id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10171v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10171v1
|
Data Engineering for Scaling Language Models to 128K Context
| 2024-02-15T18:19:16 | 2024-02-15T18:19:16 |
Yao Fu, Rameswar Panda, Xinyao Niu, Xiang Yue, Hannaneh Hajishirzi, Yoon Kim, Hao Peng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We study the continual pretraining recipe for scaling language models'
context lengths to 128K, with a focus on data engineering. We hypothesize that
long context modeling, in particular \textit{the ability to utilize information
at arbitrary input locations}, is a capability that is mostly already acquired
through large-scale pretraining, and that this capability can be readily
extended to contexts substantially longer than seen during training~(e.g., 4K
to 128K) through lightweight continual pretraining on appropriate data mixture.
We investigate the \textit{quantity} and \textit{quality} of the data for
continual pretraining: (1) for quantity, we show that 500 million to 5 billion
tokens are enough to enable the model to retrieve information anywhere within
the 128K context; (2) for quality, our results equally emphasize \textit{domain
balance} and \textit{length upsampling}. Concretely, we find that naively
upsampling longer data on certain domains like books, a common practice of
existing work, gives suboptimal performance, and that a balanced domain mixture
is important. We demonstrate that continual pretraining of the full model on
1B-5B tokens of such data is an effective and affordable strategy for scaling
the context length of language models to 128K. Our recipe outperforms strong
open-source long-context models and closes the gap to frontier models like
GPT-4 128K.
|
[
-0.3581064045,
-0.5829442739,
0.5096409917,
0.3977585435,
-0.3270449936,
-0.078943111,
-0.4650396705,
-0.5099726319,
0.0930511802,
0.6057033539,
-0.3995565772,
-0.1463074684,
-0.5210577846,
-0.1266079247,
-0.4206038415,
0.9747773409,
-0.1735668778,
-0.0868064463,
-0.1759190112,
-0.1035074145,
-0.7834727168,
-0.6594157219,
-0.5265451074,
-0.0582924001,
0.4841659069,
0.4980625808,
0.8253732324,
0.928976059,
0.1465570778,
0.2419909388,
0.0812382177,
-0.1930676699,
-0.9110748768,
0.1879748404,
-0.0702927038,
-0.213220343,
-0.7027769685,
0.1438684314,
1.0135865211,
1.1707010269,
-0.0307391137,
0.1735486835,
0.3277440965,
0.8411697745,
-0.4367254078,
0.0222982354,
-0.6294347048,
-0.2431725413,
-0.4270146191,
-0.0700953007,
-0.4141272008,
0.2442229837,
0.264962256,
-0.6899899244,
0.0701365024,
0.2022771686,
0.9208922982,
-0.0087820124,
-0.437345922,
-0.1774265319,
-0.8461509943,
1.0745817423,
-0.5721056461,
0.6391105056,
0.5477956533,
0.1613979638,
-0.0626526773,
-0.7976363301,
-0.395904243,
-0.3667134345,
0.0720802322,
-0.1638443321,
0.159762606,
0.2175503373,
0.2934879959,
0.4284034371,
-0.5224795341,
0.0485162959,
-0.3694224656,
-0.1203886941,
0.5326039195,
0.1465214938,
0.27314502,
0.2698024809,
-0.3095340729,
-0.1438429207,
-0.7592494488,
-0.1403284371,
0.2713454068,
0.2235024124,
0.0690960959,
0.4655461013,
-0.2582679391,
0.8630170822,
-0.1779298335,
0.0615454726,
0.0772215277,
-0.7824218273,
-0.3067933917,
-0.1090827733,
0.419790566,
0.1899229288,
0.2339716107,
-0.5102584958,
-0.372730583,
-0.2127708644,
0.6132441759,
-1.0092544556,
-0.122150816,
0.1529713869,
-0.2792128325,
0.1572218388,
-0.0814396068,
-0.6809182763,
0.1284121424,
-0.8200621009,
0.53207618,
-0.5058683157,
-0.4058588147,
0.4593628943,
0.0406526886,
0.09260948,
0.003853519,
-1.0888901949,
0.3996710181,
0.7460757494,
0.9609289169,
-0.227418676,
-0.5415935516,
-0.2708868384,
0.0570516549,
-0.6112738252,
0.4202638268,
-0.5342518687,
-0.4649657607,
-0.2658959925,
0.0247475747,
-0.1062888354,
-0.4078233838,
0.2511290908,
-0.6708384752,
-0.0584987961,
-0.2236291468,
-0.8004922271,
0.2235855013,
0.06416215,
-0.7627685666,
1.0198918581,
0.4701861441,
-0.5654656291,
0.6123940349,
-0.6361145377,
-0.3852094412,
0.1936978251,
-0.0422216542,
-0.2199354172,
0.1156319976,
-0.0347694866,
0.2981025279,
-0.2952198684,
0.5937893987,
-0.4132180214,
-0.3675794601,
-0.0502619781,
-0.4880898595,
0.6492131352,
0.3733536303,
-0.2379147559,
0.0716329068,
-0.7404156327,
0.110254474,
-0.0068145776,
-0.4418812394,
-0.5273100734,
-0.1653200537,
0.1710531414,
0.0502696522,
0.3369494379,
-0.5934358835,
0.222297892,
-0.4593700469,
0.3829552233,
0.6940847635,
-0.2383304983,
0.6745598912,
-0.280390799,
0.5601646304,
-0.0337995179,
0.1535984129,
-0.2086294293,
-0.1319201887,
-0.7219111323,
-0.2028146237,
0.6519441605,
0.1516697705,
-0.5754054785,
0.6689034104,
-0.7945740819,
-0.3565749228,
-0.3023633957,
0.1827160865,
0.0352351516,
0.6079183817,
0.52298069,
-0.4855005443,
-0.6007073522,
-0.844342649,
-0.1104880273,
0.1185012609,
-0.3014266789,
0.1926402152,
0.3634411097,
-0.4566645026,
1.3780884743,
-0.2989450097,
0.1126586497,
-0.3162017167,
0.0938408673,
0.2538735569,
0.7802515626,
0.6884769201,
-0.8168926835,
-0.4456219971,
-0.1046984717,
-0.5437170267,
0.075963147,
-0.1385689378,
-0.440351516,
-0.0216730963,
0.4984823465,
-0.4831944406,
0.2269330472,
0.6618813872,
-0.3331543207,
0.6511125565,
-0.2309687585,
0.1334817559,
-1.253736496,
0.158857882,
-0.0348324515,
-0.3656933308,
-0.7200683951,
0.0017218214,
0.2156617492,
-0.344768405,
-0.1879704893,
0.6843205094,
-0.476103574,
0.1180072501,
-0.4327719808,
-0.1930067837,
-0.0205880646,
0.3195853829,
0.0766635612,
0.7631602883,
0.6979863048,
-0.6577403545,
0.2370197773,
-0.2308320701,
-0.6011708379,
0.4349338412,
-0.6752811074,
0.0656161234,
0.1030866206,
0.3266357183,
-0.9021527767,
-0.2064905912,
-0.2358384281,
-0.2393122017,
0.4197319448,
-0.3360369802,
-0.580845952,
-0.3123938739,
-0.1134671494,
0.6763116121,
0.425655812,
-0.5914220214,
0.5126431584,
0.5624084473,
-0.5496420264,
-0.452590555,
-0.4471490383,
0.3033629358,
-0.292812705,
-0.8995965123,
0.4823841751,
-0.3062753379,
0.0303186271,
0.0195302088,
-0.3429231644,
-0.2990482152,
0.1050071493,
0.017435696,
0.2141698599,
-0.4244001508,
0.1364687532,
-0.0283311494,
-0.1578300893,
0.0239718128,
-0.7158634663,
0.6184915304,
-0.1180203184,
-0.1257566065,
-0.1210248172,
0.4001087248,
0.5885457397,
0.1027381942,
0.8858636618,
0.1570335478,
-0.4313227534,
-0.0822138339,
-0.449488461,
-0.172910735,
-0.5053662658,
0.5221431255,
-0.4559859633,
-1.0020378828,
0.3932332993,
-0.1919554621,
0.2358196229,
0.4759238362,
0.2162844241,
0.0405616574,
0.9194924831,
1.0076780319,
-0.5448409319,
0.7042742968,
-0.2075721622,
0.1154471785,
-0.6375838518,
0.2487752587,
-0.4541799128,
-0.316724062,
-0.2059122622,
-0.2940026224,
0.1237970069,
0.2732572854,
-0.2879931927,
0.3308871388,
-0.1165683866,
0.7789989114,
0.2940503359,
-0.0410698839,
-0.0483090617,
0.0529657826,
0.1268818825,
-0.0229101423,
-0.7812104225,
-0.3418555856,
1.2686066628,
0.4802632034,
0.7998206019,
-0.1971910298,
0.506483674,
-0.0101863053,
0.4002311826,
-0.6381363273,
0.2948922217,
-0.0953678861,
-0.7104336023,
-0.6814431548,
-0.7492257357,
-1.0093616247,
-0.0227607023,
0.1935588717,
-0.4809395075,
0.1548229903,
0.3750342429,
-0.1784616262,
0.1347960979,
-0.7920973301,
1.1375035048,
-0.3209633231,
-0.2266806513,
-0.1882128417,
-0.6937564611,
0.158424899,
-0.4659519494,
0.2079190761,
0.0458459705,
0.1444655806,
0.9923682213,
-0.5908320546,
0.6715549827,
-0.2355697155,
-0.1682548821,
0.1358677745,
0.0546499118,
0.3262585104,
0.0691451207,
0.0013339736,
0.1546727419,
0.1300791651,
-0.8680333495,
-0.5296568871,
0.602853775,
-0.6708805561,
-0.3504544199,
0.0196842086,
-0.5638919473,
-0.6075748205,
0.3776860535,
0.2833938301,
0.6257993579,
-0.0957462192,
0.7750829458,
0.5514168143,
0.0976005867,
0.1866754442,
0.4233372509,
-0.0841792822,
-0.1921323836,
1.0448306799,
0.3848651052,
0.4679586589,
0.1431502998,
0.1398868263,
-0.4022953212,
-0.6022874713,
-0.5254757404,
0.0402238332,
-0.56248492,
-0.0499456152,
-0.5637506247,
-0.3088193238,
-0.4800489247,
-0.1345536113,
-0.6912677884,
-0.2488265932,
-0.0699726567,
-0.1491725147,
0.1625123769,
0.4967459738,
-0.0366730876,
0.587205112,
-0.7914690375,
0.1528968364,
0.2279991806,
0.7200521231,
0.1660985351,
-0.8836503625,
-0.802646637,
0.288579613,
-0.0504256636,
-0.4616044462,
0.2204923183,
0.1824477017,
0.3910009265,
0.258602351,
-0.1346919388,
0.9308665991,
-0.6535226107,
0.9034875631,
0.0515659824,
-0.9033159018,
0.3336496055,
-0.2679269016,
0.368277967,
0.8127832413,
0.6925907731,
-0.7531707287,
-0.2529631257,
-0.6305750608,
-1.1628875732,
0.6441057324,
0.0683834702,
0.5196366906,
0.0128326751,
0.5467916727,
0.252525866,
0.0701440126,
-0.6690273881,
0.0560156778,
-0.3282467425,
-0.3288971782,
-0.343221426,
-0.4104708135,
-0.036676921,
-0.3884049952,
0.6684336066,
-0.1552981138,
-0.0391604491,
-0.2585848272,
-0.3945361972,
0.1577363759,
0.1545716077,
0.47895509,
1.1644517183,
-0.1958400905,
0.0134462966,
0.0074801641,
-0.6622390747,
0.1224047169,
0.0683939755,
0.2118947357,
-0.2345880419,
0.3446705639,
0.8791411519,
0.2879210114,
-0.5891795754,
0.3801533282,
-0.0886136144,
-0.1032758504,
-0.0776873678,
0.0996763334,
0.0403153077,
-0.112470679,
0.3643215895,
-0.2377613485,
-0.1390191019,
-0.3886153996,
0.5125418901,
0.1313302815,
-0.304220289,
-0.4465896189,
0.5124406219,
0.1695805043,
0.1387144476,
0.9206714034,
0.0708056167,
-0.1444922388,
0.6431233883,
0.6840061545,
0.586961627,
-0.0954866782,
-0.1314928383,
0.2547983527,
0.2363043875,
-0.5480601788,
-0.0047072065,
-0.1480132937,
-0.796949029,
-0.5736308098,
-0.8809050322,
-0.3313147724,
0.3982003331,
-0.6212744117,
0.1070442051,
-0.240616709,
-0.0330207534,
-0.1293753684,
0.0431112163,
-0.7327641845,
0.468116194,
-0.0424918123,
0.9174610972,
-0.7940779924,
1.1182500124,
0.2723456621,
-0.1884561479,
-0.8674773574,
0.0804616064,
-0.186007902,
-0.5979908109,
0.6413627267,
0.2938950658,
0.0359590426,
0.1727552265,
-0.6579875946,
-0.9304282069,
0.8770420551,
0.3680231571,
-0.7982071042,
-0.0953617245,
0.2362431437,
0.5276924968,
-0.4983093143,
-0.2282836884,
0.752071023,
0.2407842726,
-0.0379073918,
-0.8320364356,
-0.0834627748,
-0.2528321743,
0.1329833567,
0.1651394516,
-0.2888498902,
0.7806968093,
0.2020486295,
-0.2784354985,
0.0428059511,
0.8595850468,
0.090037629,
0.0471559986,
0.7109196186,
0.6470794678,
0.7175205946,
0.1584950686,
1.1022372246,
-0.6027530432,
0.4629784226,
1.1876996756,
-0.2783215046,
0.6085413694,
0.2533141673,
-0.1501840353,
0.1661633998,
0.898111701,
0.3480300009,
0.477894336,
0.2008983791,
-0.1935542375,
-0.2699861825,
0.1518731564,
-0.4614318609,
0.0600842685,
0.3655261099,
-0.1551454216,
-0.0797051638,
0.1829251796,
-0.0297225695,
-0.4097420871,
-0.2336825132,
0.4790838957,
0.1846668869,
-0.6028009057,
0.663105309,
0.028821636,
0.6099103689,
-0.7623527646,
0.4136551917,
-0.4520095289,
-0.0694585592,
0.2830931246,
-0.7095047832,
0.3344689608,
-0.0156370848,
-0.2950718105,
-0.5238836408,
0.4747659564,
-0.541874826,
-0.3559795618,
0.2208444178,
0.1636906564,
0.1581810117,
-0.2405314893,
-0.5151416063,
0.0636843815,
-0.2262460142,
-0.4620174468,
0.6281574965,
0.7159054279,
-0.0295073036,
0.42241171,
0.522351563,
0.2377417088,
0.1794949174,
0.1026554033,
1.0030345917,
-0.7324990034,
-0.6925265193,
-0.8672918677,
0.3800772429,
-0.0665336847,
-0.3063421547,
0.4916397333,
0.8100518584,
0.9645772576,
0.0373790152,
0.6481967568,
0.0178146791,
0.2493191957,
-0.6437487006,
0.6397051215,
-0.6756414175,
0.0914351568,
-0.0483588763,
-1.0228368044,
-0.0985551551,
0.3030333519,
-0.2799023986,
0.2473424226,
0.555937171,
0.6011607051,
-0.426992327,
0.042323105,
0.3752426803,
0.1567890644,
0.4190619886,
0.436770469,
0.5745275617,
-0.10037034,
0.3996632397,
-0.0615823604,
-0.4954356551,
-0.1128000468,
-0.7576849461,
-0.5792820454,
-0.6614536047,
0.0102130575,
-0.1898879558,
-0.1329201013,
0.7265218496,
1.0819438696,
-0.5501769185,
-0.3796747327,
-0.0935290977,
-0.2998763621,
-0.0689645261,
-0.2144843936,
0.2138068229,
-0.7439925671,
-0.5299699903,
0.5407278538,
0.2751545608,
0.11759644,
-0.1693707108,
-0.1714689136,
0.1494285166,
0.2501405478,
0.6812155247,
0.3136102259,
-0.113106437,
-0.4117463529,
-0.0405890271,
-0.1699116677,
0.1046087369,
1.0020335913,
-0.5140640736,
0.5030410886,
0.3410672545,
1.0602091551,
0.5573638082,
0.0860028937,
0.8257946968,
-1.0481721163,
0.2147986889,
0.1875488758,
0.3526775539,
0.1256639063,
-0.2681834698,
0.3899815381,
0.2518275976,
-0.7343033552,
-0.7854869366,
0.2004470974,
-0.7730714679,
-0.3971067071,
1.0452166796,
-0.1189512238,
-0.2154670507,
-0.0766578838,
-0.0760887712,
0.076353766,
-0.0574195571,
0.6730899215,
1.1108605862,
-0.0382044837,
0.1561047286,
-0.7051845193,
0.5215157866,
0.5572664738,
-0.8028172851,
0.4625356793,
0.4249050021,
0.5104747415,
0.0318138152,
0.9359329343,
-0.0615287311,
0.0024524487,
0.1058211327,
-0.1998583972,
0.2335541099,
-0.7760507464,
-0.1481543779,
-0.0230143163,
0.1094394997,
0.0285258573
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10153v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10153v2
|
Knowledge-Infused LLM-Powered Conversational Health Agent: A Case Study for Diabetes Patients
| 2024-02-15T18:00:02 | 2024-02-28T19:40:13 |
Mahyar Abbasian, Zhongqi Yang, Elahe Khatibi, Pengfei Zhang, Nitish Nagesh, Iman Azimi, Ramesh Jain, Amir M. Rahmani
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Effective diabetes management is crucial for maintaining health in diabetic
patients. Large Language Models (LLMs) have opened new avenues for diabetes
management, facilitating their efficacy. However, current LLM-based approaches
are limited by their dependence on general sources and lack of integration with
domain-specific knowledge, leading to inaccurate responses. In this paper, we
propose a knowledge-infused LLM-powered conversational health agent (CHA) for
diabetic patients. We customize and leverage the open-source openCHA framework,
enhancing our CHA with external knowledge and analytical capabilities. This
integration involves two key components: 1) incorporating the American Diabetes
Association dietary guidelines and the Nutritionix information and 2) deploying
analytical tools that enable nutritional intake calculation and comparison with
the guidelines. We compare the proposed CHA with GPT4. Our evaluation includes
100 diabetes-related questions on daily meal choices and assessing the
potential risks associated with the suggested diet. Our findings show that the
proposed agent demonstrates superior performance in generating responses to
manage essential nutrients.
|
[
0.0095786154,
-0.8614682555,
0.8835132718,
0.0693918541,
-0.2174966037,
0.2053965926,
-0.2004112452,
-0.7012589574,
0.9148198962,
0.8820382357,
-0.0293691382,
-0.548451066,
-0.4296971858,
-0.0167111084,
0.0519994386,
0.8768706322,
-0.1217437238,
0.5223399401,
-0.573471427,
0.0661370829,
-0.5256338716,
-0.1380405128,
-0.7684211731,
-0.5507932305,
0.628495872,
0.6651261449,
0.7080324888,
0.2549907863,
0.6326912642,
0.2032365352,
0.164006725,
0.368848145,
-0.1178948134,
0.3112010062,
-0.2055137604,
-0.6712018251,
-0.9117627144,
-0.1113914102,
-0.0599183217,
0.5682548881,
-0.1526150554,
0.129061386,
0.0398397148,
0.5973407626,
-0.52137357,
0.3917190135,
-0.3563453555,
0.1104385033,
-0.1188570485,
-0.2902859449,
-0.1550028026,
-0.2816721201,
0.1435899734,
-0.7169612646,
-0.2239304781,
-0.0222525913,
0.5407051444,
0.3661317527,
-0.323002249,
-0.4803291857,
-0.8660750389,
0.1171910241,
-0.8434398174,
0.1685526073,
0.7637103796,
0.6304354668,
0.1056646928,
-0.6745359898,
-0.5070433617,
-0.3636742234,
-0.286955893,
0.5513569713,
-0.0735965297,
0.2300024033,
-0.2617681921,
0.2019081414,
-0.3810576797,
0.2212396115,
0.0266331844,
0.0314905122,
0.3901377916,
0.3634864688,
0.3579527438,
-0.3175508678,
-0.3317433,
0.402063638,
-0.432571739,
-0.1326964945,
-0.2257127762,
0.2818585038,
-0.3442591131,
0.7578978539,
0.0218268055,
0.5032847524,
0.1088317037,
-0.1894989908,
0.0199481193,
-0.5720695257,
-0.2969109118,
0.4008050561,
0.6432052851,
0.5565736294,
0.1451099664,
-0.3367980719,
-0.1705478579,
-0.4632845521,
0.430916369,
-0.8743854165,
-0.4790740907,
0.6658778191,
-0.0962961614,
-0.1163070798,
-0.1268918067,
-0.9716241956,
-0.9022136927,
-0.0033851925,
0.3182640374,
-0.5443919301,
-0.2311345637,
0.1906741709,
0.0356240496,
0.0822990537,
0.5713093877,
-0.9971836805,
0.3830598891,
0.4119232595,
0.9111844897,
0.0041407817,
0.472846508,
-0.7079896331,
0.5544142723,
-0.1071589291,
0.6821331978,
-0.5395525694,
-0.5137254596,
-0.0228545498,
-0.1327610314,
-0.057596907,
-0.625782311,
0.3617340624,
-0.5092535615,
-0.1052687913,
-0.4610974193,
-0.658842504,
0.1177757606,
0.2615611851,
-0.674405396,
0.4222726524,
0.3759706616,
-0.5549150705,
0.3192610145,
-0.8153446317,
-0.3773517311,
0.8438439965,
-0.2494753003,
-0.2322340608,
-0.1462839395,
0.2942496538,
0.3640293181,
-0.4205587506,
0.2707808316,
-0.2459643483,
0.2218508273,
0.1306253821,
0.0728960186,
0.3609151244,
0.1444298476,
-0.1611194164,
0.4369762242,
-0.6151422858,
0.0131906597,
0.291514039,
-0.0173761342,
-0.7886933684,
-0.1146939099,
-0.1929322034,
-0.2660754323,
0.4219268858,
-0.3508399427,
0.0433874689,
-0.3576544225,
0.4228232205,
0.6477712393,
0.2292737365,
0.3363027573,
-0.3275741339,
0.607522428,
-0.0585503615,
0.328370899,
-0.0009292687,
-0.716817975,
-0.5199743509,
-0.4031141102,
0.2230999619,
0.7622405887,
-0.6585232019,
0.8172261715,
-0.286385864,
-0.5607585311,
-0.5907670259,
0.0547238812,
0.0393934436,
0.9895867109,
0.6294350624,
-0.2251230478,
-0.1967726648,
-0.6327453852,
0.164300099,
-0.0992238075,
0.0027867202,
0.6553912163,
0.3977747262,
-0.4467065036,
1.1024036407,
-0.5405661464,
-0.2371037602,
-0.5760247111,
-0.4315598607,
-0.0613532439,
0.1760410219,
0.5913933516,
-0.6332098246,
-0.5315266848,
0.3564965129,
-0.8926073313,
-0.2515483797,
0.0427105129,
-0.0969159752,
-0.5104354024,
0.0879010484,
-0.7026381493,
0.4720955193,
0.4938326478,
-0.4799872637,
0.5606760979,
-0.1603583395,
-0.0157757401,
-1.4152460098,
0.2997687757,
0.129983753,
-0.5095948577,
-0.6915224195,
-0.3631376624,
0.2506454885,
-0.1267284155,
-0.4310698211,
1.0061661005,
-0.0150639778,
0.0768403262,
-0.3073415458,
0.1141051278,
0.0756581277,
0.0765792355,
-0.0027296627,
0.6827821136,
0.3901098669,
-0.7046354413,
0.6840416193,
0.4606864154,
-0.4375642538,
0.8345266581,
-0.8087109327,
0.004621271,
-0.0249334853,
0.1924244165,
-0.7820482254,
-0.4963443875,
0.6956428885,
-0.1841427684,
0.0441628546,
0.2739242911,
-0.3488597274,
-0.2152830958,
-0.0048778662,
0.1572643071,
0.2447361648,
-0.396604687,
0.5481097102,
0.5515984893,
-0.3806906939,
0.0671375766,
-0.5341181159,
0.2631247342,
-0.2138302475,
-0.5714996457,
0.3911103904,
-0.175334394,
-0.6144080758,
0.2269728482,
-0.1099278107,
-0.0101220384,
0.0080322959,
0.2494045645,
0.1245082915,
0.0267609674,
0.2347012013,
-0.1351232082,
0.0381536298,
-0.0308408886,
-0.1975895464,
0.5667101145,
0.1557395756,
-0.3426792622,
-0.6197364926,
0.3751137257,
0.5586821437,
-0.3930221796,
0.785179019,
0.4788760841,
-0.2741070688,
0.0884036273,
-0.366209656,
-0.3295958936,
-0.4303736687,
0.2466022372,
-0.0527661853,
-0.5725535154,
0.6446608305,
0.0118377516,
0.0144670391,
0.0594982244,
0.5735585093,
-0.0301789138,
0.6666787863,
0.4697690904,
-0.062482845,
0.5368132591,
0.0633011237,
-0.0574103221,
-0.8116746545,
-0.6769900322,
-0.2821932733,
-0.250898093,
-0.0140818143,
-0.3873064518,
0.7625576258,
-0.2647542953,
-0.2233972996,
0.1525862515,
-0.0341387652,
0.1016480848,
0.2918086052,
0.6801847816,
0.237799421,
-0.3166750968,
-0.2372529954,
0.2069887221,
-0.5260382295,
-0.3389433324,
0.8999319077,
0.3146967888,
1.0493235588,
0.2985889018,
0.4334016442,
0.4976784289,
0.4669603109,
-0.9934905171,
0.3947021961,
0.0294814818,
-0.2647669017,
-0.1679287702,
-0.7162489295,
-1.0128434896,
-0.0503353029,
-0.0071029654,
-0.8301375508,
-0.2357257009,
-0.0049616317,
-0.7158793807,
0.2309580445,
-0.9940153956,
0.7348508239,
-0.7196635008,
-0.4404534996,
0.0605135038,
-0.6235435605,
0.1677975655,
-0.1930321902,
0.0146712074,
-0.0719992369,
-0.1068981439,
0.5127067566,
-0.7508447766,
0.9937232137,
-0.191462338,
-0.3232749104,
0.061668396,
-0.1165245399,
0.5970315933,
0.4852084816,
-0.114478454,
-0.0191764534,
-0.1539419144,
-0.3450615108,
-0.8718672395,
0.7066050768,
-0.6982057095,
-0.8315354586,
-0.08223515,
-0.0774825886,
-0.7356317043,
0.2480920702,
-0.1702180207,
0.0163258258,
-0.3406433761,
-0.0237495843,
0.4040639997,
-0.2537637651,
0.0427158438,
0.7497051358,
-0.021154793,
-0.6986345053,
0.4597921371,
-0.2538887858,
0.3736351132,
0.5961956382,
0.5237027407,
-0.19387573,
-0.1872514039,
-0.3728877008,
0.2466418445,
-0.411849916,
-0.2766154408,
-0.513692379,
-0.360078603,
-0.5545433164,
-0.0516239069,
-0.2089920938,
0.1329830885,
-0.5967507362,
-0.2370855361,
0.5265843272,
0.6496795416,
0.1938857138,
0.3080597222,
-0.9334299564,
0.199165687,
0.4510970712,
0.2657022476,
0.0229965765,
-0.031019466,
-0.5039060712,
0.1298583597,
-0.2411357909,
-1.2314597368,
0.5193141103,
0.173222661,
0.6153595448,
0.5438606143,
-0.0955126584,
0.5150935054,
-0.4296736717,
0.8383094668,
0.4713479877,
-0.6216319203,
0.7241801023,
0.0152416416,
0.4607527554,
0.5954884291,
0.3537344635,
-0.6540927887,
-0.330509603,
-0.2228678763,
-0.5793840885,
0.2380810231,
0.0894568563,
0.0778085738,
0.0048879008,
0.3875697255,
0.1993972808,
0.2172595859,
-0.3055944443,
-0.0872156247,
-0.3878181875,
-0.3403039575,
-0.029744124,
-0.0765939727,
-0.1289361566,
-0.3304074407,
0.4259593487,
-0.2975520194,
0.1303143203,
0.3854016662,
0.137565136,
-0.2043699473,
0.2217864692,
0.3736901283,
0.5880574584,
-0.2424187958,
0.214384526,
-0.1094896793,
-0.7847585082,
-0.3192829192,
0.1502976269,
-0.0309265144,
-0.069765307,
0.1804997027,
0.7219640017,
0.3583905399,
-0.8000652194,
0.3003534377,
-0.1812894642,
-0.040984787,
-0.2471318394,
0.2370726019,
0.096379742,
0.2031213045,
0.0605795458,
-0.2015869617,
-0.0790521428,
-0.1776589006,
0.4157515466,
0.4864086807,
-0.6510006785,
-0.5110910535,
0.8090359569,
0.7195370793,
-0.2760690451,
0.3700191975,
-0.0027489015,
-0.2454547286,
0.5305150151,
0.59698385,
0.74396348,
-0.4755811095,
0.5644215941,
0.1247110218,
0.1563530862,
0.3114485443,
0.1308400333,
-0.0737010762,
-0.7579320073,
-0.2441027313,
-0.6433370113,
-0.764785111,
0.3579790592,
-0.2872247398,
0.2090797871,
-0.4131317437,
-0.2897940874,
0.3798710108,
0.0099053513,
-0.6763305068,
-0.0729426369,
0.0216588117,
0.9733601213,
-0.4223733842,
0.7471821904,
0.8747901917,
-0.5698258281,
-0.5995701551,
0.1944543868,
-0.0829951987,
-1.1351690292,
0.2368254215,
-0.1658991426,
0.1153281927,
-0.1378458887,
-0.4050371647,
-0.6402303576,
1.1657829285,
0.6146141291,
-0.4131941199,
-0.0232763346,
0.3826990724,
0.5114585161,
-0.2977217138,
0.3822908401,
0.4432838857,
0.6982496381,
0.3188490272,
-1.0906796455,
0.0198903717,
-0.051341407,
-0.469543457,
0.0122789638,
-0.9153998494,
0.4587915838,
-0.4250970781,
-0.0207458828,
0.0111476844,
0.5032065511,
-0.0750858039,
0.439581424,
0.336158365,
0.3974066079,
1.0776339769,
0.4768792689,
0.8745598793,
-0.4482754171,
-0.0218833741,
1.0356298685,
-0.6741282344,
0.187471658,
0.2428294271,
-0.1412767917,
0.2638370991,
0.6852079034,
0.2227654457,
0.5797980428,
0.0202269126,
-0.7381615639,
-0.2269148082,
-0.5117540956,
-0.2201335281,
0.5506980419,
0.5404930711,
-0.5463491082,
-0.3566927016,
0.0560322739,
0.1866791248,
-0.0654040277,
-0.4619761109,
0.8855143785,
0.2816753685,
-0.3107782602,
0.3642925024,
-0.1514440179,
0.1552651674,
-0.8142806888,
-0.1676937491,
-0.3248322308,
-0.1002515852,
-0.289232403,
-0.6887210011,
0.1761184037,
-0.0270522963,
0.1032678932,
-0.0672786385,
0.7028794885,
-0.5039854646,
-0.2152804881,
0.0975173265,
0.8424213529,
-0.0266677421,
-0.0671778694,
-0.5691153407,
-0.3199302256,
-0.2603651881,
0.0217254553,
0.2227511257,
0.3837016225,
0.2001819909,
0.7590005398,
0.4574631751,
0.4481725991,
-0.4596139193,
0.0869049355,
0.8721137643,
-0.5962690115,
-0.5038053989,
-0.8815448284,
0.1462670863,
-0.1366248876,
-0.1439780444,
0.805251956,
0.4990743995,
0.0083791157,
-0.0710256696,
0.9862009287,
0.0832196623,
0.0953599513,
-0.660769701,
0.863117516,
-0.6072648168,
0.2032683343,
-0.0035611396,
-0.4878385663,
-0.2981642783,
0.1941302866,
-0.3329192996,
0.1532857865,
0.56401366,
0.4702500403,
0.0250482615,
0.1928674132,
0.5067350268,
0.2342637479,
0.6973474622,
0.5508854985,
0.3127411008,
0.2893414199,
0.0345500559,
0.1715869606,
-0.4671218395,
-0.4360232353,
-0.4283297956,
-0.7513546944,
-0.4102138579,
-0.0538401455,
-0.2543326616,
0.1760002375,
0.951132834,
0.7930071354,
-0.5788838267,
0.2068764716,
-0.0381410159,
0.1991136372,
-0.2278733999,
-0.2235016227,
0.1970374733,
-0.2456218153,
-0.4208418131,
0.6229202151,
0.3259680271,
0.1035494506,
-0.4922174215,
-0.0266510993,
0.1515905112,
0.2331712246,
0.5152075291,
0.2428994626,
-0.1155512929,
-0.2868748605,
0.0235862173,
-0.2729408741,
0.2423228621,
0.6949917078,
-0.6680045128,
0.72959584,
-0.0873561427,
0.6664193869,
0.3107500076,
0.0566681251,
0.4408029914,
-0.6332768202,
-0.1726223379,
0.6516535282,
0.357731998,
0.232824102,
-0.6186828613,
0.2705130279,
0.3158152401,
-0.4810984731,
-0.1635063291,
0.1180920154,
-1.2241345644,
-0.0039931973,
1.6794519424,
-0.0051122224,
-0.541819334,
-0.2606287301,
-0.3231267035,
-0.0156296361,
-0.7801172733,
0.7601270676,
0.4418926537,
-0.4788048565,
0.0319614895,
-0.7748425007,
0.4952602088,
0.1121006012,
-1.5050154924,
-0.0155754266,
0.4058238268,
0.3805465102,
0.0247693975,
0.9795057774,
0.1194683686,
-0.0614589825,
-0.3307854831,
-0.0366230272,
-0.1267035455,
-0.061763458,
0.27617082,
-0.0439998209,
-0.1943015903,
-0.2005620599
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10151v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10151v1
|
ControlLM: Crafting Diverse Personalities for Language Models
| 2024-02-15T17:58:29 | 2024-02-15T17:58:29 |
Yixuan Weng, Shizhu He, Kang Liu, Shengping Liu, Jun Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As language models continue to scale in size and capability, they display an
array of emerging behaviors, both beneficial and concerning. This heightens the
need to control model behaviors. We hope to be able to control the personality
traits of language models at the inference-time so as to have various character
features, on top of which the requirements of different types of tasks can be
met. Personality is a higher-level and more abstract behavioral representation
for language models. We introduce ControlLM, which leverages differential
activation patterns, derived from contrasting behavioral prompts in the model's
latent space, to influence the model's personality traits at inference. This
approach allows for the precise, real-time adjustment of model behavior. First,
we demonstrate ControlLM's capacity to elicit diverse persona behaviors without
any training, while precision control allows personality traits to closely
match average human values. Subsequently, we showcase improved reasoning and
question answering through selective amplification of beneficial attributes
like conscientiousness and friendliness. We hope that this work will inspire
research on controlling human-like behaviors of language models and provide
insights for future research. Our code is publicly available at:
https://github.com/wengsyx/ControlLM.
|
[
-0.2751404643,
-0.8885374665,
0.4178300202,
0.6432510018,
0.1533480436,
0.412655443,
-0.1553537101,
-0.3001619875,
0.153345108,
0.4890058935,
-0.5515483618,
-0.3556754589,
-0.5183666348,
-0.266387403,
-0.1851983666,
0.8352593184,
0.0564613566,
0.0749903694,
0.0072995373,
-0.1180949807,
-0.3692821264,
-0.9083067179,
-0.7301264405,
-0.5049775243,
0.9320636988,
0.1854743361,
0.6669747829,
0.3722341657,
0.153671369,
0.2206837833,
-0.0471493825,
0.0877685174,
-0.534067452,
0.4019031823,
-0.3097092807,
-0.345947206,
-0.7096894383,
0.0668323487,
0.6550668478,
0.7499620914,
-0.1284638047,
-0.05915232,
-0.0277736876,
0.4851058125,
-0.4915801585,
0.0309133455,
-0.4122956693,
-0.147339195,
-0.4144124687,
0.1562320441,
-0.5871734023,
-0.3528376818,
-0.0835574046,
-0.2770777941,
-0.0953484997,
0.2625214756,
0.5519644022,
0.0833436921,
-0.5399070382,
0.0854210183,
-0.956540525,
1.0162127018,
-0.6541326642,
0.3547850549,
0.4798748195,
0.3616532385,
-0.1142223775,
-0.3968693316,
-0.4794286788,
-0.384152323,
-0.2039758116,
-0.1194961295,
-0.0563547276,
-0.0421463251,
0.3867525756,
0.0661012456,
-0.6058979034,
0.2379604578,
0.0583688281,
-0.228641361,
0.8134037852,
0.4631126523,
0.3941290379,
0.3562544286,
0.223312974,
-0.0544815734,
-0.5289248824,
0.3530919254,
0.6679064631,
0.308704108,
-0.3024846017,
0.5304261446,
-0.3884402812,
0.6587165594,
0.2165186703,
0.0435265079,
0.0645038784,
0.0704319626,
-0.2664280832,
-0.3436800838,
0.4561723471,
0.1256258339,
0.1726574153,
-0.0452201106,
-0.1316716373,
0.0400350355,
0.3772421181,
-0.5846140981,
-0.2742873728,
0.460340023,
-0.5591067672,
-0.5120869875,
-0.048557207,
-0.8425142765,
-0.495932281,
-0.5275788307,
0.0513522476,
-0.3847124279,
-0.5884442329,
-0.0981317461,
-0.0629294515,
0.3881883025,
0.4404403567,
-1.1883797646,
0.5065559745,
0.4812132716,
0.5433024764,
-0.5931763649,
-0.284815222,
-0.7194014192,
0.0675318167,
-0.299004823,
0.2962425947,
-1.1238093376,
-0.3694656491,
-0.1109672934,
-0.1940543801,
0.0200289562,
-0.4535179138,
0.149838537,
-0.7043017149,
0.1096731126,
-0.3488740623,
-0.2931638658,
-0.0107400659,
0.208558172,
-0.5462631583,
0.8643752933,
0.414816618,
-0.5374232531,
0.0766272619,
-0.8225893378,
-0.5786453485,
0.0265919976,
-0.1775054187,
-0.2221814394,
0.1133730933,
-0.203801915,
0.316617161,
0.1274246722,
0.3357098699,
-0.4638259411,
-0.0369853117,
0.5321545601,
-0.0771829039,
0.9605051279,
0.1648943424,
-0.263897866,
0.6814752817,
-0.6729331613,
0.1523625553,
0.065979436,
-0.1976931095,
-0.4130409658,
0.1784044653,
0.2792019248,
0.3364890814,
0.384337604,
-0.3070114851,
0.2744734585,
-0.0554002114,
0.11347799,
0.7318581343,
-0.0831514969,
0.6862539053,
-0.5199168324,
0.6404591799,
-0.0396207869,
0.3862612545,
0.2482998371,
-0.3221916854,
-0.5231389403,
-0.3580311537,
-0.1977800578,
0.603980422,
-0.2653461695,
0.6091337204,
0.3210933208,
-0.7531706691,
-0.2658519149,
0.2167489827,
0.4503460526,
0.3084841669,
0.3037974834,
-0.2581584454,
-0.5434996486,
-0.6299911737,
-0.3459814489,
-0.1012158692,
-0.2605030835,
0.4121762514,
0.2768457532,
-0.1893871576,
0.9746005535,
-0.5280660987,
0.1923314482,
-0.6084728241,
0.010968932,
0.0087466091,
0.639680028,
0.6890947819,
-0.9562647939,
-0.5653226376,
-0.1245097741,
-0.4666594267,
-0.4816204607,
-0.1453736126,
-0.5060327053,
0.1952975243,
0.4633857906,
-0.4412066042,
0.221510008,
0.6062713265,
-0.8223324418,
0.9064574242,
-0.0473214835,
-0.1741414368,
-0.5642721653,
0.4043866396,
-0.1968383789,
-0.2690069377,
-0.8832091689,
0.0868846327,
0.0555492043,
0.1573239416,
-0.3978275359,
0.9393591285,
-0.1371356696,
0.1082140207,
-0.1238790005,
-0.2140285373,
0.1499833912,
0.7314785123,
0.1431906819,
0.4170197546,
0.6516231894,
-0.8041552305,
0.5039461851,
0.1227033213,
-0.0442284197,
0.6060509086,
-0.6086474061,
0.1336947232,
-0.1573958695,
-0.0168571956,
-0.712708652,
-0.3610433638,
0.1924801171,
-0.1732719541,
0.4399790466,
0.2640391588,
-0.2731924355,
-0.0816464126,
-0.0074341525,
-0.1623464227,
0.7373877168,
-0.1110448539,
0.830463171,
0.3801921606,
-0.4229540825,
-0.2448617369,
-0.6334087849,
-0.3098105788,
-0.3050041199,
-0.0299332831,
0.3488336802,
-0.6434491873,
-0.8398782015,
-0.2918021679,
0.0017276998,
0.0368445739,
0.3427608907,
0.2420882881,
0.1772864908,
0.1159063801,
0.178690061,
0.4664816558,
0.0136418706,
-0.118777737,
-0.2609228492,
0.9841188192,
-0.1144696921,
-0.4721152186,
-0.280362308,
0.6021906137,
0.7862428427,
-0.5662709475,
0.7567540407,
0.4294848144,
-0.0679832995,
-0.1458526701,
-0.3852585256,
-0.3928610981,
-0.4522301257,
0.3372781873,
-0.4769423008,
-1.0726494789,
0.8647277951,
0.1789429784,
0.0619975179,
0.0187150296,
0.8160600066,
-0.0292469133,
1.2495609522,
0.712531507,
0.0088126007,
0.7773628235,
0.2508806586,
0.058711309,
-0.8021860719,
-0.3102137446,
-0.4292076826,
-0.525981009,
-0.4748657644,
-0.2424225211,
-0.1131380051,
-0.0213970132,
-0.6612843871,
-0.0221454855,
-0.3553758264,
0.1993728131,
0.5161489248,
0.0911533907,
0.1734829992,
-0.3218178153,
-0.286765933,
-0.318480283,
-0.2786827385,
-0.6190105677,
0.869669199,
0.371178776,
1.059024334,
0.3944193423,
0.315177381,
0.3733248413,
0.475341171,
-0.494078964,
0.4803433716,
-0.2779231966,
-0.6529908776,
-0.4881920218,
-0.2083493173,
-0.6364164948,
0.1300247908,
-0.0045686993,
-1.0156344175,
0.1512488425,
0.4055352211,
-0.2520419657,
0.1600111723,
-0.574739337,
0.9355340004,
-0.5626106858,
-0.5009109378,
-0.1880009323,
-0.7506172061,
0.2626532614,
-0.1079442427,
-0.1398704499,
-0.3343649209,
-0.024339499,
0.3398331404,
-0.186849013,
1.2059419155,
-0.3255393505,
-0.1642223895,
-0.077634573,
0.5365965962,
0.4913192093,
0.0235691145,
-0.3325973153,
0.0010590843,
0.0646115839,
-0.6105456948,
-0.756246984,
0.6128214002,
-0.7987546921,
-0.5026122332,
-0.0429342426,
-0.7107371688,
-0.3734121323,
0.3359550238,
-0.0418172404,
0.2680571675,
-0.4019435942,
0.078226164,
0.6580055356,
-0.3488829434,
0.3233530521,
0.6471624374,
-0.7431826591,
0.015467803,
0.7100843787,
-0.2625617981,
0.5728584528,
0.6547807455,
0.2487876266,
-0.2035295665,
-0.4169592261,
-0.071249865,
0.082340084,
-0.4318864346,
0.2909923792,
-0.792915225,
-0.1521870196,
-0.5558456779,
-0.1970738769,
-0.2188386619,
-0.2224242091,
-0.3230111599,
0.1727298945,
0.3208131492,
0.654328227,
0.3533531129,
0.5748140216,
-0.4802569151,
0.125472188,
0.5131250024,
0.4776034057,
-0.0558454283,
-0.3639346659,
0.0895780846,
-0.1444246173,
-0.2126839459,
-0.8781224489,
0.6371644139,
0.1513325274,
0.8346241117,
0.5032989383,
0.0637098849,
0.1980686039,
-0.4461101294,
0.6491064429,
-0.2169282585,
-1.1149218082,
0.6237696409,
-0.3298457563,
0.4873362482,
0.271253854,
0.2829689682,
-0.8480252624,
-0.8737912774,
-0.6340537667,
-0.296484381,
0.6271035671,
-0.0080762841,
0.4154376388,
0.224342078,
0.2469156086,
0.2252258211,
0.386588037,
-0.5999572277,
-0.3123938739,
-0.4077268541,
-0.3381145298,
-0.0071452325,
-0.2856861353,
-0.2951051593,
-0.2831554413,
0.4352252483,
-0.2930926085,
-0.0039978335,
-0.1265942901,
0.0707943439,
-0.0653447881,
0.3323377073,
0.8043334484,
0.6551150084,
-0.1950482726,
0.3153085411,
0.0044330624,
-0.4522829354,
0.0317018442,
-0.0153085906,
-0.2587566674,
-0.1264998913,
0.1155668348,
0.9799435735,
0.0097439718,
-0.7084695697,
0.112301439,
-0.1138034537,
0.0657163262,
-0.1573759913,
0.5142615438,
0.1154214889,
0.3303248286,
0.2011652887,
0.1678272337,
-0.2075448632,
-0.2261404097,
0.110042043,
0.4613773525,
-0.3747482002,
-0.5089150667,
0.7083086967,
0.2037717849,
-0.4757808149,
0.4335798323,
-0.371594131,
-0.418884784,
0.5714386106,
0.7318748832,
0.8118703961,
-0.5013363957,
0.3159017265,
0.1206477135,
0.1380414665,
0.1832861155,
0.5115659237,
-0.0082225772,
-1.0818557739,
-0.4785148203,
-0.7331448793,
-0.6672803164,
0.2780086696,
-0.4518510997,
0.2172384858,
-0.8265075684,
0.0778180212,
-0.2274414152,
0.0085995095,
-0.4006773829,
0.0709150881,
0.0394634865,
0.9818082452,
-0.884576261,
1.1727794409,
0.743077755,
-0.1742451638,
-0.7330519557,
-0.0905229896,
0.2217905223,
-0.4646756053,
0.9179520607,
-0.066604495,
0.016605258,
0.2671511769,
-0.8234349489,
-0.7614440918,
0.8128482699,
0.26048702,
-0.5405059457,
-0.0651569366,
-0.2880210876,
0.5927184224,
-0.5646861196,
0.0548118837,
0.7028696537,
0.6665968895,
0.1681466699,
-0.7579111457,
0.018421514,
-0.3759507537,
0.0596166924,
0.0149934804,
-0.5010222793,
0.9143462181,
-0.1349377334,
0.1121890768,
-0.0638820678,
0.5736545324,
0.6131007671,
0.0352047458,
0.4774073064,
0.1302698702,
0.9869554043,
0.0340464301,
0.9440996051,
-0.2172510922,
-0.0241302736,
1.2949850559,
-0.6744837761,
0.6782301664,
0.4896059334,
-0.2861528993,
0.7822895646,
0.4649307728,
0.0231841467,
0.4555843771,
0.147609368,
-0.4526227415,
-0.3840417266,
-0.0574917607,
0.0619985722,
0.5269109011,
0.5742496252,
-0.1935682744,
0.0614116639,
0.2432810664,
0.1373589188,
0.2892580926,
-0.1316146404,
0.5405900478,
-0.1528793126,
-0.5974234939,
0.0775974989,
-0.0602887496,
0.7543128729,
-0.9128782153,
0.1199748144,
-0.3269430697,
0.1036082059,
-0.035383407,
-0.6464767456,
0.5662817359,
-0.1254828274,
-0.2319167554,
-0.6632683277,
0.7379036546,
-0.6550027728,
-0.1470715702,
0.3014624119,
0.5643738508,
0.0693999156,
-0.2134354562,
-0.5194948912,
0.1980544478,
-0.0000649115,
-0.2582668364,
0.3140742779,
0.1076458544,
-0.5148857236,
0.7444816828,
0.6877570748,
0.3649410009,
0.0866252035,
0.3050303757,
0.7176497579,
-0.5908307433,
-0.5748019218,
-1.0202310085,
0.6824149489,
-0.2442763597,
-0.1929959506,
0.6064110398,
0.2487576008,
0.6678528786,
-0.4568942189,
0.9232071042,
-0.5332131982,
0.5853604674,
-0.2993793786,
1.0112906694,
-0.4051001966,
-0.0783359557,
-0.0259638056,
-0.6449932456,
-0.5537264347,
0.4063572884,
-0.3842990398,
0.1699040979,
0.4502774179,
0.8344153762,
0.1776504666,
-0.3161587119,
0.5810717344,
0.2434978485,
0.7457803488,
0.3470178246,
0.6891065836,
0.4040051699,
0.1173624098,
-0.2055345327,
-0.4075710177,
-0.4071638584,
-0.9623827934,
-0.8905419111,
-0.4932762086,
-0.2768812478,
-0.2408569902,
-0.399225235,
0.8645967841,
0.8657311201,
-1.0758054256,
-0.2497587055,
-0.2284346968,
0.4787726402,
-0.5113722682,
-0.2852669656,
-0.0544158109,
-0.506053865,
-0.9546211958,
0.1403018683,
0.4340016246,
0.2190616131,
-0.5354728103,
-0.2533602715,
-0.2204772383,
0.0030469513,
0.6228544712,
0.5169895887,
-0.8120020628,
-0.2773978114,
0.3021493554,
-0.4351879656,
-0.2036920041,
1.0895849466,
-0.4587398767,
0.4305737913,
0.5770648718,
0.3427579403,
0.2226872593,
-0.0516205654,
0.7725321651,
-0.9985259771,
0.3692208529,
0.3534547985,
0.0741860494,
0.3588217497,
-0.4316530824,
0.0748287067,
0.1422181726,
-0.4577022791,
-0.5085907578,
0.5727894306,
-1.1229202747,
-0.2800561488,
1.0126085281,
-0.0214035343,
-0.0987100601,
-0.2361211479,
-0.5531542301,
0.2832601666,
-0.4060210288,
0.6872456074,
0.7594538927,
-0.5527424216,
-0.4779713452,
-0.3569371998,
0.6936814785,
0.4594950378,
-1.0477691889,
0.3099350035,
0.4479545951,
0.1736341417,
0.2002059221,
0.6814940572,
-0.1191386953,
-0.1163807735,
-0.3075062335,
0.3090611994,
0.0402751192,
-0.2214122415,
-0.4117258489,
0.080023922,
0.3239759207,
0.1846630573
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10137v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10137v3
|
TOAD: Task-Oriented Automatic Dialogs with Diverse Response Styles
| 2024-02-15T17:40:02 | 2024-06-06T20:18:11 |
Yinhong Liu, Yimai Fang, David Vandyke, Nigel Collier
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In light of recent advances in large language models (LLMs), the expectations
for the next generation of virtual assistants include enhanced naturalness and
adaptability across diverse usage scenarios. However, the creation of
high-quality annotated data for Task-Oriented Dialog (TOD) is recognized to be
slow and costly. To address these challenges, we introduce Task-Oriented
Automatic Dialogs (TOAD), a novel and scalable TOD dataset along with its
automatic generation pipeline. The TOAD dataset simulates realistic app context
interaction and provide a variety of system response style options. Two aspects
of system response styles are considered, verbosity level and users' expression
mirroring. We benchmark TOAD on two response generation tasks, and the results
show that modeling more verbose responses or responses without user expression
mirroring is more challenging.
|
[
-0.3753568828,
-0.8054734468,
0.3467864394,
0.46108675,
-0.0983901396,
-0.0116963182,
0.0908789262,
-0.363795042,
0.3574184179,
0.8231146932,
-0.8544988632,
-0.1565716118,
-0.2529709339,
0.386610806,
-0.3094743192,
0.9769465327,
0.1139691547,
-0.0166913271,
-0.248729974,
-0.071499154,
-0.8976490498,
-0.3856833279,
-0.8365290165,
0.0624536574,
0.2299815565,
0.4503667355,
0.4805960655,
0.4625046551,
0.4232635498,
0.361097157,
0.4984535277,
0.4181605279,
-0.2992930114,
0.7599853277,
0.0948228687,
-0.1374558359,
-0.847304523,
-0.3441528678,
0.3423441052,
0.3536838591,
-0.0576216057,
0.1379724294,
0.0283714198,
0.4967326224,
-0.3661948144,
0.4305976033,
-0.7353522182,
-0.0314652212,
-0.0597472824,
-0.0308214985,
-0.4421693683,
0.0233897846,
0.3833629787,
-0.8181546926,
0.0964950398,
0.2526949644,
0.6344591975,
0.1874243319,
-0.6091321707,
-0.3854140341,
-0.6566735506,
0.6830921173,
-0.6316900849,
0.1565415263,
0.1428503096,
0.4544899166,
-0.1028992683,
-0.4993365407,
-0.7222110033,
-0.0946221501,
-0.0768384859,
0.0946874171,
-0.0406311899,
0.091684185,
0.1228012145,
0.2089603543,
-0.6829096079,
-0.1490094364,
0.0263268389,
-0.3387444615,
0.7074947953,
0.7706882358,
0.2167204618,
-0.4158102572,
-0.2389411777,
-0.0978921652,
-0.3088544905,
-0.0536275618,
0.1750757545,
0.6960315108,
0.0049682842,
0.5272315145,
-0.5191531181,
0.9919506907,
0.0044594142,
-0.0530447513,
0.0582348667,
-0.6591196656,
-0.2339133173,
-0.2201436311,
0.917393446,
0.7312818766,
0.2539271414,
-0.0822123736,
-0.5188575983,
-0.1755173951,
0.443782717,
-0.5494421721,
-0.0818779618,
0.3666782379,
-0.2101500928,
-0.2028430104,
-0.322773844,
-1.0376757383,
-0.5829253793,
-0.5156912208,
0.3600087464,
-0.2527464032,
-0.0882811025,
-0.2336809188,
0.1503522247,
0.1710508764,
0.8516728878,
-0.6917140484,
0.6315351129,
0.5792643428,
0.7956725359,
-0.4350862801,
-0.0668775886,
-0.9839519262,
0.2008514851,
-0.1458019018,
0.6500065923,
-0.6575112939,
-0.8315168023,
-0.0713549927,
0.0663661733,
-0.0010267489,
-0.4817301333,
0.2251485139,
-0.3387276828,
0.4623960555,
-0.3638591766,
-0.2410190552,
0.1076341867,
0.2419876754,
-0.4525761902,
0.8684472442,
0.2719446719,
-0.5799268484,
0.4312392771,
-0.878647089,
-0.457950443,
0.0719353333,
0.1251703054,
-0.1994498372,
0.1334590465,
0.1419458538,
0.3069076538,
-0.4440408945,
0.1434732676,
-0.3639045954,
-0.1545979828,
-0.0195455961,
-0.0974401534,
0.5114764571,
0.3719871938,
-0.3890134394,
0.3772236109,
-0.8725568652,
0.1115128323,
0.153025642,
0.0412792563,
-0.3056777716,
-0.0723507553,
0.1393758506,
0.2573008835,
0.3510802984,
-0.7206355929,
0.5530980825,
0.0249381084,
0.3843968213,
0.9614745378,
-0.1988709271,
0.1407215893,
-0.096399121,
0.3029413223,
0.1269161105,
0.2667945623,
-0.3111216724,
-0.4449219108,
-0.7217750549,
-0.337228924,
-0.1396207958,
0.6395785809,
-0.817578733,
-0.0103415046,
-0.329585433,
-0.2483059019,
-0.3295528293,
0.1188671663,
0.5435337424,
0.8537791371,
0.0658910275,
-0.5958533287,
-0.6022478938,
-1.0685479641,
-0.1622139961,
-0.5746814013,
-0.1847766638,
1.0126862526,
0.2199859172,
-0.2972372174,
1.236212492,
-0.4685588181,
-0.116874516,
-0.1269492209,
0.3320459723,
-0.2047588974,
0.1849256456,
0.5148223042,
-0.8023985028,
-0.6050655842,
-0.1161304414,
-0.4864887893,
-0.5332847834,
-0.0951840356,
-0.1049243212,
0.5304147005,
-0.0286846049,
-0.6382550001,
0.0191031434,
0.5049400926,
-0.4574058354,
0.468172878,
0.01274167,
0.3426733911,
-1.2957290411,
-0.0277107116,
0.1257941276,
-0.362315774,
-0.7389148474,
-0.2848173976,
-0.1985768825,
-0.3309150934,
-0.3902662992,
1.0426573753,
-0.2931378484,
-0.5065332651,
-0.2906821966,
0.076294288,
0.0143948542,
0.6048777103,
0.2963961363,
1.1595448256,
0.4147126973,
-0.5396318436,
0.5576284528,
0.2482574135,
0.3321884573,
0.7902481556,
-0.9120234847,
0.2156623006,
0.0495235771,
0.4334949553,
-1.1209791899,
-0.7052021027,
0.1130950153,
-0.1331641227,
0.1246814802,
-0.0587487593,
-0.6807909608,
-0.3648058772,
-0.3509882987,
0.0691381916,
0.4471429288,
-0.2230255455,
0.8440357447,
0.3578059375,
-0.4182999432,
-0.1790617853,
-0.2147560567,
0.2211620212,
-0.3194893301,
-0.544917345,
-0.165307954,
-0.0271393191,
-0.3784063756,
-0.3664361835,
-0.1026404127,
-0.2902834415,
0.0033674957,
0.4106872976,
0.4152700305,
-0.0766018033,
0.0684578344,
-0.0732890964,
0.106212154,
-0.0599745698,
-0.1932868063,
0.6461549997,
-0.3131951988,
-0.3330032229,
-0.4720127881,
0.535358429,
1.005712986,
-0.0580280684,
0.3399291635,
0.3638394177,
-0.0780839995,
0.2006242722,
-0.481484592,
-0.3117263317,
-0.4754378498,
0.3262834847,
-0.5344574451,
-0.5536785722,
0.4704784453,
0.1541316062,
0.5830029249,
0.1652027667,
0.5859066248,
-0.1139209494,
1.3013541698,
0.449816972,
0.0544219725,
0.5503895283,
0.1938302666,
0.1525967568,
-0.8034806252,
-0.0945730358,
-0.3798643053,
-0.1365821064,
-0.6199213862,
-0.2682407498,
0.3903112411,
-0.3631638587,
-0.3644248247,
0.4733117223,
-0.4763449728,
-0.1522848457,
0.619250834,
-0.1182417125,
0.3887852728,
-0.2043702751,
0.4749928415,
-0.0542713851,
-0.3943091929,
-0.7338677049,
1.2759267092,
0.0750326887,
0.812045157,
0.2332060486,
0.6547899842,
0.3145431876,
0.3859085441,
-0.6589326859,
0.8805729747,
-0.066025883,
-0.4203263223,
-0.4635111988,
-0.3760805726,
-0.663236022,
0.1254794002,
0.0180971082,
-1.0926531553,
-0.1393960118,
0.5489088297,
-0.1814685315,
0.0358918943,
-1.0309351683,
0.6071091294,
-0.1138983145,
-0.5328425765,
0.1950300187,
-0.7087163925,
0.2174815983,
-0.1192988604,
0.0116638588,
-0.1209424436,
-0.1161377206,
0.4523482621,
-0.6352476478,
0.8645285368,
-0.4164531231,
-0.0743395612,
0.3708450794,
0.4304135144,
0.7976461053,
0.1718382537,
0.0622255914,
-0.3412847817,
0.0943547562,
-0.4438394904,
-0.6592461467,
0.8117592335,
-0.5468919277,
-0.8525007367,
-0.1554600596,
-0.9174585342,
-0.8415514231,
0.0773356259,
0.0134594664,
0.5127446651,
0.069431968,
-0.1385821402,
0.5818080306,
-0.0127021652,
0.3782390356,
0.581573844,
-0.3064722717,
-0.1550772786,
0.8789177537,
-0.0503457077,
0.3476218283,
0.0342791751,
-0.0790994838,
-0.2698373497,
-0.1200015172,
-0.8106020093,
-0.0660263523,
-0.1945596039,
-0.0405328199,
-0.9336589575,
0.1584753096,
-0.5585449934,
-0.0395705514,
-0.4632142782,
-0.5568913221,
-0.1111920327,
0.3524930477,
0.5172365904,
0.7799854279,
0.3414362967,
0.2623439133,
-0.8365902305,
0.3116647005,
0.7829809785,
0.3255400062,
-0.1042850912,
-0.1896115541,
0.1848850697,
0.2794222832,
-0.3999802172,
-0.7560347915,
0.4053092599,
0.2170021534,
0.2317198813,
0.0544178858,
0.1416705549,
0.6575530767,
-0.4809229374,
1.1793003082,
0.0321118869,
-0.7637503147,
0.8214600086,
-0.6360840797,
0.3072513342,
0.2337294668,
0.1196197793,
-0.5586701035,
-0.4393582046,
-0.3824937642,
-0.8867829442,
0.7321814299,
0.2041992694,
0.4525950551,
-0.0419608802,
0.151294589,
0.536210537,
0.4307101667,
-0.4531362057,
-0.0096574957,
-0.4929984808,
-0.1748415083,
0.0438071378,
-0.0429224111,
-0.3651032448,
0.1642440557,
0.3529435396,
-0.5024282932,
0.5440896749,
0.1612024009,
0.0011814213,
0.0313694477,
0.3080893457,
0.5745868087,
0.3219974935,
-0.1166394204,
-0.2038908601,
0.1766485572,
-0.3449970186,
0.0145782847,
-0.1219197884,
0.0666134134,
0.0718013868,
0.2141631693,
0.9806321859,
-0.1249493361,
-0.988930881,
0.3120273948,
-0.3281779885,
0.1412906498,
0.1226822659,
0.2749702632,
-0.2488919497,
0.0624530055,
0.3238963485,
-0.3588446081,
0.5633426309,
-0.7694110274,
-0.063944757,
0.5648978353,
-0.3217728138,
-0.4245805442,
0.5806888938,
0.6003918648,
-0.5104230046,
0.6276219487,
-0.0801957101,
-0.2597048879,
0.5396636724,
0.4488892257,
1.0738741159,
0.0214515347,
0.250451833,
0.1837134063,
-0.2691197991,
0.2688456774,
0.3893926144,
-0.4876576364,
-0.2178744078,
-0.0885313079,
-0.5049881935,
-0.77146703,
-0.0693090037,
-0.6294867396,
0.145175159,
-0.3067567647,
-0.4812789559,
-0.3649682999,
-0.1599342227,
-0.5837364197,
0.2553977668,
-0.1835523993,
0.640868783,
-0.8335934281,
0.4802803993,
0.8864135742,
-0.0981593281,
-0.6019787192,
0.3439075351,
0.3637120426,
-0.6891721487,
0.9452809691,
-0.0273287147,
-0.1460461617,
-0.2493361533,
-0.2997307777,
-0.6864417195,
0.9331300855,
0.1869325638,
-0.4850204885,
-0.3125943542,
0.1233755425,
0.7437034845,
-0.5739126205,
0.3272202015,
0.3320753276,
0.2172764838,
0.088989988,
-1.4742552042,
-0.0956872702,
-0.4238088727,
0.3285980225,
0.0835085586,
-1.0088628531,
0.8115714788,
0.0727784187,
0.0531978123,
0.1271829903,
0.3833414018,
0.414326936,
0.4806666076,
0.6718266606,
0.2054510862,
0.3307155967,
-0.3421723545,
1.0349036455,
-0.5150907636,
0.0942056775,
1.2516003847,
-0.5696387291,
0.561940074,
0.7082450986,
-0.0184135791,
0.3661287129,
0.7981792688,
0.437533766,
0.5146261454,
0.0072728884,
-0.1851325929,
-0.2045704722,
-0.3941237926,
-0.1167862266,
0.4144223034,
0.2521568537,
-0.0071882005,
-0.0490192659,
0.1608355194,
-0.1468943805,
-0.123899512,
-0.1967714876,
1.0571398735,
-0.344088167,
-0.8061256409,
0.2669883966,
-0.5497537255,
0.5959500074,
-0.4374402165,
-0.0836110562,
-0.388869077,
-0.2896338701,
-0.0867350399,
-0.9178301096,
0.2214657366,
0.2669523358,
-0.1976629347,
-0.4567426145,
0.4577435851,
-0.0218619835,
-0.1953779906,
-0.0563968346,
0.45261693,
0.0061323214,
0.3134027421,
-0.5484086871,
0.1544455886,
-0.0989511907,
-0.6835858226,
0.2797558904,
0.5657573938,
-0.4557713568,
1.0607478619,
0.2510856688,
-0.0997827053,
0.1518212557,
-0.2232353687,
0.8667349219,
-0.1819580197,
-0.327950865,
-0.2989546359,
0.6006538272,
-0.4253980219,
-0.4126659334,
0.78345263,
0.4276758432,
0.4925880134,
-0.2096275836,
0.7277721763,
-0.1845741123,
0.6397539377,
-0.2716119587,
0.1602527648,
-0.6285832524,
0.254612565,
-0.5515138507,
-0.8941144943,
0.154314965,
0.3303223252,
-0.2454879433,
0.3461174071,
0.2075564116,
0.7068151236,
-0.0770551711,
0.0868532062,
0.0417195633,
0.1204927266,
0.5101191998,
0.4800459146,
0.3912836015,
-0.143826589,
0.3740249276,
-0.2493908554,
-0.0908878967,
-0.4830947518,
-0.6436218619,
-0.5515155196,
-0.9424574971,
-0.2432609946,
-0.2965575159,
0.2218453288,
0.8440135121,
0.9318480492,
-0.7260878682,
-0.2844645679,
-0.2560350895,
-0.2540977895,
0.2207564414,
-0.3476990163,
-0.1376354396,
-0.4843034446,
-1.0277019739,
0.0260106381,
0.5145743489,
0.280251503,
-0.3911652267,
-0.0940248966,
0.4017674923,
0.3087727726,
0.6565085649,
0.3752774596,
-0.7456023097,
-0.4052444696,
0.291022867,
-0.3572669029,
-0.0770937204,
0.7887548208,
-0.8581078649,
0.9047976732,
0.33737275,
0.4383761585,
0.3071261942,
-0.0034467028,
0.931150198,
-0.6943630576,
0.0578419529,
0.2948102951,
0.1192258,
0.254211396,
-0.3904407322,
0.5292881131,
0.1232167408,
-0.378403306,
-1.1544021368,
0.3712980747,
-1.0804965496,
0.0041280114,
0.9782084227,
-0.1336352527,
-0.1711190194,
-0.0518140234,
-0.6643739343,
-0.05780112,
-0.7468294501,
0.8529669642,
0.7129036188,
-0.7411894202,
-0.1094584465,
-0.5080938339,
0.4083579183,
0.4562838078,
-1.1098406315,
0.4172869027,
0.8273460269,
0.0890917331,
0.1827994585,
0.6862630248,
0.1650278121,
0.3745006621,
0.0425590314,
-0.2287715673,
-0.0809911862,
-0.2938224077,
0.0663232356,
0.0701272562,
0.0429607704,
-0.1578519195
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10110v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10110v2
|
Selective Reflection-Tuning: Student-Selected Data Recycling for LLM Instruction-Tuning
| 2024-02-15T17:06:21 | 2024-06-07T20:23:21 |
Ming Li, Lichang Chen, Jiuhai Chen, Shwai He, Jiuxiang Gu, Tianyi Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Instruction tuning is critical to large language models (LLMs) for achieving
better instruction following and task adaptation capabilities but its success
heavily relies on the training data quality. Many recent methods focus on
improving the data quality but often overlook the compatibility of the data
with the student model being finetuned. This paper introduces Selective
Reflection-Tuning, a novel paradigm that synergizes a teacher LLM's reflection
and introspection for improving existing data quality with the data selection
capability of the student LLM, to automatically refine existing
instruction-tuning data. This teacher-student collaboration produces
high-quality and student-compatible instruction-response pairs, resulting in
sample-efficient instruction tuning and LLMs of superior performance. Selective
Reflection-Tuning is a data augmentation and synthesis that generally improves
LLM finetuning and self-improvement without collecting brand-new data. We apply
our method to Alpaca and WizardLM data and achieve much stronger and top-tier
7B and 13B LLMs.
|
[
-0.537592411,
-0.7301880121,
0.2687531114,
0.0622648075,
-0.3732010722,
0.3589062691,
-0.3109671474,
-0.2669041157,
0.2350935042,
0.9174886346,
-0.4370679259,
-0.4679495096,
-0.329843998,
-0.0351356976,
-0.6575735807,
0.9682041407,
-0.0569128953,
0.5179431438,
-0.1177298203,
-0.0806419179,
-0.6700876355,
-0.0361651927,
-0.4126506746,
-0.3533424735,
0.4107462466,
0.8616803885,
0.5365024805,
0.896920681,
0.3870491385,
0.2291634679,
0.2525483072,
0.5952323079,
-0.6834494472,
0.2577445209,
-0.3211808503,
-0.4319528341,
-0.5688256025,
0.3486681581,
0.942250371,
0.7555974126,
-0.3287450969,
0.338872999,
0.4719303548,
0.8496779799,
-0.59760499,
-0.1695916206,
-0.8786048889,
-0.1091381982,
-0.2713629901,
-0.3468734324,
-0.5598911047,
-0.6516940594,
-0.1708974689,
-0.4478064477,
0.7081198096,
0.0648120418,
0.5268005729,
0.3337431252,
-0.2897687554,
-0.2079360336,
-0.6200947762,
0.6682760119,
-0.4637324214,
0.4704475999,
0.4861501157,
0.2523517907,
-0.2349073589,
-0.3201814294,
-0.3608475626,
0.0402144007,
0.1929642111,
0.2961325645,
0.5767198205,
0.0733536109,
0.0006547341,
0.6532486677,
-0.4322449565,
0.0766039044,
-0.4496681988,
-0.0325023867,
0.6096924543,
0.3433049023,
0.0078678783,
0.1802029163,
-0.2877493203,
-0.0876194686,
-0.9669603109,
-0.1053492874,
0.5819877386,
0.556765914,
0.3346787393,
0.3239845932,
-0.2598573267,
0.9751343727,
0.065178521,
-0.1319924593,
0.1403832883,
-0.2770982385,
-0.0854570195,
0.1688155085,
0.3047053218,
0.1703292131,
0.0197179485,
-0.3118990362,
-0.3958936632,
0.1071678847,
0.2534175217,
-0.6084235907,
-0.3529778719,
-0.2065100074,
-0.4133333862,
-0.2212480009,
0.1864503473,
-0.8157767057,
-0.1302182972,
-0.7452356815,
0.3527665734,
-0.0772616193,
-0.1425153166,
0.2516177893,
0.2069764137,
0.284021914,
0.3465783298,
-1.0883928537,
0.4076315761,
0.8028670549,
0.4480012357,
-0.5986740589,
-0.4696561992,
-0.6751641035,
0.3601811826,
-0.5822327137,
0.7463871837,
-0.7952356339,
-0.4349014461,
-0.2089073807,
0.0516545326,
-0.1545225531,
-0.9264863133,
0.4444361925,
-0.5263050199,
0.1544310451,
-0.4787978828,
-0.5123715401,
-0.032177195,
-0.0529686771,
-0.6434512734,
1.1220368147,
0.3967058063,
-0.1888867319,
0.5213170648,
-0.0114694908,
-0.3736818731,
0.0478858948,
0.0191868786,
-0.4920015931,
0.1819782406,
0.0982849672,
0.2023497671,
-0.2945309579,
0.1245846525,
-0.318323344,
-0.7475968599,
-0.0486983545,
-0.428031832,
0.4102238417,
0.2132208794,
0.0328364037,
-0.0686124936,
-1.0698297024,
0.1151529178,
-0.0572723337,
-0.5600612164,
-0.2410246283,
0.0634336323,
-0.2056230605,
-0.0852818415,
0.3348510265,
-0.411770165,
0.3933666945,
-0.2283113599,
0.1136189178,
0.9738103747,
-0.1414488852,
0.4866612852,
-0.4665836096,
0.4867706001,
-0.2263413966,
0.2645675838,
0.0124677317,
-0.1757194251,
-1.0355467796,
-0.1460720748,
0.2360539138,
0.4810537994,
-0.7093265653,
0.1461335272,
0.0642948523,
-0.2878785431,
-1.0270805359,
0.5814834237,
0.2390045524,
0.7690958977,
0.5082147121,
-0.3898338974,
-0.6439369917,
-0.7015812397,
-0.2559937239,
0.2535681129,
0.126615271,
0.2414729595,
-0.0657570288,
0.0142478468,
0.8053440452,
-0.4665248096,
-0.3932947218,
-0.1910416633,
-0.3036844134,
0.2650568485,
0.6172253489,
0.3740112782,
-0.3897868693,
-0.7781636715,
-0.3135814965,
-0.4016784132,
-0.1681251526,
0.0065501956,
-0.5164234042,
0.1422950327,
0.2519239485,
-0.0169829894,
0.0459917262,
0.5705456138,
-0.2340065241,
0.3337470591,
-0.1325527132,
0.2307921052,
-0.7594134808,
-0.3112779856,
-0.2555696368,
-0.2707770765,
-0.4807785749,
0.1088760868,
0.1227710024,
0.1991731077,
-0.2389824986,
0.2910757661,
-0.5713552833,
-0.0542139597,
-0.5495646,
-0.005802955,
-0.0686691478,
0.2587890625,
-0.0345837846,
0.9715093374,
0.511711657,
-0.4899465442,
0.3326454759,
0.2961659729,
-0.463362366,
0.5275422335,
-0.3882104456,
0.3973434865,
0.077059716,
-0.0775634944,
-0.7559429407,
-0.1165924519,
0.229882881,
-0.0072004469,
0.3808909953,
-0.009896962,
-0.4614654779,
-0.1731701344,
-0.2425769567,
0.2729742527,
0.4517470002,
-0.9229175448,
0.4884749651,
0.132402882,
0.0543818995,
-0.4860289097,
-0.4657814801,
-0.0283465032,
0.0025426792,
-0.3376770616,
0.3750113547,
-0.1413967013,
0.1011441946,
-0.0288229529,
-0.2869475782,
0.1294079125,
0.0361624695,
-0.1325705945,
0.5645979643,
-0.0426339991,
-0.1660474539,
0.3293690681,
-0.1555501521,
-0.1197588369,
-0.0218867604,
0.5549115539,
0.1287902147,
-0.3953985274,
-0.1466408968,
0.1991387308,
0.0953128487,
-0.0971619263,
0.7444021702,
0.5218954682,
0.1384728104,
-0.7914580703,
-0.8155945539,
-0.5464223027,
-0.5806212425,
0.1215701178,
-0.3017272353,
-0.768532753,
0.3626562059,
0.0597498566,
0.2001646906,
-0.1675515324,
0.2636986375,
-0.0992717817,
1.3162250519,
0.4443086684,
-0.0619324222,
0.6792289019,
-0.1149388254,
-0.0447084941,
-1.0228477716,
-0.2113553286,
-0.451290518,
-0.4046540558,
-0.5573913455,
-0.0228008945,
0.1582440883,
-0.1220617667,
-0.1435847878,
0.1464753598,
-0.8969718218,
0.7678562403,
0.6365966201,
0.3585741222,
0.4193133116,
0.0360978097,
0.1995988786,
-0.0219675172,
-0.3683837652,
-0.5341130495,
1.2123596668,
-0.0299496017,
0.8923563361,
-0.1601197273,
0.8976957798,
-0.0633261055,
0.3569966257,
-0.4228597581,
0.8348833323,
-0.4715372026,
-0.4783160985,
-0.1282757521,
-0.521543324,
-0.8917987347,
0.4435341358,
-0.1284897774,
-0.2995811999,
-0.136652559,
0.1550525278,
-0.0168542191,
0.2007458061,
-0.5982199311,
0.5162295103,
0.0688166097,
-0.5399210453,
-0.3931132257,
-0.2864339948,
0.2732982635,
-0.1008392125,
-0.1478061974,
-0.2507956624,
0.0133098671,
0.6486862898,
-0.2615342736,
0.6215560436,
-0.2793673277,
-0.2783795595,
0.3181404471,
0.2484699041,
0.4754167795,
0.0396701656,
-0.1665396392,
-0.2310724109,
-0.0680204183,
-0.5119985938,
-0.6269253492,
0.866740644,
-0.7524431944,
-0.9821345806,
-0.0300363712,
-0.6188964844,
-0.4635471702,
0.026448315,
-0.0053198924,
0.1813600808,
0.0291769747,
0.1585562378,
0.7907614708,
0.2719930112,
0.2967991233,
0.9000680447,
-0.1435580254,
-0.5791723728,
1.4934806824,
0.3550254405,
0.3287836015,
0.0148780597,
-0.045565512,
-0.0413454361,
-0.7548273206,
-0.242551595,
0.2889916003,
-0.6106139421,
-0.1230708882,
-0.0409095734,
-0.2322449982,
-0.1122531295,
-0.278898567,
-0.5260834694,
-0.3757385015,
-0.5996262431,
-0.0313049518,
-0.0406666733,
0.5975944996,
0.1759551018,
0.2149338573,
-0.6631816626,
0.2470742166,
0.3994463086,
0.5468784571,
-0.0104910918,
-0.5670825839,
-0.3009061813,
-0.0499619693,
-0.4606286883,
-0.6655878425,
0.2653072774,
0.3450011611,
0.5949108005,
0.3468071818,
-0.0486596525,
0.5568632483,
-0.4014037848,
0.4984425604,
-0.1811552942,
-0.8155993819,
0.748267889,
-0.2057067156,
0.1710580736,
0.9523887634,
-0.0790564343,
-0.2669929862,
-0.6166989207,
-0.2645329237,
-0.7145750523,
0.8387514949,
-0.3095138371,
0.2397733182,
0.1274709105,
0.6433076262,
0.6188969016,
0.2119518518,
-0.4418025613,
-0.3005316854,
-0.2493559569,
-0.4489002526,
-0.0687768534,
0.0249307938,
-0.2474867851,
-0.5054225326,
0.8345173001,
-0.3338053524,
-0.0825229138,
-0.2332503349,
0.0037588186,
-0.3061050773,
0.0305411164,
0.203384757,
0.6040880084,
-0.1203398034,
0.1051923111,
0.436948806,
-0.7181249261,
0.3454482257,
-0.1369240433,
-0.4807220995,
-0.2072402537,
0.1510149688,
0.5759723186,
0.1649025977,
-0.2354895473,
0.0710172132,
0.0543497838,
-0.0422952473,
-0.049072247,
0.9348325133,
-0.2606421411,
0.1367504001,
0.4876630604,
0.0479253568,
0.2232901603,
-0.3864708245,
0.1385647506,
0.5427525043,
-0.1674726009,
-0.3500955105,
0.5350743532,
0.2328340709,
-0.1948512197,
0.7131105065,
-0.0798978731,
-0.0079233376,
0.5314466953,
0.7353194356,
0.6456660032,
-0.4852419496,
0.313778758,
0.3984367549,
-0.0191705488,
-0.3813277483,
0.5449491143,
-0.158049643,
-0.7948955297,
-0.3547684252,
-0.4889041781,
-0.4615199566,
0.0422405414,
-1.1055263281,
0.3990602195,
-0.6257643104,
-0.0332498923,
-0.4990768731,
0.1461246908,
-0.4741748869,
0.1390610337,
-0.0570515543,
0.7313028574,
-0.7332157493,
1.0283870697,
0.4263204038,
-0.1244731843,
-0.7785283327,
-0.0914029405,
-0.2023618668,
-0.8949622512,
0.3355778456,
-0.0009948183,
-0.1204417497,
0.1712920219,
-0.6357008815,
-0.876583159,
1.0970419645,
0.6442891359,
-0.8463400602,
0.0078180665,
0.3347515464,
0.4046840668,
-0.2798095644,
0.1092960015,
0.9134725928,
0.2856780887,
0.2340221554,
-0.5925109386,
0.0248627886,
0.0226349402,
0.023272818,
0.3084623516,
-1.1710906029,
0.5235980153,
0.1081859469,
-0.0650819987,
-0.0283826198,
0.7995375991,
0.2593318224,
0.2154222727,
0.399019897,
0.6047149301,
0.75041008,
-0.3194723427,
0.3819302619,
-0.5093998313,
0.2848837674,
1.1513053179,
-0.4364793897,
0.7646173239,
0.4509852529,
-0.1614001393,
0.3332358599,
0.6840258837,
-0.3591071069,
0.7409804463,
-0.1385638714,
-0.3628062904,
-0.5503785014,
-0.0667725578,
-0.4596428573,
0.5835356116,
0.2133081555,
-0.2448340952,
-0.0637187287,
0.1083863899,
-0.3068746626,
0.1373284906,
-0.4566778541,
0.7077556849,
0.0039707557,
-0.8728512526,
0.7893428802,
-0.2801474333,
0.566001296,
-0.2967313528,
-0.0896990597,
-0.3733800352,
0.2630558312,
-0.4180557728,
-0.7243320942,
0.1352369338,
-0.3682676852,
-0.1202035025,
-0.4275493026,
0.5683990121,
-0.803378582,
-0.2968713343,
0.1882354915,
0.3137127757,
-0.0937573016,
0.4729989171,
-0.533154428,
0.2438553721,
0.0767045096,
-0.3963006735,
0.5558843017,
0.0404944196,
0.3519198596,
0.6851367354,
0.5650108457,
0.4871065319,
0.0017294392,
0.3949479461,
0.9934718013,
-0.4330088496,
-0.2712610066,
-0.6234205365,
0.1913879216,
0.1139608473,
-0.2905358672,
0.8286347389,
0.7762204409,
1.0591474771,
0.1991999,
0.5337947011,
0.5214930177,
0.8112167716,
-0.7023370862,
0.4942363501,
-0.3246881366,
0.4325319529,
-0.1406660974,
-1.269231081,
0.0176257566,
0.6397677064,
-0.2506644428,
0.1395883858,
0.3628207147,
0.9257500172,
-0.1832194924,
0.3147235811,
0.1453555077,
-0.1185156852,
0.2683595121,
0.5169032812,
0.8874512315,
-0.2873665392,
0.4083193243,
-0.2131401151,
-0.2453225255,
-0.1282996833,
-0.3208882809,
-0.8451253772,
-0.6070085764,
-0.401851058,
-0.2763339281,
0.2108120322,
0.8645102382,
0.6785286069,
-0.7791869044,
-0.2747196555,
-0.1575780362,
0.1586486399,
-0.3350051641,
-0.2687387466,
0.2325301319,
-0.6488598585,
-0.9110482335,
0.6396799088,
-0.0006905276,
0.1425579935,
-0.4607769847,
-0.1735888869,
0.3560581207,
0.2454178035,
0.269913137,
0.0368495509,
-0.4374730587,
-0.2729584575,
0.0020366858,
-0.2205905467,
0.1737586558,
0.7993284464,
-0.7536643147,
0.447126776,
0.3057685196,
0.5177485347,
0.6336671114,
0.0425992683,
0.3575800955,
-0.5306589007,
0.0561889447,
0.274474889,
0.157247588,
0.2447302788,
-0.3117367923,
0.5439367294,
0.0753018707,
-0.7403619289,
-1.0511171818,
0.0222351439,
-0.6855490804,
-0.2218231261,
0.9784507155,
0.0990001485,
-0.1365616024,
0.1025264859,
-0.3433275819,
0.2308892012,
-0.3976125717,
1.0955456495,
0.6967604756,
-0.2176412493,
-0.2574869096,
-0.5788887143,
0.4932551384,
0.6581699848,
-0.6583562493,
0.0759311616,
0.4106328487,
0.3897135556,
-0.3855609894,
0.3229920268,
0.0526473634,
0.2755852342,
-0.03583676,
-0.1908680499,
-0.3359170556,
-0.608041048,
-0.0119094308,
0.2711094618,
0.1683401614,
-0.1567421108
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10109v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10109v2
|
Towards Reducing Diagnostic Errors with Interpretable Risk Prediction
| 2024-02-15T17:05:48 | 2024-03-19T16:43:09 |
Denis Jered McInerney, William Dickinson, Lucy C. Flynn, Andrea C. Young, Geoffrey S. Young, Jan-Willem van de Meent, Byron C. Wallace
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Many diagnostic errors occur because clinicians cannot easily access relevant
information in patient Electronic Health Records (EHRs). In this work we
propose a method to use LLMs to identify pieces of evidence in patient EHR data
that indicate increased or decreased risk of specific diagnoses; our ultimate
aim is to increase access to evidence and reduce diagnostic errors. In
particular, we propose a Neural Additive Model to make predictions backed by
evidence with individualized risk estimates at time-points where clinicians are
still uncertain, aiming to specifically mitigate delays in diagnosis and errors
stemming from an incomplete differential. To train such a model, it is
necessary to infer temporally fine-grained retrospective labels of eventual
"true" diagnoses. We do so with LLMs, to ensure that the input text is from
before a confident diagnosis can be made. We use an LLM to retrieve an initial
pool of evidence, but then refine this set of evidence according to
correlations learned by the model. We conduct an in-depth evaluation of the
usefulness of our approach by simulating how it might be used by a clinician to
decide between a pre-defined list of differential diagnoses.
|
[
0.0786559284,
-0.4531292319,
0.9262567163,
-0.0357889012,
-0.2316632718,
-0.2096396089,
0.2198772281,
-0.8219365478,
0.2677116096,
0.3508087695,
-0.42952618,
-0.6000577211,
-0.7952653766,
-0.1085908338,
-0.1190127656,
0.8568530083,
0.0355616957,
0.5539339781,
-0.3983328938,
0.1605623215,
-0.3943904042,
-0.4295018315,
-1.0005851984,
-0.6963373423,
0.7316928506,
0.2403957546,
0.6250907183,
0.9005117416,
0.7809423208,
0.2164706141,
-0.3646697998,
0.0532575883,
0.0682040974,
0.2089189738,
0.2533645928,
-0.7677128315,
-0.9230415225,
-0.5426213145,
0.3727524579,
0.9025927186,
-0.3082238734,
0.1106809676,
-0.0902299508,
0.4040466249,
-0.4704385102,
0.0796793699,
-0.3194572031,
0.298525691,
-0.1000445783,
-0.4720523059,
-0.3497501314,
-0.3444331884,
0.3115615845,
-0.5171601176,
0.2387269288,
-0.3328264058,
0.5689183474,
0.3906166255,
-0.3599081933,
-0.1040974557,
-0.8250027895,
0.3465790153,
-0.6958275437,
0.2677661777,
0.4107578397,
0.3352456689,
-0.0870774537,
-0.7499032617,
-0.2054605037,
-0.0359059088,
-0.3117134273,
0.2547970712,
-0.201582253,
0.2962144017,
0.2582014203,
0.0184408259,
-0.2156039178,
0.5385383368,
-0.279833436,
-0.4188046455,
0.5844323635,
0.6989706755,
0.3802116513,
0.0069567678,
-0.4906876385,
0.2546081841,
-0.9514436126,
0.075548999,
0.0111322571,
0.0411486886,
0.0219634213,
0.5440937877,
0.069370307,
0.5410938859,
0.2041766047,
-0.3050008416,
0.2867915034,
0.046177201,
-0.1605331898,
0.5867625475,
0.3828216195,
0.4866265357,
-0.1387160718,
0.0244688857,
-0.266335994,
0.1838977188,
0.2133765519,
-0.6025195122,
-0.286187917,
0.5756157637,
-0.587387979,
-0.5210923553,
-0.3276514113,
-0.7772006392,
-0.738060236,
-0.2667508423,
0.5134863257,
-0.5031876564,
-0.0263411589,
0.3627620041,
0.1148537993,
-0.3813680708,
0.5636075735,
-0.5501753092,
0.5258175135,
0.3983394802,
0.651698947,
-0.0152233504,
0.013504249,
-0.5427590609,
0.284091562,
-0.4894697368,
0.7675158978,
-0.1121957153,
-0.4704021513,
-0.0383590423,
-0.0607537962,
0.0449151844,
-0.4676139057,
0.5816941857,
-0.5082246661,
-0.1260421127,
0.014924936,
-0.6690149307,
-0.3806608319,
0.2340476215,
-0.7966669202,
0.5790959001,
0.1146195307,
-0.6707881093,
0.5569945574,
-0.4854146838,
-0.5507192612,
-0.0433214717,
-0.0687910765,
-0.7065345645,
0.1726233065,
0.2852732241,
0.5112940073,
-0.2689324915,
0.5048205256,
-0.3539324105,
-0.0945896432,
0.2473729998,
-0.3991559446,
0.4323867559,
0.0214323681,
-0.1904116273,
0.2091818452,
-0.9524015188,
-0.1636262387,
0.0824135467,
-0.4014812708,
-0.5691123605,
0.3165385127,
-0.3914454281,
0.1416042298,
0.1453483403,
-0.3636611998,
-0.1228715479,
-0.4645199478,
-0.0878137946,
0.8985534906,
0.2662969828,
0.1272093654,
-0.8469839692,
0.5807344317,
0.6897066236,
0.3388395011,
-0.1878591478,
-0.5772904158,
-0.9079015851,
-0.0657479241,
0.3212679327,
0.7542766333,
-0.3395105302,
0.5493500829,
-0.4239882827,
-0.2426601201,
-0.5045537949,
-0.1857605428,
0.2403866053,
1.0210545063,
0.5966188312,
-0.3043605387,
-0.6588444114,
-0.7470953465,
0.1601839513,
-0.3309523463,
-0.2814312279,
0.2586076558,
-0.0350370891,
-0.5215984583,
0.470628351,
-0.5855895877,
-0.3842527568,
-0.0615250021,
-0.0877489895,
0.4837434292,
0.4126164615,
0.1003819704,
-0.3070231676,
-0.3121739626,
0.1965698004,
-1.041890502,
-0.0193546861,
-0.2632193565,
0.1026572287,
-0.0732965097,
0.4230573177,
-0.5947577357,
0.7733100653,
0.2710049152,
-0.3932545483,
0.0673330501,
-0.7324055433,
-0.0220510252,
-0.7981286645,
-0.3221949339,
0.1892625391,
-0.2624743879,
-0.7327823639,
-0.533437252,
0.0823927522,
0.2289986908,
-0.2450755537,
0.5943340063,
-0.3509846032,
0.1440983415,
0.005970885,
-0.2696051002,
0.1200809851,
-0.1079515368,
0.011238195,
0.2884805799,
0.6890868545,
-0.9132090807,
-0.1042981297,
0.3634658158,
-0.3507900834,
0.3729077578,
-0.7338012457,
-0.0901446417,
-0.3497137427,
-0.0845121145,
-0.7447419167,
-0.1331566423,
0.188242808,
-0.4089613557,
0.6979669333,
-0.05259284,
-0.080242604,
-0.3955405653,
-0.085482955,
0.3107171059,
0.5253077149,
-0.5634498,
0.9019201398,
0.3598490059,
-0.4510523081,
-0.6323248744,
-0.9334234595,
-0.0354826264,
-0.3402996361,
-0.7395111918,
0.6054884195,
-0.0355425552,
-0.4322650731,
0.1379912794,
0.0654062927,
-0.1347277761,
0.3985041976,
0.4832490087,
0.5612335801,
-0.3574789166,
0.5767984986,
0.3315747976,
-0.3622488678,
0.3158732951,
-0.1699440479,
0.1032784209,
0.2806896865,
-0.6720547676,
-0.547577858,
0.2757516801,
0.3544555902,
0.3589197993,
0.5153856874,
0.3185585737,
-0.81664294,
-0.1281334907,
-0.5809040666,
-0.3320752382,
-0.4054956734,
0.2841995358,
0.0451732501,
-0.4324369431,
0.8317220211,
-0.0393921547,
-0.1677154303,
0.4905416965,
0.552963376,
-0.3053293526,
0.9533669353,
0.4618472755,
0.0341649801,
0.0223935321,
-0.0301246103,
0.0510493964,
-0.8264226317,
-0.4873294532,
-0.1352865249,
-0.1725142002,
-0.4631435573,
-0.4760793746,
0.7170600295,
-0.0705896318,
-0.2802980542,
-0.2315308601,
-0.5795137882,
0.0459435582,
0.4451744258,
0.9892275333,
0.4135604203,
-0.2530544102,
-0.1358703971,
-0.102700457,
-1.0549001694,
-0.3574464619,
1.6387742758,
0.6913764477,
0.7322533131,
0.1209671125,
0.7014918327,
0.3675910532,
0.6795810461,
-0.895445168,
0.0906224027,
-0.0997409523,
-0.5541085005,
-0.1298796982,
-0.2845529318,
-0.9835627675,
-0.1086384952,
-0.3444916904,
-0.5550602674,
0.464515388,
0.499192059,
-0.8786689639,
0.3473663628,
-0.4944153428,
0.4644276202,
-0.6076582074,
-0.2010249794,
-0.1140282825,
-0.6706271172,
0.4100315273,
-0.3471471369,
0.2774115205,
-0.0647743866,
-0.3034209311,
0.6323335171,
-0.3047945201,
1.0090364218,
-0.0221820027,
0.1235120073,
0.1575309336,
0.1603582203,
0.7128756046,
0.2880927026,
-0.2089267075,
0.3007701039,
-0.1322345734,
-0.0343427546,
-0.2867670357,
0.5287327766,
-0.6965600848,
-0.5639882684,
-0.6304941177,
-0.3940096796,
-0.258227706,
0.1344350874,
0.1943187863,
0.5703040957,
-0.1023514047,
-0.2063185424,
0.812954843,
-0.2960703075,
0.3944342732,
0.4590211213,
0.3110072613,
-0.3104336858,
0.3138737082,
0.1007907465,
0.0609266125,
0.3982496262,
0.5401948094,
-0.3163609505,
-1.1959985495,
0.1552714407,
0.0043713273,
-1.167037487,
-0.4959301353,
-0.6637228131,
-0.2673453391,
-0.0795970038,
-0.0183840059,
-0.1060234085,
-0.1755176336,
-0.6730175614,
-0.3878980279,
0.5626801848,
0.701541841,
-0.2546311021,
0.4586170912,
-0.901202023,
0.2367144227,
0.1759640872,
0.4086988568,
-0.0156075638,
-0.5563248992,
-0.1936348528,
-0.0588203855,
-0.1176452935,
-0.6407291293,
0.5864671469,
0.1832240224,
0.8615934849,
0.5544057488,
0.1070184931,
0.7623237371,
-0.6592857242,
0.4304258525,
0.6048752069,
-0.7186514139,
0.6500169635,
-0.2700479031,
-0.3006901741,
0.3689825833,
0.5521457791,
-0.2956934869,
0.2030261755,
-0.8756231666,
-0.8414729238,
0.3021644354,
-0.2705174088,
-0.3067117333,
-0.1254173368,
0.5250339508,
0.0037998385,
-0.1637297273,
-0.5626504421,
-0.501046896,
0.1263023466,
-0.3176695704,
-0.2543090582,
-0.4866056144,
-0.5044984221,
-0.4774279892,
0.4937932193,
-0.1992803812,
0.4872496128,
0.5930665731,
0.0129822325,
-0.5046442151,
0.0365195461,
0.6180577278,
0.7688404322,
-0.3488510847,
0.3168795705,
0.4474582374,
-0.5084446669,
0.2006498277,
0.1619861126,
-0.0436200947,
0.2234725803,
0.3767466247,
0.7618537545,
0.17606543,
-0.5266746879,
0.3447061181,
-0.0835425854,
-0.146185562,
-0.6667369604,
-0.0509401597,
0.1664746553,
0.2339423597,
0.0124633303,
0.4693976343,
0.1396578103,
-0.0695667118,
0.6371018887,
0.2059389651,
-0.7208758593,
-0.3447037339,
0.7014682293,
0.190922603,
-0.3617833853,
0.4605438709,
0.3533907533,
-0.2842053771,
0.895755887,
0.4795621336,
0.7410569787,
-0.2517983019,
0.0482549481,
0.3642465174,
0.3436240554,
-0.2336157411,
0.209575817,
0.6726506948,
-0.8757876158,
-0.5082580447,
-0.2924708724,
-0.4037147462,
0.3715817928,
-0.7013723254,
0.5252417922,
-0.6658710837,
-0.4542629719,
0.0614384376,
-0.4567160904,
-0.7171193957,
0.4924718142,
0.216421172,
0.6926169395,
-0.6697963476,
0.6467622519,
0.3641292751,
-0.1490305513,
-0.8339385986,
-0.1343993247,
0.2220281363,
-0.9021533728,
0.6876254678,
-0.1177899987,
0.3304122388,
-0.2657764554,
0.0269725733,
-1.0040659904,
1.2126097679,
0.2063359171,
-0.6033132672,
-0.0819346085,
-0.1097191572,
0.6086656451,
-0.3531168103,
0.3752716184,
0.4034541547,
0.4268561602,
0.0695720389,
-0.6223707199,
0.3425090313,
-0.0374681912,
-0.2377911657,
0.3611806631,
0.125394851,
0.9576043487,
-0.5503863692,
-0.0161712412,
-0.1128914207,
0.1614853889,
0.1247448549,
0.6256610751,
0.2771762609,
0.5604147911,
0.9191552997,
-0.0927415863,
1.3683427572,
-0.2427095473,
0.0555825531,
1.2334291935,
-0.1985041499,
0.6881557703,
0.354629755,
-0.437507093,
0.3416199386,
0.9278904796,
0.0479247048,
0.508834362,
0.1817810088,
-0.6123395562,
-0.4102192521,
-0.0941197947,
-0.4581342638,
0.1376651973,
0.7846201062,
-0.6941733956,
-0.0984237045,
-0.3079010844,
-0.2113451809,
-0.1206744388,
-0.4514480829,
0.7972086668,
0.2085695863,
-0.4304370582,
0.4712130427,
-0.3044791818,
0.6149179935,
-0.6251565218,
-0.0507685132,
-0.0487542786,
0.5394397974,
-0.4010832608,
-0.5552483201,
0.3833349347,
-0.4404791296,
-0.1516133696,
0.0256434418,
0.8503828645,
-0.181873247,
-0.7518801689,
0.4819312096,
0.5057124496,
-0.1956707835,
0.2396759242,
-0.4953463674,
-0.4218381047,
-0.2006015629,
-0.1418166906,
0.4387924373,
0.4636979103,
-0.0466001369,
0.9263896346,
0.6256794333,
0.6428101659,
-0.1666341722,
-0.0163545925,
0.908619225,
-0.4116487801,
-0.3061771989,
-0.8222861886,
0.706576407,
0.1347317398,
-0.2789191902,
0.1347019076,
0.0183917694,
0.3884255886,
-0.0706458464,
0.7939029932,
0.4584427178,
0.680814445,
-0.7106711268,
0.6750873923,
-0.5779736042,
0.6945792437,
0.015057819,
-0.1707357168,
-0.7229914069,
0.4160815477,
-0.1646048576,
-0.1732117683,
0.6712315083,
0.4913904369,
0.1438141912,
-0.322370708,
0.4613852799,
0.2199591845,
0.2574719787,
0.7353314161,
0.7421680689,
-0.5006308556,
0.2260463238,
-0.6109051704,
-0.2424892783,
-0.2469181567,
-1.2242068052,
-0.8284192085,
0.0186704118,
-0.5118338466,
-0.6366407275,
0.113090083,
0.8456447721,
0.6217683554,
-0.7846839428,
0.1189143807,
-0.1755681187,
0.3245066702,
-0.3542047739,
-0.0287733003,
0.5037648678,
-0.0352539197,
-0.1183932945,
0.4411540329,
0.1143492758,
0.4883382618,
0.2332803309,
-0.0236224961,
-0.0485118143,
-0.1561065465,
0.3880718052,
-0.0146840988,
-0.5621421933,
-0.3573915958,
0.0103239799,
0.0770669356,
0.4155240953,
0.4745640159,
-0.7424544096,
0.5684139132,
0.3874487281,
0.6140803099,
0.4401829839,
-0.1631936878,
0.633890748,
-0.2561931312,
0.0704388395,
0.7372677326,
0.5748459101,
0.1188264936,
-1.1821210384,
0.3991558254,
0.1267227083,
-0.4063783586,
-0.4963440597,
-0.0221534856,
-0.8821032643,
-0.1112143993,
0.949185431,
-0.3491984308,
-0.0896691456,
-0.4648330212,
0.3738184273,
0.1669053584,
-0.2644168139,
0.971039176,
0.2279332578,
-0.3955124021,
-0.044714991,
-0.5269465446,
0.6402509212,
0.3587299287,
-0.9721978903,
-0.3277637362,
0.4165920913,
0.6311446428,
0.2134067118,
0.5546525121,
-0.1797436476,
0.6119599342,
-0.0754018426,
0.0990647897,
-0.1412431747,
-0.3163915277,
-0.6535283327,
-0.022539651,
0.2001512647,
-0.2817777395
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10107v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10107v1
|
Quantized Embedding Vectors for Controllable Diffusion Language Models
| 2024-02-15T17:02:48 | 2024-02-15T17:02:48 |
Cheng Kang, Xinye Chen, Yong Hu, Daniel Novak
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Improving the controllability, portability, and inference speed of diffusion
language models (DLMs) is a key challenge in natural language generation. While
recent research has shown significant success in complex text generation with
language models, the memory and computational power are still very demanding
and fall short of expectations, which naturally results in low portability and
instability for the models. To mitigate these issues, numerous well-established
methods were proposed for neural network quantization. To further enhance their
portability of independent deployment as well as improve their stability
evaluated by language perplexity, we propose a novel approach called the
Quantized Embedding Controllable Diffusion Language Model (QE-CDLM). QE-CDLM
builds upon the recent successful controllable DLMs by remodeling the
task-specific embedding space via quantization. This leads to a gradient-based
controller for the generation tasks, and more stable intermediate latent
variables are obtained, which naturally brings in an accelerated convergence as
well as better controllability. Additionally, the adaption fine-tuning method
is employed to reduce tunable weights. Experimental results on five challenging
fine-grained control tasks demonstrate that QE-CDLM compares favorably to
existing methods in terms of quality and feasibility, achieving better
perplexity and lightweight fine-tuning.
|
[
-0.2994163334,
-0.8669216037,
0.2406074703,
0.4605300128,
-0.1028975695,
0.1310522854,
-0.3167276084,
0.3112612963,
-0.1060167477,
0.277095288,
-0.0779883191,
-0.6077680588,
-0.6675822139,
-0.1362432986,
-0.3221164048,
0.8285855651,
-0.259275645,
-0.1115401387,
-0.2178107351,
-0.3648735285,
-0.1929186583,
-0.4310490787,
-1.0511606932,
-0.2130047828,
0.5583336949,
-0.1127737239,
0.9012577534,
0.507417202,
0.1222796664,
0.3032523394,
-0.3503718674,
0.0202156249,
-0.2359195054,
0.2148826271,
-0.0684608072,
-0.5217528939,
-0.6386882663,
-0.1925808787,
0.701092124,
0.6240059733,
-0.5376268625,
-0.2181518376,
0.2063148916,
0.6353646517,
-0.8469051719,
-0.2047165632,
-0.4495343566,
0.2372989058,
0.0077665946,
-0.1328016073,
-0.2357294708,
-0.5067935586,
0.1782723665,
-0.6503999233,
0.09527684,
-0.2210890204,
0.4909451604,
0.3575594723,
-0.5604949594,
-0.1470392346,
-0.9012354612,
0.882399261,
-0.8959851861,
0.2835598886,
0.3482637703,
0.2733991444,
-0.0574523322,
-0.8038025498,
-0.4428063035,
-0.1818641424,
0.2460933179,
-0.0925040171,
-0.3713050485,
0.1150982231,
0.1190092936,
0.0401678532,
-0.6066896915,
0.0808737427,
0.1572787911,
-0.2508347929,
0.4764484465,
0.2888187468,
0.2361929417,
0.0995563418,
-0.2000175118,
-0.0402716398,
-0.6960065365,
0.0733113587,
0.4002461731,
0.046195101,
-0.063521415,
0.4279901981,
-0.2653748095,
0.5924881101,
0.0987578407,
0.1499329656,
0.1035463065,
-0.3063808978,
-0.3064770997,
-0.1712823212,
0.7706035376,
0.1036397815,
0.1433832198,
-0.1447397023,
-0.4229187071,
-0.0968602598,
0.2720248401,
-0.9367750883,
-0.3591270149,
0.4173043668,
-0.4754738212,
-0.3904726207,
-0.4498938918,
-0.2916409373,
-0.0919397026,
-0.1209665909,
0.5067120194,
-0.6860502362,
-0.3479231596,
0.1675800681,
-0.005199817,
0.0486519337,
0.4065655768,
-0.8190306425,
0.16365996,
0.4816964567,
0.8956376314,
-0.3575729728,
0.0533342063,
-0.5382193923,
0.3164708316,
-0.3481477499,
0.331391871,
-0.4841684401,
-0.3188188672,
0.1494620889,
-0.2092404217,
0.0398523249,
-0.6116029024,
0.2379208803,
-0.6996147037,
0.0092674112,
0.1512452513,
-0.593136847,
0.0008970118,
0.3290681541,
-0.460219115,
0.6425043344,
0.1308208853,
-0.7290630937,
0.1202262193,
-0.4490802288,
-0.3781361282,
-0.0947012156,
-0.1258950979,
-0.6015127301,
0.1581155807,
-0.0026622664,
0.5108978152,
-0.1707859933,
0.5188579559,
-0.1168687418,
-0.113746509,
0.2469527423,
-0.664255023,
0.7401889563,
0.2651324868,
-0.3422397077,
0.2803917527,
-0.8547528386,
0.1520466805,
-0.0305418912,
-0.6587626934,
-0.6087384224,
0.1895734221,
-0.0063735745,
0.0735093504,
0.2024286091,
-0.3957799077,
0.0942100585,
-0.3950632811,
0.6327698827,
0.6270161271,
-0.0979436338,
0.9240041375,
-0.1418658644,
0.7862334847,
0.3664528728,
0.1067559198,
0.0661695004,
-0.3466277122,
-0.7547035813,
-0.1882386506,
0.5551563501,
0.4949636757,
-1.1154294014,
0.4350682795,
-0.0620282479,
-0.2729329765,
-0.4643966556,
-0.0067858221,
0.5080824494,
0.1556280851,
0.2219275385,
-0.1364208609,
0.0311767273,
-0.784814775,
-0.0509632081,
0.3788945079,
-0.2169084251,
0.1343298107,
0.2926270664,
-0.2106517255,
0.9541983604,
-0.3874389231,
0.0742119923,
0.1216475666,
0.2959945798,
-0.1540314257,
1.0259166956,
0.3450447619,
-0.8597151637,
-0.3759981394,
0.0532867424,
-0.5607783198,
0.0492802486,
0.0093974322,
-0.1799405217,
0.3134238124,
0.6174858212,
-0.4121230245,
0.494843483,
0.7108766437,
-0.4109482169,
0.2343855947,
-0.642605722,
-0.2786816061,
-1.0114004612,
-0.0145616932,
-0.0478474312,
-0.4184737504,
-0.5664045215,
-0.0569971241,
0.3120626509,
-0.0596658811,
-0.5418809056,
0.430252403,
-0.2487488091,
0.2734565735,
-0.3345805705,
0.1744480729,
0.0247077961,
0.4860352576,
-0.227660805,
0.5687937737,
0.7013394833,
-0.8901410103,
0.1802390814,
0.1214436814,
-0.0217606537,
0.5932524204,
-0.8405494094,
-0.027653791,
-0.2883421183,
0.1511838883,
-0.7522106767,
0.4250555336,
0.1350816339,
-0.2068547904,
0.4755968153,
-0.0883892626,
-0.315725863,
0.0235594437,
-0.2284457833,
0.6867271066,
0.6029170752,
-0.1950878501,
0.6008180976,
0.1240697876,
-0.0886652619,
-0.2245437056,
-0.6424772143,
-0.1922621131,
-0.2979643643,
-0.4717491269,
0.4725006223,
-0.3083548546,
-0.1283996552,
0.087568,
-0.0084300637,
-0.0352017321,
0.2906678021,
0.0945321098,
-0.2819453776,
-0.2021362334,
0.290155977,
0.7015318274,
-0.3810741901,
-0.1063108742,
-0.5968972445,
0.4231559634,
0.1441805363,
-0.0162614714,
-0.3077422082,
0.3414568305,
0.2345652282,
-0.4708635211,
0.8614336252,
0.7154305577,
-0.3169946969,
-0.5245615244,
-0.0532047227,
0.06830924,
-0.5121754408,
0.2486247271,
-0.4210393131,
-1.2377134562,
0.40320611,
-0.4022025168,
-0.0983720794,
0.1564908475,
0.6077873707,
-0.1028202102,
1.0171535015,
0.5381672382,
0.2344888747,
0.4814178348,
-0.4619362354,
-0.0252072588,
-0.9349232316,
0.0294436645,
-0.4120305479,
-0.5166969299,
-0.6885346174,
-0.6930231452,
0.3096868694,
0.4253158867,
-0.4485351741,
0.1361178011,
-0.4238471687,
0.0992080197,
0.4434322417,
-0.0041373898,
0.1814331859,
-0.0947991088,
-0.3596899211,
0.0343007818,
-0.8767151833,
-0.5109233856,
0.9185878038,
0.3220501244,
0.7737385035,
0.3298302889,
0.6198961735,
0.3424278498,
0.0923681855,
-0.4610492885,
0.442402631,
-0.5370258689,
-0.1223602295,
-0.5091295838,
-0.4650687873,
-1.0464352369,
0.379735142,
-0.0745834783,
-0.4844793975,
0.2545979321,
0.1726516038,
-0.6105486155,
0.0644086227,
-0.4895068705,
0.7611907721,
0.1683143228,
-0.362773627,
-0.2023000121,
-0.3087596595,
0.2302636653,
-0.2001668066,
0.1260732263,
-0.1553170979,
-0.4257522523,
0.6246816516,
-0.7419813275,
0.746378541,
-0.3579250872,
-0.7222715616,
0.1842745394,
0.3459619582,
0.7243251801,
0.2187163532,
-0.1286665499,
-0.1017080173,
-0.0965139791,
-0.5600770116,
-0.8212313652,
0.9933454394,
-0.5265045166,
-0.4933284819,
0.0278667789,
-0.623488605,
-0.2081455588,
0.0111916661,
0.2302144319,
0.5556269884,
-0.0374934822,
0.148634091,
0.8811535835,
-0.5963986516,
0.7601789832,
0.423820436,
-0.2380269319,
-0.6416031718,
1.1751590967,
0.2371026576,
0.498305589,
0.5209171176,
0.1547695547,
0.1176358685,
-0.7588968873,
-0.238021642,
-0.1134049296,
-0.2950766683,
-0.2857498229,
-0.6290439367,
-0.1988261491,
-0.150320977,
-0.2152881473,
-0.5309101343,
-0.6511740088,
-0.5461576581,
0.1244889349,
0.2802112699,
0.5562416315,
0.0325485058,
0.6774991155,
-0.7612870932,
0.2937262058,
0.378360033,
0.4349422455,
0.1469207257,
-0.4730092287,
-0.4304271638,
0.2008716017,
-0.365042448,
-0.6426152587,
0.4978344738,
0.1819416732,
0.2875077128,
0.344424516,
-0.0323815458,
0.3523324132,
-0.6076487899,
0.6383935809,
0.0046345736,
-1.0163888931,
0.5373898149,
-0.3671525121,
0.3083556592,
0.0035150235,
0.3847452402,
-0.1213833168,
-0.526131928,
-0.5087015629,
-0.886128962,
0.4528432786,
0.4911087155,
0.4054479301,
-0.0397239961,
0.3162398636,
-0.0651421696,
0.406896323,
-0.2987698317,
-0.3818342388,
-0.1664355993,
-0.1849029511,
0.0248751882,
-0.2944518924,
-0.0545044579,
-0.2093904912,
0.5183065534,
-0.1627469212,
0.2430533916,
0.0998549983,
0.0697466359,
-0.0723630413,
0.0664856732,
0.7925739884,
0.3453539908,
0.0177429765,
0.2576303184,
0.012064999,
-0.2904094458,
0.4250552356,
0.0214825962,
-0.4903576374,
0.0278720781,
-0.0465671383,
0.9905217886,
0.172380358,
-0.4524861574,
0.5702633262,
-0.2345675528,
-0.2976499796,
-0.1372675002,
0.1579000801,
0.2622245848,
0.5230899453,
0.1707074195,
0.1110684052,
-0.0488600619,
0.1092851982,
0.0844480917,
0.6766812801,
-0.1997947097,
-0.3390444815,
0.9787037373,
0.3259868622,
-0.3806280494,
0.3935844004,
-0.4741474986,
-0.1621566266,
0.673058033,
0.6741928458,
1.0619192123,
-0.3427504301,
0.489374429,
0.1984175593,
0.1428060234,
0.0141597763,
0.3434518576,
-0.1742877364,
-0.894928813,
-0.4507215023,
-0.7579029202,
0.0036894865,
-0.2949053347,
-0.5262727141,
-0.241958946,
-0.6200481057,
-0.4563991725,
-0.3730733097,
-0.3251588047,
-0.4369560182,
0.2551156878,
-0.0236464255,
0.8385347128,
-0.5914905071,
1.2123892307,
0.5087687373,
-0.2161404192,
-0.7187935114,
0.0556565747,
-0.5490942001,
-0.3501470089,
0.7536987662,
-0.4064111412,
0.2169065773,
0.516408205,
-0.4281879961,
-0.841049552,
1.3875110149,
0.407217145,
-0.7394083738,
-0.0478526056,
-0.077407144,
0.5306056738,
-0.1520515531,
0.0458395258,
0.49447456,
0.3587320149,
-0.084558621,
-0.6471806169,
0.1336704493,
0.0258022584,
0.6807790399,
0.3373347819,
-0.6473791003,
0.9219617248,
0.0426578857,
-0.1424417794,
0.1328206658,
0.8256359696,
0.279826045,
0.1348908544,
0.3270478249,
0.7316474319,
0.7982696891,
0.0057166796,
0.9734989405,
-0.2716115117,
0.3660620451,
0.91326195,
-0.1699981391,
0.8936912417,
0.594881773,
-0.3750461936,
0.4257742465,
0.0769491196,
0.2919172347,
0.6376560926,
0.682513535,
-0.5294191837,
-0.1394623369,
0.0196522754,
-0.145380944,
0.093025513,
0.3582881987,
-0.2966849208,
-0.1766801327,
0.595341444,
-0.0652937144,
0.097015284,
-0.3561713994,
0.593516469,
0.1540884823,
-0.2171703428,
0.958427012,
0.199608326,
0.9759431481,
-0.5613942146,
0.0790892467,
-0.4542174339,
0.0454455018,
-0.0897593647,
-0.4213097692,
0.3121762872,
-0.0934182182,
-0.1929336339,
-0.407533437,
0.4255319238,
-0.6849228144,
-0.2968598008,
0.2284558266,
0.4812682569,
-0.1647959054,
-0.1165616736,
-0.5502855778,
0.1449985802,
0.0130855506,
-0.5886976719,
0.5609719753,
0.7725116014,
-0.163358137,
0.8260294795,
0.4160886407,
0.1839662194,
0.4816581309,
-0.0376813635,
0.8410047889,
-0.5607959628,
-0.2869294584,
-0.751280129,
0.5675168037,
0.3981158435,
-0.180050388,
0.6311407685,
0.3519430161,
0.6250469089,
-0.2150685936,
0.7658000588,
-0.1536694467,
-0.0034916862,
-0.6333376765,
0.9909822941,
-0.6243209839,
0.16178599,
-0.0499263816,
-0.751716733,
-0.3940963745,
0.4957078993,
0.0561355054,
0.1294356436,
0.6785013676,
0.8193144202,
0.1634225547,
-0.5097280145,
0.6016697884,
0.2586479485,
0.442999959,
0.688675642,
0.6247776151,
-0.5040625334,
0.5082574487,
-0.3034718335,
-0.001095295,
0.0737741068,
-0.9676239491,
-0.6248260736,
-0.5990692377,
-0.7501655221,
-0.3616373241,
0.0608201288,
0.5195371509,
0.5512648821,
-0.8564166427,
0.036810752,
-0.6768898368,
0.1561693698,
-0.0527719632,
-0.2250545323,
0.4385389388,
-0.4731423259,
-0.9727022648,
0.2844235301,
0.3284216225,
0.3049224913,
-0.4278387725,
-0.4183056653,
-0.0883794799,
0.0589760579,
0.6710889339,
0.0903823301,
-0.5401571393,
0.0020466817,
-0.333781153,
-0.3996334672,
-0.2327272594,
0.8794445395,
-0.8263397813,
0.3309653401,
0.5206021667,
0.8436197639,
0.2325587273,
-0.1024578512,
0.8458918929,
-0.9545236826,
0.2385882437,
0.304594785,
0.1602262557,
0.0978705436,
-0.0930254757,
0.1517753154,
0.0738708898,
-0.5927318931,
-0.5529548526,
0.0581688136,
-0.9216814041,
-0.316783011,
1.0748441219,
-0.3958729208,
-0.2526519597,
0.0810188055,
-0.3321116567,
0.4620313048,
-0.3365758657,
0.3339822888,
0.3976854682,
0.1752543151,
-0.200731799,
-0.3084448874,
0.6593601108,
0.640180707,
-0.5963131785,
-0.0036737258,
0.1883843094,
0.2026248276,
-0.0115683191,
0.6636632681,
0.0787301287,
0.0733784735,
-0.2008715272,
0.1166478768,
-0.0885611251,
-0.0497444458,
-0.7748863101,
0.3416044414,
0.1805344224,
-0.281588912
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10104v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10104v2
|
GeoEval: Benchmark for Evaluating LLMs and Multi-Modal Models on Geometry Problem-Solving
| 2024-02-15T16:59:41 | 2024-05-17T11:42:09 |
Jiaxin Zhang, Zhongzhi Li, Mingliang Zhang, Fei Yin, Chenglin Liu, Yashar Moshfeghi
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) and multi-modal models
(MMs) have demonstrated their remarkable capabilities in problem-solving. Yet,
their proficiency in tackling geometry math problems, which necessitates an
integrated understanding of both textual and visual information, has not been
thoroughly evaluated. To address this gap, we introduce the GeoEval benchmark,
a comprehensive collection that includes a main subset of 2,000 problems, a 750
problems subset focusing on backward reasoning, an augmented subset of 2,000
problems, and a hard subset of 300 problems. This benchmark facilitates a
deeper investigation into the performance of LLMs and MMs in solving geometry
math problems. Our evaluation of ten LLMs and MMs across these varied subsets
reveals that the WizardMath model excels, achieving a 55.67\% accuracy rate on
the main subset but only a 6.00\% accuracy on the hard subset. This highlights
the critical need for testing models against datasets on which they have not
been pre-trained. Additionally, our findings indicate that GPT-series models
perform more effectively on problems they have rephrased, suggesting a
promising method for enhancing model capabilities.
|
[
-0.237720415,
-0.9278768897,
0.7012928128,
0.3144916892,
0.0954388678,
0.0006788272,
-0.1802002639,
-0.1809076816,
-0.1957374513,
0.2052580267,
-0.7033903599,
-0.7620835304,
-0.657807827,
0.0815516859,
-0.4235105813,
0.7437692285,
-0.2244066149,
0.2936619818,
-0.5293577313,
-0.1447476596,
-0.5268058181,
-0.6987798214,
0.0161165986,
-0.100306578,
0.1973448694,
0.0217182059,
0.8796850443,
0.3845056593,
0.851282239,
0.3492510915,
-0.1376500577,
0.3680481613,
-0.6409931183,
0.1557869762,
-0.0413701572,
-0.2965399325,
-0.4924049973,
0.1543432623,
0.6798781753,
1.0455120802,
-0.3805289865,
0.4472853541,
0.1427131742,
0.6998240948,
-0.7122662067,
0.2450776994,
-0.4572046995,
-0.132224977,
-0.0918991715,
-0.0789154842,
-0.1058938205,
-0.6259909868,
0.355103761,
-1.1262214184,
0.316591084,
0.1937826425,
0.5726569295,
0.3805877566,
-0.2867254913,
-0.3082868755,
-0.7987511158,
0.7513518333,
-0.2970791459,
0.7580087781,
0.4016727507,
0.4762376547,
-0.3627337813,
-0.5030179024,
-0.0709153786,
-0.3270575404,
0.1295452714,
0.2141516209,
-0.1297983229,
-0.3031954467,
0.551707685,
0.3003563881,
-0.8088953495,
-0.3440458477,
-0.6126022339,
-0.2269234508,
0.5006102324,
0.4690324664,
0.0718216673,
-0.3887782097,
-0.3445936441,
0.0561486408,
-0.8784233928,
-0.0047333972,
0.2420883179,
0.265302211,
0.0404063426,
0.8431553245,
-0.2716058493,
0.6040697694,
-0.4442373514,
-0.2706975043,
0.1625198424,
-0.3752616346,
-0.3523724079,
-0.4667356014,
0.278178066,
0.2886583805,
0.3861965239,
-0.0065311976,
-0.0632040873,
0.0895331949,
0.0210072566,
-0.765273571,
-0.2832911313,
-0.0404829532,
-0.3458998203,
0.2271756232,
-0.2820232213,
-0.75982517,
-0.5341702104,
-0.7684496641,
0.316922009,
-0.4715334475,
-0.1977300346,
0.2519443333,
0.1536298841,
0.0873800963,
0.5105755329,
-0.5801928639,
0.2102013677,
1.0271923542,
0.8892065287,
0.0717464909,
-0.6230840087,
-0.6759153605,
-0.0488664024,
-0.4940637052,
1.0061948299,
-0.6686547399,
-0.7243391275,
0.013777311,
-0.189154461,
-0.2067251354,
-0.5649670362,
0.5697999597,
-0.3951801658,
0.2559813559,
-0.5827690959,
-0.5350934267,
-0.3045972586,
0.6118705869,
-0.5791056752,
1.2718658447,
0.1347546428,
-0.322432071,
0.3637166023,
-0.2101543844,
0.0965690762,
0.1165895611,
-0.2605482638,
-0.2752601206,
0.6026155353,
0.4708607495,
-0.0501245037,
-0.6552516222,
0.2624314427,
-0.5082403421,
-0.4111166298,
-0.1034504399,
-0.614000082,
0.2592978477,
-0.047517322,
0.013866582,
0.0214079954,
-0.6519514322,
0.3277556598,
0.0694824383,
-0.2668176293,
-0.2709220052,
0.0649638623,
0.1166411266,
0.1766074747,
0.3294902146,
-0.1515340507,
0.1263364255,
-0.1826968938,
-0.1172217429,
0.7481430769,
-0.3604393005,
-0.0476323217,
-0.1509514302,
0.4976147115,
-0.3664880693,
0.1901052445,
-0.1163862422,
-0.5757316947,
-0.528665483,
-0.3905172646,
0.0682125315,
0.6044515371,
-0.4078474939,
0.0026634391,
-0.3898013234,
-0.715675056,
-0.2018350512,
0.2324073613,
0.4966311753,
0.5524424911,
0.6797527075,
-0.0273805819,
-0.0096062366,
-0.8180282712,
-0.6658809781,
-0.0972140431,
-0.158411324,
0.4776233137,
0.5937619805,
0.2732283771,
0.7770233154,
-0.6000320911,
-0.1070532352,
0.1490716487,
0.2835354805,
0.1940799057,
0.0864235535,
0.4024257958,
-0.5571877956,
-0.3982101679,
-0.1188709512,
-0.9908211827,
-0.2112980783,
0.4186389446,
0.0830579847,
0.1171056852,
0.359346211,
-0.4760538936,
0.8852665424,
0.5691196918,
-0.5214158297,
0.8004656434,
-0.4041447341,
0.3676861823,
-0.7815907001,
0.0953122005,
0.2639088035,
-0.0937165096,
-0.3465336263,
-0.1187942028,
0.0668671876,
-0.4829754233,
-0.4322887957,
0.4153862894,
-0.7131317854,
-0.4666152,
-0.0910136476,
0.1596429348,
0.0579330437,
0.3818839192,
0.0042388332,
1.0550186634,
0.5917214155,
-0.3074861169,
0.6059055924,
0.2511038482,
-0.4748183191,
1.0744723082,
-0.915761888,
-0.018637849,
-0.2027101219,
0.0227873791,
-0.9484685063,
-0.0162832253,
-0.1170363873,
-0.0463961475,
-0.0704169795,
-0.2873406708,
-0.6111869216,
-0.2920378447,
-0.2408272922,
0.6057780385,
0.3729154766,
-0.6602126956,
0.8823643923,
0.0450662486,
-0.3288263381,
-0.5087757111,
-0.2371483892,
-0.1181795299,
-0.2746765912,
-0.7647093534,
0.1911477149,
-0.0275276657,
-0.2388437092,
0.1005811691,
-0.2643067539,
0.0850210413,
0.009728957,
0.2377436757,
0.5448573232,
-0.423969686,
0.1977125257,
-0.4091621339,
-0.4707593024,
0.1006472707,
-0.1937235743,
0.4997823834,
-0.6731488109,
-0.9767987728,
-0.383787632,
0.3765694201,
0.613168776,
-0.4507635236,
0.5775040388,
0.1375718713,
-0.5997182727,
0.1951509267,
-0.7305896878,
0.1437367052,
-0.4450019002,
0.6554533839,
-0.6522307992,
-0.3896923363,
0.5225380659,
-0.3216249943,
-0.0657931119,
0.4062360227,
0.5276876688,
0.2687036395,
1.0946471691,
0.6167615056,
-0.1525021642,
0.090304859,
-0.140825972,
0.0793797225,
-0.7951335907,
-0.5042325854,
-0.5593874454,
-0.1898599416,
-0.4972558618,
-0.5478435755,
0.776904881,
0.3451495171,
-0.3416262269,
0.2028271407,
-0.3785651326,
0.834595561,
0.2947094738,
-0.1464016587,
0.7076156735,
0.1476368606,
-0.0750575662,
-0.277808547,
-0.3595846891,
-0.5756433606,
1.3812096119,
0.0540607311,
1.0184364319,
0.4595996141,
0.1062044874,
-0.0738200769,
0.4851850271,
-0.5452738404,
0.3733391464,
0.0070685064,
-0.7234007716,
-0.1540903151,
-0.476985693,
-0.7100635767,
0.6088591218,
-0.1342601031,
-0.8493881226,
-0.0123370895,
-0.0281122141,
-0.3576918244,
0.3499371409,
-0.6628423929,
0.8967544436,
-0.4012402892,
-0.5279561877,
-0.4053245187,
-0.1531964391,
0.2528957129,
0.1028383821,
0.1408430785,
-0.4477048814,
-0.1175090745,
0.3261701167,
-0.4151346684,
0.3675756156,
-0.0902975872,
0.0780035332,
0.1097834781,
0.3954831958,
0.2608564198,
0.464348793,
0.0310042519,
0.3051801324,
0.2009073198,
-0.5314967632,
-0.6807867885,
0.7387512326,
-0.8876283169,
-0.7040994763,
-0.5902258754,
-0.701464355,
-0.3783757985,
0.1006802097,
0.0778410807,
1.0408716202,
-0.4411998987,
0.0235731639,
0.578463316,
-0.0111284247,
0.2928149402,
0.4242062569,
-0.595810473,
-0.6241157055,
0.6860634089,
0.1838897467,
0.1976257712,
-0.0637598038,
0.0717866272,
-0.5594773293,
-0.4970146418,
-0.5920780301,
0.3237077594,
-0.8874593973,
-0.1743648648,
-0.2170751393,
-0.2427477837,
-0.0330169983,
-0.0465312116,
-0.5557643771,
-0.3454681337,
-0.0971088037,
0.2758360803,
0.268411696,
0.9944596291,
0.0849711671,
0.0994776487,
-0.6475271583,
0.1773537099,
0.34510535,
0.5245379806,
-0.1741553545,
-0.3699248135,
0.0392147377,
-0.2322082669,
-0.4482290745,
-0.6252784133,
0.2628927231,
-0.0165514387,
0.5599170923,
-0.0005433836,
-0.464251399,
0.9824374318,
-0.7501379848,
0.6388686299,
0.0216315072,
-0.9689564109,
0.4471010566,
-0.4439888895,
0.165115431,
0.6239680052,
0.5155609846,
-0.5299324393,
0.1356073171,
-0.3497162461,
-0.5206855536,
0.2987061739,
0.093035467,
-0.1667306274,
0.227555722,
0.3629187346,
0.0315699279,
0.1731205881,
-0.3654955029,
-0.0106646055,
-0.1986429095,
-0.1304615587,
-0.1826797873,
-0.2011503726,
-0.2554501891,
-0.3474442363,
0.4599844813,
-0.2116786689,
0.0018844658,
0.2604912817,
-0.4234703481,
0.0546001643,
0.0983982906,
0.8784330487,
1.2837057114,
-0.1656704396,
-0.1222495139,
0.4788685143,
-0.5456806421,
-0.111590445,
0.632802248,
0.1937699318,
-0.1961569488,
0.3780843318,
0.3391918242,
0.0925790146,
-0.457185775,
0.5310521722,
-0.1110909432,
-0.1356071234,
-0.2452926338,
-0.2717708051,
0.1182830632,
0.3104574978,
0.5090278387,
0.0402155742,
0.1269160956,
-0.1622550339,
-0.0388681293,
0.686725378,
-0.1808206439,
-0.4633378088,
0.5755135417,
0.1496763825,
-0.2835997343,
0.8667407036,
0.0261364207,
-0.6505576372,
0.6085134149,
0.4615163207,
0.5929716825,
-0.0320878923,
0.0653057471,
0.4767757654,
0.2971832752,
0.0663362816,
0.3954217434,
0.0836922601,
-0.227210477,
-0.5147276521,
-0.4283003211,
-0.6613840461,
0.0215994325,
-0.5686495304,
0.3294150531,
-0.5822554827,
0.0394778587,
-0.2741934061,
0.1898147911,
-0.9621058702,
-0.0037204952,
0.2095226049,
0.9623516202,
-0.6969973445,
0.2301783413,
0.5245815516,
-0.2156696022,
-0.6797372103,
-0.1064661443,
0.4768501222,
-0.9283944964,
0.602891624,
0.2937892973,
-0.4789365232,
-0.1544873565,
-0.2612936795,
-1.2123398781,
1.2664579153,
0.3320791423,
-0.3715308011,
0.0441988483,
0.370472014,
0.4592732489,
-0.1689077914,
0.6798101068,
0.5603988767,
0.3924867511,
0.1774758399,
-1.1554620266,
-0.1863909364,
-0.1985959411,
0.2008931786,
0.3746626973,
-0.6224938035,
0.9417194724,
-0.0863461941,
-0.208105728,
0.4168005288,
0.6501587033,
0.6081019044,
0.367721051,
0.2886786759,
0.7839221358,
1.0644286871,
-0.4321617484,
1.1347042322,
-0.2858068943,
0.7646580935,
0.9382312894,
-0.4770908356,
0.7695494294,
0.1692395359,
-0.371448189,
0.4394321144,
0.6518880725,
0.0142627973,
0.4375576675,
0.3733257055,
-0.1514826566,
-0.5292840004,
-0.1272482723,
-1.0574455261,
0.35751459,
0.4108780324,
0.299433738,
-0.8114834428,
-0.3045396507,
-0.1137039661,
0.1994808763,
-0.4672695398,
0.3836285174,
-0.0460125692,
-0.3764681518,
0.4963253736,
-0.1942820996,
0.3320117593,
-0.5655819178,
0.0037452979,
-0.3228340447,
0.2727488279,
-0.1154489815,
-0.5702062249,
0.3073808849,
-0.0384846814,
-0.1957366318,
0.0543725416,
0.5328699946,
-0.2217620611,
-1.0270863771,
0.0149693042,
0.9745481014,
0.0262719952,
-0.1515787393,
-0.681360364,
-0.0432645008,
-0.6836208105,
-0.2951846123,
-0.0635328665,
0.4406511486,
-0.1334122717,
0.715154171,
0.7945719361,
-0.031588383,
0.1688632965,
0.1162367538,
1.0467764139,
-0.7251011729,
-0.3738049567,
-0.8793624043,
0.4227850437,
-0.15622513,
-0.7024788857,
0.9183681011,
0.9253432155,
0.5854534507,
0.1908436269,
0.3931882381,
0.4214710593,
0.4461568594,
-0.6353626847,
0.4017644823,
-0.6262127757,
0.2995772362,
-0.1649480462,
-1.2855439186,
-0.4484919906,
0.4305901825,
-0.9459742904,
0.3088314235,
0.9380569458,
0.7071595788,
-0.2712562382,
0.3969953954,
0.295417577,
-0.2752466798,
0.4424983263,
0.8029472232,
1.3875386715,
-0.3434136808,
0.6330627799,
0.0475572683,
-0.3624055684,
0.0056709968,
-1.032438755,
-1.0440560579,
-0.1591197252,
-0.0662431717,
-0.314168036,
0.0041931421,
0.8790723085,
0.785928905,
-0.5309630036,
-0.1601231098,
0.0438895747,
0.1953451335,
-0.0701285675,
-0.0873558,
0.6243902445,
-0.3546995819,
-0.7010290623,
0.5109487772,
0.4336386621,
-0.0630230606,
-0.448576957,
0.1284736246,
0.1114600375,
0.0230691768,
0.3866757154,
0.0604612529,
-0.7149806619,
-0.2858662009,
0.3405757844,
-0.0162968412,
0.0984423235,
0.9833035469,
-0.856387794,
0.3276076317,
0.4484514594,
0.7357070446,
0.5024163723,
0.2537906468,
0.3168335855,
-0.3309198618,
-0.0060527814,
-0.0530234762,
0.435838908,
0.4771543145,
-0.0702838525,
0.5182740092,
0.5039878488,
-0.6807458997,
-0.7025222182,
0.2508337498,
-0.4618315399,
-0.1325214803,
0.8038990498,
0.0373354703,
-0.2824778557,
0.0764885917,
0.0573067851,
-0.354209125,
0.050885547,
0.5952507257,
1.0148683786,
-0.1829203665,
0.2406527102,
-0.8761540651,
0.3170134127,
0.783102572,
-0.9980185032,
0.1400220841,
0.8338525891,
0.4433937073,
0.239591226,
0.3583592176,
-0.1818537861,
0.4005752206,
-0.0106433034,
-0.3142365813,
-0.2355119288,
-0.827250123,
-0.3933364749,
0.2095786184,
-0.1141159236,
0.0519641861
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10076v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10076v1
|
QUICK: Quantization-aware Interleaving and Conflict-free Kernel for efficient LLM inference
| 2024-02-15T16:38:41 | 2024-02-15T16:38:41 |
Taesu Kim, Jongho Lee, Daehyun Ahn, Sarang Kim, Jiwoong Choi, Minkyu Kim, Hyungjun Kim
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We introduce QUICK, a group of novel optimized CUDA kernels for the efficient
inference of quantized Large Language Models (LLMs). QUICK addresses the shared
memory bank-conflict problem of state-of-the-art mixed precision matrix
multiplication kernels. Our method interleaves the quantized weight matrices of
LLMs offline to skip the shared memory write-back after the dequantization. We
demonstrate up to 1.91x speedup over existing kernels of AutoAWQ on larger
batches and up to 1.94x throughput gain on representative LLM models on various
NVIDIA GPU devices.
|
[
-0.2768253684,
-1.0812805891,
0.5178358555,
0.5643440485,
-0.3020982146,
0.2068295628,
-0.1510844827,
-0.2208219469,
0.084260717,
0.2271265537,
-0.1248004884,
-0.3265658021,
-0.656164825,
-0.1571652293,
-0.5753083825,
0.644157052,
0.0226691011,
-0.0460707732,
-0.4744000435,
-0.3889528215,
0.012743542,
-0.6255629063,
-0.7846450806,
0.0795828849,
0.6029859781,
0.4085552692,
0.9516502023,
0.6945171356,
0.4900051355,
0.3334543109,
-0.2476025969,
0.1044943482,
-0.2538788319,
0.2539363801,
0.2758573294,
-0.5700970888,
-0.72060287,
-0.1201962233,
0.7518196702,
0.3682340384,
-0.3033033311,
0.1616333425,
0.0208374634,
0.6138979793,
-1.0421850681,
-0.0883573741,
-0.3837533593,
0.2072764337,
-0.3406606019,
0.0472484864,
-0.4938807189,
-0.8229670525,
-0.1434600502,
-0.9413548708,
0.1852877438,
0.0763059556,
0.5165485144,
0.6204651594,
-0.7396570444,
-0.1095662862,
-0.5778910518,
0.8518287539,
-0.7493853569,
0.5790638924,
0.3630717397,
0.3423545659,
-0.07062345,
-1.1454185247,
-0.8151164055,
0.2658469677,
0.0003881977,
0.0212535281,
-0.3960111141,
0.3676997721,
0.4896074533,
0.5470916033,
-0.269184947,
0.1588695943,
0.0231276881,
-0.3168312907,
0.3149748147,
0.2699498236,
0.0000401361,
0.0771438777,
-0.3924779892,
-0.1031548977,
-0.7647413611,
0.191323474,
0.2795265019,
-0.2809924483,
-0.227754876,
0.2878162861,
-0.1093208566,
0.6853223443,
0.2496517599,
-0.0344362594,
-0.1847513169,
-0.4176239371,
-0.5942966342,
0.0356696174,
0.7523670197,
0.1008374244,
-0.1462656111,
-0.1569791436,
-0.2347872555,
0.2683109939,
-0.2439328581,
-0.9499964714,
-0.4339203537,
0.3459042311,
-0.3914395571,
0.012576852,
-0.4976512492,
-0.5849833488,
-0.1051843539,
-0.0863428414,
0.8491438031,
-0.5090070963,
-0.1410746723,
0.0022120124,
0.1659497321,
0.248036474,
0.3011445999,
-0.8547926545,
0.2708922625,
0.7554370165,
0.6926112175,
0.0239471551,
0.0838081241,
-1.1714749336,
0.2197594494,
-0.3277800381,
0.5770344734,
-0.3046188056,
-0.3958601654,
-0.2885222137,
-0.3184729218,
0.0713408217,
-0.6508507729,
0.5465219021,
-0.7656239867,
-0.0865081102,
-0.3989920616,
-0.7680341005,
-0.1823398173,
0.0273346305,
-0.7922355533,
1.1333432198,
0.1186461002,
-0.770522058,
0.3837458789,
-0.1487404108,
-0.3019424081,
0.1378990561,
-0.0865252092,
-0.5376276374,
0.228109166,
0.1617068648,
0.4352884293,
-0.1988808811,
0.6372333169,
-0.6043516397,
-0.4308181405,
0.1140602231,
-0.1221108288,
0.9112564921,
0.6190410256,
-0.0176544525,
0.3889722526,
-0.6740936041,
0.1651123613,
-0.1444214433,
-0.4234567285,
-0.5840204954,
-0.0642232448,
-0.3666285276,
0.0196326189,
0.3426974416,
-0.3566054106,
0.281680733,
0.2221010923,
0.6175435781,
0.7345837951,
-0.3100753129,
0.5742715597,
-0.0887169093,
0.4279652536,
0.4496759176,
0.4942618906,
-0.0567629896,
-0.5281105042,
-1.0948839188,
-0.7094593644,
0.5560701489,
0.523404181,
-1.1182746887,
0.0932151899,
0.0852017105,
-0.1925804466,
-0.8691841364,
0.0610040165,
0.6871625185,
0.5821409822,
0.2518280149,
-0.0657900274,
-0.4423128068,
-1.1186677217,
-0.3456475437,
0.0857941657,
0.1352479905,
0.0830757916,
0.0330395587,
-0.326665163,
0.9163722396,
-0.329577297,
0.218405202,
0.1040666252,
0.2286239862,
0.1493278146,
0.4407370985,
0.433342427,
-0.6636123061,
-0.7942223549,
-0.3425046206,
-0.687574923,
-0.2258187532,
0.1137384251,
-0.2835145891,
0.2831498981,
0.7230556607,
-0.4273302555,
0.3877128661,
0.8090611696,
-0.4800375998,
0.1263522655,
-0.5092604756,
0.1853844672,
-0.9220383763,
-0.2226701677,
-0.0031409233,
-0.5128121972,
-0.7268132567,
0.1071728468,
0.7466720939,
0.3578514159,
-0.5886781216,
0.5566545129,
-0.2684234381,
-0.2664068937,
0.0709522814,
-0.1022831425,
0.1151645109,
0.3887147605,
-0.2255297899,
1.1748993397,
0.5106781125,
-0.8813964128,
0.0436892211,
0.2266837209,
-0.3825879693,
0.4477360547,
-0.4678174257,
0.0565304235,
-0.045277264,
0.1053709611,
-0.8597247601,
0.1911525279,
-0.1219934225,
-0.1094211042,
0.0726111606,
0.0276806373,
-0.6706709266,
-0.0936600119,
-0.2251675427,
0.8685276508,
0.4386779666,
-0.8087710738,
0.6764621139,
0.3794175088,
-0.0257259924,
-0.6093845963,
-0.6100993156,
-0.0309698321,
-0.3163916171,
-0.6592256427,
0.1904848814,
-0.4838624299,
-0.6500321031,
-0.0232451838,
0.1057294682,
-0.480835855,
0.2490733564,
0.2632823884,
0.1261322945,
-0.2284382284,
0.0883880928,
0.4541729689,
-0.2107192427,
-0.2956465781,
0.188280791,
0.2627485096,
-0.3997657001,
0.0417956263,
-0.4264364243,
0.5248394012,
0.2308455259,
-0.0390263051,
0.5264768004,
0.6522089243,
-0.281168431,
0.0542582236,
-0.7395333648,
-0.1068098992,
-0.5266840458,
0.0094909286,
-0.4646873772,
-1.3178728819,
0.7229104638,
-0.079306148,
-0.0115054818,
0.4582633078,
0.5060591102,
-0.1315062344,
0.7333889008,
0.704138279,
0.2242925316,
0.3867480159,
-0.3176551163,
0.3647806346,
-0.8258939385,
-0.0879888758,
-0.2745250762,
-0.512224853,
-0.3325791061,
-0.6855221987,
0.4687609673,
0.5316736698,
-0.2427327037,
0.2189903706,
-0.1536130756,
0.5197882652,
0.9146881104,
0.036352098,
0.5306951404,
-0.2876798809,
-0.3479194045,
-0.1649277657,
-0.841458559,
0.0354298875,
0.9019007683,
0.0716091543,
0.734128952,
0.0942799002,
0.6142706275,
0.3499143124,
0.3361654282,
-0.6086012125,
0.7105678916,
-0.269790262,
-0.3459244668,
0.0153500289,
-0.6427848935,
-0.5973834991,
0.2711161077,
-0.2110960186,
-0.2461378276,
0.3202360272,
0.4019094706,
-1.0426292419,
0.4868967533,
-1.075928092,
0.627643764,
0.0107810562,
-0.4369759262,
-0.5547913313,
-0.4374643564,
0.9659182429,
-0.4129607081,
0.1055900827,
-0.1593030095,
-0.1636948138,
0.8383396268,
-0.5174607635,
0.4563021064,
-0.0095394775,
-0.2520554364,
0.5209665298,
0.3318398297,
0.543913424,
0.2664759159,
-0.0242480803,
0.4999857247,
0.0910766795,
-0.2886756063,
-0.3477393389,
0.9286288619,
-0.6072676778,
-0.5260216594,
-0.208163023,
-0.8579252362,
-0.1831661612,
-0.074586235,
0.1326474547,
0.2746116817,
0.2049962729,
0.0244583059,
0.9239155054,
-0.386280328,
1.0969160795,
0.5721365809,
-0.0581804477,
-0.7240665555,
0.6278002262,
0.0800843835,
0.3351196945,
0.3544472456,
0.0655526668,
-0.1626954675,
-0.3802173138,
-0.1537804753,
0.1259509325,
-0.5436722636,
-0.5184938312,
-0.8644576669,
-0.0611788668,
-0.3361082971,
-0.1872861832,
-0.507797122,
-0.8586372137,
-0.2138366401,
0.1603197902,
0.6191791296,
0.5249543786,
-0.4272805452,
0.9864555597,
-0.9802219868,
0.6278669834,
0.6246191263,
0.4630324543,
0.0427773967,
-0.3486609459,
-0.5193746686,
-0.1855008006,
-0.3601399362,
-0.4853531718,
0.4039857686,
0.250584662,
0.3609359562,
0.5530231595,
0.057901103,
1.0287981033,
-0.001977951,
0.4114167988,
0.2813220918,
-1.3195836544,
0.1103702709,
0.110616371,
0.2418634295,
0.3444072902,
0.4042098224,
-0.5473375916,
-0.2768695354,
-0.4481672347,
-0.818828702,
0.4369426072,
-0.0320921242,
-0.5568979383,
-0.1698478311,
0.3731658161,
0.2244696021,
0.1698245853,
-0.4287123978,
-0.3702099323,
0.2455814332,
-0.1255804598,
0.1427368075,
-0.7868056893,
-0.0276194364,
-0.6152792573,
0.5288015008,
-0.1066793278,
0.2503553331,
0.1515800804,
-0.34567222,
-0.1508464217,
0.0083091399,
0.6366148591,
0.416446358,
-0.2201283276,
0.3294211626,
0.2845181823,
-0.5509492755,
0.1626652628,
-0.0923905745,
-0.0906836987,
-0.1272935122,
-0.0521730706,
0.8115269542,
0.5122035146,
-0.3599011302,
0.4102074206,
-0.702023983,
-0.2984669805,
-0.0018880523,
0.007154502,
0.2832489908,
0.740091145,
0.3289285004,
-0.2911564112,
0.0009322281,
-0.0853206068,
0.417460531,
0.5743752122,
0.0320403092,
-0.2976572514,
0.9565108418,
0.2017304152,
-0.1575691104,
0.7507264614,
-0.2969950736,
-0.231347248,
0.4784950912,
0.3149747252,
0.8744148016,
-0.3954339027,
-0.270126909,
0.3112685382,
-0.1259141564,
0.053128995,
0.5151170492,
-0.4098857641,
-0.5532636642,
-0.9072317481,
-0.7172614932,
-0.5921458602,
-0.052039694,
-0.6090202332,
0.1280084103,
-0.4968467057,
-0.3325796723,
-0.1696121544,
0.0163791496,
-0.4862061441,
0.0989953801,
0.117497161,
0.8532371521,
-0.4683918655,
1.5673108101,
0.0182436518,
0.2924128771,
-0.6616197824,
-0.5527488589,
-0.2774798274,
-0.8828719258,
0.8446331024,
-0.2262768894,
0.2951792777,
0.3033756912,
-0.3970850706,
-0.8300001025,
1.1236326694,
0.5635449886,
-1.0678668022,
-0.0667060688,
0.0263049807,
-0.1815574765,
0.1218497306,
0.4157593846,
0.6496368647,
0.3845820427,
-0.1258411855,
-0.8718269467,
-0.1236537471,
0.1158613712,
-0.1233654618,
0.7367371321,
-0.8093910813,
1.2975789309,
-0.4050338268,
-0.1876190305,
-0.0403310321,
1.0781545639,
0.1084870324,
0.4651103318,
0.5343284607,
1.2719627619,
0.8111689091,
-0.1386893988,
0.7161310315,
-0.547116518,
0.3053372502,
1.0916866064,
-0.1823580563,
0.8024277091,
0.7484292388,
-0.1726649553,
0.0608432069,
0.6187013388,
0.4631491303,
0.5639417171,
0.0124508264,
-0.8665100336,
-0.5434963107,
0.268466413,
-0.368093431,
0.1998304576,
0.444138974,
-0.0775951967,
-0.3670641184,
-0.1120535806,
0.0241507869,
-0.3209165335,
-0.4729110599,
0.6483686566,
0.2888801396,
-0.4803426862,
0.6104637384,
0.0844368935,
1.0878024101,
-0.4883747101,
0.1043492332,
-0.5693975687,
0.3862578571,
-0.0960328504,
-0.5805527568,
0.3829320669,
-0.2119416445,
-0.1393122077,
-0.3221286833,
0.4479215443,
-0.6239103079,
-0.3015964627,
0.2784413397,
0.4337500334,
-0.1614634544,
-0.1613353938,
-0.3563421369,
0.2705322802,
-0.1345362663,
-0.2047487199,
0.613386631,
0.4288824797,
-0.2994116843,
0.7839378119,
0.5741227865,
-0.1664388776,
0.5652798414,
-0.4084807634,
0.7160963416,
-0.8650146723,
-0.4885064363,
-0.9981063008,
0.1357571781,
0.3770110905,
-0.1208592355,
0.8202172518,
0.7774447799,
0.5918927193,
0.085074842,
0.3974136114,
0.2402448952,
0.2107771039,
-0.4738322794,
0.7941355705,
-0.3446184993,
-0.091243647,
0.2415609956,
-0.7669221759,
-0.2390296757,
0.3651205301,
0.0248373114,
-0.3658369482,
0.612605989,
0.6106929183,
-0.1761025786,
-0.0996609703,
0.6512274742,
0.3085654378,
0.2985429466,
1.0528900623,
0.5782698989,
-0.5536030531,
0.3759912252,
-0.6643210053,
-0.0709035695,
-0.2109135687,
-1.2916846275,
-0.3937671185,
-0.586286366,
-0.6206424832,
-0.274767518,
-0.0410886928,
0.588765204,
0.5910406113,
-0.5007984042,
-0.2162431479,
0.0992959738,
0.1870144308,
0.1090907454,
-0.2197060883,
0.3380615711,
-0.2218731642,
-0.7648690343,
0.3247994781,
0.430390507,
0.1847010255,
-0.1545469463,
-0.3611116111,
-0.1519402266,
0.3267962337,
0.8263291717,
0.309874475,
-0.4745186269,
0.0348158553,
-0.1938805431,
-0.2783857584,
0.2331728041,
1.0738230944,
-1.1824483871,
0.2107427567,
0.4882385731,
0.6164125204,
0.5457209945,
-0.3355169892,
0.3326419592,
-0.5244184732,
0.492102921,
0.209265247,
0.5134155154,
0.1301779449,
-0.3086969852,
0.2301005721,
0.2150473297,
-0.6597492099,
-0.830326438,
-0.1100061834,
-1.1667386293,
-0.0362720601,
0.8865169883,
-0.1037135497,
-0.5374194384,
0.250715822,
0.246185407,
0.6093047857,
-0.25372383,
0.6256716847,
0.5088718534,
0.0617497638,
-0.224854663,
-0.5856092572,
0.6692879796,
0.6617944241,
-0.6722542048,
0.0564592779,
0.3165532053,
0.1184430346,
-0.385086596,
0.7745870352,
0.0572892986,
0.2713448703,
-0.221921131,
0.2339877635,
-0.1227276847,
-0.2061321884,
-0.4682500362,
0.0257841852,
-0.0442338772,
-0.1407105774
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10073v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10073v3
|
Both Matter: Enhancing the Emotional Intelligence of Large Language Models without Compromising the General Intelligence
| 2024-02-15T16:36:04 | 2024-06-12T04:13:17 |
Weixiang Zhao, Zhuojun Li, Shilong Wang, Yang Wang, Yulin Hu, Yanyan Zhao, Chen Wei, Bing Qin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Emotional Intelligence (EI), consisting of emotion perception, emotion
cognition and emotion expression, plays the critical roles in improving user
interaction experience for the current large language model (LLM) based
conversational general AI assistants. Previous works mainly focus on raising
the emotion perception ability of them via naive fine-tuning on EI-related
classification or regression tasks. However, this leads to the incomplete
enhancement of EI and catastrophic forgetting of the general intelligence (GI).
To this end, we first introduce \textsc{EiBench}, a large-scale collection of
EI-related tasks in the text-to-text formation with task instructions that
covers all three aspects of EI, which lays a solid foundation for the
comprehensive EI enhancement of LLMs. Then a novel \underline{\textbf{Mo}}dular
\underline{\textbf{E}}motional \underline{\textbf{I}}ntelligence enhancement
method (\textbf{MoEI}), consisting of Modular Parameter Expansion and
intra-inter modulation, is proposed to comprehensively enhance the EI of LLMs
without compromise their GI. Extensive experiments on two representative
LLM-based assistants, Flan-T5 and LLaMA-2-Chat, demonstrate the effectiveness
of MoEI to improving EI while maintain GI.
|
[
-0.2768835425,
-0.8163633347,
0.4010413289,
0.0725417882,
0.1815685034,
0.0577120334,
-0.4885767996,
-0.6554072499,
0.4346952736,
0.052651681,
-0.6532183886,
-0.3345171511,
-0.3727555573,
0.0228030514,
-0.042040199,
0.8778232932,
0.2022090405,
-0.0929180384,
-0.2250392437,
-0.1707731932,
-0.2368766367,
-0.7299249768,
-0.7398651838,
-0.2823720574,
0.6263660789,
0.443407923,
0.3206342161,
0.1775187999,
0.4603123069,
0.3458098471,
0.0329420455,
0.5363708735,
-0.7599096298,
0.243447721,
-0.0559722669,
-0.6847837567,
-0.9067957997,
-0.2431731373,
0.2328552604,
0.2185840309,
-0.3143923879,
-0.3250222206,
-0.0560396165,
1.0155791044,
-0.8911501765,
0.1154546514,
-0.3189870417,
-0.1640574783,
0.048131261,
-0.2429224253,
-0.4046428204,
0.0364916362,
0.0802314878,
-0.6215181947,
-0.2765997648,
0.1776333451,
0.7794020772,
0.2781938016,
-0.4923765957,
-0.4913970828,
-0.799064815,
0.8859562278,
-0.5799233913,
0.2664627731,
0.2511638999,
-0.2363029718,
0.0613959655,
-0.2774401009,
-0.6150037646,
-0.3792643249,
0.0635998398,
0.5841655731,
-0.3660511971,
0.54468292,
0.3016265035,
0.354308933,
-0.3365421295,
0.2508073151,
-0.2858284414,
0.1086326838,
0.6778918505,
0.2821244597,
0.5531978607,
0.2844639421,
0.2566534579,
-0.0409299619,
-0.5382448435,
-0.0248321183,
0.3395876884,
-0.0980245471,
-0.2060570568,
0.2855070829,
-0.3359070718,
0.2202740759,
0.2908854187,
0.0451374725,
0.4019149244,
-0.2728848755,
-0.3107182384,
-0.2688478231,
0.685895741,
0.3651728332,
0.6093933582,
-0.2432551533,
0.1022687256,
-0.1333744228,
0.2975937128,
-0.7952715158,
-0.1165078133,
0.3464560509,
-0.3680546284,
-0.0091877868,
0.2513376772,
-0.6717307568,
-0.2640716434,
-0.5797222853,
0.1925895065,
-0.521922946,
-0.465207845,
-0.1742385328,
0.1530302912,
0.2920540869,
0.4345940351,
-1.1452294588,
0.1568867862,
0.9385851026,
0.6277509332,
0.0444960073,
-0.2366866022,
-0.2286388874,
0.2968420684,
-0.3309598267,
0.6210534573,
-0.8466078043,
-0.4638638496,
0.2804220915,
-0.2503709495,
-0.2491692156,
-0.4738823175,
0.5118818879,
-0.3842339218,
0.224700436,
-0.1817436665,
-0.4570427537,
-0.4811662138,
0.1961731315,
-0.3890465796,
0.8032705784,
0.0869826525,
-0.3879853785,
0.0254982207,
-1.1353390217,
-0.5942111611,
-0.2585130036,
0.0131309144,
-0.2648554742,
0.4265027344,
0.381934762,
0.5551889539,
-0.3458500504,
-0.0126795378,
-0.4773828089,
-0.4220379591,
0.3083888292,
-0.3468280733,
0.284402132,
-0.2318209112,
-0.3043058217,
0.1208052412,
-0.5821913481,
0.2242255807,
-0.1349750608,
-0.4023601413,
-0.2304792702,
0.0555508658,
-0.2013365328,
-0.0342419669,
0.1312375665,
-0.3026449978,
0.1046617851,
-0.4445159435,
0.4980154335,
0.6870573759,
0.0079939589,
0.6396402717,
-0.474124819,
0.2846142054,
0.0024396889,
0.1186645105,
-0.3209977448,
-0.2722068429,
-1.1819275618,
-0.4817204773,
-0.1277627498,
0.9312543273,
-0.6025523543,
0.4841860831,
-0.4819555581,
-0.5418804288,
-0.597638309,
0.2487362027,
0.4501953125,
0.175811097,
0.2978413701,
0.0171524175,
-0.4128247499,
-0.9159896374,
-0.0573488958,
-0.3702009022,
-0.3657330871,
0.6491160393,
0.319785893,
-0.4766873419,
0.5601903796,
-0.0650838912,
-0.2441157848,
-0.2064572126,
0.3644411862,
-0.0558990017,
0.3954462707,
0.6280605197,
-0.690508306,
-0.442835629,
0.1892760545,
-0.809564352,
-0.4171566069,
-0.0755183622,
-0.2935498059,
0.4840914309,
0.271651417,
-0.5412865877,
0.4340678453,
0.3953621984,
-0.1951494217,
0.2331083417,
-0.282830745,
0.765704155,
-0.8872900009,
-0.0049343533,
0.0725543723,
0.1319678426,
-1.188546896,
-0.0721024424,
0.1228036657,
0.0750223771,
-0.3936645985,
0.2996692061,
-0.5933496356,
0.0956364572,
-0.4216600358,
0.0742778033,
-0.0099113192,
0.8124967813,
-0.2956668735,
0.7834974527,
0.5479841232,
-0.7620745897,
0.3296263516,
-0.0121773137,
0.1465187967,
1.0149707794,
-0.6826371551,
0.6297439337,
-0.3002293408,
0.0492225289,
-0.628862381,
-0.262142837,
0.2337278873,
-0.4654649198,
0.6822786331,
0.460357666,
-0.1948408633,
-0.1846982837,
-0.4285386503,
0.0484765247,
0.7239676714,
-0.4744584262,
1.202914834,
0.0834006742,
-0.3334573805,
-0.3383618891,
-0.7166975737,
0.1951150596,
-0.2280315906,
-0.6916675568,
0.2418249547,
-0.3656312823,
-0.4379591942,
-0.1320336312,
0.1545345783,
-0.1287216693,
0.2759668827,
0.4653186798,
0.3441605866,
-0.2923319638,
0.4150087833,
0.1500041038,
0.0293634739,
0.0735183135,
0.0914498419,
0.4296619296,
-0.4299432039,
-0.5003402233,
-0.8252336383,
0.7192339897,
0.837423265,
-0.2796424031,
0.8117399216,
0.5543361306,
-0.1957499981,
0.1033214033,
-0.8365342617,
-0.0826885998,
-0.4392778575,
0.8564638495,
-0.4930655062,
-0.9886711836,
0.3003995121,
-0.0907279104,
-0.0324287303,
0.3688466549,
0.5037943125,
-0.3132407367,
1.2278883457,
0.7450559735,
-0.5724549294,
0.7233097553,
-0.1150630116,
0.4764864743,
-1.2047591209,
-0.2599478066,
-0.504237771,
-0.6373761296,
-0.1552691609,
-0.1128737852,
0.0438673124,
0.0439293496,
-0.4746932983,
-0.3187996149,
-0.369265765,
0.4156741202,
0.5206452012,
0.3192238808,
-0.0699911788,
0.1133337244,
0.5730857849,
-0.0784073621,
-0.5946978927,
-0.4305202961,
1.0347378254,
0.3315391541,
0.6117464304,
0.3698547482,
0.524662137,
0.2889939845,
0.5322683454,
-0.7279823422,
0.6647250056,
-0.106023334,
-0.2117595375,
-0.220632121,
-0.3830696642,
-0.5874690413,
-0.0006302696,
-0.3004634678,
-1.0823343992,
0.2549745739,
0.1633866727,
-0.2019395232,
0.1894506812,
-0.9601554871,
0.2810261846,
-0.521291256,
-0.4344736636,
-0.8015553355,
-0.2208437771,
0.1602419019,
0.074244976,
-0.0529984124,
-0.068303287,
-0.3728933632,
0.7174692154,
-0.1361830384,
0.7908954024,
-0.1425042003,
0.1017179713,
0.1936669201,
-0.1742816418,
0.5635656118,
-0.191079706,
-0.3299534917,
0.2964941561,
-0.6359823346,
-0.4116337895,
-1.0119137764,
0.7108736038,
-0.9026066661,
-0.9760310054,
0.0697295144,
-0.6575815678,
-0.2448249459,
-0.3362537324,
-0.0451195873,
0.2794730961,
-0.2615991533,
0.3823198378,
0.6920570731,
-0.1509242654,
0.4006746709,
0.356412977,
0.2546847761,
-0.4298689961,
0.8750288486,
-0.0808678567,
0.4741484225,
0.5995828509,
-0.0804063454,
0.0215887912,
-0.229479149,
-0.1124636158,
0.394051075,
-0.6598057747,
-0.0433883481,
-0.7986524701,
-0.0474861264,
-0.3378605843,
-0.5026624799,
0.1082426906,
-0.1005745381,
-0.6598496437,
-0.2321447432,
0.6370484829,
0.5279173255,
-0.118673481,
0.2006780207,
-0.7301309109,
0.0933073014,
0.4597053528,
-0.0549973547,
0.3119427562,
-0.4912853241,
-0.2773633003,
0.4065066278,
-0.1848166138,
-0.7278566957,
0.3357557356,
0.8375186324,
0.5221224427,
0.909668088,
-0.0443619378,
0.86494416,
-0.2439541966,
0.7596385479,
0.376271069,
-1.08484447,
0.5434148312,
-0.1589220464,
0.218411684,
0.3572670817,
0.2752991021,
-0.4726388752,
-0.4622018039,
-0.4289762676,
-0.9377740622,
0.716463387,
0.1263492405,
0.3419118822,
-0.0935523733,
0.2593281865,
-0.3096968532,
0.227468729,
-0.5226647854,
-0.1036229953,
-0.0402735211,
-0.4966304898,
0.1110830531,
-0.6253756881,
-0.0490424559,
-0.2184980512,
0.9379518032,
-0.1187127456,
0.6257687211,
0.2745165825,
-0.0933243185,
-0.0241006799,
0.4523577392,
0.6273950934,
0.333956033,
0.0609259158,
-0.2441782504,
0.5838369131,
-0.3305850029,
0.0595948957,
-0.4226059914,
0.0883302614,
-0.3523673713,
0.4576878846,
1.0763392448,
0.2747246623,
-0.6993904114,
0.346647203,
0.1482892334,
-0.3434575498,
-0.1703197807,
0.4221693873,
0.1885961294,
0.5452341437,
0.4037504196,
-0.1437847763,
0.0524770357,
-0.8438369036,
-0.2083370388,
0.3384717405,
-0.3852779269,
-0.3967228234,
0.4179589152,
0.5432771444,
-0.5655072331,
0.8703184128,
-0.1436469108,
-0.7586305737,
0.8230713606,
0.4831752181,
1.065507412,
-0.3775525689,
-0.0555827171,
0.2716069221,
0.4136246741,
0.2300206274,
0.4003793299,
-0.0422195159,
-0.5812100768,
-0.2372881919,
0.0584756173,
-0.3548260331,
-0.1348276585,
-0.5878263116,
-0.1381219625,
-0.4423924387,
0.0958270058,
-0.5217094421,
-0.0478537157,
-0.7798572183,
0.1984421313,
0.3257981837,
0.603263855,
-0.663340807,
0.6090925932,
0.7596494555,
-0.1758981943,
-0.7527710199,
0.1711055338,
-0.0194888562,
-0.5983566046,
0.6424447894,
0.3013894558,
-0.1414715201,
0.0185382888,
-0.4179905057,
-0.7364075184,
1.3027324677,
0.1208416969,
-0.7118136883,
0.1193315536,
0.0473700128,
0.7045686245,
-0.6324772835,
0.963773787,
0.4857780337,
0.5768726468,
-0.0403226987,
-0.7367023826,
-0.2639935315,
-0.6020994186,
0.0779921263,
0.2636310458,
-0.9069603682,
0.5044851303,
-0.32462883,
-0.2556970417,
0.078392908,
0.9245790839,
0.0086153746,
0.3929699957,
0.4999184608,
0.6172258258,
1.1037348509,
-0.2827038467,
1.007225275,
-0.3719009459,
-0.0248487853,
0.8089475036,
-0.557118237,
0.8618584275,
0.3120378256,
-0.0549923591,
0.4821031392,
0.3307025433,
0.1592513621,
0.3174225986,
0.0432696864,
-0.4052780867,
-0.1546033025,
-0.2376877517,
-0.1681761593,
0.1125816032,
0.6868261099,
-0.1365934908,
0.3624963462,
0.3153393567,
0.2034247816,
0.0295826718,
-0.5721769333,
0.8547036648,
0.0104035689,
-0.4693778753,
0.3712616861,
-0.1305322647,
0.8621622324,
-0.506321609,
0.0835136622,
-0.3643937111,
0.028914554,
-0.276376307,
-0.3473329842,
0.1651094854,
0.1610735506,
-0.3078330159,
0.0366533883,
0.8027876616,
-0.3787457645,
-0.3057168126,
0.5655811429,
0.3452712893,
-0.0048403013,
-0.068820335,
-0.534070015,
-0.0583071448,
0.1047889739,
-0.5687387586,
0.1840808541,
0.6185731888,
0.2488813102,
0.8600492477,
0.5501021147,
-0.0118014561,
-0.0855610594,
0.2451731265,
0.8181952238,
-0.5449935794,
-0.3159968853,
-0.9023960233,
0.6346467733,
-0.3306949735,
-0.2283854336,
0.2579715848,
0.098219946,
0.3036703765,
-0.1235453263,
0.81633991,
-0.200206995,
0.2590512931,
-0.5909410715,
0.5922215581,
-0.6167605519,
0.0354487635,
-0.2140551805,
-0.8870412707,
-0.227768302,
0.4724974632,
-0.5065974593,
0.2689217925,
0.7770879269,
0.9557718635,
0.1899478287,
-0.0094145006,
0.6903130412,
0.3653303087,
0.2801443338,
1.0594191551,
0.8977583647,
-0.2023793757,
0.5259964466,
0.0297437124,
-0.413253516,
-0.4669186771,
-0.5660712123,
-1.0902596712,
-0.3389611244,
-0.5034331083,
0.0692275912,
0.3658158779,
0.934009254,
0.6771398783,
-0.6582747102,
0.0389402322,
-0.0191234257,
-0.1350596547,
-0.1924114674,
-0.2049806714,
0.1235906258,
-0.2695575953,
-0.9918290973,
0.3732480109,
0.8091884851,
-0.0267235618,
0.0403867662,
-0.4207861125,
-0.0426501073,
0.4796613753,
0.5094004273,
0.3351919353,
-0.6800059676,
-0.3569975793,
0.1158999875,
-0.1463837028,
0.1698366702,
0.4957356751,
-0.3270846307,
0.2524342835,
0.3570232987,
0.7866840959,
-0.0076767546,
0.0282324068,
0.5962857008,
-0.3823184371,
0.1667589694,
0.1494546384,
0.4178781807,
0.1325957328,
-0.5839183927,
0.5514208674,
0.0640929863,
-0.6498705745,
-0.3906756341,
0.2997525334,
-0.9309782982,
0.0210945494,
1.0410438776,
-0.2924104631,
-0.4020788372,
0.322119683,
-0.5244933963,
0.1779864281,
-0.6719159484,
0.8462812901,
0.7639899254,
-0.1718634069,
-0.4299557507,
-0.3930943608,
-0.0562523752,
0.775945127,
-1.1919734478,
-0.2218032479,
0.4731277823,
-0.4234623015,
0.2299809903,
0.3602138758,
0.2930497825,
0.276933372,
-0.290628016,
0.3344448805,
-0.2687005699,
-0.3121502101,
-0.2810723782,
0.1369486749,
-0.1114572287,
-0.1228798404
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10058v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10058v2
|
Towards Safer Large Language Models through Machine Unlearning
| 2024-02-15T16:28:34 | 2024-06-05T04:57:09 |
Zheyuan Liu, Guangyao Dou, Zhaoxuan Tan, Yijun Tian, Meng Jiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The rapid advancement of Large Language Models (LLMs) has demonstrated their
vast potential across various domains, attributed to their extensive
pretraining knowledge and exceptional generalizability. However, LLMs often
encounter challenges in generating harmful content when faced with problematic
prompts. To address this problem, existing work attempted to implement a
gradient ascent based approach to prevent LLMs from producing harmful output.
While these methods can be effective, they frequently impact the model utility
in responding to normal prompts. To address this gap, we introduce Selective
Knowledge negation Unlearning (SKU), a novel unlearning framework for LLMs,
designed to eliminate harmful knowledge while preserving utility on normal
prompts. Specifically, SKU is consisted of two stages: harmful knowledge
acquisition stage and knowledge negation stage. The first stage aims to
identify and acquire harmful knowledge within the model, whereas the second is
dedicated to remove this knowledge. SKU selectively isolates and removes
harmful knowledge in model parameters, ensuring the model's performance remains
robust on normal prompts. Our experiments conducted across various LLM
architectures demonstrate that SKU identifies a good balance point between
removing harmful information and preserving utility.
|
[
-0.1293158978,
-0.7438488603,
0.2786539495,
-0.1896592826,
-0.4707886279,
0.3044559658,
-0.2611165941,
-0.1790144444,
-0.4379024804,
0.9925553203,
-0.4168741405,
-0.6061304212,
-0.5543140173,
-0.4725117981,
-0.2431255877,
1.1384915113,
0.3338078856,
-0.0201492272,
-0.3283986449,
-0.0862484798,
-0.5773309469,
-0.513219595,
-0.9123337269,
-0.4729272127,
0.5938237906,
0.419085741,
0.5239812136,
0.4509733617,
0.1514622122,
0.247315675,
-0.2351289093,
0.0161769129,
-0.7535206676,
0.4558501542,
-0.2043857276,
-0.4634335339,
-0.2847274244,
-0.0276058931,
0.5126641989,
0.752961576,
-0.3286101222,
-0.0003189793,
0.4994259179,
0.7528619766,
-0.6432020664,
-0.0117417406,
-1.0089011192,
-0.2060303688,
-0.1814806908,
-0.0075338902,
-0.722352922,
-0.1412945539,
-0.0529415347,
-0.5347610116,
-0.1016587317,
-0.0932331011,
0.5503281355,
0.4150830209,
-0.4503619075,
-0.1746165007,
-0.6305081844,
1.1625310183,
-0.7207903266,
0.4480381012,
0.485539645,
0.3561722934,
-0.4426836073,
-0.4006413221,
-0.372653693,
-0.0996927172,
0.0612290055,
-0.0355608016,
-0.486109823,
0.1208378896,
0.130924359,
-0.1814268827,
-0.6036198139,
0.6494678855,
-0.4448991716,
-0.3694682419,
0.5052323937,
0.0409785211,
0.3622641265,
-0.3307186067,
-0.4507310092,
0.2101854682,
-1.0448346138,
0.1198859513,
0.6020206213,
0.3075804114,
0.2421401143,
0.4794209599,
-0.0096729174,
0.4809887111,
-0.2174722552,
-0.3287739456,
0.3589145541,
0.2270168662,
-0.2915507853,
-0.1542589217,
0.7320962548,
0.2975738943,
0.3813061714,
-0.5426098108,
-0.370275557,
0.0037959714,
0.4130325615,
-0.6035208106,
-0.0404547974,
0.0646837056,
-0.4599896073,
-0.5364512205,
-0.3976523876,
-0.8688392043,
-0.6417218447,
-0.3421023786,
0.3879689276,
-0.5266135335,
-0.2732837796,
-0.0161622074,
0.086011,
-0.0367822722,
0.2786264718,
-0.508723557,
-0.0960719883,
0.6166072488,
0.3287490606,
-0.2515623271,
0.0826128572,
-0.7372575402,
0.3319582343,
-0.3024451733,
0.3347729743,
-0.6552475691,
-0.4064988792,
-0.0775096565,
0.0163337532,
0.0789967403,
-0.7445085049,
0.6014931798,
-0.7744387388,
0.2105035037,
0.0577403978,
-0.3683481514,
-0.5179441571,
0.0626169443,
-0.3155145049,
0.8566159606,
0.0148470234,
-0.5267142057,
0.3131461143,
-0.3889798224,
-0.5897495747,
0.246299237,
-0.0167343058,
-0.2940117717,
0.019713195,
-0.065235354,
0.6777142286,
-0.2600319982,
0.6103945971,
-0.3438040316,
-0.1044589207,
-0.0605771951,
-0.6815126538,
0.9044852257,
0.4465042353,
-0.2273171097,
0.3314596117,
-0.9632492661,
0.0140514728,
0.0204729624,
-0.4306522012,
-0.8649556041,
-0.1288148612,
-0.3795841634,
0.3659390211,
0.097183913,
-0.6739281416,
-0.0166495237,
-0.2913555801,
0.4761002362,
1.0617123842,
-0.0315282568,
0.7127178311,
-0.2664352953,
0.5590177178,
0.1678523868,
0.193354696,
0.0200059488,
-0.5841264129,
-0.6710096598,
-0.3775150478,
0.0755903646,
0.5537453294,
-1.00449121,
0.5222910047,
0.0532368608,
-0.5141324401,
-0.4265437126,
0.6600426435,
0.614726007,
0.7875170708,
0.3123122752,
0.1229702011,
-0.5144141316,
-0.7507573962,
-0.3367707133,
-0.1554171443,
-0.1987065673,
0.1790459007,
0.1123755202,
-0.4786649048,
0.5265662074,
-0.3129767179,
-0.1471077949,
-0.5125359297,
0.1126239076,
0.2388500869,
0.5457974076,
0.3402434289,
-0.633818984,
-0.2757557333,
-0.0181542169,
-0.862167418,
-0.1587858349,
-0.0710345283,
-0.2447879314,
0.3495717049,
0.7006995082,
-0.5682314634,
0.5563098192,
0.3417142034,
0.0915872306,
0.2777765393,
-0.1901533753,
-0.3423060477,
-0.9937696457,
0.0922245309,
-0.0454544947,
-0.0865483209,
-0.8547502756,
0.0728278905,
0.035503719,
0.0278465468,
-0.5229709744,
0.6348939538,
-0.2403043211,
0.3940810263,
-0.3227061331,
0.0237739272,
-0.0693541765,
0.4533523023,
-0.0720928833,
0.3408043683,
0.5088449717,
-0.9112173915,
-0.0535185598,
0.0365376212,
-0.2487775236,
0.177090168,
-0.4739320874,
0.1739966571,
-0.4009486139,
-0.0761580318,
-0.8632790446,
0.1491291225,
0.2655874789,
-0.4283745885,
0.3990425766,
-0.2573212385,
-0.3765594959,
-0.3298231661,
-0.0607067272,
0.3757368028,
0.9344969988,
-0.5951104164,
0.6491479278,
0.5382573605,
-0.2067047358,
-0.7740026116,
-0.422065407,
-0.2070124596,
-0.4913728237,
-0.4590032697,
-0.1179895028,
-0.1160447598,
-0.3444536328,
-0.1184504405,
-0.0787104815,
0.009653708,
0.3501525521,
0.503007412,
0.5859277248,
0.0716858506,
0.2997725904,
0.1088849679,
-0.3607982099,
0.1404819638,
-0.2220175415,
0.6781815886,
0.4568617344,
-0.1730757356,
-0.2774537206,
0.2063930333,
0.6670857668,
-0.2471254766,
0.8321551085,
0.5737742186,
-0.51798594,
-0.5852627754,
-0.484914571,
-0.123155497,
-0.5470981002,
0.3803449571,
0.0492375828,
-0.9657824636,
0.3731577694,
-0.1364775598,
0.4344525635,
0.162713334,
0.4095414281,
-0.0633907169,
1.0900826454,
0.6056030989,
-0.2956903875,
0.2962272167,
-0.1327488571,
0.5466898084,
-0.7931933403,
-0.4924755096,
-0.5075422525,
-0.1838380694,
-0.2812561989,
-0.4403148293,
0.2535215318,
0.5416848063,
-0.4878493845,
0.1732947081,
-0.2922194302,
0.5353292823,
0.5064332485,
0.0199205689,
0.2764021456,
0.1210146323,
-0.5313189626,
0.0089844009,
-0.6105598211,
-0.7121253014,
1.2497373819,
0.344009608,
0.9040426612,
0.0990956202,
0.5801560879,
0.0975150391,
0.4308966398,
-0.6602926254,
0.706361711,
-0.2962528467,
-0.6153107285,
-0.4882989526,
-0.7220839858,
-0.9111428857,
0.3013791442,
-0.119864434,
-0.9040535092,
-0.1278089732,
0.0756761506,
-0.426015228,
0.7184892297,
-0.6961405277,
0.3717077374,
-0.2456753254,
-0.3620942831,
-0.1714753807,
-0.5850616097,
0.5684626102,
-0.4054484069,
0.5451223254,
-0.1475616693,
0.0796349198,
0.7851116061,
-0.0118518276,
1.0296278,
-0.3328316212,
-0.21372962,
0.2187610716,
0.3357008398,
0.6057030559,
0.0197404493,
-0.2961715758,
0.1710495651,
-0.44176054,
-0.3298184276,
-0.5406743288,
0.672608614,
-0.6766713858,
-0.753834188,
-0.1393780112,
-0.7308699489,
-0.3511152864,
0.4336822033,
0.2393239588,
0.1699424386,
0.028399935,
0.340831697,
0.8650804758,
-0.6496011019,
0.6453535557,
0.7374451756,
-0.2660308778,
-0.2516133189,
1.1648744345,
0.0239934064,
0.557094276,
0.2129502892,
0.1825767756,
-0.36025846,
-0.8132782578,
-0.2142082006,
0.135133937,
-0.7813647389,
-0.3913124502,
-0.696444571,
-0.3648297787,
-0.4460822642,
-0.0683356896,
-0.1407866031,
-0.1203914434,
-0.465095073,
-0.3356122077,
0.0935923159,
0.8697333336,
-0.0583982952,
0.2140889913,
-0.8471984863,
0.1693106741,
0.2679170668,
0.2143124044,
0.3810139596,
-0.6387355924,
0.0988064408,
0.0865036398,
-0.3382967114,
-0.2289828658,
0.6314906478,
-0.157425046,
1.01653862,
0.9485290051,
0.4950495362,
0.4482960999,
-0.3246059716,
0.5637140274,
0.4813379347,
-0.642939508,
0.3743805885,
-0.4119822085,
0.0921093822,
0.428976804,
0.5848882794,
-0.5592011213,
-0.467371583,
-0.5776170492,
-1.0634298325,
0.4986708462,
-0.1079628021,
0.2625838816,
-0.0408638492,
0.3048728704,
0.4721756279,
0.3748759925,
-0.6838713288,
-0.232769683,
0.0409564227,
-0.0573081747,
-0.3003351688,
-0.3083955348,
-0.1014390364,
-0.1884803325,
0.9119243026,
0.1181089208,
-0.2872104049,
-0.5241054893,
-0.3539269567,
-0.3045950234,
0.4873070121,
0.2096355557,
0.2985273898,
-0.0149215981,
0.2445802093,
0.1626254916,
-0.4542275667,
0.1606956869,
-0.4350427985,
-0.5649327636,
-0.4117957354,
0.1981974095,
0.5087687373,
0.2883081436,
-0.7414613366,
0.3253703415,
0.1891404688,
-0.2053479552,
0.1046527475,
0.2976586819,
0.0304048583,
-0.0961756259,
0.3613208234,
0.2246518433,
-0.2038147748,
-0.4184022248,
0.2891850471,
0.5772396922,
-0.548969388,
-0.1631907672,
0.4989031553,
0.3896105886,
-0.2367819399,
0.7541029453,
-0.2629871666,
-0.5218402743,
0.3613084853,
0.6839244962,
0.5912315249,
-0.36795035,
0.3959511817,
0.2272041887,
0.4677908123,
0.16772452,
0.0994753465,
0.2419518381,
-0.8613988161,
-0.2194472551,
-0.7878130078,
0.1061558798,
0.7108606696,
-0.6366532445,
0.0145727294,
-0.6979888082,
0.1355769783,
-0.2306963354,
-0.2081394494,
-0.409855634,
0.1121014655,
0.0290423892,
0.6400021315,
-0.7930814028,
0.9307456613,
0.4058974385,
-0.1903794706,
-0.9260704517,
-0.1215887368,
0.2683954239,
-0.9998713732,
0.5787261128,
0.1768134087,
-0.0490048006,
-0.068676576,
-0.4500659406,
-0.6545066833,
0.9063683748,
0.5710003376,
-0.8269100785,
0.0473900363,
0.1503949463,
0.20715186,
-0.1151653454,
-0.0682059228,
0.409657836,
0.3973630071,
0.4063796401,
-0.4979809225,
0.1687475443,
-0.2084833235,
-0.266908437,
0.3440551162,
-0.388694793,
0.7509669662,
-0.4649437666,
-0.2387282848,
0.1557878554,
0.3188895881,
0.3114995956,
0.331119746,
0.7061237693,
0.6464235187,
1.1245286465,
0.110571444,
0.655965507,
-0.0513942391,
-0.1858697087,
1.0390685797,
-0.3762880266,
0.6781270504,
0.4607440531,
0.2296774685,
0.2231920362,
0.3897741139,
0.3035523295,
0.6266438365,
0.4666181505,
-0.3301587105,
-0.6284578443,
-0.1153931245,
-0.2610183656,
0.3373375535,
0.2823253572,
-0.3937604725,
-0.3236798644,
0.2662877738,
0.276125282,
0.0232606325,
-0.4472031891,
0.825899303,
0.181136325,
-0.5366770029,
0.48830989,
-0.0956790894,
0.7714285851,
-0.630466342,
0.0288438573,
-0.1419644207,
0.3827480376,
-0.1715166718,
-0.512532115,
0.0978054777,
0.1117053255,
-0.1918977052,
-0.2121778131,
0.9089825153,
-0.3935916722,
-0.4359984398,
0.6255584955,
0.5687131286,
0.0887682959,
-0.0160618518,
-0.54354918,
-0.2565314174,
0.1846438348,
-0.1571664363,
0.7449419498,
0.5451954603,
-0.3508639038,
1.0152093172,
1.0446903706,
-0.0832892805,
0.1347630918,
0.3133305311,
1.1134074926,
-0.3244228363,
-0.4388909042,
-0.6256799102,
0.5449913144,
0.0700663701,
-0.2304727286,
0.8884768486,
0.4894627929,
0.8330599666,
0.2806699574,
0.9009760618,
0.3751722276,
0.4276089966,
-0.4805822372,
1.2230445147,
-0.4743750095,
0.673707366,
-0.247038886,
-0.7879835367,
-0.3936780989,
0.3338180482,
-0.2932692468,
0.0253005549,
0.3612731397,
0.9288976192,
0.2366963327,
0.093109265,
0.7256529331,
0.3162356913,
0.3728770912,
0.4391982853,
0.9902268648,
0.1340852082,
0.7067112327,
-0.1701089591,
-0.31267187,
0.1383574009,
-0.8424341083,
-1.1513108015,
-0.3686661124,
0.033677347,
-0.3027434051,
0.1404801309,
0.6770105958,
0.5992466807,
-0.7461670041,
-0.1228604168,
-0.0620604753,
0.3908618391,
0.0820411593,
-0.1734903604,
0.0691768229,
-0.4585051537,
-0.3606997728,
0.6079026461,
0.1630330831,
-0.0046773879,
-0.2410954684,
-0.4212088883,
-0.0159128997,
0.0145950252,
0.5255632401,
0.2281836718,
-0.6178808212,
-0.2013669014,
-0.0855060816,
0.0340988711,
-0.2597580552,
0.7185026407,
-0.843939662,
0.1902427226,
0.3984519541,
0.6285491586,
-0.0184543356,
-0.310627073,
0.5552930236,
-0.783398509,
0.0911084488,
0.2563495934,
0.3822721243,
0.1993396878,
-0.5606691837,
0.3135146201,
0.1426243633,
-0.4390887916,
-1.0342284441,
0.1708618551,
-0.7165461779,
-0.6131318212,
1.4172468185,
-0.1925155967,
-0.2897750735,
-0.5111115575,
0.0082095666,
0.3917107284,
-0.6462527514,
0.6863788962,
0.3924635053,
0.2105888277,
0.0131147066,
-0.5403606296,
0.3309625685,
0.3169831336,
-0.6352547407,
0.3686864376,
0.3291607201,
0.6015149355,
-0.0425538681,
0.2279898971,
-0.2864120603,
0.0459280126,
-0.4205620885,
0.0775222555,
-0.3358438909,
-0.6937075853,
-0.4106445014,
0.2424902469,
-0.1285293102,
-0.1210110039
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10052v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10052v1
|
Unmemorization in Large Language Models via Self-Distillation and Deliberate Imagination
| 2024-02-15T16:21:14 | 2024-02-15T16:21:14 |
Yijiang River Dong, Hongzhou Lin, Mikhail Belkin, Ramon Huerta, Ivan Vulić
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
While displaying impressive generation capabilities across many tasks, Large
Language Models (LLMs) still struggle with crucial issues of privacy violation
and unwanted exposure of sensitive data. This raises an essential question: how
should we prevent such undesired behavior of LLMs while maintaining their
strong generation and natural language understanding (NLU) capabilities? In
this work, we introduce a novel approach termed deliberate imagination in the
context of LLM unlearning. Instead of trying to forget memorized data, we
employ a self-distillation framework, guiding LLMs to deliberately imagine
alternative scenarios. As demonstrated in a wide range of experiments, the
proposed method not only effectively unlearns targeted text but also preserves
the LLMs' capabilities in open-ended generation tasks as well as in NLU tasks.
Our results demonstrate the usefulness of this approach across different models
and sizes, and also with parameter-efficient fine-tuning, offering a novel
pathway to addressing the challenges with private and sensitive data in LLM
applications.
|
[
-0.2208251953,
-0.8644283414,
0.7294415236,
0.0317717232,
-0.4029985368,
0.2969717979,
-0.4825277627,
-0.1035596207,
-0.2677159607,
0.9362758994,
-0.655279696,
-0.3444375098,
-0.2760727406,
-0.1571720243,
-0.3053313494,
1.0293085575,
-0.2131709754,
-0.3592231572,
-0.1262565851,
0.0670302808,
-0.2467360646,
-0.6041705608,
-0.4694921672,
-0.3596256971,
0.4554231167,
0.3757889569,
0.4048544765,
0.7080617547,
0.070463948,
0.3894813359,
0.0550800152,
0.4576356411,
-0.8792048097,
0.4030084014,
-0.5006549358,
-0.4762446582,
0.0258116275,
0.097321637,
0.7461731434,
0.6832637191,
-0.2434835136,
0.2642891109,
0.4648010731,
0.7865464091,
-0.7479310036,
0.0749529898,
-0.9873981476,
0.1769493073,
-0.232388705,
-0.2868323624,
-0.5741962194,
0.1395762116,
-0.2216927707,
-0.3561214209,
0.3150582314,
0.002664489,
0.4662852585,
0.4422231019,
-0.2663327456,
-0.1053038538,
-1.228333354,
0.8894440532,
-0.7887254357,
0.1790808141,
0.3767984211,
0.2257819325,
-0.5634105802,
-0.801614821,
-0.6914738417,
0.1119811237,
0.1189614385,
0.1113065034,
-0.2647094429,
-0.0465832278,
0.2305303365,
0.4727045,
-0.4019816518,
0.3586428463,
-0.4219695926,
-0.1529116035,
0.7049713731,
0.177290976,
0.1106998548,
-0.006928843,
-0.4173339307,
0.1533735842,
-0.7133975625,
-0.2323178202,
0.5495556593,
0.1594824791,
0.2860380709,
0.733532846,
-0.202650547,
0.2749996483,
0.0822026208,
0.0577678606,
0.1741479039,
-0.1400168687,
-0.4472770989,
-0.0469779707,
0.9212616086,
0.0298573729,
0.3010360301,
-0.4234325588,
-0.3057759404,
0.0556951873,
0.3697552681,
-0.6887167096,
-0.1965747178,
0.3532069921,
-0.3486022651,
-0.3354496956,
-0.4290946424,
-0.8104833364,
-0.4133195877,
-0.4468709826,
0.2171554267,
-0.3263451159,
-0.3329377472,
0.2897125781,
0.1143102199,
-0.3883512318,
0.0283576306,
-1.1423680782,
0.164392814,
0.5766741633,
0.4131027162,
-0.0250264537,
-0.4288153648,
-0.1566661,
0.5052615404,
-0.2408077866,
0.3889506757,
-0.3512457311,
-0.4078588486,
-0.2198142111,
-0.2425088137,
-0.0306586772,
-0.5342588425,
0.4310427606,
-0.3753008246,
0.3704626262,
0.1213487312,
-0.6791279912,
-0.2223551869,
0.1307406425,
-0.5289925337,
0.8799344301,
-0.1899351925,
-0.6509643793,
0.3182808757,
-0.4361712635,
-0.1030865237,
-0.059664119,
-0.3806199431,
-0.4279521406,
0.6515898108,
0.2343132347,
0.4619549513,
-0.1692432165,
0.5504707694,
-0.1597312093,
-0.0625173301,
0.4920775592,
-1.0332268476,
0.5820237994,
0.5653927326,
-0.2660256624,
-0.0235827304,
-0.8176056743,
0.2227275372,
0.3257646561,
-0.334381938,
-0.4319765866,
0.0355693176,
-0.2879861891,
0.3165872097,
0.4217983186,
-0.6080617309,
0.2652463317,
-0.5167475343,
0.52472049,
0.8520250916,
0.2150569558,
0.4941042662,
-0.2580529451,
0.3582038581,
0.1354616433,
0.1083875299,
-0.2489992678,
-0.1600682586,
-0.7659394741,
-0.2062965631,
0.1915607303,
0.1893057227,
-0.6722508669,
0.3745071292,
-0.07624311,
-0.4255109429,
-0.5908564925,
0.5711970329,
0.4200115204,
0.373495549,
0.2441226691,
0.0188348908,
-0.50698632,
-0.8623585701,
-0.4759685099,
-0.0052723237,
-0.1077961102,
0.1728814691,
0.315604955,
-0.2452209294,
1.0087451935,
-0.4445198476,
-0.3075372577,
-0.4456798136,
0.5052703023,
0.1285840273,
0.6381874084,
0.2892971933,
-0.8061280251,
-0.2952849865,
-0.1854696721,
-0.8682608008,
-0.1012793481,
-0.6173701882,
-0.1063164398,
0.1696006507,
0.6585711241,
-0.5700677633,
0.478118062,
0.4493105114,
-0.1504959315,
0.2815238535,
-0.7072016001,
-0.1865469068,
-1.1674880981,
-0.0077520623,
-0.339507401,
-0.0756142065,
-0.7107900381,
0.1560769677,
0.1076135412,
0.0419787057,
-0.5617504716,
0.5334702134,
-0.8511050344,
0.3907956779,
-0.5630996823,
0.0109407511,
0.0727284104,
0.5630577207,
-0.0642449558,
0.5347608924,
0.472320199,
-0.4670345187,
-0.0220141355,
0.0856229663,
-0.4476214051,
-0.1290308982,
-0.3034796417,
0.4450110495,
-0.5944775343,
0.0485288687,
-0.8725555539,
0.004011468,
-0.051140938,
-0.220005706,
0.3934260607,
-0.0898411795,
-0.7227125168,
-0.2851470411,
-0.1861714423,
0.4781143963,
0.6468480825,
-0.7466244102,
0.6899136901,
0.5063083172,
0.0710941777,
-0.6261610985,
-0.7941659689,
0.1755144149,
-0.6178916693,
-0.3713728189,
0.2547726929,
-0.2646124363,
-0.3574423492,
-0.1049324051,
-0.1054492593,
0.0140397083,
0.2161525488,
0.3927080631,
0.132459715,
0.1174287051,
-0.06391491,
0.1986279339,
-0.0797784328,
0.1391334832,
-0.4107059836,
0.6836743951,
0.2553705871,
-0.2939526737,
-0.1751698107,
0.2528862655,
0.4116399288,
-0.3008797169,
0.782921195,
0.3994082212,
-0.4162208736,
-0.733212769,
-0.6562363505,
-0.0355322137,
-0.6375526786,
0.161653176,
-0.2464074343,
-0.9691559672,
0.5011699796,
-0.348488301,
0.3431916535,
0.0941267461,
0.7603662014,
-0.0664224699,
0.8307093382,
0.6988795996,
-0.0322207287,
0.2595956624,
-0.1135613546,
0.3478237391,
-0.9521256685,
-0.2017970085,
-0.1448675692,
-0.5294668674,
-0.468475759,
-0.6188159585,
0.0325284339,
0.3472496569,
0.0408963524,
0.085353449,
-0.3291353285,
0.9083917737,
0.3651153743,
-0.01931048,
0.3983897269,
0.0432388149,
-0.3698639274,
-0.1759565324,
-0.5032548308,
-0.6212860942,
1.2773246765,
0.3254303634,
0.8917087317,
0.0814678818,
1.1691106558,
-0.0806788653,
0.2016904354,
-0.3354608119,
0.6246817112,
-0.2094905674,
-0.7660034299,
-0.5531073809,
-0.5264436007,
-1.2035006285,
0.4387942255,
-0.1140562221,
-1.0868135691,
0.0665034801,
0.225231871,
-0.3847825527,
0.53776443,
-0.6467700601,
0.7627280951,
-0.2819679677,
-0.6057830453,
-0.2366865277,
-0.2303088903,
0.4888423085,
-0.5137475729,
0.4026049376,
-0.3096139729,
0.011303883,
0.4315704405,
-0.2528498471,
1.1060085297,
0.0193292592,
-0.3255617917,
0.5393872857,
0.3774674237,
0.6054559946,
0.1193090081,
-0.0191763099,
0.0941668153,
-0.4279549122,
-0.1437113583,
-0.6119349003,
0.9117257595,
-0.448574692,
-0.8461187482,
-0.1828949898,
-0.8176172376,
-0.3333152533,
0.4011054337,
0.3560585976,
0.0879480168,
-0.424908489,
0.1343531758,
0.7669561505,
-0.2539608181,
0.7509464622,
0.738034904,
-0.392478466,
-0.0538746752,
0.968157351,
0.1467312276,
0.3399589956,
0.2626879215,
0.3670513332,
-0.5063322186,
-0.9077222347,
-0.2587255836,
0.1975636929,
-0.6419193149,
0.0554464795,
-0.7063968182,
-0.1789253503,
-0.2841218412,
0.0089991223,
-0.4675638974,
-0.4445786178,
-0.5323637128,
-0.2520958781,
0.086770311,
0.588055253,
-0.1991042346,
0.1621764898,
-0.766557157,
0.3996683955,
0.1865605265,
0.2564900219,
0.1085267738,
-0.6674130559,
-0.0482099056,
0.1690373123,
-0.332819283,
-0.3507378399,
0.7855137587,
0.1080605164,
0.6140528917,
0.4519058168,
0.2145354152,
0.5965519547,
-0.8282712102,
0.4803388715,
0.0595476478,
-0.7385079265,
0.4391182661,
-0.4908919036,
0.4688492715,
0.8190389872,
0.24135831,
-0.4360528588,
-0.6257615685,
-0.7193712592,
-1.1061708927,
0.3695881069,
0.2897429764,
0.4034484327,
-0.0398434773,
0.3353598118,
0.2381826937,
0.3193074167,
-0.8011882901,
-0.0935641006,
0.1409687847,
-0.2425595075,
-0.2529049218,
-0.3223304152,
-0.1470941156,
-0.1240475103,
0.4742830098,
-0.0033872214,
-0.2004198432,
-0.1767046899,
-0.1989652514,
-0.1911447048,
0.3710398972,
0.205256328,
0.5292330384,
0.1596498042,
0.3273409009,
0.1299530119,
-0.4616664052,
0.0882690623,
-0.1733043194,
-0.2192668319,
-0.3636891544,
-0.052960746,
0.5842912197,
0.3215197027,
-0.7987031341,
0.1322976947,
-0.152995646,
-0.211753428,
-0.4176339507,
0.3332807422,
0.3127710819,
0.1905061603,
0.2174836546,
-0.0829030946,
0.0852759182,
-0.6596391797,
0.1485668272,
0.3529413044,
0.0739496946,
-0.2016687691,
0.9045334458,
-0.096841149,
-0.0602570996,
0.6582201123,
-0.2282269895,
-0.2044941783,
0.3592548668,
0.760784328,
1.1080539227,
-0.3777522147,
0.0433983915,
0.1937859952,
0.3725958765,
-0.2351182848,
0.3075387478,
-0.029732842,
-0.9043203592,
-0.3464090824,
-0.7198829055,
0.002697411,
0.5852746964,
-0.5217506289,
-0.1193850413,
-0.6439687014,
0.071193032,
0.128326565,
-0.2248851359,
-0.5405594707,
0.1548056304,
0.3441355824,
0.4760109782,
-0.5731493235,
1.0328655243,
0.1657976806,
-0.1566903591,
-0.7712244987,
0.0350532457,
0.1096958667,
-0.7147226334,
0.406101346,
0.196463123,
-0.0811166391,
0.0440872423,
-0.3852869868,
-0.8506886959,
0.9334837794,
0.3975693285,
-0.928176403,
0.0759241506,
0.5874682069,
0.6424190402,
-0.0814924464,
-0.3030320704,
0.7017914653,
0.3172664046,
-0.0025808045,
-0.6289687753,
0.0431017391,
-0.2319755405,
-0.0574777536,
0.3733103573,
-0.6295784712,
0.8168411851,
-0.3722168207,
-0.5017094612,
-0.0096182674,
0.7206686139,
0.1393894404,
0.1183437333,
0.3704977632,
0.5189451575,
0.8855410218,
0.1491801292,
0.6402059197,
-0.163974911,
0.1949249208,
1.5158742666,
-0.4248727262,
0.7363842726,
0.5719954967,
0.2000798732,
-0.0203436073,
0.2134762406,
0.0179273468,
0.5565705895,
0.4366355538,
-0.5147839785,
-0.2772301435,
0.056858629,
0.0220148824,
0.7144176364,
0.413458854,
-0.4590086639,
-0.339234978,
0.1400271952,
0.0455427915,
0.5274626017,
-0.2244365066,
0.8234342933,
0.1357643008,
-0.6745287776,
0.5986506343,
0.0110987173,
0.5678368211,
-0.433149308,
0.1472177505,
-0.1321956515,
0.4550175071,
-0.0343282484,
-0.75601542,
0.3353047669,
0.2167886943,
-0.0959763005,
-0.6000728011,
0.5646221042,
-0.7319280505,
-0.6119701266,
0.186399743,
0.6099715829,
0.2106761783,
-0.1092061102,
-0.601741612,
-0.0265251976,
0.1890700608,
-0.516569674,
0.6810776591,
0.9742915034,
0.0079753194,
0.7904195786,
0.7707798481,
0.0237550065,
-0.0060948711,
0.159483552,
1.0691292286,
-0.6604299545,
-0.6240594387,
-1.2081924677,
0.3895946741,
0.0250275247,
-0.2872089744,
0.9856209159,
0.7279616594,
0.9064654708,
0.0693909675,
0.8265019655,
0.3498137891,
0.419195205,
-0.60814327,
1.0074638128,
-0.3612107038,
0.476124227,
-0.135609448,
-0.783905983,
-0.1177644581,
0.3822955191,
-0.2447690815,
-0.0765518323,
0.5952376127,
0.5388206244,
-0.0382220857,
0.0283173379,
0.5602114797,
0.3296162784,
0.2982037663,
0.5551762581,
0.9684616923,
0.066704385,
0.3160018623,
-0.3973903656,
-0.1997378916,
0.3458166718,
-1.0084370375,
-1.1992986202,
-0.4724205732,
-0.1336450726,
-0.0316215083,
-0.1530183852,
0.7477265,
0.2718307078,
-0.5296102762,
-0.1831427217,
-0.2488579899,
-0.2345701307,
-0.0422321148,
-0.1128723547,
0.1089001298,
-0.37252298,
-0.870706141,
0.7713352442,
0.3114605248,
0.356483072,
-0.6166620851,
0.2517700791,
-0.0103865033,
0.3730514348,
0.3906649351,
0.3589729071,
-0.4641864598,
-0.0811691135,
-0.3318339586,
0.0744367093,
-0.0886184722,
0.9388713837,
-0.9007105231,
0.5859513283,
0.203667134,
0.5334028602,
0.6288761497,
0.0286621526,
0.6124733686,
-1.0145899057,
0.4670575857,
0.3932534456,
0.4781605303,
0.1274683625,
-0.6189118028,
0.3442130089,
-0.2392327785,
-0.5367585421,
-0.9534015059,
0.2760440111,
-0.5945718884,
-0.7961677909,
1.1352550983,
-0.0942266658,
-0.3547454476,
-0.2406735122,
-0.1889270097,
0.2439767122,
-0.1126431599,
1.1872498989,
0.5271725655,
0.0317392461,
0.04272791,
-0.4837084413,
0.5092613101,
0.3397935331,
-0.7830945253,
0.863509953,
0.5121213198,
0.2149474472,
-0.0624439195,
0.7391043901,
-0.2048299909,
-0.2276280671,
-0.0482332967,
-0.0865641534,
-0.3205930889,
-0.5279067755,
-0.320392102,
0.0908281505,
-0.0338862389,
-0.108290717
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10051v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10051v1
|
SwissNYF: Tool Grounded LLM Agents for Black Box Setting
| 2024-02-15T16:15:38 | 2024-02-15T16:15:38 |
Somnath Sendhil Kumar, Dhruv Jain, Eshaan Agarwal, Raunak Pandey
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
While Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated enhanced capabilities in
function-calling, these advancements primarily rely on accessing the functions'
responses. This methodology is practical for simpler APIs but faces scalability
issues with irreversible APIs that significantly impact the system, such as a
database deletion API. Similarly, processes requiring extensive time for each
API call and those necessitating forward planning, like automated action
pipelines, present complex challenges. Furthermore, scenarios often arise where
a generalized approach is needed because algorithms lack direct access to the
specific implementations of these functions or secrets to use them. Traditional
tool planning methods are inadequate in these cases, compelling the need to
operate within black-box environments. Unlike their performance in tool
manipulation, LLMs excel in black-box tasks, such as program synthesis.
