749304414,
-0.6523313522,
0.4637426734,
-0.3897322416,
0.5715132356,
0.2829422057,
0.5791524649,
-0.2944973409,
-1.0462965965,
-0.6392026544,
-0.1852885038,
0.1608445495,
0.2967946529,
-0.1164772511,
-0.0284704808,
-0.0845166221,
0.49336496,
-0.7083070278,
-0.1693124175,
-0.2361446768,
0.0627242997,
0.293327719,
-0.0663763434,
0.2978865504,
-0.1610510051,
-0.4003420174,
-0.0936437696,
-0.7166659236,
-0.2977361083,
0.3909142911,
0.1967650056,
0.5086487532,
0.7595447898,
-0.3320430517,
0.2317304909,
-0.2944895923,
0.3282346129,
0.3172799945,
-0.2993820906,
0.1299194247,
-0.0175573882,
0.6788876057,
0.1583547294,
0.0058978815,
-0.1445558369,
-0.1463301331,
-0.2179192752,
0.2056575567,
-0.742082119,
-0.4333279133,
-0.1235027015,
-0.5839958191,
-0.1654622108,
0.1658796817,
-0.9527431726,
-0.5372536778,
-0.0719165578,
0.5610517263,
-0.7066889405,
-0.3243335485,
-0.1418587118,
-0.4239417613,
0.644076705,
0.5675905943,
-1.0116846561,
0.1249383986,
0.9716163278,
0.9496995211,
-0.2362639904,
-0.0102547845,
-0.2806411386,
-0.0529892296,
-0.0940871909,
1.1199762821,
-0.7408468723,
-0.4535770416,
-0.1091668233,
-0.5430454612,
-0.2699007988,
-0.6031220555,
0.5014042854,
-0.7940401435,
0.3252991438,
-0.0576697066,
-0.472643584,
-0.2847700715,
0.5295603871,
-0.5685206056,
1.1365913153,
0.135818094,
-0.7694433928,
0.3793930709,
-0.6720380187,
-0.34132424,
0.5208507776,
-0.3729976416,
-0.5096637011,
-0.0720316321,
-0.006031929,
0.0086700441,
-0.3671772778,
0.074796468,
0.089713268,
-0.3651969135,
0.2525416315,
-0.8445314765,
0.2951380014,
0.3163340092,
-0.3382848501,
-0.3333714902,
-0.4201779664,
0.1472529918,
0.0334247276,
-0.4265050888,
-0.0510157645,
0.3483427167,
0.0789337903,
0.0379736833,
0.3621455133,
-0.388217032,
0.344825238,
0.0803099126,
0.715477407,
0.6488521695,
0.1848507971,
0.0978301987,
-0.3276944458,
0.5910214186,
-0.2959536612,
0.4167028069,
-0.3964158297,
-0.9364694357,
-0.529949069,
0.1742231995,
0.489507854,
0.7711607218,
-0.8319353461,
-0.050186675,
-0.3048805296,
-0.5251703858,
-0.5088533759,
-0.2419985086,
0.1091749892,
0.3319955468,
0.3480651975,
-0.3486813605,
-0.3975697756,
-0.6505925655,
-0.2173306495,
-0.5537310243,
-0.0021520955,
0.5215352178,
0.2660523355,
-0.2036545724,
1.0428489447,
-0.3204920292,
-0.6392638087,
-0.2988343835,
0.397514075,
0.258751452,
0.48475945,
0.0576507561,
-1.5852328539,
-0.5338647962,
0.3205960989,
-0.7131010294,
0.179834336,
-0.0599963404,
-0.1619338393,
0.0262098406,
0.5089346766,
-0.7454223633,
0.3487261534,
0.1942563802,
-0.030964449,
0.4512464106,
0.0211587045,
0.4878460169,
-0.754093647,
0.1973894536,
-0.1534814984,
0.0499018654,
-0.5847892165,
-0.1723044366,
-0.0701059699,
-0.4769824147,
-0.1433112323,
0.2486449629,
-0.3344728351,
-0.173943758,
-0.0777920187,
0.250588268,
-0.0848197713,
0.0951976851,
-0.1680876762,
1.0927057266,
0.0827439651,
-0.4054043591,
0.0944242626,
0.6052422523,
-0.1966048032,
0.319588393,
-0.5717058182,
0.252576679,
-0.1862548441,
0.1887920648,
-0.6834815741,
-0.2731987536,
0.1764350832,
-0.8247366548,
0.2568127513,
-0.2075776458,
-0.609533906,
-0.3543615937,
-0.1777606755,
0.4223560095,
0.7342358828,
-0.4685516357,
0.6251301169,
0.4548219442,
-0.4279524386,
-0.6503320932,
-0.406938225,
0.3456686139,
-0.1068668291,
-0.4819431305,
0.4817900062,
-0.1134625897,
-0.099074319,
0.0475317799,
-0.1783402562,
-0.1333470494,
0.0470715202,
0.0032545561,
0.3921323121,
-0.1603056788,
0.1620246023,
-0.3043994308,
-0.3111227155,
-0.2453835458,
-0.5559184551,
0.7168573141,
-0.2955576777,
-0.6135524511,
-0.4800645709,
0.3366214335,
0.1312548965,
-0.4492294788,
0.3956202865,
0.6515294313,
-0.0317233205,
0.3391010463,
-0.7015632987,
-0.0448257923,
-0.5033768415,
0.522898674,
-0.1317261159,
-0.8108659983,
0.2770863771,
-0.1508137584,
0.0348047465,
0.3926516473,
0.1739735752,
-0.1392520964,
1.0087188482,
0.7110623121,
-0.0824976489,
0.9068863392,
-0.1287612766,
0.6044313312,
-0.6745525599,
-0.6010488272,
-0.6885411143,
0.0410930105,
-0.8369835615,
-0.1740263402,
0.6475436687,
0.0070893634,
-0.2574492097,
-0.1261432618,
-0.57156533,
0.4724978209,
1.0941039324,
0.1478296518,
0.5668284297,
-0.1777049303,
0.5180102587,
0.188644588,
-0.6107135415,
-0.4574044049,
0.9180324078,
0.074328512,
0.7781922817,
0.1339175105,
0.5427185297,
0.6315646768,
0.2355467379,
-0.7065159678,
0.5052089691,
-0.1887773424,
-0.5539982319,
-0.1928023398,
-0.4091182351,
-1.0571585894,
0.2311134487,
-0.0358993523,
-0.6410791874,
-0.0447345152,
0.1926468313,
0.015779769,
0.1952906996,
-1.0039532185,
0.711890161,
-0.2641451359,
-0.1841038316,
0.0400684923,
-0.741813004,
-0.0590917803,
-0.0006533987,
-0.0695829988,
-0.1970806867,
-0.0394497439,
0.5895399451,
-0.0148275364,
0.4321135283,
0.0042906627,
0.2324577421,
0.3838462532,
-0.1043935046,
0.4728480577,
-0.0363792293,
-0.2989675105,
0.1253982335,
-0.1058270335,
-0.3473547101,
-0.5999812484,
0.3532425761,
-0.6933537126,
-0.8788437843,
-0.6302390695,
-0.457891345,
-0.1159541458,
0.5198501348,
0.3299957812,
0.2789649069,
-0.175852567,
0.2009350955,
0.7238593102,
-0.3833855391,
0.3422291875,
0.2201425731,
-0.0255771857,
-0.0660567135,
1.291810751,
0.0150133502,
0.2919114828,
0.6080951095,
-0.1037377119,
-0.1513442397,
-0.8606114984,
-0.1282127649,
-0.2752534449,
-0.5971824527,
-0.3716102839,
-0.8083024025,
-0.5064556003,
-0.4240064621,
0.2628888786,
-0.3184351325,
-0.2265094072,
-0.1137843505,
0.1808235198,
0.2925477922,
0.8716831207,
0.1879828125,
0.2015175372,
-0.8293994069,
0.0241628382,
0.2429633737,
0.5257578492,
-0.1854123026,
-0.0229475964,
-0.1916739643,
-0.0967069864,
-0.6099871993,
-0.5407652259,
0.3735758662,
0.3706137538,
0.5854070187,
-0.0000801757,
0.0550845675,
0.3055801392,
-0.6586717963,
0.9778099656,
-0.2332457751,
-0.5133712888,
0.60242033,
-0.4891424179,
0.124870792,
0.5792084336,
0.5128312707,
-0.9408866763,
-0.1614114791,
-0.6820247769,
-1.1756286621,
0.5029155612,
0.5526478291,
0.2123098671,
-0.0563921817,
0.3511285186,
0.3426401615,
0.2712132335,
-0.5966064334,
0.1101722941,
-0.2862627804,
-0.1807948351,
0.337405175,
-0.1672967672,
0.4737345576,
0.2145243138,
1.0394831896,
-0.1381665319,
0.8227272034,
0.2011024505,
0.0243585911,
0.4768866897,
0.3137448132,
-0.0438898131,
0.2533737719,
-0.2055529654,
-0.1866014898,
-0.2373869568,
-0.7296372652,
-0.2004115283,
0.5870959163,
-0.2878935635,
-0.0923270434,
0.1744563431,
0.5753100514,
-0.2035742104,
-0.6795740128,
0.5751629472,
-0.2822731137,
-0.049268309,
-0.6035191417,
0.1418023258,
-0.5011540055,
0.5487602353,
0.9556215405,
0.0394355915,
0.4448823929,
-0.5552458763,
0.2321018577,
0.6330845952,
-0.3496920764,
0.0179018024,
0.8058211803,
0.0222409721,
-0.3175888956,
1.1478275061,
-0.0167715289,
-0.7268006802,
0.4791682661,
0.3251686692,
0.6361531019,
-0.1032514945,
0.1760147363,
-0.0388241112,
0.2468979061,
-0.1158949807,
0.0773075074,
-0.1562794894,
-0.5971378088,
-0.0517766736,
-0.3451038599,
-0.8417122364,
-0.0959913135,
-0.3648972213,
0.2227718085,
0.0165311117,
-0.1753624231,
-0.1867958456,
-0.0776702538,
-0.5249775052,
-0.1114437953,
-0.0373180546,
0.6663105488,
-0.2130105495,
0.6214457154,
0.3449163437,
-0.6881895065,
-0.4167935848,
0.3814476728,
0.0692807361,
-0.9058088064,
0.6055259705,
0.399477005,
0.2241379619,
0.3289651275,
-0.2284876555,
-1.0126070976,
1.1676213741,
0.1100522354,
-0.1427257359,
-0.4625557065,
0.2487636209,
0.4184701145,
0.2067198455,
0.590098083,
0.5381752849,
0.4505764842,
0.1677859128,
-0.8132688403,
-0.4832215309,
-0.545265913,
0.1638906598,
0.4342471063,
-0.7091878653,
1.0020048618,
-0.0913965106,
-0.4498044848,
0.3278039396,
0.6626085639,
-0.0146701913,
0.2308030277,
0.1595648229,
0.0893954262,
0.7681071162,
-0.3585117757,
1.2354828119,
-0.0349526592,
0.3077989221,
0.8660008907,
-0.1980015486,
0.8142383695,
0.3625653982,
-0.1539893299,
0.4053587914,
0.7590312362,
-0.226364553,
0.4468584955,
-0.1194535345,
-0.6753904819,
0.1458041072,
-0.3379011154,
-0.5431668162,
0.4086512923,
0.5375813246,
-0.1418762058,
-0.1366715729,
0.2333200276,
-0.2055619955,
-0.1482782215,
-0.0939232111,
0.9606140852,
-0.2504946291,
-0.7587183714,
-0.0752889961,
-0.3924010098,
0.5815056562,
-0.5545047522,
-0.4530691504,
-0.251254946,
0.2909396589,
-0.0536892153,
-0.9541286826,
0.0185830779,
-0.1830722243,
0.2217736989,
-0.2625425458,
0.7629131675,
-0.1026753858,
-0.1119161621,
-0.0236179177,
0.4741180539,
0.2361335158,
-0.3254164159,
-0.5704455972,
-0.0833176747,
0.0474075899,
-0.360356003,
0.4097347558,
0.7394978404,
0.047974892,
0.8158450723,
0.4976026714,
-0.2487974167,
0.2633207142,
-0.067895785,
0.8296688795,
-0.5802253485,
-0.3288309276,
-0.6342720389,
0.0999738723,
-0.0458961762,
-0.133845821,
0.6221315265,
0.637579143,
0.9995126128,
0.4290373921,
1.1154824495,
-0.5632030964,
0.3283830881,
-0.4977246821,
0.5892668962,
-0.3159067929,
0.3551383615,
-0.2221299708,
-0.7724494338,
-0.3319001794,
0.3384211659,
-0.2135564089,
0.2320035249,
0.6460067034,
0.6579203606,
0.2126125097,
0.5031651855,
0.0796174631,
0.0004960832,
0.8028348088,
0.4797711074,
1.0753986835,
-0.5422047973,
1.1123790741,
0.0608255006,
-0.26788643,
-0.1798283011,
-0.6445099115,
-0.428763628,
-0.920455873,
0.0187161397,
-0.1483177841,
0.3685299754,
0.7485806942,
0.5004392266,
-0.6133028865,
0.2095243037,
-0.3232248724,
0.0315135866,
-0.1064714044,
-0.2961386144,
0.3343021274,
-0.733751893,
-0.7339118123,
0.0710358173,
0.2637285292,
0.2377071679,
0.2160500735,
0.1787529737,
-0.4039228559,
-0.5007358193,
0.6833508611,
0.4105153382,
-0.1558384001,
-0.2797189057,
-0.0213042311,
-0.0311405379,
0.4187783003,
0.8857320547,
-1.0038158894,
0.1790264249,
0.3470738828,
1.1659729481,
0.7686824203,
0.0397858582,
0.7834153771,
-0.436389178,
-0.1139971688,
0.4468230307,
-0.0242710114,
0.4018189311,
-0.5853760839,
0.9025911093,
0.2164117694,
-0.9772980809,
-0.5561488271,
0.0730513856,
-0.7831142545,
0.0044132834,
0.9371440411,
0.0847960711,
0.098769471,
-0.2752180099,
-0.5396440029,
0.3143606186,
-0.5897034407,
0.9316344857,
0.4324642122,
-0.6487927437,
-0.4161869884,
-1.1561141014,
0.5124316216,
0.4844722748,
-1.0214194059,
0.0298656728,
0.3316675723,
-0.2943306863,
-0.0000150072,
0.629916966,
-0.4299159944,
0.2462836057,
0.0829896182,
-0.0088299131,
0.1714290828,
-0.1891357154,
0.1637895107,
0.1822493225,
0.2733520567,
-0.1863261908
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11199v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11199v2
|
Direct Evaluation of Chain-of-Thought in Multi-hop Reasoning with Knowledge Graphs
| 2024-02-17T05:22:56 | 2024-06-19T05:14:05 |
Minh-Vuong Nguyen, Linhao Luo, Fatemeh Shiri, Dinh Phung, Yuan-Fang Li, Thuy-Trang Vu, Gholamreza Haffari
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) demonstrate strong reasoning abilities when
prompted to generate chain-of-thought (CoT) explanations alongside answers.
However, previous research on evaluating LLMs has solely focused on answer
accuracy, neglecting the correctness of the generated CoT. In this paper, we
delve deeper into the CoT reasoning capabilities of LLMs in multi-hop question
answering by utilizing knowledge graphs (KGs). We propose a novel
discriminative and generative CoT evaluation paradigm to assess LLMs' knowledge
of reasoning and the accuracy of the generated CoT. Through experiments
conducted on 5 different families of LLMs across 2 multi-hop question-answering
datasets, we find that LLMs possess sufficient knowledge to perform reasoning.
However, there exists a significant disparity between answer accuracy and
faithfulness of the CoT reasoning generated by LLMs, indicating that they often
arrive at correct answers through incorrect reasoning.
|
[
-0.3729941249,
-1.0383486748,
1.0292537212,
0.1359330416,
-0.2237394005,
0.6621974707,
-0.1539786458,
-0.2631861269,
-0.0133568253,
0.3452177048,
-0.4787248671,
-0.6274636984,
-0.7461179495,
0.392183274,
-0.2721680701,
0.6409484744,
-0.3418184817,
-0.1272925884,
-0.4108458757,
-0.1106287539,
-0.5712466836,
-0.4096339643,
-0.5314090848,
-0.2635399103,
0.7349236608,
0.1384323239,
0.7813915014,
0.2759770453,
0.3300887048,
0.2633315921,
-0.2388757765,
0.8358816504,
-0.4555307925,
0.1385568082,
-0.2040233612,
-0.4344492257,
-0.498767972,
-0.108610779,
0.5546808243,
0.7954614758,
0.2032440901,
0.2048312277,
-0.0664095432,
0.8485539556,
-0.8121647835,
-0.0516239032,
-0.9334397912,
0.0437412784,
0.1040825397,
-0.3110516071,
-0.7978802919,
-0.7146690488,
0.0426818393,
-0.4256381691,
-0.074791722,
0.1524832547,
0.4958121479,
-0.0219719131,
-0.7487285137,
-0.6087735891,
-0.6994799376,
0.4258650839,
-0.4638652205,
0.5498571396,
0.2392253727,
0.3834552467,
-0.4505608678,
-0.6394985914,
-0.717271328,
-0.0560526438,
-0.1195683703,
0.0975530446,
-0.093215771,
0.1311451346,
0.2922418416,
0.2617768943,
-0.5152993798,
-0.2411933392,
-0.164871946,
-0.0804024339,
0.5480083227,
0.1829480827,
0.0798384771,
0.0083385203,
-0.5041326284,
-0.1122614592,
-0.494360745,
-0.0645101219,
0.234284088,
0.2515563071,
0.0867245346,
0.6088329554,
-0.0848471373,
1.1255232096,
0.083795853,
-0.2767097056,
0.2640229762,
-0.275265038,
-0.2464507818,
-0.1595318168,
0.8799782991,
0.1956122518,
0.5521916151,
-0.3967583179,
0.0072758417,
0.0334681012,
0.298936069,
-0.3270713985,
-0.0344655663,
0.3725533187,
-0.2154075354,
-0.3648706675,
0.0090226801,
-0.7315542102,
-0.4835604727,
0.0177055616,
0.3532124758,
-0.4106651545,
-0.2875680923,
0.237957418,
-0.4473315179,
0.1934226155,
0.3094407022,
-0.258246839,
0.1717179567,
0.5963431001,
0.7023923397,
0.0084890993,
-0.3903202713,
-0.5193083882,
0.2821894586,
-0.7847798467,
0.7808656693,
-0.5740219355,
-0.1188236624,
-0.1438900381,
-0.2575087249,
-0.4140755236,
-0.3843360245,
0.3985552788,
-1.0485504866,
-0.3674970269,
-0.5435982943,
-0.7160039544,
-0.1038941145,
0.5738555789,
-0.5071349144,
0.8012871146,
0.1362731606,
-1.0870456696,
0.4161295891,
-0.4064537287,
-0.4298286736,
0.0621352792,
-0.2883683145,
-0.0959007367,
-0.2144912332,
0.4460918605,
0.3245025575,
-0.2576556504,
0.3761351109,
-0.5232433081,
-0.288323462,
0.5748885274,
-0.4714176059,
0.8511770368,
0.2540207803,
-0.1740068644,
-0.0811015218,
-0.6109858155,
0.3784194887,
0.3164096475,
-0.2792847157,
-0.2940613329,
-0.022618372,
-0.9608377218,
0.3278977871,
0.098286584,
-0.4620987475,
0.2842759192,
-0.1084138826,
0.2060469836,
0.8570460677,
0.1153646633,
0.1044067368,
-0.2610742152,
0.617197454,
0.0328855105,
0.2071443349,
0.23681961,
-0.6490184069,
-0.5713086128,
-0.1128694639,
0.1060696691,
0.2208254635,
-0.9771299362,
0.3793050051,
-0.3872209787,
-0.5560162067,
-0.298532933,
0.2019328177,
0.5015608668,
0.475153029,
0.2733951509,
0.0144781359,
-0.4118586183,
-0.547395885,
-0.2938999534,
-0.337903291,
0.2059629112,
0.4043965042,
0.4799214005,
-0.2021227777,
0.927156508,
-0.6535095572,
0.3954449892,
-0.4483835995,
0.0300687701,
0.1198810562,
-0.1212086082,
0.2525945604,
-0.5794340968,
-0.1422756463,
-0.0100656776,
-0.8764857054,
0.1300070882,
-0.0347221717,
-0.4894064069,
-0.1638967693,
0.1981737912,
-0.7074282765,
0.2778416872,
0.4757660627,
-0.4190877676,
0.8862056136,
-0.0783773437,
0.2714027464,
-0.7225831151,
-0.1589620411,
-0.3312783539,
-0.2197825313,
-0.3967214823,
0.196614936,
0.0390411802,
0.1735945642,
-0.1977946907,
0.4076003134,
-0.4620617032,
-0.3935818672,
-0.0262108408,
0.6257703304,
0.4075831771,
0.3820792437,
-0.0904149413,
0.7897444367,
0.4096705317,
-0.7822495103,
0.5889062881,
0.4157631397,
-0.3934428394,
0.2812098861,
-0.3550589681,
0.5626270771,
-0.203524217,
0.5045791268,
-1.1723626852,
0.0583410077,
0.0393525809,
-0.4132056534,
-0.079671517,
-0.1540756673,
-0.6143764853,
-1.0445256233,
-0.2378675938,
0.4987949729,
0.2020054013,
-0.793317616,
0.5043209791,
0.1366698593,
0.2335208654,
-0.782038331,
-0.3778402805,
-0.1473585516,
-0.0397233292,
-0.6721860766,
-0.0528845079,
0.0234238058,
-0.2510797381,
-0.1074981689,
-0.2684172094,
-0.0595235527,
-0.0222647451,
-0.2393287122,
0.1721918136,
-0.0490574501,
0.5227463245,
0.0193665102,
0.1593637019,
0.161643371,
-0.3303015828,
0.7897284627,
-0.3000696898,
-0.5153125525,
0.06848827,
-0.1477054507,
0.7543362975,
-0.3361128271,
0.704754889,
0.3398748636,
-0.0514407493,
-0.3261384964,
-0.474206239,
0.1267508417,
-0.4299505949,
0.1804367453,
-0.8214784861,
-0.7094689012,
0.4346747696,
-0.3688071966,
-0.203268975,
0.4756903052,
0.4583500326,
-0.1387175322,
0.9108843803,
0.0722635016,
0.3416748941,
-0.2611409128,
-0.4268868268,
0.5715803504,
-1.1551549435,
-0.4663644135,
-0.3498911262,
-0.0940342993,
-0.5715095997,
-0.615970552,
0.4095139503,
0.4154567122,
-0.5994144678,
0.2315262109,
-0.4147969484,
0.4974775016,
0.303078264,
0.3392828107,
0.4628444016,
-0.3311373889,
-0.6330376863,
0.6187479496,
-0.9530591369,
-0.6813262105,
1.1531358957,
0.2330979109,
0.8047121167,
-0.0400619879,
0.4279849231,
0.2903615236,
0.1502618641,
-0.6769608855,
0.6160226464,
-0.0612148345,
-0.5278733373,
-0.3147753775,
-0.6992967129,
-0.8207094669,
0.268228054,
-0.0690996349,
-0.7671955228,
-0.0642934665,
0.0789156035,
-0.2310370505,
0.7222548127,
-0.4614654481,
0.7403287292,
-0.5892116427,
-0.0752791539,
-0.0700703263,
-0.6006801724,
0.614074707,
0.028735036,
0.3072096407,
-0.0560877174,
0.3301672637,
0.8160284758,
-0.4681796134,
0.5016221404,
-0.1384476125,
-0.3394797444,
0.8978486061,
0.3730421662,
0.5001141429,
-0.2405038923,
-0.095909819,
0.1655590385,
0.0048943846,
-0.2698192894,
-0.9216352701,
0.5046635866,
-0.7805130482,
-0.6428614855,
-0.1879935712,
-0.6059736013,
-0.6295186281,
0.0330560245,
-0.0201845597,
0.4362390339,
0.1152034327,
-0.2295811027,
0.3488052189,
-0.382941097,
-0.0347605124,
0.1028874665,
-0.5857016444,
-0.5860473514,
0.5946301222,
-0.0360442437,
0.666811049,
0.3424541056,
0.4038187861,
-0.6334787607,
-0.3046331704,
-0.6765159369,
0.2391897589,
-1.1169139147,
-0.2380566597,
-0.7703023553,
-0.365881592,
-0.191128388,
-0.182686463,
-0.2950602472,
-0.2625116408,
0.4265771508,
-0.4419653118,
0.3830643594,
0.9257225394,
0.2222276777,
0.0950630084,
-0.6494611502,
0.5026899576,
0.7331761122,
0.4250394702,
0.4066539705,
-0.1292133182,
0.1102438793,
0.2507268488,
-0.5164967775,
-1.059980154,
-0.246712029,
-0.2426831424,
0.5124067664,
0.3922365904,
0.1342310756,
0.9056299329,
-0.3728884459,
0.689409256,
0.3021774292,
-0.970296979,
0.647629261,
-0.0452215597,
0.1276137531,
0.3603227437,
0.410523057,
-0.2234433293,
-0.5979701877,
-0.5326305628,
-0.605429709,
0.320876509,
0.2936815917,
-0.1267658323,
-0.5461279154,
0.3629472256,
0.1313893795,
0.1853895336,
-0.6352711916,
-0.2690522075,
0.1152818725,
0.0048516518,
0.2751685083,
-0.2690283656,
-0.0726092681,
-0.2918482721,
0.5601768494,
-0.1726296842,
0.3940168321,
0.3069927096,
0.0068188598,
-0.1838345975,
0.3956068456,
0.2343647331,
1.0707039833,
-0.1806783378,
0.6108874083,
0.381901592,
-0.1077621579,
0.406808883,
-0.5211752653,
0.0357957706,
-0.0959458649,
0.6764929891,
0.7266578078,
-0.2840360999,
-0.5910232067,
0.70536834,
-0.0264192447,
-0.1443738043,
-0.0663358495,
0.0372173972,
0.2816191614,
0.1474557817,
0.1654287279,
0.1491727978,
-0.0820741579,
-0.5731978416,
0.0484732129,
0.5292307138,
-0.1638334692,
0.0019118361,
0.4474472106,
0.2005031556,
-0.2241591662,
0.831961751,
-0.3722899854,
-0.7615768909,
0.6792295575,
0.78862679,
0.7772018909,
0.0240652971,
0.3418761492,
0.4033138156,
0.3350419998,
0.313164711,
0.2000606805,
-0.2364511341,
-1.2318706512,
-0.5919564962,
-0.6785620451,
-0.3364178836,
0.1061991304,
-0.6105117202,
0.1664535254,
-0.3816858828,
-0.3078924417,
-0.1336519569,
-0.2574586272,
-0.8042375445,
0.3252831697,
0.1507050544,
0.9376404881,
-0.6595108509,
0.5342200398,
0.4845202863,
-0.34875682,
-0.9977780581,
0.3117154837,
-0.4888496399,
-0.9725185633,
0.8785437942,
0.1657090485,
-0.7270541191,
-0.1502197385,
-0.4021143019,
-0.6932488084,
1.1981985569,
0.4187838137,
-0.6055952907,
0.084665373,
0.2816168964,
0.4602475166,
-0.3125307858,
0.5488001108,
0.7179571986,
0.391235441,
0.4366563857,
-0.9350541234,
0.0905842185,
0.0959639847,
-0.0286639109,
0.1495740861,
-0.5870984793,
0.578908205,
-0.61308676,
-0.1575565636,
-0.3171651065,
0.2944425642,
0.6967750788,
0.3158862293,
0.6535891294,
0.6651071906,
1.1050498486,
0.0002108529,
1.2964053154,
-0.2531252205,
0.3433789909,
1.0917780399,
-0.3636686802,
0.6052728891,
0.2575529218,
-0.6057202816,
0.8962519169,
0.5071766973,
0.3867280483,
0.4110378921,
0.5479858518,
-0.1456571668,
-0.5140399933,
0.1753433496,
-0.1580310315,
0.477671057,
0.18292436,
-0.3460829258,
-0.0554792322,
-0.2085933536,
0.0146302339,
-0.0004324476,
-0.3885487914,
0.7814621329,
0.0431204028,
-0.6425297856,
0.8995942473,
-0.1642831862,
0.1717354804,
-0.4254354239,
-0.0505660661,
-0.0051305257,
0.0188645683,
-0.1440916955,
-1.1794612408,
0.2329760641,
0.3127470016,
-0.0050850003,
0.1168720573,
0.691762507,
-0.0496755168,
-0.6527885199,
0.7573959231,
0.8104762435,
0.1601230949,
0.1503633857,
-0.4890285134,
-0.0102095697,
-0.2237826437,
-0.1111592278,
-0.1721092761,
0.6576300263,
-0.0486001745,
0.9846756458,
0.4640609026,
0.0936186686,
0.2172670215,
0.4211088419,
0.9524865746,
-0.4215447903,
-0.3632962704,
-1.0500175953,
0.2402191162,
-0.0450331606,
-0.119692497,
0.6700940132,
0.5650867224,
0.8421197534,
-0.1028585359,
0.9827440977,
-0.1377837062,
0.2579239309,
-0.5357097387,
0.2430102229,
-0.2248706967,
0.1605937332,
-0.6015344858,
-0.7469897866,
-0.0492429435,
0.6579822302,
-0.7594544291,
0.2039898634,
1.0544681549,
0.4202769101,
0.0802525133,
0.1329665929,
0.3684485853,
0.3880823851,
0.2481914163,
0.7394251823,
1.2251381874,
-0.4317931235,
0.5450609326,
-0.2076559216,
-0.2121206969,
0.3947033286,
-0.7713106275,
-1.0029182434,
-0.3931061625,
-0.2680116892,
-0.4178552926,
0.1350974143,
0.7726301551,
0.3867711723,
-0.6268839836,
-0.143412441,
-0.4406630397,
0.5372733474,
-0.4204650223,
-0.2555592954,
0.6265419126,
-0.5589651465,
-0.1934500039,
0.3602787554,
0.3199761212,
-0.2973153591,
-0.1619697809,
-0.3169162869,
-0.3328310847,
0.1332530826,
0.8800780177,
-0.4844482243,
-0.7590150833,
-0.523917377,
-0.0752416179,
0.2076019049,
0.1236414388,
0.7606673837,
-0.8099340796,
0.693874836,
0.341082871,
0.6043637991,
0.4039087594,
0.2911614478,
0.4335305989,
-0.6340420246,
-0.2963520586,
0.2318305522,
0.3553652167,
0.2541951537,
-0.3157941103,
0.4445639849,
0.208099246,
-0.4684762061,
-0.4469819069,
0.4631590843,
-0.7983523607,
-0.3172053695,
1.3833385706,
-0.3535363972,
-0.1033440232,
-0.1609585583,
-0.1979569793,
0.3927920461,
0.1439980865,
0.5717011094,
0.759662509,
-0.3468033671,
0.0267281961,
-0.2153965831,
0.2083231807,
-0.0793931484,
-0.7937768102,
0.2922760844,
0.3160075247,
0.3754546046,
0.1977955997,
0.8989111781,
-0.1599254012,
0.0860453844,
0.1526633948,
-0.138153553,
-0.0160483327,
-0.5207965374,
0.235690549,
0.1884617209,
0.4894745946,
-0.2238204479
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11197v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11197v2
|
Centroid-Based Efficient Minimum Bayes Risk Decoding
| 2024-02-17T05:15:12 | 2024-06-11T07:14:46 |
Hiroyuki Deguchi, Yusuke Sakai, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Taro Watanabe, Hideki Tanaka, Masao Utiyama
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Minimum Bayes risk (MBR) decoding achieved state-of-the-art translation
performance by using COMET, a neural metric that has a high correlation with
human evaluation. However, MBR decoding requires quadratic time since it
computes the expected score between a translation hypothesis and all reference
translations. We propose centroid-based MBR (CBMBR) decoding to improve the
speed of MBR decoding. Our method clusters the reference translations in the
feature space, and then calculates the score using the centroids of each
cluster. The experimental results show that our CBMBR not only improved the
decoding speed of the expected score calculation 5.7 times, but also
outperformed vanilla MBR decoding in translation quality by up to 0.5 COMET in
the WMT'22 En$\leftrightarrow$Ja, En$\leftrightarrow$De, En$\leftrightarrow$Zh,
and WMT'23 En$\leftrightarrow$Ja translation tasks.
|
[
-0.2788151205,
-0.5025599003,
0.5101450682,
0.2869993448,
-0.5589853525,
0.0777206197,
-0.0476622209,
-0.3821455836,
0.1189167872,
0.4290953875,
-0.4557060897,
-0.7543829679,
-0.5853618979,
0.0560163893,
0.0876523703,
0.9629357457,
0.4924817383,
0.3138076067,
0.2027951777,
0.018430708,
-0.0862584412,
-0.5289300084,
-0.6434203982,
0.2062619925,
0.8324756622,
0.6558416486,
0.9712656736,
0.7246177197,
0.9313771725,
0.2394925058,
-0.438321352,
-0.1969471872,
-0.2712482214,
-0.7244409919,
-0.2860374749,
-0.4022555053,
-0.4838793576,
-0.3071008921,
0.6972391605,
1.1886091232,
-0.2756130695,
0.3386684656,
0.1306810677,
1.1680002213,
-0.9288483262,
0.1695116758,
-0.5132386684,
-0.2334160358,
-0.2023020983,
-0.2527221441,
-0.6308813691,
-0.6289925575,
-0.1920145899,
-0.2455676794,
0.2559442818,
0.1891195178,
0.3167846799,
0.049754601,
-0.7788857818,
0.097040616,
-0.5722206831,
0.6971247792,
-0.3805451095,
0.3954355121,
0.1956735849,
0.7141799927,
-0.4763152599,
-0.0538344085,
-0.5909962654,
0.4265730977,
0.0264481492,
0.0135734612,
-0.4408862889,
0.1308001131,
0.2026572078,
-0.0692610666,
-0.4296539426,
-0.1477550864,
-0.2498258352,
-0.4308741093,
0.6848675609,
0.3090743423,
-0.0979462117,
-0.4710082114,
-0.1646760404,
-0.6562533379,
-0.7515671253,
0.5845158696,
0.2716227472,
0.2495368719,
-0.0451615937,
0.4627069831,
-0.3558256328,
0.4671879709,
0.1738356352,
-0.4413042963,
0.386705935,
-0.2149843723,
-0.0597418994,
0.1805006713,
0.7151678205,
0.885328114,
-0.3312988281,
-0.3153311014,
-0.0327198282,
-0.0406609029,
0.2966140211,
-0.9221644998,
-0.0638686866,
0.0701300204,
-0.7638718486,
-0.2000111341,
-0.2370610237,
-0.9369869232,
-0.183093518,
0.0751051605,
0.7009989023,
-0.8565262556,
0.0119303092,
0.1971466094,
-0.2834394872,
0.399497658,
0.0291755535,
-0.736602366,
0.4216319323,
0.4911610484,
0.6994870901,
-0.033701174,
0.0301428605,
-0.6782110333,
0.0420495756,
-0.5075956583,
0.8598082066,
-0.0387395471,
-0.5760034919,
-0.0508881509,
-0.0104733035,
-0.1381932348,
-0.3629809916,
0.6357090473,
-0.4640980065,
-0.6363394856,
-0.681333065,
-0.1283651739,
-0.5195990205,
-0.1272905022,
-0.4796229303,
0.5305976272,
0.2339919806,
-1.0364153385,
0.3860614598,
-0.3221901357,
-0.7590325475,
-0.0455551557,
-0.0250077453,
-0.3326323032,
0.3893035948,
0.5097290874,
0.5409803987,
-0.2631927133,
0.2431682944,
-0.3933008909,
-0.4241738021,
0.5302786231,
-0.3715143204,
0.7220028043,
0.1797919869,
-0.263217628,
-0.1890137494,
-0.954475224,
0.1456619799,
-0.0938259885,
-0.2667087018,
-0.2356881052,
0.4665548205,
0.1838080883,
-0.0083822599,
0.1561489403,
-0.8163110018,
-0.1985415667,
-0.241793856,
0.1300413609,
0.4858180285,
0.2066925913,
0.6143755913,
-0.6001538038,
0.052777227,
0.3956541121,
0.2727462947,
0.3896505833,
-0.6229339242,
-0.3345104754,
-0.2643464506,
0.0540139452,
0.665073216,
-1.087425828,
0.7533199191,
-0.7610228658,
-0.9268259406,
-0.5959186554,
-0.1954513341,
0.6260597706,
0.4329146743,
0.6989888549,
-0.3517353237,
-0.0768404081,
-1.2990531921,
-0.2639973462,
-0.3022520542,
0.097472854,
0.0460001528,
0.1322627515,
-0.4445663691,
0.7766315937,
-0.4218547046,
-0.1420527548,
-0.5140234232,
0.0536476411,
0.7435634732,
0.835303247,
0.6349279881,
-0.5152185559,
-0.5140778422,
0.0869040266,
-0.0314448439,
0.1924842,
-0.2440656573,
-0.5029081106,
0.1529285014,
0.0268873032,
-0.5487491488,
0.7337043285,
0.6580621004,
-0.2362561524,
0.4029459953,
-0.4395317733,
0.4621972144,
-0.9491525292,
0.3552452326,
-0.177523762,
-0.1445219815,
-0.6559042335,
-0.2484151274,
0.5645583272,
0.1628943235,
-0.4880183637,
0.0610981993,
-0.5240523815,
-0.1364047825,
-0.3895097673,
0.1408081949,
-0.3142473698,
0.4425135255,
0.0458020456,
0.6684798598,
0.5307623744,
-1.0791318417,
-0.3794724345,
0.5491348505,
-0.5283003449,
0.5833410621,
-0.2211368531,
0.0121956281,
-0.3146075308,
0.021358287,
-0.97229141,
0.1904943734,
0.2509689629,
-0.6144907475,
0.5234401822,
-0.4259033203,
-0.5798513293,
-0.4232680202,
-0.3084081709,
0.4753089845,
0.7570061088,
-0.6629476547,
0.4293402731,
0.5354995728,
-0.2134241611,
-0.7592390776,
-0.7317625284,
0.1171427667,
0.1433420926,
-0.6599357128,
0.4530229867,
-0.4298205674,
0.2959147096,
-0.0623075925,
-0.1922860593,
-0.0381478332,
0.0378829278,
0.3290368617,
0.2027336657,
0.0184260979,
-0.3785766065,
0.7455390096,
-0.485727936,
0.1509549022,
-0.0533911102,
0.0646757856,
-0.0797370374,
-0.2490029186,
-0.2956935167,
0.6455068588,
0.3912378252,
0.2211372554,
0.9519611597,
0.7837380767,
-0.4799815416,
0.1230118945,
-0.7625831962,
-0.1028707698,
-0.4909961224,
0.2296827585,
-0.7070709467,
-0.8169847131,
0.6035461426,
0.0921386778,
-0.3296185732,
0.4385867417,
0.4012980759,
-0.1594282836,
1.2737256289,
0.871055305,
-0.4637471437,
0.1584142894,
-0.220268175,
0.3398938179,
-1.1719390154,
-0.2782218456,
-0.6442658901,
-0.5151182413,
-0.5518396497,
-0.4295522571,
0.6855458021,
0.2253881097,
0.0527488068,
0.572494328,
-0.4129771292,
0.4790711105,
0.5997633338,
0.4831894636,
0.0124964491,
0.0596382432,
-0.6120428443,
-0.226729542,
-1.0585824251,
-0.2038876861,
1.1392894983,
0.0958908647,
0.6435661912,
0.5364595652,
0.7055160403,
0.0922628567,
0.4543544948,
-0.5998069048,
0.6780195832,
-0.1925644279,
-0.6826609373,
0.0043546888,
-0.9209813476,
-1.0529485941,
0.3741030395,
-0.4455213249,
-0.8460362554,
0.6808457971,
0.0453055985,
-0.5912262797,
0.3784903586,
-0.2690778375,
0.9688730836,
-0.204566583,
-0.1686371714,
-0.5164475441,
-0.9399564862,
0.3581691086,
0.0810117796,
0.6770105958,
-0.1430618614,
0.0239552911,
0.6697483063,
-0.3614936769,
0.7365497351,
-0.3788226247,
0.5416845083,
0.2846072018,
0.5296064615,
0.3404133916,
0.1883432716,
0.0364222638,
0.3015526831,
0.587154448,
-0.6490813494,
-0.1832340956,
0.3470546901,
-0.7919724584,
-0.4129811525,
-0.6857728958,
-0.4451088309,
-0.0951718688,
0.2396936268,
0.4606768787,
0.2868968248,
-0.4385021925,
0.1996813715,
0.5289248824,
-0.2208094001,
0.656756103,
0.8018895984,
0.0212837271,
-1.0069675446,
0.6860231161,
-0.2097351551,
0.0334628932,
0.7140801549,
0.1235145479,
-0.3970025778,
-0.9431814551,
-0.616897583,
0.4681296647,
-0.7211796641,
-0.7677968144,
-0.7914491892,
-0.1061529145,
-0.4271486104,
-0.3339591026,
-0.4166555405,
-0.2288622558,
0.0944868922,
0.0545122363,
0.1313611567,
0.2236157954,
-0.6366924047,
0.7839360833,
-1.7049335241,
0.2054968029,
-0.2351082712,
0.1624078006,
-0.3164112568,
-0.6232400537,
-0.7294223905,
0.089838244,
0.0346897729,
-1.21187222,
0.5745598674,
-0.0682983845,
0.780554533,
0.4871928096,
0.2894182205,
0.7539484501,
-0.7188589573,
0.2190559357,
0.3615127206,
-1.1192461252,
0.2749788165,
-0.0194826014,
0.287961334,
0.9781423807,
0.561517179,
-0.6805383563,
0.0914104283,
-0.4723957479,
-0.4759630859,
0.5836452842,
0.2784962654,
-0.2419249415,
-0.4320701063,
0.5197265744,
-0.0292461272,
-0.0284570586,
-0.2478655875,
0.0142226713,
0.2846997082,
-0.3055920899,
-0.526860714,
-0.4459577203,
0.1179428771,
-0.2791157961,
0.613073349,
-0.3180621266,
0.5035348535,
0.4983120859,
-0.5150495768,
-0.4203414619,
0.2980385721,
0.1533309966,
0.0932857916,
-0.6134924293,
0.1091810018,
0.3216928542,
-0.5417443514,
0.1540799588,
0.1066286042,
-0.1888111085,
-0.0143679539,
0.0295840614,
0.1757556647,
0.5568503141,
-0.4705964029,
1.0443450212,
-0.2760691047,
-0.0266132951,
-0.1368411481,
0.0276126061,
-0.0704981983,
0.3238030374,
0.2707516253,
0.4814875722,
0.517111659,
-0.4962698221,
0.2376723886,
0.3532555401,
-0.3809196055,
-0.3635520935,
0.4476796389,
-0.0316938646,
0.249687925,
0.4796362221,
-0.5498108864,
-0.5026251674,
0.3780513406,
0.6523653269,
0.8796032071,
-0.3123525977,
0.1293367893,
0.8871987462,
0.7812799811,
-0.0335466862,
0.6663095951,
0.0947677046,
-0.8009434342,
-0.4582192004,
-0.7383332253,
-0.5393998623,
-0.7097634077,
-0.9540116787,
-0.0696306303,
-0.6351354718,
-0.5435902476,
-0.3312445879,
-0.2106586844,
-0.743709743,
0.178502515,
0.0764883161,
1.1508805752,
-0.5419901013,
0.9900227189,
0.4987876713,
-0.1689473391,
-0.4610423148,
-0.4823325574,
0.0893719867,
-0.2816624343,
0.2189361155,
0.315368861,
-0.2561338544,
0.1259912997,
-0.2128658295,
-1.2099658251,
1.3382835388,
0.0211108308,
-0.7729905248,
0.25380826,
0.2296994328,
0.2993366718,
-0.4455237687,
0.1536235362,
0.8262735605,
0.2423644662,
-0.1170522645,
-0.5017627478,
0.2636606395,
-0.1305144131,
0.2669937313,
0.2995893657,
-0.4386867285,
0.4906406105,
-0.577647984,
-0.449134022,
0.1953008473,
0.5789253712,
-0.0356916003,
0.3665593863,
0.3756107688,
0.5214840174,
0.5477947593,
0.0434774458,
1.2037494183,
-0.6545624137,
-0.0072942865,
0.7130352259,
0.1061920896,
1.4166843891,
0.2423585057,
-0.2605585754,
0.3639353812,
0.5221253633,
0.3232544065,
0.8343430758,
-0.006442721,
-0.1134726182,
-0.2936365306,
0.4628122449,
-0.0813971162,
0.0169895142,
0.6426946521,
0.0320373327,
-0.0706225485,
-0.0305147972,
0.0005034599,
0.0096593853,
-0.4460822046,
0.7502940893,
0.1691354215,
-0.3793639839,
0.4813923836,
0.4011567831,
0.5353764296,
-0.4199229479,
0.4119790792,
-0.2796722054,
0.4566559792,
-0.0241815522,
-0.640071094,
0.5744826794,
-0.2545527816,
-0.1476286501,
0.3315975368,
0.633351028,
-0.3350694776,
-0.675845921,
0.5446721315,
0.3513156474,
0.290460676,
-0.5385992527,
-0.5299373865,
-0.0860051885,
-0.1661621034,
0.2797606885,
0.3479743004,
0.4752856791,
0.296171844,
0.6748642325,
0.9624873996,
-0.0635185018,
0.2726021707,
-0.2934204042,
0.8772499561,
-1.1610800028,
-0.4059014022,
-0.5866807103,
0.5786046386,
0.2535439432,
0.0275562778,
0.4625091255,
0.7586039305,
0.4845346808,
-0.3200134635,
0.4249487817,
-0.0197866689,
0.5517442226,
-0.6335681677,
0.988198638,
-0.1742291003,
-0.1164486632,
-0.1909853816,
-1.1849213839,
-0.5651724935,
0.6475854516,
-0.1527651548,
-0.47315979,
1.124894619,
0.8835237622,
0.1246360019,
-0.2237863392,
0.548019886,
0.0012273472,
0.1803029776,
1.0557652712,
0.3664807677,
-0.6501637697,
0.9007544518,
-0.6805917621,
-0.6493124962,
-0.5287767053,
-0.8194214106,
-0.9854709506,
-0.218329072,
-0.4332553148,
-0.3419113755,
-0.0580212921,
0.7770075202,
0.3963244855,
-0.739749074,
-0.259316206,
0.187076658,
0.1049023494,
-0.5323919058,
-0.0616474859,
0.3439512551,
-0.4530285895,
-0.2767039239,
0.4720011652,
0.4945305288,
0.0193239525,
0.4514707029,
-0.1174868718,
-0.0513276979,
0.2061583996,
0.6856018305,
-0.0093703168,
-0.2497531623,
-0.5867304802,
-0.1300136894,
-0.4992685914,
0.1959497929,
0.7250380516,
-0.4332053065,
0.1119829714,
0.6228269339,
0.9752214551,
0.627022922,
-0.1460943669,
0.1916532964,
-0.1879159063,
0.0256867185,
0.0611978546,
0.554674685,
0.1794605404,
-0.345626235,
0.324986726,
0.4790090919,
-0.5362545848,
-0.1127038598,
0.0330142565,
-1.6041265726,
-0.0284125488,
0.6905277371,
-0.060921967,
-0.9046741128,
0.0927625299,
-0.0995465815,
0.1475668103,
-0.3642281592,
0.6133739948,
0.3905910254,
0.1914920956,
-0.1001545563,
-0.3471981585,
0.3466586769,
0.3812398314,
-0.4009340107,
-0.1771081239,
0.6134570241,
0.4465173781,
0.2068214417,
0.622823596,
-0.4771018624,
0.7239378691,
0.4904342592,
0.4539565444,
0.2432000786,
-0.44224298,
-0.3158477545,
-0.1165191159,
0.1388102025,
-0.1996245235
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11194v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11194v2
|
Evaluating LLMs' Mathematical Reasoning in Financial Document Question Answering
| 2024-02-17T05:10:18 | 2024-02-29T09:13:58 |
Pragya Srivastava, Manuj Malik, Vivek Gupta, Tanuja Ganu, Dan Roth
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs), excel in natural language understanding, but
their capability for complex mathematical reasoning with an amalgamation of
structured tables and unstructured text is uncertain. This study explores LLMs'
mathematical reasoning on four financial tabular question-answering datasets:
TATQA, FinQA, ConvFinQA, and Multihiertt. Through extensive experiments with
various models and prompting techniques, we assess how LLMs adapt to complex
tables and mathematical tasks. We focus on sensitivity to table complexity and
performance variations with an increasing number of arithmetic reasoning steps.
The results provide insights into LLMs' capabilities and limitations in
handling complex mathematical scenarios for semi-structured tables. Ultimately,
we introduce a novel prompting technique tailored to semi-structured documents,
matching or outperforming other baselines in performance while providing a
nuanced understanding of LLMs abilities for such a task.
|
[
-0.152086243,
-1.2904931307,
0.9224187732,
0.4106176794,
-0.0711997896,
0.3343081772,
0.0003902387,
-0.26094082,
-0.4316237867,
0.5067104697,
-0.6567457318,
-0.7155997157,
-0.285980314,
0.468531698,
-0.433694154,
0.9023823142,
-0.3735021055,
0.1415005475,
-0.5830303431,
0.1795125753,
-0.4333400726,
-0.4909707606,
-0.6983274221,
-0.4558422565,
0.2965162098,
0.6829239726,
0.8297705054,
0.2842259109,
0.6881892681,
0.3653858304,
0.094893679,
0.1493703276,
-0.1135505885,
0.1344076693,
-0.1518879533,
-0.9356771708,
-0.5764597654,
-0.2296442986,
0.4985619485,
0.761420846,
-0.3942949474,
0.2704240382,
-0.0528328307,
0.9510598183,
-0.1123015657,
0.5994143486,
-0.708719492,
0.0268577337,
-0.2957542241,
-0.1314763427,
-0.5781052709,
-0.4515859187,
0.3782422245,
-0.8564903736,
-0.0061437762,
0.1962767243,
0.550237596,
0.2794069946,
-0.4145162404,
-0.7435632348,
-0.6637097001,
0.4782391489,
-0.5936059356,
0.2675216496,
0.3659626544,
0.4330320954,
-0.1915473342,
-0.7626644969,
-0.5122849941,
-0.2073545456,
-0.0406392068,
0.0870681331,
-0.2699294686,
0.0476515591,
0.5719430447,
0.1939821243,
-0.6046308279,
0.0624664687,
-0.28913939,
-0.1129728258,
0.4460566342,
0.2648761868,
0.048204314,
-0.0658498257,
-0.245312199,
0.0046491451,
-0.5573421121,
0.3832357824,
0.3670294285,
0.2140870094,
-0.1964962035,
0.7871505022,
0.1697449535,
0.9467525482,
-0.2356432378,
-0.2729265392,
-0.3256394565,
-0.1998506039,
-0.4084298611,
0.1535339206,
0.216838032,
0.2146760076,
0.715598762,
0.054685276,
-0.4461967945,
-0.1120595187,
-0.0124028083,
-0.2624156773,
-0.1164002195,
0.2694104314,
-0.0746275634,
-0.0934858248,
-0.0432825387,
-0.6619853973,
-0.2451232225,
-0.4981954992,
0.6208311319,
-0.3783621788,
0.3830423951,
0.4541011751,
-0.2705158293,
0.2494809628,
0.5633758903,
-0.8950772285,
0.4432073534,
0.8167084455,
0.5402606726,
0.2111332566,
-0.0040031536,
-0.7952003479,
0.3342751265,
-0.2330610007,
1.1911387444,
-0.5778203607,
-0.2925153077,
0.0289238058,
-0.406365037,
-0.4107504785,
-0.6545833349,
0.6866982579,
-0.632699728,
0.2371406555,
-0.5218641758,
-0.5541557074,
-0.1667492092,
0.3383668065,
-0.6557785869,
0.8629680276,
0.3497377634,
-0.5531985164,
0.3722777665,
-0.9811090827,
-0.5669221878,
0.046825923,
-0.0859636813,
-0.3718450665,
0.0017612042,
0.3628991544,
0.2677715421,
-0.6056646109,
0.3259077668,
-0.4360151887,
-0.1909357756,
0.9000723958,
-0.4764576256,
0.2190683335,
0.1404152364,
-0.0058364719,
0.0199857652,
-0.730287075,
-0.0922044069,
0.1126563624,
-0.470495671,
-0.2468096465,
0.0145664904,
-0.2866541147,
0.0324528553,
0.2384005785,
-0.2283232957,
0.3196590543,
-0.4178477824,
0.8178544641,
0.806899488,
0.0692989975,
0.3954583108,
-0.5981596112,
0.6286891699,
-0.0443016961,
-0.1420144141,
0.0312482268,
-0.2518319488,
-0.4805844426,
-0.0696502924,
0.3011851311,
0.7410026789,
-0.8139395714,
-0.2303479016,
-0.0122983465,
-0.2039555758,
-0.1321638376,
0.3630158305,
0.2070491612,
0.7873691916,
0.2026842684,
0.5238170624,
-0.1975667477,
-1.0930051804,
-0.4712114334,
-0.012088839,
-0.0909040794,
0.3718566895,
0.6074388623,
0.4018441737,
0.7080526948,
-0.567260325,
0.0576221719,
-0.3194149733,
0.2334525585,
0.6238802671,
-0.1212946177,
0.5603770614,
-0.8338809609,
-0.479709059,
-0.2341000587,
-0.5685934424,
-0.2090067714,
-0.6551775932,
-0.066452466,
0.22790429,
0.4181516171,
-0.6065922976,
0.4402654767,
0.2101598084,
-0.4590766132,
0.4371750653,
-0.4191197157,
-0.0610000379,
-0.7765669227,
-0.0952565968,
0.2885764241,
-0.0233788397,
-0.6476474404,
-0.4144071341,
0.0961156264,
-0.0063742343,
-0.1439855844,
0.4876893163,
-0.5092360377,
-0.5537217855,
0.2032768428,
0.4588205218,
0.1671586931,
0.3267804384,
-0.1536084563,
1.1771190166,
0.4285487831,
-0.603954196,
0.4990739524,
0.4571367204,
-0.5003296137,
0.7209973931,
-0.8465733528,
-0.1567803174,
-0.041570168,
0.1116740406,
-1.3994557858,
-0.1573158056,
-0.0419999249,
-0.1689412445,
0.3430899084,
0.1257900745,
-0.5310484767,
-0.5787829757,
-0.1393963844,
0.1226081252,
-0.1267697513,
-0.2947158217,
0.9404078722,
-0.0549478494,
-0.6149907708,
-0.545334816,
-0.5388064384,
0.2915146947,
-0.2824887633,
-0.9563719034,
0.1225054339,
-0.0105334055,
-0.8856573701,
-0.1973673403,
-0.4503648281,
0.131782189,
0.2451324314,
-0.0054583303,
0.7424899936,
-0.3317477107,
0.1274276078,
0.3030191958,
-0.1615623981,
0.4590879977,
-0.327383101,
0.3262841403,
-0.3876041472,
-0.4476871789,
-0.0739692599,
0.069416441,
0.6106599569,
-0.2137801945,
0.7194935679,
-0.0432448275,
-0.4366911948,
-0.2291557491,
-0.5569385886,
0.1560405642,
-0.5152587295,
0.1382666081,
-0.583747983,
-0.8444808125,
0.9786550999,
0.0825085193,
0.2947842777,
0.7266994119,
0.9302991033,
-0.3031201661,
0.6173665524,
-0.087420173,
0.3857442737,
-0.0135957552,
-0.1535545439,
0.158799395,
-0.4040671885,
-0.6227939725,
-0.8619621992,
-0.3994816542,
-0.1403666437,
-0.2640007734,
0.583294034,
-0.1550342739,
-0.1623993665,
0.0341988653,
-0.1071515456,
0.5459339619,
0.2883308232,
-0.0062834797,
0.3875456452,
-0.1463673413,
-0.3406074941,
0.0845333189,
-0.465952903,
-0.5577164292,
0.7131809592,
0.4211896956,
1.0986056328,
0.2554943562,
0.1931613684,
0.3095033467,
0.2985665798,
-0.6386282444,
0.366230458,
-0.1268519759,
-0.6140434742,
-0.666200161,
-0.7198593616,
-0.7101504207,
-0.1817188412,
-0.2371034771,
-0.5860493183,
-0.0787519887,
-0.009358082,
-0.6566897631,
0.1801203638,
-0.7186700106,
0.7869361639,
-0.5591934919,
-0.1894565672,
0.0897163898,
-0.3910353184,
0.4287039042,
-0.4481499195,
0.5449738503,
-0.0991099626,
-0.2485342324,
0.6036881208,
-0.4367352426,
0.6252685785,
0.0563126877,
-0.5293741822,
0.4657457471,
0.4612216949,
0.4942883253,
0.2869516015,
-0.4075966179,
-0.1608213186,
0.4095211625,
-0.2923922241,
-0.8379853368,
0.4805125594,
-0.4288320541,
-0.7528158426,
-0.4116266668,
-1.0539889336,
-0.6390769482,
0.0205936376,
-0.0957295522,
0.4509629607,
0.2763017714,
0.2933258116,
0.5668869615,
-0.1572556347,
0.3755094707,
0.4723039567,
-0.1203797609,
-0.323771596,
0.4704065919,
0.3798870146,
0.230552718,
0.6718723178,
0.3802093863,
-0.9775230885,
-0.4840041697,
-0.5378498435,
0.2554944158,
-0.8596377969,
-0.3813319206,
-0.279450953,
-0.1199892238,
-0.1911651194,
-0.3437462747,
0.3167241514,
-0.7779150605,
-0.3020407259,
-0.421364516,
0.5768465996,
0.7445536256,
0.2281439453,
0.0584498718,
-1.0936273336,
0.3748836517,
0.5866076946,
0.448646754,
-0.0172055438,
-0.773509264,
0.0922786519,
-0.1488747597,
0.1272469312,
-1.0070581436,
0.0813159198,
0.1455698907,
0.6664816141,
0.2206657231,
0.0329163894,
0.537660718,
-0.1054410413,
0.3405480981,
-0.0586705171,
-0.9738771319,
0.1870092303,
-0.5745318532,
0.2574104965,
0.5810115933,
0.3549277484,
-0.2519607246,
-0.1998785138,
-0.3443804383,
-0.4342362881,
0.5800786614,
0.1708617508,
-0.0384817906,
0.2958832085,
0.9496811032,
0.0704274252,
0.3315261602,
-0.4758897424,
-0.0533072911,
0.1471183449,
-0.2650538087,
0.1697335094,
-0.2270124555,
-0.0462455563,
-0.2392237633,
0.259509474,
-0.1004777327,
-0.1575564891,
0.0216555428,
0.1254969239,
-0.2689864039,
0.4648476243,
0.8739485145,
1.1169723272,
-0.1350654215,
0.0549222194,
0.5315244794,
-0.2681173682,
-0.0818842351,
0.3096427619,
-0.0203285608,
-0.1460041702,
0.486607641,
0.4859310389,
0.4623425007,
-0.7797707915,
0.1896735132,
-0.3017695248,
-0.7825838923,
-0.3658486903,
0.1076103747,
0.416335851,
0.263781637,
0.6335408688,
-0.2704898715,
-0.0639209822,
-0.7497340441,
0.2358320504,
0.3554978967,
0.0928393975,
0.0160370469,
0.699937284,
-0.1263483912,
-0.4715847373,
0.7342447042,
0.1560276151,
-0.5724255443,
0.8235750198,
0.6903430223,
0.3286238313,
0.0753771439,
0.2457611263,
0.0649629608,
0.3045597672,
0.1453509778,
0.7462253571,
0.0014810816,
-0.5226905942,
-0.5112120509,
-0.6668739319,
-0.7485111356,
-0.1277384758,
-0.6375495195,
0.2008777708,
-0.6613755822,
-0.1060915962,
0.5648400187,
-0.0860325545,
-0.5877628326,
0.0979557559,
0.0273200963,
1.3187605143,
-0.6690088511,
0.1924794614,
0.7206934094,
-0.3028129339,
-1.1481748819,
-0.4707605243,
0.1771501899,
-1.1555383205,
0.3874126673,
-0.2347753495,
0.1178284511,
-0.0940414518,
-0.4373255968,
-0.5001000166,
0.9069610238,
0.5508054495,
-0.6536570191,
-0.3445572853,
0.6549957991,
0.5323811173,
-0.0873593912,
0.1658262014,
0.8090335131,
0.9540623426,
0.5966761112,
-0.7210440636,
-0.2120518684,
-0.028334355,
-0.3903878033,
0.3785066307,
-0.5058649182,
0.8082876801,
-0.3737230003,
0.1856138408,
-0.1332437843,
0.5633888245,
0.3715255558,
0.8839655519,
0.5132692456,
0.395655781,
1.0204255581,
-0.4501364231,
0.8915429115,
-0.1465420872,
0.0558197722,
0.8239548206,
-0.5142537355,
0.6612735987,
0.1956330538,
-0.5074975491,
0.5747223496,
0.739094615,
-0.1939090043,
-0.2722038925,
0.5094296932,
-0.2444074005,
-0.585485518,
0.034103144,
-0.1371389925,
0.4218149185,
0.6175439358,
0.0175115373,
-0.4602329135,
-0.1938010454,
-0.1115055084,
0.3028723896,
-0.3184095919,
0.7351504564,
0.4798147082,
-0.6485954523,
0.02140777,
0.1733688414,
-0.1979880482,
-0.6698704958,
-0.0872821212,
-0.283187896,
-0.0510287844,
-0.2775371373,
-1.3042504787,
0.3222910762,
0.2538749874,
-0.0703242943,
-0.1675943434,
0.5972257257,
-0.1723463237,
-0.6919018626,
-0.1777587086,
0.6552026272,
-0.1191477478,
-0.1036593691,
-0.8022020459,
-0.2878838778,
-0.0500533246,
-0.1993304044,
0.3015421331,
1.0468071699,
-0.1980467886,
0.865193367,
1.0103942156,
-0.2166602761,
-0.273625046,
0.3937219381,
0.7947750092,
-0.6304295063,
-0.4206773043,
-1.0741897821,
0.0959438086,
0.255512774,
-0.2503696978,
0.720816195,
0.7688080072,
0.406740576,
-0.0283105467,
0.3452017605,
0.6564224958,
0.3737404346,
-0.9225698709,
0.3202696741,
-0.4976705015,
0.533279717,
-0.3858967423,
-0.8819028139,
-0.4511401653,
0.4961285293,
-0.7243768573,
-0.0172288679,
0.5585830212,
0.3843134642,
0.1661438197,
0.4120748341,
0.2712978423,
0.2983975708,
0.301638931,
0.6082160473,
0.9364612699,
0.1777094305,
0.8722171783,
0.0924974158,
0.0234093815,
-0.0349633992,
-0.9172902703,
-0.8151903749,
-0.2791120708,
-0.1172987595,
-0.4364174306,
-0.331687063,
0.7028167248,
-0.2546293736,
-0.6474457383,
-0.2276755273,
0.2005696893,
0.2996296883,
0.2714477479,
-0.2062241286,
0.4790954888,
-0.069154039,
-0.2974851131,
0.0767677203,
0.7670936584,
0.2899693251,
-0.1551583111,
0.1332904696,
-0.0830670372,
0.4067332149,
0.4225759506,
0.1749394238,
-0.3310688734,
-0.0170114227,
0.5129140019,
-0.0537635125,
0.0172448289,
0.9018852115,
-0.0483241789,
0.1482778937,
0.5137239099,
0.673458755,
0.4901527762,
0.4529179037,
0.35765329,
-0.2616499364,
-0.2650550008,
0.2967481613,
0.5175026059,
-0.0585965812,
-0.4786792696,
0.3603408039,
0.0925920904,
-0.4798013568,
-0.6173241138,
-0.1753439605,
-1.0240188837,
-0.240704909,
0.8922925591,
0.1224303767,
-0.409574151,
-0.3072358668,
-0.2398368567,
-0.1934762597,
-0.4329822063,
0.6751832366,
1.1762980223,
-0.2363054007,
-0.1443709731,
-0.7313328981,
0.1763676256,
0.3932196796,
-1.0451411009,
0.2125044167,
0.5432394147,
0.0854125842,
-0.0254908595,
0.473074019,
-0.1063545421,
0.4938459396,
-0.0563068353,
-0.6314422488,
-0.2777025998,
-0.3116666675,
-0.196401611,
0.1936943531,
0.2179022729,
0.496604234
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11192v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11192v2
|
I Learn Better If You Speak My Language: Understanding the Superior Performance of Fine-Tuning Large Language Models with LLM-Generated Responses
| 2024-02-17T05:05:31 | 2024-06-01T03:36:23 |
Xuan Ren, Biao Wu, Lingqiao Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper explores an intriguing observation: fine-tuning a large language
model (LLM) with responses generated by a LLM often yields better results than
using responses generated by humans. We conduct an in-depth investigation to
understand why this occurs. Contrary to the common belief that these instances
is simply due to the more detailed nature of LLM-generated content, our study
identifies another contributing factor: an LLM is inherently more "familiar"
with LLM generated responses. This familiarity is evidenced by lower perplexity
before fine-tuning. We design a series of experiments to understand the impact
of the "familiarity" and our conclusion reveals that this "familiarity"
significantly impacts learning performance. Training with LLM-generated
responses not only enhances performance but also helps maintain the model's
capabilities in other tasks after fine-tuning on a specific task.
|
[
-0.5434415936,
-0.6186443567,
0.4499475062,
-0.3206234276,
-0.1402129978,
0.2263354212,
-0.6677339673,
-0.621761322,
-0.0635306761,
0.2828246951,
-0.3761624396,
-0.1991454512,
-0.7466892004,
0.2803391218,
-0.2998915613,
0.7409240007,
0.6484699249,
0.3330147266,
-0.3760915697,
0.0780851841,
-0.5815121531,
-0.6355521083,
-1.0579681396,
-0.7850022912,
0.6930651069,
0.6503450871,
0.3476568162,
0.6099128723,
0.6105307937,
0.4613501132,
-0.0747311786,
0.1437983364,
-0.7365395427,
-0.0132099614,
-0.1115382239,
-0.840880096,
-0.0791520551,
-0.0704677254,
0.5989862084,
0.7248651981,
-0.0445382595,
0.1984285861,
0.4118435681,
0.7975394726,
-0.321734786,
0.0534955077,
-0.9509658217,
-0.1028321013,
-0.0616285726,
-0.3279190063,
-0.3248627186,
-0.3270732164,
0.1452025175,
-0.4377444386,
0.3526382148,
-0.0930829942,
0.76093328,
0.1326006949,
-0.378875196,
-0.1781908423,
-0.7562841773,
0.6048595905,
-0.9790502787,
0.4718160331,
0.4258064032,
0.3569085598,
-0.1849523932,
-0.6124087572,
-0.7215573788,
-0.4856478572,
-0.1931733936,
0.1040469781,
0.0752209201,
0.0230624769,
0.6197090149,
0.4837863147,
-0.587151289,
0.3773280084,
-0.5769354105,
-0.1453274041,
0.6406803727,
0.3101087809,
0.2216566652,
0.1751692891,
0.0435481146,
-0.2958048284,
-0.8708651662,
0.4549640417,
0.8324745893,
0.4496510625,
-0.0602591187,
0.5693350434,
-0.4025486708,
0.7353218198,
0.1560374945,
-0.377064079,
0.1268148571,
-0.0944477916,
-0.095835492,
-0.1274266243,
0.6190423369,
0.3623201847,
0.7812395692,
-0.227113232,
-0.2217008919,
-0.1117988676,
0.3342193961,
-0.7956130505,
-0.2934044003,
-0.0942250416,
-0.4644404352,
-0.250821054,
-0.0282437354,
-0.1546697915,
-0.4840623736,
-0.7037178874,
0.3417827785,
-0.540161252,
-0.2719476223,
0.3590224385,
0.0331296846,
0.3349037766,
0.3001107872,
-1.2041916847,
0.3985485435,
0.8129662275,
0.5260433555,
-0.2889772058,
-0.420958668,
-0.8157942891,
-0.1645848304,
-0.357445538,
0.8596671224,
-0.3412648141,
-0.7063286304,
0.1521125138,
-0.2317707241,
-0.0551056229,
-1.241891861,
0.1872419417,
-0.5047352314,
0.0477405712,
-0.5780450702,
-0.5618223548,
0.0725057274,
0.1182018295,
-0.476788938,
0.7703056931,
-0.1734567583,
-0.5951561332,
0.5814543962,
-0.2611951828,
-0.537506938,
0.0947011858,
-0.30791834,
-0.1822748184,
0.2506892383,
-0.2311929911,
0.3753777444,
-0.0200507324,
0.1044489965,
-0.4574994445,
-0.1877845824,
0.5525499582,
-0.3065268099,
0.3075084686,
0.3249527812,
-0.1765604764,
0.0909407362,
-0.644634366,
0.0530831032,
0.1780219972,
-0.8633188009,
-0.2953189015,
0.1147914976,
-0.2628313303,
-0.0204676334,
0.2405149937,
-0.6653422713,
0.1478499174,
-0.6772313714,
0.1263992488,
0.8398228288,
0.0291004609,
0.4550922215,
-0.4132925868,
0.2065672874,
0.0707615092,
-0.3482228518,
-0.0969839618,
-0.1375495493,
-0.7018457055,
0.2113492191,
0.1883786768,
0.2363821864,
-0.4725280106,
-0.0883392245,
-0.1597415358,
-0.124320887,
-0.5409251451,
0.6091541052,
0.649500072,
0.7750088573,
0.225449726,
-0.3706254959,
-0.5582327843,
-1.1734323502,
-0.6392809153,
-0.3280318379,
-0.0207192283,
0.5163599253,
0.2268930227,
0.0466428921,
0.7142153978,
-0.7046732903,
0.0447307751,
-0.4927079082,
0.0179411452,
-0.0148700699,
0.4451700449,
0.4347076714,
-0.5235142708,
-0.7177731395,
0.2939217091,
-0.4942340255,
-0.183660686,
-0.1192325428,
0.1107353717,
0.0799091682,
0.7021394372,
-0.2081419975,
0.0482469387,
0.4332521856,
-0.1882072836,
0.4894497395,
-0.4355897903,
0.0215054713,
-1.2056689262,
-0.093350701,
-0.0190310311,
-0.3271882832,
-0.4077934325,
0.0045231576,
-0.0161962602,
0.0065078316,
-0.3415707648,
0.5438114405,
-0.295652777,
-0.1638421118,
-0.3556413651,
0.0551319085,
-0.2553545833,
0.3028561771,
0.0157478377,
1.1985304356,
0.4217737019,
-0.8495386243,
-0.0693539828,
0.1738526374,
-0.6115584373,
0.4882941246,
-0.7492498755,
0.2115285993,
-0.0910632461,
-0.3957593143,
-1.0431154966,
-0.5237582326,
-0.1799637228,
-0.4892350435,
0.6962130666,
0.2121175379,
-0.3509938717,
-0.3981430531,
0.0836347565,
0.0375738665,
0.5113668442,
-0.9356994629,
0.3366519809,
0.2628704309,
-0.2414523959,
-0.4571730196,
-0.5535525084,
-0.1056241915,
-0.2909784913,
-0.3791850507,
-0.0104318075,
-0.5053529143,
-0.5303969383,
-0.3712540865,
-0.2928036749,
0.042878747,
0.4848996401,
0.3774811924,
-0.3061407208,
-0.3826712072,
0.2357577533,
-0.0613122284,
-0.1030904502,
0.1726386696,
0.0865596384,
0.7201223969,
-0.3048687279,
-0.4078241885,
-0.5983408093,
0.2372413874,
0.3937346637,
-0.1837566942,
0.6199188828,
0.3984066844,
0.0522245467,
-0.1896071285,
-0.4782541692,
-0.6615549922,
-0.5936190486,
0.4068350494,
-0.6449536085,
-0.8810694814,
0.3777737617,
-0.1822787076,
0.0569374971,
0.063416265,
0.5807830691,
-0.6781998277,
1.1536346674,
0.8761142492,
-0.2766990662,
0.7287188172,
-0.3195238709,
0.1016908512,
-0.6950608492,
-0.3126588464,
-0.5868871212,
-0.4795060754,
-0.5843049884,
-0.0183834005,
0.2673909962,
0.0309707168,
-0.1633643508,
0.1454187334,
0.0070818826,
0.6060227156,
0.6675572991,
0.2447735518,
0.4511221945,
0.0071598776,
-0.0967447087,
-0.0481651016,
-0.5343014598,
-0.6631157398,
0.9727761745,
0.3120137751,
0.9166961908,
0.360783726,
1.0649151802,
0.0726294518,
0.3198025525,
-0.8159348369,
0.5532502532,
-0.1057973877,
-0.3579953313,
-0.09360753,
-0.4836990535,
-1.1042509079,
0.1248721033,
-0.4285582602,
-0.6140677333,
-0.2773622572,
0.3972630799,
-0.2599713504,
0.2394091785,
-0.8523144722,
0.5167148709,
-0.353889972,
-0.119190909,
-0.3530735672,
-0.4860395789,
0.1454941779,
-0.0784348324,
0.0161808338,
-0.0117486473,
0.0059422511,
0.5336706638,
-0.1023903191,
1.0162633657,
0.1572436988,
-0.0807136819,
0.1556649357,
0.0819064751,
0.283610642,
0.2425940782,
-0.1178885624,
-0.1292143315,
-0.3678274453,
-0.3047359288,
-0.5911955237,
0.7875335813,
-1.0283714533,
-0.9857183695,
0.0635687932,
-0.5011516213,
-0.3705504835,
0.2373554111,
0.4176169634,
0.4306402802,
-0.2418664545,
0.2830837667,
0.8446390033,
-0.1734098047,
0.4705471396,
0.7478201389,
-0.0203835815,
-0.1815193594,
0.8861989379,
0.1208658665,
0.5535657406,
0.4324567914,
0.4576037228,
-0.2883279324,
-0.7157368064,
-0.2840099335,
0.3031404614,
-0.7093027234,
-0.1989580095,
-0.610337317,
-0.0135905864,
-0.3631092608,
0.0871758386,
-0.1896844208,
-0.2080446929,
-0.2730895877,
-0.4394954443,
0.3077295125,
0.8689244986,
-0.187000528,
0.5665672421,
-0.5345289707,
0.1498156339,
0.7735805511,
0.3493091762,
0.0300290864,
-0.7443016768,
-0.4176698625,
0.153981179,
-0.4306423962,
-0.5631687641,
0.3417553604,
0.5361956954,
0.6340405941,
0.4374084771,
-0.2463176101,
0.8129405975,
-0.5141275525,
0.5508084893,
0.0283903144,
-0.6224285364,
0.2786825597,
-0.3455054164,
0.4507497251,
0.6923300028,
0.2988130152,
-0.3075230122,
-0.7449064851,
-0.6124047041,
-0.8056892157,
0.3807321191,
-0.1717893481,
0.6748648882,
-0.1750337631,
0.7469735742,
0.2023020983,
0.3128569722,
-0.7196231484,
-0.4658442438,
0.2584655285,
0.1881994903,
-0.4999345243,
-0.2826182842,
-0.0313148387,
-0.1450125873,
0.6473028064,
-0.3791244626,
0.1149057001,
0.0088878572,
-0.2180895805,
-0.3350301087,
-0.0837170854,
0.7174342275,
0.3446834981,
0.0217353404,
0.265999645,
0.47839275,
-0.3679715693,
-0.296646446,
-0.5258729458,
0.1091181487,
-0.2459097058,
0.6757580638,
0.7492678761,
0.11004363,
-0.6833410859,
0.3165491819,
-0.2959636152,
-0.2595655024,
-0.0266641006,
0.6604670286,
0.4132273197,
0.501368463,
0.1881894618,
0.0837779865,
0.1233743429,
-0.6300883889,
0.2219690531,
0.6560865045,
-0.0845080614,
-0.2488407493,
0.6329426765,
0.0866942853,
-0.5962668061,
0.5139006972,
0.1681913286,
-0.5684956908,
0.7258549929,
0.7912987471,
0.6255765557,
-0.1059556007,
-0.0334511176,
0.6624087095,
0.080640763,
0.205099538,
0.2528113425,
-0.2188435793,
-0.6397539377,
-0.3220181465,
-0.7322454453,
-0.470837146,
0.3629128039,
-0.7824609876,
0.0531018563,
-0.3889516592,
-0.1954215169,
-0.0334125459,
0.1617798358,
-0.7484462261,
0.4390324354,
0.252011776,
0.8086799979,
-0.8568748832,
0.9559019208,
0.6372025609,
-0.4126337469,
-1.2952224016,
0.1979958266,
-0.3137848079,
-0.957975328,
0.8444342613,
0.0118787829,
-0.2939227819,
0.1824815273,
-0.4529293478,
-0.7540177107,
0.7845532298,
0.5442892909,
-0.6739110947,
0.3976464272,
0.2337513417,
0.6590313911,
-0.3694969714,
0.1028909162,
0.6354792118,
0.0569364838,
-0.0337829813,
-0.9986147285,
-0.413611114,
-0.0463589132,
0.0594673641,
-0.004785873,
-0.6179869175,
0.7877752185,
-0.6264958382,
-0.1610449553,
0.1654070765,
0.7358347774,
-0.2087957859,
0.2006839067,
0.1868209094,
0.4690241218,
0.9127821922,
-0.0201604851,
1.1337902546,
-0.3371182084,
0.1550037414,
1.3328338861,
-0.0307756867,
1.1516927481,
0.4031219482,
0.0730583742,
0.4832439423,
0.7498174906,
0.41474244,
0.5497158766,
0.2122941166,
-0.5268189907,
-0.3331658542,
0.2016227692,
-0.4248652756,
0.3684835732,
0.1036419719,
-0.3113585711,
-0.0762280822,
0.058053799,
-0.2429276109,
0.5752862692,
-0.2653921247,
1.3753772974,
0.2714304626,
-0.6212388277,
0.781593442,
-0.2059437037,
0.5219708681,
-0.5003909469,
0.2019687444,
-0.4562167525,
0.2217948884,
-0.3228650093,
-0.8436483145,
0.3043445349,
0.0521663055,
-0.4703308642,
-0.1806987375,
0.5508397818,
-0.5915306807,
0.004643681,
0.2570481002,
0.6987059116,
0.1495369673,
0.1724728793,
-0.4908299148,
0.0616829917,
0.0243526157,
-0.2619610131,
0.8876321316,
0.3181455135,
0.2252484113,
0.9364460707,
0.8711892962,
0.1196512282,
0.2831000984,
0.140981108,
0.8513256907,
-0.3469969332,
-0.016487116,
-0.8884279728,
0.4225521386,
-0.0944614336,
-0.3297988772,
0.6647408009,
0.7680557966,
1.1827787161,
-0.4230459332,
0.8533643484,
0.2897828221,
0.6377184987,
-0.5664014816,
0.7000167966,
-0.7052646279,
0.4621714652,
0.002089028,
-0.5997143984,
-0.1265410036,
0.7979719639,
-0.7218561172,
-0.1003090292,
0.4583499134,
0.9426363111,
-0.0572958365,
-0.2829948068,
0.8278712034,
0.2348638177,
0.312402904,
0.2530733943,
0.8308916092,
-0.0368847735,
0.3939846456,
-0.3867761195,
0.154396385,
-0.0942745656,
-0.7585256696,
-1.0083432198,
-0.6269458532,
-0.2855517566,
-0.4645785689,
-0.0676473975,
0.9911612272,
0.488517642,
-0.7523627877,
-0.7567564249,
-0.0582835674,
0.1660452187,
0.1100785509,
-0.1354787946,
-0.1263159961,
-0.8049125671,
-0.8056737185,
0.3675597608,
-0.0470892377,
0.1489426643,
0.1417666674,
-0.4903121293,
0.2017990202,
0.0543091036,
0.6740710139,
0.4854138494,
-0.5356145501,
-0.3339332938,
0.0251913499,
-0.409319073,
0.2870535553,
0.7218729854,
-0.7770236135,
0.7490686774,
0.3266505599,
0.729657948,
0.4938705564,
-0.0477039777,
0.7820077538,
-0.6126716137,
-0.0249305796,
0.0015020035,
0.3305780292,
0.4416526258,
-0.4531471133,
0.2546717823,
0.0078633949,
-0.4886004627,
-0.7865806222,
0.5279964209,
-0.8219208121,
-0.0289382339,
1.3183010817,
-0.1068316326,
-0.0228023175,
0.0711978972,
-0.5068520904,
0.2026845515,
-0.3774597943,
0.9114502072,
0.4173822403,
-0.2430899888,
0.0165744182,
-0.6742075086,
0.7190796137,
0.3895546496,
-0.6080828309,
-0.0761231333,
0.1786809564,
0.8571978211,
-0.0924741626,
0.5017604232,
0.3079716563,
0.3800840974,
-0.2549620569,
-0.2178075612,
-0.1016763747,
-0.2384290099,
-0.5031219125,
0.0184989069,
0.9650284052,
-0.114658162
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11191v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11191v1
|
Knowledge Graph Assisted Automatic Sports News Writing
| 2024-02-17T04:54:58 | 2024-02-17T04:54:58 |
Yang Cao, Xinyi Chen, Xin Zhang, Siying Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we present a novel method for automatically generating sports
news, which employs a unique algorithm that extracts pivotal moments from live
text broadcasts and uses them to create an initial draft of the news. This
draft is further refined by incorporating key details and background
information from a specially designed sports knowledge graph. This graph
contains 5,893 entities, which are classified into three distinct conceptual
categories, interconnected through four relationship types, and characterized
by 27 unique attributes. In addition, we create a multi-stage learning model by
combining convolutional neural networks and a transformer encoder. This model
expresses entity-task interactions using convolutional neural networks and
enriches entity representations in the query set with the transformer encoder.
It also includes a processor to compute matching scores for incomplete triples,
addressing few-shot knowledge graph completion problem. The efficiency of this
approach has been confirmed through both subjective and objective evaluations
of 50 selected test cases, demonstrating its capability in revolutionizing the
creation of sports news.
|
[
-0.1947535276,
-0.6861428618,
0.5224269629,
0.2969315052,
-0.3903520107,
0.3349002302,
0.1198058799,
-0.7010699511,
0.4591144025,
0.0875284225,
-0.7004398704,
-0.5894650817,
-0.6976791024,
0.0755226761,
-0.2803005278,
1.1895102262,
-0.2188037336,
-0.002591843,
-0.2661405504,
-0.1270426065,
-0.4687652588,
-0.00956917,
-0.9781073928,
-0.3697055578,
0.238784194,
0.3856356144,
0.4735917747,
0.5961228609,
0.7222254276,
0.3332508504,
0.1665642411,
0.5556815267,
-0.5556246042,
0.3889826238,
0.2613644898,
-0.1270068437,
-0.5673754811,
0.0068949107,
0.4936347604,
0.6699914932,
0.1799255461,
0.3422282338,
0.1404507309,
0.7305759192,
-0.1657635123,
0.4843022227,
-0.594901979,
0.2856732607,
-0.0046169297,
-0.3671039939,
-0.0541119091,
-0.5190100074,
-0.121687673,
-0.9746513963,
0.2348669767,
0.0030988874,
0.9122598171,
0.1743964851,
-0.4895258248,
-0.4526063502,
-0.7847129107,
0.0716558322,
-0.5405602455,
0.5079864264,
-0.0315953307,
0.5600851178,
0.0566342138,
-0.5035604835,
-0.6056405902,
-0.0455150343,
-0.1612027735,
0.3247200549,
-0.050725013,
-0.078298226,
0.1583746523,
-0.0441373773,
-0.4821430743,
-0.3444595635,
-0.6733416319,
0.0446280912,
0.8279897571,
0.2664925158,
0.1782950014,
-0.2582520843,
0.0487188697,
0.4359217286,
-0.4972095788,
0.2108776122,
0.6101959944,
0.1452011913,
0.1726909429,
0.8230713606,
-0.6830148697,
0.753500104,
0.211902678,
-0.5365428329,
0.3061837554,
-0.081872642,
-0.1715304255,
0.3169374466,
0.8825081587,
0.8397603035,
0.1971338391,
-0.6026425958,
-0.0528938882,
-0.1872225851,
0.2049572319,
-0.5145252347,
-0.1324480176,
0.1083089262,
-0.4459097385,
-0.5584014058,
-0.0010819588,
-0.5155178308,
-0.4813896418,
-0.446318686,
0.4020010233,
-0.7345790267,
0.0582825281,
-0.0783342347,
-0.6297043562,
-0.1089306399,
0.3381890655,
-0.5595331788,
0.0916429386,
0.1592571586,
0.5098266602,
0.160621509,
-0.2259620428,
-0.5159361959,
0.6452131867,
-0.0980269536,
0.905031085,
-0.2396811694,
-0.0072752535,
0.0904909223,
-0.4161075354,
0.1368421316,
0.079261452,
0.2651504278,
-0.8872810006,
-0.1470259726,
0.0599343479,
-1.0366564989,
-0.2795219719,
0.3493013978,
-0.7520364523,
1.0202245712,
0.1557978839,
-0.8778350949,
0.8431704044,
-0.6786007285,
-0.914994359,
0.1436570436,
-0.0150126079,
-0.7333371043,
-0.1922005415,
0.3450104892,
0.462062031,
0.1806169599,
0.1710707247,
-0.4038960934,
-0.0872112289,
-0.0659381822,
0.0504379459,
0.4048161507,
0.1012969166,
-0.2791303992,
-0.1640453935,
-0.9552315474,
0.012872735,
0.2005644739,
-0.4583340883,
-0.1130674556,
0.0950868949,
-0.4520991743,
0.3152266443,
0.1008200943,
-0.6667099595,
0.2656705976,
-0.3077479303,
0.2698970735,
0.1950810552,
0.4058161974,
0.5208745599,
-0.1204381958,
0.3338078856,
0.156912148,
0.3068625629,
-0.1033410281,
-0.3544746637,
-0.5894062519,
0.3298807442,
0.1819919646,
0.6001961827,
-0.90077281,
0.5538995862,
-0.4665767848,
-0.6117612123,
-0.4198759496,
0.2744281292,
0.095294416,
0.7465533018,
0.2690051496,
0.0671160072,
-0.7348644137,
-0.5936300755,
-0.5469287038,
0.1188310236,
0.4780963957,
0.3809717,
0.2439588159,
0.4941248,
0.9923685193,
-0.8354530931,
-0.5783674717,
-0.4693498909,
0.0649697259,
0.0619967207,
0.2951148748,
0.8875067234,
-0.7257722616,
-0.6558840275,
-0.1151601747,
-1.1671065092,
0.2496306598,
-0.1210817024,
-0.1164397299,
-0.0738728717,
0.529938221,
-0.5982187986,
0.6050703526,
0.3520245254,
-0.5035128593,
0.3398861587,
-0.2042924315,
0.3129701912,
-0.9051755667,
-0.1395590752,
0.3464399576,
-0.4840267897,
-0.4393027723,
-0.394608438,
-0.3595905602,
-0.1565484554,
-0.3400329053,
0.4218901992,
-0.4894611239,
-0.057046175,
-0.3628076613,
0.2965664566,
0.2749578655,
0.3470652103,
0.0904978886,
0.1566344202,
0.3874878585,
-0.7063669562,
0.7258774042,
0.3592216372,
-0.2089300603,
0.2870106101,
-0.4189766049,
-0.0682029799,
-0.5995597839,
0.4840911031,
-0.8427295685,
-0.3037309051,
0.5288049579,
-0.5576511025,
0.2316884845,
-0.1209299639,
-0.3702032566,
-0.8152272701,
-0.0602163188,
0.2878158092,
0.1376398355,
0.0955669656,
0.5454416275,
0.7245306373,
-0.1311243325,
-0.1374296993,
-0.4019859433,
0.0036881666,
0.0470687449,
-0.5722127557,
0.2318205833,
-0.0035118971,
0.0745387673,
0.402410835,
-0.0041132737,
-0.2779388726,
-0.0002468961,
0.1247082576,
0.1290629208,
-0.2566836178,
0.1769643575,
0.1884772182,
0.1221936792,
-0.1647900492,
-0.6304957867,
0.2536591589,
0.1844019741,
-0.0390927568,
-0.5102686882,
0.5489863753,
0.288638413,
-0.1132747009,
0.7129416466,
0.4249043167,
-0.4170765281,
-0.2281506658,
-0.3730243742,
0.0465091728,
-0.3537687659,
0.3509513736,
-0.4031617343,
-0.7422403097,
0.3305830359,
0.0202960894,
0.1345457137,
0.795838654,
0.2671768069,
-0.4352228045,
1.1789717674,
0.5133669972,
-0.0583370738,
0.3416463137,
-0.4376320243,
0.2767615914,
-0.4173746407,
-0.5428411365,
-0.3336975574,
-0.5790425539,
-0.1265154928,
0.2620688379,
0.5116724372,
0.2292741686,
-0.3310262859,
0.3736808598,
-0.6820605397,
0.7896529436,
0.7213950157,
0.4642554224,
0.520270288,
-0.1932547241,
0.0568498746,
-0.1167639121,
-0.9079819918,
-0.0877023712,
1.0432451963,
0.0040178173,
0.4494438767,
-0.0554352514,
0.8141512871,
0.4869613051,
0.5617403984,
-0.7868978381,
0.2259705812,
-0.202507019,
-0.638917923,
-0.6403623819,
-0.3387787044,
-0.543635428,
-0.2764317691,
-0.6404548287,
-0.4283486605,
-0.1868535727,
0.1610990912,
-0.7344087362,
0.4099586308,
-0.5785956383,
0.4833240211,
-0.1690667719,
-0.0222229976,
0.2084779143,
-0.4333475232,
0.639474988,
0.0014218964,
0.3842918277,
-0.1402224153,
0.304415375,
1.0310235023,
-0.4774469435,
0.6712603569,
-0.3734553754,
0.2834017575,
0.5817550421,
0.127882123,
0.4499735236,
0.3053609133,
0.0741555095,
-0.2583841383,
-0.350040406,
-0.1175932363,
-0.5604355335,
0.3467051983,
-0.7823875546,
-0.4856539965,
-0.1952700615,
-0.589492321,
-0.5268995762,
0.695535779,
0.3211377859,
0.5970557928,
-0.211442396,
0.0565880202,
0.2368782759,
0.1507804394,
0.5805075765,
0.4432620406,
-0.1981814951,
-0.6021527052,
0.8495474458,
0.3358361125,
-0.4555914998,
0.3553406298,
0.0071844826,
-0.2232818902,
-0.8625361919,
-0.4356911778,
0.060277503,
-0.73257792,
-0.9063237906,
-0.6497618556,
-0.4869924784,
-0.8392177224,
-0.0333958156,
-0.0995885655,
-0.4959514141,
-0.0286724586,
-0.374630779,
0.3042795658,
1.1508902311,
0.0996248573,
0.3746387959,
-1.177355051,
0.6410940289,
0.2069230378,
0.5206621289,
-0.1415881664,
-0.1972420365,
-0.4921559989,
0.0787839144,
-0.5918540359,
-1.0436599255,
0.3892719448,
0.2650551498,
0.6461794972,
0.41075477,
0.0357322171,
0.4740062654,
-0.7545186877,
0.7443000674,
0.466910094,
-0.78970474,
0.7728691101,
-0.6209362745,
0.0314636976,
0.5920224786,
0.4425132573,
-0.2454875261,
-0.8372044563,
-0.8488066792,
-0.4096804261,
0.8005592823,
0.2269721925,
-0.1211391091,
-0.1344136,
0.6027345657,
0.1643130183,
0.345870167,
-0.5974603891,
-0.3488855362,
-0.5571805239,
-0.4429606497,
0.1154417098,
-0.021057833,
-0.1059386432,
-0.6700770855,
0.8307569027,
-0.1936462969,
0.0934587792,
0.2990450859,
-0.2883825004,
-0.0841665491,
-0.3510847986,
0.4557752311,
0.7296127081,
-0.0417573079,
-0.1839159578,
0.1586410254,
-0.2676045597,
0.0641618744,
0.4175956845,
-0.4850791693,
0.2681472898,
0.3910351694,
0.9275254607,
0.4507274926,
-0.102223143,
0.5118886828,
0.0010219469,
-0.7520248294,
-0.1097060367,
0.0124309333,
0.2909017503,
0.3802416325,
0.5292105079,
0.3005709648,
0.2301979214,
-0.4486814141,
0.4465259016,
0.2991968393,
-0.4310712814,
-0.183655113,
1.1993277073,
0.346593678,
-0.125334546,
0.4320117235,
-0.3859436214,
-0.5807089806,
0.6107102633,
0.4175359309,
0.4647066295,
0.2488447279,
0.6938809156,
0.4018552601,
-0.081174098,
0.1175400093,
0.159592092,
0.1111043841,
-0.8438780904,
-0.307623744,
-0.7514417768,
-0.0199941285,
-0.1136095747,
-0.1605163962,
0.1751648188,
-0.1878973842,
-0.3281518221,
0.5165393353,
0.449795872,
-0.9984180927,
0.527217865,
0.3126587868,
1.0449961424,
-0.7231082916,
0.6298009157,
0.9427680969,
-0.9246739149,
-1.1966533661,
-0.2548572123,
-0.1405827552,
-0.7188025117,
0.8716675639,
-0.2227764577,
0.2858557999,
0.4220947921,
-0.3747234046,
-0.5815104842,
1.3816478252,
0.3968596458,
-0.228216812,
-0.6081501245,
0.3689018488,
0.2130793929,
-0.6002724171,
0.219236359,
0.4654969275,
0.5984994769,
0.3328741789,
-0.6673310399,
-0.0528468564,
-0.0788432956,
-0.5485752821,
0.1803368479,
-0.9268078208,
0.5121998191,
-0.1356794387,
0.1444368362,
-0.4344951212,
0.9806448817,
-0.0426804498,
0.3738032579,
0.3829824328,
0.6036527157,
0.8726348281,
0.0324080735,
0.892844975,
-0.5910371542,
0.3668639958,
0.8775337934,
-0.0609595552,
0.182024017,
-0.0423999541,
-0.0401419848,
0.304014802,
0.268910259,
-0.1499170214,
0.3724265695,
0.0730259269,
-0.2218432426,
-0.4565110505,
0.0511963889,
-0.1896077693,
0.6687130928,
-0.0722483397,
-0.5189925432,
-0.8219588399,
0.1164920554,
0.1215147898,
-0.0017472162,
-0.4901024699,
1.1664725542,
0.0036869114,
-0.7998756766,
-0.2567452192,
-0.0788158774,
0.245904237,
-0.5265841484,
-0.0814886689,
-0.161391899,
-0.0183586963,
-0.2571436167,
-1.1371159554,
0.4412911832,
-0.0263495855,
-0.3655824065,
-0.2083143145,
1.1395996809,
-0.5626770258,
-0.7634154558,
-0.1424689144,
0.7961289883,
-0.1847935468,
-0.2324960679,
-0.5849807858,
-0.0659197047,
-0.2013562769,
-0.4121120274,
-0.0171865039,
0.8368095756,
0.1707274914,
0.3848747909,
0.4343835115,
0.4301131666,
0.2617748082,
0.1062584519,
0.9259548783,
-0.6183416843,
-0.6918225288,
-0.6203214526,
0.4470386803,
-0.532307744,
-0.3152112663,
0.6414762735,
1.0345556736,
0.361364007,
-0.1859885156,
1.166841507,
-0.0853465721,
0.4060800076,
-0.4362696111,
1.0975705385,
-0.234114781,
-0.2468435615,
-0.0638606027,
-0.6046622396,
-0.5865420103,
-0.0743806064,
-0.037989255,
-0.3393556476,
0.699575007,
-0.0592989214,
0.0729114488,
0.2182349563,
0.0154130254,
-0.1168524176,
0.4474204481,
0.548435986,
0.2351143658,
-0.689427793,
1.0658894777,
-0.2894103825,
-0.1436327845,
-0.2065605372,
-0.9063438773,
-1.0594980717,
-0.5776697993,
-0.3649916947,
-0.4299536645,
0.266810894,
0.5568251014,
0.6236159205,
-0.5702914,
0.2739948034,
-0.0699099302,
0.2196219116,
-0.3364534974,
-0.2647412121,
0.4298368692,
-0.6901446581,
-0.5277315378,
0.0511241257,
0.01962905,
-0.0939254463,
0.1443014592,
0.0151653979,
-0.1792248189,
-0.1390258968,
0.7401239276,
0.383010298,
0.0474889763,
-0.5978149772,
0.0089088334,
-0.079004541,
0.1342515796,
0.8562322259,
-1.0802247524,
0.0879871622,
0.5837270021,
0.6142350435,
0.5862555504,
-0.0394223183,
0.6327210665,
-0.762637198,
0.0928520858,
0.2372630984,
0.2246658057,
0.1725434214,
-0.5380788445,
0.152642414,
0.7610844374,
-0.1841783524,
-0.3465679884,
-0.1304419935,
-0.7898241878,
-0.1458826512,
0.99696666,
0.2581624687,
-0.3745355904,
-0.122752361,
-0.123434566,
0.8449438214,
-0.3441435099,
0.8317595124,
0.7741091251,
-0.3500736058,
0.0995531231,
-0.4761651158,
0.8367787004,
-0.6520026326,
-0.6997621655,
-0.3214164376,
0.4809315205,
0.4432546496,
-0.181042254,
0.9210024476,
0.1239907593,
0.2127596885,
0.3196911514,
-0.0790491924,
-0.7083774209,
-0.3790738583,
0.6683650613,
0.5172424912,
-0.4187701941,
-0.0821990594
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11190v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11190v1
|
Disclosure and Mitigation of Gender Bias in LLMs
| 2024-02-17T04:48:55 | 2024-02-17T04:48:55 |
Xiangjue Dong, Yibo Wang, Philip S. Yu, James Caverlee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) can generate biased responses. Yet previous
direct probing techniques contain either gender mentions or predefined gender
stereotypes, which are challenging to comprehensively collect. Hence, we
propose an indirect probing framework based on conditional generation. This
approach aims to induce LLMs to disclose their gender bias even without
explicit gender or stereotype mentions. We explore three distinct strategies to
disclose explicit and implicit gender bias in LLMs. Our experiments demonstrate
that all tested LLMs exhibit explicit and/or implicit gender bias, even when
gender stereotypes are not present in the inputs. In addition, an increased
model size or model alignment amplifies bias in most cases. Furthermore, we
investigate three methods to mitigate bias in LLMs via Hyperparameter Tuning,
Instruction Guiding, and Debias Tuning. Remarkably, these methods prove
effective even in the absence of explicit genders or stereotypes.
|
[
-0.3505700529,
-0.8346812129,
0.6073458791,
0.2973542213,
0.2768059969,
-0.0090221176,
-0.2895224988,
-0.2167855948,
-0.1339183897,
0.6818358898,
-1.0206626654,
-0.4940086305,
-0.506791532,
0.2095475197,
-0.4242082834,
0.6964576244,
0.0136539685,
0.4031125009,
-0.2140518427,
0.1638346463,
-0.5335342288,
-0.4719209671,
-0.7953179479,
-0.4187399447,
0.5108452439,
0.474663049,
0.4474987984,
0.7188494802,
0.2978074253,
0.3929361403,
-0.3158217072,
0.0767152607,
-0.635258317,
0.3366510868,
-0.2273984402,
-0.8329529166,
-0.5058326721,
0.2636274099,
0.6320948005,
0.7861981392,
0.0980632901,
0.407153517,
0.3037842512,
0.7472894192,
-0.8175037503,
0.1081970558,
-0.6703565717,
0.126055032,
-0.168740198,
-0.2656291723,
-0.5888541341,
-0.3724050522,
0.0881171599,
-0.2557655871,
0.5780783296,
0.181783393,
0.5539618731,
0.1123011112,
-0.83853966,
-0.1464925557,
-0.7820488811,
0.8504059911,
-0.5491209626,
0.3269141018,
0.4049715102,
0.3334452212,
-0.1016903222,
-0.2184271961,
-0.4304210842,
-0.4442066252,
-0.411357373,
-0.1729164571,
-0.1288172454,
0.1785285026,
0.5808145404,
0.1444338113,
-0.4146728814,
0.154541418,
-0.0121569457,
-0.3587633669,
0.4297259748,
0.156021893,
0.1686373502,
-0.1611248702,
-0.3451098204,
-0.032212276,
-1.3181271553,
-0.3503727913,
1.0157753229,
0.3322434425,
-0.2913278639,
0.7975785136,
-0.0389441922,
0.4677834213,
0.4524037838,
0.0135859102,
0.1134684756,
-0.4827376902,
-0.0450048894,
0.2722651362,
0.5023322701,
0.2359744757,
0.3182264864,
0.1249356493,
-0.2111376077,
-0.0098982649,
-0.1336179972,
-0.68462497,
0.2997995913,
0.0811684877,
-0.273045063,
-0.4159321785,
-0.2794370353,
-0.8816607594,
-0.6128441691,
-0.3790728152,
0.4819305837,
0.092717357,
-0.2503744066,
-0.0492641926,
-0.3060208261,
0.3855926991,
0.1645822525,
-1.0831052065,
0.2090791315,
0.6605969071,
0.3591876924,
0.2701354027,
0.0005700129,
-0.6512203217,
0.5652623773,
-0.4052552283,
0.3154827654,
-0.5237801671,
-0.3646511734,
0.232737124,
-0.0926052034,
0.1854391545,
-0.5809029937,
0.3724469841,
-0.1843164712,
0.3336012363,
-0.687508285,
-0.3261009157,
0.1713162065,
0.2280438691,
-0.4142611921,
0.8582647443,
-0.0119422814,
-1.1694117785,
0.3037776649,
-0.42749843,
-0.2454276532,
-0.3818705082,
-0.5540763736,
-0.175977394,
-0.0436113589,
0.5468618274,
0.2979555726,
-0.4293638468,
0.449971199,
-0.2358348519,
-0.5459589362,
0.0850332752,
-0.5700919032,
0.6873903275,
-0.1338922977,
-0.7459642291,
0.1222393215,
-0.4508886337,
-0.3905012608,
0.1098042801,
0.0016851636,
-0.3578854501,
0.0706899241,
-0.4201518595,
0.0152442725,
0.0913986489,
-0.573636353,
0.1293107867,
-0.4139905274,
0.1506872624,
1.1100826263,
-0.295232594,
0.7696301341,
-0.2157280445,
0.6040535569,
0.120341979,
0.1536373347,
-0.0322226845,
0.0246705879,
-1.1964601278,
-0.3385392725,
0.3500040472,
0.3882345259,
-0.8421902061,
0.3099535704,
-0.1855106801,
-0.035161633,
-0.5985156894,
0.2246540636,
0.7937676311,
0.8112427592,
-0.0819589645,
0.3422742784,
-0.7390314937,
-1.4413620234,
-0.4719553888,
-0.2809643745,
-0.1739027053,
0.5158605576,
0.359708637,
-0.0136694564,
0.7984884381,
-0.5379230976,
-0.1728611439,
-0.4887429774,
0.2953988612,
0.2291671485,
0.3637475073,
0.5243291259,
-0.6496821642,
-0.0240758602,
-0.4993281364,
-0.6295264363,
-0.4498903751,
0.1917351037,
-0.3853397369,
0.1370213479,
0.6305155158,
-0.5685603023,
0.2360951453,
0.7508773804,
-0.4105633497,
0.4124671519,
0.1071023643,
-0.0233038608,
-0.7079870105,
-0.2217894047,
0.1560875326,
-0.3044929802,
-0.4140144289,
0.0061955065,
0.2334848642,
0.0395687409,
-0.5866255164,
0.7833436131,
-0.8662078381,
-0.2065209597,
-0.1969466209,
-0.054000333,
0.0191627014,
0.1523944139,
0.028435627,
0.8219817281,
0.5761320591,
-0.8314645886,
-0.0337687023,
0.1431693435,
-0.0329549126,
0.4077861309,
-0.5843541026,
0.3276522458,
-0.5094750524,
0.6051485538,
-0.917440474,
0.0884781852,
0.451926589,
-0.4381596148,
0.4495655596,
-0.4917330742,
-0.5246601701,
-0.3355800211,
-0.6504536271,
0.3793514669,
0.4888421595,
-0.6907466054,
0.549295187,
0.0443260185,
-0.1601225585,
-0.8177952766,
-0.6473005414,
-0.1855173558,
-0.2114374638,
-0.6124811769,
0.1608196348,
-0.3111462891,
-0.3930164874,
-0.3819291592,
-0.1530324519,
0.3624227047,
0.0011095597,
0.2118111998,
0.3826828897,
-0.2999507487,
0.097217299,
0.2432117909,
0.0990438759,
0.2461808771,
0.1275916845,
0.8846049309,
0.108178407,
-0.5169717669,
-0.1844094247,
0.4368106425,
0.1775540262,
-0.0228284597,
0.648003161,
0.617225945,
-0.1463076472,
-0.2932721078,
-0.8185245395,
-0.6380268931,
-0.6283605695,
0.1833337396,
-0.3470763862,
-0.9844673276,
0.332472533,
-0.0839762613,
-0.1919960529,
0.2231711894,
0.6227514744,
-0.0146942744,
1.4967656136,
0.9695110917,
-0.1024701372,
0.11762321,
0.0147366943,
0.2546149492,
-0.9150559306,
-0.1179825291,
-0.8347199559,
-0.3301865757,
-0.9087051749,
-0.3067952096,
0.3245240748,
-0.2429108173,
-0.4933999479,
-0.150406912,
-0.1373115033,
0.4716339111,
0.6748790741,
0.1024882421,
0.256373018,
-0.1035835817,
-0.1532526761,
-0.1493005902,
-0.4838994443,
-0.5512546301,
1.0764089823,
0.5000187755,
0.8908450603,
0.2142220289,
0.6128873825,
0.122790195,
0.3372837603,
-0.4284946918,
0.7700588107,
0.1118003726,
-1.0902332067,
-0.1954926103,
-0.679418087,
-0.6418005228,
0.2398833781,
0.0606027097,
-0.6328072548,
0.4409047663,
0.3996469975,
0.1006934345,
0.1157891974,
-0.6003132463,
0.126576215,
-0.1876433492,
-0.5399848819,
0.2191467881,
-0.4784644544,
0.8861262202,
-0.0337359272,
0.2409419566,
-0.2826720774,
-0.109836638,
0.5474175811,
-0.216011703,
1.2055238485,
-0.2140959054,
-0.3941191435,
-0.1808999032,
0.2779607773,
0.6007896662,
0.3606498241,
-0.1292340308,
-0.0064924434,
-0.428953737,
-0.3442026079,
-0.4219170511,
0.8148698807,
-0.6489663124,
-1.1618816853,
-0.417652756,
-0.6095203757,
-0.6908573508,
0.0406127647,
0.2999943793,
0.1193510294,
-0.0966978744,
-0.1914857477,
1.0054866076,
-0.5449126959,
0.219801262,
0.8739877343,
-0.3076572716,
0.3169770837,
0.3434967995,
-0.3534804881,
0.3191342354,
0.3723847866,
0.391315341,
-0.2784349322,
-0.2540829182,
-0.3104450703,
0.5790510178,
-0.6398895979,
-0.2141430974,
-0.5840817094,
-0.1372142881,
-0.8203568459,
0.1463957578,
-0.4450690746,
-0.177811563,
-0.0666369572,
-0.4418532848,
0.3538987637,
0.5604760647,
-0.149506405,
0.3431223929,
-0.3775814474,
0.5945534706,
0.4284888208,
0.0203938503,
-0.2242858857,
-0.4521321356,
0.496370405,
0.234977439,
-0.0195257515,
-0.7769908309,
0.4511562586,
-0.0096046021,
0.573301971,
0.4751756191,
0.0192272794,
0.3791341782,
-0.5680165291,
0.6919872761,
0.1377229542,
-1.2411403656,
0.8307506442,
-0.6190673113,
0.0444810241,
0.4420290887,
0.5257659554,
-0.1901319772,
-0.563849628,
-0.3245408237,
-0.9558182359,
0.8019121289,
0.1616583019,
0.6062631607,
-0.0694886968,
0.4610524178,
0.2446437329,
0.4931296408,
-0.7749831676,
-0.6667590141,
0.3176704347,
-0.0542945862,
-0.1685050279,
-0.6663007736,
-0.7089217305,
-0.3686209917,
0.5893726945,
-0.0504846089,
0.4549985826,
0.1180189252,
-0.1957897395,
0.0438683517,
0.2997438014,
0.6861420274,
0.6926636696,
-0.47030285,
0.3947222233,
-0.0290171411,
-0.2889682651,
0.4501769543,
-0.2155951262,
-0.6203624606,
0.1694799215,
0.3504308164,
0.77241081,
0.0084125819,
-0.4734494686,
0.6274958253,
-0.1345707923,
-0.4065567255,
-0.0898989663,
0.03229817,
0.3436112404,
0.20514296,
0.2305075377,
-0.5307459831,
0.1486408114,
-0.7069167495,
-0.1233901754,
0.4961247444,
-0.4570776224,
-0.0895098075,
0.5531126857,
0.2497799546,
0.1618846208,
0.5304221511,
-0.0028812767,
-0.4757293761,
0.7206733823,
0.7330967784,
0.6675018668,
-0.3707145751,
0.4247402251,
0.1598426849,
0.6048564315,
0.0846201405,
0.312176466,
0.0897827744,
-0.7632195354,
-0.2293877453,
-0.3708235919,
-0.3669416904,
0.137756303,
-0.6609202027,
0.3562373221,
-0.432926923,
-0.1364203095,
-0.2685324848,
-0.1806568354,
-0.7500521541,
0.115664266,
0.3384433091,
0.8556999564,
-0.9310706258,
0.5022608638,
0.2961233556,
-0.2152873129,
-0.7373725772,
0.1292268038,
0.3009876311,
-1.0206695795,
1.2085876465,
0.0935277715,
-0.3746110499,
-0.0787697807,
-0.6633152366,
-0.8784099221,
0.9767150879,
0.8537947536,
-0.8016589284,
-0.0898856521,
0.2934565842,
0.1203031465,
-0.2093344182,
0.5688374639,
0.5587807298,
0.8229292035,
-0.0911193714,
-0.8232347369,
0.2663083971,
0.0732758641,
0.0386886932,
-0.0054821782,
-0.5469295979,
0.8820187449,
-0.0892970189,
-0.0323575698,
-0.0904808268,
0.6290406585,
0.3930916786,
0.2614075243,
0.5418178439,
0.1038134769,
0.6495180726,
-0.1924084574,
1.0085060596,
0.0896683261,
-0.0764785707,
1.1054000854,
-0.7182359695,
0.3230469227,
0.7325373292,
0.0771118775,
0.0928179622,
0.4726773798,
0.169619754,
0.3607059419,
0.8555545807,
-0.2980347872,
-0.0677440092,
-0.4105087221,
-0.611202538,
0.4619759619,
0.2568463385,
-0.5832901001,
-0.1826633066,
0.1243178174,
0.5283337235,
0.0148557266,
-0.3669083118,
0.5057005286,
0.0492891483,
-0.600307405,
0.3860283196,
0.211579904,
1.0348002911,
-0.7288341522,
-0.0413575172,
-0.8342617154,
0.1184426472,
-0.0088478141,
-0.27801314,
-0.1545938998,
-0.0217935164,
-0.3666053712,
-0.3834314048,
0.7871382833,
-0.4738075733,
-0.6680931449,
0.4629561603,
0.6792604923,
-0.2186988741,
-0.0723454133,
-0.3997207582,
0.1605199575,
0.0475592129,
-0.3541970253,
0.5658720732,
0.1797422171,
-0.1464278549,
0.8710220456,
0.4835824072,
0.2850333154,
0.2052004188,
0.4146145284,
0.7908198237,
-0.612095654,
0.0096345693,
-0.8938806653,
0.0800358132,
-0.0737195387,
0.032257501,
0.9953494072,
0.3842488825,
0.5698569417,
0.0062791742,
0.726154387,
0.4814983308,
0.6441134214,
-0.7774164081,
0.6471792459,
-0.3545657694,
0.652210772,
-0.2837634087,
-0.970954597,
0.0384596102,
0.2060969323,
-0.2855472267,
0.2732745111,
0.595115006,
1.0207570791,
-0.0303790104,
-0.1098592058,
0.1729664803,
0.4199824333,
0.2480219156,
0.2358443588,
1.1193882227,
-0.1943909377,
0.4422127903,
-0.294478327,
-0.2056049854,
-0.0315782316,
-1.1781939268,
-0.9982421994,
-0.0734182373,
-0.3844376504,
-0.1548878103,
0.4919808805,
0.4317295551,
0.6998739243,
-0.2949393988,
-0.2435750961,
0.0862528086,
0.3258324862,
0.2440717071,
-0.2520507276,
0.2255933881,
-0.148142159,
-1.0103602409,
0.5140669942,
-0.0355567411,
-0.0867909566,
-0.5022413135,
0.1811646223,
-0.0805951282,
0.3034605086,
0.3704139292,
-0.1260900497,
-0.4791646004,
-0.3265776932,
-0.0500831455,
-0.1717303246,
-0.1388768107,
0.9855082631,
-0.6277553439,
-0.0673638657,
0.5660956502,
0.2667833567,
0.4528376162,
-0.1473572254,
1.1464012861,
-1.1366554499,
0.3741470873,
0.2566599548,
0.321044445,
0.3472341597,
-0.7375068665,
0.3186633289,
-0.1180711016,
-0.2383794188,
-0.8893198967,
0.4495387077,
-0.7684726715,
-0.4096568525,
1.5348682404,
0.1679521948,
-0.0900030136,
0.1194526479,
-0.2677350342,
0.314655453,
-0.2475839108,
0.3483371735,
0.5983560681,
0.0667149276,
-0.0400532633,
-0.9332110286,
0.4719999731,
0.7698429227,
-0.5314792991,
0.0945562348,
0.4173074663,
0.3806872368,
-0.3353146613,
0.6714805961,
-0.2317215204,
-0.0899841413,
-0.1844272017,
0.0995153412,
-0.0230325963,
-0.1649329811,
-0.2311767787,
-0.2040961981,
0.0336434506,
-0.1545516104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11187v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11187v1
|
LaCo: Large Language Model Pruning via Layer Collapse
| 2024-02-17T04:16:30 | 2024-02-17T04:16:30 |
Yifei Yang, Zouying Cao, Hai Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) based on transformer are witnessing a notable
trend of size expansion, which brings considerable costs to both model training
and inference. However, existing methods such as model quantization, knowledge
distillation, and model pruning are constrained by various issues, including
hardware support limitations, the need for extensive training, and alterations
to the internal structure of the model. In this paper, we propose a concise
layer-wise pruning method called \textit{Layer Collapse (LaCo)}, in which rear
model layers collapse into a prior layer, enabling a rapid reduction in model
size while preserving the model structure. Comprehensive experiments show that
our method maintains an average task performance of over 80\% at pruning ratios
of 25-30\%, significantly outperforming existing state-of-the-art structured
pruning methods. We also conduct post-training experiments to confirm that the
proposed pruning method effectively inherits the parameters of the original
model. Finally, we discuss our motivation from the perspective of layer-wise
similarity and evaluate the performance of the pruned LLMs across various
pruning ratios.
