id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10790v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10790v2
|
In Search of Needles in a 11M Haystack: Recurrent Memory Finds What LLMs Miss
| 2024-02-16T16:15:01 | 2024-02-21T03:07:42 |
Yuri Kuratov, Aydar Bulatov, Petr Anokhin, Dmitry Sorokin, Artyom Sorokin, Mikhail Burtsev
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
This paper addresses the challenge of processing long documents using
generative transformer models. To evaluate different approaches, we introduce
BABILong, a new benchmark designed to assess model capabilities in extracting
and processing distributed facts within extensive texts. Our evaluation, which
includes benchmarks for GPT-4 and RAG, reveals that common methods are
effective only for sequences up to $10^4$ elements. In contrast, fine-tuning
GPT-2 with recurrent memory augmentations enables it to handle tasks involving
up to $11\times 10^6$ elements. This achievement marks a substantial leap, as
it is by far the longest input processed by any neural network model to date,
demonstrating a significant improvement in the processing capabilities for long
sequences.
|
[
-0.2413473725,
-0.6942229271,
0.8903436661,
0.0267540552,
-0.5069981813,
0.0244232267,
-0.2177672982,
-0.4878144562,
-0.1494373232,
0.4643993974,
-0.3627463579,
-0.3235910237,
-1.0515098572,
0.4492861331,
-0.7927858233,
1.0031206608,
-0.0236810986,
-0.3484856188,
0.176325053,
-0.3313121498,
-0.5015866756,
-0.3768899739,
-0.4767112434,
-0.4335431457,
0.8578898311,
0.0301592052,
0.681204319,
0.6950721741,
0.7250993252,
0.2619713843,
-0.5821784735,
0.5971831083,
-0.559427917,
0.268797487,
-0.3321019411,
-0.3933593929,
-0.3039521873,
0.0652677789,
0.8380171061,
0.6473200917,
-0.2261606157,
0.1844224334,
-0.1752082705,
0.8825801015,
-0.2705403566,
-0.1260303855,
-0.6428486705,
-0.0372859538,
-0.350417465,
-0.0346499309,
-0.5489479303,
-0.3661253154,
0.1759073585,
-0.3381156623,
0.6592965126,
-0.2056758106,
1.0641719103,
0.223097682,
-0.4340673089,
-0.4241618812,
-0.7859074473,
0.6663665771,
-0.5395740867,
0.1712347716,
0.3693107069,
0.2330174893,
-0.2636550367,
-1.1491771936,
-0.4061615169,
0.0092850449,
-0.2279541194,
0.149741143,
-0.3816605508,
-0.2332981825,
0.8204381466,
0.6052233577,
-0.7714726925,
-0.0919221863,
-0.6965209246,
0.2800805271,
0.4929682016,
0.052777268,
-0.059447486,
-0.2649378181,
-0.3285509348,
0.1106749997,
-0.4703514576,
-0.4559533894,
0.1954871863,
-0.2021556348,
0.0360834859,
0.601657629,
0.0048249462,
0.6623756886,
0.0318056419,
0.1373807788,
0.1102209538,
-0.1434062868,
-0.2563651502,
-0.1170521677,
0.584469676,
0.0849216431,
0.037750341,
-0.19493936,
-0.3327408135,
-0.0101380758,
0.5253289938,
-1.076805234,
-0.3588094711,
-0.1964875311,
-0.6575858593,
-0.0486490242,
0.1101209819,
-0.836651504,
-0.5373948216,
-0.1565276235,
0.4072676897,
-0.7453337908,
0.0015417009,
0.1228261739,
-0.4651235044,
0.0027026911,
0.264071852,
-0.8476605415,
0.1012031958,
0.76312536,
1.443547368,
-0.2388663441,
-0.2646153867,
-0.4903140962,
0.0676489472,
-0.5676939487,
0.9024272561,
-0.4582484066,
-0.5639639497,
-0.2925537229,
0.2821231484,
-0.0346544087,
-0.7560647726,
0.5482426286,
-0.5700775385,
0.1993261576,
-0.116319187,
-0.6894503236,
-0.4985290468,
-0.0410071984,
-0.9862800837,
1.1651347876,
0.5982277989,
-0.5224320292,
0.0842650011,
-0.4206796288,
-0.702452898,
0.0052822581,
-0.0831009969,
-0.7760774493,
0.4899475276,
0.0116047766,
0.4702757895,
-0.812782824,
0.4419080317,
-0.0103902677,
-0.9117693901,
0.3045655191,
-0.8910608292,
0.7944961786,
0.2650595903,
-0.5591638088,
0.0052579278,
-0.8196319938,
-0.4681228995,
0.0176772196,
-0.5817298293,
-0.0891088396,
-0.1536875069,
-0.1468639076,
-0.0911761299,
0.1856304407,
-0.420401901,
0.3459779024,
-0.3032834232,
0.6299071312,
0.7778523564,
-0.2892588377,
0.1887674928,
-0.5759860277,
0.3695451021,
0.2148180306,
-0.236558497,
-0.7497421503,
-0.4477238655,
-0.7843818069,
-0.2638527453,
0.3122810423,
0.1674503833,
-0.6590594649,
0.4723762572,
-0.3192130029,
-0.7948032022,
-0.5664244294,
0.0413803346,
0.0907240808,
0.3471718132,
0.6101362109,
-0.6001694798,
-0.5066985488,
-0.8413820863,
-0.1072361693,
0.0994251296,
-0.3322595954,
0.2514809668,
0.351269722,
-0.5943001509,
0.562210083,
-0.4252058566,
-0.1873003244,
-0.157222271,
0.717233479,
0.8536412716,
0.2254354954,
0.3190610707,
-0.7551676631,
-0.3315187395,
0.1768295616,
-0.906041801,
0.081023626,
-0.3967094719,
0.2153131962,
0.542129159,
0.307759732,
-1.1730438471,
0.6371548176,
0.4347604811,
-0.1500489861,
0.3447564542,
-0.383801043,
0.0407069102,
-0.9718108773,
0.3212830722,
-0.0929082036,
-0.2504571676,
-0.3238380253,
-0.040336296,
0.4327200055,
-0.1608695388,
-0.0386717469,
0.2463949323,
-0.8123595119,
-0.1815228909,
-0.539277792,
-0.0942524523,
0.0450360402,
0.2020653635,
0.0361702405,
0.9835999608,
0.3741018474,
-0.4155398309,
0.719206512,
-0.0498957038,
-0.78748101,
0.3109958172,
-0.6138653159,
0.246779561,
-0.2514363527,
0.3330934942,
-0.8670759797,
0.0046246229,
-0.2246681452,
-0.3524993956,
0.4534099996,
-0.2912239134,
-0.4362122118,
-0.5074231625,
-0.0714772567,
0.398290664,
0.8322306871,
-0.6318047643,
0.8379453421,
0.0069570541,
-0.0458589345,
-0.5743018985,
-0.4536448419,
0.1969285756,
-0.4403238297,
-0.3521723151,
0.5214263797,
0.1729293764,
0.2672546208,
-0.0899169967,
-0.1526722014,
0.2033896595,
0.0275101997,
0.2979432046,
0.2160749286,
-0.3363863528,
0.0828830153,
-0.1937571615,
-0.3974053264,
-0.0159883499,
-0.2277840972,
0.6699869633,
0.0152633125,
0.0125095621,
-0.1250706464,
0.3731130958,
0.562482357,
-0.0531348735,
0.5763662457,
0.7310256362,
-0.3017659187,
-0.322234869,
-0.6623539925,
0.0412154645,
-0.4885675609,
0.5069756508,
-0.3996684551,
-0.8909680843,
0.4496519566,
-0.509524107,
-0.2355487496,
0.4987359643,
0.5161018968,
-0.0466362238,
0.5628941655,
0.4117308855,
-0.2899944484,
0.1724795401,
-0.3746875525,
0.3838433027,
-0.8150804639,
-0.0153995249,
-0.1853724718,
-0.4018452168,
-0.7363132834,
-0.7119591236,
0.4382332861,
0.0617976785,
-0.2227891982,
0.6996029019,
-0.6942691207,
0.4347583652,
0.6587388515,
0.1566796005,
0.1640240699,
-0.1763836145,
0.0867497921,
0.2707242072,
-0.5536431074,
-0.2645908892,
0.9274975061,
0.412514478,
0.8279956579,
0.1215348318,
0.4680641294,
0.0924585611,
0.3803400993,
-0.8437379003,
0.4986465275,
-0.5646723509,
-0.5654690266,
-0.507165432,
-0.3693751097,
-1.2851377726,
0.0699409917,
0.2369119078,
-0.3690472245,
0.1145953014,
-0.2581044734,
-0.2706894577,
0.4702249169,
-0.2979981303,
0.5680568814,
-0.0616105236,
-0.3335898817,
-0.4172183573,
-0.7084344625,
0.3083376586,
-0.1462298632,
-0.1596042216,
-0.117017962,
0.163815394,
0.6299933791,
-0.1326414943,
0.4671676457,
0.1626725495,
0.1396854222,
0.3619303107,
0.1086136922,
0.5718676448,
-0.262306422,
-0.3092621565,
0.5333893895,
-0.1040663645,
-0.2511937916,
-0.451441884,
0.5924280882,
-0.5441234112,
-0.6598412395,
-0.8113127947,
-0.3858023584,
0.2737230062,
0.1433759928,
0.5110955238,
0.4323564768,
0.0827711672,
0.6054535508,
0.8068462014,
-0.2564755678,
0.7646975517,
0.3747656047,
0.0045563015,
-0.3283891678,
0.6695992351,
0.4136559963,
-0.0556843132,
0.308550328,
0.2003626376,
-0.1507374942,
-0.5243834853,
-0.7236589193,
0.4136176407,
-0.590036869,
-0.6287685037,
-0.6247060299,
-0.6572124362,
-0.1572450697,
0.1347984374,
-0.4401638508,
-0.2094759047,
-0.2880181372,
-0.2622834444,
0.6550047398,
1.0182527304,
-0.0650372878,
0.3087361753,
-1.001875639,
0.4668812454,
0.2233683914,
0.5446078181,
0.2964173555,
-0.8274982572,
-0.5414363146,
-0.3996443152,
-0.5426325202,
-0.76116997,
0.4426208436,
-0.1797878444,
0.2626955211,
0.1439007223,
-0.2283456326,
0.8224534392,
-0.8209958076,
0.7405585051,
0.1156084538,
-0.7588852644,
0.332983911,
-0.4428155422,
0.4076169729,
0.1767403334,
0.6081084013,
-0.7824319601,
0.1135256961,
-0.693688035,
-0.8402762413,
0.6075103879,
0.1705907881,
0.1535078287,
-0.3931241035,
0.449175328,
0.3694946766,
-0.0256003588,
-0.3877183795,
-0.1208237857,
-0.0670301691,
-0.0833976269,
-0.1128392965,
-0.6427986026,
0.1575223655,
-0.0723735839,
0.5009447336,
0.1791523695,
0.4537817538,
0.2302641124,
0.0287942477,
-0.1036010757,
0.0246461295,
0.5784144402,
0.8277631998,
-0.2043256164,
0.3650739491,
0.2049812227,
-0.5191092491,
0.1242234036,
0.3487482369,
-0.1900310367,
0.5052754879,
0.410497725,
0.7733410597,
0.1538487971,
-0.4944224656,
0.2894609272,
0.0507131219,
-0.0440213941,
-0.4836221337,
0.0587737858,
0.2861951292,
0.1206119135,
0.5708008409,
-0.1341755688,
0.1762522757,
-0.7671191096,
0.526755631,
0.2329086214,
-0.2287991643,
-0.2991536558,
0.5530606508,
-0.0045921993,
-0.4902097285,
0.9974164367,
-0.0238899309,
-0.3413525224,
0.5966126919,
0.6322894692,
0.7642201185,
-0.3394395113,
-0.0090111177,
0.6078779697,
0.0524900965,
-0.4849009812,
-0.0911033303,
-0.0339991152,
-0.5241656303,
-0.4181743562,
-0.5897992849,
-0.1491084546,
0.467923522,
-0.6370314956,
0.3923636377,
-0.3805965483,
-0.2011029422,
0.2135506719,
-0.1574836671,
-0.5708453059,
0.2442525476,
-0.1465549171,
0.7537480593,
-0.4853334129,
1.0381637812,
0.2705081999,
-0.2875834405,
-0.6271035075,
-0.312474668,
-0.2490765303,
-0.684297204,
0.493981123,
0.584880352,
0.0715816915,
-0.2044890821,
-0.151420325,
-0.8265534043,
1.2984621525,
0.0610787012,
-0.9254575968,
-0.2330692559,
0.0313672535,
0.5567732453,
-0.0471302457,
0.4466371536,
0.9749504924,
0.366487056,
-0.0196590368,
-0.8316536546,
0.044272095,
-0.2006866634,
0.0793120861,
0.5297640562,
-0.8018226027,
0.9615822434,
0.0361352861,
-0.360788852,
0.5394223332,
0.6228535771,
0.3474717438,
0.5788226128,
0.2196852416,
0.7345056534,
0.8550418615,
0.0369813144,
1.0172543526,
-0.0156237036,
0.3213914931,
1.0547604561,
-0.2478344142,
0.5715690851,
0.3126240075,
-0.3051032424,
0.6175681949,
0.6810592413,
-0.3087891638,
0.4526224732,
0.3040822446,
-0.4490053058,
0.0305691361,
0.1614936888,
-0.305054307,
0.2888759673,
0.3051281273,
-0.6892700195,
-0.1552765965,
-0.2387020439,
0.0134549048,
0.2560876608,
-0.1016968489,
0.8931882977,
0.3715063632,
-0.8242208362,
0.5326451063,
0.1816970408,
0.7497660518,
-0.3692452312,
-0.2746006548,
-0.5450692177,
0.2414262444,
0.0372363813,
-0.7813726664,
0.4794251025,
0.1012839824,
-0.410071373,
-0.0447061472,
0.7605587244,
-0.3662959933,
-0.570825398,
0.3525420725,
0.2084431499,
0.33730793,
0.0090402737,
-0.2971725166,
-0.0694377646,
-0.1193869933,
-0.4033172727,
0.2364775985,
0.9410402179,
-0.0651169792,
0.5290833116,
0.4985504448,
0.1665166616,
-0.0476974733,
0.0244511645,
0.7823493481,
-1.0920760632,
-0.0854042619,
-1.0805212259,
0.2542697787,
-0.1303965747,
-0.2988127768,
0.4725061059,
0.9443908334,
0.8479303122,
-0.2277109027,
0.6766750813,
0.1020779237,
0.9083146453,
-0.4612439573,
0.6499142051,
-0.2044289261,
0.2381830364,
0.1592363119,
-1.0472420454,
-0.1299666166,
0.8502441049,
-0.0502938554,
-0.0063359626,
0.8775278926,
0.7035490274,
-0.1484642178,
0.0898316577,
0.4423078299,
0.0575103536,
0.2744522393,
0.6826995015,
0.8771697283,
-0.670014739,
0.3995442092,
-0.125891,
0.0189514607,
-0.0435884148,
-0.9316092134,
-0.9735193253,
-0.6252374649,
0.1672295034,
-0.2572399974,
0.2590971589,
0.5817442536,
0.5595284104,
-0.4992065728,
-0.2384775132,
-0.1932875067,
0.1305679977,
-0.2831570804,
-0.1928163469,
0.6106256843,
-0.2330922782,
-0.6553435922,
0.4816373587,
0.4298513234,
0.054327812,
0.1114660427,
0.1057520434,
-0.098062627,
-0.0256329682,
0.6653296351,
-0.0679208189,
-0.5425790548,
-0.3604310453,
-0.0137455268,
0.0504618362,
0.2567250431,
0.9220845699,
-0.8987609744,
0.4044436812,
0.3272066116,
0.8298650384,
1.0316909552,
0.2899729908,
0.5804775953,
-0.4311466515,
0.0507826693,
0.3273158967,
0.2616768181,
0.4423051178,
-0.4126135409,
1.0509436131,
0.3169927299,
-0.8552063704,
-0.789368391,
-0.0503515601,
-1.0183359385,
-0.4979703128,
1.0532691479,
-0.3397500813,
-0.1086352989,
0.0517421737,
-0.0871956572,
0.5146254897,
-0.1666460484,
1.1283502579,
0.7842903733,
-0.1541555077,
-0.4183791578,
-0.3690968156,
0.4509572387,
0.4774141014,
-0.3576291203,
0.2066164166,
0.3758010864,
0.1399281025,
0.2631214261,
0.4445254505,
-0.2220941782,
0.5330621004,
0.0177818108,
-0.3612617254,
-0.091351293,
-0.5146906376,
-0.4567964375,
0.0434954949,
-0.0850223303,
0.1111898422
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10787v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10787v1
|
EdgeQAT: Entropy and Distribution Guided Quantization-Aware Training for the Acceleration of Lightweight LLMs on the Edge
| 2024-02-16T16:10:38 | 2024-02-16T16:10:38 |
Xuan Shen, Zhenglun Kong, Changdi Yang, Zhaoyang Han, Lei Lu, Peiyan Dong, Cheng Lyu, Chih-hsiang Li, Xuehang Guo, Zhihao Shu, Wei Niu, Miriam Leeser, Pu Zhao, Yanzhi Wang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Despite the remarkable strides of Large Language Models (LLMs) in various
fields, the wide applications of LLMs on edge devices are limited due to their
massive parameters and computations. To address this, quantization is commonly
adopted to generate lightweight LLMs with efficient computations and fast
inference. However, Post-Training Quantization (PTQ) methods dramatically
degrade in quality when quantizing weights, activations, and KV cache together
to below 8 bits. Besides, many Quantization-Aware Training (QAT) works quantize
model weights, leaving the activations untouched, which do not fully exploit
the potential of quantization for inference acceleration on the edge. In this
paper, we propose EdgeQAT, the Entropy and Distribution Guided QAT for the
optimization of lightweight LLMs to achieve inference acceleration on Edge
devices. We first identify that the performance drop of quantization primarily
stems from the information distortion in quantized attention maps, demonstrated
by the different distributions in quantized query and key of the self-attention
mechanism. Then, the entropy and distribution guided QAT is proposed to
mitigate the information distortion. Moreover, we design a token
importance-aware adaptive method to dynamically quantize the tokens with
different bit widths for further optimization and acceleration. Our extensive
experiments verify the substantial improvements with our framework across
various datasets. Furthermore, we achieve an on-device speedup of up to 2.37x
compared with its FP16 counterparts across multiple edge devices, signaling a
groundbreaking advancement.
|
[
-0.1831644177,
-0.6245109439,
0.4631492496,
0.0183673222,
-0.5968504548,
-0.0233416352,
0.0718111768,
-0.1631496549,
0.1611979604,
0.1361913979,
-0.5019850135,
-0.4706100225,
-0.6522712111,
-0.4101724625,
-0.2152205259,
0.7593384981,
0.0230129901,
0.042468559,
-0.2196169049,
-0.4096532166,
-0.0700485632,
-0.1805806905,
-0.879142642,
-0.0595106333,
0.1396905184,
0.1712043285,
0.757361114,
0.8654435873,
0.3834405541,
0.2327306569,
-0.116554983,
-0.1486187279,
-0.3810651302,
0.2700225413,
0.2399259508,
-0.416513741,
-0.6676232815,
-0.5665591955,
0.5781364441,
0.2194540501,
-0.1115222424,
0.2969700098,
0.0917085335,
0.7572727799,
-0.9472876787,
-0.335958302,
-0.5178343654,
-0.052234482,
-0.2327755541,
-0.1425118148,
0.0686416328,
-0.3989183903,
0.0564359501,
-0.6293908358,
-0.0198274851,
-0.0395188369,
0.3525637984,
0.7128069401,
-0.6080484986,
-0.0236487221,
-0.4635585845,
0.59674716,
-0.5782446265,
0.9701094031,
0.0825690553,
0.0827397779,
0.0937334001,
-1.1187850237,
-0.2509983778,
0.2979539931,
0.7156425118,
0.1704328209,
-0.2488321662,
0.3231272399,
0.0855082199,
0.2959500253,
-0.640761137,
0.2213250995,
0.0921519771,
-0.2912496626,
0.3462873399,
0.0374505594,
0.2234334052,
0.2949070334,
-0.5934289694,
-0.2705030143,
-0.9289264679,
0.1979153603,
0.2219746113,
-0.1002245545,
-0.071730271,
0.0585152097,
-0.6379520297,
0.5043930411,
0.0962669551,
-0.2484880239,
0.2818078399,
-0.1945297867,
-0.1155649871,
0.4106242955,
0.7279137373,
0.3027338386,
-0.2572078109,
0.0510329083,
-0.3686853349,
-0.4117669165,
-0.2885021567,
-1.2972990274,
-0.2870683968,
0.4252429605,
-0.4748564363,
0.0935954005,
-0.4133041799,
-0.5388940573,
-0.3917443454,
0.1326206326,
0.7716885805,
-0.4744473398,
-0.3702865839,
0.1675545275,
-0.3410770893,
0.307133913,
0.2732734084,
-1.0155310631,
0.2325582951,
0.544636488,
0.9601153135,
-0.0881328434,
0.0458084829,
-0.7048734426,
0.091280818,
-0.1675470024,
0.6740953922,
-0.3599148989,
-0.0967844576,
-0.1420852989,
-0.465334475,
0.1391156465,
-0.2673365176,
0.820329845,
-0.6320269704,
-0.3008178473,
-0.2271360159,
-0.490293324,
-0.0837512463,
0.0525609367,
-0.5749429464,
1.2157728672,
0.0158970859,
-0.9462809563,
0.5265532732,
-0.7188391089,
-0.3347050548,
0.2901458442,
0.0186477285,
-0.5897387266,
0.279425174,
0.4843656123,
0.3337275088,
-0.2181961685,
0.0475085899,
-0.4042588174,
-0.5114243031,
0.0427943915,
-0.602152288,
0.7496655583,
0.192489326,
-0.6435467005,
0.1924115419,
-0.6743817925,
0.3750529885,
-0.0520713516,
-0.1473726779,
-0.6565297842,
0.0586094335,
-0.1203327999,
-0.0075244694,
0.3114953637,
-0.4753125012,
0.0988844931,
-0.1839154661,
0.6453052759,
0.8721750379,
0.0305721201,
0.5021247864,
0.1207704917,
0.5602081418,
-0.1359739602,
0.2597620487,
0.0300499108,
-0.3470318019,
-0.5512053967,
-0.5943341851,
0.5710368156,
0.5392912626,
-0.9810096025,
0.1968381554,
-0.5614851117,
-0.3974254429,
-0.715986371,
0.1746041328,
0.0974454507,
0.1761757284,
0.1979767382,
-0.1133824214,
-0.2385304421,
-0.6183934808,
-0.5712163448,
-0.0706687793,
-0.2491377592,
0.0259205271,
0.1665837169,
-0.2099730521,
0.8086233735,
-0.2727982402,
0.0195457377,
-0.0867295563,
0.0983057395,
-0.2844739854,
0.540440321,
0.290741384,
-0.8022099137,
-0.2334442139,
-0.1222266704,
-0.2822648585,
-0.2980742157,
0.0242159721,
-0.1904102564,
-0.2136564553,
0.4723929167,
-0.5285039544,
0.2885196805,
0.6492298245,
-0.1492308676,
0.1881260425,
0.131695509,
-0.0441959836,
-1.1631240845,
-0.3388137817,
-0.0445346162,
-0.443138063,
-0.429100275,
-0.0227665734,
0.2773247361,
-0.044144582,
-0.6365565062,
0.747048974,
-0.3835458159,
-0.1494961977,
-0.3292841315,
0.0919543132,
-0.0203259941,
0.4057748914,
-0.0627002567,
0.7900652289,
0.8956025243,
-0.8410446048,
0.298723042,
-0.1453454345,
-0.0579171367,
0.7612911463,
-0.6164019108,
-0.0338045657,
0.1076571643,
0.1135618687,
-0.7943561077,
0.1715986431,
0.0789823905,
-0.3395079672,
-0.061074499,
-0.23319529,
-0.5970160365,
-0.0054609883,
-0.6069092155,
0.8596735597,
0.8187814951,
-0.6934362054,
0.7494183183,
0.184192583,
-0.0368276387,
-0.4932651818,
-0.5882764459,
-0.1271580756,
-0.616016984,
-0.7034775019,
0.4388710856,
-0.0800554082,
-0.1780716777,
-0.1016930938,
-0.391336292,
-0.0884759277,
0.3372861445,
0.2593471408,
-0.5451359749,
-0.2474201769,
0.544202745,
0.4519150853,
0.0179190636,
0.0054301256,
-0.9396468997,
0.3359520137,
-0.2230411321,
-0.3386655152,
-0.628483355,
-0.0680149496,
0.3186866641,
-0.2348772585,
0.3265295625,
1.1979342699,
-0.4143232405,
-0.2762579322,
-0.348903805,
-0.3282154799,
-0.6044688821,
0.3883253336,
-0.5571773648,
-0.9657880068,
0.5161476135,
-0.5662184358,
-0.1012610272,
0.4351998866,
0.6030867696,
-0.0653564632,
1.0007519722,
0.64332968,
0.1204289794,
0.9296492338,
-0.2252916843,
0.0093373619,
-1.0318951607,
0.1806666106,
-0.1814487427,
-0.507130444,
-0.6633887887,
-0.3208269179,
0.6229911447,
0.2149277627,
-0.2406276762,
-0.1251725852,
-0.5415979624,
0.2634221315,
0.8304906487,
0.307153374,
0.2098734975,
0.0228707641,
-0.0029438797,
0.0682397336,
-0.9228726625,
0.0188583881,
1.1269193888,
0.3512330353,
1.0015922785,
0.0308810212,
0.752191484,
0.4174936414,
-0.0343734287,
-0.7095117569,
0.4833216965,
0.1867398769,
-0.1350159496,
-0.4053008854,
-0.6391996741,
-0.7261957526,
0.1867080778,
0.2124449313,
-0.5771018267,
0.2944435775,
0.2066464871,
-0.3816001117,
0.3166725934,
-0.6649814844,
0.9858474135,
-0.5531050563,
-0.407600075,
-0.1598132104,
-0.5309711099,
0.2790099382,
0.089803569,
-0.0616758801,
-0.1732623577,
-0.4328330755,
1.0839003325,
-0.6795890331,
0.7004616857,
-0.4165069759,
-0.0994618014,
0.5160942078,
0.0821680948,
0.710906446,
0.2436248213,
0.0522744209,
0.03153136,
-0.0341632739,
-0.6440742612,
-0.67518121,
0.4564913213,
-0.6803069711,
-0.5267495513,
-0.1024626121,
-0.5184720755,
-0.1735450029,
0.2774465978,
0.3580289483,
0.6040741801,
0.0638255551,
0.1993015409,
0.9614629745,
0.1214152426,
0.5918182731,
0.2366631925,
0.1872000396,
-0.5186262727,
1.0917313099,
0.0981206968,
0.5192046762,
0.4914006293,
0.2838257253,
-0.4941893816,
-1.0385469198,
-0.7290450931,
-0.2757409513,
-0.7507306337,
-0.4523441792,
-0.7966507077,
0.119134821,
-0.3972199559,
-0.0267663319,
-0.6066348553,
-0.7245568633,
-0.1963581294,
-0.1225835904,
0.9152680635,
0.2440837175,
-0.250623256,
1.1001343727,
-0.5015769601,
0.1839093268,
0.4431942403,
0.3229057193,
-0.1092477813,
-0.7247236967,
-0.476734221,
0.2204717994,
-0.4882732928,
-0.5596007705,
0.1332703829,
0.5177470446,
0.2509922981,
0.6804520488,
0.3450662196,
0.7216944695,
-0.0592460856,
0.6163857579,
-0.0109833516,
-1.2261531353,
0.3947189748,
-0.1431971043,
0.497100383,
0.4573097825,
0.3271738887,
-0.4194736481,
-0.3138949871,
-0.6152364612,
-1.0069149733,
0.2151836902,
0.0148534365,
0.1322597414,
0.3725323677,
0.3188171685,
-0.0367008708,
0.1677373052,
-0.6425383687,
0.0464132279,
-0.309228301,
-0.4354034066,
0.5243391395,
-0.1397417337,
0.1054379717,
-0.0150917266,
0.5834595561,
-0.4637692273,
0.2844012678,
0.3635825813,
-0.2582451105,
0.0621729083,
0.0921878219,
0.3551500142,
0.4862813652,
-0.1009814665,
0.296138376,
0.2914824486,
-0.6866545081,
0.1462923586,
0.1971902996,
-0.2209895849,
-0.1254566312,
0.1221036538,
1.0731158257,
-0.043992281,
-0.6278777719,
0.5365254283,
-0.181034863,
0.0361631438,
0.0015020568,
-0.0147039648,
0.088318117,
0.5234770775,
0.6876240373,
-0.2655321062,
0.5752724409,
-0.211987868,
0.3273268342,
0.7914937735,
-0.4508465528,
-0.3307700753,
0.8303876519,
0.2461246252,
-0.1359096467,
0.3967528343,
-0.448508352,
-0.5946345925,
0.5063718557,
0.3687834442,
1.2000855207,
-0.3349600136,
-0.0515384786,
-0.0593676865,
0.4215666056,
0.0349385627,
0.4330754876,
-0.3594275117,
-0.5541771054,
-0.3918006122,
-0.6059678197,
-0.311018914,
-0.2782840729,
-0.3464382887,
0.0983527154,
-0.3082259595,
-0.2712073326,
-0.5798881054,
-0.038504757,
-0.6547724009,
0.3759343028,
-0.0120861176,
0.687174499,
-0.7174978852,
0.727006793,
0.364638865,
0.194224,
-0.4999237061,
0.2242180258,
-0.3108082414,
-0.9538123608,
0.4406056702,
0.0290792789,
-0.1124060825,
0.53336972,
-0.4221161604,
-0.9618658423,
1.4093617201,
0.2546102405,
-0.2555610538,
0.2384660095,
0.1106429026,
0.3545720577,
-0.1813586354,
0.5582559109,
0.2283990383,
0.1817157567,
0.1119759008,
-0.6009332538,
0.2443829626,
0.1030533835,
0.0814179778,
0.3853754699,
-0.7365359664,
0.6663488746,
-0.1636742204,
-0.2382337153,
-0.1371819973,
0.8143494725,
0.2473918349,
0.4628379047,
0.4356085956,
0.7998805046,
0.7241725326,
0.0121822301,
0.8016655445,
-0.3586879373,
0.145306766,
0.6495957375,
-0.0314776003,
0.7109289169,
0.4537833035,
0.0521670245,
0.241522029,
1.1317328215,
0.4999763966,
0.6923404336,
0.2013492286,
-0.5052511096,
-0.1408128887,
-0.2267119288,
-0.4047920108,
0.1120882779,
0.4916652739,
-0.111468114,
-0.184462592,
0.2943100631,
-0.1540270001,
-0.6103201509,
-0.6717050672,
0.6901787519,
0.1691302359,
-0.0247585867,
0.785826087,
0.1513547003,
0.69258219,
-0.4240522981,
0.1662206203,
-0.3464584351,
0.0697495341,
-0.1876337528,
-0.4689490497,
-0.2030806243,
-0.3213146925,
0.2384309471,
-0.299061209,
0.7611313462,
-0.1859540045,
-0.4529415667,
-0.0856989771,
0.6237957478,
0.1637045443,
-0.4723573029,
-0.6566743851,
0.2959662974,
-0.121138975,
-0.5897805095,
0.545266211,
0.9556353688,
-0.2166167945,
1.0283544064,
0.5442222357,
-0.1466907263,
0.4764135182,
-0.2901584208,
0.924873054,
-0.5266968012,
-0.6560139656,
-1.015920043,
0.3945197761,
0.2261755466,
-0.3683825731,
0.6336875558,
0.5371237993,
0.5470574498,
0.4648857415,
0.7330146432,
0.0223951023,
-0.1070172042,
-0.7513283491,
0.405759275,
-0.7808690071,
0.2007220834,
0.0622679256,
-0.9517136812,
-0.0799506903,
0.1522408277,
-0.1319538355,
0.2265069336,
0.5380538106,
0.4453705549,
-0.0998930186,
-0.2461470664,
0.2779121995,
0.0512143746,
0.2214630246,
0.6859532595,
0.5262587667,
-0.7030925155,
0.7214035988,
-0.1140650213,
-0.1909340024,
-0.3344612718,
-0.7658740878,
-0.5826739073,
-0.4502231181,
-0.5181156397,
-0.1606434733,
0.4197123647,
0.6194870472,
0.8021082878,
-0.1981596798,
0.1521548927,
-0.3016371429,
0.3781560659,
-0.3923764229,
-0.2305850238,
0.6496941447,
-0.1601669192,
-0.6459878087,
0.2198330313,
0.2448948473,
0.203720808,
-0.1637303531,
-0.1724334657,
0.2833792865,
-0.0737452209,
0.3976069391,
0.2102167308,
-0.3852155805,
-0.0614752248,
-0.0615363307,
-0.0854869485,
0.1759498566,
0.6829101443,
-1.0111486912,
0.3345634639,
0.6336551905,
0.9420297742,
0.4950515926,
0.3011992276,
0.4265451729,
-0.7392327189,
0.2042199075,
0.4368346035,
0.1079132184,
0.2585606873,
-0.4246072769,
0.2593613267,
0.26365152,
-0.6737392545,
-1.013805747,
0.2521511912,
-0.837433219,
-0.0746926144,
1.1210412979,
0.0669252723,
-0.5265496373,
0.2040327638,
0.165233165,
0.2177461684,
-0.6060603857,
0.4632886946,
0.1645004004,
-0.204095915,
-0.6495698094,
-0.6046727896,
0.7214744091,
0.5777073503,
-0.6696301103,
-0.0035983282,
-0.0034781673,
0.2598885894,
-0.299134165,
0.7386369109,
0.3326607347,
0.3929185271,
0.2331279814,
0.4887992442,
0.161097154,
-0.00618672,
-0.3990468085,
-0.1046131998,
0.3871320784,
-0.4871577024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10779v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10779v1
|
A Condensed Transition Graph Framework for Zero-shot Link Prediction with Large Language Models
| 2024-02-16T16:02:33 | 2024-02-16T16:02:33 |
Mingchen Li, Chen Ling, Rui Zhang, Liang Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Zero-shot link prediction (ZSLP) on knowledge graphs aims at automatically
identifying relations between given entities. Existing methods primarily employ
auxiliary information to predict tail entity given head entity and its
relation, yet face challenges due to the occasional unavailability of such
detailed information and the inherent simplicity of predicting tail entities
based on semantic similarities. Even though Large Language Models (LLMs) offer
a promising solution to predict unobserved relations between the head and tail
entity in a zero-shot manner, their performance is still restricted due to the
inability to leverage all the (exponentially many) paths' information between
two entities, which are critical in collectively indicating their relation
types. To address this, in this work, we introduce a Condensed Transition Graph
Framework for Zero-Shot Link Prediction (CTLP), which encodes all the paths'
information in linear time complexity to predict unseen relations between
entities, attaining both efficiency and information preservation. Specifically,
we design a condensed transition graph encoder with theoretical guarantees on
its coverage, expressiveness, and efficiency. It is learned by a transition
graph contrastive learning strategy. Subsequently, we design a soft instruction
tuning to learn and map the all-path embedding to the input of LLMs.
Experimental results show that our proposed CTLP method achieves
state-of-the-art performance on three standard ZSLP datasets
|
[
0.0051716324,
-0.4829731584,
0.7047069073,
-0.2920732796,
-0.4293575883,
0.1675620526,
-0.310772121,
-0.5001643896,
0.0948605537,
0.4120563865,
-0.7953420877,
-0.9334068894,
-0.3703101873,
-0.1621942371,
-0.0977659822,
0.9031147957,
0.1593068689,
-0.0913134366,
0.3148500919,
-0.0090815742,
-0.1950997412,
-0.0699043423,
-0.4891032577,
-0.5553900003,
0.4590308666,
0.1894487739,
0.6473082304,
0.7970489264,
0.0102104582,
0.1288594902,
-0.087667942,
0.1168547794,
-0.6736020446,
0.3185330927,
-0.1283041239,
-0.3987196684,
-0.2557667792,
-0.4575748146,
0.7175274491,
0.9220322371,
-0.0257238448,
0.0705780312,
0.0518717393,
0.5648849607,
-0.8546996117,
0.5398807526,
-1.0471484661,
0.3609022796,
-0.2808566689,
-0.2919179797,
-0.7398257852,
-0.0327017196,
-0.0166400634,
-0.4858046472,
0.2093709111,
0.0712904856,
0.7670611143,
0.0019410159,
-0.5749433041,
0.0124931755,
-0.8487920165,
0.44024387,
-0.6449512243,
0.6886883974,
-0.1861715466,
0.3401875496,
-0.3533630371,
-0.5509519577,
-0.4049809873,
-0.1886255443,
0.0156524517,
0.1137654036,
-0.0085693123,
0.5103735924,
0.1195533425,
0.0644432902,
-0.6540219784,
0.0635160431,
-0.3015074432,
-0.1076895669,
0.2462493479,
0.3497894108,
0.1828756034,
0.0887603015,
-0.1899009198,
0.0049333279,
-0.8441457748,
-0.1894672364,
0.1329219192,
0.733422339,
-0.2248939723,
0.4588870704,
-0.2290159464,
1.0051480532,
0.2738516033,
-0.0565042682,
0.3200433552,
0.0187476501,
-0.2954615355,
0.3023860753,
0.8173485398,
0.2635566294,
0.251583308,
-0.5795093775,
0.1858349442,
0.148925364,
-0.1809786856,
-0.9520409107,
-0.132608071,
0.0638019666,
-0.0452483334,
0.0564299747,
-0.1256062984,
-0.4409721494,
-0.2224783152,
0.0078763869,
0.0956595317,
-0.7976027727,
-0.1852741688,
0.3673435152,
0.018651953,
0.3883497715,
0.4520021379,
-0.6807274818,
0.351572156,
0.5917802453,
1.0218629837,
0.159735024,
-0.3438829482,
-0.6577801108,
0.8741544485,
-0.4170311689,
0.4742335081,
-0.6986723542,
-0.2828792036,
0.2877957523,
-0.0645191893,
-0.192481041,
0.0455891229,
0.4321741462,
-0.5946857929,
-0.3080512285,
0.2464647591,
-0.8684208393,
-0.1016539261,
0.2565670907,
-0.756839335,
0.2049895078,
0.0586954802,
-0.8438254595,
0.0672249049,
-0.3586502075,
-0.6011782289,
0.2239741087,
-0.4002275467,
-0.3053553998,
-0.1349404007,
-0.1164168641,
0.4230686128,
-0.3000227809,
0.0964193568,
-0.7473093271,
-0.4075549245,
-0.1329461634,
-0.0512401499,
0.6455554366,
0.0705178604,
-0.0621694066,
0.0124081094,
-0.7357473373,
0.1600975692,
0.086274527,
-0.1630494893,
-0.2143943161,
-0.0408054627,
-0.3250468373,
0.4020151198,
0.1994880438,
-0.8147103786,
0.2737899125,
-0.469622463,
0.3679715693,
0.730666101,
0.105471395,
0.6797004938,
0.1344987601,
0.5244984627,
0.2537495792,
0.0049977815,
-0.3048706353,
-0.4069030881,
-0.7177585959,
0.4528960288,
0.2768378854,
0.2391410321,
-0.8589725494,
0.3832275271,
-0.425578177,
-0.583563447,
-0.2775635421,
0.1191443875,
0.4697945118,
0.9376571774,
0.3820930123,
-0.148114115,
-0.4436862469,
-0.6005968451,
0.0512950793,
-0.2750604153,
-0.0699169859,
0.3957303762,
0.1732513011,
0.0985470265,
0.7386103272,
-1.0750701427,
-0.4377044737,
-0.4009310007,
0.0666240677,
0.3606623113,
0.3404497504,
0.3918699324,
-0.4257801473,
-0.6279349327,
-0.086316362,
-0.5159834027,
0.3139390051,
-0.0668784305,
-0.2616763711,
0.0014343902,
0.4221815765,
-0.6696951985,
0.0460678823,
0.4667013884,
-0.3500993252,
0.4642174542,
-0.102048561,
-0.2595788538,
-0.7325025201,
-0.0523687266,
0.2729170024,
-0.026769409,
-0.7653023601,
-0.0050925543,
0.3249530494,
-0.3484128714,
-0.5579852462,
0.4513878226,
-0.49467659,
0.0074420841,
0.2074928433,
0.1688529104,
-0.080051519,
0.7156214118,
0.425103724,
0.3705910444,
0.6324527264,
-0.4563376009,
-0.0930378065,
0.2716589272,
0.0106213782,
0.3879370987,
-0.5488801003,
0.2869002521,
-0.355373323,
0.5119171739,
-0.7645343542,
0.1581315994,
0.174884811,
-0.5046024323,
0.6978495717,
-0.6103615165,
-0.4483441114,
-0.0810497254,
-0.4377402365,
0.2785185874,
0.4816003442,
0.0499173217,
0.7000969052,
0.0770486742,
0.4195619524,
-0.6325162053,
-0.4502948523,
0.0294932127,
0.2830980718,
-0.6909651756,
0.5059974194,
-0.2211261094,
0.4925212264,
0.279604286,
-0.1262689233,
-0.3077180088,
-0.1716314405,
0.4829908013,
0.3994196951,
-0.4065988064,
0.209809497,
-0.0307646319,
-0.2657977641,
-0.2220078558,
-0.4103626907,
0.8601372242,
-0.0993935913,
-0.3603626192,
-0.0374718159,
-0.1752419025,
0.3842388988,
-0.0996923149,
0.8124094009,
0.5492555499,
-0.2362036705,
-0.4329691529,
-0.1010363325,
0.0075693424,
-0.4454073608,
0.4654960334,
-0.3108872473,
-0.7925778031,
0.3343113363,
-0.1485249698,
-0.0577851236,
0.3670869768,
0.1480118334,
0.2173520774,
0.7268928289,
0.7522126436,
-0.1246559992,
0.2941596508,
-0.5841584206,
0.1952666193,
-0.9574416876,
-0.542688489,
-0.3518323898,
-0.0795234516,
-0.6098411679,
-0.287989676,
0.3464986086,
0.2110428512,
-0.5677276254,
0.5926756859,
-0.2924492359,
0.402761966,
0.2170336843,
0.2873281538,
0.2445121855,
-0.1911070794,
-0.1503923386,
-0.0751686096,
-0.7353584766,
0.1613211632,
1.1646435261,
0.1722853333,
0.942433238,
-0.0190799609,
0.8340524435,
0.1043348536,
-0.1738342941,
-0.8597002625,
0.6443498731,
-0.3937240541,
-0.2089171857,
-0.3185019195,
-0.352096796,
-0.9169574976,
-0.0822657123,
-0.3736664057,
-0.6333465576,
0.076901637,
0.1415208727,
-0.3512414396,
0.5476555228,
-0.2130001932,
0.4480401874,
0.0641250387,
-0.4723568857,
-0.0736106187,
-0.9288554192,
0.4393180907,
0.1696057469,
-0.0702230111,
-0.2539874613,
0.0553330258,
0.5393385887,
-0.2006889582,
0.7844386697,
-0.0327174552,
0.1119390577,
0.0512459166,
0.5151215792,
0.3783525229,
-0.2943901122,
-0.2868604958,
0.2022729367,
-0.3662365377,
-0.1086154953,
-0.7498158216,
0.7026056051,
-0.677218616,
-0.3068992496,
-0.1479756832,
-0.3598052561,
-0.4362882674,
0.3654637337,
0.0514728837,
0.4833479524,
-0.0333472826,
0.2434701473,
0.6819366813,
-0.0659417808,
0.3899972737,
0.7905367613,
0.1400726736,
-0.3505478799,
0.7380678058,
0.22562626,
0.2829963863,
0.6947971582,
0.0400092863,
-0.5222638249,
-0.4723351896,
-0.5334413052,
0.4076093137,
-0.7679730058,
-0.5458828807,
-0.4515793025,
-0.7319816351,
-0.4952945709,
-0.3379732072,
-0.3670647144,
-0.2984578907,
-0.2271006554,
-0.0997829512,
0.0604345314,
0.4615822136,
-0.0088302102,
0.0739749074,
-0.7907124758,
0.203589797,
0.0406934656,
0.5614625216,
0.2846170664,
-0.3303947151,
-0.0741423517,
-0.1273387372,
-0.2962983251,
-0.9986667633,
0.159760803,
0.606353879,
0.3499106169,
0.6600223184,
0.5063445568,
0.6485139132,
-0.9333462715,
0.5476730466,
0.6811852455,
-0.8536897302,
0.6189840436,
-0.2331333309,
0.1903370917,
0.4805033207,
0.4571997225,
-0.4971844852,
-0.299862653,
-0.684530139,
-0.814868927,
0.618616581,
0.1406744868,
0.1292551607,
-0.121179603,
0.3542973399,
-0.154490307,
0.3686387837,
-0.6509670019,
-0.3842402101,
-0.011418961,
-0.2566772401,
0.1332927048,
-0.177446872,
0.1192645133,
0.0280527249,
0.4576378763,
-0.222291857,
0.0009651687,
-0.0059414194,
-0.0690583587,
-0.4134841263,
0.3319116831,
0.2116718888,
0.725015521,
-0.5717440248,
0.3305462003,
-0.0268902872,
-0.2249139249,
0.3408575356,
-0.1215666309,
-0.6199656129,
0.1590446979,
0.5292660594,
0.8918733001,
0.4009066522,
-0.5311824679,
0.6495284438,
0.3767686784,
0.030683035,
-0.2379078567,
0.2468835711,
0.2077874243,
0.0878498405,
0.1957511902,
-0.3786162734,
0.1471125931,
-0.7152918577,
0.2289499342,
0.4724052548,
-0.7226050496,
-0.4177211225,
0.5690907836,
0.194587782,
-0.2333570421,
0.6072534323,
-0.2968375981,
-0.4104374051,
0.5131168365,
0.7866338491,
0.8280822039,
-0.3023917377,
0.5369636416,
0.5378696322,
0.1265712082,
0.2171096802,
-0.0960526466,
-0.0966527611,
-0.8728774786,
-0.3822102547,
-0.7614195943,
-0.4094996154,
0.3121213913,
-0.5794282556,
0.5511901975,
-0.7680712342,
0.1620259285,
-0.0452514291,
0.0553361997,
-0.6942073107,
0.1188809946,
0.3064582348,
1.0446105003,
-0.9426118135,
1.0344179869,
0.3502125144,
-0.7000207901,
-0.7447732687,
0.0074750921,
-0.2052945793,
-0.9115455151,
0.8281111717,
0.0646122396,
-0.3964365423,
0.0567218773,
-0.5279716849,
-0.6619343758,
1.1738381386,
0.6791158319,
-0.793266058,
-0.4952480793,
0.1897738576,
0.3664045334,
-0.4657853842,
0.2444580048,
0.2239269316,
0.1154524609,
0.7104614377,
-0.5992398858,
0.429731667,
0.0862880349,
0.106197767,
0.3921139538,
-0.6288956404,
0.9234672189,
-0.3601434529,
-0.4302043021,
-0.3106966019,
0.5320485234,
0.2750920355,
0.1243844852,
0.4896326363,
0.4452655911,
0.2606360912,
0.2602495253,
0.4844101965,
-0.8326846957,
0.4372021854,
1.4979892969,
-0.4881442189,
0.9012019634,
0.079205066,
-0.070802249,
0.8216105103,
0.3865666687,
-0.1235836297,
0.7070883512,
0.1568806767,
-0.1994306594,
-0.4432433248,
-0.3054301739,
-0.3976981044,
0.2751036584,
0.4338105321,
-0.4636900127,
-0.7952201366,
-0.6454045773,
0.1422226727,
-0.1917399168,
-0.3926843703,
0.5704596043,
-0.0239676163,
-0.133666873,
0.4417724609,
-0.0488781445,
0.4144197702,
-0.9602071643,
-0.3111115396,
0.0642364547,
-0.0376516469,
-0.1651094109,
-1.1849611998,
0.0731333643,
-0.5465503931,
0.0967467204,
0.3141177595,
0.9111615419,
-0.7206702828,
-0.2820566595,
0.595023036,
0.3455481529,
-0.1294884682,
0.1792097986,
-0.6682230234,
-0.042139478,
-0.0623963661,
0.1107912809,
0.4105739892,
0.4479221702,
0.3097699583,
0.7279016972,
0.4487716854,
0.441170305,
-0.0951645151,
-0.0564601347,
0.9761912227,
-0.7133814096,
-0.496227026,
-0.9019391537,
0.306381017,
-0.137857601,
0.0178886019,
0.3635909557,
0.6256506443,
0.6796543598,
0.0577615239,
0.7015595436,
0.0928590745,
0.0407714695,
-0.7202060223,
0.4784936309,
-0.2901848555,
-0.0845721886,
-0.3186949492,
-0.8197113872,
-0.2066047788,
0.1276127845,
0.0416055098,
-0.1100811884,
0.6195554137,
0.5465186238,
-0.2261277288,
-0.4214285612,
0.6234152913,
0.3874189556,
0.2211540639,
1.159383297,
0.1263900101,
-0.1700945199,
0.8170881271,
-0.3690354228,
0.0555475838,
-0.1858493835,
-1.0992897749,
-0.8272919059,
-0.656449914,
-0.3018701375,
-0.4064565301,
0.2487964183,
0.7318972945,
0.689688921,
-0.4682097137,
-0.2810710669,
-0.1985692978,
0.1236633509,
0.2459072918,
-0.1869234294,
0.5102525353,
-0.2790514529,
-0.3745684326,
0.2338066548,
0.6052160263,
0.0614202917,
-0.4415229261,
-0.2769318223,
0.0214560758,
0.0046682195,
0.5404620767,
0.4952566028,
-0.5399258137,
-0.2862195373,
-0.1111987904,
0.1796690822,
0.1312489361,
0.7638109922,
-0.6505403519,
0.3691564798,
0.4169481397,
0.3804486394,
0.755102694,
-0.3048127592,
0.6116634607,
-0.729162693,
0.2249772996,
0.2810913324,
0.5152570009,
0.2238646001,
-0.3800495565,
0.6778799295,
0.1284000278,
-0.0684000552,
-0.6000739336,
0.723502934,
-0.9955277443,
-0.3014377356,
1.116594553,
-0.5199111104,
-0.4922562242,
-0.1472363919,
0.231938675,
0.5073744655,
-0.6078852415,
0.4686416388,
0.1058969796,
-0.4079365134,
-0.2580412328,
-0.2786129713,
0.3420087695,
-0.2809617519,
-0.3913246691,
0.1204914674,
0.5028243065,
0.4577472806,
0.2642169893,
0.7676566243,
0.1450435966,
-0.0024079911,
-0.0151892491,
0.0278631654,
-0.4152206481,
-0.4080277979,
-0.0723427981,
0.4402479231,
0.1428830028,
-0.1663918942
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10772v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10772v1
|
Enhancing ESG Impact Type Identification through Early Fusion and Multilingual Models
| 2024-02-16T15:54:24 | 2024-02-16T15:54:24 |
Hariram Veeramani, Surendrabikram Thapa, Usman Naseem
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the evolving landscape of Environmental, Social, and Corporate Governance
(ESG) impact assessment, the ML-ESG-2 shared task proposes identifying ESG
impact types. To address this challenge, we present a comprehensive system
leveraging ensemble learning techniques, capitalizing on early and late fusion
approaches. Our approach employs four distinct models: mBERT, FlauBERT-base,
ALBERT-base-v2, and a Multi-Layer Perceptron (MLP) incorporating Latent
Semantic Analysis (LSA) and Term Frequency-Inverse Document Frequency (TF-IDF)
features. Through extensive experimentation, we find that our early fusion
ensemble approach, featuring the integration of LSA, TF-IDF, mBERT,
FlauBERT-base, and ALBERT-base-v2, delivers the best performance. Our system
offers a comprehensive ESG impact type identification solution, contributing to
the responsible and sustainable decision-making processes vital in today's
financial and corporate governance landscape.
|
[
-0.5455764532,
-0.6738255024,
0.3506570756,
0.1125898734,
-0.2013428509,
0.629866302,
0.0307442732,
-0.784781754,
0.3290931284,
0.6084931493,
-0.445010066,
-0.3594318926,
-0.9371606708,
-0.084351033,
-0.3782907426,
1.2792373896,
0.2295039147,
-0.0402785875,
0.0213110335,
-0.0469296537,
-0.0845278725,
-0.3637101054,
-0.4932273626,
-0.3076936603,
0.5986297727,
0.2025061101,
0.2749503255,
0.0617971346,
0.3613261282,
0.279070586,
-0.3704066873,
0.2769223452,
-0.6613405347,
-0.4080886543,
-0.0432638936,
-0.0445985831,
-0.1566573083,
-0.0044676797,
0.5989322066,
0.4028906822,
-0.3012570739,
0.3395778239,
0.3655816615,
0.2225777805,
-0.8622604012,
0.3816277981,
-0.5961023569,
0.2007847726,
-0.3227920532,
-0.0616819225,
-0.4467555583,
0.144463405,
0.480053097,
-0.6290313005,
-0.2230119258,
0.0856816098,
0.7569394708,
0.1209410951,
-0.681245625,
-0.2271318585,
-0.6170998812,
0.6455476284,
-0.1416706145,
0.4674136937,
-0.0493309982,
0.1726150662,
-0.0612147301,
-0.7941191792,
-0.2535609901,
0.3723148108,
-0.2682927251,
0.354624033,
-0.1307358295,
0.1915102005,
-0.1089953557,
0.2651202381,
-0.4753667712,
0.3347716928,
-0.7485296726,
-0.524297297,
0.5549656749,
-0.1758252382,
0.000579434,
-0.1627990156,
-0.6327849627,
-0.1437330842,
-0.7879188657,
0.0266762972,
0.5475401282,
0.4107651114,
-0.2339279354,
0.3597320914,
0.0115466202,
0.4588980377,
0.2864192426,
0.1162392646,
0.2958129644,
-0.2170554698,
-0.2424623519,
0.3632113338,
0.3807938397,
0.0136659956,
-0.3166712523,
-0.0307497885,
-0.3707120121,
-0.1532040387,
0.1988405436,
-0.6373851895,
-0.0700366348,
0.164680481,
-0.6369518042,
-0.5113255978,
0.3106677532,
-1.0224411488,
-0.6880854368,
-0.3971247971,
0.8543860912,
-0.1202614605,
-0.3789410591,
-0.1003988236,
-0.2961398959,
0.6322190166,
0.241478771,
-0.8382014036,
0.1292385906,
0.8906728029,
0.7251888514,
-0.1603543609,
-0.1308066398,
-0.802067399,
0.4630720019,
0.2942309678,
1.1855435371,
-0.765637219,
-0.8666713834,
0.0564469509,
-0.0100852512,
0.0485518426,
-0.4000083804,
0.589353919,
-0.4457076192,
0.1992510408,
-0.2221866548,
-0.4521264136,
-0.4174352288,
-0.1090370119,
-0.6451165676,
1.151473403,
-0.0568092503,
-0.5972018838,
0.7202106118,
-0.8206087947,
-0.4768854678,
0.5093194246,
-0.4823545516,
-0.332788974,
0.1967509091,
0.0984886289,
0.5557447672,
-0.1489389241,
0.1063561961,
-0.3348732591,
-0.1365526021,
-0.6915505528,
-0.2216415703,
0.5687299967,
0.1647821963,
-0.0875150114,
0.2629744112,
-1.0747418404,
0.014329873,
-0.1093930155,
-0.1510827243,
-0.3038274944,
0.3567148745,
0.3460424542,
0.218124181,
0.5387496948,
-0.2417812645,
-0.0151963159,
0.0802032202,
0.3327132165,
1.0988360643,
0.2718200982,
0.2761709988,
-0.0608950667,
0.2500270307,
-0.0383843109,
0.2685475349,
0.0075461306,
-0.6088824868,
-0.2219126523,
-0.3732572496,
0.0575435013,
0.7941752076,
-0.5380843282,
0.5210357308,
-0.2871528864,
-0.9954093695,
-0.2065385431,
-0.0641445145,
0.3230177462,
0.2240149081,
0.3010620177,
-0.1819885373,
-0.6374871731,
-1.1327325106,
-0.611395359,
-0.4652445614,
-0.1838627458,
0.44585374,
0.7272145748,
-0.0843693316,
0.8489638567,
-0.3954122663,
-0.1921821088,
0.00823115,
0.4865159392,
0.1741710901,
0.2024272382,
0.4080556631,
-1.0882406235,
-0.197440818,
0.1873918027,
-0.4056145549,
-0.0314618424,
0.0003901929,
0.0254876036,
-0.2285932899,
0.2187753469,
-0.0918177143,
-0.035712637,
0.7634625435,
-0.4894019067,
0.255268842,
-0.0384644084,
0.1694894135,
-0.9402833581,
0.127712816,
0.1922905892,
0.187499091,
-0.7532844543,
-0.261592418,
0.1832767725,
-0.1104960218,
-0.7763484716,
0.4962109029,
-0.2307800055,
-0.5063756704,
0.230371207,
-0.1560084075,
0.0207612235,
0.241548419,
0.1558998972,
0.6091467738,
0.3953358233,
-0.6618725061,
0.0305079445,
0.2947770953,
-0.5256563425,
0.7097904682,
-0.7320736647,
0.2823418677,
-0.2739526927,
0.4310534894,
-0.7937050462,
-0.3801140189,
-0.0806904957,
-0.1454950869,
0.3775878847,
-0.3408494592,
-0.4888520837,
-0.2454953939,
-0.2675735652,
0.0416824557,
0.215944916,
-0.6832566261,
1.2856068611,
0.8038605452,
-0.235170275,
-0.7052987814,
-0.5562813282,
-0.1150031015,
-0.490432471,
-0.8249051571,
0.6561470628,
0.4264431298,
-0.1477604806,
-0.0946935713,
-0.1623931378,
-0.0571398549,
0.4039096534,
0.2055620104,
0.3605781198,
0.1105341986,
0.0720565245,
0.1897129864,
0.0272984523,
-0.3053283393,
-0.0586927868,
0.4676209986,
-0.5252559781,
-0.2694275975,
0.1646992862,
0.4075243473,
0.6957034469,
-0.6551319361,
0.7907463312,
0.9086996913,
-0.6294692755,
0.0157507528,
-0.469545275,
-0.1244410202,
-0.5124179125,
0.7549613714,
-0.2843154073,
-0.879730463,
0.8476524353,
-0.2832790911,
0.2633505762,
0.9922425151,
0.5150386691,
0.0836836398,
0.8012441993,
0.5810164213,
-0.0878641829,
0.7036422491,
-0.1702289134,
0.0952975377,
-0.7718173265,
-0.5515992641,
-0.3847445548,
-0.1431086212,
-0.6807983518,
-0.0695899501,
0.7970253229,
0.0856638253,
-0.2684568465,
0.233804062,
-0.3901306689,
0.3558938205,
0.3092903793,
0.0297254678,
-0.0475011915,
0.0277015846,
0.0927052721,
0.3783262074,
-0.4695186317,
-0.6587813497,
1.0963680744,
0.4787532985,
0.6571189165,
0.3617235124,
0.8932514787,
0.5917626023,
0.4263656139,
-0.5856731534,
0.3174647391,
-0.355535835,
-0.7612758875,
-0.2161239386,
-0.2756316662,
-0.6868085265,
0.4807896018,
-0.6626618505,
-0.9326907992,
0.2431664914,
-0.0620064884,
-0.9136355519,
0.1443453431,
-0.8737812638,
0.6908595562,
-0.4449509978,
-0.2753243744,
-0.2746364474,
-0.5752058029,
0.2500425279,
-0.3013280332,
0.4234619737,
-0.0610089712,
-0.1329621375,
0.8916509151,
0.0633506626,
1.0566184521,
-0.4009757936,
-0.2766548395,
0.3336392641,
-0.4477199316,
0.99052912,
0.0538566373,
0.0305168293,
0.4171621203,
0.0333407782,
-0.1797787994,
-0.3962170184,
0.5445466042,
-0.85201478,
-0.2911156118,
-0.2675251663,
0.0244457293,
-0.2306595594,
0.1340932548,
0.2608288229,
0.2557590008,
-0.502155304,
0.2010716945,
0.4946510494,
-0.1906164289,
0.3768953383,
0.6068675518,
-0.1425313503,
-0.6334010959,
0.8704358935,
0.3887139857,
0.1103592068,
0.0590200461,
0.1469674855,
-0.4823380113,
-0.3309795856,
-0.3468056619,
-0.1360279918,
-0.7489625216,
-0.0723185912,
-0.8400805593,
-0.1099257693,
-0.3643678725,
-0.0749258474,
-0.309574306,
-0.0623995364,
-0.4094613791,
-0.2380785197,
0.2444223613,
0.748996079,
-0.082294248,
0.5028927326,
-1.1731352806,
0.1122554839,
0.408087194,
0.4742577076,
-0.4689792991,
-0.3577393889,
-0.1355047822,
-0.3161424696,
-0.3788926005,
-0.944088161,
0.0930186063,
0.5763064027,
0.8744234443,
0.7481105924,
-0.3178012371,
0.2560823262,
-0.441005975,
1.016864419,
0.0975817665,
-1.0137891769,
0.3912333846,
-0.3524400294,
-0.1564605981,
0.6225528717,
0.3558220267,
-0.6306732893,
0.1241869777,
-0.7446503639,
-1.0030105114,
0.4502211809,
0.0657787099,
-0.1814027429,
-0.0268883333,
0.0795790479,
0.214478299,
0.1205067411,
-0.5685761571,
-0.1611896306,
0.0882112533,
0.0009130751,
-0.0956333205,
-0.1980284005,
-0.1677117646,
0.1646015793,
0.8974330425,
-0.0861682966,
0.1707519293,
-0.0824580044,
-0.1424867809,
0.1031603068,
0.2393821627,
0.7153012156,
0.0913807377,
-0.2066630423,
0.0169265792,
0.4002846181,
-0.4104230404,
-0.0649342164,
0.2867001891,
-0.0339988768,
-0.2464810759,
0.4277595282,
0.7988912463,
0.2978251874,
-0.5109125972,
0.3222002387,
0.3173616827,
-0.2080968022,
-0.3607161641,
-0.2375005484,
-0.1370645463,
0.3861336708,
0.683259964,
0.0438243002,
0.326505363,
-0.4862166047,
0.4519221783,
0.2506257296,
-0.4361775815,
-0.2408351004,
0.2871073186,
0.6442269087,
-0.0182247385,
0.221668914,
-0.1234800443,
-0.8525536656,
0.8429671526,
0.335988611,
1.0592683554,
-0.455606848,
0.070533812,
0.3491533101,
0.4047448039,
-0.2546869218,
0.3939964771,
0.1796285063,
-0.8150069714,
-0.4460060596,
-0.6323285699,
-0.2954631448,
0.16654405,
-0.7491787672,
0.6494805813,
-0.4806773067,
-0.0168036446,
0.2596184313,
0.0030314219,
-0.7474068403,
-0.0334875733,
0.6612989306,
0.5828124881,
-1.2575775385,
0.3495103717,
0.7773641348,
-0.2446599156,
-0.4459974468,
-0.3244268894,
0.5533542633,
-1.0223789215,
0.5324773788,
0.3755927086,
-0.2723553479,
0.1837065369,
-0.2462937087,
-1.0225952864,
1.2717189789,
-0.0412611254,
-0.7093482018,
-0.0591194034,
-0.1359932721,
0.3023620248,
-0.4000117481,
0.3312431276,
0.5635598302,
0.8766855001,
0.0007734452,
-0.9918169379,
-0.3970197737,
-0.1099617928,
-0.2000298351,
0.5689142346,
-0.8633334041,
0.5167888999,
-0.0515289605,
-0.4573928118,
-0.5129258633,
0.6768344641,
0.1413861215,
0.2145689577,
0.8137183189,
0.5251090527,
0.9308108687,
-0.0112281032,
1.0914485455,
-0.5681610703,
0.6118683219,
1.0684839487,
-0.2983008921,
0.9037384987,
0.5775564313,
-0.247186929,
0.1470590085,
1.0531830788,
-0.3032711744,
0.7499060631,
0.3657819033,
-0.513604939,
-0.1878037006,
-0.3155690134,
-0.2882705629,
0.7878759503,
0.8412530422,
-0.496723026,
-0.3034341633,
0.0068743229,
-0.2329713106,
-0.4432145655,
-0.5988285542,
0.7936632037,
-0.1544700414,
-0.2979094982,
-0.181525439,
0.0193094481,
0.8503059149,
-0.557744503,
-0.0428775139,
0.2537807822,
-0.2459678799,
-0.4394478202,
-0.8497134447,
0.336614579,
-0.0538844801,
0.160871163,
-0.122348994,
0.7703255415,
-0.4421845973,
-0.4741877913,
0.6131361127,
0.5586330295,
-0.0547794178,
-0.197912544,
-0.3884521425,
-0.0643268004,
-0.2466043979,
-0.376612097,
0.0832757279,
0.1691975147,
0.0652496442,
0.1574065238,
0.3969104886,
-0.2706590891,
-0.0233859289,
0.0360829718,
0.5828278661,
-0.2480874658,
-0.4127981961,
-0.659380734,
0.4815162718,
-0.2062122375,
-0.4155179858,
0.3065844476,
0.6869373918,
0.7688575387,
0.1082157046,
1.0177454948,
-0.2942629755,
0.1606980413,
-0.4937393665,
0.796720922,
-0.4896987975,
0.2117829025,
-0.3929059505,
-0.9671791196,
-0.1198906898,
0.2658819854,
-0.2906576097,
-0.0307736434,
0.3189828992,
0.6490741372,
-0.1291020364,
0.1614119411,
0.3223678172,
0.109036386,
0.4687022567,
0.4024061561,
0.7542745471,
-0.274982363,
0.6114166379,
0.0860122442,
-0.3611437678,
-0.1848398447,
-1.00088799,
-0.4203766286,
-0.6208300591,
-0.2636879385,
-0.2956646979,
-0.0829205662,
1.1065564156,
0.579179287,
-0.6369953752,
0.2025661021,
0.2434737235,
-0.183363691,
-0.0760639086,
-0.1915317029,
0.5060116053,
0.1077278927,
-0.5011270046,
0.5108056664,
0.5952051282,
0.0796611607,
-0.2190613598,
-0.1118244156,
-0.1506039351,
0.1545635462,
0.856243372,
0.241716519,
-0.7354288697,
-0.9002021551,
-0.2802339494,
0.1482656747,
-0.2616407871,
0.6041352749,
-0.4246609509,
0.2122197598,
0.3729865551,
0.8514925838,
0.3793753386,
-0.3520141542,
0.4187998176,
-0.5504178405,
-0.0128887203,
0.19577986,
0.5803793073,
-0.1086697727,
-0.5996851921,
0.6497237682,
0.3098334074,
-0.2960281074,
-0.5660422444,
0.3922996223,
-0.9874724746,
-0.0019219932,
1.2215294838,
-0.1279562861,
0.0169681963,
-0.1190970987,
-0.0460462533,
0.1216447353,
-0.5030237436,
0.7748423219,
1.0861668587,
-0.0663353726,
-0.1273186207,
-0.06868276,
0.3135454953,
0.2585311234,
-0.9307188988,
-0.2087629288,
0.435803324,
-0.0117317177,
0.3747675419,
0.2118684649,
-0.2401730567,
0.1244334653,
0.0109325442,
0.2042515278,
0.1371976137,
-0.3840810061,
-0.5188913345,
0.3704747856,
-0.404488951,
0.0381961949
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10770v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10770v3
|
How Reliable Are Automatic Evaluation Methods for Instruction-Tuned LLMs?
| 2024-02-16T15:48:33 | 2024-07-02T11:46:09 |
Ehsan Doostmohammadi, Oskar Holmström, Marco Kuhlmann
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Work on instruction-tuned Large Language Models (LLMs) has used automatic
methods based on text overlap and LLM judgments as cost-effective alternatives
to human evaluation. In this paper, we perform a meta-evaluation of such
methods and assess their reliability across a broad range of tasks. We observe
that while automatic evaluation methods can approximate human ratings under
specific conditions, their validity is highly context-dependent. Specifically,
the simple ROUGE-L metric correlates well with human ratings for short-answer
English tasks but is unreliable in free-form generation tasks and cross-lingual
transfer. The effectiveness of the more advanced method of using GPT-4 as a
judge diminishes significantly if reference answers are not included in the
prompt, which is the scenario where this method has the potential to provide
the most value compared to other metrics. Our findings enhance the
understanding of how automatic methods should be applied and interpreted when
developing and evaluating instruction-tuned LLMs.
|
[
-0.2307644188,
-0.7056408525,
0.8134479523,
0.2943056524,
-0.180050388,
0.1096414104,
-0.4361382127,
-0.4694387615,
-0.1547468454,
0.1112951189,
-0.3716697991,
-0.3394837677,
-0.5946063995,
0.3949530125,
-0.4289755523,
0.8639907241,
-0.268101126,
0.1664205641,
-0.379285872,
-0.0637115017,
-0.5178186893,
-0.3285781741,
-0.4572181404,
-0.2837050259,
0.3615770042,
0.5256916881,
0.6844856739,
0.8421179056,
0.579603374,
0.3814579844,
0.1644166857,
0.4710513651,
-0.1870081574,
-0.0748464614,
-0.1737228036,
-0.2905541956,
-0.6060561538,
0.3407821953,
0.6411273479,
0.5537492037,
-0.1567064375,
0.2799671292,
0.5092163682,
0.576391995,
-0.7935872674,
0.0830488428,
-0.5984715819,
-0.0602824464,
-0.1079131141,
-0.1871275455,
-0.5228476524,
-0.4346560836,
0.1807817519,
-0.3572197855,
-0.0055737221,
-0.2357501835,
0.6553720236,
0.5491585135,
-0.5805703402,
-0.585940063,
-0.8813240528,
0.7340004444,
-0.5621014237,
0.2664877772,
0.6420854926,
0.4619039893,
-0.0313289762,
-0.6441444755,
-0.3190758228,
-0.5663480163,
-0.3887074292,
0.2250384986,
-0.0265022479,
0.1658863127,
0.3742828965,
0.2464832366,
-0.3819574118,
0.1880241632,
-0.2483782619,
-0.3166247606,
0.6047843099,
0.3335404694,
0.4142903686,
-0.3641728163,
-0.2593613863,
0.1644302458,
-0.651399374,
0.0289847013,
0.6348496675,
-0.0047713569,
0.0980600342,
0.4777725339,
-0.0829181671,
1.0409134626,
0.2769794762,
-0.2363531739,
0.0165577512,
-0.5092329979,
-0.1299432516,
-0.3977815211,
0.7877378464,
0.5007604361,
0.4022218883,
-0.4620096385,
-0.3898409009,
-0.1579354405,
0.4015491903,
-0.5627234578,
-0.0413033441,
-0.0282507762,
-0.0043638251,
-0.0075587574,
0.2050229609,
-0.5641948581,
0.1796824783,
-0.3960862458,
0.6678490639,
-0.1541292965,
0.3410599232,
-0.1965627372,
0.0259773713,
0.1933124363,
0.3815739155,
-0.885427177,
0.3870104253,
0.4900635481,
0.7437363863,
-0.5459949374,
-0.5136510134,
-0.9815991521,
-0.09414386,
-0.3166781962,
0.8187619448,
-0.544970572,
-0.3441275358,
-0.1490222663,
0.3926405609,
-0.3521567583,
-0.576405406,
0.6663705707,
-0.5320330858,
0.3431034386,
-0.2184024751,
-0.7479481101,
0.0922737643,
0.1129746139,
-0.8030177951,
0.9002497196,
0.2241469026,
-0.4712152779,
0.3332857788,
-0.3720403016,
-0.5726113915,
-0.0643914789,
0.0272790827,
-0.2886948287,
-0.0532251187,
0.1803586483,
0.2832962275,
-0.2425291836,
0.1733414531,
-0.0977111161,
-0.84679389,
0.278646946,
-0.9839750528,
0.4820214212,
-0.1268373281,
-0.7764538527,
-0.0255524721,
-0.6864063144,
0.4101339877,
-0.2565552294,
-0.5224064589,
-0.1699090302,
-0.0474793836,
-0.2372327447,
0.0415877551,
0.2650306225,
-0.1628800929,
0.0413947329,
-0.2779349089,
0.2548150718,
0.8188154101,
-0.0422280431,
0.4242307246,
-0.3378398418,
0.7251724005,
-0.4629772902,
0.0669737309,
-0.2278287411,
-0.4051611125,
-0.7627037764,
-0.1478806883,
0.4286046326,
0.7583894134,
-0.5195457935,
0.6127282381,
-0.0844737366,
-0.4871813655,
-0.4249991775,
0.3753782213,
0.5870389938,
0.3722085953,
0.510664463,
-0.2067050487,
-0.3189278841,
-0.8432053328,
-0.598413229,
0.0533127747,
-0.1114829555,
0.3741229773,
0.4558498859,
-0.3529659212,
0.941219151,
-0.1160966754,
0.3264627755,
0.0337000713,
0.1966516972,
0.0725022629,
0.1022067294,
0.3499101102,
-0.2081839144,
-0.8235615492,
-0.3092973232,
-0.5530187488,
-0.4542964697,
-0.0235730056,
0.0816422179,
0.5414593816,
0.2105165869,
-0.5489726663,
0.5201442838,
0.6292782426,
-0.1240949184,
0.8195457458,
-0.3090727627,
0.4390081763,
-0.579980433,
0.0506545082,
-0.0227265693,
-0.4084279835,
-0.3873280287,
-0.0877186656,
0.2699197233,
0.3498500586,
-0.3370080888,
0.8443404436,
-0.5410369039,
-0.2807705402,
-0.5020292401,
0.4315880537,
-0.0349589884,
0.226927489,
-0.2744596601,
1.0433440208,
0.2071658969,
-0.6618497372,
0.4813105464,
-0.2325096428,
-0.6500636339,
0.6862725616,
-0.7210112214,
0.5011869669,
0.2930515707,
0.3660928011,
-0.9031126499,
-0.3145058453,
0.2925411165,
-0.0410197563,
0.3092378974,
-0.1422224343,
-0.4189288616,
-0.2741771638,
-0.2165491134,
0.348156333,
0.4626865685,
-0.6829808354,
0.3059546947,
0.030230673,
-0.0252677463,
-0.7830112576,
-0.469856441,
0.0795737058,
-0.1641273797,
-0.4310820103,
0.2511992455,
-0.1976689994,
-0.3680078387,
0.0571198836,
-0.4402227402,
-0.0525811613,
0.1523699015,
0.1200319305,
0.1673731655,
-0.0672266409,
0.0752290785,
0.0388075635,
-0.1434977651,
0.0816682875,
-0.0472697802,
0.2054525912,
-0.3086544275,
-0.7773414254,
-0.4348973036,
0.0314265378,
0.5736792088,
0.0622842461,
0.3801633716,
0.5568179488,
-0.1630446911,
-0.2735761404,
-0.5736558437,
-0.1576664001,
-0.4826486111,
0.3442317843,
-0.1690451503,
-0.642346859,
0.2788055241,
0.1281154454,
0.1486344337,
0.5085414648,
0.4455931783,
-0.2502810061,
0.8730384111,
0.3172135353,
0.0317456611,
0.1079487801,
0.0582159758,
-0.1441146135,
-0.8027923703,
0.0878237188,
-0.3982000649,
-0.3273976743,
-0.4448161125,
-0.4933255315,
0.3847371936,
0.0950649679,
-0.1280137599,
0.295555383,
-0.2567517459,
0.73062253,
0.3417059183,
0.0518554896,
0.5160770416,
-0.1143158525,
-0.0823187754,
-0.0232477151,
-0.586810708,
-0.8569881916,
1.0794407129,
0.2792185843,
0.7496308684,
-0.018570397,
0.5138659477,
0.3699855208,
0.6316376925,
-0.9190787077,
0.6022037864,
-0.1977883279,
-0.4624048173,
-0.6256287694,
-0.4548130631,
-0.8265451193,
0.2427973449,
0.072367236,
-0.6246468425,
-0.3473994732,
0.168423295,
-0.2840625048,
0.1145097315,
-0.75772506,
0.6833339334,
-0.7331538796,
-0.5320824385,
-0.1963819265,
-0.4786858857,
0.3066966236,
-0.3471410871,
0.1588632017,
0.1201224923,
-0.2233683765,
0.7996115088,
-0.4997341633,
0.8638775349,
0.034753751,
-0.3377443552,
0.3280627131,
-0.0726260766,
0.5216395855,
-0.058310058,
-0.0956657082,
0.1208558455,
-0.0305017624,
-0.214560166,
-1.0009428263,
0.5854780674,
-0.7144625187,
-0.8284369111,
-0.3660126328,
-0.3940815926,
-0.4112359881,
0.1245818287,
0.3397377431,
0.4939830005,
-0.166512236,
0.0562791675,
0.2119570673,
-0.15368931,
0.4454670846,
0.685626328,
0.1532147378,
-0.5588297248,
0.6553330421,
0.2542079389,
0.4918606281,
0.2462987751,
0.2524757683,
-0.1729554534,
-0.1604126692,
-0.8327208161,
0.0872846469,
-0.954146266,
-0.1729232222,
-0.2838543057,
-0.2666872442,
0.1188488528,
-0.0664464906,
-0.3141491115,
-0.3819159269,
-0.1114964038,
-0.1739327163,
0.0065199407,
0.9540792108,
0.0015007765,
0.1484388113,
-0.9632575512,
0.1798903942,
0.6586722136,
0.3785597086,
-0.0470344797,
-0.8141621351,
-0.4679432511,
0.1864716709,
-0.2434562594,
-0.8962320685,
-0.2086614221,
0.2738458812,
0.8487591147,
0.1796060354,
-0.1317062229,
0.5995687246,
-0.7974291444,
0.6893773675,
-0.3303542435,
-1.0956714153,
0.262621969,
-0.0935182646,
0.4093751907,
0.5740910769,
0.4213193357,
-0.2374893427,
-0.5570828319,
-0.3465948999,
-0.7566751242,
0.6423021555,
0.0394278988,
0.0752227604,
-0.140876025,
0.5844957829,
0.1587839425,
-0.0233332571,
-0.6560730338,
-0.2397486866,
0.0402268581,
-0.1845209152,
-0.1255515218,
-0.2172483206,
-0.0534268916,
-0.3242567182,
0.5466948748,
-0.1602606028,
0.0941651091,
-0.1402671784,
-0.3268677294,
-0.2799979448,
0.4389338791,
0.8331718445,
0.9988432527,
-0.0813457519,
0.0949701592,
0.4969281554,
-0.4288377464,
0.4735943973,
-0.1475962847,
-0.1368616223,
0.1699524969,
0.7209278345,
0.8017123938,
0.5084617138,
-0.5291635394,
0.51636374,
-0.013897758,
-0.1598891616,
-0.181691438,
0.3332214653,
-0.0869765058,
0.1122569218,
0.0923187137,
0.0088431938,
0.0634009615,
-0.5238086581,
0.441742599,
0.6013827324,
-0.3701215088,
-0.2958038449,
0.39367643,
0.3967781663,
-0.489243418,
0.5955043435,
-0.1524884254,
-0.6063327789,
0.6473541856,
0.4286587238,
1.1037442684,
-0.3175598681,
0.220323652,
0.3320646286,
0.6423497796,
-0.2931270599,
-0.1595057398,
-0.1401676536,
-0.471991539,
-0.7838060856,
-0.5078197122,
-0.7377047539,
0.0932520702,
-0.5942166448,
0.3156236112,
-0.0639646649,
-0.3650801182,
-0.5689956546,
-0.0524051934,
-0.6839732528,
0.2147550583,
-0.1055296063,
0.8738808632,
-0.8771314621,
0.68950665,
0.6458343267,
0.0195401777,
-0.9988261461,
0.5105788112,
-0.0925078169,
-0.7493619919,
0.6888706088,
0.3019612432,
-0.6798394918,
-0.3063285947,
-0.1088727936,
-0.8579536676,
1.0348733664,
0.4193089008,
-0.7300061584,
-0.0890939832,
0.0449211933,
0.7112787962,
-0.1528942138,
0.7840964794,
0.802896142,
0.8000223041,
0.0650243312,
-1.371989131,
0.099405773,
-0.0767576396,
-0.3926729858,
-0.022861382,
-0.6011519432,
0.4321626425,
-0.3211469948,
-0.2640400529,
0.1882723868,
0.2381085902,
0.0683089569,
0.2711840272,
0.8196105957,
0.3933169842,
0.8953242898,
-0.0412765183,
0.949698925,
-0.5678705573,
0.4330114424,
1.0789136887,
-0.2366725057,
0.6656246185,
0.0972974673,
-0.2736620009,
0.5476206541,
0.5433790684,
-0.048396714,
0.3160637021,
0.1823904961,
-0.034501791,
-0.1871981323,
0.5376029015,
-0.0652779043,
0.4848905802,
0.1299178004,
-0.2513747215,
-0.1234085709,
-0.2110715508,
-0.0815742612,
-0.0765372515,
-0.1152744368,
0.7270201445,
0.0758739784,
-1.0614881516,
0.7904483676,
0.0405720212,
0.540194273,
-0.4241591394,
-0.0105662346,
-0.302390784,
0.0162664,
-0.321996063,
-0.6640629172,
0.2923068404,
0.3037500083,
-0.089555569,
-0.1631749868,
0.5480197072,
-0.4334932864,
-0.3440791965,
0.1927081347,
0.6612496972,
0.1360268146,
0.3645641506,
-0.4572331905,
-0.2050971091,
-0.1613899469,
-0.3415990472,
0.1938877404,
0.2697955668,
-0.0265822019,
0.5783872008,
0.1167014465,
0.0703552812,
-0.133262381,
-0.0240054522,
0.4137822092,
-0.5876564384,
-0.1534108669,
-1.1679399014,
0.4779218137,
0.0415211096,
-0.0848440602,
0.9646964073,
0.382671535,
0.7639604211,
0.0576247424,
0.9297329783,
0.3350087702,
0.3411321938,
-0.8090053201,
0.5259439349,
-0.5615081191,
0.5864437222,
-0.3892311156,
-1.2278587818,
0.0446917973,
0.5776694417,
-0.4986325204,
0.4902371168,
1.0426814556,
0.479499191,
-0.1706632227,
-0.1438939422,
0.2485812008,
-0.1081933007,
0.1141524985,
0.3804194331,
1.0640683174,
-0.2276680022,
0.5948920846,
-0.1040062457,
-0.4464136958,
-0.2793882787,
-0.939094305,
-0.8599749207,
-0.2327131182,
-0.1602574438,
-0.1910713911,
0.1321916282,
0.7598975301,
0.5391646624,
-0.571349144,
-0.3333261013,
0.2416383624,
0.3440253437,
-0.245400846,
-0.2262937576,
0.5122733712,
-0.6639040112,
-0.9032506347,
0.556884706,
0.3676368296,
-0.213718906,
-0.4276833534,
-0.1585393101,
0.3681304753,
0.2280405909,
0.5146265626,
0.1309494972,
-0.7954906821,
-0.5782747865,
0.1852743775,
-0.4302566648,
-0.169416815,
0.7385587692,
-0.5664460659,
0.3374008536,
0.2989980578,
0.7477608323,
0.0722823068,
0.3757646084,
0.7149154544,
-0.5298568606,
-0.3002757132,
0.0351656973,
0.2971066236,
0.3231646419,
-0.151205793,
0.5488898754,
0.2581988573,
-0.8880853057,
-0.6010848284,
0.1502536982,
-0.5148665309,
0.0396143608,
1.431411624,
-0.2436417192,
-0.0190521125,
-0.0526401252,
0.0417834073,
-0.0016692802,
-0.0552363284,
0.863521874,
1.0023719072,
-0.3925181031,
-0.0128348907,
-0.7375612259,
0.5319597721,
0.4560841918,
-0.8989231586,
-0.0555738136,
0.5072792172,
0.4802688956,
0.0908238068,
0.5387396812,
0.1136501878,
0.4874269664,
-0.433976084,
-0.3466317952,
0.0235318001,
-0.5111668706,
-0.3112921417,
-0.1896695644,
0.1916446984,
-0.0107187452
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10769v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10769v1
|
Distillation Enhanced Generative Retrieval
| 2024-02-16T15:48:24 | 2024-02-16T15:48:24 |
Yongqi Li, Zhen Zhang, Wenjie Wang, Liqiang Nie, Wenjie Li, Tat-Seng Chua
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Generative retrieval is a promising new paradigm in text retrieval that
generates identifier strings of relevant passages as the retrieval target. This
paradigm leverages powerful generative language models, distinct from
traditional sparse or dense retrieval methods. In this work, we identify a
viable direction to further enhance generative retrieval via distillation and
propose a feasible framework, named DGR. DGR utilizes sophisticated ranking
models, such as the cross-encoder, in a teacher role to supply a passage rank
list, which captures the varying relevance degrees of passages instead of
binary hard labels; subsequently, DGR employs a specially designed distilled
RankNet loss to optimize the generative retrieval model, considering the
passage rank order provided by the teacher model as labels. This framework only
requires an additional distillation step to enhance current generative
retrieval systems and does not add any burden to the inference stage. We
conduct experiments on four public datasets, and the results indicate that DGR
achieves state-of-the-art performance among the generative retrieval methods.
Additionally, DGR demonstrates exceptional robustness and generalizability with
various teacher models and distillation losses.
|
[
-0.1892611682,
-0.5731639862,
0.7331454158,
0.0227533076,
-0.3800875843,
0.392265439,
-0.1550490409,
0.0186058041,
-0.1446028352,
0.3105445802,
0.0114626782,
-0.4429493546,
-1.0427638292,
0.3336050212,
-0.8310953975,
1.1001735926,
0.2433613092,
0.0506879762,
-0.3478922248,
0.2871637344,
-0.2746482491,
-0.5728797317,
-0.5186089873,
-0.5247194767,
0.5642837286,
0.0462006256,
0.5285964608,
0.5469359159,
0.6753237247,
0.3158047497,
-0.6618728042,
-0.110343039,
-0.8515082002,
0.416359663,
-0.1061451659,
-0.5261771083,
-0.2933936715,
0.046602793,
0.6284125447,
0.7042793036,
-0.5195724368,
-0.1517417431,
0.4502162933,
0.8770147562,
-0.6332018971,
0.1089846045,
-0.9134225249,
0.1292120218,
-0.3604605496,
-0.1839068085,
-0.5314558744,
-0.5749252439,
0.2448377907,
-0.3798880577,
0.4298789501,
-0.2006705403,
0.4515200257,
0.3711617589,
-0.4559010267,
-0.2314172983,
-0.7436356544,
0.5011825562,
-0.4616683722,
0.2706347406,
0.4123917818,
0.6438888907,
-0.1388965547,
-1.2676054239,
-0.6050035954,
-0.1871948838,
-0.2215694189,
0.3329119086,
-0.0722389445,
0.2425111979,
0.1476479024,
0.9754827023,
-0.3850790858,
-0.2250448167,
-0.2677406669,
0.2950241268,
0.5028415322,
0.0582303442,
-0.0307448842,
-0.1409615874,
-0.5158027411,
-0.2551392913,
-0.4178377092,
-0.2816590667,
0.4183908701,
0.3144246042,
0.4282622039,
0.3054366708,
-0.1847802252,
0.9456853271,
0.3056686223,
-0.1154872477,
0.0917783901,
-0.3752987683,
-0.0559312478,
0.2278804928,
0.4521919787,
0.1764881462,
-0.2007277906,
-0.1586773098,
-0.3590569198,
-0.3898616135,
0.3303698003,
-1.0422422886,
-0.5804416537,
-0.2191837281,
-0.57514292,
-0.5811886191,
0.2322746515,
-0.9456166625,
-0.4268464744,
-0.2985707819,
0.4627404213,
-0.2400138974,
-0.2996656597,
0.0448010899,
-0.5836298466,
-0.1654209197,
0.3767679036,
-1.2140864134,
0.2541057467,
0.6582999229,
1.0030487776,
-0.3639619052,
0.1420166343,
-0.3220986426,
0.0933824033,
-0.0345177613,
0.3603660166,
-0.9221605062,
-0.6255882978,
-0.2730264366,
-0.2495508641,
0.0710911006,
-0.7391764522,
0.5242266655,
-0.7700683475,
0.0338594802,
-0.2343090475,
-0.4886952937,
-0.176160872,
0.1057358086,
-0.9033495784,
1.2282266617,
0.1054694876,
-0.7264786959,
0.434075743,
-0.2209039479,
-0.258356899,
0.4218449891,
-0.2522470057,
-0.2685999572,
0.239751786,
0.176173538,
0.2362375408,
-0.4392175376,
0.5994389653,
0.0220266506,
-0.6121669412,
-0.1147614717,
-0.8466604948,
0.637134552,
0.3918581307,
-0.2393906116,
-0.4983041286,
-0.6408772469,
-0.0639316663,
-0.0621535555,
-0.8502935171,
-0.7552416325,
0.0223154463,
0.0577605516,
-0.1168051511,
0.151278317,
-0.6030367017,
0.5049396157,
-0.0120931892,
0.4029988945,
0.548286736,
-0.0029448185,
0.4416363835,
-0.0438803397,
0.4713501632,
-0.0193792377,
0.0489904992,
0.1253309399,
-0.5525709391,
-0.4388886392,
-0.4244991243,
0.6544437408,
0.2522375286,
-1.0569841862,
0.3913946748,
-0.4852688611,
-0.4098090231,
-0.7086113095,
0.0617617667,
0.4016897678,
0.5743227601,
0.5471288562,
-0.1138070673,
-0.4118413925,
-0.4776501954,
-0.0426137559,
-0.2539685071,
-0.1298863441,
0.0542264991,
0.3453162313,
0.0340270624,
0.9252247214,
-0.9248629808,
-0.2562628388,
-0.4274021089,
0.1746175736,
0.4023230672,
0.2892874479,
0.6448390484,
-1.2568949461,
-0.7615454793,
0.0185401756,
-0.5015924573,
0.0049938941,
0.1889166832,
-0.3109924197,
-0.3754921854,
0.4208919108,
-0.1122270525,
0.3558947444,
0.4430351555,
-0.0852245539,
0.0013377112,
-0.3473319411,
0.3544046879,
-1.1022816896,
0.1685092598,
-0.2330386043,
-0.1454818547,
-0.5626904368,
-0.0731497779,
0.0036713902,
-0.1371619105,
-0.0919384286,
0.1671857834,
-0.4207542837,
0.2244764715,
-0.3976661563,
0.0239133053,
0.3729641736,
0.0683014318,
0.0147881722,
0.8614422083,
0.4650043547,
-0.602551043,
0.4249488413,
0.4315553606,
-0.3321708441,
0.4808789194,
-0.7417395115,
0.0773820505,
-0.6947265863,
0.4222832024,
-1.0576423407,
0.1548326313,
-0.020625582,
-0.2783723176,
0.7082545757,
-0.466455698,
-0.3473663926,
-0.325861603,
-0.1474870294,
0.335113138,
0.6885527968,
-0.863861084,
0.2813489437,
0.2419756204,
-0.2195321769,
-0.6146509051,
-0.6694597602,
0.2853744924,
-0.2630775273,
-0.0081379227,
0.8729122877,
0.1034940928,
-0.0233054776,
-0.0742382631,
-0.2084436566,
-0.1369947493,
0.1816243082,
-0.1766434908,
0.0993329361,
0.206255734,
0.2826515734,
0.2276754826,
-0.1520685107,
-0.360468328,
-0.3514018953,
0.3188721538,
0.3247513175,
-0.1820222884,
-0.0106895808,
0.4970452189,
0.3796654642,
-0.2360428572,
0.6523153782,
0.3794004917,
-0.2044253945,
-0.2326472551,
-0.3466697037,
-0.2771826982,
-0.5179253817,
0.3466728926,
-0.5066165924,
-0.6822912693,
0.2720741034,
-0.0545337014,
-0.2580987513,
0.2677797973,
0.2923671901,
-0.003997399,
0.9651094675,
0.5722526908,
-0.0732300133,
0.6449972391,
-0.3645596206,
0.1404232085,
-0.8025379777,
-0.524345994,
-0.5836955309,
-0.4491754472,
-0.6630371213,
-0.4195454419,
0.6085907817,
0.4166446626,
0.2549719214,
0.3427072465,
-0.9956789613,
0.5259689093,
0.5672509074,
0.2664435506,
0.6541851163,
0.2220969349,
-0.3497610092,
-0.000947018,
-0.70009166,
-0.5556527376,
1.0094343424,
0.1038694233,
1.0661435127,
0.3560402095,
1.1249536276,
0.3352843523,
0.3646474779,
-0.4994307458,
0.4165549278,
-0.5209854245,
-0.8040064573,
-0.3373835385,
-0.5394545197,
-0.9924509525,
0.712813139,
0.0868127793,
-0.3933198452,
0.2653925717,
0.0446383506,
-0.2261793613,
0.1590789109,
-0.531912148,
0.6785227656,
-0.2603873014,
-0.2373777628,
-0.0346211717,
-0.514816761,
0.0911471397,
0.0625973269,
-0.4397833645,
0.1337162405,
0.031639941,
0.4164880812,
-0.4324991405,
0.5834359527,
-0.4452545643,
-0.2004219294,
0.4017005861,
-0.2537864149,
0.4139100909,
0.1131900847,
-0.4645431936,
-0.0133310482,
-0.1086748019,
-0.1185418889,
-0.8440077305,
0.8150212765,
-0.4275708199,
-0.8783944249,
-0.5321863294,
0.0073291371,
0.1144609004,
0.1492912471,
0.3248396218,
0.2829796672,
-0.1546582878,
0.4951486886,
0.8009694815,
-0.0194030944,
0.5011447668,
0.2895691395,
-0.0980802551,
-0.383692354,
0.8826118112,
0.2260553092,
0.3165977895,
0.7846574187,
0.198019594,
-0.6988471746,
-0.9056620002,
-0.6151043177,
-0.2743769288,
-0.7616915107,
-0.3698802292,
-0.6859935522,
-0.2909644842,
-0.367181927,
0.3349994719,
-0.1025156751,
-0.3342066109,
-0.4125127792,
-0.3545122445,
0.6796938777,
0.6909664869,
0.1707620621,
-0.0338590071,
-0.8950579762,
0.2654616237,
0.4598300755,
0.4770642221,
0.3147521913,
-0.5868217349,
-0.0466976911,
-0.0093687624,
-0.5005928874,
-0.9633801579,
0.3136893809,
0.5826519728,
0.878929019,
0.1662952304,
0.321602881,
0.7623208761,
-0.5571447015,
0.6550472975,
0.1097657979,
-0.6905480623,
0.6607267857,
-0.2429611683,
0.1973436922,
0.9878475666,
0.6314882636,
-0.4004134834,
-0.2366390824,
-0.1181301028,
-1.035910964,
0.4395724535,
0.4609872699,
0.2875718176,
-0.329113096,
0.5594193339,
0.4653867185,
0.4187777936,
-0.6130058169,
-0.4045751095,
-0.3078630865,
-0.3039332032,
-0.1609275341,
-0.186189279,
0.0268636961,
-0.4235695899,
0.3961278796,
-0.0142918136,
0.0647195578,
0.3323040307,
0.0170971006,
0.3665948808,
0.3139029145,
-0.0173443183,
0.4379919469,
-0.3220576942,
0.3732711375,
-0.050702814,
-0.8483695388,
0.5167205334,
0.4238414466,
-0.4394928515,
0.3151763976,
-0.0036668018,
0.6759881377,
0.0258289166,
-0.1891443431,
0.4671851397,
-0.060218025,
-0.0414171629,
-0.0867787898,
0.121936731,
-0.0396342501,
0.2591014802,
0.9188805223,
-0.4356077015,
0.7346009612,
-0.4958150387,
0.391446054,
0.2522489429,
-0.3088588119,
-0.1106019169,
0.8498973846,
0.437930733,
0.0937100202,
0.7431187034,
-0.2377653122,
-0.4498204589,
0.3897521496,
0.5654390454,
0.9108641744,
-0.1124442443,
0.3741983175,
0.4942194819,
-0.078203477,
-0.4049891531,
0.1661786437,
-0.5131434202,
-0.2259030491,
-0.1515326798,
-0.9404571652,
-0.1372362524,
-0.0968620479,
-0.8974527121,
-0.0063866088,
0.0376756638,
-0.5202960968,
-0.0700259432,
-0.1575318277,
-0.3384232521,
0.0857731998,
0.1576959193,
0.633345902,
-0.5187504292,
0.7988559604,
0.5649330616,
-0.5287111998,
-0.3655509353,
0.2478207946,
-0.2382615954,
-0.2775417864,
1.0148632526,
0.0512937047,
-0.0405967645,
0.3807423413,
-0.009387604,
-0.900116086,
1.5350905657,
0.3426238298,
-0.8614298701,
-0.1609054804,
0.007311888,
0.7265476584,
-0.0410314091,
0.4664702713,
0.5025469065,
0.3861078024,
0.5387988091,
-0.8755535483,
0.13006486,
-0.2586972117,
0.6873033047,
0.3436223567,
-0.471447438,
0.7753680348,
-0.0356556401,
-0.4255591929,
0.0422306992,
0.5066182613,
0.0458829291,
0.2949057519,
0.2171864212,
0.7161464095,
0.7207792401,
-0.3930702806,
1.0730336905,
-0.0829498395,
0.2978445292,
0.8967679143,
-0.1853313595,
0.802220583,
0.6010612845,
-0.4143811464,
0.3764566779,
0.3973754346,
-0.0025694589,
1.1856458187,
0.4473137856,
-0.6830810905,
-0.090412125,
-0.1201728433,
-0.6228170395,
0.4136609733,
0.079366833,
-0.6973141432,
-0.3464919925,
0.1443873793,
-0.3685921133,
0.2799885571,
-0.1694248915,
0.9300615191,
0.1049495786,
-0.8365657926,
0.8032623529,
-0.1596331596,
0.7721652389,
-0.3092094064,
-0.4718889296,
-0.3382351398,
0.2668727934,
-0.1301143914,
-0.6457288861,
0.0779477432,
0.0510917753,
-0.2518669665,
-0.6016100049,
0.5493468046,
-0.8580281734,
-0.4333177209,
0.27747491,
0.3363521993,
0.1141073406,
0.030493604,
-0.4733102918,
-0.1202291325,
-0.0568987727,
-0.2214354575,
0.4787200391,
0.4989784658,
0.2891196012,
0.3379015923,
0.3793261349,
-0.04265384,
0.0219750293,
0.4763286114,
1.1166642904,
-0.4023825526,
-0.3564478755,
-0.9317480922,
0.4827741385,
-0.3014548421,
0.024189949,
0.8289299011,
0.5609047413,
0.8811610341,
-0.0457260683,
0.8580812812,
-0.1982116401,
0.2475395054,
-0.4253373444,
0.8731142879,
-0.5012755394,
0.3011823595,
-0.2819297612,
-1.0328868628,
-0.0357721671,
0.5734955668,
-0.163288936,
0.2093227506,
0.3950733542,
0.7030695677,
0.0003407695,
-0.2650764585,
0.3765438497,
-0.3056173623,
0.3748755753,
0.3759051859,
0.877872169,
-0.5797699094,
0.7181464434,
-0.0257764831,
-0.2586886287,
-0.3191895187,
-0.7626220584,
-0.7482964993,
-0.6988496184,
-0.2628537714,
-0.0701683164,
0.3629532754,
0.4884073138,
0.5649956465,
-0.5444581509,
0.2181942761,
-0.3410580158,
0.0260855183,
-0.2909359932,
-0.2508628666,
0.096976839,
-0.3270694017,
-1.1465623379,
0.350710839,
0.1062602326,
0.3604020178,
-0.2485972941,
-0.0290892813,
-0.2552897632,
-0.351821214,
0.5996143222,
-0.2277877033,
-0.5041059852,
-0.0948154554,
0.0005311013,
-0.2837737501,
-0.0261439662,
0.886421144,
-0.7397859693,
0.7429968715,
0.8287649751,
0.6629554629,
0.7225235105,
0.3720472753,
0.6307579279,
-0.8093857765,
-0.0442372635,
0.552775085,
0.0444922708,
0.3466770649,
-0.4761789143,
0.4330796897,
0.1293587834,
-0.3233017623,
-0.797924161,
0.0895070583,
-0.5860203505,
-0.2279873043,
1.0463172197,
-0.3396432698,
0.2086975873,
-0.0516594015,
-0.1675302833,
0.3026402891,
-0.4470160604,
0.9874866009,
0.6416732669,
0.1276126802,
-0.0654318333,
-0.3294157684,
0.5979558825,
0.1931066066,
-0.5227698684,
-0.0084368419,
0.5512595773,
0.025546113,
0.0631750301,
0.6004428267,
-0.4069755673,
-0.1658483297,
0.1667446494,
-0.206420809,
-0.1679365784,
-0.4508766532,
-0.375505209,
0.2296555042,
0.2224808633,
-0.3470620811
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10767v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10767v1
|
Inference to the Best Explanation in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-16T15:41:23 | 2024-02-16T15:41:23 |
Dhairya Dalal, Marco Valentino, André Freitas, Paul Buitelaar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
While Large Language Models (LLMs) have found success in real-world
applications, their underlying explanatory process is still poorly understood.
This paper proposes IBE-Eval, a framework inspired by philosophical accounts on
Inference to the Best Explanation (IBE) to advance the interpretation and
evaluation of LLMs' explanations. IBE-Eval estimates the plausibility of
natural language explanations through a combination of explicit logical and
linguistic features including: consistency, parsimony, coherence, and
uncertainty. Extensive experiments are conducted on Causal Question Answering
(CQA), where \textit{IBE-Eval} is tasked to select the most plausible causal
explanation amongst competing ones generated by LLMs (i.e., GPT 3.5 and Llama
2). The experiments reveal that IBE-Eval can successfully identify the best
explanation with up to 77\% accuracy ($\approx 27\%$ above random), improving
upon a GPT 3.5-as-a-Judge baseline ($\approx+17\%$) while being intrinsically
more efficient and interpretable. Additional analyses suggest that, despite
model-specific variances, LLM-generated explanations tend to conform to IBE
criteria and that IBE-Eval is significantly correlated with human judgment,
opening up opportunities for future development of automated explanation
verification tools.
|
[
-0.4959624708,
-0.9212316275,
1.0353950262,
0.2759929895,
-0.0875902101,
-0.1327214241,
-0.4217316508,
-0.4613595605,
-0.1805379242,
0.2308434248,
-0.3587133288,
-0.3695766926,
-0.5901834965,
0.1381389648,
-0.5496984124,
0.9122350216,
-0.0520729497,
0.0091733607,
-0.2298364043,
0.1494153142,
-0.2619715929,
-0.134458676,
-0.7386376262,
-0.565851748,
0.678561151,
0.1535594314,
0.7079466581,
0.6771763563,
0.3715880811,
0.2412385345,
-0.1297892779,
0.0528778397,
-0.472492069,
-0.127599135,
-0.6949615479,
-0.6144958138,
-0.1964170188,
-0.087597467,
0.4966770411,
0.839905858,
-0.2726751864,
-0.0363783464,
0.0232532974,
0.5223135352,
-0.6489632726,
0.0769569427,
-0.5909716487,
-0.3089657724,
0.1431238949,
-0.0858201683,
-0.7041876912,
-0.5147950053,
0.1460844576,
-0.3788914382,
0.0561766215,
0.3646646738,
1.0232076645,
0.0991718099,
-0.5113341212,
-0.2939943075,
-0.9181081653,
0.731107533,
-0.8657516837,
0.4466035366,
0.3201659918,
0.5187771916,
-0.2715214491,
-0.735930562,
-0.7858986259,
-0.3584136367,
-0.0656258538,
0.2087979615,
-0.2390989214,
0.3418016732,
0.1794602871,
0.3466733694,
-0.6045721173,
0.3645663857,
-0.085506998,
-0.1628341675,
0.75154531,
-0.0731902122,
0.2993867993,
0.0177096501,
-0.5317604542,
0.134336561,
-0.8854724169,
0.0753950328,
0.1311332434,
-0.2614167035,
0.0048077968,
0.4235921502,
-0.1116589606,
0.643765986,
0.0795327798,
-0.0277241394,
-0.3350729346,
-0.0399562158,
-0.4335967302,
0.0260898191,
0.7969735265,
0.3082734644,
0.2479972094,
-0.2634188235,
-0.3221696317,
0.175760299,
-0.0735715479,
-0.6621286869,
-0.0798898563,
0.407844156,
-0.433552295,
-0.1284469068,
0.0226122141,
-0.7108579874,
-0.3683095574,
-0.6342869401,
0.4766540527,
-0.4226531386,
-0.175842762,
0.1506124586,
0.0092460671,
0.3202374279,
0.3849640787,
-0.7986446023,
0.2413877696,
0.8333163857,
0.4916798174,
-0.0490805842,
-0.2772853673,
-0.5808243155,
0.1961612105,
-0.5645234585,
1.0640226603,
-0.6944446564,
-0.0149003835,
-0.2465525866,
-0.2029643059,
-0.0696646571,
-0.4327250123,
0.7324454188,
-0.6253254414,
0.2618136406,
-0.2383420467,
-0.905156374,
-0.5280649662,
-0.1414806098,
-0.3373402655,
0.8796693087,
-0.1542609483,
-0.4115278125,
0.3639285564,
-0.8493967056,
-0.1453046352,
-0.0067025181,
0.0563504063,
0.0640952066,
0.4755074084,
0.351221621,
0.4151936173,
-0.7495636344,
0.9317253828,
-0.4282862246,
-0.1832008064,
0.5069838762,
-0.895837009,
0.79826051,
0.3931444883,
-0.3466537297,
-0.0705704093,
-0.6292429566,
-0.0135265114,
0.0809475183,
-0.0404387452,
-0.2993734479,
0.2236565351,
-0.274815768,
0.0099420473,
0.1037875935,
-0.4771628082,
-0.1543744504,
-0.5597222447,
0.1455346495,
0.897284925,
0.0470919162,
0.3360358775,
-0.1178478971,
0.5447186232,
-0.3120611012,
0.1282524318,
-0.2039091885,
-0.268805474,
-0.2614114881,
-0.4278124869,
0.1733368635,
0.430499047,
-0.540851593,
0.3614996374,
-0.2211339176,
-0.3794039488,
-0.4467957914,
0.1899148077,
0.5484349728,
0.5750164986,
0.1362472475,
0.1154604629,
-0.3672302067,
-1.1967014074,
-0.6339809299,
-0.5029172301,
-0.2290411443,
0.1336477399,
0.5675612092,
-0.1322520226,
1.186365366,
-0.3254120946,
0.6008415818,
-0.4314424396,
0.2507891059,
0.3844717741,
0.1127700433,
0.4833211899,
-0.8629158735,
-0.4262516201,
0.0448202975,
-0.7100824714,
-0.6574553847,
-0.2568030655,
-0.3789634705,
-0.1049691215,
0.1870692521,
-0.3532864153,
0.2162408233,
0.4472387135,
-0.2752263844,
0.8019687533,
-0.1686019599,
0.0244336948,
-0.7911089659,
0.0368547849,
0.1175655574,
-0.2677631676,
-0.670396626,
0.2606677115,
0.0455201752,
0.2453702837,
-0.2431885749,
0.8821728826,
-0.3458898664,
0.0386657193,
-0.28901577,
0.4822691679,
0.2484119385,
0.3015886545,
0.0782894492,
0.5435721278,
0.6677880287,
-0.5665631294,
0.358912468,
0.012647761,
-0.3590109646,
0.5705725551,
-0.5896424055,
-0.1178620979,
-0.4046086967,
0.3186792731,
-1.0977998972,
-0.5708144903,
-0.0235907342,
-0.3859289289,
0.19963938,
0.0549623929,
-0.3175630867,
-0.4043319523,
-0.0810928345,
0.2128182799,
0.4257864058,
-0.9786362052,
0.7902004123,
0.1108159646,
-0.1453338563,
-0.5174853206,
-0.542301774,
0.1438999921,
-0.3579799235,
-0.7061355114,
-0.0864378586,
-0.2491083294,
-0.7601226568,
-0.2015231103,
-0.2136898637,
-0.2327943593,
0.3705467284,
-0.0380123928,
0.3673459291,
-0.5856303573,
0.1787591577,
0.1466492563,
-0.1420170963,
0.3212364018,
-0.0890990645,
0.1994394064,
-0.2725010216,
-0.5146372914,
-0.5192700624,
0.3116725683,
0.554207027,
-0.0428212211,
0.9606240392,
0.1912326664,
-0.3274191022,
-0.22504282,
-0.7006007433,
-0.2271346003,
-0.4359461069,
0.1456293166,
-0.3935531974,
-0.4239035547,
0.6595846415,
-0.147984162,
0.0877075344,
0.4649828672,
0.5094640851,
0.0237587318,
1.2066777945,
0.2467090636,
0.0791838318,
0.326744318,
0.0507152118,
0.689419806,
-0.8770652413,
-0.1191353723,
-0.4704526067,
-0.0450187325,
-0.3644429445,
-0.2637878954,
0.2891966701,
0.4091952741,
-0.2256740928,
-0.0356341861,
-0.1539647281,
0.8165478706,
0.3248121142,
-0.057209935,
0.2934912443,
-0.1670312732,
-0.0863946751,
0.2718259692,
-0.4827998877,
-0.8791649342,
0.7396408319,
0.3961950839,
0.8748716712,
0.210815981,
0.5277707577,
0.0331035256,
0.7314879298,
-0.5694600344,
0.5201240182,
0.2237648964,
-0.795373559,
-0.2821798027,
-0.3259687126,
-0.8565836549,
0.5277429223,
-0.042573709,
-1.1921180487,
0.0471716076,
0.3931329846,
-0.2327534407,
0.2391762137,
-0.9845671058,
0.816704452,
-0.4277619123,
-0.6216109991,
-0.2181794941,
-0.5415514112,
0.6649982333,
-0.1151466668,
0.528873086,
-0.0598945357,
0.0292965807,
0.4655299187,
-0.2986696362,
0.6409184933,
-0.2313650399,
-0.4138301015,
0.4025983512,
0.182164982,
0.6737344861,
0.1334195584,
-0.3394697607,
0.121914275,
-0.0743568987,
-0.3631190062,
-0.9886723161,
0.5259433985,
-0.3978869915,
-0.8172084689,
-0.1251975,
-0.4565061927,
-0.2117586136,
-0.1240169033,
0.1559455544,
0.5911370516,
-0.0803322718,
0.2416253239,
0.6520199776,
-0.5961860418,
0.3147541881,
0.7817221284,
-0.4669208825,
-0.0843141079,
0.8225257397,
-0.3178203106,
0.4614716768,
0.6951428652,
0.7752022743,
-0.5839853287,
-0.6768374443,
-0.4111891985,
0.3348586559,
-0.7568769455,
0.0982425064,
-0.4863855541,
-0.0103411376,
-0.1022915095,
-0.3967159092,
-0.1910516918,
-0.1367127597,
0.0882023722,
-0.4265980721,
0.0993253142,
0.6916976571,
-0.2097330242,
0.4144382477,
-0.5508514047,
0.4122100174,
0.1341541559,
0.2698444128,
0.2281779945,
-0.5609996319,
-0.0950434059,
0.2852977514,
-0.0946054757,
-0.9504344463,
0.3089065552,
0.2303241044,
0.6368325949,
0.7906224728,
0.0062295492,
0.8335811496,
-0.4092556238,
0.8617374301,
0.288482368,
-1.0877346992,
0.5801203251,
-0.3202321827,
0.1028309688,
0.2041006386,
0.2149499953,
-0.5833461881,
-0.8491607308,
-0.637578249,
-0.9796034098,
0.4710554481,
0.1551604271,
-0.1629663408,
-0.2190607339,
0.4693021476,
0.5297791958,
-0.0306273028,
-0.915394187,
0.0706655905,
0.3836200535,
-0.4454090595,
-0.0129143884,
-0.2261098027,
0.0372962169,
-0.0287007503,
0.8009831905,
-0.2156906128,
0.4190666974,
0.1603105664,
-0.2903500497,
-0.1092061996,
0.3649170697,
0.614790082,
1.2292408943,
0.1831492335,
0.4019599855,
0.2356213629,
0.033118289,
-0.0627650321,
-0.0436645746,
-0.0177573375,
-0.1902817488,
0.866435349,
0.9547887444,
0.0693662688,
-0.9112608433,
0.5050109029,
-0.0206563007,
0.0638768747,
-0.2162302434,
0.2006285489,
0.1482741684,
0.3015206158,
0.5294722915,
-0.2552930117,
0.2659233809,
-0.5527399182,
0.0697344393,
0.5483421683,
0.1168724224,
-0.493065834,
0.9135760069,
-0.0635099411,
-0.1940177828,
0.0356950089,
0.0041558482,
-0.5061450005,
0.7960045338,
0.500944674,
0.7836691737,
-0.3834367394,
0.2460398227,
0.2740834951,
0.1024787351,
-0.2395112514,
0.1103689,
0.0778077692,
-0.6595897675,
-0.8286135793,
-0.8270205259,
-0.4137151539,
0.0762156695,
-0.7811607718,
-0.0014995565,
-0.0120026888,
0.4491195083,
0.2007197589,
-0.4319120944,
-0.5625425577,
0.2414304912,
0.1337254196,
0.9585958123,
-1.0520293713,
0.4753247499,
0.380669415,
-0.1831441373,
-1.0627512932,
0.0417170525,
0.0258911774,
-1.0191925764,
0.7407337427,
0.0010565633,
-0.1466435939,
-0.1317866892,
-0.8038218021,
-0.7889248729,
0.7706499696,
0.7688401937,
-0.7717639208,
0.2335767895,
-0.1355748326,
0.6797968745,
-0.216783613,
0.6812849641,
0.688154459,
0.718673408,
0.1055974737,
-0.7981754541,
0.0224271957,
0.1323109716,
0.0860444456,
0.2669787407,
-0.4182033241,
0.2050800323,
-0.3157519698,
-0.0997453034,
0.0904609859,
0.6883174181,
0.0753538162,
0.5818921924,
0.3627498448,
0.2878289819,
1.0524638891,
-0.1512682885,
1.5345641375,
-0.395526737,
0.4263940454,
1.0293695927,
-0.2109279484,
0.7166054249,
0.4979251325,
-0.2030211687,
0.6690574288,
0.8617690802,
0.40461573,
0.4228307009,
0.1351135671,
-0.4526812434,
-0.3714566827,
-0.0488845408,
0.1917899847,
0.3654164374,
0.3062851131,
-0.5070273876,
-0.3111416101,
0.1946020722,
-0.0042035561,
0.0478413664,
-0.3234283924,
0.7223454118,
0.187669456,
-0.9820071459,
0.5245703459,
-0.1641803831,
-0.026751034,
-0.5720695853,
-0.0199084319,
-0.3393036723,
0.2342575043,
-0.0740757212,
-0.9527897239,
0.1003564969,
0.2496328801,
-0.0222072285,
-0.301954776,
0.6070862412,
-0.4179562628,
-0.3588214815,
0.3343535066,
0.481518358,
0.4307110906,
0.098414436,
-0.3836046457,
-0.1699544936,
0.0571371354,
-0.6004080772,
0.1686326861,
0.6872683167,
-0.1836569011,
0.9022865891,
0.5192008018,
0.1091952398,
0.0367246866,
-0.0338158756,
0.51506567,
-0.5495501757,
-0.4184879065,
-1.2622151375,
0.5701972246,
0.0529359765,
0.0546841882,
0.4872820675,
0.5028493404,
0.4194675684,
0.0913363174,
0.8379613757,
-0.096260041,
0.3464711905,
-0.7743762732,
0.1977381408,
-0.5509306192,
0.5121141076,
-0.057487186,
-0.9837556481,
-0.172901988,
0.7520200014,
-0.5745175481,
-0.0617489368,
0.9793337584,
0.7501718402,
-0.2226011157,
0.314050436,
0.3439429402,
0.7195939422,
0.5309900641,
0.5523221493,
0.913520515,
0.1049279645,
0.3049683869,
0.0897024497,
-0.4230230451,
-0.2128606588,
-1.122087121,
-0.6716546416,
-0.1803273112,
-0.3170493543,
-0.1640767455,
-0.0265984684,
0.9481320381,
0.35507828,
-0.8150746822,
-0.0554969981,
-0.3073450625,
0.4435694516,
-0.4100999236,
-0.2870393693,
0.4038178325,
-0.2263941765,
-0.7659537196,
0.4747969806,
0.4182103574,
-0.3676297665,
-0.142844364,
-0.1816201955,
-0.0063713142,
0.5107795,
0.6956053376,
0.16933842,
-1.1350195408,
-0.6913431287,
-0.295183301,
0.1774697006,
0.0374937281,
0.6294712424,
-0.5428282619,
0.5256951451,
0.3809022009,
0.7325329781,
0.2090548873,
0.1113774702,
0.831178546,
-0.326790899,
-0.2852059603,
0.1512373388,
0.5650616288,
0.0937207043,
-0.2253040969,
0.5999773741,
-0.015971167,
-0.5732293129,
-0.9607471824,
0.3389760554,
-0.8327278495,
-0.3813995421,
1.3776510954,
-0.2652449012,
-0.4531077445,
-0.0122939451,
-0.3155312538,
0.0125910649,
-0.3557690084,
0.8328496814,
0.9793140888,
-0.3906833827,
-0.262506187,
-0.7450896502,
-0.0320468731,
0.4019750953,
-0.9288945794,
0.2842397392,
0.6225351691,
0.2250278145,
-0.0088893352,
0.2235605717,
0.1962715834,
0.2826121747,
-0.20089522,
-0.1445836872,
0.2067922354,
-0.2110249549,
-0.3259342015,
0.085629791,
0.3245954514,
0.2091891319
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10753v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10753v1
|
ToolSword: Unveiling Safety Issues of Large Language Models in Tool Learning Across Three Stages
| 2024-02-16T15:19:46 | 2024-02-16T15:19:46 |
Junjie Ye, Sixian Li, Guanyu Li, Caishuang Huang, Songyang Gao, Yilong Wu, Qi Zhang, Tao Gui, Xuanjing Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Tool learning is widely acknowledged as a foundational approach or deploying
large language models (LLMs) in real-world scenarios. While current research
primarily emphasizes leveraging tools to augment LLMs, it frequently neglects
emerging safety considerations tied to their application. To fill this gap, we
present $ToolSword$, a comprehensive framework dedicated to meticulously
investigating safety issues linked to LLMs in tool learning. Specifically,
ToolSword delineates six safety scenarios for LLMs in tool learning,
encompassing $malicious$ $queries$ and $jailbreak$ $attacks$ in the input
stage, $noisy$ $misdirection$ and $risky$ $cues$ in the execution stage, and
$harmful$ $feedback$ and $error$ $conflicts$ in the output stage. Experiments
conducted on 11 open-source and closed-source LLMs reveal enduring safety
challenges in tool learning, such as handling harmful queries, employing risky
tools, and delivering detrimental feedback, which even GPT-4 is susceptible to.