Therefore, we harness the program synthesis capabilities of LLMs to strategize
tool usage in black-box settings, ensuring solutions are verified prior to
implementation. We introduce TOPGUN, an ingeniously crafted approach leveraging
program synthesis for black box tool planning. Accompanied by SwissNYF, a
comprehensive suite that integrates black-box algorithms for planning and
verification tasks, addressing the aforementioned challenges and enhancing the
versatility and effectiveness of LLMs in complex API interactions. The public
code for SwissNYF is available at https://github.com/iclr-dummy-user/SwissNYF.
|
[
-0.2823625505,
-0.8383700252,
0.6217218637,
0.4011506736,
-0.3405597508,
0.4848085046,
-0.1469702274,
-0.3716344535,
0.1775351614,
0.7767317891,
-0.9299324155,
-0.7170193791,
-0.4153572321,
0.0323918052,
-0.4815841913,
0.8281681538,
-0.053277161,
-0.3218340278,
-0.0784991384,
-0.1818071902,
-0.4193119705,
-0.5509179235,
-0.459286958,
-0.8964924812,
0.1924166828,
0.2952239811,
0.731225729,
0.6216496825,
0.1087265983,
0.3642406464,
0.0546809882,
0.0932772979,
-0.7409930825,
0.1899658144,
-0.3096078336,
-0.4842658341,
-0.5306659341,
-0.2932678163,
0.1323801279,
0.6036195755,
-0.2395775914,
0.169453755,
-0.3728067577,
0.3879596591,
-0.6190946698,
0.0280574989,
-0.7331501245,
0.2093847096,
0.3484892845,
-0.2274755985,
-0.1122702658,
-0.0733249635,
0.184834972,
-0.5682449341,
0.0946690813,
0.0112457182,
0.8057203889,
0.36938411,
-0.0806187689,
-0.1558842361,
-1.0473116636,
0.8157433271,
-0.6762647033,
0.1901139766,
0.3177830577,
0.2395936996,
-0.5391584635,
-0.6202495098,
-0.3001649082,
-0.1683558971,
0.0225332379,
0.0050602052,
-0.3354232311,
0.0915049091,
0.4586628973,
0.1622170061,
-0.443249017,
0.1334647983,
-0.3737842441,
-0.3263113499,
0.5112233162,
0.1763056219,
0.0009704863,
0.2345196605,
-0.3199512064,
0.1036727652,
-1.086280942,
-0.0640734807,
0.5764297247,
0.1714616716,
-0.1078911722,
0.7394248247,
-0.2081099451,
0.747261703,
0.2153563946,
-0.1887292266,
-0.1093323752,
-0.3822445869,
-0.48682037,
0.1843460202,
0.5717628002,
0.4445571601,
0.187420547,
-0.3762250543,
-0.4621701241,
0.1029805839,
0.5685043335,
-1.1460527182,
0.0840035081,
0.69694978,
-0.1093975902,
-0.4199618995,
-0.2367398441,
-0.4908176064,
-0.2118320614,
-0.3460251093,
0.3374076486,
0.1004357338,
-0.4788503051,
0.0895036906,
-0.2000618875,
0.264752537,
0.1013483256,
-0.5421091318,
0.2842868567,
0.8988662362,
0.8143141866,
0.0651256219,
-0.2599871159,
-0.8783025742,
0.5189041495,
-0.803789854,
0.6458982825,
-0.2623393536,
-0.7738446593,
0.1843209118,
0.0963794515,
0.6949425936,
-0.6108837724,
0.2635832727,
-0.4200800657,
-0.3716299236,
-0.1566556692,
-0.1445576698,
0.0005217239,
0.4524892271,
-0.4351053238,
0.9709266424,
0.2452642769,
-0.4807954431,
0.3397758603,
-0.4790304303,
-0.5227987766,
0.1448815316,
-0.2647360861,
-0.3162712157,
0.1733269393,
0.1330910921,
0.6602759361,
-0.202548638,
0.2899043858,
-0.6689057946,
-0.6255960464,
0.3726315796,
0.238771826,
0.8316521049,
0.1648469567,
-0.5322404504,
0.4655733705,
-0.9027894139,
0.1319993734,
0.0130446646,
-0.0363333225,
-0.3283545077,
0.0292168353,
-0.0046768417,
0.188585937,
0.0271699037,
-0.6040396094,
0.0184552968,
-0.7467495799,
0.5801355839,
0.8362582326,
-0.0122479191,
0.312910378,
-0.155904457,
0.6631301641,
-0.3478618562,
-0.0718852803,
-0.0459417813,
-0.0270929802,
-0.7031282187,
-0.2734746039,
0.0785932541,
0.8323503137,
-0.8509011269,
0.5461882949,
0.0794342533,
-0.4111938775,
-0.5208191872,
0.4782081544,
0.4695006311,
0.2597289681,
-0.1580892652,
-0.2291927189,
-0.4268088341,
-1.0430984497,
0.180052489,
-0.2625555992,
-0.0233051218,
0.004508364,
0.3836115003,
-0.3438153267,
0.8223314285,
-0.5991349816,
-0.0998059213,
-0.4056102931,
-0.0182628501,
0.3406154513,
0.1965385228,
0.6204185486,
-0.5398666263,
-0.1302688122,
0.0772318393,
-0.7314215302,
-0.3983770609,
0.029416291,
-0.5284399986,
0.0749233961,
0.6106348038,
-0.5969720483,
0.4245629609,
0.6337132454,
-0.1648644358,
0.6744165421,
-0.1594806463,
-0.161917448,
-0.8645834923,
0.1201680526,
0.0182198696,
-0.3176656067,
-0.6794012189,
0.2671725452,
-0.0511502326,
-0.3879971504,
-0.5840684175,
0.8321080208,
-0.3991697133,
-0.4384742975,
-0.5650060177,
-0.1663778573,
-0.1781841964,
0.4912111759,
-0.0025434638,
1.1091156006,
0.5697352886,
-0.6180983186,
0.2710342109,
-0.0013072268,
-0.0095300814,
0.8337931633,
-0.987742126,
0.1508571506,
0.2607270181,
-0.1348233074,
-0.771351397,
-0.0637878999,
0.4239459932,
-0.098212786,
0.4574199617,
-0.6288478374,
-0.7145907879,
-0.1517142653,
-0.3612138331,
0.0342535973,
0.40668571,
-0.2888036072,
0.7515743971,
0.4212647378,
-0.2216166258,
-0.9839061499,
-0.7965266705,
0.1884616315,
-0.0132198008,
-0.4638900459,
0.2196480185,
-0.3586175442,
-0.4710296094,
0.0449470617,
-0.3069140911,
0.0386245772,
0.223110944,
0.5442823172,
0.3005021811,
0.0596293472,
-0.2664079666,
0.0750602558,
-0.4179147184,
0.1339470744,
-0.5177535415,
0.2400284111,
0.0287418775,
-0.4147531092,
0.0834780112,
0.4907931387,
0.6922003031,
-0.2469139248,
0.308273375,
0.6008406281,
-0.415772289,
-0.7083188891,
-0.5271698833,
-0.0638959184,
-0.5808684826,
0.1464908719,
-0.3086229265,
-0.9295521975,
0.5975488424,
-0.2744935453,
0.4638542831,
-0.2623566985,
0.9542664289,
0.2572403252,
0.8049921989,
0.8685702682,
0.1378761232,
0.4254505634,
-0.4767136872,
0.3544350266,
-0.6484231353,
0.0616153888,
-0.4107207656,
-0.2404809147,
-0.3546427786,
-0.2655937672,
0.3496685624,
-0.0172346719,
-0.0350288264,
0.2829609513,
-0.5890765786,
0.5699824095,
0.4299662709,
-0.2581630945,
0.1612862349,
0.2675671577,
-0.5083960891,
0.2173600495,
-0.4662332535,
-0.5190736651,
1.1729326248,
0.1939066201,
0.902001977,
-0.2394725084,
1.0001060963,
0.1039138734,
0.3861916959,
-1.0250338316,
0.8280327916,
0.1303719133,
-0.6529591084,
-0.3165415227,
-0.1412063837,
-0.8640061617,
0.339722544,
-0.0208580084,
-0.6362521052,
0.0752560496,
0.091946803,
-0.2676039338,
0.1428702176,
-0.7682415843,
0.5784433484,
-0.3589349091,
-0.70774436,
-0.112060912,
-0.3013647199,
0.2924279869,
-0.10521961,
0.2265417427,
-0.3376745582,
-0.1025512964,
0.3371239901,
-0.3957305849,
0.8688460588,
-0.1589930803,
-0.2434763461,
0.2252699584,
0.5416452885,
0.6349199414,
0.1898967624,
-0.1450725347,
0.3375322819,
0.1635257006,
-0.3493512869,
-0.4350969195,
0.8962861896,
-0.723023653,
-0.8378411531,
-0.4761814773,
-0.601701498,
-0.1975220442,
0.5239194632,
-0.1645606607,
0.4715756178,
-0.2698883414,
0.0386951715,
0.6055904627,
-0.153761372,
0.5005629659,
0.7049072385,
-0.3473050594,
-0.564819932,
0.6661248803,
0.2965797186,
0.257347703,
0.2298763543,
-0.0246342141,
-0.1168653369,
-1.0948829651,
-0.7025004625,
0.3426745236,
-0.7613446712,
-0.2735653818,
-0.3544536531,
-0.1108366773,
-0.0509743206,
-0.5510835052,
-0.1485587507,
-0.4119795859,
-0.2283072323,
-0.4458160996,
0.1865044236,
0.6203353405,
0.0097342925,
0.2624054849,
-0.4772012532,
0.4066881835,
0.2561156452,
0.5330572128,
-0.1738713533,
0.125516355,
-0.2391127348,
-0.1973654479,
-0.2135245353,
-0.6664987803,
0.3970962167,
-0.2119328231,
0.7971206307,
0.1536582261,
0.1749542803,
0.686139822,
-0.4975799918,
0.6341260076,
-0.0012789984,
-0.7035515904,
0.5015497208,
-0.3749071956,
0.38091591,
0.2486677319,
0.1448220611,
-0.1174777821,
-0.8335778117,
-0.4655966759,
-0.7781347036,
0.7569801211,
0.2305342406,
0.1122045889,
0.3276307285,
0.4138401747,
0.13862589,
0.499099642,
-0.5693445206,
-0.2405425459,
-0.2541854978,
-0.1013982072,
-0.1620988399,
-0.2315510511,
-0.7851305604,
0.1745828986,
0.5399888158,
-0.3330485225,
0.3127193153,
0.0133594638,
-0.1223679334,
-0.4708879292,
0.5520805717,
0.6691459417,
1.3063027859,
-0.2707422674,
-0.0692317262,
0.0453433618,
-0.1522866189,
0.4303126633,
0.336940378,
-0.6198336482,
-0.1855781972,
0.4185774624,
0.485044688,
0.4460673928,
-0.8181524277,
0.2313947827,
0.1374918967,
-0.420978725,
-0.4236015975,
0.4053674042,
0.3110402524,
0.5554753542,
0.4438705742,
-0.3214128017,
-0.0602477081,
-0.5414184332,
0.1709506661,
0.5604294538,
-0.2266087234,
-0.3346497715,
0.3353854716,
0.1299866438,
-0.6060492992,
0.0959103331,
-0.3503510952,
-0.3961902261,
0.5605604649,
0.6012125611,
1.1195161343,
0.1311668456,
0.3265379369,
0.0141225364,
0.485147953,
0.0960998088,
0.4173817635,
0.1055018455,
-0.5051985383,
-0.6252576709,
-0.7181921005,
-0.477922231,
0.1932867318,
-0.2462952435,
0.2311914414,
-0.9919169545,
-0.3122444153,
-0.1051074415,
0.2245516926,
-0.6663812995,
-0.3136872649,
-0.3368401825,
0.7987887263,
-0.5382367373,
0.653849721,
0.9620953798,
-0.1286983043,
-0.4809057415,
-0.2622022927,
0.3314041495,
-0.7899759412,
0.4412764311,
-0.0585121587,
-0.4256683886,
-0.0316685028,
-0.628911376,
-0.5255621076,
1.1971263885,
0.5873999596,
-0.4474849403,
0.1025091559,
-0.0750725493,
0.6299238205,
-0.4025923312,
-0.1207333282,
0.4513655007,
0.5033156276,
0.4146516919,
-0.8697444797,
0.1991330981,
-0.0083485106,
-0.0030912701,
0.3659154475,
-0.4607491791,
0.3881047368,
-0.2350357324,
-0.2392050028,
-0.0007861548,
0.3346162438,
0.5339980125,
0.3020530045,
0.3715123534,
0.561819911,
0.3256133795,
-0.0400328077,
0.8639913797,
-0.1319629401,
-0.1457202286,
0.7233294845,
-0.6728688478,
0.7670029402,
0.5329324603,
-0.1496366858,
0.3160344958,
0.4661877155,
-0.1094820127,
0.5316877365,
0.2565996945,
-0.1565607339,
-0.262104094,
-0.028510144,
0.0173908416,
0.1613737196,
0.5731413364,
0.0673759729,
-0.4980886579,
-0.0790437087,
-0.0029617716,
-0.0001075389,
-0.3063984513,
0.7783648372,
0.2306949347,
-0.6863668561,
0.6542072892,
0.2531693876,
0.4795428216,
-0.9358472228,
-0.2102752179,
-0.0667061135,
0.2926035821,
-0.0785705671,
-0.744648695,
0.2182615697,
-0.1339647919,
-0.014923349,
-0.3407126665,
1.1027281284,
-0.4714430571,
-0.5387046337,
0.5074993968,
0.5911387205,
-0.2152414024,
0.2287884802,
-0.9779347181,
0.4935694933,
-0.1714949608,
-0.0001198433,
0.4233865142,
0.5826924443,
-0.0722352415,
1.0163326263,
0.915348053,
0.5544585586,
-0.0310364552,
-0.1216163486,
0.820612371,
-0.5256467462,
-0.6453403831,
-0.594692409,
0.3875630796,
0.0434802473,
-0.0705059692,
0.4827136397,
0.246232152,
0.9739826918,
-0.095193468,
0.721304059,
0.2304149121,
0.3658194542,
-0.6132433414,
0.4989904761,
-0.3869982064,
0.4007391632,
-0.1634748131,
-0.8497212529,
-0.2295584977,
0.555518806,
-0.0450358652,
-0.264588654,
0.3787183464,
1.1838246584,
-0.2174011022,
-0.3946434557,
0.5256835818,
-0.0306068417,
0.6459898949,
0.4294050336,
0.7268009186,
0.1193421409,
0.8052008152,
-0.3121038079,
-0.1677263677,
-0.323143512,
-1.1685544252,
-1.2909626961,
-0.2235090137,
-0.3348219097,
-0.1948795319,
0.2337817401,
1.1893006563,
0.9973675013,
-0.624338448,
-0.7590047121,
0.2243027985,
0.3698244393,
-0.4116478264,
-0.1743906736,
0.0759601817,
-0.1332372725,
-0.4846915901,
0.3723576665,
0.5880938172,
0.1669617742,
-0.7241627574,
-0.2624632418,
-0.0244205631,
0.0940675735,
0.7443051934,
0.4547125697,
-0.9730997086,
-0.2985998392,
-0.0821830854,
0.1568198353,
-0.2328655571,
1.171792388,
-0.7854881287,
0.6655429602,
0.1934817135,
0.952152133,
0.6740789413,
-0.2113035917,
0.9433962107,
-0.9493017793,
0.4558264613,
0.1448855102,
0.2316183895,
0.2928130031,
-0.4742709696,
0.6539171934,
-0.0303933341,
-0.3383610845,
-1.1522579193,
0.2638202012,
-0.934687078,
-0.3973897099,
1.1464805603,
-0.1553099304,
-0.2792576253,
-0.3311862648,
-0.2954694033,
-0.0635645241,
-0.4916033745,
0.5599880815,
1.2566039562,
0.0193150882,
-0.3425779343,
-0.9128409028,
0.3011039495,
-0.0188852679,
-0.6902498603,
0.283016175,
0.7920351028,
0.4748950005,
0.1991711706,
0.7116995454,
-0.0513660572,
0.2428242117,
-0.20579952,
-0.2150123715,
-0.7370370626,
-0.3526692986,
-0.2599968612,
0.2556994557,
0.2566603422,
0.2032344937
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10038v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10038v2
|
RS-DPO: A Hybrid Rejection Sampling and Direct Preference Optimization Method for Alignment of Large Language Models
| 2024-02-15T16:00:58 | 2024-03-30T16:10:47 |
Saeed Khaki, JinJin Li, Lan Ma, Liu Yang, Prathap Ramachandra
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
Reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF) has been extensively
employed to align large language models with user intent. However, proximal
policy optimization (PPO) based RLHF is occasionally unstable requiring
significant hyperparameter finetuning, and computationally expensive to
maximize the estimated reward during alignment. Recently, direct preference
optimization (DPO) is proposed to address those challenges. However, DPO relies
on contrastive responses generated from human annotator and alternative LLM,
instead of the policy model, limiting the effectiveness of the RLHF. In this
paper, we addresses both challenges by systematically combining rejection
sampling (RS) and DPO. Our proposed method, RS-DPO, initiates with the
development of a supervised fine-tuned policy model (SFT). A varied set of k
responses per prompt are sampled directly from the SFT model. RS-DPO identifies
pairs of contrastive samples based on their reward distribution. Finally, we
apply DPO with the contrastive samples to align the model to human preference.
Our experiments indicate that our proposed method effectively fine-tunes LLMs
with limited resource environments, leading to improved alignment with user
intent. Furthermore, it outperforms existing methods, including RS, PPO, and
DPO.
|
[
-0.3654047549,
-0.3767575026,
0.5269351602,
0.0831590965,
-0.2305763662,
0.2689139843,
-0.531652689,
-0.0850431994,
0.0927249044,
0.5885577202,
-0.9426314831,
-0.2330352664,
-0.1352838874,
0.2693680525,
0.317620486,
0.9529755116,
-0.0718701929,
0.0332333781,
-0.0722052976,
0.2501502931,
-0.2902743518,
-0.1666276306,
-0.6150822043,
-0.5444604158,
0.4594411552,
0.6980484128,
0.6501412988,
0.5527020693,
0.3380644619,
0.3181970417,
-0.2030342221,
0.505073905,
-0.5653547049,
-0.0211476665,
-0.3006575704,
-0.1305745989,
-0.2924855351,
0.0079916762,
0.7036015391,
0.4844953418,
-0.294908464,
-0.1327079386,
0.2462562025,
0.6993970275,
-0.7716925144,
-0.1947987378,
-0.6007796526,
0.124357596,
0.1169905663,
-0.2817158103,
-0.5518564582,
-0.4611152709,
0.3028439879,
-0.9188579917,
-0.0003173132,
0.1576867849,
0.6944605708,
0.2600879967,
-0.219642505,
-0.1582056433,
-0.8576290011,
1.1498756409,
-0.4600122273,
0.1195830777,
0.4208067656,
0.1823163778,
-0.5332276225,
0.0140548497,
-0.9668869376,
-0.4914900064,
-0.0958225802,
0.1155774519,
0.1302468181,
0.2531374395,
0.0042137234,
0.3644515276,
-0.5129517317,
0.5271027088,
-0.0800981298,
-0.2981002033,
0.6801888347,
0.1694788635,
0.0849604085,
-0.1930204779,
-0.6578711271,
-0.4278086126,
-0.562391758,
0.1222829372,
0.7506249547,
0.524579823,
-0.0082704639,
0.4048607051,
-0.425234139,
0.9513144493,
0.2941168249,
-0.3161440194,
0.2196616083,
-0.3414700925,
0.0254473574,
-0.1545230895,
1.0509575605,
0.3691484034,
0.1920470595,
0.0215166658,
-0.4263162911,
-0.0593415983,
0.1389694363,
-0.4962118268,
0.0643856078,
0.2500693798,
-0.2592896223,
-0.6364697814,
-0.1400566548,
-0.9640151262,
-0.4949763119,
-0.5228427649,
0.1237421483,
-0.2209309936,
-0.3861736953,
0.1445322484,
0.0488723852,
0.0358091109,
0.2877839506,
-1.2523258924,
0.3579584062,
0.7412281632,
0.4717332423,
-0.4473619759,
-0.3400850594,
-0.6998355985,
0.1213712394,
-0.2121814489,
0.5394424796,
-0.657324791,
-0.485316515,
0.0575753339,
-0.2442117482,
0.0250877533,
-0.7189639211,
0.861687541,
-0.5135229826,
0.2604695261,
-0.3471315801,
-0.2236013561,
0.0117139239,
0.2771893144,
-0.5059747696,
0.8572989702,
0.2483810633,
-0.6714387536,
0.416808486,
-0.5227169991,
-0.2478398234,
0.0105996169,
-0.3030747473,
-0.5198361874,
-0.077902168,
0.226736486,
0.1266980618,
-0.1970457137,
0.4839653373,
-0.4438700974,
-0.5191245675,
0.3344773054,
-0.1704386771,
0.4780451953,
0.3474319279,
-0.2430989891,
0.566917479,
-0.888279438,
-0.1448413879,
0.1926569194,
-0.5301894546,
-0.4727942348,
0.2159737945,
0.0672444254,
0.3371822536,
0.0216379203,
-0.6739219427,
0.2879672647,
-0.4462889433,
0.4794694483,
1.0328323841,
-0.3153018057,
0.6953755021,
-0.180465892,
0.694912076,
-0.1914713085,
0.142976895,
0.4502736628,
0.0793049261,
-0.2702821791,
-0.4190719724,
0.2809372544,
0.4977786839,
-0.6117144227,
0.7659287453,
-0.1926654726,
-0.0472978912,
-0.5789644718,
0.0867760628,
0.5084115267,
0.8740420341,
0.2542997897,
-0.1422967166,
-0.5722120404,
-1.1577488184,
0.0450532027,
-0.2096416056,
-0.0244901199,
0.5033534169,
0.0787484944,
-0.0690615997,
0.8985202909,
-0.5919122696,
-0.2833947837,
-0.3732999563,
-0.1111794189,
0.0962477699,
0.4567064941,
0.3861474693,
-0.7271682024,
-0.4611490667,
0.0361952707,
0.0195071828,
-0.1181575507,
-0.0205855928,
-0.2374137342,
0.1356116831,
-0.0816083252,
-0.2649968565,
-0.1717339307,
0.8092727661,
-0.1451548785,
0.5963260531,
-0.1904728711,
0.1834218055,
-0.9573538899,
0.0481716245,
0.1219099313,
-0.1175829321,
-0.2270805687,
-0.1396755576,
-0.0622024797,
-0.3009046018,
-0.2358637303,
0.596026659,
-0.2368659228,
0.0066222656,
-0.3626758456,
0.1063990742,
-0.0455500148,
0.6297747493,
0.4782528281,
0.8907071352,
0.1656862646,
-0.7122879028,
0.2076615542,
0.3599285185,
-0.1346120089,
0.4490512908,
-0.4518380463,
0.1939941496,
-0.1079486161,
0.4337903857,
-1.1217758656,
-0.2410487533,
0.5399169922,
-0.095195733,
0.289876312,
-0.0872019604,
-0.1776660085,
-0.4020863473,
-0.5601733327,
0.3599197567,
0.4794619977,
-0.5428317189,
0.3278603852,
0.3604540229,
-0.1062561721,
-0.8177734017,
-0.1784922481,
-0.3941622972,
-0.1649875939,
-0.2242774814,
0.6417247653,
0.0160222575,
-0.1666559726,
-0.1189062148,
-0.1808713526,
0.1956887543,
0.0024443108,
0.0104815206,
0.4986474216,
0.2045721859,
-0.1371384263,
-0.0288717821,
-0.2300577015,
-0.2966871858,
-0.160544157,
0.6922271252,
0.178206414,
-0.1674589664,
-0.7651526928,
0.2000608146,
0.199845463,
-0.1024235263,
0.3027002513,
0.3664501309,
0.1588194817,
-0.3522757292,
-0.2966157198,
-0.341429919,
-0.4958164096,
0.4189063013,
-0.4370730817,
-0.8386244774,
0.1279533505,
-0.135753274,
0.1444017589,
0.1331149042,
0.4980116785,
0.0277139135,
0.9673356414,
0.5056010485,
-0.2678930163,
0.8648841977,
0.0160240736,
-0.0230357368,
-0.8524961472,
-0.0215167869,
-0.5449852943,
-0.5318975449,
-0.6710861921,
-0.1386473775,
0.1246215627,
0.0447270833,
-0.1496246904,
0.2515848577,
-0.6564279795,
0.3900342882,
0.7595040202,
0.3664420545,
0.2347689271,
0.2040143758,
-0.1873937994,
-0.2660179138,
-0.5070700645,
-0.4444432855,
1.0177465677,
0.2245479822,
0.7818306684,
-0.0689895451,
0.8482733965,
0.091201596,
0.0663337037,
-0.8126052618,
0.6568375826,
-0.1300854087,
-0.2020335048,
-0.3746915162,
-0.562846899,
-0.8492848873,
0.3946876228,
-0.4798596501,
-0.5428894758,
0.2587939203,
0.6449669003,
-0.6275141835,
0.0869707689,
-0.6312968731,
0.6366772652,
-0.2495174557,
-0.5088341236,
-0.4992285371,
-0.4425612688,
0.3242026865,
0.1849921197,
0.1127555221,
-0.2022138536,
-0.0393469296,
0.5471534729,
-0.2728997469,
0.6364587545,
-0.2427485138,
-0.1721817553,
0.152553007,
0.1512910575,
0.8116777539,
-0.0541694835,
-0.2133516669,
-0.3946506083,
-0.2109346092,
-0.2582656145,
-0.4598893225,
0.7585774064,
-0.9081124067,
-0.572474122,
-0.305568099,
-0.5647066236,
-0.4279998839,
0.1484193206,
-0.1134446189,
0.1567434072,
-0.1422377974,
-0.2090321481,
0.5068207383,
-0.3913922608,
0.2164906114,
0.7733296752,
-0.1227362975,
-0.6291893125,
0.97580266,
-0.3977418542,
0.43463099,
0.5970913768,
0.6341955066,
-0.4225916862,
-0.6889055371,
-0.4115788341,
0.3281887472,
-0.2609855831,
0.0259199925,
-0.2166660875,
0.2202623039,
-0.4171315432,
-0.0805643201,
-0.3611613512,
-0.1179304495,
-0.1241371781,
0.1329179853,
0.1667733639,
0.2827410996,
-0.0814380348,
0.1869942397,
-0.4681566358,
0.339420557,
0.2894793451,
0.4964723587,
-0.2108216584,
-0.4810121357,
0.2270620018,
0.0848298743,
-0.3582711816,
-0.6187823415,
0.2190431952,
-0.1508812606,
0.4956105351,
0.3158177435,
0.4281033278,
0.5486704111,
-0.421885103,
0.4014293253,
0.1777453274,
-0.5676705241,
0.628621161,
-0.4334082603,
-0.0008035414,
0.8735861778,
0.4529120326,
-0.4395783842,
0.1157701686,
-0.3426487744,
-0.763497889,
0.9810368419,
-0.2434934527,
0.0757805109,
0.1160143763,
0.3760168254,
0.1836262941,
0.1178853586,
-0.6217902303,
-0.0270781815,
0.3196917474,
-0.2237160653,
-0.0195612703,
-0.316221863,
-0.4366812408,
-0.072404027,
0.8363934755,
-0.2401328534,
-0.1443606764,
0.1565247327,
0.0951611921,
-0.3036117852,
0.4548079967,
0.8903141022,
0.6013588309,
-0.3959253132,
-0.2473228574,
-0.1652235091,
-0.3571050465,
0.3013591468,
0.0865058228,
-0.55907619,
-0.2686261833,
-0.1499006003,
0.9787392616,
0.2145396471,
-0.858109951,
0.3996975124,
0.0578909293,
-0.3651255071,
-0.1581318676,
0.0956438258,
-0.2398033589,
0.0960311219,
0.060092058,
-0.0784486905,
0.1264468879,
-0.3109773099,
0.0170937553,
0.5427134037,
-0.3873101771,
-0.2188267857,
0.4221679866,
0.5445642471,
-0.4096689522,
0.4883396327,
-0.2374308556,
-0.4402197301,
0.2469640374,
0.5664020181,
0.7140449882,
0.0340635031,
0.4074164629,
0.4737424254,
-0.0460894741,
-0.2169626802,
0.1400268376,
-0.3826991916,
-0.9572272897,
-0.5546973944,
-0.6726073027,
-0.7321982384,
0.324208498,
-0.6698594689,
0.3816318214,
-0.574198246,
-0.009815976,
-0.1162783653,
0.2531448305,
-0.4248594642,
0.0107684229,
0.0938982591,
0.4464770257,
-0.9419742227,
0.7704755068,
0.7002531886,
-0.3520616293,
-0.7842520475,
0.1886579692,
0.136407882,
-0.9503967762,
0.6318126321,
-0.3118155003,
-0.2471989542,
0.0818667337,
-0.2187982202,
-0.6467089057,
0.7266529799,
0.3468157351,
-0.9866155982,
0.1790134758,
-0.1398020089,
0.343822211,
-0.1681486964,
0.0745714009,
0.6077060103,
0.4348111153,
0.1937015951,
-0.93725425,
0.1887926012,
0.2443812639,
0.2008616775,
0.3052746356,
-0.7958881259,
0.41361022,
-0.2354202271,
-0.0494350828,
-0.0613349825,
0.5097336769,
0.7790558338,
-0.0617795698,
0.8403264284,
0.5914239287,
0.440051347,
0.1055560037,
1.0317181349,
-0.0467146412,
0.2336474508,
1.1337871552,
-0.5994452834,
1.0064356327,
0.847648859,
-0.5442945361,
0.3291191757,
0.7736495733,
0.2169392407,
0.808914125,
0.5115357637,
-0.2830944061,
-0.2289646566,
-0.1564308256,
-0.1019652486,
0.3061398268,
-0.0170062911,
-0.2033219934,
-0.1401592791,
-0.1655589789,
-0.1105080023,
0.6219502091,
-0.1874192357,
0.9123239517,
-0.2730508447,
-1.1474260092,
0.5466940403,
-0.0104449075,
1.0678019524,
-0.591496408,
-0.0181910545,
-0.1539867371,
0.4789819121,
-0.1888325065,
-0.7353060842,
0.0947130322,
-0.2607320547,
-0.2465266585,
-0.4120267928,
0.4862135947,
-0.5758500099,
-0.0612518042,
0.2523022294,
-0.029347457,
-0.2035037875,
0.1844268888,
-0.7400225401,
0.19874461,
0.1763674766,
-0.2958415747,
0.6239561439,
0.0106879137,
-0.0594553873,
0.4672645628,
0.6651089191,
0.4122050703,
-0.5250641108,
0.1994466037,
0.7508557439,
-0.4301023483,
-0.6320343614,
-0.8220245242,
0.2658813596,
-0.1275433898,
-0.4263055027,
0.3680243492,
0.3793374896,
1.03294909,
-0.0740518495,
0.800801754,
0.0118811019,
0.8313646913,
-0.4599396884,
0.1776946038,
-0.560388267,
0.1697558612,
-0.3541928828,
-0.9501489401,
0.0337511152,
0.5435220599,
-0.5009672642,
-0.1732968241,
0.2727360129,
0.8981225491,
0.0230982713,
-0.2508324981,
0.0474348851,
-0.4391777515,
0.1271953434,
0.6363618374,
0.8710516691,
0.0019352327,
0.5626316667,
-0.4128172994,
-0.3529100716,
-0.3326079845,
-0.8278416991,
-0.5557310581,
-0.500158608,
-0.2635282576,
-0.4388848245,
0.0573512651,
1.3495345116,
0.7320095301,
-0.8600638509,
-0.2958508134,
-0.1468190402,
0.2028054148,
-0.3894233704,
-0.2450319678,
0.2723036408,
-0.2884763181,
-1.0502392054,
0.3671346307,
0.2041860223,
0.0968508348,
-0.3830045462,
-0.4454223216,
-0.1343440115,
-0.3310148716,
0.3425433636,
0.5049953461,
-0.8826921582,
-0.3133989871,
-0.0082188277,
-0.1898640394,
-0.1140141711,
0.9885150194,
-0.6171039343,
0.443554461,
0.727897048,
0.8206179142,
0.2705349624,
0.2209912241,
0.9488762617,
-0.6722078919,
0.3423410356,
0.4437860847,
0.0705038309,
0.1788155735,
-0.4132785499,
0.3034027219,
0.1977406889,
-0.5398316979,
-0.8815627098,
0.5653663874,
-1.0019593239,
-0.2753017247,
1.3363335133,
0.1211967766,
-0.1468033046,
0.1812103838,
-0.5518062711,
-0.0161044896,
-0.667532742,
0.836791873,
0.5439748764,
-0.2810999751,
-0.1786438972,
-0.1795856506,
0.8554363251,
0.7164055109,
-0.4594232738,
0.1263812035,
0.5554305911,
0.3040842116,
-0.0641608313,
0.8985808492,
-0.0187503416,
0.1368707418,
-0.2887221277,
0.2002022415,
-0.1931521595,
-0.0434164926,
-0.461469233,
-0.1194620728,
0.336766988,
-0.5172311068
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10024v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10024v2
|
Self-Augmented In-Context Learning for Unsupervised Word Translation
| 2024-02-15T15:43:05 | 2024-06-05T13:38:42 |
Yaoyiran Li, Anna Korhonen, Ivan Vulić
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Recent work has shown that, while large language models (LLMs) demonstrate
strong word translation or bilingual lexicon induction (BLI) capabilities in
few-shot setups, they still cannot match the performance of 'traditional'
mapping-based approaches in the unsupervised scenario where no seed translation
pairs are available, especially for lower-resource languages. To address this
challenge with LLMs, we propose self-augmented in-context learning (SAIL) for
unsupervised BLI: starting from a zero-shot prompt, SAIL iteratively induces a
set of high-confidence word translation pairs for in-context learning (ICL)
from an LLM, which it then reapplies to the same LLM in the ICL fashion. Our
method shows substantial gains over zero-shot prompting of LLMs on two
established BLI benchmarks spanning a wide range of language pairs, also
outperforming mapping-based baselines across the board. In addition to
achieving state-of-the-art unsupervised BLI performance, we also conduct
comprehensive analyses on SAIL and discuss its limitations.
|
[
-0.1660155952,
-0.3882651925,
0.5797171593,
0.4236728847,
-0.5721974373,
0.3242959678,
-0.4732955396,
-0.3807011545,
0.079318136,
0.4784316123,
-0.576251328,
-0.589368403,
-0.55717206,
0.204511106,
-0.4079575241,
0.9127711058,
-0.0750982463,
-0.1037279069,
-0.3090680242,
-0.4176250398,
-0.6915202737,
-0.3328064084,
-0.3432630897,
-0.4137316346,
0.2699458301,
0.7840918303,
0.1323292851,
0.2480428964,
0.1898172498,
0.2170818746,
-0.0675975457,
0.447932303,
-0.3896128833,
0.2228947431,
-0.3489421904,
-0.0720222071,
-0.3043715656,
-0.0398932658,
0.7572025657,
0.7985599041,
-0.0935628787,
0.2722806931,
0.5406684279,
0.5379725695,
-0.9062697291,
0.2517166734,
-0.7218849063,
-0.1338353902,
-0.3543803692,
-0.3773650825,
-0.4521208704,
0.321697861,
0.0138147343,
-0.7067046762,
-0.0266317874,
0.3248076439,
0.1865088344,
0.2735567987,
-0.7056609988,
-0.3202522099,
-0.6251188517,
0.8299606442,
-0.6845106483,
0.3912146688,
0.2252209336,
0.075683713,
-0.4161306024,
-0.5927122235,
-0.6180031896,
0.0179018788,
-0.0482656136,
0.3617471755,
0.0320545249,
-0.1062890813,
0.0382246599,
0.1779775918,
-0.501642406,
0.3110612631,
-0.1450279057,
0.1102654934,
0.8087107539,
0.1763712317,
0.2746713758,
-0.1458313614,
-0.6192084551,
-0.0222689845,
-0.9960973859,
0.2100041509,
-0.3112684786,
0.6536972523,
-0.4567292333,
0.6339566112,
-0.2138585448,
0.8074903488,
0.2554745972,
-0.0657703429,
0.2458538711,
-0.2469594479,
-0.0623482391,
0.4332346618,
0.7656204104,
0.34025684,
0.0159593541,
-0.2393024117,
-0.3325720429,
-0.3744577765,
-0.033572264,
-0.6129037142,
0.2439189553,
0.1050195619,
0.0219729226,
-0.0457162261,
-0.0882033184,
-0.5066257715,
-0.2766794264,
-0.0598205216,
0.7144328952,
-0.2663386464,
-0.088625297,
0.0266308859,
0.1061685532,
0.4231015444,
0.1301468164,
-0.9725535512,
-0.042985186,
0.4226045012,
0.8958865404,
-0.5499301553,
-0.6607514024,
-0.6578090191,
0.4634877741,
-0.7316080332,
0.7119724154,
-0.2997182012,
-0.6623263955,
0.215162307,
-0.0492208637,
-0.0039336588,
-0.2422941625,
0.2256451994,
-0.4761746228,
0.2355691195,
-0.3077466786,
-0.7867516279,
-0.1554289609,
0.1298798621,
-0.0458668172,
1.2019367218,
0.1328736693,
-0.5869427323,
0.5497879982,
-0.7391192317,
-0.7536071539,
0.4102838933,
-0.1070100591,
-0.0019522451,
0.3983703554,
0.431692332,
0.561073482,
-0.2240093052,
0.1678007394,
-0.2107097208,
-0.5987434983,
-0.0574170202,
-0.2364553064,
0.7292871475,
-0.060777124,
-0.5675439239,
-0.0891129225,
-0.329503864,
-0.0691366866,
0.0199710373,
-0.2720303833,
-0.6169164181,
-0.1188383996,
-0.0215060543,
0.1541277021,
0.3446157277,
-0.8555964828,
0.5092483163,
-0.9468193054,
0.0226322599,
0.5171554089,
0.0421817489,
0.7344963551,
0.2601581216,
0.242953226,
0.1196520999,
-0.2165546268,
-0.5056462288,
-0.4151895642,
-0.5895240307,
-0.2661293149,
0.1444407403,
0.4049819708,
-1.0223435163,
0.4549660385,
-0.1845742911,
-0.3026207983,
-0.4109236896,
0.4377999306,
0.6418418884,
0.7178856134,
0.8098282814,
-0.3170375824,
-0.237759918,
-0.30020684,
-0.3322537243,
-0.0051617022,
0.0897367075,
0.3420616388,
0.440156728,
-0.3209766448,
0.9151488543,
-0.3072994053,
-0.6221167445,
-0.588116467,
0.4548905194,
0.1372895092,
0.3817533553,
0.4163289666,
-0.4499631524,
-0.6888970137,
0.2249343395,
-0.9064481854,
-0.2337435782,
0.004214731,
0.1604228318,
0.3972505629,
0.6385210156,
-0.1830949336,
0.6571233273,
0.8037900329,
-0.4584685862,
0.3202374578,
-0.713500917,
0.1499904692,
-1.3181672096,
0.0046382686,
-0.1440848559,
-0.157853201,
-0.4548971951,
0.0207892191,
0.4156884253,
-0.0632183924,
-0.6325468421,
1.1037523746,
-0.6257052422,
-0.3757646382,
-0.7622313499,
0.2536551356,
-0.1722726077,
0.3724006712,
0.1861533076,
0.9865812659,
0.6841971874,
-0.7685872912,
0.2486682236,
0.475535661,
-0.4285727739,
0.5169599056,
-0.4134704769,
-0.0127749583,
-0.2308265865,
0.3558183908,
-1.0370506048,
-0.2147681117,
0.0418745428,
-0.3620170057,
0.5442060232,
-0.0948375762,
-0.1265637726,
-0.154389143,
-0.0770600662,
0.8251643777,
0.2952873409,
-1.2117931843,
0.3720912337,
0.2254964113,
0.1336011887,
-0.7082846761,
-0.7994017601,
0.2012419254,
-0.1286660284,
-0.1100806743,
0.5946929455,
-0.0957575664,
0.0727641582,
-0.1001122668,
-0.0694551766,
0.0253861584,
0.068234697,
0.2614040673,
0.1529457271,
-0.0410540476,
0.1260398924,
0.3612642884,
-0.2453972995,
-0.2671667635,
-0.5638587475,
0.1437486261,
-0.0662658587,
-0.4457086623,
-0.3291848302,
0.3119907677,
0.6194670796,
-0.5475391746,
0.5639193654,
0.2617578506,
-0.2263222486,
-0.5465626717,
-0.3515721262,
-0.1702274233,
-0.5065118074,
0.0659082681,
-0.3276959658,
-1.0703777075,
0.2507779896,
-0.288880825,
-0.0668976605,
0.3097019494,
0.5366122127,
-0.519828856,
0.7384952307,
0.7992920876,
-0.3780952394,
0.2248953432,
-0.3505607545,
0.2037139088,
-1.0810198784,
-0.1620939672,
-0.0369556211,
-0.2346739471,
-0.5098513365,
-0.5486227274,
0.697751224,
0.0878639892,
-0.1038274691,
0.3943234384,
-0.2295017093,
0.5466536283,
0.5355539918,
-0.0896355584,
0.3363505006,
-0.0385661311,
-0.5866404176,
-0.0128865652,
-0.9884626269,
0.1047387049,
1.2608921528,
-0.2191468328,
0.6717325449,
-0.0466759726,
0.9651226997,
0.2601548433,
0.3714381456,
-0.6905053258,
0.4050644338,
-0.1008870453,
-0.5888146162,
-0.4899277091,
-0.2089131922,
-0.935157001,
0.1558994502,
-0.3976815641,
-0.5938737988,
0.1830602735,
0.2585471869,
-0.3320504725,
0.1847664267,
-0.1892564297,
0.8907772303,
-0.5694637895,
-0.4968293309,
-0.215634495,
-0.454541117,
0.3155512512,
-0.2631854117,
0.2238150686,
0.1031986177,
-0.159558624,
0.2074138373,
-0.1342894137,
0.8790931702,
-0.1712293476,
-0.1415131539,
0.3427038789,
0.2804579139,
0.3393004239,
0.0137829455,
0.2297733426,
0.2484354079,
-0.1952530444,
-0.423838079,
-0.6466696858,
0.8156655431,
-0.4144145846,
-0.5040454865,
-0.5777645707,
-0.6258522272,
-0.3285701573,
0.0713967606,
0.5615374446,
0.5806313753,
-0.1765053272,
0.2174610049,
0.3748098016,
-0.1812803745,
0.9204200506,
0.8589593768,
-0.2577745616,
-0.3386649191,
0.8687331676,
0.0858293623,
-0.0734250322,
0.3617790639,
0.2437836081,
-0.6629315615,
-0.5680885315,
-0.7826698422,
0.2634441555,
-0.3344492316,
-0.3144461811,
-0.1674407423,
-0.0511787571,
-0.2717608511,
-0.5022222996,
-0.723299861,
-0.1655193716,
-0.1007980034,
0.0627492592,
0.0513667278,
0.7978338599,
-0.1264316589,
0.4659335613,
-0.6336850524,
0.0553939044,
0.3210062385,
0.2160457075,
-0.2126974761,
-0.9780171514,
-0.4593959153,
-0.0340675004,
-0.1251238883,
-0.7890121937,
0.4807685614,
0.3610728085,
0.4925948083,
0.5244860649,
0.1196189374,
0.85809201,
-0.6509327888,
0.7888255119,
0.2206235379,
-1.0871673822,
0.6549312472,
-0.3563109338,
0.5489922762,
0.5360737443,
0.5387265086,
-0.6339918375,
-0.3646491766,
-0.3584496975,
-0.7250070572,
0.5117362142,
-0.1216657981,
0.1654979438,
-0.1059658602,
0.5919699073,
-0.1845838577,
0.1401589215,
-0.7252156734,
-0.1383371055,
-0.0168752316,
-0.1055768505,
-0.6298969984,
-0.3347574472,
0.256996274,
-0.5181201696,
0.7084138989,
-0.5993449688,
-0.1520498842,
0.3735466599,
-0.4532942176,
-0.1392682046,
0.0644999817,
0.4730919302,
0.480712831,
0.0817821026,
0.1165600196,
0.7009348273,
0.0538076237,
0.2526125312,
-0.2302192599,
-0.2446909845,
-0.232088998,
0.6515350938,
0.5951102972,
0.8634009957,
-0.5282096267,
0.8873537779,
0.2595207691,
0.0151086906,
-0.0286335647,
-0.229853645,
0.01637052,
0.3502063155,
0.3670900166,
-0.4137706757,
-0.0580528863,
-0.4500460923,
0.2230913788,
0.783811152,
-0.5543703437,
-0.333515048,
0.684879303,
0.3327800035,
-0.1639591157,
0.4588593841,
-0.4666746855,
-0.5387431383,
-0.0137679931,
1.1058237553,
0.9755733609,
-0.6378009319,
0.1207184866,
0.6053248644,
0.3406996727,
-0.1668052822,
0.1841131002,
-0.598721385,
-0.8021346331,
-0.7007023692,
-0.6628770232,
-0.4227056503,
-0.0376991481,
-0.3730437756,
0.2010063082,
-0.1241119355,
0.3381031454,
-0.6502119899,
-0.0995731577,
-0.3980164826,
0.1703921258,
0.3794724941,
0.8485928774,
-1.0081019402,
1.0698354244,
0.7663792372,
-0.2709088922,
-0.6460404396,
0.2150987983,
0.116422303,
-0.6096171737,
0.61804533,
0.1196011826,
-0.4587146044,
0.3054085076,
-0.3859176338,
-0.959831357,
1.3477005959,
0.2129298598,
-0.4046597481,
0.1826617271,
0.2520582378,
0.4235861897,
-0.6864512563,
-0.0074463664,
0.285340786,
0.2760433853,
0.2263979614,
-0.8355112672,
-0.2157223672,
0.2797054648,
0.0756946802,
-0.0626601651,
-0.5173963308,
0.332921952,
-0.2429463714,
-0.2250145376,
-0.0720648393,
1.0316827297,
0.1462658644,
0.5985018611,
0.3448852599,
0.5460617542,
0.5045826435,
0.2393314391,
0.8655177951,
-0.5593827963,
0.3406428993,
1.3418835402,
-0.4233160317,
1.1339507103,
0.5293161273,
0.3082900643,
0.5457205772,
0.3431343436,
0.3855624497,
0.543782413,
-0.2544401586,
-0.5360768437,
-0.4365464151,
-0.117137067,
-0.1830670089,
0.9768643379,
0.341319263,
-0.0754493922,
-0.5336464047,
0.4374241531,
-0.2280738503,
0.32290259,
-0.4715298712,
0.7659951448,
0.2539414465,
-0.7639032006,
0.5548626781,
0.1142060757,
0.7664627433,
-0.569252789,
0.0438871831,
-0.5853489637,
0.0351354219,
-0.0543593541,
-0.7430858612,
0.1691145748,
0.181384936,
0.219703421,
-0.3573341072,
0.7748525739,
-0.7924603224,
-0.5119069815,
0.6507498026,
0.7672770023,
0.0223216079,
-0.090486832,
-0.4232563078,
-0.2603287995,
-0.2749579549,
-0.2446270883,
0.3900794387,
0.4412979484,
-0.0591038205,
0.7279593945,
0.4813813567,
-0.0406343378,
-0.0068291053,
-0.3038647473,
0.6620842218,
-0.6928961873,
-0.5216005445,
-0.8214150667,
0.3930357099,
0.1841615736,
-0.4458004236,
1.0816514492,
0.6913605928,
1.0169856548,
-0.0805799663,
0.5656213164,
0.2345363051,
0.2927126884,
-0.4815400839,
0.7446942925,
-1.0113458633,
0.0747417286,
-0.1839981824,
-0.8586599231,
-0.4147819579,
0.4200112522,
-0.2121382952,
-0.2968287468,
0.7430961132,
0.8566058278,
-0.299223125,
-0.1351258606,
0.6556466818,
-0.0206661262,
-0.0396153033,
0.4673432708,
0.7697829008,
-0.2441640496,
0.2443943471,
-0.2466967553,
-0.4212518036,
-0.2244911194,
-1.134380579,
-0.9537917972,
-0.8748984337,
-0.1906657368,
-0.1262039691,
0.0396188349,
1.1239316463,
0.7316346169,
-0.6690683365,
-0.6344902515,
-0.1402828246,
0.0880912095,
-0.3350298703,
-0.06644582,
0.232067734,
-0.7646653652,
-0.6586270332,
1.2868044376,
0.6414042711,
-0.1095375493,
-0.2652553916,
-0.2542390525,
-0.265096277,
0.0687220171,
0.8070441484,
0.6415962577,
-0.5458402038,
-0.3286816478,
-0.2763470411,
-0.0191581957,
-0.0488180779,
0.6905252934,
-0.9713277817,
0.7201817036,
0.2312715203,
0.9621462822,
0.8080694079,
-0.0211933423,
0.4865338504,
-1.0806640387,
0.2892445028,
-0.0295073967,
0.2744549215,
0.2641874552,
-0.2251884192,
0.3922012448,
0.2944882214,
-0.5025247931,
-0.6366877556,
0.195390895,
-0.7896825075,
-0.257594496,
1.1495308876,
-0.0805377662,
-0.373717159,
0.1231071204,
-0.0268359184,
0.1593250185,
0.0514467508,
0.7261530161,
0.4345017672,
-0.0945981964,
0.1433519423,
-0.1496274471,
0.6493352652,
0.6113880277,
-0.584287107,
0.1431334019,
0.3557266593,
0.2847899795,
-0.0975296721,
0.6171423793,
0.0667112544,
0.3090511858,
-0.4185677767,
0.2342858016,
-0.1641555727,
-0.7260829806,
-0.6575248241,
-0.0696187615,
0.1210452989,
-0.2332124412
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10013v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10013v2
|
Bridging the Empirical-Theoretical Gap in Neural Network Formal Language Learning Using Minimum Description Length
| 2024-02-15T15:25:30 | 2024-06-06T16:16:12 |
Nur Lan, Emmanuel Chemla, Roni Katzir
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.FL
|
Neural networks offer good approximation to many tasks but consistently fail
to reach perfect generalization, even when theoretical work shows that such
perfect solutions can be expressed by certain architectures. Using the task of
formal language learning, we focus on one simple formal language and show that
the theoretically correct solution is in fact not an optimum of commonly used
objectives -- even with regularization techniques that according to common
wisdom should lead to simple weights and good generalization (L1, L2) or other
meta-heuristics (early-stopping, dropout). On the other hand, replacing
standard targets with the Minimum Description Length objective (MDL) results in
the correct solution being an optimum.
|
[
-0.3104920089,
-0.7561129928,
0.6674166918,
0.1922604442,
-0.2066803277,
-0.0664310083,
-0.5737376809,
-0.3774216175,
0.0994062349,
-0.1126546711,
-0.4745399952,
-0.28202492,
-0.4661690891,
0.1641104519,
-0.3917950094,
0.8623306751,
-0.0857689455,
-0.142528981,
-0.1254047304,
0.0466854498,
-0.09113729,
-0.0628848746,
-1.1451630592,
-0.6894384623,
0.9313943982,
0.3807735443,
0.5345895886,
1.0195629597,
0.5209395885,
0.3317368925,
-0.1756913066,
0.3156786263,
-0.1463899016,
-0.1821441948,
0.1606826037,
-0.6273694634,
-0.1586306095,
-0.0127089405,
0.8263120651,
1.4117256403,
-0.3349272907,
0.0476830453,
0.2622880638,
0.8911337256,
-0.5363456607,
0.2488567829,
-0.4618150592,
0.5395578146,
-0.2813781798,
-0.1374153644,
-0.1812921911,
-0.2138660252,
0.2391257882,
-0.718449235,
0.1759027243,
0.0199726094,
1.113032937,
0.1152653918,
-0.293420732,
-0.1298515201,
-1.0176541805,
0.9603764415,
-0.859026432,
0.1243539676,
0.6455205083,
0.5116201639,
0.104128845,
-0.7063391805,
-0.2101139277,
-0.3712698817,
-0.1603551656,
-0.1700854748,
-0.1048652083,
0.5168652534,
0.4161233306,
0.2326362133,
-0.5024683475,
0.2214768231,
-0.8564162254,
-0.1852416098,
0.7279681563,
0.2537486255,
0.0514898114,
0.2127155215,
-0.2614406347,
0.4223353565,
-0.6274362206,
0.0765839145,
0.3815718293,
0.4331823289,
-0.1234230474,
0.1158078387,
-0.3870130479,
0.877640605,
-0.1493650526,
0.1310892701,
-0.0025303527,
-0.4153548479,
-0.3547278643,
0.0282559283,
0.8452641368,
0.1143031642,
0.4606318176,
-0.3873541355,
-0.3673518896,
0.1479472518,
-0.016494656,
-0.4878850281,
-0.0737925172,
0.0355430953,
-0.4720626175,
-0.3365686238,
-0.1216604188,
-0.4948394895,
0.2387484908,
-0.6299939752,
0.1031620875,
-0.2276489288,
0.0611614101,
0.2644698322,
0.024244586,
0.2073129416,
0.0386518799,
-0.9593689442,
0.8044274449,
0.5668643117,
0.8868305683,
0.2647879124,
-0.242242232,
-0.1850064248,
-0.0776378885,
-0.7953872085,
0.2501414418,
-0.2724379897,
0.0549348444,
0.0025991916,
-0.4205237031,
-0.198431313,
-0.1882607639,
0.5931066871,
-0.3710180223,
0.354737848,
-0.3291764259,
-0.5140858293,
-0.1765934974,
0.2176375091,
-0.3966188729,
0.7165119648,
-0.1788915247,
-0.5533798933,
0.2279417664,
-0.8418395519,
-0.5770084262,
-0.0481120944,
-0.2431762367,
-0.1213099658,
0.3109167218,
-0.2965413034,
0.4180060029,
-0.3252594769,
0.17113325,
-0.0388363376,
-0.4954466224,
0.0875828341,
-0.3839614689,
0.5458535552,
0.6041408777,
-0.4117387235,
-0.0695533752,
-0.8535021544,
0.1453616619,
0.3118255138,
-0.4739243388,
-0.5123015642,
0.1698623747,
-0.1186865494,
0.2379978746,
0.3577648103,
-0.4676168561,
0.0700852796,
-0.7122648358,
0.6307771802,
0.8771370053,
-0.3564244509,
0.7092379928,
-0.3617185056,
0.3731345236,
-0.2595168054,
0.0326480642,
0.1208692044,
-0.2642828524,
-0.8570179343,
0.0149061,
0.856748879,
0.4763982594,
-0.425162524,
0.2611951232,
-0.2261118442,
-0.0065856907,
-0.2828195393,
0.3034701645,
0.7283527851,
0.5319188833,
0.1696592569,
-0.2226036042,
-0.6754851937,
-1.3281337023,
-0.2901039422,
-0.0548804626,
0.0361734629,
0.2176556289,
0.3267363608,
-0.1020245999,
0.6986424923,
-0.2585473061,
-0.2205798626,
-0.1758736372,
0.1538019776,
0.3366436362,
0.3483130038,
0.2984220684,
-0.6788643003,
-0.53350842,
0.2349528372,
-1.0210672617,
0.0420823805,
-0.2137698233,
0.2566229701,
0.0302573312,
0.3736743033,
-0.4618709385,
0.3050754666,
0.2722276151,
0.1148458943,
0.4572764933,
-0.2850529552,
-0.214867115,
-0.8213936687,
0.0737516657,
0.2660697401,
-0.2395091057,
-0.9844021201,
0.154089734,
-0.1742771715,
0.0152187878,
-0.3219841719,
0.5286511779,
-0.6202021837,
-0.019402694,
-0.2711630762,
0.2691155076,
-0.0663942322,
0.580085516,
-0.0582768098,
0.3747174144,
0.6951524615,
-1.0125031471,
0.2257762402,
-0.072226271,
-0.1120685562,
0.1724246889,
-0.8489296436,
0.1388776749,
-0.277754575,
-0.1250369549,
-0.6060847044,
-0.3113586307,
0.4866898358,
-0.3977931738,
0.5420520306,
-0.1682592779,
-0.2332911789,
-0.2489148229,
-0.0676915273,
0.6376007199,
0.5804319978,
-0.1641646028,
0.354513377,
-0.1435765624,
0.2565453649,
-0.75062114,
-1.1299430132,
0.215948686,
-0.1621293575,
-0.7014364004,
0.262029469,
0.1482956856,
-0.4590884447,
0.0309083723,
-0.2482836396,
-0.3263171017,
0.2403561175,
-0.1946542412,
-0.1395510584,
-0.4771690667,
0.2066198587,
-0.099995926,
-0.2284120768,
0.2671273649,
-0.3576812148,
0.4036681354,
-0.4378776848,
-0.325115025,
-0.461761713,
0.1944485158,
0.1464319825,
-0.1289946586,
0.5067632198,
0.2147917598,
-0.6896164417,
-0.3012031317,
-0.1461121738,
-0.3530309796,
-0.4649303854,
0.3299821615,
-0.5207979083,
-0.5922682881,
0.474044472,
0.0964661464,
0.153102845,
0.419549495,
0.0349020697,
-0.2460012436,
1.0358549356,
0.409711659,
0.06983044,
0.2970240712,
-0.4998972714,
0.254671365,
-0.7214301229,
-0.0469512902,
-0.5546718836,
-0.6611905098,
-0.1732956767,
0.052621983,
-0.0124763846,
0.3725414574,
-0.0522166081,
0.2591705918,
-0.402828753,
0.6408829093,
0.5773888826,
0.0697578043,
0.0246653147,
0.1861051619,
-0.3366434574,
-0.1941590011,
-1.0265882015,
-0.4478453994,
0.8512076735,
0.4287148714,
0.5054628253,
-0.0761689842,
0.9794967175,
0.1650112867,
-0.2460369766,
-0.8131792545,
0.6178007722,
-0.0105860783,
-0.5620095134,
-0.4937250018,
-0.7617599964,
-1.2497657537,
0.2060551792,
0.0514841266,
-0.518124342,
0.1698748469,
0.2748498917,
-0.2796669602,
0.3190089762,
-0.1990627795,
0.7788012028,
-0.3304710984,
-0.2329925895,
-0.1725818366,
-0.848559916,
0.5253143311,
0.1918323636,
0.4802193046,
0.0149849793,
-0.1809630841,
0.7798334956,
-0.5758811831,
0.8916680813,
-0.1956519485,
0.1658415794,
0.2592584193,
0.0520535596,
0.4346698821,
-0.329333663,
0.2005452514,
-0.0392181724,
-0.1818573773,
-0.8536415696,
-0.8567111492,
0.4014663696,
-0.4738571346,
-0.2832193375,
-0.515681982,
-0.3135593832,
0.0116213607,
0.2410766929,
0.4056523442,
0.5600462556,
-0.2195708454,
0.1455604881,
0.9095485806,
0.3015509546,
0.6352226138,
0.1802518368,
-0.1364103258,
-0.1216323823,
0.8911890984,
0.148444131,
0.3778804541,
0.3633650839,
0.5564577579,
-0.1624459922,
-0.8120279908,
-0.3295012414,
0.1202627867,
-0.7894613147,
0.0878697857,
-0.3069523275,
-0.4275017083,
0.000137091,
-0.1448156685,
-0.2679778934,
-0.5388947725,
-0.2289026827,
-0.1690701842,
-0.1002181172,
0.6201694012,
-0.4315508604,
0.2770522833,
-0.6199284792,
0.0750019625,
0.3580521643,
0.2214630246,
0.0816200078,
-0.598274827,
-0.4453545213,
0.3491820097,
-0.0106125185,
-0.68502599,
-0.0265546255,
0.7361857891,
0.6837258339,
0.758443594,
-0.2792436182,
0.4766786098,
-0.5852777958,
0.5278022289,
0.4914001524,
-0.7270499468,
0.5087956786,
-0.4148622155,
0.1740358323,
0.5778324008,
0.3305431008,
-0.7277873755,
0.0252656825,
-0.5746006966,
-0.736387074,
0.326923281,
0.3246106505,
0.2914178073,
-0.1880999804,
0.5376877189,
-0.233498916,
0.1893167943,
-0.7628948689,
-0.6273633242,
0.2006033957,
-0.3731195629,
-0.004697714,
-0.0682095438,
-0.3806700706,
-0.158611238,
0.6998521686,
-0.2267480195,
0.3468675017,
0.0815698355,
-0.1740192622,
-0.1876618564,
0.4062512219,
0.9968845248,
0.9054785371,
-0.0277002696,
0.2901219726,
0.2592982352,
-0.126934886,
0.1145981029,
-0.0313874222,
-0.363840282,
0.0999139845,
0.6536547542,
0.9837250113,
0.5215737224,
-0.3618052304,
0.4068366587,
0.0345338807,
-0.6368733048,
-0.2101791501,
-0.0337075554,
-0.0811618567,
-0.0084161814,
0.3711002171,
0.4449277222,
0.3285855949,
-0.3752848506,
0.2649187446,
0.4530006647,
-0.6220939159,
-0.3702703416,
0.4488644004,
0.0447938591,
-0.5265696049,
0.464319706,
-0.3569069505,
-0.6400383711,
0.7910894752,
0.5593641996,
0.9358019829,
0.0102237985,
0.1779204011,
0.242974326,
0.5916457772,
-0.265942961,
0.1842167526,
-0.091354616,
-0.557436347,
-0.6582231522,
-0.5772285461,
-0.0522119142,
-0.1106745452,
-0.6651846766,
0.0634178817,
-0.9014132619,
0.0453329943,
-0.1110391468,
0.1406175345,
-0.608455956,
0.3073362708,
0.202045694,
0.8683856726,
-0.8521544933,
0.6253811717,
0.5359390974,
-0.5051766038,
-1.0390226841,
-0.5140994787,
-0.0617005229,
-0.4743348956,
0.8564419746,
-0.007332759,
-0.1142857745,
-0.2191231549,
-0.6524402499,
-0.6142117381,
0.8899766207,
0.2269657254,
-0.8412488699,
-0.4245145917,
0.1747894585,
0.5756298304,
-0.4813369811,
-0.1112513095,
0.3349858522,
0.6661248803,
-0.0009891676,
-0.8002669811,
-0.0898628607,
-0.2346652895,
0.0137054492,
0.3513557613,
-0.4744312465,
0.9426635504,
-0.1055558398,
-0.2370037287,
0.1507358849,
0.608766377,
-0.0646053776,
0.5646796823,
0.4023393095,
0.756624043,
0.8286777139,
-0.1646673828,
1.2885326147,
-0.0917826965,
0.3562584221,
0.9304096699,
0.0884068981,
0.3735230863,
0.3000139892,
-0.3383545578,
0.3252778947,
0.8986281157,
0.1968766898,
0.5554797649,
0.6179870963,
-0.2039149702,
-0.2791027427,
0.2391291112,
-0.4244533479,
0.2113457918,
0.3137499988,
-0.5676420927,
-0.284478426,
-0.2026655376,
-0.0293760244,
0.3389110565,
-0.4528806806,
0.6006551385,
0.4257976413,
-0.2907760441,
0.7878398895,
0.2343904674,
0.5571010709,
-0.7260400057,
0.051661551,
-0.3490067124,
0.0392846391,
-0.2907766998,
0.0067365984,
0.3486857414,
-0.478951484,
-0.313385427,
0.1311495453,
0.8826464415,
-0.5653823018,
-0.4115546644,
0.2041633576,
0.3316732347,
0.3430398405,
0.2081126869,
-0.8621665239,
-0.3146064579,
-0.2686231732,
0.0772378668,
0.2283203006,
0.3579502106,
0.086939849,
0.6816985607,
0.5326049328,
0.3722465932,
0.3940751553,
-0.2228198797,
0.4322385192,
-0.529374063,
-0.4531137347,
-1.0835893154,
0.3168064058,
-0.134200722,
-0.310010612,
0.6376522779,
0.5488226414,
0.7106630206,
-0.0387802422,
0.7621654272,
0.061390575,
0.0979960412,
-0.8459228277,
0.442317456,
-0.6515502334,
0.2945593596,
-0.0303120427,
-1.1783144474,
-0.4845777154,
0.9097697735,
-0.1900321692,
0.1935180724,
1.0177302361,
0.5460959673,
-0.365183562,
-0.2340101153,
0.580226779,
-0.0032740971,
-0.1444148123,
0.7746264935,
0.858730793,
-0.6056775451,
0.3790910244,
-0.3920499086,
-0.2118346244,
-0.1626770943,
-0.8201085329,
-0.8894956708,
-0.4130246639,
-0.4389749765,
-0.3709179759,
0.4473105371,
1.0707122087,
0.9485352039,
-0.7459500432,
-0.3460613489,
-0.3864021897,
0.2928034663,
-0.4104466438,
-0.1672539115,
0.2112918645,
-0.8473629355,
-0.55743891,
0.5164007545,
0.2164760381,
-0.1134905741,
-0.3781563938,
-0.4539909065,
-0.3241919875,
0.2132368386,
0.3142473996,
0.8884918094,
-0.7625414133,
-0.296847105,
-0.1052580997,
-0.3112997115,
0.0768925324,
0.9418985248,
-0.2890406549,
0.0998681113,
0.4040443897,
0.9740793109,
0.3429153562,
-0.3366240859,
0.5565411448,
-1.1099863052,
0.1074826866,
0.3045248091,
0.4248412848,
0.2138117701,
-0.1174731627,
0.6300422549,
0.3693653345,
-0.4675138593,
-0.8529170156,
0.5455697179,
-0.6605389118,
-0.3141143918,
0.9823371172,
-0.0332292877,
-0.4565957189,
-0.154476583,
0.0730445832,
0.0433158278,
-0.118306987,
0.5833042264,
0.6928502321,
0.0733808726,
-0.1001688763,
-0.5653836727,
0.625870049,
0.4734783173,
-0.3744397461,
-0.3459091187,
0.2978023291,
0.2640012205,
0.353343308,
0.5507700443,
0.3373937309,
0.4000050724,
-0.019509133,
-0.0880502611,
-0.2831522226,
-0.713575542,
-0.6124061942,
-0.0817693248,
0.3216938674,
-0.3730921447
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03676v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.03676v1
|
Neural Information Organizing and Processing -- Neural Machines
| 2024-02-15T15:15:11 | 2024-02-15T15:15:11 |
Iosif Iulian Petrila
|
cs.NE
|
cs.NE, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The informational synthesis of neural structures, processes, parameters and
characteristics that allow a unified description and modeling as neural
machines of natural and artificial neural systems is presented. The general
informational parameters as the global quantitative measure of the neural
systems computing potential as absolute and relative neural power were
proposed. Neural information organizing and processing follows the way in which
nature manages neural information by developing functions, functionalities and
circuits related to different internal or peripheral components and also to the
whole system through a non-deterministic memorization, fragmentation and
aggregation of afferent and efferent information, deep neural information
processing representing multiple alternations of fragmentation and aggregation
stages. The relevant neural characteristics were integrated into a neural
machine type model that incorporates unitary also peripheral or interface
components as the central ones. The proposed approach allows overcoming the
technical constraints in artificial computational implementations of neural
information processes and also provides a more relevant description of natural
ones.
|
[
-0.381467849,
-0.8241544962,
0.312092483,
0.2221344262,
-0.06101631,
-0.1774850041,
-0.2083519548,
-0.5589725971,
0.5817639828,
0.1178091988,
-0.3573799133,
-0.0301066656,
-0.192207098,
-0.1730549335,
-0.4672144353,
0.7887792587,
0.1711960584,
0.5433007479,
-0.0554066598,
-0.2591596842,
-0.4496162236,
-0.904207468,
-0.5406213403,
-0.5257403255,
0.5361414552,
-0.15745534,
0.4602411687,
0.9167478681,
0.64586097,
0.5335609317,
-0.2658266723,
-0.042008061,
0.2417345941,
0.3575926423,
-0.3507019579,
-0.7336729169,
-0.6291731,
0.0032032428,
0.8564950824,
1.016980648,
0.0491725579,
0.2560866475,
0.1501193643,
0.5922512412,
-0.2894559503,
0.2701995671,
-0.4051259756,
0.4334985912,
0.2311894894,
-0.6849642992,
-0.214674592,
-0.4775273502,
-0.0451953821,
-0.2982789278,
0.2360206544,
-0.1511926949,
0.3007352948,
0.2322345823,
-0.1271973848,
-0.2413235307,
-1.114793539,
0.5069654584,
-0.2483293265,
0.1215545982,
0.0950032845,
0.3948884606,
-0.097781308,
-0.5484749675,
-0.1198065653,
-0.2228936702,
-0.1134468764,
0.0164872501,
-0.3158662915,
0.3915948868,
-0.0174287986,
0.2362371981,
-0.404820472,
-0.0950121135,
-0.5666283369,
-0.2658115327,
0.4766302109,
0.3839834929,
0.3553152978,
0.0907221735,
-0.2527761757,
0.2766630352,
-0.2674549818,
-0.2204317749,
0.4695730209,
0.3901688159,
0.3307674825,
0.6224027872,
-0.3410785794,
0.8415892124,
-0.0894438848,
0.1087216437,
-0.2434563339,
-0.4653553963,
-0.6442770958,
0.1615155041,
0.5160983205,
0.2054827362,
-0.0972507894,
-0.4890620112,
-0.2271177173,
-0.042483408,
0.4016729891,
-0.6266940236,
-0.0601409338,
-0.0193685032,
-0.9242536426,
-0.3622120321,
0.0058351178,
-0.6321337819,
-0.2987325788,
-1.112975955,
0.5533571243,
-0.4599635303,
-0.3886202872,
-0.3435673714,
-0.2298050374,
-0.1687207371,
0.0514104106,
-0.9116050601,
0.7067234516,
0.3110913038,
0.843365252,
0.0192414131,
-0.3033236563,
0.2461892813,
-0.1009026766,
-0.1397812217,
0.358890146,
-0.172906056,
0.1557206362,
-0.3043797314,
-0.1189697087,
-0.1809529364,
-0.6591682434,
0.2058086991,
-0.7905529141,
-0.0943515822,
-0.0950424746,
-0.3782357275,
-0.4829505086,
0.0687660724,
-0.7856390476,
0.195816353,
0.0349955894,
-0.4920772314,
-0.1591483951,
-1.141581893,
-0.4717646241,
-0.1840856075,
0.1935916394,
0.3603716195,
0.3483602703,
-0.4533967376,
0.3515435457,
-0.4569505453,
0.4488269687,
-0.0742918551,
-0.2227520049,
0.672621429,
-0.6590678096,
0.7927833796,
0.3190495074,
-0.1036979035,
0.5388248563,
-0.9046923518,
0.3406424522,
-0.0013819798,
-0.5283745527,
-0.0351142921,
0.1045775637,
-0.0225191806,
0.1851097196,
0.7551080585,
-0.0449764132,
0.301743567,
-0.1830041111,
1.0657879114,
0.6518056989,
0.0252213627,
0.8667575717,
-0.0309088398,
0.0479972474,
0.0363515429,
0.5118935108,
0.0306249689,
-0.1805451512,
-0.6475142241,
0.1911757141,
0.5380437374,
0.4692396224,
-0.2868808806,
0.7376573682,
-0.055814188,
-0.2800263464,
-0.1584663838,
-0.3060831428,
0.1814790368,
0.4719949365,
0.2288157642,
-0.0949799344,
-0.8276891112,
-1.1456654072,
0.0697899237,
-0.3132060468,
-0.2139075696,
-0.1922424287,
0.2981248796,
0.1874326319,
0.4791704118,
-0.150967747,
0.0096351868,
0.2836234868,
0.3774963915,
0.7012571096,
0.4605718851,
-0.0332469828,
-0.8664915562,
0.1866759509,
0.0431706496,
-1.0496288538,
0.3289064765,
0.0619103163,
-0.1487667412,
0.0163160209,
0.3086704016,
-0.8873819709,
0.5702971816,
-0.0546653643,
-0.1631543785,
0.5401209593,
-0.6038000584,
0.3135175705,
-0.6820161343,
0.4097319543,
-0.4160698652,
0.443595171,
-0.8503097296,
0.2652454078,
-0.2295991331,
0.208218798,
-0.0176790711,
-0.0246984176,
-0.5743592978,
-0.3170104027,
-0.5154387355,
-0.3124853075,
-0.0145517401,
0.6625127792,
-0.31630826,
0.359727025,
0.573504746,
-0.9477549791,
0.7375879884,
-0.3220229447,
-0.1460116059,
0.843069315,
-0.7581654787,
0.0323907919,
-0.2599070072,
-0.2139444798,
-0.8009789586,
-0.59717381,
0.1151420549,
-0.5984175205,
0.3908030987,
-0.1214461848,
-0.5745485425,
-0.0367471091,
0.1427498013,
0.4392383695,
0.2651745975,
-0.1437986195,
0.7216719985,
0.5009195209,
-0.0837698877,
-0.2393900752,
-0.9433020353,
0.2299021333,
-0.1327530444,
-0.6938636899,
0.751070559,
-0.0537433214,
-0.5920654535,
0.2870128155,
0.1537677646,
-0.5795759559,
-0.0198888537,
0.4171254933,
0.3044086695,
-0.4110639095,
0.6716814041,
-0.0881920457,
-0.0330538563,
0.2002573758,
-0.6891540885,
0.6401962042,
-0.2538336515,
-0.1950732023,
-0.3996094465,
0.3611185849,
0.7625259161,
0.1428495347,
0.7331668735,
0.2552629113,
-0.715847075,
0.0928859934,
-0.1399015635,
-0.2494867891,
-0.3994196355,
0.3943131566,
-0.302764535,
-0.1760248244,
0.6836253405,
0.2129458785,
-0.1813592017,
0.4529984593,
0.3097092807,
-0.1347150356,
1.0796915293,
0.4362279773,
-0.1968610734,
0.5246008039,
-0.1749183089,
0.130056411,
-0.8475012183,
-0.4743867517,
-0.430075258,
-0.9328948259,
-0.3272077143,
-0.2161124647,
0.3224393129,
0.5430762172,
-0.5454767346,
0.2196966112,
-1.2556962967,
0.4844079614,
0.8273719549,
0.2629343271,
-0.044865787,
0.1245258152,
-0.2613802552,
0.0888348445,
-0.649045527,
-0.3531861007,
0.8509730697,
0.081963703,
0.5815346241,
-0.1416379213,
0.1899580956,
0.1868546605,
-0.0210642051,
-0.6968366504,
0.6031365991,
-0.0365488306,
-0.6130905747,
-0.1719158441,
-0.3799436092,
-0.7941879034,
0.1087599099,
0.1142076105,
-0.9472244978,
0.204807952,
-0.0778792948,
-0.4446110725,
0.6422584057,
-0.8874275684,
0.1155864596,
-0.5492900014,
-0.1452265233,
-0.3405355811,
-0.7518786192,
0.2253544182,
0.2829712629,
-0.1220899671,
0.2642801106,
-0.1995041072,
0.7082695961,
-0.2808790505,
0.781226337,
-0.261637181,
0.7438771129,
0.493993789,
0.1469080001,
-0.1918373704,
-0.2147845179,
-0.4252316952,
0.2480986714,
-0.1609748751,
-0.0333117917,
-0.5437889695,
0.7698694468,
-0.7575193048,
-0.2462388277,
-0.0079431282,
-0.9093542695,
0.1306110024,
0.2772162855,
0.4343722761,
0.4238402843,
-0.261933744,
0.2072915584,
0.389764607,
0.0778629705,
0.7014364004,
-0.0331165902,
-0.0994938463,
-0.7911969423,
0.7170504332,
0.7840381861,
-0.0966441929,
0.5088362694,
-0.1330369115,
-0.3305123746,
-0.7190800309,
-0.0504716709,
-0.2902829945,
-0.9045280218,
-0.3108060658,
-0.3745429516,
-0.7341634035,
0.0121563133,
0.3892769516,
0.0628103092,
-0.6527970433,
-0.4815607667,
-0.0175839216,
0.2253189534,
1.0697221756,
-0.3595999181,
0.4145714939,
-0.512270689,
0.335644275,
0.4148448706,
0.3890000284,
0.1445098519,
-0.1903741509,
-0.3665613532,
0.4497664869,
-0.3570117652,
-0.9280105829,
0.2628935874,
-0.0221859645,
0.6525306106,
0.2506166697,
-0.4553160667,
0.446423322,
-0.1899001896,
0.4343215823,
0.3378405571,
-0.7390184402,
0.569702208,
-0.148393631,
0.2664256096,
0.2460239828,
0.0886807218,
-0.1653095186,
0.3855682015,
-0.6364921331,
-0.7091529965,
0.6856395006,
0.2644194961,
0.0679299459,
0.3586089015,
0.4336184561,
-0.262542516,
0.3971103728,
-0.4950496256,
-0.1612689197,
-0.0207515545,
-0.1377556175,
0.5192432404,
0.0354099311,
-0.3032023907,
-0.3972440958,
0.334118247,
-0.0411224924,
0.8302268386,
0.1714312136,
0.0612495504,
-0.0224770103,
-0.0484217331,
0.6807337999,
0.6647195816,
-0.0707382113,
0.391218245,
-0.1398794651,
-0.1636945754,
0.398447752,
-0.0622949488,
-0.270376265,
-0.040592175,
0.2764945924,
0.725728929,
-0.020551065,
0.1355825216,
-0.2058461607,
-0.1757683903,
-0.0670731291,
-0.2504986525,
0.5169300437,
0.3213517666,
0.3905955851,
0.4458735287,
0.8294235468,
0.3756885231,
-0.5601266623,
0.0415621065,
0.2728326023,
-0.4376208782,
-0.708216846,
0.2889391184,
-0.2928243876,
-0.8064360619,
0.7533320189,
0.1384097338,
-0.3462810218,
1.2065646648,
0.4156523347,
0.8601634502,
-0.4618103206,
0.0426939428,
0.3852081001,
0.357762605,
0.1796147078,
0.3309343457,
-0.3175618947,
-0.5035995245,
-0.2198043466,
-0.8104462028,
0.0082191303,
0.2327054143,
-0.5202938914,
-0.0543851368,
-1.0424995422,
-0.6081293225,
0.6240256429,
-0.309451431,
-0.5747565627,
0.3122335374,
0.0247984957,
0.7050820589,
-0.3035067916,
0.5960153937,
0.812871933,
-0.5535246134,
-0.5363875031,
-0.4255931973,
-0.2902852893,
-0.4099066854,
0.885391891,
0.0765728876,
0.1057691649,
-0.2583633959,
-0.5999184847,
-0.9386169314,
0.8965631127,
0.5004373789,
-0.0079639899,
-0.2341393977,
0.2920274734,
0.8360846043,
-0.5233360529,
0.6743723154,
0.3248032033,
0.6847510338,
0.1263786852,
-0.5808029771,
-0.1134546548,
-0.6917498112,
0.0043985196,
0.2658783495,
-0.4765604436,
1.150043726,
0.163099125,
-0.237540707,
0.3760459423,
0.1813677698,
-0.2285717279,
0.0244418718,
0.1855327934,
0.2107106894,
0.8296070695,
-0.2834260166,
0.6488790512,
-0.5558621287,
-0.2453225851,
0.8373177648,
0.2139676213,
0.3735143244,
0.5196896195,
-0.2135487348,
0.0626021624,
0.532717824,
0.0558910556,
0.1773061901,
0.4656897187,
-0.2880283892,
0.2600353956,
-0.3030821681,
-0.2067690641,
0.4507221282,
0.4256009459,
-0.9383758903,
-0.0075200573,
-0.1027679965,
-0.5254759789,
-0.388101995,
-0.4738534391,
0.8172494173,
-0.0274376497,
-0.9757980108,
0.6855609417,
0.1402870417,
0.2567758858,
-0.5685694218,
-0.2504975498,
0.134503603,
0.0707825646,
-0.4397167861,
-0.5792738199,
0.6777508855,
-0.3347202241,
-0.7826731801,
-0.1580341011,
1.01927495,
-0.189325586,
-0.2349234521,
0.4406905174,
-0.0031214824,
0.1686978638,
-0.3040457666,
-0.5650559068,
-0.1189426184,
-0.1426517665,
-0.1499995142,
0.2058801204,
0.3053385615,
0.0017334457,
0.3689603508,
0.5431457758,
0.2797888517,
0.4903635383,
-0.1369127631,
0.6299467683,
-0.9149676561,
-0.2949229479,
-0.9211283922,
0.4787277579,
-0.2818158269,
-0.2956373096,
0.2197151929,
0.1042269021,
0.2721487582,
-0.0270467438,
0.6417976618,
-0.266656667,
-0.2188715786,
-0.3699780107,
0.8096480966,
-0.1733411849,
0.0000448129,
0.4784602523,
-1.3427014351,
-0.2170915455,
0.3434979916,
0.0492471009,
0.1252338737,
0.5712156296,
0.5352967381,
-0.169998914,
0.5201119781,
0.363294512,
0.36700055,
-0.121114023,
0.4809420109,
0.9413167238,
-0.3948434293,
0.2406982332,
-0.3752873242,
-0.2185593396,
-0.1645481884,
-0.4755075872,
-0.3598720133,
-0.7704768181,
-0.016654836,
-0.0271087065,
-0.3150084019,
0.5982629657,
1.1419519186,
-0.7400076985,
-0.3904480338,
-0.6703537703,
0.2109634727,
-0.1481609792,
-0.2502363622,
0.1260820329,
-0.4715561867,
-0.3919656575,
0.5444415212,
0.6540176868,
0.0364252999,
-0.5255709887,
0.0452718548,
-0.1210141033,
0.2537557185,
0.478535831,
0.3032644987,
-0.3858823776,
0.1770141274,
0.1857582331,
-0.2075052559,
0.2245142609,
0.5696671605,
-0.3135938346,
0.5863790512,
0.9856030941,
0.4267728031,
0.1826672554,
-0.3645935953,
0.5530595183,
-0.5706732869,
0.0732665211,
0.3695483506,
0.543110013,
0.230318293,
-0.5909702778,
0.4191367626,
0.0357231796,
-0.6374290586,
-0.5444020033,
0.2096253484,
-0.5085446835,
-0.5117690563,
0.5114187002,
-0.0547734722,
-0.6638563275,
-0.019470308,
-0.0846892297,
0.7904645801,
0.248584792,
0.70829916,
0.6746976376,
-0.5216268301,
0.3742708862,
-0.3404580355,
-0.0572966747,
0.1248907521,
-0.8596795201,
-0.2521567643,
0.4806029797,
0.0870228186,
0.89261657,
0.3191023469,
-0.2745077312,
0.1034614295,
0.2499307394,
0.3773063719,
-0.0160617456,
-0.896815598,
-0.5161834955,
0.733093679,
-0.3083540797,
-0.475164324
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09997v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09997v1
|
LoraRetriever: Input-Aware LoRA Retrieval and Composition for Mixed Tasks in the Wild
| 2024-02-15T15:02:46 | 2024-02-15T15:02:46 |
Ziyu Zhao, Leilei Gan, Guoyin Wang, Wangchunshu Zhou, Hongxia Yang, Kun Kuang, Fei Wu
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Low-Rank Adaptation (LoRA) provides an effective yet efficient solution for
fine-tuning large language models (LLM). The modular and plug-and-play nature
of LoRA enables the integration of diverse domain-specific LoRAs to enhance the
capabilities of LLMs. Previous research on exploiting multiple LoRAs either
focuses on specific isolated downstream tasks or fixes the selection of LoRAs
during training. However, in real-world scenarios, LLMs receive diverse prompts
covering different tasks, and the pool of candidate LoRAs is often dynamically
updated. To bridge this gap, we propose LoraRetriever, a retrieve-then-compose
framework that adaptively retrieves and composes multiple LoRAs according to
the input prompts. LoraRetriever contains three main components: firstly,
identifying and retrieving LoRAs relevant to the given input; secondly,
formulating strategies for effectively integrating the retrieved LoRAs; and
thirdly, developing efficient batch inference to accommodate heterogeneous
requests. Experimental results indicate that LoraRetriever consistently
outperforms the baselines, highlighting its practical effectiveness and
versatility.
|
[
-0.3924011588,
-0.8463245034,
0.4197298884,
0.4434198141,
-0.0088482881,
0.156056866,
-0.5415334702,
-0.5515654087,
0.4043853581,
0.6198406219,
-0.5823118091,
-0.3599194586,
-0.6331349015,
0.1363959908,
-0.3820646405,
0.8239945769,
-0.0088911429,
-0.3458735645,
0.1020340398,
-0.3521776497,
-0.7977759242,
-0.0959478691,
-0.6434810758,
-0.5018264651,
1.0395325422,
0.717715323,
0.3835271895,
0.2641729116,
0.4599073827,
0.3861187696,
-0.0081262561,
0.4466868937,
-0.7235506177,
0.6744560599,
-0.4906740487,
-0.5219777226,
-0.4119235873,
-0.2749674916,
0.7170339227,
0.6835789084,
-0.2927044928,
0.1113955379,
0.23698093,
0.4493381083,
-1.0491448641,
-0.2652663589,
-0.7746286392,
0.1797100902,
-0.1493171901,
-0.1662788689,
-0.4808664918,
-0.3001165092,
0.0015313107,
-0.6396932006,
-0.1946302801,
-0.156195417,
0.3613676131,
0.4175294936,
-0.0666040853,
-0.0290008299,
-0.8189911246,
0.7565611601,
-0.6257600188,
0.2039027512,
0.4251457453,
0.5685597658,
-0.3142906129,
-0.6846036911,
-0.4555376172,
0.3050955534,
0.118582882,
0.0763518438,
-0.388549149,
-0.3013090491,
-0.0792265981,
0.3124854565,
-0.4156252146,
0.5957347155,
0.0531024784,
-0.0224250499,
0.1081429273,
0.1069226339,
0.1838496476,
-0.027923299,
0.0773217455,
-0.1385907382,
-0.5335001945,
-0.1090470254,
0.2183369398,
0.7365271449,
-0.1877355576,
0.6603599787,
-0.3002522886,
0.8113123178,
0.2776008844,
-0.3330332041,
0.2190148234,
-0.235952884,
-0.2841097116,
0.0001354981,
0.7498989701,
-0.2703518569,
-0.1698552966,
-0.138240248,
-0.3044390082,
-0.1585793495,
0.1542778462,
-0.7741213441,
0.0632960945,
0.240794763,
-0.1210497394,
-0.3653895259,
-0.2141916752,
-0.8455528021,
-0.723854661,
-0.0649762973,
0.5115013123,
-0.2521292269,
0.0205816273,
0.2521619797,
-0.0519617423,
0.2156083584,
0.6334195733,
-0.9459719658,
0.308226198,
0.6154661179,
0.661575973,
-0.4681357741,
-0.5364410281,
-1.3885917664,
0.1277616322,
0.0433284789,
1.1604576111,
-0.5562375784,
-0.3716885149,
-0.0244255066,
0.2797492146,
-0.2998784482,
-0.6618431211,
0.4497560561,
-0.6892918348,
0.3018802702,
-0.2086766064,
-0.0994067267,
0.1553146541,
0.3642113507,
-0.9496234655,
1.3239371777,
0.46388188,
-0.7459848523,
0.1479828954,
-0.937425971,
-0.6704112887,
0.1319248229,
-0.122984916,
-0.2049703598,
0.2518216074,
0.3105264604,
0.2768165767,
-0.3086421192,
-0.1715061814,
-0.2229442,
-0.5620666742,
0.2093645185,
-0.1172060221,
0.4570570588,
0.0253469627,
-0.1899008453,
0.3052709103,
-0.730038166,
-0.0865705162,
0.1990465522,
-1.032169342,
-0.2718831599,
0.1589518189,
0.235966146,
-0.0689126998,
0.2386224866,
-0.6521050334,
0.3945629001,
-0.323890537,
0.4174355865,
0.6768182516,
-0.1384589523,
0.5185832977,
-0.3780202866,
0.58345294,
-0.1549752951,
-0.1115771979,
0.1157268658,
-0.0827665031,
-0.7957037687,
-0.6049224734,
0.304690361,
0.5913388133,
-0.9284468889,
0.4103772938,
-0.3897970319,
-0.3727799952,
-0.5221797824,
0.4228838384,
0.1089454219,
0.3475428224,
0.215357542,
-0.1289727092,
-0.5221170187,
-0.5501649976,
-0.2559652925,
0.1565144062,
0.244450137,
0.2879225314,
0.3865054846,
-0.6090515256,
0.9599625468,
-0.5134580135,
-0.493081063,
-0.6648448706,
0.0327116549,
0.3883629143,
0.3925215006,
0.4366292357,
-0.4942220151,
-0.4016837478,
0.3217380345,
-0.5412465334,
-0.0779020935,
0.3096273839,
-0.4052642584,
0.0006054824,
0.4910639524,
-0.4447307289,
-0.0286086444,
0.9211530685,
-0.1604807526,
0.117521964,
-0.2827466726,
-0.0010173038,
-1.237847805,
0.2164430916,
-0.4531737864,
-0.4984102249,
-0.4800645709,
0.1815130562,
-0.1268513501,
0.0035059899,
-0.6595915556,
0.831092298,
-0.1813741624,
-0.2379795462,
-0.3496504724,
0.3429028094,
0.1763961017,
0.4316870272,
-0.2890578806,
0.8516535163,
0.3802945316,
-0.4741564393,
0.3855867982,
0.2794962227,
-0.3283978403,
0.6264915466,
-0.5644178987,
0.3776596189,
-0.2966083586,
0.2348781824,
-0.7607739568,
-0.5889175534,
0.1364788115,
0.0541193224,
0.0135515481,
-0.454233259,
-0.5574913621,
-0.1521241963,
-0.1446099281,
0.3506720364,
0.533839941,
-0.6812163591,
1.143663764,
0.3525727689,
-0.3869694173,
-0.6555823684,
-0.7518293858,
-0.1433351785,
-0.2575258911,
-0.1950057894,
0.0767728388,
-0.134474203,
-0.1340712607,
-0.0671964362,
-0.0028515332,
0.0208066497,
0.4319992363,
0.2901008129,
-0.0226017665,
-0.2522243261,
-0.0910969302,
0.043400459,
0.0150973257,
-0.4732068181,
-0.3292647898,
0.6340076327,
0.054715395,
-0.6801860332,
-0.0205851886,
0.4368926287,
0.4985716641,
-0.3735405207,
0.581189394,
0.7350136638,
-0.3417976499,
-0.7750199437,
-0.4646519721,
-0.041624669,
-0.5441225767,
0.5019284487,
-0.419457227,
-1.0991139412,
0.6215302348,
-0.1453328282,
0.2788054645,
0.261021018,
0.6364509463,
-0.1373244077,
0.5596184134,
0.676379025,
-0.2431345731,
0.8304807544,
-0.1314958483,
0.0558213368,
-0.8141611218,
-0.0325880386,
-0.6785610318,
-0.5417662263,
-0.3940670192,
-0.6095355153,
0.3985079527,
-0.0644765645,
-0.0036821922,
0.2904421687,
-0.2567951679,
0.7424919605,
0.4189034104,
0.1254650354,
0.4529741108,
0.2138896585,
0.0424035415,
0.185707882,
-0.6434808969,
-0.1167149469,
0.7318376899,
0.0699627995,
1.0756213665,
0.6455933452,
0.8401563764,
0.3945595026,
0.1893391609,
-1.1038681269,
0.518673718,
-0.575984478,
-0.3049779534,
-0.3269824088,
-0.2635751367,
-1.188124299,
0.5798639059,
-0.1006863937,
-0.8095960617,
0.3212845922,
0.1749821305,
-0.58117944,
0.0532503836,
-0.3204095066,
0.7050274611,
-0.1551250368,
-0.4438014328,
-0.0776594579,
-0.3194106519,
0.2533299625,
-0.4748615026,
0.1940398365,
-0.2329782248,
0.1051086187,
0.702444315,
-0.1714555919,
0.9077099562,
-0.2161118686,
-0.4119123518,
0.0633000731,
0.3063189983,
0.6536528468,
-0.0887864977,
-0.353303194,
-0.5333324075,
0.0653268248,
-0.367051661,
-0.6052148342,
1.0400118828,
-0.9977124929,
-0.3719640076,
-0.3116057515,
-0.6610456109,
-0.4591379166,
0.5028703809,
-0.0668091774,
0.430942595,
-0.4385045469,
0.2355601043,
0.8210977316,
-0.2338068038,
0.514431715,
0.588419795,
-0.3727465272,
-0.2435074896,
0.9083440304,
-0.4109075963,
0.2819263935,
0.518101275,
0.1490816772,
0.1610149592,
-0.4524717629,
-0.3894365132,
0.0895632356,
-1.0709415674,
-0.1648725867,
-0.7006651163,
0.0293090995,
0.006746395,
-0.1062675714,
-0.5605797768,
-0.2301410139,
-0.4741684496,
0.2686084807,
0.6183367968,
0.6597146988,
0.0411493741,
0.4825691879,
-0.6233140826,
0.647148788,
0.4846656024,
0.3268541098,
-0.2388388067,
-0.7744099498,
-0.2675463557,
-0.1049248874,
0.1310667843,
-0.2623292804,
0.2445536405,
0.4235828519,
0.515075326,
0.0821482688,
-0.0730641112,
0.728521049,
-0.5159335732,
0.5010622144,
-0.1214248836,
-0.622926116,
0.4447188079,
-0.4007740021,
0.5729879737,
1.0118410587,
-0.1219437942,
-0.5320154428,
-0.0843010396,
0.0711866617,
-0.7572739124,
0.8627073765,
-0.2021680921,
0.1435125321,
0.2172542214,
0.0358591676,
0.3271348476,
-0.0645758361,
-0.4841775596,
0.1316981912,
-0.0933641419,
-0.3161272407,
-0.1204140857,
0.1100175604,
-0.3861303031,
0.0267440658,
0.4795093238,
-0.4768253863,
0.3298383355,
-0.1146821901,
-0.4153995514,
-0.1737006754,
0.6868341565,
0.5276764035,
0.4212835431,
-0.3082292974,
0.3958976269,
0.1184358746,
-0.510428071,
0.1418672651,
0.284139812,
0.0874629989,
-0.0706013143,
0.3954455256,
0.7439451218,
0.5304357409,
-0.9674352407,
0.3854753077,
-0.2084772736,
-0.110277243,
-0.1319694668,
0.407917738,
0.0882193372,
0.3034215569,
0.2021273971,
0.2005557716,
-0.1323036402,
-0.61405617,
-0.0564819798,
0.2145104557,
-0.2670049667,
-0.2258513421,
0.3710196316,
0.2118376791,
-0.1489691734,
0.3571721315,
-0.010882413,
-0.1828147918,
0.1735393256,
0.5573629141,
0.7858530879,
-0.0428646766,
0.1233975738,
-0.1604412198,
-0.0347641483,
-0.2759886682,
0.5786104798,
0.1612737179,
-0.8494105935,
-0.5814194679,
-0.8106970191,
-0.3922532499,
0.1460106671,
-0.6243732572,
0.0384031311,
-0.3364224732,
-0.1787244231,
0.1287754923,
-0.3121842444,
-0.7418892384,
-0.3079751134,
-0.0070705949,
0.8395718932,
-0.7746783495,
0.9014236331,
0.7944265008,
-0.2109899372,
-0.6656137109,
-0.0567249656,
-0.0940932035,
-0.9554356337,
0.6538974047,
-0.407715261,
-0.484718591,
0.1927272081,
-0.3266088367,
-1.034217,
0.9308306575,
0.4382716715,
-0.3091624379,
-0.0642938688,
0.0710901618,
0.3707915246,
-0.2923063338,
-0.0460515656,
0.6123126745,
0.4934930503,
0.2261527479,
-0.9456343055,
-0.1214662194,
-0.2352171987,
-0.026163172,
0.1622313708,
-0.3701094985,
0.8380669951,
0.0004527088,
0.1295669377,
0.3780724406,
0.2624798119,
0.4567477703,
-0.3288167715,
0.4735495746,
0.3636226058,
0.6632357836,
-0.0404627137,
0.9925022721,
0.1178366989,
-0.0119968029,
1.493458271,
-0.6680709124,
1.0729275942,
0.6224344373,
0.1572652906,
0.5991013646,
0.3862062693,
0.2370316982,
0.8698042035,
0.0795248002,
-0.3366667926,
-0.1818723232,
-0.2771667838,
-0.0759039447,
0.6728360057,
0.3336721063,
-0.0009423226,
-0.3129644096,
0.3661538661,
-0.0009584594,
-0.0631373003,
-0.1750768274,
0.9154496789,
-0.1233914346,
-0.8959485888,
0.6437385082,
0.221312806,
0.5549389124,
-0.6677415371,
-0.0546072088,
-0.4326650202,
0.4394337237,
-0.2985207736,
-0.4974610806,
-0.2291325182,
0.0701739341,
-0.2656787634,
-0.0717853531,
0.7649374008,
-0.366976887,
-0.4344990253,
0.3223021626,
0.8378071785,
-0.1997559071,
0.1239244342,
-0.432697773,
0.6857319474,
-0.2065622061,
-0.1945488304,
0.5132100582,
0.452768743,
-0.082979843,
0.5692666769,
0.4934584498,
0.1235612407,
0.0989288911,
0.5933940411,
1.1176671982,
-0.4167981744,
-0.4646884203,
-0.5680188537,
0.4316025078,
0.2485117614,
-0.008707732,
0.5270038247,
0.3627483547,
0.4897195101,
-0.0853183717,
1.0239899158,
-0.1434141546,
0.6088379025,
-0.5853318572,
0.420819968,
-0.4805263579,
0.2792316675,
-0.2200785726,
-1.0397479534,
-0.2318827808,
0.5193601847,
-0.2087671459,
-0.0240565743,
0.5888622403,
0.6487236619,
-0.6196812987,
-0.2152502537,
0.1449442655,
0.1694452465,
0.2609571218,
0.5143237114,
0.9235501289,
-0.2634973824,
0.1736793965,
0.1454668343,
0.0008043621,
-0.5220509171,
-0.825545013,
-0.7777554989,
-0.165489316,
-0.1919953972,
-0.1886262,
0.1738805622,
0.9720401764,
0.7150839567,
-0.7305472493,
-0.340519309,
0.2267349213,
0.0632290244,
-0.1310975999,
-0.1496300697,
0.1427753419,
-0.1820147783,
-0.6835228801,
0.9236947894,
0.2418829948,
-0.1185975373,
-0.2337771356,
-0.0132738184,
-0.1903339475,
0.0729089454,
0.8204216957,
0.5127272606,
-0.6737132668,
-0.2762129307,
0.0149474656,
-0.2499584407,
0.0820525661,
0.7158597112,
-0.8741381764,
0.2511813045,
0.4475529492,
1.0320528746,
0.4910930991,
-0.113631919,
0.274184078,
-0.8877311945,
0.3058117628,
0.1846294254,
0.5117796659,
0.3730570376,
-0.1115278229,
0.3211277723,
-0.1279408783,
-0.282566011,
-0.8720132709,
0.2082323283,
-1.2220221758,
-0.32082358,
1.1947000027,
-0.0074089733,
-0.1077286154,
-0.0584818646,
-0.2827726305,
-0.2044818252,
-0.4631526172,
0.2937788963,
0.3388387561,
-0.1024533287,
-0.2751925886,
-0.4786395133,
0.0933985338,
0.332144022,
-1.124085784,
0.1674946398,
0.4625821412,
0.3929175735,
-0.0143840825,
0.6870181561,
0.1776871234,
0.1762628704,
-0.4251466095,
-0.0716188625,
0.0845037475,
-0.1372135431,
-0.3467211425,
0.2116744518,
0.5730164647,
0.0487742908
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09989v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09989v4
|
LLMs as Bridges: Reformulating Grounded Multimodal Named Entity Recognition
| 2024-02-15T14:54:33 | 2024-05-29T16:59:59 |
Jinyuan Li, Han Li, Di Sun, Jiahao Wang, Wenkun Zhang, Zan Wang, Gang Pan
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Grounded Multimodal Named Entity Recognition (GMNER) is a nascent multimodal
task that aims to identify named entities, entity types and their corresponding
visual regions. GMNER task exhibits two challenging properties: 1) The weak
correlation between image-text pairs in social media results in a significant
portion of named entities being ungroundable. 2) There exists a distinction
between coarse-grained referring expressions commonly used in similar tasks
(e.g., phrase localization, referring expression comprehension) and
fine-grained named entities. In this paper, we propose RiVEG, a unified
framework that reformulates GMNER into a joint MNER-VE-VG task by leveraging
large language models (LLMs) as a connecting bridge. This reformulation brings
two benefits: 1) It maintains the optimal MNER performance and eliminates the
need for employing object detection methods to pre-extract regional features,
thereby naturally addressing two major limitations of existing GMNER methods.
2) The introduction of entity expansion expression and Visual Entailment (VE)
module unifies Visual Grounding (VG) and Entity Grounding (EG). It enables
RiVEG to effortlessly inherit the Visual Entailment and Visual Grounding
capabilities of any current or prospective multimodal pretraining models.
Extensive experiments demonstrate that RiVEG outperforms state-of-the-art
methods on the existing GMNER dataset and achieves absolute leads of 10.65%,
6.21%, and 8.83% in all three subtasks.
|
[
-0.5403298736,
-0.819254458,
0.5025765896,
0.0017483814,
-0.3473230898,
0.0644925982,
-0.3480657041,
-0.2657491267,
0.0268498957,
0.5342446566,
-0.5730740428,
-0.5304821134,
-0.8323450685,
-0.0361079983,
-0.1422345936,
0.9093510509,
-0.246578142,
0.1419383585,
-0.3882742822,
-0.251955688,
-0.6312496066,
-0.0519298986,
-0.6007154584,
-0.606092751,
0.6498424411,
0.3621162176,
0.4632960558,
0.6738472581,
0.7271047831,
0.3867584467,
0.0000347484,
0.3261003494,
-0.7187783718,
0.2788325548,
-0.30932796,
-0.2991946638,
-0.3754073083,
-0.0087955734,
0.5989221931,
0.5695163608,
0.0205187108,
0.0413572937,
0.1004427746,
0.5888921022,
-0.5348376036,
0.4316952825,
-0.8011087775,
-0.007998459,
-0.202700004,
-0.4516337514,
-0.2732859552,
0.0723016262,
0.0466124043,
-0.6405171752,
0.4089964032,
0.1478440613,
1.2581737041,
0.336892277,
-0.6185376644,
-0.1933560371,
-0.5340495706,
0.66866225,
-0.3469248116,
0.7433968186,
-0.0680142418,
0.3556223214,
-0.392041862,
-0.8515041471,
-0.4068703353,
-0.3739643395,
-0.125554949,
0.1636750996,
-0.0982023254,
0.3473198712,
0.2996014059,
0.5662180185,
-0.3634003997,
-0.0631749555,
-0.5092975497,
-0.0872161016,
0.3487748206,
0.0564200655,
0.4477446377,
-0.279483825,
-0.7435204387,
0.0708984658,
-0.7811425924,
0.180523172,
-0.0423607677,
0.2626528442,
0.000431766,
0.7056450844,
-0.2402633876,
0.4673353732,
0.3527444005,
-0.413241446,
0.3302057683,
-0.1040745676,
-0.4933708906,
-0.1863659173,
0.7130991817,
0.7372735143,
0.4555317163,
-0.4811364114,
-0.3888733983,
0.0392621867,
0.2909161747,
-0.7748594284,
-0.4203999937,
-0.202759251,
-0.4007347524,
-0.1502829194,
0.2166438252,
-0.6975522637,
-0.5617769361,
-0.7001101971,
0.3057031631,
-0.4003804624,
-0.2482208163,
0.0221775305,
0.0141896829,
0.5182418823,
0.5839772224,
-0.5423449278,
0.0768326893,
0.6797652841,
0.7231886387,
-0.1200215667,
-0.1907366216,
-0.6073483825,
0.2298042774,
-0.0547436662,
0.7956958413,
-0.5215405822,
-0.4655895829,
-0.2433308959,
0.5923113823,
-0.1547106057,
-0.43350631,
0.4252622724,
-0.647734344,
0.0794123858,
-0.1469632685,
-0.4855426848,
-0.2208094299,
0.6057593226,
-0.6864524484,
0.7290992141,
-0.153795734,
-0.8508901,
0.4474315047,
-0.3240995705,
-0.2353764921,
0.0968146101,
-0.6010493636,
-0.3685531318,
0.1213938296,
0.4714540541,
0.6690317988,
-0.4263760149,
0.5937677622,
-0.2470165342,
-0.2244949639,
-0.1334861368,
-0.3468191624,
0.2714743912,
-0.058022406,
-0.123419717,
0.2012178302,
-0.7479509115,
0.125812009,
0.1303256303,
-0.6071436405,
-0.3072366714,
-0.1140666455,
0.1494341344,
0.1307506114,
-0.0495209619,
-0.3578406572,
0.2220403999,
-0.1864129305,
0.3566802144,
0.7510949373,
0.1861809492,
0.8365923762,
-0.1330084205,
0.6352773905,
0.2225318253,
-0.2270757109,
-0.538058877,
-0.4059104919,
-1.0457253456,
-0.6046274304,
0.5003100038,
0.6298220754,
-0.9592536092,
0.0746418163,
-0.6932906508,
-0.4280671477,
-0.5865713358,
0.0697990134,
0.4349249899,
0.5245761275,
0.3951063156,
-0.1343060285,
-0.5536183715,
-1.0904513597,
-0.29194206,
0.0142067345,
0.0415448546,
0.435203433,
0.4454084039,
-0.5810601711,
1.0201611519,
-0.3058781922,
-0.4738904834,
-0.1707288325,
0.2475897819,
0.1759014726,
0.5521871448,
0.2505975366,
-1.1564618349,
-0.4275634587,
0.2401594967,
-0.8409427404,
0.0111377807,
-0.2697675526,
0.0804580227,
-0.3795712292,
0.8395951986,
-0.7876689434,
0.233676374,
0.4226818383,
-0.0481479168,
0.3563124537,
-0.072218895,
0.2318601459,
-1.1452022791,
-0.2339893132,
0.160018757,
-0.4141979814,
-0.6578046083,
0.3120709658,
0.0234229546,
-0.169896841,
-0.2957944572,
0.7117615938,
-1.0408039093,
0.1229266152,
-0.3162828088,
0.2521779835,
0.0076017636,
0.3432434499,
-0.2682857215,
0.8038947582,
0.889970839,
-0.5763165951,
0.502132833,
-0.0343847983,
-0.0711827427,
0.5647748113,
-0.7952408195,
0.0587377362,
-0.7239078879,
0.1351614296,
-0.9512750506,
-0.4161403477,
0.3842823505,
-0.5193211436,
0.6284137368,
-0.6709235907,
-0.2021536678,
0.0044730725,
-0.0591313802,
0.342653513,
0.3730767071,
-0.5590555668,
1.3429936171,
0.3925215006,
-0.1004420817,
-0.5538631678,
-0.4994440079,
0.2407843322,
-0.3823907673,
-0.7307479978,
0.5600143671,
0.3537291586,
-0.1707555205,
0.2018533647,
-0.3026725054,
-0.0200428832,
-0.067143172,
0.7022679448,
0.200387165,
-0.3413146734,
0.2034605742,
-0.2549756169,
-0.4580676556,
-0.0712325498,
-0.0066253408,
0.3375687599,
-0.2567554712,
-0.4572409391,
-0.1067943722,
0.2472812533,
0.6907067299,
-0.5547756553,
0.4304238558,
0.852432847,
-0.4054092169,
0.0079715801,
-0.6820403934,
-0.0274603795,
-0.4681168795,
0.3479813933,
-0.8404192924,
-1.3262523413,
0.4139253199,
-0.5456085205,
0.0327137262,
0.2912264466,
0.3479002416,
-0.1895216256,
0.5701457858,
0.8206573725,
-0.0048894868,
0.3767978251,
-0.0672038049,
0.4954886734,
-0.920583725,
-0.4486310482,
-0.0906101763,
-0.2847156227,
-0.8193577528,
-0.7041230798,
0.1764643043,
0.4667600393,
0.263972044,
0.3174512684,
-0.2433511019,
0.5455157757,
0.3599255085,
0.0704379156,
0.0850272924,
0.0220065266,
-0.2304255664,
-0.2968432605,
-0.3625142574,
-0.6018477678,
0.8529974818,
0.5370730758,
0.9468332529,
-0.0966132656,
0.7800000906,
0.1785506159,
0.5267561674,
-0.959972322,
0.7281745076,
0.0894854143,
-0.3559308052,
-0.0256689601,
-0.2921493948,
-0.7834080458,
0.6674582362,
-0.4191218615,
-0.622002244,
0.1613238752,
0.2103620619,
-0.0053348625,
0.2636572123,
-0.6000798941,
0.8172134757,
-0.0682690144,
-0.1828293204,
0.0990744606,
-0.4934879243,
0.4707969725,
0.1065335646,
0.2393123657,
-0.2218610048,
0.1379114985,
0.4469540417,
0.1625854969,
0.7376144528,
-0.2600483894,
0.017098017,
0.12788634,
-0.132280916,
0.7037425041,
0.2224241346,
0.603636384,
0.061588604,
-0.6117146015,
-0.082946524,
-0.7169846296,
0.8405937552,
-0.388084352,
-0.7765900493,
-0.3089213073,
-0.4226909876,
-0.1288459748,
0.351126492,
0.0998183042,
0.2917550206,
-0.2284605652,
0.5413946509,
0.9798206687,
0.0518452488,
0.0600018762,
0.3202205896,
-0.369857192,
-0.700013876,
0.7055643201,
-0.1071617305,
-0.0674143955,
0.3999031782,
-0.3106215298,
-0.1332475394,
-0.4583273828,
-0.3210307062,
0.4258736372,
-0.8831435442,
-0.1204945818,
-0.9830652475,
-0.242976144,
-0.2909100652,
-0.252800554,
-0.29430601,
0.1116635576,
-0.3012698889,
-0.2844547033,
0.0560201593,
0.4466700256,
0.1557172537,
0.3300368488,
-0.7220326662,
0.7696091533,
0.4177411497,
0.1104577333,
-0.3513603806,
-0.5382835865,
-0.0002356292,
-0.1242690459,
-0.0390157327,
-0.8430060148,
-0.001197221,
0.1675320417,
0.7296136022,
0.6279749274,
-0.3184962273,
1.1219139099,
-1.0551661253,
0.3908699155,
0.4015227854,
-0.5667203069,
0.3355193138,
-0.3221935332,
-0.0020039836,
0.4914422333,
0.3036779463,
-0.6459239125,
-0.1442298293,
-0.4314606488,
-1.1464310884,
0.2751736045,
0.1556230783,
0.2349875271,
-0.043878302,
0.2826304436,
-0.2200096101,
0.0440565981,
-1.026876688,
-0.2258496433,
-0.0106017198,
-0.0180537328,
-0.1154425666,
-0.4041689336,
-0.1715471447,
-0.0690969154,
0.4941839874,
-0.1081308946,
0.2903129458,
0.0784503073,
-0.344553113,
0.2013147026,
0.5760899186,
0.3441095352,
0.4058959782,
-0.0471910127,
0.3492799103,
0.1621696055,
-0.2212885469,
0.2545647025,
0.1139293611,
-0.2527128458,
0.2112480104,
0.4371448755,
0.9002337456,
0.5047203302,
-0.5078135729,
0.4732191265,
0.0325229354,
-0.1730589122,
-0.3250365555,
0.1067710817,
0.2378517091,
0.5222328901,
0.1848667711,
0.1977378279,
0.0415356681,
-0.2468619794,
0.3607484102,
0.5449663401,
-0.5528627038,
-0.1600496173,
0.5784733295,
0.1746465564,
-0.1300891936,
0.4728351533,
-0.2544623315,
-0.423353821,
0.4110319614,
0.489208132,
1.0138683319,
-0.0626477525,
-0.0612024926,
0.3929255605,
0.4994058609,
-0.2129405737,
0.13756603,
-0.0103313038,
-0.8774901628,
-0.3535675406,
-0.481669873,
0.0342946388,
0.220103845,
-0.6922366619,
0.3836449385,
-0.3609574437,
-0.3619045615,
0.0103222346,
-0.5756152272,
-0.8322167397,
0.4669679403,
0.3075918853,
0.7321709991,
-0.8368063569,
0.5835220814,
1.2911628485,
-0.3605506122,
-0.6312769055,
0.0984751731,
0.0832720026,
-0.5859184265,
0.9285537601,
0.5215530396,
-0.3508647978,
0.2322028279,
-0.3716011941,
-0.9330502748,
1.4251543283,
0.0969871283,
-0.6054208875,
-0.3209423721,
-0.0815532804,
0.1345843822,
-0.5910258889,
0.1335319281,
0.1149115488,
0.5926821828,
0.0729813054,
-0.7488196492,
-0.0227529481,
-0.2366650552,
0.4355654716,
0.4000296295,
-0.3977517784,
0.8390581608,
-0.233663708,
-0.6523979306,
-0.2461431921,
0.9496392012,
0.2931907475,
0.2019132972,
0.6696028113,
0.8772687316,
0.6243863702,
-0.3265001476,
0.5858311057,
-0.1842254847,
0.5527712107,
1.1263183355,
-0.212019816,
0.5188245177,
0.7388489246,
0.1034575477,
0.1816141158,
0.2867987454,
-0.1381055415,
0.7340218425,
0.2740116119,
-0.2489150167,
-0.5138000846,
-0.1277935058,
-0.2345209867,
0.5528330803,
0.23796013,
-0.4261477888,
-0.7742222548,
0.2890661061,
0.2000885457,
-0.0031928043,
-0.389654249,
0.617595017,
0.1512159556,
-0.2409519106,
0.2990626991,
0.3589833975,
0.7417699099,
-0.3934003115,
-0.244446516,
0.0013904951,
0.2490914762,
-0.0496849753,
-0.6531430483,
-0.004303351,
0.0145278592,
-0.3597985804,
-0.3743323386,
1.1738374233,
-0.5884846449,
-0.3285452425,
0.4036670029,
0.5890246034,
0.0479054488,
-0.093619518,
-0.7530686259,
-0.0677176937,
0.0904442742,
-0.4246828854,
0.0945810974,
0.7600263357,
-0.0907531455,
0.926145792,
0.6999544501,
-0.1918355823,
0.2221060693,
0.14784199,
1.2085895538,
-0.7220650315,
-0.2555989325,
-0.9300460219,
0.8644350767,
-0.0123620359,
-0.0780717805,
0.8405476809,
0.4283317626,
0.9519475698,
-0.2845547795,
0.5796041489,
-0.1899120808,
0.230247885,
-0.8445371985,
0.5600594878,
-0.5225503445,
-0.0702199861,
-0.1855752617,
-0.9668959379,
-0.2382262796,
0.544049263,
-0.3005417287,
0.0517634712,
0.612552762,
0.9256086946,
-0.5256645679,
-0.4699027538,
0.4947879016,
0.1103725955,
0.490424633,
0.3381778002,
0.8721134067,
-0.4873143435,
0.2864201069,
0.0553587452,
-0.1365187317,
-0.1861979663,
-0.9649112225,
-1.1888192892,
-0.4049856365,
-0.4518837333,
-0.1421231329,
0.0971359015,
0.9651690722,
0.702257514,
-0.6563366652,
0.2490955889,
-0.0475112312,
-0.1035118699,
0.1979129314,
-0.2659904957,
-0.0365582071,
-0.4066172242,
-0.5446503758,
0.662737608,
0.4635724723,
0.0306392964,
-0.1408957839,
-0.0621124879,
-0.0460879393,
-0.164274022,
0.523999989,
0.1049606875,
-1.0968557596,
-0.2345524877,
0.0031002308,
-0.100025326,
0.1015978605,
0.8608061075,
-0.75077492,
0.4083054364,
0.2495590001,
0.995559752,
0.2940746248,
0.36052683,
0.2399849445,
-0.7776857615,
0.1289069653,
0.0711515173,
0.7427229285,
0.4387587905,
-0.1362445801,
0.3575141132,
0.471765548,
-0.4904445112,
-0.6524192691,
0.468691349,
-1.0283759832,
0.1285988986,
1.1412574053,
-0.37110883,
-0.2183065265,
0.0970482156,
-0.2848058045,
0.0797855631,
-0.2438714653,
0.3329970837,
0.7034193873,
0.2357481569,
-0.7648259997,
-0.6400450468,
0.1703416705,
-0.0385465659,
-0.6236545444,
-0.1455242783,
0.6636783481,
0.6172351241,
0.2413078099,
0.6885427237,
-0.0894977972,
0.0066339169,
-0.1861571372,
0.3648387194,
-0.3511712551,
-0.6263854504,
-0.2670612037,
0.2259393483,
-0.1040709764,
-0.3650221825
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09977v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09977v1
|
Fast Vocabulary Transfer for Language Model Compression
| 2024-02-15T14:37:07 | 2024-02-15T14:37:07 |
Leonidas Gee, Andrea Zugarini, Leonardo Rigutini, Paolo Torroni
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Real-world business applications require a trade-off between language model
performance and size. We propose a new method for model compression that relies
on vocabulary transfer. We evaluate the method on various vertical domains and
downstream tasks. Our results indicate that vocabulary transfer can be
effectively used in combination with other compression techniques, yielding a
significant reduction in model size and inference time while marginally
compromising on performance.
|
[
-0.5041112304,
-0.6976296902,
0.0823113695,
0.4342939258,
-0.2713280022,
0.0123321805,
-0.2372620702,
-0.9666509032,
0.1438971758,
0.5714839697,
-0.3235115707,
0.1035301909,
-0.6770561934,
-0.337511152,
-0.5931621194,
0.5086016059,
0.1930815578,
-0.3323974907,
-0.1850993037,
0.2033036351,
-0.6832553148,
-0.7287209034,
-1.0663491488,
-0.3576522768,
0.1807188839,
0.1780096143,
0.9638652802,
0.6643237472,
0.8008188009,
0.2641136944,
-0.1070376337,
-0.0677032694,
-0.4245401621,
0.0036986619,
-0.4484973252,
-0.3046922684,
-0.5681801438,
-0.1440806389,
0.6729596853,
0.9046044946,
-0.2631493509,
0.5842236876,
-0.2125649005,
0.5927131176,
-0.749674201,
0.1354073584,
-0.5269480348,
0.0524225868,
-0.1529095918,
-0.2401715666,
-0.5624412894,
-0.1243637502,
0.2510359287,
-0.4112401903,
0.0555351116,
0.2056909502,
1.2556420565,
0.1645043045,
-0.1520771086,
0.1024756432,
-0.9337478876,
0.7628895044,
-0.6148815155,
0.4295476675,
0.2547737658,
0.4336051941,
0.32828179,
-1.0042880774,
-0.6087312102,
-0.1613321453,
0.0991864875,
-0.211518243,
-0.3928851187,
0.0223503746,
0.2984337509,
0.268268466,
-0.3554657698,
0.2464757562,
-0.6465146542,
-0.2282909006,
0.606494844,
-0.0338636264,
0.2574979961,
0.024409987,
-0.5410265326,
-0.3638378084,
-0.7080904245,
-0.0918723419,
0.146427691,
0.4821240604,
0.1037888825,
0.3261606693,
-0.0284381323,
1.1620044708,
-0.4644021988,
-0.2863661051,
-0.2322234064,
-0.4810114801,
-0.4000175595,
0.0059303045,
0.3808276951,
0.4538297951,
0.2777595222,
-0.2198915035,
-0.2709622085,
0.2213832885,
0.2884739637,
-1.1177954674,
-0.3200106919,
0.0729185566,
-0.6368656158,
-0.1684399247,
-0.1572053879,
-0.9222476482,
0.0551377423,
-0.2860046625,
0.6523243189,
-0.0928747356,
-0.1021107957,
0.5017392635,
-0.4439522922,
0.0348970741,
0.2830177844,
-0.7736008167,
0.7424516082,
0.5037147999,
1.3432463408,
-0.1070940048,
-0.0355731659,
-0.6841294765,
0.329785198,
-0.2545110285,
0.8993122578,
-0.3747802675,
-0.3652769327,
-0.14961119,
-0.2649606168,
0.0038663258,
-0.5777738094,
0.4540087879,
-0.4172454178,
-0.0971476957,
0.017629208,
-0.6810052395,
-0.0772936568,
-0.0312600471,
-0.7410027981,
0.894333303,
0.3173372149,
-0.334212184,
0.0904824361,
-0.4727236927,
-0.6205402017,
0.1335084289,
0.3032099009,
0.0444830656,
0.1201686636,
0.1066085026,
0.6609133482,
-0.5170657635,
-0.2693189681,
-0.2411653399,
-0.3766210377,
0.1372852772,
-0.1497568041,
0.6755209565,
0.5674141645,
0.1050051376,
-0.3609046936,
-0.7275168896,
0.0450163819,
0.0291491747,
-0.2621995807,
-0.6971639395,
-0.2901609838,
0.2220069319,
0.4499563873,
0.3498497903,
-0.3813823462,
0.7082460523,
-0.2813620865,
0.4602233768,
0.5300469398,
-0.2996012866,
0.6345863938,
-0.4964319468,
0.7647767663,
-0.3291158974,
0.0773892552,
0.4708369374,
-0.387348175,
-0.8218299747,
-0.4883729815,
0.8872365952,
0.6526747942,
-0.8633487225,
0.2686209083,
-0.8369025588,
-0.6306741238,
-0.5400785804,
-0.0638184473,
0.2156185955,
0.4384037852,
0.3506712019,
-0.6191907525,
-0.4155409038,
-0.9895914197,
-0.4201694727,
-0.140229091,
-0.1037629098,
0.3070158362,
0.2616787255,
0.2445107996,
0.727630794,
-0.6742830873,
-0.2605517209,
-0.6001896858,
0.5662057996,
0.1154118553,
0.6196587682,
0.7958185077,
-0.7721338868,
-0.3904781342,
-0.1082568169,
0.0505538136,
-0.2677281201,
-0.5063285828,
-0.2289374322,
0.0585144013,
0.5571101904,
-1.0010843277,
0.373013705,
1.0076123476,
-0.3639529943,
0.5043264031,
-0.2629209757,
-0.0958612859,
-1.1820938587,
0.0654931813,
-0.1162605509,
-0.4765185118,
-0.7780312896,
0.227207765,
0.0818384886,
-0.0322242081,
-0.8304290175,
0.9753480554,
-0.7100686431,
-0.305770427,
-0.2582485974,
0.149191156,
0.0774239823,
0.1497970968,
0.1049658507,
1.1004395485,
0.6026244164,
-1.0785454512,
0.2547649443,
0.4014790356,
-0.6565542221,
0.3828472793,
-0.482341677,
0.0770624131,
0.0996149853,
0.1739623845,
-0.6450136304,
0.1218877509,
-0.0997536629,
-0.2819886506,
0.5883561969,
-0.3949956894,
-0.5208547115,
-0.413808912,
-0.0877848938,
0.2210714966,
0.8514507413,
-0.5176272392,
0.4593312442,
0.3291085064,
-0.2313035578,
-0.3322244883,
-1.3594807386,
0.4467936456,
-0.2872652709,
-0.814748764,
0.9283025861,
-0.011454016,
-0.1748555154,
0.0792486966,
-0.1117461622,
-0.4108071029,
0.19844006,
-0.3686642349,
0.2680973709,
-0.0624168031,
0.132650435,
0.0285601616,
0.1986040175,
-0.1500139385,
-0.3542833328,
0.4493170679,
0.1388256997,
0.1973484606,
-0.4054117501,
0.3286125064,
0.5989298224,
-0.0656696856,
1.2198108435,
0.3618717492,
-0.345133394,
-0.3866093755,
-0.2842811644,
-0.2393024862,
-0.480071336,
0.3089155555,
-0.5372322202,
-0.8040456176,
0.4787973166,
-0.409350127,
-0.1316543221,
0.2459794581,
0.3570484519,
0.4965449572,
0.864592135,
0.9788069129,
-0.2328411043,
0.6518874764,
-0.3118561804,
0.7468032241,
-0.5034717321,
0.2057025284,
-0.8916889429,
-0.2807837427,
-0.2925236821,
-0.5838595033,
-0.1070970818,
0.299601078,
0.1289429218,
0.795763433,
-0.3607401848,
0.3222953081,
0.3198676109,
-0.2774802148,
0.1899701953,
0.2460281998,
0.2141469866,
0.1120907143,
-0.9361485839,
-0.2676052153,
0.5970804691,
0.2592003047,
0.8077194691,
0.671630919,
0.2549624443,
0.4195380211,
0.2963517904,
-1.1871703863,
0.60176754,
-0.475913316,
-0.4670747519,
-0.2214636207,
-0.6479802728,
-1.1185230017,
0.2510145903,
-0.1616205722,
-0.9821451306,
0.071352534,
0.0635960475,
-0.5671541691,
0.3352496028,
-0.8441109061,
0.6643351316,
0.105737634,
-0.2723155022,
-0.244774729,
-0.4792568982,
0.3867880702,
-0.1008374989,
0.408174783,
-0.0804727077,
-0.1629323512,
0.7762196064,
-0.5958604217,
0.5356379151,
0.1433424354,
0.0118258437,
0.0191134196,
0.5190864801,
0.4652271569,
-0.4115539491,
-0.0275943279,
0.3559339643,
0.1621074229,
-0.4916315079,
-0.9193553925,
0.4322385788,
-0.2935920954,
-0.3784438074,
-0.2378624976,
-0.7978179455,
-0.2604477406,
0.1050261259,
0.1948058009,
0.5349529386,
0.1389231682,
0.1613616347,
0.3331743479,
0.0944170952,
0.4577419162,
0.2128210217,
-0.0622487329,
0.2598272264,
0.7431718707,
0.3956874907,
0.558011651,
0.5253124237,
0.2424132824,
-0.3219121993,
-0.6770766973,
-0.4770266414,
0.0985526741,
-0.6029685736,
-0.4467900991,
-0.4208388329,
-0.3084721267,
-0.6732464433,
-0.4108870327,
-0.7573907971,
-0.839997232,
-0.0859865099,
0.238479048,
0.4426763356,
0.4828582108,
-0.0561554544,
0.56223768,
-1.330436945,
0.2733646631,
0.1226327419,
0.2269888967,
-0.0330745243,
-0.8316361904,
-0.3551571369,
-0.2389210314,
0.1782959104,
-0.8456424475,
0.9200496078,
0.662781179,
0.3720415831,
0.2281226218,
0.2236014754,
0.857521832,
-0.3226957619,
1.0397788286,
0.1843361855,
-1.2311654091,
0.2125846446,
0.1790200323,
0.1427735835,
0.2890834808,
0.6033847332,
-0.6141481996,
0.0263302755,
-0.6439951658,
-1.0157520771,
0.4030228555,
0.2287289053,
0.2846942246,
0.0828676298,
0.5095204711,
-0.0830627084,
0.1146380231,
-0.2377604842,
-0.1176809818,
0.4067252874,
0.0246459562,
-0.0308312047,
-0.0926667452,
0.0688095167,
-0.501237154,
0.5463316441,
-0.2463719994,
0.6155273914,
0.1527954489,
-0.1654484123,
0.3096422851,
0.146934092,
0.5179872513,
0.600883007,
-0.0756858066,
0.2777258158,
0.1066097468,
-0.5527147651,
0.1206771135,
0.0074427989,
0.047756847,
-0.0709618852,
0.3002789319,
0.7860705853,
0.1751294583,
-0.7017140388,
0.5003351569,
-0.1650103927,
-0.2605471909,
0.140851438,
-0.0465890057,
0.0045836945,
0.1175275743,
-0.1950872093,
0.2949262559,
0.4218968451,
-0.5890920162,
0.0167536512,
0.1791772991,
-0.0930956677,
-0.0725776404,
0.3582665622,
-0.078451246,
-0.2805670798,
0.7071858048,
-0.0214142725,
-0.5003402233,
0.4264307916,
0.5848639011,
0.6250727177,
-0.2715748549,
-0.1116365716,
0.2013168931,
0.1918373555,
-0.620633781,
0.245306477,
-0.051337339,
-0.7648813128,
-0.9595890045,
-0.6025085449,
-0.5958247185,
0.1326001734,
-0.7981100082,
0.2689792812,
-0.2426342964,
-0.3895565867,
0.1351938844,
-0.1261419952,
-0.6311523318,
0.0291197617,
0.1777201891,
1.3942662477,
-0.6310477853,
1.0918034315,
0.4850573242,
-0.2651847601,
-0.8814591765,
-0.2291258872,
-0.1779819131,
-0.4129566252,
1.0015331507,
-0.1033511385,
-0.429851532,
-0.0020455988,
-0.4516449869,
-1.1829400063,
0.6689751148,
0.4473586977,
-0.5187215805,
-0.1186161488,
-0.2149538398,
0.4836339653,
-0.3065364659,
-0.2053103894,
0.6288433671,
0.4526717365,
0.2140090615,
-1.2244001627,
0.1985369176,
-0.0807610676,
0.358869493,
0.1291953027,
-0.545994699,
1.0245314837,
0.254755497,
-0.2641367018,
0.327347368,
0.8271890283,
-0.2165820003,
-0.2669768631,
0.5482518673,
0.4754442275,
0.7947984338,
0.3085484505,
1.4361870289,
-0.4998219311,
0.4569087327,
0.904422164,
-0.2977118492,
1.3286640644,
0.6210262775,
-0.2116311938,
0.4201132059,
0.3794153333,
0.1844321787,
0.4251680374,
0.5418546796,
-0.1577119678,
-0.2651667297,
-0.3221167326,
-0.2853165567,
0.6329978704,
0.5557090044,
0.0199833084,
0.0397353284,
-0.0874367133,
0.2156119794,
-0.1698855758,
-0.2751912773,
0.2202288061,
0.0583376624,
-0.8411229849,
0.8347361088,
0.2508096695,
0.8739644885,
-0.6637029648,
-0.0690172985,
-0.0332035869,
0.2357518077,
0.1919155717,
-0.5776237845,
0.7464805841,
-0.2419787049,
0.1699359566,
-0.7138871551,
1.1410208941,
-0.4782701731,
-0.1627354622,
0.4528223872,
0.5464561582,
0.5537452102,
-0.2316010594,
-0.6364658475,
-0.0593704246,
-0.4034375846,
-0.279004097,
0.4161153734,
0.1139202341,
-0.1304906756,
0.7939422727,
0.8390730023,
0.683419168,
0.1574821621,
0.1265046895,
0.7743381858,
-0.4889972806,
-0.6806816459,
-0.469637841,
-0.0259561054,
-0.2561656237,
-0.1453740597,
0.8176729679,
0.2585590184,
0.8376997113,
-0.0712543651,
0.5975657105,
-0.1488248259,
0.3197731972,
-0.8806816339,
0.7851189971,
-0.6604881883,
0.1044647023,
-0.1186933815,
-0.8429144025,
-0.469045639,
0.7745879889,
-0.0280873552,
-0.1352702826,
0.7982013226,
0.6191996336,
-0.1367451698,
-0.2895867527,
0.5431309342,
0.1341177076,
0.2035157681,
0.4614085853,
0.4274227321,
-0.4452300072,
0.5158917904,
-0.4578852355,
-0.1932695806,
-0.3496623337,
-1.2931933403,
-0.5535631776,
-0.4624814987,
-0.6230803132,
-0.5502766371,
0.0032941313,
0.7081239223,
1.3421075344,
-0.3850845397,
-0.4287707508,
-0.0017501469,
-0.1341610849,
-0.6573696733,
-0.2301231772,
0.2970558107,
-0.135762468,
-0.7558158636,
0.3696956635,
0.1098074913,
0.1566827148,
-0.2646044195,
0.1199189946,
-0.2879168689,
0.6004629731,
0.864413023,
0.267978698,
-0.3481072187,
-0.3770001531,
-0.1609959006,
0.0922998637,
-0.2123853564,
1.1307660341,
-0.746589303,
0.0988619402,
0.9309534431,
0.8242337704,
0.625675261,
-0.1588559598,
0.6294518709,
-1.0200167894,
0.5832769871,
0.1178217158,
0.3491059244,
0.2441793829,
-0.5606175065,
0.5427472591,
0.4250040948,
-0.24948816,
-0.6525110602,
0.2588573694,
-1.1910027266,
-0.7996980548,
1.1577872038,
-0.1241241768,
-0.5129284859,
-0.0405929908,
-0.1875383258,
0.1158234403,
-0.2833071947,
0.4710856676,
0.9507331848,
-0.1193050668,
-0.2439670116,
-0.7940738797,
0.5058341622,
0.4897606075,
-0.8529891968,
0.0820472911,
0.2048656046,
-0.0846001431,
0.2515295446,
0.5024015307,
0.1180907786,
0.2050117105,
0.3297478855,
0.4168480635,
0.0308918245,
-0.5234509706,
-0.4394282401,
0.1865075231,
0.1278313547,
-0.0294198506
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09967v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09967v1
|
Case Study: Testing Model Capabilities in Some Reasoning Tasks
| 2024-02-15T14:21:30 | 2024-02-15T14:21:30 |
Min Zhang, Sato Takumi, Jack Zhang, Jun Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) excel in generating personalized content and
facilitating interactive dialogues, showcasing their remarkable aptitude for a
myriad of applications. However, their capabilities in reasoning and providing
explainable outputs, especially within the context of reasoning abilities,
remain areas for improvement. In this study, we delve into the reasoning
abilities of LLMs, highlighting the current challenges and limitations that
hinder their effectiveness in complex reasoning scenarios.
|
[
-0.4418733418,
-0.7146357298,
1.1764843464,
0.0200464632,
0.1086876318,
0.1906162947,
-0.3663096428,
-0.291337043,
-0.3456963003,
0.7178986073,
-0.5412219167,
-0.2722990513,
-0.7232078314,
0.3494821787,
-0.6077549458,
0.5759086609,
-0.3575203121,
0.0448849313,
-0.437604785,
-0.0528127626,
-0.5996951461,
-0.7298336625,
-0.7485518456,
-0.4752287269,
0.5094718933,
0.6669213176,
0.8239560723,
0.2009478658,
0.4217227995,
0.3740823269,
-0.0993504748,
0.4181468785,
-0.3771104515,
0.4724940956,
-0.2587757409,
-0.6387668848,
-0.2618769109,
-0.2231817096,
0.7068758607,
0.8327018619,
-0.068230696,
0.0329302363,
-0.2441879809,
0.4123834074,
-0.1659302562,
0.177592963,
-0.7874639034,
-0.1508104354,
-0.1327967793,
-0.0704996362,
-0.4766280949,
-0.1907761991,
0.1521252394,
-0.30668661,
-0.030095093,
0.1326413304,
0.8671376705,
0.1768588275,
-0.6060267687,
-0.5973306894,
-1.1242573261,
0.8861219287,
-0.9988174438,
0.2935160398,
0.2966047525,
0.6650882363,
-0.402880013,
-0.5870978236,
-0.4694519937,
-0.5954347849,
0.0558756515,
-0.2805157006,
-0.114731811,
-0.0259073563,
0.5190805793,
0.3745910525,
-0.3653168082,
0.4070234597,
-0.15191333,
-0.0785389543,
0.7968332767,
0.5028626323,
0.3807463646,
-0.1450376064,
0.2214561701,
0.2137886733,
-0.7016069293,
0.0664701536,
0.3677465618,
0.1338995844,
0.0905513018,
0.9850680232,
-0.094718717,
0.8056688309,
-0.3853386045,
-0.2988161743,
-0.2650691867,
-0.1277231276,
-0.3246282339,
-0.2615008056,
0.3658281863,
-0.0213539768,
0.4482058287,
-0.0249206126,
-0.2941845059,
-0.2543443441,
0.0786909908,
-0.5739984512,
0.0806347057,
0.4170415401,
-0.3918135166,
0.2152195424,
-0.1279590428,
-0.3694219887,
-0.4728907347,
-0.4506320655,
0.3952846527,
-0.3411806822,
-0.2278926373,
0.2902418375,
-0.2190840542,
0.3089873791,
0.5599886179,
-0.9235954285,
0.2644014657,
0.7082545757,
0.5736710429,
-0.2163227201,
-0.082670331,
-0.3344183266,
0.243825838,
-0.3071005642,
0.684869647,
-0.6298466325,
-0.4226294458,
0.0574170724,
0.0718146116,
-0.1277023256,
-0.81595999,
0.3359824717,
-0.3495154381,
-0.1740220785,
-0.4602339566,
-0.6649874449,
-0.1517555863,
0.3883400857,
-0.507840395,
0.6471011043,
0.2170974165,
-0.4466078579,
-0.0247823875,
-0.6398078799,
-0.4272097349,
0.1436650753,
-0.3292626441,
-0.201731801,
0.140283823,
0.003112464,
0.7714675665,
-0.5680478811,
0.3110539615,
-0.4628224373,
-0.3556140959,
0.6640272141,
-0.2523286641,
0.5483916402,
0.3368579447,
-0.3250879049,
0.3106356561,
-0.6930539012,
-0.1076299697,
0.4868271351,
-0.3794617057,
-0.1194166094,
0.3154225051,
-0.2118062228,
0.0661078095,
0.141236797,
-0.1357857287,
0.3911490142,
-0.1596050858,
0.8492182493,
0.6309877634,
-0.3120581508,
0.3210339248,
-0.4078462422,
0.8019971251,
-0.0829045326,
0.0471431613,
-0.2012239546,
-0.5109388828,
-0.8935546279,
-0.2758842111,
0.1924275011,
0.6180421114,
-0.6536961794,
0.0066831824,
-0.057398621,
-0.5201324224,
-0.0686610267,
0.5723620653,
0.2096436322,
0.2415426224,
-0.0763039514,
-0.0080906348,
-0.5454767346,
-1.0622096062,
-0.3527749777,
-0.1703695953,
-0.1202896833,
0.5768821836,
0.6387496591,
-0.3241563439,
0.6942560077,
-0.4184077978,
0.1223570779,
-0.8338004947,
-0.2020021975,
0.2393423915,
0.1247305498,
0.3453378081,
-0.8842679858,
-0.2444027662,
0.0142105771,
-0.8902949691,
-0.2758287787,
-0.2887420654,
0.0036379683,
0.1921111494,
0.6472862959,
-0.9239791632,
0.1759674251,
0.5583124161,
-0.3401559293,
0.8660443425,
-0.3495024741,
-0.0132660624,
-0.802924037,
-0.3429042995,
0.1134301871,
-0.2842214406,
-0.5043871999,
0.0431315564,
-0.1299417019,
-0.1382826716,
-0.3915767968,
0.7286224365,
-0.699213922,
-0.3663703799,
-0.2182190567,
0.2555978298,
-0.0733034313,
-0.0988949835,
0.0357604027,
0.7099331617,
0.5032228231,
-0.7415887713,
0.6239315867,
0.2178370059,
-0.5355974436,
0.4823967218,
-0.691930294,
-0.165632382,
0.0577867404,
0.1058293134,
-1.0491591692,
-0.7461314201,
-0.2308781147,
-0.1622318774,
0.2773618102,
0.1633458436,
-0.8748215437,
-0.7038745284,
-0.0345350131,
0.0684944466,
0.5286830664,
-0.4265430868,
0.8245397806,
0.2407074422,
-0.2042813599,
-0.2086659223,
-0.5868191719,
0.2243801951,
-0.4749319553,
-0.813916862,
0.0197142344,
-0.2589942217,
-0.7930915356,
-0.1590439081,
0.2067520767,
-0.0672799721,
0.3824898005,
0.4018692374,
0.1236413419,
-0.3446785212,
0.326762557,
0.0793998316,
0.1756337583,
0.1547566056,
0.1375804394,
0.4860743582,
-0.2963955998,
-0.848300457,
-0.2518354654,
0.3885358572,
0.786585927,
-0.1213024035,
0.8066462278,
0.1896678805,
-0.3555307984,
-0.3919366598,
-0.8985251784,
-0.0803921968,
-0.4702344537,
0.4624428153,
-0.6077643633,
-1.3211177588,
0.7116430402,
-0.3246608377,
0.0541568398,
0.2526329458,
0.9149586558,
-0.034333799,
1.3521550894,
0.3829782009,
0.3248024881,
0.1974479556,
-0.0828731805,
0.6147366762,
-0.8980526924,
-0.4127829373,
-0.4073518217,
0.0218839161,
-0.3708751202,
-0.3287625313,
0.1977009922,
0.1630250812,
-0.4703882039,
0.0384075828,
-0.1400216222,
0.3100832403,
0.4531544149,
-0.0964333564,
0.501896739,
-0.2707855999,
0.009021447,
-0.0650299191,
-0.6758369803,
-0.9736713767,
0.796634078,
0.6346566677,
0.884105742,
0.3070580959,
0.2575589418,
0.0334683433,
0.1691834927,
-0.8591237068,
0.7876644731,
-0.0753987357,
-0.7275004387,
-0.425439477,
-0.4077084661,
-0.7778821588,
0.1720548719,
-0.215345636,
-0.8435620666,
-0.4156339169,
0.1824077666,
-0.2738321722,
0.6434072852,
-0.8636816144,
0.736979723,
-0.4803381264,
-0.0999246314,
-0.0234995224,
-0.2002835125,
0.5912427306,
-0.118780911,
0.29418993,
-0.2201166749,
0.033134561,
0.3237794042,
-0.2408724874,
0.9275190234,
0.3021565378,
-0.1562204808,
0.3743877709,
0.3800222576,
0.319278121,
-0.0286052674,
-0.1942668855,
-0.060171932,
-0.0114133395,
-0.4060580134,
-0.4512459934,
0.7578884959,
-0.5365104079,
-1.3938564062,
-0.1136019975,
-1.0224634409,
-0.580160737,
-0.001038965,
-0.2068486959,
0.2199793458,
-0.0657335669,
0.261749059,
0.7628766894,
-0.6015567183,
0.4523926079,
0.4616913199,
-0.4194599092,
0.1793027669,
0.6396848559,
0.2957245111,
0.5407677293,
0.13608329,
0.2250172794,
-0.2891303003,
-0.9166432619,
-0.4728599191,
0.42154634,
-1.0517089367,
0.1892556101,
-0.7086956501,
-0.379753828,
-0.3840360045,
-0.2441662252,
-0.2293512523,
-0.4320991039,
-0.3061124384,
-0.1784563065,
0.1836901754,
1.1064250469,
0.1860854328,
0.1715018153,
-0.7369552851,
0.089905262,
0.6409932971,
0.1012925208,
0.2078530043,
-0.5813468695,
0.0427485146,
-0.377730608,
-0.3916595578,
-0.7985725999,
0.3032270372,
-0.1799401194,
0.8108385205,
0.3289348185,
-0.2481666058,
0.4121862054,
-0.4091949165,
0.9932430983,
-0.1149958372,
-1.0376622677,
0.5332895517,
-0.4637717903,
0.3844565153,
-0.0475706719,
0.5480598211,
-0.2382582426,
-0.4794957638,
-0.4059376717,
-0.6909518838,
0.2495173216,
0.2390717119,
0.4236838222,
0.067676492,
0.6447232366,
0.1135153696,
0.1109331697,
-0.598513484,
0.0125818616,
0.2674776316,
-0.0706173852,
-0.1050981805,
-0.6020504832,
-0.0786449313,
-0.4280237556,
0.6473962069,
-0.0507296138,
-0.114027828,
0.1766835451,
0.061381653,
0.03104298,
0.5304769278,
0.9008862376,
1.0646954775,
0.1089287028,
0.2045271695,
0.4780526459,
0.0933201388,
0.0955314934,
0.0192920789,
0.1533547044,
-0.1253386736,
0.5948104262,
0.7348455191,
0.1261805445,
-1.2782789469,
0.3622614145,
-0.1050575823,
-0.2790586948,
-0.5509288907,
0.3063112795,
0.6999464035,
0.5600554943,
0.3645128608,
-0.4707413614,
-0.1216917336,
-0.8581286669,
-0.180153355,
0.6851555705,
-0.1989488453,
-0.0826467499,
0.6702244878,
-0.0036875301,
-0.5456280708,
0.5797719359,
-0.1936573088,
-0.6099690199,
0.8177974224,
0.668028295,
0.4144897461,
-0.2214860767,
0.0819685012,
0.0082106711,
0.4123484492,
-0.2530564964,
0.2469729632,
0.2424652278,
-0.9686923623,
-0.5923932195,
-0.3472211361,
-0.8769798875,
0.3439254761,
-0.3160763681,
0.1646238863,
-0.5058946013,
-0.1870331615,
0.1100225821,
-0.1662529856,
-0.5861133933,
0.1642412841,
0.2953960299,
0.9139597416,
-0.6715911031,
0.6618125439,
0.7032524347,
-0.3197192252,
-0.9290460348,
-0.4786162376,
0.0346387587,
-0.7152822018,
1.0135947466,
0.1502370089,
0.0771223977,
-0.289570272,
-0.6097078323,
-0.5550958514,
1.0458059311,
0.6259077191,
-0.7871411443,
-0.0606054291,
0.382144779,
0.590500474,
-0.7084088922,
0.2749582827,
0.7733405828,
0.7074055672,
0.0710291639,
-1.172688365,
0.0482168943,
-0.0498163998,
0.18977274,
-0.1675136089,
-0.5843240619,
0.9688497186,
-0.4630693793,
0.0674594641,
0.2202037126,
0.601080358,
0.3898430765,
0.3722344637,
0.5627168417,
0.3842455149,
0.8104375601,
-0.2137019932,
1.5266882181,
0.2052648664,
-0.0927944183,
1.1049714088,
-0.6362941265,
0.7989535332,
0.4091460705,
-0.0093661547,
0.5792208314,
0.7043370008,
-0.1033397615,
-0.1287274659,
0.5157629848,
-0.3977771997,
-0.855910778,
-0.1516226083,
-0.0366499089,
0.3783802092,
0.4105718136,
-0.4103966653,
0.0614917614,
0.1358054876,
0.0031955533,
0.3870636821,
-0.433157742,
0.4634938836,
0.360240072,
-0.516318202,
0.2067881823,
-0.0131397368,
0.4021744132,
-0.4603152871,
-0.2153374553,
0.1241000071,
0.3021472692,
-0.1612243801,
-0.9511573911,
0.4483284354,
-0.0344876498,
-0.0890509337,
-0.1120682359,
0.8656181693,
-0.0718175173,
-0.4399392903,
0.4764842093,
0.7368918657,
0.2114571929,
-0.1432767659,
-0.6759416461,
0.4365052879,
-0.1613778919,
-0.4396923482,
0.3821762502,
0.5919325948,
-0.2666089237,
1.3097352982,
0.4712938666,
0.1741844118,
0.0548855923,
0.2484036237,
0.7249626517,
-0.7953765392,
0.0315130502,
-0.9747395515,
0.313621521,
-0.0360114835,
-0.1267075241,
0.9794884324,
0.5436694622,
0.6999302506,
-0.223048389,
0.9036099315,
0.1897790432,
0.5256999135,
-0.5474325418,
0.3917440176,
-0.5015097857,
0.5102407336,
0.1716653407,
-0.7501228452,
-0.2956955135,
0.463056922,
-0.5847862363,
0.1297339201,
0.673335731,
0.69645226,
-0.0022090368,
-0.0044351444,
0.7383487225,
0.5769795775,
0.604436934,
0.7250996828,
1.2556710243,
0.091680333,
0.4983073771,
0.0511816181,
-0.0104450891,
-0.179745242,
-1.0779075623,
-1.4988194704,
-0.5050266385,
-0.2653141022,
-0.3502905369,
-0.1191065758,
0.7447578311,
0.7067945004,
-0.7331233025,
-0.3374877572,
0.0437967144,
0.5041530132,
0.2925271094,
-0.221673578,
-0.0294896197,
-0.2498330325,
-0.7523789406,
0.3072492778,
0.3457519412,
0.1967633665,
-0.6700922251,
-0.1000328287,
-0.0131396903,
0.501097858,
0.8913429379,
0.2511082888,
-0.988614738,
-0.4723223448,
-0.1341172755,
0.0196312964,
-0.2872642279,
0.8897163272,
-0.2648140192,
0.1981222928,
0.3431322575,
0.7894624472,
0.4804905355,
-0.3128009439,
0.7199290395,
0.0217407625,
-0.036488004,
0.2005065829,
0.6707985401,
0.6654205322,
-0.3192032278,
0.4223722219,
-0.0317330733,
-0.6691820025,
-1.0183566809,
0.5152719617,
-1.1258451939,
-0.5198284388,
1.4659148455,
-0.3290350437,
-0.1315470487,
-0.2464505285,
-0.3599956334,
-0.0381492563,
0.0869719237,
0.6093342304,
1.1361054182,
-0.4177792072,
-0.3290502131,
-1.1271374226,
0.3213046491,
0.4296175241,
-0.9767793417,
-0.0346628986,
0.3896542788,
0.5690491199,
-0.0654220507,
0.5296439528,
-0.1401906908,
-0.0186225474,
-0.3293251991,
-0.2708402574,
-0.1177718565,
-0.2270157933,
-0.3027818203,
0.1535797566,
0.710252583,
0.5815104842
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09954v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09954v2
|
Crafting a Good Prompt or Providing Exemplary Dialogues? A Study of In-Context Learning for Persona-based Dialogue Generation
| 2024-02-15T14:03:33 | 2024-02-17T06:11:58 |
Jiashu Pu, Yajing Wan, Yuru Zhang, Jing Chen, Ling Cheng, Qian Shao, Yongzhu Chang, Tangjie Lv, Rongsheng Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Previous in-context learning (ICL) research has focused on tasks such as
classification, machine translation, text2table, etc., while studies on whether
ICL can improve human-like dialogue generation are scarce. Our work fills this
gap by systematically investigating the ICL capabilities of large language
models (LLMs) in persona-based dialogue generation, conducting extensive
experiments on high-quality real human Chinese dialogue datasets. From
experimental results, we draw three conclusions: 1) adjusting prompt
instructions is the most direct, effective, and economical way to improve
generation quality; 2) randomly retrieving demonstrations (demos) achieves the
best results, possibly due to the greater diversity and the amount of effective
information; counter-intuitively, retrieving demos with a context identical to
the query performs the worst; 3) even when we destroy the multi-turn
associations and single-turn semantics in the demos, increasing the number of
demos still improves dialogue performance, proving that LLMs can learn from
corrupted dialogue demos. Previous explanations of the ICL mechanism, such as
$n$-gram induction head, cannot fully account for this phenomenon.
|
[
-0.3395655155,
-0.5447525978,
0.8339762092,
0.2304786593,
-0.3543820381,
0.0195866525,
-0.1809337437,
-0.2074156255,
-0.3554148674,
0.4314653873,
-0.7092803717,
-0.3947054446,
-0.0955708623,
0.1597984433,
-0.123287268,
1.0513596535,
0.4443251491,
0.3949329257,
-0.2478474081,
-0.0306213424,
-0.6136819124,
-0.4416163564,
-0.9170501828,
-0.353327632,
0.4874499142,
0.7309057117,
0.3515281677,
0.3363935947,
-0.0628151298,
0.2480395734,
-0.0435871109,
0.3121880591,
-0.541025579,
0.2513611317,
-0.0492389947,
-0.4344072938,
-0.0617641136,
0.1049387902,
0.7567884326,
0.7691031694,
0.0138213541,
-0.1609770954,
0.4745159149,
0.4019019008,
-0.4313487411,
0.1449764073,
-0.5460373759,
-0.1192581877,
-0.1646203101,
-0.3765828311,
-0.8291534185,
-0.4239041507,
0.4443884492,
-0.2853712738,
0.1076394841,
0.2235524803,
0.5471067429,
0.0204446781,
-0.304084599,
-0.4281594157,
-0.6547734737,
0.8195096254,
-0.8473181725,
0.0280281492,
0.2479113936,
0.3880082369,
-0.3546567261,
-0.6410957575,
-0.4559983909,
-0.4975499809,
-0.1401557177,
0.0744881108,
0.0882395133,
0.2699741721,
0.569347918,
0.2268062681,
-0.265989989,
0.2604689598,
-0.0141929146,
-0.1659406871,
0.5196735859,
0.3638088703,
0.4000755548,
-0.3406785131,
-0.3389832079,
-0.2008480132,
-1.1523475647,
0.5747494102,
0.3539283872,
0.4220036268,
0.0208295435,
0.1788774431,
-0.1233217567,
0.5880292058,
0.4303894937,
-0.466550678,
-0.1195909381,
-0.3014600873,
-0.0331568271,
0.110032849,
0.7196799517,
0.4338150322,
-0.0436761156,
-0.1469628811,
-0.3342701197,
-0.3881878853,
-0.0577769279,
-1.010979414,
-0.2264232039,
0.1701747477,
-0.4893247783,
-0.0498407893,
0.2520664334,
-0.5994354486,
-0.4002203941,
-0.5450414419,
0.2329657227,
-0.6407366991,
0.1108305305,
-0.213126272,
-0.0622448847,
0.5450671911,
0.5791924,
-0.812967658,
0.0772603974,
0.5289523602,
0.5333513021,
-0.1692853719,
-0.2535251975,
-0.9554098845,
-0.1020610183,
-0.3987051547,
0.7093892097,
-0.4616860747,
-0.5446133614,
0.1356264353,
-0.2276749313,
-0.0498420298,
-0.7454702854,
0.3488022089,
-0.0925765634,
0.5304358602,
-0.6014526486,
-0.5117951632,
0.1302201599,
-0.0170644913,
-0.1893577874,
0.6288474202,
0.0714707673,
-0.4483010471,
0.5354151726,
-0.647149086,
-0.3412598372,
0.2386276126,
-0.3341332078,
-0.1311573386,
0.1432603598,
0.2862393856,
0.5876895189,
-0.445279479,
0.4504224658,
-0.0764383897,
-0.5347799063,
0.7712632418,
-0.5551264286,
0.772768259,
0.305500865,
-0.5154471993,
0.141196236,
-0.4667418599,
-0.14517878,
-0.1214687824,
-0.2337245047,
-0.0293609798,
0.1220211536,
-0.1563348025,
0.3273738325,
-0.2133059651,
-0.5839514732,
0.2104004174,
-0.5931701064,
0.337992847,
0.7807108164,
0.2616772652,
0.4884282351,
-0.4605759978,
0.3276515007,
0.1854121685,
-0.0190214701,
-0.8497020006,
-0.4054267704,
-0.793410182,
-0.1468425691,
0.1823310852,
0.3364821672,
-0.9896390438,
0.2481394559,
0.0573836602,
-0.2854490876,
-0.4710973799,
-0.0235838462,
0.7082369328,
0.7849034071,
0.1113924384,
-0.287596643,
-0.1612931788,
-0.8503765464,
-0.2110403627,
-0.3708862066,
-0.3364581168,
0.6667174101,
0.0778980702,
0.1406708062,
1.0444128513,
-0.2957009673,
0.1247419119,
-0.6108338833,
0.2887794971,
-0.0466973558,
0.3332614899,
0.6055662632,
-0.5707732439,
-0.8277702928,
-0.4087091088,
-0.552396059,
-0.397878468,
-0.4795773625,
-0.0014621494,
0.108879976,
0.5633802414,
-0.5774588585,
0.2750477493,
-0.0573313609,
-0.1643042564,
0.6537704468,
-0.1114047617,
0.2379666567,
-1.0034606457,
-0.1533910632,
0.1318412721,
-0.2179286778,
-0.8607428074,
-0.0221803486,
0.0620727576,
-0.2535099983,
-0.7159588933,
0.6566856503,
-0.2748194635,
0.0202261955,
-0.4551913142,
0.3161239922,
-0.0809783041,
0.7614172697,
-0.0871421918,
1.0447294712,
0.5461470485,
-0.8276826143,
0.0362829939,
0.3323414028,
-0.5635458827,
0.6730026603,
-0.4733505249,
0.3212954998,
-0.3932990432,
0.6717447042,
-1.2428526878,
-0.4889940023,
0.3910847902,
-0.2707356215,
0.3254772723,
0.0091662128,
-0.5305227041,
0.0293317381,
-0.1710388064,
0.1376218796,
0.6698262691,
-0.9505830407,
0.2046644986,
0.1078822687,
-0.2600819767,
-0.25185287,
-0.3092403114,
0.1525501311,
-0.429890275,
-0.4265401959,
0.4310860932,
-0.4165885746,
-0.5386597514,
-0.5734713078,
0.2569399178,
0.2378453016,
-0.0189387538,
0.036973685,
-0.0962471887,
-0.0457685813,
0.1770905107,
0.083996281,
-0.0724238008,
0.1838084012,
-0.2526741326,
0.5924797058,
0.1004032418,
-0.4080576301,
-0.8692076802,
0.4806578159,
0.5270763636,
-0.0448579602,
0.5018372536,
0.2345820665,
-0.0130179171,
-0.3331708312,
-0.4398709536,
-0.3791203797,
-0.4832340777,
0.0853398517,
-0.3365000486,
-0.6152762175,
0.4660897255,
-0.2394258529,
0.3108211756,
0.1124377847,
0.4030869007,
-0.2804244757,
1.3167250156,
0.3405941725,
-0.0166745074,
0.6023513079,
-0.0438313708,
0.2045195699,
-0.8847884536,
-0.2320860326,
-0.4459090233,
-0.2286753356,
-0.2536062598,
-0.1055980623,
0.434382081,
-0.1245291829,
-0.1635169089,
0.0990205854,
-0.1571534872,
0.3965306878,
0.7061514854,
0.3049368858,
0.0737753958,
-0.1485653967,
-0.1572267562,
-0.3648242056,
-0.6140198708,
-0.498537451,
0.7477234602,
0.1964659393,
0.6689772606,
0.1170467734,
0.5691486597,
0.0217208341,
0.2523219585,
-0.5721945763,
0.757466197,
0.1099047065,
-0.140105024,
-0.2363938391,
-0.294790864,
-0.7981763482,
0.2513716221,
-0.0019520191,
-0.8086869121,
0.057719864,
0.3427122235,
-0.5541661382,
0.1290350854,
-0.525003314,
0.6028418541,
-0.3750216961,
-0.4439221323,
-0.0245648939,
-0.8143747449,
0.319765389,
0.117182225,
-0.1692259908,
0.1677392572,
0.2855743766,
0.3127408326,
-0.3720683455,
0.9093541503,
-0.4893834591,
-0.2201107591,
0.4192849994,
-0.0404893383,
0.6206018925,
0.2679917812,
-0.0153698567,
-0.4962986708,
-0.4198667705,
-0.2870568037,
-0.9467712641,
0.37789011,
-0.5880328417,
-0.8148231506,
-0.0760924295,
-0.4400874376,
-0.3809972405,
-0.2302116007,
0.6332480907,
0.8858883381,
-0.228560105,
0.4168787301,
1.0247170925,
-0.6519246697,
0.4874145985,
0.4400205016,
-0.1525121331,
-0.1122956276,
0.8605625629,
0.0065099606,
0.5293049812,
0.4557814598,
0.2659004033,
-0.3058062494,
-0.5112657547,
-0.6886925697,
0.0357571617,
-0.6978331804,
-0.0732337981,
-0.6634529829,
-0.2354378402,
-0.3160693645,
-0.0814278871,
0.0158084184,
-0.0992122218,
-0.4623264968,
0.0268217102,
-0.0953028351,
0.4621169269,
0.2420312911,
0.6089687943,
-0.4900847077,
0.1047398746,
0.4240077436,
-0.0081548821,
0.201290071,
-0.6525639296,
-0.1223870143,
0.1946957409,
-0.5065603256,
-0.795378983,
0.314006418,
0.2177207619,
0.6443258524,
0.780118227,
0.1537941694,
0.7407162189,
-0.5364797711,
1.180347681,
0.0524461791,
-0.666339159,
0.6545626521,
-0.5878834128,
0.7072473764,
0.6222499609,
0.122428216,
-0.6924051046,
-0.5561055541,
-0.5911380053,
-0.6137323976,
0.8125456572,
0.0165958833,
0.3898455203,
-0.0466553941,
0.4906747937,
0.3757185936,
0.2007612139,
-0.6287307739,
-0.2254103422,
-0.0834415257,
-0.0345536321,
-0.0712592229,
-0.349835515,
0.0302054994,
-0.2081072032,
0.6344635487,
-0.3245491982,
0.2765983343,
0.1512734294,
-0.1175270155,
-0.0627672523,
0.3337879479,
0.7109069228,
0.6506800652,
0.0090311021,
-0.2003034055,
0.2074536383,
-0.0039185076,
0.0734903514,
-0.2569974661,
-0.3574554026,
-0.0860303268,
0.1610588133,
1.1194834709,
0.4060104489,
-0.8757564425,
0.6385540962,
-0.2347346544,
-0.1208491027,
-0.2786294818,
0.4064589143,
-0.2408888042,
0.1388807297,
0.6237444878,
-0.0035899743,
0.2914310992,
-0.7421237826,
0.1898822486,
0.5362080336,
-0.2919102311,
-0.302703917,
0.522102952,
0.3763704896,
-0.6026748419,
0.8966355324,
-0.2630871236,
-0.4039450288,
0.3183081448,
0.6690007448,
1.0246760845,
-0.1854419708,
0.4046075344,
0.39820081,
-0.1134036407,
-0.0154161006,
-0.0803508461,
-0.3578257561,
-0.4789195359,
-0.4702133536,
-0.2542769909,
-0.7434608936,
0.4134869874,
-0.4713551104,
0.2916338444,
-0.4652732611,
0.2345431149,
-0.294110775,
-0.0737157613,
-0.4876198769,
-0.0040803845,
0.0290004238,
0.7897802591,
-0.6124674082,
0.6553057432,
0.3107120991,
-0.2243246734,
-0.8502470851,
0.4318317771,
0.1181963533,
-0.2691366076,
0.4885279536,
0.4388035834,
-0.0260380693,
-0.0441258028,
-0.999771893,
-0.5242501497,
0.9319798946,
0.4333072901,
-0.3522621393,
-0.1113106906,
0.1168416589,
0.4914533496,
-0.6189603209,
0.3650293052,
0.3665385842,
0.2707218528,
0.1031375527,
-0.6142832041,
-0.1663979143,
-0.2058781832,
0.0656512454,
-0.1048251092,
-0.8269891739,
0.7132895589,
-0.0438762829,
-0.3810084462,
0.5104180574,
0.8183779716,
0.4293402433,
0.3753943741,
0.541472435,
0.0578432567,
0.7061457634,
-0.1060196757,
1.1449240446,
-0.2264202982,
-0.30544433,
1.1121926308,
-0.3965765834,
0.3430928886,
0.3156968951,
0.1630202234,
0.6439096928,
0.8830120564,
0.2448092103,
0.5674843788,
0.0831126571,
-0.4824834466,
-0.3318534195,
-0.2681947947,
0.0359266959,
0.3414579034,
0.390540421,
-0.3653182685,
-0.1319029033,
0.4198313355,
-0.0684422776,
0.2179235816,
-0.0845145062,
1.1024951935,
0.0742065012,
-1.310603857,
0.1863538027,
-0.054675214,
0.4083070755,
-0.4605017006,
-0.2387767136,
-0.4580496848,
-0.124299854,
0.1196774021,
-0.5141733885,
-0.3258199394,
0.0063525699,
-0.1131409779,
-0.4250095487,
0.5906801224,
-0.4663967192,
-0.000960852,
-0.1074047536,
0.4473605156,
0.3504852653,
0.1486409605,
-0.5491851568,
-0.3011285663,
0.1253371388,
-0.0824492127,
0.6284838319,
0.5497374535,
-0.0607520156,
0.7509946823,
0.52558887,
-0.192797333,
-0.1890323162,
0.2795345783,
0.7750040293,
-0.5453528166,
-0.5733217001,
-0.8083149195,
0.8298020363,
-0.2159544528,
-0.4081525505,
0.8509168029,
0.4283804595,
0.8802158237,
-0.0403319262,
0.8803471327,
0.1203008518,
0.5881948471,
-0.651512444,
0.3034139872,
-0.240600884,
0.3780843019,
-0.4574123025,
-0.9591037035,
-0.0945961028,
0.4693353176,
-0.1216913462,
0.1245419532,
0.6055349708,
0.8628717065,
-0.0166895539,
0.1426074207,
0.4477650821,
-0.0300909355,
0.6024509668,
0.3739256263,
1.2300424576,
-0.1113187969,
0.333717823,
-0.1548829228,
-0.2812583447,
-0.238879621,
-0.6613830328,
-1.018723011,
-0.7397917509,
-0.0994330496,
-0.2620208561,
-0.0064462274,
1.2294342518,
0.5861145258,
-0.493360281,
-0.3381412923,
-0.0444934815,
-0.0844513625,
-0.253079474,
-0.1982230693,
0.1766633093,
-0.6828339696,
-1.0706114769,
0.6179423332,
0.2665776312,
-0.0330373123,
-0.3858070076,
-0.3349630833,
0.1624248624,
0.1043676138,
0.6859514713,
0.2921198606,
-0.9128650427,
-0.3749628961,
0.0518410318,
-0.2040017545,
0.2276690006,
1.1810472012,
-0.7417133451,
0.4999983311,
0.4313152432,
0.4964807928,
0.2374607772,
0.2449934036,
0.84977597,
-0.8491905332,
-0.0186024196,
0.1370720863,
0.4057325125,
0.5014067888,
-0.3975904882,
0.1304618418,
-0.0969460756,
-0.7452802658,
-0.7348508835,
0.5052787066,
-0.7014973164,
-0.3084000051,
1.2218489647,
-0.1011529267,
-0.0020974362,
-0.1559721828,
-0.7474415898,
0.0547324903,
-0.6182817221,
0.7349971533,
0.6091456413,
-0.5919731259,
-0.3787733912,
-0.3454540968,
0.7948168516,
0.4069812,
-0.6991055012,
0.1860153973,
0.6515508294,
-0.0036469484,
-0.0434034057,
0.7219455838,
0.0485443696,
0.49329108,
-0.3785850108,
-0.3946582675,
0.2188481987,
-0.6061486006,
-0.370362848,
0.1192961186,
0.354496628,
0.2120181173
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09949v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09949v2
|
Multi-word Tokenization for Sequence Compression
| 2024-02-15T13:52:23 | 2024-04-04T22:50:25 |
Leonidas Gee, Leonardo Rigutini, Marco Ernandes, Andrea Zugarini
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models have proven highly successful at modelling a variety of
tasks. However, this comes at a steep computational cost that hinders wider
industrial uptake. In this paper, we present MWT: a Multi-Word Tokenizer that
goes beyond word boundaries by representing frequent multi-word expressions as
single tokens. MWTs produce a more compact and efficient tokenization that
yields two benefits: (1) Increase in performance due to a greater coverage of
input data given a fixed sequence length budget; (2) Faster and lighter
inference due to the ability to reduce the sequence length with negligible
drops in performance. Our results show that MWT is more robust across shorter
sequence lengths, thus allowing for major speedups via early sequence
truncation.
|
[
-0.3901060522,
-0.2944131792,
0.4176096022,
0.28707093,
-0.6997465491,
0.1100012735,
-0.1748258471,
-0.3898389041,
0.2912452519,
0.0617453195,
-0.3426353037,
-0.1498409361,
-0.8824176788,
0.2436354309,
-0.4718913734,
0.6452864408,
0.2175945938,
-0.3017067015,
0.32204175,
-0.2302634716,
-0.6635294557,
-0.8364305496,
-0.3387140632,
-0.0296752732,
0.8402501345,
0.0856092647,
0.7457876205,
0.7254208326,
0.4878233969,
0.2947250009,
-0.0594116114,
0.3096688688,
-0.148951754,
0.1755981445,
0.3839973211,
-0.1710009128,
-0.2497391254,
-0.2489417195,
0.7360996008,
0.6049676538,
-0.0215325467,
0.2426644564,
0.001410856,
0.6135704517,
-0.5170618892,
0.1744241267,
-0.5358287692,
0.0518113598,
-0.4237288535,
-0.1150268167,
-0.5663903952,
-0.1408808082,
-0.1946547776,
-0.2622600496,
0.0694557354,
0.0846055225,
0.6249856949,
0.2137623429,
-0.6590409279,
0.2628414929,
-0.6153033972,
0.7045941949,
-0.7941146493,
0.5999073386,
-0.2332359999,
-0.0554898605,
-0.1162431166,
-1.0096964836,
-0.6007192731,
0.1490017176,
-0.2362879664,
0.1441481262,
-0.1168219075,
0.3638058305,
0.3641781509,
0.3386183977,
-0.5110983849,
-0.0597605035,
-0.3632790446,
-0.3776518703,
0.2432261407,
-0.0460482128,
0.0097057968,
-0.3570588529,
-0.5734608769,
-0.058419928,
-0.596167326,
-0.0691173002,
0.1889075488,
0.5035851598,
0.1811255962,
0.7980977893,
0.0035911214,
0.7238070965,
-0.5585092306,
-0.0221565571,
0.0114686536,
-0.2138471901,
-0.106623821,
-0.0204139166,
0.5859265924,
0.1458732933,
-0.101377368,
-0.1842761338,
-0.1411649883,
0.3201702535,
0.1097642854,
-1.2357523441,
0.0407191701,
0.4223175049,
-0.5924341679,
-0.0272181425,
0.6798164845,
-0.7169252038,
-0.2003200799,
-0.0604673363,
0.4239604175,
-0.4012436569,
-0.0912572518,
0.4849085808,
-0.7233261466,
0.0438758135,
-0.0748265609,
-0.3952632546,
0.0079822512,
0.7461687922,
1.4378443956,
-0.1421925277,
-0.1998474896,
-0.9852893949,
0.1440645307,
-0.2173397988,
0.6864339113,
-0.4181061685,
-0.6258094907,
-0.209245339,
-0.2297447622,
0.1001682431,
-0.0438151881,
0.3450214267,
-0.5460927486,
-0.069005169,
-0.2052755356,
-0.5503191948,
-0.1199795604,
0.1631580591,
-0.7393471003,
1.0385533571,
-0.1114582047,
-0.8447929025,
0.4766213596,
-1.0735092163,
-0.8956677914,
0.1228276491,
0.1210332811,
-0.2026600391,
0.6432289481,
0.3002359569,
0.5157960057,
-0.0234568082,
0.0690547153,
-0.2276526093,
-0.5557291508,
0.083555229,
-0.6652566791,
0.2788904309,
0.3086642027,
-0.1131756231,
0.283107698,
-0.7738508582,
0.0367362648,
-0.0767335817,
-0.7267622948,
-0.2635945976,
-0.0140491594,
0.1132382601,
0.4389160275,
0.0154660959,
-0.7763103247,
0.6800890565,
-0.378185004,
0.7484560013,
0.7853563428,
-0.1858675629,
-0.0201585367,
-0.3474093974,
0.5896404386,
0.1215404496,
-0.0444916561,
-0.4710457027,
-0.7565783262,
-0.5118625164,
-0.793089807,
0.558827281,
0.4058692753,
-0.8654624224,
0.3830662966,
-0.5238425732,
-0.2976361513,
-0.4621199071,
-0.4551136792,
0.1234994233,
0.1181577817,
0.5254015326,
-0.5309826136,
-0.7386033535,
-0.477964282,
-0.425994575,
-0.0738834739,
-0.3039891124,
-0.021043418,
0.3291468024,
-0.0796775967,
0.9694051743,
-0.7417658567,
-0.0618701316,
-0.1958885193,
0.6894577742,
0.1747138351,
0.5433130264,
0.0756790191,
-0.8836444616,
-0.1889136583,
-0.0948427841,
-0.0167806018,
-0.065143086,
-0.161853537,
0.1142021567,
-0.1137698665,
0.4173653126,
-0.8056619763,
0.6452084184,
0.7195529342,
-0.3354248106,
0.5644081831,
-0.2921150327,
0.1212238967,
-1.2688113451,
0.1806585193,
-0.3808950484,
-0.4112561047,
-0.651075542,
0.1436849385,
0.1087805554,
-0.2860516012,
-0.59212327,
0.3751427829,
-0.5211994648,
-0.1523545086,
-0.2430797666,
-0.0158473458,
0.2152575105,
0.2631293237,
-0.0400622189,
1.0560276508,
0.1294446737,
-0.6384278536,
-0.021263916,
0.2464272678,
-0.1717657298,
0.0230547953,
-0.685180068,
0.4033258557,
-0.1055165902,
0.5552746654,
-1.0520138741,
0.1207541451,
-0.4645097554,
-0.3062133789,
0.1904103756,
-0.1447801143,
-0.8985399604,
-0.7027367353,
-0.6070289612,
0.5160181522,
0.3891820312,
-0.6909433007,
0.5703618526,
0.0226749852,
0.2891333699,
-0.4485334456,
-1.0819052458,
0.2164929956,
-0.3165866137,
-0.5075777769,
0.5747377872,
-0.1512799412,
0.2938525975,
-0.3669932485,
-0.2147884071,
0.0022373511,
0.0271027852,
0.1127884686,
0.0292658657,
-0.2378821522,
0.3685848713,
-0.104744561,
-0.1023785621,
-0.557919383,
-0.8562117815,
0.9217076302,
-0.0010028174,
-0.3183032274,
-0.2362497449,
0.7291263342,
0.7678670287,
-0.4245875478,
0.8449551463,
0.8621723056,
-0.4105324149,
0.1515382528,
-0.3816558123,
-0.1312969774,
-0.4835276306,
0.2787024081,
-0.7191154361,
-1.0382112265,
0.5110838413,
-0.299836576,
0.2845367491,
0.5630022883,
0.2246583253,
0.5013390779,
1.169254899,
0.4078776538,
-0.1142764613,
0.4515480399,
-0.0295843966,
0.5593387485,
-0.7487963438,
0.1951820254,
-0.6387876868,
-0.3560673892,
-0.5143205523,
-0.6537063718,
0.3448045552,
0.0453447439,
-0.0002547066,
0.6551020741,
-0.6021082997,
0.4095146358,
0.5953377485,
0.1906339377,
0.2072969973,
-0.4833628833,
-0.2268737406,
0.1129830852,
-0.8845523596,
-0.2030784637,
0.7011316419,
0.1070541441,
0.357344389,
0.5132063627,
0.7476853132,
0.269089222,
0.2405855656,
-0.9167072773,
0.4124701023,
-0.4750183225,
-0.443531543,
-0.2126000971,
-0.4831721187,
-1.0853981972,
0.5465077758,
-0.1500575691,
-0.7007281184,
0.0000063381,
0.0460949019,
-0.4362289608,
0.5466222167,
-0.7948400974,
0.5788016915,
0.206698209,
0.0230678003,
-0.2175944,
-0.7174531221,
0.2942891121,
-0.2585601211,
0.3033666611,
0.0213251822,
-0.2855878472,
0.6997789741,
-0.9019534588,
0.6725730896,
-0.1535775363,
0.2342557758,
0.1484836638,
-0.0584310256,
0.598702848,
-0.1886377186,
-0.1031803712,
0.1349105984,
0.1771419644,
-0.5877557397,
-0.3840736747,
0.1758530289,
0.1735063046,
-0.3525686264,
-0.2090737522,
-0.6254778504,
-0.2042863071,
0.4303514063,
0.3263744712,
0.871594429,
0.0441108383,
0.1622350067,
0.0652012303,
-0.2871598005,
0.7367878556,
-0.0608093552,
-0.025729632,
-0.3915556073,
0.6502471566,
0.2622404993,
0.2549533844,
0.3952957988,
0.6770783067,
-0.4009430707,
-0.5410829186,
-0.4318245947,
-0.1606894583,
-0.6483843327,
-0.6228888035,
-0.648933351,
0.0865506902,
-0.5769333839,
-0.0761238337,
-0.3325950801,
-0.7971320152,
0.0383520499,
-0.1510718614,
0.4803905487,
0.7820290327,
-0.1495885551,
0.5590364337,
-1.1409378052,
0.465023905,
0.2420484126,
0.4542073309,
0.0990324691,
-0.2132084072,
-0.0703122839,
-0.4826485217,
-0.1059799343,
-0.8446230888,
0.2432544082,
0.4243825078,
-0.0625221655,
0.3589482605,
0.1937653869,
1.2737172842,
-0.8162107468,
1.1194295883,
0.4154896736,
-1.2281640768,
0.0879753903,
0.0310894027,
0.7632014155,
0.295684576,
-0.0687087402,
-0.9553313851,
-0.3655820191,
-0.4684343636,
-1.1843640804,
0.3350807726,
0.096240297,
0.2974773943,
-0.579477787,
0.206750378,
0.2485258728,
0.3408280909,
-0.465967983,
-0.2272389531,
-0.0760402307,
-0.2097060829,
0.1586094499,
-0.3503080308,
0.2841325104,
-0.2740773857,
0.6007816195,
-0.3603675663,
0.5638336539,
0.3385951221,
-0.203358829,
0.4531502724,
0.4420410395,
0.7077142,
0.2237738818,
0.1302395463,
0.3652470708,
0.1760873795,
-0.570430696,
0.1026311964,
0.2369685918,
0.2456583232,
0.2770834565,
0.4170935154,
0.585785687,
0.346657306,
-0.375570178,
0.6449263096,
-0.0812434331,
-0.1226898953,
0.4122146666,
-0.4716648161,
-0.0429675132,
0.105761975,
0.2558830678,
0.2301276773,
0.3259501159,
-0.3641147912,
0.5125071406,
0.4033832848,
-0.1600175202,
-0.1752539277,
0.7860827446,
0.1053340062,
-0.2222469598,
0.3376783431,
-0.0888460055,
-0.8885820508,
0.336774826,
0.4506624639,
0.7665750384,
0.0506888814,
-0.338128686,
0.1680541337,
0.2869946659,
-0.4110883772,
0.4040017128,
-0.2804931402,
-0.4269069433,
-0.7889707685,
-0.5256850719,
-0.1409998238,
-0.2263360769,
-0.3684558868,
0.2634284496,
-0.2191760093,
-0.4502085447,
-0.0393174775,
-0.3238559365,
-0.6309368014,
-0.0902207568,
0.0387440398,
1.1174336672,
-0.4133219421,
0.9921012521,
0.1882062107,
-0.2415865362,
-0.8619593978,
-0.0072561479,
-0.0103733409,
-0.4989016056,
0.3575642407,
0.788114965,
-0.2532360554,
0.1310906559,
0.0017047446,
-0.7223458886,
0.8728070259,
0.2364705652,
-0.4921935201,
-0.1212791428,
0.183613658,
0.1981703937,
-0.0203481074,
-0.0148237152,
0.564722836,
0.7311960459,
-0.0058962018,
-0.8265702128,
0.1935229301,
0.095319666,
0.1891408712,
0.7455546856,
-0.5345375538,
0.6995183825,
-0.1928177476,
-0.4722010493,
0.35444507,
0.7758091688,
-0.1224333048,
-0.0603087358,
0.619140029,
0.3913238645,
0.9126589894,
-0.3145806193,
1.0964605808,
-0.3928467929,
0.3355989158,
0.805521965,
0.0054420279,
0.842310369,
0.7486127615,
-0.2703050673,
0.175331369,
0.3721665442,
0.1514450461,
0.3090667129,
0.5546656251,
-0.2797197998,
0.0326704606,
-0.0301291551,
-0.1842667311,
0.2968444526,
0.0401719548,
-0.0347838625,
0.0622606575,
0.1286294758,
0.0914825201,
-0.1974786669,
-0.2344722599,
0.6162489057,
0.0931580365,
-0.4680526555,
0.2562952042,
0.2243398279,
1.1885465384,
-0.7593369484,
0.0640833676,
0.0878401846,
0.0247928761,
-0.0320475101,
-0.4569789469,
0.524056077,
-0.0005377472,
0.141740188,
-0.4406315684,
0.7659220099,
-0.4092958868,
-0.3633267283,
0.1090764329,
0.4538998902,
0.1216065064,
-0.3426223993,
-0.3036774993,
-0.0263906438,
-0.3565528393,
-0.4632647038,
-0.0717903897,
0.4388081729,
0.1345048994,
0.2306916863,
0.8804882169,
0.2064845413,
0.3967614472,
0.2739110887,
0.6770355701,
-0.8318653703,
-0.7136540413,
-1.0742975473,
0.7172241211,
-0.1111639962,
-0.3057878017,
0.4856378436,
0.6014645696,
0.3226680458,
0.0075017619,
0.6308315396,
-0.208830744,
0.0720468163,
-0.5930390358,
0.4101014733,
-0.5591769218,
0.0589601621,
-0.2398296893,
-0.6230460405,
-0.9552513957,
0.2953538001,
0.2427557707,
-0.1825873256,
0.7813290358,
0.3018127978,
0.0054459814,
0.06564188,
0.5408845544,
-0.1643477231,
0.6658023596,
0.2811535001,
0.4916753471,
-0.4708427787,
0.543541193,
-0.1934451759,
0.1106454208,
-0.0081165219,
-1.2659984827,
-0.6591444016,
-0.647895813,
-0.0605752729,
-0.3446265757,
-0.2360745519,
1.1185981035,
1.1299760342,
-0.5617730618,
0.1457894892,
-0.1243247762,
0.0016600583,
-0.5386685729,
-0.1867882758,
0.5081201196,
-0.3308548033,
-0.466465205,
0.5168418288,
0.4382841587,
0.1177167743,
0.0346656926,
0.0817399174,
-0.1480686665,
0.5321341753,
1.0060838461,
0.0311702527,
-0.574102819,
-0.71967417,
-0.2396163642,
0.2565135658,
0.4004267454,
1.3595479727,
-0.7082146406,
0.3040063381,
0.5133285522,
0.7961268425,
0.6211099625,
0.1219494492,
0.6437779069,
-1.3313225508,
0.5052797198,
0.1124103144,
0.7059221864,
0.2626247108,
-0.4107305408,
0.5485506058,
0.3588889837,
-0.2308860421,
-0.8517304659,
0.4401422441,
-0.8593716025,
-0.4999110997,
0.9873281121,
-0.0695955828,
-0.0145948241,
-0.0653490573,
-0.368648082,
0.5216430426,
-0.4100231528,
0.4810252786,
0.9990631342,
-0.086476773,
0.1241505891,
-0.3829676509,
0.2440017611,
0.4130200744,
-0.6928663254,
0.309088856,
0.235190779,
-0.1189299077,
0.2495496273,
0.4721220434,
-0.204161793,
0.071772024,
0.0639095232,
-0.1199887767,
-0.136699453,
-0.2615049183,
-0.4843847752,
0.4374274015,
0.2344025373,
-0.5529717207
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09939v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09939v1
|
Generative AI in the Construction Industry: A State-of-the-art Analysis
| 2024-02-15T13:39:55 | 2024-02-15T13:39:55 |
Ridwan Taiwo, Idris Temitope Bello, Sulemana Fatoama Abdulai, Abdul-Mugis Yussif, Babatunde Abiodun Salami, Abdullahi Saka, Tarek Zayed
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
The construction industry is a vital sector of the global economy, but it
faces many productivity challenges in various processes, such as design,
planning, procurement, inspection, and maintenance. Generative artificial
intelligence (AI), which can create novel and realistic data or content, such
as text, image, video, or code, based on some input or prior knowledge, offers
innovative and disruptive solutions to address these challenges. However, there
is a gap in the literature on the current state, opportunities, and challenges
of generative AI in the construction industry. This study aims to fill this gap
by providing a state-of-the-art analysis of generative AI in construction, with
three objectives: (1) to review and categorize the existing and emerging
generative AI opportunities and challenges in the construction industry; (2) to
propose a framework for construction firms to build customized generative AI
solutions using their own data, comprising steps such as data collection,
dataset curation, training custom large language model (LLM), model evaluation,
and deployment; and (3) to demonstrate the framework via a case study of
developing a generative model for querying contract documents. The results show
that retrieval augmented generation (RAG) improves the baseline LLM by 5.2,
9.4, and 4.8% in terms of quality, relevance, and reproducibility. This study
provides academics and construction professionals with a comprehensive analysis
and practical framework to guide the adoption of generative AI techniques to
enhance productivity, quality, safety, and sustainability across the
construction industry.
|
[
-0.2564719021,
-0.8501163721,
0.5001329184,
0.1157039776,
-0.2909465432,
0.3363751471,
0.3061523139,
-0.5592642426,
0.1307179481,
0.276697427,
-0.0970468745,
-0.5069248676,
-0.5938550234,
-0.0048316461,
-0.6242161989,
0.6336687803,
-0.1546383649,
-0.2538149655,
-0.6670779586,
-0.007071964,
-0.4503346682,
-0.5827823877,
-0.5093067884,
-0.0685345307,
0.000760972,
-0.1312458515,
0.7660830617,
0.6845170856,
0.4716073871,
0.4204553962,
-0.1113088131,
0.2370854914,
-0.2126204073,
-0.0504575819,
0.0354350694,
-0.3137450516,
-0.348987788,
-0.0424594991,
0.6813845634,
0.5573251247,
-0.3480765522,
0.1306221187,
-0.0278898086,
0.8126472235,
-0.5604299903,
0.388361901,
-0.5319366455,
0.0196565557,
-0.3690848053,
-0.4373495877,
0.0537310056,
-0.2230210602,
-0.1319771111,
-0.4703238606,
0.4967030287,
0.1111477837,
0.8148292899,
0.4801642895,
-0.1796345562,
-0.385273248,
-0.6704443097,
0.2192216814,
-0.5233421326,
0.3035107553,
0.0172142349,
0.148131609,
-0.1517926455,
-0.6398506761,
-0.4054241776,
-0.4746354222,
0.0871512443,
0.4988527298,
0.0559793301,
0.1275559813,
0.2182748318,
0.9466261268,
-0.7458743453,
0.3422822058,
-0.4738800824,
-0.0169420578,
0.6723712087,
0.2562360466,
0.5434846282,
0.0014919962,
-0.5152459145,
-0.0754147619,
-0.5605762005,
-0.1344765872,
0.5832833052,
-0.0284503009,
-0.1066777259,
0.5888113976,
-0.2997611165,
0.677041769,
-0.358581692,
0.0284426399,
0.3119349182,
-0.2679411769,
-0.345125109,
-0.1428572237,
0.7890561819,
-0.1852608919,
-0.2465128303,
-0.4010519683,
-0.4416753948,
0.3492779732,
0.5759640336,
-0.4302468598,
-0.0938581377,
0.2215894759,
-0.3566236198,
-0.411555618,
0.2496721447,
-0.4393360019,
-0.297863692,
-0.2657701969,
0.0106963301,
-0.1100413129,
-0.5028524995,
0.0816062316,
-0.5979725718,
0.5836219788,
0.3086943626,
-0.5808306336,
-0.2596145868,
0.7547060847,
0.785110414,
0.0048571751,
-0.1175040826,
-0.2136343718,
0.0627225861,
-0.5866062641,
0.8182318807,
-0.1646790355,
-0.7043488026,
0.3013581932,
-0.5702465773,
-0.167665273,
-0.6705157161,
0.3598207533,
-0.716483891,
0.0802179873,
0.4744245112,
-0.4567113221,
0.1028190106,
0.6041768789,
-0.844966352,
0.7371371388,
0.6403465271,
-0.5311475396,
0.3219968081,
-0.6162605882,
-0.3814985752,
0.6675562859,
-0.5554283261,
-0.8515867591,
0.4371289909,
-0.0697320327,
0.0259042792,
-0.4047594368,
0.3511200249,
0.1620280445,
-0.2273826301,
0.2133731842,
-0.4706507027,
0.7146347165,
0.4184025228,
-0.3533376455,
0.0688263401,
-0.5699728131,
-0.1068412513,
0.034624014,
-0.4742992222,
0.077136986,
0.0750060752,
-0.111734733,
0.0569400005,
0.3484005332,
-0.3534002602,
0.0152419116,
-0.615889132,
0.0608827025,
0.5545565486,
0.018030718,
0.2600532472,
-0.6029066443,
0.944878459,
-0.0875179768,
0.158786267,
0.0273753647,
-0.204238236,
-0.6363546252,
-0.3632086217,
0.4193920791,
0.5419314504,
-0.8849023581,
0.1504249871,
-0.3787404299,
-0.6045723557,
-0.776293993,
0.1337703466,
0.4105975628,
0.2364591211,
0.0153137483,
-0.436291784,
-0.5980895162,
-0.5258840919,
-0.1319250613,
-0.320009619,
-0.0569618195,
0.1038806587,
0.3160056472,
-0.2317587286,
0.6428813934,
-0.5477687716,
-0.4711963534,
-0.2885076106,
0.305357337,
0.2276007831,
0.4596527815,
0.5293691158,
-1.3044261932,
-0.3830952644,
0.1777485609,
-1.1016821861,
0.4378511906,
-0.4344865382,
-0.0318485498,
0.2073442638,
0.7540489435,
-0.6954710484,
0.5200537443,
0.2651842535,
-0.1794330925,
0.7063823938,
-0.1698316783,
-0.0026018436,
-1.0543169975,
0.2858103514,
-0.1392224133,
0.1293469667,
-0.4973790348,
0.5173177719,
-0.3227687478,
-0.3000175357,
-0.261582911,
0.2574929297,
-0.7258391976,
0.0027121552,
-0.3261601925,
0.0009970845,
0.0618966781,
0.4544531107,
-0.0116623305,
0.9082257748,
0.4351544976,
-0.5982948542,
0.4123775065,
0.5392737985,
-0.7237753272,
0.3418393731,
-0.4874559045,
0.2815040946,
-0.3439058363,
-0.0821634531,
-0.535759747,
-0.1052896827,
0.1674762517,
-0.621265173,
0.2417706251,
0.083563216,
-0.5657009482,
-0.4083795249,
-0.2516077757,
0.2485313267,
0.6359905005,
-0.3224058151,
0.7396751046,
0.3750676215,
-0.2633973658,
-0.4905809462,
-0.3954408765,
0.262761116,
-0.052427467,
-0.3487482667,
0.7273086905,
-0.0020986761,
-0.2010211647,
0.1648504138,
-0.2496694922,
-0.2747306824,
0.3994256556,
0.2221784294,
0.3559191525,
-0.0073204394,
-0.1466231197,
-0.3351207972,
-0.1332678199,
0.2747513056,
-0.0885296687,
0.2217942476,
-0.0282047745,
-0.2765099406,
-0.3526597321,
0.392386049,
0.7127568722,
-0.5452094674,
0.8381891251,
0.4911277592,
-0.2669371068,
-0.0957292244,
-0.4564116597,
0.5177204609,
-0.4711023867,
0.4699703753,
-0.5144515634,
-0.7267321348,
0.1435307413,
-0.3643010855,
0.2064168304,
0.5824403167,
0.5509374738,
-0.3453067541,
0.8978689909,
0.9057355523,
-0.1054350883,
0.6064196229,
-0.6399953365,
0.3240593672,
-0.7424054742,
-0.5429238081,
-0.5836375952,
0.1982645541,
-0.6429802179,
-0.1501874775,
0.5674561858,
-0.0130965346,
0.0453449078,
0.2252424955,
-0.5299831629,
0.0874260217,
0.5462965369,
-0.0086440202,
0.3434186876,
-0.0601126663,
0.0767617375,
0.6318772435,
-0.9437665939,
-0.4690057337,
0.5750139952,
0.1552193463,
0.3435739279,
0.2165971994,
0.5499138832,
0.598557651,
0.5367082953,
-0.7102048397,
0.3544297218,
-0.1159144565,
-0.4957352281,
-0.3747224212,
-0.4844993353,
-1.0132519007,
0.0807923302,
-0.2788800299,
0.0107026985,
0.1111308336,
0.2033436447,
-0.1977249682,
0.456582278,
-0.4072092772,
0.7440049648,
-0.3125950098,
-0.0153142707,
-0.2616228461,
-0.2687450349,
0.1172029153,
-0.1307828128,
0.2714996338,
0.0267985109,
0.1406280845,
0.4235146642,
-0.3934649527,
0.6209945679,
-0.0421042107,
-0.2998896241,
0.6890335083,
-0.2394292206,
0.5385037661,
-0.1351012737,
-0.3174351454,
0.2456409931,
-0.1942462474,
-0.2769285738,
-0.6473376751,
0.3652206361,
-0.7172551751,
-0.8233462572,
-0.4068113267,
-0.3123756349,
-0.2671823204,
-0.0504963063,
0.5285983086,
0.3247295022,
-0.6830871105,
0.1468927562,
0.2560075819,
-0.1155030653,
0.3361535668,
0.0329608619,
0.4735527635,
-0.4497538507,
0.9615813494,
0.0590916649,
-0.1327327639,
0.5001959801,
-0.2650478482,
-0.3778342903,
-0.9346023798,
-0.5549324751,
-0.1312873513,
-0.3461961746,
-0.4097552299,
-0.3374459445,
-0.6121254563,
-0.1489494145,
-0.2860347331,
-0.1251937598,
-0.0990665257,
-0.2781259418,
-0.1449116766,
-0.1805345416,
0.7082638144,
0.3610862792,
-0.0226649027,
-0.828899622,
0.4869053364,
0.3604062498,
0.7595481277,
-0.0504079871,
0.0914275348,
-0.6003652811,
0.0598451234,
-0.4086981118,
-0.3857314587,
0.3126446307,
-0.0019489438,
0.8219021559,
0.3601132929,
0.1352296174,
0.2050962597,
-0.2813617587,
0.6733676195,
0.2487153709,
-0.5573855639,
0.4969490469,
-0.3157997429,
0.2506019175,
0.4062638581,
0.1954778582,
-0.2868567407,
-0.3691114187,
-0.9688104987,
-0.9346911311,
0.233488366,
0.5388365388,
0.2590115368,
-0.0066046999,
0.2942144573,
-0.2185759693,
0.388441354,
-0.400025636,
0.0358615033,
-0.1857826561,
-0.2387022972,
0.1622957438,
-0.4374939799,
-0.1087593511,
0.2488678396,
0.6073540449,
0.0387750007,
0.4571546912,
0.0319653265,
-0.2552194893,
-0.0027942031,
0.4681392014,
0.3941096067,
0.9008435011,
-0.1579377651,
-0.2768862844,
0.1412608027,
-0.4358339906,
0.1911061406,
0.1814010739,
-0.3160113692,
0.0629438087,
0.4852629006,
0.7179316282,
-0.5098284483,
-0.5641990304,
0.5103979707,
0.3580317199,
-0.5096556544,
-0.8454968333,
0.1586152464,
-0.3451056182,
0.2603427172,
0.3588057458,
0.1119137779,
0.295918107,
-0.3865725994,
-0.1032230109,
0.6061706543,
-0.2295760363,
-0.1197262183,
0.7543349266,
0.4089488089,
-0.3751136363,
0.915371418,
-0.1917912215,
-0.438054651,
0.8674842715,
0.3335985541,
1.1030908823,
0.2542862296,
0.1977271438,
0.1988964826,
0.285815239,
0.1803484857,
0.2515431345,
-0.0420998223,
-0.8452771306,
-0.4416546524,
-0.6918898225,
-0.4034511149,
0.1311487705,
-0.5123173594,
-0.2618030906,
-0.4931445122,
-0.2051498443,
-0.3088629842,
-0.0122355931,
-0.778008461,
0.3351516128,
0.209491089,
0.7931509614,
-0.4768156409,
0.3500727117,
0.9817988276,
-0.7014800906,
-0.2921877801,
0.0041207783,
-0.3843404949,
-0.6034601331,
0.2996357083,
0.0081416015,
-0.2722938359,
0.1786276102,
-0.4813566208,
-0.5888789892,
1.1223917007,
0.3241621554,
-0.3810760677,
-0.2974214554,
0.3179151118,
0.5936415195,
-0.1168865263,
-0.187058419,
0.29794842,
0.1816087216,
-0.0432769917,
-0.5812592506,
-0.1217563078,
-0.5827795863,
0.5483956933,
0.3206959367,
-0.6845485568,
0.1437228918,
-0.0932159051,
-0.5266824365,
0.3520477414,
0.8861027956,
0.3304355145,
0.3840624392,
0.6556569338,
0.6073055267,
0.3974845707,
-0.0518776998,
1.1062947512,
-0.459944278,
0.0836763233,
0.6862971187,
0.217308566,
0.7310705781,
0.2273917049,
-0.367541343,
0.7374788523,
0.3997594416,
-0.2410146594,
0.3837594986,
0.3660824299,
-0.4641606808,
-0.0637724549,
-0.3600126207,
-0.5494508147,
0.5604243279,
0.3104526401,
-0.144915998,
0.1307287961,
0.0507017188,
-0.2561956346,
0.3273499608,
-0.20463866,
0.9450041652,
0.0473750606,
-0.6404877305,
0.3847547472,
0.0464511663,
0.3550703824,
-0.4491046965,
-0.403349936,
-0.2045406103,
-0.0107859289,
-0.1902130693,
-0.4001814425,
0.5291538239,
-0.1027340963,
-0.1226623729,
-0.5910716057,
0.2731853724,
-0.2175154686,
-0.3331489861,
-0.1420837045,
0.5296778679,
-0.0934069231,
-0.2129299194,
-0.5045449734,
-0.0799466074,
-0.2512487769,
0.2317913771,
0.1859917194,
0.3734087944,
0.037522465,
0.4294685423,
0.7423747778,
0.1112717763,
-0.2677942812,
0.2127536535,
0.9928790927,
-0.7305615544,
-0.5928781033,
-0.5355941653,
0.8590610623,
-0.1955418587,
-0.2957133651,
0.47713691,
0.7047424316,
0.9178872705,
-0.1917735934,
0.8098710775,
-0.2039429992,
0.0405872017,
-0.6648549438,
0.6792296767,
-0.5011299849,
0.2740029693,
-0.2644212842,
-0.809232533,
-0.2181320935,
0.2018641084,
0.0991054624,
-0.0254744012,
0.3353856802,
0.6808895469,
0.3767558932,
-0.2591434419,
0.3697312474,
-0.0381032266,
0.2460636646,
0.2144630104,
1.0606254339,
-0.4998008311,
0.6719193459,
0.0478816628,
-0.176805824,
-0.2493518442,
-0.623274982,
-0.4414719939,
-0.6565471888,
-0.6712902188,
-0.1176005751,
0.1266067028,
0.4712790549,
0.4538583159,
-0.7008488774,
-0.2745650113,
-0.4550559819,
0.1475086808,
-0.5562784672,
-0.2104031891,
0.5420710444,
-0.4114275873,
-0.5179406404,
0.4912719727,
0.3064113855,
0.2709362209,
-0.1996034533,
-0.0595919378,
-0.1508136988,
-0.0638394356,
0.5408601165,
0.3323838413,
-0.3963514268,
0.0922294632,
-0.2477860004,
-0.2394446731,
0.2099199593,
0.6987429857,
-0.5816976428,
0.5427793264,
0.6091403365,
0.8970940709,
0.501493156,
0.271917522,
0.7012624145,
-0.8175999522,
0.0039080507,
0.2596282661,
0.3083435297,
0.31031394,
-0.7563131452,
0.7287811637,
0.276294291,
-0.3020479679,
-0.4788355231,
0.2134446949,
-0.4989023507,
-0.2540569305,
0.4944212139,
0.1457955092,
0.0495867506,
-0.2633529007,
-0.0204612538,
0.4713576734,
0.1420482844,
1.0440273285,
0.2798211873,
-0.1978544295,
-0.1401840597,
-0.4313997328,
0.5808221698,
0.2684198022,
-0.907318294,
-0.2774040103,
0.6566179991,
-0.1964650303,
0.1517291665,
0.837080121,
-0.1764827222,
0.442599982,
0.2816026211,
0.131709218,
-0.2950226963,
-0.3924292624,
-0.217823267,
0.5097700357,
0.390537113,
-0.4207598865
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09934v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09934v1
|
Paying Attention to Deflections: Mining Pragmatic Nuances for Whataboutism Detection in Online Discourse
| 2024-02-15T13:34:19 | 2024-02-15T13:34:19 |
Khiem Phi, Noushin Salek Faramarzi, Chenlu Wang, Ritwik Banerjee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
Whataboutism, a potent tool for disrupting narratives and sowing distrust,
remains under-explored in quantitative NLP research. Moreover, past work has
not distinguished its use as a strategy for misinformation and propaganda from
its use as a tool for pragmatic and semantic framing. We introduce new datasets
from Twitter and YouTube, revealing overlaps as well as distinctions between
whataboutism, propaganda, and the tu quoque fallacy. Furthermore, drawing on
recent work in linguistic semantics, we differentiate the `what about' lexical
construct from whataboutism. Our experiments bring to light unique challenges
in its accurate detection, prompting the introduction of a novel method using
attention weights for negative sample mining. We report significant
improvements of 4% and 10% over previous state-of-the-art methods in our
Twitter and YouTube collections, respectively.
|
[
-0.8614369631,
-0.8825069666,
0.4910229743,
0.1873964369,
-0.2716388404,
0.2522664666,
0.0091402009,
-0.0853443369,
0.5460146666,
0.4540299475,
-0.6140905619,
-0.367382288,
-0.9431390762,
-0.0235210061,
-0.8194102049,
1.0232512951,
0.2481660545,
-0.0441032238,
0.0848987997,
-0.3291294575,
-0.4811359942,
-0.3725022674,
-0.3088738322,
-0.2112865001,
0.5063482523,
0.2632473707,
0.71265167,
0.2822473347,
0.3946004808,
0.3196561038,
-0.1535061896,
0.196059227,
-0.6437963247,
-0.0125478515,
-0.6311017871,
-0.3758138716,
0.1648002565,
0.1275109202,
0.4952694774,
0.557282865,
-0.1920018345,
0.3737092316,
0.0169997066,
0.5001285076,
-0.8717976213,
0.0745623708,
-0.8145907521,
-0.1148516312,
-0.2935498357,
-0.1314382851,
-0.0340459608,
-0.6746368408,
0.1116124466,
-0.5283834934,
0.3467411101,
-0.1997825354,
0.8990728259,
0.5129133463,
-0.502749145,
-0.4298698604,
-0.3792475462,
0.8850713968,
-0.7971000671,
0.3281184435,
0.7676116824,
-0.0011683804,
0.0986887962,
-0.8058055639,
-0.7941929698,
0.2622647882,
-0.0842593387,
0.1462122649,
-0.4438256919,
0.0113824569,
0.3986489475,
0.3595014811,
-0.4274730682,
-0.3596659899,
-0.2842479348,
-0.2952522635,
0.463416189,
-0.4807044566,
0.1403822452,
-0.582695961,
-0.3398266435,
0.1603336781,
-0.4721875489,
-0.4009192884,
0.3102318347,
-0.0932276174,
0.0578542501,
0.6014294028,
-0.1650113463,
0.2683793008,
0.2023753822,
0.0557753257,
0.2157588154,
-0.2250314355,
-0.189214617,
0.3423986137,
0.5888208747,
0.6021874547,
0.5375292301,
0.0734770298,
0.191250667,
0.4491745532,
0.4126547873,
-0.5211412907,
-0.1464950293,
0.1257039756,
-0.1306756139,
-0.3092558682,
0.0886598304,
-0.7046297789,
-0.6964142323,
-0.0992591754,
0.2610396743,
-0.6506807804,
-0.4645352066,
0.1441784203,
-0.7103487849,
0.4813489318,
0.0520145744,
-0.419000119,
0.2333250642,
1.0355001688,
0.9727435708,
0.0009369103,
0.1267246008,
-0.7454481721,
0.0474086106,
-0.5720984936,
1.0102208853,
-0.5601720214,
-0.135021463,
0.3261248469,
-0.1014035791,
0.2578740716,
-0.4301888049,
0.7502282858,
-0.3887099028,
0.304032445,
-0.5464530587,
-0.6673606634,
-0.5419943929,
0.6888539791,
-0.6950455308,
1.0153865814,
-0.0257178918,
-0.9755747318,
0.2944222689,
-0.3983360827,
-0.6206265092,
0.1385149956,
-0.1395510137,
-0.3529718518,
0.3854420483,
0.0364980325,
0.1470948011,
-0.1713534743,
0.5294225216,
-0.3234380782,
-0.1481615156,
0.4283324182,
-0.3606222272,
0.8786443472,
0.0858999416,
-0.5947728753,
-0.2441996038,
-0.6694466472,
-0.0679688975,
-0.035096962,
0.1856474578,
-0.6871473789,
0.2652183175,
-0.0369338319,
0.2739773691,
-0.2209268659,
-0.5956572294,
-0.1489583999,
-0.6266648173,
0.6988372207,
0.4279341698,
0.314624697,
0.1147814766,
-0.4550187588,
0.3331002891,
-0.3169687688,
-0.0553781204,
-0.0025559706,
-0.6063644886,
-0.5348675847,
-0.109401837,
0.1821216941,
0.2374016941,
-1.0475217104,
0.1297724545,
-0.1294119507,
-0.5244898796,
-0.602260828,
-0.0636639073,
0.3733398616,
0.5848458409,
0.4140947759,
-0.3338070512,
-0.6541342139,
-0.8614701629,
-0.8152945638,
-0.4039571881,
-0.097752057,
-0.2140685916,
0.3745909035,
0.2010907531,
0.9718387127,
-0.4532384872,
-0.6820757389,
-0.2357278317,
0.550590694,
-0.1197589263,
-0.0011122428,
0.5202556849,
-1.149759531,
-0.3956874311,
-0.3962275684,
-0.4418127835,
-0.1849104315,
-0.0819331482,
0.2114441097,
0.0709852725,
0.5049518347,
-0.5941374898,
0.4319022,
0.394508332,
-0.4034369886,
0.2431741059,
0.4326269925,
0.346521914,
-0.95683676,
-0.1163318306,
0.3103312254,
-0.5255507827,
-0.6471588016,
-0.044843331,
-0.1650135517,
0.3246193528,
-0.6844688654,
0.265019238,
-0.2282210588,
0.1480541229,
-0.332514137,
0.5603711605,
0.2901544571,
0.2560418248,
0.1733712554,
0.2962810695,
0.2472020686,
-0.4729943275,
0.4210635424,
0.4362608492,
-0.4208960533,
0.9705353379,
-0.4741841853,
-0.0859206915,
-0.3353454769,
0.1617994905,
-1.3390781879,
-0.3065284193,
0.3636949062,
-0.8851459622,
0.0346128456,
-0.4044789076,
-0.4901662767,
-0.0941227973,
-0.9667004347,
0.2790227234,
0.4532603621,
-0.2069308907,
0.6566722393,
0.9190104008,
0.0050127381,
-0.6276606917,
-0.9750359654,
-0.0066098799,
-0.3656415045,
-0.2433456481,
0.6257058382,
0.3245406747,
-0.7819465995,
0.0023256179,
-0.2099713534,
-0.2208870202,
-0.03867165,
0.0898934454,
-0.2206526846,
-0.0535603985,
0.3480441272,
-0.1733256131,
0.0835312009,
0.3537863493,
-0.1324157715,
0.661685288,
0.1047180146,
-0.248842299,
-0.5107999444,
0.1938829422,
0.1457095146,
-0.0050077154,
0.6121326089,
0.7833240032,
-0.469738245,
-0.1707616448,
-0.887034297,
-0.4985063374,
-0.4760875404,
0.4137557745,
0.2222743034,
-0.4175642133,
0.151397571,
0.0289863758,
0.2340292484,
0.3750086129,
0.6883972287,
-0.2978593111,
0.702611804,
0.3231847286,
0.1165911332,
0.5623098612,
-0.3144204915,
0.2221896797,
-0.451105237,
-0.0611983351,
-0.4567551613,
-0.4154157043,
-0.6877561212,
-0.4793775976,
-0.0489000343,
-0.4191243649,
-0.1746670604,
0.3389786184,
-0.4227188528,
0.5353775024,
0.304382503,
-0.2965426147,
0.465467006,
-0.0794477314,
0.53436023,
-0.553843379,
-0.6327851415,
-0.3685250282,
0.8392544985,
0.2138734311,
0.6010308862,
0.2963771224,
0.1554750055,
0.8723165989,
0.4791155756,
-0.9439413548,
0.4971419871,
0.2083769292,
-0.8492065668,
0.0186921209,
-0.2680520117,
-0.9211588502,
0.2707376778,
0.0018831865,
-0.6909527183,
0.2106506974,
0.2954749763,
-0.0266677141,
0.48786515,
-0.8191777468,
0.7046436071,
-0.01104993,
-0.4695463777,
-0.4655633569,
-0.494881928,
0.4968376458,
-0.0478869006,
0.6000401378,
-0.2385185957,
-0.1039565578,
0.6523522735,
-0.1904705912,
1.0207591057,
-0.0625544339,
-0.2822418511,
0.474199295,
0.2417844534,
0.2984537482,
0.0782082602,
0.1156531945,
0.5411701798,
0.1680034101,
-0.299918592,
-0.3496326804,
0.6034978628,
-0.2970131934,
-0.6508573294,
-0.5820478201,
-0.3210840821,
-0.3257087171,
0.1500500143,
0.2388090491,
0.3998256624,
-0.3157324791,
0.4019882381,
0.8635235429,
0.0325566269,
0.4544058144,
0.3839423954,
0.0840452015,
-0.2047546953,
1.1516256332,
0.4676414728,
0.2524132133,
0.4252269864,
0.1073457301,
-0.6368956566,
-0.2419334352,
-0.184462741,
0.3891213238,
-0.6182081103,
-0.2962346375,
-0.3776207268,
-0.1615814269,
-0.4524929225,
0.0516027845,
-0.4493219852,
-0.5670980811,
0.0575159974,
-0.1465714127,
0.2796515524,
0.6325221062,
-0.0228459705,
0.5136252046,
-0.4796644449,
0.4928022623,
0.0373683758,
0.3061520755,
-0.0889294818,
-0.7077940106,
0.0119332634,
-0.0196672156,
-0.8158259392,
-1.3808885813,
0.555069983,
0.1204747185,
0.4000014067,
0.8138929009,
0.4642638266,
0.4237121642,
-0.1320165992,
0.5649319887,
0.0998312086,
-1.0445951223,
0.422891885,
-0.2773798406,
0.1166177988,
0.3185304403,
0.9187568426,
-0.822734952,
-0.6657631397,
-1.0797861814,
-0.8360151052,
0.5726454258,
0.5356376767,
0.1484153569,
-0.3048979044,
-0.030977251,
-0.0388903916,
0.7264768481,
-0.9500184059,
-0.3281030953,
-0.3105323017,
-0.2736692727,
0.3653993011,
-0.2158280909,
-0.3753567636,
0.1027414873,
0.6795887351,
-0.2655854225,
-0.2205220312,
0.2903159559,
-0.390037626,
0.0879671648,
-0.0006571522,
0.2611787617,
0.8686382771,
0.0675392523,
0.2999878228,
0.2218232006,
-0.4800362289,
-0.2029391974,
0.0560584143,
-0.5236001015,
0.5288423896,
0.545363903,
0.3393065333,
0.3869882524,
-0.9450287223,
0.6182612777,
0.089332521,
-0.4348416328,
-0.5741742849,
-0.1667675227,
0.078086935,
0.1259727627,
0.4376134872,
-0.1127935648,
0.33351776,
-0.823251009,
0.3097876608,
0.6097492576,
-0.5614668727,
-0.3446701467,
0.4860946238,
0.0839826688,
-0.4679592252,
0.0820661336,
-0.1324068755,
-0.5825076699,
0.5250490308,
-0.0219035652,
0.5696464777,
-0.1260914952,
0.6516738534,
0.2389262766,
0.4751850665,
0.0252308585,
0.0807991773,
-0.1505679935,
-0.7765223384,
-0.6042308211,
-0.1874458939,
-0.2842627466,
0.334790349,
-0.8222332001,
0.4795031846,
-0.5901455283,
-0.4839209616,
0.2585209012,
-0.0619166866,
-0.2434596419,
-0.0284004714,
0.3574881554,
0.7171000242,
-0.7219116688,
0.3937361538,
0.5791702867,
-0.4590991437,
-0.2657750845,
0.4855974019,
0.4330321252,
-0.715793848,
0.1078541726,
0.2354773581,
-0.1222343072,
0.0958046913,
-0.4873255193,
-0.9451024532,
0.4313978553,
0.3425605297,
-0.4615502357,
0.0196906421,
0.1554899663,
0.3954364657,
0.2024904639,
0.1249990985,
0.8762149811,
0.6394937038,
0.1209966242,
-0.5641405582,
0.0579184145,
0.1303959787,
-0.3600044847,
0.3462843597,
-0.9736620188,
0.2151463479,
0.0615978986,
-0.5300529599,
-0.59484303,
0.4244638383,
-0.0929119214,
0.4057268798,
0.4967338741,
0.4370677471,
0.575879395,
-0.2404643446,
0.9785621762,
-0.0664952174,
0.3123387694,
0.9672514796,
-0.0979937091,
0.5472835898,
0.6350860596,
-0.1657278687,
0.5962464213,
0.4409286976,
-0.097040683,
0.4751572013,
0.0958247557,
0.1820326447,
-0.1657705754,
-0.3891713917,
-0.0180313289,
0.2436273247,
0.680190444,
-0.0823803768,
-0.4943291545,
-0.0049508102,
0.2496677786,
0.495072633,
-0.3966210186,
0.8934109211,
0.2099093497,
-0.9601063728,
0.7183343768,
0.1374903619,
0.5389724374,
-0.6115736961,
0.0015618351,
-0.2257742435,
0.1448616683,
-0.3391091228,
-0.9193142653,
0.7043828964,
0.0387568325,
0.1787547171,
-0.1362143159,
0.6148693562,
-0.3203140497,
-0.2535838187,
0.2339118272,
0.5405721664,
-0.0763098896,
-0.3330844939,
-0.7904735804,
0.0191468876,
0.1199480817,
-0.1865569502,
0.2193454355,
0.5791897774,
-0.1478583366,
0.827195406,
0.6045513749,
0.2159931064,
0.013732546,
0.147508055,
0.879827857,
-0.6559399366,
-0.3266469538,
-1.1460506916,
0.2129188031,
-0.5881250501,
-0.5238279104,
1.0329897404,
0.5175732374,
1.1433023214,
0.3280901611,
0.7226424217,
-0.1818662435,
0.6591421962,
-0.2546830177,
0.4277968407,
-0.6063401699,
0.1865910739,
-0.3813662529,
-0.6696436405,
-0.1713459492,
0.7370859981,
-0.584292233,
-0.1916697472,
0.7652952075,
0.6459147334,
0.0351906158,
0.1789442599,
0.2743720412,
0.4398594201,
0.3139122128,
0.1172319651,
0.872715354,
-0.3207044601,
0.9954275489,
-0.1256341338,
-0.0964546651,
-0.3292206824,
-0.7402755022,
-0.9682051539,
-0.6329783201,
-0.5911463499,
-0.720993638,
-0.0377429724,
0.7116481066,
0.5109494925,
-0.7348921299,
0.0836397633,
-0.1507288367,
0.6700695753,
-0.3532105982,
-0.3116300702,
0.2424744368,
-0.3267667294,
-1.0346751213,
-0.0864225551,
0.2362563461,
-0.3013333678,
-0.6151752472,
0.3804529905,
-0.5522594452,
0.5561169982,
0.5327663422,
0.3102558553,
-0.6971228123,
-0.0341081209,
-0.3062485754,
0.1936000735,
0.1581538469,
0.8865218759,
-0.8459354043,
0.2786266506,
0.5104275942,
0.6718951464,
0.5235416889,
0.5025060773,
0.474804312,
-0.9546095729,
0.2393517196,
0.5512179136,
0.2212817818,
0.6270843148,
0.0355867185,
0.4669415057,
0.6572430134,
-0.1044735983,
-1.0822056532,
0.4519439936,
-0.691663146,
-0.3890312612,
1.1464949846,
0.0827785358,
-0.3638507128,
-0.6273926497,
-0.3093163669,
-0.0408803821,
-0.4260370433,
1.2774769068,
0.8921350837,
0.3103731573,
0.0053525991,
-0.6117815375,
0.7086040378,
0.4261216521,
-0.6090374589,
0.0382938161,
0.5426371694,
0.330129683,
0.2765609324,
0.4090794325,
0.0965245739,
0.226480931,
-0.0684146956,
-0.2122577131,
0.2994739711,
0.1014232859,
0.1539911479,
0.2482241094,
-0.3505722284,
-0.1509679407
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09923v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09923v1
|
A Dataset of Open-Domain Question Answering with Multiple-Span Answers
| 2024-02-15T13:03:57 | 2024-02-15T13:03:57 |
Zhiyi Luo, Yingying Zhang, Shuyun Luo, Ying Zhao, Wentao Lyu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Multi-span answer extraction, also known as the task of multi-span question
answering (MSQA), is critical for real-world applications, as it requires
extracting multiple pieces of information from a text to answer complex
questions. Despite the active studies and rapid progress in English MSQA
research, there is a notable lack of publicly available MSQA benchmark in
Chinese. Previous efforts for constructing MSQA datasets predominantly
emphasized entity-centric contextualization, resulting in a bias towards
collecting factoid questions and potentially overlooking questions requiring
more detailed descriptive responses. To overcome these limitations, we present
CLEAN, a comprehensive Chinese multi-span question answering dataset that
involves a wide range of open-domain subjects with a substantial number of
instances requiring descriptive answers. Additionally, we provide established
models from relevant literature as baselines for CLEAN. Experimental results
and analysis show the characteristics and challenge of the newly proposed CLEAN
dataset for the community. Our dataset, CLEAN, will be publicly released at
zhiyiluo.site/misc/clean_v1.0_ sample.json.