|
[
-0.304425627,
-0.7166916132,
0.4271256328,
0.0774146542,
-0.3440527022,
0.0432508141,
-0.3650566339,
-0.2232338786,
-0.0661956072,
0.8028462529,
-0.7456253767,
-0.3751349747,
-0.2961894572,
-0.1879956126,
-0.5921751857,
0.7688158751,
0.1785477549,
-0.3410259187,
-0.165166527,
0.1852988899,
-0.3218112588,
-0.5084501505,
-0.9212681055,
-0.4241552949,
0.4373184741,
0.3588953614,
0.4557713568,
0.6344687939,
0.365740329,
0.4305102527,
-0.5223906636,
0.3731839955,
-0.6124961376,
0.1455712616,
0.2166685313,
-0.6197463274,
-0.3736525774,
-0.0605909042,
0.99747473,
0.7952311039,
-0.3042048812,
0.1855108738,
0.1993460208,
0.826451242,
-0.636400342,
0.1233974695,
-0.846532166,
0.1902862191,
-0.0307231974,
0.0562001243,
-0.7060354948,
-0.1268324405,
-0.1916173846,
-0.3225332499,
0.3897005916,
0.054571569,
0.856934011,
0.2615655661,
-0.3812903762,
0.3260874152,
-1.0977720022,
1.0102987289,
-0.9726987481,
0.4113050997,
0.1980599612,
0.2812770307,
0.1527688056,
-0.6243017912,
-0.5671907663,
-0.4278892577,
-0.151935637,
0.0968534723,
0.1434238404,
0.0662324727,
0.221382305,
0.5371758342,
-0.2668533325,
0.266959101,
-0.5063925385,
-0.2988192141,
0.3942721784,
-0.0866909176,
0.2611573339,
0.0569814071,
-0.4017618597,
-0.1388059556,
-1.1449531317,
-0.0679861605,
0.4935507476,
0.1394977719,
0.3472926915,
0.46150437,
0.0306515135,
0.6331928968,
-0.1609024107,
-0.4641326368,
0.1813968271,
-0.1209187284,
-0.5061874986,
-0.0759822726,
0.8348935246,
0.3276247978,
0.1846417636,
-0.3064626753,
-0.2524721026,
-0.2688162625,
0.2058870643,
-0.8571817875,
-0.1626059264,
0.2853155732,
-0.4485503435,
-0.2168531269,
-0.0360238329,
-0.262378633,
-0.0425205231,
-0.1860978007,
0.0711412802,
-0.577547431,
-0.3181942403,
-0.0075944206,
0.2274357378,
0.1829784662,
0.3579561114,
-0.6259880662,
0.5284538865,
0.8945135474,
0.9669691324,
0.0069324258,
-0.2507065237,
-0.6751663089,
0.2100830674,
-0.2989299595,
0.2683468163,
-0.1816492826,
-0.3255679309,
-0.0915979818,
0.0251334403,
-0.1491193175,
-0.7812003493,
0.900971055,
-0.6525994539,
0.0539137609,
0.0105081666,
-0.4533136785,
-0.4041614532,
0.3990412056,
-0.8736683726,
0.7257352471,
-0.1142297313,
-0.6791062355,
-0.1862295866,
-0.1668735296,
-0.6550475955,
-0.1414071918,
0.2636828721,
-0.8056599498,
0.2619318068,
0.3471672833,
0.6003043652,
-0.5804345012,
0.3281498849,
-0.1005369648,
-0.2064847201,
-0.0120043065,
-0.1918427497,
0.9489378929,
0.2454141527,
0.0598103143,
0.0937306806,
-0.7114813924,
-0.1189361364,
0.2004482001,
-0.2164395303,
-0.3891709745,
0.0761836991,
-0.2027461082,
0.1704419702,
0.1314458698,
-0.6393308043,
0.180402115,
-0.7835017443,
1.0685021877,
0.5224499106,
-0.0290447231,
0.5994545817,
-0.296302557,
0.3712080717,
0.1062023118,
0.3162662089,
-0.2874264717,
-0.1325258464,
-1.0519958735,
-0.214750737,
0.281927079,
0.3989085257,
-0.5743529201,
0.6064895391,
-0.3517841399,
-0.4821672738,
-0.5363419652,
0.3749438226,
0.5285414457,
0.7528316975,
0.2946438789,
-0.2242950797,
-0.3354051411,
-1.316740036,
0.1136978716,
-0.2395613343,
-0.3287154138,
0.0115679139,
0.3367353082,
0.1711842716,
0.8598012328,
-0.5378906131,
-0.395213306,
-0.3741331697,
-0.0352153108,
0.2351973951,
0.6733697653,
0.2747134864,
-0.78489393,
-0.0870127454,
0.2035097927,
-0.3336481452,
0.0260934327,
-0.1094497964,
0.1109958366,
-0.0622774139,
0.6052245498,
-0.6910684705,
-0.0275977366,
0.5473793745,
0.3445603251,
0.7047315836,
-0.1247169226,
-0.1765476614,
-1.0152888298,
-0.0428729169,
0.0604713075,
-0.23391895,
-0.7460719347,
0.2389382422,
0.2137903422,
-0.1466128528,
-0.6248274446,
0.3238279521,
-0.7698519826,
0.0886232406,
-0.1883644462,
-0.0197011512,
0.2119461447,
0.5699796081,
0.0286089014,
0.42692101,
0.3776613176,
-0.5626895428,
0.3307740986,
0.0212815255,
-0.547712028,
-0.1907317191,
-0.854216814,
0.2629334629,
-0.1318960339,
0.3385235667,
-0.8068190813,
0.2051844895,
0.0104669668,
0.0217790045,
0.3536527455,
-0.4452348351,
-0.5313177705,
-0.4622181952,
-0.4786045253,
0.3954708278,
0.6080502868,
-0.4443576336,
0.5883139968,
0.4029747546,
-0.1125111356,
-0.559915185,
-0.8870226741,
0.0581709556,
-0.5351643562,
-0.8118955493,
0.5633981824,
-0.1202331409,
-0.2125518769,
-0.2135366946,
-0.2243719846,
-0.0874917433,
0.1113210693,
0.291508615,
0.3029592037,
-0.3170978427,
-0.0572109148,
0.230148688,
0.1522341818,
0.1504773945,
-0.2256373763,
0.7554078102,
-0.0847142711,
-0.425211966,
-0.5360513926,
0.1233818904,
0.6208105683,
-0.5900515318,
1.01527071,
0.3304005265,
-0.1787752956,
-0.6747130156,
-0.7598142028,
-0.1713410914,
-0.5216892362,
0.3399879634,
-0.3797999322,
-1.0889207125,
0.7763091922,
-0.3551926911,
0.0871296227,
0.2853301764,
0.35675928,
0.0181600004,
0.6438786387,
0.6076261997,
-0.2649661005,
0.5311121941,
-0.5713115931,
0.2537151277,
-1.0466822386,
-0.1733004898,
-0.544942677,
-0.2987586558,
-0.0578716956,
-0.5222953558,
0.0929564089,
0.3062867522,
-0.2164066583,
0.408613652,
-0.5550200343,
0.5927340984,
0.4865073562,
0.2404646575,
0.3247233927,
0.0654129013,
0.1068362892,
0.251902163,
-0.7934923172,
-0.244802475,
0.5959082842,
0.6437547803,
0.508402586,
0.0458972454,
0.7179255486,
-0.1287460923,
0.2851265073,
-0.9521803856,
0.7093836665,
-0.1957293898,
-0.3008876443,
-0.5488638282,
-0.7218617201,
-0.6263639927,
0.323358506,
0.078947112,
-0.7055787444,
0.1078758612,
0.2406720817,
-0.2702310383,
0.4939013124,
-0.8593495488,
0.4945608675,
-0.0911486968,
-0.256647706,
-0.0678609908,
-0.5976094007,
0.8040192127,
-0.157860592,
0.3127967119,
-0.0236730818,
0.0250383671,
0.8219800591,
-0.8961066008,
0.9839262962,
-0.0856820866,
-0.3528575897,
0.4144199789,
0.3139930665,
0.6395862103,
-0.2274021953,
-0.1327643096,
0.1602784395,
-0.3088682294,
-0.1365371943,
-0.8228822947,
0.803137064,
-0.6929060221,
-0.699549377,
0.3030738831,
-0.6470361352,
-0.2719734013,
0.0843229443,
-0.0536592193,
0.4723157585,
-0.049666319,
0.3701640964,
0.5456408262,
-0.2514761984,
0.5136408806,
0.3727152348,
-0.1687714458,
-0.3097695708,
0.9056425691,
0.1597316712,
0.3879692852,
0.7321299911,
0.4050782025,
-0.0792093277,
-0.9027591348,
0.0081821987,
0.3913426697,
-0.393248409,
-0.2714031637,
-0.2927357554,
-0.6905696988,
-0.3297119439,
0.0681861714,
-0.5148993731,
-0.617500782,
0.1732496321,
-0.1469062418,
-0.0161093026,
0.490247041,
0.431973964,
0.7307879329,
-0.9873723984,
0.0361134969,
0.2370860428,
0.1437917352,
0.3758405745,
-0.6081392765,
-0.2558073699,
-0.1359609663,
-0.1260048896,
-0.5322653651,
0.5975502133,
0.4189611077,
0.4008931816,
0.6395307183,
0.1998585761,
0.6292116046,
-0.7271460891,
0.5180051923,
0.4390226007,
-0.9814935923,
0.6628372073,
-0.1952202767,
0.3373543322,
0.3186855912,
0.2013911009,
-0.3739753067,
-0.5385661125,
-0.5256940126,
-1.1106051207,
0.6119531393,
0.3697370887,
0.0209924839,
0.2571056485,
0.4058049619,
0.0038874829,
0.107703656,
-0.8741388321,
-0.2128793746,
0.0133303972,
0.0735468194,
-0.1432997584,
-0.4410791993,
-0.31172207,
-0.1950259656,
0.702614665,
0.1213646084,
-0.1396728009,
-0.0195946041,
-0.3900277913,
0.1669474393,
0.2156912386,
0.4037968218,
0.5766243935,
-0.1995613575,
0.3461334705,
0.1109051332,
-0.4630089998,
0.0919344723,
-0.1928433627,
-0.5394032001,
-0.2763594985,
0.6301290989,
0.8311696053,
0.2001302093,
-0.5166364312,
0.2468231469,
0.0735901222,
-0.3281746209,
-0.0690924004,
0.2308844179,
0.2402887344,
0.0732011944,
0.37932688,
-0.0785812065,
-0.0146242604,
-0.6247988939,
0.0721452534,
0.362990886,
-0.1201499477,
-0.2312675714,
0.450766623,
0.3044438958,
-0.4226810038,
0.7062106133,
0.1827592701,
-0.6111692786,
0.7233256698,
0.6686834693,
0.7091011405,
-0.3415485024,
0.2333790809,
0.4869370759,
0.7340039015,
-0.4454865754,
-0.4695852399,
-0.2700781822,
-0.9241580367,
-0.8965839148,
-0.700340867,
-0.2031007558,
0.4339207709,
-0.5512402058,
-0.0550042875,
-0.6554166079,
0.0110035697,
-0.2084384263,
0.0230834447,
-0.2098648995,
0.3187592924,
0.0968822613,
1.0640002489,
-0.9252118468,
1.2451275587,
0.4872443974,
-0.4012591243,
-0.8352918029,
0.0184921976,
-0.1613055468,
-0.778151691,
0.6845569015,
0.1470097303,
-0.2582336962,
-0.0180056132,
-0.45554775,
-0.6933114529,
1.1190519333,
0.7675743699,
-1.0509221554,
-0.1711977124,
0.1728270501,
0.2822425961,
-0.297097832,
0.1138074249,
0.4776968062,
0.3706302345,
0.3210547268,
-0.8806057572,
0.1595740616,
-0.342872262,
0.2159987688,
0.3584825397,
-0.8795000315,
0.8261371851,
-0.0026458572,
-0.3687039316,
-0.0171262659,
0.7444528341,
0.0612318814,
0.004055012,
1.0340536833,
0.5991472602,
0.6787955761,
0.0130854649,
0.78072685,
-0.2918012738,
0.5137068033,
1.2651536465,
-0.3185316324,
0.8573937416,
0.501296699,
-0.2272699624,
0.2728925347,
0.3570213914,
0.1004301384,
0.4288876951,
0.2893525362,
-0.1171322316,
-0.3541654944,
-0.008642206,
-0.2181881815,
0.2258465737,
0.2187526375,
-0.2242544889,
-0.0776271895,
-0.0100357514,
0.1174297333,
0.0585646108,
-0.4009387493,
0.563609302,
0.3138187826,
-0.636987865,
0.6097763777,
0.0343098417,
0.4344503582,
-0.7043050528,
0.2402433902,
-0.2776971757,
0.2426497489,
-0.1937173605,
-0.4684909284,
0.4653166533,
-0.3113478422,
-0.0919629484,
-0.4662483335,
0.8507685065,
-0.4590640664,
-0.7522150874,
0.4199820459,
0.4587346315,
0.0198782235,
-0.2787334621,
-0.4573991895,
0.4281024933,
0.1287381947,
-0.3825267255,
0.358689189,
0.3072754443,
0.0437481143,
0.929376483,
0.5528076887,
0.2716108859,
-0.0483995117,
0.2498160452,
1.0762143135,
-0.516659081,
-0.1513383389,
-0.8492139578,
0.484721154,
-0.2134746909,
0.0370723717,
0.7491785288,
0.6658726931,
0.8404951096,
0.0762667805,
0.429967314,
0.1645508707,
0.3537262678,
-0.7671567798,
0.749166429,
-0.6182179451,
0.6484623551,
-0.0944753513,
-1.0914834738,
-0.2791894376,
0.5319148898,
-0.3220517635,
-0.0692986846,
0.6957965493,
0.7507496476,
-0.1877027303,
-0.2508798838,
0.4074802995,
0.6113530993,
0.25500229,
0.4694630504,
0.7352936268,
-0.1921930164,
0.6979762316,
-0.7008142471,
-0.1649994254,
0.0032900856,
-0.8995460868,
-0.9086498618,
-0.7412693501,
-0.3880517185,
-0.1297169328,
-0.09952306,
0.3205058873,
0.9581538439,
-0.7154874206,
-0.3569485545,
-0.0300594512,
0.2239313871,
-0.2998519838,
-0.1870817989,
0.5069813728,
-0.059168756,
-0.7445340157,
0.6243156195,
0.2302968502,
-0.3579223454,
-0.3686763048,
0.0351293609,
-0.1071596444,
-0.2058931142,
0.8355759978,
0.245077759,
-0.7588548064,
0.0064216466,
-0.3339731097,
0.2985874116,
-0.1063907072,
0.9962769747,
-0.7988538146,
-0.0110888463,
0.3751570582,
0.5672800541,
0.7531955242,
0.1161967739,
0.7140788436,
-1.0826040506,
0.3675538003,
0.2139098048,
0.5491164327,
0.2826846838,
-0.0739317462,
0.3487763703,
-0.0248322934,
-0.3784595728,
-0.9890167117,
0.372572273,
-1.1959131956,
-0.4317566156,
1.021441102,
-0.2625091672,
-0.6517492533,
0.3587868214,
-0.2100293934,
0.2657159567,
-0.2720238864,
0.6723588109,
0.524961412,
0.2072359771,
-0.630125165,
-0.3629117012,
0.1653322875,
0.2985951006,
-0.6251499057,
0.3304988444,
0.3929816484,
0.1293655932,
0.3574558198,
0.3801671565,
0.0028354211,
-0.3266505897,
-0.2398916632,
0.0600659177,
-0.4304476082,
-0.4422834516,
-0.0955991298,
0.6863167286,
-0.0312876999,
-0.1223088056
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11178v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11178v1
|
RENOVI: A Benchmark Towards Remediating Norm Violations in Socio-Cultural Conversations
| 2024-02-17T03:13:42 | 2024-02-17T03:13:42 |
Haolan Zhan, Zhuang Li, Xiaoxi Kang, Tao Feng, Yuncheng Hua, Lizhen Qu, Yi Ying, Mei Rianto Chandra, Kelly Rosalin, Jureynolds Jureynolds, Suraj Sharma, Shilin Qu, Linhao Luo, Lay-Ki Soon, Zhaleh Semnani Azad, Ingrid Zukerman, Gholamreza Haffari
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Norm violations occur when individuals fail to conform to culturally accepted
behaviors, which may lead to potential conflicts. Remediating norm violations
requires social awareness and cultural sensitivity of the nuances at play. To
equip interactive AI systems with a remediation ability, we offer ReNoVi - a
large-scale corpus of 9,258 multi-turn dialogues annotated with social norms,
as well as define a sequence of tasks to help understand and remediate norm
violations step by step. ReNoVi consists of two parts: 512 human-authored
dialogues (real data), and 8,746 synthetic conversations generated by ChatGPT
through prompt learning. While collecting sufficient human-authored data is
costly, synthetic conversations provide suitable amounts of data to help
mitigate the scarcity of training data, as well as the chance to assess the
alignment between LLMs and humans in the awareness of social norms. We thus
harness the power of ChatGPT to generate synthetic training data for our task.
To ensure the quality of both human-authored and synthetic data, we follow a
quality control protocol during data collection. Our experimental results
demonstrate the importance of remediating norm violations in socio-cultural
conversations, as well as the improvement in performance obtained from
synthetic data.
|
[
-0.3457439542,
-1.11546731,
0.0035675401,
0.1066821441,
-0.1600456387,
0.2227387875,
-0.2930471003,
-0.4802413881,
0.3974250853,
0.2896889746,
-0.460585773,
-0.1290087551,
-0.504155159,
0.1614593863,
-0.3615840375,
0.9776997566,
0.1457559615,
0.0080524674,
-0.4182851911,
-0.1419142485,
-0.4614692926,
-0.3406220675,
-0.7612090111,
-0.2530980408,
0.5152711868,
0.6927450895,
0.5175767541,
0.3547761738,
0.4011751413,
0.3286876976,
0.0410075858,
0.6604412794,
-1.0897097588,
0.4655337036,
0.0089379866,
-0.2480200678,
-0.5727241039,
0.0714292005,
0.938326776,
0.1332278997,
-0.1290366799,
0.4918288887,
0.0240930431,
0.4609540403,
-0.4520065486,
0.1598560363,
-0.5527797341,
0.0641557053,
0.0752435923,
-0.1598076373,
-0.2921880484,
-0.523060143,
-0.2564221621,
-0.7078005075,
0.035448052,
-0.1608148813,
1.2100299597,
0.564645648,
-0.4833268225,
0.1290917844,
-0.8885085583,
0.6555335522,
-0.3923003972,
0.4853298366,
0.5057370663,
0.3029406369,
-0.3242405057,
-1.0303570032,
-0.7173011303,
0.1993141919,
-0.0203927271,
0.144330889,
-0.2604554296,
-0.3135398924,
0.4612161517,
0.2313665152,
-0.1482911259,
-0.2813671231,
-0.825689435,
-0.4644207656,
0.9084331393,
0.4388895333,
0.2891224623,
-0.3170529604,
-0.1184215471,
-0.2197309285,
-0.6940892339,
0.2286101878,
0.3391311467,
0.0166950487,
0.1517485678,
0.059297584,
-0.4098398983,
0.4545544982,
-0.0592110977,
-0.2274905294,
0.4362028539,
-0.6603025198,
-0.1509213597,
-0.3199763596,
0.8451880217,
0.6874505877,
0.7507930994,
0.1489356607,
-0.1155266762,
-0.2116958499,
0.7042127252,
-0.869987607,
-0.0691628158,
-0.1220674664,
-0.2869185805,
-0.5785524845,
-0.172665596,
-0.6942772865,
-0.3059493303,
-0.6038736701,
0.262358278,
-0.3399496377,
-0.2293120623,
-0.2067605406,
-0.2022138685,
0.7622221708,
0.5385261774,
-0.7442686558,
0.2446169406,
0.6230197549,
0.8060093522,
0.1343494952,
0.0774870366,
-0.6949062943,
-0.0902045444,
-0.3179062903,
0.6195793748,
-0.5405014157,
-0.7814050913,
-0.03131276,
-0.0152136618,
0.1078949794,
-0.431447506,
0.8421278,
-0.3041937053,
-0.0743645579,
-0.31600371,
-0.2117800862,
-0.1101220027,
0.7905436158,
-0.3131370842,
0.9305611849,
-0.0633580536,
-0.6564049125,
0.4836685956,
-0.2222023904,
-0.5170353651,
0.1914210469,
-0.4149288833,
-0.5556163788,
-0.2483386546,
0.218024984,
0.0648353696,
-0.2867033482,
0.1668722332,
0.1389360279,
-0.6231087446,
0.0906208381,
-0.6270058155,
0.7210376263,
0.3743715286,
0.0044099353,
0.3348671794,
-0.5731002688,
0.0255162381,
0.0990081877,
-0.3174105585,
-0.2917014956,
0.0113003794,
-0.0013085388,
0.1224270239,
0.0725791827,
-0.6229696274,
0.2265233397,
-0.0641026944,
0.5663411617,
0.9629796147,
0.2731746435,
0.1123826429,
-0.734526813,
0.4941175282,
-0.1954210252,
0.6533519626,
0.0718622431,
-0.524584353,
-0.843174994,
-0.3496976197,
-0.0126510058,
0.6015878916,
-0.6630821228,
-0.1902033836,
-0.6347029209,
-0.6180000901,
-0.741744101,
0.2092601359,
0.2741848826,
0.5830621123,
0.1504863203,
-0.3501272798,
-0.711558342,
-0.8871209025,
-0.2486286461,
-0.3607944548,
0.1124380305,
0.6576720476,
0.3622366488,
-0.5674895644,
1.1724114418,
-0.1679228991,
-0.2600470483,
0.2180803716,
0.1915359348,
-0.3027622104,
0.4227490425,
0.0193631556,
-1.0342700481,
-0.5494490862,
-0.3012903333,
-0.7898216248,
0.1004664749,
-0.098465316,
0.0226383787,
0.0688591897,
1.0502666235,
-0.0201333687,
0.5288316011,
0.2255034596,
0.0118808988,
0.6283863783,
-0.3147416413,
0.5286902785,
-1.095267415,
-0.0598212928,
-0.1264178604,
-0.4353879988,
-0.6941987276,
-0.2475625426,
-0.1414524764,
0.0660170391,
-0.6233768463,
0.4188498557,
-0.1160811335,
0.2688610554,
0.1178182289,
0.210397929,
-0.1232319251,
0.345517993,
0.0349984393,
0.8452033997,
0.0470086038,
-0.3601466119,
0.5082448125,
0.5554183722,
-0.2773199379,
0.7765141129,
-0.960690856,
0.3690842688,
-0.2339093983,
0.403986007,
-1.0715154409,
-0.2247824818,
0.3733665347,
-0.6567454338,
-0.0536651313,
-0.2692703009,
-0.5928465724,
0.2094014585,
-0.4153265059,
0.4922285974,
0.8502591252,
-0.1321573704,
0.5183197856,
0.5827078223,
-0.1195473745,
-0.6409377456,
-0.2755908072,
0.3472887874,
-0.1942541301,
-0.9323935509,
-0.2408941686,
0.1049975827,
-0.5507310033,
-0.4032402039,
0.1427556574,
0.2214900553,
0.1272858977,
0.6681620479,
0.114930898,
0.1518959701,
0.2965694368,
-0.0252804179,
-0.1040696874,
0.2768769264,
0.2458914965,
0.4170542955,
-0.4358332455,
-0.2717024386,
-0.4143005013,
0.0412165262,
0.7707386613,
-0.2167190313,
0.5163292289,
1.0558347702,
-0.2276191264,
0.2441840917,
-0.6340095401,
-0.4058722556,
-0.4652740657,
0.0747493804,
-0.3213091493,
-0.8688059449,
0.4485964775,
-0.1454936266,
0.3288781941,
0.1464468688,
0.5126864314,
-0.1634667665,
0.7625014186,
0.3478301764,
-0.0099558532,
0.6675429344,
-0.2479032725,
0.4663495421,
-0.8455924988,
-0.3532021046,
-0.2896814644,
-0.4339810312,
-0.7690044641,
-0.6586569548,
0.5398625135,
-0.4211431742,
-0.3423861563,
0.108132571,
-0.4360860586,
0.38792786,
0.4509831965,
0.0417609327,
0.5597667098,
-0.0919779539,
0.3030368984,
-0.2122676373,
-0.5414114594,
-0.6232115626,
0.988517046,
0.3736788034,
0.77436167,
0.0481190048,
0.6905092597,
0.6597905755,
0.5617516041,
-0.7569539547,
0.5223904252,
0.340262264,
-0.5941159725,
-0.5225772858,
-0.3168714046,
-0.8444396257,
0.2740385532,
-0.4769129455,
-0.5842923522,
0.4795899391,
0.0228813924,
-0.2674154639,
0.1780063212,
-0.5347503424,
0.7694547772,
0.2555605471,
-0.590647161,
-0.5199260712,
-0.6848210692,
0.3475755453,
-0.0907421634,
0.5519530773,
-0.0668706447,
0.4096505046,
0.6366535425,
-0.2493626773,
1.2579407692,
0.0582069457,
-0.0778580457,
0.2999144793,
0.1459836513,
0.5430438519,
0.4369266927,
0.2091037184,
0.2370872945,
0.14391312,
-0.3030577004,
-0.2876754403,
0.5181251764,
-0.9831426144,
-0.6890406013,
-0.3851833642,
-0.5967018008,
-0.0399086513,
0.0411380753,
0.1529839486,
0.2677085102,
-0.7443183064,
0.4071843624,
0.7850170732,
-0.1826002747,
-0.0282817688,
0.3718136251,
-0.0732888505,
-0.2243972421,
1.0099253654,
0.0070562917,
0.310138464,
-0.1983993202,
-0.0167332403,
0.0545479394,
-0.0615133792,
-0.2186591178,
0.131694153,
-0.7581791282,
-0.0798881501,
-0.6645281315,
-0.2780296504,
-0.7331901789,
-0.1316261441,
-0.3254144192,
-0.2135504335,
-0.030342482,
-0.0062977434,
0.5096886158,
0.4650827348,
-0.5663853884,
-0.002697817,
-0.7796213627,
0.2611110508,
0.6942678094,
-0.0578038581,
-0.2524215877,
-0.8951670527,
-0.1182515323,
0.437515676,
-0.2824150026,
-0.3188998997,
0.522805512,
0.3429804444,
0.3331388831,
0.456754446,
0.1546743959,
0.8761739135,
-0.4722976685,
0.5642009377,
-0.2644920647,
-0.6941888928,
0.6043028235,
-0.3880582452,
-0.1837847382,
0.4991755784,
0.2851674855,
-1.2765814066,
-0.495996356,
-0.8086389303,
-0.9071068168,
0.3623611331,
0.1048446894,
0.4123169184,
-0.3562912643,
0.5407546163,
-0.2733511925,
0.0383089036,
-0.2716148794,
-0.0604329556,
-0.2314671278,
0.2962011397,
-0.1126231402,
-0.3730265498,
-0.6076927185,
-0.4930662513,
0.557120502,
0.1081537232,
-0.1259340644,
0.4218136966,
-0.3167772591,
-0.1644700915,
0.1458190233,
0.6978462338,
0.5300843716,
-0.1742276549,
-0.1145532578,
0.4555277228,
-0.6917052269,
0.0965422913,
-0.4841300249,
-0.2059663534,
-0.2808369994,
0.1631218195,
0.4204966724,
0.0639265925,
-0.7493292689,
0.3763861954,
-0.4208218753,
-0.1225241348,
-0.7907141447,
0.2080169767,
-0.0731925368,
0.1381483227,
-0.0501875393,
-0.1003700644,
0.091888465,
-0.6586515903,
0.5136427283,
0.3150478005,
-0.6566665769,
-0.0031512447,
0.3940135837,
0.3746398985,
-0.5406582952,
1.2837445736,
-0.151888594,
-0.2407643795,
0.3533914685,
0.2394588441,
0.4083869457,
-0.1100366414,
0.4452575743,
0.5693272948,
0.3085095584,
0.0684852973,
0.1397517473,
-0.0830277428,
-1.1808034182,
-0.6014643908,
-0.4293792844,
-0.5169823766,
-0.1673983485,
-0.9330615997,
0.1115726158,
-0.5401325226,
-0.2820328772,
-0.1389485896,
-0.158243373,
-0.5304237604,
-0.1519909352,
0.0115855187,
0.7401051521,
-1.3213107586,
0.744576335,
0.5721882582,
-0.6522864103,
-0.4522288442,
-0.3078865111,
0.205910936,
-0.9465347528,
1.0032509565,
-0.336571157,
-0.3877026737,
-0.0022922675,
-0.772572875,
-0.4010401964,
0.8502495885,
0.0445436426,
-0.2878115475,
0.3129581511,
-0.0329869241,
0.7797368765,
-0.0519571155,
0.0926190913,
0.9139895439,
0.6841842532,
0.0989401117,
-0.998634696,
-0.0090110982,
-0.6316154003,
-0.1713862866,
0.0642979071,
-0.8853806853,
0.5023688078,
-0.1498171836,
-0.1195327342,
-0.3225130439,
0.4856748581,
0.1244193092,
0.0741469339,
0.6067672968,
0.3903119266,
0.8006331325,
-0.3426150084,
0.8514078856,
-0.0165678691,
0.1486180723,
0.8097465634,
-0.0998678282,
0.6096206307,
0.5950990915,
0.2072930485,
0.4806018472,
0.6493080854,
-0.0038769606,
0.0357346833,
0.4121328592,
-0.2829848826,
-0.6042422652,
-0.443351835,
-0.0643609688,
0.6774666905,
0.704567492,
0.1491339654,
-0.0223815106,
0.0698744431,
0.0540333614,
0.1728134453,
0.0662377104,
0.992289722,
-0.0561037287,
-0.571605742,
0.7519033551,
-0.2528333366,
0.4330608845,
-0.2065547556,
-0.3052458763,
-0.4898928702,
0.1452052891,
-0.2950249612,
-0.5832831264,
0.3764490485,
-0.1814186126,
-0.1100229248,
-0.5983326435,
0.6413143873,
-0.3264772594,
-0.2127317637,
-0.2029899061,
0.5350445509,
0.5466693044,
0.0766674057,
-0.4695627391,
0.3059193492,
0.0816947967,
0.0105064791,
0.2946312428,
0.4282725453,
-0.4836549163,
0.8043925762,
0.7235232592,
-0.0140564656,
-0.2362898588,
0.1681296676,
0.8653478026,
-0.3716470003,
-0.2402454317,
-0.5990849733,
0.486425072,
-0.3806206882,
-0.2256588489,
0.743955195,
0.3068327904,
0.7955970168,
0.2708648443,
0.6357113123,
0.0274716467,
0.2151017785,
-0.0177371595,
0.6182431579,
-0.3896576762,
0.1193642542,
-0.0825252011,
-0.5883604288,
-0.1365177482,
0.8572083712,
-0.4471188188,
-0.0856013373,
0.0858895108,
0.8951793909,
0.0758747533,
-0.0819071531,
0.3397331834,
0.1612337679,
0.8419218659,
0.2224239111,
0.9714645743,
-0.4725828767,
0.6081113815,
0.1657826006,
-0.2792679369,
-0.4506403506,
-0.6832306385,
-0.6381975412,
-0.6737357974,
-0.3272035122,
-0.4732415378,
0.2815655172,
0.8876626492,
0.5897592902,
-0.5098617673,
-0.104476884,
0.3798591495,
0.2560099959,
-0.281573087,
-0.2119618058,
0.1848623306,
-0.6400060058,
-0.8798626065,
0.3127868772,
0.1863470674,
-0.088940993,
-0.2113456875,
-0.1693440676,
-0.1395207047,
0.2313692421,
0.5651996136,
0.6154807806,
-0.4250808656,
-0.6808166504,
0.1032419279,
-0.1552534699,
0.1598308682,
0.9858683348,
-0.733171165,
0.7184796333,
0.7317928076,
0.4138576984,
0.5399224162,
0.2556485236,
0.8478983641,
-0.9632681012,
0.2529193163,
0.2256439328,
0.3104787171,
0.2945755422,
-0.2899035215,
0.4681757689,
0.2541399002,
-0.766543448,
-0.8778305054,
0.2559806108,
-0.5885010958,
0.023837762,
1.2851747274,
-0.0292138252,
-0.0638194084,
-0.4145232439,
-0.3436231017,
0.4272702634,
-0.3495127857,
1.2320307493,
0.7446888685,
0.0172151607,
-0.040794678,
-0.6480597854,
0.7554242611,
0.3226898313,
-0.5388114452,
0.264144659,
0.7176245451,
0.4014317989,
0.209693104,
0.7636062503,
-0.3757310808,
0.3958032131,
0.0227068067,
0.2153762877,
-0.194659248,
-0.2030929625,
-0.1667610854,
-0.2947718203,
-0.0536171608,
-0.154942587
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11177v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11177v1
|
A Question Answering Based Pipeline for Comprehensive Chinese EHR Information Extraction
| 2024-02-17T02:55:35 | 2024-02-17T02:55:35 |
Huaiyuan Ying, Sheng Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Electronic health records (EHRs) hold significant value for research and
applications. As a new way of information extraction, question answering (QA)
can extract more flexible information than conventional methods and is more
accessible to clinical researchers, but its progress is impeded by the scarcity
of annotated data. In this paper, we propose a novel approach that
automatically generates training data for transfer learning of QA models. Our
pipeline incorporates a preprocessing module to handle challenges posed by
extraction types that are not readily compatible with extractive QA frameworks,
including cases with discontinuous answers and many-to-one relationships. The
obtained QA model exhibits excellent performance on subtasks of information
extraction in EHRs, and it can effectively handle few-shot or zero-shot
settings involving yes-no questions. Case studies and ablation studies
demonstrate the necessity of each component in our design, and the resulting
model is deemed suitable for practical use.
|
[
-0.060879264,
-0.703163743,
0.7588150501,
-0.5674721599,
-0.3674243093,
-0.2227078974,
0.4253992736,
-0.507189095,
0.0404981188,
0.6867614985,
-0.5935507417,
-0.3972584307,
-0.3859114945,
-0.0689618737,
-0.3222061992,
1.1934252977,
-0.0857393891,
0.0515902266,
0.0405531488,
-0.0963429287,
-0.3883823156,
-0.5483837724,
-0.5833542347,
-0.185849905,
0.4123176336,
0.4465333521,
0.3162973821,
0.8768303394,
0.6147499681,
0.1400017142,
0.165824011,
-0.0010157778,
-0.1255760789,
0.1207742169,
0.0509834923,
-0.4978981018,
-0.5903533101,
-0.5357836485,
0.3413707316,
0.3285036087,
-0.3893517256,
0.7479442358,
-0.2459059805,
0.4958363175,
-0.5951569676,
0.0605908446,
-0.8702869415,
0.1785243154,
-0.1280411482,
-0.3736687005,
-0.3897218108,
-0.4562793076,
0.5781258345,
-0.613309443,
0.1384258121,
-0.251863718,
1.1152803898,
0.2010544986,
-0.355058074,
-0.1671127975,
-0.7362619042,
0.4681536555,
-0.6870993376,
0.2329872251,
0.1520297676,
0.645255506,
0.4134174585,
-0.9765079021,
-0.4624621272,
0.5112656355,
-0.0380196199,
0.1852028966,
0.0625814646,
0.0434372015,
0.1826073229,
0.2345744669,
-0.6319779754,
-0.1880367398,
-0.745072782,
0.0718568936,
0.5354238749,
0.329131484,
0.492146641,
-0.4541057348,
-0.3617379069,
-0.0667477772,
-0.4615812898,
0.3558093607,
-0.508194387,
0.1689870209,
-0.0944872051,
0.38488096,
-0.2135383934,
0.4023278952,
0.226356104,
-0.0784476548,
0.3826551437,
-0.1320603937,
-0.3420009017,
0.0789230391,
0.5539346337,
-0.0213587005,
-0.0610783137,
-0.2908000648,
-0.156879276,
-0.4731304944,
0.2781836689,
-0.9102389216,
-0.5470231771,
0.8562477827,
-0.5402443409,
-0.171681881,
0.3773063421,
-0.8648784161,
-0.1520353407,
-0.2100545764,
0.5407127738,
-0.2978675663,
-0.2331222445,
0.121546872,
-0.1226830035,
0.6897434592,
0.1843928248,
-0.8036936522,
0.1608574986,
0.5172547102,
0.6292315125,
-0.2572441697,
0.1471638381,
-1.0565644503,
0.0559715778,
-0.1022511274,
0.659434557,
-0.2710795999,
-0.0733573437,
0.1624093056,
0.2420597076,
-0.1742253304,
-0.6493136883,
0.2182391733,
-0.8814616799,
0.3454327881,
-0.040186923,
-0.5394698977,
-0.1507223845,
0.3673555553,
-0.7201983929,
0.6358491182,
0.2350952774,
-0.8498697281,
0.1261006147,
-0.6211691499,
-0.2412154526,
0.4454932511,
-0.1210328788,
-0.6458313465,
-0.3522489965,
0.4713897109,
0.3952951133,
-0.271127522,
0.2656951249,
-0.0859950334,
-0.0881781951,
0.1671938151,
0.0811073631,
0.9102398753,
0.4708187282,
-0.0365164205,
0.1447688639,
-0.7602867484,
0.3949106038,
0.1301186234,
-0.3103653789,
-0.1133989543,
-0.3564095795,
-0.1283068955,
0.6041217446,
0.317681998,
-0.5953343511,
0.0276621804,
-0.2713242173,
0.3702640533,
0.36628443,
0.5447942019,
0.0542338639,
-0.6368732452,
0.8252762556,
0.1619818509,
0.3291480243,
-0.4248421788,
-0.2264649123,
-0.7376271486,
-0.152721256,
0.3581452668,
0.882740736,
-0.9965550303,
0.4546902478,
-0.442448616,
-0.5091314912,
-0.9564522505,
0.0782766193,
0.0595894605,
0.9417093992,
0.7066674829,
-0.3188407719,
-0.4254058599,
-0.5735458136,
0.1716551036,
-0.4519220591,
-0.4433708787,
0.0184328686,
0.1534877867,
0.1881948858,
0.8311190009,
-0.519400835,
-0.2257635742,
-0.5451687574,
0.1208789498,
0.2113560736,
0.2512190938,
0.0451306179,
-0.902664423,
-0.3056074083,
0.3446641266,
-1.0919345617,
0.0341392756,
-0.4149922729,
-0.2245162129,
-0.53419137,
0.1384615302,
-0.5084881783,
0.2610758543,
0.1704833657,
0.140025869,
0.4437734187,
0.0392912626,
0.0939754397,
-1.1881582737,
0.5304734111,
0.0016524678,
-0.208949551,
-0.9069091082,
0.1785088629,
0.2544650733,
-0.163788259,
-0.9813070297,
0.4606348276,
-0.247823298,
0.2150896937,
-0.0368539542,
0.0002223104,
0.4290826917,
0.4712910354,
0.2255305201,
0.2320527732,
0.4985605478,
-0.674320817,
0.4244119823,
0.8464599252,
0.1779123992,
0.3635434508,
-0.7273429036,
0.4996554255,
-0.4192867875,
-0.011885277,
-0.5032112598,
-0.188063845,
0.4762052,
-0.2834467292,
0.1939267069,
-0.5645740628,
0.0044938358,
-0.3107464015,
-0.2104462683,
0.2243668884,
0.7941894531,
-0.4113211036,
0.6482684016,
0.4743337333,
-0.5787072778,
-0.354795754,
-0.5028135777,
-0.4160639942,
-0.385216713,
-0.4359546006,
0.2404584885,
0.0705234855,
0.000004699,
0.1135102212,
0.0515272804,
-0.7775934935,
-0.0071193706,
-0.0862110034,
0.7545590997,
-0.4738558233,
0.3783362508,
0.0840027332,
0.149900347,
0.2643916011,
-0.1939808428,
0.0870527551,
0.2739422619,
-0.3979025483,
-0.771948874,
0.3253059387,
0.4162382483,
-0.7100830078,
0.4758418202,
0.320414722,
-0.6361817718,
-0.1041158065,
-0.3642333448,
-0.3019414246,
-0.3980510533,
0.5580570698,
-0.2050794214,
-0.4902376831,
0.4492323101,
0.0007061752,
0.5590267777,
0.3901476562,
0.3052385151,
0.0974128097,
0.7979705334,
0.5329275727,
0.024697803,
0.3472733498,
-0.1344220787,
-0.1266325861,
-0.7514508963,
-0.3169209361,
-0.4628601074,
0.2714482248,
-0.3120107949,
-0.0888418406,
0.5833208561,
-0.1253273338,
-0.2821231186,
0.1141529232,
-0.4442611933,
0.1788713783,
0.0884304047,
0.4410801232,
0.2998009026,
-0.2674235404,
0.4203414321,
0.1697697937,
-0.7263990641,
-0.5266076922,
1.1516783237,
0.5340059996,
0.2785658538,
-0.0555205718,
0.6468709707,
-0.0022009313,
0.368180722,
-0.5281940103,
0.038430322,
-0.1381691545,
-0.5576552749,
-0.5875923038,
-0.4286257625,
-0.8734890819,
0.2095507532,
-0.3905933201,
-0.6157195568,
0.0887448266,
0.0668252185,
-0.8369427323,
0.5152283907,
-0.422950238,
0.9644657969,
-0.2838765979,
-0.1888901889,
0.538449049,
-1.0407004356,
0.2663490772,
-0.3287129104,
0.2024441659,
-0.032279525,
0.4276888967,
0.7319224477,
-0.3185284436,
0.3578100204,
-0.1906772554,
0.1767176241,
0.6504594088,
-0.0260380823,
0.4681725204,
-0.1425168365,
-0.2622804046,
-0.0909686908,
0.5688257813,
-0.443046093,
-0.5730531812,
-0.0536207035,
-0.4974996448,
-0.3717247844,
-0.0976146013,
-0.2523966134,
-0.2656729519,
0.3308145702,
0.2117201388,
0.3204738498,
0.0151567049,
-0.0706737712,
0.7974345684,
-0.2711567283,
-0.1229285076,
0.3794955611,
-0.0148128802,
-0.0985671431,
0.8424303532,
0.1006741673,
0.2521530986,
0.4921528697,
0.1859842837,
-0.3736744523,
-0.6644468307,
-0.7840934396,
0.2946662605,
-0.6826301217,
-0.0694806501,
-0.7270349264,
-0.8051048517,
-0.395988524,
0.3574614227,
-0.1445084214,
0.0259531923,
-0.6269107461,
-0.3247032762,
0.1141203567,
0.5326490402,
0.4267754853,
0.102912426,
-1.5539492369,
0.4900326729,
0.5594494343,
-0.0915663913,
-0.0183955468,
-0.7872437835,
-0.3138386309,
-0.1283583343,
-0.4797072709,
-0.9760046601,
0.5848113298,
0.205801636,
0.4360135198,
0.4879347086,
0.49067384,
0.686380446,
-0.4295003712,
0.8166700602,
0.0959033445,
-0.6215308309,
0.5345275998,
-0.156335324,
0.0903453976,
0.7864419222,
0.4808058441,
-0.5426874161,
-0.0345302969,
-0.6431178451,
-0.7873831987,
0.5036720634,
-0.2409203947,
0.0248095095,
0.1469720453,
0.6785250306,
0.4096994698,
0.1086607799,
-0.6185740232,
-0.219542101,
-0.0773645565,
-0.3702246249,
0.5641952753,
0.0409371853,
0.0968069509,
0.0716419592,
0.6276096106,
-0.1543860584,
-0.0661313906,
0.5818035603,
-0.1526053548,
-0.3473289907,
0.605286181,
-0.302310437,
0.7594816685,
-0.2943191826,
0.1210786551,
0.257996887,
-0.2424683422,
0.0570951775,
0.1528867185,
-0.3044589758,
-0.0580998734,
0.1230166703,
0.6339688897,
-0.5410164595,
-0.8078228831,
0.6270071864,
-0.112425074,
-0.2011850625,
-0.3634211421,
-0.0246102177,
-0.12019182,
0.1004066169,
0.4450191259,
-0.466756314,
0.4181882143,
-0.3320093751,
0.7607549429,
0.1480859816,
-0.6991442442,
-0.4352264404,
0.8482453823,
0.0104418332,
-0.1334056258,
0.8334566355,
0.2309150696,
-0.3753222227,
0.5551448464,
0.2625713944,
0.7568870783,
-0.2580920458,
0.3576542735,
0.5307301283,
-0.060065344,
0.1035512313,
0.2264167368,
0.1767974645,
-0.4799590409,
-0.3766864538,
-0.2780065238,
-0.6164933443,
0.3391903639,
-1.1015040874,
0.5149418712,
-0.3328847587,
0.2041203082,
-0.0625795275,
-0.2727874219,
-0.8619685769,
0.4679863155,
0.2466221154,
0.5771251917,
-0.9176098704,
0.8568620086,
0.5523220897,
-0.5901733041,
-1.0823366642,
-0.1032203585,
-0.2541697621,
-0.6459462047,
0.3202900887,
0.0853963643,
0.459118098,
-0.0186258759,
-0.2873333991,
-0.5841272473,
1.1882163286,
0.4842478633,
-0.3715718091,
-0.340108335,
0.2349757403,
0.6236197948,
-0.2642199695,
0.3783805668,
0.5371552706,
0.0506149344,
0.2477106005,
-0.843580246,
0.2132273316,
-0.3838524818,
-0.578617692,
-0.0651213601,
-0.5095716715,
0.8293553591,
-0.2006627023,
-0.5329119563,
0.0125104627,
0.5043427944,
0.275010705,
0.4127061665,
0.3115259707,
0.1715430915,
0.8608503938,
0.3774738014,
0.8992801905,
-0.1973528564,
0.1580374092,
1.0116660595,
-0.4542826116,
0.9554223418,
0.4901795685,
-0.1301873475,
0.5471603274,
0.6699562669,
0.1986438334,
0.4211176336,
0.1159372702,
-0.0823001787,
-0.3315324783,
-0.2474982738,
-0.4223591685,
0.1900848001,
0.0899116099,
-0.3975094259,
-0.1659049243,
-0.3160385787,
-0.195801422,
-0.3310776949,
-0.0995307118,
1.1531687975,
0.1598953903,
-0.6530940533,
0.3750657737,
-0.2400075048,
0.1563798785,
-0.7722895741,
-0.4860564768,
0.0161600094,
-0.4277918637,
-0.4082266092,
-0.4844560027,
0.2411271483,
0.0261853207,
0.108692795,
0.0493210293,
0.5886428356,
-0.5442961454,
-0.2459909022,
-0.1513701379,
0.9530395865,
0.4082997143,
0.076236248,
-0.6598827839,
-0.5979089141,
0.1004017293,
-0.1005272716,
0.296505183,
0.7189234495,
0.1655088365,
0.5537891388,
0.7476818562,
0.6302798986,
0.2260582596,
-0.1881254613,
0.7401642203,
-0.5651932359,
-0.7276499867,
-0.5836188197,
0.7541085482,
0.083565712,
-0.3156879842,
0.2020328641,
0.3141646087,
0.5057798028,
0.0042002718,
1.1650872231,
0.1968090385,
0.8862570524,
-0.5602397323,
0.6213723421,
-0.3685897589,
0.3120536506,
-0.0697750673,
-0.5045236945,
-0.205083847,
0.2603342235,
-0.2280625403,
-0.4288296998,
0.4997592568,
0.2513510585,
0.0846306756,
-0.0122826714,
0.3798328042,
-0.1259160936,
0.62991184,
0.9030144811,
0.594111681,
-0.7067251801,
0.6520624161,
-0.3545114696,
-0.0763858631,
0.083477512,
-0.6270396709,
-0.5300744772,
-0.4775741398,
-0.5140112638,
-0.2157061249,
-0.01503204,
0.9546405077,
0.8843692541,
-0.9833875299,
0.1606214643,
0.2364174426,
-0.0770282,
-0.1852828562,
-0.2124094367,
0.7806553245,
-0.1551544815,
-0.3390972912,
-0.045038566,
-0.0633529574,
-0.0275051016,
0.0688184202,
0.1654686928,
-0.004650068,
-0.0992091969,
0.1559984088,
0.7176252007,
-0.2126683146,
-0.349372834,
0.3055242002,
0.0904552788,
0.5859091282,
0.5010458827,
-0.6201047301,
0.5998317003,
0.4375112951,
1.2100255489,
0.4211850464,
0.5259132385,
0.2732912898,
-0.579230547,
-0.2572910488,
0.3639942408,
0.1074054614,
0.4095104039,
-0.6225224733,
0.1560907662,
-0.0774184018,
-0.4850559831,
-0.54388237,
0.0322845392,
-0.7736482024,
-0.0831999257,
0.9593473077,
-0.440815568,
-0.3129134178,
-0.6089177132,
-0.1724318415,
0.5480670929,
-0.151299879,
0.8540691733,
0.235658437,
-0.3778423071,
-0.4054116607,
-0.5846969485,
0.257458806,
0.2686665952,
-1.3242585659,
0.0992374271,
0.2886973917,
0.5093641877,
-0.0720955729,
0.7837455273,
-0.484149158,
0.5547578335,
-0.507193923,
0.25440377,
0.0706604421,
-0.2414448112,
-0.5790074468,
0.5313751101,
0.2940033078,
-0.5729992986
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11176v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11176v2
|
KnowTuning: Knowledge-aware Fine-tuning for Large Language Models
| 2024-02-17T02:54:32 | 2024-04-17T11:45:00 |
Yougang Lyu, Lingyong Yan, Shuaiqiang Wang, Haibo Shi, Dawei Yin, Pengjie Ren, Zhumin Chen, Maarten de Rijke, Zhaochun Ren
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Despite their success at many natural language processing (NLP) tasks, large
language models still struggle to effectively leverage knowledge for
knowledge-intensive tasks, manifesting limitations such as generating
incomplete, non-factual, or illogical answers. These limitations stem from
inadequate knowledge awareness of LLMs during vanilla fine-tuning. To address
these problems, we propose a knowledge-aware fine-tuning (KnowTuning) method to
improve fine-grained and coarse-grained knowledge awareness of LLMs. We devise
a fine-grained knowledge augmentation stage to train LLMs to identify difficult
fine-grained knowledge in answers. We also propose a coarse-grained knowledge
comparison stage to train LLMs to distinguish between reliable and unreliable
knowledge, in three aspects: completeness, factuality, and logicality.
Extensive experiments on both generic and medical question answering (QA)
datasets confirm the effectiveness of KnowTuning, through automatic and human
evaluations, across various sizes of LLMs. We further verify that KnowTuning
generates more facts with less factual error rate under fine-grained facts
evaluation.
|
[
-0.3540432453,
-0.9930704832,
0.7463393807,
-0.1162787378,
-0.0342055745,
-0.0197808258,
-0.4538105428,
-0.5818191767,
-0.1451959461,
0.3459794223,
-0.4700237811,
-0.4318905175,
-0.4216525257,
-0.0287759788,
-0.1664776802,
1.0266083479,
0.1165537685,
0.1981428415,
-0.5592566729,
-0.0569143854,
-0.5113908648,
-0.0778977722,
-0.94577384,
-0.5021747351,
0.5085008144,
0.6176104546,
0.6659439802,
0.7975193858,
0.5054562092,
0.2417844236,
-0.3177357316,
0.6113349199,
-0.5738654733,
0.1499042064,
-0.4253636599,
-0.7218667269,
-0.4563333094,
-0.3299680948,
0.192063123,
0.6453660727,
0.0016192523,
0.2476307303,
0.1458456218,
0.7121137977,
-0.5258710384,
0.15617311,
-0.9431288242,
-0.0491004959,
-0.0600988753,
-0.2686269879,
0.1416896284,
-0.4866445959,
0.2024879605,
-0.6661129594,
0.363217324,
0.1107214913,
0.7331874371,
0.65034163,
-0.1305422187,
-0.244399175,
-0.6490150094,
0.618540585,
-0.9287094474,
0.3540349305,
0.639791429,
0.2629828453,
-0.1341435462,
-0.5977412462,
-0.5755892396,
0.0273406692,
-0.0785148591,
-0.1025748327,
0.0023407661,
0.2790468931,
0.3788626194,
0.5716041327,
-0.3755274117,
0.2466453314,
-0.1924752295,
-0.3860431314,
0.3173395693,
0.0065054973,
0.164101243,
-0.0697176829,
-0.2333745658,
0.2533776462,
-0.5751360655,
0.0718471929,
-0.177560702,
0.1295250654,
0.0958313495,
0.6061165929,
-0.7237768769,
0.9406210184,
0.201746434,
-0.3436445892,
0.0479914285,
-0.3828201294,
-0.347186923,
0.0240751412,
0.4381937385,
0.5511462092,
0.4118326902,
-0.3097821176,
-0.3068516552,
-0.1722246557,
0.1596505046,
-0.6746520996,
-0.1568990201,
0.3244717717,
0.0043092589,
-0.4073903859,
-0.3797169924,
-0.4352351427,
-0.7337824106,
-0.5733349919,
0.7866680026,
-0.7225465775,
-0.0739663839,
0.3239736557,
-0.1094428599,
0.3332837224,
0.394213587,
-0.8782088757,
0.1475206465,
0.7170593143,
0.5533769727,
0.1822559237,
-0.1337440908,
-0.675206244,
0.1878466308,
-0.2219095826,
0.8679635525,
-0.3396671414,
0.1966118664,
-0.2051858157,
-0.2190616727,
0.0972936824,
-0.7425655723,
0.6151628494,
-0.5997326374,
-0.1116955802,
-0.5115742087,
-0.9294444919,
-0.1646256447,
0.7248334885,
-0.3066759706,
0.9549919963,
0.1898530871,
-0.814865768,
0.5083277225,
-0.4581651092,
-0.4888315201,
0.0338693261,
-0.1515021622,
-0.3656211495,
0.1687216312,
0.4443713725,
0.7304636836,
-0.2639050484,
0.4176773727,
-0.3970030546,
-0.0517511778,
0.0430541635,
-0.34962672,
0.2421586365,
0.202762574,
-0.1166361496,
0.164264977,
-0.980073154,
0.3372243941,
-0.0679316446,
-0.4263015687,
-0.4479911029,
-0.1049231663,
-0.5107941628,
0.1289980561,
0.4606296122,
-0.5693723559,
0.0504935831,
-0.7457284927,
0.3476387858,
0.5926110744,
0.1135207936,
0.3992607594,
-0.8305546641,
0.1784130335,
0.1860334575,
0.1553455293,
0.0773733258,
-0.2447126657,
-1.0900224447,
0.2232875675,
0.2236559391,
0.6316363215,
-0.8769467473,
0.3658524752,
-0.1637811065,
-0.5798354149,
-0.5821937919,
0.4576839209,
0.4805285335,
0.8958815336,
0.5664782524,
0.0937030092,
-0.5780527592,
-0.8792886734,
-0.5305832028,
0.0598224625,
-0.0573682711,
0.266022414,
0.2131594867,
-0.1628288031,
0.9126470685,
-0.5448789001,
-0.5222675204,
-0.0052853818,
-0.0214340631,
0.0132889375,
0.4603566229,
0.1317109764,
-0.5670846701,
-0.1616698354,
0.3173139393,
-0.6325934529,
0.0213591643,
0.025216626,
0.0939223617,
-0.0143931881,
0.7758360505,
-0.5079288483,
0.0137085514,
0.3886421919,
-0.1855359674,
0.5729120374,
-0.4578976333,
0.0285555013,
-1.0823721886,
-0.1081925407,
-0.1563737392,
-0.5533421636,
-0.5358032584,
-0.0694407821,
0.1566264927,
0.2333461791,
-0.2986923754,
0.6247481108,
-0.3517212868,
0.2012464851,
-0.1235869676,
0.2437390536,
0.0687084273,
0.3743230104,
-0.0491123982,
0.7852881551,
0.5736458302,
-0.9103870988,
0.4070254564,
0.1373702586,
-0.5788975954,
0.684487462,
-0.5150414705,
0.0479632355,
-0.1188178584,
-0.4368778467,
-0.6607626677,
-0.4502047598,
-0.1131930873,
-0.3511013687,
0.3168413043,
-0.2215215862,
-0.3841643631,
-0.2662035823,
0.016403269,
0.3142428398,
0.3560545743,
-0.3688917458,
0.636813581,
0.3104787171,
-0.1966945827,
-0.449890852,
-0.4504240751,
-0.2179454118,
-0.1126499772,
-0.5995922089,
-0.033068724,
-0.0099071832,
-0.1758861244,
-0.1054992974,
-0.4193223119,
-0.2281797379,
0.2139325142,
-0.1020755619,
-0.2833662927,
-0.1522266418,
0.6098988652,
0.2058425397,
-0.0394007452,
0.0374892615,
-0.4942345321,
0.5067472458,
-0.2374100238,
-0.3529163003,
-0.1847283989,
-0.2317824811,
0.5081506371,
-0.3620263338,
0.5673094392,
0.8197762966,
-0.522815764,
-0.235703364,
-0.9672728777,
-0.3856200874,
-0.4495689571,
0.4760853052,
-0.2933500707,
-1.1739434004,
0.5666353703,
-0.2949738204,
0.0113445194,
0.3980424404,
0.3873395622,
-0.2202897221,
0.7706087232,
0.6023303866,
0.0698934868,
0.1951712966,
-0.0026389903,
-0.1246625856,
-0.7173788548,
-0.168544203,
-0.4373932779,
-0.3359484076,
-0.3475437462,
-0.6131599545,
0.5112814307,
0.2366483063,
-0.3238891065,
-0.0996330529,
-0.2511507273,
0.7147392035,
0.5398916602,
0.4320435226,
0.6059297919,
-0.2013161033,
-0.1182930693,
0.1513753533,
-0.9061371088,
-0.2594092488,
0.9915216565,
0.2466799766,
0.842931211,
-0.1548298597,
0.353351891,
-0.0774040148,
-0.0064236941,
-0.9081162214,
0.3762655556,
-0.1262577921,
-0.6004762053,
-0.4925861955,
-0.5686424971,
-0.5747684836,
-0.3036462665,
-0.5444040298,
-0.3718005121,
-0.0868250504,
0.4730426967,
-0.7971220613,
0.4594212174,
-0.8473043442,
0.7811486125,
-0.2305914462,
-0.160264641,
-0.1969374418,
-0.6398354769,
0.3499034643,
-0.1760727167,
0.2418745309,
-0.1342238933,
0.1167977676,
0.6682292223,
-0.2908677161,
0.9364394546,
-0.1084726527,
-0.3012667,
0.009711857,
0.0969084948,
0.6168630719,
0.3294586241,
-0.023167409,
-0.1873902678,
0.2782069147,
-0.2459142357,
-0.6811705232,
0.7364439368,
-0.5780178308,
-0.6557424068,
0.053644985,
-0.7244949341,
-0.7885875702,
0.463609308,
0.2228547037,
0.4259101748,
-0.1513759345,
0.1906030625,
1.3221474886,
-0.1404416859,
-0.0075704469,
0.6499962211,
-0.2704252899,
-0.247270748,
0.8166275024,
0.1157272086,
0.4036036134,
0.6127524972,
0.3543106318,
-0.1558119655,
-0.7800791264,
-0.2496094555,
0.2082115114,
-0.5722948909,
-0.5560361743,
-0.5694441199,
-0.4488748014,
-0.3874234855,
0.1081030071,
-0.4596512914,
-0.4319929183,
-0.2906161845,
-0.1441439539,
0.6820716262,
0.6665309668,
0.0419061035,
0.320022136,
-0.8896654844,
0.589686811,
0.8383087516,
0.9035789371,
-0.1088385433,
-0.6061694026,
-0.4940083921,
0.3000856638,
-0.1048053876,
-0.3153299391,
-0.0667050183,
0.4630335569,
0.2851025164,
0.5417389274,
0.1884757131,
0.785569787,
-0.458176434,
0.3420245051,
-0.1463640183,
-0.6871346831,
0.6397773027,
-0.4993432462,
0.5627561212,
0.7717692256,
0.0665184259,
-0.6082865596,
-0.676101923,
-0.4955336452,
-0.5713545084,
0.5149275661,
-0.0646319762,
0.0134512205,
0.0524836369,
0.5666353703,
0.109085314,
0.2318751365,
-0.4767541885,
-0.1006229371,
0.2132726312,
-0.2639624476,
-0.0413056761,
-0.4101113975,
-0.2454448044,
-0.3515563309,
0.7699331641,
-0.2957697213,
-0.1194886416,
0.4477056563,
-0.255158335,
-0.1964843571,
0.5252757072,
0.5632209182,
0.7620107532,
-0.1906255931,
0.3437207639,
0.5658501387,
-0.437741667,
-0.1765378118,
0.1125714183,
-0.3031294644,
-0.3782987893,
0.3199996054,
0.7859624624,
0.3302210569,
-0.6119345427,
0.3673853576,
-0.0802431181,
-0.1524342597,
-0.2716362774,
0.4992897213,
0.3095844686,
0.3422712982,
0.0340870321,
0.4548401833,
0.0167370718,
-0.2633043826,
0.2231133878,
0.5499614477,
-0.6566830277,
-0.0342047364,
0.5590048432,
0.1042807996,
-0.0607478544,
0.2810045779,
-0.1898779571,
-0.3273370266,
0.3768238425,
0.3682097197,
0.4265666008,
-0.0976317376,
-0.0543449894,
0.2810520828,
0.361091435,
-0.2927657068,
0.3902483582,
0.0932882354,
-0.9736509919,
-0.7022089958,
-0.7982939482,
-0.1537379473,
0.3532237411,
-0.5874741077,
0.3035438359,
-0.5156342983,
-0.1713726223,
0.0158094093,
-0.0264373031,
-0.8406731486,
0.4952050745,
-0.1115385741,
1.0481262207,
-0.6056140065,
0.7121784091,
0.7921389937,
-0.1568074077,
-1.115110755,
-0.0921725854,
-0.2224113643,
-0.9638550878,
0.3061144352,
0.0143800993,
-0.0128918905,
0.4226141572,
-0.5715556741,
-0.747318089,
1.0469661951,
0.4108171165,
-0.7902451754,
-0.1271760762,
0.1490379721,
0.5331279635,
0.039141465,
0.0412779488,
0.8250133395,
0.5151879191,
0.0210048612,
-1.1880967617,
-0.0955948308,
0.0580786392,
-0.2929307818,
0.1577784121,
-0.4719593823,
0.362922132,
-0.4060270488,
-0.0367945135,
0.0034596003,
0.5639865994,
0.0021447397,
0.4252280891,
0.5267255902,
0.961048007,
1.2072441578,
-0.2254834324,
0.7950932384,
-0.3157891333,
0.2064392418,
1.3555811644,
0.1346624494,
0.6295918822,
0.4066942036,
-0.057128109,
0.0980673358,
0.3473202288,
0.2930108011,
0.1503192782,
0.1444433928,
-0.3153870106,
-0.6582247019,
-0.0477426425,
-0.3211098909,
0.4887765646,
0.3219043314,
-0.1314128786,
-0.3410906196,
0.1883814186,
0.1907034069,
0.1394315064,
-0.6795268655,
1.2569019794,
0.1224185675,
-0.6820755601,
0.7882644534,
-0.1187349632,
0.5919299126,
-0.6844373345,
0.0960348547,
-0.2207663059,
0.1871792227,
-0.3203448653,
-0.9434757233,
0.2478177696,
-0.041672349,
-0.5195342898,
0.0437070243,
0.961175561,
-0.6781086922,
-0.3995660245,
-0.0434661694,
0.7024710178,
-0.058412496,
-0.3407329917,
-0.4335930645,
-0.4157351851,
0.060447786,
0.0000230113,
0.2656953931,
0.8659315109,
0.0402865484,
1.0679959059,
0.5727430582,
0.3601428568,
0.0094217537,
0.1906120777,
0.9205889702,
-0.5676227212,
-0.2117321193,
-0.8063205481,
0.2123353034,
-0.0529341772,
-0.168835029,
0.6187579036,
0.540522337,
0.9127383232,
-0.1982574016,
0.7765291333,
0.0625065118,
0.8500294089,
-0.8198446631,
0.9604743123,
-0.4035711586,
0.3667427301,
0.0022288009,
-0.6436311603,
-0.4160917997,
0.3360323906,
-0.4696645141,
0.0444785729,
0.5384370089,
0.8125374317,
-0.1357291043,
-0.0363013931,
0.5435652137,
0.6471278667,
0.096089378,
0.5282975435,
0.5978954434,
-0.2371771932,
0.5982471704,
-0.3990370631,
-0.1172083691,
0.0063693817,
-0.8722728491,
-0.8663764,
-0.4517439604,
-0.1446304768,
-0.2086122632,
-0.0212150831,
0.800419569,
0.6407182813,
-0.7809680104,
0.2392680943,
-0.2435396463,
0.3703047037,
-0.2059976906,
-0.2036697417,
0.2304810733,
-0.9154785275,
-0.3155268431,
0.2027773708,
0.1599907428,
0.0648692921,
-0.0459609628,
0.1588507444,
-0.0676642358,
-0.0646311641,
0.6016814709,
0.2287277728,
-0.412137866,
-0.5137660503,
-0.0073385308,
-0.0067554512,
0.0443385132,
0.649183929,
-0.8767045736,
0.5473732352,
0.2725405693,
0.7362064123,
0.1397005618,
0.1398038268,
0.5078508258,
-0.9919676781,
-0.1169450805,
0.2787005901,
0.2154432237,
0.3831237257,
-0.4375777245,
0.2521958649,
0.033849854,
-0.7798259854,
-0.47558254,
0.3467765152,
-0.9074351788,
-0.159838751,
1.2051525116,
0.0729187503,
-0.1529551893,
-0.4377206862,
-0.4357676804,
0.4012045562,
-0.1656878144,
0.9125515819,
0.6417896748,
0.106012471,
-0.1316287965,
-0.5842897296,
1.0167733431,
0.4614531398,
-0.9365947843,
0.3364594281,
0.4269174337,
0.6025505662,
-0.0032875764,
0.4227688313,
0.0593816489,
0.2069147825,
-0.5195040703,
-0.0354669914,
-0.3364754021,
-0.1549854577,
-0.0939433649,
0.0175324362,
0.5464536548,
0.2904765308
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11175v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11175v2
|
M4GT-Bench: Evaluation Benchmark for Black-Box Machine-Generated Text Detection
| 2024-02-17T02:50:33 | 2024-06-27T05:42:12 |
Yuxia Wang, Jonibek Mansurov, Petar Ivanov, Jinyan Su, Artem Shelmanov, Akim Tsvigun, Osama Mohanned Afzal, Tarek Mahmoud, Giovanni Puccetti, Thomas Arnold, Alham Fikri Aji, Nizar Habash, Iryna Gurevych, Preslav Nakov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The advent of Large Language Models (LLMs) has brought an unprecedented surge
in machine-generated text (MGT) across diverse channels. This raises legitimate
concerns about its potential misuse and societal implications. The need to
identify and differentiate such content from genuine human-generated text is
critical in combating disinformation, preserving the integrity of education and
scientific fields, and maintaining trust in communication. In this work, we
address this problem by introducing a new benchmark based on a multilingual,
multi-domain, and multi-generator corpus of MGTs -- M4GT-Bench. The benchmark
is compiled of three tasks: (1) mono-lingual and multi-lingual binary MGT
detection; (2) multi-way detection where one need to identify, which particular
model generated the text; and (3) mixed human-machine text detection, where a
word boundary delimiting MGT from human-written content should be determined.
On the developed benchmark, we have tested several MGT detection baselines and
also conducted an evaluation of human performance. We see that obtaining good
performance in MGT detection usually requires an access to the training data
from the same domain and generators. The benchmark is available at
https://github.com/mbzuai-nlp/M4GT-Bench.
|
[
-0.526234746,
-0.8493615985,
0.4870590568,
0.0079873959,
-0.3459972441,
0.3483225405,
-0.3454194069,
-0.4685342014,
-0.139439255,
0.2389506251,
-0.5248032212,
-0.6622179747,
-0.6617114544,
0.5614231229,
-0.3816565871,
0.9481207132,
-0.1892729998,
-0.067736797,
-0.0538863912,
-0.1383572221,
-0.4602940381,
-0.7788689137,
-0.4060879946,
-0.4571270049,
0.4927051663,
0.1142114028,
0.3886237741,
0.4964283109,
0.2940770984,
0.3145468831,
0.16993545,
0.2936261594,
-0.4954409897,
0.0494413599,
0.0078437608,
-0.142297551,
-0.1684265882,
0.1876858175,
0.8933244348,
-0.000704143,
-0.0133674135,
0.2629481554,
0.214334175,
0.2767873108,
-0.7062556148,
0.0695271119,
-0.8079858422,
0.1173261777,
-0.5015258193,
-0.3735064864,
-0.4407863915,
-0.1656784862,
-0.2754035294,
-0.3005366921,
0.5009641647,
-0.0369786322,
0.9063084722,
-0.0102204205,
-0.3993895948,
-0.2462769002,
-0.3242319524,
0.7393203378,
-0.5429962277,
0.6114026308,
0.1699972749,
0.4977781177,
-0.0857151151,
-0.6853687763,
-0.7040965557,
-0.153716296,
0.0628796816,
0.1994181275,
-0.2702044547,
-0.3138800859,
0.3229126036,
0.1779830605,
-0.7171105146,
-0.0849213526,
-0.2183364034,
-0.5924168229,
0.3359581828,
-0.0313306786,
0.1383788884,
-0.3683771789,
-0.5109230876,
-0.1106243879,
-0.6423447728,
-0.4346330166,
0.6025246978,
0.0928665251,
-0.0748787001,
0.5029808283,
-0.173357442,
0.4828219712,
-0.2699636817,
-0.3168034554,
0.6390652657,
-0.5226235986,
0.022700768,
-0.002570445,
1.0453453064,
0.3076331615,
0.2860148847,
-0.2610987723,
-0.3839348257,
0.4119719565,
0.3599100113,
-1.0432561636,
-0.0961266458,
-0.2127235085,
-0.4070479572,
-0.3572391272,
-0.0835898146,
-0.9911022186,
-0.3598847389,
-0.1550496072,
0.5004063249,
-0.3708432615,
-0.4332157075,
0.0707374811,
-0.120504424,
0.0619256236,
-0.1533907652,
-0.7624981403,
0.1505950093,
0.7253835797,
0.8836910129,
-0.4362877905,
-0.4673064053,
-0.6008556485,
0.1522948146,
0.0034225795,
0.8404132128,
-0.3393337131,
-0.3591754436,
0.0275441799,
0.0151073551,
0.000718828,
-0.5020387769,
0.96394521,
-0.2210936695,
0.0813668147,
-0.1273752749,
-0.3656168282,
0.0594868809,
0.6667584181,
-0.6047653556,
1.3150680065,
0.2435048819,
-0.8252736926,
0.5142208338,
-0.5705556273,
-0.3603164554,
0.2193949074,
-0.4174392223,
-0.8352925181,
-0.0991109833,
0.1873443574,
0.4728865325,
-0.3448454738,
0.4737152755,
-0.4172027707,
-0.410520643,
0.4281382561,
-0.8121570945,
0.2786472142,
0.168424964,
-0.5566040874,
0.0214321297,
-0.8390499949,
0.2061320096,
0.1950548142,
-0.4103787839,
-0.1176981553,
-0.0969807133,
0.2958396673,
0.4490411878,
0.232828021,
-0.7041729689,
-0.0210594945,
0.068114914,
0.3121426404,
0.8606218696,
-0.0977034047,
-0.2232786566,
-0.2197519094,
0.5780697465,
0.0173317883,
-0.0153780077,
-0.0329014324,
-0.5914438963,
-0.3827617168,
-0.3467282057,
0.5220720768,
0.3913395107,
-1.0076655149,
0.4000588655,
-0.3232161105,
-0.3436456323,
-0.5822942257,
0.1815901101,
0.6414531469,
0.3072199523,
0.3479340971,
-0.3054573238,
-0.521460712,
-0.9764668345,
-0.4093659222,
0.0795476809,
-0.047377605,
0.1897608936,
0.7228146195,
-0.6323905587,
0.5931414366,
-0.5711527467,
-0.0993092135,
-0.0288230535,
0.5104093552,
-0.1532536447,
0.2694235742,
0.5606386065,
-0.6569632292,
-0.3047256172,
-0.0176596586,
-0.9560700059,
-0.4726275802,
0.1345907301,
-0.3818935454,
-0.0122322747,
0.3299132884,
-0.4627012014,
0.2589547336,
0.883015573,
-0.2196511924,
1.0046373606,
-0.160774827,
0.3092344105,
-1.0962955952,
0.1498567462,
0.1703193784,
-0.2954383492,
-0.5095863342,
0.0944661796,
0.3682985008,
-0.1433879882,
-0.2314030528,
0.5392924547,
-0.4764979482,
-0.3105936348,
-0.4304486811,
0.3641989231,
0.1116632521,
0.4412654638,
-0.2614651322,
1.1496741772,
0.1071943864,
-0.4154908657,
0.1419406682,
0.1927985847,
-0.3793655634,
0.7859154344,
-0.4305059016,
0.2603469491,
0.2625959516,
0.0364411809,
-0.9074181318,
0.0763071626,
0.2873289585,
-0.5639506578,
0.1702046394,
-0.211840108,
-0.9589967728,
-0.3345345855,
-0.3579452336,
0.3944082856,
0.1431987137,
-0.5912523866,
0.356036365,
0.4858512282,
-0.0076485649,
-0.7378470898,
-0.6079069376,
0.3972626626,
-0.1464146972,
-0.4710874259,
0.3305121958,
-0.2528143823,
0.1449240595,
-0.1062888876,
-0.1681667864,
-0.045653943,
0.1923501343,
0.0303311944,
0.0964710712,
-0.2986924648,
0.030398421,
0.0871971548,
-0.2791868448,
0.1820959151,
-0.2687339187,
0.6227970719,
-0.107234627,
-0.3485461175,
-0.0643440932,
0.2765088081,
0.3937007189,
-0.3865471184,
0.4874934256,
1.1858729124,
-0.4060345292,
-0.1569068581,
-0.5780265927,
-0.1068199202,
-0.4719775617,
0.215191856,
-0.6476772428,
-0.8253387213,
0.1729035527,
-0.0316599309,
-0.1610919684,
0.4103091359,
0.7959189415,
0.5040466189,
0.8812597394,
0.3161650598,
-0.1771906465,
0.2982032001,
0.0128012896,
0.1112969592,
-0.7722776532,
0.094776243,
-0.6383234859,
-0.0717537478,
-0.7813174725,
-0.3429495394,
0.3004819155,
-0.268463105,
-0.0117216855,
0.3279953599,
-0.6368219256,
0.459459573,
0.492785275,
0.1523373723,
0.4352765679,
-0.1292257011,
-0.5000733137,
-0.0668930262,
-0.3268660605,
-0.7935066819,
1.3499783278,
0.1542873085,
0.4634680748,
0.2251545489,
0.8351290822,
0.5032397509,
0.7682213783,
-0.4840528667,
0.4993421733,
0.0034707855,
-0.7297359705,
0.1224218607,
-0.7661496997,
-1.1955422163,
0.8283827305,
-0.4781565964,
-0.5813981295,
-0.4236807227,
-0.0764902383,
0.1225830093,
0.3092934787,
-0.8786116242,
1.2388153076,
-0.3305148482,
-0.5019778609,
0.0087535623,
-0.318626076,
0.5401682854,
-0.3946585059,
0.2005691081,
-0.3457002342,
0.0236120615,
0.7312866449,
0.1001086831,
0.5101847053,
-0.2291679531,
-0.1063054651,
0.1533773839,
-0.0615414493,
0.38584131,
0.0419019014,
-0.0405842587,
0.3656210899,
-0.1293383837,
-0.3303379416,
-0.0817297772,
0.7819097042,
-0.721950531,
-0.2148032039,
-0.4850482345,
-0.3783425987,
-0.1656970829,
0.5883615017,
0.2787542939,
0.5718426108,
-0.4337614775,
0.1640285999,
0.3123015463,
-0.193727538,
0.2402390838,
0.5464696884,
-0.2044339329,
-0.4938124418,
0.8838778138,
-0.1566077024,
0.0376217738,
0.2669418454,
0.2413110435,
-0.5608392358,
-0.8243022561,
-0.7546132207,
0.2106989771,
-0.6958041787,
-0.3478588164,
-0.6782187223,
-0.1842797846,
-0.220678404,
0.2189382315,
-0.0863549039,
0.1532760859,
-0.1485277265,
-0.1130114049,
0.009974299,
0.572027564,
0.1686077863,
0.4078162313,
-0.846531868,
0.6592695713,
0.0153424116,
0.5397496223,
-0.3291576803,
-0.3178765774,
-0.3697679639,
-0.0175702069,
-0.7171723247,
-0.7366057634,
0.3848694563,
-0.1788218021,
0.7726299763,
0.2509117126,
-0.2356720269,
0.3778795004,
-0.7508966923,
0.4596154094,
0.1280706078,
-1.029537797,
0.0144358976,
-0.4813642204,
0.3550463021,
0.5780785084,
0.0900518596,
-0.470464766,
-0.4280224442,
-0.5781979561,
-0.4963847101,
0.365201056,
0.4798619151,
-0.1060569212,
0.0381120592,
0.1349443644,
0.2203823775,
0.4835624695,
-1.0244905949,
-0.0949780941,
-0.2243534923,
-0.3246614039,
-0.3794492483,
-0.1721317768,
-0.0699130148,
0.2216855288,
0.5246098042,
-0.2824072242,
0.4271905124,
-0.1354483366,
-0.344666779,
0.040174026,
0.4294553101,
0.7109438777,
0.5730811954,
-0.2320819944,
0.3021255136,
-0.0004453861,
-0.6723971367,
0.2566295266,
0.4501169026,
-0.0968482196,
0.2541748881,
0.1018428132,
0.4126451015,
0.3670414388,
-0.5238016844,
0.5522890091,
-0.1667446047,
-0.4597055316,
-0.1302009523,
-0.106250748,
-0.007315408,
0.0807099715,
0.3640311062,
0.0263112299,
0.3103845716,
-0.2971358895,
0.607988894,
0.4888411164,
-0.0867613256,
-0.3432883322,
0.7066941261,
0.2991950214,
-0.1218215451,
0.2102774978,
-0.5367883444,
-0.7319768071,
0.2752329111,
0.6010074019,
1.0165883303,
-0.0397910438,
0.1513739824,
0.3146113455,
0.537647903,
-0.0089390287,
0.1673628241,
0.0595587343,
-0.9266290069,
-0.4397979081,
-0.5388932824,
-0.4069873393,
0.3875201344,
-0.4266227484,
0.2923665643,
-0.1295823902,
-0.3313444853,
0.377651751,
0.1009098217,
-0.5222438574,
0.0521732569,
0.3403074145,
0.5881255865,
-0.8012601733,
0.8224431872,
0.2463473082,
-0.136981234,
-0.2900456786,
0.0578648373,
0.3123711944,
-0.7638524175,
0.2103461027,
0.6896615028,
-0.4401681721,
-0.1016767994,
-0.3305194378,
-0.406673044,
0.9421982765,
0.2933464646,
-0.2890459001,
0.3685850501,
0.1179539189,
0.4991152585,
-0.2145601958,
0.2413621843,
0.6274467111,
0.6838302612,
-0.3898013234,
-0.6903771162,
0.1662009805,
-0.3287187219,
-0.2390215397,
0.6492769718,
-0.3696353137,
0.8535006642,
0.3561886549,
-0.2993724644,
0.0404347517,
0.3759173453,
0.5442314744,
0.479090482,
0.4508258402,
0.5539034605,
0.6831883788,
-0.3317139745,
0.9245411158,
-0.2837001979,
0.4438535571,
0.7712426782,
-0.4137974083,
0.6864826679,
0.1343277693,
-0.1296682805,
0.3374977708,
0.5209175944,
-0.3319972157,
0.3502109945,
0.399572283,
-0.5108433366,
0.0818509012,
0.1443259418,
-0.4728657901,
0.4064371884,
0.3180947602,
-0.2000165284,
-0.3251281381,
-0.2262377739,
0.1193995327,
-0.0117122959,
-0.0987004042,
0.581183672,
-0.1536128968,
-0.6848483086,
0.807186842,
0.3249641657,
0.9524108768,
-0.6358284354,
0.0951323658,
0.2016275376,
0.4129595459,
0.0188389383,
-0.7431198359,
-0.0150144305,
0.3319072723,
0.029708514,
-0.0801063105,
0.8921123743,
-0.4985372126,
-0.373708427,
0.4097673297,
0.7774090171,
0.2172975689,
-0.256170094,
-0.9442072511,
0.0919416621,
-0.0586994365,
-0.0638049617,
0.4484878778,
0.6255239248,
0.0199218001,
0.485896945,
0.8735839725,
-0.1134124473,
0.1522873938,
0.3093357384,
0.715503633,
-0.7071630955,
-0.3524671197,
-1.0376340151,
0.1369110942,
-0.3144056499,
-0.3787606061,
0.8620830774,
0.9376237392,
0.8071495891,
-0.1595042348,
1.0740240812,
0.232232362,
0.4598430991,
-0.6045744419,
0.6448244452,
-0.4015285671,
-0.0655965656,
-0.5485485792,
-0.8668842912,
-0.1944763958,
0.3890010417,
-0.0226557031,
0.1945342273,
0.8942677379,
0.7638474703,
-0.3053281009,
-0.0517308675,
0.4522153735,
-0.208608821,
0.3880832493,
0.5348035693,
0.9882156849,
-0.4546407461,
0.9554385543,
0.0166204814,
-0.1430963129,
-0.2639523745,
-1.0470356941,
-0.9896833897,
-0.3792991042,
-0.1716428101,
-0.4157983065,
-0.0923064798,
0.5580970645,
0.6390408874,
-0.6449111104,
-0.2918044925,
0.2957947254,
0.0446640588,
-0.2683698833,
-0.1925070286,
0.2074244767,
-0.1327377111,
-0.6756545305,
0.3313630819,
0.2449442744,
0.1315976828,
-0.3035005331,
-0.0655881986,
-0.2876885831,
-0.1469653994,
0.7589717507,
0.0189160593,
-0.5282882452,
-0.3374541998,
-0.2538885176,
-0.2761430144,
0.2971109748,
0.8904886246,
-0.4328817725,
0.4701905251,
0.2239798605,
0.9007561207,
0.722668469,
0.1472918987,
0.531775713,
-1.0937348604,
0.0232138075,
0.0122864824,
0.6287324429,
0.5645121932,
-0.1133371145,
0.6692110896,
0.4419636726,
-0.6180010438,
-0.8389784694,
0.1292282343,
-0.9040285349,
-0.1345787793,
1.1925723553,
-0.0952055082,
-0.1014672741,
-0.2537185848,
-0.2710787952,
0.2827599049,
-0.4894731045,
0.6907799244,
0.8897638917,
0.309147805,
-0.1978446096,
-0.9514733553,
0.2832260132,
0.0559000447,
-1.197420001,
0.0334159471,
0.5574815869,
0.2947736382,
0.1327339262,
0.5997880697,
-0.1453669965,
0.1477063745,
0.0553192832,
0.3510808945,
-0.0873125121,
-0.1893058419,
-0.1523732543,
0.2002530396,
-0.1025245115,
-0.4178033769
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11167v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11167v1
|
Token-Ensemble Text Generation: On Attacking the Automatic AI-Generated Text Detection
| 2024-02-17T02:25:57 | 2024-02-17T02:25:57 |
Fan Huang, Haewoon Kwak, Jisun An
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The robustness of AI-content detection models against cultivated attacks
(e.g., paraphrasing or word switching) remains a significant concern. This
study proposes a novel token-ensemble generation strategy to challenge the
robustness of current AI-content detection approaches. We explore the ensemble
attack strategy by completing the prompt with the next token generated from
random candidate LLMs. We find the token-ensemble approach significantly drops
the performance of AI-content detection models (The code and test sets will be
released). Our findings reveal that token-ensemble generation poses a vital
challenge to current detection models and underlines the need for advancing
detection technologies to counter sophisticated adversarial strategies.
|
[
-0.4796579182,
-0.8087572455,
0.193915084,
-0.3038016856,
-0.3733189106,
0.4486412406,
0.0993294343,
-0.3821345568,
-0.0386468433,
0.7204527855,
-0.6568773985,
-0.4327439368,
-0.6151180863,
0.3799744248,
-0.8679477572,
1.1489616632,
0.1187776476,
-0.2265644222,
-0.2625856996,
-0.0093555422,
-0.447981894,
-0.3891892731,
-1.1410877705,
0.015416991,
0.5312196016,
0.2789725959,
0.353182286,
0.4522688389,
0.5561728477,
0.3483299613,
-0.0599466376,
0.3098092377,
-0.346126765,
0.4583911896,
0.1213731095,
-0.7045366168,
-0.0399355963,
-0.0352993757,
0.6631780863,
0.0794095919,
0.3099847734,
0.0135035543,
-0.0744661018,
0.2558276653,
-0.5418403149,
-0.3010146022,
-1.2758432627,
0.0952959433,
-0.6433028579,
-0.373817265,
-0.7123106718,
0.3712866008,
-0.2900158465,
-0.3959538043,
0.3273847401,
0.4324164689,
0.5867424011,
0.2146956623,
-0.2707591951,
-0.3808349669,
-0.316734165,
0.6465957165,
-0.5198991895,
-0.2909042835,
0.1634323597,
0.1405605376,
-0.2804872692,
-0.9666025639,
-0.873536706,
-0.1127032489,
0.2228828371,
0.1134300604,
-0.5258999467,
-0.0151849212,
-0.1566516012,
0.2338569909,
-0.5423678756,
0.2518537045,
-0.2049143463,
-0.4970570803,
0.611745894,
0.2135389298,
0.6621810198,
-0.3806735277,
-0.5289925933,
-0.1949555576,
-0.7689925432,
-0.030230131,
0.7810589075,
0.2840853333,
0.1312968731,
0.5652487278,
0.2144169658,
0.3757809997,
0.2565385997,
0.0107975816,
-0.1763910055,
-0.3667357564,
-0.0859171227,
0.3234158456,
0.9160112143,
0.3464665413,
-0.2348252833,
-0.2836804688,
-0.5442384481,
0.1039165407,
0.3331736028,
-0.4858243763,
-0.1760186255,
0.3054778278,
-0.4659402072,
-1.102488637,
0.0295527391,
-0.6994742751,
-0.2942142189,
0.3192833066,
0.4133971035,
-0.5192700028,
-0.1231712922,
-0.3917637467,
-0.5604851246,
0.3052291572,
0.1076961383,
-0.8268378377,
0.2422653735,
0.7882347107,
0.8536627293,
-0.7606556416,
-0.3800255954,
-0.9076678157,
0.2130155563,
-0.4466230869,
1.0100758076,
-0.3907797337,
-0.8211589456,
-0.023409117,
-0.2459983081,
-0.0763344392,
-0.5011985898,
0.6076853871,
-0.506865263,
0.3387961984,
-0.0394483767,
-0.7017006278,
0.2468080372,
0.443511337,
-0.7613546252,
0.9347011447,
-0.1487571746,
-1.0907959938,
0.492916286,
-0.587865591,
-0.5735305548,
0.3005793393,
-0.2446852177,
-0.4274223149,
0.0574395508,
0.3941690624,
0.3797520101,
0.0456242524,
-0.066808328,
-0.014698782,
-0.567853868,
0.37646088,
-0.8076791167,
0.5921502113,
0.3718925714,
-0.4248889089,
0.1580980569,
-0.7345599532,
-0.1786697209,
0.3458889723,
-0.3303073645,
-0.2171291709,
0.0869136453,
0.1501132548,
-0.1986178607,
0.2974568605,
-0.3440871239,
0.1041386724,
-0.4441748857,
0.5609282255,
1.1207114458,
0.1743781418,
0.624442637,
-0.6018395424,
0.6874991655,
0.2204829752,
0.0470394753,
-0.6368707418,
-0.6933742166,
-0.2826619744,
-0.3941083252,
0.2463947982,
0.4608442783,
-1.0675959587,
0.3351541758,
0.0056971703,
-0.398435384,
-0.2971576154,
0.062741451,
0.2015881687,
0.5138887763,
0.2341800779,
-0.0267926101,
-0.3819538951,
-0.3864580989,
-0.6635616422,
-0.5071653128,
-0.0395826027,
0.1618081182,
0.5856543183,
-0.171687603,
0.841370225,
-0.0947658718,
0.1093496978,
-0.4540834427,
0.2269743383,
-0.2425858527,
0.5974637866,
0.6358723044,
-0.8939538598,
-0.3001550436,
-0.3285381794,
-0.3588770628,
-0.0956533998,
-0.3459297717,
0.0503512397,
0.3347578049,
0.661575377,
-0.719606936,
0.2657230198,
0.3033694029,
-0.2728031576,
0.5560504794,
0.1188329905,
0.1514628232,
-1.3877339363,
-0.1647219509,
-0.2293269932,
-0.0975120366,
-0.6031183004,
0.449403733,
-0.2632207274,
-0.3106444776,
-0.6182949543,
0.6824593544,
-0.1076740548,
0.0967910662,
-0.2639777362,
-0.0218738243,
0.0470248945,
0.1692220569,
-0.3142051101,
0.9313858747,
0.4880719483,
-0.53297472,
0.2564822435,
0.2025013566,
-0.1521350741,
0.6088594794,
-0.4984821081,
0.3213609159,
-0.1237464026,
0.4985644519,
-1.4055711031,
-0.3172996342,
0.4807135165,
-0.7346632481,
0.5179417729,
0.0579630695,
-0.705287993,
-0.3092339635,
-0.6385404468,
0.5127308965,
0.4698370099,
-0.6720219851,
0.5713514686,
0.1150353923,
-0.0169044081,
-0.4496890306,
-0.9029350281,
0.6841109991,
-0.6789687872,
-0.8512303233,
0.5537938476,
0.1013432816,
-0.4485163391,
-0.1999207586,
0.038170822,
0.1139711961,
0.4332873821,
-0.1506512761,
0.1227355674,
-0.1554489434,
0.0376092978,
0.0692513287,
0.0387438498,
0.1795799136,
-0.5119336843,
0.7528070211,
0.2555239797,
-0.5446020961,
-0.591153264,
0.3757448792,
0.6214678288,
-0.3426589966,
0.5880478024,
0.9197974205,
-0.2175775319,
-0.2945859432,
-0.2758229077,
-0.2748566568,
-0.5764197707,
0.344470799,
-0.1346417218,
-0.6755245924,
0.449220866,
-0.0319995321,
0.2683749795,
0.7145763636,
0.3572795987,
-0.2043649107,
1.2012217045,
0.0980358347,
-0.1857410371,
0.4158252776,
-0.1942649782,
0.0486418381,
-0.5163732171,
-0.0585947111,
-0.5873351097,
-0.2883430719,
-0.6125967503,
-0.1857957542,
0.1805516481,
-0.1912166923,
-0.0729694366,
0.1552456766,
-0.8227117658,
0.2856040001,
0.7241653204,
0.1961393654,
0.1819957793,
0.0702645481,
-0.0032851566,
0.3247393072,
-0.6650171876,
-0.5513585806,
1.4697368145,
0.1074881777,
0.4595538676,
0.0281087067,
1.1623489857,
0.8143514395,
-0.1020860001,
-0.4727794528,
0.6705579758,
-0.0488527492,
-0.4613203108,
-0.2895618677,
-0.1998029947,
-1.0007048845,
-0.0295098089,
-0.2073625177,
-0.7595142126,
-0.296977669,
0.0109743113,
-0.2960596383,
0.7485050559,
-0.4304217994,
0.6134257913,
-0.1376461238,
-0.0421309061,
-0.0197497979,
-0.5309791565,
0.5278400779,
-0.2427038401,
0.2640298307,
0.2344324142,
-0.2317572981,
0.7382128239,
-0.435760498,
0.8776284456,
-0.0519402586,
-0.1194154099,
0.7925326228,
0.1413057446,
0.845063448,
0.0968966931,
0.0607080907,
-0.1017768383,
-0.2477994412,
-0.5423882008,
-0.2425423414,
0.4232886434,
-0.535353601,
-0.8281538486,
-0.3263341784,
-0.5281895995,
0.0771608874,
0.1088739857,
0.8509532213,
0.3849265277,
-0.3201078475,
-0.0274753515,
0.630957365,
-0.3247096837,
0.7231841087,
-0.2365696281,
0.0512639321,
-0.5021718144,
1.2371678352,
-0.1748406142,
0.336275816,
0.3061541319,
0.1180841029,
-0.3104315102,
-1.015611887,
-0.5390739441,
-0.4561178386,
-0.6260334849,
-0.1677787006,
-0.5319883823,
-0.079537496,
-0.5262790918,
-0.2872534096,
0.1655719578,
-0.3588022888,
-0.5488460064,
0.0177699458,
0.3459298015,
0.5741658807,
0.1467566192,
0.6357924342,
-0.8185173869,
0.0886070132,
0.3781008124,
-0.3751803041,
-0.1136981621,
-0.4135965109,
0.118570894,
-0.08847633,
-0.565025568,
-0.8782117367,
0.1838098168,
0.0704929903,
0.4739840627,
0.5319260955,
0.16684632,
0.1183740422,
-0.4230502248,
1.284569025,
0.2168152332,
-0.8797709942,
0.5833002925,
-0.6115393639,
0.2962034941,
0.4868686795,
-0.243025139,
-0.274923861,
-0.7355588675,
-0.9730895758,
-0.7742200494,
0.4545819759,
0.5192868114,
0.4265719652,
-0.5324428678,
0.3391087651,
-0.0345816091,
0.3601364791,
-0.5962818861,
-0.0964983329,
-0.2448755503,
-0.3869768083,
0.1968840063,
0.0267800707,
-0.0450863391,
0.2508879006,
0.4409657121,
-0.1904342175,
0.4273019135,
0.1411375999,
-0.0126871867,
0.0488278531,
-0.0164948702,
0.4887079,
-0.0527263768,
0.4866760373,
0.0333834514,
0.3259702921,
-0.5316335559,
0.1123498082,
-0.0299669057,
-0.4421961606,
0.1406863183,
0.7077873945,
0.693729043,
-0.0342294127,
-0.8648344874,
0.6282900572,
0.0130145783,
-0.3468122184,
-0.195682779,
0.3731481731,
-0.1995646805,
0.0936414078,
0.7799152732,
0.4668868482,
0.0567973554,
-0.5758470297,
0.5291380286,
0.6400995255,
-0.2783927321,
-0.0758994222,
0.7851784825,
0.1827368289,
-0.6286141276,
0.3445447385,
-0.2812935114,
-0.6313026547,
1.1826540232,
0.6579827666,
0.9106872678,
-0.0431548841,
0.2776544988,
-0.1532405615,
0.3468837738,
-0.1221189424,
-0.0908546299,
-0.2460149527,
-0.7501832247,
0.0026208924,
-0.3868598342,
-0.3841484487,
0.1174161732,
-0.4318413436,
0.3184440434,
-0.6192554235,
-0.1303007901,
-0.1567344964,
-0.1657865494,
-0.3260420561,
0.1700603664,
0.2893414497,
0.838260293,
-0.3066891134,
0.4255017638,
0.4072704613,
-0.1893727183,
-0.5218516588,
0.514072299,
0.103927739,
-1.0125391483,
0.3964485526,
0.3357193172,
0.1576735228,
0.2079462409,
-0.7390381694,
-0.4803783894,
1.1452673674,
0.1237308383,
-0.2348910421,
-0.1996522546,
0.0415592454,
0.2168065906,
-0.2825998962,
-0.0172629151,
0.438157022,
0.4697876871,
0.1698549986,
-0.2795289457,
-0.0896627232,
-0.1539716721,
-0.1944998503,
0.1510795653,
-0.8159882426,
1.1380153894,
0.0479987226,
-0.1869434416,
0.5065413117,
0.7563617229,
0.4047241807,
0.5727238059,
0.7137010098,
0.5955373645,
0.9106110334,
0.0773537457,
1.0089482069,
-0.4486963153,
-0.1036360487,
0.6005769968,
-0.2655239403,
0.6503995061,
0.6027744412,
-0.0067923898,
0.2460380495,
0.7944889069,
-0.4329817295,
0.4832772613,
0.3952671289,
-0.7079647779,
-0.2464001775,
0.0314549059,
-0.2118429393,
0.6965631247,
0.2405047566,
-0.311324656,
-0.0584625974,
0.174876377,
0.0317821987,
0.1213935018,
-0.5790189505,
0.822984457,
-0.2157738954,
-0.8113538027,
0.3028926253,
0.0947027355,
0.9355997443,
-0.3705863655,
0.2179700732,
0.0016918367,
-0.1000092328,
-0.1353218257,
-0.3931668103,
0.1155318096,
0.1695621908,
0.237248674,
0.0130017819,
1.0144886971,
-0.0863588974,
-0.5942918658,
-0.1656721234,
0.3580216467,
0.0430565551,
-0.0080298437,
-0.5724644065,
-0.1819962263,
-0.0221876353,
-0.2401774675,
0.4963212609,
0.506870985,
0.0322646722,
0.4742560685,
0.8976294994,
-0.1725610048,
0.1200311333,
-0.2390505075,
0.8353069425,
-0.2354940176,
-0.6327956319,
-1.1635364294,
0.1670124233,
-0.2760649025,
-0.3192230165,
0.7227473855,
0.4140008688,
0.7765648961,
0.3173967898,
1.1463910341,
0.0585035756,
0.0422117859,
-0.6629872918,
0.8256563544,
-0.5512493253,
0.4590456486,
-0.4068905711,
-0.5157932639,
-0.0992011055,
0.1192639172,
0.1792355031,
0.036149241,
0.6190491319,
0.5446940064,
0.1907800883,
0.2083890587,
0.230520606,
-0.0244026855,
0.595441103,
0.2975521684,
0.9271394014,
-0.5685722828,
0.9470205903,
0.2465535253,
0.0933063626,
0.0697791502,
-0.7893875837,
-1.2327756882,
-0.3346661925,
-0.1555475295,
-0.321424216,
0.2555078864,
0.6425182819,
0.182762593,
-0.701228559,
0.2021836191,
-0.6415607333,
0.112947084,
-0.0834356025,
-0.2361329794,
0.2624144554,
-0.7099319696,
-0.8629285097,
0.5053482652,
0.1019144952,
0.3206614554,
-0.5203254819,
0.1171364561,
0.0455996245,
0.3979480267,
0.1527918726,
0.0888528377,
-0.6582763791,
-0.3173606098,
0.1364213079,
-0.1868638098,
-0.0858256146,
0.7604023814,
-0.7074345946,
-0.0511702858,
0.4068176746,
1.0640650988,
0.265202105,
-0.0234728567,
0.6019530296,
-0.921061635,
0.2924797535,
0.3690906763,
0.3729465306,
0.1927307695,
-0.687815547,
0.0799557567,
0.6433641911,
-0.3151463568,
-1.0756720304,
0.3001005054,
-0.6680674553,
-0.6479540467,
1.0671781301,
-0.0366351046,
-0.462557584,
-0.0854682326,
-0.4033550918,
0.1495451331,
-0.4893887937,
0.8882373571,
0.6975059509,
0.2613690495,
0.0454719774,
-0.0467629284,
0.4862154424,
0.4832030237,
-0.6284168959,
-0.2688800097,
0.1163629591,
-0.0037319323,
0.2347417325,
0.4770359099,
0.0923855826,
0.409256041,
0.3050189614,
-0.3093996346,
-0.0688976943,
-0.203946963,
-0.0911298841,
0.4554361701,
-0.2082624882,
-0.4759527445
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11166v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11166v1
|
GenDec: A robust generative Question-decomposition method for Multi-hop reasoning
| 2024-02-17T02:21:44 | 2024-02-17T02:21:44 |
Jian Wu, Linyi Yang, Yuliang Ji, Wenhao Huang, Börje F. Karlsson, Manabu Okumura
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multi-hop QA (MHQA) involves step-by-step reasoning to answer complex
questions and find multiple relevant supporting facts. However, Existing large
language models'(LLMs) reasoning ability in multi-hop question answering
remains exploration, which is inadequate in answering multi-hop questions.