Moreover, we conduct further studies with the aim of fostering research on tool
learning safety. The data is released in
https://github.com/Junjie-Ye/ToolSword.
|
[
0.0129433023,
-0.7763488889,
0.5596184134,
0.0032123455,
-0.3826069832,
0.2579428256,
-0.0358643457,
-0.4352881908,
-0.6318156719,
0.6249579787,
-0.4071284235,
-0.7983874083,
-0.6162366867,
-0.0339048877,
-0.7417708635,
1.0462015867,
-0.1587585211,
0.1128741503,
0.0020845595,
0.1317391694,
-0.5661731958,
-0.6330165267,
-0.7180710435,
-0.0079042194,
0.6769374013,
0.3395065963,
0.4484509826,
0.6353423595,
0.4801382422,
0.315744102,
-0.0572077632,
-0.2728718519,
-0.4944535792,
0.4146463275,
-0.1557453126,
-0.639560461,
-0.3387892544,
0.2732059658,
0.3320852816,
0.6249716282,
-0.2281711251,
-0.1629116833,
0.3048510253,
0.0672916621,
-0.606197238,
-0.0166145992,
-0.8848170638,
0.0402378775,
-0.3598199189,
-0.1068180948,
-0.5107941628,
-0.4841419458,
0.0266936235,
-0.4213818908,
0.1235852093,
-0.0130970217,
0.5086947083,
0.1772304177,
-0.4796581268,
-0.366658181,
-0.2731752992,
0.7311862111,
-0.7916334271,
0.3398361504,
0.4562644958,
0.4805183113,
-0.4992646575,
-0.8159116507,
-0.4303621352,
-0.0747874603,
0.2541764081,
-0.1687884927,
0.3276084661,
0.1874667406,
0.587469697,
0.0654212385,
-0.3392384946,
0.4707458615,
-0.6978011131,
-0.3655657172,
0.7157880068,
0.2499997765,
0.2704815269,
0.0427824706,
-0.2837257087,
-0.3790921569,
-1.0026270151,
-0.2992064953,
0.6417714953,
0.32174173,
-0.4372561872,
0.2468677759,
0.2869569063,
0.554504931,
-0.3971140683,
-0.5107879043,
0.4381237924,
-0.2412670106,
-0.1743309498,
0.0802508295,
0.8656855226,
0.4577569067,
0.0549815036,
-0.3988518417,
-0.3042698503,
-0.2591874301,
0.506713748,
-0.8322342634,
-0.2590573728,
0.2445292473,
-0.0549035482,
-0.836719811,
-0.175671488,
-0.4791670144,
-0.9160961509,
0.1383505613,
0.510248065,
-0.2999302745,
-0.3842645586,
0.0133406445,
-0.0057449169,
0.4898468256,
0.1620839387,
-0.4170224071,
0.0571031086,
0.7698888183,
0.8436650634,
-0.2706608772,
-0.454778105,
-0.741792202,
0.1764807105,
-0.4100626111,
0.3002915084,
-0.2619659305,
-0.9079497457,
0.1871218979,
0.3473594785,
0.1775611341,
-0.3797622621,
0.4272451401,
-0.3882058859,
0.2123055309,
-0.1841288954,
-0.3293001056,
-0.3733685911,
0.2245315611,
-0.6618663669,
0.89616853,
-0.2056002766,
-0.8512791991,
0.6800650954,
-0.4893348515,
-0.6437225938,
-0.0982887149,
-0.304984957,
-0.5451876521,
-0.0003494601,
-0.2841356993,
0.6329323053,
-0.1108176187,
0.3165676892,
-0.6087135077,
-0.1701217741,
0.1545924246,
-0.3336642683,
0.8091742396,
0.0792602673,
-0.4069389105,
0.3943487704,
-0.4487251639,
-0.3207472265,
0.2864921689,
-0.3362088799,
-0.1968162656,
0.1266106516,
0.0769505799,
0.4617662728,
0.0379920006,
-0.7901756167,
-0.0860538855,
-0.567856133,
0.4363358319,
0.8605158329,
-0.0264263786,
0.2254288495,
0.1456743926,
0.5824625492,
0.2127513885,
0.3232429624,
-0.1473111659,
-0.0840590522,
-0.3089897037,
0.4269077778,
0.2860791385,
0.5333830118,
-0.8068609834,
0.0276105125,
0.1535094678,
-0.5006740689,
-0.1373694539,
0.3531500399,
0.6016855836,
0.3279864192,
0.0597925633,
-0.3541429341,
-0.3885191679,
-0.6733436584,
-0.3789584935,
-0.1401699334,
0.0205017887,
0.021240849,
0.3865778446,
-0.0457831435,
0.5828595161,
-0.4280801713,
-0.137199536,
-0.3691768944,
0.0347760133,
-0.1440845728,
0.5515685081,
0.5473824143,
-0.7240440845,
-0.2168505043,
-0.090916045,
-0.660387218,
0.2367514223,
0.0118217524,
0.0820793509,
0.299382925,
1.1367263794,
-0.2436161041,
0.3030798435,
0.4473199248,
-0.089218013,
0.5589877367,
0.0524330437,
-0.5551422238,
-1.3857854605,
-0.0138991205,
0.0010408942,
-0.2193468362,
-0.4563879073,
0.2253613025,
0.1854786277,
-0.0616749413,
-0.9151351452,
0.3934942782,
-0.3586716354,
0.0784692913,
-0.3376803398,
0.3306114078,
-0.3348018229,
0.0332480222,
-0.2605822384,
1.0549246073,
0.6309899688,
-0.2792142928,
0.22846587,
-0.1806689948,
-0.2339024544,
0.1618623883,
-0.8511354923,
0.2614358664,
0.2536175251,
-0.0785222799,
-0.5996820927,
-0.438277483,
0.2018847466,
-0.308440119,
0.3627738059,
-0.1539854258,
-1.0627866983,
-0.2251885682,
-0.3902468085,
-0.0195216592,
0.3836209774,
-0.2529266775,
0.4141976833,
0.7594508529,
-0.3073889315,
-0.7162028551,
-0.195766747,
0.1025865674,
-0.4817520678,
-0.1507277042,
-0.3358790278,
-0.0133046545,
-0.2191092223,
-0.2944661677,
-0.3754091859,
0.0662720352,
0.8174342513,
0.4526247382,
0.2272536308,
0.3719395697,
0.3161136806,
0.1389693618,
-0.0427980348,
0.6571707129,
0.1232574582,
0.4519847333,
-0.1387548298,
-0.4258042872,
0.3547309935,
0.0958270133,
0.4908730984,
-0.1859508604,
0.5349108577,
0.9090685248,
-0.3740098178,
-0.3167608082,
-0.4824040234,
-0.3424241245,
-0.5567557812,
0.5780971646,
-0.2240886539,
-1.0201812983,
0.3317151964,
-0.3950080872,
0.6932118535,
0.0832950696,
0.4647786617,
-0.1135588065,
1.1861060858,
0.9681745768,
-0.075549528,
0.3199397027,
-0.0556443594,
0.2907233536,
-0.5810930729,
-0.4206593633,
-0.4326851666,
-0.0968939364,
-0.5316882133,
-0.399143815,
0.6085491776,
0.1742829084,
-0.0359261706,
0.3301917911,
-0.138322264,
0.586920023,
0.4353675544,
-0.1267237365,
0.0968958884,
-0.1593508422,
-0.7046465278,
0.2018506527,
-0.528444469,
-0.533800602,
1.2662141323,
0.4639944434,
0.9172572494,
0.1021370366,
0.9283989072,
-0.0063877064,
0.2439840436,
-0.8056184649,
0.7689074874,
0.2095504552,
-0.7106552124,
-0.2487285435,
-0.1306699216,
-0.98951298,
0.1699505299,
-0.205521524,
-0.6955243349,
-0.288552314,
0.1002007201,
-0.1753713787,
0.4175121188,
-0.7276880741,
0.9799070358,
-0.6212475896,
-0.6755074859,
-0.2892820239,
-1.1034115553,
0.4342415035,
-0.4000991583,
0.4058335423,
-0.1776535511,
0.0068043307,
0.841824472,
-0.1540088207,
1.1565042734,
-0.140401125,
-0.3589053452,
-0.0169563852,
0.3698352277,
0.4812299013,
-0.0489460491,
0.1003828049,
0.0244145654,
0.2829638124,
-0.1179491505,
-0.1066861451,
0.6895240545,
-0.5152109265,
-0.7393203378,
-0.5382267237,
-0.6956894994,
-0.335296303,
0.604131341,
0.0151845366,
0.4404784441,
-0.0085799936,
0.2024027109,
0.7546302676,
-0.5197682977,
0.552148819,
0.4075642228,
-0.4365008473,
0.0152434809,
0.9790527821,
-0.03252884,
0.3416478038,
-0.3691344857,
-0.0337375402,
-0.1740064472,
-1.0932626724,
-0.2690974772,
0.280239135,
-0.7841520309,
-0.2401405126,
-0.5693394542,
-0.1360555291,
-0.0730416104,
-0.0795201734,
-0.1526637524,
-0.0069560548,
-0.1225620136,
-0.5216342807,
0.360992521,
0.9140701294,
-0.0269724075,
0.3494262695,
-0.8659111857,
-0.1269601136,
0.0263418537,
0.5842557549,
-0.1905749291,
0.0353569984,
-0.4948698878,
-0.3536112309,
-0.6457104683,
-0.8453797102,
0.1823604852,
-0.1245857179,
0.6752700806,
0.3928221166,
0.2168106139,
0.2414080352,
-0.5447100401,
0.7247862816,
0.3081176281,
-0.6618593931,
0.6994315982,
-0.4363407195,
0.1078811213,
0.6173457503,
0.5665026307,
-0.4855410159,
-0.5944480896,
-0.635423243,
-1.1769477129,
0.6112725139,
-0.2182698697,
0.1348919421,
-0.1818718165,
0.0922382101,
0.4105327725,
0.347745955,
-0.7043122649,
0.026250653,
0.0845371932,
-0.0204528179,
0.0609479249,
-0.0915040374,
-0.5099107623,
0.0581812039,
0.5530286431,
-0.1787285656,
-0.2524548769,
-0.4573044777,
-0.4647376537,
-0.0857470781,
0.3328946531,
0.3609525263,
0.7183040977,
-0.1490985304,
0.300075531,
0.363137424,
-0.6806285977,
-0.0003497757,
0.0674119145,
0.0346056558,
-0.2396781892,
0.3659185469,
0.6514562964,
0.3352109194,
-0.9151402712,
0.6249710917,
-0.0123868594,
-0.2043512315,
-0.4349113107,
0.3619250655,
0.2758968771,
0.0482001007,
0.166863665,
-0.2709026337,
0.2441775352,
-0.5138006806,
0.1704140753,
0.5041956306,
-0.6161891222,
-0.4231047034,
0.6386001706,
0.4861623645,
-0.1851011664,
0.2877418399,
-0.2405054271,
-0.4894280732,
0.3081849813,
0.314168632,
0.9752055407,
-0.1351029277,
-0.0279265605,
0.2242956907,
0.6637816429,
-0.0887838975,
0.3409518301,
0.1068324819,
-0.4105076492,
-0.4930444062,
-0.6196934581,
-0.449772954,
0.2690305114,
-0.4809626639,
0.2406549156,
-0.6648591161,
-0.2025863677,
-0.2719160616,
-0.2075198442,
-0.4747505784,
-0.0154645536,
-0.0034240708,
1.0134423971,
-0.9203439951,
0.8981505632,
0.796723485,
-0.3423199952,
-1.0332558155,
0.0502744466,
0.6188611388,
-0.6773533821,
0.6042608023,
0.3335827291,
-0.3902110755,
0.0353814028,
-0.77322644,
-0.4971588254,
1.129945159,
0.2285935581,
-0.6156295538,
-0.2476916462,
-0.0605553351,
0.1429161131,
0.1010828316,
-0.1224405766,
0.7199585438,
0.1473496854,
-0.1146389022,
-1.2177602053,
0.0883178413,
-0.068660222,
-0.2028493285,
0.3526993096,
-0.0622221269,
0.4819855094,
-0.3790697753,
-0.3941342533,
-0.1498565376,
0.1196659803,
0.2637471259,
0.2540354133,
0.5897573233,
0.5550565124,
0.3358285427,
-0.2258892953,
1.0258998871,
-0.2308377326,
0.0927911326,
1.0865769386,
-0.3432074487,
0.8289150596,
0.5677392483,
-0.1671370119,
0.1550122648,
0.7764155865,
0.2155160308,
0.3222655058,
0.2670122683,
-0.1446655393,
-0.3352653384,
0.1117136329,
-0.4248433709,
0.4802083969,
0.561316371,
-0.4184898436,
-0.4353164136,
0.2423284352,
0.4465623796,
-0.2171754688,
-0.0711291283,
1.0026650429,
0.3258395791,
-0.1976624429,
0.3406351805,
-0.0575935543,
0.6078488827,
-0.5178205967,
-0.232546702,
0.122170791,
0.2056726813,
-0.0361036658,
-1.0528764725,
0.1942158341,
-0.0836738274,
0.4692842662,
0.0717738792,
0.7192963958,
-0.1093062684,
-0.3538848162,
0.3930382729,
0.465759635,
0.2089327723,
0.2288504988,
-0.6995876431,
0.3806624115,
-0.275639981,
-0.009983656,
0.5842829943,
0.3895328939,
-0.1813218445,
0.8045808673,
0.5153121948,
0.1423874199,
0.2374934256,
0.0206331853,
1.0334165096,
-0.439148128,
-0.3657620847,
-0.6632493734,
0.5467557311,
-0.2924298942,
-0.1514795423,
1.0290660858,
0.3867451847,
1.1029238701,
0.0828811675,
0.9058955908,
-0.0625448227,
0.5821986794,
-0.5273412466,
0.9462929964,
-0.5034000874,
0.4482397437,
-0.4709483385,
-0.7167413831,
-0.4080421925,
0.356749773,
-0.5955159664,
0.0834948868,
0.7319173217,
0.6758981347,
-0.0464323685,
-0.1507059038,
0.2976102829,
0.3223225176,
0.3997262418,
0.1982841641,
0.6538493633,
-0.2470131665,
0.7669435143,
-0.2598620057,
0.0573438965,
-0.283816278,
-0.8995386958,
-1.0244740248,
-0.5708315372,
-0.1359734684,
-0.4663678408,
0.238807261,
0.854691267,
0.4857770205,
-0.5775298476,
-0.4120146036,
-0.049138248,
0.1910393387,
0.1259713918,
-0.1288974434,
0.1699694544,
-0.4318527281,
-0.4650166631,
0.4500279725,
0.1700017303,
-0.0489274673,
-0.3888103366,
-0.0144284945,
0.0114233028,
-0.3747798502,
0.6263577342,
0.2449158728,
-0.7323940396,
-0.469433099,
-0.1289709508,
0.0692621768,
-0.3745217323,
0.7947726846,
-0.645260334,
0.5498515368,
0.1833403111,
0.6897266507,
0.2607889771,
-0.4269502759,
0.7360708117,
-0.9500994682,
0.1247859672,
0.2335801125,
0.3243601918,
0.4632123113,
-0.1378197819,
0.6077461839,
0.0651747212,
-0.4696424901,
-1.2103613615,
0.5519430637,
-0.7695608735,
-0.3023994863,
1.0898079872,
-0.1011924148,
0.1504013538,
-0.5487221479,
-0.1783310175,
0.3080691099,
-0.1447733492,
0.7153368592,
0.5232560039,
0.2327596098,
-0.295257628,
-1.0539351702,
0.6646498442,
0.0875228643,
-0.7248818874,
0.1972746402,
0.5998335481,
0.7055172324,
0.0108348345,
0.0097360853,
-0.4573417306,
0.4112077355,
-0.1059529036,
0.0853635892,
-0.2592739761,
-0.3880569339,
-0.2054390162,
0.2041544318,
0.6353675127,
-0.0503374301
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10744v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10744v1
|
GenRES: Rethinking Evaluation for Generative Relation Extraction in the Era of Large Language Models
| 2024-02-16T15:01:24 | 2024-02-16T15:01:24 |
Pengcheng Jiang, Jiacheng Lin, Zifeng Wang, Jimeng Sun, Jiawei Han
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The field of relation extraction (RE) is experiencing a notable shift towards
generative relation extraction (GRE), leveraging the capabilities of large
language models (LLMs). However, we discovered that traditional relation
extraction (RE) metrics like precision and recall fall short in evaluating GRE
methods. This shortfall arises because these metrics rely on exact matching
with human-annotated reference relations, while GRE methods often produce
diverse and semantically accurate relations that differ from the references. To
fill this gap, we introduce GenRES for a multi-dimensional assessment in terms
of the topic similarity, uniqueness, granularity, factualness, and completeness
of the GRE results. With GenRES, we empirically identified that (1)
precision/recall fails to justify the performance of GRE methods; (2)
human-annotated referential relations can be incomplete; (3) prompting LLMs
with a fixed set of relations or entities can cause hallucinations. Next, we
conducted a human evaluation of GRE methods that shows GenRES is consistent
with human preferences for RE quality. Last, we made a comprehensive evaluation
of fourteen leading LLMs using GenRES across document, bag, and sentence level
RE datasets, respectively, to set the benchmark for future research in GRE
|
[
-0.5558700562,
-0.5118022561,
0.6122727394,
0.1445734203,
-0.1984815449,
0.2296777666,
-0.5231990218,
-0.537050724,
0.4155849814,
0.5464559793,
-0.4823708236,
-0.7607434392,
-0.7741192579,
0.2408750802,
-0.402225554,
1.2642128468,
0.0550812706,
-0.4792073071,
-0.6622654796,
-0.1770882607,
-0.411028266,
-0.386508286,
-0.4303696454,
-0.2628529668,
0.6495862007,
-0.1084540039,
0.5971367955,
0.4612601995,
0.8587620854,
0.2492839396,
-0.0388333835,
-0.0297648199,
-0.6177249551,
0.3300525546,
-0.1231257319,
-0.2754505873,
-0.3492654562,
0.1427375972,
0.4676814079,
0.7871412635,
-0.1521257907,
0.416960299,
-0.2144634128,
0.5814076662,
-0.8429383636,
0.1341736764,
-0.7157444358,
0.1108827665,
-0.2920644283,
-0.325080812,
-0.4945131838,
-0.2619953752,
0.2255806774,
-0.5267550945,
0.5577798486,
0.0653030649,
1.1860280037,
0.1047636196,
-0.3064625561,
-0.3164804578,
-1.0769505501,
0.4916358292,
-0.3804755807,
0.6795411706,
0.4909141362,
0.273850292,
-0.0753536224,
-0.9519728422,
-0.2986854911,
-0.4516758323,
-0.0002803206,
0.1907852143,
-0.177292183,
-0.0396573357,
0.5551733971,
0.7942298055,
-0.4224743843,
-0.0279268753,
-0.2969483733,
-0.1386673301,
0.7630896568,
0.2127818018,
0.385574609,
-0.3904409707,
-0.3878129125,
0.1094774157,
-0.7482500672,
0.0131060695,
0.3353856206,
-0.0691470206,
0.2775546908,
0.3959101737,
-0.0864593536,
0.73974365,
-0.0966737121,
-0.4416705072,
0.1611546427,
-0.3710071445,
-0.1160191819,
-0.4859540761,
1.2528364658,
0.4365317225,
0.2986789644,
-0.7318297625,
-0.166358307,
0.0849666968,
0.5578992963,
-0.4503288865,
-0.3931525946,
0.0705379695,
-0.4173726439,
-0.1762059927,
0.151328519,
-1.048068881,
-0.4470718205,
-0.4103241265,
0.1945475489,
-0.3914055824,
-0.1997821927,
0.0313709714,
-0.2817314565,
0.0144616114,
0.1237734407,
-1.0845983028,
0.4276888669,
0.8607134223,
0.8331320286,
-0.2117354423,
-0.1976937056,
-0.3585638106,
0.0685981289,
-0.2774118781,
0.9265005589,
-0.7071246505,
-0.6789343357,
-0.18072474,
-0.0788104758,
-0.0557491481,
-0.6824136376,
0.7944111228,
-0.531406343,
0.1772000045,
-0.389084518,
-0.4224639535,
-0.1428544968,
0.1086917669,
-0.9016960263,
0.9679598808,
0.2088408321,
-0.5897295475,
0.6837754846,
-0.2258912474,
-0.2523023188,
0.143728286,
-0.44231534,
-0.2950781286,
0.1667259336,
0.1181848422,
0.4790360332,
-0.6747558713,
0.5377433896,
-0.3801087737,
-0.3839856684,
0.1908591688,
-0.1948920786,
0.4709920287,
0.2312158942,
0.0081111835,
0.177007556,
-0.7983517647,
-0.2298861444,
0.0006106076,
0.0139169404,
-0.5487894416,
0.2238513529,
0.1463807821,
0.1929095089,
-0.1892690063,
-0.5481167436,
0.1434182376,
-0.3438964188,
0.4460957944,
0.3252365887,
0.2493303567,
0.3864406645,
-0.3582589626,
0.8498635888,
-0.3781657219,
-0.2989135385,
-0.0561596565,
-0.1339761317,
-0.2334837615,
-0.3791560531,
0.6080688834,
0.3913754821,
-0.44727391,
0.681129694,
-0.6587925553,
-0.6522030234,
-0.591721952,
0.0650447458,
0.1023079529,
0.1803369969,
0.1340879798,
-0.6480442882,
-0.4631213844,
-0.8602327108,
-0.3149049282,
-0.1454210281,
-0.2329820246,
0.2249394655,
0.375436604,
-0.0889048204,
1.3104451895,
-0.8127501607,
-0.2891640365,
-0.2116250992,
0.2146577388,
-0.0968829393,
0.0877284706,
0.5845772028,
-0.6848557591,
-0.2373088747,
0.001401228,
-0.9288158417,
-0.0688961893,
-0.1365067661,
0.1548520774,
-0.0640290678,
0.388548255,
-0.6648839116,
0.1967833489,
0.257253468,
-0.0338385217,
0.7642306089,
0.2336691469,
0.242128402,
-1.011269331,
0.1654542834,
0.2592712641,
0.0086367512,
-0.3344088197,
0.2149402797,
-0.1852097064,
-0.1847748756,
0.2399480045,
0.421515882,
-0.5966036916,
-0.3148787916,
-0.0502437875,
0.5240004659,
0.2497964799,
0.1554054916,
0.0344789885,
0.6689844728,
0.3414665461,
-0.1842921674,
0.4809117913,
0.1306947768,
-0.6271135807,
0.4705661833,
-0.4142662287,
0.2890501916,
-0.3856747746,
0.3863202929,
-0.9236983061,
-0.2029460818,
0.2114326656,
-0.3833613992,
0.3858471811,
-0.207081452,
-0.4209358394,
-0.1151011586,
-0.3637402356,
0.322671026,
0.4847846329,
-0.1447968185,
0.5763536692,
0.3808633089,
-0.3996396065,
-0.733741641,
-0.1969026923,
0.2632143199,
-0.665500164,
-0.5327037573,
0.4197210968,
0.1899282187,
-0.621788919,
0.286072731,
-0.2316634506,
-0.1705021411,
0.1404854953,
0.1687536836,
0.1099229231,
-0.1634614319,
0.3251581788,
-0.1318228543,
-0.0018522522,
0.2502180934,
0.1445675939,
0.4943100214,
0.0251178183,
-0.036323864,
-0.1167535931,
0.2405708134,
0.638538003,
-0.5480385423,
0.3333898187,
0.7054886818,
-0.4460103214,
-0.0480879508,
-0.6512624025,
-0.1149000749,
-0.33290869,
0.6500837207,
-0.733148694,
-0.8665507436,
0.6997917295,
0.0095588788,
0.041125007,
0.6875446439,
0.2805464864,
0.0129800234,
0.1290076822,
0.504657805,
-0.1003682166,
0.2814303041,
-0.2500960529,
0.4679653943,
-1.147923708,
-0.3595570028,
-0.6133695841,
-0.0545527637,
-0.5864526033,
-0.1128312796,
0.1580137163,
0.2841952145,
0.1939706355,
0.4315468967,
-0.1540746242,
0.530646503,
-0.0623531267,
-0.3125299215,
0.5405326486,
0.1875030547,
0.3751345277,
-0.4269180894,
-0.4229508042,
-0.7386766672,
1.1787201166,
0.3877689838,
0.6932862401,
0.0795564577,
0.8068568707,
0.1702897847,
0.623208046,
-1.2975599766,
0.4341949522,
-0.2977209985,
-0.5970010757,
-0.2968944311,
-0.4256157279,
-1.1098707914,
0.6418424845,
-0.3729285002,
-1.1178667545,
0.1516371518,
-0.345166713,
-0.5606373549,
0.3075459301,
-0.4690896273,
0.7752119303,
0.2470257431,
-0.349857837,
0.0521829836,
-0.6282814741,
0.6100372672,
-0.1615518928,
0.2390617579,
-0.2695560157,
0.1606555432,
0.9514977932,
0.245280087,
0.4995275736,
0.3500487506,
-0.3514564335,
0.2348632514,
0.3579367101,
0.0432019196,
0.3138943613,
-0.0816884115,
0.1977254897,
0.1893118769,
0.012532318,
-0.9911730289,
0.6735371351,
-0.5686190724,
-0.7051964402,
-0.4586994648,
-0.6446771622,
-0.4885436594,
0.0815318003,
0.4238616526,
0.7636888623,
-0.6297729015,
0.2071149051,
0.3500998616,
0.0261740535,
0.2681298554,
0.1524901986,
-0.431637466,
-0.6168384552,
0.9469658136,
0.22868976,
0.42106089,
0.3322539628,
-0.1949048489,
-0.3384627104,
-0.4071467221,
-0.3534969687,
0.3365063667,
-0.6879967451,
0.0907940269,
-0.9130465984,
-0.0990886539,
-0.4206786454,
0.01403399,
-0.1794510186,
-0.0389129557,
-0.1427857131,
-0.1017012522,
0.1345745921,
0.7609701753,
0.3379336894,
0.0740638301,
-0.9377256632,
0.2870281935,
0.007620302,
0.3720050752,
0.0002210002,
-0.4792870581,
0.0563294031,
-0.4294497669,
-0.364367336,
-0.9827439189,
0.1632607132,
0.1087573394,
0.3840335608,
0.3536503911,
-0.1869232208,
0.6291713715,
-0.5650487542,
0.7383540273,
0.0799665153,
-0.7317932844,
0.1601659656,
-0.4204843342,
-0.127403602,
0.8626962304,
0.533492744,
-0.8668838143,
-0.262784481,
-0.906082809,
-0.8977936506,
0.4094025493,
0.1262350827,
0.1014861465,
-0.1258914024,
0.6045672894,
0.3068611324,
0.3917164803,
-0.7293559313,
-0.2340610623,
0.3547583818,
-0.1159879491,
-0.3164990842,
-0.501314044,
-0.0982391015,
-0.0372801945,
0.1438881755,
0.2393462509,
0.413564235,
0.0844867602,
0.1596559733,
-0.16025801,
0.5396572351,
0.3361078799,
0.9757559299,
-0.488601476,
0.1375973225,
-0.2334379852,
-0.3687898219,
0.118417643,
0.1091158986,
-0.1572331339,
0.091445528,
0.7764726877,
0.8241179585,
0.1331174821,
-0.4981773198,
0.3201224506,
0.1884042472,
-0.1133900732,
-0.3341391981,
-0.1056450754,
0.1752020568,
-0.2405255884,
0.0585477911,
0.072064653,
0.3923818469,
-0.8019083738,
0.3250296414,
0.4535220563,
-0.5473495722,
-0.3875110149,
0.4979058802,
0.0681466237,
-0.3900938034,
0.597591579,
-0.2848296463,
-0.1644994766,
0.6472481489,
0.5647491813,
1.1851890087,
0.0784257352,
0.3518233895,
0.5187324882,
0.5120017529,
-0.0676516443,
-0.2806811333,
-0.0087610409,
-0.7992069125,
-0.8453404307,
-0.7834433913,
-0.1308088452,
0.4051997662,
-0.9626743197,
0.1759768277,
-0.2122323513,
-0.1219934374,
0.0805187747,
-0.0798105821,
-0.2980819046,
0.2084622085,
-0.244055301,
0.563462615,
-0.9646291733,
0.5665397644,
0.7854842544,
-0.5632271171,
-0.5794001222,
0.4971584678,
-0.0985872075,
-0.1395324767,
0.5804491639,
0.0171711575,
-0.2269494236,
0.0918375477,
-0.1655260324,
-0.8369063139,
0.8981918693,
0.2312550545,
-0.5732588172,
0.1211405173,
-0.395706594,
0.8291524649,
-0.3880273104,
0.2248966098,
0.806732595,
0.1378534436,
0.0195050836,
-0.8821386695,
-0.0078950673,
-0.108243458,
0.0253555849,
0.6716216207,
-0.4640128911,
0.4105989635,
-0.121859096,
-0.4893476963,
-0.0651678294,
0.7021684051,
0.1515789777,
0.4316987693,
0.3993338943,
0.7301232815,
0.6399917603,
-0.259460777,
1.2342784405,
0.1899310648,
0.6714432836,
1.2368247509,
-0.5572934747,
0.8298252821,
0.368888855,
-0.5850206614,
0.599488318,
0.8542064428,
-0.1329701096,
0.2953794003,
0.296888262,
-0.32843557,
-0.3151177764,
-0.1523713171,
-0.3686408103,
0.514554441,
0.35722965,
-0.3856186569,
-0.3177417517,
-0.1625883132,
0.0118938349,
0.4794453382,
0.1186888143,
0.8157782555,
0.2713784873,
-0.6448818445,
0.3368302286,
-0.0191536397,
0.4185411036,
-0.487953186,
0.0073039499,
-0.074116081,
-0.3394142091,
-0.2485567778,
-0.6534965634,
0.3764266968,
-0.1137911975,
-0.4496366084,
0.2616452873,
0.6154553294,
-0.5862416029,
-0.4077699184,
0.3176924884,
0.5383608937,
0.1678487211,
0.0513075329,
-0.2995197177,
0.0326910168,
-0.1156021208,
-0.0476154946,
0.4001755714,
0.4255601764,
-0.1762673855,
0.6667764187,
0.4266963899,
0.2329905033,
-0.3515869081,
0.1492885053,
0.4324406981,
-0.7202880979,
-0.165667057,
-0.9548452497,
0.198744297,
-0.0166169852,
-0.4887487888,
0.6981764436,
0.5475037098,
0.7777205706,
-0.238899067,
0.8269847035,
-0.409208715,
0.2181312442,
-0.5108247995,
0.4796818495,
-0.5128056407,
0.3150123954,
-0.5600001216,
-1.2460234165,
-0.4710261524,
0.4572810233,
-0.6511178017,
0.1744474918,
1.0764275789,
0.5517880321,
0.0381697565,
0.0463285632,
0.3157857358,
-0.0737371817,
0.3270922005,
0.4252612591,
0.9733000994,
-0.4034235179,
0.2111030966,
-0.2266898304,
-0.1637226939,
0.2076065689,
-0.8087477684,
-0.6676744223,
-0.7287310362,
-0.4340921938,
-0.1520629972,
-0.1996721625,
1.0078992844,
0.0949368104,
-0.4541014433,
-0.3828020692,
0.3082256317,
0.1687884778,
-0.2599935532,
-0.2794976532,
0.4638109803,
-0.3426495492,
-0.8499279022,
0.2459816188,
0.4332146347,
-0.3059386313,
-0.3460478783,
0.3793724179,
-0.0493550673,
-0.4322663248,
0.8080223799,
0.0737552345,
-1.1066629887,
-0.3981494606,
-0.1365415752,
0.0018064111,
0.0800615326,
1.0062744617,
-0.4722745717,
0.5703550577,
0.5030257702,
0.6551474929,
0.1745096594,
0.3512068093,
0.6371417046,
-0.4721557796,
-0.1548709124,
0.1931899637,
0.2541221678,
0.2320100963,
-0.3311681151,
0.7335556746,
0.52765131,
-0.5641384125,
-0.8259198666,
0.4098407924,
-1.1092370749,
-0.1614957452,
1.2957653999,
-0.2699722052,
0.0950271562,
-0.3348346353,
-0.2074911743,
-0.0795207694,
-0.0626995414,
0.9235755801,
1.0436725616,
-0.0702529401,
-0.027724864,
-0.8165679574,
0.5680931211,
0.3007011116,
-0.6482138038,
0.129050836,
0.7172467113,
0.4861570597,
0.5373818874,
0.694550097,
-0.4427204728,
0.0718360841,
-0.1275005788,
0.3467967808,
0.1720191091,
-0.5337417126,
-0.2550938427,
0.5973161459,
0.4024322331,
0.1358178556
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10743v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10743v1
|
Construction of a Syntactic Analysis Map for Yi Shui School through Text Mining and Natural Language Processing Research
| 2024-02-16T14:59:55 | 2024-02-16T14:59:55 |
Hanqing Zhao, Yuehan Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Entity and relationship extraction is a crucial component in natural language
processing tasks such as knowledge graph construction, question answering
system design, and semantic analysis. Most of the information of the Yishui
school of traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) is stored in the form of
unstructured classical Chinese text. The key information extraction of TCM
texts plays an important role in mining and studying the academic schools of
TCM. In order to solve these problems efficiently using artificial intelligence
methods, this study constructs a word segmentation and entity relationship
extraction model based on conditional random fields under the framework of
natural language processing technology to identify and extract the entity
relationship of traditional Chinese medicine texts, and uses the common
weighting technology of TF-IDF information retrieval and data mining to extract
important key entity information in different ancient books. The dependency
syntactic parser based on neural network is used to analyze the grammatical
relationship between entities in each ancient book article, and it is
represented as a tree structure visualization, which lays the foundation for
the next construction of the knowledge graph of Yishui school and the use of
artificial intelligence methods to carry out the research of TCM academic
schools.
|
[
-0.0099806916,
-1.1143760681,
0.6309722066,
-0.4276238382,
-0.3731785715,
-0.0761701241,
-0.2334927768,
-0.61383605,
0.1678779721,
0.5510612726,
-0.4165200293,
-0.8872430325,
-0.3629952967,
-0.014846866,
-0.2233109474,
0.7724476457,
-0.0409615263,
0.3058649302,
0.0542142168,
-0.2629588246,
-0.3865011334,
-0.2031782269,
-0.9301348925,
-0.0244499277,
0.1725007445,
0.0966402814,
0.564706862,
0.8963246346,
0.6793742776,
0.5256733894,
-0.0561058931,
-0.142376408,
0.1089407355,
0.2305428237,
-0.2431285232,
-0.624894917,
-0.5166168213,
-0.1185160652,
0.9340179563,
0.5243045688,
-0.1312171817,
0.1362093091,
-0.1561555266,
0.4723505378,
-0.2643906474,
0.491460681,
-0.4796724319,
0.0927621424,
-0.6569367051,
-0.2558784485,
-0.1859561801,
-0.4945162535,
0.5427267551,
-0.6157439351,
0.1128375158,
0.19809331,
1.2833856344,
-0.0563782565,
-0.5172573924,
-0.289196372,
-0.3963918686,
0.6538056731,
-0.9262727499,
0.138520211,
0.1039328575,
0.1865491718,
-0.4160203338,
-0.8416154385,
-0.7493383288,
0.0865273252,
-0.3002756536,
0.0226909928,
0.0525960289,
0.2620588839,
0.1383851022,
0.4691381454,
-0.5410420895,
-0.1245646179,
-0.5280849934,
-0.0255365074,
0.5253735185,
0.2582971454,
1.1973241568,
-0.5865394473,
-0.3631867468,
-0.1392568052,
-0.1970462203,
0.2601568401,
0.1553290933,
0.1414104849,
-0.0751077607,
0.3549111187,
0.0237776693,
0.8848144412,
-0.233496055,
-0.5410131216,
0.0743261278,
-0.6122333407,
-0.4311730862,
0.2127353847,
1.1120607853,
0.1713683456,
0.4103195369,
-0.2890956998,
-0.0479629673,
0.1628650874,
0.2202836275,
-0.6385885477,
-0.3819705248,
0.0148032168,
-0.7105883956,
-0.2697630525,
-0.0358427316,
-0.759303093,
0.0141822556,
-0.2199813128,
0.1067064852,
-0.9548190236,
-0.4168833196,
-0.2994161248,
-0.1782991886,
0.2071071267,
-0.024704434,
-0.7074978948,
0.5357249379,
0.488622278,
0.8913195133,
-0.339266628,
-0.1506046355,
0.0014301988,
0.3085823059,
-0.1072280705,
0.629755497,
-0.606292963,
-0.2134308517,
0.1065491065,
-0.0205518194,
-0.4611000121,
-0.4682605863,
0.9382935762,
-0.677416563,
0.2853892148,
-0.0756009817,
-0.7592563033,
-0.8129538298,
0.277630806,
-0.8552895784,
0.6789966226,
0.4350413382,
-0.8353070617,
0.2243920416,
-0.481523186,
-0.4680855572,
0.5380389094,
-0.3639322817,
-0.4667729437,
-0.1933139265,
0.1647545248,
-0.002188137,
-0.3917590082,
0.648019731,
-0.1107202917,
-0.2622139156,
0.1404216886,
0.1134022251,
1.2332507372,
0.2142968178,
-0.392072916,
0.0950053632,
-0.9573556185,
0.521910131,
0.24332425,
-0.2146005929,
-0.969707787,
0.3134529591,
0.2274423987,
0.2617581785,
0.0960788131,
-0.3229331672,
0.3997625113,
-0.7575669885,
0.2604742348,
0.2902023494,
0.4342718422,
0.550778985,
-0.2131572068,
0.4943194091,
0.2443736643,
-0.2711771727,
-0.1280602515,
-0.3018717468,
-0.7499811053,
-0.0306053199,
0.4630931318,
0.4833795726,
-0.7935046554,
0.5461327434,
-0.3136471808,
-0.2499485463,
-0.660377264,
-0.033978574,
0.2356697172,
0.7932420373,
0.374797076,
-0.1792524159,
-0.5550495386,
-0.8867200613,
-0.2673516273,
-0.3619846702,
0.3529600799,
-0.2070257813,
0.3367910981,
0.0649405271,
0.9513011575,
-0.645637393,
-0.5830258727,
-0.547311008,
0.1553248018,
0.0495785214,
0.256723851,
0.7600728869,
-0.9771062136,
-0.4204064012,
0.0652529374,
-0.7787441015,
-0.0976498425,
-0.1136311367,
-0.2871842384,
0.0082241436,
0.034710411,
-0.6134636402,
0.5378296971,
0.1382776499,
-0.4448469281,
0.3161744475,
-0.0213750917,
0.4106112719,
-1.1630921364,
0.0549962372,
0.434643507,
0.1834394932,
-0.7242758274,
0.4278174043,
0.1197201014,
0.0254682805,
-0.1223231331,
0.4427494705,
-0.6977162361,
0.3455246985,
-0.4322574437,
0.3186224103,
-0.1682224721,
0.5312369466,
0.348254472,
0.2126087546,
0.4940060079,
-0.4784395993,
0.0471499786,
0.0528009459,
-0.2076365501,
0.2806866467,
-0.3103154898,
-0.183547467,
0.2555846572,
-0.2340835035,
-0.5323462486,
-0.0190567579,
0.6887515187,
-0.2048098743,
0.3293946981,
-0.0518277362,
-0.5176756382,
-0.1729668975,
-0.1548024565,
0.4571057856,
0.1880558133,
-0.2238231897,
0.8347088099,
0.7071195841,
-0.2257725,
-0.0489946306,
-0.279145658,
-0.1437508315,
-0.2332945019,
-0.916011095,
0.5800223947,
0.0479786731,
-0.5095099807,
0.5511108041,
-0.1393221915,
-0.5264988542,
0.181507796,
0.3479786515,
0.8949580193,
-0.5306949615,
-0.0079228096,
0.1916639358,
0.1431177706,
0.3634819984,
-0.227057308,
0.330511719,
0.1543531269,
0.0089435931,
-0.5346190333,
0.2099153101,
0.191916883,
-0.3568100333,
0.6141141653,
0.3270120621,
-0.8384904265,
-0.434334904,
-0.2023418844,
0.1114677563,
-0.4492631555,
0.3927390277,
-0.2296412587,
-0.3812998533,
0.1436980963,
0.0789979771,
0.0358959623,
0.7450905442,
0.3599293232,
0.1965290308,
0.6188271642,
0.6088166833,
-0.4044529796,
0.3354084492,
-0.1929921806,
0.3227906227,
-0.4620552659,
-0.3721737266,
-0.4686360657,
-0.47679618,
-0.6195926666,
0.0413533486,
0.2223656029,
-0.1077289209,
0.2872031331,
0.2967919409,
-0.6451902986,
0.1856745481,
0.6821208596,
-0.1737337857,
0.3300083578,
0.1607537121,
-0.2111392766,
-0.1847535074,
-0.2450121343,
-0.4442015588,
0.6935178638,
0.1238192171,
0.2542366087,
-0.0939878002,
0.8639596701,
-0.1410470456,
0.1541935951,
-0.9233883023,
0.7429722548,
-0.1420015842,
-0.5639236569,
-0.4095441699,
-0.4851574004,
-0.8025925159,
0.2704824507,
-0.3657211661,
-0.8032759428,
0.0490117483,
-0.4228559136,
-0.467430979,
0.4657409787,
-0.8090094924,
0.5924507976,
-0.2821167707,
-0.0646440834,
-0.0567784309,
-0.5945700407,
0.4882230163,
0.0087131262,
0.1877470016,
0.2222873718,
0.4462508261,
1.1201331615,
-0.3474249542,
0.3794459999,
-0.0831282884,
0.2078012675,
0.7353603244,
0.052384872,
0.0800466686,
-0.0287052039,
-0.1869406998,
0.1023345664,
0.3440999687,
0.0645231381,
-0.5637879968,
0.6938421726,
-0.6494526863,
-0.576625824,
-0.8677637577,
-0.5539157391,
0.1045994163,
0.6337400675,
0.0709173307,
0.1819754839,
-0.1148626804,
-0.3047347069,
0.3485505879,
-0.0444318727,
0.5702612996,
0.6031817198,
0.0326354131,
-0.2770721614,
0.8488561511,
0.5778546333,
-0.4103790224,
0.4302964509,
0.2336701751,
0.0776846781,
-0.8697331548,
-0.2655892074,
0.2142497301,
-0.2936560512,
-0.1856425256,
-0.6152226925,
-0.9107401967,
-0.5896013975,
0.1633670032,
0.1610090733,
-0.1120000482,
-0.2906154692,
-0.0057639992,
-0.0850613043,
0.5905973315,
0.6287207603,
0.4936216474,
-0.9833241105,
0.4427575469,
-0.1995508224,
-0.0901590362,
0.0841067731,
-0.038377095,
-0.3516038358,
-0.1599291414,
-0.5551039577,
-1.2651566267,
0.8164170384,
0.1372217387,
0.5656594634,
0.7396733165,
-0.0583814643,
0.7157505155,
-0.4547804296,
0.6102535725,
0.1858020425,
-0.6563763618,
0.5904179215,
-0.1346977353,
0.1988450289,
0.4418444932,
0.1851776093,
-0.4866985083,
-0.5174949765,
-0.842536509,
-0.8971790075,
0.9809755683,
0.0833711997,
-0.4900551736,
-0.0941260383,
0.649516046,
-0.0732207447,
-0.0830646828,
-1.005350709,
-0.6333317757,
0.2643076479,
-0.5981804132,
0.4238525629,
-0.2701427937,
0.0793666467,
-0.2349709272,
0.6432182193,
0.3166743219,
-0.2604142725,
-0.0141412755,
-0.2058975548,
-0.3294571936,
0.4249494076,
-0.1305512339,
0.4332749546,
-0.1080250591,
0.1156661063,
0.0057691061,
-0.7496386766,
-0.0784322023,
0.4597918987,
-0.6897800565,
0.1156493127,
0.5335709453,
0.5469780564,
0.2272641659,
-0.4572823942,
0.3522510827,
-0.007163194,
0.0681295842,
-0.5163183808,
0.5146505833,
0.1255545318,
0.2695286274,
0.4156195223,
-0.0938771814,
0.5295501351,
-0.5513833761,
0.2511452436,
0.3463109732,
0.0076706223,
-0.4859127402,
0.4559705555,
-0.2393526286,
-0.4382103384,
0.9461225271,
-0.1596590877,
-0.622777164,
0.7730767727,
0.6597003937,
0.7087954879,
-0.3002210557,
0.4012481868,
0.6655758023,
0.1247214973,
0.0745164305,
0.1425993145,
0.0060929037,
-0.4092247486,
-0.0882752389,
-0.8397449255,
0.1771579236,
0.2303662598,
-0.5870637894,
0.608158946,
-0.3404849172,
-0.2435838729,
0.2131672353,
0.5241313577,
-0.7118222713,
0.6888039708,
0.0661746562,
0.5482403636,
-0.5266653299,
1.2470200062,
0.8327509761,
-0.4539229572,
-1.3440341949,
0.1593980193,
0.0393895172,
-0.65349406,
0.8806563616,
-0.0897278115,
0.1878472418,
-0.1060709804,
-0.3025360107,
-0.8075873852,
1.2238901854,
-0.0018462323,
-0.9307373166,
-0.6530877948,
0.0273780674,
0.7386816144,
-0.2277848572,
0.3544437289,
0.6568017006,
0.4882434011,
-0.234928295,
-0.2830174565,
0.3051870763,
-0.4196579754,
-0.1226820424,
0.5350596905,
-0.3926591277,
0.6552947164,
-0.0677940324,
-0.8381560445,
0.1194255278,
0.7687254548,
0.1818329245,
0.6189885139,
0.4899728298,
0.7587307096,
0.5799878836,
-0.1083463803,
0.6755843759,
-0.4071282148,
0.0462187976,
1.0241860151,
-0.0918006524,
0.663082242,
0.5063288212,
-0.0885704979,
0.7951831222,
0.6408861876,
-0.357263267,
0.5370915532,
0.1975059211,
-0.2545987368,
0.1198029295,
-0.1002494693,
-0.3245088458,
0.4193983078,
0.3345016241,
-0.6600849032,
-0.3055610061,
-0.2777791917,
0.0200448018,
0.0624308251,
-0.1336354017,
0.6560957432,
0.3630743921,
-0.8459531069,
-0.091664128,
0.4037207961,
0.1362977326,
-0.7080999613,
-0.2197725475,
0.0240109619,
-0.1719353199,
-0.1920799315,
-0.4296179116,
0.0525969118,
-0.2742820084,
-0.1505856961,
0.1951973736,
1.0129859447,
-0.7174223661,
-0.655264318,
0.3912789822,
0.5500336289,
-0.1539956182,
0.5040191412,
-0.6389392614,
-0.1644019932,
-0.0172843188,
-0.4234679043,
0.3737976551,
0.7814858556,
-0.2598391175,
0.4165921807,
0.6145866513,
0.7726889253,
-0.150056079,
0.0750548095,
0.7670965195,
-0.8198058009,
-0.5947852135,
-1.0588029623,
0.2298305184,
-0.1686915606,
-0.3608016074,
0.6471076608,
0.3991249502,
0.4155543447,
0.2563900352,
0.6661777496,
-0.1795909554,
0.2384016663,
-0.5131029487,
1.1660015583,
-0.4672661126,
0.2347077578,
-0.4229075015,
-0.7410207391,
-0.1837577224,
0.4716913104,
-0.4026277065,
-0.1914347261,
1.0868698359,
0.3053812385,
0.1302838027,
0.2469098419,
0.0823999271,
0.1571288407,
0.0971875787,
0.5221174359,
0.3633581102,
-0.4197452366,
0.472687006,
-0.4523549676,
-0.2224433124,
0.2669472098,
-0.3558362722,
-0.841052115,
-0.8420760632,
-0.4689614773,
-0.1762444526,
0.1759144962,
0.751216054,
0.2270992398,
-0.8554240465,
-0.1974482238,
0.0879359841,
0.3667380214,
-0.2943213284,
-0.3849578202,
0.9614537358,
-0.3471099138,
-0.8586030602,
0.2860542536,
0.3894487023,
-0.0864027739,
0.0677172467,
0.1472892612,
-0.4479452372,
-0.3049329519,
0.0290717203,
0.1371042579,
-0.503508687,
-0.0721565709,
0.0407178439,
-0.3357163966,
0.1822525412,
0.8578218222,
-0.5875344872,
0.58685112,
0.4940698445,
0.550511241,
0.1016091034,
-0.0514515936,
0.4861681163,
-0.1418628097,
-0.1397722661,
0.1578181535,
0.5182210207,
0.0313579254,
-0.4092313349,
0.5117049813,
0.3965991437,
-0.3893683851,
-0.4973295033,
-0.3073504269,
-1.1360070705,
-0.3784649074,
1.0054688454,
-0.2741381824,
-0.7206681371,
-0.1750295609,
-0.3133665919,
0.9592930079,
-0.1942985803,
0.9983304143,
0.8667961359,
0.1292513013,
-0.1117237434,
-0.5359226465,
0.3913073838,
0.2284020036,
-0.9180101752,
-0.596673727,
0.2597054243,
0.4791609347,
0.2627029419,
0.7380951643,
-0.2854862809,
-0.0098222969,
-0.1142792627,
0.1751767993,
0.1154938638,
-0.0214935187,
0.1285569668,
0.5351653099,
-0.1810287088,
-0.2750421762
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10738v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10738v2
|
Let's Learn Step by Step: Enhancing In-Context Learning Ability with Curriculum Learning
| 2024-02-16T14:55:33 | 2024-06-16T13:26:10 |
Yinpeng Liu, Jiawei Liu, Xiang Shi, Qikai Cheng, Yong Huang, Wei Lu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Demonstration ordering, which is an important strategy for in-context
learning (ICL), can significantly affects the performance of large language
models (LLMs). However, most of the current approaches of ordering require high
computational costs to introduce the priori knowledge. In this paper, inspired
by the human learning process, we propose a simple but effective demonstration
ordering method for ICL, named the few-shot In-Context Curriculum Learning
(ICCL). The ICCL implies gradually increasing the complexity of prompt
demonstrations during the inference process. The difficulty can be assessed by
human experts or LLMs-driven metrics, such as perplexity. Then we design
extensive experiments to discuss the effectiveness of the ICCL at both
corpus-level and instance-level. Moreover, we also investigate the formation
mechanism of LLM's ICCL capability. Experimental results demonstrate that ICCL,
developed during the instruction-tuning stage, is effective for representative
open-source LLMs. To facilitate further research and applications by other
scholars, we make the code publicly available.
|
[
-0.4662638605,
-0.6458488703,
0.5369594693,
0.1435782015,
-0.2706569433,
0.1000731885,
-0.2021204978,
-0.2858681381,
-0.518476367,
0.3889515996,
-0.4945657253,
-0.7670494914,
-0.3880145848,
0.0340683796,
-0.3097569942,
0.8114691973,
0.2408992499,
0.1509173959,
-0.2220171094,
-0.2258493304,
-0.0864146575,
-0.2008863389,
-0.6119784117,
-0.3350785673,
0.3713956773,
0.9808221459,
0.2321680933,
0.7651331425,
0.2979084253,
0.2534707189,
-0.123932451,
0.1781100184,
-0.5076188445,
-0.1207852885,
-0.1479669809,
-0.5121581554,
-0.0068268292,
0.0409822427,
0.6485571265,
0.7823858857,
-0.0303948317,
0.1678009331,
0.3175209761,
0.5049926043,
-0.703674674,
0.2206415683,
-0.5938618779,
-0.1305017024,
-0.1599591076,
-0.0234489255,
-0.8912735581,
-0.2341587842,
0.3964380622,
-0.2649483383,
0.0200426076,
0.2461761683,
0.3302071691,
0.0238175131,
-0.4038310051,
-0.2077378184,
-0.3670627773,
0.9320411682,
-0.6153386235,
0.2459853441,
0.3347962499,
0.4640617967,
-0.3442674875,
-0.8885701299,
-0.4970067143,
-0.3570578396,
-0.0802945718,
0.1227081418,
0.2377692908,
0.0546480156,
0.4613160491,
-0.0900604129,
-0.5215359926,
0.4826309383,
-0.3372918665,
0.0694968253,
0.2623461485,
0.1663690805,
0.1641402692,
-0.1757377237,
-0.5595185757,
-0.2563824356,
-1.0717821121,
0.3051995933,
-0.0359859504,
0.5540720224,
-0.2933685482,
0.3926609457,
-0.3636833429,
0.4851792753,
0.1587657034,
-0.2748553753,
-0.0024935023,
-0.0400252938,
-0.2603772581,
0.256634146,
0.5237730145,
-0.1223776489,
-0.3356336355,
0.22394979,
-0.0503743254,
-0.1935472786,
0.1673039645,
-1.0523450375,
0.0861340761,
0.0666048527,
-0.2478476018,
-0.2006890476,
-0.0117261503,
-0.5438949466,
-0.2977198362,
-0.3074613214,
0.589636147,
-0.6739923954,
0.2387295067,
-0.1761317104,
0.3443369567,
0.360047996,
0.461760819,
-0.7998998165,
0.4766213,
0.7240541577,
0.7725298405,
-0.2476678789,
-0.407528162,
-0.7689569592,
0.0379509963,
-0.392087996,
0.6278420687,
-0.2961577177,
-0.396589309,
0.076057598,
-0.4145100117,
0.2204051167,
-0.4901477098,
0.3261042237,
-0.5660101175,
0.0925155133,
-0.1577030569,
-0.8196539283,
-0.1428512186,
0.1445175707,
-0.228327781,
0.6981793642,
-0.1467221975,
-0.6113236547,
0.4599888921,
-0.7412117124,
-0.4424733222,
0.2646553218,
-0.4889300168,
-0.3840329945,
-0.0403982885,
0.2380110174,
0.7269631624,
-0.0499011353,
-0.0592655167,
-0.0654564127,
-0.6374300122,
0.1909518689,
-0.3795197904,
0.9534300566,
0.1896399558,
-0.6368939877,
0.1431943029,
-0.663913548,
0.0235697553,
-0.1064281538,
-0.354154259,
-0.1657094359,
0.1376466751,
-0.3192958534,
0.209544152,
-0.154522121,
-0.2045087963,
0.195630163,
-0.6389982104,
0.1274408549,
0.6635535359,
0.0599641912,
0.7763336301,
-0.1891388148,
0.3567756414,
-0.0097598182,
0.1466949582,
-0.436509341,
-0.4036698639,
-0.7836657763,
-0.346802026,
0.0279242359,
0.3869992495,
-0.6310631037,
0.0680365935,
-0.0043176226,
-0.4370421767,
-0.2477099895,
0.2757334411,
0.7566437125,
0.6431214213,
0.4877162874,
-0.2255244404,
-0.2268384844,
-0.673076272,
0.1292895079,
-0.3089215159,
-0.1580724567,
0.1780703664,
0.4389032125,
0.1578512788,
0.8659684062,
-0.4722180367,
-0.1304022372,
-0.4214010537,
0.5390850306,
0.1790537536,
0.356546104,
0.4059360921,
-0.567104578,
-0.5483409762,
-0.0016550176,
-0.5243487954,
-0.0171837658,
0.0124021815,
-0.1400945485,
0.2675696015,
0.7950342894,
-0.1362619549,
0.5266820788,
0.183533445,
0.2166327238,
0.5727870464,
-0.3485185504,
-0.040243756,
-0.8354068398,
-0.6083347797,
-0.1203100383,
-0.1709574312,
-0.4472932816,
0.3122103512,
0.3889790177,
-0.0259422045,
-0.9310323596,
0.5164974928,
-0.5040284991,
-0.0519456491,
-0.2314240038,
0.1897059828,
-0.3494731486,
0.5174992085,
0.1211813614,
0.8962520957,
0.6587491632,
-0.8022356033,
-0.4104437828,
0.2563125491,
-0.9313398004,
0.6045036912,
-0.1224963516,
0.1145994142,
-0.1326191127,
0.2936824262,
-1.1461014748,
-0.3015370965,
-0.0211643819,
-0.0779006779,
0.4518491626,
-0.2817085683,
-0.3410624862,
-0.0214237627,
-0.1815487742,
0.2258940786,
0.6114146709,
-0.9784361124,
0.2074760348,
-0.080158323,
0.0852451846,
-0.4796872139,
-0.4883491099,
-0.0086012585,
-0.1981166005,
-0.3173968792,
0.4385136664,
-0.4331570566,
-0.4345261455,
-0.5823882222,
0.0695586279,
-0.0977434292,
0.1053885072,
0.3265765905,
-0.0178392828,
-0.419275403,
0.2942679226,
0.3191729784,
-0.0670263544,
-0.2030328661,
-0.1524023116,
0.253862381,
-0.2506566048,
-0.6348966956,
-0.6541417837,
0.353241235,
0.4987633228,
-0.0429485068,
0.6145780087,
0.2723885179,
-0.1191603243,
-0.6618454456,
-0.3537474573,
-0.3023372591,
-0.5495215058,
0.3626171649,
-0.340519011,
-0.6723080873,
0.0590508878,
-0.4641275108,
0.3110390306,
-0.1772415638,
0.4099440873,
-0.2518711388,
1.0478228331,
0.6818408966,
0.0181956682,
0.6383857727,
-0.3468919098,
-0.0569853671,
-0.6330199242,
-0.0180124305,
-0.431679666,
-0.1720022857,
-0.3627313375,
-0.4770038724,
0.5476586819,
0.4183644354,
-0.5722575188,
0.3283081055,
-0.1718709767,
0.9092888236,
0.5214001536,
0.5108218789,
0.406873703,
0.0818192735,
-0.5166938901,
-0.0985813737,
-0.6712788343,
-0.6738123894,
0.7806529999,
-0.0418921709,
0.6959629655,
0.3014585674,
1.1152464151,
-0.0349149182,
0.6046301723,
-0.7517277002,
0.7886713147,
-0.1084316969,
-0.228768304,
-0.4239334166,
0.0600020103,
-0.6682583094,
0.3040170074,
-0.2459362447,
-0.9310136437,
-0.0418782867,
0.0254974198,
-0.4001016915,
0.0937109515,
-0.8432852626,
0.5845014453,
-0.3290784955,
-0.6541057825,
-0.4503486156,
-0.899828434,
0.2712885141,
0.1312848181,
0.3281659782,
0.2246995419,
-0.0748134702,
0.4517509639,
-0.4406661093,
1.0484138727,
0.0393073931,
0.0769768655,
0.3868331313,
0.3949638605,
0.5281903148,
0.1238586456,
-0.2334115356,
-0.1705189645,
-0.5549429655,
-0.3787125051,
-0.6246010065,
0.649202764,
-0.6174790263,
-0.7800804377,
-0.0321404561,
-0.3903901875,
-0.2859405577,
0.0269751716,
0.3443301022,
0.6767687798,
-0.0838713199,
0.1924766153,
0.7022003531,
-0.2399014235,
0.7917689681,
0.5280778408,
-0.1320097446,
-0.1440119594,
0.8264310956,
0.1346601695,
0.6792088151,
0.6076046228,
0.4460003972,
-0.0660849065,
-0.8499038219,
-0.3980857432,
0.0206009485,
-0.9655008912,
-0.1040700302,
-0.5278040171,
-0.0516237281,
-0.2456956655,
-0.6608914733,
-0.2994838655,
-0.0678618774,
-0.4443350732,
-0.1935870945,
0.0754088387,
0.7799898386,
0.2079640478,
0.5738071203,
-0.4498073459,
0.055260092,
0.5944206119,
0.1639364362,
0.1454871893,
-0.5735994577,
-0.1522170752,
-0.1155200079,
-0.5216180682,
-0.5443121791,
0.2338926345,
0.2148140222,
0.5109818578,
0.8811045885,
0.1679991335,
1.0613152981,
-0.7164717317,
0.6970936656,
0.1089415625,
-1.0098481178,
0.5757141709,
-0.0683209896,
0.3687998652,
0.5888667703,
0.4234685302,
-0.0778047442,
-0.5205515027,
-0.5405140519,
-0.8533327579,
1.0033705235,
0.1761101782,
0.1896239221,
-0.1032553613,
0.245541364,
0.2666297257,
-0.0668794513,
-0.6101923585,
-0.3332599401,
0.0617770813,
-0.0128033217,
0.0417896882,
-0.2258378714,
0.0010211024,
-0.3884949684,
0.6432679296,
-0.4405178726,
-0.1115264967,
-0.0060427571,
-0.4327079058,
0.1863278747,
0.4585046768,
0.8399271369,
0.8975770473,
-0.1748336852,
0.25181216,
0.4762430489,
-0.0979821682,
0.0680836737,
-0.4262978733,
-0.0025924328,
-0.4648159444,
0.5873461366,
0.6265925169,
0.6489622593,
-0.7346727252,
0.7658265233,
0.0594902113,
-0.0200023595,
-0.2067421973,
0.1607653797,
0.0369398668,
0.636063993,
0.4524098933,
-0.2786267102,
0.0791941732,
-0.6030109525,
0.5099908113,
0.2440030426,
-0.444930315,
-0.0334772393,
0.4405435622,
-0.0150258755,
-0.4621455073,
0.6553767323,
-0.3591854274,
-0.366499573,
0.6818522215,
0.9686670303,
0.5530096292,
-0.0794565827,
0.4069043696,
0.4510663748,
0.0535542145,
-0.3155907691,
-0.1459192336,
-0.3613731861,
-0.5577897429,
-0.4279956818,
-0.4360671937,
-0.7298595309,
-0.2249203622,
-0.5268326402,
0.6493074894,
-0.6505464911,
0.2655899227,
-0.1010936648,
-0.0601968467,
-0.5822785497,
0.0053908997,
0.2370130718,
0.8613843918,
-0.6727117896,
0.9093860388,
0.4536885321,
-0.4435976446,
-0.7436724901,
0.2152018696,
0.2200697511,
-0.6608916521,
1.0983459949,
0.3571729064,
-0.1087033004,
0.2289506048,
-1.0245239735,
-0.584535718,
1.1348469257,
0.3707800508,
-0.5128908753,
0.2444566786,
-0.2372069061,
0.4720550478,
-0.6135469079,
0.529540658,
0.1680441499,
0.1941177398,
0.3637598157,
-0.3607326448,
-0.104952164,
0.4810464978,
-0.1205994114,
-0.1498038322,
-0.5417348146,
0.5758163929,
-0.6200767756,
-0.3475069106,
0.212364763,
0.9826231003,
0.39870134,
0.3205598891,
0.5140737891,
0.1381274909,
0.6190505624,
0.1340404898,
1.1528505087,
0.1711471975,
0.1381300837,
1.3394249678,
-0.4079696834,
1.0707844496,
0.5282941461,
-0.3607933819,
0.6945393085,
0.5182653666,
0.464784801,
0.5659765601,
0.3204732537,
-0.5001810193,
-0.4923812449,
-0.0016548559,
0.0677145272,
0.3630697131,
0.4517970979,
-0.0606023856,
-0.4244852364,
0.2412817329,
-0.1148963422,
0.1715214103,
-0.2153941542,
0.8318572044,
0.2639847398,
-0.4428574443,
0.5547719598,
-0.3057422042,
0.5735009909,
-0.5701286197,
-0.3520846665,
-0.2930941582,
-0.0216973554,
-0.0556549206,
-0.586037159,
-0.2004420608,
-0.0993659422,
-0.0903433412,
-0.3431774378,
0.1870200783,
-0.3000103533,
-0.323723197,
0.4029324949,
0.3332810104,
0.3378182948,
0.2795162797,
-0.3884503841,
-0.355237335,
-0.2879962921,
-0.2240074426,
0.7604649067,
0.1834344268,
-0.4599871039,
0.7458539009,
0.4743845761,
-0.3350836933,
0.0936579332,
0.1247620732,
0.5808034539,
-0.4095039666,
-0.3232228756,
-0.8686460853,
0.5775091052,
-0.0080737472,
-0.1012062579,
0.5254989266,
0.3754889369,
1.1383949518,
0.0330017209,
0.5460145473,
0.0082078539,
0.2293976247,
-0.5775995255,
0.5877001286,
-0.5287872553,
0.4497695267,
-0.3445904553,
-0.5103381276,
-0.7173194885,
0.4510581493,
-0.183784321,
-0.3034145534,
0.9561699629,
1.0015538931,
-0.2040612847,
0.0272751693,
0.6535731554,
0.2507074475,
0.3058386743,
0.2678623199,
0.804276824,
-0.1626519561,
0.5928124785,
-0.6175493598,
-0.3474684954,
-0.1469094455,
-1.0604116917,
-1.0130544901,
-0.4745136499,
-0.3378214538,
-0.1193703339,
0.0112634096,
1.4696338177,
0.7605668902,
-0.7505712509,
-0.5480235219,
-0.1646137983,
0.4854890108,
-0.5180757046,
-0.1466839314,
0.6031701565,
-0.584474504,
-0.917416811,
0.7611370683,
0.2854142487,
-0.0636393055,
-0.0053262184,
-0.1442221403,
-0.36190328,
-0.0959136933,
0.8791620135,
0.244268775,
-0.8399553299,
-0.3797633052,
-0.2880307734,
-0.1933799237,
0.1863885075,
0.9165697694,
-0.8503258228,
0.5654748678,
0.5052868128,
0.6950995326,
0.5354517102,
-0.190764457,
0.2311983705,
-1.0175771713,
0.1526187509,
-0.1218977496,
0.3305746615,
-0.0278497841,
-0.1445458084,
0.3746938109,
-0.0220047887,
-0.4143912494,
-0.6162468791,
0.3331969976,
-0.9875477552,
-0.2972977757,
0.8905130625,
-0.172680214,
-0.1759797186,
-0.1174507663,
-0.3854065537,
0.2338124067,
-0.4451107085,
0.8092757463,
0.3588055372,
-0.4052849412,
-0.1131972447,
-0.3759867549,
0.2824360132,
0.2587024868,
-0.7788752913,
-0.1285000443,
0.3424403071,
0.2599637508,
-0.0106444648,
0.4914819598,
-0.0976833627,
0.2276925594,
-0.3425138295,
-0.1497600675,
0.0628893003,
-0.4880767465,
-0.4309915602,
0.3756548762,
0.2119184434,
-0.0236811955
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10735v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10735v2
|
Assessing the Reasoning Abilities of ChatGPT in the Context of Claim Verification
| 2024-02-16T14:52:05 | 2024-03-20T19:14:54 |
John Dougrez-Lewis, Mahmud Elahi Akhter, Yulan He, Maria Liakata
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The reasoning capabilities of LLMs are currently hotly debated. We examine
the issue from the perspective of claim/rumour verification. We propose the
first logical reasoning framework designed to break down any claim or rumour
paired with evidence into the atomic reasoning steps necessary for
verification. Based on our framework, we curate two annotated collections of
such claim/evidence pairs: a synthetic dataset from Wikipedia and a real-world
set stemming from rumours circulating on Twitter. We use them to evaluate the
reasoning capabilities of GPT-3.5-Turbo and GPT-4 (hereinafter referred to as
ChatGPT) within the context of our framework, providing a thorough analysis.
Our results show that ChatGPT struggles in abductive reasoning, although this
can be somewhat mitigated by using manual Chain of Thought (CoT) as opposed to
Zero-Shot (ZS) and ZS CoT approaches. Our study contributes to the growing body
of research suggesting that ChatGPT's reasoning processes are unlikely to
mirror human-like reasoning, and that LLMs need to be more rigorously evaluated
to distinguish between hype and actual capabilities, especially in high-stakes
real-world tasks such as claim verification.
|
[
-0.4745462537,
-0.6928267479,
0.6854967475,
-0.0855211616,
-0.204162389,
0.3383928835,
-0.2631001174,
-0.5857027769,
-0.0486809127,
0.3187232912,
-0.6227428317,
-0.2218178958,
-0.679361403,
0.1153772399,
-0.3646161854,
1.1084160805,
-0.1568969041,
-0.3591551185,
-0.1476340145,
0.1330761313,
-0.4440603256,
-0.5907312036,
-0.4767150879,
-0.284943521,
0.4770722687,
0.3092596233,
0.7864899635,
0.2430270612,
0.5300063491,
0.2210543156,
-0.1246473342,
0.4344131351,
-0.5073060989,
0.1341946423,
-0.2207222283,
-0.6016955972,
-0.3756865263,
0.1495910734,
0.3621407449,
0.2502590418,
-0.2267872393,
0.1459444165,
-0.0496122874,
0.5098879933,
-0.519718349,
0.2711933851,
-1.100088954,
0.0615696125,
-0.2649618685,
-0.17052643,
-0.399895668,
-0.3068573177,
0.3623404801,
-0.3091098368,
0.2598852217,
0.3248549998,
1.0093334913,
0.1845750511,
-0.2840302885,
-0.3784745336,
-0.677136898,
0.3042240441,
-0.5437220335,
0.2174742818,
0.3372128308,
0.6975378394,
-0.1576606482,
-0.6452766061,
-0.5321185589,
-0.4533727467,
-0.1234377697,
0.1517569423,
-0.1315854937,
0.1276108176,
0.606769681,
0.5197099447,
-0.6816694736,
-0.145066008,
-0.5649399161,
-0.7198203802,
0.4833622277,
-0.1535209566,
0.2981676459,
-0.1094560772,
-0.6746530533,
0.3355424106,
-1.0163198709,
-0.3192153573,
0.1979433298,
-0.0160033051,
-0.0404801071,
0.7151694894,
-0.3201736212,
0.3006542623,
-0.2220283449,
-0.1419849992,
-0.1065391824,
-0.2893333435,
-0.3064649999,
0.3437955379,
0.6736913919,
0.2654072046,
0.346470058,
-0.4068216085,
-0.2683841586,
0.3231893182,
0.1677194387,
-0.7694016099,
-0.1550230533,
0.2259645611,
-0.1830718815,
-0.2977630794,
0.0179836042,
-0.353109926,
-0.5094415545,
-0.0389177985,
0.4941860437,
-0.5291398764,
-0.502761066,
0.2789625227,
-0.294739753,
0.3739289343,
0.562816143,
-0.5198351145,
0.2082958966,
1.0305330753,
0.6661660075,
0.0012374197,
-0.2088890523,
-0.0988412127,
0.0418473221,
-0.3343782127,
1.3463823795,
-0.1300369054,
-0.0851197094,
-0.1115199625,
-0.2845716178,
-0.0809342712,
-0.4190067649,
0.8674414158,
-0.5184457302,
0.2954474986,
-0.5633012056,
-0.6769220829,
-0.1899019033,
0.796579957,
-0.4182784855,
0.7765598297,
0.0640014857,
-0.8796256781,
0.5448042154,
-0.5116065145,
-0.3018420637,
0.1550356746,
-0.460582912,
-0.0688746795,
-0.1356416494,
0.1599318236,
0.1809748709,
-0.6623042226,
0.1556717008,
-0.2953999341,
-0.3522348106,
0.5550283194,
-0.8394711614,
0.6351437569,
0.353135258,
-0.5000193715,
-0.201238364,
-0.4365348518,
0.0764420703,
0.0764297172,
-0.0708216503,
0.3473845124,
0.2233682871,
-0.6183061004,
0.2392700762,
0.0421624333,
-0.557441175,
0.3689254224,
-0.309135288,
0.4841497838,
0.6835287809,
0.0650133044,
-0.001415492,
-0.6439527869,
0.503610909,
-0.1063786,
-0.0626216754,
-0.1075975671,
-0.6183847785,
-0.7015736103,
-0.3121881783,
0.3015065789,
0.6266567707,
-0.7887461185,
0.061906185,
-0.2269144058,
-0.5290486217,
-0.304300338,
-0.0971332565,
0.2366112322,
0.6447660923,
0.2454639077,
0.0937148035,
-0.4741978049,
-0.9355197549,
-0.4275790453,
-0.784901917,
-0.1203022376,
0.1126876548,
0.3207328022,
0.0196106806,
1.0881894827,
-0.353073597,
-0.0172928721,
-0.3053753674,
0.2541370988,
0.1064529046,
0.1367152333,
0.3663497269,
-0.6026151776,
-0.1153505743,
-0.0221165791,
-0.9231789112,
-0.1660157442,
-0.161289081,
-0.1921066344,
0.2746130526,
0.0882002115,
-1.1279844046,
0.6377446651,
0.0525664501,
-0.4167280793,
0.918245852,
0.1345721483,
0.2935875058,
-0.4399504662,
-0.3497603834,
-0.1458485126,
-0.2488481104,
-0.2765770555,
-0.0745928511,
-0.1663583368,
0.0926614329,
-0.3804093003,
0.2979457676,
-0.4514861405,
-0.0783651918,
-0.469332546,
0.3330272436,
-0.0208265278,
0.2410702407,
0.0329045504,
0.7886237502,
0.5874587297,
-0.503739953,
0.4241347611,
0.0087006483,
-0.4255489707,
0.6837796569,
-0.4822583795,
0.0912184939,
0.0654626712,
0.5513658524,
-1.135804534,
-0.1059653163,
0.4985368848,
-0.6829701662,
-0.1056918129,
-0.3266147375,
-0.718742311,
-0.5000337958,
-0.119548969,
0.0198092051,
0.7393857837,
-0.472832948,
0.6095846295,
0.1873117834,
0.004215973,
-0.4373701215,
-0.520206809,
0.2401910871,
-0.4417443275,
-0.8559318781,
0.2246150076,
0.2138742059,
-0.643733561,
-0.040217679,
-0.5072706342,
-0.0139844045,
-0.0599279813,
0.1436287314,
0.4133330584,
-0.40614447,
0.0590393245,
-0.2008318901,
-0.3327252269,
0.4632658362,
-0.300856024,
0.1978771389,
-0.5287644267,
-0.6592415571,
-0.203426376,
-0.1620601565,
0.5134717226,
-0.0371275209,
0.4334008992,
0.7047609091,
-0.4592430592,
-0.2064644992,
-0.9559057355,
-0.1894565821,
-0.4402021468,
0.0635420382,
-0.5099169612,
-0.8028983474,
0.5330585241,
-0.1758643538,
0.1331308186,
0.6657156944,
0.7450665832,
-0.055814039,
0.6882549524,
0.0880643502,
0.0861244425,
-0.3308573067,
-0.110651046,
0.2746522725,
-0.6687799692,
-0.1624089628,
-0.3302938342,
-0.1502353698,
-0.444596678,
-0.6329739094,
0.1926485151,
0.0878953412,
-0.2895520031,
0.2454594672,
-0.3881838322,
0.5362483263,
0.0917317793,
0.2364049703,
0.5459299684,
-0.1250898838,
-0.1527762264,
0.1948778331,
-0.6796705723,
-0.7593547702,
0.9220916033,
0.5118310452,
0.5722196102,
0.2783860564,
0.426043123,
0.4417797923,
0.7125377059,
-0.8547580242,
0.7804496884,
0.5249119997,
-0.9552983642,
-0.1018771082,
-0.5375820398,
-0.4249452353,
0.5644758344,
-0.1926176101,
-0.9716050625,
-0.2516897321,
0.0536070168,
-0.3618658483,
0.5787850022,
-0.6897385716,
0.5242882967,
-0.4276579022,
-0.3929478824,
-0.3769165874,
-0.5591107011,
0.6973006129,
0.1926282644,
0.1588317305,
-0.610776186,
0.0734966919,
0.5573274493,
-0.6580092311,
0.7121328712,
-0.2356870323,
-0.4160885811,
0.8834093809,
0.3109236956,
0.5125952959,
0.2796590924,
-0.1094089225,
0.1784013808,
0.1211839318,
-0.2118556648,
-0.6439990997,
0.324495852,
-0.4797902703,
-0.8713085055,
-0.5991317034,
-0.3619628251,
-0.3995620608,
0.0703374669,
0.3342243433,
0.1666879058,
-0.2662593424,
-0.0550555401,
0.6360113621,
0.0322635137,
0.1138099283,
0.4411059618,
-0.3657428622,
-0.3211614192,
0.7757276297,
0.1184698641,
0.4341665506,
0.1431499124,
0.3290290534,
-0.3965173364,
-0.6197677851,
-0.4066898227,
0.0448485836,
-0.811121881,
-0.2460428029,
-0.3369320929,
-0.5819336772,
-0.0997169241,
0.0087289112,
-0.5278832912,
-0.5931417346,
0.4521270692,
-0.278316021,
0.4469794333,
0.6266428232,
-0.0791518465,
0.0511363111,
-0.5335065722,
0.4630032778,
0.2690491974,
0.222833842,
-0.2534882724,
-0.4725823998,
0.0806422755,
0.2239934802,
-0.2465901822,
-0.7852856517,
-0.0966904908,
-0.2233564109,
0.657089591,
0.5144780874,
0.16581963,
0.6279854178,
-0.417673856,
0.779620409,
0.0535359196,
-0.6055406928,
0.4417847097,
-0.4822543561,
-0.2304768562,
0.4076726735,
0.3371870816,
-0.3896431029,
-0.3752139211,
-0.9330491424,
-0.5001089573,
0.3444117904,
0.4726645648,
-0.3646413684,
0.0029128406,
0.3192584813,
0.1793190241,
0.0205485821,
-0.6146528125,
-0.0880329609,
0.0855694562,
0.1806556135,
0.5007622838,
-0.3887506425,
-0.3204398453,
-0.1672413349,
0.6274859309,
-0.0949868932,
0.4858696163,
0.275683552,
-0.1759244949,
0.1948349029,
0.3992927372,
0.3848486543,
0.9683693051,
-0.2999536693,
0.3194009662,
0.2959591746,
-0.3200953007,
0.2195463479,
0.2018336952,
-0.0390475169,
-0.1072511673,
0.4165190458,
0.5676829219,
0.1579785794,
-0.6532307863,
0.6091751456,
-0.1692344099,
-0.50871104,
-0.4065446258,
0.1958431304,
-0.0001349268,
0.2711586654,
0.3757118285,
0.2399667948,
-0.0197502635,
-0.5089561343,
0.2667823732,
0.3190495074,
-0.1089050695,
-0.2240724117,
0.4880627096,
0.0714221001,
-0.0439025089,
0.6448209882,
-0.4624654055,
-0.7433610559,
0.5935184956,
0.4737719893,
0.8339285254,
0.3655335009,
0.3121275306,
0.216040656,
0.7001230121,
-0.2616409361,
0.0539530553,
-0.1711683571,
-0.9947254658,
-0.5403213501,
-0.0764961541,
-0.7912803292,
-0.0342586935,
-0.2535923123,
0.4262999892,
-0.4312495887,
-0.0432424061,
-0.1636701524,
-0.0113659995,
-0.4835067093,
-0.056213554,
0.5199095011,
1.0376133919,
-0.5184642673,
0.5475484729,
0.29451105,
-0.3978717327,
-0.8437447548,
0.2650199234,
0.4765723348,
-1.1251915693,
0.5726997256,
0.3627589345,
-0.3366310298,
-0.2087892145,
-0.5497464538,
-0.6437255144,
1.1385300159,
0.6262521148,
-0.2505940497,
-0.0367120691,
0.1576523334,
0.1970877796,
-0.215984419,
0.5561545491,
0.6315506101,
0.4985193312,
0.5619416237,
-1.1364604235,
0.1353444457,
0.0350993797,
-0.3855911195,
-0.1756132394,
-0.6579524875,
0.5410987139,
-0.4989739358,
-0.4837850332,
-0.0922352672,
0.7081463337,
0.7220246792,
0.1993614584,
0.5570090413,
0.650161922,
0.9687054157,
-0.3448651135,
1.0099298954,
-0.2491077036,
0.2875271738,
1.0063090324,
-0.5034610033,
0.6575464606,
0.1642468423,
-0.5335302353,
0.5453862548,
0.7205913663,
0.0850842446,
0.2020876706,
0.4655636251,
-0.4270693064,
-0.3279122412,
0.1707647592,
-0.519382596,
0.491312921,
0.7014937401,
-0.0301961899,
-0.5435387492,
-0.3708964586,
0.2272982299,
-0.3872592449,
-0.2084812075,
0.5678392649,
0.0999988839,
-0.8885396123,
0.6640557647,
-0.1633344591,
0.4988550544,
-0.5257656574,
-0.1135693118,
-0.0439083055,
0.1059970483,
-0.2719877958,
-0.8665168285,
0.3116205633,
0.2110577971,
0.3158358634,
-0.2093582302,
1.2511081696,
-0.0928204656,
-0.2960717976,
-0.1305376589,
0.786347568,
0.377918452,
-0.315392077,
-0.6606941819,
0.0178011209,
0.0399219319,
-0.2606899142,
0.1518412977,
0.8500908613,
0.1511339247,
0.878960073,
0.6247195601,
0.2160609663,
-0.1243499219,
-0.007534279,
0.9434838891,
-0.608043611,
-0.2619786859,
-1.1333588362,
0.3640495241,
-0.0783354267,
0.0094564119,
0.8548805714,
0.6006512642,
0.5352064967,
0.3347092569,
1.0892157555,
-0.3305805922,
0.5323648453,
-0.6831573248,
0.7028931975,
0.0678413361,
0.661616385,
-0.077915512,
-0.6518747211,
-0.0532690696,
0.729850471,
-0.5518298745,
0.0025657301,
0.9924994111,
0.7632585764,
0.1174067557,
0.5786109567,
0.0450669192,
0.2805768251,
0.3932244778,
0.7202165723,
1.4143147469,
-0.2502576709,
0.7200931311,
-0.1283916086,
-0.3422279358,
0.0767586157,
-1.2537523508,
-0.8779547215,
-0.0975311473,
-0.5508157611,
-0.705401957,
0.0763205886,
0.8236575723,
0.4990038276,
-0.4004272819,
0.0096432539,
-0.2078353763,
0.3280861378,
-0.2134490758,
-0.2467739582,
0.2322596014,
-0.4089952707,
-0.0035562846,
0.3145472109,
0.3506502211,
-0.194356218,
-0.3845840693,
-0.0754245296,
-0.0152973998,
0.0245272443,
0.6912367344,
0.4128008485,
-0.8197030425,
-0.4964594841,
-0.2450596392,
0.0249812119,
0.1782105863,
0.81110847,
-1.0357606411,
0.0179562271,
0.3301052153,
0.7591694593,
0.3865248859,
0.0190692227,
0.5854634047,
-0.2633732259,
0.0052001057,
0.2982087731,
0.5327740312,
0.0580238514,
-0.3004485071,
0.8061156869,
0.6174651384,
-0.580907464,
-0.775082171,
0.2016583383,
-1.077732563,
-0.0303232744,
1.2644321918,
-0.1769458503,
-0.1283238679,
-0.1182196215,
-0.3680334687,
-0.0641119257,
-0.1690698415,
0.8808239698,
1.0949299335,
-0.4366687238,
-0.1496063322,
-0.7948634028,
0.5060116053,
0.0905003473,
-0.8114997149,
0.3995093703,
0.515910387,
0.2988320291,
0.0827783942,
0.9581861496,
-0.3613891006,
0.2465729862,
0.2575465441,
-0.2431096137,
-0.0707618967,
-0.1156712919,
0.2819090188,
0.1611881107,
0.1815137416,
0.0842595175
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.04261v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.04261v1
|
A Novel BERT-based Classifier to Detect Political Leaning of YouTube Videos based on their Titles
| 2024-02-16T14:44:30 | 2024-02-16T14:44:30 |
Nouar AlDahoul, Talal Rahwan, Yasir Zaki
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
A quarter of US adults regularly get their news from YouTube. Yet, despite
the massive political content available on the platform, to date no classifier
has been proposed to identify the political leaning of YouTube videos. To fill
this gap, we propose a novel classifier based on Bert -- a language model from
Google -- to classify YouTube videos merely based on their titles into six
categories, namely: Far Left, Left, Center, Anti-Woke, Right, and Far Right. We
used a public dataset of 10 million YouTube video titles (under various
categories) to train and validate the proposed classifier. We compare the
classifier against several alternatives that we trained on the same dataset,
revealing that our classifier achieves the highest accuracy (75%) and the
highest F1 score (77%). To further validate the classification performance, we
collect videos from YouTube channels of numerous prominent news agencies, such
as Fox News and New York Times, which have widely known political leanings, and
apply our classifier to their video titles. For the vast majority of cases, the
predicted political leaning matches that of the news agency.
|
[
-0.6631546021,
-0.5513589382,
0.2369447201,
0.0722189844,
-0.6080123782,
0.4429699183,
-0.6343666315,
0.2218415439,
0.4092534781,
0.2439170629,
-0.439779669,
-0.3628842533,
-0.8031634092,
-0.2899568379,
-0.7364760637,
1.2357641459,
0.8467203975,
0.2233582139,
0.2176264524,
0.0201005396,
0.2257088274,
-0.2282082886,
-0.3268595636,
-0.2767292559,
0.3968419135,
0.4154060781,
0.760307312,
0.5157200694,
0.1484626532,
0.2860769033,
0.0174297448,
-0.1395095438,
-0.4575069845,
-0.5565513968,
-0.2513180971,
-0.3434410393,
0.1281485856,
0.0650215447,
0.4211719334,
-0.0630747601,
-0.0852284282,
0.187191993,
-0.1887976676,
0.7031036019,
-0.4542272389,
-0.0547966138,
-1.207867384,
0.2109831274,
-0.140852809,
-0.1340022534,
-0.5265315771,
-0.861825943,
0.2596791387,
-0.0127646169,
0.5749548674,
-0.229661271,
0.9802052379,
0.1251190603,
-0.2589891255,
-0.2056763172,
-0.5983632803,
0.9040102363,
-0.6690137386,
0.6645179391,
0.074761346,
0.4741971195,
0.1405676305,
-0.0828310773,
-0.8222977519,
0.1479034275,
0.6439777613,
-0.1494673789,
-0.201176703,
-0.1685194075,
-0.2447493076,
0.2642842531,
-0.4107258618,
0.0031282529,
-0.4177904725,
-0.224963814,
0.5344393253,
-0.5312523246,
0.3999479413,
-0.7443001866,
-0.4512583613,
-0.154729709,
-0.4069085717,
0.4436598718,
0.8151103258,
0.6315992475,
0.316185981,
0.6107828021,
0.1075383574,
0.6411852837,
0.5047370195,
-0.1702748984,
0.1359069645,
0.2328408509,
-0.455096364,
0.561003685,
0.8733499646,
0.7382822037,
0.5753701329,
0.0560522303,
0.0682030395,
0.1529294103,
0.4942842722,
-0.5864431858,
-0.5344932675,
0.1089041159,
-0.4419175982,
-0.4374072254,
0.3276250064,
-0.7483504415,
-0.7834935188,
-0.2347368449,
0.2892242968,
-0.4578848481,
-0.3663845956,
-0.0350969024,
-0.0492431521,
0.4717594087,
0.5426611304,
-0.7860637307,
-0.2005753964,
1.1053373814,
0.8379144073,
-0.126967907,
0.2243427336,
-0.5634167194,
-0.2441151738,
-0.3989512324,
0.7292283773,
-0.6724115014,
0.4619198143,
0.3782504201,
0.076464951,
0.4961152375,
-0.2929559946,
0.4684702158,
-0.7793359756,
0.3004656136,
-0.3580210209,
-0.7208504677,
-0.2997978628,
0.4136157334,
-0.7932388783,
0.5301994681,
-0.4258930683,
-0.8693760037,
0.678755641,
-0.4046474695,
-0.2230303437,
-0.2835596502,
-0.3994728029,
-0.5632171035,
-0.1839193553,
0.2450737357,
0.590726912,
0.0838986412,
0.7562588453,
-0.3240000904,
-0.0367499143,
0.192069158,
-0.3730545044,
1.0121088028,
-0.0380196199,
-0.3929985762,
0.144162938,
-0.5599058867,
0.1142090932,
-0.3816873729,
-0.0473162979,
-0.3394834101,
0.3144084215,
0.0944482759,
0.2894704044,
0.2216681987,
-1.0415397882,
-0.0539541543,
0.0872185826,
0.4095801413,
1.2493056059,
-0.4463980198,
0.5169067979,
-0.048755195,
0.2143746912,
-0.2599699199,
0.1818960011,
0.6165398955,
-0.8191350102,
-0.6172379255,
-0.2338110358,
0.4630725384,
0.5960021615,
-0.4819114506,
0.7997923493,
-0.4558236003,
-0.6090488434,
-0.2709590495,
0.1399234384,
-0.0381535403,
0.2932583094,
0.371065259,
0.0967325196,
-0.5836133361,
-1.0035326481,
-0.2552905083,
-0.4886682332,
-0.1769155115,
0.3126737177,
0.3234025836,
0.0763530433,
1.0830215216,
-0.1145762578,
-0.4476720095,
-0.0941319317,
0.4431086481,
0.2691870034,
-0.0642159879,
0.2614271343,
-1.2020184994,
-0.4641723633,
0.0566752627,
-0.3479151726,
0.173848778,
-0.1712377667,
-0.0138770603,
-0.0653673038,
0.1655957103,
0.0345967188,
0.0026417514,
0.56839329,
-0.1778326631,
0.1420689672,
0.1847616881,
0.0799579471,
-0.8094207048,
-0.4699605107,
0.2341207564,
-0.2072088271,
-0.4024888873,
-0.6676316857,
0.1981632113,
0.1518130153,
-0.7814862132,
-0.0378298201,
0.2809233963,
-0.0566262379,
-0.0860247687,
-0.0313300118,
-0.6552260518,
0.240541935,
0.4256708622,
0.4520444572,
0.4382843077,
-0.4128166735,
0.6608461738,
0.1018180326,
-0.7216112018,
0.5035827756,
-0.1510370076,
-0.075946942,
-0.2922815084,
0.2077687532,
-1.2690435648,
-0.3109638691,
-0.252161324,
-0.813519299,
-0.0315730497,
-0.4291307926,
-0.3904522359,
-0.3187599778,
-0.5489048958,
-0.2563407421,
0.4441200495,
-0.6675517559,
0.531842947,
0.7343361974,
-0.1255777329,
-0.9633869529,
-0.4338832498,
0.0229087826,
-0.2792310417,
-0.5948360562,
0.2223919928,
0.1637959331,
0.1769861728,
0.4074877203,
-0.2279223651,
-0.5443643928,
-0.461173594,
0.0234230999,
-0.0903611034,
-0.1149919704,
0.3695577383,
-0.0663041323,
0.36372298,
0.1630789787,
-0.1672562212,
0.5318773389,
-0.291685462,
-0.0589868315,
-0.5447052121,
0.226547569,
0.753030479,
-0.2812868059,
0.219881162,
0.9578903913,
-0.3456016779,
-0.4436136484,
-0.6747130156,
-0.1095428318,
-0.4436334968,
0.5499847531,
0.2941572368,
-0.4942690432,
0.4886415899,
0.4097413123,
0.1560429633,
0.1832012683,
0.7047713399,
-0.1325825751,
0.9620735645,
0.6113765836,
-0.5344620347,
0.8428350091,
-0.5107955933,
0.2610252798,
-0.1839271188,
-0.1773241758,
-0.3671898842,
-0.7068023682,
-0.7526652813,
-0.3661710322,
0.09484303,
-0.6998078227,
-0.5146959424,
0.4235171378,
-0.6768057942,
0.6236746907,
0.5667518377,
0.1967835426,
-0.0591339432,
0.3121109605,
0.3014805913,
-0.3456358016,
-0.5392497778,
-0.5108116865,
1.1654596329,
0.4152430594,
0.923813045,
0.3216638863,
0.8832934499,
0.8712674975,
0.5762678385,
-1.0242741108,
0.636918664,
-0.7413662076,
-0.7981923223,
-0.5231181383,
-0.2530581653,
-0.7314844728,
-0.2376379967,
-0.041209206,
-0.3777780533,
0.0474360734,
-0.1557449698,
-0.4045655429,
0.9811831117,
-0.2722534239,
0.7265354991,
-0.6130875945,
-0.3336953819,
-0.1464783251,
-0.6458631754,
0.3159576356,
0.050462123,
0.4116792083,
-0.2221730351,
-0.0949192271,
1.023855567,
-0.1940701902,
0.702018559,
-0.5367251039,
-0.0771623328,
0.2732262015,
-0.4616506398,
0.0041145878,
0.1194169372,
0.1605282873,
-0.1210781634,
-0.3757060468,
-0.177415967,
-0.4559855759,
0.7248008847,
-0.9894610643,
-0.3904548585,
-0.5792508721,
-0.169222042,
-0.1816364378,
0.1559494585,
0.3067335486,
-0.0308281668,
-0.1801998913,
0.8927522302,
1.0896311998,
-0.084782511,
0.3949755132,
0.1265082508,
-0.1110221893,
-0.7756912708,
1.1682971716,
0.164636597,
-0.0604199208,
0.5537008047,
0.3520023823,
-0.6415998936,
-0.3518020213,
-0.5088886023,
0.0103065921,
-0.5797252655,
-0.3175832033,
-0.2959490716,
-0.382179141,
0.0279224776,
-0.3007597625,
-0.6495184898,
-0.1586439759,
-0.1453156173,
-0.0681811422,
0.2518919706,
0.5008906126,
0.0676604956,
0.1423448622,
-0.386198312,
0.4643188417,
0.8880636096,
0.5292883515,
-0.4089734256,
-0.4846923351,
0.1850390285,
0.0728538781,
-0.4499326944,
-1.1141848564,
0.2571306527,
0.4297403991,
0.4014310837,
0.8608506918,
0.3029680848,
0.4370610416,
-0.6306016445,
0.9192773104,
0.3025410175,
-0.8571184874,
0.5818895698,
-0.326941371,
-0.4479885995,
0.4634713531,
0.7056105733,
-0.0400657319,
-0.5403974056,
-0.6386059523,
-0.3973636329,
0.3319244087,
0.2273223251,
0.4826087654,
-0.1425557733,
-0.1581969857,
0.2825720906,
0.3576781154,
-0.9399293065,
-0.0963270515,
-0.5515229702,
-0.239778623,
0.0100902589,
0.096040912,
0.0065878378,
-0.2403486967,
0.6792902946,
-0.2017385066,
0.3020863533,
-0.047683768,
0.0869185925,
-0.1063347682,
0.3890154362,
0.5140711665,
0.4862183332,
-0.8139364123,
0.0244748425,
-0.4186618328,
-0.3715741038,
0.3588306308,
-0.1004308015,
-0.3576541841,
0.5275895596,
-0.1441877782,
0.3644309044,
0.0022632761,
-0.5696447492,
0.6651983857,
-0.1082737371,
-0.1441745907,
-0.636176765,
-0.1706026644,
0.0438342504,
0.2511669993,
0.5842634439,
0.1159084961,
0.1486525238,
-0.8360566497,
0.5994271636,
0.8805831075,
-0.3844177127,
-0.1394748539,
0.5507112741,
0.4866630137,
-0.5274788737,
0.2787801623,
-0.3200313151,
-0.9873377681,
0.695364058,
0.1279574037,
0.8836698532,
-0.2793699205,
0.7211096883,
0.3588458598,
0.2659964561,
-0.2056364864,
0.2499568313,
0.0087114703,
-0.8106177449,
-0.4523760974,
-0.5036094189,
-0.5325522423,
0.5241213441,
-0.8008167148,
0.6151207089,
-0.6771366,
-0.5489079356,
0.3764747679,
0.3106535375,
-0.2992606163,
0.3284634948,
0.6357021332,
0.8000535965,
-1.2596993446,
0.9336301088,
0.8510150313,
0.104792431,
-0.2043110281,
0.109396711,
0.0839492828,
-0.5600084662,
0.5174401999,
0.2631590664,
-0.2955797017,
-0.3096119463,
-0.578014791,
-0.3551283777,
0.5699249506,
0.3116362691,
-0.5141226053,
-0.2899003327,
0.0919996798,
0.3743421733,
-0.4863998294,
-0.1742232144,
-0.0440587476,
0.3590376079,
-0.068503283,
-0.7376192808,
-0.5686137676,
-0.1252889186,
-0.3250504136,
0.3775538504,
-0.7326806188,
0.9543380141,
-0.0996446535,
0.1231785268,
-0.1701908261,
0.6425699592,
-0.0182638224,
0.4855813086,
1.0326256752,
0.4537468255,
0.7379543185,
-0.1582098752,
0.4967136979,
-0.2562156916,
0.7306194901,
0.7948191762,
0.2891339362,
1.0700315237,
0.3106732368,
-0.3629977703,
0.8751089573,
0.5904091597,
-0.3140749335,
0.8720806837,
0.2381292284,
-0.1781362295,
-0.6296554804,
0.1016173065,
-0.1863654554,
0.5937499404,
0.4334816933,
-0.4988547564,
-0.2268003672,
0.1232564002,
0.0242116563,
0.2628138959,
-0.392696172,
0.4315437078,
-0.4382264316,
-0.6708972454,
0.4970135689,
-0.3291628361,
0.8407457471,
-0.4563386738,
0.2854389548,
0.2033872008,
0.3055474758,
-0.3186465502,
-1.1883127689,
0.0176790841,
0.4608894587,
-0.1711538285,
-0.1614505649,
0.2704633176,
-0.634529531,
-0.5118497014,
0.1851009876,
0.2235774547,
0.0466505662,
-0.1352007091,
-0.7422761321,
0.1157215387,
0.1931665391,
0.139521271,
0.2013436854,
0.5439274311,
0.1066091433,
0.6712189913,
0.593272984,
0.0836509541,
0.2107630521,
-0.1992728263,
0.7915369272,
-0.665109396,
-0.5838229656,
-0.7939788699,
0.2916256785,
-0.4142832756,
-0.0300660487,
0.6262132525,
0.7825609446,
0.8737493753,
-0.2232196927,
0.8965585828,
-0.3664225638,
0.3668354154,
-0.3342465162,
0.7229726315,
-0.6341945529,
-0.1764209419,
-0.3002494574,
-0.5815958977,
-0.3170078099,
1.0438071489,
-0.3315774202,
-0.2190633416,
0.2308700681,
0.5375708938,
-0.3794202209,
0.1865629852,
0.037176352,
0.0189007036,
0.5809367299,
0.6047660708,
0.7910522223,
0.0425742008,
0.8901032805,
-0.7484298348,
-0.2906399965,
-0.510902524,
-1.1568773985,
-1.1998796463,
-0.7080709338,
-0.4067629278,
-0.3971366584,
0.0313196331,
0.8976025581,
1.0499960184,
-0.9703603983,
-0.2699254751,
0.0041513029,
0.3129811883,
-0.0736412033,
-0.2972052693,
0.3384552002,
-0.0981633142,
-0.91499722,
-0.1291549057,
-0.0136473412,
-0.4405190051,
-0.4836835563,
0.0936276391,
-0.4613504708,
0.1803575903,
0.5697349906,
0.4187222719,
-1.281416297,
-0.7400997281,
0.2613551915,
0.1563851386,
0.2536606193,
0.8407837749,
-0.5777288079,
0.6070380807,
0.6067947745,
0.6908585429,
0.2642494142,
0.3985421658,
0.1227305457,
-0.7511758804,
-0.1216194332,
0.5667697787,
0.1128838062,
0.5674856901,
-0.053320121,
0.0933973342,
0.0713080466,
-0.5539433956,
-0.7598122358,
0.1717122048,
-1.2731682062,
0.0336189643,
1.0683858395,
0.0561509654,
-0.1781101376,
0.0097290054,
-0.2035014331,
0.2441896796,
-0.8317856193,
1.0333435535,
0.8511918187,
-0.0551853068,
-0.3172328472,
-0.5969206095,
0.6406846642,
0.1159953997,
-0.2990393639,
-0.0718251318,
0.3653068542,
0.5601331592,
0.5933368206,
0.1374334395,
0.1834064573,
0.5505976677,
-0.7056332231,
-0.2853153944,
0.2812494636,
-0.4161940217,
-0.0972374082,
0.4132203758,
-0.4918038249,
-0.5144351721
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10992v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10992v1
|
"Understanding AI": Semantic Grounding in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-16T14:23:55 | 2024-02-16T14:23:55 |
Holger Lyre
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Do LLMs understand the meaning of the texts they generate? Do they possess a
semantic grounding? And how could we understand whether and what they
understand? I start the paper with the observation that we have recently
witnessed a generative turn in AI, since generative models, including LLMs, are
key for self-supervised learning. To assess the question of semantic grounding,
I distinguish and discuss five methodological ways. The most promising way is
to apply core assumptions of theories of meaning in philosophy of mind and
language to LLMs. Grounding proves to be a gradual affair with a
three-dimensional distinction between functional, social and causal grounding.
LLMs show basic evidence in all three dimensions. A strong argument is that
LLMs develop world models. Hence, LLMs are neither stochastic parrots nor
semantic zombies, but already understand the language they generate, at least
in an elementary sense.
|
[
-0.3677696586,
-0.8058587909,
0.9356431365,
0.0530081987,
-0.2730045915,
-0.0079805274,
-0.1542448699,
-0.3484395146,
-0.1510637105,
0.6434244514,
-0.5084558129,
-0.4331816137,
-0.8307269216,
0.052811645,
-0.6110456586,
0.849638164,
0.1503048092,
0.1336011589,
-0.6615676284,
-0.1730097979,
-0.170366019,
-0.5243697166,
-0.6444733739,
-0.6202015877,
0.2464268059,
0.1827884763,
0.6989888549,
0.9555304646,
0.4594684839,
0.3654728532,
-0.1695808023,
-0.164854452,
-0.4488080442,
0.1586448699,
-0.1164903492,
-0.9471639395,
-0.0542977042,
0.3827652931,
0.5553826094,
1.0752491951,
0.2469923943,
-0.0713193566,
-0.0407502465,
0.7922019362,
-0.2904480994,
0.2838989198,
-0.6823886633,
0.2391002625,
0.1342269629,
-0.1632158756,
-0.2651403248,
0.0991222262,
-0.0992336571,
-0.4821445942,
0.1862639934,
0.1550435126,
0.6230272055,
0.5209073424,
-0.4907932878,
-0.3966861367,
-0.6104898453,
0.7554641962,
-0.4424405098,
0.368065238,
0.5057392716,
0.1553307176,
-0.219035849,
-0.5932148099,
-0.7728274465,
-0.5383081436,
0.0184662249,
0.1885155588,
0.1692958772,
0.1534041911,
0.2882275283,
0.6958568096,
-0.2454865426,
0.2743518949,
-0.3542812467,
0.1175625771,
0.5780745149,
-0.0891564786,
0.6428955793,
-0.0197902936,
-0.4936043322,
0.1464833468,
-0.7520296574,
-0.313590914,
0.2094604969,
0.0740850568,
-0.1995594352,
0.7029854059,
-0.1414986849,
0.6633965373,
-0.0482317246,
-0.2317521125,
-0.1123195589,
-0.1669196635,
-0.3931768537,
-0.1037212536,
0.5010522604,
0.2651478052,
0.4854353368,
-0.6278042793,
-0.0912335068,
0.3122401536,
0.3106091619,
-0.3275437057,
-0.0277323872,
0.340052247,
-0.6507267952,
-0.4035040438,
-0.0911147892,
0.0680209994,
-0.3797346056,
-0.6911494732,
0.22909832,
-0.5542577505,
-0.3052320778,
0.0495831147,
-0.1679357141,
0.889298737,
0.4384503365,
-0.8991376162,
0.3846243024,
0.9319096804,
0.5828852057,
-0.1189417392,
-0.6134182811,
-0.127772361,
0.3121966124,
-0.6103602648,
0.8240025043,
-0.3281792104,
-0.3212298155,
-0.0705825761,
-0.1553112566,
0.1579660624,
-0.5018046498,
0.3372144699,
-0.5373696685,
0.3094088733,
-0.2533000708,
-0.6763254404,
-0.3333485425,
0.4029543698,
-0.3283332288,
0.6621528864,
-0.3323007226,
-0.5077462196,
0.2814537585,
-0.544939816,
-0.3731501997,
0.1263446957,
-0.371277988,
0.2047531754,
0.4810938239,
0.0156446174,
0.6477530003,
-0.3828470707,
0.4382286668,
-0.2187579721,
-0.0973814949,
0.2892665267,
-0.3730786443,
0.8177673221,
0.2539063096,
-0.2688362896,
-0.1018213704,
-0.843008697,
-0.057059139,
0.3215888739,
-0.1353504211,
-0.2921543717,
0.4417730868,
-0.3429598808,
0.3467989564,
0.1712240577,
-0.2002689689,
0.0665563419,
-0.536724031,
0.6711246371,
0.5743751526,
-0.2752813101,
0.5630248785,
-0.178263247,
0.103683047,
0.1652537435,
-0.290640831,
-0.3367162049,
-0.398991853,
-1.2107205391,
0.0844381824,
0.1252100915,
0.4936555326,
-0.4152386785,
0.7019529343,
0.003081813,
-0.2554745078,
-0.4823443294,
0.2143329233,
0.2637491822,
0.3544876873,
0.3565252423,
0.0474567711,
-0.1410127431,
-0.8763934374,
-0.2419360429,
-0.3479377627,
-0.1126545295,
0.3372718394,
0.7587022185,
-0.4437365532,
0.8357696533,
-0.2444398403,
-0.0158883445,
-0.3278924823,
0.1986250132,
-0.0358415917,
0.4082850814,
0.3450834155,
-0.8739088774,
0.0034385636,
-0.0596920736,
-1.3759269714,
-0.0031269486,
-0.1612805426,
-0.0943819061,
-0.0882428586,
0.7121382356,
-0.7906851768,
0.318690002,
0.2871931195,
-0.2555957437,
0.11589697,
-0.3222264647,
-0.1919884533,
-0.9258908629,
-0.2677164674,
-0.1221003234,
-0.3201436102,
-0.6974583268,
0.3505367637,
-0.2876470387,
-0.0683630928,
-0.2811591327,
0.4365954697,
-0.5740089417,
-0.3812572956,
-0.5299423933,
0.5902581215,
-0.0348002724,
0.1347126514,
0.1929944158,
0.5653719306,
0.4918921888,
-0.7844973207,
0.5268604755,
0.0265716687,
-0.2577502131,
0.5763689876,
-0.5600700378,
0.2684288323,
-0.5302529931,
0.2555078864,
-1.0145256519,
-0.1652114242,
0.2344245017,
-0.6349939108,
-0.1630980223,
-0.0861461684,
-0.3785303235,
-0.1572973132,
0.1158147007,
0.3224731088,
0.5187322497,
-0.4561200142,
0.586532414,
0.491240561,
0.236379534,
-0.2460343838,
-0.7519974113,
0.419364363,
-0.4652197659,
-0.6351255178,
0.3412853479,
0.1053962111,
-0.9433232546,
0.0394908935,
0.0627916381,
0.0535816923,
0.5793071389,
0.3438402116,
-0.2890061438,
-0.3159886897,
0.2598999739,
-0.1798169613,
-0.5167403817,
0.5229187012,
-0.6822824478,
0.4645715058,
-0.083568871,
-0.3797153234,
-0.3733761311,
0.2902197242,
0.6364403367,
-0.1656262875,
0.7404898405,
0.3222029507,
-0.5255122185,
-0.206146121,
-0.4559051692,
-0.0694600418,
-0.3987043798,
0.0441413186,
-0.5353388786,
-0.6894881129,
0.558626771,
-0.2411835939,
-0.1681493372,
0.8216286898,
0.8249110579,
-0.3990923464,
0.8832865953,
0.9617355466,
-0.1538784504,
0.0670919567,
-0.4785448909,
0.1732449234,
-0.6166105866,
-0.1808625013,
-0.5318319798,
-0.0389936045,
-0.679772079,
-0.42752105,
0.1899693906,
0.420463711,
-0.1573512405,
-0.2507441044,
-0.1161402985,
0.5015934706,
0.5621833205,
-0.1038824171,
0.1856869608,
-0.0993759036,
0.0088520627,
0.2402905673,
-0.4475661516,
-0.833162725,
0.7563752532,
0.5170956254,
0.8156977892,
0.0077976598,
0.5553265214,
0.2038689107,
0.1908920556,
-0.8349922895,
0.5001980066,
0.0825352222,
-0.4267691076,
-0.2780908644,
0.030331824,
-0.6682807207,
0.4862866998,
-0.2454879284,
-0.5049197078,
-0.2498798668,
-0.0086739296,
0.0904515237,
0.3116372526,
-0.380807519,
0.8234961033,
-0.5333917737,
0.0219856985,
-0.4445392489,
-0.8741509914,
0.4579594731,
0.2048028857,
0.4171169698,
-0.3208173811,
-0.1285317838,
0.7739800215,
-0.2372892201,
0.8553078175,
-0.0591594949,
-0.4529353082,
0.2768690288,
-0.1585358977,
0.1565254182,
0.1120432764,
0.0547138453,
0.2008715421,
-0.136603713,
-0.5696543455,
-0.8244678378,
0.5258140564,
-1.1112968922,
-0.8079768419,
-0.3578300178,
-0.4893175364,
-0.1281822622,
0.2513659596,
0.1967060715,
0.1655592769,
-0.3458598554,
0.0512128547,
0.7649159431,
-0.1312979758,
0.1678147465,
0.316773206,
-0.2388000488,
-0.1293863952,
0.7703065872,
-0.0658537373,
0.2436947078,
0.5601060987,
0.2402890325,
-0.1947864592,
-0.6591999531,
-0.423568815,
0.292540431,
-1.0890336037,
0.333137244,
-0.7440929413,
-0.2891786098,
-0.2556536198,
-0.2463079989,
-0.0807318389,
-0.1542736143,
-0.489749372,
-0.3674978316,
0.1920654923,
1.1544282436,
0.0808930844,
0.5088620186,
-0.5181900263,
0.4994812906,
0.3207320869,
0.0039925817,
-0.198118329,
-0.4028835893,
-0.1227968857,
0.2342866212,
-0.1286321282,
-0.9352675676,
0.1088808104,
0.0736727193,
0.5592681766,
0.550586164,
-0.1515784711,
0.5126453042,
-0.6218262315,
0.9463828802,
-0.1753745228,
-1.0762052536,
0.6314992309,
-0.4361502528,
-0.0397921316,
0.2944482565,
0.4282889664,
-0.6157029271,
-0.6016243696,
-0.8028143048,
-0.5939443707,
0.3425226212,
0.07658007,
0.6213726401,
-0.2520049512,
0.7915076017,
0.034387283,
0.2055858076,
-0.997377336,
-0.4119510055,
-0.1253009588,
-0.1855025291,
-0.5225292444,
-0.5476706028,
-0.2255423516,
-0.0766842663,
0.2622437179,
-0.3093322814,
0.4100200832,
-0.070907928,
-0.4007778168,
0.046445284,
0.0415390171,
0.4856820405,
0.8909295797,
0.1594140828,
0.5541890264,
0.092284292,
-0.0167864617,
0.2538990378,
-0.4124846458,
-0.0328714028,
-0.3665511608,
0.8068813682,
0.797408998,
-0.0333885998,
-0.3500219882,
0.3800218105,
0.003945888,
-0.2111515105,
-0.5336937308,
0.2751421332,
0.0572060347,
0.1581018567,
0.2680983841,
-0.3869758546,
0.0444184169,
-0.6920564175,
0.0421120934,
0.6066915393,
-0.1280907542,
-0.369099766,
0.5351314545,
0.158030957,
-0.3349764943,
0.6470745206,
0.0323740318,
-0.5870239735,
0.7932310104,
0.8828128576,
0.9527902603,
0.1282117218,
-0.0628958121,
-0.1763613969,
0.3984931409,
0.0610169657,
0.0650770962,
-0.3719879091,
-1.1746780872,
-0.4158365726,
-0.5052177906,
-0.5659520626,
0.1166825742,
-0.6497184634,
0.1048471183,
-0.3152668774,
0.298553437,
0.146854803,
-0.0524056517,
-0.4354975224,
0.5252033472,
0.4393488765,
0.7679133415,
-1.1161823273,
0.6873934269,
0.7680196762,
-0.295147121,
-0.267498821,
0.3568001688,
-0.2225224823,
-1.1508392096,
1.0867345333,
0.3571078181,
-0.2271452248,
0.4149777889,
-0.949179709,
-0.9131684303,
0.8235978484,
0.1636100262,
0.0902856365,
-0.0248473268,
0.1325144321,
0.4274676442,
-0.4482029974,
0.2520035505,
0.5665838718,
0.4147552252,
-0.1228626668,
-0.2940789461,
-0.2838941216,
-0.083691746,
0.1431045681,
-0.0828605294,
-0.5433716178,
0.7599070668,
-0.1568055451,
-0.2585365176,
-0.0506197438,
1.0581364632,
-0.0501292124,
0.2571513653,
0.2415300906,
0.8201461434,
0.6015643477,
-0.1158376485,
1.0513226986,
-0.5743697286,
0.2628731728,
0.61874336,
-0.1437832564,
0.4931392074,
0.315967083,
-0.3414162695,
0.4061421752,
0.6596341729,
0.2966902554,
0.3473425508,
0.4360927045,
-0.1619425267,
-0.5438027382,
0.0664227009,
-0.2159753442,
0.7772654295,
0.608833313,
-0.2923660576,
-0.2877765596,
0.2411109656,
-0.0604685396,
0.1989338547,
-0.354139924,
1.2732297182,
0.3545918465,
-0.5947978497,
0.4984297454,
0.3174022436,
0.2196132988,
-0.1333632618,
0.0041445601,
-0.2290697396,
0.0356859192,
-0.0001582948,
-0.6796095967,
0.312153846,
-0.0705824718,
-0.4297960997,
-0.3750751317,
0.7260394692,
-0.1497315764,
-0.4440339804,
0.4062749743,
0.849060595,
0.5112349391,
0.2936199903,
-0.7744634748,
0.0359566733,
-0.3726867139,
-0.0358390212,
0.2928403616,
0.7238725424,
-0.113480486,
0.8894729018,
0.5415779352,
0.0113784019,
-0.0088475775,
-0.1277983636,
0.6682849526,
-0.9710973501,
-0.3753100932,
-1.2807041407,
0.2739742398,
0.2545771599,
-0.1238073185,
0.7287417054,
0.2448942959,
0.8087999225,
0.1619671136,
0.8106694221,
0.0348813087,
0.0689551532,
-0.8504031301,
0.4188968241,
-0.515404582,
0.0150950998,
0.039602302,
-0.7092761397,
-0.461224854,
1.0209695101,
-0.5876022577,
0.1144146472,
0.4767736793,
0.1604349315,
0.117181845,
-0.1164196432,
0.5577737093,
0.3631363213,
0.3232814968,
0.0638704896,
1.3472725153,
-0.1327743381,
-0.2625013292,
0.0114133479,
-0.2601766586,
0.157025516,
-0.810761869,
-0.9630159736,
-0.5144042969,
-0.1120961756,
-0.2185673714,
0.0062249498,
0.8492338657,
0.5782794356,
-0.5948652029,
-0.4018075764,
-0.5529774427,
0.4386612177,
0.0318506844,
-0.1494047046,
0.2618663311,
-0.9516352415,
-0.6288214922,
0.3605232537,
0.3990029991,
0.1359721571,
-0.6386460662,
0.0067160954,
0.1030878648,
0.0993540585,
0.7567129135,
0.0369563811,
-1.1674621105,
-0.4395548105,
-0.2843731046,
-0.0813500285,
0.0338582546,
0.6218182445,
-0.8809469938,
0.0609350987,
0.3119523823,
0.7686854601,
0.123737596,
0.088007018,
0.600802958,
-0.2255252153,
0.3620692194,
0.0652038381,
0.3696502447,
0.2403746843,
-0.3039756715,
0.4596159458,
0.5426204801,
-0.6129426956,
-0.7596330047,
0.3227469027,
-0.4530697763,
-0.2940759063,
1.1428707838,
-0.0170987956,
-0.3571492732,
-0.0994174033,
0.0776411965,
0.1617327034,
0.4500533342,
0.5816300511,
0.7474207282,
-0.2044581473,
-0.1386652291,
-0.7479119301,
0.4611717165,
0.3433482647,
-0.883222878,
0.0619279519,
0.5114291906,
0.3060625792,
0.2107251585,
0.7537949681,
0.2100492418,
0.0028025052,
-0.1178686097,
-0.0101596583,
0.3712050021,
-0.4770732522,
-0.4339433908,
0.0113392128,
0.4252912402,
-0.1278053075
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10712v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10712v2
|
An Empirical Study on Cross-lingual Vocabulary Adaptation for Efficient Language Model Inference
| 2024-02-16T14:15:15 | 2024-06-17T12:00:02 |
Atsuki Yamaguchi, Aline Villavicencio, Nikolaos Aletras
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The development of state-of-the-art generative large language models (LLMs)
disproportionately relies on English-centric tokenizers, vocabulary and
pre-training data. Despite the fact that some LLMs have multilingual
capabilities, recent studies have shown that their inference efficiency
deteriorates when generating text in languages other than English. This results
in increased inference time and costs. Cross-lingual vocabulary adaptation
(CVA) methods have been proposed for adapting models to a target language
aiming to improve downstream performance. However, the effectiveness of these
methods on increasing inference efficiency of generative LLMs has yet to be
explored. In this paper, we perform an empirical study of five CVA methods on
four generative LLMs (including monolingual and multilingual models) across
four typologically-diverse languages and four natural language understanding
tasks. We find that CVA substantially contributes to LLM inference speedups of
up to 271.5\%. We also show that adapting LLMs that have been pre-trained on
more balanced multilingual data results in downstream performance comparable to
the original models.
|
[
-0.2363324463,
-0.6176841259,
0.3998248875,
0.525903821,
-0.3143283129,
0.0716272295,
-0.3569912314,
-0.5003429651,
0.0884497911,
0.3831975162,
-0.2910548151,
-0.4620940685,
-0.3873136342,
0.1640829742,
-0.0847748742,
0.6019717455,
0.0501687378,
0.4188385606,
-0.18656452,
-0.1915017664,
-0.5289436579,
-0.6724612713,
-0.5578976274,
-0.2596746087,
0.5145269632,
-0.0212414432,
0.3492894769,
0.3685854673,
0.0574359521,
0.3311622441,
-0.0506286323,
0.1864868701,
-0.5633182526,
-0.2471653223,
-0.431058228,
-0.851039052,
-0.3199819326,
-0.3470990956,
0.7615712881,
0.7716594338,
-0.0399593227,
-0.0545319505,
0.0996589139,
0.5529005527,
-0.9013687968,
0.0135854892,
-0.9433345199,
0.1644980162,
-0.2423011512,
-0.3523590565,
-0.6899108291,
0.1047593877,
0.3272918165,
-1.0848956108,
0.215622887,
0.1276869625,
0.6377190948,
-0.0168885086,
-0.2295915931,
-0.3190896213,
-0.5763583183,
1.0588011742,
-0.6611596346,
0.6683214307,
0.0139563978,
0.079159677,
-0.087253809,
-0.5433731079,
-0.4593141973,
-0.0467939563,
0.0737057552,
0.3595265746,
-0.2777992487,
-0.0371134318,
0.0571042933,
0.1673935801,
-0.4909614325,
0.7421960831,
-0.1768067181,
-0.1444345564,
0.4634340107,
-0.0930384248,
0.2769031823,
-0.2950267196,
-0.5559474826,
-0.1776839197,
-0.7285804152,
0.0054996568,
0.2566867471,
0.4741490185,
-0.4300399125,
0.4149290025,
0.1618784219,
0.8593276143,
-0.1663017571,
-0.2048536539,
0.3372766078,
-0.6618183851,
-0.2650123835,
-0.0786428973,
0.5359569192,
0.2531865239,
0.6559445262,
-0.4009125531,
0.0263593774,
-0.085628435,
0.1174799204,
-0.6571379304,
-0.024051182,
-0.0625789538,
-0.3205986917,
0.1765474528,
-0.2898310423,
-0.6897924542,
-0.1859469861,
-0.2306957692,
0.4009360969,
-0.5107421279,
-0.2250261158,
0.109119989,
-0.282477349,
0.5890724659,
0.3625114858,
-0.8285301328,
0.0230554305,
0.693215549,
0.9740583301,
-0.4612516165,
-0.5590636134,
-0.6521254182,
0.0897942036,
-0.6479701996,
0.859495461,
-0.3192598224,
-0.3779547811,
-0.0069576409,
0.0446181633,
-0.4902054667,
-0.5200244784,
0.3361998498,
-0.7347385883,
0.1292257458,
-0.2849968374,
-0.4369905889,
-0.2919725776,
0.0798161477,
-0.7114828825,
0.7070938349,
0.0257040225,
-0.6665518284,
0.7609008551,
-0.4214285314,
-0.5753400922,
0.0790866092,
0.0505160615,
-0.05905018,
0.3540647924,
0.4936622381,
0.51660043,
-0.5243752599,
0.0403865948,
-0.3177095354,
-0.18880786,
0.1255787909,
-0.5123046041,
0.8745875955,
0.0780849904,
0.0628124103,
0.0301270839,
-0.6442024708,
-0.168788746,
-0.0128730349,
-0.3331947923,
-0.887381196,
0.0007223482,
0.0525543876,
0.1418436319,
-0.0521370247,
-0.2959489226,
-0.1472158581,
-0.4817321897,
0.1322140843,
0.8655912876,
-0.3082045913,
0.4241017401,
-0.259429127,
0.7099842429,
0.214336127,
-0.3139243722,
0.0492734648,
-0.2721624076,
-0.8674367666,
-0.6660482287,
0.593967557,
0.6171386242,
-1.1785045862,
0.1594560593,
-0.6230769157,
-0.3887354732,
-0.5071265697,
0.2887015641,
0.4665359557,
0.2461472154,
0.2510823309,
-0.5267659426,
-0.3211569488,
-0.7322640419,
-0.6293023825,
-0.2711349428,
-0.2136766315,
0.3041954935,
0.3794314563,
0.090893127,
0.648637414,
-0.025832152,
0.1682533324,
-0.483477354,
0.1416609138,
-0.0484026931,
0.0830112174,
1.0046806335,
-0.676386714,
-0.5605689883,
0.2135201246,
-0.5490315557,
-0.2769976258,
-0.4017385542,
-0.3983801901,
0.4949373305,
0.286655575,
-0.3438695073,
0.0794836432,
1.054676652,
-0.2542096972,
0.3935331404,
-0.3707270026,
-0.0276874695,
-1.1316052675,
-0.143376708,
0.133849442,
-0.1408593357,
-0.7514930367,
-0.0173182208,
0.104760766,
0.3350820839,
-0.5504694581,
0.7051684856,
-0.8498401046,
-0.3335999846,
0.0589421093,
0.2229469717,
0.0033083945,
0.3819779158,
0.3407410383,
0.919941783,
0.5934993625,
-0.7928686738,
-0.1540305465,
-0.0344361737,
-0.4511085749,
0.5072151423,
-0.3678949177,
-0.1940810978,
-0.2460476458,
0.0984950215,
-0.7711347938,
0.1556202769,
-0.1252674758,
-0.109793365,
0.3523851931,
-0.1792268008,
-0.1767516732,
0.0846423656,
-0.2112443298,
0.4015656114,
0.3347609341,
-0.8755646944,
1.0827502012,
0.2996021211,
-0.1640603393,
-0.5173704624,
-0.8690348268,
0.0806383789,
-0.2826042175,
-0.6103470922,
0.4102917612,
0.0697375312,
-0.3464834988,
-0.2232988775,
0.0623852089,
0.1023295298,
0.2610761821,
-0.2024713457,
0.1986219138,
-0.3655926585,
0.2546976209,
0.0502809174,
0.1692153811,
0.1316154152,
-0.1738825142,
0.5334163308,
0.0793720558,
-0.2702214122,
-0.0997351632,
0.1693404615,
0.556012094,
-0.2645568848,
0.963021934,
0.543384254,
-0.1337066591,
-0.5378436446,
-0.4802171588,
0.0460447781,
-0.3776196837,
0.6358690262,
-0.7421828508,
-0.6152094603,
0.5863577724,
0.0295025185,
0.187741518,
0.5012030005,
0.7146853209,
0.3669581115,
0.4662857354,
0.5179405808,
-0.1203893498,
0.5000706911,
-0.0305013843,
0.208352685,
-0.6655753851,
-0.0559438467,
-0.4669152796,
0.1225032955,
-0.9943112731,
-1.0000636578,
0.2229584008,
0.0879509524,
0.3287948966,
0.1485012472,
0.1439359486,
0.0523392186,
0.3934603333,
-0.1468534768,
0.4936567247,
0.3435400426,
-0.1215119958,
0.0399454758,
-1.2472264767,
-0.145841822,
1.1291511059,
0.2474659979,
0.7100375295,
0.2838664949,
0.3301402032,
-0.1087831259,
0.6527407169,
-0.7364281416,
0.2247911096,
-0.5764659643,
-0.4753712118,
-0.1789709777,
-0.5538191795,
-0.8806666136,
0.6972944736,
-0.2285400331,
-0.4070854485,
0.306959033,
0.0494183265,
-0.0433523729,
0.2855154276,
-0.7985174656,
0.8004612923,
-0.3974912465,
-0.3174006343,
-0.2450913489,
-0.1697099656,
0.4613179266,
-0.6417672634,
0.4515236914,
-0.0424531102,
-0.1501875818,
0.7575612664,
-0.2562449574,
0.755551517,
-0.0721828341,
-0.3825815618,
0.1207538918,
-0.3208110929,
0.4255896509,
-0.1250208914,
-0.2475889921,
0.6257939339,
-0.0259061046,
-0.5604100227,
-0.5633136034,
0.5431192517,
-0.7519478202,
-0.5749555826,
-0.3446066082,
-0.8284243345,
-0.3467902839,
-0.1072362512,
0.2943861783,
0.2188582122,
-0.3766190708,
0.1320651919,
0.4031640589,
-0.6201593876,
0.3901469111,
0.6966254711,
-0.1100200489,
-0.1142484397,
0.7529939413,
0.356416434,
0.6804090142,
0.6944204569,
0.1969793439,
-0.2376269996,
-0.7509579659,
-0.6781150103,
0.3071932495,
-0.626655519,
0.2426959127,
-0.7455996871,
0.0509461947,
-0.4450002015,
-0.2259377092,
-0.3108175397,
-0.2238281816,
-0.3055864871,
-0.0089212162,
0.4815291762,
0.1612353325,
0.0201335791,
0.1468349546,
-0.6589483619,
0.3960958123,
0.2320903987,
-0.0894830003,
0.1014449075,
-0.7972691655,
-0.140846312,
-0.0189945977,
0.2044975162,
-0.5397722721,
0.444866538,
0.5362839103,
0.6286720037,
0.0802690312,
-0.2117259502,
1.0073806047,
-0.4226987958,
0.6617719531,
0.1173779145,
-0.9249336123,
-0.1384548694,
-0.1084994674,
0.3838970363,
0.1277089417,
0.4583949149,
-0.4938390851,
-0.1686514616,
0.0210968591,
-0.8478226066,
0.474101156,
-0.0944292024,
0.3159668446,
0.07246124,
0.1888056993,
0.3218423426,
-0.1553586125,
-0.6074956059,
-0.0371349864,
-0.0932406932,
-0.0389585309,
-0.5359980464,
-0.0679709017,
0.1934617609,
-0.1542679965,
0.7173532844,
-0.5396078825,
-0.1028466523,
-0.0036515484,
-0.4711945057,
0.2435050011,
0.3669942915,
0.3564825952,
0.8244576454,
0.2248528898,
-0.0585515276,
0.6811287999,
-0.3505852818,
0.0053556333,
0.2297348976,
-0.1230267063,
0.0612663031,
0.69320786,
0.9459970593,
0.2648769617,
-0.735879302,
0.2450924814,
-0.1816308647,
-0.0903954059,
-0.1976059675,
0.0432569683,
0.3524641693,
0.1010224745,
0.2859006822,
-0.3398242891,
-0.1208767369,
-0.5763068795,
-0.2337294817,
0.6582207084,
-0.0119068697,
-0.2132002562,
0.3831872642,
0.1002105623,
0.0307530686,
0.3046908677,
-0.020408066,
-0.3417357206,
0.4690766037,
0.5562629104,
0.8540170789,
-0.1973611861,
0.1604012102,
0.1603087485,
0.3010255694,
0.0770610496,
0.2538636923,
0.0329405926,
-1.0418504477,
-0.8553985953,
-0.9268308282,
-0.237967357,
0.0013344779,
-0.6085925102,
-0.0134084253,
-0.0807043314,
0.0719168484,
0.2643184066,
-0.1415299475,
-0.7788320184,
0.0733690783,
0.0368012451,
1.1773853302,
-0.9617395401,
0.6951798201,
0.5821959376,
0.1064248458,
-0.6948239207,
-0.0246930569,
-0.1719739884,
-0.9237694144,
0.680054903,
-0.0379656628,
-0.3261418343,
0.0400343686,
0.0097484812,
-0.7535216212,
0.9122796059,
0.4601145983,
-0.7081818581,
-0.0756849796,
0.1652918756,
0.6793353558,
-0.440772146,
0.1233593151,
0.59584409,
0.381175667,
-0.1260440648,
-0.8615425825,
-0.0840335116,
-0.1186163351,
0.4919801056,
0.0880570486,
-0.479580164,
0.7058950067,
-0.0858704224,
-0.1406876594,
0.1053324863,
0.8163973093,
0.4321438074,
0.1487399042,
0.7847936749,
0.5564749837,
0.6591384411,
0.0614010803,
1.1384575367,
-0.4091948271,
0.0153219085,
0.9435890317,
-0.3190223277,
0.7935877442,
0.6946755648,
-0.0738165006,
0.6353554726,
0.5325997472,
0.0888831019,
0.3712670207,
0.2124597728,
-0.2859473228,
-0.3957231939,
-0.2680018842,
-0.1633762866,
0.7999952435,
0.5302602053,
-0.4981042445,
-0.0988858342,
0.0249585528,
-0.0080736428,
-0.1189590916,
-0.4475538433,
0.6855220199,
0.0650954992,
-0.9296109676,
0.802408278,
0.1051147133,
0.8262096047,
-0.6071622968,
0.2616563737,
-0.0995397642,
0.1562545747,
0.013415697,
-0.2587482929,
-0.0470326692,
0.178730309,
-0.0877727717,
-0.0307581201,
0.4828031659,
-0.4180079699,
-0.7134390473,
0.7278852463,
0.8697240949,
0.2185132802,
0.1699166596,
-0.586355567,
-0.0529667661,
-0.1031126082,
-0.3994130194,
0.3428822458,
0.5210236311,
-0.3387964368,
0.4714325666,
0.7920755148,
0.4012009501,
0.369748354,
0.3844200075,
0.6003708839,
-0.4173326194,
-0.4100240469,
-0.6678645611,
0.3422830701,
0.0897715762,
-0.3432510793,
0.9588641524,
0.401156038,
1.2714562416,
-0.1377591789,
0.8569155931,
0.1794213802,
0.2379424572,
-1.0562987328,
0.4433554411,
-0.8187040687,
0.1898099035,
-0.1930351257,
-0.7831497788,
-0.1058876514,
0.3080078661,
-0.4425598085,
0.3399531841,
0.5584414005,
0.8002775311,
-0.1576805115,
-0.2581088841,
0.4587373435,
0.2798276544,
0.1588554084,
0.5525618792,
0.4933637679,
-0.2249790728,
0.2496515214,
-0.2933285534,
-0.1952527314,
-0.1044928133,
-1.0753047466,
-0.9233903289,
-0.2504524887,
-0.1774407625,
-0.0789205357,
0.2180898488,
0.555042088,
0.7311630845,
-0.7810766101,
-0.3310512602,
-0.1610064656,
0.1187179238,
-0.2276371717,
-0.1977725625,
0.335773766,
-0.4765984118,
-0.9521132112,
0.4530643821,
0.2666041255,
-0.1196196005,
-0.2977273762,
-0.1758001745,
-0.3011794686,
0.3057709932,
0.8577516675,
0.1125921533,
-0.8251546621,
-0.1618958414,
-0.0189818889,
0.0359432623,
0.0652856454,
0.7908553481,
-0.6060580015,
0.6471524239,
0.6978887916,
0.8609544635,
0.5261393189,
-0.011214572,
0.8972257972,
-0.5554035902,
0.2508900762,
-0.1217708811,
0.4129242599,
0.4967848063,
-0.057736095,
0.2907637358,
0.2488098592,
-0.1594008803,
-0.6767889261,
0.1151071638,
-0.6655709147,
-0.504024446,
1.1923747063,
-0.4098871052,
-0.4079700112,
-0.1788215041,
0.2335623503,
0.3357108831,
0.0458442681,
0.4877833724,
0.6740294099,
0.1117646545,
-0.1302444786,
-0.5126564503,
0.2088516951,
0.7616271973,
-1.0379177332,
0.1363882422,
0.2826018035,
0.3804530203,
0.1229462922,
0.4344875813,
0.1163256988,
0.2600411177,
0.0179297477,
0.0756922737,
0.3128239214,
-0.2790257633,
-0.5438663363,
-0.0137776164,
0.1705067754,
0.0956140384
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10699v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10699v1
|
Rethinking Human-like Translation Strategy: Integrating Drift-Diffusion Model with Large Language Models for Machine Translation
| 2024-02-16T14:00:56 | 2024-02-16T14:00:56 |
Hongbin Na, Zimu Wang, Mieradilijiang Maimaiti, Tong Chen, Wei Wang, Tao Shen, Ling Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated promising potential in various
downstream tasks, including machine translation. However, prior work on
LLM-based machine translation has mainly focused on better utilizing training
data, demonstrations, or pre-defined and universal knowledge to improve
performance, with a lack of consideration of decision-making like human
translators. In this paper, we incorporate Thinker with the Drift-Diffusion
Model (Thinker-DDM) to address this issue. We then redefine the Drift-Diffusion
process to emulate human translators' dynamic decision-making under constrained
resources. We conduct extensive experiments under the high-resource,
low-resource, and commonsense translation settings using the WMT22 and CommonMT
datasets, in which Thinker-DDM outperforms baselines in the first two
scenarios. We also perform additional analysis and evaluation on commonsense
translation to illustrate the high effectiveness and efficacy of the proposed
method.
|
[
-0.3679104745,
-0.6309859157,
0.7639780641,
-0.0316445902,
-0.5741770864,
0.2315218151,
-0.5266174078,
-0.1507175416,
0.1670130938,
0.4647102058,
-0.6165046692,
-0.3603122234,
-0.5961282849,
0.3539286256,
-0.395051688,
0.9984662533,
-0.3688203096,
-0.0324262269,
0.0572253466,
-0.1611507684,
-0.4841621518,
-0.1881558448,
-0.6042374372,
-0.6344807744,
0.446274668,
0.2564258277,
0.9965913892,
0.632653594,
0.4465872049,
0.2163631767,
-0.4340747595,
-0.0621255413,
-0.4930091798,
0.0949808434,
-0.2894375622,
-0.6738810539,
-0.5801686645,
0.2312652022,
0.5434511304,
0.3837613761,
-0.479814738,
0.0997258723,
-0.0947608575,
0.6213007569,
-0.3091309369,
-0.3007358909,
-0.7172070742,
0.2247558087,
-0.1927386522,
0.0690766796,
-0.3705557287,
-0.2604751587,
0.286943078,
-0.5268397331,
0.388086915,
0.2467527241,
0.3239851296,
0.5497935414,
-0.4506123364,
-0.1247185543,
-0.746394217,
0.9639509916,
-0.9373187423,
0.4468638599,
0.1387186944,
0.1918619424,
-0.2058492601,
-0.3397314847,
-0.8593420386,
-0.029918626,
0.0938280672,
0.1330726296,
-0.1427319497,
-0.3083800673,
-0.0112227006,
0.196527943,
-0.3098076582,
0.2793979645,
-0.123515673,
-0.0376461186,
0.7481948137,
0.1923705637,
0.2825781107,
-0.1994511485,
-0.5204795599,
-0.2098629624,
-0.5175568461,
-0.4044805467,
-0.1189600602,
0.2143542022,
-0.2642504871,
0.4562281072,
-0.2703744471,
0.5726771951,
0.1355457157,
-0.0081680054,
0.4239702225,
-0.244538039,
-0.2174782008,
-0.1086810678,
0.8624052405,
0.6431572437,
0.2532462478,
-0.3515802026,
-0.5161423087,
-0.1785970032,
0.405946821,
-0.6686909199,
-0.086763531,
0.1672364771,
-0.5450216532,
-0.4965564311,
-0.509909451,
-1.0504704714,
-0.3214999139,
-0.3864984512,
0.2382792979,
-0.2498219758,
-0.5653030872,
0.1977602839,
-0.0210737176,
0.3009509146,
0.448338151,
-0.7935901284,
0.1736807674,
0.4386426508,
0.9929848909,
-0.7245367765,
-0.3129889369,
-0.3010472059,
0.1922611743,
-0.3877394497,
0.7007070184,
-0.3964685202,
-0.5751205087,
-0.2151879072,
-0.3059663773,
-0.0619290769,
-0.7349009514,
0.6545531154,
-0.6892430782,
0.2449651659,
-0.2517399788,
-0.3913001716,
-0.0396363251,
0.3667434156,
-0.5883719921,
0.5645756721,
0.0584411174,
-0.5537363887,
0.4802902341,
-0.8789006472,
-0.5301929712,
0.1988639981,
0.0115299579,
-0.3667847514,
0.255790174,
0.1365020424,
0.3964871764,
-0.4741084874,
0.253046304,
-0.1364361644,
-0.1804120094,
0.5968015194,
-0.508366406,
0.5275212526,
0.5593718886,
-0.2762230933,
0.0527746789,
-0.159951508,
-0.0173337758,
0.268665731,
-0.6197541952,
-0.1870928258,
0.1117284819,
0.1686367691,
0.5389633775,
-0.0568686128,
-0.4754150808,
0.228984192,
-0.3707222044,
0.7377066016,
0.4611326456,
-0.065746896,
0.8982991576,
-0.2447213233,
0.7422847748,
0.0375394672,
-0.0460704714,
0.2786783278,
-0.3823483884,
-0.73276335,
-0.0983597338,
0.1755319387,
0.7531000376,
-0.6970080137,
-0.0285977107,
-0.5646352768,
-0.1356624216,
-1.0383807421,
0.3289814889,
0.3113580346,
0.4807078838,
0.6185587645,
-0.2572697997,
-0.2768566608,
-0.7192137837,
-0.2810205519,
0.0930652246,
-0.0130546317,
-0.1430853754,
0.2916874886,
-0.7464103699,
0.7381739616,
-0.6154070497,
-0.1152779311,
-0.5830888152,
0.0265209768,
0.2756774127,
0.3964231312,
0.0463848971,
-1.0239804983,
-0.4663210511,
0.0715277717,
-0.4940291345,
-0.0695682019,
-0.2009831965,
-0.297349751,
0.1921868473,
0.6236621737,
-0.9165663719,
0.2872883379,
0.5037872791,
-0.0218990613,
0.2605237067,
-0.3669380844,
0.0976940021,
-1.2906825542,
-0.038293533,
0.1347587109,
-0.3787712157,
-0.6038416028,
0.3557811677,
0.1293061972,
-0.0607803874,
-0.7975759506,
0.5337941051,
-0.3626515269,
0.0884055197,
-0.3996677995,
0.3932751715,
-0.3212499917,
0.1913453639,
0.0277464967,
0.883066833,
0.0353140868,
-0.5708081126,
0.1824656427,
0.3421378732,
-0.2424148023,
0.6972183585,
-0.6062474251,
0.2078524828,
-0.1503788531,
0.4822382927,
-0.7280936837,
-0.2252884954,
0.2795173526,
-0.1321681142,
0.4196535945,
-0.1127009541,
-0.5248010755,
-0.3848980963,
-0.1086180806,
0.4307717085,
0.8833654523,
-0.1204715371,
0.4887291193,
0.294929117,
-0.1909551173,
-0.0899328664,
-0.88639009,
0.4757570028,
-0.6079694629,
-0.4399612844,
0.6425138712,
-0.1709370464,
-0.366376698,
-0.240901053,
-0.0392123647,
0.0853678584,
0.2281527817,
-0.2493939847,
0.3487594724,
0.1548975557,
-0.1295122057,
-0.0232680012,
-0.3827291131,
-0.0319353417,
-0.5228504539,
0.5230366588,
0.1617405862,
-0.1746941209,
-0.4299994111,
0.2369716018,
0.7886944413,
-0.2592982948,
0.5391367078,
0.6966669559,
0.0844658837,
-0.3461271226,
-0.4842039943,
-0.0844298825,
-0.4072399735,
0.5835309029,
-0.3741108775,
-0.7089207172,
0.3570556045,
-0.4574365616,
0.2165867984,
0.3599309921,
0.8755119443,
-0.5774351358,
0.9650774598,
0.3854288459,
-0.1300768554,
0.3440152705,
-0.2875927389,
0.0729934648,
-1.1163343191,
-0.0980445445,
0.0402508527,
-0.8779094815,
-0.6019238234,
-0.8176534772,
0.2794876993,
-0.0183403455,
0.0510678887,
0.3864949048,
-0.2130805403,
0.4272813797,
0.2750307322,
0.0310805198,
0.4784187376,
-0.1455951184,
-0.2728177905,
-0.1303609014,
-0.7120735049,
-0.6751140356,
1.0425059795,
0.2344704717,
0.6467323899,
0.3650674522,
0.7348439097,
0.5649189949,
0.5618854165,
-0.6868145466,
0.6188181043,
-0.146103099,
-0.5410746336,
-0.2360022217,
-0.4908321202,
-0.9065204859,
0.5677476525,
-0.1635663062,
-0.0933489576,
-0.2371739,
0.1983097196,
-0.0875708535,
0.3803869486,
-0.6991332173,
0.7119094133,
-0.292277813,
-0.0486204103,
-0.63019979,
-0.6472051144,
0.2390454412,
-0.4066742957,
0.3722937107,
-0.0281748064,
-0.5076683164,
0.4632062614,
-0.0397550389,
0.7282322049,
-0.0062780133,
-0.445691824,
0.1515273154,
0.3345403671,
0.6820945144,
-0.2554478645,
-0.2376541048,
-0.064960435,
-0.4954525828,
-0.5263040662,
-0.5353246331,
0.4375171959,
-0.7089902759,
-0.7349491119,
0.0352762006,
-0.5927152038,
-0.011805065,
0.28392452,
0.4499406517,
-0.0650222823,
-0.3979497254,
-0.1468506902,
0.7928187251,
0.0696397424,
0.5314407945,
0.7447084785,
-0.3153570592,
-0.4394272864,
0.8231569529,
-0.0322573595,
0.6530029774,
0.5594309568,
0.2194413543,
-0.3032531738,
-0.8094030619,
-0.9377189875,
0.3091304004,
-0.3056479394,
-0.0134423329,
-0.527207315,
0.1477007419,
-0.0235001668,
-0.2501473725,
-0.3461860716,
-0.2268066108,
-0.27875489,
-0.0208655111,
0.0054128249,
0.6265134811,
0.2401021719,
0.3221995533,
-0.589333117,
0.2741833031,
0.2822126746,
0.1035467908,
0.2162141055,
-0.7976390719,
-0.4599080682,
0.3107526302,
-0.5395088196,
-0.8697264791,
0.5220988393,
-0.1125488654,
0.631177187,
0.1923278272,
-0.0716645047,
0.3722857833,
-0.7336414456,
0.4205359519,
0.2021519542,
-0.7850298882,
0.447535336,
-0.5076901317,
0.548564136,
0.4962094128,
0.2016099095,
-0.7933399677,
-0.4004009366,
-0.3325253427,
-0.5865752101,
0.4753510356,
0.2450626343,
0.2289457321,
-0.007702786,
0.3597888052,
-0.0116375247,
0.1651009768,
-0.5827097893,
0.04961114,
0.0467744134,
-0.222096011,
-0.2293766737,
0.0480369143,
0.1228305846,
-0.1817486435,
0.4534993768,
0.1365560591,
-0.0178756379,
0.0259964373,
-0.413082242,
-0.2438387573,
0.6436704397,
0.5854696035,
0.4484874308,
-0.1835270226,
0.0874550417,
0.6740075946,
-0.3259477913,
0.5969019532,
-0.269149214,
-0.6039009094,
-0.2145274878,
0.2195365578,
0.530505836,
0.3631429076,
-0.6583939791,
0.2461678386,
0.2700361609,
-0.2664625943,
0.0110796271,
0.2687481046,
0.5026350617,
0.2768322527,
0.2277621776,
0.3762386143,
-0.1556941718,
-0.3072882891,
-0.0254227519,
0.1998431832,
-0.4582404196,
-0.5607526302,
0.7714336514,
0.6839940548,
-0.6676012278,
0.6887863278,
-0.5626342297,
-0.6975800395,
0.160308823,
0.6875921488,
1.0873439312,
-0.2320894599,
0.2727635205,
-0.0067124432,
0.3046317995,
-0.42591694,
-0.0027635584,
-0.0398068801,
-0.7353976369,
-0.8017182946,
-0.3103262186,
-0.2986964285,
-0.1455292851,
-0.6499044895,
0.2536314726,
-0.0713451579,
-0.4451893568,
-0.2937322855,
-0.1318489164,
-0.7784993052,
0.0361804664,
0.2079835832,
1.0532085896,
-0.7964585423,
0.9263037443,
0.9105337858,
-0.3425296545,
-0.0969464406,
0.4084336162,
0.1467771828,
-0.5949653983,
0.5835160017,
-0.2292085588,
-0.2590712607,
0.2772998214,
-0.394064486,
-0.8247173429,
1.2212324142,
0.2290488631,
-0.735547781,
-0.0851157457,
-0.0806114227,
0.5974351764,
-0.3026883602,
-0.2695869207,
0.720543921,
0.3770079017,
-0.0430990718,
-0.8794620037,
0.0162630323,
0.0144680543,
0.2474578917,
0.5232946277,
-0.8058868647,
0.5943371058,
-0.4606633484,
-0.4324911535,
-0.1213568002,
0.6210363507,
-0.0250851084,
0.1422227621,
0.6318147182,
0.9159625173,
0.6763209701,
0.561237216,
1.0896131992,
0.2477775514,
0.1938109547,
0.9990814924,
-0.3694756627,
1.2501008511,
0.5522301197,
-0.4490176141,
0.5691506267,
0.262689352,
0.1967114657,
0.6946707964,
0.2531186044,
-0.2700537443,
-0.3509833217,
0.0988947973,
-0.0914604813,
0.2708050311,
0.206352964,
-0.3236013651,
-0.0904138982,
-0.0492617153,
0.3572076857,
0.2547096312,
-0.1211169958,
0.8591902256,
0.1469573379,
-0.7837585211,
0.6953428984,
0.3522707224,
0.9917949438,
-0.1493107677,
0.2802450359,
-0.3305550516,
0.1398734897,
0.1572998464,
-0.9491904974,
0.2925770581,
0.2458426207,
-0.5523017645,
-0.6353145242,
0.3447167873,
-0.5333673358,
-0.4808107913,
0.1682196259,
0.881652534,
0.1075644866,
0.0246210136,
-0.7734368443,
-0.0065540103,
0.4728388488,
-0.0421778448,
0.4672567546,
0.5078727007,
-0.0516179912,
1.08824265,
0.6106353402,
0.2876046896,
-0.1643069685,
0.0733302906,
0.7309737206,
-0.8972988725,
-0.4362415373,
-1.109803915,
0.2942926586,
0.0016816458,
-0.3868422508,
0.6956528425,
0.3419428766,
0.7874754667,
-0.0146148913,
0.6628667116,
0.099247925,
0.4620656073,
-0.3784393072,
0.7875964642,
-0.3676294982,
0.2817828655,
-0.298884958,
-1.0809447765,
0.0079714786,
0.4300590158,
-0.3758216798,
-0.0406240374,
0.4181192517,
0.6858466268,
-0.1731267869,
-0.0832766593,
0.1466506124,
0.1709044874,
0.4596063793,
0.6422139406,
0.9147058725,
-0.1086455509,
0.7464569807,
0.2135682851,
-0.160073638,
-0.296132803,
-1.0415835381,
-0.7691961527,
-0.4143114686,
-0.3721343875,
-0.0398997627,
-0.281534791,
1.1202358007,
0.7136478424,
-0.4888213575,
-0.2444884181,
-0.13965635,
0.1188590825,
-0.1625896394,
-0.1450763494,
0.0220269337,
-0.3164901435,
-0.6619442701,
0.407975316,
0.0651725307,
0.3122255504,
-0.4927510321,
-0.4826549888,
-0.1134464443,
0.0053209029,
0.5864903927,
-0.0934796035,
-0.9585607648,
0.255535692,
-0.0162016954,
-0.3082621992,
-0.0855340213,
0.7767071724,
-0.8500999212,
0.5009794235,
0.364182651,
0.6918442845,
0.524261117,
0.1183097288,
0.8069248199,
-0.342189461,
0.032093551,
0.2467834353,
0.0331495926,
0.5635640025,
0.0465251096,
0.3918644786,
0.1788581759,
-0.4498834312,
-0.4760498703,
0.316310823,
-0.5664662719,
-0.2581502199,
1.1968977451,
0.1545127928,
-0.1260969639,
-0.1144347042,
-0.1964180619,
0.1820090413,
-0.5224484205,
0.9721797705,
0.6477578282,
0.1622050107,
-0.1435721964,
-0.6785168052,
0.3753875494,
0.4907788336,
-0.5894717574,
0.2189699113,
0.2443735152,
0.3680936396,
0.0535363927,
0.6545089483,
0.1235121638,
-0.0214338079,
-0.3964032829,
-0.1084916741,
0.1294840723,
0.1028596759,
-0.2251191437,
-0.3217235506,
0.1091508269,
-0.131099239
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10693v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10693v3
|
Exploring Precision and Recall to assess the quality and diversity of LLMs
| 2024-02-16T13:53:26 | 2024-06-04T11:33:27 |
Florian Le Bronnec, Alexandre Verine, Benjamin Negrevergne, Yann Chevaleyre, Alexandre Allauzen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We introduce a novel evaluation framework for Large Language Models (LLMs)
such as \textsc{Llama-2} and \textsc{Mistral}, focusing on importing Precision
and Recall metrics from image generation to text generation. This approach
allows for a nuanced assessment of the quality and diversity of generated text
without the need for aligned corpora. By conducting a comprehensive evaluation
of state-of-the-art language models, the study reveals new insights into their
performance on open-ended generation tasks, which are not adequately captured
by traditional benchmarks. The findings highlight a trade-off between the
quality and diversity of generated samples, particularly when models are
fine-tuned on instruction dataset or with human feedback. This work extends the
toolkit for distribution-based NLP evaluation, offering insights into the
practical capabilities and challenges that current LLMs face in generating
diverse and high-quality text. We release our code and data.