|
[
-0.4085889459,
-0.746111393,
0.1475846171,
0.0691222325,
0.0982460082,
-0.2596338689,
-0.1288769245,
-0.4819728434,
0.0517185293,
0.3877732456,
-0.688668251,
-0.260592401,
-0.0984496921,
0.1299932897,
-0.2185948342,
1.0315502882,
-0.1446079612,
-0.016736595,
0.1356683522,
-0.2783686817,
-0.4092225432,
-0.2499937117,
-0.6078555584,
0.2933387458,
0.6377968788,
0.4591300488,
0.5513281226,
0.6155582666,
0.1383324265,
0.1863174886,
0.1140883118,
0.6282323003,
-0.1476773024,
0.1057498977,
0.0089220097,
-0.1301762909,
-0.3094870746,
0.1351422518,
0.5879423022,
0.7598922849,
-0.1806629449,
0.4843251109,
-0.0139820874,
0.3093542457,
-0.929633379,
-0.2276615202,
-0.6912067533,
-0.1452131867,
-0.4073502719,
-0.0030555285,
-0.235614568,
-0.4902328551,
-0.0993161872,
-0.9610036612,
0.0881679952,
-0.1316420287,
1.4616336823,
0.0992240757,
-0.8125306368,
0.066140525,
-0.527048707,
0.7909960747,
-0.6274026036,
0.0450130925,
0.2384595424,
0.5607706308,
0.2090940922,
-0.6518759727,
-0.4254261255,
0.4506686032,
-0.0933407694,
0.4499054551,
0.0621505082,
-0.1053330749,
0.0009165691,
0.3485940993,
-0.5380803943,
-0.1423475146,
-0.8282781243,
-0.3495508134,
0.6738914847,
0.3522089422,
0.643672049,
-0.2491445094,
-0.8632822633,
0.3323736191,
-0.7379488945,
0.5227440596,
0.1459078342,
0.6003496647,
0.1925278902,
0.5806751251,
-0.5573496819,
0.4703252316,
-0.5159955025,
-0.053722918,
0.4108682573,
-0.7997072339,
-0.2836546004,
-0.2389514297,
0.6887788177,
0.1221797094,
0.4656108022,
0.0884819701,
-0.2402673662,
-0.3409375548,
0.2340545654,
-0.8749257326,
-0.4749671221,
0.6904331446,
-0.5032572746,
0.0808341429,
0.3262547553,
-0.7170459032,
-0.3491050005,
-0.3294584751,
0.3577285111,
-0.3824037313,
-0.5560691953,
0.2658809423,
-0.2864217162,
0.3704880774,
0.6424434185,
-0.477402091,
0.2647114396,
0.4329835773,
0.4948092401,
-0.0418828838,
-0.3320356011,
-0.7789321542,
0.0169045739,
-0.3976366818,
0.5499715805,
-0.103713423,
0.3104735315,
0.1356820762,
0.0224458594,
-0.3418456018,
-0.6938958764,
0.6317748427,
-0.5667479634,
0.3922395408,
-0.4982591569,
-0.2691616714,
-0.0906068012,
0.3625902236,
-0.9805704355,
1.2658958435,
-0.2811898291,
-0.7912988067,
0.4205296636,
-0.6571745276,
-0.2820314467,
0.016628148,
0.0751860961,
-0.2328471243,
-0.1904819906,
0.4459935725,
0.3307107091,
0.070504494,
0.3176595867,
-0.3602208495,
-0.4612395167,
0.0836356804,
-0.5489114523,
1.2766902447,
0.6321039796,
0.0013431857,
0.2281402498,
-0.5875759721,
0.4163547158,
-0.0382637046,
-0.3846016824,
-0.5009928942,
-0.1203986332,
0.0422731452,
0.6844462156,
0.3409890831,
-0.7175171375,
-0.0246835537,
-0.0168810412,
0.1319560558,
0.7908065319,
0.0565737784,
-0.1469061375,
-0.4791977704,
0.2380617112,
0.1373385936,
0.1140202731,
-0.4812512398,
-0.4351691008,
-0.4819606841,
-0.7610151768,
0.1648896188,
0.4577849805,
-0.83029598,
0.0596616231,
-0.2622781694,
-0.3288091421,
-0.8982189894,
0.0383845605,
0.5529768467,
0.2609182298,
0.7686260939,
0.2963862717,
-0.205125466,
-0.9881130457,
-0.3784942925,
0.2744758129,
-0.3556693196,
0.3073813319,
0.6416812539,
0.6102309227,
0.8184959888,
-0.7851250172,
-0.2447790653,
0.0327487551,
-0.108174108,
0.0511070043,
0.1140073091,
0.1835154295,
-0.987187922,
-0.3093426526,
-0.1600970477,
-0.7487168312,
0.1055061519,
0.0168701615,
-0.3943833411,
-0.3711970448,
0.4117317498,
-0.3893145323,
0.1383541822,
0.311774075,
-0.3012630939,
0.9638707638,
0.172155261,
0.314722389,
-1.240989089,
0.6311681271,
0.1100823507,
0.1154798642,
-1.0744546652,
0.3696233332,
0.3727973402,
0.1365677863,
-0.7843848467,
0.5957219601,
-0.4289706051,
0.0611348115,
-0.0651039332,
0.4342724383,
0.3584787846,
0.5913366675,
0.0360669568,
0.9430760145,
0.1482132375,
-0.6479291916,
-0.0372038297,
0.4476715028,
-0.0905511901,
0.2228209823,
-0.8714097142,
-0.0771168843,
-0.1778176874,
0.093495518,
-1.1318799257,
-0.3564571738,
0.0208839402,
-0.3197454214,
-0.1778215617,
0.181231007,
-0.5073280931,
-0.2693169415,
-0.68187958,
0.3627457321,
-0.0929134116,
-0.6530762315,
0.0427026972,
0.2752367556,
-0.1936805397,
-1.0884697437,
-0.2694624662,
-0.3126713634,
-0.1607782543,
-0.7213091254,
0.0051473533,
-0.0400450081,
-0.0706387758,
-0.0921497494,
-0.454937458,
-0.5918425322,
0.3682054877,
-0.1361393481,
0.392472595,
-0.353930831,
0.3860810101,
0.073888272,
0.2825319767,
0.0597533956,
0.1111282334,
0.2281203419,
-0.0802817494,
-0.050316073,
-0.2209368199,
0.3763706684,
0.2858816981,
-0.9238132238,
0.5716792941,
0.4778671563,
-0.9303129911,
-0.3604545891,
0.0307564326,
0.0148716383,
-0.4281311333,
0.3738023043,
-0.7306904793,
-0.7455074191,
0.454515785,
0.0813404024,
0.6738179922,
0.4512660503,
0.2695956826,
-0.2119191885,
0.6681140065,
0.0549873002,
0.0289964359,
-0.0102536315,
0.2611849904,
-0.2415735126,
-0.8386526704,
-0.2221907973,
-0.8740997314,
0.0358926803,
-0.1549209803,
-0.0406033807,
0.2011043429,
0.3148781955,
-0.7518378496,
0.2500423789,
-0.3351549506,
0.3009342849,
0.6674025059,
0.2974300086,
0.4072494507,
-0.3941361308,
0.0063270782,
0.1866939962,
-0.2248194069,
-0.546721518,
0.8815920353,
0.165114969,
0.3225661814,
0.304145515,
0.4314984977,
-0.0719834045,
0.1375630945,
-0.3227801323,
0.2631944716,
-0.2730599344,
-1.131305337,
-0.7139851451,
-0.4450432658,
-1.0375694036,
0.7500123978,
-0.1182072684,
-0.7164542675,
-0.3365148604,
-0.1503801048,
-0.4969530702,
0.405816406,
-0.3768912256,
0.9641930461,
0.0315877236,
-0.1319830567,
0.6047451496,
-0.9556701183,
0.9788767099,
-0.1523845196,
0.2641393244,
-0.3307061195,
0.0628660619,
0.729568243,
-0.2643550336,
0.652623117,
-0.3909108043,
-0.2962204218,
0.3200365901,
-0.1804481,
0.0683102384,
-0.0703408197,
-0.0553793274,
-0.0134922797,
0.3685538769,
-0.6543022394,
-0.2267734408,
0.3146637976,
-0.793582201,
-0.3470081389,
-0.0830894783,
-0.4825074673,
-0.3901148438,
0.5493083,
-0.0198154803,
0.4041415155,
-0.1316960156,
-0.0127668427,
0.7718706131,
-0.4797379971,
0.4679633379,
0.2164799273,
0.0187459476,
-0.3360371292,
0.6654100418,
0.001311489,
0.3463923037,
0.3272238672,
0.0697073862,
-0.3289752603,
-0.1851499528,
-0.7795467973,
0.1168504432,
-0.6319469213,
-0.2694165707,
-0.5656452179,
-0.3981955945,
-0.2403930277,
0.2513536513,
-0.3543952107,
-0.3592297137,
-0.0156917926,
-0.1625637412,
-0.1176324189,
0.447537601,
0.3250209391,
-0.192684859,
-0.980956912,
0.8924726248,
-0.027021274,
0.3721322715,
-0.0972290039,
-0.1310237199,
-0.3261679113,
0.3642708361,
-0.2302487642,
-0.8451458216,
0.1175542325,
0.3739679158,
0.6355621815,
0.4565123916,
0.5128679872,
0.7374796867,
-0.507347703,
1.0377016068,
0.0062956428,
-0.8045143485,
0.4394640326,
-0.404075563,
0.3547966182,
0.8941787481,
0.5656225085,
-0.8060105443,
-0.3970176876,
-0.1415472627,
-0.8191605806,
0.6320242882,
0.1116514802,
-0.0129778208,
0.1667416394,
0.1087243855,
0.3406271338,
0.2967208922,
-0.4712431133,
-0.5698997378,
-0.3692482114,
-0.1289628744,
0.3357014954,
0.2981491983,
-0.3311074376,
0.114940241,
0.5588719249,
-0.1805959046,
0.1185989529,
0.0253563132,
0.01464382,
0.246008262,
0.4177381694,
0.4464364648,
0.3679041564,
-0.0024670514,
0.2625629306,
0.0119855423,
-0.44646281,
-0.0321285464,
0.1946936846,
-0.2690371573,
-0.1126575023,
0.1930588633,
0.0569129847,
-0.2573396564,
-0.6793669462,
0.7766209245,
0.076501213,
-0.5036969781,
-0.1550181061,
-0.1652400941,
0.1196226254,
-0.2832129896,
0.5420515537,
0.1662883312,
0.4784781635,
-0.2599354386,
0.5735613108,
0.2929386199,
-0.4883256257,
-0.1852709949,
0.9631012082,
0.138774693,
0.4978156984,
0.9810726643,
0.1115361378,
-0.3742786646,
0.6258152723,
0.2629740834,
0.490031451,
-0.0212793611,
0.244406119,
0.6778719425,
0.3079778254,
0.1983389109,
0.6884346604,
0.1101369783,
-0.8702991605,
-0.4417918324,
-0.2993179262,
-0.2279218137,
0.2937785685,
-0.9181783795,
0.2250778824,
-0.0787075013,
0.300691843,
0.1718035042,
0.318212539,
-0.3849931061,
0.6664960384,
0.2650091052,
1.1846188307,
-0.7950600982,
0.8766758442,
0.5831274986,
-0.665266633,
-1.1299886703,
-0.0774928108,
0.2031323612,
-0.4935089946,
0.2073613405,
0.5544087887,
-0.0862098634,
-0.5200169086,
-0.6733278036,
-0.7268471718,
1.1687065363,
0.0421908386,
0.3723524213,
-0.056255661,
0.1138319448,
0.3062448502,
0.0619206764,
0.3552303016,
0.1852337122,
0.5465194583,
-0.2859091163,
-1.011005044,
0.4207633436,
-0.7404540181,
-0.3754893243,
0.2549278736,
-0.9706130028,
1.0798544884,
-0.1991240382,
-0.5014757514,
0.3377240896,
0.6344594359,
0.6429302096,
0.3940132558,
0.3233285546,
0.0970308036,
1.0708866119,
-0.3467911184,
0.5729912519,
-0.1306811869,
0.1883341819,
1.2295767069,
-0.4333432019,
0.9093701243,
0.2503754795,
0.055751279,
0.2632962167,
0.740464747,
0.0321130529,
0.4056691229,
0.5214676857,
-0.2989113331,
-0.1938179284,
-0.0800041258,
-0.1994704604,
0.4605073333,
0.1206493303,
0.0139300115,
-0.3918666244,
-0.3112083375,
0.3574719429,
0.1722907126,
-0.3166049421,
0.4789455533,
-0.1602507532,
-0.6980421543,
0.307559669,
0.165348202,
0.6550659537,
-0.6427399516,
-0.2498240918,
-0.2644108832,
-0.0665785149,
-0.3591046631,
-0.876016438,
0.1828836352,
-0.1902513951,
-0.0620463192,
-0.1060618609,
0.5881882906,
-0.6223098636,
0.2315797508,
-0.0019198906,
1.0859183073,
0.2298252583,
-0.1725672483,
-0.5275866985,
-0.6130595207,
-0.108045578,
-0.4161517024,
0.1203297377,
0.6599720716,
-0.2009370029,
0.5630669594,
0.669718504,
-0.1586604714,
0.4540866911,
-0.0346272029,
0.7870807648,
-0.5520492196,
-0.2192288637,
-0.2887304723,
0.8354600072,
-0.1771356761,
-0.7617969513,
0.8921794295,
0.8885455728,
0.703104496,
-0.0167739093,
0.9655674696,
-0.0067620836,
0.6968212724,
-0.3623847067,
0.7599394917,
-0.8059328198,
-0.0783813894,
-0.2116754651,
-0.3732575774,
-0.3036563098,
-0.2312744558,
0.3255310357,
0.1212689504,
0.5984309912,
0.5150284767,
-0.0544290729,
0.3145317137,
0.3024369478,
-0.1952309757,
0.3397658765,
0.7624943852,
0.7724789977,
-0.6269977689,
0.8032313585,
-0.1895380169,
-0.1017337143,
0.4204744101,
-0.4217200279,
-0.6057834029,
-0.6478709579,
-0.033412423,
-0.3568741083,
-0.0302971676,
0.6020991206,
0.6071329713,
-1.0465559959,
0.0517142154,
0.5646746159,
-0.1160801947,
-0.7930998206,
-0.2867043018,
0.8007181287,
-0.5838665962,
-0.8494129181,
0.2635314763,
-0.1506243646,
-0.4708033502,
0.1714440286,
0.2230631411,
-0.4543457329,
0.2020900249,
0.3990372121,
0.3689157069,
-0.4390838444,
-0.419611454,
0.6235405803,
-0.5159710646,
0.1782926321,
0.4841945767,
-0.3373518586,
0.2842220068,
0.1667715907,
0.7441598773,
0.1196332797,
0.4602876008,
0.3905522227,
-1.1260173321,
-0.6763185263,
-0.083969824,
0.4374220967,
-0.1014045253,
-0.211691618,
0.4987907708,
-0.1406795233,
-0.2738907635,
-0.4397705495,
0.1677123755,
-0.8920925856,
-0.7097325921,
1.3214890957,
-0.477912724,
0.0678506121,
-0.6659962535,
-0.2519957721,
0.1107547954,
-0.3279520571,
0.2495007068,
0.6285315156,
-0.0551094487,
-0.0231441725,
-0.6726130843,
0.4648564756,
0.1813796461,
-1.3611010313,
0.4517322481,
0.6590336561,
0.3797561228,
0.0702359006,
0.8752788901,
-0.3449077904,
0.4934278131,
0.1359001547,
0.1997521222,
-0.1934628785,
-0.6784399152,
-0.2305166721,
0.7400218844,
-0.2596949041,
-0.6878709793
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09916v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09916v1
|
BUSTER: a "BUSiness Transaction Entity Recognition" dataset
| 2024-02-15T12:39:57 | 2024-02-15T12:39:57 |
Andrea Zugarini, Andrew Zamai, Marco Ernandes, Leonardo Rigutini
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Albeit Natural Language Processing has seen major breakthroughs in the last
few years, transferring such advances into real-world business cases can be
challenging. One of the reasons resides in the displacement between popular
benchmarks and actual data. Lack of supervision, unbalanced classes, noisy data
and long documents often affect real problems in vertical domains such as
finance, law and health. To support industry-oriented research, we present
BUSTER, a BUSiness Transaction Entity Recognition dataset. The dataset consists
of 3779 manually annotated documents on financial transactions. We establish
several baselines exploiting both general-purpose and domain-specific language
models. The best performing model is also used to automatically annotate 6196
documents, which we release as an additional silver corpus to BUSTER.
|
[
-0.3908416927,
-0.9068254828,
0.3157525957,
0.0301315878,
-0.3977787495,
0.1028480902,
0.1645713449,
-1.1811609268,
0.2489618808,
0.8752425313,
-0.0039774193,
-0.2033896297,
-0.6622125506,
0.2340245843,
-0.6834877729,
1.3295822144,
0.2301567197,
-0.2352312058,
0.0431873165,
-0.1104337573,
-0.8042414784,
-0.4698923826,
-1.1004263163,
-0.5497136116,
0.2630971074,
-0.0328402407,
0.4148583412,
0.7385075092,
0.5572918057,
0.3601191938,
-0.0129073318,
0.0239736959,
-0.2124781907,
-0.1240586489,
-0.4298222661,
-0.1785203665,
-0.5308403373,
-0.13329193,
0.6578415036,
0.9240999222,
-0.1600359231,
0.1995191127,
-0.316886276,
0.7524037361,
-0.4033541679,
0.3843118846,
-0.373760879,
-0.2038472444,
-0.5296034813,
0.2530563772,
-0.6793755293,
-0.3019620776,
0.2996439338,
-0.4173015952,
0.1369586736,
0.3308196068,
1.4213020802,
-0.0250759721,
-0.7324197888,
-0.4827739,
-1.0370745659,
0.3924883008,
-0.1313283741,
0.4338751733,
0.349042803,
0.3677315712,
-0.3648415208,
-0.8805339932,
-0.2047937214,
0.1805076897,
-0.4459468722,
-0.0552119091,
-0.7065230012,
-0.1027635634,
0.4756801426,
0.241241321,
-0.2600094378,
0.1665532887,
-0.7158268094,
-0.3221702874,
0.5857188106,
0.1981057376,
-0.2463525683,
0.0189291015,
-0.3495072722,
0.087810427,
-0.405036509,
0.2058831453,
0.1971940249,
0.2377001494,
0.1238767281,
0.1867261827,
-0.0913309529,
1.248232007,
0.1745614111,
-0.3682257235,
0.2820285559,
-0.0489560254,
-0.7019326687,
0.4385267496,
0.3487308621,
0.0446891971,
0.1133101285,
-0.3645086884,
-0.3895458579,
0.0416693352,
0.4506060481,
-0.7320397496,
-0.1952353418,
0.3757531643,
-0.2709365189,
0.0332738496,
0.3271986246,
-0.6607840061,
-0.7334939241,
-0.8104231954,
0.2679754496,
-0.3449835479,
-0.178291738,
0.1454687119,
-0.502804935,
0.2190338224,
0.3395671844,
-0.5479217172,
0.3638035655,
0.9532407522,
0.61159271,
0.3080988228,
0.0174558014,
-0.7138136625,
0.7544357181,
-0.5826653242,
1.0412544012,
-0.455835104,
-0.2951758504,
-0.2199224681,
-0.0192436278,
0.0609226674,
-0.9727891684,
0.4642311037,
-0.4324019253,
-0.1731621176,
-0.080923222,
-0.8734513521,
-0.0778461918,
0.3247289658,
-0.8269953132,
0.6125395894,
0.2956559062,
-0.7164366245,
0.8970015645,
-0.5616134405,
-0.6510766745,
0.6129837632,
-0.1088781431,
-0.5904448628,
0.1629784703,
-0.1889962405,
0.3868615031,
-0.2688255906,
0.4674528241,
0.0092732403,
-0.5512504578,
0.4474313557,
-0.0380925499,
0.9155061245,
0.0442521572,
0.0358225554,
-0.4739343822,
-1.1817045212,
-0.6354501247,
0.1227716953,
-0.3360409737,
-0.8065003157,
-0.2386810035,
-0.123307541,
-0.1472935826,
0.2443804741,
-0.5456497669,
0.4285073876,
-0.2454208285,
0.1274967492,
0.7180656791,
0.169166714,
0.030651059,
-0.3425472975,
0.1989028454,
0.4943722486,
-0.0355434716,
0.0661310256,
-0.4736158848,
-0.7841807604,
-0.8112047911,
0.6425943971,
0.5958955884,
-0.2523162961,
0.5309483409,
-0.4358209074,
-0.5467228293,
-0.6880786419,
-0.0433057174,
0.1136868373,
0.8817096949,
0.2174339592,
-0.4525778592,
-0.7437560558,
-1.3311634064,
-0.3620935977,
-0.2582809031,
-0.0963433534,
0.1976436824,
0.2807843983,
-0.6696395874,
1.0955402851,
-0.5684962273,
-0.6258632541,
-0.1646412015,
0.6748452187,
0.4410175681,
0.3242877722,
0.4475385547,
-0.8101299405,
-0.2553117573,
0.1566018164,
-0.4826867878,
0.0027088809,
-0.6199210882,
-0.3780580759,
0.5468404293,
0.5510408282,
-0.3857041895,
0.6427657604,
-0.126777187,
-0.5687296391,
0.2201653719,
-0.0396691263,
-0.1574281901,
-1.0216472149,
0.3152702749,
0.1629094929,
-0.5523612499,
-0.8009101748,
-0.6145146489,
0.2478058487,
-0.0070882654,
-0.0210739709,
0.4934515059,
-0.3605052531,
-0.347720623,
-0.1275720447,
0.0904805511,
0.2599914372,
0.129587099,
0.1866723299,
0.4579865932,
0.6090699434,
-0.8604108691,
0.440313071,
0.4173270166,
-0.3404219449,
1.302230835,
-0.3257068098,
0.0300830603,
-0.3589164913,
0.0867571235,
-0.4853370786,
-0.1603367329,
0.234304145,
-0.173186183,
0.6337760687,
-0.7240074277,
-0.5347947478,
-0.2319246083,
0.1724987626,
-0.1652453542,
0.3747949004,
-0.4197396636,
0.9674441814,
0.5949619412,
0.0231262296,
-0.4478506148,
-0.7037166357,
0.4779996276,
-0.3214144707,
-0.3363127708,
0.1412411183,
0.4548310637,
-0.3263601661,
0.1543693542,
-0.1321800798,
-0.1946370453,
0.2635916173,
0.2171407789,
0.6061896086,
0.1449263245,
0.1635573506,
-0.2909179628,
-0.500711441,
0.2043891102,
-0.4435121417,
0.0822992101,
-0.0974256769,
0.1848740876,
-0.0492671579,
0.281602025,
0.2519097328,
-0.1921367496,
0.7952288389,
0.5281393528,
-0.8404247761,
-0.0466324687,
-0.5926344395,
0.4110845923,
-0.4976746738,
0.0552898385,
-0.4574468136,
-0.4793682694,
0.4508058429,
-0.2220245451,
0.2120318413,
0.3344318271,
0.4388775229,
0.0202377271,
0.5045884252,
0.6454649568,
-0.2870509326,
0.5094925165,
-0.1454650313,
0.861082077,
-0.5300382972,
-0.449699074,
-0.7148244977,
-0.1989854872,
-0.4421781301,
0.117553696,
0.2345687151,
0.1003878638,
-0.0559311211,
0.7862446904,
-0.2940375805,
0.532017529,
0.475887239,
-0.4034813941,
0.3308900595,
-0.1181928217,
0.0767311156,
0.1526816934,
-0.0031249402,
-0.4841980338,
0.6232553124,
0.1463740021,
0.6650737524,
0.2468875647,
0.8076278567,
0.46872738,
0.4944499433,
-0.5687237978,
0.5341810584,
-0.0965180621,
-0.8983132839,
0.0338664465,
-0.7713465691,
-1.489962101,
-0.2297128588,
-0.0779960081,
-0.958478868,
0.3967263103,
0.1519178897,
-0.132905215,
0.0937367082,
-0.9643163085,
0.892078042,
0.0607161708,
-0.2265915573,
0.183132261,
-0.3612558544,
0.2609963119,
-0.2577910721,
0.3434025645,
-0.1565420479,
0.0891960859,
0.5735729337,
-0.2335655391,
0.5424992442,
-0.158019498,
-0.0308152139,
0.3048298359,
0.3369756341,
0.5596564412,
0.1056341156,
0.2361959815,
0.2123906463,
0.0433603302,
-0.4264297485,
-0.4220684767,
0.2096175253,
-0.2100932151,
-0.2407885641,
-0.8699616194,
-0.2432688922,
-0.1921488345,
0.3618590534,
0.0536719263,
0.5916763544,
-0.0775009021,
0.0805980489,
0.3907664716,
0.2948055863,
0.4591669738,
0.8616907001,
-0.1208306253,
-0.1747253686,
1.0377446413,
0.4751172066,
-0.2042734772,
0.1263568848,
-0.1754571199,
-0.3930929601,
-0.3965976536,
-0.6506649256,
0.2983542979,
-0.7475969791,
-0.5618309379,
-0.6086543798,
-0.0989628211,
-0.5005993247,
-0.3495377302,
-0.2001721561,
-0.2470858246,
-0.2158634067,
-0.2513629198,
0.3571003079,
0.9308205247,
-0.0538806841,
-0.1571278721,
-0.9934069514,
0.5461759567,
0.1945879608,
0.7533938885,
-0.2574542463,
-0.2291093469,
-0.6790320277,
-0.349568069,
0.1132946163,
-0.784961164,
0.306019336,
0.0739085227,
0.4640830755,
0.7017798424,
0.0116291558,
1.0140104294,
-0.1058305949,
0.3263574541,
-0.0256581903,
-0.9712480903,
0.4630160034,
-0.063394025,
-0.0991179347,
0.6257834435,
0.5275717974,
-0.7639445662,
-0.2758785784,
-0.845171392,
-0.841245234,
0.7223208547,
0.0810223222,
-0.2827138603,
-0.0901008695,
0.4658380449,
0.0704414099,
0.3360149562,
-0.5719774961,
-0.0704933107,
0.0752187893,
-0.1778735369,
0.2753000855,
0.0881148204,
-0.0137299756,
-0.2135321498,
0.8707806468,
0.1809882373,
0.1483711004,
-0.0269565415,
-0.1728871167,
0.0529817156,
0.0567379557,
-0.0210369099,
0.7242856622,
-0.4093893468,
0.0249215979,
-0.0644221306,
-0.7731056809,
0.0758085549,
0.4913572967,
-0.4098477662,
0.0160569083,
0.2980845869,
0.666752398,
-0.1863554716,
-0.8264140487,
0.2048251629,
-0.2012883723,
0.1904883683,
-0.7354711294,
0.0286350697,
-0.0283430312,
0.1393718272,
0.2688886523,
0.0622886159,
0.5266102552,
-0.7000235915,
0.1587623805,
0.0135970768,
-0.3093099296,
0.0088845175,
0.2785880566,
0.0763212442,
-0.3578144312,
0.9110690951,
-0.7151787877,
-0.1628155261,
0.5478550196,
0.4716639817,
0.7861450911,
0.2490169406,
-0.126526311,
0.3986964524,
0.3332175612,
-0.1953924,
0.0676793754,
0.2148721665,
-0.5805518627,
-0.2278812975,
-0.6101289392,
-0.6184173226,
0.1629993916,
-0.8437050581,
0.6420544386,
-0.5947139859,
-0.4178536236,
0.484926492,
0.0961425975,
-0.6727416515,
0.184097901,
0.2375239283,
0.5683438182,
-0.6885680556,
0.8488618135,
0.7121164203,
-0.4583637714,
-0.3798907697,
-0.3671894372,
-0.0109351231,
-0.2794606686,
0.2857093513,
0.4810707867,
0.2051051259,
-0.0802994147,
-0.3091410697,
-0.4937054813,
0.839861095,
0.3019301891,
-0.6429557204,
0.1378045678,
0.2610943019,
0.5206567645,
-0.2284585834,
-0.2808989882,
1.3105342388,
0.4927428663,
-0.0382374525,
-0.5436756015,
-0.3063585758,
-0.3062649369,
-0.1862802207,
0.7178083658,
-0.4838118255,
0.6741607785,
0.4338307679,
-0.1187313274,
-0.6469442248,
0.4382989705,
0.1020110175,
0.5936309099,
0.565133512,
0.9014168382,
1.0563509464,
-0.3223267496,
0.9965946674,
0.0585668944,
0.0678992644,
1.0777288675,
-0.5165105462,
0.4828373492,
0.1111099422,
-0.065830335,
0.6009293199,
0.4002417922,
-0.4730041921,
-0.0497432761,
0.2783826888,
-0.0908927619,
-0.1062305346,
-0.3264177442,
0.1161904633,
0.4136775434,
0.6217077374,
-0.0627912581,
0.0624321885,
-0.1911898255,
0.3570016325,
-0.2332982123,
-0.4597665966,
1.1046657562,
-0.0847666785,
-0.5621902347,
0.1596580297,
0.276971668,
0.3879734874,
-0.7264193296,
-0.1171192527,
-0.3968417346,
0.2304644436,
-0.2132396847,
-0.4939747751,
0.6534371376,
0.2799994648,
0.0052415356,
-0.1600374132,
1.009245038,
-0.1928420663,
-0.6178931594,
0.3246014714,
-0.0384989642,
0.3584108651,
-0.0369303823,
-0.3775572181,
-0.1152755916,
-0.3525843322,
-0.0478223301,
0.2950731516,
0.8069791198,
-0.248717919,
0.3869843781,
0.4574503601,
0.003867923,
-0.076905854,
0.0254963785,
0.6700924635,
-0.9584034681,
-0.5863441229,
-0.6232931018,
0.4593653381,
-0.5083509684,
-0.3200962842,
0.4272152483,
0.9415099025,
0.9261448383,
0.2229438871,
0.5528172255,
-0.0974387676,
0.8204517365,
-0.272472769,
0.3638356626,
-0.1957433969,
0.1648658365,
-0.3308458924,
-0.6937227845,
-0.1888515502,
0.6979746222,
-0.0406074151,
-0.1656509638,
0.3121934235,
0.3855410814,
-0.1004792079,
0.0505945347,
0.1317095608,
0.2994616926,
0.3912006915,
0.4237746596,
0.3867387474,
-0.3715108335,
0.6620954275,
-0.2921237051,
0.116332829,
-0.4857264459,
-0.9326602817,
-0.9200584888,
-0.5624933839,
-0.7020847201,
-0.5705421567,
-0.3092478514,
0.966599226,
0.3942177594,
-0.740912199,
-0.1665267646,
0.1247549132,
0.0206818264,
-0.3871465325,
-0.1826282442,
0.1785678566,
-0.1674662679,
-0.6480856538,
0.1820297241,
0.6063229442,
0.5680361986,
0.0426383391,
0.3073555529,
-0.0871037096,
0.4230776131,
0.4424566627,
0.3175047934,
0.0406010784,
-0.1767894179,
-0.3701218069,
-0.1273310781,
0.1281898618,
0.9343770146,
-0.7769730091,
0.3554004431,
0.1567976475,
0.8170875907,
0.6476160884,
0.1195512339,
0.2227338552,
-0.8901498914,
0.3680436611,
0.2999803126,
0.5171482563,
0.4064434767,
-0.4871116877,
0.8305979967,
0.4769079387,
-0.2886793911,
-0.8696869612,
0.0698198006,
-1.0093891621,
-0.2969542146,
0.6061319113,
-0.0169545487,
-0.3244041204,
-0.9614143968,
-0.2262128145,
0.1342240125,
-0.4330421686,
0.7286570072,
0.8602573276,
-0.1206011325,
0.1616931856,
-0.5156451464,
0.3856313229,
-0.0683900192,
-0.8645949364,
0.2562302947,
0.8560991287,
0.0190821923,
0.2125911862,
0.8524194956,
-0.14768444,
0.2638060451,
0.1181228533,
-0.0199450012,
-0.2325409651,
-0.4690269232,
-0.3864613473,
-0.0010125453,
0.1131292358,
0.211370796
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09911v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09911v1
|
Enhancing Large Language Models with Pseudo- and Multisource- Knowledge Graphs for Open-ended Question Answering
| 2024-02-15T12:20:02 | 2024-02-15T12:20:02 |
Jiaxiang Liu, Tong Zhou, Yubo Chen, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Mitigating the hallucinations of Large Language Models (LLMs) and enhancing
them is a crucial task. Although some existing methods employ model
self-enhancement techniques, they fall short of effectively addressing unknown
factual hallucinations. Using Knowledge Graph (KG) enhancement approaches fails
to address the generalization across different KG sources and the enhancement
of open-ended answer questions simultaneously. To tackle these limitations,
there is a framework that combines Pseudo-Graph Generation and Atomic Knowledge
Verification proposed. The enhancement of LLM using KG in an open-ended
question-answering setting is implemented by leveraging the Pseudo-Graph
Generation. Atomic Knowledge Verification utilizes atomic-level knowledge
querying and verification to achieve generalizability under different KG
sources. Compared to the baseline, this approach yields a minimum improvement
of 11.5 in the ROUGE-L score for open-ended questions. For precise questions,
we observe a minimum accuracy improvement of 7.5. Moreover, there is also
demonstration that this framework exhibits generalizability across different KG
sources. In summary, our results pave the way for enhancing LLMs by
incorporating Pseudo- and Multisource-KGs, particularly in the context of
open-ended questions.
|
[
-0.4630591571,
-1.149876833,
0.850174427,
-0.3496089578,
-0.162140578,
0.1417303979,
-0.2926329374,
-0.3921461105,
0.1841508001,
0.7308394313,
-0.2231060416,
-0.5750808716,
-0.3078037202,
0.3096106052,
-0.1507433951,
0.8679898381,
0.0209275186,
-0.0982699245,
-0.3721058965,
-0.0667575821,
-0.1033134013,
-0.5936965942,
-0.5348419547,
-0.224391073,
0.3765739501,
0.2699801326,
0.948004961,
0.4814153314,
0.2858586311,
0.3549395204,
-0.0301017575,
0.7489272952,
-0.6712555885,
0.1110878289,
-0.1146477312,
-0.3168664277,
-0.6241269708,
-0.3592801094,
0.7356210351,
0.7446594834,
0.0361953489,
-0.0690352768,
-0.174553737,
0.5571333766,
-0.7397034168,
0.1717954278,
-0.5232402086,
-0.2609721124,
0.033031676,
-0.1637155563,
-0.5098015666,
-0.4531354904,
-0.0421783142,
-0.5521522164,
-0.1363421828,
0.2106134742,
0.7076238394,
0.1260311604,
-0.4060302079,
-0.3645610213,
-0.844522059,
0.4654472768,
-0.6949632764,
0.6457591057,
0.4826717675,
0.3245740533,
-0.1586470008,
-0.9236704707,
-0.6003575325,
-0.5041793585,
-0.3878506124,
0.0706254467,
-0.2695576847,
0.3407469988,
0.3176563382,
0.4994516075,
-0.7821939588,
-0.0893486217,
-0.2463162392,
-0.5607795119,
0.4301344454,
0.1760350764,
0.6091276407,
-0.2123720348,
0.0670069605,
-0.2110376209,
-0.7008754611,
-0.190383777,
0.4331202805,
0.3125732839,
0.1470324844,
0.7029809952,
-0.461891979,
1.0287837982,
-0.2825401127,
-0.0609148555,
0.2430070341,
-0.5078872442,
0.0194016192,
-0.0162798725,
0.6872292757,
0.3300950527,
0.502384603,
-0.4457063377,
-0.0095352437,
-0.116088368,
0.1830349565,
-0.9919168949,
-0.3482712805,
0.2690371573,
-0.2784755826,
0.0037685593,
0.0399830267,
-0.8371891975,
-0.2950947881,
-0.1814751029,
0.5324867368,
-0.3351500928,
-0.509396553,
0.1212042719,
-0.2647666633,
-0.0141612915,
0.2340062857,
-0.5036199689,
0.2577789426,
0.4687391222,
0.8040888906,
0.3025310338,
-0.2468275279,
-0.2921789885,
0.4518957734,
-0.7722536922,
0.7359300256,
-0.4878597558,
-0.2173559815,
-0.1336604208,
-0.3346711993,
0.1377640963,
-0.6426758766,
0.1315385997,
-0.8593726158,
0.2780049741,
-0.4616878927,
-0.5024431348,
-0.1199010313,
0.4295716584,
-0.5044831634,
1.023378849,
0.4607108533,
-0.7353352308,
-0.1086891741,
-0.6961495876,
-0.438172102,
0.0500440411,
-0.2191912681,
-0.1616390944,
-0.0420613363,
0.4583955109,
0.1929679662,
-0.3435995281,
-0.0140336687,
-0.4794757962,
-0.206324935,
0.1934068501,
-0.0344067849,
0.5450183749,
0.1635595709,
-0.0500263795,
0.2881077826,
-0.7970125675,
0.3898068368,
0.1693331301,
-0.0456481166,
-0.5186035037,
-0.3083166182,
-0.7275468111,
0.1383089721,
0.32356897,
-0.4417080283,
0.0125297941,
-0.611938715,
0.4069161415,
0.8184617162,
0.2890716493,
0.3722595572,
-0.3179261386,
0.5118010044,
0.0585524365,
0.0498897322,
-0.029251596,
-0.3810946047,
-0.7099509239,
-0.2874884903,
0.1288128644,
0.443631053,
-1.1189283133,
0.3538864851,
-0.3409418762,
-0.5746387839,
-0.5938003659,
0.1835360676,
0.3896219432,
0.8502299786,
0.7930012941,
-0.0467158556,
-0.4782976806,
-0.928883791,
-0.1814923733,
-0.4512057304,
0.0371210203,
0.5571846366,
0.3387154639,
-0.1074884981,
1.0789058208,
-0.7930557132,
-0.0469642989,
-0.3212727308,
0.0127327098,
0.1458364427,
-0.0034857998,
0.3454271853,
-0.6512802839,
-0.5660445094,
0.0911126211,
-0.9077187181,
-0.1484673172,
0.248421669,
-0.1894272417,
0.0860949457,
0.5883681774,
-0.658356607,
0.2089705616,
0.3501873016,
-0.2318853438,
0.8149183393,
-0.2637604177,
0.4018089473,
-1.0802510977,
-0.0297498964,
-0.2399345487,
-0.3000638485,
-0.8657132387,
0.2707892656,
0.1179812327,
-0.0906708315,
-0.2659623027,
0.7150602937,
-0.4178329706,
-0.2027830631,
-0.4796954095,
0.4143362939,
-0.0904911608,
0.3216718435,
0.0567772575,
0.9630867839,
0.6937537789,
-0.6097584963,
0.4301236272,
0.0448542051,
-0.3493672311,
0.3435601294,
-0.5889587998,
0.4292743504,
-0.4189689755,
0.2282402515,
-1.065705061,
-0.1918252558,
0.3516109288,
-0.4896525145,
0.1198060587,
0.0071400111,
-0.6800299883,
-0.5100491643,
-0.2546435893,
0.3052584231,
0.6242996454,
-0.5352796912,
0.8626208901,
0.0287696421,
-0.0174941812,
-0.6532993913,
-0.3390702009,
0.0591380782,
-0.0406070128,
-0.7345510125,
-0.0105541153,
-0.3301621974,
-0.5263380408,
0.1828808486,
-0.0687533021,
0.1037828699,
0.0166766793,
-0.2212020606,
0.2678407431,
-0.4445163608,
0.185297668,
0.1779239029,
-0.0878881142,
0.1075769886,
-0.3708153367,
0.7581615448,
-0.1012972444,
-0.1930916756,
-0.2578487098,
0.1229869947,
0.4718847275,
-0.3877476454,
0.8777374625,
0.3367338479,
-0.2930138707,
-0.4451213479,
-0.5159099102,
-0.6544005871,
-0.5365824103,
0.6840527654,
-0.6074553728,
-1.1425168514,
0.592132628,
-0.2980555296,
-0.3208816051,
0.420453757,
0.6322000027,
0.1170334816,
1.0918693542,
0.2360607386,
-0.0843645632,
0.0164634809,
-0.0875924453,
0.5101628304,
-0.8733522892,
-0.0806093886,
-0.5184897184,
0.1512159854,
-0.2747173011,
-0.401768297,
0.5988944173,
0.3605326712,
-0.1267461479,
0.1272551864,
-0.3737893999,
0.5931125879,
0.1346277446,
0.2084197104,
0.3886257708,
-0.1126290187,
-0.2566408515,
0.2187018692,
-0.7401556969,
-0.3333534598,
1.2788273096,
0.1083562076,
0.5325176716,
0.2972836792,
0.5477594137,
0.1725510657,
0.2806410491,
-0.3933463693,
0.7881435156,
0.1213383228,
-0.7006960511,
-0.6680534482,
-1.0387624502,
-0.5821977854,
0.4649314582,
-0.0526867546,
-0.7927923203,
-0.2865305543,
0.2654153407,
-0.2706586123,
0.2990617454,
-0.6056658626,
0.7620951533,
-0.2105009258,
-0.1613294482,
-0.1817755103,
-0.4832514822,
0.502505064,
-0.1371384561,
0.5093703866,
0.2549262941,
0.1163871735,
0.5523966551,
-0.477456212,
0.7208756804,
-0.1865724772,
-0.2236711085,
0.4796976447,
0.1604171395,
0.738571465,
-0.0722252801,
-0.1500609517,
0.0523625053,
-0.221105203,
-0.1610805243,
-0.9551354647,
0.6129443049,
-0.9812828302,
-0.8601313233,
0.0103068268,
-0.7968291044,
-0.4508038163,
0.487247467,
-0.0157400426,
0.4124272764,
0.0742459446,
0.0813023299,
0.6770959496,
-0.2112861574,
0.0454823077,
0.4480728507,
-0.5205760598,
-0.7770035863,
0.9488250017,
0.2066447288,
0.6812503338,
0.2585614026,
0.4998072088,
-0.6457887292,
-0.6583217382,
-0.5490123034,
0.6072090268,
-1.0616286993,
-0.1961910278,
-0.8244929314,
-0.357924819,
-0.9883635044,
0.1041954905,
-0.1455272734,
-0.3564274013,
-0.1965422779,
-0.2636319101,
0.4288662076,
0.5782591701,
-0.1815480143,
0.2771987319,
-0.6863681078,
0.7305198908,
0.458417505,
0.2430171221,
0.2798941731,
-0.5864099264,
-0.261187166,
0.1272531748,
0.1000931039,
-1.0670106411,
-0.027054878,
0.1099435464,
0.6829769015,
0.4802641273,
0.4117469192,
0.9073095918,
-0.4254710376,
0.6783798933,
0.0817677081,
-0.9789423943,
0.48470366,
-0.2952378988,
0.1138881072,
0.3781684041,
0.6127384901,
-0.4557048976,
-0.8158369064,
-0.4720057249,
-0.6928530931,
0.6545963287,
0.1876647621,
0.1178172827,
-0.152686432,
0.664524138,
-0.2109182328,
0.1216742769,
-0.882332027,
-0.3865827918,
-0.3431925178,
-0.2066718936,
-0.1733124107,
-0.2514147758,
-0.184541449,
-0.2270743102,
0.8499400616,
-0.3103507161,
-0.0347197913,
0.2998774052,
-0.2265443206,
-0.2260083258,
0.184946999,
0.4587627351,
0.8672168255,
-0.1519723982,
0.4821648896,
0.266036123,
-0.1744658798,
-0.030765282,
-0.042535454,
-0.2573666573,
-0.3658708632,
0.4942375422,
0.784621954,
-0.2044973671,
-0.6092788577,
0.1970808506,
0.1831681281,
-0.0730250701,
0.0561019592,
0.2487819195,
0.259844929,
0.268940419,
0.2950449586,
-0.5231246948,
-0.0117978537,
-0.7538294792,
0.2159905434,
0.588609159,
-0.0706290156,
-0.1089893654,
0.4206659794,
-0.2483791411,
-0.3030689359,
0.8298899531,
-0.3415728807,
-0.6919376254,
0.4590550065,
0.8814615011,
0.4427351654,
-0.4228839278,
0.2029243112,
0.608526051,
0.5459215641,
0.1009435654,
0.3661986291,
-0.1396304667,
-0.9465343356,
-0.3527510762,
-0.516022563,
-0.4174641967,
0.23917377,
-0.4903138876,
0.1892063618,
-0.391000241,
0.0118963476,
-0.2540955245,
-0.0791993067,
-0.0698767006,
0.338588357,
-0.0501601584,
0.5973966122,
-0.854454875,
0.7742285728,
0.6152361035,
-0.4926486611,
-0.7665030956,
-0.0266909637,
-0.3942244053,
-0.9081116915,
0.3511056006,
-0.0082615353,
-0.2517410219,
0.3798715174,
-0.2407769263,
-0.9686386585,
0.9937691092,
0.3078576326,
-0.340043664,
-0.0372515656,
0.6034289002,
0.7303583026,
-0.1944241524,
0.4576455057,
0.4062162638,
0.6751809716,
0.2709001005,
-0.7255368233,
0.2077598721,
-0.0235536061,
-0.1953965425,
0.3969596922,
-0.4251974225,
0.77540344,
-0.274230212,
-0.0967370421,
-0.0968617052,
0.8823314905,
0.4562666416,
0.1534398794,
0.6952294707,
0.745149672,
0.8795162439,
0.1430463046,
0.9858718514,
-0.5585631132,
0.2462711483,
1.0906076431,
-0.3941149414,
0.4995364845,
0.1979715824,
-0.1754743457,
0.6294615269,
0.4926059842,
0.1497773826,
0.4531153738,
0.3027718067,
0.0051714862,
-0.5996038914,
-0.1063323542,
-0.5346459746,
0.2870534956,
0.2689848244,
-0.2666258514,
-0.4801365137,
0.030543115,
0.1402480453,
0.0405184329,
-0.3717436194,
0.9069219828,
0.0036325292,
-0.6534254551,
0.547716558,
0.0735232607,
0.1132673696,
-0.8122254014,
-0.1079433635,
-0.2077647746,
-0.0283093173,
-0.1093093753,
-0.5862389803,
0.197969541,
-0.0672033355,
-0.0364212394,
0.05158104,
1.024875164,
-0.4717896879,
-0.4451565146,
0.5644754767,
0.7203307152,
0.2082263529,
-0.2009419054,
-0.4203414321,
-0.0272481404,
-0.1076443046,
-0.2529220879,
0.2928333879,
0.3586281836,
-0.0619830228,
0.5792275071,
0.870901227,
0.2405451238,
0.015004036,
0.1659780443,
1.0512778759,
-0.3699114621,
-0.6134467721,
-1.0287253857,
0.279406935,
-0.1242075786,
0.0513004363,
1.0499045849,
0.6610683799,
0.8624725938,
0.1838130206,
0.7236523032,
0.0839103013,
0.5030952692,
-0.6152456403,
0.869009316,
-0.7014534473,
0.0602294244,
-0.3553317487,
-1.0445567369,
-0.2628611326,
0.526258111,
-0.4788851738,
0.3471072316,
0.9068887234,
1.1330509186,
0.1394657046,
-0.0146562699,
0.4803946614,
0.5754621625,
0.2374064028,
0.3641792238,
1.0443068743,
-0.0517815165,
0.6568854451,
-0.3976043165,
-0.359203577,
0.1451625079,
-0.5824850798,
-1.0559687614,
-0.4685995579,
-0.2887353897,
-0.6224526167,
0.115166977,
0.6389093995,
0.6012228727,
-0.4984821379,
-0.2115894407,
0.0678649545,
0.2233832926,
-0.1151357144,
-0.2352491319,
0.5894978642,
-0.3924907744,
-0.4049124122,
0.611258924,
0.2291908711,
-0.0593777224,
-0.4142017663,
-0.2315016836,
-0.0178371351,
0.2814465761,
0.65089643,
0.1356293857,
-0.537340641,
-0.4672589004,
0.1088467687,
0.1622231752,
0.1024537459,
0.83021909,
-0.6888366342,
0.5064780712,
0.3300893605,
0.5167965293,
0.3282713592,
0.1503985971,
0.1952535659,
-0.6149849296,
-0.1153578833,
0.3042324781,
0.1942382902,
0.1695370078,
-0.4436433613,
0.2986820042,
0.2584998906,
-0.4288354218,
-1.0027707815,
0.458021909,
-0.6115918159,
-0.7095044255,
1.2462675571,
-0.0400862247,
-0.2261874825,
-0.2321529388,
0.0249944199,
0.373552829,
-0.0639425442,
0.8165413141,
0.8585599065,
-0.3289316893,
-0.2958197296,
-0.2367285937,
0.3742861152,
0.2650226653,
-1.3201135397,
0.3469315171,
0.7730054855,
0.1849352121,
0.2907183468,
0.8565638661,
-0.1733335704,
0.2354079336,
-0.1658776104,
-0.0859437659,
-0.4196678996,
-0.6934178472,
-0.0430004038,
0.4763487875,
0.2388024032,
0.2250449359
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09910v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09910v2
|
DE-COP: Detecting Copyrighted Content in Language Models Training Data
| 2024-02-15T12:17:15 | 2024-06-25T10:33:41 |
André V. Duarte, Xuandong Zhao, Arlindo L. Oliveira, Lei Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2
|
How can we detect if copyrighted content was used in the training process of
a language model, considering that the training data is typically undisclosed?
We are motivated by the premise that a language model is likely to identify
verbatim excerpts from its training text. We propose DE-COP, a method to
determine whether a piece of copyrighted content was included in training.
DE-COP's core approach is to probe an LLM with multiple-choice questions, whose
options include both verbatim text and their paraphrases. We construct
BookTection, a benchmark with excerpts from 165 books published prior and
subsequent to a model's training cutoff, along with their paraphrases. Our
experiments show that DE-COP surpasses the prior best method by 9.6% in
detection performance (AUC) on models with logits available. Moreover, DE-COP
also achieves an average accuracy of 72% for detecting suspect books on fully
black-box models where prior methods give approximately 4% accuracy. The code
and datasets are available at https://github.com/LeiLiLab/DE-COP.
|
[
-0.1991206557,
-0.6965741515,
0.4841174483,
-0.2497340441,
-0.4843160212,
0.1194691062,
-0.083344005,
-0.3010993302,
-0.2774532437,
0.9008811712,
-0.2599906623,
-0.6059294343,
-0.7993633747,
0.0437733084,
-0.8137553334,
0.7181518078,
0.1337142438,
0.2331526577,
-0.3642430007,
-0.1471311748,
-0.3085153401,
-0.8403170705,
-0.5381798148,
-0.0827809349,
0.1862511635,
0.3467011452,
0.417927593,
0.77346766,
0.2043670416,
0.197327435,
-0.4200435281,
-0.0217630155,
-0.4369471967,
0.3313643634,
-0.214009434,
-0.5626538396,
-0.2189442664,
-0.0710637793,
0.7325893044,
0.0003988486,
0.0651354715,
0.026736442,
0.0513946638,
0.8240174651,
-0.9205700755,
0.006238929,
-0.7448862195,
-0.0721698031,
-0.1586049646,
-0.1422886997,
-0.5492857695,
-0.1571125537,
-0.3486280739,
-0.2173593491,
0.4449127614,
-0.3124936223,
0.7307670116,
0.2692714036,
-0.4206658006,
-0.3958179057,
-0.7300921082,
0.8210036755,
-0.8465070128,
0.6461936235,
0.8756690025,
0.0417330489,
-0.023664277,
-0.610951066,
-0.8349308968,
-0.3152076006,
0.103875041,
0.0759677067,
-0.3785764575,
-0.2540085018,
0.4390057623,
0.4023292065,
-0.5001921654,
0.1419554502,
-0.2149047107,
-0.1305928081,
0.7354047894,
-0.2097196579,
0.373652786,
-0.1768683046,
-0.4328250885,
-0.3277207315,
-0.6736866832,
-0.1004357859,
0.9505628943,
0.0185044017,
0.0207552519,
0.5894313455,
-0.1383088678,
0.5137088299,
-0.1352056116,
0.0656686425,
0.2051334083,
-0.333311677,
-0.0678912476,
0.0526972152,
0.7667531371,
0.2054249495,
0.5473544598,
-0.0391417071,
-0.3885084689,
-0.3904616535,
0.2754424214,
-0.8288812637,
-0.1821230203,
0.3211488128,
-0.239921838,
-0.3516415358,
0.0891543254,
-0.6421234608,
-0.4526965618,
-0.5376403332,
0.1816716343,
-0.4015167952,
-0.4871076047,
0.1995963901,
-0.4126499593,
0.2273630053,
0.0497428253,
-0.7171975374,
0.2191975415,
0.8109977841,
0.7792445421,
-0.2785616815,
-0.4058920443,
-0.7072653174,
0.2316124439,
-0.2602123916,
0.8454582095,
-0.534758985,
-0.4170521796,
0.0056654732,
0.217446208,
0.0371459723,
-0.5740859509,
0.5261192322,
-0.7133592367,
-0.0937123895,
-0.1713046134,
-0.9549226761,
0.0049651,
0.4031400979,
-0.9633432031,
1.2575604916,
-0.0307604205,
-0.9159932137,
0.2651952505,
-0.1840284467,
-0.2764111459,
-0.0567522049,
-0.2535757124,
-0.5747667551,
-0.0727666914,
0.3071639836,
0.3932477534,
0.0033075009,
0.3406830132,
-0.2028136849,
-0.331004858,
0.5450729728,
-0.6281145215,
0.9983637333,
0.2480306029,
-0.3222100139,
-0.1932076961,
-0.6682627201,
-0.0988194495,
0.2604798675,
-0.2912381291,
-0.7331084609,
0.0959637687,
-0.0221240819,
0.0130796833,
0.1738778502,
-0.6002691984,
0.1624922156,
-0.0786464289,
0.0546817891,
0.6209961176,
0.1821139753,
0.3752303421,
-0.4700786173,
0.7841783762,
0.0400102027,
0.303684473,
0.0017347041,
-0.505215168,
-0.3381974995,
-0.4084940255,
0.4979711175,
0.4651766419,
-0.4944826066,
0.6421644688,
-0.0989305601,
-0.5875912905,
-0.1162861213,
0.1807815433,
0.4190154374,
0.3038905859,
0.2544361949,
-0.3371079266,
-0.1873986572,
-0.6872922182,
-0.3909337819,
-0.1570144892,
0.0619770959,
0.1055465043,
0.7367898822,
0.0020501239,
0.9360035658,
-0.4619213343,
-0.2547256351,
-0.2432184815,
0.1648613364,
-0.1363191605,
0.7200690508,
0.8285164833,
-1.077147007,
-0.5582247972,
-0.2770184577,
-0.5159662962,
-0.2422131747,
-0.0066896393,
-0.0812994391,
0.2786652446,
0.7615460753,
-0.125550285,
0.6041945219,
0.4751943648,
-0.1697714478,
0.615398407,
-0.3051895797,
0.2735014558,
-0.8348127604,
0.218313247,
-0.4010367095,
-0.2663502395,
-0.466160208,
0.1381105185,
0.2738324106,
-0.0418564714,
-0.5315603018,
0.648661077,
-0.3122196794,
-0.0049918429,
-0.5097665191,
0.0834712237,
0.0913351998,
0.4473213851,
0.3229737878,
0.7257366776,
0.5339418054,
-0.4956322014,
0.087752305,
0.3213936687,
-0.5222533941,
0.4119673073,
-0.4166417718,
0.5488711596,
-0.2008016407,
0.0257885233,
-0.9552550912,
0.1501557529,
0.3617432415,
-0.3227934241,
0.1890548319,
-0.9882419705,
-0.8371988535,
0.1146947965,
-0.3362848163,
0.4079753458,
0.3932103515,
-0.3433462083,
0.1682040393,
0.4840580225,
-0.1681233793,
-0.8881083131,
-0.6242249012,
-0.1732611954,
0.0370089933,
-0.0211825613,
0.2016433775,
-0.4069990218,
-0.0177109167,
0.1045216769,
-0.3185448647,
-0.6849650145,
0.4027294219,
0.0031699275,
-0.0205469821,
0.0554720983,
0.1066984087,
0.299108386,
0.0648679435,
0.031525135,
-0.2392250001,
0.7199186087,
0.079548955,
-0.5885455012,
-0.0534482934,
0.3014695942,
0.5471410155,
-0.3813675046,
0.5707730651,
0.4341478348,
-0.5207949877,
-0.3305828869,
-0.3576916754,
0.0210529566,
-0.4338190556,
0.0995130464,
-0.0329492725,
-0.3243516982,
0.4963716269,
0.2587936521,
-0.1608024687,
0.1926077604,
0.4052851796,
0.3328753412,
0.6489198208,
0.4775704443,
-0.1074312702,
0.9646941423,
-0.562050879,
-0.0958602428,
-0.5091687441,
-0.2689194977,
-0.6756076217,
-0.1790461987,
-0.2717461884,
-0.4793223441,
-0.0001872773,
0.5268315077,
0.0575155914,
0.6117291451,
-0.5197556019,
1.0370018482,
0.7622473836,
0.2049879283,
0.8070206642,
-0.0953466147,
-0.1897938699,
0.139679879,
-0.4082263112,
-0.7055132985,
1.2609542608,
0.1875384599,
0.4915655553,
0.1371181905,
0.9205465913,
0.5843958855,
0.0935336724,
-1.0090631247,
0.4592985809,
-0.1389824599,
-0.9994714856,
-0.3345234394,
-0.3580208719,
-0.9530043602,
0.0689184666,
-0.0030630822,
-0.5547281504,
0.3446924984,
-0.0558729582,
0.2057772428,
0.4754822254,
-0.3243769407,
1.0191271305,
-0.5273420215,
-0.3437890708,
-0.1583385319,
-0.2821058035,
0.1071365774,
-0.4940346777,
0.3522264063,
-0.23563613,
-0.1077470183,
0.950740397,
-0.2319089621,
0.7385236621,
-0.2385265082,
-0.3361281455,
0.4858762622,
0.3121352792,
0.3750378191,
0.106306158,
-0.0968040526,
0.1765463799,
0.4230644703,
-0.3632681668,
-0.4499374926,
0.3496094346,
-0.4731218517,
-0.2492300272,
-0.4770016968,
-0.4078796208,
0.0098040858,
0.6012217999,
0.3666579127,
0.5823312402,
-0.1658178121,
0.1943112314,
0.4898383021,
-0.1457157284,
0.3533712924,
0.857657373,
-0.0852353349,
-0.3469954133,
0.6926145554,
-0.0756265894,
0.2560872734,
0.5561190844,
0.4531771839,
-0.3805395663,
-1.093244195,
-0.4765379429,
0.1451741904,
-1.1090685129,
-0.2988896072,
-0.4612627923,
-0.2564495802,
-0.3719691932,
0.2769017816,
-0.5231652856,
-0.305921793,
-0.306925565,
0.0229812562,
0.4534405768,
0.7973539233,
-0.0109321736,
0.2409514189,
-0.957426548,
0.3124478757,
0.0329576991,
0.4202275276,
-0.1577992588,
-0.7679585814,
-0.2770781517,
0.2477319688,
-0.4162388444,
-0.9210560322,
0.50970608,
-0.0368759595,
0.660169363,
0.3181686699,
0.4502202272,
0.1747326553,
-0.4534169137,
0.7133733034,
-0.2044270486,
-1.0425453186,
0.5955889821,
-0.232139498,
-0.1494208872,
0.721260488,
0.7350203395,
-0.2442490757,
-0.7950050235,
-0.8564612269,
-0.6315589547,
0.5855320692,
0.2840770781,
0.2323831618,
-0.1389929652,
0.2783201337,
0.1709574014,
0.4468596876,
-0.9177924395,
-0.1845781505,
-0.0304324888,
-0.2524229884,
0.0031674507,
-0.2181271762,
-0.0283605531,
-0.1377035975,
0.4845815599,
-0.0371635109,
0.1028678417,
0.3211123943,
-0.5268108249,
0.0628633723,
0.293870002,
0.4515507817,
0.7275798917,
-0.3676340878,
0.1607676297,
-0.2372839898,
-0.6589075327,
0.2146450877,
0.0733440816,
-0.2309479564,
0.1474078,
0.4754838347,
0.2681287825,
0.1242656484,
-0.9951661825,
1.003051281,
-0.0609250441,
-0.2369883806,
-0.427187115,
0.1330211312,
-0.2413651645,
0.3500047624,
0.1427680254,
-0.160257712,
0.1834870577,
-0.3284918666,
0.5154163241,
0.2911425531,
-0.1796947718,
-0.2782096565,
0.6054583192,
-0.2062659413,
-0.2254461497,
0.377070874,
-0.2784482837,
-0.8346108794,
0.7933012843,
0.3388794065,
0.9515789151,
-0.0367747284,
0.2020441294,
0.2346859574,
0.2788703144,
-0.3670347333,
0.246907413,
-0.21031636,
-0.8758155704,
-0.3191652,
-0.3785724342,
-0.5824858546,
0.5128523707,
-0.8491259813,
0.4500443637,
-0.3090215921,
0.0447019562,
-0.1172272563,
-0.1186211333,
-0.5395531058,
-0.0203253385,
0.3178786635,
0.8214694858,
-0.9674988985,
1.152328968,
0.4607056379,
-0.5890356898,
-0.5329790711,
0.2819095254,
-0.2562070489,
-0.5454987884,
0.7163195014,
-0.0074703041,
-0.1203160137,
0.1471329927,
-0.57313627,
-0.6050566435,
0.8035559058,
0.6621379852,
-0.5743134022,
0.2024066299,
0.1093468368,
0.3186925352,
0.0803929269,
0.0835234076,
0.5732631683,
0.2347343117,
-0.0148169547,
-0.5752974153,
-0.0975158215,
-0.1332104802,
-0.4939605594,
0.133988753,
-0.171746552,
0.6465512514,
0.2053554803,
-0.2005018294,
0.1672216207,
-0.0348037109,
0.2004910707,
0.4705068767,
0.7022413611,
0.3926205635,
0.8786905408,
0.2637545466,
1.0913589001,
-0.3295876384,
0.6561024189,
1.0894492865,
-0.2148735821,
0.9878239632,
0.262072295,
-0.0514462516,
0.3656519055,
0.271528393,
-0.265219748,
0.6455639005,
0.3193522394,
-0.1818791479,
-0.139365226,
0.0765665248,
-0.2364423722,
0.427431643,
0.0671779588,
-0.295609802,
0.007156278,
0.0856046975,
-0.0209979936,
0.1954315752,
0.0032428508,
0.8320502639,
0.0137265399,
-0.6237927675,
0.8809559941,
-0.0572041944,
0.3373918831,
-0.5381878018,
0.0749699399,
-0.4322083592,
0.2294050753,
0.0408284403,
-0.8168641329,
0.3676663041,
0.3567726314,
-0.09284807,
-0.3410584629,
0.7453149557,
-0.6900652051,
-0.3473489583,
0.3989135027,
0.6531707048,
0.3633316457,
-0.4896634221,
-0.727411449,
0.0372500196,
-0.1752773821,
-0.1486966908,
0.3203742504,
0.5097424388,
0.0419857651,
0.5501301885,
0.6091088653,
0.1312522739,
-0.0146238962,
0.12370193,
0.7103299499,
-0.53115803,
-0.4906237125,
-0.9175187349,
0.2237440497,
-0.0990858451,
-0.1388383359,
0.6578071117,
0.9091800451,
1.1955631971,
-0.3046267629,
0.7905412912,
0.1237235963,
0.2389366925,
-0.9388693571,
0.8605213165,
-0.6547966003,
0.4522050917,
-0.4111935198,
-0.6620627046,
-0.1695836037,
0.4243770838,
-0.2444580197,
-0.2910194695,
0.8941276073,
0.9209212661,
-0.4592942894,
0.0640432537,
0.2842941582,
-0.4305640459,
0.41236341,
0.1398770213,
1.2433178425,
-0.5057499409,
0.8520190716,
-0.6050272584,
-0.0437172279,
-0.0345091261,
-1.2590979338,
-1.0785290003,
-0.6022841334,
-0.6009987593,
-0.1874719411,
-0.1743136793,
0.554164052,
0.5421845317,
-0.9071314335,
-0.2697908878,
-0.3217557669,
0.4655696452,
-0.3760911822,
-0.1680677533,
0.4129835367,
-0.1473804265,
-1.0196778774,
0.4531327784,
-0.3881399035,
0.4487849474,
0.1071967855,
0.0361070856,
-0.2968279123,
-0.068995595,
0.2039465159,
0.1023752019,
-0.4316584468,
-0.1974201351,
-0.1116256639,
-0.0731977671,
0.0135049308,
1.2151507139,
-0.472515285,
0.414888531,
0.5776575804,
0.7424601912,
0.7790894508,
-0.0193519574,
0.3640075922,
-1.2003148794,
0.406231612,
0.4078502953,
0.3514639437,
0.2153196782,
-0.3189609647,
0.5403782725,
0.4870525301,
-0.5743234158,
-1.0180579424,
0.2337628305,
-0.967787683,
-0.6380549669,
1.2721842527,
-0.3899861276,
-0.0414992012,
-0.1702717394,
-0.2057254612,
0.4461942613,
-0.3319878578,
0.4798046649,
0.6863051057,
0.3824568391,
-0.1071258113,
-0.8579813838,
0.430108428,
0.1240662634,
-0.7082827091,
0.5160239935,
0.4686654508,
0.5857735872,
-0.0771515965,
0.593382895,
-0.2572780252,
0.2487394214,
-0.0870573223,
-0.0510539636,
-0.4209000766,
-0.3483368158,
-0.5839009881,
-0.1488269269,
0.1078492254,
-0.3785805702
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09906v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09906v2
|
Generative Representational Instruction Tuning
| 2024-02-15T12:12:19 | 2024-04-17T17:12:05 |
Niklas Muennighoff, Hongjin Su, Liang Wang, Nan Yang, Furu Wei, Tao Yu, Amanpreet Singh, Douwe Kiela
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
All text-based language problems can be reduced to either generation or
embedding. Current models only perform well at one or the other. We introduce
generative representational instruction tuning (GRIT) whereby a large language
model is trained to handle both generative and embedding tasks by
distinguishing between them through instructions. Compared to other open
models, our resulting GritLM 7B sets a new state of the art on the Massive Text
Embedding Benchmark (MTEB) and outperforms all models up to its size on a range
of generative tasks. By scaling up further, GritLM 8x7B outperforms all open
generative language models that we tried while still being among the best
embedding models. Notably, we find that GRIT matches training on only
generative or embedding data, thus we can unify both at no performance loss.
Among other benefits, the unification via GRIT speeds up Retrieval-Augmented
Generation (RAG) by > 60% for long documents, by no longer requiring separate
retrieval and generation models. Models, code, etc. are freely available at
https://github.com/ContextualAI/gritlm.
|
[
-0.1811496466,
-0.7894692421,
0.6015275121,
0.1817649007,
-0.3676475585,
0.2737578452,
-0.4446362257,
-0.1794075966,
0.0127319014,
0.497456789,
-0.4117836952,
-0.7794573903,
-0.7218131423,
-0.3629839122,
-0.3135606945,
1.1814607382,
0.069128193,
0.4751634896,
-0.4490908086,
-0.3554735184,
-0.6599791646,
-0.1124208644,
-0.6818789244,
-0.5156189203,
0.4373143613,
0.2644966543,
0.8612146974,
1.1810318232,
0.7199145555,
0.2884842455,
-0.0606321171,
0.3178191185,
-0.8069083691,
0.1886001676,
-0.4092376232,
-0.4566420019,
-0.4710097909,
-0.236489296,
0.626318872,
0.6391382217,
-0.3291617036,
0.0192036442,
0.0346908681,
0.6228512526,
-0.8114526272,
0.1421492249,
-0.7657657862,
-0.2003019452,
-0.2621982098,
-0.2609307766,
-0.6216847301,
-0.2554131448,
-0.3834209442,
-0.4519991577,
0.8716710806,
0.2007170022,
1.0524338484,
0.2407567203,
-0.1134212688,
-0.3848380744,
-0.584508121,
0.7914196253,
-0.3208605945,
0.4271315634,
0.4232008457,
0.2856893241,
-0.0581079088,
-0.8475432992,
-0.1725487709,
-0.0009545392,
0.1711263359,
0.0321638882,
0.0857729092,
0.4062136412,
0.2738011777,
0.891371727,
-0.6113762856,
0.2236841619,
-0.3122408986,
-0.1376147866,
0.4885295331,
0.2416271865,
0.1946278214,
0.1267018616,
-0.3712119758,
-0.5603047013,
-0.8734222054,
-0.2766692638,
0.2786497176,
0.3483195305,
-0.0382265374,
0.3132841885,
0.1179546639,
0.8320254683,
0.0185483079,
-0.2012888491,
0.162887916,
-0.0781718418,
-0.3290603757,
0.0768060163,
0.5529455543,
0.3606341481,
-0.0175319668,
-0.4050630033,
-0.7674525976,
0.0728022307,
0.6074619293,
-0.8580091,
-0.1532642841,
-0.2056714743,
-0.3682727516,
-0.1784730852,
0.1448780447,
-0.6938540936,
-0.5402460098,
-0.478677094,
0.5630332828,
-0.5316077471,
-0.0171492752,
0.0515098609,
-0.2530459464,
0.4108846188,
0.3331823647,
-1.3130321503,
0.1404228657,
0.9632902145,
0.9809351563,
0.0727176443,
-0.2982615232,
-0.6858375072,
0.212807253,
-0.5439792275,
0.9378918409,
-0.8075910807,
-0.5208519101,
0.1516832709,
-0.0233440902,
-0.1452162117,
-0.6703913808,
0.3407834172,
-0.5242459774,
-0.114519909,
-0.4498512745,
-0.5634946823,
-0.0701203048,
0.1384137124,
-0.7257249355,
1.2220548391,
0.5456187129,
-0.4347725809,
0.3897614777,
-0.4826064706,
-0.4608499408,
0.2698846161,
-0.2811509073,
-0.5192221403,
0.5096039772,
0.2182445228,
0.2033220977,
-0.6455957294,
0.5067730546,
-0.344512403,
-0.6540468335,
-0.3644162714,
-0.3583681881,
0.4619891346,
0.2115394175,
-0.4719964266,
0.3651148379,
-0.4012170732,
0.1132578626,
0.1419271231,
-0.212498188,
-0.136208266,
-0.1874697655,
0.2215087563,
-0.015995482,
0.3127061725,
-0.4709545672,
0.177700147,
-0.2674282491,
0.3482957184,
0.92210567,
-0.3077648282,
0.4220895469,
-0.5432013869,
0.5451191664,
-0.0651283115,
-0.0124810245,
-0.4517349303,
-0.4151102304,
-1.0734699965,
-0.2552683055,
0.609654963,
0.2877793908,
-0.9206104279,
0.2384685278,
-0.5632024407,
-0.3104082048,
-1.2459909916,
0.2250494659,
0.8559626341,
0.1960439682,
0.4485566616,
-0.2482143193,
-0.3149149716,
-0.8221053481,
-0.1445024014,
0.1836837232,
-0.0263116043,
0.3413032293,
0.3612063527,
0.0420618467,
0.6484094858,
-0.5652736425,
-0.2473506182,
-0.131727457,
0.3361506164,
-0.1997361928,
0.4848841429,
0.4282227755,
-0.8251076937,
-0.6243982911,
0.3186737597,
-0.7858965397,
0.0229086559,
-0.0009367448,
-0.148791641,
0.3283926845,
0.7148494124,
-0.2973455787,
0.4765284061,
0.6257677674,
-0.3205981851,
0.19092834,
-0.5617365241,
0.2400958389,
-1.0836083889,
-0.0542334914,
-0.3494441211,
-0.4459442198,
-0.262781322,
0.5378089547,
0.4152712226,
-0.2122241855,
-0.1406387836,
0.5268594623,
-0.6647201777,
-0.165957883,
-0.5600156188,
0.1168489754,
0.2338998169,
0.4297936261,
-0.277272284,
1.1930860281,
0.5189121366,
-0.4467686415,
0.1114573404,
0.047700908,
-0.3424414992,
0.4838471711,
-0.7041175961,
0.3875994384,
-0.4108674526,
-0.0920382664,
-0.6286494732,
-0.0586739518,
-0.1953675598,
-0.2190089673,
0.8004878163,
-0.1966632754,
-0.5609686971,
-0.1150423437,
-0.3389534354,
0.0578146242,
0.6385282874,
-0.856887877,
0.6292133331,
0.3206779063,
0.0071701151,
-0.4380792081,
-0.3794936836,
-0.048032783,
0.062631771,
-0.5183478594,
0.8123275042,
0.0170983635,
0.0018446938,
0.0616600215,
-0.1357070953,
0.0495692864,
-0.0225249343,
0.2228616625,
0.0825760514,
-0.475851953,
0.4294410944,
0.4751428366,
-0.2309693545,
-0.3191311359,
-0.191939041,
0.7319652438,
-0.2171716094,
-0.3509361446,
0.2443412095,
0.5193615556,
0.5119456649,
-0.4821721017,
1.0377992392,
1.0066800117,
-0.0787660778,
-0.2907865644,
-0.5962107182,
-0.1322258115,
-0.535879612,
0.4695818424,
-0.4925828278,
-0.9854723811,
0.3023993671,
-0.0525099933,
0.2349853516,
0.4146176875,
0.5541825294,
0.0485739,
1.1861742735,
0.823261559,
0.0817549676,
0.5667151213,
-0.3045702577,
0.1415158063,
-0.9906525016,
-0.1985725015,
-0.5453264713,
-0.2962282002,
-0.7036839724,
-0.6166559458,
0.1507394761,
0.3755460382,
-0.1434735507,
0.278470546,
-0.5778077245,
0.6576119065,
0.5392926931,
0.2281720191,
-0.0654521286,
-0.0354322009,
-0.1790289581,
-0.0204033069,
-0.6934129596,
-0.5677484274,
1.0733948946,
0.1525077373,
0.7433210015,
0.0359678231,
0.6992940307,
0.2714784443,
0.6151276231,
-0.6809273362,
0.2947813272,
-0.6580547094,
-0.4531843662,
-0.09332674,
-0.3509343266,
-1.0283408165,
0.4071492255,
-0.1045360491,
-0.4178192616,
-0.1880335808,
0.2209927589,
0.0364323556,
0.4609566629,
-0.7995201349,
0.8128063083,
0.1296374947,
-0.4087730646,
-0.2683637142,
-0.3386741281,
0.0504808091,
0.1973690242,
0.0552528538,
-0.2979764342,
0.0643808469,
0.5110756159,
-0.2068044692,
0.5001766086,
-0.1586772203,
-0.0465298444,
0.0556872599,
-0.1813919395,
0.5123400092,
-0.0460754372,
-0.0999068096,
0.0673542246,
-0.3310547769,
-0.6266343594,
-0.8315480947,
0.9309949279,
-0.5739116073,
-0.7909430265,
-0.1300178617,
-0.7923769355,
-0.0732303262,
0.1788870096,
0.4838899374,
0.6859755516,
-0.1615248471,
0.4611077607,
1.0348415375,
0.0237624831,
0.5747563839,
0.3861729503,
-0.2580383718,
-0.43561396,
1.3125168085,
-0.0646833479,
0.2546190321,
0.5641943216,
0.0843080729,
-0.2853325009,
-0.6903855801,
-0.7139097452,
0.271595031,
-0.8831501603,
-0.4774971306,
-0.4997249842,
-0.2178576142,
-0.5179005265,
-0.3988507092,
-0.4550359845,
0.0195978396,
-0.3974188566,
0.0569445491,
0.3156208098,
0.9292302132,
0.2994966507,
0.5613770485,
-0.809972465,
0.2511464059,
0.1119665727,
0.7023179531,
-0.0117157232,
-0.6235189438,
-0.4752455354,
0.1466178447,
-0.5803272724,
-0.6109026074,
0.2803095877,
0.3544964492,
0.4587722719,
0.4692605734,
-0.0872674808,
0.7715916038,
-0.6918855309,
0.4914132059,
-0.0216763373,
-0.9303132892,
0.3717335165,
-0.4614521265,
0.5485435724,
0.7387391925,
0.2727906108,
-0.2898331583,
-0.374964118,
-0.518558085,
-0.6832524538,
0.6564120054,
-0.0176960155,
0.2614039779,
-0.1226663664,
0.2163601965,
0.1700202823,
0.269064337,
-0.3110414147,
-0.2671460807,
-0.2626366317,
-0.3714065254,
-0.1919424981,
-0.3312336504,
-0.1004951894,
-0.1439617872,
0.6639226675,
-0.340724498,
0.4213437438,
-0.2420255542,
-0.394893676,
-0.0720766559,
0.1008238718,
0.7790172696,
0.7817544937,
-0.1293220967,
0.0718462169,
-0.0032006125,
-0.6963546276,
-0.0175073706,
0.0363639407,
-0.2609304786,
0.0935232639,
0.399484992,
1.3725879192,
0.5429137945,
-0.4748320282,
0.3934268653,
0.0016569801,
-0.1890125424,
0.2329580188,
0.3377056122,
0.0864324048,
-0.0778805539,
0.0742474943,
-0.1460890472,
0.0462555736,
-0.3468418121,
0.0209597349,
0.4068959951,
-0.5755856037,
-0.1544188857,
0.471434474,
0.133612141,
-0.6113117933,
0.8491598964,
-0.3761616051,
-0.382170558,
0.5320062637,
0.9025479555,
0.9162034988,
-0.2858725786,
0.3763281107,
0.3104097545,
0.3378041387,
-0.0243868362,
0.2534832358,
0.0184320398,
-0.4444251359,
-0.3325252831,
-0.9596632719,
-0.2674188614,
0.1115208045,
-1.1477221251,
0.2197982073,
-0.5094551444,
0.0185113009,
0.1599268168,
-0.1653544754,
-0.6521137357,
0.1567315459,
-0.1589846313,
0.6809646487,
-0.7572512031,
0.9248272777,
0.8227052093,
-0.2785038948,
-0.4470399022,
-0.1368164867,
-0.2240206152,
-0.8263897896,
0.151122123,
0.4838635027,
-0.0552019849,
0.2929504216,
-0.4700024426,
-0.7958028316,
1.1859086752,
0.7246900201,
-0.6649871469,
-0.0949238315,
-0.1129578874,
0.4245381057,
-0.3510357141,
0.1086102873,
0.6605728865,
0.2920969129,
0.1818748564,
-0.6957418323,
-0.098275505,
-0.2208283097,
0.5393254161,
0.8904281855,
-0.5854530334,
0.9550110102,
-0.1322018802,
-0.3280842304,
-0.0170259867,
0.7555477619,
0.1287074834,
0.2843665183,
0.2415438592,
0.8668863773,
0.7902314067,
-0.4229683578,
1.2906162739,
-0.3424111605,
0.399382323,
1.1698249578,
-0.0593112372,
0.6422439218,
0.2511047125,
-0.090581499,
0.5149694085,
0.4562871456,
-0.0858148262,
0.5092440248,
0.0407110229,
-0.4546685517,
-0.3213348687,
-0.2224645615,
-0.4621557891,
0.5251051188,
0.4970765412,
-0.5355314016,
-0.5350882411,
0.2353773862,
0.0633353591,
0.3796368837,
-0.4646447599,
0.8442438245,
-0.0809075832,
-0.8240078688,
0.6952573657,
0.3731155097,
0.5886132121,
-0.6667996645,
-0.3393150568,
-0.3357851207,
0.1970519274,
0.1090838611,
-0.5898439884,
0.2798168063,
-0.20750992,
-0.6199019551,
-0.334071666,
0.5908423662,
-0.645500958,
-0.3965924978,
0.20441401,
0.0611958615,
0.089567095,
-0.0254997071,
-0.6662940979,
0.3234198391,
-0.060340073,
0.1159923449,
0.7291728258,
0.286604017,
-0.1679820716,
0.5036153793,
0.5503498316,
-0.2069373131,
0.0851837546,
0.3334169686,
1.009149909,
-0.6607261896,
-0.3954503536,
-0.7035636902,
0.2912060022,
-0.1033036411,
-0.3461804092,
0.6392356753,
0.5575815439,
0.8577517867,
-0.106336616,
0.3477861285,
-0.0121201035,
0.0897292197,
-0.8282119632,
0.8970136642,
-0.4738619626,
-0.1074993908,
0.1047874689,
-1.0533201694,
-0.0223779175,
0.4898448288,
-0.1811006367,
0.3388064504,
0.9383816719,
1.0526008606,
-0.0407410823,
0.0573430918,
0.6031345725,
-0.2837864757,
0.3397525549,
0.3785483837,
0.2374791205,
-0.4756100178,
0.3086668551,
-0.2379727215,
-0.1482104957,
-0.203565076,
-0.8056627512,
-0.9533116817,
-0.6595210433,
-0.1738251895,
-0.2686971128,
0.3782321215,
0.6419908404,
0.6930772066,
-0.7958548665,
-0.0385817476,
-0.2622855902,
0.2440791726,
-0.2577926219,
-0.2246805429,
0.4696238041,
-0.9205759764,
-0.8977643847,
0.464884907,
0.4634918869,
0.0247893184,
-0.2589631081,
-0.0173600595,
-0.1192171425,
0.0219685677,
0.5348929167,
-0.0000517513,
-0.6686711907,
-0.1085972637,
-0.090944469,
-0.4134453237,
0.238627106,
1.0873219967,
-0.4959456623,
0.8067222834,
0.3004195988,
0.8226222992,
0.6230226755,
-0.1003704742,
0.6168162227,
-0.9423498511,
0.1402339786,
0.15282242,
0.1728377044,
0.5549948215,
-0.3159151375,
0.3202442229,
-0.0506740771,
-0.4616317451,
-0.9188914299,
0.0474933833,
-0.5732373595,
-0.1628157496,
0.9528280497,
-0.3175878525,
-0.3098080754,
0.0810575336,
-0.0801267102,
0.2577057183,
-0.2355387956,
0.7321968079,
0.673581779,
0.403983742,
-0.1784831285,
-0.4433750808,
0.5109111071,
0.435667336,
-0.8034874797,
-0.0755889416,
0.2758020163,
-0.0405697785,
0.0183554832,
0.4464557171,
-0.1224096194,
0.5318783522,
0.401150912,
0.2096899599,
-0.4018051922,
-0.6923766136,
-0.4537194967,
0.1315702349,
0.2155901939,
-0.2034906298
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09894v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09894v2
|
Not Just Novelty: A Longitudinal Study on Utility and Customization of an AI Workflow
| 2024-02-15T11:39:11 | 2024-05-31T16:00:05 |
Tao Long, Katy Ilonka Gero, Lydia B. Chilton
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Generative AI brings novel and impressive abilities to help people in
everyday tasks. There are many AI workflows that solve real and complex
problems by chaining AI outputs together with human interaction. Although there
is an undeniable lure of AI, it is uncertain how useful generative AI workflows
are after the novelty wears off. Additionally, workflows built with generative
AI have the potential to be easily customized to fit users' individual needs,
but do users take advantage of this? We conducted a three-week longitudinal
study with 12 users to understand the familiarization and customization of
generative AI tools for science communication. Our study revealed that there
exists a familiarization phase, during which users were exploring the novel
capabilities of the workflow and discovering which aspects they found useful.
After this phase, users understood the workflow and were able to anticipate the
outputs. Surprisingly, after familiarization the perceived utility of the
system was rated higher than before, indicating that the perceived utility of
AI is not just a novelty effect. The increase in benefits mainly comes from
end-users' ability to customize prompts, and thus potentially appropriate the
system to their own needs. This points to a future where generative AI systems
can allow us to design for appropriation.
|
[
-0.4877308309,
-0.5279742479,
0.5687404871,
0.0260036699,
-0.364831537,
0.2027510554,
-0.0465922095,
-0.6227404475,
0.4067277908,
0.0588169806,
-0.4701971412,
-0.2005721778,
-0.477789849,
0.2833842337,
-0.3799524903,
0.980682373,
0.30632025,
-0.3821703494,
-0.4681038857,
-0.2296209335,
-0.5815744996,
-0.2547805309,
-0.6370129585,
-0.6125775576,
0.7612860799,
0.3993788958,
0.8549230695,
0.4795691371,
0.3619399667,
0.3894782662,
-0.0661949217,
-0.169390142,
-0.5099480748,
0.2241459489,
-0.129027456,
-0.6174192429,
-0.0769418851,
-0.0071803047,
0.3384782374,
0.876662612,
-0.1815898865,
0.1092435122,
0.1857321113,
0.6595855951,
-0.4071823955,
0.1723030359,
-0.2992660999,
0.2531330585,
-0.4573225379,
-0.35468629,
-0.161229834,
-0.1587475836,
0.2020778209,
-0.904948473,
0.2766358256,
0.0522127971,
0.7022334933,
0.341561079,
-0.1832276434,
-0.1103878021,
-1.1633234024,
0.4348093569,
-0.5281934738,
0.0762086362,
-0.001055454,
0.6876561046,
-0.1301674396,
-0.9135044217,
-0.6420046091,
-0.442378968,
-0.1180044562,
0.1830578297,
-0.4219787121,
-0.1362747997,
0.2886982262,
0.2977020144,
-0.463393718,
0.4121621251,
-0.4942813814,
-0.0866426975,
0.4941741228,
0.4870983064,
0.6317405105,
0.1282361597,
-0.3134679794,
-0.1053960472,
-0.4543323815,
0.3139468431,
0.0851942971,
-0.1035470814,
-0.2177592516,
0.6857787371,
-0.2642532587,
0.6357192993,
-0.0393189825,
0.2736463845,
0.3021328151,
-0.08985807,
-0.2195886075,
-0.1774542481,
0.8036189675,
0.0456304699,
0.2498038262,
-0.5209881067,
0.1279748976,
-0.0891037285,
0.6025000215,
-0.4616253376,
-0.3053328395,
0.0456380323,
-0.5242184997,
-0.424058944,
-0.016290376,
-0.4713050723,
-0.5952633023,
-0.345361799,
0.2367441505,
-0.4189833999,
-0.1564713418,
-0.2441139221,
-0.4835536778,
-0.1036094576,
0.4021451175,
-1.0008486509,
-0.3512641788,
0.5894650221,
0.9639114141,
-0.3910843134,
-0.4762456119,
-0.1342675686,
-0.0421032161,
-0.3247877359,
0.9781490564,
-0.7233476639,
-0.6775010824,
-0.32481727,
-0.2622851431,
-0.0365036391,
-0.6174514294,
0.1413226426,
-0.6192276478,
-0.0593355969,
-0.1004875824,
-0.3360524774,
0.2265188545,
-0.0391434506,
-0.7284998894,
0.4121101797,
0.0981686786,
-0.47413674,
0.843699038,
-0.8262794018,
-0.5003530383,
0.6722953916,
-0.2030118555,
-0.2438979745,
0.2752145231,
-0.3594632447,
0.2675255537,
-0.0058287769,
0.1724008769,
-0.318248868,
-0.3157373071,
0.5041797757,
-0.3377543092,
0.6544598341,
0.6118671894,
-0.2946798205,
0.2827295959,
-0.5758805275,
-0.1376473904,
-0.2707571983,
-0.1306471229,
-0.4411107898,
-0.3081338406,
-0.0371569954,
-0.1205128506,
0.2401951253,
-0.3950948417,
0.1597973406,
-0.360763967,
0.4877700806,
0.7016208172,
0.061041154,
0.6443576813,
-0.6974195242,
0.6685512066,
0.0348467305,
0.1395762414,
-0.3106488287,
-0.9266210198,
-0.3019695878,
-0.3825910687,
-0.0334186107,
0.3250278234,
-0.6554191709,
0.4204374552,
-0.0326395184,
-0.7332627177,
-0.2191052884,
0.0798149258,
0.0138665941,
0.4404186308,
0.0417302996,
-0.48673895,
-0.3962629139,
-0.8799855113,
-0.3580616117,
-0.2262464464,
-0.4539991319,
0.5276268125,
0.3785365522,
-0.1690142602,
1.1048597097,
-0.5551298857,
-0.2207443714,
-0.2453607172,
0.7217947841,
0.1935746372,
0.2148572952,
0.4299710691,
-0.9330364466,
-0.3601624072,
0.1226103157,
-1.0605145693,
0.0187142398,
-0.3866579533,
-0.020661816,
-0.1074538007,
0.2088306546,
-0.7706986666,
0.4198633134,
0.1023776457,
-0.3154836595,
0.3879015446,
-0.4932046533,
0.1529156715,
-0.9858098626,
0.3749049008,
-0.0038565055,
0.2098392546,
-0.7645341158,
-0.0633337125,
-0.2707312703,
-0.2703371644,
-0.3335186541,
0.5005842447,
-0.3469415009,
0.1163300648,
-0.5192791224,
-0.232084766,
-0.1239421815,
0.1139668599,
0.0498811826,
0.7533650994,
0.6635914445,
-0.7056759,
0.3136129081,
0.1129692867,
-0.3619021773,
0.6860374808,
-0.7103894949,
0.1155653596,
-0.4344350696,
0.1483147144,
-0.7459766269,
-0.2955113351,
0.3226557374,
-0.5447874069,
0.0056604976,
0.2460203022,
-0.0772578642,
-0.3257673085,
-0.1797995269,
0.2155078501,
0.8043938279,
-0.5106534958,
0.6108528376,
0.1681507528,
-0.1028765813,
-0.2121935785,
-0.4459696412,
0.3648240566,
-0.5642786622,
-0.4867077768,
0.4240459502,
-0.2567754388,
-0.1595620066,
0.0964117125,
0.0193574745,
-0.0599892922,
0.3700041771,
0.4847719073,
0.0450283885,
0.0293031596,
0.0424947739,
-0.1263405085,
-0.2488997132,
-0.1623239517,
-0.2027333528,
0.3244402707,
-0.1182320341,
-0.3801118731,
-0.6134016514,
0.3258562684,
0.60548985,
-0.0377972424,
0.6619888544,
0.9209131002,
-0.3561429977,
0.1210431606,
-0.3297727406,
-0.423478514,
-0.5312684774,
0.0854822621,
-0.2450527847,
-0.8825237751,
0.4078497887,
-0.0227422267,
0.1879409254,
0.165062204,
0.5786762238,
-0.4566877782,
0.7742087841,
0.7378162146,
-0.0082507618,
0.6240404844,
-0.1832991242,
0.389967531,
-0.6901337504,
-0.6133493781,
-0.4559696913,
-0.5720303655,
-0.5308523774,
-0.0116668111,
0.5292735696,
-0.0697788969,
0.0344228931,
0.0889846683,
-0.4947445691,
0.3651298285,
0.7494396567,
-0.0177260228,
0.334451437,
-0.0340171903,
0.5140132904,
-0.1744157821,
-0.5797165036,
-0.5913057327,
0.9387221336,
-0.0403799191,
0.9176855683,
0.0914739519,
0.861795485,
0.7427548766,
0.5056937337,
-0.8027499318,
0.371155709,
-0.0213430282,
0.0882839039,
-0.5511004329,
-0.2725039124,
-1.5322480202,
0.019007368,
-0.3148997128,
-0.9534972906,
0.3079428077,
0.523191154,
-0.5162525177,
0.1643771231,
-0.7475415468,
0.485399276,
0.0801028833,
-0.3483062387,
-0.2258905321,
-0.4453930259,
0.1339872628,
0.010449985,
0.052590847,
0.0005386916,
0.1144869328,
0.6626416445,
-0.1473229378,
1.0685895681,
-0.0371302366,
0.1122298837,
0.2285101414,
-0.119280979,
0.2199541777,
0.2666260004,
0.0724853575,
0.0156879872,
-0.1272754073,
-0.2700953782,
-0.9013022184,
0.7890943289,
-0.5552073121,
-1.1123454571,
-0.5303127766,
-0.4422188103,
0.0700837672,
0.349162519,
0.4436914623,
0.0771570653,
-0.4967935979,
0.1900017709,
0.4844066203,
0.1275284737,
0.483204931,
0.3525045216,
0.4720397592,
0.2116308063,
0.8707121611,
-0.0444231182,
-0.0209963918,
0.3104936481,
0.4566773176,
0.1000955403,
-0.400441587,
-0.6293540597,
-0.2641168237,
-0.3949394822,
0.003669122,
-0.6616764665,
0.0432877205,
-0.1322986335,
-0.2971325815,
-0.0812071338,
-0.4538155496,
-0.6374227405,
0.1375709176,
0.1332083642,
0.8286247849,
-0.1644621491,
-0.103552483,
-0.7557417154,
0.2434864938,
0.6259952784,
0.0433591157,
0.2275018841,
-0.3102170527,
-0.2541133463,
0.0407770686,
-0.5878475904,
-0.7638205886,
0.2504619658,
0.3378181458,
0.8396991491,
0.5430037975,
-0.0553433932,
0.096405603,
-0.3715113401,
1.0489171743,
0.125914976,
-0.4952667952,
0.286655575,
-0.1152563766,
0.5294756889,
0.2499129325,
0.4399605691,
-0.6509637833,
-0.3608644903,
-0.584136188,
-0.7374298573,
0.474196285,
0.3246188462,
0.6088528037,
0.2517009676,
0.4096745253,
0.3227740228,
0.3564162552,
-0.2133469582,
-0.3178396225,
-0.5818735957,
0.0162243918,
-0.1273453236,
0.1238480061,
-0.4782754779,
-0.1020616591,
0.0849808678,
-0.1349776685,
0.447050631,
-0.1951454133,
0.3056438863,
0.0062501342,
0.532853961,
0.4905185997,
0.7862718701,
0.1133014187,
0.0992152914,
0.0834186077,
-0.4044879079,
0.1475039274,
0.0595255718,
-0.322698772,
-0.2736033797,
0.2902251482,
0.8543416858,
-0.0554619953,
-0.5866925716,
0.1594056189,
0.0830734521,
-0.1135469675,
-0.2618114948,
0.6283766031,
0.066829443,
0.3550328314,
0.4808466733,
0.5487293005,
0.550725162,
-0.6145306826,
-0.0614608973,
0.5649237037,
0.0018533086,
-0.6461105347,
0.9343557954,
0.0478132367,
-0.7183008194,
0.3947097063,
-0.1492149085,
0.0346268602,
0.8560962677,
0.6640661359,
0.8153501749,
-0.0189101249,
0.6751499176,
0.0862298459,
-0.0210931171,
0.1914353371,
-0.0358032472,
-0.422319442,
-0.649787128,
0.1906134784,
-0.2698888779,
-0.5280290246,
0.0479245782,
-0.6777421236,
0.0779808164,
-0.2911163568,
-0.4058621824,
0.3580347896,
-0.6455293894,
-0.9490878582,
0.1412281096,
-0.1574698538,
0.6594716907,
-0.8225908875,
0.5326999426,
1.1001456976,
-0.307528019,
-0.3949582875,
0.0866073221,
0.0085707568,
-0.7518440485,
0.5558897257,
-0.0578672066,
-0.0374139547,
-0.0630010888,
-0.3566326797,
-0.7529557943,
1.3126342297,
-0.0246247929,
-0.2871880531,
0.0631120875,
0.085129045,
1.1163084507,
-0.4407582283,
0.2745358646,
0.5195329189,
0.3619117141,
0.3621425033,
-0.5408518314,
0.0047025005,
-0.6600180268,
0.4785435498,
-0.0058108014,
-0.6883172393,
0.5380711555,
-0.7663602829,
-0.3835273385,
0.1732653081,
0.7720478177,
0.2422160208,
0.8504506946,
0.4752442837,
0.2080102116,
0.7445299625,
0.1324804723,
0.9422706962,
-0.0908426493,
-0.1312778294,
0.6283541322,
-0.1325059384,
0.427282393,
0.664578259,
-0.0562418662,
0.5306314826,
0.3423483372,
-0.051107686,
0.6665903926,
0.1833331883,
-0.3856372535,
-0.1316555142,
-0.3393908739,
-0.4618950784,
0.121587202,
0.1631150395,
-0.1739601344,
0.0154818138,
0.5520713925,
-0.1115976498,
0.1021985561,
0.2482758164,
0.8893432617,
0.1022239402,
-0.7578014135,
0.3616566956,
-0.2429104745,
0.6746098399,
-0.5260136724,
-0.0897145495,
-0.3581258357,
-0.230668813,
-0.3404996097,
-0.8294519782,
0.3180475235,
-0.0750874653,
-0.1138238832,
-0.2244463712,
0.5555289388,
-0.0222621523,
-0.0315674543,
-0.3607168198,
0.4748925567,
0.1114060879,
0.3246843219,
-0.2054363489,
-0.185760051,
-0.1249739081,
-0.1655544043,
0.4343693554,
0.2365831584,
-0.213607654,
0.9884443283,
0.6499672532,
0.1053145155,
-0.1626189798,
0.2184647471,
0.9182879925,
-0.3814295232,
-0.5264229774,
-0.6702877879,
0.5751288533,
-0.167421639,
-0.5899919271,
0.6369577646,
0.3908499479,
0.6696994901,
-0.3877200782,
1.0390713215,
-0.3579717577,
-0.1216397732,
-0.3011654317,
0.6054174304,
-0.62978971,
0.4912797213,
0.0059321341,
-0.6131045818,
-0.2706719339,
0.2424990386,
-0.1944186389,
0.3474105,
0.4551326632,
0.5465702415,
-0.1005165055,
0.4438182414,
0.3134505749,
-0.1527317613,
0.6094532609,
0.3811523914,
1.0060546398,
0.4293687046,
0.2535111308,
-0.3645395041,
-0.7630121708,
-0.3051649332,
-0.7696393132,
-0.8723951578,
-0.7795551419,
-0.1737552881,
0.0608701929,
0.1904580146,
0.7204548717,
0.5042654872,
-0.6481681466,
0.0294060744,
-0.1802449375,
-0.0929375663,
-0.5465472937,
-0.2627511919,
0.185772568,
-0.4658545852,
-0.656776607,
0.4030075669,
0.3354107738,
0.3347609341,
-0.3040638864,
-0.0764366612,
0.518968761,
-0.1983370632,
0.3871038258,
0.865093708,
-0.4065071344,
-0.134021014,
0.2188919485,
0.0623257048,
0.0533799417,
1.2205929756,
-0.8266305327,
0.6269188523,
0.6385250092,
0.5100052357,
0.5251743197,
0.020994937,
0.6775448918,
-0.4190774858,
0.1069507301,
0.1417132318,
0.1497222185,
0.2989891171,
-0.8629134893,
0.2571888864,
0.2653782368,
-0.4693394005,
-0.6173736453,
0.3033382595,
-0.6754990816,
-0.0074587353,
0.6549611092,
-0.2008289695,
0.1132870167,
-0.3041817546,
-0.2178442329,
0.1300960183,
-0.5046393275,
1.5491609573,
0.4539578855,
-0.8046149611,
-0.0980258808,
-0.1779133528,
0.6092071533,
0.5128052235,
-1.0585196018,
-0.4263732731,
0.1339140981,
0.2514688671,
0.3505726755,
0.6670202613,
0.242544502,
0.468262285,
-0.1620979756,
-0.3547971845,
-0.5186662674,
-0.3806760013,
-0.0370307788,
0.0900598615,
0.3113096356,
-0.2778167129
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09880v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09880v1
|
Inadequacies of Large Language Model Benchmarks in the Era of Generative Artificial Intelligence
| 2024-02-15T11:08:10 | 2024-02-15T11:08:10 |
Timothy R. McIntosh, Teo Susnjak, Tong Liu, Paul Watters, Malka N. Halgamuge
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC
|
The rapid rise in popularity of Large Language Models (LLMs) with emerging
capabilities has spurred public curiosity to evaluate and compare different
LLMs, leading many researchers to propose their LLM benchmarks. Noticing
preliminary inadequacies in those benchmarks, we embarked on a study to
critically assess 23 state-of-the-art LLM benchmarks, using our novel unified
evaluation framework through the lenses of people, process, and technology,
under the pillars of functionality and security. Our research uncovered
significant limitations, including biases, difficulties in measuring genuine
reasoning, adaptability, implementation inconsistencies, prompt engineering
complexity, evaluator diversity, and the overlooking of cultural and
ideological norms in one comprehensive assessment. Our discussions emphasized
the urgent need for standardized methodologies, regulatory certainties, and
ethical guidelines in light of Artificial Intelligence (AI) advancements,
including advocating for an evolution from static benchmarks to dynamic
behavioral profiling to accurately capture LLMs' complex behaviors and
potential risks. Our study highlighted the necessity for a paradigm shift in
LLM evaluation methodologies, underlining the importance of collaborative
efforts for the development of universally accepted benchmarks and the
enhancement of AI systems' integration into society.
|
[
-0.4135740995,
-0.6613860726,
0.61916852,
0.2993170619,
0.0733428746,
0.4315839708,
-0.3982773721,
-0.6484327912,
-0.2873286009,
0.3004258871,
-0.2129609585,
-0.3290886581,
-0.6408779025,
0.1955706477,
-0.4813948274,
0.6308661699,
0.0110180322,
0.0780232921,
-0.4496781826,
-0.3982110322,
-0.3337900937,
-0.6733667254,
-0.4191096425,
-0.5273171663,
0.0893434137,
0.0603732169,
0.6092047691,
0.4244055748,
0.6950116754,
0.357974261,
-0.1232857406,
0.1254243702,
-0.260258019,
-0.0635632277,
0.012241751,
-0.2475325763,
-0.6164827347,
0.0357195362,
0.6857284904,
0.9052015543,
-0.0562548861,
0.3573247492,
0.1609109491,
0.7120796442,
-0.8077820539,
0.1883736104,
-0.6379044652,
0.0381043628,
-0.3755424619,
0.0575974658,
-0.1984743029,
-0.391002655,
0.0757455379,
-0.2370000631,
-0.1434612572,
-0.0786904693,
0.4112402201,
0.4364747405,
-0.3196545839,
-0.1173680723,
-1.0451512337,
0.7911021709,
-0.6113532782,
0.4101077914,
0.0950613692,
0.1858949959,
-0.2198598832,
-0.6112408042,
-0.4279187322,
-0.6073549986,
0.4474037886,
-0.1529880166,
-0.2012318224,
0.0102087408,
0.327221483,
0.2776389718,
-0.3913924396,
0.4939407408,
-0.1643550992,
-0.2175828516,
0.8267424107,
0.3209135532,
0.2204704434,
0.0961457714,
-0.3424356878,
0.0191506594,
-0.7904634476,
-0.0005581644,
0.429611057,
0.0886264443,
-0.0818065628,
0.3101395667,
-0.2639248073,
0.3181401491,
-0.3280842006,
0.0515122749,
0.4648501277,
-0.4677704573,
-0.2290885299,
-0.1682275087,
0.9871721864,
0.274110049,
0.365983665,
-0.3316004276,
-0.2136473954,
0.0770956874,
0.4548352659,
-0.492810607,
0.0464681685,
0.2342806756,
-0.3346519172,
-0.2384515256,
0.1383170038,
-0.8034846783,
-0.5684514046,
-0.1556376368,
0.1035952047,
-0.1382098794,
-0.3552419245,
-0.0611082166,
0.0431379527,
0.4217111766,
0.3677569032,
-0.6685015559,
0.3077985644,
1.0409361124,
0.6269741058,
-0.3696873784,
-0.3175337315,
0.0971961096,
-0.1173245758,
-0.5534347296,
0.6190536618,
-0.6004305482,
-0.5917664766,
0.0576717444,
-0.3943620622,
-0.0208522566,
-0.7591779828,
0.7440100908,
-0.3567530513,
-0.1838216484,
-0.2495975196,
-0.4316126704,
-0.0382092446,
0.3395576477,
-0.469807297,
1.0173809528,
-0.0061227372,
-0.4445854127,
0.3394265771,
-0.7646247745,
-0.3767850399,
0.4632436335,
-0.455075562,
-0.3282039762,
0.2237614393,
0.0198932234,
0.1757992506,
-0.6354061365,
0.6168277264,
-0.4149463475,
-0.4918853045,
0.5366398096,
-0.8677395582,
0.8865380883,
0.1574953198,
-0.4605171382,
0.2844542563,
-0.8237417936,
0.1540200561,
0.120639652,
-0.3726398051,
-0.0830662921,
0.1235470995,
0.1128371134,
0.0076532508,
0.4396848083,
-0.3485066593,
-0.0805203095,
-0.2686719298,
0.7227318287,
0.8595587015,
-0.3079073429,
0.377766937,
-0.3816078603,
0.4313494861,
-0.3238354027,
0.2866309285,
0.1178683788,
-0.3161394894,
-0.7106318474,
-0.1288416833,
0.1252103597,
0.5490026474,
-0.1361821592,
0.7467198968,
-0.3063889444,
-0.734832108,
-0.5358136296,
0.3017093241,
0.423917681,
0.2253422588,
0.1494104564,
-0.3487997353,
-0.4188752472,
-0.9710729122,
-0.2715725303,
-0.5115386844,
-0.1859139055,
0.2471791059,
0.6104201078,
-0.3334006965,
0.7333590388,
0.0662562177,
0.0753050148,
-0.287102133,
0.1948350072,
-0.0340408981,
0.4091326892,
0.4032272995,
-0.7073889971,
-0.0779458135,
-0.0359643437,
-0.9031655192,
-0.0358804874,
0.073332049,
0.1561293006,
0.2896015942,
0.5387132764,
-0.6346765757,
0.1923639029,
0.3747802377,
0.1096012816,
0.6223273277,
-0.1673897952,
0.1692295223,
-0.5973296165,
0.3582603931,
-0.0260017291,
0.1600184143,
-0.552038908,
0.3484138846,
0.0528346449,
0.0573123731,
-0.1694647223,
0.4725513756,
-0.4234968126,
-0.2116531432,
-0.1599477082,
0.0493287779,
-0.1343602687,
0.1850736886,
-0.5105521679,
0.9076383114,
0.5085656047,
-0.5372120142,
0.5036149621,
0.1645428538,
-0.5555381179,
0.5910846591,
-0.6539854407,
0.2866065502,
0.1306304038,
0.1652029455,
-0.6524146199,
-0.1596988738,
0.2381190509,
-0.2546450496,
0.1210399643,
0.2570584416,
-0.5853661895,
-0.4096517861,
-0.3957977295,
0.5088048577,
0.5758721232,
-0.2041015923,
0.6379952431,
0.5094023347,
-0.1121639758,
-0.5555733442,
-0.4751392603,
0.4327889383,
-0.2907197773,
-0.5663496852,
0.2485659719,
-0.107329689,
-0.686637342,
-0.1750053018,
-0.2343507111,
0.0034317952,
0.6280432343,
0.220882833,
0.2320998013,
-0.2534126639,
0.1025632843,
-0.3848389387,
-0.0242347531,
0.4557411969,
-0.0251900274,
0.5513511896,
-0.4431008399,
-0.6361544132,
-0.3665335476,
0.1413962245,
0.765550971,
-0.368454814,
0.4396013916,
0.4314590991,
-0.3178475201,
-0.0824705809,
-0.7476234436,
0.0822059065,
-0.4356773496,
0.6097794175,
-0.089215219,
-0.8910647631,
0.5409342647,
-0.2408992201,
0.1049142107,
0.4499073029,
0.5500651598,
0.0156381726,
0.8807325363,
0.5183039904,
-0.2196278572,
0.2636134624,
0.1404239982,
0.3693087697,
-0.9007338285,
-0.3422970176,
-0.7184457779,
-0.1125452891,
-0.8100050688,
-0.291384697,
0.4730787873,
-0.055438228,
-0.3820423782,
0.0181456208,
-0.1767654717,
0.2369218171,
0.363370806,
-0.2456426471,
0.437117517,
-0.1961961538,
-0.0086591942,
0.1974684894,
-0.3925605118,
-0.8249991536,
1.283342123,
0.5221740603,
0.7221282721,
0.0786604434,
0.4900526702,
0.5041198134,
0.3068706393,
-0.6774362326,
0.7982004881,
-0.1104383543,
-0.5263265967,
-0.4075939357,
-0.4153089821,
-0.7703135014,
0.130928576,
-0.1684074551,
-0.8907285333,
-0.0030131696,
-0.2051685303,
-0.2310527861,
0.1044277772,
-0.5377993584,
0.7617792487,
-0.6239948869,
-0.2444829643,
-0.3329677582,
-0.4791815877,
0.4156393409,
-0.3278658688,
0.2263391167,
-0.498483181,
-0.0097317165,
0.7109642625,
-0.1564074159,
0.6670286655,
0.120716773,
-0.1148343161,
0.1021199003,
-0.1920270622,
0.1625558883,
-0.0775480941,
-0.2306785136,
0.5630372763,
-0.1723100841,
-0.3311148584,
-0.4492783844,
0.6859269738,
-0.9163569212,
-0.9188087583,
-0.4847318828,
-0.4850624204,
-0.486420393,
0.0744787976,
-0.0189583134,
0.2586766779,
-0.6708509922,
0.2974439561,
0.5433418751,
-0.1539523005,
0.4299278259,
0.3838992417,
-0.0005479489,
-0.1834581494,
0.7970686555,
0.1011649072,
0.2048471421,
0.118637152,
-0.0085116001,
-0.2594978213,
-0.8170315623,
-0.3600401282,
-0.0054374789,
-0.6347346306,
0.1086087823,
-0.4563267231,
-0.4296376109,
-0.3759695888,
0.0721053928,
-0.5047026277,
-0.056456957,
-0.1690929085,
0.0628716275,
0.0445711873,
0.8291130066,
0.2075617164,
-0.060600929,
-0.6665312648,
0.124451369,
0.1021272019,
0.4153654575,
0.1562283933,
-0.3551009595,
-0.0579655915,
-0.1298319846,
-0.3752678037,
-0.4334233999,
-0.1387975812,
-0.0021144708,
0.9541499615,
0.4536675215,
0.0785513371,
0.5013670325,
-0.4327479601,
0.6138568521,
0.0293260887,
-0.9971603155,
0.1616165191,
-0.1921029985,
0.1740029603,
0.5732693076,
0.2938403189,
-0.5234110951,
-0.3307771683,
-0.4007725418,
-1.0008286238,
0.3511311114,
0.1407040656,
0.3809474111,
0.1491046995,
0.1469843835,
0.0605404489,
0.3205711246,
-0.6487762332,
-0.233918488,
0.0650715604,
-0.1218628138,
0.0407387093,
-0.0896091312,
-0.291986227,
-0.1108314842,
0.4089027345,
-0.0959095582,
0.1675886959,
-0.0983410403,
-0.0653103665,
-0.0214560833,
0.5919968486,
0.48368451,
1.1564534903,
-0.0631547943,
0.0196510181,
0.2390689999,
-0.3410505354,
0.2517073154,
0.3348861337,
-0.3466689885,
-0.4853575826,
0.4485809505,
0.6019558907,
0.183318764,
-0.953040719,
0.3222533464,
-0.0540947728,
-0.0850505903,
-0.5659347773,
0.3012560308,
0.0303953029,
0.3200564981,
0.5440163016,
0.2845431566,
0.0858118981,
-0.6387754083,
-0.0772899464,
0.7908536792,
-0.2435823679,
-0.1694735289,
0.5277447104,
0.4532869756,
-0.4248781204,
0.5716049671,
-0.1067617387,
-0.3517023921,
0.6586894989,
0.1206103563,
1.1196049452,
-0.1030553505,
0.2077896148,
-0.0364438109,
0.6748829484,
-0.2223044634,
0.0216057301,
-0.0585685819,
-0.8032551408,
-0.193039313,
-0.6839710474,
-0.5393900275,
0.281267792,
-0.5441132188,
0.0284971707,
-0.7304583192,
-0.2476977408,
-0.0570249073,
0.0753584802,
-0.5964940786,
-0.1458280534,
0.4157316685,
0.9218057394,
-0.6804730892,
0.5129610896,
0.6475554109,
-0.3158518374,
-0.3619487584,
0.2840781808,
0.0423319265,
-0.9282033443,
0.4719491899,
0.2655282617,
-0.1277067065,
-0.2851757705,
-0.4540809393,
-0.7587054372,
0.8968518972,
0.4057600796,
-0.6614473462,
0.0002667785,
0.41385144,
0.7705231309,
-0.3373211622,
0.2875873148,
0.8590155244,
0.5754094124,
-0.2349455059,
-1.0426012278,
0.1353151947,
-0.315728724,
0.2421775013,
0.137276113,
-0.7959336042,
0.6590587497,
-0.0986202136,
-0.3310027122,
0.3376573622,
0.3864275217,
0.2691604495,
0.4544227123,
0.2818930149,
0.4667663276,
0.6604784131,
-0.1827820241,
0.9700767398,
-0.3245815337,
-0.0162528399,
0.7707574368,
-0.7886916399,
0.8322365284,
0.3264320493,
-0.431240499,
0.1944329143,
0.4502946436,
-0.2771808207,
-0.0134534547,
0.4159782529,
-0.3261350989,
-0.2688814402,
-0.3163874149,
-0.3129265606,
0.6641421914,
0.3894640505,
-0.1062652394,
-0.1350695193,
-0.2761848867,
-0.1113479733,
0.2438082844,
-0.164065361,
0.7563986778,
0.0581946969,
-0.6847885251,
0.3712222874,
0.0901638269,
0.671867609,
-0.5139952302,
0.1635920405,
-0.2313575596,
0.0873790681,
-0.0189500861,
-0.7397185564,
0.1488419771,
0.2175058275,
0.0998629034,
-0.2457118779,
0.3764692247,
0.0484024137,
-0.5129594207,
0.5064240098,
0.7980275154,
0.0815309137,
0.0450557247,
-0.7512287498,
0.5106281638,
-0.3401619494,
-0.0622033738,
0.4158177972,
0.212459147,
-0.1954367906,
0.8233059645,
0.5787893534,
0.04415977,
-0.1310720295,
0.2482042015,
0.7870852947,
-0.5963898301,
-0.1069356948,
-1.0939210653,
0.1732806265,
-0.0552019589,
-0.5311806798,
0.6637161374,
0.378341794,
0.9774691463,
0.3059820235,
0.9182597399,
0.0328563452,
0.1447464228,
-0.4764307141,
0.7870841026,
-0.3776138723,
0.5013434291,
-0.2123523802,
-1.0313844681,
-0.1435218453,
0.2828063369,
-0.3232250512,
0.4712026417,
0.4588492811,
0.6086263061,
0.3522951603,
0.0032507321,
0.3444433212,
0.325602442,
0.360278964,
0.3671500981,
1.0950541496,
-0.2354234755,
0.4251374304,
0.0350314341,
-0.1769359261,
-0.3988811374,
-0.897690475,
-0.6959084868,
-0.4539239407,
-0.3770731986,
0.0261193532,
0.1956110448,
1.0182095766,
0.497361809,
-0.7472751737,
-0.4759255946,
-0.0544109158,
0.2403924018,
-0.090802379,
-0.210139215,
0.0440405048,
-0.1325154305,
-0.5550785661,
0.4001194239,
0.5484389067,
-0.0791680217,
-0.770614326,
-0.163038969,
0.1113292947,
0.132581532,
0.3908555806,
0.4124679267,
-1.0728948116,
-0.3118043244,
-0.105336681,
-0.2416399717,
0.069344528,
0.6440518498,
-0.3886043727,
0.2622577846,
0.349601835,
0.920350492,
-0.1968804449,
-0.0693016127,
0.5849080682,
-0.3142064214,
-0.1360966414,
0.2996710837,
0.2678458989,
0.4951665998,
-0.1268451065,
0.3957352042,
0.1743351966,
-0.7042946219,
-1.0199230909,
0.2712086141,
-0.7879362702,
-0.1048876345,
0.7966486216,
-0.074033007,
-0.1182228699,
-0.2409153879,
0.1972504258,
0.0133367805,
-0.385909766,
1.0228158236,
0.7329019308,
-0.2025667578,
-0.0499551669,
-0.5708744526,
0.4047043025,
0.3647697568,
-0.9713995457,
0.1915631741,
0.3749347627,
0.0757169873,
0.2787403166,
0.4592444599,
-0.161503315,
0.2595508993,
-0.0440558232,
-0.0263619367,
0.0166484751,
-0.346426338,
-0.4921017885,
0.1576218158,
0.4436481893,
0.147181347
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09874v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09874v1
|
Camouflage is all you need: Evaluating and Enhancing Language Model Robustness Against Camouflage Adversarial Attacks
| 2024-02-15T10:58:22 | 2024-02-15T10:58:22 |
Álvaro Huertas-García, Alejandro Martín, Javier Huertas-Tato, David Camacho
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Adversarial attacks represent a substantial challenge in Natural Language
Processing (NLP). This study undertakes a systematic exploration of this
challenge in two distinct phases: vulnerability evaluation and resilience
enhancement of Transformer-based models under adversarial attacks.
In the evaluation phase, we assess the susceptibility of three Transformer
configurations, encoder-decoder, encoder-only, and decoder-only setups, to
adversarial attacks of escalating complexity across datasets containing
offensive language and misinformation. Encoder-only models manifest a 14% and
21% performance drop in offensive language detection and misinformation
detection tasks, respectively. Decoder-only models register a 16% decrease in
both tasks, while encoder-decoder models exhibit a maximum performance drop of
14% and 26% in the respective tasks.
The resilience-enhancement phase employs adversarial training, integrating
pre-camouflaged and dynamically altered data. This approach effectively reduces
the performance drop in encoder-only models to an average of 5% in offensive
language detection and 2% in misinformation detection tasks. Decoder-only
models, occasionally exceeding original performance, limit the performance drop
to 7% and 2% in the respective tasks. Although not surpassing the original
performance, Encoder-decoder models can reduce the drop to an average of 6% and
2% respectively.
Results suggest a trade-off between performance and robustness, with some
models maintaining similar performance while gaining robustness. Our study and
adversarial training techniques have been incorporated into an open-source tool
for generating camouflaged datasets. However, methodology effectiveness depends
on the specific camouflage technique and data encountered, emphasizing the need
for continued exploration.
|
[
-0.3438023627,
-0.7552452683,
0.0228544753,
0.2101200372,
-0.113301754,
0.2221251577,
-0.1598590612,
-0.468423605,
-0.0707959905,
0.489334017,
-0.4230656624,
-0.2117258012,
-1.025472641,
0.0863597542,
-0.6033446789,
0.9043924212,
0.4816455245,
-0.0506878495,
0.0392270088,
-0.3475317657,
-0.2165572792,
-0.7002674341,
-0.7687026858,
-0.1076220721,
0.2077875882,
-0.247174859,
1.2174319029,
0.7135861516,
0.5237426162,
0.3946437538,
-0.3302728236,
-0.0243136808,
-0.5733194351,
0.3930380046,
-0.2463610321,
-0.5760264397,
-0.0948343724,
-0.1961910278,
0.3717902601,
0.3461208344,
-0.0404867828,
-0.0974052027,
0.0521945469,
0.3959974945,
-1.0422643423,
-0.0916280076,
-0.8309853673,
-0.0087257605,
-0.3285758197,
0.0571453422,
-0.5320068002,
0.0293567255,
0.0090923402,
-0.4596953988,
0.3904734552,
-0.3259979188,
0.7882729173,
0.2635231614,
-0.1128837541,
-0.3160279095,
-0.7828912139,
0.7705578208,
-0.7295062542,
0.3306024969,
0.3290435374,
0.3834190965,
-0.2542213798,
-0.7379579544,
-0.3928927779,
-0.225466907,
-0.1562351733,
0.2053975016,
-0.7877973914,
-0.0493297875,
0.2552067935,
0.3956881166,
-0.6454228759,
0.1023657694,
-0.1853257269,
-0.3214164376,
0.4467619658,
0.0652220026,
0.4897432923,
-0.0888224244,
-0.2674682438,
-0.5244683623,
-0.4562791884,
0.0385283381,
0.6198173761,
0.2484449744,
0.1360126436,
0.5386896729,
0.0896152556,
0.5182719827,
-0.1878844202,
0.1153898984,
-0.1692836136,
-0.2123158872,
-0.3179678321,
-0.4786909521,
0.9036610723,
0.0236938987,
-0.0076972861,
-0.6167408824,
-0.4720639288,
0.4473742843,
0.8325051665,
-0.6036054492,
-0.3665136993,
0.0088322405,
-0.2153549194,
-0.7375369668,
-0.047261171,
-1.0673869848,
-0.5972020626,
0.183417201,
0.4428192973,
-0.6068781018,
-0.2688714266,
0.2391443849,
-0.3435532451,
0.3076162934,
-0.1169215217,
-0.8957195878,
0.4777183533,
0.7765929699,
0.8400585651,
-0.1501855552,
-0.2076829821,
-0.2426359355,
-0.0492216423,
-0.2954943776,
0.4612456858,
-0.4971352518,
-0.2930098772,
0.1222389191,
0.1272610426,
-0.3904663324,
-0.3128987253,
0.8866685629,
-0.8191896677,
0.1127612963,
0.1500210911,
-0.1737388372,
-0.0772968903,
0.5136585236,
-1.1160309315,
0.8493304253,
0.205465436,
-0.9438459277,
-0.1124012619,
-0.7093285918,
-0.5667222142,
-0.0363969542,
0.1314668804,
-0.6188220382,
-0.1039463654,
0.4967738688,
0.1475588083,
-0.2069198936,
0.0925503597,
-0.2248670906,
-0.2213632017,
0.4737512171,
-0.8069544435,
1.1536406279,
0.1629619151,
-0.4919998646,
-0.0209214054,
-0.7544983625,
-0.056765832,
0.3515646458,
-0.3797113001,
-0.1883321106,
-0.0632937625,
-0.021313414,
-0.096273534,
-0.0104901167,
-0.4748780131,
-0.0795265585,
-0.8958727717,
0.36553666,
0.7515808344,
-0.1740262359,
0.6609552503,
-0.2501261532,
0.8263501525,
-0.3047244847,
0.4335935116,
-0.1614372432,
-0.5016037226,
-0.8997367024,
-0.2912422717,
0.1727768928,
0.6779515147,
-1.1761269569,
0.1545194983,
-0.2104848474,
-0.6108151078,
-0.5774445534,
-0.0653161034,
0.7877779007,
0.2441957444,
0.4382869899,
-0.0734906495,
-0.6595653892,
-0.8418639302,
-0.5572172403,
-0.1154781282,
-0.3509997725,
-0.0960160643,
0.6030285954,
-0.3494265676,
0.6935930848,
-0.3797542751,
-0.0227021221,
-0.3462819457,
0.2161851823,
-0.0536554679,
0.2730722725,
0.7905755639,
-0.941980958,
-0.1889093071,
-0.0272341408,
-0.5607623458,
0.0933820903,
0.0652020648,
-0.1441066414,
0.3052298427,
0.1669486314,
-0.6718522906,
0.4996864796,
0.7021912932,
-0.0958991498,
0.3864474893,
-0.039595075,
0.022056058,
-0.9115345478,
0.1027900651,
-0.1631223857,
-0.1233263686,
-1.1206212044,
0.6754635572,
0.0405019745,
-0.2785762846,
-0.3593041301,
0.1940124929,
-0.30310449,
0.1963356435,
-0.1544454247,
-0.0952598751,
0.1696618944,
0.3696686625,
-0.1668363065,
0.6563607454,
0.7340625525,
-0.585342586,
0.4849872291,
0.052084744,
-0.2350596786,
0.0978803113,
-0.6891484261,
0.2438579798,
-0.1447116435,
-0.0959965736,
-0.7193955779,
-0.1694332361,
0.5525117517,
-0.6014678478,
0.6311425567,
-0.2659336925,
-0.182777077,
-0.1877572984,
-0.57554245,
0.1709860414,
0.2656272352,
-0.6362178922,
0.8054337502,
0.4094204009,
-0.0164726805,
-0.9245200157,
-0.8194699287,
0.456023246,
-0.1570624411,
-0.7713609934,
0.3773788512,
0.0424236692,
-0.1549785584,
-0.1161602661,
-0.0034782027,
-0.2322496176,
0.4225071967,
0.0971817076,
0.3365725279,
-0.2235292047,
-0.2701490819,
-0.5118713379,
-0.1052932516,
0.261652261,
0.0016849559,
0.4990669787,
-0.2905257344,
-0.4561241567,
-0.0560006723,
0.3623871803,
0.7528737783,
-0.2926932275,
1.0567840338,
0.671893239,
-0.4889447391,
-0.0631056502,
-0.3891482055,
-0.1233754829,
-0.4867247343,
0.5114789009,
-0.1515233219,
-0.4763975739,
0.56747967,
0.4120557606,
0.1721647829,
0.3606021106,
0.1184120849,
0.3151312768,
1.0007096529,
0.7301534414,
-0.2869409025,
0.4251271784,
-0.2334118187,
0.4148836136,
-0.6686654091,
-0.3969981074,
-0.5400956869,
-0.0590365082,
-0.5575768352,
-0.3546185195,
0.1245661676,
-0.1076648235,
-0.0526397675,
0.6104596853,
-0.5869712234,
0.5614258051,
0.352697283,
0.2220815271,
-0.0785689726,
-0.0666909739,
0.4546788335,
-0.2600433528,
-0.8058844805,
-0.4258807003,
1.2416014671,
0.5062317252,
0.8892335296,
0.5269258022,
0.1908315718,
0.2277168036,
0.2727712989,
-0.8147716522,
0.4483416677,
-0.4319647551,
-0.3170266449,
-0.2849963009,
-0.4296287596,
-1.0424019098,
0.4424472153,
-0.347222358,
-0.4157336354,
0.1650169343,
-0.0913067758,
-0.1526584923,
0.3754217327,
-0.5255323052,
0.7469089627,
-0.2460511327,
-0.2420664877,
0.3535485864,
-0.5731203556,
0.5870124698,
-0.1399966031,
0.2454888672,
0.4756484032,
0.018553596,
0.6327105761,
-0.0181715414,
0.7996013761,
0.0513618141,
0.0268867034,
-0.092053242,
0.2651869357,
0.6487377882,
-0.1096065193,
-0.2617657483,
0.1414829344,
-0.252699405,
-0.229582727,
-0.7693683505,
0.4704296887,
-0.7060276866,
-0.7841430306,
-0.450312078,
-0.4903868437,
0.0135239977,
0.1607877016,
0.4693264365,
0.4104295373,
-0.3930324614,
0.4604003131,
0.8504494429,
-0.292158097,
0.4973342419,
0.5175510645,
0.1612877101,
-0.5193442702,
0.7870432138,
-0.1514942944,
0.5911453366,
0.351870954,
0.1800321341,
-0.3405128419,
-0.5294058323,
-0.4895625114,
-0.137594223,
-0.8934697509,
-0.4863563478,
-0.7736124396,
-0.6096055508,
-0.6943774819,
-0.1035660431,
-0.5841414928,
-0.4038358033,
-0.2791919708,
0.1163873225,
0.1618880183,
0.6540803909,
0.1519477963,
0.3488018811,
-0.4105852246,
0.593754828,
0.3155293167,
0.0897917226,
-0.281449616,
-0.8039735556,
-0.0519528314,
0.3902895749,
-0.4063853323,
-0.9743719697,
0.6899565458,
0.2477990687,
0.5461745858,
0.3535522819,
0.2606346011,
0.5541323423,
-0.1645776331,
0.7933840752,
-0.0369311273,
-0.7910380363,
0.556589365,
-0.1266397536,
0.3682142496,
0.2026831657,
0.2028091699,
-0.0762157217,
-0.8163171411,
-0.6298018098,
-0.9205037951,
0.8878512383,
0.7799549699,
0.1311539114,
0.0832805187,
0.0929869339,
-0.3519446254,
-0.1091742367,
-1.0202637911,
-0.3588884473,
-0.6925175786,
0.0687603056,
-0.0052149142,
-0.3242413104,
-0.4671775401,
0.1326136291,
0.7586351633,
-0.0068586501,
0.085509561,
-0.10723342,
-0.2164689302,
0.3090460896,
0.4715352952,
0.5281043053,
0.2078187913,
-0.0183724668,
0.2241126001,
0.184473142,
-0.6591107845,
-0.0252825338,
0.1643252373,
-0.2227334678,
0.073721163,
0.5855025053,
0.6818063855,
0.4144876003,
-0.3900308907,
0.8689231277,
-0.4113924205,
0.0466519706,
-0.0658915043,
0.1220862269,
-0.1508642286,
0.205906719,
0.0771769136,
0.5830334425,
0.1005969197,
-0.4315677285,
-0.0055461167,
0.7889302969,
-0.0337449349,
-0.1701499373,
0.5645566583,
-0.2741580009,
-0.4932416379,
0.4911747873,
-0.092238754,
-0.8818615675,
0.76760149,
0.8848330379,
0.9364196062,
-0.6681003571,
0.2693124115,
0.3004494607,
0.9356421232,
-0.1694450676,
-0.3502369821,
0.06491258,
-0.7340332866,
0.009166697,
-0.7288902402,
-0.366469115,
0.3938792646,
-1.0004948378,
0.078785345,
-0.3539936841,
-0.1168217957,
-0.0588278323,
-0.38776353,
-0.3872077465,
0.1111792624,
-0.071898438,
0.7727378011,
-0.860753417,
0.5527959466,
0.4804235697,
-0.1326175183,
-0.2308335155,
-0.0621668138,
0.042281542,
-0.7163555622,
0.2786102593,
0.1503674984,
-0.4338435233,
-0.3728432059,
-0.2945894897,
-0.7608090639,
0.9069735408,
0.8227111101,
-0.1870080531,
0.1615612358,
0.4095458984,
0.7213020325,
-0.0770845041,
0.1823759973,
0.8463423848,
0.2876519561,
0.1987376362,
-0.442797184,
0.0154243214,
-0.5438345075,
0.2475570887,
0.068253994,
-0.169178918,
0.8054004312,
0.177738592,
-0.7371379137,
0.1477237642,
0.2872958481,
-0.0617435351,
0.0103862472,
0.3985207081,
0.5915227532,
0.5509845614,
-0.2284013182,
1.1979862452,
-0.2767246962,
0.027953973,
0.9054976106,
0.2724681497,
0.7565365434,
0.260748148,
-0.0290964711,
0.147714287,
0.1166838259,
-0.1600601226,
0.5345521569,
0.0314253792,
-0.4118697941,
-0.0026586354,
0.0535542704,
-0.3599826992,
0.4944900572,
0.3548409641,
-0.3778928518,
-0.2035511285,
0.1978753358,
0.1133470684,
0.2775702477,
-0.0467085987,
0.7454012632,
-0.262314558,
-0.6213670969,
0.7047774196,
0.3185837567,
0.7537559271,
-1.024571538,
0.2211875021,
-0.2040771097,
0.2672353387,
-0.1832074374,
-0.7568192482,
0.6963458657,
0.2569983304,
-0.2495658696,
-0.2667591274,
0.9015946388,
-0.2764722407,
-0.5228772163,
0.4566249549,
-0.184225589,
-0.1661921889,
-0.2741700709,
-0.5817885399,
0.336909622,
0.0052013788,
-0.3364072144,
0.4424972236,
0.1361233294,
0.2688745856,
0.9639342427,
0.8497158885,
0.1496234983,
0.303030014,
0.1614570767,
1.2544203997,
-0.303422302,
-0.1978901476,
-1.0526455641,
0.3600222766,
-0.1803966612,
0.0434249826,
0.9214037061,
0.4789315462,
0.6538304687,
-0.1179746836,
0.6730502844,
0.0958313793,
0.0638442189,
-0.5206298232,
0.9876375198,
-0.0560961291,
0.584051609,
-0.1427719742,
-0.5664842725,
-0.5359313488,
0.5385950804,
-0.0825351402,
-0.2829256356,
0.3953801692,
1.2016688585,
-0.1278479546,
0.1817174256,
0.4067510962,
0.0741239563,
0.6460213661,
0.5892959833,
0.7694557905,
-0.8640142679,
0.9626175761,
-0.4955383837,
-0.3160457611,
0.1829208732,
-0.7368530035,
-0.9250358939,
-0.2784257233,
-0.1655089557,
-0.3579429686,
0.2958129048,
-0.0201820824,
0.5316984057,
-0.7361091971,
0.157548219,
-0.1906667203,
0.0612317212,
-0.1328542829,
-0.2931232154,
0.1990008801,
-0.3055627048,
-0.6401120424,
0.7766453028,
0.2614118159,
0.1460471451,
-0.3808585107,
-0.0112559153,
-0.1112548634,
0.1270001084,
0.4819321036,
0.4889957905,
-0.7092418075,
-0.0525199473,
0.014312923,
-0.105857715,
-0.2567383051,
0.5090591311,
-0.5957649946,
0.8003621697,
0.2688647509,
1.0008111,
0.2127131969,
-0.1031185612,
0.6464388967,
-0.8596576452,
0.3114254773,
0.4619555473,
0.3173550963,
0.5042898059,
-0.4802237451,
0.3784609437,
-0.0347595885,
-0.4016411304,
-1.0154412985,
0.432330966,
-0.4768148363,
-0.1769586354,
0.9451559186,
-0.4878196716,
-0.328448981,
-0.2942242026,
-0.0212941859,
0.1853504628,
0.0948928371,
0.867721498,
0.6191202402,
0.3085207045,
-0.1431063861,
-0.4002024531,
0.5253167152,
0.3510646224,
-0.6895888448,
0.1759299785,
0.038142994,
0.1123033389,
0.4057115614,
0.1311271191,
-0.2753658593,
0.2324672788,
0.3897812068,
-0.3974254131,
-0.2537185848,
-0.3129987717,
-0.6596080065,
0.3423937261,
-0.341058135,
-0.3830710053
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09841v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09841v1
|
LAPDoc: Layout-Aware Prompting for Documents
| 2024-02-15T10:00:49 | 2024-02-15T10:00:49 |
Marcel Lamott, Yves-Noel Weweler, Adrian Ulges, Faisal Shafait, Dirk Krechel, Darko Obradovic
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
Recent advances in training large language models (LLMs) using massive
amounts of solely textual data lead to strong generalization across many
domains and tasks, including document-specific tasks. Opposed to that there is
a trend to train multi-modal transformer architectures tailored for document
understanding that are designed specifically to fuse textual inputs with the
corresponding document layout. This involves a separate fine-tuning step for
which additional training data is required. At present, no document
transformers with comparable generalization to LLMs are available That raises
the question which type of model is to be preferred for document understanding
tasks. In this paper we investigate the possibility to use purely text-based
LLMs for document-specific tasks by using layout enrichment. We explore drop-in
modifications and rule-based methods to enrich purely textual LLM prompts with
layout information. In our experiments we investigate the effects on the
commercial ChatGPT model and the open-source LLM Solar. We demonstrate that
using our approach both LLMs show improved performance on various standard
document benchmarks. In addition, we study the impact of noisy OCR and layout
errors, as well as the limitations of LLMs when it comes to utilizing document
layout. Our results indicate that layout enrichment can improve the performance
of purely text-based LLMs for document understanding by up to 15% compared to
just using plain document text. In conclusion, this approach should be
considered for the best model choice between text-based LLM or multi-modal
document transformers.
|
[
-0.2406578213,
-0.8062898517,
1.020255208,
0.2797050476,
-0.1695897877,
-0.0592812225,
-0.3308880031,
-0.1637581587,
-0.0753459111,
0.5292657018,
-0.5814293027,
-0.607108295,
-0.4048652947,
0.1358324736,
-0.3908403516,
0.7709324956,
-0.3087690175,
0.1004003957,
-0.6960334182,
0.2066232115,
-0.6192258596,
-0.0990326703,
-0.2271753848,
-0.2551187873,
0.4153289199,
0.4309681654,
0.4107471108,
0.6266003847,
0.360616833,
0.2980628312,
-0.3553815484,
0.5513355136,
-0.1241002157,
0.3458374143,
-0.1076977029,
-0.4341615438,
-0.448197484,
0.0820026472,
0.4375599027,
0.7103409171,
-0.0748340338,
-0.3578028083,
0.1477927119,
0.5169106722,
-0.6049050689,
-0.0105932448,
-0.4022701979,
0.1372406632,
-0.0223899856,
-0.4700155556,
-0.7582793236,
-0.1340146512,
-0.0660909042,
-0.8871459961,
0.4794397354,
0.1321504116,
0.6068905592,
0.1968911439,
-0.3578526974,
-0.6005923748,
-0.5612802505,
0.5354661942,
-0.1985540837,
0.6098815203,
0.3651622534,
-0.1731905937,
-0.0811812878,
-0.7809307575,
-0.5824961662,
-0.3054106236,
-0.3745689392,
0.5159047246,
0.2362148315,
0.1950273663,
0.4113420844,
0.686668694,
-0.6298304796,
0.1541104317,
-0.3264381289,
-0.0691850111,
0.2091705948,
0.1291172355,
0.5718402863,
-0.4466000795,
-0.3144248128,
-0.2975284159,
-0.6435800195,
-0.0332116,
0.3330740035,
0.0964967236,
-0.320779562,
0.572299242,
0.2109708637,
0.8992062211,
0.1575994194,
-0.1041352153,
-0.0467300974,
-0.3559168279,
-0.4058043361,
-0.0854751393,
0.8154385686,
0.1154109985,
-0.10089086,
-0.2117421031,
-0.098227784,
-0.2159868479,
0.5775951743,
-0.5866574645,
-0.1809345484,
0.2669141591,
-0.3553768694,
-0.4080633223,
-0.013209695,
-0.5077168941,
-0.9101762176,
-0.5318553448,
0.2405278534,
-0.7078992128,
0.3756148219,
0.1266208738,
-0.4003258646,
0.2901311517,
1.0251017809,
-1.0579923391,
-0.0000966745,
0.6967099905,
0.8262428641,
-0.224649936,
-0.2938826084,
-0.7287756801,
0.2000264227,
-0.3803144693,
1.0595654249,
-0.5816830993,
-0.9258401394,
0.0799906999,
-0.002906736,
-0.4134698808,
-0.3512872159,
1.1493656635,
-0.3773220778,
0.931829989,
-0.3058627546,
-0.5918259025,
0.2520929277,
0.3129348457,
-0.5645776987,
0.9886850715,
0.2686269879,
-0.9297119975,
0.3307051361,
-0.851716578,
-0.6583238244,
0.0659460574,
-0.439716965,
-0.2293983996,
0.0744287893,
0.5939562321,
0.3175842762,
-0.0593840182,
-0.0231841113,
0.078404434,
-0.2988464534,
0.0578929745,
-0.3238984048,
0.3754517734,
0.3592264354,
0.0733805373,
0.3369853497,
-0.6873245835,
-0.3210409284,
-0.0347329453,
-0.6803274155,
-0.3431586027,
-0.1744471043,
0.2264968157,
0.0467596464,
0.2834785581,
-0.4726900756,
0.3657420576,
-0.3707086742,
0.1093778908,
0.767577529,
-0.1332818419,
1.0480282307,
-0.4789164364,
0.7224658132,
-0.330260098,
-0.0826223344,
-0.7660422921,
-0.2763718069,
-0.4567733705,
-0.6935159564,
0.2358099669,
0.5685726404,
-0.509557724,
0.5122057796,
-0.2131730616,
-0.1223279908,
-0.2791159153,
0.2081719041,
0.1036886126,
0.8428188562,
0.1921114028,
-0.0707333237,
-0.4716129005,
-0.5913058519,
-0.2016417831,
0.1633418202,
-0.1630412638,
0.4480975866,
-0.0202259477,
0.0321301445,
0.7634679079,
-0.4804238081,
-0.3331851661,
-0.6562384367,
0.0008217568,
0.1984854788,
0.2241690457,
0.2071147114,
-0.8121834993,
-0.8368250728,
0.0708349273,
-0.7000619173,
-0.2570407987,
-0.4264245629,
-0.1081454158,
0.0284254961,
0.8220639229,
-0.9433280826,
0.3119593263,
0.330502212,
-0.0716278031,
0.356972456,
-0.5619055629,
0.0356443487,
-1.3673295975,
-0.0404253043,
0.0555777252,
-0.1778726578,
-0.8108405471,
0.0420164913,
0.6649022698,
-0.39326334,
-0.2672237456,
0.8109621406,
-0.6067050099,
-0.040106006,
-0.2927925289,
0.4812084734,
0.6594104767,
0.0582958683,
0.3727135658,
1.0304722786,
0.1928367317,
-0.4072372317,
-0.0764208287,
0.6926393509,
-0.4302521348,
0.6801623106,
-0.4817936718,
0.1806439459,
-0.3132399619,
0.5748400092,
-1.1005057096,
-0.4163500369,
0.0740415081,
-0.1936150491,
0.7728908658,
-0.0159774851,
-0.3876627386,
-0.1436692476,
-0.6005139947,
-0.1646541506,
0.2980000675,
-0.8481968045,
0.8658991456,
-0.1755018532,
-0.2197364569,
-0.5297452807,
-0.4492829144,
0.0515139103,
-0.2243901938,
-0.9979774356,
0.6572133303,
-0.0286809057,
-0.0254769288,
-0.5095008612,
-0.2054107934,
0.4279274344,
0.0992481261,
0.4182482362,
0.3319672048,
-0.0256764162,
0.192644313,
0.2194501907,
0.0568491705,
-0.2043946683,
-0.2495718747,
0.7024175525,
0.2331988961,
-0.5296552181,
-0.4342432618,
0.3685383201,
0.4589316249,
-0.4272757769,
0.8036165833,
0.5951717496,
0.0580199435,
-0.2428215444,
-0.6005523205,
0.0546685793,
-0.550978601,
0.1982223243,
-0.3788750172,
-0.7845119834,
0.4036980569,
-0.2810404003,
0.1255747825,
0.2624956369,
0.5325814486,
-0.5631846189,
0.5943789482,
0.6839354038,
0.1238487512,
0.8511530161,
-0.1631058455,
0.1738782674,
-1.2745498419,
-0.3738889396,
-0.6333481669,
-0.1374910921,
-0.3367052078,
-0.6795243025,
0.4638516903,
0.0427678861,
0.1852855533,
0.0388053693,
-0.4440865815,
0.5905976892,
0.3910945058,
0.0078083645,
0.3674755991,
0.2004157901,
-0.2598229647,
0.0527315736,
-0.5231637359,
-0.6258043647,
0.8446957469,
0.2311467379,
1.1324204206,
-0.0965910107,
0.7978541851,
0.1008241698,
0.0307518747,
-0.7650911808,
0.3270456195,
-0.2201412022,
-0.075962007,
-0.3002087772,
-0.1728065312,
-1.1214072704,
0.2825339735,
0.0260038711,
-0.7974648476,
0.3053354025,
-0.0835944712,
-0.1963999271,
0.0615672395,
-0.7050824165,
0.6918048859,
-0.1500505656,
-0.2131012231,
0.011468594,
-0.2291226685,
0.073331058,
0.0554338507,
0.3597779274,
0.3518660963,
-0.0699598119,
0.2981616259,
-0.3835323155,
0.6914237738,
0.0547690094,
-0.5086643696,
-0.0413709246,
0.1694385409,
0.941699326,
0.064035967,
-0.2221693099,
-0.6984419823,
-0.3669762015,
-0.1156305149,
-0.6810727715,
0.869820714,
-0.7818641663,
-0.7765769362,
-0.0677005053,
-0.8820974231,
-0.3829161823,
0.1647125334,
0.5369443297,
0.602481544,
-0.2528009117,
0.2336261272,
1.2240512371,
-0.3797652721,
0.2430835068,
0.349703908,
-0.1148684323,
-0.031096898,
0.6240565181,
-0.3813704848,
0.0733135119,
0.8678328395,
0.2449612319,
-0.5275967717,
-0.6097386479,
-0.506003499,
0.1747426987,
-0.9343991876,
0.1235512197,
-1.1000396013,
-0.1893012077,
-0.4322551191,
-0.6081701517,
-0.0031842119,
-0.5250105858,
-0.5112592578,
-0.2544630468,
0.1813601106,
0.6840296984,
0.1046023518,
0.3854388297,
-0.7391028404,
0.4327737689,
0.3272276521,
0.2114453018,
-0.2279352099,
-0.7632116675,
-0.0656787306,
-0.3385355771,
-0.5457491875,
-0.7557480931,
0.1223758906,
0.0347448401,
0.6700673699,
0.3209238648,
-0.1108464226,
0.2568578124,
-0.35995996,
0.8323222995,
0.0130496649,
-0.6784264445,
0.7668446302,
-0.83894521,
0.4881398678,
0.4143035114,
0.2034607083,
-0.7474412918,
-0.3272090852,
-0.5509968996,
-0.659917295,
1.0206955671,
0.0693307817,
0.2661338449,
0.0923227519,
0.3693355918,
0.1503518075,
0.0335694775,
-0.5028816462,
0.1790195853,
-0.177876696,
-0.3739431202,
0.0799452066,
-0.1473374069,
-0.197900638,
0.1176946238,
0.4588315487,
-0.0952286795,
0.0454868637,
0.3272012174,
-0.4711006284,
0.0478955731,
0.6281273961,
0.8157714605,
0.629611969,
-0.1871270686,
-0.001734496,
0.1259973794,
-0.4654472768,
0.0294626281,
0.117703326,
-0.1967251301,
-0.0446784608,
0.3971498609,
0.8638106585,
0.0479398444,
-0.3660182357,
0.4340979159,
-0.3164277971,
-0.3516475558,
0.1187553033,
0.1782296747,
0.1897209585,
-0.0558343083,
0.0774238557,
-0.143890813,
0.0342016555,
-0.3380978107,
-0.1619592905,
0.4580211341,
-0.2222162336,
0.0415820964,
0.485283941,
0.2781024575,
-0.277561307,
0.5376695395,
-0.0321617126,
-0.2713278234,
0.5033649206,
0.4952505231,
0.6721546054,
0.0038178621,
0.4014705718,
0.0553659722,
0.2248979211,
0.0645013303,
0.0848005712,
-0.461673975,
-0.5333989263,
-0.3590606451,
-0.6162295341,
-0.5298967957,
0.2235955745,
-0.3878491819,
0.3058104515,
-0.4823915064,
0.271382004,
-0.0448666029,
-0.0827707797,
-0.5691915154,
0.1344268918,
0.288857013,
1.1386237144,
-0.6030746102,
0.6257548332,
1.0650262833,
-0.1022467539,
-0.6568626165,
0.1083604991,
0.0328272916,
-0.6994830966,
0.30383268,
0.0384267084,
-0.0403862111,
-0.3802237809,
-0.3244684339,
-0.43689394,
1.0426971912,
0.1844438612,
-0.4180534184,
-0.1668880582,
0.1523356885,
0.4594119489,
-0.3181269467,
0.3727681637,
0.2740670145,
0.5187559724,
0.2041387856,
-0.6919032931,
0.095948711,
-0.186856091,
0.306461364,
0.2695909739,
-0.6073843241,
0.6887177825,
-0.0086761536,
-0.1372415274,
0.1875462383,
0.5126229525,
0.3149282932,
0.2197050154,
0.3424776495,
0.4364587963,
1.0886304379,
0.0610083491,
1.4763044119,
-0.1978851706,
-0.0320559554,
1.2514699697,
-0.2656201124,
0.3715831637,
0.4476372898,
-0.1184568778,
0.4828003645,
0.6163876057,
0.1704283655,
0.4737109244,
-0.143666327,
-0.2090221047,
-0.2790486813,
-0.0940234065,
-0.4789579809,
0.3002826273,
0.543148458,
-0.536813736,
-0.2900754809,
0.0152607728,
-0.0156815071,
0.2764857113,
-0.0727711916,
0.8994776607,
0.1357186139,
-0.5972337127,
0.0631973073,
0.2790157199,
0.6092644334,
-0.7038694024,
0.3142678142,
-0.5394103527,
-0.040387664,
-0.4084844887,
-0.8839418292,
0.0034482467,
-0.0889804959,
-0.5554606915,
-0.6224110723,
1.01940763,
-0.2630788684,
-0.3518408537,
-0.0709507167,
0.5541018844,
-0.2142387629,
-0.1735182256,
-0.2303622365,
0.0644083843,
0.0493713953,
-0.1514589787,
0.7718533874,
0.5406888723,
-0.088589102,
0.3494676948,
0.7238453031,
-0.1659520864,
-0.1263812333,
0.4844722152,
0.9183766842,
-0.3440905511,
-0.7126621604,
-0.6458085775,
0.5088569522,
-0.3126668632,
-0.0404655002,
0.7362565398,
0.5688877702,
0.4008160532,
-0.1771115065,
0.9805506468,
0.1754251122,
0.3141182661,
-0.7875565886,
0.6687218547,
-0.5988111496,
0.4923013747,
-0.2949732542,
-1.0680397749,
0.0166392587,
0.5777435899,
-0.5316283107,
-0.0154760592,
0.7817425132,
0.640678823,
-0.3209435642,
0.2897735536,
0.2370626926,
-0.2548522949,
0.4985657632,
0.062378794,
1.0651872158,
-0.1168745384,
0.4982488453,
-0.0892922655,
-0.1015405357,
-0.1790074706,
-0.7852458358,
-1.0143954754,
-0.5473749638,
-0.2219531685,
-0.2607087791,
-0.2464391142,
0.634334445,
0.4770512581,
-0.39036268,
-0.0380792879,
-0.1010686085,
0.4259181917,
0.3221238554,
-0.2261969745,
0.5634208918,
-0.6970472336,
-0.6141727567,
0.8241442442,
0.4686938524,
0.2182980329,
0.0667580664,
-0.0218643546,
0.0633294806,
0.1969883144,
0.5044086576,
0.0877444744,
-0.4769013226,
0.0935938582,
0.1433051527,
-0.3059907258,
0.3992104828,
1.0357050896,
-0.5188279748,
0.5186782479,
0.7461588383,
0.5189702511,
0.6234648824,
0.2016980052,
0.6987798214,
-0.9666326642,
0.2516414523,
-0.1208917797,
0.4766553342,
0.611218214,
-0.7302504778,
0.3449826837,
-0.2567492127,
-0.379846096,
-0.5430353284,
0.1329133213,
-0.9770056605,
-0.3003872335,
1.1805729866,
0.0187126845,
-0.2179657817,
0.0617717654,
-0.6370928884,
-0.0520561263,
-0.4872459471,
0.5905653238,
0.7367139459,
-0.2791900933,
-0.3929287493,
-0.2652511895,
0.5507611632,
0.4397441745,
-1.0463296175,
0.0812487975,
0.4815198481,
0.0220753141,
0.2946775258,
0.7222723961,
-0.1624260247,
0.4460916221,
-0.2105094194,
-0.2724339664,
-0.2301499695,
-0.3004139066,
-0.3517249823,
0.1082586497,
0.1318817884,
0.076593563
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09808v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09808v2
|
Knowledge of Pretrained Language Models on Surface Information of Tokens
| 2024-02-15T09:14:53 | 2024-02-22T15:11:57 |
Tatsuya Hiraoka, Naoaki Okazaki
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Do pretrained language models have knowledge regarding the surface
information of tokens? We examined the surface information stored in word or
subword embeddings acquired by pretrained language models from the perspectives
of token length, substrings, and token constitution. Additionally, we evaluated
the ability of models to generate knowledge regarding token surfaces. We
focused on 12 pretrained language models that were mainly trained on English
and Japanese corpora. Experimental results demonstrate that pretrained language
models have knowledge regarding token length and substrings but not token
constitution. Additionally, the results imply that there is a bottleneck on the
decoder side in terms of effectively utilizing acquired knowledge.
|
[
-0.3009026647,
-0.7613648772,
0.7505662441,
-0.2270090878,
-0.4226723611,
0.0639711171,
-0.149016276,
-0.4064207971,
0.2253292054,
0.5312257409,
-0.234188199,
-0.5963823199,
-0.8282473683,
-0.1731288433,
-0.3439418972,
0.7220628262,
-0.0616475195,
0.1970582157,
-0.6182783246,
-0.0993680507,
-0.3609264195,
-0.9313929081,
-0.3074156344,
-0.1878977567,
0.2950780988,
0.2109196186,
0.4335497618,
0.6697941422,
0.3862676322,
0.2860604525,
-0.0360904746,
0.0119792772,
-0.3940370381,
-0.2546524405,
-0.1782670319,
-0.8058143854,
-0.212642327,
0.095786266,
0.4965938032,
1.0905390978,
0.0284002833,
0.1075867787,
-0.0466080718,
0.3496960998,
-0.6735758185,
0.0933729038,
-0.7553792,
0.2216019034,
-0.2512583137,
-0.2225931436,
-0.3919605911,
0.0053291172,
0.2046393305,
-0.8793480396,
0.2721526921,
0.1008561626,
0.8229486346,
-0.0151482904,
-0.4332222641,
-0.3138040602,
-0.3940374255,
0.5358273387,
-0.5386641622,
0.8323786259,
0.6339293718,
-0.0186048839,
-0.0634316728,
-0.9071366787,
-0.3239773214,
-0.3952827156,
-0.3119928837,
0.0370535366,
-0.1836039275,
0.2380131036,
0.3822747171,
0.172519803,
-0.2808402181,
0.2970635295,
-0.5504292846,
-0.3288340271,
0.2628038228,
-0.1121617481,
0.5476852059,
-0.012672198,
-0.6005119681,
0.2008823752,
-1.0194662809,
0.1496810466,
0.3460553288,
0.212380752,
-0.1234129965,
0.7079925537,
0.0082467087,
0.5176982284,
-0.2287880927,
-0.0890506804,
0.1643037647,
-0.3241640031,
0.0292819906,
-0.0962394252,
0.5832913518,
-0.0521621518,
0.4060212672,
-0.6376295686,
-0.3761025369,
-0.24013111,
0.1589121372,
-0.7399831414,
-0.1253489256,
-0.244309172,
-0.5295826793,
0.1492941678,
0.4323720634,
-0.1963543147,
-0.2917305827,
-0.3494420052,
0.5088455677,
-0.5142115951,
-0.5646950006,
0.0980111286,
-0.6462389231,
0.0849632174,
0.0120173292,
-0.9046370387,
0.3774550259,
0.7155162692,
0.7001094222,
-0.0841341391,
-0.5042559505,
-0.3767408133,
-0.0605921783,
-0.3909648955,
0.6955566406,
-0.7653585672,
-0.6789478064,
0.051226899,
-0.0536792837,
-0.3749668002,
-0.4357149601,
-0.163328141,
-0.7321659923,
-0.0417764448,
-0.4807651937,
-1.0290899277,
0.1403747946,
0.0716756955,
-0.5246058106,
0.6286817193,
0.1187857613,
-1.0724415779,
0.6667158008,
-0.4596508145,
-0.5539601445,
0.0459717512,
-0.3546725214,
0.0772244334,
0.7153173089,
0.1148302257,
0.1474167258,
0.1652526408,
0.0885597095,
-0.1036445424,
-0.4054763317,
0.4923465848,
-0.1850548983,
0.5042869449,
0.2290846109,
-0.0470988192,
-0.1230509505,
-0.6379608512,
-0.1097315475,
-0.1591571271,
-0.5150456429,
-0.5025537014,
-0.2293687016,
-0.2379765213,
0.0512553602,
0.5863759518,
-0.7985545397,
0.2659446001,
-0.1543550491,
0.4393164814,
0.5313872099,
-0.0716001242,
0.251139611,
-0.0202358086,
0.6225078106,
0.4862009585,
-0.1237413883,
-0.1792142838,
-0.3517501354,
-0.8715455532,
0.0535813235,
0.7002024651,
0.2238893658,
-0.6771332622,
0.3087804615,
-0.2675597668,
-0.4468506575,
-0.3204834759,
-0.0114140585,
0.6441084743,
0.2148314118,
0.2147437185,
-0.3715704083,
-0.5622074604,
-0.8401203752,
-0.6127855778,
-0.0678460672,
0.1234400123,
0.2833042145,
0.5706037879,
-0.1037039757,
1.0916064978,
-0.4009203315,
0.0152489329,
-0.3328462541,
0.5012751818,
-0.2194599807,
0.5796905756,
0.6187684536,
-0.4280209541,
-0.1026950181,
-0.0972767696,
-0.4581044614,
0.0166580379,
0.218807891,
-0.0893101171,
0.1504645944,
1.073448658,
-0.6872353554,
0.5370672345,
0.551930666,
-0.4646302164,
0.40337345,
-0.6106916666,
-0.3547946811,
-0.8844895959,
0.2261238098,
-0.4371963739,
-0.3827446401,
-0.7524675131,
-0.2179442197,
0.0550081283,
-0.0470615551,
-0.3581523597,
0.7077357769,
-0.6697035432,
-0.5094488859,
-0.5611958504,
0.2307510376,
-0.0171691272,
0.4802737236,
0.5255451202,
0.8717278242,
0.4826841652,
-0.7716271281,
-0.2334087044,
0.0417529717,
-0.6790114045,
-0.0111314924,
-0.4312202036,
0.4660199881,
-0.1623343229,
-0.0427899584,
-0.8459909558,
0.0779875219,
-0.3188797832,
-0.3084073663,
0.2542473674,
-0.1454583257,
-0.207187131,
-0.2420095801,
0.3376619816,
0.4564619958,
0.4247637987,
-0.3272897005,
0.36462304,
0.7143025398,
0.0540557951,
-0.4712337852,
-0.7501276731,
-0.2468909919,
0.0215256568,
-0.1048520878,
0.3549479544,
0.3714708984,
-0.0407496803,
0.189468801,
-0.0964979753,
-0.0491492189,
0.1014221236,
0.2858420014,
-0.1116852462,
-0.2273133993,
0.3107557297,
-0.0601739585,
-0.1035648063,
0.0789577365,
-0.5220234394,
0.9253857136,
-0.2045679837,
-0.5360787511,
-0.163820073,
0.0776764229,
0.5447589755,
-0.4835073054,
1.0074625015,
0.3808114231,
-0.5604249835,
0.1127915457,
-0.5762447119,
-0.1184957922,
-0.4142736197,
0.5732730031,
-0.6848847866,
-0.9597169757,
0.791551888,
-0.1855025291,
-0.2185939699,
0.5414071083,
0.126820311,
0.1113807335,
1.083733201,
1.1458505392,
0.1854397655,
0.652366817,
-0.3757929206,
0.0181665681,
-0.7434339523,
-0.4160679579,
-0.3466257751,
-0.2774518728,
-0.5518776178,
-0.2513053715,
0.0542378835,
0.5116308331,
-0.3310567439,
0.2640285492,
0.0713999197,
0.4788296223,
0.731952548,
0.1258532703,
0.1222227514,
-0.0766435862,
-0.4462558031,
0.0891754776,
-0.924721837,
-0.4419701695,
1.0282744169,
0.4884230793,
0.5848479867,
-0.2727072835,
0.5349650383,
-0.0462607704,
0.0507628098,
-0.460003227,
0.3147104084,
-0.2595266104,
-0.5613630414,
-0.1712226272,
-0.4681838155,
-0.8973495364,
-0.0470086597,
-0.1295475364,
-0.6248853803,
0.4605476558,
-0.0141688967,
-0.1816533208,
0.2930074036,
-0.5260686278,
0.9411991835,
-0.5298643112,
0.2972615659,
-0.2715386152,
-0.4231808186,
0.0050732717,
-0.1335214674,
0.2703550756,
-0.0086328723,
-0.0473365523,
1.3512603045,
-0.7598398328,
0.6945570707,
-0.5584285259,
-0.0079345517,
0.3138684332,
-0.0973175243,
0.2400026768,
-0.1055651382,
0.173925817,
0.3303722739,
0.2730318904,
-0.3509780765,
-0.4553832114,
0.2142380923,
-1.0078312159,
-0.6172041893,
-0.069712773,
-0.1966494918,
-0.3711138964,
0.4624467194,
0.778521359,
0.618963778,
-0.2973484695,
0.2296418846,
0.2588026822,
-0.3066698313,
0.2348082066,
0.4944963157,
-0.5270097256,
-0.1125184819,
0.7232861519,
0.4064382613,
0.2361845672,
0.3184806108,
0.1985205114,
-0.377694726,
-0.7030208707,
-0.201301083,
0.1997973323,
-0.7665970922,
-0.1617971659,
-0.5289504528,
-0.4137439728,
-0.2422802448,
0.1784015745,
-0.6338795424,
-0.598528266,
-0.133540839,
-0.3534085751,
0.3233933747,
1.2016061544,
-0.0294810645,
0.5866972208,
-0.9088804722,
0.0475611202,
0.0795987621,
0.4968629181,
-0.1898738593,
-0.6245570779,
-0.6058536768,
0.4423084557,
0.1779721379,
-0.6971797943,
0.068125844,
0.1286202073,
0.7248636484,
0.5299196839,
-0.1529916525,
0.4847329259,
-0.5592426062,
0.902972579,
0.1921572238,
-1.0555467606,
0.293541044,
-0.0932062864,
0.2221882641,
0.5435029268,
0.4668421447,
-0.5415431261,
-0.5235944986,
-0.7307365537,
-0.4092521667,
0.6293371916,
-0.2129065841,
0.5059233308,
-0.2020269632,
0.4652347565,
0.3972505927,
0.4620767236,
-0.3993775249,
0.0538004152,
-0.4289953709,
-0.0309295468,
0.0291738324,
-0.2795573175,
0.0885496363,
-0.2174635231,
0.2168044001,
0.1675497591,
0.4213441312,
-0.0485909656,
-0.709747076,
0.2011837661,
0.0693482384,
0.5387128592,
1.1285941601,
-0.0291185565,
0.4017775655,
0.3171289563,
-0.7423454523,
-0.0093132714,
-0.1542438865,
0.0441636816,
0.0377403088,
0.6774454117,
1.244572401,
0.1074892282,
-0.5756004453,
0.654235363,
-0.2012275308,
-0.3632780015,
-0.1430121213,
-0.0180673487,
0.1108722687,
-0.003341011,
0.101563476,
-0.160247907,
-0.3107984662,
-0.6423246861,
0.1679577976,
0.5814742446,
-0.2445822805,
-0.5311389565,
0.4402348697,
0.1725145131,
-0.1436091363,
0.9532712102,
0.1652800888,
-0.9229457378,
0.5232847333,
0.7810609341,
0.4942779541,
-0.0474949554,
-0.0852415934,
0.1874024421,
0.1874955595,
0.1556615382,
0.258353889,
-0.0640858412,
-1.0645771027,
-0.1371604353,
-0.7548738122,
-0.2879324555,
0.3318347931,
-0.594825387,
0.2065314502,
-0.6472396255,
-0.4167986512,
-0.3377926946,
-0.0219442695,
-1.1124755144,
0.2516154945,
0.2479159236,
1.0835530758,
-0.7677185535,
0.7731097341,
0.7541541457,
-0.5515440106,
-0.8692475557,
-0.1691953838,
-0.7903794646,
-0.8900675178,
1.036736846,
0.3799008429,
-0.1495453864,
0.1788649559,
-0.3093373477,
-1.0699989796,
0.7499738932,
0.4027088284,
-0.5236604214,
-0.1283957809,
0.6072522402,
0.5806735754,
-0.4306759238,
0.3031513989,
0.5291121006,
0.3315480053,
-0.2467113882,
-0.9017350078,
-0.1461336911,
-0.4282804132,
0.0655249581,
-0.0654610023,
-0.370598197,
0.9421672225,
0.0082183164,
-0.479303509,
-0.135361895,
0.7994060516,
0.0276983976,
-0.1874571592,
0.5293952823,
0.8191716671,
0.8283146024,
-0.0366754681,
0.8793444633,
-0.6761427522,
0.1100718826,
0.6298279762,
-0.0610739999,
0.8589649796,
0.3459778428,
-0.0938966423,
0.6647474766,
0.5766531229,
0.4076090157,
0.7274566889,
0.3442641199,
0.1077877358,
-0.4451797605,
-0.0166205056,
-0.525924027,
0.7199570537,
0.4792996049,
-0.2847917974,
-0.0745869353,
0.5338948369,
0.0404735282,
-0.1983110458,
-0.1650067419,
1.0106928349,
0.251663655,
-0.8330547214,
0.5197806954,
0.2610471547,
0.5127159357,
-0.4292709827,
0.2897182107,
-0.4118670225,
0.2486532331,
0.0217949823,
-0.5447462201,
0.2792235315,
0.0362936594,
0.1852285862,
-0.1364417374,
0.9060685039,
-0.5624865294,
-0.3495530486,
0.0958386436,
0.6677975059,
0.3939359486,
-0.0493762232,
-0.2401350886,
-0.0447547995,
-0.3362112641,
-0.3568127751,
0.2478711009,
0.5740925074,
-0.0838781297,
0.2953069508,
0.5392818451,
0.1589915156,
0.5470952988,
0.2697746456,
0.8500131965,
-0.4840734005,
-0.4910107851,
-0.6788480878,
0.3696853518,
0.0398032106,
-0.3128748834,
0.6292721629,
0.7054919004,
0.9632627964,
-0.2098023891,
0.938146472,
0.1629119515,
0.4507395029,
-0.9576518536,
0.808146596,
-0.5536570549,
-0.0668534562,
0.077429384,
-0.9208985567,
0.0205943976,
0.7349573374,
-0.5609053969,
0.1613405645,
0.6445644498,
0.5413551331,
-0.2982704043,
-0.0112003582,
0.0983537361,
-0.1209180653,
0.2340105623,
0.2859546244,
1.0666042566,
-0.1729761809,
0.1428644508,
-0.1148846969,
0.0284785666,
-0.1470562518,
-0.7127202749,
-1.2460240126,
-0.7466511726,
0.0442152135,
0.1420783401,
0.0543718524,
0.6110424399,
0.5866430402,
-0.6020273566,
-0.1011273563,
-0.6556707621,
-0.1879037321,
0.2922388315,
-0.094627291,
0.6004828811,
-0.5801643133,
-0.3347245157,
0.3264763057,
-0.1511267573,
0.2226693928,
-0.1587015092,
-0.0910759121,
-0.0960680768,
0.2187564522,
0.2947380245,
0.1544522345,
-0.4684255123,
-0.4697244763,
0.1440498233,
-0.2313507646,
-0.1311990619,
1.1935815811,
-0.8267921805,
0.2031511217,
0.8861273527,
0.5668528676,
0.5756186843,
0.1443243027,
0.7791718841,
-1.1167035103,
0.484021157,
-0.1698858291,
0.7243142128,
0.324070394,
-0.1860423535,
0.0137549378,
0.3065300584,
-0.1492002904,
-0.7637786865,
0.2662183046,
-0.2221182585,
-0.5341684222,
0.9819620252,
-0.3809898198,
-0.2920413017,
0.013948705,
-0.060829673,
0.7262946963,
0.3326020539,
0.2379761189,
0.871032238,
0.1129192039,
-0.1705435514,
-0.2371191382,
0.765797317,
0.3872795999,
-0.718367517,
0.2123974264,
0.1148098186,
0.3939424753,
0.3552200496,
0.8204280138,
-0.070124343,
0.097276777,
0.3227751851,
-0.0651156381,
-0.5079222322,
-0.6719257236,
0.1428840756,
-0.1946647018,
0.2852953076,
-0.1973193586
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09801v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09801v2
|
EFUF: Efficient Fine-grained Unlearning Framework for Mitigating Hallucinations in Multimodal Large Language Models
| 2024-02-15T08:58:03 | 2024-06-24T00:50:58 |
Shangyu Xing, Fei Zhao, Zhen Wu, Tuo An, Weihao Chen, Chunhui Li, Jianbing Zhang, Xinyu Dai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Multimodal large language models (MLLMs) have attracted increasing attention
in the past few years, but they may still generate descriptions that include
objects not present in the corresponding images, a phenomenon known as object
hallucination. To eliminate hallucinations, existing methods manually annotate
paired responses with and without hallucinations, and then employ various
alignment algorithms to improve the alignment capability between images and
text. However, they not only demand considerable computation resources during
the finetuning stage but also require expensive human annotation to construct
paired data needed by the alignment algorithms. To address these issues, we
borrow the idea of unlearning and propose an efficient fine-grained unlearning
framework (EFUF), which can eliminate hallucinations without the need for
paired data. Extensive experiments show that our method consistently reduces
hallucinations while preserving the generation quality with modest
computational overhead. Our code and datasets will be publicly available.
|
[
-0.5007462502,
-1.0209600925,
0.3083629608,
0.1803266257,
-0.324442178,
-0.2321562022,
-0.4483155012,
-0.4954663217,
0.0384603627,
0.5807631016,
-0.4868264496,
-0.3928992152,
-0.2883606553,
-0.0172096249,
-0.4820348322,
0.9421264529,
0.1423359364,
0.1166705936,
-0.4968542457,
-0.0759170279,
-0.0872538537,
-0.5175043344,
-0.4441395998,
-0.4808536768,
0.4341218174,
0.4068022668,
0.7938700318,
0.5861541629,
0.5983877778,
0.2852401435,
0.2437581718,
0.4221022427,
-0.7737743258,
0.1476925015,
0.0168176517,
0.0878432244,
-0.1756443083,
-0.5774754286,
0.3469440937,
0.8983726501,
-0.4265970886,
-0.1807181835,
0.1402942538,
0.746137917,
-0.6415465474,
0.2036532909,
-0.5307629108,
0.3764096498,
-0.0267819501,
-0.325778991,
-0.4199287295,
0.1309820563,
0.0312153716,
-0.8059971333,
0.3376909494,
0.2348097116,
0.7373011708,
0.4772176743,
-0.1182456017,
-0.1837539971,
-0.6850264668,
0.8208779693,
-0.3980542421,
0.6163439155,
0.5924032331,
0.181374982,
-0.4595482647,
-0.7336002588,
-0.6322299242,
-0.1430725753,
-0.2127893716,
-0.1270945966,
0.0421504378,
0.3453785479,
0.1688508093,
0.3477187157,
-0.6827576756,
0.0999160931,
-0.3297123015,
-0.4732887745,
0.5833463669,
0.0872946009,
0.1241136789,
-0.1031504124,
-0.4346980751,
-0.0800725967,
-0.4395697713,
-0.1859715432,
0.260661006,
0.2731231153,
0.1118270382,
0.675550878,
-0.2202040106,
0.6247399449,
-0.0677842796,
-0.2452252507,
0.4574622214,
-0.050498385,
-0.4537070394,
0.1798238158,
0.7382709384,
0.7367352843,
0.4196624756,
-0.6392585635,
-0.3248877525,
0.0566638932,
0.259568274,
-0.9657608867,
-0.4595125914,
0.26917997,
-0.6104705334,
-0.3309670687,
0.1272419989,
-1.4270268679,
-0.5943613052,
-0.2984329164,
0.4996992946,
-0.3218732774,
-0.1170927435,
0.0940338001,
0.0235951375,
0.0624577887,
0.2112558931,
-0.9603583217,
0.246148482,
0.4947801232,
0.7179272175,
-0.128826037,
-0.5370941162,
-0.809262991,
0.2404157519,
-0.068590574,
0.7619181871,
-0.6896060109,
-0.4992359281,
0.0301739126,
0.1909148544,
0.2511043847,
-0.4548941255,
0.4463229179,
-0.0000799423,
0.1222594231,
-0.0612532422,
-0.4843570292,
-0.4286794662,
0.0562018156,
-0.5837728977,
0.9345979691,
-0.1070047021,
-0.4277154505,
0.05727873,
-0.5244799852,
-0.6221488714,
-0.1369071007,
-0.2651304007,
-0.4784460366,
0.3312399685,
0.4543424845,
0.6879812479,
-0.2223297358,
0.5739303231,
-0.5489746928,
-0.5489674807,
0.10488417,
-0.4665291905,
0.3084226549,
0.4085996449,
-0.5253316164,
0.2504499257,
-0.9098337293,
-0.1786037385,
0.2991044819,
0.0824881122,
-0.2920233011,
0.1075267121,
0.6405339837,
0.0766083375,
-0.0913754925,
-0.3642190993,
-0.0268606357,
-0.4108211994,
0.2479738742,
0.7597273588,
-0.1441489309,
0.53938061,
-0.4064364433,
0.0583522804,
0.3121190071,
0.2029334009,
-0.4004639983,
-0.3268980682,
-0.7741567492,
-0.274503231,
-0.1556369215,
0.1139423251,
-0.6263867021,
0.3612511158,
0.0614278801,
-0.2247145623,
-0.5768275261,
0.4081976712,
0.5706386566,
0.4783637822,
0.4821197391,
-0.1097217575,
-0.6169762015,
-0.9881365895,
0.1638552845,
0.222069189,
0.1329335421,
0.1787421405,
0.386762023,
-0.4891926944,
0.5461909771,
-0.6026021838,
-0.7041454911,
0.1519839317,
0.3051744103,
-0.601262629,
0.6727822423,
0.4711816311,
-0.96346277,
-0.0040225601,
0.080183208,
-0.866697669,
0.0381331407,
-0.2618338764,
-0.1250706166,
0.5618774891,
0.5213115215,
-0.4782449603,
0.3884215355,
0.450707972,
-0.3383473158,
0.1749990433,
-0.3602524102,
0.2055251747,
-1.0615494251,
0.056507118,
-0.0923076719,
-0.1231597364,
-0.5925661922,
0.1155461296,
-0.2747078538,
-0.0586917028,
-0.249643147,
0.4477340281,
-0.5494594574,
-0.0700846314,
-0.2658095062,
0.2810598016,
0.1226951778,
0.8066012859,
0.2021362036,
0.3451678455,
0.565897584,
-0.2603723407,
0.2125808448,
0.1709657013,
-0.0651307777,
0.5796980858,
-0.2006919086,
0.2808728814,
-0.461491704,
-0.0303190872,
-0.9085305333,
-0.5252428055,
0.1568800211,
-0.1540630758,
0.2507856488,
0.3332061172,
-0.446147114,
-0.1371336728,
-0.3969118595,
0.2912631631,
0.3109033406,
-0.8276113272,
0.7095687389,
0.4702353477,
0.259611994,
-0.6472013593,
-0.7232660651,
0.0158573836,
-0.1494829208,
-0.370739758,
0.3972274363,
-0.2640964091,
-0.1057353914,
0.0675831214,
0.041644346,
-0.223701641,
0.1059006453,
0.5763633847,
0.0455572493,
-0.0886424035,
0.3911585808,
0.0033937523,
0.0005970134,
-0.0898177102,
-0.0393036902,
0.770495832,
-0.1748240143,
-0.4125257134,
-0.389229387,
0.5552865267,
0.663264811,
-0.196612373,
0.7265574336,
1.0745725632,
-0.9583843946,
-0.2097050995,
-0.6735780239,
-0.2718684971,
-0.4550735056,
0.5866577029,
-0.3012323081,
-0.8481479287,
0.5540399551,
0.1472242773,
0.0264323168,
0.2415256351,
0.5453814268,
0.0265865996,
1.0409593582,
0.5593164563,
0.1700498611,
0.2250342518,
0.0123138409,
0.241310209,
-0.5923071504,
-0.7299799323,
-0.2724752724,
-0.3369315267,
-0.3411437869,
-0.3940053284,
-0.1143922955,
0.3039789498,
-0.1091967151,
-0.1907494664,
-0.7253555059,
0.8097020984,
0.3710379303,
0.1538628787,
0.3637341857,
0.356226474,
-0.0053708008,
0.0419970714,
-0.189648211,
-0.3826713264,
1.1772831678,
0.0683718547,
0.8113187551,
-0.0412466861,
0.7110648751,
0.1704533547,
0.0838326067,
-0.837135613,
0.4987492859,
-0.1895658672,
-0.3684149086,
-0.4855266511,
-0.4670716822,
-0.6166865826,
0.3105415106,
-0.5252159834,
-0.9990554452,
0.1645724773,
0.2064211965,
-0.5465459824,
0.4144085646,
-0.687525928,
0.8734573722,
-0.2760342956,
-0.5098925829,
-0.2003180832,
-0.497377187,
0.3634338975,
-0.4408130944,
0.1234119013,
0.0276001003,
0.1569597721,
0.8050963283,
-0.1994214952,
0.8313183784,
-0.2340850532,
0.0265530553,
0.1921473593,
0.0645044446,
0.4545581639,
0.0481554791,
0.1868294924,
0.1470735222,
0.0754966214,
-0.1914280057,
-0.4909419119,
0.9702699184,
-0.5601822734,
-0.302773416,
-0.1647625715,
-0.7770399451,
-0.1844412237,
0.1748699546,
0.3297079802,
0.5311796069,
-0.4074495137,
0.5136181712,
0.5782750249,
-0.1887153387,
0.6679884195,
0.0565581247,
-0.7006198168,
-0.5488305092,
1.0242599249,
0.0684645697,
-0.2048104107,
0.3423140347,
0.1111411601,
-0.349604696,
-0.4992288649,
-0.3428963125,
0.0478794686,
-0.6611282229,
-0.2986752391,
-0.9143030643,
0.0778877735,
-0.3852099478,
-0.3989278972,
-0.3586290777,
-0.2849404514,
-0.471543014,
-0.0604596063,
0.4519141614,
0.7008381486,
-0.0901910886,
0.2695663869,
-0.6966317296,
0.5102508068,
0.1617968231,
0.4987401664,
0.3145127296,
-0.2020571828,
-0.1583508402,
0.1865355819,
-0.3371663988,
-0.5395278335,
0.402789712,
0.402595818,
0.4478858709,
0.8749483228,
0.2313848734,
1.1524454355,
-0.3479233682,
0.5674638152,
0.5077707171,
-0.8581395149,
0.1187717319,
-0.1030718684,
-0.0242656581,
0.4848568439,
0.09254843,
-0.433914721,
-0.2354056835,
-0.2837115228,
-0.7369226217,
0.5725440979,
0.227128163,
0.0419966914,
0.0084406696,
0.1743368506,
0.3972605467,
0.259991616,
-0.6681559086,
-0.1671882868,
-0.3669744134,
-0.6125856042,
-0.3621762097,
-0.2474009842,
-0.2836195827,
-0.440947473,
0.4905414581,
-0.2296821028,
0.3270651996,
0.199979648,
-0.4326215982,
-0.5123168826,
0.0296888463,
0.7803291678,
0.1854728162,
-0.254591614,
0.2958619893,
0.069182843,
-0.5528735518,
0.0730372444,
0.1927304119,
-0.0097614015,
-0.1940380484,
0.1007337794,
0.7110251784,
0.5274013281,
-0.9094664454,
0.4657230973,
0.0211924743,
-0.2300020456,
-0.3578385413,
-0.0691178516,
0.1606702358,
0.3898097873,
0.301330626,
-0.0267381631,
0.2329841107,
-0.3795096278,
0.4977169931,
0.4279042184,
-0.3481553793,
-0.3134606183,
0.7456136346,
0.1806639135,
-0.4109164476,
0.683111012,
-0.3082038164,
-0.1825319827,
0.3909288943,
0.7473176122,
1.0177761316,
-0.02954055,
0.2431299984,
0.1249351352,
0.2657563388,
-0.3538653553,
0.0859160498,
-0.0714605898,
-0.6330271363,
-0.1384331882,
-0.9662263989,
-0.0567714125,
0.3414543271,
-0.6453450322,
0.1323524714,
-0.3806898892,
0.0442885496,
0.0121151144,
-0.308627516,
-0.5270834565,
0.1296692789,
0.3524930477,
0.2707475424,
-0.7882242203,
0.7116945982,
0.5804433823,
-0.3708783388,
-0.5035715103,
0.0463830568,
0.1686168909,
-0.4644439816,
0.2532485127,
0.6444818974,
-0.2239752561,
0.13168782,
-0.377861768,
-0.5138847828,
0.847433269,
0.3781031966,
-0.7700199485,
-0.0157259088,
0.096640192,
0.4766128957,
-0.5808909535,
-0.0102503048,
0.3817660809,
0.5076621771,
0.1681148261,
-0.59652704,
0.0603643619,
-0.1585800499,
-0.1340896338,
0.3243035674,
-0.5483439565,
0.6703545451,
-0.5267945528,
-0.2215378433,
0.1036314145,
0.5999168754,
-0.1139894277,
0.627368927,
0.4606426358,
0.7845556736,
0.9338738322,
-0.1605413407,
0.3849243522,
-0.1502370685,
0.4489067197,
1.2232062817,
-0.4393149018,
0.8195351958,
0.818305254,
0.2399938256,
0.1125593856,
0.5057483912,
-0.2349358499,
0.6913017035,
-0.0337118357,
-0.0503738038,
-0.4345916212,
-0.113516964,
-0.3008202016,
0.705548346,
0.1174272969,
-0.3540193141,
-0.3652002215,
0.6034332514,
-0.110766381,
0.2416990995,
-0.2008432299,
0.8416433334,
0.0353397131,
-0.5092801452,
0.5400556326,
-0.2163298875,
0.7038043737,
-0.1228219196,
-0.2273169607,
-0.2815291286,
0.4312722385,
-0.391132623,
-0.3851191401,
0.3883702159,
-0.0465309396,
-0.1277875602,
0.0587350391,
0.4969701469,
-0.7546695471,
-0.5070791245,
0.6271756291,
0.3327865303,
0.2343314588,
-0.1338226646,
-0.6559069753,
0.0454261191,
0.0404031724,
-0.3599836826,
0.4565873146,
0.3532996178,
-0.0519773178,
0.4937854111,
0.7332448363,
-0.2780965567,
-0.0548664592,
0.2480535358,
0.8228023052,
-0.6511315703,
-0.1521940976,
-0.8894600272,
0.4067195058,
-0.0125398301,
-0.2012917548,
0.3878021836,
0.5497900844,
0.9658041,
-0.1550508291,
0.3499074578,
0.0557187386,
-0.0718361437,
-0.6029238701,
1.0432857275,
-0.9243228436,
-0.0465921983,
-0.3520651162,
-1.078062892,
-0.597718358,
0.7887201309,
0.2855901122,
0.0066184001,
0.7760518193,
1.2537224293,
-0.0527640618,
0.2518340945,
0.7905170918,
0.1194078252,
0.1012670621,
0.5371475816,
0.6429733634,
-0.2854528725,
0.5992960334,
-0.7659641504,
-0.0025464862,
-0.3515360951,
-0.7917157412,
-1.2047058344,
-0.8488452435,
-0.1929571182,
-0.1271459907,
0.0363993086,
1.2387890816,
0.5244454741,
-0.9998355508,
-0.1059951633,
-0.1163695306,
-0.1761291623,
-0.1884451956,
-0.1830879003,
0.5136951804,
-0.337895155,
-0.7913982272,
0.0553990565,
0.4155012369,
0.3065695763,
-0.4953274727,
-0.3625032306,
-0.1411990225,
-0.0692145675,
0.6781305671,
0.0490620099,
-0.932307899,
-0.3569198847,
0.0075392141,
-0.0916556343,
0.086132355,
0.6049715877,
-0.489146322,
0.7438172698,
0.1821562052,
0.635861516,
0.2583394945,
-0.0746128857,
0.2855931222,
-0.5483649969,
0.6383220553,
-0.0174614172,
0.5731291771,
0.506362915,
-0.530747056,
0.395228982,
0.2205265909,
-0.4455935955,
-1.3398307562,
-0.0668701231,
-1.0072983503,
-0.4381431043,
1.0086219311,
0.1227391213,
-0.3904435337,
-0.115732424,
-0.319960475,
0.3320243359,
-0.3800528049,
1.0573787689,
0.633275032,
0.0158491842,
-0.1650112569,
-0.2645041943,
0.6133124232,
0.3347212672,
-0.836596787,
0.3490974903,
0.7525443435,
-0.191765815,
0.2483231723,
0.3075442314,
-0.0596153401,
0.1073916107,
0.0706331581,
0.2949640453,
-0.5133349895,
-0.7688918114,
-0.4897039831,
0.473834455,
-0.2877010703,
-0.1498059034
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09773v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09773v2
|
NutePrune: Efficient Progressive Pruning with Numerous Teachers for Large Language Models
| 2024-02-15T08:03:12 | 2024-06-27T04:49:11 |
Shengrui Li, Junzhe Chen, Xueting Han, Jing Bai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The considerable size of Large Language Models (LLMs) presents notable
deployment challenges, particularly on resource-constrained hardware.
Structured pruning, offers an effective means to compress LLMs, thereby
reducing storage costs and enhancing inference speed for more efficient
utilization. In this work, we study data-efficient and resource-efficient
structure pruning methods to obtain smaller yet still powerful models.
Knowledge Distillation is well-suited for pruning, as the intact model can
serve as an excellent teacher for pruned students. However, it becomes
challenging in the context of LLMs due to memory constraints. To address this,
we propose an efficient progressive Numerous-teacher pruning method
(NutePrune). NutePrune mitigates excessive memory costs by loading only one
intact model and integrating it with various masks and LoRA modules, enabling
it to seamlessly switch between teacher and student roles. This approach allows
us to leverage numerous teachers with varying capacities to progressively guide
the pruned model, enhancing overall performance. Extensive experiments across
various tasks demonstrate the effectiveness of NutePrune. In LLaMA-7B zero-shot
experiments, NutePrune retains 97.17% of the performance of the original model
at 20% sparsity and 95.07% at 25% sparsity. Our code is available at
https://github.com/Lucius-lsr/NutePrune.
|
[
-0.2777195871,
-0.6913971901,
0.3394150436,
0.335036844,
-0.2814376056,
0.2575854063,
-0.7000533938,
-0.0144903045,
-0.1190508232,
0.4665127397,
-0.4781835377,
-0.5101995468,
-0.3480848968,
-0.0918366462,
-0.6189582348,
0.7601312995,
0.0034036452,
-0.007862472,
0.0329832546,
0.0884303525,
-0.7400736809,
-0.3390119374,
-0.5331872702,
-0.4929735661,
0.3840171099,
0.6357170939,
0.2934123874,
0.5960524678,
0.2917161584,
0.3422195315,
-0.3926727176,
0.1836053729,
-0.6745097041,
0.3880129158,
-0.2725635469,
-0.6345226765,
-0.1530470103,
-0.2846208215,
0.7625378966,
0.6801496744,
-0.6336402893,
0.1247718632,
0.1529509574,
0.6461085081,
-0.7029556036,
-0.0946288481,
-0.7837857008,
0.079561457,
-0.3565178812,
0.2618256509,
-0.4552188814,
-0.3628097177,
-0.0674291477,
-0.5072111487,
0.2521610856,
-0.1275294721,
0.7751722932,
0.2248545885,
0.0171914268,
0.1388986409,
-1.041003108,
0.8925311565,
-0.5998852849,
0.1889164448,
0.3465521932,
0.4491784573,
-0.1334127486,
-0.770781219,
-0.4483194649,
-0.0736567453,
0.3905172646,
-0.0261896849,
0.000123915,
0.0234980546,
0.2805630863,
0.5214474797,
-0.3775683045,
0.1088445112,
-0.6276327372,
0.0028370814,
0.2271373719,
-0.027541643,
-0.0429243781,
0.0824811757,
-0.2618222237,
-0.205210641,
-0.7754653096,
-0.3573973775,
0.357339412,
0.1008207276,
0.4089408219,
0.6230363846,
-0.0944832489,
0.8213607669,
-0.2235096395,
-0.5198503733,
-0.160659343,
-0.2461877465,
-0.2176087201,
0.121382907,
0.4909249246,
0.0306380522,
0.6629567146,
-0.09656699,
-0.0040881322,
0.4078872502,
0.2644298673,
-1.0426484346,
-0.5284133554,
-0.0329121873,
-0.0376620665,
-0.2508509755,
-0.2673596144,
-0.7174953818,
-0.160652563,
-0.2164738029,
-0.0234488938,
-1.0800151825,
-0.415732801,
0.1927226484,
-0.0959658325,
0.0289363675,
0.4763828218,
-0.6364132166,
0.6204010844,
0.8332138062,
1.0545071363,
-0.0322036967,
-0.2564398348,
-0.2783124149,
0.3866070807,
-0.1891923249,
0.4487727582,
-0.701133728,
-0.3709924221,
-0.4141218662,
-0.214302361,
-0.2325245738,
-0.8307573199,
0.4708008468,
-0.3569251895,
-0.0025484639,
0.078597866,
-0.6268673539,
-0.3492955863,
0.4706591964,
-0.6204534769,
1.0553890467,
0.1245282963,
-0.7166004777,
-0.0570082739,
-0.2613705397,
-0.3715530932,
-0.0734119043,
-0.09639965,
-0.5063447952,
0.3748087287,
0.1422372013,
0.3752806783,
-0.2767449915,
0.5706825256,
-0.1656804681,
-0.573390305,
-0.0565112196,
-0.5477606058,
0.5492250323,
0.1685556769,
-0.1373394877,
-0.1215589717,
-0.6142080426,
-0.1388317943,
0.3492836952,
-0.3932031691,
-0.475182265,
0.1214264631,
-0.0814958811,
0.0606049821,
-0.0547941886,
-0.3603521883,
0.6051167846,
-0.5053668618,
0.5607411861,
0.8204756975,
-0.0932540447,
0.2914396822,
-0.2946861386,
0.7669047117,
0.0922573879,
0.0865948424,
-0.2707638443,
-0.1886567026,
-0.7080212235,
-0.5372550488,
0.4848112464,
0.384273082,
-0.5134236813,
0.1629604399,
-0.3217381239,
-0.5394422412,
-0.3769299984,
0.3020575941,
0.2642633021,
0.5617836118,
0.2070305347,
-0.3670460284,
-0.3463028669,
-0.8520454764,
0.0348037407,
-0.2099734992,
0.0545344949,
0.1215036586,
0.4682801962,
0.2699584067,
1.0331145525,
-0.835513413,
-0.191638574,
-0.2269579619,
-0.3668191731,
0.3772564828,
0.5206788182,
0.3097930849,
-0.5669848919,
-0.5348043442,
-0.1000517309,
-0.1509088129,
0.0169634819,
-0.0276521724,
-0.1673659533,
-0.0653300136,
0.0551682971,
-0.7507892847,
0.2339455485,
0.5229161382,
0.0448092297,
0.98616606,
0.0500365049,
-0.2253508866,
-0.9542011619,
0.1672365665,
-0.0591064468,
-0.5273476839,
-0.3988183439,
-0.0415096134,
-0.0913251862,
-0.2060857713,
-0.4634140134,
0.2726354897,
-0.7015180588,
0.0615009852,
-0.2733756304,
0.1795512438,
0.1596687585,
0.5043095946,
0.1623234451,
0.5492635965,
0.7066946626,
-0.6293972731,
0.3553604782,
0.0406911634,
-0.5583592653,
0.4602133036,
-0.4778915942,
0.069271259,
-0.0404657945,
0.3390319049,
-0.7115056515,
-0.0906655714,
0.2377907932,
0.127860263,
0.505181849,
-0.3627003133,
-0.5451064706,
-0.4621184766,
-0.373973459,
0.2723937333,
0.5263954401,
-0.4836707413,
0.4099168479,
0.2511103749,
-0.1894421726,
-0.5014564395,
-0.5543076992,
0.1178580523,
-0.6721808314,
-0.5567298532,
0.5274974108,
0.0059810248,
-0.1334779263,
0.0193948168,
-0.5343874693,
-0.2451808155,
0.2104920596,
0.0728482679,
0.1930428594,
-0.1334940642,
0.2210700661,
0.0199734531,
0.1066609398,
-0.2815211713,
-0.264886111,
0.9083863497,
0.0624651164,
-0.3684672713,
-0.1005329341,
0.1842464805,
0.3753220439,
-0.4239682853,
0.8636410236,
0.4722936451,
-0.3840035796,
-0.579608798,
-0.7217715383,
-0.3940728903,
-0.5082351565,
0.6748079658,
-0.3250474632,
-0.9103076458,
0.2906546593,
-0.6477074623,
0.3249674141,
-0.0264112093,
0.4509699345,
0.2837892771,
0.5458615422,
0.4874474406,
-0.2650236487,
0.5920712948,
-0.3782268465,
-0.0447784513,
-0.8682978749,
-0.1013952792,
-0.5272266865,
-0.3656339943,
0.0333094597,
-0.7166823149,
0.2496103644,
0.6072589755,
-0.2070413232,
0.3498637378,
-0.9471461177,
0.6919015646,
0.2268504649,
0.061995171,
0.4583106339,
0.2530212998,
0.1265546083,
0.1251815706,
-1.051784277,
-0.5712437034,
0.7556442618,
0.3711132705,
0.8449830413,
0.122251831,
0.8187052608,
-0.4871065617,
0.4087886214,
-0.7294614911,
0.7753911018,
-0.1509965956,
-0.7242420316,
-0.231869325,
-0.5678690672,
-0.7510726452,
0.6005472541,
0.1441760659,
-0.9404572845,
-0.056176234,
0.3405848145,
-0.3257823586,
0.5136348009,
-0.8464429975,
0.7511358857,
-0.1238882095,
-0.4259793162,
-0.621732831,
-0.3742976785,
0.7760626078,
-0.2657186091,
0.000681035,
-0.3777264357,
-0.0107885823,
0.8296146989,
-0.6466193795,
1.0547794104,
-0.2371687591,
0.0890589878,
0.4581774175,
0.2440460473,
0.6439344883,
-0.0938473493,
-0.1736580431,
0.0801928416,
-0.0376056433,
-0.257669121,
-0.4681478739,
0.8400624394,
-0.5290846229,
-0.7245530486,
-0.2410147786,
-0.3563320339,
-0.1224730685,
0.1709249914,
-0.0882768482,
0.1638228297,
-0.2225829214,
0.2012768984,
0.6256756186,
-0.1704797,
0.6241608858,
0.5257684588,
-0.310359478,
-0.1977572441,
0.9716656208,
0.4607167244,
0.1492869705,
0.1861904114,
0.350235641,
0.0063146949,
-0.6218078136,
-0.1576808244,
0.385078162,
-0.2619691193,
-0.4893862903,
-0.3985219002,
-0.1494859606,
-0.1016819626,
-0.0745861605,
-0.8214429021,
-0.6372949481,
-0.2411714643,
-0.003917173,
0.5450497866,
0.257194072,
0.2422201186,
0.7538551688,
-0.5444819331,
0.0225674231,
-0.0048689297,
0.3325035274,
0.2367050648,
-0.3362595439,
-0.3452943563,
-0.2847310603,
-0.6543024778,
-1.0278198719,
0.3823757768,
0.5412103534,
0.184276551,
0.4436199367,
0.1151024848,
0.9887853861,
-0.6960731745,
0.4274520874,
0.3453894258,
-0.70713377,
0.4799986482,
-0.1075068265,
0.5077475309,
0.6165279746,
0.1940547973,
-0.5284327865,
-0.4596369267,
-0.4946703911,
-1.1104367971,
0.7828492522,
0.1693245023,
-0.0778674707,
0.073362641,
0.4137401581,
0.100781627,
0.2619164288,
-0.5381670594,
-0.1009829193,
-0.1457083076,
-0.0623296462,
0.0890031755,
-0.1950336099,
-0.1701100916,
-0.2608009279,
0.8258876204,
0.0720669255,
-0.2483034879,
-0.0643405542,
-0.0622764751,
0.326064527,
0.3878760338,
0.2188473195,
0.7510328293,
-0.0489147715,
0.2503896952,
0.2753114104,
-0.6299860477,
0.3462171853,
0.0290494263,
-0.1658382863,
0.0280978009,
0.1925634444,
0.7528642416,
0.2681452036,
-0.608948946,
0.2439236343,
0.0243517309,
-0.0060558659,
-0.3513281941,
0.422562629,
0.4167128205,
0.1647693962,
0.183170408,
-0.0545503721,
-0.2661027312,
-0.2578410208,
0.1088747978,
0.1992986202,
0.0471008942,
-0.3777497411,
0.3038538992,
0.0760008022,
-0.0948926955,
0.9634834528,
0.1885997206,
-0.4987246692,
0.4514521658,
0.6939110756,
0.6651239395,
-0.6746073961,
0.2665792406,
0.4082473516,
0.288682729,
-0.5506475568,
-0.0840920806,
-0.1890860051,
-0.6572542191,
-0.8736137748,
-0.7758334279,
-0.2399081737,
0.0299712997,
-0.3594244719,
0.2018533051,
-0.4976381063,
-0.2500326335,
-0.1245768145,
0.1244902015,
-0.3879831731,
-0.04022507,
0.0119146565,
1.1256330013,
-0.7184081674,
1.2673590183,
0.6434873939,
0.0835874379,
-1.0271495581,
-0.2875927091,
-0.1299663186,
-0.5396527052,
0.3456864953,
0.2379191965,
0.1239133701,
0.1026587859,
-0.3098549545,
-0.554746747,
1.0361047983,
0.8938741684,
-1.219119072,
-0.1520632654,
-0.1427401453,
0.170488283,
0.040634539,
0.2567737699,
0.5867039561,
0.613637507,
0.4615467787,
-0.7451021075,
-0.109530963,
0.0073723961,
0.0424677283,
0.4033814371,
-0.8558470011,
0.628669858,
0.1094341278,
-0.3227546513,
-0.1842423379,
0.6396559477,
0.6020972133,
-0.0423894152,
0.7889631987,
0.7044357061,
0.9262971282,
0.0191548299,
0.6921361089,
-0.3776986897,
0.3235610425,
1.1441390514,
-0.4471894205,
0.6596356034,
0.6397622824,
-0.4471307397,
0.3375720382,
0.5333142281,
-0.0088968044,
0.3356717825,
0.5303480625,
-0.4813743532,
-0.346655339,
-0.1217973381,
-0.2616286576,
0.4212942719,
0.2190522701,
0.1096620038,
-0.4739906192,
0.0328157879,
0.3485505879,
-0.1190062687,
-0.2511553168,
0.432975769,
0.3829677701,
-0.7971693873,
0.5909062028,
0.2348662168,
0.586766243,
-0.8390539289,
0.0216498505,
-0.2360184938,
0.4606569111,
-0.215691641,
-0.3647119999,
0.4753498733,
0.1610995829,
-0.1528311223,
-0.239125371,
0.8515908718,
-0.5272387266,
-0.6188750267,
0.0196068007,
0.1923247725,
0.4088925719,
-0.2600847781,
-0.5313228965,
0.3004156351,
0.1405217648,
-0.6200583577,
0.4045944214,
0.2675588429,
-0.3008607626,
0.7257963419,
0.4186210036,
0.3489286602,
0.1486060321,
-0.1600709856,
1.2769290209,
-0.5093391538,
-0.3573604822,
-1.1987638474,
0.3726271093,
-0.0882370993,
-0.1069334745,
0.8676873446,
0.7853739858,
0.6455646157,
0.0799410045,
0.2509160638,
-0.0219831932,
0.3488944471,
-0.2487761676,
0.428376466,
-0.2860787213,
0.4759793282,
-0.2767498791,
-1.264786005,
0.0134130474,
0.8053171635,
-0.2448001802,
-0.0566184819,
0.4705663323,
0.7807605863,
-0.3347200155,
-0.0498451404,
0.1847057194,
0.2616152465,
0.3718831241,
0.7019601464,
0.7364422083,
0.1038154364,
0.634796381,
-0.4878903031,
-0.2524082661,
0.1469620615,
-0.7165597677,
-0.7228160501,
-0.1961614341,
-0.736526072,
-0.0940147042,
0.0928220898,
0.5532845259,
1.0896337032,
-0.4962255955,
-0.3593709767,
-0.2576357424,
0.2662961781,
-0.2721220553,
-0.2494522929,
0.4493576586,
-0.0027671419,
-0.7890306115,
0.6854225397,
0.0835456327,
-0.2733232975,
-0.4251057208,
0.0133636286,
-0.3311957717,
-0.0175052583,
0.4033225179,
0.3012864888,
-0.298496455,
0.0896115676,
-0.3032715619,
0.2798481286,
-0.0875073746,
0.7384677529,
-0.9698169231,
0.1043016091,
0.2711667717,
0.4672338068,
1.1044148207,
0.1952613443,
0.5506039858,
-1.1097681522,
0.4413338602,
0.4927040935,
0.1960345358,
0.2967323959,
0.0974280164,
0.6083846688,
0.3064756989,
-0.4520925283,
-1.1872732639,
0.2218462676,
-0.7711550593,
-0.6326739788,
0.9944452047,
-0.4078063965,
-0.51661098,
0.2394477129,
-0.2479169369,
0.2474730611,
-0.3070970178,
0.4921563864,
0.7818632722,
0.1634522527,
-0.3450190127,
-0.5170937777,
0.0096695367,
0.5610165596,
-0.4739271402,
0.1479195654,
0.6011590958,
0.409811765,
-0.0278587621,
0.663259387,
0.04985011,
-0.2420593202,
-0.1173794791,
0.2131153941,
-0.4056908786,
-0.5207122564,
-0.1181126609,
0.6055806279,
-0.0123980874,
-0.2608152032
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09760v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09760v1
|
Grounding Language Model with Chunking-Free In-Context Retrieval
| 2024-02-15T07:22:04 | 2024-02-15T07:22:04 |
Hongjin Qian, Zheng Liu, Kelong Mao, Yujia Zhou, Zhicheng Dou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
This paper presents a novel Chunking-Free In-Context (CFIC) retrieval
approach, specifically tailored for Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG)
systems. Traditional RAG systems often struggle with grounding responses using
precise evidence text due to the challenges of processing lengthy documents and
filtering out irrelevant content. Commonly employed solutions, such as document
chunking and adapting language models to handle longer contexts, have their
limitations. These methods either disrupt the semantic coherence of the text or
fail to effectively address the issues of noise and inaccuracy in evidence
retrieval.
CFIC addresses these challenges by circumventing the conventional chunking
process. It utilizes the encoded hidden states of documents for in-context
retrieval, employing auto-aggressive decoding to accurately identify the
specific evidence text required for user queries, eliminating the need for
chunking. CFIC is further enhanced by incorporating two decoding strategies,
namely Constrained Sentence Prefix Decoding and Skip Decoding. These strategies
not only improve the efficiency of the retrieval process but also ensure that
the fidelity of the generated grounding text evidence is maintained. Our
evaluations of CFIC on a range of open QA datasets demonstrate its superiority
in retrieving relevant and accurate evidence, offering a significant
improvement over traditional methods. By doing away with the need for document
chunking, CFIC presents a more streamlined, effective, and efficient retrieval
solution, making it a valuable advancement in the field of RAG systems.
|
[
-0.2423591465,
-0.6695058346,
0.5902013779,
0.2765635252,
-0.5914061069,
0.1010797322,
-0.0234036148,
-0.4237832129,
0.3976319134,
0.4570816755,
-0.0938982368,
-0.3348426521,
-0.4463122189,
-0.0458424054,
-0.6375432611,
0.7936455607,
0.1194918007,
-0.0172867868,
-0.4160124362,
-0.1439893097,
-0.7225093246,
-0.4639767408,
-0.52676934,
-0.3443678021,
-0.1452698708,
0.6020604968,
0.7016855478,
0.692732811,
0.2956364155,
0.165632084,
-0.4431202412,
0.0778315961,
-0.5240187645,
0.1050623059,
-0.3363713026,
-0.2022186965,
-0.2764311135,
-0.0070561739,
0.6281198859,
0.4117620289,
-0.1593238264,
-0.1094835103,
-0.1556025594,
0.7196961641,
-1.0424512625,
-0.1407856643,
-0.8917251229,
-0.0865925848,
-0.204793185,
-0.4716460705,
-0.683493197,
0.0217825491,
-0.1329851747,
-0.6578237414,
0.2771194577,
0.0246856976,
0.9668174982,
0.1706531495,
-0.4778427482,
-0.6772363782,
-0.4964190423,
0.7063904405,
-0.6895906925,
0.579485178,
0.6258614063,
0.2464691848,
-0.2634784281,
-0.6352747679,
-0.4728715718,
-0.2377335131,
-0.282009542,
0.1900403351,
0.2138276696,
0.0208812058,
0.0603621192,
0.682451427,
-0.2856957614,
-0.3378836215,
-0.1345234811,
-0.0844832435,
0.4114510417,
-0.0057345345,
0.382453382,
-0.3029493093,
-0.5103908777,
-0.0697721392,
-0.5765972137,
0.0265888646,
0.1515401304,
0.3270697296,
0.0818809494,
0.4383867085,
-0.4835246503,
0.6103569269,
0.5170192719,
-0.1996383667,
0.1036738902,
-0.1969381422,
-0.3320568204,
0.2100172192,
0.5944722295,
0.1910031885,
-0.4619395733,
-0.4595958292,
-0.3588437736,
-0.0668894127,
0.4141429067,
-0.8065798283,
0.2123647779,
0.279370904,
-0.4909859598,
-0.5603151917,
0.3549526632,
-0.8045649529,
-0.2551335096,
-0.0666646585,
0.2246023417,
-0.7273637056,
-0.3250185251,
0.0589879565,
-0.3922899663,
0.5986943245,
0.1235785335,
-0.8815463781,
0.6548027992,
0.8727837205,
0.8263340592,
-0.0718888044,
0.2917131484,
-0.7717489004,
0.2247932553,
-0.4464485645,
0.8854207993,
-0.657633841,
-0.5435696244,
-0.135789454,
-0.0569886267,
0.1788974255,
-0.8052276969,
1.0164877176,
-0.8220462203,
0.2501312196,
-0.2732071877,
-0.6400272846,
-0.0939974412,
0.3345751166,
-0.5884259939,
1.2581796646,
0.1722333282,
-0.9902589917,
0.2554781437,
-0.3396951258,
-0.4098188579,
0.2958824337,
-0.3276582062,
0.1269115359,
0.2796447277,
0.133668974,
0.1826601177,
-0.3501816094,
0.6328098774,
-0.0003522529,
-0.6618932486,
-0.1819979846,
-0.2602681518,
0.6987114549,
0.4228437543,
-0.4540418386,
0.0409946181,
-0.8649156094,
0.1836360544,
0.0922660381,
-0.453250885,
-0.7980645895,
0.2319342643,
0.2158606648,
0.4642176032,
0.0894506499,
-0.585078001,
-0.18242082,
-0.7501128912,
-0.0259405486,
0.3637039661,
0.0282298382,
0.6898843646,
-0.1974475831,
0.2299903482,
0.1089419499,
-0.273453474,
-0.3168291748,
-0.2251353711,
-0.5288470984,
-0.292178005,
0.3113943636,
0.706572175,
-0.8128015995,
0.5247710943,
-0.3522710204,
-0.2774172127,
-0.4375036061,
-0.1681749672,
0.5265696049,
0.6811116338,
0.4931709766,
-0.4420901537,
-0.4845483899,
-0.6684518456,
-0.3309941888,
-0.0307076368,
-0.1302310079,
0.5099156499,
0.2868782282,
-0.1482640654,
1.1487771273,
-0.3401010334,
-0.1207443476,
-0.2020793706,
0.0753436983,
0.1515335143,
0.6298833489,
0.3822315037,
-1.0958906412,
-0.4207551181,
0.0290599167,
-0.8908675313,
-0.085468404,
-0.1163353696,
-0.3690615296,
0.3051368892,
0.5664539933,
-0.4976196289,
0.5273607373,
0.3363519311,
-0.7806085348,
0.4223704338,
-0.0102225365,
0.2507251799,
-1.0616410971,
0.4941344261,
-0.4578843415,
-0.4343277216,
-0.7546150684,
0.5077117682,
0.3983887434,
-0.046215903,
-0.2888405323,
0.6481000185,
-0.5634737611,
0.0450135916,
-0.6812111735,
0.231776908,
-0.0038317102,
0.2134944946,
0.0854311436,
0.873051703,
0.1733158678,
-0.5750790238,
-0.3780370057,
0.3426533639,
-0.0980380028,
0.5550429225,
-0.3620492816,
0.224547416,
-0.3537652194,
0.4732802212,
-0.5897439718,
-0.2966643274,
0.2961822152,
-0.5640177131,
0.4055302441,
-0.1010040566,
-0.3131252527,
0.0262744967,
-0.3007152081,
0.5527968407,
0.3429429829,
-0.6433389783,
0.6359953284,
0.4989676476,
0.2705055475,
-0.8770133853,
-0.3439266086,
0.3304992318,
-0.1060795635,
-0.4057144523,
0.6872522831,
-0.2180100232,
-0.3328940272,
0.036949344,
-0.5269029737,
-0.3649963439,
0.2222840786,
0.1356765181,
0.0299433656,
-0.0482766815,
-0.1567750722,
0.3420173824,
-0.0762288794,
0.0112901004,
-0.260400027,
0.4669796228,
0.0695187524,
0.0079167932,
-0.2108364403,
0.6452358961,
0.5455326438,
-0.2820080221,
0.8428210616,
0.3890767992,
-0.6972651482,
-0.0335928872,
-0.5758962035,
0.0155988755,
-0.4638356566,
-0.2196486443,
-0.5669657588,
-0.9536098838,
0.3633766472,
-0.1509836614,
-0.159365952,
0.5037617087,
0.3538732231,
0.1922229528,
0.6303314567,
0.7985236645,
-0.1100581065,
0.423771292,
-0.1533246338,
0.0185782257,
-0.9408470988,
-0.1882122308,
-0.6001827717,
0.3318612576,
-0.0818064585,
-0.600315094,
0.0270413663,
0.6075361371,
0.046527382,
0.1942457706,
-0.5647625327,
0.6480717659,
0.2345959246,
0.0509977229,
0.3544070423,
-0.0740116462,
-0.4959922433,
0.2772799134,
-0.4376833141,
-0.4502648413,
0.7878434658,
0.1157487929,
0.1957863718,
0.1387369037,
0.674926281,
0.2187886685,
0.5477718115,
-0.800296545,
0.3955224156,
-0.0876632929,
-0.8613088131,
-0.087018393,
-0.3873711228,
-0.6171073318,
0.7076682448,
-0.2606273592,
-0.6482180953,
0.1724140197,
-0.0745604932,
-0.121545814,
0.3701285422,
-0.3088694513,
0.5387162566,
0.0119406758,
-0.3122843802,
-0.2976417243,
-0.7687019706,
0.4908742309,
0.015227587,
0.3109262586,
0.082046397,
0.0134825753,
0.5447080731,
-0.3919202089,
0.3753278852,
-0.330234915,
-0.1102194637,
0.6062930226,
0.154217422,
0.5307515264,
0.2400017381,
-0.2991279364,
-0.1196469143,
0.1290024668,
-0.4400399029,
-0.5448924303,
0.7729275227,
-0.3809588253,
-0.4965702295,
-0.5643286705,
-0.5236412287,
-0.1638672054,
0.5689424276,
0.2214374691,
0.466224432,
-0.5802420974,
0.2908484936,
0.9028602242,
-0.1736778617,
0.3723184168,
0.6367942095,
0.0454641916,
-0.6045329571,
0.8333001733,
-0.158522889,
-0.0327373259,
0.7928721905,
0.0719937086,
-0.2017977089,
-0.616307199,
-0.5517032743,
0.2716266811,
-0.598141253,
-0.4084258974,
-1.0046104193,
0.031757012,
-0.6255005598,
-0.2868816853,
-0.2279435694,
-0.3162394166,
-0.3365191221,
-0.13168253,
-0.1790440232,
0.5329158306,
0.1596367657,
0.2587782443,
-0.8699526787,
0.5841677189,
-0.1813040525,
0.5949590802,
0.0629127845,
-0.4919174016,
-0.3919630349,
-0.2552847564,
-0.268758744,
-1.2203077078,
0.4704201221,
0.0421609208,
0.4148464799,
0.2684171498,
0.2021023929,
0.851210475,
-0.5747818351,
0.7081221938,
-0.1465229541,
-1.1623027325,
0.4915950596,
-0.5418311357,
0.2776310146,
0.8064338565,
0.1968702823,
-0.624068439,
-0.2887213826,
-0.7453766465,
-1.3013327122,
0.7188566327,
0.1639802456,
0.0117014451,
-0.3832699955,
0.5943613648,
0.0180468019,
0.0982374102,
-0.3651668429,
-0.0451421626,
-0.256486088,
-0.3421634436,
0.1929110885,
-0.6041818261,
-0.2207043767,
-0.0422677211,
0.8479466438,
-0.4605484903,
0.3632543087,
0.4860880971,
-0.3420939445,
-0.3228276372,
0.4832707644,
0.4970888793,
0.3482764363,
-0.454007566,
-0.0887805521,
0.2904640436,
-0.5250909925,
0.1455476284,
0.1338592321,
-0.4781647325,
0.1708384752,
-0.0237299614,
0.5272780657,
0.3976871669,
-0.8643848896,
0.6320108175,
-0.2443888485,
-0.0512267761,
-0.6908580661,
-0.2771923542,
-0.1384563297,
-0.0884152651,
0.6295254827,
-0.1507728696,
0.5386914611,
-0.3433166444,
0.5298312902,
0.4494196177,
-0.4689278901,
-0.1331033707,
0.6950827241,
-0.0594631508,
-0.0220356043,
0.5714222193,
-0.314909935,
-0.1388049424,
0.5000193119,
0.9377114177,
0.956224978,
-0.0107806092,
0.2010508329,
0.4336715043,
0.1090222225,
-0.3844006658,
0.2792203128,
-0.2954153121,
-0.5989063978,
-0.2843621373,
-0.7943829298,
-0.3213592172,
0.0847547948,
-0.9044029117,
0.093609646,
-0.5836251974,
0.2168556303,
-0.5117442608,
0.0503282137,
-0.2785544991,
0.5431856513,
0.2216300815,
1.4906172752,
-0.583118856,
0.9142233729,
0.8003520966,
-0.2824784219,
-0.9501734972,
0.2243045717,
0.017667124,
-0.0568133257,
0.337356478,
0.3723613918,
-0.3084923029,
-0.041049473,
-0.5419311523,
-1.1998063326,
1.335003376,
0.0459548905,
0.0927316546,
-0.0878598914,
-0.3440789878,
0.5269305706,
-0.5493573546,
0.4012427628,
0.5592461228,
0.2108090073,
0.1852975786,
-0.7197360396,
0.5520424843,
-0.4033113122,
0.0591955595,
0.2124004364,
-0.7274220586,
0.5496628881,
0.2916573882,
-0.7666178942,
0.3493595719,
1.0125374794,
0.3737315834,
0.6436644793,
0.5946968198,
0.8678662777,
0.7450996637,
0.1327873617,
0.9779540896,
-0.5029600859,
0.237086609,
1.1212564707,
-0.2543374598,
1.014621973,
0.5335435271,
0.3462120295,
0.7552019954,
0.1832925528,
0.5303621888,
0.5484485626,
0.0350191705,
-0.4224140048,
-0.0261165798,
-0.1938411295,
-0.2088946551,
0.3795992136,
0.5332255363,
-0.3267707527,
-0.2873992324,
-0.2026320696,
0.1795184314,
0.3074035347,
-0.1858845353,
0.8292808533,
-0.1498532742,
-0.860016346,
0.7155435681,
0.4108144641,
0.895852685,
-0.5731524229,
-0.1062943786,
-0.4126337171,
-0.0914771482,
-0.3399016559,
-0.2192185968,
0.6453307271,
0.1040562093,
-0.3747899234,
-0.2597277164,
1.0826107264,
-0.363001734,
-0.1187342927,
0.3484317362,
0.4359765351,
0.2242335081,
-0.1327091455,
-0.4711222649,
-0.0288513191,
-0.1544121057,
-0.1447035223,
0.4407064617,
0.4924012721,
-0.3774470985,
0.4711379111,
0.7101984024,
-0.2508099675,
-0.1222909614,
-0.1624812186,
1.1572886705,
-1.0173009634,
-0.8115314841,
-0.355197072,
0.5176100731,
-0.0079876166,
0.0211924687,
0.4983694553,
0.7318781614,
0.8186050653,
0.0822361037,
0.5503181815,
-0.5743406415,
0.4889639914,
-0.4785273671,
0.7556318641,
-0.5189897418,
0.0676595718,
-0.2994535267,
-0.5551996231,
-0.1959658116,
0.2980037332,
0.1933922172,
-0.1666929275,
0.896003902,
0.6407361627,
-0.0677532107,
0.1691754013,
0.2979100049,
0.0252116006,
0.3893489838,
0.1853827834,
0.455201298,
-0.6914003491,
0.3897614181,
-0.1994869411,
-0.4642888308,
-0.0091098957,
-0.6679812074,
-0.5586726665,
-0.4349073172,
0.1695866287,
-0.5218099952,
0.1250430942,
0.9711605906,
0.6050565839,
-0.9977552295,
-0.2145728916,
-0.1597482413,
0.0671967268,
-0.3492836654,
-0.3203616738,
0.2214218825,
-0.5870722532,
-0.5386713743,
1.0459034443,
0.0907536745,
-0.0834556669,
0.1230133399,
-0.05344785,
-0.5909870267,
0.3077204823,
0.6457589865,
0.3950383365,
-0.6171454787,
-0.3315542042,
0.0098968344,
-0.1781339794,
0.1081676781,
1.1527508497,
-1.281873107,
0.2235062718,
0.6258793473,
0.765509963,
0.3047757149,
0.4856063128,
0.4801567793,
-0.8704982996,
0.4126686454,
0.3040574491,
0.1294951141,
0.4006236196,
-0.80924505,
0.6016346216,
0.375346005,
-0.4330121577,
-0.823050499,
0.1569078565,
-1.0415689945,
-0.4035633504,
1.0671745539,
-0.0629401803,
-0.3077703118,
-0.1496122479,
-0.1676844805,
0.3165912628,
-0.5416839123,
0.7314174175,
0.6652998328,
0.1329235584,
0.0486029126,
-0.3971754313,
0.5576270223,
0.569026351,
-0.6232658029,
-0.0019136999,
0.7517872453,
0.2929977179,
0.2835322022,
1.1434167624,
-0.5401393175,
0.1175817251,
0.005956423,
-0.0585872717,
0.1163594574,
-0.4835384786,
-0.6835795641,
0.6055323482,
-0.1104118824,
0.1785445064
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09759v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09759v1
|
Efficient Language Adaptive Pre-training: Extending State-of-the-Art Large Language Models for Polish
| 2024-02-15T07:17:10 | 2024-02-15T07:17:10 |
Szymon Ruciński
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This study explores the potential of fine-tuning foundational English Large
Language Models (LLMs) for generating Polish text. The first step involves
Language Adaptive Pre-training (LAPT) on a high-quality dataset of 3.11 GB,
consisting of 276 million Polish tokens. The LAPT is followed by additional
fine-tuning aimed at solving nine KLEJ challenges. Our trained model
Curie-7B-v1 not only generates Polish text with the lowest perplexity of 3.02
among decoder-based Polish models but also closely rivals the performance of
the best Polish encoder-decoder models with a less than 2% gap on 8 out of 9
tasks. Curie-7B-v1 used approximately 2-3% of a typical dataset size to learn
Polish. The LAPT was completed in less than five days using a consumer GPU,
highlighting the method's efficiency. The proficiency of the model in Polish
was significantly enhanced, demonstrating the viability of this approach for
adding new languages to existing LLMs by training just 1.2% of its parameters.