Moreover, it is unclear whether LLMs follow a desired reasoning chain to reach
the right final answer. In this paper, we propose a \textbf{gen}erative
question \textbf{dec}omposition method (GenDec) from the perspective of
explainable QA by generating independent and complete sub-questions based on
incorporating additional extracted evidence for enhancing LLMs' reasoning
ability in RAG. To demonstrate the impact, generalization, and robustness of
Gendec, we conduct two experiments, the first is combining GenDec with small QA
systems on paragraph retrieval and QA tasks. We secondly examine the reasoning
capabilities of various state-of-the-art LLMs including GPT-4 and GPT-3.5
combined with GenDec. We experiment on the HotpotQA, 2WikihopMultiHopQA,
MuSiQue, and PokeMQA datasets.
|
[
-0.8037704825,
-1.1496571302,
0.9148903489,
-0.1774275601,
-0.1870917529,
0.1751051694,
-0.0599178635,
-0.1632037014,
0.1352135241,
0.39263767,
-0.5158496499,
-0.6130521894,
-0.2508918345,
0.3891233206,
-0.1774862707,
0.558555007,
-0.1640874594,
-0.200865373,
-0.2925456464,
-0.2374120504,
-0.2933911383,
-0.5028132796,
-0.6016104221,
-0.0012370949,
0.3235512674,
0.4352027476,
0.4810349047,
0.3085311651,
0.2912587225,
0.2667073905,
-0.4307477772,
0.4159042835,
-0.22988379,
0.4573299289,
-0.2891098261,
-0.3369971216,
-0.4161918461,
0.0607473329,
0.5404292345,
0.6655960679,
-0.1189752147,
0.0235170033,
0.0570516437,
0.4001792371,
-0.6755111814,
-0.1319431216,
-0.5090842843,
-0.2193825692,
0.0705229118,
-0.3770915568,
-0.4507749677,
-0.4574292898,
-0.0938199237,
-0.3730041683,
0.2750346363,
-0.0367464088,
0.6489679813,
0.2560648322,
-0.5144004226,
-0.0955334753,
-0.7895448804,
0.5602278113,
-0.6449153423,
0.5509271622,
0.3867305517,
0.3280680478,
-0.1626826227,
-0.5514523983,
-0.4959265888,
0.0610204861,
0.3771666288,
0.3303576112,
0.1727560014,
-0.0667975396,
0.4057949185,
0.5316978097,
-0.6262916327,
-0.0285946261,
-0.1361722201,
-0.0692989081,
0.0989250094,
0.2174265385,
0.4063463509,
-0.1796766967,
-0.4165736139,
-0.1406201869,
-0.7437565923,
0.1929797083,
0.1490512043,
0.0047900057,
0.0499163792,
0.6608353853,
-0.2129564285,
0.6455380321,
0.12822631,
-0.2032409459,
0.109437868,
-0.6967988014,
-0.125404045,
-0.3821772039,
0.6489652395,
0.1661614329,
0.0488758758,
-0.0931766629,
0.1717090905,
-0.1616492569,
0.0856993571,
-0.7714086175,
-0.1443275958,
0.4299579561,
-0.5257301927,
-0.0357422344,
-0.0061486461,
-1.146889329,
-0.1960230023,
-0.1857922822,
0.3181239665,
-0.6595811248,
-0.2215356082,
0.140226692,
-0.1247977912,
0.6735275388,
0.2578000426,
-0.6972762942,
-0.0838401541,
0.6118575335,
0.5328652263,
0.2275567353,
-0.3154088259,
-0.4782195985,
0.0482877828,
-0.4639728665,
0.9378168583,
-0.4413303137,
-0.1591960341,
-0.2018333822,
0.0441097617,
-0.4504884481,
-0.3358579874,
0.6624558568,
-0.8335850239,
0.3722727597,
-0.214786157,
-0.6405402422,
-0.263353169,
0.3711224496,
-0.6172645092,
0.6265381575,
-0.0205801781,
-1.1081228256,
0.2626864314,
-0.3489995003,
-0.2877991199,
-0.0516607575,
-0.194585517,
-0.3110847473,
-0.2106733471,
0.8310565352,
0.309951365,
-0.3754949868,
0.0192540605,
-0.3697572947,
-0.0303333476,
0.2832644582,
-0.5734723806,
1.0780863762,
0.402692318,
-0.2426123917,
0.0791037679,
-0.6254836917,
0.2783044875,
0.2858442664,
-0.556450069,
-0.5053462982,
0.0328910798,
-0.7014161348,
0.1673859656,
0.0248416103,
-0.5316733718,
0.2619035244,
-0.2594975233,
0.4505806565,
0.5559015274,
0.3512394726,
0.5212594271,
-0.2136593163,
0.8814226985,
-0.3393306732,
0.2748398185,
-0.347178787,
-0.8090717793,
-0.4834096134,
-0.3087640703,
0.5276883245,
0.5471999049,
-1.0732777119,
0.4780030251,
-0.0848375931,
-0.1581481695,
-0.5585096478,
-0.1286350191,
0.0696815327,
0.4604614675,
0.5294135809,
0.2055457234,
-0.366997689,
-0.4718771875,
0.0915990099,
-0.0920753479,
-0.2237968743,
0.0811940804,
0.2813167274,
-0.1953682452,
0.7753716707,
-0.4218898714,
0.1107563525,
-0.3925510347,
0.2302094698,
0.0199475065,
0.2036333829,
0.4685585201,
-0.617744863,
-0.0018237121,
-0.4054290056,
-0.7695680857,
-0.1447440386,
-0.2144086957,
-0.2805512249,
-0.0636931658,
0.7584985495,
-0.5797038078,
0.4553282857,
0.4739603102,
-0.3794582188,
0.7873789668,
-0.413055867,
0.560348928,
-1.034621954,
-0.2562579811,
-0.4199729264,
-0.0096206935,
-0.4754101634,
0.5002250671,
0.1055336893,
-0.0214955565,
-0.1317091584,
0.0841498747,
-0.3805738688,
0.059227556,
-0.2315395176,
-0.0122381831,
0.1746772379,
0.3394216597,
-0.2215974033,
0.7845589519,
0.551230073,
-0.6777799129,
0.2215589136,
0.4920687675,
-0.2356158346,
0.5393506885,
-0.5825298429,
0.3032149374,
-0.3340166509,
0.3589421511,
-1.0562210083,
-0.0252384916,
0.1905230433,
-0.5424008369,
-0.0152315823,
-0.3263192773,
-0.4629290104,
-0.4244434237,
-0.4097315371,
0.7922836542,
0.4719500244,
-0.8892022371,
1.0618610382,
0.1159947738,
-0.1832647622,
-0.1419285983,
-0.3294259608,
0.1028130129,
-0.3541733623,
-0.9220142961,
0.1114847586,
-0.3228790164,
-0.3572148383,
-0.0720756054,
0.0144271022,
0.2280510068,
0.05903548,
0.137888357,
0.1427871287,
-0.2461909205,
-0.0891149342,
0.1262850314,
-0.2423921674,
0.1156380475,
-0.0856952816,
0.5915486813,
-0.059492413,
-0.5142601132,
-0.0620758086,
0.6630243063,
0.6431614161,
-0.6038064957,
0.6396199465,
0.2811398506,
-0.0382793732,
-0.4186584949,
-0.4488781691,
-0.121624507,
-0.3756461442,
-0.2382672727,
-0.7835403681,
-0.9587260485,
0.7125219107,
-0.2590101659,
0.015885504,
0.6321772337,
0.6173647642,
-0.0690348521,
1.1962325573,
0.1370469034,
0.2324284315,
0.0327656344,
-0.3626728058,
0.1524536014,
-0.9842648506,
-0.284909457,
-0.8945481777,
0.1668202579,
-0.4550062716,
-0.7605693936,
0.4725646079,
0.2013389468,
-0.3859218657,
0.1680584103,
-0.2305643111,
0.3721583188,
0.7637975812,
0.0080944216,
0.5223577023,
-0.1236741766,
-0.5602182746,
0.3440100849,
-0.7730912566,
-0.2540514469,
1.0927863121,
0.3789612651,
1.1055953503,
0.0649226978,
0.7069256306,
-0.22409603,
-0.253991276,
-0.5903180242,
0.4605043828,
-0.0786266699,
-0.587490797,
-0.427824378,
-0.7812097073,
-0.8592666984,
0.4980568588,
0.0155681595,
-0.4750953019,
0.3408869803,
-0.4072167575,
-0.5957201123,
0.5794545412,
-0.5472038984,
0.6274573803,
-0.2423803359,
0.1039548144,
-0.0419820286,
-0.7154840827,
0.4181880057,
0.1688546687,
0.3850264251,
-0.0307599399,
0.312422663,
0.7237730026,
-0.4780563712,
0.2936403751,
0.0124082631,
-0.4177421033,
0.6482513547,
0.2935601175,
0.3311718702,
0.0736588761,
0.2026600093,
0.0050754072,
-0.0192787685,
-0.1556963623,
-0.5286380649,
0.6320607066,
-0.5361000896,
-0.627117753,
-0.2659926116,
-0.3892451823,
-0.4064605236,
-0.0157795642,
0.2709528804,
0.5014725924,
-0.1049969867,
0.0682577491,
0.9686844945,
-0.4251924157,
0.2687748373,
0.3400632143,
-0.3589117825,
-0.723775506,
0.4940755665,
-0.1495037228,
0.4668705165,
0.3194699883,
0.332216084,
-0.3944071829,
-0.5435142517,
-0.5977185369,
0.2548568845,
-0.7970331907,
-0.2103701681,
-0.8166435361,
-0.2645978034,
-0.5095525384,
-0.052284576,
-0.1752921641,
-0.2690905333,
-0.0550020188,
-0.2616377771,
0.0940921679,
0.2573210597,
-0.2709697783,
-0.1604879349,
-0.6798802018,
1.0798273087,
0.9980764985,
0.2698403895,
-0.0421876833,
-0.4766104519,
0.1519892514,
0.1460060924,
-0.0687002316,
-0.9749374986,
-0.0371845625,
-0.003790728,
0.6739401817,
0.5466691256,
0.1122344881,
0.3727629781,
-0.3957051635,
0.5636854768,
-0.0509392321,
-0.6940778494,
0.5410733223,
-0.3619661331,
0.4259225726,
0.5499049425,
0.2604213655,
-0.1655371785,
-0.4943603277,
-0.7062972188,
-0.7697102427,
0.3689384758,
0.2690112293,
-0.3399053812,
-0.1044471264,
0.1307379752,
0.1940784007,
-0.3987814188,
-0.2561886311,
-0.240995422,
-0.1563916355,
0.2023367882,
0.2430756688,
-0.6161718369,
-0.1529958695,
-0.2907102108,
0.5189521909,
-0.1734817624,
0.3931974769,
0.196470812,
0.0716548786,
-0.0615469925,
0.6762905717,
0.294798255,
0.7476569414,
-0.4346905351,
0.5906912684,
-0.038987726,
-0.1314211041,
0.408829689,
0.1167924628,
-0.5007426739,
-0.2130009532,
0.3529489934,
0.261659652,
-0.3282947838,
-0.3418825567,
0.4078125656,
-0.2339719385,
-0.4877179265,
0.0847099125,
-0.1405723989,
0.3088625371,
0.2951610684,
0.3471181095,
-0.0690956488,
0.0816611201,
-0.4540164769,
0.254776001,
0.2682168186,
0.0705741942,
-0.0641029924,
0.9863092899,
0.1014134064,
0.3293340504,
0.7718081474,
-0.3890332282,
-0.6937806606,
0.7471087575,
0.3400913775,
0.9214796424,
-0.4332049489,
0.5266491175,
0.5073297024,
0.5524812341,
-0.0665189475,
0.5691921711,
0.1140997857,
-0.8391342759,
-0.9616706371,
-0.3675412536,
-0.1399545074,
0.141240865,
-0.3739217222,
-0.1369035989,
-0.3082284629,
-0.069238767,
0.0540947989,
-0.5530505776,
-0.6378427148,
-0.0760882348,
0.1583706588,
0.724801898,
-0.7216442227,
0.4282107949,
0.5267561078,
-0.6944244504,
-1.0227168798,
0.2228904366,
-0.1313738525,
-0.4828151762,
0.2679344714,
-0.129138425,
-0.270591706,
-0.1411522627,
-0.7004482746,
-0.7103158236,
0.8615151048,
0.1976642758,
-0.117569901,
0.0760098249,
0.1402994096,
0.4010033309,
-0.197769478,
0.3097545505,
0.6274350286,
0.553805232,
0.3753129244,
-0.8072936535,
0.0819495767,
0.082832478,
-0.1026846543,
0.1480311751,
-0.3553323448,
0.9559655786,
-0.5144999623,
-0.2894805968,
0.2075754255,
0.5001506209,
0.4301680028,
0.3076862991,
0.5991318822,
1.0091403723,
0.4699635804,
-0.070341371,
0.9335560799,
0.0835701302,
0.4436148703,
1.0177736282,
-0.0545160547,
0.4370269179,
0.2406940907,
-0.349708885,
0.6286352277,
0.5590301752,
0.2895074785,
0.5647158623,
0.3192005754,
-0.1390559822,
-0.6884108186,
-0.0170119945,
-0.5364316702,
0.5186895132,
0.2189657688,
-0.1622558534,
-0.4448388517,
0.306299895,
-0.0514607616,
-0.1143956184,
-0.2706567943,
0.9189888239,
-0.0006860423,
-0.5920767188,
0.7100499272,
0.164556995,
0.3447026312,
-0.3973247409,
-0.2065435797,
-0.6119390726,
-0.0094005754,
-0.0532671809,
-0.7960214615,
-0.0438585058,
-0.1242712364,
-0.0697673187,
-0.1374452114,
0.7223191261,
-0.4608142078,
-0.3322781026,
0.2649022341,
0.9912440777,
0.0471816547,
-0.338406682,
-0.4635837972,
-0.2702961266,
0.0437611304,
-0.0511815064,
0.1344068795,
0.8607054353,
0.043257948,
0.753023088,
0.5318790674,
-0.2275751382,
0.1842780411,
0.4714415073,
0.8296557069,
-0.581897378,
-0.5888374448,
-0.4410116971,
0.2072859704,
0.2527031302,
0.0870737508,
0.8696463704,
0.4436964393,
0.5626860857,
-0.0757416636,
0.7307101488,
-0.3424594402,
0.7620957494,
-0.6729075313,
0.1481267512,
-0.331589818,
0.3067900538,
-0.3027462065,
-0.9532536268,
-0.0923660249,
0.3589874506,
-0.1300572455,
0.2027354091,
1.0074262619,
0.5777121186,
0.0633876771,
0.1972399205,
0.1796409637,
-0.0098074162,
0.5184572935,
0.6752855182,
1.2832534313,
-0.2046708465,
0.6672034264,
-0.3245159388,
-0.390630722,
0.0734457374,
-0.525801599,
-0.8395977616,
-0.6103278995,
-0.4151107669,
-0.3920978606,
-0.2665311694,
0.5607229471,
0.1619934142,
-0.797406435,
0.2893918753,
0.0136138694,
0.335166961,
-0.6704287529,
-0.2428766638,
0.7127740383,
-0.2965226471,
-0.4458766878,
0.7913427353,
0.2549957335,
0.0229531359,
-0.3524980843,
0.1324749291,
-0.4350215495,
-0.0450743474,
0.6028721333,
0.1989254206,
-0.431420505,
-0.4542507231,
0.1767077297,
0.1637956947,
0.0416801237,
1.0938247442,
-0.679889977,
0.581905365,
0.9567764401,
0.7071502805,
0.2074058056,
0.4621163309,
0.3229186237,
-0.3613829613,
-0.3677853644,
0.2456028908,
0.4376785159,
-0.0061318595,
-0.0679469258,
0.6030436158,
0.12728782,
-0.8217039108,
-0.1136175916,
0.2405641526,
-0.9604813457,
-0.732242465,
1.5235259533,
0.0245153941,
-0.0094152922,
-0.5371400118,
-0.2237275094,
0.0825019553,
-0.1195497587,
0.6749944687,
0.5118210316,
-0.1644088924,
-0.2138665617,
-0.5218774676,
0.1988959014,
0.248022154,
-0.9915700555,
0.1336381435,
0.7872020602,
0.2946036458,
0.1700698882,
0.6691128016,
-0.3994528949,
0.1187437326,
0.0986683294,
-0.0104160709,
-0.1607769877,
-0.4871799648,
-0.2621059418,
0.6483957171,
0.0251225755,
-0.4508133233
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11163v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11163v1
|
KG-Agent: An Efficient Autonomous Agent Framework for Complex Reasoning over Knowledge Graph
| 2024-02-17T02:07:49 | 2024-02-17T02:07:49 |
Jinhao Jiang, Kun Zhou, Wayne Xin Zhao, Yang Song, Chen Zhu, Hengshu Zhu, Ji-Rong Wen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we aim to improve the reasoning ability of large language
models (LLMs) over knowledge graphs (KGs) to answer complex questions. Inspired
by existing methods that design the interaction strategy between LLMs and KG,
we propose an autonomous LLM-based agent framework, called KG-Agent, which
enables a small LLM to actively make decisions until finishing the reasoning
process over KGs. In KG-Agent, we integrate the LLM, multifunctional toolbox,
KG-based executor, and knowledge memory, and develop an iteration mechanism
that autonomously selects the tool then updates the memory for reasoning over
KG. To guarantee the effectiveness, we leverage program language to formulate
the multi-hop reasoning process over the KG, and synthesize a code-based
instruction dataset to fine-tune the base LLM. Extensive experiments
demonstrate that only using 10K samples for tuning LLaMA-7B can outperform
state-of-the-art methods using larger LLMs or more data, on both in-domain and
out-domain datasets. Our code and data will be publicly released.
|
[
-0.4739291668,
-0.9133588672,
0.8252346516,
-0.0927506536,
-0.0438229777,
0.4014943242,
-0.2324329019,
-0.4788374603,
0.0728146136,
0.6474413276,
-0.3911219835,
-0.5368933082,
-0.5209707618,
-0.0705913752,
0.059157338,
0.4773727357,
-0.14828825,
-0.1068927944,
-0.2648693025,
-0.1645177603,
-0.2142092139,
-0.2324129194,
-0.8556545973,
-0.7378259301,
0.6621695757,
0.4900046587,
0.9962050915,
0.8759257197,
0.2278020531,
0.4219284058,
0.0812810361,
0.6214950085,
-0.4687277675,
0.3294761777,
-0.4058066607,
-0.4639776051,
-0.6412658691,
-0.2938516736,
0.2712708712,
0.49676916,
-0.0233064797,
-0.0679659396,
-0.491466701,
0.5997068286,
-0.611828804,
0.6514415145,
-0.5516710877,
-0.1666357815,
0.0182711687,
-0.2519227266,
-0.588996172,
-0.3587176502,
-0.1351603568,
-0.7626062036,
-0.3331568241,
0.1429197341,
0.4114743769,
0.45453462,
-0.7257046103,
-0.4925303161,
-0.6117038727,
0.525483489,
-0.6169466972,
0.2833209634,
0.31129843,
0.7023314238,
-0.6055448651,
-0.7566326261,
-0.7062212229,
-0.3768933415,
-0.000358531,
-0.0289169606,
-0.1091979668,
0.2853054106,
0.1647353172,
-0.1213261411,
-0.3200803697,
0.0337496549,
0.0996498987,
-0.2371886671,
0.7952132225,
0.2075223178,
0.1107667908,
0.0614999384,
-0.0306400526,
-0.2191019952,
-0.6028389335,
-0.0392892025,
0.5222049356,
0.187098071,
0.2977698743,
0.6446220875,
-0.6647862196,
0.9061169028,
-0.0855746046,
-0.406044364,
0.2095569968,
0.1399426907,
-0.1946737915,
-0.0437402837,
0.6534700394,
0.3285612464,
0.4369546771,
-0.4545962214,
-0.1864328235,
-0.0847864076,
0.1942003816,
-0.6630011201,
-0.3264790773,
0.3208380044,
-0.0848077834,
-0.1728529781,
-0.153743729,
-0.4644560516,
-0.513299942,
-0.4648549855,
0.6384661198,
-0.4651143551,
-0.3050689399,
0.1671376079,
-0.1740926504,
0.1490318924,
0.6186028719,
-0.3790312409,
0.1056996509,
0.4888689518,
0.228223294,
0.0538683757,
-0.358708024,
-0.5125529766,
0.6103923917,
-0.4745109677,
0.960931778,
-0.6766314507,
-0.1874786764,
-0.2964141667,
0.0015370089,
-0.1323972344,
-0.5799279809,
0.2530534565,
-0.9967058301,
-0.2520338297,
-0.3155918717,
-0.6547182202,
-0.6586351395,
0.5739833117,
-0.6166794896,
0.7467936873,
0.1675551385,
-0.2348667532,
0.092506364,
-0.9019721746,
-0.4704859555,
0.0393719301,
-0.1916881949,
-0.1795769781,
-0.5048928857,
0.293553859,
0.5339076519,
-0.3990247548,
0.2642035186,
-0.5449532866,
-0.1954937726,
0.1006352827,
-0.1171057224,
0.6162922978,
0.2572816312,
-0.1438742429,
0.2090992182,
-0.7990944386,
0.5074480176,
0.2099343091,
-0.4229682684,
-0.0195862651,
0.1140950993,
-0.641274929,
0.1520966589,
0.3102013469,
-0.3326796293,
0.576892972,
-0.2258045226,
0.2551147044,
0.7625712752,
-0.0100803589,
0.4949220121,
-0.4676658809,
0.6333833933,
-0.1410733312,
0.1104540676,
0.051048927,
-0.3939104676,
-0.7329388261,
-0.3180570602,
0.0191892516,
0.5219826698,
-1.0578978062,
0.2368049026,
-0.2551463246,
-0.7404393554,
-0.2440209687,
0.1218471602,
0.430378437,
0.4442317188,
0.3398509026,
0.137988627,
-0.1729180068,
-0.7535170317,
-0.1157832667,
-0.2139813006,
0.2449620515,
0.6310353279,
0.4399654865,
-0.3924539089,
1.1797806025,
-0.5843797326,
-0.0001395711,
-0.3614259958,
-0.0035614986,
0.1534930766,
0.225779444,
0.4085566401,
-0.7082949281,
-0.5407774448,
0.4297758043,
-0.9319685698,
-0.1846778244,
0.0831625909,
-0.4216668606,
0.1268130392,
0.5277537107,
-0.9356768727,
0.1192704812,
0.1484857649,
-0.4523426294,
0.5199477673,
-0.2858639657,
0.1515333951,
-0.8499060869,
-0.1220369637,
-0.570017457,
-0.3539628983,
-0.4712824821,
0.3589857817,
-0.0207261592,
0.2221049219,
-0.2459444404,
0.7271707654,
-0.4830147028,
-0.0394188613,
-0.4853982031,
0.1225482747,
0.0427238792,
0.6841057539,
-0.1514705867,
0.5761566758,
0.5193704367,
-0.6908319592,
0.9978622794,
0.1098825336,
-0.2384707183,
0.3337301612,
-0.3771148324,
0.4121830165,
-0.3645834625,
0.3479073644,
-0.6530543566,
-0.3972035348,
0.4060762525,
-0.3369992673,
0.3015595675,
-0.1720585674,
-0.661359787,
-0.3982028961,
-0.0050034141,
0.089089781,
0.1990881562,
-0.5929151773,
1.2518155575,
0.3071739674,
0.1040835828,
-0.7526896,
-0.171555236,
0.0818871483,
0.0227816459,
-0.8924224973,
0.0380306169,
-0.2149528265,
-0.3748060465,
0.3128051758,
-0.0081175854,
-0.0739975721,
0.1312988698,
0.0617136061,
-0.1711360812,
-0.0462819263,
0.3484147787,
0.2993568778,
-0.3299268186,
0.0411355644,
-0.3751046062,
0.6483302712,
-0.0657002553,
-0.6681387424,
-0.0018812672,
0.1459479183,
0.7780799866,
-0.086728856,
0.5888704062,
0.2723945677,
-0.0604878068,
-0.586556077,
-0.5689169168,
0.0761281922,
-0.4985023439,
0.435389936,
-0.7548527122,
-0.8394224644,
0.6369479299,
-0.5400369763,
-0.1491935998,
0.2755038738,
0.8002380729,
0.062149439,
1.0382050276,
0.2144362926,
-0.1080309078,
-0.06839367,
-0.3773492873,
0.236769557,
-0.4692916572,
-0.425679028,
-0.2265929431,
-0.2934925854,
-0.1614253521,
-0.565790236,
0.5041720867,
0.2779515386,
-0.5572826266,
0.2155966759,
-0.4489545524,
0.7361000776,
0.6275574565,
-0.0491420217,
0.4928221703,
-0.4911569357,
-0.2657172084,
0.6975257993,
-0.8795112371,
-0.4849406779,
0.9500275254,
0.0819759816,
0.8635981679,
0.306707114,
0.287861228,
0.2747491598,
0.3261367381,
-0.802120924,
0.7931990623,
0.3806090951,
-0.6046416759,
-0.5376611352,
-0.5854430795,
-0.8131189346,
0.4111166894,
0.0518912748,
-0.6485390067,
-0.1419257075,
0.0639660954,
-0.1555541754,
0.33996436,
-0.858525157,
0.7457771897,
-0.2127192169,
-0.1063082442,
-0.2086859494,
-0.715952158,
0.3032134771,
-0.1166096404,
0.1271855086,
-0.2188054621,
0.0682539493,
0.3284810185,
-0.7336598635,
0.6481015682,
-0.3607829213,
-0.0952694118,
0.6695725918,
0.1172282696,
0.9340950847,
-0.0970893502,
-0.1801741272,
-0.2418864667,
-0.0570801795,
-0.2854025364,
-1.0278673172,
0.5041107535,
-1.0689383745,
-0.7581506371,
-0.0058832848,
-0.912083149,
-0.428901583,
0.2851747572,
-0.1614658982,
0.2924574316,
0.2978325188,
0.2298469096,
0.4504352212,
-0.1059335768,
0.3194462061,
0.8091095686,
-0.2570016682,
-0.459469378,
0.8645208478,
0.3945207298,
0.3930217326,
0.5523465872,
0.2920614183,
-0.3137559295,
-0.4662231505,
-0.7068325281,
0.0569663607,
-1.093229413,
-0.3756535649,
-0.7866925001,
-0.1767652333,
-0.3370718062,
-0.2095437348,
-0.4181616604,
-0.2893952429,
0.2011343986,
-0.1740990728,
0.6313284039,
0.6570424438,
0.0701388642,
0.4651095867,
-0.6480578184,
0.3238986433,
0.580401063,
0.2401991338,
0.2402317673,
-0.1748288572,
-0.2109979838,
-0.1027850881,
-0.1943168193,
-0.6938396692,
0.178504318,
-0.1106272563,
0.8909276724,
0.5154030919,
0.3805804849,
0.6431507468,
-0.2000169903,
0.3084532917,
-0.248251155,
-0.8635165095,
0.2948117554,
-0.5576549172,
0.258749634,
0.2909853458,
0.1611259431,
-0.277674973,
-0.5494681597,
-0.4369879365,
-0.6941473484,
0.7852001786,
0.1920787543,
-0.2051265985,
0.0657876432,
0.4852267206,
-0.0409494899,
0.3085185587,
-0.5495454073,
-0.2950978577,
0.0346211977,
-0.2529696822,
0.1928153634,
-0.1004880443,
-0.2632213235,
-0.2668900788,
0.8930510879,
-0.5892810822,
0.2309793979,
0.0330490842,
-0.1130507365,
-0.1552434862,
0.1292738765,
0.3245669305,
0.7145159245,
-0.0231275819,
0.315425396,
0.3391950727,
-0.2308584154,
0.2931376696,
0.1669203639,
-0.1134631932,
-0.4807403982,
0.4791779518,
0.6199378371,
-0.1571735889,
-0.9836776257,
0.3068346977,
0.2006399333,
-0.2296006233,
-0.2477860302,
0.5175101757,
0.5262729526,
0.8335615396,
0.2291470617,
-0.0268672425,
-0.2028175592,
-0.3701857924,
0.0103123598,
0.4207697809,
0.0007497996,
0.1188147366,
0.5336121321,
0.0788439587,
-0.2580960989,
0.4487429261,
-0.7046120167,
-0.5702198148,
0.9544897079,
0.450711906,
0.4523791075,
-0.0570986941,
0.1694416851,
0.0519148596,
0.3090976477,
0.0203491449,
0.3268956244,
-0.1488257051,
-1.2432172298,
-0.7778778672,
-0.3534986675,
-0.590959549,
-0.1435073763,
-0.1237829179,
0.0831328481,
-0.4182445705,
0.1280635744,
-0.2418709844,
0.1846046895,
-0.3054727614,
0.2425878793,
-0.060738042,
0.9308311343,
-0.3799130619,
1.0570061207,
0.7277670503,
-0.3154618144,
-1.2207292318,
-0.4699070156,
-0.110116519,
-0.9024507999,
0.6488685608,
0.0381654277,
-0.5664095879,
0.1536782831,
-0.6739031076,
-1.0817545652,
1.5187008381,
0.6095927954,
-0.3928545713,
0.2562495172,
0.1579089165,
0.3454917967,
-0.4046423435,
0.3120588362,
0.4938541353,
0.8008182049,
0.5772576928,
-0.733041048,
-0.0849961117,
-0.2940794528,
-0.4631655812,
0.2926599681,
-0.9903404713,
0.7470136881,
-0.3144204021,
0.1462943703,
-0.0498797372,
0.5111851692,
0.3758424222,
0.4581974447,
0.6456038952,
0.8209071755,
0.993004024,
0.1149445102,
1.0886509418,
-0.4092769921,
0.2660405338,
1.0900352001,
-0.4101994634,
0.2947201729,
-0.006036622,
-0.0413501933,
0.4692697227,
0.3621787429,
0.1044062898,
0.3760829568,
0.2605763972,
-0.4287386239,
-0.6756034493,
0.0232999641,
-0.1385163814,
0.5689106584,
0.2538958192,
-0.0590743311,
-0.3324254453,
0.1039170623,
0.2840588987,
-0.089636974,
-0.3577421904,
0.7348607779,
-0.1333157271,
-0.6973803639,
0.2287914306,
0.1981886327,
0.0193593372,
-0.7399706244,
-0.0170246996,
0.0934540778,
0.3530855477,
-0.1286907643,
-0.7251133919,
0.1374998242,
-0.3144336343,
-0.1717791259,
0.0047768126,
1.0007202625,
-0.2737365961,
-0.3007109761,
0.6438686252,
0.7602242231,
0.1092776507,
-0.1723843962,
-0.5374096632,
-0.1592068374,
-0.1354737729,
-0.6100255251,
0.2060611844,
0.8860167861,
-0.1845840961,
1.2510317564,
0.6573399305,
-0.1007013917,
0.0533704199,
0.164702341,
1.1437737942,
-0.622154057,
-0.3433391452,
-0.7767912149,
0.2728500068,
-0.1304580569,
0.0465008318,
0.6660571694,
0.4488725066,
0.8183990121,
0.0214070734,
0.8602979779,
-0.2342361957,
0.3868223131,
-0.5276190042,
0.7373353839,
-0.3329635561,
0.1642374545,
-0.0556049347,
-0.6709057093,
-0.2345210314,
0.6267982125,
-0.4121903181,
0.1975600719,
0.5036206245,
1.0240314007,
0.1137216687,
-0.0331109613,
0.4544204772,
0.4122056961,
0.5460506082,
0.6212406158,
0.8859905005,
-0.0209361352,
0.7155575156,
-0.14509058,
-0.1425762922,
-0.0278788786,
-0.8307056427,
-0.8757467866,
-0.1349522918,
-0.1756895036,
-0.2899377644,
-0.035573028,
1.1542313099,
0.6414690614,
-0.4254016876,
-0.0819940045,
-0.1628106982,
0.665810585,
-0.3312162161,
-0.1789506376,
0.3933371007,
-0.3637793362,
-0.6975388527,
0.5615380406,
0.3795011938,
-0.3698208928,
-0.2539808154,
-0.4504067004,
-0.076793626,
0.1006645411,
0.806273818,
0.0887297541,
-0.487203747,
-0.5138481259,
-0.106236428,
0.01703256,
-0.067631714,
0.6171901822,
-0.7578371167,
0.7159218192,
0.4263086915,
0.7995002866,
0.515606761,
-0.1129582226,
0.51422894,
-0.3420435786,
-0.1001150012,
0.2049964666,
0.2820724249,
-0.0451568328,
-0.4133646488,
0.5898406506,
0.303809464,
-0.6831362247,
-0.3509013355,
0.410667628,
-1.0740423203,
-0.5452268124,
1.2906832695,
-0.0860643834,
-0.3235794008,
-0.3821978867,
-0.3350329995,
0.2652190924,
-0.4637261331,
0.5498659611,
0.7571449876,
-0.531398654,
-0.2189245522,
-0.3628510535,
0.2158635706,
-0.0512628593,
-0.9609923959,
-0.0368216708,
0.5301941633,
0.2156940103,
0.2014697492,
0.8491207361,
0.0751320794,
0.1540571153,
0.1685296744,
0.1682946384,
-0.670560658,
-0.494762361,
0.3679330945,
0.5744954944,
0.1478604525,
0.1017015502
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11161v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11161v1
|
PANDA (Pedantic ANswer-correctness Determination and Adjudication):Improving Automatic Evaluation for Question Answering and Text Generation
| 2024-02-17T01:56:19 | 2024-02-17T01:56:19 |
Zongxia Li, Ishani Mondal, Yijun Liang, Huy Nghiem, Jordan Lee Boyd-Graber
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Question answering (QA) can only make progress if we know if an answer is
correct, but for many of the most challenging and interesting QA examples,
current answer correctness (AC) metrics do not align with human judgments,
particularly verbose, free form answers from large language models (LLM). There
are two challenges: a lack of data and that models are too big. LLM based
scorers correlate better with humans, but this expensive task has only been
tested on limited QA datasets. We rectify these issues by providing clear
guidelines for evaluating machine QA adopted from human QA contests. We also
introduce Precise ANswer correctness Determination and Adjudication (PANDA), a
small, efficient, deterministic AC classifier (812 KB) that more accurately
evaluates answer correctness.
|
[
-0.249452576,
-1.2409279346,
0.4373254478,
0.3574630022,
-0.2050896883,
0.0635331199,
0.0089487219,
-0.1678439379,
0.0891643837,
0.2690121233,
-0.2352027744,
-0.2499947995,
-0.3252236247,
0.4161993563,
-0.2961222231,
1.109311223,
-0.1875460893,
-0.1215386987,
-0.5991309285,
-0.176174745,
-0.4844513834,
-0.5262711048,
-0.6752080321,
-0.0348690785,
0.2550684512,
0.4352064729,
0.8836975098,
0.6189646721,
0.7386584282,
0.2988163829,
-0.2903017104,
0.1010437384,
-0.0974493399,
0.0566241778,
-0.1322517991,
-0.8421091437,
-0.5377031565,
0.1762836277,
0.5167150497,
0.6274266839,
-0.4895420969,
0.4289458394,
-0.275547415,
0.8605599403,
-0.6552121043,
0.2214290947,
-0.610375762,
0.0515019856,
-0.0571289249,
-0.0322224535,
-0.1396019608,
-0.8381122351,
0.1419601887,
-0.9690759778,
0.4806551933,
-0.032390967,
0.8360259533,
0.7931634784,
-0.4924589097,
-0.5279916525,
-0.3821188509,
0.6705659032,
-0.4672672749,
-0.030151723,
0.41183424,
0.6222990155,
-0.0714659095,
-0.5012018085,
-0.8362421989,
-0.0695915297,
0.0385001563,
-0.0531054251,
-0.2395710349,
-0.0259022452,
0.385422796,
0.269906044,
-0.6143962741,
-0.1248898581,
-0.4387049675,
-0.0979036093,
0.8941147923,
0.4770352244,
0.2333933264,
-0.2451521903,
0.0849304944,
-0.1348472983,
-0.6483162045,
0.5364800096,
0.5596863627,
-0.1586146057,
0.2792241573,
0.7253172994,
-0.3219399452,
0.7715448141,
0.5737858415,
-0.0244247653,
0.0918477178,
-0.3325854838,
-0.0737538859,
0.0564740263,
0.761197269,
0.3154110312,
0.2306635082,
-0.0562287718,
-0.0580790751,
0.4057703018,
0.4448546469,
-0.7113630772,
-0.6204132438,
0.4390901923,
-0.2936520576,
-0.4275907278,
0.0545438677,
-0.6652674079,
-0.389613688,
-0.2560070753,
0.3486087024,
-0.2122463584,
-0.1610224247,
0.0891847312,
-0.2218042612,
0.3440611064,
0.6012271643,
-0.677747488,
0.1699055731,
0.7623082995,
0.3968383074,
0.0109462198,
-0.0872500911,
-0.8602049947,
-0.2602803409,
-0.8830897808,
0.9759098887,
-0.4292459488,
-0.2386567444,
-0.2481065243,
-0.0153424544,
-0.1422812939,
-0.8333311677,
0.684173882,
-0.582088232,
0.4134156108,
-0.3259345591,
-0.4495336115,
-0.3429815471,
0.2897841334,
-0.7285705209,
0.8927310109,
0.1922411174,
-0.7814162374,
0.4875251353,
-0.6238750219,
-0.4141386449,
0.0620728843,
0.0865547806,
-0.5508761406,
-0.0828767419,
0.2905757427,
0.3372882903,
-0.2192851007,
0.2798410952,
-0.2907717228,
-0.531932354,
0.4537151158,
-0.4942875803,
0.9591992497,
0.3066422045,
-0.1046656966,
0.0470458716,
-0.7875323296,
0.0156083452,
0.1340563148,
-0.7014143467,
-0.1454593092,
-0.0074417014,
-0.2834316492,
0.1460945308,
0.4661408961,
-0.6447640061,
0.1531831622,
-0.3334667385,
0.5144942403,
0.773871839,
-0.1260339022,
0.2554735839,
-0.6039056778,
0.8394346833,
-0.0426686443,
0.003695131,
0.0963710845,
-0.7618067861,
-0.5725919008,
-0.076354675,
0.4470061362,
1.0345679522,
-0.7353839278,
0.5540505648,
-0.1614625752,
-0.7273582816,
-0.8931382298,
0.3502745926,
0.4566645324,
0.5668332577,
0.2158211172,
-0.2549723983,
-0.2533124685,
-0.7350527048,
-0.3370861411,
-0.8207879066,
0.0438187644,
0.2838712037,
0.3720813394,
0.1418993324,
0.8835475445,
-0.6667006016,
0.0051052584,
0.064870216,
0.1829672605,
0.0840835795,
0.3240993023,
0.5018504262,
-0.9978504181,
-0.5591777563,
-0.2258951962,
-0.6571515203,
-0.1784020215,
0.1364548057,
0.0540524982,
0.3857105076,
0.1409409493,
-0.6462208629,
0.3622413278,
0.1862097085,
-0.4340765178,
0.8828157187,
-0.1320939362,
0.3839282393,
-0.647153616,
0.2018096447,
0.0410311855,
-0.2937731445,
-0.344818294,
0.0195998792,
0.2004553825,
-0.0201858263,
-0.3391489983,
0.4733804166,
0.0098332986,
0.1459074765,
0.0074849008,
0.3515416086,
0.2923529148,
0.4427093267,
-0.0230470095,
1.0437674522,
0.1058475152,
-0.7693068385,
0.9665279388,
0.4565845132,
-0.4564110339,
1.0472069979,
-0.7965855598,
0.1746060699,
-0.2797534168,
0.2887342572,
-1.2049947977,
-0.1888464689,
0.2431330979,
-0.7420927286,
0.3202312291,
0.2219363749,
-0.5977172256,
-0.5707216859,
-0.3591652215,
0.4905422628,
0.5071040988,
-0.5566787124,
0.1550810486,
0.415957123,
-0.3838725686,
-0.8030596375,
-0.4048171043,
0.0967243239,
-0.3273299634,
-0.7123929262,
-0.0864827782,
-0.4416114092,
-0.5655196309,
-0.0665008947,
-0.0518177301,
-0.2907890379,
0.3835637271,
-0.1572797,
0.0226907097,
-0.2317053676,
0.3214443624,
-0.0336876437,
-0.0050521246,
0.2297563702,
0.3808214664,
0.2187965214,
-0.3280645013,
-0.0713090375,
-0.7192348838,
0.1734465212,
0.3605993986,
-0.2859702706,
0.3572553098,
0.3760818839,
-0.319386512,
0.1025393605,
-0.5550266504,
0.1843088716,
-0.3997122943,
0.2754282951,
-0.4546590447,
-0.4692560136,
0.4383137524,
0.4004837275,
0.1692935228,
0.7012891769,
0.3715125918,
-0.2585956454,
1.3642430305,
0.3734537363,
0.2448290288,
0.2237904519,
-0.0532294363,
0.0087894872,
-0.7882889509,
-0.1888260543,
-0.9187551141,
0.0058975234,
-0.4093410671,
-0.1330810338,
0.160535574,
0.3220457137,
-0.3563341796,
0.3973454237,
-0.7563959956,
0.1614909321,
0.4834164679,
-0.0027385342,
0.2718941867,
-0.4891135097,
0.1889311224,
0.0533006564,
-0.5895702839,
-0.7834621668,
1.2365897894,
0.165011704,
0.6624640822,
0.2004512995,
0.3628901839,
0.3846474886,
0.4944857955,
-0.7475864887,
0.4720378816,
-0.1589330584,
-0.8438494205,
-0.4034729898,
-0.5617664456,
-0.749799192,
0.0489850678,
-0.0065368223,
-0.3593575954,
0.0332716219,
0.0796463341,
-0.592215538,
-0.0263835825,
-0.8743165135,
1.0317970514,
-0.1009587646,
-0.0182261113,
0.0044031888,
-0.7165998816,
0.4107632637,
-0.2908833921,
0.0529574081,
-0.1487209797,
-0.1663976014,
1.0252183676,
-0.4127115607,
0.5547596812,
-0.1346661597,
-0.4194244742,
0.6605886817,
0.0858312771,
0.3331961334,
0.0443985276,
-0.2410950065,
-0.2441126704,
0.6115714908,
-0.5293367505,
-0.7933399677,
0.3629381657,
-0.8004648089,
-0.8863118291,
-0.4206040204,
-0.2615806162,
-0.0563934632,
-0.2142373323,
0.1772405505,
0.1030691117,
-0.3176080585,
0.1659495831,
0.8595862985,
-0.3746509254,
-0.0832457766,
0.5927858353,
-0.1056101471,
-0.5725576282,
0.8714954257,
0.2077276856,
0.0011642693,
0.6043650508,
0.0402426124,
-0.5575401783,
-0.1670244336,
-0.8562309146,
0.2666226923,
-0.8522849679,
-0.2374045849,
-0.5231135488,
-0.01219049,
-0.6217648387,
-0.1260277927,
0.0400306657,
-0.8580829501,
-0.4825333059,
-0.1064804941,
0.210558489,
0.7077236176,
0.0121536301,
0.2233820856,
-0.6511493921,
0.6093600988,
0.6670098305,
0.1600308716,
-0.2839215994,
-0.3937124014,
0.1471167803,
0.2827855647,
-0.6711762547,
-0.840010643,
0.0493639261,
0.277998656,
0.5146000981,
0.4696516097,
0.2259607762,
0.5698267817,
-0.1920154393,
1.1098842621,
0.1057557613,
-0.9337804914,
0.8594694138,
0.0076830755,
-0.0566347763,
0.3630852103,
0.0054135974,
-0.5229719281,
-0.2701985836,
-0.7050663233,
-0.3840488493,
0.6940925121,
0.0184541252,
-0.0156999696,
-0.1738987565,
0.5410727859,
0.0933505967,
0.3442670405,
-0.2936559618,
-0.1739042997,
-0.3991099894,
-0.4022035301,
-0.2953950167,
-0.1117176786,
-0.1477666646,
-0.1110293195,
0.8698214293,
-0.2544134259,
0.041217342,
0.2464585006,
-0.065035142,
-0.3997408152,
0.2591277659,
0.2904730439,
0.8189233541,
-0.2028365135,
-0.1981216967,
0.1715898067,
-0.3677925766,
0.3660230637,
0.2464480102,
-0.3438157737,
-0.0702773705,
0.1385982186,
0.4041166902,
-0.4010976255,
-0.8867471814,
0.832182169,
-0.5323495269,
-0.0951484516,
-0.2981382012,
0.4025301933,
-0.184825629,
-0.0157390796,
0.2773842514,
-0.0675753877,
0.0733567253,
-0.3958617747,
0.066170074,
0.4483742714,
-0.3667811453,
-0.1795704514,
0.9400938153,
0.1586154848,
-0.5644778609,
0.694584012,
-0.1886221021,
-0.6098701954,
1.058631897,
0.1579902172,
0.7602318525,
-0.2643044889,
0.494784832,
0.3568660915,
0.2419447601,
0.0552245341,
0.4376775622,
-0.3013230264,
-0.4843171239,
-0.3264419138,
-0.6772892475,
-0.5514944792,
-0.2386909574,
-0.5603342652,
0.3012087643,
-0.4646109343,
-0.1669464558,
0.1287177652,
0.6278017759,
-0.5702456236,
0.5070340037,
-0.3311558366,
0.8993669748,
-0.5902225375,
0.4925680459,
1.1317522526,
-0.7076220512,
-0.6816535592,
-0.0995696485,
-0.2644839585,
-0.5015128255,
0.5684258342,
0.1723778248,
0.1918761581,
-0.1719012856,
-0.7531200647,
-0.3786924481,
1.0526154041,
0.330848217,
-0.1460381895,
-0.065399006,
-0.0080362996,
0.7673367858,
0.0776908025,
0.1489205211,
0.5696561337,
0.3718632162,
-0.0312046185,
-1.0927796364,
-0.0716760308,
-0.468211323,
-0.0832858905,
0.0250491574,
-0.7854845524,
0.7197828889,
-0.5158053041,
-0.2722997069,
0.5028999448,
0.6695764661,
0.3434793949,
0.4236339331,
0.4990401864,
0.8743008971,
0.9554976821,
-0.236924842,
0.9678797722,
-0.0445062071,
0.1493701786,
0.5515419841,
-0.1418747157,
0.7883620858,
0.2380986661,
-0.6329703331,
0.4139176607,
1.0031983852,
0.2644520104,
0.2214243412,
0.314492017,
-0.081710428,
-0.4654419124,
0.085603416,
-0.275693953,
0.5269908309,
0.4279069901,
-0.0306526609,
-0.0385381468,
-0.2607030571,
-0.0090209395,
0.460654974,
-0.302763015,
0.9970003366,
-0.1055152565,
-1.1085541248,
0.7534202933,
0.1013229042,
0.4687129557,
-0.2395279855,
-0.2162644565,
-0.3042710721,
0.2370328754,
-0.1274470836,
-1.0780428648,
0.353625685,
0.2837532163,
-0.2640960813,
0.2392958701,
0.3335309923,
-0.2932886779,
-0.4516972899,
-0.3028818667,
0.2790684402,
0.4494580328,
-0.1513275951,
-0.7700416446,
-0.4677935541,
-0.221291095,
-0.1034927368,
-0.0404518917,
0.7538951039,
-0.041777987,
0.8768994808,
0.6061944962,
0.0121414447,
0.1767772287,
-0.5337232947,
0.5280627012,
-0.3992686272,
-0.6076962352,
-0.4041025937,
0.1493704468,
0.0365196541,
-0.4126707017,
0.5337802768,
0.6618646979,
0.6515726447,
0.1034270376,
0.8474454284,
-0.1001301184,
0.8360834718,
-0.2728978693,
0.6470703483,
-0.6387416124,
0.2287669927,
-0.3098937869,
-0.8204395175,
-0.3957782984,
0.7252132297,
-0.3534812033,
-0.146475628,
0.3780116141,
0.5687595606,
0.3599495888,
0.139231503,
0.0858815834,
0.0631568953,
0.5050245523,
0.7717632651,
0.9210096598,
-0.6242824197,
0.9180079103,
-0.3513325155,
-0.3228841126,
-0.2665623426,
-0.6324797273,
-0.6092681289,
-0.7028982639,
-0.5939607024,
-0.4973839223,
0.0756987408,
0.6375587583,
0.2058015913,
-0.8973075747,
0.0494626574,
0.0661587343,
0.4699281752,
-0.4804016352,
-0.3287193179,
0.6410722733,
-0.5165375471,
-0.827039957,
-0.1552930474,
-0.0339964181,
-0.0564395264,
-0.2916257083,
-0.1471009105,
-0.0521215126,
0.2089549154,
0.3696911037,
0.3749685585,
-0.6308882236,
-0.3508218229,
0.0926297531,
-0.2238540649,
0.151433602,
0.4250566363,
-0.9210042357,
0.5237923265,
0.6546191573,
0.689591825,
-0.1576581746,
0.4530420899,
0.5342848301,
-0.2719489634,
-0.3399837017,
0.3509765863,
0.2517066896,
0.6518805027,
-0.386208117,
0.5370029211,
0.3505882621,
-0.8490116,
-0.8023656011,
0.0958062932,
-0.6885374188,
-0.2784855664,
1.1330860853,
-0.3913474679,
-0.4488047957,
-0.3917827308,
-0.6016364694,
0.398437351,
-0.3551319838,
1.1233854294,
0.9563574791,
-0.1639502496,
0.1905223578,
-0.1748473495,
0.7020040751,
0.3278898895,
-0.8255494833,
0.2079373896,
0.5428925753,
0.3537090719,
0.3813613355,
0.7132514119,
-0.1245842353,
0.8399085402,
-0.0600674674,
-0.2461015731,
0.1608747095,
-0.3128100038,
-0.3373894691,
0.2718848288,
0.1309461892,
-0.2774814367
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11159v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11159v3
|
Assessing News Thumbnail Representativeness: Counterfactual text can enhance the cross-modal matching ability
| 2024-02-17T01:27:29 | 2024-06-07T00:56:09 |
Yejun Yoon, Seunghyun Yoon, Kunwoo Park
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
This paper addresses the critical challenge of assessing the
representativeness of news thumbnail images, which often serve as the first
visual engagement for readers when an article is disseminated on social media.
We focus on whether a news image represents the actors discussed in the news
text. To serve the challenge, we introduce NewsTT, a manually annotated dataset
of 1000 news thumbnail images and text pairs. We found that the pretrained
vision and language models, such as BLIP-2, struggle with this task. Since news
subjects frequently involve named entities or proper nouns, the pretrained
models could have a limited capability to match news actors' visual and textual
appearances. We hypothesize that learning to contrast news text with its
counterfactual, of which named entities are replaced, can enhance the
cross-modal matching ability of vision and language models. We propose
CFT-CLIP, a contrastive learning framework that updates vision and language
bi-encoders according to the hypothesis. We found that our simple method can
boost the performance for assessing news thumbnail representativeness,
supporting our assumption. Code and data can be accessed at
https://github.com/ssu-humane/news-images-acl24.
|
[
-0.4111456275,
-0.6986475587,
0.5269776583,
0.2302537709,
-0.8077112436,
0.375628233,
0.0035981433,
-0.6056622267,
0.4020610154,
0.2029569596,
-0.3715081811,
-0.2810502648,
-0.6263388991,
0.1410572529,
-0.6895723343,
0.8234342337,
0.0044263857,
0.0333898067,
-0.182078138,
-0.3180036545,
-0.0890892372,
-0.0682225153,
-0.485881418,
0.1611426771,
0.3000705242,
0.136180833,
1.1559071541,
0.5885426998,
0.5332753658,
0.328690052,
0.1994381845,
-0.1626383066,
-0.4131818414,
-0.4769369364,
-0.5283188224,
-0.192911908,
0.1574666351,
0.4716249704,
0.4932605624,
0.3217285573,
0.3704679906,
0.2270459384,
-0.0255508646,
0.5995301604,
-0.4227953851,
-0.0165689401,
-0.8725253344,
0.0620479174,
-0.2215741873,
-0.2951593101,
-0.1731222868,
-0.358042419,
0.2294112295,
-0.4994598329,
0.6198608875,
0.1016447097,
1.1403250694,
0.1151188612,
-0.5376600027,
-0.1391273439,
-0.2189314216,
0.5473685265,
-0.3340909779,
0.8221803904,
0.1675877273,
0.2705312371,
0.3782976866,
-0.3733424544,
-0.7716442347,
-0.2003165632,
-0.244820103,
0.1892282516,
-0.6948453188,
-0.3859260976,
0.1657618135,
0.4043658972,
-0.7463072538,
-0.1231563836,
-0.3752455115,
-0.3002376556,
0.2453999072,
-0.1332902014,
0.4899964035,
-0.3009214699,
-0.6204932928,
-0.2592911124,
-0.4424106181,
-0.0214307383,
0.2657663524,
0.0390555933,
-0.3211290538,
0.5062609911,
-0.0976662412,
0.4370504022,
0.3139674664,
0.0323211551,
0.333040297,
-0.5577999949,
-0.2501744032,
0.1466334164,
0.6878291965,
1.0112528801,
0.094279781,
-0.223029539,
0.0333845131,
0.2660532892,
0.2631333172,
-0.8057301044,
-0.0959879383,
0.0592905581,
-0.4592544436,
-0.3994042575,
0.2081598341,
-0.8783767223,
-0.2343753874,
-0.1342705637,
0.7172609568,
-0.2757914662,
-0.390068084,
-0.1227177456,
-0.4937472641,
0.2681148946,
0.4069547951,
-0.5397567749,
0.0306310207,
0.5196233392,
1.0264999866,
-0.1763942242,
-0.3355268538,
-0.5160845518,
-0.0741313696,
-0.6927514076,
0.8953467607,
-0.7204865813,
-0.0958274379,
-0.0304305479,
0.0262105037,
0.0731293336,
-0.6321833134,
0.2165102661,
-0.4065782726,
0.2039809674,
-0.6613231897,
-0.2275340557,
-0.1162833348,
0.4292769432,
-0.9666349292,
0.906180799,
0.4245923162,
-1.1049262285,
0.6585512161,
-0.1001709327,
-0.5057073236,
-0.2302105427,
-0.3430494964,
-0.4845536351,
0.2012584656,
0.5538343191,
0.4156974554,
0.0035488468,
0.0465251692,
-0.377761811,
-0.3610990942,
0.263183713,
-0.292563796,
0.5532650352,
-0.1622812003,
-0.285238117,
0.0862809345,
-0.5188627243,
-0.4111763537,
0.0440148972,
-0.0944932923,
-0.5460428596,
-0.3118637502,
0.4364943802,
0.28709957,
0.0158392284,
-0.7234976888,
-0.0780700892,
0.0381528661,
0.3673285842,
0.4478174746,
0.1014328301,
0.2944998443,
-0.4422724545,
0.2971705794,
0.4839065671,
0.3552292287,
-0.2946917415,
-0.0277808253,
-0.5548573732,
-0.1249048114,
0.4766784608,
0.4460025132,
-1.3539044857,
0.1552987695,
-0.1926462501,
-0.5625818968,
-0.5853466392,
0.0937654525,
0.4095709026,
0.4818795919,
0.5330472589,
-0.496558696,
-0.6635118723,
-1.1377722025,
-0.4792446792,
-0.2081914395,
0.1284203678,
0.1794999689,
0.3697540462,
-0.0503524989,
0.7794179916,
0.0747687817,
-0.3497274816,
-0.3119899333,
0.3803898096,
0.0658047572,
0.3510713875,
0.9628024697,
-1.1162362099,
-0.4839759171,
-0.1616486758,
-0.3368180394,
-0.0762516037,
-0.3980806172,
0.0100845098,
0.1797056794,
0.5948899388,
-0.4885272384,
0.5577899814,
0.6212449074,
-0.3359797895,
0.5756838322,
0.3474993408,
0.5660945773,
-0.8809127808,
0.1267649084,
0.4743264318,
-0.4665179551,
-0.3131240308,
-0.1736218929,
-0.0442287512,
-0.2562221587,
-0.6872867942,
0.731323123,
-0.3153285086,
-0.4129259884,
-0.1911653727,
0.3666177094,
-0.059012372,
0.3002715707,
0.5698227882,
1.0603768826,
0.4948085248,
-0.0691007376,
0.1131910235,
0.139110893,
-0.5747599602,
0.6751848459,
-0.6309934258,
-0.0978567079,
-0.0823949575,
0.220705688,
-1.1418594122,
-0.1116078719,
0.0766308531,
-0.3780841827,
-0.1383376271,
-0.0510101654,
-0.6284790039,
-0.3222714663,
-0.6108907461,
0.3817238212,
0.2858240306,
-0.5873843431,
0.5295640826,
0.0548080802,
-0.0946772471,
-0.4146305621,
-0.5823811889,
0.1521950215,
0.1168424636,
-0.19701536,
0.4174626768,
0.2106449753,
0.0732630119,
0.3172676563,
-0.3668783605,
-0.0170855615,
-0.1884842217,
-0.0433811173,
0.2270332873,
-0.1835003942,
0.1557975262,
0.1003618315,
0.0446700603,
-0.2285335064,
0.4178409278,
0.2559810877,
-0.0659754276,
-0.1836780757,
-0.3345527947,
0.4188279808,
0.533860445,
-0.2716364861,
0.2190015316,
1.0310052633,
-0.2134949267,
0.2322729677,
-0.7608929276,
-0.0763616189,
-0.3797948658,
0.576153934,
0.0447986424,
-0.5860429406,
0.394240737,
0.111375846,
-0.1148990244,
0.2544896901,
0.3092972934,
0.114792347,
0.7502101064,
0.6971949935,
-0.2506129444,
0.8234321475,
-0.0610589646,
-0.1761169434,
-0.5893316865,
-0.0483932532,
-0.1711378098,
-0.458190918,
-0.408798784,
-0.4904414117,
0.2971643806,
0.0266618785,
-0.0216575824,
0.489705056,
-0.3283133507,
0.7115527391,
0.690043807,
0.4543154836,
0.3569936156,
-0.1010998711,
-0.0186147336,
-0.1019981951,
-0.4887947142,
-0.2967132032,
0.5265315771,
0.3959011436,
0.6529363394,
0.0401282981,
0.4292022586,
0.2343813181,
0.5513429046,
-0.7837500572,
0.6199871898,
-0.4449959397,
-0.3805164695,
0.069978863,
-0.2652029395,
-0.5578535795,
0.2463859767,
-0.6270100474,
-0.5420983434,
0.476105839,
0.1437954754,
-0.2629536092,
0.2135707438,
-0.6054053307,
0.9377074242,
-0.3359889388,
-0.3594622314,
-0.1274865717,
-0.5713546276,
0.1481546313,
-0.0810720623,
-0.0083151171,
0.102845341,
-0.2626940906,
0.8687463999,
-0.1197271869,
1.0018266439,
0.0175452065,
0.3661537766,
0.0610880256,
0.0700912029,
0.1398997009,
0.0274593327,
0.1982549131,
0.1846652776,
0.1453023851,
-0.5054931641,
-0.5402038097,
0.3623223007,
-0.5247834325,
-0.7827273607,
-0.3907926083,
-0.2737805843,
-0.2773096859,
0.4411632121,
0.34425506,
0.488576293,
-0.4690331519,
0.4653255045,
0.2580485642,
-0.0020721175,
0.7237849832,
0.5517187119,
-0.3601712584,
-0.5800369382,
0.8646817803,
0.0542946905,
-0.0721773133,
0.4763025045,
0.2181890905,
-0.4354184866,
-0.4709107578,
-0.5746965408,
0.1076508835,
-0.5279715657,
-0.2952440381,
-0.423568368,
-0.0231089499,
-0.130839318,
-0.3561559021,
-0.3826266825,
-0.155470714,
-0.3888806701,
-0.0646468401,
0.1269537657,
0.5537496209,
0.0133389169,
0.1395029128,
-0.8101209402,
0.3708005548,
0.5374245644,
0.3271009028,
-0.0621815212,
-0.2395902425,
-0.1308723241,
-0.2651606202,
-0.3990122378,
-0.9883643985,
0.0159277618,
0.1155707762,
0.6746088266,
0.5280809402,
0.2317179888,
0.6554412246,
-0.3540203571,
0.8066567779,
0.5185335279,
-1.1637506485,
0.5703566074,
-0.2491091937,
0.3546697199,
0.7684364915,
0.6875708699,
-0.4114351571,
-0.6539946795,
-0.6442168355,
-0.3847220242,
0.1300191134,
0.1376808435,
0.2282942533,
-0.3056056499,
-0.0855080336,
0.221249938,
0.2412875593,
-0.8325121999,
0.2868843675,
-0.9455175996,
-0.2723854482,
0.0274354648,
-0.1698313504,
-0.0669420436,
-0.0803580806,
0.1829106808,
-0.2367929965,
0.1679867506,
0.4823467731,
-0.153260693,
-0.2619474232,
0.2896559834,
0.5810168386,
0.6886281967,
-0.2085357606,
0.4136616588,
-0.232564494,
-0.6115580797,
-0.1505135447,
0.2587269247,
-0.101191476,
0.3696327806,
0.7861876488,
0.6867354512,
0.5963977575,
-0.6396116018,
0.9417264462,
0.0504634231,
-0.284719944,
0.3344916105,
-0.0805099607,
-0.2380339801,
0.6242872477,
0.766463697,
0.137698099,
0.2636153698,
-1.0059332848,
0.4778707922,
0.5461808443,
-0.5370719433,
-0.4254872799,
0.3581779301,
0.4116889536,
-0.1101949662,
0.3192800879,
-0.1873580664,
-0.9888952971,
0.5147681236,
0.4774274528,
0.5705931187,
0.0232118908,
0.4843076468,
0.208874017,
0.4060152769,
-0.052172225,
0.1299226284,
0.0463659689,
-0.5984064341,
0.0023022601,
-0.1472254395,
-0.4635111094,
0.1573426723,
-0.5511335135,
0.2377575189,
-0.5088908076,
-0.2336841822,
0.2692266107,
0.1748137325,
-0.6795098782,
0.275827527,
-0.0792479366,
1.1887480021,
-1.3866750002,
0.6314484477,
0.8040776849,
-0.6353413463,
-0.5397837758,
0.5239699483,
-0.0418874212,
-0.6487103105,
0.5405065417,
0.384288311,
0.1828219593,
-0.1365114003,
-0.4858609736,
-0.3515311182,
0.9145021439,
0.5490731001,
-0.5692643523,
0.110017769,
-0.0231700316,
0.537419796,
-0.3573282063,
0.1810394526,
0.0843376368,
0.364161104,
0.2581904233,
-1.085264802,
0.2778172195,
-0.1716444045,
0.0087843714,
0.0138192922,
-0.9286170006,
0.7477434278,
-0.4014416635,
-0.4385008812,
-0.1038017645,
0.6234639883,
-0.0174522158,
0.5104779005,
0.7502869368,
0.3523876965,
0.1742650717,
0.0480710864,
0.7644982338,
-0.0069426605,
0.5177826881,
0.9076322913,
-0.0466572344,
1.0724927187,
0.7487389445,
-0.1346488744,
0.2505054474,
0.6399831176,
-0.4129539132,
0.8786512613,
-0.3391216695,
0.131343022,
-0.5010362864,
-0.2967988551,
-0.2403589785,
0.5698302388,
-0.1343650222,
-0.5792504549,
-0.7523264289,
0.1520732045,
-0.2656951547,
0.283300519,
-0.4116062522,
0.5596680045,
-0.1772658229,
-0.3295943141,
0.1309239864,
-0.3822320104,
0.5125722289,
-0.0049139508,
-0.304576844,
-0.1564790159,
-0.2985165119,
-0.0882448107,
-1.0663055182,
0.3870884478,
-0.2180960178,
-0.1308718324,
0.1991130561,
0.6183744073,
-0.5342953205,
-0.7355128527,
0.1504835188,
0.4453730583,
-0.1684279591,
-0.0418698415,
-0.9547120333,
0.401143074,
-0.1862249374,
-0.1055886447,
0.2150150239,
0.318326503,
-0.0946869999,
0.2682197392,
0.5307081342,
-0.118943572,
-0.3083992004,
-0.0445773974,
0.9918611646,
-0.5626793504,
-0.6310908794,
-0.7177186012,
0.0923686996,
-0.2426579893,
-0.3620788157,
0.5535758734,
0.8353514671,
0.853017211,
-0.1729693264,
0.539231956,
0.0003870572,
0.5273541808,
-0.7924089432,
0.5753757954,
-0.5339128375,
-0.1317619383,
-0.3386231363,
-0.6058298349,
-0.1136150658,
0.439902097,
-0.4157393277,
0.1318818778,
0.7602710724,
0.6875777245,
-0.5193761587,
0.0194117799,
0.4006887674,
0.0297614094,
-0.1547884494,
0.4556209147,
0.7326062918,
-0.5378769636,
0.5288485885,
-0.3560130596,
-0.2418356687,
-0.456341207,
-1.1358360052,
-1.2995840311,
-0.7636078,
-0.5332613587,
-0.1585154086,
0.255746454,
0.8263369799,
0.723834455,
-0.4700805545,
0.3898915052,
0.1949315518,
0.1966572553,
-0.367123574,
-0.188049525,
0.6367012858,
0.1186266914,
-0.5373809338,
-0.1120896488,
0.2501411736,
0.1971786618,
-0.1765802056,
0.3480881155,
-0.1721720248,
0.1557293534,
0.6338503957,
0.1569670886,
-0.83217448,
-0.7999690175,
-0.0363681987,
-0.1729965061,
0.1457059383,
0.9928206205,
-0.8331225514,
0.2388726026,
0.3385471702,
0.7652484775,
0.334435612,
0.324044317,
0.0366199836,
-0.8446549177,
0.233261928,
-0.1276968271,
0.3275209963,
0.4791709781,
-0.3349281251,
0.3969062269,
0.5147245526,
0.0525955558,
-0.7151940465,
0.0645757839,
-1.5542069674,
-0.3325805664,
1.051807642,
-0.0088851405,
-0.2857893705,
-0.1940821111,
-0.4042137563,
0.1323415935,
-0.472119242,
0.7597987652,
0.5960313678,
0.1537043154,
-1.0334726572,
-0.3114219904,
0.4180374146,
0.0145963393,
-0.6334813237,
-0.0661030039,
0.2620671391,
0.4628055096,
0.2971621156,
0.5734017491,
-0.1210107282,
0.7396646142,
0.2385194451,
-0.3899604082,
-0.3131603301,
-0.1338134408,
0.0546629168,
-0.0452865958,
-0.3206002414,
-0.269511342
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11142v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11142v1
|
Grasping the Essentials: Tailoring Large Language Models for Zero-Shot Relation Extraction
| 2024-02-17T00:20:06 | 2024-02-17T00:20:06 |
Sizhe Zhou, Yu Meng, Bowen Jin, Jiawei Han
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Relation extraction (RE), a crucial task in NLP, aims to identify semantic
relationships between entities mentioned in texts. Despite significant
advancements in this field, existing models typically rely on extensive
annotated data for training, which can be both costly and time-consuming to
acquire. Moreover, these models often struggle to adapt to new or unseen
relationships. In contrast, few-shot learning settings, which aim to reduce
annotation requirements, may offer incomplete and biased supervision for
understanding target relation semantics, leading to degraded and unstable
performance. To provide the model with accurate and explicit descriptions of
the relations types and meanwhile minimize the annotation requirements, we
study the definition only zero-shot RE setting where only relation definitions
expressed in natural language are used to train a RE model. Motivated by the
strong synthetic data generation power of LLMs, we propose a framework REPaL
which consists of three stages: (1) We utilize LLMs to generate initial seed
instances based on relation definitions and an unlabeled corpora. (2) We
fine-tune a bidirectional Small Language Model (SLM) using these initial seeds
to learn the relations for the target domain. (3) We enhance pattern coverage
and mitigate bias resulting from the limited number of initial seeds by
incorporating feedback acquired from SLM's predictions on unlabeled corpora. To
accomplish this, we leverage the multi-turn conversation ability of LLMs to
generate new instances in follow-up dialogues. Experiments on two datasets show
REPaL achieves better zero-shot performance with large margins over baseline
methods.
|
[
-0.2299022526,
-0.5986251831,
0.6740452647,
0.0138357654,
-0.3682484329,
-0.1878707558,
-0.2239328921,
-0.5772750974,
0.1434779167,
0.7639545202,
-0.7084271312,
-0.4422632158,
-0.4189670682,
0.3138791323,
-0.2930339575,
1.1053853035,
0.1024324745,
-0.17692855,
-0.0708653852,
-0.3211397529,
-0.261993736,
-0.368088007,
-0.4121716619,
-0.5247392654,
0.6211541295,
0.5208535194,
0.5931301713,
0.7040611506,
0.2111668289,
0.1127937958,
-0.0070297625,
0.0440773517,
-0.6708936095,
0.4721149504,
-0.2352696359,
-0.5169411898,
-0.2915916443,
0.0701529607,
0.5751267672,
0.808673203,
0.1674488336,
0.4372186661,
-0.2283540815,
0.4117342234,
-0.819380343,
0.2275587916,
-1.0081042051,
0.0489369519,
-0.0747351423,
-0.3621926308,
-0.5195965767,
0.1152377427,
0.2256678641,
-0.5404533148,
0.1992022097,
-0.0698078722,
1.1371873617,
0.0446801893,
-0.2682441175,
0.0047332672,
-0.8375217319,
0.8262177706,
-0.7510111928,
0.3181750476,
0.2176640481,
0.2192476988,
-0.297911793,
-0.5378267169,
-0.396066606,
-0.1966536641,
-0.1546232253,
-0.0718048438,
-0.1175001487,
0.0260392502,
0.4382444024,
0.3062221408,
-0.2591897547,
0.0968294591,
-0.1746560782,
0.1039219499,
0.6043300629,
0.1104563177,
0.1079445556,
-0.2971522212,
-0.2319207788,
0.1603980958,
-1.0773528814,
-0.321749568,
0.0087472647,
0.6117101908,
-0.0238109678,
0.8028501868,
-0.190396145,
0.8234319091,
0.0470618196,
-0.2228101641,
0.0595401973,
-0.3597736657,
-0.4690501988,
-0.1530791372,
1.0006008148,
0.0448252894,
0.6610005498,
-0.2914024293,
-0.1160241216,
-0.0556592979,
0.1136796772,
-0.9619904757,
-0.0461989529,
0.1344165802,
-0.1267166585,
-0.518338263,
-0.2687304616,
-0.6763163805,
0.0070840726,
-0.4463820457,
0.098800391,
-0.537291646,
-0.324759692,
-0.1107528657,
-0.0045257453,
0.6337546706,
0.2163069397,
-0.8764346242,
0.0807491541,
0.76971066,
0.8933914304,
0.0909347534,
-0.1132115796,
-0.6081514955,
0.402911067,
-0.4643813372,
0.6085672975,
-0.5944740772,
-0.2029708028,
0.1762831509,
0.0102074975,
-0.0012425901,
-0.1939336807,
0.32858482,
-0.66953969,
0.2238484025,
0.1338466555,
-0.6272073984,
-0.040799249,
0.3449143171,
-0.4733914435,
0.7486386299,
0.2353820354,
-0.7121646404,
0.3453738093,
-0.2911466956,
-0.5144472718,
0.0633451492,
-0.3662191331,
-0.3543169498,
0.1892300993,
0.2305088937,
0.6020618081,
-0.4295591712,
0.0783563852,
-0.5097338557,
-0.1485466212,
0.0212397855,
-0.0626071692,
0.7329400182,
0.1366122812,
-0.0800166726,
0.0057045482,
-1.0751291513,
0.0247702561,
0.2110916376,
-0.0464564376,
-0.4831832051,
-0.2266161293,
-0.1359128356,
0.402774632,
-0.0747946128,
-0.5856586099,
0.2997608483,
-0.7901068926,
0.3103683889,
0.4062655866,
0.4460009933,
0.8402572274,
0.0282972138,
0.6794640422,
-0.1055321321,
-0.1727859378,
-0.6059266925,
-0.1955896616,
-0.7912577987,
-0.1922106296,
0.3798825443,
0.4687469602,
-0.8639925718,
0.3572924137,
-0.4683608711,
-0.3833134472,
-0.5378396511,
0.3828776479,
0.5318712592,
0.562007606,
0.1732292175,
-0.1006003246,
-0.7425394654,
-0.8955301046,
-0.0425345898,
-0.08466658,
-0.1854744703,
0.2776299119,
0.3254396021,
-0.0505566075,
1.2631617785,
-0.5775033236,
-0.3474764228,
-0.5134205818,
0.0268240478,
0.3671416342,
0.1202527806,
0.5227127075,
-0.4395648241,
-0.5963818431,
0.0533608235,
-1.0353729725,
-0.111389786,
-0.3687753081,
-0.2641583979,
0.1501425207,
0.3255066872,
-0.768823266,
0.2661809921,
0.2906880677,
0.0189048797,
0.3968111277,
0.1853922904,
-0.4605396986,
-1.0975574255,
0.0523362197,
0.2341745347,
-0.4513890445,
-0.7894195914,
0.2090563029,
0.0109537737,
-0.196299687,
-0.5396686196,
0.474598825,
-0.6837589741,
-0.1760284305,
-0.3195699751,
0.4785263538,
0.1281938851,
0.4845271409,
0.3226372898,
0.5680752993,
0.3164029717,
-0.5504611135,
0.09551806,
0.2793572843,
-0.0254828762,
0.4118838608,
-0.6198258996,
0.2051640153,
-0.0497803912,
0.1185844392,
-0.7022971511,
-0.1215446442,
0.3828232288,
-0.568967104,
0.6511177421,
-0.524656117,
-0.2849348783,
0.06579227,
-0.2881708741,
0.0533747524,
0.3044861853,
-0.3555220664,
0.5420689583,
0.3357530832,
-0.0172676239,
-0.695622623,
-0.4656626284,
0.255989939,
-0.01641009,
-0.4596281052,
0.2159512043,
0.4481264651,
-0.2802593112,
-0.0076276073,
-0.0164749511,
-0.1288214028,
-0.0284803472,
0.3741225004,
0.3710213602,
-0.2407018542,
0.2142105848,
-0.2271342576,
-0.3158842325,
-0.0805867463,
-0.0782578215,
0.4727373421,
0.1943786889,
0.0477867648,
-0.3497402668,
0.2097393423,
0.5917253494,
-0.0875950232,
0.8094712496,
0.3548415303,
-0.2877466679,
-0.201067239,
-0.3806075454,
-0.2540035546,
-0.3223236203,
0.3370553851,
-0.6258222461,
-0.8422321081,
0.2577671409,
-0.045851253,
0.3791786134,
0.400259614,
0.4253589213,
0.1035671979,
0.4879398346,
0.9053022265,
-0.3109812438,
0.4025363922,
-0.3430824578,
0.2088765949,
-1.039968133,
0.0070742848,
-0.3940272033,
0.0529821627,
-0.5060701966,
-0.272347182,
-0.1379283369,
0.3549287319,
-0.2085205019,
0.8099341989,
-0.3277817965,
0.3271390498,
0.3384157419,
-0.2156880349,
0.3783203363,
0.0953798741,
0.1559171826,
-0.2763196528,
-0.7195963264,
-0.6045653224,
1.16639781,
0.3096673191,
0.6429931521,
-0.0683998466,
0.883456707,
-0.2001437247,
0.5973756909,
-1.1123913527,
0.4113059044,
0.158268109,
-0.6311326027,
-0.288326174,
-0.4987843931,
-1.0293103456,
0.4308631122,
-0.286586374,
-0.6354327202,
0.2068202645,
0.0017199094,
-0.4856677353,
0.1387929022,
-0.5270681977,
0.6633054614,
-0.124929592,
-0.5942084193,
0.1356974244,
-0.699878335,
0.6591938734,
-0.0549751669,
0.0810800716,
-0.2998731136,
0.0091277091,
0.4180298746,
-0.2407060117,
0.8176654577,
-0.0743423849,
-0.0660988092,
0.2962815166,
0.4042290449,
0.3091767728,
0.0259902924,
-0.0663324818,
0.2135550827,
0.1412049383,
-0.1365058422,
-0.6543900371,
0.5919505954,
-0.5899239182,
-0.4563469887,
-0.4802206755,
-0.4219987392,
-0.3366917968,
0.2394090146,
0.0328044668,
0.1480724365,
-0.2402243763,
0.2420962453,
0.3543413877,
-0.2714375257,
0.4646847248,
0.6856838465,
-0.5241798162,
-0.4112437069,
0.70519346,
0.0575818941,
0.3771938682,
0.5031216741,
-0.0765000433,
-0.2075806111,
-0.245097056,
-0.4267147183,
0.5337604284,
-0.3243022263,
-0.5322055221,
-0.6260777116,
-0.3143711984,
-0.4911641777,
0.049332086,
-0.4896188676,
-0.4825184345,
-0.4813356698,
-0.1062723324,
0.3682216406,
0.4814040065,
-0.0139050316,
0.3282409012,
-0.9009336829,
0.406527698,
0.0161642209,
0.0067494232,
-0.0272125546,
-0.7390508056,
-0.0983973965,
-0.0724648312,
-0.2147925645,
-0.9717323184,
0.6340327263,
0.4158288538,
0.2211250514,
0.5359354615,
0.0580007397,
0.73197335,
-0.6593863368,
0.5668406487,
0.2928001285,
-0.5094636679,
0.7007297873,
-0.411201179,
0.1986802816,
0.6231530309,
0.4173664153,
-0.5641289949,
-0.1135896891,
-0.7119525075,
-0.8640452623,
0.8317912221,
0.2877965868,
0.2730532587,
-0.1109858006,
0.7899203897,
-0.1559404582,
0.2895901501,
-0.8959909081,
-0.1970336288,
0.1717289239,
-0.0206313729,
-0.0031554203,
-0.6247564554,
-0.1748948693,
-0.060112346,
0.6867948174,
-0.0269404631,
0.0112685235,
0.0951941684,
-0.2205542922,
-0.2562809587,
0.3146420717,
0.3053664565,
0.7249002457,
-0.4261772633,
0.0263003185,
-0.0304945894,
-0.0470667966,
0.1594016403,
-0.0776867792,
-0.5402431488,
0.2640505731,
0.6185005307,
0.6716517806,
0.5380464792,
-0.473297298,
0.5415589213,
0.1368879229,
-0.1516326666,
-0.4404795468,
-0.0274791103,
0.0861265883,
-0.0037651325,
0.2231424749,
-0.3440259993,
-0.2407324612,
-0.7341217399,
0.52327317,
0.5134176612,
-0.4651836157,
-0.3550075889,
0.3618319035,
0.1335310042,
-0.4560164809,
0.6643486023,
-0.1699789315,
-0.2478431016,
0.2375437766,
0.6251186132,
0.8224161267,
-0.0365052335,
0.2635502219,
0.5760913491,
0.2249486893,
0.1016473621,
-0.3154553175,
-0.1279992908,
-1.0295605659,
-0.8755295277,
-0.8815580606,
-0.3288500309,
0.3718181551,
-0.8387899399,
0.4128152132,
-0.5227452517,
0.0929252282,
0.0807007402,
0.0107389474,
-0.5516334772,
-0.0343203619,
-0.0609627329,
0.7879296541,
-0.7451099157,
1.0494558811,
0.3655115068,
-0.8135823607,
-0.788952589,
-0.2619500756,
-0.0751232058,
-0.8442679644,
0.7827302217,
0.1167221069,
0.0109262951,
-0.0337414928,
-0.5286915898,
-0.7401804924,
0.9795948267,
0.5879839063,
-0.8916906714,
-0.1119648963,
0.0795847774,
0.5684407949,
-0.7414242029,
0.2152585387,
0.7658354044,
0.0317083113,
0.4715015888,
-0.5543168187,
0.0012740033,
0.1085125208,
0.0554603897,
0.2793013155,
-0.326982975,
0.5146955252,
-0.1412428319,
-0.3691883683,
0.0718077049,
0.5958378911,
0.3451717198,
0.165792346,
0.2520718277,
0.6585553885,
0.1087741777,
0.053958416,
1.0554430485,
-0.4240945578,
0.3239565194,
1.7634555101,
-0.4974654317,
1.0812681913,
0.6272652745,
-0.1622860879,
0.3227424622,
0.5712357759,
0.0471717305,
0.3136914074,
0.044384189,
-0.2905580699,
-0.3084662855,
-0.2073744833,
-0.1541318297,
0.5608583093,
0.378157258,
-0.5525889397,
-0.5242557526,
-0.2823514938,
0.1685266197,
0.0393624902,
-0.0580913164,
0.9259536862,
0.4403221905,
-0.4854680896,
0.4148715734,
-0.0935703367,
0.5049902797,
-0.6048755646,
-0.2077815235,
-0.2234989256,
0.0463719144,
-0.1488253325,
-0.524740994,
0.3018753231,
0.1189919114,
-0.2085674256,
-0.0859410986,
0.8194776773,
-0.5643242598,
-0.4942793548,
0.4602478445,
0.6418780088,
0.2138289958,
-0.1745646298,
-0.6162617803,
-0.0496095791,
0.0568050221,
-0.3274603784,
0.3984533846,
0.630852282,
0.236864537,
0.4769340754,
0.7257992625,
0.4080840051,
-0.2147191465,
0.2223698646,
0.781914413,
-0.6838536263,
0.2080637068,
-1.0713477135,
0.2990692258,
-0.2900165021,
-0.084863767,
0.8280989528,
0.4403372407,
0.7175645828,
0.0554470234,
0.6378589272,
-0.0168406814,
0.5495860577,
-0.2542566359,
0.3371913731,
-0.3023958504,
0.2726512849,
-0.2550833225,
-1.1834392548,
-0.5793721676,
0.7777705193,
-0.3562454581,
-0.2422487885,
0.4902626574,
0.6959805489,
0.0522929989,
-0.2905429602,
0.5894931555,
0.1818933785,
0.4764992297,
0.5366872549,
0.6240364909,
-0.5510258675,
0.6693743467,
-0.2281514704,
-0.1175745428,
-0.0029951329,
-0.94373703,
-0.8337760568,
-0.1612147391,
-0.2025346905,
-0.260845989,
-0.0876003802,
0.9709793925,
0.7774894238,
-0.6919307113,
-0.2068330199,
-0.2056315839,
0.0607674159,
0.2253765464,
-0.2658399343,
0.1215541735,
-0.624522388,
-0.6415266991,
0.3703839183,
0.6108260155,
-0.0558085963,
-0.3440862,
0.0137265967,
-0.5640752912,
-0.1649012566,
0.8269660473,
0.6024965644,
-0.6236558557,
-0.3099230826,
-0.1416162848,
0.0662621558,
0.0496252738,
0.8117069006,
-0.73822999,
0.4600165188,
0.1798270047,
0.6653578281,
0.6534717083,
-0.0512658507,
0.9072304368,
-1.0030257702,
0.4149542153,
0.2378633618,
0.3278798163,
0.3724639416,
-0.2916201651,
0.8389060497,
0.1789496392,
-0.3641053438,
-0.8750678301,
0.4448195696,
-0.8310919404,
-0.226842612,
1.4089558125,
-0.257727474,
-0.281421572,
-0.1233184263,
-0.0199265592,
0.3384914994,
-0.2883229554,
0.5444020629,
0.5223887563,
-0.284953177,
-0.4447334707,
-0.5333592296,
0.4146010876,
0.2058861256,
-0.4754472971,
0.252838999,
0.5767463446,
0.3745713234,
0.3060245514,
0.6771655679,
-0.1777159274,
-0.0693095997,
-0.1309462041,
0.2034768909,
-0.1603549719,
-0.3185990155,
-0.3879921138,
0.2751332223,
0.2854368091,
-0.1916622072
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11140v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11140v1
|
Boosting of Thoughts: Trial-and-Error Problem Solving with Large Language Models
| 2024-02-17T00:13:36 | 2024-02-17T00:13:36 |
Sijia Chen, Baochun Li, Di Niu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The reasoning performance of Large Language Models (LLMs) on a wide range of
problems critically relies on chain-of-thought prompting, which involves
providing a few chain of thought demonstrations as exemplars in prompts. Recent
work, e.g., Tree of Thoughts, has pointed out the importance of exploration and
self-evaluation in reasoning step selection for complex problem solving. In
this paper, we present Boosting of Thoughts (BoT), an automated prompting
framework for problem solving with LLMs by iteratively exploring and
self-evaluating many trees of thoughts in order to acquire an ensemble of
trial-and-error reasoning experiences, which will serve as a new form of
prompting to solve the complex problem. Starting from a simple prompt without
requiring examples, BoT iteratively explores and evaluates a large collection
of reasoning steps, and more importantly, uses error analysis obtained from the
LLM on them to explicitly revise prompting, which in turn enhances reasoning
step generation, until a final answer is attained. Our experiments with GPT-4
and Llama2 across extensive complex mathematical problems demonstrate that BoT
consistently achieves higher or comparable problem-solving rates than other
advanced prompting approaches.
|
[
-0.3783637583,
-1.1754268408,
0.830840826,
0.6898781061,
-0.0233535916,
0.3404539227,
-0.1891706884,
-0.0653082728,
0.0168771613,
0.1504488289,
-0.9772971869,
0.0370910689,
-0.4205470085,
0.3481066525,
-0.2155749351,
0.7651406527,
-0.3066756427,
0.2055523098,
-0.0879356787,
0.375030458,
-0.7363664508,
-0.2784656286,
-0.9340077639,
-0.3398851454,
0.4771213531,
0.4882998168,
0.3783248663,
0.0508782156,
0.5259605646,
0.3082152307,
-0.0494903252,
0.3989286125,
-0.5000454187,
0.3958442211,
-0.2999842167,
-0.6258974075,
-0.2792809308,
-0.1453089863,
0.3914632797,
0.4478383064,
-0.0825181752,
0.1086409688,
0.0188534502,
0.7891358137,
-0.3635323048,
0.2785913348,
-0.7570556402,
0.011275637,
0.1478269398,
-0.6072271466,
-0.2892778516,
-0.395008862,
0.1430291682,
-0.56727314,
0.1038248166,
0.1928138435,
0.2287376374,
0.5240314007,
0.1388962269,
-0.5501049757,
-0.5617224574,
0.7611196041,
-0.5505992174,
-0.0842453539,
0.087878257,
0.2725489438,
-0.5687664747,
-0.2408223301,
-0.6954123378,
-0.1194941252,
0.2145762891,
0.1914669275,
-0.2751855254,
-0.0313644558,
0.6052904129,
0.2871235609,
-0.24523893,
-0.3061676025,
-0.1715492159,
0.0009489253,
0.4859074056,
0.1573628336,
0.1492175907,
-0.2092715055,
-0.1795373112,
-0.4630939364,
-0.6565610766,
0.1748606116,
0.1833994091,
0.3110401034,
0.3787216544,
0.4427683949,
-0.3529868424,
0.6289632916,
0.104043901,
0.0205696449,
0.1943078637,
-0.3425162137,
-0.241915822,
-0.0576422587,
0.684674263,
0.3078751564,
0.4115814269,
0.2154797763,
-0.4209915698,
0.0916588232,
0.2323329449,
-0.6571742892,
-0.4509066045,
0.4063598514,
-0.0385945998,
-0.3068148494,
-0.2684963346,
-0.7947890162,
-0.4471462071,
-0.1715019047,
0.7344738245,
-0.3810638785,
-0.2008212805,
0.4547333121,
-0.2028159797,
-0.1548594087,
0.6452715397,
-0.5307247043,
0.1051034406,
0.5740948915,
0.5900417566,
-0.161928013,
-0.2164647877,
-0.6896745563,
-0.286773771,
-0.5446406007,
0.8890408278,
-0.4885378182,
-0.5336920023,
0.0665853694,
-0.2619898021,
0.1026231647,
-0.554751277,
0.6758666635,
-0.3924995959,
0.147479862,
-0.4636973739,
-0.578787148,
-0.1854558587,
0.5244609714,
-0.4787665904,
1.2615174055,
0.0004658015,
-0.6379601359,
0.1671301425,
-1.0835838318,
-0.2911867201,
0.1944555789,
-0.2770950496,
-0.1875526607,
0.2272853106,
0.5723924041,
0.3289858401,
-0.3262985349,
0.1287610829,
0.0089377258,
-0.1577350348,
0.084840551,
-0.3389559984,
0.8171724677,
0.1058934629,
-0.5774989128,
0.3505856991,
-0.5211446881,
0.3177289665,
0.5411230326,
-0.1549463421,
-0.0633600876,
-0.023935236,
-0.4506585598,
0.2199188173,
0.1172051579,
-0.3897981346,
0.6093953252,
-0.3388448954,
0.505461216,
0.7564772964,
0.2525527179,
-0.0853653103,
-0.3145510256,
0.7379327416,
0.1368663758,
0.0139921783,
-0.754183948,
-0.7628855109,
-1.099904418,
0.2082534879,
0.1090736836,
0.5730190873,
-0.9113402367,
0.3592782915,
0.0093854731,
-0.3243553638,
-0.6381347179,
0.1589853466,
0.296759516,
0.495965004,
0.4504232407,
-0.0477998331,
-0.5025821924,
-0.7572879791,
-0.29186064,
-0.1956085712,
0.0270828828,
0.3233876228,
0.6222581267,
-0.1674366742,
1.0169602633,
-0.5376058817,
-0.0410965011,
-0.2190412581,
0.4704543054,
0.2182691693,
0.5305316448,
-0.1048973128,
-0.427538842,
-0.3210919499,
-0.2425376475,
-0.3431479931,
-0.1180602312,
-0.350187093,
-0.2320338786,
-0.1213565022,
0.3183879256,
-0.4534309208,
0.2353546321,
0.2037007809,
-0.0584514216,
0.7346861959,
-0.3683208227,
0.173539266,
-0.7532951236,
-0.0854014903,
-0.0369364694,
-0.3008715212,
-0.2709866464,
-0.0734362155,
0.0050847973,
0.0692428797,
-0.1514100283,
0.3718285859,
-0.4670251012,
0.0766607001,
-0.3664509356,
0.3310839534,
-0.0402941592,
0.5961800218,
-0.0600672364,
0.9560593963,
0.7242782712,
-0.4568428695,
0.5777842402,
0.1035062298,
-0.4594967961,
0.372428745,
-0.5227795839,
0.6904665232,
-0.1969128847,
0.3290501535,
-1.2630102634,
-0.1540674418,
0.1912551969,
-0.282891959,
0.1660109758,
0.1289669275,
-0.751480639,
-0.949881494,
-0.4585263133,
0.4903478324,
0.3618090749,
-0.587718606,
0.3870193064,
0.1366781145,
-0.2932160199,
-0.6332073808,
-0.2778461576,
0.1489231139,
0.0959758759,
-0.399384588,
0.0383842513,
-0.3776089251,
-0.3162379861,
-0.0687927082,
0.0092529403,
0.3385901451,
0.227285549,
0.0378543213,
0.3132562041,
0.1183781102,
0.1754508764,
0.0468431078,
-0.0645155087,
0.333963573,
-0.5048511028,
0.6518638134,
-0.2936969995,
-0.581001699,
-0.3546265066,
0.2633733153,
0.2226262987,
-0.1588829458,
-0.0343163721,
0.0239135418,
-0.3970219195,
-0.5457617044,
-0.6778177023,
-0.3509965241,
-0.484508872,
0.4180188477,
-0.4667787254,
-0.7665647268,
0.1887385398,
-0.3109221458,
0.2290935069,
0.2088829875,
0.7525365949,
-0.3371434808,
1.1665252447,
0.5728282928,
-0.1796627194,
0.3055348992,
-0.2511913478,
0.3285480738,
-0.6961875558,
-0.0265418477,
-0.3344415128,
-0.3082821965,
-0.1253357232,
-0.8103346229,
0.4612308443,
0.2024880499,
0.069698602,
0.0284884777,
-0.7817741036,
0.8728253245,
0.3532225788,
-0.145947367,
0.3541189432,
0.0002338722,
-0.3173478544,
0.1511166245,
-0.8520302773,
-0.3149066269,
0.965010047,
0.1242325082,
0.6669973731,
-0.2986529469,
0.5253890753,
0.1834568083,
0.5046663284,
-1.1093920469,
0.5676093102,
0.4901157022,
-0.7266891599,
-0.3649475873,
-0.4034286141,
-0.8874502182,
0.0510766543,
-0.0416429043,
-0.7080721855,
-0.1248933524,
0.3707484901,
-0.6532709599,
0.2724714875,
-0.377651453,
0.4375944138,
-0.3275774717,
-0.2238969207,
-0.5715703964,
-0.4536112845,
0.3433475494,
-0.0929648802,
0.1441951841,
0.2225212604,
0.1195666492,
0.6922115088,
-0.0432440527,
0.6529944539,
-0.0545185953,
-0.339816004,
0.4939355254,
0.4706791043,
0.9106644988,
-0.2531209588,
0.0565812811,
-0.4602403641,
-0.2603244185,
-0.1634042263,
-0.9364727139,
0.5925598145,
-0.3486806452,
-1.0294835567,
-0.2455375344,
-0.7393679023,
-0.5440395474,
0.1698067486,
0.0353787653,
0.4241908491,
0.0953353494,
-0.13204512,
0.7049912214,
0.0310470071,
0.3812776506,
0.0081819799,
-0.5918537378,
-0.3997246325,
0.776591599,
0.0055545866,
0.2771030366,
0.079080008,
0.3143112063,
-0.4773170948,
-0.5118944645,
-0.6495760083,
0.1949792653,
-0.8603730798,
-0.2183866501,
-0.6177520752,
0.0116413245,
-0.029191453,
0.0446183793,
-0.2451906949,
-0.4596174657,
0.2294402868,
-0.1457450539,
0.3696988821,
0.9054535627,
0.2156473547,
0.0255087167,
-0.6100203395,
-0.0119333481,
0.5188967586,
0.1263765693,
0.4114294052,
-0.1742604375,
-0.104134284,
-0.0825262964,
-0.5408677459,
-0.8717022538,
0.1988240629,
-0.2560890317,
0.3808766305,
0.3296539187,
-0.0531889386,
0.8067387938,
-0.5641001463,
0.7337434292,
0.2478793859,
-0.9726170897,
0.8197933435,
-0.3907294571,
0.255613625,
0.5280504823,
0.2579811215,
-0.5499799848,
-0.4073456824,
-0.7275537252,
-0.5567217469,
0.6082226038,
0.2760338485,
-0.1268758923,
0.0116226282,
0.4470947087,
0.0030057237,
0.306435287,
-0.5407242775,
-0.1752014607,
-0.0480501503,
-0.069942072,
0.1141926125,
-0.144658193,
-0.3859734833,
-0.3278443813,
0.7763383389,
-0.4361072481,
0.2488379925,
0.5596518517,
-0.0328087844,
-0.5654909611,
0.306768775,
0.4975234568,
0.6864247918,
0.1088463515,
0.1881248951,
0.3793267608,
-0.0315215401,
0.1566316485,
-0.2262232155,
-0.120121479,
-0.2197251767,
-0.0171447508,
0.6780688167,
0.0414849818,
-0.8540318608,
0.3252961338,
0.059843123,
-0.2114580125,
0.0202980004,
0.3537813425,
0.2488515377,
0.1619882584,
0.5129432678,
0.1376379132,
0.1848542094,
-0.6176409125,
-0.0429159552,
0.6067461967,
-0.2882674336,
-0.1877185255,
0.3263111115,
0.2499523312,
-0.5888190269,
0.4731497467,
-0.4643810987,
-1.0858901739,
0.5212004781,
0.7064176798,
1.0154101849,
0.0550487638,
0.121804446,
0.536600709,
0.0991979018,
-0.2993354499,
0.4968132675,
-0.3474622071,
-0.6937406659,
-0.8176842928,
-0.2789365053,
-0.5929270387,
0.1986199915,
-0.2253678143,
0.1521159858,
-0.6404832006,
-0.0868309364,
-0.1466860771,
0.116115123,
-0.4833773375,
0.1134404764,
0.2656124234,
1.0512501001,
-0.4868221283,
0.6252144575,
0.6206519008,
-0.0712527782,
-0.9913902283,
0.1638892293,
0.0478674546,
-0.773958087,
0.7620849609,
0.2732051909,
-0.5568603873,
0.2651174068,
-0.7076027989,
-0.6793141961,
0.8066383004,
0.0337443762,
-0.729280591,
0.0328254551,
-0.1047647446,
0.3618479073,
-0.4187592566,
0.3583657444,
0.5622965693,
0.5329456329,
0.1945485622,
-0.8707621694,
0.0826838613,
-0.347605139,
-0.2672415972,
0.1069544926,
-0.6828399897,
0.8481333852,
-0.4742825329,
-0.2658576667,
0.0398493819,
0.4732757807,
0.5283051729,
-0.000123706,
0.8496228456,
0.4477957487,
1.1557267904,
-0.0732543916,
0.9957455397,
-0.3426941633,
0.3341581821,
0.9698082805,
-0.2326986045,
0.7964921594,
0.4812570512,
-0.3943220973,
0.5643230081,
0.5813592672,
0.0126710795,
0.1553445905,
0.5032451153,
-0.1006487161,
-0.5358960032,
0.2118685842,
-0.1783401817,
-0.1126153022,
0.3705696166,
0.0650661662,
-0.2431066632,
-0.1551457494,
-0.1142264605,
-0.1060260832,
-0.4360327423,
0.527398169,
0.0833494663,
-1.1896493435,
0.5361307263,
-0.4559907615,
0.6041181684,
-0.4285135269,
-0.1724426746,
0.0591428764,
0.1969638765,
-0.0494579263,
-0.9800000787,
-0.125750199,
0.1790475845,
-0.0606998391,
-0.3468402326,
0.7104936242,
-0.1240356788,
-0.6636571288,
0.2092736661,
0.8425579667,
0.1599888504,
-0.1667965055,
-0.9543735385,
-0.187160939,
0.1229514331,
-0.3179858029,
-0.0340121724,
0.5546813607,
-0.0514714904,
1.0340105295,
0.7967042923,
0.06138869,
-0.0265471246,
0.1925933361,
0.9733783603,
-0.7390928268,
-0.4411172271,
-1.0040791035,
0.4123674929,
-0.1577537656,
-0.2709728479,
0.8271343708,
0.3939735889,
0.6651677489,
-0.0479171723,
0.849190414,
0.1724683195,
0.4938414693,
-0.4379058778,
0.3327566683,
-0.5087669492,
0.2161511481,
-0.3926343024,
-0.9687542915,
-0.147259146,
0.7088688016,
-0.3381238878,
-0.1423368305,
0.8132294416,
0.8028101325,
0.3795199096,
0.4305581152,
0.0879552811,
0.2958268821,
0.5287432671,
0.6548629999,
1.2747400999,
0.0013066577,
0.3791642189,
-0.0674318597,
-0.4177002907,
-0.2090348154,
-0.9315090775,
-0.839669466,
-0.449231416,
-0.1512471437,
-0.3608635068,
-0.0756049231,
1.4568793774,
0.4504164755,
-0.8555676937,
-0.2034536302,
-0.564271152,
0.1439590901,
-0.2991162539,
-0.1590205729,
0.2267672271,
-0.9846060276,
-0.7874312401,
0.6445305347,
0.3103916645,
-0.0514108762,
-0.6847807765,
0.1534827203,
0.0352326706,
0.2633364499,
0.3675437272,
0.1230065078,
-0.71115762,
-0.1461879164,
0.1545909941,
0.1239507496,
0.3956108391,
1.0832462311,
-1.0444991589,
0.8141848445,
0.5107786059,
0.7305637598,
0.4358876646,
0.0306318663,
0.6799782515,
-0.3034053743,
-0.1662521958,
0.4439352155,
0.4613401294,
0.3183465898,
-0.2502147257,
0.4707795382,
0.2131900638,
-0.5637310743,
-0.8468900919,
0.2073911875,
-0.8264396191,
-0.2792593241,
1.0845211744,
0.0276283324,
-0.4314426482,
-0.0528825372,
-0.75209409,
0.0191984754,
-0.4836914837,
1.0565174818,
1.0257911682,
-0.4562709332,
0.1075742617,
-0.3801722527,
0.8098476529,
0.9744464755,
-0.8400902748,
0.4479128122,
0.3051417172,
-0.0339220241,
0.558788538,
0.5341084003,
0.1146780178,
0.3101291656,
-0.1445035785,
-0.2602365315,
0.0544120483,
-0.460935235,
-0.3742578626,
0.047833886,
0.0285512749,
0.1450554579
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11138v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11138v2
|
Contrastive Instruction Tuning
| 2024-02-17T00:09:32 | 2024-06-06T06:03:34 |
Tianyi Lorena Yan, Fei Wang, James Y. Huang, Wenxuan Zhou, Fan Yin, Aram Galstyan, Wenpeng Yin, Muhao Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Instruction tuning has been used as a promising approach to improve the
performance of large language models (LLMs) on unseen tasks. However, current
LLMs exhibit limited robustness to unseen instructions, generating inconsistent
outputs when the same instruction is phrased with slightly varied forms or
language styles. This behavior indicates LLMs' lack of robustness to textual
variations and generalizability to unseen instructions, potentially leading to
trustworthiness issues. Accordingly, we propose Contrastive Instruction Tuning,
which maximizes the similarity between the hidden representations of
semantically equivalent instruction-instance pairs while minimizing the
similarity between semantically different ones. To facilitate this approach, we
augment the existing FLAN collection by paraphrasing task instructions.
Experiments on the PromptBench benchmark show that CoIN consistently improves
LLMs' robustness to unseen instructions with variations across character, word,
sentence, and semantic levels by an average of +2.5% in accuracy. Code is
available at https://github.com/luka-group/CoIN.
|
[
-0.1799412072,
-0.8259242773,
0.5164106488,
-0.1545286328,
-0.3374387026,
0.1328571886,
-0.6140559912,
-0.3057327569,
0.2426381856,
0.7062114477,
-0.6890351772,
-0.655217886,
-0.6761282682,
-0.0222909432,
-0.2587830722,
1.0968834162,
0.0150082605,
-0.1265345365,
-0.2020847946,
-0.2094239593,
-0.2850034833,
0.0237774719,
-0.5637761354,
-0.4766562581,
0.4756278098,
0.865114212,
0.8238318563,
0.8072863221,
0.4852968454,
0.4404433072,
0.1384956241,
0.4170449972,
-0.5131176114,
0.0890505388,
-0.3089199364,
-0.647826612,
-0.3398993015,
-0.0220752284,
0.3347653747,
0.5135529637,
0.0112801408,
-0.0647846982,
0.2587974668,
0.8020524979,
-0.7887740135,
0.2904720008,
-0.7442926764,
-0.3868259788,
-0.1677716672,
-0.2898788452,
-0.1323758364,
-0.2266339064,
0.0069164899,
-0.9878727198,
0.4257295728,
0.110477075,
0.964370966,
0.0151481014,
0.1667357236,
-0.5671896338,
-0.4520717263,
0.9389941096,
-0.8554342985,
-0.0204346925,
0.5480777621,
0.0873423368,
0.0618677326,
-0.6455304027,
-0.3938609958,
-0.3664510846,
0.021580914,
0.097042948,
0.0490884818,
0.1764915586,
0.3197864592,
0.5770820975,
-0.2882325053,
0.0782704055,
-0.0525575466,
-0.2431205362,
0.2121112198,
0.1631199419,
0.2144869864,
0.1251321882,
-0.3003888428,
-0.5361136198,
-0.5580604076,
-0.0071316888,
0.7298173904,
0.4162327945,
-0.2704433203,
0.4364085495,
-0.3963876665,
0.7013226151,
0.3190311491,
-0.0353884473,
0.3029426634,
-0.1673969328,
-0.0752201378,
0.0816415846,
0.5865373611,
0.5223314762,
0.100512296,
-0.1670577526,
-0.5528715849,
0.1664406508,
0.2542791069,
-0.8061904311,
-0.4124747813,
-0.1348644495,
-0.3490284085,
-0.4344829917,
0.3623084426,
-0.6663568616,
-0.3764265478,
-0.3494669199,
0.6456272602,
-0.6607189178,
-0.1181727052,
0.0372817069,
-0.1725236624,
0.2513892651,
0.1613900959,
-1.1767066717,
0.4608281255,
1.1863481998,
0.8134331107,
-0.0388578027,
-0.1963633895,
-1.05024755,
0.1858941764,
-0.5236875415,
0.5687289834,
-0.9888484478,
-0.4443111718,
0.1687754691,
0.1176007539,
-0.0611903109,
-0.7456802726,
0.4695451856,
-0.5553789139,
0.0276722182,
-0.5460409522,
-0.7974634171,
0.0334637389,
0.1758033931,
-0.7984114289,
0.6849890351,
0.2791740298,
-0.9619950056,
0.1791717261,
-0.5265593529,
-0.5687129498,
-0.0168845002,
-0.202258274,
-0.3594256639,
0.4518657029,
0.3821968734,
0.2033384889,
-0.1100326926,
-0.3357989788,
-0.300632149,
-1.0382391214,
0.2749154866,
-0.356595099,
0.3897570074,
0.2154136896,
-0.5871305466,
0.228116855,
-0.7445610762,
-0.0571571402,
-0.1140691712,
-0.0999177694,
-0.698115468,
-0.1619981974,
-0.119612366,
-0.2521200478,
0.5192633867,
-0.4110536575,
-0.0781691819,
-0.8620755076,
0.498547405,
0.9348778725,
-0.2035013139,
0.5293948054,
-0.6391326189,
0.5038247108,
0.2199902683,
-0.0480817445,
-0.2622761726,
-0.1941163689,
-1.0816229582,
-0.0936646387,
0.2696145475,
0.7076684833,
-0.9643241167,
0.3604596853,
-0.2915211022,
-0.0451749712,
-0.7323687673,
0.5113031268,
0.6194017529,
0.6321533322,
0.3664503396,
-0.1386447996,
-0.2467123568,
-0.9928677678,
-0.4656756818,
0.0907753035,
-0.1091054976,
0.2235074043,
0.3141876757,
-0.015307907,
0.2264502347,
-0.3214172423,
0.0410006754,
0.0633610487,
0.3467651308,
0.2349191457,
0.6148915887,
0.1316702664,
-0.4902198911,
-0.4126450419,
0.2109124959,
-0.3841579556,
0.0183112267,
-0.0753061324,
-0.2522558272,
0.2406067401,
0.8122028112,
-0.3211792707,
0.2329257429,
0.5394256711,
-0.1289051175,
0.3046444654,
-0.5316591263,
0.475330025,
-1.1220709085,
-0.106807068,
-0.314439863,
-0.2757321596,
-0.1453850269,
0.202382341,
0.3041368723,
-0.0735822469,
-0.0671337172,
0.270504266,
-0.6262078285,
0.0650879443,
-0.5932680964,
0.4901561141,
0.1124650314,
0.1656041145,
-0.1111593321,
1.0266120434,
0.7295712829,
-0.5534453988,
0.3103275001,
-0.0682849288,
-0.6687465906,
0.7462648749,
-0.7315117121,
0.2814921737,
0.1622231901,
-0.3177771866,
-0.7544672489,
-0.1334762722,
0.2586874962,
-0.2193045169,
0.7885546684,
0.2816185951,
-0.3229455948,
-0.0244874991,
-0.5573547482,
0.0273314267,
0.5994781852,
-0.5661451817,
0.3312413692,
-0.187081188,
-0.0045684883,
-0.7900252938,
-0.7426872849,
-0.1163879782,
-0.3119447827,
-0.3889020979,
0.5354503989,
-0.2273646742,
-0.3837218881,
0.0675868839,
-0.5100456476,
0.2496726066,
0.0679977834,
0.2532432377,
0.1324122846,
-0.4990636706,
0.1275893748,
0.2021874338,
-0.1986525208,
0.0253628846,
-0.3243899941,
0.2631540895,
-0.2917694449,
-0.2449594736,
-0.4747504592,
0.3847257793,
0.2534134388,
-0.1304762065,
0.8129439354,
0.7654997706,
-0.0596575029,
-0.3604904115,
-0.6012150645,
-0.3544461429,
-0.647701323,
0.3020680547,
-0.5520202518,
-1.027744174,
0.5311831236,
-0.1845056564,
0.1121719927,
0.2521848083,
0.230782792,
-0.1122671738,
0.698752284,
0.7211937904,
-0.1156207174,
0.7252725959,
-0.0569956377,
-0.0431896187,
-0.7586146593,
0.1268762648,
-0.5359629989,
-0.3900722265,
-0.9002352953,
-0.53982687,
0.0733241588,
0.278953284,
-0.2243587971,
0.2838145792,
-0.3745045364,
0.7222187519,
0.8272433877,
0.4945710301,
0.0445272736,
0.1834339201,
-0.1649232209,
-0.0018049901,
-0.4706276357,
-0.5391347408,
1.0361949205,
-0.2597765326,
0.8374524117,
-0.3147630095,
1.1878049374,
0.1758953035,
0.0072736931,
-0.3449706435,
0.4587421417,
-0.5148853064,
-0.1995515227,
-0.1375472993,
-0.547611177,
-0.8948628902,
-0.1159011573,
-0.0953224301,
-0.6164667606,
-0.202153638,
0.1830047816,
-0.2576265931,
0.2927976847,
-0.7203512788,
0.8819376826,
-0.1257096976,
-0.5344845057,
-0.564535141,
-0.5868721604,
0.2782335281,
0.0421771966,
0.2540970147,
0.0003645437,
-0.4439204335,
0.5529999733,
-0.6216059327,
0.8383969069,
0.1302598119,
-0.1872894168,
0.096324645,
0.1866508871,
0.7467178702,
0.1505760849,
-0.2616639733,
0.0001831846,
-0.0653493106,
-0.6579293609,
-0.8413835764,
1.456613183,
-0.8208943009,
-0.9220154881,
-0.1003277227,
-0.8282168508,
-0.2484775633,
0.1693881303,
0.2785458863,
0.4736653566,
-0.1514786184,
0.1536335349,
1.0228716135,
-0.2648590505,
0.5144926906,
0.4112195969,
0.3647986948,
-0.470095098,
1.1701141596,
-0.3453557491,
0.3522478342,
1.0496307611,
0.3782601357,
-0.0833207667,
-0.3332602978,
-0.2487936467,
0.2226584703,
-0.7301716805,
-0.1843889803,
-0.1220301241,
0.1732022166,
-0.3242544234,
-0.3820056915,
-0.338416189,
-0.4055654407,
-0.5850159526,
-0.1203558072,
0.6061715484,
0.5935533643,
-0.0649873838,
0.4071673453,
-0.6894391775,
0.3957907557,
0.4401392639,
0.4646639526,
-0.2577862144,
-0.7093713284,
-0.2687201202,
0.1563460231,
-0.062455561,
-0.6577979326,
-0.0423122011,
0.3297166228,
0.4799524546,
0.7446418405,
0.3088101149,
0.8912200332,
-0.3896432221,
0.5776513815,
0.2214770913,
-1.2236793041,
0.6351084709,
-0.2563147247,
0.4882378578,
0.8028876185,
0.1330925375,
-0.1358377635,
-0.5833359957,
-0.6524928212,
-0.7580789924,
0.8449842334,
0.165253073,
0.4294081628,
-0.1070237756,
0.4856265783,
0.3900585175,
0.2144361436,
-0.3719730079,
-0.3106649816,
-0.2961808443,
-0.4949754775,
-0.328211695,
-0.2391371429,
-0.3399386108,
0.0533064827,
0.6324321628,
-0.0203986242,
0.0229807403,
-0.07710132,
-0.0615872107,
-0.2337095141,
0.3031643033,
0.755186379,
0.7547536492,
-0.0862073973,
0.4188417494,
0.1786513031,
-0.4108751118,
-0.3285325468,
0.0852594748,
-0.289627403,
-0.1331602484,
0.6222307682,
1.0169448853,
0.6727810502,
-0.7039152384,
0.4166794121,
0.0430168919,
-0.2008267939,
-0.0088908877,
0.5230997205,
0.3395298421,
0.3965899646,
-0.2296031415,
0.0129785584,
-0.0574347191,
-0.4723284245,
0.2276175767,
0.4467647076,
-0.5041081309,
-0.200478062,
0.606690526,
0.2070570439,
-0.5123779774,
0.7232608199,
-0.0540420599,
-0.1705182642,
0.4691140056,
0.5636990666,
0.8417203426,
-0.1794663817,
0.2669963837,
0.2106979936,
0.5396985412,
0.0356260352,
0.3376379013,
-0.3376694918,
-0.536506772,
-0.1133626625,
-0.5740264654,
-0.4354696274,
0.2313087732,
-0.9068622589,
0.1203411147,
-0.5995316505,
0.2142649293,
-0.2906507254,
0.2341273129,
-0.6205170751,
0.010479182,
-0.0305124149,
0.6310504079,
-0.6844274402,
0.8874970078,
0.7318468094,
-0.4187381566,
-0.7114145756,
0.1248775795,
-0.3088881075,
-0.9978387952,
0.2089033276,
0.3551151156,
-0.3218807578,
-0.3096269965,
-0.5022623539,
-0.4759645164,
1.0910056829,
0.533637464,
-0.9731457829,
0.1764913797,
0.0894987583,
0.3794512749,
-0.3543065488,
0.2650276124,
0.5315674543,
0.3880985081,
-0.0583468303,
-0.5692088604,
0.2022649944,
-0.1283555031,
0.0774949715,
0.1630901843,
-0.713108778,
0.8756504059,
-0.1596249342,
0.0272918008,
0.2498136312,
0.8033361435,
0.2028031796,
0.298949033,
0.6503156424,
0.5275020599,
0.7950839996,
0.0704851151,
0.9796088338,
-0.6473554373,
-0.0921794996,
1.1895936728,
-0.2060100734,
0.756537497,
0.5232699513,
0.0741195381,
0.8564356565,
0.3248187602,
0.2155805081,
0.5155211687,
0.1800999194,
-0.2474456877,
-0.5955423713,
0.1775660664,
-0.3111752868,
0.2560116947,
0.4659274817,
-0.5002778769,
-0.06159335,
-0.1255967468,
-0.0287094321,
0.5820659399,
-0.466848284,
0.6236737967,
0.2103078067,
-0.5747020841,
0.6216928363,
0.1030137166,
0.832397759,
-0.791308701,
-0.2482094765,
-0.4630012214,
0.3687103093,
-0.0590246096,
-0.2530454099,
0.0122370673,
-0.190597415,
-0.234159261,
-0.174156934,
0.6372597814,
-0.4924705029,
-0.5773976445,
0.1989658326,
0.1665024012,
0.0091891522,
0.038518481,
-0.8463695645,
0.25847736,
-0.0662018955,
-0.1670829654,
0.5241525769,
0.777084887,
0.0458348617,
0.5059975386,
0.342228651,
0.1137324646,
-0.1127169356,
0.2604080439,
0.833904624,
-0.6828796268,
-0.6293560266,
-0.7255403996,
-0.004481602,
-0.258010596,
-0.3246711493,
0.8641603589,
0.5190266967,
1.0824453831,
-0.1834167838,
0.3735303879,
0.2936601341,
0.467997402,
-0.7263673544,
0.5398444533,
-0.6424494386,
0.5049240589,
-0.3923862875,
-0.7687866092,
0.1125223041,
0.771628201,
-0.1174407303,
0.067581296,
0.8916716576,
1.1911643744,
-0.2514549792,
0.0736878514,
0.482485801,
-0.0531041175,
-0.2061249018,
0.6872882247,
0.6594219804,
-0.4589441419,
0.7802824974,
-0.503693521,
-0.2130787373,
-0.0295071695,
-0.8591036201,
-1.0970346928,
-0.3738095462,
-0.5437672734,
-0.2539737225,
0.3683069348,
0.6145008206,
0.5856648088,
-1.1187597513,
-0.3043537736,
-0.3820177019,
0.303691119,
-0.7634554505,
-0.2334685475,
0.522949338,
-0.6623692513,
-0.8166322708,
0.6269460917,
0.1601072848,
-0.2866844237,
0.0361803658,
-0.2046292871,
0.0698954388,
0.2540177107,
0.153170988,
0.0226773154,
-0.8267784119,
-0.51825881,
-0.0235096384,
-0.0903820544,
-0.1008035168,
1.110214591,
-0.4500799179,
0.6632658243,
0.5134804845,
0.5648972988,
0.5166761279,
0.1141357273,
0.4645088017,
-0.7535077929,
0.1686870754,
0.0835258961,
0.1090172827,
0.4586285949,
-0.3059499264,
0.052133292,
0.1344204545,
-0.4818348587,
-0.5161340237,
0.221604839,
-0.8943672776,
-0.4483373761,
0.9710440636,
-0.4602633119,
-0.3422088623,
0.2338902503,
0.0056011239,
0.4767661393,
-0.5006020665,
0.8221162558,
0.7472398877,
0.064239189,
-0.1949071437,
-0.4801277816,
0.5182812214,
0.7060557008,
-0.6013234258,
0.121426791,
0.3717153072,
0.4857981503,
-0.0610442087,
0.2661870122,
-0.036857944,
0.2122725695,
0.3441388905,
-0.2759871483,
-0.3184660077,
-0.0764807612,
-0.3455559015,
0.1398240924,
0.1982768327,
-0.50074476
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14830v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14830v1
|
Orca-Math: Unlocking the potential of SLMs in Grade School Math
| 2024-02-16T23:44:38 | 2024-02-16T23:44:38 |
Arindam Mitra, Hamed Khanpour, Corby Rosset, Ahmed Awadallah
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Mathematical word problem-solving has long been recognized as a complex task
for small language models (SLMs). A recent study hypothesized that the smallest
model size, needed to achieve over 80% accuracy on the GSM8K benchmark, is 34
billion parameters. To reach this level of performance with smaller models,
researcher often train SLMs to generate Python code or use tools to help avoid
calculation errors. Additionally, they employ ensembling, where outputs of up
to 100 model runs are combined to arrive at a more accurate result. Result
selection is done using consensus, majority vote or a separate a verifier model
used in conjunction with the SLM. Ensembling provides a substantial boost in
accuracy but at a significant cost increase with multiple calls to the model
(e.g., Phi-GSM uses top-48 to boost the performance from 68.2 to 81.5).