|
[
-0.3428121507,
-0.4264913499,
0.2599354684,
0.1000606343,
-0.1291376948,
0.0022295944,
-0.4245055318,
-0.3700549304,
-0.1512542367,
0.5450499654,
-0.2992195487,
-0.812928915,
-0.7340140939,
0.2832815647,
-0.6907128692,
0.7407426834,
-0.0619493537,
-0.2349302024,
-0.1439824998,
-0.2475069761,
-0.4325340688,
-0.4836444259,
-0.2878969312,
-0.2562460899,
0.1926572174,
0.3378904462,
0.7491309047,
0.7009959817,
0.6534774899,
0.2249318808,
-0.1977321357,
0.3597101867,
-0.8369517922,
0.1160577238,
-0.2256529033,
-0.3290299475,
-0.3251972198,
-0.2152082622,
1.0162757635,
0.6321678162,
-0.1936770678,
0.3103075922,
0.142503038,
0.6893126369,
-0.7950203419,
-0.2162578106,
-0.9494745135,
0.0325429477,
-0.0945195556,
-0.1266023368,
-0.4894394875,
-0.5275686979,
0.1001819149,
-0.3861550093,
0.3955202103,
-0.0711915791,
0.9347119927,
0.0827725008,
-0.3118180633,
-0.5198131204,
-0.8324242234,
0.9427742362,
-0.6374972463,
0.1998208016,
0.1000220999,
0.3788557947,
-0.1844666302,
-0.8167308569,
-0.538865149,
-0.0031854794,
0.2902101874,
0.1087296456,
-0.2639101446,
-0.2334959954,
0.0638945401,
0.7607908249,
-0.3132003248,
0.4517855346,
-0.2766667902,
0.0306779873,
0.8034351468,
0.3464397788,
0.1850297004,
-0.0501562431,
-0.1608108282,
-0.3295208216,
-0.77189821,
-0.1468531787,
0.3724617064,
0.2073773444,
0.0173474159,
0.7513420582,
-0.116995126,
0.5323623419,
-0.2010081261,
-0.2402175367,
0.3532238007,
-0.4239371419,
-0.2285591364,
-0.4086076915,
1.0190559626,
0.5190579891,
0.3406977952,
-0.0108544258,
-0.4525063336,
-0.2461405694,
0.3166823089,
-0.6872834563,
0.0471419543,
-0.0642181709,
-0.6146508455,
-0.3020932674,
0.150728479,
-0.8756623268,
-0.1861274391,
-0.1027414277,
0.2282555252,
-0.4009996355,
-0.2217801362,
0.3261005282,
-0.1905971617,
0.098885648,
0.2059984505,
-1.1731494665,
0.3504004776,
0.6829532385,
0.7141615748,
-0.6307759285,
-0.3123972118,
-0.1737905741,
0.0368656293,
-0.5943962336,
0.7150841951,
-0.2559713721,
-0.6137484908,
0.184022069,
-0.3800116777,
0.2783269584,
-1.0198992491,
0.5928608775,
-0.4402393997,
-0.1130116954,
-0.4017827213,
-0.6055672765,
-0.1989412904,
0.2833680212,
-0.836758554,
1.3959327936,
0.2904952168,
-0.5972085595,
0.6189922094,
-0.1542138755,
-0.2649175525,
0.2676581144,
-0.2926864028,
-0.4262178242,
0.288064003,
0.2164299637,
0.4838113785,
-0.5338024497,
0.470969677,
-0.2865011096,
-0.3545052707,
0.2720369697,
-0.6480436921,
0.4554895163,
0.2074366808,
-0.310733825,
0.0313074924,
-0.7414423823,
0.001356282,
0.0827144012,
-0.4863739014,
-0.1686646491,
-0.092784375,
0.0573047511,
0.042969957,
0.3010805249,
-0.1905932724,
-0.0546233952,
-0.2401503474,
0.1961328834,
0.6198146939,
-0.0469102077,
0.4986623824,
-0.4523709714,
0.4553298652,
-0.2408387214,
0.0559149832,
-0.4225744605,
-0.4450883269,
-0.6573182344,
-0.4118202925,
0.1680874974,
0.5244907141,
-0.2910791636,
0.7506274581,
-0.4561099112,
-0.7345182896,
-0.4323845208,
0.3749565184,
0.2346089333,
0.3006851673,
0.0210981742,
-0.5806388855,
-0.3527056575,
-0.9047170281,
0.0169961136,
-0.0462346412,
-0.175289467,
0.3518823385,
0.4347491562,
-0.3112772703,
1.0124456882,
-0.2948534787,
0.0991303101,
-0.3042062223,
0.168237105,
0.1513849646,
0.2591807842,
0.6270706058,
-0.5900663733,
-0.1430218518,
-0.0433270261,
-0.9159414768,
-0.1548697501,
-0.1131186336,
-0.2399309278,
0.2916984856,
0.315734446,
-0.5562283993,
0.3927738667,
0.6904565096,
0.0577894971,
0.7806817293,
-0.1377147734,
0.3391124308,
-1.1408393383,
0.3220894635,
-0.2394952774,
-0.0074795987,
-0.3862975538,
0.1519592553,
0.1860982031,
0.0495053157,
-0.4569259882,
0.5593124032,
-0.4959074259,
-0.4935187697,
-0.037319012,
0.1582836062,
0.1168836132,
-0.0454474986,
0.0389551558,
0.8486948609,
0.2217057794,
-0.6018235683,
0.1812161803,
0.1709242314,
-0.7229394317,
0.4937280715,
-0.6364995837,
-0.0851976052,
0.0259819776,
-0.0402450524,
-1.1092112064,
-0.1932810843,
-0.1391196698,
-0.35299927,
0.3154805899,
0.2179954052,
-0.8347685933,
-0.4184732139,
-0.2183528095,
0.3678092659,
0.8377794623,
-0.5015394688,
0.1604973078,
0.2596323788,
-0.2825557292,
-0.8538565636,
-0.5657482147,
0.0789710507,
-0.1784855574,
-0.4391770661,
0.1647540778,
0.0080412449,
-0.3405124843,
-0.1871733963,
0.1167154163,
0.1239125431,
0.2468897104,
0.0776950419,
0.1765690148,
-0.2678983808,
0.3140466809,
0.2512428164,
0.2115288377,
-0.088181749,
-0.2824985385,
0.5049137473,
-0.132765457,
-0.5620369911,
-0.1677027345,
0.2595599294,
0.3425919414,
-0.1672530174,
0.4683903456,
0.4499862194,
-0.4050502181,
-0.2655403018,
-0.5957716703,
-0.0343851745,
-0.4609808028,
0.6257933974,
-0.1888047755,
-1.0162489414,
0.5352278948,
-0.0978881195,
0.3455639482,
0.6392288804,
0.8930196762,
0.0165991746,
0.5517904162,
0.559412539,
0.1491810977,
0.2874887586,
-0.1632217616,
-0.0024662192,
-0.5130313635,
-0.1812850237,
-0.5222713351,
-0.2583604455,
-0.3414026201,
-0.5843674541,
0.1702625006,
0.486707598,
-0.2771320343,
0.1018888652,
-0.5180798173,
0.5991077423,
0.5278381705,
-0.2121247202,
0.5164509416,
0.3678928614,
-0.0439398661,
-0.2169191539,
-0.5358759165,
-1.0367583036,
1.4161719084,
0.386572659,
0.6589451432,
0.0650414601,
0.9057639241,
0.2124702781,
0.5247850418,
-0.7436511517,
0.479528904,
-0.5056108832,
-0.4741581678,
-0.3779013753,
-0.5338324308,
-1.0215172768,
0.1027540863,
-0.3884761631,
-0.6310713887,
-0.1456439793,
-0.0390315764,
-0.2450969517,
0.4935409129,
-0.4184468091,
0.618216753,
-0.1708810776,
-0.0827732831,
-0.1082650721,
-0.317176193,
0.7123333216,
-0.2717967629,
0.0533590727,
-0.2887135446,
-0.1473312378,
0.5177764297,
0.0879673809,
0.7492451668,
0.3201525807,
-0.3984409869,
0.5504374504,
0.355895102,
0.0504700281,
-0.0669332147,
-0.4546144009,
0.4425309896,
-0.2318544239,
-0.1613527685,
-0.5759655237,
0.6485692859,
-0.8192478418,
-0.1779175103,
0.0736782923,
-0.7460362315,
0.162981078,
0.2842782438,
0.451441586,
0.3303238451,
-0.5311462879,
0.0793675482,
0.7062214017,
-0.5675491691,
0.4192867577,
0.1485979259,
-0.2662176192,
-0.7201351523,
0.7598633766,
0.1235584319,
0.6230528355,
0.5161749125,
-0.0088869659,
-0.3425573707,
-0.7389713526,
-0.6389978528,
0.2295839041,
-0.9845743179,
-0.2832645476,
-0.6193417907,
-0.2111635953,
-0.3910094798,
-0.2279158533,
-0.4887545705,
-0.5291836262,
-0.5868359804,
-0.0162360892,
0.2555602491,
1.1388124228,
-0.0400336571,
0.4269968569,
-0.9399359226,
0.204196021,
0.2027527839,
0.3758789599,
0.0740794986,
-0.5338068604,
-0.0961085781,
-0.0854251534,
-0.6005284786,
-0.7401813865,
0.5862931013,
0.2689878941,
0.6888970137,
0.1887856424,
-0.1314121038,
0.2510330379,
-0.4185459614,
0.993547976,
0.2777138054,
-1.0415072441,
0.386372745,
-0.2311915308,
0.3894684613,
0.5826999545,
0.2615578473,
-0.4590669274,
-0.4273800254,
-0.5937095881,
-0.9447284937,
0.3331378698,
0.1953452229,
0.240102008,
-0.2874945104,
0.4912485182,
0.4364487529,
0.3171950579,
-0.4907107055,
-0.1437951922,
-0.0541076064,
-0.5597400665,
-0.2770982385,
-0.4049459994,
-0.015569197,
0.1610272974,
0.261375159,
-0.055150006,
0.0783472285,
0.0257799551,
-0.1257061958,
0.0482111573,
0.3130463362,
0.6671080589,
0.6715776324,
-0.1636407077,
0.1011854559,
0.3101764917,
-0.5331255198,
0.145401448,
-0.266071558,
-0.3594007194,
0.1570116132,
0.4397877455,
0.5847610235,
0.1288640499,
-0.91305691,
0.510776639,
-0.0124325128,
-0.2705847919,
-0.0604821965,
0.0189494081,
0.097913228,
-0.0318208858,
0.4017379284,
-0.0318913013,
0.2663209438,
-0.1569823474,
0.4420832992,
0.456654042,
-0.1401121467,
-0.1551290751,
0.3538870811,
0.1337161511,
-0.3503064215,
0.8060843349,
-0.2627338171,
-0.2055675089,
0.7481184006,
0.5823380351,
0.8339439631,
-0.0216237456,
0.1818548143,
0.6494987011,
0.4507797658,
-0.4278900325,
0.2906444073,
0.1504121423,
-0.8179038167,
-0.3366350532,
-0.6362335682,
-0.4490589797,
-0.007186241,
-0.7807015181,
0.3822470903,
-0.4837710261,
-0.3365552127,
-0.3995125592,
-0.3529058695,
-0.6177105904,
0.0969152972,
0.2766650319,
0.9946240187,
-0.8547362089,
0.5243652463,
0.288833499,
-0.0922638699,
-0.6886479259,
-0.1591788381,
-0.2010189891,
-0.8134320378,
0.6520358324,
0.2793703973,
-0.0799310282,
-0.1603303552,
-0.4745310247,
-0.8386787772,
1.211124897,
0.5279440284,
-0.6723672748,
0.2299780846,
0.2644527853,
0.6834704876,
-0.4279172719,
0.3973628581,
0.7199746966,
0.0020633326,
0.1425261348,
-1.0377753973,
-0.1021211222,
-0.2057459801,
0.393268168,
0.1428600848,
-0.345661521,
0.7886919975,
-0.3276859522,
-0.4482069612,
0.3359308541,
0.737220943,
0.6555631161,
0.2021393776,
0.1725943685,
0.6754641533,
0.9734344482,
0.0451635011,
1.0997854471,
0.0255786292,
0.3418911994,
1.1683170795,
-0.3803042769,
1.1330938339,
0.393515259,
-0.1712673157,
0.297228992,
0.5391692519,
-0.1158171669,
0.2672938406,
0.4606131613,
-0.2055341601,
-0.0710158199,
-0.1116385907,
-0.2608570755,
0.2757842243,
0.4583927095,
-0.5898154974,
-0.2068903148,
-0.3162501156,
-0.2547924519,
0.3703267574,
-0.1060449556,
0.7980009317,
0.0315352492,
-0.6916009784,
0.8594328165,
-0.0208978858,
0.906157136,
-0.3094393611,
0.0572472736,
-0.2680206001,
0.1325812787,
0.0121214101,
-1.18658638,
0.3826283514,
-0.00755614,
-0.353785038,
-0.1080097631,
0.4491866529,
-0.3592930436,
-0.5474396348,
0.2346964628,
0.3360034227,
0.3349548876,
0.2432504296,
-0.5150375962,
0.2459372729,
-0.064733766,
-0.1393382251,
0.1375563294,
0.6049119234,
-0.0808482915,
0.6325427294,
0.3741315305,
0.074321717,
0.3322851956,
0.2382460684,
0.3482020199,
-0.4860057235,
-0.0469333082,
-0.9215669036,
0.365228802,
-0.0184736568,
-0.6133226156,
0.5513935089,
0.6073614955,
0.8978900909,
-0.1782620251,
0.921708405,
0.1577645838,
0.3769825995,
-0.4413006902,
0.6585128903,
-0.4668594301,
0.2379012853,
-0.4243146479,
-1.005638957,
-0.4465847909,
0.3758575916,
-0.1199242473,
0.0457715653,
0.5148957968,
0.8885554075,
-0.048905354,
0.0003906955,
0.468927145,
-0.1710129529,
0.3792854846,
0.6824973226,
1.0642006397,
-0.6471325159,
0.6893169284,
-0.0068132905,
-0.3094368875,
-0.1545080692,
-1.0207337141,
-0.7799893618,
-0.5150426626,
-0.130526498,
-0.2154383659,
-0.1248459369,
0.7289527655,
0.6095273495,
-0.5540861487,
-0.4959769547,
-0.0655707121,
-0.0091511328,
-0.150963366,
-0.1761403978,
0.2426566482,
-0.3939953446,
-0.7589665651,
0.0365741849,
0.3460083604,
0.3894189,
-0.3242332637,
-0.2321549803,
0.2211501598,
-0.0540875793,
0.5905919671,
0.0238492433,
-0.7946258187,
0.0078444686,
0.1564314514,
-0.431587249,
0.0575275347,
0.6433820724,
-0.3722546697,
0.4065914452,
0.6073017716,
0.8467338085,
0.383539319,
-0.1138605028,
0.8119858503,
-0.6850246787,
-0.003672071,
0.1828465611,
0.1554592401,
0.6427949667,
-0.2203429639,
0.3628044724,
0.0674622282,
-0.5655812025,
-0.8563175201,
0.3647598028,
-0.8223085403,
-0.0900608748,
1.3268771172,
-0.270093441,
0.0006919575,
0.190599218,
-0.216211915,
0.23677966,
-0.2552296817,
0.7795336246,
0.6870699525,
0.3934949934,
-0.2258371115,
-0.4560056925,
0.2630293071,
0.4388511479,
-0.9073274732,
0.0901162028,
0.5714735389,
0.2772710323,
0.0964147523,
0.5577187538,
-0.3690815568,
0.2118079662,
0.0177472308,
0.5375278592,
0.2996191084,
-0.2592788041,
-0.4913027883,
0.1912921816,
0.3200320899,
0.1368583441
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10691v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10691v2
|
Python is Not Always the Best Choice: Embracing Multilingual Program of Thoughts
| 2024-02-16T13:48:06 | 2024-06-16T12:29:50 |
Xianzhen Luo, Qingfu Zhu, Zhiming Zhang, Libo Qin, Xuanyu Zhang, Qing Yang, Dongliang Xu, Wanxiang Che
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Program of Thoughts (PoT) is an approach characterized by its executable
intermediate steps, which ensure the accuracy of the logical calculations in
the reasoning process. Currently, PoT primarily uses Python. However, relying
solely on a single language may result in suboptimal solutions and overlook the
potential benefits of other programming languages. In this paper, we conduct
comprehensive experiments on the programming languages used in PoT and find
that no single language consistently delivers optimal performance across all
tasks and models. The effectiveness of each language varies depending on the
specific scenarios. Inspired by this, we propose a task and model agnostic
approach called MultiPoT, which harnesses strength and diversity from various
languages. Experimental results reveal that it significantly outperforms Python
Self-Consistency. Furthermore, it achieves comparable or superior performance
compared to the best monolingual PoT in almost all tasks across all models. In
particular, MultiPoT achieves more than 4.6% improvement on average on ChatGPT
(gpt-3.5-turbo-0701).
|
[
-0.114308238,
-0.718996048,
0.5126947761,
0.9342674613,
0.0485845692,
0.1636800468,
-0.6470443606,
-0.2005240768,
0.0118461931,
0.0341893472,
-0.3599827886,
-0.1136703119,
-0.6542594433,
0.3796010017,
-0.0177140664,
0.7098383307,
0.0106547633,
0.0913928896,
-0.0010733361,
-0.2136902511,
-0.5474469662,
-0.3589062393,
-0.4869551063,
-0.7471138239,
0.4506469071,
0.4162572324,
0.5193842053,
0.1836525798,
0.6306390166,
0.3742400408,
0.5862731338,
0.1939964443,
-0.1692653,
0.0903020725,
-0.1790664196,
-0.6577017307,
-0.0562721118,
0.0099401651,
0.2134149522,
0.3013344407,
-0.2840256691,
0.0981488228,
0.0272321105,
0.5453768373,
-0.9127999544,
0.3696680367,
-0.7379584312,
0.1792090833,
-0.1166499928,
-0.4311920404,
-0.6762294769,
-0.1247256994,
-0.1053955182,
-0.6767249107,
-0.2143513858,
-0.1851550341,
0.4291974008,
0.4636200368,
-0.1219441295,
-0.2453118265,
-0.8679189682,
1.0817822218,
-0.6480382085,
0.3507124782,
0.2054438293,
0.2565101385,
-0.3315714598,
-0.3425959647,
-0.7708116174,
-0.1806530952,
0.1139695719,
0.2646365762,
-0.2382235527,
0.0571873821,
0.2611682117,
0.3280304074,
-0.6394389272,
-0.2508887649,
-0.2636615634,
-0.0243255831,
0.4503868818,
0.0426078103,
0.4020269215,
-0.2294206023,
-0.1878526807,
-0.0800097063,
-0.4791408181,
0.2662175596,
0.396484822,
0.4898287654,
-0.0298626013,
0.7017301321,
-0.1921619624,
0.8742192984,
-0.2571498156,
-0.4521468878,
0.0948441178,
-0.3231097758,
-0.367774725,
-0.152334258,
1.1028804779,
0.0674521923,
0.4067697823,
-0.2911596,
0.2415338159,
0.6726698279,
0.2577821612,
-0.4964734614,
-0.7242245674,
0.6575608253,
-0.1644750237,
-0.0349394493,
-0.2832864821,
-0.2302206457,
-0.4207691252,
-0.4430731237,
0.3010526597,
-0.8803815246,
-0.58799088,
0.1563511193,
-0.1245689243,
-0.0312109962,
0.2639070153,
-0.8761798739,
0.235003531,
0.7012429237,
0.9964879751,
-0.4155854285,
-0.8617112041,
-0.3347680569,
0.0632566586,
-0.493486315,
0.9971535802,
-0.6284641027,
-0.060214974,
-0.5341348648,
-0.4280558228,
-0.2183329612,
-0.2697968483,
0.1882468015,
0.1517393291,
0.2544643581,
-0.4820591509,
-0.4353655577,
-0.027666783,
0.4179912508,
-0.3926696777,
1.0368829966,
0.0047921324,
-0.9844474196,
0.8168818355,
-1.0630515814,
-0.5106334686,
0.0125384023,
-0.3720328212,
-0.2193277031,
-0.0731684119,
0.0791826397,
0.2132150233,
-0.0081733707,
0.2671744227,
-0.3104026914,
-0.6044902205,
0.0762174129,
-0.6175157428,
1.1145670414,
0.4710123837,
-0.430262804,
0.4525083899,
-0.4784627855,
0.3319468796,
0.1151875332,
-0.371281445,
-0.3410195708,
0.0438578203,
0.1061464623,
0.2522517443,
-0.0761689097,
-0.7320301533,
0.5998219252,
-0.3253616691,
0.7359890342,
0.6066895127,
-0.4454155266,
0.2931088805,
-0.0614184737,
0.477787137,
0.0401713215,
0.0892852172,
-0.2106727809,
-0.6095960736,
-0.706120193,
-0.4148153365,
0.3327862918,
0.8569937944,
-0.7254828811,
0.0690916553,
0.0036263317,
-0.5143347383,
-0.763246417,
0.2332874537,
0.1437368095,
0.0020705303,
0.1956572533,
-0.0735003054,
-0.5148982406,
-0.9615876079,
-0.5416096449,
-0.3159918487,
0.218784079,
0.0718066692,
0.3478981256,
-0.0282202624,
0.8076614738,
-0.4536483288,
-0.0448702201,
-0.6378324628,
0.2692864835,
0.4227718413,
0.4993936718,
0.4499292076,
-0.6737020016,
-1.0433766842,
0.3246442378,
-0.8384993672,
0.1495343745,
-0.3017658889,
-0.1802340299,
0.2561785281,
-0.2127021104,
-0.7550492287,
0.3056079745,
0.5380169153,
-0.0126703065,
0.7489082217,
-0.5638278723,
0.2635346651,
-0.8663375974,
0.1488086283,
-0.0567448102,
-0.219448328,
-0.6696150303,
0.1738627106,
0.3739115298,
0.0192357861,
-0.4329114556,
0.2837574184,
-0.4762606621,
0.1798756272,
-0.6160145402,
-0.3234792948,
-0.1068005189,
0.6085466743,
0.1450660527,
1.1746321917,
1.1215119362,
-0.5363197923,
0.6474530697,
-0.1202260032,
-0.237506941,
0.3963357806,
-0.4852669537,
0.2650819421,
0.0384565964,
-0.1574689448,
-0.8879127502,
-0.0391101427,
0.2987565994,
-0.3721422553,
0.2278144956,
0.2639943361,
-0.5406887531,
-0.6077783704,
-0.0677493811,
0.148187533,
0.0267661829,
-0.3073029518,
0.4894786775,
0.3924410939,
-0.0436096601,
-1.2347593307,
-0.6361287236,
0.2976716161,
-0.3234888017,
-0.3799622953,
-0.0969943255,
-0.1077479497,
-0.4159323573,
-0.1810791641,
-0.0123000937,
-0.0169784632,
-0.1558392495,
0.1132017151,
-0.0919735134,
0.1511800736,
0.0306666102,
-0.2372335196,
-0.1856725663,
-0.1975501329,
-0.4854169488,
0.7539082766,
-0.5186124444,
-0.3798975348,
-0.2816915512,
0.6079024076,
0.6971408129,
-0.3868924379,
0.5698342323,
0.4054937661,
-0.1518157274,
-0.3822288215,
-0.5023388863,
0.1577894986,
-0.4682723284,
0.3571703434,
-0.7954756618,
-0.2198204547,
0.3881006539,
0.1697691828,
0.2084507644,
-0.1605614722,
0.8073722124,
-0.0330369398,
0.7507960796,
0.9336736202,
-0.2456281632,
0.3590103388,
-0.210229218,
0.4770492911,
-0.5572370291,
0.0443771295,
-0.249167338,
-0.1226088107,
-0.4950499833,
-0.4371590316,
0.4481440187,
-0.3291015327,
-0.0443838425,
0.8303639889,
-0.8021313548,
0.6703817248,
0.9622548819,
0.0290031303,
0.3842468262,
-0.1192706376,
-0.197908476,
-0.061953336,
-1.0620775223,
-0.4323504567,
1.3920373917,
-0.1286953241,
0.7262000442,
-0.1031295881,
0.5997756124,
0.2145867944,
0.3398050666,
-0.7230840921,
0.3083467484,
0.0731955618,
-0.6698241234,
-0.7123039365,
-0.3454501033,
-1.0542293787,
0.8003470302,
-0.0318290778,
-0.7689922452,
-0.3245999515,
0.1314624399,
-0.3657650948,
0.41559273,
-0.9766106606,
1.1759388447,
-0.3778930306,
-0.5347570181,
-0.3341956437,
-0.4334528148,
0.3598391414,
-0.0001729955,
0.0686085373,
-0.1064910218,
0.3892649412,
0.1249231324,
-0.1342126429,
0.3013544083,
0.0249005947,
-0.0113975611,
0.4008683264,
0.0071864384,
0.2484732717,
0.0133406417,
-0.1928721815,
0.2318973094,
0.1349271834,
-0.6043175459,
-0.5736721754,
0.7642660141,
-0.8101146221,
-0.7077639699,
-0.6353635788,
-1.040864706,
-0.1588886976,
0.4768408239,
0.3788202703,
0.0161729213,
-0.1310885996,
-0.1339318752,
0.2433729321,
-0.3847968578,
0.5152124166,
0.2883183062,
-0.2274719626,
-0.0861600414,
0.8654552102,
0.1426486373,
0.2986852229,
0.3688565195,
0.2967016697,
-0.2743242681,
-0.2775062025,
-0.7802770138,
0.0360735059,
-0.6398740411,
0.0245358925,
-0.8866435885,
0.2541569471,
-0.617980361,
0.020165287,
-0.7401117682,
-0.28122136,
0.4623795152,
0.1291852146,
0.0696522072,
0.3802099824,
-0.057498686,
-0.0803738981,
-0.2128308117,
0.5016083717,
0.2017035931,
0.3471493125,
-0.2051644176,
0.2211132199,
0.0009772184,
0.1594610065,
-0.6278485656,
-0.9894752502,
0.2661383152,
0.1939649731,
0.6515048742,
0.2875274122,
0.165845722,
0.8467677236,
-0.5718340278,
0.5760390759,
0.4037663341,
-0.9167515039,
0.7183756232,
-0.3356394172,
0.6156221628,
0.5407775044,
0.1329659522,
-0.6773095727,
-0.8190306425,
-0.3596636951,
-0.5204725862,
0.6067953706,
0.5812328458,
-0.0928893611,
0.1209485382,
-0.1806699932,
0.5460273027,
0.5171715617,
-1.1273487806,
-0.3801296651,
-0.5070846081,
0.0843201056,
-0.1190057918,
0.4859316051,
-0.026781965,
-0.3912420571,
0.519290626,
-0.1716594994,
0.3837161958,
0.0005313503,
0.0044034552,
-0.2480774671,
0.4868291318,
0.3351278305,
1.0730987787,
0.0961807594,
0.2765917778,
0.0844894946,
-0.3962115347,
0.2346001118,
-0.3543969989,
-0.2729820907,
-0.0378994457,
0.132526055,
0.6012442112,
-0.2238104641,
-0.6656060815,
0.3473982811,
-0.0431368537,
0.1491497606,
-0.4057317674,
0.4103916287,
0.2474753708,
0.1364209801,
0.0937796608,
0.4226020575,
0.302768141,
-0.8440945148,
-0.0368729979,
0.6605805755,
0.0797740817,
-0.1244633123,
0.6914438009,
-0.0284359418,
-0.3344989121,
0.7501648664,
-0.348372668,
-0.6451300979,
0.5567778349,
0.7265503407,
0.6920385957,
-0.2229598016,
0.2880032063,
0.315472275,
0.5225169063,
-0.0913248137,
0.6766133904,
-0.1757703125,
-0.7048922777,
-0.8221852779,
-0.3513391912,
-0.5212195516,
0.1192575321,
-0.0518142208,
0.3183620274,
-0.1338827014,
-0.2240860313,
-0.1105357185,
0.0927977338,
-0.5827152729,
0.0422864519,
0.1110262722,
0.6591069102,
-0.8492431045,
1.3536574841,
0.8547030091,
-0.1968644857,
-0.9607586861,
-0.3398055732,
-0.2304314524,
-0.4355553985,
0.3493987322,
0.2585963309,
-0.1587094516,
-0.2588433921,
-0.2753501236,
-0.6404768229,
0.6134187579,
0.6421756148,
-0.1605694145,
0.2647328377,
0.4255482256,
0.3984407485,
-0.0970213264,
0.462880373,
0.4776616395,
0.7416425347,
-0.1054280549,
-1.2949367762,
-0.3345972002,
-0.6162840724,
-0.2470403016,
0.2642145753,
-0.8599916697,
1.0961641073,
-0.5143075585,
-0.2232051492,
-0.1922908127,
0.5971503258,
0.4820784628,
0.2854734659,
0.346558094,
0.4310704768,
0.8740389943,
-0.2580802441,
1.1252821684,
-0.5860909224,
0.337600559,
1.0232666731,
-0.1709553301,
0.66296345,
0.6860953569,
-0.6597642899,
0.2150286287,
0.5635255575,
-0.0249379836,
0.5163491964,
0.2450394034,
-0.0159878153,
-0.4193937182,
0.385910362,
-0.3806706369,
0.6498431563,
0.1257243752,
0.1512506157,
0.010884515,
0.2767808437,
-0.1014704928,
0.0667148456,
0.020981852,
0.2895353734,
0.0167030226,
-1.1991189718,
0.573947072,
-0.0683874413,
0.8447075486,
-0.6654785872,
-0.0923286006,
-0.0270306561,
0.5601533055,
-0.1102405116,
-0.6699758172,
0.3011486828,
-0.0670824423,
-0.0662258416,
-0.2374574691,
0.6997749805,
-0.4513014257,
-0.7765752077,
0.1142200157,
0.5565565825,
0.3420440257,
-0.4184238017,
-0.8336023092,
-0.0438222326,
-0.0981178433,
-0.1617528647,
0.1221320108,
0.590431273,
0.1874490082,
1.2449874878,
0.5837752223,
0.6341159344,
0.1308443695,
-0.2221966237,
0.5367048979,
-0.3087716997,
-0.8575397134,
-1.0204987526,
0.3733708262,
-0.0580263957,
-0.3633760214,
1.2019287348,
0.7217518687,
0.9384070039,
-0.2362355143,
1.1954647303,
-0.307705611,
0.1873994619,
-0.0979489386,
0.6439582705,
-0.5590624213,
0.0323822685,
-0.7146114111,
-1.1270809174,
-0.2425536066,
1.0987279415,
-0.3104682863,
-0.2499129921,
0.9394664168,
0.4069666862,
-0.1802756041,
0.1085766777,
0.4369841516,
-0.2437064052,
0.341850698,
0.9198866487,
0.7986230254,
-0.2161791027,
0.4261853099,
-0.5243909359,
-0.3751142025,
0.2435747236,
-0.800470531,
-0.8546450734,
-0.4067625999,
-0.255400449,
-0.0296479203,
-0.0006323899,
1.017570138,
0.7948644757,
-0.9320414066,
-0.7033672929,
-0.2373356521,
0.015615657,
-0.8739865422,
-0.138685748,
0.2052069604,
-0.6860302687,
-1.0765908957,
0.3035504818,
0.6269693375,
-0.5416875482,
-0.5388767719,
-0.1732682288,
-0.2402694374,
-0.0891281143,
0.6143704653,
0.2926203012,
-0.9121569991,
-0.088757582,
0.3669047058,
-0.0863252431,
0.4207769036,
1.0634924173,
-0.5447392464,
0.8126958013,
0.4296779037,
0.2669667304,
0.2390691489,
-0.0694145486,
0.7862912416,
-0.1944226027,
0.4761041403,
0.1970909834,
0.5893950462,
0.3270245492,
-0.4294750988,
0.5709405541,
0.0626991764,
-0.5631365776,
-0.7492364049,
0.2954583764,
-0.8493695855,
-0.7087777853,
1.1714388132,
-0.3417564929,
-0.0800627694,
-0.3845690191,
-0.4156172574,
0.3418570161,
-0.2854449451,
1.0989234447,
1.1063239574,
-0.6436219811,
-0.1278346181,
-0.4939141572,
0.2458189577,
0.5822438002,
-0.5590927005,
0.3669580817,
0.2302681953,
0.2895553708,
0.4564282,
0.9262259007,
0.1469999254,
0.0968987346,
0.3678925931,
0.1385294646,
-0.1428461075,
-0.7102748156,
0.3069889247,
0.3604014814,
0.0587223135,
-0.1313118339
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10689v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10689v2
|
Multi-Cultural Commonsense Knowledge Distillation
| 2024-02-16T13:46:38 | 2024-04-17T14:12:07 |
Tuan-Phong Nguyen, Simon Razniewski, Gerhard Weikum
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite recent progress, large language models (LLMs) still face the
challenge of appropriately reacting to the intricacies of social and cultural
conventions. This paper presents MANGO, a methodology for distilling
high-accuracy, high-recall assertions of cultural knowledge. We judiciously and
iteratively prompt LLMs for this purpose from two entry points, concepts and
cultures. Outputs are consolidated via clustering and generative summarization.
Running the MANGO method with GPT-3.5 as underlying LLM yields 167K
high-accuracy assertions for 30K concepts and 11K cultures, surpassing prior
resources by a large margin. For extrinsic evaluation, we explore augmenting
dialogue systems with cultural knowledge assertions. We find that adding
knowledge from MANGO improves the overall quality, specificity, and cultural
sensitivity of dialogue responses, as judged by human annotators. Data and code
are available for download.
|
[
-0.3801967204,
-0.8250535131,
0.3757926226,
0.1338067353,
-0.2366470248,
0.4793252647,
-0.4483050704,
-0.1280336231,
0.3396575153,
0.5102882385,
-0.2097644061,
-0.3382807672,
-0.6873081326,
0.1092063189,
-0.1982639879,
0.7688454986,
0.0493673049,
-0.4142077267,
-0.0776658952,
-0.4635121822,
-0.6696556807,
-0.5655029416,
-0.416768074,
-0.3451833725,
0.2196425945,
0.7181332111,
0.5591025949,
0.2449802607,
0.1203917786,
0.3575192988,
-0.2819039226,
0.5897518396,
-0.5276594162,
0.2755247355,
-0.242207706,
-0.5334207416,
-0.1630500108,
0.1427451819,
0.0774502307,
0.3979329169,
-0.4315724671,
0.3957073987,
0.220818311,
0.5430704355,
-0.558103919,
0.3304665089,
-0.8667550683,
0.0408643708,
-0.16041179,
-0.0116235744,
-0.3734524548,
-0.5950446725,
0.0123597691,
-0.5510103106,
-0.1589178145,
-0.0644079894,
0.6366884708,
0.3579002023,
-0.6750270724,
-0.1290473193,
-0.7444626689,
1.008620739,
-0.5579351783,
0.1118910536,
0.6031038761,
0.6514148116,
-0.028300697,
-0.645029366,
-0.769726038,
0.0556469448,
0.0800971538,
0.2161051929,
-0.0864211544,
-0.232158035,
0.2632969618,
0.3133561611,
-0.0078824311,
0.0293382481,
-0.5398767591,
-0.1614209116,
0.6613668203,
0.1079712883,
0.1817009151,
-0.2972170711,
-0.23424986,
0.2044455558,
-0.801101923,
-0.1520032287,
-0.093317166,
-0.0745122284,
-0.1207406595,
0.6000313163,
-0.4736605287,
0.4760437012,
0.039820347,
-0.7096794844,
0.1767702401,
-0.4564270377,
-0.1119741872,
-0.0893188193,
0.7413488626,
0.6945115924,
0.4433582723,
0.3651817441,
0.1999367923,
-0.1293999851,
-0.1649829894,
-0.614998877,
-0.2907080054,
0.3240049779,
-0.3145321012,
-0.2284964621,
-0.3076542318,
-0.6975603104,
-0.8622300625,
-0.3212966919,
0.0684718639,
-0.4871902764,
-0.4749184549,
-0.3203731477,
-0.5394961834,
0.2264475226,
0.340562284,
-0.7707129717,
0.00542905,
0.5859775543,
0.7977346778,
-0.0433977544,
-0.1607569903,
-0.3425474763,
0.3130867779,
-0.5290493965,
0.4698365629,
-0.5461021066,
-0.5024954081,
-0.267357111,
-0.2040156126,
0.1951190382,
-0.851616621,
0.6767455339,
-0.1032968238,
-0.0553813875,
-0.5942605734,
-0.240178138,
-0.2998100817,
0.393153429,
-0.4128604233,
0.9257411957,
0.0896484405,
-0.5077137947,
0.4266052246,
-0.5827336907,
-0.58984828,
0.2295325994,
-0.2934426665,
0.0758607015,
0.3863354027,
0.509652853,
0.5174383521,
-0.5570386052,
0.6421560645,
-0.2371719033,
-0.2687846124,
0.4329721332,
-0.7574326992,
0.9253337383,
0.8627066016,
-0.0979060382,
-0.2110714912,
-0.5869827271,
-0.3128345907,
0.2188114375,
-0.2392874062,
-0.6144729257,
-0.0815757364,
-0.6866278052,
0.1568915248,
0.1037920117,
-0.5686749816,
0.0814625919,
0.0639729276,
0.7800136805,
0.6672698259,
-0.0704519749,
0.1067351177,
-0.430136919,
0.2634543478,
0.2820554972,
0.1471498162,
-0.3915522099,
-0.7190541029,
-0.5430303216,
-0.3783475161,
-0.1062536016,
0.5209161043,
-1.1601874828,
0.2899826169,
-0.3547216058,
-0.6672762632,
-0.4270617366,
0.2893351912,
0.075418815,
0.6846718192,
0.1360908747,
-0.3929216266,
-0.4192665219,
-0.7280429006,
-0.278247267,
-0.2139796764,
0.0852380097,
0.2775765955,
0.1945272237,
0.1631837189,
1.0736033916,
-0.6926454306,
-0.0542299002,
-0.3584961891,
0.3191602528,
0.2860322595,
0.2135357559,
0.3261144459,
-0.6923427582,
-0.7468796968,
0.1515870243,
-0.8538687825,
-0.0585797653,
0.4499424696,
0.090095818,
0.282427758,
0.3095763028,
-0.4305544794,
0.1484633088,
0.3826553226,
0.0519607477,
0.5522770286,
-0.0643092021,
0.5919001698,
-1.4305938482,
-0.1932443976,
0.065000914,
-0.043062456,
-0.4765178859,
0.0020783739,
0.0991604775,
-0.243273899,
-0.4455204606,
0.5379733443,
-0.2380295396,
0.3643845618,
-0.0286040194,
0.1366027594,
0.161274001,
0.4266685545,
0.2614208162,
0.645352006,
0.2327589095,
-0.5422220826,
0.7740817666,
0.1941946149,
-0.769754529,
1.2402908802,
-0.3333160281,
0.080887422,
-0.3064168096,
0.4314109385,
-1.1203770638,
-0.3496970832,
-0.1233564317,
-0.2932894826,
-0.1349105239,
-0.4743833244,
-0.3971141279,
-0.6345363855,
-0.2038162649,
0.3163500726,
0.8807491064,
-0.6581485271,
0.6204481125,
0.5188647509,
-0.679348886,
-0.9463950992,
-0.863521874,
0.3264439404,
-0.7949444056,
-0.5461056828,
-0.405839324,
0.0106689604,
-0.5433695316,
-0.4034977555,
0.0208676681,
-0.2445930541,
0.3848444819,
0.0628059357,
0.1631226242,
-0.0496377945,
0.1488126516,
0.1134770811,
0.1497989744,
0.0077755353,
-0.4773035049,
0.4462712407,
0.1039911807,
-0.4074444175,
-0.2378142476,
0.1529507041,
0.7012138367,
-0.4609565139,
0.6254982352,
0.5379675627,
-0.2340893745,
0.169679597,
-1.0345497131,
0.0256855693,
-0.4628745914,
0.3831984103,
-0.5877703428,
-0.7026273608,
0.5814108253,
-0.3517181277,
0.1135708615,
0.3801810443,
0.480638355,
-0.0761836618,
0.7017838955,
0.1353217214,
-0.1142366529,
0.2014070898,
-0.164553389,
0.3859150112,
-0.7150030732,
-0.1849638522,
-0.5927631855,
-0.3215754628,
-0.3179425895,
-0.7959088683,
0.4948097765,
-0.0263043847,
-0.293584764,
0.0048293844,
-0.1719146073,
0.9452288747,
0.4641096294,
-0.2176253349,
0.8530595303,
0.0609464161,
-0.240873307,
-0.0232164375,
-0.6849983931,
-0.3266116083,
1.1825671196,
0.3713260293,
0.8880847096,
0.5056084991,
0.7313411236,
0.0923845097,
0.6372693181,
-0.5576835275,
0.3326588571,
-0.2907392085,
-0.6354501843,
-0.3071044087,
-0.5099039674,
-0.4501156211,
0.3155813217,
-0.0083139734,
-0.870300889,
0.0406653285,
0.1845448613,
-0.482892096,
0.2490907758,
-1.01124084,
0.6127653122,
-0.1159405932,
-0.3372226954,
-0.2943604887,
-0.5369294882,
0.9921922684,
-0.2816167176,
0.6957184076,
-0.4527524114,
0.2768087387,
0.6301737428,
-0.5113790631,
0.9929961562,
-0.2974251211,
-0.3691561222,
0.6025919914,
0.1540175229,
0.4640949965,
0.0326397754,
-0.1138516217,
-0.006988524,
0.1459712833,
-0.3431998491,
-0.6105380654,
0.7075971365,
-0.7185518742,
-0.7432884574,
-0.0738089755,
-0.586412549,
-0.2483889759,
-0.0363543332,
0.0832128003,
0.3250596821,
-0.3357958794,
0.1714479774,
0.752112329,
-0.5163660049,
0.2833685279,
0.4092074931,
-0.3358956277,
-0.3495177031,
1.000028491,
0.2427548021,
0.4892275929,
0.0963958278,
0.4807427227,
-0.6256799102,
-0.365511477,
-0.5105364323,
-0.0869070739,
-0.9128069878,
-0.207836166,
-0.547932744,
0.0177451801,
-0.5100549459,
-0.0136445938,
-0.2987989485,
-0.7113285065,
0.3323835135,
-0.254062295,
0.6036757827,
0.7594155073,
-0.1934860796,
0.1589687318,
-0.9971219897,
0.3798058331,
0.4644215703,
0.2084560543,
0.059627004,
-0.5175242424,
-0.1172297373,
0.3020828366,
-0.3284068704,
-0.7914284468,
0.3705628216,
0.1923894435,
0.6312348843,
0.4197672904,
0.2981708348,
0.7804982662,
-0.1229034215,
0.9959090948,
0.3613380194,
-0.8489879966,
0.6183076501,
-0.1395547688,
0.3881372809,
0.6110261679,
0.4568012059,
-0.9183086753,
-0.6124628782,
-0.3478265405,
-0.66715765,
0.3144538403,
-0.297213912,
0.3692804873,
-0.2944207788,
-0.0465627685,
0.3279051781,
0.1351886392,
-0.4529481828,
-0.0882991403,
-0.1994416863,
-0.3263303638,
-0.2483246922,
-0.2250272483,
-0.483599335,
-0.4275394082,
0.4936281145,
-0.2435332686,
-0.4578928053,
-0.0463993549,
-0.4564488232,
0.3016946018,
0.5714145899,
0.3510161042,
0.7771510482,
0.133838743,
0.3684181273,
0.4544839561,
-0.3308050334,
0.5303615928,
-0.0575211123,
0.0956289321,
-0.3341068327,
-0.1070569456,
0.4420928061,
-0.0992707461,
-0.5375301242,
0.3148319125,
-0.2444733232,
0.0531676672,
-0.1294215024,
-0.0120704379,
0.3929950893,
0.0768273845,
0.3487736583,
-0.1442797184,
-0.078923896,
-0.7834081054,
0.0540290438,
0.2279038578,
-0.1662164181,
0.2064260393,
0.4826278389,
0.6937312484,
0.1282021552,
0.8104498982,
-0.2585319877,
-0.3617351949,
0.5200284123,
0.3271224797,
0.5021057129,
-0.4277639091,
0.4136927724,
0.4276773334,
0.1442144513,
-0.0955287218,
0.1062940657,
-0.2271718234,
-0.8860602975,
-0.7938498259,
-0.6794276237,
-0.3469907641,
-0.1562727541,
-0.3490454853,
0.0875604078,
-0.2133613229,
0.0403686874,
-0.2001908869,
0.0199151319,
-0.5831302404,
-0.0425046273,
0.0226549618,
0.9929721951,
-1.0666673183,
1.0599638224,
0.2373777032,
-0.3917071819,
-0.8324990869,
-0.2305693328,
0.4339221716,
-1.0016256571,
0.5663787723,
-0.1009533405,
0.1406983286,
-0.1096936241,
-0.3737418056,
-0.7204962373,
1.1430499554,
0.2384411842,
-0.4668173492,
0.5012661219,
0.1958952844,
0.3221103549,
-0.1524537951,
0.4073891938,
1.0528337955,
0.4851213694,
0.536139071,
-1.2023769617,
0.0143057331,
-0.1828707457,
-0.0928441212,
0.078303352,
-0.6894123554,
0.5775209665,
-0.3809869587,
-0.1290014684,
0.0149728302,
0.6417674422,
0.4983495474,
0.2309881002,
0.2323053628,
0.518433094,
1.3221671581,
-0.2858328819,
0.8992863297,
-0.0847281739,
-0.0204939488,
1.3204228878,
-0.4928309619,
0.6486974359,
0.4062511623,
-0.2349516898,
0.4200275242,
0.5760771632,
0.2466814071,
0.1529269814,
0.3089014292,
-0.353386879,
0.1930499077,
-0.5362457037,
-0.3187001646,
0.6372554302,
0.6458653808,
-0.1082729325,
-0.0182908103,
0.0459083095,
0.2901885808,
0.2343564183,
-0.3334471881,
0.9982158542,
0.1504226625,
-1.2016824484,
0.7537217736,
-0.167437166,
0.8215959072,
-0.4227285981,
-0.0232144129,
-0.6592074633,
-0.1267555654,
-0.1557574272,
-0.9288857579,
0.4132183194,
0.0630859211,
0.235305205,
-0.084759295,
0.6223272681,
-0.6464038491,
-0.241199404,
-0.2287783027,
0.7040391564,
0.3026692271,
-0.1117184311,
-0.2392923236,
0.0599481799,
0.020556381,
0.2397633791,
0.0381653719,
0.612049222,
-0.2840662897,
0.6132395267,
0.3107081354,
-0.0721499249,
0.056079492,
0.073036395,
0.3629278839,
-0.5626140237,
-0.3524206281,
-0.968998909,
0.5035427213,
-0.4888352454,
-0.0182056781,
0.6757798791,
0.4632977843,
0.7139092088,
0.1007904559,
1.2123029232,
-0.1822958142,
0.3791038394,
-0.4658709168,
0.7114956379,
-0.287391901,
0.3764844835,
-0.0844426528,
-0.9295627475,
0.1710746735,
0.2595425844,
-0.2835084498,
-0.0473538786,
0.6524264216,
0.597540617,
-0.0434373356,
0.3625265956,
0.3336583078,
0.4774487615,
0.4548897743,
0.5933824778,
1.2779700756,
0.2127465904,
0.5119250417,
-0.3333805799,
-0.4904967546,
-0.0177124664,
-0.9946064949,
-0.5233264565,
-0.6619203687,
-0.3133207858,
-0.2899700999,
-0.1732476354,
0.9009950161,
0.6499761343,
-0.5952474475,
-0.3903498948,
0.4922190607,
0.4989970624,
-0.3270237148,
-0.1976877153,
0.0359959677,
-0.1920558214,
-0.7337588072,
0.2482336611,
0.3125901222,
0.0573887527,
-0.1275150478,
-0.1159641519,
0.1178245917,
0.22326231,
0.8671300411,
0.2109914869,
-0.7923554182,
-0.2837242186,
-0.3883697391,
0.2117309123,
0.041078385,
0.7579900622,
-0.6461957693,
0.5018652678,
0.3911112547,
0.3822290599,
0.5162325501,
0.0165152736,
0.875805974,
-0.9712610841,
0.1765130907,
-0.0881212875,
0.5682182312,
0.4038397372,
-0.0489283241,
0.5460092425,
0.1636923403,
-0.2711712122,
-0.5453139544,
0.4696360528,
-0.5893796086,
-0.4395217597,
1.0084434748,
-0.3857744634,
-0.119956471,
-0.5507383347,
-0.4041059017,
0.0404045433,
-0.25992468,
0.8143225908,
0.9632266164,
0.1292939484,
-0.1812335104,
-0.2941972911,
0.4374533892,
0.2650310099,
-0.8444166183,
0.3681629002,
0.5299611092,
0.490766257,
0.2948848903,
0.8332751393,
-0.2203164399,
0.0891821608,
-0.1389404684,
-0.2033105791,
-0.0304243527,
-0.1463013291,
-0.0682506561,
0.1868519634,
0.5271241069,
0.1148023978
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10688v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10688v2
|
Towards Uncovering How Large Language Model Works: An Explainability Perspective
| 2024-02-16T13:46:06 | 2024-04-15T18:43:12 |
Haiyan Zhao, Fan Yang, Bo Shen, Himabindu Lakkaraju, Mengnan Du
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have led to breakthroughs in language tasks, yet
the internal mechanisms that enable their remarkable generalization and
reasoning abilities remain opaque. This lack of transparency presents
challenges such as hallucinations, toxicity, and misalignment with human
values, hindering the safe and beneficial deployment of LLMs. This paper aims
to uncover the mechanisms underlying LLM functionality through the lens of
explainability. First, we review how knowledge is architecturally composed
within LLMs and encoded in their internal parameters via mechanistic
interpretability techniques. Then, we summarize how knowledge is embedded in
LLM representations by leveraging probing techniques and representation
engineering. Additionally, we investigate the training dynamics through a
mechanistic perspective to explain phenomena such as grokking and memorization.
Lastly, we explore how the insights gained from these explanations can enhance
LLM performance through model editing, improve efficiency through pruning, and
better align with human values.
|
[
-0.2101865709,
-0.7080440521,
1.0308204889,
-0.1021891907,
-0.1139737368,
0.0811535418,
-0.3748579323,
-0.4427201748,
-0.1798892915,
0.4183132052,
-0.565640986,
-0.2910116315,
-0.6695385575,
-0.2019953132,
-0.3629263639,
0.8541920781,
-0.1453691572,
0.0277081896,
-0.1886625588,
-0.1423553079,
-0.2636120319,
-0.6629539132,
-0.5460544825,
-0.7198652029,
0.4135757387,
0.2727027237,
0.7866742611,
0.9646112919,
0.1101938486,
0.313747704,
-0.458130151,
-0.0804677829,
-0.6191638708,
0.0191035029,
-0.2958964705,
-0.9036127925,
-0.2105815411,
-0.0887853429,
0.7908325195,
0.8994565606,
-0.2169748545,
-0.1335165948,
0.2728038728,
0.6366810203,
-0.317394197,
0.3333785534,
-0.68284446,
-0.1614143699,
-0.1355491132,
-0.2254824042,
-0.2998357117,
-0.0772692561,
0.1718352139,
-0.4762414098,
0.1399122775,
0.0368133299,
0.5843088031,
0.1633365601,
-0.2754707634,
-0.6614898443,
-0.7836684585,
0.7713993192,
-0.800475955,
0.4576368332,
0.2027509362,
0.4699045718,
-0.1854240894,
-0.444228977,
-0.518071115,
-0.3811809123,
-0.1929515302,
-0.2841847539,
0.0032908916,
0.2957753837,
0.1925593317,
0.5697537065,
-0.5638312697,
0.3110623062,
-0.1844990253,
-0.1812653989,
0.3494036496,
0.1585196108,
0.5351670384,
-0.0205128733,
-0.085971877,
0.0533180051,
-0.8503511548,
0.0851325467,
0.5260745883,
0.0061537204,
0.0211059768,
0.523956418,
-0.0079262815,
0.4970639348,
-0.2118164748,
-0.2253835648,
-0.0728932694,
-0.0467116982,
-0.2678232193,
-0.0747766569,
0.4989370704,
0.0852286443,
0.3744557798,
-0.3269846141,
-0.208917141,
-0.2160018682,
0.291166544,
-0.6996116638,
0.0343691073,
0.3196865916,
-0.6933612227,
-0.2698090076,
-0.1700710356,
-0.373914808,
-0.535290122,
-0.4989333451,
0.39045766,
-0.6100393534,
-0.4650165737,
0.2605236769,
-0.0890713185,
0.3238672018,
0.3905774355,
-1.2636493444,
0.1945861876,
0.9742767215,
0.6694707274,
0.0919912606,
-0.3807814121,
-0.0085257823,
0.3245272338,
-0.2653998733,
0.3495234549,
-0.5023372173,
-0.121641919,
-0.0450076088,
0.1333880126,
-0.1207787916,
-0.6973506808,
0.1794921905,
-0.5205646753,
-0.0755498111,
-0.2277723551,
-0.7388129234,
-0.541496098,
0.2583484948,
-0.5982701778,
0.4814793468,
-0.0869689584,
-0.6265017986,
0.0785019323,
-0.6385731697,
-0.112284489,
-0.0035066616,
-0.1288975477,
-0.0382095724,
0.5128532052,
-0.0439671203,
0.6355642676,
-0.2542734146,
0.3534819186,
-0.2250454724,
-0.3839049935,
0.4554865062,
-0.5583119988,
0.73764956,
0.3115547597,
-0.1528734863,
0.1689445078,
-0.5459170938,
-0.2430922985,
0.274654299,
-0.3404867351,
-0.2902382314,
0.0101791741,
-0.4551047385,
0.0643137395,
0.2019724846,
-0.1201093495,
0.1350664347,
-0.5287524462,
0.7159966826,
0.7496045828,
-0.0857052431,
0.7715750337,
-0.1045419797,
0.6282672286,
0.0179655068,
0.1595859975,
-0.4702041149,
-0.2176599801,
-0.5182166696,
-0.0393994562,
-0.0335096829,
0.2226377428,
-0.4313959479,
0.0170931369,
-0.1106529385,
-0.3389851749,
-0.5365792513,
0.4145566225,
0.4124340415,
0.5024374127,
0.0212594364,
0.0553956069,
-0.3480976224,
-1.1496363878,
-0.4384218156,
-0.2636427581,
-0.0904396698,
0.1441796571,
0.503816843,
-0.2696514726,
0.5472735763,
-0.2188744098,
0.2493868321,
-0.5518231988,
0.1391139627,
0.3076749444,
0.314337492,
0.2666837275,
-0.5760221481,
0.0226296019,
0.1219668761,
-1.0098434687,
-0.1057355404,
-0.1618978083,
0.1053540707,
0.1137766168,
0.7317713499,
-0.5673500299,
0.2624363005,
0.4206599295,
-0.2291799486,
0.7572765946,
-0.550129652,
-0.0560344681,
-0.6512779593,
-0.1263533533,
-0.1893009692,
-0.2373209149,
-0.6019228101,
0.4124947488,
0.0618067048,
-0.0449774042,
-0.2605384588,
0.4442938566,
-0.7405110598,
-0.1931676716,
-0.4185614288,
0.1628399044,
0.126197651,
0.3848391175,
-0.2500867248,
0.5974575877,
0.6174215674,
-0.6201528907,
0.2180575877,
-0.0876281261,
-0.4524342716,
0.2909874022,
-0.7828996778,
-0.0527167059,
-0.4618222415,
0.1170540825,
-0.9218524694,
-0.3208072782,
0.0663841218,
-0.2947781086,
0.3946882486,
-0.2243890166,
-0.6893274188,
-0.1162579209,
-0.1561975479,
0.2994192839,
0.5346667767,
-0.6026040912,
0.6475582123,
0.4326324165,
-0.1215630472,
-0.4453254938,
-0.6622099876,
0.1239574552,
-0.5424906015,
-0.7675424814,
0.1126264557,
-0.1875289083,
-0.7084861398,
-0.1783211231,
-0.1434648484,
-0.0664150044,
0.4677690268,
0.3577277064,
-0.0214650072,
-0.3345046341,
0.4667416513,
0.0540491492,
-0.1812588274,
0.453764379,
-0.3028280735,
0.5537782311,
-0.2500730753,
-0.569801867,
-0.5054821372,
0.2183231115,
0.6867886186,
-0.0162947942,
1.0315742493,
0.3301106989,
-0.292911917,
-0.4270053208,
-0.4991314411,
-0.3400494158,
-0.4768319428,
0.4861212075,
-0.4900848866,
-0.9835878015,
0.7787246108,
-0.2450355291,
-0.0757784992,
0.2732480168,
0.6562042236,
-0.0576860793,
1.0069946051,
0.6835522652,
0.0778005496,
0.3136222959,
-0.145577684,
0.4447368383,
-0.6315380335,
-0.4288060069,
-0.3481875658,
-0.172811076,
-0.3778295219,
-0.494220525,
0.1740266681,
0.6045345068,
-0.1074342057,
0.0733421221,
-0.2319954336,
0.7073225379,
0.357103914,
-0.0391044691,
0.5197681189,
-0.2763505578,
-0.1655686647,
0.0556434542,
-0.6290313005,
-0.8269165754,
0.7760406137,
0.89255476,
1.0516484976,
0.1348131746,
0.5306889415,
-0.0938365981,
0.1059659347,
-0.7753068805,
0.5208092332,
0.1142502353,
-0.6364778876,
-0.4530183375,
-0.2084549963,
-0.6074559093,
0.433136344,
-0.0956259891,
-0.924934864,
-0.1574542224,
0.3256683946,
0.1089470237,
0.4421399236,
-0.9716304541,
0.7014256716,
-0.3445457816,
-0.311873287,
-0.4863628745,
-0.5910274386,
0.5498411059,
-0.073651135,
0.487187326,
0.033364363,
0.0734959319,
0.5526502132,
-0.3933169842,
0.9025957584,
-0.1069637835,
-0.5305827856,
0.0371008664,
0.2116037011,
0.4549499452,
-0.0223456062,
-0.0863271803,
0.1322851777,
-0.1367659718,
-0.2571464181,
-0.9595655203,
0.7773146033,
-0.5291000605,
-0.8641768694,
0.1607640833,
-0.8912681341,
-0.1874969304,
0.0082031712,
0.0571903512,
0.3884081542,
-0.0729637071,
0.1562632322,
1.0462332964,
-0.5137944818,
0.4326427281,
0.416182965,
-0.5200411081,
0.2557711005,
0.8759162426,
0.1353748888,
0.3644794226,
0.4376609921,
0.3320406079,
-0.4155907035,
-0.8538451791,
-0.2158432901,
0.4626018405,
-0.9678322077,
0.4908801317,
-0.498906672,
-0.1771059483,
-0.1420516074,
-0.203357473,
-0.1770259291,
-0.3614324629,
-0.2334606946,
-0.4686704874,
0.063583605,
1.2503312826,
-0.0850863829,
0.5285663605,
-0.5439002514,
0.2015217692,
0.3763762414,
0.5127687454,
0.4691583812,
-0.6557363868,
-0.4339955747,
0.0309709255,
-0.0431082956,
-0.779636085,
0.1400912106,
-0.109494403,
0.8231406808,
0.6783339977,
-0.4212220609,
0.5633464456,
-0.4823762774,
0.6007518768,
-0.015447597,
-1.1902817488,
0.4690337181,
-0.4512169361,
0.1492250562,
0.1787969023,
0.3509890139,
-0.4017884433,
-0.5915297866,
-0.5443941951,
-0.9016616344,
0.6088459492,
0.0130658457,
0.2287893593,
0.3301675916,
0.6835718751,
0.364485234,
0.1268325299,
-0.8463070393,
-0.1645188332,
-0.055153463,
-0.1402031928,
-0.1602348238,
-0.6790550351,
-0.1311548352,
-0.1342348307,
0.5573985577,
0.0396593735,
0.150886938,
-0.112466529,
-0.5329908729,
0.0978219062,
0.4793835282,
0.7201595306,
1.0937550068,
-0.130303964,
0.4704918265,
-0.0510414168,
-0.0637560412,
0.0000615143,
-0.1877608001,
0.1555467844,
-0.2102722526,
0.8015684485,
0.8362303972,
0.2550105751,
-0.7312188148,
0.2408191413,
0.1106598228,
-0.274920702,
-0.1322192401,
0.2563340068,
0.4951377511,
0.5456598401,
0.3464236557,
-0.474263519,
0.1370255351,
-0.8970707655,
-0.0993310213,
0.5881879926,
-0.3252436519,
-0.5527154207,
0.7380464673,
-0.1311243474,
-0.2311760187,
0.3139359355,
0.0332970954,
-0.495775938,
0.5817052722,
0.5171904564,
0.5889625549,
-0.2730564475,
0.2450493127,
0.0845315009,
0.5679808855,
-0.0668406412,
-0.0613897219,
-0.0075421366,
-0.7268394828,
-0.5553147197,
-0.5268691182,
-0.4896070063,
0.3913384378,
-0.6270914078,
-0.1928411275,
-0.3613757193,
0.5292981267,
0.1959912628,
-0.3620463908,
-0.4080203474,
0.0959783047,
0.1640178859,
0.8918300271,
-1.0064586401,
0.6695616245,
0.4996001422,
-0.3627867699,
-0.9020419121,
0.0221974365,
0.0974198133,
-1.2861936092,
0.5727980137,
0.264506191,
-0.061887458,
-0.1911208034,
-0.7422806621,
-0.5234088898,
1.0342025757,
0.7513324022,
-0.5498042703,
-0.0834129006,
0.2139112055,
0.6326425076,
-0.3272959888,
0.2599749267,
0.738217175,
0.634517014,
0.0434816182,
-0.6605679393,
0.2057007104,
-0.0807943568,
0.008343433,
0.0167992357,
-0.3038691282,
0.7144083381,
-0.4369215667,
-0.180661723,
-0.1905171871,
0.3791365623,
0.1879246235,
0.2558425963,
0.3782689571,
0.4484085143,
0.9274085164,
0.0203487203,
1.2586483955,
-0.1650493741,
0.1295829266,
0.9356742501,
-0.0286148172,
0.4245176911,
0.6464797258,
-0.0510347597,
0.5361257195,
0.4196092784,
0.2514245212,
0.3366682529,
0.5453723669,
-0.2079659104,
-0.2152242512,
-0.0626618043,
-0.1156806871,
0.4747710228,
0.4253098369,
-0.6743679047,
-0.2868416011,
0.1246272177,
0.1297037899,
0.0122582745,
-0.4758493602,
0.8744356632,
0.1878843904,
-0.4528331459,
0.4947467446,
-0.1417096853,
0.3345061541,
-0.6035500765,
-0.1440319419,
0.0095833251,
0.1191353798,
-0.1568932831,
-1.0075272322,
0.4557624459,
-0.3134384453,
-0.4651198685,
-0.409668833,
0.7161386013,
-0.4234679341,
-0.0524569973,
0.4686329961,
0.6511819363,
0.348670572,
-0.2481985092,
-0.4455134273,
0.2511514127,
0.0528593734,
-0.3035272062,
0.5086880326,
0.8502801657,
-0.034903083,
1.067185998,
0.4364988208,
0.1324897856,
-0.036422845,
0.1260005832,
0.8066598773,
-0.8187609315,
-0.2946275771,
-1.182331562,
0.5888077617,
0.2001506835,
0.1233738586,
0.7113374472,
0.1756899506,
0.461329639,
-0.0803881958,
0.7448023558,
0.3022155166,
0.3314642012,
-0.7266998887,
0.9294842482,
-0.4660739899,
0.6391239166,
-0.0135848252,
-0.7229517698,
-0.2162076086,
0.4607760906,
-0.3752811551,
-0.0430369042,
0.7241895795,
0.7773411274,
-0.0710722283,
0.0266483109,
0.5496011972,
0.7359853387,
0.3679034114,
0.4664923549,
0.9902051091,
0.1470158845,
0.5687586069,
-0.0160838962,
-0.2521566749,
-0.2126477957,
-0.9869816899,
-0.9518197775,
-0.6232747436,
-0.021189129,
-0.2153792381,
0.0438270941,
0.3667701483,
0.7347570062,
-0.6116283536,
-0.271540761,
-0.3295554817,
0.5475338101,
0.1262450814,
-0.2455151379,
0.2559645772,
-0.3402497172,
-0.4556652606,
0.4512617886,
0.3464541137,
0.1360764056,
-0.498090744,
-0.2034040987,
0.1983503252,
0.0927275941,
0.5314958692,
0.2192448527,
-0.9050753713,
-0.1400097907,
-0.3352974951,
0.237891227,
-0.144337073,
0.8721449375,
-0.5527685285,
0.4448501468,
0.3767451942,
0.6568825245,
0.2790878415,
-0.254809767,
0.8633543849,
-0.4539830685,
0.0077910153,
-0.0656075403,
0.5983647108,
0.404792726,
-0.404728651,
0.4923829734,
-0.0929232165,
-0.6732230186,
-0.8412011266,
0.3690467477,
-0.7851828337,
-0.4983327091,
1.0367115736,
-0.2311954647,
-0.2486748993,
-0.2491458356,
-0.0708959773,
0.1445641816,
-0.089454636,
0.7578199506,
0.9059832096,
-0.1051427424,
-0.4305197299,
-0.7759087086,
0.3865698874,
0.1784059852,
-0.8350901604,
0.3988683522,
0.4063261151,
0.5308618546,
0.0639294609,
0.4019674659,
-0.2118617743,
-0.0852076188,
-0.1584763229,
-0.035841547,
-0.2057435215,
-0.1934610754,
-0.7295127511,
0.2594090998,
0.3118084967,
0.1265524328
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10685v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10685v2
|
LongHeads: Multi-Head Attention is Secretly a Long Context Processor
| 2024-02-16T13:39:34 | 2024-03-25T11:50:32 |
Yi Lu, Xin Zhou, Wei He, Jun Zhao, Tao Ji, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved impressive performance in numerous
domains but often struggle to process lengthy inputs effectively and
efficiently due to limited length generalization and attention's quadratic
computational demands. Many sought to mitigate this by restricting the
attention window within the pre-trained length. However, these methods
introduce new issues such as ignoring the middle context and requiring
additional training. To address these problems, we propose LongHeads, a
training-free framework that enhances LLM's long context ability by unlocking
multi-head attention's untapped potential. Instead of allowing each head to
attend to the full sentence, which struggles with generalizing to longer
sequences due to out-of-distribution (OOD) issues, we allow each head to
process in-distribution length by selecting and attending to important context
chunks. To this end, we propose a chunk selection strategy that relies on the
inherent correlation between the query and the key representations, efficiently
distributing context chunks to different heads. In this way, each head ensures
it can effectively process attended tokens within the trained length, while
different heads in different layers can collectively process longer contexts.
LongHeads works efficiently in linear time, fits seamlessly with many LLMs that
use relative positional encoding. LongHeads achieves 100% accuracy at the 128k
length on passkey retrieval task, verifying LongHeads's efficacy in extending
the usable context window for existing models. We release our code at
https://github.com/LuLuLuyi/LongHeads .
|
[
-0.5441778898,
-0.6634789109,
0.8552447557,
0.6104367971,
-0.5893201232,
-0.0006102993,
-0.7369005084,
-0.6606670618,
0.4098444879,
0.5460414886,
-0.8682405353,
-0.1894433647,
-0.7127752304,
0.1698266268,
-0.3022680581,
0.7248914242,
0.2516076267,
-0.4546115994,
-0.2893266976,
-0.1075995639,
-0.5564374924,
-0.3668747842,
-0.7709364891,
-0.2496091127,
0.8210297823,
0.2040839791,
0.4167937338,
0.9535028934,
0.4430804849,
0.2105274498,
-0.189912647,
0.1873798668,
-0.7334153652,
0.371480763,
-0.3990077376,
-0.0374342687,
-0.6670432687,
-0.3616900444,
0.6413915157,
0.6706321836,
0.2165538669,
0.1385945976,
0.2414616048,
0.9720129371,
-0.8966110349,
0.1742683947,
-0.6121029258,
0.0264318231,
-0.6553552151,
-0.4257035553,
-0.4173111618,
0.3163694739,
0.2727018297,
-0.4222021699,
-0.2806928158,
-0.0605443083,
0.2582638264,
0.4347166717,
-0.4119916856,
-0.1249270514,
-0.2598979473,
1.0146899223,
-0.3361665606,
0.6162874699,
0.244634226,
0.4642401338,
-0.1603782922,
-0.6175876856,
-0.363632977,
0.2756101489,
0.1433015019,
-0.0461780168,
0.0205256753,
0.2962156236,
0.045885928,
0.2251762152,
-0.491859436,
0.0495506041,
-0.1994638741,
-0.0284049362,
0.3380845487,
-0.195031479,
-0.1316655427,
0.0606534854,
-0.4358221591,
0.0645664856,
-0.9134225845,
0.131437242,
0.1481494457,
0.6805850267,
-0.1512863487,
0.4408891797,
-0.5338427424,
1.14272964,
0.3500005603,
-0.2930334508,
0.1998320669,
0.064301163,
-0.4299167097,
0.0310319792,
0.648211062,
0.2273168862,
0.2600173056,
-0.3569692671,
-0.1308410019,
-0.2605085969,
0.2521929145,
-0.9669423699,
0.3741713762,
0.6439441442,
-0.1015499458,
-0.0760977566,
-0.2852101028,
-0.6197736263,
-0.2257249206,
-0.4373913109,
0.2184587121,
-0.2626755238,
-0.1387585104,
0.2495495379,
-0.09485019,
0.1179715171,
0.1166176349,
-0.9647512436,
-0.1327578872,
0.9484279156,
0.9765594602,
-0.6114116907,
-0.5198950768,
-0.7056002021,
0.4905641377,
-0.0941096395,
0.7246548533,
-0.4596029818,
-0.0341235623,
0.0358654596,
0.0862669051,
0.0581099316,
-0.5758288503,
0.1533129811,
-0.6848938465,
-0.2956033051,
-0.1495889872,
-0.3974270225,
-0.0828576311,
0.2686834037,
-0.4631433785,
0.5029963851,
0.3495734334,
-0.8063169718,
0.19334732,
-0.7854338288,
-0.6049428582,
0.1971085221,
-0.2888757885,
-0.197483182,
0.0213178638,
0.354723841,
0.7932682037,
-0.1351590306,
0.3027426004,
-0.4774444997,
-0.5178312063,
-0.0680527538,
-0.0867729485,
0.9300320745,
-0.0444159396,
-0.4505543113,
0.5328216553,
-0.3900877535,
-0.011227618,
0.0962404907,
-0.3378255069,
-0.226929605,
-0.1735459268,
0.0683907419,
0.208632201,
0.0680029392,
-0.335830301,
0.1012492254,
-0.3561436236,
0.6510004997,
0.7300852537,
-0.0327895172,
0.3518955112,
-0.1581420004,
0.3868201077,
0.260548532,
-0.1393655241,
-0.3659775853,
-0.1425490379,
-0.5677015781,
-0.6327342987,
-0.0061723161,
0.1197725907,
-0.7258015275,
0.6210601926,
-0.6217172742,
0.0057270168,
-0.2481565177,
0.2203042507,
0.4001019299,
0.3542540669,
0.2404065728,
-0.511367619,
-0.5593227744,
-0.9507329464,
-0.2393582165,
0.308301568,
-0.0981330201,
0.1877788007,
0.3221082687,
-0.3799028695,
1.3086972237,
-0.5198614597,
-0.5692334771,
-0.3417254686,
-0.3104689419,
0.2300880402,
0.3566517234,
0.4420036077,
-0.5155481696,
-0.4539629519,
-0.2421886772,
-0.7113749981,
0.2405930012,
-0.0742396042,
-0.5028012395,
-0.1104069576,
0.4575698674,
-0.9417778254,
0.1302563995,
0.5673214197,
-0.1357078254,
0.3707163632,
0.2527477443,
-0.2981285155,
-0.8260802031,
0.1420794874,
-0.030622717,
-0.7570521832,
-0.5331388116,
0.4582479894,
0.4489341974,
-0.1142066196,
-0.8522500992,
0.6952136159,
-0.6759304404,
-0.0639553294,
-0.5577501059,
0.1945778877,
-0.0775518417,
0.8728809357,
0.2293915898,
0.8979665637,
0.8450101018,
-0.8342285156,
0.3457944095,
0.1209231243,
-0.3944675326,
0.9638410807,
-0.4622329473,
0.5252191424,
-0.3091499507,
0.4511140287,
-0.5136117339,
-0.5843881965,
0.1263992041,
-0.2678409517,
0.5957323909,
-0.2095218897,
-0.1610040069,
-0.4672370851,
-0.5040902495,
0.613209188,
0.0475599095,
-0.5700002909,
0.2389144003,
0.6579225659,
-0.1512446702,
-0.9048339725,
-0.7879721522,
0.1961281449,
-0.2900647223,
-0.5826641917,
0.4000187516,
-0.3401808441,
0.009275292,
-0.4012640119,
-0.1294263601,
-0.2571569979,
-0.111975044,
0.0709975362,
-0.3120193779,
-0.1259933114,
0.0275586676,
0.2421396077,
0.0391520113,
0.0687578022,
-0.5878534913,
0.6102057695,
0.2225059718,
-0.086916022,
-0.2499502003,
0.4385251999,
0.8788911104,
-0.3913654685,
0.4579000473,
0.4167550206,
-0.3017234206,
-0.3678400815,
-0.3902972639,
-0.2104078233,
-0.5086013675,
0.7285634875,
-0.3501282632,
-1.2371445894,
0.1106601655,
0.1403357089,
0.0860986114,
-0.0129368808,
0.5913375616,
0.2920432687,
0.5383815169,
0.6388642788,
-0.3350662589,
0.4250441194,
-0.1165825874,
0.0990258902,
-1.2729567289,
0.0909225643,
0.0804296061,
-0.2576231658,
-0.0144436006,
-0.5558843613,
0.3958167434,
-0.0779037625,
-0.0181162283,
0.3419110477,
-0.5699843168,
0.7434436083,
0.4202607572,
0.1846671402,
-0.10371764,
-0.1248864904,
0.2408021986,
0.2012676597,
-0.147857517,
0.0407609344,
1.2156059742,
0.4944548309,
0.4101328552,
0.0356836691,
0.5759361386,
0.1556969434,
-0.1310340911,
-1.1167274714,
0.5650500059,
0.1408373266,
-0.7424561977,
-0.6019585729,
-0.3401254117,
-0.9571996331,
0.486482501,
0.3673510253,
-0.6445049644,
-0.0894699842,
0.1161282733,
-0.8889892101,
0.1691771597,
-0.1914908737,
0.8717607856,
-0.1744247973,
-0.542229712,
-0.2442691028,
-0.8549000025,
0.4064899981,
-0.288703084,
0.1201539189,
-0.3312704861,
-0.02195655,
0.8308523893,
0.1105822101,
0.7240272164,
-0.1460287273,
-0.0376367085,
0.3277510107,
-0.1588483751,
0.437277019,
0.2181025445,
0.3689564764,
0.2064622939,
-0.375761658,
-0.3668188155,
-0.2007753402,
0.8482995033,
-0.4470811188,
-0.6928290725,
-0.3860915303,
-0.8612719178,
-0.4995419681,
0.619489193,
0.0546062738,
0.3194969594,
0.0880101845,
0.5758444071,
0.603654623,
0.08792945,
0.6840781569,
0.0901902094,
-0.3491257131,
-0.5063510537,
0.4984842539,
-0.0253095459,
0.2513615191,
0.5161491632,
0.0737193078,
-0.1921284944,
-0.5093596578,
-0.5832865834,
0.3122677505,
-0.7215496898,
-0.3413351178,
-0.8239365816,
-0.1391772479,
-0.597410202,
-0.0089466674,
-0.4458367229,
-0.153941825,
-0.1683279276,
0.0849385932,
0.1319280118,
0.3430368304,
0.1363369226,
0.6921408772,
-0.4288159609,
0.4557202756,
0.6274896264,
0.4973688424,
0.156000182,
-0.4349139631,
-0.4099394381,
-0.1109872758,
-0.4323220849,
-0.717150569,
0.4238604307,
0.1256418824,
0.0768666416,
0.7044550776,
-0.1203855127,
1.0112973452,
-0.8017343879,
0.4180307388,
0.2396430969,
-0.8480008245,
0.1742481589,
-0.5799447298,
0.814432025,
0.6608130336,
0.2720991671,
-0.6305531263,
-0.3626076579,
-0.0046608569,
-0.9851025343,
0.8568643928,
0.0991251692,
0.02674428,
-0.1831538379,
0.2328413725,
0.175461337,
0.4963378906,
-0.642763555,
-0.1907298118,
0.0846270248,
-0.0121204853,
0.0780447647,
-0.4485950172,
-0.1323035955,
-0.2038802654,
0.4691981971,
-0.3722062409,
0.4857968092,
0.1024808213,
-0.3698958457,
-0.1834317297,
0.2155820876,
0.7640429139,
1.2456743717,
-0.3917147815,
0.2349983007,
-0.0621097125,
-0.4203034341,
-0.1425884217,
-0.1112114489,
-0.0194829386,
-0.0261888113,
0.2530831397,
0.7554160953,
0.3525575697,
-0.6237344742,
0.6994922757,
0.2338684499,
0.1703171879,
-0.6217451096,
-0.3336170912,
0.4554077983,
0.2210382521,
0.5184934735,
-0.0607121326,
0.172539115,
-0.4968294203,
0.2955074012,
0.5860524774,
-0.5390123725,
-0.3383581042,
0.3973082602,
0.3114243746,
-0.1344052553,
0.4410533309,
-0.0904625207,
-0.3881464601,
0.350551337,
0.6076725125,
0.987133801,
-0.034016721,
-0.3643344939,
0.0636075139,
0.0175701696,
-0.1322255731,
0.0264010783,
-0.2482642382,
-0.3791832924,
-0.7560939789,
-0.6452929378,
-0.2880516946,
0.5784370303,
-0.6136237383,
0.297716856,
-0.4364942908,
-0.3469911814,
-0.0927587226,
-0.277022928,
-0.5823097229,
0.214288339,
0.4293574691,
0.717104435,
-0.2462654114,
1.033390522,
0.2913502455,
0.0641012043,
-0.1466269344,
0.1132169291,
0.1030113176,
-0.7163571715,
0.4630771279,
0.8701356649,
-0.2288378477,
-0.0203488357,
-0.3634003103,
-1.0165400505,
0.9572194219,
0.5144857764,
-0.9310663342,
-0.4219963253,
0.060402412,
-0.0595936477,
-0.4217077196,
0.2547925711,
0.5789118409,
0.2557404637,
-0.0275936238,
-1.0366318226,
-0.0456217565,
0.3875867724,
-0.0482399836,
0.2664581537,
-0.9138063192,
0.9033902287,
-0.1038597748,
-0.2034712434,
-0.255464375,
0.9057969451,
0.4769196808,
0.1236161962,
0.6923294663,
0.3506554365,
0.4627382159,
0.2090554833,
0.795933485,
-0.5581162572,
0.3153956234,
1.1005749702,
-0.2419972867,
0.8727048635,
0.9648399949,
-0.0522440448,
0.2137145996,
0.4554736614,
0.6370962858,
0.7918394208,
0.2730164528,
-0.2337337583,
-0.2467461526,
0.1075237915,
-0.3030554354,
0.4370328188,
0.1494494826,
-0.2162194848,
-0.1635821015,
0.1553553492,
0.2396700084,
-0.2771122158,
-0.4211507738,
0.4188284278,
0.4435916841,
-0.7817614675,
0.6439834237,
-0.0160158277,
1.1906943321,
-0.7828118205,
0.3596815765,
-0.1246440411,
0.4234294295,
-0.0219044089,
-0.5796649456,
0.2856528759,
-0.1607706696,
-0.2823587954,
-0.2957752943,
0.4485017657,
-0.6006161571,
-0.0990075395,
0.4422775209,
0.2865382433,
0.1395977587,
-0.9163640141,
-0.4029650688,
0.3266839385,
-0.0956782848,
-0.4765426219,
0.5972002149,
0.4187318683,
-0.0083616218,
0.5917945504,
0.436034441,
0.2059550285,
-0.0712053254,
-0.1437207907,
0.7949376702,
-0.7903106809,
-0.8128111959,
-1.098090291,
0.2714936137,
-0.1327854395,
-0.3196196258,
0.4806174636,
0.5710952282,
0.9950964451,
-0.2764971256,
0.6624419689,
0.1337907612,
0.6166481972,
-0.2820215225,
0.8655609488,
-0.5302026272,
-0.3327614069,
0.0941988379,
-1.0786798,
-0.385902077,
0.4140962064,
-0.0421241187,
0.0147706373,
0.8672409058,
0.2917258143,
-0.3964818418,
-0.3922779858,
0.4783571362,
-0.1200109199,
0.2832907438,
0.9956590533,
0.3991376162,
0.0566532351,
0.3728099763,
-0.354914695,
-0.1755136698,
-0.3389404416,
-0.9147082567,
-1.1770379543,
-0.3021284044,
-0.1304290146,
0.0245552883,
0.3005131781,
1.151154995,
1.1661672592,
-0.6506245732,
-0.5843402147,
0.2661218941,
-0.1987664551,
-0.3068831861,
-0.1750571281,
0.4315995574,
-0.495413512,
-0.7983101606,
0.839482367,
0.6871534586,
-0.2569419146,
-0.348228246,
0.002468732,
-0.0172094218,
-0.0278103966,
1.0928275585,
0.2549389005,
-0.7543097734,
-0.4108205736,
-0.0418085083,
-0.1294383109,
0.2828458846,
0.7279159427,
-0.7826412916,
0.3417095244,
0.2255665064,
0.9054182768,
0.3976706564,
-0.0944922715,
0.3426731229,
-1.0701388121,
0.5837833881,
0.3119623065,
0.3590444922,
0.4916369617,
-0.4672375917,
0.3751889765,
0.0666852668,
-0.5213465691,
-0.9436681271,
0.3491566181,
-1.2092818022,
-0.4122954905,
1.2339221239,
-0.0993288532,
-0.6930112243,
0.0736872256,
0.0683326051,
0.2402009368,
-0.5180830956,
0.5816837549,
0.5666801333,
-0.0675649047,
-0.0332534686,
-0.5456473827,
0.5695238709,
0.3503133655,
-0.6020847559,
0.4502684176,
0.2794663608,
0.2268327773,
0.1982911229,
0.7561340332,
-0.0608180352,
0.1717364639,
-0.5420891047,
-0.0307501126,
-0.3530562222,
-0.771936357,
-0.34713763,
0.3640239835,
-0.0038575935,
-0.2665870488
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10675v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10675v1
|
German Text Simplification: Finetuning Large Language Models with Semi-Synthetic Data
| 2024-02-16T13:28:44 | 2024-02-16T13:28:44 |
Lars Klöser, Mika Beele, Jan-Niklas Schagen, Bodo Kraft
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
This study pioneers the use of synthetically generated data for training
generative models in document-level text simplification of German texts. We
demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach with real-world online texts.
Addressing the challenge of data scarcity in language simplification, we
crawled professionally simplified German texts and synthesized a corpus using
GPT-4. We finetune Large Language Models with up to 13 billion parameters on
this data and evaluate their performance. This paper employs various
methodologies for evaluation and demonstrates the limitations of currently used
rule-based metrics. Both automatic and manual evaluations reveal that our
models can significantly simplify real-world online texts, indicating the
potential of synthetic data in improving text simplification.
|
[
-0.3017188013,
-1.0143499374,
0.7975081801,
0.0934635773,
-0.4364136159,
-0.1358565986,
-0.2912840247,
-0.4666362405,
-0.1047867537,
0.1977070719,
-0.7127179503,
-0.5642207861,
-0.2470411807,
0.5939415097,
-0.5580633283,
1.1145330667,
-0.2141964585,
0.3457551897,
-0.1434215605,
0.2266110033,
0.0991009772,
-0.6909025908,
-0.4449406564,
-0.4381387532,
0.2897936106,
0.3113642037,
0.7418420911,
0.8353004456,
0.4468938112,
0.3660677373,
-0.3202287257,
0.2446594983,
-0.7449986935,
-0.1049933434,
0.0146586141,
-0.2640506625,
-0.3564087749,
0.017332226,
0.8033083081,
1.0012654066,
-0.0654072389,
0.0431360379,
-0.1035315767,
0.4181976318,
-0.2127788365,
0.4637796581,
-0.313645184,
0.1185815558,
-0.0581444129,
-0.1533645838,
-0.3194496036,
-0.5910781622,
0.0633371994,
-0.845790267,
0.7436798215,
-0.0536643341,
0.9468973875,
0.1568423659,
-0.4322508276,
-0.3716008365,
-1.2381266356,
0.7816311121,
-0.8300840259,
0.2959643304,
0.0684705004,
0.2561734915,
-0.0680124089,
-1.1106466055,
-0.6546711326,
-0.2854637504,
-0.3341325223,
0.1205174997,
-0.1592139304,
0.2654913366,
0.559910059,
0.5857979655,
-0.5182337761,
-0.1761366129,
-0.8679866195,
-0.2493067682,
0.667375505,
0.0504858233,
0.363373816,
-0.1199986413,
-0.1419357061,
-0.1995565891,
-0.731151998,
-0.5145834088,
0.5728654265,
0.2862406969,
-0.0387485623,
0.626499176,
-0.472345978,
0.4917016327,
-0.1864946932,
-0.1136248633,
0.3816950619,
-0.6195584536,
-0.3179806471,
-0.0025581159,
0.661580205,
0.3831848204,
0.3768052161,
-0.3675761223,
-0.3906772435,
0.0868640989,
0.1507080495,
-0.9726749063,
-0.1208912507,
0.1354254335,
-0.3664458394,
-0.3116653264,
0.1974339783,
-0.6503558755,
-0.0907873213,
-0.6517070532,
0.3620786369,
-0.388232708,
0.0764702633,
0.3399040997,
-0.457926333,
0.0293023884,
0.549746871,
-0.6617488265,
0.253459841,
0.5411602855,
0.7459664345,
-0.064751409,
-0.2463985533,
-0.0576284453,
0.2712033093,
-0.4800249636,
0.5179743767,
-0.2302440703,
-0.3511561453,
0.0808363408,
-0.0140822437,
0.3422482014,
-0.6697198749,
1.0867909193,
-0.303381741,
0.4177104533,
0.1764771491,
-0.8414883614,
-0.1429462582,
0.1132152528,
-0.9933971167,
1.0775271654,
0.1786990464,
-0.6690678,
0.2124211639,
-0.5254917145,
-0.6689395308,
0.0819938406,
0.1092696786,
-0.5302303433,
0.2104631066,
0.114224337,
0.4968984425,
-0.4794152379,
0.4356175363,
-0.1871897727,
-0.4517752528,
-0.0675881207,
-0.6481814981,
0.4395938218,
0.4777456224,
-0.2229369432,
-0.0799463689,
-0.9595088363,
0.1165025979,
0.1591059417,
-0.5248503089,
-0.4164755046,
-0.2401158214,
0.4855822921,
0.2472994477,
0.1861064434,
-0.5840075612,
0.1482617855,
-0.6033923626,
0.4539637566,
0.2554415762,
0.1060054898,
0.4723025262,
-0.3914719224,
0.5443664193,
-0.2020073682,
0.0693904012,
-0.0728144646,
-0.2421559691,
-0.8180477023,
-0.3273052871,
0.7016189098,
0.443549037,
-0.6936784983,
0.3202210367,
-0.595107913,
-0.7463977933,
-0.5677651167,
0.0502917431,
0.3121606708,
0.1555578709,
0.4104391038,
0.0390046537,
-0.6248979568,
-1.0949574709,
-0.3467061222,
0.2623517513,
-0.3960312903,
-0.1597232521,
0.3771167994,
-0.3703781068,
0.8135532141,
-0.4509641826,
-0.1640902013,
-0.4735167623,
0.4366916418,
-0.1141359732,
0.4985667765,
0.3817165494,
-1.0606639385,
-0.4674246013,
-0.0938776359,
-0.8068019152,
-0.1540507227,
-0.2491899729,
0.3264458477,
0.1437058598,
0.9259210825,
-0.7292529345,
0.2267897576,
0.5288959146,
0.0242173001,
0.23899813,
-0.6148108244,
-0.0327419266,
-0.9570837617,
0.0619330071,
0.2118728608,
-0.5595123172,
-1.0682469606,
0.2605370581,
0.1554147303,
-0.2877530754,
-0.5421570539,
0.652020216,
-0.5121719241,
0.1871794164,
-0.0269405078,
-0.0085194474,
-0.2201640457,
0.33948645,
-0.0591174513,
0.719476223,
0.0837141275,
-0.5335581303,
0.3381957412,
0.0899108574,
-0.3237143457,
0.0169277415,
-0.6883126497,
-0.1592902392,
-0.3203948438,
0.5014386773,
-0.8926842809,
-0.6870557666,
-0.0719943866,
-0.0497785956,
0.1823406965,
-0.0729323179,
-0.8937999606,
-0.1538893282,
-0.3015294075,
0.6034096479,
0.6482286453,
-0.3952884674,
0.6201931834,
0.2418433428,
-0.3767664135,
0.2221208215,
-0.6340247989,
0.0181467179,
-0.3505115807,
-0.5188109279,
0.7206137776,
-0.1857364476,
-0.2002153844,
-0.2193175405,
-0.0223849099,
-0.0137544051,
-0.1029426306,
-0.0298406202,
0.2709321678,
0.175750196,
0.1152789295,
0.2645064294,
-0.0731605962,
-0.1347717196,
-0.0500362627,
0.6578691602,
0.0416954979,
-0.1019305512,
-0.6037538648,
0.4878552556,
0.5228876472,
0.2819311023,
0.587688148,
0.4940539598,
-0.4582920074,
-0.4338638186,
-0.3548614383,
-0.3443664014,
-0.4859628379,
0.1252257824,
-0.4820958078,
-0.8517442346,
0.4926126301,
-0.6130349636,
-0.1696196347,
0.8051469922,
0.5645202398,
-0.0996383652,
1.1331076622,
0.6735782623,
0.3598743081,
0.2676784694,
-0.2299356461,
0.3778216243,
0.0204702746,
-0.1660974175,
-0.4439714849,
-0.0036071648,
-1.0819221735,
-0.3046995401,
0.444489181,
0.2680745125,
-0.0589314885,
0.2109410167,
-0.3086707592,
0.5383621454,
0.6029763818,
0.1408874691,
0.4322744608,
0.2036887854,
-0.1068066359,
-0.0387638249,
-0.5813441873,
-0.6683867574,
1.0172343254,
0.3296700418,
0.6425241828,
-0.1189241335,
0.7383263707,
0.2845157087,
0.1636089832,
-0.6579532623,
0.5248727798,
-0.1724824011,
-0.6979814172,
-0.3385706544,
-0.6527307034,
-0.6809945703,
-0.0186837967,
-0.191420868,
-0.0878054276,
-0.3400080204,
0.1759205908,
-0.050730262,
-0.1234799251,
-1.2137688398,
0.6820812821,
0.2292276025,
-0.0893078446,
-0.1912948042,
-0.4733368754,
0.2098579109,
-0.6560396552,
0.3256642222,
0.1146489605,
-0.0040070005,
0.5668183565,
-0.7585070729,
0.8871293664,
0.1563975662,
-0.2231783122,
0.1981369555,
-0.0009022265,
0.9277204871,
-0.2567455769,
-0.0520631485,
0.1659062058,
0.0394569263,
-0.4592997134,
-0.5321905017,
0.6233515739,
-0.6357062459,
-0.4701006711,
-0.2329556942,
-0.4969227314,
-0.1547913998,
0.4293624461,
0.3205716312,
0.3057967126,
-0.4160763919,
0.1919904798,
0.2950470448,
-0.0607482754,
0.3008210659,
0.274089545,
-0.0060520777,
-0.2812442183,
0.8715080619,
0.2607996464,
0.4302030206,
0.2102469206,
0.1050482094,
-0.4547530711,
-0.5688884854,
-0.4017237723,
0.377397567,
-0.8844976425,
-0.0114378352,
-0.5538745522,
-0.3499402106,
-0.3291437924,
-0.1801429242,
-0.121219635,
-0.9011483192,
-0.230346337,
-0.3822565079,
0.1448915005,
0.851207912,
0.0388717428,
0.5033558011,
-0.7274803519,
0.4382839203,
0.0978419483,
0.1880529225,
-0.30066818,
-0.2985485196,
-0.0806716457,
0.11673785,
-0.2066989839,
-0.7394706011,
0.6268000007,
0.0952763781,
0.4257870615,
0.1181187853,
0.1231956705,
0.4810987413,
-0.765576005,
0.5303782225,
0.0639270693,
-1.0260711908,
0.255990237,
-0.8100212216,
0.2864119112,
0.3162370026,
0.5751995444,
-0.4801666737,
-0.5650203824,
-0.990430057,
-0.9947012067,
0.7383493185,
0.6240076423,
0.4404742718,
0.349860996,
0.4670607448,
0.1777175367,
0.2456467301,
-0.7812594175,
-0.3371917605,
0.0763590932,
-0.6247538328,
-0.1164678857,
-0.2862745225,
-0.1383026093,
-0.3352249861,
0.7814378142,
-0.0575721152,
0.1023461744,
0.0510797575,
0.06077829,
0.0638304874,
0.3810413778,
0.6969663501,
0.5425800681,
0.013242892,
0.1175385192,
0.4555909932,
-0.2820915282,
0.2564283311,
0.3844488263,
-0.7767716646,
0.411645174,
0.3802455068,
0.6733034849,
0.1139312014,
-0.7213199735,
0.2880784571,
0.0421441756,
-0.4678970873,
-0.3753969967,
0.0628680587,
0.2126633227,
-0.1032000333,
0.312356323,
-0.0391068421,
0.3607957363,
-0.617272675,
0.1478760988,
0.0719587356,
-0.0562167652,
-0.3547491133,
0.4542395771,
0.01135075,
-0.1692934632,
0.2250164896,
-0.3748689592,
-0.4328615665,
0.4853979051,
0.5723307133,
0.5290250778,
-0.1077906415,
0.3037763834,
0.4493701458,
0.142326504,
-0.5156931281,
0.2422326058,
0.2014041841,
-0.453381449,
-0.3961293995,
-0.8136831522,
-0.3165632188,
0.4620499909,
-0.2479800135,
0.5662702918,
-0.4373379648,
-0.0538650453,
0.4563408196,
-0.0685304031,
-0.6185410023,
0.4750371277,
-0.0485426225,
0.7174580693,
-1.0346125364,
0.8290462494,
0.5996016264,
-0.5972746015,
-0.9329141974,
0.2163015157,
0.0190267004,
-0.3127101064,
0.5176392794,
0.1370278597,
-0.0544256978,
0.396792829,
-0.555151701,
-0.6541996598,
0.7488850951,
0.525134027,
-0.4370367825,
-0.2990795672,
0.5246094465,
0.9794566631,
-0.0913631767,
0.1963585317,
0.5477852821,
0.6251165867,
0.1671650857,
-0.868586421,
0.0742881,
-0.1971026957,
0.0790329874,
0.2884529829,
-0.3716876805,
0.8304685354,
0.1065201983,
-0.6332294941,
0.0898843855,
0.4785576165,
-0.2053640932,
0.1224778146,
0.3079258502,
0.472268641,
0.7245592475,
-0.2399851233,
1.2100770473,
-0.1600646228,
0.6257807612,
0.8412386179,
0.0106905038,
0.5921126604,
0.4573513269,
-0.1154342666,
0.2366858274,
0.5778917074,
-0.1549348235,
0.4537459016,
0.3922275305,
-0.3997253478,
-0.2866196632,
-0.0780241042,
0.0392943509,
0.3386999965,
0.1423278004,
-0.3379848003,
-0.6097767949,
0.056266997,
0.1895437688,
0.2097442597,
-0.1904174834,
0.9459584355,
-0.121392034,
-0.6321793795,
0.7398482561,
0.5487329364,
0.5182359219,
-0.5045793056,
-0.067044206,
-0.2845214903,
0.5183343291,
-0.0810140818,
-0.4723187983,
0.2704573274,
0.2354399413,
-0.1899287999,
-0.5014705658,
0.5803360343,
-0.6611099839,
-0.7124491334,
0.0882547423,
0.5447716713,
0.2814804912,
-0.0313867107,
-0.4026192427,
-0.1380914599,
0.2078350186,
-0.1955315769,
0.2083740979,
0.675167501,
-0.3105617166,
0.6753313541,
0.8662618995,
0.124999769,
0.1014559567,
0.0505353287,
1.0683424473,
-0.6569114923,
-0.5472800732,
-0.8235103488,
0.2817443311,
-0.2779362798,
-0.1086557433,
0.8345100284,
0.9257774353,
1.2187498808,
-0.3630720973,
1.0653868914,
0.1187007576,
0.7006916404,
-0.5989473462,
0.6853349209,
-0.5686838627,
0.0404992439,
-0.1313102096,
-0.8803688884,
-0.517005384,
0.3092349172,
-0.2406621724,
0.1919299215,
0.6843156219,
0.7834529281,
-0.4926815927,
0.0329984389,
0.4083798528,
0.1516244411,
0.3287487924,
-0.0287682042,
0.4943720996,
-0.5282457471,
0.7697924376,
-0.3351727426,
-0.0051827049,
-0.1796807647,
-0.8284714222,
-0.7812820673,
-0.6819017529,
-0.279489994,
-0.0645608008,
-0.0383601636,
0.808814466,
0.5908910632,
-0.8079517484,
0.0398960747,
-0.5372222662,
-0.318231076,
-0.0082610734,
-0.2130747885,
0.3844079673,
-0.4596262574,
-1.1679173708,
0.4041671157,
-0.1711697429,
0.7101662755,
-0.2445867807,
-0.0556098185,
0.071609661,
0.3272580206,
0.5277154446,
0.0291562025,
-0.6516060829,
-0.0368946902,
-0.2551897168,
-0.4783653915,
-0.0619981699,
0.8611181974,
-0.5547939539,
0.3556183279,
0.660215795,
0.3788918853,
0.6571826339,
0.3131200671,
0.8908644915,
-1.009544611,
0.3896749914,
0.1178558096,
0.1416771859,
0.547580421,
-0.1608044654,
0.5750597119,
0.309889853,
-0.1901499182,
-0.7730901837,
0.0316993408,
-0.7274330854,
-0.4180568755,
1.4280591011,
-0.0416094139,
-0.1392141879,
-0.0378002524,
-0.3260902166,
0.4779269993,
-0.2304719388,
0.7181221247,
0.8042298555,
0.3188527524,
0.0368779339,
-0.7850567698,
1.0890022516,
0.3162783682,
-1.1265691519,
0.299605757,
0.8186737299,
0.1915564388,
0.1541027427,
0.2181800902,
0.0459524952,
0.0647881106,
0.0415929295,
0.0990171283,
0.0006689939,
-0.2715597749,
-0.4831343591,
0.2395161688,
-0.1995206028,
0.4309274852
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10671v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10671v3
|
Decomposition for Enhancing Attention: Improving LLM-based Text-to-SQL through Workflow Paradigm
| 2024-02-16T13:24:05 | 2024-07-03T04:45:29 |
Yuanzhen Xie, Xinzhou Jin, Tao Xie, MingXiong Lin, Liang Chen, Chenyun Yu, Lei Cheng, ChengXiang Zhuo, Bo Hu, Zang Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In-context learning of large-language models (LLMs) has achieved remarkable
success in the field of natural language processing, while extensive case
studies reveal that the single-step chain-of-thought prompting approach faces
challenges such as attention diffusion and inadequate performance in complex
tasks like text-to-SQL. To improve the contextual learning capabilities of LLMs
in text-to-SQL, a workflow paradigm method is proposed, aiming to enhance the
attention and problem-solving scope of LLMs through decomposition.
Specifically, the information determination module for eliminating redundant
information and the brand-new prompt structure based on problem classification
greatly enhance the model's attention. Additionally, the inclusion of
self-correction and active learning modules greatly expands the problem-solving
scope of LLMs, hence improving the upper limit of LLM-based approaches.
Extensive experiments conducted on three datasets demonstrate that our approach
outperforms other methods by a significant margin. About 2-3 percentage point
improvements compared to the existing baseline on the Spider Dev,
Spider-Realistic, and Bird Dev datasets and new SOTA results on the Spider Test
dataset are achieved. Our code is available on GitHub:
\url{https://github.com/FlyingFeather/DEA-SQL}.
|
[
-0.1109570712,
-0.9445218444,
0.5722854137,
0.1714146286,
-0.3772999346,
0.1370693296,
-0.4555289149,
-0.2561199665,
0.1610251963,
0.7141105533,
-0.736971736,
-0.5093532801,
-0.2826814353,
0.4299165308,
-0.4122031927,
0.7378824949,
-0.0070189969,
-0.0274829995,
-0.3085647821,
0.0307448339,
-0.6459340453,
-0.417455703,
-0.6798512936,
-0.085668765,
0.4876218438,
0.3789325655,
-0.0272713844,
0.8358350992,
0.6716368794,
0.2158161253,
-0.4964687228,
0.2719676495,
-0.6748472452,
0.434152633,
-0.5307341814,
-0.5092341304,
-0.4763484597,
-0.421053499,
0.6760200262,
0.775339663,
-0.291436851,
0.319270283,
0.3173847497,
1.1405888796,
-0.8789902329,
0.2548524737,
-0.5992385149,
0.0269902851,
-0.2094334662,
-0.3499101996,
-0.641767621,
0.1142380908,
0.1434050798,
-0.3633381426,
0.0476098023,
0.1421551108,
0.3916727006,
0.6373093128,
-0.3983964026,
0.1157807335,
-0.7000203133,
0.6038517952,
-0.6814222932,
0.2748741508,
0.0334231853,
0.2198777795,
-0.3454372585,
-0.5626477599,
-0.4685954154,
0.1856283396,
0.161408931,
0.1216954514,
-0.1085447073,
0.0021750745,
0.3299387395,
0.4199525416,
-0.4959929585,
-0.0317201391,
-0.2477466762,
0.0725111663,
0.4561032057,
0.3566925824,
-0.0686604306,
-0.140298605,
-0.3381356299,
0.2194476426,
-0.7540665865,
-0.2158545405,
-0.2857343256,
0.5106139779,
0.103716135,
0.6246353388,
-0.5481500626,
0.9755630493,
0.1692878753,
-0.1776751727,
0.2938484848,
-0.3811430037,
-0.709325254,
-0.2166556716,
0.4572829008,
0.2477787733,
-0.0855407566,
-0.3586571813,
-0.2749430239,
-0.0035092528,
0.3283555508,
-0.7768327594,
0.140877381,
0.3707403541,
-0.5095217228,
-0.2007633001,
-0.4497126043,
-0.6331446767,
-0.5743846297,
-0.6602638364,
0.2303604931,
-0.2390737087,
-0.2063032985,
-0.0693370923,
0.0655914545,
0.1793459803,
0.5511577725,
-0.5843886733,
0.1713677645,
0.6155959964,
0.7927336097,
-0.7607445717,
0.1045182422,
-0.5895726085,
0.4365946949,
-0.3566847146,
0.9855148792,
-0.5116997957,
0.1569482833,
0.0606589057,
0.0099133523,
-0.2777977884,
-0.9187170863,
0.3955236971,
-0.665145576,
0.1862429231,
-0.1056373194,
-0.6867272854,
-0.2777487636,
0.5201852918,
-0.5264856815,
1.0490142107,
0.2184120417,
-0.783126533,
0.279209286,
-1.1171553135,
-0.5499424338,
0.2248515785,
-0.0118329823,
-0.2137511373,
0.0247280411,
0.0874850079,
0.6862131953,
-0.5407886505,
0.2226543128,
-0.1379154027,
-0.3511232436,
0.0836880729,
0.0917168111,
0.6916256547,
0.21050331,
-0.4825700521,
0.3060660064,
-0.9228796959,
-0.1151326522,
0.1433359087,
-0.3983323574,
-0.1301894039,
0.0067305681,
-0.0585439578,
0.203918606,
-0.0013462389,
-0.2352573723,
0.0006481615,
-0.8860982656,
0.4743664265,
0.5973268747,
0.3671497703,
0.7160665393,
0.0015306154,
0.5036239624,
0.3100969791,
-0.0019505168,
-0.176851362,
0.0176110137,
-0.9739766717,
-0.4390206635,
0.1343459338,
0.6226122379,
-0.7729339004,
0.4357081354,
-0.0752282068,
-0.1165261716,
-0.1948412806,
0.2399083823,
0.29953596,
0.8131011724,
0.3456307948,
-0.3719978333,
-0.6280280352,
-0.6862716675,
-0.2942784727,
0.1224602461,
-0.064532198,
0.2196248025,
0.4166385233,
-0.3720546365,
0.8978142142,
-0.5605860949,
-0.7816051245,
-0.4043767154,
-0.212652266,
0.2680251002,
0.1494995356,
0.0770766735,
-0.6794261336,
-0.5278964043,
-0.3043292761,
-0.5424564481,
0.1204265505,
0.1791924089,
-0.2689597011,
0.6593310833,
0.4444308877,
-0.541136086,
0.4734988809,
-0.047092706,
-0.2893063128,
0.3397214711,
0.1123192459,
-0.1211366951,
-1.15893507,
0.2384987622,
0.0304450914,
-0.1449339986,
-0.6338695288,
0.0516809821,
0.0487676449,
-0.0641947463,
-0.4859620333,
0.4459747672,
-0.7143287063,
-0.1189536527,
-0.3802401125,
0.3916978538,
-0.2841069698,
0.7378908992,
0.1247620955,
0.7403227687,
0.7983952761,
-0.9139629006,
0.2879231274,
0.1800828576,
-0.2747426629,
0.7084536552,
-0.2786663771,
0.1110694036,
-0.3386714458,
0.1673650593,
-1.1358804703,
-0.347020179,
0.4646134675,
-0.2512505352,
0.4066348374,
-0.135212332,
-0.6328089833,
-0.022586016,
-0.3630048335,
0.101839669,
0.3804560006,
-0.4280109704,
0.6972306967,
0.4891813695,
-0.1219285652,
-0.5618337989,
-0.638856709,
0.2319308817,
-0.3249358535,
-0.3309161365,
0.3832157254,
-0.0881634876,
-0.3370252848,
-0.1793181747,
-0.240169391,
-0.2159440964,
-0.042772498,
0.0198817533,
0.1910280734,
0.0884399638,
0.434684366,
-0.1742279232,
-0.179911837,
0.188196674,
-0.4137994647,
0.3547392488,
0.3350133896,
0.2112123221,
-0.4130100608,
0.3306133747,
0.4986742437,
-0.4930890501,
0.7288339734,
0.433588177,
-0.4846464396,
-0.6827901006,
-0.4480193853,
-0.3011889458,
-0.420575738,
0.3802499473,
-0.0534536541,
-0.9030870199,
0.2337632477,
-0.3583560586,
0.1276696622,
0.1941514909,
0.8025238514,
-0.2300638855,
0.7562944889,
0.899269104,
-0.0202431101,
0.7043590546,
-0.3175184429,
0.248556748,
-1.1888107061,
-0.3790948987,
-0.4604617953,
-0.025693031,
-0.094553411,
-0.7204006314,
0.3250340819,
-0.2193450034,
-0.226744473,
0.1687756628,
-0.8404151797,
0.4541441798,
-0.0267360732,
0.2934448123,
0.3508623242,
0.1890889853,
-0.0474134199,
-0.0063193347,
-0.7476024628,
-0.4126723707,
1.1401048899,
0.1763072461,
0.652205348,
0.1059212461,
0.7888637185,
0.3280850947,
0.4150604606,
-0.9457399845,
0.7418177128,
0.1199961379,
-0.4302430451,
-0.4370286465,
-0.463566035,
-0.8578796387,
0.3765968084,
0.0410423279,
-0.9172020555,
-0.0481718145,
0.1822916269,
-0.1258504689,
-0.0609878637,
-0.64153862,
0.848666966,
0.2052099407,
-0.7723124623,
-0.291721493,
-0.5755103827,
0.3261329234,
-0.0531718619,
0.2217457443,
-0.0938100144,
-0.3829005659,
0.914429009,
-0.5177708864,
0.9140049219,
-0.1703782082,
-0.4836850166,
0.3475398719,
-0.0923908427,
0.7207663059,
0.0153808445,
-0.0942189619,
-0.2547041178,
-0.3648945987,
-0.1390549093,
-0.6089955568,
0.4125856757,
-0.1523484439,
-0.6463465691,
-0.2928991616,
-0.6134718657,
-0.3717273176,
0.2478758544,
-0.0524217151,
0.3887344897,
0.1378801912,
0.1937133968,
0.9467683434,
0.355494529,
0.761048317,
0.6512741446,
-0.0883751214,
-0.3827323616,
0.4660303891,
0.1360969543,
0.0712948665,
0.7311494946,
-0.1589558274,
-0.5529817343,
-0.7344589233,
-0.2100268155,
0.2689887583,
-0.9174541235,
-0.4758571982,
-0.726536274,
0.0847939774,
-0.2225340307,
0.2584567368,
-0.0843911543,
-0.1753477901,
-0.5212062597,
0.1957454979,
0.2812387049,
0.3814702034,
0.5291637182,
0.1095915139,
-0.4596409798,
0.2701622546,
0.0808111802,
0.3833512366,
0.2062433809,
-0.71883744,
-0.3849572241,
-0.2936134636,
-0.2116181403,
-0.9774335623,
0.3467718959,
0.1540131718,
0.4487871528,
0.066369459,
0.2178410292,
0.7458029389,
-0.3493000567,
0.4812413156,
-0.022620488,
-1.030077219,
0.7467861772,
-0.2671902478,
0.4382764399,
0.5347913504,
0.0942896754,
-0.1455164701,
-0.4984094203,
-0.4667387903,
-0.8536694646,
0.9894769192,
0.2948901355,
-0.25791803,
0.2038960308,
0.5823355317,
-0.2234275788,
0.2887131274,
-0.8053417206,
-0.2750476897,
0.4618372321,
-0.1761432141,
-0.0764875039,
-0.3461612761,
-0.0543411672,
-0.355730176,
0.5978887677,
-0.3810870647,
0.3463414013,
0.2400248349,
-0.3869245946,
-0.0681899413,
0.428032726,
0.3766153753,
0.9399639964,
-0.0501353852,
0.1479584873,
0.4222100973,
-0.2818483114,
0.1188756898,
-0.2672421038,
-0.1007049307,
-0.2078219801,
0.273876816,
0.4601967931,
0.1611092836,
-0.8322723508,
0.4207045734,
-0.0384477638,
-0.1231560633,
-0.1487129033,
0.4053344131,
0.2683805525,
0.3891468048,
0.4798522592,
0.0895391032,
0.5716619492,
-0.5506818295,
0.0410225913,
0.2551438212,
-0.3073112667,
-0.0148493825,
0.4204896092,
0.2975939512,
-0.3445079327,
0.1856687367,
-0.2271194756,
-0.4344108403,
0.5761331916,
0.8053476214,
0.9649808407,
-0.1232977435,
-0.0970041081,
0.4073618054,
0.1708944142,
0.0063786171,
0.6131153107,
-0.4636237025,
-0.3011861145,
-0.6548501253,
-0.4301932752,
-0.3971680105,
0.060122408,
-0.438555479,
0.2661523819,
-0.3967246711,
-0.1206454709,
-0.051156912,
0.0312949419,
-0.4241051972,
0.2531560957,
-0.0808437094,
0.8647375107,
-0.4758919775,
0.7277154326,
0.9671546817,
-0.2629008293,
-0.5762052536,
0.3855673671,
-0.2112291902,
-0.2484330684,
0.7645545006,
0.347091198,
-0.1468499899,
0.1364844441,
-0.4901669025,
-0.9222899675,
1.0033518076,
0.4646435678,
-0.6480116844,
0.2349415123,
-0.0574865341,
0.6276404262,
-0.6024742126,
0.1330147684,
0.5788844228,
0.358610779,
0.1374583691,
-0.6747692823,
0.2828730643,
-0.0801573843,
0.2557619214,
0.3235932887,
-0.6474594474,
0.482986331,
-0.3358978629,
-0.4775444865,
-0.431335777,
0.591150403,
0.1125118211,
0.1907452792,
0.5229465365,
0.3922926486,
0.6852176189,
0.0402090736,
0.5535841584,
-0.1732570678,
0.3368287683,
1.0518945456,
-0.5729647875,
1.0731818676,
0.7201020122,
-0.1158161685,
0.5389267802,
0.6051096916,
0.2146860361,
0.656719327,
0.3613052368,
-0.1393439323,
-0.2156472504,
-0.2046001554,
0.0230717976,
0.3672788739,
0.3510198593,
-0.2740758657,
-0.2424388379,
0.1693867892,
-0.0758608058,
0.1325210631,
-0.3862254322,
1.244833827,
-0.0629177392,
-0.7642296553,
0.9892093539,
-0.0494675487,
0.5763220191,
-0.2163004279,
-0.1384821087,
-0.2545192838,
0.5076180696,
-0.4460947812,
-0.5608713031,
0.3526020348,
0.2066603899,
-0.5027427673,
-0.1973626316,
0.7698524594,
-0.5823941231,
-0.1190702915,
0.3533253372,
0.3078867495,
0.032457877,
-0.2627524436,
-0.5875939131,
0.1818207651,
0.0348911099,
-0.2961655259,
0.2270948142,
0.4645557106,
0.0220061801,
0.8267912865,
0.4336912036,
-0.171873793,
-0.2998026013,
0.0779015869,
0.9648609161,
-0.7213302255,
-0.6751226783,
-0.9851433039,
0.5775129199,
-0.3071472049,
-0.0146261808,
0.6401904225,
0.7738522887,
0.5885048509,
-0.2232833952,
0.5504587889,
-0.0580662079,
0.7632752657,
-0.4842139184,
0.5018330812,
-0.6352685094,
0.4273674488,
-0.343680948,
-1.0548735857,
-0.4740099907,
0.393887043,
-0.064416565,
0.0515755862,
1.0664488077,
0.8004556298,
0.2908560336,
-0.2904593647,
0.1088582277,
0.1750602871,
0.0418471135,
0.7486574054,
0.76132828,
-0.348562479,
0.5140803456,
-0.0632351637,
-0.4449476302,
-0.4528006315,
-0.8412026763,
-1.2630348206,
-0.6163880825,
-0.5419213772,
-0.1935110837,
0.0718618035,
0.9019932151,
0.7036964297,
-0.5573709011,
-0.2583482862,
-0.2302244455,
0.2461210489,
-0.4096289873,
-0.2582847774,
0.5030376911,
-0.9285353422,
-0.556219101,
0.4021522105,
0.8551958203,
-0.2195366621,
-0.1577718109,
0.0842454508,
-0.196428135,
0.0351000987,
1.0202126503,
-0.1316095591,
-0.6173447371,
0.1935601383,
0.1387906373,
-0.1517575532,
0.2652518153,
0.691470325,
-0.8559665084,
0.3222035766,
0.576983273,
0.6663511992,
0.5666704178,
-0.1179827973,
0.4399122,
-0.7816755176,
0.1141236797,
0.3793743551,
0.2748011053,
0.2148721069,
-0.6552816033,
0.8335599899,
0.2420030236,
-0.2499613166,
-0.9902804494,
0.057812497,
-1.0774497986,
-0.1366066486,
1.198107481,
0.0868819579,
-0.7021002769,
-0.2400165349,
-0.3327557147,
0.3043221533,
-0.3634603322,
0.871907413,
0.4062995315,
-0.2574094236,
-0.2992676198,
-0.2785104215,
0.634636879,
0.6242209673,
-1.3763939142,
0.7166148424,
0.5235958099,
0.333255887,
0.0117384223,
0.6268475056,
-0.2591120005,
0.3096017241,
-0.450647682,
0.0067131249,
-0.0539032668,
-0.4699080586,
-0.4660156071,
0.2112717927,
-0.0339530706,
-0.1747530401
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10670v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10670v2
|
OpenFMNav: Towards Open-Set Zero-Shot Object Navigation via Vision-Language Foundation Models
| 2024-02-16T13:21:33 | 2024-03-25T02:52:43 |
Yuxuan Kuang, Hai Lin, Meng Jiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.RO
|
Object navigation (ObjectNav) requires an agent to navigate through unseen
environments to find queried objects. Many previous methods attempted to solve
this task by relying on supervised or reinforcement learning, where they are
trained on limited household datasets with close-set objects. However, two key
challenges are unsolved: understanding free-form natural language instructions
that demand open-set objects, and generalizing to new environments in a
zero-shot manner. Aiming to solve the two challenges, in this paper, we propose
OpenFMNav, an Open-set Foundation Model based framework for zero-shot object
Navigation. We first unleash the reasoning abilities of large language models
(LLMs) to extract proposed objects from natural language instructions that meet
the user's demand. We then leverage the generalizability of large vision
language models (VLMs) to actively discover and detect candidate objects from
the scene, building a Versatile Semantic Score Map (VSSM). Then, by conducting
common sense reasoning on VSSM, our method can perform effective
language-guided exploration and exploitation of the scene and finally reach the
goal. By leveraging the reasoning and generalizing abilities of foundation
models, our method can understand free-form human instructions and perform
effective open-set zero-shot navigation in diverse environments. Extensive
experiments on the HM3D ObjectNav benchmark show that our method surpasses all
the strong baselines on all metrics, proving our method's effectiveness.
Furthermore, we perform real robot demonstrations to validate our method's
open-set-ness and generalizability to real-world environments.
|
[
-0.260679096,
-0.7888751626,
0.5585012436,
-0.2644122839,
-0.3335253596,
-0.1478996873,
-0.326166749,
-0.2546968162,
-0.1179853454,
0.8213651776,
-0.6461465955,
-1.047440052,
-0.2782473266,
-0.3824005425,
-0.2043480277,
0.5392976999,
-0.2314903438,
-0.3817515671,
-0.3743044436,
-0.3495115042,
-0.4435508847,
-0.3299102783,
0.0244145934,
-0.1787740439,
0.3999761045,
0.6997737885,
0.8802525401,
0.8689774871,
0.5850573182,
0.0912550911,
0.0358236954,
0.1201918349,
-0.5994229317,
0.1172845364,
-0.5270318389,
-0.4883143008,
-0.0825992748,
-0.1862176061,
0.3527998328,
0.7220551968,
-0.1569185108,
0.1808501631,
-0.3933135271,
0.6843506098,
-0.9852693081,
0.3511988819,
-0.3782767355,
0.4099233449,
-0.1008395255,
-0.1931000352,
-0.3147597909,
0.0374794044,
0.2268774509,
-0.8041426539,
0.109877266,
0.0272523239,
0.9026537538,
0.4186849594,
-0.3265742064,
0.0275007673,
-0.9580105543,
1.053745389,
-0.3428456485,
0.5218735933,
0.1894940287,
0.6801837683,
-0.3709038496,
-0.3563828468,
-0.3491977751,
-0.3795598745,
0.3342932761,
-0.0358328484,
-0.1790456176,
0.0326374359,
0.0118059246,
0.189809382,
-0.6473841071,
-0.0980103686,
-0.2112920731,
0.0590784475,
0.3597869575,
0.0545033589,
0.3251539767,
0.1822681874,
-0.5546377897,
-0.2419113964,
-0.7790027261,
0.4030613601,
0.0329628699,
0.6776386499,
0.0071650073,
1.0257285833,
-0.9019591212,
1.2270805836,
-0.4378727078,
-0.0067456858,
0.1793920994,
-0.2494741827,
-0.4486792088,
0.1085517928,
0.4187210798,
0.5788017511,
0.7247031927,
-0.3434188068,
-0.2113379538,
0.0863015428,
0.2564415932,
-0.6796646714,
-0.0874304175,
0.2397107035,
-0.3627457023,
-0.42405954,
0.2139492631,
-0.5351442099,
-0.2464869767,
-0.3230240941,
0.5920351148,
-0.2515058517,
-0.4293848574,
0.7395372987,
-0.1029343009,
0.5290269852,
0.552716136,
-0.5103839636,
0.1101509854,
0.6006551981,
0.7851605415,
0.1830655187,
-0.1068344116,
-0.8992782831,
0.3123807907,
-0.5945400596,
0.6974993944,
-0.7931265831,
-0.4172556102,
-0.0314823948,
-0.1209576949,
0.0876530483,
-0.3003742993,
0.0499365367,
-0.1147488579,
0.1465086043,
-0.0182346236,
-0.106069915,
-0.6024744511,
0.6682220697,
-0.2895703912,
0.8798643351,
0.1135358289,
-0.1066196933,
0.2848127484,
-0.9846113324,
-0.4597584605,
-0.0930419341,
-0.2948273718,
-0.0289675314,
0.1640004367,
0.3844742179,
0.6191952229,
-0.1309271455,
0.0321184583,
-0.3267789185,
-0.5622241497,
-0.1767759919,
-0.1591351777,
0.6658361554,
-0.0867500231,
-0.4598350823,
0.1920319498,
-0.574541986,
-0.1032048389,
0.3840431273,
-0.319506377,
-0.3237980008,
0.2867534459,
-0.3714431226,
0.3140937388,
0.0306329448,
-0.7574878335,
0.3489980698,
-0.6475255489,
-0.146971941,
0.4545595348,
0.1685052365,
0.6597169042,
-0.1677875072,
0.6058598757,
0.1788209677,
0.2778030336,
-0.5701603293,
-0.8596591353,
-0.7134516239,
-0.084285669,
-0.1178613678,
0.554028213,
-0.8665438294,
0.1696472317,
-0.2003088742,
-0.3475699127,
-0.4312368333,
0.0674765408,
0.6090034246,
0.7625681758,
0.6427150369,
-0.1857939959,
-0.2554478347,
-0.5584446788,
0.1002576128,
-0.0178994611,
-0.2033821642,
0.5060543418,
0.6013442874,
0.0678989887,
1.1075825691,
-0.7275214195,
-0.6301971674,
0.0024972747,
-0.2673541009,
0.0174355172,
0.422344774,
0.5457749367,
-0.8350476027,
-0.0000416767,
0.3180991113,
-1.153717041,
0.3032315671,
0.0933998451,
-0.4385280311,
0.1390213668,
0.4996618629,
-0.4748629928,
0.9835186005,
0.0975072607,
-0.3717247844,
0.1552537084,
-0.0123301884,
0.0273677129,
-0.6772635579,
0.1439848095,
0.0777192712,
-0.21992293,
-0.6857386827,
0.5976436734,
-0.2753634751,
-0.2098133266,
-0.9678411484,
0.6686590314,
-0.5322346091,
-0.3309734762,
-0.1278406531,
0.3970188797,
-0.0141507089,
0.8480243683,
0.280805856,
0.1875264794,
0.7558481693,
-0.6399071813,
0.3572512269,
0.2542244792,
-0.3089583516,
0.6898061633,
-0.3084504008,
-0.034424115,
-0.408282578,
0.2097762078,
-0.6983986497,
-0.0073628239,
0.650524199,
-0.488942802,
-0.0550839528,
-0.377583921,
-0.2651907206,
-0.2133553177,
-0.134561643,
0.0238025207,
0.3705155849,
-0.5665801167,
0.7702299953,
0.0731747299,
0.4987415075,
-1.0121459961,
-0.6201912165,
-0.0406372137,
0.3558146954,
-0.5787249804,
-0.1185996309,
-0.0995510593,
-0.2186868191,
0.1641424149,
-0.5179374814,
0.0361925624,
0.3492590785,
0.543638587,
0.4221138358,
-0.6004591584,
0.0117038814,
-0.297906667,
-0.1475463808,
-0.1842175126,
-0.5811889768,
0.5164074898,
-0.3607747257,
-0.6600004435,
0.0582358167,
0.176368475,
0.3966446817,
-0.7069257498,
0.5180495977,
0.2480097115,
-0.5453228354,
-0.269113481,
-0.0683635548,
0.0649778619,
-0.4052047729,
0.2045273185,
-0.6029937267,
-0.8814215064,
0.1250050217,
-0.1424960047,
0.4278611839,
0.0826432705,
0.4459282756,
-0.0543666966,
0.8288064599,
0.6653928161,
0.3120566308,
0.2279057503,
-0.5604906082,
0.1385129541,
-0.5590907931,
-0.729655087,
-0.4536860287,
-0.4788572788,
0.2792470753,
-0.9853861332,
0.0834231675,
0.3440905213,
-0.1846821606,
0.3616092205,
-0.6054205894,
0.9040676355,
0.5148056149,
0.2899827957,
0.415001452,
0.0148386722,
-0.5663012862,
0.3835155368,
-0.5862408876,
-0.3403885961,
1.2163813114,
0.0999109522,
0.4821840525,
0.2020382732,
0.7203112245,
0.1414518952,
0.1845694333,
-1.1107703447,
0.8899552822,
-0.0329694897,
-0.6844960451,
-0.5335398316,
-0.2665337026,
-0.7975780368,
0.4982575178,
-0.1288393438,
-0.8274050951,
0.2246297002,
0.1046146527,
-0.1640659422,
0.5252088904,
-0.3554004431,
1.1117274761,
-0.2064355016,
-0.2059463859,
0.0140518732,
-0.8231552243,
0.5221511722,
0.1995836496,
-0.0669446364,
-0.485809356,
-0.2940015793,
0.1885094643,
-0.3391734958,
0.7340739369,
-0.5807888508,
0.0070984131,
0.3954802752,
0.4708305299,
0.1563831568,
-0.2452261746,
0.1869035959,
0.362313211,
-0.3941901326,
-0.4368490577,
-0.5728709102,
0.5845733285,
-0.3907034099,
-0.3062855601,
-0.3454209864,
-0.2527243197,
-0.2151940614,
0.2565253675,
-0.0697614178,
0.3888111413,
-0.4716513753,
0.444344759,
0.8006147146,
-0.2595928609,
0.5055319071,
0.8327999711,
-0.6989290714,
0.1799681932,
1.0625011921,
-0.0870470405,
0.0883237496,
0.8118047714,
0.1094897613,
-0.1868568361,
-0.4847170115,
-0.8998683095,
-0.1041382104,
-0.6174489856,
-0.4017936587,
-0.3531391025,
-0.0706255212,
0.0022384503,
-0.4558677971,
-0.4184683561,
-0.3692851961,
-0.4437755346,
-0.0898408368,
0.2016067654,
0.3773017824,
-0.0041790851,
0.1548749655,
-0.5521175265,
0.6814851165,
0.1796066463,
0.5821222067,
-0.0102811363,
-0.1809854358,
-0.1221219674,
0.2874602079,
0.0602410957,
-0.6178063154,
0.0343833864,
0.0587145165,
0.6611036658,
0.6754366159,
0.2914907336,
0.4976509809,
-0.4035159647,
0.6379558444,
0.2006701082,
-0.699948132,
0.8619837165,
-0.4981613457,
0.5348619223,
0.3877813816,
0.3424646556,
-0.4158318937,
-0.1514434218,
-0.2441216409,
-0.5939009786,
0.8311335444,
0.2571717501,
-0.268180877,
0.0791253299,
0.1919330359,
-0.2406801879,
0.3570427597,
-0.4083330929,
0.0376908146,
-0.4893764555,
-0.2489150465,
-0.1475673914,
0.3397122324,
-0.2488375753,
-0.0230499431,
0.4001515806,
-0.4478579164,
0.1337421983,
0.1776638627,
-0.4077816606,
-0.4091368914,
0.0308629237,
0.8841184378,
0.3271102607,
-0.6428461075,
-0.1685409397,
-0.2938593328,
-0.1800962389,
0.2308281362,
-0.0569379963,
-0.2588767111,
-0.0329008885,
0.1107985824,
0.7879309654,
0.5468636155,
-0.932772398,
0.9134696126,
0.1861290485,
-0.4884988666,
-0.087381199,
0.4134604931,
-0.0007352632,
0.2356334329,
0.1841404289,
0.4781502783,
-0.1517531127,
-0.51964432,
0.2229872793,
0.4630268216,
-0.6906252503,
-0.0848031119,
0.6964190006,
0.1852567792,
-0.46560359,
0.5383701324,
-0.0484646782,
-0.1231207773,
0.7504700422,
0.1814154088,
0.8204324841,
-0.2448144704,
0.4780655801,
0.1114166752,
0.5153890848,
-0.3808961511,
0.4024432003,
-0.3594568372,
-0.7563726306,
-0.3536891639,
-0.7161744833,
-0.6505826712,
-0.2013707161,
-0.574518919,
0.1711865515,
-0.7177954316,
0.3432591259,
-0.3447153866,
-0.465863198,
-0.7413491607,
0.2920999229,
0.2435607463,
1.1185133457,
-0.4418932498,
0.8013754487,
0.8137814999,
-0.6002831459,
-0.4287603199,
-0.1059611291,
0.277066201,
-1.0386698246,
0.4119603038,
0.4992421865,
-0.5696527958,
0.024811646,
-0.6693991423,
-0.8068904877,
1.1111609936,
0.2017886341,
-0.3919994831,
-0.2457975894,
0.1488762945,
0.3274897039,
-0.6477815509,
-0.1181643903,
0.2939324379,
0.4859378934,
0.4358351231,
-0.500854969,
-0.0595960841,
-0.0323751047,
-0.0361819528,
0.4684505761,
-0.377768755,
0.5946698189,
-0.5681937337,
-0.144109413,
0.0745050833,
0.457044065,
0.1169116572,
0.4464706481,
0.5335633755,
0.7398828268,
0.3575570881,
-0.1199967638,
0.8101343513,
-0.0138177434,
0.1240550503,
1.1821967363,
-0.5466639996,
1.1742035151,
0.288770169,
0.3570529819,
0.5697245002,
0.0855436251,
-0.0415424332,
0.6653425097,
0.3649359047,
-0.268383801,
-0.3801516891,
-0.1300508827,
-0.0540268794,
0.8403625488,
0.3093276918,
-0.1367711425,
-0.6630183458,
0.4382070303,
-0.1902250946,
0.1634286344,
-0.4348535538,
0.5990710258,
-0.1652387232,
-0.5215798616,
0.4429537952,
0.1465902776,
0.3113358617,
-0.6109952331,
-0.3831242621,
-0.1684786975,
0.1927840561,
0.0003866718,
-0.872423172,
0.1665920019,
0.0674301982,
0.0351256505,
-0.2076041102,
0.8341429234,
-0.2926746011,
-0.253720969,
0.3256109953,
0.6903493404,
0.2156736851,
-0.4604125321,
-0.3992171586,
-0.1979717016,
0.1679926515,
-0.3196624815,
0.3342145383,
0.180261299,
-0.1315934956,
0.9633378386,
0.8873214126,
-0.2210119665,
0.0045627281,
-0.2047584802,
0.7326526046,
-0.8079876304,
-0.3254909813,
-0.5480655432,
0.7106685638,
0.1576164812,
-0.1971079558,
0.3100339472,
0.5760585666,
1.1349657774,
-0.2149399966,
0.4193241596,
0.2508795559,
0.3561191857,
-0.5867568851,
0.5621026754,
-0.694141984,
0.0380853377,
-0.0030758758,
-1.0361565351,
-0.6549648643,
0.8360753655,
-0.0674335137,
-0.2479723841,
0.3158163428,
0.8720296025,
-0.3980274796,
-0.2750251889,
0.6732908487,
-0.0878655314,
0.2405569851,
0.7442767024,
0.6335631013,
-0.1230645329,
1.0811064243,
-0.2435311973,
-0.2368343025,
-0.4622496665,
-0.8852672577,
-0.930629611,
-0.1726686954,
-0.2376087159,
-0.0936294869,
0.2440769523,
0.7279648185,
0.8028664589,
-0.4988184571,
-0.2720479071,
-0.2141780853,
0.2003613114,
-0.3273093104,
-0.2313438505,
-0.135664925,
0.1275121123,
-0.3886544704,
0.983068943,
0.7676279545,
0.1699763834,
-0.4810674489,
-0.3188281953,
-0.4840123951,
0.2253576219,
0.5125874281,
0.8262090683,
-0.8376935124,
-0.4096178114,
0.1526226401,
0.1313779801,
0.2842315137,
0.6906016469,
-1.3019214869,
0.8840007782,
0.2528739572,
0.5463915467,
0.4944161475,
-0.1317941695,
0.5407108068,
-0.9962791204,
0.322930932,
0.180279091,
0.2774177492,
0.2661462128,
-0.0221119616,
0.835830152,
0.2099490762,
-0.0788911358,
-0.7860844731,
0.4094873965,
-1.166867137,
-0.5115998983,
0.7645817995,
-0.2506936491,
-0.4599330425,
-0.0627840012,
-0.2322856486,
0.041568201,
-0.4557685554,
0.242852658,
0.3710629642,
0.0203191228,
-0.2785619199,
-0.5860031247,
0.0834583417,
-0.0160642192,
-0.6633998156,
-0.1322649866,
0.6849017739,
0.1168801412,
0.1796912998,
0.5230305195,
0.0061409287,
0.4779495597,
-0.0241907593,
0.1017362103,
-0.7276569605,
-0.8581125736,
-0.3702165484,
0.4625935256,
-0.3514828086,
-0.7781582475
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10669v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10669v4
|
Humans or LLMs as the Judge? A Study on Judgement Biases
| 2024-02-16T13:21:06 | 2024-06-16T12:30:34 |
Guiming Hardy Chen, Shunian Chen, Ziche Liu, Feng Jiang, Benyou Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Adopting human and large language models (LLM) as judges (a.k.a human- and
LLM-as-a-judge) for evaluating the performance of LLMs has recently gained
attention. Nonetheless, this approach concurrently introduces potential biases
from human and LLMs, questioning the reliability of the evaluation results. In
this paper, we propose a novel framework that is free from referencing
groundtruth annotations for investigating Misinformation Oversight Bias, Gender
Bias, Authority Bias and Beauty Bias on LLM and human judges. We curate a
dataset referring to the revised Bloom's Taxonomy and conduct thousands of
evaluations. Results show that human and LLM judges are vulnerable to
perturbations to various degrees, and that even the cutting-edge judges possess
considerable biases. We further exploit these biases to conduct attacks on LLM
judges. We hope that our work can notify the community of the bias and
vulnerability of human- and LLM-as-a-judge, as well as the urgency of
developing robust evaluation systems.