To contribute to the community's collaborative progress, the model has been
released as open-source.
|
[
-0.2050321549,
-0.7827230692,
0.6644693017,
0.2651638389,
-0.4221513271,
0.1836249679,
-0.750570178,
-0.5032517314,
0.0039729699,
0.5394681692,
-0.4556532204,
-0.5146507025,
-0.6386886239,
0.1917351335,
-0.2164648473,
0.6980952024,
-0.167141214,
0.2168002576,
0.1446945965,
0.2134785205,
-0.4297225773,
-0.5637454391,
-0.4924295843,
-0.1036388874,
0.2454087287,
0.683219254,
0.41816324,
0.3621262908,
0.5520705581,
0.3219666183,
0.1062070355,
0.1967931688,
-0.7689367533,
0.1212131977,
-0.2031289339,
-0.2405988276,
-0.6250149608,
-0.0906876028,
0.6165404916,
0.7573570013,
-0.2324457616,
0.1722373962,
-0.0517610423,
0.8494643569,
-0.6139414907,
0.1690054387,
-1.0257406235,
-0.1978294104,
-0.4798458219,
0.0286943279,
-0.6447480321,
-0.0320787616,
-0.1721657664,
-0.9153273106,
0.1135622561,
0.1176115945,
0.5903943181,
-0.1045652479,
0.0859543085,
-0.5280674696,
-0.7677972317,
0.6579366922,
-0.7452685237,
0.5131452084,
0.3029943407,
0.1397870928,
-0.3121142089,
-0.8426365852,
-0.4991768301,
-0.3443616629,
0.301535517,
0.2265815437,
-0.082376726,
-0.0497872792,
0.2337213606,
0.4260505736,
-0.5430700183,
0.2743859291,
-0.5748205781,
-0.11841546,
0.5787959099,
0.1813436747,
0.339461267,
0.3559826612,
-0.1279838532,
0.0896883607,
-0.8665476441,
-0.0740984529,
0.5074633956,
0.6796343327,
-0.1266470253,
0.4577357173,
-0.478077054,
0.7476125956,
0.1483967751,
-0.0463725552,
0.4423368573,
-0.3638612628,
-0.1598356813,
0.1991450787,
0.811876893,
0.1050172225,
0.453971833,
-0.2120726258,
-0.2138068825,
0.1742914468,
0.2025552541,
-0.8192932606,
-0.4235233963,
-0.1450152248,
-0.2549867332,
-0.1974532902,
-0.1056566834,
-0.3688977361,
-0.1810493618,
-0.160953328,
0.4296809435,
-0.4582929611,
-0.3074747622,
0.7106360793,
0.3251129687,
0.0125139002,
0.4253329635,
-1.0324641466,
0.3990766406,
0.3686473966,
0.6063631177,
-0.179111734,
-0.3782176971,
-0.574119091,
0.0498882346,
-0.6730909348,
0.6548547149,
-0.4882763624,
-0.2540577352,
-0.060456872,
0.2143550068,
-0.0718184784,
-0.406047076,
0.543048799,
-0.6340553164,
0.2459631413,
-0.1259404719,
-0.6661435962,
0.1645833701,
0.1543158591,
-0.6617281437,
1.054361105,
0.3894745111,
-0.7120094895,
0.2699321806,
-0.6644954681,
-0.5351397991,
0.3449614346,
0.2116325349,
-0.2104290426,
0.3438611329,
0.1618593484,
0.4502622187,
-0.194841072,
0.1151158735,
-0.2965495884,
-0.21388942,
-0.1219748333,
-0.0807589516,
0.6208537221,
0.3106498718,
-0.1188720986,
0.2122319937,
-1.0151684284,
-0.0468535013,
0.228202045,
-0.3949226141,
-0.2217449993,
-0.1584401131,
0.2336312532,
0.3545167744,
0.5487129092,
-0.8409354091,
0.0600187331,
-0.6766329408,
0.4187810719,
0.6684472561,
-0.3500107527,
0.4465087354,
0.1025762782,
0.409725517,
-0.1796857864,
0.1811234802,
-0.1294734776,
-0.2682377398,
-0.5493255258,
0.0149171567,
0.5012913942,
0.4903824031,
-0.7867493033,
0.3963798285,
-0.3519547582,
-0.4767760634,
-0.4452046156,
0.3344030082,
0.271317184,
0.5540961623,
0.2076051384,
-0.3455388546,
-0.5691122413,
-0.8242747784,
-0.1358447075,
-0.0398051068,
0.0891149566,
-0.0798771232,
0.4461005926,
0.2075572014,
0.5518972278,
-0.2344523817,
-0.1135884225,
-0.5951804519,
-0.2825372815,
0.387827605,
0.4896649122,
0.4864221215,
-0.5704479218,
-0.9764614701,
0.3493909836,
-0.4992171824,
-0.1008323058,
0.2793164551,
-0.1506116092,
0.2102252692,
0.7519569993,
-0.4603609443,
0.0503801927,
0.6991738677,
-0.4884226918,
0.5564218163,
-0.6287481189,
0.0786648393,
-1.1043448448,
0.057570111,
-0.4631814957,
-0.3896835148,
-0.8770319223,
0.19718346,
0.2265260518,
-0.0922524109,
-0.6601721644,
0.5406545997,
-0.51520437,
0.0181702115,
-0.4695062637,
0.3906800151,
-0.1791528463,
0.2647072375,
0.1092515662,
0.9510232806,
0.47364676,
-0.341817826,
0.1778368056,
0.2876421809,
-0.7686002254,
0.0376643836,
-0.5316374898,
0.1993584633,
-0.0379902199,
-0.1197925508,
-0.7855043411,
-0.2960421145,
0.0513569191,
-0.419794023,
0.3355883062,
0.0440159775,
-0.4212641418,
-0.378702879,
-0.0785214975,
0.0775950253,
0.6664816141,
-0.4586371183,
0.5594341755,
0.3537076116,
-0.5590879917,
-0.4122096598,
-0.4662868679,
0.154767096,
0.113254346,
-0.6567867994,
0.2908366621,
-0.2432069331,
-0.105044663,
-0.1482379138,
0.1230233163,
0.0561676957,
0.2972471416,
-0.0424095206,
0.1750783771,
-0.2626669705,
0.0504973829,
-0.0707900226,
-0.0373453535,
-0.1077580899,
-0.153852433,
0.8080290556,
-0.2927503586,
-0.1380358189,
-0.1207044348,
0.2703448832,
0.502827704,
-0.3526572883,
0.7808417678,
0.5767747164,
-0.3088672161,
-0.1287559122,
-0.5458267927,
0.0801121444,
-0.4896579087,
0.7550452948,
-0.5198616385,
-1.0587641001,
0.63594383,
-0.0748094618,
0.0327503942,
0.4845697284,
0.8545398712,
0.026408406,
0.9062587619,
0.8618251681,
-0.1325285584,
0.6386304498,
0.1400828511,
0.1801773161,
-0.6496994495,
-0.0026333157,
-0.4599405229,
0.1184443086,
-0.4562039375,
-0.3078852296,
-0.0138591826,
0.4501582682,
-0.2180045098,
0.1629943997,
-0.1710072458,
0.6235571504,
0.3181061149,
0.2401969135,
0.3052662313,
0.1258669347,
0.0258244071,
0.0930233374,
-0.8779135346,
-0.4556651413,
1.299623847,
0.2764229178,
0.6467298865,
-0.1263702214,
0.5930233002,
-0.0223508384,
0.3786821067,
-0.4856476188,
0.3925251365,
-0.649056375,
-0.521998167,
-0.4683313668,
-0.173275277,
-0.8232853413,
0.0529876165,
-0.4457416236,
-0.4622618258,
-0.1160127074,
0.4459814429,
-0.2574007511,
0.3024817407,
-0.6930956244,
0.8538762331,
-0.1090753675,
-0.4726080894,
-0.2611639798,
-0.4951975942,
0.225799188,
-0.4594826996,
0.537582159,
-0.2657733858,
0.1030430794,
0.7364586592,
-0.3268792629,
0.5737678409,
-0.3896404505,
-0.1641809791,
0.1229064986,
-0.0932677388,
0.738060236,
-0.2833002508,
-0.1740514487,
-0.0699764043,
-0.3400475085,
-0.6377323866,
-0.2792476118,
0.5369904041,
-0.6167380214,
-0.5341809392,
0.1127912924,
-0.6433345675,
-0.489615202,
0.531584084,
0.4151235521,
0.440746963,
-0.4209200442,
0.2900657654,
0.7626664042,
-0.3225140274,
0.4164176285,
0.7048038244,
-0.3281580806,
-0.4022909105,
0.7331398726,
-0.1034344807,
0.5415249467,
0.2262549698,
0.2227898836,
-0.1779052019,
-1.2069165707,
-0.5493427515,
0.1613746732,
-0.6930888891,
-0.0798763484,
-0.4820282161,
-0.014320977,
-0.4286842942,
-0.2200538069,
-0.6969147921,
-0.3066182137,
-0.0410151258,
-0.1097033992,
0.3398695886,
0.9712222815,
0.0995343775,
0.553119719,
-0.7362346649,
0.1169516668,
0.0331511907,
0.5968354344,
-0.299831152,
-0.6204537749,
-0.6042566299,
0.0031318292,
0.0404067747,
-0.5197248459,
0.4588815272,
0.1786990613,
0.4422823191,
-0.0907278955,
0.0337663852,
0.4860659242,
-0.9288358688,
0.8514044285,
0.2392169386,
-0.8757735491,
0.3898136318,
-0.5601898432,
0.4290679395,
0.8280093074,
0.2784715295,
-0.1518962085,
-0.4772957861,
-0.4217731357,
-0.8170545101,
0.663605094,
0.0496421345,
0.3692803383,
-0.1131091341,
0.4685145319,
0.1641936302,
0.1234601736,
-0.7549889684,
0.090022862,
-0.0223311745,
-0.5035776496,
-0.3933089077,
-0.3169568777,
0.274268806,
-0.2213906795,
0.9674143791,
-0.0652927011,
-0.1022093892,
0.1220609769,
-0.6661630273,
-0.194580391,
0.3773958683,
0.9073938131,
0.8484695554,
-0.1924730837,
-0.1527757496,
0.4297501147,
-0.9818396568,
0.03533585,
0.0313120782,
0.0858762115,
-0.0905877873,
0.379409641,
1.00184834,
0.2129621804,
-0.7452505231,
0.6505427957,
-0.0910959095,
-0.5164638758,
-0.2351705134,
-0.0849652514,
0.2620858252,
0.0938723162,
0.1631475091,
-0.1823405921,
-0.0469873175,
-0.3911837041,
-0.0206423271,
0.3626917899,
-0.32563743,
-0.3494656086,
0.5528991818,
0.1850119978,
-0.1229603589,
0.6128442287,
-0.0375810638,
-0.5428856611,
0.2638050616,
0.7952210307,
0.53357023,
-0.4655692875,
-0.1874853969,
0.3962640762,
0.4078776836,
-0.4157806635,
0.5281369686,
0.3674633205,
-0.9152311683,
-0.7222676873,
-0.8512269258,
-0.2149595916,
0.3109630048,
-0.6239404082,
0.271902442,
-0.3433947861,
0.0493228398,
-0.1527083814,
0.1437617689,
-0.6383216977,
0.1197226346,
0.1522803307,
1.2510883808,
-1.0938979387,
1.1704719067,
0.6956140399,
-0.0517635494,
-0.8899430037,
-0.4523808062,
-0.7153744102,
-0.8546693921,
0.5923098326,
-0.1128615066,
-0.2605493069,
0.2131579965,
-0.4902720749,
-0.7743802667,
0.7318159342,
0.5928088427,
-1.1324760914,
-0.0151788676,
-0.0005943704,
0.5622891784,
-0.5609858632,
-0.2837999165,
0.5019258857,
0.3551660478,
-0.2720587552,
-1.034853816,
-0.1734451503,
-0.4199227691,
0.0106183141,
0.3520192504,
-0.3615180254,
0.9321243763,
-0.0934012532,
-0.154728815,
0.1829868108,
0.5964983106,
0.1532584727,
-0.075932011,
0.50549227,
0.5244708061,
0.6908300519,
0.0647942573,
1.0201479197,
-0.6513610482,
0.2453495115,
1.296464324,
-0.2696282864,
1.0575488806,
0.4052855074,
-0.2311161309,
0.5033841133,
0.5089325309,
0.1809624881,
0.5465330482,
0.0382083915,
-0.2336878777,
-0.6188771129,
0.4307710826,
-0.4104300737,
0.2654053271,
0.3918291926,
-0.3485505879,
-0.112352401,
0.3643440604,
-0.1821002811,
0.3605316579,
-0.7022174001,
0.7969866395,
-0.1358260214,
-0.3684447706,
0.4622518122,
-0.0346916467,
0.6313701868,
-0.7072646022,
0.2470005155,
-0.0420832336,
0.2849721909,
-0.0469229631,
-0.6037255526,
0.0109990528,
0.0271114223,
-0.3240776956,
-0.269900769,
0.870437324,
-0.6713778377,
-0.8068012595,
0.1417384893,
0.5563743114,
0.1118939072,
-0.0241635442,
-0.5191618204,
0.2918259203,
-0.0374766029,
-0.3030696213,
0.3996700346,
0.2985573709,
-0.1613254249,
0.3657191992,
0.5685322881,
0.4045864642,
0.2009498328,
0.1142121106,
0.8531426787,
-0.4309617877,
-0.5910236835,
-0.802324295,
0.4610119164,
-0.0329926424,
-0.1595183164,
0.7184993625,
0.6306209564,
1.1118377447,
-0.4661178887,
0.8161194324,
0.0938846841,
0.7266516089,
-0.6883454919,
0.7494475842,
-0.3277048171,
0.1207624376,
-0.2583218813,
-0.768799305,
-0.2993474305,
0.684319675,
-0.4166180491,
-0.1219243854,
0.5024359226,
0.6222268343,
-0.0758962706,
0.0016958242,
0.4852520525,
0.3750875294,
0.1218000799,
0.6239057779,
0.8095994592,
-0.4154753983,
0.2897482812,
-0.2843543589,
-0.254160732,
0.1173290536,
-0.9984024763,
-0.8801114559,
-0.4462586641,
-0.0546171479,
-0.1984305084,
0.3086625934,
1.1496907473,
0.5634427071,
-0.9592118859,
-0.2995918095,
-0.2853226662,
-0.293030858,
0.1724287868,
-0.0640181601,
0.3150855005,
-0.7406802773,
-0.6543747187,
0.6637609601,
0.2358524054,
-0.0163609553,
0.0361443721,
-0.2543185353,
0.0012532609,
-0.1427023262,
0.9745907187,
0.0441758037,
-0.4937794209,
-0.2683510184,
0.0669923201,
0.0562903434,
0.1808359772,
0.8350416422,
-0.5701013803,
0.547860384,
0.3837184906,
0.5326682925,
0.6195683479,
-0.2611873746,
0.7523397207,
-0.5100876689,
0.3164126277,
0.0989933014,
0.3285107315,
0.4380039275,
-0.2121739984,
0.2306718677,
0.0164273288,
-0.3703998029,
-0.9351949096,
0.1837136,
-0.851863265,
-0.3846766949,
0.8297259212,
-0.2387942672,
-0.2376165986,
-0.1358919293,
-0.1854704618,
0.1079488024,
-0.1070024073,
0.5664921403,
0.9165446162,
0.0141835781,
-0.1658972055,
-0.639549911,
0.6130861044,
0.0677373037,
-0.915114224,
0.5316508412,
0.3825268447,
0.7107604146,
-0.0432912074,
0.9531650543,
-0.3453959227,
0.3992901742,
0.0226321016,
0.2529629469,
-0.3199488223,
-0.3984610736,
-0.4478632808,
0.1844532788,
0.5291523337,
0.2808897793
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09748v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09748v1
|
Model Compression and Efficient Inference for Large Language Models: A Survey
| 2024-02-15T06:58:30 | 2024-02-15T06:58:30 |
Wenxiao Wang, Wei Chen, Yicong Luo, Yongliu Long, Zhengkai Lin, Liye Zhang, Binbin Lin, Deng Cai, Xiaofei He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.PF
|
Transformer based large language models have achieved tremendous success.
However, the significant memory and computational costs incurred during the
inference process make it challenging to deploy large models on
resource-constrained devices. In this paper, we investigate compression and
efficient inference methods for large language models from an algorithmic
perspective. Regarding taxonomy, similar to smaller models, compression and
acceleration algorithms for large language models can still be categorized into
quantization, pruning, distillation, compact architecture design, dynamic
networks. However, Large language models have two prominent characteristics
compared to smaller models: (1) Most of compression algorithms require
finetuning or even retraining the model after compression. The most notable
aspect of large models is the very high cost associated with model finetuning
or training. Therefore, many algorithms for large models, such as quantization
and pruning, start to explore tuning-free algorithms. (2) Large models
emphasize versatility and generalization rather than performance on a single
task. Hence, many algorithms, such as knowledge distillation, focus on how to
preserving their versatility and generalization after compression. Since these
two characteristics were not very pronounced in early large models, we further
distinguish large language models into medium models and ``real'' large models.
Additionally, we also provide an introduction to some mature frameworks for
efficient inference of large models, which can support basic compression or
acceleration algorithms, greatly facilitating model deployment for users.
|
[
-0.3661627769,
-0.75976789,
0.5799344182,
0.2206100225,
-0.1145755053,
-0.065346621,
-0.5298864841,
-0.4408780336,
0.1068566293,
0.4276166856,
-0.5090312362,
-0.1253739595,
-0.5571199059,
-0.1485985219,
-0.555822432,
0.5183598995,
0.2181603909,
-0.072298862,
-0.1168089733,
-0.0258605238,
-0.4940375984,
-0.6267144084,
-0.59818995,
-0.3040187657,
0.2642544508,
0.0379579253,
0.7725809216,
0.9054754972,
0.3322635293,
0.4358716011,
-0.425257653,
0.0489129722,
-0.35513255,
0.2391865551,
-0.0477981418,
-0.4855657816,
-0.0704192519,
-0.1624675393,
0.6990860105,
0.8874403238,
-0.3089437187,
0.3217822909,
-0.0098736957,
0.6153510809,
-0.7634954453,
0.1770778,
-0.5449517369,
-0.0736529976,
-0.0391315222,
0.1109046042,
-0.5590724349,
-0.2861098051,
-0.030997254,
-0.4236948788,
0.3166146874,
0.1496347636,
0.602417469,
0.463432759,
-0.4353110492,
-0.2524417937,
-1.2071506977,
1.1154129505,
-0.780015111,
0.563200295,
0.2055401802,
0.4702154994,
-0.0057335319,
-0.9643345475,
-0.6807805896,
-0.1933872998,
-0.0223231632,
-0.2343759686,
-0.4402252436,
0.2492768317,
0.5753781199,
0.6615268588,
-0.3746823967,
0.5520486236,
-0.1156219169,
-0.0778125077,
0.5960466862,
-0.0350715742,
0.070395194,
0.0729419366,
-0.0431314334,
-0.3620212674,
-0.7012907267,
-0.2710578442,
0.4871865213,
0.1497600079,
0.0194529649,
0.3931112885,
-0.2923844159,
0.9289981723,
-0.2532124221,
-0.2719160616,
0.0916897133,
-0.2558401823,
-0.2871900797,
-0.2422092408,
0.7579042315,
0.0443718843,
0.3152658045,
-0.2242183834,
-0.4163033068,
0.0624882877,
0.1418935955,
-1.0387710333,
-0.3166044652,
0.2501916885,
-0.7248114347,
-0.0836476311,
-0.1253199279,
-0.9096925259,
-0.3284905255,
-0.3408102989,
0.4110607505,
-0.2307807356,
-0.3711736202,
0.3331472278,
-0.0850513652,
0.1690571904,
0.1293605715,
-1.1034585238,
0.3982811868,
0.9066351652,
0.8631222844,
0.1911026388,
0.0613931194,
-0.5143219829,
-0.2570880949,
-0.1246039942,
0.5923483372,
-0.4771056771,
-0.1613249481,
0.0337733664,
-0.0794387236,
0.0343128107,
-0.5953892469,
0.7684412003,
-0.7725033164,
0.0023167608,
0.0063354191,
-0.8136407137,
-0.4298923612,
-0.0792433172,
-0.9885066152,
0.5631282926,
0.061925251,
-0.6336022615,
-0.0048543396,
-0.5520400405,
-0.4764956236,
-0.0600806214,
0.0490936004,
-0.3026034832,
0.5182153583,
0.1313647628,
0.5362214446,
-0.8335137367,
0.4970576465,
-0.2658795118,
-0.2948482037,
0.1245702207,
-0.7835286856,
0.7280406356,
0.5256000161,
-0.1621019691,
0.0375692099,
-0.6005250812,
-0.0373500958,
0.2537974417,
-0.1641819328,
-0.4001765549,
0.3092046678,
0.0198222026,
-0.050673943,
0.0935375392,
-0.3741722405,
0.624597609,
-0.3320548236,
0.8179395199,
0.4889599085,
-0.1115993559,
0.4495551288,
0.0881875902,
0.5779674053,
-0.2478019893,
0.1173906624,
-0.159663558,
-0.3194009364,
-0.6268544197,
-0.3289284706,
0.8167102933,
0.4663963616,
-0.7643975616,
0.491601795,
-0.5661439896,
-0.5759869814,
-0.4051150084,
-0.0533156432,
0.3142657578,
0.1367719918,
0.204382062,
0.027469229,
-0.3335915804,
-0.9723140001,
-0.0801356733,
-0.1195374057,
-0.3484783173,
0.1552635431,
0.3361931145,
0.0235521998,
0.6915688515,
-0.7427853346,
0.3778721094,
-0.3240225911,
0.2005976737,
0.3855341673,
0.604737401,
0.5746319294,
-1.0264102221,
-0.1639840156,
-0.2031197548,
-0.3548645377,
-0.2480266541,
-0.0566837043,
0.2450934947,
-0.078630656,
0.4628294408,
-0.6998898983,
0.1415327042,
0.9079862833,
-0.0540008247,
0.7544388771,
-0.2032299042,
-0.0748403594,
-0.978633523,
0.0813608244,
-0.0107825333,
-0.2370394468,
-0.8115662336,
0.2895900011,
0.009108956,
-0.0667963475,
-0.2874432206,
0.6100721955,
-0.5603061318,
-0.0212118309,
-0.2682736516,
-0.2168672085,
0.0038599337,
0.4110295773,
0.2420064658,
0.7049666643,
0.6736959219,
-0.6837663054,
0.4542177022,
-0.0013617853,
-0.6756584048,
0.0562025942,
-0.8415056467,
0.0032379273,
-0.1160843447,
0.2090038955,
-0.8043105602,
-0.129488349,
-0.1267971396,
0.0194174293,
0.4684427679,
-0.3226603568,
-0.7623025775,
-0.5384398699,
-0.1338692456,
0.6185324788,
0.7913614511,
-0.6522581577,
0.6260576248,
0.3746908903,
0.0939979777,
-0.4541510344,
-0.5228404403,
-0.0547355711,
-0.5499894619,
-0.4943783283,
0.3140288889,
-0.1410760134,
-0.3623177409,
-0.0551993065,
-0.0558702238,
-0.2297082841,
0.2114555687,
0.053258609,
0.0576845668,
-0.2962635159,
0.3529078662,
0.0299411342,
0.0283429176,
-0.129112646,
-0.5000683665,
0.7910895348,
-0.024028929,
-0.258936137,
-0.4561292827,
0.2736878395,
0.6810880899,
-0.3283813,
1.0038864613,
0.4856399894,
-0.2625998557,
-0.2246297151,
-0.780394733,
-0.2108966559,
-0.4447513521,
0.3146769702,
-0.3866802454,
-0.9938722253,
0.5558713078,
-0.4180780947,
0.1675600857,
0.5840290785,
0.5532930493,
0.3618128002,
1.1152724028,
0.6348942518,
-0.2296801507,
0.5723673701,
-0.3890348077,
0.2838611007,
-0.5996221304,
0.2128448933,
-0.9545840621,
-0.4535434246,
-0.6488650441,
-0.4315733612,
0.0810368508,
0.2334358841,
-0.1945658773,
0.3806970119,
-0.5581057668,
0.4864275157,
0.6158061028,
-0.1710086167,
0.2462267429,
0.0949319676,
0.2732405066,
0.3138533533,
-0.9539677501,
-0.2655972242,
0.8059512377,
0.5186332464,
0.8352994323,
0.2269931436,
0.3508594632,
0.0151319643,
0.1323989481,
-1.0765070915,
0.3853365779,
-0.3288991153,
-0.4896332622,
-0.2844253182,
-0.8714908957,
-0.899032712,
0.1700089127,
-0.2642895877,
-0.7956120372,
0.3882087469,
0.305817157,
-0.4103284776,
0.4498328865,
-0.973464489,
0.9002718329,
-0.0916149393,
-0.1605308205,
-0.369272083,
-0.5509474277,
0.5588017106,
-0.2725253701,
0.2447911203,
0.1921955645,
0.1737517118,
0.8061329722,
-0.5441179276,
0.734398663,
-0.2139008939,
-0.0677665323,
0.3541332185,
0.2414449304,
0.5196343064,
-0.2963036001,
-0.2340629995,
0.2143388093,
0.2379513383,
-0.2683061063,
-0.9028553963,
0.445597887,
-0.5045372248,
-0.6002433896,
0.1445712745,
-0.5324232578,
-0.2106875479,
0.1200774461,
0.2607045174,
0.7079380155,
0.0908412412,
0.4635180235,
0.6919143796,
-0.3817952871,
0.48243016,
0.2629882097,
-0.1346474737,
-0.1130810678,
0.8095276952,
0.068789348,
0.3779732585,
0.5250060558,
0.4560536444,
-0.4120917916,
-0.861389339,
-0.3436464667,
0.3368614614,
-0.401509434,
-0.3589183688,
-0.4621916115,
-0.1870703548,
-0.3923635483,
0.1703326255,
-0.6073690057,
-0.6033492684,
-0.0281699374,
0.1950952858,
0.2860942781,
0.5392347574,
0.1467225999,
0.6594036818,
-0.9273715615,
0.2642100751,
0.2700748444,
0.3773007393,
0.3657127917,
-0.5435507298,
-0.2832225859,
0.0756197274,
-0.2068732232,
-0.7333901525,
0.2926618755,
0.4013873637,
0.3948029578,
0.6959201097,
0.2136163116,
0.6060407758,
-0.5461435914,
0.7752858996,
0.0270858463,
-0.9398523569,
0.1799020022,
0.0841996297,
0.3116302192,
0.2915799618,
0.4308289289,
-0.5465477109,
0.0293157119,
-0.6595259309,
-0.7393659949,
0.37773332,
0.0499983765,
0.3505680263,
0.0152496807,
0.472166419,
-0.0614926964,
0.2829530239,
-0.5823021531,
-0.0899031013,
0.0786826611,
-0.2239801735,
-0.2150021195,
-0.5170477629,
0.0175537635,
-0.0997732505,
0.5753924251,
-0.1063974425,
0.2219327986,
-0.1713626832,
-0.1017931178,
0.2699021101,
0.2822748423,
0.4523538947,
0.4178903103,
0.1356205344,
0.2221657187,
-0.0653808415,
-0.2528779805,
0.1829172373,
0.1443572044,
-0.0855524242,
-0.2138930708,
0.5525330901,
1.1130611897,
0.1067537814,
-0.7645234466,
0.4790457487,
-0.175615117,
-0.1216296256,
-0.0416219831,
0.1045558676,
0.0900210813,
0.4192338884,
0.151136905,
-0.283940345,
0.225205034,
-0.3751689196,
-0.2264674604,
0.5822149515,
0.0331511609,
-0.3251548111,
0.5975233316,
-0.0525086708,
-0.2721132636,
0.819947958,
-0.1899591088,
-0.4664436281,
0.4227032661,
0.5263881087,
0.8443441987,
-0.3848665655,
-0.0887740552,
0.3927753568,
0.1234028414,
-0.6634204388,
-0.2037400454,
-0.2609817088,
-0.7496318817,
-1.0061728954,
-0.9604696631,
-0.1795926541,
0.1689376533,
-0.44436571,
0.0260650106,
-0.1405000836,
-0.1043323502,
0.1990415901,
-0.0600582212,
-0.4625881314,
0.0736474693,
0.1725290269,
1.2300732136,
-0.8859785199,
0.8687391281,
0.2947438061,
-0.0007518783,
-1.0960171223,
-0.1529233605,
-0.1283124834,
-0.4346500337,
0.6330922842,
0.1086253002,
0.0449394099,
0.146389395,
-0.4291307926,
-0.7416231036,
0.7882633805,
0.5738195181,
-0.7348197103,
-0.2587470114,
-0.1713865995,
0.5668774843,
-0.096284315,
0.1335378438,
0.5635783672,
0.467317462,
0.3276878595,
-0.9823181629,
-0.0123256678,
-0.082761094,
0.2330497801,
0.5071959496,
-0.3752479255,
0.7702134848,
0.1565584987,
-0.3172286153,
0.2600208223,
0.6717506647,
-0.0244783834,
-0.1145437285,
0.8329530358,
0.586260736,
0.7603986859,
-0.0587601252,
1.1574029922,
-0.4079244137,
0.5368070006,
0.87332654,
-0.150878191,
0.7731198072,
0.3463930488,
-0.3046595156,
0.3215835094,
0.5182921886,
-0.1160879582,
0.2383246273,
0.3699343503,
-0.3237682283,
-0.251675874,
0.0036403758,
-0.2159727961,
0.6419346333,
0.2234053314,
-0.4008277953,
-0.1164192483,
-0.0009088852,
0.0035943822,
-0.181164816,
-0.2962577045,
0.7161842585,
-0.0719374865,
-0.8635268807,
0.7668098211,
0.1811974645,
0.5362049341,
-0.5745152235,
0.0373700857,
-0.0201314017,
0.0107967379,
-0.0492104962,
-0.5220499039,
0.3871923983,
-0.1225264445,
-0.2408801317,
-0.2406339645,
0.6452718973,
-0.3215839565,
-0.4674809873,
-0.0091653829,
0.452138871,
0.2706846893,
-0.4202249944,
-0.2998432815,
0.1728348881,
-0.0148275597,
-0.5534079671,
0.1652363837,
0.221541062,
-0.178301245,
0.7785438299,
0.5797433257,
0.351524502,
-0.0562913977,
0.1167614385,
0.7338520885,
-0.3811119497,
-0.4650061131,
-0.9729058743,
0.2984975278,
0.0426998772,
0.2776428461,
0.5013784766,
0.4005751014,
0.400649637,
-0.1899620295,
0.3984875381,
-0.1649630666,
0.3063083887,
-0.8162270188,
0.5230477452,
-0.5752555728,
0.2316153497,
-0.0776340514,
-1.1170170307,
-0.4606024027,
0.4927480817,
-0.4715538323,
0.0744092911,
0.4116210639,
0.7401510477,
-0.3095908463,
0.0495205596,
0.2418174446,
0.3109272122,
0.3914492726,
0.425799638,
0.574054122,
-0.134531647,
0.3433948457,
-0.3633764982,
-0.3702000678,
-0.1685184985,
-1.093739152,
-0.4427193403,
-0.6921880245,
-0.2496643513,
-0.1425723284,
-0.3170464337,
0.7616264224,
1.0261173248,
-0.6299450397,
-0.1668313295,
-0.165350154,
0.1999061257,
-0.4097240567,
-0.1774401814,
0.4771616757,
-0.0533021353,
-0.9929825664,
0.3110642731,
-0.1322918683,
-0.0582297146,
-0.3753290474,
0.1712185293,
0.0662264004,
0.0481568314,
0.7150786519,
0.4646185935,
-0.4368573427,
-0.2739476264,
-0.2141755521,
0.3325826526,
-0.1812996268,
1.0093940496,
-0.7852814198,
0.277274251,
0.5629893541,
0.7876114249,
0.5360728502,
0.0752531439,
0.5452967882,
-0.7197163701,
0.4427274764,
0.1007631868,
0.5329927206,
0.234981209,
-0.1172540113,
0.4688410461,
0.177131176,
-0.7190977335,
-1.0050052404,
0.5849548578,
-0.7994301915,
-0.4692803621,
1.1338397264,
-0.1387069523,
-0.3151914775,
0.298212707,
-0.1018251926,
0.3811339736,
0.094911918,
0.6360515952,
0.640666008,
-0.0019272215,
-0.2807406783,
-0.7187708616,
0.2774923444,
0.2083607018,
-0.6051040292,
0.4487429261,
0.63705796,
0.0897426903,
0.3514272273,
0.0056122099,
0.1597277373,
-0.0699859187,
0.0874363035,
0.1502424479,
-0.0625886098,
-0.3192567527,
-0.5587275624,
0.3572853804,
0.1293338388,
0.0429650024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09742v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09742v4
|
AI Hospital: Benchmarking Large Language Models in a Multi-agent Medical Interaction Simulator
| 2024-02-15T06:46:48 | 2024-06-28T03:11:48 |
Zhihao Fan, Jialong Tang, Wei Chen, Siyuan Wang, Zhongyu Wei, Jun Xi, Fei Huang, Jingren Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Artificial intelligence has significantly advanced healthcare, particularly
through large language models (LLMs) that excel in medical question answering
benchmarks. However, their real-world clinical application remains limited due
to the complexities of doctor-patient interactions. To address this, we
introduce \textbf{AI Hospital}, a multi-agent framework simulating dynamic
medical interactions between \emph{Doctor} as player and NPCs including
\emph{Patient}, \emph{Examiner}, \emph{Chief Physician}. This setup allows for
realistic assessments of LLMs in clinical scenarios. We develop the Multi-View
Medical Evaluation (MVME) benchmark, utilizing high-quality Chinese medical
records and NPCs to evaluate LLMs' performance in symptom collection,
examination recommendations, and diagnoses. Additionally, a dispute resolution
collaborative mechanism is proposed to enhance diagnostic accuracy through
iterative discussions. Despite improvements, current LLMs exhibit significant
performance gaps in multi-turn interactions compared to one-step approaches.
Our findings highlight the need for further research to bridge these gaps and
improve LLMs' clinical diagnostic capabilities. Our data, code, and
experimental results are all open-sourced at
\url{https://github.com/LibertFan/AI_Hospital}.
|
[
-0.1774895936,
-0.7392244935,
1.072977066,
0.1247658655,
-0.0753629804,
0.0229991749,
-0.1737046838,
-0.7117471695,
0.1561518759,
0.3887259364,
-0.2361160219,
-0.4458593726,
-0.5175577998,
0.2307953238,
-0.2190961242,
0.5098068714,
-0.1424831003,
0.6324496269,
-0.6719173193,
-0.3257058561,
-0.1808647215,
-0.6868678331,
-1.0696568489,
-0.5173461437,
0.4376378059,
0.1694834977,
0.7873809934,
0.8334547281,
0.8333255649,
0.4527539611,
0.3850016296,
0.1815357655,
-0.1047974974,
0.3754339218,
0.1754960716,
-0.1087434813,
-0.6705089808,
-0.2203741074,
0.7618400455,
0.5921390653,
-0.2957718074,
-0.1028940678,
-0.4178379774,
0.3630652726,
-0.4346534014,
0.2624564469,
-0.0737507269,
-0.0527800769,
0.0450747833,
-0.1112513766,
-0.2530911565,
-0.2294076979,
0.2929742336,
-0.3678827286,
-0.0956189707,
0.0065324986,
0.960424006,
0.5005954504,
-0.6180660129,
0.0626127273,
-0.6204912663,
0.3746791184,
-0.8511353135,
0.2603051066,
0.2485800087,
0.6489053369,
-0.0960424542,
-0.8388656378,
-0.5009687543,
-0.7182074189,
-0.0282876901,
0.2470397949,
-0.0597776771,
0.1851160228,
0.1298481971,
0.1896581352,
-0.4838455617,
0.1755349636,
0.0258531999,
0.0784780979,
0.6399386525,
0.5511910915,
0.5874056816,
0.1415082067,
-0.4185193479,
-0.0790080652,
-0.5734279156,
-0.1466383785,
-0.2936058939,
-0.1345038414,
-0.1749071777,
0.340398401,
0.0118409814,
0.3178379238,
-0.2917320132,
-0.2635745108,
0.4720152617,
-0.2100597769,
-0.2662893832,
-0.0068135904,
0.9769130945,
0.5164290071,
0.1325510293,
-0.271514684,
-0.1763759702,
0.1882060468,
0.6705188751,
-0.765327394,
-0.2918619812,
0.5191019177,
-0.555683136,
-0.2310129404,
-0.276604861,
-0.7060909867,
-0.9297882915,
-0.2138254493,
0.3013862669,
-0.4175898731,
-0.453807503,
-0.0675833598,
0.1768059731,
0.2037460953,
0.5080467463,
-0.429566592,
0.5388072729,
0.6339964867,
0.6560905576,
-0.3280189037,
-0.5363251567,
-0.7926977277,
0.0881507173,
-0.3476133645,
0.786167264,
-0.3628952205,
-0.4485413432,
0.0156099806,
-0.2408087254,
-0.1971824467,
-0.9831588864,
0.2348044664,
-0.0684915036,
-0.0626519099,
0.178133145,
-0.3923595548,
0.1526020914,
0.6923128366,
-0.6866781712,
0.5007633567,
0.333163321,
-0.2573924661,
0.1329160184,
-0.7005616426,
-0.5491910577,
0.2157676965,
-0.5855804682,
-0.6227499247,
0.0454446077,
0.3122385144,
0.2197722197,
-0.6322527528,
0.4811143875,
-0.1607840508,
-0.3865923882,
0.2809278369,
-0.3446574509,
0.5132240057,
0.0841191411,
-0.1138222888,
0.5307767391,
-0.8777065873,
-0.0694150925,
0.2822271287,
-0.3289989233,
-0.1548610032,
0.243333295,
0.0893380791,
0.2112062722,
0.1210502535,
-0.1317125112,
0.3751088381,
-0.3531473577,
0.247375682,
0.2580093443,
0.1489453018,
0.0802470595,
-0.7406291962,
0.8618652225,
0.2104491442,
0.4356878102,
-0.1169226691,
-0.4901538491,
-0.4957120121,
-0.4814095795,
0.233451277,
0.5398414731,
-0.864970088,
-0.060043823,
-0.1290397495,
-0.3870341778,
-0.9299933314,
-0.4804390967,
0.3490009308,
0.5972335935,
0.3722232878,
-0.3844345212,
-0.243766591,
-0.8200579882,
0.0051915944,
-0.4717947543,
-0.0924303755,
0.6822502017,
0.2000742257,
-0.6502360702,
0.4592243433,
-0.1169746518,
-0.3477775455,
-0.242450729,
0.0500430912,
0.1408202052,
0.4192983806,
0.8111032248,
-0.5697724819,
-0.3053761423,
0.0020386553,
-0.9342779517,
-0.1810919791,
-0.1401166767,
0.1306520104,
0.1997405887,
0.4183687568,
-0.5676870942,
0.3678835928,
0.7386888266,
-0.2253493667,
0.6062607169,
-0.5370481014,
0.6340826154,
-1.2680344582,
0.1088559106,
-0.043670062,
-0.3392584324,
-0.6225239635,
0.3832571208,
-0.1159291491,
-0.1090746298,
-0.4596198201,
0.715536952,
-0.4168975949,
-0.0284270495,
-0.2946600318,
0.0957458615,
-0.0188914053,
0.0764637738,
0.0458269604,
0.736253202,
0.6798465848,
-0.39375633,
0.5572758913,
0.0161389578,
-0.2223562598,
0.735124886,
-0.6277095079,
0.0130852535,
0.2148964554,
0.1757469922,
-0.6766067743,
-0.2824056447,
0.2197771519,
-0.3518246412,
0.1002965197,
-0.1244101748,
-0.903439045,
-0.242341876,
-0.2178421319,
0.6214084029,
0.3785063326,
-0.3221892715,
0.8991276622,
0.503426671,
-0.1835247129,
-0.3339024484,
-0.4495689571,
0.4457776845,
-0.0652617589,
-0.4166575074,
0.0217565428,
-0.1118182838,
-0.5418847799,
0.0257179551,
0.2596243918,
-0.4853816926,
0.2971443236,
0.2202432007,
0.4954930544,
-0.5689888597,
0.2447160333,
0.0269413721,
-0.1094055325,
0.3859683573,
0.1833741069,
0.6806759238,
-0.2766963243,
-0.6763248444,
-0.4733320773,
0.5010995269,
0.9435338974,
-0.2399998456,
0.6220437884,
0.2288973182,
-0.7052389383,
0.2545223534,
-0.4733830392,
-0.1225344837,
-0.405531764,
0.5861282349,
-0.2985233963,
-0.4996167421,
0.597638011,
-0.5618091822,
0.0646303371,
0.3529432416,
0.8580749631,
-0.0890278518,
1.1857532263,
0.261187613,
-0.150925681,
-0.1042678654,
0.1595226228,
0.1377470791,
-0.6191062927,
-0.2715019286,
-0.5435920954,
-0.2249376476,
-0.636870563,
-0.6161677837,
0.9606894255,
-0.206585139,
-0.182167843,
-0.1150484979,
-0.2524098158,
0.3209922314,
0.3735389709,
0.0123796323,
0.518084228,
-0.5673089623,
-0.2206414044,
0.1316405386,
-0.6868624687,
-0.2832810879,
0.6992496848,
0.451364994,
0.7208153009,
0.1418700814,
0.7531842589,
0.0338998213,
0.4132491648,
-0.6854373217,
0.3792754412,
-0.1948599964,
-0.3615767658,
-0.0767830238,
-0.4477173686,
-1.0392477512,
0.3392773569,
-0.5333297849,
-0.5460239649,
-0.0697028711,
0.141990304,
-0.4058311284,
0.2714830041,
-0.7110824585,
0.8961247802,
-0.5355866551,
-0.1591345668,
-0.3963873982,
-0.6704217792,
0.0370711535,
-0.0010097612,
0.180003643,
-0.034934558,
0.0357844606,
0.0311766118,
-0.4181387722,
0.5197636485,
-0.0116718886,
0.0729529485,
-0.2521445751,
0.1002698913,
0.1595168412,
0.3834992051,
-0.1261240393,
0.4455775619,
0.1347720474,
-0.353897959,
-0.3676930964,
0.7951986194,
-0.9707059264,
-0.3633829653,
-0.7150323987,
-0.6927309036,
-0.6334137321,
0.3087325394,
-0.0761257336,
0.5831285715,
-0.4527399242,
-0.1174382642,
0.2838372588,
-0.4531528652,
0.0148800686,
0.6335616708,
-0.2581947446,
-0.2131140977,
0.634632051,
-0.3549152911,
-0.0166927464,
0.3073028922,
0.4048077166,
-0.126422435,
-0.6888744235,
-0.8683409691,
0.2347174287,
-0.4024527669,
-0.1162023321,
-0.6421073079,
-0.6454063058,
-0.4383901656,
-0.1731720418,
-0.4148385823,
0.2250179946,
0.0020440423,
0.3735624552,
0.1413765699,
0.9305550456,
0.1888870597,
0.2939443886,
-0.8979895711,
0.3646348715,
-0.082437627,
0.5608804226,
0.1261595339,
0.0771055967,
-0.3847617209,
-0.233833611,
-0.01280607,
-0.7406013608,
0.3084418774,
-0.1872379184,
0.6878575087,
0.6529391408,
0.0069165798,
0.6582654715,
-0.8935658336,
0.6805862784,
0.232150957,
-0.6438886523,
0.2650687099,
-0.2080859095,
0.4348944426,
0.7341763377,
0.1469498426,
-0.5992459059,
-0.564674437,
-0.5360094905,
-1.1759140491,
0.4508017302,
-0.0718821958,
-0.2593757808,
-0.0302940961,
0.3573942482,
-0.1548381001,
0.3726363182,
-0.3485166132,
-0.3898518384,
0.4044410586,
-0.4476210773,
-0.0742873028,
-0.0017727856,
-0.4356031716,
-0.1332879663,
0.4373672903,
-0.0103860768,
0.4641247988,
0.1723647267,
0.1236875504,
-0.2529770434,
-0.0175070092,
0.591674149,
0.8097786307,
0.0307659172,
0.0240488835,
0.1505046338,
-0.4544188678,
-0.058632724,
0.5900030732,
0.0961770341,
-0.0203129984,
0.6061451435,
0.5788859725,
0.0093195774,
-1.0916717052,
0.6057343483,
-0.4624396563,
-0.117883198,
-0.4015367627,
0.0599396862,
0.1214317754,
0.6188695431,
0.0390906334,
0.0084167803,
0.324144125,
-0.5215286613,
0.3881878257,
0.2720873356,
-0.354010731,
0.1201120988,
0.791993916,
0.2781385183,
-0.5383498073,
0.9204746485,
0.1185789555,
-0.3115024567,
0.9621699452,
0.3167265356,
0.7523206472,
-0.2487234175,
0.0301990993,
0.0826214403,
0.2317168713,
0.0036257687,
0.0950280055,
0.3988469541,
-0.4770793915,
-0.5815848708,
-0.1600601822,
-0.9857981205,
0.3488953412,
-0.509677887,
0.257216543,
-0.3981230855,
-0.0401001088,
-0.186608851,
0.0675167963,
-0.4613566995,
0.135450229,
0.3259921074,
0.7062759995,
-0.4876767695,
0.9322859645,
1.0337276459,
-0.2229706794,
-0.8648185134,
0.3564290702,
0.1261370778,
-0.9630134702,
-0.1881809235,
0.1941612214,
-0.0839625001,
-0.3026319146,
-0.3106963038,
-0.3920759559,
0.8931620717,
0.3772023618,
-0.643684864,
0.0294508338,
0.128984794,
1.036352396,
-0.6090723276,
0.5292583108,
0.4586140513,
0.3372151852,
-0.1518073827,
-1.1379697323,
0.0098005068,
-0.4325248003,
-0.3585572839,
0.0377198122,
-0.7956994772,
0.7448341846,
-0.3757309616,
0.2239005119,
0.3447892666,
0.1756604165,
0.4943934977,
0.8127101064,
0.7051283717,
0.5202775598,
0.6879689693,
-0.1141928658,
1.304061532,
-0.4850353599,
0.1734019816,
1.0337369442,
-0.7658045292,
0.6584032774,
0.3445358276,
-0.0022922072,
0.4107456505,
0.5116632581,
-0.0593756549,
0.2603383362,
0.4140654206,
-0.3545570672,
-0.1248637438,
-0.2555505037,
-0.5619029999,
0.4252725542,
0.1208370626,
-0.1673470736,
-0.0506521836,
0.0528289005,
0.0887796134,
0.1153222322,
-0.1126088351,
0.9591600895,
-0.0004774854,
-0.5173377991,
0.2683912516,
-0.0560108684,
0.1654165387,
-0.6843601465,
-0.3200447261,
-0.1272664815,
0.3250330985,
0.201907441,
-0.3778785169,
-0.046436213,
-0.1330459565,
-0.1423899084,
0.0247285068,
0.4013392925,
-0.5659127831,
-0.352651298,
0.4897893071,
0.7129705548,
0.3175701499,
0.0746921524,
-0.8676972985,
0.1180439442,
-0.5539655089,
-0.0007288205,
0.5826332569,
0.4677996635,
-0.1372428536,
0.6909861565,
0.4119997025,
0.5189480782,
-0.2153337151,
0.6654047966,
0.7971578836,
-0.3903183043,
-0.4651188552,
-0.8232370019,
0.1354464889,
-0.073537305,
-0.4062136114,
0.0515993983,
0.5890266299,
0.5237166286,
0.0229116343,
0.6095613837,
0.149666369,
0.5095153451,
-0.0997455046,
0.9975620508,
-1.0433158875,
0.0867557749,
-0.2200213969,
-0.3496890962,
-0.4289909899,
0.6084682345,
0.2186335027,
0.1045785844,
0.7394384146,
0.3688603342,
0.2277867645,
-0.3144390881,
0.5508199334,
0.5386024714,
0.4378750324,
0.7520750761,
0.9680662155,
-0.2129717469,
0.2142461687,
-0.2557224929,
-0.3278898001,
-0.3331013918,
-0.5952383876,
-0.6979940534,
-0.313469559,
-0.3759687543,
-0.5007714629,
0.2902131081,
1.2336888313,
0.7378528714,
-0.7779116631,
-0.3345651925,
0.4077318311,
-0.0411905721,
-0.6682825089,
-0.1779700518,
0.4562676549,
0.0651858598,
-0.9221022129,
0.5170673728,
0.5675311685,
-0.1214691103,
-0.3180000186,
-0.0388635322,
-0.1888987273,
-0.0911256373,
0.4403537214,
-0.0175432153,
-0.5724048615,
-0.1302348226,
-0.0770424902,
-0.5370531678,
0.3286630213,
0.8606583476,
-0.8293216825,
0.5354180932,
0.1245775074,
1.0900006294,
0.0203556996,
0.0685722604,
0.5074164271,
-0.2589253187,
-0.1118014902,
0.5401254296,
0.4158473909,
0.022580456,
-0.6091325283,
0.3500652015,
0.1477582604,
-0.7127829194,
-0.7643226981,
-0.0365413539,
-0.9869432449,
-0.3636309803,
0.8531442285,
-0.1435856968,
-0.0350905918,
-0.1315874755,
0.0035791413,
0.3132325411,
-0.3335987926,
1.0847680569,
0.4486718774,
-0.5816553831,
-0.1514887363,
-0.8161857724,
0.24997814,
0.4378055334,
-1.2321867943,
-0.3704161644,
0.6894847751,
0.1386554241,
-0.0151142264,
1.1227043867,
-0.2263909876,
0.5955789089,
-0.1821046025,
0.0748440772,
-0.0668858066,
-0.4856332242,
-0.3570083678,
0.0377783775,
0.1005557179,
-0.352766633
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09739v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09739v2
|
QuRating: Selecting High-Quality Data for Training Language Models
| 2024-02-15T06:36:07 | 2024-06-13T18:55:23 |
Alexander Wettig, Aatmik Gupta, Saumya Malik, Danqi Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Selecting high-quality pre-training data is important for creating capable
language models, but existing methods rely on simple heuristics. We introduce
QuRating, a method for selecting pre-training data that can capture human
intuitions about data quality. In this paper, we investigate four qualities -
writing style, required expertise, facts & trivia, and educational value - and
find that LLMs are able to discern these qualities, especially when making
pairwise judgments of texts. We train a QuRater model to learn scalar ratings
from pairwise judgments, and use it to annotate a 260B training corpus with
quality ratings for each of the four criteria. In our experiments, we select
30B tokens according to the different quality ratings and train 1.3B-parameter
language models on the selected data. We find that it is important to balance
quality and diversity. When we sample using quality ratings as logits over
documents, our models obtain lower perplexity and stronger in-context learning
performance than baselines. Our best model is based on educational value and
performs similarly to a model trained with uniform sampling for 50% more steps.
Beyond data selection, we use the quality ratings to construct a training
curriculum which improves performance without changing the training dataset. We
extensively analyze the quality ratings and discuss their characteristics,
biases, and wider implications.
|
[
-0.2597149611,
-0.2923844159,
0.2793130875,
0.2184279263,
-0.3424076438,
0.2750563025,
-0.0185196232,
-0.2800902724,
-0.1766933799,
0.5617926121,
-0.0278511904,
-0.6640453935,
-0.5873139501,
-0.0351536423,
-0.694057703,
1.0468794107,
0.0310135949,
0.3645218611,
-0.3932493627,
-0.1456008852,
-0.1620265692,
-0.9154816866,
-0.5996325612,
-0.1821206659,
0.3356717527,
0.5705217719,
0.9103080034,
0.6799832582,
0.4628304243,
0.1894377023,
-0.036637608,
0.2638713121,
-0.7283966541,
0.1832090765,
-0.1372852176,
-0.6355786324,
-0.1207870096,
0.4597425461,
0.675577879,
0.6950648427,
0.0768088102,
0.3257257342,
0.14934659,
0.9617955089,
-0.4914099872,
-0.194309026,
-0.4259768724,
0.1493285298,
-0.337469101,
-0.2253180593,
-0.1826106906,
-0.7437559962,
0.0012733075,
-0.3863347173,
0.2772946358,
0.3375340402,
1.1902005672,
0.2022342086,
-0.4531702399,
-0.2341235429,
-0.4966310859,
0.9392384291,
-0.6841448545,
0.7453337908,
1.0382312536,
0.2244466096,
0.0593984388,
-0.4423204064,
-0.4062246084,
-0.4163845778,
0.0073348712,
0.1755032688,
0.4407996237,
-0.1464882195,
0.1560347825,
0.6327655315,
-0.524553299,
-0.0176905151,
-0.5369968414,
-0.2522729635,
0.6923545003,
-0.0669872761,
0.2746641934,
-0.1984336376,
-0.239401713,
-0.3132604957,
-0.9395673275,
0.5600221157,
0.8007423878,
0.1858858466,
0.1683544815,
0.6631859541,
-0.4499303997,
0.4975698292,
-0.0424216501,
-0.2510231137,
0.2166859806,
-0.510643065,
0.0794494823,
-0.2897423506,
0.7723640203,
0.1845882684,
0.2561201751,
-0.2519257963,
-0.5322160125,
-0.3118622601,
0.412820667,
-0.8128475547,
-0.3979486525,
0.2724204063,
-0.6580122113,
-0.422070533,
0.1262321919,
-0.4243199527,
-0.1692344844,
-0.4993408918,
0.3372510374,
-0.5910257101,
-0.240445435,
-0.0068710921,
-0.0661423504,
0.1813452244,
0.041976545,
-1.0139502287,
0.1438864917,
0.4890743792,
0.609318316,
-0.4516651332,
-0.4213909805,
-0.6647008061,
-0.1169439703,
-0.7149888277,
0.8094130754,
-0.6557325721,
-0.3840059936,
0.0019377263,
-0.3394778967,
0.2544112206,
-0.592815876,
0.9785277843,
-0.5424165726,
0.208158195,
-0.3523205817,
-0.7550222874,
-0.1993385255,
0.0709322765,
-0.8494971991,
1.3123476505,
0.5196983814,
-0.6948985457,
0.708403945,
-0.1503811628,
-0.4488915205,
0.0359991379,
-0.1593557596,
-0.5438486934,
0.1327300519,
0.319412291,
0.6646502614,
-0.144204542,
0.363327682,
-0.032778997,
-0.3470880091,
0.4578677714,
-0.1525559723,
0.6570585966,
0.4301205873,
0.2739189863,
0.1958008111,
-0.7856299877,
0.2547652423,
-0.1332421005,
-0.6468374729,
-0.2075416893,
0.0306879282,
-0.141835615,
0.2321306318,
0.0041870656,
-0.2854869664,
0.0490774624,
-0.5327216387,
0.1058554128,
0.4993846118,
-0.0793288648,
0.3917842805,
-0.7427924275,
0.4627304077,
0.2263786793,
0.093894653,
0.1761568189,
-0.0978569761,
-0.8047816157,
-0.1304824799,
0.5197932124,
0.2420763224,
-0.7944777012,
0.4674333334,
0.038907934,
-0.5861446857,
-0.9020161033,
0.620192945,
0.3023231328,
0.1817444712,
0.2945016325,
-0.3111567497,
-0.4698960483,
-0.5769625902,
-0.236466065,
-0.2445530593,
0.0691861957,
-0.0920951366,
0.2987098098,
0.1007513329,
1.0819481611,
-0.10690929,
-0.0132581331,
-0.5387938023,
0.0943176374,
0.3176563978,
0.4955844879,
0.565698266,
-0.7409881353,
-0.3646525145,
-0.2659336925,
-0.6030195951,
-0.1553191841,
-0.101398468,
-0.4902791381,
0.0385061651,
0.3913715184,
-0.3712102771,
0.1921559721,
0.5198048949,
-0.1388821155,
0.7999014258,
0.1297294497,
0.3780243099,
-0.9807221293,
-0.0480707027,
-0.0087566571,
-0.304359287,
-0.6057586074,
0.0139012039,
0.0525553077,
0.1350729764,
-0.5335603952,
0.6872317791,
-0.2637914419,
0.0505770631,
-0.1721691042,
-0.1784080863,
0.1960825622,
0.4232993126,
0.0939584374,
0.9694638848,
0.5422091484,
-0.7415936589,
0.409199506,
0.4300323427,
-0.7664428949,
0.5273830891,
-0.6081893444,
0.0574499518,
0.1436581761,
-0.1972747892,
-0.9472544193,
-0.1299920082,
0.0717992112,
-0.6727559566,
0.0749913752,
-0.1350490451,
-0.5784050822,
-0.1961580962,
-0.3117520511,
0.4537250698,
0.5330790281,
-0.6941754222,
0.2287532687,
0.4658831358,
-0.1716298014,
-0.5716946721,
-0.2748531103,
-0.1296753287,
-0.1830839068,
-0.2424360961,
0.0763429925,
-0.0137036582,
-0.1026914492,
-0.1188504398,
-0.2664370537,
-0.2683753371,
0.2817409933,
0.2667130828,
0.2718852162,
-0.0841411054,
0.0837146342,
0.2720464468,
-0.180804655,
0.102281183,
-0.3119210005,
0.3616454303,
0.0368397236,
-0.4287885427,
-0.4036820233,
0.1492146701,
0.0676129907,
-0.3569845557,
0.7467882037,
0.6957172155,
-0.1204902604,
-0.2103437334,
-0.6603935361,
-0.2536952496,
-0.4560464323,
0.321465373,
-0.3991980851,
-0.8230451345,
0.0499223918,
0.0748944804,
0.1632521898,
0.2057761401,
0.454921186,
-0.5001662374,
1.1042741537,
0.5112807155,
-0.2154280692,
0.5043643117,
-0.172872439,
0.1739074886,
-0.6165946722,
0.0096793491,
-0.6173782349,
0.0807641149,
-0.405851841,
-0.1518471688,
0.2225357145,
0.4745765924,
-0.2025862336,
-0.0659584105,
-0.2645984888,
0.6584716439,
0.7993307114,
0.1173208952,
0.3463384211,
0.0065198457,
-0.1380364746,
0.1263618022,
-0.5269402266,
-0.875567317,
1.3339854479,
0.3723077178,
0.7018095851,
0.0361177996,
0.7862662077,
0.2070750147,
0.2842849195,
-0.6346176267,
0.4658195078,
-0.1924989671,
-0.58253932,
-0.4522961974,
-0.6510416865,
-0.8373154402,
0.2032344937,
-0.5772590637,
-0.3172487617,
-0.1926959902,
0.1057067811,
-0.4018423557,
0.1477705091,
-0.3540197313,
0.5858954787,
-0.4202367961,
-0.2713114917,
-0.0791971534,
-0.610653162,
0.3604418635,
-0.1423338056,
0.0889598727,
-0.3115178347,
0.2906434238,
1.0577876568,
-0.1742028594,
0.575273931,
0.0883792937,
0.0800368935,
0.4778601825,
0.2765724063,
0.0133267492,
-0.0192143992,
-0.3884664476,
0.24740839,
0.5672057271,
-0.6790980101,
-0.5707930326,
0.0720033273,
-1.2494055033,
-0.5861669183,
-0.4091709852,
-0.3454551697,
-0.4799655378,
0.0807154179,
0.2448627353,
0.3253529668,
-0.2798348963,
0.2707311511,
0.445414871,
-0.2034052461,
0.0017663166,
0.1333832145,
-0.4341771603,
-0.4339933991,
1.3062883615,
0.0809864849,
0.4696255326,
0.3076821268,
0.2506962717,
-0.4672979712,
-0.8752958775,
-0.2677170038,
0.291623801,
-0.7915372849,
-0.2591712773,
-0.4391472042,
-0.5953458548,
-0.3946180344,
0.047612831,
-0.2960109711,
-0.4828241765,
-0.2933801711,
-0.2238596231,
0.0706772879,
0.6766579747,
0.0558198839,
0.5622583032,
-1.0530017614,
0.3847237825,
0.2874475718,
0.2860204279,
-0.1200250909,
-0.8018834591,
-0.5601260662,
0.0630408227,
-0.4202388525,
-0.5876600742,
0.6052838564,
0.2235965431,
0.8367215991,
0.5198307037,
0.0915958583,
0.2744015157,
-0.071838595,
0.7478837967,
-0.1092487797,
-1.0006175041,
0.5330834389,
-0.0912693366,
-0.1147690862,
0.8969296217,
0.8005268574,
-0.5325254798,
-0.6366980076,
-0.3647708893,
-0.5701976418,
0.5932453275,
0.1968548298,
0.0912839323,
0.1020416915,
0.5553724766,
0.483545661,
0.423019439,
-0.7150658965,
0.0204338133,
-0.5710268021,
-0.3707500696,
-0.0456536561,
-0.4737887383,
-0.0440214351,
-0.4385674894,
0.7012594938,
-0.0810354948,
-0.1068674773,
-0.2101339847,
-0.3656291366,
0.1497842669,
0.2682629824,
0.0289315581,
0.7332113981,
-0.0967005342,
0.13358666,
0.0389137715,
-0.4652648568,
0.3534837067,
-0.3098701835,
0.0615883134,
-0.1489786059,
0.3872818351,
0.6328747272,
0.0027003468,
-0.6327559352,
0.6350153685,
-0.0184742808,
-0.1411109865,
-0.0268715881,
0.6108474731,
-0.1300651878,
0.0807336122,
0.2927435637,
-0.2597960234,
0.1202014834,
-0.4849848151,
0.1433214694,
0.3282197416,
-0.1268209368,
-0.2361336797,
0.3530991673,
0.2916425467,
-0.1259111762,
0.9390231371,
-0.3940688372,
-0.5226774812,
0.3700895309,
0.3443579674,
0.4534732401,
-0.260812968,
0.3310748339,
0.5540613532,
0.0833009779,
-0.4577159882,
0.3560839891,
-0.1854390055,
-0.9982596636,
-0.3370012045,
-0.9682039618,
-0.7133409977,
-0.1407636553,
-0.7240912914,
0.2880601287,
-0.5025606155,
-0.1417819411,
-0.4617422521,
0.2703366578,
-0.7536451817,
0.4478470087,
-0.0337047428,
0.693256855,
-0.910454452,
0.9698704481,
0.3946076334,
-0.6346651912,
-1.0029784441,
-0.1102347672,
-0.2195439637,
-0.7904794216,
0.9489984512,
0.1222959235,
0.1223559231,
0.1372243762,
-0.7175716758,
-0.9508105516,
0.7100682855,
0.2045245022,
-0.3745289147,
0.0173952319,
0.3002469838,
0.4170819521,
-0.2142638564,
0.5956308842,
0.7409648299,
0.1180260703,
0.1869377494,
-0.5817198753,
-0.2415663898,
-0.2966372669,
-0.1448152065,
-0.1543451548,
-0.5040352941,
0.7999801636,
-0.2232951075,
-0.401746273,
0.1817720532,
1.0291293859,
0.412774235,
0.1001436263,
0.3757502735,
0.3320697844,
0.9772318602,
-0.1292305291,
0.8164768219,
-0.470592618,
0.0551954955,
0.9224479198,
-0.1845092773,
0.973482132,
0.2819694281,
-0.3570506871,
0.3309150934,
0.9975767136,
0.0429392159,
0.4243534803,
0.217749998,
-0.0150236683,
-0.5143163204,
-0.0774108693,
-0.2769339383,
0.4278332889,
0.2704657614,
-0.0157584138,
0.1358947456,
0.0196811631,
-0.1798688024,
0.0504305996,
-0.1199901924,
0.6959536076,
0.0851657614,
-0.6456571221,
0.6085581183,
-0.1841409802,
0.554076314,
-0.4022418559,
0.0140943062,
-0.3563021421,
-0.3885665536,
-0.4069048464,
-0.9838290811,
0.1697578728,
-0.0727098137,
-0.0659613684,
-0.2750340104,
0.2430716157,
-0.5498165488,
-0.619936645,
-0.0967500061,
0.8745699525,
0.5594347119,
-0.0315023549,
-0.4731011987,
-0.0322387479,
-0.1895107627,
-0.2295666337,
0.3857999146,
0.5550010204,
0.0130039984,
0.7461434603,
1.0444704294,
0.4686463773,
-0.2210971266,
0.3694062233,
0.8400011063,
-0.8950585127,
-0.471621871,
-0.7802256346,
0.266528815,
-0.0420368053,
-0.4203378856,
0.6046628356,
0.5408847332,
0.9811004996,
0.2504591942,
0.8073471785,
0.5643859506,
0.808126688,
-0.8148390651,
0.9161316752,
-0.38182953,
0.2549247444,
-0.0742129982,
-0.896612823,
-0.1152512133,
0.8226171136,
-0.3138145208,
0.1202230155,
0.7503513694,
0.7153442502,
0.221326828,
0.0914109498,
0.5450235009,
0.0200267043,
0.5322261453,
0.3368121684,
1.3121756315,
-0.1709846407,
0.3877421916,
-0.1081140935,
-0.1366598606,
-0.1409056485,
-0.658488214,
-1.3794248104,
-0.7830309272,
-0.0912410021,
-0.3122823536,
0.027904544,
1.2077413797,
0.8753315806,
-0.7398001552,
-0.3646691442,
0.2829646468,
0.408538878,
-0.1355275512,
-0.1640808284,
0.3339520097,
-0.7836802006,
-0.4111075401,
0.1710000336,
-0.0404810384,
0.1398277283,
-0.278231293,
-0.1046197265,
0.0489883721,
0.0954775885,
0.5605601072,
0.0741592571,
-0.4399186373,
-0.1924362928,
-0.179516077,
-0.48973158,
0.1940719038,
0.686150372,
-0.6771018505,
0.2131919265,
0.4164007306,
0.8532059789,
0.2754126489,
0.2085313201,
0.5324561596,
-0.5606027842,
-0.099060446,
0.3310935199,
0.1567853391,
0.4238259792,
-0.2428973466,
0.4427708089,
0.0359399728,
-0.79166466,
-0.8128941655,
0.0558403544,
-0.7335278392,
-0.1108015031,
1.2215338945,
-0.2248920351,
-0.2172062099,
-0.3250404298,
-0.4967756271,
0.1867135018,
-0.3044990301,
0.9929309487,
0.960747838,
-0.1410298944,
-0.0983207524,
-0.622592628,
0.7829744816,
0.5359241962,
-0.9462109804,
-0.1589847356,
0.2546176612,
0.19610098,
-0.3321233392,
0.5448172092,
0.0983168036,
0.2875110805,
-0.1332360357,
0.0190459471,
-0.0777004808,
-0.3768613338,
-0.0574912876,
0.1370331496,
0.5698992014,
0.0032657352
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09738v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09738v1
|
Align before Attend: Aligning Visual and Textual Features for Multimodal Hateful Content Detection
| 2024-02-15T06:34:15 | 2024-02-15T06:34:15 |
Eftekhar Hossain, Omar Sharif, Mohammed Moshiul Hoque, Sarah M. Preum
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multimodal hateful content detection is a challenging task that requires
complex reasoning across visual and textual modalities. Therefore, creating a
meaningful multimodal representation that effectively captures the interplay
between visual and textual features through intermediate fusion is critical.
Conventional fusion techniques are unable to attend to the modality-specific
features effectively. Moreover, most studies exclusively concentrated on
English and overlooked other low-resource languages. This paper proposes a
context-aware attention framework for multimodal hateful content detection and
assesses it for both English and non-English languages. The proposed approach
incorporates an attention layer to meaningfully align the visual and textual
features. This alignment enables selective focus on modality-specific features
before fusing them. We evaluate the proposed approach on two benchmark hateful
meme datasets, viz. MUTE (Bengali code-mixed) and MultiOFF (English).
Evaluation results demonstrate our proposed approach's effectiveness with
F1-scores of $69.7$% and $70.3$% for the MUTE and MultiOFF datasets. The scores
show approximately $2.5$% and $3.2$% performance improvement over the
state-of-the-art systems on these datasets. Our implementation is available at
https://github.com/eftekhar-hossain/Bengali-Hateful-Memes.
|
[
-0.5864841938,
-0.4390932918,
0.1860723495,
0.3243979216,
-0.2971900403,
-0.1648460776,
-0.228813827,
-0.470036298,
0.3498011231,
0.3595296741,
-0.6406579614,
-0.2560009658,
-0.6549750566,
0.1232544854,
-0.2684728503,
0.7933719754,
-0.0333183035,
-0.1736023575,
-0.1735095233,
-0.5566796064,
-0.5615374446,
-0.1957404613,
-0.4473468661,
0.3467228115,
0.7968424559,
0.3863479793,
0.6485958695,
0.5352724791,
0.7444801331,
0.256159991,
0.4799646437,
0.3158943653,
-0.4300119877,
0.3659002483,
-0.4869100749,
0.1152343154,
-0.1354652643,
0.0370507725,
0.376868546,
0.0130511215,
0.2800190151,
0.1798714101,
0.0865614638,
0.3373380303,
-0.9853134751,
-0.3052105308,
-0.6751899719,
-0.0310964864,
-0.4996958971,
-0.2567777932,
-0.5955668688,
0.0362049192,
-0.0903794244,
-0.5855361819,
-0.1256179512,
0.220632866,
0.6078071594,
0.5519837737,
-0.54359442,
-0.1859076768,
-0.2185975164,
1.2217457294,
-0.5039565563,
0.719301939,
0.320099473,
0.1808623523,
0.1755122542,
-0.0523128659,
-0.8715220094,
0.2683034241,
-0.2455553412,
0.3039400578,
-0.2876036167,
-0.2950023711,
0.1928556859,
0.3076007664,
-0.9774973392,
0.040130645,
-0.1802235395,
-0.4627376795,
0.5030627847,
-0.0154246651,
0.5187532306,
-0.4639945626,
-0.8887383938,
-0.1849444807,
-0.2667431831,
-0.2843639553,
0.2750506997,
0.3040340841,
-0.396620363,
0.4648675919,
0.0002360822,
0.7231401801,
-0.0083905878,
-0.4730483294,
0.3156236708,
-0.4520664811,
-0.1419706047,
-0.0084496913,
0.7471419573,
0.7732014656,
0.3158484995,
0.0098381629,
-0.0258987211,
0.6153389812,
0.4643266797,
-0.6321401596,
0.0733108148,
0.2194603235,
-0.3237507343,
-0.1873801053,
-0.5048577785,
-0.9782765508,
-0.5425963402,
-0.1551114917,
0.397847414,
-0.6017587185,
-0.5221144557,
-0.4145100713,
-0.1701743305,
0.1865791082,
0.3293039799,
-0.616940856,
-0.2879740596,
0.2496300042,
0.6763056517,
-0.4534530044,
-0.3446623981,
-0.5123137832,
0.5060876012,
0.0851888955,
0.8511166573,
-0.7052795291,
0.2926779985,
0.0941741765,
0.052185744,
-0.1000486463,
-0.3929198682,
0.7187948823,
-0.5622401237,
0.1524304301,
-0.0222781505,
-0.186491996,
-0.2569160163,
0.6941806078,
-0.713229239,
0.6435174942,
0.3072344661,
-1.0345566273,
0.3958671093,
-0.418943882,
-0.5450484753,
-0.0582225733,
-0.1078960374,
-0.5309303999,
-0.374104172,
0.309102118,
0.4732608795,
-0.0125934007,
0.04488042,
-0.534463644,
-0.1956358552,
0.1881689727,
-0.4341718554,
0.5793601871,
0.4869461954,
-0.6084796786,
0.252515465,
-0.5977146029,
-0.0614225492,
0.0774843991,
-0.0224567894,
-0.6470957398,
0.0353162177,
0.6153792739,
0.5252816677,
0.0054770992,
-0.3818773329,
-0.2560277879,
-0.2626648545,
0.0078249322,
0.9587680101,
-0.3077822626,
0.4821505547,
-0.4795924723,
0.5637627244,
0.4325831234,
0.2793217897,
-0.3366803825,
-0.266875267,
-0.4319883287,
-0.5120400786,
-0.1261574924,
0.4708976448,
-0.8691347837,
0.0978052691,
0.0109555535,
-0.2478474528,
-0.5117431879,
0.2239135057,
0.5935317278,
0.4099527597,
0.6394923329,
-0.2916255593,
-0.833060801,
-1.1393141747,
-0.3371354043,
0.0350591987,
0.192337662,
0.3177570999,
0.0985964239,
-0.351592958,
0.4957738817,
-0.2960063815,
-0.7886473536,
-0.0008581474,
-0.0504905172,
-0.2682757974,
0.5243846774,
0.6986905336,
-1.2352477312,
-0.8291762471,
0.1142684892,
-0.6680544615,
-0.2027571797,
0.0082945311,
-0.3704106808,
0.3309741616,
0.3125315905,
0.0848859474,
0.3220990002,
0.7232897282,
-0.3913980126,
0.2452032864,
0.6293362379,
0.8778885603,
-1.2383564711,
-0.1430240273,
0.1025649384,
-0.2576468885,
-0.4313239753,
-0.1016942933,
0.1682614535,
-0.0812622756,
-0.6612477899,
0.606069088,
-0.5488224626,
0.3247077763,
-0.1354084909,
0.323626399,
0.0551787764,
0.5972681046,
-0.0646139085,
0.692622304,
0.1987471581,
-0.2135050148,
0.1994038075,
0.2246874869,
-0.2589686215,
1.116310358,
0.115961805,
-0.1174456105,
0.0137029039,
-0.2371147573,
-1.2135725021,
-0.4673842788,
0.6163572669,
-0.5294358134,
0.2911398709,
-0.094121702,
-0.2228259891,
-0.1779998094,
-0.6210533381,
0.9821895361,
0.060084749,
-0.3364212513,
0.6340954304,
0.7528008223,
-0.0719133243,
-0.7788771987,
-0.5855920315,
-0.0766677111,
-0.2752850652,
-0.767190814,
0.4498892128,
-0.3095760345,
-0.1404744089,
-0.0661578998,
0.1110555753,
-0.3589376509,
-0.0836078003,
0.259445399,
0.0006244712,
-0.2134388089,
-0.0791025609,
0.1905353665,
0.0367505029,
-0.2697370946,
0.0775336251,
0.4300639033,
0.2110068053,
-0.4571205676,
-0.2939040363,
0.8382663131,
0.9758755565,
-0.3069547713,
0.4287951589,
1.0134446621,
-0.4760966897,
0.0324332081,
-0.980790019,
-0.0068181944,
-0.4081683457,
0.3151243329,
-0.0902773961,
-0.9509093165,
0.3869651258,
0.4970240295,
-0.0602272861,
0.3211898804,
0.5993984938,
-0.0953642502,
0.967464447,
0.6035209298,
-0.0455189645,
0.650737524,
0.4177139103,
0.4417242706,
-0.7965524793,
-0.2108784914,
-0.2592107058,
-0.5418311954,
-0.217538625,
-0.625518322,
0.4095040262,
-0.3434312642,
0.1334083527,
0.398018688,
-0.6022729874,
0.4835187495,
0.1738474816,
0.1436772197,
0.0810732841,
0.1917188466,
0.1146343946,
-0.7234581113,
-0.4158291817,
-0.1827023923,
0.9147375226,
0.0135130789,
0.7447443008,
0.4958603084,
0.3058162332,
0.5491930246,
0.513995409,
-0.6086884141,
0.2738552392,
-0.093984656,
-0.7007485628,
-0.1633692086,
-0.1833212376,
-0.6406504512,
0.3681129813,
-0.1629204601,
-0.28923437,
0.063218765,
0.1906846315,
-0.1736507118,
0.2176432014,
-0.9882495999,
1.1155779362,
-0.1572553366,
-0.6307650208,
-0.4032652378,
-0.5950371027,
0.4643504024,
-0.134087339,
0.7012562156,
-0.1923223883,
-0.0635268837,
0.8230731487,
0.1087540388,
0.8082118034,
-0.0277102739,
-0.1350445598,
0.0410437919,
0.1014370099,
0.1085877717,
-0.1807401478,
0.1005512998,
0.0504563376,
-0.2666769326,
-0.4268773496,
-0.441750437,
0.8944259286,
-0.278519094,
-0.4245753884,
-0.3228911459,
-0.8513771892,
-0.2046783566,
0.276489675,
0.0065471726,
0.3871492147,
-0.0362110697,
0.163709119,
0.7755112648,
0.0292508025,
0.5668333769,
0.5607779026,
-0.0510892235,
-0.6954602599,
1.0391162634,
0.191261068,
0.0719955638,
0.4049737155,
-0.1750510484,
-0.2002369016,
-0.373647511,
-0.6233583093,
0.1049851328,
-0.6663613319,
-0.5903368592,
-0.9324662089,
0.0089810556,
-0.6529327631,
-0.5445856452,
-0.1867936552,
0.0519368015,
-0.1129315645,
0.4007591605,
0.1530179679,
0.2362954915,
-0.1620780677,
0.1414387971,
-0.7247876525,
0.4534004033,
0.2108483613,
0.2985154688,
0.1055975258,
-0.7313085794,
-0.3166927695,
-0.1804072559,
-0.5215560198,
-1.020565629,
0.313590914,
-0.0514253303,
0.5387265682,
0.853530407,
0.3553339839,
0.662645936,
-0.3911007941,
0.4900679886,
0.3319791555,
-0.7368112206,
0.7380593419,
-0.3330546618,
0.2022053748,
0.4916427433,
0.8606591821,
-0.5400684476,
-0.7859665751,
-0.4303704202,
-0.7373260856,
0.7077823281,
0.1581822038,
0.0917252079,
-0.278023243,
-0.351249963,
0.0805754215,
0.1211760938,
-1.212482214,
-0.3211989105,
-0.2766261995,
-0.4881617427,
0.1941641271,
-0.5246859789,
-0.1193232015,
-0.2567215264,
0.6445856094,
-0.1124544963,
-0.0693116635,
0.0921099335,
-0.6964272261,
-0.1905901134,
0.2673393488,
0.7698473334,
0.5582502484,
-0.0560519472,
0.2550356388,
-0.1334498525,
-0.4569062591,
0.2406342626,
-0.0131382085,
0.0364645682,
-0.1158532873,
0.397636503,
0.2418405414,
0.4998603463,
-0.8902240396,
0.9245531559,
0.0594475046,
0.0929048806,
-0.1212472841,
-0.1342823207,
-0.2976665497,
0.4827241302,
0.1418504119,
0.2127289623,
0.2383090407,
-0.2480721921,
0.6470393538,
0.4902562499,
-0.6922571063,
-0.2431752533,
0.5381653905,
0.290994674,
0.0444670022,
0.1222975254,
-0.0208855141,
-0.8145544529,
0.4293332994,
0.6839625835,
0.5710963011,
-0.6377885938,
0.1830218285,
0.4879275262,
0.6221972704,
0.7480707169,
0.1060076579,
-0.2352341413,
-0.8664314151,
-0.2966583967,
-0.8147322536,
-0.2540089488,
0.2472225428,
-0.5248529315,
0.3327262998,
-0.4174500406,
0.225370571,
0.1569147408,
-0.3957963884,
-0.3674649,
0.3936167359,
0.4695520401,
0.4811843038,
-1.0627918243,
0.2879639566,
0.6736522913,
-0.4801984429,
-0.5821457505,
0.0036311797,
0.3350181878,
-0.884262383,
0.2125314176,
0.5082372427,
-0.0270719379,
-0.0714418292,
-0.2275701612,
-0.7697151899,
0.5316066146,
0.2699277401,
-0.4269890189,
0.4335925281,
-0.2374432236,
0.0565143973,
-0.4154628217,
0.3572075069,
0.1484028697,
0.5900568366,
0.0241787862,
-0.5553626418,
0.2306503952,
-0.384003371,
-0.3572146595,
0.4951809645,
-0.8054043055,
0.5830078125,
0.0578766391,
-0.3895012736,
-0.5020877719,
0.5389422774,
-0.1507906616,
0.4623351991,
0.7014694214,
0.8206159472,
0.3446577191,
0.0972808525,
0.749489665,
0.0718746334,
0.0543197617,
0.9678254724,
-0.3019478321,
0.7341564298,
0.7367101908,
-0.0789533854,
0.3775714636,
0.4758646488,
0.0659728348,
0.7686295509,
-0.1087764353,
-0.3958097398,
-0.3656852543,
-0.6283992529,
-0.4769028425,
0.549443543,
0.1791374683,
-0.3389019072,
-0.397043407,
0.5566387773,
0.0630299523,
0.3731561303,
-0.2899459302,
0.9343284965,
-0.207306698,
-0.5298919678,
0.6218088269,
-0.1471305937,
0.9406354427,
-0.462602824,
0.0150568439,
0.0008317406,
0.1381039917,
-0.3176444769,
-0.6324159503,
0.7253246903,
0.0425165258,
-0.8223273754,
-0.2503676713,
0.6194171309,
-0.7682044506,
-0.1153484881,
0.6794836521,
0.0340891145,
-0.0232480448,
-0.2802864611,
-0.5895750523,
0.5234456062,
0.2789206207,
0.0708544329,
0.5327827334,
0.2675519884,
-0.2611763179,
0.1811365336,
0.5762659311,
-0.4250636697,
0.0621427558,
0.2048678994,
0.8940292001,
-0.5165438056,
-0.4902713597,
-0.8245791793,
0.6910182238,
-0.1591292918,
-0.2417596281,
0.6665604711,
0.5840491652,
1.2446382046,
-0.0765740573,
0.6289274693,
-0.1686921716,
0.5983581543,
-0.3357490003,
0.8799925447,
-1.0485892296,
-0.4222349226,
-0.5479348302,
-0.9200952649,
-0.416130811,
0.4564281702,
-0.1055704802,
-0.3637447357,
0.784923315,
0.9428461194,
-0.2841048241,
-0.2034172118,
0.6934993863,
0.1670048237,
0.0995988995,
0.6468189359,
0.8373387456,
-0.6125403643,
0.7657505274,
-0.2900747955,
-0.5441747904,
-0.2896466553,
-0.8120281696,
-0.843749702,
-0.7901561856,
-0.326000303,
-0.3348103464,
-0.203170076,
0.5981639624,
0.5879949927,
-1.0015279055,
0.2287235409,
0.7157030702,
0.4200235307,
-0.0664982349,
-0.2920765281,
0.1329363585,
-0.3357035816,
-0.7387660742,
0.3392210305,
0.8424468637,
-0.1358301342,
-0.0228677727,
0.0271982234,
-0.6931666732,
0.1779759079,
0.7247896194,
0.0381316617,
-0.7987360954,
-0.3582820594,
-0.1763231009,
-0.3290192187,
0.0915250108,
0.6902983189,
-0.3915459216,
0.5142545104,
0.2396936417,
0.9160417914,
-0.0160741955,
-0.0942213461,
0.0931482613,
-0.8055517673,
0.5709813833,
0.3601046205,
0.3578848839,
0.5064743161,
-0.4768163562,
0.2291613221,
0.5040488243,
-0.2865554392,
-0.8979610205,
0.3323344588,
-1.3099181652,
0.0603991002,
0.7306534648,
-0.0400865376,
-0.4129170179,
-0.2956412137,
-0.2831904888,
0.1003174782,
-0.268029511,
0.6740608215,
0.7903553247,
0.3572139144,
-0.3217813373,
-0.0723804608,
0.3782133758,
0.8435886502,
-0.5805398822,
0.0587146282,
0.6936810017,
-0.0187051557,
0.385876447,
0.573538065,
-0.2148018926,
0.6017994881,
-0.1447745711,
0.1978537738,
0.0396087654,
-0.5991081595,
0.0090071475,
0.3766382337,
-0.6038680673,
-0.1585623175
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09733v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09733v1
|
Do LLMs Know about Hallucination? An Empirical Investigation of LLM's Hidden States
| 2024-02-15T06:14:55 | 2024-02-15T06:14:55 |
Hanyu Duan, Yi Yang, Kar Yan Tam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) can make up answers that are not real, and this
is known as hallucination. This research aims to see if, how, and to what
extent LLMs are aware of hallucination. More specifically, we check whether and
how an LLM reacts differently in its hidden states when it answers a question
right versus when it hallucinates. To do this, we introduce an experimental
framework which allows examining LLM's hidden states in different hallucination
situations. Building upon this framework, we conduct a series of experiments
with language models in the LLaMA family (Touvron et al., 2023). Our empirical
findings suggest that LLMs react differently when processing a genuine response
versus a fabricated one. We then apply various model interpretation techniques
to help understand and explain the findings better. Moreover, informed by the
empirical observations, we show great potential of using the guidance derived
from LLM's hidden representation space to mitigate hallucination. We believe
this work provides insights into how LLMs produce hallucinated answers and how
to make them occur less often.
|
[
-0.3382477462,
-0.8779222369,
1.1030848026,
0.0701222196,
-0.0929445401,
0.1444461048,
-0.1925425231,
-0.7597596645,
0.5319013,
0.4684865773,
-0.8214020133,
-0.3909091055,
-0.4332499206,
0.2525823116,
-0.5589289069,
0.5159626007,
0.0470000617,
0.1324849874,
-0.2123648673,
0.052374538,
-0.4256939888,
-0.8000576496,
-0.2465136647,
-0.319191277,
0.6484466791,
0.1747994274,
0.4788421392,
0.6190351844,
0.191194877,
0.1867364645,
-0.287781328,
0.0075742034,
-0.7338792086,
0.1203616038,
0.0712894499,
-0.870806694,
-0.2252745479,
-0.0226602852,
0.4025301337,
0.8010578156,
-0.1253784597,
0.0785001367,
-0.0388560183,
0.5526670218,
-0.5713682175,
-0.0077411849,
-0.8367589116,
0.4485046566,
0.2201315463,
-0.3555105329,
-0.5485651493,
-0.5267223716,
-0.135440141,
-0.2138798535,
0.4201403856,
0.2234401405,
0.6931250095,
0.501719594,
-0.4728018939,
-0.534286797,
-0.8931089044,
0.5823382735,
-0.6126664281,
0.4347464144,
0.5725585222,
0.1931824237,
-0.2573828697,
-0.4140753746,
-0.8231191635,
-0.5531219244,
-0.3723559678,
-0.0601817034,
0.0252956524,
-0.1271246225,
0.4082939625,
0.5438235998,
-0.6353242993,
0.1563203633,
-0.2851232588,
-0.3804406226,
0.3775625825,
0.1554224193,
0.3014730513,
-0.0676092952,
-0.2366421372,
0.0929496959,
-0.8686283827,
-0.344753921,
0.3556631505,
0.0434952006,
0.0951079056,
0.9844949841,
0.0196795668,
0.3501037061,
-0.0252885167,
0.2059914917,
-0.0198509749,
0.0520558357,
-0.218760699,
0.3728900254,
0.4900880456,
0.0728936493,
0.0925116837,
-0.4409389198,
-0.5758727789,
0.3259770572,
0.3141266108,
-0.7906109691,
-0.0642920211,
0.3024798036,
-0.4988191128,
-0.3231185079,
-0.1515536159,
-0.3883091509,
-0.9004772305,
-0.1952433586,
0.7152123451,
-0.1919112206,
-0.4366211891,
0.3040164709,
-0.0687189028,
0.4209411144,
0.1372104734,
-0.8829398155,
0.7197321653,
0.6913630366,
0.5320654511,
-0.1819229126,
-0.2431523055,
-0.4093833864,
-0.177685529,
-0.5486941934,
0.8455117941,
-0.5447123051,
-0.3357234299,
0.061004892,
0.1818692833,
-0.1239707842,
-0.9860702157,
0.1569145024,
-0.6111047268,
0.0338933021,
-0.6875533462,
-0.6487061977,
-0.4265603721,
0.0895678997,
-0.7567533255,
0.8527521491,
-0.2978567183,
-0.5420703888,
0.2192047983,
-0.3045660555,
-0.0795728937,
-0.0458885171,
-0.4643840492,
-0.223942861,
0.6539658904,
-0.0023959996,
0.478900075,
0.0469444245,
0.0612484999,
-0.3261180222,
-0.7870199084,
0.9324175715,
-0.3462615907,
0.3382282555,
0.0597826689,
-0.5603169799,
0.1307680905,
-0.7786604762,
-0.3793284297,
0.3906210959,
-0.1612075865,
-0.1296420544,
0.0882707313,
-0.3569290638,
-0.0187364183,
0.2515797019,
-0.5540557504,
0.269693315,
-0.3650717437,
0.1664310545,
0.8272824883,
0.1629938036,
0.3141237795,
-0.3553935587,
0.4094391465,
-0.0344233327,
-0.170878157,
0.1616123468,
-0.3491957486,
-1.1066226959,
-0.0287574418,
-0.0298969224,
0.2809960544,
-0.2186356783,
0.3867661655,
0.1481131613,
-0.0991125777,
-0.6081945896,
-0.1040918604,
0.2934560776,
0.4868321717,
0.1614021361,
0.0221760739,
-0.494703114,
-0.9649425745,
-0.0938736647,
-0.2288341671,
0.0505553298,
0.2289266288,
0.7003048658,
-0.2964338064,
0.6184583306,
-0.5863149166,
-0.2443321049,
-0.2290466726,
0.1436588019,
0.1575619876,
-0.1148785725,
0.277079016,
-0.5698074698,
0.250887394,
-0.106114544,
-1.2509820461,
0.0494885966,
-0.2402849346,
0.1496336907,
0.1635660678,
0.5339905024,
-0.6508799195,
0.644269824,
0.5155412555,
-0.3465638161,
0.5858897567,
-0.2459222972,
-0.0342173353,
-0.5457523465,
-0.2083046883,
-0.542585969,
-0.0851684138,
-0.5666842461,
-0.0188146289,
0.0205936339,
0.0430989675,
-0.4017105699,
0.48413831,
-0.6974576712,
-0.6343414783,
-0.4738304019,
0.1683056951,
-0.2578903437,
0.6495388746,
0.3371779025,
0.8846155405,
0.5240134597,
-0.8089170456,
0.0178297404,
0.0648415983,
-0.4984564185,
-0.0654634014,
-0.5608104467,
0.351380229,
-0.2125882655,
0.093091011,
-1.1624552011,
-0.2990053892,
0.3625198007,
-0.4865130186,
-0.0405534394,
0.1895226091,
-0.6070992351,
-0.2593198121,
-0.1785648018,
0.1458253264,
0.5100212693,
-0.6346388459,
0.5144878626,
0.4082312882,
0.0412228741,
-0.3773514628,
-0.8249725699,
0.0506998338,
-0.2286585867,
-0.2918956578,
0.0712705329,
-0.481905371,
-0.5843383074,
-0.0381302312,
-0.3016183972,
0.1069071814,
0.3660212457,
0.5979196429,
0.003444406,
-0.2501574159,
0.2905888855,
0.0545700751,
0.1173059866,
0.5033810735,
0.2351093143,
0.944660902,
-0.2227789909,
-0.6566023231,
-0.4797358215,
0.1608539969,
0.4121777117,
0.0566086024,
0.9894189835,
0.2725083232,
-0.8171867728,
-0.2166332155,
-0.6365195513,
-0.6748968959,
-0.4297410846,
0.1534907371,
-0.5772643685,
-0.9019002318,
0.9443778396,
0.1534606218,
-0.1799298525,
0.0880827382,
0.9211853147,
-0.0565800443,
1.1187852621,
0.6824369431,
0.2204737663,
-0.0497511439,
-0.1852626652,
0.3170205057,
-0.8054842353,
-0.3871534467,
-0.3642237186,
-0.3566178679,
-0.598716557,
-0.3277899921,
0.2114692181,
0.0422411896,
0.0544064082,
0.0447956994,
-0.3879734874,
0.5925475955,
-0.0005092233,
0.2771216929,
0.3436844647,
-0.059645582,
-0.1325401962,
0.0054610106,
-0.3080973625,
-0.6962442994,
0.7985501289,
0.4571562409,
0.7423018813,
0.1908097565,
0.9363505244,
0.2820720375,
0.2386315912,
-0.9215794802,
0.8288969994,
0.5954924226,
-0.606926024,
-0.293948561,
-0.2380774468,
-0.9921603799,
0.3963503242,
-0.2091468871,
-0.8138023019,
0.0758135095,
-0.1623103768,
-0.2795701623,
0.2064345181,
-0.4636560977,
0.3821248114,
-0.2647175789,
-0.2632598281,
-0.2521986067,
-0.4055818319,
0.6467404366,
-0.1902057528,
0.1674982607,
-0.1948372722,
0.095539324,
0.7918971181,
-0.2207512558,
1.1285990477,
0.0387731194,
-0.6035782099,
0.175536558,
0.4332117736,
0.5582491159,
0.1258365661,
-0.2137997448,
-0.024238551,
-0.3039496541,
-0.1427656859,
-0.6360292435,
0.9092447162,
-0.7235780954,
-0.8829009533,
-0.5047485828,
-0.6078574061,
-0.1135103256,
0.0235898141,
0.1615908295,
0.045097176,
-0.2441691607,
-0.1471233666,
1.0192821026,
-0.4312973619,
0.4662092328,
0.6853977442,
-0.7530305386,
0.0942918137,
0.6411849856,
0.2330177426,
0.0380664133,
0.399543345,
0.2996821105,
-0.5101813078,
-0.4482451677,
-0.2757243812,
0.8551793694,
-0.9388155341,
0.3499483466,
-0.5924562812,
-0.3475247025,
-0.434827745,
0.1444789618,
-0.216052115,
-0.4087773263,
-0.5485551953,
-0.6226610541,
0.33173576,
1.3484121561,
0.0222701207,
0.0131853335,
-0.3960007727,
0.5923068523,
0.5203841925,
0.1969537437,
0.1700859815,
-0.6319184899,
0.2111460716,
0.1203792393,
0.1287280321,
-1.1290533543,
0.3785419166,
-0.1946404576,
0.6022444367,
0.4045641422,
0.2167085111,
0.7267251611,
-0.4816556573,
0.8169782758,
-0.1433060169,
-0.7876125574,
0.2837532461,
0.0372294374,
0.02430843,
0.1696141511,
0.356829077,
-0.4576298296,
-0.7227800488,
-0.3826369345,
-0.3667835891,
0.3137378395,
0.1276487261,
0.4010727406,
-0.1567638963,
0.3413176537,
0.4349778295,
0.2869865298,
-1.0238577127,
-0.2955081165,
0.1904699504,
0.2426951975,
0.0856265277,
-0.5717602372,
-0.2855562568,
-0.0357889831,
0.2257874608,
0.0839634165,
0.5572404265,
0.1174784377,
-0.414858222,
-0.3644178808,
0.0939794257,
0.8972377777,
0.8571372032,
-0.4324129224,
0.570438683,
0.28578794,
-0.313256979,
0.077418603,
-0.4950256348,
-0.0616068654,
-0.0051252861,
0.4496363401,
0.8925021291,
-0.0279701706,
-0.6880515218,
0.3885924816,
-0.3689721227,
-0.280652374,
-0.6331670284,
0.1756865382,
0.2622906864,
0.2168154866,
0.4074783921,
-0.1891608089,
0.1406880468,
-0.8082931042,
0.2082861066,
0.3907445371,
-0.4119865596,
-0.567115128,
0.7856970429,
-0.2649995685,
-0.4950937927,
0.5156222582,
-0.2615852952,
-0.620842576,
0.6284493208,
0.7321807146,
0.8436899185,
-0.0583209284,
0.1928694397,
0.090922609,
0.3449166715,
0.1770186573,
0.5687532425,
-0.1182993501,
-0.751896441,
-0.3075077236,
-0.7492821813,
-0.3660632372,
0.6085099578,
-0.7298544049,
0.0262830853,
-0.3289432824,
0.1430312991,
-0.2959311903,
-0.1762032062,
-0.5311758518,
0.1494693607,
0.4056898654,
0.5334221721,
-0.9756009579,
0.6435182095,
0.2850794196,
-0.3486537635,
-0.5966861844,
0.4121122658,
0.0079525504,
-1.1449139118,
0.6857584715,
0.4112500548,
-0.509455502,
-0.0537284762,
-0.7020453215,
-0.7203427553,
0.8000445366,
0.2035607398,
-0.5308822393,
0.2659249604,
0.4942989647,
0.6858407855,
-0.080340378,
0.0709190369,
0.5925014615,
0.3708425462,
0.1710495055,
-0.5145360827,
0.3147344291,
0.0026191133,
-0.2202823907,
0.0062596747,
-0.471221447,
0.6291236281,
-0.5611365438,
-0.5433936715,
0.1803024113,
0.8889021277,
0.5383933187,
0.407536447,
0.3558101356,
0.4138291478,
1.0297966003,
0.1717303395,
0.9843450785,
-0.227144748,
0.0310214236,
0.8758155107,
-0.6125702858,
0.9023499489,
0.7639494538,
0.0934887305,
0.3496888578,
0.8058838844,
0.2554132938,
0.5324808359,
0.6108301282,
-0.2931444645,
-0.2367081046,
-0.2170082033,
-0.327968806,
0.219953537,
0.4688646197,
-0.1757691503,
0.2571468651,
0.22020109,
0.1183699667,
0.0278273094,
-0.1405335963,
0.7689391375,
0.1975905895,
-0.5888406634,
0.9258102775,
-0.2723129392,
0.3549545109,
-0.306976825,
-0.155973047,
-0.6695527434,
0.0724517107,
-0.2944982052,
-0.7855822444,
0.2862540185,
0.0174102634,
-0.1914687157,
-0.0664279461,
0.6247367263,
-0.3014223576,
-0.3815038502,
0.5028692484,
0.4542902112,
0.6816037893,
-0.149802044,
-0.2408919334,
0.2892439961,
0.0094594955,
-0.3445364237,
0.4378874898,
0.4810011983,
-0.1643978655,
0.8654581308,
0.5593557954,
0.353915453,
0.508515656,
0.2667724192,
0.7808862925,
-0.7388753295,
-0.049482841,
-0.7994457483,
0.1686204076,
0.1741538048,
-0.0373564698,
0.8097634315,
0.5673696399,
0.7389019132,
-0.3392733932,
0.6255366802,
0.2638344467,
0.498518914,
-0.7169111371,
0.7907392979,
-0.7680940628,
0.6472482085,
0.0991422459,
-1.0487889051,
-0.3141759336,
0.6940834522,
-0.3986761272,
-0.3184485734,
0.8060109615,
1.1974760294,
0.1428559721,
0.0419493504,
0.7191390991,
0.5349579453,
0.04666676,
0.3741438687,
1.586779356,
-0.1891507953,
0.3605406582,
-0.3078257442,
0.1365461946,
-0.2037495673,
-0.6191353202,
-0.9298534393,
-0.5658587813,
-0.2814466953,
-0.152555719,
-0.0022778369,
0.5465657115,
0.2231654078,
-0.7592072487,
-0.4752539694,
-0.0802964643,
0.2348716706,
-0.0429600403,
-0.2106318176,
0.4351176023,
-0.1664157063,
-0.4660176933,
0.6490757465,
0.2968263328,
0.2390368283,
-0.4366460741,
-0.1105554104,
0.0096172038,
0.3553640544,
0.4332805872,
0.0524518378,
-0.965900898,
-0.4163434803,
0.395481199,
-0.2394641638,
0.1206186414,
0.7877776623,
-0.7850658298,
0.1989316493,
0.4526877105,
0.3112448156,
0.4161075056,
-0.2781633139,
0.1886347979,
-0.5719300508,
0.1364826709,
0.2879214287,
0.3311396539,
0.2030953318,
-0.4778833091,
0.3893642128,
0.1239706278,
-0.570713222,
-1.1488106251,
0.3354595006,
-0.7511590719,
-0.561207056,
1.3509399891,
0.3177193105,
-0.4839097857,
0.0051068785,
-0.2942065895,
0.319531858,
-0.0099746687,
1.1285045147,
0.7682372928,
-0.34454301,
-0.1816958636,
-0.6053522825,
0.4452752173,
0.3879431784,
-0.7277745008,
0.330716908,
0.4496408999,
0.2145336717,
0.0452247076,
0.569141686,
0.1122558266,
-0.0130331516,
-0.041686967,
0.1066077799,
0.297595799,
-0.4097765684,
-0.4932485521,
0.0414768234,
0.2337126434,
-0.1520323008
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09727v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09727v2
|
A Human-Inspired Reading Agent with Gist Memory of Very Long Contexts
| 2024-02-15T05:40:21 | 2024-02-23T18:21:28 |
Kuang-Huei Lee, Xinyun Chen, Hiroki Furuta, John Canny, Ian Fischer
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Current Large Language Models (LLMs) are not only limited to some maximum
context length, but also are not able to robustly consume long inputs. To
address these limitations, we propose ReadAgent, an LLM agent system that
increases effective context length up to 20x in our experiments. Inspired by
how humans interactively read long documents, we implement ReadAgent as a
simple prompting system that uses the advanced language capabilities of LLMs to
(1) decide what content to store together in a memory episode, (2) compress
those memory episodes into short episodic memories called gist memories, and
(3) take actions to look up passages in the original text if ReadAgent needs to
remind itself of relevant details to complete a task. We evaluate ReadAgent
against baselines using retrieval methods, using the original long contexts,
and using the gist memories. These evaluations are performed on three
long-document reading comprehension tasks: QuALITY, NarrativeQA, and QMSum.
ReadAgent outperforms the baselines on all three tasks while extending the
effective context window by 3-20x.
|
[
-0.2679361105,
-0.8219100237,
0.8591375351,
-0.142299965,
-0.453140974,
0.2648815513,
-0.464070648,
-0.5459362268,
0.2534944713,
0.4759300947,
-0.503048718,
-0.3106052876,
-0.3407400548,
0.2451020479,
-0.3856312037,
1.0478649139,
-0.1303662211,
-0.4148142636,
-0.0651671737,
-0.0651341751,
-0.4467398226,
-0.2435332984,
-0.6822875142,
-0.5900399089,
0.8558522463,
0.621520102,
0.7405543923,
0.6100551486,
0.1578338444,
0.32627514,
-0.1861591488,
0.2427107841,
-0.5603152514,
0.3845503628,
-0.2994173765,
-0.5582998991,
-0.4667912424,
-0.4107048213,
0.4965420067,
0.2465888858,
-0.0255814381,
-0.1729381382,
0.0813501924,
0.5729694366,
-0.4517657757,
0.1064190641,
-0.1942812949,
-0.0800355226,
0.1403643191,
-0.4040900767,
-0.616738975,
-0.1194298416,
0.500272274,
-0.7167291641,
0.1331797093,
-0.0053306599,
0.7195906043,
0.1406640559,
-0.3955535591,
-0.4861251116,
-0.6248074174,
0.420460701,
-0.2453874648,
0.1833851784,
0.4462458491,
0.2715556324,
-0.0054487116,
-0.6500316858,
-0.6416664124,
-0.4067420363,
-0.0666489601,
0.1096670926,
-0.0758920237,
-0.0837179497,
0.1985609233,
-0.1355733722,
-0.5830186009,
-0.2887340188,
-0.1514931172,
-0.1011743397,
0.1224661022,
0.1103468761,
0.4384794533,
-0.106943503,
-0.681357801,
-0.1580972821,
-0.3221879005,
-0.0222558882,
0.1289987862,
-0.1540438533,
0.1578675061,
0.2759948969,
-0.1952735037,
0.5604820251,
-0.1440607309,
0.0222517066,
0.022264678,
0.0577971935,
0.0157460943,
0.117704764,
0.4234869778,
0.4380394518,
0.5675865412,
-0.3191626966,
-0.4651955068,
-0.1119543612,
0.4425145984,
-0.8141815662,
-0.2021114528,
-0.0210383851,
-0.0679505095,
-0.0208965037,
0.1421902031,
-0.7383955717,
-0.5414808989,
-0.2564023137,
0.5384854674,
-0.8652332425,
0.0603961796,
0.2421268374,
-0.4335660636,
0.3011434376,
0.5581338406,
-0.8955792785,
0.2026297897,
0.4765815139,
1.0495672226,
-0.1411636919,
-0.6022000909,
-0.3999781311,
0.3547922075,
-0.0956047252,
1.0599967241,
-0.4889555275,
-0.2856514454,
-0.1591015011,
0.2224158049,
0.028169075,
-0.1758030653,
0.3548605442,
-0.8840324283,
-0.01953681,
-0.1067259684,
-0.5270103216,
-0.1620094776,
0.5207819343,
-0.666041255,
0.7675526142,
0.3689122498,
-0.4976893961,
0.159592092,
-0.7440197468,
-0.5143355727,
0.2604669929,
0.2091345191,
0.0206978992,
0.0013622801,
0.4436949492,
0.364744544,
-0.0465301387,
0.0539470874,
0.142219767,
-0.5973508358,
0.3260908127,
-0.7663178444,
0.3300687671,
0.0908013508,
-0.2729263306,
0.3088521063,
-0.4776104987,
0.0037553615,
0.2556816041,
-0.5678783655,
-0.5177800059,
-0.0819090456,
-0.1364834458,
-0.222746104,
0.3568044901,
-0.573622942,
0.4342961013,
-0.1879315823,
0.6886116266,
0.7599732876,
0.0579462983,
0.6626281142,
-0.6773661375,
0.7066027522,
-0.2073940635,
-0.2679489255,
-0.7593819499,
0.0710447505,
-0.7899854183,
-0.4257718921,
-0.0683048889,
0.5817500353,
-0.8776339293,
0.4439892173,
-0.5044435263,
-0.3054021597,
-0.0321937911,
0.070219636,
0.2123384327,
0.511603713,
0.207222864,
0.048525814,
0.0836988688,
-0.4778544009,
-0.1669363976,
-0.3170238137,
-0.2686275542,
0.3707262576,
0.5456268191,
-0.4863272905,
1.0778108835,
-0.7297067642,
-0.072323665,
-0.3128368855,
-0.10179995,
0.0899601579,
0.1509012878,
0.2238304168,
-0.4019637108,
-0.4203641117,
0.1040637046,
-0.6812312007,
-0.119290933,
-0.3152072728,
-0.2154606581,
0.0505619124,
0.6982934475,
-0.8571627736,
0.1910051852,
0.161558032,
-0.7076035738,
0.5203243494,
-0.7145704627,
0.0650209561,
-1.0730257034,
-0.0030001476,
-0.3231661022,
-0.6605818272,
-0.4422910213,
0.2874957323,
0.4982815385,
-0.27181229,
-0.416315645,
1.0671885014,
-0.8906668425,
0.0596533455,
-0.4504725337,
0.2640363574,
0.2520752847,
0.4458331764,
-0.0553547181,
1.0279004574,
0.3353512585,
-0.4072264433,
0.434777081,
0.2748705745,
-0.3884460926,
0.5992201567,
-0.4802023172,
0.4341452718,
-0.2610422373,
0.602139473,
-0.9302325249,
-0.3703306913,
0.1765812039,
-0.216150254,
0.3240478337,
0.1971866935,
-0.5462867618,
-0.2723371089,
-0.1625066698,
0.0316684507,
0.4491178095,
-0.8757401109,
0.735809207,
-0.1744993925,
-0.4501362145,
-0.3002900779,
-0.5809730291,
0.4265867174,
-0.2694699764,
-0.8078634739,
0.1211748496,
-0.109048292,
0.0227381214,
-0.0332171507,
0.0337080583,
0.0497117899,
-0.1126678512,
0.0899883285,
0.098670058,
-0.1355842352,
0.5051141381,
0.052184701,
-0.1683705002,
-0.1065143123,
-0.4778158963,
0.6340784431,
-0.5002299547,
0.0854312554,
-0.1853168309,
0.5547437668,
0.6644206047,
-0.1119193956,
0.5366714001,
0.3788939118,
-0.2261640579,
-0.4417785406,
-0.2987422347,
-0.2581672072,
-0.5370159149,
0.4710314572,
-0.6476584077,
-1.0755163431,
0.6390826702,
-0.1627433151,
-0.1902056336,
0.0422992297,
0.4326335192,
-0.1673491746,
0.645234704,
0.2683857977,
-0.2577033043,
0.8557613492,
-0.1991712451,
-0.2740190923,
-0.7577031255,
0.1991738379,
-0.08638376,
-0.4253099561,
0.237697646,
-0.5136633515,
0.17717354,
0.2179044187,
-0.3587622643,
0.2275448442,
-0.5010001659,
1.0196620226,
0.263702333,
0.362274915,
0.2917345762,
-0.0272897705,
-0.3171620369,
0.3891124129,
-0.3969967067,
-0.8512825966,
0.7270529866,
0.4268240929,
1.0317790508,
0.2658520341,
0.5965174437,
0.5968216062,
0.26391083,
-1.0998528004,
0.7922201157,
0.3022285104,
-0.6581022739,
-0.7097840905,
-0.0244365893,
-1.3100432158,
0.2586004734,
0.3825722635,
-0.7726941109,
-0.0092058508,
-0.2626112998,
-0.2760846317,
0.2126306593,
-0.6683545113,
0.5407088399,
-0.2501523793,
-0.2379672527,
-0.1986370385,
-0.7537921667,
-0.1241922453,
-0.038099017,
-0.2395771444,
0.1073743924,
-0.5815874338,
0.3768396676,
-0.5326470137,
0.8202498555,
0.050455723,
-0.1404032111,
0.5945588946,
0.2777528465,
0.8708145618,
0.1191480234,
-0.1610816717,
-0.2925159335,
0.0194241032,
-0.5642758012,
-0.8830702901,
0.5451669097,
-0.890427053,
-0.6441624165,
-0.4869031608,
-0.6078061461,
-0.1046789661,
0.4864267111,
0.1369351447,
0.3682773709,
-0.3860295415,
0.1771049649,
0.6049229503,
0.1111786738,
0.6374389529,
0.7059165239,
0.062867403,
-0.4414049089,
0.7520068884,
-0.1085395515,
0.3708643913,
0.4246205688,
0.3269333243,
-0.2868118584,
-0.1974747628,
-0.7302101851,
0.1597090065,
-0.8596459031,
0.0486608222,
-0.679473877,
-0.144019112,
0.1029200703,
-0.6594170332,
0.1989798844,
0.0943493918,
-0.6313759685,
-0.1126851067,
0.5818513036,
0.6690169573,
0.2573265135,
0.7246729732,
-0.912897408,
0.2522140443,
0.3314212859,
0.3618087173,
0.186837092,
-0.5636200309,
-0.3462190926,
-0.2718608975,
-0.2335927784,
-1.0413973331,
0.6202402711,
0.06310568,
0.3058716655,
0.6198073626,
0.1081565917,
0.4770009816,
-0.675183773,
0.511862278,
-0.1245669648,
-0.7034087181,
0.2456687838,
-0.7955430746,
0.8167583346,
0.6565885544,
0.1265993267,
-0.7000595331,
-0.279094547,
-0.2793364227,
-0.6956565976,
0.4624268413,
-0.0655522496,
0.3883572221,
-0.2714219093,
0.5968717337,
0.1015510857,
-0.238886416,
-0.3051821887,
0.4806339741,
-0.0006370535,
-0.091518417,
-0.318145901,
-0.3158825636,
0.0828716457,
-0.04074632,
0.2786852717,
-0.5290557742,
0.4209060967,
0.5735716224,
-0.5697711706,
-0.0813835114,
0.7313822508,
0.7697111964,
0.8689796329,
-0.2746450901,
0.2289883941,
0.3305494189,
-0.8671338558,
0.6427890658,
-0.0240094345,
-0.1044002101,
-0.219926849,
0.3477147222,
0.6191818714,
0.0943639651,
-0.8696841598,
0.3062160015,
-0.2834375203,
-0.0449292772,
-0.5338892341,
0.2168881893,
0.459082514,
0.6996903419,
0.5090289116,
-0.2175534219,
-0.1597689539,
-0.4271547794,
0.4155926704,
-0.0374345966,
-0.7554261088,
-0.1823866218,
0.3664070964,
0.3871769607,
-0.6215985417,
0.6219568253,
-0.2984622717,
-0.5206620693,
0.5692399144,
0.7413104177,
0.8002173305,
0.1121339649,
0.1393050849,
-0.0464424789,
0.1888708174,
-0.370274812,
0.3015985191,
-0.1263369024,
-0.73509413,
-0.245610103,
-0.4940652847,
-0.3645854592,
-0.0486573502,
-0.4969108999,
0.0430962965,
-0.3657801747,
-0.1686034054,
-0.243099004,
0.2886315882,
-0.413871944,
0.0964973047,
-0.1177255809,
0.9739989042,
-0.3319648206,
0.9873406887,
0.6748102903,
-0.226473555,
-0.5175083876,
0.2510125041,
0.0453042388,
-0.5900849104,
0.421384573,
0.3975787461,
-0.2444351166,
0.3349089324,
-0.3982493281,
-0.6377097368,
1.4172843695,
0.2898601592,
-0.872522831,
-0.2551423609,
-0.379489243,
0.6959987283,
-0.5036714077,
0.2571573853,
0.5824428201,
0.3505245149,
0.0863911062,
-0.4260032177,
0.2437580228,
-0.2197408229,
-0.3050107062,
0.3241601884,
-0.8658604622,
0.6814991236,
-0.5272951722,
-0.2753504813,
0.4045638442,
0.7315752506,
0.2465322614,
0.2947409749,
0.6123995781,
0.4005120099,
0.8745362759,
0.4256801605,
1.3580930233,
-0.1722994149,
0.0903398395,
1.1682468653,
-0.3587889075,
0.7514939904,
0.1941218227,
0.1174323484,
0.6559423208,
0.5452592373,
0.1605654955,
0.3012422621,
0.1915183663,
-0.6381451488,
-0.2671056688,
-0.0245556105,
-0.0069587585,
0.1686676145,
0.285807997,
-0.4521490633,
-0.2287913859,
0.2472037822,
0.1857042313,
-0.0110608665,
-0.1954428405,
0.6957221627,
0.1188995615,
-0.7148245573,
0.3450046778,
-0.1309056729,
0.517034173,
-0.6004514098,
0.0872826576,
-0.1150170267,
0.4212603867,
0.3682898283,
-1.1047456264,
-0.1670434028,
0.0292953216,
-0.3711879253,
-0.3075294793,
1.0941511393,
-0.2562655509,
-0.1727814525,
0.4767525792,
0.554217577,
0.3300922811,
-0.2171017826,
-0.3652427197,
-0.2448445708,
-0.191285193,
-0.6703161597,
0.2536374331,
0.7217617631,
-0.3286875784,
0.8276749253,
0.6579168439,
0.0604711995,
-0.2487870604,
0.0693355948,
0.8550511599,
-1.1181060076,
-0.7840643525,
-0.8389160633,
0.2583337724,
0.108906433,
-0.3821238577,
0.500844419,
0.3867223859,
0.3483524024,
-0.0162052084,
0.7781684995,
0.2957553566,
0.4227962792,
-0.2578126788,
1.0576356649,
-0.3555652201,
0.0867256969,
-0.0022897813,
-0.8863142729,
0.0632702559,
0.5054417849,
-0.3370129764,
-0.0056283223,
0.7682311535,
0.5608494878,
0.0016462754,
-0.008086076,
0.6056758761,
0.0672974288,
0.4114431739,
0.7092710733,
1.0917646885,
-0.0073515135,
0.6936537623,
0.5179268718,
-0.2133728117,
-0.3255680203,
-0.7084880471,
-1.1952625513,
-0.289621681,
0.2312926352,
-0.3507304192,
0.3206922114,
0.7099305391,
0.4606918097,
-0.2102259547,
-0.0728748664,
0.0146243814,
0.0251716562,
0.0510912575,
-0.2378585786,
0.2793387473,
-0.1796497256,
-0.6031190157,
0.3973009884,
0.5080649257,
0.1579183638,
-0.3798745275,
-0.3274948001,
-0.2360228747,
0.4066618383,
0.7087702751,
0.3514455855,
-0.6003155708,
-0.5565861464,
0.1966706365,
-0.5237019062,
0.1854444891,
0.6429380774,
-0.9602452517,
0.6838122606,
0.8016193509,
0.7544899583,
0.6847921014,
0.2668812573,
0.4405967593,
-0.3582858145,
0.0520833656,
0.4327223599,
0.1684301198,
0.0385002233,
-0.598564744,
0.5160948038,
-0.1855734885,
-0.819301784,
-0.259727031,
0.0232442226,
-0.9839507937,
-0.5525768995,
1.2983500957,
-0.260560751,
-0.6995481253,
-0.1952366382,
-0.6242479682,
0.0579252094,
-0.8098275661,
0.4367598593,
0.9122762084,
-0.1221869662,
-0.4082458317,
-0.4415756166,
0.1270451695,
0.2100347877,
-0.8480702639,
0.1124012619,
0.6083237529,
0.4720519185,
0.0309034623,
0.6930639744,
0.2875267565,
0.3630420566,
0.1761200875,
0.0895029381,
-0.2279075831,
-0.5867590308,
-0.3987753689,
0.1077921391,
-0.2023860961,
0.2241628021
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09725v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09725v1
|
Improving Non-autoregressive Machine Translation with Error Exposure and Consistency Regularization
| 2024-02-15T05:35:04 | 2024-02-15T05:35:04 |
Xinran Chen, Sufeng Duan, Gongshen Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Being one of the IR-NAT (Iterative-refinemennt-based NAT) frameworks, the
Conditional Masked Language Model (CMLM) adopts the mask-predict paradigm to
re-predict the masked low-confidence tokens. However, CMLM suffers from the
data distribution discrepancy between training and inference, where the
observed tokens are generated differently in the two cases. In this paper, we
address this problem with the training approaches of error exposure and
consistency regularization (EECR). We construct the mixed sequences based on
model prediction during training, and propose to optimize over the masked
tokens under imperfect observation conditions. We also design a consistency
learning method to constrain the data distribution for the masked tokens under
different observing situations to narrow down the gap between training and
inference. The experiments on five translation benchmarks obtains an average
improvement of 0.68 and 0.40 BLEU scores compared to the base models,
respectively, and our CMLMC-EECR achieves the best performance with a
comparable translation quality with the Transformer. The experiments results
demonstrate the effectiveness of our method.
|
[
-0.1259135902,
-0.4733442664,
0.1469763219,
0.2059807032,
-0.3633218408,
0.2531380355,
-0.3961610794,
-0.2740257978,
-0.0193174332,
0.4096601307,
-0.3265680671,
-0.5469531417,
-1.0245634317,
0.3511944115,
-0.3085702062,
0.8257340193,
-0.3895547986,
0.0529314019,
0.2594565749,
-0.2040263265,
-0.7668994069,
-0.3526099622,
-0.2225304246,
-0.0741368383,
0.1027473956,
0.3891556859,
0.6915155649,
0.9673869014,
0.3853212893,
0.2531998456,
0.2860926092,
0.7182331085,
-0.2698550224,
0.118881546,
-0.0054556788,
-0.3923493624,
-0.1764141619,
-0.1965597868,
0.8331138492,
0.6542553902,
-0.1791862398,
-0.1287462711,
0.1956614405,
0.5903439522,
-0.6358914971,
0.1184644029,
-0.8472593427,
0.2583012283,
0.1807771325,
-0.0591193587,
-0.7163094878,
-0.1559184939,
-0.3283559084,
-0.5931873918,
0.3959477544,
0.4195451438,
0.8335391879,
0.5505231023,
-0.3586341441,
0.1442013979,
-0.7160668969,
1.088557601,
-0.7249634266,
0.7211506963,
0.5385952592,
0.4156009257,
-0.1945036948,
-0.487934798,
-0.4705663323,
0.060913343,
-0.2771795392,
0.1896569729,
-0.0648853257,
0.0160957631,
-0.0544061065,
0.285256058,
-0.6049987674,
0.0492578894,
-0.0875802189,
-0.4805592,
0.6246697903,
0.1433190256,
-0.0489256717,
0.091552943,
-0.3578907549,
-0.1208083704,
-0.2106820792,
-0.292203933,
0.1665585041,
0.3082560301,
-0.3024890721,
0.6407173872,
-0.2083104849,
0.7645133734,
0.3603378236,
-0.054457996,
0.5810328126,
-0.296677053,
-0.5369481444,
-0.0768071488,
0.5874279737,
0.2753937244,
-0.08595296,
-0.2673186958,
-0.542543292,
0.0087178908,
0.1397768557,
-0.4798250198,
-0.1434992403,
0.1394934803,
-0.5521807671,
-0.0402818061,
0.2505217493,
-0.6802650094,
0.1000174433,
-0.5465278625,
0.6544034481,
-0.3097765148,
-0.0692529827,
0.233138606,
0.2360610515,
0.146691069,
0.4253922701,
-0.6642675996,
0.3688128591,
0.304338485,
0.7940165401,
-0.4051039219,
-0.0702208281,
-0.6702548862,
0.041711662,
-0.5390852094,
0.4472186267,
-0.0165916495,
-0.1233168989,
-0.0664287731,
0.1186441928,
-0.6725421548,
-0.4752464592,
0.4838501513,
-0.4127432406,
0.2107184529,
0.3111116886,
-0.5729981065,
-0.132296443,
0.2521384656,
-0.1765939295,
0.9406558275,
0.1142246276,
-0.7111783624,
0.1530934125,
-0.504761219,
-0.3966625035,
-0.2860364318,
0.0768333152,
-0.7466105819,
0.207929939,
0.2722036541,
0.1296354532,
0.077808775,
0.6278957725,
0.1988319308,
-0.2812580466,
0.2522872388,
-0.57987082,
0.4720266759,
0.5308992267,
-0.7691645622,
0.0283080842,
-0.8440707326,
0.280790925,
-0.0797687247,
-0.1334670931,
-0.0123078432,
-0.1677700281,
0.0646250919,
0.3398216963,
-0.0267083719,
-0.4626004398,
-0.0650278404,
-0.2131359279,
0.1856112331,
0.7587817907,
0.138554886,
0.4200695455,
-0.2373909503,
0.3443233371,
0.3443532288,
0.3176197112,
-0.2813406587,
-0.3777740598,
-1.0840803385,
-0.4409172535,
0.5116074085,
0.6898952723,
-0.9521293044,
0.6979068518,
-0.1164190769,
-0.1572122574,
-0.8297951818,
0.0736333579,
0.6922222972,
0.7423514128,
0.6824342012,
-0.3884946406,
-0.7958971262,
-0.9009286165,
-0.1564248651,
0.0752909034,
-0.0649253801,
0.1252802312,
0.3588569164,
-0.5622138977,
0.598734796,
-0.2183197141,
-0.2232556343,
0.0627885759,
0.2738895416,
0.1761728525,
0.854660809,
-0.016280558,
-0.7406554818,
-0.8036776185,
0.1246601716,
-0.5854811072,
-0.1896661073,
-0.1400164217,
-0.4158438146,
0.5260491371,
0.3578730822,
-0.0000987067,
0.6709052324,
0.8306881785,
-0.1124104857,
0.1957643926,
-0.2287145406,
0.2355198711,
-0.9527028799,
0.1021839082,
-0.2001197785,
-0.6757508516,
-0.7134934664,
-0.2496521324,
0.3069896102,
0.0791588128,
-0.4803529084,
0.3402599096,
-0.5627627373,
-0.0100863194,
-0.3065399826,
-0.094931215,
0.3110461533,
0.4407967329,
0.1184320226,
0.7341887355,
0.4347043633,
-0.5273324251,
-0.3058029711,
0.384514451,
-0.1175126508,
0.424844116,
-0.365594238,
0.4146585166,
-0.1621184647,
0.1781433225,
-0.811950326,
-0.1667728573,
0.4577626884,
-0.479881078,
0.7867131233,
-0.0074703237,
-0.4486688972,
-0.064904578,
-0.015404555,
0.224364385,
0.715507865,
-0.4171328545,
0.5373875499,
0.093287617,
0.3764739633,
-0.7654608488,
-0.8955471516,
0.1649628878,
0.0801308006,
-0.3818441927,
0.3863684535,
-0.2221313864,
-0.1671968997,
-0.0902109742,
-0.2056773752,
-0.0475289635,
0.0743718371,
-0.0271845907,
0.2107935399,
-0.2548818588,
-0.1570096165,
0.0003648517,
-0.2116333544,
-0.4855621457,
-0.6168757677,
0.3136286438,
-0.1014893055,
-0.4296532273,
-0.5593842864,
0.3868484199,
0.1558161676,
-0.0878838003,
0.9909309149,
0.3853628933,
-0.3968121707,
-0.0879968405,
-0.6778849959,
-0.0289707799,
-0.3883164823,
0.0305235405,
-0.3436069191,
-0.5090845227,
0.4827597737,
0.3844804168,
0.082233876,
0.4922997952,
0.4242306948,
-0.068938382,
1.0188953876,
0.8285646439,
-0.0019181278,
0.2635838985,
-0.0683483109,
0.1318554133,
-0.8855867982,
-0.2039174139,
-0.3310865462,
-0.1738526523,
-0.5088986754,
-0.6432817578,
0.245946601,
0.1251196712,
-0.1591187119,
0.5156159997,
-0.4082554579,
0.1367485076,
0.4107265472,
0.1941700429,
0.3796390891,
0.1161312833,
-0.3400268257,
-0.0865531862,
-0.7889294624,
-0.3158403337,
0.9440985322,
0.4006212652,
0.5698848963,
-0.0550490543,
0.7432061434,
0.3307696581,
0.443544656,
-0.3494170606,
0.030961981,
0.0480882488,
-0.4387869239,
-0.0633113682,
-0.5317372084,
-0.6449323893,
0.3559975922,
-0.0553808771,
-0.3419958949,
0.5559290648,
0.3876831532,
0.2751454413,
0.2478593439,
-0.6890577078,
0.7012970448,
-0.2436017692,
-0.3071137965,
0.2532647848,
-1.2190923691,
0.2408045083,
-0.3618054688,
0.4134292305,
0.098783426,
-0.0611413904,
0.200694412,
-0.4294561148,
0.7938885093,
-0.1835311055,
0.2151441723,
0.3055867851,
0.0342622623,
0.7563264966,
-0.2618841529,
-0.1847892404,
0.445558995,
-0.5151553154,
-0.5703780055,
-0.3911088109,
0.0459322333,
-0.7825263739,
-0.3565431237,
-0.298882544,
-0.6518130302,
-0.2226857692,
0.2227405012,
0.5364878178,
0.0426412486,
0.0639079437,
0.0412935391,
0.8815531135,
-0.1390102208,
0.3635907471,
0.6546404958,
0.031531889,
-0.8368137479,
0.7064537406,
-0.0236926209,
0.7323519588,
0.5372279286,
0.093554236,
-0.1965044439,
-0.8707629442,
-0.7071207762,
0.0732340589,
-0.7460755706,
-0.5302800536,
-0.9758226275,
-0.359280467,
-0.5091725588,
-0.1274746507,
-0.4594005644,
-0.3749465048,
-0.1252301335,
-0.0243853107,
0.1553190053,
0.1979032755,
-0.2285199016,
0.3284865022,
-0.6817675829,
0.1537853479,
-0.2465598434,
0.244095847,
-0.3231545985,
-1.0882610083,
-0.5475590229,
0.086585179,
-0.1500035077,
-0.5535941124,
0.6255574226,
0.417289108,
0.6126337051,
0.1235080138,
0.1318580806,
0.793178618,
-0.7015919685,
0.3983835876,
0.1707310975,
-1.0141257048,
0.3652952313,
-0.2378819436,
0.2073011845,
0.7303261161,
-0.0415805802,
-0.6345925927,
-0.6843672395,
-0.699929595,
-0.7253468037,
0.445548892,
0.6900610328,
-0.0595166497,
-0.2164966762,
0.1407879293,
0.280320406,
0.5148009658,
-0.715510726,
-0.5772979856,
-0.5943589807,
-0.5005132556,
-0.3157661855,
-0.0058272895,
0.1495613903,
-0.0680981502,
0.9704347849,
-0.2447787672,
0.4163326025,
0.5018661022,
-0.4505113065,
-0.5014615655,
0.0326163918,
0.8267300725,
0.499553442,
-0.2068815082,
0.250505507,
0.1176716387,
-0.506099999,
0.3009340763,
0.0343906209,
-0.3447521031,
0.4539993107,
0.2373811901,
0.7632198334,
-0.0246878006,
-0.4301400483,
0.5043302774,
0.1168444827,
-0.1846735626,
-0.2048059404,
-0.2287534475,
-0.3515384197,
-0.0586106107,
0.4083625972,
0.4247179925,
0.009226528,
-0.1399095356,
0.5124251246,
0.2282828838,
-0.3723905087,
-0.1728060842,
0.8303757906,
-0.1329889745,
-0.2130316496,
0.5480599403,
-0.2121742219,
-0.616235137,
0.5845859647,
0.7239916325,
0.9961753488,
-0.5687903762,
0.026862707,
0.393314302,
0.5508583188,
-0.2621695697,
0.0438300259,
0.1359109432,
-0.6209814548,
-0.5276350975,
-0.4654087424,
-0.3418849707,
-0.2729716897,
-0.6128559709,
0.4496582747,
-0.205993697,
0.2702096701,
-0.4603169262,
-0.2662351429,
-0.7726515532,
0.3394733965,
-0.1029413566,
0.7010683417,
-1.0821944475,
0.9897469282,
0.2485636771,
-0.2618161738,
-0.831564784,
0.0145832589,
-0.1707090437,
-0.900770843,
0.5433645248,
0.1432908028,
0.1207181215,
0.1218611002,
-0.2624063194,
-0.9792163372,
0.9127651453,
0.1613286734,
-0.8210535049,
0.4023462534,
0.140038833,
0.4080991745,
-0.5763851404,
-0.0814249441,
0.2593607306,
0.5512154102,
0.0064722816,
-1.0421184301,
-0.15570499,
-0.0894777402,
0.0360490903,
0.3489014506,
-0.4797326922,
0.5927323699,
0.0352423005,
-0.2368618846,
0.0421661735,
0.5821966529,
-0.0090609323,
0.5027723312,
0.4288685918,
0.3607912958,
0.6029761434,
0.1555958539,
0.8747766614,
-0.1088471264,
0.4335526526,
1.2439601421,
-0.2681282461,
0.6637582779,
0.5703997016,
0.0359091535,
0.2643240392,
0.6845680475,
-0.170810461,
0.8783345222,
0.0898633823,
-0.2432984561,
0.0435146205,
-0.0337038487,
-0.1970595121,
0.0837937146,
0.1342785358,
-0.7596500516,
-0.0755590945,
0.27374053,
-0.0694833398,
0.2836673856,
-0.2068701535,
0.7243734002,
0.1737008095,
-0.6553196311,
0.9039760828,
0.3068956733,
0.5608276129,
-0.208413437,
-0.0725497082,
-0.488799572,
0.1529105455,
-0.2202792764,
-0.1093917042,
0.5550881028,
-0.0241036229,
-0.2862006128,
-0.3087921441,
0.6438637376,
-0.4829563498,
-0.6148020029,
-0.0031463569,
0.4826216996,
0.3124258816,
0.2499207854,
-0.7011432648,
0.0940933377,
0.1568572819,
0.0449994877,
0.2659099996,
0.4259009957,
-0.2107527405,
0.3683121502,
0.5064937472,
-0.1884670556,
0.463226825,
-0.2279076427,
0.6022822857,
-0.3876824677,
-0.23213467,
-0.8124921918,
0.7213882804,
0.0804017112,
0.0739240423,
0.7891123295,
0.728108108,
0.721429348,
-0.1259485483,
0.6116204262,
0.0316775925,
0.4974579215,
-0.6521847248,
0.3614412248,
-0.1307987869,
0.2560109496,
-0.0569368564,
-1.0249848366,
-0.6553646922,
0.6128178835,
0.0398051664,
-0.0631621853,
0.8775202036,
0.754298985,
-0.2099264115,
-0.4366557896,
0.6076219082,
0.0839639306,
0.0984600559,
0.4309720397,
0.4566544592,
-0.9671814442,
0.3543490171,
-0.3139496446,
-0.1335145533,
-0.3082453609,
-1.1037143469,
-0.6551573277,
-0.2921258807,
-0.6601979733,
-0.5292915702,
0.2877220809,
1.0030170679,
0.6925426722,
-0.9849447608,
0.0610323399,
-0.3644265831,
0.1221912131,
-0.4093456864,
-0.1853490621,
0.3793826699,
-0.5079842806,
-0.7369645238,
0.400049448,
0.1169248819,
0.3744292855,
0.0066838833,
-0.1562183201,
-0.1368292719,
0.1273719668,
0.242936343,
0.2206634283,
-0.6988324523,
-0.5184562802,
0.1905887276,
-0.193721056,
0.5138858557,
0.5281627178,
-0.5075635314,
0.6447023153,
0.0835634992,
0.8189745545,
0.5080891848,
0.0246344637,
0.6716910601,
-1.0213912725,
0.238700375,
0.2389255315,
0.3264555335,
0.6160449982,
-0.522755146,
0.6050880551,
0.1829054058,
-0.5626410246,
-0.8671045899,
0.1442146748,
-0.6141522527,
-0.0212983638,
1.0549888611,
-0.3679684103,
-0.2858684361,
-0.3933208287,
0.0884981006,
0.4400023222,
-0.1368213296,
0.7630267739,
0.4445388615,
-0.0202976186,
-0.2242947072,
-0.8093065023,
0.1687009186,
0.54855299,
-0.5578271747,
-0.1120201275,
0.3607462049,
0.3824271262,
0.0064350069,
0.4368618727,
-0.2607644796,
0.028073296,
-0.1740126908,
0.2457541376,
-0.0684092417,
-0.2593097985,
-0.5273909569,
-0.3843978345,
0.1050040126,
-0.6468077898
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09723v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09723v3
|
Efficient Prompt Optimization Through the Lens of Best Arm Identification
| 2024-02-15T05:31:13 | 2024-05-30T19:40:21 |
Chengshuai Shi, Kun Yang, Zihan Chen, Jundong Li, Jing Yang, Cong Shen
|
stat.ML
|
stat.ML, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The remarkable instruction-following capability of large language models
(LLMs) has sparked a growing interest in automatically finding good prompts,
i.e., prompt optimization. Most existing works follow the scheme of selecting
from a pre-generated pool of candidate prompts. However, these designs mainly
focus on the generation strategy, while limited attention has been paid to the
selection method. Especially, the cost incurred during the selection (e.g.,
accessing LLM and evaluating the responses) is rarely explicitly considered. To
overcome this limitation, this work provides a principled framework, TRIPLE, to
efficiently perform prompt selection under an explicit budget constraint.
TRIPLE is built on a novel connection established between prompt optimization
and fixed-budget best arm identification (BAI-FB) in multi-armed bandits (MAB);
thus, it is capable of leveraging the rich toolbox from BAI-FB systematically
and also incorporating unique characteristics of prompt optimization. Extensive
experiments on multiple well-adopted tasks using various LLMs demonstrate the
remarkable performance improvement of TRIPLE over baselines while satisfying
the limited budget constraints. As an extension, variants of TRIPLE are
proposed to efficiently select examples for few-shot prompts, also achieving
superior empirical performance.
|
[
-0.4699381292,
-0.8214122057,
0.7861589193,
0.2976222336,
-0.162505582,
0.20219405,
-0.1351307333,
-0.1483986676,
-0.1980001777,
0.4008994997,
-0.8300334811,
-0.354536891,
-0.3192116618,
0.3625673056,
0.0861990154,
0.8421453834,
-0.1792706102,
-0.1696160138,
0.2462650687,
-0.118564263,
-0.6965191364,
-0.2306511253,
-0.9768821001,
-0.0011934093,
0.7412186861,
0.562042594,
0.3296555281,
0.850366354,
0.3346778452,
0.2007168233,
-0.0070884135,
0.5474073291,
-0.2263126373,
0.0426035821,
0.1661604941,
-0.3827105463,
0.0585951358,
-0.0214631632,
0.7361228466,
0.4541386664,
0.042778939,
0.1310006529,
0.1991320401,
0.771612525,
-0.8334618807,
0.3413905501,
-0.4448987246,
-0.1818953007,
-0.3476849794,
-0.15259552,
-0.3611374795,
-0.6689895988,
0.2179967016,
-0.7296476364,
0.1512431949,
0.3568466604,
0.9134153128,
0.255233258,
-0.1338659376,
-0.4404292405,
-0.4492907524,
0.9374919534,
-0.250680238,
-0.0355486833,
0.2957252562,
0.339202106,
-0.2091140449,
-0.0847411528,
-0.3623894155,
-0.3202118576,
0.0837917775,
-0.1112913489,
-0.3223414123,
0.2522855997,
0.3223108947,
0.1502929628,
-0.3782885373,
0.2692232132,
-0.1912549436,
-0.4030922949,
0.371740371,
0.1310939044,
0.2391031981,
-0.1690790653,
-0.4893214107,
-0.0135196326,
-0.7989811897,
0.137708813,
0.5171589851,
0.5306626558,
-0.0496053323,
0.4431961775,
-0.0920670331,
0.9314745069,
0.4163784385,
-0.3439339995,
0.2068625093,
-0.4365322888,
0.2259793729,
-0.2094898224,
0.6420506835,
0.3528956771,
0.1357109696,
0.1759933233,
-0.520539701,
-0.296271652,
-0.1442014575,
-0.6506207585,
0.2021419555,
0.2166472524,
-0.3798414171,
-0.1926260293,
-0.2461262792,
-0.7855942249,
-0.3435479999,
-0.1842576116,
0.5772277713,
-0.3902805746,
0.0472427383,
-0.2728945613,
-0.1218434498,
0.3916567266,
0.0525462218,
-0.9747879505,
0.0058427867,
0.6576880813,
1.0794370174,
-0.2115290165,
-0.209154889,
-1.1252422333,
0.2521772385,
-0.6899798512,
0.8354930878,
-0.5417299271,
-0.3607276976,
0.0251302253,
-0.5054875612,
0.0451984927,
-0.3821342885,
0.5984031558,
-0.7063389421,
0.085522525,
-0.2435698211,
-0.2518786192,
-0.091660291,
0.1201544032,
-0.9146683216,
0.8655354977,
0.1713540852,
-0.6009415984,
0.5022824407,
-0.7881392837,
-0.3526524007,
0.1738220751,
-0.0538294688,
-0.3637722731,
0.0330964848,
0.5984725356,
0.4676155746,
-0.6778914332,
0.3569096327,
-0.3580908775,
-0.3323220313,
-0.1642043591,
-0.3365964592,
0.8060827851,
0.3434241712,
-0.2431359142,
0.2631963491,
-0.5952575803,
-0.2967250943,
0.1154920384,
-0.1568545699,
-0.1884331852,
-0.078196995,
-0.4826484621,
-0.3848764598,
0.2277589887,
-0.373678267,
0.2917199731,
-0.640188992,
0.145849064,
0.9323593974,
0.1957426816,
0.4369302094,
-0.33741346,
0.5645009279,
-0.3501548767,
0.213829428,
-0.4183534086,
-0.2763478458,
-0.3701882362,
-0.7901778221,
0.1634691358,
0.7243263721,
-0.9512668252,
0.2284172773,
0.3122708499,
-0.145416528,
-0.3944394588,
0.1766444445,
0.455309391,
0.6143571734,
0.2479407638,
0.3258424699,
-0.3386995792,
-1.0091516972,
-0.229610756,
-0.3436831832,
-0.0136871189,
0.508434236,
0.0042998316,
-0.0155189615,
0.8321332932,
-0.7504617572,
-0.1793047488,
-0.5872624516,
0.1413750798,
0.6787183285,
0.1924777478,
0.7452126741,
-0.5123274922,
-0.5497121215,
-0.3737469018,
-0.2992264926,
-0.702740252,
-0.4653812945,
-0.2915256321,
0.2627307773,
0.2229663879,
-0.5839965343,
0.3238638937,
0.2102718502,
0.114835903,
0.5786544085,
-0.1181545034,
-0.0537154563,
-0.9118404388,
0.0374745466,
0.1558209658,
0.2284269631,
-0.3961776495,
0.2518401444,
0.2239905,
-0.0736489072,
-0.0610909089,
0.9461140037,
-0.7752668858,
0.1434247047,
-0.3419765234,
0.2101698965,
-0.0438232161,
0.6762111187,
-0.0585932024,
0.9838539958,
0.9693361521,
-0.7214539051,
0.4309748709,
0.1516715288,
-0.080449678,
0.611100018,
-0.6833043694,
-0.0104299998,
-0.2668559551,
0.1957892925,
-0.9243158102,
-0.3109078109,
0.5202184319,
-0.2036428601,
0.5048295259,
-0.2047837079,
-0.3661316037,
-0.5765464902,
-0.635492444,
0.2714142799,
0.3140586019,
-0.8828142881,
0.6329439878,
0.2232272029,
-0.3147571683,
-0.9195760489,
-0.1412450075,
-0.1591528803,
-0.3967767358,
-0.2729996145,
0.1869959533,
-0.2432349473,
-0.1611552238,
-0.5051806569,
-0.2995612621,
0.0974854156,
0.2219115943,
-0.0557334609,
0.7687950134,
-0.1635337621,
0.1073540077,
0.2083155811,
-0.4407004416,
-0.0770813227,
-0.168981865,
0.3768334985,
-0.0853029564,
-0.2283674181,
-0.5381878018,
0.6490398049,
0.0784178078,
-0.2237270027,
0.468305707,
0.6193670034,
-0.1388510615,
-0.2929029763,
-0.8041226268,
-0.1701697856,
-0.5254324079,
0.1136598885,
-0.6083559394,
-0.7390772104,
0.232247442,
0.0674635172,
0.4293871224,
0.3380100131,
0.3954168558,
0.1375492215,
1.0089857578,
0.4572966099,
-0.286131084,
0.5572063327,
0.0349727795,
0.0515685081,
-0.8518831134,
-0.0260946043,
-0.7857248187,
-0.0336431041,
-0.317147404,
-0.2598043978,
0.7300912142,
0.2491400391,
-0.2775108814,
0.2931682765,
-0.3358849585,
0.6827402115,
0.9298892021,
0.0597426668,
-0.2132315785,
-0.1649047136,
-0.353831619,
0.4876930416,
-0.5569183826,
-0.563302815,
1.1787011623,
0.0850343034,
0.5854958892,
0.0636381581,
0.9930208325,
0.1110708192,
0.1174025685,
-0.6718167067,
0.6465449333,
0.2692259848,
-0.592243731,
-0.1984215528,
-0.6483607888,
-1.1269878149,
0.0214754753,
-0.0961184129,
-0.8494483829,
-0.0254773572,
0.372032702,
-1.1180251837,
0.1088520512,
-0.7598196864,
0.5553156734,
-0.2915834486,
-0.4334377646,
-0.2287794054,
-0.8391245604,
0.1559550315,
-0.3236840367,
0.1720391363,
-0.3889873326,
-0.4681361616,
0.4942344427,
-0.1410985738,
0.4637305737,
-0.4425531328,
0.159668982,
0.4584609866,
-0.0176311675,
0.6113142371,
0.1614226848,
-0.1739887148,
-0.0682212487,
-0.2057628483,
-0.3824187517,
-0.3818148971,
0.6080650091,
-0.7900252342,
-0.8908362389,
-0.2374892086,
-0.4730719924,
-0.5214443803,
0.4655546248,
0.0525480695,
0.869825542,
-0.0678551942,
-0.0649536699,
0.5531503558,
-0.3871112168,
0.9959482551,
0.3559091687,
-0.0218279716,
-0.5188658237,
0.8298668861,
-0.2787659764,
0.2473903,
0.6360551715,
0.6285850406,
-0.32741943,
-0.7250768542,
-0.767745018,
0.3005963266,
-0.5233142376,
-0.5203016996,
-0.5582661629,
0.13092044,
-0.231990993,
-0.3349451423,
0.1173325032,
-0.1638248265,
-0.6680845022,
-0.0845399871,
0.2538716197,
0.3699838221,
-0.5569673181,
0.4829837084,
-0.8061717749,
0.710789144,
0.3837117255,
0.1836338788,
-0.1369401664,
-0.181834504,
0.0050749169,
-0.2038176656,
-0.3550072312,
-0.9784625769,
0.2154001892,
0.1859030277,
0.979010582,
0.611299932,
0.208548069,
0.4348015487,
-0.4475593865,
0.6230273843,
0.1419983506,
-0.8337486386,
0.4441822171,
-0.3326188624,
0.3775403202,
0.5012668371,
0.4345809519,
0.0893102139,
-0.1877104491,
-0.2609225214,
-0.8640807271,
1.0379661322,
0.0092746792,
-0.0054178671,
-0.1590177864,
0.2889226675,
0.2772212625,
0.2195449322,
-0.3898359835,
-0.1954456717,
0.2866428792,
-0.2971864045,
0.1980814636,
-0.3749728203,
-0.2834109366,
0.2407750487,
0.6917887926,
-0.3897781372,
0.2947336733,
-0.1000585556,
0.0188506972,
-0.0081985863,
0.0590472966,
0.5281466842,
0.4123161137,
-0.0978761539,
-0.2606611252,
0.1238987595,
-0.2057522833,
0.0497894213,
0.2335826904,
-0.224734351,
-0.0876619518,
0.2818415463,
0.9348881841,
0.011467834,
-0.5881894231,
0.6034898162,
0.2143000513,
0.0938686207,
-0.0545346662,
0.1765727997,
-0.3995980024,
0.5820531249,
0.7577309012,
0.202844739,
0.3119547665,
-0.2622724771,
0.1237103045,
0.7303939462,
0.1148378327,
0.0623024292,
0.453235209,
0.4615287781,
-0.4738722146,
0.4539618492,
-0.1912333667,
-0.4593973458,
0.5383712649,
0.4222470522,
1.2495105267,
-0.0942645445,
0.2387195975,
0.6497105956,
0.2788693905,
-0.0913344026,
0.3596476614,
-0.2950418591,
-0.6315267086,
-0.3616157472,
-0.4230760038,
-0.3872098327,
-0.3268535733,
-0.7073048353,
0.5731158853,
-0.5694024563,
-0.2099182755,
-0.1379725337,
0.1481044441,
-0.6520664692,
-0.2302250564,
0.4400580227,
0.6741958857,
-0.3914985657,
0.442217052,
0.1410215199,
-0.2640502155,
-0.9804038405,
0.0346917622,
0.3786813319,
-1.3342154026,
0.4242012203,
0.4627951086,
-0.3925461471,
0.0389533117,
-0.5467746854,
-0.9951424003,
0.7504624128,
0.271099329,
-0.5360818505,
-0.3174558878,
-0.4986955822,
-0.0217889324,
-0.4288053513,
0.545383513,
0.653101027,
0.5725260973,
0.4561807513,
-0.7952159643,
-0.1088804677,
0.2103488892,
0.1091355085,
0.4806394279,
-0.7395080328,
0.6373286843,
-0.6907538772,
-0.3658556938,
0.4128988683,
0.6117475033,
0.7947440147,
0.3598838747,
0.5822657943,
0.0916950107,
0.7362321019,
-0.0431118868,
0.9062184095,
-0.3709994853,
0.0175827183,
0.7322100401,
-0.3214173317,
0.5464823246,
0.4941398501,
-0.0122691393,
0.3449504673,
0.8336969018,
0.0241483059,
0.7638277411,
0.2392710298,
-0.2319674343,
-0.0725328922,
0.034895584,
-0.0643231198,
0.0536949895,
0.3493032455,
-0.0675797984,
-0.2618959844,
0.1200649738,
0.2270534486,
-0.2991014719,
-0.5301917195,
1.0206954479,
-0.2142966241,
-0.8476113677,
0.5561900139,
-0.072495006,
0.5559740663,
-0.7315386534,
-0.0815666318,
-0.37646842,
-0.0947857499,
0.2046191394,
-0.5240064263,
-0.0475073047,
0.1423202306,
-0.0588207915,
-0.3290219009,
0.5340210199,
-0.1862277985,
-0.3284258246,
-0.1817075461,
0.2656089365,
0.0578788035,
0.0304706581,
-0.6616762877,
0.3520717919,
0.1168159172,
-0.2798946202,
-0.0576167032,
0.4044938982,
0.0784341991,
0.7477149963,
0.5387091041,
0.176973477,
-0.3059577942,
-0.1755189747,
0.7221345901,
-0.6710762978,
-0.47014907,
-1.0809342861,
0.2425032258,
-0.1538788676,
-0.4245364368,
0.4194826484,
0.3907917738,
0.4375255406,
0.0851456746,
0.6974046826,
0.1050529331,
0.8622395992,
-0.6299422383,
0.1602608711,
-0.434345454,
0.3928203583,
-0.4691155553,
-1.0076578856,
-0.3916400373,
0.5583146811,
-0.2509155869,
-0.1001579389,
0.7562891245,
0.9687021375,
0.3525181711,
0.0619732626,
0.0340366587,
-0.3202231824,
0.1628221422,
0.6748540998,
0.8028075695,
0.1792150736,
0.6124357581,
-0.0736240447,
-0.5841134787,
-0.3632708192,
-0.9773774743,
-1.0552927256,
-0.4790104032,
-0.2514160275,
-0.0284217652,
-0.0433167517,
1.3987290859,
0.615668416,
-0.6543246508,
-0.275952816,
0.1539201587,
0.3910754621,
-0.3573181629,
-0.159324497,
0.4594286382,
-0.5965390801,
-0.7226315141,
0.6312633753,
0.4268465638,
-0.0820875913,
-0.1423481256,
0.1088941842,
-0.0040640766,
0.4813017547,
0.4019056857,
0.3748058975,
-0.8160803914,
-0.3716283441,
0.1159880087,
-0.0529968813,
-0.1103797778,
0.7796049714,
-0.6901177764,
0.5192773938,
0.2776784301,
1.0109775066,
0.1329326481,
0.0265576784,
0.8258066773,
-0.6167547107,
-0.0934935957,
0.373200506,
0.3159293234,
0.1768507957,
-0.2595974505,
0.4932464659,
0.1139790565,
-0.5496775508,
-0.956994772,
0.2481222749,
-0.8910871744,
-0.1071246266,
1.3828117847,
-0.0104691666,
-0.1410976052,
0.0453033596,
-0.6917716861,
0.0797750875,
-0.6954114437,
0.5669177771,
0.6720138192,
-0.3032541573,
-0.3133616745,
-0.305539161,
0.4788746536,
0.2512328029,
-0.6162632108,
-0.0699207857,
0.9859127998,
-0.1599464864,
-0.0814275742,
0.3997784853,
0.3713177741,
0.2635325491,
-0.0991619825,
-0.2379782349,
-0.0846027285,
-0.5648249388,
-0.1901570261,
0.3645450473,
0.2056886554,
-0.5303952694
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09696v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09696v2
|
An Analysis of Language Frequency and Error Correction for Esperanto
| 2024-02-15T04:10:25 | 2024-02-16T02:19:49 |
Junhong Liang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Current Grammar Error Correction (GEC) initiatives tend to focus on major
languages, with less attention given to low-resource languages like Esperanto.
In this article, we begin to bridge this gap by first conducting a
comprehensive frequency analysis using the Eo-GP dataset, created explicitly
for this purpose. We then introduce the Eo-GEC dataset, derived from authentic
user cases and annotated with fine-grained linguistic details for error
identification. Leveraging GPT-3.5 and GPT-4, our experiments show that GPT-4
outperforms GPT-3.5 in both automated and human evaluations, highlighting its
efficacy in addressing Esperanto's grammatical peculiarities and illustrating
the potential of advanced language models to enhance GEC strategies for less
commonly studied languages.
|
[
-0.304092288,
-0.9558468461,
0.6328983903,
0.1867808402,
0.2363708019,
-0.1256858855,
-0.4939780235,
-0.5003492832,
0.0552957542,
0.0075927177,
-0.2911988199,
-0.541952014,
-0.7380285263,
0.667817831,
-0.5047490597,
0.9613617063,
0.1106794775,
-0.1763782054,
-0.1441091895,
0.0880277976,
-0.4363569915,
-0.5904311538,
-0.7215152383,
-0.050962396,
0.446534574,
0.8208812475,
0.5621043444,
0.295299232,
0.2165418863,
0.4433985353,
-0.2283234894,
0.1463020593,
-0.4801646769,
-0.203224048,
0.2121818513,
-0.1986736357,
-0.5358938575,
-0.2840759456,
0.4401181638,
0.7412026525,
-0.5792778134,
-0.1694055796,
0.0452561602,
0.6451212764,
-0.496406734,
0.4187631011,
-0.4872261584,
0.0823028535,
-0.7257114053,
0.2706114948,
-0.4283804893,
-0.2947785854,
-0.1757474542,
-0.9324918985,
0.2761226296,
-0.1548562199,
1.0882093906,
0.033581119,
-0.3372102082,
-0.2664461136,
-0.7509434223,
0.5848264694,
-0.3396609128,
0.1869170964,
0.5079402924,
0.1670677364,
-0.0698812082,
-0.2490638793,
-0.3756848574,
-0.2689405978,
-0.1874191314,
0.4146879911,
-0.3901718557,
0.3251883686,
0.6322367191,
0.3797361553,
-0.5124169588,
-0.2639259398,
-0.5116980076,
-0.1494771391,
0.2339385152,
-0.1403274685,
0.3598259091,
-0.0308097526,
0.198349908,
0.1503995806,
-0.4905910194,
-0.1577308923,
0.6565946341,
0.2684483826,
0.000825468,
0.4814244509,
-0.3968693912,
0.9145774245,
0.0305740777,
-0.0185787994,
0.3390892446,
-0.2560721338,
-0.1913007498,
-0.1353205144,
0.6273691654,
0.494808197,
0.7202865481,
-0.0537204109,
-0.268906951,
0.0884096324,
0.366879046,
-0.0666478872,
-0.0857298076,
-0.1511485726,
0.0097150514,
-0.1644630581,
0.539131403,
-1.1753078699,
0.0396131575,
-0.1719661355,
0.3606858552,
-0.2745963633,
0.0832127333,
0.1998669505,
-0.1202262864,
-0.1990176886,
0.2986967862,
-1.289306283,
0.767100215,
0.7008913755,
0.7234697938,
0.3691640198,
-0.4456222653,
-0.2862608135,
0.1346418411,
-0.2436741889,
0.848084271,
-0.63004601,
-0.5847228765,
0.1501926482,
0.1906187683,
-0.3216383457,
-0.280970335,
0.5017989278,
-0.1289897561,
0.2567795515,
-0.4257188141,
-0.3577860594,
-0.1428864747,
-0.0147130592,
-0.7566075921,
1.3938248158,
0.4504105449,
-0.4651644528,
0.281270057,
-0.6050488353,
-0.6069740057,
-0.1585142612,
-0.0742787048,
-0.5740216374,
0.3576138914,
0.1588447541,
0.0097016562,
-0.2237235606,
0.251552999,
-0.0331156626,
-0.527913332,
0.0544355437,
-0.4146018922,
0.3194634318,
0.3028316498,
-0.3810434937,
-0.2067235708,
-1.0587468147,
-0.2385660857,
-0.0378889143,
-0.1564043462,
-0.3702996671,
0.0327792764,
0.100238353,
-0.1063161567,
-0.0515100323,
-0.4435170591,
0.1420095265,
-0.3085416257,
0.2768065035,
0.6540898681,
-0.2604143918,
0.4436199665,
-0.0381551161,
0.6644207239,
-0.5484282374,
0.4215439558,
0.007590719,
-0.9278225303,
-0.8264103532,
0.3689776957,
0.2862285674,
0.6687640548,
-0.5479248762,
0.2889316976,
-0.1901422292,
-0.3825360537,
0.0435610414,
-0.0512383841,
0.5181480646,
0.5974804163,
0.3925749063,
-0.2427650392,
-0.5798488855,
-0.7710930705,
-0.5105221272,
-0.2677811086,
-0.1777648181,
0.3178489506,
0.247771576,
-0.0441225581,
0.6886191368,
-0.468075484,
-0.1473197043,
-0.08885777,
0.2828367352,
0.2729258239,
0.1604579538,
0.6894387007,
-0.4784910083,
-0.7397152185,
0.4366621375,
-0.3089944124,
-0.7116014361,
0.1162705868,
0.1041648462,
0.3509861231,
0.5244820714,
-0.0863647163,
0.157924816,
0.8394833803,
-0.6468929648,
0.0245752502,
-0.2129045874,
0.5103667378,
-0.6054782867,
0.0827985182,
0.0485267639,
-0.1647491306,
-0.7809319496,
-0.4669804573,
0.133322373,
-0.1192576438,
-0.0581161976,
-0.0102969008,
-0.3202086985,
-0.2620649934,
0.0240620375,
-0.0678224862,
-0.0474526212,
0.2277980745,
-0.4023324847,
0.7757726312,
0.2586193681,
-0.2339937389,
0.3176328242,
0.018764684,
0.0146352714,
0.5884227157,
-0.5604749322,
0.3124965727,
-0.1218222752,
-0.3244920671,
-0.7156623006,
-0.6676187515,
0.4178415835,
-0.3045886457,
0.48273018,
-0.5680783391,
-0.1583643854,
-0.3876513243,
-0.0765496269,
0.0307512861,
0.4557038248,
-0.156313166,
0.6750854254,
0.4822604358,
-0.3670730591,
-0.5797535181,
-0.4880899787,
0.0830450356,
0.008343013,
-0.6474189758,
0.1649809927,
0.2328855246,
-0.5145757794,
-0.0296448339,
0.0681880414,
0.0301010869,
0.2846686244,
0.2562861443,
-0.0298729148,
-0.0110235643,
0.3266607523,
-0.177542299,
-0.3761431277,
-0.2942538857,
-0.2009598464,
0.3936036527,
-0.5016044974,
-0.5252038836,
-0.0002260526,
0.4345833957,
0.2403794676,
0.1825304478,
0.4058261812,
0.1353877336,
-0.4652242362,
0.064610526,
-0.5911355019,
0.2516276836,
-0.4430218637,
0.4512170553,
-0.4086010456,
-0.6106643677,
0.4714541435,
0.2900162637,
-0.3986605406,
0.7280293703,
0.3583288491,
-0.0942834765,
0.5445548296,
0.6096824408,
-0.0349573679,
0.6760020852,
0.4459427595,
-0.1238218322,
-0.0367774479,
-0.1755826771,
-0.8958177567,
-0.0503437482,
-0.6273456812,
-0.1734560877,
0.3485027254,
-0.0394342281,
-0.204263553,
0.4142754972,
-0.0737925395,
0.964165926,
0.4785249531,
-0.1684969068,
0.444988519,
0.2002642453,
0.2717501819,
0.0521445908,
-0.5594915748,
-0.4193993509,
0.9036168456,
0.180568248,
0.5727854967,
0.1153505519,
0.5059884787,
0.179947108,
0.2606897056,
-0.7769799829,
0.1282667518,
-0.680439949,
-0.471314162,
-0.5445099473,
-0.4401465058,
-0.6078976393,
0.1328650266,
0.0976835266,
-0.4490625262,
0.1689399481,
0.4113111198,
-0.4943210185,
0.123412326,
-1.0660241842,
0.9998362064,
-0.0242481977,
-0.0039806738,
0.1582725793,
-0.3932614326,
-0.0791567937,
-0.2036649436,
0.4898334444,
-0.2176244557,
-0.1108973846,
0.3848782778,
-0.4942885637,
0.6937378645,
-0.1733475327,
-0.1090961844,
0.4098240435,
-0.2450287044,
0.6899322271,
-0.0806674063,
-0.1125818342,
0.3541116118,
-0.3125051856,
-0.4097820818,
-0.1975742728,
0.386749804,
-0.7563939691,
-0.3727226257,
-0.6406773329,
-0.0145486565,
-0.440256089,
-0.0753935426,
0.4082269371,
0.2068230808,
-0.558265388,
-0.062951237,
0.3434407413,
-0.1065460443,
0.3808836341,
0.6164275408,
0.0849741846,
-0.2919377685,
0.5231475234,
0.5334631801,
0.2351419628,
0.1950828582,
0.1715152562,
0.0204670671,
-0.4507414103,
-0.5081196427,
0.0219048578,
-0.6638058424,
-0.0769196227,
-0.6067709327,
0.3130729795,
-0.3187897503,
-0.1385246962,
-0.464073807,
-0.3070849478,
-0.0212212093,
-0.2855432928,
0.6331081986,
1.0250028372,
-0.1871530563,
0.6371692419,
-0.8435440063,
0.1535585523,
0.509735167,
0.4233284891,
-0.5938816667,
-0.4830713868,
-0.2098027617,
-0.2758318782,
0.0130050927,
-1.0848090649,
0.2370191216,
0.6815954447,
0.3591721952,
0.1927249432,
-0.6519796252,
0.7341843247,
-0.7243591547,
0.7512064576,
0.0561402217,
-1.3154850006,
0.7444883585,
-0.6333929896,
0.0129038971,
0.6652494073,
0.0387579314,
-1.3430240154,
-0.1746338308,
-0.6128425598,
-0.9370641112,
0.9008046389,
0.1258331686,
-0.1161606684,
-0.2506047487,
0.4804900289,
-0.0669141114,
-0.0515429303,
-0.7203143835,
-0.0771904588,
-0.1418404728,
-0.5021062493,
-0.1340602338,
-0.4940763712,
-0.2409485728,
0.1042765751,
0.6996287704,
-0.330152005,
0.0412871093,
-0.0191238429,
-0.2479239106,
-0.4746670723,
0.5156028867,
0.6907759905,
0.6274190545,
0.1211926639,
0.0839334205,
0.5633638501,
-0.7639618516,
0.1221468747,
0.1888715327,
-0.2968868315,
0.0202569235,
0.378477633,
0.420486629,
0.414034605,
-0.3527678847,
0.6401584744,
-0.0683669969,
0.0863643959,
-0.492213428,
-0.0272946563,
-0.0180505402,
-0.2199826539,
0.1127702817,
0.2737975717,
0.1387032717,
-0.2758426666,
0.1465395987,
-0.1721529067,
-0.3114574552,
-0.6208612919,
0.3674756885,
0.5496282578,
0.1772853583,
0.6071189046,
-0.2864208221,
-0.4600919485,
1.042645812,
0.3232968152,
0.7423722744,
-0.412666142,
0.1467677057,
0.6229639053,
0.5006660223,
-0.5325193405,
0.5164011717,
0.4676847756,
-0.721170187,
-0.6696717739,
-0.5763508081,
-0.102165848,
-0.2172061652,
-0.6727829576,
0.4337962568,
-0.2642218173,
-0.1578677148,
-0.2307729572,
-0.3844615221,
-0.4465984404,
0.0364572965,
0.3432528675,
0.2454761565,
-1.4647401571,
0.8289352655,
0.5790989995,
-0.2638047636,
-0.6863768101,
-0.1604741812,
0.5719672441,
-0.7186160684,
0.4197993875,
-0.0320862904,
-0.3213600218,
-0.080190368,
-0.1424456537,
-0.8504981399,
0.8918015361,
0.2967002094,
-1.1943324804,
0.3564689755,
0.2022695988,
0.6930667162,
0.1690513045,
0.305929184,
0.8744832277,
0.9329788089,
-0.2974580228,
-1.1557204723,
-0.4150756299,
-0.265755415,
0.2199686468,
0.4469918013,
-0.6828012466,
1.043107748,
0.0820745975,
-0.4842108786,
0.0902888402,
0.4122676849,
-0.309792012,
0.2544209957,
0.6028712988,
0.7245359421,
0.9462300539,
-0.830403626,
1.2408146858,
-0.13388291,
0.6653584838,
0.8755782843,
-0.1535115987,
0.4074113667,
0.4971204996,
-0.7531244755,
0.0751982778,
0.6094822288,
-0.3688394427,
0.149005428,
-0.0799893513,
-0.273311913,
-0.1167513505,
0.049220264,
-0.4171977937,
0.3781958818,
0.3795318902,
-0.2344041169,
0.0064967042,
-0.1324593127,
0.34427616,
0.3740031719,
-0.3920386434,
0.7664514184,
-0.2266995758,
-0.5741705298,
0.0534366295,
0.0310025103,
0.663233459,
-0.5910102129,
-0.1008338928,
-0.5147400498,
0.1523694992,
-0.3376148045,
-0.5833340287,
0.458545506,
0.3247945905,
-0.1718162745,
-0.1447914392,
0.669929564,
-0.42688784,
-0.475048393,
0.3341020346,
0.413457185,
-0.0781383961,
-0.1418153644,
-0.2833867073,
0.0798608661,
-0.0304218866,
-0.0673319623,
-0.0288409926,
0.5504635572,
0.0034928753,
0.0020872049,
0.1756597459,
0.0979812443,
0.0972534567,
0.7151723504,
0.4572981894,
-0.7337653041,
-0.301184237,
-0.8204331994,
0.2253466547,
-0.1937912852,
-0.5112942457,
0.8437749147,
0.3559036255,
1.3276207447,
-0.5276240706,
0.7935285568,
-0.4427076578,
0.4245802462,
-0.643633306,
0.2441459596,
-0.188787356,
0.2734600604,
-0.3352448046,
-0.8072385788,
-0.4663076699,
0.7088162899,
-0.3454328775,
0.2860263884,
0.6728768349,
0.9337379336,
0.1841820031,
0.268767029,
0.6277496219,
0.2730543017,
0.0128271226,
0.6863427758,
1.1160740852,
-0.5026702881,
0.6692686081,
-0.3835143149,
-0.3360472918,
-0.423227936,
-0.6872704029,
-0.406580776,
-0.2218632102,
-0.0957911611,
-0.1720523238,
0.5344829559,
0.934202075,
0.1316312402,
-1.122475028,
-0.2076971084,
-0.2615833282,
-0.0644422621,
-0.5190885663,
-0.113324821,
0.0925697312,
-0.4721211791,
-1.3766438961,
0.3748355806,
0.3360133171,
0.1005675346,
0.442215234,
0.0155670801,
0.1739312112,
-0.3217728436,
0.5825700164,
0.4408746958,
-0.5074976087,
-0.6143929362,
0.0552666783,
-0.2275535166,
0.1771980226,
0.9668719172,
-0.1985941082,
0.5226381421,
0.5646318793,
0.2003867626,
0.1697618216,
0.0041041109,
0.6887549758,
-0.9515826702,
0.1583708525,
-0.0147494609,
0.6430534124,
0.2268952727,
-0.3171494305,
0.9707853794,
0.6860330105,
-0.3636692762,
-0.1705786586,
0.1048707291,
-0.736266315,
-0.1360516399,
1.3432834148,
-0.0567973927,
-0.2143743783,
-0.5406907201,
-0.3610859215,
0.0962082222,
-0.4831279218,
0.6863501668,
1.1496756077,
-0.0575808957,
0.2419365346,
-0.7689255476,
0.67372334,
0.3676630557,
-0.8995543718,
0.091448918,
0.849904716,
0.1365102381,
0.2219438553,
0.4962202311,
-0.4688846469,
0.4360215962,
0.3370754421,
0.0525777936,
-0.0139707588,
-0.5321209431,
-0.6600813866,
0.1804359704,
0.2557061911,
0.2905240357
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09674v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09674v1
|
PAL: Proxy-Guided Black-Box Attack on Large Language Models
| 2024-02-15T02:54:49 | 2024-02-15T02:54:49 |
Chawin Sitawarin, Norman Mu, David Wagner, Alexandre Araujo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have surged in popularity in recent months, but
they have demonstrated concerning capabilities to generate harmful content when
manipulated. While techniques like safety fine-tuning aim to minimize harmful
use, recent works have shown that LLMs remain vulnerable to attacks that elicit
toxic responses. In this work, we introduce the Proxy-Guided Attack on LLMs
(PAL), the first optimization-based attack on LLMs in a black-box query-only
setting. In particular, it relies on a surrogate model to guide the
optimization and a sophisticated loss designed for real-world LLM APIs. Our
attack achieves 84% attack success rate (ASR) on GPT-3.5-Turbo and 48% on
Llama-2-7B, compared to 4% for the current state of the art. We also propose
GCG++, an improvement to the GCG attack that reaches 94% ASR on white-box
Llama-2-7B, and the Random-Search Attack on LLMs (RAL), a strong but simple
baseline for query-based attacks. We believe the techniques proposed in this
work will enable more comprehensive safety testing of LLMs and, in the long
term, the development of better security guardrails. The code can be found at
https://github.com/chawins/pal.
|
[
-0.35262537,
-1.2317130566,
0.4325504601,
0.22788544,
-0.5437880158,
0.2333534807,
0.0721763447,
-0.2269645184,
0.2401836663,
1.0048724413,
-0.5631932616,
-0.5366906524,
-0.6275553107,
-0.0150823081,
-0.4589724839,
0.7926577926,
0.1941241026,
0.0245070793,
0.2426233888,
0.2097191811,
-0.4951103628,
-0.7591505647,
-0.9425620437,
0.0122597329,
0.2955548465,
-0.0842090249,
0.592022717,
0.4498620629,
0.3790116906,
0.2127688527,
-0.4139539599,
0.0892572626,
-0.7211236358,
0.208602339,
-0.2062717229,
-0.5109443069,
-0.5245754123,
-0.3372028172,
0.5685586333,
0.4789767563,
-0.2808595002,
-0.0016611894,
-0.1386787891,
0.5491352081,
-0.6670871377,
0.0727314278,
-1.196958065,
-0.0682279691,
-0.4721985757,
-0.3006688058,
-0.6075498462,
-0.0612799376,
-0.1103366613,
-0.2590753436,
0.1074391305,
0.3102718592,
0.6563030481,
0.3822092116,
-0.5971535444,
-0.1525060982,
-0.130230993,
0.6476890445,
-0.577726841,
0.2981103659,
0.2135008723,
0.4118856788,
-0.9522600174,
-0.4474323392,
-0.4593321085,
-0.3278545439,
0.1130751818,
0.001147232,
-0.3077730238,
0.3859350979,
0.1669346541,
0.1325833648,
-0.5382390022,
0.0918175504,
-0.2607982457,
-0.3241753876,
0.65284127,
0.1322572976,
0.2449884266,
-0.0781797171,
-0.4778739512,
0.0436892919,
-1.1272855997,
-0.1765914112,
0.3659553826,
0.3175443113,
-0.3298511207,
0.5681855679,
-0.2983403504,
0.7229511142,
-0.0839039534,
-0.0679225251,
-0.187049672,
-0.0763186291,
-0.1576058269,
0.1728637666,
0.827494204,
0.5068555474,
0.4911090136,
-0.0760771409,
-0.2150847912,
0.2492490113,
0.3392867148,
-0.8244886994,
-0.0643798709,
0.0175358504,
-0.1873267889,
-0.3509148061,
-0.2192227691,
-1.1300595999,
-0.6140723825,
0.1995450705,
0.2069841325,
-0.0252995174,
-0.1560037434,
0.5068238974,
0.1065100878,
0.3925655186,
0.227613166,
-0.6657123566,
0.3467051685,
0.9934070706,
0.8348969817,
-0.0335521065,
-0.0642726123,
-1.2172526121,
0.4852308631,
-0.4684211314,
0.5623958111,
-0.6975576878,
-0.8272487521,
0.2637328506,
0.0921274573,
0.2458950281,
-0.2712135911,
0.5251146555,
-0.7135292292,
-0.1871370226,
-0.2571079731,
-0.3617254198,
0.1293869764,
0.447413981,
-0.5500607491,
0.6719143391,
-0.2351068556,
-0.7056182623,
-0.1463637054,
-0.5148591995,
-0.3856359422,
0.055727385,
-0.003609298,
-0.1988589913,
0.3337271512,
0.148975119,
0.3695371151,
-0.4868398905,
0.088135004,
-0.560911417,
-0.4219161868,
0.1237475574,
-0.500967741,
0.613399148,
0.0576683171,
-0.2720575333,
-0.1450526416,
-0.5982056856,
-0.048689872,
0.3503319919,
-0.3041430414,
-0.4115230441,
0.2818281949,
-0.4726935923,
-0.0926254243,
0.3269401789,
-0.6755265594,
0.2888711691,
-0.4770188332,
0.3801015615,
0.9954105616,
0.2449080944,
-0.0162637867,
-0.06773936,
0.6812762618,
-0.5342490673,
0.3821294606,
0.1335422844,
-0.5170656443,
-0.5256262422,
-0.0881205574,
0.1532140076,
0.478641957,
-0.8880783319,
0.1390704215,
-0.1905642301,
-0.4354170859,
-0.4357302487,
0.1631565243,
0.6901045442,
0.4626646042,
0.3000664115,
-0.2686159015,
-0.2000671178,
-0.7909650207,
-0.2822324634,
-0.4620963931,
0.130388543,
0.2223475575,
0.3646878004,
-0.559677422,
0.4132033885,
-0.8518381715,
-0.1620102674,
0.0446390882,
-0.2876176834,
0.1378338933,
0.3636386693,
0.614526391,
-0.5274742842,
-0.7151226997,
-0.0106735071,
-0.309443593,
-0.5913841724,
0.0503813624,
-0.3915413022,
0.3021053076,
0.6235195398,
-0.749178648,
0.1626997888,
0.6063213348,
-0.1912291646,
0.7627514005,
-0.0560134947,
-0.2929831445,
-0.75366503,
-0.1950478852,
0.1749976575,
-0.1019525826,
-0.9009949565,
0.4113018215,
0.0662408471,
0.0311868228,
-0.6404228806,
0.977900207,
-0.1419487596,
0.2097187638,
-0.3242216706,
-0.0700683072,
-0.0815125108,
0.463175565,
-0.1021958664,
0.7697915435,
0.6205171943,
-0.3260135353,
0.2360943854,
0.0987849608,
-0.057140667,
0.6383445859,
-0.7903692722,
0.3269177675,
-0.195253402,
0.3875656128,
-0.8027960062,
-0.1794940382,
0.3989552855,
-0.3512750864,
0.493427068,
-0.4084309936,
-0.5239567757,
-0.1516073793,
-0.7216330171,
0.107686311,
0.4368253648,
-0.766903162,
0.4217637777,
0.5352957845,
-0.2418356538,
-0.8522440791,
-0.6227464676,
0.3026550412,
-0.3130887449,
-0.4602689147,
0.3076369166,
-0.2790623903,
-0.3013553917,
-0.400544852,
-0.4285740256,
0.110689491,
0.3157954812,
-0.0916719958,
0.175253883,
0.1363730133,
-0.2526162565,
0.1177080795,
-0.1279412061,
0.4324785769,
0.0067046341,
0.9197046161,
-0.2053118199,
-0.5226271749,
-0.2283633649,
0.3547732532,
0.5428455472,
-0.2102254331,
0.6158546209,
0.2820149064,
-0.1286661476,
-0.4312240183,
-0.69359231,
0.024922315,
-0.5890684724,
0.471077472,
-0.4452004135,
-1.0070666075,
0.4837310314,
-0.0783978403,
-0.0771256164,
0.0810606778,
0.4434057474,
0.0943634808,
1.2736443281,
0.5331650972,
-0.3350830972,
0.3443609774,
-0.0927216411,
0.0934712663,
-0.868844986,
-0.2678988278,
-0.4881830215,
0.2170165479,
-0.8355083466,
-0.1048898324,
0.4565334022,
0.1361911297,
-0.5745088458,
0.0340226404,
-0.4132687747,
0.5823113918,
0.3354439437,
0.0491688997,
0.1061543822,
-0.0114998035,
-0.1930403709,
0.1700368077,
-0.359751761,
-0.3332710564,
1.2680473328,
0.5107482672,
1.1790492535,
0.2869303823,
0.6249368787,
0.3059832752,
0.2604829371,
-0.4427433908,
0.8604249954,
-0.351341188,
-0.485705018,
0.0805432349,
-0.5889571905,
-0.9587137699,
0.4783782065,
0.1606040746,
-0.8423550129,
-0.1825259626,
-0.0025301503,
-0.0085600782,
0.3919158578,
-0.8917927146,
0.6981893182,
-0.7598555088,
-0.3362332284,
-0.0891322941,
-0.5824164748,
0.5357851982,
-0.4247420132,
0.1684493273,
-0.0516137779,
-0.281657964,
0.328514576,
-0.3658902347,
0.9580689669,
-0.2720701694,
-0.1836120039,
-0.0637917817,
0.4189448357,
0.8387688994,
0.2607576549,
-0.057770431,
0.2875096202,
0.1034557447,
-0.5875228047,
-0.4466403127,
0.8163371682,
-0.5074953437,
-1.3456587791,
-0.4497962296,
-0.2978469133,
-0.1597586721,
0.1295322478,
-0.3168134987,
0.05680722,
0.1058626622,
0.2108747661,
0.7801650763,
-0.566203177,
0.2805050015,
0.9094240069,
-0.298364073,
-0.4347231686,
0.9431877732,
-0.1668835282,
0.6202498078,
0.3657886386,
0.1994512975,
-0.4437256753,
-0.8736737967,
-0.3613483906,
0.5461990237,
-0.619042635,
-0.3867530227,
-0.1966862679,
-0.199798584,
-0.2212815881,
-0.1642719656,
-0.2368564904,
0.1426794976,
-0.0872561708,
0.0515474565,
0.2559852302,
0.3430413306,
0.2838925719,
0.7046816945,
-0.6207661033,
0.3199303746,
0.3759359419,
0.5214214325,
-0.1940995604,
-0.1636161804,
0.192927599,
-0.0027053189,
-0.2142815143,
-1.0026831627,
0.5651875734,
0.066101186,
0.6628326774,
0.3470813632,
0.2192299962,
0.5392723083,
-0.5943055153,
0.78859061,
0.0785759166,
-0.8567354083,
0.5433138013,
-0.3996502161,
0.1612065136,
0.49179703,
0.1725913286,
-0.3631550968,
-0.3437893093,
-0.5328817964,
-0.521533072,
0.5554729104,
-0.0249021053,
0.3488567173,
-0.2878689468,
0.5654278398,
-0.0937985703,
0.4726563096,
-0.9096329808,
-0.4258143604,
0.0400280617,
0.171396032,
0.079929024,
-0.3834893107,
-0.2198365331,
0.1254336089,
0.6883462667,
-0.1903652251,
-0.0558549576,
-0.0781580135,
0.0338357463,
-0.2074446082,
0.2878072858,
0.4957477748,
0.2143103331,
-0.3967124522,
0.197509408,
0.389692992,
-0.5402060747,
0.1225338727,
0.2442893535,
-0.255587548,
-0.2086350769,
0.1881755143,
0.5894734859,
-0.0349553712,
-0.9119540453,
0.4955982566,
-0.2411352098,
0.0983650461,
-0.0813376456,
0.2446899414,
-0.2207978815,
0.1945105493,
0.312961936,
-0.4671078622,
-0.2868571877,
-0.5129137039,
-0.0080740545,
1.1281404495,
-0.1180404425,
-0.1616614759,
0.6715318561,
0.1396341771,
-0.4392238855,
-0.0222663917,
-0.3010429442,
-0.7614255548,
0.5488306284,
0.7629727125,
0.6851748228,
-0.3117955923,
0.1493596584,
-0.175405398,
0.6577198505,
-0.1200763211,
0.2596508861,
0.0576002188,
-0.3877772987,
-0.5429373384,
-0.899910152,
-0.6764881015,
0.5576338172,
-0.155564487,
0.3213119507,
-0.6177985668,
0.0899853632,
-0.2902728617,
0.3314770162,
-0.1516764611,
-0.0168252569,
0.0943834782,
0.9376901388,
-0.5310088992,
0.8810815215,
0.5497218966,
-0.0849391297,
-0.308388263,
-0.0266671684,
0.0658691823,
-0.9822391868,
0.3779596984,
0.1090173051,
-0.1577911675,
-0.1547232121,
-0.6122378707,
-0.8575730324,
0.848793447,
0.8170438409,
-0.6887902021,
0.0299781077,
0.5379942656,
0.5871402025,
-0.0203279648,
0.025535306,
0.7423716187,
0.3874833882,
-0.0333138891,
-0.8692762256,
0.1643034369,
-0.1179655939,
0.0599314384,
0.4915497303,
-1.0373184681,
0.7119292021,
0.4480015039,
-0.1349109709,
-0.0721020475,
0.2048350275,
0.5634082556,
0.1332559735,
0.4721815884,
0.6465339065,
0.6076130271,
0.0301154964,
1.3427518606,
-0.3643977344,
0.0319335461,
0.8837268353,
-0.4261839986,
0.7946927547,
0.4984441996,
-0.1111294404,
0.0238896236,
0.5249830484,
0.094335191,
0.7329522967,
0.5089225173,
-0.4246159196,
-0.0634886324,
-0.1917250752,
-0.4858296812,
0.1328125447,
0.6083610058,
-0.0041688397,
-0.3524717093,
-0.224912256,
0.3845706284,
-0.0957514495,
-0.5321620703,
0.5148046017,
0.2906390727,
-0.5913521647,
0.8616787791,
0.1644897014,
0.8446911573,
-0.8066741824,
0.1078456864,
-0.421063751,
-0.0332258083,
0.0819845051,
-0.6122487783,
0.0863879398,
0.115850471,
0.303974241,
0.0181554686,
0.8257701993,
-0.2808099389,
-0.3749266267,
0.5566078424,
0.3067669868,
-0.0343334563,
-0.1734434813,
-0.7132090926,
0.3859947324,
0.056882266,
-0.2173351347,
0.6567570567,
0.188967973,
-0.1487846673,
0.9912823439,
0.7598451972,
0.510107398,
0.2807223499,
-0.0062819133,
0.9610365629,
-0.4443385899,
-0.3397041857,
-1.045984745,
0.1277838796,
-0.0739841983,
0.0245894846,
0.5417631269,
0.3601286709,
0.8505746722,
0.2037978619,
0.6689815521,
0.3707757294,
0.2031630427,
-0.7467285395,
0.612392962,
-0.5349033475,
0.830304265,
-0.3203434348,
-0.9192162156,
-0.4636256993,
0.1404799372,
-0.4029027224,
-0.3523964584,
0.4350836575,
1.2818243504,
0.1166549698,
-0.2379402667,
0.1498638541,
0.311365962,
0.9719359279,
0.6375845671,
0.8984137177,
-0.0906939432,
0.8104727268,
-0.184280619,
-0.19422777,
-0.1395394802,
-0.9942798615,
-1.2247179747,
-0.1428631842,
-0.1217111424,
-0.3003887236,
0.4791666567,
0.5874691606,
0.3735799193,
-0.4973846376,
-0.1417681426,
-0.1956886351,
0.1454289258,
0.3086580932,
-0.1768247783,
0.4975156188,
-0.2569423318,
-0.5206029415,
0.6640154123,
0.1515754163,
0.064542532,
-0.3539592028,
-0.1648575068,
-0.1017544791,
0.2439686656,
0.4013024271,
0.3160496354,
-0.7813622952,
-0.5151508451,
-0.2240598351,
0.1184728518,
-0.2322767079,
0.3079957962,
-0.5459128022,
0.5463844538,
0.2027545124,
0.9206162691,
0.5353420377,
0.0786222443,
0.4672517776,
-0.9064431787,
0.1055314094,
0.0925614834,
0.5216217041,
0.1136475652,
-0.3116900325,
0.6132817864,
0.0948393568,
-0.4591823816,
-1.3038755655,
0.2809500992,
-1.1401308775,
-0.3823665977,
1.3895902634,
0.1065463275,
-0.3898485303,
-0.0376335531,
-0.4326614439,
-0.0959642678,
-0.5741606951,
0.9701589942,
0.5220739841,
0.1617061049,
0.0439714044,
-0.7466148138,
0.4081130028,
0.4542752206,
-0.7828626633,
0.0729420632,
0.4970058203,
0.2152737975,
0.0397950411,
0.4148362279,
-0.114116095,
0.1704290956,
-0.2159437835,
-0.3958419263,
-0.124316752,
-0.1703658253,
-0.4352226853,
0.5255830288,
0.006463686,
-0.1292140931
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09668v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09668v1
|
How to Train Data-Efficient LLMs
| 2024-02-15T02:27:57 | 2024-02-15T02:27:57 |
Noveen Sachdeva, Benjamin Coleman, Wang-Cheng Kang, Jianmo Ni, Lichan Hong, Ed H. Chi, James Caverlee, Julian McAuley, Derek Zhiyuan Cheng
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The training of large language models (LLMs) is expensive. In this paper, we
study data-efficient approaches for pre-training LLMs, i.e., techniques that
aim to optimize the Pareto frontier of model quality and training resource/data
consumption. We seek to understand the tradeoffs associated with data selection
routines based on (i) expensive-to-compute data-quality estimates, and (ii)
maximization of coverage and diversity-based measures in the feature space. Our
first technique, Ask-LLM, leverages the zero-shot reasoning capabilities of
instruction-tuned LLMs to directly assess the quality of a training example. To
target coverage, we propose Density sampling, which models the data
distribution to select a diverse sample. In our comparison of 19 samplers,
involving hundreds of evaluation tasks and pre-training runs, we find that
Ask-LLM and Density are the best methods in their respective categories.