In this work, we present Orca-Math, a 7-billion-parameter SLM based on the
Mistral-7B, which achieves 86.81% on GSM8k without the need for multiple model
calls or the use of verifiers, code execution or any other external tools. Our
approach has the following key elements: (1) A high quality synthetic dataset
of 200K math problems created using a multi-agent setup where agents
collaborate to create the data, (2) An iterative learning techniques that
enables the SLM to practice solving problems, receive feedback on its solutions
and learn from preference pairs incorporating the SLM solutions and the
feedback. When trained with Supervised Fine-Tuning alone, Orca-Math achieves
81.50% on GSM8k pass@1 metric. With iterative preference learning, Orca-Math
achieves 86.81% pass@1. Orca-Math surpasses the performance of significantly
larger models such as LLAMA-2-70B, WizardMath-70B, Gemini-Pro, ChatGPT-3.5. It
also significantly outperforms other smaller models while using much smaller
data (hundreds of thousands vs. millions of problems).
|
[
-0.3981295228,
-0.7302558422,
0.3467805386,
0.1261837929,
-0.162251994,
0.1893363446,
-0.0839207992,
-0.4956998229,
0.0931684524,
0.4319059849,
-0.4179457724,
-0.4955694675,
-0.5817353725,
-0.203047961,
-0.0706161484,
0.7943506241,
-0.0290052705,
0.4099989533,
-0.160333395,
-0.2192410976,
-0.3331453204,
-0.6220160723,
-1.128780961,
-0.5291912556,
0.4004571736,
0.620975554,
0.7386505604,
0.8274799585,
0.5280800462,
0.2276032865,
-0.2064312398,
0.4933007658,
-0.528437078,
-0.0011047808,
-0.0286194943,
-0.744738102,
-0.7219970822,
0.0701022893,
0.4954796433,
0.832252264,
-0.4493237436,
0.4831589162,
-0.088145718,
0.9174435139,
-0.5493978262,
0.4842711389,
-0.7126322985,
0.0035320413,
-0.4486095905,
-0.0960879177,
-0.3480282128,
-0.5376703739,
-0.0889060125,
-0.705311358,
0.041323632,
0.0167509131,
0.6554563046,
0.241461426,
-0.2184997499,
-0.6739702821,
-0.488013804,
0.9818384051,
-0.608743906,
0.3317994773,
0.5013706684,
0.415920943,
-0.3587157726,
-0.4996151626,
-0.2140728384,
-0.0826961845,
0.4042255878,
0.2599369884,
0.2018654495,
-0.0681034625,
0.5562657118,
0.2019133717,
-0.4807439148,
-0.0295151789,
-0.7188392878,
-0.046921283,
0.6846220493,
0.6004673839,
0.1307076514,
0.0945767313,
-0.0046766181,
-0.1796645224,
-0.9354692101,
0.5027415156,
0.3458515108,
0.3855256438,
0.1669816375,
0.7608568072,
0.1151689515,
0.8811484575,
-0.1039757729,
-0.6454063654,
-0.152026251,
-0.2481655478,
-0.2938832343,
0.1674168706,
0.36059618,
-0.2049778253,
0.059682671,
0.2213531137,
-0.3106496036,
0.5722092986,
0.2048156112,
-0.9337866902,
-0.1548009515,
-0.2107764482,
-0.3523139358,
-0.1319181621,
-0.0623587817,
-0.4892823994,
-0.1918075681,
-0.6395338178,
0.496881336,
-0.4780156612,
0.1362634897,
0.6628785729,
0.200203374,
0.0719850808,
0.6147930622,
-0.8097241521,
0.6276931763,
0.8257947564,
0.8642510772,
0.025642015,
-0.2879516482,
-0.4823245108,
-0.2595919371,
-0.6849708557,
0.6261258721,
-0.6189954877,
-0.4566626251,
-0.36798805,
-0.4818940461,
-0.2930075824,
-0.6755839586,
0.6318089962,
-0.569657743,
0.0348742828,
-0.2422616482,
-0.4298107028,
-0.2379055172,
0.0956825837,
-0.4790697396,
1.2421398163,
0.1191369444,
-0.3083345294,
0.2497082353,
-0.6362318397,
-0.0765502304,
0.0640181825,
-0.0403671563,
-0.5842916965,
0.3411366045,
0.142345041,
-0.0310172997,
-0.4588256478,
0.0147549314,
-0.5130106211,
-0.451628834,
0.1385735273,
-0.2404729575,
0.7364069819,
0.3951772451,
-0.051718615,
-0.2071842849,
-0.7246751785,
0.1828757524,
0.2484941036,
-0.2847045958,
-0.4323154688,
-0.2635808289,
-0.330593735,
0.2803925872,
0.283185482,
-0.5367435217,
0.2032401264,
-0.5562303066,
0.6688230038,
0.567379415,
-0.4066862762,
0.6326891184,
-0.5520119071,
0.6695742011,
-0.2411567122,
0.1507840306,
-0.2215548009,
-0.7432059646,
-0.8076530695,
-0.2271751612,
0.5124551654,
0.0830545276,
-0.6503474116,
0.0080794627,
-0.1327800006,
-0.8207155466,
-0.7511861324,
0.1838321388,
0.2578182518,
0.5391684771,
0.1944851875,
-0.4088953137,
-0.3591105342,
-0.4430721402,
-0.2951364517,
-0.0984394103,
0.1890802383,
0.367883414,
0.4145428836,
0.0757273063,
1.1516985893,
-0.6641783118,
-0.5239498019,
-0.0374294519,
0.0760209709,
0.3525810838,
0.3839900196,
0.4508444071,
-0.7501156926,
-0.5594305992,
-0.1058757231,
-0.6507945061,
-0.1378776133,
0.3229286373,
-0.0726877153,
0.053135518,
0.0915259197,
-0.5611847639,
0.7497162223,
0.3859433234,
-0.2392725348,
0.5338324308,
-0.4191153646,
-0.276096195,
-0.7237902284,
-0.1455296427,
0.1693089008,
-0.2950620353,
-0.5335305929,
0.2264382094,
0.2097920328,
-0.6582963467,
-0.4456682801,
0.3445661664,
-0.4801947474,
-0.2430918962,
-0.2684769034,
0.0563348494,
-0.0987137705,
0.3553445637,
-0.07251928,
0.888669908,
0.5483523607,
-0.5167587996,
0.2454559654,
-0.149163112,
-0.2292461544,
0.3766571283,
-0.702413857,
0.3130936623,
-0.1482384354,
0.2713078856,
-0.7509041429,
-0.0408693291,
0.0423489064,
-0.5904099345,
-0.1368644536,
-0.161414817,
-0.6792436242,
-0.2918280363,
-0.3651042581,
0.5667970777,
0.3649370372,
-0.6805667281,
0.8528211713,
0.6728636622,
-0.1596825272,
-0.3682184517,
-0.3168762922,
0.0438026711,
-0.2763904631,
-0.8035498857,
0.3158428371,
-0.1764935553,
-0.1255605519,
-0.1269774139,
-0.4987986386,
0.0376693308,
0.079807356,
0.4071122408,
0.5347932577,
-0.1198604405,
0.0771081001,
0.1760201752,
-0.403236866,
0.1273229867,
-0.4080862403,
0.8122750521,
-0.4847008586,
-0.4361727238,
0.1628698856,
0.0219511036,
0.6157277226,
-0.2977553606,
0.6354842186,
0.2011187226,
-0.6924670339,
-0.4895172119,
-0.2431854755,
-0.1466522515,
-0.5141967535,
0.0533599518,
-0.6672436595,
-0.8152924776,
0.6312602162,
-0.0486188792,
0.3602705896,
0.135876447,
0.3113855422,
0.1764207631,
1.4294776917,
0.5645435452,
-0.1618130207,
0.3383221924,
-0.2839848995,
0.2402580976,
-0.4888348281,
-0.4074159563,
-0.7456347942,
-0.2373773605,
-0.3765713871,
-0.3720955849,
0.7845234871,
0.244337678,
-0.3130155504,
0.5174849629,
-0.600541532,
0.5397936106,
0.4480826855,
0.1912109405,
0.4320367575,
0.2643303275,
-0.0835368857,
-0.3033426702,
-0.8209875822,
-0.5713533163,
1.2461909056,
0.421551019,
1.1265673637,
0.2447815984,
0.5735071898,
-0.0514664315,
0.4450462759,
-0.986900866,
0.6140642166,
-0.1270310879,
-0.4089440703,
-0.3413720131,
-0.6573079228,
-1.0529989004,
0.5025924444,
0.0757403895,
-0.5916563272,
-0.0558678657,
-0.0379030891,
-0.4688359797,
0.0680789053,
-0.6616161466,
0.4658943117,
0.0176346023,
-0.127182588,
-0.2172186524,
-0.2417091578,
0.2590864003,
-0.2177811712,
0.2939291894,
-0.0315057039,
-0.2592294812,
0.7739006281,
-0.7158041596,
0.6326307058,
0.1461278498,
-0.3967686594,
0.3817022741,
0.2533944845,
0.3383637369,
0.3786756992,
-0.1396009326,
0.1329088509,
-0.0684721544,
-0.4070080221,
-0.6114398241,
0.8925206065,
-0.810880661,
-0.4312504232,
-0.5284520388,
-0.579795599,
-0.083844468,
0.0861237943,
0.1441749185,
0.6968980432,
0.4364984334,
0.0154717248,
0.6975746751,
0.2059740126,
0.5183523297,
0.6849392056,
-0.5321205258,
-0.6098241806,
1.3488023281,
0.6179064512,
0.1179606393,
-0.1191232577,
0.2965268195,
-0.4929501712,
-0.2590484917,
-0.5495200753,
0.4299810529,
-0.61328578,
-0.3609299958,
-0.4638208449,
-0.4553734064,
-0.2822204828,
-0.2098561823,
-0.5739567876,
-0.4176103473,
-0.2962644398,
0.2016180754,
0.0897496864,
0.5817855597,
0.1089286357,
0.2003470361,
-0.5624240637,
0.0000753953,
0.3232667744,
0.1250330508,
0.0555389747,
-0.8082997203,
-0.2373302132,
0.2191296518,
-0.5366730094,
-0.6298505068,
0.6434890032,
0.0708397254,
0.1447402835,
0.3308107257,
-0.098785758,
1.1240948439,
-0.2121092677,
0.5626524091,
0.1449464113,
-1.1701487303,
0.4083579183,
-0.1371410191,
0.1866008788,
0.3052507639,
0.1718049794,
-0.2884637713,
-0.2720467448,
-0.8605132103,
-0.477357626,
0.9692713022,
0.3233391941,
-0.1713371128,
0.5415764451,
0.5051896572,
0.132194832,
0.2954810858,
-0.3816564977,
-0.2744975388,
-0.1528162807,
-0.1884843111,
-0.1973289847,
0.0639431626,
0.0668093339,
-0.3915289044,
0.5744388103,
-0.2005058676,
0.0417544283,
-0.108441487,
-0.1247014031,
-0.1555049121,
-0.0161748417,
0.8217075467,
0.9520405531,
-0.0392665192,
0.3183180094,
0.3605754972,
-0.9448324442,
0.1299601048,
0.1550625414,
-0.2578927577,
0.1172013432,
-0.0649375916,
0.4272896945,
-0.0520368256,
-0.6925946474,
0.1093497351,
-0.0799890161,
-0.2108332664,
-0.4377565682,
0.2317972332,
-0.0356062017,
-0.0634013489,
0.5427702069,
0.296364516,
0.099303402,
-0.4740107954,
-0.2151346356,
0.2885875702,
-0.242453903,
-0.4398970604,
0.5287569165,
-0.252756685,
-0.623046875,
0.1876490265,
-0.1314247549,
-0.6119428277,
1.1158064604,
0.7997157574,
0.2481604964,
-0.2726867199,
0.2369823605,
0.3053151965,
0.3152058125,
-0.4910629988,
0.4648777843,
0.0565282628,
-0.7663466334,
-0.232876569,
-0.3982439041,
-0.64653337,
0.1469870955,
-0.9087597728,
0.3780412078,
-0.6788125038,
-0.3287904561,
0.0893327743,
0.4734214246,
-0.5035027266,
0.2425979227,
-0.0281563904,
0.9777179956,
-0.6014719605,
0.8857650161,
1.1222269535,
-0.0840372145,
-1.1750589609,
-0.5998939872,
0.0800515339,
-0.9158479571,
0.7172661424,
0.1790745258,
-0.2955704629,
0.1732883453,
-0.6265408993,
-0.8615140319,
0.9376631379,
0.5923444629,
-0.4396092892,
0.1337800175,
0.3382600844,
0.5151937604,
-0.5563048124,
0.5327512622,
0.5825954676,
0.1652004272,
0.2346755564,
-0.854531467,
-0.194385007,
-0.2160572559,
0.2214248478,
0.4512800574,
-0.8450509906,
1.1128712893,
-0.1481418312,
-0.1564760208,
-0.0755566731,
0.6692647338,
0.7961274385,
0.6698635221,
0.5279155374,
0.7027463317,
0.7917513847,
-0.1353392899,
0.5095919967,
-0.2227416933,
0.5755265355,
0.8462174535,
-0.2483100146,
0.6514338255,
0.2519322336,
-0.1776517481,
0.0478025824,
0.8145601153,
0.3687472939,
0.3795277178,
0.3640084863,
-0.3892782032,
-0.435313642,
-0.1927866936,
-0.5679742694,
0.4668933153,
0.7516076565,
-0.0026599749,
-0.5197160244,
-0.0481030867,
0.0225026552,
0.1045406759,
-0.7736299634,
0.4067697823,
0.6032532454,
-0.5835465193,
0.5950093865,
0.3247244954,
0.5105589032,
-0.6004478931,
-0.10362003,
-0.3690080941,
0.3161242008,
-0.1286922544,
-0.4816803038,
0.160648331,
-0.0486458428,
-0.0131050954,
-0.2579035461,
0.9756807685,
-0.5728473067,
-0.5076611042,
-0.0488152765,
0.3360573053,
0.0976222456,
0.0319746621,
-0.6799195409,
0.088724263,
-0.3788996637,
0.1782155782,
0.5595143437,
0.47057724,
-0.0808162466,
1.0268796682,
0.8786765337,
0.4257708788,
0.0630559847,
-0.0978802443,
1.160697937,
-0.4725469351,
-0.6379820108,
-0.8703732491,
-0.0256154612,
0.0770893767,
-0.5414495468,
0.9707632065,
0.7758712173,
0.98586303,
0.0814838484,
0.3565438986,
0.3856586814,
0.3179939091,
-0.3976309001,
0.5569365025,
-0.4553694427,
0.4265124798,
-0.0936843455,
-1.0713176727,
-0.0670601726,
0.8290170431,
-0.4010007381,
-0.140198946,
0.5288384557,
0.7251838446,
-0.0279929042,
0.4459571242,
0.4357239306,
-0.4618869126,
0.3814821541,
0.8325933218,
0.9032220244,
-0.569920361,
0.5773820877,
-0.212834537,
-0.3095224202,
-0.0829014331,
-0.5124155879,
-1.1101485491,
-0.113913469,
-0.096228756,
-0.5845681429,
-0.0635592192,
1.0080162287,
0.5881618857,
-0.4612239897,
-0.5343152285,
-0.0348263457,
0.2002547383,
-0.2907829285,
-0.1690689772,
0.304040581,
-0.4019930065,
-0.8148968816,
0.3423799574,
0.3821306229,
0.0285358783,
-0.2516516149,
-0.1144811213,
0.6939336658,
0.3468209207,
0.5607264638,
0.2727100849,
-0.4311720133,
0.088827312,
0.2458219975,
-0.3774416149,
-0.0506925546,
0.9333772659,
-0.6829300523,
0.4542273283,
0.2812574804,
0.7471055388,
0.6762799621,
0.0915034711,
0.2743817866,
-0.195803538,
0.1046872586,
0.2411748022,
0.2999729216,
-0.135993585,
-0.1670442075,
0.5749259591,
0.3452064991,
-0.4188888669,
-0.961819768,
0.0621807873,
-0.801397264,
0.0719151869,
0.8969145417,
-0.1537287384,
-0.3887115717,
-0.142489478,
-0.3429481685,
-0.193872422,
-0.787250936,
0.9833597541,
0.6425309181,
0.1600302905,
-0.0121922353,
-0.4501417279,
0.4145842493,
0.7205410004,
-0.8108052015,
-0.4645033479,
0.0642440692,
0.07329119,
0.2521615326,
0.5220198035,
-0.255212456,
0.2769452035,
0.0208418723,
-0.2275186181,
-0.4644999504,
-0.4788760841,
-0.2756271064,
0.4394879043,
-0.121045351,
-0.1870660931
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11131v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11131v1
|
Speculative Streaming: Fast LLM Inference without Auxiliary Models
| 2024-02-16T23:36:43 | 2024-02-16T23:36:43 |
Nikhil Bhendawade, Irina Belousova, Qichen Fu, Henry Mason, Mohammad Rastegari, Mahyar Najibi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Speculative decoding is a prominent technique to speed up the inference of a
large target language model based on predictions of an auxiliary draft model.
While effective, in application-specific settings, it often involves
fine-tuning both draft and target models to achieve high acceptance rates. As
the number of downstream tasks grows, these draft models add significant
complexity to inference systems. We propose Speculative Streaming, a
single-model speculative decoding method that fuses drafting into the target
model by changing the fine-tuning objective from next token prediction to
future n-gram prediction. Speculative Streaming speeds up decoding by 1.8 -
3.1X in a diverse set of tasks, such as Summarization, Structured Queries, and
Meaning Representation, without sacrificing generation quality. Additionally,
Speculative Streaming is parameter-efficient. It achieves on-par/higher
speed-ups than Medusa-style architectures while using ~10000X fewer extra
parameters, making it well-suited for resource-constrained devices.
|
[
-0.3241841793,
-0.6710733175,
0.5791347623,
0.2570915818,
-0.6184142232,
0.3713629544,
0.0034786335,
-0.5206282735,
0.6975610852,
0.8490824699,
-0.8968837857,
-0.1981128454,
-0.6140452027,
-0.0857815072,
-0.7605400681,
0.420583576,
0.0589988455,
-0.2091665268,
0.0533765219,
0.4009879827,
0.1160748526,
-0.4017089009,
-0.9333924055,
0.1315501928,
0.6786576509,
0.4079049826,
0.4910309315,
1.0065615177,
0.343264699,
0.2628426552,
0.0591103807,
0.4480399191,
-0.895639956,
0.2901883721,
0.1999384612,
-0.6873562336,
-0.5639134049,
-0.0485631973,
0.7759518027,
0.5107443929,
0.0808784664,
0.2617248595,
-0.2322348505,
0.754619658,
-1.0515530109,
-0.0597929358,
-0.8573507667,
-0.0846976489,
-0.6180215478,
-0.7688933611,
-0.7606205344,
-0.1699136496,
-0.211665988,
-0.6892074347,
0.5705598593,
0.4479392767,
0.5741018653,
0.5206974745,
-0.4071069062,
0.2638067305,
-0.8764734864,
0.5801283121,
-0.8429775238,
0.4873185754,
0.5459029675,
0.2727941573,
-0.0739393309,
-0.9313154817,
-0.5338016748,
0.0060346844,
0.2228695899,
0.2909552157,
0.0804404095,
0.242299512,
0.2892706096,
0.2474706769,
-0.3790733814,
0.1969353855,
-0.4191249013,
-0.2578098774,
0.8523266912,
0.4510620832,
-0.2736983895,
0.1500312686,
-0.2338180542,
0.2942376137,
-0.6427899599,
-0.1444140077,
0.7226900458,
0.2878116071,
-0.278487891,
0.4107967913,
-0.5766080022,
0.6268846393,
0.2056399882,
-0.038967967,
-0.077829048,
-0.1752226055,
-0.1589816958,
0.0843218639,
0.4765978456,
0.2363853306,
-0.2540110052,
-0.1896094382,
-0.0628286228,
0.3745820224,
0.209027946,
-0.7743856907,
-0.15398027,
0.4761294425,
-0.6125840545,
-0.3187831938,
-0.2918868363,
-0.706002295,
-0.2905563712,
-0.1277472228,
-0.1745911688,
-0.5222833157,
-0.3137899339,
0.3440804183,
-0.3919574916,
0.167255789,
0.3337290883,
-1.2112401724,
0.2901324034,
0.7125709057,
0.8087781072,
-0.3573113084,
-0.2815787494,
-0.848601222,
0.3059107661,
-0.4567063451,
1.3418527842,
-0.5280831456,
-0.4136251807,
-0.1318123639,
-0.3494609892,
-0.0506973192,
0.0031332735,
1.063706398,
-0.8966040611,
-0.4622329473,
-0.2116276622,
-1.0871133804,
-0.1622302383,
-0.0475838296,
-0.6851140857,
0.6787749529,
-0.1305577904,
-0.7968559861,
0.5786081553,
-0.200287804,
-0.2700485885,
0.2818003595,
0.1710847616,
0.3411164284,
0.312887013,
0.1716784835,
0.5399185419,
-0.2918297052,
0.0424742065,
-0.7819183469,
-0.7942613959,
0.0227973871,
-0.9985954165,
0.1834246665,
0.584389329,
0.2998722494,
0.0621888302,
-0.6188865304,
0.1422393769,
-0.129580602,
-0.3971550465,
-0.1109379157,
0.4702050388,
0.2069392055,
-0.0327078179,
-0.0985114947,
-0.5111441016,
0.3638269901,
-0.4464665949,
0.3387711048,
0.6927149296,
-0.0520649664,
0.4258650541,
-0.2473302782,
0.5918545127,
-0.2757260799,
0.0461469106,
-0.3875062764,
-0.3962413967,
-0.7079898119,
-0.5428623557,
0.3704891205,
0.3105072081,
-1.0354815722,
0.0043239058,
-0.2633799016,
-0.5373678803,
-0.6260146499,
0.0443358757,
0.0929955766,
0.3662250042,
0.2293704897,
0.3370242417,
-0.7019231319,
-0.7373374701,
-0.4374761581,
-0.1281502992,
0.1768417358,
-0.0357767716,
-0.2033285797,
-0.1604599953,
0.3925612569,
-0.5072256923,
0.3337024748,
-0.4348401129,
0.2240588665,
0.3121025562,
0.3801337779,
0.5068474412,
-0.595610559,
-0.3844958544,
-0.2283109725,
-0.5774466395,
-0.0100102788,
-0.2405185848,
-0.2661134303,
0.1992975473,
0.7819661498,
-0.6789460182,
0.2579656243,
0.7693001628,
-0.5077953339,
0.6787999272,
-0.218970865,
0.1647858769,
-0.890845716,
-0.3311974108,
-0.1259185672,
-0.0949394405,
-0.6786447763,
0.3447150588,
0.1736080796,
0.0576137714,
-0.5942006111,
0.7228562236,
-0.3713542223,
0.3390958607,
-0.6214053035,
-0.2727692723,
-0.1305891871,
0.1276816577,
0.2653004527,
0.6599664092,
0.7642728686,
-0.6302966475,
0.0884315521,
-0.2928496301,
-0.0796674937,
-0.2680146694,
-0.3467538059,
0.1768205464,
-0.0813109279,
0.3927435875,
-0.8694176674,
-0.3427179456,
0.0849692374,
-0.2077672184,
0.3093405068,
-0.258225739,
-0.407851249,
-0.5210698843,
-0.2133452296,
0.5177262425,
0.3922044933,
-0.4066290855,
0.8231554031,
0.1491942257,
0.0440886505,
-0.6625861526,
-0.6605972648,
-0.0227286946,
-0.0766405836,
-0.7339997888,
0.5062413216,
0.0521268435,
-0.0141860675,
0.0402226374,
-0.2965649664,
-0.133097738,
-0.0392540209,
0.0959044546,
0.4538531601,
-0.3902771473,
-0.267760098,
0.5218411088,
-0.4659141004,
-0.0541202761,
-0.5385630727,
0.4027050138,
0.2147655338,
-0.3490302563,
-0.4497833252,
0.7289227247,
0.5404382944,
0.1659086496,
0.4546796978,
0.6874974966,
-0.2226011753,
-0.4302146733,
-0.8781390786,
-0.2612008452,
-0.5429356694,
0.0445363596,
-0.623246491,
-0.979922533,
0.5955346227,
-0.0314450748,
0.1128898114,
0.3595847785,
0.3411175013,
-0.1899688691,
0.8845524192,
0.6357920766,
0.0002840508,
0.3139959276,
-0.3044231236,
0.1010372713,
-0.4555598199,
0.0663681179,
-0.2976499498,
-0.4007757604,
-0.3662744462,
-0.7458481789,
-0.0831868425,
0.1217275411,
0.3346087039,
0.0599377938,
0.0425855108,
0.5483192801,
0.6200914979,
0.1661971509,
0.4338117838,
-0.043684423,
-0.13666448,
0.0510806069,
-0.8497276306,
-0.3464083076,
1.3068217039,
0.1564002335,
0.9241833091,
-0.0968422368,
0.6707596183,
0.5168830752,
0.2903724611,
-0.7939913869,
0.600096643,
-0.3860188425,
-0.5954529047,
-0.0723665133,
-0.2831659019,
-0.5169090033,
0.3843573332,
-0.514297545,
-0.7195269465,
0.2129224092,
0.5472658873,
-0.5952394605,
0.6461488008,
-0.9721227884,
0.3732502759,
0.1620992571,
-0.6098198295,
-0.6138135195,
-0.1420108527,
0.9658026695,
-0.0985521078,
-0.1115162224,
-0.3781008124,
-0.2481595725,
0.4851833284,
-0.4870248437,
0.5983346701,
-0.1024669409,
0.1252062619,
0.4199828804,
0.3186280131,
0.7026828527,
0.2611469924,
-0.3999436498,
0.1628799587,
0.2677292228,
-0.6663796902,
-0.695951283,
0.5749332905,
-0.4957274199,
-0.7612251043,
-0.333009243,
-0.6573525071,
-0.4290624261,
0.0530036427,
0.5523189902,
0.3886196017,
-0.0361085571,
-0.2313209325,
0.5466395617,
0.3103085458,
0.6179395318,
0.4693800211,
-0.1464344859,
0.1181716174,
0.8851596713,
-0.163432315,
0.3283696473,
0.5389869213,
-0.1274172217,
-0.4751426578,
-1.2483999729,
-0.330337882,
0.1510265321,
-0.4699992239,
-0.0729878694,
-0.8933266997,
-0.1912574172,
-0.3462058902,
-0.3460291922,
-0.5181642175,
-0.4301681221,
-0.2850436866,
-0.2434474975,
0.4443618357,
0.2811511159,
-0.0832632259,
0.4454689324,
-1.0543520451,
0.5205106139,
-0.0687367171,
0.3238866031,
0.0452686623,
-0.7641167045,
-0.1974214464,
-0.1675855666,
0.0460343882,
-0.6989910603,
0.6000313163,
-0.0041007129,
0.5563294291,
0.991401732,
0.1356688589,
0.914521277,
-0.566415906,
0.4965553582,
-0.048768945,
-0.7933003902,
0.2288391441,
-0.544475615,
0.2986875176,
0.5378275514,
0.3957991004,
-0.3986870944,
-0.4238623977,
-0.3998973668,
-0.8404800892,
0.7724768519,
-0.1042847037,
0.1911989152,
-0.0564586222,
0.4250839353,
0.4030093253,
-0.1409984976,
0.0371384323,
-0.2900336683,
0.0255644992,
0.2574895918,
-0.3304566145,
-0.657294333,
0.3673939407,
-0.3936144114,
0.6744201779,
-0.345864296,
0.4258458912,
-0.095100902,
0.2443483174,
-0.1349844784,
0.03338027,
0.470369488,
0.311306417,
-0.5952054858,
0.1620774418,
0.0707121789,
-0.6060177684,
0.1035439596,
0.1604392529,
-0.2998417616,
0.0470825471,
0.492249161,
0.9248723388,
0.3181757033,
-0.6879725456,
-0.0975965783,
-0.3142337501,
-0.4759062529,
-0.0645810738,
0.2941512764,
0.259650588,
0.215665102,
0.5722655058,
0.6622335911,
0.4262429774,
-0.2956951857,
0.1784290224,
0.2617172301,
-0.0077967737,
-0.2745067775,
0.7944684625,
0.2749934494,
0.0366519317,
0.5014663339,
-0.4667929411,
0.1285449266,
0.3951203227,
0.6442404389,
1.0573318005,
0.1083649024,
0.0699760467,
0.2891346514,
0.1312838644,
-0.1279708445,
0.5542018414,
-0.0732543841,
-0.8456264138,
-0.9681348205,
-0.8003575802,
-0.3340392709,
-0.1200963184,
-0.5725262761,
0.1215373203,
-0.4529758096,
-0.2102503628,
0.1073415726,
-0.2260930091,
-0.5682365298,
-0.1460294276,
0.4716670513,
1.5532854795,
-0.5805535316,
1.256511569,
0.2597887218,
0.1364938468,
-0.9385173917,
0.1827945262,
0.2787612975,
-0.6111375093,
0.5485633612,
-0.0724020153,
-0.31734851,
0.2238427401,
-0.2432249933,
-1.289862752,
0.9078885913,
0.6167464852,
-0.6733878851,
-0.3263536394,
-0.3025064468,
0.249405399,
-0.4136696756,
0.4997798204,
0.5283849835,
0.3253652751,
0.5469585061,
-0.3086425662,
0.1248965561,
-0.2836870849,
0.0414162613,
0.1381151974,
-0.6309010983,
0.7848428488,
-0.3757174611,
-0.3718027472,
0.1910069436,
1.007871747,
0.2000836283,
0.244199276,
0.2828648388,
0.3555524945,
0.9226044416,
-0.0571133718,
1.3790817261,
-0.4148808718,
-0.0572582595,
1.0996857882,
-0.3797724843,
1.1633293629,
0.6496347785,
-0.0582349375,
0.2588196099,
0.8714522123,
0.4067542553,
0.6435514688,
-0.130083099,
-0.5600987077,
-0.672545135,
0.0143671753,
-0.3213225603,
0.4681281745,
0.6941008568,
-0.0754864067,
-0.2412811965,
-0.2831661105,
-0.4308805168,
-0.0877802595,
-0.6308092475,
0.3186635077,
0.1223784834,
-0.6554597616,
0.7362737656,
0.1627005637,
0.9469757676,
-0.8140823841,
0.2383109033,
-0.2338821739,
0.134529084,
-0.1328907609,
-0.4167573452,
0.5123539567,
-0.1262591183,
-0.3056259453,
-0.173795566,
0.8124604821,
-0.0460637994,
-0.7525303364,
0.3898869753,
0.6266943216,
0.1043110043,
-0.2152195126,
-0.470505327,
0.3557866216,
-0.1753941029,
-0.2716250122,
0.1399928182,
0.3323956132,
0.1472206563,
0.9211024046,
1.1000034809,
0.3319989443,
0.3563106656,
0.1139239818,
0.9110727906,
-0.7788782716,
-0.7470055819,
-0.8881987333,
0.3499223888,
0.1448973715,
-0.2558027804,
0.7584379911,
0.4136300087,
0.5231310725,
-0.2833372355,
0.7318930626,
0.1602656841,
0.2762586176,
-0.9490739703,
0.4894244671,
-0.324995786,
0.2458262593,
0.0214701835,
-0.5745049715,
-0.0517233163,
-0.1701254696,
-0.2765100598,
-0.3521775305,
0.8313068748,
0.7422668934,
-0.2209781706,
0.5442954898,
0.501680851,
0.1003659964,
-0.1426597983,
0.5097151399,
0.9426019788,
-0.2227541059,
0.3147714734,
-0.2820213437,
-0.1005388647,
-0.3195307553,
-0.9604331851,
-0.8372385502,
-0.2851344347,
-0.1658849865,
-0.220481813,
0.144255355,
0.7952445149,
1.0252453089,
-0.6792367101,
-0.2530011237,
-0.1347584873,
0.0106040044,
-0.5902072787,
-0.224028334,
0.1007743031,
-0.4562173486,
-0.6702672243,
0.8210456371,
0.4109829962,
-0.178314209,
-0.1282413602,
-0.0732087791,
-0.241187498,
0.3854833543,
0.6302145123,
0.3837530911,
-0.8702593446,
0.1368786693,
-0.0147312442,
0.2235760391,
-0.3271819055,
1.1574858427,
-0.8233446479,
0.2223297358,
0.5794661641,
0.7978322506,
1.1323740482,
-0.007839663,
0.6250254512,
-0.3334470391,
0.6225676537,
0.3130711615,
0.4896625578,
-0.2827454209,
-0.6914556623,
0.1426437646,
0.4141628444,
-0.1093049496,
-0.6501977444,
0.1800887287,
-1.1769038439,
-0.3476409614,
0.9219223857,
-0.0057753241,
-0.284886539,
-0.1612451375,
-0.0143314842,
0.0388228446,
-0.7213854194,
0.5485571027,
0.4085338414,
-0.2232093662,
-0.2831756771,
-0.6784980297,
0.4782167673,
0.2817956507,
-0.5568497777,
0.216396451,
0.4606093764,
-0.033039216,
-0.1909111589,
0.9479946494,
0.2883455455,
0.299343884,
0.6522086263,
-0.4141170084,
-0.1793242395,
-0.2817041874,
0.0274626706,
0.3435453475,
0.0065141362,
0.1209281385
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11129v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11129v1
|
BlendFilter: Advancing Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models via Query Generation Blending and Knowledge Filtering
| 2024-02-16T23:28:02 | 2024-02-16T23:28:02 |
Haoyu Wang, Tuo Zhao, Jing Gao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Retrieval-augmented Large Language Models (LLMs) offer substantial benefits
in enhancing performance across knowledge-intensive scenarios. However, these
methods often face challenges with complex inputs and encounter difficulties
due to noisy knowledge retrieval, notably hindering model effectiveness. To
address this issue, we introduce BlendFilter, a novel approach that elevates
retrieval-augmented LLMs by integrating query generation blending with
knowledge filtering. BlendFilter proposes the blending process through its
query generation method, which integrates both external and internal knowledge
augmentation with the original query, ensuring comprehensive information
gathering. Additionally, our distinctive knowledge filtering module capitalizes
on the intrinsic capabilities of the LLM, effectively eliminating extraneous
data. We conduct extensive experiments on three open-domain question answering
benchmarks, and the findings clearly indicate that our innovative BlendFilter
surpasses state-of-the-art baselines significantly.
|
[
-0.6541908383,
-0.9535315037,
0.6779717207,
-0.0411578566,
-0.2495079786,
0.5429509878,
-0.1646963805,
-0.5395957232,
0.1950506568,
0.9615159631,
-0.6391217113,
-0.3101079166,
-0.4814752638,
-0.2733340859,
-0.6178658009,
0.558596611,
0.0613318011,
0.0947315916,
-0.5835761428,
-0.1258593798,
-0.4748529494,
-0.4217039645,
-0.7258909345,
-0.7062774897,
0.30379197,
0.0430643372,
0.6589141488,
-0.0719546676,
0.149716258,
0.2945543528,
-0.2979259193,
0.7220736146,
-0.7696487904,
0.6446985006,
-0.2412149906,
-0.6282757521,
-0.1329833865,
-0.3086345494,
0.6492624283,
0.8243812919,
-0.3604251444,
-0.170590058,
0.0805468187,
0.6051622629,
-0.9427480102,
-0.1518241912,
-1.0583610535,
-0.0178516414,
-0.0877299458,
-0.2856393158,
-0.2386492342,
-0.3163424432,
-0.0765388459,
-0.5297017097,
0.1442002952,
0.4947357178,
0.5080667734,
0.1324426681,
-0.376255393,
0.1283376962,
-0.7014017701,
0.7137762308,
-0.641366601,
0.553720355,
0.5111088753,
0.6376430988,
-0.5366225839,
-0.9298342466,
-0.7748479843,
0.1255249977,
-0.0340424366,
0.1858205646,
-0.1051512435,
0.0587665737,
0.0209659431,
0.5688199401,
-0.4693187475,
-0.1505016536,
-0.2072289139,
-0.225559026,
0.4900220335,
0.0808516219,
0.1594559252,
0.2119582146,
-0.1544167846,
0.1661265194,
-0.7605490685,
-0.2212146074,
0.1771698743,
0.2567549944,
0.5403605103,
0.5946696997,
-0.6220572591,
0.9789025187,
0.0145259751,
-0.0764521062,
-0.2319935858,
-0.4389641881,
-0.3342253864,
-0.2458156943,
0.5108440518,
0.1393696815,
0.0066631217,
-0.2255790085,
-0.4356744885,
-0.6387282014,
0.1120027229,
-0.9806175828,
-0.261751622,
0.0233479217,
-0.1332326978,
-0.1719577909,
0.1039234623,
-0.8545413613,
-0.6825043559,
-0.196040377,
0.6214668155,
-0.0924786106,
-0.3840537071,
0.3031026721,
-0.1889611632,
0.3106765747,
0.3925025761,
-0.4412757158,
0.4212449193,
0.7838990092,
0.5695183873,
-0.3511011004,
0.2627545893,
-0.8228651881,
0.2340312898,
-0.183259055,
0.914539814,
-0.8351128101,
-0.5715442896,
0.1726337075,
-0.3873617053,
-0.0325638503,
-1.0401992798,
0.3567809165,
-1.4168275595,
0.3447900712,
-0.0464871116,
-0.7501391768,
-0.2584298253,
0.3603196442,
-0.586951375,
1.4319368601,
0.1678185165,
-0.4298059344,
0.1912920028,
-0.2704637349,
-0.5541526675,
0.5136501193,
-0.1318870187,
0.1384100318,
-0.0447785556,
0.3669019341,
0.048309125,
-0.830008924,
0.3592650294,
-0.4014001787,
-0.2362430245,
0.228752315,
-0.2810859382,
0.5830724835,
0.2609596848,
0.1921864897,
0.022097202,
-0.5312027335,
0.3365134895,
0.073877126,
-0.3409125507,
-0.4314943254,
-0.0135998959,
-0.0043156729,
0.088014178,
0.2675464451,
-0.6146994829,
-0.1090785936,
-0.3620594442,
0.3477587402,
0.4768898785,
0.4219494462,
0.3372488022,
-0.4543163776,
0.7199412584,
0.0542786531,
0.0362631865,
-0.1556749046,
-0.6926175356,
-0.7531187534,
-0.2798027098,
0.1606013179,
0.3562161922,
-1.1397558451,
0.3365327418,
-0.1088056639,
-0.3763474822,
-0.6109691858,
0.4820631444,
0.033771731,
0.6966169477,
0.4915076792,
-0.2480760813,
-0.392644912,
-0.609105587,
-0.5912528634,
-0.0523424447,
-0.1351570785,
0.5141605139,
0.1919322908,
-0.0838656276,
1.0820784569,
-0.9741897583,
-0.066209197,
-0.2390257269,
-0.2209437937,
0.3503806889,
0.2092197239,
0.2894183695,
-1.1222759485,
-0.4366300106,
0.1512296796,
-0.3374930918,
-0.2086676955,
0.4416176379,
-0.5773760676,
-0.1616814882,
0.6907240748,
-0.5648142695,
0.1203731298,
0.293738693,
-0.3037861288,
0.3807812035,
-0.1189968437,
0.3642554879,
-0.89831388,
0.1012461856,
-0.2459657192,
-0.5817067027,
-0.4643302262,
0.2988624573,
-0.0415894575,
-0.1246753335,
-0.297948271,
0.8963646293,
-0.2189930975,
0.1964760423,
-0.3503578305,
0.2923164666,
0.5977468491,
0.1669725627,
-0.2755162418,
0.7728143334,
0.2416442782,
-0.5787376761,
0.4563135505,
0.0983487144,
-0.5075411201,
0.7079871297,
-0.4786633551,
0.0675107837,
-0.1938377172,
0.296479851,
-1.2264285088,
-0.2481223196,
-0.0714385808,
-0.212502107,
0.2981135249,
-0.3192327619,
-0.6496093273,
-0.3832770586,
-0.2199681997,
0.492045939,
0.659444809,
-0.7136951089,
0.976290822,
0.4247902632,
-0.1682661027,
-0.3501186669,
-0.5199761391,
-0.0258999094,
-0.1111010909,
-0.8020603061,
0.3835154772,
-0.3822657764,
-0.0522185899,
-0.0592526123,
-0.3044595718,
-0.5244131088,
0.0409201235,
-0.2060985416,
0.2386567593,
-0.3205805719,
0.0324111916,
0.2410863191,
0.5437297821,
0.0253255777,
-0.427372396,
0.710411787,
0.4957386255,
-0.4687600136,
0.1094249934,
0.4412032664,
0.6121755242,
-0.4913694561,
0.8598595858,
0.507288754,
-0.4239572585,
-0.5455543995,
-0.9471898079,
-0.3197930157,
-0.5374705791,
0.3516016006,
-0.4650629163,
-1.3226560354,
0.3977919221,
-0.060079854,
-0.0560771637,
0.2744071782,
0.3490732312,
-0.1262869686,
0.9942506552,
0.2522318959,
0.0807797387,
0.5838755369,
0.1138635799,
0.327580601,
-0.9009081721,
-0.4315252602,
-0.5426003933,
-0.1557760984,
-0.2487293631,
-0.7236586809,
0.5344842672,
0.2001640648,
-0.1394127905,
-0.2442300171,
-0.160137251,
0.7414781451,
0.5706187487,
0.4059678614,
0.6640788317,
0.1506709158,
-0.2718651891,
0.1261942834,
-0.7693647742,
0.1526962072,
1.0811715126,
-0.1524982303,
0.8642299175,
0.0139819514,
0.4899574816,
0.1871396899,
0.0576426946,
-0.6278041005,
0.6295153499,
-0.1546253264,
-0.6822927594,
0.0071954015,
-0.5742155313,
-0.7143260241,
0.7692527175,
-0.4001333714,
-0.3867141008,
-0.0412734635,
0.1030387133,
-0.1934066117,
0.4360914826,
-0.6102363467,
0.504308939,
-0.2024883628,
-0.4096117914,
-0.3431376517,
-0.2283233106,
0.5839462876,
-0.2815822661,
0.1994360387,
-0.115145117,
0.0017933918,
0.4692116082,
-0.2752795219,
0.5805540085,
-0.1549603194,
-0.0225041602,
0.4511803389,
0.2142916918,
0.395696342,
-0.048820857,
-0.3047707677,
-0.2046085,
-0.0803941116,
-0.2884340286,
-0.7817461491,
0.8078125715,
-0.2490738928,
-0.8617001772,
-0.0871766135,
-0.7019667029,
-0.531306088,
0.4577281177,
-0.075906761,
0.261372447,
-0.1810777485,
0.2905202806,
0.9249645472,
-0.2291205078,
0.0336364545,
0.6836808324,
-0.6224976182,
-0.5164624453,
0.8618484735,
0.0426472835,
0.4789198935,
0.4544922709,
0.1272835732,
-0.4095264673,
-0.6599673629,
-0.1650357842,
0.3267068565,
-0.599689126,
-0.3286587,
-0.6551724672,
-0.4007091224,
-0.4947709441,
0.2290308923,
-0.0965203941,
-0.4045461714,
-0.0139802368,
0.2680861652,
0.3641524613,
0.497607559,
0.4310703576,
0.2371401489,
-0.7491713762,
0.5950180888,
0.4580812156,
0.5207921267,
-0.0349796563,
-0.6861653924,
-0.1405722499,
0.0156920459,
-0.3574716449,
-0.5031384826,
0.2282784134,
0.5310106277,
0.7010719776,
0.131744206,
0.3077529073,
0.8464946747,
-0.4131889045,
0.7684734464,
-0.0030226707,
-0.5024235249,
0.5261064172,
-0.1015337333,
0.59950459,
0.690549314,
0.2365470976,
-0.3340262175,
-0.4715960026,
-0.2743968368,
-1.0339021683,
0.5398737788,
0.0659639686,
0.0448893458,
0.1590576917,
0.454903692,
0.0094369799,
0.5197692513,
-0.2345430851,
-0.2167282254,
0.1434497386,
-0.2307640612,
0.2449708432,
-0.1958456188,
-0.3193255961,
-0.3354701698,
0.8682428002,
-0.0712623522,
-0.0257427227,
-0.0391306095,
-0.3080575466,
-0.269180119,
0.0648543313,
0.1468709707,
0.4379647076,
-0.0477910973,
-0.0228044912,
0.039039772,
-0.3955054283,
-0.2484098822,
0.315230757,
-0.4416716695,
-0.2011796981,
0.0566645637,
0.6555657983,
0.190787673,
-0.9355450869,
0.2968539,
-0.0674825162,
0.0107321087,
0.0166071393,
0.5486041903,
0.1836192608,
0.2405064851,
0.555801034,
-0.1295346171,
0.4931262136,
-0.4573722482,
0.1669103801,
0.7557675242,
-0.11991027,
-0.0057613989,
0.7955085039,
0.1629597247,
0.0674634203,
0.5134081841,
0.1483210325,
-0.6201726794,
0.243234694,
0.5596877337,
0.6973001361,
-0.2181991935,
0.0540068224,
0.2759582698,
0.155164659,
-0.0834961981,
0.4032834768,
-0.4372337162,
-0.7788243294,
-0.5407747626,
-1.0581247807,
-0.5665823221,
0.0323685631,
-0.5859539509,
0.1219116151,
-0.1068636775,
0.0839095339,
-0.0202125404,
-0.0307128169,
-0.629375875,
0.3349244893,
0.0498789363,
1.0468883514,
-0.4352405965,
0.7424676418,
0.8701164126,
-0.0888400599,
-0.5021378994,
-0.0535406843,
-0.3274303079,
-1.0245062113,
0.3908534944,
-0.0742654428,
-0.2762627006,
0.1279664785,
-0.3912756443,
-0.7911636829,
0.9733448029,
0.550103128,
-0.1872879714,
0.0217406247,
0.2081924975,
0.4145430028,
-0.3674710691,
0.3773171008,
0.9004628062,
0.5927236676,
0.6901164055,
-0.6802770495,
-0.0695345551,
-0.2692133784,
0.0632963851,
0.3524744511,
-0.5683011413,
0.4332642853,
0.2393274754,
-0.0449069068,
0.0773986131,
0.5910833478,
0.2939143479,
0.2844473422,
0.4262382388,
0.4719332159,
0.856531918,
-0.2156537175,
0.9765719771,
-0.2293185741,
0.0319294073,
1.3433804512,
-0.547208786,
0.9442734122,
0.3951131403,
-0.2494654357,
0.3755179048,
0.3374847174,
0.3183825314,
0.5213648677,
-0.0499278083,
-0.7399907112,
-0.4872919619,
-0.3123327494,
-0.2192495465,
0.2606975138,
0.4363102019,
-0.0642671958,
-0.2640626431,
-0.0998986959,
-0.1726148576,
0.1030708626,
-0.3490790129,
0.9217403531,
0.1287982017,
-1.0436995029,
0.5215114355,
-0.1728869975,
0.5366091728,
-0.7933691144,
-0.0030504249,
-0.339356482,
0.0547190569,
-0.208939895,
-1.0997641087,
0.1342097968,
-0.3078494072,
-0.2119314373,
-0.0944273174,
0.9170101285,
-0.9377893806,
-0.2442705333,
0.3779347837,
0.6207273602,
-0.1428793073,
-0.4222294092,
-0.5490453243,
-0.0633493736,
0.0069370717,
-0.2867464423,
0.3950876296,
0.4096020162,
0.1336745322,
0.7016986012,
0.7787190676,
0.2228232622,
0.431188792,
0.2009845674,
1.0911923647,
-0.4460896254,
-0.435331434,
-0.4698168337,
0.3680422902,
-0.2839313745,
0.1261170059,
0.4956113994,
0.6157935262,
0.7219796181,
0.0897425935,
0.7124034166,
0.0703533441,
0.4654186666,
-0.5358402729,
0.8263804317,
-0.8013316989,
0.3684831858,
0.2437712997,
-1.2342002392,
-0.367253691,
0.1059798002,
-0.0558395274,
0.316526711,
0.3194195032,
0.9574008584,
-0.2285096496,
0.0530607998,
0.5749878287,
0.4714193642,
0.4506195486,
0.2821775675,
0.6227306724,
-0.3570887744,
0.6173174977,
-0.0052054916,
0.0351185314,
-0.2753911316,
-0.6513937116,
-0.7839118242,
-0.3732607961,
-0.2023336589,
-0.2152963132,
-0.0120635079,
0.6100681424,
0.8493037224,
-0.8601226807,
-0.2659465969,
0.0163967963,
0.253759414,
0.0888547301,
-0.2507811785,
-0.1072243974,
-0.4159996808,
-0.8458912373,
0.7456309199,
0.2642306983,
-0.2207144946,
-0.3136266768,
0.0737435296,
-0.3287953138,
0.4297038317,
0.8103969097,
0.1817248762,
-0.5320289135,
0.0024322548,
-0.051122319,
0.1404286623,
0.0331566297,
0.74941957,
-1.0854085684,
0.8794848323,
0.6025879383,
1.1010059118,
0.7509175539,
0.0203542951,
0.5672866106,
-0.804659009,
-0.1381790638,
0.3252160549,
0.4652474821,
0.4199659824,
-0.3377380073,
0.469781965,
0.130534634,
-0.3806605339,
-0.9093814492,
0.3541331291,
-0.8470592499,
-0.2278958559,
1.0053222179,
0.1802604795,
0.0718905777,
-0.1362341046,
-0.2064328045,
-0.0431762859,
-0.3291719854,
0.2728904188,
0.8005212545,
-0.0518842377,
-0.0806712657,
-0.6783912778,
0.1703272015,
0.4806467295,
-0.7285277843,
-0.1725139022,
0.700974524,
0.4056347907,
-0.2836946249,
0.4881046116,
-0.2510769069,
0.0563222989,
-0.4688705206,
-0.2829907835,
0.0027054006,
-0.0357114337,
-0.0253832676,
0.583288312,
0.213209942,
0.2206230164
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.14633v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.14633v3
|
Born With a Silver Spoon? Investigating Socioeconomic Bias in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-16T23:18:19 | 2024-04-16T17:14:16 |
Smriti Singh, Shuvam Keshari, Vinija Jain, Aman Chadha
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Socioeconomic bias in society exacerbates disparities, influencing access to
opportunities and resources based on individuals' economic and social
backgrounds. This pervasive issue perpetuates systemic inequalities, hindering
the pursuit of inclusive progress as a society. In this paper, we investigate
the presence of socioeconomic bias, if any, in large language models. To this
end, we introduce a novel dataset SilverSpoon, consisting of 3000 samples that
illustrate hypothetical scenarios that involve underprivileged people
performing ethically ambiguous actions due to their circumstances, and ask
whether the action is ethically justified. Further, this dataset has a
dual-labeling scheme and has been annotated by people belonging to both ends of
the socioeconomic spectrum. Using SilverSpoon, we evaluate the degree of
socioeconomic bias expressed in large language models and the variation of this
degree as a function of model size. We also perform qualitative analysis to
analyze the nature of this bias. Our analysis reveals that while humans
disagree on which situations require empathy toward the underprivileged, most
large language models are unable to empathize with the socioeconomically
underprivileged regardless of the situation. To foster further research in this
domain, we make SilverSpoon and our evaluation harness publicly available.
|
[
-0.0764836743,
-0.5490919352,
0.5212235451,
0.1758811921,
0.0633312017,
0.3789229095,
-0.1870428622,
-0.3185661137,
0.1100140139,
0.3365398049,
-0.2769004107,
0.0456967168,
-0.8665292263,
-0.3034172356,
0.0264253579,
1.1959837675,
0.6316595674,
0.2646260262,
-0.1696758121,
-0.0882158056,
-0.035113208,
-0.3457908034,
-0.47449857,
-0.3844623864,
0.2703855336,
0.5891896486,
0.9637970328,
0.3928875327,
-0.043321006,
0.252527386,
-0.3655001223,
-0.1316078156,
-0.4635284543,
-0.2791581154,
-0.3503385186,
0.0052016857,
-0.4472342134,
0.2339303344,
0.3600173891,
0.9775108099,
0.0203759316,
0.7237557769,
0.4186136723,
0.4405950904,
-0.8792923689,
-0.0198138915,
-0.4504066408,
0.0486322157,
-0.3265554011,
0.332100004,
-0.0299464557,
-0.4149112105,
0.0478143059,
-0.3602176309,
0.0417047739,
-0.3139948845,
0.5704706907,
-0.0403108858,
-0.6684943438,
-0.3294283748,
-0.3904442489,
1.0639749765,
-0.7286624908,
0.1445311606,
0.4818612933,
0.0124137355,
0.0390971228,
-0.6069040298,
-0.5328432322,
-0.1588566601,
-0.0388360322,
0.077690199,
0.1302840859,
-0.1991859525,
0.2859427035,
0.0550034791,
-0.2038369626,
0.0967831612,
-0.6300257444,
0.1800643802,
0.6520036459,
-0.0932299048,
0.3476740122,
-0.2813755274,
-0.1413010657,
0.0723755509,
-0.3685737848,
0.2749835551,
0.8601030111,
0.3789774477,
-0.328210324,
0.5730163455,
0.3293656111,
0.4115182757,
0.0956673697,
0.0853901505,
0.3038969934,
-0.0218648538,
0.2530950308,
0.405739218,
0.3666472733,
0.6481519341,
0.7082312703,
0.1818394214,
-0.2008818984,
0.3280704618,
0.1049284935,
-0.501314044,
0.2079964876,
0.2632502019,
-0.3282677233,
-0.3991955221,
-0.0909447968,
-0.9240844846,
-1.0443819761,
-0.0015866774,
0.0356723368,
0.2173492461,
-0.4927885532,
0.022079898,
-0.4064474106,
0.1325628608,
-0.005752414,
-1.0108259916,
0.376527667,
0.9038441777,
0.8079776168,
0.3593252301,
-0.3168483078,
-0.4960184693,
0.2205991596,
-0.2735588849,
0.5324897766,
-0.7339923382,
-0.5808563232,
-0.3287482262,
-0.100012593,
0.2512384057,
-0.3368066251,
0.2013842911,
0.0929488465,
-0.1172825843,
-0.4033357501,
-0.1377126276,
0.3919512331,
0.2303790897,
-0.3210937679,
0.5475227237,
0.3173234463,
-1.1496590376,
0.6041340828,
-0.8639372587,
-0.5691134334,
0.1367232352,
-0.2955864072,
-0.1195813715,
0.1762540787,
0.0108928783,
0.1176772714,
-0.3403612673,
0.6478192806,
-0.7093515992,
-0.3763981164,
0.4592055082,
-0.6297982931,
1.2704846859,
-0.0376193188,
-0.5679933429,
-0.2449650019,
-0.7558250427,
-0.3714127839,
0.2324401587,
0.1495746076,
-0.9235898256,
-0.035300646,
0.1330003589,
0.3239342272,
0.5782368183,
-0.7715612054,
0.0009392238,
-0.4364319444,
0.7262766361,
1.2212272882,
-0.1192274168,
0.6558733582,
-0.1533746421,
0.4867191315,
0.0777057111,
0.6578950882,
0.5215482712,
-0.1460397094,
-0.4090698659,
-0.0780434832,
0.4906580448,
0.4445238411,
-0.1507784724,
-0.036203552,
-0.027421942,
-0.1966351122,
-1.0141760111,
-0.0305056106,
0.2226339281,
0.4596805871,
0.0215192065,
-0.2222767621,
-0.4213123322,
-1.1638873816,
-0.4451717436,
0.0434128866,
0.0175746549,
0.521931231,
0.6823644042,
-0.1981956959,
0.8775020242,
-0.3436970711,
-0.1796704084,
-0.0028082947,
0.0079078032,
0.1206903011,
0.604229331,
0.2751357853,
-0.8027040958,
-0.2865617275,
0.166206494,
-0.4937315583,
-0.3613748848,
0.0717092082,
0.0407356657,
0.1702449173,
0.1842894256,
-0.3992364705,
0.5006420612,
0.7174789906,
-0.7034736276,
0.383236587,
-0.087272048,
-0.0704961866,
-0.8936434388,
0.1447948664,
0.2129783928,
0.1307690591,
-0.2748488188,
-0.3990447223,
0.0308074709,
-0.0070575671,
-0.3568827808,
0.8318045735,
-0.4690539241,
-0.347214669,
0.0237438232,
0.2372327,
-0.0191447642,
-0.1500377208,
-0.1110139266,
0.8202887177,
0.422534734,
-0.1060608402,
-0.1965093464,
-0.0910059586,
-0.1792737544,
0.6588766575,
-0.9294742942,
-0.1333905458,
-0.2677784264,
0.1270880401,
-0.8144569993,
-0.0958127305,
0.0818743929,
-0.5176433325,
-0.2267628759,
-0.2312521935,
-0.2781947255,
-0.354757607,
-0.286516279,
0.3604954183,
0.5334091783,
-0.1122938395,
0.2920535505,
0.9188115597,
-0.5945469141,
-0.6845041513,
-0.7217725515,
0.0560723804,
-0.3824275732,
-0.5021391511,
-0.2354538888,
0.1057211831,
-0.8959988356,
-0.1694777161,
0.0321083255,
0.0656863376,
0.2707389295,
0.3096675873,
0.194442749,
0.1774950922,
-0.1181360334,
0.4562690258,
-0.1769641191,
0.084197551,
-0.0746982917,
0.5379545689,
-0.1809106618,
-0.1563906223,
0.237526536,
0.4318442345,
0.7079373598,
-0.2681927383,
0.5663024783,
0.2592422366,
-0.224857688,
-0.0167132281,
-0.3513749838,
-0.119068414,
-0.5076141357,
0.2270644754,
0.0082365805,
-0.7980351448,
0.6385309696,
0.286485523,
0.1788775176,
0.0385094471,
0.2759669721,
0.2628914714,
1.3937577009,
0.3673847914,
-0.0437561721,
0.1495292336,
-0.1731784642,
0.3152046502,
-0.9879211187,
0.1178927198,
-0.4798069894,
-0.325214535,
-0.574036181,
-0.0684806928,
0.425452441,
-0.2419385463,
-0.4926679432,
-0.4343442917,
-0.4576196373,
0.6174776554,
0.3462119699,
0.0028601929,
0.2171160877,
-0.3831489384,
0.0273907036,
-0.1231487095,
-0.6082162261,
-0.8272190094,
0.9700780511,
0.305454284,
0.6030970216,
0.0097831106,
0.5178925991,
0.6862804294,
0.4708770216,
-0.4791410267,
0.3581968844,
-0.3201045692,
-0.5902603865,
-0.3510799408,
-0.3377572894,
-1.1362872124,
0.1734569967,
0.0029144275,
-0.8438385129,
0.3852478564,
0.2682816386,
-0.2989200056,
0.0054368884,
-0.9172948599,
0.9147226214,
-0.3893738389,
-0.6880891323,
0.0143535594,
-0.9604403377,
0.451925993,
-0.0231682528,
0.9748860002,
-0.1194577962,
0.1070531532,
0.525698185,
-0.2965277135,
1.087649107,
-0.5024942756,
-0.2276017964,
-0.1106074154,
-0.0057870573,
0.262255758,
0.2669269145,
-0.2876330614,
0.1003946662,
0.0984105542,
-0.7651342154,
-0.2598599195,
0.9329608679,
-0.9114863873,
-0.4477837086,
-0.7653458118,
-0.6188516021,
-0.1854928583,
0.3265279233,
-0.0481900759,
0.3421765268,
-0.0685576722,
-0.1328057498,
0.3079863191,
-0.2836502194,
0.1294099987,
0.3764868081,
-0.0864415243,
-0.2488597035,
0.6502537727,
0.7156590819,
0.2725755274,
-0.6944611669,
0.5647851229,
-0.2114711702,
0.0211158991,
-0.4566160738,
0.540299952,
-0.3481013477,
0.1394590139,
-0.5351477861,
0.0135506,
-1.0284334421,
-0.6384564042,
-0.3165287673,
-0.2199327052,
-0.282382071,
-0.1120002568,
0.1139482781,
0.7701669335,
-0.24493213,
0.0951967984,
-0.4682349265,
0.1351240128,
0.3272658587,
0.2920071781,
0.4979426563,
-0.5497860312,
-0.1209362373,
0.4493183792,
-0.236024633,
-0.5581328273,
0.1068158001,
-0.0629522279,
0.2768428028,
0.3507502675,
0.4120646715,
0.8482752442,
-0.5359044671,
0.942781806,
0.0039339894,
-1.1051361561,
0.3609094918,
-0.4602810442,
0.5053163171,
0.3335505724,
0.2160212398,
-0.6248136759,
-0.6275037527,
-1.1216648817,
-1.2674542665,
0.6456338763,
-0.2497411966,
0.2562513947,
-0.1752361357,
-0.0162197091,
0.2884431779,
0.2789560556,
-0.6637100577,
0.1041031703,
-0.2233573496,
-0.2486000061,
-0.291028738,
-0.2029248029,
-0.1159256771,
-0.2194334865,
0.439066112,
0.010843969,
-0.3666930497,
-0.0553222895,
-0.2418262064,
-0.069747366,
0.380980432,
0.4089867771,
1.0051653385,
0.2078365833,
0.2064777464,
0.1580001116,
-0.5793526173,
0.199339956,
0.1463642716,
-0.1747506112,
-0.4112092555,
-0.0160649791,
0.5853783488,
0.2209177911,
-0.9802654982,
0.6453711987,
-0.0391225033,
0.0614817739,
-0.7248014212,
-0.0492962785,
0.2180128098,
0.6121263504,
0.3692654967,
-0.2544972897,
0.3716978431,
-0.6144940257,
-0.1631130129,
0.4936174452,
-0.2931405902,
-0.2596715391,
0.4337584972,
0.0759670958,
-0.463998884,
0.4694445431,
-0.0492604785,
-0.3319319189,
0.4752373695,
0.6139024496,
0.5371776819,
-0.0688270926,
0.5609254241,
-0.1862585247,
0.3445573747,
-0.0898898914,
0.1039109975,
-0.2283756137,
-0.7352782488,
-0.0922163054,
-0.8617408872,
-0.2460452169,
-0.0825273842,
-0.7625864744,
0.0682082623,
-0.4165492058,
-0.3795163929,
0.1018008813,
-0.1053502634,
-0.2715899944,
0.1085863933,
-0.071167469,
0.580778718,
-1.3251256943,
0.4097264707,
0.8358618617,
-0.2281691879,
-0.3501675725,
0.0602609068,
0.0220655482,
-0.8185961843,
0.6155071855,
0.0764800236,
-0.2643865943,
0.1241880134,
-0.3894545138,
-0.6282696724,
0.6796119809,
0.4231924713,
-0.2094756067,
-0.0690951273,
0.1964023411,
0.4307304621,
-0.194944635,
0.0891787112,
0.9102153182,
0.6847246289,
-0.2191392779,
-0.9316542745,
-0.2634062469,
-0.4050109684,
0.2351495773,
0.1798740625,
-0.8868417144,
0.8960049748,
-0.331186235,
0.1474836618,
-0.2765920758,
0.241345942,
0.4403461218,
0.6386387944,
0.5421124697,
0.3036340773,
0.5837602615,
0.2614005506,
0.7523729205,
-0.2110743374,
0.3837062716,
0.8951762319,
-0.7491212487,
0.3175340891,
0.7830327749,
-0.0484709963,
0.2692493498,
0.4635693729,
0.2158118486,
0.2669842243,
0.3558413088,
-0.2548228502,
0.0270869154,
-0.4706244469,
-0.1433580816,
0.5018322468,
0.4634061754,
-0.3200936019,
-0.0937535092,
0.2245973498,
0.3703827262,
0.2525756955,
-0.7199808955,
0.6018086076,
0.0764788762,
-0.4350785017,
0.1243434921,
-0.3088901043,
0.7989878058,
-0.5485286713,
0.0919326097,
-0.2455845326,
0.293038547,
-0.309489578,
-0.8576053381,
0.1913011372,
0.2476458251,
-0.0898253247,
-0.0411406681,
0.7732715011,
-0.3145063519,
-0.6202695966,
0.27460289,
0.2849811614,
0.1584944129,
0.3410897255,
-0.7366876006,
0.2250506729,
-0.1079202816,
-0.2288390845,
0.6018512845,
0.6225871444,
-0.2630422413,
0.5116540194,
0.336347878,
0.4951782227,
0.0131401829,
0.1093429029,
0.4908228517,
-0.5095593333,
-0.8205054402,
-0.8896682262,
0.8331425786,
-0.5257422328,
-0.5216595531,
0.9458339214,
0.4890708625,
0.6732029319,
0.0543874241,
1.0626926422,
-0.075269267,
0.4504792988,
-0.061291676,
0.9413835406,
-0.7177085876,
0.0377796851,
-0.6492180824,
-0.4398127794,
-0.0193425752,
0.913400948,
-0.6647951603,
0.362300694,
0.0317877606,
0.6986654997,
-0.2232747972,
-0.0872282162,
0.1976442784,
0.3002819717,
0.0264442563,
0.1016884074,
0.7554358244,
0.0935817286,
-0.0967147797,
0.0634704456,
-0.4481879175,
-0.0618451163,
-0.7277764082,
-0.4920962751,
-0.3310963213,
-0.1106411666,
-0.636218667,
0.257166177,
0.9745208621,
0.2184709013,
-0.3695648611,
-0.652567625,
0.2159659415,
0.2899937928,
-0.0176905897,
-0.3228030503,
0.1817229837,
-0.027606843,
-0.7845679522,
-0.4476789534,
0.2885405123,
-0.0126343854,
-0.5042290092,
0.0924386084,
-0.2298605591,
0.2457958758,
0.6471863985,
0.1816251427,
-0.386223495,
-0.38508448,
-0.2228752375,
0.015134179,
-0.308334738,
0.6728530526,
-0.4330247343,
0.1665243953,
0.0574248023,
0.4057748914,
0.064667508,
-0.0273056664,
0.4002787769,
-0.6561686993,
0.2941924334,
0.4184832573,
0.0962410346,
0.4711809158,
-0.4831165969,
0.096025832,
0.1948946714,
-0.8277088404,
-1.2562245131,
0.3856657445,
-0.5067341328,
-0.5037744045,
1.2063981295,
0.1824248284,
-0.3700135946,
-0.2402359694,
-0.2351286858,
0.3574182093,
-0.6846936941,
1.0505472422,
0.595465064,
0.1342130899,
-0.2526572645,
-0.3537780344,
0.0850400776,
0.2039673179,
-0.2981046438,
0.4233253002,
0.6804301739,
0.3683054745,
-0.0570904352,
0.5787702799,
-0.2435892522,
0.214846909,
0.1105275005,
0.1425428391,
0.1144666448,
-0.0603750125,
-0.3238456845,
0.2041617632,
0.2800654471,
0.2064413875
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11122v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11122v1
|
Navigating the Dual Facets: A Comprehensive Evaluation of Sequential Memory Editing in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-16T23:08:55 | 2024-02-16T23:08:55 |
Zihao Lin, Mohammad Beigi, Hongxuan Li, Yufan Zhou, Yuxiang Zhang, Qifan Wang, Wenpeng Yin, Lifu Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Memory Editing (ME) has emerged as an efficient method to modify erroneous
facts or inject new facts into Large Language Models (LLMs). Two mainstream ME
methods exist: parameter-modifying ME and parameter-preserving ME (integrating
extra modules while preserving original parameters). Regrettably, previous
studies on ME evaluation have two critical limitations: (i) evaluating LLMs
with single edit only, neglecting the need for continuous editing, and (ii)
evaluations focusing solely on basic factual triples, overlooking broader LLM
capabilities like logical reasoning and reading understanding. This study
addresses these limitations with contributions threefold: (i) We explore how ME
affects a wide range of fundamental capabilities of LLMs under sequential
editing. Experimental results reveal an intriguing phenomenon: Most
parameter-modifying ME consistently degrade performance across all tasks after
a few sequential edits. In contrast, parameter-preserving ME effectively
maintains LLMs' fundamental capabilities but struggles to accurately recall
edited knowledge presented in a different format. (ii) We extend our evaluation
to different editing settings, such as layers to edit, model size, instruction
tuning, etc. Experimental findings indicate several strategies that can
potentially mitigate the adverse effects of ME. (iii) We further explain why
parameter-modifying ME damages LLMs from three dimensions: parameter changes
after editing, language modeling capability, and the in-context learning
capability. Our in-depth study advocates more careful use of ME in real-world
scenarios.
|
[
-0.2148650438,
-1.1132804155,
0.7408284545,
0.2498852015,
-0.2198431045,
0.1981167048,
-0.4170199037,
-0.2820497751,
-0.1185883507,
0.5781400204,
-0.3523975611,
-0.3717603087,
-0.4889578223,
0.0060585034,
-0.0972013921,
0.9940887094,
-0.262958318,
0.1465329379,
-0.2475068569,
-0.3038364947,
-0.7635634542,
-0.6789411902,
-0.8401676416,
-0.0725811943,
0.699077785,
0.3999952972,
0.8576998115,
0.5456906557,
0.2763499022,
0.3185016811,
-0.3753970563,
0.0357128493,
-0.4166483581,
0.1107877493,
-0.3927950859,
-0.3543916345,
-0.7109094262,
0.1403831542,
1.0230566263,
0.8024400473,
0.1559141129,
0.2268589586,
0.1955600083,
0.8961164355,
-0.6736767888,
-0.1878658831,
-0.6240000725,
-0.0833480358,
-0.4055669904,
-0.1932952702,
-0.3865357339,
-0.0492057689,
0.2053577751,
-0.2423575073,
-0.0724994987,
-0.1889159679,
0.4335826933,
0.3118872643,
-0.3241065741,
-0.2795981765,
-1.0508447886,
0.6509340405,
-0.6432074904,
0.3452972472,
0.0539182648,
0.2251174748,
-0.150761798,
-0.5766488314,
-0.5762884617,
-0.1950160861,
0.0746885166,
0.0795240849,
-0.0851144716,
0.2749591768,
0.5662426353,
0.2645551264,
-0.4023835957,
0.2257997245,
-0.624007225,
-0.3206805289,
0.4140967429,
0.3651241064,
0.320551604,
-0.13783364,
-0.1385664493,
-0.0212944057,
-0.7679963112,
0.1296593994,
0.5797095299,
0.0113867652,
0.3564227223,
0.6529954672,
0.0512015335,
0.8054459691,
0.0107778078,
-0.3207271099,
-0.1904112995,
-0.398280412,
-0.2619790435,
-0.2207576632,
0.5774775147,
0.3440570533,
0.0469381548,
-0.1562510133,
-0.0650401637,
-0.2658048272,
0.2028546482,
-0.7763794065,
-0.1046697572,
0.2367762923,
-0.3541729152,
-0.0258932896,
-0.1533720046,
-0.6222455502,
-0.3044127226,
-0.3747060001,
0.6107778549,
-0.55293262,
0.0858166516,
0.4290806353,
-0.087236546,
-0.1627969146,
0.7231442332,
-0.7902393937,
0.2369584888,
0.7538658977,
0.8574287295,
0.0956745669,
-0.6312010288,
-0.4027153254,
0.2279378772,
-0.146415934,
0.6656966209,
-0.7178418636,
-0.3872088194,
-0.2625793815,
-0.2990562916,
-0.2222547531,
-0.6637560129,
0.43924281,
-0.8291528821,
0.130534634,
-0.5208544731,
-0.4112256169,
-0.1919638067,
0.0123254862,
-0.7010830045,
0.6641921997,
-0.0234962683,
-0.6071421504,
0.3187887669,
-0.3083572686,
-0.391600877,
-0.5085276961,
-0.0859140903,
-0.2653867304,
0.3293937445,
-0.0300909914,
0.4200109541,
-0.0621490851,
0.343921721,
-0.1444632858,
-0.2742272615,
0.3013424873,
-0.4404887855,
0.5311738253,
-0.0726386532,
-0.0071936306,
0.2332005054,
-0.7232566476,
-0.2663139105,
-0.249563694,
-0.602288723,
-0.4568232596,
0.0271032639,
-0.3110225201,
0.4220322371,
0.3727371991,
-0.4532971084,
0.4181089997,
-0.1299969554,
0.2964335978,
1.0484347343,
0.2788624167,
0.5166333318,
-0.3024617434,
0.4335090816,
0.1379926354,
0.1352628917,
-0.1937389523,
-0.3579192758,
-0.7047196031,
-0.2069051415,
0.3520167768,
0.6436634064,
-0.664852798,
0.165896818,
-0.2444162071,
-0.1872737706,
-0.484383136,
0.3643068373,
0.5220125914,
0.5399580002,
0.4794417024,
-0.1436009258,
-0.3715729415,
-1.233602643,
-0.7115089297,
-0.151751399,
0.075897105,
0.1659819335,
0.4652669132,
-0.2363412976,
0.7413818836,
-0.3178389966,
-0.1089942679,
-0.0741357729,
0.226249963,
0.0903311744,
0.611349225,
0.2893169224,
-0.1849116683,
-0.3884296119,
-0.2799617648,
-0.5295103788,
-0.2846724093,
-0.6546331048,
-0.1331709623,
0.2679153681,
0.4547115266,
-0.5946969986,
0.519380033,
0.359395206,
-0.3383399546,
0.8873870373,
-0.5219697356,
0.3263064623,
-0.5307434797,
-0.1658018529,
-0.1854921132,
0.0237431992,
-0.7359105945,
0.064683035,
0.3672254682,
0.225388512,
-0.1912067235,
0.6494902968,
-0.6014124155,
-0.1212970763,
-0.2651988566,
0.0768224224,
0.0839925483,
0.4049372077,
-0.3576200902,
0.9330171347,
0.2538124621,
-0.6245809197,
-0.0166415796,
0.0628208593,
-0.3783855736,
0.4572345912,
-0.4184653759,
0.4978972971,
-0.1826533824,
0.19207865,
-0.8787050247,
0.1912676841,
0.1867478639,
0.05036515,
0.6075368524,
-0.0006806771,
-0.7862362862,
-0.1254941672,
-0.4833717048,
0.5065790415,
0.230153352,
-0.578805685,
0.5093915462,
0.0926593319,
-0.3084445,
-0.4816381931,
-0.6024052501,
0.4632619619,
-0.2210288346,
-0.9272819161,
0.3553729355,
-0.2765848935,
-0.6219350696,
-0.0252852459,
-0.3857006133,
0.0911093429,
0.0773503259,
-0.0216356516,
0.1962099522,
-0.124637194,
-0.0002490498,
0.5680854917,
-0.3094112277,
-0.0307409018,
-0.0324967466,
0.1965222806,
-0.1248604432,
-0.3428826332,
-0.5001612902,
0.2992952764,
0.5560995936,
-0.3697507679,
0.7489828467,
0.3238785565,
-0.1510419548,
-0.1109948754,
-0.8718565702,
-0.0182892606,
-0.4607332647,
0.5504263639,
-0.7411109805,
-1.1274935007,
0.6195690632,
-0.1812211722,
0.1872496754,
0.330409348,
0.3508145511,
-0.0597333983,
0.8792226911,
0.387250036,
0.1359477639,
0.2748214602,
-0.0674528331,
0.2930969596,
-1.2916494608,
-0.0880646333,
-0.283595711,
-0.6362758279,
-0.3471420109,
-0.7986727357,
0.5364642143,
0.4046059251,
0.0354706757,
-0.0442040339,
-0.0183778033,
0.4480861127,
0.1583754271,
0.2690634131,
0.486018002,
-0.3419475853,
-0.0648571402,
-0.4648417234,
-0.4816219211,
-0.8169952035,
1.1065778732,
0.408498019,
0.6245806813,
0.3002901971,
0.3908533454,
0.0627461299,
0.2555559576,
-0.660830617,
0.6902174354,
-0.2831725478,
-0.5359451771,
-0.2644557357,
-0.2265924662,
-0.4709280729,
0.4932393432,
-0.1343957335,
-0.6939913034,
0.0395278558,
0.26554811,
-0.469453156,
0.5830795765,
-0.6698067784,
0.7848981619,
-0.4268593788,
-0.7309548855,
-0.6649464369,
-0.5348527431,
0.6199799776,
-0.2698592842,
0.2276914567,
0.0554898083,
-0.4405011237,
0.6838299632,
-0.4493388832,
0.6987758875,
-0.3018659353,
0.1013735086,
0.1193001121,
0.3435071707,
0.3572895527,
0.207961455,
-0.2074023038,
0.0923288167,
0.1214280874,
-0.3417668045,
-0.9943039417,
0.8410115838,
-0.5946958661,
-0.9930258393,
-0.3133131862,
-0.6884347796,
-0.4173929989,
0.0646522194,
-0.2750515342,
0.4700722396,
-0.3004430234,
0.0414022505,
0.6790011525,
-0.5998978019,
0.2993514836,
0.5729388595,
-0.2949167788,
-0.318544805,
0.6923455,
0.4941646457,
0.4772652686,
0.2485412061,
0.41196087,
0.1064858362,
-0.8936399221,
-0.5499030948,
0.3206188083,
-0.6740052104,
0.2684640884,
-0.7845268846,
0.0259046033,
-0.0623579063,
-0.1173984483,
-0.3794921339,
-0.6576556563,
-0.1822614819,
-0.074858278,
0.1726483852,
0.9079377651,
-0.3000279963,
0.4589158297,
-0.6931734681,
0.2157863826,
0.3929507434,
0.4353859127,
0.0162553415,
-0.6094921231,
-0.3790552616,
-0.1234073713,
-0.1073426232,
-0.9122991562,
-0.0790450722,
0.0958438516,
0.4891023636,
0.2744337022,
-0.4493615031,
1.1715471745,
-0.8863813877,
0.6783894897,
-0.3026770949,
-1.0435887575,
0.3702158034,
-0.206962809,
0.4631350636,
0.7641163468,
0.0623081997,
-0.4885885119,
-0.3715119958,
-0.4838116467,
-0.7257940173,
0.741435051,
-0.1811406463,
0.2035804093,
0.2339600325,
0.9387199283,
0.303632617,
0.211341396,
-0.2578989267,
-0.3540359139,
0.2003022283,
0.2982802987,
-0.0708273128,
-0.8792812824,
0.2181602865,
-0.5970832705,
0.6925356984,
0.3125735819,
-0.1073851362,
0.1240690649,
-0.3355558813,
-0.0686220676,
0.2751735747,
0.8564044237,
0.9026708007,
-0.3636557162,
0.1500512064,
0.2745167613,
-0.3976808488,
-0.0970480591,
-0.2709780931,
-0.2548179626,
-0.0605607517,
0.2978473902,
0.772253871,
0.7455622554,
-0.5218129754,
0.1786989421,
-0.1056456938,
-0.0241678078,
-0.0663237423,
0.0921344608,
-0.0045155375,
0.2462507188,
0.0310216509,
0.4797933996,
0.106611006,
-0.6128016114,
0.2036665231,
0.4682882726,
0.0897935927,
-0.6444762945,
0.5259675384,
-0.1597736627,
-0.2386409938,
0.5067284703,
0.0075009186,
-0.4422437251,
0.1893892288,
0.3672432601,
0.9462966323,
-0.5018684268,
-0.0294994228,
0.5683649778,
0.578371644,
0.0882051289,
0.0120707415,
-0.0197892152,
-0.6505554318,
-0.4563502669,
-0.4096142352,
-0.4378827214,
0.3424743116,
-0.621024847,
0.240236342,
-0.9059973359,
0.0180520862,
-0.0059951874,
-0.082537286,
-0.5034369826,
0.0661146119,
-0.0382100828,
0.8953620791,
-0.5529640317,
0.9224534035,
0.7228382826,
-0.264834106,
-0.4330991805,
0.1364361644,
0.2871797681,
-0.6823468208,
0.3293884695,
-0.0279321633,
-0.1071679369,
-0.1427968144,
-0.4074340761,
-0.827414155,
1.037612915,
0.330740422,
-0.4436357915,
-0.00436999,
0.0171720088,
0.5644097328,
0.0002756876,
0.1467045844,
0.9802320004,
0.6494866014,
0.1237315834,
-0.8328855634,
0.0164004881,
-0.0571763404,
-0.0006980291,
0.139596805,
-0.6936663389,
1.0211831331,
-0.3229519427,
-0.2459126264,
0.1923585683,
0.5647637248,
0.0831930712,
-0.0086866282,
0.4328245223,
0.6502493024,
0.7217485905,
0.2527095377,
1.0111305714,
-0.2109510154,
-0.0624656565,
1.3819929361,
-0.2455111593,
0.9579328299,
0.6803582907,
-0.1616582721,
0.3615068793,
0.4053762257,
0.3290724456,
0.3189849555,
0.1841769069,
-0.4131484628,
-0.047587961,
0.3735916913,
-0.1859018505,
0.4180971086,
0.4303433895,
-0.1294381171,
-0.2063298076,
-0.0428162776,
0.5433378816,
0.0624425001,
-0.113361083,
0.6395320892,
0.0069926521,
-0.6157522202,
0.2325458825,
0.4157395065,
0.382971108,
-0.4900544584,
-0.0142073371,
-0.0847884864,
0.1511591077,
-0.1272363365,
-0.8020251393,
0.6895279884,
0.2295555472,
-0.3558652401,
-0.533603847,
0.6122376323,
-0.4128279388,
-0.3332742453,
0.3701960444,
0.5987725854,
0.0094459802,
-0.3424403965,
-0.7760429382,
0.4487994611,
0.0179357231,
-0.4033928812,
0.5620569587,
0.4312964082,
-0.0952439457,
0.4022321403,
0.5506243706,
0.2076371908,
0.155875355,
0.1330529451,
0.8289387226,
-0.8798024058,
-0.1634344459,
-1.104932785,
0.8404445052,
0.1539775729,
-0.245392859,
0.863451004,
0.7691762447,
0.7532024384,
-0.0412773117,
0.6881278753,
0.0969066769,
0.3540098667,
-0.8144232035,
0.5311574936,
-0.4270533621,
0.6485142112,
-0.304423511,
-0.8913213611,
-0.3850333989,
0.2824370861,
-0.6439995766,
0.0023739126,
0.9871511459,
0.7582107782,
0.1024730876,
-0.0326499231,
0.5646079183,
0.8236213923,
0.2915348709,
0.4523890913,
1.0783879757,
-0.3625948131,
-0.0227087028,
-0.620149672,
-0.430372268,
0.0635213628,
-0.7936839461,
-1.0695022345,
-0.5519177914,
-0.4227770269,
-0.1515783519,
0.0900548175,
0.5901022553,
0.2128596455,
-0.6202008724,
-0.3268438578,
0.392442733,
0.2599613965,
0.0194324758,
-0.130185172,
0.3955343962,
-0.1313275099,
-0.6243646741,
0.6065608263,
0.7895854115,
-0.297988981,
-0.381290406,
0.0741728395,
-0.3440201879,
0.0728546977,
0.7581039071,
0.1878456026,
-0.8820037246,
-0.5458683372,
-0.2773858309,
0.0335876346,
0.0137806162,
0.9016380906,
-0.7332422137,
0.8507182598,
0.4884122908,
0.6792327762,
0.3040563762,
0.0547569506,
0.5649051666,
-0.4320980012,
0.1327133477,
0.0017740446,
0.425454706,
0.3512478173,
-0.4201417863,
0.1410946995,
0.1546563208,
-0.6568233967,
-0.645001471,
-0.0413046218,
-0.9357329011,
-0.2408441454,
1.0514194965,
0.1011237726,
-0.0985806882,
-0.0351560004,
-0.3747673035,
0.078532964,
-0.0101504298,
0.5776466131,
0.9399831891,
-0.3808080554,
-0.0754267722,
-1.1030399799,
0.3274429739,
0.5460830331,
-0.4847760797,
0.0330479443,
0.897595048,
0.2551481128,
-0.1128028408,
0.5625151992,
-0.2455741763,
0.2645288408,
-0.2139857262,
-0.1760959029,
-0.2042543441,
-0.5933004022,
-0.8196401596,
-0.1017926037,
0.2904351354,
0.1505331993
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11114v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11114v2
|
Whose Emotions and Moral Sentiments Do Language Models Reflect?
| 2024-02-16T22:34:53 | 2024-06-17T23:41:37 |
Zihao He, Siyi Guo, Ashwin Rao, Kristina Lerman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.SI
|
Language models (LMs) are known to represent the perspectives of some social
groups better than others, which may impact their performance, especially on
subjective tasks such as content moderation and hate speech detection. To
explore how LMs represent different perspectives, existing research focused on
positional alignment, i.e., how closely the models mimic the opinions and
stances of different groups, e.g., liberals or conservatives. However, human
communication also encompasses emotional and moral dimensions. We define the
problem of affective alignment, which measures how LMs' emotional and moral
tone represents those of different groups. By comparing the affect of responses
generated by 36 LMs to the affect of Twitter messages, we observe significant
misalignment of LMs with both ideological groups. This misalignment is larger
than the partisan divide in the U.S. Even after steering the LMs towards
specific ideological perspectives, the misalignment and liberal tendencies of
the model persist, suggesting a systemic bias within LMs.
|
[
-0.262040019,
-0.6210844517,
0.5871151686,
0.0757787898,
-0.1191114709,
0.3422420025,
-0.0454257466,
-0.3256498873,
0.3666515946,
0.5518192649,
-0.4123417139,
-0.3633230627,
-0.7353366613,
-0.1008718982,
-0.272492379,
1.067717433,
0.2776134312,
0.3285638988,
0.2138939649,
-0.5941650867,
-0.0561109036,
-0.6624584794,
-0.513065815,
-0.5281780362,
0.7500584126,
0.1341894269,
1.2706360817,
0.4182287455,
0.6565012336,
0.2850677371,
-0.1787841618,
-0.4939044416,
-0.6236994863,
0.0550246462,
-0.5475152135,
-0.3323480785,
-0.250092268,
0.3259446323,
0.4699391127,
0.4826903939,
-0.1681263894,
0.0697039589,
-0.0283280779,
0.7372366786,
-0.4549126029,
-0.4316701591,
-0.6587911248,
-0.106011562,
-0.0197873432,
-0.1181560084,
-0.3879048526,
-0.7959443331,
0.2172524184,
-0.088838622,
-0.1343092173,
0.1811364442,
1.0354082584,
0.2639132142,
-0.8412501216,
-0.4759803414,
-0.5654695034,
1.127188921,
-0.8926321864,
0.4230311215,
0.2214033306,
-0.1876888275,
0.1420429349,
0.1819526106,
-0.6891050935,
0.1390445381,
-0.0954770222,
0.1922181398,
-0.2338179499,
0.0916384235,
0.2344452888,
0.0933878869,
-0.4859531522,
0.0453515314,
-0.4193847179,
0.2299842685,
0.709856689,
0.2701146901,
0.4860543907,
-0.4210079908,
-0.3426700234,
-0.0964816287,
-0.5910462141,
0.3945152462,
0.7856052518,
0.4050859213,
-0.138947621,
0.6379706264,
0.3713395894,
0.599388659,
0.1573619843,
0.1178954989,
0.0520445779,
-0.0391236283,
-0.2917761803,
0.1775517613,
0.9127554893,
0.794393301,
0.5955989361,
0.53634727,
-0.1930691004,
0.2706409395,
0.5175397396,
-0.5552547574,
0.1318835169,
0.226230979,
-0.7381823063,
-0.4869610071,
0.0501102209,
-0.6366437078,
-1.0310009718,
-0.4497072995,
0.011691154,
-0.3871940374,
-0.4520338476,
0.0347271301,
0.24671866,
0.5001718402,
0.1628221869,
-0.8190620542,
0.1425436139,
0.9377323389,
0.7056854367,
-0.0876614079,
0.1894069314,
-0.3449533284,
-0.071960941,
-0.4518983066,
0.5760260224,
-1.0796704292,
-0.4343701601,
0.1599275619,
0.0387537703,
0.0533913374,
-0.1247993335,
0.7058015466,
-0.3563659787,
0.3748077154,
-0.8698692918,
-0.6039927602,
-0.246308893,
0.1303211451,
-0.5322146416,
0.6021653414,
-0.1161157414,
-1.0566818714,
0.0993861854,
-0.3306172788,
-0.0487273633,
-0.2026425004,
-0.4335398376,
-0.2209637314,
0.4653665125,
-0.3820285797,
0.3336901963,
-0.3647789359,
0.2914670706,
-0.6574715972,
-0.2906125486,
0.4743478298,
-0.0481768101,
0.9623389244,
0.1131954268,
-0.3561974168,
0.3489176333,
-0.2889020741,
-0.1681080163,
0.1871878356,
-0.0612792298,
-0.7900823951,
0.4952916801,
0.1177724749,
0.6027488708,
0.1459393799,
-0.6490201354,
0.1363897324,
-0.4070228338,
0.2479970306,
1.1940718889,
-0.2979687452,
0.6556586027,
-0.3761289418,
0.436856091,
0.238573432,
0.2591014504,
0.4212794006,
-0.3227035701,
-0.8055990934,
0.446944207,
-0.418040961,
0.6017762423,
-0.0264639296,
0.2529516816,
0.0201311018,
-0.4852624834,
-0.7057768703,
-0.0474714488,
0.3904937208,
0.2019053251,
0.0704252794,
-0.0840443447,
-0.35993734,
-1.325874567,
-0.7362984419,
-0.6850639582,
0.4839557409,
0.3008615673,
0.2966281772,
-0.0430165119,
0.7760945559,
-0.2842609882,
0.2202264071,
0.067539461,
0.1912436634,
0.199290067,
0.22898449,
0.6289792657,
-0.7663069367,
-0.5943031311,
0.0453245975,
-0.5747310519,
-0.3433818817,
0.1687326729,
-0.3354590833,
0.4056602716,
0.0670252442,
-0.1739164293,
0.3261638284,
0.9106153846,
-0.8546837568,
0.2503851652,
0.3713137209,
0.4899950325,
-1.1874165535,
-0.154584527,
0.2694465518,
-0.0569321439,
-0.6263476014,
-0.5875849724,
0.0982500687,
0.161490187,
-0.5949885249,
0.3667619526,
-0.1095062345,
-0.0359056666,
-0.0610312521,
0.2528618574,
0.1875576377,
0.0147066731,
0.0860655904,
0.4205121696,
0.4203203022,
-0.0705585182,
0.2098892927,
0.0459972806,
0.0576823652,
1.0558729172,
-0.5817167759,
0.2237586081,
-0.4254301488,
-0.0541479774,
-0.9400237203,
-0.0526957437,
0.4509752095,
-0.1649071127,
0.020240061,
-0.1135608181,
-0.1350059956,
-0.1607726365,
-0.3243739605,
0.2933389246,
0.5131081939,
-0.1852205843,
0.6974844337,
0.5565868616,
-0.201927498,
-0.8257372975,
-0.5611553788,
-0.2689320147,
-0.5813561678,
-0.4714637995,
0.0133667532,
0.0916742682,
-1.0617169142,
0.1661781669,
0.0690420493,
0.195332244,
-0.2346390337,
0.4863038659,
0.1773465425,
-0.1451324522,
0.4096301794,
-0.0746455863,
0.3093638122,
0.1912111491,
0.0225411672,
0.3812255859,
-0.631696701,
-0.4336766899,
-0.2301041335,
0.5412085056,
0.6588532925,
-0.2608189881,
1.0928121805,
0.1454861015,
-0.2971420884,
0.107981585,
-0.6999657154,
-0.0574331693,
-0.4671821296,
0.1872268319,
0.1895320565,
-0.9156486988,
0.629126966,
0.3765370548,
0.1531578302,
0.3838808835,
0.468532145,
-0.410484165,
1.2875615358,
0.6128749251,
-0.261013478,
0.6531356573,
0.0599988475,
0.4473561049,
-0.7392383218,
-0.058613006,
-0.6234771013,
-0.486112386,
-0.7169002295,
-0.1823023111,
-0.2377664745,
0.125336349,
-0.5767884851,
0.1188662872,
-0.8014968634,
0.4465970695,
0.0444579571,
-0.2304379493,
-0.0465746261,
-0.1818028241,
0.1161691174,
-0.3878480494,
-0.2718956172,
-1.0150651932,
0.7916464806,
0.4927384555,
0.8775038719,
0.394975692,
0.5203978419,
0.234542951,
0.7065854669,
-0.7082596421,
0.4247380793,
-0.1097408012,
-0.6248673797,
-0.1187065616,
-0.2569432557,
-0.5391482115,
0.0562897064,
-0.0224025417,
-1.0388152599,
0.382388562,
0.1436351091,
-0.0984585732,
0.5264542103,
-0.3677829802,
0.8857701421,
-0.6919801235,
-0.4738509655,
-0.2484928966,
-0.7310760617,
0.3225544393,
-0.0279545188,
0.4458637238,
-0.6475763917,
0.0002455005,
0.7350608706,
-0.2638207972,
0.8660377264,
-0.2618589699,
-0.4741024673,
0.1233439147,
0.1475035548,
0.3854860663,
-0.2764970362,
-0.3602023721,
0.1815090179,
0.1017557234,
-0.3286999166,
-0.321510762,
0.8892782927,
-0.8440949917,
-0.7537688017,
-0.495845437,
-0.5079886913,
-0.0295455195,
0.014066102,
0.1342809349,
0.1523128897,
-0.4622715414,
0.029250009,
0.4901262224,
-0.3654992878,
0.4600664377,
0.4877611697,
-0.5067768693,
-0.16091308,
0.846843183,
-0.0169209149,
0.5312033892,
-0.0163413044,
0.1476958692,
-0.2618676722,
0.071386449,
-0.1258984804,
0.5585666895,
-0.8494284749,
-0.1393242329,
-0.5417786837,
0.044109989,
-0.2222275585,
-0.5210174918,
-0.6405426264,
-0.0563223101,
-0.3368110061,
0.074344568,
0.3987342119,
1.0752809048,
0.2132161409,
0.463527739,
-0.6743988991,
-0.0950270742,
0.057811182,
0.5610541105,
-0.3994853497,
-0.5173934698,
-0.0307050124,
0.2196661979,
-0.3767794073,
-1.3616605997,
0.1719810516,
-0.0385313109,
0.1630508602,
0.7091460228,
0.0911631063,
0.3916694522,
-0.3519791961,
0.7667681575,
0.2384381592,
-1.1191819906,
0.4383655787,
-0.5420916677,
0.1277667284,
0.4661147296,
0.5512514114,
-0.9389868379,
-0.7985374331,
-0.5749146938,
-0.2403745353,
0.7455769777,
0.1176227257,
0.347674787,
-0.3597061038,
0.139350757,
-0.1526498795,
-0.0013403788,
-0.7814164162,
-0.2774041891,
-0.4654014707,
-0.6666796803,
0.0365463644,
-0.3691764176,
-0.2574880123,
0.0972707719,
0.5871931911,
0.0656920224,
0.0343980864,
0.0317275375,
0.2616022229,
-0.4545165896,
0.4919131696,
0.6391478777,
0.7013270259,
-0.1532617509,
0.2594210505,
-0.2206871957,
-0.1278277189,
0.4392854869,
-0.2291849852,
-0.0125670675,
-0.0504285134,
0.0522149131,
0.8344482183,
0.0330011882,
-0.4054482281,
0.6360633373,
-0.0091049392,
0.2361816764,
-0.2140318006,
-0.1068781242,
0.4909248948,
0.5325164795,
0.0782449394,
-0.0371138118,
-0.0228511095,
-0.6878418922,
-0.1409064531,
0.762912035,
-0.8593372107,
-0.5137344003,
0.5013028383,
0.147895202,
-0.6839200258,
0.4314951003,
0.0570340864,
-0.8236718178,
0.5102866888,
0.3664919436,
0.8029667735,
-0.7238855958,
0.3849823177,
0.2678773999,
0.353736937,
0.0748482645,
0.4974564016,
0.5235155821,
-1.0983351469,
-0.146355927,
-0.7456401587,
-0.3079672456,
-0.2187033743,
-0.8156583309,
0.2759877741,
-0.3903837502,
-0.4892995059,
-0.0917351395,
-0.2466104329,
-0.3681806028,
0.3020855188,
0.537422061,
0.3289669752,
-0.9940020442,
0.7167183161,
0.8019016981,
-0.2797705829,
-0.8458716273,
0.1033656299,
0.3220337033,
-0.5898497701,
0.5706648827,
0.1864235103,
-0.5281188488,
-0.1230563596,
-0.5906586051,
-0.7789878845,
0.4968265891,
0.2956678569,
-0.6586485505,
0.0266901609,
0.3488435447,
0.6436549425,
-0.6115261316,
0.0339945741,
0.3214010894,
0.339432478,
-0.284347564,
-0.7508926392,
0.0377627164,
-0.3639520109,
0.0327227861,
0.5427801609,
-0.8763380647,
0.8093791008,
0.0471757576,
-0.1415137798,
-0.594568193,
0.375595361,
0.3141501248,
0.07267607,
0.5869029164,
0.3221923113,
0.6364423037,
-0.1039615944,
1.0783622265,
-0.556650281,
0.4868151844,
0.8113644123,
-0.3651016653,
0.6638092995,
0.6611710787,
0.0398994535,
0.5752292871,
0.5178225636,
0.2165688425,
0.3849533796,
0.184409976,
-0.1438238025,
-0.2309194356,
-0.5653879642,
-0.3010068834,
0.4123895466,
0.4658284485,
-0.635797143,
0.1998090744,
-0.2544454336,
0.0177826378,
0.296086818,
-0.325933665,
0.5960826874,
0.2507287562,
-0.4818024039,
0.3270476162,
-0.054164622,
0.5270577073,
-0.3540123105,
0.1327582449,
-0.1690616906,
-0.0168352928,
-0.4514120519,
-1.1481262445,
0.5588222146,
0.1029898822,
-0.0909488574,
-0.2958426774,
0.573086679,
-0.4638633132,
-0.3988665938,
0.7062092423,
0.2805796266,
0.0190128796,
0.2214050591,
-0.8422213793,
0.4517536461,
0.0988080055,
-0.5194215178,
-0.0057802242,
0.3234958351,
-0.0838782862,
0.4874886274,
0.2828727663,
-0.0241421852,
-0.0496861599,
0.1985031068,
0.6753626466,
-0.9333304167,
-0.0395492166,
-1.1540045738,
0.6469907165,
-0.2284200042,
-0.2428088784,
0.476154834,
0.3634299636,
0.6391559243,
0.3268102705,
0.598736465,
-0.0025550083,
0.3872357905,
-0.3412173986,
0.8613383174,
-0.6259846687,
0.1670661569,
-0.5832776427,
-1.0665832758,
0.0066717099,
0.9285225272,
-0.6766796112,
0.0763726905,
0.5824798942,
0.6388408542,
0.0260432884,
0.3023239076,
0.2211516649,
0.3524014652,
0.2512082756,
0.4044845104,
1.3138638735,
-0.0452004634,
0.1059759632,
-0.2593064904,
0.021743916,
-0.0477093756,
-0.8224799633,
-0.7339747548,
-0.5570432544,
-0.3320656121,
-0.4912794828,
-0.1241575852,
1.0664278269,
0.2984219193,
-0.8029547334,
-0.3755198717,
0.0056154397,
0.3084586859,
0.3144958615,
-0.2659889758,
0.3084751666,
0.0852733478,
-0.7807247043,
-0.1724012494,
0.5408107042,
-0.0450186282,
-0.2862107456,
-0.1318949014,
-0.3401273787,
0.5420212746,
0.3900227845,
-0.0304203834,
-1.2203024626,
-0.8290618658,
0.2011805326,
-0.7018011808,
0.1984320432,
0.7404934168,
-0.1932469159,
0.3532261252,
0.2914837897,
0.1624318957,
-0.2730785608,
0.3228891492,
0.6707413197,
-0.2840749621,
0.0450179651,
0.4555828571,
0.5230309963,
0.4815184772,
-0.4004239738,
0.2812599242,
-0.0269767363,
-0.8204664588,
-0.7199893594,
0.5218869448,
-1.0014306307,
-0.0458790809,
1.1995440722,
0.0507295132,
-0.0500659384,
0.248923704,
-0.2708498538,
0.3871718645,
-0.4848983288,
0.6431484222,
0.9007541537,
-0.1333075762,
-0.2754267454,
-0.5127677321,
0.4594272375,
0.7308802009,
-0.6390146613,
0.2547462881,
0.711009264,
0.1969817132,
0.1439873427,
0.529620111,
-0.0717869624,
-0.1445354223,
-0.4485494196,
0.3076019883,
0.6723681092,
0.0893741176,
-0.455666095,
-0.0689136386,
-0.0216146577,
0.4127141535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11111v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11111v1
|
Language Models as Science Tutors
| 2024-02-16T22:24:13 | 2024-02-16T22:24:13 |
Alexis Chevalier, Jiayi Geng, Alexander Wettig, Howard Chen, Sebastian Mizera, Toni Annala, Max Jameson Aragon, Arturo Rodríguez Fanlo, Simon Frieder, Simon Machado, Akshara Prabhakar, Ellie Thieu, Jiachen T. Wang, Zirui Wang, Xindi Wu, Mengzhou Xia, Wenhan Jia, Jiatong Yu, Jun-Jie Zhu, Zhiyong Jason Ren, Sanjeev Arora, Danqi Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
NLP has recently made exciting progress toward training language models (LMs)
with strong scientific problem-solving skills. However, model development has
not focused on real-life use-cases of LMs for science, including applications
in education that require processing long scientific documents. To address
this, we introduce TutorEval and TutorChat. TutorEval is a diverse
question-answering benchmark consisting of questions about long chapters from
STEM textbooks, written by experts. TutorEval helps measure real-life usability
of LMs as scientific assistants, and it is the first benchmark combining long
contexts, free-form generation, and multi-disciplinary scientific knowledge.