|
[
-0.2685921192,
-0.3209910095,
0.5590820312,
0.1949168444,
0.0162987281,
-0.0129531026,
-0.2942123413,
-0.5734586716,
0.0093672061,
0.734485507,
-0.4776816964,
-0.4362431765,
-0.6577920914,
0.1724830121,
-0.3424688578,
0.8682549596,
0.3697005212,
0.5351880193,
-0.3861373365,
-0.1380266547,
-0.3830940425,
-0.7409830689,
-0.0634769127,
-0.4122091532,
0.6954445243,
0.4075556397,
0.8562235236,
0.1376204193,
0.7424662113,
0.0950302631,
-0.2562462986,
-0.1014533266,
-0.3230481744,
-0.1014934033,
-0.730294764,
-0.7551136613,
-0.4513306022,
0.516050756,
0.2694516182,
0.7390683889,
-0.110791795,
0.3648495078,
-0.1413679123,
0.761420846,
-0.8905928135,
-0.185528174,
-0.802867651,
0.2186724544,
-0.3361011147,
-0.1851611584,
-0.5335581303,
-0.3094055653,
0.0463279821,
-0.2973581254,
0.1693463326,
0.2054540813,
0.7340622544,
0.2272007316,
-0.4212608039,
-0.0946958661,
-0.6238597631,
0.819052279,
-0.5522673726,
0.3010047078,
0.4634864628,
0.4207214713,
-0.1083300039,
-0.2909261584,
-0.4953145683,
-0.4495506883,
-0.2327083051,
0.1567281187,
-0.0865226015,
-0.1274358183,
0.2686541677,
0.4660539627,
-0.1684466898,
0.3026151359,
0.0345627107,
-0.1917746514,
0.8576828837,
-0.0003098224,
0.1922407597,
-0.517133832,
-0.442158103,
-0.0470163822,
-0.7759987116,
-0.3201728165,
0.5613369346,
0.543412149,
0.1255801022,
0.5060399175,
-0.055198133,
0.3866832256,
-0.1197793111,
-0.0690014958,
0.0758368745,
-0.0105499811,
-0.2207897305,
-0.2900174558,
0.8181080818,
0.7037368417,
0.425780654,
-0.4002628922,
-0.3132815659,
0.3279485703,
0.5580773354,
-0.4190559685,
0.1974220276,
-0.0626744851,
-0.528871417,
-0.8443226814,
0.4343831837,
-1.2431858778,
-0.9028912783,
-0.1934881657,
0.5063604712,
0.0244468842,
-0.2357386947,
-0.0867484286,
-0.0699399859,
0.3829367757,
0.4215904474,
-0.7267748713,
0.5484387875,
0.6189926863,
0.3406408429,
-0.2123213708,
-0.2967490256,
-0.46597296,
-0.1197783053,
-0.2849617898,
0.6304502487,
-0.5663616061,
-0.5585206747,
0.0074013839,
-0.2237136364,
0.0986822397,
-0.6592668891,
1.036237359,
-0.6945711374,
0.0799949467,
-0.6188010573,
-0.2819207013,
-0.0274420213,
0.2440792769,
-0.6012917161,
0.8209995031,
0.0345238,
-1.0116895437,
0.776426971,
-0.7960851789,
-0.2339323908,
-0.0431779139,
-0.4968534112,
-0.3520806432,
0.0837934911,
0.4677760601,
0.1688941419,
-0.3850643337,
0.4288048744,
-0.5079408884,
-0.4037341475,
0.2664960027,
-0.5459641814,
0.7281323075,
0.2296916097,
-0.4914302528,
0.2963755429,
-0.7063904405,
-0.2733469009,
0.1898293048,
-0.3830736876,
-0.1046037376,
0.3161990345,
0.3133991659,
0.1051851958,
-0.198214978,
-0.3109287322,
0.0796687156,
-0.2164194733,
0.4641951323,
1.0670540333,
-0.0598897226,
0.3897716701,
-0.5072614551,
0.4150259495,
-0.0686380789,
0.1962817013,
-0.1495163888,
-0.2752175629,
-0.7205256224,
0.0360509939,
0.4385772645,
0.502402842,
-0.196060285,
0.384062916,
-0.419403553,
-0.6166267991,
-0.4936668873,
0.1502675712,
0.2804914117,
0.3623200059,
0.1249083951,
-0.5623064041,
-0.4048801959,
-1.1103715897,
-1.0107117891,
-0.4016161561,
-0.0757252723,
0.480237633,
0.6800406575,
-0.3469767272,
1.3205180168,
-0.000131363,
-0.1835950315,
0.0986121893,
-0.0261960868,
0.0792630985,
0.4313009679,
0.7333420515,
-0.8041085005,
0.1901893467,
-0.3156064749,
-0.6709380746,
-0.3091354072,
0.1171331853,
-0.4025535882,
0.0473717824,
0.1284077466,
-0.5416874886,
0.5983991623,
0.09984456,
-0.577139318,
1.0191550255,
0.3468774557,
0.224028632,
-0.6086350679,
0.139581725,
0.1976972967,
-0.3506430686,
-0.3926745057,
0.4115081131,
-0.0460785776,
0.2677439153,
-0.3620319366,
0.5023441911,
-0.2511775792,
-0.3391246498,
-0.1129892915,
0.1784086078,
0.0319725163,
0.2113023549,
-0.1055177301,
0.4960037768,
0.2577110231,
-0.5438289642,
0.285322845,
0.2663691044,
-0.3870385587,
0.8680114746,
-0.1708606184,
0.3860092163,
-0.1284532547,
0.3306079507,
-0.6316254139,
-0.4219223261,
0.4126134515,
-0.3661291301,
0.1600607187,
-0.2892268002,
-0.7614971399,
-0.587508142,
-0.4857128263,
0.0926905721,
0.2380333394,
-0.6781124473,
0.5631816387,
0.3314634264,
0.1801230758,
-0.6147716045,
-0.7895317674,
0.4826351106,
-0.5133731365,
-0.6873847842,
0.1508638412,
0.0149815902,
-0.8832496405,
-0.2832678258,
-0.1042716652,
0.1825060397,
0.3819163144,
0.3894444704,
0.0703616813,
-0.0101827169,
0.1480511278,
-0.4872114062,
0.2060552537,
0.3095237017,
-0.0807277933,
0.2835687101,
-0.158863619,
-0.8282152414,
-0.4426266849,
0.0864845738,
0.7101529241,
-0.147796616,
0.4045805633,
0.2255999595,
-0.3455233276,
-0.003756331,
-0.9454366565,
-0.2875396311,
-0.3628226519,
0.3508857489,
-0.1894445121,
-0.7211300135,
0.2503341436,
0.0142696593,
0.1932062656,
0.609844923,
0.8183783889,
-0.0367161073,
0.5266465545,
0.6841595769,
-0.4914706051,
0.3999461532,
0.1036216095,
-0.1810343564,
-0.7073744535,
-0.2094118893,
-0.5721401572,
-0.4235154986,
-0.4480076432,
-0.5012462139,
0.0066185696,
0.1471757293,
-0.3184525669,
-0.1446197033,
-0.3400115371,
0.338075906,
0.5223547816,
0.1818366498,
0.5392586589,
-0.0423779786,
-0.3358778656,
-0.1292472035,
-0.3694798052,
-1.193793416,
1.4120577574,
0.6058060527,
0.8519585729,
0.1818711758,
0.4033989906,
0.6569771171,
0.6475654244,
-0.6544232368,
0.4106579423,
0.1858129948,
-0.8592250347,
-0.0009059805,
-0.308848083,
-0.4145872295,
0.7225777507,
-0.1880684942,
-0.9440587759,
0.34303087,
-0.0164882801,
-0.2652567029,
0.4771315455,
-0.5630272627,
0.5814808011,
-0.6198884249,
-0.5586229563,
-0.1504221559,
-0.7615104318,
0.4908077717,
-0.0465500653,
0.6442946196,
-0.2622484267,
0.1947896332,
0.8353541493,
-0.3934155107,
1.0410399437,
-0.3188599348,
-0.2336424738,
0.0997567549,
0.1115866378,
0.2842520773,
0.2353695482,
-0.278958708,
0.1464474201,
-0.27952829,
-0.2248922586,
-0.4557417929,
0.4275389314,
-0.84379673,
-0.7340629697,
-0.6249832511,
-0.2083686739,
-0.6126686335,
-0.0230443124,
-0.0199051294,
-0.1690645963,
-0.3893903494,
-0.3114716709,
0.21865049,
-0.0763656944,
0.134770155,
0.7001954317,
-0.4904823005,
-0.4166288972,
0.3724011183,
-0.1557794809,
0.117640011,
0.1919586211,
0.1396463662,
0.0230054483,
-0.401559025,
-0.3467077017,
0.1394325346,
-0.7028885484,
-0.0136022149,
-0.3008060753,
-0.0809627473,
-0.1792848259,
0.1541886032,
-0.2609112263,
-0.1757147163,
-0.4236745536,
-0.1388902962,
0.314840883,
0.837343514,
0.1236405969,
0.4189803898,
-0.329022795,
0.1830284745,
0.4561607838,
0.5301811099,
0.0217629969,
-0.6016859412,
0.1459655911,
0.0791574046,
-0.5894135833,
-0.8895983696,
0.0218340475,
-0.0569869727,
0.7482017875,
0.711771667,
-0.2222483307,
0.6036027074,
-0.6051335931,
0.7419887185,
0.0386812352,
-0.92604357,
0.6657230854,
-0.3243235052,
-0.2435648143,
0.6987789273,
-0.0153336469,
-0.6702595353,
-0.3909965158,
-0.5468296409,
-0.6883193254,
1.0080925226,
0.1928861439,
0.1277904958,
0.101375781,
0.5698126554,
0.2437161207,
0.4718767405,
-0.8989812732,
-0.0771694928,
0.0061305468,
0.2980469465,
-0.0459485278,
-0.6021669507,
-0.3304477036,
-0.1876950562,
0.5184980631,
-0.0635618865,
0.0526399724,
0.3565642536,
-0.4614065588,
-0.3003542721,
0.5368446112,
0.3706637919,
0.7650142312,
-0.2928799391,
0.2303592414,
0.1247170195,
-0.1982278824,
0.0065947417,
-0.3041118979,
-0.2365984917,
-0.2083354443,
0.5307976604,
0.7330390811,
0.363068223,
-0.8415099978,
0.622928381,
0.0936839432,
-0.1448369175,
-0.3261268139,
-0.1699847281,
0.145314306,
0.2337839007,
0.4927558303,
0.3813362718,
0.0260273088,
-0.6111467481,
0.3533370197,
0.472219348,
-0.5361058712,
-0.3244382739,
0.8624138236,
0.2265302539,
-0.2451403141,
0.3079810739,
-0.0982329845,
-0.6018254161,
0.2456249595,
0.1127128378,
0.74754107,
0.079753004,
-0.0881429836,
-0.0901712999,
0.5986692905,
-0.2456449419,
0.0734151378,
0.0300899968,
-0.882332623,
-0.0944892615,
-0.9284099936,
-0.5948290825,
-0.0021315406,
-0.6800858378,
0.3975734413,
-0.516489923,
-0.5198093057,
-0.1743153185,
-0.0003875685,
-0.5829890966,
0.069633387,
0.5734382272,
1.1986656189,
-0.763046205,
0.2742319107,
0.7976178527,
-0.4110459387,
-0.3442972004,
0.3839833438,
0.2984285951,
-0.6533783078,
0.7765324712,
0.2429106385,
-0.0482843667,
-0.579130888,
-0.5937283635,
-0.5166870952,
1.0407567024,
0.6831593513,
-0.7031577826,
-0.088610895,
0.0736207142,
0.439892143,
-0.364615649,
0.5661774278,
0.979118824,
0.728300035,
-0.0227366462,
-1.1639293432,
-0.1956933737,
-0.259178102,
0.1517719924,
-0.4078194797,
-0.9310712218,
0.6854044199,
-0.1631539762,
-0.0797266662,
0.0559692383,
0.5146112442,
0.3378912807,
0.2321815938,
0.5080537796,
0.7383541465,
0.8426277637,
-0.1665097177,
0.9869951606,
-0.0449756086,
0.4756252468,
1.008983016,
-0.5565214753,
0.7021051645,
0.5653397441,
-0.7530812025,
0.4900768399,
0.7405087948,
-0.3102976084,
0.27656582,
0.6799949408,
-0.1167104468,
-0.3206709027,
-0.0416979864,
-0.0083984379,
0.5128825903,
0.1844334304,
-0.5240898728,
-0.3533174694,
-0.1900274903,
0.1477181613,
0.4321607649,
-0.5388237834,
0.500272274,
0.2427221537,
-0.3631063998,
0.0177570041,
0.4216516018,
1.0616277456,
-0.1906520575,
0.2662602663,
0.0075587006,
-0.0164622013,
-0.5366613865,
-0.427339226,
0.1187302694,
0.3355176449,
-0.3536137044,
-0.0584876314,
0.6835052371,
0.2596670687,
-0.7595906854,
0.5266624093,
0.5939026475,
0.161146,
-0.2891037762,
-0.5841850638,
-0.0127036227,
-0.2059851587,
-0.3883276582,
0.271528542,
0.1103898808,
-0.4253466129,
0.8311238289,
0.5192854404,
0.2124976218,
0.1653301567,
0.5777167678,
0.800042212,
-0.9096793532,
-0.3437447846,
-1.1913113594,
0.161323607,
-0.0786097944,
0.0043443046,
0.6772003174,
0.555025816,
0.5662817955,
0.0961602703,
0.8705580235,
0.1298039705,
0.6599662304,
-0.3298439384,
1.1361122131,
-0.4588386714,
0.5269005299,
-0.5959809422,
-0.7443304658,
-0.2932031155,
0.5193144083,
-0.4881395698,
0.5018566251,
0.2306610048,
0.6404505372,
0.1474246681,
0.2256712466,
0.2345290035,
0.2455540299,
0.3765665293,
0.300886333,
1.0461161137,
-0.2046124637,
0.2852604091,
-0.0358278118,
-0.1662068516,
-0.5705958605,
-0.8141617775,
-0.9099683762,
0.1843773276,
-0.096355319,
-0.1051142141,
-0.0048204367,
0.9387192726,
0.6356339455,
-0.8164770603,
-0.3461749554,
0.0537867099,
0.2388570607,
0.0442913286,
-0.2787048817,
0.2363296747,
-0.2471266687,
-0.5769852996,
0.3085778654,
0.1586309969,
-0.3704018891,
-0.5586323142,
-0.0915427133,
-0.0187658202,
0.0413999856,
0.4081124663,
-0.2113123685,
-1.1423447132,
-0.4665465951,
-0.4672017992,
-0.0975345299,
0.1826303303,
0.6536844969,
-0.8950366974,
0.3278380632,
-0.1670005322,
0.3943566382,
-0.0065369825,
0.2454281449,
0.466735661,
-0.5751168132,
0.0493788123,
0.4378148317,
0.4566267133,
0.381421864,
-0.1869773269,
0.4472667873,
0.5730291009,
-0.3788388669,
-1.012675643,
0.2891862094,
-0.8837872148,
-0.0118807917,
1.1865628958,
0.1306895018,
-0.2168567479,
0.2335781455,
-0.1360799968,
-0.1748601794,
-0.3578633368,
0.9100842476,
1.0846853256,
0.0180265419,
0.2000588477,
-0.7663881183,
0.2793167531,
0.4079881608,
-0.6891950965,
0.1454110742,
0.3374564648,
0.5928747058,
0.283945322,
0.5233268142,
-0.5764668584,
0.261559546,
-0.1152455956,
0.3533942103,
0.1779940128,
-0.0436016917,
-0.5016213059,
0.1147869453,
0.4147622287,
0.2645606995
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10666v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10666v2
|
Multi-Hop Table Retrieval for Open-Domain Text-to-SQL
| 2024-02-16T13:14:35 | 2024-06-19T15:19:16 |
Xuanliang Zhang, Dingzirui Wang, Longxu Dou, Qingfu Zhu, Wanxiang Che
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Open-domain text-to-SQL is an important task that retrieves question-relevant
tables from massive databases and then generates SQL. However, existing
retrieval methods that retrieve in a single hop do not pay attention to the
text-to-SQL challenge of schema linking, which is aligning the entities in the
question with table entities, reflected in two aspects: similar irrelevant
entity and domain mismatch entity. Therefore, we propose our method, the
multi-hop table retrieval with rewrite and beam search (Murre). To reduce the
effect of the similar irrelevant entity, our method focuses on unretrieved
entities at each hop and considers the low-ranked tables by beam search. To
alleviate the limitation of domain mismatch entity, Murre rewrites the question
based on retrieved tables in multiple hops, decreasing the domain gap with
relevant tables. We conduct experiments on SpiderUnion and BirdUnion+, reaching
new state-of-the-art results with an average improvement of 6.38%.
|
[
-0.2492295057,
-1.1429727077,
0.590254724,
-0.0064241178,
-0.1440373212,
0.0393235907,
0.2142663598,
-0.4628240168,
0.5678258538,
0.5266964436,
-0.4468923211,
-0.2699538767,
-0.4286822379,
0.0805267915,
-0.2482825667,
0.9818809032,
0.1209868863,
-0.172091946,
-0.0991199911,
-0.3153519332,
-0.4231192768,
-0.4527874887,
-0.5019161105,
-0.0695182085,
0.6671508551,
0.5565181375,
0.8995031714,
0.531093359,
0.8376355171,
0.1685677767,
-0.2178579867,
0.3071188033,
-0.4691677094,
0.2853678465,
-0.4396460354,
-0.15132083,
-0.8114647269,
-0.2013531327,
0.6670210361,
0.9194143414,
-0.0877600461,
0.0892457217,
-0.0340720974,
1.0145555735,
-0.7413913012,
0.0665838644,
-0.7882656455,
0.0466834418,
-0.7276992202,
-0.6038102508,
-0.7158674002,
-0.3583258092,
0.0529839844,
-0.6595374942,
0.3610208333,
0.621884644,
0.6106221676,
0.0284272265,
-0.9394848347,
-0.1308011711,
-0.7001873255,
0.381862551,
-0.2834579945,
0.8233821392,
0.1011003777,
0.2577988803,
-0.5645727515,
-0.7868779898,
-0.430663377,
-0.1334496886,
-0.3968901932,
0.0205734689,
-0.017061485,
-0.1976635456,
0.2513911426,
0.2528283298,
-0.9466065764,
-0.410858959,
-0.3080602884,
-0.2551338375,
0.4920759499,
0.1205016822,
-0.1433664262,
-0.0353528634,
-0.6044104695,
-0.1415443122,
-0.7380567789,
-0.2327549309,
0.0105545977,
0.7224673629,
0.5395025015,
0.8036600947,
-0.3608864248,
0.781200707,
-0.0933513492,
0.0564960688,
0.417396456,
-0.5400505066,
-0.0214421209,
-0.0236973669,
0.602891326,
0.0244872645,
-0.0873200297,
-0.4419599771,
0.1661914438,
-0.2334299833,
0.2059997916,
-0.5772567987,
-0.0107081402,
0.2312452197,
-0.6591509581,
0.0967849195,
0.0231093951,
-1.1397289038,
-0.2816910744,
0.0821220726,
0.654211998,
-0.5664392114,
-0.3143429756,
-0.1629570127,
-0.2169351578,
0.1369998008,
0.4127492905,
-0.4957988858,
0.1970807165,
0.5859310031,
1.023607254,
-0.3824760616,
-0.6780081987,
-0.9487190843,
0.5340533853,
-0.2523782551,
0.8887868524,
-0.5251909494,
-0.4438671172,
-0.099104546,
-0.0254603755,
-0.3124682307,
-0.3728793561,
0.5924718976,
-0.8056583405,
0.1389673501,
-0.0775321424,
-0.6492088437,
0.047857862,
0.0617335103,
-0.8692513704,
0.7115430832,
0.0220631529,
-0.8831210732,
0.43632254,
-0.8217425942,
-0.7239796519,
0.0774216056,
-0.1026002094,
-0.5939558744,
0.1074944958,
0.1861981004,
0.1346408278,
-0.2354979813,
0.0535397157,
-0.3401906788,
-0.3403304517,
-0.2978135943,
-0.1747240573,
0.6074916124,
0.2202881575,
-0.1108859405,
-0.049993854,
-0.5572784543,
0.1959214807,
0.3622365296,
-0.6338508725,
-0.5262346864,
0.2567659616,
-0.158471033,
0.1380332261,
-0.1163811907,
-0.6150591969,
0.463380307,
-0.293789953,
0.0451876558,
0.2662402987,
0.1232905909,
0.4897692204,
-0.4392852783,
0.1881064922,
0.189541012,
0.0313887894,
-0.2334162295,
-0.6086109877,
-0.4651153982,
-0.0771679804,
-0.0162448958,
0.3382952809,
-0.7305440903,
-0.0760209262,
-0.3968879282,
-0.5224021673,
-0.5873251557,
-0.3428074121,
0.3125837147,
0.5649383068,
0.9095921516,
-0.1524273455,
-0.1926248223,
-0.6756945848,
-0.6745367646,
0.1472375989,
0.2242600173,
0.4786908627,
0.5519140959,
-0.0481373221,
0.797231853,
-0.7590625882,
-0.7231936455,
0.1694756448,
0.0006405407,
0.2230253667,
0.4755163491,
0.4271160662,
-0.9016906619,
-0.6804668903,
0.0058135521,
-0.5276090503,
0.4991676509,
0.1159190312,
-0.3582530022,
0.3257636726,
0.6041147709,
-0.8480426669,
0.5203474164,
0.1441141665,
-0.5105910897,
0.528444767,
-0.0505866446,
0.6441281438,
-0.9417627454,
0.3127852976,
-0.4629987478,
-0.1292941868,
-0.6983835101,
0.2639766335,
0.3041654229,
-0.4330824912,
-0.5547044277,
0.3184861243,
-0.6699367762,
-0.1037094817,
-0.0180236176,
0.5990744829,
0.1347571462,
0.4152004123,
0.0579319261,
0.9431763291,
0.4784673452,
-0.777728796,
0.2508313656,
0.7263525128,
0.0268698353,
0.7282206416,
-0.4081479907,
0.3589052558,
-0.149055928,
0.4308992922,
-0.9264758229,
-0.1083156988,
0.2263160199,
-0.5191491842,
0.3476367891,
-0.3551106155,
-0.2145789415,
-0.2945182323,
-0.3415677845,
0.5186674595,
-0.2589428723,
-0.6816680431,
0.6858927608,
0.2364573479,
0.040409185,
-0.9441960454,
-0.5662293434,
0.0501524396,
-0.0707141757,
-0.6970952749,
0.7035284638,
0.0498265736,
0.1293222606,
-0.0001671367,
-0.3347423971,
-0.1426191479,
-0.2448415458,
-0.0861624032,
0.2569704652,
-0.3564089537,
0.2828768492,
0.081382148,
-0.2447871119,
-0.1915024519,
-0.3618466556,
0.6150889993,
-0.0712337717,
-0.5221152902,
-0.1544453204,
0.8318942785,
0.5822000504,
-0.7267232537,
0.9657769799,
0.166582942,
-0.2597914934,
-0.0692750141,
-0.3687698841,
-0.2534126937,
-0.4041748643,
0.422200799,
-0.8830823302,
-1.025596261,
0.1947891265,
-0.2845814228,
0.0821560845,
0.5822443366,
0.1963499337,
-0.1224165112,
0.6544015408,
0.5804941654,
0.0843222365,
0.1332936585,
0.0186166931,
0.4685925543,
-0.8162183166,
-0.3977058232,
-1.0778608322,
-0.0320409462,
-0.4480641782,
-0.40270257,
0.2871804535,
-0.06119835,
-0.3011147976,
0.8362159133,
-0.5530910492,
0.460618794,
0.6037293673,
0.0605885573,
0.872826457,
0.0223088618,
-0.3510029018,
-0.0507290922,
-0.5527348518,
0.081185177,
1.1243731976,
-0.2109313011,
0.9785957336,
0.534643054,
0.6354680657,
0.267573595,
0.0459890738,
-0.5511692762,
0.3639322817,
0.1314011663,
-1.0795822144,
-0.5101357102,
-0.8291630149,
-1.0280587673,
0.6814709306,
-0.3108043969,
-0.7359955311,
0.1409082264,
0.1415001899,
0.1310664564,
0.4039573073,
-0.5495439768,
0.9294326901,
-0.0528923199,
-0.30111444,
-0.3106408715,
-0.8204035759,
0.3873110712,
-0.3334997594,
0.1520975381,
0.0092987856,
0.096603848,
0.5495857,
-0.4220326543,
-0.0364042111,
-0.0635888875,
0.1603962183,
0.1907209903,
0.487026155,
0.6895678639,
-0.0177019294,
-0.224052906,
0.1527867466,
-0.1081259996,
-0.2226216942,
-0.4648763239,
0.6656966805,
-0.269783318,
-0.4935512245,
-0.6934041381,
-0.4746289849,
-0.2611211836,
0.5487982035,
0.1498205215,
0.1699379832,
-0.2010748684,
0.4081804752,
0.3831656277,
0.0595025197,
0.3058327138,
0.6511465311,
-0.3020776808,
-0.1868630648,
0.5608486533,
-0.0012168651,
0.2887316346,
0.6989287734,
-0.0844439194,
-0.5242259502,
-0.2815955579,
-0.4937532544,
0.4394224584,
-0.3863118291,
-0.6626105905,
-0.6613458395,
-0.0439014025,
-0.521761179,
0.0170367509,
-0.56923455,
-0.4898111224,
0.0578691363,
0.2110242099,
0.3448518515,
0.2508547902,
0.2100612223,
0.2335575968,
-0.9918768406,
0.2456387728,
-0.1845645756,
0.7733595371,
0.132552743,
-0.5194600224,
-0.2334253639,
-0.1731980443,
-0.4462944865,
-1.1229889393,
-0.0397738256,
0.5826412439,
0.5805128813,
0.2408534139,
0.2288529873,
0.8967172503,
-0.9038597941,
0.2553114295,
0.1989118308,
-0.9396013618,
0.8819269538,
-0.1410295814,
-0.1862264723,
0.5620343089,
0.7725347281,
-0.5644884706,
-0.2518074811,
-0.4330720007,
-0.8257669806,
0.9121309519,
0.5180052519,
-0.3547942638,
0.0506880283,
0.3735322356,
-0.085525766,
0.1530442238,
-0.6662201881,
-0.5747430921,
0.0720982328,
0.5116432905,
0.1236787587,
-0.0693093538,
0.0613647588,
0.1650136709,
0.625767529,
-0.0734315142,
0.4630825818,
0.2660058737,
-0.1421719342,
-0.3863827884,
0.3166989684,
0.0535189733,
0.5979260802,
-0.4281049371,
-0.0422940999,
0.0222157668,
-0.3479039967,
0.1003024429,
0.1692835987,
-0.1657280177,
0.2111247033,
0.2266601324,
0.3197100163,
-0.1929524392,
-0.4175124168,
0.6222006679,
-0.0077364394,
-0.1879323274,
0.1626066417,
0.0423481166,
0.1676441133,
0.2307676524,
0.5063449144,
0.2419623882,
0.3385760188,
-0.5559558272,
0.6892152429,
0.6569654942,
-0.3213770092,
0.2184651196,
1.0168101788,
0.0877948627,
-0.6225454211,
0.8340039849,
-0.0888262615,
-0.1241127178,
0.1823932976,
0.8276786804,
0.4794392884,
-0.460711062,
-0.006508817,
0.4221447706,
0.4081796706,
0.1351928115,
0.323094815,
0.1364532709,
-0.4789874852,
-0.4328385293,
-0.3823571801,
-0.4770216942,
-0.2149240822,
-0.5136788487,
0.3233357668,
0.0624779016,
-0.1891224831,
0.1450242251,
-0.1067206636,
-0.2087124735,
-0.0910626575,
-0.4355432391,
1.0795038939,
-0.5747134089,
0.7903602719,
0.5483050346,
-0.7074620128,
-0.7726792693,
0.016427068,
0.1475930512,
-0.293915689,
0.2543337643,
-0.0998388678,
-0.2661672533,
0.0453111604,
-0.1198499799,
-1.1172487736,
1.041727066,
0.1790506095,
-0.2780224681,
-0.0947683752,
0.1894181669,
0.2222695649,
-0.2348481715,
0.3479581773,
0.5398896337,
0.4261201322,
0.1061425433,
-1.008518219,
0.0652966499,
-0.0225716215,
-0.12522012,
0.7659434676,
-0.7004172206,
1.0162330866,
-0.3217188716,
-0.2838657498,
-0.2586236596,
0.8739980459,
0.3027684987,
0.5474924445,
0.4640372097,
0.4513398111,
0.6755667329,
-0.0821012259,
0.5387086868,
0.0156327095,
0.8415451646,
1.3176301718,
-0.6759219766,
1.0171501637,
0.6141397953,
-0.3309980631,
0.1341812611,
0.2460091412,
0.176408112,
0.6315914989,
0.0204199944,
0.0386148989,
0.1046531647,
0.1263137758,
-0.6197926998,
0.4713765383,
0.1498423666,
0.0232895613,
-0.7237840891,
-0.072755672,
0.1577571929,
-0.0945543274,
-0.0514952354,
0.5794452429,
-0.1034114957,
-0.5284006596,
0.2848983407,
0.0732863173,
0.4067730606,
-0.6907821298,
-0.1167511567,
-0.5114930868,
0.2684952021,
-0.3269252479,
-0.5888621807,
0.6059712768,
-0.3075879514,
-0.0537363812,
0.2099542171,
0.6556225419,
-0.4448886216,
0.0529117323,
0.6506444216,
0.8356603384,
0.2956081927,
-0.5013840795,
-0.614964664,
-0.1989834458,
0.0639977232,
-0.4204145074,
0.2256601304,
0.5179197192,
0.0397665836,
0.6854981184,
0.6951149702,
-0.1325221062,
0.1590794027,
-0.1063358188,
0.9479178786,
-0.705472827,
-0.3388332725,
-0.6321462393,
0.2517431974,
-0.0292011555,
-0.3083891273,
0.683722496,
1.1809939146,
0.8027451038,
-0.2491395772,
0.2482716888,
-0.3283815384,
0.8437364101,
-0.3385367095,
0.762721777,
-0.9773397446,
-0.0423831865,
-0.6251235604,
-1.3729327917,
-0.5319215059,
0.4474993348,
0.383756429,
-0.0542947203,
1.2219498158,
0.9909114838,
-0.2958441377,
0.0672055706,
0.2250413448,
0.0137227662,
0.5036476254,
0.5799126625,
0.5658809543,
-0.7386093736,
1.0914214849,
0.0915030465,
-0.2085672468,
-0.5150879025,
-0.6812847853,
-0.4625145197,
-0.579018712,
-0.2474209368,
-0.5386720896,
0.1303318292,
0.7350533605,
0.4821300209,
-0.7623440623,
-0.1462123245,
0.2461355478,
0.2173940539,
-0.4558407366,
-0.1856303215,
0.8574000597,
-0.5047892928,
-0.494238615,
0.601768136,
0.6040692329,
-0.2651469707,
0.3490506113,
0.0952403843,
-0.8631634116,
-0.1171699911,
0.6720112562,
0.0861124843,
-0.2889155447,
-0.4185913801,
0.1731026918,
-0.1812871993,
0.2836476862,
0.9609394073,
-0.6664850116,
0.1511823535,
0.3940988779,
0.6580713987,
0.745716393,
0.1326966137,
-0.0274189562,
-0.7367572784,
-0.1108624637,
0.3761612177,
0.3696505129,
-0.1495092213,
-0.3034932315,
0.8269565105,
0.4104267955,
-0.7801965475,
-0.4170031846,
0.3628343642,
-0.9368655682,
-0.2768637836,
0.6689491868,
0.0724777207,
0.0264131464,
-0.2922261953,
-0.1467755139,
0.2243897021,
-0.2428743094,
0.4905796349,
0.3639823794,
-0.4337966442,
0.1713105291,
-0.3615432382,
0.4444799423,
0.4251539409,
-0.7403048277,
0.3368930519,
0.5708024502,
0.0416323654,
0.3683471978,
0.88290447,
-0.2452043295,
0.1904066652,
0.2456665039,
-0.1585461795,
-0.0205258261,
-0.7569981813,
0.2406196147,
0.3611119688,
-0.1593800187,
-0.308489114
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10663v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10663v3
|
Improving Demonstration Diversity by Human-Free Fusing for Text-to-SQL
| 2024-02-16T13:13:18 | 2024-06-26T06:54:35 |
Dingzirui Wang, Longxu Dou, Xuanliang Zhang, Qingfu Zhu, Wanxiang Che
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Currently, the in-context learning method based on large language models
(LLMs) has become the mainstream of text-to-SQL research. Previous works have
discussed how to select demonstrations related to the user question from a
human-labeled demonstration pool. However, human labeling suffers from the
limitations of insufficient diversity and high labeling overhead. Therefore, in
this paper, we discuss how to measure and improve the diversity of the
demonstrations for text-to-SQL. We present a metric to measure the diversity of
the demonstrations and analyze the insufficient of the existing labeled data by
experiments. Based on the above discovery, we propose fusing iteratively for
demonstrations (Fused) to build a high-diversity demonstration pool through
human-free multiple-iteration synthesis, improving diversity and lowering label
cost. Our method achieves an average improvement of 3.2% and 5.0% with and
without human labeling on several mainstream datasets, which proves the
effectiveness of Fused.
|
[
-0.6091140509,
-0.572981596,
-0.0384177677,
0.37015751,
-0.4020213783,
0.2617418468,
-0.2905279398,
-0.2959119678,
0.1119306237,
0.3310195804,
-0.5935159326,
-0.7509849668,
-0.266700387,
0.1807721257,
-0.8336995244,
1.1101093292,
0.0486035943,
-0.2310204208,
-0.5499569774,
-0.3785131574,
-0.4635457397,
-0.1975682378,
-0.1945548803,
-0.2914883792,
0.2416456342,
0.7745707631,
0.4374153018,
0.4766184986,
-0.0824884996,
0.3309172094,
-0.1040591821,
0.4289865494,
-0.7371454835,
0.0365443677,
-0.3734507263,
-0.391805917,
-0.0397698842,
-0.0074924128,
0.9839498401,
0.7935193777,
0.0684965253,
-0.0706939846,
0.2592850327,
0.6333872676,
-0.5512715578,
-0.3451265991,
-0.7326032519,
0.048249688,
-0.1377995759,
0.1138113216,
-0.5744727254,
-0.2989792228,
0.0196734741,
-0.3794627488,
0.4717300832,
0.1882922202,
0.5405128002,
0.0049300739,
-0.5637939572,
0.1888597757,
-0.8489332199,
1.2082526684,
-0.4162659049,
0.3783868551,
0.0281642955,
0.4414734542,
-0.2831885815,
-0.4634108543,
-0.608327806,
-0.1158726886,
-0.1525616646,
0.0703153759,
-0.1239833683,
-0.2759573162,
0.1536147296,
0.4488231242,
-0.3720718026,
0.3042931557,
-0.2124996781,
-0.3227431178,
1.0493541956,
0.215201363,
0.2435132563,
-0.1092361286,
-0.6250818968,
-0.3834472299,
-0.5359258652,
-0.1003658921,
0.1976124644,
0.2297171801,
-0.0813854411,
0.5598631501,
-0.4748889804,
0.6941784024,
-0.3307869732,
-0.0294878874,
0.259328723,
-0.6759140491,
-0.3543972075,
-0.2662352026,
0.772116363,
0.2277930826,
-0.4314925671,
-0.3517726958,
-0.0782845989,
0.037318211,
-0.0658260882,
-0.7737377286,
-0.1315000057,
0.2053038478,
-0.439565897,
-0.0273878351,
0.1109465212,
-1.125970006,
-0.5233843923,
-0.0850597918,
0.4637917578,
-0.3936655819,
-0.3506539464,
-0.2065311074,
-0.537783742,
0.2293333858,
0.3995028138,
-0.6399376392,
0.423625052,
0.4983200729,
0.6624328494,
-0.7222107053,
-0.452652812,
-0.39049384,
0.2568085194,
-0.1528746635,
0.9598713517,
-0.0788780376,
-0.7800405025,
-0.323993504,
-0.1697118431,
-0.1558355391,
-0.7857121229,
0.2971358001,
0.0128948987,
0.5165943503,
-0.3449085653,
-0.9597131014,
-0.0924715921,
0.1245422512,
-0.5039006472,
0.8843874335,
0.2662271261,
-0.4707598686,
0.553194046,
-0.7299820781,
-0.5487654805,
0.194837302,
-0.438952893,
-0.7209637165,
-0.1080005467,
0.4234216511,
0.1757927239,
-0.3166482747,
0.3251654804,
-0.1534468681,
-0.8083920479,
0.4327100515,
-0.2757232785,
0.8893131614,
0.0973711535,
-0.6526001096,
0.5131945014,
-0.7968228459,
-0.127219826,
-0.0739336163,
-0.3443832994,
-0.0566616617,
0.2271722406,
-0.0423358753,
0.0576575138,
-0.3654981256,
-0.292838186,
0.0930846259,
-0.7453148365,
-0.0817616358,
0.6174431443,
0.1105172485,
0.5303077102,
-0.5284335613,
0.3389976621,
-0.0253376998,
0.1409856826,
-0.1992932707,
-0.5997989178,
-0.9235941768,
-0.6118007302,
-0.0060388064,
0.2741057575,
-0.696805656,
0.6943299174,
-0.1320785135,
-0.4896170497,
-0.3868088722,
0.4569075406,
0.2594937384,
0.4968698025,
0.4459017217,
-0.3317519724,
-0.4509314299,
-0.9497215748,
-0.5190085769,
-0.0593921803,
-0.2877295613,
0.2819886804,
0.519828856,
-0.3032124043,
1.166413784,
-0.1797635406,
-0.3945870399,
-0.2919693589,
0.2790774703,
0.0793829784,
0.4653350711,
0.4883618951,
-0.6252499819,
-0.4093039036,
-0.0614190847,
-0.5255371928,
0.1561559439,
-0.1083546951,
-0.1801223755,
0.310016185,
0.2090614438,
-0.0204954185,
0.4783215523,
0.4558336139,
-0.2808177471,
0.3539931774,
0.0381130576,
0.3899958432,
-1.0343972445,
-0.2877434194,
-0.0625684112,
0.1189341247,
-0.4476986527,
-0.0926323831,
0.0590194203,
-0.1935474873,
-0.5973550081,
0.5316084623,
-0.5019120574,
-0.1827489287,
-0.1383617073,
0.3008434772,
-0.141040042,
0.2731624544,
-0.1437461078,
0.8901717663,
0.4854719937,
-0.6523449421,
0.4308932424,
0.3318625987,
-0.5549102426,
0.5943790674,
-0.2981716096,
0.0464948863,
-0.0169896539,
0.3972851634,
-1.4642660618,
-0.4605745971,
-0.1235370785,
-0.167986691,
-0.1269805729,
0.1287308037,
-0.3962842226,
-0.3768441081,
-0.6506499648,
0.1183042228,
0.8108251691,
-0.9762055874,
0.5392694473,
0.0781199038,
0.1769101769,
-0.3853056729,
-0.5155090094,
0.1794020832,
-0.3194568455,
-0.9134867191,
0.581620872,
-0.0747979209,
-0.1211641058,
-0.4909935594,
-0.0608655512,
-0.1570180655,
0.0975926369,
0.1802793592,
0.1965660453,
-0.1014470607,
0.4959391952,
0.4635208845,
0.181206882,
-0.1775972098,
-0.0699362755,
0.2454830408,
-0.066746451,
-0.6528941393,
-0.563547194,
0.6749019623,
-0.0077821189,
-0.0527201816,
0.7385175228,
0.5564184785,
-0.1901405156,
-0.4533543587,
-0.5079293251,
-0.2267048061,
-0.5195399523,
0.4848879278,
0.0673725009,
-1.0930101871,
0.27049312,
-0.4226314723,
0.3547074795,
0.4742786288,
0.5038099885,
-0.2459560037,
0.9494224787,
0.4147136211,
0.1562494487,
0.446528405,
-0.1502482146,
-0.0816581696,
-0.3238486052,
-0.4039467871,
-0.817271769,
-0.4870342016,
-0.1428430974,
-0.6084016562,
0.5331945419,
0.1464660764,
-0.1622089893,
0.1147502661,
-0.6104041934,
0.6988224387,
0.4312615097,
0.3355496824,
0.5273146629,
0.4432803094,
0.1694655716,
-0.2563101947,
-0.4857921004,
-0.3087496758,
0.8663674593,
0.0702172965,
0.7288841605,
0.2915290594,
0.9884729385,
0.1621858478,
0.6247910857,
-0.50889045,
0.7227087021,
-0.3047131896,
-0.4348694086,
-0.4505646527,
-0.5338466763,
-0.8823550344,
0.4823748171,
-0.4800498486,
-0.8940836787,
0.0876513273,
0.3174654245,
0.1843012869,
0.164886713,
-0.8282251358,
0.8400242329,
-0.2899792492,
-0.272733897,
-0.3260534406,
-0.4703826606,
0.4688998163,
0.089938283,
0.3079335988,
0.1360690892,
-0.0248444322,
1.0161141157,
-0.4597871006,
1.0042278767,
-0.1364326179,
-0.270614773,
0.4124627113,
-0.1520028412,
0.3974722028,
-0.2538839877,
-0.1933487505,
-0.3305541873,
-0.7559359074,
-0.4676507711,
-0.6103234291,
0.6930916309,
-0.5808894634,
-0.5716124773,
0.349170059,
-0.5739751458,
-0.5328757167,
-0.2425199896,
0.2922328711,
0.1194593161,
-0.4040897787,
0.4881997705,
0.7365139723,
-0.3996624649,
0.4677999616,
0.1064956114,
-0.281372875,
-0.4860442877,
1.1026260853,
-0.1275933534,
0.4647095501,
0.2559012771,
0.3848876357,
-0.5364474058,
-0.4972940981,
-0.5700809956,
0.1518550813,
-0.8282145262,
-0.0228331331,
-0.7938815355,
0.166640088,
-0.4381035864,
-0.141542837,
-0.1355110854,
-0.6308740377,
-0.4137526155,
-0.0936995223,
0.5364385247,
0.4427700639,
0.4402241707,
0.6449894309,
-0.6442452073,
0.2295169681,
0.7004666328,
0.4298844337,
0.0353132375,
-0.4981518686,
-0.0382441208,
-0.0317439139,
-0.5981661677,
-1.1291050911,
0.039685864,
0.5145251155,
0.8103458881,
0.3240307868,
0.1443367898,
0.7762882113,
0.1553138047,
1.0434888601,
0.427257061,
-1.2149585485,
0.8855742216,
-0.1706031412,
-0.0495849252,
0.3775987923,
0.274024725,
-0.2495293319,
-0.6264402866,
-0.5457608104,
-1.0423448086,
0.6151047349,
0.2356806844,
0.0893371254,
0.1847913861,
-0.1905194372,
0.4021188617,
0.0032251109,
-0.7348964214,
-0.2485840023,
-0.1587800533,
-0.1365621686,
-0.0579985566,
0.1230665296,
-0.3893706203,
-0.7201502919,
0.5890023112,
-0.2853488028,
-0.0563217811,
-0.1530251205,
-0.1676916927,
0.1783524603,
0.7317263484,
0.4194609821,
0.5057677627,
0.1232714131,
-0.0570972711,
0.5806959867,
0.1267515123,
0.2274067849,
-0.0357918404,
-0.186127767,
0.1257864088,
0.2460588068,
0.9411756396,
0.1437195241,
-0.852058053,
0.62049824,
0.0686671063,
-0.3484173417,
0.2111221999,
0.577789247,
0.3111753166,
0.0662437677,
0.3397326469,
-0.1741815805,
0.211836949,
-0.4314644337,
0.4393649995,
0.5487733483,
-0.3817828298,
0.2298030257,
0.5328885913,
0.6047737598,
-0.3397868574,
0.7866985798,
-0.0359937288,
-0.2588467598,
0.64714849,
0.7684789896,
0.64509058,
-0.1780176312,
0.3481250107,
0.3618148863,
0.1839457154,
-0.1805972457,
0.1636342704,
-0.3130639195,
-0.4831488431,
-0.2335189283,
-0.2069687247,
-0.5599157214,
-0.3714624941,
-0.452813983,
0.5410661697,
-0.2490105778,
0.104049556,
-0.0948512182,
-0.1717616469,
-0.2551390529,
0.1631598473,
-0.2522031963,
0.9419714808,
-1.1741577387,
0.6564735174,
0.4614854455,
-0.2631345689,
-0.5749588609,
-0.2540570498,
-0.0661196187,
-0.3342836797,
0.2354599833,
0.2976633608,
0.0790623873,
-0.1515050232,
-0.780988276,
-0.1993334889,
1.1346901655,
0.4565737844,
-0.4736092687,
0.381958127,
0.1249221042,
0.4462323189,
-0.5936226845,
0.1411755383,
0.4992123544,
0.3658794463,
0.2654666305,
-0.6275591254,
-0.0795086697,
-0.1186223179,
0.0547023863,
0.1719229519,
-0.4131503999,
0.815764308,
-0.3781696856,
-0.3804942966,
0.1522120386,
0.9103420377,
0.4796063602,
0.5571787357,
0.8129286766,
0.1592747122,
0.9602861404,
-0.1484085768,
1.006937623,
0.6835576296,
0.477866739,
1.0521818399,
-0.4776872098,
0.7402302623,
0.62464118,
-0.4860046506,
0.7531390786,
0.2888288498,
-0.2238998115,
0.0922229066,
0.40655002,
-0.6771895885,
-0.475890249,
-0.0466723852,
-0.3369756043,
0.1713116914,
0.2945530713,
-0.3935415447,
-0.3505768478,
0.1942283958,
-0.3751776218,
0.4061559141,
0.0785028636,
1.0287076235,
-0.3065881133,
-0.6092470884,
0.8276682496,
-0.1636685282,
0.9405763149,
-0.4143407047,
-0.0813653469,
-0.3448048234,
0.055922389,
-0.4298235178,
-0.7574672103,
0.2897395492,
-0.0055820136,
-0.1389364749,
-0.0653004795,
0.609777391,
-0.6100538969,
-0.3012174964,
0.2880369723,
0.3372988403,
0.361710459,
0.0714006126,
-0.3379938304,
0.01125596,
0.3600697815,
0.148527801,
0.5589787364,
0.0102016404,
-0.4142821431,
0.5229537487,
0.4363071918,
-0.34642905,
0.1258946955,
0.332675457,
0.9166746736,
-0.7151088715,
-0.4534411132,
-0.8808988333,
0.7065443993,
-0.6621476412,
-0.1140032485,
0.7366446853,
0.7679018378,
0.7503685355,
-0.1510151476,
0.6999890804,
0.0600892417,
0.7004019618,
-0.1656706482,
0.7190486193,
-0.7072708011,
0.4159628153,
-0.3242137134,
-0.8309446573,
-0.1818584055,
0.3733391166,
0.4088681638,
0.0306346398,
0.5694909096,
0.8706062436,
-0.1102268025,
0.4676820934,
0.2369082272,
0.0124945622,
0.4513342977,
0.5926186442,
0.9331952333,
-0.4414328039,
0.8534121513,
-0.3002609909,
-0.6986647248,
-0.0265855957,
-1.0083265305,
-0.9828885198,
-0.4656699002,
-0.5523861647,
-0.3904047906,
-0.1814368367,
0.9570820928,
0.6629810333,
-0.8670597672,
-0.6686987281,
0.123142153,
0.4176510274,
-0.5598950982,
-0.2314947546,
0.2330625057,
-0.2697707415,
-0.6054075956,
0.5902770162,
0.1625288427,
0.1518730968,
-0.0802726373,
-0.0907631889,
-0.0665401667,
-0.1686851084,
0.7092936039,
0.2138428986,
-0.5947936773,
-0.1284909248,
-0.1998448521,
0.1647350192,
0.15416269,
0.8471676111,
-0.859395206,
0.3725680709,
0.487968713,
0.8349519372,
0.5477303863,
0.0526017584,
0.5781311989,
-1.393045783,
0.1158937514,
0.1457915306,
0.178599149,
0.4384553432,
-0.1538831443,
0.3995816112,
0.4987826645,
-0.2800675929,
-0.695866406,
0.2977404594,
-0.9920043349,
-0.351331085,
1.0060760975,
0.0890259445,
-0.067924045,
-0.2621232271,
-0.4029893279,
0.2420443594,
-0.2893210053,
0.9034913778,
0.3473283052,
-0.4137420356,
-0.1448114067,
0.1960159689,
0.3042096198,
0.4932222664,
-1.3882015944,
0.2821435332,
0.661555469,
0.213086009,
-0.0813986063,
0.5879177451,
-0.1442727745,
0.3408647776,
-0.1625658423,
-0.0302678198,
0.1820145547,
-0.1102085114,
-0.2492224574,
0.3245076537,
-0.1388445497,
-0.094507508
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10662v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10662v1
|
Fine Tuning Named Entity Extraction Models for the Fantasy Domain
| 2024-02-16T13:11:13 | 2024-02-16T13:11:13 |
Aravinth Sivaganeshan, Nisansa de Silva
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Named Entity Recognition (NER) is a sequence classification Natural Language
Processing task where entities are identified in the text and classified into
predefined categories. It acts as a foundation for most information extraction
systems. Dungeons and Dragons (D&D) is an open-ended tabletop fantasy game with
its own diverse lore. DnD entities are domain-specific and are thus
unrecognizable by even the state-of-the-art off-the-shelf NER systems as the
NER systems are trained on general data for pre-defined categories such as:
person (PERS), location (LOC), organization (ORG), and miscellaneous (MISC).
For meaningful extraction of information from fantasy text, the entities need
to be classified into domain-specific entity categories as well as the models
be fine-tuned on a domain-relevant corpus. This work uses available lore of
monsters in the D&D domain to fine-tune Trankit, which is a prolific NER
framework that uses a pre-trained model for NER. Upon this training, the system
acquires the ability to extract monster names from relevant domain documents
under a novel NER tag. This work compares the accuracy of the monster name
identification against; the zero-shot Trankit model and two FLAIR models. The
fine-tuned Trankit model achieves an 87.86% F1 score surpassing all the other
considered models.
|
[
-0.7288861871,
-0.7443777323,
0.2591763139,
-0.2296076715,
-0.1603574008,
0.1459703594,
-0.1079768315,
-0.9123513699,
0.2555373311,
0.8594337106,
-0.7258292437,
-0.4847235084,
-0.5076265335,
0.6297103763,
-0.2498607934,
1.2916718721,
0.0655658767,
-0.172508195,
0.0051392722,
-0.0127752004,
-0.5465850234,
-0.3312105238,
-1.0676966906,
-0.2343320847,
0.6249753833,
0.1236430034,
0.6009947658,
0.9551650882,
0.9269871712,
0.2437453866,
-0.1629961878,
0.4917036891,
-0.821380198,
0.3317326307,
-0.6067873836,
0.0139018279,
-0.7063236237,
-0.3078118563,
0.441213727,
0.3000457883,
-0.0924464315,
0.2032431215,
0.1436267942,
0.2960494757,
-0.6374780536,
0.0231315196,
-0.7349920869,
0.0845802128,
-0.2995115221,
-0.35599491,
-0.2535804212,
-0.4734259844,
0.4564425349,
-1.0382996798,
0.5884100199,
0.1807264388,
1.2581505775,
0.2354563475,
-0.2089612037,
-0.3299071491,
-0.9533244371,
0.798561573,
-0.7034679651,
0.4657900929,
0.3419410586,
0.4462469816,
-0.252386719,
-0.6881091595,
-0.8294225335,
0.0311053172,
-0.1875385046,
-0.334397167,
-0.2960988879,
0.1124246567,
0.594163835,
0.3490174413,
-0.4405482113,
0.2894724011,
-0.4231898189,
-0.1691721678,
0.8602747321,
0.5032740831,
0.397903353,
-0.1300633252,
-0.3450184464,
-0.2185497582,
-0.7029958963,
-0.2029751241,
0.4478430748,
0.3944341242,
0.2295452058,
0.498098284,
-0.2179703265,
0.8364232183,
0.6650285125,
-0.600104332,
0.1303509623,
0.0905172229,
-0.399371624,
0.2457224429,
0.5579223633,
0.3997279704,
0.3186390102,
-0.4801565409,
-0.6146409512,
-0.0429673009,
0.4608500004,
-0.961093843,
-0.3652279377,
-0.1149891466,
-0.6265464425,
-0.3616433442,
-0.0816594213,
-1.0996009111,
-0.7077201009,
-0.475251466,
0.6514652371,
-0.575420022,
-0.4802617729,
0.1220261082,
-0.1780049503,
0.306202352,
0.548817873,
-0.9103513956,
0.3736187518,
0.8516008258,
0.6396430731,
-0.6255813837,
-0.090001978,
-0.4471293688,
0.2428534329,
-0.224432528,
0.9855042696,
-0.7234643102,
-0.5412371755,
-0.3804468513,
0.3851220608,
-0.0510612801,
-0.7554616332,
0.6868725419,
-0.817828536,
0.0541226976,
-0.0482603386,
-0.7337602973,
-0.5405144691,
0.41377303,
-1.033940196,
0.5764533877,
0.0238774419,
-0.7831023335,
0.5409839749,
-0.4958311021,
-0.3462615609,
0.4538643062,
0.0469212309,
-0.1711358279,
0.2016814947,
0.1028141752,
0.4658572078,
-0.6036321521,
0.2039914876,
-0.2868353426,
-0.3021175563,
0.1091500446,
-0.2322521508,
0.5080701709,
0.203179881,
-0.1685738564,
-0.3490665853,
-0.8269404173,
0.2909309268,
-0.1088968962,
-0.1216834933,
-0.8152163625,
0.0355078541,
0.0679551214,
0.125569284,
-0.1547349393,
-0.4708862305,
0.2899065614,
-0.5686666965,
-0.0461034738,
0.4898190796,
0.2874598205,
0.4450403154,
-0.2665744424,
0.6308629513,
-0.1240523085,
-0.1105278656,
0.0866429433,
-0.1798989326,
-0.634370327,
-0.4916775227,
0.6519095302,
0.3876128197,
-1.0701562166,
0.4082921147,
-0.4715355635,
-0.7002257109,
-0.5912443399,
-0.325026989,
0.3018265069,
0.7095420957,
0.3919756711,
-0.3159566224,
-0.5407683253,
-0.8439679742,
-0.3473137021,
0.0594127551,
-0.0001435668,
0.4280791879,
0.4465941787,
-0.4250652492,
1.1234242916,
-0.6886368394,
-0.3805542886,
-0.2149743885,
0.1686601937,
0.3711433709,
0.5180841684,
0.4280438125,
-1.0227160454,
-0.5437077284,
0.3550349772,
-0.5614788532,
0.0090872077,
0.0664671883,
-0.0804858729,
-0.1628653705,
0.1617511511,
-0.5391094685,
0.6105237007,
0.1744022369,
-0.239877671,
0.6069095731,
0.0295077804,
0.3234514296,
-1.0706349611,
0.2305688262,
0.1369332671,
-0.1860196888,
-0.780813098,
-0.0385598838,
-0.1149470955,
0.0839784071,
-0.3476106226,
0.9984058738,
-0.7151561975,
0.2424521148,
-0.3309540749,
-0.1368308812,
0.0726730153,
0.2379932851,
0.3635382652,
0.6887497306,
0.5674660802,
-1.2572208643,
0.5096441507,
0.1067638472,
-0.3523007929,
0.9917102456,
-0.6864065528,
0.3152958155,
-0.0422417596,
-0.1753256768,
-0.3173015118,
-0.3400176466,
0.2962323129,
-0.3292382061,
0.7417929769,
-0.3152473569,
-0.2624052465,
-0.1837863326,
0.1368923187,
0.414277494,
0.3278496265,
-0.6425840259,
0.6795168519,
0.7776243687,
0.0416047685,
-0.6626727581,
-0.1778264791,
-0.0529019758,
-0.5257638097,
-0.2412177771,
0.733101368,
0.0857888386,
-0.2210537791,
0.1987107545,
-0.2258748412,
-0.5715472698,
-0.0249782316,
0.1589221358,
0.2467576414,
-0.3790432215,
0.0056295879,
0.0468943901,
-0.2415608466,
-0.2025964558,
-0.1084105819,
0.2858470976,
0.2316087931,
-0.0800650343,
-0.5182617307,
0.0558616966,
0.4867133498,
-0.1587236822,
0.529343605,
0.4110148251,
-0.8225899339,
-0.5842596889,
-0.6276006103,
-0.2589235902,
-0.4509823918,
0.3602891564,
-0.6447888017,
-0.827177763,
0.5058719516,
-0.2762996554,
0.007943375,
0.8893252015,
0.0568215623,
0.1177534163,
0.94294554,
0.9646590352,
0.0972468257,
0.0868171304,
-0.2818366885,
0.2398469746,
-0.8513361812,
-0.3533198535,
-0.6501529813,
-0.6023858786,
-0.7256585956,
-0.2518494427,
0.0711635947,
0.1924124658,
0.0185097009,
0.7660505176,
-0.6549600363,
0.8415091038,
0.1490337402,
-0.1412867606,
0.2893445194,
0.2666324377,
0.0640661493,
-0.3225106895,
-0.1157810837,
-0.6293510199,
0.7530785799,
0.1719722152,
1.0713287592,
0.1328626722,
0.7037813067,
0.4328916371,
0.1226599067,
-0.7642515898,
0.407622695,
-0.3742079139,
-0.8635495305,
-0.3143287301,
-0.4269553125,
-0.8949104548,
-0.0065170918,
-0.4006679356,
-0.8722435832,
0.7295444608,
-0.1032259613,
-0.6736139655,
0.6010234356,
-0.2665779293,
0.7042239308,
0.0503491722,
-0.1463296413,
-0.0042003407,
-0.400581181,
0.2976689339,
-0.269358933,
-0.246937722,
-0.1057559326,
0.0671098381,
0.6938691735,
-0.1176527664,
0.4951409698,
0.0363650508,
-0.2709414065,
0.2218063772,
0.5597223043,
0.5087617636,
0.1373822987,
-0.2650113404,
0.4140449464,
0.2275031507,
0.3120789826,
-0.6249918342,
0.7342104316,
-0.6494189501,
-0.2715076506,
-0.4095744789,
-0.1409810483,
-0.1217899919,
0.358633399,
0.5901560187,
0.6193643808,
-0.5454795957,
0.1064197645,
1.129347086,
-0.1857305467,
0.3177728951,
0.6696538329,
-0.0763492286,
-0.6128771901,
1.0098195076,
0.0778391883,
-0.0280267894,
0.6273195148,
-0.3064368367,
-0.2759039104,
-0.3339444697,
-0.5406611562,
0.2787399292,
-0.4813231528,
-0.6616063118,
-0.957398057,
-0.6402230859,
-0.2592462599,
0.0519277677,
-0.1675639302,
-0.3130073547,
-0.6917610765,
-0.0275792312,
0.4002484083,
0.9524201751,
0.0228356197,
0.3768680692,
-0.9554751515,
0.4931706488,
0.1189667955,
0.4051753581,
-0.0066700648,
-0.6419909,
0.0628467053,
0.0042750789,
-0.1444271058,
-1.1228846312,
0.851508379,
0.3592558801,
0.542368412,
0.6184127927,
-0.0034943277,
1.1443912983,
-0.5483020544,
0.4072650969,
0.1346669346,
-0.6872742176,
0.4066475928,
-0.1896287501,
-0.2590600252,
0.6937811971,
0.4760634303,
-0.7498716712,
0.0967579186,
-0.6449839473,
-0.4300835729,
1.1092960835,
-0.0078303032,
0.0578259192,
-0.0141151706,
0.719747901,
0.715420723,
0.2488569021,
-0.5811244249,
-0.2604138851,
0.3890375793,
-0.0772119984,
-0.0596842989,
-0.3395524025,
0.3315399885,
-0.3016298115,
0.7599824667,
0.1133534536,
0.0996913314,
0.1207232177,
-0.0949710757,
-0.212439239,
0.0593458675,
0.1964989752,
0.5429905653,
-0.0025242639,
0.0569766611,
0.311337471,
-0.8404787183,
0.0515231825,
0.0436815023,
-0.4867758155,
0.3059646189,
0.2322478443,
0.9151952863,
0.0481839664,
-0.3370762765,
0.2217862457,
-0.2764967978,
-0.0041923705,
-0.0100825634,
0.4254546165,
-0.5117772222,
0.2537891865,
0.2371014804,
0.2081838548,
0.4752172828,
-0.0740887374,
0.1755453497,
0.3406177461,
-0.5406430364,
-0.5758259296,
0.3756257892,
0.1518747509,
-0.4942815602,
0.7101848125,
-0.5219439864,
-0.3992973268,
0.7137283683,
0.7704947591,
1.3486051559,
-0.3221655786,
0.3422440886,
0.740113914,
0.3774985373,
-0.2300136536,
0.1256682724,
0.1125032008,
-0.6872009039,
-0.2637480795,
-1.0707067251,
-0.1420799643,
0.3674051464,
-0.576166451,
0.6628341079,
-0.3109112978,
-0.3877465129,
0.1643013805,
0.2093141079,
-0.9526174664,
0.3501841128,
0.0801329017,
0.7653872371,
-0.491317749,
0.665056169,
0.7921544313,
-0.1300225407,
-1.0053569078,
0.0304647181,
-0.1050930247,
-0.2634675801,
0.8517353535,
0.0956276804,
-0.0979204848,
0.3811336756,
-0.522015214,
-1.2231292725,
0.9731997848,
0.2338325828,
-0.8374780416,
-0.252074331,
-0.1577399373,
0.6486563087,
-0.4660470188,
0.2353899926,
0.4289060533,
0.4028560221,
0.1556942463,
-1.1037467718,
-0.1483983696,
-0.1426795572,
0.0850233138,
0.4675032496,
-0.0262750704,
0.8417211175,
-0.2082086056,
-0.6240506172,
-0.010639349,
0.6791809797,
0.0928635076,
0.4191683233,
0.6046988964,
0.7248364091,
0.8803281188,
-0.21021083,
0.7948375344,
-0.0505969077,
0.3490681052,
1.1337711811,
-0.5522842407,
0.5842302442,
0.0747857168,
0.1245680898,
0.5280787349,
0.7321761847,
-0.2480446398,
0.8624790907,
0.1092653349,
-0.1769212484,
-0.2812975943,
-0.3140210509,
-0.5208175778,
0.5402198434,
0.3869043589,
-0.2404199094,
-0.1605078876,
-0.0085303178,
-0.0378720053,
-0.2634595335,
-0.5044599175,
1.223246336,
0.0383521691,
-0.6850782633,
0.2697736025,
0.1634964794,
0.7159436941,
-0.5031868815,
-0.3101930618,
-0.1055228263,
0.3625154793,
-0.2744351625,
-0.4396886528,
0.2891462445,
0.2953754961,
-0.4009667337,
0.0131555619,
1.1215068102,
-0.3878368139,
-0.4836069942,
0.1963577271,
0.529953301,
0.1625708789,
0.0186837222,
-0.5399619341,
-0.2128639668,
-0.1406303793,
0.0323835164,
0.1458829194,
1.097260952,
-0.0456176251,
0.4243454933,
0.5974047184,
0.2893840969,
-0.1863700449,
-0.2376441061,
0.7596078515,
-0.6550187469,
-0.5024799109,
-1.0630072355,
0.0741438866,
-0.282553494,
-0.5636110902,
0.756136775,
0.5699221492,
0.857819736,
-0.1937553734,
0.3545284867,
-0.3233182728,
0.697924614,
-0.2363450378,
0.9664391875,
-0.5633369684,
0.0241579395,
-0.5070832372,
-1.2253227234,
-0.1480929554,
0.5453162789,
-0.1210891902,
-0.0401995964,
0.5121243,
0.8521865606,
-0.2291682512,
0.170374319,
0.2915726602,
0.0622135289,
0.0880847797,
0.3032757342,
0.9384960532,
-0.2890827656,
0.1709107161,
-0.3142161965,
0.0617666282,
-0.0799965486,
-0.9846583605,
-0.9102237821,
-0.5094971657,
-0.5301671028,
-0.291834265,
0.1867014319,
0.6778582931,
0.7625341415,
-1.0311857462,
-0.0308618806,
0.2685087919,
0.2084508985,
-0.3451106846,
-0.298465699,
0.2474502176,
0.0097768223,
-0.6869502664,
0.2328411043,
0.2753118575,
0.1240817085,
0.0348506421,
-0.1179716066,
0.0648109317,
-0.0293306243,
0.3046698272,
0.3281289637,
-0.6270797849,
-0.2896247804,
0.3264511824,
-0.2204299569,
-0.1928595155,
0.6380810142,
-0.9285314679,
0.5107553601,
0.5187937617,
0.624686718,
0.1443060935,
-0.007567775,
0.5436197519,
-0.5010028481,
-0.3782740533,
0.4874104261,
0.0016976916,
0.319558531,
-0.614166677,
0.6372494102,
0.2501096129,
-0.4639478922,
-0.9801250696,
-0.1707233042,
-0.6769727468,
-0.0447207056,
1.1623547077,
0.1292883158,
-0.2785236537,
-0.2115329206,
-0.2238718569,
0.2799519002,
-0.1555735469,
0.6243137121,
0.581355989,
0.1110739633,
0.1792174131,
-0.4742047489,
0.9685920477,
-0.3558588028,
-0.782638371,
-0.0733368173,
0.5861454606,
0.3582535386,
0.2891189754,
0.5084865689,
-0.0339540243,
0.1396448612,
-0.2894389629,
0.2235696167,
0.1692298502,
-0.6102567911,
-0.3930562437,
0.127692908,
-0.4773171246,
0.0352806151
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10659v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10659v3
|
Network Formation and Dynamics Among Multi-LLMs
| 2024-02-16T13:10:14 | 2024-06-02T13:50:14 |
Marios Papachristou, Yuan Yuan
|
cs.SI
|
cs.SI, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MA
|
Social networks shape opinions, behaviors, and information dissemination in
human societies. As large language models (LLMs) increasingly integrate into
social and professional environments, understanding their behavior within the
context of social interactions and networks becomes essential. Our study
analyzes LLMs' network formation behavior to examine whether the dynamics of
multiple LLMs are similar to or different from human social dynamics. We
observe that LLMs exhibit key social network principles, including preferential
attachment, triadic closure, homophily, community structure, and the
small-world phenomenon, when asked about their preferences in network
formation. We also investigate LLMs' decision-making based on real-world
networks, revealing that triadic closure and homophily have a stronger
influence than preferential attachment and that LLMs perform well in network
formation predictions. Overall, our study opens up new possibilities for using
LLMs in network science research and helps develop socially aware LLMs by
shedding light on their social interaction behaviors and exploring their
impacts on social dynamics.
|
[
-0.4865367711,
-0.9020951986,
0.4203582704,
0.178366974,
0.0729392394,
0.178408742,
-0.2450756729,
-0.356682539,
0.7699540854,
0.4467737675,
-0.6278824806,
-0.226317957,
-0.2889801562,
0.2772215307,
-0.2407973707,
0.7718231678,
0.248997882,
0.1026065126,
-0.1463061422,
-0.2158835679,
-0.2335880995,
-0.7839243412,
-0.8653284311,
-0.7195966244,
0.9460417628,
0.2896484733,
0.6493196487,
0.6478787661,
0.533346355,
0.406571418,
-0.3092996478,
0.2471836358,
-0.7833902836,
0.1215801686,
-0.1066914052,
-0.4129638672,
-0.4615038633,
0.0139785884,
0.8843021989,
0.7940645218,
-0.115351297,
0.1512857825,
0.3548604548,
0.9032897949,
-0.0353335254,
0.0913871452,
-0.4599526227,
0.1096304581,
-0.3420028985,
-0.2195290476,
-0.2211086452,
-0.5199685693,
0.3267402351,
-0.2367482483,
0.1374362409,
0.2704716027,
0.6424144506,
-0.3320091963,
-0.9108898044,
-0.1107848361,
-0.526248455,
0.2541216612,
-0.2267682999,
0.1598412097,
-0.0253626574,
0.3259601295,
-0.5556842685,
-0.5176153183,
-0.490165174,
-0.0175296422,
0.0993149877,
-0.2142394781,
0.3316403925,
0.261929214,
0.1363658011,
0.0440803841,
-0.2618200183,
0.2090893984,
-0.7231635451,
0.1337920874,
0.4442400932,
0.4233955145,
0.2834284604,
-0.1767888665,
-0.2793817222,
0.2273653448,
-0.915553987,
0.0749471486,
0.4438955486,
0.4467986226,
-0.2785604298,
0.6875146031,
0.0498731732,
0.3242778778,
-0.088914685,
-0.1841626763,
0.226917088,
-0.3480061889,
-0.2519052923,
0.0186212733,
0.8742492795,
0.5235176682,
0.7619658709,
0.1474641412,
0.0817097425,
-0.0166518427,
0.092791006,
-0.5627379417,
0.1964823157,
-0.1795076877,
-0.9607237577,
-0.5614373684,
0.1419893056,
-0.39834553,
-0.6555514336,
-0.4157261252,
0.1031592935,
-0.0703116208,
-0.6837751269,
0.0096174907,
-0.1735198945,
0.2411214858,
0.3729870021,
-0.5540626645,
0.6981549263,
0.5595738292,
1.1934767962,
-0.2178130001,
-0.7363755703,
-0.076352194,
0.272274226,
-0.2872063816,
0.4909945726,
-0.323635608,
-0.3680281341,
0.2647924125,
0.2447705716,
-0.163125664,
-0.3498167694,
-0.0811466575,
-0.6864495873,
-0.3363859355,
-0.4530016482,
-0.5430270433,
-0.150300473,
0.2726801634,
-0.6755516529,
0.5854333639,
-0.4187841713,
-0.7426825762,
0.1684648395,
-0.9373463392,
-0.3459528685,
-0.1917717457,
-0.2673084438,
0.1161811575,
0.1518416852,
-0.5962525606,
0.7139909863,
-0.1883394718,
0.2410401404,
-0.8509653807,
-0.161665827,
0.5321304202,
-0.1785367876,
0.657833755,
0.0122481855,
0.0831981003,
0.1146851107,
-0.3744619191,
-0.4557557404,
0.2025758326,
-0.3473453224,
-0.213499099,
0.320322752,
-0.4747287333,
0.3167489171,
-0.1073621362,
-0.2889602482,
0.5680008531,
-0.2633677721,
0.5975179672,
0.8443943858,
0.392675519,
0.3580650389,
-0.5160599351,
0.3739484251,
0.1479961425,
0.2007385492,
0.1216697246,
-0.5681633353,
-0.7102488279,
0.1956126541,
-0.1296000332,
0.1949011832,
-0.4733443856,
-0.1990453601,
-0.3480080962,
-0.3210614026,
0.0012461622,
0.2209388912,
0.3722091317,
0.1014160588,
-0.108429864,
-0.1670794338,
-0.5184497237,
-0.8689933419,
0.0553937592,
-0.2255525738,
0.6083881259,
0.4347376525,
0.5298350453,
-0.4020526409,
0.881423831,
-0.4790686965,
-0.1895757914,
-0.2394737005,
-0.1353674382,
0.2984905839,
0.0298940055,
0.6028482914,
-0.5613562465,
-0.4314975739,
-0.090107955,
-0.6768581271,
0.2027066648,
0.2206210047,
-0.1146164984,
-0.0089248605,
0.6417928934,
-0.4555934966,
0.1477631032,
0.7675052285,
-0.2969980538,
0.7027449608,
-0.0364719033,
0.0639496222,
-1.2095252275,
-0.5078958869,
0.1755449474,
-0.0769840479,
-0.7530896664,
-0.1923504919,
-0.4207550883,
0.1417970657,
-0.6430528164,
0.4290671051,
-0.8002165556,
-0.3683744371,
-0.0994298607,
0.3745290041,
-0.2286487967,
0.1955184639,
-0.1549135298,
0.6434751749,
0.8597952724,
-0.8932919502,
0.4233944714,
0.1533511877,
-0.2241891176,
0.085375011,
-0.7152158022,
-0.0358197391,
-0.0732077584,
0.3199521601,
-1.0900059938,
-0.3124620616,
-0.0070900079,
-0.2105963677,
0.0425575078,
-0.2949568033,
-0.6807566881,
-0.3088952601,
-0.4482477903,
0.353102386,
0.1113599166,
-0.3537839353,
0.2522381246,
0.7301678658,
0.0498549268,
-0.2911322117,
-0.8031458855,
0.0990670547,
-0.2791843414,
-1.0761859417,
0.0512064882,
-0.052278351,
-0.5932277441,
-0.3193038404,
0.2587257326,
-0.065008305,
0.1252563447,
0.5294970274,
0.0637788028,
-0.3384869397,
0.1981314868,
0.1197469309,
0.3294570446,
0.2713722587,
0.0470062606,
0.752687037,
-0.4632302821,
-0.3401094973,
-0.2188684046,
-0.0063917795,
0.8790088892,
0.00748921,
0.9959719777,
0.2337132394,
-0.1058568954,
-0.1115217358,
-0.3914805651,
-0.4160721302,
-0.5640287399,
0.135997951,
-0.4482322633,
-1.1655580997,
0.7655768394,
-0.4276112318,
-0.2002379149,
0.0804291293,
0.6613503098,
-0.2179801911,
0.7959107161,
0.5051886439,
0.0357873216,
0.4631167948,
-0.2413461059,
0.0054993709,
-1.147736907,
-0.2165623605,
-0.1911360919,
-0.4207837582,
-0.7834035158,
-0.3253393471,
0.4745379686,
0.1677483916,
-0.0923496708,
0.101892814,
-0.1855967939,
0.4536572695,
0.1063793451,
0.1005095914,
0.1349884272,
-0.037346229,
-0.4418429732,
0.2867085934,
-0.6029339433,
-0.7097666264,
0.9581868649,
0.3628887236,
0.7488760352,
0.7895900607,
0.7904960513,
0.2750711143,
0.273683399,
-0.5465688705,
0.7030417919,
0.0835975632,
-0.3851333559,
-0.3560269177,
-0.2643697262,
-1.3220728636,
0.1869722456,
-0.519179225,
-0.9297935963,
0.1070554107,
0.1677330285,
-0.1416821331,
0.2267630249,
-0.3437638283,
0.3820455074,
0.033348307,
-0.2570663095,
-0.2894211411,
-0.8661824465,
0.6346854568,
0.0206304286,
0.5277826786,
-0.4176848829,
-0.063099958,
0.4761690497,
-0.2367111295,
1.1337339878,
0.1620258242,
-0.0690623671,
0.4356786311,
0.2780019343,
0.462939024,
0.1301755607,
-0.1352539212,
0.2664310634,
-0.0789995193,
0.2608248293,
-0.3772979379,
0.8656820059,
-0.9826775193,
-0.5871179104,
-0.1503885537,
-0.2574466765,
0.0443362929,
0.2254164666,
-0.0687283948,
0.6272547245,
-0.4451011717,
0.232972309,
0.7127943039,
0.1745525002,
0.6373481154,
0.3401881754,
-0.7835136056,
-0.3450495601,
0.6696940064,
0.2568734288,
0.634689033,
0.0730194673,
0.4718634784,
-0.2049457282,
-0.4173785746,
-0.1255583912,
0.6257826686,
-0.4945262671,
0.0139842732,
-0.6412854195,
-0.2461497635,
-0.470315963,
-0.0723356605,
-0.0874713957,
-0.3734850287,
-0.2617497742,
-0.051221855,
0.3354896009,
1.0252070427,
-0.0871302336,
0.4447633326,
-0.8558380008,
0.1374695748,
0.2387348861,
0.3647697866,
0.0892602652,
-0.1205594391,
-0.2797930837,
-0.1822749078,
-0.2421886176,
-1.3208222389,
-0.0065150443,
0.489112556,
0.4859741926,
0.8173731565,
-0.1961667538,
0.4007639289,
-0.6065236926,
0.8557595015,
0.3460624218,
-0.754011035,
0.3520587087,
-0.7714614868,
-0.1623672992,
0.2894652486,
0.2277243286,
-0.7637713552,
-0.2691345811,
-0.4641310573,
-0.4782877266,
0.6482621431,
0.2032520324,
0.2904278338,
-0.1937537342,
0.6082512736,
-0.4633421302,
0.3669779003,
-0.9551038742,
-0.7351351976,
0.227144137,
0.3140487671,
0.1931719631,
-0.3751529753,
-0.305514276,
-0.1429791301,
0.2118294388,
-0.2492061406,
0.1713159978,
-0.059462484,
0.2817319036,
-0.1850955188,
0.0670745149,
0.8659584522,
0.6706118584,
-0.0549087264,
0.369889468,
0.131499961,
-0.256228745,
0.4170348644,
-0.7685577273,
0.1276652664,
-0.1894528121,
0.1166869849,
0.5924055576,
0.1123912036,
-0.1521970779,
0.6017439961,
-0.2459281683,
-0.3863183558,
-0.1774985492,
0.3151847422,
0.6073397994,
0.3957062066,
-0.0456966572,
0.0600429811,
0.0579771101,
-0.7786642313,
0.0505729727,
0.4692265391,
-0.1579815,
-0.4706770778,
0.1074936762,
0.4486720264,
-0.5389964581,
0.3518690467,
-0.2438066304,
-0.4931182265,
0.684140265,
0.6145700216,
0.7522020936,
-0.2952504158,
0.2831424773,
0.0704092234,
0.4371584356,
-0.2308145165,
0.2701615989,
0.2967514098,
-1.1952605247,
-0.2241802812,
-0.4122753143,
-0.2721084356,
-0.2242818028,
-0.519179225,
0.5387108922,
-0.5196057558,
-0.6036036611,
-0.0683842227,
-0.10967087,
-0.4289636314,
-0.1675221473,
0.0123162288,
0.6820032597,
-0.7493271232,
0.8073987961,
0.8715263009,
-0.1756401062,
-0.8952757716,
-0.1628468782,
0.5856819153,
-0.6492933035,
0.8384201527,
0.3232966661,
-0.6113857627,
-0.016986154,
-0.4363321662,
-1.211504221,
1.1273988485,
0.2070365548,
-0.4896903634,
0.0161804147,
0.0683776811,
0.4658400416,
-0.6452217698,
0.089754194,
0.0788809583,
0.4105778933,
0.0832246393,
-0.8896738887,
0.0837331414,
-0.0966719687,
0.1506048292,
0.4529573321,
-1.2470442057,
0.9500303268,
-0.3720247149,
-0.3055256903,
-0.2148732543,
0.5066315532,
0.4080074131,
0.2045640051,
0.4210680723,
-0.0539803356,
0.6643964052,
0.2822387218,
0.6582437158,
-0.5929545164,
0.2268382013,
0.9145287275,
-0.4158195853,
0.5607323647,
0.464897573,
-0.1014042273,
0.6287873387,
0.7334732413,
0.0938663408,
0.0822159573,
0.5343564749,
0.0162487384,
0.0532510243,
-0.2510768473,
-0.3208376765,
0.4811597764,
0.4122619033,
-0.3536076844,
0.1553955972,
-0.2023287416,
0.0894902721,
-0.3370323181,
-0.4197896421,
0.7330254316,
0.3233662844,
-0.3503078222,
0.0796598792,
-0.0821764991,
0.4923749864,
-0.5775344968,
0.0893597901,
0.0965934619,
-0.0624150783,
-0.4074354768,
-0.8815133572,
0.2512798905,
-0.3751617074,
-0.3372773528,
0.0447449237,
0.688703835,
-0.2795017064,
-0.0394434296,
0.5637623072,
0.7234920263,
0.4438433349,
0.4037960768,
-0.6082583666,
0.1833310425,
-0.131050691,
-0.3928185105,
0.5151728392,
0.6895653605,
-0.0202064961,
0.7845172286,
0.7226125598,
0.3781140447,
0.271797657,
0.2942034602,
0.8155834079,
-0.4218495786,
-0.0910029858,
-1.0968761444,
0.2203612626,
-0.2252533138,
-0.347722888,
0.910235703,
0.2354991734,
0.4783450663,
0.3340568542,
0.4911346436,
0.1651697755,
0.0483662486,
-0.4576926231,
0.7100694776,
-0.4998255372,
0.3570435643,
-0.4814870656,
-0.8916208744,
-0.0668952093,
0.3635571599,
0.0578834526,
-0.0254203845,
0.750831008,
0.8837813139,
0.1361967474,
-0.0001319995,
0.2062031329,
0.2503600121,
0.3645919859,
-0.0310045723,
0.9774047136,
0.0938813835,
0.3789117634,
0.0809895024,
-0.1629960835,
-0.186259076,
-0.9961714745,
-1.1017600298,
-0.4405765235,
-0.2489692271,
-0.4430401623,
-0.2879732847,
1.2383834124,
0.582881391,
-0.2661193013,
-0.881581068,
-0.0137388958,
0.4232685864,
0.0708486438,
-0.2839354873,
0.0377867185,
-0.2895487249,
-0.1761588305,
0.3650803566,
0.4431847036,
0.1732491851,
-0.4784334898,
-0.2657190859,
-0.4444772303,
0.3591313958,
0.7685879469,
0.084923692,
-0.6275655627,
-0.1866187751,
-0.0969930962,
-0.2438485473,
0.1252880394,
1.0063127279,
-0.1037715003,
0.2670535445,
0.4172403514,
0.1725937426,
0.1556080878,
-0.2433815151,
0.6104818583,
-0.7107874155,
-0.2271483392,
-0.2643159032,
0.5030480027,
0.1234486625,
-0.2231056243,
0.5151478648,
0.4076415002,
-0.7857455611,
-0.7846226096,
0.4713019729,
-0.6486616135,
-0.1488526911,
1.440454483,
0.2007980645,
-0.2388262451,
-0.1340336651,
-0.1859609187,
0.2691673636,
-0.4674675465,
0.3506101966,
0.6166476011,
-0.6405043006,
-0.1503570974,
-0.248733446,
0.456404984,
-0.1507462114,
-0.6661342382,
-0.0646134168,
0.4581498206,
0.2702479064,
0.3246747851,
0.7588185668,
0.2725841701,
-0.2465713024,
-0.3671028316,
-0.18943578,
-0.0367760211,
-0.5324624181,
-0.1770026982,
0.341538161,
0.2461389899,
0.1253063977
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10654v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10654v1
|
Enhancing Numerical Reasoning with the Guidance of Reliable Reasoning Processes
| 2024-02-16T13:02:11 | 2024-02-16T13:02:11 |
Dingzirui Wang, Longxu Dou, Xuanliang Zhang, Qingfu Zhu, Wanxiang Che
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Numerical reasoning is an essential ability for NLP systems to handle numeric
information. Recent research indicates that fine-tuning a small-scale model to
learn generating reasoning processes alongside answers can significantly
enhance performance. However, current methods have the limitation that most
methods generate reasoning processes with large language models (LLMs), which
are "unreliable" since such processes could contain information unrelated to
the answer. To address this limitation, we introduce Enhancing NumeriCal
reasOning with Reliable procEsses (Encore), which derives the reliable
reasoning process by decomposing the answer formula, ensuring which fully
supports the answer. Nevertheless, models could lack enough data to learn the
reasoning process generation adequately, since our method generates only one
single reasoning process for one formula. To overcome this difficulty, we
present a series of pre-training tasks to help models learn the reasoning
process generation with synthesized data. The experiments show that Encore
yields improvement on all five experimental datasets with an average of 1.8%,
proving the effectiveness of our method.
|
[
-0.2662035823,
-0.6309748292,
0.7801241279,
0.4232821167,
-0.2511866689,
0.0814165697,
-0.1467362642,
-0.2403400987,
0.0276782028,
0.8402082324,
-0.531396091,
-0.3002390862,
-0.4921534061,
0.2941942513,
-0.0428223498,
0.8343989849,
0.1077164784,
0.1485127211,
-0.4935736358,
0.0251898468,
-0.3636534512,
-0.4972397089,
-0.9095059037,
-0.4986510575,
0.3214254975,
0.5599535704,
0.730512619,
0.5819142461,
0.6203006506,
0.2557657659,
-0.1632878631,
0.7560924888,
-0.5770115852,
0.5179497004,
-0.271317035,
-0.3545549512,
-0.5164778829,
-0.4329800904,
0.6878785491,
0.7555348277,
-0.2199200243,
0.1001829579,
0.1547967046,
0.7836508751,
-0.5256219506,
0.2049033642,
-0.9252223372,
-0.0175396856,
0.1415115148,
-0.5408530235,
-0.6734339595,
-0.6861276627,
-0.2425699383,
-0.7051407099,
-0.0639062524,
-0.1198521703,
0.3746836483,
0.6939809918,
0.0428181626,
0.1035745367,
-0.8306129575,
0.8066116571,
-0.9027751684,
0.0321059935,
0.4062892497,
0.1077273786,
-0.4372439086,
-0.7968461514,
-0.3333007991,
-0.1936366111,
0.1745815724,
-0.0111705679,
-0.0026539201,
0.1445640773,
0.9110780954,
-0.2025384605,
-0.3785873055,
-0.2052997053,
-0.2933907807,
-0.2207497656,
0.7836747169,
0.2132866383,
0.1719470471,
-0.0248708259,
-0.1115617678,
-0.1480015516,
-0.8230019212,
-0.1681396812,
0.1765777469,
0.4429099262,
0.4535436034,
0.596442163,
-0.1584866345,
0.6041980386,
-0.2447957247,
-0.1656410843,
0.4276112914,
-0.2011871636,
-0.1119209379,
0.1661708951,
0.4965482056,
0.0176136643,
0.2806117833,
-0.1171076521,
-0.2703815997,
0.0733477846,
0.5730513334,
-0.7367802262,
-0.2478377223,
0.2187502533,
-0.0813004375,
-0.1215602532,
0.0153481672,
-0.2814474702,
-0.0227377787,
-0.6491319537,
0.3508128226,
-0.6320851445,
-0.3990799189,
0.2997655869,
-0.2289267033,
-0.1148321331,
0.4315440953,
-0.6706210375,
0.1818515956,
0.9602211118,
0.5224143863,
-0.0293258969,
-0.1183895394,
-1.0660611391,
-0.0087686703,
-0.6758703589,
0.9095950127,
-0.7750548124,
-0.3799040318,
-0.3346502483,
-0.1961661726,
0.0934472308,
-0.7293775678,
1.0697786808,
-0.4714743495,
-0.4122902453,
-0.4659622014,
-0.5676664114,
-0.1342064887,
0.1853408515,
-0.4544577897,
1.2793929577,
-0.1858663112,
-0.6531569362,
0.245115146,
-0.7971525192,
-0.3188112676,
0.0244831741,
0.0372555368,
-0.4499450326,
0.3294317424,
0.5301773548,
0.2711425424,
0.0366825908,
0.4108866751,
-0.6390496492,
-0.2458504289,
0.1213458851,
-0.5543100238,
0.5481402874,
0.2109205574,
-0.1165484041,
0.0765976757,
-1.0656073093,
0.4929705262,
-0.0309505686,
-0.1710706949,
-0.1848552376,
0.0150605766,
-0.6068150997,
0.1513997316,
-0.0253268331,
-0.3268300891,
0.2267155498,
-0.5466843247,
0.1022302061,
0.6012168527,
0.3988640904,
0.4227200449,
-0.2733424902,
0.7737684846,
-0.0536177456,
-0.130107522,
-0.4700444639,
-0.5101158023,
-0.6705086827,
0.2024431974,
0.1691419333,
0.5975851417,
-1.1375486851,
0.1313645989,
-0.184526965,
-0.4675536454,
-0.0924079791,
0.0974228308,
0.3534328043,
0.8237975836,
0.4858101904,
0.1687405854,
-0.8696495295,
-0.5796701908,
-0.3367700279,
-0.1699708551,
-0.1111458242,
0.1721637398,
0.4535764158,
0.0180599447,
0.7086629868,
-0.477478534,
0.304695636,
-0.108024925,
0.4695668519,
0.3843599558,
0.552161932,
0.3002498746,
-0.5285937786,
-0.4051097929,
-0.0597814284,
-0.9184214473,
-0.2609368265,
-0.1504218429,
-0.2997846603,
0.2281829119,
0.5004498959,
-0.2756930292,
0.3693186939,
0.313424021,
-0.1161930114,
0.8251289725,
-0.508027494,
0.0234691855,
-0.6317578554,
-0.0226585902,
0.0455648378,
-0.3385033906,
-0.4510235488,
-0.0249518566,
-0.2478133887,
-0.2019025981,
-0.3991662264,
0.3796440661,
-0.4212478101,
-0.0668302923,
-0.453071177,
-0.0527525693,
0.1307931393,
0.1220907494,
0.5350550413,
0.8426185846,
0.6328908205,
-0.7049016356,
0.2341030985,
0.1722632051,
-0.3466365337,
0.2271381617,
-0.8338114619,
0.2673108876,
-0.2140888274,
0.0855997652,
-0.7583483458,
-0.2383322865,
-0.0037710655,
-0.5965367556,
0.12615183,
-0.2999115586,
-0.5027220845,
-0.3834199011,
0.0534816869,
0.0749035329,
0.6043559313,
-0.623795867,
0.8354528546,
0.1990754902,
-0.5678150058,
-0.7918868661,
-0.4309071898,
0.0503048934,
-0.2278573811,
-0.8491317034,
0.1628757864,
0.0731606036,
-0.3629575074,
-0.06158714,
-0.1562422216,
-0.1409213394,
0.06916859,
0.1242180392,
0.113517262,
-0.2135958672,
0.4171338081,
0.4146710336,
-0.4793241918,
0.4397515953,
-0.3181133866,
0.1519925892,
-0.1621763259,
-0.2748143971,
-0.3361026943,
0.2029285729,
0.5124237537,
-0.2322911024,
0.8565681577,
0.5511068702,
-0.4243209064,
-0.5216915011,
-0.4002735615,
-0.6186822057,
-0.4416049421,
0.0948756561,
-0.5083087087,
-0.5297319889,
0.5303338766,
-0.3466271162,
0.1276552677,
0.4692057073,
0.167224735,
0.0680346042,
1.4091014862,
0.3105165064,
0.4667699337,
-0.0350350849,
-0.2102866322,
0.0347891487,
-0.7575570345,
-0.4067761302,
-0.6645138264,
0.0417293981,
0.0179447215,
-0.5202983022,
0.5324195027,
0.3697192371,
-0.2601326406,
0.1108039171,
-0.783534348,
0.6788875461,
0.5289247632,
0.1726302803,
0.3216511309,
0.264937669,
-0.20070526,
-0.3700612783,
-0.9158875942,
-0.6946979761,
1.008035779,
0.2270106673,
0.7861434221,
-0.1215799525,
0.6739630699,
0.0880026668,
0.3655334711,
-0.2761944532,
0.5468344688,
-0.1344659328,
-0.2458176613,
-0.3186232746,
-0.7931014895,
-0.5289657712,
0.1872874051,
-0.5078645349,
-0.5173170567,
-0.0360060371,
0.4527968168,
-0.5892051458,
0.2615984082,
-0.5370268226,
0.6587712169,
-0.4647330046,
-0.7954164743,
-0.1839662641,
-0.3992201686,
0.4339764118,
-0.0835832581,
0.0744869187,
-0.0699646249,
0.2763688266,
0.5580880642,
-0.8058816791,
0.606936872,
-0.3819051981,
-0.0699370354,
0.5462536812,
0.1479090154,
0.7603756189,
0.3593063653,
-0.5799816847,
-0.0187630896,
-0.0720340088,
-0.2166388184,
-0.9189557433,
0.5945531726,
-0.3084352911,
-0.5991979837,
-0.3524667919,
-0.4614630938,
-0.2635117173,
0.0676064938,
0.0201533139,
0.4269173145,
0.2797705829,
0.4070598483,
0.8410850763,
-0.1987200677,
0.1863479316,
0.1217588037,
-0.2966411114,
-0.6376820803,
0.7344079614,
-0.0049241865,
0.2077759504,
0.1957582086,
0.2219078243,
-0.7267692685,
-0.6426897645,
-0.2463898659,
0.0686412305,
-0.697244823,
-0.2988925576,
-0.693587482,
-0.2747289836,
-0.3625812829,
-0.029791085,
-0.5150834322,
-0.7390405536,
-0.3577135801,
-0.2062147558,
0.4675238431,
0.3711127341,
-0.4894880652,
0.0211005434,
-1.1803554296,
0.3869730532,
0.1974761635,
0.2218176574,
0.0654913336,
-0.7104183435,
0.0777880028,
0.3763217032,
-0.2161354423,
-0.4848611653,
0.5517782569,
0.3247783184,
0.6656876206,
0.3783925772,
0.2146472186,
0.7683771253,
-0.6126506925,
0.7129788995,
0.0123982523,
-0.7916003466,
0.8109805584,
-0.4349617362,
0.3949238956,
0.5241366029,
0.4434012771,
0.090870142,
-0.2547813952,
-0.7435973883,
-0.8384429216,
0.6359132528,
0.2870617211,
0.0925704315,
-0.2925669253,
0.7169318199,
0.1322146207,
0.0426440276,
-0.4937832355,
0.0532519184,
-0.0897334665,
0.1504667103,
0.2381777167,
-0.2702758908,
-0.0294249803,
-0.455296427,
1.1228513718,
-0.343980819,
-0.1324849129,
0.0950767174,
0.3417812586,
0.0131998044,
0.06149197,
0.7119508982,
0.9606113434,
-0.0940740556,
0.0788187161,
0.2707040906,
-0.1679759473,
-0.0533064157,
-0.016140053,
-0.0970652476,
0.0781846568,
0.2162518799,
0.7505158782,
0.1241380051,
-0.6953654289,
0.0204372387,
-0.0560922399,
-0.3579803705,
-0.6197796464,
0.431637913,
0.1157700643,
0.1643208712,
0.4422926903,
0.4329708219,
0.0310931988,
-0.0902055725,
0.4527373016,
0.3110633194,
-0.137517646,
-0.0167372804,
0.8118494153,
0.1259744167,
-0.1977046877,
0.9330742955,
-0.4238343835,
-0.5046525598,
0.7162364125,
0.7067435384,
0.6973981261,
-0.0588509776,
0.3856800199,
0.90947932,
0.1960780323,
-0.7720823884,
0.5635105371,
-0.0109973364,
-0.7545651197,
-1.0702109337,
-0.6444852352,
-0.6443027258,
-0.0443733111,
-0.6721087694,
0.1633866131,
-0.3601304889,
-0.2967884839,
-0.0571169704,
-0.4125169516,
-0.2881957889,
0.2863883376,
0.0368391983,
0.8995098472,
-0.7918364406,
0.5195224285,
0.4946963191,
-0.3807610273,
-1.0240677595,
-0.45456779,
-0.3134444654,
-0.4154119492,
0.8160245419,
0.0288470499,
-0.3215880692,
-0.1414540112,
-0.6837235689,
-0.9311795831,
0.3979072869,
0.805138886,
-0.471600771,
0.1760339886,
0.0450773276,
0.6390324235,
-0.4067327976,
0.3263609707,
0.4529963434,
0.5902841091,
0.6196924448,
-0.5800585151,
-0.1292200089,
-0.3165671229,
-0.0442644395,
0.1219318658,
0.0446715467,
0.380322665,
-0.6680378318,
-0.1377281696,
0.0634797141,
0.7314312458,
0.8126996756,
0.3278631568,
0.3665949106,
0.8848519325,
0.9486907721,
-0.3800163865,
1.0723477602,
-0.3273056746,
0.0344919562,
1.4268280268,
-0.3178832829,
1.05851686,
0.2265883237,
-0.0745251179,
0.5927361846,
0.3525688052,
0.1260633171,
0.1663490683,
0.1366917491,
-0.3604774773,
-0.8909850717,
-0.0259206537,
-0.365601629,
0.2973002791,
0.6181584597,
-0.4499364197,
-0.1357176006,
-0.0948555395,
-0.1042878032,
0.4698534906,
-0.4518075287,
0.6053349972,
0.2235895544,
-1.0685218573,
0.691154182,
-0.3303151429,
0.0940962955,
-0.6307486892,
-0.5855382681,
0.0252342131,
0.2002456188,
-0.472686559,
-0.7837061882,
0.7087842226,
-0.0097616874,
-0.1870827079,
-0.4322602153,
0.869677484,
-0.3039980829,
-0.9102227092,
-0.0725673586,
0.2791651189,
0.3643070161,
-0.2345713973,
-0.5599071383,
0.0681059808,
0.104857862,
-0.0460560769,
-0.1440773904,
0.5038632154,
0.1239476055,
0.9255882502,
0.9309307933,
0.317377001,
0.0512760431,
0.2688258588,
0.7092083693,
-0.4671469033,
-0.2327075303,
-0.8200868368,
0.7587430477,
-0.4436083436,
-0.0691192895,
0.7107631564,
0.4990124702,
0.5704234838,
-0.0886651501,
0.826613009,
0.4661487639,
0.690641284,
-0.7355810404,
0.3085428178,
-0.2906088233,
0.6338614225,
-0.1259638071,
-1.2254385948,
-0.6139718294,
0.8314085603,
-0.3122537136,
0.1183981895,
0.5054135919,
0.6984767914,
0.0714233667,
0.272300452,
0.1773328632,
0.1620668471,
0.3461849093,
0.4505884945,
0.7863119245,
-0.1508729607,
0.432882607,
-0.2936572134,
-0.1380005926,
0.154623419,
-1.3694640398,
-0.531028986,
-0.0592766516,
-0.5062243938,
-0.54237324,
0.0221872758,
0.8396440148,
0.6518572569,
-0.5439337492,
0.2942059338,
-0.4680763483,
0.2106838673,
-0.4636183083,
-0.2508833706,
0.2246552259,
-0.752327621,
-0.4902341664,
0.6691474915,
0.4644099176,
-0.2326675951,
-0.1430417299,
-0.1186133698,
0.2597761154,
0.1522914767,
0.5229215622,
0.5996745825,
-0.4792298377,
-0.2463353127,
0.180705905,
0.5751300454,
0.1408488005,
0.6234971881,
-0.8660000563,
0.5758630633,
0.6930422783,
0.7976503968,
0.5181961656,
0.4796220064,
0.7391495109,
-0.6014741659,
-0.1052905843,
0.5079246759,
0.4339534342,
0.3883123398,
-0.1865077317,
0.7036142945,
-0.0592756085,
-0.8061733842,
-0.9769355655,
0.2143262476,
-0.7494072914,
-0.0694225803,
1.2050303221,
-0.1767528802,
-0.1283049136,
-0.0221110508,
-0.1522387415,
-0.03226576,
-0.4087175429,
0.6836804152,
0.4344483018,
-0.5176209807,
-0.2837710083,
-0.2298348993,
0.5049902201,
0.4347805083,
-0.9334557056,
0.0111914063,
0.4452492297,
0.1327877194,
0.3798058629,
0.5343085527,
-0.3127783835,
0.2635208666,
0.329336822,
-0.1407085806,
-0.2467000932,
-0.5522261858,
-0.1468418688,
0.3345321119,
0.1180895269,
0.3686560392
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10646v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10646v2
|
AbsInstruct: Eliciting Abstraction Ability from LLMs through Explanation Tuning with Plausibility Estimation
| 2024-02-16T12:47:11 | 2024-06-17T16:39:02 |
Zhaowei Wang, Wei Fan, Qing Zong, Hongming Zhang, Sehyun Choi, Tianqing Fang, Xin Liu, Yangqiu Song, Ginny Y. Wong, Simon See
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Abstraction ability is crucial in human intelligence, which can also benefit
various tasks in NLP study. Existing work shows that LLMs are deficient in
abstract ability, and how to improve it remains unexplored. In this work, we
design the framework AbsInstruct to enhance LLMs' abstraction ability through
instruction tuning. The framework builds instructions with in-depth
explanations to assist LLMs in capturing the underlying rationale of
abstraction. Meanwhile, we introduce a plausibility estimator to select
instructions that are more consistent with the abstraction knowledge of LLMs to
be aligned. Then, our framework combines abstraction instructions with
general-purpose ones to build a hybrid dataset. Extensive experiments and
analyses demonstrate that our framework can considerably enhance LLMs'
abstraction ability with strong generalization performance while maintaining
their general instruction-following abilities.
|
[
-0.241653055,
-0.5746082664,
0.5796461701,
0.0902607813,
-0.1636977345,
0.2240607888,
-0.1100560129,
-0.3566273749,
0.1309636384,
0.2449005991,
-0.721122086,
-0.6310498714,
-0.3977192044,
-0.0692885667,
-0.4872480631,
0.844175458,
-0.1141015738,
-0.1361296773,
-0.7535295486,
0.1351492256,
-0.3849460483,
0.0217800345,
-0.2991119921,
-0.5811806321,
-0.0875913575,
0.512735188,
0.4856193364,
0.9483988285,
0.2435283512,
0.3813031018,
-0.0388198048,
0.4343776703,
-0.214084059,
-0.1373921335,
-0.4534897804,
-0.6724912524,
-0.6728454828,
-0.3658638,
0.5076311231,
0.814764142,
0.0018015932,
0.1070762202,
0.2647641897,
0.7037793398,
-0.8430597782,
0.2005454153,
-0.5859851241,
0.0037551092,
-0.0078801978,
-0.2634836435,
-0.393986553,
-0.1709987968,
0.0263585858,
-0.7056818008,
0.2154460102,
0.071373634,
0.4742712379,
0.4452386796,
-0.2139710635,
-0.2478910983,
-0.5441012979,
0.68980515,
-0.7831819654,
0.0927285925,
0.4714768529,
0.0707203895,
-0.2431613803,
-0.698338449,
-0.2074685246,
0.0379880331,
-0.1628172994,
0.3399980664,
-0.0125115328,
0.4605246186,
0.093530409,
0.715678215,
-0.4442453086,
0.3923063576,
-0.2048748881,
-0.433578372,
0.6981483698,
0.2187201679,
0.3416911066,
0.1431107968,
-0.4496273994,
0.4197327495,
-0.676420033,
-0.03677468,
0.4634954631,
-0.0054863081,
-0.2360881716,
0.6868642569,
-0.2348731905,
0.886839509,
0.1808273196,
0.0234599467,
0.2727526128,
-0.3632092178,
-0.1991156489,
0.248590529,
0.3867323101,
0.1167927384,
0.191215679,
-0.3642211556,
-0.2915661633,
0.0909266472,
0.2736068666,
-0.7041078806,
-0.3050492406,
0.5451068282,
-0.4422349334,
0.0891060531,
0.2365080267,
-0.5659934282,
-0.3351162374,
-0.6306116581,
0.4856933057,
-0.7398971319,
-0.3983762264,
0.3922584653,
-0.1009973884,
0.290414542,
0.2217030972,
-1.0658819675,
0.461895287,
0.8516734242,
0.8057757616,
-0.3742011786,
-0.2071515918,
-0.4189035594,
0.3391781747,
-0.203725487,
1.0742843151,
-0.5482127666,
-0.3318834603,
-0.2174774706,
-0.1812448651,
-0.2991158366,
-0.6449195147,
0.5948678851,
-0.2028111666,
-0.0194041561,
0.1080530882,
-1.0527408123,
-0.4067486823,
-0.2383380681,
-0.4216920435,
0.7789823413,
0.1656338274,
-0.6507841945,
-0.0495148711,
-0.9164230824,
-0.6894018054,
0.2572403848,
-0.3029149175,
-0.3557908535,
0.4871451259,
0.2887151539,
0.3389922678,
-0.0689748377,
-0.0277318303,
-0.0086748367,
-0.7617632151,
0.1844171584,
-0.2845137715,
0.9679394364,
-0.1421715617,
-0.3572944105,
0.1685563326,
-0.7790240049,
0.1830922365,
-0.2680283487,
-0.2788746655,
-0.1959157288,
0.1734142452,
-0.6822140217,
-0.2347888947,
0.3336604238,
-0.3857592642,
-0.1056160182,
-0.9245199561,
0.220957607,
0.8887693286,
0.1626975238,
0.7305383086,
-0.5321645737,
0.6416348219,
-0.0726186186,
-0.0880527794,
-0.1805448532,
-0.481256783,
-0.6923258305,
-0.682411015,
0.1817681491,
0.790381074,
-0.5982504487,
0.8314929605,
-0.0883358866,
-0.229761973,
-0.7249153852,
0.5425726175,
0.5438563824,
0.683468163,
0.5356474519,
-0.1718840152,
-0.6716641188,
-1.1782106161,
-0.2647018135,
0.0083592627,
-0.5335725546,
-0.0795116648,
0.599429369,
-0.0000924772,
1.019928813,
-0.2584808767,
-0.1667814404,
-0.1714447737,
0.2119265646,
0.2102980316,
0.4505113363,
0.3642165363,
-0.5208727121,
-0.080968596,
-0.0653797239,
-0.8365240097,
-0.3310899138,
-0.0740231648,
-0.2794359624,
0.0266654082,
0.4916860759,
-0.4381304085,
0.5238617063,
0.340064615,
-0.1896548122,
0.6914277673,
-0.219100222,
-0.1368877888,
-0.9320676923,
-0.099631235,
-0.0119356783,
0.0074334876,
-0.4331376851,
-0.0579737797,
-0.0191799048,
0.2421189994,
-0.4198117256,
0.3896037638,
-0.6365585923,
-0.231515035,
-0.3904612958,
0.0202652644,
0.0109058507,
0.4879891276,
0.1715913713,
0.7819135189,
0.766035378,
-0.7932568789,
0.209257409,
0.2824887335,
-0.7369483709,
0.7189355493,
-0.8651970625,
0.0407622233,
-0.1594224125,
-0.0780986622,
-1.0408196449,
-0.3914067149,
0.1912551969,
-0.2090232968,
0.216585815,
-0.1893842518,
-0.3618832827,
0.0287461355,
-0.2700005472,
0.0802229196,
0.4171176255,
-0.4942286909,
1.1390588284,
0.1623084247,
-0.1528370082,
-0.5577456951,
-0.7915866375,
-0.2961024046,
-0.1564723104,
-0.4862145782,
0.8037425876,
-0.2847848535,
-0.3206624091,
0.1167367697,
-0.2736254036,
0.0336377621,
0.2489417493,
0.4213575125,
0.2593926787,
-0.3463090956,
0.0382330716,
0.5719864964,
-0.2334514707,
0.297331363,
-0.0627881438,
0.23404257,
-0.1954183578,
-0.7399556637,
-0.8995749354,
0.2230228335,
0.3586582541,
-0.2468337566,
0.6381524205,
0.2045698613,
-0.1360017508,
-0.4850908518,
-0.0952219591,
-0.3590203822,
-0.5432491899,
0.4920481443,
-0.3260139823,
-0.4699982703,
0.4586298466,
-0.4303019047,
0.5393403172,
0.0196198188,
0.4576368928,
-0.2643651366,
0.8761505485,
0.3774165213,
0.2508021295,
0.3674789667,
-0.38034302,
-0.1114282608,
-0.8882715702,
-0.3078480065,
-0.2048428357,
-0.6308200359,
-0.0459960885,
-0.263294667,
0.1771648079,
0.2053394318,
-0.3907234371,
0.0049726581,
-0.5307967663,
0.7254013419,
0.4773164988,
0.4278012514,
0.4924204946,
0.2682956457,
-0.0915392712,
-0.0715186074,
-0.7060934901,
-0.3883168697,
0.8498178124,
0.3252671659,
0.5835496783,
0.2572540641,
0.5958521366,
0.1734798253,
0.4469738901,
-0.8970721364,
0.690466702,
-0.2177822292,
-0.4532057941,
0.0301946197,
-0.3014216423,
-0.5040742159,
0.1762870699,
-0.379075557,
-0.7249265909,
0.024454806,
0.4013553262,
-0.2204435766,
0.1689808071,
-0.789866209,
0.4804779887,
-0.561694622,
-0.3387428522,
-0.1621191055,
-0.5088062882,
0.5592038035,
0.0268276446,
0.1700289845,
-0.0999714136,
-0.4483285546,
0.6183653474,
-0.3727134168,
1.2095315456,
-0.1000311747,
-0.1425338537,
0.173429057,
0.1231285259,
0.2928615212,
0.0484418906,
-0.431476742,
0.1052014679,
-0.4071198702,
-0.3481858373,
-0.8605226278,
0.5715587735,
-0.6098680496,
-0.765922308,
0.0869516283,
-0.8597097397,
-0.4397295713,
0.0390694402,
0.4304955304,
0.3849958777,
0.0364786983,
0.1388745606,
0.8626872301,
0.028817324,
0.4338504672,
0.448182255,
0.166023761,
-0.422314018,
0.8523306251,
-0.072306715,
0.3674059212,
0.6009576917,
0.1448226273,
-0.4128527045,
-0.9464330673,
-0.4280280173,
0.20234631,
-0.6959123015,
-0.2986012995,
-0.1610511839,
-0.3197427988,
0.0307708401,
-0.4193223119,
-0.3361365199,
-0.4500555098,
-0.3173336387,
-0.4892481565,
0.4304238856,
0.4606734216,
-0.0636839122,
0.3934119344,
-0.4040059745,
0.3651316166,
0.1637514383,
0.3547506928,
0.0445182137,
-0.8448082209,
-0.2006286085,
0.2097217143,
-0.0891863331,
-0.7193772197,
-0.070364207,
0.4953116477,
0.9958574772,
0.7033375502,
0.2938567996,
0.6914528608,
-0.2167129964,
0.3075913787,
0.0573093332,
-1.1675107479,
0.6316536665,
0.0231031161,
0.3572860956,
0.5490826964,
0.3610669374,
0.313634336,
-0.4938205183,
-0.4787929356,
-1.0700874329,
0.6129846573,
0.3055427372,
0.0525460951,
0.2909114957,
0.5434846878,
0.3008016944,
0.2008382976,
-0.4981219471,
-0.3166007102,
-0.1679698825,
-0.5817842484,
0.3065797985,
-0.1439913213,
-0.3729586601,
-0.2947321534,
0.6696004868,
-0.1636146307,
0.2116426378,
-0.1216943711,
-0.2042197585,
0.1152844504,
0.1193190813,
0.5074365735,
1.0348910093,
-0.1540897489,
0.1413600594,
0.1690497845,
-0.3876615465,
0.1106329039,
0.098610878,
-0.301453054,
-0.1657175869,
0.7813447714,
0.6806154251,
0.320782721,
-0.6991110444,
0.3066423833,
0.20961079,
-0.4842968881,
-0.3679399192,
0.5134071708,
0.355638355,
0.1241905913,
0.4511222839,
0.0558346398,
0.0746010989,
-0.2085260004,
0.3177363575,
0.3995773196,
-0.0592037477,
-0.3020215631,
0.6440083385,
0.3898536265,
-0.3783065379,
0.5926266313,
-0.0705138296,
-0.0898791254,
0.6980749965,
0.6440432072,
0.8019055128,
-0.2948695123,
0.3081334829,
0.0885187313,
0.1849894822,
0.0224637091,
0.2892378867,
-0.2703075707,
-0.9004427195,
-0.835796535,
-0.6005109549,
-0.3894440234,
0.1152429879,
-0.7188172936,
0.010125869,
-0.612128973,
0.2910909057,
-0.0269384012,
-0.2283508778,
-0.3144517541,
-0.0430500619,
-0.2133771777,
0.9359326363,
-1.0551577806,
0.3742884398,
0.8271244168,
-0.2870139778,
-0.4370112419,
-0.0161859784,
0.1456241608,
-0.7681289315,
0.4846710861,
0.226122424,
-0.4577551186,
0.2089230418,
-0.570546329,
-0.5108398795,
1.2252976894,
0.8408387899,
-0.4420790076,
0.1828044504,
-0.0648684651,
0.417119205,
-0.6016223431,
0.164219901,
0.6501840353,
0.4967048466,
0.1612916142,
-0.5173826218,
0.0760530233,
-0.1556175202,
-0.0280064195,
0.0806294829,
-0.1232212856,
0.3336303234,
-0.3996336162,
-0.408110261,
0.2429673076,
0.9481576085,
0.544039309,
0.3579162359,
0.5033096075,
0.5242552161,
0.6980944872,
0.0632044598,
0.8723134995,
-0.4016857147,
-0.2696340978,
1.3098813295,
0.0157061797,
0.6853186488,
0.3699908257,
-0.0388824455,
0.8915627003,
0.5233358145,
0.1864423156,
0.5321887136,
0.0996271819,
-0.5714167356,
-0.3346614242,
0.0246426724,
-0.1367579699,
0.5925348401,
0.7189564705,
-0.5118963122,
-0.1191089526,
-0.1946084201,
-0.1167791784,
0.4087999165,
-0.6128724813,
0.7914872766,
0.0614309497,
-0.5027064085,
0.5147711039,
-0.0505678393,
0.6401306391,
-0.6826984286,
-0.2090211064,
-0.2716031671,
0.260995239,
-0.7177541256,
-0.8496673107,
0.4512240589,
-0.3972479701,
-0.2023245245,
-0.0739240199,
0.5624859333,
-0.2844033539,
-0.5118023753,
0.1035301015,
0.6100155711,
0.259121865,
0.1769213825,
-0.7702649832,
-0.1364247203,
0.1121814996,
-0.083755821,
0.3027555943,
0.3606105447,
0.1042588949,
0.7596963048,
0.45788908,
0.1411348134,
-0.3500801623,
-0.0826056302,
0.7049863935,
-0.2519095838,
-0.2475454509,
-0.8870939016,
0.8338007927,
-0.2445659488,
-0.1807470471,
0.6709023118,
0.6383388042,
0.5986691117,
-0.1256049424,
0.8942043185,
0.0224696882,
0.3683017194,
-0.8912032843,
0.3445124626,
-0.3473065197,
0.7282122374,
0.0755415857,
-0.7928684354,
-0.2461914271,
0.6947604418,
-0.3996932805,
0.0411901027,
0.4486579895,
1.0517030954,
-0.3621166348,
0.1109513491,
0.068154566,
0.1536242068,
-0.0914216787,
0.5628211498,
0.6342906952,
0.0279731285,
0.4321862757,
-0.3502732813,
-0.5147805214,
0.0551252067,
-0.9844831228,
-1.0481625795,
-0.3105053604,
-0.4821271598,
-0.1412851214,
0.0749408826,
0.6676512957,
0.6067478061,
-0.8918620944,
-0.2794999182,
-0.4984182119,
0.4022987783,
-0.7025289536,
-0.2491621077,
0.5993896127,
-0.1695057005,
-0.7453785539,
0.6975994706,
0.4299863875,
0.0416455641,
-0.2261730283,
-0.1055924967,
-0.1958886385,
0.0038319903,
0.5178264976,
0.4714364111,
-0.5702683926,
-0.0603607856,
-0.1595678329,
0.408023864,
-0.0532411411,
0.8181454539,
-0.68040061,
0.2888987958,
0.4191645682,
0.8257396221,
0.1250335425,
0.4537833333,
0.8623096943,
-1.0321593285,
0.1615282297,
0.2935963273,
0.4379372299,
0.3687677979,
-0.4529457986,
0.5547667742,
0.0752721578,
-0.3479388952,
-0.5592924356,
0.5475158095,
-0.7269358635,
-0.5696110725,
0.9431595206,
-0.1892657131,
-0.2553293407,
-0.6024301648,
0.0113162613,
-0.0801355243,
-0.2480220795,
0.7986840606,
0.3780869842,
-0.9057468772,
-0.36829862,
-0.3997164667,
0.4137932658,
0.4212234914,
-0.9011836052,
-0.0254557393,
0.4919644594,
0.3090207577,
0.0933896601,
0.4325788021,
-0.0732153952,
0.3490871191,
0.0609003417,
-0.037782371,
-0.5097925067,
-0.1240810007,
-0.105926998,
0.1321995556,
-0.0781462938,
-0.3358258307
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10645v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10645v1
|
Can Separators Improve Chain-of-Thought Prompting?
| 2024-02-16T12:46:16 | 2024-02-16T12:46:16 |
Yoonjeong Park, Hyunjin Kim, Chanyeol Choi, Junseong Kim, Jy-yong Sohn
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting is a simple and effective method for
improving the reasoning capabilities of Large language models (LLMs). The basic
idea of CoT is to let LLMs break down their thought processes step-by-step by
putting exemplars in the input prompt. However, the densely structured prompt
exemplars of CoT may cause the cognitive overload of LLMs. Inspired by human
cognition, we introduce CoT-Sep, a novel method that strategically employs
separators at the end of each exemplar in CoT prompting. These separators are
designed to help the LLMs understand their thought processes better while
reasoning. It turns out that CoT-Sep significantly improves the LLMs'
performances on complex reasoning tasks (e.g., GSM-8K, AQuA, CSQA), compared
with the vanilla CoT, which does not use separators. We also study the effects
of the type and the location of separators tested on multiple LLMs, including
GPT-3.5-Turbo, GPT-4, and LLaMA-2 7B. Interestingly, the type/location of
separators should be chosen appropriately to boost the reasoning capability of
CoT.
|
[
-0.8312957287,
-0.9333207607,
0.8200292587,
-0.0073246877,
-0.6171957254,
0.5067595243,
-0.3646657169,
-0.541031003,
0.2342073768,
0.475707531,
-0.3093395233,
-0.2249892056,
-0.5239260197,
0.3031854928,
-0.3289940059,
1.0093138218,
-0.154580906,
-0.0460134596,
0.0397853181,
0.1344513595,
-0.7170756459,
-0.6947753429,
-0.7637095451,
-0.1797884554,
0.7842140198,
0.3117076755,
0.4525800347,
0.4146683812,
0.4447770119,
0.3125216663,
-0.6630132198,
0.5415688157,
-0.317119509,
0.4134644866,
-0.4273331165,
-0.6878650784,
-0.2182231694,
-0.2064650059,
0.4817489982,
0.533821404,
-0.1729303747,
-0.1456718147,
0.030642122,
0.823585391,
-0.8875267506,
-0.1741634458,
-0.5913441777,
-0.0551358312,
-0.0971601754,
-0.1649487466,
-0.6084672809,
-0.3695973456,
0.1645640284,
-0.209538132,
0.0990725905,
0.1509488672,
0.5295246243,
0.214296788,
-0.3305583,
-0.2221048623,
-0.7697626352,
0.6362187266,
-0.3039712012,
0.2449079752,
0.0622854605,
0.4155685902,
-0.3947574496,
-0.5252823234,
-0.6857479811,
0.0889038146,
-0.0147732254,
-0.0618402511,
0.1552335173,
0.2467414439,
0.6078888178,
0.2206580043,
-0.0720965862,
-0.0934432149,
-0.8005709648,
-0.0886638835,
0.3652275801,
0.2410970628,
0.446444422,
0.1158147082,
-0.5293801427,
-0.0036014901,
-0.8580471277,
0.257522583,
0.0927390754,
0.2690857053,
0.2014056891,
0.2700504363,
-0.0439909026,
0.7668724656,
0.2200094461,
-0.2755334675,
-0.1077759266,
-0.2216708064,
-0.1544962972,
0.321947813,
0.6501092911,
0.2146079838,
0.3155439198,
0.1485671699,
-0.3197795451,
0.0803402886,
0.1416887939,
-0.6844978333,
-0.398575753,
0.2470088154,
-0.2649133503,
-0.250619173,
0.1019395068,
-0.7169203162,
-0.4494119585,
-0.4398300052,
0.1865622252,
-0.3291397691,
-0.2587873936,
0.1373581886,
-0.3280895948,
0.2465664297,
0.5361461043,
-0.8475680351,
0.4262861609,
0.5855615139,
0.7372879386,
-0.2842030227,
-0.2372961789,
-0.8510021567,
0.0846451744,
-0.3662788272,
1.2619798183,
-0.7860215306,
-0.3272631466,
-0.2759822011,
-0.0966301262,
-0.2857846916,
-0.7070834041,
0.4630846381,
-0.5288479924,
0.2027959675,
-0.9673927426,
-0.4103682339,
-0.1907138079,
0.3168850839,
-0.8763729334,
0.8096473217,
-0.1760515422,
-0.5812276006,
0.4347651303,
-0.583403945,
-0.4131738842,
-0.1197236553,
-0.4850401878,
0.039922677,
0.0526442043,
0.6608102322,
0.0037095135,
-0.6539092064,
0.2241389155,
-0.2354095578,
-0.3344871998,
0.5014573932,
-0.3579633236,
0.7278155684,
0.1935068369,
-0.2514776886,
0.163504526,
-0.4931411147,
0.1300208271,
-0.2749752104,
-0.2092013806,
-0.2438589633,
-0.0446175821,
-0.4351435006,
0.6722901464,
-0.0643501878,
-0.4753356278,
0.1542568356,
-0.1442845464,
0.4310986698,
0.8530186415,
0.1655783653,
0.4500032365,
-0.3190056384,
0.7812408209,
0.3087613583,
0.1190925911,
-0.1323195696,
-0.6099467874,
-0.7662819624,
-0.6704286337,
0.2200879604,
0.3743304014,
-0.7347376943,
0.5381859541,
0.3200653791,
-0.2724564373,
-0.3717101216,
0.0753778592,
0.4431195557,
0.5599921942,
0.4777590036,
-0.3076355755,
-0.5696486831,
-0.391892463,
-0.0908263624,
-0.1547373831,
0.2065798044,
-0.2681028545,
0.3774059415,
0.2566002309,
0.9856161475,
-0.6742256284,
0.0360173844,
-0.5107015967,
-0.0903059989,
0.1135817841,
0.2218305767,
0.1836069375,
-0.4829062521,
-0.2160257697,
-0.0975318104,
-0.5337963104,
-0.1965006143,
-0.2693050504,
-0.6867306232,
0.0160399955,
0.496525228,
-0.9204169512,
0.4601996839,
0.1396748126,
-0.3297984302,
0.9715809226,
-0.1943039447,
0.0342157669,
-0.8932895064,
-0.0927495733,
-0.4600716233,
-0.1196767464,
-0.515503943,
-0.1447869092,
0.0482294969,
0.1572257876,
-0.6210385561,
0.3288136423,
-0.5846440792,
0.0107524749,
-0.4012605548,
0.3649823666,
0.4402176738,
0.2755199671,
0.1044879407,
0.9156247377,
0.6233619452,
-0.6937372088,
0.1410338283,
0.3769465387,
-0.2442986965,
0.4019734859,
-0.4801481664,
0.3025498092,
-0.2429267466,
0.7925934792,
-1.0131778717,
0.0100788558,
0.1465256214,
0.0560884736,
-0.1032822728,
-0.0345998704,
-0.4050775468,
-0.4361298084,
-0.422447443,
0.5856733918,
0.4273473918,
-0.9514809251,
0.5045182705,
0.2414596677,
-0.008873608,
-0.5169822574,
-0.5980152488,
0.0379233323,
-0.3373245299,
-0.3668884635,
0.0251649376,
-0.0267339144,
-0.342549026,
-0.3010987639,
-0.2815549076,
0.0286183301,
-0.0585026704,
0.0267221294,
0.4807219505,
0.0065435637,
0.2575946748,
0.3953464627,
-0.1669508964,
0.3002309501,
-0.3750707805,
0.7620622516,
-0.1965938061,
-0.2880320847,
-0.3445125222,
0.2229983211,
0.5817670226,
-0.4842421412,
0.9178100824,
0.3029193282,
-0.1516098529,
-0.272120595,
-0.8135492802,
-0.1805263311,
-0.5091326833,
-0.3087674677,
-0.5437757373,
-0.9061649442,
0.6482970715,
-0.2729225159,
-0.1826753616,
0.118385002,
0.503685832,
-0.1063028723,
1.0129745007,
0.2058532834,
-0.0384041481,
0.4548084438,
-0.273096025,
0.6161681414,
-1.3604104519,
-0.2409540862,
-0.2953362465,
-0.5115033388,
-0.4371486902,
-0.5905809402,
0.1802610755,
0.5619308352,
-0.2371421158,
0.082548067,
-0.8210833073,
1.1363916397,
0.2451785654,
0.1916706413,
0.3397669792,
-0.0375330932,
-0.573586762,
0.3803375959,
-0.5650889277,
-0.5631437898,
0.6632128954,
-0.0195343811,
0.8138389587,
0.0251950733,
0.8722829223,
-0.0447336622,
0.1769769937,
-0.621172905,
0.7370088696,
0.0775209442,
-0.4996623099,
-0.1040050089,
-0.3840506077,
-0.9122508168,
0.4719350636,
0.0788926408,
-1.0059678555,
0.4547562003,
0.0258350633,
-0.6514373422,
0.5909975767,
-0.7408468127,
0.4326127172,
-0.3147808611,
-0.1584249884,
-0.089933455,
-0.6472111344,
0.282409966,
-0.0424717851,
-0.0194973201,
-0.071609363,
-0.1604333967,
0.7278303504,
-0.857129097,
0.729308188,
-0.1434684396,
-0.1939423233,
0.8554766774,
0.1942956746,
0.6495516896,
-0.2101072967,
-0.0532936715,
-0.1860346049,
-0.1181860939,
-0.1985988319,
-0.8743564487,
0.4283187687,
-0.642619729,
-0.7809174061,
-0.2612406909,
-0.5734601617,
-0.0396276601,
0.0439847447,
0.2940892875,
0.4950831234,
0.3754549026,
-0.0622611456,
0.5635783672,
-0.0550658368,
0.4500136971,
0.1401095539,
-0.300105989,
-0.8361718059,
0.5768324733,
0.1591318101,
0.6276664138,
0.2996690869,
0.3432094157,
-0.5165569186,
-0.3163668513,
-0.364990741,
0.2663075626,
-0.9878362417,
-0.2209472358,
-0.7418251634,
-0.2066512108,
0.0054232911,
-0.4351970553,
-0.0257687438,
-0.7396689057,
-0.0508384705,
-0.536010921,
0.5141009092,
0.7654295564,
0.083961077,
0.1674227566,
-0.7253527641,
0.1782316118,
0.4208213687,
0.1029255837,
0.1839221567,
-0.2304442227,
0.0110778389,
-0.1250503659,
-0.3509080708,
-0.6798789501,
0.1385062039,
-0.2863773406,
0.3955018818,
0.5763036609,
0.2313383222,
1.1153615713,
-0.3308748603,
0.8220230937,
0.4062519372,
-1.0275266171,
0.6936324239,
-0.2333420217,
0.4906659722,
0.6681489348,
0.0293349735,
-0.3768059909,
-0.7929262519,
-0.4208200872,
-0.8458841443,
0.6846908927,
0.2509939373,
-0.4199516475,
-0.5526434183,
0.2608941495,
0.1188584864,
0.0882116184,
-0.31723544,
0.170799315,
0.4203653038,
-0.069188185,
0.364292115,
-0.2215135843,
-0.1442467719,
-0.2581870556,
0.389700532,
-0.0035023137,
0.1025063321,
0.4134032428,
-0.2084780782,
-0.133184731,
0.3673408926,
0.54895854,
0.7730902433,
0.0986214578,
0.5601997972,
0.6302710772,
-0.4196488261,
0.4881743789,
-0.3390346467,
-0.184502542,
-0.2674422562,
0.2026883066,
0.5867728591,
-0.2145608664,
-0.6893897653,
0.1249944046,
-0.2805271447,
0.0681437105,
0.0343937911,
0.3903272748,
0.0471288227,
0.290132612,
0.0656145737,
0.2457076311,
0.0769662783,
-0.4140620828,
0.0109830583,
0.01998128,
-0.3164908588,
-0.176183939,
0.5040061474,
0.4721762836,
-0.344195962,
0.4723362029,
-0.1526276171,
-0.8113368154,
0.7529837489,
0.8253894448,
1.0024039745,
-0.1978317648,
0.0498649292,
0.2380181998,
0.3162462413,
-0.4093363881,
0.4160350859,
-0.5333305597,
-0.6897601485,
-0.6625251174,
-0.2754649222,
-0.5439680219,
-0.220704183,
-0.6198244095,
0.372386843,
-0.6452583671,
-0.3296528161,
-0.3924613893,
-0.1248347461,
-0.5385083556,
0.1243843734,
0.4120375514,
0.9459735751,
-0.6303815246,
0.7021835446,
0.57799685,
-0.3915429711,
-1.0492440462,
0.1394122243,
-0.0437642001,
-0.1649226844,
0.5233000517,
0.5865513086,
-0.6013359427,
-0.4111130536,
-0.3951358795,
-0.9410201311,
1.0330051184,
0.3228258193,
-0.742716372,
0.1566401273,
0.2516741157,
0.627019465,
-0.4504036009,
0.7277864814,
0.8276817799,
0.293428421,
0.0262841545,
-0.7907757163,
0.4262294471,
-0.1356366426,
0.1434785426,
0.6175372005,
-0.7496145368,
0.8339657784,
-0.4741492569,
-0.1705479026,
-0.0153265372,
0.4294361174,
0.8936083913,
0.1538100243,
0.8099977374,
0.4741245508,
1.2921345234,
0.0173147973,
0.8144093156,
-0.2473955601,
0.0689269379,
1.3260681629,
-0.6239975095,
0.8415797949,
0.6422788501,
0.0393518917,
0.939838469,
0.3539647758,
0.5193030238,
0.3065721095,
0.3497325778,
-0.5570749044,
-0.3286452889,
-0.1015684083,
-0.2749609947,
0.175389424,
0.4852645993,
-0.283801496,
-0.1413554996,
0.1172190234,
0.1259185672,
-0.2348601967,
-0.0965665355,
0.8328148127,
0.2892354429,
-0.9717212319,
0.748237431,
-0.5822125077,
0.2122932971,
-0.2960551679,
0.0251941402,
-0.1351731122,
0.2544148862,
-0.286328584,
-1.0046995878,
0.1372039914,
0.2549978197,
-0.0634747148,
-0.1882790327,
0.8286502361,
-0.5075970888,
-0.3697874546,
0.5778657198,
0.5042717457,
0.2291553617,
-0.1204771772,
-0.3987935483,
0.201557681,
-0.0472531654,
-0.2367060632,
0.171680361,
0.845656991,
-0.3914511502,
0.7379966378,
0.8925865889,
0.0655015633,
-0.125329569,
0.5069508553,
1.3046563864,
-0.9860268235,
-0.6189275384,
-1.0878880024,
0.5494004488,
-0.3239942193,
-0.2330004722,
0.365865469,
0.5408599973,
0.663775444,
0.2103295624,
0.791153729,
-0.1144152135,
0.1113661155,
-0.5223684907,
0.3931506872,
0.0457683317,
0.6201243997,
-0.2571875155,
-0.9816209674,
-0.2471764982,
0.4695514441,
-0.5978634953,
-0.0611125529,
1.246571064,
0.7962693572,
0.2056964636,
0.4916225672,
0.1895256341,
0.0779305995,
0.6881967187,
0.5383683443,
1.4677577019,
-0.0465546511,
0.6789506078,
-0.2596795857,
-0.1808587611,
0.0742348209,
-0.5016742945,
-1.213531971,
-0.2033184618,
-0.2439903021,
-0.290068537,
0.0591245778,
1.3493192196,
0.4799255431,
-0.6712730527,
-0.212097317,
-0.4407339096,
0.351228714,
-0.262506783,
-0.2022785842,
0.2601182759,
-0.6216239333,
-0.2460879534,
0.2935335338,
0.4666897058,
-0.2404564023,
-0.0739547536,
0.1059242114,
-0.2295913398,
0.1497267038,
0.8437812328,
-0.1276593953,
-0.8557940125,
-0.4055099785,
-0.1810751557,
0.127331242,
0.225833714,
0.9972323179,
-1.0497674942,
0.5933616161,
0.8481582403,
0.2837768793,
0.3658450544,
0.2778123617,
0.679851532,
-0.4328451455,
0.1584523767,
0.1322656423,
0.5185161233,
0.1343676001,
-0.5119833946,
0.4456778467,
-0.0421859212,
-0.6528992653,
-0.6361420155,
0.2895959318,
-0.9213284254,
-0.1500929296,
1.2214467525,
-0.0246507861,
-0.623103559,
-0.2587664723,
-0.7911565304,
0.084960781,
-0.6728536487,
0.9066568017,
0.8158285022,
-0.3245654404,
-0.2358705997,
-0.0182178672,
0.2748765647,
0.4505749643,
-1.2079713345,
0.2380969375,
0.1742383987,
0.1048706099,
0.2715907395,
0.6351153255,
-0.2451044172,
0.4317561984,
-0.0660466924,
-0.0461773425,
0.2339849472,
-0.5499774218,
-0.1484263837,
0.0036715982,
0.0571639575,
-0.1893120408
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10644v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10644v2
|
Linear Transformers with Learnable Kernel Functions are Better In-Context Models
| 2024-02-16T12:44:15 | 2024-06-05T14:13:22 |
Yaroslav Aksenov, Nikita Balagansky, Sofia Maria Lo Cicero Vaina, Boris Shaposhnikov, Alexey Gorbatovski, Daniil Gavrilov
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Advancing the frontier of subquadratic architectures for Language Models
(LMs) is crucial in the rapidly evolving field of natural language processing.