Coverage sampling can recover the performance of the full data, while models
trained on Ask-LLM data consistently outperform full-data training -- even when
we reject 90% of the original dataset, while converging up to 70% faster.
|
[
-0.5301873088,
-0.736405611,
0.5373198986,
0.0113058127,
-0.2934539616,
0.1510819495,
-0.2734705508,
-0.0344815999,
0.190928936,
0.7542032599,
-0.3622256219,
-0.5398330092,
-0.6448200345,
-0.2195631117,
-0.5994942784,
0.6221175194,
-0.0696337521,
0.1871980429,
-0.2547602057,
-0.104710184,
-0.0407489948,
-0.558026433,
-0.5920382738,
-0.0187057368,
0.6113947034,
0.5637038946,
0.6034154892,
0.9357146621,
0.3376255631,
0.2639481425,
-0.2147655487,
0.2006572932,
-0.9430322051,
-0.0348933302,
0.0384417921,
-0.6458085179,
-0.0899148509,
0.3738326728,
0.5839854479,
0.9756629467,
-0.2278646678,
0.2167562544,
-0.0642790124,
0.4681544006,
-0.6544927955,
-0.1939110458,
-0.8920388818,
0.0965875536,
-0.2198291868,
-0.2285641581,
-0.219598189,
-0.4292739332,
-0.1513989866,
-0.4552119374,
0.1650489271,
-0.0074606929,
0.812236011,
0.2633161247,
-0.2823647857,
-0.2047220618,
-0.7234771252,
1.1232126951,
-0.3348443806,
0.4831564426,
0.6653868556,
0.316283226,
-0.0601869039,
-0.4188409746,
-0.3937632143,
-0.3062390387,
0.2547535896,
0.060106989,
-0.0940318555,
-0.0393617749,
0.1955989152,
0.5280745029,
-0.4739411175,
0.4404374957,
-0.236622721,
-0.1218060181,
0.7059112787,
0.0826544389,
0.1106848791,
0.1657853872,
-0.3196918964,
-0.2337182462,
-0.7896780968,
-0.003779463,
0.5133004189,
0.162655592,
0.1323322207,
0.6673351526,
-0.2662005723,
0.9581280947,
-0.3904343545,
-0.1932276934,
0.1039368436,
-0.4585696161,
-0.26037094,
-0.4628398418,
0.4690856934,
0.0785931945,
0.400796175,
-0.2118017673,
-0.4752457142,
-0.244107917,
0.2558796108,
-0.6896343827,
-0.0793722868,
0.2820902467,
-0.2743272781,
-0.2110401988,
-0.3561907113,
-0.6511414051,
-0.0402218662,
-0.5742185116,
0.5067890286,
-0.4262007475,
-0.0313710012,
0.2838338315,
0.078299284,
0.2477228343,
0.4396133423,
-0.8487099409,
0.1317772716,
0.4360552132,
0.652561903,
-0.029642215,
-0.2361706048,
-0.5985867381,
-0.0797401369,
-0.6617268324,
0.8847205043,
-0.3811421692,
-0.3930549324,
-0.1541438997,
-0.4923452735,
-0.2108027786,
-0.8065730929,
0.2876233459,
-0.5287521482,
-0.0299087726,
-0.4516539574,
-0.7422578931,
0.0046541016,
0.3685326874,
-0.7332249284,
0.9928708076,
0.4784168005,
-0.6484933496,
0.7142698169,
-0.1998650879,
-0.3185769022,
-0.0210573059,
-0.087379232,
-0.4681493938,
0.0182863176,
0.5390160084,
0.767727077,
-0.2424654961,
0.0731629506,
-0.3989274204,
-0.5478502512,
0.3800336123,
-0.2167639434,
0.6437407732,
0.5313370824,
-0.0800414681,
-0.1351307184,
-0.6850095987,
0.0814779848,
0.2482609302,
-0.5358142853,
-0.2378804982,
0.0635857657,
-0.3274818957,
-0.1486515701,
0.0738358945,
-0.2064189762,
-0.036181923,
-0.3539289832,
0.1947559267,
0.5972021222,
-0.2629065216,
0.5817265511,
-0.5788692236,
0.6590746641,
-0.0921261087,
0.3525501788,
0.0258581694,
0.1043448746,
-0.9486188293,
-0.4148007631,
0.2552098632,
0.5613545179,
-0.9566969872,
0.5610067844,
-0.1667725146,
-0.6689336896,
-0.5720005631,
0.6158611774,
0.1990675628,
0.3499706686,
0.2960413396,
0.0417048968,
-0.1871295273,
-0.7123000026,
-0.1488516182,
0.0325542353,
0.1357324868,
0.4607165456,
0.3435909152,
-0.0339379273,
0.9578578472,
-0.5043417811,
0.2052263618,
-0.7582603693,
-0.2514623106,
0.2597994804,
0.295034796,
0.58518821,
-0.6390911341,
-0.4278119504,
-0.3269958496,
-0.4534031451,
-0.2144936621,
-0.0394061357,
-0.373709619,
-0.0360050499,
0.4096233547,
-0.5355513096,
0.007153552,
0.5334634185,
0.1000251621,
0.1476121694,
-0.1035207435,
0.1105983332,
-0.8901337981,
-0.034335535,
-0.0732924268,
-0.241442427,
-0.7124435306,
-0.0823849589,
-0.054324951,
-0.291089803,
-0.5305194259,
0.6798529625,
-0.5288876295,
-0.2883456945,
-0.0887577981,
-0.021090392,
-0.0769363344,
0.3843907714,
-0.0717504025,
1.0565809011,
0.6792538762,
-0.6847420335,
0.1075390354,
0.1001520082,
-0.7062066793,
0.4092770219,
-0.4173520207,
0.0264259614,
-0.3869521916,
-0.1510144025,
-0.8942719698,
-0.0884817392,
0.088128753,
-0.1314361989,
0.2621408999,
-0.0830235183,
-0.5337719321,
-0.2387280464,
-0.3326307535,
0.2049260139,
0.7258332968,
-0.9055655003,
0.2138838917,
0.5723071694,
-0.1223198771,
-0.5831647515,
-0.6846051216,
-0.2018103749,
-0.4899680614,
-0.4810521305,
0.0191000886,
0.0859577805,
-0.2324096262,
-0.2583505809,
-0.0582114011,
-0.2844553292,
0.4641073346,
-0.3243682086,
-0.1071152464,
0.1329486221,
0.025832044,
0.0599132292,
-0.0317083076,
-0.1322335303,
-0.0626336634,
0.7781569362,
0.1805178821,
-0.5902513862,
-0.008229862,
0.2208327651,
0.0275124274,
-0.1873859018,
0.5819242597,
0.3124572039,
-0.0158883389,
-0.6440793872,
-0.8569336534,
-0.1034304127,
-0.4107199907,
0.482685715,
-0.2382005304,
-0.8707366586,
0.4075720906,
-0.0045587579,
0.1590721756,
0.05267125,
0.455198586,
-0.4175839126,
0.7409198284,
0.4226935208,
-0.1518945992,
0.6486492157,
-0.5280553102,
0.0407709181,
-0.3850121498,
-0.0843101591,
-0.5271191597,
-0.2822967768,
-0.0896642953,
-0.8116749525,
0.3911101818,
0.45073241,
-0.2958317995,
0.1479818672,
-0.2365567237,
0.6137267947,
0.7826064825,
0.2733623385,
0.0673619658,
0.4497717619,
0.3513226807,
0.0238698386,
-0.9499405026,
-0.458568573,
1.4127130508,
0.3926101327,
0.9112326503,
-0.2548781931,
0.9405490756,
-0.2493869811,
0.1177110672,
-0.7191931605,
0.6121252775,
-0.2761302888,
-0.3218566775,
-0.5184246898,
-0.932957232,
-1.0963588953,
0.3358469605,
-0.1597861201,
-0.21569103,
0.1156036705,
0.4319448471,
-0.2728923261,
0.558277905,
-0.5530753136,
0.625084579,
-0.6453851461,
0.0281050429,
-0.2787350714,
-0.3319561183,
0.3378177583,
-0.2635044456,
0.1611105353,
-0.4004361629,
-0.1178790852,
0.6386818886,
-0.2786795497,
0.5172073841,
-0.2884359658,
0.1956596971,
0.3726322949,
-0.0405929759,
0.3377044499,
-0.0156882126,
-0.1165645793,
0.3268799186,
-0.2959077954,
-0.7822207808,
-0.5313420296,
0.185711056,
-0.9377456903,
-0.2861700952,
-0.0228398591,
-0.5815132856,
-0.4317699671,
-0.1423338205,
0.4328580797,
0.294498682,
-0.213081941,
0.1998786777,
0.9570106864,
-0.5368053913,
0.150351733,
0.3138260841,
0.0050306781,
-0.5148378015,
0.9533874989,
0.4240096211,
0.6029652357,
0.5036824942,
0.095053561,
-0.2948531806,
-1.0238941908,
-0.2733205855,
0.138938874,
-0.6820390224,
-0.1964023262,
-0.8141454458,
-0.293703109,
-0.0513929427,
-0.2049114108,
-0.4295713902,
-0.1643628925,
-0.3941074014,
-0.1181649789,
0.4252260923,
0.1574917138,
0.1066691577,
0.7639801502,
-0.472620219,
0.1696223617,
0.3905718327,
0.3057343364,
-0.3727149367,
-0.5039846897,
-0.3013332188,
0.0190316532,
-0.0748105869,
-0.5373529196,
0.4611597657,
0.0996283665,
0.9911932945,
0.1601673812,
-0.1905980408,
0.4065881371,
-0.1995149106,
0.5390564203,
-0.0646506324,
-0.6688491106,
0.5370180607,
-0.1226811558,
0.0861800462,
0.9854610562,
0.6002663374,
-0.1354723424,
-0.4006972909,
-0.5015902519,
-0.8541719913,
0.6256998181,
0.1608618498,
0.4217439294,
-0.0330136269,
0.4421688616,
0.1351165473,
0.3514246643,
-0.6503133774,
-0.1209488809,
-0.1816943288,
-0.2298852205,
-0.276387006,
-0.356018424,
-0.1858517677,
-0.2545592487,
0.4231668115,
-0.2625134587,
0.103475146,
-0.0791093409,
-0.4053601325,
0.4614978135,
0.3828048706,
0.1874481887,
0.778146863,
-0.2336855382,
0.1320627183,
0.3414154053,
-0.2871152461,
0.3278132677,
0.1225513741,
-0.175922364,
-0.018212406,
0.2965618372,
1.1448222399,
0.1030408889,
-0.8913168311,
0.5894085765,
0.0902338848,
-0.4056630731,
-0.1250379682,
0.422208637,
0.1979983151,
0.2202678025,
-0.0801324174,
-0.5066668987,
0.0353830159,
-0.3584522009,
0.0526325107,
0.5886332989,
0.1350215375,
0.1671097279,
0.3608663976,
0.0228053927,
0.0749448761,
0.8311586976,
-0.0954259112,
-0.2963614166,
0.7117891312,
0.1980085224,
0.4791897833,
-0.2626664042,
0.3209423721,
0.1165785491,
0.3081871271,
-0.2531391084,
0.741871357,
-0.0023559772,
-0.9374709725,
-0.4848428667,
-0.691718936,
-0.5871767402,
0.231858924,
-0.4728839695,
0.3067103624,
-0.5877687931,
0.0195928216,
-0.3936778903,
0.0836523026,
-0.8591743708,
0.3375243247,
-0.0078097344,
1.0739876032,
-0.8475682735,
0.7858757377,
0.4129194617,
-0.2089025825,
-0.9574045539,
-0.3925460875,
-0.3506579697,
-1.2894353867,
0.6209629178,
0.0361222252,
0.3365301788,
0.1052408516,
-0.5630671978,
-1.0888464451,
1.0369927883,
0.8063549995,
-0.8227300644,
0.2651344836,
0.2631590366,
0.195550397,
-0.1959830076,
0.3747560084,
0.7691431642,
0.1686371267,
0.2522656322,
-0.4993432164,
-0.4752499461,
0.0146401972,
0.1276383251,
0.2568937838,
-0.5382721424,
0.933075428,
-0.0828572065,
-0.0936050788,
-0.2011468261,
0.4074217379,
0.4982627332,
0.1173233911,
0.8699237704,
0.7497036457,
0.8198882937,
-0.0729031786,
1.2683990002,
-0.4240845144,
0.314548254,
0.7636682987,
-0.3203992546,
0.7106727362,
0.3514842689,
-0.3433555961,
-0.213050276,
1.0100083351,
-0.2941708267,
0.5113194585,
0.4925010502,
-0.2632868588,
-0.5143581629,
0.1214286238,
-0.1608977765,
0.4083843529,
0.206488356,
-0.1728373915,
-0.4527691901,
0.1058468744,
0.0132383658,
0.0121829677,
-0.3711672723,
0.8782430291,
0.0985439345,
-0.3519767225,
0.6812027693,
-0.1697424948,
0.583445549,
-0.6604046226,
0.4283694029,
-0.7626692653,
-0.1334269047,
0.0694426,
-0.7299980521,
0.3231073618,
-0.0269320309,
-0.0930586755,
-0.324878335,
0.5134451389,
-0.6477534771,
-0.5605356097,
0.2475278974,
0.8019690514,
0.5028134584,
-0.1332071275,
-0.7656374574,
0.0324326679,
-0.1222245544,
-0.503693521,
0.533864677,
0.0828585923,
0.0054692207,
0.7697720528,
0.6274748445,
0.6669383645,
0.1128514707,
0.2025550753,
0.8936599493,
-0.587582767,
-0.4848295748,
-0.7576354742,
0.3458434641,
-0.1939121187,
-0.1988891512,
0.3658421338,
0.6070507169,
1.0380963087,
0.2384962887,
0.7386315465,
0.3741779923,
0.8379486203,
-0.8992527723,
0.4952747226,
-0.6504966021,
0.4944058061,
0.1466730088,
-1.1015076637,
-0.1186862066,
0.6339128017,
-0.4196526706,
0.2257872671,
0.2914181054,
0.9617357254,
-0.274704814,
-0.1703753769,
0.4699290991,
-0.1562673599,
0.3198891878,
0.6463464499,
1.0338016748,
-0.0347681753,
0.4532751739,
-0.4900385439,
-0.3118742406,
-0.0544662029,
-0.7113528252,
-0.9338105917,
-0.1441569775,
-0.0788905844,
-0.0735822544,
-0.0446494408,
0.9210669994,
0.9134456515,
-0.58669734,
-0.4513984621,
0.0648768246,
0.1604689211,
0.0762586966,
-0.127056241,
0.3777689338,
-0.7433078885,
-0.729256928,
0.5214105844,
0.0608938858,
0.2493204474,
-0.1602332592,
0.0931831971,
0.2238371074,
0.1081733257,
0.5177328587,
0.0039365259,
-0.3068203926,
0.1504744291,
0.0065133236,
-0.1995934844,
0.0656841695,
0.9294112921,
-0.4720191658,
0.316493541,
0.4379095733,
1.2332031727,
0.575455904,
0.0508845113,
0.4966526926,
-0.5978555679,
0.2490806282,
0.3755505085,
0.2541908622,
0.3407735825,
-0.3688388765,
0.5430469513,
0.1138508692,
-0.5520486236,
-0.8772001266,
0.104615517,
-0.768612504,
-0.5145101547,
1.2472661734,
-0.0966752321,
-0.0298966728,
-0.0414041691,
0.0162971541,
-0.0366486683,
0.0189715531,
0.6023044586,
0.5947464108,
-0.0920036212,
-0.38916412,
-0.8543507457,
0.4332374036,
0.6390096545,
-1.1959607601,
-0.0890390873,
0.3485594392,
0.4436478913,
-0.411980927,
0.8409797549,
0.0317362323,
-0.058780428,
-0.1290896535,
0.0759069175,
-0.1251863241,
-0.358033061,
-0.4505944848,
0.0781722888,
0.2209829092,
-0.1905996352
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09666v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09666v1
|
EntailE: Introducing Textual Entailment in Commonsense Knowledge Graph Completion
| 2024-02-15T02:27:23 | 2024-02-15T02:27:23 |
Ying Su, Tianqing Fang, Huiru Xiao, Weiqi Wang, Yangqiu Song, Tong Zhang, Lei Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Commonsense knowledge graph completion is a new challenge for commonsense
knowledge graph construction and application. In contrast to factual knowledge
graphs such as Freebase and YAGO, commonsense knowledge graphs (CSKGs; e.g.,
ConceptNet) utilize free-form text to represent named entities, short phrases,
and events as their nodes. Such a loose structure results in large and sparse
CSKGs, which makes the semantic understanding of these nodes more critical for
learning rich commonsense knowledge graph embedding. While current methods
leverage semantic similarities to increase the graph density, the semantic
plausibility of the nodes and their relations are under-explored. Previous
works adopt conceptual abstraction to improve the consistency of modeling
(event) plausibility, but they are not scalable enough and still suffer from
data sparsity. In this paper, we propose to adopt textual entailment to find
implicit entailment relations between CSKG nodes, to effectively densify the
subgraph connecting nodes within the same conceptual class, which indicates a
similar level of plausibility. Each node in CSKG finds its top entailed nodes
using a finetuned transformer over natural language inference (NLI) tasks,
which sufficiently capture textual entailment signals. The entailment relation
between these nodes are further utilized to: 1) build new connections between
source triplets and entailed nodes to densify the sparse CSKGs; 2) enrich the
generalization ability of node representations by comparing the node embeddings
with a contrastive loss. Experiments on two standard CSKGs demonstrate that our
proposed framework EntailE can improve the performance of CSKG completion tasks
under both transductive and inductive settings.
|
[
-0.2707123756,
-0.8992311358,
0.7340865135,
-0.0213753954,
-0.3052967787,
-0.1022051349,
-0.2255159914,
-0.3248817325,
0.4263330996,
0.6608606577,
-0.3775832355,
-0.7236813307,
-0.5661588311,
0.2308520973,
-0.4720510244,
0.7644919753,
-0.3630999923,
-0.5725229383,
-0.7282605767,
0.0302599259,
-0.3353199661,
0.0990527719,
-0.6513768435,
-0.3700202703,
0.3293969333,
0.3396869302,
0.7254850268,
0.5879583359,
0.2115047276,
0.3275436759,
-0.1427446753,
0.6506006122,
-0.6813515425,
0.2458179742,
0.0232419111,
-0.1321003139,
-0.1994587332,
-0.0106765404,
0.5638568997,
0.963488102,
0.171803847,
-0.1766426116,
0.5192179084,
0.5067501664,
-0.6945508122,
0.2603287697,
-0.663392365,
-0.0411938652,
-0.009730882,
-0.0772941634,
-0.4812542796,
-0.4453395307,
0.3254665136,
-1.2703675032,
0.3776578009,
0.1154724285,
0.9637426138,
0.3381012976,
-0.6012964249,
-0.367826134,
-0.1088028401,
0.3938569129,
-0.6430760622,
0.4553958178,
0.6167924404,
-0.002903769,
-0.1683188975,
-0.9546505213,
-0.7451605201,
-0.4484842122,
-0.6977921128,
0.2946290076,
-0.0873412639,
0.285587728,
0.1957797259,
0.286986053,
-0.4547217488,
-0.142180264,
-0.0191278141,
-0.1862384975,
0.3905398846,
0.0418183766,
0.2456100136,
-0.2332751304,
-0.2597351074,
0.3346714675,
-0.7028127313,
-0.3639698327,
0.442790091,
0.080138728,
-0.1561561674,
0.6570211053,
-0.5274694562,
0.6971802711,
0.1197901368,
0.1454205513,
0.2357481271,
-0.6001298428,
-0.2146891505,
0.2357411981,
0.5560528636,
0.3270611167,
0.3892570734,
-0.6074231267,
0.3732011914,
0.0685138479,
-0.0312981978,
-0.7304647565,
-0.038015224,
0.4332405329,
-0.2624793649,
-0.1800052673,
-0.061326284,
-0.3385825157,
-0.5137233734,
-0.5979293585,
0.4064497352,
-0.6881166101,
-0.4462855756,
0.3201642632,
-0.408662945,
0.1243500933,
0.4172341228,
-0.4810938239,
0.4543593526,
0.9222849011,
0.8382365704,
-0.0253026448,
-0.1817339212,
-0.2726503909,
0.6705986857,
-0.3859069645,
0.5731486082,
-0.6425125003,
-0.0794955567,
-0.0282475464,
0.1513989866,
-0.1767135113,
-0.3225245178,
0.6430025697,
-0.2672780156,
-0.0094333263,
-0.1758610308,
-0.9325196147,
-0.2449603379,
0.4445080459,
-0.5723721385,
1.0842536688,
-0.1099900231,
-1.0597257614,
0.2853824794,
-0.5172339678,
-0.5036905408,
0.1582477242,
0.1025976911,
-0.1986350268,
-0.2417934537,
0.0939583629,
0.6174619794,
-0.0684958547,
0.3299194872,
-0.3289549649,
-0.273432523,
0.0687446296,
-0.0737081468,
0.6530330777,
-0.0522188731,
-0.0754333958,
-0.0937442705,
-0.6195843816,
-0.2014680356,
-0.1076495796,
0.0174884647,
-0.733312428,
0.1401276141,
-0.2616924644,
-0.3342728019,
0.2551041543,
-0.7788035274,
-0.2947251797,
-0.8767902255,
0.4721675515,
0.357791692,
0.2890404463,
0.7296744585,
-0.1794686615,
-0.1342914701,
0.0628968626,
-0.0684640557,
-0.0040308633,
-0.5398203731,
-0.7366717458,
-0.2310807109,
0.2850027084,
0.4207455218,
-0.9650566578,
0.3931014836,
-0.3822836876,
-0.2725275755,
-0.3371707797,
0.0037925399,
0.2368082404,
0.6375219822,
0.2921764851,
0.1664677262,
-0.4659380913,
-0.9122604132,
-0.328055948,
0.113314122,
-0.1065851152,
0.0928865969,
0.624125421,
-0.0067044082,
0.9514150023,
-0.6122727394,
-0.2679636776,
-0.2013063729,
0.1401789337,
0.0877688825,
0.492890656,
0.3575447798,
-0.7789052129,
-0.6196716428,
0.3881035447,
-0.7309550643,
0.0061746733,
0.0639380142,
-0.4438733757,
0.0752787739,
0.5316836834,
-0.5070582628,
0.5630412102,
0.0597284846,
-0.4247037768,
0.1132400259,
-0.0902368277,
0.2200722247,
-0.9466567636,
-0.2812458575,
-0.1039884388,
-0.2523428798,
-0.5345073342,
0.163827315,
0.0210689045,
0.0314270854,
-0.2072657943,
0.5184133649,
-0.2889955342,
0.1768718213,
-0.0494989082,
0.6540429592,
0.2152964026,
0.3835190237,
0.0557341278,
0.1054085866,
0.5375047922,
-0.7078645825,
0.2920145094,
0.2821981013,
0.0381540917,
0.5935299397,
-0.7200106382,
-0.1483103782,
-0.372975409,
0.2230410725,
-0.9930125475,
-0.2789560258,
0.365447253,
-0.6364347339,
0.1848032624,
-0.2674570978,
-0.672567606,
0.068003282,
-0.1829576194,
0.1965720803,
0.303616792,
-0.3595810831,
0.8041547537,
0.1435330212,
0.1226597577,
-0.5516757965,
-0.6799249649,
0.1195692122,
-0.0108443275,
-0.7968893051,
0.4717825651,
0.3269608915,
-0.2468453646,
0.5456982851,
-0.0270666629,
-0.175871402,
0.1406854093,
0.1728590727,
-0.0061765462,
-0.2016327977,
0.4541462958,
0.3670158982,
-0.1611503512,
-0.1134441346,
-0.3919559121,
0.1973785162,
0.0015103985,
-0.4523488283,
-0.2918335497,
0.4637862742,
0.0907963663,
-0.1467143893,
0.7256760597,
0.4926195741,
-0.7080786824,
-0.1671810597,
-0.420184046,
-0.2303706855,
-0.3922724426,
0.2815980315,
-0.2005086988,
-1.0987160206,
0.4187073708,
-0.1300792098,
0.1155988798,
0.5504025221,
-0.0506876521,
-0.1130058989,
0.4713478684,
0.2063382417,
0.5792906284,
-0.1267814338,
-0.2758227587,
0.0942367688,
-0.7265326977,
-0.3527183533,
-0.5124472976,
-0.2282560617,
-0.6899117827,
-0.40929088,
0.3501518667,
0.1582068056,
-0.3798655272,
0.3318082094,
-0.4739982784,
0.6071041822,
0.1958330572,
0.2036325037,
0.5067279339,
0.0509597436,
-0.1907172203,
-0.0805321559,
-0.6470013261,
-0.3513267934,
0.770185113,
0.1264404655,
0.3022505939,
0.1748217493,
0.8225810528,
0.0218024943,
0.2118115872,
-0.6648138165,
0.5360015631,
-0.3981015682,
-0.1784485132,
-0.5154492259,
-0.4182480276,
-1.0095957518,
0.2388731539,
-0.3935116827,
-0.54507339,
0.1299400926,
0.0629004389,
0.1806599647,
0.1515089571,
-0.7346733809,
0.8078286648,
0.4585361779,
-0.4700644612,
-0.3791253269,
-0.3692257702,
0.4089079797,
0.3048295081,
0.117172502,
-0.0759345293,
-0.2573845983,
0.6682801843,
-0.553986907,
1.0515348911,
-0.1058147997,
0.0099835005,
0.5511543155,
0.1765272766,
0.6707887053,
0.2154369652,
0.0963970348,
-0.0693544745,
-0.1383222491,
-0.3103737831,
-0.8460561037,
0.7416638136,
-0.4660213292,
-0.4042750299,
-0.0155215636,
-0.3474945128,
-0.2231201679,
0.1900057495,
-0.0596285351,
0.7621805072,
-0.132690534,
0.2891577184,
1.0255894661,
-0.1668052673,
0.2234162092,
0.2794457972,
0.2288457006,
-0.3188809156,
0.9042290449,
0.1690453589,
0.2598066926,
0.5817830563,
0.2379774004,
-0.4842289984,
-0.4808035195,
-0.2936177552,
0.2776905596,
-0.7784498334,
-0.2890256941,
-0.9719400406,
-0.3247938156,
-0.5543447137,
-0.3095876873,
-0.0616311468,
-0.6037392616,
-0.1414103061,
-0.2197188437,
0.7684938312,
0.648457408,
0.1743320972,
0.1708572358,
-0.3456881642,
0.3924452066,
0.2503739297,
0.436583519,
0.1966672689,
-0.325689882,
-0.0418707579,
0.0453651361,
-0.1873617172,
-0.9795388579,
-0.0746550187,
0.2719703317,
0.7307086587,
0.2083430737,
0.4358129203,
0.5043010712,
-0.3906611502,
0.47028929,
0.1479853392,
-0.9553764462,
0.4875590801,
-0.3992533982,
-0.0723106638,
0.3313095272,
0.5251773596,
-0.6253886223,
-0.8394523263,
-0.7559579611,
-0.9314883947,
0.428152144,
0.4706608355,
0.0395678617,
-0.3237850666,
0.4132674634,
0.0548606813,
-0.0508572534,
-0.5773409605,
-0.1812190711,
-0.5203924179,
-0.579267621,
0.4353647232,
-0.1352920681,
-0.1095037088,
-0.0706017539,
0.6143565774,
-0.2464619875,
0.0153655875,
0.3500475287,
-0.0808904245,
0.4679344594,
0.3444431126,
0.1236930341,
0.4986396134,
0.0255769584,
0.5064405203,
0.4814830124,
-0.3687242866,
-0.2359990031,
0.0985000506,
-0.3904819787,
0.0440165251,
0.5859351158,
0.5520313978,
0.4806762934,
-0.3040927052,
0.6084199548,
0.2808492184,
-0.6053543687,
-0.1685605496,
-0.1397656351,
0.5883101821,
-0.1613107324,
0.1179861054,
-0.1206636056,
0.3455212116,
-0.1680256426,
0.2151394933,
0.291536212,
-0.3500679731,
0.2169869691,
0.3797800541,
0.3234030604,
0.3200670779,
0.3437942863,
-0.4915654063,
-0.3694862425,
0.8070343137,
0.4988405704,
0.7332755327,
0.318100512,
0.4437145591,
0.7489817739,
0.4158344269,
-0.1029361412,
-0.0648780838,
-0.0435833447,
-0.813831687,
-0.7611226439,
-0.4921071231,
-0.1844295859,
-0.2522233725,
-0.3369542956,
0.2150583267,
-0.2013286352,
0.354629308,
0.0126910321,
-0.0627961308,
-0.5333440304,
0.0202710833,
-0.2394594401,
0.81072402,
-0.7461182475,
0.419536978,
0.4134800732,
-0.3869917989,
-0.6839802265,
-0.1228355691,
-0.2923959494,
-0.5129726529,
0.5959572196,
-0.056954246,
-0.1230457351,
0.1725987494,
-0.5752788782,
-0.7866201997,
1.1261465549,
0.2085817307,
-0.1122846305,
0.2131272405,
0.1611146033,
0.3097183704,
-0.2799598575,
0.2092317194,
0.367025733,
0.6909843087,
0.409693867,
-0.6605688334,
0.6003041863,
0.0636207536,
-0.1446405053,
0.3229566216,
-0.3143704236,
0.4733463824,
-0.1524817795,
-0.5702912211,
-0.2041250914,
0.8735839725,
0.1638137847,
0.6404461265,
0.4070160687,
0.8172150254,
0.7968050241,
-0.2271358222,
0.7653433084,
0.028718546,
0.100756295,
0.9945017695,
-0.129847005,
0.7004631758,
0.2048107386,
-0.0539300293,
0.487147212,
0.4930291772,
0.3858611882,
0.2933567464,
0.1315303147,
-0.1812452227,
-0.3963178992,
-0.367127955,
-0.4283899367,
0.162347734,
0.5858912468,
-0.037896283,
-0.4808245897,
-0.143046841,
0.1406194419,
0.4108472466,
-0.4146368206,
0.8846981525,
-0.1325953454,
-0.5405613184,
0.4528293014,
-0.0743201226,
0.5692474842,
-0.6516396403,
-0.2329914719,
-0.1233768389,
-0.2084677517,
-0.4032617211,
-0.8541530371,
0.6649630666,
-0.381221205,
-0.0397551581,
-0.1014815345,
0.9988653064,
-0.7237115502,
-0.3669342995,
0.140413776,
0.4024484456,
0.010388202,
0.0318803005,
-0.226376608,
-0.4335926771,
-0.2686778307,
0.1147649288,
0.1262845993,
0.9670414925,
-0.0400888026,
0.3786494434,
0.4787441492,
-0.2005236298,
-0.1674594879,
0.0365778394,
0.8299517632,
-0.2672320008,
-0.5071102977,
-0.6878788471,
0.395182699,
-0.5114159584,
-0.0640461519,
0.8007293344,
0.7074126005,
0.7832487822,
0.1424003094,
0.6850515008,
-0.2327152193,
0.42219311,
-0.6445989013,
0.6787657738,
-0.3778902292,
-0.051892478,
-0.2024771869,
-0.4316860735,
-0.1845126301,
0.421379596,
-0.2777188122,
-0.3085523546,
0.9668527842,
0.86713624,
-0.1037760451,
0.2677333653,
0.244493112,
0.2212487012,
-0.2315663099,
0.5637049675,
0.793464303,
-0.3118867874,
0.6125017405,
-0.0009976864,
-0.1863545179,
0.2102359533,
-1.0005363226,
-0.9106511474,
-0.7707133889,
-0.6193736792,
-0.4552990794,
0.1567839533,
0.6374741793,
0.2667114735,
-0.610245347,
0.1749772877,
-0.2815583348,
0.5835548639,
-0.2154040188,
-0.3171136379,
0.6249109507,
-0.4701245427,
-0.6088091135,
-0.0019894287,
0.201829195,
0.0711743161,
0.1405879706,
-0.1447016746,
-0.2476850003,
-0.0716809183,
0.5361595154,
-0.1317843646,
-0.8411406875,
-0.4339503944,
-0.0915262252,
0.0526059978,
-0.4753510654,
0.9405485988,
-0.8016726971,
0.1950016022,
0.7292335033,
0.8609359264,
0.5267683268,
-0.2885865867,
0.3049456477,
-1.1080505848,
0.1440843195,
0.0613760389,
0.358605355,
0.3557883203,
-0.4538325369,
0.6898103356,
0.480843842,
-0.1197227016,
-0.5166245699,
0.4314296544,
-1.0235893726,
-0.4891598523,
1.2965049744,
-0.1397474557,
-0.1905536205,
-0.6978456378,
-0.0965867266,
0.4238060415,
-0.1789584756,
0.1700619757,
0.6066514254,
0.0280777644,
-0.1034133434,
-0.5525255203,
0.6768948436,
-0.023631217,
-0.6674965024,
0.2591712475,
0.4062367976,
0.1677654684,
0.0814127252,
0.6624988914,
-0.0629823431,
0.1255873442,
0.277667135,
-0.225248903,
-0.4642148614,
0.1412006468,
0.5590059161,
0.2869103551,
-0.4027794302,
-0.0743410289
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09664v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09664v4
|
CodeMind: A Framework to Challenge Large Language Models for Code Reasoning
| 2024-02-15T02:24:46 | 2024-04-03T06:23:48 |
Changshu Liu, Shizhuo Dylan Zhang, Ali Reza Ibrahimzada, Reyhaneh Jabbarvand
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.PL
|
Solely relying on test passing to evaluate Large Language Models (LLMs) for
code synthesis may result in unfair assessment or promoting models with data
leakage. As an alternative, we introduce CodeMind, a framework designed to
gauge the code reasoning abilities of LLMs. CodeMind currently supports three
code reasoning tasks: Independent Execution Reasoning (IER), Dependent
Execution Reasoning (DER), and Specification Reasoning (SR). The first two
evaluate models to predict the execution output of an arbitrary code or code
the model could correctly synthesize. The third one evaluates the extent to
which LLMs implement the specified expected behavior.
Our extensive evaluation of nine LLMs across five benchmarks in two different
programming languages using CodeMind shows that LLMs fairly follow control flow
constructs and, in general, explain how inputs evolve to output, specifically
for simple programs and the ones they can correctly synthesize. However, their
performance drops for code with higher complexity, non-trivial logical and
arithmetic operators, non-primitive types, and API calls. Furthermore, we
observe that, while correlated, specification reasoning (essential for code
synthesis) does not imply execution reasoning (essential for broader
programming tasks such as testing and debugging): ranking LLMs based on test
passing can be different compared to code reasoning.
|
[
-0.1795766503,
-0.4354725182,
0.8254781961,
0.3306280375,
0.1250506938,
0.225621894,
-0.3616825938,
-0.3003451824,
-0.2743189633,
0.5089637637,
-0.595405519,
-0.6116702557,
-0.4867349565,
0.1016920507,
-0.5526922345,
0.6938150525,
-0.3200094402,
0.1476648301,
-0.5707882047,
0.0447006375,
-0.7173532844,
-0.4775786102,
-0.3246409893,
-0.567055881,
0.393999815,
0.2736674249,
0.5265713334,
0.524995029,
0.6207810044,
0.2182661593,
0.097482577,
-0.0484900288,
-0.5006298423,
0.2659098208,
-0.0957176462,
-0.9221788645,
-0.2873927057,
-0.1114167646,
0.318875879,
0.6816796064,
-0.0674461499,
0.234320119,
-0.1359521747,
0.6201022267,
-0.6524643302,
0.4250348806,
-0.7131205797,
-0.0628370792,
0.030876724,
-0.1206173673,
-0.5657566786,
-0.5327883363,
-0.2947007418,
-0.127714172,
-0.1031794101,
0.0160561167,
0.3637405634,
0.4995532334,
-0.0899834558,
-0.3875040114,
-0.5122692585,
0.6764048338,
-0.8031807542,
0.2976178527,
0.2132841498,
0.3645447195,
-0.1070086658,
-0.526057899,
-0.6806380749,
-0.343917191,
0.0913663134,
-0.0199258644,
-0.082642287,
0.118578963,
0.5607312918,
0.3737360835,
-0.776242137,
-0.0026541008,
-0.2903331816,
-0.2565095127,
0.6825911999,
0.3547917604,
0.3152914643,
0.0806192905,
-0.1720702648,
-0.003662861,
-1.0843626261,
0.0661193952,
0.3473321497,
0.1237953901,
0.0132841524,
0.6268210411,
-0.1644016951,
0.8418794274,
-0.4352144003,
0.0455460139,
0.1304232478,
0.1210225597,
-0.348526001,
-0.1628730893,
0.6585831046,
0.2779882848,
0.4497122467,
-0.1459079832,
-0.4092201293,
0.481372416,
0.3019639552,
-0.7564111948,
-0.3843755424,
0.3870446086,
-0.4602225125,
-0.3050187528,
0.0724721923,
-0.3773048818,
-0.4458324611,
-0.3986195624,
0.352856189,
-0.4465580285,
-0.2274537832,
0.2724823654,
-0.2267677188,
0.4468435049,
0.3590062559,
-0.5782336593,
0.2275043279,
1.0706307888,
0.5742692351,
-0.5229526758,
-0.3320237398,
-0.2281319201,
-0.1378510892,
-0.6298871636,
0.7278508544,
-0.6998804808,
-0.1831454933,
-0.0568862744,
-0.2878061831,
-0.2155314833,
-0.7719202638,
0.1545349658,
-0.6458204389,
-0.210885942,
-0.0733506307,
-0.8652864099,
-0.093802765,
0.2661938369,
-0.4235021174,
0.7374765873,
0.1545413435,
-0.4908603728,
0.3572579622,
-0.548247695,
-0.6324362755,
0.200546667,
-0.6868444085,
0.0895854309,
0.1277308166,
-0.1189142689,
0.4102745354,
-0.4127284288,
0.2961695492,
-0.6016151905,
-0.797490716,
0.4781195521,
-0.267121315,
0.7381916046,
0.3280499279,
-0.6076593399,
0.1442189217,
-0.5682150722,
0.641215682,
0.0903383791,
-0.2709191442,
0.0174719449,
0.2026468962,
-0.3746361732,
0.0624791086,
-0.0575833209,
-0.1778964996,
0.3210822046,
-0.2488316745,
0.6320840716,
0.8125958443,
-0.0644199625,
0.2415952981,
-0.533189714,
0.7659133673,
-0.2202299982,
0.1101433784,
-0.2261802405,
-0.5939491391,
-0.7695263028,
-0.2418983579,
0.2413430214,
0.6712271571,
-0.638630271,
0.3483811021,
-0.329341501,
-0.4161244333,
-0.2797551751,
0.2575168014,
0.6027861834,
-0.0239490401,
0.0137685379,
-0.1550522149,
-0.5347200632,
-0.8158339262,
-0.5876458287,
-0.5264056921,
-0.1471067667,
0.2089029849,
0.5464291573,
-0.1780866534,
0.6945422888,
-0.6870396733,
-0.0339618996,
-0.5067777038,
-0.0968533754,
0.4788380563,
0.4680752754,
0.169622466,
-0.6705657244,
-0.1722156256,
-0.1989775598,
-0.7434960604,
-0.2519652247,
0.0091136852,
0.0737692118,
0.1889065802,
0.6496462226,
-0.488868922,
0.3720830977,
0.7311331034,
-0.2834940553,
0.617008388,
0.1119523868,
0.1078061834,
-0.4977460206,
0.0730352923,
-0.446469605,
-0.1760437191,
-0.2346115708,
0.6535862088,
0.230157271,
-0.1555957347,
-0.2152762264,
0.3627540767,
-0.245083347,
-0.1661865711,
-0.1412844211,
-0.3303785324,
-0.0520190485,
0.5500715971,
-0.0758203715,
1.0379379988,
0.5974479318,
-0.5867988467,
0.3023787141,
-0.1220735833,
-0.681253314,
0.2280895412,
-0.7157878876,
0.3670163155,
0.3292081654,
0.0791217983,
-0.8374922276,
-0.2516024113,
-0.084860906,
-0.6094411612,
0.2039539665,
-0.1743500531,
-0.6671054959,
-0.4405586123,
-0.1065535247,
0.3049016893,
0.8067732453,
-0.2412214726,
0.4513076544,
0.2827648222,
0.0327476896,
-0.3351790607,
-1.0077979565,
0.0746174753,
0.035660129,
-0.5070155859,
0.1204137504,
-0.4260577261,
-0.5720430017,
-0.0612065457,
-0.3343685269,
-0.2645539343,
0.1563725024,
0.4451797605,
0.2534922063,
-0.2172012776,
0.1181258336,
-0.1670538187,
0.1271036118,
0.575570941,
-0.3857653439,
0.4456017017,
-0.1638375372,
-0.7739959359,
-0.0103289923,
0.2463507056,
0.6486216784,
-0.1684034467,
0.3907184899,
0.0911026672,
-0.2858408988,
-0.8295019269,
-0.5517581105,
-0.0177693777,
-0.4556465149,
0.1909042597,
-0.7264387608,
-1.0293816328,
0.5432040691,
0.0137230819,
-0.0439137705,
0.2476554662,
0.8420758247,
0.0931845531,
1.1675423384,
0.4717078805,
0.0895028859,
0.0774014294,
-0.2533468902,
0.4303602874,
-0.5276257396,
-0.2082881778,
-0.3733429313,
-0.1013529301,
-0.4289702177,
-0.6466359496,
0.1591640711,
0.1333307922,
-0.166138947,
0.3954455554,
-0.5079180598,
0.6766113639,
0.3908942044,
0.0947026461,
0.2747789919,
-0.3373359442,
-0.4076243639,
0.1733372062,
-0.7030796409,
-0.4099268913,
1.1561326981,
0.2559093833,
1.173576355,
0.0847587883,
0.6678846478,
0.501010716,
0.4939101338,
-0.8444908261,
0.6317390203,
0.1220940575,
-0.6613898277,
-0.0308734197,
-0.7026197314,
-0.3405579627,
0.0082158027,
0.3982197344,
-0.6266727448,
-0.084955737,
0.104075253,
-0.2396826446,
0.1837235689,
-0.91093117,
0.8107197285,
-0.0492681935,
-0.219291389,
-0.1797316074,
-0.2013438344,
0.7130940557,
-0.0593328588,
0.3057495058,
-0.1282781512,
0.1228501722,
0.4840577841,
-0.495817095,
0.6933503151,
-0.015880147,
-0.3163928688,
0.4309827685,
0.6388780475,
0.239522323,
0.2144517601,
-0.1558226496,
0.1626814455,
0.1009303108,
-0.1950172037,
-0.8363301158,
0.7906182408,
-0.4894293845,
-0.8098059893,
-0.2317064255,
-0.6566433311,
-0.4301183522,
0.2730929852,
0.201336056,
0.4889997542,
0.0746177286,
0.061308004,
0.7287079096,
-0.1857442707,
0.1043434441,
0.1957232654,
-0.5166462064,
-0.2024886608,
0.7811441422,
-0.187179476,
0.5214753151,
0.2954693139,
-0.0022402357,
-0.169707045,
-0.6421591043,
-0.3184040785,
-0.0627115741,
-1.0943863392,
-0.4488114119,
-0.4808857441,
-0.414434433,
-0.3861692548,
-0.0821203738,
-0.2957171202,
-0.3168929219,
0.2646822631,
0.0469900668,
0.2390675992,
0.8900623322,
0.1946365088,
-0.3305882514,
-0.5178266168,
0.2799837887,
0.422097832,
0.721288383,
-0.0852072164,
-0.4586259127,
0.0165421888,
-0.1948409081,
-0.0898636729,
-0.7836265564,
-0.0403566621,
-0.0867596716,
0.5730215907,
0.2067957073,
0.1404732466,
0.5083737969,
-0.5237374306,
0.7075614929,
0.1020196676,
-1.272410512,
0.5213778615,
-0.2391695082,
0.4319521785,
0.5314923525,
-0.0989070684,
-0.2507237494,
-0.7367725968,
-0.2887370586,
-0.4080170691,
0.4199823141,
0.3585897088,
0.0718174949,
-0.0228674039,
0.3200059533,
-0.0021482834,
0.1712563336,
-0.7779877186,
-0.2676370442,
0.1613847762,
-0.2454915494,
0.1658318788,
-0.0401091352,
-0.1389282346,
-0.2871252,
0.2914229631,
-0.3262429237,
0.5495200157,
0.1862155497,
-0.28795591,
0.0763546452,
0.2116782516,
0.5913707614,
1.0529789925,
-0.0665062219,
0.2521679699,
0.0073411777,
-0.2484335899,
0.2222319692,
-0.1608451158,
-0.212634787,
-0.0784766749,
0.752866745,
0.5408515334,
0.2137066424,
-1.1198246479,
0.7907341123,
-0.092558071,
-0.5544719696,
-0.3950347602,
0.6284314394,
0.1850100756,
0.2007627487,
0.2544844151,
0.2609863877,
0.145168677,
-0.4877644479,
0.3250971735,
0.2455833256,
-0.4439122975,
-0.1060499102,
0.6309964061,
-0.0742345601,
-0.3150027692,
0.4824340343,
-0.4166752398,
-0.8158836365,
0.9310897589,
0.4916112125,
0.9452738762,
0.1997824162,
-0.0300540086,
0.1381155252,
0.4990770519,
-0.1055216864,
0.6069244742,
-0.0339986347,
-0.6746425629,
-0.8658479452,
-0.4275327325,
-0.5706381798,
-0.0031032285,
-0.6013424397,
0.2215099484,
-0.6290934682,
0.0873224065,
-0.1605814397,
-0.1968963295,
-0.8365080357,
0.044915244,
0.3283692598,
1.3026885986,
-0.4001244009,
0.880486846,
0.6717156768,
-0.2140323967,
-1.0239270926,
0.0800944865,
0.0854579657,
-0.9929827452,
0.7910166979,
0.4022266865,
-0.2103217095,
-0.1213484481,
-0.6577478051,
-0.6534980536,
0.8745161891,
0.4577564001,
-0.4966339767,
0.0223038606,
-0.000605514,
0.4474578798,
-0.4918006361,
0.350733906,
0.5137962699,
0.4596037269,
0.0691161677,
-0.765416801,
0.2307773978,
-0.357968539,
0.1660245508,
0.1066449136,
-0.4291293025,
0.8005515337,
-0.5762174129,
-0.2604332268,
0.1410184205,
0.2038888037,
0.5691415071,
0.0768771842,
0.5669513941,
0.5534109473,
0.5244471431,
-0.212525934,
1.3006560802,
-0.3913169503,
0.206991151,
1.0120961666,
-0.7498360872,
0.8665437698,
0.3614244461,
-0.5286692977,
0.5946230292,
0.3539708555,
-0.0763236135,
0.377545923,
0.7827260494,
0.0981856063,
-0.4340471625,
0.2716563344,
-0.356306076,
0.5802180171,
0.2953344584,
-0.2099352777,
0.0900172442,
-0.295134902,
-0.0922892168,
0.1432040781,
-0.0982811823,
0.5524873734,
0.2878409922,
-1.0361602306,
0.7554571033,
-0.0610859394,
0.4141589403,
-0.6017577052,
-0.2727115154,
-0.3208759725,
0.4591154456,
-0.1491772532,
-0.8024551272,
0.461327076,
0.1776693463,
-0.2003342807,
-0.3867164254,
0.5633484125,
-0.147039935,
-0.3252768815,
0.5110445619,
0.5387256145,
0.1078096926,
-0.2656900883,
-0.7501651645,
0.4854109287,
0.0876766667,
-0.1676356792,
0.1604521126,
0.4142502248,
0.152456373,
0.9449153543,
0.6877236962,
0.2371300459,
0.0385021977,
0.2869099677,
0.8732159138,
-0.682864964,
-0.4347952604,
-0.9979840517,
0.0468487069,
0.0213977266,
-0.253954649,
0.6658480763,
0.5698801279,
0.9797163606,
-0.0471843593,
0.91590029,
-0.1946937144,
0.3900481761,
-0.781249404,
0.6852453351,
-0.358073473,
0.5324044228,
-0.1953364313,
-0.9069016576,
-0.4801660776,
0.5410231948,
-0.2624928057,
0.0891834572,
1.026741147,
0.8806835413,
0.2175145745,
0.0224856641,
0.4726524651,
0.1366898417,
0.3984642625,
1.0181891918,
1.1943750381,
-0.2365810275,
0.5929466486,
0.0329478644,
-0.2748134136,
0.0845012888,
-0.8146166205,
-1.0596016645,
-0.17830275,
-0.2865712643,
-0.3857908547,
-0.0826625973,
0.7456972003,
0.7385433316,
-0.9853578806,
-0.4032206535,
-0.4990709424,
0.4571327865,
-0.4106230736,
-0.30391559,
-0.012208323,
-0.5880666971,
-0.3462882042,
0.4336423874,
0.4394172132,
-0.4676245749,
-0.5266258717,
-0.2243638337,
0.3104636371,
0.0845617801,
0.465872705,
-0.0073642842,
-0.8812078834,
-0.2118324041,
0.1620391607,
-0.3259977698,
-0.108923547,
1.2390458584,
-0.6873880625,
0.2986129522,
0.5698387623,
0.8719635606,
0.1107079312,
-0.4946962595,
0.8749780059,
-0.3551151156,
-0.1443753392,
0.3261281848,
0.4492073655,
0.0300224088,
-0.1878574491,
0.6182701588,
0.2139347345,
-0.5317773819,
-0.9367440343,
0.4050479233,
-0.573608458,
-0.4963727295,
1.2560371161,
-0.303822577,
-0.23363325,
0.0130584417,
0.1844808459,
-0.2409892082,
-0.1379087716,
0.534535706,
0.7266300917,
-0.1452051848,
-0.2610760331,
-0.7486131191,
0.5135047436,
0.4355262816,
-0.8936496377,
0.1307702363,
0.3940678239,
0.3355996311,
0.0016948644,
0.7237805128,
-0.2250719368,
0.3254254758,
0.0834739432,
0.1534032077,
-0.0974436402,
-0.2403652072,
-0.3820486963,
0.0980575308,
0.2561751902,
0.0968234614
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09654v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09654v2
|
GPT-4's assessment of its performance in a USMLE-based case study
| 2024-02-15T01:38:50 | 2024-03-26T20:12:18 |
Uttam Dhakal, Aniket Kumar Singh, Suman Devkota, Yogesh Sapkota, Bishal Lamichhane, Suprinsa Paudyal, Chandra Dhakal
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.MA, stat.ML
|
This study investigates GPT-4's assessment of its performance in healthcare
applications. A simple prompting technique was used to prompt the LLM with
questions taken from the United States Medical Licensing Examination (USMLE)
questionnaire and it was tasked to evaluate its confidence score before posing
the question and after asking the question. The questionnaire was categorized
into two groups-questions with feedback (WF) and questions with no feedback(NF)
post-question. The model was asked to provide absolute and relative confidence
scores before and after each question. The experimental findings were analyzed
using statistical tools to study the variability of confidence in WF and NF
groups. Additionally, a sequential analysis was conducted to observe the
performance variation for the WF and NF groups. Results indicate that feedback
influences relative confidence but doesn't consistently increase or decrease
it. Understanding the performance of LLM is paramount in exploring its utility
in sensitive areas like healthcare. This study contributes to the ongoing
discourse on the reliability of AI, particularly of LLMs like GPT-4, within
healthcare, offering insights into how feedback mechanisms might be optimized
to enhance AI-assisted medical education and decision support.
|
[
-0.2003931105,
-0.6657122374,
0.9334099293,
-0.0180822052,
-0.2402848899,
-0.046538353,
0.1811728626,
-0.5074337125,
-0.1833254099,
-0.088579163,
-0.3872289062,
-0.6138726473,
-0.4688618183,
0.5463706255,
-0.0502806678,
0.8774474263,
-0.155411765,
0.4952233136,
-0.2938931584,
0.0167089999,
-0.5680350661,
-0.7693616748,
-0.8428783417,
-0.3948984742,
0.524944663,
0.2202093452,
0.3878538311,
0.0544352457,
0.8082183003,
0.3223947287,
0.3240640461,
-0.3932169378,
-0.3082828522,
0.0382034481,
0.0265617743,
-0.6555464268,
-0.5422186852,
0.5878186822,
0.5833307505,
0.2539041936,
-0.3413879275,
0.2345397025,
0.1163494363,
0.3970379829,
-0.299947679,
0.084975183,
-0.2392617911,
0.0816581845,
-0.0648230314,
-0.4587829411,
-0.2111299783,
-0.6849898696,
0.4439797699,
-0.3462326229,
0.2317696512,
-0.024205802,
0.7991603613,
0.4858367145,
-0.1924114972,
-0.2588328421,
-0.5604119301,
0.4430367649,
-0.7452161908,
0.1127330139,
0.3714696765,
0.3021837771,
0.0729824081,
-0.8841418028,
-0.3174376488,
-0.6037609577,
0.150165081,
0.4404486418,
0.1447025239,
0.2707466781,
0.2300498039,
0.4075700343,
-0.5425653458,
0.0216018036,
-0.3255377412,
-0.3228263557,
0.4890692532,
0.0971076638,
0.1315029114,
0.1191364229,
-0.4393777847,
0.0648500025,
-0.6471150517,
0.1411294043,
0.0225954037,
-0.2019564062,
0.1424061507,
0.4042758346,
0.0420701094,
0.3905735016,
0.0797268152,
-0.2805399001,
0.332031548,
-0.4632839262,
-0.3719083667,
-0.143865943,
0.7295958996,
0.6034885645,
-0.0275841393,
-0.0802725032,
-0.2970464826,
0.264863193,
0.591830194,
-0.8230183721,
-0.073605381,
0.2454179525,
-0.3902987242,
-0.334451884,
0.2210715264,
-0.4824362099,
-0.0537212752,
-0.1266778708,
0.7189723849,
-0.3674740195,
-0.0609235317,
-0.2404816747,
-0.0275737178,
0.466524452,
0.3519703746,
-0.634606123,
0.5770941377,
0.5078116655,
0.7704973221,
-0.6465163231,
-0.178432554,
-0.2970368266,
-0.1976012588,
-0.4209523797,
0.5962455869,
-0.2275590897,
-0.8296531439,
-0.2038632184,
0.0533164702,
-0.1461339295,
-0.7473441362,
0.5153582692,
-0.410025835,
0.3234502375,
-0.3830716908,
-0.7462980151,
-0.234451279,
0.5673722625,
-0.4233956635,
0.781078279,
0.412962079,
-0.6119338274,
0.6866439581,
-0.7748203874,
-0.1056579202,
0.2160213292,
-0.6982374191,
-0.5859622955,
0.1334414482,
-0.0011532838,
0.3819225729,
-0.1295292228,
0.0302289221,
-0.038841892,
-0.8747005463,
0.2384767979,
-0.7038140297,
0.2282638848,
-0.2061863691,
-0.4604613185,
0.0322210416,
-0.5071943402,
0.2548391521,
-0.0479088277,
-0.4629864991,
0.0454271957,
-0.4519531131,
-0.4571039379,
0.0875450671,
0.2760621309,
-0.5063690543,
0.3730707765,
-0.0913274884,
0.125435546,
0.6758367419,
0.5334798098,
0.1895891577,
-0.4559226334,
1.043241024,
-0.0896126032,
0.660785675,
0.3166400194,
-0.8926854134,
-0.2400438786,
0.1876335144,
0.5348424315,
0.5431398153,
-0.802675426,
-0.0856332406,
0.1504267454,
-0.0843154564,
-0.6812195182,
0.0734978095,
0.3490224183,
0.7192044258,
0.3534050286,
-0.6135813594,
-0.0601365082,
-0.7412865162,
0.0885341093,
-0.5380791426,
-0.0903888494,
0.4415174425,
0.3673587739,
-0.2463665754,
0.4865779877,
-0.264596343,
-0.1158298105,
-0.1172134802,
0.2155861109,
0.216310963,
0.1306609958,
0.5213593245,
-0.6213757396,
-0.5138667822,
-0.343177855,
-0.6130839586,
-0.0666458234,
0.0627254248,
0.1258595437,
0.3286211193,
0.1229020208,
-0.4660440981,
0.671312511,
0.4825921059,
-0.1871919632,
0.7302836776,
-0.4146387875,
0.7093917727,
-0.5501900315,
0.0973500535,
-0.2446525693,
0.0831417888,
-0.4997296035,
-0.265345186,
-0.035431277,
0.3665951192,
-0.2471092045,
0.208193019,
-0.3539758027,
-0.1785261333,
-0.1267795861,
-0.0500681736,
0.0214611217,
0.3938697875,
-0.2100934386,
1.0661556721,
0.4641755521,
-0.5356860757,
0.2602155507,
0.0110132825,
0.0584464706,
0.9638850093,
-0.7072372437,
0.4046956897,
0.3734071851,
-0.0808404237,
-0.8746788502,
-0.2875823379,
0.2308224291,
-0.4852119684,
0.6584314108,
-0.0209748615,
-0.2138002068,
-0.6646433473,
-0.4976576567,
0.0779073983,
0.3942634165,
-0.0510753542,
0.2975579202,
0.0323023051,
-0.1978413165,
-0.4575749934,
-0.6135293245,
-0.0709393024,
-0.2735528946,
-0.3692058921,
0.188670516,
-0.3735001981,
-0.2587100565,
-0.0920775533,
-0.3196761012,
-0.4107307196,
0.0088586528,
0.369974196,
0.6205372214,
-0.1532876045,
0.0392642729,
-0.1650985926,
-0.1375922263,
0.2673268914,
0.041947227,
0.101878427,
-0.2729354799,
-0.6199936271,
-0.9514352679,
0.186964646,
0.5294721127,
0.3483228981,
0.3855263889,
0.3860382736,
-0.0099863326,
0.3770893216,
-0.5656142831,
-0.5899008512,
-0.447886318,
0.2568715215,
-0.2652299404,
-0.9100359678,
0.2083253264,
-0.0422953516,
0.0655213818,
0.4471624792,
0.7510650158,
-0.3109200001,
0.7730186582,
0.4010675848,
-0.0981322452,
0.0981464684,
-0.1959508806,
-0.1356389374,
-0.574998796,
-0.2721439302,
-0.2756229341,
-0.2530198991,
-0.5215297937,
-0.5041931272,
0.6823775172,
-0.139771834,
-0.1849911064,
-0.3646626472,
-0.5639933944,
0.1274650991,
0.5547693372,
0.1263533533,
0.4776532054,
-0.3990235925,
-0.3741442859,
-0.0402350836,
-0.5407497287,
-0.4763132632,
1.3534959555,
0.4383221269,
0.5363060832,
0.1570084989,
0.9008357525,
0.2092653066,
0.7681758404,
-0.8052968383,
0.3331750631,
0.2315397412,
-0.4793202281,
-0.4494695067,
-0.5133505464,
-0.9028550982,
0.0016185031,
-0.0436763167,
-0.4441408813,
-0.3596813679,
0.2077630907,
-0.6791175604,
-0.1438147724,
-0.8132459521,
0.5398268104,
-0.532432735,
-0.3001260757,
0.1395103037,
-0.7382864952,
0.1515937895,
-0.3724539578,
-0.116922304,
0.0848772824,
-0.2664745152,
0.531466186,
-0.5700005293,
0.5673649907,
-0.3974815011,
0.0756610185,
0.4243682623,
-0.2927780449,
0.243767038,
0.3398169577,
-0.161536485,
0.318385601,
0.1786621064,
-0.0970207453,
-0.8294167519,
0.6220450401,
-0.8298096061,
-0.7804833055,
-0.5674568415,
-0.2675157189,
-0.6662281156,
0.0585755855,
0.5047568083,
0.3945247233,
-0.2343883365,
-0.0848600715,
0.4249806702,
-0.1221746728,
0.3807204366,
0.6819038391,
-0.0268575642,
-0.2358305305,
0.3240933716,
0.3599496782,
0.27737391,
0.0901520997,
0.2462659776,
-0.7476292849,
-0.7299137712,
-0.5786778927,
0.3048731387,
-0.3450606465,
0.0035256026,
-0.0350001715,
-0.35924685,
-0.0783839673,
0.1658566594,
-0.1738085151,
-0.1803981662,
-0.2397785485,
-0.4023086429,
0.3856289983,
1.2479603291,
0.1263868064,
0.1109963879,
-0.5698266029,
-0.0775696188,
0.4465302527,
0.5855122805,
-0.4348990917,
-0.443503499,
-0.0265833829,
-0.2944175303,
-0.5373593569,
-0.9552294016,
-0.157640025,
0.0170408804,
0.792606473,
0.3246635199,
-0.1840204298,
0.2986958027,
-0.5700526834,
1.2742211819,
0.2263059467,
-0.5026005507,
0.456887871,
-0.1844457835,
0.2169398516,
0.7534239888,
0.5123096108,
0.1035468131,
-0.4376170337,
-0.7577776909,
-0.5871583819,
0.2554137111,
0.314168781,
-0.1144516245,
0.0710098892,
0.942477107,
-0.0903355926,
0.3289957345,
-0.5421444178,
-0.3937506974,
-0.2192073762,
0.0168763101,
0.0294903889,
-0.3417976201,
-0.222012803,
-0.2452948093,
0.4291504025,
-0.0015562883,
0.4578439295,
0.4276774526,
0.2913944423,
0.1835528165,
0.2711591125,
0.704605937,
0.8248081803,
-0.3243228495,
-0.0524295457,
0.2876621187,
-0.9472728372,
0.3840533197,
-0.1265367866,
0.0743970945,
-0.0169442445,
0.2883971035,
0.3123238683,
-0.0798294768,
-0.1540465057,
0.796977818,
-0.4420203269,
-0.5345754623,
-0.1120079756,
0.2366281897,
-0.1259538531,
0.0095740538,
0.3267278671,
-0.0169577636,
0.4112969339,
-0.3231575489,
0.6070988178,
0.1896297485,
-0.6782799363,
-0.3753241599,
0.5981773138,
0.1325920224,
-0.071077235,
0.4973287582,
-0.03634388,
-0.2699952722,
0.5158424377,
0.4433417618,
0.5598685145,
-0.6170087457,
0.2934719324,
0.3088982999,
0.2199749351,
-0.169734031,
0.5733960271,
0.1522813588,
-0.5232518911,
-0.4611501396,
-0.2223394364,
-0.721820116,
0.2579333186,
-0.9543498158,
-0.2444701642,
-0.6688417196,
-0.769269228,
-0.6585243344,
0.3323486745,
-0.7073801756,
0.5571910143,
-0.1712295115,
0.6831470728,
-0.4284948707,
0.6763640642,
0.6002811193,
-0.6679070592,
-1.4894948006,
0.2634687722,
0.2634566426,
-0.9615839124,
0.2336885929,
0.2017339915,
-0.2473178357,
-0.1275822222,
-0.3820046484,
-0.5472888947,
1.3961496353,
0.2844301462,
-0.3668364286,
0.2717237771,
0.0920895785,
0.7213534713,
-0.1047760323,
0.5367594957,
0.6593365073,
0.3660760224,
0.2613669038,
-1.1124548912,
0.0546840355,
-0.2868023515,
0.0059913979,
-0.1755331755,
-0.6033507586,
0.6112788916,
-0.3256606162,
0.1197805777,
0.0748819038,
0.1631927788,
0.3778630495,
0.3800364435,
0.35660097,
0.4694234729,
1.0436358452,
-0.1379402876,
1.3754858971,
-0.2597466707,
0.2418234795,
0.9107428789,
-0.3434205651,
0.8494123816,
0.5431264043,
-0.5245898962,
0.4577804804,
0.7149950266,
0.087939553,
0.4540741742,
0.2366113663,
-0.4544056654,
0.3513921201,
0.179082647,
-0.48291412,
0.429500401,
0.2328063697,
-0.3264103234,
0.1617480665,
-0.2950446308,
-0.1611467451,
-0.4427768886,
-0.3039753139,
0.795514524,
0.2731503248,
-0.7394391894,
0.4199337065,
-0.427225858,
0.3794748485,
-0.640854001,
-0.3253167868,
-0.3533471227,
-0.1450923085,
-0.2017397881,
-0.6441004872,
0.2199535072,
-0.0607542433,
-0.1381404549,
0.0330385976,
0.2741006613,
0.0539619476,
-0.1363402307,
0.2497632504,
0.49423787,
0.4343135059,
0.1440617442,
-0.7911157012,
-0.0924556777,
0.0363983549,
-0.3513577878,
0.2558635771,
0.3567126393,
0.0824558362,
0.5509004593,
0.4703786373,
0.2710900605,
-0.0460503101,
0.392488122,
0.5358259678,
-0.4285906255,
-0.2735309899,
-0.8520445824,
0.256608963,
-0.0460912772,
-0.2851202488,
0.7151348591,
0.2593540549,
0.2606470287,
0.138138324,
0.8619557619,
0.3883138299,
0.5822002888,
-0.5604538918,
0.6652723551,
-0.5123198628,
0.4578348398,
-0.3481453061,
-0.6005653739,
-0.3679044843,
0.6610078812,
-0.2929305434,
0.468305856,
0.8621702194,
0.64277035,
0.5739680529,
0.1677149385,
0.6524732709,
0.4327595532,
0.2611072958,
0.444696039,
0.845641315,
-0.1626853198,
0.3177581728,
0.010776028,
-0.5409088135,
-0.0229709875,
-0.6374832988,
-0.6815253496,
-0.1025734097,
-0.2710891962,
-0.3831261694,
-0.0659717694,
0.4881789684,
0.5942198038,
-0.7214927077,
0.1287889332,
0.106302835,
-0.2318737954,
-0.0371193849,
-0.1751659513,
0.5210987329,
-0.2232140303,
-0.4583640993,
0.3573857248,
0.5396763086,
0.3034759164,
-0.2067935616,
-0.1765071899,
0.2296600044,
-0.0644287691,
0.1051910222,
-0.0223985035,
-0.6662874222,
-0.4400377572,
0.176164493,
-0.2363862693,
0.2940376401,
0.6000052691,
-0.4843009412,
0.4279161096,
-0.0841733813,
0.5290325284,
0.3398162127,
0.4341591597,
0.8248353601,
-0.6133036017,
-0.1672923416,
0.3229905367,
0.3797491491,
0.2741161287,
-0.7473564744,
0.5563486814,
0.4266412556,
-0.998015523,
-0.2078357488,
-0.1621222049,
-0.7849368453,
0.07426247,
1.0848808289,
-0.3948474824,
0.2147919983,
-0.4608887732,
-0.2565517128,
0.0429841727,
-0.4252882898,
0.6253845096,
0.7366229892,
-0.8268282413,
-0.0876066089,
-0.950240612,
0.7645856738,
0.3122431338,
-0.7442332506,
-0.7841377854,
0.426818192,
0.7751456499,
0.1259514242,
1.3177342415,
-0.3170865774,
0.5134035349,
-0.0763617232,
-0.1845270246,
0.0957297385,
-0.0884740055,
-0.5442445874,
0.3937671781,
0.4148755968,
-0.4352921844
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09642v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09642v1
|
Answer is All You Need: Instruction-following Text Embedding via Answering the Question
| 2024-02-15T01:02:41 | 2024-02-15T01:02:41 |
Letian Peng, Yuwei Zhang, Zilong Wang, Jayanth Srinivasa, Gaowen Liu, Zihan Wang, Jingbo Shang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This work aims to build a text embedder that can capture characteristics of
texts specified by user instructions. Despite its tremendous potential to
deploy user-oriented embeddings, none of previous approaches provides a
concrete solution for it. This paper offers a new viewpoint, which treats the
instruction as a question about the input text and encodes the expected answers
to obtain the representation accordingly. Intuitively, texts with the same
(implicit) semantics would share similar answers following the instruction,
thus leading to more similar embeddings. Specifically, we propose InBedder that
instantiates this embed-via-answering idea by only fine-tuning language models
on abstractive question answering tasks. InBedder demonstrates significantly
improved instruction-following capabilities according to our proposed
instruction awareness tests and instruction robustness tests, when applied to
both large language models (LLMs) (e.g., llama-2-7b) and smaller encoder-based
LMs (e.g., roberta-large). Additionally, our qualitative analysis of clustering
outcomes, achieved by applying different instructions to the same corpus,
demonstrates a high degree of interpretability.
|
[
-0.2320288122,
-0.866903007,
0.9441826344,
-0.0661289692,
-0.063008301,
0.0074554123,
0.05387979,
-0.213973105,
0.0240603238,
0.6221052408,
-0.4674050808,
-0.643548131,
-0.7032732964,
-0.0576346852,
-0.5119507909,
0.9606841803,
-0.2671373785,
0.0344062261,
-0.6600258946,
0.048417449,
-0.5377367735,
-0.3050571084,
-0.2171175778,
0.0250400063,
0.3150469363,
0.6605061293,
0.677272439,
0.8505381346,
0.0935419798,
0.210742712,
0.0150830001,
0.0305625368,
-0.2210821807,
0.1436765045,
0.0083208857,
-0.5267025232,
-0.0175201185,
-0.1972953975,
0.7006382942,
0.546228826,
-0.004370416,
0.1141032428,
0.4150543511,
0.0657075793,
-0.5337780118,
-0.0532675087,
-0.2860354781,
-0.1143653169,
0.2682781518,
-0.2107669115,
-0.5405025482,
-0.7670913935,
0.2086521089,
-0.3218539059,
-0.1236495972,
0.0134100765,
0.537771225,
0.3937834203,
-0.2902920842,
-0.8242449164,
-0.4192388058,
0.636552453,
-0.6401827335,
0.3047995567,
0.5238794684,
0.3305046856,
0.1096484289,
-0.6293631792,
-0.4606005847,
0.0718885586,
-0.3259315789,
0.2276788205,
0.0132795088,
0.0600279756,
-0.0554476157,
0.192700386,
-0.5297352076,
-0.0875412375,
-0.1624180377,
0.0727970302,
0.2300941199,
0.1608861387,
0.5158115625,
-0.033308249,
-0.4452889562,
-0.0375371575,
-0.5484676361,
0.1719860137,
0.1422231495,
-0.1038514525,
-0.0810374618,
0.687220633,
0.1297220588,
0.5848966241,
0.0712610185,
0.3650623858,
-0.0238948427,
-0.1871713102,
0.0659722164,
0.2276016027,
0.4697727859,
0.2231534123,
0.1776926816,
-0.2893081903,
-0.166446507,
-0.2099475712,
0.316752404,
-1.1051478386,
-0.1835494339,
0.3087121844,
-0.3538849354,
-0.2090245485,
0.1910460293,
-0.7473447323,
-0.17996189,
0.0177405141,
0.6469535232,
-0.5180549622,
0.2202019393,
0.1163406223,
-0.0814259872,
0.7042657137,
0.3661827445,
-1.1008431911,
0.5118761063,
0.8965088129,
0.6424969435,
-0.0244127437,
-0.1275513172,
-0.637146771,
0.3422968388,
-0.3037717044,
0.8040724993,
-1.0885558128,
-0.4963915944,
0.1562719047,
0.0079871956,
-0.0915363431,
-0.2376696169,
0.002641601,
-0.7344912291,
0.4548506439,
-0.2643612921,
-1.1886396408,
-0.2899169028,
0.4251868725,
-0.3009213209,
0.9096608162,
-0.0897538364,
-0.6957464814,
-0.1399593353,
-0.6248782873,
-0.1425994933,
-0.0332465917,
-0.357231766,
-0.1581789851,
0.1705983877,
0.3035908937,
0.4610139132,
-0.0174151659,
-0.3733779192,
-0.1933539808,
-0.7263192534,
0.3194524646,
-0.412432611,
0.6386178136,
-0.2249981761,
-0.1746388227,
0.0526136681,
-0.4688524604,
0.2436259687,
-0.0832880214,
-0.4273452461,
-0.4737550914,
0.0888277292,
-0.2993231714,
-0.1974010617,
0.6858516932,
-0.73332268,
0.198374182,
-0.3730421066,
0.2146096826,
0.8424744606,
0.4437295794,
0.6083626747,
-0.2480767667,
0.737757206,
-0.2579009831,
-0.0674918294,
-0.618317008,
-0.6933888197,
-0.6377750635,
-0.1187215447,
0.2204767019,
0.8605357409,
-0.4716617167,
0.1598723084,
-0.1430102289,
-0.2170944661,
-0.8888198137,
0.1812120378,
0.7333126068,
0.5094900131,
0.5094572306,
0.0547222421,
-0.2359738946,
-0.663079679,
-0.1451672912,
-0.1488756984,
-0.09706375,
0.33284536,
0.4317052066,
-0.245971337,
0.6917541623,
-0.8243946433,
0.3133719265,
-0.1857972443,
-0.0398652628,
-0.0948025137,
0.4887191951,
0.341778934,
-0.5712939501,
-0.8070640564,
0.2137130052,
-0.8880198002,
0.1157403663,
0.1739089787,
-0.3059394956,
-0.1334060729,
0.8210895061,
-0.3171976507,
0.4363898337,
0.4705557227,
-0.1957781613,
0.1816738844,
-0.3285798728,
0.2469997406,
-1.2872784138,
-0.3861332536,
-0.2922614217,
-0.2090480477,
-0.5516608357,
0.316794306,
0.1862618327,
-0.1341615021,
-0.3735121489,
0.3988845646,
-0.3611756563,
-0.0686081797,
-0.2611111104,
0.1566636115,
0.1142481938,
0.4890552759,
-0.0744362324,
1.0703494549,
0.452508986,
-0.4917888045,
0.0637842491,
0.6432701349,
-0.2345241606,
0.3370183408,
-1.0021241903,
0.5338485241,
-0.4923057556,
-0.0198911522,
-1.3183051348,
-0.1746060103,
0.3884441853,
-0.4716880918,
0.2450842559,
-0.40946576,
-0.5261882544,
-0.0313674659,
-0.4808937013,
0.2146476358,
0.8586536646,
-0.5667426586,
0.7294254899,
0.1437604129,
-0.3283415437,
-0.4875249267,
-0.6659894586,
-0.2414183021,
-0.1016592085,
-0.3582723737,
0.2378181368,
-0.3220667839,
0.0571819805,
0.3901770711,
-0.0518834814,
-0.291837275,
0.0085895555,
0.2543628812,
0.23186481,
-0.3949339688,
0.2395452708,
0.6178281903,
-0.14796637,
0.1603809595,
-0.3984621763,
0.3370880783,
-0.0725528076,
-0.4731674492,
-0.5560160875,
0.894241631,
0.1939709038,
-0.4729602039,
0.6543918848,
0.3150182962,
-0.3541844785,
-0.1314682364,
-0.1750264913,
-0.2726565897,
-0.5087750554,
0.3125929236,
-0.3097378016,
-0.9490420818,
0.2602923512,
-0.0006181924,
0.4750635028,
-0.1076994836,
0.4010399282,
-0.7090656757,
1.2014763355,
0.8181809187,
0.1674273759,
0.3608843088,
-0.0605042838,
0.0344739072,
-0.6806896329,
-0.1642735749,
-0.579199791,
-0.2658343315,
-0.5350646973,
-0.437998265,
0.2070223093,
-0.0460790917,
-0.2323036045,
0.4353467524,
-0.5187221766,
0.7137663364,
0.4993650913,
0.1350355893,
-0.0119041419,
-0.1025375724,
0.0233723745,
0.0372906253,
-0.5811943412,
-0.9471389055,
0.8988036513,
0.2236337811,
0.8445836902,
0.1174308211,
1.0846438408,
-0.0096807089,
0.5095330477,
-0.6151405573,
0.5170585513,
-0.2021695971,
-0.4287509322,
-0.1779965013,
-0.1505190283,
-0.7321224213,
0.126075983,
-0.0918143243,
-0.8924845457,
0.0002400861,
0.3208361566,
-0.484698534,
0.0396400206,
-1.018025279,
0.9864616394,
-0.0256656799,
-0.0641404688,
-0.0386384316,
-0.5731118917,
-0.0924665928,
0.3027371466,
-0.0234976113,
0.3402869403,
-0.5284781456,
0.5345095396,
-0.1654510498,
1.0217704773,
-0.2069733739,
-0.0795293376,
0.5966252089,
-0.0782287419,
0.4194279909,
-0.0512995124,
-0.0730762929,
-0.457995832,
0.1711412817,
-0.3979839087,
-1.1757514477,
0.9058237076,
-0.7193101048,
-0.7233734131,
0.0119186938,
-0.4916057885,
-0.2705805898,
0.1114915982,
0.0810630098,
0.8174072504,
-0.2547377944,
0.1523704827,
1.2759904861,
-0.2339123785,
0.4534468055,
0.2128259093,
-0.25035882,
-0.1921319216,
1.0097007751,
-0.0380135551,
0.2742158771,
0.9467146993,
0.269338429,
-0.48015517,
-0.4514225423,
-0.8209062815,
0.1528291106,
-0.8894206285,
-0.0506818742,
-0.9464893341,
-0.1248144358,
-0.016002804,
-0.5045816898,
-0.0871825665,
-0.1940979958,
-0.5768746138,
-0.2947800756,
0.4379104972,
0.9677531719,
0.6661561131,
0.4927514195,
-0.953882575,
0.1345598698,
0.6310465336,
0.247524336,
0.0739247277,
-0.5346026421,
-0.189696759,
0.1910610795,
-0.2583447695,
-1.2460464239,
-0.0937323421,
0.2074596584,
0.4629641175,
0.3199558556,
0.0903474987,
0.6333661079,
-0.7010701299,
0.5201542377,
-0.2673965394,
-0.8729797602,
0.67765522,
0.0132593773,
0.3383687735,
0.6576333046,
0.7265552282,
-0.2563611269,
-0.5786274076,
-0.3860602677,
-0.5031018257,
0.4387302101,
-0.0198501945,
0.7463116646,
-0.2025254965,
0.5503607988,
0.1680467129,
0.0765958577,
-0.2811800838,
-0.1301980615,
-0.2351759523,
-0.7201476097,
0.0751447827,
-0.3426346779,
0.038969405,
0.0194108039,
0.3094525337,
-0.0678877756,
0.4214265347,
0.0351365842,
-0.2776122689,
0.3544745743,
0.3772270679,
0.1936756819,
0.336346209,
-0.1735759079,
0.1923694015,
0.3651802242,
-0.4484995008,
0.0983763114,
0.0284926072,
-0.4268448353,
-0.1262006462,
0.3185510635,
0.4699421525,
0.576452136,
-0.7840106487,
0.7909644842,
-0.1139615774,
0.0479291081,
-0.3069867492,
0.2861538231,
0.4050428867,
0.0584066957,
0.1084848121,
-0.0923422053,
0.2466024607,
-0.5365976095,
0.3672133684,
0.1873835772,
-0.9916126132,
-0.3060325384,
0.5359858274,
0.167571485,
-0.3936504722,
0.4719776511,
-0.2762772441,
-0.4635026455,
0.5325468779,
0.7985157967,
0.6897504926,
-0.2157523334,
0.1971409619,
0.1271268725,
0.220154196,
0.2805659473,
0.5268186331,
-0.2206900716,
-0.5637773275,
-0.4200944602,
-0.2253306806,
-0.6344399452,
-0.5744869709,
-0.8576458693,
0.0677202344,
-0.6578296423,
0.4805328846,
-0.1400363892,
-0.2690791786,
-0.4935599566,
-0.0095479712,
-0.0734926239,
0.9056025743,
-0.6218691468,
0.6703921556,
1.098485589,
-0.3529390395,
-0.6134738922,
0.2634934187,
-0.0795499235,
-0.8063467145,
-0.0363608003,
0.4381667972,
-0.2224574089,
0.3393992782,
-0.7353426218,
-0.4670667648,
1.2082335949,
0.2451204956,
-0.1401288956,
-0.0133111263,
-0.1921364963,
0.3335773349,
-0.6147584319,
0.4087016881,
0.4136779308,
0.1231376454,
0.0920618176,
-0.120069325,
0.0907177478,
-0.2797261477,
-0.0793913156,
0.2632610798,
-0.2183393538,
0.403917104,
-0.3805762529,
-0.3516405225,
0.1981751472,
0.9850488305,
-0.0280672461,
0.1249497086,
0.291826725,
0.5001727343,
0.6386237144,
0.3174136281,
1.3196210861,
-0.2371713221,
-0.1235699654,
1.1472938061,
0.1760369092,
1.208237052,
0.3428156972,
0.0883630961,
0.8359113932,
0.1941189468,
0.3118935525,
0.6722759008,
-0.0472740196,
-0.3384898305,
-0.2047741413,
-0.0901481956,
-0.2361166477,
0.3970005512,
0.4073113799,
-0.2518984973,
-0.2641812563,
-0.0296085812,
0.0863107666,
0.5803754926,
-0.2566245794,
0.9239690304,
-0.0556352884,
-0.3706553578,
0.266985029,
-0.0706098527,
0.6043670177,
-0.5353326797,
-0.5152344704,
-0.1146356016,
-0.1906235516,
-0.0738280788,
-1.1291892529,
0.370303601,
0.3303775191,
-0.246015057,
-0.4087860584,
0.450707972,
-0.4844013453,
-0.449737519,
0.0938331187,
0.5246596932,
0.2399041057,
0.2151472867,
-0.3013637364,
-0.0386683494,
0.1173293069,
-0.0331142843,
0.2836316824,
0.5652095675,
0.0602886565,
0.6150306463,
0.3873727322,
-0.5582383871,
0.2482987344,
-0.0978590325,
0.9120531082,
-0.575322628,
-0.4867447913,
-0.6385627389,
0.6028948426,
0.0958806723,
-0.3593347073,
0.6974635124,
0.394200623,
0.7586784959,
-0.0188729614,
0.7470206022,
0.0774409845,
0.51527071,
-0.399271369,
0.6053489447,
-0.3663935959,
0.2173985839,
-0.2454336286,
-0.7862608433,
-0.0492970198,
0.6064779758,
-0.2778224945,
-0.1966493428,
0.5494360924,
0.8554563522,
-0.1679550111,
0.2818988264,
0.1699551642,
0.0393613279,
0.0215429924,
0.6156802773,
0.9456409216,
-0.4928669333,
0.759772718,
0.0237143077,
-0.4698452353,
0.0311478395,
-0.5810223818,
-0.947193861,
-0.494585067,
-0.2953460813,
-0.0520992465,
0.2303662151,
0.8485820293,
0.3262045383,
-0.8108071089,
-0.0127614401,
-0.0335661545,
0.3028706312,
-0.282523185,
-0.116881907,
0.4058921039,
-0.335526675,
-0.7815566659,
0.3003399074,
0.1950491667,
0.2654765844,
-0.0916306973,
-0.1105143875,
-0.0397879183,
0.3557150364,
0.5037958622,
0.1434461176,
-0.4306257665,
-0.6742876172,
0.3962658048,
-0.3200773001,
-0.0911759287,
0.5833454132,
-0.4992488325,
0.4754594862,
0.5180376768,
1.3602082729,
0.4624839425,
0.0990426391,
0.5201256275,
-0.7276358604,
-0.2149922699,
0.2534083724,
0.0424404144,
0.2991175056,
-0.3706758022,
-0.0784551948,
-0.5254024863,
-0.3631869555,
-0.4142323732,
0.2475408018,
-0.7915197611,
-0.1898562163,
0.7796133757,
-0.585616231,
-0.2358243912,
-0.2594780624,
-0.2316516042,
-0.0281397086,
-0.3941544294,
0.5141494274,
0.5921539068,
-0.0489564501,
-0.5752660036,
-0.5929168463,
0.026243886,
0.3199546933,
-0.8501092792,
-0.1704605222,
0.1697318107,
0.2679697573,
-0.0646654516,
0.5878582597,
-0.2073787749,
0.3460912704,
0.0367792547,
-0.1546307504,
-0.0867584571,
-0.3200363219,
-0.3278715611,
0.231883347,
0.0073122559,
-0.6500652432
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09631v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09631v5
|
Representation Surgery: Theory and Practice of Affine Steering
| 2024-02-15T00:20:30 | 2024-06-25T13:00:08 |
Shashwat Singh, Shauli Ravfogel, Jonathan Herzig, Roee Aharoni, Ryan Cotterell, Ponnurangam Kumaraguru
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Language models often exhibit undesirable behavior, e.g., generating toxic or
gender-biased text. In the case of neural language models, an encoding of the
undesirable behavior is often present in the model's representations. Thus, one
natural (and common) approach to prevent the model from exhibiting undesirable
behavior is to steer the model's representations in a manner that reduces the
probability of it generating undesirable text. This paper investigates the
formal and empirical properties of steering functions, i.e., transformation of
the neural language model's representations that alter its behavior. First, we
derive two optimal, in the least-squares sense, affine steering functions under
different constraints. Our theory provides justification for existing
approaches and offers a novel, improved steering approach. Second, we offer a
series of experiments that demonstrate the empirical effectiveness of the
methods in mitigating bias and reducing toxic generation.
|
[
-0.3538123667,
-0.7029410601,
0.5300860405,
0.1522573382,
0.0079775732,
-0.3811228573,
-0.3008698821,
-0.1392784119,
0.1127114818,
0.5139266849,
-0.517403841,
-0.5271551609,
-0.6443800926,
-0.096287787,
-0.848454535,
0.9882929325,
0.1408180147,
0.4723037481,
0.0217724741,
-0.3474556804,
-0.3615256548,
-0.5277277231,
-0.3706944883,
-0.5078648925,
0.3913244009,
0.2366361171,
1.1886948347,
1.0835059881,
0.1183352545,
0.3321031928,
-0.1914777905,
-0.186641708,
-0.3078588247,
0.3495771289,
-0.3007631302,
-0.6628719568,
0.0239785574,
0.0028920332,
0.536123991,
1.1120882034,
-0.6138080359,
-0.5909186602,
0.1108411998,
0.8502372503,
-0.4774197936,
-0.0579498224,
-0.624699235,
0.1020636037,
0.0082161101,
-0.1028652415,
-0.3685154915,
-0.4530104697,
0.3112907112,
-0.7177917957,
-0.0211169794,
0.0729713216,
0.6702743173,
0.3154830039,
-0.7207152247,
-0.4743338525,
-0.921570003,
0.5953810811,
-0.638451457,
0.4691469669,
0.3209960461,
0.139294222,
-0.2238289118,
-0.3445009589,
-0.2574719489,
-0.484482795,
-0.1296284795,
-0.4491971731,
-0.5639132261,
0.5724018216,
0.314592272,
-0.0231609885,
-0.2491342574,
0.0749438554,
-0.4823868871,
-0.2516926229,
0.7567816973,
0.1545338333,
0.486618191,
-0.2571783364,
-0.4638105333,
-0.1938202679,
-0.9731589556,
-0.1955671757,
0.5527771115,
0.334646523,
0.1215262339,
0.5895743966,
-0.2008300573,
0.5840159059,
0.2070582509,
0.2613446116,
0.007517451,
-0.0058300057,
-0.2783470452,
0.050476674,
0.6002753973,
0.5103814006,
0.4188314676,
-0.1240496114,
-0.2813378274,
0.2675045431,
0.7235951424,
-0.4440480471,
-0.2295796573,
0.0073464909,
-0.8784990907,
-0.6711518168,
-0.2453313172,
-0.7283722758,
-0.7066260576,
-0.4869229198,
0.2156309932,
-0.7330147624,
-0.3757157326,
0.1154532656,
-0.0793914199,
-0.0909163728,
0.1199996024,
-1.2725141048,
0.6566594243,
0.710062325,
0.5818949938,
-0.1902016401,
-0.0331533551,
-0.1683975309,
0.1932779849,
-0.5789949298,
0.5376343131,
-0.5781389475,
-0.511094749,
0.4101414382,
-0.1426920742,
-0.0802551061,
-0.6635001898,
0.4952899516,
0.00872094,
-0.2064984739,
-0.4078554213,
-0.3962228298,
-0.5022728443,
-0.1040800884,
-0.5313621759,
0.5283014774,
-0.1171224266,
-0.3215397894,
0.193123728,
-0.7110645771,
-0.7397950888,
-0.5520572066,
-0.2303682715,
-0.2060335428,
0.519590795,
0.1255656779,
0.3958448768,
-0.0062250393,
0.3988250792,
-0.0681742281,
-0.0754405558,
0.2680186927,
-0.4727834463,
0.7594107389,
0.3273969591,
-0.3254211843,
0.5049978495,
-0.6056483984,
-0.4042637944,
-0.1334134787,
-0.0093352208,
-0.8861714005,
0.3790654838,
-0.0052319192,
0.1079250202,
-0.2635940015,
-0.7317066789,
0.3101705015,
-0.5681319833,
0.6152806282,
0.7077686787,
0.2431062013,
1.1523483992,
-0.3422724307,
0.4035453796,
0.053284429,
0.1963254511,
0.3955754638,
-0.4902275801,
-1.0844837427,
0.3544989526,
0.0101386569,
0.3738591373,
-0.9902459979,
-0.2491760701,
0.1287324876,
-0.3807269931,
-0.4754814804,
0.0366466455,
0.5198327303,
0.4148589075,
0.2717423439,
0.0257515311,
-0.5810712576,
-1.1152454615,
-0.2470947057,
-0.3397821486,
0.1959175318,
0.0961139873,
0.2549517155,
-0.0349963456,
0.5639623404,
-0.3977313936,
-0.2820416391,
0.1738946438,
0.3336873651,
-0.1171497852,
0.7522267103,
0.8927793503,
-0.8230050206,
-0.0797740221,
-0.017197514,
-0.6622728109,
-0.3052683473,
-0.2256061882,
-0.2863495648,
0.6648970246,
0.7696408033,
-0.6792778373,
0.7698940635,
0.4889754057,
-0.3292682767,
0.4676426053,
-0.2802369595,
0.0295048524,
-0.3767359257,
0.1013069749,
0.2046148479,
-0.1915068626,
-0.9199696779,
0.167958945,
0.1283623874,
-0.1644227058,
-0.2197308093,
0.3323739767,
-0.4648207724,
0.1974691898,
-0.3061848581,
-0.1818227321,
-0.4319011569,
0.4967259467,
0.2201256901,
0.4167549312,
0.4108116925,
-0.9119613171,
0.0473642312,
0.5617157817,
0.1797924191,
0.9256600738,
-0.5157545805,
-0.2241181135,
-0.4054219425,
-0.3622071743,
-1.1368346214,
0.4295743108,
0.4313253164,
-0.5548920631,
0.5884532928,
-0.3081249595,
0.1563575864,
-0.0821501389,
0.0070984955,
-0.2250832915,
0.5079650879,
-0.1129845977,
0.4127480984,
0.5082051158,
-0.3457912505,
-0.5139160156,
-0.8350179791,
-0.1290726513,
-0.2102177739,
-0.4533733428,
0.5086048245,
0.1871394962,
-0.4453134835,
0.2491636425,
-0.3612061441,
0.0226457659,
-0.0871323049,
0.2019270658,
0.1676088125,
-0.1361676157,
0.157554388,
0.5026668906,
-0.3754615486,
0.2314222753,
-0.2100885957,
0.3463506401,
0.3405260146,
-0.3106082976,
-0.1773541123,
0.6760833859,
0.5865641832,
-0.0081017772,
0.5023991466,
0.2259316444,
-0.4789662063,
-0.1954189092,
-0.3600772917,
-0.4525761306,
-0.5212575793,
0.7354227901,
-0.0531600118,
-0.6030805111,
0.4307072759,
0.07255885,
0.1651187241,
0.3805165887,
0.5066459775,
-0.1551354229,
1.5203113556,
0.6474479437,
-0.0025203854,
0.5921637416,
-0.0790646598,
0.0586909726,
-0.7377998233,
-0.3844977319,
-0.745672822,
-0.406930685,
-0.6779375672,
-0.224585861,
0.541875124,
-0.2227893174,
-0.4693594575,
0.2157737762,
-0.6343179941,
0.0203196052,
0.5564742684,
-0.009645883,
0.0886033624,
0.1280211657,
-0.5673494339,
-0.2619130909,
-0.8137540817,
-0.4467176795,
1.0336257219,
0.4923112988,
0.9653385878,
-0.0302566048,
0.4709683359,
0.1004045159,
0.446180582,
-0.800357461,
0.5733835101,
-0.4916373491,
-0.7238342166,
-0.3518278599,
-0.219001919,
-0.7728511095,
0.360096544,
-0.4225801826,
-0.8002976775,
0.5113745928,
0.4446522593,
-0.1072942019,
0.5390856266,
-0.4550342858,
0.452622354,
-0.265632093,
-0.4484579265,
-0.3574482501,
-0.6215701103,
0.2214632481,
0.502104342,
0.1548556387,
0.1808205098,
-0.1937735975,
0.6484727859,
-0.4750029445,
0.8128894567,
-0.7322280407,
-0.1519654244,
-0.0529261567,
0.7030712366,
0.564234376,
-0.3009224832,
-0.0670719147,
0.1209911779,
0.074204661,
0.0521250516,
-0.820961237,
0.6624637842,
-0.6772031188,
-0.7198703289,
-0.5522012115,
-0.6058771014,
-0.3185307086,
-0.034046188,
0.1820684522,
0.2104514092,
-0.3821139336,
0.0146710863,
0.5954325199,
-0.2558510005,
0.5268543363,
0.4056477249,
-0.3263280988,
-0.36683321,
0.6648154855,
0.1052598283,
0.3288096786,
0.1530530453,
0.1037144065,
-0.4040453732,
-1.0398719311,
-0.3394452333,
0.1176130846,
-0.6303237081,
-0.2338544279,
-0.3829764426,
-0.1769237667,
-0.2860026956,
-0.1126067787,
-0.4453459978,
-0.6697655916,
-0.2639906406,
-0.1710361987,
0.2591368854,
1.1562105417,
-0.3583474457,
0.6039324403,
-0.4018013179,
-0.0334898047,
0.0947105885,
0.3494153917,
0.2021948546,
-0.125578329,
0.1435946077,
0.4205224812,
-0.4788742363,
-1.0845845938,
0.8191351295,
0.0636292472,
0.8805702329,
0.6281930208,
-0.1227031201,
0.5505434275,
-0.6718459725,
0.3272333741,
0.2546827495,
-1.0834207535,
0.303496331,
-0.4727184176,
-0.1990620494,
0.3898709714,
0.5990722775,
-0.9924944639,
-0.4471636117,
-0.3883329034,
-0.7257179618,
0.6099462509,
0.3476406932,
0.2837416828,
0.0815794989,
0.5771941543,
0.013771168,
0.468988657,
-0.4319003224,
-0.715143919,
-0.4306911826,
-0.257430464,
0.0839132816,
-0.4351674318,
-0.2882025838,
-0.2939370871,
0.778724432,
-0.1063929424,
0.5207387805,
0.1610156298,
-0.1795179695,
-0.1609582007,
0.0902015418,
1.0264780521,
0.297488302,
0.0179866701,
0.0896302462,
-0.2294238657,
-0.5093305111,
0.4276249111,
0.0591763631,
-0.4960985482,
-0.0283590443,
0.0020617901,
0.9020552635,
0.4346168339,
-0.0593260303,
0.494792223,
0.1930237263,
-0.3182059824,
-0.0246444158,
-0.059427131,
0.0318468213,
0.1162063479,
0.5214987993,
0.6084570289,
0.4184338748,
-0.1715296507,
0.3536153436,
0.6976212859,
-0.6608791351,
-0.2928334773,
0.7242527604,
0.5101100206,
-0.320738852,
0.6022418141,
0.0204917211,
-0.5063532591,
0.4935068488,
0.6382405758,
0.6843822002,
-0.5077187419,
0.5438070297,
0.3246379197,
0.5753475428,
0.0403941609,
0.0862809941,
0.1880864948,
-0.9489037395,
-0.0676741675,
-0.300463587,
-0.1056937426,
-0.1073315889,
-0.802878499,
0.0733610317,
-0.605363965,
-0.2456030846,
0.2603895068,
-0.485501349,
-0.105740793,
-0.0044064852,
0.2527266741,
0.7950056195,
-1.0564334393,
0.5069603324,
0.8425762653,
-0.3915533721,
-0.5247821808,
-0.1148899794,
0.4305524528,
-1.0852435827,
0.3767808676,
-0.4504748285,
0.1614250392,
-0.223656401,
-0.8224124908,
-0.8468026519,
0.4455163777,
0.6924112439,
-0.5788685083,
-0.3254033923,
0.2557292879,
0.4138963819,
-0.3261676431,
-0.025021065,
0.5657816529,
0.5446290374,
0.0677006543,
-0.9505742192,
0.290864259,
-0.154306978,
0.4800466001,
0.3438450396,
-0.2368267328,
0.7505190969,
-0.2463169992,
-0.0702837706,
0.2798840702,
0.4403199255,
0.227349326,
-0.1417908669,
0.5549328327,
0.0981560722,
0.6594353318,
-0.3058488369,
1.0430669785,
-0.2899383605,
0.2554384172,
0.3994965851,
-0.0517040193,
0.567784369,
0.9735956192,
0.0143393027,
0.5651295185,
-0.001687205,
0.1768000424,
0.8259800076,
0.3848024011,
0.1847853959,
-0.1658746451,
-0.0074204621,
-0.1004626229,
0.7097977996,
0.4664532244,
-0.5617640018,
-0.3447315395,
0.4848613143,
0.3849895895,
0.5149374008,
-0.5090992451,
0.7283782363,
0.1855500489,
-0.7397480607,
0.6677977443,
0.2403404117,
0.839697957,
-0.7390806675,
-0.2847451568,
-0.1285380721,
0.1663715988,
-0.2895749509,
-0.6553639174,
0.7825080156,
-0.6136763096,
-0.0569927581,
-0.4981045425,
0.9295156002,
-0.6439305544,
-0.2593111694,
0.2296065688,
0.3053181469,
-0.3188565671,
0.0839151815,
-0.6741918921,
0.2543677986,
0.3412567377,
-0.1402838528,
0.1678560525,
0.1561557949,
-0.3070599437,
0.9571703076,
0.5522733927,
0.5511686206,
0.0189073514,
-0.3239717484,
0.7712645531,
-0.5790075064,
-0.6430726051,
-0.7751682401,
0.4786762297,
0.0556017533,
-0.2544679642,
0.3637962341,
0.2100596875,
0.5231903791,
-0.0845443234,
0.7269554734,
-0.1489071101,
0.1292183995,
-0.6795290709,
1.2722774744,
-0.4360886514,
0.0023284808,
-0.5217559338,
-0.6476129293,
-0.3296505809,
1.1583451033,
-0.313438952,
0.1066664159,
0.9078420401,
0.7211868167,
0.1675850153,
0.2794077396,
0.3796122372,
0.4028078616,
0.0983867869,
0.5775673985,
0.7628847361,
-0.3141414523,
0.4019714296,
-0.6053111553,
-0.1185087338,
0.045666609,
-0.8923359513,
-0.5584035516,
-0.9669902325,
-0.3922689557,
-0.3577027321,
0.2558377683,
0.8611644506,
1.1065765619,
-0.8202010989,
-0.5330469608,
-0.2379318625,
0.237953186,
-0.2698099613,
-0.1384061426,
0.2286826074,
-0.0965481922,
-0.6971183419,
0.1406545937,
0.0327387713,
0.2361388952,
-0.4886473417,
-0.0878330246,
-0.3903720081,
-0.1417673975,
0.3816221654,
0.4030207396,
-0.5346323252,
-0.3790042996,
0.1721512377,
-0.0927341357,
0.0844305083,
0.9396345019,
-0.6154746413,
0.3336955011,
0.4168679118,
0.2251512706,
0.3794040978,
-0.0719008222,
1.2461025715,
-0.760626018,
0.4177179337,
0.4127708375,
0.3305673003,
0.346064955,
-0.4390857816,
0.34961164,
0.1954910755,
-0.242108956,
-0.825114131,
0.2330117971,
-0.585285604,
-0.2543224692,
1.2795946598,
0.2559198439,
-0.361327529,
-0.0873708427,
-0.3678562343,
0.3112676144,
-0.6356467009,
0.5469221473,
0.5041239262,
-0.3270970583,
-0.1489060521,
-0.5544493794,
0.8431834579,
0.5440459847,
-0.3657435477,
0.143653512,
0.4753189385,
0.5429826379,
0.1163838357,
0.3674912155,
-0.2831804752,
0.2127378881,
-0.0991142988,
0.2500012219,
-0.251139909,
-0.3292264938,
-0.7908375263,
0.0006783911,
0.0416335575,
-0.1670401692
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09615v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09615v4
|
API Pack: A Massive Multi-Programming Language Dataset for API Call Generation
| 2024-02-14T23:09:15 | 2024-06-03T22:38:04 |
Zhen Guo, Adriana Meza Soria, Wei Sun, Yikang Shen, Rameswar Panda
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
We introduce API Pack, a massive multi-programming language dataset
containing more than 1 million instruction-API call pairs to improve the API
call generation capabilities of large language models. By fine-tuning
CodeLlama-13B on 20,000 Python instances from API Pack, we enable it to
outperform GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 in generating unseen API calls. Fine-tuning on API
Pack also facilitates cross-programming language generalization by leveraging a
large amount of data in one language and small amounts of data from other
languages. Scaling the training data to 1 million instances further improves
the model's ability to generalize to new APIs not used in training. To
facilitate further research, we open-source the API Pack dataset, trained
model, and associated source code at https://github.com/zguo0525/API-Pack.
|
[
-0.5014597178,
-0.4812089801,
-0.0635258332,
0.352991879,
-0.0516813733,
0.1193755418,
-0.3039192855,
-0.5043298602,
-0.1554994285,
0.6464287639,
-0.8235074878,
-0.597998023,
-0.0319263376,
0.0728442967,
-0.1091986522,
0.9465439916,
0.3119745851,
-0.1155295223,
0.0718814656,
-0.0973568261,
-0.742901504,
-0.3095471263,
-0.4542781413,
-0.2643374503,
0.6489429474,
0.4151126444,
0.3450258374,
0.7081154585,
0.1958740205,
0.2528772652,
0.3511716723,
0.1754019707,
-0.33303532,
0.0602274351,
0.0953578651,
-0.5537992716,
-0.6875365376,
-0.041529309,
0.3509098589,
0.5722170472,
0.000736521,
0.6609149575,
-0.1053663865,
0.7471872568,
-0.3700782061,
0.4673455954,
-0.8123796582,
-0.1756929457,
-0.1779197156,
-0.3818929791,
-0.4960085154,
-0.3545661271,
0.4032430053,
-0.5296579003,
0.2058041096,
0.1277606189,
0.4665027559,
0.1184694767,
-0.0889402628,
-0.471295774,
-0.4965178967,
0.9108706713,
-0.5621112585,
-0.0504195131,
0.4735470712,
0.2715976834,
-0.1168400422,
-0.4945878983,
-0.1647719592,
-0.0421740636,
0.3893156052,
-0.2529225051,
-0.0280255415,
-0.0124188103,
0.1434382796,
0.3240812719,
-0.8455014229,
0.0798440203,
-0.6168571115,
-0.0144914379,
0.6676969528,
0.0215217862,
0.525565505,
0.2276599258,
-0.0919032842,
0.0708493143,
-1.1260296106,
-0.0158770066,
0.7980101109,
0.8852410913,
-0.1013660431,
0.3923608065,
-0.2333360761,
1.0204538107,
-0.2249751687,
0.1398769766,
0.3550841808,
-0.0105049117,
-0.1876069605,
0.1817263812,
0.4429424107,
0.2715806365,
0.2920314968,
-0.1642987728,
-0.0503242277,
-0.0856638774,
0.4250409007,
-0.911174655,
-0.3269781768,
0.5643678308,
-0.5271878242,
-0.3057011068,
0.0114910575,
-0.6667013764,
-0.1311235577,
-0.4482866824,
0.1003576219,
-0.4796929657,
-0.5847356319,
0.1122415066,
-0.0921396911,
0.3459254801,
-0.0803871527,
-1.0577142239,
0.0323748104,
0.8761551976,
0.7841024995,
0.2137394845,
-0.678355217,
-0.4578665197,
0.0620342679,
-0.4297664762,
1.1308813095,
-0.7683604956,
-0.2595071793,
0.4596961737,
0.0252781156,
0.0873031542,
-0.8206284046,
0.0941142589,
-0.291231364,
-0.3012968898,
-0.1725164354,
-0.6621326208,
-0.0415088497,
0.1634811908,
-0.5771838427,
1.0577099323,
0.3320371509,
-0.1634679735,
0.4453406632,
-0.6925580502,
-0.2154292166,
0.6094405055,
0.001654822,
-0.2012352943,
0.1516017467,
0.076802291,
0.2097979188,
-0.2557543516,
-0.0515701473,
-0.4379203022,
-0.3487533331,
0.1594841033,
0.0143483868,
0.7409607768,
0.3025973439,
-0.1687093675,
0.0800340474,
-0.9210489988,
0.4705258608,
-0.1261327565,
-0.5516393185,
-0.4745416939,
-0.2345990539,
0.0795496181,
0.21796453,
0.1613964736,
-0.4705991149,
0.795496583,
-0.307992965,
0.7456017733,
0.7712393403,
-0.3147827089,
0.3749145269,
-0.1232214794,
0.5613959432,
-0.3676003516,
0.1636180431,
-0.7795076966,
-0.6386396885,
-0.377728641,
-0.1149831563,
0.4257588089,
0.3356342912,
-0.4992958903,
0.6581107974,
-0.2202780694,
-0.5912373662,
-0.7813693285,
0.3889996409,
0.5598630309,
0.1549903899,
0.2347177118,
0.0160308592,
-0.5517559052,
-0.7495163083,
-0.148355931,
-0.1539631933,
-0.227502048,
0.3284539282,
0.4069570303,
-0.2734798193,
0.8061966896,
-0.409992367,
-0.1592536718,
-0.2358866036,
0.3253920972,
0.2477440089,
0.6770730615,
0.6924350262,
-0.5183373094,
-0.3734374046,
-0.1563556343,
-0.413117677,
-0.3681603968,
0.0308091845,
-0.3383362293,
0.4634631276,
0.2184099406,
-0.3600089848,
0.1174510717,
0.8711245656,
-0.2605660856,
0.6807994246,
-0.3822905421,
-0.1008714363,
-1.0465474129,
-0.0150776831,
-0.1362399608,
0.342032522,
-0.4762605727,
0.2119072974,
0.3074326515,
-0.444195658,
-0.6023584008,
0.4700642526,
-0.5658035874,
-0.1122376248,
-0.4177594185,
-0.5623065233,
-0.2478104383,
0.4282075167,
-0.2388559282,
0.8205887675,
0.9911494255,
-0.6271696091,
0.5421137214,
0.1688536704,
-0.2807703018,
0.3782631457,
-0.514428556,
0.3708301485,
0.3102422953,
0.480320245,
-0.9532271028,
-0.2126280963,
-0.0110190222,
-0.2320723534,
0.1296716034,
-0.7228730917,
-0.6293484569,
-0.6970034838,
-0.4482762516,
0.5305080414,
0.3451578021,
-0.7590010762,
0.3028534353,
0.4663531482,
-0.2872055769,
-0.4357993305,
-0.7952778339,
-0.1042488366,
-0.0836825147,
-0.4876050949,
-0.1111732796,
-0.3801469207,
0.1537636667,
0.0470155105,
-0.2074439228,
-0.2413581461,
-0.4127264917,
0.5265974402,
0.4227899611,
-0.2842750251,
0.4128066003,
-0.1648710966,
-0.3406688571,
-0.1034024805,
-0.9341791868,
1.2105585337,
-0.2395717651,
-0.2310653776,
-0.0983972251,
0.4797902703,
0.4636862278,
-0.3351126313,
0.5647223592,
0.4176134169,
-0.1670823842,
-0.5238292217,
-0.3236000836,
0.140437603,
-0.4987776279,
0.0715268478,
-0.4374286532,
-0.6250348091,
0.7513504028,
-0.2298706919,
0.3483499289,
0.2447282076,
0.5217410922,
0.3498007953,
0.9725440145,
0.5517044663,
-0.5081166029,
0.3143676519,
-0.5003980398,
0.2222132534,
-0.5103216767,
-0.1952402443,
-0.7298707366,
-0.3303258121,
-0.7422510982,
-0.3033584654,
-0.1087462828,
-0.0600260831,
-0.341076225,
0.5161626935,
-0.8987570405,
0.8908617496,
0.8166685104,
0.0111769205,
-0.0827997774,
0.1943523288,
0.302165091,
0.2473289073,
-0.5842996836,
-0.3541496992,
1.5885014534,
0.0071325973,
0.8755913377,
-0.1579523981,
0.572047174,
0.1955932379,
0.1256512702,
-0.7219193578,
0.4452637732,
-0.022814231,
-0.5813349485,
-0.0456794426,
-0.414067626,
-1.0459553003,
-0.0864584818,
0.0386597253,
-0.6083183885,
-0.1949771345,
0.3425819576,
-0.4861081839,
0.1515589654,
-1.1286896467,
0.8068009019,
-0.253313601,
0.0051288935,
-0.1335782111,
-0.3716489673,
0.2827572525,
-0.0337992311,
-0.05329616,
-0.2109778374,
0.021126369,
0.4044851065,
-0.4078796804,
0.7280329466,
-0.2580280006,
-0.4120671451,
0.4476177394,
-0.0186961237,
0.2903066576,
0.0904768184,
0.0367495865,
0.4858697653,
-0.1273930669,
-0.6725882888,
-0.1481291205,
0.9715556502,
-0.698351562,
0.0234344695,
-0.1457876712,
-0.9991956949,
0.0651904866,
0.2952488065,
0.317412883,
0.8542311192,
0.2101961523,
0.0324762538,
0.5586843491,
-0.7798525095,
0.4752414823,
0.6917122006,
-0.3377908468,
-0.2681284845,
1.2757863998,
0.4373641014,
0.1228983477,
0.0419810116,
0.0105242701,
-0.4204980731,
-0.5012247562,
-0.4593548775,
0.0803969726,
-0.3170230091,
-0.4102027118,
-0.5190734863,
-0.0336962119,
-0.7205304503,
-0.0394543037,
-0.5790362954,
-0.2825249135,
0.3386192024,
0.0998817235,
0.4486303031,
0.7402220368,
0.0121582076,
0.3622277081,
-0.7909135222,
0.4133810699,
0.3388393819,
0.8109993339,
-0.1888481677,
0.0036709339,
-0.3804478645,
-0.0518367589,
-0.1545918882,
-0.6528746486,
0.5239525437,
0.2112520486,
0.4883365035,
0.3595848978,
0.060011249,
0.7980712056,
-0.7331497073,
0.8287376761,
-0.1132939085,
-0.696113348,
0.9082027674,
-0.6212185621,
0.5843469501,
0.2502279282,
0.0151228039,
-0.2379477918,
-0.56273669,
-0.7517644763,
-1.1729631424,
0.8846820593,
0.0139790019,
0.2148272991,
0.175834164,
0.3264763355,
0.5099608302,
0.2900211513,
-0.425853014,
-0.3306549489,
-0.0731714964,
0.0001345619,
0.0779185519,
-0.0568603277,
-0.3484620452,
-0.250433892,
0.5358341932,
-0.3638631105,
0.3183964193,
-0.3455643356,
-0.0303572174,
-0.3335411847,
0.2784893513,
0.6336695552,
0.9932465553,
-0.4646809995,
-0.0219562948,
-0.3046685755,
-0.5170559883,
-0.1358270049,
0.3350205421,
-0.1912060529,
-0.128400296,
0.136789903,
0.6382118464,
0.0780893117,
-1.0192439556,
-0.0446539521,
-0.111599274,
-0.0719044358,
-0.3405439258,
0.1179097071,
0.034950763,
0.2180769444,
0.6562053561,
0.0996982008,
-0.0225646701,
-0.5328009129,
0.2937944233,
0.2366413325,
0.1800617129,
-0.4869592488,
0.375364095,
0.3994119167,
-0.4125952423,
0.5605322123,
-0.159560293,
-0.2876337767,
0.7638046741,
0.7036530972,
0.8091363907,
-0.360861063,
0.429607302,
0.4742985964,
0.3171681464,
-0.1386128217,
0.1720981747,
-0.1261264384,
-0.4583475888,
-0.4339330792,
-0.6290760636,
-0.4122334719,
0.6428440809,
-0.6667973995,
0.1056140885,
-0.1718077213,
0.2911973,
0.0150685497,
0.26725775,
-0.6157867312,
-0.3578948081,
0.2666700482,
1.1236686707,
-0.8750956059,
1.1015874147,
0.8307694793,
-0.4206743836,
-0.9744329453,
-0.0967402682,
0.1760708988,
-0.9003753662,
0.4540398419,
0.578328371,
0.2794779837,
0.0599898919,
-0.7214527726,
-0.4741667807,
0.8689407706,
0.5278912783,
-0.5032430887,
0.2787474394,
0.5123091936,
0.4196693599,
-0.7774735093,
0.1553603858,
0.7326918244,
0.2711203992,
-0.2753077447,
-0.8061346412,
-0.2915457785,
-0.4759801626,
0.1917479485,
0.1216137186,
-0.5593680739,
1.0136799812,
0.0122199552,
0.1716534048,
0.1786156148,
0.1103193834,
0.5653381944,
0.0640731081,
0.4193639457,
0.5423116684,
0.7607514262,
-0.0349477828,
1.2294688225,
-0.5250150561,
0.3677766323,
1.1096209288,
-0.2026478201,
0.6768848896,
0.3331741095,
0.0716754645,
0.0886660814,
0.8612216115,
-0.1785493642,
0.5581258535,
0.2563575804,
-0.36409688,
-0.1137493402,
0.0488860682,
-0.805986762,
0.2835631967,
0.2865170538,
-0.1188314632,
-0.4135326743,
0.0345921889,
-0.313588798,
-0.3742846549,
-0.5106183887,
0.6809517741,
-0.3135913014,
-0.749050498,
0.7646306753,
-0.5310544372,
0.6446093321,
-0.6430107355,
-0.2538382113,
-0.3130293787,
0.3828526139,
-0.0936679244,
-0.731705606,
-0.0005802943,
0.2185105383,
-0.2225182354,
-0.2375321686,
0.7942948341,
-0.6754437685,
-0.4582711458,
0.3389279246,
0.4008853137,
0.2150746733,
-0.3433745503,
-0.8402863145,
0.2241296619,
-0.0793878138,
-0.2934300303,
0.5167789459,
0.6629322767,
0.2156532556,
0.7939113975,
0.851315558,
0.4405224621,
0.6592971683,
0.2317834646,
0.7983517647,
-0.4518201053,
-0.6285839081,
-0.5864768028,
0.474483192,
0.0356881469,
-0.5752960443,
0.514733851,
0.9632098675,
0.9876807928,
-0.4548462927,
1.1507692337,
-0.3386665285,
0.2737827599,
-0.1800778508,
0.6126126051,
-0.2319143862,
0.3200840056,
-0.1109759286,
-1.0438686609,
-0.2883063853,
0.3399755955,
-0.0321498886,
-0.3661919534,
0.2431050986,
0.94356215,
-0.0786369741,
0.090092577,
0.1037557349,
0.0358207524,
0.5015507936,
0.573009789,
0.7682356238,
-0.4836397171,
1.0025128126,
-0.2151044309,
-0.4166154861,
-0.0910082906,
-0.5676683187,
-0.7924594879,
-0.664917171,
-0.1695240736,
-0.2974757552,
-0.0687113628,
1.0430088043,
1.0387716293,
-0.9246281385,
-0.3540363014,
-0.3899044096,
-0.2129660547,
-0.5907970667,
-0.2102440149,
0.1902195364,
-0.9360803962,
-0.9683070183,
0.3802396655,
0.3983479142,
-0.2764451504,
-0.2200915217,
-0.2978118956,
0.0428039059,
-0.2370993942,
0.5658143163,
0.6088675857,
-0.4783718884,
-0.1053752452,
-0.3292595744,
0.0736642703,
0.048975084,
1.1605530977,
-0.5730251074,
0.5306214094,
0.3447747231,
0.6532304883,
0.1086667702,
-0.2491839528,
0.7169598937,
-1.1508222818,
0.6165757179,
-0.1377292424,
0.227445662,
0.003568144,
-0.1474715173,
0.7733587623,
-0.112104848,
-0.792218864,
-1.0169378519,
0.2406760901,
-1.143094182,
-0.3568639159,
1.1725412607,
-0.2881489992,
-0.27507177,
-0.2209473401,
-0.4523154795,
0.2007239312,
-0.7207743526,
0.8826129436,
0.565775454,
-0.2569378018,
-0.1861556023,
-0.8832338452,
0.4076451957,
-0.1101357192,
-0.99203825,
0.4938082695,
0.5131620765,
0.3115580678,
0.3622066677,
0.4930654168,
-0.0548768379,
0.21843265,
0.2153381556,
0.2597133517,
-0.2063699514,
-0.3865962029,
-0.192713052,
0.2861610949,
-0.1911289245,
-0.5142550468
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09614v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09614v2
|
Probabilistic Reasoning in Generative Large Language Models
| 2024-02-14T23:05:44 | 2024-06-17T05:13:33 |
Aliakbar Nafar, Kristen Brent Venable, Parisa Kordjamshidi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
This paper considers the challenges Large Language Models (LLMs) face when
reasoning over text that includes information involving uncertainty explicitly
quantified via probability values. This type of reasoning is relevant to a
variety of contexts ranging from everyday conversations to medical
decision-making. Despite improvements in the mathematical reasoning
capabilities of LLMs, they still exhibit significant difficulties when it comes
to probabilistic reasoning. To deal with this problem, we introduce the
Bayesian Linguistic Inference Dataset (BLInD), a new dataset specifically
designed to test the probabilistic reasoning capabilities of LLMs. We use BLInD
to find out the limitations of LLMs for tasks involving probabilistic
reasoning. In addition, we present several prompting strategies that map the
problem to different formal representations, including Python code,
probabilistic algorithms, and probabilistic logical programming. We conclude by
providing an evaluation of our methods on BLInD and an adaptation of a causal
reasoning question-answering dataset. Our empirical results highlight the
effectiveness of our proposed strategies for multiple LLMs.
|
[
0.0819198191,
-1.035695076,
1.2171119452,
0.3654319942,
0.0366253108,
-0.3109900951,
-0.3550618291,
-0.0745593011,
-0.4224173129,
0.6714157462,
-0.6316577792,
-0.533034265,
-0.537728548,
0.1061071232,
-0.1706512868,
0.5441447496,
-0.1918426007,
0.0042938115,
-0.112503171,
0.1660407037,
-0.5261772275,
-0.3715451956,
-0.6524237394,
-0.0574380606,
0.5033976436,
0.4403499067,
1.0516600609,
0.0479131751,
0.5604462028,
0.241493836,
0.1219864562,
0.0915960819,
-0.0087689413,
0.4336761236,
-0.3592555225,
-0.7435914874,
-0.0453207083,
-0.3716402352,
0.7460258603,
1.0720710754,
-0.1264336556,
-0.2028882504,
-0.1970210075,
0.4080191255,
-0.7801604271,
0.4004976749,
-0.7243762612,
0.037631847,
-0.2061713636,
0.04130226,
-0.5686970949,
-0.3393836617,
-0.0208637528,
-0.4437896907,
0.1773479432,
-0.1168114766,
0.3755787015,
0.3417308927,
-0.3998688757,
-0.1830452532,
-0.9053079486,
0.8017635345,
-0.8765282035,
0.2699594796,
0.7194344997,
0.1982575208,
-0.6207538843,
-0.3172173202,
-0.7455616593,
-0.3256283104,
0.3115651906,
0.041683618,
-0.2930378914,
0.0724018216,
0.2657683194,
0.1517329216,
-0.7008728981,
0.2485434413,
0.1609473228,
0.0886957571,
0.6639809608,
-0.048776187,
-0.1792660654,
-0.1252156943,
0.1232464463,
-0.1051954329,
-0.756200552,
-0.4213414788,
0.3737586439,
0.129216522,
-0.0176703315,
0.830920577,
-0.2492530346,
1.1207971573,
-0.4097473323,
-0.0434135646,
0.004074587,
0.0599746145,
-0.2712471783,
-0.2219769955,
0.8158982396,
0.1452903748,
0.590010345,
0.144948706,
-0.1559120864,
-0.0462775193,
-0.1607469618,
-0.260640204,
-0.3344067633,
0.5973371863,
-0.1579068154,
0.018151518,
-0.0770015642,
-0.549954772,
-0.5047094822,
-0.0534870774,
0.6362745762,
-0.5643743277,
-0.2406227738,
0.604344964,
-0.06674245,
0.0064061619,
0.5934198499,
-0.8898448944,
-0.1347540766,
0.5830306411,
0.4044662714,
0.2897130847,
0.0556599312,
-0.3556950986,
0.3231223524,
-0.6238857508,
0.62091434,
-0.5500639677,
-0.1566776186,
0.0980515555,
-0.0947479457,
0.0155928656,
-0.6017850041,
0.6064074039,
-0.3876095414,
0.1016920656,
-0.1347195953,
-0.6392888427,
-0.1621971577,
-0.0709238276,
-0.5168170333,
0.4975572526,
0.1859672517,
-0.9003213644,
0.3420724869,
-0.1617894918,
-0.4794403315,
0.2825293541,
-0.3946889639,
-0.4371423721,
0.2160861492,
0.3145473897,
0.7266930938,
-0.4436194897,
0.6729696393,
-0.5834267735,
-0.018748004,
0.7933771014,
-0.8010475636,
0.7484028339,
0.2257682383,
-0.213214308,
-0.0034062408,
-0.7475860119,
-0.0661555454,
0.1586986631,
-0.269636035,
-0.1993374676,
0.5998516083,
-0.2020328343,
-0.0469997972,
0.0273491256,
-0.217949912,
0.2691398561,
-0.3562839627,
0.5306821465,
0.7510643005,
0.0616561212,
0.1994712055,
-0.207871601,
0.3230190575,
-0.0169564895,
0.2357271612,
0.0480618589,
-0.8960238695,
-0.6229081154,
-0.2036099583,
0.3106532693,
0.7379456758,
-1.087793231,
0.5541183949,
-0.0633073524,
-0.1173214689,
-0.5472112894,
-0.1176607981,
0.1249580756,
0.315752238,
0.1226555854,
0.097068727,
-0.2502586842,
-0.7130123973,
-0.1185739934,
-0.5140102506,
-0.3510939181,
0.1118981242,
0.5007641315,
-0.1031167358,
0.8251728415,
-0.4701071978,
0.0077938647,
-0.4494108856,
0.2871342897,
0.5255134702,
0.5187023282,
-0.0606003888,
-0.9240977168,
0.1161639094,
-0.2528278232,
-0.854847908,
-0.2532734275,
-0.7109888196,
0.0588592812,
0.1985774189,
0.357711643,
-0.971778214,
0.4199146926,
0.6227939725,
-0.203618139,
0.8262196183,
-0.3808935881,
0.060739629,
-0.7369620204,
-0.2551327348,
0.1958078295,
-0.0044053877,
-0.3920076787,
0.0519554913,
-0.1574598253,
0.0379604958,
-0.2050621063,
0.5044000745,
-0.4665923119,
-0.1049706191,
-0.1530744135,
-0.0275942385,
-0.2507050931,
0.0386419483,
0.4202859402,
0.4909018874,
0.824786067,
-0.5013558269,
0.6987336874,
0.2558981776,
-0.6812437773,
0.4845797718,
-0.5318540335,
-0.4177393913,
-0.3334307075,
0.3064737022,
-0.9742746353,
-0.4699524343,
0.3880936205,
-0.5388624072,
0.2065427601,
-0.0520018004,
-0.9928019047,
-0.5309482217,
0.1339969337,
0.2132469118,
0.3677079976,
-0.2506704926,
0.1579681933,
0.0143263619,
-0.3186004758,
-0.5038661957,
-0.7372335792,
0.2982144952,
-0.1980073601,
-0.5825986266,
0.1621006131,
-0.0456413813,
-0.6471149921,
-0.0004396949,
-0.0385735743,
-0.0001556534,
0.3216672242,
0.1197539717,
0.1735992134,
-0.2102597803,
0.4280974269,
0.1573604345,
-0.2068814039,
0.1302767545,
-0.470497638,
0.2910704017,
0.1630305797,
-0.8570054173,
-0.3839918673,
0.4609699547,
-0.0047459411,
0.0457163639,
0.9678798914,
0.2769325376,
-0.5455439687,
-0.3598647118,
-0.5602665544,
-0.24684304,
-0.3717825711,
0.2896499932,
-0.5862835646,
-1.057749629,
0.3714390099,
-0.0402082093,
-0.3373882174,
0.4135245383,
0.8353478312,
-0.1869561523,
1.1255367994,
0.2457974255,
0.1792981923,
-0.0248107612,
0.0801541433,
0.3780267239,
-0.3721315265,
-0.2313655317,
-0.5741881728,
0.1941701323,
-0.6203263402,
-0.8089083433,
0.3681093156,
0.417988956,
-0.3319595754,
0.0929053947,
-0.2093797326,
0.2722866833,
0.6597175598,
0.2056230456,
0.2450566292,
-0.2385162711,
0.0611688718,
0.0864619985,
-0.8566936851,
-0.4579324424,
0.911129117,
0.322054565,
1.0899399519,
0.2850001454,
0.3988610208,
-0.0437739491,
0.2011196315,
-0.5082792044,
0.5640463233,
-0.0160514172,
-0.7311795354,
-0.523588419,
-0.9207472801,
-1.0726336241,
0.1746912003,
-0.2618818283,
-0.98306036,
0.2793074846,
-0.0876756236,
-0.349670738,
0.3177828193,
-0.5791608095,
0.9108682871,
-0.1652163714,
-0.3701407015,
0.0885538682,
-0.7685630322,
0.4649219215,
-0.2771213055,
0.4764659405,
-0.1502324194,
0.09376169,
0.4543680549,
-0.3043118715,
0.9077996612,
0.0395169705,
-0.3476729691,
0.4396309555,
0.1869025975,
0.4987706542,
0.403614223,
-0.2110127658,
0.0279753655,
-0.1144788116,
-0.3811674714,
-0.4590794742,
0.3964644074,
-0.4602203369,
-0.9771689773,
-0.4965539575,
-0.7801429629,
-0.6069191098,
-0.0497756042,
0.2148918808,
0.0260242503,
0.1641159058,
0.1204177067,
0.8896743059,
-0.8286113739,
0.2409396023,
0.5067178607,
-0.0372286662,
-0.1889920384,
0.6728683114,
0.0448101722,
0.3967524767,
0.8796344399,
0.347653091,
-0.3623138666,
-0.6996135712,
-0.4045778215,
0.2572103143,
-0.6745359302,
-0.1508916616,
-0.4232590199,
-0.2144172788,
-0.5182961226,
-0.1213020533,
0.1174737215,
-0.4402261376,
-0.364120543,
-0.0807837322,
0.2765227854,
0.2441868782,
-0.1676638126,
0.4132387638,
-0.7283141613,
0.4608095586,
0.4930068254,
0.1741238981,
-0.2650941312,
-0.4365023971,
0.2061693519,
-0.0265025645,
-0.0849077106,
-1.3459695578,
0.4676003158,
0.0084359404,
0.697322607,
0.4623661339,
0.2195174843,
0.1643172652,
-0.3923430145,
0.56877774,
0.1281624734,
-0.8057431579,
0.823677659,
-0.6672607064,
0.3891113997,
0.1721845865,
0.6241126657,
-0.2279473245,
-0.727152884,
-0.6814315915,
-0.714387536,
0.2876956165,
0.3684258461,
-0.0477535762,
-0.2945127487,
0.4089508951,
0.1240129173,
0.2782847583,
-0.6195985079,
0.0910641775,
0.379945755,
-0.4237599075,
-0.3782736361,
-0.3022314608,
0.019360397,
-0.1690054536,
0.4985996783,
-0.2346048802,
0.2757781744,
0.0832315534,
-0.0287679918,
-0.0110125393,
0.5059175491,
0.4038796425,
0.8237156868,
-0.2308763266,
0.4206590056,
0.0026397977,
-0.0191555973,
0.0944616497,
0.3533779681,
-0.1810209453,
-0.002160304,
0.6504088044,
0.7793346643,
0.1577216536,
-0.9749356508,
0.5497372746,
0.2424050272,
-0.3348316848,
-0.3209012151,
-0.0433861613,
0.3383717537,
0.3593024909,
0.393622905,
-0.2396059781,
0.0230148118,
-0.6578140855,
0.1230516136,
0.3943826258,
0.0199316051,
-0.0074135675,
0.8919927478,
-0.3160935938,
-0.0924461186,
0.7378119826,
-0.280554831,
-0.3694891334,
0.5366430879,
0.5359151959,
0.5230210423,
-0.3460625708,
0.4725446403,
0.0538664907,
0.520986557,
-0.4732733667,
0.5527129769,
0.0941297412,
-0.9480534792,
-0.9080227613,
-0.6368477345,
-0.5903397202,
0.0744545758,
-0.2108203322,
0.050437551,
-0.3323789239,
-0.2032805234,
0.1347089112,
-0.2583399415,
-0.3418900371,
0.2755080163,
0.2778761685,
0.7755324841,
-0.9880384803,
0.7864288092,
0.3097108305,
-0.457314074,
-0.508879602,
0.0595985129,
-0.0612574704,
-0.7748530507,
0.6857753396,
0.0222183447,
0.4182003736,
-0.1265564114,
-0.7038959861,
-0.576171279,
0.4326588511,
0.5721903443,
-0.9179118872,
0.2823002934,
0.3369499743,
0.3181585073,
0.106170021,
-0.0004739932,
0.5694416761,
0.6347577572,
0.0555315986,
-0.6599047184,
0.1077407822,
0.2950464487,
0.0305811875,
0.0311976206,
-0.307905525,
0.9815602899,
-0.5789300799,
-0.0241794027,
0.1713794172,
0.7712051272,
0.576916337,
0.1946756691,
0.401827693,
0.7228583694,
0.7864989042,
-0.2817639112,
1.1852105856,
0.2116729617,
0.1445614249,
1.0134681463,
-0.4958583415,
0.9660968781,
0.4298474789,
-0.4930711091,
0.3741839826,
0.7801413536,
-0.0764273033,
0.3561916649,
0.691659987,
-0.7447934151,
-0.7455669045,
0.1918852627,
-0.2696838379,
0.1091178209,
0.6312699318,
-0.1687780172,
-0.0748947412,
0.134184137,
-0.0873639584,
-0.0431912951,
-0.1214653328,
0.5412552357,
0.2924010158,
-0.6194081903,
0.3237045705,
0.3375044465,
0.3149096966,
-0.4648742378,
0.0010677758,
-0.118650414,
0.2908787429,
-0.0939308107,
-1.1635926962,
0.2571479678,
-0.150137201,
0.0373237729,
-0.0966673717,
0.6176162958,
-0.3013797998,
-0.8174470067,
-0.0436497256,
0.6361906528,
0.3268508017,
-0.4032348096,
-0.6278530955,
0.0658003092,
-0.2316775173,
-0.3477513492,
0.327944845,
0.9749118686,
-0.4120959938,
1.0226539373,
0.5106312633,
0.3621897995,
-0.0104471752,
0.459284097,
0.4608159065,
-0.5634871125,
-0.2951810658,
-0.9115170836,
0.2207729816,
0.2287262082,
-0.0780914947,
0.7627046108,
0.20062159,
0.6269521713,
-0.2097673565,
0.9217408895,
0.0317034051,
0.2715837657,
-0.8007891178,
0.2886646092,
-0.279530704,
0.3705021143,
-0.2370899767,
-0.6778931022,
-0.7159295082,
1.0444799662,
-0.5531509519,
0.0977405682,
0.6045180559,
0.6851792932,
0.3115882277,
0.0624830574,
0.3527338207,
0.2795909345,
0.0902635232,
1.0962687731,
1.0815348625,
-0.1867302805,
0.3102920353,
0.0849179178,
-0.4596624672,
-0.1523728967,
-0.9555387497,
-0.5891527534,
-0.6109662652,
-0.5995336771,
-0.3168378174,
0.3012082279,
0.376444757,
0.4414515793,
-0.7937517166,
-0.0248535946,
-0.4951416552,
0.508564651,
-0.3202646673,
-0.2487830967,
0.3509561121,
-0.2544420063,
-0.4272081256,
0.2568487227,
0.2343489677,
0.0066989358,
-0.2145826072,
0.146878168,
-0.1034725606,
0.1051418856,
0.4778584838,
0.1450978816,
-0.6694718003,
-0.4733889103,
-0.4293417335,
0.1617244184,
-0.3722602129,
0.5908681154,
-0.5537694097,
0.2106958926,
0.581905365,
0.6319003701,
0.4346583486,
-0.3147604167,
0.6058700681,
-0.618283689,
0.1254191995,
0.4293998182,
0.3792114258,
0.4225796461,
-0.0584460795,
0.3168390095,
0.3680813611,
-0.5767946839,
-0.7868155837,
0.4783143997,
-0.9428696036,
-0.7937876582,
1.4287590981,
-0.2407623976,
0.0569690876,
-0.287643373,
0.0620367788,
0.0994944721,
0.0541303642,
0.6038582921,
0.8670448065,
-0.0480731539,
-0.5493881702,
-1.0253241062,
0.2597254813,
0.5138826966,
-0.9507809877,
0.2180335522,
0.7409718633,
0.1020943671,
-0.261510849,
0.7044548392,
-0.0436440706,
0.0886149481,
0.2397853285,
-0.1145001501,
0.4790368974,
-0.3861415982,
-0.3087675571,
0.2755353153,
0.1936379224,
0.1462651342
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09611v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09611v1
|
Towards Privacy-Aware Sign Language Translation at Scale
| 2024-02-14T22:57:03 | 2024-02-14T22:57:03 |
Phillip Rust, Bowen Shi, Skyler Wang, Necati Cihan Camgöz, Jean Maillard
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
A major impediment to the advancement of sign language translation (SLT) is
data scarcity. Much of the sign language data currently available on the web
cannot be used for training supervised models due to the lack of aligned
captions. Furthermore, scaling SLT using large-scale web-scraped datasets bears
privacy risks due to the presence of biometric information, which the
responsible development of SLT technologies should account for. In this work,
we propose a two-stage framework for privacy-aware SLT at scale that addresses
both of these issues. We introduce SSVP-SLT, which leverages self-supervised
video pretraining on anonymized and unannotated videos, followed by supervised
SLT finetuning on a curated parallel dataset. SSVP-SLT achieves
state-of-the-art finetuned and zero-shot gloss-free SLT performance on the
How2Sign dataset, outperforming the strongest respective baselines by over 3
BLEU-4. Based on controlled experiments, we further discuss the advantages and
limitations of self-supervised pretraining and anonymization via facial
obfuscation for SLT.
|
[
0.07553076,
0.0150962425,
0.2631306052,
0.2866717875,
-0.3669583201,
0.1328705996,
0.0273180883,
-0.4733557999,
0.2572749853,
0.6613212228,
-0.4660367966,
-0.5798285604,
-0.8918133974,
-0.1132601351,
-0.5179317594,
1.1543866396,
0.059397947,
0.2122308165,
0.2351595312,
-0.2544921041,
0.1358646601,
-0.1891923547,
-0.4949125946,
0.2582025528,
0.1561760902,
0.2961460948,
0.7947234511,
1.0073928833,
0.5047877431,
0.20429793,
0.0527110808,
-0.1112820879,
-0.3111757934,
0.1906875521,
-0.107546635,
-0.1317369044,
-0.6277593374,
0.054737173,
0.8417677879,
0.3928789794,
0.1234457195,
0.5972300768,
-0.0889450088,
0.6953923702,
-0.4386200607,
0.2543089688,
-0.4145513773,
0.1210798174,
-0.4111959934,
0.3329442441,
-0.1307599097,
-0.4137157798,
-0.1038391292,
-0.4685347974,
0.3993178606,
0.1164252162,
0.6223574281,
0.5411916971,
-0.4668106139,
0.1022654176,
-0.6628808975,
0.4582683742,
-0.769685626,
0.6578978896,
0.5166417956,
0.2532147467,
0.3279381692,
-0.6054157019,
-0.192220211,
-0.0981107056,
-0.2413147986,
-0.0226856507,
0.2181892544,
0.1656128466,
0.3312078714,
0.5460478663,
-0.8877723813,
0.3204791844,
-0.3919034004,
-0.5562904477,
0.7835566998,
-0.0282747019,
0.1222764999,
-0.0537835024,
-0.5631437898,
-0.0221829936,
-0.4325383604,
-0.064731136,
0.1941224039,
0.5832532644,
-0.4580904841,
0.5463722944,
-0.3151025772,
0.5583713055,
0.2041062564,
-0.0747246966,
0.3578393459,
-0.4559515715,
0.072083883,
0.0097984755,
0.9180135131,
0.1597312093,
0.1419837922,
-0.0962473601,
-0.1410940886,
-0.1036269963,
-0.0902307779,
-0.8958066702,
-0.0163643751,
0.3091751635,
-0.2208607346,
0.0132821063,
-0.0014302409,
-0.5278000236,
-0.703125596,
-0.2450471967,
0.3799909651,
-0.146402061,
-0.4867186844,
0.1181775257,
0.1698108315,
0.2263568789,
0.1806600988,
-0.9331264496,
0.4325538874,
0.6234134436,
0.8903731108,
-0.3891523182,
-0.2326833606,
-0.6596711278,
0.1787345409,
-0.0203511454,
-0.1176310629,
-0.0291257165,
-0.0412803814,
-0.1547603011,
-0.0463216268,
0.0166592486,
-0.1848810762,
0.0350096337,
-0.2771221399,
-0.0148774842,
0.0103198737,
-0.3986193836,
0.3865013123,
-0.0335768349,
-0.5366054773,
0.718752563,
0.2312735915,
-0.4468314946,
0.4298187494,
-0.4634442925,
-0.7750818729,
0.4041424096,
-0.0842695236,
-0.763214469,
0.0517938472,
0.1656614989,
0.5449303985,
0.2076114416,
0.0361900032,
-0.0894106179,
-0.134292841,
-0.0173806548,
-0.1632494479,
0.6589545608,
0.50045681,
-0.7051369548,
-0.1066950932,
-0.8305882812,
0.0803703964,
-0.1095257401,
0.1794694811,
-0.2825002372,
-0.4891163707,
-0.1127901524,
0.304089576,
0.6344242096,
-0.8799946308,
-0.1970907599,
-0.3050507605,
0.4787049592,
0.5330099463,
-0.1096527651,
0.5854561329,
0.2790783644,
0.7474221587,
-0.1120687276,
0.7421221733,
-0.041286733,
-0.4904214144,
-0.4686975479,
-0.2426329106,
0.1551339924,
0.387640208,
-0.3807020783,
0.2772405148,
-0.274766922,
-0.3637557328,
-0.8468282819,
0.2323539555,
0.9126105309,
0.2949967682,
0.3128655553,
-0.7650588751,
-0.1192536727,
-0.6815180779,
-0.4601774216,
0.0227394104,
-0.0922400728,
0.0507898927,
0.1758370548,
0.3348698914,
0.7111151218,
-0.4332265854,
-0.8669597507,
0.2564066052,
-0.0484790131,
-0.1122599468,
0.796141386,
0.0989864022,
-1.0312632322,
-0.7656040788,
0.1415656507,
-0.5649514794,
0.0347448289,
-0.2334175259,
0.191531986,
-0.1668354869,
0.5109565258,
-0.3565986753,
0.4762007594,
0.9002420306,
-0.4078243077,
0.2135942876,
-0.324641645,
-0.0557203405,
-0.8807598352,
-0.059338443,
-0.0413423516,
-0.6562503576,
-0.8610988855,
0.1828473657,
0.2764534056,
-0.4971961379,
-0.7048031092,
0.3626571596,
-0.7757201195,
-0.4999006987,
-0.0127952537,
0.1867255867,
-0.1461053044,
0.304559648,
0.1582598686,
0.7221285105,
0.7001772523,
-0.2574872077,
-0.1510282457,
0.348839879,
0.0321243368,
0.5532121062,
-0.3452104926,
0.1485003233,
-0.0348681882,
-0.0520411432,
-0.8440346122,
-0.1431495696,
0.2183203846,
-0.5363081694,
0.4869217873,
-0.2084216774,
-0.4490201473,
-0.2762128413,
-0.1501439661,
0.265889734,
0.448844105,
-0.3414768577,
0.4021094441,
0.4422712028,
-0.1290753037,
-0.462150842,
-0.7711162567,
0.055153951,
-0.1879273951,
-0.3783501983,
-0.1410593987,
0.0265032034,
0.1149656028,
-0.4073205888,
-0.3995354176,
-0.1504025459,
-0.101529263,
0.4241187572,
-0.1826751679,
0.052613344,
-0.1796845645,
0.0459835716,
-0.4136377871,
0.0226481874,
-0.5418118834,
0.1855268627,
-0.5242724419,
-0.4894612432,
-0.7060987949,
0.199417606,
0.5317342281,
-0.5239714384,
0.6015272737,
0.7766809464,
-0.1210050881,
0.0585165024,
-0.4630721509,
-0.1258595437,
-0.4962141812,
0.0235033762,
-0.1416913569,
-1.251190424,
0.386387527,
-0.0353321135,
0.3248538077,
0.0425469689,
0.3792352974,
-0.0246561263,
0.8214451075,
0.3720966578,
0.195541352,
0.5849668384,
-0.0187735558,
0.2389375567,
-0.6527724266,
-0.1533451527,
-0.1816916168,
-0.2366570383,
-0.7144238949,
-0.5631757379,
0.3323068023,
-0.2245307267,
-0.2126366198,
1.032730341,
-0.7524061799,
0.4575694501,
0.4126137793,
0.2786368728,
0.5337371826,
-0.1164969057,
0.4747755826,
-0.2565413713,
-0.2404060662,
-0.1373010129,
1.1613904238,
0.3848631382,
0.6574957967,
0.1832802892,
0.9683943987,
0.3460206687,
0.188666001,
-0.262752831,
0.6825773716,
-0.4691934586,
-0.8360229731,
-0.913837254,
-0.3536256552,
-0.8213034868,
0.4902856648,
-0.0003974543,
-0.5759502649,
0.095807761,
0.6420285106,
-0.1914204955,
0.0402713306,
-0.8696265817,
0.82068187,
-0.4922600389,
-0.6037597656,
-0.0014175475,
-1.4740812778,
0.3246361911,
-0.3787451386,
0.5175454021,
-0.1923668832,
-0.0145357056,
0.5256844759,
-0.6304562092,
1.0807708502,
-0.4235236645,
-0.2292349339,
-0.0613915808,
0.2875829637,
0.5586610436,
-0.0000831531,
0.1968179494,
0.2566450238,
0.085462831,
-0.4853956997,
-0.4361692369,
0.6084476709,
-0.4659157991,
-0.5167648196,
-0.37015903,
-0.526453793,
-0.2786610425,
0.4227443635,
0.1400093287,
-0.0006894637,
0.0515266769,
0.0477634855,
0.7833337784,
0.1910818517,
0.182397306,
0.7525964975,
-0.0872573256,
-0.1980428845,
1.1440238953,
0.0218800213,
0.7328477502,
0.3139392734,
0.411054194,
-0.5648707747,
-0.6753391623,
-0.5389865637,
0.4451261759,
-0.4265932739,
-0.0408727862,
-0.3201334178,
-0.166000545,
-0.9003832936,
-0.0719570592,
-0.8042455316,
-0.7832583189,
-0.0788174421,
-0.2788333893,
0.4391233325,
0.4558468759,
-0.5438116193,
0.5274682045,
-0.3765935898,
0.4728631973,
0.2222057581,
0.5235411525,
-0.3525267243,
-0.4738533497,
-0.2921303511,
-0.0828917325,
0.1267901361,
-0.4635263979,
0.1740302145,
0.2431059033,
0.0191029813,
0.5371235013,
0.1926952451,
0.69960922,
-0.5261623859,
0.8227900863,
0.4534674585,
-0.8750019073,
0.5896897316,
-0.4020820558,
0.3782192767,
0.807522893,
0.2518382072,
-0.5279778838,
-0.7653307319,
-0.6550490856,
-0.8927102685,
0.6228528619,
0.429277122,
0.1931047738,
0.383076936,
0.2273773402,
0.2599124908,
0.4404619634,
-0.9848481417,
-0.2479352504,
-0.6224474311,
-0.0035104265,
-0.1621126384,
0.3729486465,
-0.0963483602,
-0.2322402596,
0.4719114006,
0.0588397346,
-0.4246136248,
-0.0621821173,
-0.2468027025,
-0.0100601017,
0.0939441398,
0.4476508498,
0.3295891881,
-0.0618157089,
0.109576948,
-0.0433725752,
-0.8564103246,
0.1963380724,
0.074481912,
-0.5732816458,
-0.1434624046,
0.1047186628,
0.8396013975,
0.0853440464,
-0.3244127631,
0.8625529408,
0.1864163429,
-0.27446118,
-0.246598199,
-0.1135386229,
-0.090419285,
0.1221035942,
-0.1228641048,
-0.1356496811,
0.0828836858,
0.1055703387,
0.4254026115,
0.2170562148,
-0.5120450258,
-0.3686092794,
1.2162841558,
0.1390901506,
-0.5740303397,
0.2483715117,
-0.1090098917,
-0.0845884755,
0.174657464,
0.3705521822,
0.8025501966,
-0.6628078818,
0.6450661421,
0.3386958838,
0.4427483082,
-0.1706361324,
0.1384121031,
-0.3818710446,
-0.243370533,
-0.1710100323,
-0.5286570787,
-0.3566409647,
0.1417208165,
-0.9549384713,
-0.1258278191,
-0.7088875175,
-0.1300983727,
-0.4497971237,
-0.4122711122,
-0.7114933133,
0.3864973187,
0.2582474649,
0.3561455309,
-1.146756053,
0.7279400229,
0.2359445393,
-0.399199605,
-0.5933976769,
-0.1846430898,
0.1741303802,
-1.0975168943,
0.2529558837,
0.0779637471,
-0.2270804197,
0.3839922845,
-0.3842594922,
-1.1499483585,
1.0388827324,
0.3005664647,
-0.6819324493,
0.0413805395,
0.7046304345,
0.7462177873,
-0.1302285641,
-0.4625516534,
0.5841506124,
0.4569067657,
0.1570834816,
-0.963328898,
0.3441286087,
0.4432091415,
0.2026704401,
0.1422923505,
-0.9131660461,
0.3565823436,
-0.2170289606,
-0.2337222397,
-0.0138747049,
0.810893476,
-0.0530360788,
0.2058065236,
0.4596114457,
0.3376588225,
0.4761064053,
0.2851112187,
0.527929008,
-0.3363339007,
0.273319155,
1.2928408384,
-0.2596933246,
0.556804955,
0.6066640019,
-0.168901369,
-0.1752394438,
0.3898945749,
0.0213563163,
0.5209829211,
0.3717107773,
-0.2589042485,
-0.2853532135,
-0.0234681275,
-0.2853303254,
0.3950812519,
0.203850612,
-0.3522652388,
-0.3718177676,
0.2677873969,
0.1167328134,
0.3923318982,
-0.2730817199,
0.6154562235,
0.3006321192,
-0.279387325,
0.4040113688,
-0.3016575575,
0.3770652115,
-0.8321051002,
0.3273358941,
-0.2566266358,
0.136427924,
-0.2925442159,
-0.7356416583,
0.1841110289,
-0.0346438102,
0.3938273191,
-0.9934031367,
0.5073162317,
-0.5450437069,
-0.2256986797,
0.0291552544,
0.4296240509,
0.8228801489,
0.0807456896,
-0.7733731866,
-0.0606464185,
0.0248260405,
-0.3088411093,
0.7964451909,
0.3009890318,
-0.2783618569,
0.5947600007,
0.4832122922,
0.1672876477,
0.3038017154,
0.3276915848,
0.6232664585,
-0.293518126,
-0.6572412252,
-0.4375123978,
0.5252369642,
-0.0712018311,
-0.447578311,
1.0675020218,
0.8083664775,
0.7863228321,
-0.0449512489,
0.6488585472,
-0.0656014457,
0.4978978038,
-0.2521297038,
0.8497136235,
-0.3924748898,
-0.0828701332,
-0.2738736272,
-0.565192461,
-0.5998328924,
0.3341676593,
-0.0800701082,
-0.3544259667,
0.4389569163,
0.8057994843,
0.052248463,
-0.0967700854,
0.5841699839,
0.1396415234,
0.1434236318,
0.2958728075,
-0.0049890564,
-0.5721547008,
0.636972785,
-0.1962269098,
-0.4585478902,
0.1426893324,
-0.9190599918,
-0.7866209745,
-0.8218927383,
-0.6290206313,
-0.2589478791,
-0.1358788759,
0.352193445,
0.7810635567,
-0.738653183,
-0.2317794263,
-0.0729496032,
-0.181611985,
-0.4369461536,
-0.101540111,
0.4874482751,
0.0916020498,
-0.5589663386,
0.3977178037,
0.2811626196,
0.3431865871,
-0.4871383607,
-0.1100012586,
0.1436493248,
-0.3496753871,
0.4522092044,
0.8030051589,
-0.6116591692,
-0.3347328901,
-0.3097426295,
-0.0384070463,
0.0521688089,
0.7373459935,
-0.4096302092,
0.6488373876,
0.0845303312,
0.4803256094,
1.2032059431,
0.398939997,
0.2665013969,
-1.2400093079,
0.2500974536,
0.2604660988,
-0.226359874,
0.4681292176,
-0.6002148986,
0.5640541911,
0.1438912004,
-0.3267212212,
-0.6957489848,
0.5468300581,
-1.0467575788,
0.0925215259,
1.1375361681,
-0.4047693014,
-0.1380818039,
-0.2589101493,
0.2672674954,
0.1740651131,
-0.311521858,
0.5866889358,
0.2682752609,
-0.2802406251,
-0.2628823817,
-0.3603495955,
0.6801729202,
0.2756745517,
-0.4904081821,
0.5836759806,
0.3770051003,
0.334733814,
0.0725385249,
1.0189009905,
-0.377364248,
0.0957925394,
-0.0184718277,
0.0788080767,
-0.3953870237,
-0.2513100803,
-0.3486737013,
0.0458882637,
-0.0136786271,
-0.50001055
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09609v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09609v1
|
LogicPrpBank: A Corpus for Logical Implication and Equivalence
| 2024-02-14T22:36:07 | 2024-02-14T22:36:07 |
Zhexiong Liu, Jing Zhang, Jiaying Lu, Wenjing Ma, Joyce C Ho
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Logic reasoning has been critically needed in problem-solving and
decision-making. Although Language Models (LMs) have demonstrated capabilities
of handling multiple reasoning tasks (e.g., commonsense reasoning), their
ability to reason complex mathematical problems, specifically propositional
logic, remains largely underexplored. This lack of exploration can be
attributed to the limited availability of annotated corpora. Here, we present a
well-labeled propositional logic corpus, LogicPrpBank, containing 7093
Propositional Logic Statements (PLSs) across six mathematical subjects, to
study a brand-new task of reasoning logical implication and equivalence. We
benchmark LogicPrpBank with widely-used LMs to show that our corpus offers a
useful resource for this challenging task and there is ample room for model
improvement.
|
[
-0.3154570162,
-0.4433988035,
0.6436014771,
0.2317094654,
-0.0611527152,
-0.240469709,
-0.221064508,
-0.3263157606,
-0.3509889841,
0.5562036037,
-0.2700357437,
-0.1399161667,
-0.6436973214,
0.3702916205,
-0.4390688241,
0.8825349212,
0.1003186852,
0.1847250611,
-0.5132356882,
-0.0231867395,
-0.3724624515,
-0.5673862696,
-0.4569571018,
-0.3261570334,
0.0081075905,
0.100629054,
0.9457600713,
0.2563443482,
0.7794782519,
0.3633562922,
0.1389103383,
0.1473785788,
0.0942255333,
-0.0450733043,
-0.7734645009,
-0.3813975453,
-0.2710668743,
-0.1559629589,
0.4427107871,
0.921856463,
0.1247699633,
0.4470592737,
-0.2804513872,
0.5104485154,
-0.7460727692,
0.2836489379,
-0.6062917113,
-0.1570609063,
-0.0744266063,
0.1835933626,
-0.5394450426,
-0.3837234974,
0.4188065231,
-0.8765161037,
0.1127205789,
0.1705886126,
0.5296257734,
0.1964044422,
-0.2554222047,
-0.2610344589,
-0.4547803104,
0.7444586754,
-0.5587561131,
0.2336595953,
0.2430112213,
0.4397830665,
-0.1127179414,
-0.803252399,
-0.7203295231,
0.093202807,
-0.3301585615,
0.1058515385,
-0.4570567906,
-0.0179975051,
0.5065839291,
-0.0285822116,
-0.4630016387,
-0.331746012,
-0.5377891064,
-0.3931298554,
0.4278633893,
-0.2020404637,
0.1778976172,
-0.5991681814,
-0.390293479,
0.033900626,
-0.6593783498,
0.1056849584,
0.487619549,
0.288515687,
0.1548062861,
0.6455186009,
-0.006061519,
1.0960098505,
-0.3732832074,
-0.2511357069,
0.2120951116,
-0.1457365602,
-0.1376350075,
0.3620148897,
0.2732553184,
0.2835425735,
0.4162428677,
0.4279638529,
-0.3943190873,
0.4872951806,
0.1306986064,
-0.4967834353,
-0.3298616409,
0.3379361331,
-0.3070206642,
0.2040703595,
0.1891675442,
-0.3982512355,
-0.4515456259,
-0.7034998536,
0.4572088718,
-0.7226774096,
-0.2994954884,
0.7375745177,
-0.4378621876,
0.0785704702,
0.3717594743,
-0.6639432311,
0.4231619239,
1.1977523565,
0.2900772393,
-0.0138132423,
-0.1374339461,
-0.6575213075,
-0.0192192681,
-0.2864282429,
1.0790326595,
-0.8321635127,
-0.1824207753,
0.072591424,
-0.3033219576,
-0.1575375348,
-0.7835600972,
1.408049345,
-0.3060297072,
0.177349776,
-0.228551805,
-1.007651329,
-0.1618993133,
0.1365460008,
-0.5254822373,
0.6993129253,
0.110938333,
-0.5492432117,
-0.1235620528,
-0.5357877612,
-0.319224447,
0.2521013021,
-0.2402695268,
0.0401941687,
0.2471869141,
0.1482171863,
0.1694927812,
-0.3087544441,
0.7129662037,
-0.2151617855,
-0.0826372355,
0.6346143484,
-0.2018679678,
0.857000351,
0.3498294652,
0.0728247538,
0.1527241617,
-0.7547026277,
-0.2012405246,
-0.0731895715,
0.1786128432,
-0.4752241969,
0.0488286354,
-0.1477892101,
0.4269864261,
0.4704720974,
-0.6923450828,
-0.0398015939,
-0.4785289168,
0.6202559471,
0.5238182545,
-0.3689782619,
0.0854429901,
-0.4392132759,
0.2180221677,
0.1361946166,
-0.0617266558,
-0.172951296,
-0.5769371986,
-0.5089913011,
-0.4171350896,
0.4151829779,
0.6634973288,
-0.4267444313,
0.3991960585,
-0.0778604969,
-0.1692356616,
-0.6479818225,
-0.0434710421,
0.4084812999,
1.0974345207,
0.3933085799,
0.2473100424,
-0.6517983675,
-1.3034316301,
-0.5663060546,
0.0321932957,
-0.2372106314,
0.070584707,
0.5556635261,
0.2829864323,
1.2095052004,
-0.5236070752,
-0.2339649796,
-0.2998694777,
0.0173411015,
0.5358090401,
0.4173303545,
0.3937131763,
-0.9448288679,
-0.1006076336,
-0.4849451184,
-0.6157470345,
-0.3826855421,
-0.1455256492,
-0.2593877912,
0.0491423123,
0.2950348556,
-0.7062740326,
0.3485974967,
0.2734751701,
-0.3499032557,
0.6334630847,
-0.3071210682,
-0.1651285589,
-0.6498205066,
0.0701402351,
0.2086948156,
-0.2384418696,
-0.4773948789,
-0.0998750031,
0.2383704931,
-0.4587671161,
-0.559022367,
0.6989177465,
-0.0104494365,
-0.3193515837,
-0.2115849257,
0.640758872,
0.1672502607,
0.2880144417,
0.4545211494,
0.6055061221,
0.5774535537,
-0.2663907111,
0.4758618772,
0.5238742232,
-0.3611212373,
0.6639925838,
-0.486127615,
-0.5306591988,
-0.2442336828,
0.3625787497,
-0.9436324835,
0.0067544049,
0.1824735105,
-0.3004393876,
-0.3743151426,
0.0441360697,
-0.5735934973,
-0.3905667067,
0.0267097577,
0.5634943843,
0.3332851827,
-0.685947001,
0.8084217906,
0.18905586,
-0.270906806,
-0.424998641,
-0.2660099864,
-0.2257111967,
-0.202458024,
-0.4811789691,
0.3639276922,
0.2611502707,
-0.6841127872,
0.2133526951,
-0.3161503077,
0.1490942687,
-0.0558763407,
0.1603800803,
0.7058857083,
-0.0654143989,
0.3975564837,
-0.1402449012,
-0.4095090926,
0.402851969,
-0.629095614,
0.2796341479,
-0.6060135961,
-0.377894491,
-0.288598001,
0.2160302103,
-0.0638674647,
-0.5154013634,
0.5729938149,
0.126699701,
-0.7208118439,
-0.1654114723,
-0.3055953681,
-0.0012846626,
-0.3951750696,
-0.0884401351,
-0.5882051587,
-0.7060414553,
0.2574009001,
-0.4399620593,
0.0974052846,
0.7246609926,
0.2985247672,
0.117152974,
0.6283755302,
-0.0820039362,
0.5239928961,
-0.1983065605,
0.2099197954,
0.5510308743,
-0.5691767335,
-0.1101227552,
-0.5913187265,
-0.0282781851,
-0.384435147,
-0.3127184808,
0.1978267282,
0.324560672,
-0.4278813004,
0.5321334004,
-0.5964013338,
0.5221560001,
0.5753312111,
-0.1101840064,
0.4910207093,
-0.2646820247,
-0.0341768637,
-0.2821979821,
-0.4404555857,
-0.6807726622,
1.0356602669,
0.0364446864,
0.0882660747,
0.4005250335,
0.4866788983,
0.2064290792,
0.3604253232,
-0.31894961,
0.6442342401,
-0.3346812129,
-0.9601937532,
-0.1262622774,
-0.2627697289,
-0.6041556597,
0.4350696504,
-0.4871593714,
-0.8303484321,
-0.1385457069,
0.2164316773,
-0.7087858319,
0.1103416607,
-0.9152926207,
1.2311406136,
-0.3213019967,
-0.3592288792,
-0.2874927819,
-0.6013457179,
0.7066597939,
-0.1341655254,
0.3905166388,
-0.4121873975,
-0.0500186421,
0.5550505519,
-0.4669529796,
0.5829367042,
-0.0363503024,
-0.0629231632,
0.6615355015,
0.1726198345,
0.1220096722,
0.2642118931,
-0.1699436605,
-0.1498087049,
0.5131560564,
-0.4754751921,
-0.6797252893,
0.4977228343,
-0.5851390958,
-0.7911449671,
-0.6586208344,
-0.5904419422,
-0.3810094297,
0.3000723124,
-0.2537063956,
0.7611281276,
0.1750870794,
-0.0095800329,
0.6938809156,
-0.4031117558,
0.223410964,
0.1529417336,
-0.5240523815,
-0.2063775212,
0.9377361536,
-0.4193185568,
0.1109055728,
0.8252375722,
0.4442174137,
-0.7925948501,
-0.1571426541,
-0.2097177356,
0.2016550601,
-0.8471022844,
-0.3313579857,
-0.3336327076,
-0.0933914632,
-0.6475355625,
-0.1283455491,
-0.296182245,
-0.9764181376,
0.0680035576,
-0.1494941562,
0.3941605389,
0.1716228276,
-0.2518227696,
-0.0109867612,
-0.640493691,
0.6708400846,
0.1866521537,
0.2767187059,
-0.4421652853,
-0.3948023021,
0.6009441614,
-0.2757283747,
-0.1760130972,
-0.8122215867,
0.2585060894,
0.0751245692,
0.4542653263,
0.3387746811,
0.4575289488,
0.3449814618,
-0.4678055048,
0.2140239924,
0.2879319787,
-1.2685054541,
0.5600683689,
-0.4020858407,
0.0335463881,
0.4099384248,
0.4864237905,
-0.4048449397,
0.1705773771,
-0.8456962109,
-0.4319404066,
0.3014312983,
0.204390496,
-0.2633571923,
-0.2244146764,
0.1991834342,
0.3242988586,
0.4056726396,
-0.4161022902,
0.0008006591,
-0.5214532614,
-0.4464392364,
0.1362986565,
0.0574145652,
-0.218521893,
-0.3489759266,
0.5872808099,
-0.0956897959,
0.1489856541,
0.2086474597,
-0.0863530263,
0.4067853391,
0.5442848802,
0.6115476489,
0.9779779911,
-0.1430050135,
0.5029378533,
0.0426135585,
0.0683134496,
-0.1780284941,
0.6598642468,
-0.0880814716,
-0.0978261083,
0.3991520107,
0.5599182844,
0.3440277576,
-1.5381504297,
0.6001101732,
0.2348525822,
-0.3813435435,
-0.6402088404,
-0.1313988119,
0.6120553017,
0.2205254138,
0.395573467,
0.1663142443,
0.144973129,
-0.4991178215,
0.3993517458,
0.1869330257,
0.247443229,
0.1169938073,
0.6510130167,
0.1269128323,
-0.3910071552,
0.6640657783,
-0.2343631089,
-0.5909551382,
0.3687348068,
0.5217903852,
0.1856572926,
0.2355398089,
0.2318721265,
0.4872936606,
-0.0646893457,
-0.2014080435,
0.1424104869,
0.09418042,
-0.9119575024,
-0.4221537411,
-0.8640836477,
-0.6361056566,
-0.0121801887,
-0.5700542927,
0.145409286,
-0.5434012413,
-0.0483951047,
0.3826622367,
-0.1090833396,
-0.5611184239,
0.1313298494,
0.2329647243,
1.1170507669,
-0.7855961919,
0.666806519,
0.684915781,
-0.3060306311,
-0.6806820631,
-0.6536544561,
-0.0078926273,
-0.6971486807,
0.7932234406,
0.1664453298,
-0.01513483,
-0.2976280749,
-0.2395002842,
-0.5417472124,
0.4998717606,
0.4882262051,
-0.6415836811,
0.2909245789,
0.4598556757,
0.5428245664,
-0.4374252558,
-0.0425448604,
0.6636213064,
0.5882065296,
-0.051102832,
-0.6463592649,
0.0028006895,
-0.2548748255,
-0.1928948164,
0.1856501102,
-0.2394236475,
0.9811100364,
-0.0399361998,
0.0180889219,
-0.0319268703,
0.9720795155,
0.8023865223,
0.1937671006,
0.5701889992,
0.6694328189,
0.7286545038,
-0.285379231,
0.8426763415,
-0.3680014312,
0.0753011331,
1.283213377,
-0.660995543,
1.0629302263,
0.3821959198,
-0.183123678,
0.3278382421,
0.5255281925,
0.0982406288,
0.0941501558,
0.6271085739,
-0.4517565668,
-0.9401804209,
-0.2568405271,
-0.1797809005,
0.3016206026,
0.616094172,
-0.1357895285,
-0.4880191982,
-0.1033779979,
-0.3517824113,
0.826533258,
-0.3276159763,
0.0504562221,
0.1739455611,
-1.0119057894,
0.0724362284,
0.1554206312,
0.2510282397,
-0.3881631196,
-0.042744901,
0.0423499271,
0.5517151356,
-0.2520623505,
-0.9948257208,
0.4133995473,
-0.0009957746,
0.1173435152,
-0.4410840273,
0.8844118714,
-0.053097941,
-0.6791413426,
0.1456499845,
0.6828109026,
0.114298068,
0.0659962147,
-0.6367609501,
-0.0151578272,
-0.3228541315,
0.1066781357,
0.3200713396,
0.4539692998,
-0.3192980886,
0.6527215838,
0.5768669248,
-0.0070205601,
0.0165132638,
0.0529362001,
0.5689882636,
-0.5972562432,
-0.2793551087,
-0.586433053,
0.0159144849,
-0.1668555439,
-0.557010293,
0.5453985929,
0.8518050909,
1.0114752054,
-0.0330780335,
0.8555011749,
-0.003180471,
0.8215424418,
-0.3619070947,
-0.2862253785,
-0.2761777043,
0.2609497607,
-0.2533928454,
-0.6823230982,
-0.5156350136,
1.0176957846,
-0.8319242001,
-0.5549215674,
0.8157307506,
0.4211483598,
-0.1697487831,
0.6534333825,
-0.0192815047,
-0.2698151767,
-0.0206980761,
0.8844411373,
0.8673671484,
-0.2166515291,
0.7293354273,
-0.214400664,
-0.0208434202,
0.2163161337,
-1.0958658457,
-0.7102553844,
-0.6156321764,
-0.3369357884,
-0.3535137475,
0.0343895108,
1.248839736,
0.1068500206,
-0.8506266475,
-0.0822022185,
-0.0829372332,
0.1487867534,
-0.3093900383,
-0.1157737225,
0.5074272752,
-0.248570174,
-0.5770264864,
0.1205947995,
0.2142681628,
-0.2844216824,
-0.034876477,
0.1974163949,
-0.255271107,
0.0390550233,
0.4799048603,
0.4486647546,
-0.7589982152,
-0.4222039282,
-0.2213385999,
-0.0504246727,
-0.1377613395,
0.9565060139,
-0.8014340401,
0.0427643061,
0.5996559858,
0.8866420984,
0.2728260159,
0.330947727,
0.4232922792,
-0.2728476226,
0.3253611326,
0.365907222,
0.6990261674,
0.3159418702,
0.2710169554,
0.4507725239,
0.3897827566,
-0.0691163093,
-0.6429306865,
0.5198253393,
-0.9563778043,
-0.786839366,
0.9619424939,
-0.0857525319,
-0.2256129384,
-0.0168766472,
-0.210252434,
-0.0569650494,
-0.3839140534,
0.4363156557,
0.8273764849,
-0.4332640469,
-0.084977068,
-0.7017880678,
0.5526005626,
0.6898135543,
-0.7932829261,
0.1485623419,
0.5921658874,
0.020430658,
0.4670455456,
0.4865546525,
-0.098604843,
0.2318007201,
0.0747222006,
-0.283360064,
0.0705112144,
-0.2447854578,
-0.0738045052,
0.5007128119,
-0.1306634098,
0.162620753
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09588v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09588v2
|
Emerging Opportunities of Using Large Language Models for Translation Between Drug Molecules and Indications
| 2024-02-14T21:33:13 | 2024-02-16T20:55:08 |
David Oniani, Jordan Hilsman, Chengxi Zang, Junmei Wang, Lianjin Cai, Jan Zawala, Yanshan Wang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
A drug molecule is a substance that changes the organism's mental or physical
state. Every approved drug has an indication, which refers to the therapeutic
use of that drug for treating a particular medical condition. While the Large
Language Model (LLM), a generative Artificial Intelligence (AI) technique, has
recently demonstrated effectiveness in translating between molecules and their
textual descriptions, there remains a gap in research regarding their
application in facilitating the translation between drug molecules and
indications, or vice versa, which could greatly benefit the drug discovery
process. The capability of generating a drug from a given indication would
allow for the discovery of drugs targeting specific diseases or targets and
ultimately provide patients with better treatments. In this paper, we first
propose a new task, which is the translation between drug molecules and
corresponding indications, and then test existing LLMs on this new task.
Specifically, we consider nine variations of the T5 LLM and evaluate them on
two public datasets obtained from ChEMBL and DrugBank. Our experiments show the
early results of using LLMs for this task and provide a perspective on the
state-of-the-art. We also emphasize the current limitations and discuss future
work that has the potential to improve the performance on this task. The
creation of molecules from indications, or vice versa, will allow for more
efficient targeting of diseases and significantly reduce the cost of drug
discovery, with the potential to revolutionize the field of drug discovery in
the era of generative AI.
|
[
0.0584420823,
-0.7550601959,
1.065490365,
-0.025548229,
-0.0879861116,
0.0512703359,
-0.4998924136,
-0.596660316,
0.1356185675,
0.4838820994,
-0.2187030017,
-0.7324195504,
-0.9372509718,
0.5099455714,
-0.5039391518,
0.926872611,
-0.2440000027,
0.3795136213,
-0.2444671988,
-0.0510250926,
-0.3529301584,
-0.6258555651,
-0.532328248,
-0.6447983384,
0.7039533854,
0.0221622121,
0.2752444744,
0.5423449278,
0.9381010532,
0.3704091907,
-0.0860283673,
0.0168288518,
-0.186630249,
0.1611455381,
-0.3617197573,
-0.8077509403,
-0.4853485227,
-0.0540966503,
0.6931645274,
0.7622722387,
-0.1819806993,
-0.119989723,
-0.3159258962,
0.5733150244,
-0.4300282896,
0.1112648696,
-0.4533747435,
0.3548077047,
-0.3294578195,
0.0259509198,
-0.1821757555,
-0.109509401,
0.3470238149,
-0.473587513,
0.2049579471,
0.0978069827,
0.9052512646,
0.246267736,
-0.3462914228,
-0.648065865,
-0.8106335402,
0.843818903,
-0.9940367341,
0.4177157879,
-0.1637001336,
0.6298257709,
-0.7755020857,
-0.9303742647,
-0.4045946002,
-0.6499679685,
0.0177821293,
-0.1296951175,
-0.2051619738,
0.1003075168,
0.1846477538,
0.4823950231,
-0.293302238,
0.3298730254,
-0.3957079053,
-0.2994305789,
0.3928493559,
0.2602489889,
0.6337352991,
-0.1690333039,
-0.5895470381,
0.2426684648,
-1.0208297968,
-0.2705437839,
-0.2467622459,
0.3858312368,
-0.0621435344,
0.8559793234,
-0.1975537091,
0.6634597778,
-0.059016183,
-0.1527823359,
0.1035584062,
-0.4253712595,
-0.4348979592,
0.2925275266,
1.0002542734,
0.3694649935,
-0.0423913524,
-0.0493585281,
-0.4146368504,
-0.0652112588,
0.0164646134,
-0.9629161358,
-0.0502181165,
0.6562356949,
-0.5671235323,
-0.3823319077,
-0.2986126542,
-0.7911558747,
-0.6166641116,
-0.1344230324,
0.3768855035,
-0.5549329519,
-0.0695014521,
0.2231194824,
-0.0294073783,
0.1274753809,
0.3420100212,
-0.9700407386,
0.0379180796,
0.6490095258,
0.8428000212,
-0.4105598629,
-0.1954300255,
-0.4596163034,
0.4675392509,
-0.6029520035,
0.9649171233,
-0.5330814123,
-0.5179159641,
0.0577415824,
-0.1747342795,
0.0876993984,
-0.851537168,
0.3640682101,
-0.2612755597,
0.0222064126,
-0.2745339274,
-0.6699315906,
-0.1121096388,
0.3977754414,
-0.7823914289,
0.3457708955,
0.1195005774,
-0.2015364766,
0.362962544,
-0.8904083371,
-0.3829081059,
0.1244998425,
-0.2160083801,
-0.2409283072,
0.3901155591,
0.1096808389,
0.3684158027,
-0.611946702,
0.4940221012,
0.0369138941,
-0.1659323126,
0.866155386,
-0.282582581,
0.4994247258,
0.3708139956,
-0.1719772667,
0.2730253637,
-0.3625235558,
-0.3083287477,
0.0149276527,
-0.6299427152,
-0.1036828458,
-0.0260133166,
0.0239915028,
0.2124959528,
0.5031315088,
-0.511210978,
0.5201564431,
-0.3914472163,
0.7409080267,
0.590362668,
0.1113827601,
0.2470860183,
-0.0189156737,
0.6075507402,
0.235650599,
0.0116889263,
-0.1577574611,
-0.5540365577,
-0.5706127882,
-0.2997123599,
0.6823384762,
0.4429321289,
-0.6223917007,
0.218337968,
-0.378102988,
-0.104183495,
-0.4874898493,
0.2478372455,
0.3281679153,
0.122494027,
0.3898682296,
-0.1324238181,
-0.352258265,
-0.8581323028,
-0.3083422482,
-0.0361639336,
-0.0762937441,
0.2497462481,
0.5793665051,
-0.6367468834,
0.4535075426,
-0.5332542658,
-0.6333374977,
-0.5635868311,
-0.2495447844,
0.2596535087,
0.1508859545,
0.3512957394,
-0.7860902548,
-0.3637177646,
0.3349823356,
-0.8499022722,
-0.1961819082,
-0.0707819238,
-0.1966802478,
0.0758150592,
0.7372482419,
-0.8589758277,
0.0394488834,
0.5132290125,
0.0017712492,
0.1001553684,
-0.4348288774,
0.0567875691,
-1.1959397793,
0.0880287141,
0.1639129072,
-0.0916818678,
-0.9235776067,
0.0065393723,
-0.1434649527,
-0.1334466487,
-0.5232112408,
0.6824849248,
-0.4440278709,
0.1335356981,
-0.3195042312,
0.094118759,
-0.0664144456,
0.0170725249,
-0.0637498572,
0.5698599219,
0.4190938771,
-0.5330995321,
0.5796762109,
0.1554445326,
-0.363717705,
0.3297364116,
-0.5275353789,
-0.1916240603,
0.103612259,
0.3572595119,
-0.5840100646,
-0.6071231365,
0.6281847358,
-0.3447603881,
0.4276095927,
-0.0029035909,
-0.4673927128,
-0.3750647604,
0.1119882911,
0.3741643131,
0.5726415515,
-0.3089084923,
0.6008343697,
0.2916789055,
-0.1142666712,
-0.3180264235,
-0.7821434736,
0.3011571765,
-0.3598144054,
-0.2526765764,
0.4848672152,
0.2638252974,
-0.3247786164,
0.1167373136,
0.0421908423,
0.1363545507,
-0.0959730819,
-0.0685213208,
0.3829652965,
-0.1581549793,
0.2522080243,
0.1252411902,
-0.2014954239,
0.1168975085,
-0.5190686584,
0.4330607355,
0.0728158578,
-0.17458722,
-0.2890145779,
0.5862643719,
0.6637498736,
-0.3675884008,
0.5681902766,
0.2932516932,
-0.3900667727,
-0.2537939548,
-0.1892827451,
-0.0357794575,
-0.4459510744,
0.5236185193,
-0.3001150787,
-0.530223012,
0.2772669792,
-0.5964961648,
-0.3044071496,
0.303194195,
0.9875568748,
0.1683964878,
0.8284297585,
0.5054497719,
0.0734784529,
0.2566666603,
-0.2217447013,
0.5887416601,
-0.9474004507,
-0.4645801783,
-0.299646467,
-0.2659149766,
-0.7458533645,
-0.8391877413,
0.7309230566,
-0.1268950552,
0.0968655273,
0.1742695719,
-0.3446847796,
0.1475416869,
0.4722547233,
0.1205646247,
0.241851002,
-0.0426756144,
-0.0408338606,
0.1890884191,
-0.6235013008,
-0.4713861048,
1.418474555,
0.2069005519,
0.389593631,
0.1535401493,
0.6409450173,
0.2973237336,
0.6336445808,
-1.0007324219,
0.7368617654,
-0.3603083491,
-0.6006904244,
-0.1567530036,
-0.31926018,
-1.0774600506,
-0.1295687556,
-0.3904046714,
-0.5189934373,
0.2663353086,
0.0902052745,
-0.2259837985,
0.238609314,
-0.628374815,
0.7701473236,
-0.6826511621,
-0.091562435,
-0.2119895518,
-0.5229610205,
0.1063543484,
-0.2951747477,
0.0400800072,
-0.3407587111,
-0.0838174075,
0.3814660609,
-0.2642473578,
0.6105989218,
-0.0941207334,
-0.6320184469,
0.1803160757,
-0.3207420409,
0.3990760148,
-0.2679601312,
-0.1214712858,
0.3779927492,
-0.2523236573,
-0.3942469656,
-0.7607246637,
0.6482447982,
-0.4316613674,
-0.7250002027,
-0.4570340812,
-0.673992157,
-0.0866145641,
0.4319703281,
0.3215285838,
0.2328099906,
-0.281370759,
-0.0912770107,
0.4491651654,
-0.6100216508,
0.028013505,
0.6121765375,
-0.505723834,
-0.2038788199,
0.9870167971,
-0.1559895277,
0.4126087427,
0.8319872022,
0.3050305545,
-0.3160255551,
-1.1008056402,
-0.457321316,
0.2390273809,
-0.5103820562,
-0.2022525668,
-0.2037567943,
-0.0459861197,
-0.4363652468,
-0.0446594954,
-0.3672394156,
-0.0963608474,
0.1694614887,
0.1155765951,
0.2833833396,
0.7330059409,
-0.0730659887,
-0.175416559,
-0.865829587,
0.5601296425,
-0.0833488256,
0.265337497,
-0.2521734238,
-0.0072447616,
-0.4596326053,
0.3633547127,
-0.1118161604,
-0.7464526892,
0.3945026994,
0.1826841533,
0.6448218226,
0.6031799316,
-0.3260756433,
0.1622769833,
-0.7174246311,
0.6067800522,
0.1992349476,
-0.7550304532,
0.7805025578,
-0.5159264207,
0.0823471472,
0.1516080201,
0.4082135856,
-0.685823679,
-0.3428973854,
-0.2048161179,
-0.9121229053,
0.3295400143,
0.3344675004,
0.0106620593,
0.0549402386,
0.499902755,
0.014388483,
0.2973825634,
-0.3758043349,
-0.2276539654,
0.0663520247,
-0.2400693744,
-0.0741372854,
0.0332763232,
-0.4362381399,
0.0919295251,
0.419911474,
0.024026433,
0.6964346766,
0.219887495,
0.0446842164,
0.0480966121,
0.5136196613,
0.5843346715,
0.3836590052,
-0.1335001439,
-0.1470953822,
-0.1570812613,
-0.6428555846,
0.3017656505,
0.408189863,
-0.4182975888,
-0.2057754844,
0.4698149264,
0.5999504328,
-0.3451811969,
-1.0918726921,
0.1568220109,
0.2827158272,
0.00439785,
-0.2929411232,
0.1628277898,
-0.0598342493,
0.5156204104,
0.1331138313,
-0.0963705778,
0.3216148019,
-0.8360010982,
-0.1183715761,
0.4652534723,
-0.2207966894,
-0.1786243916,
0.6309997439,
0.2609262168,
-0.4986995161,
0.6944262981,
-0.0326148644,
-0.5215513706,
0.6951677799,
0.6560983062,
0.8683999777,
-0.4416382313,
0.1523589045,
0.0465903953,
-0.0602652878,
0.0242926795,
-0.1427266449,
0.2676933706,
-0.8779685497,
-0.2354647517,
-0.5507651567,
-0.4615526199,
0.1085837111,
-0.2593010068,
0.3519051671,
-0.198578611,
-0.1802743971,
0.4338302016,
-0.2034031451,
-0.2524562776,
0.1483457386,
0.2817058563,
0.5306791067,
-0.7774165869,
1.0217189789,
1.0067305565,
-0.3640411794,
-0.6080621481,
0.1919053197,
0.0360693,
-0.5898120403,
0.6595790386,
-0.0175406449,
0.0204419047,
-0.2932138741,
-0.3646221161,
-0.9363790154,
1.2419637442,
0.2069524527,
-0.6518312097,
-0.1969949156,
0.6173102856,
0.8600248098,
-0.6797958612,
-0.1968296766,
0.8279178739,
0.6044399738,
0.0939442515,
-0.7357935309,
0.2170954794,
-0.3759494424,
0.1975670457,
0.4476763308,
-0.4691796005,
0.8717339039,
-0.5061567426,
0.0646939874,
0.4862842262,
0.3844388127,
0.3525495529,
0.3553710282,
0.0900394097,
0.3490079045,
0.7075038552,
-0.2507260442,
1.2789925337,
-0.2790641189,
0.2833595276,
0.6555327177,
-0.5180811286,
0.7338030934,
0.5674695373,
-0.3943730295,
0.5332239866,
0.562784791,
-0.5055279732,
0.5422207117,
0.4759235382,
-0.6075181365,
-0.12379805,
-0.3021548986,
-0.2220604718,
0.3642656803,
0.9773263335,
-0.602628231,
-0.0406596996,
0.3137162328,
-0.0522745028,
-0.0621890463,
-0.2720346749,
0.592448175,
0.4101654291,
-0.657864511,
0.4369306266,
0.3579871058,
0.1552612782,
-0.6645286083,
-0.3062227368,
-0.1956411302,
0.3714385629,
-0.083257623,
-0.3840155303,
-0.1084917039,
-0.0758671537,
0.0250337012,
0.1315783262,
0.6702763438,
-0.5803730488,
-0.6671607494,
0.3186905682,
0.271048516,
0.2653476894,
0.2743835151,
-0.5791072249,
0.0811040178,
0.013120424,
0.0916355997,
0.273791045,
0.7570648193,
-0.1438905746,
0.8924438953,
0.6189520359,
0.5519902706,
-0.1475767046,
-0.1091949865,
0.7490622997,
-0.6558519006,
0.0601870306,
-0.7922372222,
0.1653143317,
0.1186894104,
-0.0207249932,
0.6564795971,
0.5827088356,
0.3745593727,
-0.2095070481,
0.9098082781,
-0.0375525057,
0.2865161598,
-0.8679640889,
0.4603953063,
-0.5284893513,
0.5688628554,
-0.0988179669,
-0.7955442667,
-0.4432825446,
0.2801446915,
-0.3298399746,
0.1000089645,
0.9115387797,
0.6276772022,
0.174567312,
-0.2831796706,
0.1467686892,
0.6319836378,
0.6211710572,
1.1047688723,
0.7635655999,
-0.3823737204,
0.3798175454,
-0.0163833946,
0.1337824464,
-0.3760606945,
-0.6796472669,
-0.7966979742,
-0.267279774,
-0.1796405017,
-0.5346803069,
0.2309368104,
1.0796848536,
0.3499907553,
-1.0155985355,
-0.2521501184,
-0.2765472233,
0.0227380972,
-0.1972631812,
-0.0812711492,
0.4480735958,
-0.1059210673,
-1.0358024836,
0.4084647596,
0.4738542736,
0.3033477366,
-0.3812228739,
0.0067665433,
-0.1920746267,
-0.0178013407,
0.7417231798,
0.259213835,
-0.8257730603,
-0.0638902932,
0.0913204402,
-0.1535463184,
0.0959330872,
1.1432888508,
-0.5967522264,
0.4021156132,
0.2873116434,
0.6258073449,
0.3960335851,
-0.0928988829,
1.1713345051,
0.0115418574,
0.0143527836,
0.3321477175,
0.2773652673,
0.3567816317,
-0.348600775,
0.4569996595,
0.0132857738,
-0.4103549719,
-0.5795298219,
0.3323069513,
-0.8598535657,
-0.4980924129,
1.3447102308,
-0.2186238319,
-0.2853288949,
-0.0392369628,
-0.1208184287,
0.199690029,
-0.4291449189,
0.926237762,
0.6055877805,
-0.3306789994,
0.1896285266,
-0.7806583643,
0.6084018946,
0.2571300864,
-0.9918968678,
-0.0230033454,
0.6038121581,
0.100970678,
0.3242792487,
0.6962829828,
-0.4388108253,
0.1487871855,
-0.2554603219,
0.0371797979,
0.2354821265,
-0.3266324103,
-0.2994463146,
-0.0870290622,
0.1604191512,
-0.086876601
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09573v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09573v2
|
Changes by Butterflies: Farsighted Forecasting with Group Reservoir Transformer
| 2024-02-14T20:48:58 | 2024-06-13T21:22:02 |
Md Kowsher, Abdul Rafae Khan, Jia Xu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
In Chaos, a minor divergence between two initial conditions exhibits
exponential amplification over time, leading to far-away outcomes, known as the
butterfly effect. Thus, the distant future is full of uncertainty and hard to
forecast. We introduce Group Reservoir Transformer to predict long-term events
more accurately and robustly by overcoming two challenges in Chaos: (1) the
extensive historical sequences and (2) the sensitivity to initial conditions. A
reservoir is attached to a Transformer to efficiently handle arbitrarily long
historical lengths, with an extension of a group of reservoirs to reduce the
sensitivity to the initialization variations. Our architecture consistently
outperforms state-of-the-art models in multivariate time series, including
TimeLLM, GPT2TS, PatchTST, DLinear, TimeNet, and the baseline Transformer, with
an error reduction of up to -59\% in various fields such as ETTh, ETTm, and air
quality, demonstrating that an ensemble of butterfly learning can improve the
adequacy and certainty of event prediction, despite of the traveling time to
the unknown future.
|
[
-0.5241548419,
-0.1328304261,
0.3348868787,
0.4250609875,
-0.2771593928,
0.0214064028,
0.2837156653,
-0.5486355424,
0.4551033378,
0.3998401165,
-0.9911878705,
0.0199780613,
-0.7528907061,
0.0772295892,
-0.4620074928,
0.9836304784,
0.0553020388,
-0.1843400598,
0.7718777657,
0.3351136744,
-0.0610326789,
-0.1688555777,
-0.5043995976,
-0.4169310927,
0.7481171489,
-0.2214972377,
0.8955852985,
0.5554856658,
0.6326876283,
0.2824526429,
-0.1204123199,
0.1050066501,
-0.5796632171,
0.2587964535,
0.1221919954,
-0.4926930964,
0.0608713515,
-0.4605129063,
0.4918734729,
0.5791420341,
-0.2365832627,
-0.0991885886,
0.0278862584,
0.8249820471,
-0.7507833838,
0.4086101949,
-0.5685403347,
0.4917910695,
-0.1045970395,
-0.3052067459,
-0.3320896029,
-0.0871405378,
0.2998371124,
-0.8213173151,
0.4106298983,
-0.01734755,
0.7105219364,
0.530921042,
-0.5926282406,
0.047123421,
-1.1240824461,
0.8529232144,
-0.2064442486,
0.7923228145,
0.0528334863,
0.6264128685,
-0.3748314083,
-0.7650039792,
-0.4120971262,
0.382679224,
0.2995799184,
0.6456128359,
-0.4615868628,
-0.2239050716,
0.0181140434,
0.2106904536,
-0.3313758373,
0.1845330745,
-0.6089065671,
-0.0588723719,
0.4675383568,
0.5144915581,
-0.3269213736,
-0.2190185338,
-0.3821397126,
-0.2689803839,
-0.5089198947,
0.3147292733,
0.3744319677,
0.6806632876,
-0.0261108167,
0.1871313006,
0.1245341599,
0.3388084471,
0.4801385701,
0.009892853,
-0.172820434,
0.3787269294,
-0.2514264584,
-0.1546857059,
0.426787436,
0.5794434547,
-0.3166099191,
-0.5503132343,
-0.0929836482,
-0.1315666884,
-0.0111701181,
-0.9942583442,
-0.3946381807,
-0.0147082675,
-0.4335301518,
-0.3107692897,
0.0609299056,
-1.4774098396,
-0.7838471532,
-0.1792607605,
0.2878195047,
-0.2246483415,
-0.2354071587,
-0.0265113916,
-0.3240740895,
0.1321472526,
0.3729017675,
-1.1374756098,
0.0688579604,
0.6772351265,
1.0203270912,
-0.1904281974,
-0.3918820024,
-0.2063037753,
0.5693819523,
-0.4409028888,
1.0270477533,
-0.1290337592,
-0.8340885043,
-0.0786904842,
-0.0220832899,
0.1098614782,
-0.4726882577,
0.1191215366,
-0.628625989,
-0.0012214836,
0.0489397645,
-0.1568908244,
-0.1637229323,
-0.1566471905,
-0.8852345347,
0.392187655,
0.2244641334,
-0.3613928854,
0.7795212269,
-0.6905615926,
-0.3152516186,
-0.4612791836,
0.3149103522,
-0.8171349168,
0.2965371609,
0.5436793566,
0.4649699032,
-0.0087859072,
0.2914074957,
-0.703135848,
-0.3263612688,
0.2748066783,
-0.5924542546,
0.6380325556,
0.2002757788,
0.2008557022,
0.0591707826,
-0.7447098494,
-0.2966248691,
-0.2653673589,
0.063900359,
-0.1354064792,
0.3404890895,
0.2580376863,
0.1168168038,
-0.4117746949,
-0.1007897705,
0.5554031134,
-0.4840174317,
0.63326478,
1.3016713858,
0.5065180063,
0.4723922312,
-0.3909986317,
0.4458451271,
0.5153300762,
0.9212810397,
-0.2056016326,
-0.413369596,
-0.6631512642,
-0.4016379714,
-0.2703023553,
0.340228647,
-0.4852519631,
0.1817933321,
-0.4840298295,
-0.7516434789,
-0.1122471392,
-0.1118442863,
-0.6538665891,
0.0907474235,
0.6159114242,
0.1816732287,
-0.869002223,
-0.536965251,
-0.2093120068,
-0.0802014098,
-0.1084115952,
-0.2355125248,
0.3366067708,
-0.5522356033,
0.9563363194,
-0.8394536376,
-0.232112512,
0.2991711795,
0.431961745,
0.7352419496,
0.1242046431,
0.4925568104,
-0.9758149981,
-0.2574781775,
-0.1380028278,
-0.4333967268,
0.4401597381,
-0.0939761624,
0.2425128669,
0.1993104517,
0.1534308046,
-0.5436871052,
0.4788166881,
0.7209913135,
0.0944078863,
0.2592018545,
0.2206228524,
0.2288044244,
-1.4443398714,
-0.3877395391,
-0.1554579139,
0.4023081362,
-0.5359161496,
-0.445887655,
-0.0204444472,
-0.3194560111,
-0.2308366597,
0.2162433565,
-0.3534700274,
0.2205690593,
0.0040683844,
-0.7193551064,
-0.4309042096,
0.1750967503,
-0.1378097385,
0.6677249074,
0.6560111046,
-0.6999536157,
0.4069094062,
0.1275294274,
-0.2412781715,
0.027254926,
-0.1520693898,
0.0761402622,
-0.1834787726,
0.3316763341,
-0.6583442688,
-0.1529047191,
0.0893997997,
-0.3034634292,
0.5510223508,
-0.1136366725,
-0.0341224633,
-0.8156763315,
-0.4351548851,
0.0048501557,
0.4259181917,
-0.7321783304,
1.1980003119,
-0.1891764104,
-0.0304886363,
-0.9371891022,
-0.9313755631,
0.1349133849,
-0.45849666,
-0.2840289772,
-0.0390547067,
0.0537360385,
-0.1475008577,
-0.119920738,
-0.3474901617,
-0.612824738,
0.0749696866,
0.8004724383,
0.3180160224,
-0.1638227254,
0.288549751,
0.0770126656,
-0.368262738,
-0.1015062183,
-0.5923383832,
0.236385718,
0.1569977999,
-0.325696677,
-0.2273137569,
0.4674807787,
0.6317948103,
0.0996575803,
0.8101959825,
0.3448147476,
-0.4061384797,
-0.2909459472,
-0.3165994287,
-0.5141775608,
-0.5018010736,
0.5716246367,
-0.3351821005,
-0.990865767,
0.964107573,
-0.2339300662,
-0.1291725338,
0.644507587,
0.2796639502,
-0.1883260459,
0.6498598456,
0.8156654835,
-0.5145300031,
0.5970590115,
-0.386049509,
0.5033702254,
-0.5603954792,
-0.1849712878,
-0.3823497891,
-0.1694303453,
-0.7869896889,
-0.3333338499,
0.5169743299,
0.224674359,
-0.4154333174,
0.1588127017,
-0.4330607057,
0.2725043595,
-0.037927635,
0.2159942538,
0.2386919558,
-0.0524052829,
0.5934138298,
-0.327567786,
-0.3656677902,
0.0561775118,
1.354473114,
-0.0103189796,
0.9942700267,
0.1968297809,
0.8721475601,
0.3434232473,
0.8545766473,
-0.5227131844,
-0.0017167345,
-0.0855922922,
-0.7275354266,
-0.4209843576,
-0.2788445055,
-1.023914814,
0.1243990138,
-0.2214233875,
-0.8995965123,
0.5577631593,
0.2706599534,
-0.7051402926,
0.63616395,
-0.2550373673,
0.3444316983,
-0.1190663427,
-0.2525416017,
-0.1056691408,
-0.4916365743,
0.2781844139,
-0.6531139016,
0.0611914918,
0.1216079071,
-0.2337205559,
0.1058381125,
-0.0358715318,
0.8574556112,
-0.1215074211,
0.0245477371,
0.153761819,
0.0573708788,
0.5766610503,
0.0132086743,
-0.3225415647,
0.2244442999,
-0.3609024882,
-0.1470949799,
-0.881978929,
0.5734450221,
-1.1028609276,
-0.5155960917,
-0.5209009051,
-0.5959265232,
-0.0975078493,
-0.0109635731,
0.6150153875,
0.1949555725,
-0.1985981762,
0.000698617,
0.3999858797,
0.2388174236,
0.7863355279,
0.4944243729,
-0.5708203316,
-0.7804796696,
0.6503891945,
0.3872075677,
0.0161407441,
0.9059083462,
0.067846626,
-0.4254791141,
-0.5772308707,
-0.0303111952,
-0.1998997778,
-0.5734362602,
-0.3866005838,
-0.3349492848,
0.0452214517,
-0.5001577735,
-0.2197451591,
-0.3092588186,
-0.2148868144,
-0.4451885521,
-0.105392009,
0.2086431384,
0.8303296566,
-0.3600103259,
0.6193829179,
-0.8609810472,
0.0433014035,
0.456240356,
0.2936049402,
-0.1702764779,
-0.3159634173,
-0.2268764526,
-0.0663720593,
-0.860978961,
-1.1232566833,
0.4419951141,
0.1592713296,
0.3442358375,
0.976416409,
0.0497566834,
1.1550912857,
-0.4581983089,
0.7064757347,
0.6759537458,
-1.0981553793,
0.4948112965,
-0.5486261249,
-0.0332638025,
-0.0843164995,
0.2726943791,
-0.4141686857,
-0.2649430037,
-0.4887912571,
-0.7453925014,
0.352331847,
0.1076041088,
-0.1106337234,
0.3849445581,
0.555351615,
0.2098137587,
0.2207822502,
-0.7683428526,
-0.2638647854,
-0.649217248,
0.3578185439,
-0.7838764787,
-0.013805191,
0.1839708984,
-0.2059439868,
0.6504975557,
-0.1182106957,
0.5454962254,
0.028569635,
0.4575679302,
-0.7289931178,
0.2809447944,
0.6666319966,
0.6823644638,
-0.3280771077,
-0.1401980668,
0.5383910537,
-0.1822687536,
0.242349416,
0.6641261578,
-0.0208032895,
-0.0631243289,
0.6267136335,
0.7133567929,
0.0237421077,
0.0718453228,
0.1159214005,
0.0878174454,
0.1299861372,
-0.3833567202,
-0.1501399726,
0.0941944793,
0.742356956,
0.9526888728,
0.5502664447,
0.3962171078,
-0.3143464327,
0.0069163376,
0.0429767445,
-0.606144011,
-0.4939163625,
0.7566692829,
0.0754865184,
-0.1349590123,
0.5589979291,
0.226292789,
-0.460909307,
0.6297464371,
0.6255116463,
1.0000776052,
-0.9849960804,
-0.2725208402,
0.0844353959,
0.5931196213,
0.1184579656,
0.0253464449,
0.0233826786,
-0.5077298284,
-0.4877171218,
-0.4875102639,
-0.3758452535,
0.3816428781,
-0.8057478666,
0.2352647483,
-0.3196494579,
-0.4898154438,
0.2186341286,
-0.1117426455,
-0.3045851588,
0.0301612541,
-0.0413560048,
0.8620685339,
-1.2750021219,
0.5460855365,
0.5615782738,
-0.2268994302,
-0.9146236777,
0.1383680403,
0.033829093,
-0.5619877577,
0.4664383233,
0.1447522342,
-0.1611613333,
-0.2604973614,
-0.290217936,
-0.6842874289,
1.211779952,
0.3848493397,
-0.9211589694,
0.0311294552,
0.1847348213,
0.6187286973,
0.1093555242,
0.0571825691,
-0.0505554862,
0.6781708598,
0.115606226,
-0.6517630219,
-0.5338013768,
0.0542417318,
0.2692555189,
0.9675583243,
-0.7678866386,
1.0796191692,
-0.5672908425,
-0.0897579268,
0.3026895523,
1.0829422474,
-0.3235655129,
0.5493108034,
0.4270972311,
0.2922925651,
0.7197079659,
-0.5573648214,
0.7976783514,
-0.319400847,
0.8369383812,
0.8674770594,
-0.3728893101,
0.6463823318,
0.8949483037,
-0.6191636324,
0.3255423009,
0.8101919889,
-0.2939839363,
0.8781903982,
0.1648542136,
-0.4056782126,
-0.3425012529,
0.2486632615,
-0.7878554463,
0.2497817725,
0.2267263234,
-0.1880778074,
-0.4384800494,
0.3135260344,
-0.270829469,
-0.1432266831,
-0.4616087675,
0.3871612847,
0.1353199929,
-0.387390852,
-0.0013527578,
-0.5410203338,
0.4295494258,
-0.7252731919,
-0.0750794932,
-0.123941429,
0.8918443322,
-0.1709152013,
-0.7331309319,
0.4220653176,
-0.6336548328,
-0.5918381214,
-0.0494779237,
0.4681668878,
-0.1177973747,
-0.4768511653,
0.5916932225,
0.1579118073,
-0.2356899977,
-0.2367595881,
-0.3423986435,
-0.0317313634,
-0.1103146747,
-0.3863136172,
-0.0267021991,
0.5326203108,
0.2304971963,
1.0798842907,
0.481123209,
0.0748859346,
0.2754707932,
-0.3097106218,
0.9298112988,
-0.6882701516,
-0.7309858203,
-0.6771194339,
0.0485119671,
0.2185963541,
-0.2602565587,
0.4081620872,
0.9223399758,
0.2395505756,
-0.4711488485,
0.8084777594,
0.3483083248,
0.3561796248,
-0.1397148669,
0.6670947671,
-0.3415866494,
-0.1270291805,
-0.2116214633,
-0.8243589997,
-0.4146364927,
0.2673608959,
-0.2312121093,
-0.0023590601,
0.4067606628,
0.5407592654,
-0.0529650711,
0.6490228176,
0.3456819355,
0.4556254745,
0.6823996902,
0.8174461722,
1.1825267076,
-0.433901608,
0.4501933753,
-0.482837975,
-0.129638046,
-0.1106411517,
-0.9826682806,
-0.6866314411,
-0.7790816426,
0.0342711657,
-0.2514402568,
0.6462597251,
0.8773682714,
0.7123709917,
-1.0880717039,
-0.2288347483,
-0.002116574,
-0.1377841532,
-0.543574214,
-0.2089903802,
0.4540387094,
0.0858344212,
-0.5150387883,
0.2183189243,
0.5109935999,
0.5642341375,
-0.2339733988,
-0.1394961774,
0.2370503694,
-0.184064731,
0.3383619785,
0.2479388267,
-0.7085075974,
-0.4791008234,
-0.1002564803,
0.2610934675,
-0.1465215981,
0.582744658,
-0.5741381645,
0.4706521034,
-0.1389764249,
0.1806996614,
0.835016489,
-0.4967375994,
0.471534282,
-0.0739729926,
0.2427911162,
0.2720665038,
0.2919611037,
-0.0518245921,
-0.4607107937,
0.4181116223,
0.4438323975,
-0.6732487679,
-0.7280802727,
0.0354323573,
-0.9724023342,
-0.0502682589,
0.2807872295,
-0.097460255,
0.0256459173,
0.0034869534,
0.1849963069,
0.7257658243,
-0.4348247647,
1.3146864176,
0.7847399712,
-0.5384108424,
-0.349576354,
-0.1271490157,
0.2460407168,
-0.0690517947,
-0.7246732116,
-0.0925867632,
0.2688791156,
0.3518438339,
0.5807215571,
-0.1097291932,
0.2067159265,
0.2729299963,
0.0809211284,
-0.0279061664,
-0.2708106935,
-0.5535583496,
-0.3807680607,
0.1812835634,
-0.3974277377,
-0.0391674936
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09552v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09552v2
|
STEER: Assessing the Economic Rationality of Large Language Models
| 2024-02-14T20:05:26 | 2024-05-28T16:27:56 |
Narun Raman, Taylor Lundy, Samuel Amouyal, Yoav Levine, Kevin Leyton-Brown, Moshe Tennenholtz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, econ.GN, q-fin.EC
|
There is increasing interest in using LLMs as decision-making "agents." Doing
so includes many degrees of freedom: which model should be used; how should it
be prompted; should it be asked to introspect, conduct chain-of-thought
reasoning, etc? Settling these questions -- and more broadly, determining
whether an LLM agent is reliable enough to be trusted -- requires a methodology
for assessing such an agent's economic rationality. In this paper, we provide
one. We begin by surveying the economic literature on rational decision making,
taxonomizing a large set of fine-grained "elements" that an agent should
exhibit, along with dependencies between them. We then propose a benchmark
distribution that quantitatively scores an LLMs performance on these elements
and, combined with a user-provided rubric, produces a "STEER report card."
Finally, we describe the results of a large-scale empirical experiment with 14
different LLMs, characterizing the both current state of the art and the impact
of different model sizes on models' ability to exhibit rational behavior.
|
[
-0.5394895077,
-0.7901038527,
0.727509737,
0.4005559385,
-0.0114994682,
-0.0940616503,
-0.3775209486,
-0.4914919138,
0.1398885697,
0.4859483838,
-0.3521988988,
-0.3468572497,
-0.4558183253,
0.0967153311,
-0.3761617839,
0.6426181793,
0.2023744732,
0.1374477148,
-0.2017696798,
-0.3068045676,
-0.3154614568,
-0.3021275699,
-0.8278633952,
-0.6826091409,
0.602157712,
0.2614606917,
1.1617782116,
0.8111970425,
0.4162395895,
0.3308427334,
0.105208762,
-0.2172712982,
-0.4059518576,
0.2795562446,
-0.6061757207,
-0.518253684,
-0.6602374315,
0.5282119513,
0.5750524998,
0.5967468619,
-0.2561017275,
0.2338584512,
-0.1895080656,
0.5711064339,
-0.6130342484,
0.3136001527,
-0.7820088267,
-0.3078378439,
0.0621383674,
-0.2035862803,
-0.8123160601,
-0.6444610953,
0.2743837535,
-0.6274907589,
-0.5016980767,
0.5855628848,
0.6708324552,
0.1946437508,
-0.6021908522,
-0.5456063151,
-0.6685821414,
1.0687506199,
-0.434910357,
0.3982845247,
0.7387090325,
0.2618893087,
-0.1092708781,
-0.6158626676,
-0.288639158,
-0.6723839641,
0.1023300141,
0.3071678579,
-0.3439202607,
0.0299697295,
0.3516536653,
0.0901426151,
-0.1335049421,
0.2099926323,
-0.0292595513,
-0.0618582591,
0.7615024447,
0.1769509912,
0.0110041909,
0.1026066318,
-0.5956192017,
-0.3258486688,
-0.6615089178,
-0.0895118415,
0.5520648956,
0.0516553447,
0.1053724661,
0.8461611271,
-0.287781328,
0.3340557218,
0.1149661988,
-0.3981606364,
-0.1493811309,
-0.2508468032,
-0.4636244178,
0.1939059794,
0.534860909,
0.7330893874,
0.5835575461,
0.0310043562,
-0.7221885324,
0.0847399235,
0.2243741304,
-0.6473723054,
-0.0048117847,
0.2833682299,
-0.5822695494,
-0.2903403342,
-0.2522443235,
-0.5925821662,
-0.4743511677,
-0.666113019,
0.4528675377,
-0.445682466,
-0.2579782903,
-0.0219060127,
-0.1407433599,
0.7435649633,
0.2347379327,
-0.7335737944,
0.3361466825,
0.7934381366,
0.5469349027,
-0.2025270909,
-0.442595005,
-0.6313723922,
0.0229676068,
-0.6699522734,
0.9814145565,
-0.5646914244,
-0.5162283182,
0.1595511436,
-0.13503021,
-0.0322846472,
-0.5488392115,
0.3912831545,
-0.7348611951,
-0.1371167451,
-0.5448413491,
-0.8151136637,
-0.2047789842,
0.6825217009,
-0.6936736703,
0.7092721462,
0.2261260599,
-0.6408563852,
0.6353152394,
-0.4471363127,
-0.2117773145,
0.0034875411,
-0.0272604506,
0.0125479288,
0.0389230102,
-0.2639068961,
0.4022327363,
-0.5448185802,
0.5498374701,
-0.5013644695,
0.1049813032,
0.8898921609,
-0.8033645749,
0.6988269687,
0.1505589336,
-0.1193176806,
0.3754682541,
-0.6898186803,
0.0070972098,
-0.0311097931,
-0.1231974959,
-0.4363544285,
0.2059488893,
-0.0215210747,
-0.0692853704,
0.2136648148,
-0.2132638395,
0.0890728533,
-0.2100455165,
0.2863687277,
0.884744525,
-0.0558510311,
0.6180400848,
-0.830735445,
0.5983170867,
-0.3984954655,
0.1979763061,
0.1410107017,
-0.2310774028,
-0.9140116572,
-0.3043340743,
0.4383101463,
0.403336823,
-0.5421138406,
0.3361147344,
0.0886845216,
-0.6058491468,
-0.0949627832,
-0.2379003316,
0.0187009089,
0.2925176919,
0.0573136322,
-0.1102814898,
-0.1092909798,
-1.0887920856,
-0.1873293668,
-0.4015133977,
0.1518049985,
0.1440172493,
0.6883245111,
-0.3225550056,
1.1270332336,
-0.2972269952,
-0.0031143152,
-0.332516253,
0.1158930287,
-0.1256469339,
0.4056954682,
0.4738761783,
-0.3997757733,
-0.2272845358,
0.1478105038,
-0.4774860442,
-0.1504683048,
-0.2433247864,
-0.4100800753,
0.3682858348,
0.2744658887,
-0.7382773757,
0.2134086341,
0.4724931419,
-0.4301746786,
0.7654711008,
-0.5274646282,
-0.2054987699,
-0.6093943119,
0.1546204686,
0.3003430068,
-0.2149076611,
-0.2977375388,
-0.0254779756,
-0.0898397714,
0.5364498496,
-0.2569071352,
0.6326588392,
-0.2038784623,
-0.419983238,
-0.2694503963,
0.3306544423,
-0.1007397175,
0.0477428101,
-0.0051490362,
0.8628058434,
0.4056462944,
-0.5503416657,
0.3925208449,
-0.1432905644,
-0.4424082339,
0.9882782698,
-0.7549017072,
-0.1390573233,
-0.0748356208,
0.000458862,
-0.6713874936,
-0.3595500886,
0.1151180118,
-0.0374331996,
0.1146157905,
-0.0514124446,
-0.337702632,
0.2641318142,
-0.2506346703,
0.1150877997,
0.6556376815,
-0.3240366876,
0.8838948011,
0.5148075223,
-0.3652549684,
-0.3150292933,
-0.259752661,
-0.1876430213,
-0.4816745818,
-0.6203032732,
-0.0940882117,
-0.1535428762,
-1.1131477356,
-0.0228333846,
-0.1044667661,
-0.0047314949,
0.2531858683,
-0.0358535573,
0.3316047192,
-0.1054980904,
0.0301674623,
0.0847120062,
-0.4055550396,
0.6175534725,
-0.1364231259,
0.3833451271,
-0.339038372,
-0.2576795816,
-0.0602437481,
0.0382014886,
0.8531748652,
-0.4052330852,
0.4774419069,
-0.0023025284,
-0.2306107581,
-0.5729579329,
-0.7002247572,
0.051421918,
-0.4676222801,
0.1053653359,
-0.2086818367,
-0.444676429,
0.4959290326,
-0.2862342,
0.0336981714,
0.5004236698,
0.7635397911,
-0.0206845906,
1.0058217049,
0.4823438823,
0.0639239699,
0.1140475944,
-0.2013527602,
-0.0429201871,
-0.5573208928,
-0.5144551992,
-0.5825868249,
-0.1449412704,
-0.5162769556,
-0.5523754954,
0.1262759864,
-0.0625706762,
-0.4989866316,
-0.0535127632,
-0.0329355597,
0.5773857832,
0.6682399511,
-0.4203680456,
0.5187385082,
-0.3121452928,
-0.1985506713,
0.2727330923,
-0.3883804977,
-1.0902400017,
0.9709020853,
0.5800865889,
1.0626889467,
0.0149933398,
0.3447868228,
0.3773706555,
0.840911746,
-1.2497358322,
0.7017184496,
0.3029382229,
-0.5114224553,
-0.4184733331,
-0.2612211704,
-0.9960673451,
0.5274013877,
-0.3535829782,
-0.4499067664,
0.0742165819,
0.0477137938,
-0.1462973505,
0.0160400886,
-0.5343333483,
0.6994723082,
-0.7277172208,
-0.3025023639,
-0.3406572938,
-0.325784713,
0.4943077564,
-0.3154280484,
0.2650875449,
-0.4247614443,
-0.3598229289,
0.7954862118,
-0.212891534,
0.5840038061,
0.009316124,
-0.1865447015,
0.2547532022,
0.2814898491,
0.5579141378,
0.1978944689,
-0.231978327,
-0.1194467321,
0.2678218782,
-0.1227509081,
-0.4476413131,
0.6019167304,
-0.7913587689,
-0.6056333184,
-0.6942393184,
-0.6859332919,
-0.4498381019,
0.3603773117,
-0.0201527607,
0.3408956528,
-0.5180925131,
0.4077960253,
0.5276966095,
-0.1059604362,
0.3653979301,
0.5499072671,
-0.6002258062,
-0.5761649609,
0.6223201752,
0.3106460571,
0.4157728851,
-0.0085043581,
0.4142325819,
-0.6634435654,
-0.4991489351,
-0.2550406754,
0.232179299,
-0.7238175273,
-0.1768001169,
-0.2395468205,
0.0586462915,
0.1424167305,
-0.3018809259,
-0.5235202909,
-0.0377730615,
-0.1668325365,
-0.3165471554,
0.2897512317,
1.0384287834,
0.2271732688,
0.2235381603,
-0.4336782694,
-0.1276092082,
0.509237051,
0.3841398954,
0.124527216,
-0.2253442705,
-0.0974001288,
0.1872045696,
-0.1121734232,
-0.6279188395,
0.5187866688,
-0.3699854612,
0.800182879,
0.5893492699,
0.5335184336,
0.3672838211,
-0.2327965647,
0.4722349942,
0.2179476023,
-1.1464828253,
0.1906133443,
-0.446203351,
-0.1879991442,
0.3917052448,
0.4104839861,
-0.2729784548,
-0.3863710165,
-0.5663412809,
-0.6822161674,
0.4846672416,
0.1633030176,
-0.1233014166,
-0.2116330862,
-0.035617847,
0.1843070984,
0.2470857948,
-0.5867785811,
-0.1119312719,
-0.061201226,
-0.0115339328,
-0.0806266963,
-0.3524223268,
-0.2401805967,
0.0463256352,
0.5226516128,
-0.2199338675,
-0.2044981867,
0.1874066442,
-0.1120723039,
-0.0147852656,
0.3880995512,
0.4976319671,
1.0944176912,
-0.2587490082,
0.3301776946,
0.0714299828,
-0.0610579215,
0.2987851501,
-0.0882244408,
-0.2098511457,
-0.2972837985,
0.2356772423,
0.4890270531,
0.0632602721,
-0.9787749648,
0.3811988235,
0.1014719605,
-0.4910559952,
-0.5061608553,
-0.0987234712,
0.221423313,
0.5741659403,
0.1432243437,
0.0744140074,
0.0346147344,
-0.6306486726,
0.0014047511,
0.5626132488,
-0.240380764,
-0.2340052426,
0.4328037202,
0.4609151483,
-0.3226281703,
0.6999685168,
-0.3285525441,
-0.4029986262,
0.8041504622,
0.5833477974,
0.9578130841,
0.0991642326,
0.2591618001,
-0.0950267091,
0.7246796489,
-0.5885558724,
0.1302572787,
0.3481539786,
-0.9472456574,
-0.4952481389,
-0.3472445607,
-0.9005559087,
-0.0002705766,
-0.8647133112,
-0.1676395386,
-0.4552031159,
-0.5718106627,
-0.1668661684,
0.1335849762,
-0.5788331628,
0.1932297349,
0.0760239363,
1.2880218029,
-0.625173986,
0.9165407419,
0.6423125863,
-0.3103092015,
-0.8221109509,
-0.0461902358,
-0.2060191184,
-0.852460146,
0.8129585385,
0.1268471926,
-0.4373112023,
-0.1457711309,
-0.5137766004,
-0.9168956876,
1.2499247789,
0.3463433981,
-0.5181571841,
0.4132252038,
-0.1158093661,
0.2598272562,
-0.5804989338,
0.3884097934,
0.9749188423,
0.8637073636,
0.0527794659,
-0.7752994895,
-0.0516065545,
0.1155298799,
0.035099946,
0.0524934791,
-0.7537703514,
0.8595146537,
-0.1195942536,
-0.1301271021,
0.1698586196,
0.4971389174,
0.5829036832,
0.66497612,
0.6585083008,
0.2715959549,
1.0947202444,
-0.1179314628,
1.0627360344,
-0.5509243011,
0.4828945398,
0.7678011656,
-0.8169936538,
1.0451606512,
0.4444440007,
-0.1098591834,
0.1834320724,
0.3700272143,
-0.031981729,
0.2630534768,
0.3705370128,
-0.0254516229,
-0.5532633662,
-0.2098245323,
-0.0486904234,
0.4419573545,
0.4428942502,
-0.2645138204,
0.0366196446,
-0.2003839314,
0.0739885569,
-0.0576227233,
-0.505631268,
0.5155070424,
0.1780228317,
-0.8932942152,
0.1123143435,
0.1164146215,
0.4444560111,
-0.7066643834,
0.207800284,
-0.4261220992,
0.2031880617,
0.0699330568,
-0.9040445685,
0.2340735793,
0.0623717122,
-0.1108438075,
-0.3704807758,
0.7186422944,
-0.1420900673,
-0.4371885657,
0.4430374801,
0.6897324324,
0.0430700183,
0.1069801226,
-0.4977716804,
0.4564780295,
-0.1802181602,
-0.5799860358,
0.4607778192,
0.5593939424,
-0.0531879179,
1.0640119314,
0.63808465,
0.0119491853,
-0.1886374652,
-0.0252170935,
0.5147935152,
-0.9559813142,
-0.215383932,
-0.7701154351,
0.2459125817,
-0.2247223854,
-0.3738960922,
0.9473664761,
0.4857144058,
0.8246475458,
0.0898869857,
0.8837918043,
0.2894584537,
0.0001796749,
-0.694657445,
0.7267112136,
-0.2181961834,
0.379255265,
0.0958697572,
-1.0761988163,
-0.1266411841,
1.0342379808,
-0.4668503106,
0.0643181503,
0.7854707241,
0.6910443306,
0.3152503669,
0.1607051641,
0.5239104629,
0.2789369226,
0.0854125991,
0.0182984211,
1.4732855558,
0.2478642315,
0.301292479,
-0.2399282157,
-0.3034765124,
-0.2166674882,
-1.0554640293,
-0.9141905308,
-0.0039049906,
-0.5152000785,
-0.3702259362,
-0.2510894537,
1.3240553141,
0.5725415945,
-0.4283945262,
-0.7946679592,
0.3467920125,
0.4138498008,
-0.1831056327,
-0.1455268115,
0.1382723749,
-0.4473427534,
-0.7518937588,
0.2787584364,
0.4635524452,
0.0807618052,
-0.4997215569,
-0.2448451966,
0.2595523,
0.6823537946,
0.9576631784,
-0.1018755361,
-0.7954135537,
-0.2143577933,
0.2215567231,
-0.1774845868,
-0.3137146831,
0.7725295424,
-0.4895859361,
0.2319473922,
0.2230320126,
0.4688736498,
0.0232192725,
0.0502869338,
0.6125039458,
0.1086488515,
-0.1556356847,
0.2615815103,
0.5397716761,
-0.090185523,
0.2320450991,
0.4363442361,
-0.0019431976,
-0.9139561057,
-0.612685442,
0.1857464761,
-1.3236929178,
-0.1680545062,
1.4176855087,
0.0389299244,
-0.2261284739,
-0.1337183118,
-0.3880281448,
-0.3045716286,
-0.6682449579,
0.2827051878,
0.8525080085,
0.0592635311,
0.0931675583,
-0.4942896962,
0.1377135068,
0.0638768226,
-0.7015196681,
0.2659373581,
0.729234457,
0.3062665164,
-0.0559146442,
0.7081991434,
0.2609776556,
-0.0641488507,
0.3281149566,
-0.1832270771,
0.1814682186,
-0.2323741168,
-0.1294357628,
0.2628991604,
0.7775396109,
0.1000581309
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09404v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09404v1
|
AQA-Bench: An Interactive Benchmark for Evaluating LLMs' Sequential Reasoning Ability
| 2024-02-14T18:59:33 | 2024-02-14T18:59:33 |
Siwei Yang, Bingchen Zhao, Cihang Xie
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
This paper introduces AQA-Bench, a novel benchmark to assess the sequential
reasoning capabilities of large language models (LLMs) in algorithmic contexts,
such as depth-first search (DFS). The key feature of our evaluation benchmark
lies in its interactive evaluation protocol -- for example, in DFS, the
availability of each node's connected edge is contingent upon the model's
traversal to that node, thereby necessitating the LLM's ability to effectively
remember visited nodes and strategize subsequent moves. We comprehensively
build AQA-Bench with three different algorithms, namely binary search,
depth-first search, and breadth-first search, and to evaluate the sequential
reasoning ability of 12 different LLMs. Our investigations reveal several
interesting findings: (1) Closed-source models like GPT-4 and Gemini generally
show strong sequential reasoning ability, significantly outperforming
open-source LLMs. (2) Naively providing interactive examples may inadvertently
hurt few-shot performance. (3) A very limited number of predecessor steps
following the optimal policy can substantially boost small models' performance.