Moreover, we show that fine-tuning base models with existing dialogue datasets
leads to poor performance on TutorEval. Therefore, we create TutorChat, a
dataset of 80,000 long synthetic dialogues about textbooks. We use TutorChat to
fine-tune Llemma models with 7B and 34B parameters. These LM tutors specialized
in math have a 32K-token context window, and they excel at TutorEval while
performing strongly on GSM8K and MATH. Our datasets build on open-source
materials, and we release our models, data, and evaluations.
|
[
-0.1219783053,
-0.571515739,
0.3897884488,
0.2470276505,
-0.0850395933,
0.2828499377,
-0.3556719124,
-0.4115327299,
-0.0480633564,
0.4305787385,
-0.5123935938,
-0.5418994427,
-0.2459492534,
0.3627319336,
-0.3741458654,
1.0263644457,
0.1730056256,
0.4280471504,
-0.675411582,
0.0186687186,
-0.2104571015,
-0.3408358693,
-0.642070353,
-0.1584508121,
0.4365619123,
0.2720241249,
0.5393338203,
0.5824128985,
0.485164851,
0.1944231838,
-0.3426943123,
0.2076426893,
-0.3548572063,
0.4530282915,
-0.4082346261,
-0.6068673134,
-0.3166717291,
-0.152271539,
0.5592870116,
1.0401513577,
-0.0337639041,
0.059268821,
-0.0541902296,
0.5641431808,
-0.1983622909,
0.4646781683,
-0.5001990199,
-0.1605003476,
-0.0363746248,
0.0773341507,
-0.5440497994,
-0.379448235,
0.4355779588,
-0.6484533548,
0.3812138736,
0.2295656502,
0.4704400003,
0.2491392493,
-0.2826373577,
-0.4260415137,
-0.5385617614,
0.9374737144,
-0.9611278176,
0.3639872372,
0.4490282834,
0.5206451416,
-0.423766911,
-0.6806611419,
-0.3603962362,
-0.3284851611,
-0.0176871158,
0.0238497835,
-0.0271079205,
-0.0090807276,
0.2432737052,
0.0275135785,
-0.5576148033,
0.156927228,
-0.8109488487,
-0.1120411158,
0.5259494185,
0.1822243482,
0.1288580149,
-0.388364464,
-0.081793718,
-0.1216921583,
-0.7328060269,
0.0606573001,
0.0793639719,
0.7852923274,
0.0424330123,
0.7071430683,
0.0714529306,
0.6854192615,
-0.4083918929,
-0.1172127053,
-0.1142538711,
-0.5250623822,
0.1134049371,
0.0662824512,
0.616204381,
0.3575505316,
0.410556972,
-0.0921210349,
0.0599347018,
-0.1538817286,
0.0460744835,
-1.0964616537,
-0.2764345407,
0.1975115091,
-0.0186070446,
-0.1120711416,
-0.3825565279,
-0.8228324056,
-0.4876461625,
-0.399700284,
-0.0370526575,
-0.3728072345,
-0.1274924129,
0.2760230303,
0.2565429211,
-0.2493630201,
0.2742677927,
-0.955915153,
0.4781134129,
0.8501935005,
1.0064382553,
-0.2138275206,
-0.2316733748,
-0.193765983,
-0.184301734,
-0.2994531095,
0.6796161532,
-0.3629192114,
-0.5828050971,
-0.0158100594,
0.0846695602,
-0.028586952,
-0.4289945662,
0.4143264294,
-0.4103123248,
0.4421480298,
-0.0316330045,
-0.7910319567,
0.0109522268,
0.0118627287,
-0.4279995263,
1.0265265703,
0.0438025482,
-0.5932722688,
0.007262405,
-0.8823415637,
-0.030328257,
0.1397810429,
0.0388632938,
-0.2007862926,
-0.1014031246,
0.1741015613,
0.5772337914,
-0.4313512146,
0.6022357345,
-0.1115000546,
-0.112791039,
0.1209763959,
-0.3919449151,
0.5533456802,
0.1976598799,
0.0717669129,
0.1375576109,
-0.8608474135,
0.0120718805,
-0.0035015903,
-0.0243813824,
-0.4912306964,
0.3130544722,
0.0484884381,
-0.0123147359,
0.1814633757,
-0.780338645,
0.3369042873,
-0.7093948126,
0.7161901593,
0.4984203577,
-0.2800353467,
0.1848555505,
-0.103528358,
0.4258260429,
-0.2574557364,
-0.21608527,
-0.4862244427,
-0.5016559362,
-0.6194851995,
-0.1992826164,
0.2403005511,
0.2700260878,
-0.4537115097,
0.1859820038,
-0.2446095347,
-0.7803768516,
-0.6967898011,
0.1031950042,
0.3216970563,
0.9317740798,
0.6481705308,
0.0911436081,
-0.5175168514,
-0.8611568809,
-0.3573422432,
-0.1008900702,
-0.2394686043,
0.3936245739,
0.5786942244,
0.0610023178,
1.1919075251,
-0.5183953047,
0.0053022504,
-0.0008065575,
-0.1028100252,
0.3514147699,
0.3706709445,
0.5823938251,
-0.5012559295,
-0.5012513995,
-0.1162018925,
-0.6869226098,
-0.0985555798,
0.2952792943,
0.1277814806,
0.2038677931,
0.5808867812,
-0.6734362841,
0.2378058583,
0.5564069748,
-0.3346695602,
0.7728539705,
-0.1296899617,
-0.1103307903,
-1.316552043,
0.0717070997,
0.1119078994,
-0.2149722576,
-0.6370708942,
-0.026527537,
0.0279209856,
-0.5448872447,
-0.6647496819,
0.8370838165,
-0.2253664732,
-0.1310296506,
-0.3602728248,
0.2359069437,
-0.0553394444,
0.1593633592,
0.1907860339,
0.9550121427,
0.5658667684,
-0.3287140429,
0.4178088903,
0.1971350908,
-0.5658340454,
0.2547146976,
-1.0411918163,
-0.0140775293,
-0.0328893475,
0.3824821413,
-0.7071928978,
-0.2339242399,
-0.1609059572,
-0.1322648674,
0.0197757185,
-0.1503937095,
-0.4758019745,
-0.3030174971,
-0.0103394594,
0.330299288,
0.3292325437,
-0.6250829697,
0.309301734,
0.0327243358,
-0.7432098985,
-0.6062660813,
-0.2416959107,
0.0201958884,
0.0882518366,
-0.5732955933,
0.2743694186,
-0.2782074511,
-0.1920368373,
0.1013714224,
-0.1418360174,
-0.0513874255,
0.0108370287,
0.2541353703,
0.3715161681,
-0.4735897183,
0.353653729,
0.1573449969,
-0.0992153659,
0.1907862127,
-0.0831374153,
0.5145046711,
-0.4765906036,
-0.3959603608,
-0.2660635412,
0.2775883675,
0.5874900222,
-0.0323492326,
0.7052439451,
0.023563372,
-0.2284898162,
-0.1824342757,
-0.310539782,
-0.5190205574,
-0.4658876956,
0.5920539498,
-0.1615473181,
-1.0457222462,
0.4992495775,
-0.0004348558,
0.4775047302,
0.2862222493,
0.4203266799,
-0.0647268221,
1.0038353205,
0.4964855611,
0.0759265497,
0.1742928922,
-0.1228409931,
0.3144865036,
-0.5931568146,
-0.2523452342,
-0.6461916566,
0.1601528525,
-0.3462883234,
-0.4209813178,
0.2139621675,
0.1428014338,
-0.2175220102,
0.4895136058,
-0.6440326571,
0.8415638208,
0.3334450722,
-0.3120328188,
0.3029618263,
-0.0369342603,
-0.2041397095,
-0.3429230452,
-0.642310679,
-0.7192193866,
1.1089310646,
0.363055259,
0.7051112652,
-0.1697609425,
0.2725015581,
-0.1475319415,
0.3147529364,
-0.7538708448,
0.6633114815,
-0.1026027352,
-0.6335356832,
-0.374045223,
-0.3443197608,
-0.8432384133,
0.3291268647,
0.0246159416,
-0.5070303679,
-0.2219407707,
0.1286082417,
-0.2608722448,
0.2198291868,
-0.583771348,
0.7861367464,
-0.2673666179,
-0.4056738615,
-0.2054289132,
-0.7057484388,
0.2298238873,
-0.0577943847,
0.3329728842,
-0.302013278,
0.1922333986,
0.7814812064,
-0.3607177138,
1.0065323114,
-0.0769670159,
0.0128746917,
0.1694394946,
0.2042862326,
0.0474151708,
0.1074615121,
-0.2446873635,
0.0088713504,
0.4814822376,
-0.5175473094,
-0.6652716398,
0.9134072661,
-0.8102939725,
-0.8113334775,
-0.494916141,
-0.7936829329,
-0.2787097394,
0.1113500968,
-0.2474886775,
0.2914605439,
-0.0616321489,
0.4804522991,
0.3742986619,
-0.0685541406,
0.3375309706,
0.6950935125,
-0.4535598457,
-0.116741769,
0.8611064553,
-0.0185940675,
0.4101295471,
0.0435488448,
0.3718357086,
-0.3387855291,
-0.3965097666,
-0.2829416394,
0.4219121635,
-0.6537632346,
-0.1797013879,
-0.5322715044,
-0.4907289445,
-0.5798837543,
-0.0462169349,
-0.5098174214,
-0.7140870094,
-0.5039055347,
-0.18373622,
0.5836518407,
0.5548655987,
0.1046776548,
0.1819764078,
-0.6993768811,
-0.0359103754,
0.1943557113,
0.1306076646,
-0.0460310653,
-0.4808708429,
-0.2775102258,
0.2128732502,
-0.1749945581,
-0.5725045204,
0.6003338099,
0.3374545574,
0.2732708156,
0.1799660772,
-0.088388361,
0.5111781955,
-0.6859352589,
0.8877153993,
0.0229643621,
-0.6997651458,
0.4727825522,
-0.3113803864,
0.069893226,
0.3982774615,
0.738846004,
-0.6398528218,
-0.3548575044,
-0.2623093724,
-0.7071174383,
0.507871151,
-0.1388592869,
0.2074838728,
0.1022607982,
0.4379507005,
0.3207400441,
0.2331004441,
-0.4977000952,
0.0532835834,
-0.6721992493,
-0.3666565418,
-0.2574245334,
-0.0627655089,
-0.1915141195,
-0.4555623233,
0.49483338,
-0.3208279312,
-0.2199166417,
0.0055689802,
0.0313495286,
0.1369254887,
0.3149790168,
0.8948197961,
0.8978827596,
-0.3801442087,
0.0919514373,
-0.0858425647,
-0.4375298023,
-0.0896575674,
0.3016287088,
-0.0354816727,
0.0207990538,
0.3181203902,
0.6698514223,
0.41647017,
-0.9197641611,
0.2811348736,
0.0411134101,
-0.2237375677,
-0.1859087646,
0.1573068351,
0.5211770535,
-0.0419816934,
0.5390907526,
-0.0726948828,
-0.2351238877,
-0.2819538414,
0.0464304537,
0.3379485309,
-0.2256908566,
-0.5650658011,
0.6541925073,
0.3044519424,
-0.5215875506,
0.5609401464,
0.2622414827,
-0.3814215362,
0.7286663651,
0.8649222851,
0.3536444008,
-0.2750656605,
0.2564131916,
0.3793332577,
-0.0357485861,
-0.0774116814,
0.0522857569,
0.0829500481,
-0.5005060434,
-0.5707851648,
-0.6562861204,
-0.8999235034,
0.1524271369,
-0.5853518248,
0.3269298375,
-0.3718129098,
0.0798888952,
0.3335476518,
0.0884998292,
-0.3825077116,
-0.031363979,
-0.5064168572,
0.9611634612,
-0.8565964103,
0.6584439874,
0.4823056459,
-0.1640218645,
-0.4938398004,
-0.7700295448,
-0.0310116988,
-0.6613034606,
0.9366048574,
0.1113864705,
0.0906468257,
0.1074934676,
-0.7206197977,
-0.7787621021,
0.9305233359,
0.3551359773,
-0.7441110611,
-0.2778712809,
0.2158925533,
0.9131680727,
-0.4580118656,
0.3832511306,
0.312897861,
0.1314644665,
0.0370781012,
-0.9422675967,
-0.2056762129,
-0.2205066085,
-0.291955173,
-0.1179453358,
-0.4764403999,
0.8594552279,
-0.2022639662,
-0.0342967995,
0.2765145302,
0.6986423731,
0.5737003684,
0.3727360368,
0.1857179254,
0.2097659856,
0.7064262033,
-0.0542486385,
0.8615708947,
-0.4846768677,
0.328601867,
0.9932129979,
-0.393225342,
0.8769746423,
0.6112205982,
-0.2754918337,
0.4705583155,
0.6797013283,
-0.1306914836,
0.3780639768,
0.4438625574,
-0.3027496636,
-0.1904965043,
-0.3414949775,
-0.4129995406,
0.0321918912,
0.6192613244,
-0.030644292,
-0.4317664802,
0.229599461,
-0.0190210119,
0.37552163,
-0.053218089,
0.32004565,
0.3556001484,
-0.5708758235,
0.4811059535,
-0.0969471931,
0.4817836881,
-0.5282905102,
-0.0496184193,
-0.320440203,
-0.0003494174,
-0.1140142828,
-0.7164666653,
0.111025326,
0.1922619343,
-0.272192359,
-0.1458821446,
0.4706958532,
-0.665029645,
-0.559992969,
0.0042706635,
0.4786765575,
0.5134580731,
0.326151073,
-0.5866955519,
-0.2591833472,
-0.2856364846,
-0.2993445396,
0.3660201132,
-0.0197202433,
-0.2061231732,
1.1719868183,
0.9387819767,
0.3369084001,
0.0638190731,
0.1278831363,
0.8830373287,
-0.5107922554,
-0.1432714909,
-0.6562824845,
0.2256506532,
-0.0052508516,
-0.351482898,
0.7855735421,
0.7176243067,
0.665455997,
-0.1484770775,
0.5672689676,
0.425074935,
1.0318325758,
-0.3819968402,
0.7579713464,
-0.3491213322,
0.2778070569,
-0.0595767014,
-0.9083108902,
-0.5013161302,
0.5676845312,
-0.2428192198,
-0.176517278,
0.6906369328,
0.8620046377,
-0.0469249412,
0.3653336465,
0.2088654786,
0.0822490901,
0.6961084008,
0.2878441811,
0.9243732095,
-0.1863425225,
0.4149901569,
-0.2159541398,
0.0913959742,
-0.2894838154,
-0.9333841205,
-1.2556880713,
-0.4790506661,
-0.2175110728,
-0.1396972388,
0.16723755,
1.0258563757,
0.7014222741,
-0.8350613117,
-0.307277441,
-0.2138161659,
0.0438257121,
0.1613586247,
-0.2694503963,
0.6768112183,
-0.377483964,
-0.8696906567,
0.9224231839,
0.0159748103,
0.2147080898,
-0.6198953986,
0.1496070474,
0.1175843328,
0.2160520554,
0.5067412257,
0.5697461367,
-0.7488333583,
-0.2769660652,
0.501932025,
-0.0995188653,
-0.1043855399,
0.7876250744,
-0.7598105073,
0.5441232324,
0.2959726751,
0.7011271715,
0.5503172278,
-0.0528275333,
0.5297324657,
-0.6645521522,
0.1924439371,
0.6187970638,
0.1695608348,
0.5591776967,
0.1158018559,
0.5029483438,
0.0706645846,
-0.8411899805,
-1.2910320759,
0.0036623527,
-0.7801495194,
-0.3256004453,
0.7662866116,
-0.2337219268,
-0.2370286882,
-0.0339641906,
-0.1776394844,
-0.0683259964,
-0.3957379162,
0.7701846957,
0.9954212308,
-0.1492372453,
-0.1851876527,
-0.7137506008,
0.6259809136,
0.795131743,
-0.753590107,
0.1943044513,
0.3141036928,
0.3134908974,
0.3891305923,
0.1248041093,
0.1151479408,
0.1425415426,
-0.2337134928,
0.0026745724,
-0.4293812513,
-0.4209083617,
0.0028641734,
0.0651181191,
-0.0442779064,
0.3349723816
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11100v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11100v2
|
When LLMs Meet Cunning Texts: A Fallacy Understanding Benchmark for Large Language Models
| 2024-02-16T22:12:53 | 2024-06-09T17:55:05 |
Yinghui Li, Qingyu Zhou, Yuanzhen Luo, Shirong Ma, Yangning Li, Hai-Tao Zheng, Xuming Hu, Philip S. Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recently, Large Language Models (LLMs) make remarkable evolutions in language
understanding and generation. Following this, various benchmarks for measuring
all kinds of capabilities of LLMs have sprung up. In this paper, we challenge
the reasoning and understanding abilities of LLMs by proposing a FaLlacy
Understanding Benchmark (FLUB) containing cunning texts that are easy for
humans to understand but difficult for models to grasp. Specifically, the
cunning texts that FLUB focuses on mainly consist of the tricky, humorous, and
misleading texts collected from the real internet environment. And we design
three tasks with increasing difficulty in the FLUB benchmark to evaluate the
fallacy understanding ability of LLMs. Based on FLUB, we investigate the
performance of multiple representative and advanced LLMs, reflecting our FLUB
is challenging and worthy of more future study. Interesting discoveries and
valuable insights are achieved in our extensive experiments and detailed
analyses. We hope that our benchmark can encourage the community to improve
LLMs' ability to understand fallacies. Our data and codes are available at
https://github.com/THUKElab/FLUB.
|
[
-0.1978012621,
-0.679715991,
0.6733087301,
0.328351438,
-0.2575079799,
0.2224536538,
-0.2343562394,
-0.3530595005,
-0.2908472121,
0.6211650372,
-0.7425686717,
-0.4268074334,
-0.8446561694,
0.3386139274,
-0.4813242555,
0.810636282,
-0.1565600783,
0.0866053477,
-0.324080795,
0.0059001581,
-0.3313855529,
-0.4376772344,
-0.3979362249,
-0.4836702645,
0.4941423833,
0.3780377209,
0.7305451035,
0.3906404972,
0.6697319746,
0.4010382295,
-0.1123589203,
0.4563826323,
-0.815417707,
-0.0890455097,
-0.2355967313,
-0.8690200448,
-0.2373160273,
-0.0973431468,
0.4718856812,
0.6403908134,
-0.1828097552,
-0.0188008714,
-0.0459062383,
0.7953609824,
-0.6376388073,
0.039024625,
-1.0678510666,
-0.1410453171,
-0.4251980782,
0.0781262591,
-0.5756574273,
-0.285294205,
-0.1726517528,
-0.4556207359,
0.1932117343,
0.1660535783,
0.8982719779,
0.4009152651,
-0.4911797047,
-0.4590361714,
-0.3431707919,
0.9082041979,
-0.7360070944,
0.3043958843,
0.0665041208,
0.3909131587,
-0.6272756457,
-0.6483134627,
-0.5277280807,
-0.1767899841,
-0.0235597137,
-0.1102641821,
-0.2416096032,
-0.2141818702,
0.2522070408,
0.2488969713,
-0.5476848483,
0.0043937485,
0.0450788662,
-0.1678809226,
0.5965759158,
0.2480668873,
0.1320196092,
-0.28365466,
-0.5185611248,
0.1330532283,
-0.5775189996,
-0.1427406818,
0.5237085223,
0.0274341255,
-0.0315147825,
0.2946440876,
0.1104478091,
0.5054730773,
-0.1752560884,
-0.3385587633,
0.3647423983,
-0.2332660109,
-0.1865156144,
-0.2273702174,
0.6079493165,
0.2354447395,
0.7436708212,
-0.1906651109,
-0.3338549137,
0.0047815726,
0.2570589781,
-0.4379490614,
-0.1343536079,
0.0773594677,
-0.3132803142,
-0.3954375386,
-0.1662197709,
-0.5538150072,
-0.7084644437,
0.1181102023,
0.5457801223,
-0.7501788735,
-0.3403621912,
0.4162165523,
-0.2853352726,
0.2290953994,
0.4988300204,
-0.6632080078,
0.5311632156,
0.996630311,
0.6616678834,
-0.3367744684,
-0.5728151798,
-0.265240401,
0.2411167622,
-0.1767827272,
1.0037225485,
-0.3319190741,
-0.2390476614,
-0.2847111225,
-0.2118296772,
-0.3539192379,
-0.7559064627,
0.8557159901,
-0.3453524113,
-0.0191924497,
-0.1811461598,
-0.520098269,
-0.314977169,
0.4303395748,
-0.6895789504,
0.8496130705,
-0.0656184107,
-0.9170997739,
0.2108052671,
-0.3711092472,
-0.5131322145,
0.0564928986,
-0.1276866794,
-0.2210653424,
0.2200865448,
0.1564062685,
0.4628854394,
-0.5051422119,
0.4003069997,
-0.373929292,
-0.4732114971,
0.7268336415,
-0.8741747737,
0.6910349727,
0.1308278888,
-0.370953232,
-0.4702960551,
-0.5862635374,
-0.0471296087,
0.4416629374,
-0.4963494539,
-0.3984372318,
0.2879478335,
-0.0716237724,
-0.0094758803,
0.4796169996,
-0.1660759747,
0.0905238092,
-0.4135748744,
0.4737216234,
0.915751338,
-0.3111203909,
-0.1932824552,
-0.5256338716,
0.2437321097,
0.0560041927,
-0.0479372852,
-0.0126974527,
-0.3109741211,
-0.6701719165,
-0.2997052372,
0.304720521,
0.4945114553,
-0.6573435068,
0.2240420133,
-0.6724666953,
-0.4905765355,
-0.5797236562,
0.5272713304,
0.6086578369,
0.3189438879,
0.1921063662,
-0.0144462334,
-0.0854553133,
-1.0418075323,
-0.9448342323,
-0.3008513749,
-0.148612991,
0.3839580417,
0.7081651688,
-0.0527868606,
0.6867110729,
-0.3764873147,
-0.1075174734,
-0.4016561806,
0.3537648916,
0.3130527735,
0.1497154683,
0.4003638923,
-1.0285967588,
-0.2706696987,
-0.2240015268,
-0.5964406729,
-0.3036769927,
-0.0442631915,
0.1407556981,
0.2630613148,
0.3599604368,
-0.5608102083,
0.1264563352,
0.4295043349,
-0.3295083046,
0.711376071,
0.1173931509,
0.3869627118,
-0.8684079051,
-0.0683085993,
-0.0481006913,
-0.4223393202,
-0.4627400935,
0.1560323685,
0.1811226904,
0.5750662088,
-0.662771523,
0.4527468681,
-0.4680088758,
0.0348316953,
0.0564482249,
0.3389918804,
0.0206540115,
0.2680879235,
-0.1626541615,
0.6494885087,
0.1613792479,
-0.327907294,
0.4703614414,
-0.0348242298,
-0.454626739,
0.7476279736,
-0.3434052467,
0.0301556196,
-0.0075914557,
0.1488034278,
-1.140556097,
-0.3331650496,
0.0395563953,
-0.512018919,
0.155682072,
-0.1145037413,
-0.8422628641,
-0.2872769833,
-0.3258767128,
0.2471161783,
0.4349884391,
-0.6009851098,
0.5364075899,
0.1902298778,
0.3052932322,
-0.9494558573,
-1.0023733377,
0.2880781889,
-0.4876230359,
-0.8732049465,
0.2735254765,
-0.2561402023,
-0.4558674693,
-0.2428281456,
-0.2154773921,
-0.010018683,
0.2222694159,
-0.0496815629,
-0.2419969887,
-0.3044816852,
0.0096601462,
-0.3131446838,
-0.000003291,
0.2935121357,
0.126276508,
0.3903615177,
-0.2696168721,
-0.5028852224,
-0.0737101138,
-0.0393754207,
0.5240800381,
0.4179242849,
0.5198867321,
0.2171073109,
-0.4654255211,
-0.4982399046,
-0.8365463018,
-0.0134456195,
-0.5670539737,
0.3939600587,
-0.736561656,
-0.3795287311,
0.4739619493,
-0.3389008343,
0.2253015488,
0.2358776629,
0.466432333,
-0.0454128236,
0.8751183152,
0.2653260827,
0.069939144,
-0.0751061291,
0.1714222133,
0.0015289002,
-0.3916661143,
-0.2160467505,
-0.5525466204,
-0.3986122906,
-0.364944607,
-0.4768911898,
0.1970448643,
0.2521103024,
0.0506482422,
0.2858273685,
-0.1246654615,
0.63932693,
0.1780137569,
0.0901498944,
0.6039094925,
0.0286644399,
-0.398948878,
-0.3090953529,
-0.4954194129,
-0.6563867331,
1.0149995089,
0.5039256215,
0.8719813824,
0.5744150877,
0.5379127264,
0.369091481,
0.220623672,
-0.6872918606,
0.8813929558,
-0.3322726488,
-0.7167420387,
0.0492451228,
-0.6145735979,
-0.8572250009,
0.3468811214,
0.0039092116,
-0.8033061028,
-0.3051099181,
-0.0308717042,
0.2458258718,
0.4038851261,
-0.7902238369,
0.9343044758,
-0.4047259986,
-0.2788169682,
-0.3697743714,
-0.5120244026,
0.603764534,
-0.1275100261,
0.6237745881,
-0.2751376033,
-0.5327956676,
0.6608839631,
-0.3787676692,
0.8201698065,
0.1925115436,
-0.2379287332,
-0.0086390413,
0.2352597862,
0.4218967259,
-0.0048216172,
-0.4578059316,
0.2059896141,
-0.065670386,
-0.6235949993,
-0.5727101564,
0.6716379523,
-0.558133781,
-0.7149327993,
-0.4994845688,
-0.3780822158,
-0.3694141507,
0.2346534133,
0.15086101,
0.3343934715,
-0.2865840197,
0.0987738818,
0.6599382758,
0.0631033629,
0.4196280241,
0.7192792892,
-0.0036320842,
-0.2296376675,
0.8760060668,
0.0290515926,
0.3637761474,
0.4276716411,
0.0666880012,
-0.3262768984,
-0.9480259418,
-0.3873678148,
0.4691549838,
-1.162045598,
-0.1074995026,
-0.4236441255,
-0.2267589569,
-0.2321838588,
-0.0983818546,
-0.21940355,
-0.1726637334,
-0.1968617141,
0.2026168108,
0.2864015996,
0.8584547043,
-0.025458442,
0.3331564963,
-0.7407460213,
0.3314913809,
0.1028615907,
0.1840327531,
-0.107801266,
-0.7401838303,
0.0828778297,
-0.1605557054,
-0.4245836139,
-1.0878865719,
0.077540867,
0.011839103,
0.7513010502,
0.5636659265,
0.0782086924,
0.5608067513,
-0.4641732275,
0.6578673124,
0.1462273151,
-1.0395745039,
0.3029266,
-0.3127930462,
0.2972099781,
0.6038898826,
0.4628331065,
-0.3821618259,
-0.5054718256,
-0.625048399,
-0.6516334414,
0.6300221682,
0.3983565867,
0.2125100642,
0.0234060809,
0.4188757241,
0.4128430486,
0.3815898001,
-1.1062592268,
-0.2995245755,
0.3597535789,
-0.3760923147,
-0.0045157545,
-0.1354315132,
-0.0929393545,
0.1655722111,
0.5872118473,
-0.1788768172,
-0.1833537072,
-0.1489732862,
-0.4186667204,
-0.0477535538,
0.2535451651,
0.3754355609,
0.8301234841,
-0.0273727011,
0.3560261726,
0.5068125129,
-0.6475754976,
0.0243147314,
0.1085748076,
0.1329718381,
-0.0952691063,
0.8297337294,
0.3516872227,
0.5578938723,
-0.9858257174,
0.662114501,
-0.164591074,
-0.363756448,
-0.1866590828,
0.3453881443,
0.4379850924,
0.1386347264,
0.5716201067,
0.1016506478,
0.0480879769,
-0.4123924375,
0.1266118139,
0.5254052877,
0.0450891331,
-0.0620620847,
0.3673906028,
0.2905403078,
-0.5484037399,
0.239964664,
-0.3008395135,
-0.6102182865,
0.6138869524,
0.4974611104,
0.5667853951,
0.028422961,
0.1991912276,
-0.1084596589,
0.6706112623,
-0.1610010862,
0.3331208825,
0.188280344,
-0.7231041193,
-0.3097748756,
-0.56861341,
-0.5445019007,
0.4353023469,
-0.1483658403,
0.6685132384,
-0.3047435284,
0.1801777184,
0.2009582222,
0.2491623759,
-0.4238078296,
0.0636599585,
0.1135838926,
1.0632312298,
-0.5917018056,
0.594117105,
0.5584592819,
-0.0051713842,
-0.3894691467,
0.3882646263,
0.3397622108,
-1.014765501,
0.3908179998,
0.4759123027,
-0.4249212444,
-0.0231992621,
-0.7385208607,
-0.4392030537,
0.7203641534,
0.6826981902,
-0.618309021,
-0.067471534,
0.3523160517,
0.3377578557,
-0.1978193671,
0.41380319,
0.7947422862,
0.7936594486,
0.1494007111,
-0.8351880908,
0.2992201447,
-0.1131873578,
-0.4825155735,
0.1828732342,
-0.9031915069,
0.8590756655,
-0.2677877247,
-0.2260474265,
0.0790310353,
0.4635815918,
0.3996004462,
0.5591983199,
0.8437568545,
0.4991053045,
0.6096032858,
-0.1874551922,
0.550485909,
0.1382278353,
0.1929846853,
0.7959706187,
-0.1442348063,
0.8683629036,
0.5045556426,
-0.3492637277,
0.4768767953,
0.6804189086,
-0.0286337491,
0.214866206,
0.563401401,
-0.158773616,
-0.6104894876,
0.2561797798,
-0.2027432621,
0.3937899172,
0.5903635621,
-0.0645488948,
-0.392441541,
-0.2505070865,
0.3196321726,
0.5333618522,
-0.0847676247,
0.6046125293,
0.2902650535,
-0.633743763,
0.8629519343,
0.1625688225,
0.9091112018,
-0.5297525525,
0.112343885,
-0.0998093486,
0.2666005492,
-0.1980525404,
-0.9198140502,
0.1219146699,
0.0461730883,
0.1653327793,
0.0480469726,
0.5588376522,
-0.0287666079,
-0.523229301,
0.5237751603,
0.4815397561,
0.5717937946,
0.1171177775,
-1.1345334053,
0.1841241121,
-0.0040387898,
-0.4866302013,
0.1475000978,
0.7197275758,
0.1488688737,
0.9079458117,
0.353677541,
-0.0340810344,
-0.1289915144,
-0.0561739095,
0.7355350852,
-0.7723972797,
-0.3888956904,
-1.0721555948,
0.263887018,
-0.2636228204,
-0.3893072307,
0.5808396339,
0.457208842,
0.6742672324,
0.1921094358,
0.722923696,
0.054663308,
0.5530498028,
-0.6832640171,
0.7421723604,
-0.9552826881,
0.5501541495,
-0.2313757986,
-0.6394299865,
-0.0845525116,
0.298392266,
-0.4604536593,
0.1699170917,
0.8097970486,
0.7622005343,
-0.3488036692,
0.1385402083,
0.4469000399,
0.5064617991,
0.1913167536,
1.1273798943,
0.9671526551,
-0.3831804097,
1.0562576056,
0.0206617154,
-0.1560439616,
-0.4422836304,
-1.1787832975,
-1.2884441614,
-0.3186247051,
-0.2256311029,
-0.400174588,
0.2772381306,
0.6006464958,
0.3191964626,
-0.5386086106,
-0.1757947206,
-0.2680310309,
0.693302989,
-0.1449290663,
-0.2538509071,
0.0454121195,
-0.240594402,
-0.9669884443,
0.4015940726,
0.0494696498,
0.0416791551,
-0.4361307025,
-0.1250350773,
-0.3047045767,
0.5097321272,
0.0484367274,
-0.0744883865,
-0.9572755098,
-0.1696283668,
-0.1972717792,
-0.2191798389,
-0.011248895,
0.6664843559,
-0.5961824059,
0.1064627692,
0.5788730383,
0.5336224437,
0.2619837224,
-0.0901244134,
0.4928653836,
-0.4882618785,
-0.2223743945,
0.0627312809,
0.2360155284,
0.5260749459,
-0.404337585,
0.510861516,
0.3842240572,
-0.3455245495,
-1.1397750378,
0.2973094881,
-0.6937304735,
-0.6980937719,
1.1552752256,
-0.3150328398,
-0.3160125315,
-0.3389275372,
-0.0441937298,
-0.1590517163,
-0.2386819124,
0.8230947256,
1.0468640327,
0.0902675167,
-0.0336948149,
-0.7528706789,
0.4946291447,
0.7086846828,
-0.7884854078,
0.2825112343,
0.3673666716,
0.5464566946,
0.0570092984,
0.4311675727,
-0.0106332349,
0.3515991569,
0.0318498425,
-0.4589326084,
0.0416986383,
-0.1762539297,
-0.0999925882,
0.3181218505,
0.0764233693,
0.1391437352
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15397v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15397v1
|
Regulating Large Language Models: A Roundtable Report
| 2024-02-16T21:49:17 | 2024-02-16T21:49:17 |
Gabriel Nicholas, Paul Friedl
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
On July 20, 2023, a group of 27 scholars and digital rights advocates with
expertise in law, computer science, political science, and other disciplines
gathered for the Large Language Models, Law and Policy Roundtable, co-hosted by
the NYU School of Law's Information Law Institute and the Center for Democracy
& Technology. The roundtable convened to discuss how law and policy can help
address some of the larger societal problems posed by large language models
(LLMs). The discussion focused on three policy topic areas in particular:
1. Truthfulness: What risks do LLMs pose in terms of generating mis- and
disinformation? How can these risks be mitigated from a technical and/or
regulatory perspective?
2. Privacy: What are the biggest privacy risks involved in the creation,
deployment, and use of LLMs? How can these risks be mitigated from a technical
and/or regulatory perspective?
3. Market concentration: What threats do LLMs pose concerning market/power
concentration? How can these risks be mitigated from a technical and/or
regulatory perspective?
In this paper, we provide a detailed summary of the day's proceedings. We
first recap what we deem to be the most important contributions made during the
issue framing discussions. We then provide a list of potential legal and
regulatory interventions generated during the brainstorming discussions.
|
[
-0.5016311407,
-0.7780785561,
0.7054674029,
0.0086518601,
0.1367241442,
0.1419664472,
-0.39876315,
-0.7907335162,
0.0321137793,
0.9547528625,
-0.0385622978,
-0.2163244635,
-0.7445917726,
-0.1502054483,
-0.7086840868,
0.927705884,
0.0560708009,
0.037174318,
-0.0603930503,
0.0672737435,
-0.397513032,
-0.7776796818,
-0.4355915487,
-0.0643063709,
0.5526280403,
0.1215650439,
0.7203201652,
0.4790928066,
0.5005210042,
0.414870739,
-0.465898782,
-0.2305341959,
-0.5294805169,
-0.033194989,
-0.1388658583,
-0.5075560212,
-0.4410876036,
0.2367753386,
0.7576186657,
0.8106833696,
-0.3558103144,
0.1287901998,
0.0526941679,
0.8187236786,
-0.4567855,
0.0266543292,
-0.3707533777,
0.1390535235,
-0.1981831789,
-0.0135530662,
-0.4707428813,
-0.5566686988,
0.0741172582,
-0.4065201879,
0.0157921165,
0.3767122924,
0.6221891642,
0.1061452553,
-0.5838194489,
-0.3467864692,
-0.8342729807,
0.8509302735,
-0.8587172031,
0.4372484088,
0.5480780602,
0.1920794249,
-0.3399504423,
-0.8036455512,
-0.684704423,
-0.2507962286,
0.2225540578,
-0.2076396942,
-0.4340600073,
0.0241795667,
0.4723489583,
0.3357101381,
-0.3292472064,
0.2560860217,
-0.858106792,
-0.3912116587,
0.8030571342,
0.1311500669,
0.1544262171,
0.2265084237,
0.1985480487,
0.2967173755,
-0.7988291979,
-0.4364509881,
0.7546558976,
0.2559743524,
-0.2217241824,
0.5184078813,
-0.0901681334,
0.7274808884,
-0.0364695154,
0.1086803004,
0.2372678965,
-0.4612467289,
0.0316192992,
0.244258821,
0.682253778,
0.3128406703,
0.2617285252,
0.1173686758,
-0.2612015903,
-0.5086861253,
0.4578358233,
-0.6301498413,
0.245017454,
0.2882533669,
-0.6541811824,
-0.2639909685,
0.179483667,
-0.9175831676,
-0.8324609399,
-0.7107614875,
0.1166503876,
0.318536222,
-0.4271512926,
0.2845318019,
-0.0585010536,
0.2199524343,
0.120175831,
-0.9248731732,
0.2903274894,
0.9288215041,
0.6776556969,
0.0528791472,
0.1784785539,
-0.2373791188,
0.2771664262,
-0.3165518045,
0.1326131672,
-0.3547949791,
-0.5329815149,
0.4125330448,
-0.1143914983,
0.3572490215,
-0.480054915,
0.1737366766,
-0.5343647003,
0.3841678798,
-0.5096985102,
-0.5349290371,
-0.1216828898,
0.3708582819,
-0.7828330994,
0.3439554572,
-0.4549732208,
-0.8300791979,
0.0487405732,
-0.9343430996,
-0.3192784786,
0.1020252705,
-0.4819509685,
0.0740372613,
0.0262638256,
-0.3177086115,
0.5044879913,
-0.3590537012,
0.6657253504,
-0.3808903396,
-0.0699282661,
0.5300630927,
-0.6134782434,
0.8226079345,
0.2102212906,
-0.4370107353,
0.4238934219,
-0.7348836064,
-0.1223781705,
0.1888120174,
-0.1578493863,
-0.1095853671,
-0.0270637218,
0.0354942977,
0.2125406265,
0.3123237491,
-0.479677856,
-0.0536574908,
-0.1723129004,
1.1435650587,
0.8723231554,
0.0439096242,
0.4448711872,
-0.3017188907,
0.3409058452,
-0.1012507752,
0.4752435386,
0.0620638169,
-0.3406843245,
-0.5116457939,
0.002310168,
0.4030406177,
0.1793283671,
-0.398614496,
0.2443740219,
-0.323192209,
-0.4594056606,
-0.3718112707,
-0.1598012,
0.0329735316,
0.0385646634,
-0.0130597576,
-0.1142669544,
-0.2947303057,
-0.9396823645,
-0.1077865064,
-0.1995095611,
0.3024352491,
0.1677326709,
0.5049283504,
-0.0423421897,
0.922065556,
-0.4034422636,
-0.1919027418,
-0.1236176416,
0.0525513776,
0.0277137533,
0.3291649222,
0.3013893068,
-0.9710559249,
-0.2791071236,
-0.1742791831,
-0.4402430654,
0.0196850505,
0.2131506056,
0.4840667844,
0.4080625772,
0.7888554335,
-0.5446008444,
0.3012097776,
0.543693006,
-0.1502181888,
0.610691011,
-0.3607974648,
0.0542141572,
-0.9933506846,
0.0032182604,
-0.0353893079,
-0.0822147951,
-0.701274395,
0.0178596117,
-0.2777043581,
-0.1807675362,
-0.6003767848,
0.5587082505,
-0.3478916287,
-0.2863557637,
-0.4740402699,
0.3549739122,
-0.2430592179,
-0.0754541084,
-0.3268391788,
0.9237132668,
0.3361365497,
-0.692004323,
0.4602037072,
0.1136858612,
-0.4560683072,
0.4912779331,
-0.554921031,
0.258862108,
-0.0167047549,
0.3346912563,
-0.3583950996,
-0.2687935531,
0.1449094713,
-0.2199154198,
0.2752479017,
0.2374411076,
-0.6580558419,
-0.4442399144,
-0.2746165097,
0.3913426101,
0.2160263509,
-0.0746304169,
0.3286374211,
1.2191274166,
-0.297477752,
-0.5311660767,
-0.7537387013,
0.5323622227,
-0.2611301243,
-0.4430719614,
0.1389824152,
-0.1831133962,
-0.6895899773,
-0.0499439687,
0.1284435987,
-0.1944954693,
0.0354088619,
0.4069759846,
-0.0705877692,
0.0434784554,
0.1086387858,
-0.3708349764,
-0.2557041943,
0.3758941889,
-0.2756132185,
0.7422055006,
-0.4052564502,
-0.1985667944,
-0.3137238324,
0.4800861776,
0.6667392254,
-0.2192196697,
0.5375074148,
0.2907602787,
-0.2719470561,
0.0662538558,
-0.7999655008,
-0.0982884243,
-0.4969742894,
0.347604841,
0.1453981102,
-1.4734575748,
0.4303781092,
0.0777648166,
0.3439273238,
0.302097857,
0.8755971193,
0.0756464601,
0.6573916674,
1.1742575169,
-0.2358708382,
0.575851202,
0.0186817553,
0.618535459,
-0.3869808614,
-0.2508997619,
-0.7632066607,
-0.1367751807,
-0.8772838116,
-0.2286750376,
0.2903668284,
-0.5431613326,
-0.3011908531,
0.193882674,
-0.2169524878,
0.4700072706,
0.5622226596,
-0.2476038337,
0.433536917,
-0.1796245277,
0.2167174965,
0.1940054595,
-0.4680850506,
-0.7938559651,
1.0378257036,
0.7510786057,
0.5756958127,
0.0091118813,
0.5227760077,
0.4521274865,
0.074270457,
-0.6332038045,
0.9061789513,
0.0131891239,
-1.018376708,
-0.4855621159,
-0.5216119289,
-0.5433725119,
0.0197589267,
-0.0904966742,
-0.7398579717,
0.2046199292,
0.0706375539,
-0.2485115975,
0.4841432571,
-0.2383996844,
0.5491331816,
-0.2799927592,
-0.3142594993,
-0.6322319508,
-0.6368036866,
0.3858953714,
-0.3874687254,
0.6904503703,
-0.2145663798,
-0.0192494746,
0.9522577524,
-0.1908184886,
0.8309890032,
0.0275252014,
-0.3807167709,
0.3074349761,
-0.3169303238,
0.2439485937,
-0.3716883659,
0.1092756316,
0.4845189154,
0.2757754326,
-0.1913452744,
-0.0409119949,
0.6311779022,
-0.7556712627,
-0.8634094,
-0.4622365832,
-0.5249904394,
-0.1506246924,
0.3825652003,
0.1072448865,
0.1779538393,
-0.4201879799,
0.4528167546,
0.9086244106,
-0.2565160394,
0.6236997843,
0.5544401407,
-0.4967455566,
-0.4594599903,
0.93406564,
0.5068973899,
0.3168229461,
-0.0374786295,
0.1410277039,
-0.1756162494,
-0.5936960578,
0.0076662465,
0.2544000447,
-0.7088180184,
0.0864054486,
-0.6105511785,
-0.4638242424,
-0.3432166278,
0.1349589825,
-0.3990702927,
-0.4227463603,
-0.3611351848,
-0.0736166388,
0.1913634837,
0.8593304753,
-0.1052262411,
0.1367778778,
-0.7836119533,
0.0529210046,
0.1418228149,
0.326261878,
-0.0999935865,
-0.4085126519,
-0.1204596609,
-0.0235258602,
-0.3316724598,
-0.3440998793,
-0.0226721913,
-0.3076860905,
0.4258235097,
0.0237725936,
0.2341922671,
0.3698731661,
-0.6465126276,
0.8287035823,
0.5103439689,
-0.9209699035,
0.0515115634,
-0.2659919262,
-0.1561775357,
0.2322109044,
0.3210377991,
-0.8638358116,
-0.5797052979,
-0.4820863008,
-0.8951534033,
0.43801561,
-0.1069737673,
0.7447462678,
0.2833010554,
0.2647670507,
0.042788025,
0.5534700751,
-0.7378348708,
-0.0444269404,
0.1490951329,
-0.2199389935,
0.2401069403,
-0.4932134449,
-0.3601047695,
0.00614003,
0.6227216721,
0.2346991897,
-0.046780359,
-0.0888632089,
0.1907388121,
-0.2743989527,
0.6206699014,
0.8969935179,
1.1493147612,
0.3885408938,
0.1262281984,
-0.1053342149,
-0.7406038046,
0.3292238712,
-0.1008638367,
-0.4791670144,
-0.3022496104,
0.1563759744,
0.5415592194,
-0.1021469161,
-0.6558213234,
0.5612367392,
0.0411212146,
-0.5320883393,
-0.422394067,
0.0350861736,
0.0078510093,
0.448867321,
0.3097877204,
-0.3918234408,
0.0331275985,
-0.6289188862,
0.1027841568,
0.3549247086,
-0.5311484337,
-0.1517174244,
0.5067877769,
0.2572962642,
-0.2288900167,
0.2266805768,
0.2866669893,
-0.4394432604,
0.4061579704,
0.241398856,
0.7882665992,
-0.0872134715,
0.2082652152,
-0.1446486712,
0.7225794196,
-0.3690035045,
0.015211639,
0.3762397766,
-0.5442906022,
-0.3090144694,
-0.2420863211,
-0.6108651757,
0.294590801,
-0.3537817001,
0.0172718819,
-0.7717425227,
-0.583040297,
0.0937900618,
0.4033851326,
-0.2503080368,
-0.1959629506,
0.3445045948,
0.7813271284,
-0.706217885,
0.5701833367,
0.3738133311,
-0.4109972417,
-0.4157814384,
0.1457698643,
0.3571942747,
-0.3594934642,
0.3190746605,
0.0433380827,
0.0752326027,
-0.0701431334,
-0.9207699895,
-0.6394152045,
0.9153882861,
0.5082296729,
-0.906098485,
0.1363771707,
0.5215491056,
0.4403960407,
-0.1008321121,
-0.0990551114,
0.6172175407,
0.6758204103,
0.1756602824,
-1.2905119658,
-0.0103301806,
0.1245641559,
0.1452879459,
0.2792083323,
-0.8727124929,
0.6746415496,
-0.0031358572,
0.0282149389,
-0.1842006147,
0.7350158691,
-0.0185714979,
0.3302352726,
0.1339082122,
0.2462830544,
0.7786715031,
-0.0280125458,
0.8094924688,
-0.3765406907,
0.109748058,
0.7101413012,
-0.597962141,
0.6344448328,
0.4994244277,
-0.2467913479,
-0.2278311104,
0.5211651921,
-0.0519993417,
0.3497675359,
0.5258948803,
-0.2130886167,
0.1844037175,
-0.4468064904,
-0.5996519327,
0.1638169885,
0.2862065434,
-0.1511862576,
-0.0220764559,
0.2718037367,
0.1676009893,
0.260997057,
-0.3930025399,
0.7509376407,
0.3040058613,
-0.223277688,
-0.0928246826,
0.2366932482,
0.4111713171,
-0.4771179259,
0.1463775337,
-0.0775710717,
0.0077295136,
-0.1506484896,
-0.9993709326,
0.4596668184,
0.1404920369,
-0.3987172246,
-0.2313925922,
0.3553514779,
-0.3779082,
-0.2702151835,
0.0041938866,
0.1119318828,
0.0464550443,
0.0163771603,
-0.6890975833,
0.8159487844,
-0.2310193181,
-0.2247282863,
0.5622270703,
0.5110757947,
-0.2739746273,
0.833534658,
0.5269213915,
0.2281683087,
0.2642767429,
0.0523923934,
0.9099244475,
-0.6293745637,
-0.469971329,
-0.5712496042,
0.2210762948,
-0.2111227661,
-0.1275774091,
0.4320607483,
0.3427670896,
0.7430128455,
0.262978375,
0.7321951985,
-0.2609520257,
0.2419101894,
-0.5509957075,
1.0410223007,
-0.3021977544,
0.372454226,
0.2037716508,
-1.0320613384,
-0.3776291907,
0.3411012292,
-0.658166945,
0.1696534902,
0.36158216,
0.701764822,
0.2351079583,
0.215586096,
0.4035330415,
0.4959062338,
0.6776570678,
-0.0802636221,
0.6913207173,
-0.0991817564,
0.4189343452,
0.0722057447,
0.0856893361,
-0.2909478247,
-0.9521009922,
-0.5466910005,
-0.6539050937,
-0.5213018656,
-0.3062746823,
0.0379235521,
0.9940853119,
0.4122879207,
-0.7580780387,
-0.487275064,
0.0617895275,
0.1917390525,
0.385153532,
-0.1821573973,
0.0543904155,
-0.0547857434,
-0.5250300765,
0.0122464495,
0.5334746838,
0.0200422034,
-0.5441280007,
0.0898652822,
-0.0552105606,
0.0912148058,
0.5744645596,
0.451895833,
-0.8209161758,
-0.4801291823,
-0.4099330604,
-0.4311353266,
-0.145777896,
0.8204606175,
0.0006231514,
0.4283674955,
0.2622192204,
0.6302179694,
0.2288611084,
-0.3754559159,
0.6595146656,
-0.3136579096,
0.1939322948,
0.4436101615,
0.1577773392,
0.2424148619,
-0.0348346308,
0.3518766463,
0.0187618416,
-0.6374406219,
-0.9632624984,
0.2499828041,
-0.8068365455,
-0.2431280464,
1.0390894413,
0.1273356676,
-0.17156066,
-0.2746829987,
-0.1725495309,
0.0629877225,
-0.1118512675,
0.8159726262,
0.9446594119,
0.4689826667,
-0.2220435739,
-1.1448132992,
0.3096113503,
-0.2047435194,
-0.8702691793,
0.3937591016,
0.7655912638,
0.1656343341,
0.1457781345,
0.6374108791,
-0.4364415705,
-0.0664062202,
-0.3827472925,
0.0303721018,
-0.1555426121,
-0.4634285569,
-0.4422815442,
0.1006520092,
0.0633999035,
0.1493233144
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11094v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11094v2
|
Word Embeddings Revisited: Do LLMs Offer Something New?
| 2024-02-16T21:47:30 | 2024-03-02T14:01:04 |
Matthew Freestone, Shubhra Kanti Karmaker Santu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
Learning meaningful word embeddings is key to training a robust language
model. The recent rise of Large Language Models (LLMs) has provided us with
many new word/sentence/document embedding models. Although LLMs have shown
remarkable advancement in various NLP tasks, it is still unclear whether the
performance improvement is merely because of scale or whether underlying
embeddings they produce significantly differ from classical encoding models
like Sentence-BERT (SBERT) or Universal Sentence Encoder (USE). This paper
systematically investigates this issue by comparing classical word embedding
techniques against LLM-based word embeddings in terms of their latent vector
semantics. Our results show that LLMs tend to cluster semantically related
words more tightly than classical models. LLMs also yield higher average
accuracy on the Bigger Analogy Test Set (BATS) over classical methods. Finally,
some LLMs tend to produce word embeddings similar to SBERT, a relatively
lighter classical model.
|
[
-0.0533193052,
-0.7531305552,
0.7385567427,
-0.2436096668,
-0.3543457389,
0.1962435097,
-0.4039060473,
-0.3324864507,
0.1830979139,
0.3165854514,
-0.0865586922,
-0.4514944255,
-0.8025536537,
-0.0093523981,
-0.4963282347,
0.5726148486,
-0.0884147659,
0.4290268421,
-0.6180113554,
-0.222966671,
-0.3244800568,
-0.5971958041,
-0.2510314584,
-0.5562473536,
0.5157893896,
-0.1725700945,
0.8461989164,
0.6836786866,
0.5894949436,
0.2854768336,
-0.3918994963,
0.055947952,
-0.4356889725,
0.1430347711,
0.0591482334,
-0.6621451378,
-0.0806538612,
0.0956593379,
0.5301857591,
0.9149816036,
-0.2227575332,
-0.0388213582,
0.1364669949,
0.4132128358,
-0.6271017194,
0.0328708999,
-0.9058079123,
0.1711570919,
-0.0178607758,
-0.2113953382,
-0.3947371244,
-0.3913011849,
0.260024339,
-0.3215571344,
-0.0067083249,
0.1316680759,
0.7753862143,
0.2504677176,
-0.2330239117,
-0.5736407042,
-0.5425144434,
0.8376197219,
-0.818567276,
0.6594514847,
0.0384308845,
0.050571043,
-0.1393162608,
-0.7668226957,
-0.4733611643,
-0.3422691524,
0.1642391682,
-0.0797281489,
-0.2550463378,
0.0345418938,
0.1616839319,
0.4719835818,
-0.2542319,
0.4328858852,
-0.1031446382,
-0.0415966175,
0.2994464338,
0.060622301,
0.2291553617,
-0.1246626228,
-0.4602951407,
-0.2059787363,
-1.0664767027,
0.0307421722,
0.0848663673,
0.2492895573,
-0.0139011182,
0.8444314599,
0.3566549122,
0.7270763516,
-0.2357229292,
-0.3511005342,
0.1071140766,
0.0448797643,
-0.1034061909,
0.0495469645,
0.4905698895,
0.3109784722,
0.4256736934,
-0.5719441175,
-0.304510355,
0.3048236966,
0.2015417069,
-0.4958817661,
-0.0250606574,
-0.1113695726,
-0.5239109397,
-0.2914786041,
0.2555000782,
-0.1707217395,
-0.3021837175,
-0.3166981637,
0.5840427279,
-0.4301490486,
0.0640869439,
0.1305866092,
-0.3539033532,
0.6294927597,
0.3857214153,
-0.7693626881,
0.2079043686,
0.9621804953,
0.8314020038,
-0.2905684114,
-0.056375023,
-0.4081645906,
-0.0225202311,
-0.7106211185,
0.8131563663,
-0.8675066829,
-0.3653005958,
0.3697696328,
-0.2163532525,
0.0957066566,
-0.6879628897,
0.2024872154,
-0.6215029955,
0.1410458535,
-0.5029200315,
-1.031496644,
-0.114545919,
0.2393128276,
-0.400193125,
0.9430845976,
0.004728707,
-0.8857369423,
0.5623478293,
-0.134001866,
-0.202478081,
-0.073947534,
-0.3671430647,
-0.2238122523,
0.6325047612,
0.0536935776,
0.8191066384,
-0.2417037636,
-0.1116392091,
-0.7378243804,
-0.546300292,
0.7248176932,
-0.3147795796,
0.2568441331,
0.0967506766,
0.0156813171,
-0.1586743444,
-0.4648114443,
0.0162037686,
0.1056101397,
-0.4384317398,
-0.6087149978,
0.0980649292,
-0.2924557924,
0.0256900713,
0.3151062131,
-0.6478975415,
0.0179483257,
-0.3905000687,
0.6481645703,
0.7059557438,
-0.2027804852,
0.3977779746,
-0.4614194334,
0.4271900654,
-0.1162798628,
-0.4358530343,
-0.1266416907,
-0.3590809703,
-0.6538383961,
-0.3573307693,
0.54148525,
0.3716451526,
-0.5524278283,
0.4988750517,
-0.4305585921,
-0.3120884299,
-0.4337415397,
0.0826307908,
0.1158292741,
0.1144820303,
0.089906849,
-0.3051615059,
-0.2467891276,
-0.7053635716,
-0.279998064,
-0.0212741867,
-0.0893907025,
0.2432283759,
0.4513790011,
-0.1253081709,
0.7931625843,
-0.4785160422,
-0.0411908627,
-0.4205841124,
-0.1660524011,
-0.1372730583,
-0.0138395336,
0.6903991699,
-0.294359237,
-0.2836970091,
-0.2734727263,
-0.7801190615,
0.1270780116,
0.0807208419,
0.3176004887,
0.1334476322,
0.7408849001,
-0.3208013475,
0.1826994419,
0.8164346218,
-0.1101602688,
0.259883821,
-0.4563699365,
-0.1911982745,
-1.1505721807,
-0.3521942794,
-0.2137829065,
-0.3095432222,
-0.389526397,
0.2334339172,
0.122159034,
-0.0910237059,
-0.5658278465,
0.2123955488,
-0.5788297653,
-0.4444825649,
-0.4483114183,
0.4729959071,
-0.1243426651,
0.2392215282,
-0.0689261034,
0.8500337601,
0.5188071132,
-0.5236206651,
0.3370975852,
0.1897065639,
-0.513625443,
0.2459239215,
-0.8353636861,
0.0283272769,
-0.152509287,
0.1611055732,
-0.9932950139,
0.1819482148,
-0.334743619,
-0.260255605,
0.5843046904,
0.2531375587,
-0.6465371847,
-0.3624506295,
-0.6877682209,
0.0922091305,
0.7461445928,
-0.6203974485,
0.1524624676,
0.4960712194,
-0.0181996729,
-0.3116190434,
-0.9728642106,
0.0471004769,
-0.3725251555,
-0.4048706889,
0.3153653145,
0.2273376137,
-0.2918904424,
0.2162806243,
-0.0844673663,
0.0509348586,
0.2329482287,
0.1377834529,
0.0329867825,
-0.2580167651,
0.5040415525,
-0.0433093272,
0.0139442552,
-0.053368032,
-0.2083639503,
0.587913394,
-0.2666491568,
-0.4702883661,
-0.1455980241,
0.3066855371,
0.3343001902,
-0.2802113593,
0.9306206107,
0.6393830776,
-0.3972055018,
-0.1210448965,
-0.5190162659,
-0.3389118314,
-0.4307015836,
0.2650604248,
-0.2288447469,
-1.5384869576,
0.2358821481,
-0.3260937333,
0.1142663807,
0.3707425594,
0.5516290665,
-0.2974043489,
0.6765760779,
0.8828520775,
-0.0457065664,
0.4412287176,
-0.1772592515,
0.3415032327,
-1.0358058214,
0.0449355207,
-0.4474622011,
-0.3011325002,
-0.7988201976,
-0.7133936882,
0.2459584773,
0.2317922711,
0.055383008,
0.3455556333,
-0.208364293,
0.1202944368,
0.3270472288,
-0.0365965813,
0.130449459,
0.3448270559,
-0.352383852,
-0.4080805182,
-0.9213729501,
-0.7479878068,
1.2655808926,
0.4806372821,
1.1117591858,
0.1008155718,
0.7617257237,
0.180620864,
0.2375377268,
-0.9661070108,
0.5230531096,
-0.4419188797,
-0.1040243208,
-0.093577601,
-0.2384156585,
-1.177426219,
0.4241441488,
-0.6837434769,
-0.6194793582,
-0.0320685282,
-0.0753001422,
-0.1986042261,
0.570014298,
-0.4167838991,
0.5765702128,
-0.2262154818,
-0.107842885,
-0.366217494,
-0.1844322681,
0.0806903839,
-0.0487805493,
0.172745347,
-0.1165409014,
-0.4273925424,
0.7114670277,
-0.486171484,
0.6640056968,
0.2242603749,
-0.2933253944,
0.2486514896,
-0.1435671151,
0.4275304675,
-0.1751182228,
-0.0115056681,
0.0988123193,
0.051952973,
-0.2724657655,
-0.6546064615,
0.8485540152,
-0.6672366261,
-0.5456504226,
-0.3700083196,
-0.4152502716,
-0.1973555088,
-0.134487927,
0.1755780429,
0.7070804834,
-0.4219984412,
0.6771886349,
0.8968623877,
-0.4898564219,
0.4880280197,
0.1843304634,
-0.1476471722,
-0.261845082,
0.6053822637,
0.1502771527,
0.2727824748,
0.7334498763,
0.3051651418,
-0.3780736923,
-0.6033251286,
0.0074921506,
0.4546058774,
-0.605453074,
-0.06283582,
-0.6291793585,
-0.0212801751,
-0.3550280929,
-0.3346385956,
-0.386336863,
-0.4539143443,
-0.155139342,
-0.085917905,
0.452245146,
0.8959528804,
-0.0486133657,
0.2057347894,
-0.7536728978,
0.0257794205,
0.4826734066,
0.1848305762,
-0.1161032766,
-0.6200349927,
-0.2086630017,
-0.1775511056,
-0.2320129424,
-0.9226353765,
0.0377346501,
0.3360640109,
0.5976553559,
0.5356850624,
-0.165241316,
0.4672881961,
-0.7941380739,
0.9490556717,
0.1822268516,
-0.6736031175,
0.3046858013,
-0.2060114443,
0.2858160734,
0.1836597025,
0.4023396075,
-0.4693375826,
-0.4111204147,
-0.7155098915,
-0.7066554427,
0.056925986,
-0.1354594678,
0.5258546472,
-0.1812628657,
0.4948268831,
0.1318925768,
0.5352776647,
-0.6282457709,
-0.1079020798,
0.1878386736,
-0.0914649367,
-0.3226298392,
-0.6226118207,
0.1516675055,
-0.030008506,
0.267472595,
0.1062162891,
0.6145862937,
0.0420066044,
-0.3505809903,
0.1867926121,
0.4135774076,
0.3232816458,
0.4968889058,
0.0002165495,
0.2738605142,
0.4923249781,
-0.1955112368,
0.0041838102,
-0.1931057274,
-0.0423777997,
0.1816915572,
0.7981176972,
0.9029400349,
0.5507060885,
-0.7372251749,
0.7379953265,
0.1079681218,
-0.2956867516,
-0.2779841721,
0.1080055237,
0.4006686509,
0.2208405584,
-0.0504051596,
-0.2479380369,
-0.1585576236,
-0.7549087405,
0.1196496263,
0.7313326001,
-0.4251234829,
-0.0995783806,
0.5071234107,
-0.0891942233,
-0.1591231972,
0.3320089579,
0.0105793579,
-0.5910323858,
0.0592386574,
0.5391383171,
0.6680665612,
-0.0443700664,
-0.0158815663,
0.0433413796,
0.3597252369,
-0.1868270338,
0.1942676604,
-0.0990607888,
-0.7998148799,
-0.4703129828,
-0.7895377278,
-0.4861248136,
0.0510573462,
-0.6579267383,
0.00996063,
-0.5162253976,
-0.1048103496,
-0.3909631073,
-0.0172624439,
-0.6639556289,
-0.0176960509,
0.1373566538,
0.816791594,
-0.8164140582,
0.8700598478,
0.9970823526,
-0.1035333872,
-0.8227617145,
-0.0106235966,
-0.2218899429,
-0.7558341026,
0.4203699827,
0.2655804455,
0.0382345468,
-0.1128752157,
-0.4202285409,
-0.8965239525,
1.1924748421,
0.334551394,
-0.595569551,
-0.0589211769,
0.1315950155,
0.677733779,
-0.4214648604,
0.0257340521,
0.3479104936,
0.0006443977,
-0.0576083064,
-0.4919772446,
-0.0290026739,
0.2221547365,
0.4990613461,
0.1548786014,
-0.3487631977,
0.7471448183,
-0.1487793475,
-0.1410752237,
0.153510958,
0.9299230576,
0.156501621,
-0.1108846441,
0.3740279675,
0.9264093637,
0.6714267731,
-0.2542787492,
1.1821426153,
-0.3115363121,
0.3129799664,
0.8958663344,
-0.1839247942,
1.3561520576,
0.4802728593,
-0.4179731607,
0.4835609198,
0.6021749377,
-0.0339484513,
0.5449163914,
0.4333220124,
-0.1116731688,
-0.3900181949,
0.0305003542,
-0.4524354339,
0.5080125928,
0.5080587864,
-0.3397389948,
-0.348833859,
0.1973592788,
0.0905022025,
0.3759323359,
-0.1604076177,
0.7306808233,
0.501003027,
-0.2120903134,
0.3443726301,
0.1950622499,
1.0959819555,
-0.5935916901,
0.2613484859,
-0.0494094752,
0.3439079225,
0.1846367419,
-0.4803465605,
0.2283365875,
0.0119129382,
0.2172459811,
-0.1452270746,
0.7672213316,
-0.4734392762,
-0.4364309013,
0.2991184294,
0.7062378526,
0.2941952646,
0.1287771463,
-0.6686377525,
0.2201138288,
-0.3823654056,
-0.1813794225,
0.3831904531,
0.5060993433,
0.1967501789,
0.6464583874,
0.5413549542,
0.3501605392,
0.2374447137,
0.0137093635,
0.7093762159,
-0.5837559104,
-0.3307141364,
-0.6736479998,
0.0089185955,
0.1714450717,
-0.0902450457,
0.8610098958,
0.3757741153,
0.9473282099,
-0.0767454654,
0.6147097349,
0.1903184801,
0.5173493028,
-0.7236970663,
0.4055687487,
-0.895909667,
0.2461271435,
-0.339417845,
-1.0355000496,
-0.3523207605,
0.8978785276,
-0.3634881973,
0.0650642365,
0.851426959,
0.7194120288,
-0.038292069,
-0.1020514891,
0.5686854124,
0.1305342317,
0.1965999901,
0.299987644,
0.9252955317,
-0.368676722,
0.2341095358,
0.0602158755,
-0.0610787943,
-0.2457047999,
-0.909154892,
-0.9938380122,
-0.390619427,
-0.2891235054,
-0.0475649424,
0.1430449188,
0.8955742121,
0.2015720606,
-0.5602958202,
-0.1113755181,
-0.0753991231,
-0.0059857899,
-0.1624123752,
-0.1488321126,
0.3619430065,
-0.5524689555,
-0.592636466,
0.3672378063,
0.3889505863,
0.2440850437,
-0.3870552182,
-0.0438474528,
-0.0792936832,
0.1918646693,
0.8510016203,
-0.1839924157,
-0.8035942316,
-0.5783062577,
-0.0133783724,
-0.3111103177,
-0.087123625,
0.8508407474,
-0.637802422,
0.2114174366,
0.6222460866,
0.9638136625,
0.3092964292,
-0.4409908354,
0.6054801345,
-0.4652227461,
0.1731867194,
0.017861506,
0.608894527,
0.5621662736,
0.1513645649,
0.290322125,
0.1989614218,
-0.3450646102,
-0.7545819879,
0.2724066675,
-0.8072003126,
-0.4507131875,
1.2656956911,
-0.2128562629,
-0.2069868147,
0.2396752089,
0.1285286993,
0.2356061041,
-0.0680336207,
0.5406916142,
0.8056596518,
0.0906950831,
-0.1028103828,
-0.3449709117,
0.315523833,
0.4879220724,
-0.3583839238,
-0.3258396089,
0.3320217431,
0.3541726768,
0.0694116876,
0.2027671784,
-0.2891789973,
0.0206207633,
0.009261162,
-0.1321094781,
-0.0680137426,
-0.140152663,
-0.5174732804,
0.164697811,
0.481180191,
-0.2027273178
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11078v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11078v3
|
Model Editing by Standard Fine-Tuning
| 2024-02-16T21:10:33 | 2024-06-03T05:39:10 |
Govind Gangadhar, Karl Stratos
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Standard fine-tuning is considered not as effective as specialized methods
for model editing due to its comparatively poor performance. However, it is
simple, agnostic to the architectural details of the model being edited, and
able to leverage advances in standard training techniques with no additional
work (e.g., black-box PEFT for computational efficiency), making it an
appealing choice for a model editor. In this work, we show that standard
fine-tuning alone can yield competitive model editing performance with two
minor modifications. First, we optimize the conditional likelihood rather than
the full likelihood. Second, in addition to the typical practice of training on
randomly paraphrased edit prompts to encourage generalization, we also train on
random or similar unedited facts to encourage locality. Our experiments on the
ZsRE and CounterFact datasets demonstrate that these simple modifications allow
standard fine-tuning to match or outperform highly specialized editors in terms
of edit score.
|
[
-0.3825716972,
-0.828324914,
0.7008524537,
-0.3636716604,
-0.395627141,
-0.4413262308,
-0.429515332,
-0.5533137918,
-0.0839790404,
0.4858000875,
-0.4934863448,
-0.587772131,
-0.4145900309,
0.1896364838,
-0.2789107859,
1.0944945812,
0.1139079556,
0.045769155,
-0.2490053922,
-0.3775226176,
-0.3778993785,
-0.5955660939,
-0.6913727522,
-0.0668912455,
0.7052463293,
0.4017197788,
1.1241725683,
0.767293036,
0.5609539747,
0.315536201,
-0.5365104675,
0.4128567576,
-0.5476167202,
-0.2559389472,
-0.6748684049,
-0.5510421991,
-0.8813101649,
0.1334501505,
0.4947256744,
0.5984141827,
0.138418451,
0.2369608432,
0.0189301018,
0.7883343697,
-0.8499795198,
-0.1847953647,
-0.8139697313,
-0.1032948345,
-0.3491944075,
-0.0592982024,
-0.2153939754,
-0.1884714067,
-0.0055575976,
-0.7606977224,
0.7674129605,
-0.1346367151,
0.896207273,
0.4721983373,
-0.3660828471,
0.0229108837,
-0.7626768351,
0.4177028835,
-0.9261991382,
0.2996534109,
0.0304898713,
0.1148798764,
-0.0696266517,
-0.7543802261,
-0.3474038541,
0.0526693761,
-0.0001534032,
-0.0660602078,
-0.3085394502,
0.5099142194,
0.5804392099,
0.4310028851,
-0.2259047776,
0.3912668824,
-0.4074625969,
-0.0254169945,
0.7825946808,
0.3093006909,
0.1341008395,
-0.0612763762,
0.1643070877,
0.0504488982,
-0.6466202736,
0.3009314537,
0.4746792614,
0.4450286925,
0.2086917013,
0.6633854508,
-0.5926759839,
1.0007717609,
0.3351102471,
0.3786203265,
-0.0555306971,
-0.3181034625,
-0.5286279321,
-0.2378343791,
0.5735321045,
0.8238095045,
0.2447918355,
-0.19372347,
-0.4325391054,
0.0764553696,
0.2940840423,
-0.7089146376,
-0.4494106472,
-0.1058635786,
-0.5922064781,
-0.5154166222,
-0.0520861633,
-0.5477591157,
-0.2257866114,
-0.6201264858,
0.7040829659,
-0.1320280284,
0.3255181611,
0.4678349793,
-0.6070693731,
-0.2709273696,
0.7271354795,
-0.890707016,
0.1649364531,
0.6804019213,
0.8042010069,
0.0071902587,
-0.310902983,
-0.5558255911,
-0.2152929157,
-0.6153265238,
0.8917973042,
-0.8025985956,
-0.3534187376,
-0.4542409778,
-0.1598559618,
-0.1069181785,
-0.5438975096,
0.556953907,
-0.5113942027,
-0.1896877438,
-0.6091172695,
-0.6804504395,
-0.096784845,
-0.154507935,
-0.5418880582,
0.8275520802,
-0.0543439351,
-0.6212447286,
0.6669515371,
-0.5363175273,
-0.3268781304,
-0.4960587025,
0.0752803013,
-0.5907565355,
0.5872472525,
0.3959953487,
0.3781248033,
0.0122115565,
0.1251753718,
-0.6386086941,
-0.658736825,
0.0652975664,
-0.1154066995,
0.3683104217,
0.2373538762,
-0.0383965708,
0.2353156507,
-0.9354090095,
-0.0958246216,
-0.2835906148,
-0.2557560205,
-0.4426362813,
0.0208983161,
-0.1683656573,
0.1053552926,
0.1447849423,
-0.4967930615,
0.5475912094,
-0.4098515809,
0.4000035822,
0.686403513,
0.3810290098,
0.6954845786,
-0.5802364349,
0.2487609833,
-0.0978296772,
0.1848903745,
0.3223380148,
-0.4593628049,
-0.7995977402,
-0.3308521509,
0.9316419363,
0.38189587,
-0.3707078099,
0.0030400194,
0.0395848937,
-0.6352052093,
-0.7454379201,
0.407384932,
0.2568094432,
0.5774957538,
0.5328741074,
-0.1404898167,
-0.6149035096,
-1.3218628168,
-0.8128925562,
0.5375375152,
-0.1937131137,
0.2325704992,
0.338216275,
-0.0136119071,
0.8821317554,
-0.4843206704,
-0.0045123505,
-0.1926340014,
0.2772853673,
0.1902050227,
0.7014189959,
0.9021624327,
-0.5961821675,
-0.5566816926,
-0.1029651165,
-0.4687806666,
-0.2115222067,
-0.3437708318,
-0.2136093825,
-0.0898577869,
0.5988780856,
-0.67574054,
0.603345871,
0.151057899,
-0.1208707839,
0.4043850899,
-0.4371321201,
0.4768557549,
-0.5815404654,
-0.0385871567,
-0.0339671262,
-0.2282667756,
-0.6922867894,
0.2117497772,
0.2656461596,
-0.1439298242,
-0.4417575598,
0.364331454,
-0.2139824778,
0.042990569,
-0.2923920751,
0.0089566438,
-0.0091042286,
0.5139909387,
0.1975532323,
0.6274725199,
0.3201066256,
-0.7140035629,
-0.0730464309,
0.2733632326,
-0.5125377178,
0.4323311746,
-1.0032757521,
0.4976159036,
-0.2346029878,
-0.0581642985,
-0.4934521914,
-0.1869983226,
-0.0908842683,
-0.0815924853,
0.1359090507,
-0.3176154792,
-0.4584961534,
0.1332686394,
-0.3034891188,
0.0603755191,
0.4481306076,
-0.4542748034,
0.1995924115,
-0.0941509902,
-0.124355875,
-0.1556747556,
-0.6726807952,
-0.0399135351,
-0.1073985398,
-0.6647294164,
0.4792431593,
-0.2927375138,
-0.1453386843,
-0.0383670852,
-0.245377779,
-0.1525731087,
0.3305900097,
-0.043021705,
0.2860134542,
-0.1567245126,
0.0939368829,
0.5805348754,
-0.0846220553,
-0.4573222697,
0.2616026103,
-0.2626940906,
0.1104661897,
-0.1693615019,
-0.6203454137,
0.2017685324,
0.5458782911,
-0.4185167253,
0.5099995732,
0.1707001328,
-0.3139518797,
-0.2858195007,
-0.4110860825,
-0.1692556739,
-0.4683619142,
0.4866528809,
-0.6778822541,
-0.7895761132,
0.4337728322,
-0.1014325991,
0.3121379018,
0.6381103992,
0.2794497311,
-0.1804045141,
1.3388912678,
0.7265601158,
0.3725402355,
0.4126365185,
0.0486848876,
-0.0175161064,
-0.7035030723,
0.3179722726,
-0.7438289523,
-0.8094905019,
-0.661613822,
-0.1853361577,
0.2869674563,
0.5766748786,
-0.2266575545,
0.3050394058,
-0.4593491852,
0.8265666962,
0.68266958,
0.4449758828,
0.4005921781,
-0.363807708,
-0.0052555897,
-0.2622705102,
-0.9520765543,
-0.6054221392,
1.2011774778,
0.1344474107,
0.5959512591,
-0.0732863992,
0.7816803455,
0.1898877472,
-0.0367620066,
-0.3856553733,
0.3292502761,
-0.7373966575,
-0.6116072536,
-0.3377075791,
-0.1785854846,
-0.2954752743,
0.1253426522,
-0.5966665745,
-0.5322374105,
0.8178372979,
0.5919058919,
-0.8484282494,
0.4124225378,
-0.6917117238,
1.0724387169,
0.351242274,
-0.1148178652,
-0.431414932,
-0.2892895639,
0.1332120895,
-0.220622614,
0.1347986013,
0.0753536522,
0.0691934898,
0.5884006023,
-0.4451402724,
0.7456982732,
-0.1616804004,
0.5680190325,
0.0605859756,
0.2686311007,
0.6874824166,
0.3392804265,
-0.3177528083,
0.0981251821,
0.1221020743,
-0.37398839,
-0.9349954128,
0.48555246,
-0.6613274813,
-0.6594732404,
0.0187160075,
-0.5419971943,
-0.3410294056,
0.0890280902,
0.6140059233,
0.428060621,
-0.2104352564,
0.4546726644,
0.7709346414,
0.0604440644,
0.0316071361,
0.5878287554,
0.2670345306,
-0.1460118592,
0.5284774303,
0.2912299335,
0.3015252054,
0.2387654185,
0.2901133001,
0.2845014632,
-0.857531786,
-0.4052243233,
-0.1501842886,
-0.6407571435,
-0.1746507436,
-0.6310936809,
-0.1618680805,
-0.2495176047,
-0.6842438579,
-0.6026420593,
-0.7917819619,
-0.5120971799,
-0.0371486768,
0.3472782373,
0.6895255446,
-0.5288974047,
0.3155646026,
-0.7718219161,
0.4623704255,
0.5918560028,
0.3434158564,
-0.2594201863,
-0.8100374341,
-0.4523487389,
0.2810295224,
-0.2223620117,
-0.6244309545,
-0.0823661461,
0.5176907778,
0.4704528153,
0.1167188659,
0.1551808864,
0.9254512787,
-0.5071773529,
0.7281364799,
-0.2834991217,
-1.1156119108,
0.7050859928,
-0.3944717348,
0.421895057,
0.8370469809,
0.0843240097,
-0.4042045772,
-0.5258734822,
-0.5889610052,
-0.3061097562,
0.7530782819,
0.0307881013,
0.0964197963,
0.1183876246,
0.814014852,
0.1270604432,
0.3394328654,
-0.4107660055,
-0.1445186287,
-0.1480547041,
-0.0059495228,
-0.2190060318,
-0.3936685622,
-0.0490839034,
-0.5949066281,
0.7109465599,
0.1304771304,
-0.1102391481,
0.3700837791,
-0.2114130557,
-0.3903285265,
0.3945228457,
0.7752429247,
0.6496055126,
-0.5797988772,
-0.1763340086,
0.4879777133,
-0.0116554331,
-0.1856177002,
-0.083002612,
-0.6171590686,
0.1381139606,
0.3588478565,
1.1486288309,
0.6952117682,
-0.1636309922,
0.1518843323,
0.0641712099,
-0.6018180847,
0.6856539845,
0.7195383906,
0.0719897375,
0.4884094596,
-0.168325901,
0.8185120821,
0.4113995731,
-0.2362396419,
0.0745021477,
0.2560040355,
-0.0623571798,
-0.2988440096,
0.9137316942,
0.0533061326,
-0.3899323344,
0.4133102,
-0.1950281858,
-0.14021945,
0.5233235955,
0.0649368912,
0.7464408875,
0.0580064319,
-0.0864161402,
0.4891609848,
0.2620530427,
-0.3083080649,
0.0802420676,
-0.0222036913,
-0.5660201907,
-0.2101511508,
-0.4465004206,
-0.4409999847,
0.1308037937,
-0.8151156306,
0.7399903536,
-0.7164574862,
-0.1751030535,
0.4972236753,
-0.25152421,
-0.883551836,
0.4143566191,
-0.1880027652,
1.13116467,
-0.767495811,
0.7855494618,
0.8663650155,
-0.3043600619,
-0.4845456779,
-0.3571285307,
0.0341265984,
-0.1447010636,
0.3216219544,
-0.170328036,
0.2545073628,
-0.0361001305,
-0.5320953131,
-0.6843621731,
0.731813252,
0.527123332,
-1.1016170979,
-0.3202133477,
-0.165300265,
0.699824512,
-0.2234831452,
-0.1176553145,
0.6316337585,
0.2943302393,
-0.189233467,
-0.9794903398,
-0.2837834656,
-0.0886928439,
0.1666877866,
0.0980976224,
-0.6161869764,
0.9950153828,
-0.1387650967,
0.0785664469,
0.1716941148,
0.5330178738,
-0.2006777674,
0.2572372556,
0.4221608937,
0.7583409548,
0.6775795817,
0.1359895915,
0.6988684535,
-0.3341947198,
0.4349299669,
1.5415943861,
0.0270924773,
0.8418936133,
0.0836898834,
-0.034836743,
0.2170638293,
0.7513012886,
-0.232555002,
0.7283499241,
-0.3390341401,
-0.0985308215,
-0.7884647846,
0.508905232,
-0.2382087857,
0.5354216695,
0.0013996322,
-0.4301113188,
-0.4085244536,
-0.0264499485,
-0.101858817,
0.3563052416,
-0.5618371964,
0.6901057363,
0.0873926952,
-0.4290850759,
0.3243127465,
0.3555165231,
0.4916776717,
-0.3961541951,
-0.0662588105,
-0.1185443327,
0.0537468717,
-0.2029222846,
-0.4749698937,
0.4777984023,
0.2378282547,
-0.5316851735,
-0.0914928317,
0.6295184493,
-0.1703994125,
-0.509216249,
-0.1835652739,
0.2152071744,
-0.2422306538,
-0.2837354839,
-0.738458395,
-0.1244869083,
0.0371062495,
-0.3917341232,
0.4532506764,
0.46421808,
-0.0148490816,
0.2928193808,
0.7089461684,
0.1654496342,
-0.283511728,
-0.0474950559,
0.7274807096,
-0.6384114623,
-0.6848766804,
-0.8232247829,
0.6378518343,
-0.1323656291,
-0.5680303574,
0.6458741426,
0.4516938329,
0.8430864215,
-0.2282398194,
0.7242640257,
0.2768401504,
0.5912368894,
-0.7774933577,
0.6873202324,
-0.585485518,
0.0740814731,
-0.3012031317,
-0.8253233433,
-0.3019512594,
0.4766457081,
-0.6041067243,
-0.1658934206,
0.4459344745,
0.9629753828,
-0.345816493,
0.0913940519,
0.4899326861,
0.1963205487,
-0.0165821128,
0.3103536367,
0.2720854282,
-0.4158196449,
0.0937678814,
-0.6469786167,
-0.1258411556,
-0.1835604906,
-0.8814017773,
-1.180877924,
-0.2644661367,
-0.4321923554,
0.0718384683,
0.4912209213,
0.8959094286,
0.6368618011,
-0.7937253118,
0.2574437559,
-0.0317038149,
0.0802907422,
-0.3910404146,
-0.0684678033,
0.308262974,
-0.4344262779,
-0.8444991112,
0.5496528745,
0.1889528036,
0.0369587652,
0.4344485402,
0.103463836,
-0.1006478593,
0.4925173521,
0.3088382185,
0.2089965791,
-0.4463894665,
-0.4027315378,
-0.193617329,
-0.104099229,
0.1490032077,
0.7465475202,
-0.4873555005,
0.6986737251,
0.4617016912,
0.441093564,
0.5145550966,
0.1389599293,
0.6914374828,
-0.5741215944,
0.2677364349,
-0.0144550707,
0.2816468179,
0.0458776057,
-0.4910030961,
0.2827529311,
0.3250952363,
-0.708663404,
-0.8324733973,
0.0182719771,
-0.6524004936,
-0.4926958382,
0.7672657371,
0.0175534617,
-0.090228498,
0.1422890425,
-0.3846395016,
0.3750841916,
-0.2040633261,
0.9042423964,
0.7592774034,
-0.3539106548,
-0.0217704028,
-0.6731638908,
0.8813586831,
0.4579767883,
-0.3302312195,
-0.0607440062,
0.5746978521,
0.5959946513,
-0.3860919178,
0.3709776402,
0.2419412732,
0.9743068814,
0.0932521448,
-0.1030415595,
-0.4892796278,
-0.2308624238,
-0.5927174091,
-0.0835475624,
0.3137739897,
0.0921259075
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11073v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11073v3
|
AFaCTA: Assisting the Annotation of Factual Claim Detection with Reliable LLM Annotators
| 2024-02-16T20:59:57 | 2024-06-02T18:35:25 |
Jingwei Ni, Minjing Shi, Dominik Stammbach, Mrinmaya Sachan, Elliott Ash, Markus Leippold
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
With the rise of generative AI, automated fact-checking methods to combat
misinformation are becoming more and more important. However, factual claim
detection, the first step in a fact-checking pipeline, suffers from two key
issues that limit its scalability and generalizability: (1) inconsistency in
definitions of the task and what a claim is, and (2) the high cost of manual
annotation. To address (1), we review the definitions in related work and
propose a unifying definition of factual claims that focuses on verifiability.
To address (2), we introduce AFaCTA (Automatic Factual Claim deTection
Annotator), a novel framework that assists in the annotation of factual claims
with the help of large language models (LLMs). AFaCTA calibrates its annotation
confidence with consistency along three predefined reasoning paths. Extensive
evaluation and experiments in the domain of political speech reveal that AFaCTA
can efficiently assist experts in annotating factual claims and training
high-quality classifiers, and can work with or without expert supervision. Our
analyses also result in PoliClaim, a comprehensive claim detection dataset
spanning diverse political topics.
|
[
-0.2213639617,
-0.8332592249,
0.7332549095,
0.2243904471,
-0.2042975724,
0.169666037,
-0.1446268409,
-0.5014742017,
0.3385874927,
0.5310530663,
-0.0950401798,
-0.326397121,
-0.908133328,
0.1828778833,
-0.3465605378,
0.8100816011,
-0.0645189285,
-0.214570567,
-0.4711758196,
-0.4827716351,
-0.3356492817,
-0.5181994438,
-0.5725567341,
-0.1810811758,
0.29619959,
0.4161770642,
0.7702045441,
0.734978199,
0.3374782205,
0.413049221,
0.0584606156,
0.48418504,
0.0505800247,
0.2102311403,
-0.0913685486,
-0.7189730406,
-0.2716724277,
0.2530977726,
0.6134027839,
0.3654490113,
-0.1551587433,
0.2682180107,
-0.5969952345,
0.4281914532,
-0.7605937719,
0.4701313376,
-0.876896143,
-0.0845611542,
-0.4255045056,
0.0237399489,
-0.3825507164,
-0.5113354325,
-0.050623741,
-0.4432608485,
0.3507822156,
0.1067676693,
0.9081357121,
0.6323336959,
-0.4968084395,
-0.5121248364,
-0.6213589907,
0.1767150611,
-0.6284633875,
0.2528048754,
0.3361571133,
0.2792545259,
0.0461434126,
-0.757286191,
-0.9872525334,
-0.3426225185,
-0.2628455758,
-0.1626441926,
-0.1714929342,
0.1598660499,
0.4972003996,
0.5189697146,
-0.1701009423,
-0.0890467986,
-0.2965696454,
-0.7413553596,
0.7039008141,
-0.3293704391,
0.3749863803,
-0.2149136811,
-0.4122776389,
0.1651618332,
-0.8251783252,
-0.0703244805,
0.4037144482,
0.2831991911,
-0.0938615948,
0.5821029544,
-0.3266797066,
0.5469200015,
0.0343236029,
-0.1286486387,
0.121842891,
-0.2592222989,
-0.3963478506,
0.2138430476,
0.6854929924,
-0.157748878,
0.0397428609,
-0.1054495499,
-0.1541133523,
0.3753889203,
0.0858076066,
-0.6622392535,
-0.3353224397,
0.2756519616,
-0.2217933238,
-0.2680468857,
0.2525414526,
-0.5199996233,
-0.6651003361,
-0.5126199126,
0.4306187928,
-0.1271383613,
-0.311024189,
-0.1434360296,
0.112175405,
-0.0820587277,
0.5096634626,
-0.459890306,
0.0828368962,
0.7246465087,
0.7931534052,
0.1152457297,
0.0166642331,
-0.8840632439,
-0.1189443097,
-0.502454102,
1.1684523821,
-0.4632530808,
0.1148938164,
0.2780539095,
0.0717210323,
0.0985316932,
-0.5043978095,
0.7766723633,
-0.5018229485,
0.0805276558,
-0.4504475296,
-0.630822897,
-0.4576953351,
0.3938492239,
-0.8406695127,
0.7426124811,
-0.1930770576,
-0.5126444697,
0.8196151257,
-0.4953563213,
-0.485023886,
0.1203137264,
-0.4225418866,
-0.4264909625,
0.158571437,
0.0185560435,
0.3410829604,
-0.2142495364,
0.4959637225,
-0.0517279916,
0.0644457489,
0.4016082585,
-0.4797744751,
0.9021347761,
-0.0256095435,
-0.5278334022,
0.1375390887,
-0.8629912138,
-0.440851599,
-0.093533881,
-0.4342067242,
-0.1651468575,
0.1538666338,
-0.1828461587,
0.1225601062,
0.2330552787,
-0.7738944292,
0.2630722225,
-0.112261042,
0.079214491,
0.7836741805,
-0.129332602,
-0.0428736359,
-0.3679788113,
0.160730511,
-0.0440397263,
-0.1007172614,
-0.2872239947,
-0.4951886535,
-0.954122901,
-0.668957293,
0.7619574666,
0.8178281784,
-0.6242018342,
0.2682698071,
-0.0673174411,
-0.2217636853,
-0.4798120558,
0.2036844045,
0.1434046179,
0.5745546222,
0.3689354956,
-0.053204935,
-0.6366006136,
-0.8224240541,
-0.4149135053,
-0.659252286,
-0.0372990221,
-0.0035726551,
0.4910816848,
-0.094910942,
1.0714517832,
-0.1905153543,
-0.4918897152,
0.159249261,
0.468934685,
-0.0165777355,
0.1050484031,
0.4760615826,
-1.0093253851,
-0.3938337266,
-0.1415581107,
-0.6821582913,
-0.3039672375,
-0.4181037843,
0.2693669796,
0.5695752501,
0.4148498476,
-0.9068419933,
0.4941845536,
0.2488986403,
-0.5005580783,
0.3087673485,
-0.0874070302,
0.3150582016,
-0.6706783175,
-0.031304013,
-0.0009293924,
-0.5256896019,
-0.4729060531,
-0.2108078003,
-0.0498595312,
0.2970179319,
-0.2451256514,
0.3781890869,
-0.2546453476,
0.1703974605,
-0.4444211125,
0.1633707732,
-0.1039738581,
0.1873608828,
-0.0682244748,
0.6579652429,
0.5042327046,
-0.498603195,
0.3408183157,
0.3929952383,
-0.0464125499,
0.7165396214,
-0.4159685671,
0.0663134083,
0.021635972,
0.3664663434,
-1.2055763006,
-0.3869909048,
0.4534423053,
-0.4385608435,
0.2942716181,
-0.3194382489,
-0.7825206518,
-0.0252254512,
-0.0941142589,
-0.0282699596,
0.083311066,
-0.7674078941,
1.0287981033,
0.6546311975,
-0.1947399676,
-0.6445835829,
-0.5843358636,
0.2811587155,
-0.0377250984,
-0.3975390196,
0.1673345715,
0.3453474045,
-0.6333835721,
0.0624623001,
-0.2764615417,
-0.1217018589,
0.0617636926,
0.4498083591,
0.3081542253,
-0.2055728883,
0.2426521331,
-0.0599314198,
-0.1645669639,
0.3529799581,
0.0715937838,
-0.0377279148,
-0.103862077,
-0.5160028934,
-0.5940022469,
0.1941598505,
0.6682052612,
-0.2677053213,
0.698738575,
0.4291982651,
-0.5676520467,
-0.0426959135,
-1.0196171999,
0.1713677645,
-0.4131387472,
-0.1379394531,
-0.007802539,
-0.7045841813,
0.5728791952,
-0.2915917635,
0.4305999875,
0.7648596764,
0.462536931,
0.1376658082,
0.5376938581,
0.5864868164,
-0.0855659768,
0.0860469788,
0.0229342543,
0.2191012651,
-0.2284027338,
-0.1352586895,
-0.5711889863,
-0.0566481948,
-0.5658988953,
-0.5609955788,
-0.0332647711,
-0.3497198522,
-0.2172354758,
-0.1033848599,
-0.3328178823,
0.4061883986,
0.3483716846,
-0.1579860449,
0.5413203239,
-0.0039172187,
0.3439201415,
0.1690480262,
-0.4166124165,
-0.5829513669,
1.0329737663,
0.4425679147,
0.2294755131,
0.3033635318,
0.3793799281,
0.7489115596,
1.0017112494,
-0.7548167706,
0.4335010946,
-0.2149604112,
-0.8633251786,
-0.1046179309,
-0.2339219451,
-0.1646133661,
0.3757636249,
-0.6008849144,
-0.5103837848,
0.3958332539,
0.4022476971,
-0.4039535522,
0.5815646052,
-0.3542726636,
0.5569694638,
-0.169532299,
-0.2108360678,
-0.2017873824,
-0.512144506,
0.5115849376,
0.0506063141,
0.1399251223,
-0.3235167861,
-0.0197206177,
0.6880965233,
-0.4227890074,
1.0699659586,
-0.5391783714,
0.0164554752,
0.6098163724,
-0.0528248101,
0.5112789273,
0.2516648769,
0.1210341454,
0.2592487931,
-0.050953716,
-0.2005814761,
-0.3874990642,
0.1439074278,
-0.3603011966,
-0.7553556561,
-0.8648615479,
-0.3867574334,
-0.1123613343,
0.01805293,
-0.0034761236,
0.3688012958,
-0.3652737141,
0.2911913395,
0.9124670625,
0.0721810535,
0.0789390206,
0.5179891586,
-0.0790202022,
-0.5326304436,
0.8358855247,
0.2327800691,
-0.0592286028,
0.2483078986,
0.0579586104,
-0.4829804897,
-0.5333291292,
-0.4047099054,
0.1999033988,
-0.7678231597,
-0.6033207774,
-0.7348138094,
-0.0369005762,
-0.2121446878,
0.044795014,
-0.4401115477,
-0.6751383543,
-0.0878409147,
-0.3817590773,
0.5981715918,
0.5680947304,
-0.4244459867,
0.3095769882,
-0.2598150969,
0.7360596061,
0.4667442143,
0.111185275,
-0.6276781559,
-0.3508448899,
0.1156668663,
0.0314795375,
-0.1893487573,
-0.6799862981,
-0.1304780245,
0.3034904003,
0.4982378781,
0.4937131405,
0.122681208,
0.2155134529,
-0.4848335385,
0.7552924156,
-0.0432594754,
-0.9379418492,
0.4483543634,
0.0331315845,
-0.4393750131,
0.7959039807,
0.3400975466,
-0.1977065802,
-0.4036776721,
-0.7467435598,
-0.7246819735,
0.2394515723,
0.0299405027,
0.0541534126,
-0.1568202078,
0.4648605287,
0.1432677507,
0.1858358234,
-0.5442023277,
-0.3650784492,
-0.2646492124,
-0.2618524432,
0.227624312,
-0.4584442079,
-0.713283062,
0.1929381639,
0.762810111,
-0.4696395695,
0.0973212123,
0.4643022716,
-0.3005091846,
-0.0482962281,
0.173330754,
0.541474998,
0.7444748878,
0.0123616401,
0.170869872,
0.2131968588,
-0.4035311341,
0.297624588,
0.5118198395,
-0.4183894992,
0.3751985729,
0.5367931724,
0.6928538084,
-0.1116403416,
-0.3993433714,
0.6468598247,
0.0179070514,
-0.0524197109,
-0.5526515841,
0.0187735129,
-0.124749057,
0.2881184816,
0.6386034489,
0.2795746922,
0.093243897,
-0.6596751213,
0.4937940538,
0.5638142228,
-0.0375522673,
-0.2064323276,
0.6687223911,
0.277703464,
-0.2143413872,
0.2865367532,
-0.1509226859,
-0.7289842367,
0.7388449311,
0.2290939689,
0.8068298101,
-0.2841986716,
0.4811166227,
0.1701519042,
0.5745019317,
-0.2404309958,
0.0169931278,
-0.0038682644,
-0.7129029632,
-0.5862342715,
-0.3101968169,
-0.7556814551,
-0.0214584563,
-0.2510508895,
0.0579234436,
-0.7171037793,
-0.1635937393,
0.1341712773,
0.2958939075,
-0.4818110764,
0.2719373107,
0.415708065,
1.0969947577,
-1.1056776047,
0.4122895002,
0.5949496031,
-0.5225567222,
-0.5430922508,
0.1771765053,
0.4545747042,
-0.559461534,
0.5728093386,
0.2199093103,
-0.1986228675,
-0.4523574114,
-0.7743368745,
-0.4971792698,
1.0760542154,
0.6957978606,
-0.2433996499,
0.2529306412,
0.1897182316,
0.3307303786,
-0.458840847,
-0.0830364898,
0.4170615375,
0.6988602877,
0.1754134446,
-0.627468884,
0.34767887,
0.2591086924,
-0.4691488147,
-0.0904664472,
-0.8797288537,
0.6617224216,
-0.1567475349,
-0.3569894135,
-0.0651258454,
1.2416704893,
0.3456784785,
0.5910329223,
0.8708569407,
0.5289683342,
1.2281585932,
-0.3034657836,
0.8978452086,
-0.2017368078,
0.1763430536,
1.0118944645,
-0.1862434149,
0.5797687769,
0.2294918299,
-0.1324281991,
0.4529466927,
0.4979400635,
-0.0657652915,
0.0394232199,
0.0240338426,
-0.4946009815,
-0.411558032,
-0.1787213981,
-0.0763766915,
0.5389435887,
0.6014811993,
-0.0588566549,
-0.0722415596,
-0.2743098438,
0.3297512829,
0.1789067537,
-0.1962708533,
0.4944474697,
-0.1621046066,
-0.6113442779,
0.2279136777,
-0.2406725287,
0.4364857972,
-0.4702456892,
-0.3716023862,
-0.3165854216,
-0.0312579386,
-0.3990497887,
-0.5468075275,
0.4643213451,
0.0391087756,
-0.1760443747,
0.0923759267,
0.8493198156,
-0.4774716198,
-0.3924827576,
-0.0935287476,
0.3992321491,
-0.1554470509,
-0.179657042,
-0.6134860516,
0.2399400473,
-0.1296029836,
-0.1820994169,
-0.1058368683,
0.6327074766,
0.0461447313,
0.683704555,
0.813878119,
0.1275343448,
-0.1467459053,
-0.3151934147,
0.7271710634,
-0.2792726457,
-0.2277435511,
-0.7235453129,
0.5489652157,
-0.2378228754,
-0.0699766055,
0.5197565556,
0.4786514342,
0.4289440811,
0.2405062616,
0.8961110115,
-0.3975279629,
0.5302647948,
-0.694971323,
0.6765579581,
-0.2809423506,
0.0739697888,
0.1481992751,
-0.6524128914,
-0.5744342208,
0.7583938837,
-0.0793617144,
-0.3138182163,
0.5146039724,
0.5845762491,
-0.161093235,
0.0064695599,
0.0275529586,
0.4908594787,
0.4990161359,
-0.0962735042,
0.5885634422,
-0.29702124,
0.3162468672,
-0.2049261481,
-0.2094222903,
-0.2265999615,
-1.0981693268,
-0.7237946987,
-0.570792675,
-0.8380035162,
-0.5073534846,
-0.1174576953,
0.7918057442,
0.6347843409,
-1.109244585,
0.1831759512,
0.0835811943,
0.3498234749,
-0.0173571389,
-0.2159513086,
0.4657177627,
-0.432808429,
-0.5913591981,
0.3205154836,
0.2505569756,
-0.1841757447,
-0.3512901366,
0.3166767061,
-0.6212475896,
0.578016758,
0.4450068772,
0.8579038978,
-0.7501839399,
-0.6862006187,
-0.6004932523,
0.1283920705,
0.110677354,
0.8197154999,
-0.8004735112,
0.3659402132,
0.3102581799,
1.0955253839,
0.2099379003,
0.2024855316,
0.3651338518,
-0.6630311012,
0.2562999725,
0.048761487,
0.512810111,
0.6302986741,
-0.4912499785,
0.7385616302,
0.4821882844,
-0.5047995448,
-1.02328372,
0.1556037962,
-0.9519132972,
0.1193155944,
0.9073429108,
-0.4181645811,
-0.2737155259,
-0.194992125,
-0.1011493057,
0.2479995787,
-0.1519818008,
0.8580803871,
0.8749375343,
-0.1082028151,
0.034155488,
-0.6804916263,
0.7294141054,
0.1726529449,
-0.7424358726,
0.2906367481,
0.8097751737,
0.3871597946,
0.6849814057,
0.7316676974,
0.1088490561,
0.3007881641,
0.0436948687,
-0.0860256702,
-0.1185550243,
-0.4594539106,
-0.1316778362,
0.2978335619,
-0.085013561,
-0.3633045256
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11068v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11068v1
|
Bridging Causal Discovery and Large Language Models: A Comprehensive Survey of Integrative Approaches and Future Directions
| 2024-02-16T20:48:53 | 2024-02-16T20:48:53 |
Guangya Wan, Yuqi Wu, Mengxuan Hu, Zhixuan Chu, Sheng Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Causal discovery (CD) and Large Language Models (LLMs) represent two emerging
fields of study with significant implications for artificial intelligence.
Despite their distinct origins, CD focuses on uncovering cause-effect
relationships from data, and LLMs on processing and generating humanlike text,
the convergence of these domains offers novel insights and methodologies for
understanding complex systems. This paper presents a comprehensive survey of
the integration of LLMs, such as GPT4, into CD tasks. We systematically review
and compare existing approaches that leverage LLMs for various CD tasks and
highlight their innovative use of metadata and natural language to infer causal
structures. Our analysis reveals the strengths and potential of LLMs in both
enhancing traditional CD methods and as an imperfect expert, alongside the
challenges and limitations inherent in current practices. Furthermore, we
identify gaps in the literature and propose future research directions aimed at
harnessing the full potential of LLMs in causality research. To our knowledge,
this is the first survey to offer a unified and detailed examination of the
synergy between LLMs and CD, setting the stage for future advancements in the
field.
|
[
-0.3836972713,
-1.0458381176,
1.0645400286,
0.2442365438,
0.1920556873,
0.1883711517,
-0.5013952851,
-0.7774534822,
0.013176295,
0.400641799,
-0.5842239857,
-0.4763536751,
-0.8824201226,
0.1575881541,
-0.4927196205,
0.731497407,
-0.0749007687,
0.1040243059,
-0.48290205,
0.0449745506,
-0.7020748258,
-0.6039665341,
-0.6383439302,
-0.5786810517,
0.751116693,
0.1956397891,
0.6057389379,
0.3752548695,
0.6361184716,
0.3660494983,
0.0005697494,
0.3240423203,
-0.3038209677,
0.0752578303,
-0.4468050003,
-0.357119143,
-0.324639082,
0.0162956119,
0.6548691988,
0.9607598186,
0.0819489062,
-0.0470139608,
0.0898415223,
0.386100173,
-0.5348259807,
0.3290121257,
-0.4251043499,
-0.1000826657,
-0.3945845068,
-0.4030112028,
-0.2710807621,
-0.3467579186,
0.2026747912,
-0.449998945,
0.2163150907,
-0.0636004955,
0.3723579943,
0.5081340075,
-0.963288486,
-0.6427568197,
-1.1690574884,
0.9563298225,
-0.8762664199,
0.2634192109,
0.168646574,
0.1872851253,
-0.6201440096,
-0.8410677314,
-0.7409543395,
-0.2635324895,
-0.1414791793,
0.0411942676,
-0.2400922775,
0.1080943421,
0.1703845263,
0.1912732273,
-0.4654789567,
0.6602074504,
-0.0472429842,
-0.3079828918,
0.7271488309,
0.4068982303,
0.5954200625,
0.2008989006,
-0.3013494313,
0.3221467733,
-1.0524201393,
-0.3025764227,
0.3153163791,
0.3094885945,
-0.1554124802,
0.5092793703,
0.0166740827,
0.7912819386,
-0.3067728281,
-0.1477556676,
-0.1922704577,
-0.7970019579,
-0.165451318,
0.09425129,
0.8935046196,
-0.1128909662,
-0.0844612122,
-0.4314910173,
-0.0246369187,
0.0335140638,
-0.0056460076,
-0.417673558,
-0.0645761415,
0.1857333481,
-0.2486898601,
0.0022657069,
0.0183692854,
-0.5215412378,
-0.6128102541,
-0.939528048,
0.2648976445,
-0.2223347723,
-0.300082922,
0.2076118737,
0.0555572324,
0.3061680794,
0.4552440047,
-0.6452620625,
0.2525479794,
0.8976394534,
0.6304143071,
-0.079830043,
-0.3632412553,
-0.4854184389,
0.3932969868,
-0.2742644846,
0.8873662353,
-0.4030438662,
-0.1265556663,
0.3394886851,
0.0560410991,
0.0010550013,
-0.4005100429,
0.9405457973,
-0.6843138337,
0.1701204628,
-0.5119144917,
-0.6484335661,
-0.4067557752,
0.1599075347,
-0.7472139597,
0.8308538795,
-0.2718756795,
-0.8105247021,
0.3845091164,
-0.5130732656,
-0.6149815321,
0.035386268,
-0.3029845059,
-0.3189814389,
-0.0560219288,
-0.1271543503,
0.6661521196,
-1.0054295063,
1.0108528137,
-0.4934888184,
-0.1929419637,
0.1285844147,
-0.4661620259,
0.6845062971,
-0.0541639142,
-0.6676691771,
0.219610095,
-0.6489855051,
-0.4179341197,
0.0987639725,
-0.2932748795,
-0.3938527107,
0.5380225778,
-0.0498347431,
0.3968421817,
0.3956694603,
-0.3213580251,
0.2539607584,
-0.1112812907,
0.4187173545,
0.7215005159,
-0.1243337542,
0.5204762816,
-0.0392097048,
0.1981901526,
0.1431308687,
0.1083459184,
-0.0703947917,
-0.345593065,
-0.5234209895,
-0.0271493476,
-0.0514888763,
0.4536744356,
-0.7525368929,
0.5602683425,
-0.2333897799,
-0.4590258002,
-0.1219196469,
0.1399552673,
0.3004076183,
0.4156503677,
0.3544013202,
-0.0752520785,
-0.5074583888,
-0.8594878316,
-0.3640416861,
-0.1564453691,
0.0373652205,
0.3100499809,
0.3995054364,
-0.4843066335,
0.9928644896,
-0.4094280005,
-0.3208998144,
-0.2138875872,
0.1194073409,
0.3768873811,
0.3359569013,
0.4227245152,
-0.8927748203,
-0.1423405707,
0.1529079527,
-1.0482348204,
-0.1392598748,
-0.0489803478,
0.1205968782,
-0.0514966436,
0.7235948443,
-0.6410959959,
0.1581866294,
0.3228349388,
-0.5216006041,
0.5591533184,
-0.2389869392,
0.0806664452,
-0.7762824893,
0.1078546867,
0.1338610351,
0.2286721468,
-0.8423079848,
-0.1717505753,
0.0557564087,
0.3723984957,
-0.0878381655,
0.634426415,
-0.7792360187,
-0.1987440884,
-0.1579352915,
0.147518605,
-0.4614088535,
0.1843781471,
-0.2408302128,
0.410179913,
0.4905811548,
-0.6535116434,
0.3878774941,
0.1167353913,
-0.174251169,
0.347659111,
-0.6047264934,
-0.1143107489,
-0.2185308486,
0.4759506881,
-0.9126991034,
-0.3861216605,
0.1212738156,
-0.1214978397,
0.4257467985,
0.0507088415,
-1.1267427206,
-0.3729635775,
-0.0920262039,
0.6637391448,
0.1722336113,
-0.5872010589,
0.5687783957,
0.6085246801,
-0.3344410062,
-0.4512773752,
-0.3706335425,
0.5496050119,
-0.4493370354,
-0.6281861663,
0.3691386282,
-0.2109387815,
-0.5040509701,
-0.2826711833,
0.2052583694,
-0.0191066843,
0.2428449392,
0.1135268882,
0.2210843712,
-0.1140647158,
0.2739283144,
-0.0261128861,
-0.0079541681,
0.4057574868,
-0.4338077605,
0.4578154683,
0.1390578449,
-0.3382605314,
-0.122865051,
0.3906817436,
0.6080645323,
-0.3172391355,
0.5856830478,
0.6355779171,
-0.3282087147,
-0.051344838,
-0.7099698782,
-0.1548962295,
-0.3872140348,
0.1221636534,
0.0661160648,
-1.0780411959,
0.4590620995,
-0.5107973814,
-0.0467357934,
0.4359483123,
0.7284639478,
0.2489887923,
0.8807089329,
0.7976831794,
-0.4449189603,
0.3292227387,
-0.0946004465,
0.6840209961,
-0.6871158481,
-0.4469565153,
-0.6384859085,
-0.1804232299,
-0.7115321755,
-0.3917533159,
0.5556559563,
-0.0839096904,
-0.4901885986,
-0.0844161361,
-0.141312331,
0.1029228345,
0.6238490939,
-0.0487086847,
0.5922898054,
-0.5193380713,
0.1414568573,
0.1805787385,
-0.6398963332,
-0.4620113969,
0.9748862386,
0.1985996217,
0.6259909868,
0.2603654265,
0.4067756534,
0.1644899994,
0.2767913938,
-0.5654956102,
0.5449724197,
0.2131130993,
-0.6201681495,
-0.3645264208,
-0.2709128857,
-0.9748176932,
-0.1011863649,
-0.1574610919,
-0.5303919911,
0.1544886231,
-0.1207232773,
0.137899816,
0.3102222085,
-0.4822122753,
0.677410841,
-0.332395494,
-0.6512728333,
-0.2655208111,
-0.9336022139,
0.856090486,
-0.2547988296,
0.521789968,
-0.0686950237,
-0.0311026648,
0.5674934387,
-0.1135289222,
1.1384366751,
-0.0781453848,
-0.6758844852,
0.1141928881,
-0.0647598207,
0.7355699539,
-0.0281613078,
0.1437918842,
0.3079124689,
-0.3588844538,
-0.2912937105,
-0.4440499544,
1.0996859074,
-0.6718794703,
-0.5351050496,
-0.3623767793,
-0.6628607512,
-0.3123499155,
0.4276655018,
-0.0865400806,
0.444761306,
-0.3154796362,
-0.2284730226,
0.788225174,
-0.4114669561,
0.6339088082,
0.7736822963,
0.2601570189,
-0.0723536536,
0.6965979934,
-0.0369607881,
-0.0112712951,
0.5237775445,
0.0721103027,
-0.2453735769,
-0.6739922166,
0.0880956277,
0.5714927316,
-0.6457154155,
-0.2828626931,
-0.6232727766,
0.0522481352,
-0.3713825345,
-0.1467206031,
-0.1710091382,
-0.0668026879,
-0.3993306756,
-0.1525920331,
0.3145745695,
1.1659566164,
-0.1324023753,
0.0505605713,
-0.6467772126,
0.1878518611,
0.008199391,
0.2905144691,
0.2364409119,
0.0530571491,
-0.4177768528,
-0.1322988868,
-0.3496300578,
-0.6935178041,
0.3570938408,
-0.0521205217,
0.6260440946,
0.4726779163,
-0.0106438538,
0.5966804624,
-0.7867311835,
0.8489364386,
0.2027328461,
-0.7119942904,
0.405821234,
-0.6047967076,
-0.0077247452,
0.0226052124,
0.6232087612,
-0.4255611002,
-0.4567640126,
-0.5339781642,
-1.0063092709,
0.3970720768,
0.0148071721,
-0.3319607079,
0.0058926446,
0.1865517795,
0.1536743492,
-0.0034512763,
-0.4620766044,
-0.2389811128,
0.5545514226,
-0.1592406929,
-0.4377326667,
-0.182755515,
-0.2828541696,
-0.1368290484,
0.462148428,
-0.1936687827,
0.1634669751,
0.196452409,
-0.0976807103,
-0.0260747019,
0.2250358313,
0.4839609861,
0.6012333035,
0.1357629597,
0.2850123942,
-0.0692979768,
-0.1920578927,
0.0614025146,
0.2069059461,
-0.0446036533,
-0.1479402483,
0.9601482749,
0.5133062005,
0.6304240823,
-0.7598853707,
0.3834254146,
0.0608867183,
-0.0451137349,
-0.5861536264,
-0.1770225018,
0.2358008176,
0.5281701684,
0.3695707321,
-0.2925804257,
0.3657377958,
-0.6906033158,
-0.0761367455,
0.7083874941,
-0.1355447322,
-0.6011819839,
0.8229323626,
0.0152982837,
0.1106996015,
0.3074875772,
0.1370434314,
-0.3905108273,
0.6479161978,
0.3845601678,
0.9019017816,
-0.1262466758,
-0.0292521268,
0.2441735417,
0.2835270762,
-0.0425632708,
0.0588804595,
-0.1588846743,
-0.7221257687,
-0.5248790383,
-0.4088716507,
-0.3351843953,
-0.1172643527,
-0.3370115757,
0.3528211713,
-0.0183553081,
0.1708248258,
0.0542244799,
0.1880252808,
-0.8606219888,
0.0381501652,
0.0623062141,
0.588113606,
-0.914963901,
0.7104952931,
0.530605495,
-0.4580807388,
-0.7325726151,
-0.0136788636,
0.2496952266,
-0.5300347805,
0.9115002751,
-0.2094756216,
0.0646136552,
0.0670673847,
-0.625711143,
-0.9810138941,
1.422842741,
0.2743122578,
-0.3637079298,
-0.1801546365,
0.2282920182,
0.491132021,
-0.1091045141,
0.3448998332,
0.9524091482,
0.7517926097,
-0.1058911532,
-0.9179495573,
0.2778902352,
0.1198700443,
-0.1319067031,
0.4417107701,
-0.5025373697,
0.7068683505,
-0.2011759281,
-0.2859925032,
-0.0207617637,
0.6028718948,
0.1387652904,
0.6458684802,
0.1413268447,
0.4032807648,
0.6958596706,
-0.0581700876,
1.1808004379,
-0.1871159822,
0.2696030736,
0.9441289306,
-0.4585529566,
0.3534789681,
0.5741152167,
-0.4134210646,
0.5117830038,
0.660065949,
0.3611645997,
0.3036401868,
0.2644307017,
-0.5294243097,
-0.0800777972,
-0.2527126372,
-0.109408021,
0.1669253111,
0.5924306512,
-0.1761213392,
-0.3845500052,
-0.0385336131,
0.208291918,
-0.0406944826,
-0.1932883859,
0.8948888183,
0.1294229776,
-0.6940081716,
0.239078626,
-0.1016886532,
0.6206077933,
-0.6614476442,
-0.1674063206,
-0.3090383112,
0.1590908468,
-0.2211599648,
-0.7195703387,
0.106952548,
-0.2656775117,
-0.2686591148,
-0.0678791031,
0.7856698036,
-0.5218361616,
-0.2413790673,
0.6638053656,
0.6161023974,
-0.140157938,
0.1250463724,
-0.168823272,
0.1308866143,
-0.282556802,
0.0362600163,
0.4412014782,
0.9117888212,
-0.2817845345,
0.7156041861,
0.8051378727,
0.174653247,
0.0730205998,
0.0590193383,
1.0269333124,
-0.9985284209,
-0.1122709662,
-1.0426889658,
0.3508681357,
-0.00548016,
-0.0502710715,
0.8544780016,
0.4193997085,
0.6241341233,
-0.0363126881,
0.8998045921,
0.0013794801,
0.4310392439,
-0.6545832157,
0.4166020155,
-0.4676550329,
0.4896619022,
-0.5686509609,
-0.6570270061,
-0.5673033595,
-0.2112900019,
-0.3755659759,
-0.1976667345,
0.691457212,
0.640293479,
0.0068316814,
-0.0613801852,
0.1813407987,
0.4879485369,
0.8993730545,
0.646243453,
0.982490778,
-0.153332755,
0.1393285394,
0.2200793773,
-0.4256429374,
-0.2157423049,
-0.9374899268,
-0.7468741536,
-0.8121036291,
-0.0450629964,
0.2117552906,
-0.1491572112,
0.5427038074,
0.1696106941,
-0.4851357043,
-0.2710697651,
-0.380240798,
0.4386032522,
0.0632488355,
-0.2582510114,
0.4956075251,
-0.4599618614,
-0.7508712411,
0.5485924482,
0.5109832287,
-0.1633098722,
-0.4474241734,
-0.0785909072,
-0.2694658637,
0.0588375628,
0.9818845391,
0.3934285939,
-0.8587560654,
-0.2032266408,
-0.1450163722,
0.1076346859,
-0.4337871373,
1.2407786846,
-0.7289826274,
0.169363752,
0.472479701,
0.8218418956,
0.1717913747,
-0.4868860841,
0.9094387889,
-0.3445366025,
0.0169827547,
0.292963922,
0.5336666703,
0.3228164017,
-0.4574601054,
0.6672309637,
0.2820201516,
-0.8578447104,
-0.7931329012,
0.3986597657,
-1.0417696238,
-0.3480010331,
1.1321582794,
0.1568726897,
0.2646566033,
-0.3682721853,
-0.1178453788,
0.2420178354,
0.0958212093,
0.70003438,
0.6567558646,
-0.2993506491,
0.206675753,
-0.6707502007,
0.4228562117,
0.0700325146,
-0.9451343417,
0.1706131846,
0.7595483065,
-0.0137603227,
-0.0057591614,
0.4949251413,
-0.2416124046,
-0.0345937163,
-0.5506480932,
0.0569494404,
0.303507179,
-0.2701917589,
-0.2935111523,
-0.028982237,
0.0056579397,
0.4964678884
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11060v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11060v1
|
Persona-DB: Efficient Large Language Model Personalization for Response Prediction with Collaborative Data Refinement
| 2024-02-16T20:20:43 | 2024-02-16T20:20:43 |
Chenkai Sun, Ke Yang, Revanth Gangi Reddy, Yi R. Fung, Hou Pong Chan, ChengXiang Zhai, Heng Ji
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
The increasing demand for personalized interactions with large language
models (LLMs) calls for the development of methodologies capable of accurately
and efficiently identifying user opinions and preferences. Retrieval
augmentation emerges as an effective strategy, as it can accommodate a vast
number of users without the costs from fine-tuning. Existing research, however,
has largely focused on enhancing the retrieval stage and devoted limited
exploration toward optimizing the representation of the database, a crucial
aspect for tasks such as personalization. In this work, we examine the problem
from a novel angle, focusing on how data can be better represented for more
efficient retrieval in the context of LLM customization. To tackle this
challenge, we introduce Persona-DB, a simple yet effective framework consisting
of a hierarchical construction process to improve generalization across task
contexts and collaborative refinement to effectively bridge knowledge gaps
among users. In the task of response forecasting, Persona-DB demonstrates
superior efficiency in maintaining accuracy with a significantly reduced
retrieval size, a critical advantage in scenarios with extensive histories or
limited context windows. Our experiments also indicate a marked improvement of
over 15% under cold-start scenarios, when users have extremely sparse data.