Current innovations, including State Space Models, were initially celebrated
for surpassing Transformer performance on language modeling tasks. However,
these models have revealed deficiencies in essential In-Context Learning
capabilities - a domain where the Transformer traditionally shines. The Based
model emerged as a hybrid solution, blending a Linear Transformer with a kernel
inspired by the Taylor expansion of exponential functions, augmented by
convolutional networks. Mirroring the Transformer's in-context adeptness, it
became a strong contender in the field. In our work, we present a singular,
elegant alteration to the Based kernel that amplifies its In-Context Learning
abilities evaluated with the Multi-Query Associative Recall task and overall
language modeling process, as demonstrated on the Pile dataset.
|
[
-0.2212780714,
-0.684271574,
0.3739511073,
-0.0612190142,
-0.0250283666,
0.0840572417,
-0.1600645483,
-0.3933098316,
0.26339221,
0.1941468865,
-0.1311771274,
-0.0661650598,
-0.5846683979,
0.0000175747,
-0.828450799,
0.9381563067,
0.1421039551,
-0.0644463524,
-0.5021288991,
-0.3539145291,
-0.2963902354,
-0.5305355787,
-0.3626274765,
-0.5178770423,
0.2132431567,
0.0709080547,
0.8428372145,
0.2290433496,
0.1753842384,
0.2940140665,
-0.1493647546,
-0.0023513841,
-0.5220896006,
0.1479751766,
-0.0027487129,
-0.3563675582,
-0.3345791996,
-0.267980814,
0.6876794696,
0.9266490936,
-0.2934032381,
-0.1609248668,
0.1738123149,
0.583696425,
-0.59491539,
0.1516125202,
-0.8677558303,
-0.0378844291,
0.0732640475,
-0.1291476488,
-0.7544308305,
-0.2055422366,
0.2675382495,
-0.6685893536,
0.2402959764,
-0.0757365972,
0.6770111322,
0.2144533694,
-0.3855700791,
-0.3979502022,
-0.9272409081,
0.7840052843,
-0.6305490136,
0.8169928193,
0.0178183746,
0.4599542618,
-0.277884841,
-0.9768139124,
-0.6288201213,
-0.2903503478,
-0.3705390692,
0.0877545327,
-0.2069161236,
-0.1346735805,
0.1094015017,
0.5750763416,
-0.2258697301,
0.1442039311,
-0.4184873104,
-0.2382460982,
0.1685049385,
0.0359114185,
0.1381134987,
-0.1784783155,
-0.5530451536,
-0.1455750167,
-0.7602632642,
0.4734401703,
0.0407163128,
0.4002999067,
-0.1164350733,
0.3042087257,
-0.0687208548,
0.6240121722,
0.0982530862,
-0.0533934645,
0.1588296294,
-0.0212444738,
-0.2640538514,
-0.2145582736,
0.4016558528,
-0.1300349236,
-0.0126570472,
-0.2109513432,
-0.500330627,
0.1259388328,
0.4749220312,
-0.492384553,
-0.4434782863,
0.1803130507,
-0.3909725249,
0.0596700162,
0.0011542505,
-0.4663933516,
-0.3095059991,
-0.318241626,
0.5287132859,
-0.634272635,
-0.1530981511,
0.0854560286,
0.0529767275,
0.3014442325,
0.259644866,
-0.9162307978,
0.5139346123,
0.7196984291,
0.7482820153,
-0.102815859,
0.1452807188,
-0.6399303675,
-0.1238097399,
-0.3480746448,
0.7013966441,
-0.7372236848,
-0.5965517759,
0.243296355,
-0.2022801191,
-0.157939896,
-0.623516202,
0.5828394294,
-0.7731187344,
0.4074648321,
-0.2087546885,
-0.6662166119,
-0.275883168,
-0.0164597388,
-0.8165713549,
1.3256701231,
0.3385531306,
-0.5240636468,
0.4188210368,
-0.7730855346,
-0.5308364034,
0.5410398841,
-0.1814911962,
-0.4717462063,
0.1664930582,
0.2456889749,
0.4822692871,
0.0412186533,
0.3959023356,
-0.1805769801,
-0.3299235404,
0.0792643428,
-0.0913452432,
0.745454073,
-0.00724599,
-0.1275414526,
0.2628569007,
-0.7457375526,
-0.2890525162,
-0.1215326861,
-0.3223950267,
-0.6695197225,
0.242203176,
-0.001654141,
0.1822500825,
0.12288028,
-0.6153642535,
-0.0789004639,
-0.5316611528,
0.4608414471,
0.4803668559,
-0.3542037308,
0.9175516367,
-0.2053078413,
0.4974953532,
0.0457222909,
0.0363341086,
-0.4733654857,
-0.3837216496,
-0.9645785689,
-0.462551564,
0.1414810568,
0.4712379575,
-1.0119558573,
0.3002559543,
-0.3922322989,
-0.504699111,
-0.4655849934,
-0.0676365271,
0.2443828136,
0.8435780406,
0.6106157899,
-0.1605193913,
-0.4015432596,
-1.0800528526,
-0.195649907,
0.0443979986,
-0.0014573536,
0.4307940602,
0.4350498319,
-0.2028269917,
1.2368843555,
-0.218486011,
-0.2922014892,
-0.4883688688,
-0.1239871606,
0.3727397621,
0.3616445065,
0.456590116,
-0.9201171994,
-0.4275790751,
0.1411320567,
-0.7120267749,
0.0683576316,
0.0770376697,
0.1432134807,
0.2794465721,
0.5886766315,
-0.6408380866,
0.2090801746,
0.4269739985,
-0.1624443084,
0.3920999765,
-0.2836786211,
-0.191028595,
-1.0408476591,
0.0896602347,
0.0523484312,
-0.3064233661,
-0.9009265304,
0.160023123,
0.4938352704,
-0.0100708725,
-0.5331025124,
0.4602075219,
-0.2126340866,
-0.1139921173,
-0.1470000297,
0.0356566869,
-0.2401999682,
0.5176099539,
-0.1307978183,
0.7757178545,
0.6822220683,
-0.6887136102,
0.1547403187,
0.2821370661,
-0.4568913281,
0.3579847813,
-0.576880753,
0.1384752244,
-0.4534719884,
0.6400182247,
-1.0551738739,
-0.0986998528,
-0.1876478195,
-0.0455972664,
0.2040964514,
0.053359367,
-0.458914876,
-0.2475049198,
-0.0582508035,
0.5132043958,
0.5534830689,
-0.7604877949,
1.0059527159,
0.4897139072,
-0.0405281633,
-0.4494573176,
-0.2341478914,
-0.0411063395,
-0.2596717477,
-0.4402391315,
0.4936125875,
0.1964323819,
-0.1738224626,
-0.1263034493,
-0.0903985053,
-0.0052449391,
-0.0588155836,
-0.0258087274,
0.3092321455,
-0.2748203278,
0.2184114605,
-0.0542082563,
-0.2351419032,
-0.0949185342,
-0.4291622043,
0.4628993869,
-0.3237544596,
0.0003401709,
-0.2626061141,
0.2214827389,
0.6108928919,
-0.2583794892,
0.7859950066,
0.2248877287,
-0.5306639671,
-0.5779443979,
-0.2116377801,
-0.3893446326,
-0.5052936673,
0.4089363813,
-0.4222116172,
-1.208353281,
0.4952067435,
-0.0487402156,
0.1524689645,
0.5727804303,
0.3871942163,
-0.1987059265,
0.5675372481,
0.9000163078,
0.0284444764,
0.5214618444,
-0.2471679747,
0.4187488556,
-0.8360593915,
-0.3984139264,
-0.3430502415,
-0.4187578559,
-0.5758159161,
-0.2006720006,
0.7360185385,
-0.2447114587,
0.0719249472,
0.7416145205,
-0.2334472686,
0.2464475632,
0.4299427867,
0.0998738855,
0.1230461895,
-0.1038283557,
-0.4702184796,
-0.0946011171,
-0.9832641482,
-0.3971984982,
0.7953703403,
0.4933409989,
0.6941290498,
0.0048272298,
0.2115742862,
0.1752048284,
0.4306391776,
-0.7627070546,
0.4749100804,
-0.4905847609,
-0.307901144,
-0.2846601009,
-0.2824869156,
-0.8051040769,
0.5655689836,
-0.3564537168,
-0.66887784,
0.2549996376,
0.3815333545,
-0.5196821094,
0.4110304713,
-0.7785164118,
0.7177039981,
0.0229021255,
-0.0901957676,
-0.2181186527,
-0.4978776276,
0.3244117796,
-0.1464919597,
0.4573328495,
0.2774781883,
-0.0293846466,
0.4156654775,
-0.2932912111,
0.76941818,
-0.2037077099,
-0.3445991874,
0.1440113783,
0.3676241934,
0.5992480516,
-0.1539753675,
-0.06607759,
0.0866924599,
-0.2195586562,
-0.2520495355,
-0.7711846232,
0.6229647994,
-0.4478231668,
-0.4619745314,
-0.0008861232,
-0.7286703587,
-0.3289646506,
0.030283086,
0.1887002736,
0.8927938938,
-0.0751297176,
0.5779247284,
0.7502263784,
-0.2884094417,
0.7194722891,
0.2233812362,
-0.2167171836,
-0.1731232405,
0.6838771105,
0.0289960057,
0.3538722694,
0.866178453,
0.2168766409,
-0.4739309251,
-0.2036789656,
-0.2358498424,
-0.107670173,
-0.8195007443,
-0.0375335999,
-0.8150470257,
-0.3040013909,
-0.1544182003,
-0.1739719808,
-0.4017845392,
-0.6152529716,
0.0811092928,
-0.0705139339,
0.160549894,
0.8606297374,
0.4153247476,
0.4186771512,
-0.5089221001,
0.2031250596,
0.4404299557,
0.4755059183,
0.1906347126,
-0.6421029568,
-0.3318695724,
-0.0827301145,
-0.3262808621,
-0.4837201834,
0.361612767,
0.4208794534,
0.5474455357,
0.0757654086,
-0.1220506132,
0.539162159,
-0.6661102176,
0.6270532012,
0.0166225675,
-0.9287545681,
0.2460451871,
-0.2567831278,
0.4293469191,
0.1069647968,
0.267547965,
-0.5880181193,
-0.4737493098,
-0.5317070484,
-0.9852036834,
0.6097714901,
0.3519340158,
0.3564112782,
0.1065090671,
0.1883966327,
0.4941527545,
-0.0284441393,
-0.9772648811,
-0.1927524209,
-0.3280419111,
-0.1176122129,
-0.1746035069,
-0.1200171858,
0.3423805535,
-0.4386398196,
0.7330330014,
-0.1730261594,
0.1497742832,
0.0961811617,
-0.3108896911,
-0.1702867895,
0.3041954041,
0.62105757,
0.6494915485,
0.0403220206,
0.3777429163,
0.4065045118,
-0.232012704,
-0.2163301408,
0.054311946,
-0.184975341,
0.1693081707,
0.2945256829,
0.7531020641,
0.7536049485,
-0.4950663447,
0.3831588328,
0.1297956109,
-0.033013802,
-0.3371254802,
0.1124541312,
0.0785908327,
0.1243139654,
0.7941806316,
0.2480222285,
0.202775836,
-0.3300889134,
0.5189443827,
0.628405273,
-0.612292707,
-0.4247232676,
0.6915142536,
0.2177245766,
-0.5431405902,
0.3274047375,
0.1476869434,
-0.6016343832,
0.296051383,
0.7520309687,
0.7546522021,
-0.1549206227,
0.025173746,
0.3366749585,
0.2825187147,
0.0385135077,
-0.028862346,
-0.2859297693,
-0.835963428,
-0.3774143159,
-0.7628765106,
-0.1773744524,
0.2192177773,
-0.4448034763,
0.2100632787,
-0.3129656315,
0.137894839,
-0.0136805745,
-0.4930160642,
-0.3676559329,
0.2805639803,
0.0367898494,
1.0032590628,
-0.6967201829,
1.0446124077,
0.6994426847,
0.0714775845,
-0.4696220458,
-0.0773383453,
-0.4433304667,
-0.670928061,
0.5414950252,
0.1658298075,
-0.1685944796,
0.0017036045,
-0.4335560203,
-0.8113902211,
0.8646147251,
0.299284339,
-0.6280747652,
0.2084138244,
0.1202432066,
0.6855998039,
-0.5162845254,
0.1914221197,
0.3496057987,
-0.1144880652,
0.1071115509,
-0.99845016,
-0.1374506205,
-0.1257866323,
0.1626526117,
0.7040635943,
-0.3226895928,
0.8926447034,
0.0451456644,
-0.2797159851,
-0.0347462855,
0.9470018148,
0.0575795621,
-0.0061780144,
0.6972178817,
0.6824482083,
0.4863508642,
-0.0630894378,
1.1937203407,
-0.1645864546,
0.4499889612,
0.9390720129,
-0.0797094032,
1.1801737547,
0.4817169905,
-0.0629771054,
0.8254398108,
0.077381894,
0.4535166025,
0.5888431072,
-0.1481065154,
-0.3416346312,
-0.3509691656,
0.1070997342,
-0.0956338197,
0.4190340042,
0.5878599286,
-0.2550178766,
-0.5870744586,
-0.0537837781,
-0.1846048683,
0.444729954,
-0.2552551627,
0.6289234757,
0.3162001371,
-0.5769585967,
0.4622456431,
0.0136395562,
0.791605711,
-0.4893046618,
-0.0431230552,
-0.2337754369,
0.2586595416,
-0.1180203333,
-0.5889940858,
0.38178128,
-0.230517447,
-0.1101301685,
-0.5754352808,
0.6072741747,
-0.5489445329,
-0.469909519,
0.4143691361,
0.3051980734,
-0.2318470031,
0.3008149266,
-0.401392132,
-0.2009364516,
-0.332778573,
0.1428806931,
0.0550317764,
0.0966183394,
-0.2140879035,
0.7509405017,
0.6553570628,
-0.28656739,
0.1846379042,
0.1001124755,
0.7678491473,
-0.4642083049,
-0.6734243631,
-0.7782039642,
0.662029624,
0.1401131749,
-0.2228241414,
0.5641545653,
0.7263586521,
0.9410914779,
-0.1591653824,
0.6056959033,
-0.2127067447,
0.5965389609,
-0.4083839357,
0.6286559105,
-0.5035459995,
0.2176394463,
-0.1663336158,
-0.9359084964,
-0.2880498767,
0.5482438803,
-0.2788929939,
0.1276463717,
0.6436217427,
0.7358273268,
-0.3439772725,
0.1642617285,
0.5471208096,
0.391015172,
0.3135752678,
0.6780419946,
0.9232341647,
-0.6476014853,
0.2073902339,
-0.2465990037,
-0.4007998705,
-0.0779450536,
-0.9410290718,
-0.7781769037,
-0.9659559727,
0.0378343165,
-0.0692415535,
-0.2004099637,
0.868313849,
0.7106126547,
-1.1242756844,
-0.3612112403,
-0.1774492413,
-0.0223693419,
-0.2124356478,
-0.2501218915,
0.2718478441,
-0.5222746134,
-0.6618415117,
0.5389044881,
0.5717173815,
-0.2454550117,
-0.1659283787,
-0.1690665036,
-0.1908801049,
0.0883578882,
1.002378583,
0.196363464,
-0.8241331577,
-0.3024127781,
0.1776835024,
-0.0955253392,
0.1598646045,
0.8106777668,
-1.2731624842,
0.6029748321,
0.2314587384,
0.7773433924,
0.2770614922,
-0.1535008848,
0.6773193479,
-0.7399880886,
0.2452128232,
0.2251186371,
0.6587569714,
0.5255230069,
-0.2963755429,
0.0924935341,
0.183655858,
-0.2260678858,
-0.6005057693,
0.275038749,
-0.8169695139,
-0.1557042152,
1.1269079447,
0.2321350873,
-0.093265608,
-0.2020172328,
-0.062252827,
0.0977040827,
-0.3431191146,
0.999729991,
0.4947297275,
-0.0361591429,
-0.1124581173,
-0.4141990244,
0.4723265171,
0.6224552989,
-0.5458076596,
-0.1933217198,
0.2322936654,
0.0700670034,
0.2135627717,
0.2772211134,
-0.1424219459,
0.2260314226,
-0.3794914186,
-0.2058855444,
0.2074555606,
-0.5176503658,
-0.4319397807,
0.4128363132,
-0.2108031511,
-0.0861677378
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10643v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10643v1
|
`Keep it Together': Enforcing Cohesion in Extractive Summaries by Simulating Human Memory
| 2024-02-16T12:43:26 | 2024-02-16T12:43:26 |
Ronald Cardenas, Matthias Galle, Shay B. Cohen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Extractive summaries are usually presented as lists of sentences with no
expected cohesion between them. In this paper, we aim to enforce cohesion
whilst controlling for informativeness and redundancy in summaries, in cases
where the input exhibits high redundancy. The pipeline controls for redundancy
in long inputs as it is consumed, and balances informativeness and cohesion
during sentence selection. Our sentence selector simulates human memory to keep
track of topics --modeled as lexical chains--, enforcing cohesive ties between
noun phrases. Across a variety of domains, our experiments revealed that it is
possible to extract highly cohesive summaries that nevertheless read as
informative to humans as summaries extracted by only accounting for
informativeness or redundancy. The extracted summaries exhibit smooth topic
transitions between sentences as signaled by lexical chains, with chains
spanning adjacent or near-adjacent sentences.
|
[
-0.5424126983,
-0.8383657336,
0.3461126387,
0.3165074885,
-0.4598942697,
0.178306818,
-0.1774080396,
-0.275390774,
0.9326514006,
0.4308896065,
-0.6634125113,
-0.2920798659,
-0.4919536412,
0.1780525744,
-0.4138086736,
1.4527099133,
-0.0280756522,
-0.6534793377,
-0.7830956578,
-0.2318535745,
-0.4159846306,
-0.4612702429,
-0.1792862862,
-0.3772848547,
0.6168195605,
0.5839999318,
0.9821751118,
0.9538094997,
0.7935471535,
0.2428453118,
-0.2900687158,
0.2208530903,
-0.6431325674,
0.3928373754,
-0.414093554,
-0.2793458402,
-0.3385729194,
-0.1841448396,
0.4662833214,
0.6103827953,
-0.3518251479,
-0.0693458989,
0.2786604166,
0.678982079,
-0.5948922038,
-0.0090582334,
-0.2239033729,
-0.1203557625,
-0.1055163741,
-0.2724100053,
-0.0796962455,
-0.3789020181,
0.3355049789,
-0.4379271865,
0.1476663202,
0.091944024,
1.3048393726,
0.2976814508,
-0.09058512,
-0.2916804552,
-0.4790964425,
0.5010746717,
-0.1411363333,
0.0671339408,
0.5856425762,
-0.212817654,
-0.0839048326,
-0.5817049146,
-0.2295396924,
0.1162537634,
-0.1443303078,
0.456954211,
0.0337596498,
-0.1522862762,
-0.1912133843,
0.1559097469,
-0.6271486878,
-0.3488796949,
-0.8205764294,
-0.0559936799,
0.8152161837,
-0.0109561179,
0.8292595148,
-0.0442765765,
-0.5501208305,
0.0234825648,
-0.4564245045,
-0.1982047111,
-0.0155315837,
0.1629235893,
-0.0872301757,
0.732642591,
-0.0541876405,
0.1892254353,
0.1429327726,
-0.0853654221,
0.0238904823,
-0.497328341,
0.0164705794,
0.4485617578,
0.8320922852,
0.6898508668,
0.4270758629,
-0.4431887567,
0.202614516,
0.2838430107,
0.5833418965,
-0.4848848283,
-0.5247712135,
0.3131076097,
-0.5133683085,
-0.1787825078,
0.2071520239,
-0.7087963223,
0.1025724933,
-0.2858362496,
0.3330606818,
-0.5405389667,
-0.1675437391,
-0.0139998598,
-0.600906074,
-0.1885208189,
0.2292328626,
-1.0387927294,
0.7458699942,
0.8128672242,
1.2408107519,
-0.6620118022,
-0.8010820746,
-0.5923264623,
0.4641857445,
-0.0007442185,
0.8332478404,
-0.3290245533,
0.0059580961,
-0.3500871062,
0.043335259,
-0.016744554,
-0.4882668257,
0.1536863297,
-0.428691417,
0.302124083,
-0.4072847366,
-0.6296436787,
-0.1837303042,
0.321780026,
-0.6889705062,
0.5725405216,
-0.0472097807,
-0.8541959524,
0.2760110795,
-0.164835453,
-0.5082738996,
-0.3355323374,
-0.0994031131,
-0.476952076,
0.3342222571,
-0.2231889367,
0.002781641,
0.078889057,
0.411422044,
-0.3817272186,
-0.4686456025,
0.0787630156,
0.0204113461,
0.5346226692,
0.3291502297,
0.2549991608,
0.2130246609,
-0.3673924506,
-0.4613097012,
-0.1671678871,
-0.1893842816,
-0.5410587192,
0.102275759,
-0.3106786311,
0.3535421789,
0.247195676,
-0.3048641086,
0.2824856043,
-0.0207480844,
0.2716679871,
0.3979934752,
0.3676092625,
0.5843682289,
-0.7849233747,
0.4335292876,
0.3219947219,
-0.3820143044,
-0.3892878592,
-0.3309415579,
-0.5064578056,
-0.2147180438,
0.3172303438,
0.6446270943,
-0.3226619959,
0.5796044469,
-0.1721906364,
-0.2406201512,
-0.1262339056,
0.1449259967,
0.1315062493,
0.284853369,
0.3442045748,
-0.6051317453,
-0.585508883,
-0.7722513676,
-0.1230285987,
-0.1391467154,
0.1517048031,
-0.4386819303,
0.6208212376,
0.1025906578,
1.2315578461,
-0.6057384014,
-0.2080113441,
-0.3883860409,
0.3353483379,
0.0084841633,
0.625690937,
0.2500629425,
-0.7767001987,
-0.1400748342,
-0.3463045955,
-0.9763706326,
-0.0488548204,
-0.5490607023,
-0.4643096328,
-0.084643431,
0.5727515221,
-0.8333641887,
0.5038110614,
0.3554700017,
-0.6195992827,
0.3926212192,
-0.6677208543,
-0.1724720448,
-1.2293109894,
-0.1111669317,
-0.0103550917,
-0.3660856187,
-0.3456635773,
-0.0814802796,
-0.0129449293,
-0.0103724999,
-0.1211807504,
0.2931198776,
-0.5784336329,
-0.038974978,
-0.1383351833,
0.4069056809,
0.2485807836,
0.5453370214,
0.2268724442,
0.6669650078,
0.1343731433,
-0.8114288449,
-0.0541124158,
0.7025461793,
0.1488515288,
0.5429215431,
-0.7242553234,
-0.1899181604,
-0.3915820718,
-0.0771661028,
-0.9349502921,
-0.3638981879,
-0.1598567516,
-0.1417141706,
0.1982881874,
0.1535542905,
-0.293510139,
0.1616071612,
-0.5547902584,
0.0677988753,
0.4573979974,
-0.326336354,
0.5168687701,
0.710226357,
-0.6094561219,
-0.414850682,
-0.6213769913,
0.1554291099,
-0.4494285882,
-0.6599785089,
0.3732170761,
-0.1364311576,
-0.5667458773,
0.2948649526,
-0.3305651844,
-0.4375778735,
0.3551169336,
0.3988163173,
0.4267227352,
0.1744582206,
0.3676949441,
0.3317306936,
0.0752194449,
0.0291505177,
-0.3149246275,
0.4595272541,
-0.0028374591,
-0.0294659045,
-0.4883365631,
0.7427034974,
0.7313418984,
0.0376828872,
0.6851897836,
0.1373533458,
-0.2568589747,
0.0312528089,
-0.1921910793,
-0.2741216421,
-0.4261499345,
0.2561286688,
-0.3698874712,
-0.7018653154,
0.6052081585,
-0.0428194813,
0.1570551842,
0.447930932,
0.2520966828,
-0.5332499743,
0.3302194774,
0.6956207156,
-0.2299223095,
0.2953284383,
0.0759260356,
-0.1581411064,
-0.4874900579,
-0.0309548154,
-0.160892576,
-0.4851269424,
-0.3432366848,
-0.1553312838,
-0.0299746841,
0.7252056003,
0.0724238604,
0.4706601202,
-0.4541403353,
0.8190047145,
0.3157424629,
0.2456883937,
0.391718775,
0.11645706,
-0.007269314,
-0.0501179174,
-0.47901842,
-0.5829382539,
0.3814537823,
0.0657317564,
0.8145698309,
0.2795229256,
1.2107232809,
0.449424088,
-0.0102202743,
-0.3624398708,
0.5070738792,
-0.0828946084,
-0.2196581215,
-0.3260963857,
-0.3511095047,
-1.0622614622,
0.2326509356,
-0.1201135889,
-1.0209213495,
0.0874718204,
0.1884180009,
-0.3615438938,
0.2027380764,
-0.6612941027,
0.6972173452,
-0.1803300083,
-0.6778557301,
-0.1791025698,
-0.7630349994,
0.2518966496,
0.1873309016,
-0.065228425,
-0.0802132413,
-0.1353254765,
0.7761473656,
-0.6011585593,
0.8634717464,
0.3843580782,
0.004889017,
0.491625756,
0.2354689687,
0.2739038765,
-0.1266985834,
0.1962393969,
0.0674531981,
0.0789578483,
-0.5131543875,
-0.4750781953,
0.3068454862,
-0.7503777742,
-0.7163276672,
-0.44983688,
-0.7714599371,
0.3381994963,
0.19097054,
0.3282440603,
0.3101484478,
-0.4266884625,
0.0648295432,
0.6430408955,
0.2435468137,
0.6878082752,
-0.3286607862,
-0.3241050541,
-0.4925942719,
1.0740633011,
0.2199383378,
0.4544087648,
0.4127506912,
0.3807729185,
-0.1743076593,
-0.3846602738,
-0.0977131873,
0.4169678986,
-0.2966295481,
0.0395858474,
-1.0606856346,
-0.2116400748,
-0.1080229506,
-0.4463008642,
-0.2375594527,
-0.8056325316,
-0.3316319287,
-0.0940141976,
0.3891063035,
0.7620551586,
-0.2236916274,
0.0478188582,
-1.0776073933,
0.5020902753,
0.2414053977,
0.0442775711,
-0.3107405007,
-0.3267843127,
-0.180102095,
-0.3849309385,
-0.3709073961,
-0.7915527821,
0.6606417298,
0.2487900406,
0.094179742,
0.4209330678,
0.267618984,
0.8159176111,
-0.2025256008,
0.630564332,
0.3639392555,
-0.7836659551,
0.5765867233,
-0.6476746798,
0.6310065985,
0.9699555635,
0.2865874767,
-0.56401968,
-0.748945415,
-0.7672128081,
-0.9083822966,
0.3900457323,
0.3297969997,
-0.2027765065,
-0.2498294115,
0.391551882,
0.1588340998,
0.247893244,
-0.2949122787,
0.0615639351,
-0.0325374268,
-0.4956029058,
0.1043834612,
-0.4136913717,
-0.3526746333,
0.1972073019,
0.2076630443,
0.119083032,
0.0158656705,
0.3585428894,
-0.3399237692,
0.137756601,
0.1846618354,
0.8956796527,
0.6855682731,
-0.5370020866,
0.5139610767,
0.0465215892,
-0.8122585416,
0.2058168054,
-0.2100809216,
-0.4226599932,
0.0983900726,
0.3597244322,
0.3967285156,
0.1614098996,
-0.5244378448,
0.250998348,
-0.3134048283,
-0.2363469303,
-0.2875176072,
0.2548217475,
0.3953772783,
0.1899749935,
-0.0207126215,
0.4337817729,
-0.3151625395,
-0.8387355208,
0.7342767715,
0.0720781833,
-0.394528836,
-0.4790787995,
0.6665504575,
0.1933516711,
-0.5205159783,
0.7053923607,
-0.3472451568,
-0.5539262891,
0.6449626088,
0.6191375852,
0.7854087949,
0.1625241488,
-0.0020693208,
0.4499912262,
0.1946425587,
-0.6376105547,
0.4350847602,
-0.3305114508,
-0.7367258668,
-0.2674701214,
-0.1368819475,
-0.6853838563,
-0.4865702391,
-0.8567091227,
0.1891869605,
-0.3138998449,
0.0083161071,
-0.3780703545,
-0.1389094591,
-0.0264987703,
0.1493138671,
-0.0431791991,
0.9296070933,
-0.8372483253,
0.8215575814,
0.2973822057,
-0.6541514993,
-0.3825927377,
0.2161546797,
0.2903434932,
-0.0709027946,
0.5352630019,
0.29393664,
-0.0325659811,
-0.3380223215,
-0.3284700811,
-1.0468473434,
1.2401692867,
0.3669190705,
-0.5312358141,
-0.1469158381,
-0.4088795781,
0.3640865386,
-0.4561315477,
0.1268610507,
0.6016895175,
0.2403824031,
0.0927116722,
-0.7166697979,
-0.0209193751,
-0.4498867393,
-0.5386649966,
0.3810563982,
-0.8666021228,
0.7618210912,
-0.4490775168,
-0.5120618343,
0.0645169616,
0.919985652,
0.6634575129,
0.4266240895,
0.3499635756,
0.7281965017,
1.0836874247,
-0.1617484838,
1.0174362659,
-0.1400874257,
0.2367131859,
1.8414407969,
-0.3692202568,
0.9108931422,
0.5599813461,
0.1845254153,
0.5313252211,
0.4497667253,
-0.0405612327,
0.6885091662,
0.0767898113,
-0.046020817,
0.0382685326,
-0.3054309189,
-0.0341124497,
0.6469606757,
0.1032177731,
-0.080975078,
-0.120213747,
-0.4887153804,
0.1886806339,
0.1619374454,
-0.089559719,
0.9209133387,
0.0680649057,
-1.1062612534,
0.2005336434,
-0.6901641488,
0.5225426555,
-0.584192276,
-0.1188864559,
-0.1478151679,
0.1551969945,
-0.2742004693,
-0.7469661832,
0.6730876565,
-0.1321063936,
-0.4506840408,
-0.1596930623,
0.8157609105,
-0.9384296536,
-0.204794243,
0.3159521818,
0.4713429213,
0.1814946383,
0.24621135,
-0.0981167257,
0.0879588574,
0.0531338118,
-0.1434186846,
0.6210919619,
0.6651465893,
-0.111607708,
0.4850889146,
0.4775391221,
0.3206737339,
-0.3012298644,
-0.1272926629,
0.8482863903,
-1.0608621836,
-0.733204484,
-1.1739935875,
0.5559655428,
-0.6331297755,
-0.4182864428,
0.6746332049,
0.6466390491,
0.4612316489,
0.1539774835,
0.5790641904,
0.0774590522,
-0.0421722978,
-0.3826942742,
0.9064388871,
-0.2597675323,
0.1552594304,
-0.2455268204,
-0.8525864482,
-0.3227355778,
0.5426856875,
0.2148468196,
-0.4398986995,
0.9670909047,
0.4315240979,
-0.1389398724,
0.2128426731,
0.277549237,
-0.1819099635,
0.004250193,
0.3896403313,
0.7459719181,
-0.0760481581,
0.5102151632,
-0.2181788087,
-0.0876288265,
0.0594098419,
-0.950676918,
-0.9950423241,
-0.4304946363,
-0.5850628018,
-0.5023809671,
-0.0984471962,
0.9844344258,
0.7164199352,
-0.6055122614,
-0.5266829133,
-0.3749890029,
0.3000134826,
-0.4711357355,
-0.2714676559,
0.3393850327,
-0.3606019616,
-0.3637693226,
0.141857937,
0.7554095387,
0.0370682217,
0.0307549164,
0.1444977522,
-0.4531583488,
-0.059839692,
0.3209830225,
0.4345604181,
-0.3526822627,
-0.2834076285,
-0.2715948522,
-0.0926406384,
0.2359422594,
0.9006394148,
-0.6574978828,
0.4405728877,
0.6960008144,
0.6419785023,
0.6157042384,
0.3861512244,
1.0293297768,
-0.826862216,
0.1354997754,
-0.1473770738,
0.3820591867,
0.039851632,
-0.5394445658,
0.832321763,
0.0985253155,
-0.6418796182,
-0.3773596883,
0.0845609754,
-1.1720949411,
-0.3949294388,
0.6230779886,
-0.327142179,
-0.3987340033,
-0.4625118673,
-0.0708557442,
0.417969197,
-0.6306427717,
1.0938245058,
0.8197143078,
-0.3054920137,
-0.3282638192,
0.000128511,
0.3643700182,
0.3698664904,
-1.0821508169,
0.1775496006,
0.438046664,
0.156404525,
0.64411515,
0.533076942,
0.2422561347,
0.4201427996,
0.105603382,
-0.1262563765,
0.0317401588,
-0.5124478936,
-0.3478735983,
0.7043765187,
-0.3498921394,
-0.2699033916
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10639v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10639v2
|
Generalizability of Mixture of Domain-Specific Adapters from the Lens of Signed Weight Directions and its Application to Effective Model Pruning
| 2024-02-16T12:39:10 | 2024-06-06T04:52:09 |
Tuc Nguyen, Thai Le
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Several parameter-efficient fine-tuning methods based on adapters have been
proposed as a streamlined approach to incorporate not only a single specialized
knowledge into existing Pre-Trained Language Models (PLMs) but also multiple of
them at once. Recent works such as AdapterSoup propose to mix not all but only
a selective sub-set of domain-specific adapters during inference via model
weight averaging to optimize performance on novel, unseen domains with
excellent computational efficiency. However, the essential generalizability of
this emerging weight-space adapter mixing mechanism on \textit{unseen,
in-domain examples} remains unexplored. Thus, in this study, we conduct a
comprehensive analysis to elucidate the generalizability of domain-specific
adapter mixtures in in-domain evaluation. We also provide investigations into
the inner workings of the mixture of domain-specific adapters by analyzing
their weight signs, yielding critical analysis on the negative correlation
between their fraction of weight sign difference and their mixtures'
generalizability.
|
[
-0.5682629347,
-0.5091084838,
0.3730430603,
0.38739568,
-0.4006207287,
-0.1299799681,
-0.2385606617,
-0.3193278015,
-0.0282255802,
0.3774956465,
-0.4577853978,
-0.2936031818,
-0.6652621627,
-0.0613265671,
-0.2879859209,
0.8818895221,
-0.1398700327,
0.1397573352,
-0.1664846241,
-0.589048624,
-0.6434242725,
-0.5625247955,
-0.2976089716,
-0.2701665163,
0.1737816185,
0.2052280158,
0.6133976579,
0.1497232169,
0.7089661956,
0.2676764131,
-0.0844394639,
0.2296133339,
-0.5477913022,
-0.0360529758,
-0.3828010857,
-0.4180183709,
-0.6494449377,
0.0364360213,
0.7197704315,
0.9269470572,
-0.2510803044,
-0.0207623187,
0.2851903439,
0.4336310029,
-0.8211054802,
-0.3221814632,
-0.9725349545,
-0.0427982248,
-0.1389743239,
-0.2370145619,
-0.261169374,
0.0415503159,
0.2016294748,
-0.7815816998,
0.403727293,
0.0622515716,
0.7935418487,
0.0886114836,
-0.2797314823,
-0.1797540486,
-1.0245162249,
1.1973993778,
-0.9004474282,
0.3341705501,
0.0561384223,
0.4918222427,
-0.2630366981,
-0.6425964832,
-0.6527910829,
0.2194155902,
0.0943782553,
0.0979923308,
-0.0371228456,
0.3659352958,
-0.0804936439,
0.6188154817,
-0.516443789,
-0.0781268328,
-0.0660884082,
-0.0733786821,
0.4752388895,
-0.0017045406,
0.565957725,
0.5788324475,
-0.2349825948,
-0.0045430069,
-0.6845862865,
-0.235616073,
0.2214381844,
0.0739255026,
-0.2059885561,
0.5233002305,
-0.185199216,
1.2578274012,
0.2967711985,
-0.0548863932,
0.0122861685,
-0.5341747999,
-0.4833530486,
-0.6601369977,
0.3769517839,
0.4500345886,
0.6343316436,
-0.3775686026,
-0.247453928,
0.0847199038,
0.1807045043,
-0.9368656874,
-0.4340658188,
0.2522170842,
-0.6043941975,
-0.0803516954,
0.1909726262,
-0.33313936,
-0.2587641478,
-0.3341596127,
0.6747015715,
-0.3523305058,
-0.4393652678,
0.5535296202,
-0.4530223012,
0.4553346634,
0.2725962996,
-0.7322379947,
0.5069687963,
0.7399827838,
0.648432374,
-0.4290316105,
-0.2567654252,
-0.2816666067,
0.0130822901,
-0.1111914665,
0.6919952631,
-0.8315267563,
-0.4088078737,
-0.0448896922,
0.0989627466,
-0.6848583221,
-1.1294794083,
0.5183660984,
-0.7223880291,
0.028765101,
0.0120558785,
-0.8083893657,
-0.2573530078,
0.0542474613,
-0.2779904604,
0.4984044433,
0.3903761804,
-0.3865404427,
0.6466018558,
-0.1684224755,
-0.5240471363,
0.0443807356,
-0.1457074583,
-0.3706533909,
0.4870370924,
-0.0120042274,
0.3862707913,
-0.3172914386,
0.4203844965,
-0.5837498903,
-0.4995343387,
0.4445529282,
-0.0960652009,
0.7796123028,
0.1442895383,
-0.0691893771,
0.1612436771,
-0.987795651,
-0.0918448642,
0.1871422529,
-0.2706703246,
-0.6638298631,
0.0496484004,
-0.143406719,
0.1820279658,
-0.016412003,
-0.2962975502,
0.1702370644,
-0.21784468,
0.2372885495,
0.5334410071,
0.3836111426,
0.6697918773,
-0.3478788733,
0.5988309383,
0.3004070222,
0.1286880076,
0.0600918531,
-0.6356679201,
-0.8726396561,
-0.2429661006,
0.4992486835,
0.2393063158,
-0.5821711421,
0.6838382483,
-0.0185636394,
-0.5226970911,
-0.4050147831,
0.292092979,
0.3075968623,
0.3845627606,
0.3347264826,
-0.531106174,
-0.2299221754,
-0.8222939372,
-0.6791287661,
0.3055266142,
-0.1897859275,
0.2704527974,
0.3293612003,
-0.1058104411,
0.8993669748,
-0.5206417441,
-0.1000306457,
-0.307813704,
-0.1361486465,
0.1739086211,
0.7042514682,
1.0377658606,
-0.8570930362,
-0.6779595017,
0.0404788442,
-0.5928512812,
-0.1418516636,
-0.0953678936,
-0.1885190308,
-0.6163831353,
-0.0848367959,
-0.3003409803,
0.2189679593,
0.7355260849,
-0.3197590113,
0.5094890594,
-0.3139006793,
-0.0781012401,
-0.6391421556,
-0.1492498964,
0.4223852158,
-0.0576759055,
-1.1143937111,
0.2743420005,
0.0469853282,
-0.0121241771,
-0.405757755,
0.5080292821,
-0.3930520713,
0.0395415984,
-0.4064995348,
0.0752663016,
0.0696562007,
0.5076560378,
-0.04871713,
0.7325463891,
0.7878838778,
-1.0843350887,
-0.1515553445,
-0.0594394431,
-0.1551665366,
0.6054317355,
-0.7713162303,
-0.0058320845,
-0.0913922712,
0.0353575312,
-1.022770524,
0.1258971542,
0.4403460026,
-0.0764731094,
0.3450967669,
-0.3563206792,
-0.0127703762,
-0.0224438272,
-0.2002508938,
0.6287328601,
0.386479646,
-0.3710217774,
0.8280191422,
0.4521003664,
0.0211404189,
-0.1755581349,
-0.4328264594,
-0.3605951965,
-0.4336117804,
-0.6730819941,
0.4769882858,
-0.6058818698,
-0.3635909855,
-0.2584060729,
-0.4561225176,
-0.4297172725,
0.210026145,
0.0468320698,
0.1420285404,
-0.238432169,
-0.5952031612,
0.343297869,
0.0593572967,
-0.191224426,
-0.5558481216,
0.4318256676,
0.1218193546,
-0.6034972668,
-0.3671991825,
-0.0037797499,
0.4076792598,
-0.0880749002,
0.7568590045,
0.3909435868,
-0.3412193358,
-0.432995528,
-0.4133424163,
-0.0608836599,
-0.5269840956,
0.293766439,
-0.5405389071,
-0.7010411024,
0.641598165,
-0.2309308052,
0.1132384837,
0.4820634425,
0.3258166313,
0.2220980227,
0.9400373101,
0.5801025033,
-0.0645537749,
0.3681401908,
-0.1345243305,
0.1988394707,
-0.8622208238,
0.1638146788,
-0.547190547,
-0.4691684544,
-0.4033788443,
-0.4824014604,
-0.0211960413,
0.1174425557,
0.0480266921,
0.3021725714,
-0.515355587,
0.5667514801,
0.221504584,
-0.2508212924,
0.3327415586,
0.1540574282,
-0.1917648613,
-0.1305617392,
-0.6974955201,
-0.0789584965,
1.017629385,
0.2428738028,
0.5014030933,
0.0181888845,
0.3287456036,
0.1899905801,
0.2477935702,
-0.7658528686,
0.503514111,
-0.4911083579,
-0.51088202,
0.1331911385,
-0.3368764222,
-0.6125597954,
0.7621765733,
-0.0886156484,
-0.5001179576,
0.7781808972,
0.1692900658,
-0.2151075602,
0.1701224446,
-0.8887803555,
0.7883925438,
-0.1335505694,
0.0592875108,
-0.3358327448,
-0.3823082447,
0.3097323179,
-0.2660582066,
0.1860533506,
-0.0404858291,
0.1729218513,
0.7744714022,
-0.2948614061,
0.6422632337,
-0.577871263,
-0.2309952974,
0.5000079274,
0.220943734,
0.2936467528,
-0.1630412489,
0.1000742167,
0.3568847477,
-0.1386101246,
-0.3846154809,
-0.7012210488,
0.5756361485,
-0.7970858216,
-0.4653508365,
-0.0278373454,
-0.5692259073,
-0.4966941774,
0.2779219449,
-0.0189065449,
0.4820286334,
0.02807853,
0.136994645,
0.7682340145,
-0.1988741755,
0.1133541688,
0.9669268727,
-0.1569764018,
-0.3549530208,
1.4729832411,
0.0072251367,
0.349008739,
0.4891909659,
0.1280989945,
0.3517714143,
-1.0648630857,
-0.2367008328,
0.4425342679,
-0.4436569512,
-0.1239524558,
-0.2339608371,
-0.1376027614,
-0.0744929016,
-0.1819431335,
-0.1031957194,
-0.5468910336,
-0.2044245303,
0.1758205295,
-0.23444812,
0.5977316499,
0.4226108789,
0.9204570651,
-0.5651523471,
0.4610112906,
0.2900469601,
0.4490939975,
0.0604824871,
-0.7123259902,
-0.218409881,
0.1325104088,
-0.2585474253,
-0.7479763627,
0.1835095435,
0.570450604,
0.6331474781,
0.9190976024,
-0.1886934191,
0.7571519017,
-0.1633595377,
0.7041317225,
0.0018627158,
-0.7842633724,
0.1681932062,
-0.3804657757,
0.0439256392,
0.5581344962,
0.1344957501,
-0.2897632718,
-0.4940545857,
-0.494887352,
-0.9176641107,
0.6356141567,
0.1750192046,
0.0110650025,
0.3419981897,
0.4870973527,
0.3141775429,
0.2650133371,
-0.4127857685,
-0.4117094278,
0.0967865884,
-0.1969860196,
0.0967279896,
-0.2796220183,
-0.2320360988,
-0.3860183656,
0.6787366271,
-0.1218568161,
0.0835715681,
-0.1759035736,
-0.4502130151,
-0.0289731026,
0.1400290132,
0.7350716591,
0.8944303393,
-0.3673335612,
0.063779965,
0.0895773247,
-0.5922242403,
0.0617702976,
0.021113161,
-0.3592728078,
-0.0901056156,
0.119164817,
0.6117309332,
0.1262077838,
-0.538623035,
0.4420938194,
-0.2680271268,
-0.225034982,
0.0697456971,
0.4440411925,
-0.0711772516,
-0.0693708137,
0.4514557123,
0.4368242919,
0.1869226694,
-0.13991566,
0.0512354635,
0.7067314982,
-0.3606542945,
-0.7801283002,
0.4735682905,
0.3146716058,
0.0143098729,
0.2278573066,
-0.1701786518,
-0.2054143846,
0.5223644376,
0.7320747972,
0.9397986531,
-0.2303299457,
-0.0745144635,
-0.089987874,
0.1353512704,
0.1508388966,
0.0527027622,
-0.1772044599,
-1.1667170525,
-0.5138937235,
-0.6723767519,
-0.3214618564,
-0.0047196671,
-0.5273029804,
0.0542292669,
-0.5780454278,
-0.2308492213,
0.0475393422,
-0.2535672188,
-0.6678083539,
0.4839296639,
-0.1493427306,
0.9074503183,
-1.015131712,
0.8118418455,
1.0280530453,
-0.1669016331,
-0.6074408293,
0.2225452363,
-0.2237374187,
-0.9100703597,
0.2326710224,
-0.2099900991,
-0.0273582879,
-0.1025406495,
-0.3519731462,
-0.5278012156,
0.8600772619,
0.3224655986,
-0.5332127213,
-0.0373090878,
0.3713489771,
0.3472549021,
-0.4629841149,
0.1995238662,
0.75123173,
0.57408005,
-0.0120392097,
-0.7732827067,
0.0362993032,
-0.2718439698,
0.058993686,
0.0252618864,
-0.6166605353,
0.7476950884,
0.3770633936,
-0.17707479,
-0.0914512947,
0.6524707675,
0.2000217438,
0.2811509669,
0.6114245653,
0.5512896776,
0.6258581877,
0.0575026833,
0.8215608597,
-0.6888236403,
0.3473685682,
0.9508290291,
-0.3102979958,
0.3401895761,
0.4039409459,
-0.4560491741,
0.3567683101,
0.1560504436,
0.0088488692,
0.4539823234,
0.1131016761,
-0.3170952499,
-0.2806006372,
-0.0109319855,
-0.3232159615,
0.0540759414,
0.4883843958,
-0.2236634046,
-0.119718276,
-0.1906556785,
-0.262124747,
-0.2407817692,
-0.2273012847,
0.8271542788,
0.3500105143,
-0.5526881218,
0.6310110688,
0.1972670406,
1.0078005791,
-0.8792507052,
0.083074443,
-0.0681439713,
0.4136673212,
-0.2971583009,
-0.5593864918,
0.275996238,
-0.4265289307,
-0.1806814969,
-0.0660328045,
1.2553156614,
-0.3367826045,
-0.2092561126,
0.3342340291,
0.4618077576,
-0.1867021173,
-0.3433744907,
-0.4814370275,
0.0131086921,
0.0933614746,
-0.0702697113,
0.8046589494,
0.2996930778,
0.1423599124,
0.527161479,
0.4066494107,
0.3308245242,
0.0944900364,
0.2503050864,
0.9291651845,
-0.2953237593,
-0.260014236,
-0.6402261853,
0.5980424285,
0.0924972072,
-0.2123768479,
0.9728928208,
0.4096301496,
0.7886232138,
-0.2852448821,
0.9845125675,
0.0313195065,
0.1451168209,
-0.2591405213,
0.5958119631,
-0.566704154,
0.113078177,
-0.2312101424,
-1.1937736273,
-0.3941963911,
0.4314557314,
-0.262547344,
0.1924563646,
0.477663517,
0.5945599079,
-0.431265682,
-0.0249343161,
0.2892130315,
-0.0654782429,
0.2997107208,
0.1236386895,
0.3771869838,
-0.2926728129,
0.306284219,
-0.2590061128,
-0.2107203305,
-0.1972709149,
-0.6798914075,
-0.7155534625,
-0.5011550784,
-0.4782420993,
-0.1576341689,
-0.0058279177,
0.4466437101,
0.7070322037,
-1.1471152306,
-0.3770378828,
-0.1348460615,
0.1130089313,
-0.5004556775,
-0.2835078835,
0.0335954167,
-0.1072060466,
-0.612375319,
0.4829947352,
0.2817367613,
0.1468541473,
-0.1117516011,
-0.1892179996,
0.177632153,
0.3865849674,
0.4687058628,
0.3717734814,
-0.3992671072,
0.0194700453,
-0.2434084266,
0.4174584448,
0.0322350934,
1.1939668655,
-0.4936096668,
0.4911766946,
0.5631104708,
0.4887288809,
0.2079573125,
0.3550833762,
0.872377336,
-0.8999585509,
0.2926861644,
0.0723123699,
0.6115145683,
0.1734050363,
0.0689169839,
0.2584522069,
0.4369138181,
-0.6029621959,
-0.5337148905,
0.2289952189,
-1.1117116213,
-0.2527503371,
1.2092652321,
-0.056504935,
-0.0533565804,
-0.0190091543,
-0.1711593419,
0.0359047167,
-0.3109717667,
0.3824941516,
0.5214731097,
-0.124785617,
0.3134457171,
-0.2244665623,
0.2782954276,
0.5100823045,
-0.4741339982,
-0.0231963471,
0.3095396161,
0.6467831135,
0.0571448766,
0.6538280249,
0.2033438236,
-0.1675313115,
-0.2745277584,
-0.2545838654,
0.1164436042,
-0.3900519907,
-0.540902257,
0.2298268527,
0.4548458457,
-0.1124556959
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10631v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10631v1
|
BitDistiller: Unleashing the Potential of Sub-4-Bit LLMs via Self-Distillation
| 2024-02-16T12:27:15 | 2024-02-16T12:27:15 |
Dayou Du, Yijia Zhang, Shijie Cao, Jiaqi Guo, Ting Cao, Xiaowen Chu, Ningyi Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The upscaling of Large Language Models (LLMs) has yielded impressive advances
in natural language processing, yet it also poses significant deployment
challenges. Weight quantization has emerged as a widely embraced solution to
reduce memory and computational demands. This paper introduces BitDistiller, a
framework that synergizes Quantization-Aware Training (QAT) with Knowledge
Distillation (KD) to boost the performance of LLMs at ultra-low precisions
(sub-4-bit). Specifically, BitDistiller first incorporates a tailored
asymmetric quantization and clipping technique to maximally preserve the
fidelity of quantized weights, and then proposes a novel Confidence-Aware
Kullback-Leibler Divergence (CAKLD) objective, which is employed in a
self-distillation manner to enable faster convergence and superior model
performance. Empirical evaluations demonstrate that BitDistiller significantly
surpasses existing methods in both 3-bit and 2-bit configurations on general
language understanding and complex reasoning benchmarks. Notably, BitDistiller
is shown to be more cost-effective, demanding fewer data and training
resources. The code is available at https://github.com/DD-DuDa/BitDistiller.
|
[
-0.1363810748,
-0.4804939032,
0.7015737295,
0.3390388489,
-0.4598529935,
0.4594391286,
-0.1478608251,
-0.0117220972,
0.0881545097,
0.249901861,
-0.152615577,
-0.2908582687,
-0.7469641566,
0.0234960597,
-0.5057688951,
0.7735794783,
-0.115923427,
-0.0525714345,
-0.3241388202,
0.0121459672,
-0.3750954568,
-0.4864005148,
-0.5379282236,
-0.3977274001,
-0.0037430678,
0.3109021485,
0.4863967597,
0.5742229223,
0.2264518291,
0.3471549153,
-0.0922950059,
-0.2051861435,
-0.2988973558,
0.2575238645,
-0.0009104503,
-0.7036350369,
-0.1531202942,
-0.0161939114,
0.4780807793,
0.3731419146,
-0.5918150544,
0.0442136638,
0.1124911904,
0.9066342115,
-0.8431656957,
-0.0196782872,
-0.5666152239,
-0.1146498397,
-0.1710929722,
0.103567645,
0.0207722876,
-0.4185059071,
0.0503915064,
-0.4898233116,
0.2720183134,
-0.1568999738,
0.4656189084,
0.5606040359,
-0.330134511,
-0.3832841516,
-0.7786951661,
0.9292294383,
-0.8356479406,
0.5111207366,
0.3148846626,
0.3215109706,
0.1377034783,
-0.8314419389,
-0.7304146886,
0.250461787,
0.1953200698,
-0.0314857736,
-0.4882502556,
0.173441276,
-0.0111181196,
0.8568601608,
-0.3111759722,
-0.0644198805,
-0.3222594261,
-0.2562877238,
0.3243146837,
0.0222529303,
-0.2203760445,
0.0098756822,
-0.3329342604,
-0.2136042118,
-0.4733151495,
-0.0189076588,
0.2058432102,
-0.0856187791,
-0.0803132728,
0.3966373801,
-0.3793925643,
0.4297035635,
0.4526703954,
-0.2796700597,
-0.0246077329,
-0.4301239252,
-0.4085019827,
0.4018279314,
0.8439164162,
0.2360579669,
0.0516432114,
0.1108752713,
-0.3627886772,
0.1078493074,
0.0682844743,
-1.3300334215,
-0.747977078,
0.2380408049,
-0.0551689975,
-0.3355019987,
-0.262662977,
-0.5328412652,
-0.4194455743,
-0.1580151021,
0.5440797806,
-0.5425075889,
-0.122356616,
0.4754659534,
-0.1842786819,
-0.0520488694,
0.09558779,
-0.944470346,
0.2891898453,
0.5101447701,
0.9404181242,
-0.0135882776,
0.1593190432,
-0.2646394074,
0.1933741868,
-0.3939702511,
0.4863048792,
-0.1600188613,
-0.4233223796,
-0.378516227,
-0.3640998304,
0.3036314547,
-0.609692812,
0.4544506371,
-0.6463861465,
-0.0175222214,
-0.1700471044,
-0.646158576,
-0.0472791977,
0.1995602995,
-0.6918051243,
1.0673344135,
0.1819650382,
-0.6620258689,
0.4618526995,
-0.3222111762,
-0.3344980478,
0.2994615734,
-0.3277256787,
-0.5686156154,
0.5184644461,
0.2360735983,
0.3220663965,
-0.4917084277,
0.362449795,
-0.0719441324,
-0.285559535,
0.1559561491,
-0.660964787,
0.6861224174,
0.2219962478,
-0.2154974341,
-0.1309341639,
-0.7692077756,
0.0772467628,
0.138078481,
-0.5153948665,
-0.7108978033,
-0.3323852122,
-0.2748702466,
0.0755873546,
0.3893744349,
-0.7622587681,
-0.0129514439,
-0.4528564513,
0.6075837612,
0.7375342846,
-0.0351036489,
0.5541424751,
-0.0270024315,
0.5666245818,
0.2127473205,
0.0279396344,
-0.0701367036,
-0.0924787372,
-0.8442951441,
-0.6098822355,
0.6617354751,
0.2345721275,
-1.0366374254,
0.5701307058,
-0.2871508002,
-0.4056250453,
-1.054138422,
0.3020050228,
0.3943562508,
0.2200584114,
0.3449425399,
-0.151448071,
-0.4646424353,
-0.712859273,
-0.0507516153,
-0.0236893278,
-0.1329944581,
-0.3895958364,
0.2274317145,
-0.0381121226,
1.1399793625,
-0.5293639302,
-0.4209400117,
-0.3095375299,
0.3335878253,
0.1744569689,
0.4018014371,
0.2565592825,
-0.7631374002,
-0.6346251369,
-0.163820982,
-0.5420203209,
-0.1216189489,
0.0791308954,
0.0907734409,
0.3606449664,
0.5642223954,
-0.5269373655,
0.3670503199,
0.9415782094,
-0.1498007625,
0.5212159157,
-0.4994615912,
0.0433300883,
-1.1913362741,
-0.2930538058,
-0.0311795622,
-0.349622488,
-0.4846886396,
-0.2222492993,
0.3068377972,
0.2112517506,
-0.2884563208,
0.1629569829,
-0.5322488546,
0.2262720168,
-0.5421647429,
0.0586696565,
0.3611682355,
-0.0109986607,
-0.1119574234,
0.8852934241,
0.4901100099,
-0.5548579693,
0.5350903869,
-0.0855848491,
-0.4212242365,
0.6726141572,
-0.8748729825,
-0.0390183628,
0.0308518652,
0.0768866614,
-0.9739983678,
0.2270340174,
-0.2017715424,
-0.2189190686,
0.2945049703,
-0.2193710357,
-0.5494908094,
-0.4361423552,
-0.7316439152,
0.6163253188,
0.5593196154,
-0.5501974821,
0.6445965767,
0.387473762,
-0.0056772083,
-0.2653726637,
-0.8823757768,
-0.0068907575,
-0.3981021941,
-0.1414238214,
0.3788764179,
-0.3286754191,
-0.1987523735,
-0.002056269,
-0.5665098429,
0.036559239,
0.0005457518,
0.0814493671,
0.0871606022,
0.0355738141,
0.1579484195,
0.3545873761,
-0.3442846537,
0.004598455,
-0.7089116573,
0.5306740999,
-0.1560610235,
-0.1999303102,
-0.4735935628,
-0.0587613285,
0.2686979473,
-0.0491365008,
0.5676578283,
0.5158462524,
-0.1605942845,
-0.1866177469,
-0.615676403,
-0.2548084557,
-0.5711965561,
0.2230427265,
-0.6265751719,
-1.2333865166,
0.0326441862,
-0.191775322,
-0.215974912,
0.0945731252,
0.663441062,
-0.1854262203,
0.5799736977,
0.9339237809,
-0.2091201842,
0.2099216729,
-0.3424093127,
0.4456511736,
-0.6829904914,
0.1679411978,
-0.1318117976,
-0.3674260676,
-0.6431442499,
-0.6154171228,
0.4498287141,
0.4594222307,
0.0952674672,
0.3404389322,
-0.481375277,
0.8549560308,
0.6747460365,
-0.3084522486,
0.5488491058,
-0.1555168778,
-0.2016602308,
-0.1423197687,
-0.6742498279,
-0.2320883721,
0.9667292833,
0.2015338838,
1.1689511538,
0.0585052632,
0.8928262591,
0.3562896252,
-0.1817327887,
-0.8037559986,
0.3638691008,
-0.1073141173,
-0.3890440464,
-0.4880473912,
-0.509711206,
-0.7090751529,
0.4025620222,
0.082299374,
-0.4230428636,
0.2870949805,
0.3652278483,
-0.7820836902,
0.2809650302,
-0.6961788535,
0.6843143702,
-0.0555427,
-0.0938984752,
-0.2236053348,
-0.4645991325,
0.377543062,
-0.3938861489,
0.1919517219,
-0.1197092161,
-0.1680244058,
0.6656831503,
-0.3955721557,
0.7649542689,
-0.1252036989,
-0.5781540275,
0.3573023379,
0.5394979119,
0.391589433,
0.1034803316,
0.1229952127,
0.3356630802,
0.3796104193,
-0.2664067447,
-0.6530476809,
0.7396997213,
-0.5160448551,
-0.5058018565,
-0.3659111261,
-0.4945527613,
-0.0524839684,
0.1876609176,
0.1752776355,
0.2687402964,
0.1113737747,
0.2664377391,
0.7936624885,
0.0902299359,
0.6260282993,
0.5754033923,
-0.1943724304,
-0.6149889231,
0.989782691,
0.055756297,
0.4885372818,
0.4726206362,
0.385964632,
-0.4177936614,
-0.6031891704,
-0.2990249395,
0.1461282223,
-0.4836945236,
-0.5776782632,
-0.611266315,
-0.1791585088,
-0.4770563543,
-0.0377197675,
-0.773933351,
-0.6837373376,
-0.0862392858,
-0.2018430382,
0.4398118854,
0.6378797889,
-0.3685893714,
0.6668764353,
-0.6026940346,
0.2820239663,
0.5644021034,
0.3920775056,
-0.2013642192,
-0.5413766503,
-0.4871210456,
0.0546599664,
-0.3182668984,
-0.3802605569,
0.4006042778,
0.2125275135,
0.0132792201,
0.3871037662,
0.3002552986,
0.6123049855,
-0.2489076257,
0.5528574586,
0.2862650454,
-1.0873771906,
0.4644988477,
0.2154882103,
0.5317435265,
0.8093374968,
0.5238893628,
-0.4600523412,
-0.4341900647,
-0.3363974988,
-0.8790569305,
0.5421586037,
0.1681159884,
0.0807113722,
0.0178550892,
0.179365322,
0.0435052626,
0.392198652,
-0.5810585022,
-0.2144308537,
-0.0616138987,
-0.4715198576,
-0.1012152433,
-0.5335225463,
0.168771565,
-0.3192576766,
0.7282727957,
-0.2807624042,
-0.1541301608,
0.1368237138,
-0.2347075939,
-0.0238172058,
0.4164620638,
0.126189217,
0.3139912784,
-0.1778033078,
0.5912654996,
0.0744491071,
-0.6169320941,
0.4275666773,
0.1975613236,
-0.1728866249,
-0.3018667698,
0.0684074238,
0.5663527846,
0.2654517293,
-0.5679808855,
0.6731457114,
-0.3225432336,
-0.2185602486,
-0.000680708,
-0.0276867747,
0.1891765594,
0.4817537069,
0.2565353513,
-0.4518930614,
0.3760166168,
-0.1972188205,
0.1927672476,
0.3218635023,
-0.4323727787,
-0.404741317,
0.5651810765,
0.086344853,
0.1381513625,
0.3950329721,
-0.5780201554,
-0.4634186327,
0.0599104166,
0.5655837059,
0.787525475,
-0.3661339581,
0.0624335445,
0.0502304323,
0.1656316519,
-0.0561846271,
0.2503856421,
-0.4352354705,
-0.8372103572,
-0.5670185685,
-1.034873724,
-0.14023754,
-0.0925270095,
-0.5362727046,
-0.0444554575,
-0.3651918769,
-0.2350483686,
-0.0783673078,
0.0063431021,
-0.2193802148,
0.0102762375,
0.1614941806,
0.6939634681,
-0.5333192945,
1.0437079668,
0.4945297539,
-0.1483892649,
-0.4863149524,
0.1225816831,
-0.0839718357,
-0.6587723494,
0.4192246199,
0.0478303209,
-0.2888892293,
0.4835949838,
-0.2802917361,
-0.7272979021,
1.2999844551,
0.38891837,
-0.8397282362,
0.0268438905,
0.3350076079,
0.3623440266,
0.1088373363,
0.0673160553,
1.1443219185,
0.109005861,
0.2612020075,
-0.8832179308,
0.1033651307,
0.1067620292,
0.3907003701,
0.4907582104,
-0.5951604843,
0.7632228732,
-0.2381130308,
-0.2209441513,
-0.1188331991,
0.8728173375,
0.4298472703,
-0.0324769206,
0.5083706975,
0.9228782058,
0.6293956041,
-0.0173592437,
0.7050071955,
-0.4079428613,
0.3398551047,
1.2145336866,
-0.1916968524,
0.6086440682,
0.7839809656,
-0.55587852,
0.5006065965,
0.1171822697,
0.3498312533,
0.7623409033,
0.3271941543,
-0.5459083319,
-0.1923053414,
-0.0421016552,
-0.0361571275,
0.4031296968,
0.1057412699,
0.0596582778,
-0.3383271098,
0.0947387144,
-0.0404966734,
0.1100454852,
-0.0700213686,
0.8568459749,
0.298199743,
-0.1931166053,
0.6911195517,
0.1156690642,
1.0797157288,
-0.5299845338,
0.008847652,
-0.3289062381,
0.4347285628,
0.1951217502,
-0.8066666126,
0.1949970424,
-0.0942150652,
-0.0831474736,
-0.3102220297,
0.6740369797,
-0.5790516734,
-0.5160904527,
0.130417496,
0.4009071887,
-0.0950742215,
-0.4641035795,
-0.4840864241,
0.131295532,
-0.019370243,
-0.1053864956,
0.2612733543,
1.002269268,
0.1855764836,
0.7610560656,
0.4564203024,
0.2612051368,
0.0890217498,
0.137243405,
0.9480023384,
-0.6284666657,
-0.5740637779,
-1.2347019911,
0.1359687746,
0.0686940625,
0.1160132661,
0.9351177216,
0.7567524314,
0.7823812962,
0.1319072992,
0.7017839551,
-0.1568944752,
0.2991101742,
-0.4577933252,
0.6615560055,
-0.2615694702,
0.2030968666,
0.0686578825,
-0.5868027806,
-0.0820388272,
0.4632874727,
-0.1670905799,
0.0018279887,
0.5356465578,
0.5686185956,
0.0630624443,
-0.090601325,
0.6014031172,
0.1681331396,
0.362529546,
0.5435934067,
0.7743797898,
-0.5144705772,
0.5158939958,
-0.6715875268,
-0.3344969749,
0.0169696845,
-0.9511190653,
-0.8266319036,
-0.5884867907,
-0.3052695692,
0.0400159284,
0.0028184473,
0.8675107956,
0.795583427,
-0.7462241054,
-0.2643150091,
-0.2587281764,
-0.0419301093,
0.0766179264,
-0.2426641434,
0.1622274369,
-0.335505724,
-0.5708695054,
0.3056563139,
0.4298997223,
0.4498955011,
-0.4741432667,
-0.0299276821,
-0.0112402504,
0.1948433816,
0.6223242283,
-0.1133294478,
-0.3709410429,
0.1977899373,
-0.4266989529,
-0.0545763969,
-0.0160947591,
0.8035469055,
-1.0556502342,
0.4698756635,
0.1211915836,
0.6340098381,
0.6340507865,
0.1844582707,
0.4671300948,
-1.0057998896,
0.0850082934,
0.1617223918,
0.1956085712,
0.419056505,
-0.301907748,
0.3387580812,
0.3166081905,
-0.4449953437,
-0.6953914762,
-0.0167191084,
-0.5867364407,
-0.2836036682,
0.8910465837,
0.0336612016,
-0.305441916,
0.0470244735,
-0.1527007818,
0.1500596404,
-0.5720158219,
0.8691319227,
0.6435412169,
0.0463897139,
-0.2910373211,
-0.2449409366,
0.5936926007,
0.2748639286,
-0.6272078753,
0.4035100043,
0.312259376,
0.3353776932,
0.0899287239,
0.8701687455,
-0.0304473806,
-0.0620650053,
-0.0453431234,
0.377928555,
-0.0311871842,
-0.3218647838,
-0.5421782136,
-0.1951724142,
0.2472528517,
-0.2530977428
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10618v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10618v2
|
Enhancing Role-playing Systems through Aggressive Queries: Evaluation and Improvement
| 2024-02-16T12:12:05 | 2024-06-15T13:51:38 |
Yihong Tang, Jiao Ou, Che Liu, Fuzheng Zhang, Di Zhang, Kun Gai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The advent of Large Language Models (LLMs) has propelled dialogue generation
into new realms, particularly in the field of role-playing systems (RPSs).
While enhanced with ordinary role-relevant training dialogues, existing
LLM-based RPSs still struggle to align with roles when handling intricate and
trapped queries in boundary scenarios. In this paper, we design the Modular
ORchestrated Trap-setting Interaction SystEm (MORTISE) to benchmark and improve
the role-playing LLMs' performance. MORTISE can produce highly role-relevant
aggressive queries through the collaborative effort of multiple LLM-based
modules, and formulate corresponding responses to create an adversarial
training dataset via a consistent response generator. We select 190 Chinese and
English roles to construct aggressive queries to benchmark existing
role-playing LLMs. Through comprehensive evaluation, we find that existing
models exhibit a general deficiency in role alignment capabilities. We further
select 180 of the roles to collect an adversarial training dataset (named
RoleAD) and retain the other 10 roles for testing. Experiments on models
improved by RoleAD indicate that our adversarial dataset ameliorates this
deficiency, with the improvements demonstrating a degree of generalizability in
ordinary scenarios.
|
[
-0.1737241894,
-0.705054462,
0.0305082016,
0.1904016584,
-0.0760314986,
0.0668485239,
-0.2018865645,
-0.3461660445,
0.0532628968,
0.7340629697,
-0.5833897591,
-0.539947629,
-0.4682876766,
0.0457729176,
0.0024954304,
0.9090413451,
0.3093540072,
0.3151814938,
-0.1185361221,
-0.15498887,
-0.7650616765,
-0.3659093976,
-1.0222707987,
-0.1702308208,
0.2252339572,
-0.0560822785,
0.9866018891,
0.4565011263,
0.5891213417,
0.3240252733,
0.0544861704,
0.5604370832,
-0.7474575043,
0.5406352282,
-0.2602552176,
-0.5448603034,
-0.7438208461,
-0.1754473746,
0.5655625463,
0.2617493272,
-0.3361105621,
-0.2035977989,
0.074094601,
0.2383259088,
-0.6374354362,
0.3147124648,
-0.7671917677,
0.1701524109,
-0.0607806258,
-0.1550845206,
-0.5834951997,
-0.1796576977,
0.1353208572,
-0.6856960654,
-0.0221215095,
-0.0306457933,
0.6260007024,
0.2743288279,
-0.3100958467,
-0.194715187,
-0.5930898786,
0.6416530609,
-0.9511118531,
0.0985676944,
0.372787863,
0.3150699139,
-0.554651618,
-0.1101013348,
0.1379375011,
-0.1044123396,
-0.1872221828,
0.2345475107,
0.1493775696,
0.2533623874,
0.3796076179,
0.04688574,
-0.6675275564,
0.2222551405,
-0.2237434387,
-0.1904977858,
1.2125897408,
0.5206215382,
0.3864037097,
-0.1236367449,
-0.3384943008,
-0.1428059936,
-0.6532701254,
0.3936513662,
0.5589811206,
0.4826137424,
0.1106132194,
0.5551481843,
0.0680086985,
0.8115392923,
0.1768068075,
0.1219190881,
-0.3468571901,
0.0933355764,
-0.2023058683,
-0.1569076926,
0.6993452907,
0.5015333891,
0.36769858,
-0.116361469,
-0.4869980216,
0.1129484624,
0.748046279,
-0.6067709923,
-0.024986336,
0.1764311492,
-0.1452252269,
-0.4993183613,
0.1596023291,
-0.7690693736,
-0.7182839513,
0.0531323329,
0.6327430606,
-0.4269003272,
-0.1592385024,
0.1467960328,
-0.0655811355,
0.4005295038,
0.1903121769,
-0.8311852813,
0.5301948786,
0.9026976824,
0.5650070906,
-0.2689240277,
-0.0241981409,
-0.8549705744,
0.2525479794,
-0.599365592,
0.6168279648,
-0.777144134,
-0.729983449,
0.1851634979,
0.0221546013,
-0.3583287001,
-0.9271869063,
0.4821746647,
-0.7569153905,
-0.013294654,
-0.0617278069,
-0.342605412,
0.3077910244,
0.5923601985,
-0.5915383101,
1.008474946,
-0.1809842587,
-0.3877517879,
0.166742608,
-0.6187979579,
-0.3502041996,
0.0669640601,
-0.4460110962,
-0.4412227571,
0.0822864622,
0.4544661343,
0.3633003533,
-0.1892286539,
0.389867872,
-0.2318849713,
-0.9069207311,
0.2313082665,
-0.0506925099,
0.8144769073,
-0.0328453034,
-0.3108789921,
0.1773103476,
-0.2069390118,
0.014398871,
0.0576210693,
-0.2979389727,
-0.3804395199,
0.3620247245,
-0.679864645,
0.0781028718,
-0.0815045163,
-0.1938832402,
0.5461384058,
-0.4334569871,
0.0621136054,
0.8185527921,
-0.0015166001,
0.3872397244,
-0.3417210877,
0.8725150824,
-0.1073309556,
0.3223298192,
-0.0179432761,
-0.3602969646,
-0.3663727045,
-0.2692202032,
0.1848875582,
0.7952992916,
-0.8673251271,
0.5253321528,
-0.2639067471,
-0.2677845359,
-0.4107469022,
-0.0519179367,
0.5910669565,
0.0891132951,
0.1832998395,
-0.6208962798,
-0.4863411486,
-0.8628556132,
-0.4167870879,
-0.2491410673,
-0.0732697397,
0.7748738527,
0.0809016377,
-0.0017868876,
0.5808095336,
-0.5300397277,
-0.2862488031,
-0.1418618411,
0.0172863714,
-0.0598134622,
0.4114886224,
0.2655842602,
-0.5636685491,
-0.5115895271,
-0.2824737728,
-0.7749157548,
-0.2864659131,
0.0538954884,
-0.4619302154,
0.0419679172,
0.5272783637,
-0.6078252196,
0.3821023405,
0.4405872822,
-0.133228451,
0.6064943671,
0.3318811655,
0.3378368914,
-0.9094817042,
0.1081779152,
-0.2313208729,
-0.0568722747,
-0.6199735999,
0.3871404529,
-0.0742321834,
-0.4083652198,
-0.1576609612,
0.3615285456,
-0.6392959952,
-0.1974972785,
-0.1891277581,
0.4484083951,
-0.067741178,
0.469198674,
-0.096940428,
0.9910399318,
0.5964670777,
-0.545899272,
0.3996191919,
0.444653511,
-0.2351110131,
0.5726506114,
-0.5448338389,
0.0541851223,
0.0009414006,
0.5209453702,
-1.077093482,
-0.2604330778,
0.1156585291,
-0.3120120466,
0.5904544592,
-0.6277421117,
-0.1628066897,
-0.2045835853,
-0.5076138377,
0.4815771282,
0.5598294735,
-0.1552262157,
0.6454337835,
0.4646221101,
-0.1574035734,
-1.1592646837,
-0.2671789527,
0.1709929109,
-0.3354229331,
-0.7285093665,
0.232371226,
0.0907364935,
-0.1804263145,
-0.2318337858,
-0.2641285658,
-0.0846513584,
0.082877785,
0.0615375303,
0.2723431885,
-0.2787726223,
0.1653423011,
-0.0647348315,
0.0718737021,
0.290756017,
0.0960522443,
0.4957688153,
0.2337745577,
-0.3733498156,
-0.1065383255,
0.33860448,
0.4279227853,
-0.4775826037,
0.4231062233,
0.2831455767,
-0.134851709,
-0.5038504601,
-0.4978246093,
-0.2849217355,
-0.4987758696,
0.3144680858,
-0.2836372554,
-0.8878433108,
0.8416341543,
-0.105777435,
0.2767074406,
0.2030358762,
-0.0025706238,
0.1714485735,
1.3194825649,
0.3312923908,
-0.0011549761,
0.4563280642,
-0.2226586938,
0.1161819473,
-1.1846089363,
-0.1284029335,
-0.2989492714,
-0.4513807595,
-0.4816267192,
-0.5333092213,
0.6139567494,
0.0768395066,
-0.2148686349,
0.385099262,
-0.3849891424,
0.3818928301,
-0.0542893559,
0.2308214158,
0.0174426399,
-0.2910515368,
-0.1025509015,
-0.1366375238,
-0.7950478792,
-0.5103606582,
0.8979313374,
0.0649597123,
1.051082015,
0.479111284,
0.570469141,
0.18386136,
0.4089644849,
-0.7503679395,
0.8629680872,
-0.2869230807,
-0.8119617105,
-0.4090871215,
-0.2403232455,
-0.9831982255,
0.3652874231,
-0.3134937584,
-0.7845017314,
0.0846978053,
0.1015631557,
-0.6581753492,
0.238189131,
-0.3443127573,
0.7549542189,
-0.1605786532,
-0.7974939942,
-0.0024658476,
-0.6378905177,
0.6789243221,
0.2793776691,
-0.0592702813,
0.0281266253,
-0.0312021635,
0.400641948,
-0.0927773267,
1.1873211861,
-0.4038059115,
-0.3831052184,
0.3907188177,
0.5098667145,
0.7707689404,
0.2370529771,
-0.4924384654,
-0.3368328214,
-0.1943656653,
-0.2550638616,
-0.7200272083,
0.7991108894,
-0.6102724075,
-1.1780431271,
-0.1735182256,
-0.6224902868,
-0.4945289195,
-0.0811687708,
-0.1453699023,
0.6352526546,
-0.696395874,
0.2727244496,
0.961227417,
-0.3504014611,
0.1706548184,
0.5267999768,
-0.1671748757,
-0.1656739116,
0.5063433051,
0.0869535655,
0.3180418313,
0.2239088118,
-0.110363245,
-0.1746988744,
-0.3174358904,
-0.5819999576,
-0.0710746273,
-0.1870879978,
-0.4981810153,
-0.693565011,
-0.4306399226,
-0.6720981598,
-0.105918631,
-0.2315352559,
-0.1169585884,
0.1478430033,
0.0155096129,
0.0002570346,
0.5987671614,
-0.0630816743,
0.3166044354,
-0.8055974245,
0.0588241331,
0.3760332763,
0.5769382119,
0.0578805022,
-0.5540983677,
-0.2700789869,
-0.1454285085,
-0.3855630159,
-0.9806239605,
0.1693009138,
0.1617302895,
0.7896487117,
0.4373178482,
0.1347766817,
0.796502471,
-0.5575563908,
1.0080878735,
-0.5416975617,
-0.7569804192,
0.5437222123,
-0.8065782785,
0.1709282994,
0.4271289408,
0.2761767805,
-0.4103490412,
-0.3439941406,
-0.536901474,
-0.7530514002,
1.0778956413,
0.1089090481,
0.229601711,
-0.0709728897,
0.4360410869,
-0.1451405138,
0.1788404435,
-0.4275711477,
0.1183987409,
0.0557919554,
0.0252444781,
-0.0742336661,
-0.1375948787,
-0.574144125,
0.1012282446,
0.8110154271,
-0.0556110889,
0.1501441151,
0.0742039159,
0.0644820333,
-0.2575990558,
0.2560998201,
0.5924853683,
0.3209322095,
-0.2318729758,
-0.0384739339,
0.2606755793,
-0.1574455351,
0.0681178644,
0.0809836611,
0.0499038845,
-0.3471221924,
0.3814560473,
0.5232720375,
0.4544421434,
-0.8239044547,
0.6128478646,
0.0139296371,
0.0937777758,
0.0172477607,
0.5892474055,
0.1287980676,
0.251888901,
0.0618242659,
-0.2568055689,
0.2522988319,
-0.6398181319,
0.340462029,
0.8770410419,
-0.3982621431,
-0.1652652919,
0.4153302908,
0.4662427306,
-0.6059195399,
0.5444028378,
-0.0358049721,
-0.5907566547,
0.6779351234,
0.535943985,
0.763481915,
-0.7883438468,
0.2999202013,
0.4128957689,
0.4669936299,
-0.0676124021,
0.2713541687,
-0.0362737998,
-0.7307011485,
-0.4530030489,
-0.1806359887,
-0.3158581257,
0.2366660833,
-0.9170078039,
0.3127858639,
-0.4524609149,
-0.2476303875,
-0.4246555865,
0.2296973616,
-0.2999500334,
0.0788705349,
-0.2371691167,
0.7171369791,
-0.756377995,
0.256177187,
0.8095983267,
-0.0682360232,
-0.534714222,
0.0115364492,
0.0794821605,
-0.8494974375,
0.3438673019,
0.0809253976,
-0.2122552991,
-0.1290733218,
-0.8124032021,
-0.5506752729,
1.0090352297,
-0.0257592704,
-0.3165691495,
0.0651056245,
-0.0456161872,
0.7756906748,
-0.5908896327,
0.2358541042,
0.4373038709,
0.3680599928,
-0.1566580832,
-0.7131928205,
0.137275666,
-0.3601116538,
-0.0145688755,
0.3293892443,
-0.8848488927,
0.4729621708,
-0.0475527011,
-0.3917828798,
0.1963657588,
0.3285132945,
0.2849976122,
0.1542773545,
0.674942255,
0.4723474085,
0.1693779379,
-0.1185024008,
0.7554895878,
-0.2051466107,
-0.1192278042,
1.1863678694,
-0.743299067,
0.644235611,
0.0842691809,
0.161030978,
0.2622859776,
0.4879355431,
-0.0245866664,
0.3256595135,
0.6882343888,
-0.3221709728,
-0.599388361,
-0.0652383119,
-0.1604005992,
0.540830195,
0.5632940531,
-0.0809290931,
-0.2783840299,
-0.3434814215,
-0.1006581336,
0.3034649491,
0.0211008806,
1.0196059942,
-0.046620138,
-0.995087266,
0.2072743177,
0.0234110113,
0.5700415969,
-0.8692871928,
-0.1742838174,
-0.3488062024,
0.1365360171,
-0.1531829238,
-0.5609269142,
0.1778387874,
0.0123722069,
0.1460377127,
0.1751057059,
0.6587524414,
-0.5020033717,
-0.0781169161,
0.4689796269,
0.4712992907,
0.1844626516,
0.2446960062,
-0.8911491632,
0.3393082023,
-0.1475374252,
-0.2336586863,
0.3381917775,
0.4765934944,
-0.3768296838,
0.4680345953,
0.3800024986,
0.0355805159,
0.0101408726,
0.0753610209,
1.0594406128,
-0.5033106804,
-0.3313784301,
-0.5078522563,
0.6494401097,
-0.3219071329,
-0.2411881685,
0.5501518846,
0.5864660144,
0.6018731594,
-0.0008569066,
0.604616642,
0.0530003309,
0.1558283567,
-0.3851677477,
0.4247175157,
-0.3560530841,
0.5221477151,
-0.1695486903,
-0.9423872828,
-0.2320303619,
0.517242372,
-0.2648854554,
0.2664756477,
0.2606013715,
1.256717205,
-0.3056094646,
-0.2104504555,
0.6029236913,
0.2643732429,
0.5243496895,
0.4980109036,
0.9869379997,
-0.650724411,
0.4695863724,
0.204173848,
-0.4179296792,
-0.3143598139,
-0.7258002162,
-0.9504823685,
-0.1729780734,
-0.0489876419,
-0.2690393925,
0.526201129,
0.7863750458,
0.6309034228,
-0.5594390035,
-0.5632205009,
0.4141392708,
-0.1323580742,
-0.4521526992,
-0.312589556,
0.2069599181,
-0.5646263361,
-0.794975996,
0.7825770378,
0.2271977514,
-0.2903746367,
-0.3617786467,
0.1141492724,
-0.2854967713,
0.6670264602,
0.5324985981,
0.25999704,
-0.5811277032,
-0.3859761357,
0.19984442,
-0.2226545066,
-0.1419528574,
1.1869833469,
-0.4037327468,
0.5088333488,
0.3399240375,
0.7630056143,
0.053846892,
0.4365724623,
1.013786912,
-0.7929787636,
-0.1090706661,
0.3784444928,
-0.0173298828,
0.2768212557,
-0.7334073186,
0.7506209612,
-0.3266062438,
-0.7023007274,
-0.8847014308,
0.4093701243,
-0.802964747,
-0.185403198,
1.1006394625,
-0.388207376,
0.0581765175,
-0.155926466,
-0.2679522932,
0.1760858446,
-0.3772080243,
1.0272727013,
0.8415542245,
-0.3329842985,
0.2047541291,
-0.4551720321,
0.8160020709,
0.7144651413,
-0.5063324571,
0.4023238122,
0.7216988206,
-0.0498604625,
0.055850178,
0.5244081616,
-0.4740177095,
0.105249919,
-0.177213788,
-0.1049771085,
0.0339539498,
-0.4147427082,
-0.3719415665,
0.0355759338,
-0.214168027,
0.0423333459
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10614v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10614v2
|
Can LLMs Speak For Diverse People? Tuning LLMs via Debate to Generate Controllable Controversial Statements
| 2024-02-16T12:00:34 | 2024-06-07T20:19:09 |
Ming Li, Jiuhai Chen, Lichang Chen, Tianyi Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Making LLMs speak for different, especially minority groups of people, and
generate statements supporting their diverse or even controversial perspectives
is critical to creating an inclusive environment. However, existing LLMs lack
sufficient controllability to the stance of their generated content, which
often contains inconsistent, neutral, or biased statements. In this paper, we
improve the controllability of LLMs in generating statements supporting an
argument the user defined in the prompt. We find that multi-round debates
between two LLMs with opposite stances generate higher-quality and more salient
statements for each, which are important training data to improve the
controllability of LLMs. Motivated by this, we develop a novel debate & tuning
(DEBATUNE) pipeline finetuning LLMs to generate the statements obtained via
debate. To examine DEBATUNE, we curate the largest dataset of debate topics so
far, which covers 710 controversial topics and corresponding arguments for each
topic. Evaluations by the GPT-4 judge with a novel controversy controllability
metric show that LLMs' capability of generating diverse perspectives is
significantly improved by DEBATUNE. Moreover, such controllability can be
generalized to unseen topics, generating high-quality statements supporting
controversial arguments.
|
[
-0.7941841483,
-0.5633649826,
0.1241767108,
0.2545655072,
-0.527554512,
0.4596552849,
-0.3601275086,
-0.2668348849,
0.3535170257,
0.3961566091,
-0.4280779958,
-0.4506568909,
-0.8325805664,
0.0250753071,
-0.1426774263,
1.1214929819,
-0.0846675187,
0.0574889444,
0.2187508494,
-0.4785434008,
-0.5719797015,
-0.3062084019,
-0.4087384343,
-0.3272650838,
0.9536335468,
0.5851202607,
0.8659092784,
0.4250239432,
0.3193620741,
0.3002015054,
-0.392457813,
0.4700317681,
-0.7660024762,
0.3975114822,
-0.7068707943,
-0.5187553167,
-0.0376988463,
0.0680890083,
0.4822199941,
0.3947681487,
-0.1847990602,
-0.1580749154,
0.1731209308,
0.3619838357,
-0.4298612177,
-0.5327480435,
-1.2602421045,
0.3007750213,
-0.585095644,
-0.2238007486,
-0.1181635186,
-0.4788604975,
-0.3294550776,
-0.5036624074,
0.2747614086,
0.1988407224,
0.7746961713,
0.4440876842,
-0.5823124051,
-0.2885060012,
-0.7408286333,
0.5943193436,
-0.8193997145,
0.0521840788,
-0.0350843966,
0.3258418143,
-0.2779034078,
-0.3613522053,
-0.6115058064,
0.1871534735,
0.2386148423,
0.1739492863,
-0.2216961682,
-0.0212448426,
0.2760177851,
0.3028799593,
-0.2141107321,
0.719597578,
-0.2796263695,
-0.3617019951,
0.7220424414,
0.2839635611,
-0.0875930637,
-0.3513472974,
-0.2619816363,
0.2251976579,
-0.6638060808,
0.000205225,
0.8932560682,
0.1895243227,
0.0324154869,
0.5334733129,
-0.3558111489,
0.5768142343,
0.3910599947,
-0.0454180017,
-0.0440373793,
-0.0466503687,
-0.2619533241,
0.0084607452,
0.7247638106,
0.5632618666,
-0.0289582703,
-0.0240616556,
0.011430664,
-0.0349384211,
0.1864279509,
-0.7674372792,
-0.3477514684,
0.2415712774,
-0.2054718137,
-0.3761513531,
-0.024772387,
-0.8666284084,
-0.969974339,
-0.4407962263,
-0.0923367813,
-0.0924890488,
-0.3568448722,
-0.0580193289,
-0.1951529384,
0.1172380298,
0.7255152464,
-0.8976021409,
0.1378361434,
0.6185098886,
0.5981460214,
-0.7042921185,
0.1898274422,
-0.6167005897,
0.2563352585,
-0.2299809456,
0.6182451248,
-0.7660421133,
-0.4413920045,
-0.3549083769,
-0.2928204238,
0.2784727216,
-0.8178181052,
0.5638337135,
-0.435728997,
0.1798832268,
-0.551433742,
-0.5020073056,
0.2649954259,
0.4221133292,
-0.4495465159,
0.3167984188,
-0.0391998366,
-0.9052672982,
0.650524199,
-0.499376446,
-0.1707711518,
0.2188480049,
-0.7967075109,
-0.4477941394,
0.0253690202,
0.1822715253,
0.0280533042,
-0.0528155081,
0.4429571331,
-0.3602477014,
-0.2205050737,
0.5191634893,
-0.4916594923,
0.673912406,
0.426936239,
-0.5642113686,
0.1854000837,
-0.4472075105,
-0.1486373842,
-0.173468858,
-0.5215916634,
-0.0491899997,
0.1183169633,
-0.1705396771,
0.1506118178,
-0.1379809678,
-0.5832304358,
0.3623204529,
-0.2061421275,
0.4414764941,
1.0687968731,
0.019393431,
0.2829471529,
-0.3313333392,
0.7151858211,
0.3205293119,
-0.0927785337,
0.2202623636,
-0.4113795161,
-0.8231085539,
-0.2743501365,
0.1996685714,
0.5325322151,
-0.568554759,
0.1841647625,
0.1598436683,
-0.3777091801,
-0.6216399074,
0.5001932383,
0.1201660633,
0.6048441529,
0.3200536668,
-0.0169171337,
-0.6081332564,
-0.9897577167,
-0.5891831517,
0.0457664393,
0.0546774305,
0.575130105,
0.0751462802,
-0.0964622572,
0.7883637547,
-0.2576059103,
0.1301239133,
-0.1813229918,
0.4472738802,
0.1071425974,
0.4784879684,
0.3078576326,
-0.8221407533,
-0.4574664533,
-0.1308716238,
-0.3955294788,
-0.34929052,
-0.2940581143,
-0.4708241224,
0.1020056084,
0.2447148561,
-0.380675137,
0.0588435717,
0.2813139856,
-0.4181814492,
0.3882347643,
0.3086595535,
0.2234354019,
-1.0950205326,
-0.4158680141,
-0.109334901,
-0.3289172053,
-0.0577319339,
-0.1858650148,
-0.1550931633,
0.0781765804,
-0.6819170713,
0.3589298129,
-0.2509805858,
0.4599641562,
-0.2283892035,
0.270232141,
-0.1099756733,
0.3029755354,
-0.2005399913,
0.337825954,
0.4761681557,
-0.5927113891,
0.5449097753,
0.4420446455,
-0.2297303826,
0.8896861672,
-0.4253872931,
0.1414789557,
-0.1250713915,
0.2395791262,
-1.136182189,
-0.3062528968,
0.4345909655,
-0.1382545382,
0.4409351051,
-0.1520028114,
-0.0855406448,
-0.3834599853,
-0.2903936505,
0.1369609386,
0.3735767901,
-0.4741173387,
0.1421854347,
0.527548492,
-0.3957006633,
-0.6598450541,
-0.8179521561,
0.3535344005,
-0.6285087466,
-0.433619976,
0.3187576234,
-0.2170905471,
-0.5060201287,
-0.2463348508,
-0.2926729023,
0.2741619051,
0.2139356285,
0.2701584399,
-0.1433764845,
0.0300905239,
0.3816833496,
0.629273057,
0.017665457,
-0.085390687,
-0.0553312153,
0.344845444,
-0.0481578112,
-0.6405457258,
-0.0645534769,
0.5486866832,
0.1273559481,
0.0350415446,
0.3377869427,
0.4209871888,
0.082959719,
-0.4586412907,
-0.5873883367,
-0.0608569756,
-0.4919227958,
0.3084692657,
-0.2021102309,
-1.4327683449,
0.4197933674,
-0.3263994157,
0.4930812716,
0.4489819109,
0.9514455795,
-0.3183533251,
0.7486696839,
0.2496345341,
0.0592103414,
0.2863412201,
0.1535242498,
-0.0118259108,
-0.5546780229,
-0.2190203369,
-0.5770326853,
-1.1564712524,
-0.7365233898,
-0.3798307776,
0.2915755212,
0.2073636949,
-0.3458147049,
-0.2029523104,
-0.7432385087,
0.6586218476,
0.1793065071,
0.0469194092,
0.5035993457,
0.136602208,
-0.2472221106,
-0.5977135301,
-0.3832422495,
-0.6021957397,
0.7085024118,
0.3705900013,
1.1245316267,
0.3899011612,
0.848731339,
0.4629122317,
0.6375623941,
-0.6711424589,
0.4185400307,
-0.019248629,
-0.6921095252,
-0.1603877544,
-0.6189993024,
-0.7675961256,
0.608201921,
-0.2166054547,
-0.7013934851,
0.2038225532,
0.3862482309,
-0.1601525396,
0.6523988843,
-0.2772659659,
0.5632715821,
-0.3830601275,
-0.3939546943,
-0.1765637398,
-0.5290948749,
0.5253250599,
-0.0478278473,
0.0482085198,
-0.4247637987,
-0.1139364243,
0.6823432446,
-0.3062117994,
0.9543820024,
-0.3046244681,
-0.4968765676,
0.2683770359,
0.161777243,
0.195021078,
0.5041964054,
-0.2229541987,
0.211418435,
-0.6401715279,
-0.2205912173,
-0.3956224322,
0.8496057391,
-0.9344938993,
-1.2001572847,
-0.0899024904,
-0.5953693986,
-0.2790754139,
0.1009601057,
0.4295363724,
0.056345664,
-0.2093544602,
0.1761663109,
0.8178379536,
-0.082982786,
0.3511953354,
0.4559824467,
-0.136414662,
-0.5744873881,
0.7093155384,
0.1390299946,
0.1846508235,
0.1803975403,
0.2051765919,
-0.3014788628,
-0.6662726402,
-0.483638078,
-0.0881695673,
-0.7170727253,
-0.5032106638,
-0.7916710973,
-0.0293328092,
0.0180287547,
-0.1893792599,
-0.2215074897,
-0.988773644,
-0.2708394825,
-0.3200935721,
0.3512661159,
0.4070002139,
-0.0839040354,
0.3668493629,
-0.4141882062,
0.4775147736,
0.5644299984,
0.1851862669,
-0.527816236,
-0.7251461744,
0.1321582943,
0.1076070294,
-1.0829027891,
-0.9637851715,
0.0679658204,
0.0775196329,
0.7617450356,
0.4599989057,
0.2109082788,
0.460849762,
-0.2572775185,
0.8164848089,
0.3552432358,
-0.9653888345,
0.8011968136,
-0.3854686618,
0.08173161,
0.4846424162,
0.3034419715,
-0.3949149847,
-1.059087038,
-0.4876361787,
-0.8368557096,
0.643781662,
0.1690796912,
0.3701287508,
0.0491335839,
0.1217129156,
0.609947443,
0.5317361355,
-0.7478154302,
-0.2413190901,
-0.5730916858,
-0.083258763,
0.3103347421,
-0.1177058816,
-0.8871123791,
-0.3641419113,
0.3742034733,
-0.1459738016,
-0.2576893568,
0.004959567,
0.1590233147,
-0.2907617986,
0.7601238489,
0.5998886228,
0.6905929446,
0.0532575771,
0.4627164006,
0.0727581754,
-0.1727487147,
0.3987465203,
0.0965230241,
-0.3410775959,
0.011420113,
-0.2240133435,
1.0584409237,
-0.2361783832,
-0.2580313683,
0.1057133749,
-0.1524250358,
-0.4329961538,
0.2645182312,
0.5022855401,
0.4415318668,
0.5040128827,
0.040100906,
0.3696137965,
-0.0670936331,
-0.0600651279,
0.0823808089,
0.514197588,
-0.1765965372,
0.1018007547,
1.0931046009,
0.6834833026,
-0.187997818,
0.3266600966,
-0.1587693393,
-0.2257272154,
0.5364806652,
0.4587119818,
0.7614063621,
-0.07090801,
0.4657886624,
0.1313486844,
0.2570547163,
0.3911755085,
0.2778312862,
-0.277882874,
-0.9253929257,
-0.1975815296,
-0.4432722628,
-0.9618492723,
0.1979770958,
-0.4443797767,
0.1505292803,
-0.8661611676,
-0.3535042107,
-0.0276969224,
0.0204640795,
-0.3964467347,
-0.0166783128,
0.371560514,
0.8590699434,
-0.6936153769,
0.494622916,
0.5868749022,
-0.1015764847,
-0.4115519226,
0.0278510768,
0.0662203282,
-0.3569248915,
0.4732483029,
0.0897958502,
-0.1898865998,
-0.2978794873,
-0.9779214263,
-0.3159948587,
0.9072819948,
0.8330042362,
-1.0275686979,
0.4870153368,
0.194644466,
0.1781037748,
-0.3027510047,
0.0947425365,
0.3175475597,
0.6336941123,
0.420229286,
-0.6461340785,
0.0783660561,
-0.1621891409,
-0.1454472542,
-0.0225458853,
-1.0628576279,
0.9747630954,
-0.2424452156,
0.0109095164,
-0.3972839415,
0.7611771822,
0.5898749232,
0.3074826896,
0.4878481328,
0.4271017015,
1.3470351696,
-0.249366641,
0.6650076509,
0.0715571418,
0.1263565123,
1.2844851017,
-0.38561216,
0.2986872196,
0.4692752659,
-0.0001692225,
0.383462131,
0.7406817675,
-0.1129471436,
0.3160049021,
0.672278285,
-0.3453928232,
-0.4957610071,
-0.0739905238,
-0.4817251563,
0.2781254351,
0.3482850492,
-0.0915445611,
-0.2501392961,
-0.1083392799,
0.2563351989,
0.4046029449,
-0.2408306301,
0.6305734515,
0.1171348318,
-0.4920350313,
0.742651403,
0.1244759038,
0.9397768378,
-0.520095408,
0.1725828648,
-0.5145737529,
0.0338744484,
-0.4424885809,
-0.7755823731,
0.2307125628,
0.171443969,
-0.1120492816,
-0.366268903,
0.5597011447,
-0.5327849984,
-0.2981778085,
-0.0877447873,
0.4491131008,
0.1543388069,
0.2822215855,
-0.7479290366,
0.1618206948,
0.2826062143,
-0.4011895061,
0.1955224276,
0.6631613374,
-0.1369512826,
0.4658602774,
0.2424497455,
0.2562275231,
0.1487398446,
0.2998340726,
1.3282288313,
-0.5992523432,
-0.4107269645,
-0.912809968,
0.562214613,
-0.4538348615,
-0.6101985574,
0.7791583538,
0.4003505707,
0.7903125286,
0.1677383929,
1.0027838945,
-0.04665263,
0.5256052017,
-0.4825499356,
0.6652638316,
-0.5450385809,
0.2062842846,
-0.1387732178,
-0.6237821579,
-0.1152786538,
0.4710382223,
-0.0508767255,
-0.0528793223,
0.3031898141,
0.7889818549,
-0.2648710608,
0.1949738711,
0.2042168677,
0.4323437512,
0.8611907959,
0.6006608605,
1.0744838715,
0.2635074556,
0.5228467584,
0.1943648905,
-0.2195867598,
-0.0806044787,
-1.078163147,
-0.8852888942,
0.1698181182,
-0.5676158071,
-0.2603006959,
-0.2560555339,
0.880761683,
0.4192331731,
-0.9466944933,
-0.0374752283,
-0.127960071,
0.6006942987,
0.1403135955,
-0.2201039642,
-0.1180706173,
-0.2547681928,
-0.8185964823,
0.3233332336,
0.2516926527,
-0.1076461449,
-0.3396673799,
-0.2783893645,
0.0531152152,
0.2047834396,
0.2568038702,
0.3880639672,
-0.7309659123,
-0.1603375673,
-0.4635165334,
-0.1973544508,
0.2524235249,
0.9788252711,
-0.5239627361,
0.5448395014,
0.3219671547,
0.649111867,
0.485330373,
0.210049808,
0.3922303319,
-0.8274504542,
0.3077667356,
0.5359892249,
0.2724883556,
0.4554947913,
-0.4041396677,
0.1485883445,
0.3465200961,
-0.482889086,
-0.528059721,
0.584051311,
-1.1377944946,
-0.2181847394,
1.2080911398,
-0.0617834926,
0.3764308095,
-0.1838475317,
-0.6756427884,
0.1868513376,
-0.5476773381,
0.9952248931,
0.7417951822,
-0.3439708948,
-0.0475767069,
-0.1905378252,
0.5659662485,
0.6448142529,
-0.832565546,
0.1246464252,
0.6022338867,
0.3346605897,
-0.0566178933,
0.7679178119,
-0.1511700749,
-0.1498675048,
-0.2218969017,
-0.2830315828,
-0.2418739051,
-0.1186026335,
-0.106346488,
0.2269811034,
0.0509030446,
-0.0371390805
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10612v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10612v1
|
Retrieve Only When It Needs: Adaptive Retrieval Augmentation for Hallucination Mitigation in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-16T11:55:40 | 2024-02-16T11:55:40 |
Hanxing Ding, Liang Pang, Zihao Wei, Huawei Shen, Xueqi Cheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Hallucinations pose a significant challenge for the practical implementation
of large language models (LLMs). The utilization of parametric knowledge in
generating factual content is constrained by the limited knowledge of LLMs,
potentially resulting in internal hallucinations. While incorporating external
information can help fill knowledge gaps, it also introduces the risk of
irrelevant information, thereby increasing the likelihood of external
hallucinations. A careful and balanced integration of the parametric knowledge
within LLMs with external information is crucial to alleviate hallucinations.
In this study, we present Rowen, a novel approach that enhances LLMs with a
selective retrieval augmentation process tailored to address hallucinated
outputs. This process is governed by a multilingual semantic-aware detection
module, which evaluates the consistency of the perturbed responses across
various languages for the same queries. Upon detecting inconsistencies
indicative of hallucinations, Rowen activates the retrieval of external
information to rectify the model outputs. Rowen adeptly harmonizes the
intrinsic parameters in LLMs with external knowledge sources, effectively
mitigating hallucinations by ensuring a balanced integration of internal
reasoning and external evidence. Through a comprehensive empirical analysis, we
demonstrate that Rowen surpasses the current state-of-the-art in both detecting
and mitigating hallucinated content within the outputs of LLMs.
|
[
-0.3540968001,
-0.7128082514,
0.6372640133,
0.4497647583,
-0.1047331989,
-0.3088369668,
-0.5416979194,
-0.5760297775,
0.5574505925,
0.7441672683,
-0.37213099,
-0.3813276589,
-0.4005897045,
0.2095237076,
-0.2538778186,
0.7253264189,
0.142418623,
0.2134675682,
-0.1733339131,
-0.1925241798,
-0.5953857899,
-0.4365000725,
-0.5392252207,
-0.2612745464,
0.7854101062,
0.0281728022,
0.7875295877,
0.3331255615,
0.4148579836,
0.2895280123,
-0.0543686934,
0.6422259808,
-0.6746547818,
0.4789734781,
-0.1839634031,
-0.1326950639,
-0.1500127017,
-0.557151556,
0.6445005536,
0.6881546974,
-0.3262766898,
-0.2917820215,
0.1951026469,
0.5994393229,
-0.9234333634,
-0.0435786918,
-1.0926275253,
0.1011377424,
-0.0581493452,
-0.3626678884,
-0.6144032478,
-0.2059933096,
-0.0139419343,
-0.5542853475,
0.1811968684,
-0.0565739386,
0.4743008912,
0.4347923994,
-0.3360224068,
-0.4224435091,
-0.5744435787,
0.7451725006,
-0.5130659938,
0.6388274431,
0.485281229,
0.1947401762,
-0.3433479667,
-0.6204855442,
-0.4964211881,
-0.5989043117,
-0.227679655,
0.1315138787,
0.0720916763,
0.0549498983,
0.2672178447,
0.1408273131,
-0.6038271189,
-0.0661257207,
-0.3442039192,
-0.5775237083,
0.565387547,
0.1309185922,
0.1956607848,
-0.2868546844,
-0.2741529942,
0.0389721766,
-0.5553527474,
-0.3848416805,
0.4069881737,
0.4132368863,
0.4519039989,
0.7324125767,
-0.0063995947,
0.5419093966,
-0.0298894569,
0.2027388215,
0.2194781303,
-0.1368312091,
-0.0557927489,
0.3898357749,
0.5803744197,
0.1339762956,
-0.0794604272,
-0.5506201386,
-0.415478766,
-0.0240500811,
0.529990077,
-0.5551392436,
-0.3087635636,
0.3908819556,
-0.2678079903,
-0.0470107049,
-0.0074168989,
-0.695909977,
-1.0119863749,
-0.4224093556,
0.6767666936,
-0.5500352979,
-0.4517237544,
0.2332595289,
-0.1316475719,
0.2405186743,
0.3080435395,
-0.6561869979,
0.0626822636,
0.4631402791,
0.9055386782,
-0.5548099279,
-0.3395643234,
-0.7633451819,
0.4704416394,
-0.5213455558,
0.8079656363,
-0.4180701077,
-0.1943828315,
0.2246297896,
0.1365996152,
0.0140137644,
-0.8244202137,
0.5761211514,
-0.7195137739,
-0.0025983988,
-0.3436587155,
-0.4783176184,
-0.069898054,
0.1443834603,
-0.834258616,
1.042083025,
0.0676780716,
-0.8555958867,
0.1397554725,
-0.3038465679,
-0.5554700494,
-0.0047527738,
-0.0159058701,
-0.1446802914,
0.3097322881,
0.2683030069,
0.1997892857,
-0.0484444983,
0.3809251487,
-0.3928176165,
-0.433165729,
0.1353546977,
-0.3849576712,
0.6456642747,
0.0359732956,
-0.1272093058,
0.5071913004,
-0.7634970546,
0.0180055182,
-0.0116699785,
-0.1676805615,
-0.4783470631,
-0.0209402442,
0.1653898358,
0.1063281149,
0.3202426434,
-0.300159663,
-0.0689975172,
-0.5222116709,
-0.0692485124,
0.8512021303,
0.0131895998,
0.4144622982,
-0.5054088831,
0.2485098988,
-0.010431964,
0.0932384804,
-0.0104830433,
-0.0969950333,
-0.9431686401,
-0.2593258023,
-0.1299395412,
0.5899072289,
-1.1078401804,
0.5759163499,
-0.0815138519,
-0.1813077033,
-0.6009235978,
0.1654151529,
0.0665438101,
0.4037931561,
0.6286510825,
0.2056632191,
-0.8778433204,
-0.8378774524,
-0.293100208,
-0.1019012183,
-0.3318281472,
0.1638482511,
0.2530236542,
-0.2665617764,
0.4406178594,
-0.3068003654,
-0.7475075722,
-0.2422585189,
-0.0211103689,
0.114703536,
0.213217929,
0.194523558,
-0.7475114465,
-0.397254467,
0.3557071388,
-1.0421088934,
-0.2249827832,
-0.3759607673,
-0.2831549644,
0.2073413432,
0.4333684444,
-0.6961672902,
0.3162186146,
0.138133049,
-0.1477273256,
0.6082036495,
-0.4210241735,
0.0310287196,
-0.903576076,
-0.2636293769,
-0.301966846,
-0.1206086427,
-0.4221733809,
0.0933426619,
0.1765544266,
0.2485191077,
-0.1979462057,
0.6579882503,
-0.4402244389,
0.0242943577,
-0.5502945781,
0.4423662722,
0.0372955352,
0.2236426622,
0.200691402,
0.6467188001,
0.5099746585,
-0.6162029505,
0.5584565997,
0.2135867923,
-0.261434257,
0.4476442337,
-0.3540549278,
0.1929076612,
-0.4485290051,
0.0491689816,
-0.8574602604,
-0.2760308981,
0.1833839566,
-0.2808789015,
0.224550426,
0.2001082897,
-0.2337790877,
-0.1934264451,
-0.5186939836,
-0.0479176901,
0.1477078497,
-0.8873713613,
1.1939419508,
0.294483006,
-0.058720734,
-0.5586701632,
-0.6354279518,
0.3234714866,
-0.1251127124,
-0.719517231,
0.5408393741,
-0.2391433418,
-0.1153108478,
-0.171799168,
-0.1467711776,
0.0956917703,
-0.285430789,
-0.0938715115,
0.2407723814,
-0.2479064912,
0.1764747053,
0.0659787506,
0.0302819721,
0.1616940498,
-0.4127568901,
0.5444718599,
0.3183449209,
-0.3258155584,
-0.3525640666,
0.496522218,
0.492613405,
0.1204062849,
1.1177208424,
0.8335815072,
-0.6240143776,
-0.3570003808,
-1.0295248032,
-0.5396822691,
-0.4673446119,
0.6762335896,
-0.550842762,
-0.5260776877,
0.8023955822,
0.2765346766,
-0.2204260975,
0.257745862,
0.6071288586,
0.1040337831,
1.0224168301,
0.2188729346,
0.0992664471,
0.3704124987,
0.067616187,
0.2543930709,
-1.1797311306,
-0.5258598328,
-0.2987832129,
-0.0437224507,
-0.3946675062,
-0.3632488549,
0.3679761291,
-0.1010562405,
-0.1106090769,
0.079536818,
-0.4340178967,
0.5378127098,
0.2979291379,
0.6073542237,
0.3614110649,
0.0580487587,
-0.2143080831,
-0.2102121562,
-0.6105309129,
-0.2223233879,
0.9219720364,
-0.0056278664,
0.8714245558,
0.1612603366,
0.4440652728,
0.4903106093,
0.3763137758,
-0.7033036947,
0.5393775702,
0.0201781467,
-0.4883288145,
-0.3897589147,
-0.639531076,
-0.7340071797,
0.682113409,
-0.2117479891,
-0.7975795865,
0.2991624773,
-0.0342973806,
-0.2330022454,
0.2466048151,
-0.542078197,
0.5397334695,
-0.2467308491,
-0.7754961848,
-0.2681283653,
-0.4115080535,
0.3683210015,
-0.3477306664,
0.0068356921,
0.1075128019,
-0.0849226788,
0.467461735,
0.0011577678,
0.6525628567,
-0.2656634152,
-0.2908048928,
0.0575191714,
0.3020597994,
0.9548921585,
0.0671239495,
-0.4178240299,
0.0444750451,
-0.0871316344,
-0.2325058728,
-0.7972308993,
0.9418436885,
-0.4988052249,
-0.9240145087,
-0.3620768785,
-0.9089967012,
-0.271659404,
-0.0854906663,
0.1588667929,
-0.0146510787,
-0.0608279258,
0.3297931254,
0.7296431661,
-0.4025721848,
0.2252842039,
0.5327015519,
-0.5395168066,
-0.6488906741,
0.8800873756,
0.1936512142,
-0.022573296,
0.1957604587,
0.2447399497,
-0.5728583932,
-0.65420717,
-0.1818426102,
0.3055417538,
-0.9848982692,
-0.2731476426,
-0.8752992749,
-0.4133427739,
-0.5704208016,
0.1115428433,
-0.2776407301,
-0.1307542473,
-0.1536130905,
-0.0930326432,
0.3008497059,
0.4912089407,
-0.0900326371,
0.0757216439,
-0.6523500681,
0.6263156533,
0.1713031977,
0.2069951892,
0.2152288109,
-0.7856997252,
-0.2421936542,
-0.0084165167,
-0.0717165694,
-0.8247273564,
0.4101762772,
0.1147616059,
0.7087222338,
0.4331531823,
0.385507226,
0.8537306786,
-0.3689162433,
0.5796324611,
0.0380574316,
-0.7982594371,
0.3762557507,
-0.249161765,
0.0797107145,
0.3149920702,
0.375869751,
-0.4649105072,
-0.5241472721,
-0.0206555333,
-1.0147019625,
0.6218711734,
0.2126450092,
0.3139257431,
-0.1044961512,
0.4187990129,
0.1688946337,
-0.0074044089,
-0.9621448517,
0.1653481275,
-0.0147734154,
-0.2200545967,
0.4701490998,
-0.3172398806,
-0.1721564233,
-0.3766084015,
0.9423620105,
-0.0334987193,
0.1104806215,
0.2536801696,
-0.4795899093,
0.0044908952,
-0.2624704838,
0.4539887905,
0.6419427395,
-0.1512472928,
0.2483113706,
0.488185674,
-0.4276411533,
-0.051509086,
-0.0054487251,
-0.1620388031,
-0.0172648262,
0.4667146504,
0.8424289227,
0.0409320742,
-0.5924937725,
0.3196620941,
0.0859329477,
0.0803324431,
-0.5468497872,
0.0876863822,
-0.1797223538,
0.5243265629,
0.5548560023,
-0.009779131,
0.1779844761,
-0.1382371485,
0.3901036382,
0.5373004675,
-0.4170294702,
-0.1766629517,
0.6460651159,
-0.2282355577,
-0.1894687414,
0.591175139,
-0.0599757433,
-0.3434977531,
0.2382294536,
0.8426076174,
0.9100482464,
-0.5038002729,
0.0618617795,
0.3319083452,
0.4592202604,
-0.1991838962,
0.2744722366,
0.095498018,
-1.016977787,
-0.4363000691,
-0.645083189,
-0.0292653684,
0.3023830652,
-0.5914954543,
0.3450796902,
-0.1423315853,
-0.1512670368,
-0.184096396,
-0.4830054939,
-0.244221434,
-0.1467838883,
0.0393561199,
0.6282644868,
-0.5845547915,
0.810051322,
0.3033317029,
-0.5209802985,
-0.3123464286,
0.2605941892,
-0.213536039,
-0.60177356,
0.4270917773,
0.0623774752,
-0.2749707401,
-0.1575319022,
-0.1890668124,
-0.6786358356,
0.6660530567,
0.692599833,
-0.3246168196,
-0.1152126491,
0.0811757669,
0.3768999875,
-0.2933701873,
0.201789543,
0.5275135636,
0.7368326187,
0.4239122868,
-0.5526772141,
0.1936734766,
-0.131553188,
0.2332792729,
0.0411180109,
-0.2567862272,
0.4682301879,
-0.1557960361,
-0.0830752179,
0.1354980469,
0.7913134694,
0.309679538,
0.1534018964,
0.4866698384,
0.2355757952,
1.0908868313,
0.0717557818,
1.0060728788,
-0.2673366368,
0.0833444372,
1.2188476324,
-0.6948150992,
0.8041618466,
0.7301065326,
0.0102604674,
0.1997330785,
0.4743436873,
0.1229213104,
0.6276981235,
0.2186222076,
-0.4964901805,
-0.3123632669,
-0.3278823793,
-0.3961220086,
0.2590045035,
0.3708795011,
-0.2007413357,
0.0961923003,
0.5908324718,
-0.200627774,
0.1364938021,
-0.1754347235,
0.9113397002,
-0.1101306155,
-0.6487540007,
0.7565046549,
-0.2330906391,
0.5787445903,
-0.6732146144,
-0.09932556,
-0.3710686862,
0.3547310233,
-0.3333520293,
-0.434486717,
0.6241018176,
-0.3574947715,
-0.2525404692,
0.0826458484,
0.804812789,
-0.6905886531,
-0.6081273556,
0.930469811,
0.3206856251,
0.0166862719,
-0.5527725816,
-0.2584337592,
0.314245522,
-0.0059694895,
-0.185393095,
0.2246605605,
0.7210847735,
0.0099343406,
0.6431165934,
0.64634794,
0.3852464557,
0.1091725677,
0.4409680963,
0.9963719845,
-0.5686106682,
-0.2872059345,
-0.784054637,
0.38578704,
-0.2836110294,
0.2464582324,
0.7422327399,
0.6528013945,
0.6281709671,
-0.2097008973,
0.5609643459,
0.3016008139,
0.2575163543,
-0.7470238805,
0.8838041425,
-0.6285477877,
0.5986412764,
-0.0901437476,
-1.2080618143,
-0.5770487189,
0.957913816,
-0.2458291203,
0.0849755183,
0.8151603341,
1.241902113,
0.012327618,
0.0783093423,
0.6217813492,
0.4411307871,
0.1146609858,
0.3733132184,
1.1194176674,
-0.3093775213,
0.6294454336,
-0.01572497,
-0.011754551,
-0.096705094,
-0.6747049689,
-0.8255679607,
-0.6485029459,
-0.2036716491,
-0.6835595369,
0.228303507,
0.9743058085,
0.5654431581,
-1.1311292648,
-0.1683517992,
0.0980382785,
0.3259586096,
-0.0724371746,
-0.2922278047,
0.5391050577,
-0.6252614856,
-0.5206586123,
0.5781165957,
0.4114622176,
-0.208236739,
-0.4519061446,
-0.2359737009,
-0.1900649071,
0.1587944627,
0.7593464851,
-0.3098139465,
-0.9345653057,
-0.3247674704,
0.269253999,
0.0056540766,
0.1186921746,
0.7923700213,
-0.7786679864,
0.5522115231,
0.4563087225,
0.8331302404,
0.4745496213,
-0.440107882,
0.4347110093,
-0.767133534,
0.4391715229,
0.3193935156,
0.3715335429,
0.4414808452,
-0.6649788618,
0.4042922258,
0.0518812053,
-0.266379416,
-0.9101631045,
0.1303855032,
-0.6583694816,
-0.3468613327,
1.0757730007,
0.0763656497,
-0.1263006181,
-0.2900642455,
-0.5007789135,
0.1602145731,
-0.1637048423,
1.3320450783,
0.8329091668,
-0.026758289,
-0.2730150819,
-0.5269302726,
0.354894489,
0.3382154405,
-0.7343361974,
0.3587847948,
0.51292485,
-0.1499636024,
0.1622552872,
0.2404523343,
-0.1062452346,
0.099401772,
-0.1650943011,
0.0752895325,
0.0570100173,
-0.4937038422,
-0.2383485138,
0.2724287212,
-0.2026964724,
0.0987773985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10601v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10601v1
|
Jailbreaking Proprietary Large Language Models using Word Substitution Cipher
| 2024-02-16T11:37:05 | 2024-02-16T11:37:05 |
Divij Handa, Advait Chirmule, Bimal Gajera, Chitta Baral
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are aligned to moral and ethical guidelines but
remain susceptible to creative prompts called Jailbreak that can bypass the
alignment process. However, most jailbreaking prompts contain harmful questions
in the natural language (mainly English), which can be detected by the LLM
themselves. In this paper, we present jailbreaking prompts encoded using
cryptographic techniques. We first present a pilot study on the
state-of-the-art LLM, GPT-4, in decoding several safe sentences that have been
encrypted using various cryptographic techniques and find that a
straightforward word substitution cipher can be decoded most effectively.
Motivated by this result, we use this encoding technique for writing
jailbreaking prompts. We present a mapping of unsafe words with safe words and
ask the unsafe question using these mapped words. Experimental results show an
attack success rate (up to 59.42%) of our proposed jailbreaking approach on
state-of-the-art proprietary models including ChatGPT, GPT-4, and Gemini-Pro.
Additionally, we discuss the over-defensiveness of these models. We believe
that our work will encourage further research in making these LLMs more robust
while maintaining their decoding capabilities.
|
[
-0.2262987942,
-0.9951835275,
0.8041870594,
-0.0242405254,
-0.5652552843,
0.2133823782,
-0.1198261902,
-0.5591788292,
0.2132464051,
0.8384622931,
-0.5233881474,
-0.5021779537,
-0.7888918519,
0.3309572935,
-0.1810592264,
0.8679741621,
-0.3197668195,
0.3755968511,
0.2155808806,
-0.0665010214,
-0.8445170522,
-0.8317061067,
-0.4333590865,
-0.0084383674,
0.2259186208,
0.2067289054,
0.674728632,
0.5025183558,
0.4632943571,
0.3214757442,
-0.2721529901,
0.01954397,
-0.3876109719,
0.2508699596,
-0.2340576351,
-0.4445323646,
-0.1922544688,
0.1225762069,
0.1919461787,
0.1132309958,
-0.133165583,
-0.1621250957,
-0.1346440166,
0.5246272087,
-0.4993917942,
0.1476359665,
-1.0853691101,
-0.0337360911,
-0.2883972824,
-0.1242052242,
-0.4375271201,
-0.6157146096,
-0.0702334866,
-0.3883748949,
-0.2046166956,
0.2701636553,
0.3458898962,
-0.0524414442,
-0.0402652659,
-0.7953912616,
-0.3769671917,
0.7380304337,
-0.8462896943,
0.1591113508,
0.586063087,
0.2469554245,
-0.3752929866,
-0.4661242962,
-0.4869996309,
-0.5626710057,
0.2577525973,
-0.1524370313,
-0.2100048959,
0.124213025,
0.1558044106,
0.1492435336,
-0.4349397123,
0.3557206094,
-0.4120134115,
-0.3347505033,
0.4049515724,
0.2362006307,
0.7124687433,
-0.2856219411,
-0.2400809377,
-0.1344795674,
-1.1082230806,
-0.1738590896,
0.6929389238,
0.2767728269,
-0.0110349124,
0.6884869337,
0.3278522193,
0.5464527011,
-0.1328161657,
-0.1265881211,
0.0546143763,
-0.2443652004,
0.0173299685,
0.2504341006,
0.8405328393,
0.5011312366,
0.449023664,
-0.220777899,
-0.2537935376,
0.0490534268,
0.1879145801,
-0.7259108424,
0.0199077185,
0.2763623297,
-0.2934674621,
-0.5338346362,
0.0080117378,
-0.5606959462,
-0.7343736291,
0.1549511999,
0.299636811,
-0.8440721035,
0.1014969721,
0.3399925232,
-0.1388521343,
0.3841396272,
0.2031274438,
-1.0011552572,
0.176847741,
0.8735228181,
0.8218595982,
-0.0088563533,
-0.1213285848,
-0.4502086639,
0.1594590843,
-0.1715245247,
0.397179991,
-0.5161325932,
-0.7881857753,
-0.0065345927,
-0.0067407084,
0.147997275,
-0.4550057948,
0.6264810562,
-0.7001057863,
0.0080808122,
-0.3907446265,
-0.782916069,
-0.1060394123,
0.5158809423,
-0.7975897789,
0.3015394509,
-0.2428195775,
-0.8430020809,
-0.0277522933,
-0.4151859283,
-0.3259340227,
0.0771078765,
-0.112106055,
-0.3411394358,
-0.0006091347,
0.4498159587,
0.2963126898,
-0.1442163736,
0.2708952725,
-0.3706746697,
-0.4289766848,
0.6558377147,
-0.5742548704,
0.8058513999,
0.3486229479,
-0.3695967495,
-0.0547489338,
-0.4304586053,
-0.2031480074,
0.3857678771,
-0.1712911725,
-0.4401038885,
-0.0293122754,
-0.0676152706,
-0.0713393614,
0.5098909736,
-0.7568576932,
0.3479056656,
-0.4375825822,
0.8748363853,
0.8925557733,
0.1334339678,
0.2814191282,
-0.141461432,
0.6954969168,
-0.1497536451,
0.1440101862,
-0.2286337316,
-0.6361940503,
0.019786261,
-0.1987536997,
0.0932396501,
0.8451238871,
-0.5529723763,
0.294529736,
0.1672225893,
-0.3819984496,
-0.479777962,
0.1645132452,
0.3190083504,
0.4110098481,
0.4671109617,
0.0716083795,
-0.5828531981,
-0.6519421935,
-0.6313428283,
-0.2098673731,
0.1783910394,
0.1062939465,
0.5360431075,
-0.2946445644,
0.5743470788,
-0.4288609922,
0.1339574754,
-0.5473694205,
0.0575434715,
0.3565042615,
0.5305863023,
0.3994967341,
-0.5052655935,
-0.2856606543,
-0.4139786065,
-0.5527908206,
-0.0618044622,
-0.1527506262,
0.1687977165,
-0.0472094864,
0.6859203577,
-0.7720463872,
0.2364519835,
0.5999253392,
-0.4544802606,
0.8859093785,
-0.3116921484,
0.1504612863,
-1.1616442204,
-0.3056383133,
-0.1770574301,
-0.222065568,
-0.7118937969,
0.4694615602,
0.1855143458,
-0.1802474558,
-0.4515721798,
0.3418273926,
-0.6146657467,
0.2751528025,
-0.299689889,
0.1854865253,
-0.2984881401,
-0.0823609978,
-0.0916379765,
0.8808991313,
0.4412310719,
0.0186283942,
0.4737592936,
0.5648473501,
-0.4497829378,
0.0660744607,
-0.822011292,
0.5148186684,
-0.1041466519,
0.2365464568,
-0.775693357,
-0.1200051606,
0.3592399955,
-0.2336502075,
0.179894045,
-0.2402597815,
-0.6921938062,
-0.2843536735,
-0.6792549491,
0.2987655103,
0.6423872709,
-0.5622765422,
0.0187290814,
0.2521958649,
-0.1568052173,
-0.5604621172,
-0.7104384303,
0.4154809117,
-0.4602074027,
-0.704100728,
0.2859587371,
-0.0726663023,
-0.3232975602,
-0.3172053695,
0.0835714936,
0.1333104819,
0.1709353477,
0.2514142096,
0.6755543351,
0.0280260276,
-0.4896495044,
0.055017069,
-0.0141799878,
0.2380442023,
-0.1891632974,
0.6633903384,
-0.2330299318,
-0.2818390429,
-0.4588666856,
0.3928427994,
0.720641911,
-0.2952291369,
1.0087206364,
0.0860605761,
-0.3416077495,
-0.062409915,
-0.610604763,
-0.1783649474,
-0.5888447762,
0.0691256374,
-0.2152873278,
-1.2572591305,
0.6431723237,
-0.0941635668,
-0.0699494854,
-0.261585623,
0.4535871744,
0.1597758085,
0.9313319325,
0.3170784116,
-0.4053075016,
0.3944115043,
0.0953523889,
0.4067231417,
-0.5978953838,
-0.0342569128,
-0.4470223784,
-0.0050808201,
-0.7133525014,
-0.4371582866,
0.3509704173,
0.3049300611,
-0.1100530326,
0.5131545663,
-0.3268645406,
0.6075025201,
0.173124373,
0.1386695504,
0.3420284986,
-0.240638569,
-0.128254801,
-0.1348284781,
-0.1709601879,
-0.6361277699,
1.1214290857,
0.4912903607,
1.0240215063,
-0.0384752154,
0.9907072186,
0.0441772938,
0.003861811,
-0.6886699796,
0.641494453,
-0.1014836878,
-0.6209589839,
-0.198964566,
-0.4369390905,
-0.7913101315,
0.0033559937,
-0.209427774,
-1.1479585171,
-0.25004372,
-0.0236682463,
-0.3203918636,
0.5996857285,
-0.5566651225,
0.6882290244,
-0.3259638846,
0.0778915957,
-0.1108112335,
-0.5315987468,
0.6336346865,
-0.1809754223,
0.4221417904,
0.0895033553,
0.115794614,
0.6119965315,
-0.7486684918,
0.8058989644,
-0.1686359942,
-0.2577804029,
0.3049952388,
0.3147672713,
1.0575942993,
0.2023032308,
-0.168520391,
0.0900829658,
-0.0523958132,
-0.0286738686,
-0.4853828251,
0.7494280338,
-0.5914523602,
-0.9337330461,
-0.3157241344,
-0.6004645228,
-0.3429023623,
0.1714332551,
0.4780154228,
0.2965364158,
-0.1699112058,
-0.1112483218,
0.6487764716,
-0.6262235045,
0.3509619534,
0.2324219048,
-0.140751496,
-0.4643369019,
0.6043701172,
0.007750107,
0.2578108609,
0.0927981883,
0.3614401519,
-0.3847940564,
-1.1129533052,
-0.3271346092,
0.2963803709,
-0.5918298364,
-0.2165677547,
-0.4131913185,
-0.1928089857,
-0.4582150877,
-0.5288592577,
-0.2572408915,
-0.2915361226,
-0.1658104807,
-0.4169787467,
0.501335144,
0.5657129884,
0.0059419102,
0.1677420586,
-1.1197599173,
0.3784675896,
0.1686960757,
0.0826222673,
-0.2909994125,
-0.3984178305,
0.1494945139,
-0.1334742159,
-0.0734507069,
-1.3562049866,
0.3417769969,
-0.4096366465,
0.3723307848,
0.3469091654,
0.1190191507,
0.550645411,
-0.8666788936,
0.7876609564,
0.4264575243,
-1.2470300198,
0.5341870785,
-0.5784010291,
0.0718290731,
0.733625114,
0.1484428644,
-0.6504487395,
-0.7933074236,
-0.2964156568,
-0.801035583,
0.3358460069,
0.1079780161,
0.5059162378,
-0.1998498291,
0.5486317277,
0.3594867885,
0.0737304911,
-0.7568377256,
-0.1521228701,
-0.1735578626,
-0.2054173946,
0.2508943379,
-0.4024059176,
-0.1068195924,
-0.1371096969,
0.4246811867,
0.2429519445,
0.0935805663,
-0.0107637784,
-0.1502059996,
0.2297747731,
0.6816343069,
0.528185904,
0.4015582204,
-0.2016300857,
-0.0000942498,
0.2015903592,
-0.7880142927,
0.3145475686,
0.0050216978,
-0.3272654116,
-0.1491233855,
0.3493048251,
0.6527626514,
0.055949796,
-0.7402957082,
0.5664327145,
-0.1170987412,
-0.2053815424,
-0.3808826208,
0.1120414361,
0.141663,
0.1541634053,
0.0676348954,
-0.2795842886,
0.1075389683,
-0.7397343516,
0.0443809666,
0.7161120772,
-0.0695093796,
-0.217474252,
0.7779169083,
0.0698562488,
-0.2172787488,
0.6853846312,
-0.2903689742,
-0.660512805,
0.4863834977,
0.9845458269,
0.861445725,
-0.2830915451,
0.3324739635,
0.1997616291,
0.7112510204,
-0.4111489356,
0.4612575769,
0.2857754827,
-0.912355125,
-0.4182461202,
-0.4524300098,
-0.5986841321,
0.3802487254,
-0.5737430453,
0.194184944,
-0.8902492523,
0.0187533107,
-0.4178876877,
-0.3768336773,
-0.1209433153,
-0.0449416935,
0.4525942504,
1.0948858261,
-0.4509740174,
0.80059582,
0.5090637803,
0.0427506529,
-0.9915167689,
-0.0656098276,
0.1465296894,
-0.9489791393,
0.2857093513,
0.3931599557,
-0.0817093477,
-0.2457075715,
-0.8556759357,
-0.665890336,
0.937626183,
0.4925915897,
-0.8288857937,
-0.2276901007,
0.3230046928,
0.1663004011,
-0.1931573451,
-0.1639093757,
0.8320483565,
0.6652295589,
-0.1585267335,
-0.6317073703,
0.4727846384,
-0.0430910885,
-0.077050522,
0.3203571439,
-0.2034997344,
0.7961330414,
-0.3991585374,
-0.0786268562,
0.5397815704,
0.3564955294,
0.7642524838,
0.1005320475,
0.4031392336,
0.6011020541,
0.7751587033,
-0.1172097921,
0.8792887926,
-0.4288878739,
0.2203650177,
0.8642043471,
-0.2630084157,
0.647510767,
0.7074291706,
0.1297627538,
0.5034204125,
0.2261591703,
-0.2567413747,
0.6030083895,
0.5228680372,
-0.3017950356,
-0.0668666363,
0.3964723945,
-0.3372947276,
0.487044096,
0.4937847257,
-0.3604430258,
-0.121738106,
0.2655017376,
0.565544188,
0.0325697698,
-0.4610595703,
0.6333188415,
0.3195938766,
-0.3662869036,
0.5702078342,
0.4665616751,
0.8474743366,
-0.7250440717,
0.1417379379,
0.0058591482,
-0.1680927277,
-0.0110388175,
-0.7722044587,
0.1929578781,
0.4978693426,
0.3660346568,
-0.3004027605,
0.7311930656,
-0.117477335,
-0.2928717434,
0.2860895991,
0.2305913568,
0.0317602307,
-0.0955522954,
-0.6670552492,
0.3126189113,
-0.0481051356,
-0.2685159445,
0.2646885812,
0.0986812264,
0.0375294648,
0.5889915228,
0.6926541924,
0.2322821319,
0.1518601924,
-0.1304847598,
0.9091852903,
-1.0147303343,
-0.7557764053,
-1.2413316965,
0.32580176,
-0.0149276899,
-0.0748116747,
0.9342527986,
0.1742502004,
0.4996053576,
-0.0608687699,
0.9561538696,
0.1780789793,
0.0001717961,
-1.041000843,
0.8973813653,
0.0125889778,
0.5601442456,
-0.479162842,
-0.7887910008,
-0.0972289219,
0.3511876762,
-0.5851005912,
-0.2331449091,
0.755115509,
0.7047639489,
0.2069594413,
0.4224982858,
0.2511657178,
0.2553388178,
0.4714925587,
0.5825663805,
0.9737401605,
-0.2054242641,
0.50784868,
-0.0772439241,
-0.2107373774,
0.106920369,
-0.8293656707,
-1.0072962046,
-0.2625476718,
-0.0214348081,
-0.4937909842,
0.2212176472,
0.825696826,
0.1579525918,
-0.7939476967,
-0.0576668717,
-0.4295089245,
0.1236019656,
0.1590191573,
-0.1342945248,
0.1102781817,
-0.0810511634,
-0.4061734676,
0.8925516009,
0.2553364336,
0.2120278478,
-0.2068255693,
-0.012532915,
0.2170356214,
0.3684957922,
0.3202308118,
0.2199058682,
-0.6214287877,
-0.4596424699,
-0.049051173,
-0.0548855215,
-0.0887571573,
1.023696661,
-0.3202211261,
0.1855112314,
0.4668523073,
0.7169368267,
0.3073815703,
0.0549552217,
0.6145107746,
-0.3759056926,
0.2137245685,
0.320543319,
0.7838411331,
0.4688827991,
-0.5805703998,
0.0843061879,
0.2169431597,
-0.5116418004,
-0.7426441312,
0.5772335529,
-0.8532658219,
-0.5713366866,
1.209127903,
-0.287111491,
-0.3904044032,
-0.166425705,
-0.3419770896,
-0.062464036,
-0.4091622233,
0.8266031146,
0.9341451526,
0.0756101608,
-0.1074398682,
-0.4598561227,
0.3340710998,
0.2341505736,
-0.7992091775,
0.1506802291,
0.4215112329,
0.5516592264,
0.0101739308,
0.4280528128,
-0.6874893308,
0.2543370724,
-0.0010066316,
-0.3309800923,
-0.3946668506,
0.0577250794,
-0.6119674444,
0.136539191,
0.1314927787,
-0.0403511152
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10597v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10597v1
|
Efficiency at Scale: Investigating the Performance of Diminutive Language Models in Clinical Tasks
| 2024-02-16T11:30:11 | 2024-02-16T11:30:11 |
Niall Taylor, Upamanyu Ghose, Omid Rohanian, Mohammadmahdi Nouriborji, Andrey Kormilitzin, David Clifton, Alejo Nevado-Holgado
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The entry of large language models (LLMs) into research and commercial spaces
has led to a trend of ever-larger models, with initial promises of
generalisability, followed by a widespread desire to downsize and create
specialised models without the need for complete fine-tuning, using Parameter
Efficient Fine-tuning (PEFT) methods. We present an investigation into the
suitability of different PEFT methods to clinical decision-making tasks, across
a range of model sizes, including extremely small models with as few as $25$
million parameters.