(4) The scaling correlation between performance and model size is not always
significant, sometimes even showcasing an inverse trend. We hope our study can
catalyze future work on advancing the understanding and enhancement of LLMs'
capabilities in sequential reasoning. The code is available at
https://github.com/UCSC-VLAA/AQA-Bench.
|
[
-0.4372419715,
-0.6452041268,
1.1582747698,
0.3100799322,
-0.1094116792,
0.2797436416,
-0.038688466,
-0.1325784177,
-0.2496633828,
0.2237783819,
-0.6899644732,
-0.5140921474,
-0.4604775608,
0.0690315664,
-0.7069967389,
0.0499351323,
-0.1645236164,
0.1441705972,
-0.4111846685,
-0.1674673855,
-0.1997584701,
-0.1646239311,
-0.7923228145,
-0.2489033788,
0.4068021476,
0.3095161319,
0.8845179081,
0.8386718035,
0.4979794025,
0.3346645832,
-0.0793405622,
-0.0324678719,
-0.3785582185,
0.3181816936,
-0.4148287475,
-0.2466138452,
-0.2628920674,
-0.1101473197,
1.1735037565,
0.7786772847,
-0.0788327679,
0.2269211709,
-0.3609615564,
0.822583437,
-0.6449195743,
0.0167177618,
-0.6481199265,
-0.0420443714,
-0.1644036174,
0.1676936001,
-0.306896776,
-0.5171049833,
0.1375274658,
-0.5834226608,
-0.4143871367,
0.0742616206,
0.5043373704,
0.6962493658,
-0.4896199107,
-0.0601861663,
-0.4781858921,
0.6091125011,
-0.7933953404,
0.5378373265,
0.0640816614,
0.5928988457,
-0.2268794328,
-1.1250348091,
-0.7925274968,
-0.3836812973,
0.0736992136,
0.0437316075,
0.0208537392,
0.0438754074,
0.6414377689,
0.3615944386,
-0.4377427697,
0.2057393044,
0.0161978211,
0.1259565502,
0.6776662469,
0.3434546888,
0.0127433538,
0.1380972117,
-0.4282783568,
-0.2414992452,
-0.7253637314,
0.2908582389,
0.131940335,
-0.101636447,
0.0024615058,
0.4600330293,
-0.6133740544,
0.738096714,
-0.2365954071,
0.0398687534,
0.2411699742,
-0.3711078167,
0.0681568161,
-0.2362661213,
0.8107075095,
-0.0480170883,
0.1612526625,
-0.0174343083,
-0.2685667872,
-0.2024938166,
0.1091534868,
-0.8349110484,
-0.2193407416,
0.3569464087,
-0.4327318072,
-0.0046681371,
0.0032874162,
-0.4505105913,
-0.5886817575,
-0.2010497153,
0.4842274189,
-0.2501475513,
-0.1765973419,
-0.0238524079,
-0.0127164116,
0.295743227,
0.3902926147,
-0.4890860021,
0.7436777353,
0.851483345,
0.7553908825,
-0.353369236,
-0.5878186226,
-0.6360855103,
-0.1823193878,
-0.3670574129,
0.7884503007,
-0.6079464555,
-0.3046220541,
-0.127468124,
-0.2837137878,
-0.1028157175,
-0.4502892792,
0.5891748071,
-0.5784502029,
-0.3284900784,
-0.5222360492,
-0.4964665771,
-0.2697329819,
0.2570743263,
-0.7958517671,
1.1256585121,
0.0619557425,
-0.5535117984,
0.3071913123,
-0.4919011295,
-0.2502014935,
0.1458495706,
-0.5760160089,
-0.1092830002,
-0.1120896935,
0.2108869702,
0.0388786681,
-0.5611653328,
0.2847111821,
-0.6308171153,
-0.7579974532,
0.4903585315,
-0.2468515933,
0.6655015349,
-0.0586455986,
-0.3567302525,
0.2415006161,
-0.861512959,
0.3760588467,
0.2257958353,
-0.0800606236,
-0.0670588911,
0.3116340637,
-0.566495657,
0.3597587347,
0.2796958983,
-0.3955292106,
0.3079446256,
-0.2957420647,
0.3675743937,
0.6811534762,
0.1320789009,
0.2785372436,
-0.4370978773,
0.3738613129,
-0.2354339808,
0.2050911635,
-0.3732432723,
-0.3875082731,
-0.7090514302,
-0.4516523182,
0.6401172876,
0.6041994095,
-0.699795723,
0.2193354964,
-0.2661220431,
-0.3684212863,
-0.5743582249,
0.10670463,
0.4099775851,
0.2796572149,
0.2434105724,
-0.6358441114,
-0.4068658352,
-0.8774250746,
-0.1855088174,
-0.4275203645,
0.0571180768,
0.4282838702,
0.6370275021,
-0.0183389038,
0.9325404763,
-0.1872427464,
0.2193345129,
0.2068857998,
0.1730931848,
0.3148294687,
0.1916774809,
0.3663679659,
-0.5755939484,
-0.2916845977,
-0.386015594,
-0.785697937,
-0.2604782879,
-0.0170353726,
-0.3323151171,
-0.127747938,
0.3862553537,
-0.6603988409,
0.4359113872,
0.2793428004,
-0.2320957035,
0.4406053424,
-0.0068652979,
0.1152827963,
-0.2827002406,
0.176782161,
-0.328703016,
-0.0004354202,
-0.3616650105,
0.2143155932,
0.141461879,
0.1295266449,
-0.3951945007,
1.0003422499,
-0.3757424951,
-0.5612900853,
-0.1964255124,
0.1550538838,
-0.1212432235,
0.4162557423,
0.1744422168,
0.7303741574,
0.500392735,
-0.4597076178,
0.3212273717,
0.3534367085,
-0.648837924,
0.2262054831,
-0.667216599,
0.3517390788,
0.2781336308,
0.412588954,
-1.1904845238,
0.1198651716,
-0.0738330185,
-0.236889869,
0.0017968176,
-0.1428991705,
-0.7712010145,
-0.4988510609,
-0.3436571658,
0.6933555603,
0.3486506343,
-0.7379148006,
0.5439417362,
0.1204262599,
-0.3250185847,
-0.4969761074,
-0.397136122,
-0.0083624218,
0.0597486012,
-0.6954187155,
0.4155089259,
-0.2361083627,
-0.404307127,
0.0893782377,
-0.2437992394,
-0.0560361855,
0.3196538091,
0.1415284276,
-0.0512920059,
-0.1264515966,
0.0813188329,
-0.0147356456,
-0.0409189276,
0.2475319952,
-0.1722783893,
0.3155163825,
-0.3678459525,
-0.7176238894,
-0.1745800972,
0.252114296,
0.6237974167,
-0.3711071312,
0.374971807,
0.3760497868,
-0.3553334475,
-0.2592562139,
-0.7153469324,
-0.1104564592,
-0.4468786716,
0.1531211734,
-0.5455186963,
-0.7548023462,
0.5518491268,
-0.4213756621,
0.0148796858,
0.3563728929,
0.5644645691,
0.1696889102,
1.1205524206,
0.1916831732,
0.103627339,
0.2768608928,
-0.1823999882,
-0.0666822046,
-0.8407177925,
-0.1781208813,
-0.3515768051,
-0.3004440963,
-0.5431182981,
-0.5098215342,
0.4912959337,
0.2183490694,
-0.7550070286,
-0.1375543028,
-0.1744555533,
0.3681502938,
0.7074517012,
-0.026987642,
0.5779138803,
-0.4981218874,
-0.5819875002,
0.1497748196,
-0.5603180528,
-0.4863926172,
0.9939428568,
0.5040912628,
0.5827400684,
0.2760795951,
0.744669795,
0.2173393369,
0.2042828798,
-0.8090266585,
0.9070019722,
0.0379677117,
-0.3422721326,
-0.484877646,
-0.4757797122,
-0.6089840531,
0.5341661572,
-0.2361511588,
-0.7915368676,
0.2181499004,
-0.1459781528,
-0.4105916619,
0.0685500056,
-0.482676506,
0.8231346607,
-0.6962302923,
-0.7116860747,
-0.2336807251,
-0.465244174,
0.6546256542,
-0.0817422569,
0.2135817111,
-0.3290567994,
-0.4381076097,
0.5233070254,
-0.4098668993,
0.5347650647,
-0.288751334,
0.1731562614,
0.2268835902,
0.2967061698,
0.4984867871,
0.2897668481,
-0.2686655819,
0.1228469014,
0.1428467333,
-0.2684000134,
-0.7348076105,
0.6807963252,
-0.5586232543,
-0.7963053584,
-0.6153416634,
-0.4358254671,
-0.6482056379,
0.396708101,
-0.4598496258,
0.2159411013,
-0.3662903905,
0.1847777665,
0.5103414059,
-0.152281031,
0.3628771007,
0.8787267208,
-0.4057715833,
-0.3310744166,
0.4751216173,
0.0346025378,
0.0032951271,
0.3669288456,
0.2320687324,
-0.5497913361,
-0.9377165437,
-0.4701627493,
0.1383435726,
-0.7995426059,
-0.0298053455,
-0.4677898884,
-0.4713144302,
0.038472537,
0.2761005461,
-0.3749851286,
-0.7532292008,
0.3494431674,
0.1114606857,
0.2103053182,
0.8920097351,
-0.0269615538,
0.0416115448,
-0.5299832225,
0.4008741677,
0.4892683923,
0.6515215039,
0.278234005,
-0.4280558825,
0.0169593766,
-0.2645077109,
-0.3310250342,
-0.7244350314,
-0.1180695817,
0.047587581,
1.030134201,
0.118254289,
0.0281820744,
0.3146912754,
-0.5328168869,
0.6164741516,
-0.1396463066,
-0.9101627469,
0.3732293844,
-0.2909643352,
0.7673943043,
0.865203023,
0.4997263253,
-0.0853182301,
-0.1396223307,
-0.4805677533,
-0.8275700212,
0.6004623175,
0.2179365158,
-0.4617596865,
-0.0322313495,
0.1974685788,
-0.0157985091,
0.2938509285,
-0.3879264295,
-0.1706060618,
0.060772121,
-0.0712076873,
0.1831011474,
-0.247897163,
-0.0381723829,
-0.3796774447,
0.5740116835,
-0.1288609207,
0.0856667534,
0.1195359379,
-0.0438418798,
0.0976689905,
0.1588560641,
0.2806649506,
0.905310452,
-0.2590466142,
0.0296219923,
0.3413550258,
-0.1574259847,
0.0738121867,
0.5764793754,
-0.2896151543,
-0.2508505285,
0.2877576947,
0.6164726019,
0.5217654705,
-0.8807547688,
0.5276836753,
-0.3250780702,
-0.2323270887,
-0.3425491452,
-0.0188612305,
0.0662675276,
0.6178658009,
0.5436215401,
-0.2987358272,
0.3790846467,
-0.6016106606,
0.3080706894,
0.4193828702,
-0.0561682507,
0.0849824175,
0.4776345789,
0.1853802502,
-0.1510485858,
0.6821180582,
-0.3603466153,
-0.5578947067,
0.4809457958,
0.0332921371,
0.7886738777,
-0.1932078153,
0.0245635454,
0.5991594791,
0.306301415,
-0.2939462066,
0.4327428341,
-0.3885660172,
-0.5906613469,
-0.4321021736,
-0.5286195874,
-0.9686719775,
0.0633542091,
-0.5051985979,
0.1323040873,
-0.6457800865,
-0.1236117557,
0.0004039711,
0.399486959,
-0.7432761788,
0.0797790289,
0.2150065452,
1.3421684504,
-0.3611565828,
0.8324791193,
0.606880486,
-0.2622723579,
-0.4793845117,
-0.0068535605,
0.2132993937,
-0.8630199432,
0.433607161,
0.0638251603,
-0.191097483,
0.0166998766,
-0.3906628489,
-1.1865506172,
1.3393867016,
0.2516391575,
-0.6055772901,
0.0251511503,
-0.0823136196,
0.4296324551,
-0.5002752542,
0.7221117616,
0.9511244297,
0.6203294992,
0.427452147,
-1.0116811991,
0.3784839809,
-0.4625059962,
0.0408579186,
0.0146542713,
-0.7643639445,
0.7648865581,
-0.3067083061,
-0.2877646387,
0.6080186963,
0.5414106846,
0.6798536777,
0.2801209986,
0.7183736563,
0.6041774154,
0.842456162,
-0.2252764702,
1.127687335,
-0.2805441618,
-0.2018785924,
1.3793447018,
-0.6466718316,
1.1903815269,
0.2259119451,
-0.2698096335,
0.7143990993,
0.5863737464,
0.0239087474,
0.6424928308,
0.6599585414,
-0.1947386712,
-0.3507347405,
-0.0349402763,
-0.4970813692,
0.4267864525,
0.4373216629,
-0.1133058369,
-0.1337187737,
-0.4437531829,
-0.4062151015,
0.2232689857,
-0.3108891845,
0.735095799,
0.2201687396,
-0.8317929506,
0.5787537694,
-0.0302114449,
0.1633506268,
-0.6509130001,
-0.2232769281,
-0.1334787905,
0.1658318639,
-0.1065436453,
-0.9597085118,
-0.0899103954,
-0.1557594389,
0.0601144917,
-0.0147879245,
0.5678008199,
-0.1920702606,
-0.3321367204,
0.40133968,
0.7271797657,
0.0382310338,
0.0390845314,
-0.9317317009,
0.3929084241,
-0.4871419966,
-0.388489902,
0.3143247664,
0.4633982778,
-0.2149900347,
0.7872043252,
0.4594022632,
-0.071711868,
-0.0103212278,
0.4373549223,
0.9395542145,
-0.8106685877,
-0.3420582116,
-0.5626169443,
0.4401656985,
-0.1504112184,
-0.1656583846,
0.5464064479,
0.5605400801,
0.8142607808,
0.3453887701,
0.8057743907,
0.1466478109,
0.6396253109,
-0.6408398151,
0.3441834152,
-0.3833278716,
0.5257434845,
0.0086253211,
-0.87033391,
0.0344243832,
0.6302136183,
-0.5639472008,
0.4091894329,
0.9505190253,
0.5782195926,
0.070949994,
0.1493867785,
0.208113566,
0.4789168537,
-0.1039604321,
0.7278068066,
1.3213353157,
-0.3558472693,
0.4545150101,
-0.3468610942,
-0.4898253679,
0.1033821478,
-1.0722681284,
-0.862606585,
-0.4064272344,
-0.2633043528,
-0.1302951872,
0.1936118156,
0.6619451642,
0.575614512,
-0.5886368752,
-0.3657695055,
0.0025699532,
0.2924489081,
-0.3433150053,
-0.1341944188,
0.1596529484,
-0.1915842146,
-0.4527754188,
0.7939561009,
0.1633443981,
-0.1781667322,
-0.4876435101,
-0.1261205226,
-0.3911590576,
0.1372819096,
0.4849266708,
0.4617082775,
-0.7618647218,
-0.1530078202,
-0.1179939732,
0.0231075864,
-0.2327000797,
0.8263521194,
-1.0945004225,
0.5039396286,
0.5368185639,
0.7271050811,
0.8931741118,
0.1083024889,
0.5925917625,
-0.4426998794,
-0.1075074747,
0.3200236857,
0.4972424507,
0.2566497028,
0.0671728477,
0.7995795608,
-0.0200706553,
-0.5158801675,
-0.9083619714,
0.1748920381,
-0.961191833,
-0.1458474994,
1.0549769402,
-0.187860921,
-0.1016282588,
0.000673431,
-0.0036227033,
-0.13082771,
-0.3284965158,
0.5948454142,
0.7205053568,
-0.0930836946,
-0.2906546593,
-0.6016883254,
0.4061562121,
0.3988687098,
-0.6860590577,
-0.0456602164,
0.3285826743,
0.0455951616,
-0.0988314152,
0.992844224,
-0.2037084252,
0.5700294971,
0.062151432,
-0.261890173,
-0.2417597324,
-0.4735455513,
-0.4096985459,
-0.003107093,
0.43773669,
0.1259742826
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09401v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09401v1
|
Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback with Active Queries
| 2024-02-14T18:58:40 | 2024-02-14T18:58:40 |
Kaixuan Ji, Jiafan He, Quanquan Gu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, math.OC, stat.ML
|
Aligning large language models (LLM) with human preference plays a key role
in building modern generative models and can be achieved by reinforcement
learning from human feedback (RLHF). Despite their superior performance,
current RLHF approaches often require a large amount of human-labelled
preference data, which is expensive to collect. In this paper, inspired by the
success of active learning, we address this problem by proposing
query-efficient RLHF methods. We first formalize the alignment problem as a
contextual dueling bandit problem and design an active-query-based proximal
policy optimization (APPO) algorithm with an $\tilde{O}(d^2/\Delta)$ regret
bound and an $\tilde{O}(d^2/\Delta^2)$ query complexity, where $d$ is the
dimension of feature space and $\Delta$ is the sub-optimality gap over all the
contexts. We then propose ADPO, a practical version of our algorithm based on
direct preference optimization (DPO) and apply it to fine-tuning LLMs. Our
experiments show that ADPO, while only making about half of queries for human
preference, matches the performance of the state-of-the-art DPO method.
|
[
-0.2968695164,
-0.8630132079,
0.4458563328,
-0.1752366722,
-0.0369367674,
-0.0452329703,
-0.4733059704,
-0.2283408046,
0.1602347195,
0.6255335808,
-0.7016018629,
-0.4169976115,
-0.0079249255,
-0.258169204,
0.2423654646,
0.65058887,
-0.2558436394,
-0.0607853904,
0.0442891605,
-0.2682991326,
-0.2401696295,
-0.2913413048,
-0.7515076399,
-0.220390141,
0.7014285326,
0.5482165813,
0.8565485477,
0.671005547,
0.1058801487,
0.31043607,
-0.1615496129,
0.7183145285,
-0.4887741804,
0.4532490075,
-0.217967853,
-0.4635875225,
-0.2685747147,
0.0322101489,
0.4829778671,
0.4232291281,
-0.5785295367,
-0.3327273428,
-0.2196667641,
0.8908045888,
-0.8459995985,
0.0889864489,
-0.689168334,
0.1385281831,
-0.1168143749,
-0.050580956,
-0.349688977,
-0.5088270307,
0.1684839129,
-0.9417775273,
0.0033971772,
0.3103583157,
0.8432745337,
0.3147027493,
-0.4962736368,
-0.2900944054,
-0.6985939145,
0.8727138638,
-0.4564468563,
0.2556008399,
0.4745753109,
0.3459768295,
-0.4435542524,
-0.2448061556,
-0.6933503151,
-0.2245916426,
-0.1042062268,
0.1555627733,
0.0158683807,
0.263635695,
0.0589051321,
0.1842478067,
-0.3793585002,
0.2914819717,
-0.0257119071,
-0.2518123984,
0.8842733502,
0.0603564009,
0.0227105971,
-0.0403561816,
-0.4238009155,
-0.3239308596,
-0.7382941842,
0.3411818743,
0.6297276616,
0.3081125319,
0.4113581479,
0.4375935495,
-0.2205940187,
1.178325057,
0.1879088432,
-0.1132217199,
-0.102732785,
-0.1294105351,
0.1305343956,
0.0434293896,
0.878679812,
0.1710709631,
0.0750703812,
-0.214529708,
-0.3001917303,
-0.0804089531,
0.4983176589,
-0.4029149413,
-0.1234083027,
0.1174317375,
-0.014507425,
-0.3176112175,
-0.0277967732,
-0.5703240037,
-0.4452753365,
-0.3240490556,
0.5892950296,
-0.229813233,
-0.0220601186,
0.0555472262,
0.304703027,
0.3025944531,
0.3941042125,
-1.2026278973,
0.0663288981,
0.6642765403,
0.5659863949,
-0.2133741826,
-0.1158158928,
-0.8560688496,
0.1764101535,
-0.4242872298,
0.7373036742,
-0.5611433387,
-0.3795522749,
0.1293144375,
-0.0318890288,
-0.2324586064,
-0.7859337926,
0.7393046021,
-0.9452450275,
0.2992036343,
-0.2942656577,
-0.3812714219,
-0.1288478971,
0.2652525902,
-0.6166538,
0.9889256358,
0.026384769,
-0.4487898946,
0.4184568524,
-0.5516245365,
-0.5089257956,
-0.1398568153,
-0.1930140406,
-0.7338686585,
-0.1653338224,
0.3622635603,
0.2090232074,
-0.0367103294,
0.3123988211,
-0.4030249715,
-0.496817559,
0.2157964855,
-0.0957321674,
0.5187837481,
0.2501568496,
-0.4781295657,
0.5832959414,
-0.3911148906,
0.0586117469,
0.050147187,
-0.608161509,
-0.4370186329,
0.4129391015,
-0.3502039909,
-0.0337847769,
0.1391939372,
-0.3984899521,
0.6659898162,
-0.6089857221,
0.4719261527,
0.8896306157,
-0.1707100868,
0.6400482059,
-0.140614301,
0.5381963253,
-0.2800917625,
0.2283998281,
0.1251936406,
-0.0667981654,
-0.5944513083,
-0.2712400556,
0.5148911476,
0.4830937088,
-0.8121823072,
0.7143470049,
0.0267826673,
-0.1671376377,
-0.6648473144,
0.1918737292,
0.5182634592,
0.5515112877,
0.2937219143,
-0.2080719471,
-0.3805413246,
-1.0028460026,
-0.2937880456,
-0.404845655,
0.0435959063,
0.8982430696,
-0.041752547,
-0.0691760853,
0.9580298066,
-0.8595805764,
-0.2822501063,
-0.0469636358,
-0.021707708,
0.0450754128,
0.2078111172,
0.3579303324,
-0.7911663055,
-0.678889513,
-0.0127333198,
-0.3324351311,
0.0264290422,
0.1184026599,
-0.4249159098,
0.2184334993,
0.1966710091,
-0.5320225954,
-0.0278374869,
0.4431970716,
-0.3231431842,
0.2302084118,
-0.3267352581,
0.0299127828,
-0.7468982339,
-0.0261865593,
-0.1058982983,
-0.3463273942,
-0.2823672891,
-0.1155968904,
0.1825937629,
-0.151667729,
-0.2910924852,
0.7645392418,
-0.4455456436,
-0.0441699512,
-0.2440095991,
0.1415846646,
-0.1327407062,
0.7919275165,
0.2369904965,
0.8423279524,
0.4549601972,
-0.7200725675,
0.6013154984,
0.3044947684,
-0.2281932235,
0.4007253349,
-0.4731218517,
0.1802157462,
-0.1177105457,
0.3972192109,
-1.0233857632,
-0.2889884412,
0.2926798165,
-0.3473226428,
0.4295428991,
-0.2554614842,
-0.1971413493,
-0.1082042158,
-0.3884118199,
0.2393543124,
0.4671362638,
-0.8478475213,
0.4259114563,
0.746964395,
0.103558585,
-0.8548845649,
0.0808903053,
-0.2278990597,
-0.1762241721,
-0.4501488209,
0.5457949638,
0.3037282825,
-0.0881716833,
-0.0155392261,
-0.2882955968,
0.1272232085,
0.1071428359,
-0.0416821875,
0.2666270435,
0.2728649676,
0.115081057,
-0.098011449,
-0.1446307451,
-0.2455260307,
-0.3557724953,
0.3706798255,
-0.0609137565,
-0.3928842843,
-0.2544673979,
0.0950718671,
0.3886434734,
-0.3014995456,
0.5045500994,
0.4255422354,
0.0249085873,
-0.5353928804,
-0.3743691146,
-0.2480949759,
-0.4520428479,
0.2897361517,
-0.1515076756,
-0.8474290371,
0.2641668916,
-0.1331227571,
0.295959115,
0.1955631375,
0.4463841319,
-0.1120469496,
1.3909549713,
0.3139799237,
-0.0072940579,
0.9652113914,
-0.2754376233,
-0.0157012492,
-0.6267212629,
-0.350014478,
-0.3407663107,
-0.6365926266,
-0.5302303433,
-0.4344207644,
0.5243808627,
0.2834470868,
-0.2514748573,
0.2609361112,
-0.3973557949,
0.3932261765,
0.7726939917,
0.3438678682,
0.0640468299,
-0.0178263914,
-0.3387584686,
-0.0516389497,
-0.8643538952,
-0.2663798332,
0.983561337,
0.034897577,
0.9784133434,
0.3502250314,
0.6545310616,
0.2140992433,
0.1705288589,
-1.1463600397,
0.5569235682,
-0.1312790513,
-0.4947259426,
-0.6685500741,
-0.6085274816,
-1.3282848597,
0.4249815047,
-0.3372713923,
-0.3323301375,
0.2627741992,
0.5319458246,
-0.5832237601,
0.2245567441,
-0.7361563444,
0.8586924672,
-0.589345932,
-0.9311144352,
-0.2372705787,
-0.6395413876,
0.2633036077,
0.3289531767,
-0.0641611218,
-0.1771421582,
-0.3180765212,
0.7657189369,
-0.5171837211,
0.6269459128,
-0.5069885254,
-0.0949351937,
0.34396258,
-0.1020326167,
0.8970957994,
0.2177450508,
-0.025992902,
-0.5088363886,
-0.2688210607,
-0.4419277906,
-0.6716902852,
0.7987354994,
-0.9970088601,
-0.6330657005,
-0.4544819295,
-0.1498919278,
-0.624324441,
0.0596863441,
-0.2532072961,
0.2682665884,
-0.2509724796,
0.178047061,
1.0690666437,
-0.2830802798,
0.3283872604,
0.8967263103,
-0.0366674364,
-0.4771912098,
0.7251455188,
-0.0741444752,
-0.02973371,
0.5071563721,
0.3729444444,
-0.7012149692,
-0.3111602962,
-0.7071882486,
0.2462051809,
-0.1703494489,
-0.2884466648,
-0.4565371573,
0.1224566326,
-0.1689408123,
-0.0416549444,
-0.5690206289,
-0.298012048,
-0.0963214785,
0.1599605978,
0.3677215576,
0.2510187924,
0.0737429187,
0.1655331254,
-0.6067734957,
0.3441895247,
0.9082624912,
0.5505850911,
-0.0345970988,
-0.3006498516,
-0.1730032414,
-0.0084672291,
-0.5085000992,
-0.9084330201,
0.2851358056,
0.1340397894,
0.7892643213,
0.4936417937,
0.5255117416,
0.6365902424,
-0.3817707896,
0.5116801262,
0.020513026,
-0.5632007122,
0.6780498028,
-0.4083187878,
0.0570981801,
0.7413008213,
0.5535926819,
-0.4925672114,
0.250490129,
-0.6153291464,
-1.1246278286,
1.0644724369,
-0.0597336888,
-0.0256752595,
0.0784044564,
0.5838518143,
-0.1262780577,
0.0462027304,
-0.3036243618,
-0.1359706372,
0.0905284435,
-0.0448163003,
0.0209154282,
-0.0595605411,
-0.4859976172,
-0.1256230325,
0.8888528347,
-0.321282804,
0.0718356594,
0.0137069998,
0.0013073769,
-0.284295857,
0.4402587712,
0.3884969652,
0.5534858108,
-0.281000793,
0.0293584876,
-0.0196931716,
-0.0900465995,
0.2990003824,
0.1470150352,
-0.2840288281,
-0.2671447396,
0.0116630448,
1.1183624268,
0.2683382034,
-0.9547389746,
0.6247386336,
-0.2180306911,
-0.3036286235,
-0.1470800638,
0.539388895,
0.0200044308,
0.1937628686,
0.2473478466,
-0.1940461546,
-0.0932884738,
-0.6756579876,
0.1569569558,
0.6860736609,
-0.7496265173,
-0.2183551341,
0.6277893186,
0.4916551113,
-0.3427917957,
0.6072669029,
-0.2364598215,
-0.6240329742,
0.2719407976,
0.3066490889,
0.7616995573,
-0.1146821305,
0.2361133993,
0.4577901363,
-0.2593875527,
-0.3447192311,
0.2521393001,
-0.4278218448,
-0.7318305373,
-0.4799339175,
-0.6598340869,
-0.7026460767,
-0.018698005,
-0.6220915914,
0.3551562428,
-0.3188744187,
-0.0991884321,
-0.1450499147,
0.370228678,
-0.1465237141,
-0.045098871,
-0.1320532262,
0.3639024794,
-0.6041753292,
0.8688150048,
1.0888682604,
-0.1537975669,
-0.7470775843,
0.0173183791,
-0.1019165814,
-1.0821251869,
0.374641031,
-0.1977516711,
-0.0917338505,
0.0844211504,
-0.4570855498,
-0.6685286164,
0.9699884057,
0.2804840505,
-0.7133610845,
-0.0224742536,
-0.5862196684,
0.4609582126,
-0.1494294256,
0.130749613,
0.4710028768,
0.4571229517,
0.3722111583,
-0.7395438552,
-0.0276636072,
0.0724115595,
-0.0499372818,
0.723495245,
-1.0466948748,
0.3386233151,
-0.3124563694,
-0.104281202,
-0.3349592388,
0.5991542935,
0.4517796338,
0.0166191552,
0.912538588,
0.6497871876,
0.6701724529,
-0.0871193111,
0.913395226,
-0.207627669,
0.3320716321,
0.8325055242,
-0.2635989189,
0.9119355679,
0.3392053246,
-0.4593295753,
0.2946964502,
0.9223216772,
0.2421291173,
0.8366692066,
0.3648477197,
-0.4447565973,
-0.4917387366,
0.0177262072,
-0.0990819111,
0.4662198126,
0.1681590825,
-0.0947665498,
-0.1192795709,
-0.3527654111,
0.085683085,
0.3475624323,
-0.2194544673,
1.2968422174,
-0.3157240748,
-1.3416347504,
0.7149984837,
0.1845647246,
0.8036467433,
-0.7700805664,
0.0441185832,
-0.4163988233,
0.3604778349,
-0.1106265187,
-0.5272033215,
0.1518162638,
-0.2027048618,
-0.0653183535,
-0.3494357169,
0.4759298265,
-0.7166061401,
0.0989408717,
0.0399093553,
0.2159272879,
-0.2104703635,
0.0707776323,
-0.8357639313,
-0.2379864156,
0.169796288,
-0.4306067228,
0.5832043886,
0.1496616751,
-0.3385885358,
0.4592574537,
0.6482537985,
0.1703732461,
-0.2365712374,
-0.1124892682,
0.8134515285,
-0.6405017376,
-0.6156665683,
-0.6318680048,
0.1562678367,
-0.1204770133,
-0.2078857571,
0.4988509417,
0.5729727745,
0.7493261099,
0.2281903476,
0.7182270885,
-0.0267998576,
0.5266644955,
-0.5891990066,
0.3519099951,
-0.732265234,
0.4471299052,
0.1832096279,
-0.9607360363,
-0.0941146165,
0.753105104,
-0.4480410516,
-0.0724028051,
0.2417545021,
0.9893581867,
-0.0371452123,
-0.3234530985,
0.147024259,
-0.1350665092,
0.192763418,
0.6191810369,
0.8736602068,
-0.0963009,
0.7290799022,
-0.1579480022,
-0.3724261224,
-0.4909475446,
-0.6840999126,
-0.5602387786,
-0.365244478,
-0.1829482019,
-0.3954294324,
0.3308406472,
0.9916270375,
0.8176902533,
-0.7493098974,
-0.2251063883,
-0.057241179,
0.415227592,
-0.4967925549,
-0.2001365721,
0.6701827049,
-0.4770185947,
-0.9392116666,
0.4177625775,
0.1175726727,
-0.0559384599,
-0.3400888741,
-0.4459666014,
-0.380672127,
-0.0477999114,
0.3880444467,
0.6005578637,
-0.8016453981,
-0.0644747019,
0.134718135,
-0.0598793179,
-0.0396700613,
1.0602025986,
-0.7236864567,
0.8096850514,
0.7029455304,
0.712395668,
0.7372412086,
0.4050941467,
0.7665428519,
-0.8476694226,
0.0147625469,
0.4113231599,
0.071402356,
0.1926943958,
-0.2963948548,
0.4677621722,
0.1964406818,
-0.639839828,
-0.7142047882,
0.3926858008,
-0.8245928288,
-0.3962509632,
1.2248746157,
-0.1529442668,
-0.2312607169,
-0.0499150977,
-0.4312035143,
0.1425474733,
-0.6639862061,
0.9512960315,
0.396206826,
-0.634668231,
-0.0603445023,
-0.3390602767,
0.8909133673,
0.6233588457,
-0.518506825,
0.2920636535,
0.6552317142,
-0.002515798,
-0.208707571,
0.6879051924,
-0.0891675875,
0.1901441664,
-0.3355470598,
-0.0297021903,
-0.1735644192,
-0.2273381203,
-0.2055508196,
0.1672816724,
0.3151435256,
-0.2573933601
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09394v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09394v2
|
Long-form evaluation of model editing
| 2024-02-14T18:45:14 | 2024-03-29T21:17:23 |
Domenic Rosati, Robie Gonzales, Jinkun Chen, Xuemin Yu, Melis Erkan, Yahya Kayani, Satya Deepika Chavatapalli, Frank Rudzicz, Hassan Sajjad
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Evaluations of model editing currently only use the `next few token'
completions after a prompt. As a result, the impact of these methods on longer
natural language generation is largely unknown. We introduce long-form
evaluation of model editing (LEME) a novel evaluation protocol that measures
the efficacy and impact of model editing in long-form generative settings. Our
protocol consists of a machine-rated survey and a classifier which correlates
well with human ratings. Importantly, we find that our protocol has very little
relationship with previous short-form metrics (despite being designed to extend
efficacy, generalization, locality, and portability into a long-form setting),
indicating that our method introduces a novel set of dimensions for
understanding model editing methods. Using this protocol, we benchmark a number
of model editing techniques and present several findings including that, while
some methods (ROME and MEMIT) perform well in making consistent edits within a
limited scope, they suffer much more from factual drift than other methods.
Finally, we present a qualitative analysis that illustrates common failure
modes in long-form generative settings including internal consistency, lexical
cohesion, and locality issues.
|
[
-0.2420471758,
-0.9348499179,
0.806039989,
0.1301385462,
-0.1050931439,
0.0394178443,
-0.3442464173,
-0.4927947223,
0.1408569217,
0.1989645511,
-0.4870623946,
-0.3933562636,
-0.5087181926,
0.3430521488,
-0.3970425725,
0.7535982728,
-0.10499385,
0.0428051166,
-0.5289010406,
-0.0901883543,
-0.4860217869,
-0.4860997498,
-0.756406486,
-0.2877214253,
0.553753376,
0.1156591401,
0.7917081714,
0.2825727463,
0.6343718767,
0.3152440786,
-0.5083197951,
0.1637574136,
-0.4773325026,
-0.1489689648,
-0.3311902285,
-0.4442416131,
-0.9885453582,
0.0528443679,
0.9483892322,
0.8069474101,
-0.0141860005,
0.1757239848,
0.1553393006,
0.7388464808,
-0.7612075806,
-0.3478120267,
-0.490106523,
-0.0565719083,
-0.3830153942,
0.1599634439,
-0.5695593953,
-0.1617682874,
-0.0215296559,
-0.3419930041,
0.1825568825,
-0.2172771096,
0.6488280892,
0.09053424,
-0.2778817415,
-0.3100813925,
-0.727563262,
0.6563562751,
-1.162112236,
0.4277496934,
0.3671986163,
0.3027052581,
-0.3209522963,
-0.6491568685,
-0.5230525732,
-0.6333616376,
0.0212572124,
0.1779159456,
-0.172879681,
0.3054876626,
0.5448040962,
0.3377659619,
-0.3615877628,
0.4619687498,
-0.5021643043,
-0.2381181866,
0.6642186642,
0.1528348178,
0.2415277362,
-0.5131412745,
-0.1099982038,
0.145723775,
-0.7119451165,
0.0549582466,
0.5349935889,
0.134220615,
-0.0264919885,
0.7630422115,
-0.233231172,
0.8677818775,
0.0571919307,
-0.1573891193,
0.0656976402,
-0.3456553221,
-0.4935914278,
-0.1980621368,
0.9814289808,
0.7149165869,
-0.1839532554,
-0.0019653786,
-0.3860985637,
-0.0299515221,
0.1068306863,
-0.717443347,
0.2307437211,
0.0452339575,
-0.5529144406,
-0.4540167749,
-0.0760720447,
-0.5998340249,
-0.3462649882,
-0.2210411578,
0.5458261371,
-0.3166221678,
0.0680176988,
0.2465751022,
-0.1579527259,
-0.0637233555,
0.5503891706,
-0.6968783736,
0.3314107955,
0.7928003073,
1.0791373253,
-0.20598194,
-0.4081259072,
-0.6330786943,
-0.0549514219,
-0.3433282375,
0.6323703527,
-0.4717004895,
-0.709261775,
-0.2563866377,
0.094187364,
-0.0660263598,
-0.4666439593,
0.6201673746,
-0.265443027,
0.3079132736,
-0.1272660494,
-0.8959516287,
0.1203438342,
0.0799840167,
-0.763648808,
0.9753138423,
0.1284933984,
-0.4886547923,
0.4220017493,
-1.0539222956,
-0.2692791224,
-0.2060127258,
0.1097861975,
-0.5074660778,
0.4924939573,
0.1379197985,
0.4877735078,
-0.2603172064,
0.255622983,
-0.3287498355,
-0.2424212694,
0.2296262085,
-0.5544314384,
0.5778473616,
-0.0689236745,
-0.2082497329,
0.0776763111,
-0.9948363304,
-0.1729875952,
0.0224228967,
-0.2514995635,
-0.3148148954,
-0.1346922517,
-0.1238238811,
0.1131795123,
0.1256886274,
-0.6515787244,
0.5686099529,
-0.3019714057,
0.6643922329,
0.8573145866,
0.1922201961,
0.497870177,
-0.3934416473,
0.6692276001,
-0.4128238261,
0.2167991549,
-0.1318197995,
-0.3569001257,
-0.8920289874,
-0.0876377001,
0.7169665694,
0.2851809561,
-0.2519862652,
0.2430666983,
-0.3129914701,
-0.6087601185,
-0.4747599065,
0.1486685127,
0.2292571515,
0.4677996337,
0.1875725091,
-0.4859032333,
-0.2228908539,
-0.9757677913,
-0.1950429231,
0.1268239766,
0.0242868159,
0.0889878944,
0.7499465942,
-0.4805295467,
0.8634525537,
-0.1959899217,
0.1135261878,
-0.1120302156,
0.3857280016,
0.11875543,
0.4992298782,
0.5970519781,
-0.1443795115,
-0.2118284106,
-0.2553014457,
-0.5860542655,
-0.1179206073,
-0.4635088742,
-0.184822619,
0.2536829412,
0.5678189993,
-0.7776757479,
0.5836014748,
0.5151981711,
-0.1657783538,
0.8024135232,
-0.226817444,
0.3424366415,
-1.0074442625,
-0.0122925891,
-0.2310076207,
-0.3180967271,
-0.5667131543,
-0.0217706952,
0.0741601586,
-0.1170623228,
-0.5452171564,
0.6337922215,
-0.4689281881,
-0.1000692919,
-0.0800851211,
0.2183188349,
0.2731563747,
-0.0319425575,
-0.1651971191,
0.5707532167,
0.0993990898,
-0.4720924199,
0.3070566952,
0.0000227449,
-0.5106969476,
0.646961689,
-0.7740927935,
0.7553402185,
-0.2027531564,
0.2131332755,
-0.5152092576,
-0.2231206298,
-0.0952810347,
-0.3442766964,
0.2568247616,
0.0272734668,
-0.5118904114,
-0.2836093903,
-0.4029464126,
0.3332880139,
0.3169511259,
-0.3060416579,
0.460800916,
-0.2798557878,
-0.157801494,
-0.4060627818,
-0.596639514,
0.314140588,
-0.1862954497,
-0.8806728721,
0.3008871973,
-0.316595912,
-0.4167917073,
-0.1574189514,
0.0701223016,
0.2098707706,
0.2956704199,
0.1857344359,
0.0201771017,
-0.1168991849,
0.1867483854,
0.3410314023,
0.0627618134,
-0.0752446726,
0.4611137807,
0.3465934992,
0.0252912585,
-0.5783564448,
-0.7997744679,
0.4382615387,
0.7115241289,
-0.2319405824,
0.4637697041,
0.291606456,
-0.433627218,
-0.1277427524,
-0.4346298575,
-0.0326731727,
-0.4297083318,
0.576662004,
-0.5703659058,
-0.8207418323,
0.4050309062,
-0.2728452981,
0.2012859136,
0.7754560113,
0.3665520847,
-0.1705498099,
0.942702651,
0.9000833035,
0.104534246,
0.2659029663,
-0.2609235644,
0.0304575842,
-0.8579340577,
0.081657283,
-0.4883440137,
-0.2429690808,
-0.3112830222,
-0.5333133936,
0.2293259203,
0.6786522269,
-0.0303309988,
0.2056566626,
-0.2275604159,
0.4035493731,
0.339092344,
-0.0119499788,
0.4019196928,
-0.2740651965,
-0.0068281321,
-0.2041558772,
-0.6194497347,
-0.6701813936,
1.0503461361,
0.5995784402,
0.5104483962,
0.1199830249,
0.9101219177,
0.5723636746,
0.484624058,
-0.8654729724,
0.5029162765,
-0.0867675692,
-0.3351430893,
-0.5675961375,
-0.2121113837,
-0.7455307841,
-0.1391633302,
-0.2141382247,
-0.7524338961,
0.0865315869,
0.1421247423,
-0.5734709501,
0.2865028977,
-0.5222864747,
0.9359279871,
-0.3569222987,
-0.2766162157,
-0.2232455015,
-0.4435670972,
0.3068010211,
-0.2146285623,
0.3774675429,
-0.0184131395,
0.0895359218,
0.7953330874,
-0.6414413452,
0.6489188671,
0.0068462077,
-0.1435031891,
0.1771641523,
0.1967867911,
0.569955647,
0.1584624648,
-0.3277305961,
0.1246649176,
-0.1436368376,
-0.2327190191,
-1.0374163389,
0.4390923977,
-0.526120007,
-0.4574559927,
-0.2939405739,
-0.2072890848,
-0.2723811865,
0.1549061835,
0.4131311774,
0.4740332365,
-0.5520730019,
0.1632253677,
0.1694373041,
-0.3095433712,
0.4811795354,
0.2398494631,
-0.4341359437,
-0.558752954,
0.5827993155,
0.1361719519,
0.8266535997,
0.1607642621,
0.2728846967,
0.1744404882,
-0.452668339,
-0.6715192199,
0.1150114015,
-0.7430234551,
-0.0583598763,
-0.4375647902,
-0.2704856098,
-0.377060622,
-0.3720995784,
-0.5149119496,
-0.5197312236,
-0.1240193099,
-0.1199526712,
0.0495710373,
1.0225605965,
-0.259655565,
0.4452047348,
-0.8343265057,
0.2902339995,
0.3762785196,
0.2670011222,
-0.0855879039,
-0.5400537848,
-0.2554989755,
0.19443959,
-0.1489778608,
-1.002178669,
0.0475809127,
0.377903372,
0.4036715925,
0.2162850946,
-0.4389435053,
0.7653855085,
-0.5681378245,
1.0488921404,
0.2357470542,
-1.2215591669,
0.7108997107,
-0.3040902019,
0.5055243373,
0.5286023617,
0.1098719388,
-0.7074716687,
-0.3251869977,
-0.5275470614,
-0.6444855928,
0.2926687896,
0.1147508621,
0.2421703041,
-0.0980238244,
0.5722173452,
0.2790477276,
0.1365330815,
-0.6696988344,
-0.0600452796,
-0.0154878525,
0.2280067056,
-0.21467565,
-0.7166904807,
0.0161138941,
-0.3612107038,
0.7227514982,
0.0808340907,
0.1642254889,
0.2324377149,
-0.3201409578,
-0.074637942,
0.6745461226,
1.012394309,
1.0259491205,
-0.4650693238,
-0.2067609876,
0.2975695729,
-0.1884404123,
-0.0957782194,
-0.0898033455,
-0.4746278822,
0.3183062077,
0.6222491264,
1.0311632156,
0.0994082391,
-0.3893049061,
0.3934046328,
0.007153715,
-0.294020772,
-0.0122139826,
-0.1612986624,
0.0075230598,
-0.1113657504,
0.0000365357,
0.1761391908,
0.374776274,
-0.6688978076,
-0.0130649479,
0.3273895979,
-0.3849491477,
-0.3881598413,
0.5060930848,
0.2611419261,
-0.5193656087,
0.5422857404,
-0.2961223423,
-0.2383919209,
0.530179739,
0.4362223744,
1.0717382431,
-0.1906224489,
0.2780396938,
0.5086969137,
0.5388826132,
0.0018299164,
0.027648326,
0.165220961,
-0.3659988046,
-0.7458988428,
-0.792728126,
-0.4889631569,
0.4533729255,
-0.6066165566,
0.4366385043,
-0.3664202094,
-0.4725141227,
0.1172604561,
-0.3352397382,
-0.595646739,
0.1294036359,
0.0468520708,
0.9756870866,
-0.7754121423,
0.4824388325,
0.6827730536,
-0.2522150278,
-0.5251554251,
-0.1848466247,
0.0303903818,
-0.2451355904,
0.4727724791,
0.341329962,
-0.1743933409,
-0.3295896351,
-0.5128310323,
-0.7970541716,
0.9612018466,
0.3730347157,
-0.9983472228,
-0.2692974806,
0.2854551971,
0.576996088,
-0.2037754655,
0.2177353352,
0.5958303213,
0.4886335433,
-0.3271898925,
-1.4115875959,
-0.124983944,
-0.1583339572,
0.0835151374,
0.1097986847,
-0.5775850415,
0.6441774964,
-0.2426236123,
-0.0768875554,
0.4761987329,
0.7061485648,
-0.0905836895,
0.3210829198,
0.5375872254,
0.7531967759,
0.7595206499,
0.2016906738,
0.9062845707,
-0.2085934132,
0.5328555107,
1.4195029736,
-0.1329913437,
0.940269351,
0.3368576467,
-0.2275670916,
0.5562236309,
0.513704896,
0.0670692772,
0.2129629701,
0.4902974963,
-0.2090535909,
-0.2672189772,
0.0751709864,
-0.3493096828,
0.5640710592,
0.1550585181,
-0.4746182263,
-0.2269982547,
0.1952988356,
0.2262723744,
0.107505016,
-0.3320505023,
0.6456765532,
0.2004208416,
-0.4762575626,
0.4543810487,
0.2549262345,
0.6333830953,
-0.3054334819,
-0.2115822434,
-0.1501019746,
-0.1459813863,
-0.1866272688,
-0.4496082067,
0.1737847924,
0.0376780108,
-0.3502578735,
-0.0877982602,
0.5723382831,
-0.0831527859,
-0.7565862536,
0.1851467043,
0.5457827449,
0.0904880464,
0.058850009,
-0.6779574752,
0.1136348769,
-0.2491843998,
-0.4009102583,
0.105449155,
0.1649779379,
-0.1959619373,
0.3861045241,
0.575180769,
0.1255896688,
-0.0618894883,
0.4938390255,
0.3966709673,
-0.7426591516,
-0.1113185361,
-0.9931307435,
0.7066996098,
-0.2754440606,
-0.4101728499,
0.6387042999,
0.695815742,
0.713883698,
0.0192932002,
0.8743335605,
-0.0203122105,
0.3319402635,
-0.7367678285,
0.7103833556,
-0.4488740265,
0.1819096804,
-0.4106430411,
-1.1797196865,
-0.2710641921,
0.2312675864,
-0.3874675632,
0.0125446012,
0.7293385863,
0.6953417063,
-0.0157721844,
-0.3431031704,
0.4667233527,
0.3427650034,
0.2745589018,
0.361392796,
0.9569977522,
-0.3816107512,
-0.1317917407,
-0.5571061373,
-0.1898868829,
-0.0063697966,
-1.1543502808,
-0.9913705587,
-0.3683165312,
-0.2944697738,
-0.3214311898,
0.4052904844,
0.8458411694,
0.4668151438,
-0.3510032296,
-0.0832675025,
0.0987756625,
-0.0206026807,
-0.0215761587,
-0.2190231383,
0.5466443896,
-0.1884683222,
-0.8276380301,
0.5674373507,
0.4681408703,
-0.0203555152,
-0.2961284816,
-0.0821518078,
0.0464249551,
0.181710884,
0.8542968035,
0.0634984747,
-0.732018292,
-0.4900616109,
0.0027982073,
-0.0226467736,
0.051502984,
0.5819137096,
-0.5294923186,
0.8592128158,
0.4103914797,
0.3165438175,
0.2287044674,
0.0286306366,
0.658814311,
-0.4609190524,
-0.101663366,
0.0963786021,
0.4250663817,
0.5126862526,
-0.2225946486,
0.3982006311,
0.195067808,
-0.7405368686,
-1.0411883593,
0.1091665551,
-0.9997472167,
0.0180892628,
1.2498311996,
-0.0164724626,
-0.2095267177,
0.4474706352,
-0.3221284151,
0.1025558114,
-0.187038213,
0.6281644106,
0.9044306278,
-0.245647788,
-0.0259040855,
-0.8299629688,
0.5255962014,
0.3979816139,
-0.8415179253,
-0.1763818711,
0.8178161383,
0.3262614012,
0.219201982,
0.6771888733,
-0.0181957819,
0.5333614945,
-0.1885931641,
0.1217144355,
0.005673233,
-0.1706689149,
-0.5390328169,
-0.0804037228,
0.4173049927,
0.3451243043
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09391v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09391v3
|
LlaSMol: Advancing Large Language Models for Chemistry with a Large-Scale, Comprehensive, High-Quality Instruction Tuning Dataset
| 2024-02-14T18:42:25 | 2024-04-01T17:28:16 |
Botao Yu, Frazier N. Baker, Ziqi Chen, Xia Ning, Huan Sun
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CE, cs.CL
|
Chemistry plays a crucial role in many domains, such as drug discovery and
material science. While large language models (LLMs) such as GPT-4 exhibit
remarkable capabilities on natural language processing tasks, existing research
indicates that their performance on chemistry tasks is discouragingly low. In
this paper, however, we demonstrate that our developed LLMs can achieve very
strong results on a comprehensive set of chemistry tasks, outperforming the
most advanced GPT-4 and Claude 3 Opus by a substantial margin. To accomplish
this, we propose SMolInstruct, a large-scale, comprehensive, and high-quality
dataset for instruction tuning. It contains 14 selected chemistry tasks and
over three million samples, laying a solid foundation for training and
evaluating LLMs for chemistry. Using SMolInstruct, we fine-tune a set of
open-source LLMs, among which, we find that Mistral serves as the best base
model for chemistry tasks. Our analysis further demonstrates the critical role
of the proposed dataset in driving the performance improvements.
|
[
0.1156092137,
-0.5765644908,
0.781285584,
-0.0778525323,
0.1318912059,
0.1867267638,
-0.4837836027,
0.0502728634,
-0.3228294253,
0.543340385,
-0.5755035281,
-0.7490955591,
-0.5869975686,
0.0862418339,
-0.1291665882,
1.1877845526,
-0.0694940612,
0.4176092744,
-0.3025053442,
0.210344404,
-0.1425137222,
-0.18964912,
-0.4591652155,
-0.4543165863,
0.5592241287,
0.4799645841,
0.3947038949,
0.8212778568,
0.6652219296,
0.3494170606,
0.0112128742,
0.297506392,
-0.7303991914,
0.2236596048,
-0.4356864691,
-0.5223619938,
-0.7581472397,
0.0606097393,
0.5524757504,
0.555565238,
-0.2875163257,
0.1793473065,
0.0558822565,
0.8335807323,
-0.5510769486,
0.4246177971,
-0.5753622055,
-0.1027240753,
-0.3296312392,
-0.0119739315,
-0.4250711799,
-0.1990970671,
0.0377680697,
-0.7157760262,
0.3379864991,
-0.1863772422,
0.6199862361,
0.3534428775,
-0.6501684189,
-0.56227988,
-0.5383194685,
0.9505678415,
-0.7320827246,
0.5837090611,
0.1292565018,
0.3390308022,
-0.4884382188,
-1.1624270678,
-0.1430090517,
-0.4245349765,
0.2540298104,
0.0563137494,
0.2122707963,
0.3934311569,
0.259054333,
0.5419836044,
-0.7511946559,
-0.2315244824,
-0.4447849393,
-0.3653320074,
0.1531791091,
0.3942774236,
0.1286482662,
0.2322503626,
-0.2828215361,
-0.0299474001,
-0.6693249941,
-0.2102887779,
0.1284734607,
0.4461708069,
0.311953038,
0.5769463778,
-0.2283232063,
0.6585490108,
-0.0675811619,
-0.0898013264,
0.0863042697,
-0.2956838012,
-0.3614938855,
0.0634169281,
0.4376478493,
-0.01541935,
0.2277042717,
-0.1467625946,
-0.1180618927,
0.2666926086,
0.2806662321,
-1.3249893188,
-0.7362080216,
0.2558235228,
0.0902282447,
-0.1537239105,
-0.1354826987,
-0.6290495396,
-0.4194823503,
-0.6456302404,
0.5006275773,
-0.417302072,
0.1550423354,
0.027232619,
-0.1777920127,
-0.2373651862,
0.3687294126,
-1.245896101,
0.4981021881,
0.7991071343,
0.8916277289,
-0.3712102175,
-0.2923549712,
-0.5726214051,
0.3738921881,
-0.3478363156,
0.8983415365,
-0.7052621841,
-0.2531960905,
-0.3843429387,
0.1447501183,
0.0200464353,
-0.8224534988,
0.5095489025,
-0.246200636,
-0.0083671026,
-0.3610529602,
-0.7611323595,
0.2291565239,
0.0194521081,
-0.6466204524,
0.9574819803,
0.3834351599,
-0.2982699573,
0.23658292,
-0.6050729156,
-0.3578731716,
0.0070449621,
-0.1232685074,
-0.2407544255,
0.2551569045,
0.2391762733,
0.3703530133,
-0.4066621065,
0.0640785992,
-0.1519853324,
-0.4176429808,
0.3416243494,
-0.2965750992,
0.5561969876,
0.2202853709,
-0.3259043694,
0.2317756265,
-0.6729654074,
0.1922281832,
-0.4742797315,
-0.5680711269,
0.0437169001,
-0.266220361,
-0.0061514825,
0.2308056802,
0.4282231331,
-0.4346336424,
0.3536656797,
-0.2565374374,
0.551784575,
1.2143887281,
-0.1277388781,
0.4888139069,
-0.0674657375,
0.5839192867,
-0.2391515374,
0.1634780914,
0.0149439033,
-0.2309794426,
-0.8018456101,
-0.6566849351,
0.3359578252,
0.2709809542,
-0.5922535062,
0.0061132777,
-0.3509078324,
-0.5634762645,
-0.3705216646,
0.6977108717,
0.3438301086,
0.4148893952,
0.3345719874,
0.2008685172,
-0.3682694435,
-0.9601997137,
-0.4027872384,
0.2739419043,
0.036687769,
0.3586700857,
0.5135685802,
-0.4091893137,
0.5562363267,
-0.7377436161,
-0.3290360272,
-0.1643051803,
-0.1059049144,
0.4020452797,
0.1267943084,
0.194082588,
-0.4585488439,
-0.7218309641,
0.2397925109,
-0.5707120895,
-0.3033796251,
0.423633188,
-0.6512047052,
0.1169874296,
0.583822906,
-0.533659637,
-0.1995079666,
0.7516309619,
-0.231858477,
0.4527176619,
-0.1985468864,
0.2429243773,
-0.9832007289,
0.0715055019,
-0.0694788918,
-0.0288623851,
-0.7448303103,
-0.0567468926,
0.2782999277,
-0.2598253489,
-0.6092612147,
0.6330834627,
-0.356757462,
0.1124910042,
-0.4016939402,
-0.2082244903,
-0.0597571768,
0.420822978,
-0.111610502,
0.9404037595,
0.5170717239,
-0.5436627865,
0.4425386786,
-0.1310759038,
-0.2706746757,
0.4544245899,
-0.558744669,
-0.0638335496,
0.2626257241,
0.3491245508,
-0.7656827569,
-0.6884182096,
-0.1038095281,
-0.1328358948,
0.3539522588,
-0.2582920194,
-0.5700205564,
-0.1566627026,
-0.1039358303,
0.2655285299,
0.3282551169,
-0.5534527302,
0.7170080543,
0.1976896673,
-0.2275843322,
-0.4665095508,
-0.2998201549,
-0.1736623496,
-0.1524542123,
-0.5791979432,
0.1870842874,
-0.3587372005,
0.0696089715,
-0.2074230462,
-0.5980561972,
-0.2128424793,
-0.2127710879,
0.4322032928,
0.2518931925,
-0.1556992829,
0.3197771013,
0.0138538601,
-0.258665055,
-0.1739697456,
-0.4507749975,
0.5352461338,
-0.2037851363,
0.0543276407,
-0.3159333467,
-0.1374072134,
0.867598474,
-0.2104852647,
0.5995816588,
0.3930809796,
-0.0470265932,
-0.6977379918,
-0.158369571,
-0.2893784344,
-0.6253324747,
0.4518037736,
-0.2142282873,
-0.9772515893,
0.160659343,
-0.3959563076,
-0.0177657194,
0.1939106733,
0.7752902508,
-0.0707244426,
0.8962239623,
0.3413375318,
0.0770862922,
0.4166659713,
-0.3000909388,
0.2326834351,
-0.6675072908,
-0.0832015574,
-0.2996817827,
-0.0713364184,
-0.3535092771,
-0.583379209,
0.6049181223,
-0.2651144862,
-0.3921667635,
0.2573927045,
-0.4285292327,
0.8724840283,
0.3283866346,
0.1375350058,
0.1856718212,
0.3251529634,
-0.1204311177,
-0.096511282,
-0.4758428633,
-0.4591197073,
1.4005935192,
0.0802033842,
1.0022367239,
0.186330989,
0.5801020265,
0.1685016304,
0.2577993274,
-0.6065725684,
0.5722445846,
-0.4580560327,
-0.9251163602,
-0.2397262156,
-0.6806234717,
-0.8470058441,
0.2916912735,
0.1327359378,
-0.3487577438,
-0.4126450717,
0.2479953021,
0.0158203617,
-0.1028648317,
-0.7899908423,
1.0574630499,
-0.3730745614,
-0.6852868795,
-0.1641252339,
-0.2044317424,
0.3747933805,
-0.1446763575,
0.2104449272,
-0.2670936584,
0.0558454357,
0.4483472705,
-0.388246417,
0.5106594563,
-0.0614315607,
-0.3774862885,
0.0773193687,
0.1267047971,
0.3195328712,
-0.0240625832,
-0.1818674058,
-0.0318642706,
0.1500906944,
-0.5711476803,
-0.9171423316,
1.2982031107,
-0.5539684296,
-0.4215104282,
-0.4248521924,
-0.7557564974,
-0.264383167,
0.2630471587,
0.3131175935,
0.514726758,
-0.0286169127,
0.1156709641,
0.7154500484,
0.0222313181,
0.0629924312,
0.4809667468,
-0.0254866481,
-0.4887624979,
1.326469183,
0.1992109567,
0.4648803473,
0.2331871092,
0.0814554542,
-0.3088355064,
-0.2795243561,
-0.3984443247,
0.2632973492,
-0.8326660395,
-0.196288839,
-0.3463191688,
-0.1742807776,
-0.5840219855,
-0.1699197292,
-0.5485780239,
-0.4828311503,
-0.1333264261,
-0.0946774483,
0.2641714811,
0.6925985217,
0.0999070555,
0.2887888551,
-0.6679552794,
0.4845837355,
0.3678331375,
0.5586004257,
-0.1801514328,
-0.4097743332,
-0.642562151,
0.0923509374,
-0.320474118,
-0.461568743,
0.1752029359,
0.432137996,
0.7369451523,
0.1602623165,
-0.2313491553,
0.5977289677,
-0.6988502741,
0.6902273893,
-0.3373474181,
-0.8149870634,
0.6563344598,
-0.5705092549,
0.368326813,
0.5459774137,
0.2739503086,
-0.1648592651,
-0.2755793333,
-0.5043101907,
-0.8870041966,
0.6720226407,
0.3860069811,
-0.129192695,
0.171950385,
0.2200525254,
0.0663219392,
0.3166978657,
-0.6951719522,
-0.1824442297,
-0.1387677789,
-0.5832982659,
-0.2533139884,
0.1958425641,
-0.2245431244,
-0.3827316165,
1.0236836672,
-0.0682171062,
-0.0303306151,
-0.3121539056,
-0.2636905611,
0.0298383515,
0.3352635801,
0.7182180882,
0.5624614954,
-0.3485971391,
0.1804776788,
0.0242817104,
-0.8095461726,
0.354711473,
-0.0468591787,
0.4023467004,
-0.3757672906,
0.3622974157,
0.5362874269,
0.1337715536,
-1.0167793036,
0.3229395449,
0.0774990097,
0.0122885769,
0.0405105017,
0.6787773371,
0.0530416444,
0.2858034074,
0.2265385836,
-0.1497262269,
0.3092484772,
-0.6893410087,
0.2350732982,
0.2637919188,
-0.1922426522,
-0.0992879868,
0.3508586884,
0.0375428684,
0.058054965,
0.6036741734,
0.0509655476,
-0.4288852811,
0.6333953142,
0.5500524044,
0.5291053057,
-0.453648299,
0.1503886729,
0.421657443,
0.1378847808,
-0.2340892851,
0.1136731952,
-0.1784981042,
-0.2418171316,
-0.1356176436,
-0.8276446462,
-0.3314647079,
0.1706207097,
-0.4449212849,
0.2224278003,
-0.6913232803,
-0.0676757619,
0.1124459654,
0.2466918975,
-0.3921678662,
0.168049857,
-0.1537187696,
0.5270005465,
-0.9106761813,
0.8912898302,
0.6669400334,
-0.1041148826,
-0.5943100452,
-0.1968107522,
0.2670089602,
-0.3920356631,
0.7968425751,
0.187648803,
-0.2489920259,
0.1830794215,
-0.6900581717,
-1.0350195169,
1.1937664747,
0.5799813867,
-0.4799180329,
0.0409801416,
0.20606938,
0.6750316024,
-0.2440166175,
0.0560210906,
0.9606980085,
0.3995589912,
0.2362428755,
-0.7514278293,
-0.127973631,
-0.379748404,
-0.1915982068,
0.4368018508,
-0.5929125547,
1.0558552742,
0.0131387608,
-0.0657561198,
0.2253578454,
0.3603266478,
0.6123346686,
0.1984290481,
-0.0789841041,
0.5328812003,
0.8106076717,
-0.216117546,
0.9017559886,
-0.2748997509,
0.2771693468,
1.0647791624,
-0.3371033669,
0.7426491976,
0.3410021961,
-0.1948060393,
0.4277448356,
0.5449715257,
-0.1964591593,
0.6756871939,
0.3506961465,
-0.48913607,
-0.3427168727,
0.0809481367,
-0.1881912202,
0.2297149599,
0.8673242927,
-0.3233944774,
-0.2976693809,
0.0312865898,
-0.2568855286,
-0.0948918685,
-0.3707594872,
0.463122189,
-0.0499493517,
-0.4867376983,
0.6201456189,
-0.1812548041,
0.2814243436,
-0.6048499346,
-0.3397985101,
-0.2866331339,
0.4724934399,
-0.2496078312,
-0.5354503989,
-0.4168180525,
-0.1042600945,
-0.2209881693,
0.0206982978,
0.4264722764,
-0.6107591987,
-0.6011326313,
-0.0544965975,
0.0833371431,
0.1216888055,
0.1173964515,
-0.4883495867,
0.112540938,
0.0740938634,
-0.0488404185,
0.3777502775,
0.5728145838,
0.0536570102,
0.7191746831,
0.8135732412,
0.2362934798,
0.186504975,
-0.0478155203,
0.9353201985,
-0.5368974805,
-0.241192475,
-0.7337084413,
0.4896962345,
-0.0380037948,
-0.263505429,
0.8334066868,
0.9417372346,
0.6988703609,
-0.2730020285,
0.7660511732,
0.4457054734,
0.436352849,
-0.8141433597,
0.5360386372,
-0.4108614624,
0.3772707582,
-0.268489182,
-1.1620862484,
-0.1768301278,
0.6972894669,
-0.0673068762,
0.2355986387,
0.8137796521,
1.0787892342,
-0.3635978103,
-0.1836584657,
0.2420013398,
0.4640995264,
0.6913827658,
0.5906502008,
0.7322616577,
-0.3287443221,
0.4352417588,
-0.1328972131,
-0.120662719,
-0.1647369266,
-0.515742898,
-1.1507849693,
-0.5125728846,
0.0061346833,
-0.3090530932,
0.1834663749,
0.9514214396,
0.6088676453,
-0.7746830583,
-0.5430269837,
-0.3212798238,
-0.3292754889,
0.0326641537,
-0.1870792359,
0.4803281724,
-0.5820427537,
-0.8730306625,
0.63568753,
0.395336628,
0.0187396277,
-0.0925219804,
-0.1936225295,
0.135446012,
0.2013069242,
0.58450073,
0.1058461592,
-0.710563302,
0.1319966763,
0.1871435046,
-0.335801959,
0.0038251579,
0.9613630176,
-0.5289285183,
0.4894744754,
0.2769254744,
0.4562882185,
0.7254408598,
-0.1283290833,
0.6532821655,
-0.651679635,
-0.0282090809,
0.1643529832,
0.1533581913,
0.3324821889,
-0.2567328215,
0.6666345,
-0.0085694408,
-0.9132481813,
-0.7751793265,
0.1050939709,
-0.9681783319,
-0.6033211946,
1.1708073616,
0.1192877069,
-0.3588757813,
0.2089242339,
-0.4882005751,
0.2609107792,
-0.660489738,
0.7539545894,
0.9730221629,
-0.5373392105,
-0.0995476544,
-0.7614447474,
0.8332274556,
0.3484731317,
-0.9820917249,
0.4028427899,
0.8846016526,
0.5128962994,
-0.1070356071,
0.4025960565,
-0.0101472717,
0.4366154373,
-0.0638388693,
-0.1719498038,
-0.1716382653,
-0.7145460248,
-0.2386199385,
-0.0654870123,
0.2032103688,
0.2888700068
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09390v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09390v2
|
HGOT: Hierarchical Graph of Thoughts for Retrieval-Augmented In-Context Learning in Factuality Evaluation
| 2024-02-14T18:41:19 | 2024-07-02T12:42:59 |
Yihao Fang, Stephen W. Thomas, Xiaodan Zhu
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
With the widespread adoption of large language models (LLMs) in numerous
applications, the challenge of factuality and the propensity for hallucinations
has emerged as a significant concern. To address this issue, particularly in
retrieval-augmented in-context learning, we introduce the hierarchical graph of
thoughts (HGOT), a structured, multi-layered graph approach designed to enhance
the retrieval of pertinent passages during in-context learning. The framework
utilizes the emergent planning capabilities of LLMs, employing the
divide-and-conquer strategy to break down complex queries into manageable
sub-queries. It refines self-consistency majority voting for answer selection,
which incorporates the recently proposed citation recall and precision metrics
to assess the quality of thoughts, linking an answer's credibility
intrinsically to the thought's quality. This methodology introduces a weighted
system in majority voting, prioritizing answers based on the citation quality
of their thoughts. Additionally, we propose a scoring mechanism for evaluating
retrieved passages, considering factors such as citation frequency and quality,
self-consistency confidence, and the retrieval module's ranking. Experiments
indicate that HGOT excels as a versatile approach, outperforming competing
models in FEVER by up to $7\%$ and matching leading models such as
Retrieve-then-Read in Open-SQuAD, and DSP in HotPotQA, demonstrating its
efficacy in enhancing LLMs' factuality.
|
[
-0.3886141777,
-1.2653195858,
0.8717535734,
0.0387940966,
-0.2705957592,
0.3557602465,
-0.1879443824,
-0.349609375,
0.5434702635,
0.3768878281,
-0.3613953292,
-0.5574827194,
-0.5047964454,
-0.032315895,
-0.247019887,
1.1121584177,
0.1282840967,
-0.4229030013,
-0.2190546393,
0.0229257587,
-0.4296105206,
-0.6632960439,
-0.3701911271,
-0.5001266599,
0.5869360566,
0.2771330476,
0.6385495663,
0.4669894278,
0.6420939565,
0.226011157,
-0.0826032683,
0.2526310086,
-0.7183065414,
0.3407901227,
-0.4191801548,
0.0674361065,
-0.6674124002,
0.0742575973,
0.6549383998,
0.7469475865,
-0.2867093086,
0.093520321,
0.238203615,
0.696053803,
-0.7176751494,
0.2551317513,
-0.7780653834,
0.1278113276,
0.0445048697,
-0.5240931511,
-0.5235182047,
-0.3446270227,
0.4380713105,
-0.5130616426,
-0.0114418892,
0.3265730441,
0.6578059793,
0.1993192583,
-0.4601575434,
-0.3409675062,
-0.4164096117,
0.4928481281,
-0.3864063919,
0.4977345169,
0.2562971711,
0.153257817,
-0.156991899,
-0.786985755,
-0.435572952,
-0.3289069831,
-0.1199901029,
0.3936662078,
0.1205176711,
0.089605175,
0.2031194717,
0.3882520199,
-0.6343883872,
-0.5313191414,
0.0749494061,
-0.2033061981,
0.2922305465,
0.0033486998,
0.1650549024,
-0.6872089505,
-0.6464425921,
0.2238713354,
-0.5892305374,
-0.3913686275,
-0.0039575086,
0.3626791835,
0.2538353503,
0.4809397161,
-0.2462541312,
0.4973602295,
0.2403497398,
-0.3292661309,
0.3381121755,
-0.2232908159,
-0.3079126775,
0.0722338557,
0.577216208,
-0.0038725245,
-0.198904261,
-0.4238512218,
-0.2727284431,
-0.3871960938,
0.5399535894,
-0.8127265573,
-0.3863625228,
0.0253819097,
-0.4023193419,
-0.1217644513,
-0.0220988356,
-0.8273453116,
-0.3220882714,
-0.4632546902,
0.6993312836,
-0.619276166,
-0.2321239859,
-0.0923196226,
0.031119084,
-0.209141016,
0.4458512664,
-0.8014963865,
0.3915743232,
0.5985484123,
0.8666645885,
-0.3696115911,
-0.4491250515,
-0.4740163386,
0.1482450217,
-0.3103312254,
0.8252972364,
-0.5267444849,
-0.3204731643,
-0.0824865699,
-0.2593816817,
-0.3220740557,
-0.4898171425,
0.487750113,
-0.8034817576,
0.0965170711,
-0.6652579308,
-0.6853365898,
-0.2130352706,
0.9412881732,
-0.528981626,
1.1272907257,
0.1547318399,
-1.0477318764,
0.3031407297,
-0.570694387,
-0.327919513,
0.3625038862,
-0.3589200675,
-0.1444647312,
-0.3203408718,
0.0776307285,
0.1807849407,
-0.0168696307,
0.2272477746,
-0.2217159718,
-0.3951046169,
-0.1358565837,
-0.2718349695,
0.6067877412,
0.077925913,
-0.5275563598,
0.3328843117,
-0.4353220165,
0.1812690049,
0.0149752069,
-0.4863596261,
-0.3175232112,
0.0344557501,
-0.2652817965,
0.2012057602,
0.3024657369,
-0.4616179764,
0.1905368716,
-0.2785815299,
0.2397600859,
0.5471710563,
0.3569726944,
0.2544031441,
-0.1391239911,
0.2388216704,
-0.0410080329,
0.1792742461,
0.053172186,
-0.5147073269,
-0.5775010586,
-0.2117070854,
0.0578506961,
0.5218487978,
-0.859461844,
0.5459359288,
-0.274573952,
-0.3036486208,
-0.3337584138,
0.0895079821,
0.3274233043,
1.1068499088,
0.4766396284,
-0.0939489976,
-0.3989712596,
-0.7930160761,
0.02534022,
-0.4589779079,
0.3518287539,
0.3258939087,
1.0076192617,
-0.4902326167,
0.9347633123,
-0.6115995646,
-0.1873854101,
-0.0620374195,
0.2686490715,
0.0374655426,
0.2782574296,
0.2340015024,
-0.7930925488,
-0.3146306574,
0.0226604212,
-0.9756710529,
0.2386577874,
0.2103745341,
-0.5283955932,
-0.0052842679,
0.318140775,
-0.5649769306,
0.2218059897,
0.0958525985,
-0.2242884487,
0.7072976232,
-0.1050205007,
0.4302364886,
-1.0271039009,
0.1097466871,
-0.1887842715,
-0.2759189308,
-0.2322252244,
0.3678015172,
0.0767145678,
0.0883170813,
-0.0915731713,
0.2488103807,
-0.2376637757,
-0.0062074615,
-0.2776614726,
0.5102259517,
-0.0215159934,
0.5521157384,
-0.0532496758,
0.7753603458,
0.3422949314,
-0.2070849538,
0.2150961608,
0.2813325524,
-0.4300128222,
0.5917187929,
-0.2555240691,
0.5209951401,
-0.1061730608,
0.323964864,
-0.8853239417,
-0.2171428651,
0.1835837513,
-0.2255927324,
0.1364705563,
-0.2960411608,
-0.5382231474,
-0.2385990918,
-0.1819367558,
0.3458230197,
0.3258874416,
-0.741768539,
0.4529877305,
0.6413500905,
-0.1258779317,
-0.8452017307,
-0.2060849816,
0.2865579426,
-0.0890848935,
-0.3964765668,
0.3836434782,
-0.1740634888,
-0.2833946943,
0.1087367982,
-0.140911743,
0.0737518445,
-0.0751095414,
0.033615388,
0.3349490762,
-0.1364670396,
0.2262023091,
0.0176859237,
0.194005549,
0.1371265203,
-0.7207669616,
0.4778737724,
-0.6140486598,
-0.3362998962,
0.1285839826,
0.2370112985,
0.3388642669,
-0.1385366917,
0.3694938719,
0.4444710612,
-0.6299749613,
-0.1969601512,
-0.5662597418,
-0.0052841743,
-0.3797155023,
0.3149846494,
-0.4832450151,
-1.0103707314,
0.4554936886,
-0.0738803148,
-0.1460112482,
0.4276300967,
0.8390655518,
-0.3277279437,
0.8272758126,
0.4120365083,
-0.113147296,
0.4449250698,
-0.4480053782,
0.2374774218,
-1.0462470055,
-0.4854483008,
-0.1140317693,
-0.1152087823,
-0.4805482626,
-0.3417794704,
0.7024345994,
-0.1077403277,
-0.3046979606,
0.0038038243,
-0.4837013185,
0.5920662284,
0.3005439937,
0.4565161765,
0.4365615845,
0.1081650779,
-0.4129105508,
-0.0091958195,
-0.5762498379,
-0.475605756,
0.8318714499,
0.1044824272,
0.5095979571,
0.1435703337,
0.9086267352,
0.4979075789,
0.4614946544,
-1.0294183493,
0.5817170143,
0.3237434924,
-0.8736451268,
-0.5968123078,
-0.5707264543,
-0.7668802142,
0.7643424869,
-0.1562914252,
-0.8691717386,
0.1113946363,
-0.0458919071,
-0.2832226455,
0.4048317671,
-0.4241760373,
0.6974242926,
-0.0170164574,
-0.5743499398,
-0.2967155576,
-0.622728765,
0.4773030281,
-0.0231752265,
0.1007684916,
0.1556656361,
0.2314009368,
0.8138794303,
-0.2427593321,
0.5486995578,
-0.0649902895,
-0.0853606164,
0.6722622514,
0.2907630205,
0.4660924375,
0.1765601784,
-0.1100485176,
-0.0902701095,
-0.0308023654,
-0.4206544459,
-0.7573042512,
0.7000230551,
-0.6358551383,
-0.7373677492,
-0.4882582128,
-0.6935957074,
-0.3851534128,
0.5494284034,
0.2469225228,
0.488764137,
-0.3875918686,
0.1068533286,
0.7400300503,
0.2777424455,
0.1914091557,
0.0717837438,
-0.4332004488,
-0.6595876217,
0.9005756974,
0.4044821262,
0.3043341637,
0.4036604464,
0.3066034913,
-0.4459208846,
-0.6344442964,
-0.3551398814,
0.258713454,
-1.1416453123,
-0.0838366896,
-0.6852181554,
-0.3835124671,
-0.3152002692,
0.1390289217,
-0.0857163817,
-0.279358685,
0.2525310516,
-0.3923954368,
-0.0118580312,
0.767168045,
0.1642059237,
0.1091538444,
-0.334349364,
0.2347647846,
0.381000787,
0.3084875941,
0.1236229688,
-0.5831763744,
-0.466222316,
-0.1042291448,
-0.5753880143,
-0.9165418744,
0.3324032724,
-0.094608672,
0.4367480278,
0.162231043,
-0.0473874621,
0.8095170259,
-0.4973869324,
0.5728291273,
-0.0220557209,
-0.7900072932,
0.6236919165,
-0.4530248046,
-0.0706032589,
0.8159655333,
0.3728473783,
-0.2531808913,
-0.2781791389,
-0.6920205951,
-0.6347491741,
0.1994819939,
0.2561381161,
-0.2474811822,
-0.2278898209,
0.5105606318,
0.0490242168,
0.3893145025,
-0.5684140325,
-0.0387630835,
-0.3756481111,
-0.0288764443,
0.1953328252,
-0.2526747286,
-0.3435206413,
-0.5731570125,
0.5439947248,
-0.4231412709,
0.2309505492,
0.5003314614,
-0.2310591489,
-0.1607172042,
0.3459605575,
0.0763256103,
0.853241384,
-0.7350894213,
0.4915178716,
0.2160770148,
-0.6439805627,
0.0561602525,
-0.263759166,
-0.3245942891,
-0.2076538354,
0.4848393202,
0.6145784259,
0.2870039642,
-0.3276814222,
0.3860677481,
0.235474363,
-0.162024796,
-0.0855578855,
-0.1184516177,
-0.0141021274,
0.1753629297,
0.374189347,
0.1263259053,
0.6071559191,
-1.0139789581,
0.3832328916,
0.3377812803,
-0.5202596784,
-0.2085615247,
0.3952053189,
0.0911099464,
-0.2565380335,
0.8910838366,
-0.4752853513,
-0.7845297456,
0.3101750016,
0.8290963769,
0.9579760432,
0.1390928179,
0.2692439854,
0.4721945226,
0.4197283089,
-0.0224252827,
0.3999536335,
-0.1913532764,
-0.7465510964,
-0.3134450316,
-0.5486658812,
-0.6501362324,
0.0189879406,
-0.5523993373,
-0.1945729852,
-0.4618626237,
-0.4592273533,
-0.2980514169,
0.4024015665,
-0.3286747634,
0.3541925251,
0.2117555887,
0.7236927152,
-0.5241120458,
1.0059152842,
0.5644003153,
-0.5142396688,
-0.6429098845,
0.3832015395,
-0.0133028477,
-0.4639984071,
0.5339044929,
-0.0309608448,
-0.5297459364,
0.1473761946,
-0.3479790688,
-1.0538166761,
1.1125621796,
0.3944967687,
-0.2947092354,
-0.238817066,
-0.3035951257,
0.4891401529,
-0.5178034902,
0.2757912576,
0.7422752976,
0.4326106906,
0.3398874998,
-0.6422792077,
0.1479618996,
-0.2026347965,
-0.4387960732,
0.0518873967,
-0.6155936718,
0.8289806843,
-0.4284677207,
-0.2319771647,
-0.3989025652,
0.7336699367,
0.5651555061,
0.4029491246,
0.59993577,
0.4759664834,
1.3583712578,
0.048304338,
1.0562595129,
-0.1081379279,
0.5688279867,
1.0980621576,
-0.3633422256,
0.9680549502,
0.4269225299,
-0.0068152165,
0.8134378195,
0.7294822335,
0.3638547063,
0.5539317131,
-0.0157782827,
-0.0837533027,
-0.327791512,
-0.0439483188,
-0.2483123094,
0.0129157156,
0.4075547457,
0.0649286062,
-0.1804223657,
-0.1251387745,
0.0235070977,
0.04381923,
-0.0932096615,
0.5716676116,
0.1603022665,
-0.7166885138,
0.6994209886,
-0.443102628,
0.3820720017,
-0.2338567376,
-0.0250491202,
-0.1280250102,
0.0275460444,
-0.3702522814,
-0.8352071047,
0.1208635941,
-0.0962453634,
-0.2913834453,
-0.1043847129,
0.6450455189,
-0.3593558669,
-0.4133404493,
0.4857804775,
0.7136380076,
0.0896365941,
-0.171849966,
-0.8424177766,
-0.0861222446,
-0.3012830913,
-0.4574976265,
0.2746160328,
0.577830255,
-0.044583369,
0.6135451198,
0.3370704949,
0.1068896502,
-0.0198301021,
0.340888381,
0.7717767954,
-0.5509554148,
-0.4438855052,
-0.8919285536,
0.1190763488,
-0.2579764128,
-0.2014653832,
0.9018492103,
0.7714005709,
0.7490839958,
0.2312508076,
0.7644577622,
-0.0861562341,
0.2934426367,
-0.5427196026,
0.7877459526,
-0.4722048342,
0.1536473185,
-0.607834518,
-0.8708527684,
-0.0922590643,
0.6647879481,
-0.5994499922,
0.0979088843,
1.2147415876,
0.5617536902,
0.0017183679,
0.0590462387,
0.3435988426,
0.2519058883,
0.4263269603,
0.3502871096,
1.0669108629,
-0.4201651216,
0.2941216826,
-0.2133523524,
-0.3992930949,
-0.2319984734,
-0.6169572473,
-0.8258389235,
-0.7293280363,
-0.3047625124,
-0.4618604481,
0.0868746489,
1.2488324642,
0.8469322324,
-0.5146784782,
-0.3837490082,
0.2099698931,
0.4133882821,
-0.2322713882,
-0.1994002163,
0.6850167513,
-0.6991365552,
-0.4565710425,
0.5229042768,
0.494661659,
-0.2483203858,
-0.166756615,
-0.1599178314,
-0.4489557445,
0.2255757153,
1.0655885935,
-0.2002450973,
-0.7184514403,
-0.5795948505,
0.1933141351,
-0.3200445473,
0.3296384513,
0.7963200212,
-0.8879978657,
0.5726634264,
0.549890399,
0.5504194498,
0.7113456726,
0.3082183897,
-0.011473407,
-0.4177972972,
-0.1281754673,
0.462634027,
0.4518178701,
0.2466323376,
-0.4929002523,
0.5795831084,
0.5531015396,
-0.6456298828,
-0.7795904279,
0.1284516305,
-0.9982780814,
-0.2759314477,
0.9748228192,
-0.0217874348,
-0.3505542874,
-0.1550700068,
-0.3530643582,
0.1710853279,
-0.2149644494,
1.1263239384,
0.8839775324,
-0.355638653,
0.1941588074,
-0.611461699,
0.4465899765,
0.1915904135,
-0.8774120808,
0.1515408158,
0.5281901956,
0.1871933639,
0.3554852903,
0.8748173118,
-0.1422143877,
-0.0187221952,
0.0341327451,
-0.1781110018,
0.1392397732,
-0.8389364481,
0.1407686621,
0.5719051957,
0.0070926072,
0.1602692753
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09371v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09371v1
|
Transformers Can Achieve Length Generalization But Not Robustly
| 2024-02-14T18:18:29 | 2024-02-14T18:18:29 |
Yongchao Zhou, Uri Alon, Xinyun Chen, Xuezhi Wang, Rishabh Agarwal, Denny Zhou
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Length generalization, defined as the ability to extrapolate from shorter
training sequences to longer test ones, is a significant challenge for language
models. This issue persists even with large-scale Transformers handling
relatively straightforward tasks. In this paper, we test the Transformer's
ability of length generalization using the task of addition of two integers. We
show that the success of length generalization is intricately linked to the
data format and the type of position encoding. Using the right combination of
data format and position encodings, we show for the first time that standard
Transformers can extrapolate to a sequence length that is 2.5x the input
length. Nevertheless, unlike in-distribution generalization, length
generalization remains fragile, significantly influenced by factors like random
weight initialization and training data order, leading to large variances
across different random seeds.
|
[
-0.4931301475,
-0.4705176055,
0.5167638659,
0.5562697649,
-0.3195059299,
0.0811046511,
-0.5236409903,
-0.5451210737,
0.0656340867,
0.0141255828,
-0.0791467801,
-0.0063510179,
-0.9987237453,
0.2285346985,
-0.7478644252,
1.0174162388,
0.1297499388,
-0.2910085022,
0.1787582338,
-0.241787076,
-0.3748301268,
-0.5686163306,
-0.3197639287,
-0.1318373829,
0.4575944543,
0.4507499635,
1.3690117598,
0.7233330011,
0.8515774012,
0.3528796434,
0.0565631092,
0.0102708405,
-0.2922082245,
0.0823956951,
0.1224035397,
-0.8794635534,
-0.2286467403,
-0.2036104351,
0.9863344431,
0.7830981612,
-0.1007548347,
0.1360648423,
-0.2815055549,
0.8275899291,
-0.2200400978,
-0.0374362953,
-0.4463640153,
0.1409623772,
-0.1650386751,
-0.005619538,
-0.4770389497,
-0.3248560429,
0.1137618572,
-0.3900972307,
0.5368469357,
-0.0348318852,
0.9089016914,
0.3449085355,
-0.3925661445,
-0.2352086753,
-1.5019674301,
0.896527648,
-0.5264239311,
0.6260994673,
0.2279326618,
0.557049036,
0.1076877713,
-0.5690276027,
-0.7060880065,
-0.1680253148,
-0.3240127265,
-0.1035021171,
-0.1097198948,
-0.0812315345,
0.7534650564,
0.4260824919,
-0.5732477307,
0.1647744775,
-0.6831005812,
0.2113692015,
0.8191661239,
0.1169166118,
0.1559725702,
0.0619560517,
-0.0377152525,
-0.6897953153,
-0.3197523654,
0.4530444741,
0.8132758737,
0.0129682431,
-0.2459807545,
0.7524294853,
-0.045174893,
0.5649950504,
0.2442851663,
0.13728863,
0.2257690877,
-0.2073937356,
0.0596275292,
-0.2213469744,
0.7094730139,
0.4044315815,
0.4675683677,
-0.1783622503,
-0.0485883169,
0.0161802713,
0.2360503227,
-0.7396649718,
-0.0805928409,
0.171657443,
-0.339216888,
-0.109626852,
0.4475206435,
-0.7102153897,
-0.0155671341,
-0.0704883188,
0.2905704975,
-0.4148492515,
0.1167552769,
0.4284637272,
-0.4975929558,
0.6641643643,
-0.1669106483,
-1.4494971037,
0.4406636357,
0.7150737047,
0.749658823,
-0.1324970573,
-0.2713839412,
-0.2775441408,
-0.0804028213,
-0.490498364,
0.643224597,
-0.673345983,
-0.5647669435,
-0.2507970929,
0.0474958196,
0.1434883922,
-0.3340971768,
0.4179171622,
-0.5542364717,
0.1730597764,
0.1416660845,
-0.3478503823,
0.2173448652,
-0.1135567352,
-0.6201022267,
0.9507648349,
0.5545653701,
-0.5782524347,
0.5803438425,
-0.6085810661,
-0.6733968854,
-0.1619644016,
-0.3398044705,
-0.7065368891,
0.5096264482,
0.1533753127,
0.263646096,
-0.2232624143,
0.3865650296,
-0.2027093023,
-0.8349295855,
0.441201508,
-0.7193863988,
0.4408843815,
-0.1788650453,
-0.3788523376,
-0.1290382445,
-0.8152252436,
-0.0898965374,
0.2075006068,
-0.4824812114,
-0.079043068,
0.0356936045,
-0.2110579163,
0.0879451111,
0.0081938608,
-0.7103680968,
0.6439270973,
-0.6198170781,
0.2260388136,
0.5091406107,
-0.3470732272,
0.7317095399,
-0.2479021251,
0.5148362517,
-0.1410802305,
0.1975417733,
-0.0214648601,
-0.4846924543,
-0.9426185489,
0.05960932,
0.5721487999,
0.5877645612,
-0.7123147845,
0.5137611628,
-0.9601463675,
-0.5934028029,
-0.1872905493,
-0.1680852324,
-0.0350425541,
0.0196708255,
0.5272092223,
-0.2569011152,
-0.586658299,
-1.0669176579,
-0.2761872709,
-0.1592134982,
-0.7387068272,
-0.0832894593,
0.3625830412,
-0.3026025891,
1.0636562109,
-0.7065120935,
0.1125749722,
-0.2601361573,
0.0923093334,
0.5909364223,
0.4202097952,
0.4769101739,
-0.6984478235,
-0.4003615975,
-0.0905756503,
-0.6919534802,
0.2967151999,
-0.1655453146,
0.5055066943,
-0.2214445919,
0.0848646387,
-0.6375722289,
0.5588353872,
0.5907917023,
-0.2431505919,
0.4766098559,
-0.4416673779,
-0.110506393,
-0.8585401773,
-0.3229739666,
0.0018873293,
-0.1179088429,
-0.788421452,
-0.1294946969,
0.1258880645,
-0.1605307311,
-0.2442946285,
0.0231002923,
-0.0536111332,
-0.2251913995,
-0.2298075259,
-0.4792788625,
0.0258292109,
0.4043920636,
-0.05475026,
0.7040600777,
0.4217485487,
-0.6058601737,
0.5789929032,
0.146247521,
-0.1987870187,
0.3242799342,
-0.9604988098,
0.1283139288,
-0.354919672,
0.3274247348,
-0.8345860839,
-0.4342031777,
-0.1784975678,
-0.4804107547,
0.3625237048,
-0.1257620305,
-0.637403667,
-0.6686013937,
-0.3029796779,
0.6361401677,
0.9061109424,
-0.4095007479,
0.5118047595,
-0.1652490348,
-0.1185878888,
-0.6222816706,
-0.8549997211,
-0.0592719577,
-0.4631109536,
-0.8441259265,
0.3235795796,
-0.0930046961,
-0.1639977694,
-0.5338771343,
-0.0694237277,
-0.1041748822,
-0.1391147673,
0.041560661,
-0.0165405516,
-0.143744126,
0.1661427915,
0.2769729495,
-0.2588516176,
0.1882972866,
0.0030569925,
0.5372699499,
-0.1001077294,
-0.5545243621,
-0.3576812446,
0.5363815427,
0.5685655475,
0.1360237896,
0.5794481635,
0.6590558887,
-0.3047474921,
-0.1585058719,
-0.3573589325,
-0.266666621,
-0.5665596128,
0.4376939237,
-0.4030107856,
-0.8085343838,
0.3566025794,
0.1846776158,
0.0100542614,
0.6018401384,
0.1078186855,
-0.0883448645,
1.2270895243,
0.7950381637,
0.2704032063,
0.1658131927,
-0.4085242152,
0.4403577745,
-0.5805804133,
-0.0923011824,
-0.486100316,
-0.6204068661,
-0.7756742239,
-0.3487383425,
0.0727978125,
-0.0260699242,
-0.153973639,
0.7780637145,
-0.5022079349,
0.5181859136,
0.5265051126,
-0.0116159376,
0.0723397508,
-0.0706091672,
0.2574953735,
-0.3231658638,
-0.3803054988,
-0.1119275913,
1.106898427,
0.6439838409,
0.9425349236,
0.3490260541,
0.3821799755,
0.256885916,
-0.0251505375,
-1.072893858,
0.1996180117,
-0.5084531903,
-0.1415042579,
-0.7264592648,
-0.3431266248,
-0.8542639613,
-0.092841208,
0.0389655903,
-0.4445755482,
0.6157624125,
-0.0634294823,
-0.3035257757,
0.27628389,
-0.6297529936,
0.2666056454,
-0.3781829178,
0.2588485777,
0.1353674531,
-0.7932402492,
0.1556273401,
-0.2635343671,
0.2263268232,
0.0031440076,
0.0583088286,
0.8460325003,
-0.4506340921,
0.5094662309,
0.105253838,
-0.0894356743,
0.1697454005,
-0.1183588728,
0.6433342099,
0.2782308757,
0.1699983031,
0.1792837381,
-0.2656811774,
-0.6821455956,
-1.0725539923,
0.2937625945,
-0.8405473232,
-0.7281264663,
-0.2501076758,
-0.690094769,
-0.3794252872,
-0.0540311038,
0.5986625552,
0.3539091647,
0.1088554785,
0.6262910366,
0.6482351422,
-0.0278832596,
0.7986267805,
0.1598999202,
-0.0736964047,
-0.3609777093,
0.9427806735,
0.2852517962,
0.4108072221,
0.4568865299,
0.4309810698,
-0.4861610532,
-0.3918684721,
-0.5024111867,
-0.1016844437,
-0.5601507425,
0.1284534931,
-0.5259758234,
-0.3864103258,
-0.2944443822,
-0.2355357111,
-0.4361256361,
-0.7862941027,
0.134479329,
-0.3465993106,
0.325886935,
0.9825260043,
-0.2378317416,
0.5583318472,
-0.8284854293,
0.4063892663,
0.7385575771,
0.5499952435,
-0.1811147332,
-0.7591378689,
-0.2035448849,
-0.0129758874,
-0.2726447284,
-0.6011176705,
0.0762869865,
0.32102561,
0.1226866171,
0.6480967402,
-0.2688265741,
0.5284226537,
-0.7223782539,
0.9005063772,
0.3017434776,
-0.6559137106,
0.2273773104,
-0.3050055206,
0.3733842671,
0.2807811499,
0.4225786924,
-0.4842236638,
-0.1257556081,
-0.7976002693,
-0.8555210233,
0.3727571964,
0.5226200223,
0.7550737262,
-0.1310165673,
0.1625353098,
0.2545741796,
-0.1233033314,
-0.3837149739,
-0.6180769801,
-0.4645825326,
-0.0811096951,
-0.2656604946,
-0.4711217582,
0.0457455069,
-0.2702120841,
0.2065529972,
-0.0522834472,
0.4937885404,
0.1130745113,
-0.0413716249,
0.2328800708,
0.6587130427,
0.7838586569,
0.7105999589,
-0.1596572995,
0.2040362805,
0.3803285658,
-0.6323523521,
0.5732331872,
0.1573779285,
0.084150359,
0.3325045705,
0.3910181522,
0.6288527846,
0.1719016731,
-0.326605618,
0.6451812983,
-0.2132993788,
-0.086631082,
-0.3222675323,
0.0611798055,
-0.0520651229,
-0.1984415054,
0.5854973197,
0.0568915717,
0.0650571212,
-0.2016806751,
0.4731816053,
0.0559994876,
-0.5656030178,
-0.6921867132,
0.503339529,
0.0495064668,
-0.5362237096,
0.7585092783,
-0.1461200565,
-0.2829861641,
0.8560775518,
0.5942675471,
0.6233552098,
-0.2680356503,
0.0581969582,
0.2915818095,
0.4886784852,
-0.3816013038,
0.0915491581,
0.1747655421,
-0.6055614352,
-0.5198554993,
-0.5065538287,
-0.2515444458,
-0.030505253,
-0.7446430326,
0.3269857466,
-0.3977186084,
-0.3610064089,
-0.178404808,
-0.4278719127,
-0.8817176819,
0.195823893,
-0.0943707898,
0.9259434342,
-0.9502102137,
0.5095174909,
0.3968933225,
-0.1012499407,
-0.7581233382,
-0.1253647357,
-0.5266645551,
-0.6682154536,
0.6090387702,
0.5288053751,
0.1877859384,
-0.1548387855,
-0.3976178467,
-0.9823563695,
0.9348134398,
0.2468182147,
-0.5274367332,
-0.3263662159,
0.9105136991,
0.7765062451,
-0.1579556316,
0.3658074141,
0.6402999163,
0.4133117497,
-0.0676296875,
-0.8022810817,
-0.1607055068,
-0.0458168164,
0.4410838783,
0.3110693991,
-0.705409348,
0.8477717638,
-0.2519498169,
-0.0959962383,
-0.0233350582,
0.8794899583,
-0.2208127081,
-0.1629688442,
0.5539035201,
0.8114853501,
0.4162906706,
-0.1791795194,
1.1261893511,
-0.1708911657,
0.5008270144,
1.0841542482,
0.1230081469,
0.5479153395,
0.2392763048,
-0.5884795189,
0.7618331313,
0.3114071786,
-0.3686729968,
0.2062477469,
0.2725889683,
-0.1065721512,
-0.083535634,
0.1695893109,
-0.5208028555,
0.5473710895,
0.4988712668,
-0.6629875302,
-0.0931097493,
-0.0275471751,
-0.0845892057,
-0.004275593,
0.0099427113,
0.5274561048,
0.0191906039,
-0.4637022913,
0.4142179191,
0.0932944864,
0.765293479,
-0.6035116911,
-0.0790395215,
-0.0703762174,
0.0691884533,
-0.1261577457,
-0.9783488512,
0.5613598824,
-0.2458411455,
-0.3964006901,
-0.0041741966,
0.4142010808,
-0.0518733747,
-0.6454688907,
0.1287156343,
-0.0041116476,
-0.0008582454,
-0.0294347797,
-0.114442423,
-0.2280526757,
-0.2718880773,
-0.2176328301,
0.161853835,
0.1773364395,
-0.2401123941,
0.6422998905,
0.7080984712,
-0.3204341829,
0.3534947634,
-0.0338599198,
0.635409832,
-0.6407788992,
-0.2689014673,
-1.0975193977,
0.5010844469,
-0.0662159175,
-0.3280792236,
0.5124278665,
0.6049833894,
0.8662571311,
-0.3032348752,
0.7730625868,
-0.1329401881,
-0.06596791,
-0.0416335687,
0.2864514291,
0.0159531683,
0.0071172514,
0.150878042,
-1.233963728,
-0.3207055926,
0.230141893,
-0.3366854489,
0.0867482051,
0.7652538419,
0.4198285043,
-0.1051793545,
-0.1070682257,
0.5115659833,
0.0039521591,
0.3977728188,
0.6236477494,
0.6988341212,
-0.706179738,
0.8982582092,
-0.582883358,
-0.2877000272,
0.0341186896,
-0.5675799251,
-0.9100568891,
-0.4242846966,
0.2340545207,
-0.1717751175,
-0.1926402599,
0.535138011,
0.6779341698,
-0.7875419259,
0.0576858632,
-0.0665118098,
0.0362636074,
-0.2316413522,
-0.3027040362,
0.3384304643,
-0.0372703299,
-0.8350145817,
0.3724811077,
0.2580066025,
0.4475716352,
-0.2529388964,
0.102451697,
0.2301762402,
0.1208863184,
0.4502096176,
0.369774282,
-0.529586792,
-0.7929335833,
0.2496679723,
0.1261955351,
0.2559596002,
0.7647174597,
-0.4776737094,
0.3634891808,
0.5909637809,
0.574015677,
0.2134566307,
0.2642790079,
0.8007038236,
-1.0528976917,
0.1108344197,
0.0769031495,
0.3693349361,
0.3133614063,
-0.4465381801,
0.4542571306,
0.0965300202,
-0.4975141585,
-0.4047006965,
0.6588416696,
-0.7438884974,
0.1495041251,
1.13218081,
-0.0937747955,
0.1609470099,
0.0293105841,
0.0764218643,
0.1442550868,
-0.2621656358,
0.9101418257,
0.7311831117,
-0.1628495455,
0.1813066751,
-0.030463608,
0.3829938769,
0.2384428829,
-0.4296509326,
-0.2867595553,
-0.301259011,
0.4167861938,
0.670625627,
0.0923178717,
0.0012051289,
0.2971389592,
0.0722002387,
-0.405182451,
0.0674473494,
-0.3421844542,
-0.5274723768,
0.0722760186,
0.1558293253,
-0.0199485794
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09369v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09369v1
|
Massively Multi-Cultural Knowledge Acquisition & LM Benchmarking
| 2024-02-14T18:16:54 | 2024-02-14T18:16:54 |
Yi Fung, Ruining Zhao, Jae Doo, Chenkai Sun, Heng Ji
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Pretrained large language models have revolutionized many applications but
still face challenges related to cultural bias and a lack of cultural
commonsense knowledge crucial for guiding cross-culture communication and
interactions. Recognizing the shortcomings of existing methods in capturing the
diverse and rich cultures across the world, this paper introduces a novel
approach for massively multicultural knowledge acquisition. Specifically, our
method strategically navigates from densely informative Wikipedia documents on
cultural topics to an extensive network of linked pages. Leveraging this
valuable source of data collection, we construct the CultureAtlas dataset,
which covers a wide range of sub-country level geographical regions and
ethnolinguistic groups, with data cleaning and preprocessing to ensure textual
assertion sentence self-containment, as well as fine-grained cultural profile
information extraction. Our dataset not only facilitates the evaluation of
language model performance in culturally diverse contexts but also serves as a
foundational tool for the development of culturally sensitive and aware
language models. Our work marks an important step towards deeper understanding
and bridging the gaps of cultural disparities in AI, to promote a more
inclusive and balanced representation of global cultures in the digital domain.
|
[
-0.6563076377,
-0.6089430451,
0.1303461045,
0.1218028441,
-0.0279429518,
0.354684025,
-0.636497736,
-0.6362543702,
0.2117885053,
0.145052731,
-0.5106368065,
-0.5049619675,
-0.6308622956,
-0.0011593606,
-0.0390419737,
0.9628345966,
0.0822404772,
0.0305923633,
-0.0315697044,
-0.4691266418,
-0.1267678142,
-0.2541729808,
-0.1514887512,
-0.2047685236,
0.4740192294,
0.5609181523,
0.4504887164,
0.5962669849,
0.3138424456,
0.24424164,
-0.0984946117,
0.4870766103,
-0.7310028076,
0.1321505308,
-0.3393442929,
-0.2398796082,
-0.1596426517,
0.1292028129,
0.6592966318,
0.6708886623,
-0.0212967433,
0.6580067277,
-0.1506914943,
0.3850557208,
-0.7378861308,
0.204470098,
-0.5867868662,
0.1750092804,
-0.3400887251,
0.1009832174,
-0.2037179768,
-0.352794528,
0.1305126846,
-0.6899347901,
-0.1519456506,
-0.0973002911,
0.5065775514,
0.1006230116,
-0.815731287,
-0.2186109275,
-0.8965148926,
0.8157685995,
-0.1341453344,
0.5476819873,
0.3958857358,
0.5330082774,
0.2063523233,
-0.6434041858,
-0.6658520699,
-0.1229894236,
0.1682527512,
0.1525596082,
0.0589927323,
-0.5935437679,
0.3599646688,
0.4432453215,
-0.4583779871,
0.226383239,
-0.6379295588,
-0.2927365005,
0.6835289598,
0.0259505045,
0.3680758178,
-0.0982716233,
-0.2463503927,
-0.2207285762,
-0.7408747673,
0.0005958109,
0.2847170532,
0.3759065866,
-0.3914875388,
0.3420750201,
-0.4851263463,
0.4504141212,
-0.2996396422,
-0.3434251547,
0.5232666135,
-0.443316102,
0.1556046456,
-0.1335771233,
0.654032588,
0.258155942,
0.7234392166,
-0.1259979159,
0.1451427191,
-0.0471462496,
-0.0388633311,
-0.8585163355,
-0.0809731334,
0.1430031955,
-0.3907658458,
0.0100086303,
-0.013950252,
-0.8779039979,
-0.5639201403,
-0.3750151396,
-0.0072648544,
-0.2794834673,
-0.5295639634,
-0.1794805825,
-0.036717508,
0.1596710235,
0.2369950265,
-0.8418973684,
-0.2583182752,
0.5662545562,
0.6675773263,
-0.0684386939,
-0.448581785,
-0.190702945,
0.3944948614,
-0.2510797381,
0.3458435237,
-0.6423571706,
-0.2510246038,
0.2167366594,
-0.1246055216,
0.2214859426,
-0.5805155635,
0.4895150363,
-0.6769047976,
0.1380754411,
-0.4351694286,
-0.2986656725,
-0.2626349628,
0.5829442143,
-0.7146290541,
0.9628450871,
-0.0717170537,
-0.6389110088,
0.5757455826,
-0.554060936,
-0.4582001269,
0.1245658845,
-0.2736996412,
0.1529516429,
-0.0225696228,
0.4002341926,
0.515426755,
-0.3389374614,
0.2661425173,
-0.3666132092,
-0.1760851592,
-0.1585840136,
-0.2988443375,
0.9334948659,
0.5368990302,
-0.2864001989,
-0.0318076834,
-0.8520073295,
-0.100668259,
0.2110828012,
-0.336423099,
-0.5700103641,
-0.2805838287,
0.1455416083,
0.6531402469,
0.5096549392,
-0.4917937517,
0.2436364144,
0.1482847035,
0.3030903935,
0.6279308796,
-0.4719177783,
0.3781050444,
-0.2070886791,
0.4186392426,
0.2392793596,
0.181613043,
-0.306709528,
-0.0862445757,
-0.37424016,
-0.4192514718,
0.1055080146,
0.645565331,
-0.9087082744,
0.3368277848,
-0.5812226534,
-0.880243063,
-0.4624556303,
0.5233004093,
0.218178004,
0.4430464804,
0.3757725358,
-0.1035342738,
-0.2979906797,
-0.7251529694,
-0.1161167249,
-0.1320954561,
-0.0843130052,
0.2982343435,
0.3690542579,
-0.4079130888,
0.6632094979,
-0.2580325305,
-0.3641515374,
-0.3598785102,
0.1635506004,
0.0987565964,
0.4962990284,
0.384856075,
-0.9115192294,
-0.551407814,
0.1811679006,
-1.1180841923,
0.0648151115,
0.1803093553,
-0.3678875268,
0.0302864257,
0.6935996413,
-0.4995470941,
-0.0575472265,
0.6976935267,
-0.0648381487,
0.3068348467,
-0.0819180161,
0.1669188738,
-1.3335174322,
0.3295635879,
0.0997366309,
0.0467263013,
-0.5412900448,
0.3300917447,
0.2307914495,
0.0145582771,
-0.4247566462,
0.6198164225,
-0.4787546694,
0.107085079,
0.0889290795,
0.1716800481,
-0.0858009905,
0.3585314751,
0.0554666296,
0.5787920356,
0.3989498019,
-0.2592028677,
0.3982917964,
0.2500879467,
-0.615391016,
0.7322442532,
-0.2954376042,
-0.0288702641,
-0.274445802,
0.5977013707,
-0.7171679735,
-0.2107580304,
-0.0069339848,
-0.0863007307,
0.1088765264,
-0.0525156371,
-0.5459481478,
-0.3409988284,
-0.0675233454,
0.9065330029,
0.4431609809,
-0.6289286017,
0.6713519096,
0.5773067474,
-0.2255859226,
-0.9040188789,
-0.3689674139,
0.0465443619,
-0.4912742972,
-0.6911510229,
0.0107602952,
-0.0990711972,
-0.3474363685,
-0.4706476331,
0.1123691946,
-0.0674958527,
0.2129223049,
0.0219275206,
0.1111396998,
-0.2690549195,
0.3233370185,
-0.2355169505,
0.092675209,
-0.0323913805,
-0.5224125981,
0.6181765199,
-0.0603254549,
-0.3939971328,
-0.2600380182,
0.3736837804,
0.8388723135,
-0.6635071039,
0.7258470654,
0.9308642149,
-0.4025213122,
-0.1986490041,
-0.8196278214,
-0.0993576199,
-0.3940038681,
0.5762768984,
-0.3861940801,
-0.8902007937,
0.7572687864,
-0.3448890448,
0.1453476548,
0.4314678609,
0.4214450717,
-0.0420425311,
0.6525091529,
0.7516379356,
-0.4688144624,
0.2953481674,
-0.2494168729,
0.0838754401,
-0.4311153889,
-0.3396988511,
-0.5234889984,
-0.3329220712,
-0.7205244303,
-0.6342519522,
0.3557468653,
-0.0594366752,
-0.4176956713,
-0.0376109816,
0.0081059327,
0.653211832,
0.5799346566,
-0.0506691858,
0.4535355866,
0.202987805,
-0.2117288858,
-0.2155558169,
-0.607324779,
-0.3209396601,
1.0565017462,
0.3047053814,
0.5841080546,
0.3320897222,
0.4839061201,
0.3537354469,
0.4351994395,
-0.4777575731,
0.2548218071,
-0.2989524305,
-0.795113802,
-0.4008415639,
-0.578826189,
-0.6008594036,
0.2706682682,
-0.0699534267,
-0.7163882256,
0.0612159893,
-0.0035024323,
-0.1988010257,
0.2608804405,
-0.5861105323,
0.9836453795,
-0.3171281815,
-0.5105861425,
-0.3631083071,
-0.7648978829,
0.5450385809,
-0.4677061439,
0.4562545717,
-0.2830533385,
0.1706909835,
0.5444211364,
0.2868896425,
0.7153490186,
-0.162156716,
-0.2835024297,
-0.0064010657,
0.1942146271,
0.2554748952,
-0.0800220221,
-0.2326346785,
0.6465064287,
-0.0239936616,
-0.6253387332,
-0.3349087536,
0.526606977,
-1.0337291956,
-0.2493022382,
-0.1692987382,
-0.8613220453,
-0.4744902551,
0.1964925975,
-0.0547164753,
0.3153646886,
-0.2957620323,
0.2625311315,
0.5444975495,
-0.4231956899,
0.2708995342,
0.7197324038,
-0.0926506594,
-0.1578518748,
1.0330808163,
0.1225276664,
0.2158931941,
0.404363662,
-0.0254607536,
-0.361166805,
-0.3180999756,
-0.480240345,
0.1899965703,
-0.9563344121,
0.1407462507,
-0.6411446333,
-0.0282500573,
-0.3637978137,
0.017272329,
-0.2676589191,
-0.1933746338,
0.2999630272,
-0.1437277645,
0.1368347704,
0.7304745913,
-0.2928754985,
0.2380065024,
-0.9177395105,
0.2777836323,
0.1700326353,
0.2217271775,
0.0794298723,
-0.3389365971,
-0.5343261957,
0.0398462974,
0.0222208835,
-0.4261388481,
0.2565516233,
0.215581432,
0.8568306565,
0.5508984327,
0.1203143299,
0.7119634748,
-0.3578501344,
0.6348444819,
-0.0590784699,
-0.7210190296,
0.4751251042,
-0.4896404743,
0.6363717914,
0.7726341486,
0.9545598626,
-0.9572094679,
-0.2670456171,
-0.4596526921,
-0.8980942369,
0.5123417974,
-0.3714327514,
0.2849207819,
0.0577839874,
-0.0668522716,
0.2533585727,
0.1398153454,
-0.6782556772,
0.0117917061,
-0.1123162284,
-0.3134337664,
-0.4266759157,
-0.1895147115,
-0.4498103559,
-0.2586387396,
0.6600262523,
-0.4083915949,
-0.3851575851,
-0.1947384626,
-0.6872164011,
0.1172524542,
-0.0491276719,
0.5051589012,
0.9596502781,
-0.1233905181,
0.1195937693,
0.1571976542,
-0.5434841514,
0.0212016571,
0.1881415397,
-0.0586571731,
-0.3901504278,
0.3639810085,
0.3494108915,
-0.2088023573,
-0.8126900792,
0.2893943191,
-0.1964410394,
0.2141056508,
-0.3665200174,
-0.2223170847,
0.0945289209,
0.4053791463,
0.5393323898,
-0.3944683969,
-0.2699636519,
-0.5692420602,
0.3873318136,
0.3631560504,
-0.2072325796,
-0.1306075752,
0.5019087195,
0.4168652892,
0.1886214763,
0.8793874979,
0.0602078736,
-0.4509343505,
0.518522799,
0.1645798385,
0.4470507205,
-0.2120745778,
0.3734643459,
0.5251695514,
0.3272671402,
0.0818948448,
0.0783013254,
-0.3699987233,
-0.976359725,
-0.4503369033,
-0.7111579776,
-0.3105090857,
0.0343849547,
-0.4983665049,
0.0758149549,
-0.3973792493,
0.2535679936,
-0.1062334776,
0.1383173168,
-0.8114317656,
0.4306529462,
0.4559472799,
1.1077638865,
-1.2167407274,
0.8610078096,
0.4937061369,
-0.4913726151,
-0.6716160178,
0.1771809012,
0.1644441187,
-1.0528432131,
0.8316084146,
0.2760248482,
0.1640184671,
-0.1381422579,
-0.2044340372,
-0.8391495347,
0.9076317549,
0.2609163225,
-0.3286919594,
0.229749918,
0.2883121967,
0.6106638312,
-0.3620477915,
0.4992358088,
0.5444597602,
0.4520992935,
0.1686736643,
-0.8637734652,
0.0256842393,
-0.452308774,
-0.272025466,
-0.1229093745,
-0.8640127182,
0.8157812357,
0.0557228141,
0.0897747204,
-0.1530417204,
0.7038215995,
0.2905658185,
0.1312857866,
0.5298762321,
0.4180009365,
1.0289191008,
-0.0927378163,
0.8723832369,
-0.6275411844,
0.0484527647,
0.987119019,
-0.439232558,
0.7515947223,
0.3039534688,
0.077888079,
0.3747167885,
0.6616316438,
0.0046177967,
0.2184353173,
0.2852179706,
-0.3439340293,
-0.3841743767,
-0.6707026362,
-0.6002200246,
0.9754211903,
0.4598341882,
-0.1741803885,
-0.346369803,
0.0235870797,
0.1001719236,
0.0542198345,
-0.2081265599,
0.6725477576,
-0.1423150301,
-0.7953166366,
0.4144518375,
-0.2226402014,
0.8206111789,
-0.8041035533,
0.1366780996,
-0.5751698613,
0.197741583,
0.0085695758,
-0.4795853198,
0.0592414178,
-0.1129270047,
-0.3159388304,
-0.3431501985,
0.5354345441,
-0.5401229262,
-0.5122193098,
0.4927257895,
0.9815237522,
0.1325323433,
0.1042778119,
-0.3096499145,
0.1872594655,
-0.0948796049,
0.0591772273,
0.2760691047,
0.6121405959,
-0.362742871,
0.5672152042,
0.6536813974,
0.047268495,
0.0509215258,
0.2277880907,
0.4751327634,
-0.4812805057,
-0.6132689118,
-0.6867954135,
0.4940884411,
-0.4227509499,
-0.3650554717,
0.8725214601,
0.4996195734,
1.3288557529,
0.0890098736,
0.9916456342,
-0.1341038495,
0.3092021346,
-0.1240492389,
0.9516573548,
-0.732175529,
-0.0156310685,
-0.1905682087,
-0.9339917898,
-0.1739180535,
0.3243182003,
-0.3232902884,
0.1773111224,
0.2757996619,
0.6881913543,
-0.3046986759,
0.171694994,
0.3240200877,
0.2697219849,
0.3087903559,
0.4134024382,
1.0741519928,
0.0136888092,
0.5426619053,
-0.3413844109,
-0.2685426474,
0.01688773,
-0.882129252,
-0.677752018,
-0.5533294082,
-0.164922744,
-0.180741027,
0.0313835703,
0.9731957912,
0.9189432263,
-0.816206038,
-0.3756521344,
0.5898502469,
0.1214806661,
-0.070272699,
-0.130424425,
0.1683442444,
-0.0555672757,
-0.8640646935,
0.30010432,
-0.0361113623,
-0.0920265466,
-0.4944861531,
-0.0069942391,
-0.2484959215,
-0.176400736,
0.5768384933,
0.4730586112,
-0.397339046,
-0.029322695,
-0.188956365,
-0.1824652404,
-0.2089020014,
0.656776607,
-0.5653614402,
0.4207373559,
0.4895065427,
0.8886232972,
0.4055636823,
-0.1511573792,
0.5780996084,
-0.9568067789,
0.5221965313,
-0.0044970913,
0.2348478436,
0.5296698213,
-0.1024209484,
0.4299440384,
0.2366394699,
-0.2979211211,
-0.6575065255,
0.199157089,
-0.7746532559,
-0.3211993277,
1.1083273888,
-0.3360186815,
0.0422389992,
-0.1079520807,
0.0993755758,
0.3466342688,
-0.1147541702,
1.148075223,
0.7340561748,
0.5685489774,
0.0317341723,
-0.6523269415,
0.2073118091,
0.5008170009,
-0.7792910337,
0.0436107367,
0.7725220323,
0.2230096757,
0.4157375097,
0.3556293547,
0.0946743488,
0.181638062,
-0.1735117435,
0.0708848983,
-0.0470365174,
-0.5284966826,
-0.1526076347,
0.464348942,
-0.2300461829,
0.0525081567
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09363v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09363v2
|
Copyright Traps for Large Language Models
| 2024-02-14T18:09:53 | 2024-06-04T21:07:11 |
Matthieu Meeus, Igor Shilov, Manuel Faysse, Yves-Alexandre de Montjoye
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Questions of fair use of copyright-protected content to train Large Language
Models (LLMs) are being actively debated. Document-level inference has been
proposed as a new task: inferring from black-box access to the trained model
whether a piece of content has been seen during training. SOTA methods however
rely on naturally occurring memorization of (part of) the content. While very
effective against models that memorize significantly, we hypothesize--and later
confirm--that they will not work against models that do not naturally memorize,
e.g. medium-size 1B models. We here propose to use copyright traps, the
inclusion of fictitious entries in original content, to detect the use of
copyrighted materials in LLMs with a focus on models where memorization does
not naturally occur. We carefully design a randomized controlled experimental
setup, inserting traps into original content (books) and train a 1.3B LLM from
scratch. We first validate that the use of content in our target model would be
undetectable using existing methods. We then show, contrary to intuition, that
even medium-length trap sentences repeated a significant number of times (100)
are not detectable using existing methods. However, we show that longer
sequences repeated a large number of times can be reliably detected (AUC=0.75)
and used as copyright traps. Beyond copyright applications, our findings
contribute to the study of LLM memorization: the randomized controlled setup
enables us to draw causal relationships between memorization and certain
sequence properties such as repetition in model training data and perplexity.
|
[
-0.1524998695,
-0.5109146833,
0.4357579052,
0.1142870858,
-0.4620268941,
-0.1505151838,
-0.2445425987,
-0.2512699962,
0.0037176036,
0.7747769356,
-0.32017079,
-0.4035198092,
-0.7083755732,
0.2751002312,
-0.6739479899,
0.8453930616,
0.0034450253,
0.2721953094,
-0.1995907128,
-0.1336301863,
-0.5071024299,
-0.7440071106,
-0.5824482441,
-0.2302920669,
0.471235007,
0.1086120605,
0.2619416118,
0.7214750051,
0.1466377825,
0.1432282031,
-0.3432229459,
-0.0811934173,
-0.6486468315,
-0.0064537814,
-0.2812292278,
-0.8853371143,
-0.0621256158,
0.1457881778,
0.9133880138,
0.11387299,
-0.2062911093,
0.1709697843,
0.0401882604,
0.5306634903,
-0.6849737763,
-0.0004897981,
-0.7370632887,
0.2437373698,
-0.3703754544,
-0.4274716675,
-0.789470911,
-0.2397945374,
-0.1846664548,
-0.5684446692,
0.4112014174,
0.1592606902,
0.8832713366,
0.1901373714,
-0.1730970591,
-0.604341805,
-0.6377919912,
0.957036078,
-1.0073629618,
0.2878795862,
0.5018758178,
0.1643065214,
-0.2897999585,
-0.5753408074,
-0.9084460139,
-0.4038824737,
0.1312377006,
0.0098338062,
-0.2361952066,
-0.2104993016,
0.839388907,
0.2741031051,
-0.5322332382,
0.2424699515,
-0.3232809305,
-0.3735467196,
0.6238589287,
0.0224007387,
0.3633979261,
-0.2489322424,
-0.5184230208,
-0.0035949659,
-1.1192407608,
-0.0673544034,
0.7217538953,
0.1251943558,
0.0724866614,
0.762421906,
0.5258134604,
0.351254791,
-0.020374788,
-0.2631136179,
-0.0003836629,
0.0701942965,
-0.2164381146,
0.1466254443,
0.6357555389,
0.0386220068,
0.7299173474,
-0.1492480338,
-0.4579221606,
-0.087152563,
0.0175252315,
-0.6702038646,
-0.0429226719,
-0.0210212637,
-0.3621633351,
0.0306349788,
-0.0080700014,
-0.4396518171,
-0.5720694661,
-0.3429149389,
0.6607365012,
-0.3780075908,
-0.1217019483,
0.4132441878,
-0.4201088846,
0.1505632252,
0.0874362737,
-0.7370874286,
0.240124166,
0.6444407701,
0.7708933949,
-0.1133232266,
-0.4416102767,
-0.6517692208,
0.3997951746,
-0.2750652432,
0.6036896706,
-0.3399848938,
-0.3749304414,
0.0582255684,
0.2523141205,
0.0165745765,
-0.7830855846,
0.1919633597,
-0.9280436039,
0.1141412407,
-0.2221117616,
-0.9740187526,
-0.0425346456,
0.138696149,
-1.0774515867,
0.6361375451,
-0.1047185883,
-0.9436725378,
0.3656561077,
-0.0378495194,
-0.4136402309,
-0.2753674984,
-0.3376094401,
-0.6624923944,
0.1333139837,
-0.1511286646,
0.3133293986,
-0.1533074826,
0.3181093335,
-0.1863381416,
-0.5938630104,
0.4900632203,
-0.4276846647,
0.9825758338,
0.2073242068,
-0.4319780767,
-0.352964431,
-0.4178738594,
-0.5486594439,
0.4180434644,
-0.7209247947,
-0.5195485353,
-0.1027440354,
-0.1698338389,
0.0382073447,
0.0876526386,
-0.575864315,
0.2495686561,
-0.1116683483,
0.1777588874,
0.7697132826,
0.0780664086,
0.5014221072,
-0.5013939142,
0.7855533361,
0.0906982422,
-0.1362320483,
-0.2357594222,
-0.3596093655,
-0.51440835,
-0.4842338264,
0.5567292571,
0.4430254102,
-0.5762290955,
0.2242743671,
-0.2514443398,
0.0134277204,
-0.3424703479,
0.3338527381,
0.554771781,
0.0951531753,
0.052895572,
-0.5394465327,
-0.4459897876,
-0.6794751883,
-0.5829600096,
0.3266236484,
-0.2540556192,
0.3896039724,
0.6035529971,
0.1871198267,
0.9183294177,
-0.3394081891,
-0.4950734377,
-0.1711983085,
0.2546216846,
0.1703625321,
0.4670715332,
0.519602716,
-0.7795857787,
-0.426320076,
-0.4098762572,
-0.7223505974,
-0.1590034366,
-0.3424232006,
0.167936787,
0.43426916,
0.6990615726,
-0.627111733,
0.5568047166,
0.3472162187,
-0.2055366337,
0.5899916291,
-0.212361142,
-0.1187662855,
-0.8062381148,
0.222955659,
-0.1547933817,
-0.1363021135,
-0.2992204726,
0.0454602502,
0.2241113782,
-0.0504976846,
-0.4657220542,
0.7211270928,
-0.5875738859,
-0.1611391306,
-0.31229195,
0.1054646745,
0.0757033601,
0.4713638723,
0.1691575348,
0.7992119193,
0.287638694,
-0.4861154854,
-0.1002616063,
0.1971044391,
-0.6646527648,
0.4931958616,
-0.3836794794,
0.2940591276,
-0.4395038486,
0.3666423857,
-0.5939885378,
0.0075234249,
0.1123895943,
-0.4970955253,
0.5763533711,
-0.4990386963,
-0.8168532252,
-0.0732399076,
-0.3222046494,
0.1706200242,
0.5844156146,
-0.4582135975,
0.5266500711,
0.3646785319,
0.0989490673,
-0.8959165812,
-0.9112062454,
-0.0507893451,
-0.3576826453,
-0.3694385886,
0.0048924014,
-0.1677687168,
-0.0581322685,
0.0032271929,
-0.4918551147,
-0.0938059837,
0.1658942401,
0.300057292,
0.0325058401,
-0.198050797,
0.0679550543,
-0.035914652,
0.035282284,
0.1008175611,
-0.4941271245,
0.5808779001,
0.3694504499,
-0.3593522608,
-0.2163464874,
0.2688207328,
0.3853828609,
-0.215249449,
0.7807789445,
0.2672275901,
-0.5859285593,
-0.6458308101,
-0.6988621354,
-0.1398271024,
-0.454313904,
0.0550103895,
-0.1843555421,
-1.1080949306,
0.7276856899,
0.2085349411,
-0.0252346918,
0.0863345861,
0.4189922214,
-0.0975134075,
0.6057613492,
0.495105505,
-0.0448736921,
0.6040323377,
-0.5816092491,
0.2337838709,
-0.7697315812,
-0.2193285674,
-0.5015839934,
-0.3256312907,
-0.3075914383,
-0.4660691023,
0.0823305994,
0.2743830383,
-0.2049221694,
0.4841456711,
-0.0829340219,
0.8715462685,
0.7006546259,
0.1388498694,
0.6510492563,
0.101136975,
-0.0993197858,
-0.022324048,
-0.6228764653,
-0.5763364434,
1.2268990278,
0.3531864583,
0.9630476236,
0.0829482004,
0.9117250443,
0.4471191168,
0.4797486961,
-0.8449243307,
0.5506371856,
-0.3042808473,
-1.2330647707,
-0.2880123854,
-0.4874154031,
-1.0377054214,
-0.1309053004,
-0.0343486667,
-0.6560406089,
0.1721997708,
0.3037024438,
-0.2469955981,
0.5676906109,
-0.5836501122,
0.8326921463,
-0.1007791832,
-0.5635271668,
-0.1926005632,
-0.4398223162,
0.4931972027,
-0.427503556,
0.2822826505,
-0.04401391,
0.1433952302,
0.9387965202,
-0.1272653043,
0.9089512825,
-0.2027719915,
-0.2549380958,
0.5524977446,
0.4816065133,
0.5439459682,
0.0297354292,
-0.0701450631,
0.045940455,
0.0928615555,
-0.3823056221,
-0.4037689865,
0.6524729133,
-0.4901810288,
-0.5803080797,
-0.4975633621,
-0.4966463149,
0.2226322293,
0.4892268777,
0.3953287005,
0.2929500937,
0.0015697691,
0.2368754447,
0.8721047044,
-0.3662822545,
0.2325517833,
0.901048243,
0.1199989766,
-0.1299048811,
0.9167163372,
0.2780591846,
0.3397623301,
0.388876617,
0.3654037416,
-0.3054026663,
-0.9253998995,
-0.1970466524,
0.359061867,
-0.8983541727,
-0.1681498587,
-0.5396055579,
-0.2108196467,
-0.2524008453,
-0.0171852447,
-0.1781201661,
-0.2519500852,
-0.3133773208,
0.0604923107,
0.1561511606,
0.7077786326,
-0.1451368034,
0.3124615252,
-0.9017578363,
0.4283895493,
0.2921696603,
0.5225495696,
0.1428044438,
-0.9048190117,
-0.2683679461,
-0.118038848,
-0.20690687,
-0.8090432882,
0.4043627083,
-0.0518031754,
0.6175585389,
0.2855389118,
0.0616372563,
0.1990785301,
-0.6229054928,
0.6073194742,
-0.0367648713,
-0.9640017748,
0.1747668684,
-0.377789259,
-0.1275926977,
0.376912415,
0.5328605175,
-0.2701366544,
-0.4682792723,
-0.7792236209,
-0.465449065,
0.6866265535,
0.0968119577,
0.3024261296,
-0.0812011212,
0.3684650362,
0.123257488,
0.4711976945,
-1.1311522722,
0.0935894772,
0.1100841612,
-0.2088157535,
-0.059307009,
-0.3207253814,
-0.0473970845,
0.1383469403,
0.4523410201,
0.1345729083,
0.0199279524,
0.1145071164,
-0.4763970673,
-0.1271491349,
0.1525961161,
0.3044848144,
0.5384927392,
-0.3413427174,
0.3293445706,
0.0590262376,
-0.6713282466,
0.1890609413,
-0.059627533,
-0.3524229228,
-0.001432157,
0.3489970565,
0.2906820178,
0.18900612,
-0.9431666732,
0.8064039946,
0.0834981427,
-0.0869018734,
-0.5916048288,
0.0478011295,
0.2756740451,
0.2896656096,
-0.0496910326,
-0.2021213174,
0.0767776966,
-0.5329787135,
0.3788810372,
0.4387081563,
-0.1185205951,
-0.1931286752,
0.6610168815,
-0.2011570632,
-0.4527020156,
0.5274384022,
-0.3501783311,
-0.577950716,
0.8644880056,
0.7154824734,
0.7189036012,
-0.22882846,
-0.1676647514,
0.4578450322,
0.4834168553,
-0.4609612226,
0.240582794,
0.0534726046,
-0.7058473825,
-0.3342034221,
-0.5921523571,
-0.3302429318,
0.448582679,
-0.5672793984,
0.450476408,
-0.6929666996,
0.0258840341,
-0.0822887272,
-0.0498503149,
-0.5420777798,
0.0076920823,
0.4549979866,
1.1598050594,
-0.9473567009,
0.9252838492,
0.1495331228,
-0.470433414,
-0.9289395213,
0.036088407,
0.0766028538,
-0.7408105731,
0.456123054,
0.1656453013,
-0.0447033681,
0.1169597059,
-0.9834706187,
-0.427804023,
0.9540952444,
0.5771577358,
-0.6296465397,
-0.014379397,
-0.0096460562,
0.4036227763,
-0.078358151,
-0.2775672972,
0.636266768,
0.2023691982,
0.1477861702,
-0.640896678,
0.1194448695,
-0.1361847669,
-0.2495785058,
0.0912750065,
-0.3601934612,
0.9275519252,
-0.1880657226,
-0.5063089728,
0.1700434983,
0.2424031347,
0.5994425416,
0.5553926826,
0.5195183754,
0.5828566551,
0.5559298396,
0.2683634758,
1.0625306368,
0.0270208791,
0.5194612741,
1.242642045,
-0.3157603443,
0.7816576958,
0.5727636218,
0.0175851751,
0.2032482475,
0.1899158955,
-0.381357789,
0.4273268282,
0.8670387268,
-0.290597409,
-0.1606178582,
-0.0672194511,
-0.1452718079,
0.0977912843,
0.3404046595,
-0.4240222275,
0.0856389105,
-0.0957365632,
0.3008378744,
0.2099959552,
-0.0261069555,
0.6453951597,
0.506270349,
-0.6335126162,
0.5864353776,
-0.0233087409,
0.6975397468,
-0.7232840061,
0.1005431935,
-0.4585089087,
0.2037507743,
-0.1082581282,
-0.7406440377,
0.1392942518,
0.3703533113,
-0.0458261445,
-0.1345844865,
0.5285852551,
-0.4927002192,
-0.1178201139,
0.3104021251,
0.1881726384,
0.2091814727,
-0.1447125971,
-0.2634557486,
0.0889571831,
-0.1434726864,
-0.3943074048,
0.4014486372,
0.5143498778,
-0.1935588866,
0.6232050657,
0.6723282337,
0.185979709,
0.2432091832,
0.0342050679,
0.7800537348,
-0.7027613521,
-0.5613541007,
-0.8334823251,
0.2795746028,
-0.0165652782,
0.023084417,
0.8086593747,
0.7986926436,
1.1412395239,
-0.4050489366,
0.9184804559,
0.124286823,
0.3041594625,
-0.9139878154,
0.8486815095,
-0.7097389698,
0.5144326687,
-0.1464668363,
-0.8319271207,
-0.3225688636,
0.559281826,
-0.2312798649,
-0.151483193,
0.8049992919,
0.9143610001,
-0.4111359417,
-0.010755606,
0.1743302345,
0.1725173891,
0.4418669939,
0.6979608536,
1.2025756836,
-0.1796823144,
0.6653385758,
-0.1605121195,
-0.1562903523,
-0.2480963171,
-1.1708517075,
-1.1491396427,
-0.3258227408,
-0.0840630457,
-0.5588483214,
-0.0553314649,
0.8523181081,
0.4269192219,
-0.9112148285,
-0.314173907,
0.0812282264,
0.264598757,
-0.0111721661,
-0.1139446422,
0.392558217,
0.1328767091,
-0.6540867686,
0.1341277957,
0.0395106152,
0.4047323167,
-0.1936429739,
-0.0772754624,
-0.1643488109,
0.3615909517,
0.1622052938,
0.5651119351,
-0.6142294407,
-0.1290694177,
0.1324760169,
-0.235209614,
-0.0622328222,
1.2217880487,
-0.3905446827,
0.4951949716,
0.5442060232,
0.5650695562,
0.7522455454,
-0.2487121671,
0.4617545903,
-0.8740502596,
0.3314672112,
0.5079847574,
0.4114329219,
0.2828649282,
-0.2453915775,
0.2807180285,
0.3382902145,
-0.379000783,
-0.9631091356,
0.2545822263,
-0.9160458446,
-0.3822054863,
1.1833175421,
-0.5823855996,
-0.2426299304,
-0.0311887152,
-0.13190566,
0.4225431383,
-0.1017790437,
0.9432498217,
0.7810814977,
0.4699843228,
0.1134655997,
-0.9173233509,
0.5454986095,
0.3442038298,
-0.5266119838,
0.1600222737,
0.4408347905,
0.6330426335,
0.1030675247,
0.7101842165,
-0.3179751039,
0.2807758451,
-0.0474125631,
0.0811955333,
-0.2215569317,
-0.4671801925,
-0.6210842133,
-0.1178005263,
0.1865147203,
-0.0310798269
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09353v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09353v5
|
DoRA: Weight-Decomposed Low-Rank Adaptation
| 2024-02-14T17:59:34 | 2024-06-03T07:27:15 |
Shih-Yang Liu, Chien-Yi Wang, Hongxu Yin, Pavlo Molchanov, Yu-Chiang Frank Wang, Kwang-Ting Cheng, Min-Hung Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Among the widely used parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) methods, LoRA
and its variants have gained considerable popularity because of avoiding
additional inference costs. However, there still often exists an accuracy gap
between these methods and full fine-tuning (FT). In this work, we first
introduce a novel weight decomposition analysis to investigate the inherent
differences between FT and LoRA. Aiming to resemble the learning capacity of FT
from the findings, we propose Weight-Decomposed Low-Rank Adaptation (DoRA).
DoRA decomposes the pre-trained weight into two components, magnitude and
direction, for fine-tuning, specifically employing LoRA for directional updates
to efficiently minimize the number of trainable parameters. By employing \ours,
we enhance both the learning capacity and training stability of LoRA while
avoiding any additional inference overhead. \ours~consistently outperforms LoRA
on fine-tuning LLaMA, LLaVA, and VL-BART on various downstream tasks, such as
commonsense reasoning, visual instruction tuning, and image/video-text
understanding. Code is available at https://github.com/NVlabs/DoRA.
|
[
-0.1790757626,
-0.7851492167,
0.3645748496,
0.2377867252,
-0.3558401465,
0.058224149,
-0.2427601963,
-0.2416793555,
0.1388358325,
0.2118119448,
-0.641716361,
-0.4249288142,
-0.7692228556,
0.0409792401,
-0.2273029983,
1.0686116219,
0.071913071,
-0.0428907461,
0.0570584238,
-0.3803934455,
-0.5259433985,
-0.1816138029,
-0.9025486112,
-0.0110511761,
0.788864553,
0.752223134,
0.3053087592,
0.3251499534,
0.3710979521,
0.2288077176,
-0.1136739478,
0.315931201,
-1.0902476311,
-0.0028552585,
-0.0677378923,
-0.5979900956,
-1.0694215298,
-0.0057142666,
0.6715438366,
0.6287879944,
-0.3231291175,
0.6799991131,
0.2383734584,
1.1788551807,
-1.0724183321,
-0.0118900379,
-0.9225800037,
-0.1164593399,
-0.0671546385,
-0.2191822976,
-0.372785002,
-0.1407721788,
-0.2625347972,
-0.8654584289,
0.1025506109,
0.0119535523,
0.8527657986,
0.7757977247,
-0.3009785414,
0.0957434699,
-0.5151231289,
1.0019471645,
-0.3510662317,
0.2200030982,
0.5746690035,
0.3923156559,
0.0859330371,
-0.429364264,
-0.1496171504,
0.3338531852,
0.5261825919,
-0.0030225134,
-0.2643462718,
-0.1818782538,
0.114571467,
0.3915582597,
-0.152786538,
0.3487590849,
-0.5329645276,
0.3148352504,
0.6278464198,
-0.2067538798,
0.0300223976,
0.0638087615,
-0.4814634919,
-0.2694731355,
-1.0611985922,
0.1354474276,
0.3611758351,
0.4893613458,
-0.3056732118,
0.3552176654,
-0.3246046603,
0.622571826,
0.4994906783,
-0.2465833426,
0.2408710867,
-0.0014960858,
-0.5513156056,
0.3313863277,
0.3837980926,
0.3752488196,
0.108168833,
0.1445498019,
-0.1069793701,
-0.1397121549,
0.1040648371,
-0.8955919743,
-0.4060950875,
-0.1439619064,
-0.7402561903,
-0.5042279363,
-0.1381335855,
-0.6936398149,
-0.479079783,
-0.1620257646,
0.954282999,
-0.161594674,
0.0873680711,
0.2963092029,
0.0871893764,
0.4816364646,
0.7898577452,
-0.9659918547,
0.5539629459,
0.6696978807,
0.6292207241,
-0.0526587479,
-0.0165929291,
-1.4131079912,
-0.0902974531,
-0.2920289636,
0.6843058467,
-0.2690346539,
-0.1039436683,
-0.4383323491,
0.066445142,
-0.2856706679,
-0.3484221101,
0.7300905585,
-0.6683986783,
0.0706899837,
-0.4787960649,
0.0051421556,
-0.4162287414,
0.123482056,
-0.6667692065,
0.8515592813,
0.3556120992,
-0.5123335123,
0.5871637464,
-0.6380056143,
-0.5348377228,
-0.4658003747,
0.2947406471,
-0.6704182625,
0.3809667528,
0.6443203092,
0.3304706514,
-0.3550273776,
-0.3672884107,
-0.3100378513,
-0.7449643612,
-0.2831899524,
-0.2949395776,
0.7499650121,
0.1807269156,
-0.0943579823,
0.2073153853,
-0.9922068715,
-0.0860552192,
0.3457413018,
-0.6406679749,
-0.3901605308,
0.3296200633,
-0.1491752118,
-0.3002670407,
0.4032216966,
-0.4675242603,
0.2293319851,
-0.3572992384,
0.4276783168,
0.9107763171,
-0.0609578937,
0.5573624372,
-0.2322575897,
0.5167148709,
-0.1121988147,
0.3081156313,
0.2845858335,
-0.4617893994,
-0.7875366211,
-0.2656082213,
0.6225206256,
0.2412737161,
-0.4707658887,
0.2265172452,
-0.4037339687,
-0.2255008072,
-0.6376008391,
0.4477382302,
0.2600878179,
0.6921500564,
0.5664718151,
-0.0729884654,
-0.638073504,
-0.4359019995,
-0.1649970859,
0.0195555706,
0.0186108146,
-0.0698958039,
0.2601541579,
-0.0494090617,
0.4246610105,
-0.4968132377,
-0.7031189203,
-0.2352908403,
0.0364823751,
0.223872155,
0.4287891388,
0.9584844708,
-0.5972903967,
-0.5642511845,
-0.1033625677,
-0.3560116291,
0.171525389,
0.2046696544,
-0.1520397961,
0.1837600321,
0.2967929244,
-0.0695249289,
0.4756501615,
0.8516151905,
-0.3331510127,
0.0895622149,
-0.5029450655,
0.0645358488,
-0.6224768162,
-0.087690115,
-0.2048097104,
-0.2850705683,
-0.1936396211,
0.104712531,
-0.0684367791,
-0.1766407341,
-0.1488624513,
0.2703505158,
-0.4088460207,
-0.2570869923,
-0.0862087682,
0.1070990488,
0.081535168,
0.5967574716,
-0.249829635,
0.8802512884,
0.5912720561,
-0.6475923061,
-0.1136814058,
0.3394895196,
-0.4061110914,
0.6255186796,
-0.8238781691,
0.0572439022,
-0.1793410629,
-0.0617077909,
-0.949965179,
-0.1211018786,
0.17095083,
-0.1186146587,
0.2633161247,
-0.6344197989,
-0.2741227746,
0.0897554681,
-0.8407608867,
0.4841220379,
0.8855460882,
-0.6643347144,
0.4139809906,
0.3466908932,
-0.0039236811,
-0.5095598698,
-0.430734098,
-0.3259834051,
-0.3864501119,
-0.2918189764,
0.2713747323,
-0.1798026264,
-0.053331174,
-0.1372703165,
-0.3623016775,
0.1821515709,
0.4490245879,
0.306434691,
-0.132121563,
-0.5540067554,
-0.0585148558,
0.4480709434,
-0.0668094829,
-0.2399370968,
0.1582823396,
0.3297579885,
-0.3801508546,
-0.3649179935,
-0.2918519676,
-0.0417408906,
0.6224495769,
-0.2056334615,
0.9198480844,
0.8105585575,
-0.0406479463,
-0.4804729223,
-0.1712929159,
0.1393264383,
-0.4923542738,
0.2636654675,
-0.4794560075,
-0.2749091685,
0.4244895875,
-0.158119753,
-0.0705370829,
0.4968574941,
0.1940741241,
-0.3785367906,
1.0765981674,
0.9549497366,
-0.0395890214,
0.611015141,
-0.4221018553,
-0.0014930277,
-1.1524956226,
-0.07063438,
-0.5396351814,
-0.8663647771,
-0.4289571047,
-0.3904383481,
0.6515063643,
0.4131815434,
-0.5820896029,
0.1369144469,
-0.5093722343,
0.4638618529,
0.548481822,
0.3409623802,
0.4932342172,
0.2887167633,
0.5618770719,
0.0980915949,
-0.7279610634,
-0.0752435252,
1.3614814281,
0.3031793833,
1.1326200962,
0.1487962604,
0.8177612424,
0.4241219163,
0.0088534849,
-0.975331068,
0.4376661777,
-0.5537084937,
0.0683936104,
-0.3812820613,
-0.2779689133,
-1.0584162474,
0.2650021911,
-0.2811071873,
-0.485257268,
0.3911398649,
0.0306733306,
-0.4356202781,
0.3209652305,
-0.6836314797,
0.6585685015,
-0.301602453,
-0.1757025868,
-0.484816283,
-0.436778456,
0.2885191441,
-0.1468782127,
0.07368242,
-0.3038317263,
-0.1910040081,
1.1136344671,
-0.6467089057,
0.7453132272,
-0.4461515546,
-0.4902386963,
0.1115018204,
0.0736435428,
0.5599857569,
0.1243191138,
-0.3634140193,
0.0297593102,
0.2913383842,
-0.6164820194,
-0.5135152936,
0.722766757,
-1.0879819393,
-0.3419069052,
-0.2773849666,
-0.3536656797,
-0.3676957488,
0.1316470504,
0.0635257289,
0.2622545362,
-0.1009168252,
0.3212072253,
0.7120547295,
-0.085233286,
0.2796856761,
0.3504524231,
-0.1405699402,
-0.3803964555,
0.9703443646,
-0.0906079933,
-0.0160881076,
0.5770644546,
0.2271627337,
0.038271524,
-0.8179751039,
-0.2938024402,
0.2337188721,
-0.5847681761,
-0.3388706148,
0.0760245919,
0.0789093003,
0.2223173082,
-0.3302313089,
-0.5047379136,
-0.5075805187,
-0.4649364054,
0.1855716258,
0.501885891,
0.8205758333,
-0.0602537245,
0.4934616387,
-0.3499114215,
0.6683924198,
0.6257571578,
0.2415860146,
0.0060262815,
-0.7003566623,
-0.138839975,
0.257807374,
-0.0889687836,
-0.5081700683,
-0.0181230456,
0.773240447,
0.1908136308,
0.5469239354,
0.3034712374,
1.0539752245,
-0.280215174,
0.5412442684,
0.0642344505,
-0.8775709867,
0.774409771,
-0.2040505111,
-0.003474226,
0.7606315613,
0.0441582352,
0.1998154372,
0.2987623513,
-0.3216414154,
-0.5823425651,
0.7315500379,
-0.0492462814,
-0.0756386593,
0.4705063403,
0.1920091212,
0.2530566752,
0.0623560101,
-0.4677109122,
0.1496954262,
-0.1005556509,
-0.2613258064,
-0.1872972697,
-0.4119158685,
-0.266397059,
-0.6966469288,
0.6717383862,
-0.4559971094,
0.1532628089,
-0.084235087,
-0.556137681,
-0.4624664783,
0.0078954464,
0.6427182555,
0.8071050048,
-0.5986147523,
0.084071368,
0.3276935816,
-0.4702220559,
-0.0271637645,
-0.2003721744,
-0.110782437,
-0.4686783254,
0.3382083476,
0.703686595,
0.7183366418,
-0.5655110478,
0.5291517377,
-0.0893187448,
-0.3118371665,
0.190405041,
0.3265930414,
-0.2013146728,
0.268820256,
0.5651558638,
0.3026157618,
-0.2019586116,
-0.5917861462,
-0.2147197425,
0.4189832509,
-0.2628800869,
-0.5506383777,
0.8054443598,
0.3340141177,
0.046349097,
0.3853123486,
-0.2868129611,
-0.0832074583,
0.4489364028,
0.3388685286,
0.7099884152,
0.0335042775,
0.3502026498,
0.3364142478,
0.0950048491,
0.0369590521,
0.571282804,
-0.3890202343,
-0.3416189849,
-0.4429115355,
-0.9727687836,
-0.0875143409,
0.0277404916,
-0.8383338451,
0.2779482603,
-0.7761849165,
0.05780904,
-0.2753356695,
0.3066766858,
-0.6287092566,
-0.1510245204,
0.0838142112,
0.8188253045,
-0.8085778356,
0.8113283515,
0.8303926587,
-0.3778305054,
-0.5523370504,
0.0716876462,
-0.20200409,
-1.1913466454,
0.9448068738,
-0.254068464,
-0.6054491401,
0.1614180505,
-0.6501428485,
-0.9794574976,
1.3528038263,
0.5200839639,
-0.2546294928,
-0.1434690654,
-0.2740464807,
0.3507835269,
-0.2475452125,
-0.2985841632,
0.4187864661,
0.5009351373,
0.0914971307,
-0.9286688566,
0.0512897447,
0.089455694,
0.0342945568,
0.0500326902,
-0.828615725,
1.1272674799,
-0.4520552754,
-0.0584157407,
0.3427294791,
0.5334464312,
0.089097701,
0.2095336765,
0.5630592704,
0.5110517144,
0.9329452515,
0.0894673392,
0.6498717666,
-0.0935524106,
0.4441685081,
1.1190761328,
-0.2454935312,
1.1341240406,
0.5124260783,
-0.4510393739,
0.9185552001,
0.5537564754,
0.0971487314,
0.9584164023,
-0.2795496881,
0.1733151823,
-0.3117339313,
0.3119754195,
-0.4721514285,
0.7866061926,
0.3607438505,
-0.0878558159,
-0.5505635738,
0.1077651232,
-0.1058728918,
-0.1051460877,
-0.8483707309,
0.6766816378,
0.0166021045,
-0.346249193,
1.2299984694,
0.0839667022,
0.622451067,
-0.5485875607,
-0.0955563188,
-0.1722749025,
0.3777770996,
-0.3508464694,
-0.425316453,
-0.0721348897,
-0.0257629547,
-0.1219273508,
-0.1580760032,
0.7452643514,
-0.0593413338,
-0.4057384133,
0.0093686637,
0.4403265119,
-0.0706555769,
-0.2521781027,
-0.6221920252,
0.3532067239,
-0.2284473777,
-0.187355563,
0.6307343245,
0.3368140161,
-0.0103192059,
0.6829102039,
0.5173236728,
0.19897829,
-0.0071777781,
0.0260570124,
0.7368210554,
-0.3885858655,
-0.575977087,
-0.3638190031,
0.3894763887,
0.2228167802,
-0.1831927747,
0.7032207251,
0.3555088639,
0.5102617145,
-0.2638050914,
0.2791596651,
-0.2011171132,
0.2263369262,
-0.8198919892,
0.8761873841,
-0.9589656591,
0.3425872326,
-0.3165800869,
-0.864685595,
-0.069517456,
0.7254271507,
-0.3911886513,
0.0137929255,
0.4851740897,
0.4048770964,
-0.52981776,
-0.2907267213,
0.2329394668,
0.2407051474,
-0.1327679008,
0.8003727198,
0.4568217397,
-1.0557688475,
0.4918373823,
-0.0819572359,
-0.1141983941,
-0.7671200037,
-0.9095029235,
-0.9522432089,
-0.5814731717,
-0.3926611245,
0.0979645625,
0.0964132473,
0.4523216486,
1.0372769833,
-0.7842879891,
0.0959946439,
0.0098035531,
0.4741244912,
-0.7629454732,
-0.1521918327,
0.6699721813,
-0.3348182142,
-0.6220462322,
0.6954540014,
0.0535383187,
-0.1920641065,
-0.0587050393,
-0.3857015371,
-0.1272255778,
-0.1181557849,
1.0024081469,
0.45646137,
-0.4479050934,
-0.4118155837,
-0.4393079877,
0.4216197431,
0.3293562233,
0.3580403626,
-1.1480380297,
0.2464642376,
0.4581497908,
0.5312933922,
0.6912577152,
0.3622409701,
0.2405225784,
-0.8544173837,
0.1301620901,
-0.1590622365,
0.2304282784,
0.0909090638,
-0.2259527296,
0.6238924265,
0.0595232546,
-0.3263684511,
-1.070348382,
0.1327927262,
-1.4371209145,
-0.1960805058,
0.8899148107,
0.1490186602,
-0.5467072129,
0.3417633474,
-0.3600670695,
0.0363211818,
-0.2998549342,
0.7148592472,
0.0605409779,
-0.1976154149,
-0.2719404697,
-0.3354038,
0.6776551008,
0.3583562374,
-0.7067089081,
-0.1397862285,
0.1307974756,
0.6228997111,
-0.1110166535,
0.4079308212,
0.0041772141,
0.3898929954,
-0.1001999527,
-0.4856755137,
-0.2970370352,
-0.4584867656,
-0.5403702259,
0.3700181246,
0.5337815285,
-0.6397584677
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09344v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09344v1
|
Generating Diverse Translation with Perturbed kNN-MT
| 2024-02-14T17:46:46 | 2024-02-14T17:46:46 |
Yuto Nishida, Makoto Morishita, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Taro Watanabe
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Generating multiple translation candidates would enable users to choose the
one that satisfies their needs. Although there has been work on diversified
generation, there exists room for improving the diversity mainly because the
previous methods do not address the overcorrection problem -- the model
underestimates a prediction that is largely different from the training data,
even if that prediction is likely. This paper proposes methods that generate
more diverse translations by introducing perturbed k-nearest neighbor machine
translation (kNN-MT). Our methods expand the search space of kNN-MT and help
incorporate diverse words into candidates by addressing the overcorrection
problem. Our experiments show that the proposed methods drastically improve
candidate diversity and control the degree of diversity by tuning the
perturbation's magnitude.
|
[
-0.8245586753,
-0.5151516199,
0.3077608347,
0.1552174687,
-0.6155405641,
0.4998115599,
-0.3547354937,
-0.2603089809,
0.2524159551,
0.6930304766,
-0.5636969209,
-0.5042446256,
-0.9096462727,
0.3438923657,
-0.2092456073,
1.0488313437,
0.0136485454,
0.073980622,
0.2374588549,
-0.219470486,
-0.48858127,
-0.6892416477,
-0.0745445564,
-0.2970186472,
0.8575213552,
0.8149587512,
0.9054586291,
0.5921657085,
0.6156648993,
0.2941637635,
-0.3706505597,
0.1094671637,
-0.7189818025,
0.5144696832,
0.0890970305,
-0.7472865582,
-0.0497285239,
-0.1767459661,
1.0316029787,
0.6450878382,
-0.0795186311,
-0.0282129794,
-0.3519453108,
0.7542788386,
-0.5799230337,
-0.5269735456,
-1.0806709528,
0.3926102817,
-0.609380126,
-0.1669778824,
-0.0054287841,
-0.4727519453,
0.0090495097,
-0.3511419892,
0.1782597303,
-0.0474518649,
0.6312439442,
0.0233403612,
-0.7290247679,
-0.1465935707,
-0.9953835607,
1.1753171682,
-0.7571923137,
0.5133456588,
0.3302426636,
0.6907515526,
-0.4221785367,
-0.3733052611,
-0.6243901849,
-0.217361927,
0.3137943447,
0.4537400007,
0.2276471853,
-0.3543670774,
0.3241860569,
0.5380754471,
-0.1477041245,
0.291478008,
-0.3435874879,
-0.0301002581,
0.4742565155,
0.494936794,
0.2993552685,
-0.1436035633,
-0.1213274598,
-0.4909030497,
-0.530266583,
-0.0452550985,
1.059741497,
0.4319511354,
0.2338646948,
0.734945178,
-0.3277838528,
0.5063508153,
-0.0170921665,
-0.0024642281,
0.5207423568,
-0.4118011892,
0.0608432703,
0.1147107929,
0.6270011663,
0.3446737528,
-0.1778262705,
-0.1888709962,
-0.2084665298,
-0.0888682678,
0.3136504292,
-0.8697045445,
-0.1845204234,
0.0542401597,
-0.5015086532,
-0.5981265306,
0.164804399,
-1.161190629,
-0.2281281054,
-0.0869585276,
0.091271691,
-0.3558488786,
-0.4495272338,
-0.1325340122,
-0.4286133945,
-0.1564987004,
0.1679190248,
-0.8739365935,
0.0319013409,
0.3103633523,
0.6433454156,
-0.2572433949,
-0.3871509731,
-0.3511755466,
-0.0445571728,
-0.3574045002,
0.4951812923,
-0.8255228996,
-0.7531920671,
-0.0196730457,
-0.5600683689,
0.3384203017,
-0.8087009192,
0.396887958,
-0.5699540377,
0.3179031014,
-0.7521478534,
-0.2207352519,
-0.1594376564,
0.3974739015,
-0.5081685185,
0.801520884,
0.4369933903,
-0.7339541912,
0.6315523386,
-0.8090257645,
-0.561540246,
-0.1432909817,
0.0446360819,
-0.7980074883,
0.4566997886,
0.505677104,
0.0887167528,
-0.0039258259,
0.0887081549,
-0.3042531013,
0.0247339997,
0.6225458384,
-0.1902652234,
0.6118380427,
0.4525283575,
0.0065532238,
0.1750480086,
-0.8460366726,
-0.0115453824,
0.1177185476,
-0.6972796917,
-0.3696637154,
-0.128110379,
0.0733521283,
0.3855701089,
-0.0101043461,
-0.7010999322,
0.3116253316,
-0.6955859661,
0.1123493835,
0.5366595387,
0.0041159489,
0.5165755153,
-0.4201109409,
0.8028194308,
0.317163527,
0.0670011044,
-0.0291109979,
-0.7737542987,
-0.3954590559,
-0.13336128,
0.5189530253,
0.3894369304,
-0.7822128534,
0.2182776928,
-0.2416599393,
-0.482539922,
-0.8120214939,
0.3492204249,
0.1631894857,
0.3701138794,
0.485999018,
-0.3320634961,
-0.8853337169,
-0.609513402,
-0.5164624453,
0.3500313759,
-0.0579745732,
0.4891695082,
0.3364270926,
-0.7213510275,
0.6785469651,
-0.373434335,
-0.3816759586,
-0.1291085184,
0.0576357692,
0.4486592412,
0.5494847298,
0.4756596088,
-1.139798522,
-0.947740078,
0.477545917,
-0.1569974422,
-0.1493238211,
0.016058553,
-0.3211321831,
-0.0355050787,
0.2187470645,
-0.2548931241,
0.0394232087,
0.6376273036,
0.1028968394,
0.4499001503,
-0.0113038933,
0.2333898544,
-1.406522274,
-0.0760211796,
-0.6036983728,
-0.19855088,
-0.6390001774,
0.3557182848,
-0.2149602175,
-0.0246309042,
-0.2486841828,
0.2029671073,
-0.3819455504,
-0.0763408765,
-0.4609229267,
0.2604826391,
-0.5527413487,
0.1066840589,
-0.3208048046,
0.2951717675,
0.3136492372,
-0.5025613308,
0.3683510125,
0.5147152543,
-0.2708425224,
0.1710785478,
-0.1486231089,
0.1563058197,
-0.230495885,
0.180428341,
-1.0442339182,
-0.3633263707,
0.1990068853,
-0.5621449351,
0.3250718117,
-0.2422130108,
-0.5204120874,
-0.5821967721,
-0.2101971805,
0.5244503021,
0.6660320759,
-0.6534417272,
0.4962262511,
0.1272568256,
-0.0776765198,
-0.5518568158,
-0.9192894697,
0.1385369897,
-0.4114218354,
-0.4369188249,
0.3464992344,
-0.1440041065,
0.1469998509,
-0.138752237,
-0.2150637358,
0.1451968551,
0.1569804102,
-0.0020596157,
-0.0650105923,
-0.3298333585,
-0.2125186771,
0.6124970317,
-0.1335557401,
-0.2947570384,
-0.5186147094,
0.7443169355,
0.2378118634,
-0.2401508987,
0.0927105099,
0.6038703322,
0.4109083414,
-0.3351078928,
0.5741434693,
1.0497078896,
0.0087830517,
-0.004034949,
-0.5648450851,
-0.1705007404,
-0.5323267579,
0.7290840149,
-0.5446720719,
-1.1914596558,
0.9535343647,
-0.4240438342,
0.1173242852,
0.4508441687,
0.8453730941,
-0.1659153104,
1.4146183729,
0.3661265969,
0.1621793061,
0.7024107575,
-0.0983646065,
-0.1077747494,
-1.0191444159,
-0.1012513191,
-0.6217299104,
-1.0070989132,
-0.9471419454,
-0.1667626798,
0.3541814685,
0.2473394126,
-0.0543402508,
0.2556220591,
-0.5896556377,
0.4544491172,
0.7988882661,
-0.0052189124,
0.1503133774,
0.4388230145,
-0.6188593507,
-0.5190392137,
-0.8253672123,
-0.0303203929,
1.3626635075,
0.0881102532,
0.3905244768,
0.3934137523,
1.1854798794,
-0.27259022,
0.6810205579,
-0.3836206198,
0.2960974276,
-0.7061713338,
-0.7250064611,
-0.4065032005,
-0.9338156581,
-1.2111312151,
0.3825457394,
-0.5815761685,
-0.564661622,
0.144580096,
0.1096627489,
-0.0261859,
0.4036895335,
-0.1629131734,
0.6694880128,
-0.2189240307,
0.5293418169,
-0.2705832124,
-0.87213099,
0.4154087901,
-0.5422701836,
-0.0394544676,
0.0998047367,
0.0565762036,
0.3175434172,
-0.3845459521,
0.5680961013,
-0.1155313551,
0.0298905857,
0.0831714496,
0.1853538007,
0.5923677087,
-0.0715006739,
-0.1729751527,
0.1055669412,
-0.5528885722,
-0.4712750018,
-0.7760519981,
0.746717751,
-0.9805902839,
-0.4539079964,
0.136844635,
-0.7842212319,
-0.1938772649,
0.5737564564,
0.8245456219,
-0.0646682903,
0.1110720187,
0.4759577513,
0.3515580893,
-0.3335951269,
0.1291808188,
0.2787075341,
-0.6899107695,
-1.1232275963,
1.0581721067,
0.3773321807,
0.442266345,
0.4771502912,
0.7644081116,
-0.2286147177,
-0.8372718692,
-0.3299959004,
-0.1704966575,
-0.5584207177,
-0.1871576756,
-0.7336320877,
0.1753960997,
-0.2626410425,
-0.1928685606,
-0.2981809974,
-0.5440921187,
-0.0794512257,
0.1238706484,
0.2332082391,
0.5905060768,
0.0095783025,
0.8915787339,
-1.0721817017,
0.455291301,
0.32405743,
0.4575924873,
-0.0715038478,
-0.5993662477,
-0.2284415364,
0.1334039867,
-0.5610835552,
-1.0668588877,
0.3961289227,
0.0745835304,
0.723721981,
0.2586195469,
-0.0538490117,
0.6875559092,
-0.4974206686,
0.6277595758,
0.5398536921,
-0.7049831152,
0.6974725723,
-0.50324893,
0.8023636341,
0.5977907181,
0.4131138325,
-0.5264397264,
-0.928988874,
-0.5766884685,
-1.001396656,
0.6286178231,
0.524176538,
0.3785772622,
0.0503630266,
0.1978447586,
0.4279534221,
0.3999320567,
-0.4378373325,
-0.2373451889,
-0.6589544415,
-0.006991555,
-0.0959623531,
-0.2292584032,
0.145365119,
-0.1391843855,
0.5869029164,
0.238179177,
-0.0004506288,
0.1914576441,
0.1372766793,
-0.5987412333,
0.168659091,
0.7925509214,
0.2210727036,
-0.1183899194,
-0.1280349195,
0.4016259015,
-0.5887207985,
-0.017915776,
-0.01289172,
-0.4375756681,
0.19212237,
-0.1593194604,
0.804508388,
-0.2390078902,
-0.241387248,
-0.0357239954,
0.0840948746,
-0.3960771263,
0.1805255115,
0.1787262857,
0.0704775527,
0.2684569955,
0.3076588213,
0.5323792696,
0.0596536957,
-0.3951528072,
0.0988368392,
0.3333422542,
-0.1803116947,
-0.1643474698,
0.7920094132,
0.1184947193,
-0.6985778809,
0.9099342227,
-0.3288945854,
-0.9236569405,
0.5693996549,
0.9251947403,
0.9724622965,
-0.6298723221,
-0.1754160374,
0.3770712316,
0.3903042972,
-0.0788548887,
0.5133856535,
0.1011544615,
-0.8586596251,
-0.5271381736,
-0.3771443367,
-0.2447528243,
0.1432780176,
-0.4665267169,
0.1283875257,
-0.4240228832,
-0.8394370675,
-0.2185058147,
-0.0565589368,
-0.3903450966,
0.1534294784,
-0.0659555495,
0.376394093,
-0.5282833576,
0.7595124841,
0.9838430285,
-0.4267963767,
-0.4565057755,
0.141300112,
-0.4119193554,
-0.2916460931,
0.7495382428,
-0.1266127527,
0.2824009657,
-0.0465482734,
-0.557481885,
-0.8528438807,
0.6724248528,
0.4147674739,
-0.5871878266,
0.3792722821,
0.3898381889,
0.4643037915,
-0.2913432121,
-0.2116069645,
0.0314785205,
0.7264585495,
0.1130520776,
-0.66159904,
-0.1026512831,
-0.1139123142,
0.3527745306,
0.6549663544,
-0.3958825171,
0.7735774517,
-0.1481631845,
0.0064069503,
0.2201743275,
0.6136544347,
0.2671402097,
0.1067812964,
0.5067474842,
0.4327699244,
0.6474093199,
0.1230060384,
0.9751803875,
0.0492430478,
0.2061259896,
1.1613607407,
0.0236370116,
0.6573519111,
0.5757507086,
-0.3181110024,
0.2218615562,
0.2644639611,
-0.3676865101,
0.4078010619,
0.3578409851,
-0.0507415459,
-0.4879934192,
0.248413831,
-0.5012701154,
0.4478808939,
0.3276917338,
-0.4427146316,
-0.2338673472,
0.1279999614,
-0.426006794,
0.3898861706,
-0.1182699502,
0.4488050044,
0.2079354972,
-0.4590799809,
0.4527513981,
0.2448139936,
0.6880528927,
-0.6156492233,
0.0293653924,
-0.265175581,
0.0320697576,
-0.2097044438,
-0.6643339992,
0.2818497717,
-0.3859449625,
-0.3435157239,
-0.2182315141,
0.8084436059,
-0.6796116829,
-0.7166129351,
0.0726632774,
0.2390570939,
0.2335348129,
-0.0257323403,
-0.5337424278,
-0.1196405962,
0.3458877206,
0.027977312,
0.541827023,
0.6070386767,
-0.0569749512,
0.6034401059,
1.0325065851,
0.3282436728,
0.5115796924,
0.138242662,
0.8471781015,
-0.5148788691,
-0.5607637763,
-0.8418021202,
0.4695223868,
-0.0779135823,
-0.5993905663,
0.9152853489,
0.4770153761,
0.913706243,
-0.2766407728,
0.6233391166,
0.3190639317,
0.5484550595,
-0.1556721479,
0.7228295207,
-0.5768567324,
0.1150031537,
-0.6355209947,
-1.188890934,
-0.718091011,
0.5235369205,
-0.149238795,
0.2180413753,
0.2335057408,
0.4174364209,
-0.2533415258,
-0.0783228651,
0.5149802566,
0.3193579316,
0.3220997155,
0.3289405406,
0.9537290335,
-0.4642169774,
1.0048214197,
-0.2231800556,
0.0883099437,
-0.4396161437,
-0.9235541821,
-0.8291431069,
-0.2888685167,
-0.2315973192,
-0.372690022,
-0.0817667916,
0.7852125168,
0.4831056297,
-0.9235659242,
-0.0252033882,
-0.1684411913,
0.3735056221,
-0.321967274,
-0.1409709007,
-0.0648280829,
-0.3936366737,
-0.6297753453,
0.3604537845,
0.0830714181,
0.2343648672,
-0.0538612343,
-0.2019565701,
0.0102593107,
-0.2937947512,
0.5106073618,
0.0595795512,
-0.5493434072,
0.2126778662,
0.0464268178,
0.0297440384,
0.418798089,
0.815162003,
-0.412512064,
0.8284820914,
0.6521291137,
0.9399396181,
0.6399039626,
0.0687391832,
0.8416550159,
-1.0237283707,
-0.0821899697,
0.4115595222,
-0.0604772866,
0.1929668486,
-0.3652553558,
0.0711091161,
0.1739923209,
-0.5296128988,
-0.8126864433,
0.6825802326,
-0.6397131085,
-0.2441683859,
1.0898395777,
0.1752690524,
0.1555968821,
-0.119299598,
-0.3886569738,
0.4407631159,
-0.4254362881,
0.8846555352,
0.6203115582,
0.308863163,
0.2474799305,
-0.5097183585,
0.2468603402,
0.8472601771,
-0.3204018474,
-0.2923345268,
0.1717179418,
0.1994383335,
0.3183488548,
0.2027561218,
-0.3582498133,
0.2525599897,
0.030805571,
-0.1463049054,
-0.0654292628,
-0.0176019315,
-0.2161841691,
0.1107569709,
0.1927957088,
-0.1912509501
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09320v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09320v1
|
ICDPO: Effectively Borrowing Alignment Capability of Others via In-context Direct Preference Optimization
| 2024-02-14T17:14:34 | 2024-02-14T17:14:34 |
Feifan Song, Yuxuan Fan, Xin Zhang, Peiyi Wang, Houfeng Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) rely on Human Preference Alignment (HPA) to
ensure the generation of safe content. Due to the heavy cost associated with
fine-tuning, fine-tuning-free methods have emerged, typically modifying LLM
decoding with external auxiliary methods. However, these methods do not
essentially enhance the LLM itself. In this paper, we rethink the derivation
procedures of DPO, based on which we conversely build an instant scorer using
the states of the LLM before and after In-context Learning (ICL). Accordingly,
we propose a novel approach called In-Context Direct Preference Optimization
(ICDPO). It enables LLMs to borrow the HPA capabilities from superior LLMs with
ICL, generating well-aligned responses as estimated by the aforementioned
instant scorer, thereby enhancing the final performance. ICDPO can be further
enhanced with a two-stage retriever and an upgraded scorer, both offering
benefits. Extensive experiments show its effectiveness, particularly in
outperforming two fine-tuning-free baselines, and it exhibits competitiveness
with SFT + LoRA. We also conduct detailed analyses to offer comprehensive
insights into ICDPO.
|
[
-0.3040979803,
-0.2972029448,
0.5140318274,
0.1129726991,
-0.4336715937,
0.1067883521,
-0.3271176815,
-0.506788671,
-0.1359934509,
0.4270497262,
-0.2953273356,
-0.1529718637,
-0.4438762665,
0.1612775475,
0.1869804561,
0.792676568,
-0.1811896861,
-0.0760218427,
-0.0932958573,
0.1963302642,
-0.4644964635,
-0.3483712971,
-0.490368396,
-0.268419534,
0.2050873786,
0.9933151007,
0.4348808527,
0.9824889302,
0.4486155808,
0.271166712,
0.0099477582,
0.3729659617,
-0.4591573477,
-0.065309599,
-0.1642360389,
-0.2080583721,
-0.6308946609,
0.1970183253,
0.7056991458,
0.4255646169,
-0.0828678682,
-0.1468281448,
0.4398435354,
0.8354028463,
-0.7857298255,
0.0290844012,
-1.1786009073,
0.0047654179,
-0.0595147572,
-0.4347256422,
-0.5896323919,
-0.4443390369,
0.4117647409,
-0.6257405877,
-0.315392226,
-0.1265015304,
0.6699397564,
0.3038839996,
-0.4401354492,
-0.3787499368,
-0.5676873326,
0.9319038391,
-0.5520669818,
0.1270384789,
0.286852628,
0.2341166735,
-0.3872127533,
-0.1420603245,
-0.588994503,
-0.2156813294,
0.0971334577,
-0.0478076413,
0.2159432471,
0.0702820122,
-0.1162595898,
0.2531108856,
-0.0329990685,
0.485044539,
0.223562941,
0.0040787966,
0.6456276178,
-0.0623760149,
0.1633963287,
-0.1749018282,
-0.7520717382,
-0.0809692517,
-0.8859590292,
0.3457404971,
0.377738297,
0.4645776749,
0.0219917819,
0.5154758692,
-0.1171072125,
0.5981540084,
0.7066633105,
-0.5217159986,
0.0967395976,
-0.1736465544,
-0.0390000604,
0.38749066,
0.5779790282,
0.3936165273,
0.1376634538,
-0.2472600192,
-0.2305904329,
-0.2013553977,
0.0850413889,
-0.7070755959,
0.2918517888,
-0.0034777056,
-0.3062452376,
-0.3073183298,
0.1256681979,
-0.8693622947,
-0.1397240758,
-0.7254078984,
0.2583177388,
-0.5134176612,
-0.0021778271,
0.0379138961,
0.213471055,
0.5127830505,
0.2505000532,
-1.17897439,
0.1184563637,
0.9433948994,
0.5840027332,
-0.5788295269,
-0.3480143249,
-0.7474416494,
0.4750133157,
-0.178657949,
0.6720306873,
-0.5480186939,
-0.4434187412,
-0.1405948251,
-0.3583250046,
0.1541361958,
-0.4606315494,
0.7157783508,
-0.5587141514,
0.1578899324,
-0.2536251247,
-0.6508971453,
0.2771282196,
0.1347910315,
-0.2183136791,
0.8531376123,
0.0578072555,
-0.5923088193,
0.6686261892,
-0.4579680562,
-0.326680243,
0.0334451348,
-0.2012240142,
-0.1665498316,
0.1307887286,
0.1667872518,
0.4358518124,
-0.29212147,
0.3432471752,
-0.4755333364,
-0.4615335464,
0.2676519454,
-0.3939947784,
0.6425272822,
0.1621757746,
-0.3181404173,
0.0776025206,
-0.8529081345,
-0.1163929254,
-0.2231488675,
-0.6420192122,
-0.6080335379,
0.0751607642,
-0.4385642409,
0.4328658283,
0.3759372234,
-0.5759602785,
0.2759971917,
-0.6319490671,
0.3697875738,
1.2616270781,
-0.2926396728,
0.9673169851,
-0.0919564366,
0.276185751,
-0.2058358639,
0.2429971099,
0.3004710972,
-0.1418810338,
-0.2810024917,
-0.7002943158,
-0.0080210585,
0.4908343852,
-0.6123235226,
0.9125463367,
-0.3103419542,
-0.1412398666,
-0.4253003597,
0.1482634991,
0.4884645939,
1.043798089,
0.168039456,
-0.2089868635,
-0.3834245801,
-0.9043341279,
-0.2303024977,
-0.0926336125,
0.1750604659,
0.440618664,
-0.1224477589,
0.0014669353,
1.1082334518,
-0.5699698925,
-0.2579505146,
-0.2840666771,
-0.3036522269,
0.2269842476,
0.5764065385,
0.6251058578,
-0.7574378252,
-0.9999262094,
0.2061273605,
-0.4396442771,
-0.1922434717,
0.1779294908,
-0.4195447862,
0.3176254034,
0.2936071455,
-0.4478067756,
0.0824243426,
0.3676519096,
-0.2856315076,
0.4720894992,
-0.2927129865,
0.0591063313,
-1.1604708433,
0.0228606947,
-0.0940901339,
0.0790753737,
-0.4372009337,
0.0695799217,
0.1700994521,
-0.0339289121,
-0.5557229519,
0.8060131073,
-0.4014752805,
0.0582490489,
-0.4577038288,
0.1580972522,
-0.1778247803,
0.4889020026,
-0.0401987992,
0.9038069248,
0.3330359161,
-0.637793839,
-0.1533232927,
0.3000109494,
-0.3443683982,
0.5676469803,
-0.261857152,
0.3647460341,
-0.1952045858,
0.1729987264,
-1.0254909992,
-0.1990419775,
0.1176892519,
-0.1101609766,
0.5617101192,
-0.1711135656,
-0.3336083591,
-0.0369685739,
-0.4795697629,
0.5309003592,
0.2760656178,
-0.9062560201,
0.2816134989,
0.5825708508,
-0.0709725022,
-0.9075762033,
-0.0812311992,
-0.0040908405,
-0.5088779926,
-0.2752298117,
0.7271634936,
-0.3417820632,
-0.3693787158,
-0.3717679381,
-0.0591723062,
0.1542319059,
0.2318588346,
-0.0371109247,
0.5201049447,
0.2521255314,
-0.0196039733,
0.3169428408,
-0.3972876072,
-0.2963095307,
-0.3013283312,
0.5511231422,
0.1206843033,
0.0079123089,
-0.6062197685,
0.3762840331,
0.5419696569,
-0.127043888,
0.4528955817,
0.0050551281,
-0.1091583297,
-0.2745360732,
-0.3727671206,
-0.148037225,
-0.5303722024,
0.1477531344,
-0.5525909662,
-0.6789388061,
0.0604968034,
-0.0909257755,
-0.0829019248,
0.1003092378,
0.4248331189,
-0.0305176359,
1.1342915297,
0.7357645631,
-0.275486201,
0.8220950365,
0.0746445656,
0.0990557671,
-0.9400715232,
-0.0489323512,
-0.5212578773,
-0.3133805692,
-0.6745226383,
0.0001628695,
0.3340456188,
0.3676252663,
-0.2005855888,
0.4234345257,
-0.5487690568,
0.7350216508,
0.5266929269,
0.1420449317,
0.4033638835,
0.1140229404,
-0.2532424033,
-0.2417953163,
-0.3331873715,
-0.5698893666,
1.1872156858,
0.1445633322,
0.4320138097,
0.0775553808,
0.8166367412,
0.0686136335,
0.3334826827,
-0.9556435347,
0.6117625833,
-0.4064596593,
-0.164814949,
-0.2141675949,
-0.3064539731,
-0.4747122824,
0.2754847407,
-0.1962269545,
-0.919028759,
0.395857513,
0.1953499764,
-0.1617753953,
0.0321918279,
-0.6427628994,
0.5370187759,
-0.3459462523,
-0.529925704,
-0.1878104657,
-0.6038610339,
0.2878398001,
-0.110488303,
-0.0754193142,
-0.2518512607,
-0.1800050437,
0.2788014412,
-0.2156437784,
0.4857718945,
-0.1210056096,
-0.4131672382,
0.0620608665,
0.0070430352,
0.6837880015,
0.1901331991,
-0.6154792905,
-0.1948765367,
-0.3138725758,
-0.2471769452,
-0.4398404956,
1.0541186333,
-0.8202009201,
-0.6431883574,
-0.2274175584,
-0.6017090678,
-0.3795471489,
0.3486034572,
0.2478780597,
0.3087438345,
-0.2030185163,
0.054310184,
0.4441674352,
0.0349872299,
0.6819038987,
0.5841962099,
0.1584391594,
-0.6764259338,
0.7805611491,
-0.2220935524,
0.380410254,
0.850690484,
0.4845513105,
-0.345747143,
-0.6851092577,
-0.3539929688,
0.2869220078,
-0.5734625459,
-0.2131075561,
-0.2928282917,
0.336309284,
-0.2722133398,
-0.4787986577,
-0.2637233734,
-0.2436303794,
-0.5895608068,
-0.0815938637,
-0.1014542654,
0.0966963023,
-0.1262697279,
0.0884096771,
-0.6365222335,
0.2094423026,
0.3910723627,
0.3756172657,
-0.0023861954,
-0.4113088548,
-0.1189513355,
0.0184820313,
-0.4749551713,
-0.6598574519,
0.3649500906,
0.1723661423,
0.4688726068,
0.6228637099,
0.1972221732,
0.7915908694,
-0.5737152696,
0.3399985135,
0.0467114113,
-1.1685926914,
0.5332860351,
-0.3019289076,
0.0279389694,
0.8571107984,
0.3311913013,
-0.0719634667,
0.036824774,
-0.1476713419,
-0.7979112864,
0.8333548903,
-0.2139134258,
0.0820645466,
-0.173465386,
0.8081381321,
0.4545429349,
0.0598780699,
-0.5173707604,
-0.0516738556,
0.1110207215,
-0.2732237577,
-0.0734352544,
-0.3098540604,
-0.2344587445,
-0.2610081732,
0.8363482952,
-0.5891897678,
-0.0039063036,
0.1281089783,
-0.0481983311,
-0.2937549949,
0.3089134693,
0.338668555,
0.7636244893,
-0.3802832663,
-0.0769936293,
-0.1363616586,
-0.2050016522,
0.3338600695,
0.2110063583,
-0.318248719,
-0.620233655,
-0.0051300805,
0.6193557978,
0.2947235405,
-0.6945368648,
0.397500813,
-0.0966507196,
0.1318748593,
-0.0517696515,
0.0021088091,
-0.3108155727,
0.1702683419,
0.3799959123,
-0.0604489036,
0.196895957,
-0.6102304459,
0.2615843415,
0.7794346213,
-0.5703456998,
-0.364292711,
0.4407769442,
0.2041170299,
-0.3020874262,
0.4519805312,
-0.0039532245,
-0.2470060587,
0.419377178,
0.9651972055,
0.9342185259,
-0.1640118808,
0.1651778668,
0.1322742999,
-0.282171458,
-0.0291045103,
0.1022086143,
-0.3278128207,
-1.0090616941,
-0.4494885504,
-0.6116998792,
-0.352825135,
-0.1496646404,
-0.6554500461,
0.3997272253,
-0.4520793259,
0.1024194658,
-0.2023430616,
0.1517166048,
-0.355525285,
0.0491745397,
0.1321162432,
0.7253661752,
-0.2504193783,
1.1438721418,
0.5709542036,
-0.0589604117,
-0.7772051692,
0.3926492035,
0.0145184901,
-0.7998148799,
0.6393988729,
0.1533104926,
-0.3045122325,
0.1301440895,
-0.3539036512,
-1.0427179337,
1.1332994699,
0.6293754578,
-0.528434217,
-0.0719182938,
-0.0413639583,
0.4627987742,
-0.597212553,
-0.0399222337,
0.7102051973,
0.2027182579,
0.0711088702,
-0.8069572449,
0.1712984592,
0.2123808414,
0.0375730768,
0.3457137644,
-0.711568594,
0.65500772,
-0.1942389011,
-0.2859552801,
0.2236597538,
0.4631671309,
0.4594976008,
0.0080733811,
0.5256693363,
0.5174193978,
0.4960610569,
0.099456653,
1.0446888208,
-0.3919806778,
0.2210946679,
1.1218545437,
-0.5782821774,
0.9841755629,
0.8271235228,
0.0171624348,
0.219469443,
0.4131168127,
0.6371580958,
1.0152944326,
-0.0243438464,
-0.3948891163,
-0.1068164408,
-0.2131359428,
-0.1479489207,
0.8037121296,
0.1437826604,
-0.2674667835,
0.0176657848,
-0.1866789758,
0.0226218347,
0.3102560043,
-0.2434195727,
1.0679347515,
0.0415653475,
-1.0516209602,
0.544616282,
-0.2286128402,
0.7296039462,
-0.5763367414,
-0.0366081186,
-0.2819474339,
0.6130336523,
0.077773042,
-0.6260244846,
0.0652716756,
-0.1918136328,
-0.2407557517,
-0.4050608873,
0.4695074856,
-0.4961369932,
-0.1875568628,
0.5843413472,
0.114273414,
-0.3597580492,
0.132718578,
-0.5680748224,
-0.1852864474,
0.0559095182,
0.0826802179,
0.7643350363,
0.327929765,
-0.0057448382,
0.4765349329,
0.5962120295,
0.043576587,
-0.3314977884,
-0.1968244463,
0.7405596375,
-0.3659555018,
-0.5580198169,
-1.024861455,
0.2452670187,
0.0147663504,
-0.421464026,
0.7196740508,
0.4330477715,
0.9522634745,
0.0015298337,
0.6212130785,
0.041793786,
0.3551865816,
-0.6484259367,
0.4594371915,
-0.6148015857,
0.2861352265,
-0.6248656511,
-1.1821485758,
-0.3104640543,
0.2536514699,
-0.3683672845,
-0.474953413,
0.3584961295,
0.6196661592,
-0.0450262576,
-0.1804118454,
0.1212493405,
-0.0621696077,
0.5213870406,
0.6697313786,
0.7286971807,
-0.1303637624,
0.3518652618,
-0.4668668509,
-0.5976719856,
-0.2731686234,
-1.1823728085,
-0.4474326968,
-0.4883165956,
0.0209181961,
-0.1648036391,
-0.0469540507,
1.3189702034,
0.5475443006,
-0.7173938155,
-0.449811548,
-0.0646367669,
0.3229648769,
-0.3195089102,
-0.2295164168,
0.4844802618,
-0.3251075447,
-1.1018599272,
0.6701158881,
0.4712373614,
0.0829401091,
0.105595693,
-0.2539561093,
-0.235196054,
0.0180536993,
0.8330827951,
0.3006841242,
-0.6712617874,
-0.4929180443,
-0.0678388551,
-0.0762902945,
0.3595314324,
0.9133309722,
-0.612221241,
0.5607477427,
0.667971611,
0.7026189566,
0.2025613189,
0.2824876606,
0.857540071,
-0.6066272259,
0.2082660347,
0.1520525962,
0.4344747066,
0.2734214067,
-0.66157341,
0.195990935,
-0.0730462074,
-0.6354376078,
-0.7082805634,
0.3421493173,
-0.9987760782,
-0.2372252643,
1.1152975559,
-0.0163529459,
0.0377240814,
0.1716100723,
-0.4391998053,
0.2367281467,
-0.8476073742,
1.1082357168,
0.378347218,
-0.3597643375,
0.2099497318,
0.1864857823,
0.7954810858,
0.3237584829,
-0.9052137136,
0.0473421365,
0.4177942574,
0.3247478008,
-0.068862468,
0.7230210304,
-0.2824106812,
-0.0073362892,
-0.6426275373,
-0.193829149,
0.0926098824,
-0.5133652687,
-0.3972934484,
0.2331190109,
0.2660798728,
-0.1748585701
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09283v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09283v3
|
Attacks, Defenses and Evaluations for LLM Conversation Safety: A Survey
| 2024-02-14T16:14:03 | 2024-03-27T13:55:14 |
Zhichen Dong, Zhanhui Zhou, Chao Yang, Jing Shao, Yu Qiao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are now commonplace in conversation
applications. However, their risks of misuse for generating harmful responses
have raised serious societal concerns and spurred recent research on LLM
conversation safety. Therefore, in this survey, we provide a comprehensive
overview of recent studies, covering three critical aspects of LLM conversation
safety: attacks, defenses, and evaluations. Our goal is to provide a structured
summary that enhances understanding of LLM conversation safety and encourages
further investigation into this important subject. For easy reference, we have
categorized all the studies mentioned in this survey according to our taxonomy,
available at: https://github.com/niconi19/LLM-conversation-safety.
|
[
-0.3505014777,
-1.2852572203,
0.444562763,
-0.001965875,
0.0210658535,
0.1230001152,
-0.0309522375,
-0.7884381413,
0.0806838199,
0.7907145619,
-0.1402394325,
-0.3594053388,
-0.7363031507,
-0.0902267843,
-0.6720812321,
0.963060081,
0.2524163723,
0.2608588934,
-0.1214654073,
0.1002463475,
-0.4048974514,
-1.0967911482,
-0.8930280209,
0.1281364709,
0.5172260404,
0.2539694607,
0.3217341602,
-0.0826159418,
0.9724193811,
0.420530498,
-0.3545662761,
-0.3252564073,
-0.7654661536,
0.4344872534,
0.023061756,
-0.4934490025,
-0.7849152088,
-0.0525840111,
0.611397028,
0.7433544397,
-0.2007978261,
-0.0668291524,
0.0956672579,
0.5132305622,
-0.5884248018,
-0.3230246007,
-0.9375039339,
0.10955026,
-0.3974948525,
-0.1320308894,
-0.7476817966,
-0.5394394398,
0.2675243914,
0.1718456596,
-0.3916021585,
0.1072463989,
0.4975824952,
-0.3014789224,
-0.8478805423,
-0.4824756086,
-0.6402190328,
0.7812141776,
-0.6184174418,
0.1306817234,
0.408503741,
0.4850426316,
-0.3124757111,
-0.5103831887,
-0.1043270975,
-0.5141336322,
0.0290268436,
0.084415637,
-0.6139740348,
0.4572330117,
0.3259502053,
0.3905004859,
-0.4213266969,
0.4674277604,
-0.4618519843,
-0.220289126,
0.7959904075,
0.6598535776,
0.5947281122,
-0.1239728853,
-0.4098092318,
-0.012287545,
-1.1431449652,
-0.0773666874,
0.4278688133,
-0.0514834225,
-0.2894247174,
0.5540491939,
0.0388371311,
0.7050394416,
-0.2745755911,
-0.4066182673,
-0.1241796985,
-0.5743792057,
-0.2443895191,
-0.1558098048,
1.1067453623,
0.8240377307,
0.3059818447,
-0.1611991674,
-0.0485150553,
-0.1315832883,
0.4136972427,
-0.8365799785,
0.1282347441,
0.1409322768,
-0.4565078318,
-0.7239444256,
-0.0569461137,
-0.8922362924,
-0.5863443613,
0.3820970058,
-0.0746806115,
-0.2246154249,
-0.2969738543,
0.1136575341,
0.1306984574,
0.5311123729,
0.2104965299,
-0.6820697784,
0.5672498941,
0.6640539765,
0.5738825798,
-0.3856867254,
0.017128231,
-0.3102787435,
0.0390494242,
-0.3175950944,
0.7356016636,
-0.2796311378,
-1.0829014778,
0.4260933697,
-0.0698800683,
-0.0672327355,
-0.3793677092,
0.6243475676,
-0.6905264258,
0.1924388409,
-0.0884346962,
-0.4856296182,
-0.0939209983,
0.7207553387,
-0.6535013914,
0.5038030148,
-0.3143726587,
-1.0886775255,
-0.3021185398,
-0.4924147129,
-0.5620532632,
-0.1128551811,
-0.0751984566,
-0.2461863607,
0.1296311319,
-0.2527135313,
0.6423707604,
-0.4468414485,
0.0395644717,
-0.3539188802,
-0.0057796193,
0.7828087211,
-0.6682611108,
0.7902198434,
0.3635683358,
-0.0595850609,
0.2443273515,
-0.5926761627,
-0.0331669338,
0.2031126916,
-0.3485906422,
-0.108041741,
-0.0114776483,
-0.0911272168,
0.0480375662,
0.1890317947,
-0.6085767746,
-0.0216925945,
-0.5573401451,
0.4681095183,
0.5509361625,
0.5313177705,
0.3055964112,
-0.2833093703,
0.7333609462,
-0.2178281844,
0.3935382664,
-0.0887588039,
-0.3838848472,
-0.6171081066,
0.1173514724,
0.1647061706,
0.7358903885,
-0.5501061082,
0.303745091,
-0.0624627396,
-0.702935338,
0.2017449439,
-0.1077036336,
0.6359468102,
0.1773444414,
-0.2802140713,
-0.3159261644,
-0.6136449575,
-0.9827361703,
-0.231960699,
-0.6016716361,
0.0477235727,
0.4089559019,
0.2390182763,
-0.2776908278,
0.5981803536,
-0.6411127448,
0.1499266177,
-0.5476064682,
-0.1744179577,
-0.2255420834,
0.3771037161,
0.8754615784,
-0.4266503751,
-0.4532735646,
-0.2418931425,
-0.5543062687,
-0.0959797353,
0.1314270347,
-0.0900923386,
0.2544263005,
0.7157444358,
-0.7546910644,
0.4234720767,
0.6832574606,
-0.1741303951,
0.5347717404,
0.3997544646,
0.1885770857,
-1.1338791847,
-0.2034812272,
0.0944014266,
-0.1746177673,
-1.1000901461,
0.2089626342,
-0.2994761467,
0.0326033309,
-0.8316390514,
0.2830170095,
-0.2819883823,
0.163270995,
-0.2936432958,
0.196676746,
-0.2112286687,
-0.1154948547,
-0.1558999419,
0.5432456136,
0.6608716846,
-0.5740497708,
0.439057678,
0.1597593576,
-0.6368910074,
0.4756529331,
-0.9128078222,
0.529099822,
0.2860216796,
0.3323156834,
-0.9612469673,
-0.2904930711,
0.4464446604,
-0.4856694937,
0.3025984466,
-0.1289277673,
-0.4038431942,
-0.220381856,
-0.5880278349,
0.2948346138,
0.3187356293,
-0.078980796,
0.3833861053,
0.89531672,
-0.3638056219,
-0.5355708003,
-0.7844330668,
0.5509710908,
-0.6456708312,
-0.6198041439,
-0.1669649035,
-0.4130821824,
-0.8519191146,
-0.5897223353,
0.1741083115,
-0.0665570721,
0.6574053764,
0.399848789,
0.3386276364,
0.1351623833,
-0.3032858372,
-0.6687341928,
0.1062248498,
0.5124284029,
0.5329166055,
0.7815927267,
-0.1521752477,
-0.6648596525,
-0.3481687605,
0.4714247584,
0.4976550341,
0.1610451043,
0.5634793639,
0.2147579342,
-0.1825297326,
0.2442531735,
-0.6752272844,
-0.3148440421,
-0.499761045,
0.7293242216,
-0.1819033027,
-1.1631939411,
0.3395909667,
0.0031664867,
0.3032833636,
0.1949588358,
0.6171748042,
-0.2621259391,
0.8990154862,
0.5615913868,
-0.3024733961,
0.5301264524,
0.2132033557,
0.427798301,
-0.6934861541,
-0.2333487719,
-0.6689881086,
0.1051178798,
-0.5917689204,
-0.1073223054,
0.3528237939,
-0.1546104252,
-0.0573225543,
0.1850771904,
-0.097389631,
0.3258913755,
0.0369672142,
-0.2814751863,
0.275870204,
-0.1157302484,
0.1882732064,
-0.0315179899,
-0.3749960661,
-0.8121065497,
1.1469483376,
0.9247034192,
1.154370904,
0.6040604115,
0.5985928774,
0.1603501588,
0.3723839819,
-0.9152699709,
0.9687789679,
0.3190408349,
-0.9111520052,
-0.2620122433,
-0.591437757,
-1.2477778196,
0.3039521873,
-0.1775497049,
-1.135515213,
-0.424672842,
-0.0926611796,
-0.2283841968,
0.3100677729,
-0.6524896026,
0.4854776561,
-0.6288019419,
0.0387671813,
-0.233807236,
-0.6504439116,
0.8416525126,
-0.1608657092,
0.1850854903,
-0.0222073719,
0.1823003292,
0.8335849643,
-0.0559456907,
1.1362552643,
0.0468573347,
-0.3935414255,
0.4661121368,
0.2188083529,
0.4632332325,
0.0554113612,
0.0120357834,
0.1062639579,
-0.0096228309,
-0.0493691713,
-0.2797683477,
0.7831013799,
-0.4098489285,
-1.0335624218,
-0.4797992706,
-0.4223554134,
-0.3959181011,
-0.053183239,
-0.029659152,
0.3082552552,
-0.783059895,
0.5461989045,
0.8476251364,
-0.4448913038,
0.5248960853,
0.6896985173,
-0.4779872298,
-0.577229917,
0.5503944159,
-0.0368094519,
0.6439743638,
0.1695231348,
-0.0682777688,
-0.1808090508,
-1.027048707,
-0.0526664779,
-0.0888784006,
-0.7229190469,
-0.2454707325,
-0.8081463575,
-0.4216980338,
-0.4817205369,
0.1634376347,
-0.213606894,
-0.3118638694,
-0.0001437049,
-0.520660758,
0.354403317,
1.0684762001,
0.3605588078,
0.6396402121,
-0.7472802997,
-0.0141132884,
0.3365910649,
0.1169833392,
-0.0386773236,
-0.4128286541,
-0.1043890566,
-0.2276880294,
-0.5621367693,
-1.1194171906,
0.0988618731,
-0.1959959418,
0.7177301645,
0.5680609941,
0.1174114272,
0.2871735692,
-0.5426436663,
1.1814972162,
0.5788458586,
-0.5448820591,
0.4650441706,
-0.3005472422,
-0.1134463772,
0.5340228081,
0.3732311428,
-0.560933888,
-0.2370747924,
-0.613797009,
-0.7880173922,
0.3260958195,
0.2199908048,
0.5868797898,
-0.1054755375,
-0.0272747912,
-0.3031770587,
0.0199910793,
-0.8153983951,
-0.2634326816,
0.4324362278,
0.0777370557,
0.1822893918,
-0.7704119682,
-0.5983127952,
0.0500956289,
0.466077745,
0.2624443769,
0.0140352836,
-0.243846193,
-0.163635537,
0.1958335191,
0.5544707775,
0.6111138463,
0.4727247357,
-0.0494100749,
0.2341345996,
0.6658499837,
-0.6447157264,
0.2581411302,
-0.1977240592,
0.1024232507,
-0.3156337142,
0.4408021867,
0.6692733169,
0.4571734369,
-0.7473487854,
0.6175119877,
-0.4161976874,
-0.1479313672,
-0.3804461062,
0.0506769344,
0.1567142159,
-0.0530130267,
-0.0122734001,
-0.258775115,
0.123229906,
-0.6003440022,
-0.0979415849,
0.8451544046,
-0.3684933186,
-0.2137243897,
0.1040836573,
0.4564824104,
-0.2405540347,
0.1685510725,
0.2153225988,
-0.4415597022,
0.4008957446,
0.6712093949,
0.8969961405,
-0.3470554948,
-0.1918234825,
0.1118322313,
0.4492324293,
0.2743849754,
0.0975915715,
0.2244704664,
-0.6562834382,
-0.0953665823,
-0.4190386832,
-0.8601788282,
0.352458775,
-0.4221678972,
0.0038381272,
-0.6767321825,
-0.525398612,
-0.1178772748,
0.0435237512,
-0.1629496664,
-0.1323948503,
0.3125423193,
0.9910607338,
-0.5141435266,
0.5973415971,
0.6433623433,
-0.1422932297,
-0.3445611298,
-0.1445741206,
0.3492442667,
-0.5363306999,
0.4968669713,
-0.0229663663,
-0.4261323512,
-0.5121892691,
-0.5948177576,
-0.7186461687,
0.7154340148,
0.2973947525,
-0.6921855807,
0.159823969,
0.4639648199,
0.3692327142,
-0.2654889822,
0.3997087181,
0.7044661641,
0.3706675172,
-0.0889750943,
-0.9664440751,
-0.2064851075,
-0.252797544,
0.1081892774,
0.0099461023,
-0.8558673859,
0.3795634806,
0.1204754189,
-0.2891767621,
0.3022815287,
0.440194279,
0.4842685759,
0.2111814916,
0.5573288202,
0.5758767724,
0.3647165,
-0.1144070923,
1.2419707775,
-0.4087267816,
-0.0716867372,
1.0750780106,
-0.3602030575,
0.8266310096,
0.326208204,
-0.3194186985,
0.0651073009,
0.563598156,
0.1656342298,
0.0255635548,
0.6534555554,
-0.2791388333,
0.0535010807,
-0.0384949744,
-0.4433353841,
0.4885109961,
0.5283457041,
-0.3419962823,
0.0012958815,
-0.05808191,
0.5481001139,
-0.1561927497,
-0.167521283,
1.0311301947,
0.4299385548,
-0.4874554574,
0.3509561419,
0.0816966519,
0.8004867435,
-0.7183914185,
0.2104131281,
-0.2136819214,
-0.0361901112,
-0.1826752871,
-0.9677363038,
0.2711685598,
0.3283343017,
0.1279716939,
-0.1806889623,
0.9850050211,
-0.0460267924,
-0.1948903054,
0.2285236567,
0.4603059292,
0.2961398959,
0.1893242896,
-0.5085107684,
0.6418328881,
-0.1123531014,
-0.4851658642,
0.6089122295,
0.0118342722,
-0.0404030979,
0.7530737519,
0.4105495214,
0.0305837858,
0.178414613,
0.343996495,
0.8738027811,
-0.7724208236,
-0.0685925186,
-1.0723716021,
0.2482837886,
-0.3491448462,
-0.1429362297,
1.1697441339,
0.4652607143,
0.4474009871,
0.1884151846,
0.8050413132,
0.172008127,
0.3708796799,
-0.5644803047,
1.0362534523,
0.1115533859,
0.5456630588,
-0.5558465719,
-0.7131383419,
-0.2714216709,
0.1953004599,
-0.4622244239,
0.0457536466,
0.4734542668,
0.8146976233,
0.3722594082,
0.1501272917,
0.4667029083,
0.3298565447,
0.6770505905,
0.5770616531,
1.5660657883,
-0.2917258739,
0.6945043802,
-0.0581724793,
-0.0527915284,
-0.2277533561,
-0.8800891638,
-1.1404569149,
-0.2301002592,
-0.3984419107,
-0.4533197582,
0.1192385331,
0.6029965281,
0.5802381635,
-0.7612967491,
-0.4457223415,
0.3608723283,
0.1179535314,
0.539624095,
-0.1408015341,
-0.0186402965,
-0.2347597331,
-0.680531621,
0.6493787169,
0.1601281315,
0.3449439406,
-0.4333480597,
-0.0000748912,
-0.0453994982,
0.2365802974,
0.9250346422,
0.3751005232,
-0.6929906011,
-0.3177748919,
-0.2353558838,
-0.3905731142,
-0.1220339909,
0.702182889,
-0.1492508501,
0.0936628655,
0.5802201629,
0.7863749266,
0.1110877022,
-0.1867985874,
0.5882723927,
-0.5399363637,
0.0112671359,
0.1731760204,
0.5882116556,
0.4311722219,
-0.3771315217,
0.5389671922,
-0.0601659752,
-0.6343399882,
-1.2257502079,
0.5246652365,
-1.1661518812,
-0.058826685,
1.4575997591,
-0.1278296709,
-0.1263527721,
-0.1067911312,
-0.4306662083,
-0.2216979265,
-0.1350264996,
0.6635380387,
0.7854654193,
-0.0094099464,
-0.0521594472,
-0.8857094646,
0.4103817344,
0.1878000647,
-1.1500891447,
0.0892303064,
0.6059737206,
0.4033049643,
0.0301244669,
0.5807681084,
-0.5628099442,
0.043786671,
-0.3281965852,
-0.1898424029,
0.3252666295,
-0.3131147325,
-0.3617147505,
0.3982336521,
0.533028245,
-0.0644961447
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09282v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09282v4
|
Leveraging Large Language Models for Enhanced NLP Task Performance through Knowledge Distillation and Optimized Training Strategies
| 2024-02-14T16:10:45 | 2024-03-24T07:06:19 |
Yining Huang, Keke Tang, Meilian Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Emerging Large Language Models (LLMs) like GPT-4 have revolutionized Natural
Language Processing (NLP), showing potential in traditional tasks such as Named
Entity Recognition (NER). Our study explores a three-phase training strategy
that harnesses GPT-4's capabilities to enhance the BERT model's performance on
NER. Initially, GPT-4 annotates a subset of the CONLL2003 and additional BBC
dataset without fine-tuning. We then train BERT using a mix of original and
LLM-annotated data, analyzing the efficacy of LLM annotations against
traditional methods. The second phase involves comparative experiments with
different training regimens, assessing the synergy between distilled and
original data. We observe that sequential strategies, particularly a simple mix
of training first with distilled data followed by original data, significantly
boost performance. In the third phase, we investigate various data blending
techniques, including sigmoid and power decay functions, to optimize the
training process further. Our results indicate that a strategic mix of
distilled and original data markedly elevates the NER capabilities of BERT. Our
approach presents a scalable methodology that reduces manual annotation costs
and increases efficiency, making it especially pertinent in resource-limited
and closed-network environments. The study concludes that while the 'Simple
Mix' strategy yields the best results, understanding its underlying mechanisms
requires further research. Future work will also focus on refining prompt
designs and enhancing annotation selection processes, aiming to extend our
methodology to diverse NLP tasks.
|
[
-0.6072243452,
-0.5765911341,
0.5721222162,
0.1840820163,
-0.5051583648,
0.1011438817,
-0.486676991,
-0.6140240431,
0.0166376717,
0.3788882196,
-0.3416564167,
-0.2334094346,
-0.7869119644,
0.429913193,
-0.3165725172,
1.2314943075,
0.0748274326,
0.0737161636,
0.2195680737,
0.0630540848,
-0.465090543,
-0.7206618786,
-1.0240945816,
-0.7202413082,
0.652771771,
0.108529754,
0.3919291496,
0.32655406,
0.469841212,
0.2654695809,
-0.2027941644,
0.1933409721,
-0.4773936272,
0.3072967827,
-0.0087596215,
-0.3560684025,
-0.2965732217,
-0.0410780199,
0.6187773943,
0.6245008707,
-0.1479060501,
-0.0651230216,
0.434088856,
0.6051449776,
-0.3537604809,
0.3948363364,
-1.1070786715,
0.0577116758,
-0.4035566747,
-0.1450665444,
-0.2981276214,
-0.1245255321,
0.466804117,
-0.5291697979,
0.3307389915,
-0.0230416227,
0.8532837033,
0.3682858348,
-0.098147817,
-0.3045245111,
-0.8283077478,
0.6295127869,
-0.9449084401,
0.2982791066,
0.2731461227,
0.1811057627,
-0.2051275522,
-0.8114168644,
-0.7849677205,
-0.1058449596,
-0.0207442138,
-0.1649657041,
-0.0687050447,
0.1842184216,
0.6151391268,
0.2312299162,
-0.2360117137,
0.199664399,
-0.254907161,
-0.0744094476,
0.411545366,
-0.3020494878,
0.0705957264,
-0.0832852423,
-0.4194020033,
-0.0409547575,
-0.6114156842,
-0.1757849157,
0.3019874394,
0.5374569893,
0.3637287617,
0.4728648365,
-0.1214287579,
0.7220674157,
0.2770905495,
-0.3146745861,
0.4192848504,
-0.2785494626,
-0.2110989392,
0.2362315357,
0.6111647487,
0.0492915176,
0.1509397477,
-0.2852069139,
-0.5357766747,
-0.4102869928,
0.1643874496,
-0.822837472,
-0.5490102172,
-0.0626478195,
-0.1557276994,
-0.1312586963,
-0.3776780367,
-0.6775540113,
-0.4265061915,
-0.6819703579,
0.5771335959,
-0.7288181186,
-0.2694931328,
-0.0055413027,
-0.2703089714,
0.1404443979,
0.4651156366,
-1.3050708771,
0.4169598222,
0.7349696755,
0.8320376277,
-0.1155906767,
-0.1101676822,
-0.4116063118,
0.1533579528,
-0.0761771724,
0.4839200974,
-0.3932828009,
-0.0429539233,
-0.159754023,
-0.3037470281,
-0.0589391515,
-0.6281006932,
0.4984137118,
-0.7413161993,
0.003584492,
-0.4148944318,
-0.6602863073,
-0.3300049603,
0.2513352334,
-0.9714280963,
1.2240267992,
-0.0440323167,
-0.9905211329,
0.7348040938,
-0.6651027203,
-0.4909307063,
0.3170873225,
-0.1354001462,
-0.2427417189,
0.121237725,
0.5036582947,
0.7497599125,
-0.1454996169,
0.2548023164,
-0.1315265447,
-0.2061530501,
-0.0830029845,
-0.3703813851,
0.4859587252,
0.0140656959,
-0.6094074845,
-0.3213220239,
-0.7122550607,
-0.0516700186,
0.1217102259,
-0.5132815838,
-0.5981138945,
0.0640284196,
-0.1140483916,
0.1462571174,
0.2320615053,
-0.462642312,
0.2431083769,
-0.4018441439,
0.5579298139,
0.5624220967,
0.1071044356,
0.3593915999,
-0.1035701334,
0.197320953,
-0.1202663258,
-0.1260791272,
0.0567085929,
-0.5846433043,
-0.8273014426,
-0.3643354475,
0.5165442228,
0.3849591613,
-1.1212598085,
0.2816369236,
-0.3249310553,
-0.4043998718,
-0.4609922171,
0.2732515633,
0.1169685721,
0.5743796825,
0.5730375648,
-0.1484654099,
-0.530905962,
-0.8848167658,
0.0119826552,
-0.0596510246,
-0.0811285153,
0.0379923396,
0.4871514738,
-0.0300840512,
0.8819099665,
-0.2520252168,
-0.3640454412,
-0.5227670074,
0.4718213975,
0.4173308909,
0.2928511798,
0.4480279088,
-0.8837848306,
-0.392329663,
-0.0722435862,
-0.4689504504,
-0.0759177282,
-0.2235542238,
0.110234268,
0.1670475453,
0.3159268498,
-0.3994229138,
0.0560902804,
0.5675396323,
0.3256245852,
0.2508334517,
-0.1924969256,
0.0272513069,
-0.8636893034,
-0.0205681734,
0.0950896963,
-0.1733031124,
-0.7843145132,
-0.2436668128,
-0.0678604916,
0.0129090156,
-0.2935303152,
0.2853144407,
-0.7815809846,
0.0728179067,
-0.3689681888,
0.2018654644,
-0.047987964,
0.5148892403,
0.2011393458,
0.6215412021,
0.3460533321,
-0.5631874204,
0.2816209793,
0.1218508929,
-0.3504054546,
0.3531443179,
-0.7048045397,
0.346331507,
-0.1801939458,
0.2158931494,
-0.8616716266,
-0.1037523821,
0.0636393204,
-0.1110706925,
0.7197241783,
-0.3240627944,
-0.7916641831,
-0.3262763917,
-0.124355264,
0.1832132936,
0.42170614,
-0.5576488972,
0.7905337214,
0.335103631,
-0.3672391772,
-0.5695379972,
-0.6990245581,
0.2896883786,
-0.4448951483,
-0.3614190221,
0.6337774396,
0.2411612719,
0.0605719201,
-0.1051981971,
-0.2244223505,
-0.180710122,
0.1094693393,
0.0901461169,
0.2316276878,
0.122918196,
0.1705438346,
0.0600762405,
0.0123736756,
-0.0288417488,
-0.3660301864,
0.6198627949,
0.0727633238,
-0.1612207592,
-0.3850746155,
0.1675702184,
0.1390224546,
-0.1923357993,
0.6957631111,
0.783103168,
-0.4570228159,
-0.3107094467,
-0.7932147384,
-0.3406835496,
-0.4456063509,
0.3738892078,
-0.3131670058,
-0.9728342295,
0.2939016223,
-0.2236566097,
0.3323300183,
0.2500081658,
0.5359762311,
-0.0700418055,
0.6284624934,
0.5519699454,
-0.2836506963,
0.6176579595,
-0.1886360943,
0.4459929466,
-0.9822748303,
-0.2375810295,
-0.291639477,
-0.5520695448,
-0.431601882,
-0.5486154556,
0.374058187,
0.2500097454,
0.0150091685,
0.3974245787,
-0.4967881441,
0.3928365111,
0.603267014,
0.1680759788,
0.2889094651,
0.0421813838,
-0.1748680472,
-0.1399736702,
-0.6803345084,
-0.4393115938,
1.2606879473,
0.404086113,
0.5868100524,
-0.0906558037,
1.1185628176,
0.0448088013,
0.2617065012,
-0.600899756,
0.6173256636,
0.0294988323,
-0.6652937531,
-0.4082866609,
-0.4443192184,
-0.8394247293,
0.3475772142,
-0.3900127411,
-0.623499155,
-0.0452612489,
0.2554777861,
-0.3314957023,
0.2831836641,
-0.7747665644,
0.4683979452,
-0.4050159454,
-0.1427914649,
0.0168793891,
-0.6218848825,
0.2189850807,
-0.4943157732,
0.0130918613,
-0.165653497,
-0.0233447645,
0.7764145732,
-0.1298543066,
0.7283117175,
-0.4413952827,
-0.1502661407,
0.0606921203,
-0.2890556753,
0.7538393736,
0.0930172056,
-0.0880017132,
0.4111854434,
-0.3042919338,
-0.090669781,
-0.5590003729,
0.610562861,
-0.6003544331,
-0.5361524224,
-0.3795652092,
-0.4617033899,
-0.3357527554,
0.3369450569,
0.2458010316,
0.3075957,
0.0129039008,
0.2145835608,
0.8188880086,
0.023256246,
0.698143065,
0.2427580655,
0.0083876653,
-0.3972478807,
0.5519725084,
0.2497940212,
0.3405944109,
0.5116733909,
-0.0725006685,
-0.3902058005,
-1.0978677273,
-0.1420337856,
0.1461485773,
-0.6123652458,
-0.1882516593,
-0.7732531428,
-0.2137084901,
-0.2332126051,
0.2221556306,
-0.2487619966,
-0.3212581575,
-0.2413949966,
0.0125340214,
0.3768569827,
0.6173560023,
-0.1106474623,
0.3142513335,
-0.5512898564,
0.3368318081,
0.3918165863,
0.1712067872,
-0.0016743342,
-0.3997846842,
-0.1981061399,
0.0565726198,
-0.1908130795,
-0.8739002943,
0.3723348379,
0.4385756254,
0.6862493157,
0.0258471891,
-0.1141488478,
0.6750287414,
-0.8702822328,
0.6387652159,
0.1500401944,
-0.8771073818,
0.6043950915,
-0.3341289461,
0.0704143643,
0.7511430383,
0.5770932436,
-0.2512928247,
-0.2550210655,
-0.4315818846,
-1.2418223619,
0.6361413002,
0.4529595375,
-0.0029695157,
0.02859376,
0.4101314843,
0.1039048359,
0.4089779556,
-0.8560672402,
-0.2141157985,
0.0822082013,
-0.038166333,
0.0155084552,
-0.1708728969,
-0.1477987468,
-0.2759255767,
0.82345891,
-0.1133929789,
0.2174203992,
0.1473602355,
-0.0755898729,
0.4288337231,
0.1691582352,
0.1041820496,
0.5550800562,
-0.2544571459,
0.0430319645,
0.3207319677,
-0.5910453796,
0.0298502669,
0.5965815783,
-0.1194404364,
0.2395272106,
0.3621530831,
0.9090983272,
0.3174138069,
-0.251044929,
0.3190973699,
-0.0923728719,
-0.3205960989,
-0.168921262,
0.1300846934,
0.1323147267,
0.5557467937,
0.6058621407,
-0.0895648673,
0.2881617546,
-0.2416922301,
0.1347886026,
0.3319541812,
0.108345367,
-0.2188758105,
0.5367399454,
0.1720777303,
0.0543465093,
0.612585783,
-0.3028714061,
-0.4906423688,
0.2136874497,
0.4325219095,
0.7679181695,
-0.1170422733,
0.0621892288,
0.279066056,
0.369197458,
-0.3590094149,
0.1355814338,
-0.1294295639,
-0.7301821709,
-0.692895472,
-0.7705944777,
-0.3253698051,
0.4205588102,
-0.6721578836,
0.3447192311,
-0.3951908648,
-0.4377550781,
0.3284108341,
0.0854484588,
-1.0157803297,
0.0713077039,
0.4848153889,
0.6549561024,
-0.6974788308,
0.9322890043,
0.5885201097,
-0.2745405138,
-1.0094473362,
0.1189915538,
-0.0297496095,
-0.6882697344,
0.9066501856,
0.2353679687,
0.2011518329,
0.1779962778,
-0.2363275886,
-0.9773572087,
1.1424322128,
0.3775420189,
-0.9566893578,
-0.2875788212,
0.0272715725,
0.4922527671,
-0.2689212859,
0.1260447651,
0.7691292167,
0.3949866295,
0.211893782,
-1.1078475714,
-0.0057879537,
-0.0489945449,
0.3625541329,
0.4431866109,
-0.1615622044,
0.6587120891,
-0.1178361624,
-0.2329523265,
-0.2817096412,
0.6019756198,
0.2721554637,
0.0528229252,
0.7073023915,
0.672757864,
0.9497678876,
-0.268273294,
0.6830853224,
-0.1874951422,
0.3185992241,
1.3924289942,
-0.5564442873,
0.8656054735,
0.6227391958,
-0.1882009357,
0.3298233747,
0.564848423,
-0.1064022332,
0.8018040061,
0.3184881508,
-0.343921721,
0.0804241523,
0.0844895318,
-0.2703861892,
0.3908838332,
0.2890483141,
-0.4019158781,
-0.3743728995,
0.2097163945,
0.2052525878,
-0.3161770701,
-0.1257907748,
1.0204496384,
0.0079681352,
-0.5372741818,
0.6137171388,
-0.2462015599,
0.837684691,
-0.7048334479,
-0.1082207486,
0.0385808907,
0.0230791103,
-0.0336393863,
-0.6690450311,
0.0711110458,
0.0553641096,
-0.1517626494,
-0.4128035009,
0.6392555237,
-0.574914515,
-0.2941842973,
0.2942810953,
0.2895051837,
0.1581106931,
-0.2255078703,
-0.7119311094,
0.0563725568,
0.0534416847,
-0.257122308,
0.3898949623,
0.7854039073,
0.2493351549,
0.3866693974,
0.64693892,
0.4418288171,
0.0576591156,
0.2236159891,
1.1529946327,
-0.4214491546,
-0.1936299652,
-1.0240350962,
0.374751389,
-0.3249686062,
-0.137662679,
0.654103756,
0.3637811542,
0.9398949742,
0.1604441106,
0.8749830127,
-0.1283055693,
0.4596348107,
-0.642922163,
0.39859128,
-0.2090525478,
0.3620185852,
-0.3996373415,
-1.1847889423,
-0.0920816138,
0.4871284962,
-0.3626635969,
0.167473793,
0.6358444691,
0.4094418287,
0.2206235975,
0.1232064739,
0.0946499929,
0.1197210029,
0.5600349903,
0.6021978855,
0.5834120512,
-0.1919698715,
0.2894545794,
-0.4205259383,
-0.3045704663,
-0.0554573052,
-1.1550097466,
-0.9944852591,
-0.6259346604,
-0.2293146998,
-0.0109445602,
0.106480211,
0.8591416478,
0.7549653649,
-0.5748104453,
0.2270534635,
-0.1091637686,
-0.3475687206,
-0.1411540806,
-0.1459130049,
0.2263526171,
-0.6386937499,
-0.7859290242,
0.4182509184,
0.2304516733,
0.1489502341,
-0.1557131708,
0.3035100996,
-0.3260936737,
-0.2225717455,
0.7217032313,
-0.0692887977,
-0.711611867,
-0.1268622726,
-0.2882809341,
0.1221825108,
-0.0723773316,
0.6844582558,
-0.7296112776,
0.5427304506,
0.3315130174,
0.939375639,
0.6621012092,
-0.0446698628,
0.6113945842,
-0.9284660816,
0.0912142247,
0.5488973856,
0.4273790121,
0.5736225247,
-0.4270783365,
0.5827863812,
0.0485197268,
-0.7080947757,
-0.6823030114,
-0.1305275112,
-0.9167356491,
-0.0605987646,
1.2800526619,
-0.1485151201,
0.1974788457,
-0.1805946231,
-0.1971284747,
0.2047771066,
-0.5434033871,
0.5999638438,
0.8881616592,
-0.2637173533,
-0.0415987857,
-0.9627149701,
0.7492984533,
0.181731835,
-0.7048160434,
-0.0334439278,
0.4456456304,
0.3622058332,
0.17326276,
0.60215801,
0.0535942428,
-0.2829397619,
-0.2413294315,
0.0704084188,
-0.1171710491,
-0.3262521327,
-0.3067003191,
0.0862083137,
0.1378165185,
-0.141682595
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09269v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09269v1
|
Personalized Large Language Models
| 2024-02-14T15:55:30 | 2024-02-14T15:55:30 |
Stanisław Woźniak, Bartłomiej Koptyra, Arkadiusz Janz, Przemysław Kazienko, Jan Kocoń
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have significantly advanced Natural Language
Processing (NLP) tasks in recent years. However, their universal nature poses
limitations in scenarios requiring personalized responses, such as
recommendation systems and chatbots. This paper investigates methods to
personalize LLMs, comparing fine-tuning and zero-shot reasoning approaches on
subjective tasks. Results demonstrate that personalized fine-tuning improves
model reasoning compared to non-personalized models. Experiments on datasets
for emotion recognition and hate speech detection show consistent performance
gains with personalized methods across different LLM architectures. These
findings underscore the importance of personalization for enhancing LLM
capabilities in subjective text perception tasks.