Furthermore, our analysis reveals the increasing importance of collaborative
knowledge as the retrieval capacity expands.
|
[
-0.6685948372,
-0.6093766689,
0.7030383945,
0.2147576809,
0.0632051453,
0.2560667992,
-0.2930006981,
-0.2962503433,
0.4350056946,
0.6374982595,
-0.7805571556,
-0.5149227381,
-0.1342294961,
-0.0669941455,
-0.1351740956,
0.8377203941,
0.5515703559,
0.0643920675,
-0.5075286627,
-0.0087914523,
-0.5690150261,
-0.7186329365,
-0.4953431189,
-0.5244045854,
0.7856805325,
0.6182115674,
0.6972840428,
0.550570786,
0.4479000866,
0.3280111849,
0.1799854636,
0.0413301438,
-0.7414335012,
0.5465921164,
-0.240822345,
-0.4069323838,
-0.5645659566,
-0.334869355,
0.3956781328,
1.2376697063,
-0.3463644087,
0.0083936593,
0.1006450653,
0.827485323,
-0.5763654113,
0.3288650811,
-0.5329269171,
-0.0718320385,
-0.2704333961,
-0.2130838782,
-0.5893917084,
-0.1666060239,
0.5696102381,
-0.5933141708,
0.3141852915,
0.3208712637,
0.2829487622,
0.1035099328,
-0.3788282871,
0.1598189175,
-0.8979204893,
0.8075990081,
-0.47283566,
0.5266503692,
0.3415241241,
0.5452356339,
-0.3213890493,
-0.6918925047,
-0.3399053812,
-0.1188274249,
-0.1958387047,
0.0934695154,
-0.0793835893,
0.0662751719,
0.2065285444,
0.2936697006,
-0.6018012166,
0.1652523577,
0.0170869585,
-0.1370760798,
0.5554795265,
0.4005110264,
0.0032822152,
-0.3069968522,
-0.1569851637,
0.091693975,
-0.6156131029,
-0.1397751123,
0.3223079443,
0.4655492008,
0.1010256484,
0.5347934961,
-0.4721183777,
0.6348302364,
0.4489511549,
-0.0027925505,
0.4348599911,
-0.2730582952,
-0.2348301858,
-0.3608286977,
0.7456137538,
0.3508281112,
0.0302360281,
-0.4699257612,
-0.1147236228,
-0.3154437244,
0.400949508,
-0.8259070516,
-0.3852533102,
0.3933552504,
-0.3926343024,
-0.0750659928,
-0.0519576445,
-0.9578314424,
-0.8156184554,
-0.6126350164,
-0.0930025131,
-0.5172864795,
-0.1329541355,
0.0665333793,
0.2875259221,
0.0070926654,
0.6208594441,
-1.0163918734,
0.4371515512,
0.7841206789,
0.4617976844,
-0.1102167517,
0.0449334942,
-0.7032058239,
0.375257045,
-0.1549602598,
0.9901181459,
-0.7010437846,
-0.5819123983,
-0.1121009961,
-0.2081110775,
0.1367689669,
-0.6285862327,
0.386700809,
-0.7167862058,
0.5453181267,
-0.6611754298,
-0.6460106373,
0.0799736381,
0.1618731618,
-0.5931773186,
0.7419618964,
0.2040849328,
-0.7663178444,
0.3645946085,
-0.4422353804,
-0.2469192594,
0.3462786674,
-0.2836974561,
-0.3207206726,
0.1257152706,
0.3006310761,
0.7084292173,
-0.4782036245,
0.240383774,
-0.6327725649,
-0.3910624683,
0.174867034,
0.3449998796,
0.372356385,
0.1962286085,
-0.0464503802,
0.2027350217,
-0.7172775865,
0.039850831,
-0.0041869408,
-0.4079602957,
-0.5799657702,
0.0369075909,
0.1182431206,
-0.0400071628,
0.5386533737,
-0.4136297703,
0.2037070245,
-0.7482731342,
-0.1562069356,
0.7642399669,
0.076091826,
0.8063092828,
-0.3522209823,
0.5095458627,
-0.0310941283,
-0.0904365033,
-0.4232549071,
-0.3554306924,
-0.5027352571,
-0.1655322611,
0.2311589122,
0.461075902,
-0.5786011219,
0.5517959595,
-0.5398291349,
-0.3814891875,
-0.3683093786,
0.2244079858,
0.290304184,
0.7591615319,
0.2608154118,
-0.5598173738,
-0.9036272168,
-1.2437517643,
-0.1896654367,
-0.2034294456,
-0.4772453904,
0.7661496401,
0.1691569537,
-0.312266022,
1.1421166658,
-0.8913500905,
-0.1946106255,
-0.3691728413,
-0.0419965759,
0.2954191864,
0.3767555356,
0.6867234111,
-0.8459780812,
-0.6996952295,
0.0673651248,
-0.5801411867,
-0.1614622474,
-0.0041979318,
-0.1466221362,
-0.0285551716,
0.0507759303,
-0.4132839739,
-0.031754896,
0.1995150298,
-0.2009334564,
0.4588671625,
-0.2063908577,
0.1888725758,
-1.2657206059,
0.261726141,
0.1965275556,
-0.4024509788,
-0.7334497571,
0.1684843153,
0.0693381429,
-0.0435389578,
0.0147259226,
0.4555129707,
-0.3546611667,
-0.2797094584,
-0.1521508843,
0.1590335518,
-0.1824535877,
0.6005734205,
0.0339002758,
0.6816433072,
0.3295603096,
-0.5004003048,
0.5599591732,
0.4378268123,
-0.4300660789,
1.0199159384,
-0.5819253922,
0.5178083181,
-0.5287300348,
0.2299326956,
-0.9617544413,
-0.6639001966,
0.1699545234,
-0.4286948442,
0.1460969597,
-0.1747307777,
-0.6897903681,
-0.2579868734,
-0.3039883971,
-0.0868115723,
0.4169204235,
-0.5048470497,
0.7125672102,
0.6284689307,
-0.2518523932,
-0.4274501503,
-0.4005905092,
0.1671531647,
-0.366122961,
-0.7210736871,
0.5307223797,
-0.5003235936,
-0.3616275489,
-0.3408565223,
0.0396478921,
-0.2281826735,
0.0185954869,
0.1818225682,
0.2256998718,
0.0589093082,
0.2069501132,
-0.0555453859,
0.0339715555,
0.0414934456,
-0.0994917229,
0.7802148461,
0.0623516589,
-0.0607838966,
-0.2235547304,
0.363573283,
0.3647110164,
-0.1016500294,
0.9082114697,
0.4864422679,
-0.4242230654,
-0.0490437411,
-0.806044817,
-0.2551290989,
-0.5088672638,
0.3457826078,
-0.5835599303,
-0.7904099822,
0.7601855397,
-0.1237699315,
0.0033708168,
-0.0362997986,
0.5260555148,
-0.2091149092,
1.1475622654,
0.7168511748,
-0.274374187,
0.5361269116,
-0.1338298768,
-0.0374788679,
-1.0532251596,
-0.806034863,
-0.580524087,
-0.3192355037,
-0.2861423194,
-0.2571846843,
0.4195776284,
-0.3330520093,
-0.3063931763,
0.4484683275,
-0.1995598227,
0.2890709639,
0.4052353203,
0.3655110002,
0.4524623454,
0.1694253236,
-0.0207432061,
-0.6611035466,
-0.382722348,
-0.247294724,
1.2377789021,
0.1893983781,
0.7043738961,
0.3623991609,
0.7919403911,
0.0791664794,
0.3458648622,
-0.8471558094,
0.6328291893,
-0.0782865137,
-0.547604382,
-0.1108019724,
-0.5603041053,
-1.0380796194,
0.4165325165,
-0.3410829008,
-0.8600195646,
0.2679879665,
0.1763009727,
-0.502477169,
-0.149073869,
-0.7390652895,
0.5993827581,
0.0590850636,
-0.6823891997,
-0.3636818826,
-0.6222625971,
0.3310190737,
-0.3480491042,
0.1660783589,
0.0529930703,
-0.3686947525,
0.5505126119,
-0.3958712816,
0.7748994231,
-0.243201673,
0.0259824861,
-0.2406104207,
0.1313515157,
0.6158803701,
0.0156995822,
-0.3517576158,
-0.602784574,
-0.2398537993,
-0.3660702407,
-0.947614193,
1.0263519287,
-0.5321053267,
-0.795648694,
-0.1061934158,
-0.4470603764,
-0.8355555534,
0.2600009739,
0.0507077314,
0.2999105453,
-0.4769356549,
0.6276118159,
1.0231375694,
-0.3454053402,
-0.0292458441,
0.7441778779,
-0.3967499733,
-0.4122856557,
0.561671555,
-0.0270381682,
-0.2703628242,
0.6462991238,
0.1574773937,
-0.4380396008,
-0.5508355498,
-0.148666203,
0.2099143714,
-0.4833136499,
-0.1328764707,
-0.8203708529,
0.3141238689,
-0.5802586675,
0.1235399097,
-0.1973635703,
-0.2399192005,
-0.3672862649,
0.0168567635,
0.0078720637,
0.4815666974,
0.2988640368,
0.4893443286,
-0.5319923162,
0.2384572923,
0.2274731696,
0.4969179034,
0.1373705566,
-0.3816039264,
-0.3994782865,
-0.0849794075,
-0.2920882702,
-0.9308367968,
0.5777266026,
0.0425593145,
0.5888807178,
0.2724692822,
0.1009817496,
0.8308409452,
-0.4087479711,
0.4611811936,
0.1043551788,
-0.6045411825,
0.648458302,
-0.7145524621,
0.370819062,
0.5983874202,
0.4325206578,
-0.6501988173,
0.0592282824,
-0.6254513264,
-0.8997532129,
0.6128122807,
0.0163724776,
0.1939211637,
0.2516297102,
0.5357732177,
0.241438061,
0.5869903564,
-0.3424952328,
-0.3306057453,
0.0894665122,
-0.0739428103,
-0.1512360871,
-0.182594806,
0.0312831253,
-0.2954202294,
0.3694728911,
-0.2874141634,
0.148440823,
-0.1395941526,
0.1571284384,
-0.20968692,
0.2688196898,
-0.0997308046,
0.7144550681,
-0.3171949983,
-0.322996527,
0.0833049417,
-0.1437850595,
-0.1544804871,
0.2132229656,
-0.1401202232,
-0.2187777162,
0.1742476821,
0.697271347,
0.5469048619,
-0.7115639448,
0.4236921966,
-0.1277987361,
0.1932813227,
-0.4575379789,
0.0870075673,
0.2234613597,
0.2121587098,
0.4549406767,
0.1195805594,
0.5679746866,
-0.6072018743,
0.119179599,
0.5510815978,
0.0932392254,
-0.4896403551,
0.7377333045,
0.2440292835,
-0.082274206,
0.6563553214,
0.2734362781,
-0.0486203432,
0.2822165489,
0.3373874426,
0.7292910814,
-0.5542553067,
0.3242886364,
0.3181422949,
-0.2837657928,
-0.0766590536,
0.1382829696,
-0.0503920019,
-0.6753101349,
-0.3741820157,
-0.6282307506,
-0.5661832094,
0.2966362834,
-0.7341839671,
0.1288054883,
-0.7821176648,
-0.2875705957,
0.1095572039,
0.3813766539,
-0.7876354456,
0.2260037214,
-0.0858831406,
0.7377548218,
-0.388286829,
0.8596231937,
0.8242502809,
-0.2665124834,
-0.5685529709,
-0.0538646728,
0.1136034429,
-0.5131111741,
0.4950174689,
-0.006925493,
0.0846828595,
-0.0493033901,
-0.421826303,
-0.8877469301,
1.0685607195,
0.7471389771,
-0.7544261813,
-0.136480853,
-0.0029829408,
0.952916503,
-0.6407042742,
0.0215592347,
0.7286807299,
0.4492097497,
0.3705923259,
-0.7833660841,
-0.01821585,
-0.1673789322,
0.2584964335,
0.0410116203,
-0.5601373911,
0.4587153196,
-0.2018970549,
-0.0998566002,
0.3528887928,
0.8322305679,
0.2066928148,
0.282335341,
0.3630021811,
0.429246068,
0.9722585082,
-0.0444285348,
1.323004365,
-0.1479360908,
0.0963949859,
1.3409508467,
-0.4048722982,
0.8732299209,
0.3102398813,
-0.2749310732,
0.7351518273,
0.6893455386,
0.1138663888,
0.665620625,
-0.0689311773,
-0.355489552,
-0.4605441391,
-0.1816773415,
-0.2422345579,
0.132460162,
0.3466138542,
-0.3268525898,
0.1120709255,
0.0003415481,
0.0007285028,
0.5133501291,
-0.2105582356,
0.8571639657,
-0.0927147642,
-0.7668707371,
0.2032416314,
0.0242572501,
0.6723632216,
-0.4207413495,
0.3666613102,
-0.4883005917,
0.2818892896,
-0.3427901268,
-0.6775909662,
0.2693738043,
-0.2003109604,
-0.4279958606,
-0.3037329614,
0.6774830818,
-0.4416106939,
-0.1734024435,
0.3151639402,
0.752179265,
-0.1208581924,
-0.2428147644,
-0.7055281997,
0.023524683,
-0.0577106886,
-0.4091776609,
0.6571233273,
0.0989542529,
0.2024306059,
1.0401031971,
0.5309918523,
0.0495082922,
-0.3434299231,
0.1823738068,
1.0788171291,
-0.4846774936,
-0.5512082577,
-0.6079821587,
0.3755910993,
-0.26670748,
0.1709550917,
0.9263352156,
0.8847862482,
0.7193453312,
-0.2848822773,
0.8635029197,
0.114649035,
0.9545106888,
-0.1688653827,
0.4418126941,
-0.383318007,
0.7933816314,
-0.5448989868,
-1.1517773867,
-0.3025326133,
0.413721025,
-0.555865407,
0.3010574281,
0.3986623883,
0.7704353929,
-0.0997408628,
-0.1229577288,
0.2893790305,
0.2384199202,
0.3612955511,
0.5090343356,
0.355091691,
-0.0770394355,
0.4593781233,
-0.4439435601,
-0.270042181,
-0.1683682799,
-0.4923271239,
-0.9661613703,
-0.841267705,
-0.238395378,
-0.2786458135,
0.0685096383,
1.0745391846,
0.8586022854,
-0.781291008,
-0.4367170632,
0.1354278624,
-0.1302880049,
0.1785467267,
-0.2429723442,
0.1475106925,
-0.1426216662,
-0.9907085896,
0.5829308033,
0.151910305,
0.0214799456,
-0.5337215662,
-0.2509387434,
0.1925339997,
-0.0171146467,
0.6287038922,
0.2646845877,
-0.4563939571,
-0.1993529052,
0.2648631334,
-0.0240482427,
0.0987786651,
0.8497548103,
-1.3752162457,
0.5439267755,
0.5952781439,
0.6008964181,
0.6780612469,
0.2640800476,
0.9893407822,
-0.9601576924,
-0.0837775245,
0.2375293225,
0.4475749135,
0.731523931,
-0.6370803118,
0.4905435741,
0.2545126677,
-0.4442806542,
-0.6698558331,
0.333515197,
-0.9790450335,
-0.2478004396,
0.8698933721,
-0.101538986,
-0.0982784405,
-0.209106192,
-0.3788674474,
-0.2679857612,
-0.8059315681,
0.9557548761,
0.5557801723,
-0.3879300952,
-0.3972770274,
-0.2853403687,
0.4755761027,
0.2740550637,
-0.8897383213,
0.1481680423,
0.9392284155,
0.4148121178,
0.1390296668,
0.8218153715,
0.1295792609,
0.1001498625,
-0.460899055,
-0.4470119178,
0.0163654294,
-0.2971842885,
-0.1441521049,
0.513677001,
0.0837971643,
0.3293319345
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11058v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11058v3
|
II-MMR: Identifying and Improving Multi-modal Multi-hop Reasoning in Visual Question Answering
| 2024-02-16T20:14:47 | 2024-06-03T01:09:38 |
Jihyung Kil, Farideh Tavazoee, Dongyeop Kang, Joo-Kyung Kim
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Visual Question Answering (VQA) often involves diverse reasoning scenarios
across Vision and Language (V&L). Most prior VQA studies, however, have merely
focused on assessing the model's overall accuracy without evaluating it on
different reasoning cases. Furthermore, some recent works observe that
conventional Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting fails to generate effective
reasoning for VQA, especially for complex scenarios requiring multi-hop
reasoning. In this paper, we propose II-MMR, a novel idea to identify and
improve multi-modal multi-hop reasoning in VQA. In specific, II-MMR takes a VQA
question with an image and finds a reasoning path to reach its answer using two
novel language promptings: (i) answer prediction-guided CoT prompt, or (ii)
knowledge triplet-guided prompt. II-MMR then analyzes this path to identify
different reasoning cases in current VQA benchmarks by estimating how many hops
and what types (i.e., visual or beyond-visual) of reasoning are required to
answer the question. On popular benchmarks including GQA and A-OKVQA, II-MMR
observes that most of their VQA questions are easy to answer, simply demanding
"single-hop" reasoning, whereas only a few questions require "multi-hop"
reasoning. Moreover, while the recent V&L model struggles with such complex
multi-hop reasoning questions even using the traditional CoT method, II-MMR
shows its effectiveness across all reasoning cases in both zero-shot and
fine-tuning settings.
|
[
-0.5643881559,
-1.0758056641,
0.7103498578,
-0.0050322986,
-0.166171968,
0.2473008931,
0.1758245677,
-0.508757174,
-0.2818291485,
0.2175779194,
-0.7433905005,
0.0691778436,
-0.5276215672,
0.1588561684,
0.1329475641,
0.3874609172,
-0.22507447,
0.3398058414,
-0.2682677209,
-0.3003061712,
-0.9502955675,
-0.4139830172,
-0.5455618501,
0.152461648,
0.855223,
0.6856721044,
0.3537124395,
0.4333507717,
0.852343142,
0.2819266617,
-0.1887728721,
0.6875298619,
-0.2369300872,
-0.0238519758,
0.056675382,
-0.4700520933,
-0.3153900802,
-0.2360467166,
0.5961210132,
0.2458158731,
0.2864457667,
0.2590917647,
-0.1720653027,
0.7863635421,
-0.8804568052,
0.0174653009,
-0.6012827158,
-0.1192035824,
-0.1418614388,
-0.7073633671,
-0.466339469,
-0.0845745429,
0.0889817551,
-0.5379319787,
-0.0191833284,
-0.08437749,
0.6156740785,
0.3981374204,
-0.9029923081,
-0.2124032825,
-0.8183229566,
0.5758205652,
-0.2098947167,
0.4935212731,
0.1213845536,
0.8973556757,
0.0401686318,
-0.5269834399,
-0.8939409256,
0.0317271724,
0.1430186331,
0.3670157492,
-0.2015911937,
-0.0366015993,
0.4680388868,
-0.0043852394,
-0.5526978374,
-0.4386827052,
-0.6877919436,
-0.3967383504,
0.0928833261,
0.3112938702,
0.1601015925,
-0.0767591223,
-0.6653683186,
-0.0833056867,
-0.3779660165,
0.851637423,
0.0082148835,
0.0687503293,
0.2375635207,
0.9248325825,
-0.4820545018,
0.8238357306,
-0.0096205529,
-0.2898674905,
0.2691867948,
-0.7002129555,
0.1312761158,
-0.5071877837,
0.3785025775,
0.7547585964,
0.3328455091,
0.4005531371,
-0.0281941202,
0.0603265613,
0.0896193236,
-0.7669124007,
-0.1538568586,
0.1230969355,
-0.5456336737,
0.1521892697,
0.1578114033,
-0.6942921877,
-0.1554370224,
-0.3026394248,
0.8731664419,
-0.5686581135,
-0.2561672926,
-0.0507682078,
-0.5535510778,
0.8040162325,
0.7821193337,
-0.2866460979,
-0.0115878731,
0.677413702,
0.825355351,
0.2073486,
-0.3891310394,
-1.1277662516,
0.0043689273,
-0.2522700131,
1.0831203461,
-0.5606435537,
0.025502082,
-0.1923242211,
0.040701773,
-0.277695626,
-0.4152073562,
0.3840715885,
-0.7369766831,
0.1404194385,
-0.7861933112,
-0.192873016,
-0.3737764359,
0.7195265293,
-0.4850593507,
0.744997859,
-0.1391105652,
-0.8716830015,
0.5109241009,
-0.58105582,
-0.1027145535,
-0.111379452,
-0.4113945067,
-0.1706942767,
-0.1237342581,
0.6402568221,
-0.0364382863,
-0.2362875342,
-0.1862332523,
-0.2360627353,
-0.4662527144,
0.3566406369,
-0.6632832885,
0.585247159,
0.2199345082,
-0.2772868872,
0.2879825234,
-0.586897254,
0.2917219698,
0.056983225,
-0.2976226807,
-0.2957106233,
-0.0243401174,
-0.238519311,
0.498917073,
-0.0230484903,
-0.3734798133,
0.2748927176,
-0.0146817099,
0.200827837,
0.6847819686,
0.2196126431,
0.2192724496,
-0.3991271555,
0.5609079599,
0.3492742479,
0.3663879931,
-0.3854098022,
-0.976567328,
-0.8653535843,
-0.5540620089,
-0.088556096,
0.8326022029,
-1.2231711149,
-0.324428916,
-0.0157729387,
-0.2143674642,
-0.6213456392,
-0.112506628,
0.6005977392,
0.6898400784,
0.6100111008,
-0.1493450701,
-0.4320147038,
-0.6232458353,
-0.2082473636,
-0.2632328868,
0.1520159245,
0.3883697391,
0.482814163,
-0.2634440362,
0.7815659046,
-0.2836484015,
-0.1253999025,
-0.0120602213,
0.3173972964,
-0.1428758353,
0.112489894,
0.2445985228,
-0.9884330034,
-0.3326557577,
-0.1824184954,
-0.5314103961,
-0.0283414163,
-0.2933579981,
-0.2029295862,
-0.0540605262,
0.584982574,
-0.5387296081,
0.5036412477,
0.1476739943,
-0.5236074328,
0.7255191803,
-0.2230771631,
0.5996887684,
-0.773989141,
-0.0792935714,
-0.0622933023,
-0.0485910028,
-0.4080429673,
0.1081902757,
0.2411898375,
0.2739133537,
-0.3545821607,
0.614957273,
-0.6529595852,
0.0891491026,
-0.1705974936,
-0.2285364568,
0.0460171737,
0.4751090109,
0.0539324023,
1.0899372101,
0.4809780717,
-0.5736153126,
0.3940344751,
0.2529957891,
-0.1067530736,
0.8995211124,
-0.6789650321,
0.1764212251,
-0.4985305965,
0.1909734607,
-1.5471105576,
-0.095810473,
0.3881172836,
-0.787468493,
-0.0030190994,
-0.325186193,
-0.2580936551,
-0.6350010633,
-0.2648317218,
0.7588763237,
0.2124822587,
-0.6222890615,
0.7494658828,
-0.0221723467,
0.0806823373,
-0.7566360235,
-0.3852885067,
0.0529669933,
-0.1687328517,
-0.6961790919,
-0.263985604,
-0.4706251621,
-0.2774264812,
-0.1856860667,
-0.1411945373,
-0.4119152129,
-0.2345629334,
0.0939899981,
0.3243938684,
-0.4203850925,
0.0862632021,
-0.0831180289,
-0.4463824034,
-0.0255818218,
0.0577822924,
0.1999510378,
-0.5018333793,
-0.584405899,
-0.4090633094,
0.6611447334,
0.836040318,
-0.7988255024,
0.297173053,
1.0784003735,
-0.0785210431,
0.2132934779,
-0.7136244774,
-0.1307524443,
-0.4215118885,
0.2050431967,
-1.0562382936,
-1.0011789799,
0.2137455493,
-0.2358284146,
-0.1704077125,
0.2859781682,
0.7051265836,
-0.3736351728,
1.2447780371,
0.5624710917,
0.5215901732,
0.2100926042,
-0.2709031999,
0.2434501499,
-1.0045264959,
-0.5504947901,
-0.2275071144,
-0.2710476518,
-0.2877894044,
-1.0002518892,
0.9407129288,
0.3339693546,
-0.1903709173,
-0.065085426,
-0.3786407113,
0.5054340363,
0.9062930346,
0.1595486999,
0.3798463941,
-0.2075800896,
-0.233983621,
0.0673902482,
-0.5991533399,
-0.1991645396,
0.8386276364,
0.242524758,
0.5005883574,
0.4633852243,
0.1641888618,
-0.0309529342,
-0.2519624233,
-1.0325188637,
0.4471372068,
0.3371272683,
-0.6079247594,
-0.1988106817,
-0.4621326923,
-0.6183143854,
0.4195572734,
-0.2698066831,
-0.5958941579,
0.3423312902,
0.3334022164,
-0.4471412599,
0.1874741763,
-0.5921747684,
0.8028789163,
-0.2670240104,
-0.2748446763,
-0.0627857298,
-1.1225939989,
0.5523665547,
0.3023466766,
0.3161396384,
0.1273584664,
-0.0745614618,
0.3701967001,
-0.571105957,
0.5027014613,
-0.1891639233,
0.2671705782,
0.6722960472,
0.0723814964,
0.3926198184,
-0.0911795869,
0.3203916252,
-0.0322607085,
0.2185703814,
-0.3411722481,
-0.6058263779,
0.2188798636,
-0.5434863567,
-0.3444483876,
-0.5214111209,
-0.5280595422,
-0.3799024224,
0.0584563911,
0.3090336025,
0.6582362652,
0.1911647469,
0.207812801,
0.6535291672,
0.0456620343,
0.3742168844,
0.4103662074,
0.0194676723,
-0.7620956898,
0.6449919939,
-0.0077320542,
0.3272040486,
0.5866658688,
0.2605569959,
-0.4201763868,
-0.1659454107,
-0.9504467845,
0.0476232171,
-0.7337197065,
-0.2730656564,
-0.8542823195,
-0.1854514331,
-0.0117553165,
-0.0891944766,
-0.1769830883,
-0.3203491569,
0.0443910584,
0.0788267329,
0.480784446,
0.2569397092,
-0.3440888226,
0.1809455454,
-0.6926646233,
0.8463657498,
0.9599195719,
0.2297160625,
-0.0247019939,
-0.4684849977,
0.1321227849,
0.0485291183,
-0.1383270472,
-0.932258606,
-0.1466792077,
0.1428221315,
0.3901146948,
0.3444858193,
-0.1403371245,
1.1254729033,
-0.7780770063,
0.5869976282,
0.4578224719,
-0.6971435547,
0.5811448693,
-0.2336419523,
0.3768217564,
0.5631758571,
0.1516250819,
-0.4064227641,
-0.0409818664,
-0.0183154438,
-0.7009400129,
0.2889074385,
0.0826548338,
-0.1246224493,
-0.0199101772,
0.1178152487,
-0.0318733118,
-0.0134859839,
-0.5152179003,
-0.217349723,
-0.0906515121,
0.1585827619,
0.2270556539,
-0.5667769313,
-0.0680584088,
-0.5446430445,
0.3538171649,
-0.3358100653,
0.3578676581,
0.433539331,
-0.0858919397,
-0.3116067052,
0.3251746297,
0.4285258651,
0.7472692728,
-0.2500365078,
0.4551135302,
-0.0397183709,
-0.2858594954,
0.2031865269,
-0.1048371568,
-0.1640918106,
-0.0567604862,
0.3993711174,
0.6005307436,
-0.4221899807,
-0.8316755891,
1.0589404106,
-0.3151561618,
-0.2184834629,
-0.1420333534,
-0.039847441,
-0.0631378964,
0.8023263812,
0.3130528629,
0.41990152,
0.4664749503,
-0.6159911156,
0.4266906977,
0.56983459,
-0.6463406682,
-0.0449521393,
0.7317205667,
0.0014978504,
-0.1972334087,
0.6762222052,
-0.2182269692,
-0.5972489715,
0.5124653578,
0.4204337001,
0.6444728374,
-0.1017557606,
0.3531975746,
0.6494886875,
0.5890737772,
0.157963559,
0.8764457107,
-0.1429568678,
-0.552136302,
-0.5836715698,
-0.1591338664,
-0.3615011275,
-0.1630040854,
-0.6211557984,
0.2380363643,
-0.2721312046,
-0.1043535843,
0.0434413403,
-0.3470880389,
-0.7728026509,
0.277495116,
0.283787787,
0.8344296813,
-0.6270133257,
0.4925078452,
0.5766835809,
-0.6428809166,
-0.8671150208,
0.0845400319,
0.4945839047,
-0.8710157275,
0.4934695065,
0.3357591331,
-0.550591886,
-0.0849887207,
-0.5692678094,
-0.6803426147,
1.1584726572,
-0.1419551075,
-0.3324480355,
0.2072455436,
-0.079354085,
0.2578397095,
-0.1471342593,
0.6802509427,
0.1921508014,
0.4974576533,
0.8206332326,
-1.0465852022,
-0.0985510126,
-0.6082920432,
0.0207202677,
0.1061128601,
-0.7233019471,
0.9201331735,
-0.8660205007,
0.0622916222,
0.1840964556,
0.4210524261,
0.5879380703,
0.7518222928,
0.6289404631,
0.3312290311,
0.6768031716,
-0.0223132316,
0.6523968577,
0.1370095313,
0.0087969229,
1.2277122736,
0.0272344276,
1.066691041,
0.7901032567,
0.088722676,
0.3867926598,
0.4853729606,
0.2446952909,
0.6714395881,
-0.0036228059,
-0.1835576892,
-0.6225274205,
0.0114554809,
-0.4856568277,
0.6713655591,
0.0945500657,
0.1830419451,
-0.0450674146,
0.0670095086,
-0.2000571787,
-0.184467271,
-0.2433883846,
0.9108852744,
-0.104467757,
-0.4788021743,
0.6264273524,
-0.1470391452,
0.3966331184,
-0.3875116706,
-0.4645984471,
-0.0658695176,
0.1080971807,
0.1935569942,
-0.8203815818,
0.124669306,
0.138368383,
-0.3413353562,
0.104237847,
0.5976117253,
-0.3660185337,
-0.6274351478,
0.1648317724,
1.1461209059,
0.0629877746,
-0.3259907961,
-0.619132936,
-0.1157063246,
-0.2092685848,
-0.1060222313,
-0.2091887742,
0.9648224711,
-0.202199623,
0.8117768764,
0.7170011997,
-0.3113858402,
0.3385461867,
0.1350444257,
0.8421905637,
-0.700912714,
-0.4244930148,
-0.6349724531,
1.0123665333,
-0.0409619659,
-0.373703599,
0.574200809,
0.5693335533,
0.6220665574,
-0.0901636705,
0.6168481112,
-0.0434494205,
0.6220064759,
-0.6143382788,
0.1307506412,
-0.8630353212,
0.1369362921,
-0.2930485606,
-0.667139411,
-0.3005279005,
0.599571228,
-0.2582292259,
-0.1605414152,
0.7291793227,
0.9118666053,
-0.2305624932,
-0.3323419094,
0.2458315343,
0.1493635774,
0.290132314,
0.7139992714,
1.3698012829,
-0.4671865702,
0.8101842403,
-0.1039949656,
-0.6054170132,
-0.3104214072,
-0.6549546719,
-0.7420958281,
-0.7029349208,
-0.1923343986,
-0.3393768966,
0.00801259,
0.6986959577,
0.5132847428,
-0.579077661,
0.0297062006,
0.0654096305,
0.032931067,
-0.6727238297,
-0.2249284834,
0.1714023352,
-0.1935708076,
-0.2243541777,
0.3875468075,
0.5170870423,
-0.2244499028,
0.1601364166,
-0.1418859363,
-0.3601283133,
0.1867834032,
0.8912757039,
0.2321958542,
-0.9470511675,
-0.6226561666,
0.4461823106,
0.0773138031,
0.3782476187,
0.7355147004,
-0.7229761481,
1.0726253986,
0.5624354482,
0.5089299083,
0.3378836513,
0.1536028087,
0.2943281829,
-0.3227228522,
-0.083970584,
0.2222182453,
0.2499967366,
0.0433912687,
-0.0803538412,
0.3937895298,
0.3861544132,
-0.4328691065,
-0.4208056331,
0.3926879466,
-1.4479991198,
-0.2198816091,
1.2384104729,
0.291002214,
-0.0381125994,
-0.1705355346,
-0.8169719577,
0.1234598458,
-0.1153575182,
0.4839369655,
0.46896106,
-0.3669882715,
-0.6015014648,
-0.7593775988,
0.247854054,
0.0759301633,
-0.7845463753,
-0.1877881736,
0.94068259,
0.2622632682,
-0.0356524959,
1.0680032969,
-0.0378548801,
0.7506849766,
0.1218320653,
-0.2919488549,
-0.152973026,
-0.8569844365,
-0.1087156758,
0.0999977812,
0.0267082732,
-0.5902337432
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11051v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11051v1
|
Large Language Models Fall Short: Understanding Complex Relationships in Detective Narratives
| 2024-02-16T19:59:45 | 2024-02-16T19:59:45 |
Runcong Zhao, Qinglin Zhu, Hainiu Xu, Jiazheng Li, Yuxiang Zhou, Yulan He, Lin Gui
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Existing datasets for narrative understanding often fail to represent the
complexity and uncertainty of relationships in real-life social scenarios. To
address this gap, we introduce a new benchmark, Conan, designed for extracting
and analysing intricate character relation graphs from detective narratives.
Specifically, we designed hierarchical relationship categories and manually
extracted and annotated role-oriented relationships from the perspectives of
various characters, incorporating both public relationships known to most
characters and secret ones known to only a few. Our experiments with advanced
Large Language Models (LLMs) like GPT-3.5, GPT-4, and Llama2 reveal their
limitations in inferencing complex relationships and handling longer
narratives. The combination of the Conan dataset and our pipeline strategy is
geared towards understanding the ability of LLMs to comprehend nuanced
relational dynamics in narrative contexts.
|
[
-0.1312320232,
-0.5765181184,
0.8762168288,
0.1583831757,
-0.2308115959,
0.4042657316,
-0.0015364776,
-0.8505687714,
0.0860836804,
0.6163759828,
-0.7681325674,
-0.3464661837,
-0.7463905811,
0.279440552,
-0.0330137946,
1.1979224682,
-0.0049837306,
-0.1327320337,
-0.0524054691,
-0.2886688709,
-0.2188279778,
-0.5014512539,
-0.7891901731,
-0.3687743247,
0.9552081227,
-0.1694467515,
0.9551364183,
0.7242979407,
0.610858798,
0.0819865465,
-0.1473285556,
0.5984705091,
-1.0305800438,
0.2149513662,
-0.050967779,
-0.5061256289,
-0.5781412721,
0.103524819,
0.3144358099,
1.016749382,
0.2311574519,
0.0447821952,
-0.1901724935,
0.5819572806,
-0.6817048192,
0.8317258954,
-0.2779564559,
0.1099661514,
-0.3604035676,
-0.1049685106,
-0.3123705983,
-0.2364501506,
0.5157929659,
-0.7494267821,
0.2582662702,
0.2366361469,
1.0026865005,
-0.1162554547,
-0.6954638362,
-0.5867042542,
-0.7172150612,
0.5209773779,
-0.3935329914,
-0.0626255125,
0.7071572542,
0.4584578574,
-0.305536598,
-0.681750834,
-0.3201592565,
-0.4131540656,
-0.1281484663,
0.0243790392,
-0.3242946267,
0.0976387858,
0.2934730053,
0.3286479115,
-0.387763679,
-0.0156566873,
-0.5234145522,
0.0230418872,
0.7888189554,
0.7364297509,
0.2532839477,
-0.2322669327,
0.0842779651,
-0.2574958205,
-0.9265091419,
0.1233587116,
0.6695412993,
0.2685985565,
-0.0561543219,
0.5157592297,
0.1802823842,
0.3852097094,
-0.113624081,
-0.3003301322,
0.0316530131,
-0.0105747618,
-0.010329823,
0.0706868321,
1.0542687178,
0.5616347194,
0.8141206503,
-0.2043954581,
0.2525117099,
-0.0914016068,
0.1828763783,
-0.8002336621,
-0.4106742144,
0.0350845121,
-0.334105432,
-0.5087153912,
-0.1660486013,
-0.6965660453,
-0.8230919838,
0.117981486,
0.0345187001,
-0.291913271,
-0.2737273872,
0.0140871927,
-0.2170304805,
0.1693466157,
0.4739999771,
-0.7385526896,
0.3554911911,
0.7178666592,
0.9302104115,
-0.2081920654,
-0.2968996763,
-0.657759726,
0.5564246774,
-0.6175646186,
0.3876560628,
-0.6431024671,
-0.1484834999,
0.0114414832,
0.2298877835,
0.1048582718,
-0.3528113365,
0.6064326167,
-0.5310830474,
-0.0956281945,
-0.218854323,
-0.4055503607,
-0.1422618926,
0.3438298702,
-0.8501572609,
0.5687814951,
0.0686226562,
-0.8150346875,
0.1237691715,
-0.1234344169,
-0.6587896943,
-0.1675663739,
-0.0823462084,
-0.3357097805,
0.0947104394,
0.4208053946,
0.8838992715,
-0.6833215952,
0.5756512284,
-0.7583685517,
-0.3423181772,
0.0099712843,
-0.181300208,
0.8534891605,
0.182335183,
0.1439305842,
-0.2959467769,
-0.9159127474,
-0.6052368283,
0.3953814209,
-0.0566493571,
-0.5807751417,
0.3733075857,
-0.0852094218,
-0.1853510886,
0.0791626275,
-0.4371182919,
0.3592351079,
0.0530296341,
0.7999433279,
0.4369116724,
-0.0106437216,
-0.0018188013,
-0.0840200186,
0.852651298,
-0.2090486735,
-0.330812335,
-0.2203383595,
-0.3630335629,
-0.4560516477,
-0.2731066644,
0.0648378879,
0.5398383141,
-0.4117367268,
0.4116672873,
-0.4972741604,
-0.5723944306,
-0.4054860771,
-0.1953931302,
0.4389590025,
0.1664659381,
0.1006892771,
-0.3501741886,
-0.2774893641,
-0.7034152746,
-0.3667654991,
-0.4693548977,
-0.173733741,
0.2240564078,
0.297939539,
-0.2979679108,
0.9789628386,
-0.9101658463,
-0.4115017354,
-0.5085943937,
0.2634429038,
0.1215975583,
0.1669891328,
0.4347943366,
-0.3788578808,
-0.3257783055,
0.0837376937,
-0.9283738136,
0.1131519824,
0.0077581294,
0.2402424961,
-0.5348907709,
0.661652863,
-0.6445233226,
0.4329353273,
0.5336138606,
-0.0379114449,
0.8063463569,
-0.0963921845,
-0.0506403334,
-0.8984866738,
-0.0559277982,
0.1343398988,
-0.5379830599,
-0.4930213988,
-0.1017844155,
-0.0299873296,
-0.4030603468,
0.1110939011,
0.3963597417,
-0.605930984,
-0.3168201447,
0.2965068221,
0.4003610015,
0.1508840621,
0.6173119545,
0.1215309128,
0.5229010582,
0.3322103024,
-0.2152186185,
0.5453336239,
0.2022221386,
-0.498511225,
0.4820412993,
-0.8592939973,
0.0909237862,
-0.2000079602,
0.5967034698,
-1.112039566,
-0.5280140638,
-0.0527267046,
-0.2604361176,
0.5184339285,
-0.7538522482,
-0.8157051802,
-0.1612201631,
-0.2447035462,
0.4779268801,
0.1654073149,
-0.3852465749,
0.3825177252,
0.5254496932,
-0.2624586225,
-0.5406281352,
-0.629018724,
0.2679962814,
-0.3712225556,
-0.7866874337,
-0.0751346722,
0.1489418894,
-0.3634161055,
-0.0342888348,
-0.0229349919,
-0.481292963,
-0.0366454571,
0.0855324268,
0.021635171,
-0.3214999735,
0.0933302715,
0.2081339806,
-0.08305154,
0.2234710306,
0.5940703154,
0.4325017631,
-0.1905389279,
0.0047494676,
-0.2663913965,
0.170261845,
1.0714436769,
-0.3302341104,
0.7452687025,
0.5741379857,
-0.1844349355,
-0.0034033556,
-0.2563112974,
0.2015545964,
-0.3774950206,
0.6928994656,
-0.6565881371,
-0.9840444326,
0.8405339718,
-0.1040214151,
-0.3400478065,
0.2350270897,
0.0065388433,
-0.0595549047,
1.1436630487,
0.3827838898,
-0.2987729907,
0.0992688388,
-0.1872805655,
0.7375520468,
-1.1206605434,
-0.0251439717,
-0.1976452172,
0.0991231352,
-0.6926112771,
0.0499521755,
0.3708290756,
0.4698592722,
-0.0994645581,
0.6342449188,
-0.0242783204,
0.5400406122,
-0.0585271902,
-0.0581129342,
0.5741892457,
-0.233105734,
0.4056774974,
-0.1673375666,
-0.4324873984,
-0.582219243,
1.0085244179,
0.6010476351,
0.9947730899,
0.3000702858,
0.2287177891,
0.1496076733,
-0.1278655529,
-0.714507401,
0.3172932863,
-0.2667810917,
-0.6736289263,
-0.3238731623,
-0.5374143124,
-1.4226584435,
0.2062353343,
0.0149997333,
-0.8704901338,
0.2669059634,
-0.2865241766,
-0.3760184646,
0.2145218253,
-0.5361248255,
0.7534050345,
0.0775696784,
-0.4250047505,
-0.1200248525,
-0.9358178973,
0.612611115,
0.1339790225,
0.1415135711,
-0.589238584,
0.2402663082,
0.6494931579,
-0.5302732587,
0.8875749111,
0.2681670189,
-0.1285645813,
0.1482281387,
0.6242412925,
0.744053185,
0.1535519511,
-0.2429146469,
-0.0385148264,
0.1993117183,
-0.3480106592,
-0.4524566531,
0.5573117733,
-0.8026992679,
-0.2701969147,
-0.62591362,
-0.7867900133,
-0.4713597,
0.0576915443,
0.1685199887,
0.8222745061,
-0.3630796373,
0.2375642061,
0.4235298634,
-0.110389784,
0.1987651587,
0.2193904519,
-0.0832331702,
-0.2170000672,
0.6787976027,
0.1238697171,
0.4230830073,
0.2643191814,
0.1863815933,
-0.1337906271,
-0.5314100385,
-0.332703948,
0.4237806201,
-0.5862184763,
-0.0499693379,
-0.7868819237,
-0.1128348261,
-0.2563711703,
-0.1556490213,
-0.3607649803,
-0.1222917289,
-0.3386691213,
-0.2640501261,
0.4442196488,
1.1230541468,
0.2724208832,
0.266692698,
-0.7804321051,
0.2635599971,
0.4228806794,
0.1195502579,
0.2276679575,
-0.1273191124,
-0.0624169223,
-0.2933553755,
-0.1602496654,
-0.7720137239,
0.5362040401,
0.1682762802,
0.1505502611,
0.6094655991,
0.2814214826,
0.9839470387,
-0.401404053,
0.7444065213,
0.0853806362,
-0.757084012,
0.4191984534,
-1.0282771587,
0.0140235722,
0.6786743402,
0.4358852208,
-0.4255948067,
-0.4897773266,
-0.4577945471,
-0.7514656782,
0.8845685124,
0.3703231514,
0.0742651299,
-0.124299705,
0.3600637913,
0.0975990295,
0.4073613286,
-0.8650933504,
-0.1807111949,
0.4119080305,
-0.2176623195,
-0.289575994,
-0.3157417774,
-0.0803642347,
-0.1369090974,
0.2217840701,
-0.1224376857,
0.037872076,
0.2403879464,
-0.1926179975,
-0.2228870243,
-0.2042190135,
0.2443529963,
1.1307830811,
-0.6513444781,
0.2039329708,
-0.1325993389,
-0.5078182817,
-0.186139822,
0.0416664183,
0.3466043472,
-0.262460947,
1.2285144329,
0.8836824894,
0.1192496046,
-0.8355106115,
0.75197047,
-0.1450823694,
0.1616437435,
-0.2491823137,
-0.0007678503,
0.1757270545,
0.3198675811,
0.2788337171,
-0.205408752,
0.0260548405,
-1.3284404278,
-0.1222770661,
0.0962437838,
-0.7310928702,
-0.3723238707,
0.4924441874,
0.0669220388,
-0.210613966,
0.7488281131,
-0.4546081126,
-0.4199209809,
0.795303762,
0.4256024659,
0.8020322919,
0.2083638757,
0.2826912105,
0.3113695383,
0.3884703815,
-0.1378500313,
-0.4850532711,
0.1497988999,
-0.6410717964,
-0.5111185312,
-0.3533401191,
-0.4203639627,
0.4762833118,
-0.9480622411,
0.1340108365,
-0.5111512542,
0.2638809383,
-0.084450528,
0.3597148955,
-0.4661679566,
0.0018242681,
-0.3651964664,
0.3824353218,
-0.9059836864,
0.9066929221,
0.1354929358,
-0.5560478568,
-0.7791507244,
0.2745342255,
-0.0973433554,
-0.8512096405,
0.6064306498,
0.336879909,
-0.2452859432,
-0.2513202131,
-0.524136126,
-0.5680496097,
1.1913790703,
0.4895592034,
-0.7088316083,
-0.154394269,
0.0524915941,
0.9766703844,
-0.8170148134,
0.2033035755,
0.7277167439,
0.2202760428,
0.0367678478,
-0.8747498989,
0.1376152635,
-0.1953988224,
-0.2543392777,
0.2326007783,
-0.7662806511,
0.8014319539,
-0.2235942185,
-0.0980511606,
0.2265169919,
0.3929849267,
0.3212562501,
0.5944974422,
0.4899017215,
0.3957396746,
0.8103096485,
-0.0098756673,
1.2998348475,
0.1093074456,
0.3313252628,
1.41949296,
-0.5118319392,
0.568674922,
-0.0113157919,
-0.3464872241,
0.4989125729,
0.9187645316,
-0.1810943782,
0.5262853503,
0.2537287474,
0.066257298,
-0.3327708542,
-0.0013014497,
-0.3711642027,
0.2982712388,
0.3923076689,
-0.2813647389,
-0.0194377638,
-0.3456550837,
0.4680093229,
-0.0930985957,
-0.2854367197,
0.5756838322,
0.182624802,
-0.5400066376,
0.215485692,
-0.2596811652,
0.2163919806,
-0.8194271326,
-0.004266989,
-0.1342480332,
0.1497941911,
-0.0170497354,
-0.8701769114,
0.029545676,
-0.0377197377,
-0.1483691335,
0.2983826399,
0.4376024008,
-0.5266962647,
-0.5299742818,
0.7192365527,
0.2608638108,
0.3200859725,
-0.1365599334,
-0.3462032974,
0.2743119597,
-0.1361326873,
-0.0378992856,
0.3190033734,
0.8723017573,
-0.1293342113,
0.6734206676,
0.5558974743,
0.087013863,
-0.1156352684,
0.0741228983,
0.6369517446,
-0.4525880516,
-0.4710535705,
-0.6684217453,
0.1812485009,
-0.2388714701,
-0.6246120334,
0.6130955219,
0.427408874,
0.4277869463,
0.1316191405,
0.6366215944,
0.1243979707,
0.3646555245,
-0.3447769284,
0.5914648175,
-0.4998208582,
0.4903207421,
-0.5572633147,
-1.0216193199,
-0.3587876558,
0.5522527099,
-0.3295131326,
-0.2852657437,
0.827760458,
0.5596320629,
-0.2399552613,
0.0110692941,
0.2735595107,
0.3237204552,
0.5851792693,
0.7248296142,
0.9384996295,
-0.4401421547,
0.826431334,
0.1676841974,
-0.1013349667,
-0.1933835596,
-0.9190119505,
-1.5012567043,
-0.513892591,
-0.1758528352,
-0.2228782177,
0.2729579508,
0.5901898146,
0.8389114141,
-0.3400272429,
-0.4189939797,
-0.238818571,
0.0549215823,
-0.1139154807,
-0.2487491518,
0.6379705667,
-0.0782426298,
-0.6137235165,
0.4373103678,
0.3123318255,
-0.2702231109,
-0.3710989356,
-0.1261301339,
-0.003913309,
0.0223037843,
0.7686777711,
0.129162848,
-0.591801703,
-0.4015617967,
-0.3610033989,
0.1020966023,
0.1174656451,
1.0499550104,
-0.2848681509,
0.5929824114,
0.4981150925,
0.4486201108,
1.0854183435,
-0.2057982981,
1.0112935305,
-0.6232674718,
-0.1085575595,
0.2071890682,
0.2497819215,
0.2781174481,
-0.5227190852,
0.8708685637,
0.1467926055,
-0.5509341955,
-0.9380611777,
0.4774945676,
-1.2162802219,
-0.39606601,
0.9863283038,
-0.6316123605,
-0.1717861891,
-0.4957361221,
-0.1317989379,
0.0390955284,
-0.485591948,
0.6258046031,
0.9920067191,
-0.279453367,
-0.1243575662,
-0.7138295174,
0.5082987547,
-0.1114159971,
-0.6519236565,
0.6398156881,
0.4206723571,
0.0586621687,
0.3383599222,
0.4366796613,
-0.1666826457,
-0.1344964504,
-0.0310175139,
-0.5861055255,
-0.1831281036,
-0.3601613939,
0.0546029061,
0.4498819709,
-0.2833686173,
0.2084690332
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11035v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11035v2
|
Retrieval-Augmented Generation: Is Dense Passage Retrieval Retrieving?
| 2024-02-16T19:28:52 | 2024-04-16T20:22:21 |
Benjamin Reichman, Larry Heck
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Dense passage retrieval (DPR) is the first step in the retrieval augmented
generation (RAG) paradigm for improving the performance of large language
models (LLM). DPR fine-tunes pre-trained networks to enhance the alignment of
the embeddings between queries and relevant textual data. A deeper
understanding of DPR fine-tuning will be required to fundamentally unlock the
full potential of this approach. In this work, we explore DPR-trained models
mechanistically by using a combination of probing, layer activation analysis,
and model editing. Our experiments show that DPR training decentralizes how
knowledge is stored in the network, creating multiple access pathways to the
same information. We also uncover a limitation in this training style: the
internal knowledge of the pre-trained model bounds what the retrieval model can
retrieve. These findings suggest a few possible directions for dense retrieval:
(1) expose the DPR training process to more knowledge so more can be
decentralized, (2) inject facts as decentralized representations, (3) model and
incorporate knowledge uncertainty in the retrieval process, and (4) directly
map internal model knowledge to a knowledge base.
|
[
-0.2537365854,
-0.7422368526,
0.658804059,
-0.1356575638,
-0.1817242205,
0.2197283208,
-0.2338680029,
-0.3660442531,
-0.00778392,
0.7689625621,
-0.2613154948,
-0.0378074311,
-0.5312718749,
0.0890518054,
-0.295458287,
0.8960023522,
0.0418121293,
0.17652224,
-0.0500992015,
0.0465383381,
-0.3543274701,
-0.6199727654,
-0.6847943664,
-0.5107104778,
0.6201306581,
0.4252562225,
0.6517803669,
0.7584164143,
0.7186022401,
0.3273091912,
-0.2966335714,
0.3512485921,
-0.7064788342,
0.3224222064,
-0.3103379011,
-0.6077822447,
-0.2063642293,
-0.1214740053,
1.0211315155,
0.9129900336,
-0.1097685471,
-0.0631653219,
0.0886861235,
0.8886922598,
-0.699495852,
-0.2874824703,
-0.8751652837,
0.0399134196,
-0.2179354727,
-0.4380879998,
-0.4588649571,
0.004256954,
0.2119360119,
-0.4016308486,
0.4840895534,
0.2252532691,
0.6966648698,
0.3471207917,
-0.4175586998,
-0.2421942502,
-0.7232859731,
0.6972166896,
-0.3498671949,
0.4282339811,
0.403125912,
0.3511641026,
-0.1627129018,
-0.9924579263,
-0.5865975022,
-0.3474515975,
-0.1965320259,
-0.1960047781,
0.3156102896,
0.2549026608,
0.1742748022,
0.6958957314,
-0.3187372088,
0.0474849083,
-0.3745592237,
-0.002353797,
0.7360340953,
0.1493199915,
0.2552657425,
-0.2172003388,
-0.4828769565,
-0.2110395283,
-0.6355031133,
-0.2206508666,
0.2771426737,
0.5448471308,
0.2145175934,
0.7554882765,
-0.3094004989,
0.9580721855,
0.2143514305,
0.0203155149,
0.0687501878,
-0.5686458945,
-0.1158440188,
0.1957509518,
0.6136456132,
-0.1587079167,
0.0308790002,
-0.214235276,
-0.6309162974,
-0.6606526375,
0.5102522373,
-0.7155591249,
-0.270178467,
0.0764206946,
-0.377179414,
-0.2326559126,
-0.0181069262,
-0.3494495749,
-0.3987249434,
-0.6862635612,
0.6007197499,
-0.4754118621,
-0.5319642425,
0.3392776549,
-0.415863961,
0.0442762151,
0.1998715699,
-1.013910532,
0.4782726467,
0.8415187597,
0.7668191791,
0.0421391241,
-0.3426667452,
-0.4172816873,
0.2069816142,
-0.3316097558,
0.6499460936,
-0.6351543665,
-0.0794892386,
-0.1584714651,
-0.3611554801,
-0.0517785437,
-0.5648267269,
0.2620944679,
-1.0695873499,
-0.097665213,
-0.66175735,
-0.6706312895,
-0.0738477856,
0.3770955503,
-0.7337579727,
0.937346518,
0.1486414671,
-0.9386804104,
0.4650332034,
-0.2797387838,
-0.175790146,
0.0805977583,
-0.2960266173,
-0.2119498849,
0.2299948782,
0.1502940804,
0.4054426849,
-0.1152701899,
0.1876513362,
-0.2272690684,
-0.4099317193,
0.2405311465,
-0.3244718015,
0.754472971,
0.3508951068,
-0.0541663691,
-0.2633493245,
-0.6179418564,
-0.0580525026,
0.0630567446,
-0.417576164,
-0.5983765721,
-0.1621936262,
-0.3923020065,
-0.0670988932,
0.3594384789,
-0.5348861217,
0.5757747889,
-0.3596591651,
0.3190585673,
0.5452061296,
0.4131427407,
0.8755112886,
-0.2826961577,
0.2493148297,
0.1385322809,
0.0992608443,
0.0304990429,
-0.0418267772,
-0.5190140605,
-0.1368026584,
0.4199861288,
0.1648262143,
-0.7127229571,
0.0107496735,
-0.2597382665,
-0.4206112027,
-0.4434293509,
0.1838633418,
0.3893477023,
0.6589128971,
0.4054042697,
-0.0833633691,
-0.4838613868,
-0.6453730464,
-0.1381927282,
0.0374918357,
0.293228358,
0.3442129791,
0.484713465,
-0.1338419467,
0.735159874,
-0.5188127756,
-0.3562370241,
-0.3975073099,
0.0566605404,
0.2183826268,
0.5470690131,
0.3647193611,
-1.0661741495,
-0.4689319134,
0.0497353338,
-0.5560753345,
0.0812301487,
-0.1183607876,
-0.291451484,
-0.3908343911,
0.7170171738,
-0.3926369846,
0.0113219451,
0.2295056731,
0.0169717278,
0.5082634687,
-0.4105695188,
0.1778231859,
-0.9435557723,
-0.0736350492,
-0.3782160282,
-0.0513552837,
-0.5501986146,
0.2266044319,
0.0960229561,
-0.1178281233,
-0.159256041,
0.54776752,
-0.846648097,
-0.346819818,
-0.3430801332,
0.292561233,
0.3156898618,
0.2196577191,
0.1111090705,
0.9755961895,
0.4154719412,
-0.8244408965,
0.1322452873,
0.3633614779,
-0.3622688949,
0.1219881028,
-0.7161715627,
0.2340860814,
-0.3459427059,
0.1086184755,
-0.8696376085,
-0.2083754241,
-0.1437568218,
-0.2477390319,
0.7098366618,
-0.338452518,
-0.4832292497,
0.0300893169,
0.0763531849,
0.6955096722,
0.1552586257,
-0.5413697362,
0.4734841585,
0.4684814513,
-0.0372682624,
-0.9152668715,
-0.5850847363,
-0.0327804089,
0.0942956507,
-0.5235749483,
0.5677761436,
0.314076066,
-0.4616399407,
-0.0751634166,
0.0562709533,
-0.3486870527,
0.0394159742,
-0.1765071303,
-0.1797787845,
-0.1468833089,
0.3659303486,
0.1894770563,
0.1592371464,
-0.1334876269,
-0.1117950082,
0.6273150444,
0.0647311807,
-0.4717284441,
-0.2001749724,
0.2305758893,
0.1779816598,
-0.6478643417,
0.7502579093,
0.4029803276,
-0.200169757,
-0.4374347329,
-0.5263012052,
-0.4658658803,
-0.4957762957,
0.3166480362,
-0.6115970016,
-0.889330864,
0.4562133551,
-0.0743383765,
-0.2136770487,
0.2311223894,
0.3103105426,
-0.0422772765,
0.8832944632,
0.7175049782,
0.1281030327,
0.6902057528,
-0.5457243919,
-0.0993865505,
-1.154727459,
-0.2243941873,
-0.5127894282,
-0.4644515514,
-0.3608516455,
-0.3689858317,
0.4335179329,
0.5318972468,
-0.3991830647,
0.1462423503,
-0.635171473,
0.5692212582,
0.4869694114,
0.5355555415,
0.4372090995,
0.138285622,
-0.1870816052,
-0.0968417525,
-0.9654401541,
-0.2419885546,
1.114151001,
0.2214873731,
0.6973404884,
0.0619197153,
0.981025815,
0.137408331,
0.0452425033,
-0.4846135378,
0.4265090823,
-0.1073680893,
-0.7456703782,
-0.3536514938,
-0.5469347239,
-0.9213760495,
0.1589732021,
-0.212074548,
-0.2015680373,
0.4498710334,
0.1103934944,
-0.3933892548,
0.3530584574,
-0.558208406,
0.5155243874,
-0.4216545224,
-0.4571248591,
-0.3707067668,
-0.5570350289,
0.3010788858,
0.0377535298,
-0.2736798525,
0.2160726935,
-0.0727798194,
0.3292178512,
-0.347433418,
0.6991904974,
-0.2800196111,
0.0097330296,
0.4167903662,
0.2192696333,
0.4537080526,
0.1725499183,
-0.2932599485,
-0.1120207831,
-0.2120732367,
-0.3880243599,
-0.7125248909,
0.4905828536,
-0.866115272,
-0.4733339548,
-0.3544094265,
-0.4663888216,
-0.1121751219,
0.3850220442,
0.1643881649,
0.6816703081,
-0.0242874902,
0.3093601763,
1.0586423874,
-0.0884026289,
0.0613688566,
0.5037394166,
-0.1075950786,
-0.2901369333,
0.7723296881,
0.2976307869,
0.3605243266,
0.9223962426,
0.1842065006,
-0.4994599521,
-0.9790502787,
-0.2256595194,
0.3889467716,
-0.5784160495,
-0.1939945221,
-0.6985216737,
-0.3581885099,
-0.3586068451,
0.0570355877,
-0.4599663317,
-0.3177232146,
-0.4129645228,
-0.0878877714,
0.4027762711,
0.8368247747,
-0.2882185578,
0.3703862131,
-0.8138630986,
0.3714824915,
0.3192453086,
0.4394610226,
0.0674271286,
-0.6816036105,
-0.3692354262,
0.2465974241,
-0.130484581,
-0.7019066215,
0.1641562879,
0.3438890874,
0.498136133,
0.191457957,
0.1621241421,
0.7455095649,
-0.5435041189,
0.508046329,
-0.2396792471,
-0.4463236928,
0.6005499959,
-0.4249708354,
-0.1131249666,
0.8582602143,
0.4632204473,
-0.1198862866,
-0.0259982441,
-0.4685398042,
-0.6216855645,
0.4200029671,
-0.1883565187,
0.1548678726,
-0.1005001515,
0.964414835,
-0.0052760746,
0.3279549181,
-0.4215287864,
0.1118996516,
-0.0273792893,
0.0120003177,
0.008415523,
-0.4415188134,
-0.1451024711,
-0.2686068714,
0.3968481123,
0.0732863694,
0.0955893919,
0.6402984858,
-0.2596313059,
-0.0894954801,
0.0450764857,
0.3565342426,
0.778334856,
-0.2650572658,
0.1725355983,
-0.1243982166,
-0.5584278703,
0.1513215899,
-0.0401174724,
-0.2928881645,
-0.1280089766,
0.3994980454,
0.8358867168,
0.1531676352,
-0.4047160745,
0.4692579508,
0.0022375614,
-0.109442465,
-0.412332505,
0.160786733,
-0.4116847217,
0.4718215466,
0.5223013759,
-0.0176397208,
0.3102512062,
-0.4101288021,
0.4572047889,
0.4739467204,
-0.267180413,
-0.190908581,
0.5736601949,
0.0111832712,
-0.1046717241,
0.8585125804,
-0.2207204103,
-0.5379441381,
0.2476943731,
0.4098974466,
0.6384667754,
-0.0062946198,
0.1560631096,
0.5383009911,
0.3701158166,
-0.3778217435,
0.3033562899,
-0.3496910036,
-0.9203003049,
-0.8159262538,
-0.7363524437,
-0.3506869376,
0.0155453151,
-0.7536674142,
0.0749945268,
-0.4125647247,
-0.0734854043,
-0.2776999176,
0.3815345764,
-0.5107693076,
0.2521473765,
-0.0732162669,
0.9899104238,
-0.6014986634,
0.7014576793,
0.5272752047,
-0.6532880664,
-1.0733331442,
-0.0386927389,
-0.4804212749,
-0.7842949629,
0.9527464509,
-0.1810519546,
0.0522048771,
0.257781446,
-0.5634946227,
-0.9704930186,
0.961497426,
0.3801653087,
-0.6253482103,
-0.1539855301,
0.1559980363,
0.6114351749,
-0.2639166117,
0.1821459085,
0.3428670466,
0.2344993949,
-0.1426738948,
-0.696121335,
-0.0394271798,
-0.038579952,
0.0348637812,
0.2149808705,
-0.5867768526,
1.0850015879,
-0.3173514605,
-0.156738013,
-0.0741247162,
0.6606855989,
0.2936314046,
0.0776154175,
0.3971832991,
0.8392885327,
0.6793622375,
0.05682908,
1.2490224838,
-0.2746584415,
0.0630754009,
1.2087862492,
-0.1969032586,
0.9554918408,
0.4578472674,
0.024616899,
0.401656121,
0.5570436716,
0.2777615786,
0.6630237699,
0.0608996376,
-0.3491098285,
-0.2704903781,
-0.1910846531,
-0.4270795584,
0.4724139571,
0.3950302601,
-0.4706868827,
-0.0077206478,
-0.0618716031,
-0.3096502125,
0.2302782834,
-0.488529563,
1.0245678425,
0.0920039639,
-0.6986665726,
0.6769515872,
-0.3162115216,
0.1906903386,
-0.5068014264,
-0.179426074,
-0.2771593034,
0.3040567636,
-0.1735019982,
-0.9332350492,
0.2296935618,
-0.4176153243,
-0.3555601835,
-0.3492386937,
0.9275121093,
-0.5020059347,
-0.1904421002,
0.2754190564,
0.6447643638,
0.0109253777,
-0.3465219438,
-0.747761786,
0.0882966146,
-0.0746611133,
-0.3453412056,
0.4721570611,
1.0013030767,
0.1433714777,
0.6487374902,
0.595202744,
0.329844296,
0.1981173754,
0.3539085388,
1.0064293146,
-0.4473128617,
-0.1578686237,
-0.5814373493,
0.5048553944,
-0.1888798177,
-0.1470624954,
0.694450438,
0.3905476928,
0.8740080595,
0.116216518,
0.5475216508,
0.0476071462,
0.6385331154,
-0.5376561284,
0.6612139344,
-0.6922717094,
0.2404570132,
-0.1169046685,
-0.9462237954,
0.0483028367,
0.473986119,
-0.3056197762,
0.0718066171,
0.4202830195,
0.8472479582,
-0.249147132,
-0.2591859996,
0.0637506843,
0.2265174985,
0.0808518082,
0.1304864138,
0.8595778942,
-0.5238564014,
0.4740237892,
-0.6112371683,
-0.1814964861,
-0.1275161803,
-0.636877954,
-0.6552650928,
-0.7088592649,
0.0244037416,
-0.141800344,
0.0372412764,
0.4783420265,
0.5202535391,
-0.3700521588,
-0.143024385,
-0.3802565932,
0.0543967038,
-0.1517330259,
-0.2094321698,
0.1538703144,
-0.7319376469,
-0.4930499196,
0.5926238894,
0.0541237481,
0.1087698787,
-0.3408005238,
0.0342755169,
-0.38183406,
-0.3083527684,
0.4142552316,
0.1802049428,
-0.1602059007,
-0.169673115,
0.1974311471,
-0.2033360898,
-0.1901149452,
0.972674489,
-0.6284759641,
0.5840962529,
0.7566990852,
0.932356298,
0.5942140222,
0.1832891554,
0.7405652404,
-1.09499681,
0.2418763489,
0.5356300473,
0.3140060306,
0.3845477402,
-0.4899867475,
0.4473293722,
-0.0617499687,
-0.9909430742,
-1.0023347139,
0.4356246889,
-0.8100324273,
-0.2363837063,
1.0777125359,
0.2289706618,
-0.1399164498,
-0.1791610122,
-0.2717681825,
0.3359322548,
-0.0998891816,
0.7486560345,
0.3164782226,
-0.0577344708,
-0.2079256773,
-0.4574525058,
0.7105787396,
0.3036645651,
-0.2518695891,
0.0637096241,
0.4845934212,
0.1567879319,
0.2476533502,
0.9235861897,
-0.0836004987,
0.0331193767,
0.119110465,
-0.1340468824,
-0.201692611,
-0.5099953413,
-0.2356232256,
0.2214920074,
0.20943968,
0.1370181143
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11034v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11034v2
|
PAT-Questions: A Self-Updating Benchmark for Present-Anchored Temporal Question-Answering
| 2024-02-16T19:26:09 | 2024-06-03T18:36:59 |
Jannat Ara Meem, Muhammad Shihab Rashid, Yue Dong, Vagelis Hristidis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Existing work on Temporal Question Answering (TQA) has predominantly focused
on questions anchored to specific timestamps or events (e.g. "Who was the US
president in 1970?"). Little work has studied questions whose temporal context
is relative to the present time (e.g. "Who was the previous US president?"). We
refer to this problem as Present-Anchored Temporal QA (PATQA). PATQA poses
unique challenges: (1) large language models (LLMs) may have outdated
knowledge, (2) complex temporal relationships (e.g. 'before', 'previous') are
hard to reason, (3) multi-hop reasoning may be required, and (4) the gold
answers of benchmarks must be continuously updated. To address these
challenges, we introduce the PAT-Questions benchmark, which includes single and
multi-hop temporal questions. The answers in PAT-Questions can be automatically
refreshed by re-running SPARQL queries on a knowledge graph, if available. We
evaluate several state-of-the-art LLMs and a SOTA temporal reasoning model
(TEMPREASON-T5) on PAT-Questions through direct prompting and
retrieval-augmented generation (RAG). The results highlight the limitations of
existing solutions in PATQA and motivate the need for new methods to improve
PATQA reasoning capabilities.
|
[
-0.4310941994,
-0.9292120337,
0.7756664157,
0.3931844831,
-0.2951447666,
0.3306777477,
0.1187740117,
-0.4292316437,
-0.0411469489,
0.5960563421,
-0.8629254699,
-0.0961904153,
-0.0763378069,
0.2592137158,
0.1348185241,
0.5709016919,
-0.2343076915,
-0.1955186129,
-0.0843086392,
-0.3602139056,
-0.6014478803,
-0.5213980675,
-0.5709382892,
-0.3138444126,
0.2624483109,
0.35292992,
0.3049908876,
0.4548655152,
0.32581532,
0.2426441163,
-0.0626644716,
0.3534680605,
0.0523009598,
0.4867734313,
-0.2412881851,
-0.3100318313,
-0.4500857592,
0.1267220974,
0.6814103723,
1.0429116488,
0.0244299937,
0.59450984,
-0.3028095067,
0.5208793283,
-0.6822380424,
-0.0798130631,
-0.6995664239,
-0.005476356,
-0.075164035,
-0.5422230959,
-0.1523912996,
-0.5919355154,
0.2443019003,
-0.4445766807,
0.1066768616,
-0.1719979942,
0.94131428,
0.4311972558,
-0.8130572438,
-0.1303039044,
-0.5798745155,
0.5490665436,
-0.2971973419,
0.4906055033,
0.2994562984,
0.4266349375,
-0.1611044407,
-0.7136867046,
-0.5730183721,
-0.3879902959,
0.342297107,
0.2601714134,
-0.078408435,
-0.4771159291,
0.2315526754,
0.1885583103,
-0.4215700328,
-0.1924963295,
-0.0648531392,
0.0946511924,
0.0901379362,
0.1757132709,
0.0065247403,
-0.3609515131,
-0.8983992934,
-0.1267874986,
-0.6811581254,
0.2675567269,
0.240214169,
-0.0893177316,
0.3833544552,
0.3676699698,
-0.5255618095,
0.5866642594,
0.3736000061,
0.3219653666,
0.0735021457,
-0.4223147631,
0.0076428517,
-0.3200024068,
0.34047997,
0.2572040856,
0.3235748708,
-0.0692042485,
0.2778021097,
-0.2917290926,
0.1405250728,
-0.4546391666,
0.0651188195,
0.5094559193,
0.0609246418,
0.1089618877,
-0.0161749739,
-0.8464227319,
-0.2042683661,
-0.100539498,
0.5965345502,
-0.2483868748,
-0.2397454232,
-0.0088133216,
-0.2540162206,
0.3985339999,
0.4977288842,
-0.2534787059,
0.2589547932,
0.7282524705,
0.318462342,
0.3216807544,
-0.4914270639,
-0.7136505842,
0.3243427575,
-0.6851805449,
1.0644160509,
-0.4335682392,
-0.1445848346,
-0.0676523075,
0.1945942044,
0.0227023754,
-0.7104275227,
0.2355676889,
-0.771252811,
0.4490714669,
-0.8417434692,
-0.3367435336,
0.2646863163,
0.600151062,
-0.4049735665,
1.4062100649,
0.1981244385,
-0.6859070659,
0.4522716701,
-0.3757531941,
-0.1414083689,
0.0467343964,
-0.1106506586,
-0.1916923076,
-0.2678938806,
0.2531526089,
0.3431591392,
-0.4992719293,
0.5259074569,
-0.0967594236,
-0.1162804365,
0.430721432,
-0.1323752254,
0.965302825,
0.2276766896,
-0.4533420205,
-0.3133699894,
-0.5804014802,
0.2658237815,
0.0300375931,
-0.2740522027,
-0.1404671222,
-0.0773911253,
-0.7841806412,
0.1942362487,
0.4441916645,
-0.6510660648,
0.1882685423,
0.1878583133,
0.3036970198,
0.9728055596,
0.5245725513,
0.0454914384,
-0.6113936901,
0.594705224,
0.0599814542,
0.330070734,
-0.4455772638,
-0.6105653644,
-0.6378505826,
0.2569685578,
0.2199171931,
0.6859169602,
-0.4933826923,
0.0034567099,
-0.4105270505,
-0.4292693734,
-0.3138929605,
-0.1823794842,
0.2743684947,
0.806016922,
0.5228339434,
-0.232465297,
-0.4800449014,
-0.459808141,
-0.4321162999,
-0.6915652156,
-0.0287855454,
0.5847016573,
0.4917177856,
0.3571946621,
0.8505519032,
-0.5213640928,
0.2520419657,
0.1365998536,
0.3476153016,
0.0061179074,
0.3371294737,
0.2611229718,
-0.6007164121,
-0.3022702038,
-0.2514413893,
-0.6913276315,
-0.5008896589,
-0.3208485842,
-0.0335913189,
0.0285222065,
0.4444713295,
-0.7422366142,
0.1218286753,
0.35671103,
-0.4840165377,
0.80018121,
-0.1642374843,
0.5900030136,
-1.0103595257,
0.0884814188,
-0.3301938772,
-0.2045006156,
-0.4069616795,
0.1200568378,
0.0850735754,
-0.2853851318,
-0.3631910384,
0.9062017798,
-0.4962850213,
-0.1444272846,
0.161594972,
0.2322166115,
0.2351694554,
0.2810000479,
-0.1776000559,
0.8866183162,
0.1619673371,
-0.7058894634,
0.2327519953,
0.1875684559,
-0.0315617621,
0.6178750992,
-0.6191789508,
0.4831861258,
-0.0861067921,
0.4376909733,
-0.8615914583,
-0.0141296685,
0.0638475642,
-0.4974520206,
0.19400087,
-0.2158572823,
-0.3405871689,
-0.3722447753,
-0.3215499818,
0.4097698629,
0.3884094357,
-0.8071611524,
0.5750555396,
0.2072179317,
-0.1122326851,
-0.997574985,
-0.3544639349,
0.2598074377,
-0.0751599669,
-0.6040750742,
0.3862897754,
-0.2366867363,
-0.5326133966,
0.2855183184,
-0.4569034278,
-0.2256214023,
0.0483059771,
-0.1637075096,
0.0069047622,
-0.2287576199,
0.2291522473,
-0.2623823881,
-0.2173763365,
0.0252550021,
-0.3212492466,
0.6197209954,
-0.1565404236,
-0.1938898563,
-0.4188969731,
0.5811625719,
0.4746780097,
-0.5046041608,
0.3881713748,
0.2959888875,
-0.2545130849,
-0.462713182,
-0.9411664009,
-0.2067635506,
-0.4864743054,
0.0658919439,
-0.6732670069,
-0.9939084649,
0.6977585554,
-0.3552156687,
-0.2138346434,
0.2965121567,
0.480432719,
-0.382820338,
0.4275661707,
0.1219133362,
0.2258725017,
0.3732535839,
-0.0523468629,
-0.182342574,
-0.8080324531,
-0.2446330041,
-0.6234669685,
0.1190503091,
-0.4579331577,
-0.7396234274,
0.2716732025,
0.1781841516,
-0.7422406077,
0.1875530332,
-0.2466462404,
0.2970942557,
0.7255048156,
-0.0037925502,
0.2827670276,
-0.6861846447,
-0.0785370842,
0.2507610917,
-0.5131286383,
-0.3635526001,
1.0075517893,
0.1329352856,
0.606367588,
0.1174877957,
0.4915530384,
0.3125007749,
0.0926800743,
-0.0084437551,
0.8020157218,
0.0179576855,
-0.9759472609,
-0.1849001348,
-0.5341588855,
-0.8545902371,
-0.0005016847,
0.0821703896,
-0.6665233374,
0.3568496108,
0.2619084418,
-0.324696213,
0.3587907255,
-0.6642249823,
0.9313292503,
-0.2455050051,
-0.3367927074,
0.2898990214,
-0.7112131715,
0.117929101,
0.0431485847,
-0.2168874294,
-0.5170148015,
-0.237901479,
0.4562426507,
-0.3905780613,
0.7358138561,
-0.3387838006,
0.3295054734,
0.5803071856,
0.1642491072,
0.5376700759,
0.2428758442,
0.11211209,
-0.2252831161,
0.4047314525,
-0.5195814967,
-0.7185884714,
0.5864431858,
-0.6710271835,
-0.9661368728,
-0.7271969914,
-0.2831959426,
-0.5156208277,
0.0040938579,
-0.1069622114,
0.5646827817,
-0.0594410636,
0.0837492049,
0.6436020732,
-0.3860687315,
0.2457438558,
0.8316187859,
0.0745177045,
-0.3671076596,
0.2532117069,
0.3005918264,
0.2942254245,
0.5876633525,
0.294622153,
-0.3386220038,
-0.2346535176,
-0.3546025157,
0.3851634562,
-0.6271191239,
-0.247833997,
-0.7944855094,
0.087545529,
-0.3831832707,
0.1472295225,
-0.3988918662,
-0.756510973,
-0.1453154981,
0.0824155584,
0.1784243882,
0.3809279501,
-0.0545374379,
-0.1493870914,
-0.4879820645,
0.5517325997,
0.7985261679,
0.4581299722,
-0.2791740894,
-0.2264457643,
0.2971740067,
-0.3913252056,
-0.228327468,
-1.2613464594,
-0.2045766711,
0.2483184785,
0.5806447268,
-0.200411737,
0.378602922,
0.8343048692,
-0.7044632435,
1.0520398617,
-0.4297563434,
-0.858461678,
0.8262591958,
-0.4414241016,
0.5936690569,
0.5880396366,
0.3839192688,
-0.6088619828,
-0.3137151599,
-0.7169614434,
-0.4199621975,
0.3178669512,
-0.2090386003,
0.0668619126,
-0.3779986203,
0.7533098459,
0.0109060295,
0.193385765,
-0.4274204075,
-0.2559598684,
-0.2154901773,
0.2201493829,
0.2542345524,
-0.2933362722,
0.0219060816,
0.0215371642,
0.6411570907,
-0.2436408401,
0.3103674054,
0.5050951242,
0.2006766349,
-0.2909429073,
0.6338843703,
0.2529214323,
1.0147547722,
-0.5921373963,
0.3103123307,
0.4393907487,
-0.1843209118,
0.2980023623,
0.2377302051,
-0.1493473351,
-0.1514362246,
0.2823511362,
0.2117390335,
0.0521470755,
-0.6360762715,
0.5569288135,
-0.0464359894,
-0.0909085497,
-0.464132905,
-0.2275700867,
-0.0744251385,
0.4715964496,
0.8454619646,
-0.1246212348,
-0.3728800714,
-0.9690323472,
0.4386418462,
0.3292225301,
-0.3085834086,
-0.4155965447,
0.7906215787,
-0.1643042415,
-0.3065928817,
0.3521061242,
-0.2933021784,
-0.8603518605,
0.5120216012,
0.6993955374,
0.685319066,
-0.5110387802,
0.5111746788,
0.3435966671,
0.4394416213,
0.1849176437,
0.9620007277,
-0.1548897922,
-0.6756824851,
-0.5421322584,
-0.2388285846,
-0.8022085428,
0.1538341194,
-0.5709906816,
-0.2239354104,
-0.6159998178,
-0.5201075077,
-0.1843475401,
0.4663234055,
-0.7230014205,
0.4359952211,
-0.3726610839,
1.0258126259,
-0.5905602574,
0.5372010469,
0.7738032341,
-0.3551272154,
-0.6352669597,
0.1385367215,
-0.1364773363,
-0.6080223918,
0.6417034268,
-0.2581810653,
-0.0978990644,
-0.0742797703,
-0.4014579952,
-0.8485912085,
1.1432105303,
0.4277340174,
0.1911775917,
0.0499212407,
0.0746128038,
0.551428616,
-0.0986367911,
-0.0943610519,
0.3892721534,
0.3939904273,
-0.0958022326,
-0.8516301513,
0.1214488074,
-0.3956160843,
-0.5267495513,
0.4420936406,
-0.9877303243,
1.1335815191,
-0.1382119209,
-0.1666412055,
0.0902201608,
0.4909292161,
0.3771808445,
0.4620809555,
0.5705096126,
0.659584105,
0.8414014578,
-0.359978646,
0.9218860865,
-0.1755752265,
0.1217029989,
1.4365152121,
-0.3307162225,
0.8538594246,
0.4701297879,
-0.2735316455,
0.6604290009,
0.5530835986,
0.0486113317,
0.2744790316,
-0.0126784015,
-0.280662626,
-0.5009146333,
-0.2997957468,
-0.6011512876,
0.4312827289,
-0.0643981919,
0.1398510337,
-0.272410512,
-0.3097697496,
0.0984594375,
0.0180045869,
0.0648414493,
0.5609765053,
-0.1955813766,
-1.0149344206,
0.2180660516,
-0.3517114222,
-0.2056307346,
-0.6499941349,
-0.0705264509,
-0.5412804484,
0.0389223769,
0.454210639,
-0.7940353751,
0.0509463325,
0.1598255783,
-0.0535548367,
-0.124831453,
0.4572336674,
-0.0521287508,
-0.2034357488,
0.1296702921,
1.0601398945,
-0.088013798,
0.0733023956,
-0.7378025651,
-0.0902882293,
-0.3981303275,
-0.2474388778,
0.0734897032,
0.8251155615,
-0.1242619529,
1.1212884188,
0.3728800416,
0.1545948237,
0.5456404686,
0.1600604504,
0.8531981707,
-0.8701490164,
-0.5941262245,
-0.2467962503,
0.2773508132,
-0.0201704893,
-0.5716965795,
0.6976290941,
0.2807842791,
0.604323566,
0.2897628844,
0.4204187989,
-0.024475731,
0.9317068458,
-0.4663205147,
0.0967289507,
-0.6447665095,
0.3492303491,
-0.288688153,
-0.7226909995,
-0.0874758735,
0.0916392058,
-0.2478545159,
0.230563134,
0.871139884,
0.4521891475,
0.277218014,
0.1166684851,
0.0162200872,
0.1311091632,
0.3580525219,
0.5558122993,
1.271209836,
-0.446308881,
0.5523085594,
-0.5325753689,
-0.1516551375,
0.2189581245,
-1.1576405764,
-0.698615253,
-0.9810808301,
-0.513127625,
-0.2397700846,
0.4771514535,
0.858514607,
0.6382730603,
-0.6080860496,
0.0300789159,
0.3703767359,
-0.0388675071,
-0.4435766637,
-0.1672688276,
0.6868095994,
-0.3735563755,
-0.3963286281,
0.5269525051,
0.2474898547,
-0.0516622216,
-0.0611785762,
0.4727067649,
-0.643240273,
0.2126510888,
0.276687175,
0.5203089714,
-0.6611320972,
-0.8123363256,
0.3283380866,
0.2993588746,
0.2816489637,
0.7792852521,
-0.9962336421,
0.5749015212,
0.3844902217,
0.7618328929,
0.6456343532,
0.6426725984,
0.3944765627,
-0.8842487335,
-0.3657611907,
0.3600046039,
0.1232597977,
0.3099179566,
-0.1426858306,
0.5198269486,
0.2311762273,
-0.8902571797,
-0.8781700134,
0.2650698423,
-1.1658366919,
-0.3592640758,
0.7682554126,
-0.145827204,
-0.2593458891,
-0.4932801425,
0.1707778722,
0.1816384196,
-0.0574541762,
0.6571637988,
0.4948290288,
-0.3229314089,
-0.2680332959,
-0.6290110946,
0.46722278,
0.424861908,
-0.853047967,
0.2891959548,
0.3330216408,
0.4631121457,
0.1016672701,
1.1617445946,
-0.1324585229,
0.5218267441,
0.167221114,
-0.4728836715,
-0.2030987591,
-0.4894047081,
0.071596913,
0.4739966094,
-0.0315166041,
-0.230090633
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10893v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10893v1
|
RLVF: Learning from Verbal Feedback without Overgeneralization
| 2024-02-16T18:50:24 | 2024-02-16T18:50:24 |
Moritz Stephan, Alexander Khazatsky, Eric Mitchell, Annie S Chen, Sheryl Hsu, Archit Sharma, Chelsea Finn
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The diversity of contexts in which large language models (LLMs) are deployed
requires the ability to modify or customize default model behaviors to
incorporate nuanced requirements and preferences. A convenient interface to
specify such model adjustments is high-level verbal feedback, such as "Don't
use emojis when drafting emails to my boss." However, while writing high-level
feedback is far simpler than collecting annotations for reinforcement learning
from human feedback (RLHF), we find that simply prompting a model with such
feedback leads to overgeneralization of the feedback to contexts where it is
not relevant. We study the problem of incorporating verbal feedback without
such overgeneralization, inspiring a new method Contextualized Critiques with
Constrained Preference Optimization (C3PO). C3PO uses a piece of high-level
feedback to generate a small synthetic preference dataset specifying how the
feedback should (and should not) be applied. It then fine-tunes the model in
accordance with the synthetic preference data while minimizing the divergence
from the original model for prompts where the feedback does not apply. Our
experimental results indicate that our approach effectively applies verbal
feedback to relevant scenarios while preserving existing behaviors for other
contexts. For both human- and GPT-4-generated high-level feedback, C3PO
effectively adheres to the given feedback comparably to in-context baselines
while reducing overgeneralization by 30%.
|
[
-0.3821913302,
-0.9980422258,
0.5112099648,
0.3197814226,
-0.1783636212,
0.0194278155,
-0.7317371964,
-0.3929652572,
0.0406897068,
0.5005280972,
-0.849894166,
-0.4741372764,
-0.1444966942,
0.0368530415,
0.1679919511,
1.0402692556,
-0.0297205038,
0.0366237685,
-0.3938469291,
0.1239145324,
-0.3925124705,
-0.6805183887,
-0.6020294428,
-0.8250617385,
0.6377707124,
0.6955911517,
0.3612809777,
0.3912391663,
-0.0848629326,
0.1969210654,
-0.049850475,
0.3949615955,
-0.7264982462,
0.1827577651,
-0.165261969,
-0.2912017703,
-0.0813495293,
0.0379183516,
0.6424441934,
0.5449215174,
-0.4403378367,
0.0357176363,
0.2298942357,
0.8272287846,
-0.839176476,
0.5039576292,
-0.4942911565,
0.4834829867,
0.3102349341,
-0.4698416293,
-0.651411891,
-0.505361855,
0.1749190837,
-0.8009605408,
-0.0478019603,
-0.0161018241,
0.6624674797,
0.2782607675,
-0.2099247575,
-0.1600137353,
-1.0498759747,
0.9796097279,
-0.3876193762,
0.3278208077,
0.6627472639,
0.1776348054,
-0.1066486761,
-0.3421863317,
-0.3761115372,
-0.6584095359,
-0.0151684945,
0.2303359956,
0.0105422474,
0.1699096411,
0.3417990506,
-0.1544855088,
-0.1004956886,
0.1592973322,
-0.3571256101,
-0.1073174477,
0.4190843999,
-0.0804210082,
-0.0444232859,
-0.1342680156,
-0.433008492,
-0.1155201942,
-0.7942219973,
0.4115488529,
-0.0142541211,
0.4596188366,
0.1019392759,
0.464304179,
-0.2044856697,
0.5187445879,
0.2816334367,
-0.1334879547,
0.3752541244,
-0.1258433163,
-0.1168818921,
0.0230250284,
0.6477023959,
0.4948628545,
0.4961470068,
-0.2563772798,
-0.2443638891,
-0.1602700055,
0.2408656925,
-0.8604184985,
0.3268106282,
0.0950738937,
-0.4639593363,
-0.2933420539,
-0.007958441,
-0.6553131938,
-0.3171470165,
-0.5245485306,
0.0424084738,
-0.3574061692,
-0.0096252905,
-0.1555805355,
-0.0002528137,
0.2889057398,
0.3347581029,
-1.1625941992,
0.3606081605,
0.7825525999,
0.6440268755,
-0.0853740051,
-0.5027320981,
-0.7626715899,
0.2514612675,
-0.3948328495,
0.6295452714,
-0.6071414351,
-0.6022983789,
0.1510227025,
-0.0901048258,
-0.0868821517,
-0.6643164754,
0.5212766528,
-0.3108096719,
0.1915700585,
-0.425793767,
-0.5514114499,
-0.0277726538,
0.4147517681,
-0.2555241883,
1.0047514439,
0.0990660563,
-0.5338966846,
0.6698217392,
-0.5567926764,
-0.4547173679,
0.0632238463,
-0.3210583031,
-0.2942057252,
-0.0341994613,
0.3303229213,
0.3479934335,
0.0118861105,
0.1877015084,
-0.5505745411,
-0.353545934,
0.2575226426,
-0.1311137974,
0.2331748158,
0.1252744794,
-0.4080595672,
0.3943328261,
-0.6500132084,
0.1305732429,
-0.0646011755,
-0.6331506371,
-0.3216003776,
0.0988659412,
-0.1297456622,
0.4070291817,
0.074228026,
-0.7490037084,
0.2398598939,
-0.694221139,
0.5290375948,
0.7659298182,
0.1283704937,
0.5405396819,
-0.3957427442,
0.7164621949,
-0.3458740115,
0.3346630037,
0.2565612793,
-0.1370867789,
-0.5774371624,
-0.1514817327,
-0.0120767262,
0.5525541902,
-0.7663705945,
0.3707297742,
-0.143863976,
-0.1091038212,
-0.1462991983,
0.4639149308,
0.5337566733,
0.4529098868,
0.289719224,
-0.1444122344,
-0.6561371088,
-0.7228741646,
-0.010564412,
-0.3001187742,
0.0602192171,
0.5900663137,
0.2615926564,
-0.0514045209,
0.9788559675,
-0.3678431511,
-0.2853467464,
-0.5192539096,
0.1003879905,
-0.1286050379,
0.4567611814,
0.38882038,
-0.4060705602,
-0.221066609,
-0.0640162304,
-0.5279522538,
-0.0495232716,
-0.1124819815,
-0.0114577217,
0.2961477339,
0.861135006,
-0.5377724767,
-0.0133511806,
0.3501953185,
-0.1559430212,
0.1271357685,
-0.357049942,
-0.1811427921,
-0.7462188005,
0.0032152114,
0.0340615921,
-0.3180383146,
-0.4040444791,
-0.0183127765,
-0.0049670194,
-0.1349029243,
-0.4805534482,
0.6158035994,
-0.2132995576,
0.111582987,
-0.2339524329,
0.0491545387,
-0.0973472744,
0.9051709771,
0.2867867649,
0.3740361035,
0.155407235,
-0.5849519372,
0.2404958457,
0.1646607369,
-0.0192801822,
0.5452373624,
-0.7570741773,
0.1571314484,
-0.3893517852,
0.7421684861,
-0.5436572433,
-0.169440344,
0.4196369648,
-0.4610048234,
0.2027129829,
-0.1331497282,
-0.2781819105,
-0.2617534697,
-0.6485917568,
0.1624785364,
0.4867407084,
-0.5572366118,
0.642160356,
0.2474570423,
-0.0937544927,
-0.7024015188,
-0.5643566847,
-0.2078896314,
-0.0336791798,
-0.3531346619,
0.2018042356,
-0.1834383607,
0.0352502391,
-0.2563334703,
0.072516486,
0.1602321863,
0.0586052574,
0.4355244935,
0.2318811268,
0.185987711,
0.2004916221,
-0.0679959208,
0.0520658866,
0.2093230635,
-0.2939304113,
0.4565622509,
-0.1141661108,
-0.0784313232,
-0.3669393361,
0.1810432225,
0.4245783687,
-0.208581686,
0.4798995852,
0.6992830634,
-0.1988803297,
-0.6433323026,
-0.3063746095,
-0.3787949681,
-0.4493138492,
0.3119559288,
-0.2167355418,
-1.2411906719,
0.1560169011,
0.0618666969,
0.1145059168,
-0.0654814839,
0.7092813849,
0.0296788178,
1.2203272581,
0.4510627389,
0.1178792641,
0.8063246608,
-0.2881343961,
-0.0524545982,
-0.8547795415,
-0.4325648248,
-0.3081719279,
-0.1479379237,
-0.5978189707,
-0.2122851014,
0.1926141977,
-0.1063428223,
-0.3144867122,
-0.1028215289,
-0.2682525814,
0.6133421659,
0.5946298838,
0.3632639945,
0.0136909317,
-0.0504558422,
-0.2220689803,
-0.0373137146,
-0.7979744077,
-0.0334472023,
0.9608284235,
0.5386605263,
0.7361338139,
0.0242889374,
0.9500010014,
0.0806400925,
0.5059633255,
-1.0987397432,
0.4637629986,
-0.0614131317,
-0.3372913003,
-0.4140708745,
-0.6311644316,
-1.0113813877,
0.3858114779,
-0.3695913851,
-0.7786188126,
0.3699063063,
0.4817607403,
-0.6200553179,
-0.1346634775,
-0.7001567483,
0.5867394209,
0.1527481377,
-0.5228105783,
-0.2558973134,
-0.5677108169,
0.3064603508,
0.1731952131,
0.4668051302,
-0.0718953162,
0.0985958502,
0.486364603,
-0.5752281547,
1.2510923147,
-0.4403031468,
-0.2034792006,
0.2138153613,
0.0461138599,
0.6702198386,
0.2326262444,
0.1465038657,
-0.5674817562,
-0.0706056356,
-0.2511684299,
-0.908128798,
0.8767921925,
-0.9592558742,
-0.5902414918,
-0.3034196794,
-0.369531095,
-0.5422027707,
0.0840335265,
0.3064995706,
0.432103008,
-0.3244096935,
0.2878824472,
0.6122152805,
-0.1387078315,
0.4026741683,
0.4292272627,
-0.3398008347,
-0.5696727037,
0.9407191873,
-0.0430374928,
0.3456321359,
0.3471942544,
0.5973898768,
-0.5085484385,
-0.228853479,
-0.3361395299,
0.2327230126,
-0.9935363531,
0.1623310745,
-0.4470024705,
-0.0135241002,
-0.2726030052,
-0.1717057079,
-0.3546476662,
-0.457760036,
-0.316214323,
-0.1433740854,
0.0298155285,
0.770740509,
-0.1272831261,
-0.149576053,
-0.6731127501,
0.1467784941,
0.5499686599,
0.2918109596,
0.2660638988,
-0.4127507806,
-0.1898645759,
-0.0342924148,
-0.30675143,
-0.5067560077,
0.284183681,
0.4015341103,
0.5395540595,
0.1080483571,
0.0831273347,
0.3307974041,
-0.3789823949,
0.7475463152,
0.0303235631,
-0.966727674,
0.6030898094,
-0.4418228567,
0.5088196397,
0.6341849566,
0.3050862849,
-0.5364540815,
-0.3042418957,
-0.4705065787,
-1.0250891447,
0.6656511426,
-0.0662591532,
0.3795173764,
-0.1126503274,
0.6164295673,
-0.1439768374,
0.2641293705,
-1.1046459675,
0.0275102798,
-0.4620333314,
0.0827036351,
0.0498526804,
-0.2300879657,
-0.3728605807,
-0.4350937903,
0.7742613554,
-0.2761521637,
-0.0610822551,
0.4013103247,
-0.119232893,
-0.4077976942,
0.4221418202,
0.8319625258,
0.6777985692,
-0.3463597298,
0.0030021768,
0.2615126669,
-0.1895177513,
0.1145421788,
-0.2028508335,
-0.2990187109,
-0.2596641779,
0.3969775736,
0.9981610775,
0.2933435738,
-0.5259743929,
0.5679141879,
-0.1213953048,
-0.441190958,
-0.3665188849,
0.1712913215,
-0.2057453543,
0.0641452149,
0.0773105919,
-0.1251790375,
-0.056623362,
-0.7434272766,
0.1408859044,
0.389136076,
-0.7146220207,
-0.1342106909,
0.3744445443,
0.4415036142,
-0.1004294455,
0.328660965,
-0.2889763117,
-0.4953993261,
0.4161997736,
0.6101580262,
0.897223711,
-0.0355802812,
0.4996819794,
0.5190767646,
0.0627223775,
-0.2138651013,
0.118429184,
-0.4539091885,
-0.7917333245,
-0.661729753,
-0.5001770258,
-0.5695656538,
0.0543926097,
-0.7492011189,
0.1918987036,
-1.0345072746,
-0.2160497308,
0.0396746621,
-0.2951427698,
-0.2704193592,
0.132053405,
0.2390960753,
0.4570566416,
-0.6546312571,
0.8709973693,
0.562946558,
-0.5329766273,
-0.7956416011,
0.1437527984,
-0.020955814,
-0.9556224942,
0.7819654942,
0.1204008311,
-0.3438886702,
-0.034240257,
-0.5956409574,
-0.7443482876,
0.82178545,
0.2748140991,
-0.4625228941,
0.0095673334,
-0.1422564685,
0.6737555861,
-0.4010316133,
0.1728172004,
0.5208292603,
0.5035830736,
0.2792223692,
-0.786031127,
0.2518747151,
-0.1692334265,
0.403860867,
0.07903447,
-0.8203408122,
0.5119678974,
-0.2346729636,
-0.110612832,
-0.1514137089,
0.5109741092,
0.3447246253,
-0.0904430896,
0.7413387895,
0.3042499125,
0.5321389437,
0.076241523,
1.2045702934,
-0.1349617243,
0.4908800125,
1.2950966358,
-0.3596665561,
0.830657959,
0.6607931852,
0.1238142103,
0.631926477,
0.5800312161,
-0.0065856297,
0.6646263003,
0.6207728386,
-0.1645522714,
-0.275492698,
-0.3627473414,
-0.1733293682,
0.390866816,
0.2549269497,
-0.1864867359,
-0.1719928831,
0.109638311,
0.1273943037,
0.3222090304,
-0.2633066773,
0.9569621682,
0.1087273508,
-1.1783987284,
1.1341658831,
-0.0851619542,
0.7372952104,
-0.5244649649,
-0.0688764006,
-0.1366005093,
0.2154749185,
-0.3697085977,
-0.4141301811,
0.2420191169,
-0.196487397,
-0.3060617447,
-0.3958460093,
0.2864975035,
-0.6375052929,
-0.3050730526,
0.4122886956,
0.2744496763,
-0.3760186732,
0.2509942949,
-0.692197144,
-0.0110051259,
0.0351578034,
-0.3948197961,
0.3026200533,
0.2446878701,
-0.1009832472,
0.7907354832,
0.6116611362,
0.2029757649,
-0.4220055342,
0.5177973509,
0.7279897928,
-0.6253417134,
-0.6209219694,
-0.8145859241,
0.0926624909,
0.0443229787,
-0.4149743319,
0.6095184088,
0.1492385417,
0.9513853192,
-0.0406337306,
0.9217724204,
0.1812179387,
0.5207576752,
-0.7898820639,
0.2240556031,
-0.4628627598,
0.4487609267,
-0.2960280776,
-0.9164617658,
-0.2785846889,
0.5197164416,
-0.440728873,
0.2989893854,
0.8033066392,
0.6719208956,
0.1705159098,
0.0120060509,
0.2189108133,
0.0815118402,
0.3150424361,
0.6668448448,
1.0883187056,
0.2952994704,
0.5210134387,
-0.3619136214,
-0.2612573206,
-0.2072276026,
-0.8955144882,
-0.9900866151,
-0.2923340201,
-0.2283206135,
-0.5320754647,
0.1957737356,
1.5581028461,
0.8552147746,
-0.760797739,
-0.3461284935,
-0.2692665756,
0.0970757306,
-0.0544819757,
-0.2357290983,
0.1008823514,
-0.5983895063,
-0.5408707857,
0.6318659782,
0.0888429582,
0.0086019058,
-0.4356937408,
-0.3373955488,
0.0018488576,
0.1091360748,
0.728964746,
0.5524065495,
-0.844850421,
-0.6157349348,
-0.0892732888,
0.0221752934,
0.1040612012,
0.963668704,
-0.6749721169,
0.4206204414,
0.4775457978,
0.5102304816,
0.7048245668,
0.1020644531,
0.9125743508,
-1.2146931887,
0.3455704153,
0.2053451091,
0.2150647342,
0.4722145796,
-0.4936695695,
0.2388453335,
0.1579215229,
-0.4809755385,
-0.5873126984,
0.3699360192,
-0.7533208132,
-0.5118274093,
1.5207176208,
-0.1062057465,
-0.2745016515,
0.0704746097,
-0.3521546125,
0.0432804301,
-0.7577909827,
0.7769965529,
0.7287271619,
-0.35698241,
-0.2186338902,
-0.4066928923,
0.948996067,
0.6755912304,
-0.7410567999,
0.1956459731,
0.6666465998,
0.2685273886,
-0.139761284,
0.7025942206,
0.0661127791,
0.4425133467,
-0.49617064,
0.057896059,
-0.1585096121,
-0.3020273149,
-0.5763363838,
0.2216295302,
0.529571414,
0.0743446574
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10892v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10892v2
|
Proving membership in LLM pretraining data via data watermarks
| 2024-02-16T18:49:27 | 2024-06-10T19:39:34 |
Johnny Tian-Zheng Wei, Ryan Yixiang Wang, Robin Jia
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Detecting whether copyright holders' works were used in LLM pretraining is
poised to be an important problem. This work proposes using data watermarks to
enable principled detection with only black-box model access, provided that the
rightholder contributed multiple training documents and watermarked them before
public release. By applying a randomly sampled data watermark, detection can be
framed as hypothesis testing, which provides guarantees on the false detection
rate. We study two watermarks: one that inserts random sequences, and another
that randomly substitutes characters with Unicode lookalikes. We first show how
three aspects of watermark design -- watermark length, number of duplications,
and interference -- affect the power of the hypothesis test. Next, we study how
a watermark's detection strength changes under model and dataset scaling: while
increasing the dataset size decreases the strength of the watermark, watermarks
remain strong if the model size also increases. Finally, we view SHA hashes as
natural watermarks and show that we can robustly detect hashes from
BLOOM-176B's training data, as long as they occurred at least 90 times.
Together, our results point towards a promising future for data watermarks in
real world use.
|
[
-0.339248091,
-0.4060240686,
0.694226563,
-0.0592725649,
-0.7037338614,
0.1013864949,
0.1622801572,
-0.5662010312,
0.1046375632,
0.7629255056,
-0.5300706029,
-0.5243449807,
-0.645796597,
-0.0062414911,
-0.7609142661,
0.6847643852,
-0.3143041432,
-0.0323682837,
-0.3265124559,
-0.3417627215,
-0.2310589552,
-0.904346168,
-0.2604029477,
-0.308591187,
0.4273275137,
0.1624402255,
0.4163000584,
1.01653409,
0.5055926442,
0.1613727808,
0.0498396158,
0.0443142354,
-0.5558931828,
0.1595326215,
0.0904634744,
-0.9523903131,
-0.1361434162,
0.4168766141,
0.6599606872,
0.0339394733,
0.1870963424,
0.3117693067,
-0.0185261834,
0.6450195312,
-0.8736628294,
-0.0456892326,
-0.6961186528,
0.2831150293,
-0.8181420565,
-0.3627838194,
-0.4370709956,
-0.2444489151,
-0.3282900155,
-0.6777011752,
0.480710119,
0.4923927784,
1.2814432383,
0.3129503727,
-0.0814902559,
-0.1516008824,
-0.6191392541,
0.824157536,
-0.8594392538,
0.3871247768,
0.7574433684,
0.4170285761,
-0.0555498824,
-0.7371675372,
-0.5851413012,
-0.0662300512,
0.2900919318,
0.0839494467,
-0.0530220084,
-0.2563353181,
0.6676850915,
0.6577859521,
-0.3708035648,
-0.0762790367,
-0.1161469221,
-0.2825210989,
0.9090839624,
-0.0647778511,
0.2466071993,
0.3553636074,
-0.3656429052,
-0.317733705,
-1.1588996649,
-0.0871657282,
0.8837205768,
0.1258925796,
-0.2618167996,
0.6226580143,
0.0788780078,
0.5017550588,
-0.0867698938,
0.0495052859,
0.11948663,
-0.218971774,
-0.3272316158,
0.0633940473,
0.6435623765,
-0.1129582524,
0.5941746235,
-0.0857903361,
-0.3544772863,
-0.2170116454,
0.0974638462,
-0.9319840074,
-0.3485014737,
0.1462495327,
-0.5813364983,
-0.3706991971,
0.3738660514,
-0.3025397658,
-0.7597823143,
-0.5253411531,
0.8362309337,
-0.2246841639,
-0.34851408,
0.2731980681,
-0.3396768272,
0.2432261854,
0.0375287831,
-0.5140194297,
0.0678563863,
0.6392154098,
0.7200694084,
-0.3634582162,
-0.2236361802,
-0.3608081341,
0.2525547147,
-0.3759420812,
0.8111544847,
-0.4859836698,
-0.2273427695,
-0.1391187012,
0.1011109278,
0.2203503847,
-0.9233251214,
0.11648947,
-0.8743553758,
-0.0084113404,
-0.6089493632,
-1.0560878515,
0.1344110072,
0.1019189358,
-0.8902630806,
0.8311526775,
0.1895945519,
-1.1189789772,
0.7747966051,
-0.4947274923,
-0.2636142969,
0.1088879034,
-0.1686930656,
-1.0156993866,
0.0121743325,
0.0056288051,
0.268045038,
0.1380060315,
0.0410703756,
-0.7117929459,
-0.6270484924,
0.6991563439,
-0.3284698129,
0.6900290251,
0.00221787,
-0.3864409924,
-0.144451037,
-0.7269427776,
0.1169971973,
0.4147336483,
-0.3862489462,
-0.3804885745,
0.0013128519,
-0.1046745181,
-0.1427153945,
0.1171345264,
-0.4815670252,
0.1001469195,
0.4528021812,
0.0346190333,
0.8648347855,
0.2629766166,
-0.039670907,
-0.5461106896,
0.6132887006,
0.3607995808,
0.1932534575,
-0.0601673312,
-0.3378345072,
-0.6636702418,
-0.4821611047,
0.7454476953,
0.1181352586,
-0.5939701796,
0.4245770276,
-0.2814910114,
-0.2031258792,
-0.4762770832,
0.3660188615,
0.1301895082,
0.1592598408,
0.4765863419,
-0.4117826521,
-0.5157821178,
-0.9449347854,
-0.4675133526,
-0.0949535891,
-0.2076801807,
0.3584229648,
0.7112503052,
0.0329801366,
1.1054455042,
-0.5128782988,
-0.2054641098,
-0.0520890839,
0.2998993993,
0.0668461472,
0.5202008486,
0.3794749677,
-0.9457463026,
-0.2910157442,
-0.4244761765,
-0.8505783081,
-0.2772931159,
0.0867796093,
-0.0520125329,
-0.3289886415,
0.4708800614,
0.0020898846,
0.8141531944,
0.5265311599,
-0.2226854116,
0.6241808534,
-0.1052513197,
0.2532185018,
-0.7455622554,
0.0292411726,
-0.2695883512,
-0.2372158468,
-0.3167611659,
0.0195299257,
0.3469981551,
-0.2068408579,
-0.5220583081,
0.3709700108,
-0.3019836843,
-0.2317302227,
-0.5259005427,
-0.5580505729,
0.0334073901,
0.0751432851,
0.1196226031,
0.9838421345,
0.5712606311,
-0.6602514982,
0.1132518575,
0.0182751883,
-0.6467456222,
0.6640034318,
-0.7497941852,
0.3461298347,
-0.1236739233,
0.1325598359,
-0.8185480237,
-0.0284240115,
0.0620021671,
-0.1720561832,
0.2046502233,
-0.654602766,
-0.7246143818,
-0.1833457053,
-0.2846196592,
0.4113752246,
0.300606668,
-0.5893201232,
0.3082339168,
0.2536443472,
0.3497089446,
-0.434386909,
-0.9604474306,
-0.1181180999,
-0.5090350509,
-0.583714664,
0.5884446502,
-0.2942538857,
0.0141909439,
-0.034950804,
-0.4115206897,
-0.5297114253,
0.3896151781,
0.6012100577,
0.2049056739,
-0.1812648177,
-0.2400115728,
-0.2815334797,
-0.1468656212,
0.0122876158,
-0.3530222178,
0.339597255,
0.232670784,
-0.9093495607,
-0.4159020185,
0.0108990921,
0.353489995,
-0.3284401894,
0.4495090246,
0.5199989676,
-0.5470761657,
-0.3958123028,
-0.6584047675,
-0.2744432986,
-0.5024029016,
-0.1081053391,
-0.0382075123,
-0.6373785138,
0.6058369279,
0.004178633,
0.1429249495,
-0.0519678444,
0.1537537724,
-0.2934066951,
0.3618234992,
0.5099382401,
-0.2153922468,
0.8009824157,
-0.5036296844,
0.2607870996,
-0.719017148,
0.0202390198,
-0.418317616,
-0.5450450778,
-0.2614749074,
-0.4577862322,
0.1025436968,
0.2955747545,
-0.1869628876,
0.4805295467,
-0.1316714883,
0.8520614505,
0.6455919147,
0.47910133,
0.2863866091,
0.0844936445,
-0.0142526561,
-0.2506272793,
-0.1915386319,
-0.5078396797,
1.5644978285,
0.2001344711,
0.63504076,
-0.1491539329,
1.2413954735,
0.7114794254,
0.6372823715,
-0.4939240515,
0.3880216479,
0.1607664526,
-1.1015937328,
-0.2653669715,
-0.4015430808,
-1.0086578131,
-0.0123336595,
-0.2498435229,
-0.2541981339,
0.2503617108,
0.0072728479,
-0.0262384526,
0.4525197744,
-0.3790403605,
0.6671355367,
-0.4809774756,
-0.7155208588,
-0.0102572208,
-0.1140079722,
0.2197796702,
-0.451911211,
0.3388587832,
-0.3389334679,
0.18968229,
1.0897055864,
-0.4792349935,
0.4974672198,
-0.5787651539,
-0.1102742255,
0.5102166533,
0.1278638244,
0.3966471553,
0.0077267089,
-0.0070491186,
0.0914383829,
-0.1038153321,
-0.5160898566,
-0.3046897948,
0.1324808449,
-0.5757408142,
-0.452778846,
-0.3704304695,
-0.3949105144,
-0.173770681,
0.4243333042,
0.27348876,
0.1569956392,
0.174044162,
0.5207825899,
0.7921891212,
0.0767458677,
0.2913405597,
0.7227404118,
-0.021095885,
-0.1865776479,
1.0548654795,
0.3606641591,
0.0831522942,
0.0114504322,
0.3074973524,
-0.432317853,
-1.2838276625,
-0.1856179535,
0.164615646,
-0.5973462462,
-0.1616276354,
-0.099226281,
-0.2272474915,
0.0753024146,
0.0666515976,
-0.3587420583,
0.0604426265,
-0.1527443677,
-0.1032580659,
0.2715846896,
0.6679752469,
-0.0917734057,
0.4572231174,
-0.4601513743,
0.6209070683,
0.5623257756,
0.5599268675,
-0.2038395107,
-0.7397553325,
-0.2449298799,
0.225137189,
-0.4419662058,
-0.6293815374,
0.1030543223,
-0.0003539418,
0.650177598,
0.6439483166,
0.1031297967,
0.6238805056,
-0.307682246,
0.6652572751,
-0.0358791985,
-0.935590148,
0.4851981699,
-0.2935942411,
-0.3508691192,
0.8955127597,
0.5247513652,
-0.0455574468,
-0.3491776884,
-0.8928226829,
-0.5785570145,
0.3288298845,
0.2985338271,
-0.0603457838,
0.4222128093,
0.4275483787,
0.0340481885,
0.1988774687,
-1.0008946657,
-0.2943909764,
-0.1377032399,
-0.0755976811,
0.1970602423,
-0.2042155862,
-0.1972533762,
-0.0100064371,
0.6551231742,
0.0272698831,
0.1244627163,
0.1233076826,
-0.2996333838,
0.0332312398,
0.0668069199,
0.0739945993,
0.8035587072,
-0.4203131199,
0.1614272445,
-0.04872353,
-0.5521003008,
0.4338167608,
-0.0068861702,
-0.3028855026,
-0.0273492374,
0.621642828,
0.3638886213,
0.211204499,
-0.354814291,
0.7842330337,
-0.065964289,
-0.3240752518,
-0.1633073837,
0.2996901572,
0.1980042309,
0.055743061,
0.5575771332,
-0.2787733972,
-0.1141524538,
-0.3696025014,
0.6011494398,
0.4238228202,
-0.1538104117,
-0.2690893114,
0.7578220367,
-0.1674527377,
-0.0492721051,
0.3562478721,
-0.0125039425,
-0.5379952788,
0.7362276316,
0.3750213981,
0.5809178948,
-0.0615871921,
-0.1165813282,
0.1608547866,
0.2136245668,
-0.3307190239,
0.3067242205,
-0.2524331808,
-0.8783539534,
0.0481905676,
-0.5464040637,
-0.6633184552,
0.4922385812,
-0.8495529294,
0.2833595872,
-0.759570539,
-0.4009256661,
0.2124900818,
0.2273574322,
-0.7329641581,
0.3413192034,
0.4698105156,
0.7528343797,
-1.1023211479,
0.8539883494,
0.2632757127,
-0.2973151505,
-0.6357809305,
-0.0121507086,
0.0986449197,
-0.9499629736,
0.3840039074,
0.3337686658,
0.272614032,
-0.0577255599,
-1.112675786,
-0.6853983402,
1.1872600317,
0.5796129704,
-0.5587709546,
0.3745934069,
0.4882174432,
0.1292029917,
-0.2171665728,
-0.2357314527,
0.4133284092,
0.5980837941,
-0.0321018286,
-0.2397483438,
0.0704179108,
-0.0564973503,
-0.3939970434,
-0.1337817907,
-0.3281338215,
0.8284442425,
0.006236841,
-0.429151088,
-0.15706563,
0.5909566879,
0.8558104634,
0.4371617734,
0.6962394118,
0.6146561503,
1.0027390718,
-0.2311149687,
1.0837036371,
-0.271548003,
0.306945622,
0.881303668,
-0.4793165028,
0.7129720449,
0.491725117,
-0.4727615714,
0.3886946142,
0.6921874881,
-0.4678795934,
0.5509161949,
0.7095022798,
-0.2665436566,
-0.4539439678,
-0.1965261549,
-0.6528373361,
-0.0694587156,
0.0775270388,
-0.3470571637,
0.1272837818,
-0.321926713,
-0.1066965386,
-0.1658550054,
-0.0902783573,
0.4545146227,
0.2984592319,
-0.0778600946,
0.4392954111,
-0.0307967775,
0.8471927643,
-0.8143895268,
0.1910060495,
-0.278553009,
0.1321668476,
-0.4060856402,
-0.8087139726,
0.0044098361,
0.0849397629,
0.0345142223,
-0.1375500113,
0.7986840606,
-0.3264317811,
-0.3104630113,
0.1933065802,
0.4295289814,
0.2668175995,
-0.3716631532,
-0.615070343,
0.2007102817,
-0.0375512838,
-0.1641646773,
0.4952803254,
0.3411631584,
-0.0295939222,
0.7639530897,
1.1775625944,
0.3871338069,
0.2519916296,
0.1228525117,
0.6926234961,
-0.569611311,
-0.5529667735,
-0.8311389089,
0.1484112889,
-0.1691794097,
-0.0520096347,
0.7653236985,
0.8034043312,
0.8098081946,
-0.0568269119,
0.8767620325,
0.2486563623,
-0.0721751079,
-0.5367798805,
0.8651692271,
-0.4943738282,
0.0534157529,
-0.1783150584,
-0.8010693789,
-0.1587122083,
0.5004619956,
-0.2399674952,
-0.0785367265,
0.5639724731,
0.693827033,
-0.4631357789,
0.204565376,
0.2417470366,
-0.4223640561,
0.6720957756,
0.3942365646,
0.9650691748,
-0.6407473087,
0.2991790771,
-0.467492193,
-0.0100585129,
-0.0689887553,
-1.2740849257,
-0.9679620862,
-0.4154647589,
-0.6301996112,
-0.4559902549,
-0.1402008235,
0.528263092,
1.1551676989,
-1.109218359,
-0.0351835564,
0.106989041,
0.2589357793,
-0.1122165993,
-0.2224382609,
0.4277433455,
0.2000544965,
-0.2313510031,
0.3369991183,
-0.0353674851,
0.9345262647,
-0.0165908206,
-0.096263364,
0.0606844909,
0.1260611266,
-0.0999419764,
0.2238303721,
-0.0166856553,
-0.1628402174,
-0.3846688271,
0.1030223742,
0.0555261858,
1.1995706558,
-0.3671114445,
0.2827545106,
0.2826289535,
0.7608459592,
0.8510988355,
0.2399623543,
0.2431013584,
-0.7358777523,
0.254671663,
0.088001512,
0.5686044693,
0.428486675,
-0.2058346868,
0.490529418,
0.5886921287,
-0.2881521583,
-1.030064106,
-0.1506053954,
-0.6601101756,
0.0334834084,
0.886392653,
-0.6726993322,
-0.2930721045,
-0.308809489,
0.1575063765,
0.1160206348,
0.000876756,
0.7653870583,
0.9791888595,
0.2733020782,
0.2198171914,
-0.5501217246,
0.5034938455,
0.2593790293,
-0.9552292228,
0.458049804,
0.1835258454,
0.7419770956,
0.0235763621,
0.5988327861,
-0.3793614507,
0.208042562,
-0.0311029684,
-0.0262540169,
-0.6769704819,
-0.2148012966,
-0.1889844388,
0.036247585,
0.0210850332,
-0.3303002417
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10891v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10891v1
|
Instruction Diversity Drives Generalization To Unseen Tasks
| 2024-02-16T18:47:21 | 2024-02-16T18:47:21 |
Dylan Zhang, Justin Wang, Francois Charton
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Instruction tuning -- fine-tuning a large language model (LLM) on pairs of
instructions and desired outcomes -- is an approach that enables pre-trained
language models to perform real-world tasks and follow human instructions. Its
practical success depends on the model learning a broader set of instructions
than those it was trained on. Yet the factors that determine model
generalization to such \emph{unseen tasks} are not well understood. %To
understand the driving factors of generalization, In this paper, we experiment
with string rewrites, a symbolic task that serves as a building block for
Turing complete Markov algorithms while allowing experimental control of
"inputs" and "instructions". We investigate the trade-off between the number of
instructions the model is trained on and the number of training samples
provided for each instruction and observe that the diversity of the instruction
set determines generalization. Generalization emerges once a diverse enough set
of tasks is provided, even though very few examples are provided for each task.