Our analysis shows that the performance of most PEFT approaches varies
significantly from one task to another, with the exception of LoRA, which
maintains relatively high performance across all model sizes and tasks,
typically approaching or matching full fine-tuned performance. The
effectiveness of PEFT methods in the clinical domain is evident, particularly
for specialised models which can operate on low-cost, in-house computing
infrastructure. The advantages of these models, in terms of speed and reduced
training costs, dramatically outweighs any performance gain from large
foundation LLMs. Furthermore, we highlight how domain-specific pre-training
interacts with PEFT methods and model size, and discuss how these factors
interplay to provide the best efficiency-performance trade-off. Full code
available at: tbd.
|
[
-0.1300745755,
-0.8115387559,
0.8005960584,
0.1674038172,
-0.1373166293,
-0.2264502198,
-0.5147721171,
-0.4006447792,
0.0002471518,
0.5744427443,
-0.1864397526,
-0.1484530866,
-0.771902144,
0.1243046969,
-0.2994373441,
0.5264334083,
-0.0005232668,
0.2968606353,
-0.1316005737,
0.0319325291,
-0.0418354236,
-0.4997407496,
-1.070933938,
-0.5537264943,
0.4686605036,
0.5182437897,
0.8596047759,
0.8104609251,
1.0494855642,
0.2740210891,
-0.0729342699,
0.0779639781,
-0.6002450585,
-0.2323058844,
-0.0707225204,
-0.448913306,
-0.9409341216,
0.0056290892,
0.5308355689,
1.2767233849,
-0.3524186313,
0.014255452,
-0.0956087112,
0.7931261659,
-0.6915309429,
0.0335689075,
-0.5340180993,
-0.1103207543,
-0.1160590723,
0.0985415727,
-0.3897343874,
-0.102080591,
0.2842738032,
-0.4490099251,
0.1951621771,
-0.0719336942,
0.5710952282,
0.3499778211,
-0.369412154,
-0.3200613558,
-0.7157070637,
0.8309121728,
-0.7800875306,
0.4581949413,
0.6496223211,
0.1786218882,
0.1034608632,
-1.0303071737,
-0.0281395148,
-0.4098381102,
-0.2528268099,
-0.3185533583,
-0.4327525198,
0.5291751027,
0.4333570004,
0.3925522566,
-0.3139927983,
0.4221759439,
-0.3156192899,
-0.0534858108,
0.5985341072,
0.3560734987,
0.111567907,
0.258237958,
0.2425691932,
0.1291289479,
-0.8660168648,
-0.1449028999,
-0.1014286652,
0.467351824,
-0.0577385984,
0.5468346477,
-0.2681132257,
0.8181942701,
0.2954470217,
-0.419921428,
-0.1511458606,
-0.2990412712,
-0.510315299,
-0.1706255078,
0.6673870087,
0.2308081836,
0.2096199393,
-0.2483256608,
-0.1610039026,
-0.0152488351,
0.4640816748,
-1.0120428801,
-0.4219427109,
0.1853210181,
-0.5995470881,
-0.288898468,
-0.6085581183,
-0.4643705785,
-0.1835746914,
-0.3664880991,
0.5347175002,
-0.4495024383,
0.0255941562,
0.4112102389,
0.3176113367,
-0.1455709636,
0.6309087873,
-0.9177150726,
0.5654745698,
0.4217893481,
0.7462820411,
-0.070317097,
0.0035641447,
-0.7227689028,
-0.1960354,
-0.4124349654,
0.5932290554,
-0.4695637524,
-0.5633132458,
-0.1449527442,
-0.0839339867,
-0.4517301619,
-0.6670072675,
0.7378304005,
-0.1956834793,
-0.1998177469,
-0.2177600265,
-0.4398737252,
0.2980247438,
-0.0769114643,
-0.5525553823,
0.6042086482,
0.3832478821,
-0.4920824766,
0.481901437,
-0.6069681048,
-0.6539104581,
0.074734427,
-0.1197023764,
-0.4426383674,
0.4754308462,
0.087712504,
0.6881859303,
-0.5313405991,
0.1835545599,
-0.204934746,
-0.3836540282,
-0.0500152074,
-0.1727243364,
0.3369865417,
0.4867630899,
-0.2254796922,
-0.1587468535,
-0.8246668577,
0.0236700755,
0.0933961868,
-0.3472320735,
-0.4188021123,
-0.0729869157,
-0.0501085259,
-0.0297424421,
0.3631215096,
-0.358060956,
0.1017058268,
-0.362760812,
0.6691971421,
0.2015158385,
-0.2143129557,
0.3946701586,
-0.3227253854,
0.6357987523,
-0.4916442633,
0.4830261469,
0.2071988732,
-0.2185363024,
-0.6180534959,
-0.6281536222,
0.5007147193,
0.0496362858,
-0.2805198133,
-0.0654076561,
-0.033908125,
-0.5633407235,
-0.5364899635,
0.0538249798,
0.4915455878,
0.4347936511,
0.1153609827,
-0.1500488967,
-0.0060651931,
-1.2680768967,
-0.3082419038,
-0.1142634079,
0.0997196138,
0.5368099213,
0.4853779972,
-0.1569414884,
0.6159051061,
-0.4595465064,
-0.1912661493,
-0.3413776755,
-0.0056830267,
0.2824693322,
0.5054604411,
0.7292873859,
-0.7408491373,
-0.710549891,
0.2339565754,
-0.280025214,
-0.3209603727,
-0.0039652893,
0.1877898872,
0.0352679677,
0.501865685,
-0.5654141307,
0.2825420499,
0.505851984,
-0.2276948839,
0.4541153908,
-0.844650805,
0.3334855139,
-0.3060674667,
0.2905717492,
-0.1283603609,
-0.4624437094,
-0.8269221187,
0.004711444,
0.3471801877,
0.0236198734,
-0.35565871,
0.3203117847,
-0.3956750333,
0.2426098585,
-0.2790146768,
0.0466409884,
-0.0555164441,
0.2924407721,
0.0510222055,
0.9200639129,
0.4499185383,
-0.4609736502,
-0.1882071942,
0.0395806916,
-0.3079477847,
0.4577672482,
-0.8705121875,
0.0686899126,
0.1935627013,
-0.3285748959,
-0.9233289957,
-0.3892020285,
-0.3040023744,
-0.023377778,
0.5733175278,
-0.0083409343,
-0.6237047911,
-0.3530166447,
-0.1909219027,
0.3227558732,
0.5865471363,
-0.316192925,
0.4532993734,
0.4723529816,
-0.4254594445,
-0.1799016148,
-0.6049752831,
-0.118184641,
-0.3769631386,
-0.4407697618,
0.4425532818,
-0.1052609906,
-0.4617087543,
-0.3719969094,
-0.1186692342,
-0.1871224791,
0.2094567418,
0.0302679427,
-0.1844703555,
-0.2401200384,
0.2554906905,
0.3591680527,
0.1685149968,
0.0761967972,
0.1055631861,
0.4004405141,
-0.2986254096,
-0.3613301814,
-0.4569326341,
0.3405798078,
0.8032732606,
0.0056949737,
0.8311004043,
0.1842895448,
-0.4518556893,
-0.1716697961,
-0.6107962132,
0.0061830673,
-0.4458214045,
0.5715469122,
-0.4018411934,
-0.8457356691,
0.3772509098,
-0.3883639574,
-0.0462486446,
0.5126578212,
0.7968252301,
0.1042818576,
1.2061357498,
0.8226152658,
0.3712703586,
0.3213674128,
-0.1254192144,
0.2239622623,
-0.5672246218,
-0.0438909233,
-0.6934735179,
-0.1572075784,
-0.3601480722,
-0.4960298836,
0.5976145267,
0.3044950068,
-0.34268713,
0.1935624629,
-0.4599134922,
0.4910080731,
0.2557871938,
0.2255226225,
0.5163413286,
-0.1586543024,
0.0161769092,
-0.0047402359,
-1.0638623238,
-0.4964808226,
1.4788426161,
0.4784281552,
0.8022705317,
-0.0410155095,
0.5129353404,
0.1895618141,
0.3926948011,
-0.7579385638,
0.3415563703,
-0.5985818505,
-0.2865705788,
-0.4013531208,
-0.2431033552,
-1.0368099213,
0.238724947,
-0.127066642,
-0.8280379176,
0.2452727407,
0.2599570453,
-0.8164258003,
0.1727568358,
-0.8816184402,
0.8437985182,
-0.3307323456,
-0.3993283808,
-0.4202825427,
-0.5613259077,
0.1058839709,
-0.771592319,
0.1993920952,
-0.0446809381,
-0.3375751972,
0.813124299,
-0.611876905,
0.7065830231,
0.0100183673,
-0.1291554719,
-0.140727818,
0.1103346348,
0.4919342399,
0.0801715329,
-0.1729938537,
0.1382797062,
0.3791222572,
-0.4036576748,
-0.4509711266,
0.737264514,
-0.7152395844,
-0.4356908202,
0.0155593082,
-0.5008453131,
-0.6502214074,
0.176577419,
0.4238834679,
0.548156023,
-0.2909348309,
0.3365785182,
0.7063226104,
-0.166197896,
0.0673965812,
0.5994961858,
0.0072818855,
-0.1183274016,
0.4148843288,
0.2336821854,
0.5618547797,
0.4363010228,
0.3587186635,
-0.179683581,
-1.0996630192,
-0.0294181723,
0.5174788833,
-0.5059337616,
-0.0395562686,
-0.6474313736,
0.0209327955,
-0.3327588141,
-0.404287219,
-0.7049438953,
-0.5610310435,
-0.2303428501,
0.2149829865,
0.2340019941,
0.6120284796,
-0.110407576,
0.7782710195,
-0.4935792685,
0.1430595666,
0.1775311828,
0.4548527002,
-0.1190353036,
-0.6381677389,
-0.4618164301,
-0.2067121565,
-0.2820585966,
-0.5068824887,
0.5098568797,
0.3179234862,
0.5450201631,
0.5352219343,
-0.0356720611,
0.6322910786,
-0.4719054103,
0.5271232724,
0.3436633945,
-0.8658649921,
0.5296317935,
-0.5106689334,
0.0679093376,
0.7414951324,
0.3426271081,
-0.0939427614,
-0.1118862405,
-0.666156292,
-0.7074589133,
0.7100020051,
0.214503482,
-0.0866730139,
0.0311007556,
0.6581172347,
0.3194052279,
0.3051641583,
-0.1662720889,
-0.1040736586,
0.5175634623,
-0.0902724192,
-0.2766574919,
-0.1332639754,
-0.3202718496,
-0.4485328794,
0.3575628698,
-0.3624273539,
0.3342222571,
0.3686875999,
0.0004670001,
-0.3100928664,
0.1452887654,
0.5111448765,
0.9535025954,
-0.2097516954,
-0.0881476998,
0.3329100013,
-0.5724940896,
-0.1574925035,
0.072219491,
0.3024336994,
-0.1564357728,
0.4888838828,
0.6776282787,
0.3094937503,
-1.0199543238,
0.5116830468,
-0.1268507242,
-0.4184604585,
0.0240927264,
0.175319463,
0.0042642774,
0.3858816326,
-0.1327157468,
-0.01177641,
0.2856194377,
-0.3452275693,
0.03194087,
0.4626061916,
-0.1775118411,
-0.2580753863,
0.7465918064,
0.1294745952,
-0.4726504982,
0.5547398925,
0.2799925208,
0.0426178239,
0.6371646523,
0.439103812,
0.5998919606,
-0.0006346874,
0.1751080602,
0.044001054,
0.2180991322,
-0.3282982707,
0.1156920865,
-0.0058493274,
-0.4158090651,
-0.5142543912,
-0.6661414504,
-0.552756846,
0.4277244508,
-0.734757483,
0.1500267684,
-0.6334025264,
-0.4989355206,
0.1355160475,
0.1400695443,
-0.9491322041,
0.2869450152,
0.14325203,
1.1670417786,
-0.5205128193,
0.8216565847,
0.7256314754,
-0.0201194286,
-0.9066777229,
-0.2270205319,
-0.2586926222,
-0.8912674785,
0.630910933,
-0.267747432,
-0.0939550996,
-0.0930007026,
-0.4053214788,
-0.7192621827,
0.9622698426,
0.7247226834,
-0.8672455549,
-0.3667639494,
0.2181035876,
0.8176707029,
-0.4611816406,
0.278137058,
1.2575478554,
0.2385323346,
-0.1787577718,
-1.5772612095,
-0.0449986123,
0.0180023611,
-0.1229327023,
0.3115363419,
-0.8481759429,
0.9820622802,
-0.4275824726,
0.1820399314,
0.3069111705,
-0.1376268417,
0.088615343,
0.2511224449,
0.3767126203,
0.3900243342,
0.8803805709,
-0.1080968976,
1.1886795759,
-0.4962379634,
0.5718379021,
0.6501449943,
-0.2923710942,
0.6452999711,
0.5775353312,
-0.6801072955,
-0.0336785764,
0.6251555085,
0.2306086272,
0.5049357414,
0.16174604,
-0.0209363177,
-0.6087659597,
-0.0221923534,
-0.2640403807,
0.4125022292,
0.455344528,
-0.6098204851,
-0.1207218096,
-0.0227167476,
0.024620004,
0.0158467516,
-0.5607331991,
0.5886464119,
0.325609684,
-0.576662302,
0.7437350154,
-0.0180800371,
0.2963859439,
-0.8981236219,
0.2142636478,
-0.2229140401,
0.4897172153,
-0.0762875602,
-0.2615071237,
0.2351640314,
-0.1030220389,
0.0030676452,
-0.2853763402,
0.6776583791,
-0.1212486327,
-0.3871934414,
0.2669102252,
0.7560353875,
0.2370895445,
-0.166210264,
-0.6957571507,
0.0522316135,
-0.2058638632,
-0.3595204055,
0.6757250428,
0.3914857507,
-0.0422026329,
0.6306411624,
0.3050950468,
0.4906677008,
-0.3436323404,
0.1775770038,
0.7246544361,
-0.4836466908,
-0.4440689385,
-0.7775089741,
0.049485106,
0.0221457072,
-0.395542562,
0.4535721242,
0.3607141674,
0.5133715868,
-0.0599064417,
0.5248252749,
0.1007525623,
0.4259565771,
-0.4939896166,
0.6376841068,
-0.9444257617,
0.2921359241,
-0.3487327099,
-0.3974424303,
-0.4793754518,
0.5919809341,
-0.6664834023,
0.0391569585,
0.7469373941,
0.5900848508,
-0.0986580476,
0.1088671684,
0.742998898,
0.1769922078,
0.2142968476,
0.7508684397,
0.455747664,
-0.1263644099,
0.0912277475,
-0.3602353632,
-0.5657638311,
-0.3233298957,
-0.7350803614,
-0.8183652163,
-0.2292558104,
-0.5082054138,
0.0323406793,
0.108343713,
0.905375421,
1.0833085775,
-0.6634764671,
-0.2279416621,
0.0006654192,
-0.2927071452,
-0.3117043972,
-0.0628877133,
0.7135691643,
-0.3654313684,
-0.8088853359,
0.2879915535,
0.3698857725,
-0.1365127861,
-0.0197824668,
0.0352311917,
0.1490731537,
0.2893550098,
0.7048923969,
0.0448636152,
-0.5443219543,
0.0997079536,
-0.0153651359,
-0.1181651205,
0.0735025704,
1.0311609507,
-0.611781776,
0.3052451909,
0.2133856714,
0.6285513043,
0.4546616375,
-0.1218531057,
0.6051021218,
-0.2935955226,
-0.0901825503,
0.326891005,
0.5563778877,
0.1429563314,
-0.5085722804,
0.630559504,
0.1361928582,
-0.8862761259,
-0.9730117917,
-0.0626708195,
-0.9397592545,
-0.4422187209,
1.0298950672,
-0.1190490872,
-0.0233597457,
-0.0563373417,
-0.3142927587,
-0.1509655267,
-0.2015145272,
0.6437579393,
0.5315994024,
-0.8016020656,
0.114298813,
-0.6344957352,
0.7086985111,
0.5906364322,
-0.678313911,
0.275393635,
0.3458864093,
0.3993278444,
0.1042762995,
0.9085065722,
-0.2005873919,
0.2667659223,
-0.028970575,
-0.4014904797,
0.0662043318,
-0.3718113303,
-0.5247020125,
0.3353035748,
0.4287419021,
0.2810644209
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10588v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10588v4
|
Do Llamas Work in English? On the Latent Language of Multilingual Transformers
| 2024-02-16T11:21:28 | 2024-06-08T11:15:14 |
Chris Wendler, Veniamin Veselovsky, Giovanni Monea, Robert West
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
We ask whether multilingual language models trained on unbalanced,
English-dominated corpora use English as an internal pivot language -- a
question of key importance for understanding how language models function and
the origins of linguistic bias. Focusing on the Llama-2 family of transformer
models, our study uses carefully constructed non-English prompts with a unique
correct single-token continuation. From layer to layer, transformers gradually
map an input embedding of the final prompt token to an output embedding from
which next-token probabilities are computed. Tracking intermediate embeddings
through their high-dimensional space reveals three distinct phases, whereby
intermediate embeddings (1) start far away from output token embeddings; (2)
already allow for decoding a semantically correct next token in the middle
layers, but give higher probability to its version in English than in the input
language; (3) finally move into an input-language-specific region of the
embedding space. We cast these results into a conceptual model where the three
phases operate in "input space", "concept space", and "output space",
respectively. Crucially, our evidence suggests that the abstract "concept
space" lies closer to English than to other languages, which may have important
consequences regarding the biases held by multilingual language models.
|
[
-0.0803776011,
-0.5266312957,
0.5687701106,
0.3019611537,
-0.2331998646,
0.467746824,
-0.1423711777,
-0.4041795731,
0.3251281977,
0.3115715384,
-0.3714633584,
-0.1496882141,
-0.7177653313,
0.3595929146,
-0.5208054781,
1.016451478,
-0.1783471406,
0.1549484879,
-0.2397264093,
-0.034602847,
-0.4570616186,
-0.532335639,
-0.4598554671,
-0.4971483648,
0.5357033014,
0.647793591,
0.8522782922,
0.4482967556,
0.2780407071,
0.2960803211,
-0.1633137614,
-0.0638437718,
-0.20022735,
0.2327782959,
-0.0584861822,
-1.009414196,
-0.0022018799,
0.1259532422,
0.4898013175,
0.8952595592,
-0.2189101875,
0.1149275824,
0.0893602595,
0.1481153369,
-0.396166116,
0.1686178595,
-0.7921839952,
0.1944897324,
-0.3122364283,
-0.1955947429,
-0.4606162012,
0.0315020308,
-0.1862967908,
-0.3146179914,
0.0418963581,
0.1134689301,
0.8390216231,
0.3998118043,
-0.8119931221,
-0.3402282894,
-0.6814315319,
0.9017319679,
-0.6264938116,
0.4069186151,
0.4232072532,
0.1515071392,
-0.0015159713,
-0.5151286125,
-0.7816238403,
-0.315779686,
-0.3451070487,
0.1293497384,
-0.3587014079,
-0.314354986,
-0.0705483183,
0.2541302443,
-0.4330883622,
0.4655022919,
-0.586371243,
-0.0218514428,
0.496953994,
-0.0209652651,
0.3637205958,
-0.1085843071,
-0.2966701686,
0.1285892278,
-0.888045311,
0.1243593097,
0.5720618367,
0.2997899652,
-0.3522595167,
0.8719379902,
0.4215772748,
0.2885862291,
0.1932995021,
-0.5543333292,
0.2778976262,
-0.0795698687,
0.2671820223,
0.0541595444,
0.7012364268,
0.2584720254,
0.3468437791,
-0.3381592333,
-0.2584852278,
0.3076058328,
0.1625027657,
-0.2967630029,
0.1271123141,
0.2014698386,
-0.225918442,
-0.2784249187,
-0.1337821484,
-0.4205436707,
-0.1622852832,
-0.0647067577,
0.0332787335,
-0.0459844694,
-0.3400992453,
-0.0032567894,
0.1108189821,
0.2736302614,
-0.1464326084,
-0.9371211529,
0.2225991637,
0.6290266514,
0.6084827185,
-0.5652623773,
-0.6743894219,
-0.2437194884,
0.3810801506,
-0.4392092824,
1.1153942347,
-1.0122119188,
-0.4247123897,
0.3274413347,
0.3715099096,
-0.0832013711,
-0.3904762268,
0.4148403108,
-0.4594753385,
0.5622700453,
-0.0400582366,
-0.2272179127,
-0.1402247399,
0.0247572605,
-0.5697368979,
1.2120827436,
-0.3098265827,
-0.7779762149,
0.32459566,
-0.496578902,
-0.8107295632,
-0.1665692329,
-0.3410492837,
-0.0538023561,
0.2225119323,
0.1944528669,
0.509934485,
-0.3137977421,
0.3491792381,
0.1360680908,
-0.3314736485,
0.4052853584,
-0.6146137118,
0.6169768572,
-0.0487467572,
-0.5159504414,
-0.2180623263,
-0.6398963928,
-0.4952571392,
0.5183609724,
-0.3085007071,
-0.4236470163,
0.2091748416,
-0.1712215245,
0.270290345,
0.2357651442,
-0.7646651864,
0.2755667865,
-0.4097386301,
0.7096233964,
0.5724596977,
-0.2651113868,
0.725594759,
-0.0041713957,
0.7997534275,
0.3546361029,
-0.2253513485,
-0.5683624148,
-0.8657526374,
-0.8656721115,
-0.029037714,
0.0700444803,
0.7335925102,
-0.5630487204,
0.1290688068,
-0.0467513576,
-0.3295668364,
-0.7279522419,
-0.0685790032,
0.11298161,
0.4089466333,
0.1775374115,
-0.0295434631,
-0.2987579405,
-1.4013861418,
-0.0719976798,
-0.3139987588,
0.0778193101,
-0.0641833171,
0.6055627465,
-0.2073828876,
0.6987039447,
-0.2875209451,
-0.0951245651,
-0.350258857,
-0.102577731,
0.3503251374,
0.0167946387,
0.5160967708,
-0.6606804729,
-0.3092573881,
0.1326520443,
-0.6677278876,
-0.2192325294,
-0.111198917,
0.0914147347,
0.2245226502,
0.4165951908,
-0.7553107142,
0.2924751639,
0.9541757703,
-0.3578160405,
0.2191096395,
-0.0135418829,
-0.0969322696,
-1.2992794514,
-0.1856742054,
-0.2972014546,
-0.0359001867,
-0.6184358597,
0.0053582368,
0.0793289393,
0.0197772849,
-0.5236369371,
0.5734675527,
-0.313239187,
-0.2433585227,
-0.3592309654,
0.2883577645,
0.1089982316,
0.5137034655,
0.0243611429,
1.1344336271,
0.3590026796,
-0.5219564438,
-0.0432731248,
0.0845143422,
-0.0982155949,
0.4761278927,
-0.7151674032,
0.2404298931,
-0.312184751,
0.1985397488,
-1.310564518,
0.2189510316,
0.1594475955,
-0.2112164497,
0.4257186651,
0.018498905,
-0.4792684913,
-0.4090935886,
-0.0926520377,
0.4420872927,
0.267518729,
-0.5146583915,
0.4708506763,
0.6844428778,
-0.2760520577,
-0.8358148932,
-1.18539083,
0.0432649367,
-0.1498939395,
-0.5300455689,
0.4861970246,
0.0086076837,
-0.514426589,
-0.0077231885,
-0.0111496067,
-0.1661175042,
0.0721297637,
0.1828041226,
0.2071556896,
-0.2323900014,
0.0221792832,
0.3968709707,
-0.1301499456,
-0.0050872341,
-0.2903984785,
0.6133756042,
0.0872236937,
-0.6210873127,
-0.1696558297,
0.5541923642,
0.6479479074,
-0.3118678033,
0.7720636725,
0.3752451241,
-0.3927459121,
0.0025452957,
-0.5066781044,
-0.1000328958,
-0.4395662546,
0.6646803617,
-0.4995349348,
-0.9976400733,
0.6099408865,
0.317063868,
0.3267488182,
0.757853508,
0.9254405499,
-0.159815982,
0.9466072917,
0.8862614036,
-0.0116920779,
0.0774523839,
-0.2107649744,
0.5295746326,
-0.7986603379,
-0.3567146659,
-0.5931843519,
-0.3275024295,
-0.6650221944,
-0.4387863576,
0.294903934,
-0.0916473344,
-0.1564916819,
0.3391998708,
-0.2756780386,
0.6545796394,
0.2702822983,
-0.5610538125,
0.350904882,
0.2436146885,
-0.3880413771,
-0.3039887249,
-0.7105484605,
-0.8328572512,
1.0354628563,
0.4263651371,
0.4439047873,
0.1273999512,
0.4061487913,
0.0148792733,
0.2430770248,
-0.6933827996,
0.180998385,
-0.0812049955,
-0.5897512436,
-0.0323153362,
0.2721374929,
-1.2468448877,
0.4866081178,
0.043166358,
-0.5779839754,
0.1089569777,
-0.1247583106,
0.0894748643,
0.6237409711,
-0.6572121978,
0.4199536145,
-0.4879060984,
-0.1719393134,
-0.2830900848,
-0.3651931286,
0.410081476,
-0.3114078641,
0.711732924,
-0.1773723513,
-0.3646404743,
0.7681930065,
-0.1073134467,
0.9447187781,
0.1023550704,
-0.7134459615,
0.2358025461,
0.2246130556,
0.4397936463,
0.0666314885,
0.0142167266,
0.590056777,
-0.0619454943,
-0.395147264,
-0.3599131107,
0.4228427112,
-0.9514521956,
-0.61746943,
-0.4720189273,
-0.5654699802,
-0.2509136796,
-0.0074753128,
0.3854811192,
-0.0349198729,
0.084457241,
-0.0308798812,
0.0363791548,
-0.3204039931,
0.6648103595,
0.7011728287,
-0.3552585244,
-0.0129575636,
0.5720112324,
0.1282509118,
0.0918864012,
0.5578712821,
0.1670552492,
-0.1970077753,
-0.0762149915,
-0.499417752,
0.4975199699,
-0.7589336634,
-0.1100601405,
-0.5995643139,
-0.0657113567,
-0.0476912186,
-0.1043162197,
-0.4438962042,
-0.4924391508,
-0.1771887839,
-0.360624671,
0.0109712118,
1.21616745,
0.2110531479,
0.428466469,
-0.5213261247,
0.1542767137,
0.3657126129,
0.0203511938,
-0.0041752141,
-0.8630912304,
-0.3581043482,
0.1383308619,
-0.3264296353,
-1.1204067469,
0.2756220102,
0.1702211499,
0.7640967369,
0.2219409943,
-0.5122731328,
0.4512947202,
-0.9914723635,
1.1950266361,
0.1131701246,
-0.7658816576,
0.3069829345,
-0.0722031891,
0.0823223516,
0.1808037311,
0.4544036984,
-0.7438691258,
-0.6142217517,
-0.4506792128,
-0.9136537313,
0.5310302377,
0.1283665299,
0.5716013312,
-0.3964256048,
0.1628597826,
0.4763451219,
0.3945734799,
-0.9998027086,
-0.6167451739,
-0.1054969952,
-0.102283448,
-0.2226348221,
-0.3966498077,
0.0408531427,
-0.1174894646,
0.4478243887,
-0.1798138469,
0.4834597707,
-0.2140992731,
-0.3504630327,
-0.1541250944,
0.380063802,
0.7149148583,
0.6395926476,
0.4057248235,
0.3253130019,
0.2735604942,
-0.515198648,
0.4218345582,
-0.1846494377,
-0.2417252362,
0.1570130438,
0.615624845,
0.7997350097,
0.4318427444,
-0.4202323854,
0.5781570673,
-0.023197297,
0.0692531094,
-0.5371056795,
-0.3920884728,
0.209340468,
0.3220647573,
0.7068921328,
-0.1090847999,
-0.1583182365,
-0.555862844,
-0.0770806074,
0.3870917261,
0.0207087044,
-0.8069501519,
0.8694856763,
0.0802731887,
-0.4415558577,
0.3238720596,
-0.1406406611,
-0.7274312377,
0.5725418329,
0.9338923693,
0.8329721689,
-0.3090967238,
0.215778023,
0.0895139873,
0.7251486182,
0.1897610128,
0.2357475162,
0.2323066145,
-1.0664353371,
-0.8219999075,
-0.6205816269,
-0.4259865582,
0.0402864739,
-0.3304036856,
0.2724342346,
-0.067931287,
-0.0504818223,
-0.1739574969,
-0.4380118549,
-0.8557428718,
-0.0452859476,
0.5430631042,
0.6257609725,
-1.1180266142,
0.8169852495,
0.9366976023,
-0.5178380013,
-0.8610044718,
0.1724777967,
-0.0537877008,
-1.1962797642,
0.8473602533,
0.1445782781,
-0.1552052051,
-0.199655354,
-0.5731215477,
-1.26882267,
0.920805335,
0.5505337119,
-0.3879814744,
-0.0835658386,
0.5123912692,
0.510555625,
-0.6630200148,
0.4956904352,
0.5333385468,
0.4243796766,
-0.2019610703,
-0.9912840724,
-0.3384445012,
-0.4121969342,
-0.0784688145,
-0.023266362,
-0.6525008678,
1.1119586229,
-0.117054604,
-0.1186084971,
-0.2813872397,
0.6890693307,
0.1788127124,
-0.1350215375,
0.3522326946,
0.3619682789,
0.8364173174,
-0.0884245262,
1.143358469,
-0.7892446518,
-0.0092327632,
0.8209764957,
-0.5332067013,
1.0985569954,
0.7247021794,
-0.5049759746,
1.0556964874,
0.5476830602,
0.196568653,
0.3944386244,
-0.1236118451,
0.1257730275,
0.1003426686,
-0.30182603,
-0.1523136795,
0.7486336231,
0.3610337675,
-0.1583911926,
0.0800147802,
0.1274888068,
0.3615352809,
-0.0956488326,
-0.0830695406,
0.5172719359,
0.1554668397,
-0.6228928566,
0.4154630601,
0.2773914635,
0.9899495244,
-0.4789351523,
0.2499732375,
-0.595920682,
-0.2127754092,
-0.3559674025,
-0.9530501962,
0.3171087205,
0.1668882072,
-0.1259526461,
-0.2108533233,
0.3509159982,
-0.6606035233,
-0.7174059749,
0.4118424654,
0.6458407044,
0.3256126344,
0.3346122205,
-0.4044673145,
-0.0816134885,
0.040583659,
-0.3377248347,
0.1287307739,
0.3714525402,
-0.292822212,
0.4848096073,
0.4486880302,
0.275742352,
0.312214613,
0.2785936594,
0.5651710629,
-0.4226918221,
-0.4841069281,
-0.7774773836,
0.762062788,
0.3169573247,
-0.3400512636,
0.6220089197,
0.5519676805,
1.0859825611,
0.0705741197,
0.7523967028,
0.2491098046,
0.3764327466,
-0.4561809599,
0.3747901022,
-0.7862341404,
0.2606393397,
-0.1907885671,
-1.219457984,
-0.1921367943,
0.7526957989,
-0.2343443036,
-0.1316192448,
1.056221962,
0.4944081903,
-0.0293446817,
-0.1828843653,
0.201358214,
0.2026540637,
0.179016605,
0.3185555339,
0.9556948543,
-0.462187171,
0.4857694507,
-0.2867903709,
0.1387161314,
0.2100919485,
-0.7036625743,
-0.7357518077,
-0.6600922346,
-0.1726602316,
-0.0252876524,
-0.3332004249,
0.7366458774,
0.4122874141,
-0.8412004709,
-0.558429122,
0.4795406759,
0.1150818616,
0.13970007,
-0.1691099554,
0.2735190988,
-0.2920507789,
-0.8911114335,
0.600025177,
0.4804008305,
0.0356443003,
-0.6285945177,
-0.055554077,
-0.2185528725,
0.0502438061,
0.6820735335,
-0.1322232485,
-1.0767439604,
-0.2143593431,
0.3163041174,
-0.1926124096,
0.2029493302,
0.7143450379,
-0.7688041925,
-0.0379570797,
-0.0052267737,
0.4830398262,
0.3085095286,
-0.5208579302,
0.642090261,
-1.0040476322,
0.8719007969,
0.0541879684,
0.6778532863,
0.5645358562,
-0.2135414481,
0.5140078068,
0.2002454847,
-0.3000697196,
-0.7924941778,
0.2561752498,
-0.3609692752,
-0.1783031821,
1.4080520868,
0.2481476814,
-0.2859040797,
0.0320453085,
-0.1365948766,
0.178534016,
-0.1919469982,
0.5281196237,
0.8466914296,
0.1973050237,
-0.229131937,
-0.5547876954,
0.0875224695,
0.57062608,
-0.4100488424,
-0.3356503546,
0.0215715282,
0.081887655,
0.3733696342,
0.4503960013,
-0.0315118395,
-0.1260320097,
-0.1716540009,
0.142738387,
0.2942740619,
-0.3908126354,
-0.4872796535,
0.0299178045,
0.2943129241,
-0.0515239425
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10586v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10586v2
|
Threads of Subtlety: Detecting Machine-Generated Texts Through Discourse Motifs
| 2024-02-16T11:20:30 | 2024-06-06T20:04:52 |
Zae Myung Kim, Kwang Hee Lee, Preston Zhu, Vipul Raheja, Dongyeop Kang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
With the advent of large language models (LLM), the line between
human-crafted and machine-generated texts has become increasingly blurred. This
paper delves into the inquiry of identifying discernible and unique linguistic
properties in texts that were written by humans, particularly uncovering the
underlying discourse structures of texts beyond their surface structures.
Introducing a novel methodology, we leverage hierarchical parse trees and
recursive hypergraphs to unveil distinctive discourse patterns in texts
produced by both LLMs and humans. Empirical findings demonstrate that, although
both LLMs and humans generate distinct discourse patterns influenced by
specific domains, human-written texts exhibit more structural variability,
reflecting the nuanced nature of human writing in different domains. Notably,
incorporating hierarchical discourse features enhances binary classifiers'
overall performance in distinguishing between human-written and
machine-generated texts, even on out-of-distribution and paraphrased samples.
This underscores the significance of incorporating hierarchical discourse
features in the analysis of text patterns. The code and dataset are available
at https://github.com/minnesotanlp/threads-of-subtlety.
|
[
-0.0827129781,
-1.0332618952,
0.7617628574,
0.061566893,
-0.2390057594,
0.5713666081,
0.1006711051,
-0.5400719643,
0.1366101652,
0.7237355709,
-0.4820089936,
-0.6020868421,
-0.5350853801,
0.2048620731,
-0.5048178434,
0.9978182912,
0.1486069411,
-0.2704760134,
-0.146353364,
-0.1189877242,
0.0618623085,
-0.5609535575,
-0.1727344692,
-0.472560972,
0.8430247903,
0.039183069,
0.7192519307,
0.9802732468,
0.5436994433,
0.3412480056,
-0.3784230053,
0.4441307187,
-0.256991148,
0.3522781134,
-0.2076265663,
-0.4081606865,
-0.0993548036,
-0.1098484024,
0.8808786273,
0.8383246064,
0.385709852,
0.2909905612,
0.6578000188,
0.5544738173,
-0.4522657692,
0.0754949301,
-0.6822776198,
0.0605627708,
-0.7813606262,
-0.5476269722,
-0.534709394,
-0.3281107545,
-0.0317741521,
-0.2098809481,
0.3613424599,
0.2512837946,
1.0272768736,
0.1886818409,
-0.3900133073,
-0.5666465163,
-0.906101346,
0.8529952765,
-0.5391511917,
-0.1201173738,
0.1104827449,
-0.0500821732,
-0.2045776695,
-0.7521643639,
-0.2784620523,
-0.1657661349,
-0.4040242136,
-0.2349674702,
-0.1645132154,
-0.1217619628,
0.3686881959,
0.3325322568,
-0.4857799411,
-0.0202379227,
0.1008784845,
-0.2112427205,
0.4263279438,
0.4249574542,
0.4668753445,
-0.4135731459,
-0.1344964504,
0.2867696881,
-0.7045138478,
0.1145222187,
0.5684305429,
0.184370622,
-0.049912069,
0.4378355145,
0.1943301857,
0.3608952165,
0.0642171428,
-0.4628555477,
-0.068333216,
-0.2571440637,
0.0662618205,
-0.0591023192,
0.9962325692,
-0.1021146327,
0.1717587709,
-0.1007360891,
-0.2562443018,
-0.0672838613,
0.0961330086,
-0.5682324171,
-0.2732803524,
-0.2389438599,
-0.7275227308,
-0.8412803411,
0.0900706872,
-0.3757598698,
-0.8019749522,
-0.3460376263,
-0.1986844391,
-0.2847329676,
-0.2069313675,
-0.1402705312,
-0.3573541343,
0.3145597875,
0.066119045,
-0.768525064,
0.4215192497,
0.965724647,
0.7629680037,
-0.1777095646,
-0.2423018664,
-0.0611706898,
0.2974317968,
-0.4765415788,
0.8317216039,
-0.757053256,
-0.1931561828,
-0.1348061115,
-0.2186844796,
0.1910374612,
-0.635905683,
0.7953224182,
-0.178374216,
0.0413659476,
-0.2960858345,
-0.4271296263,
0.1004838198,
0.0576059557,
-0.6469718218,
1.2235578299,
0.1091521084,
-1.4240012169,
0.2514682412,
-0.2679787278,
-0.5629268885,
0.1684445888,
-0.6447493434,
-0.6189421415,
0.2908506989,
0.0332683958,
0.4212536514,
-0.4513877928,
0.6047953367,
-0.2119070292,
-0.5408973694,
0.650888741,
-0.6886208057,
0.8377944827,
0.1209854186,
-0.5635427237,
0.0631415546,
-0.8384388089,
-0.1903797388,
0.0379912257,
-0.3366396427,
-0.4536374509,
0.2885928452,
0.0269398969,
0.0858884826,
0.2200764716,
-0.3103792667,
0.0836409181,
-0.3549546897,
0.6020988226,
0.8710879087,
0.1835445464,
0.3917320371,
-0.6464733481,
0.4115774632,
0.3857064843,
-0.0188080221,
-0.4945483804,
-0.797722578,
-0.6607060432,
-0.3643049002,
0.3023278713,
0.5187191963,
-0.7937502265,
0.5711339712,
-0.1784478873,
-0.3186755776,
-0.6261911392,
0.1478184164,
0.7457817197,
0.2434008569,
-0.2554294169,
-0.3631762564,
-0.6766477227,
-0.8958577514,
-0.7045330405,
-0.2673211694,
-0.1532049626,
0.5324853659,
0.5777410269,
-0.2703664601,
1.0965094566,
-0.5011539459,
0.1767212152,
-0.0502730608,
0.7009106874,
-0.0144086834,
0.3334163725,
0.4490170479,
-0.5095037818,
-0.5252422094,
0.2440945953,
-0.8969784975,
-0.2993605435,
-0.4665867388,
-0.1053924039,
0.0930775329,
0.6525537372,
-0.4848834872,
0.2269940376,
0.1771568209,
-0.2110334188,
0.5433957577,
0.1011064276,
-0.0811630562,
-0.9726483226,
0.2444654852,
-0.1999761015,
-0.3197593093,
-0.3524264097,
0.1471140981,
-0.1405125409,
0.0651799664,
-0.1744010299,
0.4249907136,
-0.5773045421,
-0.1329060644,
-0.0388905592,
0.0101777157,
0.1486848146,
0.513915956,
-0.2920176983,
0.65147084,
0.3188231289,
-0.3610357046,
-0.232641235,
-0.2031404525,
-0.2890841365,
0.5279231071,
-0.5283412933,
0.4264232218,
-0.182375595,
0.101099439,
-1.1508363485,
-0.3498054445,
0.3083303869,
-0.4433276057,
0.2836479247,
-0.1331787705,
-0.7090856433,
-0.2880866528,
-0.5955471992,
0.3265047669,
0.4185577929,
-0.1162298098,
0.4041370749,
0.5948056579,
-0.3559777141,
-0.493350625,
-0.7088266611,
0.348672986,
-0.2015266865,
-0.6048541665,
0.2563425601,
0.0186210163,
-0.4168266356,
-0.2294910848,
0.1706104726,
-0.342027247,
0.3133290112,
0.4598969817,
0.0700785369,
-0.3972194791,
-0.0487713553,
0.4229967594,
0.0401543751,
0.2016406357,
-0.3963415027,
0.4874572158,
-0.0336206928,
-0.2880896032,
-0.563855052,
0.4844949543,
0.7015732527,
0.1233952418,
0.4546242952,
0.6538546085,
-0.1786970794,
-0.1111260876,
-0.3849437237,
-0.2129496336,
-0.5114949346,
-0.0481305718,
-0.4122923613,
-1.0349675417,
0.427983433,
-0.3890376985,
-0.0301839635,
0.3084166348,
0.4708674848,
-0.3689599931,
1.1601868868,
0.6434730887,
-0.2377117574,
0.3192074299,
0.1771693379,
0.1911454946,
-0.8280196786,
0.0643447414,
-0.8659294248,
-0.4371967614,
-0.9955590963,
-0.4511019289,
0.0472634286,
-0.1152493805,
-0.1320707649,
-0.0385002159,
-0.8000952005,
0.7791749835,
0.5705871582,
0.04842747,
0.3781631887,
0.0087269172,
-0.4785068333,
-0.3063115478,
-0.3659190238,
-0.9986199141,
0.8954424262,
0.4265924394,
0.4972770214,
-0.2118095458,
0.9255214334,
0.5023258328,
0.1209017262,
-0.5907655954,
0.607948184,
-0.0864253342,
-0.2827468514,
0.035874106,
-0.498821795,
-1.2392879725,
0.1457472444,
-0.0141037637,
-0.5172514915,
0.0130521012,
-0.0385403596,
-0.0460152663,
0.3763063252,
-0.4394491613,
0.5081442595,
0.0458927229,
-0.2582227886,
0.3437749743,
-0.7465505004,
0.403552264,
-0.0056796232,
0.3270713389,
0.027543379,
-0.195277974,
0.5387550592,
-0.0127964616,
1.3729506731,
0.254570961,
-0.4141373336,
0.5631964207,
0.3082696497,
0.567856133,
-0.1067544222,
0.2626155615,
0.2125496119,
-0.6028475165,
-0.3714505136,
-0.1750570834,
0.7240155339,
-0.7220406532,
-0.4765576422,
-0.3025287092,
-0.5969064236,
0.1848796606,
0.4199578762,
0.3848585486,
0.3679991961,
-0.4216426313,
0.0163751207,
0.8891662359,
-0.1646514982,
0.576902926,
0.1598629951,
-0.0835950449,
-0.1682506353,
1.0060837269,
-0.0351560898,
-0.051466316,
0.5754778981,
0.4378917515,
0.1352594495,
-0.5726249218,
-0.3800603747,
0.3378956616,
-0.4664183259,
-0.0285500661,
-0.7458564639,
-0.4908216298,
-0.2427691966,
-0.2807584405,
-0.0004561307,
-0.5120934844,
-0.4901798368,
0.0771418586,
-0.0954316407,
1.1643658876,
0.3190563917,
0.2647872567,
-0.7327324152,
0.3200884461,
0.3014348745,
-0.1808535308,
-0.0550720356,
-0.4211968482,
0.0995418653,
-0.1697616428,
-0.6989340782,
-0.7067126036,
0.3234490752,
-0.0548146628,
0.1736349612,
0.5481066108,
-0.1713133156,
0.3962209225,
-0.6990180612,
0.863971889,
0.072579518,
-1.0747798681,
0.5512673855,
-0.805257082,
0.5698522329,
0.1805425584,
0.2889359593,
-0.3741384149,
-1.0483430624,
-0.7729314566,
-0.6898085475,
0.4830441773,
0.5184643269,
0.237934351,
-0.093529582,
0.388802588,
0.1844641566,
0.3722974956,
-0.706046164,
-0.2545781434,
0.3357066214,
-0.2772509456,
0.354372412,
-0.5373747349,
-0.1519842893,
-0.1100294888,
0.0205928907,
-0.1721018106,
0.1107930988,
0.0233160425,
-0.0614018179,
-0.1266874075,
0.3273089826,
0.6198334098,
0.4943139851,
0.1592570394,
0.5471397042,
-0.2038013041,
-0.6218880415,
-0.005258543,
-0.4345285296,
-0.7237551212,
0.4296809435,
0.716822207,
0.5673262477,
0.5734267235,
-0.2963119149,
0.3045621812,
0.0141264917,
-0.1735296845,
0.0316250138,
0.0434302278,
0.247750476,
0.2879194617,
0.1879908293,
0.5019845366,
0.4493969381,
-0.6889107823,
0.1361189187,
0.3000159264,
-0.4401950836,
-0.6565562487,
0.2969408929,
0.2521700859,
-0.5175950527,
0.2160051763,
-0.3747984767,
-0.4004693627,
0.3919515908,
0.4261529744,
1.1799092293,
-0.1579756439,
0.4332756698,
0.0292902775,
0.3907517791,
0.1812148392,
0.2090522349,
-0.3193282485,
-0.4827985764,
-0.2475452572,
-0.5916762948,
-0.3709961772,
-0.1089233756,
-0.4576631188,
0.2674553692,
-0.6486105323,
-0.194275409,
0.4000983536,
-0.0967664346,
-0.1543917358,
-0.4212222099,
0.3192213178,
0.1896562874,
-0.7388724089,
0.7815229297,
0.4689419568,
-0.0117939673,
-0.4322830439,
0.2782090604,
0.2883181274,
-0.5057295561,
0.4583540261,
0.2355540097,
-0.4025380611,
-0.1441855133,
-0.7899786234,
-0.6009932756,
0.9599943757,
0.4926328659,
-0.5716922879,
-0.2085436881,
0.6332302094,
0.5777863264,
-0.2673482597,
0.1225634217,
0.7178458571,
0.3556269407,
-0.0090475567,
-0.7206159234,
0.0698288828,
-0.1157522127,
0.2516466081,
0.3760993779,
-0.4302771688,
1.0619883537,
0.0105374996,
-0.4897455275,
0.1157677695,
0.4363137484,
0.3172646165,
0.4506335855,
0.0632636324,
0.2818259895,
1.1829248667,
-0.0324389115,
0.9474003315,
-0.2364710271,
0.144370839,
1.0906974077,
-0.3131269217,
0.5180729628,
0.4685411751,
-0.0861450285,
0.9210080504,
0.2197310477,
0.3173514009,
0.121881634,
0.4398860037,
-0.3461379111,
-0.0090373177,
-0.2576939464,
-0.0501578972,
0.2978903651,
0.3391701579,
-0.4995698333,
-0.1470130682,
-0.2386898398,
0.340700984,
0.3135415614,
-0.1169659123,
1.0077621937,
0.3253006935,
-0.5559405684,
0.4921353757,
0.0168361235,
0.7311987877,
-0.2707247436,
-0.0355649889,
-0.088981919,
0.2393601239,
-0.2526672482,
-0.8893587589,
0.3802534342,
0.1246374175,
-0.4045611918,
-0.4092859328,
1.0622279644,
-0.1797019243,
-0.5684222579,
0.0122742476,
0.5667070746,
0.1289717555,
-0.1509807706,
-0.8298903108,
0.0957011133,
-0.0512989573,
-0.0900781602,
0.3336823881,
1.170502305,
-0.2710492909,
0.3696857095,
0.7260050774,
-0.1175183654,
0.0725954771,
0.256094873,
0.9411672354,
-0.9037948251,
-0.286373049,
-1.1838493347,
0.4766265154,
-0.2782210708,
-0.4497252703,
0.8048579693,
0.5361621976,
0.418756187,
-0.0132498182,
0.6854683161,
0.2283938825,
0.5432817936,
-0.2842248082,
0.8197590709,
-0.0309706666,
0.4387000799,
-0.5538386703,
-0.5612520576,
-0.269146353,
0.2914589942,
0.1694728434,
-0.1108959019,
0.8330165148,
0.7882916331,
0.0490573011,
0.1418941319,
0.3154112399,
0.2548364401,
0.1950533837,
0.3060081005,
1.2186604738,
-0.3242723644,
0.4404312074,
-0.0414973423,
-0.1569040269,
-0.117987223,
-0.7620940804,
-1.251881361,
-0.6048045158,
-0.4074982405,
-0.0330807753,
-0.1404165328,
0.2686887383,
0.4641371965,
-0.5713757277,
-0.3654194772,
-0.4235766828,
0.4959889054,
-0.0613269024,
-0.2940202951,
0.2120589465,
-0.5031647682,
-0.5710662007,
0.0369159058,
0.6595448256,
0.0174227711,
-0.417146951,
0.1395131201,
-0.1771359295,
0.530154109,
0.6835315824,
-0.1446448565,
-0.7435875535,
-0.2337214053,
0.0737257674,
-0.562779367,
0.1255105287,
1.4669995308,
-0.6470908523,
0.0346229151,
0.6156324148,
0.4029682875,
0.1268968433,
-0.2109864354,
0.2780678272,
-1.3229635954,
0.1215095147,
0.4707470834,
0.1711479723,
0.3642750978,
-0.4390817583,
0.2812005281,
0.4240487814,
-0.5373458266,
-0.9731354117,
0.3129882514,
-0.7481472492,
-0.5622003078,
0.9865540862,
-0.2176285386,
-0.4726910591,
-0.5653114915,
-0.5443988442,
0.0523889102,
-0.1970204711,
0.8477749228,
0.6766083837,
0.0593340807,
-0.1114572436,
-0.1622616798,
0.5850200057,
0.1447128952,
-0.7919968367,
0.2321116477,
0.3714474142,
-0.0235411711,
0.3785777986,
0.7083999515,
-0.2129160613,
0.065138258,
0.2016308606,
-0.3574571311,
0.3469674587,
-0.4579797387,
-0.1252100021,
0.3640188277,
0.1811670065,
0.100005202
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10573v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10573v2
|
LinkNER: Linking Local Named Entity Recognition Models to Large Language Models using Uncertainty
| 2024-02-16T11:02:29 | 2024-02-27T15:08:02 |
Zhen Zhang, Yuhua Zhao, Hang Gao, Mengting Hu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
Named Entity Recognition (NER) serves as a fundamental task in natural
language understanding, bearing direct implications for web content analysis,
search engines, and information retrieval systems. Fine-tuned NER models
exhibit satisfactory performance on standard NER benchmarks. However, due to
limited fine-tuning data and lack of knowledge, it performs poorly on unseen
entity recognition. As a result, the usability and reliability of NER models in
web-related applications are compromised. Instead, Large Language Models (LLMs)
like GPT-4 possess extensive external knowledge, but research indicates that
they lack specialty for NER tasks. Furthermore, non-public and large-scale
weights make tuning LLMs difficult. To address these challenges, we propose a
framework that combines small fine-tuned models with LLMs (LinkNER) and an
uncertainty-based linking strategy called RDC that enables fine-tuned models to
complement black-box LLMs, achieving better performance. We experiment with
both standard NER test sets and noisy social media datasets. LinkNER enhances
NER task performance, notably surpassing SOTA models in robustness tests. We
also quantitatively analyze the influence of key components like uncertainty
estimation methods, LLMs, and in-context learning on diverse NER tasks,
offering specific web-related recommendations.
|
[
-0.4993687272,
-0.7727123499,
0.5821826458,
-0.216722548,
-0.1430863589,
0.0189334732,
-0.4328627586,
-0.7665494084,
0.1447001845,
0.2494018823,
-0.3741975725,
-0.3500534594,
-0.7404056787,
0.5358566046,
-0.2740049064,
1.0519012213,
-0.1263585836,
-0.0310717132,
-0.1877896935,
0.051097136,
-0.1335857958,
-0.2113606036,
-1.05370152,
-0.1332042366,
0.7821750641,
0.2797619998,
0.8678331375,
0.5672836304,
0.8678978086,
0.2857010961,
-0.101693891,
0.1696709543,
-0.5389772654,
0.2663251162,
-0.3996373117,
-0.38151142,
-0.3650416136,
-0.3737965524,
0.6566896439,
0.5918890238,
-0.02892063,
0.0709277615,
0.0033939702,
0.3774999678,
-0.6889403462,
0.0942407027,
-0.8905879855,
-0.4010997117,
-0.1867463291,
0.0272992756,
-0.1172871217,
-0.3479468226,
0.2319596708,
-0.5717051625,
0.4480866492,
0.2804741859,
1.1906335354,
0.4485280812,
-0.3541997075,
-0.2022117376,
-0.9656413198,
0.6231825948,
-0.7042489648,
0.6840671301,
0.6459456086,
0.3231496513,
-0.3902616501,
-0.5719206929,
-0.699246943,
0.0382943191,
0.1766722202,
-0.3248887062,
-0.4365054667,
0.0269934349,
0.2552177012,
0.1913913786,
-0.4037425816,
0.1800283641,
-0.3156488836,
-0.1905549467,
0.363863796,
-0.0128441434,
0.1451220363,
-0.1046828628,
-0.2044291645,
0.1180521399,
-0.8558402658,
-0.2021944523,
0.4365338981,
0.6219365597,
-0.0936101526,
0.4238105714,
-0.4347993135,
0.7544748783,
0.3289652169,
-0.0539559349,
-0.0302419588,
-0.1831951886,
-0.1162484065,
0.0849188939,
0.8695429564,
0.0778385624,
0.0431695655,
-0.3492390215,
-0.3347994089,
-0.0851760656,
0.1237330809,
-0.8825023174,
-0.3596107066,
0.1201883852,
-0.0956967548,
-0.1568049341,
-0.0297703668,
-0.6752853394,
-0.327917099,
-0.3865442276,
0.6086257696,
-0.5356289148,
-0.0765376836,
-0.0028110777,
0.3386369348,
0.0241232868,
0.4664679468,
-0.7532499433,
0.4240409136,
0.6217175126,
0.7231499553,
-0.0965563655,
-0.1685934812,
-0.6671259999,
0.2800947726,
-0.1237504408,
0.800016582,
-0.5913236141,
0.0679451004,
-0.136918366,
-0.0351302139,
0.109204866,
-0.3627707362,
0.3269162774,
-0.9031807184,
-0.0512522012,
-0.3209817708,
-0.6041817665,
0.0282980241,
0.1979127675,
-0.9607257247,
0.8619108796,
-0.0206924584,
-1.0517805815,
0.5027116537,
-0.252109468,
-0.4944824278,
0.040817596,
-0.1531488448,
-0.453833282,
0.1711633205,
0.2685625851,
0.583147943,
-0.5656589866,
0.2544508576,
-0.5027392507,
-0.3640776873,
0.2094641328,
-0.376447618,
0.2323272675,
0.0743596852,
-0.3076791465,
0.0307796095,
-0.754371345,
-0.012191236,
-0.0928575024,
-0.2432685345,
-0.5382000804,
0.0554614849,
0.0193268154,
0.2107556164,
0.2581073642,
-0.2930017114,
-0.1924608052,
-0.3412990868,
0.4384976625,
0.5511846542,
0.0717999339,
0.4560888112,
-0.1051704213,
0.4086351395,
-0.1756471843,
-0.1178647056,
0.3644980788,
-0.4121781886,
-0.9747164845,
-0.0516181439,
0.6489640474,
0.1858233213,
-0.7516221404,
0.3605183065,
-0.6336607933,
-0.4514499009,
-0.428116709,
0.1108143404,
0.2317042798,
0.2832948267,
0.4523760378,
-0.1579660475,
-0.5606049895,
-0.6099866033,
-0.1869578809,
-0.1256599128,
-0.2496786863,
0.2863303721,
0.6416554451,
-0.2919228375,
0.9306431413,
-0.2966863811,
-0.33099702,
-0.1798957884,
0.3411855996,
0.1170657277,
0.191222325,
-0.0228171628,
-0.9873265028,
-0.4563970268,
0.0654790029,
-0.4263889492,
0.1704167128,
-0.0080225589,
0.1108682826,
0.0583542399,
0.4751806557,
-0.5759590268,
0.279778868,
0.529601872,
-0.0930386186,
0.400206089,
-0.2282786071,
0.0221537501,
-1.0970582962,
-0.2039531767,
0.3125436306,
-0.1950330287,
-0.4905600846,
-0.0205446687,
0.0520391464,
0.0897248685,
-0.2218536735,
0.5781099796,
-0.7480790615,
-0.0340744853,
-0.172186777,
0.2149820477,
-0.2149139941,
-0.0156036615,
0.0854389668,
0.7926285267,
0.4398760796,
-0.7349823713,
0.1049774215,
0.0919483453,
-0.3680231869,
0.6991045475,
-0.7280173302,
0.119261235,
-0.0637147054,
-0.0406019501,
-0.4423929453,
-0.5608323812,
0.0844186246,
-0.3510576189,
0.6071904302,
-0.1809815764,
-0.5217208266,
-0.1582499892,
0.1341092288,
0.3825879693,
0.1461822242,
-0.3927943707,
0.6785954833,
0.4201268554,
-0.2167581916,
-0.402636975,
-0.4304905236,
0.1970295459,
-0.2633124292,
-0.3845734596,
0.4491938055,
0.1005539224,
-0.1835116595,
0.1376626194,
-0.5610870123,
-0.4548285604,
-0.0667709038,
0.4029221833,
0.1255397797,
-0.2154703736,
0.1815533638,
-0.1094134748,
-0.1622552127,
-0.0164727513,
-0.2035463899,
0.2277272493,
-0.2655477822,
-0.3683739007,
-0.2629588544,
-0.0179883149,
0.2108647227,
-0.2514389157,
0.6705034971,
0.7553287745,
-0.5918258429,
-0.1498791724,
-0.7406117916,
-0.2877136171,
-0.4515105188,
0.28088516,
-0.630772531,
-1.344245553,
0.4182718694,
-0.1685979068,
-0.5647025108,
0.251036942,
0.3430076241,
-0.1351530999,
0.5121251941,
0.7813225985,
-0.2711681724,
0.4082459509,
0.1270966679,
0.5546184778,
-0.7458298802,
-0.0200395826,
-0.6125890017,
-0.2870786488,
-0.7432588935,
-0.7313693166,
0.0774230659,
0.2062137574,
-0.3407288194,
0.6366065145,
-0.2711038291,
0.5289943218,
0.5784054399,
0.1758849174,
0.4508594573,
0.1079438254,
-0.046684213,
-0.1751586348,
-0.5153146982,
-0.4747962952,
1.0350202322,
0.1854201108,
1.050678134,
0.2825380266,
0.7922722697,
-0.0414088666,
0.000051168,
-0.5198594332,
0.410409987,
0.1447966993,
-0.7176946402,
-0.4587245286,
-0.6293920279,
-0.9208147526,
-0.1197014153,
-0.4545232356,
-1.0015208721,
0.41147843,
0.0349908732,
-0.3834570348,
0.4969340861,
-0.2635951042,
0.652586937,
-0.1304084063,
-0.5169872046,
0.0100923236,
-0.7739290595,
0.076884754,
-0.3332266808,
0.2178392112,
-0.2020849735,
-0.1180493757,
0.4407216311,
-0.0421253443,
0.7637440562,
0.3486812711,
-0.0494210348,
0.0981910452,
0.3174131513,
0.9870914817,
0.2350234985,
-0.1715118885,
0.4602094293,
-0.2372567058,
-0.0339110084,
-0.5921163559,
0.8766425252,
-0.6102991104,
-0.3222289979,
-0.4623036087,
-0.5599813461,
-0.1937506497,
0.4457478225,
0.343609333,
0.1652023345,
-0.197457388,
0.2382233143,
0.8556335568,
0.0236203242,
0.2611421943,
0.370282799,
0.2338596284,
-0.4813822508,
0.8810590506,
-0.0220202897,
0.2837255299,
0.9197003841,
-0.1223058999,
-0.2364954203,
-0.7895057797,
0.0809982717,
0.1723747402,
-0.5579792857,
-0.4386895895,
-0.6476949453,
-0.1173786744,
-0.2087205946,
-0.0721164271,
-0.3947594762,
-0.2452537566,
-0.4592578411,
-0.1117269099,
0.5233083367,
0.7050573826,
-0.0198006332,
0.2726153135,
-0.4309433103,
0.4343421459,
0.27516222,
0.654669404,
-0.2728403509,
-0.2822438478,
-0.2226463258,
0.0480167679,
0.2071343511,
-0.7627414465,
0.2343247533,
0.2220771015,
0.1787795275,
0.5102103353,
0.3458142877,
0.8926945329,
-0.6021731496,
0.2417564392,
0.134576723,
-0.8303198814,
0.5353466868,
-0.5014120936,
-0.0024310786,
0.8347851038,
0.679738462,
-0.2070942968,
-0.3077850342,
-0.4909968674,
-1.0160988569,
0.3967273235,
0.3457000554,
-0.0230974834,
-0.1412712932,
0.3307704926,
-0.1318563521,
0.2187764347,
-0.818482399,
-0.1288051754,
0.25935027,
-0.1642065644,
-0.0621488169,
-0.3560668528,
0.0524690896,
-0.0938538536,
0.7486045957,
-0.1770883501,
0.2351764739,
0.0957949758,
-0.2590380013,
-0.2835801244,
0.4647942781,
0.1108296141,
0.5893290043,
-0.3508063257,
0.2799641192,
0.3361231983,
-0.3051768243,
0.0989377722,
0.3371664882,
-0.3529215157,
0.0793835893,
0.2462329268,
0.8069581389,
0.69381392,
-0.3258420825,
0.2799439728,
-0.1716069579,
0.0910707191,
-0.2474513203,
-0.0512831919,
0.2157854587,
0.3363053203,
0.1445296109,
0.0955344364,
0.0520733148,
-0.0306727607,
0.3322264254,
0.5055070519,
-0.6997135282,
-0.2733153403,
0.8186762929,
-0.0809366778,
-0.2161808461,
0.4662986696,
-0.4228393734,
-0.2402188927,
0.326701045,
0.69857651,
0.7790295482,
-0.1960029453,
0.0444835052,
0.5271044374,
0.426543504,
-0.2788482606,
0.1159417555,
0.0360680409,
-0.7882556319,
-0.3741126359,
-0.7763579488,
-0.5019712448,
0.0963872224,
-0.7040842772,
0.3672347963,
-0.4274476171,
-0.4051590562,
0.0767697915,
0.0173486024,
-0.911021769,
0.2368102968,
-0.023023665,
0.5863596201,
-0.559234798,
0.8417099118,
0.7425720096,
-0.6029779911,
-1.0573072433,
0.2051633745,
0.0951779857,
-0.2671900094,
0.7674530745,
0.002436596,
-0.2040515542,
0.2330409735,
-0.1843540221,
-1.3249664307,
1.085350275,
0.3799034655,
-0.7489272356,
-0.2744837105,
0.0915290713,
0.3823072016,
-0.2020250261,
0.4051074982,
0.2134656012,
0.4587044418,
0.2242670506,
-0.8905653358,
0.3800896108,
0.058956977,
0.2723946869,
0.4041171372,
-0.3917172849,
0.8366442919,
-0.4787376523,
-0.2764109373,
-0.0344656594,
0.7931053638,
0.0983386338,
0.0456490442,
0.3153119683,
0.5658115745,
0.98329252,
-0.1298504174,
0.8344598413,
-0.2883861065,
0.4739795029,
1.5362131596,
-0.4269953072,
1.2188091278,
0.4877049625,
-0.3516073525,
0.4618266523,
0.6093694568,
-0.2127693594,
0.4138151407,
0.205780521,
-0.4406792819,
-0.4074143469,
-0.1187587157,
-0.2428968996,
0.4054619372,
0.2158141881,
-0.1707591563,
-0.2591158748,
-0.3682875931,
0.0022010326,
-0.0879061446,
-0.209671393,
0.7240610123,
0.2160587013,
-0.1906213015,
0.3093666434,
-0.0645073801,
0.8244566917,
-0.5166985393,
0.0599157661,
-0.0036406389,
0.1139919013,
-0.1256976575,
-0.2979800701,
0.1803060323,
-0.0311697479,
-0.3061185479,
0.1598995924,
0.9588105083,
-0.4017012417,
-0.612347424,
0.3615444899,
0.4607273042,
0.1226897389,
-0.3549281657,
-0.4570660591,
0.0332755223,
-0.2012740672,
-0.1030864567,
0.5321513414,
0.7825981379,
-0.0211167894,
0.9357164502,
0.7662479877,
0.3463643789,
-0.1714225858,
-0.020270545,
0.6212025285,
-0.6897331476,
-0.1981436014,
-0.7929123044,
0.1611083001,
0.014200598,
-0.0871289074,
0.8158633113,
0.4781414568,
1.1327522993,
0.1117916182,
0.5557476878,
-0.1660814881,
0.2634544969,
-0.3309804499,
0.7891936302,
-0.4502018094,
0.2222844213,
-0.5153853297,
-0.9071928859,
-0.5307241678,
0.7558628917,
-0.4862658978,
0.0949121118,
0.7208163738,
0.8351698518,
-0.2280143797,
-0.093686156,
0.3945021927,
0.1755246371,
0.0409618802,
0.4874558449,
0.4951909781,
-0.5856445432,
0.6552225351,
-0.302975595,
0.2154832631,
-0.1477305442,
-1.0464787483,
-0.9566015005,
-0.5020529628,
-0.5056464076,
-0.2929727137,
0.3087997437,
0.8740497231,
0.7184137702,
-0.9566770196,
0.0491992161,
-0.2820607424,
0.3323236108,
-0.0950239375,
-0.1714490652,
0.3111785352,
-0.1816039234,
-0.716920495,
0.2458313555,
0.1843369007,
0.066228129,
0.1508260667,
-0.110215649,
-0.2750349939,
-0.2772734463,
0.2161799818,
0.2305223793,
-0.9893758297,
-0.415713042,
-0.1426209658,
-0.066777654,
-0.076896213,
0.3723187149,
-0.6441394091,
0.3394538164,
0.2545300126,
0.8400259018,
0.4606911838,
-0.0690146014,
0.6626064777,
-0.5730138421,
-0.2801867127,
0.2317568958,
0.4844419062,
0.4459390044,
-0.470590204,
0.5100105405,
-0.0566729195,
-0.5924815536,
-0.6277256608,
0.2596172392,
-0.7897177935,
-0.0555720478,
1.2219930887,
-0.0599094108,
-0.05191724,
-0.2233677953,
0.3169264197,
0.3909852207,
-0.4827231169,
0.6339108944,
0.5504043698,
0.0762443915,
-0.223097831,
-0.7319883108,
0.4963630736,
0.0034223758,
-0.7286129594,
-0.15350236,
0.523491323,
0.6277680397,
0.0989101306,
0.4341507256,
0.1931737959,
-0.1195281744,
-0.0132919718,
0.2079026848,
0.01166014,
-0.3945905268,
-0.3122180104,
0.1151826456,
0.1965602189,
0.1442342252
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10571v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10571v2
|
Direct Preference Optimization with an Offset
| 2024-02-16T10:55:38 | 2024-06-06T12:02:37 |
Afra Amini, Tim Vieira, Ryan Cotterell
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Direct preference optimization (DPO) is a successful fine-tuning strategy for
aligning large language models with human preferences without the need to train
a reward model or employ reinforcement learning. DPO, as originally formulated,
relies on binary preference data and fine-tunes a language model to increase
the likelihood of a preferred response over a dispreferred response. However,
not all preference pairs are equal. Sometimes, the preferred response is only
slightly better than the dispreferred one. In other cases, the preference is
much stronger. For instance, if a response contains harmful or toxic content,
the annotator will have a strong preference for that response. In this paper,
we propose a generalization of DPO, termed DPO with an offset (ODPO), that does
not treat every preference pair equally during fine-tuning. Intuitively, ODPO
requires the difference between the likelihood of the preferred and
dispreferred response to be greater than an offset value. The offset is
determined based on the extent to which one response is preferred over another.
Our experiments on various tasks suggest that ODPO significantly outperforms
DPO in aligning language models, especially when the number of preference pairs
is limited.
|
[
-0.5153159499,
-0.529399693,
0.4456127286,
0.279348135,
-0.3287742734,
-0.0322751477,
-0.2152198851,
-0.4002830684,
0.1603018194,
0.4106462002,
-0.6093438268,
-0.1407191008,
-0.7237465382,
0.2806702256,
0.4578412175,
0.5948575139,
0.0173936374,
-0.0938975811,
0.0621248335,
-0.0508352704,
-0.6815851331,
-0.2266110778,
-0.6058344245,
-0.4086983204,
0.4862424731,
0.7234929204,
0.8969003558,
1.1905039549,
0.4414380193,
0.2817801833,
-0.1192322522,
0.2825761735,
-0.556601882,
0.033329539,
-0.1374622732,
-0.2816225588,
-0.5343959928,
-0.0653593019,
0.3968860805,
0.9810025692,
-0.0186313614,
-0.323029995,
-0.0956319124,
1.1037304401,
-1.0922739506,
-0.3252877295,
-0.6759858131,
-0.0109360442,
0.1604848504,
-0.0918084532,
-0.1523812413,
-0.5836762786,
0.2971770167,
-0.8019532561,
-0.2743279338,
0.0082084397,
0.6455344558,
0.5401181579,
-0.4566728473,
-0.181579411,
-0.8217180967,
1.039180398,
-0.4852313101,
0.0469349623,
0.3598628342,
0.1018990874,
-0.3601552546,
0.0198981464,
-0.7196811438,
0.0349623151,
-0.0296879653,
0.0068123164,
-0.0173549075,
0.2315127552,
0.0180781949,
0.3484791815,
-0.2542169988,
0.6096549034,
0.1344099939,
0.1612019539,
0.6083165407,
-0.0052482509,
0.0602284521,
-0.0844249278,
-0.7269880772,
-0.129036516,
-0.5498114228,
0.2862425148,
0.76973629,
0.2349043041,
0.3370209038,
0.3466844559,
-0.3992808461,
1.0000998974,
0.7066170573,
-0.1027248949,
0.1137188748,
0.0094720582,
-0.1375251263,
0.311796695,
0.8544037342,
0.6673148274,
0.2592557371,
-0.0538612083,
-0.1804461032,
0.1231436357,
0.2367542535,
-0.7030078769,
0.213357687,
0.3239424825,
-0.08198338,
-0.5281677246,
-0.0650700033,
-0.9475001097,
-0.2755432129,
-0.4409099817,
0.194251284,
-0.3566800952,
-0.2047786713,
0.5422392488,
-0.12631464,
-0.1014627889,
0.1380117685,
-1.4796373844,
0.3755467832,
1.0631734133,
0.6665065885,
-0.4539578855,
-0.1777103841,
-0.6157547235,
0.1355113387,
-0.367533505,
0.691291213,
-0.9318681955,
-0.5724577308,
-0.0201544724,
-0.2000182867,
0.1143353283,
-0.4373158813,
1.0640782118,
-0.5852956772,
0.207224831,
-0.4365578294,
-0.5874435902,
0.1685784012,
-0.0275734197,
-0.5773255229,
0.9859933853,
-0.135739401,
-0.847284317,
0.6387670636,
-0.4044098258,
-0.2367251366,
-0.2286238968,
-0.2241581976,
-0.276401937,
0.2343877703,
0.1585691571,
0.0703910664,
-0.0798406526,
0.2684594989,
-0.58356148,
-0.531272769,
0.1001229584,
0.0521483123,
0.6075546145,
0.1973301172,
-0.4253401458,
0.1824035048,
-0.8775279522,
-0.1746879965,
0.1569558531,
-0.3348203301,
-1.0726983547,
0.367008239,
-0.5799639225,
0.1229788959,
0.2656303346,
-0.8195363283,
0.6458040476,
-0.5894417167,
0.3776341975,
1.2138718367,
-0.1812613904,
0.8346819282,
-0.279717803,
0.2307555526,
-0.2226393521,
0.1890322119,
0.3832845092,
-0.1897119433,
-0.5554382205,
-0.3261432648,
0.0712469816,
0.3792084157,
-0.379214704,
1.1468554735,
-0.370478183,
-0.1483228654,
-0.3503932059,
0.0383709185,
0.3737640381,
0.8837988377,
0.1591255218,
-0.2664678395,
-0.3772857785,
-1.0796780586,
-0.0275745708,
-0.0574033298,
0.0669671372,
0.3950569034,
0.0077665523,
0.1447821856,
1.0758664608,
-0.9983513355,
-0.1340792477,
0.1069640517,
-0.1598842442,
0.2657702267,
0.5116519332,
0.6304494739,
-0.9847770333,
-0.7085037231,
0.0217296388,
-0.1831659675,
-0.1882646084,
0.2065120786,
-0.6746584177,
0.1398353428,
-0.0996294618,
-0.2345350832,
-0.0888766646,
0.6145000458,
-0.15777722,
0.2332162708,
-0.2089057267,
0.0672855824,
-0.8354133964,
0.2527402341,
-0.2110631168,
0.1579253674,
-0.6857115626,
-0.2041159421,
0.1595387161,
-0.0306315199,
-0.2612268627,
0.7317407131,
-0.3118239641,
0.2449626029,
-0.4972099364,
0.0211630873,
0.1169397086,
0.5166053176,
0.4281794131,
0.6076523662,
0.4927903414,
-0.7778839469,
0.2662037611,
0.3399504423,
-0.048863221,
0.6391417384,
-0.6814683676,
0.6331891418,
-0.1778179556,
0.0044922344,
-1.2213865519,
-0.1035584062,
0.3012862206,
-0.0812936723,
0.4847703874,
-0.2242629081,
-0.0756709576,
-0.3872584999,
-0.5803732276,
0.5013700128,
0.3657384813,
-0.5985147953,
0.0110566616,
0.3293662667,
-0.0742286593,
-1.1707930565,
-0.0834728703,
-0.5166990757,
-0.3049737811,
-0.4216411114,
0.6189755797,
-0.0500131138,
-0.2550092936,
-0.2035386562,
-0.4410682023,
0.0380848013,
0.0780691728,
0.1617050171,
0.2698238194,
0.1845502108,
0.251011014,
0.2282847166,
-0.3496163487,
-0.3756818771,
-0.2733490467,
0.736048162,
0.2927663922,
-0.1301018894,
-0.1023955271,
0.4662855864,
0.3360426128,
-0.185471192,
0.3605814874,
-0.024039967,
-0.137043789,
0.0023548906,
-0.4594335556,
-0.1038210765,
-0.5454828143,
0.1650626212,
-0.470315963,
-0.4737257957,
0.1678665429,
0.0751850456,
0.1058036685,
0.2853571475,
0.2361062169,
0.1774956584,
1.0814625025,
0.7633734941,
-0.3641888797,
0.8345865011,
0.2184141874,
-0.1587175578,
-0.7581216693,
0.2382970899,
-0.6746587753,
-0.7363444567,
-0.6875966191,
-0.0102702687,
0.032899797,
0.1806429774,
-0.4485386312,
0.2154287845,
-0.8958930373,
0.4979918897,
0.812422812,
0.2746012807,
0.467707932,
0.0657214597,
-0.154791519,
-0.1460748911,
-0.4231987298,
-0.4764836133,
0.9646751285,
0.1896868944,
0.6665805578,
-0.0535417087,
0.7902925014,
0.0944598541,
-0.0840056613,
-0.8753579855,
0.2839595973,
-0.4630261958,
-0.6810878515,
-0.529956162,
-0.3620813787,
-0.9631585479,
0.1576462984,
0.0532829314,
-0.746196568,
0.7935878038,
0.3262367845,
-0.4254280627,
0.154243201,
-0.721726656,
0.7824642658,
-0.5277913809,
-0.6636815071,
-0.0209410917,
-0.6785565615,
0.0543399751,
0.0833792984,
0.068268843,
-0.5270781517,
-0.4109957218,
0.3462742269,
-0.1694813669,
0.7318271399,
-0.3286260664,
-0.0965702459,
-0.1596991867,
0.0722232834,
0.669775486,
-0.0547152683,
-0.5375216007,
-0.1339042336,
-0.2140300125,
-0.5391089916,
-0.477373302,
0.9570574164,
-0.9488806129,
-0.7642618418,
-0.4101423621,
-0.3428245485,
-0.4363274276,
0.421441108,
0.1834035814,
-0.1238819882,
-0.2894994318,
-0.3095395863,
0.4415110648,
-0.276892066,
0.446359694,
0.5712769628,
0.0621035062,
-0.5577988625,
0.5439628959,
-0.2447713315,
0.701222837,
0.8430229425,
0.6161902547,
-0.22300753,
-0.3942610323,
-0.5684147477,
0.1213311702,
-0.3954977691,
-0.0342780203,
-0.3866845071,
0.4738200009,
-0.3380483091,
-0.3783084154,
-0.5139182806,
-0.4167813957,
-0.0493814684,
-0.0047760815,
0.2916093171,
0.2407589108,
-0.1073012426,
0.1670044065,
-0.3278532624,
0.4150252938,
0.4915029407,
0.7251040936,
-0.2544555068,
-0.3117089868,
0.3075515628,
0.3157683015,
-0.5172761083,
-0.7962424755,
0.275166899,
0.1824656278,
0.6534994245,
0.6832613349,
0.5230585933,
0.6484444141,
-0.5423550606,
0.2603811324,
0.2428562194,
-0.8592745066,
0.7282348871,
-0.42915833,
0.1036651433,
0.8782591224,
0.8590457439,
-0.5476080775,
0.0696509778,
-0.2609294951,
-0.8442669511,
0.7631918192,
0.0095761465,
0.3252362311,
-0.0890029296,
0.5740110278,
0.4879019558,
0.2964794934,
-0.3975035548,
-0.4015671909,
-0.1072399095,
0.0860637203,
-0.1048291028,
-0.4301388562,
-0.397878319,
-0.0167992227,
0.4642454684,
-0.1788038909,
0.225027591,
0.1793716401,
0.2967709005,
-0.5129916668,
0.2720963657,
0.7156536579,
0.5617646575,
-0.7673386335,
0.0089206388,
-0.3202485144,
-0.4530002177,
0.3718046248,
0.255875349,
-0.3292476535,
-0.266441375,
-0.12809515,
0.9402316809,
0.078960605,
-0.4228114486,
0.4125844538,
0.0580278225,
0.0153125357,
0.1873476356,
0.0905762017,
-0.2461870015,
-0.1793975234,
0.3401300907,
-0.0270421784,
0.267342329,
-0.5520048738,
0.029628247,
0.4970267713,
-0.5415183902,
-0.1907292157,
0.5065842271,
0.5496537089,
-0.3160479665,
0.2626262903,
-0.0088882186,
-0.3515002429,
0.625916481,
0.4558673799,
0.7710452676,
-0.2907840312,
-0.0191178471,
0.4589716494,
-0.1021187529,
-0.0090933656,
0.0023986485,
-0.1468905509,
-1.0864276886,
-0.4506646991,
-0.6348264217,
-0.5313563347,
-0.0923952237,
-0.8793405294,
0.4915730357,
-0.4801600575,
-0.1621452272,
0.3157716691,
0.0673731193,
-0.4805105329,
0.104499422,
-0.0384889841,
0.6273959875,
-0.7364282608,
0.8299635649,
0.8113489151,
-0.1264248788,
-0.4471478462,
0.1576039493,
-0.1318864226,
-1.236880064,
0.7070057392,
0.0890768319,
-0.0576253906,
-0.0061495728,
-0.0821181312,
-0.8910982609,
0.705163002,
0.5298358798,
-0.8270270824,
-0.0062992442,
0.069265984,
0.4224203229,
-0.2363142222,
0.1307378262,
0.6604737639,
0.3534031212,
0.2980743945,
-1.0726826191,
0.1937490553,
0.0642146766,
0.0737194791,
0.5632825494,
-0.8610432744,
0.5135017037,
-0.110106647,
-0.1065198332,
-0.0448930301,
0.0355961733,
0.162966311,
0.0025469817,
0.813465178,
0.5224506855,
0.4548273087,
-0.1326746494,
1.1422277689,
-0.2742647529,
0.2458052635,
1.1979403496,
-0.4529082775,
0.8146256804,
0.8161259294,
-0.2813815176,
0.0590941198,
0.7795932889,
0.3607888222,
1.0075831413,
0.1749611497,
-0.1441227198,
-0.1651624441,
-0.1625338942,
-0.4225725532,
0.5182138085,
-0.0119949924,
-0.3403035104,
0.050632596,
-0.2261655927,
-0.0177967176,
0.3746256232,
-0.1995996684,
0.9829801917,
-0.2095244229,
-1.1751030684,
0.7648117542,
-0.2487415671,
0.8181760311,
-0.5566402674,
0.1558454633,
-0.5037334561,
0.4827476144,
-0.1196566969,
-0.765486598,
0.2530195713,
-0.3322835565,
-0.2247112244,
-0.3130293489,
0.5120199323,
-0.2085850686,
-0.3049872816,
0.4506041408,
-0.0718971044,
-0.4405165315,
-0.1823713779,
-0.4000495374,
0.076283291,
0.0419431478,
-0.2720872164,
0.4023626447,
0.5081962943,
0.1907870919,
0.4828522205,
0.5574796796,
0.2195105851,
-0.1863627285,
-0.1798918247,
0.9342027903,
-0.3030706644,
-0.6029183269,
-1.10970819,
0.4114476144,
-0.2085609734,
-0.4813639224,
0.5220100284,
0.5565885305,
0.6881914735,
-0.0826905593,
0.6303218007,
-0.1029919386,
0.4698003829,
-0.3364729583,
0.0532751158,
-0.5777816772,
0.1854948252,
-0.5951681137,
-1.0556607246,
-0.3035488129,
0.7127845287,
-0.7636014223,
-0.2797625065,
0.3531219661,
0.5702153444,
0.005288708,
-0.2502714694,
0.2558988035,
-0.1967627108,
0.2091212273,
0.6904928088,
0.6266465187,
-0.005187883,
0.4572357833,
-0.7125447392,
-0.5560240746,
-0.3214601576,
-1.2007497549,
-0.5169528127,
-0.2058339119,
-0.1092964038,
-0.0425126664,
0.1663574725,
0.9209575057,
0.7243579626,
-0.69890064,
-0.1629226953,
-0.3204150796,
0.3332648277,
-0.4302786589,
-0.1540799886,
0.2440846413,
-0.2752985358,
-1.3454521894,
-0.0057411031,
0.3239923418,
0.0781265572,
0.054249756,
-0.0975493193,
-0.2490246743,
-0.015843844,
0.2499021441,
0.397008419,
-0.6234602928,
-0.5356696248,
0.2634387314,
-0.1227224618,
0.4111265838,
0.7068698406,
-0.3238146007,
0.9063073397,
0.4742740095,
0.4513522089,
0.4059598446,
0.2776100636,
1.0082262754,
-0.9344558716,
0.5310053825,
0.2952991128,
0.1537215859,
0.1015534177,
-0.5845068097,
0.3619235158,
0.1068942994,
-0.6314707994,
-0.624812901,
0.4949423075,
-1.2218830585,
-0.2507218122,
1.3883669376,
0.0333497934,
0.059531305,
0.2039246559,
-0.4885273874,
0.1221764311,
-0.851396203,
1.0519394875,
0.5946426392,
-0.301785171,
0.2692819834,
-0.1967098862,
0.6121611595,
0.6256622076,
-0.4363131523,
0.0490801968,
0.4526910186,
0.3845496774,
0.240109846,
0.5896008611,
0.203225553,
-0.0011335235,
-0.1061416343,
0.118929863,
-0.1339138597,
0.102320388,
-0.3671776056,
0.0175483283,
0.3118864,
-0.803188324
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10567v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10567v4
|
InSaAF: Incorporating Safety through Accuracy and Fairness | Are LLMs ready for the Indian Legal Domain?
| 2024-02-16T10:54:10 | 2024-06-17T17:46:07 |
Yogesh Tripathi, Raghav Donakanti, Sahil Girhepuje, Ishan Kavathekar, Bhaskara Hanuma Vedula, Gokul S Krishnan, Shreya Goyal, Anmol Goel, Balaraman Ravindran, Ponnurangam Kumaraguru
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent advancements in language technology and Artificial Intelligence have
resulted in numerous Language Models being proposed to perform various tasks in
the legal domain ranging from predicting judgments to generating summaries.
Despite their immense potential, these models have been proven to learn and
exhibit societal biases and make unfair predictions. In this study, we explore
the ability of Large Language Models (LLMs) to perform legal tasks in the
Indian landscape when social factors are involved. We present a novel metric,
$\beta$-weighted $\textit{Legal Safety Score ($LSS_{\beta}$)}$, which
encapsulates both the fairness and accuracy aspects of the LLM. We assess LLMs'
safety by considering its performance in the $\textit{Binary Statutory
Reasoning}$ task and its fairness exhibition with respect to various axes of
disparities in the Indian society. Task performance and fairness scores of
LLaMA and LLaMA--2 models indicate that the proposed $LSS_{\beta}$ metric can
effectively determine the readiness of a model for safe usage in the legal
sector. We also propose finetuning pipelines, utilising specialised legal
datasets, as a potential method to mitigate bias and improve model safety. The
finetuning procedures on LLaMA and LLaMA--2 models increase the $LSS_{\beta}$,
improving their usability in the Indian legal domain. Our code is publicly
released.
|
[
0.0810549855,
-0.5355045795,
0.4876441956,
0.3218125701,
-0.4950526953,
0.1142164543,
-0.0601878539,
-0.5631272793,
-0.1915525496,
0.3995358348,
0.0866578966,
-0.561367929,
-0.7541065812,
-0.0256196856,
-0.7532314658,
0.8721126318,
0.182024315,
0.2017948478,
-0.3353659213,
-0.3332583308,
-0.6141026616,
-0.7487533092,
-0.4740764201,
-0.3476830721,
0.0621231869,
0.1105136424,
0.7812618613,
0.7645936012,
0.5594946146,
0.2734906375,
-0.1876149774,
-0.2089414746,
-0.1988863349,
0.2330024689,
-0.3009688854,
-0.7237908244,
-0.4376286268,
-0.0176586788,
0.7145990133,
0.4558299482,
-0.6227151155,
0.1747580022,
0.0380962752,
0.5158619881,
-0.69781214,
0.3109532893,
-0.711540699,
-0.0812084973,
-0.3750114143,
0.0506564714,
-0.2692143321,
-0.5827019811,
-0.3555488586,
-0.2457669973,
-0.237420857,
0.3763507605,
0.8373004198,
0.6853441596,
-0.5588408113,
-0.412337631,
-0.4607725441,
0.6650066376,
-0.9102293849,
0.2232786566,
0.4601137042,
0.6120980978,
-0.1614510119,
-0.5944695473,
-0.5001395345,
-0.2619432807,
0.0857018828,
-0.140663594,
0.0449438766,
0.0347336642,
0.2904149294,
0.1056154519,
0.0048571168,
0.4276444912,
-0.4060680866,
-0.2973814607,
0.9773991108,
0.3267183304,
0.2920795083,
-0.2527367473,
-0.0229056273,
0.1143912673,
-0.8751990795,
0.2128411829,
0.5638774037,
0.4672952294,
-0.4713678658,
0.636199832,
-0.1810297519,
0.3533314168,
-0.0242856499,
-0.4312645197,
0.213348031,
-0.0590900593,
-0.2943634689,
0.2929939032,
0.6943064928,
0.3806211352,
0.6417432427,
-0.0381718464,
-0.4930942953,
0.1765086651,
0.0282637812,
-0.7183920741,
0.4371757507,
0.1441245675,
-0.6600299478,
-0.4546137154,
-0.1744892299,
-0.4965170026,
-0.6483507752,
-0.5089581013,
0.2536463141,
-0.1611798108,
-0.2827877104,
0.0241208337,
0.2900933623,
0.6671488881,
0.1174040958,
-0.7730500698,
0.2496278882,
1.0048595667,
0.6937665343,
0.204482466,
0.1138996854,
-0.886472702,
0.29896456,
-0.2774057388,
0.5879737139,
-0.6209436059,
-0.5374035239,
0.3095635176,
-0.2759791613,
0.298935324,
-0.3233557343,
0.6244232059,
-0.5613604188,
-0.4029183686,
-0.3093294501,
-0.4254321456,
-0.288749069,
0.2247925699,
-0.2204975784,
0.6117005944,
-0.2627968788,
-0.6980683804,
0.8322193027,
-0.6959241033,
-0.6552865505,
0.089969568,
-0.4984388053,
-0.2941623032,
-0.0500164554,
0.0666042715,
0.5575865507,
-0.3813861012,
0.6250033975,
-0.6930194497,
-0.5689920187,
0.2248681337,
-0.4692775905,
1.029640317,
0.4476211071,
-0.2408294678,
0.0690004528,
-0.6023697257,
-0.1120804623,
-0.2110678405,
-0.4011843204,
-0.3409979343,
0.0970917791,
-0.0951717496,
0.43327865,
0.0877990723,
-0.647974968,
-0.4495421648,
-0.3727998435,
0.4559735358,
1.0903674364,
-0.1947689354,
0.539729774,
-0.184392944,
0.5121434927,
-0.247883305,
0.3720782101,
0.3857484758,
-0.4418020844,
-0.5773937106,
-0.3713391125,
0.7511067986,
0.7717925906,
-0.2307437211,
0.2549506426,
-0.3961217999,
-0.3089592457,
-0.6689715385,
0.1009281203,
0.4822308421,
0.3561273217,
-0.2737593949,
-0.2091483772,
-0.2577073574,
-0.8047440648,
-0.411485225,
-0.2420704663,
0.1823233664,
0.0684792474,
0.4579083622,
-0.1135658696,
0.9770624042,
-0.0218360312,
-0.3340522349,
0.0946117416,
-0.2106700391,
0.1826886237,
0.3322924078,
0.5520985723,
-0.942056179,
-0.4879478514,
0.0159254987,
-1.2485715151,
-0.2120644152,
0.283634305,
-0.076828748,
0.3704284132,
0.7187233567,
-0.5684674978,
0.5500738025,
0.0726589039,
-0.5170852542,
0.3371098936,
-0.1767173558,
0.1397073865,
-0.8838415146,
-0.1814874858,
0.1353570968,
-0.4108140469,
-0.315987736,
0.4772365987,
0.0566528179,
0.0076847901,
-0.9369168282,
0.722779274,
-0.2039799392,
-0.2506801188,
-0.3028418422,
-0.0300675202,
-0.5729176998,
0.1624974459,
-0.3941731155,
0.7571147084,
0.8066025972,
-0.5733600259,
-0.063978456,
0.0575616173,
-0.1903016567,
0.9374701381,
-0.6638730168,
-0.015626248,
-0.3517615795,
-0.0980663374,
-0.4248623848,
-0.4637675881,
0.1921829581,
-0.2790546715,
0.2524747849,
-0.3364402652,
-0.755787015,
-0.0784029588,
-0.0997710451,
0.2029080093,
0.9220322371,
-0.2262676209,
0.8925665021,
0.9948703051,
-0.1008579135,
-0.9491800666,
-0.9352964759,
0.0338027291,
-0.5885370374,
-0.6815251708,
-0.2492212504,
0.1122968346,
-0.8343179822,
0.0126343891,
0.0102398535,
0.0713876411,
0.0816725343,
0.8890952468,
0.1723846942,
0.233676374,
0.0481279567,
0.3040229678,
-0.1368382722,
0.322933197,
0.2497300506,
0.2050541192,
-0.3410179019,
-0.5625742078,
-0.2379654944,
0.3214080036,
0.5551973581,
-0.2081306875,
0.6041859984,
0.331060499,
-0.7658590674,
0.1233757213,
-0.7099069357,
0.1192832291,
-0.5311873555,
0.1098779589,
-0.1323705614,
-0.9943522811,
0.5579226017,
0.0910772383,
0.3525330126,
0.4227550626,
0.6698394418,
-0.0915327445,
0.946151793,
0.8737927079,
0.0603786558,
0.1611557007,
0.2151529491,
0.4957110584,
-0.4445854425,
-0.4097729325,
-0.6804445386,
-0.0373688154,
-0.7712186575,
-0.2111494541,
0.5928955078,
-0.0577214919,
-0.6482361555,
-0.2058816552,
-0.2477054298,
0.6408282518,
0.5427624583,
0.0343049765,
0.3983493149,
0.2179248631,
-0.190517813,
0.0077927122,
-0.3734072745,
-0.9186325073,
1.3477131128,
0.4770816863,
0.8100277781,
0.0874147937,
0.7379245758,
0.5896384716,
0.6437308788,
-0.5263037682,
0.7843247056,
-0.487491399,
-0.7969892621,
-0.1920392215,
-0.193180874,
-0.5648487806,
0.1312520355,
-0.4427243173,
-0.4660063684,
0.1597149372,
0.1250494868,
-0.4975855947,
0.2918666601,
-0.6336644888,
0.3046982586,
-0.3483964503,
-0.3965410888,
-0.5471867919,
-0.7630948424,
0.619889617,
-0.304820776,
0.7561035156,
-0.5876520276,
-0.0752345398,
0.6783753037,
-0.5584520102,
0.8561572433,
-0.3798847795,
0.0851609409,
0.5622891784,
0.1450179219,
0.3394790888,
0.2762788534,
-0.5040161014,
0.4232530594,
-0.0121137155,
-0.3249117732,
-0.2388971597,
0.8158065677,
-0.6133288741,
-0.6930099726,
-0.8123942614,
-0.5823436975,
-0.1794366539,
0.2200348228,
-0.2618596554,
0.0699651018,
0.2161075473,
0.0512845181,
0.4929438233,
0.0196218453,
0.7547986507,
0.5048030615,
-0.0299155265,
-0.0532024838,
0.5012492537,
0.1664033383,
-0.0200824961,
-0.080040358,
-0.030407507,
-0.6868454218,
-0.7818356752,
-0.2339642495,
0.2225319445,
-1.0785446167,
-0.4502013922,
-0.6082818508,
-0.3789002597,
-0.1703373492,
-0.1869734377,
-0.0748026147,
-0.2243896127,
0.1351138204,
-0.1412408054,
0.4352107942,
0.8123616576,
-0.3575024903,
0.0681015775,
-0.6725383401,
0.0428075418,
0.4399873316,
0.6721405387,
-0.1240337491,
-0.5991688967,
0.0997612998,
0.0391738191,
0.0858081207,
-0.2391130179,
0.1381863058,
-0.1994433105,
0.6619079113,
0.1581436992,
0.0290599242,
0.3654027879,
-0.5699515939,
0.5213862062,
0.1926549375,
-0.8642295003,
0.3532544076,
-0.3263129592,
-0.2180080265,
0.5844651461,
0.2144507319,
-0.1664808691,
-0.504088521,
-0.1723199338,
-0.7556831837,
0.3151753843,
0.2348505706,
0.4584730268,
0.1180029884,
0.6380274296,
0.1889624,
0.1824502498,
-0.7759877443,
0.2119097412,
0.103920266,
-0.3905992806,
0.3251822293,
-0.1167209297,
-0.1799871773,
-0.1776343137,
0.5612959862,
0.0556343123,
-0.1928641796,
-0.155388236,
-0.1581990421,
-0.0561059006,
0.419906795,
0.2615967691,
0.7425661683,
-0.1392233968,
-0.1239682138,
0.3321023285,
-0.5928736329,
0.4451630414,
0.0918236226,
-0.3274638951,
-0.3676552176,
0.0559634864,
0.3451788723,
-0.0820162967,
-0.8020487428,
0.4498753548,
-0.1388287842,
0.0070876987,
-0.5120514631,
0.2563263178,
-0.0095365075,
0.462027967,
0.3042320013,
0.266043365,
0.1379587352,
-0.4615950882,
0.0047345152,
0.5020154715,
-0.369748652,
0.2312330455,
1.0841025114,
0.4403747916,
-0.533649087,
0.4571943879,
-0.2873513401,
-0.0698092207,
0.564355135,
0.1096498966,
0.627620697,
0.1503778547,
-0.1941620111,
0.1692771614,
0.3700852394,
-0.3336799145,
0.1731437594,
0.3009395599,
-0.3679613769,
-0.4799128771,
-0.9484701753,
-0.1216621995,
-0.3264397979,
-0.1849681735,
0.3877521753,
-0.7182516456,
-0.4262343645,
-0.4216951132,
-0.2425789535,
-0.7230120301,
0.2935352921,
0.3056507111,
0.9222857952,
-0.8771591187,
0.5755777359,
0.4960097075,
-0.5251310468,
-0.8664512038,
0.0339903943,
0.1306156218,
-0.7398567796,
0.6142237186,
0.006364292,
-0.2698297501,
-0.4293619692,
-0.6215906739,
-0.7308821678,
1.1091916561,
0.723731339,
-0.8007616401,
-0.0396521538,
0.3889688849,
0.5478766561,
-0.3863690197,
0.0024370404,
0.6705327034,
0.2875531316,
-0.2087727189,
-1.1056027412,
0.2587587237,
-0.1749791354,
0.1278151274,
-0.0329527818,
-0.735630095,
0.695840776,
-0.4017579854,
-0.0883006752,
-0.2097689956,
0.6997358799,
0.6566683054,
0.4345299006,
0.7193944454,
0.5062448978,
0.8111150861,
-0.1783903837,
1.3719297647,
-0.2201975584,
0.0019394078,
0.7835403085,
-0.5532391071,
0.8028120399,
0.4255367219,
-0.186634168,
0.3105912209,
0.5743011832,
0.3050793409,
0.434106946,
0.2191194445,
-0.1332201809,
-0.4878662229,
-0.2732437849,
-0.3038173318,
0.6558764577,
0.3608487844,
-0.0696495771,
-0.0235183463,
-0.0210925806,
0.1912573278,
0.4297339022,
-0.6254125834,
0.4357064962,
0.4938148558,
-0.509358108,
0.1637404263,
0.129404068,
0.9718164206,
-0.3711594939,
-0.0455376133,
-0.2364600897,
0.1272504032,
-0.1861528605,
-1.2196143866,
0.377420485,
0.2742236853,
0.0180527214,
-0.0307196267,
0.8406690359,
-0.0934672281,
-0.6931698322,
0.3313094079,
0.3381466568,
0.1984523237,
0.2516798973,
-0.5775876641,
0.1302969307,
-0.4103956223,
0.3856087029,
0.4422511458,
0.3840380311,
-0.5539923906,
0.9635717273,
0.4487509131,
0.096322909,
0.3650802076,
0.1927248687,
0.4860727787,
-0.4132413864,
-0.7987201214,
-0.8181639314,
0.6384754777,
-0.3014136553,
0.054529313,
0.4615858197,
0.298579663,
0.6620898843,
0.0445363596,
0.7858404517,
-0.2520116866,
0.3237306476,
-0.6296690702,
1.1668807268,
-0.4810201526,
0.4174325466,
-0.0861791,
-0.8208239079,
-0.3017877042,
0.1725883037,
-0.2290176898,
0.2254516929,
0.2841121256,
0.9140959382,
-0.1424815059,
-0.0485650524,
0.1858710498,
-0.0167227592,
0.3575552702,
0.4025867581,
0.6254306436,
-0.3044235706,
0.6849969029,
-0.0697391331,
-0.2307739258,
-0.1414663792,
-1.1056975126,
-0.9020349383,
-0.1354581118,
-0.2202841789,
-0.4126316905,
0.4275268316,
0.9266893864,
0.9441149831,
-0.8328346014,
-0.4129663408,
0.1958279759,
0.0682018697,
0.3572028279,
-0.1670916528,
0.2184495479,
-0.2939770222,
-0.5339251757,
-0.1055383757,
0.3377374411,
-0.033645913,
-0.1390592903,
-0.3868074119,
-0.2050926685,
0.2488843501,
0.6602914929,
0.2386548817,
-0.6671026945,
-0.4288394153,
-0.5178822875,
-0.1937202811,
-0.1769548059,
0.5698167086,
-0.4491956532,
0.2553127408,
0.2711027563,
0.6040492654,
0.2140501738,
-0.2097444832,
0.4586580396,
-0.54441154,
0.4446479976,
0.1756147444,
0.6544120312,
0.5456402302,
-0.5396197438,
0.750120163,
-0.0218653753,
-0.6235828996,
-0.9454719424,
-0.0506756082,
-0.7042580843,
-0.0318016857,
1.2804217339,
0.0516749956,
-0.3017369509,
-0.1078190282,
0.0229619052,
0.4360328615,
-0.5304936171,
0.9917978048,
0.5889012218,
0.1196865886,
0.1983276755,
-0.7283502817,
0.5323139429,
0.2987366319,
-0.8582193255,
-0.2340548038,
0.4277061522,
0.7389830351,
-0.0580008328,
0.7781871557,
-0.5282604098,
0.5088991523,
-0.0855349004,
-0.1798945367,
-0.0999863967,
-0.0678762943,
-0.4657609761,
0.2634968162,
0.2689523399,
-0.0028691462
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10558v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10558v1
|
Neural paraphrasing by automatically crawled and aligned sentence pairs
| 2024-02-16T10:40:38 | 2024-02-16T10:40:38 |
Achille Globo, Antonio Trevisi, Andrea Zugarini, Leonardo Rigutini, Marco Maggini, Stefano Melacci
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Paraphrasing is the task of re-writing an input text using other words,
without altering the meaning of the original content. Conversational systems
can exploit automatic paraphrasing to make the conversation more natural, e.g.,
talking about a certain topic using different paraphrases in different time
instants. Recently, the task of automatically generating paraphrases has been
approached in the context of Natural Language Generation (NLG). While many
existing systems simply consist in rule-based models, the recent success of the
Deep Neural Networks in several NLG tasks naturally suggests the possibility of
exploiting such networks for generating paraphrases. However, the main obstacle
toward neural-network-based paraphrasing is the lack of large datasets with
aligned pairs of sentences and paraphrases, that are needed to efficiently
train the neural models. In this paper we present a method for the automatic
generation of large aligned corpora, that is based on the assumption that news
and blog websites talk about the same events using different narrative styles.
We propose a similarity search procedure with linguistic constraints that,
given a reference sentence, is able to locate the most similar candidate
paraphrases out from millions of indexed sentences. The data generation process
is evaluated in the case of the Italian language, performing experiments using
pointer-based deep neural architectures.
|
[
-0.1496727616,
-0.6502302885,
0.6120368838,
0.1799880415,
-0.4815509021,
-0.2354462147,
-0.1188229695,
-0.0844009891,
0.4533436596,
0.479170084,
-0.5335999727,
-0.5989175439,
-0.141904369,
0.3238337338,
-0.7293043733,
0.9759092927,
-0.0440518223,
0.0388146676,
-0.3787050843,
-0.1795133352,
-0.1304100007,
-0.3361192644,
-0.5520405769,
-0.110693492,
0.492112577,
0.0938981324,
0.8841292858,
0.944848299,
0.62785393,
0.3137423694,
-0.051239159,
0.3797181249,
-0.1703564078,
0.4491949677,
-0.2816857696,
-0.1937416494,
0.0890343785,
-0.0861369446,
0.6726025939,
0.6252102256,
-0.0945489779,
0.1039077789,
0.367217809,
0.4335514605,
-0.4714444876,
-0.002068022,
-0.8094888926,
0.1546956599,
-0.0254615359,
-0.4689658284,
-0.0476943515,
-0.7768847346,
0.1668905765,
-0.5410032272,
0.3800463378,
0.0007992142,
0.8486419916,
0.293469727,
0.0160369687,
-0.5972002745,
-0.2171210647,
0.5370617509,
-1.0057343245,
0.050854899,
0.0971145034,
-0.2065401226,
-0.1407181919,
-1.0149686337,
-0.6273190379,
-0.25036484,
-0.3296182156,
-0.1816660911,
0.0836340263,
-0.2391088754,
-0.0056557017,
-0.0363569334,
-0.7511561513,
-0.1323724091,
-0.2680104971,
-0.0249705222,
0.5280868411,
0.1918253005,
0.3907827437,
-0.6164126992,
-0.4854394197,
-0.1163278222,
-0.6956775784,
-0.3596488237,
0.5425661206,
0.1932222247,
0.3114371598,
0.5565623045,
-0.3994377255,
0.7101206779,
0.1908709854,
0.1348650604,
0.2059158683,
-0.5713567138,
-0.0501060672,
0.3455818295,
1.0835534334,
0.7889666557,
0.3638242483,
-0.4725809991,
-0.0604645573,
-0.0539269075,
0.3855893016,
-0.4923242629,
-0.1617438942,
-0.2630955279,
-0.4462762177,
-0.3968699872,
-0.0215559453,
-1.1083220243,
-0.0686428025,
-0.5719081759,
0.3387115896,
-0.5449398756,
0.3690451384,
-0.1271144003,
-0.3022206724,
0.3559265733,
-0.3144261241,
-0.7113937736,
0.307063669,
0.8157010674,
1.0098065138,
-0.3150154352,
-0.5583681464,
-0.6414573789,
0.2820224762,
-0.3200823069,
0.6306344867,
-0.5470041633,
0.016295569,
0.1176179424,
-0.2377295345,
-0.3110758662,
-0.4777332246,
0.6782653332,
-0.5331753492,
0.3330318034,
-0.0222743265,
-0.6559216976,
0.1450029165,
0.279701978,
-0.360789746,
0.8342772126,
-0.3974894881,
-0.8269453049,
-0.0986377448,
-0.2543679774,
-0.5680450201,
-0.0402134396,
-0.3223860264,
-0.4089592993,
0.1414569616,
0.3854115903,
0.570045948,
-0.2102317661,
0.6128070951,
-0.2381326109,
-0.243294239,
0.140862748,
-0.2025842071,
0.8245712519,
0.2545738518,
-0.6240296364,
-0.11630404,
-0.7204544544,
0.0925585628,
0.0030198055,
-0.1562245637,
-0.6359223127,
0.1321197152,
-0.1009661928,
0.2231128365,
0.4646873772,
-0.448941946,
-0.1173145175,
-0.5666475296,
0.7405999899,
0.4301064312,
0.2996032834,
0.4418604374,
-0.4618056715,
0.302958101,
-0.1931347251,
-0.1426597983,
-0.1805482805,
-0.2113227844,
-0.5434877872,
0.425955683,
0.263821125,
0.464926213,
-0.6760449409,
0.6628433466,
-0.6068224311,
-0.3858690858,
-0.6232550144,
0.4962549806,
0.4926376939,
0.8213601112,
0.4215976596,
0.0068407306,
-0.5269731283,
-1.0791202784,
-0.3453653157,
0.1601114422,
0.0414993614,
-0.0574615076,
0.151887998,
0.2175175399,
0.7097719312,
-0.4137316942,
-0.1187248752,
0.0655417293,
0.2455606461,
-0.093218267,
0.597843349,
0.4291751981,
-1.1081850529,
-0.5604401231,
-0.1674585044,
-0.9930685163,
-0.0902884826,
-0.3545747995,
-0.2195205092,
-0.0891113877,
1.2058776617,
-0.7229603529,
0.0682965294,
0.3643830419,
0.0732504129,
0.3077842891,
-0.2659839094,
0.0192668885,
-1.540817976,
0.1722156107,
0.1134922579,
-0.0618982241,
-0.2780435085,
0.4455008209,
-0.0715499073,
-0.1037984863,
-0.3734253049,
0.2356911749,
-0.5645783544,
-0.0124505265,
-0.4498284757,
0.6179427505,
0.099038735,
0.5517356396,
0.1066127494,
0.6613452435,
0.4261725545,
-0.5120978951,
0.5798462629,
0.5305172801,
-0.3546175659,
0.5154313445,
-0.6440665126,
0.1402974427,
-0.2134701461,
0.1997491568,
-0.9101959467,
-0.0508141443,
0.0832896009,
-0.4047405422,
-0.0537589751,
0.0418892838,
-0.4153697193,
-0.1126169562,
-0.289378196,
0.2972078919,
0.4101149142,
-0.5326210856,
0.1665729433,
0.0950011835,
-0.6397746801,
-0.490064621,
-0.5106487274,
0.6704446673,
-0.6186298132,
-0.5033735633,
0.5110354424,
0.0710153654,
-0.2580972016,
0.0958077535,
0.1617931724,
-0.0661357716,
-0.0456810147,
0.001631108,
0.0649559423,
-0.38872841,
0.1372548789,
-0.0206069462,
0.1178664118,
0.1832018048,
-0.492638588,
0.7646450996,
0.0141016189,
-0.1227937862,
-0.5646319389,
0.685013473,
0.5385355949,
-0.3604796231,
0.52430439,
0.4624662697,
-0.2712082863,
0.033304479,
-0.4251270592,
-0.1064626724,
-0.4569872618,
0.0918581113,
-0.2463956326,
-0.3058368564,
0.2409031838,
0.1082386523,
0.0867816284,
0.5059213638,
0.4093740582,
-0.2481423169,
0.8232742548,
0.0853818581,
-0.0628467053,
0.2441278845,
0.1399990618,
0.1803630888,
-0.685274303,
-0.2173109949,
-0.5352329612,
-0.8338535428,
-0.5701172948,
-0.2194715887,
0.1327691525,
-0.026805114,
0.1141906753,
0.619958818,
-0.5723647475,
0.4505979419,
1.1821880341,
0.289536953,
0.246943295,
0.0693860799,
-0.2814408839,
0.0529704578,
-0.6340184808,
-0.6213007569,
0.9807716012,
-0.3783406317,
0.4879485965,
-0.3113404512,
1.0994386673,
0.0274166465,
-0.2454408109,
-0.4759375155,
0.7234047651,
-0.2587034702,
-0.272051841,
-0.1440214664,
-0.3163165748,
-0.9243997335,
-0.3202046752,
-0.0135929454,
-0.5341407657,
0.2189066112,
-0.0385647714,
-0.5834538937,
0.1718300879,
-0.466622144,
0.763943553,
-0.1829481125,
-0.3422657549,
-0.1328762323,
-1.0216801167,
-0.041000925,
0.0561430044,
-0.3197910786,
0.1787751317,
-0.0748262703,
0.8809964657,
-0.2335285246,
0.6551846862,
0.093945995,
0.2403303981,
0.5524820089,
0.0885030702,
0.442887187,
-0.0602353588,
-0.2158113718,
-0.1690834761,
-0.0714271441,
-0.292401582,
-0.5300269723,
1.1561465263,
-0.3642890155,
-0.6560075879,
-0.0933155343,
-0.5625139475,
-0.1698008329,
0.1708067656,
0.5628246069,
0.409507364,
-0.3446805179,
0.452691853,
0.4787742794,
0.0774801448,
0.7910827994,
-0.1522693485,
0.2834565938,
-0.4070425332,
0.7744034529,
-0.2074028552,
0.131022349,
0.6125398874,
0.0365316272,
-0.2525119185,
-0.6577912569,
-0.2807365656,
0.2192382216,
-0.3028879166,
-0.4301609993,
-0.7919790745,
-0.3047188818,
-0.6414211988,
-0.4064067304,
-0.1121508107,
-0.4523492157,
-0.3462407291,
-0.1217505112,
0.1663377732,
0.3507147729,
-0.096564211,
0.4504770339,
-0.8547997475,
0.4355297089,
0.3248923123,
-0.0470842794,
-0.1153599992,
-0.2172016501,
-0.0034852109,
0.3525766432,
-0.5411980748,
-0.8252276182,
0.6846576333,
0.2810151577,
0.3493199944,
0.3547754288,
0.004655113,
0.7355099916,
-0.9146183133,
0.5625086427,
0.1695117503,
-0.800231576,
0.586779952,
-0.55545789,
0.0979247168,
0.83050704,
0.6514536738,
-0.4769195616,
-0.4036463797,
-0.8557134867,
-0.8187305927,
0.2758821547,
0.2503051162,
0.3485530913,
-0.4469295144,
0.5740197301,
0.1172897369,
0.3359971642,
-0.7638652921,
0.0508753136,
-0.020206023,
-0.7712119818,
-0.2456260473,
0.0884133577,
-0.2550927401,
0.0559801161,
0.4542051554,
-0.14509435,
0.1840683967,
0.4188649058,
-0.2320588976,
0.076795429,
0.1050976664,
0.362123847,
0.6182607412,
0.0682329834,
0.3090476692,
0.0431995466,
0.0819308311,
0.1024067476,
0.4459130764,
-0.369034797,
0.4075419009,
0.1834188104,
0.6317014694,
0.3731016517,
-0.7620865703,
0.4105326831,
0.2413281649,
-0.304551214,
-0.1963573396,
0.0082189161,
0.5150081515,
0.4614494145,
0.2684913278,
0.0792093351,
0.2358051986,
-0.5691382289,
0.5774842501,
0.397081852,
-0.2365469784,
-0.1304841191,
0.6985930204,
0.0850247741,
-0.7167935371,
0.8413934112,
0.0260603074,
-0.3699679077,
0.6276455522,
0.6311371922,
0.8364678025,
-0.1040159613,
0.2749898136,
0.3337718248,
-0.0901604593,
-0.2183227688,
-0.2294363678,
-0.0472935103,
-0.5217552185,
-0.2444186509,
-0.7594912052,
-0.0435249247,
0.1498402059,
-0.7093111277,
0.2496057451,
-0.3939004838,
0.1573155671,
0.1381076872,
-0.4196224511,
-0.3868459761,
0.1941594929,
0.3134646416,
0.5862580538,
-0.699385643,
0.5457222462,
0.6932257414,
-0.1605288386,
-0.5672855973,
0.3479383886,
-0.3453695774,
-0.9307204485,
0.6306656003,
0.2348339707,
0.0990033895,
0.122467123,
-0.399720192,
-0.6924276352,
0.9399368763,
0.3694136441,
-0.5746323466,
-0.9051671624,
0.1464387178,
0.7780234218,
-0.4063058496,
-0.3328150511,
0.3863887191,
0.1911113262,
-0.0849774331,
-0.7441932559,
0.06792631,
-0.221068278,
-0.1071843132,
0.261636883,
-0.5738822222,
0.7003660798,
0.1759339124,
0.1523628831,
0.4421872795,
0.7038811445,
-0.0587882847,
0.3006144166,
0.375734508,
0.8153207898,
0.3493464589,
0.1698390096,
0.7615490556,
-0.5090534091,
0.1691347361,
1.3352975845,
-0.1973584443,
0.9597626925,
0.6277179122,
0.3386293352,
0.4733464718,
0.3186395168,
-0.1207419857,
0.6966733932,
0.0881055221,
-0.1945649832,
-0.2846731842,
0.0575570092,
-0.0712246075,
0.5968650579,
0.1786006093,
-0.8269081712,
-0.5500127077,
0.0014629783,
-0.0258852877,
0.6441697478,
-0.2220819443,
1.0319575071,
0.118827939,
-1.2691400051,
0.46453017,
-0.110742189,
0.4420431256,
-0.3476314843,
0.0690253526,
-0.2503991425,
0.1422464997,
0.0171314236,
-0.6408687234,
0.5906397104,
0.0386264473,
0.0864098668,
-0.4934304655,
0.4183866978,
-0.5773011446,
-0.5531250834,
0.202236861,
0.4759856164,
0.0275081769,
-0.1184792519,
-0.7637867928,
-0.4946074784,
0.2258661687,
-0.1199465618,
0.2991161346,
0.4673830271,
0.1122178435,
0.4311300814,
0.4375949502,
-0.0008181178,
0.4156356454,
-0.4071322083,
0.6539444327,
-0.6725318432,
-0.550568521,
-1.0566056967,
-0.0158563368,
-0.3607888222,
-0.4075584114,
0.742092371,
0.7135375738,
0.4972975552,
0.1158729047,
0.5309375525,
-0.0646019503,
0.5504431129,
-0.5477882028,
0.4573330581,
-0.3756420314,
-0.2263746113,
-0.2505507767,
-1.1063165665,
-0.1525033116,
0.7743643522,
-0.203941375,
-0.3211972117,
0.7468424439,
0.8841525316,
-0.2887111008,
0.0867679939,
-0.0402841642,
0.0024053492,
-0.0247006062,
0.5739238262,
0.6035735011,
-0.4848977029,
1.0253776312,
-0.2635460496,
0.2865304351,
-0.1501084715,
-0.7786729336,
-0.7155754566,
-0.7773740888,
-0.4406748116,
-0.2647944987,
0.5137816072,
0.7521170378,
0.2804606557,
-0.6338884234,
-0.0315372199,
-0.6494227052,
-0.0999753103,
-0.1398403049,
-0.2251636386,
0.5287631154,
-0.6643887758,
-1.0873872042,
0.5455042124,
0.0182669777,
-0.1998238117,
0.073361814,
0.3077066839,
-0.8475978971,
-0.0963169783,
-0.0594377071,
0.1833888292,
-0.3444119394,
-0.2748109996,
-0.0458923355,
-0.3773741722,
0.2435928583,
0.7591959834,
-0.7629494071,
-0.0504667945,
0.5032442212,
0.9211220741,
0.3239250183,
0.2906023562,
0.9125235677,
-0.8926443458,
0.0370171219,
0.4453148246,
0.3837178648,
0.4513373971,
-0.1556189656,
0.1440179199,
0.0824360251,
-0.6099496484,
-0.4424690008,
-0.0326796286,
-0.8906883597,
-0.3385558128,
1.3042658567,
-0.1936427355,
-0.12218979,
0.1843458712,
-0.139175415,
0.4524669647,
-0.0411559194,
0.8361535072,
0.5886505842,
0.1617505252,
0.3160806,
-0.1511348635,
0.4860625267,
0.7161428332,
-0.5669697523,
-0.0447903611,
0.4834420979,
0.3202861547,
0.4381126761,
-0.0705836266,
0.0225520469,
0.2562068105,
-0.0569048859,
-0.1959642321,
0.0688042864,
-0.1441452205,
-0.1325534433,
0.5893096328,
-0.5119256973,
-0.3795858026
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10555v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10555v2
|
SPAR: Personalized Content-Based Recommendation via Long Engagement Attention
| 2024-02-16T10:36:38 | 2024-05-22T02:44:40 |
Chiyu Zhang, Yifei Sun, Jun Chen, Jie Lei, Muhammad Abdul-Mageed, Sinong Wang, Rong Jin, Sem Park, Ning Yao, Bo Long
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Leveraging users' long engagement histories is essential for personalized
content recommendations. The success of pretrained language models (PLMs) in
NLP has led to their use in encoding user histories and candidate items,
framing content recommendations as textual semantic matching tasks. However,
existing works still struggle with processing very long user historical text
and insufficient user-item interaction. In this paper, we introduce a
content-based recommendation framework, SPAR, which effectively tackles the
challenges of holistic user interest extraction from the long user engagement
history. It achieves so by leveraging PLM, poly-attention layers and attention
sparsity mechanisms to encode user's history in a session-based manner. The
user and item side features are sufficiently fused for engagement prediction
while maintaining standalone representations for both sides, which is efficient
for practical model deployment. Moreover, we enhance user profiling by
exploiting large language model (LLM) to extract global interests from user
engagement history. Extensive experiments on two benchmark datasets demonstrate
that our framework outperforms existing state-of-the-art (SoTA) methods.
|
[
-0.5174872279,
-0.6081901193,
0.5920193195,
0.1095658913,
-0.1303421408,
-0.0345383808,
-0.2653226256,
-0.044846002,
0.4521431923,
0.9749014974,
-0.73530972,
-0.6597073674,
-0.3158921599,
-0.1803515255,
-0.2609168291,
1.3956240416,
0.0145408316,
-0.4600220919,
-0.2358888984,
-0.219201833,
-0.9119157791,
-0.6953808069,
-0.6693770289,
-0.2621772885,
0.9135614038,
0.2999171019,
0.5330491066,
0.3910922706,
0.2793448865,
0.2083546072,
-0.2631830275,
0.3237571418,
-0.9274157286,
0.2562739253,
-0.4003276825,
-0.0205734763,
-0.3003108203,
-0.2971264422,
0.3118145764,
0.4238245785,
-0.1665609628,
0.0521263331,
0.1293558627,
0.9132897854,
-0.4892662764,
-0.1585524529,
-0.2367838472,
0.0176228341,
-0.3217489421,
-0.3873194456,
-0.5501331091,
-0.1720665544,
0.4811832011,
-0.6088021994,
0.2288639098,
0.2741738558,
0.5290774107,
-0.0679571629,
-0.4869687259,
-0.2682116926,
-0.875202179,
0.7810360193,
-0.2843595445,
0.5414196849,
0.7979143858,
0.2553371489,
-0.4603141844,
-0.5349878669,
-0.1709455103,
-0.2570032775,
-0.0607423112,
-0.0994907916,
-0.1315224469,
-0.1159397289,
0.2025317997,
0.3062004745,
-0.7682617307,
-0.2298454791,
-0.0803543106,
0.164266333,
0.581854105,
0.0987737849,
0.2722445726,
0.2671025395,
-0.7257939577,
0.0071566957,
-0.6330781579,
0.178897351,
0.3714800179,
0.0942059532,
-0.1991914958,
0.7018887997,
-0.1650325507,
0.5576351285,
0.5396896601,
0.1589459777,
-0.0455199033,
-0.2764162719,
0.0380211957,
0.1585225165,
0.7594445348,
0.3517702222,
0.4582830369,
-0.4023190141,
0.0591278113,
-0.2429921627,
0.2204492539,
-0.7865411043,
-0.006071772,
0.0834887847,
-0.2932768762,
0.3072851896,
0.3185352981,
-0.7678771615,
-0.6914131045,
-0.0550701693,
0.199743852,
-0.404683888,
-0.1357172281,
0.4332835078,
0.1481473595,
-0.3270441592,
0.108030431,
-1.0009852648,
0.4809537232,
0.9151714444,
0.7865943313,
-0.5465142727,
-0.3018954694,
-0.8695805669,
0.416950345,
0.0389827341,
0.9174187183,
-0.8531543612,
-0.3987975121,
0.3351674676,
0.1960784048,
0.198505789,
-0.4033750594,
0.3724199235,
-0.8827715516,
0.2889892459,
-0.2531299293,
-0.6697798371,
-0.2256397605,
0.0394781232,
-0.6065989137,
1.2497661114,
0.3205158114,
-0.5696717501,
0.4767683744,
-0.8100976944,
-0.5979071856,
0.3448662162,
0.1575582772,
-0.3412133455,
-0.0100149633,
0.2159114331,
0.6247895956,
-0.1617038399,
0.7139445543,
-0.5637339354,
-0.6127695441,
-0.0050444533,
-0.0751158521,
-0.021173792,
0.0019830903,
-0.1861576289,
0.4292568266,
-0.4429246783,
-0.6192137003,
-0.0864769891,
-0.1782185286,
-0.6335561275,
0.206989184,
0.2422653735,
0.1102173626,
0.4080176055,
-0.4308609664,
0.0438726097,
-0.7803167701,
0.245408088,
0.7251440883,
0.3273569047,
0.6123800874,
-0.2221483141,
0.4562409222,
-0.0196178928,
-0.2412310541,
-0.5900681615,
-0.0683544874,
-0.5116500854,
-0.0825868919,
0.2345168889,
0.1254291981,
-0.0881072208,
0.9071000218,
-0.3215735853,
-0.1312819123,
-0.1508515328,
0.5518929958,
0.0862561092,
0.0675853863,
0.3577130139,
-0.5597409606,
-0.5596287847,
-0.4533547759,
-0.2112838179,
-0.0184319094,
-0.0945752561,
0.8100947142,
-0.0486284159,
-0.5882006288,
1.0962178707,
-0.5504459143,
-0.8018163443,
-0.4720990956,
0.0357883722,
0.4010985196,
0.1549222022,
0.2099099755,
-0.6879466772,
-0.7803262472,
0.1588572562,
-0.2599551976,
0.2144411653,
-0.402382195,
-0.3974207044,
-0.0318783,
0.1976311356,
-0.4396605194,
0.4425522387,
0.3659901023,
-0.7283767462,
-0.0675397441,
-0.2236031592,
0.1228024065,
-1.2214282751,
0.1267743558,
0.6944648027,
-0.4638928175,
-0.3579406738,
-0.6269256473,
-0.0780609101,
-0.2710449994,
-0.291016072,
1.1158803701,
-0.2219857275,
0.0864382014,
-0.2949897945,
-0.010631646,
-0.1065846458,
0.6026459336,
0.3199034035,
0.4275503457,
0.0994775444,
-0.5532311797,
0.1295069307,
0.4705432355,
-0.2563762069,
0.4061459303,
-0.6924259067,
0.4029800594,
0.0806294829,
0.2906942964,
-1.118383646,
-0.1472633779,
0.0564791523,
-0.0871666744,
0.0876787156,
-0.5739811659,
-0.3014428318,
0.0243444443,
-0.5206865668,
0.3546215594,
0.2147407383,
-0.5407862067,
0.8126413226,
0.4161804616,
-0.3863682449,
-0.4762042165,
-0.0032598048,
0.1623603553,
-0.2613004446,
-0.5316664577,
0.6678350568,
-0.408052057,
0.3016324639,
-0.0036911785,
-0.145399332,
0.0392951481,
-0.1259150505,
0.6347239614,
0.1915259361,
-0.1531724036,
0.0610480048,
-0.1394196004,
-0.342402041,
-0.3326473534,
0.1370868832,
1.005048275,
0.1265670806,
-0.3549303412,
-0.5773379207,
0.6222984195,
0.4300584793,
-0.3864278197,
0.5418477654,
1.0065429211,
-0.1556102335,
-0.0369309112,
-1.1304059029,
-0.1829496026,
-0.4810688794,
0.5987111926,
-0.0739869624,
-1.501873374,
0.2557810247,
-0.0940648615,
0.0705002323,
0.2353469282,
0.7664476037,
-0.2246184498,
1.0412832499,
0.8069368005,
-0.5782482624,
0.9959814548,
-0.0769558623,
0.0875229836,
-0.8362973332,
-0.1795315593,
-0.0310063753,
-0.2481777072,
-0.1992907077,
0.0818982422,
0.0502453335,
-0.0546544529,
-0.2928482592,
0.1389776915,
-0.3270702958,
0.4898717105,
0.4410304427,
0.1943259537,
-0.0181090366,
-0.1100637764,
0.4946444333,
-0.2550590336,
-0.378362447,
-0.2190354913,
0.8660131097,
0.3746185899,
0.9345774055,
0.057018742,
0.6480308771,
0.9464871883,
0.0995896682,
-0.8528702259,
0.4055434465,
-0.1933993697,
-0.3709876239,
-0.2880273163,
-0.0618324392,
-1.2831406593,
-0.2231555879,
-0.3180419207,
-0.7547498941,
-0.0071671735,
0.2352913916,
-0.62516886,
-0.0453606732,
-0.5488595366,
1.1132341623,
-0.3948872387,
-0.6808241606,
-0.2954543233,
-0.3650605083,
-0.0730412006,
0.0301997457,
0.0372128487,
-0.2284720987,
0.1317801923,
0.7377348542,
0.1601861268,
0.9422137141,
-0.2364649624,
0.3601643741,
0.0091624642,
0.3495979309,
0.8214601874,
0.270483464,
0.0993112549,
-0.0962582454,
-0.1847043037,
0.0488706157,
-0.3775721192,
0.99454844,
-0.5320035815,
-0.7304688096,
-0.5154871345,
-0.386732012,
-0.1245313883,
0.3492043912,
-0.2729144692,
0.3060450554,
-0.5602830052,
0.6178284883,
0.8386824727,
-0.0470538922,
0.3992524445,
0.4833773971,
-0.1459404081,
-0.5580950379,
1.0349596739,
-0.2821899652,
-0.4803175628,
0.405118078,
0.1660439521,
-0.498146683,
-0.4875963032,
-0.3890816271,
0.3979936242,
-0.1689375043,
-0.0508620329,
-0.897980988,
0.2708560824,
-0.3101195395,
-0.4310132861,
-0.1878633797,
0.4733328521,
-0.6616315246,
0.1734316647,
0.2983182967,
0.6598728299,
0.5157067776,
0.3072986901,
-0.6650850773,
0.5417004824,
0.1186892316,
0.5654966831,
-0.226121977,
-0.4460044205,
-0.6746430993,
-0.3584665954,
-0.2632832527,
-0.6149021983,
0.6265223622,
0.3235303164,
0.7424146533,
0.6523185968,
0.2094740272,
0.6117464304,
-0.676135242,
0.7473303676,
0.2263320088,
-0.6850785613,
0.5364141464,
-0.3142506182,
0.3746894002,
0.6530868411,
0.6512182355,
-0.8924793005,
0.167086333,
-0.2521532178,
-1.0022118092,
0.6384376287,
-0.4712708294,
0.2894789875,
-0.0002851121,
0.4676179886,
0.3627827764,
-0.1307967603,
-0.629412353,
0.1287284791,
0.1605817825,
-0.3928547502,
-0.3185629249,
-0.7370544672,
0.0100264465,
0.2603954375,
0.7090271115,
-0.1065384373,
-0.2156599909,
0.1446774453,
-0.3164744079,
-0.2457826883,
0.1967826039,
0.2793207169,
0.6872064471,
-0.342893213,
-0.2795032561,
0.0096944654,
-0.2091400027,
0.1086141691,
0.1828324348,
0.170717299,
-0.1386717707,
-0.1221720874,
0.6962090135,
0.643912971,
-0.8336260319,
0.7795550227,
-0.2977679074,
0.2250716537,
-0.683303237,
0.0679167435,
0.2412738502,
0.2501933277,
0.2549577951,
-0.2189644128,
0.1976038963,
-0.4455453157,
0.2292829901,
0.4566518366,
-0.870251894,
-0.3167295456,
0.3782933652,
0.3707532287,
-0.4893256724,
0.1691180915,
0.3199792206,
-0.1510319412,
-0.2319226861,
0.5522353053,
0.8501275778,
-0.1539393216,
0.0749066025,
0.1757301837,
-0.3808315992,
-0.2890862226,
-0.289706707,
-0.4138034582,
-0.4504415393,
-0.5690982938,
-0.6558839083,
-0.3754675686,
0.2279596329,
-0.7912593484,
0.5317433476,
-0.4565722048,
-0.3947846591,
0.0948705822,
0.1558339447,
-0.6407345533,
-0.0745213181,
0.162920326,
0.5126150846,
-0.7845594287,
0.6012862921,
0.6889207363,
-0.0933633968,
-0.0437855944,
-0.1875940114,
-0.1842712611,
-0.2791681886,
0.3590455651,
0.200478062,
-0.2591710687,
-0.0073987981,
-0.1055087596,
-0.8257961869,
0.865772903,
0.3579570353,
-0.6392180324,
-0.0233939961,
-0.0609455742,
0.5337072611,
-0.5212084055,
0.1602561772,
0.275031209,
0.0947014838,
0.0820747092,
-0.4453044236,
-0.0988519862,
-0.1253114492,
0.0453456156,
0.3260096312,
-0.6617724299,
0.1166423187,
-0.0312828496,
-0.2855535746,
-0.0742146745,
0.9810828567,
0.3479358256,
0.5936347842,
0.5490939021,
0.3084376752,
0.1350057423,
0.2485396415,
1.0422365665,
-0.3633518219,
0.1952940375,
1.1797531843,
-0.7110399604,
1.0126693249,
0.4832340777,
-0.04494562,
0.6114505529,
0.8836452365,
-0.1304699033,
0.8319867253,
-0.1070872173,
-0.2077186555,
-0.3253037632,
-0.2431340814,
-0.273498863,
0.0988351479,
0.2539701462,
-0.4237287343,
0.1260383427,
-0.0425530337,
0.0828912556,
0.1749760062,
-0.1775545031,
1.2700897455,
-0.1435846686,
-0.8651789427,
0.159579888,
-0.0927259922,
1.1006577015,
-0.920024097,
-0.2621434033,
-0.2938437164,
0.1668587327,
-0.1468636096,
-0.7308715582,
-0.1669359505,
0.1243818253,
-0.5539702177,
-0.2133328766,
0.9435694218,
-0.6082593799,
-0.1681040376,
0.319104135,
0.2742345035,
-0.1628201008,
-0.2119375169,
-0.4173793793,
0.0392317064,
0.1852749437,
-0.3989272416,
0.6840632558,
0.1110741943,
0.0126966117,
0.6933871508,
0.8385139108,
0.0265948065,
-0.3330280185,
0.0300093554,
0.7138304114,
-0.9214755893,
-0.7435590029,
-0.9684768915,
0.4653632939,
0.1155979782,
-0.5104070306,
0.4335760772,
0.7883326411,
0.8534991145,
0.1208362952,
0.729807198,
0.4059158266,
0.585771203,
-0.2636100352,
0.4860697985,
-0.4199927151,
0.418874681,
0.0136672407,
-0.9725627899,
-0.0801456422,
0.2403292656,
-0.3409001529,
0.2308444679,
0.2142385542,
0.5860074162,
-0.3280869722,
-0.2322481722,
0.3980035484,
-0.1711123437,
0.1956579983,
0.6035298705,
0.7491061687,
0.1741103083,
0.3554096222,
-0.1575612128,
-0.0788420141,
-0.6531453729,
-0.7379347086,
-1.1205062866,
-0.7536103725,
-0.2453125268,
-0.3929192722,
0.4529283345,
1.3189086914,
0.873200357,
-0.8273515701,
-0.4370587468,
0.4007899463,
-0.0906775296,
-0.059819106,
-0.1951208115,
0.7415056825,
0.0457879119,
-0.5770400763,
0.6465560794,
0.6145693064,
-0.0197045691,
-0.4345127642,
-0.273301065,
-0.1835525483,
-0.2389393896,
0.6676948667,
0.4955586493,
-0.7886656523,
-0.1606139839,
0.0818937495,
0.016051596,
0.176764071,
0.986502111,
-0.7855703831,
0.4655539393,
0.2581600845,
0.8327102661,
1.1279246807,
0.2662377656,
0.778243959,
-0.7190457582,
-0.10265854,
0.3804233372,
0.3774442971,
0.3558913171,
-0.8077397943,
0.3829445541,
-0.1962217987,
-0.5835071802,
-0.8426606655,
-0.1389799714,
-1.4236264229,
0.2307166755,
1.3853037357,
-0.4984339476,
-0.124665983,
-0.3764523864,
-0.5084514618,
0.0602126718,
-0.8723205924,
0.8697036505,
0.5031330585,
-0.1899322122,
-0.1958573759,
-0.3761033416,
0.3566925824,
0.4605210721,
-0.431001395,
0.3204193115,
0.4034665227,
0.2477692813,
-0.1711992621,
0.5160947442,
0.11663647,
0.3041359484,
-0.6491240263,
0.0415618047,
-0.2553878427,
-0.3419971168,
-0.2068004608,
0.4036241174,
-0.01337016,
0.2438858449
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10554v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10554v2
|
Disordered-DABS: A Benchmark for Dynamic Aspect-Based Summarization in Disordered Texts
| 2024-02-16T10:35:18 | 2024-06-17T20:06:04 |
Xiaobo Guo, Soroush Vosoughi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Aspect-based summarization has seen significant advancements, especially in
structured text. Yet, summarizing disordered, large-scale texts, like those
found in social media and customer feedback, remains a significant challenge.