|
[
-0.3764286339,
-0.8908625245,
0.8041443825,
-0.01108348,
-0.064136371,
0.0078464719,
-0.5976058245,
-0.4859661758,
-0.0474795252,
0.7812718749,
-0.3630242646,
-0.8152135611,
-0.4115175903,
0.166401282,
-0.2665095329,
1.0063747168,
0.2121295333,
-0.0504147373,
-0.1522238106,
-0.1417696178,
-0.5610055923,
-0.6965979934,
-0.8380612731,
-0.5467872024,
0.8354230523,
0.5694125891,
0.6384265423,
0.4846693873,
0.5215826631,
0.3984909356,
-0.280641526,
0.0860226452,
-0.3460375369,
0.4929844141,
-0.490272522,
-0.5237839818,
-0.3600046039,
-0.2689866424,
0.3301330805,
0.6617931128,
-0.0157607235,
0.2020567805,
-0.1868891716,
0.6823682189,
-0.5185303688,
-0.0176516175,
-0.6951493621,
0.0747890472,
-0.2074718028,
-0.32372576,
-0.5088630319,
-0.1765387654,
0.2958508432,
-0.4145217836,
0.1591921151,
0.1986189336,
0.4846336544,
0.3338494003,
-0.423945725,
-0.3883307874,
-1.169826746,
1.1122591496,
-1.1062942743,
0.2208458483,
0.2550268471,
0.3362036645,
-0.1310751438,
-0.227913335,
-0.3825429082,
-0.5343889594,
0.1252456307,
-0.1881544739,
-0.2816840708,
0.2466966063,
0.2131176442,
0.3964149654,
-0.4281669557,
0.5422756672,
0.0284058899,
-0.0464549214,
0.7856062651,
0.3476559222,
0.2966503501,
-0.0482764393,
0.1378258616,
0.2119401395,
-0.4299405217,
0.0331119075,
0.5436474085,
0.4577952027,
-0.011486331,
0.6999741793,
-0.801435113,
1.0458471775,
0.2356986701,
-0.3514152169,
0.1237544045,
-0.0732627288,
-0.5255653858,
0.0100465016,
0.6756358147,
0.3330747783,
0.6262711883,
-0.3784210086,
-0.1001104489,
-0.2243575007,
0.118686758,
-0.621350348,
0.0375986435,
0.4254322052,
-0.4608539939,
-0.428501904,
-0.4685031772,
-0.3881329,
-0.5642641187,
-0.7630087137,
0.2421151847,
-0.3737398684,
0.1792330295,
0.5164999962,
0.0054239025,
0.0048202444,
0.5689827204,
-1.0974649191,
0.1925991178,
0.6734010577,
0.6924650669,
-0.2124238163,
0.0311224945,
-0.4463765323,
0.1409714371,
-0.1870194525,
1.0544928312,
-0.7841353416,
-0.1529612541,
0.084409833,
-0.3015232682,
0.4169152677,
-0.7240633368,
0.7199650407,
-0.4409734011,
0.2416970879,
-0.3420621753,
-0.6394125223,
-0.2940293252,
0.4115608335,
-0.1123391539,
0.6383105516,
-0.0614955015,
-0.5703341365,
0.2620169222,
-0.6820088029,
-0.4535779655,
0.175526157,
0.0997762606,
-0.2251941711,
0.4282517731,
0.1729160398,
0.9436799288,
-0.3168866336,
0.4326204956,
-0.6933886409,
-0.3286273181,
0.2666124403,
-0.2131380439,
0.1407835186,
0.3908087313,
-0.1918157786,
0.4761854112,
-0.907289505,
0.0060308473,
0.1212029457,
-0.5562469363,
-0.496988833,
0.3342361152,
0.1017248482,
0.0777429193,
0.4791465104,
-0.6299870014,
0.1407023072,
-0.8755429387,
0.4198000133,
0.880929172,
-0.1704121083,
0.4982521832,
-0.3671596348,
0.1932367235,
0.1708670706,
-0.1902662665,
-0.2902811468,
-0.3036137223,
-1.0116013288,
-0.037675906,
0.0778051689,
0.5826002955,
-0.2773044705,
0.566315949,
0.0502919629,
-0.3190568388,
-0.094372116,
0.3437446058,
0.3322266936,
0.3480930924,
0.2403977364,
-0.0921541676,
-0.5010210872,
-1.1143649817,
-0.6744621396,
0.0732918829,
-0.3680531383,
0.7182596922,
0.1970028579,
-0.2991532683,
0.882214129,
-0.7598622441,
-0.2614057362,
-0.2646661997,
-0.0208259691,
0.3013294935,
0.1267789006,
0.5105453134,
-0.5486607552,
-0.6709079146,
0.3184658587,
-0.6729850173,
-0.2745919526,
-0.1782108098,
0.1362582594,
0.0906063989,
0.2919000089,
-0.2478236705,
0.1210301667,
0.389760077,
-0.5172301531,
0.3497298062,
-0.2723513842,
0.0626696646,
-0.9904945493,
-0.1911628991,
0.4621701539,
-0.6332621574,
-0.8930196762,
0.0440370366,
-0.4821244776,
0.0920841396,
-0.4920873642,
0.893432498,
-0.1872660965,
-0.0800398588,
-0.5286771059,
0.2281917781,
-0.328766942,
0.3955951929,
0.0587071776,
0.409497261,
0.4622575343,
-0.6914053559,
0.4805240631,
0.2400999814,
-0.3442908823,
0.7456389666,
-0.8514655828,
0.3971526623,
-0.2343660891,
-0.1020965278,
-0.7875381112,
-0.3896165192,
-0.0621404648,
-0.2025495023,
0.1352131069,
0.1914147586,
-0.3663303256,
-0.0492366254,
-0.3235290945,
-0.0103538167,
0.3500855565,
-0.5057582259,
0.4732382298,
0.183426857,
-0.206965521,
-0.1392173618,
-0.5116491318,
0.332672745,
-0.3273124397,
-0.5094460249,
0.266531229,
-0.3938069344,
-0.5603960752,
-0.4778314233,
0.157438606,
-0.0421595871,
0.2399101853,
0.5125564933,
-0.0356401578,
-0.202728942,
0.294138819,
-0.0441256911,
-0.0429408215,
-0.3025494814,
0.0013319963,
0.6573881507,
-0.2155692577,
-0.0438120104,
-0.6035073996,
0.2474505007,
0.3470456898,
-0.1289429069,
0.7189614177,
0.6234087944,
-0.2393061817,
-0.1935595423,
-0.952339232,
0.0305775627,
-0.5392314196,
0.2635513246,
-0.4357966483,
-1.522043705,
0.2711920142,
-0.0891004875,
0.0512249805,
0.1718904972,
1.1705887318,
-0.2562122047,
1.2313979864,
0.6692070961,
-0.3341731429,
0.6192868948,
0.2322481573,
0.3977537751,
-0.8691921234,
-0.1542860717,
-0.6097401977,
-0.5279050469,
-0.480524987,
-0.0674670562,
0.0325317457,
-0.0511820912,
-0.6786019802,
0.0417101532,
-0.734393239,
0.6541598439,
0.5839202404,
0.1193158776,
0.5474005342,
0.0218861662,
0.1821193546,
-0.0839229897,
-0.2330153137,
-0.8187986016,
1.0320321321,
0.5189127922,
0.7944223881,
0.1274871528,
0.6214164495,
0.3524061441,
0.173433736,
-1.0644960403,
0.5465545654,
-0.6040620804,
-0.7083829045,
-0.3461892605,
-0.3551266789,
-0.712983489,
0.1554386914,
-0.3336972892,
-1.0698633194,
-0.107604906,
0.2956605852,
-0.5301485658,
0.2572245896,
-0.7795373201,
0.42318362,
-0.1440608352,
0.0093562584,
-0.3754157722,
-0.2372477353,
0.4211123288,
-0.1513074636,
0.1638490856,
-0.4237562716,
-0.1550650448,
0.4723926783,
-0.0465308987,
0.9567319155,
-0.0011817613,
-0.0177552179,
-0.1255793124,
0.2114106268,
0.4621773064,
0.0414170064,
-0.3697176576,
0.0569090955,
-0.1198760346,
-0.1924563795,
-0.468647778,
1.0858410597,
-0.7310137153,
-0.8725750446,
-0.1807577163,
-0.6624754667,
-0.4387770891,
0.295488447,
0.0239034127,
0.1297405809,
-0.2960863411,
0.4402921796,
0.6889423728,
-0.7682747841,
0.4671267569,
0.7630317807,
-0.145818159,
-0.1405509859,
0.6972169876,
-0.0887900293,
0.0759797767,
0.6047329307,
0.4617618024,
-0.0361934006,
-0.833307445,
-0.0283368453,
0.1792805195,
-0.6229273677,
-0.2234259993,
-0.848721683,
0.0832149386,
-0.4346467257,
-0.3712408245,
-0.2535562515,
-0.2389992177,
-0.5535939336,
0.0040514488,
0.4467051625,
0.6829633117,
0.273746103,
0.5122049451,
-0.6312252283,
0.5904774666,
0.3492495418,
0.4494167864,
-0.1015033945,
-0.6829918027,
-0.1099182665,
-0.0330882408,
-0.3477291167,
-0.5566265583,
0.4571891129,
0.2442905456,
0.1816151738,
0.5222331285,
-0.1617136598,
0.4583690166,
-0.7157251239,
0.7335175276,
0.207439363,
-1.0505851507,
0.6001548767,
-0.5862190127,
0.5499791503,
0.31755808,
0.3141721487,
-0.6433674097,
-0.3223017752,
-0.2332919687,
-0.4834100008,
0.5635847449,
-0.0012677199,
0.5737749338,
0.1529234797,
0.8420415521,
0.0023718798,
0.2049917281,
-0.5764213204,
-0.1639521122,
0.2519340217,
-0.339195013,
-0.4734475613,
-0.4266681373,
0.1153640598,
-0.4509375989,
0.3611990511,
-0.322461307,
0.0086792512,
0.0980397314,
0.1592649221,
-0.1205167472,
0.6020108461,
0.6459256411,
0.3308668137,
-0.3252565563,
-0.0449140072,
0.4647139013,
0.0535529852,
0.1176034585,
-0.3628432155,
-0.2430927306,
-0.0145861218,
0.4067525566,
1.0282796621,
0.3449583054,
-0.7358778119,
0.3471716642,
-0.034029562,
-0.1775103509,
-0.2310702503,
0.3803954124,
0.3651753664,
0.4731115103,
-0.172780171,
-0.0010704577,
0.3612369299,
-0.6623475552,
-0.2907337248,
0.5995907187,
-0.2566404641,
-0.4194965065,
0.6600517035,
0.050076779,
-0.5497173071,
0.1677183211,
0.1285619885,
-0.2498788685,
0.2782432735,
0.4658249617,
0.9799813032,
-0.1952559948,
0.4119793177,
0.2282343507,
-0.0992836058,
-0.077310659,
0.0521496162,
-0.1236644015,
-0.9825300574,
-0.3784338534,
-0.8830065727,
-0.6463782191,
0.2266614735,
-0.3356072009,
0.4376703501,
-0.79387784,
-0.1958442926,
0.4670929909,
0.0293154959,
-0.742127955,
0.6206775904,
0.4413342178,
0.5555292368,
-0.369104296,
0.8048860431,
0.6592522264,
0.0188859385,
-0.4747393429,
-0.3185230494,
-0.0321661793,
-0.6272218823,
0.8084808588,
-0.1762605906,
-0.0082975216,
-0.2128876448,
-0.6678438187,
-0.6499899626,
0.6995735765,
0.487283349,
-1.0686944723,
-0.0859768614,
0.2571069002,
0.9623400569,
-0.3634987473,
0.274697572,
0.7365689874,
0.4182964265,
0.1279173195,
-0.7762751579,
-0.2188272029,
0.2274075747,
0.276948899,
0.0527930222,
-0.7094548345,
0.652309835,
-0.2487590015,
0.1625879407,
-0.0199424513,
0.4776239991,
0.1564262956,
0.3237054944,
0.4801990986,
0.5512475371,
0.6349254847,
0.0329716206,
1.1864993572,
-0.2242975831,
0.2098144293,
1.3707593679,
-0.4897833765,
1.0048803091,
0.1994166821,
-0.1269543171,
0.3757256866,
0.5785617232,
-0.063871488,
0.2748998106,
0.2438609451,
-0.3321865499,
-0.4875567853,
-0.1866065413,
-0.0266057402,
0.5196216106,
0.0825230181,
-0.4278669357,
-0.1805221736,
0.176427573,
0.0670670196,
0.2450575382,
-0.3462162018,
1.0464327335,
0.1971589476,
-0.3997019529,
0.3368545473,
0.4735494852,
1.1460729837,
-0.3230041564,
0.3618460894,
-0.2031799108,
0.3444995582,
-0.4529909194,
-0.7520450354,
0.5007987022,
0.2580388188,
-0.4145459235,
-0.3882835507,
1.0544326305,
-0.2176391035,
-0.4427211881,
0.288456589,
0.2852404118,
0.0236974936,
-0.4308805466,
-0.5521163344,
-0.0113645904,
0.1115504503,
-0.5764530897,
0.5207477808,
0.2295775563,
0.1068108305,
0.9627535343,
0.7724251151,
0.2137428969,
-0.1373587549,
0.2149342895,
0.8184607625,
-0.9565396905,
-0.2089775205,
-1.1225042343,
0.1793815345,
0.1394872665,
-0.3929303586,
0.903018117,
0.4561244249,
0.798958838,
-0.3134197295,
0.7562496066,
0.4076238871,
0.8246789575,
-0.4107889831,
0.3811161518,
-0.6240597367,
0.2806690335,
-0.2460633367,
-0.9494434595,
-0.5535128117,
0.4608062506,
-0.6762779951,
0.0794553012,
0.2279510796,
0.5938238502,
0.0760368258,
-0.0595940948,
0.8213067651,
0.4007054567,
0.5909792781,
0.551392436,
0.735935986,
0.0155480159,
0.0104456544,
-0.2723227143,
-0.0673946515,
-0.2568168938,
-0.7733088136,
-1.2925714254,
-0.3869418502,
-0.3918619752,
0.0397020355,
-0.0679327846,
0.9660351872,
0.7571519613,
-0.9390066862,
-0.2258712351,
0.0377851576,
0.1189941615,
0.4339936674,
-0.2481970936,
-0.2337050587,
-0.5034406781,
-0.8370309472,
0.3940090537,
0.7336484194,
-0.0896357968,
-0.331397593,
0.0106145963,
0.0307384171,
0.5169999003,
1.0468651056,
0.1778352708,
-0.918779254,
-0.5053146482,
-0.05489875,
0.1238028258,
0.1407355219,
0.7661868334,
-0.6738948822,
0.4171141684,
0.6444344521,
0.4227738678,
0.5174313784,
-0.0037942592,
0.5021702647,
-0.5563854575,
0.2275624275,
0.3161610365,
0.2213856429,
0.4161463082,
-0.6457207799,
0.2856135964,
-0.1578993946,
-0.7990281582,
-0.8718541861,
0.253488034,
-1.1057350636,
-0.3837236464,
1.2941735983,
-0.0877568573,
0.0470603779,
-0.1231086031,
-0.4184468091,
-0.0301561523,
-0.4448883533,
0.7089067101,
0.9399768114,
-0.292748332,
-0.1442651004,
-0.5791367888,
0.3859627247,
0.4413666129,
-1.007566452,
-0.163006708,
0.3061375916,
0.4973940551,
-0.0130341752,
0.4936491549,
0.2137691379,
-0.2316652238,
-0.6397327185,
0.0314498842,
-0.0039934791,
-0.0961712599,
-0.6066220403,
0.1995539963,
0.2828318179,
0.3005979359
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09267v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09267v2
|
Self-Alignment for Factuality: Mitigating Hallucinations in LLMs via Self-Evaluation
| 2024-02-14T15:52:42 | 2024-06-11T12:22:14 |
Xiaoying Zhang, Baolin Peng, Ye Tian, Jingyan Zhou, Lifeng Jin, Linfeng Song, Haitao Mi, Helen Meng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Despite showing increasingly human-like abilities, large language models
(LLMs) often struggle with factual inaccuracies, i.e. "hallucinations", even
when they hold relevant knowledge. To address these hallucinations, current
approaches typically necessitate high-quality human factuality annotations. In
this work, we explore Self-Alignment for Factuality, where we leverage the
self-evaluation capability of an LLM to provide training signals that steer the
model towards factuality. Specifically, we incorporate Self-Eval, a
self-evaluation component, to prompt an LLM to validate the factuality of its
own generated responses solely based on its internal knowledge. Additionally,
we design Self-Knowledge Tuning (SK-Tuning) to augment the LLM's
self-evaluation ability by improving the model's confidence estimation and
calibration. We then utilize these self-annotated responses to fine-tune the
model via Direct Preference Optimization algorithm. We show that the proposed
self-alignment approach substantially enhances factual accuracy over Llama
family models across three key knowledge-intensive tasks on TruthfulQA and
BioGEN.
|
[
-0.2233683765,
-0.578854382,
0.8380556703,
0.2118128538,
-0.1997366846,
0.1818089783,
-0.2429594994,
-0.3755892515,
0.4314646721,
0.6794238687,
-0.6457796097,
-0.5101543665,
-0.4268400967,
0.3503012061,
-0.1608792841,
1.2069932222,
0.1657201648,
0.023780439,
-0.3673626184,
-0.1951865852,
-0.5927585363,
-0.6323840618,
-0.1230705082,
-0.2663773,
0.6356116533,
0.4046638608,
0.8008927107,
1.0085349083,
0.5216152072,
0.2438745648,
0.2897626758,
0.4199169278,
-0.6316478848,
0.2936756313,
-0.3878640234,
-0.3454428911,
-0.4668415189,
0.0215480886,
0.2888563871,
0.3877119422,
-0.2031778693,
0.4375751019,
0.0525105968,
0.6883480549,
-0.5581929684,
-0.1302577108,
-0.6817908287,
0.2211791277,
0.078123495,
-0.4361136854,
-0.2192510366,
-0.4746604562,
0.0387811363,
-0.4971048832,
0.3059377968,
0.2605131269,
0.7628535628,
0.9725993276,
-0.2929347157,
-0.3531444669,
-0.7081227899,
0.5521868467,
-0.8443702459,
0.4464983344,
0.3097729981,
0.0749116316,
-0.199682489,
-0.1970022768,
-0.7315812707,
-0.3804214001,
-0.148638308,
0.1004458219,
0.168448627,
0.1085899919,
0.2930081487,
0.2468260974,
-0.6216169596,
0.233057037,
-0.297224462,
-0.5714045763,
0.7247805595,
0.2176113129,
0.1476231515,
-0.3570258617,
-0.5472904444,
0.1241753027,
-0.514641881,
-0.3157598376,
0.5096899867,
0.2968256474,
0.147988379,
0.8458503485,
-0.3551185131,
0.6055500507,
0.5365194678,
-0.4625391662,
0.1939792037,
-0.2504439354,
-0.1181256324,
0.6120926142,
0.5933554769,
0.5405586958,
0.0846024528,
-0.2069053203,
-0.2614228725,
0.2976690531,
0.6961467266,
-0.6316174269,
-0.1618210226,
0.3144959509,
-0.3348394036,
-0.5775314569,
-0.1970985383,
-0.8735584021,
-0.6808702946,
-0.6390148997,
0.8231400251,
-0.2858816981,
-0.0352683365,
0.2344233394,
0.3203863502,
0.1302784234,
0.2851001322,
-1.1113698483,
0.0829598829,
0.5656707287,
0.6590607762,
-0.3050179482,
-0.2477705479,
-0.4784506559,
0.3436410129,
-0.4304584265,
0.8330768347,
-0.2767439783,
-0.1335751861,
-0.2778635323,
-0.2375882268,
-0.0885460973,
-0.4475002885,
0.6564062834,
-0.2642215788,
0.1783204973,
-0.5222411156,
-0.5415757298,
-0.1526018679,
0.3503054976,
-0.324590534,
0.9818229675,
-0.1435887516,
-0.7733981013,
0.353316009,
-0.4388022423,
-0.4360318482,
-0.0989448205,
-0.4551635385,
-0.3610713482,
0.2961198092,
0.3318761587,
0.4577052295,
0.1228029877,
0.3713368475,
-0.4167350531,
-0.3021751642,
0.2804178894,
-0.3886112571,
0.3151741326,
0.2215845734,
-0.635646522,
0.2475059628,
-0.8553262353,
-0.2255008817,
-0.0294217151,
-0.1357548237,
-0.1450761706,
-0.0401733629,
-0.6643021703,
0.2517952323,
0.5423541069,
-0.4357135892,
0.3556960821,
-0.4620952904,
-0.0592367649,
0.9578355551,
-0.0934119225,
0.0825717002,
-0.4734649956,
0.3432030082,
-0.0108344238,
0.2544061542,
0.18457672,
-0.1031925082,
-0.9673101902,
-0.3415494561,
0.3043544888,
0.4742864966,
-0.4034342766,
0.9481390715,
-0.308408618,
-0.3428624272,
-0.8913427591,
0.3904972374,
0.2057283521,
0.9894685745,
0.4393573403,
-0.2004618347,
-0.5878973007,
-1.0848021507,
-0.1092563793,
-0.2604752183,
0.3120002151,
0.0842066854,
0.361104399,
-0.446392715,
0.9748740792,
-0.5460593104,
-0.4683561921,
0.1574631929,
0.2596681118,
-0.0539859831,
0.4025329053,
0.268481195,
-0.3873091042,
-0.0434725173,
0.0020346404,
-0.9893772006,
-0.3221419752,
-0.2578768134,
-0.2057580203,
0.4572191238,
0.1753244549,
-0.6133589745,
0.4729861021,
0.411082983,
-0.2590567768,
0.819631815,
-0.3494993746,
0.2636471391,
-0.7904025316,
-0.0904543698,
-0.2296929061,
-0.2553214431,
-0.3347057402,
-0.2070887983,
-0.0479688086,
0.3326111436,
0.0582490191,
0.3993458748,
-0.3472362757,
-0.1468977183,
-0.4533156455,
0.2473576665,
-0.0158277526,
0.4816009998,
0.0893416852,
0.8122389913,
0.4188275933,
-0.412391901,
0.2355651259,
0.3446060419,
-0.3012875915,
0.4371225238,
-0.1996841729,
0.2960889935,
-0.0802735388,
-0.0191703811,
-0.8451567292,
-0.3377856612,
0.4264589548,
-0.2796201706,
0.3006424904,
0.0789202824,
-0.3460667729,
-0.205522716,
-0.3275626302,
0.2517791688,
0.3567467928,
-0.828720212,
0.7844485044,
0.181535542,
0.0465845093,
-0.7473391294,
-0.3890541494,
0.2164559066,
-0.3596695065,
-0.4926912189,
0.1732435971,
-0.3049986362,
-0.0603820831,
-0.1522789448,
-0.4632738829,
0.4600847661,
0.0098066404,
0.3219199181,
0.4417181909,
-0.2186348289,
0.3278622627,
0.1082898602,
-0.0489830524,
0.2673444152,
-0.229579255,
0.4032854438,
-0.1609638333,
-0.4785122573,
-0.4263244867,
-0.1174877062,
0.4588636756,
-0.1239359155,
0.5837147236,
0.4326793253,
-0.3371170461,
-0.0337543003,
-1.2397062778,
-0.3752906322,
-0.4683203995,
0.1280955374,
-0.3501809239,
-0.8708618283,
0.3638120294,
-0.0516065471,
-0.2672238052,
0.5106381178,
0.8198490739,
-0.312846005,
1.0217673779,
0.5012947321,
-0.0487986207,
-0.0856913924,
0.1497987211,
0.3693051934,
-0.9016668797,
-0.325865835,
-0.2108391523,
-0.1772166193,
-0.4634211659,
-0.3641602099,
0.4001031518,
-0.2594433725,
-0.1392884552,
0.0893285498,
-0.6634218693,
0.4690314233,
0.2709787488,
0.2545306981,
0.4713045359,
-0.0025693774,
-0.2369972914,
-0.2047702223,
-0.6138885617,
-0.825366497,
1.0420629978,
0.3930124342,
0.876134336,
-0.0944857076,
0.8201654553,
0.3175762594,
0.2949829102,
-0.6401438713,
0.469255209,
0.0887393504,
-0.7123950124,
-0.4109996855,
-0.5154196024,
-0.4617863894,
0.0974562988,
-0.4977477491,
-0.767717123,
0.2740580142,
0.3011959791,
-0.7491026521,
0.1270252168,
-0.4266012013,
0.7944800258,
-0.8431143165,
-0.3775049448,
-0.4344612956,
-0.7781026363,
0.5415580869,
-0.3740496337,
0.1593556106,
-0.3608329892,
0.091454722,
0.4920384288,
-0.0982065573,
1.0445079803,
0.090784505,
-0.3343127966,
-0.0177075453,
0.294990629,
0.31836164,
0.1256730109,
-0.0360018238,
0.2824662626,
0.1034465879,
-0.0330865495,
-0.8687385321,
0.7153677344,
-0.9095195532,
-1.1079567671,
-0.6462150812,
-0.484162271,
-0.3991068006,
0.0108155562,
0.1871427745,
0.1999328434,
-0.1393806934,
-0.1314877123,
0.8126288056,
-0.0428713635,
0.0625276268,
0.4862789214,
-0.4222325385,
-0.5220139027,
1.0808975697,
0.2176463604,
0.1691421866,
0.047038652,
0.4445330501,
-0.6316618919,
-0.4468203485,
-0.4372305274,
0.5041981936,
-0.8094132543,
-0.4436866343,
-0.7308031321,
-0.3395134211,
-0.6354391575,
-0.0508726314,
-0.4498173892,
-0.4547671676,
-0.4457738698,
-0.3115603924,
0.1997748315,
0.7273387313,
-0.3211395144,
0.1148670167,
-0.4199262261,
0.5661665201,
0.5072461963,
0.4083134234,
-0.2083191872,
-0.89705199,
-0.204737395,
0.0574052781,
-0.3389110863,
-0.7878545523,
0.2702912092,
0.0054243091,
0.4845474958,
0.5964199901,
0.2098136842,
0.9415265322,
-0.3700524569,
0.4477609992,
0.077515617,
-0.9939570427,
0.6127325892,
-0.092141822,
-0.1051505506,
0.8341139555,
0.3454568982,
-0.2729158401,
-0.2829395533,
-0.3915017843,
-0.3159777522,
0.31628564,
0.2349532247,
0.0673419014,
0.0928693563,
0.7617083788,
0.3379912078,
0.3051666021,
-0.8403743505,
-0.0252940319,
-0.5697202682,
-0.5421298146,
0.1098855287,
-0.4503513277,
-0.5343309641,
-0.4254947901,
0.9074999094,
-0.5174338222,
-0.1062802672,
0.5509192944,
-0.1251479387,
-0.3262902498,
0.0463953316,
0.6986646056,
0.6592379808,
-0.2581651807,
0.2606742382,
0.3942581415,
-0.2485157698,
0.1963134408,
-0.1236464083,
-0.1036330834,
-0.4017428458,
0.2742612958,
0.7233191729,
0.181013912,
-0.4718395472,
0.4987225235,
-0.007366118,
0.0039082188,
-0.1221541017,
0.3361572623,
-0.043294169,
0.3643816113,
0.1466568708,
0.0213714857,
0.2639867067,
-0.4429195523,
0.0117641324,
0.5987985134,
-0.1870744079,
-0.310200721,
0.6859802008,
0.0793261603,
-0.266012013,
0.4210964739,
-0.1295652241,
-0.6699947119,
0.28508389,
0.6888754368,
0.9729982615,
-0.2821962833,
0.2379732728,
0.3494994044,
0.4887546301,
-0.1034372374,
0.0704791918,
-0.0723790079,
-0.9635179043,
-0.4341081679,
-0.899435401,
-0.4447918534,
0.0188561529,
-0.5496134758,
0.3311904371,
-0.4347670078,
-0.1976070702,
-0.2265098691,
0.0064541036,
-0.4520043731,
0.5514886379,
0.3055064082,
0.4618200064,
-0.6344065666,
0.7695057392,
0.2723647952,
-0.2534478009,
-0.7465699911,
0.2431679517,
-0.0422056243,
-0.8761944175,
0.5756142139,
0.292876631,
-0.5201901793,
-0.1144870594,
-0.6853899956,
-1.0562264919,
1.0010942221,
0.6850708127,
-0.7988436222,
0.1497591734,
0.2243421823,
0.6632908583,
-0.5591842532,
-0.0397319458,
0.8077338934,
0.558604002,
0.1365445852,
-0.6993550658,
0.2281511426,
0.1576808393,
-0.2746818066,
-0.2413211316,
-0.8092355728,
0.137476325,
-0.448461026,
-0.1082575247,
-0.0807329714,
1.0119117498,
0.4115233421,
0.2291537821,
0.6760968566,
0.5821121931,
1.0439310074,
0.1288987249,
0.6240483522,
-0.6564164162,
0.2127346396,
1.3426885605,
-0.5625377893,
0.4926723838,
0.5665350556,
0.1774087846,
0.5406808853,
0.5596591234,
-0.2394639254,
0.3496304452,
0.0680478588,
-0.2390212566,
-0.5943444967,
-0.0762831718,
-0.264760375,
0.6672089696,
0.1716060042,
-0.0243665762,
0.0901894569,
-0.1415451765,
-0.1417875141,
0.1147527471,
-0.0405837186,
0.893167913,
-0.1157332659,
-0.7716447115,
0.4191662669,
-0.2584502697,
0.5000763535,
-0.4605948627,
-0.0434901267,
-0.2746808529,
-0.2240427434,
-0.4621463716,
-0.520849824,
0.3096635044,
-0.0600373931,
-0.1702391207,
0.0884253681,
0.838983357,
-0.4102255106,
-0.5895797014,
0.2691165805,
0.33468467,
0.1416190118,
-0.0010999069,
-0.5574576855,
0.1571090221,
-0.0353425592,
-0.0938013494,
0.1915063262,
0.4391447008,
0.1795427799,
0.7496631742,
0.6362327933,
0.243180573,
0.0942519903,
0.0350065902,
0.7466406822,
-0.8073939085,
-0.2406680584,
-0.9815417528,
0.2122647911,
0.0238357186,
-0.2930338681,
0.7617255449,
0.6126564741,
0.5621361732,
-0.100296706,
0.730014801,
0.2966604233,
0.439434886,
-0.6319189668,
0.74091959,
-0.4985118508,
0.3007119894,
-0.0994268954,
-0.9066795707,
-0.2196078748,
0.922285676,
-0.3158711791,
-0.0628698319,
0.5645663738,
0.9888201952,
0.1380168498,
0.1101738513,
0.5789784193,
0.580216229,
0.0196061712,
-0.0163459126,
0.9680119753,
-0.0398995094,
0.281745255,
-0.4626009464,
-0.181420505,
-0.1885772794,
-1.0846230984,
-0.9974520206,
-0.3203619123,
-0.5290401578,
-0.3770513833,
0.1306072474,
1.2906680107,
0.6137667894,
-0.7470601797,
-0.2146750242,
0.3149393797,
0.1543666422,
0.0625626594,
-0.141887188,
0.3753682375,
-0.7116553783,
-0.3114165068,
0.5493178964,
0.65505445,
0.1793542206,
-0.6151212454,
-0.0034126025,
0.0174998008,
0.3822795749,
0.3805467486,
0.0514281765,
-0.9596813917,
-0.7889573574,
-0.0184558164,
-0.1880670488,
0.4317762256,
0.5776735544,
-0.8746472597,
0.677949369,
-0.1388534456,
0.6363580823,
0.3328810334,
0.3180054128,
0.4176592231,
-0.5311573744,
-0.3561086059,
0.1407523751,
0.2124722153,
0.5609555244,
-0.9662685394,
0.5997043848,
0.2094416916,
-0.8557060957,
-0.8899416327,
-0.0310419165,
-1.0553972721,
-0.0331971273,
1.033178091,
0.2937169671,
-0.2872621417,
-0.0249799751,
-0.4457594752,
0.407643944,
-0.0191840231,
1.6330327988,
0.8219142556,
-0.3479997218,
0.1926838607,
-0.3799152672,
0.6883504987,
0.6707385778,
-0.8066681623,
0.175247997,
0.4783274829,
0.4527667463,
0.2642664909,
0.3037252426,
0.1186726764,
0.1094475314,
-0.4175751507,
0.4235975146,
0.0842570662,
-0.5911618471,
-0.5274725556,
-0.0625199676,
0.0432139188,
0.1073516458
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09259v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09259v2
|
SyntaxShap: Syntax-aware Explainability Method for Text Generation
| 2024-02-14T15:45:56 | 2024-06-03T10:30:00 |
Kenza Amara, Rita Sevastjanova, Mennatallah El-Assady
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
To harness the power of large language models in safety-critical domains, we
need to ensure the explainability of their predictions. However, despite the
significant attention to model interpretability, there remains an unexplored
domain in explaining sequence-to-sequence tasks using methods tailored for
textual data. This paper introduces SyntaxShap, a local, model-agnostic
explainability method for text generation that takes into consideration the
syntax in the text data. The presented work extends Shapley values to account
for parsing-based syntactic dependencies. Taking a game theoric approach,
SyntaxShap only considers coalitions constraint by the dependency tree. We
adopt a model-based evaluation to compare SyntaxShap and its weighted form to
state-of-the-art explainability methods adapted to text generation tasks, using
diverse metrics including faithfulness, coherency, and semantic alignment of
the explanations to the model. We show that our syntax-aware method produces
explanations that help build more faithful and coherent explanations for
predictions by autoregressive models. Confronted with the misalignment of human
and AI model reasoning, this paper also highlights the need for cautious
evaluation strategies in explainable AI.
|
[
-0.0230813026,
-0.7555112839,
0.6743902564,
0.5103511214,
-0.1548227817,
-0.0104507357,
-0.0458695851,
-0.2470992357,
-0.0028978426,
0.4606598914,
-0.5060254931,
-0.4710592031,
-0.3484783471,
-0.041489955,
-0.5948498845,
0.8709187508,
-0.2952581942,
-0.2593344748,
-0.6166713834,
-0.0283827484,
-0.5112666488,
-0.7081333995,
-0.4474770725,
-0.2479795963,
-0.1081778705,
0.2921784222,
0.9867289066,
1.0418649912,
0.3664635122,
0.3781308234,
-0.0157717485,
-0.1179219782,
-0.2154292464,
0.4102981687,
-0.2126924247,
-0.4294717908,
-0.2970203459,
-0.2848329246,
0.4304212034,
0.6851860285,
-0.5997921228,
-0.0810871422,
-0.0601747259,
0.5527121425,
-0.5688062906,
0.2714734077,
-0.771447897,
0.0299076382,
-0.0400168151,
-0.1325551569,
-0.4634321034,
-0.1926896274,
-0.0666583702,
-0.5435160398,
0.4688801467,
0.1183514968,
0.8496303558,
0.2331878245,
-0.1452159137,
-0.0830082595,
-0.5630981922,
0.6285863519,
-0.7098895311,
0.2561947107,
0.2843264043,
0.4585916698,
-0.0556124002,
-0.6605200768,
-0.712515831,
-0.0257426873,
-0.0338848829,
0.137562871,
-0.0959886611,
0.2124974579,
0.144838661,
0.2897788882,
-0.6421656609,
-0.133736521,
0.173724547,
-0.1288436353,
0.7272582054,
0.3388912976,
0.4782500863,
-0.5850240588,
-0.6965269446,
0.1309562325,
-0.5940841436,
0.2751626372,
0.2776578069,
0.1230199635,
-0.3092284203,
0.3610579371,
-0.090617381,
0.8524407148,
0.0991260782,
0.2688789368,
-0.3727253675,
-0.6477791667,
-0.3476377428,
-0.0498431511,
0.8180372119,
0.2658139467,
0.2057823241,
-0.3734565973,
0.0202932861,
0.0127480095,
0.2692159414,
-0.8547680378,
-0.2757891715,
0.4842224717,
-0.7434177399,
-0.6156172156,
-0.1845213324,
-0.8159677386,
-0.5416584015,
-0.0869099721,
0.2960157394,
-0.7302696705,
-0.3659801483,
0.1744830161,
-0.197178185,
0.2386155576,
0.1783381402,
-1.2552731037,
0.2613134384,
0.6950520277,
0.8472735286,
-0.0714763477,
-0.4638992846,
-0.1856085658,
0.3686027825,
-0.3391008377,
0.744722724,
-0.3517096043,
-0.2293768823,
-0.0855993107,
-0.2933859825,
-0.2243850678,
-0.5226882696,
0.3017237782,
-0.1063855588,
0.1767706275,
-0.2907196283,
-0.6673784256,
-0.220750466,
-0.0694008619,
-0.4290372133,
0.5489265323,
0.1516531557,
-0.6697135568,
0.5655431151,
-0.5243911147,
-0.6171765924,
0.1524099857,
-0.2943962812,
-0.438462019,
0.0659972578,
0.3006181121,
0.4914689064,
-0.2818328142,
0.7963081002,
-0.3690465689,
-0.0588524565,
0.1581951678,
-0.4072332084,
0.9630545378,
0.1696476191,
-0.4084307253,
0.2978632152,
-0.5641023517,
0.2859607935,
0.38968274,
0.0806244984,
-0.0642465651,
0.454028517,
-0.0970004946,
0.2327033132,
0.1910828948,
-0.054662168,
-0.071439147,
-0.5223070383,
0.7218274474,
0.6961036921,
0.1463286281,
0.496614486,
-0.3067655265,
0.73916924,
-0.0894335508,
0.3473201692,
-0.4594334066,
-0.3944832683,
-0.6143136024,
-0.0808089375,
0.1133039668,
0.3915866613,
-0.6694623828,
0.5074850321,
-0.1338200122,
-0.3414777219,
-0.165281117,
-0.0367477499,
0.5577835441,
0.4776347578,
0.2525978088,
-0.1329131573,
-0.6333360076,
-0.9084282517,
-0.634591639,
-0.5068093538,
0.3271327913,
0.2123849243,
0.3940363824,
0.1627172381,
1.0643264055,
-0.2295669168,
0.2735512555,
-0.4810828269,
0.1539982855,
-0.1459555924,
0.3842834234,
0.5254708529,
-0.7414638996,
-0.2590819895,
-0.3182608187,
-0.7575647235,
-0.1342886537,
-0.4156364501,
-0.283031553,
0.000847625,
0.4651239514,
-0.6407065392,
0.1357171386,
0.5236301422,
-0.6586353183,
0.5498855114,
-0.0682319552,
0.0991063491,
-1.1671403646,
0.0250715706,
-0.3653621674,
-0.5553181171,
-0.4872997403,
0.5353061557,
-0.1353790462,
-0.3492318392,
-0.167128399,
0.4703613818,
-0.2465381473,
0.0300614107,
0.0289133098,
0.0475659035,
0.3518562317,
0.1846229881,
0.0600185059,
0.7263323665,
0.4358275533,
-0.3992291391,
0.2109263092,
0.4766846895,
-0.1879699379,
0.3735654056,
-0.7620649338,
-0.3338360786,
0.0481963046,
0.1788973957,
-0.8117637038,
-0.3393827379,
0.0123173706,
-0.4796288013,
0.0632453412,
-0.3788613379,
-0.3893252015,
0.0300704893,
0.0041292286,
0.3496850133,
0.5784395933,
-0.657215476,
0.387770623,
0.3041039407,
-0.2511458099,
-0.394598037,
-0.3565707803,
0.2218141705,
-0.482468456,
-0.9411816597,
0.3915711045,
0.031057762,
-0.5320443511,
-0.2102953047,
-0.1226229444,
-0.4221445322,
0.4996366203,
0.4683552682,
0.07921049,
-0.2559372187,
0.2102449536,
0.0914094523,
-0.0978932232,
0.5516729951,
-0.2015043944,
0.4557684064,
-0.1444385797,
-0.2611547709,
-0.0538775623,
0.3954880834,
0.1720588654,
-0.3118397892,
0.7066572309,
0.2396383137,
-0.2949285805,
-0.6000900865,
0.0091321254,
0.0495037921,
-0.4635836482,
0.3072586954,
-0.1757728606,
-0.4227353334,
0.5626165271,
-0.0578988642,
-0.1673680842,
0.6970137358,
0.4013750255,
-0.0265581198,
1.0602416992,
0.5391554236,
0.187213093,
0.3867740929,
-0.0445824489,
0.1610777825,
-0.1149272695,
-0.0885243416,
-0.5162997842,
0.1882902384,
-0.1988149285,
-0.4669151306,
0.0360104591,
0.4870510399,
-0.0897854641,
0.3812851906,
-0.4681733549,
0.6093683839,
0.2970525324,
-0.0811866596,
0.2436670661,
-0.1570888162,
0.0353760459,
-0.0354185142,
-0.9086333513,
-0.3653642535,
0.6768614054,
0.0546698757,
0.3859443367,
0.2662647367,
0.8951948881,
0.2722243369,
-0.1614300013,
-0.3897268772,
0.4462660253,
-0.1063934788,
-0.4618890584,
-0.3060985804,
-0.4561432898,
-0.8565030098,
0.1366012096,
-0.3317900002,
-0.7074635625,
-0.0433468893,
0.3671059906,
-0.4896911383,
0.0221757088,
-0.7932882905,
1.265376687,
-0.344843328,
-0.2053408027,
-0.2730176151,
-0.5487488508,
0.5557538271,
0.2664649189,
0.2349243462,
-0.0686777309,
0.1024083048,
0.7471168637,
-0.9258108735,
0.6971842647,
-0.2779504955,
-0.0925669819,
0.3309507966,
0.3977851868,
0.4256257713,
0.0802690238,
0.060198307,
0.1728312075,
0.2131941766,
-0.3574899733,
-0.790219903,
0.6327416897,
-0.3264859915,
-0.5278317928,
-0.1295827627,
-0.59523803,
-0.2526443005,
0.1332459152,
0.4417003989,
0.5346027017,
-0.2254982442,
-0.1820775568,
0.5395888686,
-0.3595238924,
0.48988837,
0.1619779319,
-0.4899230003,
-0.2076343894,
1.0920633078,
-0.2171094418,
0.3610537648,
0.358604759,
0.3171785474,
-0.2432754934,
-0.6877196431,
-0.679481566,
-0.1992521882,
-0.6547508836,
-0.1752440184,
-0.3885452747,
-0.3220026791,
-0.1146079227,
-0.5935601592,
-0.2136527002,
-0.8803735971,
0.1919060796,
-0.0873002708,
0.4282108545,
0.6716843247,
0.1634551883,
0.4101820588,
-0.5300738215,
0.4422104955,
0.154146269,
0.4989589155,
0.0255672485,
-0.300917536,
-0.1965395957,
-0.0585514233,
-0.2157182097,
-1.0933183432,
0.2825719714,
0.2373912781,
0.3484465182,
0.378695935,
0.0119174179,
0.6400610805,
-0.3848919868,
0.8803854585,
0.1325209141,
-1.4155085087,
0.7869400382,
-0.6219360828,
0.1270831525,
0.4363855422,
-0.125851199,
-0.2830490768,
-0.5345647335,
-1.0804289579,
-0.9430750608,
0.4086449146,
0.4210446477,
-0.0350398645,
-0.0049781394,
0.5022068024,
0.3260063827,
0.1298326701,
-0.7030768991,
-0.1811213791,
-0.2731504142,
-0.4021294117,
0.0233587902,
-0.2014895678,
-0.0920763314,
0.1545065045,
0.5285989642,
-0.045650322,
0.2571218908,
0.012293647,
-0.3110187352,
-0.0680593923,
0.3549683392,
0.4530004859,
0.8451815844,
0.0045087398,
0.1126358882,
-0.236245349,
-0.2207404822,
0.1157451272,
0.4182862937,
-0.3337774575,
0.1162795424,
0.7585994601,
0.5971515775,
0.1328804046,
-0.6183265448,
0.8702040315,
-0.0334605575,
-0.0596434548,
-0.0989912972,
0.3510130346,
0.1366254836,
0.0998631194,
-0.0852022469,
0.1799778342,
0.3379230797,
-0.1983444989,
0.2170372754,
0.6163332462,
-0.3257158101,
-0.2446932048,
1.0377149582,
0.3999118209,
-0.1820463389,
0.1654470414,
-0.1619956195,
-0.3784223199,
1.0316426754,
0.5965697765,
0.8854125142,
-0.1410945505,
0.5489951968,
0.3366098404,
0.2081421912,
0.0878308937,
0.5369993448,
-0.2730439007,
-0.6148956418,
-0.4855664372,
-0.4280420244,
-0.3523103595,
-0.0809345171,
-0.6895212531,
0.0015882129,
-0.6324619651,
0.1252552122,
0.3716547787,
-0.4107187688,
-0.3319061697,
0.1164725497,
-0.1549869925,
0.7412610054,
-0.8823966384,
0.3239193559,
0.2969502211,
-0.5781246424,
-0.7504945397,
0.2945357561,
-0.0917219445,
-1.0465540886,
0.0548160449,
0.1184987575,
0.0411907956,
-0.1283294261,
-0.6646487117,
-0.6187178493,
0.8332428932,
0.6792280674,
-0.3291331828,
-0.0458154567,
0.122737743,
0.4711926579,
-0.0201751646,
0.0396063663,
0.3124232292,
0.3908017576,
-0.4235687852,
-0.6440760493,
0.3929761946,
-0.0692300275,
0.0359853283,
0.3719086945,
-0.4364133179,
0.4855581224,
-0.5708303452,
-0.2793579102,
0.2805747986,
0.55962497,
0.2172067612,
0.2158851922,
0.4609893262,
0.3130354285,
0.6651505232,
-0.1212020516,
1.2849954367,
-0.3812069595,
0.2377201617,
1.1925727129,
0.1006270424,
0.7592329979,
0.3901036382,
-0.2668775618,
0.8767530322,
0.5315391421,
0.1001576185,
0.2793426514,
0.1495210975,
-0.1224922612,
-0.5718557835,
-0.0544169359,
-0.2895085812,
0.6424492002,
0.0611528233,
-0.6543936133,
-0.3355071843,
-0.367890805,
0.0693832487,
0.3938732743,
-0.1398620307,
0.7748715281,
-0.0626897439,
-0.7172561884,
0.5890776515,
0.176914081,
-0.0234416574,
-0.5602391958,
-0.2254868448,
-0.0998387039,
0.0811770111,
-0.1608258635,
-0.8325607181,
0.3602454066,
-0.1049697325,
-0.5080834031,
-0.3575773835,
0.6639123559,
-0.5239830017,
-0.2985985279,
0.0486073419,
0.5887966156,
-0.0517874323,
-0.1385518909,
-0.8562021852,
-0.3827352524,
0.040548075,
0.1032509208,
0.1893289834,
0.4370380938,
-0.1828546673,
0.6924107671,
0.3412057459,
-0.0507839024,
-0.2480112016,
-0.0439381748,
0.3350861967,
-0.7032225728,
-0.7156239152,
-1.020159483,
0.4734692574,
-0.0019836491,
-0.2567315996,
0.7184159756,
0.4950813651,
0.1978709996,
0.0823188424,
0.9926860332,
-0.2360513359,
0.1973120272,
-0.7503752112,
0.8967151642,
-0.193535462,
0.1381493658,
-0.1759163737,
-0.5345055461,
-0.025800053,
0.5391311049,
0.0408770405,
0.1515818983,
0.7553809285,
0.3403090835,
-0.0764487684,
0.1633390635,
0.1048252359,
0.4190876484,
0.0960068554,
0.4855619073,
0.7404401302,
-0.155539915,
0.5908885598,
-0.2814763486,
-0.0702955127,
0.1011841521,
-1.1621336937,
-0.6397433281,
-0.8073095083,
-0.2698045671,
-0.5699824691,
0.2048103064,
0.4026799202,
0.8071736693,
-0.62412709,
-0.0760328695,
-0.6310096979,
0.4599088132,
-0.4982197285,
-0.3049818277,
0.3086572886,
-0.4530411661,
-0.080174692,
0.4274722636,
0.2137216628,
-0.076278761,
-0.2590892911,
-0.0814763233,
0.1666347533,
0.2272593677,
0.2323507369,
0.2644875348,
-0.7782477736,
-0.2032301873,
-0.39450109,
0.1834079623,
0.0214012805,
0.827845633,
-0.7517742515,
0.6539622545,
0.4165230393,
0.3141462505,
0.1260763109,
0.2107869536,
1.134644866,
-0.8257882595,
0.0058037932,
0.0267129056,
0.5010610223,
0.4499850273,
-0.4847012758,
0.4149399102,
0.1502599418,
-0.4885306954,
-0.6616840959,
0.4459422827,
-0.8306246996,
-0.3064620495,
1.1016324759,
-0.274238795,
-0.0264275689,
-0.1533822417,
-0.0195025969,
0.0889221728,
-0.1652165055,
0.7993252277,
0.6107462645,
-0.1499166489,
-0.0880469829,
-0.3250507414,
0.9460320473,
0.5078933835,
-1.1802940369,
0.7024499178,
0.4880728424,
0.1939572692,
-0.2072972804,
0.5327016115,
0.0704441592,
0.5161681771,
0.2990016341,
0.1115843207,
-0.1547036469,
-0.2167569548,
-0.4416528046,
0.0530363098,
0.1272300631,
0.0410799533
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09221v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09221v1
|
Spectral Filters, Dark Signals, and Attention Sinks
| 2024-02-14T15:01:07 | 2024-02-14T15:01:07 |
Nicola Cancedda
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Projecting intermediate representations onto the vocabulary is an
increasingly popular interpretation tool for transformer-based LLMs, also known
as the logit lens. We propose a quantitative extension to this approach and
define spectral filters on intermediate representations based on partitioning
the singular vectors of the vocabulary embedding and unembedding matrices into
bands. We find that the signals exchanged in the tail end of the spectrum are
responsible for attention sinking (Xiao et al. 2023), of which we provide an
explanation. We find that the loss of pretrained models can be kept low despite
suppressing sizable parts of the embedding spectrum in a layer-dependent way,
as long as attention sinking is preserved. Finally, we discover that the
representation of tokens that draw attention from many tokens have large
projections on the tail end of the spectrum.
|
[
-0.7004369497,
-0.2398138642,
0.6188285947,
-0.0886929035,
-0.5302019715,
0.2967327833,
-0.0871204287,
-0.4021196365,
0.5159920454,
0.8521845341,
-0.5969132185,
-0.4778673053,
-0.6142472029,
-0.2970117331,
-0.8190757036,
1.1034351587,
0.3343757093,
0.154725194,
0.153535381,
-0.0315826386,
-0.3052594066,
-0.2788252532,
-0.713942945,
-0.3881773353,
1.0739283562,
0.234121576,
0.8528349996,
0.3665611148,
0.8289495111,
0.1669864506,
-0.1592559367,
-0.0997444093,
-0.8770904541,
-0.077408798,
-0.2069550008,
-1.042342782,
-0.1217053682,
0.0131742414,
0.835657537,
1.0158401728,
0.0141947698,
0.3689510822,
0.2743163705,
0.7538391352,
-0.6182528138,
-0.1523709893,
-0.7663121819,
0.2227981687,
-0.3238571286,
-0.3522870839,
-0.7501032948,
0.3872682452,
-0.0133939618,
-0.3625409305,
0.3242949545,
0.1579710692,
1.0023760796,
0.6330277324,
-0.6581884027,
0.0555572398,
-1.0174020529,
0.7863846421,
-0.381289959,
0.634696126,
0.2679171562,
0.4178168774,
0.1749498993,
-0.94878757,
-0.2414767444,
0.0897785127,
-0.349159807,
0.5641491413,
-0.1774794608,
0.4774638414,
-0.0090896934,
0.3018403053,
-0.2323483825,
0.0427159816,
-0.6982059479,
-0.173527211,
0.3140482903,
0.229648158,
-0.0745913908,
-0.072351329,
-0.4842109978,
0.1279917657,
-0.9211668372,
-0.4070557952,
0.4262787104,
-0.0092074946,
-0.0253752992,
0.646707952,
0.4824687541,
0.7553920746,
0.3181044757,
0.3088567257,
-0.2111647725,
-0.0426705517,
-0.3899405003,
-0.0318019241,
0.1847287565,
0.562168479,
0.1384772658,
-0.3388406634,
-0.2290519476,
0.4102799594,
0.4875216484,
-0.4066825509,
-0.4487941265,
0.0739470348,
-0.5967107415,
-0.2098924816,
-0.2267324328,
-0.7364003658,
-0.0864150003,
-0.3871922493,
0.4783227444,
0.0272506382,
-0.1395293027,
0.1714168042,
0.0543106906,
0.4272916615,
-0.047122892,
-0.8569421768,
0.4782097638,
0.6035997868,
0.7379920483,
-0.1994741559,
0.1589173079,
-0.1534346491,
0.4122505188,
-0.4807980061,
0.8247058988,
-0.7228713036,
-0.3993401825,
0.0835266262,
0.0463346727,
-0.1323571652,
-0.490357548,
0.6161893606,
-1.1267085075,
0.0183284413,
0.0479938202,
-0.546061337,
-0.311393857,
-0.1652911901,
-0.8053466082,
0.9729230404,
0.1593310088,
-0.5197582841,
0.1689813435,
-0.3403405249,
0.0897639915,
0.1949554384,
-0.2140988708,
-0.2458416373,
0.3792237639,
-0.0089920154,
0.4438615739,
-0.123678796,
-0.1929941922,
-0.3667923212,
-0.5496234894,
0.3264629841,
-0.1871688068,
0.479516238,
0.2592558265,
-0.1238956675,
-0.0365934074,
-0.767955482,
-0.3437469602,
-0.2492493242,
-0.1490206271,
-0.3473407924,
0.262770921,
0.2446924746,
-0.0538933314,
-0.0981236994,
-0.5705558658,
-0.3061453998,
-0.3849036396,
0.4429735243,
1.0780004263,
0.3346835375,
0.6693385839,
0.1028190553,
0.5217401981,
0.3991873264,
0.2803689241,
-0.2904238999,
-0.4322100878,
-1.3429071903,
-0.080330044,
0.1331912577,
0.0852795541,
-0.6079035997,
0.0508509763,
-0.3628036976,
-0.330918014,
-0.518289268,
-0.0144927138,
0.1490606517,
0.434682399,
0.1565668285,
-0.2382772267,
-0.4675905108,
-1.2124452591,
-0.254483521,
-0.1369174123,
0.0976310149,
0.1496134102,
0.2756344378,
-0.2281520665,
0.8577994108,
-0.8489090204,
-0.5483711958,
0.0997859687,
-0.3234687448,
0.6385982633,
0.3590371013,
0.6930732131,
-1.0766983032,
-0.3279343247,
-0.2687092125,
-0.4164730012,
0.0503301099,
-0.2070403546,
-0.6589105725,
-0.3241582215,
0.7372408509,
-0.5225437284,
0.2532260418,
0.5400785804,
-0.6973397136,
0.2570818961,
0.2803306282,
-0.3362122774,
-0.6944230199,
-0.0774175748,
0.1445433199,
-0.4730836749,
-0.8045294285,
0.2184209526,
-0.0503645577,
-0.0243359637,
-0.4912798703,
0.3571911156,
-0.577583313,
-0.2391130626,
-0.1245037243,
0.3720709085,
0.0565714128,
0.7554653883,
-0.2520075142,
0.2089897394,
0.4084731042,
-0.616981864,
0.24234429,
-0.0218329355,
-0.2186481208,
0.6609678864,
-0.5374934673,
0.2478582412,
-0.4671826661,
0.0622864217,
-1.7086361647,
0.0663981736,
0.2727462351,
-0.3643305898,
0.512981534,
-0.4836724102,
-0.2901388109,
-0.4062581956,
-0.2566153705,
0.3081305921,
0.7121366858,
-0.5363266468,
0.8670934439,
0.4920687675,
0.2037533522,
-0.4732142687,
-1.1861311197,
0.0943063274,
-0.481341213,
-0.4850229025,
0.4209960401,
0.1917030662,
-0.2232897431,
0.5202558041,
-0.0702935159,
0.0819961876,
-0.0985427722,
0.1375999004,
0.5960668325,
-0.3804561794,
0.2266576886,
0.0239995271,
-0.138487488,
0.4277455211,
-0.6622927189,
0.3885585368,
0.3475546539,
-0.5958072543,
0.0775253996,
0.2869439423,
0.5304926038,
-0.1116439849,
0.3599280119,
0.8079117537,
-0.2046331316,
-0.2874130011,
-0.641120851,
-0.4320929348,
-0.5331535935,
0.4144160151,
-0.2840595543,
-0.6919875145,
0.9441254139,
0.1854723543,
0.0810529813,
0.6229665279,
0.4211859405,
-0.4376114011,
0.9451160431,
0.6166113615,
0.2589462399,
0.7073152661,
-0.6082167625,
0.2946465611,
-1.2568403482,
-0.1952088773,
-0.2422422767,
-0.9043354392,
-0.5297988057,
-0.4778244495,
0.4030880928,
-0.0324953683,
-0.2623219192,
-0.2780925035,
-0.7476342916,
0.6454465985,
0.399741441,
0.5686448812,
0.1076195762,
0.0900367647,
0.0195150562,
-0.2653971016,
-0.5496147275,
-0.265471071,
1.2647441626,
0.5344353318,
0.8451553583,
0.0525442772,
0.7320008874,
0.2845519781,
0.4619583488,
-0.8469853997,
0.7235696316,
-0.335473299,
-0.9724854827,
-0.082382448,
0.0772594586,
-0.8951285481,
0.5689303279,
0.3000865579,
-0.695002079,
0.9167081118,
0.072317332,
-0.2479281873,
0.3999457657,
-0.7242830992,
0.5094774365,
0.1615701318,
-0.4908644557,
-0.4502362013,
-0.6446345448,
0.5973234773,
-0.2243713886,
0.1129757315,
-0.2752963603,
-0.4820403159,
1.1365058422,
-0.2435220182,
1.3985364437,
-0.5472680926,
-0.0875676274,
0.5825400949,
0.0328059718,
0.5669620037,
-0.1823467463,
0.3576872349,
-0.1165469438,
-0.2545477748,
-0.5714618564,
-0.6549435258,
0.5620946884,
-0.6898661256,
-0.772356689,
-0.1598601788,
-0.1864105463,
-0.211180523,
-0.0144358911,
0.1627431512,
0.2629212737,
0.369618237,
0.1695850194,
0.7722719908,
0.3442763388,
0.5590283871,
0.3705609739,
-0.7297537923,
-0.2551653683,
0.8223369718,
0.4281867743,
0.4083595574,
0.2083330452,
-0.0928980038,
-0.306437254,
-0.7807595134,
-0.235237509,
0.4019049406,
-1.2810100317,
-0.1152274087,
-0.3477858901,
-0.1412319392,
0.1981267631,
-0.0566698797,
-0.1622158289,
-0.4102829993,
-0.3400364816,
-0.243564114,
0.3370988071,
0.6481415629,
-0.1165655032,
0.7470505834,
-0.5003046393,
0.2752460539,
0.2450261563,
0.268484354,
0.3302571476,
-0.887349844,
-0.8686898947,
-0.3059010506,
-0.1025164425,
-0.9342488647,
0.2509942055,
0.4684334993,
0.563464582,
0.5920296907,
-0.0401954018,
0.7869940996,
-0.4197673202,
0.8583370447,
0.4205233455,
-0.7796022296,
0.2268702239,
-0.2244908214,
0.1498336792,
0.3889182508,
0.278509587,
-0.6607322097,
-0.8112103939,
-0.4294340611,
-1.024949193,
0.8024589419,
-0.110363096,
0.5623810291,
0.0649067014,
0.5207716227,
-0.1071364358,
-0.0126334485,
-0.7682068944,
-0.6063963771,
-0.2255849093,
-0.2061987072,
-0.3876652718,
-0.6137131453,
-0.2948002517,
-0.0974884704,
0.405382663,
0.0475572422,
0.6326352358,
0.277408123,
-0.1600064486,
-0.069338657,
-0.239045009,
0.1723305732,
0.2631735504,
-0.2161262333,
0.7019327283,
-0.0175696369,
-1.0048277378,
0.1369927377,
-0.3248785734,
-0.3548033535,
0.3849986792,
0.3889424503,
0.8387298584,
0.6939253807,
-0.1781798005,
0.2824211419,
0.4363830984,
0.0889194906,
-0.4062554538,
-0.2121792287,
0.270560205,
0.1346208155,
0.8720795512,
0.2893308103,
0.3219712675,
-0.4636118114,
0.2436129302,
0.1330524236,
-0.9014493227,
-0.4688867331,
0.8600328565,
0.1430180222,
0.1431183815,
0.3192563057,
0.2360936105,
-0.4443814456,
0.5124307871,
0.370041579,
0.9963672757,
-0.3837789893,
0.0076367883,
0.1231455207,
0.4513919353,
0.4772268236,
0.1542186141,
-0.162277028,
-0.7097696066,
-0.770383358,
-0.6106405258,
-0.0534621142,
-0.1536397934,
-0.701292336,
0.398326844,
-0.2030090094,
-0.3979827464,
0.3040610552,
-0.3904025853,
-0.6855139732,
0.3077759147,
0.5225610137,
0.5950647593,
-0.9376968145,
0.7799181342,
0.5737450123,
-0.4362260699,
-0.5621454716,
-0.1357539296,
-0.2943853438,
-1.24875319,
1.0632885695,
-0.1586640179,
-0.3818596303,
0.3111842871,
-0.5986902118,
-1.3280336857,
0.7645006776,
0.4894002974,
-0.6431343555,
-0.4201343954,
0.2705176175,
0.4463593066,
-0.3054139316,
0.2697921395,
0.4707521498,
0.5961039066,
0.2421696931,
-0.3435956836,
-0.1219512522,
-0.1276168227,
0.0377781726,
0.3735354543,
-0.7410548329,
0.7793709636,
0.0134205846,
-0.5914103389,
-0.4267891943,
0.5240775347,
-0.3474686742,
0.2094129324,
0.529430747,
0.4819500148,
0.2444071621,
-0.2931997776,
0.8648461103,
-0.4493583143,
0.4528901279,
0.9110841155,
0.0358990803,
0.8990091085,
1.0119217634,
-0.4623920619,
0.5223230124,
1.0421226025,
-0.357449919,
0.9546020031,
0.2456328124,
-0.2540052533,
-0.119622007,
-0.1412542611,
-0.1375582218,
0.2814143896,
0.5494249463,
-0.5645633936,
-0.1130652726,
0.3479306102,
-0.2394564301,
-0.2366603911,
-0.780205369,
0.69292593,
0.5039969087,
-0.554864347,
0.7916077375,
-0.3999715149,
0.5093048215,
-0.4545432925,
0.1677059233,
-0.2729445398,
0.3745624125,
-0.603721261,
-0.9509304762,
0.4827364385,
-0.4323355854,
-0.0763600767,
0.0759824887,
0.7897924185,
-0.4962212145,
-0.5252873302,
0.7551243901,
0.2746697068,
0.3487853408,
0.1057143509,
-0.3299655318,
0.135549888,
0.1016199142,
-0.6204605103,
-0.0283178743,
0.2482119799,
0.3076276481,
0.4975555837,
0.4299102128,
0.0848659426,
0.8151557446,
0.2030042112,
0.9881210923,
-0.6534531116,
-0.614988327,
-0.9019376636,
0.62346977,
0.0810654163,
0.1385323703,
0.7477590442,
0.7271721363,
0.6241310239,
-0.2035684884,
0.3280405104,
0.5356064439,
0.2647433877,
-0.7457594275,
0.6744664311,
-0.5342937112,
0.3855150938,
-0.0200774502,
-1.5037255287,
-0.4180335999,
0.0590471402,
-0.1888844073,
-0.0526741222,
0.7242097259,
0.6101934314,
-0.1924273074,
-0.1931123137,
0.6255702972,
0.4398556948,
0.0887797251,
0.5351980925,
1.0559364557,
-0.4492207766,
0.7182030678,
-0.0984080657,
0.2378101498,
-0.365636766,
-0.266988039,
-0.7350914478,
-0.6802604795,
-0.3712202907,
-0.0737426952,
-0.1201966852,
0.0524243601,
0.9358837605,
-0.4916494489,
-0.2227554172,
0.0104596419,
-0.0490694642,
0.1023562998,
-0.2055982798,
0.6308566332,
-0.4464541674,
-0.7855887413,
0.0303460956,
0.4206376672,
0.1777919978,
-1.0099793673,
0.0718515888,
-0.0423970371,
0.217892319,
0.6908898354,
-0.3186435103,
-0.8172593117,
-0.4017129838,
0.0191841964,
0.0755182281,
0.1720711142,
0.5756772757,
-0.8819251657,
0.3134613931,
0.1157970428,
0.3504706919,
1.1724903584,
-0.555501461,
0.2927266359,
-0.6882222891,
0.2490562648,
0.440649569,
0.573639214,
0.139907822,
-0.212662816,
0.7497122884,
0.2750264704,
-0.3259827197,
-1.2349461317,
0.3668819666,
-1.0697319508,
-0.0353755839,
0.8519545197,
-0.0780588537,
-0.6651561856,
-0.2472991347,
-0.1173192337,
0.1295289844,
-0.1248358637,
0.3271368444,
0.7964340448,
0.0304672699,
-0.5854467154,
-0.5488265753,
0.222725898,
0.5986124277,
-0.0929076597,
-0.0431141742,
0.2012485564,
-0.0177584868,
0.4867497087,
0.3051573932,
-0.2083639503,
0.157916218,
0.2151722014,
-0.1631485969,
0.4994240105,
-0.0279790573,
-0.4507575631,
0.2798567712,
0.0916246772,
-0.4814046323
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09216v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09216v3
|
AutoTutor meets Large Language Models: A Language Model Tutor with Rich Pedagogy and Guardrails
| 2024-02-14T14:53:56 | 2024-04-25T13:15:55 |
Sankalan Pal Chowdhury, Vilém Zouhar, Mrinmaya Sachan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have found several use cases in education,
ranging from automatic question generation to essay evaluation. In this paper,
we explore the potential of using Large Language Models (LLMs) to author
Intelligent Tutoring Systems. A common pitfall of LLMs is their straying from
desired pedagogical strategies such as leaking the answer to the student, and
in general, providing no guarantees. We posit that while LLMs with certain
guardrails can take the place of subject experts, the overall pedagogical
design still needs to be handcrafted for the best learning results. Based on
this principle, we create a sample end-to-end tutoring system named MWPTutor,
which uses LLMs to fill in the state space of a pre-defined finite state
transducer. This approach retains the structure and the pedagogy of traditional
tutoring systems that has been developed over the years by learning scientists
but brings in additional flexibility of LLM-based approaches. Through a human
evaluation study on two datasets based on math word problems, we show that our
hybrid approach achieves a better overall tutoring score than an instructed,
but otherwise free-form, GPT-4. MWPTutor is completely modular and opens up the
scope for the community to improve its performance by improving individual
modules or using different teaching strategies that it can follow.
|
[
-0.3990786076,
-0.7763645053,
0.5966951847,
-0.1047194377,
-0.3395648003,
0.4926136434,
-0.3769992888,
-0.1286111027,
-0.0214185845,
0.2812128067,
-0.2449274957,
-0.1807607412,
-0.6274128556,
0.0379023366,
-0.614348948,
0.8356381655,
-0.2044857144,
0.2565409541,
-0.3215300739,
0.2268954664,
-0.3859504461,
-0.6602774262,
-0.4994124472,
-0.4452332258,
0.4291172624,
0.2427890301,
0.5246099234,
0.7553887367,
0.1040865034,
0.3753051758,
0.0477364548,
-0.0555975176,
-0.2213589996,
0.1020601839,
-0.3636333942,
-0.5276970863,
-0.2193719894,
-0.0341082178,
0.391859591,
0.684101522,
-0.2084546834,
-0.0672390535,
0.1752179563,
0.241677314,
-0.4213855863,
0.2113445401,
-0.4326229692,
0.2542353868,
-0.1536470205,
0.0180346593,
-0.4135469198,
-0.3969814479,
0.3646997213,
-0.3453453779,
-0.0492718518,
-0.0262341071,
0.275826633,
0.349336803,
-0.5616197586,
-0.2331256121,
-0.8876927495,
0.7413628101,
-0.7539107203,
0.2362028807,
0.1553082913,
0.6556321979,
-0.2465542406,
-0.3620762527,
-0.553489089,
-0.1278399676,
0.0383300371,
0.18643713,
-0.0086816596,
0.0214180332,
0.0374245681,
0.4736055732,
-0.5455901027,
0.4629288614,
-0.2364183962,
-0.4768550396,
0.5058938265,
0.2683494091,
0.2705541253,
-0.1336886138,
-0.1928352267,
-0.2585498393,
-0.7010890245,
-0.0944374502,
0.6415293217,
0.2000114173,
0.0538488664,
0.5849456787,
0.269353807,
0.900850296,
-0.0255231522,
-0.1943878978,
-0.3039860129,
0.0498854294,
0.0746101141,
0.0112273907,
1.0516806841,
0.0652494654,
0.6670113802,
-0.1134481579,
-0.4213883579,
-0.0616450608,
-0.0077173337,
-0.7427969575,
-0.4405192733,
-0.0606719367,
-0.0725525841,
-0.2744255364,
0.0641148463,
-0.7661022544,
-0.3011339009,
-0.5725138783,
0.622612834,
-0.6144999862,
-0.2642899156,
0.1080307886,
0.2096983641,
0.2760321498,
0.2321004272,
-1.0039708614,
0.563580215,
0.7468370795,
0.8028082252,
-0.3934824467,
-0.2351296842,
-0.2724922597,
0.1604275107,
-0.28829059,
0.8225451112,
-0.5154490471,
-0.6682183146,
0.0046532881,
-0.1108234227,
0.0370871238,
-0.3773469925,
0.0450720713,
-0.4579657018,
0.7476627231,
0.1998665035,
-0.8765382767,
-0.1666508913,
0.1261551529,
-0.514801085,
0.8373113871,
0.0858870968,
-0.2424007952,
-0.0394770652,
-0.577180922,
-0.5153862834,
0.1566554904,
-0.2383318245,
-0.2380229682,
0.0781989396,
0.1218010634,
0.474190861,
-0.359338969,
0.633905828,
0.0478077978,
-0.2920494676,
0.2381229103,
-0.5921266675,
0.5525884032,
0.0990712047,
-0.3509636521,
0.2358857393,
-0.5205494165,
0.0161371343,
0.1400946528,
-0.4345471263,
-0.2815949619,
0.1081756502,
0.0565308891,
0.1757121086,
0.3410942256,
-0.655825913,
0.1345081627,
-0.400645256,
0.7399997711,
1.1278432608,
-0.2190067768,
0.339048028,
-0.3613235652,
0.7565065622,
-0.2681248784,
-0.0547105633,
-0.3268297613,
-0.2766351998,
-0.837138772,
-0.1951275319,
0.4660610855,
0.4889019132,
-0.5292289853,
0.711619854,
-0.1690243483,
-0.5036287308,
-0.2079088539,
0.1541253626,
0.332449019,
0.289572984,
0.1831451654,
0.0023499592,
-0.417416811,
-0.8117690682,
-0.2311401069,
0.042345982,
-0.1182459295,
-0.0130110905,
0.5046529174,
0.1046000645,
1.1146275997,
-0.4530825913,
-0.2650076747,
-0.4306957126,
-0.2756173313,
0.144176811,
0.5778386593,
0.4699856639,
-0.3918225169,
-0.6483379006,
-0.2330251932,
-0.4701772928,
-0.089296177,
0.0247795936,
-0.1832775027,
0.1763320863,
0.5320212841,
-0.5658717155,
0.0180492438,
0.4694713652,
-0.2072074264,
0.6235904694,
-0.2389204055,
-0.4027683735,
-1.4012681246,
-0.1263683587,
-0.1283262968,
-0.3931774497,
-0.2423167527,
-0.05549426,
0.0154301366,
-0.3358350992,
-0.1664937288,
0.665117979,
-0.4103959799,
-0.1156509668,
-0.4044537544,
0.2022432536,
-0.2074392885,
0.3841097057,
-0.2266862839,
0.8416998982,
0.4775363505,
-0.2183945179,
0.7658653855,
0.0677623898,
-0.3552621007,
0.47091645,
-0.8363659382,
0.2650424838,
0.0746859908,
0.4672817886,
-0.8935450912,
-0.2705057859,
-0.0928908437,
-0.1988629699,
0.3740272522,
-0.2411465794,
-0.7621144056,
-0.5771647692,
-0.1811621338,
0.0155151095,
0.6216707826,
-0.5846242905,
0.7078512311,
0.4199138582,
-0.3761007488,
-0.3103969991,
-0.4527783096,
0.379235357,
-0.0643363595,
-0.2975879014,
0.156545043,
-0.2946311235,
-0.1662838459,
0.0334587619,
0.0332999676,
-0.0608371384,
0.1248766929,
0.0826993138,
0.5026684999,
-0.1562637687,
0.2450120151,
0.2169867605,
-0.3009512126,
0.2508142591,
-0.6083552837,
0.8225095272,
-0.1032381207,
-0.6465544701,
-0.2898059189,
0.3193889856,
0.7670353651,
-0.3418541551,
0.5255715251,
0.0814940184,
-0.2812665403,
-0.4519769847,
-0.4809560478,
-0.2375586629,
-0.5426599979,
0.4201986194,
-0.2834718525,
-0.9331753254,
0.3552676141,
0.0120559298,
0.3032149971,
0.1826354861,
0.5934717059,
0.0817562714,
1.0482871532,
0.6851396561,
-0.358017236,
0.6201713085,
-0.335454464,
0.3116241992,
-0.618657887,
-0.2812339962,
-0.1746468246,
-0.312817812,
-0.3095497787,
-0.1344002038,
0.3527445197,
-0.19094266,
-0.2809924185,
0.3405637443,
-0.5396339297,
0.6547734737,
0.5415179133,
-0.0977552608,
0.3003557324,
-0.0162706282,
-0.5174154043,
-0.0839683637,
-0.7051008344,
-0.6367228627,
1.1199455261,
0.1512022316,
0.8842769265,
0.2598080039,
0.572404325,
0.0892053321,
0.3628342748,
-1.023014307,
0.8059464097,
-0.1195717081,
-0.6542921066,
-0.3472078145,
-0.337718606,
-0.7738627195,
0.4409752488,
-0.1248586327,
-0.4504543245,
-0.3837784231,
0.0333213955,
-0.4073308408,
0.4498159289,
-0.6188514233,
0.6949360371,
-0.546605587,
-0.3340778053,
-0.1035097539,
-0.383171767,
0.2211975753,
-0.3191708922,
0.1175545752,
0.1739681065,
-0.0871622935,
0.7759407163,
-0.771668911,
0.9190523028,
-0.1948990971,
-0.3246714473,
0.1615863442,
0.3398225904,
0.3538638949,
-0.4114417434,
-0.0890102983,
-0.4349012375,
-0.0566892549,
-0.2921892703,
-0.7118397355,
0.8045234084,
-0.8461874723,
-0.8374248147,
-0.3492503166,
-0.7683079839,
-0.323941499,
0.3325587213,
0.0529513471,
0.7476975322,
0.0553507805,
0.0896439254,
0.6801967621,
-0.2942824066,
0.6752581,
0.6590493321,
-0.2765127718,
-0.399728328,
1.025862813,
0.2278681695,
0.1778698415,
0.1751971096,
0.5809319019,
-0.4077321589,
-0.5356639624,
-0.7075001001,
0.3598362207,
-0.6867710948,
-0.1383057386,
-0.4708923697,
-0.3445171416,
-0.3319332004,
-0.3736534715,
-0.2737951577,
-0.4258461595,
-0.2161233127,
-0.2567035258,
0.4671616852,
0.9569658637,
-0.0124186147,
0.403354764,
-0.5559636354,
-0.1436270177,
0.5526376963,
0.2806007862,
0.1859378517,
-0.7329689264,
-0.0250413585,
-0.1813659519,
-0.2663082778,
-0.4480280578,
0.4024488926,
0.1860191077,
0.6139415503,
0.3627589941,
0.0165322423,
0.5015345812,
-0.6920435429,
0.6255791187,
0.1015555114,
-0.9133926034,
0.3203244209,
-0.4998350739,
0.367875129,
0.1965453476,
0.3203179538,
-0.506138742,
-0.5489106774,
-0.2224320322,
-0.7624337077,
0.4306183755,
-0.3589324355,
0.4541111588,
0.2501371205,
0.2713176608,
0.3406888247,
0.1481119692,
-0.6875025034,
-0.0106689101,
-0.3264368474,
-0.7550196648,
-0.1897253841,
-0.0882432386,
0.0032968118,
-0.1826834083,
0.5019855499,
-0.2353315204,
0.0473840944,
-0.1911585629,
-0.3158435225,
-0.083290115,
0.2822150588,
0.4662160575,
0.6602937579,
0.2678602636,
0.272104919,
0.0816549733,
-0.4177721739,
0.3335861564,
0.2116066068,
-0.165915072,
-0.2137110829,
0.4537016749,
0.4497387409,
0.3999427855,
-0.6637424827,
0.5500069857,
0.1974843442,
-0.240867421,
-0.6272570491,
0.2939195037,
0.2462103665,
0.0378564969,
0.5361630321,
-0.2390684932,
-0.2458830923,
-0.3911703527,
0.0374930352,
0.4637924731,
-0.2503645122,
-0.4686922729,
0.6579450369,
0.3619532287,
-0.624384284,
0.2595435083,
0.2454333305,
-0.8792982101,
0.531027317,
0.7426729798,
0.7432466745,
-0.3893142343,
-0.0007289764,
0.0570427217,
0.1470364332,
-0.0768278986,
0.0267403163,
-0.1837732792,
-0.5183063149,
-0.7618997097,
-0.5694009066,
-0.6775380373,
0.1457058191,
-0.4501701593,
0.2393392026,
-0.7248407602,
0.1464340687,
-0.1499614269,
-0.0601868704,
-0.2833367288,
-0.0823703706,
0.1745167077,
0.9054937959,
-0.6585059166,
0.8428077102,
0.7677342892,
-0.0013440546,
-0.8284991384,
-0.232596308,
0.1300119609,
-0.5899086595,
0.44653216,
0.0866368264,
-0.1807959229,
0.2760744095,
-0.401099354,
-0.7700493932,
0.9457680583,
0.4245800674,
-0.7554816008,
-0.1830787063,
0.330411911,
0.6861633062,
-0.1421539187,
0.2101721317,
0.209418267,
0.3572632372,
-0.0655581206,
-0.8464648724,
-0.0092615914,
-0.0561636835,
-0.0387265459,
0.2679257691,
-0.7207224369,
0.8301354647,
-0.0332946405,
0.0155191328,
0.2193364799,
0.4643833637,
-0.0228696708,
-0.2517304718,
0.5626752973,
0.4804072082,
0.5018976331,
-0.0778618529,
0.9738810062,
-0.4099593759,
0.2656191885,
1.0240008831,
-0.1219009683,
0.7188164592,
0.3755418658,
-0.3833551705,
0.5957972407,
0.572437942,
-0.0874150172,
0.2858762443,
0.4354200363,
-0.2977700531,
-0.3463501632,
0.1771582514,
-0.0287724473,
0.4840062261,
0.2342974991,
-0.1034723222,
-0.4230972826,
0.3398852944,
0.1221725792,
0.3395323753,
-0.1792606711,
0.5976385474,
0.1640649587,
-0.5749354959,
0.23015517,
-0.1624646336,
0.8029104471,
-0.6309214234,
0.1524500102,
-0.2011281103,
0.3055173457,
0.0428439863,
-0.7540246844,
0.0594728515,
0.2093508542,
0.0649136305,
-0.4714033306,
0.3803930879,
-0.5265061259,
-0.6035487056,
0.2486179918,
0.5934628844,
0.108396478,
0.4080126882,
-0.4728601277,
-0.232154429,
-0.3306641877,
-0.2917144597,
0.4096421301,
0.4181033075,
-0.0057584899,
0.9347454906,
0.7096383572,
0.1052694917,
-0.0151306419,
0.0174877606,
0.9239449501,
-0.5213263631,
-0.5076370835,
-1.0422205925,
0.2091066688,
0.0548119247,
-0.2555290461,
0.9833330512,
0.6469011307,
0.7519215345,
0.0461771227,
0.9387772679,
0.0691978186,
0.6584727168,
-0.3819800019,
0.8041523099,
-0.2064708173,
0.23452878,
-0.1483129263,
-1.1338038445,
-0.2334533483,
0.608780086,
-0.435316205,
0.0345674008,
0.4812057316,
0.5128308535,
-0.1116884872,
0.0301657226,
0.4626010656,
0.1508789361,
0.5920473337,
0.6333709359,
1.1874239445,
-0.0748679265,
0.6976286769,
-0.1317970008,
-0.1396628171,
-0.1931216568,
-0.5636567473,
-1.1237473488,
-0.4259887934,
0.0098949512,
0.1039885953,
0.0111520905,
0.9084819555,
0.5802018642,
-0.6843274236,
-0.4082970917,
-0.1583968997,
-0.0223503876,
0.4493874907,
-0.2595582306,
0.2542042732,
-0.0748950467,
-0.8710172772,
0.4364511073,
0.066015467,
0.3680627048,
-0.9335253835,
0.1475138217,
0.1457253247,
0.1346309036,
0.4938057363,
0.0590378791,
-0.6217962503,
-0.4260964394,
0.1537343711,
-0.1517541558,
-0.3204576969,
0.8622014523,
-0.983682394,
0.3595354557,
0.1784167141,
0.7980720401,
0.411850512,
-0.3059894145,
0.9446822405,
-0.1372206062,
0.0649161115,
0.2526433468,
0.5083518028,
0.5322670937,
-0.1624344885,
0.1840966642,
0.1128668636,
-0.5240427852,
-0.7191467285,
0.0893647671,
-0.4766360223,
-0.3488433957,
0.9958862662,
-0.1800040156,
-0.2262906134,
-0.1678264886,
-0.26864326,
0.0515036099,
-0.2756944895,
0.7903427482,
0.9254388213,
-0.0031370919,
-0.1426304132,
-0.4524747729,
0.0545647927,
0.5532482266,
-0.6774642467,
-0.0523366816,
0.5083013773,
0.7084364295,
0.0035758321,
0.0815690309,
-0.0064820731,
0.0709109232,
-0.2640898526,
-0.0457104966,
-0.4705265462,
-0.2434943318,
-0.3798419833,
-0.0447810888,
-0.0324169695,
0.0001507889
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09205v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09205v2
|
Tell Me More! Towards Implicit User Intention Understanding of Language Model Driven Agents
| 2024-02-14T14:36:30 | 2024-02-15T09:59:52 |
Cheng Qian, Bingxiang He, Zhong Zhuang, Jia Deng, Yujia Qin, Xin Cong, Zhong Zhang, Jie Zhou, Yankai Lin, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
Current language model-driven agents often lack mechanisms for effective user
participation, which is crucial given the vagueness commonly found in user
instructions. Although adept at devising strategies and performing tasks, these
agents struggle with seeking clarification and grasping precise user
intentions. To bridge this gap, we introduce Intention-in-Interaction (IN3), a
novel benchmark designed to inspect users' implicit intentions through explicit
queries. Next, we propose the incorporation of model experts as the upstream in
agent designs to enhance user-agent interaction. Employing IN3, we empirically
train Mistral-Interact, a powerful model that proactively assesses task
vagueness, inquires user intentions, and refines them into actionable goals
before starting downstream agent task execution. Integrating it into the XAgent
framework, we comprehensively evaluate the enhanced agent system regarding user
instruction understanding and execution, revealing that our approach notably
excels at identifying vague user tasks, recovering and summarizing critical
missing information, setting precise and necessary agent execution goals, and
minimizing redundant tool usage, thus boosting overall efficiency. All the data
and codes are released.
|
[
-0.3704459965,
-0.3698151708,
1.1358741522,
-0.0669518337,
0.2137023509,
-0.2742587328,
0.0411593691,
-0.6764526367,
-0.1899564862,
0.4420966208,
-0.753926456,
-0.4383012652,
-0.3317220211,
-0.1543070674,
-0.6005891562,
0.8859963417,
-0.0963046849,
-0.0551508032,
-0.2547639012,
0.1462192982,
-0.434025228,
-0.2453384548,
-0.8590524197,
-0.3136512935,
0.3456093371,
0.6295877099,
0.8361599445,
0.2471697181,
0.1050262004,
0.4082398117,
0.2927793264,
0.1604990512,
-0.6260735989,
0.0005129939,
-0.2268377692,
-0.5161355734,
-0.5589847565,
0.2208380401,
0.4242214561,
0.5898519158,
0.1818837076,
0.0247359071,
0.1831699759,
0.2267050743,
-0.6890588403,
0.2687858939,
-0.2383271158,
-0.1771823466,
0.0090945791,
-0.0340311974,
-0.5211369991,
-0.1599930227,
0.108174324,
-0.7966010571,
0.1680246443,
-0.2537608743,
0.5718948245,
0.3740366995,
-0.5070261955,
-0.3021947443,
-0.6092461944,
0.6797510386,
-0.8452214003,
0.5066976547,
0.3485809565,
0.2573177516,
-0.4600177407,
-0.9618848562,
-0.8635287881,
-0.3104415834,
-0.3667432964,
-0.0163459554,
-0.4348607659,
0.4403391778,
0.3534970582,
-0.0680908784,
-0.5227745771,
-0.0933115482,
0.1447072327,
0.117065914,
0.7773988247,
0.3253978491,
0.2641563714,
0.2170907408,
-0.3441832662,
0.0144428769,
-0.5290816426,
0.3668452203,
0.4963175952,
0.1323775202,
-0.0639093369,
0.4537943304,
-0.3917157948,
0.6928061247,
0.1964489073,
0.4523981512,
0.0463227928,
-0.2708209753,
-0.1064749658,
-0.1632094383,
0.7171660662,
0.2300042212,
0.3381762803,
-0.2210838646,
-0.496080637,
-0.4019536972,
0.3092099428,
-0.8537704945,
0.0512088053,
0.5585300922,
-0.3015251458,
-0.006028791,
0.2096689492,
-0.3377278745,
-0.4921103418,
-0.3731036782,
0.5041009188,
-0.417619735,
-0.3130192459,
0.2477710098,
-0.2471435368,
0.2806078196,
0.5073945522,
-0.8279598951,
0.6136143208,
0.9711520672,
0.5138346553,
0.2579266131,
-0.6147249341,
-0.6665639877,
0.4864040017,
-0.1543214023,
0.6537393928,
-0.8270536661,
-0.3693517148,
0.0259309392,
-0.3123281002,
-0.1531241536,
-0.0388937816,
0.4946430624,
-0.4831447303,
0.2056479454,
-0.311720252,
-0.5191190243,
-0.4867820442,
0.0997046009,
-0.4365414977,
1.0964051485,
0.3197283745,
-0.195228979,
0.5619311333,
-0.9824780822,
-0.2315502018,
0.2438529581,
-0.1866891384,
0.2287475616,
0.3906576037,
0.050398916,
0.5732882619,
-0.2141497135,
0.1528799534,
-0.2173108011,
-0.6274430156,
0.4953919053,
-0.4448687136,
0.3053050041,
-0.0118610533,
-0.5809339881,
0.3449521065,
-0.4967950284,
0.233325094,
-0.3160737157,
0.1135539562,
-0.4748985767,
0.117482841,
0.0261127725,
0.5428295732,
0.5220695138,
-0.4016614854,
0.0727283284,
-0.4241757393,
0.1643481106,
0.8529774547,
0.0029901834,
0.5068674684,
-0.0922542438,
0.4158999324,
-0.5164266229,
0.7471576929,
0.0079090167,
-0.4984001219,
-0.7752938867,
-0.1538432539,
-0.2775020301,
-0.0543180779,
-0.4406888187,
0.1223377287,
-0.33261922,
-0.3490583897,
-0.5356121659,
0.1717543155,
0.6921910048,
0.3320539892,
0.0539271906,
-0.1789769679,
-0.0823251531,
-0.8318766952,
-0.4713927507,
-0.4528347552,
0.0625282824,
0.5171845555,
0.5451378822,
-0.3596076369,
1.2807816267,
-0.5173589587,
-0.06908793,
-0.448839128,
0.2778230608,
0.1504024565,
0.3370105922,
0.4892992675,
-0.9485964775,
-0.837166667,
0.4944228828,
-0.8657094836,
-0.068418704,
-0.0627111942,
-0.0925153866,
0.0550053716,
0.437787801,
-0.6752653122,
0.4984212816,
0.172745809,
-0.3223452568,
0.1267877221,
-0.1784205586,
0.2623831332,
-0.5597382784,
0.0700187385,
-0.0516684763,
-0.3200314641,
-1.1198936701,
0.0126364408,
0.1863612384,
0.0522993319,
-0.7064618468,
1.0572369099,
-0.6378391981,
-0.0189873725,
-0.5124874115,
0.1058085263,
-0.0017863532,
0.5477378368,
0.1235511974,
0.8701384664,
0.3866451979,
-0.5469971299,
-0.2829121053,
0.1948002726,
0.0371878482,
0.4279151857,
-0.7971934676,
0.4025513828,
-0.1193064749,
-0.1860781014,
-1.0366200209,
-0.5222677588,
0.5785602927,
-0.5192507505,
0.2756782472,
-0.3319603503,
-0.5232346654,
-0.0886386037,
-0.2371547073,
0.3533085585,
0.3595229983,
-0.55190593,
0.7962977886,
0.2398664802,
0.0737298653,
-0.6170367002,
-0.4975688457,
0.0329900831,
0.0113416677,
-0.7330148816,
0.0659988672,
0.0705452338,
-0.3595784009,
0.0663576275,
-0.1233307198,
-0.2408880144,
0.0078762667,
0.5400838256,
-0.1260517687,
0.0399307571,
0.0162868313,
0.2113226354,
-0.2452522218,
0.2230844647,
-0.2027329803,
0.3895870745,
-0.1117580235,
-0.6193909645,
-0.9513298869,
0.4782392383,
0.4432585835,
-0.0821485445,
0.4513545632,
0.4860415459,
-0.2397767007,
-0.0580227077,
-0.537101984,
-0.3786817491,
-0.5412874222,
0.2964922786,
-0.6576461792,
-0.5948600173,
0.3492122889,
-0.2289045453,
0.1730578989,
0.1976748258,
0.1416544467,
-0.1575494111,
1.5161066055,
0.8946686983,
0.0720475763,
0.5350240469,
-0.2080886066,
0.0307135191,
-0.589140892,
-0.1828805357,
-0.3445993364,
-0.1793849021,
-0.1948312521,
-0.3563008904,
0.3994667828,
-0.1646278352,
-0.0299765952,
0.2328169495,
-0.2596818209,
0.3717127144,
0.2148479372,
-0.0377323478,
0.188607499,
-0.3732840717,
0.48631832,
0.098330833,
-0.3601011634,
-0.7103021145,
0.8890529275,
0.2716278434,
0.692168057,
0.1492065042,
0.6371523142,
0.4603459239,
0.4110823572,
-0.5471233726,
0.612552166,
0.4350233078,
-0.5754684806,
-0.4415750802,
-0.1248715445,
-1.0035326481,
0.3909091651,
0.1645787954,
-1.0312178135,
0.4896208346,
0.2478453517,
-0.1613324732,
-0.2566051483,
-0.9863168597,
1.0799629688,
-0.345505923,
-0.5632414818,
-0.4540114403,
-0.5454077721,
0.3977052569,
-0.0049973717,
0.0830133334,
-0.0662505329,
-0.5309200287,
0.3627844155,
-0.6403878331,
1.0005583763,
-0.4830411077,
-0.0657283068,
0.117248334,
-0.1620154232,
0.9845335484,
-0.0165222418,
-0.3576338887,
0.0376464501,
-0.4074219465,
-0.2991639972,
-1.0514391661,
0.6696278453,
-0.6027445197,
-0.6870072484,
-0.3345573545,
-0.6829034686,
-0.2180788964,
0.2680369914,
-0.1150037497,
0.4488076568,
-0.5129902363,
-0.5046926737,
0.6353725195,
0.3659049869,
0.4482413828,
1.0034916401,
-0.0141428774,
0.1143581718,
0.837121129,
-0.269292891,
0.3620289266,
0.4890102744,
0.0245475881,
-0.4207369089,
-0.6760388017,
-0.3624172509,
0.1304476261,
-0.7393098474,
0.2683998942,
-0.893545568,
0.1692047119,
-0.287614435,
-0.3010204136,
-0.1470451355,
-0.1047138423,
-0.2209979892,
0.1406963021,
0.3842771649,
1.2737209797,
0.0223796349,
0.9172388315,
-0.5916874409,
-0.0543137453,
0.1036767289,
0.1302807778,
0.0455147102,
-0.4147577882,
-0.4309210479,
0.0708285198,
-0.0400220603,
-0.9187127352,
0.2937141061,
0.1033458263,
0.9551005363,
0.9095945358,
-0.0210586339,
0.6736465096,
-0.0859057829,
0.461322993,
-0.1703525633,
-1.1583142281,
0.4416780472,
-0.2564794719,
0.1758527607,
0.7101693749,
0.6475204825,
-0.5624426603,
-0.5276843905,
-0.610804081,
-0.6936240792,
1.1229039431,
0.363986969,
0.0935963094,
0.3122063279,
0.577860415,
0.4321398437,
0.2688308954,
-0.5159883499,
-0.312191546,
0.1529071778,
-0.1060668379,
-0.1242765039,
-0.1608924568,
-0.0216365606,
-0.0600000769,
0.6956368089,
-0.2739448249,
-0.0046324828,
-0.0588029101,
-0.3525730371,
0.0720824897,
0.1941488385,
0.4937951267,
0.6442759633,
-0.1917682886,
-0.0348197408,
0.0575069115,
-0.5192480683,
0.1292634159,
0.3346063197,
-0.0918981582,
-0.1178731993,
0.2123869359,
0.5637539625,
0.2995711863,
-0.7960157394,
0.6902380586,
-0.5473838449,
0.1691149175,
-0.3279573023,
0.3454585671,
-0.1975783259,
0.2608451843,
0.214679569,
0.0284687802,
0.6573166251,
-0.3977560103,
0.0543099307,
0.4827569425,
-0.9582530856,
-0.5478082895,
0.4877227247,
0.2888513505,
-0.1561719626,
0.3690064549,
-0.4558764994,
-0.2480179965,
0.2358942926,
0.2172983587,
1.1976270676,
-0.0763420835,
0.2661167681,
-0.0055221389,
0.325116545,
0.1308488399,
0.7101240158,
-0.5241100192,
-0.4660640955,
-0.3256922662,
-0.0399533473,
-0.3849006593,
-0.0171558764,
-0.3820536435,
0.2022355199,
0.0309385881,
-0.0082634641,
0.0473704226,
-0.0664021149,
-0.7130048871,
0.0451276824,
-0.4449926317,
0.6693682671,
-0.7926686406,
0.692813158,
0.6919711232,
-0.6395269632,
-0.6609369516,
0.221895054,
0.1128054485,
-0.6682233214,
0.5259318948,
0.2588281333,
-0.3971576989,
0.0571633875,
-0.6626437902,
-0.8482723236,
0.8090755343,
0.3870285153,
-0.2740600407,
0.1982790083,
0.4438707232,
0.4094558358,
-0.236428827,
0.8397075534,
0.7135062814,
0.8259417415,
-0.0529396981,
-0.4802496731,
0.2080180794,
-0.5161754489,
-0.3072638512,
0.3894042373,
-0.4369419515,
0.5975875854,
-0.2024121881,
-0.3672473133,
0.0996859446,
0.7438095212,
-0.0713653117,
0.5762796998,
0.4976217449,
0.1453152448,
0.7138382792,
0.1453875154,
1.3300145864,
-0.2106028646,
-0.1652072221,
1.12056005,
-0.5169875026,
0.5321657062,
0.4834615886,
0.0761051401,
0.2572395802,
0.4774746895,
0.5842900872,
0.3186815977,
-0.1496577412,
-0.5855355263,
-0.2456683666,
-0.4008348286,
-0.1804464012,
0.4621348083,
0.4600166976,
-0.0580073223,
-0.1669542193,
0.0095651215,
0.2136435509,
0.0637782738,
-0.296434164,
0.8569774032,
-0.1648418754,
-0.6736469865,
0.2151435912,
-0.2510580719,
0.3485613167,
-0.6961576343,
-0.291544497,
-0.0317266621,
0.2701472342,
-0.4325644672,
-1.0674748421,
-0.2075587064,
-0.0359206945,
-0.3116351366,
-0.3015696108,
0.7493923306,
-0.1835821867,
-0.0736034662,
0.2844548821,
0.5752731562,
0.6342409253,
-0.4299047887,
-0.5693385601,
-0.0654758513,
-0.064973563,
-0.2139920443,
0.3206611872,
0.5956593156,
-0.3040133119,
0.764213264,
0.5405383706,
-0.1887778342,
-0.1082349643,
0.2810109556,
0.9409971237,
-0.4560390711,
-0.2835050523,
-0.6539196372,
0.7294357419,
-0.2848044932,
-0.3276073933,
0.8858371377,
0.6887688041,
0.9267346859,
0.1062345877,
0.9927070141,
-0.0067139505,
-0.010508026,
-0.2323142886,
0.533544302,
-0.7070994973,
0.2180587947,
-0.2242544591,
-0.5602583885,
0.2761543095,
0.0362265408,
-0.4358814061,
0.4129794836,
0.3878756166,
1.0242806673,
-0.161765188,
0.0091718687,
0.5413921475,
-0.074222587,
0.3482915461,
0.4419476688,
1.2959342003,
-0.2624723017,
0.4710914791,
-0.2339865863,
-0.473875016,
-0.2646233141,
-0.4969598949,
-0.9331507683,
-0.7350257039,
-0.0773670524,
0.1655872166,
0.33107692,
0.868190527,
0.8507196903,
-0.4215056598,
-0.4575272202,
-0.3150929511,
0.2511671484,
-0.530847609,
-0.2267734259,
0.1494053602,
-0.6204087138,
-1.0453438759,
0.4960229695,
0.3452138007,
0.1149665713,
-0.2422930896,
-0.4735567868,
-0.0383885317,
0.1686875075,
0.4198666215,
0.5558120012,
-0.5710611343,
-0.1458447129,
-0.1323862821,
-0.214974001,
-0.2332137227,
0.9566587806,
-0.715084374,
0.5260024667,
0.4881414175,
0.1689748019,
0.5379481316,
0.0437549502,
0.9280596972,
-0.6140992641,
0.0141237043,
0.2006596476,
0.1759551316,
-0.0660289451,
-0.8226679564,
0.4773580134,
-0.4821480215,
-0.5493996739,
-0.7280266285,
0.1357900053,
-0.8531239033,
-0.266073823,
1.0570912361,
-0.1162075177,
-0.3004227281,
-0.6142380238,
-0.3627981842,
0.0204961244,
-0.9571317434,
0.3229942024,
0.1158735007,
-0.6375555992,
-0.0325584151,
-0.7469909191,
0.911126256,
0.2318796664,
-0.9186105728,
0.1714371443,
0.5194603801,
-0.1776004285,
-0.2017955631,
0.8172767162,
0.2064810097,
0.6930909753,
-0.0031142924,
0.5245464444,
-0.1165311709,
-0.3588389754,
-0.3346093297,
0.0128572742,
0.346832037,
-0.1011668816
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09199v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09199v1
|
Ten Words Only Still Help: Improving Black-Box AI-Generated Text Detection via Proxy-Guided Efficient Re-Sampling
| 2024-02-14T14:32:16 | 2024-02-14T14:32:16 |
Yuhui Shi, Qiang Sheng, Juan Cao, Hao Mi, Beizhe Hu, Danding Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
With the rapidly increasing application of large language models (LLMs),
their abuse has caused many undesirable societal problems such as fake news,
academic dishonesty, and information pollution. This makes AI-generated text
(AIGT) detection of great importance. Among existing methods, white-box methods
are generally superior to black-box methods in terms of performance and
generalizability, but they require access to LLMs' internal states and are not
applicable to black-box settings. In this paper, we propose to estimate word
generation probabilities as pseudo white-box features via multiple re-sampling
to help improve AIGT detection under the black-box setting. Specifically, we
design POGER, a proxy-guided efficient re-sampling method, which selects a
small subset of representative words (e.g., 10 words) for performing multiple
re-sampling in black-box AIGT detection. Experiments on datasets containing
texts from humans and seven LLMs show that POGER outperforms all baselines in
macro F1 under black-box, partial white-box, and out-of-distribution settings
and maintains lower re-sampling costs than its existing counterparts.
|
[
-0.5238592029,
-1.0429059267,
0.7313216925,
-0.074756369,
-0.4733166695,
0.1529290229,
-0.0199137554,
-0.402574718,
0.3364984989,
0.5310410857,
-0.3871036172,
-0.5212597251,
-0.6968701482,
0.2851389945,
-0.6612211466,
0.9889489412,
0.0729464144,
-0.3172911108,
0.0770344287,
0.042173896,
-0.3372509778,
-0.4021492898,
-0.7128481865,
-0.0877059251,
0.2768521905,
0.2474051416,
0.4563296735,
0.4187319875,
0.119357422,
0.327149421,
-0.3024616241,
0.535227716,
-0.4962621033,
-0.0981819406,
-0.006672977,
-0.314424336,
-0.2664783597,
0.1441781372,
0.5543273091,
0.1084965542,
-0.2130179405,
0.2981465161,
-0.0270175897,
0.2103489488,
-0.7288809419,
-0.1549309939,
-0.7870413065,
-0.0853159726,
-0.4128926992,
0.0062426934,
-0.3060086668,
-0.0591133647,
0.0485016778,
-0.5969964266,
0.521143496,
0.2922026515,
0.8279626369,
0.192884028,
-0.1330089867,
-0.2124698162,
-0.286026597,
0.6138772964,
-0.7979413867,
0.1942402124,
0.5303810835,
0.240283668,
-0.4711024463,
-0.9555979371,
-0.9812573791,
-0.3818514347,
-0.1330837309,
0.0109774023,
-0.4094287753,
-0.2889335155,
0.1315555573,
0.1545537412,
-0.2808606625,
-0.1749940962,
-0.3134295046,
-0.5989123583,
0.682299912,
-0.0221290551,
0.4031444192,
-0.0076191281,
-0.1367927343,
-0.3772265613,
-0.7071284652,
-0.0846105069,
0.69864434,
0.009741148,
0.0641333163,
0.3562769592,
-0.0829658359,
0.7702818513,
0.0827678815,
-0.254393667,
0.3562287986,
-0.3093489707,
-0.0318985134,
0.0231493022,
0.9278274775,
-0.0125004789,
0.3355104327,
-0.0286897272,
-0.2443927675,
0.2386466414,
0.6315351129,
-0.6486365199,
-0.3609162569,
-0.0806729272,
-0.4625211954,
-0.4210669696,
0.1933661997,
-1.1113805771,
-0.5389754176,
0.1411106586,
0.4756501913,
-0.1889346391,
-0.3973094225,
0.2079091668,
-0.394207716,
0.0232520346,
0.2140672207,
-0.1564155221,
-0.1064034626,
0.3834391832,
0.7306761742,
0.0115740942,
-0.3017184138,
-0.9702035785,
-0.0482676327,
-0.3767727911,
1.0697102547,
-0.6157943606,
-0.4081008732,
0.1297779828,
0.2070718259,
0.5306926966,
-0.6749657393,
0.3701825738,
-0.197073251,
0.1912626624,
-0.081652686,
-0.2542260587,
0.1684438288,
0.1730367392,
-0.6150599122,
1.0771715641,
-0.0891596824,
-0.7402352095,
0.4385542274,
-0.2932005227,
-0.5391072035,
0.2579962909,
-0.3153582215,
-0.9378526211,
0.5976940393,
0.3475515246,
0.2648897469,
-0.1157717109,
0.3882551491,
-0.3182401955,
-0.6124609709,
-0.0216635391,
-0.5161668062,
0.4105603993,
0.1782390922,
-0.5495846272,
0.0218460429,
-0.7164726257,
-0.1743892729,
0.2390283644,
-0.3010631502,
-0.3913194239,
0.1297179461,
-0.1766895652,
-0.0598524027,
-0.1037004665,
-0.8369256854,
-0.044918105,
-0.2098582387,
0.291405201,
0.6190440655,
0.0169784874,
0.2677483261,
-0.2798088193,
0.780005455,
-0.035231445,
-0.242858544,
-0.2817545831,
-0.7614086866,
-0.4427046776,
-0.4458904266,
0.220853433,
0.4582485557,
-1.3192887306,
0.5301998854,
0.003123628,
-0.4237880409,
-0.8021547794,
0.2346116006,
0.5756629705,
0.3684665859,
0.3823333979,
-0.0952896103,
-0.0011899071,
-0.9704578519,
-0.5424766541,
-0.2659937441,
-0.2516340613,
0.1152768433,
0.4703965485,
-0.2166243345,
0.7848914862,
-0.8209208846,
-0.4719595313,
-0.0965856463,
0.4755003452,
-0.2765851617,
0.0002972333,
0.5018814802,
-0.7329639196,
-0.2830889225,
-0.470377028,
-0.4101928771,
-0.6023569107,
-0.0668785647,
-0.3512339592,
-0.0616637319,
0.8958704472,
-0.000463259,
0.7471776009,
0.5006527305,
-0.4418608546,
0.4333837926,
-0.3194904029,
-0.169482708,
-0.8901417851,
-0.144727394,
0.3289017081,
-0.2565874159,
-0.6338413358,
-0.0827230066,
0.2820896506,
-0.0829558298,
-0.571069777,
1.0131031275,
-0.6557997465,
0.428057909,
-0.7225282788,
0.3164078593,
-0.0531973429,
0.2038590312,
0.052746512,
1.0313290358,
0.2396977693,
-0.4835170507,
0.1664894521,
0.247326225,
-0.4665353,
0.6305913925,
-0.5091803074,
0.1156198829,
-0.5102760196,
0.4330184758,
-1.2142682076,
0.1064461693,
0.3354173899,
-0.5690088868,
0.2786672413,
0.3349942863,
-0.4377891421,
-0.3603058159,
-0.5507665873,
0.1723955423,
0.4991598427,
-0.6813589334,
0.3848610222,
0.6501728892,
0.1270642579,
-0.5308172107,
-0.6896550655,
0.2033777833,
-0.1331289858,
-0.260017395,
0.4236115515,
0.2471432686,
-0.1262096018,
0.2577772737,
-0.2707667053,
0.2620469034,
0.1315183192,
-0.1279082745,
-0.0601247139,
0.1878290623,
0.2060122937,
0.0265396442,
-0.1268090904,
-0.0982327983,
-0.2802682817,
0.5745318532,
0.1876152158,
-0.1669656336,
-0.258954972,
0.3445557356,
0.3283417225,
-0.3724255264,
0.8366155624,
1.0382508039,
-0.4240120947,
-0.6809248924,
-0.5216124058,
-0.3011365533,
-0.476611793,
0.3966476619,
-0.3559908867,
-0.838051796,
0.297101289,
0.0928108767,
0.0791778713,
0.2232111841,
0.4060153067,
-0.0666252747,
0.789752543,
0.5415931344,
-0.2293435037,
0.818518877,
-0.1211520955,
0.5594016314,
-0.8277975321,
0.0144853424,
-0.4398616552,
-0.4574464262,
-0.6289104819,
-0.0211642534,
0.5055059195,
0.0489759296,
0.0066449633,
0.3177171946,
-0.7843254805,
0.1992156506,
0.8688867092,
0.3410789669,
0.0540187396,
0.388574332,
-0.0848460346,
0.3190917969,
-0.4551262259,
-0.4822099805,
1.009776473,
0.1138122156,
0.761507988,
0.0321786851,
0.8139857054,
0.4688689709,
0.8055046797,
-0.4020017385,
0.6265978217,
-0.4069700539,
-0.6187019944,
-0.2555443048,
-0.3916203082,
-0.9779686332,
0.2160515636,
-0.3600417674,
-0.7243404388,
-0.0379190408,
0.4117727578,
-0.2363235801,
0.4367364347,
-0.6463723183,
0.5267214179,
-0.1657578796,
-0.4039899707,
0.1026297435,
-0.1322672963,
0.4015692472,
-0.4255486429,
0.1995550841,
-0.1003788412,
-0.2310521901,
0.6458250284,
-0.4443800449,
0.7902165055,
-0.3968200088,
-0.2543154359,
0.6703431606,
-0.1364330649,
0.7393206954,
0.0553335994,
0.24332802,
0.2630535066,
-0.2134210467,
-0.3228473961,
-0.2237349004,
0.4784286916,
-0.5672386289,
-0.8907669783,
-0.4334106147,
-0.1653228402,
0.0062935683,
-0.0426649489,
0.6127607822,
0.3472431302,
0.3159727752,
0.2360581905,
0.3583301902,
-0.8645244241,
0.4922990799,
0.5061504841,
-0.0430320241,
-0.6241393685,
1.0418616533,
0.0190476011,
0.0821309611,
0.3191700578,
0.3632427156,
-0.5299060941,
-0.5828954577,
-0.5481325984,
0.3736205399,
-0.1911412328,
-0.4279266894,
-0.7580509186,
-0.0680327713,
-0.362333864,
-0.1696018279,
0.0673438162,
0.3023656607,
-0.2122321576,
-0.1112583727,
0.3132516146,
0.3687064052,
0.2179812342,
0.8707905412,
-0.6526725888,
0.8252984881,
0.2988538146,
0.2524039745,
-0.0910861641,
-0.6557075977,
0.0634367168,
-0.0921685323,
-0.3805701435,
-1.1348543167,
0.4925189316,
0.1660596877,
0.7280430198,
0.1892256141,
0.2359776348,
0.7479047179,
-0.5483452678,
0.8274450898,
-0.0102679571,
-0.8173999786,
0.3525449336,
-0.0096336314,
0.4645940065,
0.4686530828,
0.0231513046,
-0.5528749824,
-0.876496911,
-0.7986260653,
-0.8274851441,
0.7183907032,
0.2439338863,
0.3793823123,
-0.4001820683,
0.5524126291,
-0.0991907492,
0.5971762538,
-0.7140631676,
-0.2547006011,
-0.2029214501,
-0.3982866406,
-0.1770561785,
-0.3711619079,
0.2233912647,
0.2925222516,
0.7565997243,
-0.2171657979,
0.536493957,
0.1979284137,
-0.1047366485,
0.0854061544,
0.1298534423,
0.5754143596,
0.2260430604,
-0.0472688749,
0.3671042919,
0.1468745619,
-0.8149328828,
0.420820415,
0.0178598743,
-0.5035123825,
0.1415656954,
0.5542014241,
0.5224747658,
-0.1280282289,
-0.7396854758,
0.5213624835,
-0.15178141,
-0.2048366964,
-0.3088048995,
0.1855041385,
-0.003481596,
0.1131055579,
0.3992577195,
-0.5386219621,
-0.060766127,
-0.5320749879,
0.4617443085,
0.7876666784,
-0.055988472,
-0.0486359745,
0.812243402,
0.1545458138,
-0.740816772,
0.4576530159,
-0.7515437007,
-0.4711630046,
0.595404923,
0.7181195021,
0.9436430335,
-0.0232018605,
0.3887032866,
0.229092434,
0.3296453953,
-0.4329259396,
0.3096750975,
0.0450767577,
-1.0101928711,
-0.2830222547,
-0.86755687,
-0.1155182645,
0.8342692256,
-0.3096922636,
0.3530969024,
-0.3564026356,
-0.424061209,
0.0479295477,
0.0140797598,
-0.5163164735,
0.0669558868,
0.2331229448,
0.8159434199,
-0.9786633849,
0.7261170149,
0.9874581099,
-0.1714008898,
-0.5654988885,
0.318613708,
0.3047361076,
-0.8042328358,
0.0631826892,
0.1177251339,
-0.2411093414,
0.1094966307,
-0.6617090702,
-0.5731902719,
0.826446414,
0.1662193984,
-0.7206402421,
0.0650896505,
-0.2422393858,
0.5465343595,
-0.0564317293,
0.1826622784,
0.6967669129,
0.5705755353,
-0.188969478,
-0.4404406846,
-0.1497442275,
-0.2184339315,
0.0107587157,
0.6050307155,
-0.5375272036,
0.5108412504,
0.2165501714,
-0.3727043271,
-0.0527735278,
0.5326729417,
0.6787053347,
0.3804886639,
0.7779321074,
0.5964647532,
0.5944307446,
-0.0765534192,
1.0021342039,
-0.3139067888,
-0.0108809993,
0.9193924665,
0.0004519634,
0.564191103,
0.1691123247,
-0.1606906801,
0.079617694,
0.3814777136,
-0.1662334651,
0.5000728369,
0.6396918297,
-0.3627966344,
-0.0786837488,
-0.0736610964,
-0.0384241492,
0.4822520018,
0.2159685791,
-0.3369790912,
-0.2878985107,
0.1256995648,
0.3570598066,
0.3238615394,
-0.2364384234,
0.8076770306,
0.0469370447,
-0.7346799374,
0.3299449086,
0.1149694696,
1.1596927643,
-0.4803909063,
-0.0855639204,
-0.4160543382,
0.2362338603,
0.0300906952,
-0.6601788402,
0.1562611461,
0.165765062,
0.1586819291,
-0.1568501592,
0.9153794646,
-0.7395482659,
-0.7439207435,
0.2639322579,
0.7285276055,
0.1639876962,
-0.4170849025,
-0.2882165313,
-0.0600511655,
0.1819806695,
-0.1422920823,
0.3256637156,
0.5388989449,
-0.3674786985,
0.3745061457,
0.7155583501,
0.6594308615,
0.1615868956,
-0.2353792936,
0.4854371846,
-0.7022180557,
-0.4986773133,
-0.9529602528,
0.2411440462,
-0.181307137,
-0.316159606,
0.4753505588,
0.1253556758,
1.1380177736,
0.0317747146,
0.8859128356,
-0.0361396223,
0.3046918213,
-0.3248293996,
0.7287037969,
-0.7802946568,
0.1293869466,
-0.3114280701,
-0.9376977086,
-0.059185531,
0.6701347828,
-0.2851569951,
-0.1441775411,
0.5200536847,
0.8979392052,
0.0775521025,
-0.2373279184,
0.4428906739,
-0.1480434537,
0.7996336222,
0.2483357489,
0.7520226836,
-0.160590589,
0.7530299425,
-0.0845319554,
-0.2623034716,
-0.0557133816,
-0.9616185427,
-0.8012795448,
-0.4738253653,
-0.2394939512,
-0.1999646723,
-0.0707661584,
0.4143201709,
0.6005043983,
-0.7597854137,
0.1608412266,
0.0981564224,
-0.003381371,
-0.2520239055,
-0.1891898066,
0.4189107716,
-0.2435475737,
-0.8269991279,
0.2238339037,
0.0885456428,
-0.059771236,
-0.1288310289,
0.2385637015,
-0.1012766734,
0.0190594215,
0.4828127325,
0.0533213392,
-0.6230882406,
-0.4965049922,
-0.1712925434,
0.1098749265,
-0.3081288636,
0.7301774025,
-0.9801487327,
0.4825899601,
0.4772745669,
0.8766062856,
0.4007615745,
0.430544883,
0.4377640486,
-0.9131447673,
0.2623116076,
-0.0790335909,
0.3928979337,
0.1921842694,
-0.3093827665,
0.4438595772,
0.3335306346,
-0.2982491553,
-0.880853951,
0.1958809495,
-0.0964679345,
-0.5393532515,
1.2585501671,
-0.0120362695,
-0.2925796807,
-0.148609221,
-0.3245933652,
0.2304049283,
-0.6305993795,
0.9016555548,
0.8021712303,
0.0781796873,
-0.4256148338,
-0.5935710073,
0.61481148,
0.1059397981,
-0.9295625091,
-0.20076029,
0.6367737055,
0.1601209342,
0.344022274,
0.7361214161,
0.0452769473,
-0.0247726832,
-0.0563537739,
-0.005360445,
-0.3828856349,
-0.4520355761,
-0.2708315253,
0.2828775048,
-0.2767138779,
-0.5136113763
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09193v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09193v2
|
(Ir)rationality and Cognitive Biases in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-14T14:17:21 | 2024-02-15T11:09:09 |
Olivia Macmillan-Scott, Mirco Musolesi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
Do large language models (LLMs) display rational reasoning? LLMs have been
shown to contain human biases due to the data they have been trained on;
whether this is reflected in rational reasoning remains less clear. In this
paper, we answer this question by evaluating seven language models using tasks
from the cognitive psychology literature. We find that, like humans, LLMs
display irrationality in these tasks. However, the way this irrationality is
displayed does not reflect that shown by humans. When incorrect answers are
given by LLMs to these tasks, they are often incorrect in ways that differ from
human-like biases. On top of this, the LLMs reveal an additional layer of
irrationality in the significant inconsistency of the responses. Aside from the
experimental results, this paper seeks to make a methodological contribution by
showing how we can assess and compare different capabilities of these types of
models, in this case with respect to rational reasoning.
|
[
-0.531088829,
-0.7751960158,
0.9411621094,
0.1776069403,
0.1410772949,
-0.0676208884,
-0.6547831297,
-0.4963944852,
-0.072656244,
0.4792424142,
-0.5857951045,
-0.0358814783,
-0.6679002047,
0.192471236,
-0.0114307171,
0.5604944229,
0.0485519953,
0.5418599248,
-0.3911895156,
-0.3554585278,
-0.538718164,
-0.8110921979,
-0.5127825141,
-0.6972385049,
0.3430219591,
0.4045802653,
0.8766291142,
0.3055943549,
0.3405778706,
0.3273252547,
0.063758105,
-0.1412924081,
-0.4242425859,
0.1673532873,
-0.4326274097,
-0.6507158279,
-0.2888123095,
0.3589246571,
0.3970927,
0.7263891697,
0.2115242928,
0.0876819342,
-0.2419166267,
0.723048687,
-0.4392623603,
0.1636734754,
-0.6787442565,
-0.1086529642,
0.0815392658,
0.0011684357,
-0.7544807792,
-0.205252707,
0.2210576683,
-0.504208982,
-0.0689675659,
0.3187129796,
0.4585461318,
0.1252397448,
-0.6776223779,
-0.5101442933,
-0.8599386811,
1.2049280405,
-0.9039642811,
0.312132597,
0.549574852,
0.2802055776,
-0.132292673,
-0.1199359447,
-0.7677341104,
-0.9994342327,
0.0298378915,
-0.056589134,
0.002197599,
0.0274415109,
0.8304034472,
0.2095931321,
-0.4613869786,
0.1416639984,
-0.1228869185,
-0.1394995004,
0.8100800514,
0.0851651728,
0.2728500068,
-0.0179679804,
-0.2807560563,
-0.2660730481,
-0.5452021956,
-0.0744379535,
0.5299129486,
-0.1270219386,
0.2248446643,
1.0696593523,
-0.274168551,
0.528862536,
0.0392516069,
-0.2537929714,
-0.1396392584,
0.1074010134,
-0.2322116643,
-0.1915392131,
0.5185720325,
0.4366699159,
0.9116905928,
0.0115032243,
-0.4425780773,
0.5568194389,
0.1104146242,
-0.3270263076,
0.059565749,
0.1939998716,
-0.458999604,
-0.0839366764,
-0.289003849,
-0.1980046332,
-0.6395776272,
-0.598897934,
0.223432973,
-0.4624329209,
-0.2479297519,
0.2443074286,
-0.1142824963,
0.2046772242,
0.4851880074,
-0.8232473731,
0.3605904579,
0.6913101673,
0.1936621815,
-0.091986075,
-0.2368000299,
-0.1235095486,
-0.130693078,
-0.3331167102,
0.881519258,
-0.7384320498,
-0.2339111269,
-0.0108277127,
-0.1142757311,
-0.0866680145,
-0.754075408,
0.711799562,
-0.5979870558,
0.2168576568,
-0.7260293961,
-0.7453257442,
-0.4716520607,
0.4722584188,
-0.5707228184,
0.6451986432,
0.1338492483,
-0.7444318533,
0.199156642,
-0.4397827089,
-0.0865733624,
-0.1457297057,
-0.3929290473,
0.1235046312,
0.142885074,
0.0333158299,
0.3103762269,
-0.6200479865,
0.3783575594,
-0.7903879285,
-0.2016387433,
1.022089839,
-0.6486739516,
0.9240462184,
0.191248104,
-0.4126712382,
0.1816966981,
-0.5139378905,
0.1239377558,
0.2054168731,
-0.3743071556,
-0.336748451,
0.2033518106,
0.0429443009,
0.4783043265,
0.1807280928,
-0.4384603798,
0.5209966302,
-0.1366086453,
0.5885982513,
0.8065155745,
-0.3596255779,
0.5964650512,
-0.7889755964,
0.4887123406,
0.0502496697,
-0.0023181774,
0.2279360294,
-0.5728799105,
-0.8856741786,
-0.1975588351,
0.003319304,
0.7386072874,
-0.3880412281,
0.2627872825,
-0.1710539758,
-0.4185799062,
-0.1399111897,
0.0390500836,
0.2525902092,
0.4453312755,
0.0742188916,
-0.0298769549,
-0.3804136217,
-1.3221275806,
-0.5808250904,
-0.2999000251,
-0.1423115283,
0.3456373513,
0.6013101935,
-0.3207963109,
0.7349110842,
-0.249137938,
0.0289189275,
-0.2001451254,
0.1887322217,
-0.1599460095,
0.4174870551,
0.3660154939,
-0.3908700943,
-0.0895843059,
-0.0636996552,
-0.937707901,
-0.1309744865,
-0.0859267339,
-0.0072098011,
0.6172287464,
0.2958196104,
-0.9826667309,
0.2942111492,
0.2940621376,
-0.4926736355,
0.7147192955,
-0.0804474503,
0.1891082525,
-0.4997504652,
-0.0372258984,
0.2570866644,
-0.0912834853,
-0.5149919987,
-0.2490973771,
-0.0397429392,
0.3199302852,
-0.1077051535,
0.5880519152,
-0.4237521291,
-0.3068138659,
-0.2366983742,
0.2454889119,
0.0438065007,
0.5156913996,
0.072179459,
0.4603907168,
0.3534365594,
-0.2522183657,
0.3637884259,
-0.3850600719,
-0.4107559323,
0.475980252,
-0.4487722516,
0.1874906421,
-0.3606219292,
0.451017797,
-0.8949734569,
-0.396902144,
0.1567795277,
-0.439640671,
-0.0360315144,
0.1349105835,
-0.50782758,
-0.3477726877,
-0.2591203749,
0.5538613796,
0.6117559671,
-0.1995646209,
0.6050918102,
0.2627917826,
-0.0722171888,
-0.5603555441,
-0.7357913852,
-0.301301837,
-0.3105151355,
-0.8923934698,
-0.1587223262,
-0.2847645581,
-1.0857694149,
-0.1998583227,
-0.0409867615,
-0.1522358656,
-0.0345774032,
0.1832224578,
0.4487186074,
-0.3933137357,
0.1143161058,
-0.293356806,
0.2555550933,
0.4263835251,
-0.1232905164,
0.5886675119,
-0.3624533117,
-0.6228914857,
-0.4612203836,
0.3406805992,
0.9458759427,
0.0103037897,
0.6676986814,
0.0943472907,
-0.5176155567,
0.0206153691,
-1.0920352936,
-0.345916003,
-0.3723134398,
0.1839198917,
-0.1780367345,
-0.9956931472,
0.729658246,
0.1982659698,
-0.0798441023,
0.5847369432,
0.7892455459,
-0.0300458111,
1.4831441641,
0.1587257683,
0.1191332936,
0.2283678204,
-0.1685370356,
0.1742775887,
-0.8087368608,
-0.2718175054,
-0.4681256413,
-0.0740147382,
-0.5253990889,
-0.3519012332,
-0.0656053573,
0.1868455708,
-0.6611303687,
-0.2240930349,
-0.3281612992,
0.5607526898,
0.3130863607,
-0.1373963952,
0.401206255,
-0.108218573,
0.038021896,
-0.1864989549,
-0.6633270979,
-1.0856844187,
0.979983151,
0.5007513165,
0.6816872954,
0.0433379337,
0.0151172355,
0.3642444909,
0.8974184394,
-0.897611618,
0.6704864502,
0.3606406748,
-0.8943231106,
-0.3547824025,
-0.4302326739,
-0.5859683752,
0.4995917976,
-0.4492675662,
-0.7630550265,
0.0960698947,
0.1212867349,
-0.0056990618,
0.246067062,
-0.9394652247,
0.6330935955,
-0.3829291165,
-0.2030012459,
-0.4355242848,
-0.1902077943,
0.8976461887,
0.0030088273,
0.3709297478,
-0.3491586447,
-0.003867286,
0.7503778934,
-0.123151727,
0.6968228221,
-0.1000026092,
-0.1976832747,
0.2436727434,
0.2137374133,
0.4968671203,
0.2777158916,
-0.2113533318,
-0.0285179019,
-0.0342392772,
-0.6763092875,
-0.6504741907,
0.863614738,
-0.8756941557,
-0.9416908622,
-0.6520349979,
-0.8295913935,
-0.4295312166,
0.2962970436,
0.1280935407,
0.3818309307,
-0.2341925651,
-0.117807053,
0.6180161238,
-0.3459325731,
0.1676460803,
0.4338077009,
-0.3164120018,
-0.1861078441,
0.5288636684,
0.3209753036,
0.527109921,
-0.0678058863,
0.056050878,
-0.3562458754,
-0.3655714989,
-0.2588647008,
0.4001668394,
-0.9992560744,
0.1964298785,
-0.3327577412,
0.0106661478,
-0.5400989652,
-0.2749901414,
-0.2262825966,
-0.4302744567,
-0.133359164,
0.1063914001,
0.3284234405,
1.2449859381,
0.2088092715,
0.0136543987,
-0.3199172616,
0.1406086683,
0.4076221883,
0.2371188849,
0.4076738358,
-0.5282574892,
0.0704861283,
0.3639636636,
-0.1469714493,
-0.7779964209,
0.2529628277,
-0.5117048025,
0.4988387525,
0.5524471402,
0.0880194902,
0.4085920155,
-0.3711053133,
0.6626262665,
0.1321536154,
-0.9551747441,
0.1139981151,
-0.5811504722,
0.2793743312,
0.3310410082,
0.5233249664,
-0.43167454,
-0.4146155715,
-0.6955251694,
-0.3967758715,
0.6678876281,
0.0601565205,
-0.0784713775,
-0.2388570905,
0.2996527553,
-0.0422657169,
-0.1922827959,
-0.9256731272,
-0.060295064,
-0.0514350943,
-0.0275071543,
0.0238670036,
-0.4754192531,
-0.2498330176,
-0.1553404331,
0.614246726,
-0.0319486782,
0.1529061794,
0.3757956922,
-0.1831627637,
-0.1355504394,
0.4961008728,
0.9462704062,
0.9249473214,
-0.1501713991,
0.1533479542,
0.4336310029,
-0.2155623138,
0.2298501581,
-0.3537305295,
0.0518940389,
-0.4404678941,
0.6560435891,
0.5963110924,
-0.0582891107,
-1.1758320332,
0.5059653521,
-0.1630162746,
-0.1387182176,
-0.7444229722,
-0.0355474725,
0.3356595039,
0.3810412288,
0.2852700651,
0.3649227321,
-0.0053789904,
-0.8127570748,
-0.3597120941,
0.706014812,
-0.0653630346,
-0.1680119038,
0.326320678,
-0.0760698766,
-0.4211598635,
0.7792350054,
-0.0740552172,
-0.5153945088,
0.6144632697,
0.4540414214,
0.574616611,
-0.0115964971,
-0.2407958806,
0.088030383,
0.5924714208,
-0.3808295131,
0.1597639322,
0.2498141974,
-0.9759222865,
-0.7086153626,
-0.1557820588,
-0.4551515579,
0.3005076349,
-0.6896787286,
-0.0873973593,
-0.5141253471,
-0.3446637392,
0.1311732978,
-0.0643498898,
-0.4631993175,
0.2069440186,
0.3476144075,
0.9507035017,
-0.8110255003,
0.9080137014,
0.7090927958,
-0.3532200456,
-0.6600897908,
-0.0508709401,
-0.1312635392,
-0.7441589832,
0.932762444,
0.2382283658,
-0.1012328193,
-0.408279568,
-0.7427297235,
-0.8543691039,
0.7296640277,
0.5600611567,
-0.3539601266,
0.1381790787,
0.2983552516,
0.5953720212,
-0.6375184059,
0.5026118159,
0.5529818535,
0.7788494825,
-0.1846345663,
-0.7819173932,
0.0573026501,
-0.1036835909,
0.1572859287,
-0.3256210089,
-0.5258159041,
0.9547553062,
-0.1455682963,
-0.1512667239,
-0.0405521207,
0.5372430682,
0.557481885,
0.2647604644,
0.5837539434,
0.4696520567,
0.7860543728,
-0.0878407359,
1.3146669865,
-0.0841888338,
0.1548288465,
0.7858327627,
-0.6274053454,
0.7668651938,
0.4985488951,
-0.0252516679,
0.3361691535,
0.4978927672,
0.2599315643,
-0.0512363762,
0.544672966,
-0.3449038863,
-0.5966128111,
-0.1221360713,
-0.0631283894,
0.1641402692,
0.5065062642,
-0.1970185339,
0.1559427828,
0.0652561411,
0.2831835449,
0.2115288824,
-0.4140715301,
0.4421825707,
0.1482346654,
-1.1869257689,
0.7159484625,
0.2381925434,
0.7063766122,
-0.2999787331,
0.1555646807,
-0.2042473704,
0.3119332492,
-0.2552424967,
-0.8584702015,
0.3870057464,
0.0897515789,
-0.5517565012,
-0.133275941,
0.68269521,
-0.0725589916,
-0.4086514711,
0.3493613899,
0.5402508378,
0.0252375007,
-0.1899947375,
-0.6624087095,
0.282618016,
0.1065373272,
-0.5370869637,
0.3339220881,
0.4873649776,
-0.579090178,
1.0586285591,
0.6274010539,
-0.082054697,
0.1766030043,
0.018831227,
0.7322280407,
-0.943553865,
0.2059018016,
-0.9259642363,
0.148885861,
-0.0996816754,
-0.2671500742,
0.7804540992,
0.3820073009,
0.8792721629,
-0.2549442649,
0.8778073788,
0.1157458797,
0.4090584219,
-0.4134038389,
0.4596197009,
-0.1418608129,
0.4730128944,
0.0525198057,
-0.9326028228,
-0.1958559453,
0.9712580442,
-0.8561364412,
0.2734191716,
0.7586588264,
0.8118379712,
0.0688619018,
0.2836334407,
0.3268823624,
0.5153703094,
0.0257020108,
0.5112059116,
1.3939653635,
0.0049245432,
0.0159842856,
-0.1087878495,
-0.3480559289,
-0.0670266971,
-0.6450334787,
-1.1581950188,
-0.3278487027,
-0.1585394889,
-0.3176001012,
-0.1822599024,
1.1430029869,
0.4369131327,
-0.7823334932,
-0.4508441687,
0.0566927604,
0.1765353978,
0.1321837753,
-0.2691248655,
-0.0188357234,
-0.1869668365,
-0.5682353973,
0.2064477354,
0.11872264,
-0.0007979815,
-0.6470422745,
-0.0874157846,
-0.1480654329,
0.5037807226,
0.7661725283,
0.141176939,
-1.1665335894,
-0.5696551204,
0.2328644693,
-0.2558742166,
-0.1001439989,
0.780561924,
-0.6862121224,
-0.0514388867,
0.591162324,
0.2265870571,
0.1130616739,
-0.2924087942,
0.64422822,
0.0875181556,
0.1860169023,
0.4829720557,
0.6209965944,
0.3732218742,
-0.1359003186,
0.2507970035,
0.1159699634,
-0.8529447317,
-0.7911313772,
0.4135902524,
-1.226786375,
-0.3372447789,
1.3273535967,
-0.0225634743,
-0.1837294698,
-0.1611354053,
-0.4201131165,
-0.0168261807,
-0.2570513785,
0.7503524423,
1.1928156614,
-0.3328057826,
0.2360812128,
-0.8583604097,
0.3910575807,
0.681007266,
-0.5542418361,
0.2921745777,
0.7848575711,
0.3392561376,
0.1238035187,
0.6851938367,
-0.1076996326,
0.1409964561,
-0.1483678073,
-0.0089765014,
0.3350238204,
0.1205918789,
-0.4173122942,
-0.2004672438,
0.6227054,
0.6714893579
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09177v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09177v1
|
Leveraging the Context through Multi-Round Interactions for Jailbreaking Attacks
| 2024-02-14T13:45:19 | 2024-02-14T13:45:19 |
Yixin Cheng, Markos Georgopoulos, Volkan Cevher, Grigorios G. Chrysos
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are susceptible to Jailbreaking attacks, which
aim to extract harmful information by subtly modifying the attack query. As
defense mechanisms evolve, directly obtaining harmful information becomes
increasingly challenging for Jailbreaking attacks. In this work, inspired by
human practices of indirect context to elicit harmful information, we focus on
a new attack form called Contextual Interaction Attack. The idea relies on the
autoregressive nature of the generation process in LLMs. We contend that the
prior context--the information preceding the attack query--plays a pivotal role
in enabling potent Jailbreaking attacks. Specifically, we propose an approach
that leverages preliminary question-answer pairs to interact with the LLM. By
doing so, we guide the responses of the model toward revealing the 'desired'
harmful information. We conduct experiments on four different LLMs and
demonstrate the efficacy of this attack, which is black-box and can also
transfer across LLMs. We believe this can lead to further developments and
understanding of the context vector in LLMs.
|
[
-0.5171611905,
-1.4471479654,
0.617321372,
0.0691653118,
-0.2026577294,
-0.0571808703,
-0.2349682152,
-0.6640256643,
0.3416272998,
0.8051035404,
-0.5499187112,
-0.0431687944,
-0.6003860831,
-0.0613429137,
-0.4559485316,
0.9512345195,
0.0961213186,
-0.3285043836,
0.0800959766,
-0.0673967525,
-0.8231816888,
-1.0164624453,
-0.4541617632,
0.1417053938,
0.5704653263,
0.2356874198,
0.4848616123,
0.1615660489,
0.4615474641,
0.3283195198,
0.1074690968,
-0.1459176391,
-0.521241188,
0.6386700869,
-0.167398423,
-0.3925073743,
-0.308264941,
0.1446283758,
0.3017475009,
0.4786901772,
-0.0978668854,
-0.1171057671,
-0.155214116,
0.5766513348,
-0.8031154275,
-0.2590631843,
-0.9881374836,
-0.0083188294,
-0.4139632583,
-0.1768569946,
-0.6291611791,
0.0867376626,
-0.0583145283,
-0.1869504899,
-0.4074540436,
0.1452164352,
0.3972977698,
0.0996100456,
-0.485899508,
-0.4077395499,
-0.489664644,
0.3896413445,
-0.7494446635,
0.056203492,
0.2885304391,
0.2713862658,
-0.5062529445,
-0.5446970463,
-0.567345202,
-0.4203403592,
-0.1943867952,
-0.2848668396,
-0.3386431336,
-0.0006600545,
0.3737044632,
0.0108052408,
-0.0843625963,
-0.0988174975,
-0.5329999924,
0.0068889377,
0.5897855163,
0.1374747008,
0.6612157822,
-0.4631923735,
-0.6053993106,
0.0888354853,
-0.9281388521,
0.0758434981,
0.2472190261,
0.2547558844,
-0.2245687842,
0.6741850376,
0.0942013711,
0.9716945887,
0.2822316885,
0.1138394028,
-0.1086017564,
-0.3547143042,
-0.2554296255,
0.1857655495,
0.9027971029,
0.4959465265,
0.0710653365,
-0.3231894374,
-0.0704416782,
-0.379794836,
0.6148887873,
-1.0390956402,
-0.1012476608,
0.2198638618,
-0.0226463564,
-0.5856286883,
0.334830761,
-0.8432359099,
-0.5851168633,
0.0581238866,
0.4041334391,
-0.3405768275,
-0.2208525687,
-0.1495914608,
-0.0363297798,
0.3394290209,
0.109721452,
-0.8671357632,
0.2127085179,
0.4055352509,
0.8301743865,
0.0082070502,
-0.2401923984,
-0.8897935152,
0.5901575089,
-0.1388256699,
0.6192878485,
-0.5354091525,
-0.5705573559,
-0.2226776928,
-0.0063822386,
-0.0232262164,
-0.3714318275,
0.1127802432,
-0.8416290283,
-0.1533655375,
-0.2459980696,
-0.358989507,
0.0464013703,
0.3708258271,
-0.8232133985,
0.670347929,
-0.205462411,
-1.0304448605,
0.0785659775,
-0.729327023,
-0.5715870261,
-0.0305221751,
-0.140127942,
-0.1728856117,
0.164545387,
0.1699426025,
0.5688095689,
0.1054941639,
0.3977686763,
-0.6225794554,
-0.0440515019,
0.5246768594,
-0.2350650579,
0.6604520679,
0.2914090753,
-0.4753857851,
0.1254416704,
-0.5094552636,
-0.2091841996,
0.3802495897,
-0.0566738769,
-0.7879835367,
0.0704123676,
-0.247089088,
0.2879642546,
0.2625280619,
-0.4813686907,
0.4409340322,
-0.42029351,
0.7726962566,
0.7184057236,
0.3641708195,
0.50237602,
-0.0329799838,
0.3477437198,
-0.0064115338,
0.1376642883,
-0.3962708712,
-0.1703560501,
-0.2040110677,
0.0289485287,
-0.1207378432,
0.5293179154,
-0.5839502215,
0.163994208,
0.1206152961,
-0.3494861722,
-0.0315372646,
0.2614790797,
0.2946636081,
0.6009391546,
0.4153535962,
-0.2788418829,
-0.6597437263,
-0.8079574108,
-0.4397586584,
-0.1275081933,
0.1812047511,
0.4182144403,
0.3665269017,
-0.22526519,
1.0561974049,
-0.6223896742,
-0.0142490873,
-0.3085180521,
-0.032434646,
0.0330203138,
0.5494879484,
0.7678588033,
-0.7964208126,
-0.2455759495,
-0.3557032645,
-0.9818114638,
-0.1761767268,
-0.0557173342,
-0.1695278585,
-0.1215665862,
1.1339930296,
-0.4354302287,
0.40789783,
0.3889838159,
-0.575484097,
0.5926848054,
-0.0134611139,
0.2082536966,
-1.1006108522,
-0.1323528886,
-0.0264709815,
-0.2395154387,
-1.1047332287,
0.4007284641,
0.0232704747,
-0.0777158886,
-0.6092755795,
0.7379494309,
-0.5229440928,
0.0168982688,
-0.3397179842,
0.2410728335,
-0.0357349366,
0.1495727599,
-0.1938698739,
0.9353331327,
0.1534901261,
-0.2673348486,
0.1772114336,
0.126993835,
-0.2375307232,
0.5535835624,
-0.7600556612,
0.3957729638,
-0.107800439,
0.3241304159,
-0.9137430787,
-0.3166817725,
0.3126365244,
-0.3398396075,
0.2311066538,
-0.2155243456,
-0.4862052202,
-0.0922206044,
-0.4266541004,
0.5924897194,
0.130647108,
-0.5863626599,
0.5157496333,
0.686570704,
-0.3052333295,
-0.514256835,
-0.6245117188,
0.5244582891,
-0.6827850342,
-0.806902051,
0.1985308826,
-0.1615591943,
-0.659940064,
-0.4696829915,
-0.0554367416,
-0.0318184718,
0.4267825782,
0.3172215819,
0.3830560446,
0.1437028944,
-0.2717634141,
-0.0297692902,
0.2798684537,
0.4067404866,
-0.006860083,
0.5793066621,
-0.044738587,
-0.1688057035,
-0.1969824135,
0.4147578478,
0.6616532803,
-0.258649528,
0.9287627339,
0.1044447124,
-0.2335567474,
0.0121475551,
-0.6916107535,
-0.2926079631,
-0.5617223382,
0.3956294954,
-0.5421898365,
-1.0313416719,
0.4964321256,
-0.1105186418,
-0.1743955314,
-0.0915299654,
0.4843913913,
0.1137647778,
0.8036406636,
0.6599574685,
-0.4116610885,
0.7381289005,
0.0516640991,
0.2254372239,
-1.1344432831,
-0.2108879387,
-0.1932595521,
0.1097772643,
-0.1420923471,
-0.2210756242,
0.3191010952,
0.7165956497,
-0.1987212449,
0.578548491,
-0.2486115098,
0.4501828849,
0.0880681425,
0.218680799,
0.2043673545,
-0.2415964603,
-0.3272001445,
0.1698734164,
-0.4795556366,
-0.4202480614,
1.11467731,
0.2383548319,
0.7819361091,
0.3374200761,
0.6648501754,
0.3395762444,
0.5245277286,
-0.3308844268,
0.4184649885,
0.3611952066,
-0.7012281418,
-0.2339467555,
-0.1158565506,
-0.9561933279,
0.4922971129,
-0.1710134,
-1.3424924612,
-0.1611170173,
0.0939423069,
-0.4316387773,
0.3961544633,
-0.8901036382,
0.9058299661,
-0.3166242242,
-0.6782060862,
-0.0951809958,
-0.9240167141,
0.7665640116,
-0.1708792597,
0.8464375734,
0.1152358502,
0.2749642432,
0.5718538761,
-0.6336430311,
1.059073329,
-0.3662322164,
-0.3319433033,
0.2042571604,
0.2631393969,
0.7357293963,
0.5220469832,
0.0504935831,
-0.1141072959,
-0.1735197008,
-0.2288134247,
-0.6545612216,
0.7760213017,
-0.5328026414,
-1.070971489,
-0.2436849475,
-0.6010915041,
-0.1356143355,
0.2535407841,
-0.037053708,
0.3715449274,
-0.23507227,
-0.0419396386,
0.5732572079,
-0.2624901533,
0.6153167486,
0.4803916514,
-0.3142307997,
-0.3263570666,
0.4696764648,
-0.1986509562,
0.5217357874,
0.058588203,
0.083887659,
0.0077099716,
-0.5310527682,
-0.3020497561,
0.0431885645,
-0.5706322193,
-0.2300810963,
-0.6788992882,
-0.2278555185,
-0.3866802752,
-0.4072762728,
-0.0739448667,
-0.0651536137,
0.1307341307,
-0.2296810299,
0.3604814708,
0.7544649243,
-0.148642987,
0.4652590752,
-0.8766573668,
0.3508134782,
0.496060133,
-0.028569242,
0.1051721051,
-0.1548775434,
-0.0265176184,
-0.0490206853,
-0.2490645945,
-1.497248292,
0.280695796,
-0.2320763618,
0.4218918085,
0.2965275347,
0.1229389235,
0.6332368851,
-0.8766795993,
0.722553134,
0.1824468523,
-0.9995403886,
0.8285239339,
-0.3948761523,
0.2209779173,
0.6685366631,
-0.0398318507,
-0.6277000308,
-0.7891177535,
-0.5339334607,
-1.1437324286,
0.6440556049,
0.1087249815,
0.3950890303,
-0.2027024329,
0.672213614,
-0.1957297772,
0.390902698,
-1.0201265812,
-0.3403606117,
-0.173627317,
0.2213854194,
0.1104242578,
-0.3203230202,
-0.3359707594,
-0.2561911047,
0.2310333252,
0.204713583,
-0.0057412446,
0.2742306292,
-0.5323680639,
0.118253842,
0.4416208565,
0.658869803,
0.450363636,
-0.1592361182,
0.1986850053,
0.1952725351,
-0.5633792281,
0.2936883867,
0.037167415,
-0.1616076082,
-0.4913350344,
0.2935533226,
0.8046483397,
0.3314647079,
-0.7088612318,
0.6458994746,
-0.2215506881,
0.1964248568,
-0.47370103,
0.167022571,
-0.0185401235,
0.4220668674,
0.5541743636,
-0.1742633283,
0.0321544483,
-0.7292149067,
0.5024724007,
0.8259533048,
-0.4664409459,
-0.3250594139,
0.7683552504,
0.1758764982,
-0.2344704568,
0.427715838,
-0.0537637062,
-0.6561620831,
0.6447059512,
0.7429035902,
0.6103774905,
-0.3199206591,
-0.1340705454,
0.2139369547,
0.439552784,
0.3432469368,
-0.1218487471,
-0.3197564781,
-0.6936650872,
-0.5415278077,
-0.4431591332,
-0.2755650282,
0.3927902877,
-0.7194386721,
0.1138627157,
-0.5342740417,
-0.0269067045,
-0.0587230101,
-0.3287885487,
-0.2027816772,
0.0159711223,
0.1791472733,
0.7308262587,
-0.5821362138,
0.9802595377,
0.5826362371,
-0.2830427289,
-0.5987750888,
0.1793073416,
0.1801518947,
-0.631033659,
0.9563881159,
0.5465122461,
-0.0766256973,
-0.1018305272,
-0.7407898307,
-0.864472568,
0.774353683,
0.2096259743,
-0.6036885381,
-0.0861075819,
-0.0935040787,
0.1523622721,
-0.4506224692,
0.1207978204,
0.7527950406,
0.5654808879,
-0.0525491796,
-0.6140620112,
0.4923858345,
-0.369615376,
-0.1467389762,
0.5577008724,
-0.5666598678,
0.6793043017,
-0.4198302627,
-0.0430004038,
0.014916393,
0.6450060606,
0.4229001701,
0.0415597893,
0.6223224998,
0.474262625,
0.3444118798,
0.1264427453,
1.0968610048,
-0.5629121065,
0.0980580151,
1.2876831293,
-0.3792846203,
0.9545987248,
0.9256272316,
0.0220714863,
0.513064146,
0.1562674493,
0.0645379946,
0.6737420559,
0.5843696594,
-0.3969016373,
0.1190805957,
0.3492789268,
-0.3134487271,
0.3706243336,
0.5029281378,
-0.0426605716,
-0.2745447755,
0.553331852,
0.5874422789,
0.0206413735,
-0.2817152143,
0.9436410069,
0.1107018515,
-0.5270447135,
0.4232085347,
0.2845915556,
0.8493936062,
-0.5531522036,
0.1145181432,
-0.0237052888,
-0.1746533811,
-0.1154152527,
-0.5038718581,
0.4288491607,
0.1359101236,
-0.1235616952,
0.0673473105,
0.7809545398,
-0.2265456021,
-0.0824805498,
0.6082481742,
0.3383239508,
-0.1586751491,
0.0049423948,
-0.4723479152,
0.1820293963,
-0.1748679578,
-0.5530253649,
0.7320263386,
0.1490445882,
0.0260894541,
0.4837404788,
0.6890981197,
0.042375654,
0.2403976023,
-0.1709563285,
1.1665065289,
-0.8067523241,
-0.3831396699,
-1.3221313953,
0.4296646118,
-0.3594678342,
0.0245496258,
0.8493738174,
0.2402938902,
0.7601715922,
0.4502316415,
0.91792202,
-0.3015573323,
0.0671240464,
-0.7392119765,
0.7500373721,
-0.2990579009,
0.6754902601,
-0.5289716721,
-0.6380006671,
-0.1317885667,
0.4475459754,
-0.5786632895,
-0.1037311405,
0.708476007,
0.5137453079,
0.0588139109,
-0.041122783,
0.149665162,
0.4840636253,
0.5131288767,
0.5629059672,
0.8569039702,
-0.3050956726,
0.3943644762,
-0.2081256658,
-0.3205142319,
0.0160432588,
-0.932760179,
-1.2910788059,
-0.4293908179,
0.1472967714,
-0.5034779906,
0.3569941521,
0.7514896989,
0.6247578859,
-0.5611422062,
-0.3125670552,
-0.1065218151,
-0.0622213893,
0.3634774089,
-0.2975799739,
0.1184496656,
-0.6094170213,
-0.353521049,
0.7486208081,
0.349011749,
-0.0000121625,
-0.3551740944,
0.1558686942,
-0.3791041672,
0.1661162078,
0.7060244083,
0.3180834353,
-0.5113618374,
-0.3578008115,
-0.3000308573,
-0.0926959887,
0.1003832817,
1.1251914501,
-0.7999001741,
0.2701928914,
0.0174461622,
0.6552095413,
0.4324338138,
0.1190544292,
0.8689906001,
-0.8388377428,
0.5372571945,
-0.201836139,
0.4181756079,
0.2202648968,
-0.6560586095,
0.1618181467,
0.0127800619,
-0.403844595,
-0.9109033942,
0.4823716283,
-0.5646436214,
-0.8564087749,
1.1353952885,
-0.1377434283,
-0.4304738641,
-0.0868771672,
-0.2843282819,
-0.1244586259,
-0.4433537424,
0.8254849911,
0.8545802832,
-0.0508177057,
0.0226416793,
-0.8362534642,
0.5051898956,
0.265663147,
-1.0572557449,
0.157822147,
0.5632789731,
0.3500719666,
0.0860331282,
0.5824110508,
-0.3423210979,
0.1106472984,
-0.4151951373,
-0.2393087447,
-0.1693314612,
-0.363666147,
-0.4214319587,
0.6067779064,
0.0550880879,
0.30856511
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09151v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09151v2
|
Chinese MentalBERT: Domain-Adaptive Pre-training on Social Media for Chinese Mental Health Text Analysis
| 2024-02-14T13:08:25 | 2024-06-12T16:03:31 |
Wei Zhai, Hongzhi Qi, Qing Zhao, Jianqiang Li, Ziqi Wang, Han Wang, Bing Xiang Yang, Guanghui Fu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In the current environment, psychological issues are prevalent and
widespread, with social media serving as a key outlet for individuals to share
their feelings. This results in the generation of vast quantities of data
daily, where negative emotions have the potential to precipitate crisis
situations. There is a recognized need for models capable of efficient
analysis. While pre-trained language models have demonstrated their
effectiveness broadly, there's a noticeable gap in pre-trained models tailored
for specialized domains like psychology. To address this, we have collected a
huge dataset from Chinese social media platforms and enriched it with publicly
available datasets to create a comprehensive database encompassing 3.36 million
text entries. To enhance the model's applicability to psychological text
analysis, we integrated psychological lexicons into the pre-training masking
mechanism. Building on an existing Chinese language model, we performed
adaptive training to develop a model specialized for the psychological domain.
We evaluated our model's performance across six public datasets, where it
demonstrated improvements compared to eight other models. Additionally, in the
qualitative comparison experiment, our model provided psychologically relevant
predictions given the masked sentences. Due to concerns regarding data privacy,
the dataset will not be made publicly available. However, we have made the
pre-trained models and codes publicly accessible to the community via:
https://github.com/zwzzzQAQ/Chinese-MentalBERT.
|
[
-0.3654164076,
-0.635851264,
0.4117198884,
0.8332946897,
-0.3252975643,
-0.0891611874,
-0.5398312211,
-0.4582681954,
0.2814959586,
0.3324058652,
-0.730324924,
-0.646133244,
-0.801849544,
-0.0526075177,
-0.1842618585,
1.2337577343,
0.0270270202,
0.3096442521,
0.1192563847,
-0.0821465552,
-0.2590411901,
-0.9250614047,
-0.6321022511,
-0.1832499802,
0.3933956623,
-0.0270021278,
0.4075915813,
0.0286334846,
0.5820859075,
0.2136636078,
0.2669637203,
0.098948285,
-0.6509391069,
-0.2860670984,
-0.2989008129,
-0.2117880583,
-0.7683339715,
0.0994784012,
0.4487179518,
0.3653198183,
-0.286205858,
0.1917341799,
0.2331761569,
0.6924489141,
-0.7050401568,
0.0591967069,
-0.6357856989,
0.2882941961,
-0.1237447411,
-0.2295224816,
-0.2161585391,
-0.5888467431,
0.2804866731,
-0.7800329924,
0.209813565,
-0.3570756018,
0.7822860479,
0.1780249327,
-0.3216279447,
-0.056440711,
-0.7683631778,
0.4444562793,
-0.6109219193,
0.1200228631,
0.6791422963,
0.2495747954,
0.0978137478,
-0.9582330585,
-0.4906823933,
-0.0701811239,
0.0436781943,
0.3948504031,
-0.0919808075,
0.1107143685,
0.1543526649,
0.0662210733,
-0.7623809576,
-0.2305971682,
-0.3902677298,
-0.2171430588,
1.0128909349,
0.2210008204,
0.5373444557,
0.0235177558,
-0.2071393877,
0.1216099858,
-0.3077834249,
-0.0935999453,
0.0050316774,
0.0505445674,
-0.3172744513,
0.1701497436,
-0.2098437399,
0.4153412282,
0.0369696133,
0.039610602,
0.3462915123,
-0.2013927698,
-0.2828839421,
0.2147464901,
0.8771805167,
0.503267765,
0.6165523529,
0.131871894,
-0.2227926403,
0.1990158856,
0.4861707091,
-0.9029294848,
-0.7798776031,
0.3170834184,
-0.6408813596,
-0.1417171657,
0.104408212,
-0.5357397199,
-0.7556924224,
-0.2836897671,
0.3386000097,
-0.5336350203,
-0.4048376381,
0.3514429033,
0.0910331756,
-0.0517341122,
0.2896068096,
-0.6936115026,
0.4075361192,
0.4193203747,
1.0228914022,
-0.0416437164,
-0.3813215196,
-0.3332664967,
0.0609585792,
-0.3332743645,
0.6340449452,
-0.3936286271,
-0.2000299543,
0.3006018102,
0.1452705413,
-0.1983974129,
-0.3592101634,
0.5711901188,
-0.3684536219,
0.2715356052,
-0.3488248289,
-0.2609828413,
0.0698689073,
0.209762007,
-0.3950468004,
0.8189170361,
0.0795764402,
-0.8862832189,
0.0452114791,
-0.8619620204,
-0.5745254755,
0.1133517474,
0.0296776742,
-0.2810679674,
-0.0161881912,
0.4340514243,
0.7226334214,
-0.1561880112,
0.2063428015,
-0.6102845669,
-0.478613615,
0.484313339,
-0.1148997247,
1.1792283058,
0.2677662969,
-0.1529785246,
0.4093610346,
-0.7417120337,
-0.0219852738,
0.2354306579,
0.1114442497,
-0.4977688789,
0.13160941,
0.3897193074,
0.4402470887,
0.2353798151,
-0.3916429579,
-0.0771641061,
-0.3193894625,
0.4186073542,
0.9098160267,
0.115794301,
0.2012121826,
-0.2499482185,
0.5214893222,
-0.015915107,
0.4349611402,
0.1489196122,
-0.1956464946,
-0.2639885843,
-0.3797947466,
-0.0939704776,
0.6785658598,
-0.7600508928,
0.5543348193,
-0.1629254222,
-0.7634721398,
-0.5250406861,
0.0568098873,
0.1751238406,
0.2492935658,
0.3045264184,
-0.3827970624,
-0.5270802379,
-0.4809964597,
-0.3159866929,
0.0145853506,
-0.3451102078,
0.1592847258,
0.3951121271,
-0.4467720687,
0.6087502837,
-0.8882461786,
-0.6066018343,
-0.2209074646,
0.1855186224,
-0.1083937585,
0.2718043029,
0.6296640635,
-0.8492463231,
-0.6636631489,
-0.1213340908,
-0.8843716383,
-0.2934084237,
-0.1503283381,
-0.3801742792,
0.0023669151,
0.3008136749,
-0.5269513726,
0.3177789748,
0.5454815626,
-0.1415999532,
0.7804906964,
-0.1504883617,
0.0565575063,
-1.1418020725,
0.0858753547,
0.3366332054,
-0.0583491176,
-0.875431776,
-0.1535370052,
0.1016109437,
-0.3338539302,
-0.4274408519,
0.3397151828,
-0.2609251738,
0.3194001019,
-0.4821437597,
0.4091931581,
-0.1621050537,
0.5958945751,
0.2043919712,
0.3794618249,
0.7683247924,
-0.6038085818,
0.4115848243,
0.1153225526,
-0.3163813949,
0.4487935603,
-0.5567696095,
0.1703009456,
-0.2084246427,
0.4219280481,
-0.7825946212,
-0.3857070208,
0.6217151284,
-0.5309894085,
-0.019207526,
0.4566889107,
-0.2626206577,
-0.2840560675,
-0.5358118415,
0.2626478076,
0.2224778682,
-0.3696231842,
0.2699787915,
0.5637654662,
-0.2277876288,
-0.5226978064,
-0.5361756086,
0.0177163556,
-0.2308057696,
-0.4217679799,
0.5296114683,
-0.2708024979,
-0.0150757851,
0.0360508785,
0.0927011818,
-0.4604483247,
0.2029516101,
0.0666474253,
0.3406054974,
-0.2375397235,
0.4184753001,
-0.1504389346,
0.0660216138,
0.417063266,
-0.1622069329,
0.6017642021,
-0.1698659658,
0.0327532776,
-0.6064889431,
0.2141597867,
0.2270269096,
-0.4813279212,
0.9784821272,
0.8254140615,
-1.0351719856,
-0.1586616486,
-0.1932912618,
-0.0680438578,
-0.5005822182,
0.6080028415,
-0.0375458896,
-0.6397190094,
0.368383199,
0.1925252229,
-0.1661719084,
0.1608018577,
0.6707047224,
-0.0727743432,
1.0852811337,
0.8223881721,
-0.4371013045,
0.6626318097,
0.2251461446,
0.2762208581,
-0.4328920543,
0.1547650993,
-0.1767127216,
0.0365583785,
-0.5975888968,
-0.145919174,
0.2308050096,
-0.1067558751,
-0.5306117535,
0.0922602341,
-0.7762244344,
0.1333060712,
0.299308598,
0.4826643467,
0.0624572635,
-0.0870458409,
0.5608044863,
-0.2903235257,
-0.3433077037,
-0.4072545469,
0.9196473956,
0.3171767592,
0.7354637384,
-0.0881047919,
0.5184913874,
0.3672907054,
0.7945936918,
-0.6122531295,
0.4868748784,
-0.2957009077,
-0.6313743591,
-0.2780005336,
-0.3086563051,
-0.7581682205,
0.0999701545,
-0.2607635558,
-1.0120354891,
0.044147443,
0.1252034605,
-0.4284215271,
0.0441481061,
-0.6729332805,
0.880987525,
-0.4901544452,
-0.0757965147,
-0.2618513405,
-0.6167660356,
0.6732373238,
-0.6142274737,
0.0191870406,
-0.1278437078,
0.2902623415,
0.988571167,
-0.1667776853,
0.9288950562,
-0.2953357399,
0.0030400306,
0.1727037281,
-0.3070958853,
0.0845876411,
0.044331938,
0.1109567359,
0.156901136,
0.2990868688,
-0.5403706431,
-0.7401176095,
0.4115153551,
-1.1595510244,
-0.5719020963,
-0.4314127266,
-0.3218871057,
-0.3056066334,
0.3512266874,
0.3921784461,
0.1403278261,
-0.3161973357,
0.1156918928,
0.4864692986,
-0.5920539498,
0.0205716453,
0.4306697845,
-0.2407462895,
-0.4095154107,
1.0472588539,
0.2826636732,
-0.0889535323,
0.3237388432,
0.1174687818,
0.0555228256,
-0.3115274906,
0.3073545396,
0.2755669057,
-0.6201487184,
0.0575987771,
-0.5993824601,
-0.6900544763,
-0.6983795166,
-0.121468775,
-0.305041194,
0.0638811439,
-0.2433445305,
-0.163539663,
0.2496072054,
0.5414950252,
-0.1022933349,
0.6062071919,
-0.8852460384,
0.4180038869,
-0.0936444923,
0.5570882559,
0.1128685251,
-0.262367487,
-0.6371607184,
0.1153584123,
-0.483279705,
-1.1255477667,
0.6239471436,
0.10985291,
0.2862355411,
0.666892767,
0.5368358493,
0.7034459114,
-0.329870075,
0.6779011488,
0.279790163,
-0.9883765578,
0.6763127446,
-0.4334821105,
0.0525962338,
0.396255374,
0.708643198,
-0.8828698993,
-0.2994046807,
-0.4061350226,
-0.7368689775,
0.8487949371,
0.1603818089,
0.3307216465,
0.1119621396,
0.403055042,
-0.1863836199,
0.0702628717,
-0.965847075,
-0.2378309965,
-0.7196513414,
-0.5660142899,
-0.2859905958,
-0.077773504,
-0.2680062056,
-0.3157562315,
0.7236450315,
-0.0516997725,
0.536078155,
0.3752689064,
-0.2673381567,
-0.017918678,
-0.0420294292,
0.5433488488,
0.6075656414,
-0.4698787034,
-0.0501366705,
0.1138624027,
-0.9024032354,
0.0665517226,
0.3902865052,
0.252921313,
-0.2076457888,
0.3617607653,
0.6085380316,
-0.2008399218,
-0.7385724187,
0.6360637546,
-0.2529601157,
-0.3283679783,
-0.6567568183,
-0.0135464426,
0.1555736959,
0.3350490034,
0.3487328589,
-0.2511156499,
0.1550791413,
-0.3957253695,
0.2972895801,
0.0307624936,
-0.6277563572,
-0.5547025204,
0.6884250045,
0.0095470063,
-0.4389088154,
0.6566358209,
-0.028907638,
-0.6501043439,
0.3676435351,
0.464294672,
1.085089922,
-0.3291107714,
0.4601711035,
0.2423078716,
0.4485960007,
-0.0268514939,
0.2103577852,
0.0563940741,
-1.0237011909,
-0.2095318139,
-0.2017432451,
-0.1907723695,
0.5103343129,
-0.8570174575,
0.1498911828,
-0.8130087852,
-0.3081831038,
-0.2724825442,
0.22712107,
-0.6302056313,
0.6234070659,
0.4025485218,
0.8315322399,
-0.9584453106,
1.0606180429,
0.8034954667,
-0.4090538323,
-0.6726070046,
0.5363106728,
-0.0416953377,
-0.6705963016,
0.3904666007,
0.3927249014,
0.0195395928,
-0.1884239316,
-0.6551318765,
-0.5311577916,
0.8974168301,
0.4381391108,
-0.2657175362,
0.0442978814,
0.136660859,
0.953211844,
-0.4403291345,
0.0219877716,
0.3261861503,
0.1952810436,
-0.5234887004,
-0.4831320345,
0.1882049888,
-0.5500258207,
-0.0480858833,
-0.3292674422,
-0.7424299717,
0.6592312455,
0.2087584883,
-0.3771630824,
-0.2682165504,
0.8019971848,
0.4290670156,
0.5395464897,
0.3621459603,
-0.0196144376,
1.042075038,
0.2079518437,
0.8691826463,
-0.5070089698,
0.3734211624,
1.201143384,
-0.4690040946,
0.7360725403,
-0.0477551855,
-0.1384181678,
0.4216937721,
1.0321725607,
0.0579880178,
0.5766272545,
0.1060624793,
-0.3351308405,
-0.1273486167,
-0.2169308066,
-0.3729864657,
0.1313902289,
0.4830231667,
-0.3508859575,
0.1275801063,
0.1813851148,
-0.1578162611,
0.1791582853,
-0.3490828574,
0.408916831,
0.2730543315,
-0.3446230888,
0.5333220959,
0.0889441594,
0.6417514682,
-0.6976438165,
0.2924245894,
-0.2287628949,
0.3647651374,
-0.314817965,
-0.4918434322,
0.3455231786,
0.0230714176,
-0.0625319406,
-0.0848270282,
1.1572816372,
-0.3691615462,
-0.4590330422,
0.6118453741,
0.4964564145,
0.1066340134,
-0.5198707581,
-0.840631187,
-0.2647125423,
-0.2121098191,
-0.413764447,
0.4703114033,
0.5835790038,
-0.2328091562,
0.5367931128,
0.5346625447,
0.3156354725,
-0.1920690089,
0.2984680831,
0.8225601912,
-0.7926926017,
-0.6022452116,
-0.9419031739,
0.3496434093,
-0.2427417934,
-0.3860679567,
0.5446360111,
0.1418094784,
0.8267246485,
-0.1075110808,
1.0338443518,
0.2056620866,
0.2532993257,
-0.1849066913,
1.1857839823,
-0.6231079698,
-0.0923447981,
-0.4972593188,
-0.8151853085,
-0.4822191894,
0.7961900234,
-0.5016828775,
0.0222421531,
0.6076251864,
0.8076677322,
0.104455933,
0.0529239662,
0.1675306559,
0.319124788,
0.3810925782,
0.6395468116,
0.8504493833,
-0.2086218596,
0.3382048011,
-0.3357000649,
-0.3654743731,
-0.0154185891,
-0.6491904259,
-1.0105601549,
-0.6854607463,
-0.2948991358,
-0.3690297008,
0.1831670702,
1.1551843882,
0.5681393743,
-0.7207490206,
-0.1668306589,
0.1597215533,
-0.0987974331,
-0.2957217991,
-0.2925409973,
0.6289464235,
-0.1500586271,
-0.3769622445,
-0.3242976964,
0.1504247934,
-0.1377892047,
-0.1544046402,
-0.0674045533,
-0.1772544682,
0.2751015425,
0.7535653114,
0.1022603214,
-0.2990416884,
-0.2400266528,
0.0994883627,
-0.3339444399,
0.0422772989,
0.8989188075,
-0.3046819866,
0.3506009877,
0.2614395916,
0.7899619937,
0.2923126817,
0.0141617712,
0.696280539,
-0.5659964085,
0.0196261797,
0.0508293472,
0.3259963095,
0.3551502228,
-0.6378053427,
0.3976180255,
0.3338112235,
-0.3512150049,
-0.8398171663,
-0.1023291647,
-0.8072749972,
-0.6140660644,
0.9389520288,
-0.4133975208,
-0.1377904564,
0.0134639172,
-0.4836681783,
0.7022322416,
-0.2230050415,
1.3152016401,
0.9628180861,
-0.0913367122,
-0.1808226407,
-0.5412842631,
0.5559097528,
0.3617115915,
-0.8899353147,
0.1720855683,
0.1470510811,
0.1625224799,
-0.0902635679,
1.2077044249,
0.1364195794,
0.4496431351,
-0.2661141753,
0.2661628127,
0.3361982405,
-0.1544947475,
-0.3608222306,
0.0688408911,
-0.1510292441,
-0.08968582
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09141v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09141v1
|
Advancing NLP Models with Strategic Text Augmentation: A Comprehensive Study of Augmentation Methods and Curriculum Strategies
| 2024-02-14T12:41:09 | 2024-02-14T12:41:09 |
Himmet Toprak Kesgin, Mehmet Fatih Amasyali
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This study conducts a thorough evaluation of text augmentation techniques
across a variety of datasets and natural language processing (NLP) tasks to
address the lack of reliable, generalized evidence for these methods. It
examines the effectiveness of these techniques in augmenting training sets to
improve performance in tasks such as topic classification, sentiment analysis,
and offensive language detection. The research emphasizes not only the
augmentation methods, but also the strategic order in which real and augmented
instances are introduced during training. A major contribution is the
development and evaluation of Modified Cyclical Curriculum Learning (MCCL) for
augmented datasets, which represents a novel approach in the field. Results
show that specific augmentation methods, especially when integrated with MCCL,
significantly outperform traditional training approaches in NLP model
performance. These results underscore the need for careful selection of
augmentation techniques and sequencing strategies to optimize the balance
between speed and quality improvement in various NLP tasks. The study concludes
that the use of augmentation methods, especially in conjunction with MCCL,
leads to improved results in various classification tasks, providing a
foundation for future advances in text augmentation strategies in NLP.
|
[
-0.4466458261,
-0.7981866598,
0.1692369282,
0.2577179074,
-0.0550579168,
0.5620186329,
-0.387973249,
-0.6199865937,
-0.0322908498,
0.6108202934,
-0.6478776932,
-0.5256407261,
-0.6387913227,
0.3569685519,
-0.4055162072,
1.0380527973,
0.1810833067,
0.0967287198,
-0.3094248474,
-0.3102964759,
-0.7680573463,
-0.8158971071,
-0.7225788832,
-0.4659971297,
0.3071000576,
0.3528919518,
0.6997477412,
0.6231334805,
0.8415855169,
0.2899932861,
-0.2905305624,
0.5292491913,
-0.3168950975,
0.1135338098,
-0.2912909985,
-0.2892781794,
-0.4855921268,
-0.0189600326,
0.7431820035,
0.8815749884,
-0.1659884453,
0.1050150916,
0.1230728328,
0.7279286385,
-0.7931611538,
-0.0540650785,
-0.4823257029,
0.1501292735,
-0.2074246407,
-0.3671320677,
-0.50355196,
-0.2426196933,
0.4009425342,
-0.5104125738,
0.1743575931,
0.0429857709,
0.4342736602,
0.0274355747,
-0.4110130966,
-0.5598959327,
-0.7300589085,
1.0728727579,
-0.933252275,
0.2046295255,
0.2767443359,
-0.0863961652,
0.0599730723,
-0.9067103267,
-0.3504980206,
-0.1786215454,
-0.0711633042,
0.203976959,
0.1868475527,
0.4132569134,
0.4896165431,
0.5950404406,
-0.5526575446,
0.2872622013,
-0.3403331339,
0.1420856714,
0.7163817286,
0.1977409571,
0.4511317611,
-0.1125711575,
-0.3588854373,
-0.2696585059,
-0.404250741,
0.1520501226,
0.4832638204,
0.302220732,
0.2392555028,
0.8467125297,
-0.2152531147,
0.867244482,
-0.0918788463,
-0.0031452207,
0.4049364626,
-0.7556682229,
-0.1224447563,
0.3738901913,
0.474799037,
0.3384004533,
0.04237023,
-0.1078964919,
-0.3437735736,
0.22382842,
0.6856001019,
-0.5302065015,
-0.0544215068,
0.0823489577,
-0.3802215457,
-0.6515716314,
0.0207856763,
-0.746244967,
-0.1444128305,
-0.6434572339,
0.2183830142,
-0.7643069029,
-0.049113147,
0.2657344043,
-0.2338436544,
0.2218688428,
0.0911682397,
-1.0736764669,
0.4091819525,
0.9740145802,
0.8231325746,
-0.4994434416,
-0.0018748259,
-0.1403872818,
0.0468042232,
-0.4357346892,
0.7656999826,
-0.9954609275,
-0.4911204278,
0.3739672303,
-0.2754992843,
-0.0837166533,
-0.6002241969,
1.0870292187,
-0.687584281,
0.4991437793,
-0.2448316813,
-0.7124818563,
-0.4501949549,
0.4315389395,
-0.7294006348,
1.3655118942,
-0.0712211654,
-0.6938510537,
0.3150741756,
-0.9238609672,
-0.4440942705,
-0.002588175,
0.185066402,
-0.3241969347,
-0.0326923504,
0.5880122185,
0.2192912251,
0.0024309095,
0.2802305818,
-0.0484466478,
-0.4807645082,
0.1417479962,
-0.4890805185,
0.8519420624,
0.0128143309,
-0.18448852,
0.1396097243,
-0.8768895268,
0.136531651,
-0.1200582385,
-0.4692472816,
-0.4373873174,
0.2072651386,
0.077184312,
0.1825160533,
0.197408855,
-0.2586160004,
0.3017694354,
-0.9372868538,
0.0760992542,
0.5599321723,
0.2158451229,
0.6705793142,
-0.4622522891,
0.3796741366,
-0.132573247,
0.0268187989,
-0.5512927175,
-0.4145424366,
-0.8587765098,
0.0749501064,
0.3241831958,
0.7440055013,
-1.0012530088,
0.5786543489,
-0.1623743623,
-0.4380856752,
-0.3312723041,
0.0741121843,
0.3456737101,
0.5379956365,
0.6855865717,
-0.5965507627,
-0.9229940772,
-0.5926559567,
-0.4894564152,
-0.1435369253,
0.1045778245,
-0.1543123871,
0.2933169305,
-0.1757547557,
0.9709438086,
-0.3611400127,
-0.0813653767,
-0.3827238679,
0.5289819241,
0.1403626204,
0.5975136757,
0.4137374163,
-0.827015698,
-0.2533605099,
-0.0290988386,
-0.7506836057,
-0.1629569381,
-0.2259846628,
0.2596571445,
0.1088918447,
0.3619116545,
-0.0278611127,
0.3193893731,
0.4034443498,
-0.0647548586,
0.7937010527,
-0.0616600774,
0.3269511759,
-0.7988057733,
-0.3492491543,
0.1658824384,
-0.1487222314,
-0.9283307791,
0.2361349463,
-0.1318902075,
-0.0005241862,
-0.1604308933,
0.2015834749,
-0.385153085,
0.1450017989,
-0.5533385277,
0.1658449024,
0.0338803492,
0.2171145231,
0.1621510088,
0.8805672526,
0.3726908565,
-0.5475634336,
0.3414738774,
0.2320804745,
-0.2898423076,
0.4354523122,
-0.5835407972,
-0.0085695321,
-0.1270584017,
0.1543424875,
-0.8452022076,
0.1107279509,
0.152299881,
-0.4126569033,
0.4649187624,
0.233090356,
-0.4373196065,
-0.3070493937,
-0.3555341065,
0.307274878,
0.3478569984,
-0.4675813019,
0.3269908428,
0.2472557724,
-0.3044225276,
-0.8822744489,
-0.7177259922,
0.346151799,
-0.2335043252,
-0.4964437187,
0.7265333533,
0.025861416,
-0.2377262115,
-0.2806037068,
0.0238358751,
-0.2598854601,
-0.1035347655,
-0.13661623,
0.4006054699,
-0.2604420781,
0.1809755713,
0.0818473175,
-0.0405734219,
0.1583257318,
-0.3059362769,
0.5560085773,
-0.0555833727,
-0.3580702543,
-0.3161824644,
0.2545621991,
-0.0276435483,
-0.3507233262,
0.9389925003,
0.9640147686,
-0.2754946649,
0.0078761671,
-0.81409657,
-0.2940026224,
-0.5168170333,
0.4349749386,
0.06867484,
-0.8549392223,
0.1312540323,
-0.2156090736,
0.2717357576,
0.3496512473,
0.275449872,
-0.0424302444,
1.0975168943,
0.7205773592,
0.1278557181,
0.692697823,
-0.3575128019,
0.2650501132,
-1.080316782,
-0.1643643975,
-0.4597735405,
-0.2088549882,
-0.7287674546,
-0.5312944651,
0.0055274521,
-0.0538895726,
-0.0632129312,
0.3410430551,
-0.808301568,
0.4662216902,
0.3572387695,
0.2872501016,
0.530167222,
0.1243940517,
-0.097961396,
-0.4039102197,
-0.8578712344,
-0.7018147707,
1.1657086611,
0.2801375985,
0.2124468535,
0.0123640103,
0.5427993536,
0.3858312666,
0.2395223081,
-0.6976879835,
0.545398891,
-0.1983862817,
-0.5201848745,
-0.2177090347,
-0.2701528072,
-0.6850901842,
0.2198501527,
-0.6124507189,
-0.5972145796,
0.2138603926,
-0.1467592865,
-0.176654771,
0.259001404,
-0.4497245252,
0.500472188,
-0.1720595956,
-0.2768369615,
-0.2894299924,
-0.6039065719,
0.5102694631,
-0.1340866536,
0.1381635517,
0.2035082579,
-0.3648394644,
0.8780258298,
-0.1131720692,
0.6702779531,
0.1257808208,
0.0487150736,
0.3186555505,
-0.4809648395,
0.4242736697,
-0.1058822051,
-0.2850986123,
0.0866633728,
-0.0505765527,
-0.3393016756,
-0.6678046584,
0.4905723631,
-0.4798805416,
-0.525639236,
-0.5875755548,
-0.709166646,
-0.3688626587,
0.0235489961,
0.0469131246,
0.5281620622,
-0.2223352492,
0.3961077332,
0.8508812189,
-0.3649908006,
0.717022717,
0.1808733791,
-0.0094950888,
-0.545794189,
0.7922540903,
0.0873821601,
0.3814319968,
0.4263381064,
-0.0225631911,
-0.4334121346,
-0.8528236747,
-0.108714968,
-0.1170390025,
-0.697281301,
0.0195295699,
-0.7117856145,
-0.5115433931,
-0.5337482691,
-0.3528292179,
-0.1612055004,
-0.6125831604,
-0.3087137043,
-0.1086428985,
0.1915117651,
0.4657703936,
0.1051841229,
0.7252488732,
-0.8437306285,
0.183864966,
-0.0009327097,
-0.0352272615,
0.0561365299,
-0.6127303839,
-0.2309304923,
0.1207488403,
-0.6904640198,
-0.8979520798,
0.5214284062,
0.2434475273,
0.5485334396,
0.2453345209,
-0.0203604829,
0.8749876022,
-0.5454795361,
0.9576278329,
0.2746336758,
-0.8428789377,
0.5896468163,
-0.3643313646,
0.2417030483,
0.6442784667,
0.4086067677,
-0.4293736517,
-0.2200096846,
-0.7552863359,
-1.0831654072,
0.6286967993,
0.4204560518,
0.2896478474,
0.0400697887,
0.4029681385,
-0.2469579428,
0.4322327375,
-0.7131689787,
-0.3042691946,
0.01743415,
-0.2336203009,
0.0449563749,
-0.3931949139,
0.0178606696,
-0.3251019716,
0.8544049263,
-0.0131598162,
0.0528888069,
0.1501280814,
-0.0169665087,
0.2346485406,
0.281632185,
0.4763703644,
0.8571979403,
-0.0902845562,
-0.3107153475,
0.4950216115,
-0.6593186855,
0.0968183503,
0.0316595398,
-0.0928977951,
0.1564146578,
0.5176655054,
0.6219886541,
0.3726919591,
-0.6413072944,
0.2934704423,
0.1533382982,
-0.0374643654,
-0.2008433789,
0.1357749701,
-0.3756682873,
0.2075612843,
0.4517542422,
0.2126603574,
0.5503969789,
-0.4573929012,
0.3945355415,
0.4281877577,
-0.5131442547,
0.0854474902,
0.1794460267,
-0.0221047681,
-0.2865673006,
0.4732974768,
-0.1078316048,
-0.5055758357,
0.5349833965,
0.6992641091,
0.6412094235,
-0.3701847196,
0.3089470565,
0.6177170277,
0.6004189253,
-0.2765232325,
-0.0458859168,
-0.0431159548,
-0.6468687654,
-0.879116416,
-0.5775709748,
-0.4998060763,
-0.1582661718,
-0.8684398532,
0.3962902725,
-0.2906012535,
-0.254237175,
-0.1151523963,
0.2200453877,
-0.2862243652,
0.4556574821,
-0.003658273,
0.9620194435,
-0.5797876716,
0.5751144886,
0.7749413848,
-0.3058066368,
-0.4282779396,
-0.0065275338,
0.0692813322,
-0.4437078536,
0.5435058475,
0.2914940715,
0.1600218862,
0.0305635594,
-0.2993305624,
-0.7420392632,
0.8819098473,
-0.2491943389,
-0.5021067262,
-0.2772204578,
0.4427498877,
0.6735495329,
-0.410061568,
0.3633122742,
0.6244136095,
0.4274038076,
0.2414772809,
-0.5011101365,
-0.2354236841,
-0.0674298257,
0.3152680099,
0.1571860313,
-0.2223433852,
0.3688468635,
0.0868593752,
-0.1080793813,
0.1261187047,
0.8968815804,
0.3626842499,
0.5118772388,
0.3995668888,
0.670329988,
0.5601758361,
-0.3302824497,
0.8722494841,
-0.2143418491,
0.3367926776,
1.1642332077,
-0.1022253707,
0.7554574609,
0.3701896369,
-0.1351691633,
0.5924922824,
0.6637859941,
-0.1095232442,
0.4341607392,
-0.0139481667,
-0.4200932682,
0.0259174351,
-0.3930693269,
-0.3625644445,
0.4138301015,
0.6934939027,
-0.4720841348,
-0.1811754405,
0.2931064069,
-0.1200623363,
0.3524635136,
-0.3708812296,
0.9483218789,
0.0069729025,
-0.6427668929,
0.3060232699,
0.2416010499,
0.8285113573,
-0.5819191337,
-0.128027603,
0.2860517502,
0.0402245447,
-0.2653734088,
-0.8334386945,
0.747518599,
0.0073668887,
-0.1517312527,
-0.3695652187,
0.9410785437,
-0.3590888083,
-0.6704935431,
0.0716261938,
0.2974849939,
-0.3282174766,
0.1181459948,
-0.9042862058,
0.0209103674,
-0.1467771381,
-0.0559687167,
0.2459759116,
0.2536376417,
0.1285122782,
0.4682536721,
1.0440350771,
0.23432073,
0.0381988212,
0.0979924053,
0.9066012502,
-0.4764260352,
-0.3064247966,
-0.8725232482,
0.6515663862,
-0.5597080588,
-0.1632321328,
0.9291241765,
0.5585017204,
0.9611352086,
0.1363925338,
0.5691791177,
0.176522851,
0.4934597909,
-0.7014589906,
0.2524575889,
-0.2295211554,
0.4916525781,
-0.4600465596,
-1.1036102772,
-0.3925353587,
0.5841034055,
-0.6152510643,
0.1073230505,
0.718670547,
0.5890911222,
0.1318999976,
0.4670524299,
0.1619192213,
-0.2107573748,
0.2996155322,
0.1262809187,
0.8531078696,
-0.652505517,
0.2492143214,
-0.6226215363,
-0.2313046753,
0.0570506491,
-0.9090556502,
-0.8149231076,
-0.4784698486,
-0.3119009137,
-0.2039494365,
0.3987770081,
0.9593648911,
0.5123186111,
-0.7585464716,
-0.2619695067,
-0.2187876999,
-0.0195823424,
-0.4448564053,
-0.3556590378,
0.1283937544,
-0.9125306606,
-0.8314441442,
0.4815014005,
0.4111063778,
-0.2056891173,
-0.0860096365,
0.184659332,
-0.6929078698,
0.2194071114,
0.9349113107,
0.082874544,
-0.5407857895,
0.0854810476,
0.1284221858,
0.1324947476,
0.1715259552,
0.9036989212,
-0.7384663224,
0.6419962645,
0.4643675685,
0.9248822927,
0.2055212855,
0.269530952,
0.5807179809,
-0.9992530942,
0.1128674746,
0.5053266883,
0.0868623257,
0.462364465,
-0.3092268407,
0.699319005,
0.183848694,
-0.6708701253,
-0.8650823832,
-0.0142599074,
-0.9097881913,
-0.1608704329,
0.928725183,
0.0783103108,
0.1018409133,
-0.2561248243,
-0.3482942283,
0.2819631398,
-0.1942254305,
0.7568897009,
0.9582886696,
-0.0767216533,
-0.1640093774,
-0.7498176098,
0.5019307733,
0.4254137576,
-0.9000054002,
-0.2570808232,
0.4205736518,
-0.3453329504,
0.4119687974,
0.1433069408,
-0.2669693232,
0.075206317,
-0.3441907167,
-0.2060679495,
0.0405674055,
-0.2774718404,
-0.3360826969,
0.1613639742,
-0.1558759362,
0.0198031347
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09136v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09136v1
|
DolphCoder: Echo-Locating Code Large Language Models with Diverse and Multi-Objective Instruction Tuning
| 2024-02-14T12:34:58 | 2024-02-14T12:34:58 |
Yejie Wang, Keqing He, Guanting Dong, Pei Wang, Weihao Zeng, Muxi Diao, Yutao Mou, Mengdi Zhang, Jingang Wang, Xunliang Cai, Weiran Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Code Large Language Models (Code LLMs) have demonstrated outstanding
performance in code-related tasks. Several instruction tuning approaches have
been proposed to boost the code generation performance of pre-trained Code
LLMs. In this paper, we introduce a diverse instruction model (DolphCoder) with
self-evaluating for code generation. It learns diverse instruction targets and
combines a code evaluation objective to enhance its code generation ability.