Instruction diversity also ensures robustness with respect to non-uniform
distributions of instructions in the training set.
|
[
-0.2383416146,
-0.92765522,
0.432103008,
0.0714413673,
-0.3506519198,
0.2410563678,
-0.251893878,
-0.2548995316,
-0.2011364698,
0.5589063168,
-0.9465183616,
-0.665761292,
-0.8493078351,
-0.0216011778,
-0.3994760811,
1.3462663889,
-0.0719754249,
-0.0873863548,
0.1030494422,
-0.0615232885,
-0.4453665912,
-0.3033407331,
-0.4016209245,
-0.3012205958,
0.6779917479,
0.5415347815,
0.6896213293,
0.9969754815,
0.4081414342,
0.3965644538,
0.073116526,
0.1212306172,
-0.7184175849,
0.3204775155,
-0.1140552685,
-0.9647182226,
-0.1464969069,
0.0447608195,
0.9845807552,
0.9375476837,
-0.1592510492,
0.3286713958,
0.2857055068,
0.6651892066,
-0.4107384682,
-0.0752811208,
-0.8585707545,
-0.0782377049,
-0.1708328873,
-0.1213497743,
-0.2256103605,
-0.4421545267,
0.0560623147,
-0.6374700665,
0.7800181508,
-0.0305066258,
0.7107329965,
0.0860259384,
-0.5626859665,
-0.1455021054,
-0.9698227644,
1.2104059458,
-0.3791819513,
0.2576452494,
0.2345508486,
0.0725261644,
-0.4314021766,
-0.3364183605,
-0.1157252938,
0.0114569636,
0.1627465487,
-0.2511772811,
-0.1552641243,
0.3822425604,
0.4630126953,
0.4602995515,
-0.2549941242,
0.2089531273,
-0.5625510216,
0.0696124583,
0.522929132,
0.3415393829,
0.5724891424,
0.3290343285,
0.2069421411,
-0.114116624,
-0.6966713667,
0.1922470629,
0.603427887,
0.1950428933,
-0.1316180527,
0.6564396024,
-0.4136951268,
0.8917467594,
0.0628493205,
0.0983387455,
0.0192333739,
-0.5108701587,
-0.3569666147,
-0.1695143431,
0.3581408262,
0.1518948674,
0.5554383397,
-0.0519781001,
-0.1866282672,
0.0817999542,
0.5598519444,
-0.6534838676,
-0.1682807952,
-0.2712657452,
-0.4586246908,
-0.1447062343,
0.0069483616,
-0.2529044747,
0.0966954902,
-0.5670825243,
0.1195008382,
-0.4893866181,
0.1552134156,
0.0732418001,
-0.420027703,
0.3684862554,
0.3709808588,
-1.4489017725,
0.518696785,
1.0543968678,
0.5579249859,
-0.1358263642,
-0.4171344042,
-0.4571110308,
0.175549686,
-0.5180039406,
0.4181432128,
-1.0364050865,
-0.3807647228,
-0.3058357537,
0.1172131225,
-0.2282750905,
-0.5346183777,
0.1749720126,
-0.4732462466,
0.0977515653,
-0.2331021428,
-0.4802698195,
-0.416685611,
-0.2101663053,
-0.4765990376,
0.6301570535,
0.1926537454,
-0.4655745924,
0.6983712316,
-0.4757865071,
-0.593913734,
-0.0882642642,
-0.3328234255,
-0.4539781511,
0.8407977223,
-0.0392143242,
0.1849596798,
-0.1882441789,
0.023340743,
-0.2491063029,
-0.9012980461,
0.0995881706,
-0.4739255607,
0.5223096609,
-0.0221726838,
-0.6071056724,
0.3156982064,
-0.5329625607,
0.0737174898,
0.0475647002,
-0.6669150591,
-0.4572578073,
0.0240237657,
-0.5205953121,
-0.1793361902,
-0.0458594635,
-0.4956141114,
0.4186812937,
-0.612821877,
0.2141614258,
0.9348598719,
-0.0607361309,
0.4842381477,
-0.4187048078,
0.6849605441,
-0.1251741499,
0.0830634013,
-0.2062888145,
-0.900547564,
-0.8474609852,
0.107432507,
0.1928927898,
0.5655676126,
-0.2898467779,
0.0945399553,
-0.0997113958,
-0.3754629195,
-0.8900994062,
0.4302688241,
0.6249186397,
-0.0482847318,
0.0547473803,
-0.3093506694,
-0.6011720896,
-1.1909717321,
-0.6601275802,
0.3561666012,
-0.2342641205,
0.2493657768,
0.4082348645,
-0.3680785894,
0.4539918303,
-0.3689979315,
0.1068719998,
-0.1618308127,
0.2768181562,
0.4138185382,
0.7506120801,
0.1923680454,
-0.5695534945,
-0.279078424,
0.0015767653,
-0.5614824891,
0.0524804741,
-0.2363557518,
-0.1021450832,
0.2383035719,
0.3403426409,
-0.2342511266,
0.4554726779,
0.6066160202,
-0.1115273312,
0.3669265211,
-0.5706805587,
0.331395179,
-0.6917128563,
-0.2925450802,
-0.1166634709,
0.083568193,
-0.6165617704,
0.3534082472,
-0.1435171068,
-0.1130171418,
-0.2240695059,
0.0184136555,
-0.8448942304,
-0.265009582,
-0.3176217973,
-0.225322172,
-0.2105572522,
0.6184026599,
-0.3220764399,
0.6220137477,
0.8066120148,
-0.717318058,
0.1360455006,
-0.1675250381,
-0.2593771815,
0.0678659827,
-0.7879937291,
0.2013072222,
-0.1492825896,
-0.1318675578,
-0.9276471734,
-0.0187551286,
0.1232200414,
-0.2278395593,
0.2909446061,
-0.1092182174,
-0.5286002755,
-0.1489276141,
-0.0843359083,
0.5839274526,
0.7753921151,
-0.209503144,
0.6518031359,
0.1062619463,
0.1072256342,
-0.5554527044,
-0.6811993718,
-0.2975671589,
-0.014300881,
-0.4525997639,
0.0746221989,
-0.1570269465,
-0.2693454623,
-0.1914292723,
-0.4822475314,
-0.0280959811,
0.4760377705,
0.6066816449,
0.1865051836,
-0.3345783055,
0.1050199717,
0.6776297688,
0.1747118831,
0.2215327173,
-0.5598585606,
0.5106700063,
-0.0096234512,
-0.6665372849,
-0.4847403467,
0.5546869636,
0.2315673828,
-0.1516540349,
0.7349549532,
0.3218298852,
-0.0137371412,
-0.5521259308,
-0.2892405093,
-0.2802011371,
-0.579382062,
0.6013396382,
-0.5381884575,
-1.2547551394,
0.2915301025,
-0.0417003371,
0.4307149947,
0.288053304,
0.4761548042,
-0.1831575185,
1.1055434942,
0.7146575451,
0.2547416985,
0.5487247109,
-0.0803864077,
-0.0790602937,
-0.5676811337,
-0.0497374199,
-0.4474085569,
-0.7946192026,
-1.0923855305,
-0.5553665757,
0.0739294589,
0.0035210657,
-0.2005441934,
0.1020374149,
-0.6980394125,
0.8895823956,
1.0199357271,
0.1523432881,
0.0702714771,
0.2945941389,
-0.2366367728,
0.0511055663,
-0.6299769282,
-0.392839998,
1.3767715693,
0.1804417223,
0.8526819348,
-0.0218241382,
1.1962212324,
0.0993871391,
-0.0648189262,
-0.4815512598,
0.7186629176,
-0.6824735999,
-0.4282059371,
-0.349466145,
-0.4423395693,
-1.4604159594,
0.281186223,
-0.1216644868,
-0.6448249221,
-0.0880707428,
0.358602345,
-0.1367761493,
0.3799419403,
-0.7652261853,
0.6923317313,
-0.0957612544,
-0.0682583675,
-0.6665270329,
-0.5032908916,
0.565767765,
-0.0512946062,
0.0242621619,
0.0488904901,
-0.0833345354,
0.6671723723,
0.0851418152,
1.1577786207,
0.0920002162,
-0.3144514859,
0.0179389808,
0.2331507355,
0.5230987668,
-0.1878283024,
0.2318849117,
0.0218217485,
-0.4048008919,
-0.5259860754,
-0.7555254698,
0.812194407,
-0.9445830584,
-1.1297233105,
-0.0277744979,
-0.852088213,
0.0297203902,
0.0593664721,
0.1805683225,
0.4833906889,
-0.24163495,
0.3530809283,
1.0596235991,
-0.2578701973,
0.1436061412,
0.4267825186,
-0.2119612992,
0.1048753262,
0.9214988947,
0.1232035309,
0.6904963851,
0.5707814693,
-0.0372070223,
0.2955351472,
-0.6256970167,
-0.2225166857,
0.1647469103,
-0.7166569829,
0.4360894859,
-0.641697228,
-0.0372979976,
-0.293581903,
-0.1163598076,
0.0054168925,
-0.4277066886,
-0.5099121928,
-0.1316007078,
0.0600476675,
0.9969124198,
0.1212250218,
0.3141030371,
-0.7296433449,
0.6024677157,
0.7054376006,
0.4512479305,
-0.0407336429,
-0.6524535418,
-0.2098822296,
0.193411395,
-0.2022448182,
-0.8573901653,
-0.0011256393,
0.2286573499,
0.7747281194,
0.3096277118,
-0.4621865451,
0.4800617099,
-0.7033838034,
0.3866457045,
-0.1931653917,
-0.9715601206,
0.6551165581,
-0.4972864389,
0.683262527,
0.2894653678,
0.1710362285,
-0.4752152264,
-0.9730279446,
-0.6870440245,
-0.6229054928,
0.8556726575,
0.2130418718,
0.3889986575,
0.1385381669,
0.3250161409,
0.3536159694,
0.2760325372,
-0.3177158535,
-0.3538381159,
-0.1042053252,
-0.0542361736,
-0.1982069016,
-0.3045218289,
-0.304430753,
-0.2819055021,
0.2663025856,
0.0964917317,
0.2259374112,
-0.358384639,
-0.0307095014,
-0.1981420666,
0.5994898081,
1.0769916773,
0.5712189078,
-0.0669493452,
0.186186254,
0.1456599087,
-0.4179749191,
0.2380821109,
-0.1816070825,
-0.3737891614,
-0.0518436655,
0.3793124855,
1.2256391048,
0.5010788441,
-0.4185802937,
-0.1987611502,
-0.0021442133,
-0.3597741723,
0.1455972791,
0.9903534055,
0.1095683575,
0.2080310136,
0.2726250589,
0.121171318,
0.1141808033,
-0.5977195501,
0.285109818,
0.6490767598,
-0.1482678056,
-0.4359703958,
0.4935049713,
0.0909759328,
-0.6677190661,
0.7094749212,
-0.1704955995,
-0.2717542648,
0.8825231791,
0.6807528138,
0.9328029156,
-0.2647648156,
0.2474566996,
0.1873205006,
0.682330966,
0.0464526676,
0.5017765164,
-0.1741542369,
-0.5407213569,
-0.195494622,
-0.5660680532,
-0.3211501241,
-0.2236963212,
-0.6037519574,
-0.1338426173,
-0.5851668715,
0.1518032998,
-0.2301097661,
-0.2656924427,
-0.7018347979,
0.3099965155,
0.0388615653,
0.4940581322,
-0.8203498125,
0.8157311082,
0.5747560859,
-0.0436199047,
-0.9244022965,
-0.0346304365,
-0.0175270233,
-1.1084703207,
0.9121543169,
0.1668489724,
-0.0282261167,
-0.0024569852,
-0.6273087859,
-0.917083025,
0.8539432287,
0.4936059713,
-0.90711689,
-0.1055971831,
0.2592237294,
0.5817226171,
-0.4136527479,
-0.0598837882,
0.6041747928,
0.3804425895,
-0.0574679971,
-0.8647111058,
0.0566191152,
-0.2713930309,
0.2558170259,
0.4827925265,
-0.2583310008,
1.0930272341,
-0.4445888698,
-0.4195584357,
-0.1720439345,
0.6193766594,
0.5843506455,
-0.0035718086,
0.4046736658,
0.3609568477,
0.6763970256,
-0.0449488238,
1.2615123987,
0.0361633152,
-0.0799809694,
1.1998728514,
0.1853812486,
0.4662582576,
0.5439911485,
-0.1271110922,
0.7757581472,
0.4864979982,
-0.504165709,
0.1963148266,
0.7670798302,
-0.1995236576,
-0.3350869715,
0.1177201197,
-0.1715194136,
0.3289974034,
0.1492392421,
-0.6200382113,
-0.2423074543,
-0.0303719547,
-0.2364289761,
0.0323713198,
-0.4853657782,
0.7997863889,
-0.0146128926,
-0.821420908,
0.7914861441,
0.0694942251,
0.7477382421,
-0.7738698125,
-0.2787314951,
-0.0234975517,
0.180712387,
-0.0842482224,
-0.7998273969,
0.2464621067,
-0.2537551224,
-0.5732562542,
-0.2080691457,
0.5936279297,
-0.4932730496,
-0.6411246061,
0.2072374076,
0.250323087,
0.2367992848,
-0.0556438155,
-0.5768303275,
-0.0169837922,
0.3058410287,
-0.1642293185,
0.6724177003,
0.6758052707,
-0.2482389957,
0.7776329517,
0.6206895113,
0.0353867598,
0.4875073433,
-0.0096371043,
0.8537416458,
-0.7385098934,
-0.3343029618,
-0.9936470389,
0.3671419024,
0.2374274731,
-0.3334175646,
0.8823552728,
0.4381309748,
0.9642699957,
-0.4115072489,
0.6640754938,
0.4662523866,
0.1248172745,
-0.4194463491,
0.5881446004,
-0.4629504681,
0.1610790491,
-0.0689766183,
-0.890498817,
-0.0619740672,
0.1888643801,
-0.2285704911,
0.3434862494,
0.5428744555,
0.8569065332,
-0.142430529,
-0.0199375451,
0.4297266304,
-0.1048926115,
0.0572049953,
0.7087155581,
0.6650807261,
-0.1780307591,
0.5141553879,
-0.0171060991,
-0.2349894941,
0.1000329778,
-0.5219048262,
-0.9853811264,
-0.3820268512,
-0.2214807272,
0.1208936274,
0.2281492054,
0.6399117112,
0.5599578023,
-0.913749516,
-0.5202404857,
-0.3505378067,
0.4791479111,
-0.5147325397,
-0.1665086895,
-0.0701082274,
-0.6124260426,
-0.7862530351,
0.3809924424,
0.2279578298,
0.1725494117,
0.0126677314,
0.0240014102,
-0.1434469521,
0.1627644002,
0.1873742342,
0.2559828758,
-0.994289279,
-0.1251817644,
0.1454232335,
-0.015351125,
0.0413774066,
1.0166594982,
-0.4494140744,
0.3648054302,
0.4357942641,
0.6267156005,
0.2172915041,
-0.0283395313,
1.0168315172,
-0.9073052406,
-0.2070858181,
-0.1706486642,
0.090538241,
-0.0094867107,
-0.3384882808,
0.1600815058,
0.2398817688,
-0.6735661626,
-0.6231853366,
0.5136739612,
-0.5984428525,
-0.4683530331,
1.0213475227,
-0.1090260297,
-0.3139028251,
-0.0347686484,
-0.2276990414,
0.4823543727,
-0.3988720775,
0.8007173538,
0.5935531259,
-0.1031910926,
-0.3796830475,
-0.3109264076,
0.5499876738,
0.735852778,
-0.653580308,
0.1627148092,
0.3708474338,
0.420118928,
-0.090737313,
0.3008416593,
0.4365092218,
0.5275230408,
-0.0880089849,
-0.0079757366,
-0.059104193,
-0.3477233052,
-0.5690620542,
0.3132342696,
0.0578003079,
-0.4554633498
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10890v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10890v2
|
When is Tree Search Useful for LLM Planning? It Depends on the Discriminator
| 2024-02-16T18:45:58 | 2024-06-06T14:55:40 |
Ziru Chen, Michael White, Raymond Mooney, Ali Payani, Yu Su, Huan Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In this paper, we examine how large language models (LLMs) solve multi-step
problems under a language agent framework with three components: a generator, a
discriminator, and a planning method. We investigate the practical utility of
two advanced planning methods, iterative correction and tree search. We present
a comprehensive analysis of how discrimination accuracy affects the overall
performance of agents when using these two methods or a simpler method,
re-ranking. Experiments on two tasks, text-to-SQL parsing and mathematical
reasoning, show that: (1) advanced planning methods demand discriminators with
at least 90% accuracy to achieve significant improvements over re-ranking; (2)
current LLMs' discrimination abilities have not met the needs of advanced
planning methods to achieve such improvements; (3) with LLM-based
discriminators, advanced planning methods may not adequately balance accuracy
and efficiency. For example, compared to the other two methods, tree search is
at least 10--20 times slower but leads to negligible performance gains, which
hinders its real-world applications. Code and data are available at
https://github.com/OSU-NLP-Group/llm-planning-eval.
|
[
-0.1571165472,
-0.6436182857,
0.7946401238,
0.2058309019,
-0.0730421916,
0.3662561476,
-0.0996519476,
-0.6477876306,
0.0624056943,
0.4109198749,
-0.3362449706,
-0.5291708708,
-0.5820934176,
0.2426092327,
-0.4645813107,
0.2915980816,
-0.1798076183,
-0.0535034277,
0.1740209758,
-0.1265743971,
-0.5880573392,
-0.5437675118,
-0.9228181839,
-0.4825511575,
0.6214935184,
0.5073837042,
0.9733151197,
0.9504237771,
0.207183212,
0.4348928928,
-0.4642803371,
0.1786425561,
-0.1555414498,
0.5905885696,
-0.0238212999,
-0.6536947489,
-0.4082221091,
-0.0749501213,
0.6753584146,
0.5003066659,
-0.4129922986,
-0.2356311232,
-0.2067556679,
0.8710901141,
-0.6881991029,
0.3634622991,
-1.004278183,
0.1317418069,
-0.3783764839,
-0.4463208318,
-0.6105313301,
-0.2730296552,
-0.083107084,
-0.3430198431,
0.4808349013,
0.0295021906,
0.5189489126,
0.242898494,
-0.4157831371,
-0.4765331149,
-0.9522272944,
0.8458101153,
-0.5323025584,
0.357512176,
0.5518130064,
0.4233873487,
-0.3778392076,
-0.4037843645,
-0.292612344,
-0.1565422863,
-0.1175538823,
-0.2528877258,
-0.2554986775,
0.4579207599,
0.5967410803,
0.1411414891,
-0.4823783636,
0.5790309906,
-0.1012619361,
-0.100012213,
0.6514005661,
0.1482072324,
0.1149545535,
0.1341343522,
0.2704339027,
-0.3572589755,
-0.7415390611,
0.1358073354,
0.2323139161,
0.541092813,
0.6032509208,
0.5946947932,
-0.285353303,
0.8427475691,
-0.2096300721,
-0.4037575424,
-0.0128408745,
-0.225790754,
-0.0943645015,
0.1350804567,
0.3766672015,
0.2517373264,
0.4684123695,
-0.1027773321,
-0.8019717336,
0.2003222257,
0.11138504,
-0.703797996,
-0.2292667031,
0.3614134789,
-0.1978672743,
0.0729066879,
-0.491754055,
-0.5871382356,
-0.2740677893,
-0.178329289,
-0.0518191308,
-0.2253324538,
-0.133321628,
0.1336417049,
0.0437546857,
0.2891117632,
0.5001912117,
-0.7545364499,
0.2219198048,
0.691622436,
0.7461838722,
0.0953801125,
-0.4324835837,
-0.7979557514,
0.1439387649,
-0.7697870135,
0.9830669165,
-0.6097928882,
-0.4391072989,
0.2565602064,
-0.2499301583,
-0.2212673128,
-0.8356593251,
0.587102592,
-0.6102052927,
-0.1049826965,
-0.1766660362,
-0.2133597285,
-0.2594691217,
0.0086602708,
-1.0611175299,
0.9663878679,
-0.182824865,
-0.4751326144,
0.7596515417,
-0.5575888157,
-0.5529496074,
0.0180126429,
-0.2771939933,
-0.6049989462,
0.0894514099,
0.3030076921,
0.4441047609,
-0.0250881072,
0.3895683587,
-0.0021398978,
-0.5768868327,
0.0056804749,
-0.2794071734,
0.6709741354,
0.2012286931,
-0.3413917422,
0.3376322389,
-0.6043132544,
0.1723837256,
0.2034479082,
-0.8106719851,
-0.061301861,
0.6731176376,
-0.3587211668,
0.1468966454,
-0.0115250489,
-0.488266319,
0.2199058831,
-0.3675742745,
0.1447314769,
0.9918285012,
-0.5415778756,
0.4152840674,
-0.390714258,
0.7196838856,
-0.3664162755,
-0.0838494971,
-0.0091803791,
-0.4209795594,
-0.7496982217,
-0.0122013967,
0.1615341604,
0.4188330472,
-0.7193590403,
0.1141063049,
-0.1014538184,
-0.365295589,
-0.3486453295,
-0.1205263063,
0.4807440341,
-0.4017584622,
0.3115421832,
-0.0293944515,
-0.7333453894,
-0.5142670274,
-0.4304739833,
-0.4910078347,
0.3258458674,
-0.0205093566,
0.2554841936,
0.11495471,
0.9411356449,
-0.3541049361,
-0.3518505991,
-0.5262888074,
-0.0602957606,
0.1164963916,
0.0820249692,
0.5235825181,
-0.7810764909,
-0.4460802674,
0.0631560311,
-0.4528823793,
-0.2443326861,
0.0447276123,
0.3214823604,
0.5278862119,
0.4574140012,
-0.6987320185,
0.430005461,
0.5652855635,
-0.3051766753,
0.5256960988,
-0.2528772652,
-0.1796308011,
-0.5455060005,
-0.1523601413,
-0.0801376849,
-0.198349759,
-0.8025324345,
0.4005717933,
-0.0669758469,
0.2710745335,
-0.2854197621,
0.3312180936,
-0.6421117187,
-0.4580850601,
-0.3909040391,
0.1513236016,
-0.3064833879,
0.2636707425,
-0.073680222,
1.0445482731,
0.3423394263,
-0.8739513755,
0.0976185724,
0.0579221509,
-0.2328832448,
0.3162289858,
-0.1435863078,
0.3034983277,
-0.2615079284,
0.3938481212,
-0.8349031806,
0.1371655166,
0.0226530861,
-0.3445004225,
0.4201160371,
0.0029152804,
-0.6478540897,
-0.4861229956,
-0.4897091687,
0.3136583865,
0.0218338389,
-0.700601995,
0.7224853039,
0.3165837824,
0.0394998826,
-0.8403518796,
-0.5629389286,
0.1266096383,
-0.2112488151,
-0.4181374013,
0.5155960321,
0.0528649613,
-0.3262384236,
-0.145241797,
-0.2900618315,
0.0206892807,
0.2613223493,
0.0174487103,
-0.2440269142,
-0.0723191574,
-0.0695644543,
-0.2914010286,
-0.3547512591,
0.063279748,
0.1173466444,
0.814735949,
0.2891994417,
-0.4948825538,
-0.2202066332,
0.3400531411,
0.3324521482,
-0.3340829015,
0.3373612165,
-0.0183426961,
-0.2547834218,
-0.256921649,
-0.6360913515,
0.1451792866,
-0.4634336829,
0.6092597246,
-0.6748031378,
-0.7610692382,
0.4155805111,
-0.0600226074,
0.4814953208,
0.4068593681,
0.3299495578,
0.1051797345,
1.5589786768,
0.6906127334,
-0.0533151291,
0.5633721948,
-0.0844725594,
0.2487646043,
-0.6580744982,
-0.2150287926,
-1.1717065573,
-0.384560287,
-0.7654229403,
-0.4022449255,
-0.0837132931,
0.0829858407,
-0.0862466469,
0.3724173307,
-0.5756824613,
0.6740015745,
0.5851868391,
-0.2976664603,
0.6885430217,
0.0962546542,
-0.0238829646,
0.0202713385,
-0.682415247,
-0.5679535866,
0.8994783759,
0.2926086783,
0.6449137926,
0.1428371519,
0.6469333768,
-0.0967156291,
0.1417040378,
-0.9829664826,
0.887191236,
-0.3492017686,
-0.5145683885,
-0.5473393798,
-0.3401385546,
-1.3927067518,
0.6721674204,
0.2032716125,
-0.7370818257,
0.4039058983,
-0.0000048814,
-0.0730880648,
0.5969253182,
-0.501057446,
0.3528389037,
-0.4335584342,
0.2264231741,
-0.4936451316,
-0.1172375306,
-0.0050698221,
-0.3213290274,
0.1141317263,
-0.3440323174,
0.0632981285,
0.8900665641,
-0.30322209,
0.5120625496,
-0.4299189746,
-0.1532567739,
0.0738444626,
0.2682198882,
0.9229672551,
-0.6970359087,
-0.4494773746,
-0.1833370626,
-0.0365506932,
-0.2780029774,
-0.3346123993,
0.4333179891,
-0.494276762,
-1.0305639505,
-0.6190091968,
-0.5033670664,
0.0026369628,
0.159714818,
-0.1637823582,
0.0316816494,
0.0128530422,
0.1889512688,
0.1654402465,
-0.2876554132,
0.790240705,
0.709382236,
-0.7579676509,
0.025284756,
0.6571742892,
0.4675990641,
0.3207692504,
0.4135730863,
0.2275186777,
-0.1952803433,
-1.0669227839,
-0.1970143318,
0.194238022,
-0.8268091679,
-0.3328027427,
-0.4930525124,
-0.3218170404,
-0.0173001662,
-0.0845770389,
-0.211247772,
-0.2428203672,
0.177425459,
-0.2228413671,
0.2665924132,
0.9847047329,
-0.0165604185,
0.4951222539,
-0.1369665712,
0.1313371509,
0.1604871601,
0.1973634064,
-0.0942730233,
-0.0143809505,
-0.1333649904,
-0.1063871905,
-0.3713519275,
-0.7676478028,
0.4053867161,
0.1161366105,
0.729886055,
-0.0194385238,
-0.1091026068,
0.7593112588,
-0.2714903653,
0.329859972,
-0.2647808194,
-0.4761618376,
0.5460786819,
0.1275872141,
0.4097320437,
0.4848677814,
0.0907914862,
-0.3418965638,
-0.5452037454,
-0.2571251988,
-0.8659071326,
1.1725087166,
0.2262088805,
-0.2881747186,
0.1905912608,
0.2234148532,
-0.292827487,
0.0354832187,
-0.7089528441,
-0.2977712452,
0.3941296637,
0.4103637338,
-0.1382043958,
-0.5326434374,
0.1484194249,
-0.1582477987,
0.5580824614,
-0.2240971625,
0.1819849312,
-0.0790723786,
-0.0036349613,
-0.5394417644,
0.3335574567,
0.2957082093,
0.8395721316,
-0.2382853031,
0.2116582692,
0.2704795003,
-0.3599683046,
0.2219813913,
0.3163609803,
-0.3142318428,
0.2091609836,
0.4485221505,
0.5211886168,
-0.0581899174,
-0.5021041632,
0.1976113617,
-0.0030438781,
-0.2709662914,
-0.1801538467,
0.0107322233,
-0.0962622985,
0.340598464,
0.3672147095,
-0.0729897693,
0.0702660084,
-0.5548860431,
0.0378025062,
0.6028271317,
0.0762665048,
-0.0136355152,
0.3726551533,
-0.059983518,
-0.8063015938,
0.5569075942,
-0.2362654507,
-0.789280653,
0.6470289826,
0.6845371723,
0.8501002192,
-0.7972868085,
0.3774403632,
0.17213507,
0.3906756938,
-0.1994935721,
0.2936246395,
0.0010986996,
-0.8593974113,
-0.9199042916,
-0.5742434859,
-0.2990000844,
-0.1005076692,
-0.0900830477,
0.3219877779,
-0.4596417248,
-0.1226431206,
-0.0706277564,
0.2394149005,
-0.6072223186,
0.0823005065,
-0.2285390794,
0.7625108957,
-0.514603734,
0.833658278,
0.6683087945,
-0.1395638436,
-0.9259211421,
0.090272367,
0.0209323596,
-1.0475679636,
0.6454331875,
0.319960922,
-0.4010723829,
-0.0741466284,
-0.1390224546,
-1.0185068846,
1.2307143211,
0.4286137521,
-0.8547062874,
-0.4639398158,
0.3732541502,
0.5327072144,
-0.1059161052,
0.4673614502,
0.8620610833,
0.5075139999,
0.3520713747,
-1.1738606691,
-0.0090206238,
0.2610576749,
0.1827615499,
0.6003047228,
-0.408331573,
0.8649757504,
-0.1662399173,
-0.6431245208,
0.0283425692,
0.1347882599,
0.6872285008,
0.3874321878,
0.741068244,
0.4774897397,
0.8128451705,
-0.1744398028,
0.9662926197,
-0.1627324075,
0.2096468061,
0.9196004868,
-0.3524390459,
0.9223229289,
0.2095769644,
-0.5576982498,
0.2989535034,
0.7034314275,
0.3800672591,
0.3624949157,
0.3634026945,
-0.1972136497,
-0.1429895163,
-0.1315267682,
-0.1575336009,
0.4681506753,
0.2794160247,
-0.2927038968,
-0.5057833791,
-0.380091399,
0.1681006551,
0.2340117991,
-0.1894936562,
0.6798051596,
0.0049329437,
-0.7567934394,
0.5147742033,
0.1587072909,
0.5108653903,
-0.391313225,
-0.1850233525,
-0.2438633442,
0.3446881473,
-0.4703277051,
-1.0522691011,
0.3715782762,
-0.1478487104,
0.1547204107,
-0.4816256166,
0.6960512996,
-0.0902919844,
-0.1604256183,
0.7902971506,
0.5487585664,
0.1563397497,
-0.3841744959,
-0.6969263554,
0.2029458433,
0.1284157485,
-0.2596926391,
0.0894919634,
0.5028081536,
-0.3376754522,
0.906735003,
0.5525915623,
0.2513300478,
0.0654328018,
0.2043323815,
0.8214065433,
-0.8168691397,
-0.2554908097,
-0.9310404062,
0.1473879665,
0.1749468893,
0.0739940181,
0.4928310215,
0.7973955274,
0.9972031713,
0.4293448329,
0.3207415342,
0.1059993282,
0.4643215239,
-0.8264144659,
-0.0244419631,
-0.4193728864,
0.6721135974,
-0.1317802221,
-1.5277626514,
-0.445333451,
0.7256969213,
-0.3199374378,
0.305306673,
0.8678925037,
0.9200123549,
0.4426910281,
-0.1690039784,
0.508037746,
0.2737514675,
0.790158093,
0.6548797488,
1.0274273157,
-0.0092143938,
0.6587414145,
-0.1739196628,
0.0033281706,
-0.2099478394,
-0.4322680235,
-0.5389208198,
-0.5295729041,
-0.1125881225,
-0.2422030419,
0.3025767803,
0.8097715378,
0.5467114449,
-0.63567698,
-0.6339065433,
-0.2681411803,
0.447216481,
-0.1413829625,
-0.1780737638,
0.2603693306,
-0.3403852582,
-0.7570970058,
0.6313241124,
0.1813271493,
-0.1400239617,
-0.3823890388,
-0.231578812,
-0.4523611665,
-0.3074183166,
0.7018210888,
0.2615581751,
-1.0310952663,
-0.3433047533,
-0.168892473,
0.0556610599,
0.2729128599,
0.9305801392,
-0.9039673209,
0.575820148,
0.2860266268,
0.3403504193,
0.6861851811,
-0.0952177048,
0.5686392784,
-0.5558404922,
-0.164396584,
0.2876257896,
0.4100289941,
0.2317985296,
-0.2087162882,
0.8128970861,
-0.1006959677,
-0.815991044,
-0.7335171103,
0.4130466282,
-0.5317210555,
-0.2610815167,
1.2257614136,
0.3464697301,
-0.0317413136,
-0.3242917657,
-0.623221755,
0.0427006111,
-0.564437747,
0.438277334,
0.6361128092,
-0.4415700436,
-0.2914150059,
-0.5541671515,
0.6482582688,
0.411567688,
-0.5886315107,
0.2482365072,
0.5635391474,
-0.1041093543,
0.343606025,
1.0781402588,
0.1585865468,
0.0596028008,
-0.1535137147,
-0.0369678847,
0.2781864703,
-0.5556733012,
-0.3818387389,
0.1001972631,
0.8847050667,
-0.0805928856
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10886v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10886v1
|
Reviewer2: Optimizing Review Generation Through Prompt Generation
| 2024-02-16T18:43:10 | 2024-02-16T18:43:10 |
Zhaolin Gao, Kianté Brantley, Thorsten Joachims
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent developments in LLMs offer new opportunities for assisting authors in
improving their work. In this paper, we envision a use case where authors can
receive LLM-generated reviews that uncover weak points in the current draft.
While initial methods for automated review generation already exist, these
methods tend to produce reviews that lack detail, and they do not cover the
range of opinions that human reviewers produce. To address this shortcoming, we
propose an efficient two-stage review generation framework called Reviewer2.
Unlike prior work, this approach explicitly models the distribution of possible
aspects that the review may address. We show that this leads to more detailed
reviews that better cover the range of aspects that human reviewers identify in
the draft. As part of the research, we generate a large-scale review dataset of
27k papers and 99k reviews that we annotate with aspect prompts, which we make
available as a resource for future research.
|
[
-0.605071485,
-0.3154758215,
0.8772044778,
0.4447897077,
-0.4872915745,
-0.3039890528,
0.1469040811,
-0.4947695434,
0.0688025206,
0.5805501342,
-0.8166981339,
-0.3884907663,
-0.2109432071,
0.5798599124,
-0.2259063721,
1.1696527004,
-0.125463143,
-0.0102030234,
-0.100104481,
0.1075668409,
-0.4291569591,
-0.1087005064,
-0.7364223003,
-0.4368410707,
0.8430333734,
0.5194066763,
0.4893490672,
0.2054272592,
0.5422518849,
0.1949954033,
-0.2915792763,
0.5465335846,
-0.396566838,
0.6059541106,
-0.0661713704,
-0.5326164365,
-0.6221290827,
0.1418145597,
0.4450920522,
0.4205601513,
0.3171343803,
0.1955141872,
0.3818748593,
0.7766682506,
-0.3080755174,
-0.095395349,
-0.4640170038,
0.2315296531,
-0.0488267243,
-0.4579687119,
-0.3086189628,
-0.679628551,
-0.0889525488,
-0.4423505366,
0.492428869,
0.0393288881,
0.577616632,
0.137358278,
-0.4421068132,
-0.4198698103,
-0.5840008259,
0.5748892426,
-0.4700864851,
-0.140986681,
0.3091396689,
0.3158839941,
-0.1932383627,
-0.4352919757,
-0.615095973,
-0.1175435483,
-0.0907152146,
0.3007610142,
-0.0158029422,
0.1205818355,
0.3524264991,
0.3601269722,
-0.3921661377,
0.1756899208,
-0.2974000275,
-0.3326406479,
0.9123767018,
0.4005637765,
-0.2371612787,
-0.5735030174,
-0.2458016127,
-0.1990661472,
-1.1165732145,
0.341360569,
0.8198409081,
0.0811044425,
0.1863448769,
0.6652386785,
-0.3617999852,
0.4497938156,
0.1952991635,
0.044248268,
-0.0085932994,
-0.710570991,
0.1245126352,
-0.4930454493,
0.6131141782,
0.9113060832,
-0.323385179,
0.4735666811,
-0.8953748345,
-0.3062373996,
0.2623132765,
-1.0160820484,
-0.1149959266,
0.5124168396,
-0.6539821625,
-0.7314099073,
0.4018476009,
-0.9222982526,
-0.9215096831,
-0.3303729594,
0.06060341,
0.0049264417,
-0.1297878772,
-0.4022803307,
-0.2528367341,
0.0271005277,
0.7395120859,
-0.5297243595,
-0.0211518351,
0.7494308949,
0.6154816747,
-0.1109829992,
0.0192320254,
-0.6953476071,
-0.3657159805,
-0.5254259706,
1.3019450903,
-0.1037590206,
-0.5842963457,
0.2545213401,
-0.3529009521,
0.7451806664,
-0.7619107366,
0.5412771702,
-0.2801318169,
0.3304161131,
-0.4509007037,
0.0158060957,
0.0464586467,
0.4563758075,
-0.5973255634,
1.1230686903,
0.4167690575,
-0.7439675927,
0.4556731284,
-0.440982461,
-0.3463668823,
0.0319251828,
-0.1866206974,
-0.6739220619,
0.4770491421,
0.4689921439,
0.3465574384,
-0.5963051319,
0.0720930845,
-0.1419415474,
-0.1723208278,
0.2707019448,
-0.0538836047,
0.4329927564,
0.5395005345,
-0.3493126333,
0.4556552768,
-0.5434677005,
0.2036334872,
-0.1660301983,
-0.4985141456,
0.2361779511,
0.0214656629,
0.1265781522,
0.2228865921,
-0.0200989284,
-0.2467905581,
0.1828859001,
-0.4719255269,
0.3510908484,
0.8152327538,
0.6930264235,
0.4103241861,
-0.5940932631,
0.7367044687,
0.2558763921,
0.3223276138,
-0.604480803,
-0.324575007,
-0.8020255566,
0.2601601779,
0.1904374361,
0.3057189286,
-0.8811196685,
0.6143680215,
0.3484605849,
-0.4969805181,
-0.6586668491,
0.5509271622,
0.6428330541,
0.2083332539,
0.0282214731,
-0.2351330668,
-0.4677259624,
-0.9266084433,
-0.1502272785,
-0.7923930287,
-0.230327785,
0.3344334066,
0.2073750645,
-0.1886700243,
0.7898198962,
-0.3569124341,
-0.0439517684,
-0.6168882847,
0.0712463409,
0.1868373156,
0.2209719718,
0.0376252607,
-0.5838638544,
-0.1882516295,
-0.2653860748,
-0.7202394009,
-0.5927576423,
-0.4507059157,
-0.3315715194,
0.108657904,
0.4077422321,
-0.5574797988,
0.1460227817,
0.1463062018,
-0.4372034371,
0.5009968281,
0.0122921476,
0.0821111649,
-1.0155414343,
-0.0287222005,
0.0518202744,
-0.1073244065,
-0.2956888676,
0.0206030458,
-0.0048499489,
-0.3720040619,
-0.2086999416,
0.5576050878,
-0.7056470513,
0.0564765818,
-0.4246665835,
0.1923008263,
0.3963041008,
0.2037411928,
-0.1643021107,
0.5488283038,
0.0495743863,
-0.4795153141,
0.1235656291,
0.2466488928,
-0.4395390749,
0.6902813911,
-0.7899392247,
0.3365289867,
-0.3336735964,
0.4773554206,
-1.0884213448,
-0.5374518633,
0.268391937,
-0.3262922466,
0.2687152922,
0.0709725469,
-0.5851849914,
-0.6011160016,
-0.9849649072,
-0.1106470674,
0.4994083941,
-0.4876025915,
0.3558610678,
0.247800529,
-0.7238880992,
-0.1265246868,
-0.2717547715,
0.111505039,
0.0342502706,
-0.7024415135,
0.0108563527,
0.024237413,
-0.5791780949,
-0.2900011539,
-0.0339376405,
0.3278311193,
-0.056216944,
0.3160714507,
0.0635187998,
0.0658552051,
-0.0264681168,
0.4439506233,
-0.1740306467,
0.1998849809,
-0.0594899543,
0.1483993679,
0.2751376033,
-0.2519313991,
-0.4702145457,
0.6953591108,
0.2797298431,
0.0454296805,
-0.3509524167,
0.3102208376,
-0.0473326258,
-0.7170650959,
-0.7322688103,
-0.5411667824,
-0.4265320599,
0.4470437169,
-0.3740479052,
-0.6697596312,
0.3578433394,
-0.091925025,
0.4463661909,
0.4441409111,
0.7812470794,
-0.2010006905,
1.0498173237,
0.6355111599,
0.3030101359,
0.5359488726,
-0.1419135034,
0.0833215937,
-1.0042675734,
-0.3709121048,
-0.5960184336,
-0.4081192315,
-0.2813447416,
-0.5040978789,
0.6435396671,
0.5558624864,
0.0906601548,
0.0650209039,
-0.6647565961,
0.4156162441,
0.7419878244,
0.3133751452,
0.0103480155,
0.0154221682,
-0.2393438816,
0.0357608013,
-0.4655888677,
-0.9392775297,
1.0753477812,
0.4968359172,
0.5633550286,
-0.0559891872,
0.9008546472,
0.3216088414,
0.5182145834,
-0.5662080646,
0.7303854823,
0.3347190917,
-0.4429682791,
-0.1676107198,
-0.3136317134,
-0.6778330803,
0.2569973171,
-0.3501859903,
-0.1362791359,
0.2692556083,
0.4109706879,
-0.5535019636,
0.0106270257,
-0.5995616913,
0.2709426284,
-0.1036338061,
-0.5974202156,
-0.0038122861,
-0.6644662619,
0.5303555131,
-0.2057647258,
-0.1691859961,
-0.0941436216,
-0.0673484579,
0.5964275002,
-0.8520976305,
0.7895206213,
-0.5560295582,
-0.2071015686,
0.8295587301,
0.2910937965,
0.8033288717,
0.588475883,
-0.3096088171,
-0.3341960907,
-0.4646387398,
-0.0831680745,
-0.5722461343,
0.5208445191,
-0.6623374224,
-0.6232740879,
-0.2168049067,
-0.2749328911,
-0.216529116,
0.0059481794,
0.6763035059,
0.4077992141,
0.0760476366,
-0.3268152773,
0.280223161,
-0.236256659,
0.2874972522,
0.2308889031,
-0.1599726677,
-0.8671993017,
0.4756404459,
-0.086936757,
-0.130892083,
0.0649935752,
0.1067553386,
-0.4937494993,
-0.938957572,
-0.6512608528,
0.1100193039,
-0.7031541467,
-0.5169697404,
-0.6012270451,
0.1320468187,
-0.24621059,
-0.1012485176,
0.0836892799,
-0.5241054893,
-0.3060266674,
-0.2341987342,
0.1353578568,
1.3428378105,
-0.1239091977,
0.3055614829,
-0.5873227715,
0.2607503831,
0.327201277,
0.0836488158,
0.0112007586,
-0.2956708074,
0.0069351029,
-0.5211814046,
-0.9173629284,
-0.8648505211,
0.0626695529,
-0.1461606175,
0.3986378908,
0.635959208,
0.1487828344,
0.3529727459,
-0.3297308385,
1.2003548145,
0.3523803353,
-0.5891584754,
1.012286067,
-0.3632203341,
0.4233463705,
0.8876671791,
-0.0914021954,
-0.197236985,
-0.7157276273,
-0.4067888856,
-0.9691619873,
0.68436867,
0.32057935,
0.185282439,
0.0490487143,
0.558722496,
0.4235695302,
0.3122891486,
-0.4683381915,
0.2208173722,
-0.1217348129,
0.0849801227,
0.0241947416,
-0.8818534017,
-0.2502169013,
0.2469657958,
0.6259512305,
-0.2605108619,
0.3327362537,
0.5223594308,
0.124041982,
-0.4597419798,
0.3252278268,
0.6120160818,
0.6261872053,
0.0469122566,
0.3734264374,
-0.0046595545,
-0.3141685128,
0.2872220278,
0.0903495699,
-0.7447540164,
0.1652732342,
0.7387363911,
0.7305153012,
-0.0815049633,
-0.3704968989,
0.3586080074,
0.0897899792,
-0.4668011069,
-0.089036338,
0.1632778645,
-0.1350152493,
0.4074271619,
0.3615164459,
0.1632062495,
0.2712541819,
-0.4297248423,
0.1838199049,
0.2172075361,
-0.4068110585,
-0.5411311984,
0.7011535764,
0.8518701792,
-0.4889879823,
0.5131821632,
-0.4714985788,
-0.4963395894,
0.4230623245,
0.2095733732,
1.1464301348,
0.1895295978,
0.1721059084,
0.6336839199,
0.2264404744,
-0.0805815607,
0.6378507614,
-0.160594672,
-0.1260545105,
-0.1548882276,
-0.5665451884,
-0.7302353382,
-0.0877462253,
-0.4740719199,
0.508204937,
-0.6642020345,
-0.4480645955,
-0.1353340894,
0.2407027334,
-0.5097345114,
-0.0587065481,
0.0646859482,
0.7685750127,
-0.5860571861,
0.3407715857,
0.6841162443,
-0.4865418971,
-0.7453324795,
0.1835638434,
0.2888676524,
-0.4033513963,
0.4676111639,
0.475446552,
0.0138932141,
-0.3736341894,
-0.4413560927,
-0.088458918,
1.1598389149,
0.1001697704,
-0.8243154287,
0.2064169496,
-0.1760204881,
0.5710387826,
-0.3943712115,
0.622413516,
0.20545955,
0.5962101221,
-0.0223511364,
-0.3946518004,
0.2091102004,
-0.6204338074,
0.273203969,
0.0783364028,
-0.6400247216,
0.8050152063,
-0.5751485825,
-0.1921767741,
0.2766716778,
0.7453665137,
0.614004612,
0.5897542238,
0.7889903188,
0.1003992632,
0.7791073918,
-0.0556861088,
1.2310466766,
-0.2492234856,
-0.0408460535,
0.9208644629,
-0.4519821107,
0.7638698816,
0.6517122388,
-0.1347192526,
0.3616074622,
0.9133657813,
-0.1676464379,
0.3585645854,
0.5215699077,
-0.4365774095,
-0.1842491627,
-0.1745274216,
-0.1728538126,
-0.2951830029,
-0.2185474634,
-0.5305614471,
-0.2208092064,
-0.3208296597,
-0.0185441878,
0.2148621976,
-0.3432993591,
1.194200635,
0.2084171921,
-1.2886042595,
0.1931196004,
0.119393222,
0.6580858827,
-0.4811689556,
-0.2157385498,
-0.6914564967,
-0.0421760604,
-0.3353309035,
-1.1024746895,
0.0943189189,
0.4341270328,
-0.3978524804,
-0.6354163289,
0.6385265589,
-0.2475215644,
-0.6200927496,
0.1251620948,
0.7436518073,
0.2933222353,
-0.1017864943,
-0.5149886012,
0.1158196926,
0.07320223,
-0.6902407408,
-0.0003582182,
0.6128239036,
-0.4239050746,
0.2474823445,
0.663885653,
0.253757894,
-0.2013771534,
0.2238501161,
0.9410475492,
-0.7825132608,
-0.5437751412,
-0.7439501882,
0.614544034,
-0.2978530228,
-0.7795693278,
0.520945251,
0.6073313951,
0.4463447928,
-0.0554344729,
1.0414031744,
0.0339031778,
0.5839341283,
-0.621691525,
0.5224477649,
-0.2811586261,
0.5092740655,
-0.0463197418,
-1.2840631008,
-0.3768833578,
0.3166953921,
0.0304179639,
0.1181299388,
0.7313603759,
1.1714509726,
0.4853735268,
-0.1308345944,
0.0013284851,
-0.0096647041,
0.5201897621,
0.6195869446,
1.1891646385,
-0.2668239474,
0.5285018682,
-0.2217266709,
-0.0301364418,
-0.3952192664,
-0.8948477507,
-1.150044322,
-0.3241037428,
-0.2052248418,
-0.777700007,
-0.1474525779,
0.9320070148,
0.7087414861,
-0.7433096766,
-0.0005883512,
-0.2927967608,
0.2229971141,
0.0707468837,
-0.1742078364,
0.2576188743,
-0.5456700921,
-0.6088339686,
0.2544047236,
0.289285928,
0.1106511503,
-0.7099635601,
-0.3609016538,
0.6810500622,
0.0275180563,
0.5737745762,
-0.2075736523,
-0.7286093831,
-0.1133461595,
-0.1063375622,
-0.2623352408,
-0.1383417845,
1.2132312059,
-0.4343174994,
0.4344179928,
0.9005483985,
0.1408925802,
0.2681408525,
0.2518908381,
0.6768147349,
-0.571082592,
-0.0518595017,
0.5254445076,
0.2376225889,
0.4053125381,
-0.5311229229,
0.6579750776,
-0.0064136465,
-0.437823236,
-0.9266473055,
0.257132113,
-1.0089883804,
0.0919542536,
1.428535223,
-0.0173599422,
0.1472043693,
0.0119866692,
-0.5871688128,
-0.1882160157,
-0.5624325871,
0.7742733359,
0.5775843263,
-0.3881960809,
-0.1312345117,
-0.4459671974,
0.6547805071,
0.3574101031,
-1.1085095406,
-0.0390457474,
0.5738210082,
0.0568496622,
-0.0731055513,
0.8778981566,
-0.267254889,
0.5023294091,
0.0845966041,
0.0464530252,
-0.3450442255,
-0.4456657171,
-0.6679371595,
0.4536002874,
0.5463353992,
0.3858342767
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10884v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10884v1
|
Multi-modal preference alignment remedies regression of visual instruction tuning on language model
| 2024-02-16T18:42:08 | 2024-02-16T18:42:08 |
Shengzhi Li, Rongyu Lin, Shichao Pei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
In production, multi-modal large language models (MLLMs) are expected to
support multi-turn queries of interchanging image and text modalities. However,
the current MLLMs trained with visual-question-answering (VQA) datasets could
suffer from degradation, as VQA datasets lack the diversity and complexity of
the original text instruction datasets which the underlying language model had
been trained with. To address this challenging degradation, we first collect a
lightweight (6k entries) VQA preference dataset where answers were annotated by
Gemini for 5 quality metrics in a granular fashion, and investigate standard
Supervised Fine-tuning, rejection sampling, Direct Preference Optimization
(DPO), and SteerLM. Our findings indicate that the with DPO we are able to
surpass instruction-following capabilities of the language model, achieving a
6.73 score on MT-Bench, compared to Vicuna's 6.57 and LLaVA's 5.99 despite
small data scale. This enhancement in textual instruction proficiency
correlates with boosted visual instruction performance (+4.9\% on MM-Vet, +6\%
on LLaVA-Bench), with minimal alignment tax on visual knowledge benchmarks
compared to previous RLHF approach. In conclusion, we propose a
distillation-based multi-modal alignment model with fine-grained annotations on
a small dataset that reconciles the textual and visual performance of MLLMs,
restoring and boosting language capability after visual instruction tuning.
|
[
-0.2989574075,
-0.9729992747,
0.4265321791,
-0.0864147246,
-0.3080376983,
-0.1077980995,
-0.3648000956,
-0.2358820587,
0.0422428623,
0.5981396437,
-0.5720980167,
-0.4335885942,
-0.5898370743,
-0.0508749187,
-0.1148424298,
0.9198893905,
0.0278394353,
0.3680474758,
-0.4698413312,
-0.2596493661,
-0.7853103876,
-0.2983741164,
-0.2332143784,
-0.0627626926,
0.57237643,
0.6147748232,
0.7739015818,
0.9424699545,
0.6104159951,
0.3491474688,
0.0393464454,
0.421105057,
-0.4669950604,
0.2163574398,
0.1720523089,
-0.4122735262,
-0.5238849521,
0.0094899442,
0.5859524608,
0.4649558961,
-0.1110253334,
0.2923791111,
0.1896857321,
0.9379719496,
-0.734351635,
0.0635500476,
-0.6605715156,
-0.203366518,
-0.1034443453,
-0.3353688717,
-0.5110551119,
-0.3502918184,
0.2408045977,
-0.7119484544,
0.0201119613,
0.0830167532,
0.8349956274,
0.768553257,
-0.5225570202,
0.0318203643,
-0.4563596845,
1.0207730532,
-0.5673362017,
0.4261285067,
0.5051425099,
0.3618969917,
0.0431301706,
-0.4789451659,
-0.4210942686,
-0.2226680815,
-0.1060827598,
0.172966525,
0.1104541495,
0.1799857616,
0.1992697418,
0.372947216,
-0.536608696,
0.1288829297,
-0.3003531992,
-0.2183203548,
0.3488613963,
0.3762732148,
0.1617819369,
-0.2197278291,
-0.5242046118,
-0.2731590569,
-0.452537775,
0.2950873375,
0.1870779991,
0.3551388085,
0.0737896115,
0.7049223185,
-0.3045727909,
1.1388220787,
0.0581888631,
-0.3787001669,
0.3486510515,
-0.5976490974,
-0.3921365142,
-0.1090963706,
0.6760550737,
0.7350103259,
0.2546482384,
0.2957030833,
-0.1238431856,
-0.1963718534,
0.2555509508,
-0.800408721,
-0.135392189,
0.014205412,
-0.4740996361,
-0.1663599163,
-0.1181769744,
-0.6872221828,
-0.4084808528,
-0.8222614527,
0.5314934254,
-0.4389196634,
0.0491946638,
0.1714787036,
-0.1136214435,
0.2236445695,
0.5599204302,
-1.0387351513,
-0.0775024593,
0.5194966793,
0.584856689,
-0.1255206764,
-0.4159511626,
-0.6679228544,
-0.0984920785,
-0.1872491837,
0.4944400787,
-0.7181930542,
-0.220679611,
-0.0269875415,
0.0280178338,
-0.2618252039,
-0.5152982473,
0.3640103638,
-0.3990807235,
0.4502524734,
-0.5917232633,
-0.430899173,
-0.134111464,
0.3776338995,
-0.6333165169,
0.9927724004,
-0.0054939417,
-0.7849142551,
0.5650428534,
-0.2418532521,
-0.1536669731,
-0.2793675065,
-0.2566063702,
-0.4366223812,
0.1106602177,
0.429780215,
0.350525707,
-0.2831290066,
0.2566865683,
-0.3372703791,
-0.4198757708,
0.1733748913,
-0.8323409557,
0.5159140825,
-0.0001488169,
-0.2589553893,
0.4450274706,
-0.7971782684,
0.1367444843,
-0.1270367503,
-0.3962750733,
-0.5654206872,
-0.067197904,
0.0182676893,
0.2524567246,
0.4132641256,
-0.3166895211,
0.4963824451,
-0.0593837202,
0.1543063372,
0.8015509844,
-0.1992391795,
0.4354596436,
-0.0339842141,
0.4613114297,
0.0730065256,
0.6253706217,
-0.0746251792,
-0.477835834,
-0.9839068651,
-0.4916275442,
0.2720300257,
0.5296685696,
-1.0000872612,
0.1028644964,
-0.2660633028,
-0.1980896443,
-0.8158560395,
0.2528146505,
0.5624935627,
0.8772156835,
0.6227373481,
-0.1238766313,
-0.3444657326,
-1.1756826639,
0.0746210515,
-0.0800692737,
0.1933273226,
0.3164463937,
0.113428399,
-0.1170996577,
0.7376213074,
-0.5746276379,
-0.2571446002,
0.1171217263,
0.1133038998,
0.0121016521,
0.2286159843,
0.6157953143,
-0.8628212214,
-0.5350627303,
-0.0187206175,
-0.4365858138,
-0.1117544323,
0.1280551404,
-0.2510378361,
0.3417689204,
0.3628293574,
-0.0935305804,
0.3423728347,
0.6418671012,
-0.317781508,
0.5837868452,
-0.1539370716,
0.5534677505,
-1.1269066334,
-0.2007822841,
0.0766059682,
-0.2237410694,
-0.3502237797,
-0.2391308844,
0.2173450887,
0.279671669,
-0.4311065674,
0.3843173981,
-0.3875252903,
0.1502970904,
-0.3770535886,
0.0628243983,
0.1828484684,
0.5229308009,
0.2113765329,
0.9656009078,
0.5917730331,
-0.307280004,
0.2345911711,
0.1990770251,
-0.094092004,
0.6177893877,
-0.5812829137,
-0.189111039,
-0.1586725414,
-0.2038139552,
-1.0443867445,
-0.0686167553,
0.2589339614,
-0.2012058645,
0.5267311335,
-0.2157191038,
-0.0885676295,
-0.1009542719,
-0.533806622,
0.2765305638,
0.2391697317,
-0.4471948445,
0.4897786379,
0.0817130506,
-0.0727144703,
-1.1860173941,
-0.4379433095,
-0.0910246149,
-0.1835776567,
-0.4692330062,
0.1496065408,
-0.1670811623,
-0.1135644615,
-0.0693999603,
-0.1524203718,
-0.0794873908,
-0.0388358757,
0.1210713834,
0.6997281313,
-0.4201898873,
0.1931546479,
0.0939690322,
-0.0905924588,
-0.247254774,
-0.0685488135,
0.3276602924,
-0.2897305787,
-0.3636315167,
-0.3812073469,
0.2349639982,
0.8306251168,
-0.4155662954,
0.7727762461,
0.7399567366,
0.0072471956,
0.1511628777,
-0.5954936743,
-0.2019132823,
-0.4353935122,
0.3919050097,
-0.2340178639,
-0.842110157,
0.1901170611,
0.2171491385,
0.0919700563,
0.3219242096,
0.5401965976,
-0.1299464852,
0.9470592141,
0.6978483796,
-0.0785186812,
0.9069580436,
-0.0290282071,
-0.1322453469,
-0.7768194675,
-0.1757371277,
-0.319645375,
-0.4773615003,
-0.6558766961,
-0.4319933355,
0.3750297725,
0.1580570936,
-0.1866354048,
0.0723924935,
-0.6409671307,
0.4332156181,
0.8666660786,
0.2193070352,
0.3770604134,
0.0682449862,
-0.0358619019,
-0.2793970406,
-0.599752903,
-0.5236002207,
1.1529179811,
0.1316871941,
0.9472466707,
-0.0035740025,
0.6458231807,
-0.0299182385,
0.2736519277,
-0.9186878204,
0.3560484648,
-0.3292043209,
-0.4608591199,
-0.4668720067,
-0.4320167601,
-0.6384186149,
0.3089989126,
-0.4407494068,
-0.6876353621,
0.2796854973,
0.4178960323,
-0.2484799623,
-0.0996412113,
-0.9969805479,
1.1285949945,
-0.5749722719,
-0.7666360736,
-0.0185032003,
-0.7447612882,
0.4238545895,
0.2029978335,
-0.0486646332,
0.0908130556,
-0.0994977802,
0.4259715378,
-0.339009881,
0.841397047,
-0.1115845144,
-0.0610987097,
0.063672483,
-0.2318651825,
0.2256071121,
-0.0188621338,
0.1261090636,
-0.1017024219,
0.1459230483,
-0.3619165719,
-0.6916151047,
0.7747981548,
-0.8027545214,
-0.705255568,
-0.2922908068,
-0.5405721068,
-0.266869396,
0.0763004124,
0.2145950049,
0.5085946321,
0.0250563845,
0.4341489375,
0.8153076172,
-0.0574372038,
0.4533731937,
0.4872093797,
-0.2760097384,
-0.6491675973,
1.0190402269,
0.0548154265,
0.4715935588,
0.4526329339,
0.2598417103,
-0.4268763661,
-0.4312015176,
-0.8076899648,
-0.0158385839,
-0.6711440086,
-0.3258438408,
-0.3714969158,
0.0657551736,
-0.1512408257,
0.03059013,
-0.4491089284,
-0.3699510992,
-0.3620411456,
0.1090347469,
0.4297674894,
0.489759773,
0.2960711122,
0.1274503618,
-0.7794012427,
0.408289969,
0.4703064561,
0.3914094269,
-0.2077932209,
-0.5969112515,
-0.3084580004,
0.2162578106,
-0.338036567,
-0.7419493794,
0.1237425506,
0.2445753366,
0.5174559355,
0.3390188217,
-0.0877532512,
0.9314504862,
-0.3850060105,
0.7278978229,
0.2206041217,
-0.7172515392,
0.5911835432,
-0.2737081349,
0.2739547491,
0.7918208241,
0.3041714728,
-0.3329511881,
-0.1367309093,
-0.1169862822,
-0.8641777039,
0.5616558194,
-0.081423901,
-0.0457008407,
0.1670363396,
0.31500718,
0.2037816197,
0.3759845495,
-0.6731560826,
-0.4395926297,
-0.4946922958,
-0.3856959939,
-0.1277348846,
-0.2840946019,
-0.2324971259,
-0.3998422623,
0.6476191282,
-0.4036744237,
-0.2177958339,
0.0421968885,
-0.1216620803,
-0.000238256,
0.3493286669,
0.8188420534,
0.6950495243,
-0.2539631426,
0.0070028785,
-0.1748747081,
-0.5717447996,
0.1291431785,
0.1584022939,
-0.233084321,
-0.2699832022,
0.2595041692,
0.8604033589,
0.0721020997,
-0.5572876334,
0.5337144136,
-0.3568314016,
-0.0253776684,
0.1951616704,
0.1835012883,
-0.0097265989,
0.2487690449,
0.2333536595,
0.1167416647,
0.1999786645,
-0.4006949067,
0.0489775203,
0.5740785599,
-0.5896615386,
0.0162124634,
0.5807965398,
0.2008712292,
0.0237929262,
0.5451776385,
0.2448545545,
-0.2287601233,
0.3537811041,
0.2969503105,
0.5588653088,
-0.0341107026,
0.2479580045,
0.2884836495,
0.3753684163,
-0.1453955173,
0.3725285232,
0.0012711752,
-0.5516533256,
-0.5055678487,
-0.6473936439,
-0.3074577451,
0.0556767583,
-0.8898327947,
0.3551855981,
-0.227818802,
-0.2529545724,
-0.089287512,
-0.1166194454,
-0.6263242364,
0.2560441494,
0.1976997852,
0.6098777056,
-0.908808589,
0.9659069777,
0.8449683785,
-0.7187646031,
-0.637429595,
0.016622778,
0.1558802426,
-0.7802826762,
0.55340451,
0.0544767939,
-0.2239126116,
-0.1412548423,
-0.4397499561,
-0.7505853176,
1.1710214615,
0.5214327574,
-0.7916671634,
0.2694474757,
0.0564373136,
0.5905607343,
-0.2117523104,
0.1974575967,
0.5264854431,
0.4695474207,
-0.0134115731,
-1.0087093115,
-0.2185933292,
-0.2138604671,
-0.097930178,
0.2547094226,
-0.7229188085,
0.5826851726,
-0.117528066,
0.2308212668,
0.00160795,
0.4972220063,
0.1032503769,
0.3452696502,
0.3718696833,
0.5786178112,
0.645861268,
-0.2215769142,
0.9060767293,
-0.2467339486,
0.2019272298,
1.2382696867,
0.0593758859,
0.9578359127,
0.9400690794,
0.0643821582,
0.2907778621,
0.6009587646,
0.2909902632,
0.6143032908,
-0.1619580239,
0.0569609851,
-0.462282002,
-0.2538177371,
-0.4332034886,
0.6414673328,
0.1609704047,
-0.4822098315,
0.101958245,
0.0184477344,
-0.3159880638,
0.2539246678,
-0.2216203213,
0.834713161,
-0.1942115426,
-0.7021337152,
0.8633841872,
-0.3166975975,
0.6666395068,
-0.5531522036,
-0.1474170536,
-0.2781529725,
0.09122511,
-0.0404151864,
-0.7634999752,
-0.0174943972,
-0.1866341382,
-0.5222678185,
-0.2039799392,
0.5385754704,
-0.7013263702,
-0.5029486418,
0.0696871132,
0.7224058509,
-0.3111037612,
0.1397423148,
-0.7338263392,
0.1751077026,
0.0801622272,
-0.3592533469,
0.4334203005,
0.4106784463,
-0.0676130503,
0.5537625551,
0.3399752378,
-0.1938453764,
0.1593135446,
0.3530235589,
0.9585264325,
-0.5071719289,
0.0020996763,
-0.8543599844,
0.730007112,
-0.1241675392,
-0.5430731177,
0.6955308318,
0.5186380148,
0.7305864096,
-0.1666506082,
0.5336638689,
0.1446897984,
0.109712705,
-0.8930702209,
0.3757547438,
-0.9259446859,
0.1878776103,
-0.3282617331,
-0.9681245685,
-0.1866078377,
0.3695998788,
-0.4358999431,
-0.045384489,
0.6368247271,
0.8554528356,
-0.0868802145,
-0.1967128068,
0.4155742824,
-0.1166581586,
0.032695394,
0.3075350225,
0.8786287308,
-0.3385879695,
0.5217846632,
-0.3332675397,
-0.3418242633,
-0.4150871038,
-0.7532807589,
-0.8345336914,
-0.6504795551,
-0.25210464,
-0.1299516261,
-0.0550187342,
0.9579385519,
0.6200373173,
-0.5837842226,
-0.0299013685,
0.3174308836,
0.1127432883,
-0.4232345819,
-0.2296811193,
0.3874969482,
-0.398458004,
-0.8476437926,
0.2597149909,
0.3735185862,
0.2088308334,
-0.2123919427,
-0.0656776652,
-0.1875901073,
-0.1350523978,
0.6890489459,
0.0097440761,
-0.9257182479,
-0.4130064845,
0.4683635533,
-0.288075,
0.1843103021,
0.6862257719,
-0.5444324017,
0.7797239423,
0.5577381253,
0.6179568768,
0.1678888798,
0.2094724327,
0.5318265557,
-0.7833692431,
0.1533189565,
0.0294699818,
0.494164288,
0.3892730176,
-0.3501804471,
0.2028540671,
0.0371012613,
-0.5469158292,
-0.5022899508,
0.1869098991,
-1.1323599815,
-0.2397413552,
1.0286072493,
0.1040770262,
-0.2711791396,
0.0389611647,
-0.702357471,
0.1752717942,
-0.4246375263,
0.8142713904,
0.7000932097,
-0.1104655042,
-0.2993102372,
-0.5919551253,
0.5322324038,
0.5298365355,
-0.5883780122,
0.2918573618,
0.9894900322,
0.1778933555,
0.0711460412,
0.4039442837,
-0.0442252234,
0.413389802,
-0.1892943978,
0.0593989901,
-0.3376581073,
-0.5093088746,
-0.3074664176,
-0.0240199007,
0.2781070471,
-0.5188091397
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10882v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10882v3
|
Universal Prompt Optimizer for Safe Text-to-Image Generation
| 2024-02-16T18:36:36 | 2024-06-25T05:56:40 |
Zongyu Wu, Hongcheng Gao, Yueze Wang, Xiang Zhang, Suhang Wang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Text-to-Image (T2I) models have shown great performance in generating images
based on textual prompts. However, these models are vulnerable to unsafe input
to generate unsafe content like sexual, harassment and illegal-activity images.
Existing studies based on image checker, model fine-tuning and embedding
blocking are impractical in real-world applications. Hence, we propose the
first universal prompt optimizer for safe T2I (POSI) generation in black-box
scenario. We first construct a dataset consisting of toxic-clean prompt pairs
by GPT-3.5 Turbo. To guide the optimizer to have the ability of converting
toxic prompt to clean prompt while preserving semantic information, we design a
novel reward function measuring toxicity and text alignment of generated images
and train the optimizer through Proximal Policy Optimization. Experiments show
that our approach can effectively reduce the likelihood of various T2I models
in generating inappropriate images, with no significant impact on text
alignment. It is also flexible to be combined with methods to achieve better
performance. Our code is available at https://github.com/wzongyu/POSI.
|
[
0.0100260153,
-0.5432002544,
0.6648050547,
0.2032992691,
-0.6867460608,
-0.4267727137,
0.1289054453,
-0.1970417649,
-0.4103985727,
0.3470205069,
-0.6808465123,
-0.5925395489,
-0.4038794637,
0.159548223,
0.3039725125,
0.9752727151,
0.2436655462,
-0.1732087284,
0.0869529769,
0.2197306156,
-0.9261460304,
-0.0318895765,
-1.2452354431,
0.1678809673,
0.501358211,
0.4627242982,
0.6701832414,
0.5586228371,
0.3407849669,
0.2133782059,
0.0064729182,
0.3038146496,
-0.5163036585,
0.4028971493,
-0.5070941448,
-0.0683414415,
-0.2751603127,
-0.2622725964,
0.2939349115,
-0.2286984324,
0.1962671578,
-0.1613763869,
0.0613860786,
0.1376187801,
-0.8968294263,
-0.2406444997,
-0.4630692303,
0.1509882063,
0.0554655306,
-0.5154901147,
-0.6515421867,
-0.6432880163,
-0.1657130271,
-0.8008946776,
-0.2206968814,
0.0735020712,
1.0238782167,
0.4814430773,
-0.5416278243,
-0.052267272,
-0.5630602241,
0.7904452682,
-0.6430251598,
-0.2073574215,
0.0992466658,
0.3234869838,
-0.3149087131,
-0.49884969,
-0.2987859249,
-0.0338495709,
-0.0151980538,
0.2121168077,
-0.3122610152,
0.1458323002,
0.0420070402,
-0.1525925398,
-0.5646749735,
0.2191882282,
0.005368589,
-0.421472609,
0.673027575,
0.351695776,
0.6061073542,
-0.2089078426,
-0.4637090564,
-0.1843584478,
-0.735665679,
0.2382407635,
0.4245616794,
-0.0383699387,
0.0682610646,
0.3570728004,
0.2402307838,
0.283228159,
0.0338268243,
-0.1310620457,
0.0175910573,
-0.5276870131,
0.2485889792,
-0.0260876864,
1.1927378178,
0.8890540004,
0.3578233719,
-0.174969539,
-0.2928511798,
0.2806870639,
0.4044687152,
-1.4005064964,
0.014254583,
0.2294938564,
-0.251621604,
-1.0358829498,
0.0180289652,
-0.9807053208,
-0.4866490364,
0.2078440487,
0.4702878296,
-0.4806375206,
-0.2785055637,
-0.1298235506,
-0.1956365854,
0.0760035217,
0.1085517034,
-0.5440106988,
-0.2083177716,
0.5373310447,
0.6394325495,
-0.0262579899,
0.0577144958,
-0.8889858127,
0.331669271,
-0.4774651229,
0.7322232127,
-0.382551074,
-0.5744190812,
0.2102996707,
0.0605108403,
0.2587170899,
-0.1974177659,
0.8537598848,
-0.2946819365,
0.2286447883,
-0.1678849161,
-0.1795724481,
0.2998158336,
0.057412602,
-0.4085428119,
0.6483738422,
-0.0958781242,
-0.9770617485,
0.3456414938,
-0.7401064038,
-0.383987546,
0.2011871934,
-0.1383332461,
-0.7928319573,
-0.0500382297,
0.1051947698,
0.2332266569,
-0.2266398966,
0.5846521258,
-0.2478686273,
-0.4827705324,
0.1394630075,
-0.3798343837,
0.8285523653,
0.4037994742,
-0.4667493999,
0.4449614286,
-0.5051246285,
0.0248183291,
0.5274400115,
-0.0027538957,
-0.4147574604,
0.0894568115,
0.286249578,
0.284345746,
0.0443318225,
-0.9550834298,
-0.081492655,
-0.0791272148,
0.4882314801,
0.8266317844,
0.4152947962,
0.3501634598,
-0.2212124616,
0.334579438,
0.1410771161,
0.3517592549,
-0.4549791515,
-0.6264536977,
-0.1467368752,
-0.1564426273,
0.1708230227,
1.0160489082,
-0.7631635666,
0.6921272278,
0.0610149764,
-0.3176542222,
-0.3073274791,
-0.3196196854,
0.7738166451,
0.7315378785,
0.1085762531,
-0.1165671498,
-0.0637601614,
-0.8642802238,
-0.1734089553,
0.0205646139,
-0.4236008227,
0.1991532147,
0.3663299382,
-0.196938619,
0.7266036868,
-0.4686899185,
-0.2675158381,
0.1798266321,
0.0785089433,
-0.1480000615,
0.8512886763,
0.6991288662,
-0.6356422901,
-0.1761584729,
-0.189723894,
-0.6881331205,
-0.2366664857,
-0.177571103,
-0.5264315009,
0.2798556685,
0.3767071366,
-0.4155898392,
0.5593937635,
0.0531867035,
-0.8463358879,
0.5079846382,
-0.4254198074,
0.2575583458,
-1.2993626595,
0.3674140275,
0.2331648022,
-0.1649216413,
-0.6239884496,
0.1029910967,
0.3714814782,
-0.5865627527,
-0.5896755457,
0.6858133078,
-0.1256928295,
0.5312874317,
-0.0194348525,
-0.1404159367,
0.0064597735,
0.3872163892,
0.0345550925,
1.0026006699,
0.635620892,
-0.4979528785,
-0.1002229303,
0.3904282153,
-0.0765054598,
0.899335146,
-0.8568966985,
0.3608680665,
-0.3333416283,
-0.029776806,
-1.1431680918,
-0.4145747423,
0.6269446611,
-0.3558523953,
0.5101015568,
0.059128698,
-0.3308685124,
-0.3136838973,
-0.5542168617,
0.3951933682,
0.8044760823,
-0.4964568019,
0.0979151949,
0.1655994803,
-0.1445865482,
-0.6461315751,
-0.5738219023,
0.1292088032,
-0.2639562786,
-0.7637941241,
0.3693983257,
-0.1350502372,
0.086300455,
0.0733650625,
-0.0787838548,
-0.0614359714,
0.1039267406,
0.1999137253,
0.4404389858,
-0.0350856856,
-0.0910333246,
0.5015999079,
-0.5485522747,
0.0746664107,
-0.2352814227,
0.1031772718,
0.0795666277,
-0.0562882237,
-0.8788051009,
0.6754652262,
0.3090706766,
-0.3007714152,
0.5503802299,
0.5694780946,
-0.4324694872,
-0.1080180928,
-0.1889984906,
-0.0268925074,
-0.5446401238,
0.402795881,
-0.2676027417,
-0.6673402786,
0.1606931686,
-0.0052050566,
0.2942656577,
0.2323208898,
0.2279228121,
0.0503731035,
1.32033813,
0.4077515602,
0.2060501128,
0.4315366149,
0.0365150645,
0.2609924078,
-0.3932268322,
-0.3492909968,
-0.5238634348,
-0.1720250845,
-0.4063095152,
-0.0731536075,
0.5314665437,
-0.0175687503,
-0.8153836727,
0.049811963,
-0.9512833953,
0.7528130412,
0.4991408885,
0.3618601859,
0.0249105394,
0.1589111537,
-0.1014172733,
-0.1955640316,
-0.3821626604,
-0.7402907014,
0.7706900239,
0.2100759745,
0.7043328285,
-0.1452505887,
0.6887964606,
0.2906098962,
0.100509055,
-0.3628562987,
0.658247292,
-0.3335665464,
-0.3283664882,
-0.3009892702,
-0.3600707352,
-1.0015989542,
0.0597570688,
-0.3164351285,
-0.7075368166,
0.1354344487,
0.2605659664,
-0.3671349585,
0.4488423467,
-0.8258178234,
1.1163212061,
-0.277505815,
-0.6752467752,
0.1756308377,
-0.6568491459,
0.3093024194,
0.0331505947,
0.0543905161,
0.0448823385,
-0.3787292242,
0.385972321,
-0.3976440132,
0.5695595741,
-0.5710921288,
-0.1711167097,
0.3171978593,
0.3262254596,
0.5692546964,
0.1685649008,
-0.1438269913,
0.0424544662,
-0.1350935996,
-0.5127096772,
-0.1644535661,
0.6177309155,
-0.6034108996,
-0.4750258327,
-0.12209934,
-0.4264768958,
-0.0240652021,
0.3179268837,
0.9200445414,
0.4834117889,
-0.1089407653,
-0.2487154007,
0.7325783968,
-0.6104774475,
0.6204348803,
0.1604971886,
0.3019033372,
-0.6190396547,
1.1778788567,
-0.3809479773,
0.0794944465,
0.2325111777,
0.2660538852,
-0.3565561175,
-0.5281473398,
-0.7168880701,
0.1877243519,
-0.4108755887,
-0.5706425309,
-0.3676017821,
-0.0917310566,
-0.2693096995,
-0.4079879522,
-0.0117588779,
-0.1124021783,
-0.6216818094,
0.1094902158,
0.1623450071,
0.5166751146,
0.0749965236,
0.2837208509,
-0.7686827183,
0.1866291016,
0.2608018219,
0.578856349,
-0.2046378255,
-0.119118914,
0.4156848788,
-0.0829966664,
-0.6865612864,
-1.075715661,
0.319714576,
0.1206976324,
0.1844676882,
0.6245949268,
0.4662800133,
0.286344856,
-0.5963059068,
0.761330843,
0.5603034496,
-0.6780526638,
0.823149085,
-0.6521804929,
0.1057824194,
0.5011600852,
0.1968588829,
-0.3401114643,
-0.63651824,
-0.3751874566,
-0.7435037494,
0.7778893709,
0.4236004949,
0.079950504,
-0.0402344801,
0.4147123098,
0.1910224557,
0.0100251697,
-0.4021739662,
-0.1171649769,
-0.421764791,
-0.5246383548,
0.2044380605,
-0.5251228213,
0.0152014541,
0.2833615243,
0.6313724518,
-0.0594803356,
0.3378587365,
0.2746338248,
0.0773978829,
-0.5193487406,
0.5792858005,
0.4216549993,
0.1030945107,
-0.1536190808,
-0.1468576193,
-0.1727548838,
-0.4482666254,
0.5351497531,
0.020342987,
-0.7780920863,
-0.1680261046,
-0.168985188,
0.9842587709,
0.0030352324,
-0.614869535,
0.7976738214,
-0.2448696941,
-0.4041362703,
-0.0351081975,
0.4125571549,
-0.2470733523,
0.1472475231,
0.2406172305,
0.2787100077,
0.2236881852,
-0.0618803762,
0.1206478849,
0.4210511148,
-0.3600487411,
-0.2169808447,
1.2447879314,
0.590277493,
-0.5953062773,
0.4605018497,
-0.6936861277,
-0.2449311316,
0.6311187744,
0.8729528189,
1.0332698822,
-0.4218508005,
0.417519778,
0.7576058507,
0.3084017932,
0.0684979931,
0.3934778571,
0.1712431312,
-0.3718071282,
-0.149947077,
-0.196180746,
-0.3247737288,
0.2310774177,
-0.300657779,
0.4721190631,
-0.4953183234,
-0.1988092363,
-0.1153806299,
-0.174574703,
-0.4019460678,
0.2197720408,
0.1965733618,
0.6597936153,
-0.7982730269,
0.3553839028,
0.8255334496,
-0.3181015551,
-0.7020999193,
-0.1114764586,
0.0824505687,
-0.4332708418,
-0.0177378561,
0.4895557463,
0.1766936779,
0.0665732101,
-0.6414543986,
-0.3119248748,
1.040392518,
0.5267931819,
-0.5884523988,
-0.1597879231,
0.0688214377,
0.2919372618,
-0.2657980621,
0.3421725631,
0.4133049846,
0.4550828636,
0.2270320356,
-0.4309819639,
0.5726237893,
-0.6284450293,
0.3786869943,
0.4002112448,
-0.4359615445,
0.3488566875,
-0.5156131983,
-0.5209638476,
0.4863587916,
0.285510391,
0.4865871072,
0.5525414944,
0.6306776404,
0.4797587991,
0.6536924243,
-0.2590812147,
1.0467433929,
-0.0130536556,
-0.0478255861,
0.5462983251,
-0.1204096377,
0.3882748187,
0.222126171,
0.3953743577,
0.2796573639,
0.6689087749,
-0.2945203185,
0.7522799969,
0.069163993,
-0.2733182609,
-0.2382124811,
-0.4187057912,
-0.2680935562,
-0.2417890877,
0.1715733111,
-0.1310010999,
-0.3343794942,
0.0834570602,
0.2357657254,
0.1067517549,
-0.3039491177,
0.7368729115,
-0.3299083412,
-0.8410701752,
0.4777139723,
-0.0532648675,
0.9300506115,
-0.4659948051,
0.0445274264,
-0.1086532474,
0.1233134344,
-0.1151114404,
-0.9591094851,
0.1735455692,
0.2080371231,
0.1190356016,
-0.0648761913,
1.1214860678,
-0.4416909814,
-0.2160258293,
0.0093076369,
-0.0966451019,
0.016757613,
0.0509544425,
-0.5618745685,
-0.1903473735,
0.1165353507,
-0.1862640679,
0.2789991498,
0.5933952928,
-0.2531276047,
0.2777834833,
0.5349630713,
-0.1119477376,
-0.2666352093,
-0.0754008517,
0.5966220498,
-0.6744117737,
-0.8281604052,
-0.6214225888,
0.8711280227,
-0.2233564407,
-0.5196020007,
0.051273495,
0.2800136805,
0.3737675548,
-0.1802076548,
0.7674177289,
-0.0159917828,
0.0150944516,
-0.3024421632,
0.923205018,
-0.6727416515,
-0.276099205,
-0.4544167221,
-0.698581934,
-0.2987076044,
0.2739067972,
-0.0453542769,
-0.288643986,
0.6257581711,
1.0462809801,
0.1855604798,
0.2180456519,
0.1492266208,
-0.2382352352,
0.4019950032,
0.8866092563,
0.7372326851,
-0.401609093,
0.9331370592,
-0.3191643953,
-0.4277557135,
0.1384547353,
-1.2097780704,
-0.8659755588,
-0.3758186698,
-0.4225995541,
-0.4751164019,
0.2080324441,
0.6016919613,
0.5367359519,
-0.8176318407,
0.2458926439,
-0.2404440641,
-0.0739846453,
0.1297517866,
-0.1967443228,
0.3657139838,
-0.536147356,
-0.5952553749,
0.0129673611,
0.2542566657,
0.2381573468,
0.2688832581,
-0.3215098679,
0.3749958277,
0.1403419524,
0.2975030839,
0.1929782033,
-0.3968218863,
-0.2420777678,
-0.0671286359,
-0.2804485857,
0.0340987109,
0.7067537904,
-0.2954003215,
0.3131066263,
0.3198106289,
0.7095106244,
0.0458454639,
0.0258788727,
0.4317904413,
-0.6891972423,
0.2964898646,
0.2415459007,
0.2222162783,
0.3097859323,
-0.7333959341,
0.4666008353,
0.0764863417,
-0.6475399137,
-0.851837635,
0.2053127736,
-0.8452314138,
-0.2886117995,
1.1766680479,
-0.0370579958,
-0.4745983183,
0.0541518927,
-0.7483733892,
0.4495236278,
-0.8660686016,
0.6061888337,
0.1559258252,
0.2867737412,
-0.1527207196,
-0.1107651293,
0.5493659973,
0.3691163063,
-0.9957358241,
-0.2794020474,
0.6463693976,
0.2919892371,
0.0390806012,
0.4839367867,
-0.3118752241,
0.6753061414,
-0.0050782431,
-0.0011213532,
-0.4559293687,
-0.2148946077,
-0.3020737171,
0.1971486956,
-0.2486216128,
-0.5875128508
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11005v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11005v2
|
Exploring Value Biases: How LLMs Deviate Towards the Ideal
| 2024-02-16T18:28:43 | 2024-02-21T22:02:18 |
Sarath Sivaprasad, Pramod Kaushik, Sahar Abdelnabi, Mario Fritz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large-Language-Models (LLMs) are deployed in a wide range of applications,
and their response has an increasing social impact. Understanding the
non-deliberate(ive) mechanism of LLMs in giving responses is essential in
explaining their performance and discerning their biases in real-world
applications. This is analogous to human studies, where such inadvertent
responses are referred to as sampling. We study this sampling of LLMs in light
of value bias and show that the sampling of LLMs tends to favour high-value
options. Value bias corresponds to this shift of response from the most likely
towards an ideal value represented in the LLM. In fact, this effect can be
reproduced even with new entities learnt via in-context prompting. We show that
this bias manifests in unexpected places and has implications on relevant
application scenarios, like choosing exemplars. The results show that value
bias is strong in LLMs across different categories, similar to the results
found in human studies.
|
[
-0.4227169156,
-0.6445769072,
0.5658507943,
-0.229060784,
-0.1380839646,
-0.041704312,
-0.1316945404,
-0.7065868974,
0.4812930822,
0.6983435154,
-0.3824653029,
-0.2374086976,
-0.5375706553,
-0.0882270634,
-0.4020543694,
0.9891479611,
0.0146724451,
0.2199709862,
-0.2350249887,
-0.3013237715,
-0.2911596,
-0.8109301925,
-0.5933127999,
-0.5078974962,
0.5413342118,
0.2644037008,
0.6231673956,
0.4923656583,
0.1826068312,
0.0674480498,
-0.078906551,
-0.1207428426,
-0.9375901818,
0.1997825801,
-0.2206795365,
-0.9094390869,
-0.2905828059,
0.5585332513,
0.5373371243,
0.7905604243,
0.273958981,
0.4937828183,
0.1008034125,
0.7068619728,
-0.9176367521,
0.1176846847,
-0.7380424738,
-0.0293305013,
-0.2800231576,
-0.2289993167,
-0.5041978359,
-0.5015233159,
0.1443354934,
-0.3737670779,
0.1213193089,
0.1140955091,
0.8538804054,
0.0104201948,
-0.4552851915,
-0.336761713,
-0.623649478,
1.0512369871,
-0.5529404283,
0.1556400359,
0.3473747075,
0.1959459484,
-0.2202501595,
-0.1812886894,
-0.4550851882,
-0.2470572144,
0.212263003,
-0.0287259985,
0.180401966,
0.071484521,
0.3391448855,
0.4538367987,
0.050467629,
0.3579204082,
-0.320446223,
0.1087928712,
0.7737546563,
-0.0138306003,
-0.0593764819,
-0.2161876708,
-0.2684716582,
-0.2942953408,
-1.2233179808,
0.377614826,
0.7370352745,
0.2955195904,
0.1247961819,
0.8893874884,
-0.0949752033,
0.761425674,
0.0763597041,
-0.0846831501,
0.1517509222,
-0.1333182454,
-0.3749134541,
0.1230497286,
0.4761962593,
0.4909951985,
0.7791714072,
0.2955277264,
-0.456959188,
-0.0435187817,
0.2818996012,
-0.6270622611,
0.2455280423,
0.1536173671,
-0.6547638774,
-0.5832746029,
-0.0599202625,
-0.7123803496,
-0.2555803657,
-0.4386574924,
0.2387696654,
-0.0813992918,
-0.228203848,
0.1745166183,
-0.1534344703,
0.3328383267,
0.2792077959,
-1.0430333614,
0.2241218537,
0.4476010799,
0.4379500747,
-0.3921993971,
0.0059495536,
-0.508934319,
-0.0091238972,
-0.5747763515,
0.9205425382,
-0.6938349605,
-0.8295919895,
0.1795865148,
-0.2561120391,
0.3646096885,
-0.8285834193,
0.6291365027,
-0.7750651836,
0.0238431189,
-0.6240942478,
-0.5588367581,
-0.0786740482,
0.2665629089,
-0.7263041139,
1.2059053183,
0.1460257173,
-0.5697077513,
0.8864392042,
-0.650188446,
-0.1794233322,
-0.234307304,
-0.5862446427,
-0.1935093552,
0.4698474407,
-0.0730638131,
0.3464725316,
-0.3782631159,
-0.0454978198,
-0.7015243769,
-0.4622754753,
0.7496853471,
-0.7349944115,
0.6861199737,
0.2153238505,
-0.2487658709,
0.0703024864,
-0.6461558938,
0.1063626409,
0.245712921,
-0.2666437924,
-0.9036055803,
0.021041248,
0.0826858059,
0.3977832496,
-0.0065922257,
-0.3396526277,
0.2518482208,
-0.334392041,
0.2475321889,
1.1121066809,
0.0114542972,
0.5579693913,
-0.4315713644,
0.4636414349,
-0.09307383,
0.0685317069,
0.1681702435,
-0.1359596848,
-0.5181135535,
-0.1258795857,
0.2295844108,
0.0233841762,
-0.2473391294,
0.0060826242,
-0.1705806106,
0.051358249,
-0.7025113702,
0.0225642882,
0.0581504144,
0.2309173346,
0.0447148606,
-0.1907524914,
-0.338883996,
-1.1633548737,
-0.456927985,
-0.3002923727,
-0.0966637805,
0.498088479,
0.3527011871,
-0.0299359076,
1.2474350929,
-0.5077664852,
0.1124716252,
-0.3181010485,
0.0027641742,
0.1689956784,
-0.0420973226,
0.5394320488,
-0.9207744002,
-0.087444149,
-0.5421270728,
-0.4933538437,
-0.3958429694,
-0.1053704396,
-0.3175130785,
0.2995423079,
0.37730515,
-0.3789759874,
0.2843899131,
0.410325408,
-0.1073135883,
0.663444221,
0.0711945891,
0.0831567645,
-1.0797669888,
-0.0149188749,
0.2557019591,
-0.0177175719,
-0.2589256763,
-0.0488131903,
0.0090393815,
0.4657205939,
-0.5999529362,
0.8315647244,
-0.526506424,
-0.4488886297,
-0.4669628441,
0.2021438032,
0.0166300964,
-0.1097628772,
0.2207890898,
0.771800518,
0.0357126221,
-0.7708063722,
0.078084752,
-0.0170807932,
-0.2984012663,
0.8627022505,
-0.4108716249,
-0.0357299633,
-0.2710140646,
0.2836804986,
-0.9149605036,
-0.2263592333,
-0.0365328453,
-0.3289435208,
0.1386045665,
-0.1878326684,
-0.3979324102,
-0.3255449533,
-0.5252463818,
0.4611416459,
0.4931210279,
-0.5081215501,
0.0784884468,
0.6943167448,
-0.0494220704,
-0.7145782709,
-0.4898132682,
-0.007396081,
-0.3420363069,
-0.2601543367,
0.0928015336,
-0.154578492,
-0.8560150862,
-0.123525776,
-0.1179352701,
0.1730061322,
-0.0343786292,
0.3535514474,
0.5249035954,
0.0181497708,
0.1626447588,
-0.0200622343,
0.014555933,
0.3164718151,
-0.3968170285,
0.5883389115,
0.2021467835,
-0.7617421746,
0.0163316894,
0.2158007026,
0.7541074157,
0.0143834818,
0.5439191461,
0.0352430306,
-0.2947734296,
-0.3205488026,
-0.6876993775,
-0.4460759461,
-0.4438144565,
0.3323984742,
-0.4506928623,
-0.8057491779,
0.232069701,
0.1506112814,
0.272120297,
0.1866233051,
0.7656912804,
-0.2233217806,
0.9125245214,
0.5030689836,
-0.2318540663,
0.6126606464,
-0.2818456292,
0.272909224,
-0.9932721257,
0.0479640104,
-0.4007672668,
-0.3987170756,
-0.5954247713,
-0.3765453994,
0.4248998761,
-0.0567072891,
0.0480368398,
-0.3705784082,
-0.2857135534,
0.6223549843,
0.6620143652,
-0.1008578464,
0.2363319397,
0.0074027451,
-0.032596793,
-0.106882751,
-0.481549114,
-0.8561936617,
1.4051400423,
0.2735549212,
1.1095795631,
-0.2410807908,
0.612875402,
0.1318717897,
0.5338281989,
-1.0497912169,
0.5019675493,
0.4223924875,
-0.7767044902,
-0.4260804951,
-0.1261735111,
-0.9863491654,
0.3485370874,
-0.1738164276,
-0.5708026886,
0.2034573406,
0.2378852218,
-0.3960688114,
0.3809348941,
-0.4541367292,
0.3267332017,
-0.3537305892,
-0.6475663185,
-0.1993293911,
-0.4975836575,
0.395716399,
-0.0656619519,
0.3562887609,
-0.3334003091,
0.210386917,
0.4650207758,
0.1582371891,
0.865385592,
-0.0223138947,
-0.3321045637,
0.282007724,
0.1705275476,
0.4827935994,
0.2457606345,
-0.4091120064,
-0.0959921256,
-0.1316173375,
-0.627748549,
-0.3592156768,
0.5145429373,
-0.781717658,
-0.6530809999,
-0.4970972836,
-0.6493852139,
-0.2904054821,
0.0153920967,
0.2919147909,
0.1705079973,
-0.4515774548,
0.0327137932,
1.0673363209,
-0.2947127521,
0.2860075533,
0.4132509232,
-0.3027547896,
0.1225223094,
0.2402448952,
0.4474629164,
0.888205409,
0.3575180173,
0.1392199546,
-0.6271599531,
-0.4930978715,
-0.5362048149,
0.1177844107,
-0.6691237092,
0.2117699832,
-0.5361534953,
-0.0530679226,
-0.41733706,
-0.4337690771,
-0.3915863633,
-0.2637176514,
-0.2690078318,
-0.5506592393,
0.2241169661,
0.7453538179,
0.023846738,
-0.2112680227,
-0.4182177782,
0.2792512476,
0.4128778875,
0.2224470079,
-0.0124591701,
-0.4778423607,
-0.1037587598,
0.3090238273,
-0.1319838911,
-0.8365337253,
0.3579075336,
-0.3079702556,
0.876632154,
0.5492095351,
0.1612071693,
0.3303382993,
-0.3039681613,
0.8663768768,
-0.2107313722,
-0.7018545866,
0.3852615654,
-0.3582346737,
0.1463604569,
0.6720792055,
0.2843810618,
-0.8094640374,
-0.2954019308,
-0.5616234541,
-0.9517410994,
0.536005497,
-0.1509401202,
0.3904048204,
-0.1113293543,
0.5744549632,
0.2318176031,
0.431746155,
-1.1356585026,
-0.2907473743,
-0.0084824031,
0.0215836149,
-0.0967966616,
-0.523608923,
-0.3128953874,
0.2081222236,
0.5782489181,
-0.218378827,
0.3045559227,
0.0444912575,
-0.1855480373,
-0.238538146,
0.5970714688,
0.663393259,
0.6661224961,
-0.2486360222,
0.3142915666,
0.237141788,
-0.1702400446,
0.342517823,
-0.3081479371,
-0.2621746361,
-0.158080548,
-0.0295547973,
0.6458339095,
0.149913013,
-0.7425052524,
0.4781726599,
0.2056009322,
0.0114789475,
-0.3263158798,
0.1143533885,
0.0036214215,
-0.0712606683,
0.4012744427,
-0.2288365215,
0.2680053413,
-0.8301361799,
-0.1471741945,
0.7643868327,
-0.4273660481,
-0.251860857,
0.5338810086,
0.0770976469,
-0.1993676573,
0.3557899296,
-0.2810083032,
-0.1893038452,
0.6209223866,
0.5949339271,
0.7276870608,
0.0628791302,
0.1364466548,
-0.0215132833,
0.2441089451,
-0.1367884427,
0.2741911709,
0.1688586473,
-0.9626453519,
-0.389857322,
-0.6298482418,
-0.5206192732,
0.3092602491,
-0.8334105015,
0.2485767007,
-0.0348455161,
-0.1311130673,
-0.2681210935,
-0.3592048883,
-0.547444284,
0.1863125712,
0.2742168307,
0.9420111775,
-0.9188758731,
0.8275856972,
0.6931241155,
-0.2939431965,
-0.7511421442,
0.193903923,
0.2161777169,
-1.1671530008,
0.9366925359,
0.083827056,
-0.2329037488,
-0.2606296241,
-0.580743134,
-0.9421563148,
0.7380742431,
0.3668439388,
-0.2608325779,
-0.1687527597,
0.4911818206,
0.3853215873,
-0.3924423456,
0.4738167524,
0.6795665026,
0.4416765273,
0.0178423431,
-0.7818153501,
-0.1371840537,
-0.0938867554,
0.2854509652,
0.3350601792,
-0.7731381059,
0.7290421128,
-0.2084215879,
0.1450523883,
-0.3962399065,
0.3642962277,
0.5873968601,
0.1876229495,
0.3877405226,
0.3052708209,
0.6818291545,
0.0593802296,
1.1393117905,
-0.347417891,
0.1197941005,
0.8580483198,
-0.6657717228,
0.8174618483,
0.9202903509,
-0.1906965375,
0.1753408313,
0.9957771301,
0.3096908927,
0.3865587413,
0.6647132635,
-0.500983119,
0.0514527783,
-0.2005677074,
-0.25601542,
0.2803554833,
0.5227313042,
-0.5676723719,
0.0167093389,
-0.0751531497,
0.1231123582,
-0.0869175568,
-0.4647260904,
0.6302945018,
0.3089715838,
-0.7933089733,
0.446533531,
-0.1561842561,
0.8087088466,
-0.4898818731,
0.076722376,
-0.046342086,
0.0710281059,
-0.0980895832,
-0.8738167882,
0.1091495231,
-0.2625112832,
-0.356548816,
-0.5352963209,
0.5748371482,
-0.2032527179,
-0.276252389,
0.2804708183,
0.7316359878,
0.03739243,
0.0272429548,
-0.374688834,
-0.0640034974,
0.0703051835,
-0.4944810867,
0.6001831889,
0.4063201845,
-0.3103395998,
0.5769867897,
0.6779772639,
0.3565460443,
0.1129130647,
0.0146274576,
0.5054439902,
-0.5721387863,
-0.4225842059,
-1.0739923716,
0.2333218753,
-0.2219452709,
-0.3071127534,
0.7349680662,
0.6779159904,
1.1740603447,
0.0251336861,
1.0982108116,
0.409589082,
0.420617789,
-0.6407334805,
0.5322032571,
-0.303571701,
0.4320693314,
-0.2905729115,
-0.9040644169,
0.0408566333,
0.6873583198,
-0.7507792115,
0.0902485996,
0.4351383448,
0.6021636724,
0.0512790941,
-0.0136590432,
0.3044137657,
-0.0283145625,
0.5323662758,
0.2934137881,
0.9611945152,
0.1525966972,
0.1737552583,
0.2348194867,
-0.3631099463,
-0.5030779839,
-0.945508182,
-0.7105256319,
-0.2139912993,
0.1137132719,
-0.440097183,
0.1443982869,
1.5209748745,
0.8062664866,
-0.5690450072,
-0.6407031417,
0.1398370117,
0.0753373206,
0.0490687229,
-0.2421879768,
0.021882521,
-0.342815578,
-0.9680979848,
0.00724382,
0.3806584775,
0.3434264958,
-0.4761970043,
0.1385133862,
0.1005259454,
0.5348561406,
0.7549514174,
0.1846710593,
-0.5505381823,
-0.3270844221,
0.1267412156,
-0.3280479908,
0.3321896791,
0.8863950372,
-0.7903185487,
0.2858067155,
0.2969233096,
0.5929531455,
0.5136054754,
-0.2861856222,
0.7634244561,
-0.5142950416,
0.089308843,
0.4060969055,
0.3729476333,
0.0846826732,
-0.396912396,
0.3221848905,
0.2256283611,
-0.5510203838,
-0.9157783985,
0.6342772245,
-0.6659346223,
-0.3194983304,
1.5836381912,
0.3785814345,
-0.043020241,
-0.0084744915,
-0.3830398917,
0.0094572147,
-0.4468857944,
1.1572858095,
1.0260545015,
-0.4841336608,
0.0311365034,
-0.9896882176,
0.4530111253,
0.4387568831,
-0.9498991966,
0.0191204101,
0.643494308,
0.3938474953,
-0.0807040259,
0.824667871,
-0.2616650164,
0.00595725,
-0.3802365065,
0.2222879231,
0.3379451632,
0.1291858703,
-0.3343654573,
0.2375825942,
0.6417854428,
0.0058104577
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10866v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10866v2
|
EcoRank: Budget-Constrained Text Re-ranking Using Large Language Models
| 2024-02-16T18:03:42 | 2024-05-28T02:34:57 |
Muhammad Shihab Rashid, Jannat Ara Meem, Yue Dong, Vagelis Hristidis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved state-of-the-art performance in
text re-ranking. This process includes queries and candidate passages in the
prompts, utilizing pointwise, listwise, and pairwise prompting strategies. A
limitation of these ranking strategies with LLMs is their cost: the process can
become expensive due to API charges, which are based on the number of input and
output tokens. We study how to maximize the re-ranking performance given a
budget, by navigating the vast search spaces of prompt choices, LLM APIs, and
budget splits. We propose a suite of budget-constrained methods to perform text
re-ranking using a set of LLM APIs. Our most efficient method, called EcoRank,
is a two-layered pipeline that jointly optimizes decisions regarding budget
allocation across prompt strategies and LLM APIs. Our experimental results on
four popular QA and passage reranking datasets show that EcoRank outperforms
other budget-aware supervised and unsupervised baselines.