Current research largely targets predefined aspects within structured texts,
neglecting the complexities of dynamic and disordered environments. Addressing
this gap, we introduce Disordered-DABS, a novel benchmark for dynamic
aspect-based summarization tailored to unstructured text. Developed by adapting
existing datasets for cost-efficiency and scalability, our comprehensive
experiments and detailed human evaluations reveal that Disordered-DABS poses
unique challenges to contemporary summarization models, including
state-of-the-art language models such as GPT-3.5.
|
[
-0.2157658637,
-1.144346714,
0.6487041712,
0.3391513526,
-0.3612205684,
0.6520601511,
0.2028065324,
-0.373465836,
0.6682731509,
0.2625533342,
-0.4713029563,
-0.6019940376,
-0.4850491583,
-0.0524816923,
-0.6219459772,
1.2742908001,
-0.0926653817,
-0.3659687936,
-0.4339523017,
-0.0377942696,
-0.2599712014,
-0.7727016211,
-0.392264992,
0.0770868212,
0.440299809,
0.1625633091,
0.8100246787,
0.5566599369,
0.8527558446,
0.3087258041,
-0.494462043,
0.2412425727,
-0.3663899004,
0.8612366319,
0.0801614448,
-0.1680763811,
-1.3664191961,
-0.0476885512,
0.7415227294,
1.1161991358,
-0.3461155593,
-0.1038964316,
0.1936757118,
0.8069675565,
-0.5338497758,
0.1637677699,
-0.4391794205,
-0.0193068366,
-0.1873115897,
-0.1888396591,
0.1127732769,
-0.315095365,
-0.0225791521,
-0.548370719,
0.4354633391,
-0.2921412587,
0.6956662536,
0.30035308,
-0.7580016851,
-0.2836104333,
-0.7690700889,
0.4023784101,
-0.5670719743,
0.1527527571,
0.3591442108,
0.133319512,
-0.3630761802,
-0.8864926696,
-0.2770532966,
0.1439469755,
0.125446409,
0.2722308636,
0.0022243029,
0.0270450171,
-0.027840076,
0.7659721375,
-0.4063175321,
0.1825751811,
0.0549116246,
0.014178047,
0.8071596026,
0.5491070151,
0.0863720104,
-0.1613121331,
-0.1149159297,
-0.090316765,
-0.0044075167,
-0.0692378208,
0.4172284901,
0.190958187,
-0.5068036914,
0.2501508594,
-0.4246677458,
0.4514680505,
0.3370739818,
-0.0808469132,
0.3993607759,
-0.2763781548,
0.034861058,
-0.1274727285,
0.5433157086,
0.7703495622,
-0.3799884915,
-0.3576464355,
-0.3953306675,
-0.4005687535,
0.3002973199,
-0.9385473728,
-0.6693710685,
0.6754018664,
-0.5719588995,
-0.5930909514,
-0.0063493405,
-1.1750923395,
-0.8933182359,
0.2261343449,
0.1934008747,
-0.2260461301,
-0.4736531377,
-0.2336315513,
-0.3843355477,
-0.4101835191,
0.3792558014,
-0.9582413435,
0.3337604403,
0.776081264,
1.1315410137,
-0.6189873219,
-0.3883432746,
-0.297077626,
0.1842116863,
-0.382214725,
1.2170048952,
-0.4327688217,
-0.3598461151,
-0.2896511853,
-0.1857485324,
0.2881284058,
-0.690282464,
0.4317078292,
-0.3789771497,
-0.0067411349,
-0.3305376768,
-0.3510918319,
-0.2071982026,
0.3713283241,
-0.4679737091,
0.9496030211,
0.3334762454,
-0.7077363729,
0.6974005699,
-0.3832941353,
-0.7461594939,
0.0937817022,
-0.0677408129,
-0.6612263918,
0.4845044911,
0.0726107508,
0.5488833785,
-0.0373767391,
0.4470172524,
-0.8245803118,
-0.1134472489,
0.5113723278,
-0.7357463241,
0.2891520262,
0.2835196555,
-0.0554738753,
0.2892274261,
-1.1183416843,
-0.1112311631,
0.23267667,
-0.4339414537,
-0.6204300523,
0.4509810507,
0.2484727353,
-0.097770609,
0.3800304234,
-0.236843273,
0.3742085695,
-0.3957737684,
0.4109166265,
0.5697765946,
0.286922574,
0.3634158373,
-0.3780031502,
0.3919025362,
0.4196867049,
-0.0541734993,
-0.3900877833,
-0.2558536828,
-0.2254008651,
-0.7268144488,
0.1720482856,
0.2768445909,
-0.4397095442,
0.4437392652,
-0.1907932311,
-0.6593567133,
-0.0956242383,
-0.268473804,
-0.0052942755,
0.2159120142,
0.385601759,
-0.5808360577,
-0.0495493822,
-0.7192764878,
-0.2814896703,
0.1094057858,
-0.2128624767,
-0.0347095318,
0.2780375779,
-0.2180833668,
0.7513357401,
-0.5828795433,
-0.3104298115,
-0.1552289277,
0.4634653628,
-0.0009163009,
0.2695952654,
0.6146149635,
-0.8434169888,
-0.3765774667,
-0.2221743613,
-0.5933380723,
-0.2504178286,
-0.237172544,
0.3640093207,
0.2714808583,
0.4632901251,
-0.2323800176,
0.4831402302,
0.7361630201,
-0.70072788,
0.3717386127,
-0.7337455153,
0.530710876,
-1.2266203165,
-0.0916820988,
-0.3600046039,
-0.3063363731,
-0.3898047507,
-0.0817914531,
0.2322695404,
-0.1485902071,
0.0257091168,
0.2105505913,
-0.7147706151,
-0.0048934072,
-0.5721647739,
0.081441015,
-0.0815999508,
0.3410251141,
-0.3817183971,
0.5385045409,
0.615676403,
-0.7252485752,
0.4793418944,
-0.1048612595,
-0.211819604,
0.7557745576,
-0.4324898124,
0.073736541,
-0.2762454748,
0.3731428981,
-0.8403314352,
-0.5545767546,
-0.0874756202,
-0.015563962,
0.3195472062,
-0.0338028632,
-0.3356816173,
-0.2482827604,
-0.5715594888,
0.6806106567,
0.3049972057,
-0.2674583495,
0.811789453,
0.8515964746,
-0.3389669359,
-0.1557978243,
-0.6674574614,
0.4020404816,
-0.3021511137,
-0.2594151795,
0.8934077621,
-0.1893989742,
-0.3725886941,
0.1341604143,
-0.6878787875,
-0.368845731,
0.4044049382,
0.3565651476,
-0.2163426727,
0.069992803,
-0.3824175596,
0.4478769004,
0.0307244044,
0.0867509246,
0.1251051128,
0.5665283799,
-0.0920198709,
-0.3670326769,
-0.3719645739,
0.6389790177,
0.826967597,
-0.0589616671,
0.5119037628,
0.1553467363,
-0.3986800313,
-0.2369305193,
-0.2998172343,
0.0768442228,
-0.4923593402,
0.9228452444,
-0.2819823325,
-0.4535575509,
1.0173308849,
0.140519172,
0.1689179391,
0.1996484697,
0.6892623901,
-0.3197116554,
1.042108655,
0.651973784,
0.1339271516,
0.4634753466,
0.1796084046,
0.1945720613,
-0.3214213252,
-0.2830685377,
-0.2190214694,
-0.6577046514,
-0.7268276215,
-0.2634024918,
0.5025552511,
0.1269214153,
0.2152100801,
-0.0985587612,
-0.3391369581,
0.5645384789,
0.3125573993,
0.1254902333,
0.5083798766,
-0.2135887295,
0.244293794,
0.1512250453,
-0.3481477797,
-0.4072294533,
0.930817008,
0.2797489464,
0.7494782209,
0.4326687753,
0.6972919703,
0.5073338151,
0.0589117855,
-0.7405884862,
0.557888031,
-0.2803631723,
-0.4722859859,
-0.0738300085,
-0.5554141402,
-0.9716261029,
0.2082550675,
-0.1611980498,
-0.7938722372,
0.3270274997,
0.4279842675,
-0.4175074697,
0.4997060299,
-0.6261674762,
0.7182475328,
-0.1838233322,
-0.0733310431,
-0.3853943348,
-0.3311027586,
0.0447375886,
-0.3567471802,
0.3605897725,
-0.2778878212,
-0.2287082225,
0.8463236094,
-0.5770753622,
0.6440374851,
-0.1633783579,
-0.2935777605,
0.0856444538,
0.4576865435,
0.3296718299,
0.2462941408,
0.1818694025,
0.1785747111,
0.4821587801,
-0.6028805971,
-0.5983929634,
0.821442306,
-0.3193100691,
-0.3819222748,
-0.7530352473,
-1.0640090704,
-0.4249715805,
0.2575145066,
0.084893629,
0.6672895551,
-0.4048950374,
0.2346998304,
0.3744859993,
-0.1001605168,
0.8693277836,
0.6788107157,
-0.3368858397,
-0.4080506265,
0.8077916503,
0.2914294302,
0.0985305831,
0.2167184502,
-0.0695531294,
0.1172605008,
-1.0929157734,
-0.2244835049,
-0.106136933,
-0.4434393048,
-0.1148399264,
-0.8342200518,
-0.0173682887,
-0.5131456852,
-0.1961606443,
-0.7344383597,
-0.4328339696,
-0.1060669497,
-0.0130357407,
0.1117933393,
0.9332607985,
-0.1889808923,
-0.0399251096,
-0.6840150356,
0.4989101589,
0.0281320009,
0.7877947092,
0.0929266885,
-0.4714598358,
-0.2342134118,
0.012606144,
-0.549623251,
-0.9824948311,
0.371896863,
0.0350895822,
0.2682215571,
0.3659923375,
0.4287927151,
0.551104784,
-0.2126075476,
0.8099285364,
-0.1350052804,
-0.4820751548,
0.3601098955,
-0.6734820008,
0.346539855,
0.5065136552,
0.2401842922,
-0.4719471335,
-0.7483885288,
-0.5434813499,
-1.4052708149,
0.555739522,
0.0567739382,
0.1985729933,
-0.0481833741,
0.3705574572,
0.3336993754,
0.2109272033,
-0.3754523695,
-0.3851133287,
-0.14251104,
-0.3388242424,
-0.0145719443,
-0.6019572616,
0.037867371,
-0.1134314984,
0.4019266963,
0.2142899334,
0.0169160403,
0.121545665,
-0.0208526496,
0.0562733449,
0.2371595353,
0.5805916786,
0.6318584085,
-0.7265638113,
0.1667599231,
-0.0819541588,
-1.0877884626,
0.0875393525,
0.4199610949,
-0.4196451306,
-0.2966432869,
0.1971227378,
0.5591439009,
0.0773128048,
-0.5979459882,
0.4832848608,
-0.2211508602,
-0.0488422029,
-0.0717377961,
0.0096406573,
-0.3406148255,
0.2747855186,
0.5786885619,
0.1834730059,
0.2378217876,
-0.6966900826,
0.1499313116,
0.2228565365,
-0.4750680625,
-0.5870609283,
0.8829635978,
0.5025541782,
-0.4837386012,
0.2862035632,
-0.572996974,
-0.1652171165,
0.471645534,
0.4450463057,
1.0958342552,
0.0431368276,
0.1543411314,
-0.1819457859,
0.1231477484,
0.0847263783,
0.2835417986,
-0.1819690168,
-0.332421422,
-0.1886776984,
-0.6584767103,
-0.547817409,
0.1548229307,
-0.8646900058,
0.0353609771,
-0.3676938713,
-0.3164381087,
0.0793909952,
-0.1942921728,
-0.0866538882,
0.075115703,
-0.1565830857,
0.4421543777,
-0.6668763757,
0.4976416826,
1.0847073793,
-0.3101834357,
-0.2245964408,
0.6228576899,
0.2852453589,
-0.1644377261,
-0.1081630066,
-0.0779639706,
0.0887268931,
-0.0208483618,
-0.0475206599,
-0.8578768373,
0.8775503635,
-0.0219186656,
-0.3001145124,
-0.1775025427,
-0.0839578658,
0.6384910941,
0.1133191288,
0.2606524527,
0.5668101311,
0.093497403,
-0.2385071069,
-0.9110469818,
0.0297527593,
-0.3666276932,
-0.2834683657,
0.3512234986,
-0.7323822975,
0.7415990233,
-0.1347717047,
-0.2400948107,
-0.1470440775,
1.0145684481,
-0.1618893892,
0.6473085284,
0.4674531817,
0.3126624525,
0.9303339124,
-0.1104880795,
0.82277596,
-0.1731006652,
0.2901407182,
1.1752382517,
-0.2036143988,
0.5797920823,
0.1851028949,
-0.1768295318,
0.4346394837,
0.6917103529,
0.0931269601,
0.7542718053,
-0.1199158654,
-0.119195044,
0.0021490946,
0.2448189706,
-0.4665282369,
0.4654458165,
0.2732736468,
0.1103055254,
-0.280390054,
-0.0153121613,
0.1438354254,
0.2159009427,
-0.290992111,
0.9263828993,
-0.0974820182,
-0.4769828618,
0.4056430757,
0.1059807688,
0.9517360926,
-0.3272891939,
0.4350228012,
-0.6623594761,
0.2800379097,
-0.1757464409,
-0.8892495632,
0.7824867964,
0.1985402107,
-0.6324020624,
-0.3951275349,
0.2470336407,
-0.3706091642,
-0.3346693218,
-0.0307743065,
0.2142698616,
0.1008818075,
-0.4066052735,
-0.4428607225,
-0.023472853,
-0.2596363425,
-0.5239236951,
0.7172417641,
0.7916225791,
-0.1130468324,
0.6819037795,
0.0488171093,
0.0449108779,
-0.388686955,
0.1536322236,
0.7562770247,
-0.914093852,
-0.8555909991,
-0.7042138577,
0.5293540955,
-0.1158713549,
-0.507288456,
0.7294510603,
0.8364569545,
0.5564803481,
0.2445324957,
0.5674852729,
-0.2807677686,
0.5724974275,
-0.2566423416,
1.2527623177,
-0.8435355425,
0.4448722899,
-0.449700743,
-0.8743032217,
-0.2605736852,
0.0652119964,
-0.0659269765,
0.132462889,
0.8878185153,
0.5521144271,
-0.1303097308,
-0.0465603806,
0.1450063586,
0.5962166786,
0.5121485591,
0.1216440797,
0.5885078311,
-0.214729771,
0.6117428541,
-0.381834805,
-0.6663794518,
-0.1836110353,
-1.1565711498,
-0.8601464629,
-1.0204585791,
-0.7844521999,
-0.5077590346,
0.0400775559,
0.6392003298,
0.2912844419,
-0.855851531,
-0.0237223376,
-0.0015209058,
-0.0277326759,
-0.5273471475,
-0.2019446045,
0.433627516,
0.0381525569,
-0.7432650924,
0.4339428246,
0.6038771272,
0.4132121205,
-0.0110546974,
0.5220912099,
0.2510284483,
0.0311309956,
0.5774825811,
0.0439786091,
-0.4318635464,
-0.010082298,
-0.2194132656,
-0.1429570913,
-0.0052768732,
0.7079383135,
-0.48756513,
0.2346273363,
0.5593276024,
0.416710645,
0.4794713259,
0.1801034659,
0.5108944178,
-0.5617325902,
0.1774176359,
0.3117951453,
0.0151091525,
0.1768570095,
-0.2657344341,
-0.0347892344,
0.4695160091,
-0.5834997892,
-1.2197630405,
-0.0206467006,
-1.3231116533,
-0.5238475204,
0.9934535027,
0.1038212553,
-0.0426483974,
-0.3217972815,
0.0439220406,
0.1141639352,
-0.4712562859,
1.3419510126,
0.5411553383,
-0.1326820403,
0.2933457494,
-0.0409518965,
0.5847436786,
0.3901119232,
-0.9404623508,
0.6050437689,
0.6831988692,
0.1701435149,
-0.2444074452,
0.8147586584,
0.0234102793,
0.0246360432,
0.2042208314,
-0.176912114,
-0.2309374213,
-0.3177078366,
-0.2505543828,
0.5788921714,
-0.1728828996,
0.0417263843
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10553v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10553v1
|
A novel integrated industrial approach with cobots in the age of industry 4.0 through conversational interaction and computer vision
| 2024-02-16T10:35:01 | 2024-02-16T10:35:01 |
Andrea Pazienza, Nicola Macchiarulo, Felice Vitulano, Antonio Fiorentini, Marco Cammisa, Leonardo Rigutini, Ernesto Di Iorio, Achille Globo, Antonio Trevisi
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
From robots that replace workers to robots that serve as helpful colleagues,
the field of robotic automation is experiencing a new trend that represents a
huge challenge for component manufacturers. The contribution starts from an
innovative vision that sees an ever closer collaboration between Cobot, able to
do a specific physical job with precision, the AI world, able to analyze
information and support the decision-making process, and the man able to have a
strategic vision of the future.
|
[
-0.6218111515,
-0.6087704301,
0.8351359963,
-0.0738289207,
-0.049721051,
0.4127358496,
0.5043990016,
-0.9499286413,
0.3773868084,
0.5443738699,
-1.1854355335,
-0.2210152894,
-0.1354818344,
0.05153431,
-0.2452097833,
0.4870171249,
-0.0725830346,
-0.4134348035,
-0.37417081,
0.0173888169,
-0.8791685104,
-0.6606150866,
-0.5563547611,
-0.467296809,
0.2135144621,
0.3873226643,
0.7119516134,
0.2528077066,
0.984549284,
0.5470403433,
0.5106415749,
0.0580392815,
-0.063253887,
-0.00460723,
-0.3557298183,
-0.4910986722,
-0.8371393085,
0.1812793314,
-0.1562769562,
0.8740552068,
0.1663743109,
0.0019374866,
-0.0319623612,
0.3866172135,
-0.2566128671,
0.5259384513,
-0.4537266493,
0.3942442238,
0.1182291135,
-0.5444366336,
-0.1284154803,
-0.1919984668,
-0.0121777896,
-0.7839124203,
0.174153313,
0.1223453134,
1.0104043484,
0.4622994661,
-0.1453043967,
0.0257329606,
-1.1587666273,
0.7030777335,
-0.3526628017,
0.2728117406,
-0.0991495848,
0.8205680847,
-0.3990942538,
-1.0539540052,
-0.7057839632,
0.2874373794,
0.2562993765,
0.5448099375,
-0.2270810306,
0.2946627438,
-0.1975801438,
0.2789298892,
-0.1040732935,
0.3237067163,
-0.6667976975,
-0.3969582617,
0.7064170241,
0.3232346773,
0.3037804365,
0.1705740541,
-0.7783846855,
0.0099953385,
-0.1318818778,
-0.1405654103,
0.5147354603,
0.1175781116,
-0.1637221575,
0.2109432518,
-0.6132509112,
0.5446915627,
0.187192753,
0.0969433337,
0.6502264142,
-0.6916118264,
-0.2807821631,
-0.0737105384,
0.8231804967,
0.7070778012,
-0.2277218997,
0.032718949,
0.0856130943,
0.3233899474,
0.5218262672,
-0.0929510072,
-0.3116120398,
0.451277554,
-0.1989724189,
-0.1756692529,
0.2103404999,
-0.807520628,
-0.1790308356,
-0.6101617813,
0.5031483173,
0.2279610932,
-0.1013902053,
0.203248173,
-0.6032819152,
0.6026991606,
0.8758528829,
-0.7243730426,
0.042683553,
0.9219771028,
0.785515368,
-0.0117964093,
-0.0034831094,
-0.2375433743,
0.4828665853,
-0.5108571649,
0.831746161,
-0.2467135489,
-0.2682889104,
-0.2536213696,
0.2463554591,
0.3600738347,
-0.6467393637,
0.0744778812,
-0.5028744936,
0.4152924716,
0.2648581862,
0.1846723408,
-0.5640854239,
0.5760700107,
-0.846077919,
0.546775043,
0.1930579096,
-0.2884266376,
0.4467501938,
-0.9161704779,
-0.1983443946,
0.6140380502,
-0.8235276937,
-0.4606812596,
-0.3707486093,
-0.2387833893,
0.552590251,
0.0660770386,
0.0868419483,
-0.6126756072,
0.1452293247,
0.1725068688,
-0.2965729833,
0.7038798332,
0.1002396718,
-0.4277122915,
0.3570334315,
-0.5646004677,
-0.1837702841,
-0.2075354457,
0.2481801957,
0.067764543,
-0.225862965,
-0.249052003,
0.6014912724,
0.8749264479,
-0.6068536043,
0.014702295,
-0.5383091569,
0.3846488297,
0.8436255455,
0.3469938338,
0.6570327282,
-0.3291725814,
0.7427914143,
-0.0784136131,
0.6752795577,
-0.2445600182,
-0.472194612,
-1.0304806232,
-0.2112610191,
-0.5061861277,
0.4148946702,
-0.9700416327,
0.692281127,
0.1464331597,
-0.4251050651,
-0.2939353883,
-0.127573669,
-0.0887407809,
0.564234376,
0.1953350604,
-0.9834033847,
-0.5956133604,
-1.0741978884,
0.2052275538,
-0.0542602651,
-0.2142824382,
0.194298625,
0.3138513267,
-0.4463506043,
0.9323113561,
-0.3761233389,
-0.5892987251,
-0.3444783688,
0.1659464985,
0.7461214662,
0.5007343888,
0.1296773106,
-0.9735850096,
-0.3219658434,
0.6236840487,
-1.1692618132,
0.3646404743,
-0.1042895913,
-0.1880579591,
0.3003638387,
0.9558687806,
-0.5269331932,
0.6107900143,
0.3899373412,
0.0696686804,
0.3265060186,
-0.2522213459,
0.1756464839,
-1.0825098753,
0.0931190327,
-0.0389195718,
-0.1381652057,
-0.7808730602,
-0.0356817953,
-0.7052474618,
-0.2221262008,
-0.5729686022,
0.1006284356,
-0.3320838213,
-0.4102004766,
-0.1739179045,
0.2701886296,
0.2971722782,
0.6170520186,
-0.0916471779,
0.5151548982,
0.0549860746,
-0.690371871,
1.0355541706,
0.5485734344,
-0.2836408913,
0.7367655039,
-0.5491933823,
0.2724131644,
0.2180252671,
0.4500844777,
-0.8041075468,
-0.4603715241,
0.6351253986,
-0.6010245681,
-0.2204528451,
0.7542098165,
-0.4284102321,
-0.8477497697,
-0.2411846519,
0.2589224875,
0.1765525937,
-0.2554178536,
0.993585825,
0.5575389266,
-0.485391587,
-0.2912180722,
-0.7932394743,
0.3361825347,
-0.162908867,
-0.6989448667,
0.4707207978,
-0.0518482514,
-0.4167311192,
-0.2498623729,
-0.1299183518,
-0.3118089139,
0.1045786813,
-0.0087773288,
0.6976525784,
0.2136458308,
-0.2296723276,
-0.1115201116,
-0.6285502911,
0.3373186886,
0.0132131893,
0.8109331727,
0.1200242117,
-0.4114730954,
-1.4894117117,
0.3068142831,
0.7091753483,
-0.0441625342,
0.1112704352,
0.204765588,
-0.3433465064,
0.0070541753,
-0.1723955423,
-0.3614693582,
-0.682117641,
0.5344077945,
-0.3802328706,
-0.4214146137,
0.4070305526,
-0.4409267902,
0.0668461397,
0.5213354826,
0.756583631,
-0.4373362958,
0.8539899588,
0.971532464,
0.1127352938,
0.3136063218,
-0.4268816113,
0.7895141244,
-0.4926785231,
-1.0651711226,
-0.4847796857,
-0.5110007524,
-0.69503057,
-0.3089009225,
0.622284472,
-0.4658966959,
-0.4382223189,
0.4710989594,
-0.6846525073,
0.0404901654,
0.9803698063,
0.274336189,
0.5352604389,
-0.6785336137,
0.367328763,
0.2410549968,
-0.7648897767,
-0.5626244545,
0.1865058392,
0.4148358703,
0.349153161,
-0.1755026579,
0.3635722995,
0.4473190904,
-0.3846748769,
-1.0591975451,
0.8363623619,
0.3369977176,
-0.7795315385,
-0.2366550118,
0.1994749308,
-0.96809268,
-0.3272510767,
-0.0178312194,
-0.5313476324,
0.5144579411,
0.3715613186,
-0.4799595177,
0.204779312,
-0.7752427459,
1.101018548,
-0.4712068737,
-0.2080153823,
-0.4817297757,
-0.9973078966,
-0.0017869415,
-0.1474566907,
0.49308002,
-0.3185748756,
-0.0875266343,
0.5676258206,
-0.4499459565,
0.967635572,
0.0164910164,
-0.0406665951,
0.3860748708,
-0.291477412,
0.1654500812,
-0.5687932968,
-0.0184651613,
0.6002178788,
-0.2862070203,
-0.1165160239,
-0.6008380651,
0.1364067495,
-0.6096377373,
-0.4526830018,
-0.8370215297,
-0.7070044279,
-0.2412093282,
0.3282061219,
0.1841212213,
0.0748171359,
-0.2632704675,
0.2095850855,
-0.025740305,
-0.473467499,
0.7849775553,
-0.0294423997,
0.1905034184,
-0.2665599585,
0.6856328249,
-0.1528825313,
0.3613485992,
0.5959723592,
-0.2454658598,
0.0350525789,
-0.0674079582,
-0.3743202686,
-0.3555357158,
-0.7009909153,
-0.3466828465,
-0.4922141433,
-0.2735772431,
-0.0836788788,
-0.6896438599,
-0.3442807794,
-0.2495873719,
-0.3591950536,
0.1002386808,
0.2457254678,
0.9230903387,
0.1008756012,
0.3494509757,
-0.6025797725,
0.0973976851,
0.4727160931,
0.2575899065,
-0.1905398965,
0.1439245492,
-0.4143061042,
-0.0392105244,
-0.6232159138,
-0.2315210402,
0.4574375749,
-0.1858481318,
0.6234972477,
0.4388759136,
0.0504134744,
0.3941326439,
-0.5047479868,
0.9061462879,
0.7633098364,
-0.9409103394,
0.3690696061,
-0.5498820543,
0.323972404,
0.3003883362,
0.4093025327,
-0.4269994199,
-0.3068507314,
-0.8046504259,
-1.0182727575,
0.5917503834,
-0.1531426758,
0.0618135147,
0.4942843914,
-0.1293872893,
0.3534870148,
0.3788733184,
-0.3858400881,
0.0614263043,
0.00225882,
-0.4859597087,
0.0350684412,
0.3642802238,
-0.164353326,
-0.0202969629,
0.2976997793,
-0.1163085625,
0.8875834942,
-0.2192923129,
0.6195177436,
-0.0512746349,
0.0030483184,
0.1395448148,
0.5786780715,
-0.0967054367,
-0.0444070734,
0.06762629,
-0.3318478465,
0.0137831541,
-0.3235243857,
0.3287378848,
-0.282476604,
0.2641252279,
0.4341638386,
-0.0972669646,
-0.2924200892,
0.3687164783,
0.3801754415,
-0.3504041135,
-0.772223711,
0.2706288695,
-0.2064283788,
0.7909018993,
0.5101292729,
0.5513634086,
0.4060434699,
-0.8864908218,
0.4563412368,
0.4187572598,
-0.6810705662,
-0.6838197112,
1.0199594498,
0.7832717299,
-0.6886675358,
0.115470767,
-0.1385371536,
-0.6726552248,
0.954585135,
0.1984811425,
0.8105688095,
-0.0037539487,
0.0475903377,
0.1123718396,
0.2227322608,
0.1436254978,
0.1915854067,
0.1037394181,
-0.8632053137,
-0.4269039631,
-0.0488518551,
-1.1894671917,
-0.0231830403,
-0.2700276077,
0.6540004015,
-0.7298746109,
0.1280084252,
0.0998842642,
-0.1222333834,
-0.7794522643,
0.6726406813,
-0.113860257,
0.1119715124,
-0.746512413,
0.426212281,
0.4037471712,
-0.6872372031,
-0.2669005096,
-0.1614023447,
-0.097138688,
-0.979878366,
0.8268404603,
0.4019323587,
-0.4586035609,
0.0339949019,
-0.6794358492,
-0.5615676045,
1.142047286,
0.0427855775,
-0.6938050985,
-0.0317899995,
0.1951819658,
0.3833998442,
-0.3005490899,
-0.0799001083,
0.2558529079,
0.4418689311,
0.1588780284,
-0.9085970521,
-0.1382541955,
-0.2375297099,
-0.1768115014,
0.2802236676,
-1.0725405216,
0.5932090878,
0.3351506591,
-0.0672605336,
-0.0355280563,
0.8710669279,
-0.0492523164,
0.9629888535,
0.4712570012,
0.2272260636,
0.5071688294,
0.035831932,
0.6104081869,
-0.2475094646,
-0.0684610605,
0.8900709152,
-0.2028944045,
0.5639888048,
0.3937847018,
-0.2126948088,
0.9225658178,
0.344636023,
-0.1598465592,
0.4763188958,
-0.4350633025,
-0.5477792621,
0.043079704,
-0.1418725252,
-0.0940805078,
1.0222678185,
0.3021227121,
0.1986976415,
0.4242765307,
0.2430805266,
-0.2154893428,
0.2576442957,
-0.3669490516,
0.8140057921,
-0.1614224613,
-0.3225708008,
-0.1505451202,
-0.4368952513,
0.6007835269,
-0.1262494922,
-0.4136868715,
0.1359819174,
0.4661165178,
-0.1994750202,
-0.7807111144,
0.6941735148,
-0.567650497,
-0.0184493195,
-0.3617711365,
0.6756759286,
0.1164341941,
-0.320908159,
0.2080544978,
0.2975133955,
0.2641360164,
0.2157377601,
-0.3615009189,
0.1765113026,
0.0351055786,
0.4331270754,
-0.141394034,
0.59340626,
-0.0776902735,
0.6706023216,
0.1604757309,
-0.5015074015,
-0.3848459423,
-0.2808740139,
0.6675409675,
-0.9016217589,
-0.4562153816,
-0.4361656606,
0.714577198,
-0.3686719835,
0.0313057788,
0.8639814854,
0.5298827887,
1.2450635433,
0.0245326683,
1.1934367418,
-0.1857851595,
0.3852245808,
-0.1267169118,
0.3910694718,
-0.6158021092,
-0.1318571419,
-0.4635095298,
-0.5776981711,
-0.5380238891,
0.6615983844,
-0.2332171947,
0.2654588819,
0.5377762914,
0.5681704283,
0.0236896463,
-0.1485001743,
0.489543438,
0.0454326086,
0.6038398147,
0.3493452668,
0.6621592045,
-0.4567029774,
0.4611018598,
-0.1202236116,
-0.4720599949,
-0.4906642437,
-0.8661988378,
-0.3083106875,
-0.6698508263,
-0.1818960458,
0.0127749108,
-0.3153388798,
0.8492751122,
0.610342741,
-0.6751102209,
-0.422115922,
-0.5414936543,
-0.3830021024,
-0.4270458519,
-0.1801501215,
-0.1256206483,
-0.2256104648,
-1.0829991102,
0.2744584978,
0.9546587467,
-0.2194984555,
-0.5883547068,
0.116936408,
-0.2202000767,
0.1699588448,
0.7003577948,
0.2286344767,
-0.3522696793,
-0.5432606339,
0.0425133854,
0.2767467797,
0.364374876,
0.1199141517,
-0.7591183186,
0.7660761476,
0.4644164741,
0.6338425279,
0.3814482689,
-0.0265520792,
1.134388566,
-0.4231207669,
0.5455382466,
0.3469774127,
0.0814778879,
0.447956264,
-0.3861719072,
0.5869974494,
0.4517454803,
-0.6890318394,
-0.2947704792,
0.6291849613,
-1.3366436958,
0.0169982444,
0.3236745,
0.2519279718,
-0.3121376336,
-0.6331923008,
-0.2714371681,
0.6387873888,
-0.3088864684,
0.8606509566,
0.3611030281,
-0.5662606359,
0.056861002,
-0.6510010958,
-0.0578893013,
0.1517739445,
-1.1922463179,
-0.598654747,
0.6087967753,
-0.5739421248,
0.5761401653,
0.5412074327,
-0.0446099751,
0.1877342314,
0.3948118985,
0.7172062397,
0.3445291221,
-0.5348519087,
-0.1313815713,
0.0702293888,
0.0941579491,
-0.7898849845
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10552v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10552v3
|
Conversational SimulMT: Efficient Simultaneous Translation with Large Language Models
| 2024-02-16T10:32:16 | 2024-06-21T07:18:13 |
Minghan Wang, Thuy-Trang Vu, Yuxia Wang, Ehsan Shareghi, Gholamreza Haffari
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Simultaneous machine translation (SimulMT) presents a challenging trade-off
between translation quality and latency. Recent studies have shown that LLMs
can achieve good performance in SimulMT tasks. However, this often comes at the
expense of high inference cost and latency. In this paper, we propose a
conversational SimulMT framework to enhance the inference efficiency of
LLM-based SimulMT through multi-turn-dialogue-based decoding. Our experiments
with Llama2-7b-chat on two SimulMT benchmarks demonstrate the superiority of
LLM in translation quality while achieving comparable computational latency to
specialized SimulMT models.
|
[
-0.0851313248,
-0.7753388286,
0.6087292433,
0.6647670865,
-0.6882193089,
0.4882642329,
-0.1842492819,
-0.4017519057,
0.1947988719,
0.7478683591,
-0.5569017529,
-0.4059481621,
-0.534072876,
0.1312799007,
-0.3080925345,
0.5038601756,
0.1094861478,
0.4365657866,
-0.3091701567,
-0.0406690128,
-0.3879734278,
-0.6995778084,
-0.6929711699,
-0.3674023151,
0.3218868673,
0.2957848012,
0.9303100705,
0.514960885,
0.453964442,
0.2858698368,
-0.0524142012,
0.6145788431,
-0.5784448385,
0.2341233343,
0.4102219641,
-0.7708625793,
-0.5641263723,
-0.3412317336,
0.5962836742,
0.7378743291,
-0.1519512832,
-0.2265837342,
-0.052022092,
0.4511744678,
-0.157158047,
0.3991196156,
-0.4545427561,
-0.2140394896,
-0.0850108042,
-0.4697222412,
-0.7032231688,
-0.5257071257,
-0.3079321086,
-0.4084776044,
0.0597586073,
0.3127833605,
0.5151365399,
0.5602059364,
-0.4861025214,
-0.1000296175,
-0.7329298258,
0.9209395647,
-0.9796190262,
0.5606991649,
0.1208937243,
0.4191142619,
-0.5239108205,
-0.6513538957,
-0.5274027586,
-0.2004831433,
-0.1024079844,
0.3439477384,
-0.071763657,
0.2351730764,
0.0990039185,
0.4827847183,
-0.5254771709,
-0.0990619436,
0.0608158223,
-0.023092201,
0.4740912616,
0.3924178481,
0.1236849651,
-0.0210447703,
-0.3530153036,
-0.1107300967,
-0.5173888206,
-0.2074695975,
0.4485591352,
0.2535914183,
-0.1775354445,
0.602428019,
-0.2610066235,
0.3612216711,
-0.2305366397,
-0.423293978,
0.2807503045,
-0.5140474439,
-0.1156718731,
0.0062483363,
0.8059365153,
0.4481011629,
-0.0914105698,
-0.316803813,
-0.0294794552,
-0.0011670808,
0.119648695,
-1.0356057882,
0.0182741024,
0.4247724712,
-0.3822261095,
-0.0501225069,
-0.0429074354,
-0.6508663297,
-0.0713599995,
-0.1458067894,
0.0192400962,
-0.552372098,
-0.2628909349,
0.4470324814,
0.130599767,
0.2252851278,
0.705596745,
-0.4600068629,
0.3860526979,
0.5905156732,
1.0502634048,
-0.4772295356,
-0.0799494013,
-0.6477031708,
0.2635724247,
-0.2732928395,
0.6938177347,
-0.4071074128,
-0.5951988697,
-0.2406918257,
-0.3555943668,
-0.2973054051,
-0.5416995287,
0.4775294065,
-0.430108726,
-0.0972915515,
0.0203572512,
-0.4312833846,
-0.2670073211,
0.1672441065,
-0.5917606354,
0.9420132041,
-0.303635329,
-0.6153516173,
-0.218696937,
-0.5307908654,
-0.6699825525,
0.1425728053,
-0.092600815,
-0.332267642,
0.2811235189,
0.432967633,
0.389929384,
-0.5828081369,
0.4469367862,
-0.2360163033,
-0.5440638065,
0.6790714264,
-0.8621567488,
0.5069382191,
0.4494813681,
0.0053895884,
-0.0846289843,
-0.5906193256,
0.0425011143,
0.1427208781,
-0.5049213171,
0.147927165,
0.0347570889,
0.0599578433,
0.1855970323,
0.1057769358,
-0.3608658016,
0.286773324,
-0.4810846448,
0.1780323088,
0.2907911539,
-0.0309210401,
0.1834761351,
-0.4814544618,
0.5110390782,
0.4047993124,
-0.0917192027,
-0.3292648494,
-0.6015706062,
-1.168941021,
-0.5738770366,
0.189440161,
0.6868267655,
-1.1028797626,
0.0055187154,
-0.3790643811,
-0.3782111406,
-0.870690167,
0.0969691873,
0.386210531,
-0.0576611087,
0.5185484886,
-0.2657028139,
-0.3804701865,
-0.7173311114,
-0.3741784096,
-0.1648261547,
0.1372148395,
0.5440425873,
0.0056381193,
-0.2285548598,
0.5917654037,
-0.3825851381,
0.0257593337,
-0.5814865828,
0.3547054529,
0.3960785568,
0.4179136455,
0.1868967861,
-0.7257409692,
-0.336401552,
0.0552458093,
-0.7192311287,
-0.3783802092,
-0.4473235607,
-0.2822674215,
0.1270755827,
0.6714121699,
-0.6837933064,
0.3598649502,
0.7409268022,
0.1416598409,
0.3801211417,
-0.2020471096,
0.3796465695,
-1.2860455513,
-0.1315489113,
-0.5766021609,
-0.5554454923,
-0.7188801765,
-0.188858211,
-0.0186526477,
0.2639841735,
-0.6332883239,
0.3029377162,
-0.4987433851,
-0.2737462819,
-0.1413646936,
0.0040993122,
-0.0134826889,
0.6401227713,
0.1128400192,
1.193125844,
0.0398774035,
-0.5103129148,
0.2278263122,
0.3170422018,
-0.0836166367,
0.5854297876,
-0.5369812846,
0.1871262342,
0.2246526629,
0.5299721956,
-1.0952935219,
-0.36084342,
0.1388462931,
-0.3371424675,
0.2751277685,
-0.2354335636,
-0.7591979504,
-0.1143004,
-0.095826894,
0.5726003051,
0.5338202715,
-0.6431776881,
0.7047597766,
-0.004598015,
-0.2516072989,
-0.4130560458,
-0.8290997744,
0.4311506748,
-0.0928683951,
-0.8363469243,
0.1245585456,
-0.1659148932,
-0.038303446,
-0.5029138327,
-0.031190522,
0.0820068568,
0.0344942734,
0.4933995903,
-0.0638743713,
-0.2345177829,
-0.15311037,
0.3783889115,
-0.2653965056,
-0.0168557167,
-0.1508539319,
0.8032979369,
-0.1865783632,
-0.7703416944,
-0.5414447188,
0.5789909363,
0.7272003293,
0.0819252133,
0.8205716014,
0.5009895563,
0.0992332995,
-0.0849202871,
-0.8653473258,
-0.1356650591,
-0.4368039072,
0.2542255521,
-0.632770896,
-0.8115279078,
0.4291892946,
-0.5813382268,
-0.115489386,
0.0022306854,
0.8540036082,
-0.1221820936,
1.189871192,
0.2658005357,
0.406293869,
0.3258430362,
-0.0499605797,
0.2757775187,
-0.7561400533,
-0.272654891,
-0.3480559289,
0.035710372,
-0.4556884766,
-0.9253652096,
0.3446686268,
0.2213372737,
0.0979532227,
0.1953035444,
0.1355789602,
0.300236553,
0.6180598736,
0.2748135924,
0.843973279,
0.169908002,
-0.2885413766,
-0.0834121928,
-0.8301230073,
-0.6014547348,
0.6860638857,
0.3445079625,
0.9494641423,
0.3730975986,
0.6202212572,
-0.0721852407,
0.1846338063,
-0.7876123786,
0.6489343643,
-0.0103042033,
-0.3572152555,
0.0890164673,
-0.6673771739,
-0.7331461906,
0.5696439743,
-0.0238256771,
-0.4754160047,
-0.2227777541,
0.133738786,
0.0584921986,
0.2534300089,
-0.5469045043,
0.5525343418,
-0.388864696,
-0.3634819388,
-0.3904953599,
-0.6481149793,
0.481869638,
-0.1460306048,
0.1436628848,
-0.3661380112,
0.0137038454,
0.3579955995,
-0.3924297988,
0.7736214399,
0.2040792257,
0.0559376106,
-0.0328747965,
0.2692278922,
0.4229027629,
0.2343841642,
-0.1378183365,
0.4280539155,
0.043689236,
-0.4498054385,
-0.5557554364,
0.4595789909,
-0.801857233,
-0.581740737,
-0.3802997768,
-0.9998040199,
-0.3537782431,
0.0491130613,
0.1880212575,
0.2277003974,
-0.2794772387,
0.144851476,
0.4918245971,
-0.2870253623,
0.3035147488,
0.3469006121,
-0.4259951711,
-0.4779662192,
0.7800244093,
-0.1739814878,
0.6585937142,
0.4549927413,
-0.1277759373,
-0.3717841804,
-0.6900244355,
-0.7281349897,
0.4759596884,
-0.6554913521,
-0.3215343952,
-1.0355728865,
-0.1749932617,
-0.2025899887,
-0.0374224931,
-0.6915689707,
-0.387262404,
-0.1916770488,
0.2952906191,
0.28247118,
0.5765001774,
0.0524383113,
0.8116278648,
-0.8434208632,
0.4983000457,
0.0841021389,
0.0658839718,
-0.2323642075,
-0.488132596,
-0.1170477942,
0.2078520209,
-0.0512485616,
-0.7357208133,
0.5795322061,
-0.0980384052,
0.4679971337,
0.1781913638,
0.0881847739,
0.8270287514,
-0.4457506537,
0.6122421026,
0.3715131581,
-0.9857037663,
0.1538482904,
-0.1764999628,
0.5623661876,
0.4442664981,
0.0496829562,
-0.6703653932,
-0.525668323,
-0.3247147202,
-0.7048253417,
0.9747676849,
0.6580450535,
0.1605143845,
-0.0162082296,
0.1521448046,
0.1779408604,
0.3201503754,
-0.4167063832,
-0.3252871633,
-0.0806278214,
-0.2848403454,
0.0383332297,
-0.4933651686,
0.0155741256,
-0.0317443274,
0.7329999208,
-0.3117414713,
0.4372993112,
-0.0590171702,
-0.306219101,
0.2114014328,
0.4027256966,
0.4408695996,
0.2593715489,
-0.2229543924,
0.2834029496,
0.5052495599,
-0.4284049273,
0.3222078681,
0.0409856141,
-0.0535278171,
0.1394292563,
0.2857574522,
1.0220630169,
0.3978962898,
-0.4831332266,
0.4838410318,
-0.3546461761,
0.0179572292,
0.1200937033,
0.1892835498,
0.483337611,
0.4632925391,
0.20969069,
-0.0488343984,
0.1335364282,
-0.140457049,
-0.0923509821,
0.2818686962,
-0.0369885899,
-0.0546619073,
0.6077550054,
0.2897616625,
-0.3923573792,
0.5193495154,
-0.0429166481,
-0.5272974372,
0.3411063254,
0.7129064798,
0.7322024107,
-0.2629107535,
0.0849817544,
0.1335159689,
0.1242917776,
-0.2941708863,
0.3050532937,
-0.1244398206,
-0.5291011333,
-0.7503423095,
-0.7449426055,
-0.9335517883,
-0.1131138951,
-0.6025063396,
0.1487928927,
-0.018967431,
0.0023489404,
-0.3998653591,
-0.2637219429,
-0.461813271,
-0.0491030477,
0.0364024751,
0.6440387368,
-0.420955956,
0.9628322124,
0.3503822684,
-0.109110035,
-0.5073987246,
-0.0260917377,
-0.1420337111,
-0.712600112,
0.3809743822,
0.3104707301,
-0.7157017589,
0.2183048427,
-0.4395389557,
-0.6573546529,
1.0771862268,
0.7991788387,
-0.6648948789,
0.2039818913,
0.7198255062,
0.329926461,
-0.3944446445,
0.4428887963,
0.7756766081,
0.33449018,
0.6016663909,
-0.8794612885,
-0.0987848267,
-0.1040857136,
0.1484485269,
0.0611058585,
-0.7570304871,
0.5345429778,
-0.1256028265,
-0.4077326357,
0.2110358179,
0.7608287334,
0.1951986849,
0.2377549708,
0.299425602,
0.2815638483,
0.4666473866,
-0.1698880494,
1.1591874361,
-0.2107750326,
0.2431146055,
1.1638816595,
-0.0960660949,
0.8907171488,
0.7290366888,
-0.2695034742,
0.0449065305,
0.4350359738,
0.4464408755,
0.3798693717,
0.0720322132,
-0.4481661618,
-0.7706976533,
-0.1905582696,
-0.3855579793,
0.3459522724,
0.5002431273,
0.0007885987,
-0.0803141668,
-0.1869899482,
0.2165437341,
-0.0736783072,
0.2213867158,
0.8912150264,
0.327082485,
-0.5410314798,
0.6087684035,
0.0727852434,
0.5145609975,
-0.377794385,
-0.13750799,
-0.6935560703,
0.2030392587,
-0.0152584892,
-0.4512384236,
0.167552501,
-0.1931214631,
0.0655413941,
-0.1747828424,
0.3664995134,
-0.7840771079,
-0.552400291,
0.4149758816,
1.0153981447,
0.6410979629,
-0.0581339411,
-0.6574288011,
0.5524049997,
0.0270345565,
-0.3201048672,
0.0523200668,
0.4979110062,
0.0643619075,
0.751140058,
0.8811018467,
-0.0398438014,
0.2035128772,
0.2956179678,
0.9038438797,
-0.576120317,
-0.5367816687,
-0.8451189995,
0.2666255236,
-0.1177899987,
0.0896698087,
0.729054749,
0.5636493564,
0.5525701046,
0.1009675711,
0.6353473067,
0.4082732201,
0.2619524896,
-0.7986594439,
0.3766745329,
-0.5083889365,
0.5399135351,
-0.1570752263,
-0.9501268268,
-0.4689816236,
0.5396437049,
-0.0962363705,
-0.0570360832,
0.7613157034,
0.9527291059,
-0.3316183984,
0.1383670717,
0.6829372048,
0.2636939883,
0.6006093621,
0.7314634323,
1.0569452047,
-0.51276052,
0.757447958,
-0.0813117027,
-0.0299902745,
-0.7122019529,
-0.9055252671,
-1.1040021181,
-0.1824610233,
-0.2360755503,
-0.4442210197,
0.1896791309,
0.9914444685,
0.724722743,
-0.7034668922,
-0.3895694911,
0.0391094051,
0.1499350369,
-0.239954114,
-0.1281751543,
0.1133268997,
-0.4452076554,
-1.0479615927,
0.5865290761,
0.5422750711,
0.1633952707,
-0.0457635075,
-0.4557178915,
-0.2340190411,
0.4862578511,
0.531545639,
-0.1929054409,
-0.9199025631,
0.0849286541,
-0.0709099174,
-0.3548884094,
0.3313820362,
0.9036142826,
-0.4883296192,
0.4462807477,
0.2692375779,
0.9223754406,
1.0717983246,
0.1388824582,
0.6312975883,
-0.6333546638,
0.3822897077,
0.0855394602,
0.284971565,
0.5262675285,
-0.2514660954,
0.5796208978,
0.2182624191,
-0.3384085596,
-0.7289216518,
0.2155848891,
-1.2814255953,
-0.0832323059,
1.3180017471,
-0.2344212681,
-0.1733441204,
-0.3076921701,
-0.6378178,
0.4068147838,
-0.4964495897,
0.1779339314,
0.530192256,
-0.2708975375,
-0.3745467067,
-0.6734290123,
0.2589516044,
0.7131899595,
-1.0581632853,
0.071127221,
0.4209365249,
-0.1210652664,
-0.055621542,
0.5615083575,
-0.0436653458,
0.1128467545,
0.2034674883,
-0.0649665743,
-0.3887741864,
-0.2440318912,
-0.2003562897,
0.1559893042,
0.0714593455,
-0.1349816024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10543v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10543v1
|
Strong hallucinations from negation and how to fix them
| 2024-02-16T10:11:20 | 2024-02-16T10:11:20 |
Nicholas Asher, Swarnadeep Bhar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
Despite great performance on many tasks, language models (LMs) still struggle
with reasoning, sometimes providing responses that cannot possibly be true
because they stem from logical incoherence. We call such responses
\textit{strong hallucinations} and prove that they follow from an LM's
computation of its internal representations for logical operators and outputs
from those representations. Focusing on negation, we provide a novel solution
in which negation is treated not as another element of a latent representation,
but as \textit{an operation over an LM's latent representations that constrains
how they may evolve}. We show that our approach improves model performance in
cloze prompting and natural language inference tasks with negation without
requiring training on sparse negative data.
|
[
-0.3900674284,
-1.0918194056,
0.7689966559,
-0.1064793542,
-0.2041172236,
-0.3109776974,
-0.2740783989,
-0.6489459872,
0.454782784,
0.9434328079,
-0.5584387183,
-0.1632311046,
-0.7565485239,
0.1467955858,
-0.4356838763,
0.9217176437,
0.4008500874,
0.2812755704,
-0.0596695617,
-0.098862797,
-0.8754783869,
-0.8498203158,
-0.4603194296,
-0.5993041396,
0.4177159965,
0.2791129053,
1.1745752096,
0.1968749613,
0.2435211241,
0.299593091,
-0.0070892209,
0.2303640097,
-0.5373485088,
0.4857226312,
-0.3815228045,
-0.4906049967,
-0.1644996703,
-0.2909819484,
0.2074926496,
1.0200818777,
-0.1436693519,
-0.4211393893,
-0.0029658529,
0.4342828989,
-0.3200407326,
-0.1168888286,
-0.9234498739,
0.2595172524,
0.0739075094,
-0.1716865897,
-0.6568036079,
-0.2800309956,
0.1354372203,
-0.2669136226,
0.2090387493,
-0.1537918746,
1.0093312263,
0.5068362951,
-0.4182603359,
-0.4985291362,
-0.8103506565,
0.7438290715,
-0.8377076983,
0.3582157791,
0.5006625652,
0.2007221729,
-0.5520113111,
-0.3869666457,
-0.6263937354,
-0.5909831524,
-0.2419788092,
-0.3562796116,
0.0497954525,
0.1535603255,
0.5256061554,
0.2269665897,
-0.4238830209,
0.1104765832,
-0.3528602719,
-0.4573862851,
0.4567118883,
0.2195545435,
0.3389038444,
-0.1722880602,
-0.0619461946,
0.0473482125,
-0.6712455153,
-0.4151616395,
0.4819467962,
0.3597606421,
0.303894192,
0.7999777198,
0.1633902341,
0.8342959881,
0.2071442604,
0.1393815577,
0.265522331,
0.1205212772,
-0.1973044425,
0.1831142604,
0.2590254843,
0.05298407,
0.3771929443,
-0.4244040847,
-0.4045759439,
0.6074063778,
0.5096055865,
-0.5986596942,
-0.4646521509,
0.2923586965,
-0.3998587132,
-0.011506754,
-0.1414007694,
-0.6894373894,
-1.0650110245,
-0.5803268552,
0.8065093756,
-0.4375188053,
-0.2906782627,
0.2583783865,
-0.0361393653,
0.0684346855,
0.3982506394,
-0.886179328,
0.4975772202,
0.4185548723,
0.5298269987,
0.1936689764,
-0.0832244679,
-0.8591998219,
-0.3256070912,
-0.580168128,
0.6641578078,
-0.7114276886,
-0.1528643966,
-0.1307577044,
0.1968467683,
0.0522823669,
-1.0501106977,
0.3643208146,
-0.2596120536,
0.227871865,
-0.1719332188,
-0.5425692201,
-0.4014726877,
-0.0262903329,
-0.6815125942,
0.7333840132,
-0.0168962441,
-0.4017294347,
0.0797383934,
-0.2943180799,
-0.6017155647,
-0.0645836741,
-0.2571709156,
-0.2643887699,
0.5835592747,
0.0922483131,
0.4817575812,
0.0457746871,
0.4100745618,
-0.3816995025,
-0.3894179463,
0.3563154638,
-0.0436030403,
0.851251781,
-0.0851438567,
-0.5949704647,
0.5468634367,
-0.6439262033,
-0.2388321757,
0.3099991679,
0.3757731616,
-0.4415856004,
0.2339717448,
-0.4820563495,
0.1965562254,
0.0817590207,
-0.2543030381,
0.2916458249,
-0.648455739,
0.3676233292,
0.8683249354,
0.1040307209,
0.5454822779,
-0.1181207672,
0.2581065893,
0.1360675544,
-0.1648972183,
-0.0367516652,
-0.4859706163,
-1.063368082,
0.0541299917,
-0.146562174,
0.2821615636,
-0.7598395944,
0.2475256771,
0.3431645632,
-0.3500075936,
-0.3535102904,
0.3010474741,
0.0568222143,
0.7757273912,
0.5796999931,
-0.0830724686,
-0.6346819997,
-0.913399756,
-0.1885071695,
-0.1290394813,
0.0591096953,
0.0961941332,
0.6328924298,
-0.5099074244,
0.3441200554,
-0.4454694092,
-0.2783932388,
-0.2608605027,
0.3273288012,
0.4433297515,
0.3009999096,
0.2122589946,
-0.5980603099,
0.0944446027,
-0.2311029285,
-0.9581577182,
-0.2076279968,
-0.3440434337,
0.041166421,
0.4279708862,
0.5925084352,
-0.6193984747,
0.5206624866,
0.3441593945,
-0.5523706675,
0.7370375395,
-0.1143182889,
-0.1086085364,
-0.4902966619,
-0.3610957265,
-0.2859085202,
-0.114722468,
-0.6202215552,
0.1331908107,
-0.2474666536,
-0.1503536999,
-0.1657071114,
0.4389677942,
-0.466687113,
0.1992990673,
-0.4386471808,
0.1179067865,
-0.1729813516,
0.4511651397,
0.2874843478,
0.2319437563,
0.8771126866,
-0.9005636573,
0.3265340328,
0.0406180285,
0.0748796016,
0.3108549118,
-0.6851361394,
0.2997027636,
-0.5243384838,
0.0238522254,
-0.6484079957,
-0.4126265645,
0.3692746758,
-0.3112351,
0.1425511688,
0.0641359016,
-0.5611703992,
-0.2755470872,
-0.0936285928,
0.1012300402,
0.4797070622,
-0.6269934773,
0.5915138125,
0.235941425,
0.1843481809,
-0.3219574392,
-0.775243938,
0.283775568,
-0.2513435781,
-0.5028781891,
0.1961580664,
-0.2060192823,
-0.6502061486,
0.1464263201,
-0.112727426,
-0.0761799887,
0.1146542802,
0.3652338088,
0.0633824095,
-0.2172939777,
0.3789793253,
-0.0713927448,
-0.0771125555,
0.2252736241,
-0.1801882088,
0.7886132598,
-0.0620470047,
-0.3879483342,
-0.3924937546,
0.2792394161,
0.5123996735,
-0.0563685149,
0.8953158259,
0.3958436847,
-0.928412497,
-0.5947170258,
-0.5021326542,
-1.1080679893,
-0.4114359319,
0.210024491,
-0.3248601556,
-0.8505164385,
0.6917427778,
0.3862161934,
-0.2669884562,
0.4522113204,
0.473823458,
0.0617526993,
1.127961278,
0.2870926857,
0.3832213581,
0.202231735,
-0.0520299673,
0.6087869406,
-0.331343919,
-0.3157188892,
-0.4465191066,
-0.1496700048,
-0.4574366808,
-0.2980968356,
0.1304860711,
0.2948079705,
-0.1295065731,
0.3681775331,
-0.7108439803,
0.4248992801,
0.1557537019,
0.1483986974,
0.0585197769,
-0.034607958,
0.0165462345,
-0.3764084876,
-0.5787738562,
-0.6065302491,
0.7544505596,
0.400693208,
0.8584015965,
0.2041457295,
0.707875669,
0.1868308336,
0.1425809711,
-0.6847571731,
0.8582385182,
-0.0073346854,
-0.6531698704,
-0.3010179102,
-0.4715317786,
-0.7773283124,
0.4450334311,
-0.4783803225,
-1.0654212236,
0.2105099857,
0.0959466174,
-0.2106072754,
0.318643719,
-0.8085641265,
0.7805848718,
-0.2212477475,
-0.6186711788,
-0.3640683591,
-0.3814882934,
0.5821463466,
0.1741657257,
-0.0494636707,
-0.0021283093,
0.1992886662,
0.5763287544,
-0.6866133809,
0.9399392605,
-0.3194743991,
-0.2613290548,
0.5110206008,
0.4699806571,
0.6281147003,
0.1703686267,
-0.2021981478,
0.0570216253,
-0.3802734911,
-0.4091859758,
-0.9140075445,
0.6847633123,
-0.4429445565,
-0.7643437982,
-0.5889389515,
-0.4182933569,
-0.2014306039,
0.1949453056,
0.3423753381,
0.5501123667,
0.2389464378,
0.0766649023,
0.8874437213,
-0.2617191076,
0.2983579636,
0.0565288328,
-0.470484525,
-0.154158026,
0.8119958043,
0.3887334466,
0.1948930919,
-0.0062975576,
0.1669047177,
-0.3779920638,
-0.5953785777,
-0.1710395515,
0.3086115122,
-0.9369024038,
-0.080914259,
-0.6969145536,
-0.2874345779,
-0.3187302053,
-0.1356125027,
-0.1972665042,
-0.3360497952,
-0.4771492481,
-0.1436097026,
0.158339113,
0.9823780656,
-0.0231257007,
0.0595946833,
-0.3517945111,
0.7204447985,
0.5036067963,
0.1021328196,
0.359480679,
-0.4831961095,
-0.1230129674,
-0.0220043752,
-0.1738865525,
-1.3288019896,
0.4369308352,
-0.2063194513,
0.4221876264,
0.3860376775,
0.1344343573,
0.8592920899,
-0.2163519412,
0.8366841674,
0.1579575241,
-1.1049201488,
0.4380994141,
-0.1687590331,
0.2286757678,
0.3326985836,
0.2201832235,
-0.2724713087,
-0.7389243245,
-0.5343513489,
-0.8329063654,
0.3162541986,
0.2034284472,
0.2950581312,
-0.2782724798,
0.2767132521,
0.3377824128,
0.1681228429,
-1.0132879019,
-0.0366007425,
-0.4235848486,
0.1792513281,
0.014465983,
-0.3772604465,
0.0297340248,
-0.3210433424,
0.7663148642,
-0.050676316,
0.3783367276,
0.3640805781,
-0.5142207742,
-0.0105084097,
0.1714807153,
0.6208677888,
0.6439259052,
-0.1235019267,
0.6102192402,
0.2353194505,
0.0811838508,
-0.01253701,
-0.1475663483,
0.100651361,
0.0560041927,
0.6178005934,
0.8048180938,
0.0487040281,
-0.6968945861,
0.3166597784,
0.1264649183,
-0.0494641028,
-0.3288330436,
0.2171193361,
-0.0728738979,
0.0692309216,
0.4368499815,
0.1195850596,
0.1703100353,
-0.7256851196,
0.223868385,
0.4307363033,
-0.540017724,
-0.3630755246,
0.6085345149,
-0.1698963642,
-0.3503782153,
0.7640861869,
-0.5018286109,
-0.7165540457,
0.5275855064,
0.8026941419,
0.9450310469,
-0.0367948934,
0.1993107945,
0.4561051726,
0.5467467308,
-0.0070208772,
0.3828056455,
0.1991380602,
-0.7928387523,
-0.3913025856,
-0.2773761153,
-0.3103293777,
0.473415792,
-0.2855188847,
0.3702470064,
-0.6981236339,
-0.1609736979,
-0.1358323246,
-0.2352987379,
-0.47948578,
0.2766706645,
0.3320662975,
0.4923292696,
-0.7520545721,
0.6133287549,
0.4621032774,
-0.5603833199,
-0.5824286938,
0.0493404269,
-0.1539049894,
-0.3550719619,
0.5314180255,
0.3352345526,
-0.3022382259,
-0.3468132615,
-0.8519945145,
-0.432595253,
0.253921181,
0.6213703752,
-0.5119073987,
0.1558778435,
-0.054875154,
0.6375104785,
-0.3022358418,
0.1686019152,
0.1990030557,
0.5938745737,
-0.3008420467,
-0.6392501593,
0.2777329087,
-0.0685694441,
-0.4056378603,
0.2448831946,
-0.1382492036,
0.9201722741,
-0.4589124918,
-0.2139713317,
0.0491406508,
0.7707404494,
-0.0043096752,
0.2308003604,
0.5260445476,
0.6533772349,
1.1199499369,
-0.1350373626,
0.7887984514,
-0.045500163,
0.0701862648,
1.3011267185,
-0.3454224169,
0.6211705804,
0.7004581094,
0.4543048739,
0.7935850024,
0.3381776512,
0.0207259115,
0.2633239925,
0.363694936,
-0.066802375,
-0.5696610212,
-0.2500751317,
-0.4449733496,
0.2910258472,
0.4617602229,
-0.2009202391,
-0.2580610514,
0.1882405728,
0.1191265211,
0.532034874,
-0.300868392,
0.6943254471,
0.2161449641,
-0.7898087502,
0.9267958403,
-0.1637221128,
0.4722033441,
-0.5042623281,
-0.5268229842,
-0.0937301666,
0.1672419161,
-0.5737889409,
-0.4827927947,
0.6668972373,
-0.2637187839,
-0.1161670089,
-0.1876519769,
0.830958128,
-0.3133602738,
-0.2741354108,
0.6754636168,
0.1884238273,
0.2406690717,
-0.0846529603,
-0.3350123465,
0.2074748129,
-0.088219054,
-0.0289369915,
-0.0382114649,
0.4269986451,
-0.3418869078,
0.580776155,
0.5339980125,
0.0603271164,
0.2368336469,
0.1519948542,
0.6715011597,
-0.9438092113,
-0.3213344812,
-1.0352131128,
0.4817843139,
0.0007947354,
-0.2625788152,
0.68654567,
0.3240799904,
0.5866186023,
-0.157750383,
0.5393336415,
0.0424646363,
0.1582595557,
-0.5766906738,
0.6095929742,
-0.5340439081,
0.2553679049,
-0.2312184721,
-1.0418844223,
-0.5690473914,
0.8589818478,
-0.6300534606,
-0.155942291,
0.8881232738,
1.0764365196,
0.0507835671,
0.0572343208,
0.4008410871,
0.7894968987,
0.1140378937,
0.7063401341,
0.9481937885,
-0.2520104349,
0.0993051678,
-0.2643567026,
0.1307935268,
-0.2926989496,
-0.8576999307,
-1.1760963202,
-0.5720740557,
-0.4518396258,
-0.8084599376,
0.0168349836,
0.875439465,
0.6330131888,
-0.9793843031,
-0.1602722108,
-0.3579180241,
0.6315109134,
-0.2412268668,
-0.2871216238,
0.1616021395,
-0.5170147419,
-0.4174442887,
0.4766883254,
0.1863654703,
0.1540973634,
-0.5482228398,
-0.3713314533,
0.042461507,
0.3534948528,
0.5229741931,
0.100567922,
-0.8442148566,
-0.2969989777,
-0.0015354907,
-0.0423870943,
0.0375007167,
0.5484972596,
-0.9807687402,
0.5706012845,
0.4928300381,
0.5197325945,
0.4929341972,
-0.4774340391,
0.4483550489,
-0.1966188252,
0.2963141799,
0.6579008698,
0.2855558097,
0.5244901776,
-0.3209747672,
0.2885429263,
0.2578440011,
-0.2431127727,
-1.1058202982,
0.4917566776,
-0.5865339637,
-0.6067439318,
0.8737992048,
0.4136481285,
-0.1790131032,
-0.1459391415,
-0.2884496748,
0.0618053004,
-0.1976559758,
0.8531680703,
0.86001122,
-0.2560456097,
-0.0788927451,
-0.5630578399,
0.4170707166,
0.783513248,
-0.504294157,
-0.0694466904,
0.6351259351,
-0.0554400496,
0.2825356126,
0.3293842673,
-0.1163334921,
0.1303639412,
0.0513353124,
0.0052049905,
0.1391201764,
-0.6569414139,
-0.527620554,
0.4767236114,
0.172786355,
0.1811127216
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10532v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10532v1
|
Properties and Challenges of LLM-Generated Explanations
| 2024-02-16T09:37:54 | 2024-02-16T09:37:54 |
Jenny Kunz, Marco Kuhlmann
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG
|
The self-rationalising capabilities of large language models (LLMs) have been
explored in restricted settings, using task/specific data sets. However,
current LLMs do not (only) rely on specifically annotated data; nonetheless,
they frequently explain their outputs. The properties of the generated
explanations are influenced by the pre-training corpus and by the target data
used for instruction fine-tuning. As the pre-training corpus includes a large
amount of human-written explanations "in the wild", we hypothesise that LLMs
adopt common properties of human explanations. By analysing the outputs for a
multi-domain instruction fine-tuning data set, we find that generated
explanations show selectivity and contain illustrative elements, but less
frequently are subjective or misleading. We discuss reasons and consequences of
the properties' presence or absence. In particular, we outline positive and
negative implications depending on the goals and user groups of the
self-rationalising system.
|
[
-0.5773180723,
-0.7916436195,
0.6264827251,
0.0775608122,
-0.0723269805,
-0.2768158913,
-0.5013970137,
-0.272818774,
-0.0729333088,
0.6130433679,
-0.8086410165,
-0.3286444843,
-0.4745929837,
0.3214986324,
-0.2432365268,
1.0735861063,
-0.2612795532,
-0.1262875199,
-0.352111578,
-0.0503014103,
-0.4532918632,
-0.8668317795,
-0.2498556077,
-0.4792340696,
0.8118282557,
0.7406486273,
0.7867352366,
0.8594988585,
0.1017964706,
0.3292833269,
0.2849735618,
0.2404972017,
-0.4887961149,
0.248755917,
-0.2839430869,
-0.4459685385,
-0.2998442948,
0.3368202746,
0.6078330278,
0.8891041279,
0.1453460604,
0.0272125434,
0.28189677,
0.6920928955,
-0.4468750954,
-0.0833002478,
-0.680252552,
0.0812742561,
-0.2048842609,
-0.4561212063,
-0.3436558247,
-0.0264045727,
0.1025680378,
-0.6252009273,
0.7397466898,
0.1122179404,
0.8315437436,
0.3223265111,
-0.4814533591,
-0.6415003538,
-1.030616045,
1.0105028152,
-0.5919654965,
0.0745069161,
0.3866713941,
0.3835836947,
-0.2835869193,
-0.4261669815,
-0.4611415565,
-0.0777273551,
-0.3271403611,
-0.0056426656,
0.1051336005,
0.1774416119,
0.3812073469,
0.399094671,
-0.3241654634,
0.4916913211,
-0.5060742497,
-0.3568562865,
0.8344162703,
0.3213966191,
0.0078155212,
-0.131611079,
-0.2224782258,
0.1549591124,
-1.1544114351,
-0.0008175981,
0.5638004541,
0.2954899669,
0.080104202,
0.5935922265,
-0.2076280564,
0.8029081821,
0.0445173867,
-0.1011115164,
-0.1399761438,
-0.3019068241,
-0.250797987,
0.1140917763,
0.6908420324,
0.2492506951,
0.6180140376,
-0.2351133078,
-0.3229153454,
0.0073160399,
-0.006004672,
-0.7454535365,
-0.1332535893,
0.4075508118,
-0.3160054088,
-0.0963860527,
-0.1174819395,
-0.5219547153,
-0.306509912,
-0.751041472,
0.2479556054,
-0.1764748693,
-0.1622496545,
0.1670737118,
-0.0255526882,
0.2533306777,
0.5802057981,
-1.3605582714,
0.097344853,
0.4725659788,
0.2174672484,
-0.37846452,
-0.4400551021,
-0.3651664853,
0.1640697718,
-0.1713255644,
0.8007477522,
-0.3817761838,
-0.2388019115,
-0.0636426508,
0.0110919923,
-0.0260359719,
-0.7156280875,
0.0590458773,
-0.2909127772,
0.3394900262,
-0.5688279271,
-0.6953385472,
-0.1219710335,
-0.0676612258,
-0.4036732912,
0.6384776831,
-0.115128763,
-0.4778314531,
0.6061497331,
-0.5638552904,
-0.5325770378,
-0.0996185541,
-0.1988348365,
-0.0424512401,
0.1988301575,
0.2010443062,
0.7745976448,
-0.2441370338,
0.3997258246,
-0.2782568932,
-0.3383589983,
0.6593414545,
-0.8376134038,
0.5054311752,
0.4997432232,
-0.3134101331,
0.0846860334,
-0.813872993,
-0.2072941065,
0.2770439982,
-0.341241926,
0.0069605368,
0.1256298572,
-0.4724348783,
0.1653172374,
0.4897993207,
-0.2043499053,
-0.0112904096,
-0.065550372,
0.5388334394,
0.9469817877,
0.0684163645,
0.3931259513,
-0.2869660854,
0.7881266475,
0.2139805108,
0.1193568632,
-0.5206586123,
-0.2330152839,
-0.5901821852,
-0.2117770016,
0.1838811189,
0.1708724201,
-0.1229158789,
-0.0064480286,
0.055523742,
-0.1693622321,
-0.552544713,
0.5069341063,
0.3705216348,
0.3686054051,
0.1205409169,
0.2092530131,
-0.4935133457,
-1.0758509636,
-0.3361164033,
0.2780492008,
-0.0448797308,
0.455360949,
0.2544293106,
-0.3177213371,
0.876752317,
-0.2946248055,
0.0744659603,
-0.3087242842,
0.112137571,
0.0803981051,
0.3779947758,
0.2806813717,
-0.5920888782,
-0.0899716094,
-0.270807296,
-0.834915936,
-0.3490277231,
-0.5921667218,
0.0440747142,
0.2543812692,
0.5314142108,
-0.5683327317,
0.3062444329,
0.4843585491,
-0.0579086021,
0.8887475133,
-0.4290978611,
-0.0878710151,
-0.804540813,
-0.2513782382,
0.0852844492,
-0.1064030305,
-0.3427731097,
-0.0354172997,
-0.3115617335,
0.0139997881,
-0.3626746833,
0.4967325926,
-0.5796641707,
-0.2366755307,
-0.1020828038,
0.6078207493,
0.3534687161,
0.5028059483,
-0.0768862739,
0.8770448565,
0.4648390412,
-0.9261994362,
0.252301991,
-0.0599421002,
0.1239985079,
0.1907258928,
-0.7404822707,
0.0461644717,
-0.1713630706,
-0.1612761617,
-1.0926525593,
-0.6670770049,
0.1040086672,
-0.3682387173,
0.2820775509,
-0.1900259256,
-0.4985803366,
-0.3401412964,
-0.1141515449,
0.2156687677,
0.3644024432,
-0.7318181992,
0.4115301073,
0.1244462356,
0.1449326128,
-0.5136587024,
-0.6348172426,
-0.0859277397,
-0.4809716642,
-0.5600647926,
0.2133328617,
-0.3014658689,
-0.4770433307,
-0.1572793722,
-0.1681613475,
0.0701486394,
0.4659321308,
0.5364057422,
0.1260355711,
-0.4035683572,
0.3130505383,
0.2794927657,
-0.0390694551,
0.3965350389,
0.0701878741,
0.2441250682,
-0.1430735141,
-0.4387560189,
-0.3940575421,
0.3464925289,
0.497148782,
-0.0797603428,
0.7920352817,
0.2885812521,
-0.1406912208,
-0.4782751799,
-0.4012328982,
-0.395904392,
-0.5266945958,
0.0343425572,
-0.4753374457,
-0.9653329849,
0.7170078754,
-0.1322915256,
0.1401685327,
0.6615535021,
0.7112447619,
-0.2244001031,
1.172244668,
0.1944182217,
0.3826275766,
0.151416406,
-0.0511017554,
0.2761021554,
-0.6061694622,
-0.3045551181,
-0.4920803607,
-0.1470219791,
-0.8112238646,
0.0704082176,
0.0043984787,
0.37505427,
-0.1821577251,
-0.0078912387,
-0.6799606681,
0.5511782169,
0.6942551732,
-0.1841183901,
0.2048561573,
0.0781950429,
-0.1129481941,
-0.0133499885,
-0.7483235002,
-0.8660203815,
1.1355588436,
0.3397422433,
0.9780921936,
-0.0737914741,
0.8636429906,
0.2434239835,
0.4349984825,
-0.7307351232,
0.5197510719,
-0.0245292298,
-0.8318746686,
-0.4753367007,
-0.3509576023,
-1.2377250195,
0.2188425213,
-0.2587763369,
-0.5660389662,
-0.1633817703,
0.5586918592,
-0.4522583187,
-0.0084852995,
-1.0757129192,
0.879989624,
-0.4640045166,
-0.4688255489,
-0.1848715842,
-0.3302351236,
0.5028176904,
-0.0783206448,
0.1340762526,
-0.1838834286,
0.3122886717,
0.6917505264,
-0.3415188491,
1.0393513441,
-0.2045163959,
-0.2149765044,
0.3927657604,
0.1302669048,
0.1196271703,
0.0309259426,
-0.1129604056,
0.0271207523,
-0.1418145895,
-0.4564154744,
-0.5658185482,
0.8293313384,
-0.8977894783,
-1.2803398371,
-0.1699467301,
-0.5508396029,
-0.1635081917,
0.1981420964,
0.2030637413,
0.7422213554,
-0.0346527435,
0.1414917707,
0.7473214865,
-0.5386413932,
0.3159430623,
0.5632265806,
-0.3764046431,
-0.0346581414,
0.9627829194,
0.2216971666,
0.4042960107,
-0.0480473563,
0.3093062043,
-0.2797617912,
-0.6822529435,
-0.5689305067,
0.3214110434,
-0.9159792662,
0.0427584536,
-0.3070936799,
-0.1751270145,
-0.2061894685,
-0.3431018293,
-0.031673722,
-0.423227489,
-0.7678083777,
-0.2317224592,
0.2944519818,
1.1561888456,
-0.1354969293,
0.3860472143,
-0.5813943744,
0.39539361,
0.5066447258,
0.1876921356,
0.0481730662,
-0.6054339409,
-0.4042955041,
0.2670131624,
-0.3539728522,
-0.6807777286,
0.1222168952,
0.1379114389,
0.6295397282,
0.6450031996,
-0.1339310706,
0.5418570042,
-0.381003648,
0.8693090081,
-0.1045842469,
-0.7400169373,
0.6002939343,
-0.4181981087,
0.2862683237,
0.305421263,
0.3996531963,
-0.0992693156,
-0.5381510258,
-0.5247900486,
-0.5120175481,
0.7480903268,
-0.102866143,
0.3154172599,
-0.1709096432,
0.7320677638,
0.4872587621,
-0.0038728588,
-0.6748000383,
-0.3215685189,
-0.3254155517,
-0.0850945637,
0.0048900009,
-0.390111655,
-0.176363185,
-0.0810925663,
0.4988487065,
-0.1786056608,
0.1763189137,
0.2091002613,
-0.1629904956,
-0.2605510354,
0.3684439659,
0.9698495865,
0.8665952682,
-0.0195409749,
0.2409471273,
-0.0544009693,
0.0859486163,
-0.0391508974,
0.1184676513,
0.1185564026,
-0.1695953608,
0.5775105953,
0.805993855,
0.0494080819,
-0.5387781858,
0.2552261353,
0.0167543739,
-0.3422645926,
-0.3418803513,
0.469366312,
0.1768327802,
-0.0674462318,
0.4361773431,
0.0290870517,
-0.0676150769,
-0.5006001592,
-0.1327693909,
0.4641702771,
-0.0219431352,
-0.650908947,
0.7257634997,
0.0475183204,
-0.221197173,
0.3847495019,
-0.2048879713,
-0.3949607313,
0.5349881649,
0.5850625038,
0.5665649176,
-0.085993059,
0.3036294281,
0.1349329352,
0.2727058232,
0.2114130706,
0.0755898654,
-0.286301285,
-0.9298864007,
-0.6350799203,
-0.5135655999,
-0.5982921124,
0.3053246737,
-0.5948629975,
0.0640461966,
-0.4880152047,
0.0600203983,
0.2863160372,
-0.236530304,
-0.9171597362,
0.3605797589,
0.2320549935,
0.5670831203,
-0.8077884912,
0.7360718846,
0.4133803844,
-0.4637059569,
-1.0001734495,
-0.1315398663,
-0.1866407841,
-1.0300080776,
0.7958071828,
0.1774034649,
-0.2085186094,
-0.2027931213,
-0.6414151788,
-0.6746976972,
0.785695076,
0.5997246504,
-0.5374576449,
0.0268222298,
0.5189945698,
0.7548745275,
-0.4022403061,
-0.0842089951,
0.5595393181,
0.5276029706,
-0.1741169244,
-0.5059508681,
0.0821550786,
0.2029407471,
-0.3053723574,
-0.070526503,
-0.4453644156,
0.7517060637,
-0.3887739778,
-0.1787037551,
-0.2833603323,
0.6276282668,
0.2037567049,
0.2841107249,
0.2159928679,
0.2904282808,
0.7167580724,
-0.1437722296,
1.2347468138,
-0.331576705,
0.0386561863,
1.0649397373,
-0.2077352852,
0.3346073627,
0.504165411,
-0.027860621,
0.5448566675,
0.854596436,
0.1297209561,
0.2302178442,
0.4404223561,
-0.1351445168,
-0.4069579542,
-0.0488492884,
-0.0552141331,
0.5720787048,
0.5181338787,
-0.4843105376,
-0.1442647278,
-0.0396241061,
-0.1455847025,
0.128453061,
-0.4035170674,
0.7108479142,
0.1857814342,
-1.0221681595,
0.9161635637,
-0.1749721915,
0.3723423481,
-0.3704223633,
-0.0275511686,
-0.3026660383,
0.1066704914,
-0.3289306462,
-0.8453752398,
0.2613150179,
-0.1039822176,
-0.3240598142,
-0.6092933416,
0.7236513495,
-0.4328946769,
-0.0831471533,
0.1248899922,
0.7147396207,
0.3690160513,
0.0847016498,
-0.5468078256,
0.0114700375,
0.1287250519,
-0.4792566001,
0.4186447859,
0.9354202151,
-0.0871842206,
0.5563024879,
0.4258657694,
0.0170606263,
0.0750207901,
0.1323960274,
0.7276912928,
-0.6525335312,
0.0293201972,
-0.9615842104,
0.3185851872,
0.2030241191,
-0.4366742373,
0.8805633187,
0.3460136354,
0.6809939146,
-0.0619645864,
0.8076951504,
0.3878289163,
0.3587304056,
-0.7548262477,
0.4141759276,
-0.5207293034,
0.5041195154,
0.1314954609,
-0.8832221031,
-0.0480207056,
0.302747339,
-0.3556845784,
0.1876388937,
0.5538893938,
0.8230397105,
-0.0774443969,
0.1114391834,
0.4910956025,
0.3024891019,
0.1171393692,
0.2547394931,
0.9270883203,
0.1249909475,
0.3719827533,
-0.1692760736,
-0.0113623049,
-0.2235454917,
-1.0000931025,
-1.1976875067,
-0.5054425001,
-0.3023586273,
-0.1915157586,
-0.2143300027,
0.7418403029,
0.6350905299,
-0.9323048592,
-0.0601722226,
-0.0660802126,
0.3464512229,
0.1163337901,
-0.238035053,
0.2127078176,
-0.4615315497,
-0.403093338,
0.3701896369,
0.1286553144,
0.1936168671,
-0.7019863725,
-0.2119517922,
0.406577915,
0.2756286263,
0.570899725,
0.3442943692,
-0.9820915461,
-0.4552181065,
0.0676251054,
-0.0289974231,
0.1501740515,
0.8682749271,
-0.8005376458,
0.3283206224,
0.0929387957,
0.4748244584,
0.3803367913,
-0.1066974029,
0.7784314752,
-0.6730058193,
-0.1023282632,
-0.0873507336,
0.4892853498,
0.5366846323,
-0.5178868175,
0.2459213734,
0.0577856451,
-0.6356130838,
-0.7532294989,
0.1652821898,
-0.626054883,
-0.3043032885,
1.2985756397,
-0.3284370601,
-0.1457778364,
-0.082225129,
-0.2349671423,
0.2682712376,
-0.2177704871,
0.8798933029,
0.8008713722,
-0.2652063966,
-0.1324457675,
-0.4880074561,
0.5471695662,
0.4783583283,
-0.8440086246,
0.4635033607,
0.696608007,
0.2982478738,
0.003924476,
0.3355116248,
-0.0490957424,
0.2999145985,
-0.3158077598,
0.0208179057,
-0.1983073354,
-0.4572910368,
-0.4170773923,
0.0756703541,
0.4035174847,
0.0988007188
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10528v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10528v2
|
Can We Verify Step by Step for Incorrect Answer Detection?
| 2024-02-16T09:29:50 | 2024-06-15T16:53:58 |
Xin Xu, Shizhe Diao, Can Yang, Yang Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting has marked a significant advancement in
enhancing the reasoning capabilities of large language models (LLMs). Previous
studies have developed various extensions of CoT, which focus primarily on
enhancing end-task performance. In addition, there has been research on
assessing the quality of reasoning chains in CoT. This raises an intriguing
question: Is it possible to predict the accuracy of LLM outputs by scrutinizing
the reasoning chains they generate? To answer this research question, we
introduce a benchmark, R2PE, designed specifically to explore the relationship
between reasoning chains and performance in various reasoning tasks spanning
five different domains. This benchmark aims to measure the falsehood of the
final output of LLMs based on the reasoning steps. To make full use of
information in multiple reasoning chains, we propose the process discernibility
score (PDS) framework that beats the answer-checking baseline by a large
margin. Concretely, this resulted in an average of $5.1\%$ increase in the F1
score and $2.97\%$ improvement in AUC-PR across all 45 subsets within R2PE. We
further demonstrate our PDS's efficacy in advancing open-domain QA accuracy.
Data and code are available at https://github.com/XinXU-USTC/R2PE.
|
[
-0.3525594175,
-0.9497256279,
0.8828553557,
0.0655378923,
0.0608752556,
0.2582596242,
0.0837792084,
-0.6610345244,
-0.2667084336,
0.5270949006,
-0.5496254563,
-0.5440576673,
-0.6338841319,
0.1580163836,
-0.3095608354,
0.6412591338,
-0.4712625444,
-0.1752464771,
-0.3086144924,
-0.076531373,
-0.3365472257,
-0.312925458,
-0.698948741,
-0.5908997059,
0.3309682906,
0.3371140063,
0.6005565524,
0.5201691985,
0.2496622056,
0.1589561403,
-0.1070824713,
0.770065546,
-0.2583873868,
0.1767118573,
-0.652628839,
-0.6088799834,
-0.6362965703,
0.1511829793,
0.3083046675,
0.40481022,
-0.0620355345,
0.324118942,
0.1691554934,
0.9239946008,
-0.845636189,
-0.060426645,
-0.647936821,
-0.085286133,
0.0772350058,
-0.3976479769,
-0.8598715663,
-0.4568025172,
-0.0935364068,
-0.3316294253,
0.435392499,
0.2088335752,
0.7037476897,
0.2441478074,
-0.3573475182,
-0.3928554952,
-0.7415866256,
0.5217422247,
-0.4817154408,
0.358951658,
0.6033598185,
0.2133338898,
-0.4010725319,
-0.601864934,
-0.6528386474,
0.1056017354,
0.0442689732,
0.0214167759,
-0.2072203755,
0.0115871681,
0.6162673235,
0.2802310288,
-0.6107444763,
-0.1615965813,
-0.1982304901,
-0.2715914249,
0.5742949247,
0.0073348554,
0.1863766313,
0.2691157758,
-0.501029253,
-0.1623042673,
-0.7135702968,
0.1927657574,
0.3847132325,
0.1605352163,
0.1441285759,
0.7017528415,
-0.2827102542,
0.5287235379,
0.1237550154,
-0.0111622391,
0.2651488185,
-0.4798163176,
-0.1609041095,
-0.1129403189,
0.6351608038,
0.3381980062,
0.3448748887,
0.0219326187,
-0.3367472589,
0.1613356471,
0.4382917285,
-0.5724651217,
-0.4566121995,
0.5079308748,
-0.0469853245,
0.0257230103,
0.0874387547,
-0.5171070695,
-0.5020760894,
-0.0108101089,
0.3620492816,
-0.3904768527,
-0.412943393,
-0.0108067673,
-0.0087332483,
0.1159717068,
0.5545959473,
-0.2533913851,
0.6336916685,
0.9534617662,
0.9095406532,
-0.1905651987,
-0.4277109802,
-0.9586669803,
-0.2852018774,
-0.8931623697,
1.058077693,
-0.2760547996,
-0.0641064718,
-0.226473704,
-0.0811957717,
-0.0954771861,
-0.8416131139,
0.5446682572,
-0.6035629511,
-0.1933297366,
-0.6051190495,
-0.6436203718,
-0.1295556426,
0.3864750862,
-0.5550020337,
1.4465845823,
0.0474289693,
-0.697495997,
0.2888368666,
-0.2302728295,
-0.2618763745,
-0.2955845296,
-0.2142696232,
-0.3902699947,
-0.0217442047,
0.2586954534,
0.1963983923,
-0.3574204445,
0.047559645,
-0.2965993881,
-0.5312848091,
0.4904953539,
-0.4879841805,
0.6151242852,
-0.048193071,
-0.5452850461,
-0.0150518222,
-0.8292946815,
0.5622988343,
-0.2625904083,
-0.2881124318,
-0.0998360589,
-0.0251107197,
-0.6030278206,
0.6364905238,
-0.1159760058,
-0.554130733,
-0.0924773961,
-0.1941771805,
0.0420425981,
0.9562826157,
0.1457303464,
0.073381789,
-0.3241446018,
0.6555126309,
0.1534354389,
-0.1217744499,
0.0659844354,
-0.8451930881,
-0.7231336832,
-0.063970983,
0.2121782154,
0.6993222237,
-0.7459041476,
0.5589745641,
0.0471175276,
-0.5468700528,
-0.3639393449,
0.1606287658,
0.7472828627,
0.6253246069,
0.4559626579,
-0.6145429015,
-0.4076782763,
-0.6241954565,
-0.4700393081,
-0.6396968365,
-0.1133294106,
0.152659744,
0.5918650031,
0.0726760179,
0.654145956,
-0.4160511792,
0.0847404525,
-0.074181132,
0.2745797038,
0.281678021,
0.3713510633,
-0.1032099128,
-0.3215282559,
-0.3209274113,
-0.0248971432,
-0.6351901293,
-0.0890278593,
0.0498258024,
-0.2849792242,
0.4577551484,
0.3491083086,
-0.3714312315,
0.6402383447,
0.5295157433,
-0.5788397193,
0.8303415775,
-0.4246737063,
0.4390618205,
-0.3765051961,
0.1673830599,
0.204560101,
-0.3533618152,
-0.4383426607,
0.0655628443,
0.3246113658,
0.2243546844,
-0.3225494921,
0.2645695508,
-0.2252459228,
-0.462685734,
-0.2351397276,
0.2473915815,
0.2417069525,
0.5557661653,
0.0876776353,
1.1198465824,
0.3326697946,
-0.6958292723,
0.1845006347,
0.0349692181,
-0.5499081612,
0.7092965245,
-0.5967459679,
0.3850443959,
0.1024175286,
0.5655950308,
-1.2956413031,
0.0710801333,
0.3187475801,
-0.4961417317,
-0.0579977743,
-0.1381156743,
-0.6578252316,
-0.4084888101,
-0.1795404106,
0.2945430279,
0.4052124619,
-0.6793452501,
0.4494938254,
0.0813013688,
0.1123063713,
-0.6652750969,
-0.5718096495,
-0.2237755656,
0.3110333681,
-0.5801336765,
-0.0076186452,
-0.1080095619,
-0.1714530438,
-0.2677745819,
-0.5957513452,
-0.2905034125,
0.0107152425,
0.2546076179,
0.162637651,
-0.1271287352,
0.1432622224,
-0.0638224706,
-0.2635896206,
0.4773529172,
-0.1205585599,
0.4281657934,
-0.2407327592,
-0.5411159396,
-0.5358749628,
0.0374271981,
0.6204612255,
-0.2400606573,
0.4587702155,
0.3134506047,
-0.4599335194,
-0.4516498446,
-0.4695365131,
-0.1019840911,
-0.4005274773,
0.0202200003,
-0.7435358167,
-0.2934254706,
0.5712940693,
-0.3133904636,
-0.0760722756,
0.3233453035,
0.2001832426,
0.0881472081,
1.1119400263,
0.160242483,
0.5697259307,
-0.1488666087,
-0.2976167798,
0.4749315977,
-1.0143800974,
-0.3363776803,
-0.5770426989,
-0.0188850109,
-0.6037450433,
-0.9373520613,
0.441567421,
0.5304207206,
-0.2871688902,
0.2971800268,
-0.4067823291,
0.5784014463,
0.4228342175,
0.4156806171,
0.519502759,
-0.2125210911,
-0.4702187479,
0.2555567622,
-0.5559917688,
-0.7344301343,
1.033364296,
0.5237112641,
0.5832850933,
0.015867075,
0.4994354248,
0.4683197141,
0.012132396,
-0.5318225026,
0.6957617402,
0.1315801889,
-0.462335825,
-0.3010780513,
-0.2700306475,
-0.3992199004,
0.326762706,
0.0034829127,
-0.7663168311,
0.1621301621,
0.3097313941,
-0.2246616781,
0.3785919249,
-0.4538530111,
0.8036054373,
-0.1000199169,
-0.7431710362,
-0.3032158911,
-0.570374608,
0.3343205154,
0.1034749448,
0.3037544489,
-0.2509013414,
-0.0542316772,
0.630946815,
-0.6327476501,
0.7026116848,
-0.0524306931,
-0.4819523394,
0.6057472825,
0.3830988407,
0.9174954295,
0.0571262538,
-0.31609568,
0.0868731365,
0.0184653308,
-0.4563831091,
-0.7579142451,
0.7183925509,
-0.486092031,
-0.4828650057,
-0.6649416685,
-0.1204991341,
-0.4561313987,
0.0509388074,
0.0640145913,
0.3474657238,
0.1734941602,
-0.4350678921,
0.9827649593,
-0.0790382773,
0.0056183059,
0.4480801225,
-0.1609064788,
-0.2894753218,
0.7137712836,
-0.0633622333,
0.5344717503,
0.2742568552,
0.0610296577,
-0.4676258862,
-0.4550970793,
-0.690215528,
0.1870986968,
-1.0443216562,
-0.1599216312,
-0.4873650968,
-0.1552229673,
-0.1195396706,
0.1685408503,
-0.6136412024,
-0.3383866549,
-0.0546542667,
-0.3170190454,
0.1667859256,
0.8645943999,
-0.1118679419,
-0.3895657361,
-0.4070464969,
0.4788342714,
0.2575386167,
0.5867465138,
0.1179183722,
-0.3016600907,
0.1530812681,
0.1838528216,
-0.4304690063,
-0.6667163968,
-0.1894523203,
-0.0913927928,
0.4307251871,
0.0982512683,
0.279250145,
0.7002282739,
-0.3624121845,
0.8272795081,
0.1902798563,
-1.110247016,
0.8502206802,
0.1692916155,
0.1076806858,
0.4058795571,
0.3369271159,
-0.2313139886,
-0.6315024495,
-0.6787858605,
-0.7383372784,
0.6387026906,
0.1658886373,
-0.4730988741,
-0.2025898695,
0.4035651982,
0.2405441552,
-0.1013411582,
-0.3925314248,
-0.3843027353,
0.2036504745,
0.1529909521,
0.1738618463,
-0.2275819927,
0.0069191051,
0.0649716482,
0.9381614923,
-0.3830294907,
0.1650662869,
0.6647292972,
0.1106765196,
-0.5984222293,
0.3173748851,
0.4153956175,
1.3215364218,
-0.1636838913,
0.5059359074,
0.2175531536,
-0.3323174715,
0.3213281631,
-0.3704822361,
-0.0222142488,
-0.0062419348,
0.5746235847,
0.503249824,
-0.0815329701,
-0.7856183648,
0.5377904177,
-0.0562669411,
-0.1471615732,
-0.123295635,
0.2592790127,
-0.2080377042,
0.281776309,
0.2299204618,
0.4216073453,
0.0795303434,
-0.7210783958,
0.3464967012,
0.1516046971,
-0.4473161995,
-0.1886744797,
0.4235798419,
0.157119289,
-0.3493124545,
0.607865572,
-0.2485426068,
-0.5313894153,
0.6173955202,
0.4644145072,
0.633323431,
-0.1396161318,
0.37818259,
0.6319234967,
0.2346468717,
-0.333629787,
0.5242828131,
-0.1757657677,
-0.6544134617,
-0.556319952,
-0.3447178006,
-0.673273325,
0.0548653454,
-0.8390116692,
0.1126123369,
-0.5661289692,
-0.0620103851,
0.0307279658,
0.1812944114,
-0.5534366965,
0.4805487394,
-0.1250172555,
0.9959015846,
-0.9063004255,
0.8877221346,
0.5412982106,
-0.1999502033,
-0.805449903,
0.1404146254,
-0.0642561093,
-0.6985428333,
0.4688107073,
0.2456046343,
-0.5836414099,
-0.3756249547,
-0.1984668672,
-0.6172339916,
1.0377182961,
0.1149277389,
-0.6852827668,
0.1275441945,
0.0373862535,
0.6608276963,
-0.2900313139,
0.4161711037,
0.7783577442,
0.2748633027,
0.2090908587,
-1.0341970921,
0.4480953813,
-0.0659634918,
-0.0039526867,
0.2995942235,
-0.1712394953,
0.6037967801,
-0.5721787214,
-0.3342209458,
0.1333670318,
0.4335324466,
0.7659209967,
0.5854412317,
0.6026091576,
0.5313714147,
1.0407061577,
-0.0568705313,
1.0050364733,
-0.1130737439,
0.2351813465,
1.3133300543,
-0.4331541359,
1.1350030899,
0.542212069,
-0.5902402401,
0.8548243046,
0.4975928068,
0.4506037235,
0.3490219414,
0.4665238857,
-0.1581170112,
-0.4314671755,
0.0676298067,
-0.1647908092,
0.0776693374,
0.4147687852,
-0.4139143825,
0.0066266079,
-0.4486249685,
-0.2137525529,
0.5117288232,
-0.2102017105,
0.6205394864,
-0.0535609238,
-1.0991754532,
0.8546261787,
-0.2354281247,
0.2459231615,
-0.2558709681,
-0.4054435492,
-0.0475864708,
0.3606621027,
-0.2261071801,
-1.2034387589,
0.2858014405,
0.0572936013,
-0.2324066758,
-0.1819111258,
0.6325820684,
-0.1970932782,
-0.379009068,
0.4649014175,
0.7295185924,
0.2250044793,
-0.090548858,
-0.6733763814,
0.1731231362,
-0.0621905103,
-0.0735680535,
0.0369094275,
0.42226547,
-0.2363832742,
0.8345661163,
0.5122138262,
0.1058391705,
-0.0350635163,
0.0907779112,
0.5884337425,
-0.4490547478,
-0.3518022299,
-0.6282058954,
0.3315293789,
-0.1201237887,
-0.3913992941,
0.5283330679,
0.6259939075,
1.0821948051,
0.1405670196,
0.7427858114,
0.0566823035,
0.7661151886,
-0.5632081032,
0.1117145121,
-0.2157361954,
0.6275594234,
-0.3204571009,
-0.7223109603,
-0.0828329697,
0.6097463965,
-0.2342066318,
-0.1097162291,
1.1516685486,
1.0060671568,
0.0839456916,
0.1788795739,
0.131994307,
0.1869146079,
0.3305784166,
0.7003498673,
0.7314689755,
-0.8552075624,
0.495438993,
-0.538967669,
-0.3743391037,
0.0727018416,
-0.8976151943,
-0.8609479666,
-0.4545273483,
-0.8118342757,
-0.9391903877,
0.3636141121,
0.5860875845,
0.4569735825,
-0.9692137837,
-0.182740286,
-0.6821943521,
0.4565339088,
-0.9348561168,
-0.1967635602,
0.3132953644,
-0.1669376194,
-0.4209299982,
0.4407165945,
0.3460353613,
-0.1467230469,
-0.1661272049,
-0.2280659676,
-0.4243248105,
0.1487559527,
0.4357863367,
0.2364227772,
-1.0888233185,
-0.6398056746,
-0.1537121534,
-0.0309388991,
0.0993898064,
0.9008184075,
-0.8890634179,
0.4117283821,
0.6814891696,
0.2770411074,
0.402830869,
0.1311776191,
0.740762651,
-0.6204840541,
-0.5699964762,
0.070179373,
0.2854386568,
0.2227162123,
-0.3559938073,
0.8753300905,
0.1086927354,
-0.6244511008,
-0.7869812846,
0.3371663094,
-0.8929597139,
-0.2198622376,
1.1075313091,
-0.5420184135,
-0.204701364,
-0.3285082281,
-0.1816737801,
0.111232549,
-0.3147859871,
0.6640667915,
0.5906180739,
-0.552480042,
-0.0666521117,
-0.3272164464,
0.3556524813,
0.2481717318,
-0.8610125184,
0.533772409,
0.4195595086,
0.4761971235,
0.4495037198,
0.7860697508,
-0.057337977,
0.6956703067,
0.0385574661,
-0.3109764159,
0.0600356609,
-0.4415522218,
-0.0529542379,
0.2741130292,
0.3542533219,
-0.1946816295
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10527v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10527v1
|
Zero-shot sampling of adversarial entities in biomedical question answering
| 2024-02-16T09:29:38 | 2024-02-16T09:29:38 |
R. Patrick Xian, Alex J. Lee, Vincent Wang, Qiming Cui, Russell Ro, Reza Abbasi-Asl
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR, stat.AP
|
The increasing depth of parametric domain knowledge in large language models
(LLMs) is fueling their rapid deployment in real-world applications. In
high-stakes and knowledge-intensive tasks, understanding model vulnerabilities
is essential for quantifying the trustworthiness of model predictions and
regulating their use. The recent discovery of named entities as adversarial
examples in natural language processing tasks raises questions about their
potential guises in other settings. Here, we propose a powerscaled
distance-weighted sampling scheme in embedding space to discover diverse
adversarial entities as distractors. We demonstrate its advantage over random
sampling in adversarial question answering on biomedical topics. Our approach
enables the exploration of different regions on the attack surface, which
reveals two regimes of adversarial entities that markedly differ in their
characteristics. Moreover, we show that the attacks successfully manipulate
token-wise Shapley value explanations, which become deceptive in the
adversarial setting. Our investigations illustrate the brittleness of domain
knowledge in LLMs and reveal a shortcoming of standard evaluations for
high-capacity models.
|
[
-0.2719344497,
-1.1044188738,
0.92895329,
-0.3790614307,
0.0325988159,
-0.0481370091,
0.0004426605,
-0.2985400856,
0.2752991617,
0.6777176857,
-0.4248266816,
-0.3835324347,
-0.7762585282,
-0.1559722275,
-0.3752915561,
1.1163836718,
0.1009673625,
0.1963153332,
-0.4828231633,
-0.3327370286,
-0.0210410282,
-0.5220197439,
-0.5443048477,
-0.2077637166,
0.7972680926,
-0.2058355808,
0.7703698277,
0.5236058235,
0.5499538779,
0.1696440279,
-0.1765996665,
0.1252422184,
-0.4427898228,
0.3370918036,
-0.2926085293,
-0.6198058724,
-0.2259798348,
0.0802969486,
0.3481663465,
0.9930567741,
0.0044886461,
0.0023147913,
-0.2948465347,
0.3347840309,
-0.8520878553,
-0.2326887399,
-0.8730560541,
0.0779461637,
-0.3116555214,
-0.2814330161,
-0.4027530551,
0.047533676,
0.1894995272,
-0.6703401804,
0.4592352509,
0.0009240385,
0.9928548336,
0.596123457,
-0.1855040044,
-0.2941153646,
-0.4823500514,
0.9086889625,
-0.4249114394,
0.0255909916,
0.3624306619,
0.318664968,
-0.1667379886,
-0.4999759495,
-0.3800643682,
-0.253290385,
0.0783406943,
-0.1133657098,
-0.5132287145,
0.0925148875,
0.1970497966,
0.0410726704,
-0.5805058479,
-0.0221533421,
-0.4800157845,
-0.1571845859,
0.4802549481,
-0.0341358706,
0.3287167251,
-0.0359963737,
-0.5305873156,
-0.0272428803,
-0.7632815242,
-0.264373064,
0.2606379688,
0.158053875,
0.1698120683,
0.4351541698,
0.1079180837,
0.7834301591,
0.1259236187,
0.1978087872,
-0.0886230022,
-0.1173908189,
-0.3737751544,
-0.1989374757,
0.6168784499,
-0.0051394491,
0.0969327688,
-0.5399481654,
0.1542688906,
-0.4522410929,
0.6894561648,
-0.8279577494,
-0.2175886035,
0.4741597772,
-0.1142679974,
-0.3984820843,
-0.2193462551,
-0.6624830365,
-0.6290177107,
0.2394153178,
0.4034253061,
-0.731323123,
0.100244835,
-0.0084254276,
-0.3178834617,
0.1140782386,
0.2172833979,
-0.5161270499,
0.0813986287,
0.4975843728,
0.6052267551,
-0.0323655829,
-0.2241210341,
-0.6281934977,
0.0901727825,
-0.2238435,
0.6466859579,
-0.3448989987,
-0.4263967574,
-0.1827778816,
-0.1751335114,
-0.126846686,
-0.5947748423,
0.3253166378,
-0.8558307886,
0.0471871831,
-0.4555788338,
-0.5447452068,
-0.2398117036,
0.483569324,
-0.675222218,
0.6143526435,
0.2961185575,
-0.9608912468,
0.3339878321,
-0.4629233479,
-0.3051660657,
0.2498741001,
-0.2703054249,
-0.4822624922,
0.0358212776,
0.4412461519,
0.6554478407,
-0.0144687342,
0.1497537643,
-0.7856900692,
-0.1811193079,
0.5779089332,
-0.4574048519,
1.0303404331,
0.2332112342,
-0.1970878839,
-0.0755038485,
-0.6149086356,
0.0224671569,
0.3666255474,
0.1758958101,
-0.6969663501,
-0.1449655592,
-0.3100424409,
0.0354559086,
0.105275251,
-0.6753828526,
0.0441575907,
-0.4963017106,
0.2520415187,
0.4090792537,
0.4567871094,
0.3922532499,
-0.3888860941,
0.7403519154,
0.1419402212,
-0.0568214841,
0.0098600211,
-0.2800448835,
-0.239598766,
-0.5792273283,
0.2672268152,
0.3869780898,
-1.1544451714,
0.1762956381,
-0.1174986362,
-0.5713863969,
-0.656627357,
-0.0102039287,
0.5328535438,
0.4953450561,
0.7491424084,
0.108537674,
-0.1817474663,
-0.8393512964,
-0.314221859,
-0.0407149345,
-0.4089163244,
0.6021009684,
0.7102900147,
0.0487504043,
0.7538009286,
-0.6372123361,
-0.1209525838,
-0.1506586373,
-0.0811952427,
-0.3275521696,
0.1137062162,
0.7347208858,
-0.8702635169,
0.0865378454,
-0.6845673919,
-0.7925879359,
0.0645973086,
-0.2021712065,
-0.2250224203,
-0.3459468782,
0.4524563253,
-0.7768197656,
0.1560861915,
0.4815579355,
-0.1431092173,
0.3840029836,
-0.1866853833,
0.071247749,
-1.1480125189,
0.2464815825,
-0.031316936,
-0.186577782,
-0.8092210889,
0.5882433653,
0.0212065894,
-0.0497543328,
-0.6986729503,
0.6465365887,
-0.4334463179,
0.1851172894,
-0.1140635461,
0.4254876077,
0.3162022233,
0.2191645503,
-0.0648157746,
0.5646210909,
0.5517254472,
-0.5809757113,
0.2994020879,
0.2230607718,
0.0055505256,
0.7963660359,
-0.7510082126,
0.1015810519,
-0.3571566939,
0.3346504569,
-0.7049773932,
-0.2717208862,
0.0544649921,
-0.7454813719,
0.4923210442,
-0.1236381158,
-0.240202412,
-0.1561149955,
-0.3591604233,
0.533454299,
0.2859272659,
-0.3265098631,
0.2097550184,
0.672776103,
-0.007529615,
-0.7415297031,
-0.8751195669,
-0.0932490975,
-0.2317414135,
-0.3850472271,
0.3777014017,
0.1348540187,
-0.4666881263,
0.1163413599,
0.0691875145,
-0.1796303391,
0.3319779634,
0.3942905068,
0.2380462885,
-0.0126211857,
0.16098167,
-0.2863906324,
0.2192580104,
0.1424614489,
-0.3067260683,
0.3543836176,
0.2699224651,
-0.8043265343,
0.055810526,
0.220442012,
0.5361118913,
-0.1994866431,
0.8975043297,
0.4682770073,
-0.694006443,
-0.3212765753,
-0.404661268,
-0.2575929761,
-0.3949975669,
0.7130768895,
-0.1706302464,
-0.8292975426,
0.5134142637,
0.2888459861,
-0.0969877169,
0.4415170252,
0.6614498496,
0.0420480147,
0.6392396092,
0.2741664052,
-0.1316652447,
0.0467545278,
-0.2592621446,
0.2430438846,
-0.8429899812,
-0.2923383415,
-0.3878859282,
-0.1804312021,
-0.1495028287,
-0.9016746879,
0.5165085196,
-0.0067013088,
0.093058981,
0.2508193254,
-0.3641810119,
0.3449844718,
0.4228270054,
0.2762441635,
-0.1674508005,
0.0148257203,
-0.1544053257,
0.0502900667,
-0.6075869203,
-0.2201451063,
1.1750130653,
0.3295629919,
0.766343534,
-0.1429176629,
0.6750769019,
-0.0230481606,
0.2080400884,
-0.679908812,
0.3467251658,
-0.0543222316,
-0.908223331,
-0.3445319831,
-0.5143339634,
-1.0918672085,
0.116150707,
0.1524277031,
-0.6933577061,
0.0958598182,
-0.0580221117,
-0.9962406158,
0.7182064652,
-0.2202517539,
0.5044017434,
0.0343979374,
-0.1772373319,
0.1183168069,
-0.5515494943,
0.32284832,
0.0413594618,
0.1960130483,
-0.0903925598,
-0.0482071191,
0.5669254661,
-0.3198011518,
0.6470379233,
-0.3697494864,
-0.0544281453,
0.4713405967,
0.1952072978,
0.2431691736,
0.2061192542,
-0.2498252541,
0.1804378629,
0.0963388234,
-0.7797169089,
-0.5622245669,
0.7331635952,
-0.524897635,
-0.4623416364,
-0.3182022572,
-0.8533364534,
-0.4951578677,
-0.0198666342,
0.3981755674,
0.2383509874,
-0.3585025966,
0.4236270487,
1.0529857874,
-0.3899140656,
0.187482506,
0.5997813344,
0.3350014687,
-0.2807774246,
0.7528566122,
0.0824954584,
0.4565937221,
0.6091026068,
-0.3345616758,
-0.2316951752,
-0.6905183196,
-0.6801805496,
0.0728303194,
-0.4218707681,
-0.377931565,
-0.7886610031,
-0.2619365752,
-0.4169000983,
-0.3026031852,
-0.3044633567,
-0.3407036066,
-0.276900053,
-0.1643649936,
0.3160104156,
0.3223308921,
0.1927534342,
-0.0417055115,
-0.6943259835,
0.3701106012,
0.3396911025,
-0.0509275943,
-0.1877871752,
-0.5688098073,
-0.137330398,
0.3390218019,
-0.277066946,
-1.1894888878,
0.4938863814,
0.0630321652,
0.6307415962,
0.3466394544,
0.1471950263,
0.492819041,
-0.458181113,
0.9128648639,
-0.1802921742,
-0.3733249307,
0.4450684786,
-0.2373103648,
0.2697547078,
0.6185828447,
0.6257862449,
-0.3527237475,
-0.7118592858,
-0.9708523154,
-0.8043572307,
0.4269257188,
0.2340233475,
0.0563716181,
-0.1408321559,
0.5875208378,
-0.2345719635,
0.1215271577,
-0.3177007735,
-0.4814368188,
0.1321076006,
-0.0974480212,
0.0708303601,
-0.0177664645,
-0.6024622917,
0.2078410238,
0.6991428733,
-0.1888013929,
0.2684663534,
0.436263293,
-0.270629257,
-0.0665800571,
0.3303868175,
0.3327890933,
0.3178192079,
-0.0837785155,
0.2871648073,
0.3669272661,
-0.4431726336,
0.0994243771,
0.6315451264,
-0.3824132979,
-0.0597225018,
0.470751375,
0.4353903234,
0.1755520254,
-0.8496696949,
0.7689490318,
0.0340150818,
-0.2183789015,
-0.0982221961,
-0.0628803074,
0.0918576494,
0.1960092932,
0.3902105391,
0.0671639889,
0.22585769,
-0.3954931796,
0.5065616965,
0.9008119106,
-0.7988755703,
-0.2274826318,
0.7813072801,
-0.2506135106,
0.0400248393,
0.2948147655,
-0.314494431,
-0.3622567058,
0.8142775893,
0.2576178014,
0.6920598745,
-0.1671942025,
0.2856853306,
0.0138581963,
0.216599673,
0.3389728665,
0.0560477003,
0.1161470488,
-0.6879966855,
-0.1010971442,
-0.7145650983,
-0.5205238461,
0.4630157351,
-0.8429029584,
-0.1755700111,
-0.4832907617,
-0.1521862745,
0.4053344131,
0.0685328245,
-0.52126652,
0.2663725615,
0.2761152089,
0.6792765856,
-0.5389298797,
0.768083334,
0.6457384229,
-0.5004913211,
-0.6333062053,
0.150504753,
0.1242289841,
-1.0128655434,
0.5121366382,
-0.1574932486,
0.0658081397,
-0.3318928778,
-0.5975141525,
-0.826905787,
1.0325672626,
0.3936875463,
-0.164650619,
-0.3187016249,
-0.0016712674,
0.5991648436,
0.0611133166,
0.2704112828,
0.3725981414,
0.0263330005,
0.0522939265,
-0.5392305851,
0.3169160187,
-0.1338754147,
-0.2106143832,
0.1159440577,
-0.6197769642,
0.7363551259,
-0.5284924507,
-0.066949673,
0.1294846237,
0.530697763,
0.6058769822,
0.217081219,
0.3322433233,
0.6218571663,
0.8450676799,
0.0210175626,
1.2352970839,
-0.4757015705,
0.2712197602,
0.8703217506,
-0.2035523653,
0.5481374264,
0.6302468181,
-0.3137707412,
0.2406047732,
0.3741724193,
-0.2282531112,
0.3723145425,
0.4496591687,
-0.3669305742,
-0.1139017418,
-0.1527371407,
-0.2687880397,
0.2408047765,
0.5104774833,
-0.4507929981,
-0.4896256924,
0.1349443793,
0.3898837268,
-0.0814364105,
-0.0679494143,
0.5261183977,
0.1687300205,
-0.51415205,
0.5347832441,
0.1132104695,
0.5495749712,
-0.679527998,
0.1131222099,
0.0498191901,
0.172655493,
0.0780469552,
-0.633062005,
0.261269927,
0.0189927109,
-0.1056454033,
-0.1601639539,
0.6638288498,
-0.4517372847,
-0.3170212805,
0.1806559563,
0.5105584264,
0.1869014055,
-0.5155783296,
-0.7618994117,
-0.6211090088,
-0.2109115869,
-0.3794048429,
0.6270853877,
0.463948369,
0.1811273247,
0.7889313102,
0.5483179092,
0.4302728176,
-0.0904620588,
0.0349125192,
0.7526436448,
-0.2862258852,
-0.1817827821,
-0.9266707897,
0.0348507427,
-0.122264035,
-0.1421210617,
0.9489576817,
0.4615520835,
0.6682355404,
0.0943178311,
0.7060275674,
0.0304868631,
0.5135285854,
-0.2560822368,
1.0542707443,
-0.5415340662,
0.1666885018,
0.0339236781,
-0.1477257311,
-0.3424000442,
0.126302287,
-0.5257806778,
0.0617824793,
0.6550999284,
0.7957840562,
0.1044287905,
-0.2092916667,
0.6062112451,
0.1695539355,
0.393768698,
0.7067095637,
0.4271946549,
-0.4703829288,
0.743896246,
-0.3618766963,
-0.0915639326,
-0.1432052553,
-0.5604954958,
-0.8812142611,
-0.2880316377,
-0.3117827177,
-0.5143746138,
0.3331618309,
0.5053420067,
0.8821789026,
-0.9118369818,
0.6713986993,
0.2177906632,
0.1183072478,
-0.0368334092,
-0.2858463228,
0.454375267,
-0.2840003669,
-0.6640427709,
0.4461283684,
0.2662183344,
0.0499053821,
-0.5185881257,
0.4047111869,
-0.1895889044,
0.4677644074,
0.1763610244,
0.3531766534,
-0.6167788506,
-0.1620218903,
0.2009475231,
-0.3756231368,
-0.3005597889,
0.6979942918,
-0.8321082592,
0.3031113148,
0.2372856885,
0.8835451603,
0.1830964535,
0.1093387082,
0.3254295588,
-1.1162953377,
0.1453082114,
0.625280261,
0.3629889488,
0.482921958,
-0.6839782596,
0.091466777,
0.3240592182,
-0.4694749117,
-0.7765359282,
0.2086559385,
-0.6938843131,
-0.6534070969,
1.2605788708,
-0.4788001776,
-0.3408040106,
-0.0881525055,
0.162361607,
0.2178518474,
-0.0289716925,
0.7775347829,
0.6480028629,
-0.032991305,
0.3339577019,
-0.7808654904,
0.636161387,
0.4822430909,
-0.8286790848,
-0.0294306409,
0.2309712768,
0.467328161,
0.3315320611,
0.6352779865,
-0.3285223544,
0.2353750318,
0.2850187421,
-0.1285236031,
-0.1947909147,
-0.1714641303,
-0.3887720406,
0.6534578204,
-0.2362226695,
-0.2232439369
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10524v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10524v1
|
LLM Comparator: Visual Analytics for Side-by-Side Evaluation of Large Language Models
| 2024-02-16T09:14:49 | 2024-02-16T09:14:49 |
Minsuk Kahng, Ian Tenney, Mahima Pushkarna, Michael Xieyang Liu, James Wexler, Emily Reif, Krystal Kallarackal, Minsuk Chang, Michael Terry, Lucas Dixon
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Automatic side-by-side evaluation has emerged as a promising approach to
evaluating the quality of responses from large language models (LLMs). However,
analyzing the results from this evaluation approach raises scalability and
interpretability challenges. In this paper, we present LLM Comparator, a novel
visual analytics tool for interactively analyzing results from automatic
side-by-side evaluation. The tool supports interactive workflows for users to
understand when and why a model performs better or worse than a baseline model,
and how the responses from two models are qualitatively different. We
iteratively designed and developed the tool by closely working with researchers
and engineers at a large technology company. This paper details the user
challenges we identified, the design and development of the tool, and an
observational study with participants who regularly evaluate their models.
|
[
-0.579482913,
-0.7638711333,
0.6357693076,
0.4553606212,
-0.4776400626,
0.3728922009,
-0.1848508716,
-0.4313489199,
0.2293166369,
0.2491369545,
-0.6363110542,
-0.6135557294,
-0.7353174686,
-0.0556240268,
-0.5558895469,
0.5811992288,
-0.0538107082,
0.2224275321,
-0.8237081766,
-0.3376024961,
-0.7180271149,
-0.3033360839,
-0.968705833,
-0.410440594,
0.323846072,
0.365827769,
1.0989648104,
0.3692217767,
0.8290994763,
0.5027187467,
0.1689554453,
-0.336943239,
-0.5856679082,
0.3427030444,
0.0079603391,
-0.2787670195,
-0.5539088845,
-0.0832077339,
0.4561773539,
0.6126756668,
0.1051474512,
0.5397538543,
0.2702645659,
0.6028648019,
-0.2992527783,
0.4877755046,
-0.2742342651,
0.1389844716,
-0.087837562,
-0.3172152936,
-0.2290416062,
-0.4503456354,
-0.0522440635,
-0.4367898107,
-0.1804109961,
0.2058131099,
0.5808471441,
0.572619617,
-0.3741968572,
-0.1492360383,
-0.1702166796,
0.8026209474,
-0.7263780832,
0.385168165,
-0.287189573,
0.8211479187,
-0.0366951674,
-0.789513886,
-0.6038531065,
-0.2892746627,
-0.2594748139,
0.2593177855,
-0.6792970896,
-0.2728669643,
0.2776673138,
0.4465527534,
-0.8663398027,
0.4742521644,
-0.0158929229,
0.0181687064,
0.8624020815,
0.5752494931,
0.5567906499,
-0.1457396448,
-0.2135790288,
-0.2282015085,
-0.361748755,
0.1855163127,
0.3820129931,
-0.0536691882,
-0.4097901881,
0.7201188803,
-0.3855377138,
0.7379706502,
-0.0733384639,
0.1850942969,
0.3772012293,
-0.1280812025,
-0.2627938986,
-0.3268781602,
1.0257949829,
0.7254196405,
0.0726911128,
0.1278242618,
-0.4401270151,
0.0041182693,
-0.0136254365,
-0.9463297725,
-0.403434217,
0.2568634748,
-0.7105018497,
-0.3567696512,
-0.2814106345,
-0.9351369143,
-0.7280100584,
-0.3599162102,
0.6093223691,
0.3112528026,
-0.2228277475,
-0.1611852497,
-0.2057221085,
-0.1013810113,
0.5288828015,
-0.4474869072,
0.2372594774,
0.7102906704,
0.8176855445,
-0.5276259184,
-0.3076565862,
-0.9370764494,
-0.3962123096,
0.0061602616,
1.0451295376,
-0.682284236,
-0.5168265104,
-0.1837190241,
-0.3119190335,
0.1594875306,
-0.6969044209,
0.1858279109,
-0.4624931812,
-0.0489643142,
-0.1496080309,
-0.4562735558,
0.1711672843,
0.2273590714,
-0.9482263923,
0.9376717806,
0.000105967,
-1.0816756487,
0.5196669102,
-0.5455604196,
0.0227809791,
0.3794228733,
-0.7120857835,
-0.5550032258,
0.1536671221,
0.2982414961,
0.4486438036,
-0.5536035299,
0.1309403181,
-0.7470257282,
-0.3268655837,
0.3281401098,
-0.4231001437,
0.8649367094,
0.2135231197,
-0.1951990277,
0.7608836293,
-0.8824670315,
0.1698253751,
0.2351823002,
-0.2485985309,
-0.137297973,
0.0255637299,
0.0407228991,
0.2543039024,
0.5142458081,
-0.2720339894,
0.0911858156,
0.0338712335,
0.2067111433,
0.4987585545,
-0.036726322,
0.2369997203,
-0.1214666441,
0.8670790195,
-0.2523141801,
0.3381357789,
0.2922827899,
-0.4373978376,
-0.9111264944,
-0.3092389703,
0.1120903268,
0.3941222429,
-0.9338920712,
0.270129174,
-0.5035495758,
-0.5946125388,
-0.5444630384,
0.2586343288,
0.2014403641,
0.2985289097,
0.1650570482,
-0.3782176971,
-0.3978121579,
-1.0867587328,
-0.4487967193,
-0.1802081764,
-0.2964232564,
0.0444768518,
0.4411026835,
-0.1323256344,
0.7978988886,
-0.3976106048,
0.0909726992,
-0.3543785214,
0.529301703,
0.1745042503,
0.1162023023,
0.3786144853,
-0.5802750587,
-0.6250115037,
0.1175037995,
-0.8294296861,
-0.6262364984,
0.0904931948,
0.0904981047,
-0.0377734974,
0.7091331482,
-0.2767105103,
0.4698146582,
0.9110328555,
-0.1843426228,
0.4627397358,
-0.1362234652,
0.3239298165,
-0.7698749304,
0.1904046535,
-0.0419262536,
-0.2406426668,
-0.218715772,
0.2197817415,
-0.0813265741,
-0.2636465132,
-0.3381514251,
0.6995316148,
-0.4657622576,
-0.4656437337,
-0.3241823614,
0.2831583321,
0.0164170545,
0.1584478468,
-0.0325105414,
0.7416877747,
0.3347443044,
-0.0862162039,
0.7796263695,
0.1867732257,
-0.736530304,
0.7052053809,
-0.8737952709,
0.1557762623,
0.1974241138,
0.0590208992,
-1.0573093891,
-0.0086584175,
0.0148496171,
-0.4400795698,
-0.0757068545,
-0.1784650236,
-0.627117753,
-0.509986937,
-0.4970734715,
0.4043849111,
0.315248251,
-0.7675815225,
0.7754969597,
0.4065045416,
-0.4988028705,
-0.229894653,
-0.6292793751,
0.2319983989,
-0.402105093,
-0.9612303972,
-0.2118910551,
-0.4148459435,
-0.819498837,
-0.0686535239,
-0.1715993881,
-0.1026184112,
0.1275365353,
0.4568477869,
0.2778604627,
-0.1399710625,
-0.2294100821,
-0.0147427451,
-0.2902544737,
0.3163351715,
0.33545506,
0.3521152735,
-0.187715739,
-0.5514523387,
-0.3744263947,
0.2974317074,
0.4333162606,
-0.1832576096,
0.4042798281,
0.3299647868,
-0.0407973751,
-0.1865540147,
-0.6078514457,
0.2108223289,
-0.5261234641,
0.2269973159,
-0.6440526247,
-0.7409650087,
0.5722050667,
0.0431548469,
0.0180910248,
0.4015356898,
0.8375942707,
0.1556297988,
1.3895922899,
0.7256749272,
0.0734164119,
0.3818603158,
-0.1836615205,
0.246628195,
-0.2837859392,
-0.2676500678,
-0.4132630229,
-0.3175166845,
-0.4731064141,
-0.2954936326,
0.6173706055,
-0.1274875849,
0.0407508127,
0.1030805185,
-0.2427444905,
0.5319091678,
0.3405106068,
-0.2880299091,
0.6569852233,
-0.1042464525,
-0.0446277708,
-0.0495358482,
-0.4700532258,
-0.4442810416,
0.622707963,
0.3521311879,
0.8928752542,
0.0325827822,
0.6318494081,
0.454339087,
0.4748618305,
-0.9637529254,
0.7270068526,
-0.0339729376,
-0.0783282667,
-0.3674953282,
-0.5332821608,
-0.8734468222,
0.5028640628,
-0.2651945353,
-0.7531297207,
-0.0031461956,
0.1896999031,
-0.288425833,
-0.0348400176,
-0.85505265,
1.1157047749,
-0.3817659914,
-0.4758844078,
-0.263109982,
-0.3884273171,
0.0469653904,
-0.168698743,
0.2830424607,
0.0332698636,
0.0597831383,
0.592675209,
-0.5627372265,
0.3726649284,
-0.0958541855,
-0.2711027861,
0.0777899548,
0.2782251239,
0.4513474703,
0.1074508876,
-0.232225731,
0.1965907216,
0.1089444458,
-0.2515614033,
-0.9799961448,
0.9936006069,
-0.406399399,
-0.8486052752,
-0.3748347461,
-0.6491352916,
-0.2693249285,
0.2054103017,
0.0989924148,
0.2719276547,
-0.1702063382,
0.1988670528,
-0.0655641183,
-0.4124970138,
0.4664951563,
0.5415368676,
-0.623329699,
-0.2739714682,
0.775401473,
-0.002715864,
0.2290592045,
0.3324777186,
0.1128869653,
-0.3423198462,
-0.6861824393,
-0.528293848,
-0.1470795572,
-0.9660021067,
0.0226091146,
-0.4358815849,
-0.0220037457,
-0.0526269972,
-0.0914715156,
-0.1918596327,
-0.4069316387,
0.1166955978,
0.1578382701,
-0.0048932405,
0.9631655812,
0.1224647388,
0.241556555,
-0.3899126351,
0.2242604345,
0.5518491268,
0.4135128558,
0.0426074602,
-0.1783697754,
-0.3661375046,
-0.2478746474,
-0.1184920594,
-0.4757737219,
0.4441850185,
-0.5262516737,
0.4579778612,
0.2545799315,
-0.1586986184,
0.6545448303,
-0.3354232311,
0.5925872922,
0.2185336053,
-0.9685202241,
0.2437848896,
-0.0816020295,
0.6155567765,
0.5854290724,
0.1880460232,
-0.2520383298,
-0.447437197,
-0.2715132833,
-0.8283143044,
0.3273667395,
0.2265397757,
-0.340750128,
0.2920901179,
-0.416654706,
0.3527559638,
0.2258164734,
-0.6810272336,
-0.1533329189,
0.0274734627,
-0.2043456435,
-0.2582054138,
-0.0806215927,
-0.0171182845,
-0.1012594402,
0.3343992829,
-0.1049436554,
-0.0859634727,
-0.4095543027,
-0.3757765889,
-0.0752665251,
0.2546239495,
0.0614951737,
1.143206358,
-0.1213880703,
0.1368694603,
0.407348305,
0.0952219516,
-0.2420567721,
0.3911538124,
0.1638090163,
-0.0569240041,
0.4886007905,
0.781483829,
0.018342467,
-0.7274577022,
0.7979214191,
-0.3993944526,
0.1297786534,
-0.2353916317,
-0.1154545471,
0.2094990611,
0.6433085203,
0.2179377377,
-0.2927521169,
0.6379444003,
-0.3674662411,
0.0205275603,
0.5921869278,
-0.1611638665,
0.0021391988,
0.6544146538,
0.3907304108,
-0.4404705465,
0.1556582898,
-0.0893005878,
-0.3208473921,
0.6710339189,
0.0629138723,
0.7790261507,
0.0667511746,
0.0387955457,
-0.1206725612,
0.0863634124,
0.2111323178,
0.2622466385,
-0.1164512411,
-0.0842996538,
-0.4572179615,
-0.5483547449,
-0.7630534768,
0.2932582796,
-0.8995569348,
0.50423944,
-0.1458760351,
-0.2003764063,
0.486230433,
0.0835045278,
-0.9508930445,
0.2777091265,
0.129286617,
0.7132816911,
-0.8164131045,
0.6275266409,
0.7308974266,
-0.4491117001,
-0.3980893791,
-0.0382765606,
0.2429584563,
-0.9250652194,
0.7651010156,
0.1477311105,
-0.3910472393,
-0.1841065735,
-0.3326531649,
-0.6166599989,
0.8962718844,
0.4706898928,
-0.7780721188,
0.4143621922,
0.2696070671,
0.8306927681,
-0.2438461483,
0.6661049724,
0.4740799665,
0.4376965761,
-0.1999306381,
-1.1212232113,
0.2204718143,
-0.5367504358,
-0.0147283245,
0.29554829,
-0.7365468144,
0.5923767686,
0.0758694634,
-0.1335223615,
0.0957179591,
0.6442518234,
0.0615359321,
0.6901655793,
0.6821507812,
0.5754510164,
0.3351565599,
0.133799836,
0.9910820723,
-0.182436347,
0.4753267765,
1.3415449858,
-0.2783386409,
0.9436487556,
0.6041623354,
-0.1818717718,
0.3426856101,
0.4706268311,
-0.290365994,
0.1859041005,
0.5452699661,
-0.1034636423,
-0.3118849695,
0.0120339403,
-0.2607179582,
0.2738229632,
0.0022982946,
-0.1126592755,
-0.3598187268,
-0.0608867779,
-0.1203478277,
0.136474669,
-0.27628842,
0.5702352524,
0.0720987171,
-0.5727005005,
0.4286740124,
-0.2175938487,
0.5155128837,
-0.2384199649,
-0.1195905134,
-0.3395340443,
0.1653824449,
-0.3142521083,
-1.1220564842,
0.1716405004,
0.1705181003,
0.0603653491,
-0.2804465592,
0.4367333055,
-0.1364340633,
-0.5423790812,
0.6111556888,
0.7189173102,
0.2749156654,
-0.014135262,
-0.9176498652,
0.7104254961,
-0.1491875052,
-0.4423867762,
0.233652249,
0.3306081593,
-0.2006473094,
1.1955187321,
0.3452928364,
-0.0622365028,
-0.0348756239,
0.5787000656,
0.9175323248,
-0.4586727917,
-0.4531110227,
-0.9235098958,
0.5758063793,
-0.3963829875,
-0.0681342855,
1.1209965944,
0.925704658,
0.8030189872,
0.0596345253,
0.7612558007,
0.1814197004,
0.3767193258,
-0.4727936685,
0.7432658076,
-0.8243012428,
0.6166222095,
-0.1501636058,
-0.9944698811,
-0.2911225557,
0.1548337936,
-0.4920089245,
0.0248503238,
0.7766899467,
0.5548318028,
-0.1663315296,
-0.0921364054,
0.4327626228,
0.3552483022,
0.3320795,
0.2881546021,
0.9996788502,
0.0636259392,
0.7185504436,
-0.216418311,
-0.300245136,
-0.1916381419,
-0.9557586908,
-1.2654495239,
-0.3326981962,
-0.4709739983,
-0.2031503916,
0.0213117152,
0.8224396706,
0.2881650627,
-0.8270644546,
-0.6750616431,
0.2440452725,
0.0486177802,
0.0927854478,
-0.1904968172,
0.1920386255,
0.0236057881,
-0.8328321576,
0.4222288132,
0.438978076,
-0.1706665456,
-0.426559329,
0.0865837187,
0.3865366876,
-0.0419451781,
0.5536833405,
-0.007797536,
-0.5442239046,
-0.0976540074,
-0.460921526,
0.0196188018,
0.1395946294,
0.6916230917,
-0.628318429,
0.706933558,
0.8748654723,
0.6144097447,
0.5984432697,
-0.0738438889,
0.5931445956,
-0.3331956565,
-0.1248444617,
-0.1383459568,
0.5250203609,
0.4264631271,
-0.1618579328,
0.4599297643,
-0.1963497549,
-0.6184014082,
-0.8953284025,
0.0941264927,
-1.0639023781,
-0.0934553817,
0.95863837,
-0.0457547046,
-0.0679389015,
0.1456166506,
-0.2471651137,
0.1692158282,
-0.4305709004,
0.8194660544,
0.7186684608,
-0.357919395,
0.0220379978,
-0.8179053068,
0.2094163448,
0.5002987385,
-1.0959954262,
-0.1823551655,
0.5795725584,
0.3901083767,
-0.1281637251,
0.2366745621,
0.1448719352,
0.1612432748,
0.1138240695,
0.1304336786,
-0.0855991393,
-0.0469651483,
-0.7614488006,
0.1127947345,
0.3224451244,
-0.022831751
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10500v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10500v2
|
Active Preference Optimization for Sample Efficient RLHF
| 2024-02-16T08:19:34 | 2024-06-05T15:10:08 |
Nirjhar Das, Souradip Chakraborty, Aldo Pacchiano, Sayak Ray Chowdhury
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) is pivotal in aligning
Large Language Models (LLMs) with human preferences. Although aligned
generative models have shown remarkable abilities in various tasks, their
reliance on high-quality human preference data creates a costly bottleneck in
the practical application of RLHF. One primary reason is that current methods
rely on uniformly picking prompt-generation pairs from a dataset of
prompt-generations, to collect human feedback, resulting in sub-optimal
alignment under a constrained budget, which highlights the criticality of
adaptive strategies in efficient alignment. Recent works [Mehta et al., 2023,
Muldrew et al., 2024] have tried to address this problem by designing various
heuristics based on generation uncertainty. However, either the assumptions in
[Mehta et al., 2023] are restrictive, or [Muldrew et al., 2024] do not provide
any rigorous theoretical guarantee. To address these, we reformulate RLHF
within contextual preference bandit framework, treating prompts as contexts,
and develop an active-learning algorithm, $\textit{Active Preference
Optimization}$ ($\texttt{APO}$), which enhances model alignment by querying
preference data from the most important samples, achieving superior performance
for small sample budget. We analyze the theoretical performance guarantees of
$\texttt{APO}$ under the BTL preference model showing that the suboptimality
gap of the policy learned via $\texttt{APO}$ scales as $O(1/\sqrt{T})$ for a
budget of $T$. We also show that collecting preference data by choosing prompts
randomly leads to a policy that suffers a constant sub-optimality. We perform
detailed experimental evaluations on practical preference datasets to validate
$\texttt{APO}$'s efficacy over the existing methods, establishing it as a
sample-efficient and practical solution of alignment in a cost-effective and
scalable manner.
|
[
-0.2564706504,
-0.843629837,
0.383983165,
-0.0421614498,
-0.1995497495,
-0.182199657,
-0.4779610932,
-0.2998128533,
0.0136584351,
0.4555018246,
-0.7789471745,
-0.2329928577,
-0.084446311,
-0.1560165435,
0.1415958852,
0.8709743619,
-0.1770470291,
-0.1701046675,
-0.0652425289,
-0.230962351,
-0.3162180781,
-0.161641255,
-0.6112907529,
-0.3280460536,
0.6144816279,
0.6863365173,
0.8774707913,
0.9436841607,
0.1232208237,
0.2084865272,
-0.0466150716,
0.4058701098,
-0.4672676325,
0.4763436615,
-0.0213345401,
-0.301592052,
-0.2286720574,
-0.021561902,
0.548599422,
0.4391127527,
-0.6334043741,
-0.0628496557,
-0.1385413557,
0.7216684222,
-0.8091414571,
0.0050022784,
-0.6525442004,
0.2028838396,
-0.112728402,
-0.1118934676,
-0.4904816747,
-0.5671854019,
0.3671760857,
-0.8603346944,
0.24167566,
0.3159277737,
1.0781902075,
0.4195862412,
-0.2972610891,
-0.2684569955,
-0.6723082662,
0.9009354115,
-0.454076618,
0.2845901251,
0.4434989989,
0.3729583621,
-0.1406246424,
-0.4102570713,
-0.4707883596,
-0.2313618958,
0.0984539092,
0.3097630441,
-0.0362570137,
0.2423057258,
0.2020348608,
0.2139027864,
-0.4311163425,
0.2455970794,
-0.1488395035,
-0.2923841178,
0.7157287598,
-0.0214387663,
-0.0340495072,
-0.2077149749,
-0.4498196542,
-0.4175614715,
-0.6436436772,
0.3931716681,
0.6856257915,
0.4562324584,
-0.0016591973,
0.4544583857,
-0.1689192057,
0.9068353772,
0.3001756072,
-0.1637554318,
0.092002973,
-0.2294121534,
-0.0829012468,
0.0721149817,
0.7361692786,
0.1336190999,
0.3000224829,
0.0975502729,
-0.4712350368,
-0.1705110371,
0.4334338903,
-0.4657004178,
-0.2061152011,
0.2829612792,
-0.2682347,
-0.307280153,
-0.0322327018,
-0.8028980494,
-0.2752245367,
-0.1979860663,
0.3195612729,
-0.1357808113,
-0.0644633919,
-0.1458129138,
0.2259179652,
0.1764007956,
0.4018558264,
-1.0446562767,
-0.096386686,
0.3903950155,
0.5909183621,
-0.3682021201,
-0.2890233397,
-0.6886357069,
-0.067468971,
-0.4077926576,
0.7921299338,
-0.4492417872,
-0.5400195122,
0.225420922,
-0.2148515433,
-0.1284203529,
-0.6468282938,
0.730522573,
-0.7394967079,
0.2652666569,
-0.3722518682,
-0.4062891901,
0.0516088866,
0.0585837774,
-0.7207238674,
0.9844625592,
0.234460175,
-0.4111733437,
0.691215694,
-0.4908944368,
-0.2286647111,
-0.0842508227,
-0.1244933829,
-0.906476438,
-0.1389104724,
0.3375895023,
0.1895538419,
0.0400247276,
0.3290579319,
-0.4992699623,
-0.2873216271,
0.3055494726,
-0.4363614023,
0.6516168118,
0.4213980734,
-0.3481616974,
0.6175992489,
-0.4550964236,
-0.0260142926,
-0.0072634765,
-0.6322678328,
-0.1042537466,
0.1486734003,
-0.0723673105,
-0.155487448,
0.1797520816,
-0.3416639566,
0.370256871,
-0.3257261515,
0.281106174,
1.1213086843,
0.0675008819,
0.6174299717,
-0.3233950436,
0.7650811672,
-0.3049538136,
0.3089550138,
0.0469806567,
-0.1254370213,
-0.4043226838,
-0.2995637059,
0.5731869936,
0.4298846424,
-0.5396392345,
0.5212546587,
0.0135316299,
-0.0445751697,
-0.5775119066,
0.1190264747,
0.522044003,
0.6832808852,
0.3492655456,
-0.0764523894,
-0.4633713067,
-1.0851317644,
-0.1508948803,
-0.3043338358,
0.1948564053,
0.7018477917,
-0.0985517353,
0.100279212,
1.1454654932,
-0.6003727913,
-0.0159911904,
-0.2992041409,
0.0834473595,
0.0902910233,
0.3565787375,
0.3685281873,
-0.7971663475,
-0.6063566208,
-0.1590916067,
-0.3620664775,
-0.2170691043,
-0.0305852778,
-0.2810463309,
0.374148339,
0.1289578229,
-0.4975615442,
0.1069978923,
0.5437632203,
-0.2333238721,
0.339951992,
-0.2101332098,
-0.0715873763,
-0.7481199503,
0.008385146,
-0.0363091566,
-0.2364127338,
-0.3083339036,
-0.0168608148,
0.1889253706,
0.0613660663,
-0.4021095335,
0.6940620542,
-0.4306115508,
-0.054541558,
-0.3278820515,
-0.0504739173,
-0.3195213079,
0.704986155,
0.2278586179,
1.0145142078,
0.2243651748,
-0.5037539601,
0.3037283123,
0.1348453909,
-0.2724662721,
0.3661265671,
-0.5415289402,
0.0511551946,
-0.0675785542,
0.3747680485,
-0.8332685828,
-0.4072103798,
0.2979864478,
-0.3982614875,
0.401620239,
-0.1365043819,
-0.0109670674,
-0.1048356667,
-0.1842085123,
0.4572039545,
0.6850670576,
-0.6988978982,
0.4680482745,
0.5122129321,
0.0820161477,
-1.0319210291,
-0.0393300839,
-0.4633107483,
-0.2698840797,
-0.2938820124,
0.2136622965,
0.1715883613,
-0.1873425543,
0.1076927632,
-0.3581885099,
0.2615693808,
0.0393529534,
0.0075955265,
0.4205177426,
0.0712424442,
0.0403598174,
-0.0481121875,
-0.2125805467,
-0.2139428407,
-0.2740810215,
0.3210220933,
0.1036289558,
-0.3878750205,
-0.0899048373,
0.0365748256,
0.3222584426,
-0.1058046222,
0.2407104671,
0.4072468877,
-0.1241989657,
-0.5165413618,
-0.4509141445,
-0.2195769995,
-0.4233185947,
0.3166284859,
-0.2206202447,
-0.7438277602,
0.3144097924,
0.1975419074,
0.4631451368,
0.2987126708,
0.4327366948,
-0.1254477799,
0.9526811242,
0.2867554724,
-0.0060238168,
0.8120657802,
-0.074808538,
-0.06062961,
-0.6383239031,
-0.062559016,
-0.3957021236,
-0.3933451474,
-0.4793625772,
-0.2936500013,
0.5076134801,
0.1863220185,
-0.2498666048,
0.0760497227,
-0.4805474877,
0.336222142,
0.8178617358,
0.2287351042,
0.0120271211,
-0.0417178012,
-0.2201277018,
-0.0094888201,
-0.9123342037,
-0.3750819564,
1.1509150267,
0.2758846581,
0.9742134213,
0.1247492507,
0.6557919979,
0.3719443679,
0.2772304714,
-0.9777982235,
0.4181024134,
0.0697214007,
-0.5558760166,
-0.7446883917,
-0.5212404728,
-1.1967973709,
0.329346329,
-0.3859000504,
-0.4536007047,
0.4713687897,
0.7890013456,
-0.6964126229,
0.0915235132,
-0.734847188,
0.7646411061,
-0.2079049498,
-0.6999490857,
-0.0515530184,
-0.7687475085,
0.402171582,
0.1175809577,
0.0187828578,
-0.144158259,
-0.0457982123,
0.7720282078,
-0.3868418336,
0.7015968561,
-0.5297290683,
-0.0843891874,
0.3791261017,
-0.1663363427,
0.8385589123,
0.165975064,
-0.0328810662,
-0.4490876794,
-0.1771392971,
-0.5862910748,
-0.5101139545,
0.5288847685,
-1.0217967033,
-0.6059304476,
-0.4409872591,
-0.4245750606,
-0.4889780879,
0.0525840111,
0.2577773631,
0.2910067737,
-0.133686319,
0.1268977225,
1.0263897181,
-0.0551700369,
0.5261315703,
0.3993114531,
-0.0811976492,
-0.6492105126,
0.711089313,
-0.038348835,
0.4102929831,
0.3825956285,
0.4570326507,
-0.5839534402,
-0.4510780275,
-0.7818975449,
0.1138361543,
-0.4147618711,
-0.2354587764,
-0.4306969047,
0.0648391023,
-0.2794387341,
-0.2255975604,
-0.4469869435,
-0.3979187012,
-0.1477725059,
-0.1259183437,
0.275701344,
0.2468356937,
-0.1469899267,
0.2225659341,
-0.5976809263,
0.2381283045,
0.6999415159,
0.105574578,
0.0852595344,
-0.3592473865,
-0.2170620859,
-0.0098109329,
-0.3130050898,
-0.8158408403,
0.2407200634,
-0.0414646938,
0.7884088159,
0.574768424,
0.5428474545,
0.6635445356,
-0.2496614903,
0.6209007502,
-0.0711743832,
-0.6955415606,
0.4593608677,
-0.4304528236,
0.248670876,
0.8395831585,
0.1662054807,
-0.3485408723,
0.0342310332,
-0.7626377344,
-1.0836158991,
0.9340461493,
-0.027410714,
-0.0957994759,
0.268242538,
0.4770435095,
0.0643445924,
0.1668787003,
-0.5538637638,
-0.1876688451,
-0.1857788563,
-0.2139797211,
-0.028394144,
-0.1815567613,
-0.448397845,
0.1174517199,
0.9034346342,
-0.2946290374,
0.1078243479,
0.1873880476,
0.1227659732,
-0.5214853883,
0.3859859705,
0.6716649532,
0.5518019795,
-0.4302757978,
0.0314646214,
0.0066945669,
-0.3832309246,
0.2442248613,
0.1497920454,
-0.6135348082,
-0.2377761602,
0.2952881157,
1.034145236,
0.1686642468,
-0.8315301538,
0.4693300724,
0.0116305696,
-0.2252966315,
-0.2331178933,
0.3287768066,
-0.2313381881,
0.0995347053,
0.4279785156,
0.0256736148,
-0.1411719173,
-0.495084554,
0.2650913298,
0.6625546813,
-0.5985393524,
-0.1503794193,
0.4448264837,
0.3300827742,
-0.3951208889,
0.5283391476,
-0.1968831271,
-0.5083591342,
0.5221546888,
0.4105080366,
0.8159044385,
-0.2331761271,
0.168348521,
0.5009461045,
-0.054991696,
-0.3284190893,
0.1532255411,
-0.3955791295,
-0.9863636494,
-0.1459283829,
-0.6221737862,
-0.7159392238,
-0.097702913,
-0.8600074649,
0.1859640032,
-0.352540642,
-0.0743918419,
-0.4100455642,
0.2004037201,
-0.2712817192,
0.1396817863,
-0.3198944032,
0.5982582569,
-0.7368260622,
0.7861505747,
0.7601364851,
-0.1648528874,
-0.9874484539,
0.250526458,
0.0011460352,
-1.1215020418,
0.2575086057,
-0.3430264294,
0.0388337672,
0.0403202847,
-0.4653457999,
-0.8842071891,
0.9961604476,
0.1566387266,
-0.5606819391,
-0.1369962692,
-0.6421562433,
0.1838291287,
-0.2868004143,
0.1031414643,
0.4850191474,
0.6080377102,
0.3683495224,
-0.7756103873,
0.0822943673,
0.1124426872,
-0.0835693404,
0.4873538911,
-0.8447269797,
0.5700139403,
-0.3511151373,
-0.2680921257,
-0.047121942,
0.7806364298,
0.744662106,
0.2307311296,
0.8727462292,
0.5763266683,
0.7160320878,
-0.0073502031,
0.872633636,
-0.1779787689,
0.4431191087,
0.9727398157,
-0.2382432222,
0.8110927343,
0.5570952296,
-0.4181904197,
0.208427161,
1.0254508257,
0.053224884,
0.8428453803,
0.1967915148,
-0.3068901002,
-0.3951660693,
-0.0815332606,
-0.1941513121,
0.1557787806,
0.0185923446,
-0.1829725802,
-0.133562386,
-0.2900986969,
-0.0180223268,
0.272177279,
-0.1096417084,
0.9783951044,
-0.2802379131,
-1.2601501942,
0.5634391308,
-0.0899720043,
0.6886377931,
-0.7539681196,
0.0970727652,
-0.2920291126,
0.1229885519,
-0.0910377502,
-0.4961339235,
0.0272685066,
-0.2303222567,
-0.2254855335,
-0.3721809685,
0.4000017643,
-0.4373163581,
-0.1056091785,
-0.1041652039,
0.3559189737,
-0.2200722992,
0.5335624814,
-0.728836894,
-0.0536034815,
0.2539170086,
-0.5131305456,
0.3936537206,
0.1812606603,
-0.1383977979,
0.4020306766,
0.7655462027,
0.3393730819,
-0.1453368962,
-0.0666550696,
0.5580358505,
-0.5209997296,
-0.570602715,
-0.6066704988,
0.2839138806,
-0.0196080003,
-0.5745906234,
0.4977151155,
0.4788125455,
0.7652903795,
0.1367125064,
0.8546729088,
0.0619830601,
0.532755971,
-0.7438304424,
0.3042639196,
-0.5282402635,
0.3642937541,
0.0659816787,
-0.8763347864,
-0.0190598331,
0.7497776151,
-0.2502045631,
0.152548179,
0.5044677854,
0.7975159883,
-0.0400645919,
-0.1192877665,
0.1431188285,
-0.1781185269,
0.1359919161,
0.4917181134,
0.7689747214,
0.018231282,
0.5875661969,
-0.3312579393,
-0.3780936599,
-0.2576921284,
-0.8080856204,
-0.5003099442,
-0.4672623873,
-0.1711875796,
-0.5610876679,
0.3103247881,
1.3704191446,
0.885501802,
-0.7642038465,
-0.2649302185,
-0.199431181,
0.3669172823,
-0.5152006149,
-0.2668991685,
0.5448320508,
-0.4363770485,
-0.8499383926,
0.3222770393,
-0.0168881677,
0.141677022,
-0.3320633769,
-0.3425027132,
-0.129022032,
0.1231932193,
0.2099216133,
0.7340351343,
-0.9375101924,
-0.2570365667,
0.1448186487,
-0.1234996095,
0.0114856558,
1.0017110109,
-0.6300464869,
0.4118229747,
0.4660120308,
0.7897164226,
0.4990167916,
0.5097556114,
0.7266682386,
-0.668332994,
-0.1293783188,
0.3707029521,
0.2561403811,
0.1268249601,
-0.5407065749,
0.4356898069,
0.2698936462,
-0.8050857782,
-0.9662256241,
0.4623256922,
-1.0298959017,
-0.3914385438,
1.3657011986,
-0.1899129003,
-0.1679635495,
-0.038154088,
-0.2317452431,
0.1696775407,
-1.0005556345,
0.9396112561,
0.5484371781,
-0.5887682438,
-0.3132018447,
-0.2539923489,
0.7713978887,
0.6462157369,
-0.4632892609,
0.2646265924,
0.6803608537,
-0.0000489156,
-0.1713620573,
0.7369887233,
0.2242196202,
0.3709079623,
-0.2292018533,
-0.0292020794,
-0.1078211293,
-0.2118788213,
-0.4418322146,
0.3673006892,
0.3230392039,
-0.2742402852
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10496v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10496v2
|
Comparing Hallucination Detection Metrics for Multilingual Generation
| 2024-02-16T08:10:34 | 2024-06-16T00:44:28 |
Haoqiang Kang, Terra Blevins, Luke Zettlemoyer
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
While many hallucination detection techniques have been evaluated on English
text, their effectiveness in multilingual contexts remains unknown. This paper
assesses how well various factual hallucination detection metrics (lexical
metrics like ROUGE and Named Entity Overlap, and Natural Language Inference
(NLI)-based metrics) identify hallucinations in generated biographical
summaries across languages. We compare how well automatic metrics correlate to
each other and whether they agree with human judgments of factuality. Our
analysis reveals that while the lexical metrics are ineffective, NLI-based
metrics perform well, correlating with human annotations in many settings and
often outperforming supervised models. However, NLI metrics are still limited,
as they do not detect single-fact hallucinations well and fail for
lower-resource languages. Therefore, our findings highlight the gaps in
exisiting hallucination detection methods for non-English languages and
motivate future research to develop more robust multilingual detection methods
for LLM hallucinations.