Our model achieves superior performance on the HumanEval and MBPP benchmarks,
demonstrating new insights for future code instruction tuning work. Our key
findings are: (1) Augmenting more diverse responses with distinct reasoning
paths increases the code capability of LLMs. (2) Improving one's ability to
evaluate the correctness of code solutions also enhances their ability to
create it.
|
[
-0.4627299011,
-0.4975360334,
0.4297583401,
0.1510347426,
-0.1640651226,
0.2825460732,
-0.4440865219,
-0.4165266156,
-0.0562945567,
0.5647580624,
-0.5348489881,
-0.651756525,
-0.5488081574,
0.0514227673,
0.1053036079,
0.9606288075,
0.1672863513,
0.2902907431,
0.3090593815,
-0.0419856757,
-0.5364215374,
-0.4166727662,
-0.105384782,
0.0338122658,
0.4281578362,
0.7824041247,
0.3818746209,
0.9017298818,
0.7584116459,
0.3554633856,
0.1647407711,
0.432757169,
-0.6501906514,
0.3244452178,
-0.1342005879,
-0.5022954345,
-0.5372402668,
-0.0675832033,
0.6845231056,
0.4420853555,
-0.1712462306,
0.3554256856,
-0.0243283156,
0.4757865667,
-0.897053957,
-0.3584265113,
-0.7675758004,
-0.0720988289,
-0.1026361883,
-0.4968758821,
-0.4029764831,
-0.3947565258,
-0.3574635983,
-0.0583888106,
0.2915607095,
0.2088598907,
0.259434253,
0.3987133205,
-0.4216915965,
-0.6699391603,
-0.5530044436,
1.2307192087,
-0.665844202,
0.3754457831,
-0.0532131083,
0.2356174439,
-0.0600256063,
-0.5525799394,
-0.3640500307,
-0.2474707365,
0.3678639233,
0.1640671492,
-0.2061208636,
-0.0070765116,
0.1631078869,
0.8384233117,
-0.4469091296,
0.5381898284,
-0.2444490641,
-0.0816514865,
0.7089388371,
0.3266580403,
0.4099927545,
-0.0626484603,
-0.3398658931,
0.0242296029,
-0.5266315341,
-0.2780350149,
0.6851226687,
0.4385947883,
-0.2639546692,
0.4755996764,
0.0387394503,
0.8338912129,
0.2906145155,
-0.2287459075,
0.3426989317,
-0.1829201877,
-0.1225934848,
0.2222625464,
0.4104788303,
0.3167420626,
-0.1743021309,
-0.0472680032,
-0.3490570784,
0.0086793359,
0.6372916698,
-0.7409753203,
-0.0875286311,
0.0775853693,
-0.8814763427,
-0.2325366586,
0.0084249265,
-0.725432992,
0.0004544022,
-0.3612061739,
0.1308661848,
-0.3722113669,
-0.3546364009,
0.2212115228,
-0.0316480063,
0.3871439695,
0.3161728382,
-1.0460606813,
0.1208405346,
0.6990860105,
0.4886806309,
-0.2523190379,
-0.6250012517,
-0.8014908433,
0.1540774703,
-0.5711196065,
0.7263502479,
-1.0958132744,
-0.5491341352,
-0.1388363093,
-0.2436936796,
-0.0434591174,
-0.8323733807,
0.3795644641,
-0.3744217455,
0.2073723972,
-0.1827040464,
-0.7149319649,
-0.0674279034,
-0.0148686972,
-0.3606814742,
0.8321627975,
0.3249820769,
-0.7466164231,
0.210747987,
-0.6967264414,
-0.4631005526,
0.1919641793,
-0.2365307063,
-0.3901093006,
0.5034319758,
0.223798126,
0.3408897221,
-0.3813236654,
0.0100716902,
-0.3909044266,
-0.6234818697,
-0.0323009603,
-0.3364538848,
0.6178429127,
0.521236062,
-0.5590993166,
0.3474439383,
-0.6370041966,
0.3295631707,
0.0002717762,
-0.4981944263,
-0.0271503497,
-0.2913428545,
-0.1371780187,
-0.038485162,
0.3785514534,
-0.292303443,
0.3489177227,
0.0570929796,
0.1314670295,
0.7674024105,
0.0344146043,
0.3234924078,
-0.5478841662,
0.7992711067,
-0.1638723761,
0.1731314361,
-0.4345689416,
-0.4019154012,
-0.7209719419,
-0.6417917013,
-0.069693096,
0.4671352506,
-0.2500099242,
0.6355701089,
0.1929765642,
-0.5661022663,
-0.8527198434,
0.2157715112,
0.6095273495,
0.3893774152,
0.4582473934,
-0.0664219931,
-0.6696570516,
-0.8321805,
-0.1903208196,
0.1196204722,
-0.0287130438,
0.5531890988,
0.3536972106,
-0.6088493466,
0.1952400655,
-0.4133994877,
0.0544415303,
-0.4119819701,
0.0851392522,
0.5058705807,
0.5729925632,
0.4890418053,
-0.4271951914,
-0.3889802694,
-0.1499760002,
-0.5472859144,
-0.2530655265,
0.0406551398,
-0.2100746632,
0.1538088322,
0.141133368,
-0.1930531114,
0.0311888382,
0.8203321099,
0.1106579751,
0.4909360409,
-0.5072907805,
0.6043614149,
-1.0249267817,
-0.0372303911,
-0.352532953,
-0.022324279,
-0.2793550193,
0.6712192893,
0.1492437273,
-0.2030818164,
-0.134431839,
0.2844833136,
-0.7267190218,
-0.2437220216,
-0.4361870587,
-0.2448255271,
-0.3124060631,
0.346685648,
0.0964483842,
0.8650172353,
0.8415931463,
-0.6309395432,
0.1749353707,
-0.1749869138,
-0.5148223042,
0.4282955825,
-0.5674485564,
0.5367880464,
0.0870822072,
-0.1437795758,
-0.9323878288,
-0.2087614834,
0.085633643,
-0.0962208584,
0.5566024184,
-0.1547052413,
-0.3504945636,
-0.4207155704,
-0.4046800137,
0.3887082934,
0.8554397225,
-0.9054389596,
0.199124828,
0.3495126963,
-0.003693576,
-0.5951089859,
-0.2276721746,
-0.0683004484,
-0.3121202886,
-0.3487292826,
0.2786412835,
-0.2647257745,
-0.2107802629,
-0.3414785862,
-0.3128624856,
-0.0049759345,
0.168505758,
0.0909206197,
0.1596052647,
-0.4311869144,
0.3273213506,
0.3734725416,
-0.0922268853,
-0.1961871386,
-0.3118184805,
0.6112312675,
-0.4165093601,
-0.5064147711,
-0.1404491663,
0.5804709792,
0.2806083858,
-0.5438626409,
0.4122949243,
0.5159299374,
0.1069774628,
-0.5715799928,
-0.694237411,
-0.1204001904,
-0.5103143454,
0.4802123308,
-0.2701514959,
-1.1197824478,
0.3289054632,
-0.3173649609,
0.0493037216,
0.3426383734,
0.9337647557,
-0.2405348718,
0.896912694,
0.6304628253,
0.136920169,
0.2861271203,
-0.0597152077,
0.1956856251,
-0.8681207895,
0.0078280307,
-0.551173687,
-0.3966654241,
-0.8210144043,
-0.7679851055,
0.207821399,
0.3168576956,
-0.3372761011,
-0.0511582084,
-0.9929016232,
0.5824425817,
0.6196012497,
0.1372450888,
0.2289076,
-0.0846703425,
-0.0566385798,
0.0118425833,
-0.8130437732,
-0.6513704658,
1.157703042,
0.4635739923,
1.0051425695,
0.083066605,
1.3157216311,
0.2085056305,
0.3365625739,
-0.3828840554,
0.3340014219,
-0.3108616173,
-0.6507338881,
-0.1235671416,
-0.6368314028,
-0.8310897946,
0.0568889156,
-0.0660233274,
-0.5982639194,
-0.034507636,
0.2370779663,
-0.0523100756,
0.365057528,
-0.5732188225,
0.7055107355,
-0.693097353,
-0.3409142196,
-0.5590171814,
-0.3351259828,
0.2469401956,
-0.0869335979,
0.1806498319,
-0.2897005379,
-0.2758614123,
0.2026363015,
-0.2491864264,
0.749104321,
-0.1231980994,
-0.4645223022,
0.3133093119,
0.1638497114,
0.0381550305,
0.1447938681,
-0.2621278465,
0.3625914752,
-0.4110376537,
-0.3447045684,
-0.3696533442,
1.0100214481,
-0.8191998005,
-0.7654396892,
0.0755431503,
-0.7035787106,
0.0454140715,
0.345782727,
0.4626542032,
0.358032465,
0.1038967296,
0.1874548942,
0.5874402523,
-0.3836404979,
0.4800179005,
0.6166632771,
-0.2804813683,
-0.360037297,
0.8058350682,
-0.18528983,
-0.0407413505,
0.4712091088,
0.2293501198,
-0.1789548695,
-0.6114062071,
-0.341301471,
0.0744209513,
-0.6163482666,
-0.331315428,
-0.2740415335,
0.0118512139,
-0.227736488,
-0.3059249818,
-0.5165707469,
-0.0732376277,
-0.1430470347,
0.1529043913,
0.0922463164,
0.8567602038,
-0.3091045916,
0.2156695426,
-1.0452336073,
0.4981634915,
0.4382005632,
0.6741856337,
0.037031278,
-0.5487059951,
-0.2864298224,
0.0394449644,
-0.3278822005,
-0.8979190588,
0.0729183331,
0.1788026839,
1.0774217844,
0.0199348591,
0.0227247644,
0.5462880731,
-0.4975052178,
0.3502670228,
0.2843763828,
-1.1972606182,
0.8176736236,
-0.5013706684,
0.680526495,
0.4174533784,
0.4195704162,
0.0113228858,
-0.478458643,
-0.3182212412,
-0.4393063188,
0.5691068769,
0.0508436635,
0.3168094456,
-0.4276619256,
0.4407641292,
0.4301451743,
0.1965429634,
-0.5921627879,
-0.1120635644,
-0.1135776341,
-0.2535806298,
0.1777333617,
-0.2713266015,
-0.0998798609,
-0.1174862906,
0.25639382,
-0.2307098657,
0.3602762818,
0.0226149093,
-0.0811497718,
-0.3480584025,
0.3515859842,
0.5561702251,
0.9195702672,
-0.1948851943,
0.0125449318,
0.1391974539,
-0.1804316342,
0.0780227333,
-0.1704513878,
0.3196756244,
-0.2531250715,
0.829269886,
0.824788034,
0.3455883563,
-0.5860133767,
0.2526560426,
-0.1356967241,
-0.0344552137,
0.1040866375,
0.7184761763,
0.0255840681,
0.4581758678,
0.3992021084,
0.1467384994,
0.2703737915,
-0.5574445724,
0.3154323697,
0.2578918934,
-0.0815593153,
0.0825757161,
0.6112078428,
0.4131259322,
-0.6053034067,
0.9564757943,
-0.1448238045,
-0.374863565,
0.6520618796,
0.8710008264,
0.9504967332,
-0.626675725,
-0.038768705,
0.3813775778,
0.2034427524,
0.3388720155,
0.6987633109,
-0.3819969594,
-0.6359088421,
-0.4350526333,
-0.5483940244,
-0.275569737,
-0.3165963888,
-0.9799566865,
0.2783862054,
-0.6195086837,
-0.118506223,
-0.3223390877,
-0.1228116825,
-0.6699761748,
0.1737010479,
0.4920070469,
0.6352971792,
-0.3854436874,
0.9141976237,
0.7140533328,
0.0165148228,
-0.7383975983,
0.3044744134,
-0.2554797828,
-1.0570696592,
0.7815354466,
0.456720531,
-0.4670483172,
-0.004879815,
-0.4963302314,
-0.6758002639,
0.8200423121,
0.6267917752,
-1.0939383507,
0.1844825894,
-0.2515301406,
0.5361141562,
-0.7121415138,
0.3571485877,
0.2744945586,
0.1003234759,
-0.0347225219,
-0.863502264,
-0.19786717,
-0.259039253,
0.07019981,
0.3241509497,
-0.8214950562,
0.8208507299,
-0.6932519078,
0.0396961533,
0.035750024,
0.1966168582,
0.6898453832,
0.0553388558,
0.3759850264,
0.5082628727,
0.8716304302,
0.2278433591,
1.2262730598,
-0.7274699211,
0.3747803867,
1.3236554861,
-0.312649101,
0.7629503608,
0.2002181858,
-0.0446840636,
0.5267498493,
0.5172641277,
-0.2155884355,
0.5980863571,
0.3189881146,
0.0379757248,
-0.5843547583,
0.150056988,
-0.7390482426,
0.8073988557,
0.0754749179,
-0.4324904084,
0.0664119571,
-0.2450927496,
-0.2098096311,
0.1760865748,
-0.4316155612,
0.631501615,
-0.0609063692,
-0.5701470375,
0.6560493708,
0.0509264171,
0.5938933492,
-0.5502710938,
-0.3375273347,
-0.3935690224,
0.2888753116,
-0.1693225056,
-0.635533154,
0.1543874443,
0.0089594452,
-0.2881755531,
-0.2451391518,
0.4889973104,
-0.2364496142,
-0.7159389257,
0.603279531,
0.3941223919,
0.0478803143,
0.3737445176,
-0.7623687387,
0.4025256038,
0.2440437078,
-0.1098004654,
0.2113067061,
0.4147588611,
0.429010123,
0.5754547715,
0.4137572944,
-0.0776939467,
0.2100812048,
0.1066192687,
0.8215674162,
-0.658334136,
-0.3902176321,
-0.7981185913,
0.421074599,
0.0084717767,
-0.5425946712,
0.8995020986,
0.6997351646,
0.815946281,
-0.2480554283,
0.6412305832,
0.2187610716,
0.6284695864,
-0.5763682127,
0.3264315128,
-0.6300706863,
0.5417798758,
-0.3607854247,
-1.3997176886,
-0.255443275,
0.8025643229,
-0.3471252024,
0.4026186168,
0.4298170805,
0.6474829316,
-0.1404727548,
-0.0368696973,
0.3596721292,
-0.06523031,
0.0697034374,
0.6912360787,
1.2502090931,
-0.0993989557,
0.2325327992,
-0.2637126148,
-0.3771257401,
-0.2872599363,
-0.8545319438,
-0.8814384341,
-0.1334345937,
-0.3598007262,
0.2076952606,
0.0812126473,
0.8740143776,
0.837684989,
-0.7423796058,
-0.568872571,
0.0269153677,
0.2105457783,
-0.1711904854,
-0.1248826683,
0.0859790221,
-0.9624990225,
-0.8092210293,
0.5287212133,
0.6739036441,
-0.1874984056,
-0.0974958241,
-0.3871751726,
0.1728288382,
-0.0327448696,
0.2071489394,
-0.1326044053,
-0.6843033433,
-0.1797588468,
0.1103431582,
-0.0971046612,
0.2934480906,
0.9944394231,
-0.2985683978,
0.6231567264,
0.2723041475,
0.5045936704,
0.3702517152,
-0.1268453002,
0.7094997168,
-0.5113280416,
0.1247770488,
0.4394353628,
0.3681788743,
0.0811061338,
-0.4918110073,
0.3923779726,
-0.3572982848,
-0.8076651692,
-0.783156991,
0.2908283174,
-0.5663149357,
-0.5256547928,
0.7448986769,
-0.2568764389,
0.0657808632,
0.2652549446,
-0.2754456699,
0.2096454501,
-0.1474568099,
0.9440448284,
0.1261921972,
-0.3705061972,
-0.4602809846,
-0.0666543171,
0.0916571021,
0.5129680634,
-0.8254768252,
-0.0933702067,
0.6580489874,
0.2721101642,
0.0280017592,
0.4476158619,
-0.0603857674,
0.5255954266,
0.2280606478,
0.1933080852,
-0.0566878468,
-0.5482369065,
-0.3376599848,
0.2311051786,
0.4480122626,
-0.31441769
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09126v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09126v2
|
MPIrigen: MPI Code Generation through Domain-Specific Language Models
| 2024-02-14T12:24:21 | 2024-04-23T16:59:46 |
Nadav Schneider, Niranjan Hasabnis, Vy A. Vo, Tal Kadosh, Neva Krien, Mihai Capotă, Guy Tamir, Ted Willke, Nesreen Ahmed, Yuval Pinter, Timothy Mattson, Gal Oren
|
cs.DC
|
cs.DC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SE
|
The imperative need to scale computation across numerous nodes highlights the
significance of efficient parallel computing, particularly in the realm of
Message Passing Interface (MPI) integration. The challenging parallel
programming task of generating MPI-based parallel programs has remained
unexplored. This study first investigates the performance of state-of-the-art
language models in generating MPI-based parallel programs. Findings reveal that
widely used models such as GPT-3.5 and PolyCoder (specialized multi-lingual
code models) exhibit notable performance degradation, when generating MPI-based
programs compared to general-purpose programs. In contrast, domain-specific
models such as MonoCoder, which are pretrained on MPI-related programming
languages of C and C++, outperform larger models. Subsequently, we introduce a
dedicated downstream task of MPI-based program generation by fine-tuning
MonoCoder on HPCorpusMPI. We call the resulting model as MPIrigen. We propose
an innovative preprocessing for completion only after observing the whole code,
thus enabling better completion with a wider context. Comparative analysis
against GPT-3.5 zero-shot performance, using a novel HPC-oriented evaluation
method, demonstrates that MPIrigen excels in generating accurate MPI functions
up to 0.8 accuracy in location and function predictions, and with more than 0.9
accuracy for argument predictions. The success of this tailored solution
underscores the importance of domain-specific fine-tuning in optimizing
language models for parallel computing code generation, paving the way for a
new generation of automatic parallelization tools. The sources of this work are
available at our GitHub MPIrigen repository:
https://github.com/Scientific-Computing-Lab-NRCN/MPI-rigen
|
[
-0.6290660501,
-0.0867013708,
0.5688349009,
0.37577492,
0.016094625,
-0.0827896595,
-0.1077404246,
-0.0830224827,
-0.0153505187,
0.4399598837,
-0.476827085,
-0.5067046285,
-0.7279244661,
0.0710226074,
-0.0939929634,
0.7541639805,
-0.2541232109,
0.036760658,
-0.4393353164,
-0.1596648097,
0.0405729711,
-0.8003533483,
-0.4367360771,
-0.5266278386,
0.5196931362,
0.3833094239,
0.2803208828,
0.9541891813,
0.6629923582,
0.1652489305,
0.2899493575,
0.0338385664,
-0.3799342513,
-0.3323989511,
-0.0782066435,
-0.3350737989,
-0.490786761,
0.0268868338,
0.7935972214,
0.6598277688,
-0.2339985222,
0.397426337,
0.0586158037,
0.4620528817,
-0.8599085808,
0.1344455034,
-0.5397495627,
-0.0520658158,
-0.3822159469,
-0.4160975516,
-0.4377162158,
-0.2051012367,
-0.3775386214,
-0.1584693193,
0.0712189078,
-0.2434635311,
0.5662662387,
0.3258166611,
-0.1671907306,
-0.1266620308,
-0.7039546371,
0.9317795038,
-0.9059548378,
0.0852505192,
-0.0840746984,
0.2364218086,
-0.0773807243,
-1.0401419401,
-0.5314185023,
-0.1327591538,
0.0127221858,
-0.0700651333,
-0.0962591097,
0.1846612692,
0.536141336,
0.2534978688,
-0.6947985888,
0.0323085636,
-0.3575862646,
0.0974049345,
0.4784108698,
0.2472387552,
0.3738642335,
0.0812234655,
0.0022830791,
-0.0259614829,
-0.9237915277,
-0.0354301035,
0.4695557654,
0.1712753475,
-0.0737249255,
0.5335170031,
-0.1828941107,
0.7479172349,
-0.2494547367,
-0.2860225439,
0.1499193162,
-0.1645779014,
-0.2612309456,
0.0727545172,
0.7130250335,
0.2463534474,
0.48642537,
-0.0024692484,
-0.0768407956,
0.2608902156,
0.1121168807,
-1.2017196417,
-0.1991725862,
0.3633785844,
-0.5962103605,
-0.3499863148,
-0.0232800264,
-0.4433028102,
-0.1020753309,
-0.4862612784,
0.0287705623,
-0.2674660385,
-0.2677607536,
0.0171384327,
0.071180366,
0.1858255267,
-0.2945176363,
-0.6240075231,
0.2434562147,
0.6858705878,
0.6924455762,
-0.3421704471,
-0.7323812842,
-0.6296765208,
0.3340028524,
-0.0287384149,
0.546728909,
-0.8866078258,
-0.501290679,
-0.1635790318,
-0.09980084,
-0.4284023046,
-0.6123962998,
0.4527961612,
-0.0561622828,
-0.2639242411,
-0.1175381541,
-0.453651756,
0.3072865605,
-0.1501634121,
-0.1175951809,
0.4787964523,
-0.1191750541,
-1.101580143,
0.1133085787,
-0.7366817594,
-0.5388998389,
-0.0019137884,
-0.2729684114,
-0.3932959139,
0.2541890144,
0.2400620878,
0.2977672517,
-0.5475532413,
0.3236899972,
-0.2398450375,
-0.5172114968,
-0.0198362283,
-0.1073973551,
0.4464455843,
0.48181656,
-0.4501076043,
0.1383784413,
-0.7193561792,
0.3312494755,
0.033100035,
-0.2715555131,
0.2433543205,
0.1426362693,
-0.0905730277,
0.1168276891,
0.3073256314,
-0.6775723696,
0.2084353119,
0.0541809425,
0.3321070671,
0.4268552661,
-0.0770573243,
0.2066504359,
-0.2673341036,
0.6107729673,
0.0452148058,
0.3081911504,
-0.5049461126,
-0.4402007163,
-0.6388633847,
-0.2967892289,
0.5003784895,
0.6701374054,
-0.7452549934,
-0.0856739804,
-0.3075591028,
-0.6265281439,
-0.288141042,
-0.0580149107,
0.5324974656,
0.2225215882,
0.0068699736,
-0.228582859,
-0.5837205052,
-1.0834815502,
-0.2292879224,
-0.1138983294,
-0.0073785931,
0.5223132372,
0.1954539567,
-0.5436961055,
0.4761110246,
-0.6660053134,
0.3056376874,
-0.3486538529,
0.5341981053,
0.1149987876,
0.7189381123,
0.6295429468,
-0.7353665233,
-0.5739365816,
0.1658777893,
-0.6205022931,
-0.3993090689,
0.0845834985,
-0.0877157226,
-0.1555676609,
0.4496877491,
-0.5498545766,
0.2570083737,
0.6806372404,
0.1803659648,
0.6109933257,
-0.3571671247,
0.3953145742,
-0.932918489,
0.5460677147,
-0.0732846335,
-0.0772709921,
-0.7852317691,
0.4228194058,
-0.1008473709,
-0.5416848063,
-0.5020737648,
0.1888326257,
-0.2693967819,
-0.0167821683,
-0.5469552875,
-0.3977186084,
-0.3189195395,
0.4981409311,
0.1171720847,
1.1443259716,
0.802967906,
-0.587187767,
0.0308938026,
-0.4594160914,
-0.1433739215,
-0.0526696183,
-0.8048160076,
0.1689493209,
-0.120766677,
-0.1074807793,
-0.3944369555,
-0.4209638238,
0.0446688458,
-0.379221499,
0.3413538635,
-0.3454316854,
-0.5382232666,
-0.3346426785,
0.1590907872,
0.7271289825,
0.7834516764,
-0.4780707657,
0.4432535768,
0.4063776433,
-0.3288442791,
-0.4234383106,
-0.5869144797,
-0.0618947223,
0.0042879716,
-0.5297175646,
0.2398861796,
-0.1482714117,
-0.1337464899,
-0.2973433435,
0.1083935052,
-0.1185487509,
-0.2315565348,
0.3468872905,
-0.0884087384,
-0.2772437334,
-0.3657721281,
0.1763207167,
-0.2239261121,
-0.1300612241,
-0.5990167856,
0.6795427799,
-0.2360627502,
-0.5835646987,
-0.4278006554,
0.6779435873,
1.0328127146,
-0.6998173594,
0.8341098428,
0.5856412649,
-0.2443466932,
-0.049416557,
-0.4369994402,
0.1283842325,
-0.4101984203,
0.0410268791,
-0.7804833055,
-0.7890288234,
0.3708724976,
-0.4657533467,
-0.1962572485,
0.1559790224,
0.5527853966,
0.4051162004,
1.4917680025,
0.9988667369,
0.0347457975,
0.2010264993,
-0.0941987708,
0.3948731422,
-0.5535498261,
-0.0000115596,
-0.5342950821,
-0.1578154415,
-0.7007786036,
-0.405271709,
0.3827237785,
0.1197747663,
-0.0779930502,
0.4627232254,
-0.6493916512,
0.6008222699,
0.5757913589,
-0.3546952009,
-0.0367319882,
0.1405472904,
-0.3548429906,
-0.0118213147,
-0.8177615404,
-0.5053988099,
0.9145624042,
0.2653564215,
0.5011274815,
-0.1663420945,
0.9092835784,
0.0996751115,
0.5467448831,
-0.0121451393,
0.5001043081,
-0.4877666235,
-0.0752046555,
0.2903557122,
-0.8089069724,
-0.3746330738,
-0.0882828087,
0.3466965854,
-0.8227928281,
0.3694999218,
0.0712023079,
-0.2435099781,
0.4183054566,
-1.0193165541,
1.0698770285,
0.0932227373,
-0.3796647489,
-0.1941752285,
-0.2637012601,
0.4141449332,
-0.1065801159,
-0.0943048149,
-0.15310736,
0.2339934558,
0.1730616391,
-0.4077925682,
0.3985849023,
-0.3984999657,
0.1016880721,
0.4244868457,
-0.0871940777,
0.3811462224,
0.0656489208,
-0.2365142554,
0.1598992646,
0.156790331,
-0.5478289127,
-0.4055383503,
1.1471549273,
-0.4932723045,
-0.4683985412,
-0.0073801689,
-0.5952177048,
0.04440118,
0.2970440984,
0.4971144497,
0.751922667,
0.1019673124,
-0.1216133088,
0.6489642262,
-0.4087429643,
0.2907494903,
0.2332181782,
-0.3747319579,
-0.1596235782,
1.3688254356,
-0.1723563671,
0.0696824342,
0.2899091244,
-0.364210695,
0.2305795997,
-0.7030428648,
-0.4367012084,
0.3801659644,
-0.304420203,
-0.1612311006,
-0.6962282062,
-0.3720487952,
-0.5210739374,
-0.1473077238,
-0.4412049055,
-0.2800246179,
-0.0144301793,
0.3982030749,
-0.3150907755,
0.626960814,
-0.1305653751,
0.3717548251,
-0.8156824708,
0.1212199405,
0.158275336,
0.4777350426,
-0.1887422502,
0.1752138287,
-0.1919120103,
-0.0019952136,
-0.1167740747,
-0.5421904922,
0.3172623217,
0.1516140252,
0.4569243491,
0.200129047,
-0.1164926067,
0.431702435,
-0.6235340834,
0.5849254727,
0.0603284724,
-0.8565661311,
0.6305901408,
-0.4018601477,
0.6873294711,
0.3874079883,
0.4563890696,
-0.230775699,
-0.2576408684,
-0.3560329378,
-0.4025638103,
0.6651732326,
0.5482723713,
-0.1192609444,
-0.1400195509,
0.6129467487,
-0.1148763523,
0.2892325222,
-0.4011001587,
-0.281267643,
-0.0636454672,
-0.2929775119,
-0.1546516865,
-0.3743559718,
0.1476936489,
-0.1903629899,
0.5878577232,
-0.3132781982,
0.4306712151,
0.252694428,
0.1318618357,
0.0082746139,
0.1886421144,
0.7294159532,
0.9616123438,
-0.1571902633,
-0.0563684143,
-0.143620804,
-0.4203798771,
-0.0331309848,
0.4132968783,
-0.0856283307,
-0.0353971682,
0.0825382099,
0.692373693,
-0.4323380888,
-0.9280021191,
0.5743383765,
-0.3245967329,
-0.0347270146,
-0.2124060392,
0.2204515934,
-0.0029158315,
0.1401710957,
0.0926572159,
0.3417399228,
0.2460155487,
-0.2293213457,
0.3871327043,
0.1847777069,
-0.1585969776,
-0.2412553728,
0.787168622,
0.0453826562,
-0.033318717,
0.482735455,
-0.4442753792,
-0.3687188029,
0.7092064023,
0.4607315063,
0.8761382699,
-0.1779717505,
0.0927682295,
0.5194193125,
0.2496553361,
0.2208077312,
0.2644864023,
-0.2562552392,
-0.4718912542,
-0.7570779324,
-1.0074875355,
-0.1746471822,
-0.0383204147,
-0.3909708261,
0.0577102639,
-0.5652227402,
-0.3071758747,
0.05158934,
-0.2739828527,
-0.4096630216,
0.1379075199,
0.4945149124,
0.9673197865,
-0.5631158948,
1.2112908363,
0.9504968524,
-0.0464417599,
-0.6778295636,
0.2710460722,
-0.2133038044,
-0.2154819816,
0.510424912,
0.1754783094,
-0.228173241,
0.1173370034,
-0.3485891521,
-0.5585052371,
0.8193128705,
0.5447723269,
-0.4686312675,
-0.0575976707,
0.6256526113,
0.4073970914,
-0.9437040091,
0.1806726903,
0.6796105504,
0.2393241227,
0.0742205605,
-0.8895375133,
-0.2706954777,
-0.5579734445,
0.394985199,
0.3660578728,
-0.5961437225,
0.7953916788,
-0.1432125717,
-0.1186260954,
0.371974498,
0.4007958472,
0.3154063523,
0.2158222049,
0.0108549865,
0.6003327966,
0.4058520794,
-0.2084424943,
1.512814045,
-0.9481831789,
0.1074176207,
0.8583656549,
-0.3261905909,
0.6423694491,
0.2891469002,
0.1217247695,
0.3970603049,
0.2777944207,
0.0887338966,
0.4156737328,
0.1950323582,
-0.6125947833,
-0.2748182118,
-0.4004115164,
-0.2901765108,
0.3205651939,
0.2616750598,
-0.4910179973,
-0.0393138975,
0.1418283135,
-0.1192412451,
-0.0493889749,
-0.2743854225,
0.3679927886,
0.0449178629,
-0.9392719269,
0.6835215688,
0.3342615962,
0.447630465,
-0.5697599649,
-0.0468012802,
-0.2502790093,
0.6163389683,
-0.0210102275,
-0.337113291,
0.5121492743,
0.1459499896,
-0.4543202221,
-0.0655337349,
0.8042780161,
-0.3770007491,
-0.516726613,
0.2046629488,
0.3515846729,
0.2258509547,
-0.0784337148,
-0.5610579848,
0.3982184529,
0.3250353038,
0.190822646,
0.3573825359,
0.0164885279,
0.3321598768,
0.5869753957,
0.606831193,
0.1098663509,
0.1973083168,
0.1907106638,
0.7472727895,
-0.2554935515,
-0.0442635603,
-0.5629207492,
0.3509010375,
-0.0528144054,
-0.1529866904,
0.5115838051,
0.6943231821,
0.7563961148,
-0.2696778476,
0.7711658478,
-0.196489349,
0.4002939463,
-0.2125067115,
0.70511657,
-0.5130036473,
0.1833887845,
-0.0810308382,
-1.0390911102,
-0.2566358745,
-0.082518369,
-0.4054526389,
0.008937927,
0.4448523819,
1.0634227991,
-0.3185548186,
-0.1259435266,
0.3396343887,
-0.0080059431,
0.2775405049,
0.7438101172,
0.5144508481,
-0.300070852,
0.5156864524,
-0.4319317341,
-0.4383670688,
0.2573162019,
-0.6241178513,
-0.744584024,
-0.4078270495,
-0.5611183643,
0.0842625499,
0.2056592554,
0.4403579533,
0.8638672233,
-0.8743750453,
-0.4271839857,
-0.4225595295,
-0.2055749446,
0.0463577844,
-0.2083399296,
0.0447060205,
-0.598695755,
-0.9128430486,
0.2727257311,
0.4462946951,
-0.0708774105,
0.0135232946,
-0.2302373946,
0.0227223281,
0.2460518628,
0.3883715868,
0.5125245452,
-0.4404334724,
0.2296511233,
-0.1879576892,
-0.1074610651,
-0.0131643806,
1.2884033918,
-0.5392994285,
0.2140039802,
0.4239824414,
0.5755566359,
0.5243321061,
0.073329702,
0.8290382624,
-0.7611655593,
0.3141014874,
-0.0411172956,
0.4138589501,
0.2453155071,
-0.2241868079,
0.3134824634,
0.1807372123,
-0.6782765985,
-0.7986574173,
0.472576648,
-0.289487958,
-0.2543208599,
0.8950080276,
-0.3011943698,
-0.3571916521,
0.5012344122,
-0.1703083217,
0.1393319368,
0.1437467635,
0.1584869027,
0.3405997157,
-0.3656793237,
-0.4498867095,
-0.3576794267,
0.5295462012,
0.4271295965,
-0.5972533822,
0.0825434625,
0.1585184783,
0.1421089023,
0.329826802,
0.4456240535,
-0.3246147037,
0.3368675411,
0.3853998482,
0.3743266165,
-0.1379843652,
-0.4894715846,
-0.0634543821,
0.4382772148,
0.2208032161,
0.011952457
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09025v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09025v4
|
SLEB: Streamlining LLMs through Redundancy Verification and Elimination of Transformer Blocks
| 2024-02-14T09:01:13 | 2024-06-12T01:40:12 |
Jiwon Song, Kyungseok Oh, Taesu Kim, Hyungjun Kim, Yulhwa Kim, Jae-Joon Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have proven to be highly effective across
various natural language processing tasks. However, their large number of
parameters poses significant challenges for practical deployment. Pruning, a
technique aimed at reducing the size and complexity of LLMs, offers a potential
solution by removing redundant components from the network. Despite the promise
of pruning, existing methods often struggle to achieve substantial end-to-end
LLM inference speedup. In this paper, we introduce SLEB, a novel approach
designed to streamline LLMs by eliminating redundant transformer blocks. We
choose the transformer block as the fundamental unit for pruning, because LLMs
exhibit block-level redundancy with high similarity between the outputs of
neighboring blocks. This choice allows us to effectively enhance the processing
speed of LLMs. Our experimental results demonstrate that SLEB outperforms
previous LLM pruning methods in accelerating LLM inference while also
maintaining superior perplexity and accuracy, making SLEB as a promising
technique for enhancing the efficiency of LLMs. The code is available at:
https://github.com/jiwonsong-dev/SLEB.
|
[
-0.4860905707,
-0.9021703601,
0.3981032968,
0.3999003768,
-0.5941330791,
0.2554651797,
-0.4752610028,
-0.3177228868,
0.2202296555,
0.5851852298,
-0.6530629992,
-0.5478905439,
-0.4296038449,
0.1572997123,
-0.7255257368,
0.7445254922,
0.0097130341,
-0.2324451506,
-0.1667878032,
0.0367833674,
-0.5117797852,
-0.1249108538,
-0.5681163669,
-0.5471565127,
0.3118682802,
0.3709361255,
0.4985396564,
0.6561759114,
0.4622656703,
0.4425902367,
-0.5230395198,
0.4492090046,
-0.7032105923,
0.4088342786,
-0.0972780138,
-0.4568125606,
-0.4849458635,
-0.4904543757,
0.7378278971,
0.5757620931,
-0.2134652734,
0.3276098967,
-0.0797478482,
0.6681637764,
-0.4744361639,
-0.084677726,
-0.8126320243,
-0.2085422873,
-0.345730722,
-0.0583535768,
-0.6006850004,
-0.532487452,
-0.0787853301,
-0.1033503339,
0.4666541517,
0.1773721278,
1.1421868801,
0.3190161884,
-0.3685584664,
0.1441408992,
-0.7984976768,
0.741093874,
-0.7391799688,
0.324316889,
0.0453236513,
0.1560984254,
-0.1756091863,
-0.8952738643,
-0.4011149108,
0.0107795866,
-0.3911382854,
-0.1152668521,
-0.0343698896,
0.2548092604,
0.2251317948,
0.3785775006,
-0.6005746722,
0.1166676655,
-0.600004077,
-0.4071348906,
0.6522957683,
0.0038351661,
-0.0201022308,
-0.1305293739,
-0.3779218793,
0.2957717478,
-0.9271703959,
-0.2074964792,
0.4326345325,
-0.0349203646,
0.4168592393,
0.4655509889,
-0.0253696889,
0.7373572588,
-0.1903717965,
-0.2745887637,
0.2079340369,
-0.2224110961,
-0.3592185676,
0.0600648336,
0.5218635201,
0.2333904803,
0.2328492254,
-0.1658769399,
-0.378343761,
0.1250648052,
0.4150893986,
-0.7812295556,
-0.153096199,
0.392275542,
-0.3003005683,
-0.2476953566,
-0.1326289475,
-0.5462671518,
-0.2717879415,
-0.2269649357,
-0.0623673014,
-0.4105606377,
-0.400682807,
0.048265595,
0.0947495103,
0.3390247226,
0.3198561668,
-0.541529417,
0.2589168549,
1.0573157072,
0.6990898848,
-0.291261375,
-0.2626939416,
-0.2973089218,
0.0582143366,
-0.2602793276,
0.82344836,
-0.2572462559,
-0.1477756202,
-0.1905492246,
-0.0054688742,
0.2472361773,
-0.76159513,
0.6174325943,
-0.6397310495,
-0.3613308966,
0.1264664084,
-0.5937530994,
-0.2646300793,
0.3001489937,
-0.6642280221,
1.0828527212,
-0.0862010419,
-0.4987536371,
0.0063558291,
-0.3137956262,
-0.9437307715,
0.3816212416,
0.0576433428,
-0.7104434371,
0.3790558279,
0.0616231933,
0.3433789909,
-0.3697102964,
0.7797368169,
-0.1557841301,
-0.694321692,
-0.052266106,
-0.3356409669,
0.7061826587,
0.1289429963,
-0.2220156193,
0.3363291323,
-0.9075261354,
0.2212726623,
0.2205118537,
-0.2531186044,
-0.2458676994,
0.0520547517,
-0.2589202523,
-0.1800469458,
0.1590352654,
-0.5317423344,
0.0982893556,
-0.435533762,
0.5694203377,
0.9237806201,
-0.0109522305,
0.4276670516,
-0.2125526518,
0.3264922798,
-0.1401461661,
-0.048471041,
-0.2841473222,
-0.2043120861,
-1.0353697538,
-0.5611019135,
0.4606176913,
0.4652899504,
-0.4810959697,
0.6521231532,
-0.3144589365,
-0.4759303629,
-0.8249325156,
0.2365671545,
0.1637566388,
0.3793643713,
0.3332790732,
-0.0155207897,
-0.989102304,
-1.1158415079,
-0.2632421255,
-0.0703273416,
-0.1225837395,
-0.0097525502,
0.3864767849,
-0.2662929296,
1.1000031233,
-0.3750844896,
-0.0196718331,
-0.6763321161,
0.0256820153,
0.2944244444,
0.3262579441,
-0.2178177536,
-0.7609415054,
-0.272018373,
-0.0878613815,
-0.522131443,
-0.5133877993,
-0.3814623654,
-0.029708324,
0.072580412,
0.5589942336,
-0.5324706435,
0.4449094832,
0.5084927678,
-0.078240715,
0.7344940901,
-0.0261853337,
-0.2413985282,
-0.4445070624,
-0.0924549475,
-0.0317697525,
-0.7096130252,
-0.8049800992,
0.0957160518,
0.2714889944,
0.0800516903,
-0.4820819795,
0.3967293501,
-0.7351970673,
-0.1419036537,
-0.3397999108,
0.4397033155,
0.1911302209,
0.5100457668,
-0.1082546785,
0.7424019575,
0.2681408525,
-0.6504074931,
0.5358448625,
-0.0121612456,
-0.3467202187,
0.2318034172,
-0.6706642509,
-0.0374042355,
-0.4565517008,
0.2617792487,
-0.8562332392,
0.2180379033,
-0.1162775084,
0.040591374,
0.2562896609,
0.005946144,
-0.4824497104,
-0.5261625648,
-0.254538089,
0.1939498335,
0.6390045881,
-0.5620862842,
0.7902686,
0.2868215144,
-0.1707372963,
-0.4169603586,
-0.7166349888,
0.0796050355,
-0.2503371835,
-0.7177583575,
0.5085155964,
0.0646826476,
-0.2648565471,
-0.0730262622,
-0.5183409452,
-0.0463470817,
0.3394479752,
0.1440127194,
0.3963473141,
-0.1722668558,
0.1884626746,
-0.0628184006,
-0.2530059814,
-0.024154922,
-0.0775277168,
0.7109227777,
-0.2812436521,
-0.5886414647,
-0.4839600325,
0.1334735602,
0.5281672478,
-0.2414270192,
0.5008327365,
0.5526146889,
-0.2400774509,
-0.5170264244,
-0.9027639627,
-0.3004253209,
-0.510039866,
0.5322618484,
-0.2583545744,
-0.9668594599,
0.3374972939,
-0.512054801,
0.3394525051,
-0.0261451323,
0.3820261359,
-0.0205914527,
0.4421357512,
0.5215402842,
-0.0371080525,
0.3136474788,
-0.130813241,
0.7320863008,
-0.9225245118,
-0.1325746477,
-0.4219766557,
-0.6288900375,
-0.3317971528,
-0.4908080995,
-0.0516645983,
0.2670209706,
-0.0896733627,
0.5144979954,
-0.5577394366,
0.7505074143,
0.4358199835,
0.067489475,
0.5500021577,
-0.1154211313,
0.0298207756,
-0.0799119547,
-0.4947665632,
-0.4886260331,
0.5905207396,
0.4781866968,
0.6975113153,
-0.0307254009,
0.8111189008,
0.0278046615,
0.5842602849,
-0.6299794912,
1.0772590637,
0.133299768,
-0.5552880764,
-0.4535289705,
-0.4585107863,
-0.7267719507,
0.6752090454,
-0.0012393559,
-0.6779950261,
-0.2728814781,
0.2575709224,
-0.0832026899,
0.5193097591,
-0.8254371881,
0.5560270548,
-0.291685164,
-0.4430189431,
-0.2348585576,
-0.5216919184,
0.5653973818,
-0.074817121,
0.1646393389,
-0.1868071109,
0.0475309864,
0.4884832501,
-0.5693615079,
0.8280627728,
-0.0114437016,
-0.04352694,
0.3653479517,
0.152363345,
0.9515070319,
-0.0141585274,
0.0312793888,
0.16726695,
-0.5876691937,
-0.2873040736,
-0.4634111226,
0.6229447126,
-0.2255013436,
-0.7385007739,
-0.0269415881,
-0.5202715993,
-0.1156287864,
0.3275178075,
-0.0735787451,
0.1603775918,
0.1051278114,
0.3660839796,
0.6864914298,
-0.1292609125,
0.5128065348,
0.3353467286,
-0.3286932111,
-0.2727210522,
0.9172770381,
-0.1267143637,
0.2878227234,
0.2421340942,
-0.0302645657,
-0.1881291419,
-0.9791613817,
0.0652242005,
0.5991995931,
-0.6308296919,
-0.4355203211,
-0.3995299637,
-0.424036473,
-0.1651490778,
-0.2048742771,
-0.5081422329,
-0.0871164203,
0.034474764,
-0.3328304887,
0.0547073483,
0.5870615244,
0.4482898712,
0.5633636117,
-0.8261359334,
0.2872329056,
0.0367075689,
0.4865127802,
-0.003640732,
-0.314776212,
0.0046528359,
-0.3177119493,
-0.2081342191,
-0.7592666149,
0.3985145688,
-0.1305984408,
0.5524112582,
0.3145538867,
0.1280127168,
1.0597051382,
-0.582741797,
0.6069027781,
0.1774281561,
-1.0202559233,
0.2567711771,
0.2067742795,
0.3237456679,
0.4336972833,
-0.0143120419,
-0.5304138064,
-0.7599720955,
-0.7258270979,
-1.2863162756,
0.4366620183,
0.2405301332,
-0.3427911699,
0.0914495289,
0.2175693661,
-0.0585916489,
0.431651026,
-0.8718106151,
-0.4480743408,
0.1769366413,
-0.1136438996,
0.2107294947,
-0.5108513236,
0.0070484667,
-0.0781487077,
0.9651180506,
0.087662518,
-0.0397650898,
0.1685948372,
-0.6695572138,
0.199593395,
0.4352949262,
0.5475947261,
0.7053804994,
0.0261356346,
0.2950108051,
0.5420926213,
-0.3515642285,
0.2162111104,
-0.3521600068,
-0.5145346522,
0.2825292945,
0.4421092868,
0.8499723673,
0.2900730669,
-0.7764180303,
0.2970324457,
-0.06480176,
-0.1440166682,
-0.1813975275,
-0.1469294578,
0.3475514054,
0.2671814561,
0.3773254454,
0.0314943865,
-0.1955631971,
0.0645623431,
0.2162946463,
0.3504720628,
0.049483303,
-0.1104725748,
0.1807307303,
0.3367260993,
-0.5524582267,
0.6617405415,
-0.2938432693,
-0.5631980896,
0.5741292834,
0.7288230062,
0.7417812347,
0.0043843244,
0.0922593325,
0.3285447657,
0.6713114977,
-0.2257154137,
-0.1078417301,
-0.0535659008,
-0.5946859121,
-0.8126841784,
-0.7757677436,
-0.2675572634,
0.3120555878,
-0.4323446453,
0.4749205112,
-0.4012919068,
0.0220753737,
-0.3719572723,
-0.1261105239,
-0.2605819106,
-0.1366287768,
0.1793475896,
1.061841011,
-0.6907132268,
0.8214118481,
0.4820470512,
0.1950855851,
-0.7263902426,
-0.1680094749,
-0.0167433601,
-0.5917334557,
0.5004935265,
0.3273441195,
-0.1178059578,
0.0234682187,
-0.3001829386,
-0.6411010623,
1.2002468109,
0.381165117,
-1.0178557634,
-0.1961221695,
-0.1025768146,
0.3575772047,
-0.1009618565,
0.2955406308,
0.8801770806,
0.7438838482,
0.177496314,
-0.5805351734,
0.1868885159,
0.02207008,
0.1707567424,
0.6260537505,
-0.3850927055,
0.587798357,
-0.2313551307,
-0.3750902414,
-0.1285731941,
0.9450398088,
0.4870174527,
0.1038555205,
0.7767629623,
0.5001356006,
1.0163121223,
-0.2886418104,
0.4434435666,
-0.278698802,
0.5182592869,
1.1833888292,
-0.5203832388,
0.617372036,
0.7158606052,
-0.3127282262,
0.4321386516,
0.295941025,
-0.0710518062,
0.1950749755,
0.4720775187,
-0.3010326326,
-0.3016314805,
0.1891233027,
0.0746149421,
0.0950843766,
0.2769515812,
0.0264389347,
-0.5491097569,
-0.163027063,
0.1271143109,
0.0826440975,
-0.2141096592,
0.5541340113,
-0.0135886669,
-0.7100204229,
0.5853720903,
0.0236844234,
0.9002841711,
-0.8289213777,
0.1889059693,
-0.2819905579,
0.3465560973,
-0.3531831205,
-0.4941202998,
0.5614344478,
-0.1727957129,
0.0145889539,
-0.6225014329,
1.0141117573,
-0.4668540955,
-0.2676461637,
0.4133357108,
0.306494385,
0.1501398981,
0.0565360114,
-0.3135357499,
0.4055673182,
0.3807195723,
-0.4203567803,
0.1927267909,
0.3793491125,
-0.0586091429,
0.9355450869,
0.7556784153,
0.559738934,
0.1376578212,
0.0631999001,
0.7686489224,
-0.8091292977,
-0.2526421249,
-1.1310125589,
0.6127839684,
-0.4219943881,
0.0972189605,
0.6003621221,
0.5909261107,
0.7485523224,
0.074116677,
0.5432094336,
0.0124575822,
0.4228424728,
-0.1621847302,
0.4501149356,
-0.242933929,
0.7431814671,
0.2264333367,
-0.7642822862,
-0.3956120014,
0.6850176454,
-0.1402786821,
-0.2850195169,
0.9710794091,
1.0909929276,
0.0669396371,
0.0985486284,
0.3319313228,
0.4657652676,
0.5066455603,
0.2818309665,
0.518561244,
-0.2580702305,
0.8851706982,
-0.3581160009,
-0.1498615593,
-0.2092530578,
-1.039688468,
-0.8651015162,
-0.2339530289,
-0.2862503231,
-0.2826139629,
-0.0117905876,
0.7560542226,
0.5316751003,
-0.6523031592,
-0.3082912564,
-0.3230073154,
0.648499608,
-0.4110428393,
-0.2339472324,
0.0162589103,
-0.4513032138,
-0.6341811419,
0.4045507312,
0.4689612985,
-0.1481110454,
-0.404163599,
0.0471376292,
-0.351569891,
-0.108969532,
0.5347838402,
0.0419204719,
-0.8386619687,
0.0267949942,
-0.2678026855,
-0.1240708381,
0.0740838274,
0.97018224,
-0.8906675577,
-0.1633944064,
0.6650635004,
0.7719892859,
0.5627516508,
0.2280178815,
0.4907448888,
-0.9983684421,
0.1893686652,
0.381154865,
0.5637267828,
0.2320104837,
-0.0909231305,
0.4540109634,
0.2456948012,
-0.5096789598,
-1.3058855534,
0.3942968547,
-0.7513878345,
-0.3516876101,
1.2219468355,
-0.1281123459,
-0.6456380486,
-0.0994955078,
-0.3204438984,
0.1142049879,
-0.2971063256,
0.4488813281,
0.638281405,
0.2038876861,
-0.3376350701,
-0.3499224484,
0.0382867604,
0.5721552968,
-0.8329517245,
0.4916876256,
0.3069266379,
0.338678807,
0.2241404951,
0.5452878475,
0.0514701493,
-0.0661313906,
-0.2950567603,
0.3218112886,
-0.3541319668,
-0.4071533978,
-0.3370418847,
0.5480485559,
-0.1150241643,
-0.0063446555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09015v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09015v3
|
Towards better Human-Agent Alignment: Assessing Task Utility in LLM-Powered Applications
| 2024-02-14T08:46:15 | 2024-02-22T23:49:10 |
Negar Arabzadeh, Julia Kiseleva, Qingyun Wu, Chi Wang, Ahmed Awadallah, Victor Dibia, Adam Fourney, Charles Clarke
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The rapid development in the field of Large Language Models (LLMs) has led to
a surge in applications that facilitate collaboration among multiple agents to
assist humans in their daily tasks. However, a significant gap remains in
assessing whether LLM-powered applications genuinely enhance user experience
and task execution efficiency. This highlights the pressing need for methods to
verify utility of LLM-powered applications, particularly by ensuring alignment
between the application's functionality and end-user needs. We introduce
AgentEval provides an implementation for the math problems, a novel framework
designed to simplify the utility verification process by automatically
proposing a set of criteria tailored to the unique purpose of any given
application. This allows for a comprehensive assessment, quantifying the
utility of an application against the suggested criteria. We present a
comprehensive analysis of the robustness of quantifier's work.
|
[
-0.1780263484,
-0.5063765645,
0.4621596634,
0.22399804,
0.1934911311,
0.430989176,
-0.1768198162,
-0.4404422045,
0.0268278625,
0.5294117332,
-0.4258696437,
-0.4480825067,
-0.4256831706,
0.0323501937,
-0.2583770752,
0.593791008,
-0.2006435245,
-0.0102946544,
-0.886282444,
-0.3152001202,
-0.6920024157,
-0.4267400503,
-0.4469816387,
-0.7180291414,
0.0546599142,
0.4879876077,
1.1830006838,
0.5319829583,
0.948145926,
0.5379112959,
0.4755959213,
0.1733799428,
-0.2714414895,
0.4355680346,
-0.1304307282,
-0.3437888026,
-1.0965725183,
-0.0392075144,
0.3881983757,
0.6458439231,
-0.4608666301,
0.328130573,
0.1515719891,
0.5963276625,
-0.8325153589,
0.0290117208,
-0.5047386885,
-0.2867257297,
-0.0673111677,
-0.2775739729,
-0.2632856965,
-0.4134629667,
-0.1357906461,
-0.6002404094,
-0.0406898893,
0.088364549,
0.7969093919,
0.7382382751,
-0.658423841,
-0.1703819036,
-0.6662189364,
0.9485404491,
-0.4405640364,
0.3710199594,
0.4733289778,
0.6665818095,
-0.2924150825,
-0.5383332968,
-0.6004855037,
-0.4177550972,
-0.1223872155,
-0.0829209611,
-0.3403291702,
0.1934205741,
0.2823226452,
0.1355508864,
-0.6966966391,
0.071092613,
0.2396412194,
-0.4683800638,
0.7777411342,
0.4746596217,
0.4967348576,
0.081149675,
-0.2670269608,
-0.1490903497,
-0.6128519773,
0.2288823426,
0.4110444188,
0.2037137896,
0.0369592756,
0.7763641477,
-0.0001802205,
0.5939759016,
-0.1370804161,
-0.1865561157,
0.139095813,
-0.4008717239,
-0.2054778785,
0.0791654587,
0.4824608266,
0.4538783729,
0.3423165679,
-0.1330188811,
-0.2889655828,
0.1829217821,
0.4558108747,
-0.6843906641,
0.2662121356,
0.5016221404,
-0.1243234798,
-0.2796313167,
-0.0863137394,
-0.2698130012,
-0.6560407877,
-0.4923047721,
0.3237376809,
-0.2470730245,
-0.2198709697,
0.1674766541,
0.1758732498,
0.3581997454,
0.2525740564,
-0.9107122421,
0.5116949081,
1.2182428837,
0.6349896789,
-0.2409829497,
-0.3664449155,
-0.887775898,
0.018161783,
-0.2053370327,
0.7698414326,
-0.2698421776,
-0.1502229869,
0.0532401875,
-0.1392462552,
-0.0413466431,
-0.5125740767,
0.6873398423,
-0.5758222342,
-0.1166919023,
-0.1997769028,
-0.5930348039,
0.3079023957,
0.455129385,
-0.6068965197,
1.1097872257,
0.3225283027,
-0.4815062582,
0.3211047351,
-0.7569716573,
-0.4446002543,
0.1647925079,
-0.1293975562,
-0.6074685454,
0.0172663163,
-0.009844101,
0.1798092425,
-0.4877447784,
0.3328944743,
-0.226300329,
-0.2016117126,
0.507945776,
-0.3874051571,
0.9348059893,
0.2623171806,
-0.3987701535,
0.3587074578,
-0.7382460237,
0.2121107727,
-0.0893732309,
0.0579965673,
-0.4530322254,
0.1441279054,
0.0894397944,
-0.0167138353,
0.6583845615,
-0.4859369695,
0.1369558126,
-0.3282709718,
0.1741878837,
0.7059608698,
-0.47539711,
0.5611694455,
-0.4613537788,
0.9548078179,
-0.5227726698,
0.3623344004,
0.1185422689,
-0.1684204936,
-0.4190177321,
-0.3716248274,
0.3645562828,
0.7501316071,
-0.6839105487,
0.7493005395,
-0.3058069944,
-0.4869134128,
-0.4223960936,
0.2641400397,
0.3572957814,
0.4634687603,
0.0300311614,
-0.0083683915,
-0.3175874054,
-0.7971283197,
-0.3998173177,
-0.3229252696,
-0.2628242671,
0.374824971,
0.1986495703,
-0.2475556433,
1.3410358429,
-0.2972413003,
-0.1923746318,
-0.1692510396,
-0.1651791185,
-0.0103883464,
0.3376235068,
0.4482281804,
-0.8225856423,
-0.6199008822,
0.289537102,
-0.7638563514,
-0.7252728343,
0.0646817014,
-0.236028567,
0.1287451684,
0.2170974463,
-0.6220490932,
0.4474139214,
0.5860273838,
-0.6044296026,
0.4464541972,
-0.2911758423,
0.2729663253,
-1.0015870333,
0.3180544078,
-0.0869062692,
-0.5127922893,
-0.5747430325,
0.1193476915,
0.2020718157,
-0.0175802317,
-0.2508571148,
0.580370605,
-0.490607053,
-0.264914155,
-0.5048751235,
0.176634714,
0.077493526,
0.020874491,
-0.405638814,
1.058683157,
0.4705744386,
-0.3056797683,
0.5316069126,
0.0992983058,
-0.0100249555,
0.8928576112,
-0.7283526063,
0.1347565651,
0.172926724,
-0.1285248995,
-1.0540266037,
-0.2466603816,
-0.1263392866,
-0.4205792844,
0.0604242235,
0.2446600497,
-0.5038462877,
-0.1317622662,
-0.365981251,
0.6522459984,
0.4916319251,
-0.3925877213,
1.1363050938,
0.5041104555,
0.0260355007,
-0.7816335559,
-0.1928275824,
0.1692371666,
-0.2841777503,
-1.0502519608,
0.3709903359,
0.0565761477,
-0.6996321082,
-0.0488120131,
-0.1254825741,
0.1140020564,
0.4283160567,
0.4054159224,
0.4464196563,
0.0428332686,
0.0499511361,
-0.0626702011,
-0.3918324113,
-0.0180697441,
-0.1066353098,
0.2905510962,
-0.2825385928,
-0.7681707144,
-0.2789580524,
0.0813809335,
0.595051527,
-0.2504470348,
0.3393580914,
0.3900776505,
-0.3626015186,
0.070421949,
-0.629524827,
0.0834025517,
-0.5806690454,
0.2338216603,
-0.1629188508,
-0.8048482537,
0.7310784459,
-0.2495196909,
0.2067677528,
0.2646976709,
0.665286243,
0.1670994908,
1.3027021885,
0.7703228593,
0.0207286179,
0.4529769719,
-0.0303606857,
0.0033861254,
-0.5879567862,
-0.1684363484,
-0.6784866452,
-0.2959546745,
-0.4931901395,
-0.1724904776,
0.5506896377,
-0.2425487041,
-0.0944255665,
0.5224153399,
-0.4339020848,
0.6331763864,
0.1800838262,
-0.3235475123,
0.3444413245,
0.04061855,
-0.0065481891,
0.0381984822,
-0.347989589,
-0.8028409481,
0.9304257631,
0.3040095568,
0.8677332401,
0.4494416714,
0.5922024846,
0.4849183559,
0.4681447446,
-0.9791177511,
0.6215705872,
-0.0816909298,
-0.4388335645,
-0.6233562231,
-0.322485894,
-1.4410003424,
0.2738950253,
-0.0412196778,
-0.8985104561,
-0.0330414549,
0.2710551023,
-0.4673659801,
-0.1177552268,
-0.7216193676,
0.9615553021,
-0.6037798524,
-0.7915718555,
-0.294608444,
-0.4506959319,
0.0516787618,
-0.0097392416,
0.1833009124,
-0.4016647637,
-0.3008579612,
0.3978834152,
-0.8955641389,
0.5705176592,
-0.0262408108,
-0.4484559596,
0.1860858947,
0.0498588383,
0.4899424314,
-0.1735678017,
-0.2454750091,
0.012964963,
0.1804435551,
-0.5199355483,
-0.9215480089,
0.6620881557,
-0.6440801024,
-0.6581127048,
-0.5841014981,
-0.612216115,
-0.4004866183,
0.1943507046,
-0.2074185759,
0.3410158157,
-0.2993498445,
0.0539628975,
0.2714239061,
0.2743184566,
0.3944389224,
0.5385439992,
-0.3432866633,
-0.3486433625,
0.7963621616,
-0.2225473821,
0.2165818363,
0.4154404998,
0.2009912729,
-0.4943135083,
-0.2630325854,
-0.404859513,
-0.1133392155,
-0.4396444559,
-0.3437075019,
-0.0971731693,
0.0045745173,
-0.351744324,
-0.2517370284,
-0.4160740376,
-0.3225681782,
-0.1775167286,
0.2324108183,
0.1319624633,
0.4889796972,
0.0365049429,
0.3593107462,
-0.7503160834,
0.2091725022,
0.4313944578,
0.2935745716,
-0.162447691,
-0.1814628243,
-0.3750329316,
-0.122133255,
-0.6223903298,
-0.6902517676,
0.3383364975,
0.1609344929,
0.6317564845,
0.4422377348,
0.1785354465,
0.4508140683,
-0.3692717254,
0.7428430915,
0.2305288315,
-1.1866166592,
0.3620273769,
-0.0394656844,
0.1462257653,
0.6096251011,
0.0755825788,
-0.3569101691,
-0.2339595854,
-0.5315983891,
-0.7341552377,
0.370223105,
0.505649209,
-0.0234385692,
0.2649789453,
0.3303647041,
-0.043244984,
0.090885438,
-0.2390804142,
-0.154304713,
-0.0936267823,
-0.4505741894,
-0.1200860068,
-0.0416203998,
-0.1494522542,
-0.0905701146,
0.459746182,
-0.3682435155,
-0.0763427168,
-0.038613122,
-0.1860768199,
-0.254565239,
0.3393033147,
0.6553595662,
0.8648775816,
-0.1599552035,
0.4214977324,
0.0873227268,
-0.6456773281,
0.5401280522,
0.3214564621,
0.0620604008,
-0.318669796,
0.5253124833,
0.4527504742,
0.043104317,
-0.8740103841,
0.7622980475,
-0.2942924798,
-0.0290206317,
-0.2853552997,
0.3813860714,
-0.1829064339,
0.4106685221,
0.4635326266,
-0.1161471903,
0.1972019672,
-0.2719675004,
0.163373217,
0.920224309,
-0.187182799,
-0.2392628044,
0.451972425,
0.286563158,
-0.9318255186,
0.2644253969,
-0.1271875203,
-0.4878921211,
0.8372942209,
0.4099420607,
1.1512346268,
-0.3791396618,
0.0426924229,
-0.1162137911,
0.3043254018,
0.1665109396,
0.3750194609,
-0.2229336947,
-0.7278319001,
-0.6678349972,
-0.40921399,
-0.589879334,
-0.3726661205,
-0.5723545551,
0.2085029632,
0.0702342615,
-0.6538978219,
0.0984014347,
0.2542682588,
-0.6161366701,
-0.3143529296,
-0.2484264225,
0.7350425124,
-0.6958433986,
0.8010060191,
0.9551485181,
-0.0145937828,
-0.7275024056,
0.0116089499,
-0.020121377,
-0.9662154317,
0.594075501,
-0.0461617783,
-0.4762940109,
-0.0898885205,
-0.449072957,
-0.7390388846,
1.3621999025,
0.9157627821,
-0.4849188328,
0.3630170524,
0.5526783466,
0.6517882943,
-0.2588737011,
0.4022350907,
0.5355730057,
0.5731387138,
0.2187189311,
-1.2533487082,
0.1115685701,
-0.2872804105,
0.0593259893,
0.3812919557,
-0.3972814679,
0.3938320577,
-0.1463679969,
-0.1150832027,
0.1079532057,
0.5828486085,
0.2897262871,
0.7265069485,
0.5888454914,
0.3182446659,
1.0184062719,
0.1569443345,
1.0533289909,
-0.5279313326,
0.4901817441,
0.7579991817,
-0.7261105776,
0.5641753078,
0.5169069171,
-0.4815991223,
0.3100855649,
0.3054580986,
0.3294663429,
0.170029074,
0.2779254913,
-0.3740036488,
-0.4948266149,
-0.2652716935,
-0.2615578771,
0.5571034551,
0.0675804466,
0.2293741554,
-0.329582572,
-0.015880594,
-0.2454520762,
0.3400629461,
-0.1049638987,
0.7303319573,
0.0415468179,
-0.7953240871,
0.4538314342,
-0.0350777805,
0.3647177517,
-0.499111712,
-0.0902783051,
-0.1103429273,
0.3056034446,
-0.3847330213,
-0.6151721478,
0.2963432372,
-0.0847781748,
0.0181059726,
-0.1503315121,
1.0340992212,
-0.2149270624,
-0.3459999859,
0.006398601,
0.6512795091,
0.0887649357,
-0.0094213877,
-0.6812989712,
0.1650676876,
-0.4235207736,
0.0864027739,
0.4250435829,
0.3484967053,
-0.153400749,
0.9204007983,
0.5495001674,
-0.0391326882,
-0.2897414565,
0.1369224787,
0.5819811225,
-0.3599961698,
-0.4499103129,
-1.194212079,
0.4384788275,
-0.2283318788,
-0.010723752,
1.0274319649,
0.5907857418,
0.1923675537,
0.2810845971,
0.4292992949,
0.0961621404,
0.089767009,
-0.352628082,
0.5959753394,
-0.5864095688,
0.6195801497,
-0.2029275894,
-0.7998158336,
-0.3907148838,
0.6061282754,
-0.3871171474,
0.1516937762,
0.6132895947,
0.872585237,
0.0110133793,
-0.1068899259,
0.5126247406,
-0.4350154102,
0.4410010874,
0.5644841194,
1.0809499025,
-0.2449976653,
0.3526690304,
-0.0434515551,
-0.487277329,
-0.2835104465,
-1.3282623291,
-0.7423186302,
-0.4922393262,
-0.4301537275,
-0.5979267955,
-0.0916578397,
1.2625601292,
0.6718314886,
-0.743742764,
-0.6758857965,
-0.1913532913,
0.4413423538,
-0.4734871984,
-0.1638548076,
0.4995119572,
-0.2936319113,
-0.5585544109,
0.0210832935,
0.3613862097,
-0.0827282518,
-0.5317109227,
-0.4013724327,
0.3431537449,
0.1787704825,
0.558642447,
0.2716200054,
-0.5770620704,
-0.2026397735,
0.2614035606,
-0.3495985568,
-0.0509447232,
1.0567295551,
-0.6472717524,
0.2855156064,
0.3900251389,
0.8240818977,
-0.032620009,
0.3166189492,
0.4579647779,
-0.6939531565,
-0.2143981904,
0.1611817181,
0.3467424512,
0.3162802458,
-0.5108476281,
0.5066402555,
-0.0653246045,
-0.9084331989,
-0.8997408152,
0.1957334429,
-1.2416627407,
0.0965230837,
1.0481294394,
0.0667590871,
-0.3113661408,
-0.2166728675,
-0.3428786397,
0.0526379161,
-0.4050279558,
0.8575072885,
0.6723617315,
-0.5300598741,
0.1099636927,
-0.360999167,
0.4429092705,
0.5238898396,
-0.9559747577,
0.2025895864,
0.4659769237,
0.141829133,
0.3305877447,
0.6094032526,
0.151916042,
0.237318337,
-0.305110395,
0.206246525,
-0.210947454,
0.0913575366,
-0.3495137095,
0.3530056775,
0.3757404089,
-0.1231482252
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.09008v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.09008v1
|
Multi-Query Focused Disaster Summarization via Instruction-Based Prompting
| 2024-02-14T08:22:58 | 2024-02-14T08:22:58 |
Philipp Seeberger, Korbinian Riedhammer
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Automatic summarization of mass-emergency events plays a critical role in
disaster management. The second edition of CrisisFACTS aims to advance disaster
summarization based on multi-stream fact-finding with a focus on web sources
such as Twitter, Reddit, Facebook, and Webnews. Here, participants are asked to
develop systems that can extract key facts from several disaster-related
events, which ultimately serve as a summary. This paper describes our method to
tackle this challenging task. We follow previous work and propose to use a
combination of retrieval, reranking, and an embarrassingly simple
instruction-following summarization. The two-stage retrieval pipeline relies on
BM25 and MonoT5, while the summarizer module is based on the open-source Large
Language Model (LLM) LLaMA-13b. For summarization, we explore a Question
Answering (QA)-motivated prompting approach and find the evidence useful for
extracting query-relevant facts. The automatic metrics and human evaluation
show strong results but also highlight the gap between open-source and
proprietary systems.
|
[
-0.3158682883,
-0.752494514,
0.5948296785,
0.5192480087,
-0.3706173897,
0.1261529624,
0.0395402461,
-0.0434161611,
0.3838003874,
0.2928619981,
-0.5997118354,
-0.3910408914,
-0.458752811,
0.244300127,
-0.6489596963,
1.0868033171,
0.1176592782,
-0.1602580547,
-0.0178034492,
0.0495487973,
-0.3790891767,
-0.3373973668,
-0.5592473149,
0.0670114905,
0.7213278413,
1.0844296217,
0.385889411,
0.2975159585,
0.4977869689,
0.2173791081,
-0.0479398519,
0.2498228848,
-0.6527807117,
0.1700656116,
0.0428749025,
-0.2435936183,
-0.1385991126,
-0.1492697746,
0.4216551483,
0.2973701358,
-0.3983689547,
0.3077250123,
0.1803194582,
0.6047385335,
-0.8060613871,
0.2417554706,
-0.3757521808,
-0.0534128845,
0.1514719427,
-0.5319490433,
-0.4388406277,
-0.6406958699,
0.138880074,
-0.3639346063,
0.5126046538,
-0.0540740006,
0.3852030039,
0.3590639234,
-0.6733701825,
-0.4515540898,
-0.4122277796,
0.5532907248,
-0.3011502326,
0.2340945452,
0.2403167933,
0.1982930899,
0.0557418615,
-0.8242095113,
-0.2335175276,
0.2495620102,
0.0208458044,
0.3014810383,
0.1989348233,
-0.0747176036,
0.0457644276,
0.2572205961,
-0.5211570859,
-0.1045920998,
-0.4484440088,
-0.2318065315,
0.6522006392,
0.3740077913,
0.0967773646,
-0.5667566657,
-0.4794041812,
-0.1643288434,
-0.8516490459,
-0.08616478,
0.0070217438,
0.3347834051,
-0.1735031605,
0.5853456259,
-0.3611918092,
0.312206924,
-0.1851457506,
-0.2516230643,
0.0206864215,
-0.4988346994,
-0.1063460037,
0.1165846512,
0.6593309641,
0.7994710207,
0.040395882,
-0.055204913,
0.0028156003,
-0.5819340348,
0.202195555,
-0.9089655876,
-0.2448098063,
0.1977819204,
-0.5028049946,
-0.2799035311,
0.0183625817,
-1.120524168,
-0.5786533356,
-0.0322275572,
0.5802078843,
-0.0013156699,
-0.0684994459,
-0.1368292421,
-0.4800716341,
0.0380403623,
0.6030116081,
-0.5873221159,
-0.1008639187,
0.4211365283,
1.0127800703,
0.1613771319,
-0.1037028953,
-0.5487038493,
0.1229692996,
-0.0312415008,
1.1865913868,
-0.2979069054,
-0.579878211,
0.0876119435,
0.0690928996,
0.161870271,
-0.5187748671,
0.6326521039,
-0.5305585265,
0.218132019,
-0.6286607981,
-0.3052594066,
-0.3793777227,
0.1322887987,
-0.4571470022,
0.9083325863,
-0.3622047603,
-0.8618206382,
0.2325299978,
-0.4443109035,
-0.573702395,
-0.2011300474,
0.0028792149,
-0.3471421301,
0.1752298623,
0.3833296895,
0.3605923355,
-0.385288924,
0.2037075907,
-0.1757553071,
-0.2930014431,
-0.3022069931,
-0.5521381497,
0.6683612466,
-0.0840937048,
-0.1410629153,
0.0944752768,
-0.5047929287,
-0.0691248626,
0.124163568,
-0.7506600618,
-0.2566884756,
0.2276442051,
-0.0654812306,
0.0698754191,
0.244979158,
-0.1251600385,
0.2605772316,
0.0280695781,
-0.0116737708,
0.4306743741,
0.5685950518,
0.1499289125,
-0.3649009168,
0.3622364104,
-0.0930349678,
0.2205163389,
-0.6572263241,
-0.5436092615,
-0.7041218281,
-0.1298502684,
-0.1674938053,
0.9292680621,
-0.631534338,
0.0297565106,
0.0502025597,
-0.4445950687,
-0.2144194841,
-0.0350914747,
0.1925489306,
0.7203518152,
0.7670912743,
0.025626976,
-0.8145233989,
-0.6751973033,
-0.2344012856,
-0.2278207988,
-0.0827479139,
0.1530364901,
0.1987908334,
0.2448224574,
0.7403429747,
-0.9622113705,
-0.0398850031,
-0.4111893773,
0.4506819844,
0.0483554415,
0.1020109802,
0.4167368412,
-0.7176295519,
-0.2411406487,
-0.5286028385,
-0.7282536626,
-0.1249318346,
-0.0509635136,
0.0856745914,
-0.0755436793,
0.4118612707,
-0.4477276206,
0.4003343582,
-0.1419795752,
-0.2094430178,
0.6852433681,
-0.1125625223,
0.4158774614,
-1.210550189,
-0.1069155931,
-0.1157641336,
-0.0043110689,
-0.5139425397,
0.1532414556,
0.1561837643,
-0.1756269634,
-0.3886158764,
0.3081544042,
-0.5808069706,
-0.071643956,
-0.3349070549,
0.4344448447,
-0.1422412843,
0.1492549032,
0.019902382,
0.7356358171,
0.3087227941,
-0.6911979318,
0.5581640601,
0.3801544905,
-0.0514094681,
0.3032217026,
-0.582133472,
-0.0317700319,
-0.3960439563,
0.44662866,
-1.058401227,
-0.5545763373,
0.1523955911,
-0.1934427172,
-0.0088702608,
-0.3529039621,
-0.350415647,
-0.4859928191,
-0.6818186641,
-0.0189766046,
0.3081719577,
-0.4209738672,
0.4986921251,
0.5564728379,
-0.7186352611,
-0.7687371969,
-0.4564675093,
0.362082392,
-0.2436310947,
-0.3785859942,
-0.0865778327,
-0.1714400351,
-0.1004943028,
-0.0744415447,
-0.3195241392,
-0.4137650132,
0.2751306593,
0.2319829166,
0.1747860312,
-0.2810608447,
0.1197466999,
0.1716554165,
0.0355536118,
0.2314970046,
0.0518175587,
0.3144765496,
0.0373557582,
-0.2355178595,
-0.5385189652,
0.7947853208,
0.493124187,
-0.1558994651,
0.6622718573,
0.2342320979,
-0.3981774449,
0.1756066829,
-0.6328369975,
-0.5727413297,
-0.3560344279,
0.2554305196,
0.0803956389,
-0.6615444422,
0.6246165037,
-0.249242574,
0.4325384498,
0.4351410568,
0.5302014947,
-0.0703782141,
0.780076921,
0.4760093093,
-0.2043118477,
0.382537961,
-0.1369529516,
0.0158892032,
-0.3704390526,
-0.4982551336,
-0.6488342881,
-0.1702289879,
0.0287769251,
-0.2989702523,
0.659609437,
0.094585225,
0.1735849828,
0.0464038774,
-0.1142149344,
0.6544712782,
0.4215506911,
0.1382056177,
0.5009381771,
0.0121771209,
0.2097801864,
0.3655966818,
-0.6867823005,
-0.3619962335,
0.816368103,
-0.0813309997,
0.6516343951,
0.4101108313,
1.0397747755,
0.2329667509,
0.474737525,
-0.6829112172,
0.5471425056,
0.1843767017,
-0.7015655041,
-0.4264199436,
-0.5007428527,
-0.6994442344,
0.2613053322,
-0.1921216249,
-0.4519814253,
0.1375813484,
0.1687397063,
-0.7296113968,
-0.153061524,
-1.000877738,
0.5208381414,
0.0749746487,
0.1512178034,
-0.7473953366,
-0.7132622004,
0.5792159438,
0.1371426731,
0.5251616836,
0.0511912368,
-0.1965595633,
0.4159635603,
-0.4118169546,
0.8054757118,
-0.240181759,
-0.0715717003,
0.7011853456,
-0.0005249687,
0.4439443052,
0.4337884486,
0.0674331412,
-0.5063295364,
-0.1680350751,
-0.3431334794,
-0.6899697185,
0.5236507058,
-0.3786044717,
-0.7556818128,
-0.128503114,
-0.3870736957,
-0.0429867692,
0.2554769814,
0.1221898049,
0.9350286126,
-0.2075581849,
0.1231966615,
0.6377892494,
0.000035879,
0.7968478203,
0.6778817177,
-0.0472544171,
-0.4252671897,
0.9195251465,
0.3535405695,
-0.1197575778,
0.5476076603,
0.2709528804,
-0.3107108176,
-0.3543838561,
-0.5935108066,
0.1514513344,
-0.7633305192,
-0.5685754418,
-0.7806401849,
-0.0367454626,
-0.3144794106,
-0.0851404816,
-0.0708731934,
-0.6844602823,
-0.3403863311,
-0.42614007,
0.2092436105,
0.8039007187,
-0.1899559796,
-0.0396553092,
-1.078999877,
0.4622018635,
0.356903404,
0.0626780316,
0.1470773667,
-0.2929999828,
-0.2633270025,
-0.2470672876,
-0.4453468621,
-1.4384150505,
-0.0291143861,
0.3895422816,
0.2841430008,
0.6691020727,
0.5279461145,
0.6204897165,
-0.4586284459,
0.7140655518,
0.095399566,
-0.5846111774,
0.7301992178,
-0.1756949723,
0.0411289446,
0.5403788686,
0.5836334825,
-0.4865469337,
-0.4637137651,
-0.4722827077,
-0.9220382571,
0.6956737638,
0.0083320122,
0.0620096289,
-0.2441714704,
0.2097390294,
0.0037585848,
0.1363155097,
-0.0440864936,
-0.4690461457,
-0.3892680109,
-0.2320954651,
0.0925185904,
-0.6555230021,
-0.2679307461,
0.1145071015,
0.6462994218,
-0.1511846334,
-0.1669987887,
0.2306947112,
-0.2712200582,
0.250630945,
0.3353352547,
0.8555519581,
0.5861566663,
-0.1352679133,
0.2965832651,
0.4180950522,
-0.6470910311,
0.23494941,
0.220257625,
-0.2557258606,
0.0832403302,
0.4580695331,
0.1625379175,
0.7084930539,
-0.6882982254,
0.4505374134,
-0.2890606523,
0.1206544712,
0.010616079,
0.1067042425,
0.1258124411,
0.3856623173,
0.9090730548,
-0.2514082491,
0.7309553623,
-0.4670600593,
0.3453059494,
-0.0014972346,
0.2487128675,
-0.3567720354,
0.3651976287,
0.5303604007,
-0.0346152894,
0.472448647,
-0.1890799254,
-0.2806352377,
0.605918169,
0.3316234946,
0.7001310587,
-0.5058575273,
0.4308334291,
0.6280198097,
0.3100889921,
-0.3547592461,
0.693058908,
-0.1390151531,
-0.2709803879,
-0.5126395226,
-0.1268273592,
-0.4890082181,
-0.0519204363,
-0.7266789079,
0.3295508623,
-0.4133017957,
-0.0690421611,
-0.1747414917,
-0.2535475492,
-0.1125368401,
0.1009308472,
-0.1956676096,
1.1137439013,
-0.7031446099,
-0.0798473433,
0.7640093565,
-0.4503905475,
-0.8450884819,
0.2257764786,
0.3462966084,
-0.510289669,
0.1607944071,
0.1110463515,
0.1539367735,
0.1731149405,
-0.3903401494,
-0.8626408577,
0.9007627368,
0.4673390687,
-0.3353126943,
-0.3183985054,
-0.3087620735,
0.1196287647,
0.0711184815,
0.5605225563,
0.3899697661,
0.5304544568,
0.038804166,
-0.6570781469,
0.0621816926,
0.0581854247,
-0.7036299706,
0.2355701178,
-1.0419430733,
0.3709980845,
-0.7906091809,
-0.4265837967,
-0.2411138713,
0.8856320381,
0.0676910207,
0.6316003203,
0.3571070135,
0.4507649541,
0.8686490059,
0.0284674671,
0.8691830635,
-0.2715300918,
0.5606363416,
1.0602283478,
0.3191727102,
0.7728316188,
0.0595135801,
-0.0643880516,
0.418820858,
0.7168501616,
0.4450101554,
0.6351957917,
-0.2712487876,
-0.3637999296,
-0.2556580007,
-0.1245044917,
-0.341204226,
0.3550587595,
0.3792657256,
-0.080221802,
-0.8852049112,
-0.2401179522,
0.1402362585,
-0.5631537437,
-0.2437755167,
0.9091903567,
0.223879382,
-0.6112202406,
0.3276905715,
0.0040962645,
0.0558322929,
-0.170806244,
-0.0929958448,
-0.5102481842,
-0.3263002336,
-0.2717921734,
-0.8398219347,
0.5319123864,
0.2348267883,
-0.5288179517,
0.1112150475,
0.4788101017,
-0.3940798044,
-0.2656685114,
-0.1523170769,
0.627667129,
0.2983655334,
-0.2075460702,
-0.3408693671,
-0.0447032414,
-0.1580782831,
-0.3340325058,
0.1597153991,
0.5696151257,
-0.0304926336,
0.7929905653,
0.3326022923,
-0.3221818209,
0.0521075651,
0.3288962841,
0.8760952353,
-0.713328898,
-0.5425593853,
-0.7933863997,
0.4361854494,
-0.0986668095,
-0.2071809173,
0.6367326379,
0.7189266682,
0.1583409607,
-0.0066077779,
0.7603291869,
-0.1148447618,
0.635533154,
-0.3763563633,
0.4782906473,
-0.5038625598,
0.0101166312,
-0.1045562029,
-0.7284711599,
-0.1622402668,
0.1875211895,
0.196098879,
-0.2389803976,
0.5367441773,
0.5600071549,
0.0697608218,
0.1944676936,
-0.1798462123,
0.2536625862,
0.1699144989,
0.2921432257,
0.6538556814,
-0.0557118542,
0.8811246157,
0.0374906212,
-0.4601803422,
-0.8692542911,
-0.8275773525,
-0.6925911903,
-0.6226392984,
-0.2715929151,
-0.0825485587,
0.0309162252,
0.8186367154,
0.4029179513,
-0.7759859562,
0.151012972,
0.1800835282,
0.7478458285,
-0.0039300187,
-0.2274027318,
0.4042857289,
-0.2809003294,
-0.3869513571,
0.7880095243,
0.4643665552,
0.0347341821,
-0.0636382028,
0.2451911867,
0.0089449622,
0.1691292673,
0.6713452339,
0.3040888906,
-0.3893606365,
-0.3675642908,
-0.091151759,
0.0581012629,
-0.2525041699,
0.9172923565,
-0.7258955836,
0.0554649383,
0.6305221319,
0.6479433179,
0.0737089142,
0.4374719262,
0.3119383454,
-0.7933907509,
-0.0331143364,
-0.0327974334,
0.1699649841,
0.3905672431,
-0.4765345156,
0.4249466956,
0.4664382935,
-0.3974803686,
-0.884360671,
0.1663908064,
-0.412388891,
-0.1415603608,
0.9152084589,
-0.0806536973,
0.2109176517,
-0.3501437604,
-0.2586874962,
0.3446065485,
-0.6878796816,
1.1420688629,
0.5935252905,
-0.3093034625,
-0.4733899534,
-0.2753572166,
0.3097285628,
0.0234421659,
-0.9547755718,
0.1000931486,
0.7545113564,
0.365601629,
0.1288336068,
0.530303061,
0.2365701646,
0.4183026552,
-0.1557639241,
-0.0972653404,
-0.0653310791,
-0.7811838984,
-0.0757063478,
0.6112287045,
-0.3656503558,
0.0497844592
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08983v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08983v3
|
SafeDecoding: Defending against Jailbreak Attacks via Safety-Aware Decoding
| 2024-02-14T06:54:31 | 2024-06-07T17:25:04 |
Zhangchen Xu, Fengqing Jiang, Luyao Niu, Jinyuan Jia, Bill Yuchen Lin, Radha Poovendran
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
As large language models (LLMs) become increasingly integrated into
real-world applications such as code generation and chatbot assistance,
extensive efforts have been made to align LLM behavior with human values,
including safety. Jailbreak attacks, aiming to provoke unintended and unsafe
behaviors from LLMs, remain a significant/leading LLM safety threat. In this
paper, we aim to defend LLMs against jailbreak attacks by introducing
SafeDecoding, a safety-aware decoding strategy for LLMs to generate helpful and
harmless responses to user queries. Our insight in developing SafeDecoding is
based on the observation that, even though probabilities of tokens representing
harmful contents outweigh those representing harmless responses, safety
disclaimers still appear among the top tokens after sorting tokens by
probability in descending order. This allows us to mitigate jailbreak attacks
by identifying safety disclaimers and amplifying their token probabilities,
while simultaneously attenuating the probabilities of token sequences that are
aligned with the objectives of jailbreak attacks. We perform extensive
experiments on five LLMs using six state-of-the-art jailbreak attacks and four
benchmark datasets. Our results show that SafeDecoding significantly reduces
the attack success rate and harmfulness of jailbreak attacks without
compromising the helpfulness of responses to benign user queries. SafeDecoding
outperforms six defense methods.
|
[
-0.1917610317,
-0.8192062378,
0.2671313584,
0.101214543,
-0.4433000386,
0.4036574066,
-0.0372231081,
-0.5229907632,
0.1440488398,
0.824972868,
-0.069674924,
-0.8810101748,
-0.6161834002,
0.0129691735,
-0.4550229013,
0.9487310648,
0.2052925229,
-0.2238672823,
0.0399132036,
0.0497512817,
-0.6938245296,
-0.8579005003,
-0.7227095962,
0.366522938,
0.3547230661,
0.4115687907,
0.6145662069,
0.5878926516,
0.4601657987,
0.2574974895,
-0.1933781058,
0.2151895314,
-0.5196624398,
0.5767226815,
0.0201039761,
-0.4817820489,
-0.5010389686,
-0.1407657266,
-0.160179317,
0.0566880181,
-0.279517144,
-0.2996331751,
0.0194607116,
0.6944527626,
-1.0043377876,
-0.0406825878,
-0.7683671117,
-0.0264530424,
-0.1891563237,
-0.2489842027,
-0.788051486,
-0.667119503,
-0.4338304996,
-0.1013873741,
-0.0157142114,
0.1637976617,
0.1748921424,
0.0323251858,
-0.425817728,
-0.3294931352,
-0.228456229,
0.5118872523,
-0.6901014447,
0.0701542869,
0.7456768155,
0.1549996287,
-0.5673241615,
-0.253262043,
-0.0854521543,
-0.2262655199,
0.189463526,
-0.2564116716,
-0.2976757884,
0.3857581317,
0.1620376855,
-0.089890182,
-0.2714286447,
0.1913212836,
-0.1690962315,
-0.5055021048,
0.7263387442,
0.2424895018,
0.4339383841,
-0.3138422966,
-0.491145879,
-0.0054209828,
-0.8762004375,
0.0555091575,
0.4851619899,
0.2129183114,
-0.1044743657,
0.4904357791,
-0.0862833187,
0.4694564641,
-0.04195337,
-0.2397202551,
-0.0479827039,
-0.3483551741,
-0.0057089673,
0.5044662952,
0.9168992639,
0.8496397138,
0.5544752479,
-0.5000309944,
-0.1172973439,
-0.0541963913,
0.4628091156,
-0.9194058776,
-0.2434566617,
0.2368214279,
-0.4163083136,
-1.0343251228,
0.2119391114,
-0.6282483935,
-0.8349619508,
0.6195400357,
0.0996992737,
-0.4568226933,
-0.1844066232,
0.3080492616,
0.0629207939,
0.0382391699,
-0.056402728,
-1.0772596598,
0.4367146492,
0.804821074,
0.6737299562,
-0.0407799259,
0.044558987,
-0.712007761,
0.411663413,
-0.4383714795,
0.5175182819,
0.0301306061,
-0.7531222105,
-0.1622330248,
-0.0494086035,
-0.0043673166,
-0.5481637716,
0.8188617826,
-0.7584981918,
-0.7441244125,
-0.0888126045,
-0.4941212535,
-0.0262916796,
0.2242894322,
-0.7916708589,
0.3698739111,
-0.4021247029,
-1.1556601524,
0.1679105312,
-0.2916569114,
-0.7103460431,
-0.0663727745,
0.2143825591,
-0.3394898772,
0.1596246213,
0.3267930746,
0.5276278257,
0.0666897893,
0.1881406605,
-0.4551058114,
-0.2922745943,
0.5056465864,
-0.4575863183,
0.7768550515,
0.5785118937,
-0.3491869271,
0.1224179566,
-0.5768459439,
0.1292671859,
0.292694658,
-0.2527289987,
-0.8268530965,
0.276189208,
-0.167019397,
-0.0721605197,
0.1288823783,
-0.8911138773,
-0.0129148355,
-0.4535305798,
0.6533926129,
0.8179978132,
0.1699538678,
0.3247718513,
0.0236935392,
0.393748939,
0.0578907393,
0.3803819716,
-0.2016818076,
-0.2992912531,
-0.1024085954,
-0.2625915408,
0.2271126062,
0.8852501512,
-0.2915544808,
0.5405645967,
0.0977579877,
-0.2740638554,
-0.3385359049,
0.3319637179,
0.536316216,
0.5671222806,
0.1866796464,
-0.316049993,
-0.7063690424,
-0.6945780516,
-0.4270040393,
-0.2809400856,
0.3234084547,
0.0029174739,
-0.0503549241,
-0.3301042318,
0.7276652455,
-0.4939717352,
0.0794280767,
-0.5238350034,
-0.2916882932,
-0.0653195679,
0.6536890864,
0.7072165012,
-0.4789406955,
-0.1651241034,
-0.3639383316,
-0.7228178382,
-0.0626935363,
-0.0470440127,
-0.1711038798,
0.2973452508,
0.6785513759,
-0.717757225,
0.4748351276,
0.3025648296,
-0.6360885501,
0.3891501129,
-0.2380699068,
0.101200752,
-1.1382710934,
-0.3280410469,
-0.2379164845,
-0.3639037907,
-0.5965138078,
0.273671627,
0.2368864864,
0.0556587577,
-0.5629245043,
0.2312217206,
-0.1384488791,
0.2506715357,
-0.2362306118,
-0.0324730016,
-0.0815394297,
-0.1858751476,
-0.2698381543,
0.8014714122,
0.4715768993,
-0.1474686414,
0.3170636594,
0.2142384648,
-0.583560884,
0.0516438745,
-0.6892725825,
0.3590410054,
-0.0648247078,
0.0873869732,
-0.8404511213,
-0.0770186111,
0.3282517791,
-0.2624777555,
0.1502699703,
-0.4839285612,
-0.6936920881,
-0.3988811374,
-0.6544274092,
0.234547466,
0.4395737052,
-0.4486401975,
0.0492400266,
0.6084809899,
-0.2411118746,
-0.7803667784,
-0.6120555997,
0.3788506389,
-0.4965492189,
-0.6298573613,
-0.0101258401,
-0.237354964,
-0.4079961479,
-0.3529965281,
-0.3912428916,
-0.0490851849,
0.8256026506,
0.5163042545,
0.4239689708,
0.4052948952,
-0.4347657561,
0.0918070748,
-0.4544380605,
0.500746727,
0.0195077304,
0.4692684114,
-0.159105584,
-0.2553764582,
-0.3327120245,
0.5308762789,
0.6191053987,
-0.2281838655,
0.7968367338,
0.1363129467,
-0.1469019055,
-0.0193359181,
-0.4243892729,
-0.2498937845,
-0.5603545308,
0.1851909906,
-0.2480814755,
-0.9871689081,
0.4749603868,
0.0745263994,
0.0449837185,
-0.2022833377,
0.2565792501,
-0.3215408027,
1.2144986391,
0.593416512,
-0.3920725882,
0.3093757033,
-0.0114530781,
0.4624318779,
-0.4212761223,
-0.3851095736,
-0.5399485826,
-0.0305468217,
-0.7047207355,
-0.0779296309,
-0.0436682031,
0.5047957897,
-0.2132451981,
0.5587278008,
-0.4393695891,
0.8751596212,
0.3162126541,
0.2311470658,
0.3502688706,
-0.1087268218,
-0.3020291328,
0.0367445238,
-0.4935124815,
-0.4762323201,
1.19559443,
0.3090352714,
1.4400631189,
0.2486320585,
1.1958134174,
0.4518800378,
0.0141600724,
-0.7069532275,
0.7271569371,
-0.126096949,
-0.5985349417,
0.1153328642,
-0.4545131028,
-0.8797857761,
0.0057395506,
-0.1620583832,
-0.846447587,
-0.0372631103,
0.1840580255,
-0.4084571004,
0.5472171307,
-0.7440742254,
0.7779379487,
-0.6093681455,
-0.2866115868,
-0.2114549577,
-0.8305968046,
0.5061491132,
-0.0506744683,
0.5268303156,
-0.1668017805,
0.2359122038,
0.661468029,
-0.4565689564,
0.8777108192,
-0.3920430541,
-0.0396286696,
0.4001591206,
0.5790442228,
0.6538102031,
0.347355932,
-0.0253004562,
-0.1744247526,
0.1527429521,
-0.1695874035,
-0.1807417721,
0.8798807263,
-0.5414636731,
-0.8668850064,
-0.246723637,
-0.6086173654,
-0.0222531296,
0.4611325264,
0.1110399738,
0.3156346083,
-0.0391618125,
0.1873183399,
1.0059477091,
-0.279047668,
0.6309854984,
0.1728851348,
-0.1022264287,
-0.5437114835,
0.5810562968,
-0.2178874612,
0.1022673473,
0.1145668626,
0.0653869286,
-0.471213609,
-0.968547225,
-0.1868281215,
-0.0616584569,
-0.8053358793,
-0.6065788269,
-0.6302781701,
-0.1424235851,
-0.3900733888,
-0.3066414595,
-0.2626003623,
-0.4111626446,
0.057449352,
-0.7427558899,
0.7631584406,
0.4839814603,
-0.249174431,
-0.0793498307,
-1.1412805319,
0.363355577,
0.2257385701,
0.3918885291,
-0.1621392965,
0.0974469855,
-0.2393419594,
-0.076866731,
-0.040578451,
-1.041367054,
0.3913582563,
-0.1162904873,
0.5775969625,
0.4376061559,
0.836189568,
0.3471000791,
-0.4510117471,
0.4311518371,
0.2342390567,
-0.8198924661,
0.7704439163,
-0.2896994054,
-0.1902015507,
0.9740214944,
-0.0634187236,
-0.3146989346,
-0.5448306203,
-0.3073364794,
-1.1298764944,
0.4023375809,
0.0804156438,
0.4426765442,
-0.5873871446,
0.3168553114,
-0.0023997515,
0.1843628287,
-0.6267755628,
-0.1681459993,
-0.3723312914,
-0.231089294,
0.1246487349,
-0.5178586245,
-0.3899245858,
-0.0445548669,
0.1599551588,
0.1857032925,
0.1839685887,
-0.1738534868,
-0.2685418129,
0.2791814208,
0.6914037466,
0.3724464774,
-0.1494480073,
-0.4584518075,
0.3974782228,
-0.1096397415,
-0.8033263087,
0.3809521198,
0.1145542637,
-0.209990412,
-0.3288346529,
0.1010850072,
0.599619925,
0.1324576885,
-0.7839148045,
0.545660615,
-0.3904924095,
0.0312984847,
-0.0433293134,
0.5871860385,
0.0490565337,
0.0325918607,
0.2027967423,
0.1945450753,
0.0909880996,
-0.244087562,
0.2238779217,
0.4968756735,
-0.1769616455,
-0.0392067805,
0.8616754413,
0.4790497422,
-0.2543557584,
0.5969426036,
0.115257211,
-0.4305391014,
0.8232231736,
0.9029977322,
1.0627019405,
-0.1296448559,
-0.0869495645,
0.1912034899,
0.6104258299,
0.0068869209,
0.3272638321,
-0.22035034,
-0.7044545412,
-0.1168921888,
-0.3875731528,
-0.2508846223,
-0.2130710036,
-0.7849007845,
-0.0332529508,
-0.7724837065,
-0.3082261086,
-0.4845918119,
-0.3252896369,
-0.1571925133,
-0.0189544111,
0.1543062925,
1.3916407824,
-0.4867312014,
0.9409484863,
0.4111651778,
0.0701657683,
-0.7325034142,
-0.1179125682,
0.1067532003,
-0.344997108,
0.3951260448,
0.4985068142,
-0.4315238297,
0.0449246503,
-0.4421091378,
-0.5679483414,
0.9049048424,
0.3783065975,
-0.7120531201,
0.0983302221,
0.062954165,
0.0149477124,
-0.1785547435,
-0.2055458724,
0.6287546754,
0.1796068847,
-0.2890154719,
-0.5639995933,
0.342138797,
-0.2678633928,
0.0317034163,
0.3906162083,
-0.2235793769,
0.3242371976,
-0.7895299792,
-0.1453116983,
0.3579235971,
0.2330631167,
0.579076767,
0.3208139241,
0.4779215157,
0.6081702113,
0.4631597102,
-0.1925999969,
1.0691244602,
-0.5304903388,
0.1292357743,
0.756704092,
-0.1465205401,
0.7699344158,
0.4203940034,
0.2840360105,
0.2681691349,
0.4791640043,
0.2460622638,
1.2519516945,
0.2624370158,
-0.5871540308,
-0.2284914255,
0.2834822834,
-0.3301631808,
0.3178632259,
0.4916602373,
-0.2247650921,
-0.2587651014,
0.3770347238,
0.5276325941,
0.0823711455,
-0.3568997383,
0.8152994514,
0.0764734745,
-0.2327430844,
0.7201503515,
0.2910823226,
0.8628337383,
-0.5885084271,
0.4921785593,
-0.4195076525,
0.1996143609,
-0.2647885382,
-0.9359641671,
0.3648030162,
0.3638025224,
-0.0771878362,
-0.0918294191,
0.9335754514,
0.0680768713,
0.0821337625,
0.511952579,
-0.0489145406,
-0.0164466463,
0.2619544864,
-0.5343862772,
0.4185679555,
0.0143754007,
-0.1871653497,
0.5327464938,
-0.092558749,
-0.0921508223,
0.8014369011,
0.6561210155,
-0.1643407643,
0.1158790961,
0.0462172739,
0.8240244389,
-0.7169182897,
-0.644415617,
-1.0276689529,
0.4982408583,
0.0257841945,
0.3973852396,
0.7638481259,
0.3118676543,
0.5719095469,
-0.0373163447,
0.9331927299,
-0.1168850064,
0.1539535075,
-0.591971755,
1.1893799305,
0.2142178118,
0.6388341188,
-0.3908321261,
-0.4983999729,
-0.5366937518,
0.6111966968,
-0.2509766817,
-0.2845085859,
0.2112708539,
0.7695690989,
0.3204812109,
0.0628622249,
0.0704744458,
0.1108694449,
0.583588779,
0.5260202289,
0.7923308015,
-0.2236910164,
0.7003629208,
-0.3266268671,
-0.1582701951,
-0.1299981028,
-1.0981318951,
-0.9344949722,
0.1120076627,
0.023831971,
-0.5834264159,
0.4156673253,
0.7464600801,
0.5767354965,
-0.8569761515,
-0.1274086684,
-0.2598308325,
0.3065870702,
-0.0696102008,
-0.1778702736,
0.0227488708,
-0.1414532214,
-0.2962227464,
0.7436630726,
0.1562981308,
0.1693215966,
0.2331202477,
-0.1374613196,
0.2333891988,
0.1031130776,
0.5727878809,
0.4965873063,
-0.4841145575,
-0.3260376155,
-0.0424979031,
-0.4243001044,
-0.1381251961,
0.6352818608,
-0.7475696206,
0.4378703833,
0.3315021396,
0.7528066039,
0.1350619644,
0.0553936549,
0.3606351316,
-0.7010627985,
0.4168854952,
0.1251577586,
0.325643599,
0.3299083412,
-0.5207152963,
0.3073075414,
0.0092288395,
-0.4689252377,
-0.9587804079,
0.367223084,
-0.9424925447,
-0.3020165265,
0.8060899377,
-0.317550987,
-0.1311060935,
-0.310924232,
-0.3539116681,
-0.0576246046,
-0.5339002013,
0.8547647595,
0.2779482901,
0.0576671511,
-0.2451553047,
-0.4024159908,
0.4669804275,
0.0368089564,
-0.7820560336,
0.4905271232,
0.3684289753,
0.6642259955,
-0.1258164942,
0.4853495657,
-0.4595679939,
0.4388346076,
-0.2132996321,
-0.1811306179,
-0.4589804411,
-0.4449958801,
-0.1135448217,
0.3754509389,
0.4696108401,
-0.4137639105
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08971v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08971v2
|
Structured Language Generation Model for Robust Structure Prediction
| 2024-02-14T06:33:22 | 2024-02-19T00:06:41 |
Minho Lee, Junghyun Min, Woochul Lee, Yeonsoo Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Previous work in structured prediction (e.g. NER, information extraction)
using single model make use of explicit dataset information, which helps boost
in-distribution performance but is orthogonal to robust generalization in
real-world situations. To overcome this limitation, we propose the Structured
Language Generation Model (SLGM), a framework that reduces sequence-to-sequence
problems to classification problems via methodologies in loss calibration and
decoding method. Our experimental results show that SLGM is able to maintain
performance without explicit dataset information, follow and potentially
replace dataset-specific fine-tuning.
|
[
-0.0551375933,
-0.8770507574,
0.1320428401,
-0.0089687174,
-0.3138394356,
-0.0525808483,
-0.117670536,
-0.3234904408,
-0.3415465057,
0.5921311975,
-0.5264273882,
-0.4500914812,
-0.4336865246,
-0.1084934697,
-0.5067263246,
1.0750522614,
0.2551296353,
0.1254717857,
-0.0791752636,
0.1876530349,
-0.4716436863,
-0.4570530951,
-0.381899178,
-0.4198022485,
-0.0100143589,
0.1477695107,
0.8255630136,
1.2074496746,
0.2910246551,
0.2877557278,
-0.2610622346,
0.1200955957,
-0.4254548252,
0.2282992601,
0.1376955807,
-0.4157625139,
-0.5776589513,
-0.3477080762,
1.0099577904,
0.9694170952,
-0.4192845821,
0.1117198765,
0.3425289989,
0.4553242326,
-0.3877518773,
0.3311540484,
-0.8096417189,
0.2518600225,
-0.1580239534,
-0.4045507312,
-0.6232581735,
-0.3320835233,
-0.0240014028,
-0.2936389148,
0.6319676042,
0.121693559,
0.6359428763,
0.3846063018,
-0.111985445,
-0.1243215054,
-0.6979517937,
0.590906918,
-0.9802299738,
0.2287472337,
0.4752317965,
0.1991377771,
-0.4368285537,
-0.544906199,
-0.0429694615,
-0.1784721911,
-0.0657020137,
-0.134965539,
0.3110893667,
0.2628618181,
0.3365712464,
0.311768204,
-0.6814546585,
-0.0387979671,
-0.4058855474,
-0.2173096389,
0.7262638211,
0.1998581141,
0.1044587567,
-0.2477172315,
-0.296276927,
0.1053968519,
-0.8677178621,
-0.0051029283,
0.4994339645,
0.8022074103,
0.0374177396,
0.4720603824,
0.0228680242,
0.8426932096,
0.0996410176,
-0.429082036,
0.2659898102,
-0.3718043268,
-0.4050432146,
0.266692251,
0.4091851711,
-0.1450207978,
0.3073809743,
-0.1096136495,
-0.3742692173,
0.0933147445,
0.0877218321,
-0.9431337714,
-0.375323981,
-0.0421801396,
-0.5712365508,
-0.6155990362,
0.1024212316,
-0.6440430284,
-0.0853035599,
-0.0305925403,
-0.0028043503,
-0.2325710207,
-0.1756939143,
0.0516207553,
-0.0588492304,
-0.0329309516,
-0.0060678874,
-0.7734002471,
0.3238230646,
0.4320443273,
0.7582089901,
-0.1218761429,
-0.0003447842,
-0.6491265893,
0.4630891085,
-0.2682928443,
0.6797943115,
-0.42988801,
-0.3676888347,
0.0398097858,
-0.2306916118,
-0.0169741176,
-0.4362327456,
0.4918837249,
-0.0663996637,
0.1751585156,
0.3318396509,
-0.6128343344,
0.1055668816,
0.2285729349,
-0.6845488548,
1.0207656622,
0.2102239281,
-0.9326904416,
0.5464456677,
-0.3272901475,
-0.624517858,
0.5578781962,
-0.293458581,
-0.632776022,
0.215802148,
0.1133704633,
0.3712946177,
-0.0741487443,
0.7916790247,
-0.478174001,
-0.3878300786,
-0.14007774,
-0.299403131,
0.2204704732,
0.3840251565,
-0.1864529997,
0.0455448851,
-1.279818058,
0.4602333307,
0.1141411141,
-0.6986243725,
-0.3199347556,
0.6391804218,
0.0862667412,
0.2166971713,
0.0854295939,
-0.2561652958,
0.2289027572,
-0.8035010695,
0.5039924383,
0.7527995706,
-0.0625732765,
0.6421667933,
-0.134294495,
0.647305727,
0.0178304818,
-0.0289895926,
-0.3405774534,
-0.3995439112,
-0.3695548475,
-0.0601688214,
0.3020067215,
0.541999042,
-0.4977270365,
0.4078240097,
-0.1504548639,
-0.1094812453,
-0.2333912998,
0.2225562334,
0.5633026361,
0.9028477669,
0.0524041839,
-0.0392566174,
-0.8747041821,
-0.7305030823,
-0.0585679226,
-0.186320886,
-0.0306985769,
0.0486924686,
0.0317570493,
-0.2884858251,
0.853158772,
-0.6043993831,
0.0528021231,
-0.5241138339,
0.0377446339,
0.3225055635,
0.5448484421,
0.1781235784,
-0.9647759795,
-0.1524962783,
-0.0739123672,
-0.6775632501,
-0.1941335499,
0.1740703434,
0.1571858376,
0.0914310887,
0.4182722867,
-0.0418763757,
0.5588795543,
0.6392667294,
-0.212723583,
0.5421835184,
-0.151341334,
-0.5536313057,
-1.3135919571,
0.1817152947,
0.0264613032,
-0.3100158572,
-0.8724184632,
-0.0455225259,
-0.0010603102,
-0.3475837409,
-0.2253315449,
0.4182491004,
-0.3884126544,
-0.2241739333,
-0.1995945573,
-0.1722726375,
0.0328315273,
0.4354436398,
0.1016899124,
0.7599804997,
0.5837408304,
-0.7913612127,
-0.1887485683,
0.4186651409,
-0.4423718154,
0.164026618,
-0.8218789101,
-0.0267972108,
-0.4158822596,
0.1051850319,
-0.7156513929,
-0.3607751131,
0.0539209284,
-0.3191995919,
0.5939468741,
-0.2749524117,
-0.3167912066,
-0.2666118741,
-0.1599352807,
0.2883341014,
0.2250258923,
-0.1521763951,
0.1250047684,
0.3316043615,
-0.3255495727,
-0.5867592692,
-0.7788350582,
-0.2140485495,
-0.2640274763,
-0.7432214618,
0.2670049369,
-0.3004732132,
-0.009264485,
-0.2036127597,
-0.0576318763,
-0.1906821132,
0.2397361547,
0.4350578487,
0.2706057727,
-0.2633892894,
0.4347117245,
-0.0055716746,
-0.0037066373,
-0.1387078613,
-0.2261255383,
0.5175421238,
-0.2304120809,
-0.0697866902,
0.1034335643,
0.428050071,
0.0860791579,
-0.1513910145,
0.641475141,
0.2677539289,
-0.5097349882,
-0.6833896637,
-0.0774790272,
0.0048266831,
-0.5156186223,
0.5665099621,
-0.4180825949,
-0.7067881227,
0.5129386187,
-0.1676268578,
-0.1621197909,
0.2254917622,
0.3085691929,
0.0154274199,
1.5125888586,
0.8930659294,
0.0467006601,
0.6007021666,
-0.2016542256,
0.2254469842,
-0.5145766139,
-0.3667239249,
-0.6082961559,
-0.1195596009,
-0.5018565059,
0.1088635847,
0.2677089274,
0.4873013794,
-0.3282067478,
0.4400680959,
-0.6366086602,
0.1704859287,
0.2523864806,
-0.0746370852,
0.2883597314,
0.1583469212,
-0.2069555223,
0.0612681583,
-0.9691423178,
-0.6177779436,
0.8446130157,
0.3740322888,
1.0469738245,
-0.2271533459,
0.572096765,
0.2705304325,
0.1785894632,
-0.6395533681,
0.4571366012,
-0.0033186427,
-0.2219342589,
-0.2570202053,
-0.8185918331,
-0.8337571025,
-0.1049369499,
-0.1664977372,
-0.5199401975,
0.2344844341,
0.3317591846,
-0.038928695,
0.1184482723,
-0.4435322881,
0.5698432326,
-0.0569664016,
-0.0123233581,
0.4399326742,
-0.6767157316,
0.4123582244,
-0.2356783003,
0.4212352931,
-0.0520729125,
0.2263410389,
0.4211635292,
-0.5033825636,
0.6206858754,
-0.2504166961,
-0.033008974,
0.1722979695,
0.0993558168,
0.6939455867,
0.1146017611,
-0.5060034394,
-0.0823180154,
-0.1256321669,
-0.2437861562,
-0.5114966035,
0.4272511005,
-0.4574302435,
-0.2344167233,
-0.0633661076,
-0.8135395646,
-0.2563104331,
0.2242717296,
0.7386024594,
0.7983886003,
-0.2016759962,
0.1984208524,
0.6026368141,
0.0527717359,
0.5252586603,
0.0006967655,
-0.0026119594,
-0.5538854599,
0.5650047064,
0.0824431255,
0.3225665092,
0.3627689481,
0.348102659,
-0.3376241922,
-0.88106215,
-0.436096251,
-0.1025330946,
-0.5591296554,
-0.5952935815,
-0.2779627144,
-0.4872736037,
-0.5245747566,
-0.0989430323,
-0.1200076416,
-0.4161532819,
-0.2365659624,
-0.375851512,
-0.1491747946,
0.8766934276,
0.231096223,
0.4592034221,
-0.7926043868,
-0.0144817,
-0.1602055281,
0.5967514515,
-0.278570056,
-0.4663226902,
-0.3645345569,
0.1335086226,
-0.2691882849,
-0.8518908024,
0.7289485931,
0.8445571065,
0.6138608456,
0.5820096731,
-0.0268380865,
0.8520101309,
-0.5378777981,
0.4140670598,
0.0875659212,
-0.7891038656,
0.9239022732,
-0.4783551991,
0.3463296294,
0.3843344748,
-0.1473820657,
-0.0305301603,
-0.3427901864,
-0.4358666241,
-0.7512872219,
0.7282428145,
0.1213019267,
-0.003750945,
-0.0248645339,
0.4772011936,
0.1249725968,
0.4941450059,
-0.9004784226,
-0.1306289732,
-0.3232871294,
-0.2345532477,
-0.1285424978,
-0.2398520261,
0.1473134607,
-0.0565800779,
0.4855740666,
-0.4450595081,
0.111761041,
0.1202046871,
-0.080484353,
-0.5212757587,
0.3332814276,
0.5490037203,
0.7063245177,
-0.3709601164,
0.0489419773,
-0.0202215388,
-0.4146885872,
0.1097947657,
0.0606984422,
-0.6258167624,
-0.0045560771,
0.394870162,
0.9197515845,
0.3493344188,
-0.6647724509,
0.3593043089,
0.2101574391,
-0.1878408045,
-0.1428157091,
0.0902443081,
-0.3505786359,
0.0559232906,
0.4858402014,
0.1893588305,
0.2843383253,
-0.5191234946,
0.4444457889,
0.3515172601,
-0.241720736,
-0.4043530524,
0.7062466741,
-0.1110658348,
-0.3587903976,
0.5680707097,
-0.1295196861,
-0.494464308,
0.5443102717,
1.0643131733,
0.7246849537,
-0.383282721,
0.2585766315,
0.4188255072,
0.1445974708,
-0.4770123363,
0.3045012057,
-0.0746970773,
-0.627980113,
-0.5085926652,
-0.9847471714,
-0.0742050484,
0.0597095937,
-0.6588776112,
0.2801228762,
-0.6029064655,
-0.0840583816,
-0.3305001855,
0.0136856241,
-0.412778616,
0.2296599895,
0.2607183754,
0.9621173143,
-0.7392892838,
1.1053317785,
0.5226986408,
-0.0828750879,
-0.8962675929,
-0.2736819386,
-0.293702662,
-0.4780914485,
0.4741487205,
0.3076788187,
0.0452688299,
-0.1473688632,
-0.7996528745,
-0.9853478074,
1.0695710182,
0.6301449537,
-0.4410555363,
-0.519572854,
0.1527430862,
0.5302094817,
-0.6188541055,
-0.3457357883,
0.1975418627,
0.3490411937,
0.3976151049,
-0.7147844434,
-0.0874710679,
-0.4838446081,
0.4857260883,
0.5141583681,
-0.0524068065,
0.9235694408,
-0.222571969,
-0.4895274639,
0.2436773926,
0.5576594472,
0.3114873171,
0.3658291698,
0.2456472218,
0.4163167477,
0.7596299052,
-0.046159517,
0.9200279713,
-0.2740081251,
0.4205806255,
1.2084790468,
-0.1963669062,
0.8525753617,
0.1012632027,
0.1220262051,
0.4385870993,
0.4781731367,
-0.0777970403,
0.7924899459,
0.2438836694,
-0.0204024576,
-0.1962350458,
0.1018027067,
-0.5186954141,
0.5379353166,
0.5040280819,
-0.5080553889,
-0.235995397,
-0.1652899534,
-0.2349481136,
0.1717557311,
-0.4968091547,
0.6676076055,
-0.0980753899,
-0.6400659084,
0.5454348922,
0.0919657052,
0.6228616238,
-0.7695470452,
-0.1592066586,
-0.1761631966,
0.2973827422,
-0.3386285305,
-0.4235305786,
0.614925921,
-0.3379443288,
-0.3396558762,
-0.2924814522,
1.2107002735,
-0.6519887447,
-0.6291661263,
0.0700283945,
0.2928964496,
0.0273178574,
0.117250964,
-0.6098677516,
-0.1415813863,
-0.1143450812,
-0.1491554081,
0.4158969223,
0.1751351953,
-0.17516312,
0.7290852666,
0.6399548054,
0.2506644428,
0.2553386688,
-0.1808313578,
0.7679418921,
-0.5331879854,
-0.5962697268,
-0.6817529798,
0.265252322,
0.0668613613,
-0.1108732149,
0.6026312113,
0.5583132505,
0.691406548,
-0.0000510589,
0.8196273446,
0.0871390328,
0.4287504256,
-0.2871508598,
0.5918545127,
-0.2480118126,
0.2557822764,
-0.4784275591,
-0.9950760603,
-0.4203757942,
0.5770427585,
0.1541806608,
-0.0327508897,
0.2461425811,
0.7865492702,
0.0768440142,
-0.0161606185,
0.5361120701,
0.1751152724,
0.2073609978,
0.5121202469,
0.5274178386,
-0.4599424899,
0.6081201434,
-0.0652587861,
-0.0230152588,
-0.1375852674,
-1.032530427,
-0.715058744,
-0.599267602,
-0.1156205535,
-0.3230812252,
-0.000107707,
0.6216562986,
0.855391264,
-0.7567157149,
-0.1285858601,
-0.4309948981,
0.0337619781,
-0.093138501,
-0.1988031864,
0.2168099284,
-0.3203189075,
-0.5218510628,
0.7667122483,
0.3430243134,
0.1408737898,
-0.2058363706,
-0.3418641984,
0.0505132452,
-0.0061499127,
0.5113076568,
0.3112457693,
-0.420830369,
-0.215937227,
-0.1544837952,
-0.105930984,
0.1499327123,
0.7143615484,
-0.8220030665,
0.3095426559,
0.5612409711,
0.3736736476,
0.2753807306,
0.3527323008,
0.8443709016,
-1.3060544729,
0.2837412953,
0.3065582812,
0.4892894924,
0.2928135991,
-0.5686929226,
0.5936153531,
0.1453919411,
-0.5415914655,
-1.0828773975,
0.3812103868,
-0.7590741515,
-0.062133614,
1.1346875429,
-0.1568748951,
-0.1995864064,
-0.2055940479,
-0.0096221697,
0.3134782016,
-0.285110265,
0.3645181954,
0.3801926374,
0.0966047794,
-0.1385740936,
-0.3209066093,
0.5830106139,
0.0794010311,
-0.7926815152,
-0.049201373,
0.5832008123,
0.3253195882,
0.0654840767,
0.41965729,
-0.1087700054,
-0.0234028585,
-0.1199957579,
-0.0997043997,
-0.3828617632,
-0.5773760676,
-0.4565420151,
0.6110165715,
0.1291175336,
0.0276892465
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10965v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10965v2
|
Generalization in Healthcare AI: Evaluation of a Clinical Large Language Model
| 2024-02-14T06:24:52 | 2024-02-24T13:17:38 |
Salman Rahman, Lavender Yao Jiang, Saadia Gabriel, Yindalon Aphinyanaphongs, Eric Karl Oermann, Rumi Chunara
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Advances in large language models (LLMs) provide new opportunities in
healthcare for improved patient care, clinical decision-making, and enhancement
of physician and administrator workflows. However, the potential of these
models importantly depends on their ability to generalize effectively across
clinical environments and populations, a challenge often underestimated in
early development. To better understand reasons for these challenges and inform
mitigation approaches, we evaluated ClinicLLM, an LLM trained on [HOSPITAL]'s
clinical notes, analyzing its performance on 30-day all-cause readmission
prediction focusing on variability across hospitals and patient
characteristics. We found poorer generalization particularly in hospitals with
fewer samples, among patients with government and unspecified insurance, the
elderly, and those with high comorbidities. To understand reasons for lack of
generalization, we investigated sample sizes for fine-tuning, note content
(number of words per note), patient characteristics (comorbidity level, age,
insurance type, borough), and health system aspects (hospital, all-cause 30-day
readmission, and mortality rates). We used descriptive statistics and
supervised classification to identify features. We found that, along with
sample size, patient age, number of comorbidities, and the number of words in
notes are all important factors related to generalization. Finally, we compared
local fine-tuning (hospital specific), instance-based augmented fine-tuning and
cluster-based fine-tuning for improving generalization. Among these, local
fine-tuning proved most effective, increasing AUC by 0.25% to 11.74% (most
helpful in settings with limited data). Overall, this study provides new
insights for enhancing the deployment of large language models in the
societally important domain of healthcare, and improving their performance for
broader populations.
|
[
0.0807789415,
-0.7991651893,
0.8928903937,
0.1368002445,
-0.1532139331,
-0.1962711662,
-0.414311558,
-0.5050640702,
0.0512935184,
0.6493498683,
-0.1148488,
-0.9258078337,
-0.7355668545,
0.0787222981,
-0.2739390135,
1.1077678204,
-0.1492542624,
0.2039186209,
-0.1537512094,
-0.1231975108,
-0.3201093972,
-0.7038461566,
-0.8979543447,
-0.5472754836,
0.4324393272,
0.3822511435,
0.5967380404,
0.5015994906,
0.9435730577,
0.3287023902,
-0.0877198502,
0.0058698831,
-0.3715509772,
-0.162941739,
0.1350285113,
-0.5001122355,
-0.668821454,
-0.3538834155,
0.7940301895,
1.0974086523,
-0.3547655046,
0.0736088604,
-0.1763125956,
0.8280668855,
-0.4764237702,
0.0660335347,
-0.3604187071,
0.2399736494,
-0.0410002209,
0.0601405054,
-0.1807552725,
-0.4013086557,
0.4456038177,
-0.5252276659,
0.6211134791,
0.0463179089,
0.5928165913,
0.0739296153,
-0.5658820271,
-0.403295666,
-0.9047057033,
0.7608132362,
-0.8439772129,
0.2647689283,
0.3757884502,
0.3537689149,
-0.0584808439,
-0.67386204,
-0.1018485501,
-0.5167187452,
-0.1487892717,
0.2537552714,
-0.315505147,
0.4109125137,
0.3050410151,
0.6038933396,
-0.7316963673,
0.4175158441,
-0.4619735777,
-0.1618446857,
0.6540133357,
0.5484841466,
0.3410367668,
0.1699195653,
-0.0695682541,
0.1043502614,
-0.5200704336,
-0.0286399722,
-0.1467098594,
0.120220378,
-0.4129486382,
0.4640018046,
-0.3081378043,
0.4546313584,
-0.2606778443,
-0.105969362,
0.3125678897,
-0.344189167,
-0.4428124428,
0.0388961919,
0.7262157798,
0.4700501263,
0.3072628677,
-0.4026566446,
-0.1132619753,
0.18385984,
0.3024163544,
-0.6445905566,
-0.1822112948,
0.4533260763,
-0.7594565153,
-0.2737086415,
-0.1331364512,
-0.5775697827,
-0.4363273382,
-0.4106170833,
-0.2328398824,
-0.3454695642,
-0.0522920899,
0.1263112426,
0.0921202451,
0.1343036592,
0.6192784905,
-0.8854783773,
0.4351642728,
0.648272872,
0.7956194282,
-0.3696532249,
-0.06126412,
-0.4642233849,
0.1794551909,
-0.4979967177,
0.6286843419,
-0.3906061649,
-0.66681391,
0.4436808527,
-0.0861677527,
-0.2799645066,
-1.0424394608,
0.7065253258,
-0.0258855801,
-0.0841908678,
0.2162219286,
-0.4847385585,
0.2356427014,
0.1692118794,
-0.6041730642,
0.0388167575,
0.3843843043,
-0.3604602516,
0.5064300299,
-0.7268802524,
-0.5950012803,
0.1356370598,
-0.1594871581,
-0.6974326372,
0.670769453,
0.3991480172,
0.4663477242,
-0.3044113219,
0.3662689924,
-0.1731944978,
-0.4929352105,
0.1013431028,
-0.2442271113,
0.2261565179,
0.4383476377,
0.0924863219,
0.2537123561,
-0.677390337,
-0.1207338199,
-0.0044116923,
-0.528640449,
-0.3236200809,
-0.0697651356,
0.2412004322,
-0.2163075656,
0.1288850456,
-0.2684885263,
0.2870841622,
-0.5789225101,
0.3834399283,
0.3457307816,
0.1871299595,
0.4754829407,
-0.5941761732,
0.6846178174,
0.1931766868,
0.4501302838,
-0.1293305308,
-0.4092545807,
-0.475379765,
-0.4023019671,
0.2159135491,
0.4660873115,
-0.1295479238,
0.0990684554,
-0.2472403347,
-0.2419843078,
-0.6895366311,
0.0579297207,
0.3591700792,
0.3605799079,
0.2926489115,
-0.2509374619,
-0.4126909077,
-1.0463112593,
-0.0765831396,
-0.1146244779,
-0.1425539702,
0.4432366192,
0.3302082419,
-0.9134140015,
0.4449831545,
-0.4705144167,
-0.6479330063,
-0.4371167719,
0.0281545445,
0.4401203692,
0.4131927192,
0.2515559196,
-0.50704813,
-0.3765451908,
0.4065780938,
-0.6473698616,
-0.1165990084,
-0.077477403,
0.4419154227,
0.1708699167,
0.4043130577,
-0.4876449406,
0.6012428403,
0.5187243223,
0.003226713,
0.3975111544,
-0.7093306184,
0.0218267608,
-0.8941101432,
0.1919581592,
0.1349569708,
-0.0091165304,
-0.8436838388,
-0.004107614,
-0.0345014818,
-0.2777849436,
0.0237702318,
0.342731595,
-0.4122768044,
0.1887240708,
-0.0248612016,
-0.0329074487,
-0.123401843,
-0.0257105157,
-0.0721433833,
0.4767512381,
0.3788062334,
-0.4694390893,
0.2040052414,
0.0297699422,
-0.382463485,
0.3492289484,
-0.8453986645,
-0.0044763158,
-0.2360225916,
0.1942910999,
-0.8146110177,
-0.3457082808,
-0.1306661367,
-0.2051629871,
0.3075999618,
0.0154216094,
-0.3435936272,
-0.4436219633,
0.0316928551,
0.361735642,
0.4433293045,
0.0617350265,
0.4557266533,
0.1630395204,
-0.1835502684,
-0.1230082884,
-0.702131927,
0.1275689155,
-0.2635212243,
-0.3927983046,
0.2150229961,
-0.0420331582,
-0.5744777918,
-0.2408529967,
0.0254066736,
-0.1324649006,
0.1932701617,
0.2435317039,
0.1521480829,
-0.2868892252,
0.3303207159,
0.2027631849,
-0.009398804,
0.1416544616,
-0.1354860067,
0.4989746511,
-0.2648612261,
-0.424590975,
-0.6277338266,
0.6031211615,
0.6015052795,
-0.0763820261,
0.6079461575,
0.4417634308,
-0.480845958,
-0.0102262245,
-0.703970015,
-0.0180073492,
-0.3345016539,
0.6936431527,
-0.0565267876,
-1.020717144,
0.6335033774,
-0.3465058506,
0.1726786792,
0.5009421706,
0.6136395931,
-0.0600029342,
1.0037542582,
0.5111303926,
-0.3412259817,
0.1349286586,
-0.4123165607,
0.1407296211,
-0.8767054677,
-0.209928602,
-0.6100543737,
-0.0028222764,
-0.9492180943,
-0.388654083,
0.5139023066,
-0.0081555722,
-0.092400603,
-0.3508501947,
-0.3951279819,
0.0915248618,
0.1065429449,
0.1956914663,
0.4823039174,
-0.0700909793,
-0.1780233234,
0.2027783394,
-0.5578320026,
-0.4012886882,
1.3076497316,
0.7221264839,
0.7765468955,
0.2191557139,
1.0514262915,
0.573387742,
0.5335945487,
-0.7492920756,
0.1761698723,
-0.6411447525,
-0.2723708451,
-0.3705562651,
-0.5756860375,
-1.3002208471,
0.0779168829,
-0.1827446669,
-0.7108494639,
0.0419766605,
0.2428130358,
-0.4772973359,
-0.0410661325,
-0.9217277169,
0.7398725152,
-0.1237790734,
0.1853045672,
-0.343686074,
-0.4571041167,
0.2511327267,
-0.3083030879,
0.5538910031,
0.132359758,
-0.0420872979,
0.3805665672,
-0.3445430398,
0.8220837116,
0.0828142539,
-0.1864891797,
-0.1481033266,
-0.3133521378,
0.3348711431,
0.1175431013,
0.0358117595,
0.3434094489,
0.0568801425,
-0.3569022417,
-0.6533103585,
0.7162063122,
-1.0350195169,
-0.7027375102,
-0.2117890269,
-0.4662473202,
-0.4582405984,
0.0190307163,
0.2392287403,
0.6609880328,
-0.5482368469,
0.1060012877,
0.6201831102,
-0.3827823102,
-0.0517201722,
0.5332403183,
-0.3254791796,
-0.5118297338,
0.573058784,
-0.1719560623,
0.3422461748,
0.6158547401,
0.6126987338,
-0.1068140864,
-1.0490435362,
-0.3229972124,
0.3541900814,
-0.515889585,
0.290884465,
-0.5952551961,
-0.4131430387,
-0.6332530975,
-0.1767058969,
0.1709313691,
-0.2006135732,
-0.419058919,
0.1036073416,
-0.0612873174,
0.980240643,
0.3381937146,
0.5470021367,
-0.7643954158,
0.2642157674,
0.0652055517,
0.2476091236,
0.0985038579,
-0.5478506088,
-0.575609982,
-0.1634072065,
-0.2053512335,
-0.6846964359,
0.2356319726,
0.2415692806,
0.806607604,
0.7144449949,
-0.2815411091,
0.5450969338,
-0.6337329149,
0.5170676112,
0.3645221591,
-0.561223805,
0.6673337817,
-0.32438308,
0.5649852157,
0.5848865509,
0.1288873255,
-0.6502432823,
-0.40270859,
-0.4448841214,
-0.9367767572,
0.2883285582,
0.0071119363,
0.171124965,
0.0700237527,
0.5098568201,
-0.0840755552,
0.1589984745,
-0.2971106768,
-0.2248304039,
0.1850380599,
-0.3805242777,
-0.4936215878,
-0.2882508039,
-0.274082154,
-0.2003937513,
0.1594793946,
-0.1289157718,
0.21300219,
0.4599298239,
-0.0005016094,
-0.3160123527,
0.6280039549,
0.8974207044,
0.9425927401,
-0.1948511153,
-0.0921045765,
0.2719794214,
-0.7523508072,
-0.1413991153,
0.2913794518,
-0.0524252951,
0.0425200164,
0.768350482,
0.9571157694,
0.0595631972,
-0.6051308513,
0.3145603538,
-0.1531909555,
-0.1748185754,
-0.3084401488,
0.132372126,
-0.0761864558,
0.1486914605,
0.1340333223,
-0.1731908619,
0.442245394,
-0.5704033971,
-0.0146043468,
0.418335408,
-0.4544353187,
-0.1192624569,
0.4568708241,
0.0801487043,
-0.3080804646,
0.6077994108,
0.4943779111,
-0.080236882,
0.8194260597,
0.6166548133,
0.9330144525,
-0.32151407,
0.1904540062,
0.197974354,
0.3396550119,
0.0246763732,
-0.1078320742,
0.0528840274,
-0.5052210689,
-0.4026856124,
-0.5923514366,
-0.6753939986,
0.2301616818,
-0.7179154158,
0.0614442155,
-0.5678373575,
-0.3838897943,
-0.0949537531,
0.0523420162,
-0.8070731163,
0.3500355482,
0.1969014853,
0.8182051182,
-0.6725859046,
0.6756984591,
1.0189272165,
-0.1399490833,
-0.7183920145,
0.1764827073,
-0.2240309864,
-0.8709360361,
0.3290046453,
0.1548186541,
0.4036828578,
-0.2693728507,
-0.2063848376,
-0.5069149137,
0.9953874946,
-0.0819174871,
-1.0041898489,
-0.196999982,
0.5156584978,
1.0721302032,
-0.627938211,
0.239986062,
0.6460270286,
0.1691622734,
-0.0426542573,
-1.1748614311,
-0.1088887751,
-0.1077313349,
0.298516959,
0.1958354264,
-0.5970469713,
0.645034492,
-0.5115078092,
0.2319988012,
0.057346262,
0.3206714094,
0.2263055146,
0.786231041,
0.3006024063,
0.7365429401,
0.8644730449,
0.007878758,
1.1319271326,
0.0174864121,
0.2923743427,
0.9044607878,
-0.4501017332,
0.5248426199,
0.3653327823,
-0.3796750009,
0.4575704336,
0.3118522763,
0.0564764924,
0.4960037768,
0.5472211838,
-0.4390534163,
-0.0939714536,
-0.0570222363,
-0.4749341905,
0.2688193023,
0.4867072105,
-0.7514160275,
-0.1373993903,
0.1357060671,
-0.0313172229,
0.0513724387,
-0.5495457053,
1.0725086927,
0.3956885934,
-0.6199432611,
0.6245731711,
-0.0734827146,
0.2009297609,
-0.7636625171,
0.0047683986,
-0.3820410669,
0.4658087492,
-0.2919295728,
-0.3171626627,
0.2412940711,
-0.0275583901,
-0.4057272971,
0.0421654284,
0.4884026051,
-0.2890149653,
-0.6236944795,
0.1549887955,
0.3970926404,
0.2454784214,
0.0976506472,
-0.5780516267,
0.1457976997,
-0.1114350483,
0.079120785,
0.5329403281,
0.4829766154,
-0.3337792158,
0.6345145106,
0.6604951024,
0.6938712597,
-0.2843850851,
0.6403262019,
0.7313181162,
-0.493989259,
-0.2673857212,
-0.8731843233,
0.2275501341,
0.0327539369,
-0.3523977399,
0.3634703457,
0.5543037057,
0.3500671387,
-0.0860328749,
0.9007392526,
0.4078810513,
0.5147303343,
-0.5264363289,
0.6639324427,
-0.6765948534,
0.2924855053,
-0.2304910123,
-0.5279958844,
-0.5419669747,
0.3717814684,
-0.5851928592,
0.0925796628,
0.5057072043,
0.3698514402,
0.2438676506,
-0.1208722591,
0.6618285179,
0.3195420504,
0.5704641938,
0.6429373622,
0.5858048797,
-0.1534416229,
0.1886130869,
-0.1444961727,
-0.4309214056,
-0.3775874674,
-0.5614739656,
-0.8894116879,
-0.1716549993,
-0.3175376654,
-0.2068502605,
0.3151814938,
0.7633646131,
0.4855335355,
-1.1087079048,
-0.2858862281,
0.0443589501,
-0.0557781756,
-0.1545249671,
-0.1626648307,
0.470056504,
-0.3338879049,
-0.4184997976,
0.001502656,
0.3873384297,
0.0584689863,
-0.1423811466,
0.0205954742,
0.2753540874,
-0.1421163082,
0.5518496037,
-0.0117495507,
-0.7969142795,
0.1138238832,
-0.0084522255,
-0.3260648549,
0.0466774628,
0.9690115452,
-0.222230047,
0.507650435,
0.054911159,
0.4657031596,
0.2993838489,
0.1420251131,
0.422839731,
-0.1718058139,
-0.093264617,
0.3913001418,
0.5768918991,
0.2023194283,
-0.5127230287,
0.3064796925,
0.2167391032,
-0.8371822238,
-0.5462405682,
-0.0086231017,
-0.855019927,
-0.0179484356,
1.1685461998,
-0.1968647689,
0.0145282308,
-0.3628814518,
-0.2855692506,
0.1007399559,
-0.4106642604,
0.8778820038,
0.503123641,
-0.3032264113,
-0.0642528757,
-0.8187488317,
0.3926494718,
0.3438695669,
-0.9438003302,
-0.009759957,
0.6311368346,
0.3379766345,
0.0827418789,
1.0252739191,
-0.1569642574,
0.3672531545,
-0.5905596614,
-0.0330571495,
0.2798331976,
-0.0635902956,
-0.6139684319,
0.0509159528,
0.1489616334,
0.0305762328
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08966v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08966v2
|
Pretraining Vision-Language Model for Difference Visual Question Answering in Longitudinal Chest X-rays
| 2024-02-14T06:20:48 | 2024-06-17T12:57:55 |
Yeongjae Cho, Taehee Kim, Heejun Shin, Sungzoon Cho, Dongmyung Shin
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Difference visual question answering (diff-VQA) is a challenging task that
requires answering complex questions based on differences between a pair of
images. This task is particularly important in reading chest X-ray images
because radiologists often compare multiple images of the same patient taken at
different times to track disease progression and changes in its severity in
their clinical practice. However, previous works focused on designing specific
network architectures for the diff-VQA task, missing opportunities to enhance
the model's performance using a pretrained vision-language model (VLM). Here,
we introduce a novel VLM called PLURAL, which is pretrained on natural and
longitudinal chest X-ray data for the diff-VQA task. The model is developed
using a step-by-step approach, starting with being pretrained on natural images
and texts, followed by being trained using longitudinal chest X-ray data. The
longitudinal data consist of pairs of X-ray images, along with question-answer
sets and radiologist's reports that describe the changes in lung abnormalities
and diseases over time. Our experimental results show that the PLURAL model
outperforms state-of-the-art methods not only in diff-VQA for longitudinal
X-rays but also in conventional VQA for a single X-ray image. Through extensive
experiments, we demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed VLM architecture
and pretraining method in improving the model's performance.
|
[
-0.4430786967,
-0.5576429963,
0.5352319479,
-0.0433339179,
-0.8048800826,
-0.0415362902,
0.4159966707,
-0.3042446077,
0.0864514038,
0.5577096343,
-0.936375916,
-0.4715597928,
-0.7630856037,
0.1062133834,
-0.5214571357,
0.6101967096,
-0.1504552066,
0.2568423152,
-0.2164362967,
-0.2305491567,
-0.5901269317,
-0.427970022,
-0.3919419348,
-0.1096969172,
0.4376617372,
-0.1843883991,
0.6397884488,
0.2267372906,
0.6743097901,
0.3174168766,
-0.1604863405,
0.1326923668,
-0.3753381371,
-0.1609169394,
0.1606734544,
-0.4924894571,
-0.2680177987,
-0.3185897171,
0.6969342232,
0.52810812,
-0.191375047,
0.0908582062,
-0.3459630013,
0.9624755979,
-0.4508373439,
-0.0782380328,
-0.5312941074,
0.2720933855,
-0.2222511321,
-0.2726552784,
-0.1923449039,
-0.1490116417,
0.494620651,
-0.6702008843,
0.1332874894,
-0.1947425604,
1.0254753828,
0.3928914964,
-0.6533942819,
0.0119481403,
-0.4463534951,
0.3915216625,
-0.566601634,
0.73993361,
0.1676661521,
0.4821053743,
0.3572669029,
-1.132144928,
-0.5529350042,
-0.2052602768,
-0.2173888534,
0.3857293129,
-0.3965730667,
-0.0392720923,
0.0246109013,
0.2783464789,
-1.0457344055,
-0.0226808544,
-0.7256659269,
0.053688366,
0.4836726189,
0.2783746421,
0.2970555425,
-0.20773305,
-0.6777687073,
-0.0915228575,
-0.5391882658,
-0.0575878918,
-0.1851632595,
-0.1552635282,
-0.0652743503,
0.3514293134,
-0.4862819612,
0.9525735378,
0.0097858617,
-0.0845208913,
0.6969229579,
-0.2313937098,
-0.6202772856,
-0.0547939278,
0.2680220902,
0.3258680105,
-0.1447824389,
0.1653406024,
-0.0478666462,
0.237549454,
0.3539094329,
-0.6083201766,
-0.2477597594,
-0.0154257156,
-0.697052002,
-0.3741336465,
0.0249004401,
-0.379200846,
-0.0768493116,
-0.5181794167,
0.8025414348,
-0.2436217219,
-0.1602119654,
0.5557838082,
-0.2147890776,
0.1285413951,
0.454691112,
-0.2051028609,
0.408914566,
0.1937362701,
0.8167341948,
0.0767750368,
-0.2749165297,
-0.7648150325,
-0.36769256,
-0.2339092195,
0.7304033637,
-0.3602609634,
-0.480533421,
-0.2353710979,
-0.0415196009,
-0.3155992329,
-0.7301691175,
0.1326491535,
-0.8803485632,
0.5235046744,
-0.3273438513,
-0.3583960533,
-0.2626858354,
0.4752248824,
-0.7796189785,
0.9034338593,
0.1751638353,
-0.8070560098,
0.3441843987,
-0.4076042771,
-0.1771018356,
0.2661960423,
-0.6241893172,
-0.5667273998,
0.2089057416,
0.4570395947,
0.2424779981,
-0.135036096,
0.0542359613,
-0.0274839271,
-0.233419165,
0.3730740845,
-0.5025583506,
0.8190606833,
-0.1086409763,
-0.4475106001,
-0.0160065554,
-0.8501480222,
0.1707152724,
0.1011496112,
-0.0217857696,
-0.3693953156,
0.0246938318,
-0.3389062583,
0.4348301888,
0.0534146428,
-0.4504543245,
0.2632831037,
-0.122811079,
0.1003747433,
0.6260143518,
0.0857954919,
-0.1772216111,
-0.6027440429,
0.5189244151,
0.415579766,
0.7439344525,
0.0247052182,
-0.6094722152,
-0.6093238592,
-0.3124621511,
-0.0907523856,
0.6124754548,
-1.0425598621,
-0.2582227886,
-0.0295227133,
-0.5211757421,
-0.53630656,
0.1039515808,
0.7434385419,
0.8379489183,
0.7005956769,
-0.7228828669,
-0.6624961495,
-0.778613925,
0.2139700651,
-0.3690724075,
0.3023059368,
0.2445093095,
0.3731698096,
-0.4365232289,
0.4031368494,
-1.0541206598,
-0.2859328091,
-0.0264646802,
0.2176674306,
0.1291331202,
0.0481143892,
0.4837987721,
-1.406170249,
-0.4571497142,
-0.0741048381,
-0.8283048868,
0.0430861712,
-0.0831413791,
-0.3101666272,
-0.0963788033,
0.9160209894,
-0.2098774761,
0.8012011051,
0.7179182172,
-0.247191146,
0.8642350435,
-0.1685092151,
0.2047613561,
-0.7336911559,
-0.1049770787,
-0.0699512586,
-0.3275183141,
-0.8324120641,
0.1202098057,
-0.0698954985,
0.1094123051,
-0.9505172968,
0.639311254,
-0.5478237271,
0.0853854269,
0.0257221423,
-0.0849542245,
0.3326943815,
0.3406856954,
0.4394307733,
0.2469144017,
0.8715516925,
-0.5204393864,
0.1431904584,
0.5686407685,
-0.5082938075,
0.5531586409,
-0.9343625307,
0.1407279521,
-0.4301095903,
0.0593262948,
-0.8879929185,
0.286904633,
-0.0359065384,
-0.1717927605,
0.1308219284,
-0.239827618,
-0.1278904676,
-0.5757248998,
0.0319754928,
0.6842232943,
0.5168850422,
-0.549900353,
0.4872358739,
-0.0689244419,
-0.1218556464,
-0.6395579576,
-0.7731708288,
-0.1860962063,
-0.0637074187,
-0.6103056073,
0.5822937489,
-0.2572276592,
-0.2872808576,
0.1945725828,
-0.1508474946,
-0.596947372,
-0.0132687306,
0.3151336014,
0.5528516769,
-0.474819988,
0.2340495586,
-0.0152857369,
-0.1836861968,
-0.3871074021,
-0.4566565752,
0.374150157,
-0.2824026644,
-0.5702152848,
-0.4540627897,
0.462839514,
0.4293919504,
-0.4558169544,
0.5139403343,
0.5574756861,
-0.2757814825,
0.2628050447,
-0.5838112235,
0.0917317942,
-0.4920497835,
0.5161575079,
-0.296785444,
-0.8520017266,
0.1878025532,
0.1430494636,
0.0179170296,
0.0177692454,
0.6396075487,
-0.4291031063,
0.7923702598,
0.5432671309,
0.3819914162,
0.4862328768,
-0.3486241698,
-0.1160187721,
-0.7306578755,
-0.3251492679,
0.0019347342,
-0.2575876117,
-0.0489255674,
-0.6574504972,
0.6509019136,
0.0113386018,
-0.1516034007,
-0.2337455004,
-0.396019876,
0.4480824172,
0.4406671226,
0.5336539149,
0.4088896215,
-0.0425152555,
0.0001842717,
-0.1795204729,
-0.7012671232,
-0.0950999558,
0.9394774437,
-0.1368554533,
0.4931682348,
0.2894648314,
0.8495522141,
0.2091839015,
0.0878941938,
-0.2894153595,
0.4550540149,
-0.7716312408,
-0.5354261398,
-0.2360417545,
-0.2922696173,
-1.1700257063,
0.4614570737,
-0.1699913591,
-0.4498926699,
0.251738131,
0.3804716468,
-0.2438346297,
0.2629483044,
-0.4999076724,
0.9842632413,
-0.8119722605,
0.0743496194,
0.0668210909,
-0.8685392141,
0.3813335896,
-0.103202492,
0.0492666177,
0.3552862108,
0.2241320312,
0.4466149807,
-0.5837811232,
0.8615839481,
-0.32083413,
0.3274220824,
0.3032186329,
-0.1306525767,
0.050216347,
0.1727800071,
0.1775391996,
0.2262214571,
0.2584911287,
-0.5490157008,
-0.7533752322,
0.0792269558,
-0.9611102939,
-0.6265518069,
-0.2690395117,
-0.0972276405,
-0.0927510932,
0.3272720277,
0.7269436121,
1.100384593,
-0.2870798409,
0.0829150602,
0.7723739743,
-0.2854369283,
0.0155225564,
0.6122907996,
-0.5247870088,
-0.062110614,
0.5427120924,
0.2066572607,
0.4991009831,
0.9012338519,
0.2286405116,
-0.4988062084,
-0.6541274786,
-0.3966193497,
0.2559640706,
-0.7120335102,
0.0408524014,
-0.5527063012,
-0.2300330251,
-0.1579824388,
-0.161452204,
-0.2031869143,
-0.0407685824,
-0.1908017546,
0.0318283141,
0.1427601576,
0.488219738,
0.019191321,
0.1868313104,
-0.8723000884,
0.6046282053,
0.8324542046,
0.070159696,
-0.2657889128,
-0.7431569695,
-0.0861166194,
-0.1737554818,
0.0168993026,
-0.9345268607,
0.4506953657,
0.3056226075,
0.5843366385,
0.0664558113,
-0.0396648273,
0.9552782178,
-0.4188014865,
0.6938721538,
0.5286827087,
-0.868044436,
0.4703666568,
0.1193865165,
0.5217875838,
0.5878345966,
0.3646027744,
-0.5896510482,
0.0898057297,
-0.5444963574,
-0.8627599478,
0.2505486012,
0.2233688384,
-0.0848463997,
0.1473177522,
0.2287288606,
0.1414815336,
0.3091696799,
-0.6950114965,
-0.2935994267,
-0.5504381061,
0.0339284763,
-0.1236348599,
0.0212681219,
-0.2211935371,
-0.3281931877,
0.501326263,
-0.0937123597,
0.2557767928,
0.5238842368,
-0.5724630356,
0.4699681401,
0.0581519268,
0.5394171476,
0.5361952782,
-0.1044517532,
0.2043869048,
0.1561736166,
-0.5653122067,
0.1940422356,
-0.0022597904,
-0.1456267089,
0.2122196704,
0.4347104728,
1.2994140387,
-0.0077799521,
-0.7547977567,
0.7777276635,
-0.7231568694,
-0.5665163398,
-0.2365835458,
-0.1174875721,
0.1128537357,
0.553152144,
0.1800522357,
0.2143785506,
0.070057556,
-0.2669077218,
0.4250851274,
-0.0710657835,
-0.5223644972,
-0.0964300185,
0.3381279707,
0.0274782721,
-0.0318229795,
0.9902502894,
-0.1254868358,
-0.4898109138,
0.663277328,
0.2282303274,
0.5129717588,
-0.0612140112,
0.6370678544,
-0.0351537466,
0.332036823,
0.0225951932,
0.5580074191,
0.0552096516,
-0.6699711084,
-0.1712476611,
-0.2689293921,
-0.1096223816,
0.1903593391,
-1.142870307,
0.3291769922,
-0.3345707357,
-0.1049420759,
-0.1792852879,
-0.0986387059,
-1.1246435642,
0.8343541026,
0.4535785019,
0.8365780711,
-0.9151272178,
0.8249942064,
0.7925908566,
-0.3309408426,
-0.9518273473,
-0.0652610287,
0.3287445307,
-1.0041861534,
0.9280039072,
0.0771475658,
-0.0483439937,
-0.0261293128,
0.0438252166,
-0.8586360812,
1.2057948112,
0.1561768204,
-0.8495649695,
-0.0835995674,
-0.063138403,
0.5885145068,
-0.1566716135,
0.1464556307,
0.0844149068,
0.1500228047,
0.1322344244,
-0.7862337232,
-0.1844883859,
-0.5490757823,
0.1202041954,
0.1243382841,
-0.5214422345,
1.0632418394,
-0.3449598253,
-0.181189999,
0.0014938047,
0.4279390574,
0.3571105301,
0.5507784486,
0.7907930613,
0.6325493455,
0.9302970767,
0.1623874158,
1.0263386965,
0.0011601722,
0.1540542841,
1.3102840185,
-0.3637033403,
0.8916672468,
0.4827456176,
-0.0433100536,
0.8280110955,
0.3797025383,
0.0940499604,
0.6246681809,
0.147637859,
-0.2771680355,
-0.3138225973,
0.5130265355,
-0.7670804262,
0.4138559699,
0.1119046807,
-0.3028016388,
-0.1632410586,
0.3080404103,
-0.3777348101,
-0.1472129524,
-0.3058734238,
0.6632383466,
0.0839635655,
-0.3775343597,
0.7907663584,
-0.3204209208,
0.5384069681,
-0.8131530881,
0.2118185014,
-0.2705303729,
0.1493873596,
-0.1620730013,
-0.6635351777,
0.3673479557,
-0.045722954,
-0.3553746343,
0.0679841042,
0.3745527565,
-0.1913719177,
-0.6755712032,
0.3718330264,
0.7172418237,
0.1175848395,
-0.0308532007,
-1.1342246532,
0.2414271086,
0.1242654622,
-0.132904321,
0.3202598095,
0.2649115324,
-0.2945864201,
0.5065931678,
0.4661025405,
0.0674847513,
0.4711150229,
0.3044310212,
1.0060706139,
-0.287204206,
-0.7030469775,
-0.5930233002,
0.7017424107,
0.014217223,
-0.6570281386,
0.2698837221,
0.1633514166,
1.0351984501,
-0.0917778611,
0.7816618681,
0.140763551,
0.2190975547,
-0.9464964867,
0.3023213148,
-1.1746987104,
0.1928913146,
-0.3785329163,
-0.3766111434,
-0.4977137148,
0.6288329959,
-0.3518854678,
-0.131838575,
0.8482915759,
0.9305029511,
-0.1026845276,
-0.2957801223,
0.468742311,
0.3938630223,
0.3787387908,
0.5706962943,
0.7012717128,
-0.4881701767,
0.5653099418,
-0.2923086286,
-0.2226288915,
-0.2703853548,
-0.6293053627,
-0.6746095419,
-0.8804885745,
-0.6953850985,
-0.163666293,
0.5148833394,
0.44717291,
1.0055513382,
-0.1398791224,
0.0525838397,
-0.0075449641,
-0.2161041498,
-0.418183744,
-0.0637327656,
0.4742544889,
0.2371451557,
-0.1647775918,
0.2418993264,
0.4360335171,
0.2022142708,
-0.1228538305,
-0.1038784236,
-0.0805875957,
0.0505807027,
0.7447656989,
0.4360917211,
-0.5123215914,
0.011891203,
0.1402415931,
-0.1104437932,
0.3190131485,
0.6476958394,
-0.9023814797,
0.9256640673,
0.5298403502,
0.576351881,
0.8210380077,
-0.0141481049,
0.0835587829,
-0.7592195272,
0.2688622177,
0.2502553165,
0.4521726966,
0.3167016208,
-0.2716960907,
0.0101164375,
0.4017683268,
-0.2675618827,
-0.8388947845,
0.5889874697,
-1.1227300167,
-0.5613977909,
0.7298715711,
-0.1172034368,
-0.2909600735,
-0.1708009392,
-0.3846949637,
0.0018134351,
0.3132911325,
0.7361774445,
0.1518317014,
-0.2176807672,
-0.5242710114,
-0.0939812288,
0.1562050283,
0.6118782163,
-0.9664151073,
-0.588803947,
0.2913533151,
0.4588983655,
-0.119717665,
1.110234499,
-0.3663720191,
0.7033872008,
0.1531458348,
-0.2434479594,
-0.2058520019,
-0.3485869467,
-0.2925342023,
0.0114046037,
-0.0626988932,
-0.4346564114
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08957v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08957v3
|
MUSTARD: Mastering Uniform Synthesis of Theorem and Proof Data
| 2024-02-14T05:57:58 | 2024-05-23T03:13:23 |
Yinya Huang, Xiaohan Lin, Zhengying Liu, Qingxing Cao, Huajian Xin, Haiming Wang, Zhenguo Li, Linqi Song, Xiaodan Liang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.FL, cs.LG, cs.PL
|
Recent large language models (LLMs) have witnessed significant advancement in
various tasks, including mathematical reasoning and theorem proving. As these
two tasks require strict and formal multi-step inference, they are appealing
domains for exploring the reasoning ability of LLMs but still face important
challenges. Previous studies such as Chain-of-Thought (CoT) have revealed the
effectiveness of intermediate steps guidance. However, such step-wise
annotation requires heavy labor, leading to insufficient training steps for
current benchmarks. To fill this gap, this work introduces MUSTARD, a data
generation framework that masters uniform synthesis of theorem and proof data
of high quality and diversity. MUSTARD synthesizes data in three stages: (1) It
samples a few mathematical concept seeds as the problem category. (2) Then, it
prompts a generative language model with the sampled concepts to obtain both
the problems and their step-wise formal solutions. (3) Lastly, the framework
utilizes a proof assistant (e.g., Lean Prover) to filter the valid proofs. With
the proposed MUSTARD, we present a theorem-and-proof benchmark MUSTARDSAUCE
with 5,866 valid data points. Each data point contains an informal statement,
an informal proof, and a translated formal proof that passes the prover
validation. We perform extensive analysis and demonstrate that MUSTARD
generates validated high-quality step-by-step data. We further apply the
MUSTARDSAUCE for fine-tuning smaller language models. The fine-tuned Llama 2-7B
achieves a 15.41% average relative performance gain in automated theorem
proving, and 8.18% in math word problems. Codes and data are available at
https://github.com/Eleanor-H/MUSTARD.
|
[
-0.4365996122,
-0.6367815137,
0.5355952382,
0.5183674097,
-0.0900703147,
0.0423779823,
-0.4175803065,
-0.1599863023,
-0.2144539654,
0.6796976328,
-0.3558811247,
-0.9407977462,
-0.4267204404,
0.2092572898,
-0.5206871033,
0.8301383257,
-0.2157527506,
0.0557624176,
0.0167594571,
-0.0647839904,
-0.3330946565,
-0.1836298853,
-0.4414135814,
-0.3281337619,
0.1432751417,
0.6663581133,
0.5005339384,
1.1465181112,
0.261492312,
0.295435071,
0.1482646465,
0.3434735239,
-0.443605125,
0.3580656946,
-0.2294885665,
-0.5845291615,
-0.3200777769,
-0.1001894474,
0.388361305,
0.6606493592,
0.0319509767,
0.0843621567,
-0.0918695331,
0.6377179027,
-0.6150363684,
0.1309224665,
-0.8348433375,
-0.0380453803,
-0.3738547266,
0.0466684811,
-0.3687670529,
-0.5218695998,
-0.3167507052,
-0.7216665745,
0.2975970805,
-0.1555716693,
0.8016052246,
0.4009566903,
-0.2782776356,
-0.4285782278,
-0.7122377753,
0.863484621,
-0.5329166055,
0.4117262065,
0.20278579,
0.7780423164,
-0.5035705566,
-0.7232248783,
-0.6558033228,
-0.0453406237,
0.3575397134,
0.008633526,
0.0610482059,
-0.2766397595,
0.2373680025,
0.3226265609,
-0.426784575,
-0.070921123,
-0.171750024,
-0.0939519331,
0.7035776973,
0.0727579296,
0.0432648212,
-0.313100338,
-0.1580235809,
-0.3641601801,
-0.724039793,
-0.1938830316,
0.347917527,
0.2074696869,
-0.0708981603,
0.7634677887,
-0.3446058929,
0.6140909791,
-0.1386701018,
-0.2632276118,
-0.0704265162,
-0.4463095069,
-0.2394469082,
-0.1427041888,
0.7666167021,
0.1823592484,
0.5800492764,
-0.041327484,
-0.0997463316,
0.5476554036,
0.0482197069,
-0.7059937119,
-0.5073301196,
0.48369506,
0.0242502522,
-0.2912586629,
0.0061772591,
-0.8843339086,
-0.4826697707,
-0.3812658787,
0.0047424026,
-0.8007185459,
0.0285037737,
0.3198912442,
-0.2400969863,
0.0763480589,
0.2854785025,
-0.5689376593,
0.4574933648,
0.8907079697,
0.4696435332,
0.1098462641,
-0.2165581584,
-0.3740959466,
0.2898470759,
-0.7867267132,
0.8514941335,
-0.4599607587,
-0.0559814423,
0.0642158985,
-0.3702053428,
0.1824707091,
-0.7893379331,
0.7194125652,
-0.2759821117,
-0.1959544718,
-0.2250186652,
-0.7432806492,
0.1536970288,
0.2750197947,
-0.4124489725,
1.172116518,
0.0397474952,
-0.6518823504,
0.4826778173,
-0.3694975972,
-0.3756654859,
-0.095928669,
-0.4937930703,
-0.3389930427,
-0.1373281032,
0.4526620805,
0.4902617037,
-0.4863784313,
0.1130760759,
-0.2406763583,
-0.0914279297,
0.437907964,
0.0063211587,
0.6454882026,
0.2539105117,
-0.4981121421,
0.0577530041,
-1.3630399704,
-0.0263652597,
0.3359857202,
-0.5267810822,
-0.2486987561,
-0.1311466992,
-0.1928375065,
0.2118259221,
-0.0117905838,
-0.4022293985,
0.2300037742,
-0.2357167751,
0.0281541999,
0.818069756,
0.0862592682,
0.3352156878,
-0.3622686863,
0.2838433683,
0.058667507,
-0.0157431327,
-0.1028860882,
-0.4661965966,
-1.1712677479,
-0.5754832029,
0.5395534635,
0.4427650869,
-0.73735708,
0.6051986814,
-0.1801678389,
-0.5453208089,
-0.6554077864,
0.554086864,
0.3489828408,
0.3619658053,
0.3850628734,
-0.0456644818,
-0.9212912321,
-0.6932327151,
-0.3907815516,
0.0950329229,
-0.3691920042,
0.1214366555,
0.3871839941,
-0.5983974338,
1.06683743,
-0.376635462,
-0.2266653627,
-0.2727744281,
0.1400858462,
0.4403517842,
0.4513316154,
0.3212774396,
-0.4060215652,
-0.5226418972,
0.181745261,
-0.7969372272,
-0.5216172338,
-0.1480629146,
-0.6241052747,
0.2275578082,
0.576595664,
-0.2698155046,
0.1957198977,
0.3346806467,
-0.1225638539,
0.5486183763,
0.0304011367,
0.0274312198,
-0.9531697631,
-0.1043153107,
0.2170523256,
-0.3930390477,
-0.4310758412,
0.1210063994,
0.0945661888,
0.2218912244,
-0.1870706379,
0.440227747,
-0.1541039646,
0.0775403604,
-0.2011210471,
-0.1444856673,
-0.0583999343,
0.2605011761,
-0.2374565303,
0.4993610084,
0.5694799423,
-0.9426181316,
0.4347670078,
-0.0489136241,
-0.2000654638,
0.589443624,
-0.6074324846,
-0.1256220341,
0.1723033935,
0.1983409524,
-1.0623786449,
-0.4331720769,
0.2955560982,
-0.2826526761,
0.0475714989,
-0.4133403897,
-0.7937896252,
-0.2593222558,
-0.2504585683,
0.1539786905,
0.7488681078,
-0.7136718631,
0.4600805938,
0.2284131199,
-0.0646612272,
-0.2562457025,
-0.4715366662,
-0.1005394757,
-0.106003724,
-0.6557748914,
0.1832082868,
0.0241975542,
-0.5423672199,
-0.2004187405,
-0.1738230586,
-0.011965597,
-0.1677398235,
0.0739767775,
-0.1316994578,
0.182540372,
-0.1664815843,
0.1130316034,
-0.2876723111,
0.0795818791,
-0.4962445796,
0.6742812395,
0.210802421,
-0.3222672641,
0.0388278626,
0.1276762933,
0.378552556,
0.1008316502,
0.2885274589,
0.585093379,
-0.4124912918,
-0.7654858232,
-0.4095270336,
0.1179172918,
-0.4798016846,
0.123069495,
-0.505063951,
-0.2291641235,
0.3916399777,
-0.5111609697,
0.3965097368,
0.5390281677,
0.7703303695,
-0.1043559909,
0.6594716907,
0.3706205189,
0.2719841003,
0.1894222796,
-0.4974087775,
-0.1760438979,
-0.5915495157,
-0.1756531298,
-0.6679481864,
0.030777799,
-0.5452213287,
-0.9149214029,
0.4749661982,
0.318710357,
-0.3020096719,
0.3464063704,
-0.3845584095,
0.4923035502,
0.5140101314,
0.0452330783,
0.2819354832,
0.0373600945,
-0.4287837744,
-0.187631011,
-0.6418851614,
-0.5765888691,
1.4291044474,
0.3197458386,
0.8925099969,
0.1305136979,
1.0806628466,
0.1805170625,
0.1359143257,
-0.5036525726,
0.7873851061,
-0.1475761235,
-0.3913093507,
-0.1523047984,
-0.7603217363,
-0.8755120635,
0.1815795451,
-0.0421209224,
-0.420694083,
-0.1740291864,
0.1407785863,
0.2149726003,
-0.1224293485,
-0.5103254914,
0.5252713561,
-0.1034421027,
-0.4804445505,
-0.0268225446,
-0.4041775763,
0.6251477003,
-0.0447049476,
0.4963185191,
-0.1552251875,
0.1884747595,
0.8542726636,
-0.7784388661,
0.6650279164,
-0.0319384485,
-0.4725516737,
0.2431747019,
0.3746701181,
0.6015598178,
0.2256264091,
0.0432685353,
-0.0227125827,
-0.318567872,
-0.4504346848,
-0.5096580386,
0.6403028965,
-0.5646092892,
-0.3885776699,
-0.4097163677,
-0.6625959277,
-0.2946819663,
0.2871829569,
0.3101575077,
-0.0318271592,
-0.0560370497,
-0.1811874509,
0.8564004302,
-0.1036603376,
0.1471687704,
0.0837141573,
-0.327747494,
-0.7894628048,
0.9892333746,
0.0866214633,
0.2053034753,
0.238112241,
0.196935147,
-0.182447806,
-0.3575387597,
-0.5345814824,
0.2685403526,
-0.966509819,
-0.1900321543,
-0.545666039,
-0.0411849916,
-0.5797312856,
-0.2827534378,
-0.7151832581,
-0.6853454709,
0.2129938155,
0.3101122975,
0.5235139132,
0.6996120811,
-0.2639988065,
-0.0286253057,
-0.4089768827,
0.9679206014,
0.4120655656,
0.3360814452,
-0.261402607,
-0.1762699485,
-0.2324762791,
0.0105429869,
-0.364074707,
-0.746718049,
0.2407244444,
0.001598186,
0.3707839549,
0.338295877,
0.0881798044,
0.7123540044,
-0.6329057217,
0.4975259006,
0.0073779039,
-1.029792428,
0.6356280446,
-0.2648209035,
0.1104142219,
0.4200073183,
0.2699067593,
-0.2610368133,
-0.6622247696,
-0.661575377,
-0.9644834995,
0.1845352054,
0.4316326976,
-0.591571033,
0.1527618021,
0.072257176,
0.3068132401,
0.0541651212,
-0.3887782693,
-0.3291876614,
-0.2237413228,
-0.50397259,
0.0854366645,
-0.0841471702,
-0.4405453205,
-0.3444030881,
0.7501311898,
-0.1579335779,
0.1315980703,
-0.0574673004,
-0.123793982,
0.0910941735,
0.3815839291,
0.2933266461,
0.6611492634,
-0.1686849743,
0.3483141363,
-0.1215979531,
-0.3827412724,
0.3639685214,
0.3123348057,
-0.1483878493,
0.3070723116,
0.4560183585,
0.1935791671,
0.0941980034,
-0.5988582373,
0.1372209787,
-0.1508429646,
-0.1505814195,
-0.1866224557,
0.4174760282,
0.0264870953,
0.2044340074,
0.2361777127,
-0.0384437479,
0.0680919364,
-0.3586746752,
0.3151316047,
0.1556576043,
0.3774933219,
-0.0434916839,
0.5567699075,
-0.0106455898,
0.0857646614,
0.1521231681,
-0.2604422867,
-0.4698367417,
0.6288202405,
0.6223412156,
0.6042308211,
0.0012298891,
0.08614631,
0.3176884353,
0.1702179611,
0.0432040878,
0.5111409426,
-0.1538974792,
-0.478130281,
-0.1667286754,
-0.8122276068,
-0.5780178308,
-0.1145185977,
-0.3993275762,
0.3029200137,
-0.703763783,
0.2030021846,
0.1756256521,
0.1662517041,
-0.8719984889,
0.2370045781,
-0.1167008579,
1.0089687109,
-0.7987080216,
0.731302619,
0.5622195005,
-0.1408125907,
-0.7514392138,
0.022981815,
0.0211553462,
-0.6638168097,
0.402700305,
-0.0557940826,
0.164479658,
-0.2267578542,
-0.539485991,
-0.6199532747,
0.8650464416,
0.5485039353,
-0.6265445352,
0.5421872735,
0.5375030637,
0.4079155922,
-0.3015494049,
-0.1159105301,
0.9057639837,
0.5382004976,
0.4794663191,
-0.6469038725,
0.0808316246,
-0.2221327573,
0.1787046939,
-0.0836409032,
-0.2964963913,
1.0413019657,
-0.0368356593,
-0.076885432,
0.177987352,
0.7041299343,
1.0143301487,
0.2622058988,
0.160694167,
0.8988032341,
0.9394226074,
-0.1956710219,
1.2126740217,
-0.0821434781,
0.0936144143,
1.0202778578,
-0.4222723842,
0.5443537831,
0.4423232675,
-0.2436404973,
0.5731543303,
0.5611402988,
0.1129587367,
0.359313637,
0.6395199299,
-0.1786626726,
-0.1841172874,
-0.0221266262,
-0.4443477392,
0.2539046407,
0.4105647504,
-0.2687434554,
-0.1597429812,
-0.236799255,
0.2445899844,
0.1828881204,
-0.1857680678,
0.849309206,
-0.0933928639,
-0.5714487433,
1.0211858749,
0.2511855364,
0.4812263548,
-0.5278272629,
-0.2220813632,
-0.4169690609,
0.5947673321,
-0.1549850851,
-0.7223190665,
0.0148342997,
0.3611283898,
-0.144225508,
0.1075345054,
0.4724691808,
-0.4052400887,
-0.7865748405,
0.0563352406,
0.2411402315,
0.1510287523,
0.2851046026,
-0.3794363439,
0.5392510891,
-0.1937068701,
-0.0610044673,
0.0141029358,
1.0545446873,
-0.0517784618,
0.6483442783,
0.8032765985,
0.4336256683,
0.4091121256,
0.1240606904,
1.0228203535,
-0.61506778,
-0.4935069978,
-0.8554359674,
0.3747057319,
-0.2568868995,
-0.0495854616,
1.0087763071,
0.450145334,
1.0319669247,
-0.0988241881,
1.0809525251,
-0.0526317842,
0.3293037117,
-0.7521242499,
0.4053226113,
-0.1250933558,
0.3394591212,
-0.5135043859,
-1.0459229946,
-0.5392748117,
0.6967105865,
0.001312655,
-0.0226291064,
0.5873497128,
0.6779623032,
-0.1931123286,
-0.3053779006,
0.0738853961,
0.3206962943,
0.852781713,
0.6016591191,
0.5535264015,
-0.6506664753,
0.5360023975,
-0.3533792198,
-0.3951984346,
-0.1105149388,
-0.8059265018,
-0.9654228091,
-0.3038997054,
-0.3934956789,
-0.6428766251,
-0.0333720371,
0.9269600511,
0.734498322,
-0.7873368859,
-0.4447537363,
-0.6848086119,
0.3149742484,
-0.3301293254,
-0.222079739,
0.2529077828,
-0.5244922638,
-0.6513348818,
0.4114299119,
0.231042847,
0.0331171788,
-0.216908738,
-0.4057777226,
-0.1999801993,
0.4132742882,
0.3313494623,
0.380567342,
-0.5240343809,
0.067135483,
-0.4047233164,
-0.1392711401,
-0.0869572684,
0.7483861446,
-0.7614162564,
0.5115814805,
0.3041881323,
0.7163389325,
0.391818434,
-0.1542803943,
0.6667435765,
-1.0868699551,
0.1857663244,
0.0737687349,
0.5868699551,
0.4390184879,
-0.1233292967,
0.6064411402,
0.2316929847,
-0.3844799995,
-0.8150773048,
0.3804850876,
-0.7633911371,
-0.2775060534,
1.4518041611,
-0.0897361189,
-0.5497171879,
-0.0932215527,
-0.2651632726,
0.4818350673,
-0.3229434192,
0.8175010681,
0.4935641289,
-0.0907114223,
0.0955497921,
-0.1959164292,
0.5546744466,
0.2559530437,
-0.9710663557,
0.2721005976,
0.4997211695,
0.355055213,
0.1625597328,
0.4675912559,
-0.1361334026,
0.2737455964,
0.2516029477,
0.0504248291,
-0.1631584764,
-0.78162992,
-0.0384860821,
0.1938856542,
0.0542897284,
-0.3009671271
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08955v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08955v1
|
Using Counterfactual Tasks to Evaluate the Generality of Analogical Reasoning in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-14T05:52:23 | 2024-02-14T05:52:23 |
Martha Lewis, Melanie Mitchell
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have performed well on several reasoning
benchmarks, including ones that test analogical reasoning abilities. However,
it has been debated whether they are actually performing humanlike abstract
reasoning or instead employing less general processes that rely on similarity
to what has been seen in their training data. Here we investigate the
generality of analogy-making abilities previously claimed for LLMs (Webb,
Holyoak, & Lu, 2023). We take one set of analogy problems used to evaluate LLMs
and create a set of "counterfactual" variants-versions that test the same
abstract reasoning abilities but that are likely dissimilar from any
pre-training data. We test humans and three GPT models on both the original and
counterfactual problems, and show that, while the performance of humans remains
high for all the problems, the GPT models' performance declines sharply on the
counterfactual set. This work provides evidence that, despite previously
reported successes of LLMs on analogical reasoning, these models lack the
robustness and generality of human analogy-making.
|
[
-0.5373616815,
-0.8506857157,
1.0219722986,
-0.3755026758,
-0.2624356151,
-0.2892776728,
-0.2049547434,
-0.6171355844,
0.1893623024,
0.2696515918,
-0.5733240247,
-0.0637332052,
-0.5647192597,
0.1224961802,
-0.4273818731,
0.9032295346,
-0.1424315423,
0.0603747144,
-0.3926822543,
-0.3268344998,
-0.2319987863,
-0.7894765139,
-0.513771832,
-0.7703734636,
0.3603234291,
-0.0557398088,
1.111022234,
0.4918771684,
0.1932477057,
0.3508960009,
0.2841773033,
-0.1538859755,
-0.4382617474,
-0.0878169239,
-0.7415469885,
-0.5396385789,
-0.3372235596,
0.4826001823,
0.4040199518,
0.8283112049,
0.006037124,
0.1705932468,
0.0439465344,
0.3520988226,
-0.3411736786,
0.1285144389,
-0.9979462028,
-0.226381585,
0.2557780147,
0.0462183803,
-0.1442868114,
-0.2826351821,
0.4242997468,
-0.6851232648,
0.5186040998,
0.2040582299,
0.8401567936,
0.0496809855,
-0.1785990447,
-0.3729104102,
-0.6253373027,
0.9170328379,
-0.8575361371,
0.101077877,
0.3529904485,
0.2063177079,
-0.2119443268,
-0.5865770578,
-0.9148975015,
-0.629873395,
-0.198636964,
-0.1472548395,
-0.546810627,
-0.0303323194,
0.5821634531,
0.1877484471,
-0.8179174662,
0.1582219452,
-0.2612478137,
0.0212806128,
0.301556319,
0.2730081379,
0.3719632626,
0.2370345592,
-0.2675182223,
-0.0774607956,
-1.0068404675,
-0.1395783722,
0.2614352107,
-0.0302716568,
-0.0058876313,
0.3756079078,
-0.2646946609,
0.5651512742,
0.0081610093,
0.1662379503,
0.0840600654,
-0.0268322323,
-0.3404924572,
-0.3087804317,
0.5056909323,
0.6528633237,
0.8600252271,
-0.3292017579,
-0.2486089468,
0.5354910493,
0.2171709687,
-0.6305617094,
-0.2992190421,
-0.0920499265,
-0.3786566854,
-0.0143167563,
0.0288265888,
-0.187396571,
-0.0330094583,
-0.6751310229,
0.8566555977,
-0.2279571593,
-0.1228267327,
0.0188507531,
-0.2221939266,
0.1879003048,
0.3205747008,
-0.8955903649,
0.590041101,
0.7961726189,
0.6513860226,
-0.147002548,
-0.7707329392,
-0.5432007313,
0.0561319329,
-0.524862051,
0.8176916242,
-0.8179115057,
-0.3661405742,
-0.2746487856,
0.0828527883,
-0.3052596748,
-0.9726388454,
0.1349546611,
-0.2548111379,
0.1692926735,
-0.5933730602,
-0.54460603,
-0.1821825206,
0.5399909616,
-0.426938802,
0.6025283337,
0.0135992328,
-0.551328063,
0.3284787834,
-0.4236620367,
-0.2616130412,
-0.2000961304,
-0.5695716739,
-0.2773244381,
0.2815576792,
-0.0249381457,
0.2508936524,
-0.7120382786,
0.2166670263,
-0.6492922306,
-0.8493717313,
0.3142117262,
-0.4028609991,
0.5645772815,
-0.015949402,
-0.4689581096,
-0.0306623112,
-0.3720878363,
0.0684794337,
0.2877087891,
0.0560051762,
-0.5123872757,
0.0452693477,
-0.432370156,
0.4132497311,
-0.0679530799,
-0.632368505,
0.2844184935,
-0.328886807,
0.5250799656,
0.6530135274,
-0.2055073977,
0.1576803178,
-0.8302573562,
0.5068534613,
-0.1147994846,
-0.1513534039,
0.0648474023,
-0.7512580752,
-0.6611038446,
-0.103067562,
0.0225172304,
0.5515508056,
-0.726978898,
0.0688158721,
-0.5178588033,
-0.4741627574,
-0.1665667295,
0.0322025605,
0.5774955153,
0.6245791316,
0.3918511569,
-0.3815178275,
-0.424253732,
-1.269726038,
-0.6419109702,
-0.4244515598,
-0.4395802319,
0.1388991028,
0.8295946121,
-0.1808957607,
0.8984828591,
-0.4245198965,
0.0451450199,
-0.01528206,
0.5423955321,
0.2801477909,
0.3328116536,
0.7259258032,
-0.6204506159,
-0.2524365187,
-0.1149141118,
-0.896250844,
-0.3547650874,
-0.1474190801,
0.4381798804,
0.2467599809,
0.6958737969,
-0.890239656,
0.4711534083,
0.4384742379,
-0.2337465733,
1.0106948614,
-0.3761203885,
0.3325587809,
-0.4705040753,
0.1845846176,
-0.0840229914,
-0.0211034715,
-0.6253429055,
0.1897259355,
-0.2380751967,
-0.01521465,
-0.4697675407,
0.7556539178,
-0.307711035,
-0.2509509921,
-0.2771880329,
0.0455504134,
-0.0669786707,
0.4548871517,
0.2509762645,
0.8600364327,
0.3842495084,
-0.4605821669,
0.3478941917,
-0.309927702,
-0.2359993756,
0.7666372061,
-1.0099617243,
0.228060171,
-0.153085798,
0.2732889056,
-0.9456541538,
0.0269787814,
0.126288265,
-0.1799310744,
-0.1758969128,
-0.0602174513,
-0.6163387895,
-0.3340960741,
-0.4127289057,
0.3988062739,
0.8715329766,
-0.3661081791,
0.5969125032,
-0.3305999041,
-0.2097839862,
-0.296554178,
-0.8856153488,
0.1757197976,
-0.4062172174,
-0.3280437291,
0.2275696993,
-0.0671183243,
-0.5378576517,
0.2752857506,
-0.2201436758,
-0.1071994826,
-0.0795998648,
0.1165165976,
0.3123085201,
-0.2833003402,
0.0354578346,
-0.1753326505,
-0.145522207,
0.2799821496,
-0.1590941846,
0.2289881408,
-0.2487223893,
-0.7301585674,
-0.0400768109,
0.2997272015,
0.4713797569,
0.1999851912,
0.6906602383,
0.2784036696,
-0.2746989131,
0.0868741944,
-0.7576857209,
-0.3299272954,
-0.4126669466,
0.4857681096,
-0.7070898414,
-0.7674081922,
0.6913577318,
0.0693843439,
0.0815968364,
0.4869092405,
0.4718889594,
-0.150921151,
0.6321980357,
-0.0770301521,
0.1582277715,
-0.0150651922,
-0.0389884636,
0.1450997293,
-0.5280547738,
0.1305570453,
-0.4135902822,
-0.1513086855,
-0.5543212891,
-0.3772662282,
0.1620036364,
-0.0552417301,
-0.5776803493,
0.3354809284,
-0.0632128939,
0.6305443048,
0.4453090727,
0.0177861992,
0.4658603668,
-0.0184946377,
-0.1435506195,
-0.190357253,
-0.5709614158,
-0.6739182472,
1.0397455692,
0.0838744044,
0.6274470091,
0.051490888,
0.4076335728,
0.2352806628,
0.7445974946,
-0.3601344228,
0.7947030067,
-0.5059043169,
-0.6663864255,
-0.2187756598,
-0.3856950104,
-0.9917192459,
0.6095100641,
-0.2228249907,
-0.8890032172,
-0.0030336459,
0.393342942,
0.0514700599,
0.536664784,
-0.8397291899,
0.7778869271,
0.1594889313,
-0.1259565949,
-0.426892519,
-0.5107836127,
0.4161854386,
-0.1874094456,
0.2377434075,
0.0503879189,
-0.0143083846,
0.5707384944,
-0.3531556726,
0.8645906448,
-0.0864091069,
-0.0749284923,
0.2324184328,
0.3668364882,
0.553786993,
-0.3455573022,
-0.084836334,
0.2681160271,
0.0191423707,
-0.5508423448,
-0.9971371293,
0.8085122108,
-0.5799242854,
-1.18125844,
-0.3942736983,
-0.5691940188,
-0.3379205763,
0.1123784781,
0.1598658711,
0.4543408453,
-0.4752591848,
0.0965798944,
0.4751178026,
-0.1196710989,
0.2856865227,
0.5685811043,
-0.1179157421,
-0.0456404127,
0.7798768878,
0.1776933223,
0.7355942726,
0.2305159271,
0.2208897471,
-0.2884331942,
-0.5149488449,
-0.5046615005,
0.2035208791,
-0.7027130723,
0.3208871484,
-0.3587825596,
0.124082163,
-0.0947378278,
-0.2145187408,
-0.1788354367,
-0.3289245367,
0.0970177427,
0.1721367538,
-0.159588486,
0.8796511292,
-0.069944866,
-0.1035902351,
-0.5201294422,
0.7536569834,
1.0240303278,
0.1295721084,
0.3274314702,
-0.6542127132,
0.0959185436,
0.1749473363,
-0.2096547037,
-0.5089710951,
-0.0855367407,
0.1564969569,
0.7024572492,
0.3026833534,
-0.1075831652,
0.5764352679,
-0.7056903243,
0.7179855704,
0.2965252101,
-0.9508265257,
-0.0647964329,
-0.559986949,
0.3378783166,
0.3605873883,
0.4372323453,
-0.3874295652,
-0.3858446777,
-0.5780339241,
-0.3174315095,
0.3707709312,
0.3117803335,
0.2103124112,
-0.1125062034,
0.2599897683,
0.2578806877,
0.1965934336,
-0.7943872809,
-0.0470284671,
-0.245847106,
0.0367673561,
-0.2311362922,
-0.1135765016,
-0.0078812251,
-0.2115054578,
0.3281675279,
0.0206534471,
0.0617281832,
0.2393197864,
-0.1039359495,
-0.1333137006,
0.5571113825,
0.6396915317,
0.9472759962,
-0.2583062649,
0.4561472237,
0.5654498339,
-0.1764133573,
0.4684150815,
0.1228929162,
-0.0640116408,
-0.1848799437,
0.7805898786,
0.5553207397,
0.3346095383,
-0.8448092341,
0.3384657502,
0.1308628172,
-0.4806344807,
-0.1320085973,
0.2362107635,
0.4166668653,
0.2028205991,
0.4335344136,
0.0537222996,
0.1305977255,
-1.1085883379,
-0.0089834929,
0.6424773335,
-0.0468380228,
-0.4491737187,
0.6599577069,
-0.0778107867,
-0.4330130816,
0.5705000162,
-0.2778544128,
-0.5375237465,
0.7531690598,
0.5487724543,
0.7476071119,
-0.1348158568,
-0.1218779385,
0.0804046616,
0.4315858781,
-0.1670834869,
-0.0035935708,
0.1445546448,
-0.7045798302,
-0.4877964854,
-0.1989496946,
-0.4828498065,
0.5200631618,
-0.4946302772,
-0.0790467486,
-0.291562438,
0.0118487291,
0.0454115309,
-0.3567653894,
-0.8412781954,
0.4222953022,
-0.2079758793,
0.5476797819,
-1.1987094879,
0.8136609197,
0.9600987434,
-0.2268398404,
-0.3340340555,
0.2004706562,
-0.1710114777,
-0.7322481871,
0.9453520775,
0.1809105128,
-0.2915911376,
-0.4354086518,
-0.3938044012,
-0.4311612844,
0.7660661936,
0.7687132955,
-0.6302306652,
-0.2253725082,
0.4114701152,
0.9048953652,
-0.5071463585,
0.2664551735,
0.6362367868,
0.4412415028,
-0.0534753576,
-1.4423240423,
0.3376204967,
-0.2378284931,
0.0248580407,
-0.1228295267,
-0.3097258806,
1.1034117937,
-0.285179764,
-0.0182706565,
0.2340980619,
0.2125295699,
0.5486009717,
0.3163425922,
0.7756176591,
0.810536623,
0.1107795537,
0.1033177525,
1.1723200083,
0.3161103427,
0.2920157015,
1.2387070656,
-0.3407463729,
0.7065737247,
0.4866185486,
-0.4411154687,
0.4906206429,
0.1891262084,
-0.0300555136,
0.355981797,
0.4257731736,
-0.0699838474,
-0.604835391,
0.1822000742,
-0.3973191679,
0.2201523632,
0.1029796302,
-0.2756238878,
-0.4686757028,
-0.343421191,
-0.0108805308,
0.341248244,
-0.1973135024,
0.4121238887,
0.1916466653,
-0.7953605056,
0.9321972132,
-0.1463151574,
0.5581553578,
-0.4222143888,
-0.3746984601,
0.0043043592,
-0.0004515648,
0.1651087552,
-0.8122950792,
0.3288961947,
-0.1792055219,
-0.2272180319,
0.13303563,
0.4179395735,
-0.2245879024,
-0.2586123049,
0.366776228,
0.6212841868,
0.4405943453,
-0.1335318238,
-0.5921285748,
-0.1547558159,
-0.0426889174,
-0.1280003339,
0.5470479727,
0.2602044046,
-0.3151359558,
0.7949932218,
0.5112658143,
0.1960551739,
-0.2644060254,
-0.0515017621,
0.8427460194,
-0.7115324736,
-0.3865151405,
-1.0851557255,
-0.0097712614,
0.0741860196,
-0.3009200096,
0.4957896471,
0.2838236988,
0.9414020181,
-0.3677299321,
0.7439512014,
0.2291051149,
0.4960148335,
-0.550131619,
0.4331785142,
-0.4920007586,
0.2614194155,
-0.4291913509,
-1.2069811821,
0.1153301969,
0.5319277644,
-0.7135826349,
0.3811170757,
0.8969807625,
0.7653312087,
-0.5522242785,
-0.028973911,
0.6218624711,
0.3592387438,
0.3197653592,
0.8751422167,
0.8281444907,
-0.1983199269,
0.3925942481,
0.2111653388,
-0.1028020158,
-0.0103922104,
-1.0396103859,
-1.2373884916,
-0.4766561091,
-0.1375315785,
0.0854644626,
0.4593830705,
0.885987699,
0.5293299556,
-0.8141263127,
0.0153084202,
-0.1276879013,
-0.0907732919,
-0.1182460114,
-0.1223059967,
0.3935901225,
0.0799181536,
-0.6635719538,
0.2028845549,
0.0136211626,
0.1319167018,
-0.1408106834,
-0.1112367511,
-0.0875237733,
0.3086799383,
0.4629896879,
0.370218277,
-1.1783864498,
-0.6027492285,
-0.4519585073,
0.1286197752,
-0.1734452695,
0.7818065882,
-0.9270874858,
0.1942474842,
0.3091602623,
0.4121051133,
0.4496378005,
0.1497904807,
0.5411502123,
-0.2553187311,
0.2821116149,
-0.0356050581,
0.427000463,
0.1989745051,
0.1927070022,
0.3995527923,
0.4153334796,
-0.4429422915,
-0.6346247196,
0.4337434173,
-0.4889198542,
-0.5791986585,
1.0233905315,
-0.5839224458,
0.1873436868,
-0.380500108,
-0.0423005261,
-0.0475949571,
-0.1227542758,
0.9132371545,
0.8619227409,
-0.2806916535,
0.1036179215,
-0.5967174768,
0.172480911,
0.7704694271,
-0.665917933,
-0.0416022502,
0.4214199185,
0.6746237874,
0.0764665604,
0.5281832814,
0.0861838013,
0.5783783793,
0.1617225111,
-0.1912595332,
-0.1804952323,
0.0880020857,
-0.16468364,
0.0703753009,
0.2854707241,
0.1480030566
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08939v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08939v3
|
Premise Order Matters in Reasoning with Large Language Models
| 2024-02-14T04:50:18 | 2024-05-28T04:32:09 |
Xinyun Chen, Ryan A. Chi, Xuezhi Wang, Denny Zhou
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have accomplished remarkable reasoning
performance in various domains. However, in the domain of reasoning tasks, we
discover a frailty: LLMs are surprisingly brittle to the ordering of the
premises, despite the fact that such ordering does not alter the underlying
task. In particular, we observe that LLMs achieve the best performance when the
premise order aligns with the context required in intermediate reasoning steps.
For example, in deductive reasoning tasks, presenting the premises in the same
order as the ground truth proof in the prompt (as opposed to random ordering)
drastically increases the model's accuracy. We first examine the effect of
premise ordering on deductive reasoning on a variety of LLMs, and our
evaluation shows that permuting the premise order can cause a performance drop
of over 30%. In addition, we release the benchmark R-GSM, based on GSM8K, to
examine the ordering effect for mathematical problem-solving, and we again
observe a significant drop in accuracy, relative to the original GSM8K
benchmark.
|
[
0.0810778961,
-0.702229321,
1.1566479206,
0.5084338188,
-0.2614089549,
-0.1310401708,
-0.121232681,
-0.5591798425,
-0.3080162108,
0.6938810945,
-0.0005039019,
-0.5693821907,
-0.9489009976,
0.0311431419,
0.0750507563,
0.63079983,
0.1214055419,
0.2544229329,
-0.5206446052,
-0.3998093605,
-0.1396359205,
-0.7728607655,
-0.4533770084,
-0.8307915926,
0.3184255958,
0.3054096699,
1.0864709616,
0.8516424298,
0.6332625747,
0.3586117923,
-0.5625436306,
0.118281953,
-0.3924964964,
0.3740855753,
-0.3450491428,
-0.9191178083,
-0.6238301992,
-0.0610577837,
0.3864863515,
0.9539994001,
-0.229711622,
0.0391021445,
-0.2772975266,
0.7464849949,
-0.5413928032,
0.2359642386,
-0.736119628,
-0.2815648019,
-0.0491323285,
-0.2782739997,
-0.7137085199,
-0.3325068057,
0.3130383193,
-0.222770527,
0.0952069461,
0.2549578846,
0.6743623614,
0.283347398,
-0.2682911158,
-0.0825738683,
-0.9328360558,
0.8720200658,
-0.7843818069,
0.3385045528,
0.1988533139,
-0.025969835,
-0.5467171073,
-0.5346901417,
-0.2632460296,
-0.2659013271,
0.134617731,
-0.0324033648,
0.1069289744,
0.3638871908,
0.641415894,
0.3015437424,
-0.4445939064,
0.1828876287,
-0.2088428587,
0.1872898042,
0.5544443727,
0.3662042618,
0.1927137524,
-0.2267090827,
-0.3088043928,
-0.002865209,
-1.2249647379,
0.084997572,
0.1203534082,
0.3442085087,
0.2600753009,
0.7948009372,
-0.2865144312,
0.7882322073,
0.1980721056,
-0.5046819448,
0.1185673401,
-0.0573513806,
-0.4270731807,
0.2706081867,
0.6822516918,
0.2391280681,
0.0581353903,
0.1156160906,
-0.2848175466,
-0.0043437597,
0.0450438522,
-0.7086643577,
-0.2669858932,
0.3289552629,
-0.3512184918,
0.108432807,
-0.0034361824,
-0.0292833168,
-0.4574233294,
-0.4346892238,
0.3431904316,
-0.361138612,
-0.0944543406,
0.4178390205,
0.3156826794,
0.0862061828,
0.5931057334,
-0.9427995682,
0.4405179322,
0.9696782231,
0.5104038119,
-0.0166544728,
-0.3780450821,
-0.3798876107,
0.1899485439,
-0.5742335916,
0.8040320873,
-0.5291261077,
-0.1465474218,
-0.1896630079,
-0.1513634771,
-0.1799083799,
-0.9603999257,
0.994961381,
-0.6538701653,
-0.1113218218,
-0.5486955643,
-0.5921800137,
-0.1114874706,
-0.1941087395,
-0.3642967045,
0.8830694556,
-0.4121407568,
-0.6536955833,
0.4734687507,
-0.0922194272,
-0.7803624272,
-0.0826473236,
-0.2583990097,
-0.4192024767,
0.4654797912,
-0.0070754532,
0.6363886595,
-0.2691871524,
0.2164535522,
-0.5586124659,
-0.4821888208,
0.3484245241,
-0.1589485258,
0.7252758741,
0.2791218758,
-0.4932732284,
-0.08088018,
-0.5428882241,
0.2646612227,
0.4237243235,
-0.3189719319,
-0.5724078417,
0.5516456366,
-0.4146829247,
0.3863971531,
0.0426519103,
-0.2406000048,
0.1859119385,
-0.6101261973,
0.5405575037,
0.6078773141,
-0.1052817851,
0.6962453127,
-0.1875142455,
0.0790963545,
0.0021569021,
0.1430073977,
0.1574004591,
-0.6882110834,
-0.4883511961,
-0.0720960721,
0.1336010844,
0.7104582787,
-0.1340188831,
0.0542986356,
-0.3799346089,
-0.2314492613,
-0.012658244,
-0.0518174134,
0.3738406599,
0.2114213854,
0.2175040841,
0.2039236426,
-0.1146863177,
-0.7883133292,
-0.3182445765,
-0.4218574464,
0.1886966228,
0.2079195529,
0.2994226217,
0.1534243673,
0.768473208,
-0.7484762669,
0.2086207271,
-0.431886375,
0.1830747277,
0.5787039399,
0.2299016863,
0.4365870953,
-1.1079148054,
-0.0932755694,
-0.1389969587,
-0.6615236402,
-0.1934715658,
0.2009710521,
0.0103282547,
0.3552913368,
0.3280417323,
-1.154507041,
0.2163275778,
0.1948979199,
-0.065797247,
0.7091937661,
-0.343880862,
0.1603686213,
-0.9126259685,
-0.4270091653,
-0.2011084706,
-0.0768645331,
-0.473254472,
-0.0645518377,
-0.0250201244,
-0.0928497314,
-0.1634466499,
0.2667678893,
-0.5113627911,
-0.2135852873,
-0.2092473805,
0.1477727294,
0.2094602138,
-0.0029696093,
0.0466356091,
0.7248319387,
0.291585803,
-0.7182844281,
0.0202207565,
0.2544295788,
-0.5354263783,
0.2628338039,
-0.7474262714,
0.0241592657,
0.0319783539,
0.1567998528,
-1.0661547184,
-0.1156215891,
0.0917303115,
-0.3810051084,
0.49290663,
-0.3783248067,
-0.7079921365,
-0.2548187673,
0.0445568301,
0.2508322001,
0.4162089825,
-0.3696406186,
0.3995122313,
0.1131705195,
-0.2379904538,
-0.8784842491,
-0.5615879297,
0.0420245752,
-0.2860308886,
-0.7687615752,
0.4329906106,
0.0366484225,
-0.8238701224,
0.0019905714,
-0.5217120647,
-0.0118497135,
0.2054893374,
0.3191500008,
0.1148583665,
-0.4528587162,
0.1962093264,
0.0328899808,
-0.1274124533,
0.3467825353,
-0.4365020692,
0.1450592279,
-0.1177846044,
-0.4446862936,
0.0476391539,
0.2050684988,
1.0611809492,
-0.1483914256,
1.0293595791,
-0.1899025142,
-0.3058255017,
-0.4505777061,
-0.6350231171,
0.1026060656,
-0.4642046988,
0.2479903996,
-0.8125193119,
-0.6893439889,
0.544960618,
-0.2947171032,
0.0180201791,
0.4433946311,
0.508867085,
-0.2202068716,
1.1576616764,
0.5470912457,
0.0303233918,
0.3252426982,
-0.0363981463,
0.6057744622,
-0.5771314502,
-0.1655936986,
-0.608204484,
0.2082141042,
-0.3546195328,
-0.3991027772,
0.1600821465,
0.506980896,
-0.2229687572,
0.198440209,
-0.2967709601,
0.713778317,
0.0853832215,
0.165096879,
0.5476759672,
0.1139941439,
-0.2193433493,
-0.095786266,
-0.7873342037,
-0.8106944561,
0.9376885295,
0.1504365355,
1.0129725933,
0.2370288521,
0.6787368059,
0.0133922268,
0.1049305722,
-0.7398990393,
0.7629619837,
-0.3640744388,
-0.5241442323,
-0.2543095052,
-0.6292464137,
-0.8557966948,
0.4122901261,
0.0377271101,
-0.7306089997,
0.0882646292,
-0.0372498333,
-0.4302454591,
0.2005667686,
-0.8751196265,
0.6539640427,
-0.3796418011,
-0.4681102931,
-0.3156372011,
-0.6987611055,
0.4077655077,
0.4224418104,
0.0381820016,
-0.4342519343,
0.3007361591,
0.5722050667,
-0.6329649687,
0.5524095893,
0.0212851223,
-0.327144146,
0.3545237482,
0.2560817897,
0.7432585955,
0.1422749758,
-0.2148764282,
-0.0333228335,
-0.1877198368,
-0.4748983681,
-0.7713804245,
0.7267832756,
-0.8282011151,
-1.1747020483,
-0.4537215531,
-0.4375611842,
-0.3114875853,
-0.0250191055,
0.5138452649,
0.8626618385,
0.1048505828,
-0.0294618383,
1.2081160545,
-0.0226885155,
-0.037445087,
0.4277091026,
-0.0312700942,
-0.3762604296,
0.6912412643,
0.5333627462,
0.7715564966,
0.6691645384,
0.2074186057,
-0.4475889206,
-1.1236906052,
-0.3263529539,
0.3673911095,
-1.2625744343,
0.0593291484,
-0.8373114467,
-0.1352740973,
-0.473328501,
-0.1252002269,
-0.3754315972,
-0.543150425,
-0.0858478546,
-0.0099204835,
0.1899615824,
0.8339192271,
0.4124800563,
0.0329103768,
-0.7230343819,
0.3256365359,
0.2034850866,
0.1951724738,
-0.2876314223,
-0.6581506133,
0.0522807315,
-0.2575266361,
-0.0910087675,
-0.5548855066,
-0.1557679325,
-0.2628645301,
0.7169900537,
0.4762739539,
0.1904837638,
0.7200763226,
-0.7624143958,
0.4844656885,
0.0903319195,
-0.7868549228,
0.3933081925,
-0.5566369891,
0.2698352039,
0.4126520157,
0.1450614184,
-0.139204517,
-0.3659079671,
-0.6508492231,
-0.9304432869,
0.6717791557,
0.1667186469,
0.0290513374,
0.080585897,
0.5297652483,
-0.0486291461,
0.1046410352,
-0.5653008819,
-0.3932728767,
0.1716567576,
-0.0771946013,
-0.0837547109,
-0.5842490196,
-0.1649608165,
-0.2660791278,
0.4750002325,
-0.0099460306,
0.4106455445,
0.3306035995,
-0.2312393337,
-0.1972207427,
0.3932635188,
0.9811264873,
1.2546862364,
-0.2755910456,
0.4369054735,
0.0991502404,
-0.3119736314,
0.3506737053,
0.1258449107,
-0.1092092767,
-0.171438396,
0.5207335949,
0.6319803596,
0.3832044005,
-0.4918829203,
0.3925209939,
0.1987523884,
-0.182560131,
0.0277085006,
0.0735601783,
0.2000485659,
0.4297586679,
0.5210801363,
0.197420612,
0.0252866726,
-0.5151222348,
0.117142722,
0.2890514135,
0.3929457068,
-0.22834526,
0.6261206269,
-0.0992656127,
-0.2676675916,
0.4525380731,
-0.0891540647,
-0.9580481052,
0.7587639689,
0.8284865022,
0.7403398156,
-0.2033686489,
0.2424986213,
0.0904200003,
0.5081837177,
-0.6325064301,
0.0955459103,
0.0236317273,
-0.7527653575,
-0.7749418616,
-0.5942468047,
-0.7767710686,
0.0851176456,
-0.3328167498,
-0.0216764119,
-0.6460794806,
-0.2380442023,
-0.1119327098,
0.1517585963,
-0.0960926488,
0.3615752161,
0.260399282,
0.5478207469,
-0.8041322827,
0.4682967663,
0.9028856158,
0.1255428344,
-0.8524103761,
0.2059730589,
-0.1507199109,
-0.4332589805,
0.9455640912,
0.1549004018,
-0.4984205663,
-0.3617400527,
-0.5293636918,
-1.2756115198,
0.7915275097,
0.5711048841,
-0.3895129561,
0.3632820547,
0.0652031675,
0.5612581968,
-0.3085169792,
0.111593768,
0.105810307,
0.2151974887,
0.3885194361,
-0.8169243932,
0.1967166513,
0.12318445,
-0.0463737883,
0.56729877,
-0.8788529634,
0.903865099,
-0.5977464914,
-0.3421099782,
0.0010077072,
0.6252198219,
0.4494689703,
0.4793646336,
0.4092105329,
0.7543697953,
0.8568390608,
-0.3073143661,
0.9813063741,
0.1023701504,
0.2470115125,
1.1784483194,
-0.8882859945,
0.7760155201,
0.2242987305,
-0.4950873852,
0.4175888896,
0.8313592076,
0.3288332522,
0.3802859783,
0.2963527441,
-0.0798913538,
-0.5782975554,
0.2823550701,
-0.2883242071,
0.0940246731,
0.3781071901,
-0.2006223202,
-0.111996524,
-0.2315965742,
0.1570784599,
0.0400768369,
-0.2190538049,
0.4451108575,
0.5028248429,
-0.6235798597,
0.8564793468,
0.1436492503,
0.008274558,
-0.4423826635,
0.102296114,
-0.0380386896,
0.4491645992,
-0.3665464818,
-0.8580006361,
0.2195672542,
-0.3345192969,
-0.6166134477,
-0.3322274685,
0.7181620598,
-0.0793017969,
-0.2529516518,
0.5514184833,
0.5482968092,
0.0303084757,
-0.0354430117,
-0.6846728325,
0.0966209471,
-0.5722128749,
-0.6489719748,
0.446865797,
0.7406859994,
-0.2718861401,
0.8225167394,
0.5543846488,
-0.1243758947,
0.1566938907,
0.1168508902,
0.802312851,
-0.5152161717,
-0.2861335278,
-1.0118609667,
0.0005292262,
-0.0303076077,
-0.2029647678,
0.8539725542,
0.4155060053,
0.532859683,
0.1804824471,
0.3409947455,
-0.0363269299,
0.0545684174,
-0.8284723163,
0.3882006109,
-0.4699543715,
0.5090684295,
-0.3442903757,
-1.2301311493,
-0.4825985134,
0.3604933918,
-0.9484215379,
-0.0523712896,
0.958170414,
0.5407281518,
0.0386769809,
0.0754066557,
0.5086399317,
0.5256711841,
-0.0192775689,
0.5062733889,
1.0580984354,
-0.3342570364,
0.4271821678,
-0.1550886333,
0.0063856672,
-0.1742612123,
-0.640401125,
-0.9159438014,
-0.2134095877,
-0.2973416746,
-0.6001092792,
0.2004180402,
1.0180705786,
0.5271596909,
-0.7024847865,
-0.166754663,
-0.0571991578,
0.6097487807,
-0.4207250476,
-0.2139200568,
0.4628397226,
-0.3797340691,
-0.547219038,
0.511598587,
0.5483012795,
-0.0941764414,
0.3672968149,
0.0353044756,
-0.1851172,
0.2236180454,
0.859316349,
-0.0320787951,
-1.0471315384,
-0.3740080893,
0.1470437497,
-0.4352165759,
0.4034918845,
0.9390798807,
-0.3860256374,
-0.0131159397,
0.7394580841,
0.5977752209,
0.3100372255,
0.2921342552,
0.4240541756,
-0.1048447341,
-0.0870027319,
0.195475474,
0.4942739606,
0.1431233287,
-0.5270800591,
0.3306797445,
0.5167600513,
-0.8107950687,
-0.8885216117,
0.38242957,
-1.0406979322,
-0.4518580139,
1.225481391,
-0.1971420646,
-0.4158847332,
-0.2984569967,
0.0408188887,
-0.2309637368,
-0.29035303,
0.5949862599,
0.9350853562,
-0.2761518061,
-0.1160490513,
-0.4849141538,
0.3554880023,
0.9206224084,
-0.4844588637,
0.3837135434,
0.3843441904,
0.5400099158,
0.318092078,
0.6484150887,
-0.0646409169,
0.0973430425,
-0.1593275368,
-0.4765976667,
0.2665778697,
-0.5265052319,
-0.293284446,
0.4553827047,
0.3990522325,
0.202162087
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.08925v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.08925v1
|
MaxMin-RLHF: Towards Equitable Alignment of Large Language Models with Diverse Human Preferences
| 2024-02-14T03:56:27 | 2024-02-14T03:56:27 |
Souradip Chakraborty, Jiahao Qiu, Hui Yuan, Alec Koppel, Furong Huang, Dinesh Manocha, Amrit Singh Bedi, Mengdi Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.RO
|
Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) aligns language models to
human preferences by employing a singular reward model derived from preference
data. However, such an approach overlooks the rich diversity of human
preferences inherent in data collected from multiple users. In this work, we
first derive an impossibility result of alignment with single reward RLHF,
thereby highlighting its insufficiency in representing diverse human
preferences. To provide an equitable solution to the problem, we learn a
mixture of preference distributions via an expectation-maximization algorithm
and propose a MaxMin alignment objective for policy learning inspired by the
Egalitarian principle in social choice theory to better represent diverse human
preferences. We elucidate the connection of our proposed approach to
distributionally robust optimization and general utility RL, thereby
highlighting the generality and robustness of our proposed solution. We present
comprehensive experimental results on small-scale (GPT-2) and large-scale
language models (with Tulu2-7B) and show the efficacy of the proposed approach
in the presence of diversity among human preferences. Our algorithm achieves an
average improvement of more than 16% in win-rates over conventional RLHF
algorithms and improves the win-rate (accuracy) for minority groups by over 33%
without compromising the performance of majority groups, showcasing the
robustness and fairness of our approach. We remark that our findings in this
work are not only limited to language models but also extend to reinforcement
learning in general.
|
[
-0.3496769965,
-0.6651884317,
0.2481358647,
0.0162679926,
0.0447091013,
0.171916157,
-0.5996367335,
-0.2898365855,
0.3493691385,
0.2085733265,
-0.5265754461,
-0.3588894606,
-0.6320245862,
-0.2022857219,
0.0794131458,
1.0377967358,
-0.017732814,
-0.1692597717,
0.0179249328,
-0.6245110035,
-0.2199926525,
-0.608250916,
-0.4638415277,
-0.5434136987,
0.769474268,
0.5669808388,
1.0479674339,
1.1065496206,
0.2087116241,
0.2099194527,
0.0902778581,
0.1829739809,
-0.8277564049,
0.2373195291,
-0.1631079912,
-0.3004187644,
-0.1365123987,
-0.1640715897,
0.6448674798,
0.5409122109,
-0.7808542252,
0.0250317305,
0.1031621546,
0.7001440525,
-0.6863356233,
-0.0454266556,
-0.3517363667,
0.3911562562,
-0.004225383,
0.0133011779,
-0.2778329849,
-0.5259081125,
0.2217861712,
-0.744156003,
-0.1370423138,
0.310195446,
1.0971390009,
0.248727262,
-0.5796452165,
-0.0205510892,
-0.5347958803,
1.1079211235,
-0.4358815253,
0.4251230061,
0.2578326166,
0.4398691654,
-0.1015841141,
-0.0190066248,
-0.4724414051,
-0.1379404664,
0.132562831,
0.2328976244,
0.0956552699,
0.2317840159,
0.1878917366,
0.0967477188,
-0.7189510465,
0.3875798285,
0.006723403,
-0.4635117054,
0.6717538238,
0.2261697203,
0.1860355288,
0.1148316637,
-0.4755650163,
-0.4140613675,
-0.5693609118,
0.2140159905,
0.8351201415,
0.3999899924,
-0.2763766944,
0.5237708092,
-0.0454081371,
0.6998578906,
-0.0278775021,
-0.2727304995,
0.263276428,
-0.1399860978,
-0.1806631982,
-0.1544584632,
0.7932257056,
0.3515202999,
0.2809308767,
0.0927409455,
-0.3329334855,
0.0429334044,
-0.0776306987,
-0.4082222879,
0.0201054495,
0.0577962846,
-0.4023577869,
-0.4553622603,
0.0346883908,
-0.879876852,
-0.4413610399,
-0.3924446106,
0.2185244858,
0.0288453922,
-0.6170910597,
0.0331094451,
0.0884650797,
0.502276361,
0.2618370652,
-1.2990289927,
0.3134364486,
0.7452976704,
0.4442197978,
-0.4664616883,
-0.6434946656,
-0.5592719316,
0.1464725137,
-0.1333690137,
0.5968039036,
-0.5484905243,
-0.2096384615,
0.2861953676,
-0.2178284377,
-0.0700936168,
-0.6104055047,
0.7105546594,
-0.3966062069,
0.276461035,
-0.4123384058,
-0.5094419122,
-0.0486324616,
0.1709373444,
-0.7733054161,
0.8307923675,
0.236158967,
-0.6555837989,
0.6744591594,
-0.6080792546,
-0.4801664948,
-0.2520047724,
-0.2153865248,
-0.5205953121,
-0.1137833074,
0.1599735618,
0.0503889062,
-0.1213168278,
0.6579789519,
-0.7578657269,
-0.1825134307,
0.3571197093,
-0.5363277197,
0.788431406,
0.4661234617,
-0.3409785628,
0.6087388396,
-0.3358467221,
-0.1688475162,
0.2312589884,
-0.4740926027,
-0.0141651072,
-0.0841028094,
0.3780266345,
0.2087597251,
0.1961393803,
-0.3184139729,
0.0791028962,
-0.214054063,
0.175068751,
1.4587649107,
-0.5487527847,
0.6438254118,
-0.5999059081,
0.6916025877,
-0.0887677372,
0.4522978365,
0.3709917367,
-0.2170623094,
-0.4010456204,
-0.3695704639,
0.3742900789,
0.5260232091,
-0.0857112408,
0.5658425093,
-0.2025521547,
0.2414521873,
-0.5569005609,
0.3146255016,
0.3702456653,
0.4034538865,
0.0323784724,
-0.2995122969,
-0.6122125983,
-1.0338485241,
-0.3226796687,
-0.26284042,
0.4156560004,
0.557800591,
0.0975396633,
-0.2434187531,
0.7324357033,
-0.2892042696,
0.0060764626,
-0.369821161,
-0.3258799314,
0.2403986007,
0.3158231974,
0.1496873051,
-0.8760664463,
-0.5626918077,
0.2043980956,
-0.5568784475,
-0.1133377627,
0.1409163028,
-0.5583997965,
0.3037324548,
-0.1324558556,
-0.2416186333,
0.0054359077,
0.7162889838,
-0.2968190312,
0.4080885947,
-0.2602435052,
0.0298209749,
-0.9285732508,
-0.0676013753,
0.208713159,
-0.6133109927,
-0.4070200622,
0.1864588857,
0.1656709313,
0.1245969385,
-0.2883943319,
0.6200493574,
-0.0841429234,
-0.2079514414,
-0.2043216079,
0.2568698525,
-0.2922488153,
0.7699588537,
-0.0611340627,
0.4734611511,
0.3836721778,
-0.5903422832,
0.4819371402,
0.0785265341,
0.091497004,
0.7509035468,
-0.4547924995,
-0.0862284154,
-0.2878809869,
0.1292033494,
-0.7636210322,
-0.6276813149,
0.3545963168,
-0.4145072699,
0.3633929491,
0.1562370509,
-0.180501461,
-0.0324916914,
-0.3635427654,
0.3976190686,
0.5175018311,
-0.7353429198,
0.5479604602,
0.8722438216,
-0.018707199,
-1.1160979271,
-0.4084880054,
-0.2257583737,
-0.432946384,
-0.5521329045,
0.1014429703,
-0.0548060164,
-0.1705710143,
0.037350405,
-0.0926083475,
0.1081074104,
0.2171606869,
0.0414255038,
0.5184535384,
0.108291246,
0.0989878476,
0.1082094908,
-0.1871089637,
-0.4697509706,
-0.5170466304,
0.5275851488,
-0.1739666611,
-0.5087184906,
-0.1633136123,
0.3669833839,
0.3001562059,
-0.0675551593,
0.5463868976,
0.6128205657,
-0.2308972031,
-0.142916292,
-0.4761084616,
0.0116505092,
-0.401189357,
0.6089790463,
-0.1261499673,
-1.24588871,
0.4870317578,
0.173079133,
0.5106112361,
0.4239334166,
0.6214876771,
0.043293763,
1.2313113213,
0.8784430027,
-0.4091573656,
0.6669537425,
0.2390097678,
-0.0630616024,
-0.633143127,
-0.0737305135,
-0.4036662579,
-0.4594620466,
-0.5591065884,
0.0534857772,
0.2034183592,
-0.0234577805,
-0.6498060822,
0.140562579,
-0.395213604,
0.4400903583,
0.5483139157,
0.1265354455,
0.1274415255,
0.2637262344,
-0.3787322938,
-0.1095290259,
-0.8496980071,
-0.1948215216,
1.3106224537,
0.4300056696,
0.9181653261,
0.4672749043,
0.9826442599,
0.4380181432,
0.4693070948,
-0.7248941064,
0.0929422453,
0.1424049884,
-0.4474562705,
-0.7978585362,
-0.7451668382,
-1.1176662445,
0.6394707561,
-0.2266120613,
-0.5951892734,
0.1327930689,
0.3130245507,
-0.21405451,
0.1229100525,
-0.6008424163,
0.9521789551,
-0.4213548005,
-0.425003618,
-0.3003545702,
-0.735697031,
0.5623221397,
0.1518338472,
0.5276451111,
-0.1688061506,
-0.1017380208,
0.732185781,
-0.2600224018,
0.5222371221,
-0.2351331562,
-0.231610328,
-0.2307434529,
-0.2249381989,
0.6843790412,
-0.0824744254,
0.0063565471,
-0.3793777823,
-0.2032651603,
-0.8164440989,
-0.4831134081,
0.6380280852,
-1.1319254637,
-0.4728478789,
-0.4569174647,
-0.6415934563,
-0.1152852848,
0.0217907578,
0.0256690159,
0.2767846286,
-0.2183201909,
-0.0734124035,
0.905841887,
-0.3764095008,
0.218838349,
0.1614369452,
-0.6169049144,
-0.873986721,
1.0694339275,
-0.2628111243,
0.5576251745,
0.4490909278,
0.4067768455,
-0.7045016885,
-0.1534255892,
-0.5681676865,
0.2801179886,
-0.8093227744,
0.0899965167,
-0.5568605661,
0.1747638732,
-0.413269937,
-0.1478458941,
-0.1280007809,
-0.314039439,
0.0215578191,
-0.1855123639,
-0.0968686268,
0.4453420341,
-0.4149701297,
0.0700590312,
-0.5244262218,
0.2621997893,
0.4790422916,
0.3521186113,
-0.0273456275,
-0.61260885,
-0.2531328499,
0.0024496999,
-0.2456247061,
-0.7833169103,
0.2591377497,
0.248445794,
1.0016279221,
0.413128525,
0.029797066,
0.5022938848,
-0.0504092351,
0.451977998,
0.6285185814,
-0.7596815228,
0.0958946943,
-0.2360491604,
0.0995908678,
0.6027780771,
0.1453887671,
-0.8557628393,
-0.2752918005,
-0.5144454241,
-0.81327492,
0.5465424061,
-0.2374922633,
0.0886955708,
0.2885670364,
-0.1261051446,
0.3006103039,
0.1196792275,
-0.880135119,
-0.4322898388,
-0.2407613248,
-0.5608736873,
0.0421659499,
-0.049266398,
-0.5279041529,
-0.0120026767,
0.7175565958,
-0.2728643119,
0.1233114675,
-0.082252562,
-0.343862921,
-0.3854035139,
0.5055865049,
0.8205777407,
0.7449237704,
-0.0031061484,
0.0451992825,
0.0397885032,
-0.2468942255,
0.5091114044,
0.0921947211,
-0.2029740065,
-0.3972446918,
-0.0214277338,
0.9938833117,
0.1035178527,
-0.7042307258,
0.6010937691,
-0.2188961357,
-0.4576998949,
-0.0194668733,
0.0881352276,
-0.0140300123,
0.2557032108,
0.264319092,
-0.0395313241,
-0.1205744296,
-0.4770970345,
0.3149947524,
0.564694941,
-0.583353579,
-0.0471093804,
0.5576971769,
-0.0210390333,
-0.3143606186,
0.262299329,
-0.2125858217,
-0.630769968,
0.524966538,
0.5911042094,
0.840878129,
-0.163572669,
0.4619346857,
0.3098092377,
0.181788981,
-0.3050690889,
0.192661792,
-0.1441715807,
-0.8957244754,
-0.4404346943,
-0.7039086819,
-0.5348934531,
-0.3550750017,
-0.5826814175,
-0.0326804891,
-0.5022078156,
-0.157370314,
-0.4568447471,
-0.1402685046,
-0.6198655963,
-0.2084071487,
0.061426945,
0.1887778938,
-0.8306372166,
0.7502119541,
0.5634661317,
-0.2654093504,
-1.0748670101,
-0.1403570622,
0.1840097606,
-0.8782353401,
0.3961316347,
-0.1237845942,
0.1117043346,
-0.1148624271,
-0.5613076687,
-0.8355950117,
0.9491044283,
0.5074386001,
-0.5503290892,
0.1522665471,
-0.0761076584,
0.0548592433,
-0.3661665618,
0.3611739278,
0.4278836548,
0.6203957796,
0.059945967,
-0.9716609716,
0.0214299504,
-0.0486398265,
-0.0180766974,
0.4548876584,
-0.7561385632,
0.5420479774,
-0.2614464164,
-0.3117926419,
-0.2192879915,
0.7863610983,
0.6899138689,
0.0470382199,
0.6962348223,
0.8319271803,
1.0716640949,
0.1174307019,
0.9206403494,
-0.0715395957,
0.7711715698,
0.9215161204,
-0.4250280261,
0.4301980138,
0.4497933686,
-0.5546780825,
0.128693223,
0.7218765616,
0.3030464649,
0.5798358321,
0.3578318954,
-0.2320578843,
-0.3266069889,
-0.1699613035,
-0.3424200714,
-0.1355741471,
-0.0276831109,
-0.0898766592,
-0.2535877526,
-0.0416333862,
-0.1659961492,
0.2337599397,
-0.0891720355,
0.7680622339,
0.0077324458,
-0.7266349792,
0.5804743767,
-0.0046448545,
1.0646618605,
-0.5004680157,
0.0812994316,
-0.2801676989,
0.0592287779,
-0.1970478743,
-0.6759130955,
-0.0440783836,
-0.2903275788,
-0.0765676349,
-0.0795830786,
0.4672119319,
-0.6287516952,
-0.0276382938,
0.3347784579,
0.4048598111,
-0.1058556363,
0.5461393595,
-0.8098313808,
0.017580783,
0.2839416265,
-0.1289588511,
0.7307509184,
0.1765952706,
0.1441175938,
0.5877971649,
0.6695390344,
0.1912008971,
0.1757536978,
0.1509795487,
0.4277579784,
-0.6296639442,
-0.7172302604,
-0.9330602288,
0.2545869052,
-0.1763443202,
-0.3365595639,
0.3220842183,
0.3883597851,
0.9651582241,
0.2223711908,
1.0233156681,
0.0134324115,
0.2703298926,
-0.3014785349,
0.3166628778,
-0.5421695709,
0.1029266641,
-0.1643032432,
-1.046051383,
-0.3137934506,
0.5631912351,
0.0898661315,
-0.038468577,
0.6208367348,
0.8729816079,
-0.1105022877,
-0.0113017084,
0.5451880097,
-0.3651795387,
0.4293474853,
0.8445009589,
0.897236228,
0.0647727326,
0.5331251621,
-0.0869637802,
-0.3917020261,
-0.2288570702,
-0.6911321878,
-0.4167953432,
-0.3251548409,
-0.0369467661,
-0.4663683176,
0.1518016458,
1.6146484613,
0.5790277719,
-0.7583829165,
-0.5424100161,
-0.0036078654,
0.6027134061,
-0.406449765,
-0.2264759839,
0.3550350666,
-0.3529953063,
-0.5279275179,
-0.1535762548,
0.336851716,
-0.1956595033,
-0.2742157876,
-0.8663085103,
-0.0936113074,
-0.0731206238,
0.3056173325,
0.6795266271,
-0.72937572,
-0.3007682264,
-0.0128107406,
-0.3984613419,
0.1567693353,
0.779956758,
-0.1627250314,
0.3037689328,
0.4763300419,
1.1003371477,
0.2404435873,
0.0259573255,
0.7101581693,
-0.2620251179,
-0.0092291739,
0.1199701354,
0.448835969,
0.2826809585,
-0.2256538272,
0.2803099453,
0.2664296627,
-0.8407070041,
-0.780365169,
0.6817370057,
-0.8882005215,
0.0387429595,
1.2542124987,
-0.1336748749,
-0.3005285859,
-0.1218187511,
-0.1593115032,
0.4340966344,
-0.8721509576,
0.6416865587,
0.7302961946,
-0.0270279534,
-0.3715908229,
-0.4610209167,
0.2964601517,
0.7898324728,
-0.7408939004,
0.169788599,
0.6524602771,
0.1754439324,
-0.3386199772,
0.6871555448,
-0.1385840625,
0.3887978494,
-0.4395855665,
0.0402011238,
0.0592515245,
-0.1276934296,
-0.726873219,
0.2396068871,
0.445032239,
0.080275327
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.00774v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.00774v2
|
Regional inflation analysis using social network data
| 2024-02-14T02:33:17 | 2024-03-14T11:34:28 |
Vasilii Chsherbakov, Ilia Karpov
|
q-fin.ST
|
q-fin.ST, cs.CL, cs.SI
|
Inflation is one of the most important macroeconomic indicators that have a
great impact on the population of any country and region. Inflation is
influenced by range of factors, one of which is inflation expectations. Many
central banks take this factor into consideration while implementing monetary
policy within the inflation targeting regime. Nowadays, a lot of people are
active users of the Internet, especially social networks. There is a hypothesis
that people search, read, and discuss mainly only those issues that are of
particular interest to them. It is logical to assume that the dynamics of
prices may also be in the focus of user discussions. So, such discussions could
be regarded as an alternative source of more rapid information about inflation
expectations. This study is based on unstructured data from Vkontakte social
network to analyze upward and downward inflationary trends (on the example of
the Omsk region). The sample of more than 8.5 million posts was collected
between January 2010 and May 2022. The authors used BERT neural networks to
solve the problem. These models demonstrated better results than the benchmarks
(e.g., logistic regression, decision tree classifier, etc.). It makes possible
to define pro-inflationary and disinflationary types of keywords in different
contexts and get their visualization with SHAP method. This analysis provides
additional operational information about inflationary processes at the regional
level The proposed approach can be scaled for other regions. At the same time
the limitation of the work is the time and power costs for the initial training
of similar models for all regions of Russia.
|
[
-0.6154327989,
-0.8646758199,
0.2477079779,
0.4060818851,
-0.5047886968,
-0.344065696,
-0.2455260903,
-0.3087361455,
0.5913850069,
0.351331383,
-0.3827398419,
-0.4052321017,
-0.4627988935,
-0.3421082199,
-0.2811757326,
0.7443212867,
0.18437998,
0.0372345187,
0.0769548118,
0.4631887674,
-0.0343444385,
-0.5196905732,
-0.8322173357,
-0.2888598144,
0.4682097733,
0.3882953823,
0.2292057872,
0.552821219,
0.361911267,
0.4382843673,
-0.1730643213,
-0.1142156497,
-0.5483460426,
-0.0622249432,
0.2215759009,
-0.1215618327,
-0.1239792556,
-0.3986845315,
0.803859055,
0.4542458057,
-0.0085976925,
0.3077284694,
0.1923545301,
0.8570693135,
-0.4429086745,
0.0572783239,
-0.6061938405,
-0.1658324748,
-0.351390779,
-0.3640925884,
0.2284185886,
-0.587972939,
0.4457262754,
0.0250190981,
0.4005913436,
-0.2805813551,
0.929017961,
-0.3612916172,
-0.4009467661,
-0.3607009351,
-0.7946127653,
0.6076058149,
-0.6455673575,
0.1947427988,
0.2612535357,
0.360109657,
-0.20672822,
-0.6081312895,
-0.4782289863,
0.2645235956,
-0.1014008075,
0.1364691257,
-0.2770199478,
-0.2923554182,
-0.1979419291,
0.3204704225,
-0.1161405295,
-0.1231518611,
-0.4863735735,
-0.0853833258,
0.324618578,
-0.0983044803,
-0.0264553167,
-0.6558570862,
-0.6479072571,
-0.1808775663,
-0.1904286593,
0.201855287,
0.6534978747,
0.5893576741,
-0.2543266714,
0.4587552249,
-0.6020260453,
0.470359534,
0.0421808511,
0.0535718463,
0.3258830011,
-0.3847538829,
0.0725460425,
0.0563881472,
0.3971311748,
0.3532783091,
0.0195407663,
0.3035088181,
-0.2114154398,
-0.3052150905,
0.1443383396,
-0.5424484015,
-0.0057405652,
0.12547113,
-0.5820704699,
-0.4061796069,
0.2109826207,
-1.3769731522,
-0.4244429767,
-0.4075568318,
0.3698223233,
-0.0473267063,
-0.4015838504,
0.0997953787,
-0.0454538986,
-0.2531041801,
0.1646010429,
-0.7088531256,
0.2623048723,
0.7761096954,
0.9825869203,
0.2674735487,
-0.1212385893,
0.1791183949,
-0.3143084943,
-0.0236905683,
1.3557863235,
-0.1596457064,
-0.128639847,
0.4970074594,
-0.0012219456,
0.0753359273,
-0.2140335292,
0.6241945624,
-0.579474628,
0.0494948551,
-0.50016886,
-0.3860400319,
-0.1688897014,
0.4120143652,
-0.5094638467,
1.015856266,
0.1385693401,
-0.6772462726,
0.6588563323,
-0.6351544261,
-0.1678092778,
-0.0072213258,
0.1792497635,
-0.4228419065,
0.1812151819,
0.5427935719,
0.6204717755,
-0.2706308663,
0.2457512915,
-0.2565549314,
-0.067583777,
0.2402804792,
-0.2813403904,
0.5780108571,
0.2375162542,
-0.3294023573,
0.0259946398,
-0.6475629807,
-0.0923351124,
-0.1079981774,
-0.3127322495,
-0.5206825137,
0.0833423212,
0.2655162513,
0.2114568204,
0.3362616897,
-0.5711572766,
0.3531467319,
-0.3238018155,
0.4020535648,
0.9667912722,
0.5868780017,
0.1951712221,
-0.3416841626,
0.1909508705,
0.1824480742,
0.5745220184,
0.3272859156,
-0.3035694063,
-0.5839933157,
-0.114358373,
0.3434212208,
0.0471132398,
-0.6177889109,
0.1968337446,
-0.1242485642,
-0.6751022935,
-0.0548012443,
-0.2279557139,
-0.1205916107,
0.6440221071,
-0.1262914538,
0.3307497203,
-0.7025052905,
-0.6883523464,
0.0047109677,
-0.192169413,
0.0385885127,
0.3149664402,
0.4548103809,
0.0928071588,
0.6453171968,
-0.5798609853,
-0.3334938586,
-0.0803911984,
0.3382438719,
0.5607780218,
0.4135667384,
0.4590899348,
-1.0618646145,
-0.5880101323,
0.0225684717,
0.0840988308,
-0.222552225,
-0.1432555914,
-0.3543507457,
0.3816765249,
0.1030423939,
-0.0792638361,
0.3774112761,
0.591172576,
-0.4947275221,
0.3882527649,
-0.5103852153,
0.4015347064,
-1.1305931807,
0.1077121422,
0.4314723909,
0.1062923819,
-0.7307389975,
-0.1828847826,
-0.1199441478,
-0.214686662,
-0.4296015501,
0.5125127435,
-0.1111757681,
-0.1947530955,
-0.1071583107,
0.1694072485,
-0.2684531212,
0.4634186924,
0.1762011647,
0.5428614616,
0.4202790558,
-0.4116050899,
0.3896381259,
-0.0672515929,
-0.7067163587,
0.16933617,
-0.6246696711,
-0.1471960694,
-0.0884588063,
-0.0466246866,
-1.1242281199,
-0.09787862,
0.0996300131,
-0.4273428023,
-0.0389491282,
-0.113134861,
-0.5619514585,
-0.3264210224,
-0.2329687625,
-0.0418688618,
0.4710478485,
-0.3813922703,
0.4022918046,
0.458060503,
-0.1411706954,
-0.5397709012,
-0.1832269728,
-0.2804665864,
-0.4503090978,
-0.7354240417,
0.0647502244,
0.2798912823,
-0.2991628945,
0.1835835427,
0.1037330851,
-0.2246599197,
-0.2190378159,
-0.0991964489,
0.1358887106,
-0.0713730827,
0.3119407594,
-0.2179571986,
-0.2489727885,
-0.2184627801,
-0.4063180983,
0.8777629733,
-0.3528344929,
0.1666567475,
-0.1863041669,
0.104866229,
0.323744148,
0.0727829859,
0.8789957166,
0.5875077248,
-0.6064199209,
-0.0107695609,
-0.8211134672,
-0.1184269711,
-0.4338044226,
0.2448545098,
-0.0281911623,
-0.5537789464,
0.941311419,
-0.2909781635,
-0.1866450012,
0.4736364782,
0.7263539433,
-0.0840956494,
0.7022015452,
0.6192185283,
-0.0716608688,
0.6454136372,
-0.2586203218,
0.0137201874,
-0.4470456243,
-0.3511232138,
-0.8902841806,
-0.6159435511,
-0.5789505243,
-0.166698426,
0.7501745224,
0.1072458103,
-0.0527325794,
0.0737330019,
-0.3657218218,
0.4341178834,
0.4609881341,
0.2134851962,
-0.1977268308,
0.3748512566,
0.0830793008,
-0.0597296916,
-0.5706821084,
-0.1480630338,
0.8894183636,
0.2236162871,
0.2880178392,
0.1166067049,
0.4607180655,
0.656191051,
0.0703560412,
-0.4194786549,
0.2065645754,
-0.3398040533,
-0.7532840371,
-0.4928484559,
-0.5204316974,
-0.9076507092,
0.0189141352,
-0.6596167088,
-1.0195178986,
0.6225965023,
0.1828247309,
-0.2794380784,
0.4739636779,
-0.4677550495,
0.7820389867,
-0.0558134727,
-0.2191325277,
-0.1310440302,
-0.3051090539,
0.2082864046,
-0.1158404574,
0.1155656427,
-0.2602447271,
0.066136539,
0.5764623284,
-0.3926363885,
0.8176752329,
-0.4215113223,
0.3727461696,
0.3723138869,
-0.3899781406,
0.4694046378,
-0.1631744802,
-0.1857761741,
0.3747405708,
0.1330331415,
-0.7659873962,
-0.5645356774,
0.9380598068,
-1.1697442532,
-0.1109915897,
-0.3451740742,
-0.2385668606,
-0.0671411678,
0.1970162392,
0.3135631979,
0.8139030337,
-0.0079300376,
0.2348252088,
0.3298387527,
0.0092620384,
0.2832486331,
0.3228326738,
-0.3826568127,
-0.5255642533,
0.8811893463,
0.4567585588,
0.0831660926,
0.3465226889,
1.0936373472,
-0.4898231328,
-0.3925325274,
-0.1531924456,
0.3873416483,
-0.7581010461,
-0.0653175265,
-0.2697454393,
0.1889754683,
-0.8174241185,
-0.2465111464,
-0.1760218143,
-0.3112728596,
-0.1499326378,
0.0286824573,
0.322067529,
0.6943805218,
-0.4967515767,
0.5278134942,
-0.5852205157,
0.0176284015,
0.1395245641,
0.3247847855,
0.1329127401,
-0.155270353,
-0.3887752593,
-0.0135984784,
-0.0357072018,
-0.8403379321,
0.4217275977,
-0.0596362874,
0.3298359811,
0.7991168499,
0.2830153704,
1.0308285952,
-0.0257885437,
0.64158535,
0.0034970243,
-0.8251700401,
0.2109838128,
-0.4682653844,
0.2381837517,
0.4668879509,
0.4919008017,
-1.1214891672,
0.1092707664,
-0.7596030235,
-0.982845366,
0.6592908502,
0.126336813,
0.1578266323,
-0.0408683307,
0.6828064322,
0.0528386459,
0.2630425096,
-0.4829823673,
-0.1385196596,
-0.1802477688,
0.021938365,
-0.0469114222,
-0.6392300129,
0.1335367262,
-0.1684499681,
0.8237259984,
0.1342684329,
0.482814908,
0.4068112075,
0.5843370557,
-0.3769978285,
-0.0155042363,
1.0682846308,
0.8052671552,
-0.2933287024,
0.0630868077,
-0.1376640648,
-0.4318604171,
-0.265852958,
-0.1030351147,
-0.2460501194,
-0.0368771218,
0.2184835821,
0.5668597221,
0.0766901299,
-0.4044710398,
0.3951128721,
-0.2210733145,
-0.228468135,
-0.9606324434,
-0.5173728466,
0.0752269775,
0.4958995581,
0.3741788268,
0.1491806358,
-0.0033291199,
-0.5307666063,
0.0591274574,
0.1968445033,
-0.5838223696,
-0.4134243429,
0.1232092083,
0.3025771081,
-0.2845870852,
0.5516116619,
0.1205255911,
-0.766340673,
0.7669430375,
0.4961417615,
0.7299246788,
-0.1000746042,
0.3907407522,
0.3390344381,
0.4364767373,
0.0136830499,
0.5543035269,
0.1131709144,
-0.7273318172,
-0.2863970697,
-0.5669569969,
0.1149261072,
0.49781546,
-0.5747157335,
0.5452613831,
-0.3206450939,
-0.3168654144,
-0.099066332,
0.3780709505,
-0.5785810947,
0.1129836813,
0.1637952626,
0.7376838326,
-1.1063604355,
0.473346442,
0.7671899199,
0.064909175,
-0.4920474589,
0.0260783993,
0.0248634182,
-0.8202393055,
0.6493119001,
-0.1483165473,
0.2143059522,
-0.2620741129,
-0.3028444648,
-1.0319867134,
0.6860304475,
-0.2195229083,
-0.1771252006,
0.1659834981,
0.2405684739,
0.6800749898,
-0.360006839,
0.1447722614,
0.3277145028,
0.6328641772,
0.1606262177,
-0.4158211946,
-0.3017145991,
-0.3065875769,
0.0716567412,
0.6836815476,
-0.7377899289,
1.1604738235,
0.4863758087,
-0.233705923,
-0.2340135574,
0.5477906466,
-0.3759857714,
0.4436216652,
0.6554688811,
0.2566102743,
0.3511234224,
-0.0106228869,
0.8138709664,
-0.4783266187,
0.741138041,
0.2682198286,
0.130918324,
1.0153257847,
0.5060299635,
-0.2481548041,
0.1934616864,
0.8131748438,
0.0829607174,
0.5005262494,
0.1431509703,
-0.3106027544,
-0.2861963212,
-0.1670540422,
-0.2827776968,
0.320381552,
0.3653003573,
-0.0436814763,
-0.4405822754,
0.0535062999,
0.1391517818,
0.1577902883,
-0.6388118863,
0.6721050739,
-0.4054483175,
-0.1909529716,
0.1983453035,
-0.0359479524,
0.425435394,
-0.7046766877,
-0.0272167474,
-0.1804189682,
0.3337482512,
-0.0944588855,
-0.357847333,
0.3984133005,
0.0030985302,
-0.1304431111,
0.0427570678,
1.0974806547,
-0.2908815145,
-0.9263066053,
-0.0304160528,
0.4589244723,
0.3061115742,
0.034117762,
-0.727499187,
0.0051713018,
0.0209857356,
-0.4754190147,
0.3038777411,
0.5413034558,
0.0628356785,
0.228575021,
0.7338035107,
0.3904938698,
0.0234588813,
-0.2428292781,
0.7793525457,
-0.3046323657,
-0.7631086111,
-0.6347565651,
0.4074263871,
-0.4060953557,
-0.5292592645,
0.7395393252,
0.1809355915,
0.779910326,
0.0454957187,
0.5768990517,
-0.0586515553,
0.8981742859,
-0.503526628,
0.86622715,
-0.7115202546,
-0.0927498788,
-0.4050160944,
-1.0294730663,
-0.2353312969,
0.4663325548,
-0.6847470403,
0.0376533307,
0.4275692999,
0.1982092857,
0.0379419625,
0.1347743571,
0.2669997215,
0.1362750083,
0.1938031465,
-0.1077704132,
0.469443053,
-0.1281233877,
0.2448202074,
-1.1070109606,
-0.2109918147,
-0.5655171275,
-1.1740515232,
-0.7957130671,
-0.7972467542,
-0.120785661,
-0.2346386164,
-0.1646781117,
1.1804977655,
0.5103741288,
-0.6811256409,
-0.4719340205,
0.2136611491,
0.0226944331,
-0.4345757365,
-0.2636919022,
0.9391855597,
-0.0724094659,
-0.6503787637,
-0.1433135122,
0.0490738302,
0.0064625815,
-0.3576245308,
0.4167161286,
-0.2688488066,
0.1657833904,
0.3225976527,
0.2114833742,
-0.3179359734,
-0.3268456459,
0.031368535,
0.14242737,
-0.034419518,
1.0049045086,
-0.3277997375,
0.7523531318,
0.8839648366,
0.386790961,
0.5664715767,
0.4195283353,
0.0815569982,
-0.701582253,
0.2054661661,
0.0084827822,
0.3242148161,
-0.0549290329,
-0.5372747779,
0.02363538,
0.4501411021,
-0.9805024266,
-0.4631281197,
-0.0211744681,
-0.6645521522,
-0.2897516191,
0.9175334573,
-0.0238873418,
-0.5414109826,
-0.1319220066,
-0.1949162632,
-0.0047210637,
-0.7514109015,
1.3206818104,
0.9282639623,
-0.3721300364,
-0.0993910208,
-0.5512717962,
0.0840587765,
-0.054482419,
-0.566814363,
-0.0015248931,
0.3300898671,
-0.0219941754,
0.2179982513,
0.6195627451,
0.1026915237,
-0.0400508121,
0.2584842741,
0.1298860013,
-0.0839058906,
-0.2494680882,
-0.397123754,
0.2748481631,
-0.2467143536,
0.0028392205
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.