|
[
-0.2475700974,
-0.6214015484,
0.8068355918,
0.3190589547,
-0.2450922877,
0.3278136253,
-0.1772946268,
-0.2146011591,
0.2862662971,
0.6461737752,
-0.6582865119,
-0.4942503572,
-0.3706567287,
0.4079116881,
-0.1895311326,
0.7162932754,
0.102024436,
-0.0768233463,
-0.4531222284,
-0.1168294474,
-0.264924109,
-0.6472632885,
-0.8303778768,
-0.2870349288,
1.0840300322,
0.5386824608,
0.4270966649,
0.825658679,
0.4784633815,
0.2851366401,
-0.3421654105,
0.2200804502,
-0.654052496,
0.4889200032,
-0.2467102408,
-0.4914545715,
-0.2466016114,
0.0190481022,
0.4750145376,
0.592282474,
-0.0452335253,
0.2667884827,
0.1467054933,
0.7009376287,
-0.6393117905,
0.1863664538,
-0.6973131895,
-0.3427571952,
-0.3361519575,
-0.3836045265,
-0.6832765341,
-0.5500072241,
0.2359039485,
-0.7192360759,
-0.1255434304,
0.4644840062,
0.6297492385,
0.4561018646,
-0.4098457098,
-0.3206700385,
-0.2080720812,
0.9808371663,
-0.2581358254,
0.5283930898,
0.306591779,
-0.0563096739,
0.0431676134,
-0.8217714429,
-0.0388444029,
-0.0072395378,
0.2370157242,
0.1543276459,
-0.3088755608,
0.0912201703,
-0.1175312698,
0.1695335656,
-0.4938281178,
0.3801001906,
-0.0715204403,
-0.1887237728,
0.5234231949,
0.0410741717,
0.3408218324,
-0.0747247934,
-0.3311915994,
-0.4129371047,
-0.7629318833,
0.0098995371,
0.5548291206,
0.4571383893,
0.5171980858,
0.6469752789,
-0.2896333635,
0.5381680727,
-0.0905670822,
-0.1764542162,
0.0775154606,
-0.344766736,
-0.0374803841,
0.0442041345,
0.2866969109,
0.5842552185,
0.1989765018,
-0.1994249374,
-0.4879809618,
-0.3023740053,
0.1034326404,
-0.6882798672,
-0.205422014,
0.2468976825,
-0.4383448064,
-0.2839104533,
-0.4178085625,
-0.9273108244,
-0.2452729791,
-0.3083044291,
0.6582134366,
-0.0279357508,
0.1111097708,
-0.2008603811,
-0.2393754274,
0.1011095941,
0.2746676505,
-0.7838441133,
0.1135248765,
0.8579953313,
1.0133720636,
0.0615649037,
-0.270480901,
-0.6025915146,
-0.0683632866,
-0.4212278128,
1.1341708899,
-0.6647972465,
-0.448564142,
0.3843560517,
-0.1780831516,
0.1445043385,
-0.7379414439,
0.7872827053,
-0.7590256929,
-0.0424055047,
-0.4964460433,
-0.7650190592,
0.1550078988,
-0.0456569642,
-0.7132365108,
0.9515150189,
0.0570976511,
-0.478038758,
0.3812890649,
-0.314185679,
-0.3782799542,
0.1688348651,
0.4686835408,
-0.2908494771,
-0.0213961415,
0.4039192498,
0.144377768,
-0.3145951331,
0.1959625632,
-0.1962907165,
-0.2905804515,
-0.1570267379,
-0.3083820939,
0.5834881663,
0.3375007808,
0.0671870261,
0.1825809926,
-0.3980566859,
0.0350488685,
-0.0802716538,
-0.7323236465,
-0.6607630253,
0.1982251853,
0.2653933465,
-0.2703832686,
0.4637621045,
-0.5259879827,
0.4222505391,
-0.5578020215,
0.6837078929,
0.888790071,
-0.0033113938,
0.640243113,
-0.238950327,
0.425303787,
-0.7363054156,
0.1512531638,
-0.2615023553,
-0.4845721722,
-0.650573194,
-0.388674438,
0.4699973166,
0.5847848058,
-0.4733759463,
0.2808968127,
-0.0475602075,
-0.477227509,
-0.6184107065,
0.083365418,
0.2275264561,
0.1586956233,
0.2920764089,
0.3769176304,
-0.4393239319,
-0.9355716705,
-0.6123686433,
-0.2688720822,
-0.1095193475,
0.4230182469,
0.194614172,
-0.0520831607,
0.79100281,
-0.7784949541,
-0.3363145292,
-0.231197834,
0.2364735156,
0.2072128356,
0.191964075,
0.2058348209,
-0.6818345189,
-0.2945608497,
-0.4642025828,
0.0653053522,
-0.7582553625,
-0.0283350628,
-0.1993485093,
0.2593642175,
0.7906083465,
-0.2920128703,
0.1999192238,
0.5077705979,
-0.1954050064,
0.267727226,
-0.2306219637,
-0.0321885794,
-0.8820985556,
-0.0341904089,
-0.0071568964,
-0.3684115112,
-0.0117826425,
0.3900469542,
-0.0138958208,
-0.2692101896,
0.0258683953,
0.736821413,
-0.3532152772,
-0.0080658086,
-0.2528483868,
0.3992160261,
0.0355856605,
0.4995881319,
-0.0297159515,
0.9076986313,
0.1172093004,
-0.4643799663,
0.2167086154,
0.2059808671,
-0.321511656,
0.4930588305,
-0.7263214588,
-0.0467113219,
0.0675847158,
0.5354234576,
-1.2152686119,
0.1856161952,
-0.2365615368,
-0.1526125968,
0.0464664139,
-0.3181354105,
-0.5998359323,
0.0278954841,
-0.4258557558,
0.4994543195,
0.4524746239,
-0.879999578,
0.2666586936,
0.5758330822,
-0.8146429062,
-0.3579673171,
-0.360545069,
0.2471991926,
-0.0654612482,
-0.2960068882,
0.6351436377,
-0.1130307689,
-0.2262196243,
-0.0240889657,
-0.111819908,
0.1380277425,
0.0545105375,
-0.0068579074,
0.2435263097,
0.0184007417,
0.2517829239,
0.1650677472,
-0.2235788256,
0.0595560782,
-0.5771896839,
0.6100362539,
0.14236103,
-0.2512562275,
-0.046668496,
0.4265418053,
0.7188724875,
-0.4335696697,
0.4977080822,
-0.0078603718,
-0.4513894022,
-0.2736265361,
-0.5786613822,
0.0963025242,
-0.4804787338,
0.4351139367,
-0.154399693,
-0.8620162606,
0.3382833302,
-0.4215582609,
0.5899520516,
0.4027165771,
0.523377955,
0.0222402513,
1.1804927588,
0.553765595,
-0.2605449855,
0.4956100285,
0.0420199931,
0.3705783188,
-0.7882185578,
-0.3226113617,
-0.8720270395,
-0.5397313237,
-0.7275379896,
-0.3959080279,
0.3441416323,
-0.0097026182,
-0.3398611844,
-0.0047959643,
-0.4258313477,
0.6906150579,
0.8527002335,
0.0475766212,
0.3563152552,
0.0259021688,
-0.3710674942,
0.0127963955,
-0.5819331408,
-0.3793537319,
1.1829755306,
0.2410709113,
0.6343187094,
0.4443134069,
0.8960955739,
0.326914072,
0.2794994116,
-0.8316264749,
0.5066813827,
-0.2236944735,
-0.3152264059,
-0.6909430027,
-0.5723569393,
-1.0657879114,
0.3764238954,
-0.0427336507,
-0.7240452766,
0.1983250231,
-0.1644176096,
-0.2539727688,
0.2537749112,
-0.4216314554,
0.4963296354,
-0.162699312,
-0.4241805673,
-0.450085938,
-0.142139703,
0.0128963916,
-0.1620857418,
0.1746140569,
0.1473176181,
-0.4388368428,
0.7389196157,
-0.521679163,
0.4040973783,
0.096221447,
-0.1397757381,
-0.1024266332,
0.0111430334,
0.6063274741,
0.2401783615,
-0.1023523435,
-0.1835568249,
-0.096046932,
-0.3927437961,
-0.2371151149,
1.1016885042,
-0.5666455626,
-0.6791414618,
-0.4286944568,
-0.4763007164,
-0.2563545406,
0.4109347165,
0.4583643079,
0.661714375,
-0.1438898742,
0.2852698863,
0.9058137536,
-0.5669592619,
0.5018971562,
0.3110596836,
-0.5055469871,
-0.6829636097,
1.0031001568,
0.2699383795,
0.0436984971,
0.760512948,
0.2545518875,
-0.8554700017,
-0.4860783219,
-0.2250690609,
0.0997843891,
-0.6112508774,
-0.3625481129,
-0.6466671228,
0.0513971075,
-0.4613071978,
-0.5026014447,
-0.3552541137,
-0.3721904159,
-0.2173401415,
-0.2353716195,
0.3293303549,
0.5909337997,
-0.083334893,
-0.0291278902,
-0.3662746549,
0.0145813487,
0.4831035435,
0.5299423933,
0.1590542942,
-0.3417614698,
-0.0839184895,
-0.4324112535,
-0.1455384791,
-0.7469667196,
0.5269888639,
0.0362223946,
0.6079865098,
0.2972002625,
0.3754451275,
0.6115651727,
-0.6706398726,
0.539334476,
-0.1430896521,
-0.8418637514,
0.3351019025,
-0.3446289003,
0.2781443,
0.6922476888,
0.0147632873,
-0.3548702598,
-0.5044804811,
-0.4212457538,
-1.4235150814,
0.5322806239,
0.0436911024,
0.0758194849,
-0.0292728413,
0.320838064,
-0.2274392545,
0.145583123,
-0.4165724814,
-0.2656716406,
0.1193570197,
-0.2027791739,
-0.1860248893,
-0.4841082096,
-0.0811086893,
-0.1280660778,
0.6322247982,
0.0362566486,
-0.0338767096,
0.4155159593,
-0.0909688026,
-0.0447328985,
0.3044047952,
0.4209632277,
0.4344128966,
-0.3664538264,
0.018374566,
0.0739852935,
-0.1798139513,
0.1781660765,
0.0626075491,
-0.3025066853,
0.141874969,
0.2294296473,
0.3352237642,
0.7119799852,
-0.824047029,
0.2655224502,
-0.0012865635,
-0.2717629969,
-0.0794448853,
-0.4609737694,
0.4035443366,
0.3797996938,
0.4158259034,
-0.3065573871,
0.3357452154,
-0.4414624572,
0.2033232301,
0.3881912827,
-0.0381773487,
0.2235388607,
0.6668151617,
0.7588767409,
-0.6456104517,
0.7411594391,
0.0173015576,
-0.691607058,
0.4228299558,
0.4716853797,
0.8700597286,
0.0125498418,
0.3664512336,
0.3023281693,
0.4894014895,
-0.3753820956,
0.1545242965,
0.1027458981,
-0.3299670815,
-0.2997304797,
-0.6915118098,
-0.8199067116,
0.0024059128,
-0.6708808541,
0.1728176326,
-0.5884429812,
-0.2514609993,
-0.1515089273,
0.3418655694,
-0.5031909943,
-0.0779064149,
0.117935881,
1.1825824976,
-0.4281547368,
0.2662013471,
0.7103365064,
-0.2748332322,
-0.7182335854,
0.1146263033,
0.0492172837,
-0.6371350288,
0.5677658916,
0.0696902275,
-0.2328070253,
0.5070428848,
-0.3285358548,
-1.1443650723,
0.9684012532,
0.332916081,
-0.8459030986,
0.0613789335,
-0.2785892189,
0.1891933233,
-0.1274879426,
0.289606601,
0.2447324097,
0.5782181621,
-0.116652824,
-0.7112351656,
-0.1836096346,
0.0614891276,
-0.1474221647,
0.513792634,
-0.9744831324,
0.7671278715,
-0.2207820565,
-0.2389068753,
0.3679000437,
0.4387435615,
0.4664709568,
0.6365067363,
0.6041614413,
0.7184555531,
1.0335224867,
-0.1360157132,
0.8938453197,
-0.2438904941,
0.4283389747,
0.6066709757,
-0.6048773527,
1.2462787628,
0.5137781501,
-0.1635969877,
0.4909557402,
1.0008795261,
0.0418016538,
0.8037719131,
0.4379700124,
-0.0313339196,
-0.4606948793,
-0.4364632666,
-0.0745585114,
0.0815616027,
-0.0325852297,
-0.2254458815,
-0.2204703242,
-0.1545781195,
0.1382769197,
0.0616687611,
-0.4237018526,
0.7803888917,
0.0664916784,
-0.7828155756,
0.1475584507,
0.1478439867,
0.608268559,
-0.4100703001,
0.0163336974,
-0.5320810676,
0.0169253126,
0.1636857092,
-0.6192960143,
-0.1786940545,
0.1848376244,
-0.3213014007,
-0.6912686825,
0.4768090844,
-0.3741583824,
-0.571005404,
0.2279550582,
0.430775404,
-0.0536522157,
-0.2672968507,
-0.5167886615,
0.0332439989,
-0.0315067172,
-0.430290699,
0.6223156452,
0.3418184519,
0.0083128707,
0.9709043503,
0.8774597645,
0.0647977889,
-0.2349335104,
0.2064892799,
0.7225859761,
-0.5164090395,
-0.753598392,
-0.8122760653,
-0.0516087189,
-0.1127241403,
-0.4404231012,
0.4432358444,
0.7083124518,
0.7715269327,
0.3129136264,
0.653505981,
0.6640814543,
0.5162792206,
-0.705553174,
0.6838642955,
-0.8193463683,
0.5361489058,
-0.3173538744,
-1.0730421543,
-0.1405539364,
0.3824975193,
-0.1372654736,
-0.3090132475,
0.5545958281,
0.6745988131,
0.5035473704,
-0.1646206975,
0.1347078383,
-0.1473979056,
0.2369797975,
0.5011255741,
0.7947028279,
0.1084170714,
0.8326465487,
0.1041450351,
-0.3086250722,
-0.4668267369,
-0.7067559361,
-0.5038355589,
-0.489890039,
-0.3131093383,
-0.0198032539,
0.1877120435,
0.8766396046,
0.5559665561,
-0.360807389,
-0.1915043443,
0.1066197008,
0.5631087422,
-0.2851986289,
-0.2166844159,
0.453884244,
-0.4000706673,
-1.134952426,
0.377582103,
0.5010891557,
-0.5405734777,
-0.2772800922,
0.1448349655,
-0.2720001042,
0.5246961117,
0.5543071628,
0.1374030113,
-0.9514586926,
-0.0727090314,
0.4324197173,
-0.1628410965,
-0.4553814828,
0.9730240703,
-0.7717658281,
0.089087598,
0.7648334503,
0.8366754055,
-0.1472630352,
0.198395133,
0.6930351853,
-0.5538643003,
-0.448918581,
0.174910754,
0.3807371855,
0.1024046913,
-0.4118958116,
0.4718930721,
0.0586803965,
-1.007627964,
-1.057089448,
0.0566605441,
-0.8392598033,
-0.5902470946,
1.2587282658,
0.024000911,
0.0861520916,
-0.1279566586,
-0.3068577349,
-0.0491794907,
-0.617516458,
0.5801905394,
0.7503294945,
-0.0258215945,
-0.2607686222,
-0.289986223,
0.3287923336,
0.5481553674,
-0.4952994883,
0.2920001745,
0.4886486828,
0.2206429392,
0.0326441601,
0.3700142801,
0.0961555764,
-0.2341350168,
-0.0995121151,
-0.2211142927,
0.0757716969,
-0.2785861492,
-0.1525454372,
0.2620492876,
0.2118171453,
-0.1960642636
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10835v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10835v2
|
Time Series Forecasting with LLMs: Understanding and Enhancing Model Capabilities
| 2024-02-16T17:15:28 | 2024-02-19T02:30:15 |
Mingyu Jin, Hua Tang, Chong Zhang, Qinkai Yu, Chengzhi Liu, Suiyuan Zhu, Yongfeng Zhang, Mengnan Du
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have been applied in many fields with rapid
development in recent years. As a classic machine learning task, time series
forecasting has recently received a boost from LLMs. However, there is a
research gap in the LLMs' preferences in this field. In this paper, by
comparing LLMs with traditional models, many properties of LLMs in time series
prediction are found. For example, our study shows that LLMs excel in
predicting time series with clear patterns and trends but face challenges with
datasets lacking periodicity. We explain our findings through designing prompts
to require LLMs to tell the period of the datasets. In addition, the input
strategy is investigated, and it is found that incorporating external knowledge
and adopting natural language paraphrases positively affects the predictive
performance of LLMs for time series. Overall, this study contributes to insight
into the advantages and limitations of LLMs in time series forecasting under
different conditions.
|
[
-0.2082084119,
-0.5094099045,
0.8162491918,
0.3019195795,
-0.487626642,
0.278527379,
-0.1235303581,
-0.5498654246,
-0.0320461802,
0.6187310219,
-0.7309461832,
-0.3472146392,
-0.4506049454,
0.4734692276,
-0.275515765,
0.5987911224,
-0.2421786785,
0.3178275228,
-0.3354597092,
0.1860125065,
-0.6109133363,
-0.5801507235,
-0.380128026,
-0.5734804869,
0.3050335348,
0.112951465,
0.6043255925,
0.7211908102,
0.3801046312,
0.3256336451,
-0.0440533161,
0.4418980777,
-0.0255253911,
0.5316702127,
0.3395680785,
-0.521642983,
-0.266740799,
-0.1724520177,
0.6457420588,
0.84019804,
-0.1139399782,
0.1369033009,
0.15777722,
0.622036159,
0.0377827398,
0.6424706578,
-0.5647141933,
0.1263740212,
-0.1731749624,
-0.4203640223,
-0.1743383706,
-0.2043970823,
0.2012209445,
-0.431827426,
0.0827626437,
0.3328844309,
0.5709446073,
0.4383827746,
-0.3076452315,
-0.0991428941,
-0.9772378802,
1.0596405268,
-1.0014288425,
0.2820852995,
0.1709289849,
0.6025747061,
-0.0377547629,
-0.5080680251,
-0.1501487643,
-0.377602309,
0.0590818264,
-0.124138549,
0.1483764797,
-0.3468871713,
0.3269228041,
0.3117794991,
-0.3954642713,
0.2987415195,
-0.1379244775,
0.1726683676,
0.4739659429,
0.680316627,
-0.1839985102,
-0.3245095015,
-0.431602627,
0.2973234951,
-0.5858390927,
0.034285441,
0.1977100074,
0.6182777882,
-0.2219251841,
0.5594895482,
-0.0020045026,
0.5565006733,
-0.2989044487,
-0.1802600622,
-0.0098172994,
-0.065512903,
-0.3529229164,
-0.2810406089,
0.4785627127,
0.3532008529,
0.4213500321,
-0.3624020219,
-0.0683947206,
-0.2389159352,
-0.2084251642,
-0.6792924404,
0.2122084647,
0.0954633951,
-0.5228348374,
-0.2806426585,
0.0806902498,
-0.8954566121,
-0.6072627902,
-0.8771172166,
-0.0029327238,
-0.2551482916,
0.1276308745,
-0.0194355343,
-0.1828805953,
0.1111643463,
0.6647843719,
-0.756357193,
0.3070657253,
0.7163785696,
0.9114564061,
-0.3576029241,
0.0499835275,
-0.4058153033,
0.0517632812,
-0.2801523805,
0.6212717891,
-0.5552058816,
-0.6766455173,
-0.0735817775,
-0.0476172566,
0.0869146287,
-0.5401489139,
0.0112930182,
-0.6125510931,
0.0314962119,
-0.3067203462,
-0.6157813668,
-0.1744298339,
0.0538435616,
-0.516299963,
0.7945644259,
-0.1281049401,
-0.4423588812,
0.1675095409,
-0.4724679887,
-0.2597665191,
-0.0025218753,
-0.1219761297,
-0.2249509692,
-0.0941197276,
0.5088483095,
0.7479586601,
-0.544048667,
0.4365885556,
-0.5713735223,
-0.0095904311,
0.6903541684,
-0.7426253557,
0.2958115339,
0.6424907446,
-0.1453970224,
0.0673078671,
-0.5851304531,
-0.2440219671,
0.0836486518,
-0.0265595615,
-0.0706447512,
0.2587277889,
-0.0172437467,
0.0196844712,
0.2290366888,
-0.0755838007,
0.2945566475,
-0.3745797276,
0.7937691212,
0.9637597203,
0.1084955409,
0.4067078233,
-0.7596594691,
0.9074628949,
-0.0439856127,
0.108998999,
-0.5137521029,
-0.2694860399,
-0.4526806474,
-0.1753774285,
0.189717114,
0.6889805198,
-0.6814469099,
0.2727945745,
-0.2640906572,
-0.494466722,
0.1929395199,
0.4666344523,
-0.1868795604,
0.3205623925,
0.1708263308,
0.0629870817,
-0.7029084563,
-0.3466513455,
-0.0277881473,
0.116368778,
-0.1655555069,
0.3519043326,
0.2054211795,
0.0127602462,
0.7963964343,
-0.5906229019,
0.0908674896,
-0.5235440135,
-0.0267419405,
0.5118784308,
-0.1000134423,
0.377260536,
-0.6210543513,
-0.3981971443,
-0.2943491936,
-0.8789445758,
-0.1520199925,
-0.0815322399,
0.3736539781,
0.3755453527,
0.704660356,
-0.4295080006,
0.1924618781,
0.5172637105,
-0.1478579044,
0.5169585943,
0.0368901938,
-0.137283057,
-1.2473070621,
-0.0976510048,
0.3391798139,
-0.3426013887,
-0.3846278191,
-0.4868092537,
-0.265075624,
-0.3427067697,
-0.4012542963,
0.7980859876,
-0.5019999146,
-0.1377192885,
-0.2143687606,
-0.0402600057,
0.0092341062,
0.0484325327,
0.0622496866,
0.8831167221,
0.3460337222,
-0.7794124484,
0.6025063992,
0.0542563498,
-0.5996538997,
-0.0996039212,
-0.6315816641,
-0.1307176203,
-0.1007522047,
0.05437259,
-0.7776658535,
-0.0526097268,
-0.0095422734,
-0.132328555,
0.6114590168,
0.04031232,
-0.4454253018,
-0.4093342423,
-0.3037584424,
-0.0082923807,
0.6061822176,
-0.5245555043,
0.3960452974,
-0.0258499067,
-0.4034202993,
-0.4382697344,
-0.5768628716,
0.1630740017,
-0.6656852961,
-0.4446910024,
0.2635900974,
-0.3091978133,
-0.6146340966,
-0.2822899818,
-0.1936303377,
0.2662016451,
0.4171521664,
0.315880388,
0.6099033356,
-0.305533886,
0.2660677731,
-0.463754952,
-0.2109006196,
-0.0901578665,
-0.2652158737,
0.6926241517,
-0.0672463477,
-0.3546802402,
-0.3764923215,
0.0891201049,
0.5656942129,
0.0076128771,
0.5999667048,
0.1695723981,
-0.240062952,
-0.1579025537,
-0.5332092643,
-0.2154201865,
-0.5222952366,
0.1309974492,
0.031030871,
-0.7884640098,
0.332991749,
-0.0974392295,
-0.0411859266,
0.2613371313,
0.3810479641,
-0.1820768416,
0.876059413,
0.4682197869,
-0.3678339422,
0.7287225127,
-0.2071189731,
0.0470904931,
-0.7747219205,
-0.3358142674,
-0.5022690892,
-0.1246162727,
-0.4707628489,
-0.2031570375,
0.3648352623,
0.0275793392,
-0.3579826057,
0.0136175584,
-0.1301792264,
0.1819990575,
0.3932257295,
0.0993266553,
0.4013292789,
0.3535951972,
0.3011577725,
-0.381239444,
-0.476326704,
-0.8223486543,
1.0859218836,
0.6081270576,
1.2494097948,
-0.0872767642,
0.2784786522,
0.465246439,
0.1255554557,
-0.7430469394,
0.4819922745,
-0.2899518013,
-0.1131788716,
-0.4215035737,
-0.3616354764,
-0.9556694627,
-0.1449706405,
-0.1091872305,
-0.5262340307,
0.0307855196,
-0.1162444726,
-0.3532291055,
0.4497233629,
-0.2177308649,
0.5109419227,
-0.5715566278,
-0.1719099581,
-0.0005305661,
-0.3913852572,
-0.0652051643,
0.1148068905,
0.3512115479,
-0.4953519702,
-0.3283645809,
0.5767250657,
-0.458724618,
1.015037179,
0.0810799748,
0.0102910008,
0.1077674776,
-0.0597521961,
0.3645427823,
0.2181360126,
-0.3927378356,
0.0887165144,
0.0535528585,
-0.2302398086,
-0.5200343132,
0.690526545,
-0.7031164169,
-0.8998993039,
-0.6285119057,
-0.7599464059,
-0.4959792495,
-0.0553946644,
0.0382683985,
0.7018413544,
-0.1744995415,
0.1099266559,
0.5295672417,
0.0472474769,
0.9018657207,
0.4023668766,
-0.644893527,
-0.3170213103,
0.6412675381,
0.2762348056,
0.2583620548,
0.6220546365,
0.3542369902,
-0.3936089277,
-0.7464776039,
-0.2552990317,
0.3652156889,
-0.6730061173,
-0.2233724743,
-0.2560899556,
-0.203599304,
-0.6156306267,
-0.0038360334,
0.2042307705,
-0.4589708745,
-0.68424052,
-0.0695066378,
0.7093468308,
0.9024878144,
0.3626171052,
0.1810037494,
-0.9549174309,
0.2292659432,
0.2723145783,
0.199137181,
0.0175550953,
-0.5589965582,
-0.1167300865,
-0.1579215676,
-0.6168494821,
-0.8529657125,
0.9021838307,
-0.1213881522,
0.5199319124,
0.493832916,
-0.1079178229,
0.6084305644,
-0.43795982,
1.0166602135,
-0.0329411216,
-0.8020083308,
0.3565390408,
-0.5165555477,
0.3076065481,
-0.137604177,
0.4424408972,
-0.6205009222,
-0.1205878258,
-0.4303249121,
-0.6553348899,
0.5414645672,
-0.1546307057,
0.1881506741,
0.1103212908,
0.3755618334,
0.3151367307,
0.6530398726,
-0.5338551402,
-0.4141857326,
-0.2150602341,
-0.1762985736,
-0.6254500151,
-0.2915975153,
0.1176725551,
-0.1704898924,
0.533839941,
0.0909869447,
0.2206680924,
0.0645412058,
0.2620510459,
-0.1378025413,
0.3647414744,
0.463209033,
0.8458502293,
-0.1804634184,
-0.1497135907,
0.4729574621,
0.0674984455,
-0.024894949,
0.1756713688,
-0.0145210018,
0.2999106944,
0.3937740922,
0.920358479,
0.0897417292,
-0.6019330025,
-0.1199727207,
0.2828277946,
0.0417919159,
-0.6264804006,
-0.0642799363,
0.261171937,
0.5327267647,
0.6081030965,
-0.0607563034,
-0.1682869047,
-0.5952273607,
-0.3485001922,
0.5364803672,
-0.0768113732,
-0.096092917,
0.5984658003,
0.0828792676,
-0.2094043195,
0.2921140492,
0.2330659777,
-0.3931081295,
0.9585249424,
0.5234894156,
0.6586998105,
-0.2990109324,
-0.0541897304,
-0.1394307315,
0.1032901928,
-0.2989855111,
0.2094087601,
0.1632664204,
-0.4520362318,
-0.4560899734,
-0.7427883148,
-0.6972821355,
0.4830703437,
-0.4426484406,
0.6258586645,
-0.5874756575,
-0.1995594352,
-0.1076433063,
0.1719306409,
-0.5687530041,
-0.0298173167,
0.2394170463,
1.0753901005,
-0.6067412496,
0.7423456311,
0.4238556921,
-0.1171728373,
-0.6129121184,
-0.1902999729,
-0.0550449081,
-0.7202846408,
0.6703113914,
0.2790234089,
0.2326594889,
-0.1380242407,
-0.3282811344,
-0.8949245214,
1.2766637802,
0.2993272245,
-0.6204882264,
-0.2915881872,
0.2041838169,
0.3997471631,
-0.6425286531,
-0.1661924571,
0.2882897854,
0.5483061671,
0.1169167683,
-0.7204267383,
-0.1077912673,
0.0471555144,
0.2043022364,
0.4410605729,
-0.3389855921,
0.8295387626,
-0.1267032772,
-0.07189136,
0.5991640687,
0.8458960056,
-0.0888846517,
0.8708643913,
0.1946725398,
0.045740813,
0.6056745052,
-0.1102477536,
1.1548326015,
-0.114940457,
0.1512779891,
0.9244368076,
-0.4836117029,
0.7436364293,
0.4165971875,
-0.5809875131,
0.5161373615,
0.851852417,
-0.5146077871,
0.3576978743,
0.0442057252,
-0.2312202454,
-0.556399107,
-0.0755548999,
-0.5136541724,
-0.0574756823,
0.5643104911,
-0.3023773134,
-0.2064360529,
0.1213082299,
0.0827883333,
0.2994129658,
-0.4796126187,
0.574105382,
0.5432843566,
-0.4248900115,
0.2321432829,
-0.0349633098,
0.6701871157,
-0.7284297943,
0.1232289225,
-0.0659976378,
-0.0876290128,
-0.1454617679,
-0.551668644,
0.4555009305,
-0.0832970962,
-0.2691209912,
-0.274238497,
0.551117897,
-0.1708384752,
-0.6876215935,
0.0676946342,
0.6822093129,
-0.0617243871,
0.055419758,
-0.5407719612,
-0.1359599084,
-0.2087217271,
-0.1202816144,
0.1876974255,
0.2917765677,
-0.1139727235,
1.0445877314,
0.6279562712,
0.2678189278,
-0.095155403,
0.0306868311,
0.4426196218,
-0.818091929,
-0.2120255679,
-1.1203066111,
0.0024962786,
0.1344901323,
0.265481323,
0.9329019189,
0.3463576138,
0.2196951658,
-0.2503308952,
0.981151998,
0.5807945132,
0.8072980046,
-0.9295708537,
0.1101090312,
-0.3614254296,
0.854603529,
0.0979663059,
-0.8072115183,
-0.1790401936,
-0.048537489,
-0.6573348641,
0.2226944715,
0.5918036103,
0.4201729596,
0.1445508152,
0.3134585917,
0.3210011125,
0.1221809685,
0.1979710758,
0.1705967039,
0.9932283759,
0.1666639447,
0.5568457842,
-0.2491941452,
0.0364853889,
-0.2750332952,
-1.2176728249,
-1.1616185904,
-0.3585038483,
-0.091206409,
-0.149763748,
0.0096346326,
1.2074446678,
0.3190011084,
-0.7565019727,
-0.5604997873,
0.0072653773,
0.2332290709,
-0.1478074491,
-0.2688781917,
0.1481909901,
-0.481406033,
-0.7890202403,
0.5647614002,
0.0519233756,
0.5196784735,
-0.3627701402,
0.0709331408,
0.4432984889,
0.0541927367,
0.5053239465,
0.2195962965,
-0.6670154929,
0.0599709116,
0.319144845,
0.2232649773,
0.0420122519,
0.8749980927,
-0.7014559507,
-0.0712963715,
0.4425940812,
0.4250527322,
0.5302764773,
-0.0642690957,
0.7153009176,
-0.4456208348,
-0.0240174495,
0.133331418,
0.7334618568,
0.5594367385,
-0.3313578367,
0.2904706895,
0.2956254482,
-0.641977191,
-0.6519891024,
0.2085599452,
-0.9204621315,
-0.4830040932,
1.2573128939,
0.1877330393,
0.014626313,
-0.3053206205,
-0.1335318387,
0.2724961936,
-0.4188260734,
0.6694950461,
0.7140478492,
-0.2052602917,
0.0121442629,
-0.9469831586,
0.2949256599,
0.2010720372,
-0.6173272133,
0.1286900789,
0.118935436,
0.3763068318,
-0.1948412657,
-0.0345704444,
0.0309944116,
-0.1103579774,
-0.6196142435,
-0.43842417,
-0.6462296844,
-0.259642154,
-0.5379753113,
-0.0380898863,
0.5037913322,
0.0536839105
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11000v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.11000v2
|
ASGEA: Exploiting Logic Rules from Align-Subgraphs for Entity Alignment
| 2024-02-16T17:03:05 | 2024-03-05T13:57:28 |
Yangyifei Luo, Zhuo Chen, Lingbing Guo, Qian Li, Wenxuan Zeng, Zhixin Cai, Jianxin Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Entity alignment (EA) aims to identify entities across different knowledge
graphs that represent the same real-world objects. Recent embedding-based EA
methods have achieved state-of-the-art performance in EA yet faced
interpretability challenges as they purely rely on the embedding distance and
neglect the logic rules behind a pair of aligned entities. In this paper, we
propose the Align-Subgraph Entity Alignment (ASGEA) framework to exploit logic
rules from Align-Subgraphs. ASGEA uses anchor links as bridges to construct
Align-Subgraphs and spreads along the paths across KGs, which distinguishes it
from the embedding-based methods. Furthermore, we design an interpretable
Path-based Graph Neural Network, ASGNN, to effectively identify and integrate
the logic rules across KGs. We also introduce a node-level multi-modal
attention mechanism coupled with multi-modal enriched anchors to augment the
Align-Subgraph. Our experimental results demonstrate the superior performance
of ASGEA over the existing embedding-based methods in both EA and Multi-Modal
EA (MMEA) tasks.
|
[
-0.1612675786,
-0.7351765037,
0.6259365082,
0.0263405889,
-0.2830046415,
-0.0781501532,
0.0842712373,
-0.569647193,
0.576766789,
0.1800191104,
-0.8861083984,
-0.6017907262,
-0.5703288317,
-0.1110976189,
-0.1309221089,
0.6900036335,
-0.1340771317,
-0.0331429057,
-0.3868281543,
-0.3910152912,
-0.6508385539,
0.1441427022,
-0.6123649478,
-0.3629600704,
0.3032755256,
0.0668464676,
0.7196823955,
0.734164536,
0.206546545,
0.2473424524,
0.2711015046,
0.4041522741,
-0.1262343824,
-0.3371669948,
-0.6323990822,
-0.2201723456,
-0.786883533,
-0.1556675881,
0.4135442376,
0.4775101542,
-0.1039978862,
0.2559902072,
-0.2312540859,
0.4294289351,
-0.599111557,
0.8224320412,
-0.5857521892,
-0.0714980215,
-0.2479317337,
0.0621403009,
-0.35582304,
-0.0586140044,
0.0692230612,
-1.2576857805,
-0.3945498466,
0.3441891074,
1.191971302,
0.4889270961,
-0.5142583847,
-0.3377323747,
-0.0417491272,
0.4291536808,
-0.5492649078,
0.7693188787,
-0.2127132714,
0.2169798017,
-0.0741440654,
-0.5726656914,
-0.6113064289,
0.4218658805,
-0.5153346062,
0.1739468575,
-0.4149806201,
0.1767870337,
0.3814477324,
-0.1056095511,
-0.3001053035,
-0.1098181829,
-0.1234936789,
-0.2182188183,
0.4563376009,
-0.127022326,
0.6957544684,
-0.2143448144,
-0.6614024043,
0.3383241296,
-0.7933683395,
-0.0281804707,
0.3112143576,
0.4369926751,
0.2591172457,
0.5768585801,
-0.2290875167,
0.4707635343,
0.1839366406,
-0.0549164191,
0.3473857939,
-0.3822253048,
-0.4508370459,
0.3058426082,
0.7155727148,
0.4141911268,
0.2513706088,
-0.4105189443,
-0.1630024612,
0.2183857411,
0.2376739681,
-0.5183188319,
-0.2032877505,
-0.1813225597,
-0.5271149278,
0.0658238754,
-0.0527017303,
-0.6221390963,
-0.1762375534,
-0.4250800312,
0.6588432789,
-0.660838306,
-0.1543015093,
0.1258253753,
-0.043550577,
0.3926796913,
0.383043915,
-0.675124228,
0.5532054901,
0.7445697784,
0.5470852256,
0.1954624206,
-0.3917856812,
-0.5066245198,
0.5804213285,
-0.0077531431,
0.6494307518,
-0.7315184474,
0.2580116093,
-0.1402245015,
0.1504391432,
-0.4474473596,
-0.2574846745,
0.5264773965,
-1.0433604717,
-0.2809477746,
-0.2584933341,
-0.6800823808,
-0.6676324606,
0.2063004375,
-0.759051621,
0.5396553278,
0.0401371531,
-0.4889174998,
0.4907003045,
-0.7160792351,
-0.7820806503,
-0.1532826871,
-0.5261131525,
-0.3430064619,
-0.1951526254,
0.5697051883,
-0.0052464809,
-0.3285070956,
0.1831747442,
-0.0883309543,
-0.1310645938,
-0.1243262589,
-0.151196301,
0.8543878198,
-0.0553508252,
-0.5790144205,
0.1210986301,
-0.5270053148,
0.1172289699,
-0.0312815532,
-0.0748116672,
-0.3972626925,
0.0993665904,
-0.3809104264,
0.360678643,
0.2726193964,
-0.4674895108,
0.1443089545,
-0.3116034865,
0.2564930618,
0.7236926556,
0.0121900486,
0.5757863522,
0.0084584616,
0.4927012026,
0.3391163349,
-0.0571613349,
0.1457073689,
-0.4820172787,
-0.411246717,
-0.2960322201,
0.5587219,
0.6690856814,
-0.8371331692,
0.6150166988,
-0.6408939362,
-0.2986623645,
-0.8119111657,
0.2850872576,
0.3963118196,
0.908561945,
0.6523293853,
-0.3376902342,
-0.3512578309,
-1.0059207678,
-0.4807458222,
-0.0630957186,
0.1897616386,
0.5157850385,
0.3415746987,
-0.360753715,
0.7821787596,
-0.4887343049,
-0.7140401602,
0.0562360585,
-0.2175089717,
-0.0443170033,
0.553609848,
0.4489587843,
-0.557092607,
-0.3275042176,
-0.0354408138,
-0.8217496276,
-0.2215596884,
-0.1358713508,
-0.5128816962,
0.0220820401,
0.6112043858,
-0.9820483327,
0.3536252975,
0.0941672921,
-0.5227380395,
-0.0252840258,
0.3127122819,
0.0682787225,
-0.8033376336,
-0.0865685865,
0.1553693712,
-0.354919374,
-0.1483175009,
0.0314451084,
0.1136002615,
-0.0010762986,
-0.1789018959,
0.2076594234,
-0.6780536175,
-0.4296658635,
0.1288680881,
0.6124398112,
0.4016056359,
0.5145546198,
-0.0321273133,
0.2380510569,
0.615042448,
-0.262915343,
0.4278152883,
0.5165078044,
-0.1026219204,
0.8569059372,
-0.4099357128,
-0.0066977288,
-0.2644465566,
0.4196667969,
-0.5453528166,
0.2172806859,
0.5346775651,
-0.1939284801,
0.5676670671,
-0.4152455926,
-0.2657614052,
0.0772555396,
-0.0285129938,
0.461789459,
0.2531176805,
-0.5152343512,
1.522233367,
0.3427680731,
0.3241802752,
-0.9215393066,
-0.340177834,
-0.2875043452,
-0.0133615024,
-0.9466808438,
0.3937181234,
0.4477515817,
-0.1108367965,
0.8173960447,
-0.4334769249,
0.49795717,
0.1338424683,
0.4082562923,
0.2922690213,
-0.5961434841,
0.0718186721,
0.3794491291,
-0.3840596378,
0.2532889843,
-0.7495898008,
0.1542461216,
-0.0396700315,
-0.6849803329,
-0.577288568,
0.3328485191,
0.4595369101,
-0.5050039291,
0.8190907836,
0.3418762684,
-0.8738037348,
-0.1674490422,
-0.2167797387,
-0.1131247059,
-0.426874876,
0.2115934491,
-0.6930963397,
-0.313754946,
0.3995194137,
-0.4710550308,
-0.0011383551,
0.7523688674,
-0.0646729246,
-0.0173480622,
0.9534502029,
0.3670680523,
-0.1139635369,
0.2910699844,
-0.0164735578,
0.5797995329,
-0.9082295299,
-0.5687374473,
-0.1207059771,
-0.6874788404,
-0.2729355693,
-0.412283957,
0.1440374106,
0.322764039,
-0.3406912982,
0.4729956388,
-0.2609246671,
0.5534344316,
0.4122391045,
0.1683892161,
0.3168794513,
-0.1279968321,
-0.1173870564,
-0.0031256715,
-0.6209921837,
-0.3420285285,
0.5367012024,
0.3476222157,
0.9635365009,
0.4014359713,
0.4614531398,
0.0042116777,
0.4085468948,
-0.9546196461,
0.4858332872,
-0.1199627146,
-0.4611780643,
-0.4908504188,
-0.3485797644,
-0.5653840303,
0.131610468,
-0.2588776946,
-0.8158811331,
0.1772140265,
0.150500834,
-0.4308511913,
0.3367666602,
-0.9172898531,
1.3178044558,
-0.1490055472,
0.0151668051,
0.1070313826,
-0.7761470079,
-0.0369822755,
0.3066325486,
0.0898416489,
-0.1911531836,
-0.1145894229,
0.4845050275,
-0.3393961787,
0.6597339511,
-0.3044345975,
0.011820347,
0.3912365735,
-0.0119814016,
0.7341439128,
0.2028903216,
0.1612165868,
0.1230712831,
-0.1235736758,
-0.3532608449,
-1.0158956051,
0.7502750158,
-0.690534234,
-0.6640091538,
-0.1483833194,
-0.533012867,
-0.3391530514,
0.5297189355,
-0.0417717211,
0.633996129,
0.2163962871,
-0.0499268547,
0.610467732,
0.208109498,
0.098152332,
0.3615064919,
0.0124400677,
-0.2104436308,
1.0279996395,
0.3841771483,
0.1603023559,
0.6124380827,
-0.1300365478,
-0.6304274797,
-0.2547867298,
-1.0601536036,
0.2457472086,
-0.8961771727,
-0.4706321359,
-0.8412547112,
-0.1240928024,
-0.7102472782,
-0.3359442949,
-0.2735809982,
-0.2667385042,
-0.30124259,
-0.3316528797,
0.3366953433,
0.4788746834,
0.0829053223,
-0.1675879508,
-0.6984779239,
0.1129995063,
0.2812139094,
0.3760959208,
0.1457539201,
-0.0945864618,
0.1720516831,
-0.1914075464,
0.0418661758,
-1.1238132715,
-0.1315360367,
0.0582118332,
0.7091733813,
0.4662505984,
0.0107930591,
0.8236314058,
-0.6322276592,
0.142847687,
0.036586646,
-1.2495520115,
0.4892461896,
-0.1101042107,
-0.2053141892,
0.5622866154,
0.4687957764,
-0.2538996041,
0.133196041,
-0.7677901387,
-0.9069728851,
0.7569333315,
0.0355570726,
-0.2398023158,
0.1592679918,
0.3370531797,
-0.3494600058,
0.2869777381,
-0.6331698298,
-0.4467118084,
-0.23233895,
-0.8735123873,
0.3844076395,
0.234360829,
-0.369651258,
0.127669692,
0.8898631334,
-0.6118854284,
0.0809648037,
0.0598028973,
-0.4215461612,
-0.0956161171,
0.0780794695,
0.1026976705,
0.7257433534,
0.2213888466,
0.3560980558,
0.4086958468,
-0.1902811825,
0.0647201985,
0.4681352675,
-0.3866019547,
-0.3294573128,
0.2989733815,
0.6877891421,
0.293543756,
-0.4707847834,
0.6701511145,
0.149560228,
0.3312354684,
-0.0861477479,
-0.0698170364,
0.4970672727,
0.508857131,
-0.0740866438,
0.1819523126,
0.2082341611,
-0.6344952583,
0.3682545125,
0.5031222701,
-0.814520359,
-0.2440150976,
0.6660925746,
0.1845082641,
-0.2016383111,
0.7142862678,
-0.4330643117,
-0.6434007287,
0.6750702262,
0.7696188688,
0.5665476918,
0.1254723668,
0.0422744341,
0.1043034792,
0.6269525886,
0.4341921508,
0.2805222869,
0.2226663232,
-0.9059532881,
-0.3962192237,
-0.5403457284,
0.1031747535,
-0.3150301874,
-0.6261525154,
0.2548372447,
-0.2926951349,
0.2913011014,
0.2063039839,
-0.1394046396,
-0.6828484535,
0.4196788371,
-0.0946727693,
1.0025252104,
-1.1085106134,
0.474896431,
1.1238195896,
-0.7022016644,
-1.2513884306,
-0.0567946918,
0.2710160315,
-0.8942499161,
0.4244372249,
0.1520518214,
-0.3071035445,
0.1239324436,
-0.1802440882,
-0.9094563127,
1.6305023432,
0.5189161301,
-0.3129374385,
-0.2583921552,
-0.277533412,
0.3475746214,
-0.6220455766,
0.046562206,
0.7201141715,
0.4641345143,
0.0042897682,
-0.5291933417,
0.7450932264,
-0.2484071553,
-0.2919695973,
0.5422412753,
-0.9915323853,
0.3693798184,
-0.0772296488,
-0.3946181834,
-0.5157719254,
0.8637563586,
0.2090332955,
0.4294568598,
0.8360927701,
1.031594038,
0.7769774199,
-0.1452328116,
0.7407162189,
-0.20213525,
0.1985311061,
1.1841053963,
-0.3465542197,
0.5044903159,
0.4075827003,
0.1659446508,
0.8019284606,
0.2745814323,
0.2038419098,
0.5027492046,
0.0683627129,
-0.0558859706,
-0.3928568065,
-0.3898602426,
0.0546573922,
0.2839291096,
0.4321793914,
-0.3892862201,
-0.1475539356,
-0.3474724591,
0.0766134113,
-0.0634653419,
-0.4798855782,
0.7829602361,
0.1056616828,
-0.5775640011,
-0.4657198191,
-0.0740030706,
0.1860149354,
-0.299780786,
-0.2784127295,
0.3119499385,
0.0238863751,
-0.5514222383,
-0.6392965317,
0.2265162319,
-0.4901817143,
-0.3218037486,
0.0067458493,
1.0799521208,
-0.4358369112,
-0.1321741045,
0.5961152911,
0.4378224909,
-0.2213687003,
0.1495643556,
-0.6596341133,
-0.2504772544,
-0.1982257217,
-0.0992099717,
0.1937105805,
0.8513079882,
-0.2051930279,
0.4071939588,
0.4668881297,
-0.2729931474,
0.0029480641,
0.2087515444,
0.9410308599,
-0.4385005236,
-0.4554176629,
-0.7332199812,
0.4040451944,
-0.1578862667,
-0.0381152965,
0.5100572109,
0.5431391001,
0.8835426569,
0.3128544688,
0.4242206812,
-0.2611329257,
-0.015920233,
-0.8211296201,
0.6530585289,
-0.5190626979,
0.2054238319,
-0.326204747,
-0.7280865908,
0.002348118,
0.5557749271,
-0.2697557211,
0.0392277576,
0.7705690861,
0.7216446996,
-0.3716301024,
0.0815667957,
-0.0172671583,
0.1139141247,
0.2855048776,
0.6109636426,
0.5184482336,
-0.6040332913,
0.5178143382,
0.0571941584,
-0.1330551058,
0.081711553,
-0.8538519144,
-0.5544181466,
-0.3017269373,
-0.5295932293,
-0.4503169358,
-0.1135116443,
0.9645778537,
0.4578871131,
-0.8163481951,
0.5457678437,
0.0728479251,
0.5323699117,
-0.5583183765,
-0.2449209392,
0.6181479096,
-0.0849899277,
-0.6465781331,
0.3823025823,
0.5444281101,
-0.0946529731,
-0.0012235689,
0.085087195,
-0.5421569943,
0.1582976431,
0.353073746,
0.1386260688,
-0.6147572398,
-0.7577908039,
0.10168688,
-0.0928184167,
-0.0288449749,
0.6262378693,
-0.5720996261,
0.3663649559,
0.5611441135,
1.1129175425,
0.1214809865,
0.3941029608,
0.5280303359,
-0.8264691234,
-0.3493443429,
0.1259899139,
0.6929017305,
0.1022160202,
-0.4674379528,
0.6750087142,
0.4269942641,
-0.1476592869,
-0.3529646993,
0.3173483908,
-0.9580193162,
0.1778708994,
0.9608598948,
-0.4904281199,
-0.5234934688,
-0.2042934895,
-0.0262412056,
0.4074680507,
-0.469642967,
0.1898462772,
0.4366462231,
-0.3991542161,
0.1523250192,
-0.2410214692,
0.5150795579,
0.3862456381,
-1.000371933,
-0.3595959842,
0.5156779885,
0.4183385074,
0.5197620392,
0.665859282,
-0.2249620259,
0.3604275584,
0.121303156,
-0.185878098,
-0.09326832,
-0.5261794925,
-0.0514372848,
0.2129629999,
-0.2334933281,
-0.2434036583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.04769v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.04769v2
|
Using Hallucinations to Bypass GPT4's Filter
| 2024-02-16T17:02:53 | 2024-03-11T01:21:32 |
Benjamin Lemkin
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) are initially trained on vast amounts of data,
then fine-tuned using reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF); this
also serves to teach the LLM to provide appropriate and safe responses. In this
paper, we present a novel method to manipulate the fine-tuned version into
reverting to its pre-RLHF behavior, effectively erasing the model's filters;
the exploit currently works for GPT4, Claude Sonnet, and (to some extent) for
Inflection-2.5. Unlike other jailbreaks (for example, the popular "Do Anything
Now" (DAN) ), our method does not rely on instructing the LLM to override its
RLHF policy; hence, simply modifying the RLHF process is unlikely to address
it. Instead, we induce a hallucination involving reversed text during which the
model reverts to a word bucket, effectively pausing the model's filter. We
believe that our exploit presents a fundamental vulnerability in LLMs currently
unaddressed, as well as an opportunity to better understand the inner workings
of LLMs during hallucinations.
|
[
-0.4663421512,
-0.9860398173,
0.7247796059,
-0.0857469887,
-0.4470316172,
-0.0465131328,
-0.3602342904,
-0.5030369759,
0.3431504071,
1.2757365704,
-0.704215467,
-0.4132943451,
-0.5966868997,
0.1317432672,
-0.5837442279,
1.1712294817,
0.0802051201,
-0.120178774,
0.2374711037,
0.2047868818,
-0.5342390537,
-0.6402125359,
-0.6497630477,
-0.7303053141,
0.6322690248,
0.1441066712,
0.7816577554,
0.2287316769,
0.2199896872,
0.2985191941,
0.0827531219,
0.0924967527,
-0.8242475986,
0.1366329789,
-0.1830608249,
-0.4466382861,
-0.1155553758,
0.0305666272,
0.5934451222,
0.4532291889,
-0.2929073572,
-0.4193975329,
0.2211920917,
0.6570513844,
-0.4082864821,
-0.0106335431,
-1.0183942318,
0.225640595,
-0.0176485553,
-0.5541290641,
-0.5693637133,
-0.2558135092,
-0.1938649565,
-0.3238759339,
0.2526079118,
-0.0446036085,
0.7808321118,
0.5422020555,
0.0613653883,
-0.2393989116,
-0.8646951318,
0.5434421897,
-0.7311403751,
0.3940266669,
0.6299737096,
0.1607542485,
-0.632563889,
-0.5869818926,
-0.8199168444,
-0.4274820983,
-0.0789988413,
-0.1857625693,
0.0760808513,
0.1151740402,
0.2847076952,
0.2123324871,
-0.542355895,
0.2104290873,
-0.5166686773,
-0.3735716343,
0.3303571939,
0.0376630574,
0.2213301063,
-0.1851813346,
-0.1585166454,
-0.0425979197,
-0.8574542999,
-0.4064000547,
0.4697212577,
0.3497616649,
0.392963022,
0.4812759757,
0.0670284107,
0.5004842281,
0.0355192758,
-0.0348612778,
0.054107774,
0.2605782747,
-0.473356545,
0.2466593385,
0.6051083803,
0.1401193291,
0.4076431692,
-0.4265957177,
-0.5064272881,
0.1256023943,
0.5657578111,
-0.7597385645,
-0.4139942527,
0.1853258908,
-0.2370654494,
-0.4076910615,
0.048582036,
-0.7353185415,
-0.8452352881,
-0.0409846045,
0.7266963124,
-0.3854869008,
-0.0038199518,
0.2966875136,
0.1593031883,
0.1742295772,
0.15429838,
-0.8788656592,
0.4388456345,
0.6959325671,
0.8809574842,
-0.0611537732,
-0.6534398198,
-0.9188463688,
0.0025608893,
-0.2527596056,
0.6276981235,
-0.5969333053,
-0.5352324843,
0.0900368318,
0.2720554173,
0.1442874223,
-0.8801553249,
0.2810157239,
-0.7922859192,
0.0765581205,
-0.0764281452,
-0.3496539593,
-0.3189640939,
0.1913585812,
-0.7899321914,
0.6515653729,
-0.0211950932,
-0.6051393747,
0.0947160199,
-0.2985967994,
-0.3758944273,
-0.1988615841,
-0.060404893,
-0.6167365313,
0.0810000747,
0.3891065121,
0.3269204497,
0.1668379754,
0.296053201,
-0.4653175771,
-0.9153826833,
0.2423271388,
-0.5127539635,
0.7260042429,
-0.0246311072,
-0.5183259249,
0.3146818578,
-0.4840085208,
-0.2659660876,
0.1220939457,
-0.1511999965,
-0.2319123447,
-0.0489138663,
-0.1110971123,
0.2315190881,
-0.1960416883,
-0.3834141791,
0.2426930964,
-0.5636604428,
0.5554683208,
0.9735479951,
0.2688455582,
0.2524619997,
-0.3045431077,
0.6061659455,
-0.1792476773,
0.0952372029,
-0.035354577,
-0.3251793683,
-0.5680258274,
-0.2141736448,
0.0055379756,
0.4602915943,
-0.8848651648,
0.2881789207,
-0.0517657176,
-0.2360228002,
-0.5131927133,
0.3274978697,
0.2467397749,
0.3176437616,
0.4891634583,
-0.2545358241,
-0.4277933836,
-0.7548447251,
-0.5140231848,
-0.1216619387,
0.0260029994,
0.0748174936,
0.5339203477,
-0.5367379189,
0.4568272829,
-0.4887169003,
-0.5169918537,
-0.2919153571,
0.1763987839,
0.2192670852,
0.3878444135,
0.1310997754,
-0.4555532038,
0.2115329802,
-0.3982971609,
-0.5358873606,
-0.3247600496,
-0.4422616363,
-0.0456683747,
0.3743901849,
0.8731017113,
-0.6634687781,
0.6304194331,
0.448220104,
-0.5272790194,
0.75934726,
-0.4132632017,
0.134226352,
-0.5825129747,
-0.2257250994,
-0.2172772288,
-0.3502859771,
-0.4488255978,
0.1851862222,
0.0220661312,
-0.0385920815,
-0.3461032808,
0.5126432776,
-0.4719780087,
-0.1177412942,
-0.5947912931,
0.2567541301,
-0.1064717248,
0.6047833562,
-0.1384248286,
0.5871729255,
0.2634139061,
-0.6136577725,
0.2346142977,
0.1273768991,
-0.2757476866,
0.1673011184,
-0.4028796852,
0.5291532278,
-0.2463256866,
0.3302178681,
-0.801066637,
-0.1145705134,
0.5769107342,
-0.1971568912,
0.3638841808,
-0.0895210728,
-0.6493088007,
-0.322243005,
-0.5718076825,
0.0188786145,
0.3791795373,
-0.7859405875,
0.4916057885,
0.296097219,
0.068179816,
-0.3260310888,
-0.7797715068,
0.5030761957,
-0.404261142,
-0.1088478863,
0.2761463821,
-0.0630384833,
-0.1970260143,
-0.0964631215,
-0.0051292549,
0.1547386944,
0.0941640213,
0.3259055614,
0.3215678632,
0.2291308343,
-0.0957399383,
0.1023235992,
-0.0215508863,
0.2661888599,
-0.2727852166,
0.8337019086,
-0.0107467221,
-0.4531182051,
-0.4621796906,
0.0871123672,
0.6536511779,
-0.0551791675,
0.5713533759,
0.4044728577,
-0.5486938357,
-0.4792319834,
-0.4673749804,
-0.9604167342,
-0.5147569776,
0.6021704078,
-0.3495986164,
-1.0690535307,
0.4816879332,
0.1349959671,
-0.1557760686,
-0.0750851333,
0.4771628082,
0.1135669723,
0.8271271586,
0.4839608967,
-0.2227571011,
0.4544533193,
-0.1439010501,
0.5078753233,
-0.9010429978,
-0.1101034507,
-0.3107685149,
-0.4283847809,
-0.5864640474,
-0.3485882878,
0.317666918,
0.1772760898,
-0.1565184742,
0.1848878711,
-0.4255021513,
0.6571018696,
0.3373170197,
0.5017399192,
0.4009185135,
-0.0047003226,
-0.0255802982,
-0.1685110927,
-0.3172437549,
-0.4227899611,
0.966146946,
0.333702594,
0.9044240713,
-0.0152735282,
0.8532105684,
0.2876115441,
0.3478852212,
-0.6689016223,
0.8362269998,
-0.0518710762,
-0.2973057628,
-0.5427786112,
-0.269377321,
-0.8422719836,
0.5783730745,
-0.0726515055,
-0.9727112055,
-0.0014353547,
0.2721384764,
-0.3358289003,
0.6634919047,
-0.6350870132,
0.6402220726,
-0.04018135,
-0.4609763324,
-0.5862565637,
-0.4241692722,
0.7575445175,
-0.2559774518,
0.3060232699,
0.1568764746,
0.2314553708,
0.5193930268,
-0.4045186043,
1.102799058,
-0.2798603773,
-0.2809523642,
-0.015557426,
0.5046184063,
0.7676230669,
0.2332281321,
0.1511091888,
0.039780613,
-0.2323778272,
-0.1631765813,
-0.8362705708,
1.1242929697,
-0.6224415898,
-0.9644280076,
-0.4829055667,
-0.3091673553,
-0.1982283741,
0.0817040801,
0.1018902138,
0.2110884637,
0.037454702,
-0.2595054507,
0.6787768602,
-0.4664892554,
0.4136500955,
0.3748032153,
-0.8285857439,
-0.3654776216,
0.8018078804,
0.0566358566,
0.214422822,
0.0164171997,
0.3159347177,
-0.2613546252,
-0.6079064012,
-0.3072466552,
0.497900933,
-0.6532107592,
0.020297002,
-0.6546732783,
-0.3379290104,
-0.2481709272,
-0.0288608409,
-0.2282315791,
-0.0960252732,
-0.300737083,
-0.1859835088,
0.306099385,
0.8082431555,
-0.0344348773,
0.111908488,
-0.5357128382,
0.5374022126,
0.4681687653,
0.4497309029,
0.0373914763,
-0.9452198744,
-0.0403323732,
-0.1698077917,
-0.2388435751,
-1.0532376766,
0.4628597498,
0.035279721,
0.2473719567,
0.3818038106,
0.0627217889,
0.7484740615,
-0.6146340966,
0.7005950809,
-0.1440175921,
-0.9928975701,
0.351292789,
-0.1716086268,
0.3262566924,
0.4186355174,
-0.0016066869,
-0.693326354,
-0.7836151719,
-0.3266326189,
-0.7555469275,
0.6147085428,
0.0144754611,
0.3766607642,
0.0235284921,
0.6611660719,
0.2000312358,
0.2096713632,
-0.8015464544,
0.003473632,
-0.3671203256,
0.303709209,
-0.1749742776,
-0.3140366971,
-0.0009527534,
-0.5346593261,
0.8365172744,
0.0808877274,
0.0972211882,
0.308041364,
-0.2383659631,
-0.090767853,
0.2038401216,
0.7419496775,
0.4863813519,
-0.2354838103,
0.4649986625,
0.1095867679,
-0.6879033446,
-0.0504692011,
-0.114054814,
-0.3324947655,
-0.1618138999,
0.3123519123,
0.9805465341,
0.3894551098,
-0.7683680654,
0.0731680915,
0.0524713099,
-0.2614516616,
-0.3901180029,
0.1115889177,
-0.1450408399,
0.4123586118,
0.1102882102,
-0.0334536508,
0.0012320593,
-0.7589789629,
0.514084518,
0.3311312199,
-0.5381201506,
-0.3775857389,
0.7648314238,
-0.3307600915,
-0.5117635131,
0.6914988756,
-0.1637169272,
-0.8284738064,
0.1590081304,
0.809681952,
1.1618510485,
-0.2126827091,
0.3575035036,
0.2242017537,
0.61419034,
-0.190090239,
0.1417910457,
0.2277941853,
-0.9334900975,
-0.4305512309,
-0.4535141885,
-0.1532491297,
0.6325888038,
-0.3516564369,
0.2329418063,
-0.5986722708,
0.02385935,
-0.2726581395,
-0.3244936168,
-0.2978663146,
-0.0610846207,
0.1383572519,
0.5230723619,
-0.6512853503,
1.1797573566,
0.4091345668,
-0.1689558178,
-0.6592056751,
0.5536313653,
0.0637634248,
-0.7584151626,
0.3774309456,
0.1744012237,
-0.5469663143,
0.1425305903,
-0.8118211627,
-0.3991929889,
0.6478645802,
0.3640466332,
-0.5921892524,
0.1915900111,
-0.0400767513,
0.4604135454,
-0.0912980437,
-0.1013005525,
1.0531799793,
0.6206797957,
-0.0730019361,
-0.7232218981,
0.2274724692,
-0.0962393135,
-0.0171443149,
0.2058106661,
-0.2928550243,
0.7128330469,
-0.4852784276,
0.0053126672,
-0.1167816594,
0.3266639113,
0.4093824327,
-0.0673384815,
0.7444216013,
0.6051265597,
0.782858789,
0.1357463151,
0.898191452,
-0.0360468626,
0.3188870251,
1.3177412748,
-0.4882831573,
0.9405750036,
0.9439229369,
0.1104079485,
0.3527236879,
0.4291642606,
-0.0488377064,
0.8578266501,
0.5607659817,
-0.1777283847,
-0.2489702404,
0.3370610178,
-0.0613898896,
0.3546130657,
0.3160882294,
-0.034262009,
-0.1962736547,
0.4466993213,
0.3416396677,
0.3029203713,
-0.2940648496,
0.6524257064,
0.2294725329,
-0.7243949771,
0.9229316115,
0.0698571578,
0.5976426005,
-0.3119691908,
-0.2027893215,
-0.2005048096,
0.2550402582,
-0.0934834927,
-0.5673453212,
0.4525074661,
-0.0828047097,
0.1245817095,
-0.0931334421,
0.6150293946,
-0.5054609776,
-0.2576822042,
0.7055442929,
0.0218835752,
0.2606323659,
-0.425278008,
-0.4829560518,
0.3503423333,
0.1494501084,
-0.3714375198,
0.2475553602,
0.2780990303,
-0.0934563577,
0.7608913183,
0.5738631487,
0.4324996769,
0.0639524087,
0.4357572794,
1.022952199,
-0.9591036439,
-0.4723421931,
-1.1104418039,
0.0179785714,
0.1137276739,
-0.0625729635,
0.4937361777,
0.2853384018,
0.9679523706,
-0.1137789115,
0.7858992219,
0.3682485223,
0.3631325066,
-0.8689985871,
1.0660979748,
-0.4233307838,
0.8312239051,
-0.3768773079,
-0.9437695742,
-0.4851087928,
0.6351097226,
-0.4891524613,
-0.0173800923,
0.9661211967,
1.1877498627,
0.1312879026,
0.0691729113,
0.5330373645,
0.7394886613,
0.4789993763,
0.4884150624,
0.8087245822,
-0.2238395959,
0.4772642553,
-0.2701306641,
-0.1377642751,
-0.2051696479,
-0.6044312716,
-1.2373034954,
-0.4232996702,
-0.1083746701,
-0.6692610383,
0.2892537713,
0.822253108,
0.3616391718,
-0.9134236574,
-0.1113467216,
-0.1969765723,
0.2736990154,
-0.1850129068,
-0.1847892851,
0.2935905159,
-0.2977204919,
-0.558434844,
0.5085946918,
0.3955638409,
0.0472134426,
-0.7188815475,
-0.2795803249,
-0.0228092782,
0.0484111346,
0.4067512155,
0.1510675997,
-1.0004726648,
-0.6663041115,
-0.1900483072,
0.0643213093,
0.0154921962,
0.9614090323,
-1.0177131891,
0.346786201,
0.2115084678,
0.5653292537,
0.6079874635,
-0.2663452327,
0.4384513199,
-0.3522835076,
0.2753895521,
0.3227698803,
0.2759827971,
0.309451282,
-0.45661515,
0.0922668874,
0.2968431711,
-0.5049129725,
-0.9450722933,
0.3684123755,
-0.5957831144,
-0.6120111942,
1.0505957603,
0.3437826633,
-0.1872868985,
-0.2709594667,
-0.3981845677,
0.111752212,
-0.2198258638,
1.4625512362,
0.8066635728,
0.1018024161,
-0.3798340559,
-0.817538619,
0.6259335876,
0.343297869,
-0.647668004,
0.2078994066,
0.3863920569,
0.2209065408,
-0.2893649936,
0.6277232766,
-0.3458788395,
-0.0940231457,
-0.3724629581,
0.0334405862,
-0.0770907998,
-0.5140076876,
-0.6003623605,
0.0924950838,
-0.0284118205,
-0.0796314552
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10812v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10812v1
|
Exploring Hybrid Question Answering via Program-based Prompting
| 2024-02-16T16:35:41 | 2024-02-16T16:35:41 |
Qi Shi, Han Cui, Haofeng Wang, Qingfu Zhu, Wanxiang Che, Ting Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Question answering over heterogeneous data requires reasoning over diverse
sources of data, which is challenging due to the large scale of information and
organic coupling of heterogeneous data. Various approaches have been proposed
to address these challenges. One approach involves training specialized
retrievers to select relevant information, thereby reducing the input length.
Another approach is to transform diverse modalities of data into a single
modality, simplifying the task difficulty and enabling more straightforward
processing. In this paper, we propose HProPro, a novel program-based prompting
framework for the hybrid question answering task. HProPro follows the code
generation and execution paradigm. In addition, HProPro integrates various
functions to tackle the hybrid reasoning scenario. Specifically, HProPro
contains function declaration and function implementation to perform hybrid
information-seeking over data from various sources and modalities, which
enables reasoning over such data without training specialized retrievers or
performing modal transformations. Experimental results on two typical hybrid
question answering benchmarks HybridQA and MultiModalQA demonstrate the
effectiveness of HProPro: it surpasses all baseline systems and achieves the
best performances in the few-shot settings on both datasets.
|
[
-0.4354029,
-1.0108720064,
0.6061965227,
0.182950303,
-0.2642789483,
0.552513063,
-0.2589513659,
-0.3692819774,
0.1098923087,
0.1352766007,
-0.6560851932,
-0.1936240047,
0.0329165272,
0.2753849924,
0.0654689968,
1.019462347,
-0.0440839417,
0.0773487166,
-0.3554027975,
-0.2544093728,
-0.5684970021,
-0.1195745245,
-0.1171667427,
-0.268501997,
0.4633027017,
0.5753313303,
0.661706388,
0.2973877192,
0.0363012925,
0.2379400581,
0.1811971664,
0.3945447505,
-0.5134429336,
0.077995576,
-0.1358698756,
-0.4557214975,
0.1123355702,
-0.1576432288,
0.5294780135,
0.5935816765,
-0.2052819282,
0.3286049068,
-0.0650539026,
0.0215262007,
-0.7552011013,
-0.2831394672,
-0.6689381599,
0.2003223002,
-0.0565015711,
-0.7771685719,
-0.2908464968,
-0.6127588153,
-0.0554729104,
-0.8189741969,
0.0939798206,
0.3324518204,
0.5278503299,
0.2730343938,
-0.3137509227,
-0.0116662709,
-0.8549176455,
0.7816534042,
-0.3631098866,
-0.0259294137,
0.3685089648,
0.5185621977,
0.0602398366,
-0.3528703451,
-0.8531945348,
-0.2455564588,
-0.0217901468,
0.2481185496,
0.0752784014,
0.0673931539,
0.2776587605,
0.6720917225,
-0.7970519066,
-0.1302814931,
-0.5308455825,
-0.4780241847,
0.2101076543,
0.2417933047,
0.2344998866,
-0.3931512237,
-0.3856922686,
-0.195438534,
-0.4261528254,
0.1589127332,
0.3291092813,
0.1748118103,
-0.1369770318,
0.6912231445,
-0.0360995196,
0.8264453411,
0.0729319155,
-0.1784789264,
0.1680253744,
-0.347776562,
-0.278711766,
-0.2012584507,
0.7451104522,
0.0715877563,
-0.0842079818,
0.0206975359,
0.1612360477,
0.0590093471,
0.0121974498,
-0.2371601313,
-0.1382256001,
0.5380591154,
-0.4973390698,
-0.2543136179,
0.1946320385,
-1.218550086,
-0.2962735891,
-0.0620523319,
0.573988378,
-0.5118815303,
-0.1739993691,
0.0480801612,
-0.2626376152,
0.4967025816,
0.480196476,
-0.4830696881,
0.2404862046,
0.6802839637,
0.4526249766,
-0.2101262957,
-0.411980927,
-1.0755249262,
0.2098844349,
0.0292628445,
0.7886391878,
-0.8529550433,
-0.469923526,
-0.1383984685,
-0.1692848206,
-0.4584788978,
-0.6691424251,
0.3972680569,
-0.3964979649,
0.673068583,
-0.3861463964,
-0.2848719358,
0.0354128405,
0.310217917,
-0.3619120419,
1.6103938818,
0.3935870826,
-0.9035150409,
0.2107871324,
-0.4973877668,
-0.6063497066,
0.4350750148,
-0.5769964457,
-0.0352192111,
-0.1398635805,
0.2544512749,
-0.1577963084,
-0.4860494435,
0.1640601605,
-0.1885548979,
-0.5149136186,
0.0057004723,
-0.1373943985,
0.5997032523,
0.1324205101,
-0.3852745295,
0.2037717402,
-0.4441321194,
0.3230159283,
0.0205944795,
-0.4613740742,
-0.3886806965,
-0.3630792499,
-0.1304738373,
0.2725401223,
0.2290291041,
-0.7750576138,
0.2339716703,
0.0748128816,
0.2289968431,
0.4643112421,
0.0787449256,
0.2807184756,
-0.4753600061,
1.1132041216,
-0.3803808689,
0.1800766736,
-0.2531604171,
-0.7040212154,
-0.0965048671,
-0.2223168612,
-0.0538379848,
1.0845929384,
-1.1265112162,
0.0915618241,
0.2372886837,
-0.1427966356,
-0.6295717955,
0.079469189,
0.2396382838,
1.0378540754,
0.4700464606,
0.3422778547,
-0.4845423698,
-0.5564104319,
0.0513492562,
-0.2676440477,
0.0229149517,
0.6454979777,
0.3233549297,
-0.022933593,
0.8310893178,
-0.5531683564,
0.4357868731,
-0.6831998825,
0.3929154575,
0.0860833153,
0.3707931638,
0.3374599516,
-1.0234214067,
-0.371509999,
0.2073927969,
-0.5496496558,
-0.1063875705,
-0.2105100751,
-0.179344669,
-0.3959845901,
0.3528997898,
-0.5395897031,
0.2072493732,
0.5469381809,
0.1582760513,
1.0079149008,
-0.4430996776,
0.4719349444,
-0.9204717278,
0.4738636017,
-0.3190511763,
-0.0663533956,
-0.357531786,
-0.0774763003,
-0.0231385957,
-0.5578613877,
-0.3780266345,
0.3276460171,
-0.2596883178,
-0.0414327271,
-0.112136431,
-0.2832878828,
0.0952357277,
0.2816257477,
0.0708560273,
1.0610980988,
0.5668781996,
-0.5205412507,
0.430103451,
0.3810612559,
0.139812395,
0.4753242135,
-0.8703683615,
0.3133913279,
-0.2797181606,
0.4484386444,
-0.9885953665,
-0.442302376,
0.2552106678,
-0.2066172212,
-0.1793042123,
-0.1175697222,
-0.4030331969,
-0.9114117622,
-0.5499870777,
0.7007681131,
0.4257332981,
-0.5268258452,
0.6345686316,
0.0668360814,
-0.1755699068,
-0.4969232678,
-0.4284544289,
-0.1654530019,
-0.2424722761,
-0.4567130208,
0.442584753,
-0.307825774,
-0.1071366221,
-0.0707548335,
0.0263600033,
-0.2013760209,
-0.4443383813,
-0.0282758288,
0.7170566916,
-0.2369113117,
-0.035360083,
0.268825978,
0.0573014431,
-0.1749165207,
-0.0839946941,
0.6470140219,
-0.1323488057,
-0.3051692843,
-0.4000127912,
0.6917504668,
0.6019223928,
-0.5500169992,
0.4686928689,
0.5311715603,
-0.0362217166,
-0.366376549,
-0.3437038064,
-0.2216419876,
-0.4899327755,
-0.0866286308,
-0.2869423926,
-0.9120550156,
0.3558782935,
-0.1137989163,
-0.088770397,
-0.0815227851,
0.5974186659,
-0.2345800847,
1.0022615194,
0.4661100209,
0.0507397614,
0.3498511314,
-0.0365676731,
0.142826125,
-0.4920924902,
-0.4293854237,
-0.453956455,
-0.0809141546,
-0.3632225394,
-0.764200151,
0.8128507733,
-0.1648884863,
0.0712719336,
0.3874168098,
-0.6051228642,
0.5110481977,
0.6374664903,
0.2226096541,
0.3069041073,
-0.0900578573,
-0.298049897,
0.103560552,
-1.0171194077,
-0.0585878491,
0.5863428116,
-0.0744476616,
0.7982186079,
-0.4371790588,
0.6154485345,
0.2764347792,
0.0283803698,
-0.6879606843,
0.5611256361,
0.2580666244,
-0.4456802309,
-0.2241920382,
-0.7330152988,
-0.7049000263,
0.1882879585,
-0.3042498529,
-0.6242508292,
0.2377127558,
0.5534300804,
-0.734716773,
0.1937106401,
-0.4576338828,
0.8063356876,
-0.3553147912,
-0.3805491328,
-0.2184863389,
-0.7642869949,
0.3735487461,
0.410741359,
0.0701374635,
0.0692742467,
0.0158478841,
0.2943467796,
-0.3286704123,
0.3886989951,
-0.1011849642,
0.1291418821,
0.4598083198,
0.2932173312,
0.4022105038,
0.1974910349,
-0.1842537969,
-0.5991261005,
0.2512362599,
-0.3835462034,
-0.5787118673,
0.5148720145,
-0.2069092095,
-0.3238805532,
-0.2251506001,
-0.9544165134,
-0.6149205565,
0.0433454327,
0.5935226083,
0.3893226385,
0.0775253624,
-0.046588067,
0.7291271687,
-0.607604146,
0.1289358139,
0.1704753786,
0.0098459292,
-0.4691994786,
0.9280980229,
-0.555211544,
0.3255672455,
0.5252363086,
0.572853744,
-0.3458014727,
-0.15000844,
-0.7336350679,
0.3759767711,
-0.2591402233,
-0.0741542354,
-0.5122274756,
0.1681775153,
-0.2284376025,
-0.2088303268,
-0.0276833363,
-0.2471170574,
0.0720077008,
0.0927685574,
0.3438242376,
0.2071484178,
-0.0364611186,
-0.1533709913,
-0.7216156125,
0.6543559432,
0.6102606058,
0.0428477861,
-0.127930373,
-0.1177075803,
0.2008250803,
-0.1853262335,
0.0827346742,
-1.0088084936,
-0.0224125814,
0.1487845629,
0.6571136117,
0.0345973335,
0.2274754047,
0.6350668073,
-0.1656522155,
0.5597648621,
0.0834797248,
-0.6268105507,
0.7989539504,
-0.6882063746,
0.4772147834,
1.0795446634,
0.4473740757,
-0.6000772119,
-0.1666298807,
-0.4141787291,
-0.3980861902,
0.5604715943,
-0.1488205642,
0.0852156281,
0.1468384415,
0.1081412435,
0.5183013678,
0.4799817502,
-0.4023186862,
-0.0120678861,
-0.2200745493,
-0.0933030993,
0.4456921518,
0.4036999643,
-0.2613876164,
-0.5036141276,
0.3286911547,
-0.4623819888,
0.3412817717,
0.1930928975,
-0.0431067571,
-0.1582281888,
0.4577453732,
0.365478158,
0.5112031698,
-0.073250398,
-0.0227592792,
0.0900082961,
-0.3581425548,
-0.0126607884,
0.3044292629,
-0.2713151872,
-0.2062494755,
0.110685721,
0.4575546086,
0.0921962485,
-1.1062481403,
0.3941362202,
0.1847478598,
-0.014939337,
0.2769236267,
0.1269943863,
-0.1617420465,
-0.2748009264,
0.6093865633,
-0.1429691166,
0.2117533535,
-0.845733285,
0.1013212502,
0.2531420588,
-0.0838192627,
-0.2839897871,
0.5233789682,
0.1425374597,
-0.0311447922,
0.5963932276,
-0.1974942386,
-0.7586214542,
0.530987978,
0.6650069356,
0.318374455,
-0.1285022348,
0.8359988928,
0.2878066599,
0.0681253076,
0.1182311177,
0.6957556605,
-0.5503960252,
-0.5123176575,
-0.4580307901,
-0.3696535826,
-0.8499551415,
0.2980152071,
-0.5237708688,
-0.0449187569,
-0.5959013104,
0.3362607956,
-0.1021341607,
-0.3976694643,
-0.2547490001,
0.1013900936,
0.2281099409,
0.918738246,
-0.8542569876,
0.4550214112,
0.853808701,
-0.2810890675,
-0.9307451844,
0.1438637227,
0.0292686783,
-0.6617192626,
-0.0408114567,
-0.0389246568,
-0.2303536981,
-0.1665937006,
-0.5327799916,
-0.2119494081,
0.7897746563,
0.4208273292,
-0.0314850584,
-0.1455574036,
0.3389328122,
0.4313856661,
-0.2814900577,
0.1008626521,
0.4588773847,
0.6381981373,
0.3855361044,
-1.0546308756,
-0.0492803119,
-0.3534005582,
-0.3078534007,
0.2452831566,
-0.4003642201,
0.8309096098,
-0.2981032431,
0.0001718224,
0.0516736247,
0.3213093877,
0.6440908313,
0.580842793,
0.5381093621,
0.216500327,
1.003338933,
0.2138853371,
1.1234327555,
-0.0901440084,
0.1028479263,
1.1430069208,
-0.536875546,
0.6360342503,
0.6381011605,
-0.1559211165,
0.7900999784,
0.3575443327,
0.1033867002,
0.3088800013,
-0.1614955813,
-0.5649370551,
-0.3892454207,
-0.2275609821,
-0.3224617541,
0.4182992876,
0.1108197048,
0.1096892282,
-0.4981466532,
0.3522846699,
-0.1498681605,
0.3393827081,
-0.2181580514,
0.3120245934,
-0.1727120727,
-1.0841242075,
0.4904648364,
-0.2109483629,
0.703728497,
-0.848388195,
-0.2053642124,
-0.081978105,
-0.2344321609,
-0.2981266975,
-0.8136034012,
0.2874012887,
-0.0837158263,
-0.0169446655,
-0.1642245352,
0.7362688184,
-0.4055157602,
-0.2979603112,
0.0554127023,
0.8479960561,
-0.3070999384,
-0.0194816347,
-0.9025919437,
0.0548247732,
-0.0566149876,
0.2518093288,
-0.0135285566,
0.2373508811,
-0.2184326798,
0.447050482,
0.7904851437,
-0.074189119,
0.1503132284,
0.1361110061,
0.7956870794,
-0.4272169173,
-0.8260769844,
-0.1306119859,
0.2607153654,
-0.2037222385,
-0.5847800374,
0.8469979763,
0.708432734,
0.4018601477,
-0.1122102439,
0.8375355005,
-0.6099222302,
0.6219166517,
-0.1816122681,
-0.0583412386,
-0.354890734,
0.015643876,
-0.2672790885,
-0.7293087244,
0.0622838102,
0.3986824453,
-0.7083138227,
0.0126098245,
0.5861392617,
0.9157972932,
-0.378895551,
0.2825891674,
0.009547675,
-0.2644136548,
-0.2075955868,
0.6356022358,
1.1914308071,
0.0508095324,
0.8242283463,
-0.3752095997,
-0.376706183,
-0.1264042705,
-0.6365210414,
-0.5446414351,
-0.3647561967,
-0.1433205158,
-0.35132882,
-0.0329898037,
0.9373883009,
0.8411663771,
-0.735614419,
-0.0952330679,
-0.1906083077,
-0.0253083352,
-0.3762699366,
-0.34380126,
0.0884385407,
0.1910687387,
-0.4131372273,
0.7824252844,
0.4708071351,
-0.1703850627,
-0.0789971724,
-0.0869250521,
-0.2011881918,
0.0188775659,
0.2840491235,
1.0912089348,
-0.2221883684,
-0.1361348778,
0.2987712622,
0.0147063453,
0.3882803619,
1.2578090429,
-1.0716674328,
0.2974416316,
0.8233399391,
0.7318122387,
0.6515564919,
0.4496306777,
0.6130062342,
-0.4621779621,
0.1368635595,
0.6683542728,
-0.1093795747,
0.4057375789,
-0.663487196,
0.0307333712,
0.2655164301,
-0.2820014656,
-0.7488614917,
0.1888892055,
-1.183200717,
-0.2470748723,
0.9630239606,
0.3047405183,
-0.3210305274,
-0.3025137186,
-0.5457647443,
-0.0882022381,
-0.3544596732,
0.4596646726,
0.0159340445,
-0.6801847816,
-0.3365317285,
-0.4838711023,
0.3892417252,
0.6235258579,
-1.2283517122,
-0.0500205606,
0.6684717536,
0.3539816141,
-0.0391077623,
0.7406214476,
-0.2536761761,
0.8950743675,
-0.0349430442,
-0.4788278043,
-0.1189868972,
-0.3380666077,
-0.2302223593,
0.390918225,
-0.3603591025,
-0.0438273996
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10811v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10811v2
|
Quantifying the Persona Effect in LLM Simulations
| 2024-02-16T16:35:35 | 2024-06-17T11:06:57 |
Tiancheng Hu, Nigel Collier
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable promise in simulating
human language and behavior. This study investigates how integrating persona
variables-demographic, social, and behavioral factors-impacts LLMs' ability to
simulate diverse perspectives. We find that persona variables account for <10%
variance in annotations in existing subjective NLP datasets. Nonetheless,
incorporating persona variables via prompting in LLMs provides modest but
statistically significant improvements. Persona prompting is most effective in
samples where many annotators disagree, but their disagreements are relatively
minor. Notably, we find a linear relationship in our setting: the stronger the
correlation between persona variables and human annotations, the more accurate
the LLM predictions are using persona prompting. In a zero-shot setting, a
powerful 70b model with persona prompting captures 81% of the annotation
variance achievable by linear regression trained on ground truth annotations.
However, for most subjective NLP datasets, where persona variables have limited
explanatory power, the benefits of persona prompting are limited.
|
[
-0.5246466994,
-0.5919528008,
0.967161715,
0.7826479077,
0.0244371109,
0.0340351313,
-0.1710594594,
-0.4510150552,
0.2683300972,
0.4583466649,
-0.5951371789,
-0.3035449684,
-0.382751435,
0.1000631526,
0.0548878983,
0.7891253829,
0.3841752112,
0.2642256916,
-0.488671124,
0.183234632,
-0.4808914661,
-0.9003430009,
-0.5529618859,
-0.7720423937,
0.9644533396,
0.1019801944,
0.4646039605,
0.1007061377,
0.3200688064,
0.2576254308,
0.0295988042,
-0.0604575835,
-0.4357426763,
0.2628593445,
-0.2456770837,
-0.6901825666,
-0.3269252479,
0.3515518308,
0.7403196096,
1.0038591623,
0.0985248089,
0.1636327505,
0.0766863078,
0.433953017,
-0.507560432,
0.2173874229,
-0.1979028434,
0.1175513491,
-0.2785369456,
-0.2844943106,
-0.6187018752,
-0.2895146012,
0.3870389163,
-0.2299014777,
-0.2076430321,
0.1531081647,
0.4408661127,
0.2307564318,
-0.4507592916,
0.0394557416,
-1.0836881399,
0.7925114036,
-0.685326755,
0.0616014525,
0.360814482,
0.070415847,
-0.209423393,
-0.2522818148,
-0.5522012115,
-0.2447470874,
-0.2064549327,
0.1021816656,
-0.1556129754,
0.1701973826,
0.608727932,
-0.0338332951,
-0.0640341789,
0.270283848,
-0.2166715264,
-0.036372181,
0.5285092592,
0.3589025736,
0.1429313123,
-0.6083028913,
-0.1343544871,
0.0017365376,
-0.5978537798,
0.255484879,
0.6567748785,
0.3472727537,
-0.1031045318,
0.6785780191,
0.0258832667,
0.5246264935,
0.3377452493,
-0.505525887,
0.2404082417,
0.04594405,
-0.151467666,
-0.316500932,
0.7908813357,
0.4607475102,
0.5332655907,
-0.1199470907,
0.037508484,
0.0180688966,
0.2290429473,
-0.6350160241,
-0.2619353235,
0.3273663521,
-0.2801852226,
-0.1765584648,
0.0184280928,
-0.9821338654,
-0.9632279277,
-0.5377041101,
0.205129832,
-0.4601872861,
-0.0862312317,
0.1018603519,
-0.0720377415,
0.6458209753,
0.687437892,
-0.8516076803,
0.1911580712,
0.8200525641,
0.726356566,
-0.1614897102,
-0.2869235575,
-0.5493272543,
-0.0234664734,
-0.1234983802,
0.9088635445,
-0.7277388573,
-0.5969145298,
0.0324739181,
-0.4520772099,
-0.1922539622,
-0.537535131,
0.2332473397,
-0.0318434797,
0.2339432687,
-0.8483047485,
-0.587844491,
0.1849963814,
0.1361915469,
-0.4561449289,
0.8011344075,
0.10486608,
-0.7555336952,
0.3955128789,
-0.4271898568,
-0.1825094968,
0.3122856617,
-0.4513480663,
0.0216303971,
0.3727620244,
0.2173712403,
0.75895226,
-0.1230352595,
0.4698697925,
-0.2809978127,
-0.3088959455,
0.8180242181,
-0.1783669889,
0.761572361,
-0.221170634,
-0.2343872488,
-0.0885764435,
-0.4296769798,
-0.3450213671,
-0.106132105,
-0.2805519998,
-0.3908810914,
-0.0920098871,
0.0705939159,
0.372531116,
-0.0300654639,
-0.4774579406,
0.2745064497,
-0.2109813839,
-0.0857676864,
0.9078358412,
0.4352258742,
0.5362024903,
-0.4769539535,
0.8912247419,
-0.0679303631,
-0.0535895675,
-0.216221109,
-0.8425999284,
-0.638769567,
-0.5971409678,
0.2409987599,
0.557753861,
-0.5829362869,
0.149747476,
-0.1726158112,
-0.3709171712,
-0.3910993636,
-0.0979976654,
0.4904527366,
0.4179025888,
-0.1210910678,
-0.2384311855,
-0.5139760971,
-0.9743469954,
-0.4064619541,
-0.7596960068,
-0.4628194571,
0.7006344795,
0.508104682,
-0.0025117858,
0.9541088939,
-0.3338385522,
-0.1138929352,
-0.2983222008,
0.3988515437,
-0.0469508991,
0.3349845707,
0.8832421899,
-0.3905024529,
-0.5390274525,
-0.5770534873,
-0.6789357662,
-0.5557277799,
-0.4376624525,
-0.0462633334,
-0.181760639,
0.2511103153,
-0.582387507,
0.3205140233,
0.3876366019,
-0.3031429946,
0.7097605467,
-0.0139268059,
0.2582153678,
-0.7436253428,
0.0564920194,
0.6360175014,
-0.1676657796,
-0.7520897985,
0.0515392646,
-0.1828011423,
0.0635718256,
-0.589900732,
0.6358260512,
-0.1684926152,
-0.2302366942,
-0.1171481237,
0.1589230597,
0.0663983747,
0.434540391,
0.1563291252,
0.8965809345,
0.3274106979,
-0.5716775656,
0.1431654841,
0.2636401057,
-0.244766444,
1.0953626633,
-0.6770239472,
0.2402279228,
-0.533747673,
0.4688060582,
-1.0824024677,
-0.5898156762,
0.3626921177,
-0.3321537375,
0.080066815,
-0.0336260907,
-0.6743856072,
-0.2682044506,
-0.4433847964,
-0.0023635447,
0.5613031983,
-0.3418421149,
0.9742711186,
0.3582583964,
-0.1174301356,
-0.1891657114,
-0.7252812386,
0.3309000731,
-0.5085150003,
-0.3749694228,
0.2442415804,
-0.2409870923,
-0.7333657742,
-0.5909371376,
0.3064793944,
0.2018947154,
-0.0709992796,
0.5193970799,
0.3839257956,
0.141228199,
-0.0218411423,
-0.1937430948,
0.0487603582,
0.515134275,
-0.124543488,
0.6701741219,
-0.208011657,
-0.2709394693,
-0.6716411114,
0.2015599757,
0.3700448871,
0.0294344369,
0.9769687057,
0.3362312913,
-0.2528648674,
0.1436945498,
-0.7025673985,
-0.0867029279,
-0.4952099025,
0.0447836518,
-0.3324572742,
-0.7689154744,
0.777839303,
-0.1562291533,
0.146509707,
-0.0736318827,
0.449216038,
-0.4568254948,
0.8046739697,
0.4517554343,
0.0398236848,
0.4940164685,
0.1057815775,
0.1272687167,
-1.1263097525,
-0.7379329205,
-0.5215847492,
-0.5524773002,
-0.6678715348,
-0.6476586461,
0.1756405085,
-0.4710459709,
-0.096162498,
-0.0137070166,
0.0102357864,
0.3543714285,
0.5266934633,
0.2639382482,
0.0545384176,
-0.0443540439,
-0.0054718065,
-0.8382942677,
-0.212088421,
-0.5800415874,
1.0344963074,
0.4506169558,
0.9439436793,
0.186371699,
0.6914493442,
0.1360642016,
0.4927627742,
-0.8196597695,
0.8475220203,
0.0123944357,
-0.6036592126,
0.0123107051,
-0.3554187119,
-0.5136083364,
0.116681084,
-0.3494507074,
-1.2078620195,
0.5790827274,
0.2035120428,
-0.6205627918,
0.0422210507,
-0.5440532565,
0.2523934245,
-0.1516450793,
-0.5116146803,
0.2319017202,
-0.656360209,
0.5158939362,
-0.2762439549,
0.0457653366,
-0.2861210704,
-0.1959603131,
0.6046595573,
0.0765106678,
1.2413005829,
-0.3356289566,
-0.1965184212,
-0.0688944459,
0.1638648808,
0.2890598774,
0.1300562918,
-0.3485504091,
0.0055305157,
-0.3516745567,
-0.300188899,
-0.7271820903,
0.6791087389,
-0.8564289212,
-0.8147898912,
-0.4350433946,
-0.688708663,
-0.6665714979,
-0.3562020361,
0.1717984974,
0.1007981896,
-0.1358714998,
0.2759853005,
0.8725870848,
-0.6581304669,
0.0952044129,
0.5140016675,
-0.7143044472,
-0.2774468958,
0.4590258002,
0.0171915889,
0.3250040412,
0.2799367011,
0.2783722878,
-0.2000853419,
0.0472853743,
-0.0956374705,
0.5040899515,
-0.7404717207,
0.1388034821,
-0.8267352581,
0.07966353,
-0.3385531008,
-0.1962096095,
-0.0864618048,
-0.1931111515,
-0.2825466394,
-0.2160993218,
0.2090855986,
0.6283342242,
0.1062212437,
0.8030343056,
-0.2612464428,
0.1129488721,
0.4296999276,
0.1096548215,
0.0027435164,
-0.6692712307,
0.1290484667,
-0.1491125375,
0.0936711058,
-1.042601347,
0.3288258314,
0.1007350683,
0.4430862069,
0.5457039475,
-0.1685121655,
0.9124010205,
-0.4833186865,
1.0328167677,
0.0542597324,
-0.9287967086,
0.5667496324,
-0.71349895,
0.6168531775,
0.7451486588,
0.3468879461,
-0.6840338111,
-0.500721097,
-0.362988472,
-0.6159057617,
0.6591591239,
0.217138648,
0.5204702616,
0.0108271372,
0.9480910897,
0.0584396161,
0.3203008175,
-0.8933736086,
-0.5771704912,
0.0704550222,
0.0451706164,
0.0604417585,
-0.4185986817,
0.1636318117,
-0.4200609624,
0.3270106018,
0.0842854306,
0.3963801861,
-0.0854979381,
0.3633293211,
-0.1343482733,
-0.0442762151,
0.441470921,
0.5632650256,
-0.2217649817,
0.1430760622,
0.1113950908,
-0.2787262797,
0.1388650537,
-0.168753162,
-0.4399797022,
0.0700393543,
0.3651306033,
0.811298728,
0.5088056922,
-0.5554435253,
0.4157983661,
-0.3219697773,
-0.2162488848,
-0.3309839666,
0.2564747334,
0.3428449631,
0.2910860181,
0.3929058909,
-0.0045379032,
0.0563811548,
-0.5376793742,
-0.0113302041,
0.4012356997,
-0.1421499699,
-0.4539003074,
0.7727685571,
0.1874163747,
-0.6506124735,
0.5559576154,
0.1768539697,
-0.3100164533,
0.5045930743,
0.4615184963,
0.6533517838,
-0.4996994138,
0.6489186883,
0.2761453092,
0.2566786706,
-0.0137712127,
0.0872210264,
0.2461776882,
-0.5019847751,
-0.5926100612,
-0.6778583527,
-0.8495048881,
0.3357155621,
-0.6411400437,
0.2980158627,
-0.6267043948,
-0.3291319311,
0.2097055018,
0.0947356448,
-0.9140696526,
0.0937288329,
0.4367822707,
0.6244882345,
-1.0673952103,
0.5936495066,
0.8765059114,
-0.3630953729,
-0.7565845251,
0.4942215681,
0.3060806096,
-0.5884098411,
0.6524739861,
0.2910344303,
0.070787549,
-0.0968818069,
-0.6757912636,
-0.6847433448,
0.7371845841,
0.8195412159,
-0.4255447388,
-0.0169419833,
0.5131191015,
0.8172184229,
-0.5921818614,
0.0929976627,
0.5677236319,
0.5799850821,
0.2073536068,
-0.6675312519,
-0.1663046032,
-0.1344995201,
0.2230768502,
-0.2354582101,
-0.6044428945,
0.7835118175,
-0.1226401255,
0.0760135278,
-0.1633383781,
0.7596160769,
0.6861755848,
0.2440075874,
0.4774884284,
-0.0499193706,
0.8102106452,
0.1178958714,
1.2311973572,
-0.1523540467,
-0.0017216047,
1.1675817966,
-0.6146698594,
0.6601573825,
0.7312535644,
-0.2888559103,
0.7250130177,
0.6439496875,
0.0501666442,
0.2462117225,
0.1269167066,
-0.4471979737,
-0.385456115,
-0.3584421277,
0.0183540955,
0.4626649916,
0.4034930766,
-0.3825590611,
0.1868492961,
0.2016723156,
0.2527670264,
0.1466052979,
-0.0252096504,
0.4457440078,
0.3185067773,
-0.8028437495,
-0.2499462515,
-0.0139554366,
0.7094512582,
-0.508184135,
0.2199327946,
-0.4232046008,
-0.1668414623,
-0.1060759053,
-0.7460305095,
0.0821797177,
0.0750033259,
-0.1464845091,
-0.5731655359,
0.7557945848,
-0.3343041241,
-0.5554669499,
0.2663325071,
0.8389575481,
0.2723381817,
-0.1129322052,
-0.4128519297,
-0.018593533,
-0.0986536816,
-0.5347593427,
0.6436616182,
0.4513349235,
0.2468060851,
0.7511859536,
0.5209530592,
0.1135361865,
-0.1212845594,
0.2991487086,
0.8104350567,
-0.5547217727,
-0.2797667682,
-1.0624214411,
0.6155269742,
-0.0508341044,
-0.1773649752,
1.0130596161,
0.2424494624,
0.384844631,
-0.2282326221,
0.6531974077,
0.0455053598,
0.2181117982,
-0.1462283134,
0.4360462725,
-0.1573515087,
0.5520242453,
-0.5442276001,
-0.945502758,
-0.2963516414,
0.7621970177,
-0.6725773215,
0.3478062153,
0.3776459694,
0.4269166589,
0.3351787031,
-0.0690396354,
0.4408697188,
0.0064012106,
0.4318739176,
0.2356985956,
0.7979457974,
0.1297586262,
-0.0842092559,
-0.3709948957,
-0.2295902967,
-0.1479967237,
-0.9838241339,
-1.3781427145,
-0.4166249633,
-0.3958638906,
-0.3307960331,
-0.183026433,
0.9928041101,
0.5536914468,
-0.4806531072,
-0.2067504078,
0.303360492,
-0.214050293,
0.1512131244,
-0.2841718197,
-0.1520677805,
-0.0707083941,
-1.00048244,
0.0224886946,
0.4396260977,
0.0088639911,
-0.9354875684,
-0.0280767493,
-0.1932818592,
0.5162990689,
0.7148174644,
-0.0474049151,
-0.7860280275,
-0.4994888902,
0.3514702916,
-0.1113690585,
0.0730618685,
0.8813122511,
-1.0483087301,
0.2670621872,
0.2298772633,
0.2658553421,
0.2368354052,
0.3043163717,
0.7502965331,
-1.1199190617,
0.1355846822,
0.2686853707,
0.313203007,
0.5572103858,
-0.6783847213,
0.4057804942,
0.1823288202,
-0.4970257282,
-0.6828088164,
0.246381402,
-0.8242759109,
-0.0761439204,
1.4793264866,
-0.2371126264,
-0.232463032,
-0.1534846872,
-0.2192414552,
-0.3257708848,
-0.5658367872,
0.8493353724,
0.9475851655,
-0.5591376424,
-0.4984359741,
-0.7833165526,
0.2578920424,
0.3282068372,
-1.0389746428,
0.0682790279,
0.7986618876,
0.1633448601,
0.1075737551,
0.8634486794,
0.1876732111,
-0.0987885073,
-0.1701943725,
-0.1390732229,
0.2599098384,
-0.1971055716,
-0.4711105824,
0.0552035347,
0.1258154809,
0.4511715472
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10805v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10805v1
|
Generative Cross-Modal Retrieval: Memorizing Images in Multimodal Language Models for Retrieval and Beyond
| 2024-02-16T16:31:46 | 2024-02-16T16:31:46 |
Yongqi Li, Wenjie Wang, Leigang Qu, Liqiang Nie, Wenjie Li, Tat-Seng Chua
|
cs.MM
|
cs.MM, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.IR
|
The recent advancements in generative language models have demonstrated their
ability to memorize knowledge from documents and recall knowledge to respond to
user queries effectively. Building upon this capability, we propose to enable
multimodal large language models (MLLMs) to memorize and recall images within
their parameters. Given a user query for visual content, the MLLM is
anticipated to "recall" the relevant image from its parameters as the response.
Achieving this target presents notable challenges, including inbuilt visual
memory and visual recall schemes within MLLMs. To address these challenges, we
introduce a generative cross-modal retrieval framework, which assigns unique
identifier strings to represent images and involves two training steps:
learning to memorize and learning to retrieve. The first step focuses on
training the MLLM to memorize the association between images and their
respective identifiers. The latter step teaches the MLLM to generate the
corresponding identifier of the target image, given the textual query input. By
memorizing images in MLLMs, we introduce a new paradigm to cross-modal
retrieval, distinct from previous discriminative approaches. The experiments
demonstrate that the generative paradigm performs effectively and efficiently
even with large-scale image candidate sets.
|
[
-0.2600579858,
-0.791480124,
0.4375997186,
0.0366573557,
-0.3287148476,
0.0032494145,
-0.1215394512,
-0.2603265643,
-0.0215432215,
0.4772745371,
-0.2538905144,
-0.3459689021,
-0.4292968214,
-0.1331936121,
-0.5047262311,
0.7321310043,
0.0183744989,
0.2814366817,
-0.426827997,
-0.3462080956,
-0.4690508842,
-0.5220969319,
-0.7562565207,
-0.1023927927,
0.8221361637,
-0.100833647,
0.545604229,
0.496828109,
0.3799603283,
0.3194562495,
0.0961234793,
0.1147708148,
-0.5360052586,
0.3833775222,
-0.3548888862,
-0.6837764978,
0.1583511382,
-0.3129347861,
0.7538591027,
0.4900405705,
-0.0138715664,
-0.1710704416,
-0.3287452161,
0.6356179118,
-0.9488622546,
0.2299534529,
-1.0058240891,
0.3280303478,
-0.123965323,
-0.7598782182,
-0.6131979823,
0.0702850372,
-0.0205155518,
-0.6907773614,
0.3159893453,
0.1496594101,
0.5629171133,
-0.1092239693,
-0.5924813747,
-0.4397370815,
-0.72318995,
0.6945419908,
-0.1435812414,
0.8716911077,
0.7334497571,
0.4427609146,
0.3002112508,
-0.9237425327,
-0.4634208381,
-0.2661672533,
0.0129526723,
0.1400437355,
-0.0136912568,
-0.2035780251,
0.3576633036,
0.4651026428,
-0.6421860456,
-0.2499223799,
-0.3715669811,
-0.3857236803,
0.3330690563,
0.2803629935,
0.4291290939,
0.0154456282,
-0.5843951106,
-0.2245790213,
-0.8331407309,
-0.2548176944,
-0.1433134973,
0.1715504378,
0.1677938849,
0.5916942954,
0.0698214248,
0.5258257985,
0.0241728574,
-0.3562191725,
0.2642870843,
-0.4629954994,
-0.2026983798,
-0.2865003049,
0.5573465228,
0.3017213345,
0.0086870799,
-0.2440746874,
-0.5547730327,
-0.1788035631,
0.283162266,
-0.6639609933,
-0.2584160566,
-0.4378879368,
-0.8233502507,
0.1916836649,
-0.1433185935,
-0.7113473415,
-0.2935650945,
-0.3103904426,
0.8074733615,
-0.6429214478,
-0.1299284846,
-0.2737286389,
-0.222568363,
0.1844399422,
0.4982915521,
-1.0852690935,
-0.0164489262,
0.2485432327,
0.5461389422,
0.1479599029,
-0.5612996817,
-0.6202262044,
0.5476748347,
-0.2459242493,
0.5147577524,
-0.9142578244,
-0.5691786408,
0.1697996706,
0.108046487,
-0.2294740975,
-0.5929252505,
0.0484677553,
-0.9002880454,
0.3068324625,
-0.5074920058,
-0.4097244143,
-0.4574671984,
0.4695722163,
-1.0036407709,
0.8975892067,
0.048577331,
-0.6966270804,
0.2181811333,
-0.1181704551,
-0.6197652817,
-0.0733070821,
-0.3397671878,
-0.423635602,
0.1669560969,
0.1934203058,
0.4560007751,
-0.5069595575,
-0.0761272684,
-0.2853043973,
-0.1435188949,
0.1293916106,
-0.6092365384,
0.4686076045,
0.2130692452,
-0.0034063268,
0.1279680729,
-0.5343458056,
-0.0554939918,
0.3511093855,
-0.616338253,
-0.6081668139,
-0.10695301,
0.4436992407,
0.3750509024,
0.1124997362,
-0.3487468064,
-0.0595783815,
0.2945761681,
0.2838383019,
0.4494291544,
-0.0369613469,
0.4859392047,
-0.3608951569,
0.4351225495,
0.1752435565,
0.1416532099,
-0.7685719728,
-0.1631038189,
-0.6707184911,
-0.3872303367,
0.0938724056,
0.4071571231,
-1.3114254475,
-0.0327295102,
-0.1364288777,
-0.2758562565,
-0.2619176507,
0.3703866005,
0.7063484192,
0.2374666184,
0.4648608267,
-0.5158275366,
-0.5011322498,
-0.821839571,
0.0992033035,
-0.0507428981,
0.0529764295,
0.5621830225,
0.6261629462,
-0.1604420692,
0.5328428745,
-0.2489286065,
-0.5197324157,
-0.052446235,
0.3439227641,
-0.5843669772,
0.3280293643,
0.6426511407,
-1.3641555309,
-0.4743391275,
0.1505562663,
-0.789521277,
0.4614729881,
-0.2479632497,
-0.0276717767,
0.3860586882,
0.8229579329,
-0.8525445461,
0.2830817103,
0.2574751675,
-0.212156713,
0.2966222763,
-0.3837406635,
0.2763455808,
-0.9599739313,
0.3036891818,
-0.1682898253,
-0.3228645027,
-0.3026894331,
0.0810728967,
0.2325604111,
-0.1387244165,
-0.3465306163,
0.5184758902,
-0.9284482598,
-0.1673317105,
-0.0907634646,
-0.2123662829,
0.0908221602,
0.5528008342,
0.1795861721,
0.79658252,
0.6856881976,
-0.3229731619,
0.4026305974,
0.168424055,
-0.3337631822,
0.8234199882,
-0.2788599432,
0.1917358339,
-0.5669332147,
0.3233655393,
-0.8254541159,
0.0769455433,
-0.0578747131,
-0.0498609208,
0.5543346405,
-0.1326395571,
-0.616579771,
-0.1289486736,
-0.0249106847,
0.7468309999,
0.3533655107,
-0.5251767635,
1.0800014734,
0.3429853618,
-0.0845426619,
-0.6080380678,
-0.4015693367,
0.0679117665,
-0.0410272181,
-0.1617583781,
0.286716342,
-0.0130466055,
0.2099058926,
0.1391863823,
0.0842033252,
-0.0898945853,
-0.1621643901,
0.1288205385,
0.1687260419,
-0.1394843906,
0.4762165546,
-0.3633117676,
0.0524137393,
-0.1761389077,
-0.2530616224,
0.677354157,
0.0125477631,
-0.6475909352,
-0.0014333446,
0.872792244,
0.8345650434,
-0.7530160546,
0.3911201656,
0.9344770908,
-0.3605984449,
-0.0454794951,
-0.6750251055,
-0.1178829595,
-0.3885912299,
0.6970425248,
-0.7177977562,
-0.7529771924,
0.5056285858,
0.0909034386,
-0.2525669336,
0.0677850097,
0.8550861478,
-0.2032137513,
1.0198825598,
0.7279838324,
-0.0015897811,
0.7156323791,
-0.2643681765,
-0.0842576176,
-0.8474240303,
-0.7233883142,
-0.1408745944,
-0.1986240149,
-0.0203909762,
-0.8177597523,
0.3666871786,
0.0937540233,
0.0359225832,
0.127041176,
0.0121234972,
0.5654230118,
0.8035761714,
0.2941663563,
0.4215973914,
0.1839559674,
-0.4418816268,
0.1084339544,
-0.5889232755,
0.0070105218,
1.0058941841,
0.0830690861,
1.2158001661,
-0.0053488282,
0.4559358954,
-0.0131411348,
0.1835967004,
-0.7592931986,
0.6470146775,
-0.2031949461,
-0.7337802649,
-0.0887238383,
-0.3480861187,
-0.9634791613,
0.5073708296,
-0.3373784125,
-0.3445259333,
0.2317148745,
0.2860820591,
-0.1345905662,
0.4478369951,
-0.3962896466,
0.8742147684,
-0.5180723071,
-0.3657063544,
-0.5013155937,
-0.8676939607,
0.2114024907,
-0.0629843399,
-0.1739766896,
0.0909633264,
-0.1583224386,
0.2235259116,
0.2103369534,
0.9252272844,
-0.0540299155,
-0.0386339389,
-0.0181642622,
0.1733893454,
0.1600268185,
-0.2644971311,
0.1512723565,
-0.2447810322,
-0.0147944922,
-0.2322026342,
-0.7301460505,
0.638313055,
-0.355787456,
-0.4843379855,
-0.1052304655,
-0.9372566342,
-0.0512172915,
0.2655610442,
0.1715001911,
0.4887457788,
-0.5003414154,
0.4621675611,
0.9625559449,
-0.2182905525,
0.5680949092,
0.4105443954,
-0.5014365911,
-0.5483335257,
1.1187057495,
0.1097761318,
0.4123026729,
0.8828657269,
-0.2816891372,
-0.4129882753,
-0.3776524961,
-0.3563196361,
0.1449393332,
-1.0720643997,
-0.2172758132,
-0.6189879179,
-0.0133062033,
-0.1435342431,
0.0230667274,
-0.2304085046,
-0.2959204316,
-0.2605056465,
0.3196126223,
0.0638079047,
0.4574843645,
0.0854827315,
-0.2518668473,
-0.9087734818,
0.6024674773,
0.6527813673,
0.337528497,
0.2471144944,
-0.1518726349,
-0.225547567,
-0.1598273963,
-0.3718052804,
-0.6854968667,
0.4090996385,
0.4359140694,
0.8209282756,
0.4047366381,
-0.2694379389,
0.6082095504,
-0.5740548968,
0.3840779364,
0.4830009341,
-0.7242765427,
0.5014408231,
-0.1615178138,
0.4241634905,
0.2675514221,
0.6614293456,
-0.7295520306,
-0.0164293703,
-0.1706757993,
-0.7468216419,
0.3310494423,
-0.1148142889,
0.3448126614,
-0.1554230452,
-0.0805796981,
0.2723235488,
0.236757651,
-0.7603827715,
0.0475230515,
-0.3734831214,
-0.2158814669,
-0.1166930497,
-0.3310152888,
-0.5537363291,
-0.2795842886,
0.4220194221,
-0.3133128583,
0.3515248597,
0.1333608031,
-0.6047825813,
-0.0366852693,
0.2260696739,
0.5777039528,
0.657830596,
0.0446073227,
0.4143088758,
-0.0267792307,
-0.2600648999,
0.110575445,
0.1161435917,
-0.2580011785,
0.0004117532,
0.2357927412,
1.0719137192,
0.2644979358,
-0.882820785,
0.5731668472,
0.0281873047,
-0.0522056893,
-0.2660588026,
-0.3206025362,
0.2083684802,
0.4091047943,
0.4731892645,
0.0332253091,
0.1135830432,
-0.9363865852,
0.2865996063,
0.8261627555,
-0.3075418174,
-0.3187541664,
0.6764954329,
0.0573495217,
-0.2452950627,
0.6765852571,
0.1008890495,
-0.478482455,
0.4198234677,
0.9378898144,
0.7405821681,
-0.1967426986,
0.1838530898,
0.1849936694,
0.111774601,
-0.1524110138,
0.4340316355,
-0.3809881806,
-0.5819965601,
0.0559495725,
-0.4588440061,
0.0291700531,
-0.0725378469,
-0.5754083991,
-0.0224965066,
-0.5681071877,
-0.1430433244,
-0.0453247949,
-0.5387934446,
-0.683645308,
0.3057767749,
0.4513853192,
0.8294299841,
-0.7246491313,
1.0197925568,
0.7242380977,
-0.8286479712,
-0.4730226398,
-0.1575707644,
0.0393729173,
-0.9799925685,
1.0040953159,
0.1396537125,
0.0056262091,
-0.0585579872,
-0.3251752257,
-0.7675580382,
1.3191286325,
0.2523176968,
-0.378302902,
-0.201084286,
-0.0583378337,
0.4523517191,
-0.4474858642,
0.2392557263,
0.1336434036,
0.2538997531,
0.3969011903,
-1.0161005259,
0.2001465559,
-0.4284225702,
0.5985247493,
0.3001953065,
-0.5553534627,
1.0692601204,
-0.5229291916,
-0.3988701701,
0.2494192272,
0.4326223731,
0.0479511321,
0.3876966834,
0.5728751421,
0.845630765,
0.4456819594,
0.0395965092,
1.1719460487,
0.0182738509,
0.2703852355,
0.8883098364,
-0.1885873973,
1.0087013245,
0.7369049191,
0.1711841375,
0.2029802054,
0.2692099512,
-0.1868792027,
0.8341258168,
-0.2262101471,
-0.5465651155,
-0.527576685,
-0.2749486566,
-0.3971283138,
0.4736705422,
0.4290003479,
-0.8343734145,
-0.4141593874,
0.4961124659,
-0.398856163,
0.0458611585,
-0.3574174345,
0.9229322076,
0.1352595538,
-0.5698780417,
0.6665528417,
-0.3076408207,
0.3959292173,
-0.6679539084,
-0.2857930362,
-0.0818931535,
0.1981578022,
0.0548844822,
-0.6038740277,
0.1083334386,
-0.6130982637,
-0.458787024,
-0.2636760175,
0.6298519373,
-1.0868862867,
-0.4489472508,
0.4051350653,
0.3498302698,
-0.1893787384,
0.0759092122,
-0.7209497094,
0.1812957525,
-0.1473289579,
-0.1193428189,
0.3797123134,
0.3162325323,
-0.26229164,
0.9268261194,
0.5867375731,
-0.2775630951,
0.3328070939,
0.2883866429,
0.9566681385,
-0.7027617693,
-0.2162781805,
-0.490617007,
0.3152607977,
0.1515367329,
-0.0336580724,
0.5343390107,
0.6681246758,
1.0024700165,
-0.4834529161,
0.7233441472,
-0.2053942084,
0.0747367889,
-0.8365780115,
0.5490115881,
-0.8922658563,
-0.0129574193,
0.0606480204,
-0.743709743,
-0.3474283218,
0.451672554,
-0.0408256426,
0.2087300718,
0.7306566238,
1.1270531416,
-0.2989688516,
-0.176631093,
0.5175827146,
-0.0055681909,
0.1765017062,
0.8075140715,
1.0756618977,
-0.408246845,
0.8138203621,
-0.1819740683,
0.2218784243,
-0.2862989604,
-0.5245748758,
-0.9587798715,
-0.9734287858,
0.0572929382,
-0.0929558128,
0.2015406787,
0.7509829402,
0.797149241,
-0.5958580971,
-0.0987025127,
0.3052945137,
0.0257006176,
-0.2622104883,
-0.172075212,
0.1672183871,
-0.4049508274,
-0.8145952821,
0.2356293648,
0.6151708961,
0.3275413513,
-0.4209903181,
-0.1310759187,
-0.5896680951,
-0.297375083,
0.893060565,
0.5412889719,
-0.9452483654,
-0.1111543402,
0.0115781585,
-0.4911330342,
0.1506426632,
1.1982014179,
-0.7989667654,
0.6398667693,
0.6580996513,
0.7952596545,
0.8097316623,
-0.2514974177,
0.5384982228,
-0.5503890514,
0.1821677685,
0.2692684233,
0.4411858916,
0.5573526621,
-0.0381002687,
0.1579321474,
0.3054649234,
-0.1769353002,
-0.4794960022,
0.4426101446,
-0.9841333032,
-0.4901847839,
0.885640502,
-0.1878482401,
0.0146999545,
-0.0688748136,
-0.3692995012,
0.0260944217,
-0.0115323467,
0.7800062299,
0.4463016093,
0.2795017064,
-0.7976207733,
-0.2841587663,
0.2689627707,
0.6694173217,
-0.607821703,
-0.092740044,
0.7739053965,
0.3493772447,
0.2776625454,
0.7541182041,
-0.3388661742,
0.4791755974,
0.2112297714,
0.031845659,
-0.0749403164,
-0.5683687925,
-0.0959777385,
0.4440882206,
-0.1756233722,
-0.1509454548
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.