|
[
-0.5709339976,
-0.5874372125,
0.6383610368,
0.3685451448,
-0.0167038739,
0.214623794,
-0.2726664245,
-0.7775338292,
0.8466700912,
0.4345725775,
-0.5280203819,
-0.6186340451,
-0.4347191453,
0.6087036729,
-0.3133680224,
0.9169235826,
0.1697660387,
0.1034568772,
-0.3659068346,
-0.3799297214,
-0.4421830177,
-0.7393351197,
-0.5559183359,
-0.0976320878,
0.5250067711,
0.0095754135,
0.7036184669,
0.0709650293,
0.438451618,
0.2664973438,
-0.0034326452,
0.7481889725,
-0.3203649223,
0.354378283,
0.0919474214,
-0.2865207791,
-0.330294013,
-0.1649926156,
0.4905300438,
0.7809989452,
-0.0301169604,
-0.0175761506,
-0.0997318923,
0.5848254561,
-0.8226116896,
-0.1040544286,
-0.5390748978,
0.4348751307,
-0.0313085578,
-0.5222240686,
-0.5352894664,
-0.5239849687,
-0.1412903816,
-0.2026049793,
0.5494354963,
0.0266332775,
0.694449544,
0.352950871,
-0.4083222151,
-0.7436512709,
-0.6625519991,
0.6372001171,
-0.62926054,
0.826233685,
0.3865731359,
0.2349926531,
0.0719797537,
-0.3036417365,
-0.6440722942,
-0.5003154874,
-0.558005929,
0.1121565327,
-0.0867832676,
-0.2531938553,
0.3889133632,
0.3017118275,
-0.9091804624,
0.1443152279,
-0.4030492604,
-0.7087894082,
0.5869754553,
0.0921145752,
0.3924314976,
-0.4414069057,
-0.0338188075,
0.176360786,
-0.5276443362,
-0.3805614412,
0.8172249198,
0.269123286,
-0.2139879912,
0.350371182,
-0.1233575642,
0.427259624,
-0.3647306263,
-0.5504996181,
0.5491718054,
-0.5447286367,
0.2549181879,
0.2602669001,
0.8895166516,
0.5195182562,
0.4826569259,
-0.7105435729,
-0.0580235347,
0.1634687632,
0.1045366898,
-0.5509545803,
-0.2152410895,
0.3286580741,
-0.3128876388,
-0.0253046006,
0.3367022872,
-1.0752332211,
-0.7026603818,
-0.1389263868,
0.1542763561,
-0.4417060316,
-0.4216373861,
-0.0827230588,
-0.3244108558,
0.3069653809,
0.1174663231,
-0.8011871576,
0.1189812347,
0.58912462,
1.1595392227,
-0.681018889,
-0.5467243791,
-0.5802354813,
-0.1342201531,
-0.4558445811,
0.8887203932,
-0.1668582708,
-0.2658692896,
0.1751191914,
0.2389938086,
-0.0910331234,
-0.8482289314,
0.5187215805,
-0.0075531574,
0.2933645546,
-0.2759102285,
-0.1658687741,
-0.2848604321,
0.1066012532,
-0.8024062514,
0.93839252,
-0.1641384959,
-0.7897673249,
0.698079288,
-0.0795297697,
-0.6341193318,
-0.0492300689,
-0.2209820002,
-0.4252650738,
0.16765742,
0.1339011043,
0.5932037234,
0.0717724413,
0.3893019855,
-0.1466892511,
-0.5565075874,
0.1733675301,
-0.5075501204,
0.7711031437,
-0.038882304,
-0.5407651663,
-0.0838793069,
-0.8574860692,
-0.262717098,
-0.0707328096,
0.0807358176,
-0.2475794554,
-0.0301393885,
0.050977461,
0.0162342247,
-0.0343658887,
-0.3091763258,
-0.2002187669,
-0.2546405196,
-0.1283973902,
0.2139982432,
0.1648358554,
-0.0814112723,
-0.3253951371,
0.3510135114,
-0.0191192571,
-0.3102710247,
-0.0740884319,
-0.463413924,
-0.8032847047,
-0.3700883985,
-0.0765533969,
0.680605948,
-0.5122233629,
0.7901309729,
-0.2831109166,
-0.3352665007,
-0.3958181739,
0.0144767156,
0.1356020868,
0.2781787217,
0.3918542266,
-0.1583462209,
-0.7124978304,
-1.0473598242,
-0.3456594944,
-0.4379775226,
0.0163518097,
0.1656455845,
0.6842052937,
-0.2459751517,
0.4833910167,
-0.2294384837,
-0.4239414334,
-0.2857042253,
0.215319559,
-0.1137981638,
0.0410907827,
0.7196344733,
-0.6529497504,
-0.3265661597,
0.1658385396,
-1.3047078848,
-0.1514185071,
-0.5051189661,
0.1437254399,
0.7388976812,
0.4747994542,
-0.4808386862,
0.5428330302,
0.4278836548,
-0.3999895453,
0.8790338635,
-0.1238638684,
0.6278548241,
-0.8795017004,
0.0166137535,
-0.116138801,
-0.1956792474,
-0.6191589832,
-0.0029826155,
-0.03636178,
0.4035245478,
-0.2995039523,
0.3890748918,
-0.5660158992,
-0.2944065332,
-0.0368984379,
0.4695222378,
-0.1435244828,
0.3405024707,
0.2118309289,
0.8260185719,
0.4987325668,
-0.5903303027,
0.2995257974,
0.1070313007,
-0.442033112,
0.6330292225,
-0.1027563214,
0.0278776642,
-0.1521216333,
-0.0308063477,
-1.0574270487,
-0.3991980255,
0.2025485784,
-0.5547825098,
0.1263132393,
0.3610804975,
-0.5410179496,
-0.1526872367,
-0.5902122855,
0.0772915483,
0.3307634294,
-0.6834478378,
0.605979681,
0.3344449997,
0.1021514237,
-0.6759630442,
-0.8015576005,
0.4902230203,
-0.4326184392,
-0.4204162061,
0.0976130515,
0.0116821621,
-0.5495995283,
-0.3556642532,
-0.0955643207,
-0.1391918361,
0.0272659305,
0.2295835763,
0.2000203282,
-0.2479230464,
-0.1192414984,
0.0744822472,
0.0427512303,
0.2699532509,
0.1702278852,
0.5597076416,
0.0153473439,
-0.3133709431,
-0.6588767767,
0.4044767618,
0.7650751472,
0.1434523612,
1.0709042549,
0.8627195358,
-0.6277500987,
0.0424077921,
-0.9450942278,
-0.352039516,
-0.3205941319,
0.4796521366,
-0.4257974327,
-0.49099195,
0.7587972879,
0.2871064842,
-0.0006977796,
0.3881792724,
0.6567006111,
0.2429874092,
0.8740734458,
0.4101445079,
0.0406781808,
-0.1587764472,
-0.163913995,
0.5779063106,
-0.6230732203,
-0.3222948909,
-0.3653095365,
-0.0490984581,
-0.8529452085,
-0.0941138566,
0.1901509464,
-0.138182953,
0.3274187744,
0.2865405977,
-0.4173592627,
0.5181565285,
0.0675629303,
-0.164442271,
0.6504317522,
0.1549827605,
0.145962581,
-0.3530254066,
-0.2810292244,
-0.7188630104,
0.6937860847,
-0.0011292592,
0.2081062347,
0.4262726605,
0.7102484107,
0.4206677675,
0.1001130641,
-0.7701650858,
0.5113174319,
-0.0474303029,
-0.5108578205,
-0.2707782984,
-0.4719161093,
-0.7633954883,
0.5519839525,
-0.3601821661,
-1.0220843554,
0.1694501191,
-0.1115528569,
-0.4247769117,
0.5042089224,
-0.6346116066,
0.6667445898,
-0.2108394504,
-0.2031364739,
-0.1599214375,
-0.4329091609,
0.5993339419,
-0.2356972396,
0.3791986108,
-0.1410224587,
-0.0434087589,
0.7279632688,
-0.0628620163,
0.7112298608,
-0.0722825006,
-0.2272498757,
0.0993732736,
0.2164780945,
0.0854719728,
0.2755347192,
0.0303272754,
0.5727897286,
0.1224036813,
-0.0783677921,
-0.5312852859,
0.7638735771,
-0.3678444922,
-0.5702643394,
-0.5219216943,
-0.5282746553,
-0.2426535189,
-0.1258334368,
0.6502462626,
0.3143108487,
-0.424770385,
0.0177822094,
0.3253331184,
-0.34817487,
0.4047090411,
0.3987675607,
-0.3174828589,
-0.2951976061,
1.1230282784,
0.1372484267,
0.050999634,
0.2468935549,
-0.0175246578,
-0.2497778535,
-0.5150929093,
-0.458792448,
0.6463433504,
-0.8322163224,
0.077429302,
-1.1569039822,
-0.2817402482,
-0.6127373576,
-0.1447585523,
-0.1890163273,
-0.2718607783,
-0.0032268441,
-0.1847856045,
0.140205428,
0.6743158102,
-0.2357019931,
-0.1344115734,
-0.4474453926,
0.5339003205,
-0.1434440166,
-0.0975600928,
0.1201569289,
-0.5640346408,
-0.144536674,
-0.2890329659,
-0.1191153973,
-1.0890212059,
0.4494172335,
0.1875236779,
0.4826950729,
0.654807806,
-0.0418697931,
0.7336326241,
-0.3965812922,
0.8886635303,
0.0476287752,
-0.6654617786,
0.2012235522,
0.1126513109,
-0.0480098501,
0.7033991218,
0.7032794952,
-0.7787721753,
-0.919628799,
-0.1804531962,
-0.5920311809,
0.3610571027,
0.1927434802,
0.0818926767,
-0.1829089671,
0.2985864282,
0.6893085241,
0.0776005685,
-0.9523756504,
-0.4313554168,
0.1529801786,
-0.0118822884,
-0.1731081903,
-0.1478150338,
0.1982726902,
-0.3438060582,
0.5457065105,
-0.0666434169,
0.1904804111,
0.249952361,
-0.3802404106,
0.0696251839,
-0.0810941607,
0.8061876297,
0.9044322371,
-0.2722076774,
0.3146734834,
0.5320778489,
-0.6963163018,
0.125814721,
-0.2518332601,
-0.0642112419,
0.5813890696,
0.9137759209,
0.8387496471,
0.101765126,
-0.7468730807,
0.4516906142,
-0.1403537393,
-0.2911841273,
-0.5810964704,
-0.0211850163,
-0.0625075921,
0.0448814221,
0.2861559689,
-0.0577450953,
0.385263592,
-0.7017118931,
0.366091311,
0.660777986,
-0.2685663998,
-0.4725114107,
0.6304402351,
-0.0885961428,
-0.5681527853,
0.4698874354,
-0.5857779384,
-0.5944879651,
0.5255047679,
0.4906893075,
1.0086236,
-0.08292225,
0.3846494853,
0.6498502493,
0.5473167896,
-0.0005901611,
0.1233412847,
-0.0201228391,
-0.8311668634,
-0.3999162316,
-0.5914015174,
-0.2573001385,
0.3360078931,
-0.5588189363,
0.4051199853,
-0.0667785779,
0.0020930048,
0.1907782704,
-0.2586874366,
-0.5606765747,
-0.1503032148,
0.3612592816,
0.3553433716,
-0.9737525582,
0.3590398431,
0.3042193949,
-0.3055520654,
-0.1250145584,
0.5492542982,
0.3277207017,
-0.4850089252,
0.4766551852,
0.6285572648,
-0.5123391151,
-0.2786133587,
0.0464720353,
-0.4760284424,
0.7103654146,
0.238271907,
-0.2179509103,
-0.0762641206,
0.170310542,
0.720394671,
-0.2652597129,
0.3268473446,
0.9056660533,
0.5486636162,
-0.0910985544,
-0.6605862379,
0.0794785246,
0.0573647581,
-0.5229754448,
0.2549091876,
-0.4476223886,
0.3979477584,
-0.454508096,
-0.6329939961,
0.1989820749,
0.660864234,
0.1620775461,
0.5529217124,
0.5918495655,
0.3910154998,
1.0014878511,
0.0085411752,
0.9378719926,
-0.5405962467,
0.1512606442,
0.809330523,
-0.4025994241,
0.5507873297,
0.4261978865,
-0.2000607103,
0.6331398487,
0.526735723,
-0.1069646925,
0.2596753538,
-0.1485918909,
-0.2040657252,
-0.0410568304,
-0.123308979,
-0.2202789336,
0.3580539227,
0.201036945,
-0.0299712364,
-0.0794818848,
0.1888690591,
0.0723528787,
0.0065115276,
0.2319384366,
0.8116539717,
-0.0700351149,
-0.8656555414,
0.7118666172,
-0.3249769211,
0.9170700312,
-0.3177909851,
-0.0381331928,
-0.5342089534,
-0.1691192985,
-0.4958637953,
-0.4114421606,
0.6898496151,
0.1817165315,
-0.0390717201,
0.2576145232,
0.3422803879,
-0.5042147636,
-0.3782171607,
0.722420752,
0.8510273695,
0.799697876,
0.0124782249,
-0.1363809109,
-0.1368926764,
0.0213047415,
0.1093644202,
0.0347095579,
0.5186050534,
-0.0258740671,
0.4568888247,
0.4260748029,
0.4169292152,
0.0154404743,
0.4209505916,
0.0404369235,
-0.7423853874,
-0.34091416,
-1.2138727903,
0.1614584476,
-0.2783846557,
-0.3285004199,
0.9930564761,
0.8319377899,
0.8544424176,
-0.1019392982,
0.5700960755,
0.079045862,
0.3519979119,
-0.5876772404,
0.8806508183,
-0.7730410099,
0.0781206042,
-0.2933356762,
-1.1700712442,
-0.4334464371,
0.6791263223,
0.0793899894,
0.0680021346,
1.2213312387,
0.9896591902,
0.0740471557,
0.0460846499,
0.6387296319,
0.12434268,
-0.1296159476,
0.1683415323,
0.9308934808,
-0.179404512,
0.275763005,
-0.2804733515,
-0.0659393072,
-0.1215020567,
-0.6489388943,
-1.216991663,
-0.7693615556,
-0.4360084832,
-0.2836176455,
0.0372714102,
0.725866437,
0.4987010062,
-1.1707447767,
-0.2906506658,
0.2692600787,
0.3574424088,
-0.2739470005,
-0.3163363934,
0.3773064017,
-0.442863524,
-0.8436807394,
0.3143433332,
0.4871924222,
-0.0133190528,
-0.6511580944,
-0.098449789,
-0.1043988913,
0.0669584721,
0.6667737961,
0.0099840583,
-1.1396455765,
-0.3569433987,
0.054002475,
-0.0714540407,
0.2013672143,
0.9544109106,
-0.6777566671,
0.2528594434,
0.3856847882,
0.4489527941,
0.0557689629,
-0.2366813719,
0.164840132,
-0.7427170277,
0.4008166194,
0.0512528121,
0.4674060941,
0.652349174,
-0.6214612126,
0.7142779827,
0.510301888,
-0.3627319932,
-1.1966508627,
0.0635449588,
-0.7041167021,
-0.390737921,
1.0210872889,
0.3659058213,
0.0574636124,
-0.4514537752,
-0.0197969563,
0.15939942,
-0.0258271769,
1.1267619133,
0.919332087,
-0.3834563494,
0.1391337663,
-0.9501423836,
0.6833103299,
0.3459765017,
-0.9052937627,
0.1514599472,
0.458472997,
-0.2012848556,
0.6520929337,
0.4357633293,
0.1602365673,
0.2814542055,
0.0031800326,
0.1643961072,
0.3223908544,
-0.6683861613,
-0.2834527791,
0.0266233236,
-0.3312941194,
0.1444870681
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10481v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10481v2
|
Emoji Driven Crypto Assets Market Reactions
| 2024-02-16T07:05:49 | 2024-05-04T14:32:44 |
Xiaorui Zuo, Yao-Tsung Chen, Wolfgang Karl Härdle
|
q-fin.CP
|
q-fin.CP, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, q-fin.ST
|
In the burgeoning realm of cryptocurrency, social media platforms like
Twitter have become pivotal in influencing market trends and investor
sentiments. In our study, we leverage GPT-4 and a fine-tuned transformer-based
BERT model for a multimodal sentiment analysis, focusing on the impact of emoji
sentiment on cryptocurrency markets. By translating emojis into quantifiable
sentiment data, we correlate these insights with key market indicators like BTC
Price and the VCRIX index. Our architecture's analysis of emoji sentiment
demonstrated a distinct advantage over FinBERT's pure text sentiment analysis
in such predicting power. This approach may be fed into the development of
trading strategies aimed at utilizing social media elements to identify and
forecast market trends. Crucially, our findings suggest that strategies based
on emoji sentiment can facilitate the avoidance of significant market downturns
and contribute to the stabilization of returns. This research underscores the
practical benefits of integrating advanced AI-driven analyses into financial
strategies, offering a nuanced perspective on the interplay between digital
communication and market dynamics in an academic context.
|
[
-0.1482758075,
-1.0531256199,
0.1837198436,
0.1144689322,
-0.5698488355,
0.6006803513,
-0.3584646583,
-0.4038761854,
0.7868358493,
0.2371714562,
-0.5197113156,
-0.4847681224,
-0.6681159735,
0.1081405431,
-0.3365674615,
1.2599551678,
0.2068876028,
-0.1004122719,
0.3350134194,
-0.0028868737,
-0.0754151419,
-0.5816758871,
-0.8034466505,
0.1088952571,
0.5942601562,
0.3253321946,
0.9318400621,
0.0705740601,
0.77971071,
0.3032586277,
0.2026167065,
-0.2221293896,
-0.2766757309,
0.1899991632,
0.519862771,
-0.0607439429,
-0.4150129855,
-0.0442611463,
0.0741336718,
0.0536363274,
-0.3072663248,
-0.057584811,
-0.1468984783,
0.5354610682,
-0.5273768902,
0.4473275244,
-0.7263569832,
0.0848849937,
-0.2107539922,
-0.1520313621,
-0.1680981964,
-0.3712204993,
0.2780240178,
-0.4289377034,
-0.3211618364,
0.0378969982,
0.6966917515,
-0.191275537,
-0.1614991426,
-0.7679659128,
-0.4146780968,
0.8958460093,
-0.4477607012,
0.366887629,
0.065235436,
0.3577269614,
0.4114738703,
-0.6212466955,
-0.5479050875,
-0.0798764527,
0.2127512693,
0.0354688801,
-0.2623912394,
-0.1740758866,
-0.0495654605,
0.1688018292,
0.0176530126,
-0.2201960832,
-0.4490520358,
-0.0672972128,
0.6064778566,
0.0226793438,
0.5659009814,
-0.2763024569,
-0.3530748785,
-0.1846181154,
-0.5515745282,
-0.09385892,
0.7054477334,
0.3924780786,
-0.1794625819,
0.518361032,
0.3137417138,
0.2409537435,
0.0927887708,
-0.1163936853,
0.2910627127,
-0.5555154085,
-0.0930068567,
0.3352691829,
0.9398851991,
0.4717655182,
0.4547797143,
-0.1239410192,
-0.2506417036,
-0.020745445,
0.4763917327,
-0.8319169283,
-0.2725044489,
0.2831889987,
-0.5648595095,
-0.7203193307,
0.1209600866,
-1.059394598,
-0.3308299184,
-0.0118776411,
0.3438290954,
-0.5269777775,
-0.2668638825,
-0.322211653,
-0.5816115141,
0.2783935368,
0.2521879375,
-1.2904274464,
0.2927521169,
0.9435786009,
0.7432491183,
0.5388863087,
0.2279524505,
-0.0405011438,
0.0282520168,
-0.4597798586,
0.4439928532,
-0.6789695621,
-0.4249359965,
0.2411830425,
-0.3236034513,
-0.0361219905,
0.066736348,
0.2135064155,
-0.4706019759,
-0.0801407918,
-0.3702642322,
-0.2204638273,
-0.0197924301,
0.3838010728,
-0.6507820487,
0.4466068447,
0.0446198173,
-1.1680465937,
0.4533387125,
-1.0794965029,
-0.4924715459,
0.0533446297,
-0.2448652983,
-0.4897772372,
-0.0215446372,
0.4265816808,
0.5004173517,
-0.2644557357,
-0.1673576832,
-0.6960265636,
-0.127687484,
1.0653098822,
-0.3121890724,
0.4020918608,
0.2775989473,
-0.5028423667,
-0.0167496838,
-0.4924195707,
-0.161797598,
0.170960784,
0.2724550366,
-0.5623574257,
0.1522967815,
0.6257694364,
0.0611611046,
0.3576464951,
-0.6958627105,
0.2717331946,
-0.2541978955,
1.1873087883,
0.9935611486,
0.0036595454,
0.3675434589,
-0.1214717701,
0.3828679621,
-0.0953455493,
0.5572906137,
-0.1255566478,
-0.5456944704,
-0.2821901143,
-0.5371140838,
0.2341181189,
0.3595627546,
-0.6796840429,
0.2238472104,
-0.3451650441,
-0.4209976196,
-0.8911573291,
0.1265795082,
-0.3085491061,
-0.1052096188,
-0.0313155837,
-0.0152425375,
-0.4138203859,
-0.7861431837,
-0.2956852615,
-0.1588094383,
0.0915068984,
0.370413065,
0.4486826062,
-0.534080863,
0.6392036676,
-0.2704158127,
-0.2193199396,
-0.1664941609,
0.3614353538,
0.0736187324,
0.0386672094,
0.6415866613,
-1.0473484993,
-0.4233021736,
0.5372874141,
-0.5720410347,
0.3953464925,
-0.5035838485,
0.1380926371,
0.4051907659,
0.1486948431,
-0.5235789418,
0.3627570271,
0.4965088367,
-0.4156216383,
-0.2299038917,
0.0897979736,
0.5549810529,
-1.101318121,
0.0549558327,
0.2567289472,
0.1875917315,
-0.4996565878,
-0.1680387557,
-0.1356066316,
-0.1230575219,
-0.3904698193,
0.2594700754,
-0.0393167846,
0.0326274931,
-0.166217804,
0.2649303377,
-0.3013896346,
0.0125834569,
-0.3026710749,
0.7494468093,
0.7481192946,
0.0395338908,
0.3953105211,
0.1467167586,
-0.1200535074,
0.2133256942,
-0.7538301945,
0.350993365,
0.3732376397,
-0.1350181401,
-1.3656548262,
-0.1558135301,
0.7892815471,
-0.7457395792,
0.3610987365,
0.2524437308,
-0.7399693727,
-0.3860971332,
-0.8669676185,
0.2244637161,
0.3514508605,
-0.3050051928,
0.946957469,
0.3070575893,
-0.3652526736,
-0.7596343756,
-0.7865793109,
0.27025792,
-0.391228497,
-0.6712901592,
0.1165943593,
0.0175356418,
-0.5502862334,
-0.141869083,
0.16902785,
0.0085054152,
0.250674516,
0.425031662,
0.6209726334,
0.2201785892,
0.0442963205,
0.0251365341,
-0.0648318902,
0.3323507011,
-0.2218454778,
0.457159102,
-0.3734106123,
0.0064437967,
-0.6823775768,
0.0376469605,
0.8790161014,
0.1569694728,
0.962454319,
0.5705178976,
-0.1402627975,
0.3826393485,
-0.4315513372,
-0.1335803419,
-0.5617729425,
0.0355706476,
-0.2221045643,
-0.839315176,
0.7958760858,
0.2082083374,
-0.0688679889,
0.5346396565,
0.8258904815,
-0.1262806654,
1.2240632772,
0.5576192141,
-0.4383536279,
0.7255548835,
-0.2593615651,
0.7819357514,
-0.4608958364,
-0.2700362802,
-0.3266939819,
-0.4148196876,
-1.1178201437,
-0.0224054493,
0.0064900047,
-0.3768050969,
-0.0762298331,
0.1921412498,
-0.4595612288,
-0.1821690351,
0.2216801941,
0.0860364512,
-0.1858498156,
0.2372989804,
0.1458975077,
-0.1503131688,
-0.3600678444,
-0.4534341097,
1.3392708302,
0.7050738335,
0.9505535364,
-0.0183741339,
0.6440052986,
0.6239039302,
0.6621353626,
-0.825099051,
0.0674141422,
-0.0178751964,
-0.3442462087,
-0.2797156572,
-0.4033923447,
-0.6388329268,
-0.239161849,
-0.4116654992,
-0.4254710674,
0.0464878716,
-0.3786568642,
-0.2300394475,
0.1672006845,
-0.5695061684,
0.9105024934,
-0.4559296668,
-0.0864263847,
-0.4777148366,
-0.4857143462,
0.0259482544,
-0.4288106859,
0.5109112263,
-0.1708328575,
-0.2684276998,
0.5593162775,
-0.3130015433,
0.9145585299,
0.1758207083,
-0.143425554,
0.3633176088,
-0.3491635025,
0.3994205594,
0.3218009174,
0.0904025733,
0.4875497222,
-0.1083836555,
-0.5582531691,
-0.4771561623,
1.0788203478,
-0.9454774857,
-0.1434879899,
-0.2576210201,
-0.1807136983,
0.2743571401,
-0.1696442068,
0.1606182605,
0.0089783221,
-0.454012394,
0.0799080878,
-0.0161765832,
0.1185602844,
0.6911540031,
-0.1010999754,
0.0320847072,
-1.1856817007,
0.9514403939,
0.1898802221,
-0.1002886444,
0.4672626555,
0.344214201,
-0.4721094072,
-0.0089687724,
-0.3011404574,
0.1330682039,
-0.6866172552,
-0.0348176397,
-0.5992854238,
0.2422893047,
-0.8751200438,
-0.417632848,
-0.2393083721,
-0.4873200059,
-0.3766263127,
-0.3612805307,
0.6410765052,
0.6946772337,
-0.005742372,
0.1726447046,
-0.8465136886,
0.1045419425,
0.4146887362,
0.2235704362,
0.0612720586,
0.0124674356,
-0.280082196,
0.2515520751,
-0.4468708038,
-0.9336609244,
0.5299721956,
0.1420573294,
0.0884178504,
0.9250788093,
-0.0793620124,
0.5167825818,
0.0004223536,
0.5374890566,
0.5374729633,
-1.155834794,
0.6890553832,
-0.4414641261,
-0.2968327403,
0.2243410349,
0.3734920025,
-0.7160594463,
-0.4685772061,
-0.825740099,
-0.8750498295,
0.336198777,
0.6095054746,
0.592137754,
-0.4776663184,
0.4757584631,
0.1074428186,
0.6730508804,
-0.6865323782,
-0.2922326922,
-0.738463819,
-0.4758779109,
0.2651958466,
-0.2443381697,
-0.0808245987,
-0.2063233405,
0.2817302644,
-0.1777712405,
0.4231099784,
-0.2106385678,
0.2707384527,
-0.117875129,
0.2374466807,
0.2801180482,
0.5430123806,
-0.2745212615,
-0.2866711915,
-0.0527651012,
-0.2773401737,
-0.3317984045,
0.1011298746,
0.0559832528,
-0.1114043668,
0.1774200946,
0.5682573318,
0.334620297,
-0.7560680509,
0.6987278461,
-0.3278360069,
-0.1567614228,
-0.4111193419,
-0.3580459952,
-0.2008703053,
0.1943188906,
0.7199121118,
0.1892695874,
0.2921130657,
-0.9293507934,
0.2928648889,
0.5089868307,
-0.5862234235,
-0.8262532353,
0.6443452835,
0.3439734578,
-0.0854360759,
0.8685175776,
0.4508796036,
-0.506785512,
0.7346394062,
0.1516614854,
1.2677471638,
0.0455183126,
0.3393816054,
-0.069620803,
0.5052925944,
0.2732980251,
0.4747387767,
-0.158254683,
-0.7599710226,
-0.1383851171,
-0.3460125029,
-0.222573489,
-0.3833077848,
-0.3382659554,
0.434289515,
-0.825697124,
-0.6735062003,
0.5021703839,
-0.1611344218,
-0.6804802418,
0.3337613046,
0.4013825655,
0.2865208387,
-0.8305496573,
0.6316354275,
0.8054847121,
-0.5189884305,
-0.2399330437,
0.0629111826,
-0.2567555904,
-0.920126915,
0.6513405442,
0.4887486398,
0.1026680246,
-0.2361977696,
-0.7405064106,
-0.4605676532,
0.7908132076,
-0.0062758448,
-0.4670934975,
0.4832224846,
0.1494503915,
0.7985172868,
-0.7151671052,
0.5505023599,
0.3087241352,
0.5486946702,
0.1931569129,
-0.4428113401,
0.0051533813,
-0.4550085366,
0.0736869201,
0.6245872378,
-0.6795424819,
0.5724367499,
-0.3473045528,
-0.3571535349,
-0.0653290898,
0.4120337963,
-0.1539494842,
0.6095573306,
0.2936375737,
0.4651057124,
0.2512418032,
-0.1554049551,
1.1101907492,
-0.9330134988,
0.6207891107,
-0.0217863638,
-0.0453077294,
1.0615565777,
0.602807343,
-0.0711232275,
0.6256930232,
0.6714576483,
-0.1659454703,
0.6635981202,
-0.0618990809,
-0.1592681408,
-0.2045023292,
-0.0813633651,
-0.2742563784,
0.3295545876,
0.5729298592,
-0.5842499137,
0.3777616322,
0.1867135465,
-0.0922979936,
-0.2247445136,
-0.2138351947,
0.6996069551,
0.121070087,
0.0395825654,
-0.0860501453,
-0.0950431228,
0.6963815093,
-0.3407573402,
0.1202155575,
0.1363197714,
0.2181022167,
0.0587580055,
-0.7014034986,
0.3868774474,
-0.2971220911,
0.1798842996,
-0.3285861313,
0.7131376863,
-0.1124491915,
-0.8067035079,
0.390068084,
0.1768307239,
-0.2147671431,
-0.1490845382,
-0.9780020118,
0.1608200073,
-0.0741600394,
-0.1646821946,
0.3803988099,
0.8283392191,
0.2973463833,
0.7195066214,
0.8644801974,
-0.4656417966,
-0.2923468351,
0.0147143435,
1.0800372362,
-1.0323500633,
-0.4653847516,
-1.0708892345,
0.2827691436,
-0.1122839376,
-0.1067270786,
0.6436281204,
0.2621241808,
0.45382303,
-0.167893976,
0.8923401833,
-0.1577419639,
0.0003048006,
-0.2798756063,
0.9103584886,
-0.4519784749,
0.3055306077,
-0.4378491044,
-0.4680074155,
-0.1829958409,
0.4838360548,
-0.3648833632,
0.1374275088,
0.3225237429,
0.3796703815,
0.4019768536,
0.3508569002,
0.1517306864,
0.0347678587,
0.2053499371,
-0.0659642145,
0.8933140635,
-0.7249653339,
0.4739252925,
-0.4438428283,
0.0935141668,
-0.4855765104,
-0.735109508,
-1.059743762,
-0.2088938057,
-0.5879252553,
-0.3653550148,
0.0915927663,
0.9124256372,
0.0767800659,
-0.8367208242,
-0.0469467975,
0.1341547221,
0.1241361573,
-0.272470057,
-0.3308046162,
0.4522430003,
-0.3417834342,
-0.4688123465,
-0.3150976598,
0.6449791193,
0.1933190525,
-0.11415115,
0.0560071431,
0.1408471465,
0.3763509989,
0.6521794796,
-0.1647261977,
-0.6893205643,
-0.1472656131,
0.2756548822,
-0.2604762316,
0.0939300135,
1.0089834929,
-0.1502837241,
0.6137379408,
0.479372412,
0.403080523,
0.0743468702,
0.0835889429,
0.518905282,
-0.2806889713,
0.0636756867,
0.1254037321,
0.2562149465,
0.3439059556,
-0.5046319366,
0.1611337811,
0.404864043,
-0.4502131343,
-0.2708683312,
-0.4510245323,
-0.8290941715,
-0.3375053108,
0.7914501429,
0.0178532079,
-0.6678728461,
0.2003758848,
-0.0937132537,
-0.035252016,
-0.9933046699,
1.3073518276,
0.8167330623,
0.2150822431,
-0.3585655689,
-0.2377260774,
0.2619297504,
0.0562802739,
-0.454146415,
-0.1214201823,
0.1971221566,
0.0718060583,
0.2026625127,
0.5829748511,
0.0280890148,
0.2232157588,
0.0805132836,
0.1250079572,
0.193539232,
-0.1808187664,
0.0193330497,
0.2387583405,
-0.1168211401,
-0.4468258619
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.12170v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.12170v2
|
Where is the answer? Investigating Positional Bias in Language Model Knowledge Extraction
| 2024-02-16T06:29:16 | 2024-05-23T06:52:31 |
Kuniaki Saito, Kihyuk Sohn, Chen-Yu Lee, Yoshitaka Ushiku
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models require updates to remain up-to-date or adapt to new
domains by fine-tuning them with new documents. One key is memorizing the
latest information in a way that the memorized information is extractable with
a query prompt. However, LLMs suffer from a phenomenon called perplexity curse;
despite minimizing document perplexity during fine-tuning, LLMs struggle to
extract information through a prompt sentence. In this new knowledge
acquisition and extraction, we find a very intriguing fact that LLMs can
accurately answer questions about the first sentence, but they struggle to
extract information described in the middle or end of the documents used for
fine-tuning. Our study suggests that the auto-regressive training causes this
issue; each token is prompted by reliance on all previous tokens, which hinders
the model from recalling information from training documents by question
prompts. To conduct the in-depth study, we publish both synthetic and real
datasets, enabling the evaluation of the QA performance w.r.t. the position of
the corresponding answer in a document. Our investigation shows that even a
large model suffers from the perplexity curse, but regularization such as
denoising auto-regressive loss can enhance the information extraction from
diverse positions. These findings will be (i) a key to improving knowledge
extraction from LLMs and (ii) new elements to discuss the trade-off between RAG
and fine-tuning in adapting LLMs to a new domain.
|
[
-0.380743593,
-0.8990402222,
0.6936234236,
-0.0815095678,
-0.2940500677,
0.104952395,
-0.0324653201,
-0.3638672233,
0.0365849026,
0.5333251357,
-0.6155192852,
-0.3906905651,
-0.9780203104,
0.1199434623,
-0.3157995045,
0.9210205078,
0.0550938956,
0.109485507,
-0.3545258045,
0.1153873578,
-0.5363901258,
-0.7756892443,
-0.5199907422,
-0.1772064865,
0.4527846277,
0.5237317085,
0.5806354284,
0.6389323473,
0.4666803479,
0.2457036078,
-0.1558981836,
0.0481270254,
-0.4410862923,
0.2861921787,
-0.039015945,
-0.8354660869,
-0.2566021383,
0.2621006668,
0.6103371978,
0.7092145681,
-0.0119982185,
0.2453925163,
-0.0306719337,
0.4958963394,
-0.5408098102,
-0.0028642477,
-0.9245827794,
0.0183567367,
-0.3082191348,
-0.3413289487,
-0.1009205356,
-0.3585825562,
0.4112625718,
-0.5478239059,
0.4525093138,
0.0203242265,
1.0598592758,
0.5782140493,
-0.4442243576,
-0.3276259601,
-0.5617563128,
0.6816970706,
-0.6512069702,
0.3066505492,
0.4974061847,
0.0919990093,
-0.2034108192,
-0.2877272666,
-0.5885804892,
0.0620108135,
0.0247986726,
-0.022567112,
-0.1437222511,
-0.2435570657,
0.4381466806,
0.2701984048,
-0.3096284866,
0.2967774272,
-0.252785027,
-0.1207572967,
0.5598248839,
-0.0341484174,
0.2350937426,
-0.35056144,
-0.3848427236,
-0.1216717958,
-0.8806241751,
0.2136281729,
0.4576745033,
0.0894463882,
0.2472259998,
0.4610742927,
0.0570621602,
0.50981915,
0.2158995122,
-0.0088349674,
0.1151465774,
-0.0838302225,
-0.1674140096,
0.0026163175,
0.6100481749,
0.0448973365,
0.3229615688,
-0.2139863968,
-0.2998813391,
-0.3553165793,
0.2697212696,
-0.5400410891,
-0.1136373505,
-0.0264679305,
-0.3274047673,
-0.4008903503,
0.0898269117,
-0.6955795288,
-0.5925332308,
-0.1631235182,
0.1152980104,
-0.189241603,
-0.3027939796,
0.0090079652,
-0.0852472037,
0.4184781611,
0.2660853267,
-0.8831858635,
0.1198314428,
0.6485130191,
0.4261062741,
-0.5571076274,
-0.1626616269,
-0.4172991216,
-0.0613487251,
-0.1935879737,
0.9567370415,
-0.6115530729,
-0.4212594628,
-0.0744247586,
0.105632022,
-0.1697083116,
-0.8065097928,
0.3456359804,
-0.7432671189,
0.4991105199,
-0.5468007326,
-0.5687133074,
-0.0140403379,
0.2611545622,
-0.515869081,
0.9530903101,
-0.0334310159,
-0.7091200948,
0.3905662894,
-0.3122268915,
-0.2786644995,
-0.2877722383,
-0.4042980075,
-0.3603453636,
0.3055675626,
0.3740949035,
0.243615061,
-0.4810239673,
0.225903064,
-0.3013330102,
-0.1967125833,
0.6054736972,
-0.5957903862,
0.6526420712,
0.1741520911,
-0.2750611305,
-0.2035083771,
-0.7367969751,
-0.3633088171,
0.3260672688,
-0.414196074,
-0.6065462232,
-0.1412879229,
-0.5458115339,
0.3910109401,
0.4198857248,
-0.4157797694,
0.391741097,
-0.4635627866,
0.0804876238,
0.9280433655,
0.2813660204,
0.5684014559,
-0.195050627,
0.9512842894,
0.132563591,
0.1024423391,
0.0317486227,
-0.3364403844,
-0.6943259239,
0.1476443112,
0.3694844842,
0.5500721335,
-0.5220760107,
0.1634756625,
-0.0489871874,
-0.0132970568,
-0.6392396092,
0.3138558865,
0.4366068244,
0.6852731705,
0.1879810989,
-0.2933733761,
-0.4451865256,
-1.0814731121,
-0.3132106662,
-0.0940525383,
-0.0026133575,
0.2327354848,
0.2390610278,
0.1511357576,
1.0591058731,
-0.6132751703,
-0.05472105,
-0.1056841761,
0.1946024001,
0.2791286409,
0.3602941632,
0.1847952306,
-0.9496586919,
-0.2054530382,
-0.3982849717,
-0.7812920809,
-0.3481718898,
-0.0103826644,
-0.1538308561,
0.2130455971,
0.6334187388,
-0.751655519,
0.1037882343,
0.2301107347,
-0.284244746,
0.5943099856,
0.0681415573,
-0.2516766489,
-1.0284959078,
0.0906274915,
-0.1797635555,
-0.0368116125,
-0.4514134824,
-0.2176954448,
-0.1366368234,
0.2179495394,
-0.0085111912,
0.5847256184,
-0.6056667566,
-0.1381984055,
-0.3011307418,
0.5395416021,
0.0736095756,
0.4114142358,
-0.0782120079,
0.8383425474,
0.2909264565,
-0.5611032248,
-0.0605345368,
0.406986475,
-0.2025980502,
0.2363036871,
-0.3990780115,
0.3540342748,
-0.2383716851,
-0.0706281811,
-1.0158014297,
0.0137387617,
0.1178963631,
-0.6497712135,
0.5437932014,
-0.2263137847,
-0.2884835899,
-0.1736584008,
-0.0964243039,
0.2394219637,
0.503236413,
-0.207925126,
0.2973481119,
0.8029144406,
-0.4482133985,
-0.9313969612,
-0.3009333611,
-0.1462285668,
-0.2709535956,
-0.3664937615,
0.0219665244,
0.1033115834,
-0.4685560167,
-0.2344392836,
-0.5576452613,
0.072982043,
0.4644054472,
0.0548957065,
0.2663827538,
-0.1745830178,
0.3003628254,
0.0593604818,
-0.1182324067,
0.4643584192,
-0.2387563735,
0.4475747943,
0.1285045147,
-0.3274261355,
-0.0915349945,
0.1198692098,
0.4968197346,
-0.1995655298,
0.483043015,
0.3397340178,
-0.3094791472,
-0.1445753276,
-0.8892387152,
-0.3647525907,
-0.4119474888,
0.4481791556,
-0.451341331,
-0.7686027288,
0.6825897098,
-0.1404601038,
-0.0671677738,
0.4489576817,
0.3095278144,
-0.1115370765,
1.0823862553,
0.6928674579,
-0.2178114653,
0.5262240767,
-0.2695414424,
0.1502512693,
-0.8571146131,
-0.2563695014,
-0.5481925011,
-0.1938145459,
-0.3919426501,
-0.1777832061,
0.3157441616,
0.4450432658,
0.1584562957,
-0.0471689701,
-0.3244135976,
0.4013178945,
0.4980228543,
-0.0442680046,
0.358132571,
-0.0264671091,
-0.3250888586,
-0.1072015911,
-0.7464119196,
-0.5538910627,
1.0783746243,
0.4570622444,
0.5452359319,
0.0321202055,
0.5911986232,
0.0227152072,
0.1843622625,
-0.5940034986,
0.3705151379,
-0.1194099188,
-0.6321998835,
-0.3928230405,
-0.2258191854,
-1.0172531605,
0.3465947211,
-0.1720968187,
-0.5783782005,
0.4095225334,
0.1156914979,
-0.3830910325,
0.0514568612,
-0.5618345141,
0.8156614304,
-0.2359500378,
-0.3805569112,
0.2051846087,
-0.8017164469,
0.2508413792,
-0.0300857183,
0.2792710662,
-0.0683943778,
0.1464170069,
0.7939921618,
-0.2399883568,
0.7851102948,
-0.4480150342,
-0.5370228887,
0.0427978151,
0.2357876301,
0.7295671701,
0.0347485878,
-0.0783064812,
-0.1277902871,
0.0092290966,
-0.2434143722,
-0.6941389441,
0.4840429425,
-0.8134792447,
-1.0960776806,
-0.3749787211,
-0.5934147835,
-0.5852212906,
0.1438512355,
0.2739862502,
0.2327784598,
-0.0179141108,
-0.0486927852,
1.1174262762,
-0.4165270925,
0.2052977532,
0.6935673356,
-0.1810423434,
0.0538244434,
0.7094727755,
0.1488455981,
0.2076445073,
0.4609221518,
0.2123506069,
-0.4120963216,
-0.8118308187,
-0.2661342025,
0.3309018612,
-0.7965494394,
-0.1598499268,
-0.7217926979,
-0.2762483954,
-0.6501343846,
0.2094182521,
-0.2706984878,
-0.5349029303,
-0.4657466412,
-0.3139605224,
0.0995767713,
0.7683996558,
0.2247901857,
0.1810695827,
-0.7132117152,
0.0894505158,
0.2426679134,
-0.0842729658,
-0.084611088,
-0.7459840178,
-0.1699927151,
-0.2156439275,
-0.3312436342,
-0.9889876246,
0.3906348348,
-0.2825020254,
0.7662447691,
0.3204725385,
-0.0272844844,
0.6237214804,
-0.2593292296,
0.6851260066,
-0.2403903008,
-0.5588352084,
0.457921803,
-0.2840798497,
0.4144273698,
0.5537922978,
0.3977378309,
-0.4284464717,
-0.5767834783,
-0.673558116,
-0.8079708219,
0.6092638373,
-0.1514029205,
-0.0732885003,
-0.1096796244,
0.7113194466,
0.3385309279,
0.3999891877,
-0.6935310364,
-0.2363794744,
0.1363550723,
-0.1307540238,
0.0610877946,
-0.5987368226,
-0.0765495077,
-0.0492694601,
0.6231554151,
-0.055800207,
0.2760911882,
0.3818466365,
-0.3529325724,
-0.1834223717,
0.2579117119,
0.4730964601,
0.7992777824,
-0.1128806844,
0.240110606,
0.227768749,
-0.3635672927,
-0.1284868419,
0.2686177194,
-0.3287988305,
-0.1164157167,
0.324827224,
0.7583428025,
0.1892711222,
-0.3173266053,
0.6128341556,
0.0067144483,
-0.04603488,
-0.4366146922,
0.0304049514,
-0.160322234,
0.334130913,
0.6563061476,
-0.0791179165,
0.1171684042,
-0.3523605764,
0.1623298824,
0.668413043,
-0.3269533515,
-0.2792523503,
0.6321878433,
-0.0586102977,
-0.2451921999,
0.5217300653,
-0.0955704972,
-0.6696511507,
0.6017931104,
0.5454772711,
0.7369017601,
-0.1465694904,
0.1003208607,
0.2290699035,
0.20537965,
0.1039188355,
0.2522574961,
0.0674958453,
-0.8293889761,
-0.3294084072,
-0.673079133,
-0.2200878561,
0.2808655202,
-0.5836755037,
0.111996077,
-0.3219580054,
-0.0525496714,
-0.2857062817,
0.0445178188,
-0.5501669645,
0.0732914954,
0.1577292532,
0.7684640288,
-0.5708414912,
0.9225999713,
0.5856095552,
-0.4320457876,
-0.7385966182,
0.1522502601,
0.0313529149,
-1.0202602148,
0.6481081247,
-0.0836232454,
-0.1324665248,
-0.0453556702,
-0.7837370038,
-1.0490131378,
1.052531004,
0.4320355356,
-0.5028921962,
-0.4255684018,
0.0555023141,
0.4949369431,
-0.2705863118,
0.0432691835,
0.6531134844,
0.3069519997,
0.0040752878,
-0.6989921331,
0.2146291733,
-0.2621322274,
-0.0923083276,
0.022832308,
-0.5685074925,
0.8274079561,
-0.1359916776,
-0.1664101779,
-0.143758297,
0.3824759722,
0.2777096331,
0.082433112,
0.4823524356,
0.2877707183,
0.981626153,
-0.0067491634,
1.1308107376,
-0.2824138999,
0.1222937554,
1.1853115559,
-0.1938246042,
0.6665819883,
0.8208918571,
0.0196124502,
0.5168524384,
0.7308080196,
0.1531478763,
0.5227975845,
0.3125194013,
-0.0429399833,
-0.2589243054,
0.0277617238,
-0.2106389552,
0.4557515979,
0.3489695489,
-0.4594594538,
0.010575207,
-0.0004672244,
0.1452109069,
-0.0803198069,
-0.0147871245,
0.9530828595,
0.2340328991,
-0.9711784124,
0.6078036427,
-0.0587213747,
0.4745799601,
-0.5828765631,
-0.1037916169,
-0.4904553294,
0.0137713822,
-0.0308140814,
-0.479950279,
0.126343444,
-0.0858174041,
-0.3295448124,
-0.2877186835,
0.8388778567,
-0.3775278926,
-0.1813841611,
0.1451655626,
0.7670654058,
0.2195013463,
-0.1202911362,
-0.6183937788,
-0.2363704741,
0.0262337141,
-0.3759554923,
0.5136891007,
0.7174369097,
-0.1263549328,
0.5986645818,
0.6078745127,
0.2414033413,
0.2519322932,
0.0461383872,
0.8322054148,
-0.6176249981,
-0.3100284636,
-0.8531073332,
0.2401968241,
-0.0982511416,
-0.4772901535,
0.8965903521,
0.3986372948,
0.7542607188,
0.0812490284,
0.8524608612,
0.1325078905,
0.6060183644,
-0.7086884379,
0.6132440567,
-0.6079853773,
0.6715049744,
-0.1442409009,
-0.753651917,
-0.2272524387,
0.6651763916,
-0.7130942345,
-0.1188966781,
0.7936163545,
0.7076721191,
0.1340419799,
-0.0381585285,
0.1854546368,
0.5742824674,
0.2149306238,
0.3684919477,
0.8802530169,
-0.3386052847,
0.5576340556,
-0.122756198,
-0.1312365979,
-0.0951194912,
-0.6618219018,
-0.629978478,
-0.5223973393,
-0.1527378261,
-0.3331361711,
0.0431968123,
0.8827866316,
0.3533399999,
-0.7840755582,
-0.1700939238,
-0.0842540115,
0.562682271,
0.0711592287,
-0.265928328,
0.4052730501,
-0.5664313436,
-0.6969771385,
0.3865213692,
0.0411808565,
0.1120028719,
-0.2724010348,
0.1072757691,
-0.4561730325,
-0.1802443564,
0.3139920533,
0.2843863368,
-0.6408612132,
-0.2594989836,
0.270786196,
-0.1376735866,
0.2237548828,
0.8711839914,
-0.6260851622,
0.3643221259,
0.2869926691,
0.7661076784,
0.4498839378,
0.1813437641,
0.880428791,
-0.8648576736,
-0.1185235605,
0.0740481392,
0.255313307,
0.3245682716,
-0.5263906717,
0.3457448184,
0.4145099521,
-0.6173859835,
-0.8409917951,
0.1668411791,
-0.6039992571,
-0.4372906685,
1.2979772091,
-0.0706961155,
-0.1953688115,
-0.2766450047,
-0.2036768496,
0.3989757895,
-0.1890934259,
1.1667129993,
0.9939729571,
-0.1125359982,
-0.2102864534,
-0.689660728,
0.665892899,
0.6910279989,
-0.614127934,
0.1556530446,
0.4495144784,
0.5255900621,
0.0900092348,
0.6043875813,
-0.3546741009,
-0.0137934955,
-0.2430908233,
-0.0574853048,
0.0313876495,
-0.3166506886,
-0.631016314,
0.21165815,
0.3900156617,
-0.115814127
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10466v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10466v4
|
Large Language Models as Zero-shot Dialogue State Tracker through Function Calling
| 2024-02-16T06:13:18 | 2024-05-30T04:19:54 |
Zekun Li, Zhiyu Zoey Chen, Mike Ross, Patrick Huber, Seungwhan Moon, Zhaojiang Lin, Xin Luna Dong, Adithya Sagar, Xifeng Yan, Paul A. Crook
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly prevalent in conversational
systems due to their advanced understanding and generative capabilities in
general contexts. However, their effectiveness in task-oriented dialogues
(TOD), which requires not only response generation but also effective dialogue
state tracking (DST) within specific tasks and domains, remains less
satisfying. In this work, we propose a novel approach FnCTOD for solving DST
with LLMs through function calling. This method improves zero-shot DST,
allowing adaptation to diverse domains without extensive data collection or
model tuning. Our experimental results demonstrate that our approach achieves
exceptional performance with both modestly sized open-source and also
proprietary LLMs: with in-context prompting it enables various 7B or 13B
parameter models to surpass the previous state-of-the-art (SOTA) achieved by
ChatGPT, and improves ChatGPT's performance beating the SOTA by 5.6% average
joint goal accuracy (JGA). Individual model results for GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 are
boosted by 4.8% and 14%, respectively. We also show that by fine-tuning on a
small collection of diverse task-oriented dialogues, we can equip modestly
sized models, specifically a 13B parameter LLaMA2-Chat model, with
function-calling capabilities and DST performance comparable to ChatGPT while
maintaining their chat capabilities. We have made the code publicly available
at https://github.com/facebookresearch/FnCTOD
|
[
-0.2317014486,
-1.0309650898,
0.6312866807,
0.1415788978,
-0.42473948,
0.1954915076,
-0.5681167245,
-0.3103533685,
0.1523814797,
0.7182263136,
-0.7074708939,
-0.500764668,
-0.3062339127,
-0.0911172032,
-0.1535006464,
0.8894125819,
-0.0029508399,
0.0262244008,
0.0834623724,
0.0416867286,
-0.4494969845,
-0.3980590701,
-0.5524638891,
-0.0455066636,
0.3318492174,
0.3826061189,
0.2967527807,
0.275467366,
0.2201621979,
0.2235207111,
-0.1995363086,
0.1580234021,
-0.7727510333,
0.2770344019,
-0.2028522193,
-0.5222187042,
-0.53538692,
-0.4483295083,
0.6292790771,
0.4938316345,
-0.2365262657,
0.1206729487,
0.218139872,
0.1143976226,
-0.5029379725,
0.6282706857,
-0.8095667958,
-0.2780689895,
-0.1200272664,
-0.4468392134,
-0.5110563636,
-0.2178743184,
0.0500845499,
-0.3445883691,
-0.0318470746,
-0.2537275255,
0.3901807368,
0.2929240763,
-0.2984751165,
-0.2279714793,
-0.8104158044,
0.8492017984,
-1.0950461626,
0.1638052464,
0.0753053203,
0.273162663,
-0.437207371,
-0.325958997,
-0.4694350958,
-0.5002474785,
0.4071504474,
-0.1250327229,
-0.2599171102,
0.2378536165,
0.455824852,
0.2866252363,
-0.2855006158,
0.0956110284,
-0.0332688726,
-0.0999459103,
0.5994416475,
0.3815059066,
0.0724758953,
0.1066410467,
-0.2240868062,
0.2219122052,
-0.7303833365,
0.0994460061,
0.004602782,
0.8891843557,
-0.1848910749,
0.4536851943,
-0.5959747434,
0.8981961012,
0.1792040318,
-0.2539857924,
-0.0834754407,
-0.3428068161,
-0.3094122112,
-0.1097284555,
0.7130836844,
0.3350346684,
0.2640903294,
-0.0057029361,
-0.1652142555,
-0.1964736879,
0.1232800558,
-1.1578991413,
0.0787035525,
0.0398307182,
-0.2174945474,
-0.2166129947,
-0.4393927753,
-0.5237839222,
-0.3042243123,
-0.3727664649,
0.4993273318,
-0.4796967208,
-0.3639785945,
0.009722651,
0.5953620672,
0.25356251,
0.711407423,
-0.9687515497,
0.2660250366,
0.7480349541,
1.211468935,
-0.0915694907,
0.2539299428,
-0.7824298143,
-0.0470981188,
-0.3877776861,
0.5921771526,
-0.4767251015,
-0.4654890299,
-0.0019856791,
-0.1182912439,
-0.1683597863,
-0.278070569,
0.1588112414,
-0.2958625853,
-0.2215508372,
-0.2113578916,
-0.5195926428,
-0.1006599441,
0.3899363279,
-0.2653045058,
0.763566792,
0.0412992053,
-0.5023208261,
-0.0085737826,
-0.7483200431,
-0.3194844723,
0.1637975574,
-0.2072675824,
-0.1226967052,
0.2780546546,
0.1609260291,
0.6355546713,
-0.4532218277,
0.420498848,
-0.5723848343,
-0.4801084101,
0.2188717872,
-0.4827671349,
0.7361186147,
0.1506702453,
-0.3414737284,
0.2711882889,
-0.4640751481,
0.0777909011,
0.0748686343,
-0.1406659484,
-0.1742719561,
-0.0052700466,
-0.0570433177,
0.2024937421,
0.1342969984,
-0.8065202236,
0.3745436966,
-0.468208909,
0.564326942,
0.5813341737,
0.0786856264,
0.0965272635,
-0.1575631499,
0.6526984572,
-0.0844879225,
0.015025679,
-0.2564322352,
-0.4964498878,
-0.6087139845,
-0.5889243484,
0.1227229685,
0.504465878,
-0.9041141272,
0.2820003331,
-0.3598180413,
-0.4402060509,
-0.1612167656,
0.0168736484,
0.4233151972,
0.4027421474,
0.225837335,
-0.3652677834,
-0.0589835607,
-0.570733428,
-0.1097479016,
-0.0787791386,
-0.1375820935,
0.5090594292,
0.3813458085,
0.0925128534,
0.9701756835,
-0.6384536624,
-0.439360708,
-0.4317358136,
-0.138775751,
0.3056798875,
0.1796143502,
0.4820008278,
-0.3838147223,
-0.6970643401,
0.0980801284,
-0.323158443,
-0.2453102618,
0.103679508,
0.0519145876,
0.3733662665,
0.3713597357,
-0.5014143586,
0.5871421099,
0.5294486284,
-0.202014789,
0.4014869034,
0.1038687453,
0.0565247647,
-1.3402611017,
0.1577729136,
0.0788082927,
-0.4424517155,
-0.8570354581,
-0.1741541326,
-0.1035520062,
-0.1822891533,
-0.5948597789,
0.740172863,
-0.2907351851,
-0.1000590473,
-0.47293818,
0.1094850749,
-0.5387957692,
0.73499614,
0.0626221001,
0.6600220203,
0.6025329232,
-0.4124810994,
0.3689007163,
0.2445047647,
-0.4040323198,
0.5980701447,
-0.4231190383,
0.1678858548,
0.1913515776,
0.6993100643,
-1.2143739462,
0.0068653915,
0.2092845887,
-0.2978733182,
0.3031062484,
-0.3884679973,
-0.380176872,
-0.1426356882,
-0.2002598792,
0.3057436645,
0.2293454409,
-0.3521440327,
0.5772513151,
0.1919017285,
-0.4590070248,
-0.4193995297,
-0.4025421143,
0.1178437173,
-0.0312626772,
-0.5342144966,
0.2328828275,
-0.1975476295,
0.0611913577,
-0.3844118714,
-0.4903430343,
-0.036778897,
-0.0224165004,
0.1775778532,
0.2913821936,
-0.3168771863,
-0.1481972337,
-0.039477922,
-0.0890385062,
-0.2352418154,
-0.4215430617,
0.8984376788,
-0.0642276332,
-0.3347501457,
-0.6997902393,
0.3507781327,
0.6168844104,
-0.2432615906,
0.5600389242,
0.4459062517,
-0.2314672619,
-0.4523907006,
-0.5254290104,
-0.3850681782,
-0.4529267251,
0.3455011249,
-0.5171524882,
-1.4419797659,
0.556735456,
-0.0205412917,
0.2904233336,
-0.0264772028,
0.9096795321,
0.1712576896,
0.9407631755,
0.6171482801,
-0.1030580923,
0.8501653075,
-0.1637047529,
0.4237174392,
-0.799746573,
0.0865373015,
-0.4630544782,
-0.1177276969,
-0.4978407919,
-0.7319766283,
0.3870117962,
0.0831040889,
-0.1796306223,
0.370785147,
-0.2542751729,
0.3621578515,
0.2866639793,
0.1079189107,
0.5406492352,
-0.0093543325,
-0.0732026622,
-0.0021821563,
-0.6705822945,
-0.3266972601,
1.0687214136,
0.2839056253,
0.8714825511,
0.1532825679,
0.6881706715,
0.1104421839,
0.5030930638,
-1.0261051655,
0.8198453784,
-0.3340273499,
-0.4397546649,
-0.4001989663,
-0.5565339327,
-0.5111348629,
0.3672350347,
0.1815805584,
-1.4530923367,
-0.127291292,
0.1956317872,
-0.6321125031,
0.3033319116,
-0.4866941869,
0.7282442451,
0.0232499707,
-0.3774482906,
-0.2936235666,
-0.4206421673,
0.4744488299,
-0.0572164953,
-0.1375716925,
-0.4772685766,
0.2485317737,
0.4801140726,
-0.5575162768,
1.2420061827,
-0.4279640913,
-0.5086705089,
0.4012232423,
0.24957183,
0.5518997312,
0.0241767988,
0.1260082275,
0.148827523,
0.3907739222,
-0.2728922665,
-0.6476793885,
0.9885577559,
-0.3726243079,
-0.7269622087,
-0.1546981484,
-0.7704845667,
-0.3964380026,
0.1572329253,
-0.1570910066,
0.7453439236,
-0.2468865663,
0.4292053878,
0.5868288279,
-0.1810860187,
0.6052692533,
0.8224486113,
-0.3841791749,
-0.1145492941,
0.9057666063,
0.0559975207,
0.7154031992,
0.5381845832,
0.0530091152,
-0.5785492659,
-0.4766118228,
-0.517608285,
0.184087038,
-0.393527478,
-0.487136513,
-0.6700270176,
-0.2293502688,
-0.37390697,
-0.0087534618,
-0.4307914674,
-0.3525011539,
-0.1687049419,
0.1225606874,
0.5321155787,
0.3059621453,
0.1708030552,
0.4050465226,
-0.5789932013,
0.3390626013,
0.16979146,
0.5122137666,
0.0649168342,
-0.4500646889,
-0.0891135484,
0.360041827,
-0.4208553731,
-0.7434297204,
0.2900646031,
0.1364089251,
0.3691523075,
0.2685654759,
0.2897855043,
0.7071892023,
-0.4200042486,
0.7702721953,
0.2459339052,
-1.1759530306,
0.4756706059,
-0.7891286612,
0.5263017416,
0.3049137592,
-0.0322239622,
-0.5771396756,
-0.5569550991,
-0.2230289131,
-0.5792152882,
1.1102280617,
0.2245858908,
0.3084158003,
0.1172580943,
0.1953079104,
-0.1799262464,
0.133667022,
-0.4327707291,
0.104796581,
-0.1151536554,
-0.2398381084,
-0.0389855504,
-0.0640458167,
-0.1300134957,
-0.0755918622,
0.5525236726,
-0.6317954659,
0.4186972678,
0.0349448659,
-0.0622288473,
-0.1674118489,
0.4929344952,
0.8788674474,
0.6108722091,
-0.2706088424,
-0.3975119591,
0.3345888555,
-0.3013155758,
0.0356772542,
0.2113678753,
-0.1604421437,
-0.1262825727,
0.0388316549,
0.9943551421,
0.505864799,
-0.671826303,
0.5993584394,
0.0586890616,
-0.2056961507,
-0.0415760763,
0.3252188563,
0.1030518413,
0.5736455321,
0.3741816878,
-0.2974413335,
-0.1244885549,
-0.5697401166,
0.1732027382,
0.6612672806,
-0.5449957252,
-0.3589008152,
0.5371035933,
0.413993746,
-0.34213081,
0.3060460389,
0.0293607078,
-0.4412223697,
0.438700676,
0.7270751595,
0.8944951892,
-0.4368258119,
0.39453125,
0.179223001,
-0.1141514257,
-0.110204801,
0.3430504799,
-0.3950605392,
-0.7702065706,
-0.9312503338,
-0.7310454845,
-0.4964295328,
0.298994422,
-0.6289824247,
0.2429804802,
-0.5107684135,
-0.2157758921,
-0.0044933748,
0.2083148211,
-0.3510806561,
-0.0376986898,
0.2477060109,
0.9144400358,
-0.3805111647,
1.122956872,
0.3323548734,
-0.1581064761,
-0.734485507,
0.1269816011,
0.30489856,
-0.6450917125,
0.2793703973,
0.2188856453,
-0.4097777307,
0.2866460681,
-0.4946963787,
-0.7801593542,
1.1265300512,
0.4438512325,
-0.8820434213,
0.1209641621,
0.0246013105,
0.5656327605,
-0.6183473468,
0.3183869123,
0.6348406076,
0.1427558959,
0.4934343994,
-1.3700703382,
0.2172682732,
0.1017445922,
0.1782503575,
0.4747361243,
-0.8767060637,
0.4627811611,
-0.3010913432,
-0.1524758637,
0.3972318769,
0.3997495174,
0.3624457717,
0.1128930449,
0.5399106741,
0.1809124947,
0.3443419337,
-0.145476535,
0.7664869428,
-0.2458718568,
0.5747843385,
1.2067790031,
-0.57478863,
0.9316134453,
0.3496748507,
0.0706147477,
0.0453268811,
0.2915302217,
0.1285334826,
0.5617748499,
0.4150856733,
-0.4304957986,
-0.3312933743,
-0.2412594259,
-0.1601778567,
0.530145824,
0.62183249,
-0.1017880514,
-0.424335897,
-0.079302974,
0.1666938066,
-0.1537080854,
-0.2808079422,
0.8030328155,
0.2414555401,
-0.6906531453,
0.7684036493,
-0.0471575558,
0.671661675,
-0.7397040725,
-0.0011136025,
-0.3447285593,
0.3427174985,
0.0646257848,
-0.4548015296,
0.2528277338,
0.2391052693,
0.1383090913,
-0.2599654198,
0.4784322679,
-0.6373564005,
-0.3655541837,
0.324082464,
0.3334811628,
0.0106820455,
-0.195801422,
-0.5256330967,
0.2884992957,
0.4147853553,
-0.1707573086,
0.3986148238,
0.21395877,
-0.4318023026,
0.7759379148,
0.7037089467,
-0.0660006776,
-0.1140941009,
0.1829293966,
0.9187130332,
-0.626178205,
-0.547426641,
-0.7524046302,
0.4097723961,
-0.0125464341,
-0.2911784947,
0.4697552323,
0.3324247599,
0.6751668453,
-0.042784337,
0.6145783663,
-0.1645253301,
0.6363882422,
-0.5033898354,
0.5623574853,
-0.3767952621,
0.2458836138,
-0.4365962446,
-1.1019283533,
-0.3875672817,
0.490359664,
-0.4830669761,
-0.0376755148,
0.3863295913,
1.023801446,
-0.1398106366,
0.2225363851,
0.6257205606,
0.4039661586,
0.7243638635,
0.6307539344,
0.9183929563,
-0.0683282465,
0.5692806244,
0.0628538504,
-0.4020825624,
-0.5432643294,
-0.7728238106,
-1.0695254803,
-0.6211588383,
-0.4199496806,
-0.1284775883,
0.0420188718,
0.9139652252,
0.8518887162,
-0.8045121431,
-0.327839613,
0.0930190682,
-0.2328653634,
-0.1795784831,
-0.2680403888,
0.0672929212,
-0.3533265889,
-0.8194958568,
0.5532844663,
0.4627311826,
-0.084505178,
-0.262732178,
0.053020943,
-0.0817097351,
0.3008366823,
0.7890112996,
0.3008111119,
-1.0965982676,
-0.3628539741,
-0.0985059366,
0.1233441904,
-0.0815720856,
1.0835504532,
-0.4195088744,
0.4211999476,
0.3001301289,
0.5271027684,
0.892475605,
0.0621130392,
0.7001951933,
-0.79402107,
0.1532253176,
0.2830742598,
0.1274379641,
0.3206076622,
-0.1697473973,
0.3160036206,
-0.0058747092,
-0.4309737384,
-0.9214532971,
0.429479748,
-1.245321393,
-0.0875367895,
1.1850897074,
-0.3259735107,
0.0218435824,
-0.0770719275,
-0.3533319235,
0.1216461882,
-0.7589151859,
0.6638088822,
0.6032820344,
-0.2823391259,
-0.2818763852,
-0.7333974242,
0.4612880051,
0.2267258614,
-0.7274085283,
0.4068115354,
0.607029438,
0.5657941699,
-0.022911841,
0.9850272536,
0.0421256013,
-0.1067592576,
-0.4277887344,
-0.2606455982,
0.0091316774,
-0.2292856425,
-0.2673165798,
-0.076159589,
-0.083035633,
-0.2812298238
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10462v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10462v1
|
QDyLoRA: Quantized Dynamic Low-Rank Adaptation for Efficient Large Language Model Tuning
| 2024-02-16T05:42:17 | 2024-02-16T05:42:17 |
Hossein Rajabzadeh, Mojtaba Valipour, Tianshu Zhu, Marzieh Tahaei, Hyock Ju Kwon, Ali Ghodsi, Boxing Chen, Mehdi Rezagholizadeh
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Finetuning large language models requires huge GPU memory, restricting the
choice to acquire Larger models. While the quantized version of the Low-Rank
Adaptation technique, named QLoRA, significantly alleviates this issue, finding
the efficient LoRA rank is still challenging. Moreover, QLoRA is trained on a
pre-defined rank and, therefore, cannot be reconfigured for its lower ranks
without requiring further fine-tuning steps. This paper proposes QDyLoRA
-Quantized Dynamic Low-Rank Adaptation-, as an efficient quantization approach
for dynamic low-rank adaptation. Motivated by Dynamic LoRA, QDyLoRA is able to
efficiently finetune LLMs on a set of pre-defined LoRA ranks. QDyLoRA enables
fine-tuning Falcon-40b for ranks 1 to 64 on a single 32 GB V100-GPU through one
round of fine-tuning. Experimental results show that QDyLoRA is competitive to
QLoRA and outperforms when employing its optimal rank.
|
[
-0.2784017622,
-0.8629545569,
0.4875656366,
0.1891310364,
-0.4968324602,
0.4935719669,
-0.2893964648,
-0.2010981888,
-0.1134493425,
0.165082857,
-0.3713594675,
-0.5921221375,
-0.3310329914,
-0.1838905364,
-0.1100649461,
1.0111032724,
0.2451238632,
-0.3380008042,
0.2856381238,
-0.3626722097,
-0.5217265487,
-0.3379624784,
-1.0195615292,
0.1678079665,
0.9081727266,
0.4147943854,
0.9838202,
0.5499706268,
0.4113771915,
0.3809487224,
-0.3241591454,
0.2132955343,
-0.934289813,
0.3540530503,
-0.2718894184,
-0.7557474971,
-0.9212456942,
-0.1085896194,
0.9620636106,
0.3946350217,
-0.2723644078,
0.413100183,
-0.08075241,
0.8021000028,
-0.9639630318,
0.1814299524,
-0.8703865409,
0.0913128704,
-0.2588327229,
-0.3550317287,
-0.0279085208,
-0.5413541198,
-0.2376769632,
-1.0731662512,
-0.2976442873,
0.0263416525,
0.619969964,
0.5810686946,
-0.5423777103,
0.0295271873,
-0.8921492696,
0.5333068371,
-0.7351481915,
0.2544826567,
0.1074367464,
0.598739624,
-0.1068767533,
-0.7452668548,
-0.4070745409,
-0.0039527025,
0.5624709725,
0.0911019817,
-0.1456432045,
0.2121929079,
0.4507615268,
0.4909636974,
-0.4825312495,
0.3864666522,
-0.2159612775,
0.2739585638,
0.4351412356,
0.1179020032,
0.2363431901,
0.2398135811,
0.057024803,
-0.311901927,
-0.6608430743,
0.1182259545,
0.4135709107,
0.4405273199,
-0.1737872362,
0.1905834079,
-0.2889575958,
0.6822564006,
0.4321008325,
-0.3452959061,
-0.1570333391,
-0.0647669658,
-0.4532661736,
0.3540375531,
0.189646244,
0.0284066964,
0.254802227,
0.0118407663,
-0.2221133709,
0.090182431,
0.1554525495,
-1.1247981787,
-0.5401223302,
0.2242212892,
-0.3994455636,
-0.3705349267,
-0.1459501684,
-0.8381029963,
-0.3873704076,
-0.210610196,
0.6057627201,
-0.0805921406,
-0.2571882904,
0.0315446518,
0.1382871866,
0.1030288115,
0.6010163426,
-0.9722722173,
0.306419611,
0.5906456709,
0.9254502058,
-0.2361658216,
-0.1136960462,
-1.1332058907,
0.1280387342,
-0.5052527785,
0.6968955994,
-0.4098743796,
-0.2003994733,
-0.1752362251,
0.1382906139,
-0.2553014457,
-0.7581134439,
0.3190411031,
-0.8726402521,
-0.1383841038,
0.012438708,
-0.3444320858,
-0.0139800422,
-0.1477415264,
-0.684679985,
0.7215575576,
0.5780866742,
-0.5653560758,
0.2054567635,
-0.4490802288,
0.0032158385,
0.170049578,
0.2399117202,
-0.454613924,
0.4589045942,
-0.0418959521,
0.0163210165,
-0.1233238652,
0.1420450211,
-0.6268069148,
-0.7597609758,
0.2572048008,
-0.521407783,
0.7795177698,
0.5247407556,
-0.1867714077,
0.3585259318,
-0.8253724575,
0.2821262777,
0.046491392,
-0.6377892494,
-0.4516803622,
-0.1000500768,
-0.0743406862,
0.1362540722,
0.1567143649,
-0.0614383146,
0.5569446087,
-0.494225204,
0.5580668449,
0.7147516608,
-0.0321896523,
0.4650402367,
-0.1541838348,
0.8395848274,
-0.0728443041,
0.1771441102,
0.3239639103,
-0.1679870188,
-0.8556123376,
-0.2668049932,
0.4970827401,
0.4213727117,
-0.9779525399,
0.1989829391,
-0.3848351538,
-0.4406227767,
-0.5897032022,
0.2148196101,
0.195618242,
-0.0960466862,
0.208928749,
0.0319801793,
-0.3138901293,
-0.465860635,
-0.1757110357,
-0.0681010336,
0.1514799297,
-0.0212924834,
0.1882178932,
0.0548631065,
0.6277268529,
-0.4954965413,
-0.3652376235,
0.0470620617,
-0.1403589547,
0.4164718091,
0.5513830185,
0.81822896,
-0.6350557208,
-0.6461353898,
0.1516287476,
-0.4017709792,
-0.0730057955,
-0.0576425456,
-0.2989067435,
0.1821265668,
0.5738224387,
-0.5020460486,
0.2074376941,
1.1245040894,
-0.4776024222,
0.2981370389,
-0.636081934,
0.0021053387,
-0.9699646235,
0.0661528558,
-0.3193857968,
-0.5214727521,
-0.4725991189,
0.2384562641,
0.1116838977,
-0.3908090889,
-0.5475509167,
0.5008738637,
-0.326529175,
-0.2048867494,
-0.4794659019,
0.4678674936,
-0.1425092518,
0.5142820477,
-0.4279140234,
1.0762150288,
0.4191868901,
-0.5121079683,
0.4760604203,
0.0801948309,
-0.3821150959,
0.6862131953,
-0.4153154492,
0.0858493969,
0.0747811273,
0.1749996841,
-0.6988498569,
0.1554117352,
0.1365615726,
0.167390883,
0.2468561977,
-0.5711477995,
-0.2682273388,
-0.0353741907,
-0.3139098287,
0.8433631659,
0.5324520469,
-0.7471707463,
0.147577256,
0.3282167614,
-0.3462906182,
0.032264106,
-0.2425178885,
0.1097545102,
-0.6010020971,
-0.1507038325,
0.5035039783,
-0.4921970367,
-0.3361932039,
-0.2779865861,
-0.0199707467,
0.1495020688,
0.5534870625,
0.260810107,
-0.0663596019,
-0.5509420037,
0.1627726108,
0.3092867434,
-0.1477353871,
-0.3316448033,
-0.2734579146,
0.4267755151,
-0.3312860131,
-0.0314362608,
-0.5836078525,
0.0170014072,
0.78964293,
-0.197604686,
0.6880078316,
0.7063897848,
-0.2123884708,
-0.5346326232,
0.0090848617,
-0.0339653455,
-0.5485072732,
0.5315734744,
-0.5241693258,
-0.7758929133,
0.4812115431,
-0.3962798119,
-0.3114381135,
0.4329348803,
0.4960778356,
-0.0514556356,
1.1289509535,
0.5001983643,
-0.0417700522,
0.7763553262,
-0.3169350028,
0.1586501598,
-0.7689662576,
0.3680766821,
-0.4641852975,
-0.5045983195,
-1.1221743822,
-0.4067345262,
0.5518296957,
0.4744787514,
-0.5014403462,
-0.0890419334,
-0.3860717416,
0.4115632474,
0.4359568059,
0.0280593038,
0.4535861909,
-0.0208398364,
0.4098731279,
0.1663746089,
-0.7746068835,
-0.1141547635,
0.7568457723,
0.221063301,
0.7300437093,
0.5547330379,
0.5740641952,
0.4946730435,
0.0058082473,
-0.7718238831,
0.4151163399,
-0.5792431235,
-0.1399015337,
-0.5562077761,
-0.3414184749,
-0.9444978833,
0.4061233103,
-0.3838193417,
-0.5455359221,
0.365380168,
0.1553326398,
-0.8769078851,
0.2347334474,
-0.5017234087,
0.854355216,
-0.0916528627,
-0.3760813177,
-0.4892151356,
-0.0789114535,
0.364433527,
-0.4045346081,
0.0451339893,
-0.4451502562,
0.1061116308,
0.804590404,
-0.5082728863,
0.6449351311,
-0.4502388835,
-0.5654398799,
-0.0487976335,
0.2624147534,
0.75917238,
0.3215304911,
-0.1399678439,
-0.1888385117,
0.694396019,
-0.5921904445,
-0.8777707815,
1.0771702528,
-0.9569254518,
-0.6134362221,
-0.4446521997,
-0.6756982803,
-0.3253169954,
0.1237669587,
-0.2296405137,
0.3113430142,
-0.006326702,
0.1914798915,
0.5811468959,
-0.4148481488,
0.3872671425,
0.4391077161,
-0.2895552516,
-0.4940139949,
1.2170438766,
0.2332895398,
0.2249013782,
0.3177130222,
0.1925976276,
-0.0081230197,
-0.8690589666,
-0.4697044194,
0.2648334503,
-0.5727296472,
-0.3336922526,
-0.0792545453,
-0.3612236381,
-0.1542106718,
-0.0340892859,
-0.5548862815,
-0.6782835126,
-0.5516527295,
0.3017295599,
0.4271167517,
0.423045218,
0.269248873,
0.5732676983,
-0.5551089048,
0.5457416773,
0.6480009556,
0.257876724,
-0.0053530638,
-0.7727342844,
-0.4649578929,
0.1860623062,
-0.2125661671,
-0.5433285832,
0.5317454934,
0.6933683753,
0.3858982325,
0.4286800921,
0.4043980241,
1.0860784054,
-0.2400783449,
0.3325608075,
-0.3666630089,
-0.992425561,
0.451318711,
-0.477868855,
0.5132357478,
0.5444030762,
-0.0092320647,
-0.3308691382,
-0.3302809894,
-0.2252150029,
-0.564250052,
0.7236732841,
-0.0304280072,
0.0128562422,
0.3902479708,
0.7165703773,
-0.10052412,
0.1388844699,
-0.3227539659,
-0.0218893327,
-0.2011810541,
-0.2502707243,
-0.3577914536,
-0.3175974786,
-0.1789014041,
-0.4083257914,
0.6272575259,
-0.6835005879,
0.0953124091,
-0.3454663455,
-0.3460227549,
-0.2266853899,
0.1232167333,
0.8979386091,
0.7545355558,
-0.5575195551,
0.3289405406,
0.375988245,
-0.3925299942,
0.32172364,
-0.0934452862,
-0.0164553411,
-0.4638387263,
0.1371747106,
1.0919017792,
0.5078759193,
-0.6040555239,
0.2659824491,
-0.1449871659,
-0.0406480767,
-0.0705836713,
0.5440527201,
0.1321882457,
0.6812744141,
0.271525681,
-0.3621065915,
-0.2886300981,
-0.6935301423,
-0.1778416187,
0.3776547313,
-0.2073451281,
-0.4348836243,
0.7121921778,
-0.0007659842,
-0.20658198,
0.6093037128,
-0.2807885408,
-0.0447626635,
0.5611388683,
0.6844428182,
0.7679936886,
-0.3386675715,
0.3114746809,
0.1835144907,
-0.2905551493,
0.0049482258,
0.3870401084,
-0.0136044035,
-0.4679909647,
-0.2000802606,
-0.9374293685,
-0.3545117676,
-0.1038463935,
-0.6948030591,
0.1332899928,
-0.6607291102,
-0.338493377,
-0.0705881491,
0.4310175776,
-0.339255929,
-0.0218466427,
0.1660109013,
0.7967956066,
-0.5953524113,
1.5748161077,
0.4052753747,
-0.1491294652,
-0.4747499526,
0.0423765257,
-0.3121367693,
-0.682339251,
0.7729862332,
-0.427321732,
-0.1381879598,
0.6519259214,
-0.1609364003,
-1.1298795938,
1.5183317661,
0.7834110856,
-0.7629153132,
-0.1345980614,
-0.0971448347,
0.7310627103,
-0.2279847115,
-0.0495518818,
0.6144710779,
0.5233310461,
-0.1859763414,
-0.8752720356,
0.0658750832,
0.0056139566,
0.3720496893,
-0.0771120638,
-1.0169420242,
1.0726292133,
-0.193269521,
-0.278418541,
0.3622560501,
0.6351600885,
0.4487577379,
0.1517429948,
0.564664185,
0.2285635769,
0.9710279703,
0.0484516658,
0.640106976,
-0.539460659,
0.5489734411,
0.9303269386,
-0.298238039,
1.0472077131,
0.40861696,
-0.4247077405,
0.5370567441,
0.6721336842,
0.0762486458,
0.6797137856,
0.4217548966,
-0.1733929515,
-0.3608328998,
0.1099201441,
-0.3460846543,
0.6304599643,
0.322358042,
0.1049482673,
-0.143335402,
0.2588794231,
-0.0911181495,
-0.1875246316,
-0.6252361536,
0.7689934373,
0.1030272543,
-0.4928771257,
1.4617948532,
0.080228135,
0.4315179586,
-0.398417592,
0.0030753149,
-0.5735096931,
0.3668963313,
-0.0973473415,
-0.1692379117,
-0.073788777,
-0.3028258085,
-0.1401437521,
0.0500230007,
0.4534316957,
-0.5484771729,
-0.4661363065,
0.0901318043,
0.4464576244,
-0.0571978353,
-0.4190464318,
-0.6638196111,
0.5252999067,
-0.3008778691,
-0.2704707384,
0.9264038205,
0.4914934039,
-0.4016076028,
0.8424515128,
0.6487465501,
0.3819197714,
0.0556787848,
0.0264937077,
0.9300676584,
-0.7565501928,
-0.6582229137,
-0.4658265114,
-0.1782076955,
0.3124865294,
-0.0556515492,
0.5468341708,
0.3625122309,
0.4945588112,
-0.0618436821,
0.5193530321,
0.4129733145,
0.109211944,
-0.912525475,
1.0077102184,
-0.7756187916,
0.3142789006,
-0.0080199726,
-1.1708897352,
-0.2225972116,
0.5695121884,
0.0084877415,
0.0680200309,
0.7092292309,
0.722205162,
-0.2344890386,
-0.2842671573,
0.8201093078,
0.5814791322,
0.4456594288,
0.8110920787,
0.6710218191,
-0.4947206676,
0.3505659103,
-0.1070609465,
-0.1174301356,
-0.5316982269,
-0.9386963248,
-0.6346715093,
-0.3985795081,
-0.6183807254,
-0.240415886,
0.5887620449,
0.7363883257,
0.8715664148,
-0.9708109498,
-0.1497693807,
0.1072367132,
0.1570862979,
-0.4884241819,
-0.2268898189,
0.7251970172,
-0.3645817339,
-1.1311980486,
0.6169469953,
0.3218192756,
0.1267662644,
-0.5132800937,
-0.2899039686,
0.04751084,
0.002964122,
0.690967679,
0.3882020414,
-0.4578436613,
-0.3285443485,
-0.5834239721,
-0.1993774474,
0.0742091909,
0.7381581664,
-0.9300588369,
0.2276913524,
0.4782315791,
0.3749377728,
0.628459096,
0.1599200368,
0.3031735718,
-0.292068541,
0.3481554389,
-0.0047876271,
0.0209082905,
-0.0330648683,
-0.1469369233,
0.1310363859,
0.2836264372,
-0.6194847822,
-1.0388796329,
-0.059781123,
-1.4169636965,
-0.4712717235,
1.3163682222,
-0.2388685793,
-0.3290052116,
0.0037637115,
-0.4054116905,
0.2262610048,
-0.2563016713,
0.9334083796,
0.0249811523,
0.2161143571,
-0.4048000574,
-0.6435182095,
0.9180731177,
0.1491729319,
-0.9336848855,
0.2635678947,
0.1017462239,
0.3119881749,
-0.3530550301,
0.4368753135,
0.2077494711,
0.2381326556,
-0.1206681132,
-0.2670937777,
-0.1249442995,
-0.3129765987,
-0.6035857201,
0.4353806674,
0.7452635765,
-0.0605591089
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10987v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10987v2
|
WilKE: Wise-Layer Knowledge Editor for Lifelong Knowledge Editing
| 2024-02-16T05:29:59 | 2024-06-05T07:44:30 |
Chenhui Hu, Pengfei Cao, Yubo Chen, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Knowledge editing aims to rectify inaccuracies in large language models
(LLMs) without costly retraining for outdated or erroneous knowledge. However,
current knowledge editing methods primarily focus on single editing, failing to
meet the requirements for lifelong editing. This study reveals a performance
degradation encountered by knowledge editing in lifelong editing, characterized
by toxicity buildup and toxicity flash, with the primary cause identified as
pattern unmatch. We introduce a knowledge editing approach named Wise-Layer
Knowledge Editor (WilKE), which selects editing layer based on the pattern
matching degree of editing knowledge across different layers in language
models. Experimental results demonstrate that, in lifelong editing, WilKE
exhibits an average improvement of 46.2% and 67.8% on editing GPT2-XL and GPT-J
relative to state-of-the-art knowledge editing methods.
|
[
0.2193043083,
-0.7571353316,
0.7583858967,
0.1675178558,
0.0041987193,
0.2246387601,
-0.1110899076,
-0.5343844891,
0.0149529483,
0.8023093939,
-0.3219560981,
-0.6987817883,
-0.3852680027,
-0.21381253,
-0.2860296667,
0.7858203053,
-0.0161013175,
0.1218644604,
-0.4492530823,
-0.3491457701,
-0.9538219571,
-0.0902725682,
-1.1299108267,
-0.3837320805,
0.4953982532,
0.6551795602,
1.0437847376,
0.5517676473,
0.1838120222,
0.376242429,
-0.3371205926,
0.300200969,
-0.3198327422,
0.3996248841,
-0.3782576621,
-0.3500349224,
-0.8826882243,
-0.0211908538,
0.5639002919,
0.5247221589,
0.026792556,
0.0105530415,
0.1393796653,
1.0395858288,
-0.6855829358,
-0.2240965068,
-0.5639827847,
0.0884422734,
-0.3680742979,
-0.1962840855,
-0.3183380663,
-0.3918777704,
-0.0035208305,
-0.8399476409,
-0.2188398093,
-0.0503326766,
0.1305871457,
0.2305767834,
-0.3122330606,
0.1454219818,
-0.7126085162,
0.5933920145,
-1.2195887566,
0.3975674212,
0.3955158889,
0.0218626447,
-0.4193932414,
-0.7443016768,
-0.6265267134,
-0.0780341849,
0.0940324068,
0.180950731,
0.1956513375,
0.2941531241,
0.2913135886,
0.0708325133,
-0.4223005474,
0.019142827,
-0.0536317937,
-0.3931780756,
0.7535793185,
0.1832819581,
0.5818421841,
-0.2325376123,
-0.1603003293,
0.2509839833,
-0.6928849816,
-0.2159085721,
0.5062776804,
-0.2766302824,
0.4526847303,
0.5023164749,
-0.2106388956,
0.9117561579,
-0.1793171912,
-0.5436767936,
0.0473603792,
0.0140245762,
-0.3874921501,
0.0774353892,
0.7892583609,
0.6968156695,
0.2717984319,
-0.4158168137,
-0.2579910457,
-0.412235409,
0.139046669,
-0.4348638058,
-0.3585433066,
0.3397965431,
-0.2285093367,
-0.6687915325,
-0.0875786096,
-0.7759670615,
-0.6510856748,
-0.1144204214,
0.7776020169,
-0.6119274497,
-0.0874281004,
0.340113014,
-0.3369451165,
-0.3254668415,
0.4910303056,
-0.3294249475,
-0.1766972393,
0.43969962,
0.8610903025,
-0.1348766685,
-0.6133739948,
-0.4728184044,
0.4593113363,
-0.4725829661,
0.9353687763,
-0.6854708791,
-0.3863294125,
-0.2418947369,
-0.2478046268,
0.0177805964,
-0.5357794166,
0.5081702471,
-0.9223168492,
0.392883867,
-0.4282842577,
-0.8524953127,
-0.1309182644,
0.0476922281,
-0.7251843214,
1.2309125662,
0.2431398332,
-1.0392080545,
0.4452118576,
-0.8819526434,
-0.4252788723,
0.154534772,
0.4475207627,
-0.4106859267,
-0.0799607262,
0.067446366,
0.2686544657,
0.1928892136,
0.3502309322,
-0.3621532321,
-0.2973736823,
0.1118607819,
-0.2047092766,
0.8214536905,
0.0340607427,
-0.2683148086,
0.3705813587,
-0.9899353385,
0.1575111598,
0.0222563483,
-0.4275562167,
-0.7609777451,
0.1853206903,
-0.0656041205,
0.4645014703,
0.237154752,
-0.6267025471,
0.5074632764,
-0.1186140478,
0.4047068059,
1.1272147894,
0.4040590525,
0.3582423627,
-0.645825386,
0.5200504661,
0.1588754803,
0.4034398794,
0.5560789704,
-0.7580225468,
-0.7225971818,
0.2053369433,
0.341786921,
0.8567193151,
-0.8748733997,
0.1858474463,
-0.1813032329,
-0.3922306895,
-0.2195577472,
0.7266654372,
0.3080841601,
0.7961878777,
0.5116919875,
-0.3178423047,
-0.3396085501,
-0.7170886397,
-0.7706431746,
-0.0271508396,
0.1430695653,
-0.0512477271,
0.2092755139,
-0.514537096,
1.058790803,
-0.329011023,
-0.364145577,
-0.2120095789,
-0.0050440682,
-0.2708100677,
0.3423008323,
0.4025601447,
-0.3450535834,
-0.7600662708,
0.0068004294,
-0.6164842844,
-0.3276594579,
-0.1552840769,
-0.4761532843,
0.2981155813,
0.7447599173,
-0.280066967,
0.2404610664,
0.6773306727,
-0.4336718023,
0.6841410398,
-0.3309496343,
0.4135199189,
-1.1028374434,
-0.0305930357,
-0.2430670261,
-0.3465481997,
-0.7876297832,
-0.1329976022,
0.3558941782,
0.1778042018,
-0.5360190272,
0.5230984092,
-0.3869955242,
0.1959412545,
-0.1384870112,
0.1659073979,
0.0644752681,
0.3287392557,
-0.2896361947,
0.8882695436,
0.3861199915,
-0.4410757422,
0.371480912,
0.1361485571,
-0.5250858665,
0.5523315072,
-0.4217303991,
0.5490000844,
-0.0181825291,
-0.043735221,
-0.6141271591,
-0.2207525671,
0.0926180407,
0.0646811947,
0.311706543,
-0.0611582398,
-0.6600781679,
-0.1649788171,
-0.590806365,
0.3738660514,
0.2536492944,
-0.3682944477,
0.6354917288,
0.2004056126,
-0.0643980801,
-0.7616637945,
-0.7718474865,
0.3210403025,
-0.2272780389,
-0.9307569265,
0.3865112066,
-0.4195692241,
-0.3198495507,
0.1514986008,
-0.2200077772,
0.0089444751,
0.0273992885,
-0.0417876355,
0.1094253212,
-0.0457900241,
0.0853426531,
0.3158980906,
-0.1306919008,
-0.0740926266,
-0.368264854,
0.0428274423,
0.2760722935,
-0.2100553662,
-0.2439985275,
0.4086232185,
0.9115540385,
-0.398189187,
0.8412930369,
0.2828730941,
-0.2081248164,
-0.345943749,
-0.9807190299,
0.3831121624,
-0.5368173122,
0.4637914598,
-0.1882016659,
-0.8341587186,
0.7821882367,
-0.1390558183,
0.1847408414,
0.6466076374,
0.0340401754,
-0.2501374781,
0.798913002,
0.6166557074,
-0.3393630087,
0.4728315175,
0.1070442796,
0.0122340964,
-1.0228328705,
-0.1156924665,
-0.0483317785,
-0.4369858205,
-0.2291914076,
-0.1766121984,
0.5734463334,
0.4432130456,
-0.2987560928,
0.2063425779,
-0.4363670647,
0.9766467214,
0.3629323244,
0.3944709003,
0.8047100902,
-0.3061397672,
-0.1943278462,
0.0350327455,
-0.7507879138,
-0.3646754026,
1.2229162455,
0.0923768803,
0.6621814966,
0.4300456643,
0.5923109055,
0.400336206,
0.3087638617,
-0.3382796049,
0.6982876658,
-0.1350536346,
-0.5242051482,
-0.4371031523,
-0.3568680584,
-0.3701159656,
-0.1210762709,
-0.1288887858,
-0.5761168003,
0.019230416,
0.4681392908,
-0.2296649218,
0.8932473063,
-0.8168837428,
1.0596530437,
-0.2969501615,
-0.4576953351,
-0.2468430102,
-0.6001634598,
0.4405306876,
-0.3261454999,
0.4321914017,
0.3168193996,
-0.0461001582,
0.9594270587,
-0.4494727254,
0.4574110508,
-0.3518522978,
-0.2691640258,
0.1434430033,
0.5803591013,
0.7982906699,
0.2411203533,
-0.2292069197,
0.1153615043,
-0.0002803067,
-0.1407913119,
-0.6671911478,
0.7329400182,
-0.672649622,
-0.5914433599,
-0.2118961215,
-0.7898010015,
-0.6159120798,
0.3830842078,
0.3622265756,
0.3536063731,
0.0008923966,
-0.1773506105,
0.8021194935,
-0.4964845479,
0.2314831316,
0.4593401253,
-0.3158580959,
-0.242898941,
0.858830452,
0.2877416313,
0.7218702435,
0.1826482117,
0.4393338263,
0.1079037264,
-0.6523631215,
-0.298348546,
-0.0226724446,
-1.0418747663,
-0.3227454126,
-0.7789580822,
-0.2997342944,
-0.3859033287,
-0.2614949346,
-0.350294143,
-0.3875612319,
-0.0684605166,
0.1855563372,
0.6676137447,
1.1326640844,
-0.3181555271,
0.052924227,
-0.6601685286,
0.3825617135,
0.6462666988,
0.7809904218,
-0.1066541299,
-0.6516084671,
-0.2507248223,
-0.0412409827,
-0.2974101007,
-1.2954595089,
0.0890729353,
0.3798105717,
0.4909596443,
0.0222823601,
-0.232695967,
0.8525096774,
-0.4171717167,
0.6290928721,
-0.2213721573,
-1.1252788305,
0.7022935748,
-0.3865482211,
0.5262417793,
0.675106883,
0.0422659181,
-1.0745273829,
-0.7948470712,
-0.5006349087,
-0.7078128457,
0.5604986548,
-0.2436623871,
-0.1250307262,
0.1726589203,
0.5221791267,
0.0022150683,
-0.0408411771,
-0.5780839324,
-0.2676329911,
-0.2915425301,
0.0329766981,
0.1668175161,
-0.5851774216,
0.0882720128,
-0.5712223649,
1.0985162258,
0.037785694,
0.0966769084,
0.183878392,
-0.4898430109,
-0.5782822371,
0.6227958202,
0.6804498434,
0.8332297206,
-0.3079272211,
-0.028935533,
0.5374923348,
-0.5954992175,
-0.0478786044,
-0.3445459008,
-0.2790191472,
-0.2850567698,
0.5627971292,
0.4119839072,
0.4212509394,
-0.3970039785,
0.3750380278,
0.1688321978,
-0.3122490644,
-0.0171795376,
0.4083525538,
0.3897601962,
0.1452332139,
0.0713474005,
0.5725845695,
0.052932404,
-0.3477381468,
0.1146940663,
0.3897429109,
0.0300671998,
0.2524905801,
0.7646688223,
0.0304882582,
-0.2184665203,
0.6865622401,
-0.2757602036,
-0.6215533614,
0.2698697746,
0.3074047863,
0.9012872577,
-0.2474068999,
0.1533821225,
0.3364746869,
0.2609700263,
-0.1908056587,
0.0341157541,
0.2796498537,
-0.8338788748,
-0.7561546564,
-0.4339483678,
-0.3884176016,
0.4379048347,
-0.4723723829,
0.0701950416,
-0.4703647494,
-0.0121540744,
-0.1874926388,
-0.1291592717,
-0.5240488648,
0.0064905742,
-0.3357796669,
0.9283742905,
-0.6804160476,
1.1208297014,
0.7377663255,
-0.1840379238,
-0.9067481756,
0.1081597954,
0.248519063,
-0.5857649446,
0.4010456204,
-0.2265954167,
-0.0996740758,
0.3161095679,
-0.4521173239,
-0.6962861419,
1.2542847395,
0.439810276,
-0.7418997884,
-0.0374315642,
0.0910442546,
0.4026048481,
0.2617387474,
0.0651452914,
0.6857528687,
0.68504107,
-0.2312918752,
-0.8704953194,
-0.0481984727,
-0.189423129,
0.1608084142,
0.1460492909,
-0.5867879391,
0.5194400549,
-0.2448498309,
-0.1485674679,
-0.006678944,
0.4079705179,
-0.2210698575,
-0.1144217625,
0.6095041633,
0.8631449938,
0.61253649,
0.2130022645,
0.6336737871,
-0.4312942326,
0.341592133,
1.0093981028,
-0.0745863616,
0.5818711519,
0.1933975965,
-0.0849286169,
0.883085072,
0.3521866202,
0.2328733355,
0.4454461038,
-0.2373054624,
-0.4698135555,
-0.3452577889,
0.4602035284,
-0.2966776788,
0.081243515,
-0.0101757916,
-0.0333495624,
-0.0872174725,
0.1342761815,
0.2394157946,
-0.0330273211,
-0.3264354467,
0.8295610547,
-0.1616129577,
-0.5800666809,
0.0478994586,
0.2761074901,
0.8389368057,
-0.6521178484,
-0.0038276212,
-0.4084650278,
0.0402803011,
-0.4747286737,
-1.1516504288,
0.418969065,
-0.0937933102,
-0.1467314959,
-0.2201884687,
1.0433124304,
-0.5506214499,
-0.4275847971,
0.4809243977,
0.4235531092,
-0.3580812216,
-0.2850700021,
-0.976213336,
-0.0337059349,
-0.0020829998,
-0.5202408433,
0.3096108437,
0.474291265,
-0.1248943061,
0.6961936355,
0.6626254916,
0.3082280755,
0.0605551526,
0.2304157317,
0.6924036145,
-0.6983299255,
-0.3634179831,
-0.7912920713,
0.807897985,
-0.0702343509,
-0.3158058524,
0.6547003984,
0.3983722329,
0.878749609,
-0.0090710586,
0.8464094996,
-0.1348886639,
0.2914274037,
-0.7421183586,
1.0943256617,
-0.686680913,
0.3185725212,
-0.6844790578,
-1.0856471062,
-0.5332587957,
0.4467405677,
-0.2655495107,
0.236307919,
0.9309588671,
0.9890515208,
-0.0568240359,
0.0284463186,
0.4938684106,
0.5775146484,
0.2405242473,
0.649158299,
0.5479853749,
-0.3413880467,
0.1502239257,
-0.7128154635,
-0.1703985929,
0.2065048814,
-1.0254495144,
-0.9485091567,
-0.4432391226,
-0.3722268045,
-0.3999125659,
0.2833934426,
0.5923776627,
0.3397944868,
-0.61353755,
0.1888796836,
-0.2270804942,
0.1409047544,
-0.4183941782,
-0.2681771517,
0.3966443539,
-0.2929653823,
-0.1842664331,
0.5890328288,
0.488160342,
-0.2878822088,
-0.2915436327,
-0.1619434804,
-0.2141591907,
-0.0450943895,
0.6834723353,
0.1947815716,
-0.4075159132,
-0.5996256471,
-0.1457669884,
-0.1567101032,
0.0389813036,
0.787088275,
-0.5751703978,
0.7797750831,
0.4762016535,
0.5909873247,
0.1151686087,
-0.3231106699,
0.3062848449,
-0.6384042501,
-0.1614530534,
0.0756633356,
0.2547074854,
0.3595990241,
-0.6296736002,
0.2550819516,
0.4379001856,
-0.8647034764,
-0.3915856481,
0.0041571674,
-1.1176760197,
-0.2883351445,
1.3757337332,
0.1913629472,
-0.0413051955,
-0.3039920926,
-0.3027682602,
0.2432426959,
-0.0175511576,
0.6840148568,
0.857121408,
-0.0971206874,
-0.1408226788,
-0.9748246074,
0.6514697671,
0.5967425108,
-0.910189867,
0.1668097675,
0.6101209521,
0.8198104501,
-0.3228698969,
0.6650322676,
-0.2858330309,
0.445984453,
-0.3217480183,
-0.0055141607,
-0.4377228618,
-0.3414455056,
-0.0685668513,
-0.0805997252,
0.348886162,
0.4049988687
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10986v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10986v3
|
FinTral: A Family of GPT-4 Level Multimodal Financial Large Language Models
| 2024-02-16T05:05:12 | 2024-06-14T13:26:47 |
Gagan Bhatia, El Moatez Billah Nagoudi, Hasan Cavusoglu, Muhammad Abdul-Mageed
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We introduce FinTral, a suite of state-of-the-art multimodal large language
models (LLMs) built upon the Mistral-7b model and tailored for financial
analysis. FinTral integrates textual, numerical, tabular, and image data. We
enhance FinTral with domain-specific pretraining, instruction fine-tuning, and
RLAIF training by exploiting a large collection of textual and visual datasets
we curate for this work. We also introduce an extensive benchmark featuring
nine tasks and 25 datasets for evaluation, including hallucinations in the
financial domain. Our FinTral model trained with direct preference optimization
employing advanced Tools and Retrieval methods, dubbed FinTral-DPO-T&R,
demonstrates an exceptional zero-shot performance. It outperforms ChatGPT-3.5
in all tasks and surpasses GPT-4 in five out of nine tasks, marking a
significant advancement in AI-driven financial technology. We also demonstrate
that FinTral has the potential to excel in real-time analysis and
decision-making in diverse financial contexts. The GitHub repository for
FinTral is available at \url{https://github.com/UBC-NLP/fintral}.
|
[
-0.2000274658,
-0.8379852176,
0.2346425503,
0.3723144531,
-0.2014131397,
0.2500315607,
-0.4107272923,
-0.7195987105,
-0.0578685626,
0.8394062519,
-0.4362996519,
-0.7187105417,
-0.5168749094,
-0.0714687258,
-0.3698184788,
1.0542906523,
0.1774470508,
0.0777231455,
0.2955945432,
0.0223034546,
-0.2352634519,
-0.828273952,
-1.0442512035,
-0.3471385241,
0.4864694476,
0.1700125337,
0.5938604474,
0.3197080493,
0.7664926052,
0.2767496407,
0.2727881074,
-0.0245492049,
-0.513047576,
0.1444887072,
-0.017128367,
-0.143011108,
-0.7283607721,
-0.0916650668,
0.4711710513,
0.5486738682,
-0.4922139049,
0.2961042821,
-0.2509996891,
0.634709239,
-0.4253096581,
0.8814760447,
-0.3723031878,
-0.0144417435,
-0.3419127762,
-0.075631693,
-0.4266182184,
-0.0351744331,
0.3448539972,
-0.605214119,
0.143631503,
0.2685829997,
0.4911343753,
0.3016137481,
-0.6464478374,
-0.2817444205,
-0.747811377,
0.4448559582,
-0.6078062057,
0.9414092898,
0.2278617024,
0.42998752,
-0.0383957997,
-1.1767200232,
-0.3551103175,
-0.3684245944,
0.1302682757,
0.1472868621,
-0.3788784444,
0.5278849602,
0.0392753854,
0.3186543286,
-0.5314511657,
-0.1400470734,
-0.6501160264,
-0.3197924793,
0.5343191624,
0.1724073291,
0.0184556581,
0.0272039734,
-0.5565037727,
-0.4469437599,
-0.4705037177,
-0.0082274126,
0.4432032108,
0.6685725451,
-0.1968609095,
0.3598836958,
-0.0817594603,
0.9362547994,
0.106727317,
-0.6010494828,
0.1924204975,
-0.3945403695,
-0.3746884167,
0.3473294973,
0.7206830978,
0.2113468349,
0.1100001186,
0.0162495747,
-0.5196946859,
-0.1754815429,
0.1630948782,
-0.5270596743,
-0.4768613875,
0.2104839981,
-0.3746744394,
-0.299741298,
-0.1601748765,
-0.8237086535,
-0.3042218685,
-0.3769449294,
0.480317682,
-0.3668594956,
-0.3195890486,
0.7011641264,
-0.199942559,
0.1657978743,
0.164199695,
-1.2558004856,
0.6481624842,
0.8781180382,
0.6518604159,
0.2387138903,
-0.2832306623,
-0.6011466384,
0.1983650029,
-0.4041664898,
0.947208941,
-0.5753494501,
-0.2102234811,
-0.064745158,
-0.3588278294,
-0.3164390028,
-0.3050322533,
0.3400393128,
-0.562876761,
0.1961794943,
-0.1010208353,
-0.2741593122,
-0.5161707997,
0.1479438394,
-0.8860920668,
0.8956218958,
0.4080045819,
-0.7995473742,
0.5359374285,
-0.9351611733,
-0.1881329566,
0.1882736832,
-0.2154177129,
-0.2247294635,
-0.2380601913,
0.1377609819,
0.4726466238,
-0.5857969522,
0.4123251438,
-0.4572680295,
-0.1976640821,
0.1530976444,
-0.661075294,
0.2695989013,
0.141889289,
-0.5412017107,
0.4156315923,
-0.7107521892,
-0.3218802214,
-0.006094656,
0.0464873612,
-0.3469593823,
-0.406863302,
0.574321568,
0.246130988,
0.3822692037,
-0.3118699789,
0.1830466986,
-0.2897033691,
0.6438177824,
0.9251672029,
-0.1035764813,
0.1785562187,
-0.2359235436,
0.5795471668,
-0.2674410641,
0.6058869362,
0.0883389711,
-0.1910255402,
-0.3997910619,
-0.6618283987,
0.2831074893,
0.357560128,
-0.5754707456,
-0.1622167677,
-0.2251411527,
-0.5068240166,
-0.1739983112,
0.2128541321,
0.1701703519,
0.3062939644,
0.0786515325,
-0.1533619314,
-0.2730613351,
-1.1563432217,
0.091387637,
-0.4310275316,
0.4491631985,
0.2367910892,
0.2140983194,
-0.2205419391,
0.6490627527,
-0.5223166347,
-0.3283165991,
-0.6102651954,
0.1447034478,
0.4012225866,
0.060606733,
0.8894606829,
-1.08373034,
-0.1687715352,
0.1960368454,
-0.5494172573,
0.0198498983,
-0.3830949664,
-0.0924812704,
0.0519328527,
0.4950523376,
-0.5624434352,
0.0323181003,
0.6483798027,
-0.7427153587,
0.6346942782,
-0.3225370944,
0.0479523093,
-0.8745760322,
0.2482759804,
0.1103916019,
-0.2490068674,
-0.6659142375,
-0.0024305568,
0.0435639992,
-0.0561653189,
-0.1775376797,
0.8918791413,
-0.2204036713,
-0.4494099319,
-0.0626869798,
0.1864110976,
-0.0150132813,
0.6026153564,
-0.0887536407,
0.8031498194,
0.5108236074,
-0.3030133247,
0.8163686395,
0.2558774352,
-0.2984115779,
0.3019140065,
-0.5084563494,
-0.2842762172,
0.0228137691,
0.2896936834,
-0.9378539324,
-0.3766393065,
0.5664948225,
0.0462319218,
0.3504232168,
0.0598633662,
-0.3993099928,
-0.3604227006,
-0.1129290983,
0.5388704538,
0.0004369636,
-0.497176528,
0.8947073817,
0.1470176429,
-0.717161715,
-0.9743458629,
-0.2725327909,
0.3646514714,
-0.3525272906,
-0.4800006449,
0.2049168199,
0.0432017148,
-0.5371572971,
-0.0586769432,
-0.1640206873,
0.0640870929,
0.1005517766,
0.2765475512,
0.7582401037,
-0.3258846104,
0.2788555324,
-0.1906435043,
-0.319468677,
-0.0956479162,
-0.7232275605,
0.7248491049,
-0.4942804277,
-0.2850167751,
-0.3011381626,
-0.1227225587,
0.7666130066,
-0.4334525466,
0.5388996005,
0.6775916815,
-0.1841721684,
-0.0543180965,
-0.771368444,
0.1313180178,
-0.5093166828,
0.3371305168,
-0.3691327274,
-1.1344066858,
0.5803663135,
0.1360216439,
0.2690382004,
0.5602747798,
0.6217743158,
0.4513660669,
0.4095527232,
1.0994398594,
-0.1414312273,
0.7124360204,
-0.202236712,
0.3194694221,
-0.2309163958,
-0.2844062448,
-0.1813489348,
0.00187652,
-0.2430693954,
-0.212098971,
0.3569845259,
0.0304350667,
-0.5455322266,
0.1770718545,
-0.146045804,
0.1985572577,
0.3588761091,
-0.2048542351,
0.3668324351,
-0.001308436,
-0.2536663413,
0.3392953575,
-0.7489215136,
-0.3104489148,
1.361243248,
0.5363517404,
0.9224818349,
-0.0665161535,
0.4367799163,
0.6143990159,
0.5130152702,
-0.6446725726,
0.1866715401,
-0.2722572088,
-0.6817927361,
-0.3982952535,
-0.5915378928,
-0.51228863,
0.2680466175,
-0.2762820721,
-0.5007103086,
0.1949915439,
-0.0580726415,
-0.986782074,
0.4244709015,
-0.5246454477,
1.0798313618,
-0.6361172795,
-0.2323546857,
-0.1738715768,
-0.2977452576,
0.6679711342,
-0.5373969078,
0.4526166022,
-0.0539431199,
-0.0264164675,
0.6366869211,
-0.0998860821,
0.9010031223,
-0.0491704307,
-0.574216783,
0.0949111283,
-0.1127214432,
0.1338909566,
0.2032653391,
-0.0589676872,
0.2547866702,
0.2237106413,
-0.3611194789,
-0.5949365497,
0.5874831676,
-0.6683087349,
-0.3997915983,
-0.402102828,
-0.51649791,
-0.1519713104,
0.2359238267,
-0.2062714249,
0.912470758,
-0.2296483815,
0.0709843263,
0.2681754529,
-0.2166622579,
0.3309094906,
0.1877291948,
-0.5734131932,
-0.8847276568,
0.8320806623,
-0.2056594342,
0.2847621143,
0.3448896706,
-0.0473887771,
-0.7223371863,
-0.3916913867,
-0.4267989099,
0.4485984147,
-0.8193960786,
-0.1724378169,
-0.601323843,
-0.1612489969,
-0.5754519701,
-0.1190434098,
-0.4973784387,
-0.4300726652,
0.2297932059,
-0.4398279488,
0.5742488503,
1.0476396084,
-0.4165424705,
0.4095575213,
-0.8272725344,
0.3498831689,
0.3999236524,
0.617595911,
0.0695766658,
-0.1160911098,
-0.2731487155,
-0.1470963508,
0.1764293164,
-0.2563245893,
0.4698557556,
0.1621125489,
0.5589826107,
0.7690881491,
-0.0921425894,
0.6393151283,
-0.0652699918,
0.5902096033,
0.375039041,
-0.7302880883,
-0.0631950647,
-0.569974184,
-0.15219751,
0.4487557113,
0.0231877808,
-0.9094315767,
-0.2638642192,
-0.537180841,
-0.9303696156,
0.549859643,
0.0522353202,
-0.0666117147,
0.1161655709,
0.6450932026,
0.4796382189,
0.50292629,
-0.7287169099,
-0.1245656684,
-0.4829137027,
-0.340233624,
-0.4358565211,
-0.287776351,
-0.1111513302,
0.0800313875,
0.4909590185,
-0.2584553659,
0.077134423,
0.1037648916,
0.2006869316,
-0.0128120333,
0.0306482799,
0.7056507468,
0.8578203321,
-0.4040137529,
0.06916783,
-0.0937227085,
-0.7029880881,
0.0211908706,
0.4353204966,
0.3589732945,
-0.1200521067,
0.6524712443,
0.8898978233,
0.7309959531,
-0.9104822278,
0.4340254664,
-0.4104479253,
-0.4862061739,
-0.7018219829,
0.0018168931,
-0.116281569,
0.8429179192,
0.6189719439,
0.0475720502,
0.0923393145,
-0.5006892681,
0.3614652753,
0.2371183038,
-0.4425984621,
-0.2898613811,
0.8631061912,
0.1166065186,
0.2864480019,
0.6540637016,
0.1795541048,
-0.5455318689,
0.3462360203,
0.4230862558,
0.9223804474,
0.0726741701,
0.5026346445,
0.0500994511,
0.2661620378,
-0.4639235139,
0.2876094878,
-0.1448978931,
-0.6976832747,
-0.4495655596,
-0.9442340136,
-0.4469363987,
0.1141484156,
-0.5892330408,
0.1085463986,
-0.7682411075,
-0.4739641249,
0.1549399048,
-0.0381108671,
-0.6109759212,
0.0208344031,
0.469462961,
0.9495744705,
-0.5580627918,
0.5316082239,
0.4414763749,
-0.3973651826,
-0.5046417713,
-0.2412773669,
-0.0105060386,
-0.6700531244,
0.8688391447,
-0.0762970597,
-0.3017823696,
0.1435938179,
-0.4539461434,
-0.8722411394,
1.1949057579,
0.487478435,
-0.5807167888,
-0.3545665443,
0.1573000997,
0.3447527587,
-0.4301845431,
0.0642035976,
0.5811634064,
0.7268745899,
0.1391867697,
-1.043612957,
-0.4006217718,
-0.2261695415,
-0.3164221048,
0.416110158,
-0.9071611762,
1.0077553988,
-0.0914351344,
-0.0769845918,
-0.2076292634,
0.4987967014,
0.2465395331,
0.3087484837,
0.6145589352,
0.3458726406,
0.7774714828,
-0.0831102505,
1.125975728,
-0.7012619376,
0.3548264503,
0.8446310759,
-0.391464889,
0.7793180943,
0.123600632,
0.0632769093,
0.3225187361,
0.87059021,
-0.0502225198,
0.3993352652,
-0.0725628808,
-0.4338558912,
-0.6581773162,
0.0913731158,
-0.2268718779,
0.6806312203,
0.4291557968,
-0.0069669979,
-0.2496397197,
0.1837884784,
-0.251622349,
-0.2289590091,
-0.3756185472,
0.5784976482,
0.3790629804,
-0.0930924937,
0.3678858578,
0.1382958293,
0.6808089018,
-0.9851773977,
0.0413840041,
-0.2484985888,
0.3550261557,
0.1399403811,
-0.3876925409,
-0.0857540444,
-0.1368636787,
0.1856147498,
-0.3493126333,
0.7697377801,
-0.3258671463,
-0.6757745743,
0.6650006771,
0.5538673401,
-0.0939526856,
-0.0744303018,
-0.6613680124,
-0.1242041886,
-0.0536425486,
-0.263358593,
0.0970873535,
0.5297813416,
-0.1549061537,
1.0297335386,
0.9921263456,
0.0239623804,
-0.1956500411,
0.2367710471,
0.8495717645,
-1.0368840694,
-0.5446685553,
-0.7760974765,
-0.0665357858,
0.1655593067,
-0.3684325814,
0.34473598,
0.733612597,
0.7895191312,
0.0193008259,
0.834353745,
0.3544932008,
-0.0402017795,
-0.607922852,
0.7440268397,
-0.3918694258,
0.1131420508,
-0.4755297601,
-0.9822070599,
-0.4668764472,
0.461820662,
-0.4020491838,
-0.0502094068,
0.4414390326,
0.4866632819,
-0.1340109706,
0.2684101164,
0.4634588063,
0.147780478,
0.2827112675,
0.3454592526,
0.6559292674,
-0.1505260468,
0.5670929551,
-0.1691496372,
-0.1774474084,
-0.2919452786,
-0.5142531395,
-0.9642631412,
-0.6125099063,
-0.0326841697,
0.1296279579,
0.1698063165,
1.2284758091,
0.342895925,
-0.3773506284,
-0.6372249722,
0.4403406084,
-0.1894261241,
-0.3256322742,
-0.1055438221,
0.3839609623,
-0.3573752344,
-0.3676505685,
0.3142790496,
0.8099969029,
0.2809489667,
-0.4473786056,
0.0373485871,
0.1591572464,
0.0238253381,
0.7615292668,
-0.0245299526,
-0.54506284,
-0.254850626,
0.0971503183,
-0.0825119913,
-0.1502263397,
0.832098186,
-0.2654250264,
0.1880293339,
0.0884121209,
0.4216463864,
0.5717105865,
0.0437973514,
0.8412795067,
0.0129076615,
0.3627485037,
-0.0299283136,
0.4686227739,
0.0293702967,
-0.3096833527,
0.5246741772,
0.1698135883,
-0.2343672812,
-0.5605657101,
-0.1796402931,
-0.9821206331,
-0.3067659736,
0.9542708993,
0.0820978358,
-0.4608538747,
-0.1370367557,
-0.3200813234,
-0.0324679464,
-0.565979898,
0.7028880715,
0.7903640866,
-0.0274309181,
-0.2569797635,
-0.9770594239,
0.6496813893,
-0.1447923183,
-0.4857572615,
0.5056321621,
0.68080616,
0.2704224288,
0.0022177461,
0.8512615561,
-0.1534032971,
0.3075139523,
0.3422286808,
0.3112130165,
-0.3534816802,
-0.5034838319,
-0.2151355296,
0.3244849443,
0.098770678,
0.329447329
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10453v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10453v1
|
Steering Conversational Large Language Models for Long Emotional Support Conversations
| 2024-02-16T05:03:01 | 2024-02-16T05:03:01 |
Navid Madani, Sougata Saha, Rohini Srihari
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this study, we address the challenge of consistently following emotional
support strategies in long conversations by large language models (LLMs). We
introduce the Strategy-Relevant Attention (SRA) metric, a model-agnostic
measure designed to evaluate the effectiveness of LLMs in adhering to strategic
prompts in emotional support contexts. By analyzing conversations within the
Emotional Support Conversations dataset (ESConv) using LLaMA models, we
demonstrate that SRA is significantly correlated with a model's ability to
sustain the outlined strategy throughout the interactions. Our findings reveal
that the application of SRA-informed prompts leads to enhanced strategic
adherence, resulting in conversations that more reliably exhibit the desired
emotional support strategies over longer conversations. Furthermore, we
contribute a comprehensive, multi-branch synthetic conversation dataset for
ESConv, featuring a variety of strategy continuations informed by our optimized
prompting method. The code and data are publicly available on our Github.
|
[
-0.2539913654,
-0.7223467827,
0.8393504024,
0.6658357382,
-0.2755541205,
0.1762965322,
-0.4662201405,
-0.2095549554,
0.513674736,
0.5167278647,
-0.9900648594,
-0.3735069335,
-0.4227449596,
0.036797639,
-0.0490798615,
1.0567858219,
-0.2007922828,
-0.0110622486,
-0.2013941705,
-0.4290815592,
-1.0621436834,
-0.2812569439,
-1.0044224262,
-0.2499159724,
0.9676947594,
0.8133749962,
0.4379116297,
0.5209944248,
0.5006691217,
0.2245386392,
-0.297372669,
0.1399092525,
-0.6980593801,
0.6487005353,
-0.2467591166,
-0.676687777,
-0.3854155838,
-0.4041904807,
0.6771485806,
0.3401307166,
-0.6990328431,
0.3042108417,
0.0458454825,
0.69763273,
-0.4572870135,
-0.0014558962,
-0.7398504019,
0.0834071562,
-0.1448152661,
-0.2550970018,
-0.6004546881,
-0.0088607669,
0.3337949216,
-0.4458495677,
-0.4957155287,
-0.0026904114,
0.6486307979,
0.4151713848,
-0.5256144404,
-0.4206436872,
-0.6696408987,
0.8479835391,
-0.5664052367,
0.3675638735,
0.2432216257,
0.1908279955,
-0.2091015875,
-0.3725110888,
-0.194648847,
-0.3624571562,
0.1443316191,
0.3046658933,
-0.504606545,
0.1688141078,
0.3321741223,
-0.410359472,
-0.0893794075,
0.3047349453,
-0.2436235398,
0.2346921861,
0.4904808998,
0.2530212104,
0.0609504767,
0.1412674338,
-0.378002733,
0.1040411517,
-0.7166468501,
0.2741197944,
0.2244793475,
0.0598042905,
-0.3589734733,
0.6514220238,
-0.1363627315,
0.3465471566,
0.4479247332,
0.1343981475,
-0.1272391677,
-0.2411226332,
0.0658533126,
0.2723700702,
0.42147699,
0.582095921,
0.522942543,
-0.007840937,
-0.0079641948,
0.0441944413,
0.4374631345,
-0.5911759138,
0.1688575894,
0.3706180751,
-0.4927730858,
0.0892567486,
-0.373811692,
-0.8951140046,
-0.3910048604,
-0.5590173006,
-0.16392456,
-0.0855188966,
-0.1171427071,
-0.0115647363,
0.2225150168,
0.4702153504,
0.1142695248,
-0.9031305909,
0.0861251727,
0.9268293381,
1.0046876669,
-0.1582704633,
0.0659022406,
-0.5774695277,
0.3673302829,
-0.5423642397,
0.8142230511,
-0.6811706424,
-0.3732401133,
0.1784185171,
0.0572699681,
-0.0663989708,
-0.3853233457,
1.0628199577,
-0.2519606352,
0.0670662299,
-0.4213884771,
-0.2660439312,
-0.042131152,
0.5965055823,
-0.3740917444,
0.7062439322,
-0.376549542,
-0.3446645737,
0.1385892332,
-0.5665184259,
-0.426561743,
-0.2068032473,
-0.0649795979,
-0.3420945406,
0.1531747431,
0.3115659058,
0.6473697424,
-0.3595528007,
0.2656969428,
-0.4307945669,
0.053757526,
0.3242150545,
-0.2700858116,
-0.012563617,
0.243787095,
-0.3993753493,
0.3416547477,
-0.4598010778,
0.0199158899,
0.1823295057,
-0.1152107492,
-0.3685890138,
0.2450433224,
-0.2276792526,
0.3296779692,
0.149710834,
-0.2828666866,
0.1475173831,
-0.2381079495,
0.593231976,
1.0299445391,
0.1921316683,
0.2345020622,
-0.1321457177,
0.9197844863,
-0.1053883061,
-0.0273968223,
-0.2326200604,
-0.4085606337,
-0.8568821549,
-0.2595978081,
-0.1611617953,
0.482459873,
-0.4502104223,
0.1976463944,
-0.4014308155,
-0.5682806373,
-0.4161831737,
-0.0796805099,
0.3422802091,
0.4640685618,
0.1306730956,
-0.1953775883,
-0.6287817955,
-1.1511602402,
-0.2088348716,
-0.2225017399,
0.2737531364,
0.6189053059,
0.1963199526,
-0.1932840049,
0.7001470923,
-0.3448592424,
-0.1398252845,
-0.498395443,
-0.0249744859,
0.1411450505,
-0.0080585983,
0.4740200043,
-0.483369112,
-0.7591876984,
-0.1110712215,
-0.5423229337,
-0.3242336512,
-0.3935905099,
-0.3465656936,
0.2297929376,
0.6610082388,
-0.7087856531,
0.1237166226,
0.8424426317,
-0.487270087,
0.2725222707,
0.1306246817,
0.3512742519,
-1.1808845997,
-0.0348656662,
0.3390756845,
-0.1903097034,
-0.8185895085,
-0.3976183832,
-0.1383938193,
0.0835205317,
-0.3434839249,
0.42751652,
-0.3624964058,
-0.0319940597,
-0.0615747347,
0.3580143452,
-0.2731706798,
0.4230796397,
0.4624738693,
0.6239660978,
0.5032148957,
-0.4640917182,
0.2618045509,
0.3980175555,
-0.112543188,
1.1143699884,
-1.0675132275,
0.1979172677,
-0.137548089,
0.5094979405,
-1.1155883074,
0.0783889666,
0.2574450672,
-0.1444956362,
0.1725642681,
-0.1072411686,
-0.0656813532,
-0.3388200402,
-0.0766325966,
0.1097766832,
0.2787802219,
-0.2881493568,
0.8933939934,
0.3313838243,
-0.8147143722,
-0.5090920925,
-0.4118882418,
0.2790253758,
-0.5554062128,
-0.6747089624,
0.1813650578,
-0.2075421065,
-0.3293723166,
-0.224382624,
0.0154798944,
0.4014196098,
0.002951348,
0.418145448,
0.2557768822,
-0.1838248223,
0.3315484524,
-0.3278710544,
0.0309004877,
0.3181907237,
0.0352879204,
0.7246773243,
-0.1327614784,
-0.4069431424,
-0.677500546,
0.5217666626,
0.7353871465,
-0.1792807877,
0.8239593506,
0.3026065826,
-0.1232954934,
-0.1839367598,
-0.6943433285,
-0.4423079789,
-0.4010772705,
0.619027853,
-0.2448619753,
-0.6829174757,
0.6617226601,
0.1292616427,
0.2299121469,
-0.008060596,
0.5580539703,
-0.2484121472,
1.3927670717,
0.5268176794,
-0.2711543143,
0.7459883094,
0.1347398013,
0.4210295379,
-0.8408882022,
-0.2624769211,
-0.3715213537,
-0.7074881792,
-0.1374081373,
-0.132781297,
-0.0022036701,
-0.3434915543,
-0.1764787883,
0.0822101459,
-0.3181234896,
0.1804860234,
0.0773267671,
-0.0903189927,
-0.139025569,
-0.0115852952,
0.3810735941,
-0.3294672668,
-0.8621816039,
-0.3742641509,
0.7337533236,
0.9357049465,
0.8418537974,
0.241546005,
0.2930227816,
0.1242898554,
0.32813555,
-1.0262849331,
0.6826511025,
0.4088932276,
-0.2312136292,
-0.0953026488,
-0.4469756782,
-0.9932755232,
0.0406318046,
-0.1689789444,
-0.7733950615,
-0.0800095797,
-0.0353969149,
-0.4176400006,
-0.1398971081,
-0.6847091317,
0.7873676419,
-0.4769828916,
-0.1928890944,
-0.4937975705,
-0.4719440937,
0.0508026741,
0.0214315318,
-0.0207445081,
-0.1975334287,
-0.1462071538,
1.0287257433,
0.027465431,
0.924287498,
0.1490264535,
-0.3476374447,
0.3659098148,
-0.2436880171,
1.1363289356,
-0.1435343474,
0.3074929714,
-0.1657273322,
-0.2211599797,
-0.2210184485,
-0.5721177459,
0.7638661861,
-0.5397549868,
-0.8876284361,
-0.3340902328,
-0.4722734392,
-0.5918375254,
-0.1000999808,
-0.1601409614,
0.0366686583,
-0.1026459858,
0.6610718966,
0.9392527938,
0.081943363,
0.3223997056,
0.6221030951,
0.1945164204,
-0.2888488173,
0.4188522995,
0.1465870738,
0.4616689384,
0.1278293282,
0.0801293775,
-0.3968429267,
-0.2876017988,
-0.2567702532,
0.4468940794,
-0.6640537977,
-0.0980222523,
-0.6967493296,
0.1627514958,
-0.2496097982,
-0.2835240066,
-0.4294084907,
-0.0323082432,
-0.4793243408,
-0.5040562749,
0.5611155629,
0.5474916697,
0.2982667685,
0.1767768562,
-0.7923130393,
-0.1088712364,
0.1182910725,
-0.0548489243,
0.226800859,
-0.6752702594,
-0.20895271,
0.0227191951,
-0.1498079449,
-1.1560480595,
0.2931587398,
0.1490317434,
0.7757748365,
0.3885988295,
-0.0395771191,
0.8529332876,
-0.4287250638,
0.8675484657,
0.4170538783,
-0.8037222028,
0.7411108613,
-0.6110751033,
0.427062571,
0.3940642774,
0.4572516978,
-0.9170134068,
-0.3214805722,
-0.4891038835,
-0.9687197804,
0.6842123866,
-0.1654740125,
0.18337062,
-0.0341668501,
0.2593053281,
-0.6637194157,
0.2166470587,
-0.5894447565,
-0.2750561535,
0.4114475846,
-0.5695338845,
0.2286512554,
-0.5203418732,
-0.4799969196,
0.4592494369,
0.8093915582,
-0.3084796369,
0.0348386057,
-0.0338668339,
0.4508505464,
-0.326864928,
0.4595535696,
0.6393803954,
0.6777468324,
0.2135862708,
-0.3325635493,
0.5007314086,
-0.300470531,
0.1170890182,
-0.1338813305,
0.0101256873,
-0.2800405622,
0.1522348076,
0.798180759,
0.4559165537,
-0.8869672418,
0.2037194669,
-0.0692611933,
0.0101560466,
-0.2948080599,
-0.2430978715,
0.3319971263,
0.3965089321,
0.1044292748,
-0.4206857383,
-0.2416218519,
-0.7231082916,
0.1485280991,
0.5983758569,
-0.9742061496,
-0.0710631385,
0.3007950783,
0.4181585014,
-0.2952160537,
0.4421820939,
0.2738397121,
-0.5899404883,
0.6874351501,
0.4569708407,
0.6529229879,
-0.2780433297,
0.3173816204,
0.1270366013,
0.1145277694,
-0.1533597708,
0.2170490324,
0.0597357713,
-0.3630612791,
-0.3704553246,
-0.14627707,
-0.4648643136,
-0.1215366051,
-0.7723437548,
0.3306418061,
-0.4399704635,
-0.4517389536,
-0.2021721303,
-0.1262002587,
-0.4017645717,
-0.1305873096,
0.3045889139,
0.8765124679,
-0.7032800913,
0.3738517463,
0.6888870001,
-0.1990615875,
-1.0496892929,
-0.2020960599,
0.1562954783,
-0.7150299549,
0.594286859,
0.1081849411,
-0.2693863511,
-0.238996312,
-0.4697082937,
-0.9849868417,
1.2788882256,
0.2981832027,
-1.0707770586,
0.1921202242,
-0.112331003,
0.6523874402,
-0.6116631031,
0.2116784751,
0.4904778302,
0.4647398889,
0.2686785161,
-0.7546501756,
-0.0011806119,
0.0257471893,
-0.1651395112,
0.258888185,
-1.1723049879,
0.0907792374,
-0.3537329733,
-0.3769504428,
0.1929585338,
0.9162558317,
0.6266641021,
0.3389380872,
0.6276211143,
0.7655729651,
0.6571365595,
-0.1582222581,
0.6552526355,
-0.3461858332,
0.0963690653,
1.1080352068,
-0.6309438348,
1.0966835022,
0.7764661908,
0.2205630541,
0.6900584698,
0.690292716,
0.1164040044,
0.4248585403,
0.1552448422,
-0.1107909158,
-0.3239867389,
-0.6424429417,
-0.3162992299,
0.1710007191,
0.5123537779,
-0.5503998399,
0.1827063411,
-0.0365021154,
0.3241383135,
0.0745633319,
-0.4564960003,
0.8873187304,
0.3640386164,
-1.1367918253,
0.2519078553,
-0.275277704,
0.4594014585,
-0.9892655015,
0.0711068884,
-0.169152841,
0.2041811049,
-0.0914004818,
-0.8817201853,
0.0766047314,
0.2084353566,
-0.1807128936,
-0.2972207963,
0.45289886,
-0.7348106503,
-0.1930442899,
0.3662747145,
0.3059397936,
-0.2296168059,
0.177077949,
-0.872954309,
0.2324979305,
0.0501836427,
-0.6555126309,
0.3339730203,
0.5870533586,
0.0022006992,
1.0452071428,
0.6492617726,
0.064628318,
-0.2585002184,
0.2206383049,
0.6541261077,
-0.572096467,
-0.770111382,
-0.7292275429,
0.5100644827,
-0.0815926492,
-0.4152721465,
1.0307461023,
-0.1165161505,
0.2847182751,
0.1474342048,
0.4743101001,
0.2397840172,
0.1583561301,
-0.6973287463,
0.3984907269,
-0.3187897801,
0.258179754,
0.044675082,
-0.9667140841,
0.2209954262,
0.4895563126,
-0.5421914458,
-0.0021957776,
0.4222888947,
0.8305290937,
0.2372061312,
0.061896231,
0.0872683674,
0.2505705953,
0.5851512551,
0.8154093623,
1.0657368898,
0.253334254,
0.5870639086,
0.2942891717,
-0.116780363,
-0.1938512623,
-1.05146873,
-0.8360425234,
-0.3994276226,
-0.3951207995,
-0.3163310289,
0.3147712052,
1.2650002241,
0.8114562631,
-0.6731745601,
-0.0931129456,
-0.0531736463,
0.008815418,
-0.1256909817,
-0.2018852085,
0.0745094121,
-0.3381663859,
-0.5996577144,
0.3010317683,
0.3858993351,
-0.0098312926,
-0.3781161904,
-0.1133743897,
-0.3804117441,
0.5290957689,
0.5433535576,
0.414041698,
-0.63272506,
-0.303483963,
0.2890491188,
-0.1706973016,
-0.0841308609,
0.8053526878,
-0.4230889082,
0.2682854533,
0.381580472,
0.8727937341,
0.0282474216,
0.2245365977,
0.8085327148,
-0.6534766555,
-0.0432011932,
0.4310773313,
0.5145972967,
0.4365981221,
-0.5401283503,
0.6058146358,
-0.2142906338,
-0.8289518952,
-0.744736135,
0.3048663735,
-1.0303093195,
0.1839714944,
1.6597901583,
-0.2919811904,
-0.2288859934,
0.0817199349,
-0.4759763181,
-0.17762734,
-0.8671700954,
0.5531352162,
1.0489780903,
-0.1363456398,
-0.5925580263,
-0.483134985,
0.438459307,
0.9179506302,
-0.8178635836,
0.3789460659,
0.4752091765,
-0.0632698089,
0.279653728,
0.5791785121,
0.2938192189,
-0.0172168706,
-0.4905749261,
-0.4731771052,
0.3463052809,
-0.6008466482,
-0.3541582525,
-0.085618943,
-0.0431674235,
0.0786047503
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10447v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10447v2
|
Incremental Sequence Labeling: A Tale of Two Shifts
| 2024-02-16T04:41:33 | 2024-05-27T15:23:17 |
Shengjie Qiu, Junhao Zheng, Zhen Liu, Yicheng Luo, Qianli Ma
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The incremental sequence labeling task involves continuously learning new
classes over time while retaining knowledge of the previous ones. Our
investigation identifies two significant semantic shifts: E2O (where the model
mislabels an old entity as a non-entity) and O2E (where the model labels a
non-entity or old entity as a new entity). Previous research has predominantly
focused on addressing the E2O problem, neglecting the O2E issue. This
negligence results in a model bias towards classifying new data samples as
belonging to the new class during the learning process. To address these
challenges, we propose a novel framework, Incremental Sequential Labeling
without Semantic Shifts (IS3). Motivated by the identified semantic shifts (E2O
and O2E), IS3 aims to mitigate catastrophic forgetting in models. As for the
E2O problem, we use knowledge distillation to maintain the model's
discriminative ability for old entities. Simultaneously, to tackle the O2E
problem, we alleviate the model's bias towards new entities through debiased
loss and optimization levels. Our experimental evaluation, conducted on three
datasets with various incremental settings, demonstrates the superior
performance of IS3 compared to the previous state-of-the-art method by a
significant margin.The data, code, and scripts are publicly available at
https://github.com/zzz47zzz/codebase-for-incremental-learning-with-llm.
|
[
-0.0533806421,
-0.5467698574,
0.3707764447,
0.2022428662,
-0.1973838657,
0.031545721,
0.2653158605,
-0.6443066597,
-0.2394500822,
0.5038662553,
-0.742677927,
-0.4276292026,
-0.7780817151,
0.1465012282,
-0.546658814,
1.0563209057,
0.0430173278,
0.1633554399,
-0.1011922061,
-0.2090989798,
-0.5223425627,
-0.1146179065,
-0.8552119732,
-0.5959558487,
0.4934651852,
0.5402935743,
0.4081740379,
0.9886062741,
0.3109327555,
0.1150091887,
-0.1824789494,
0.0727689117,
-0.4540368021,
0.1948843002,
-0.3178913295,
-0.6106435061,
-0.2542366385,
-0.2819578648,
0.7042359114,
0.673048079,
-0.1080836505,
0.3386192024,
-0.0444386564,
1.0155178308,
-0.6765535474,
0.2793072462,
-0.9195138812,
0.2536143363,
-0.3921793997,
-0.08949662,
-0.5161159039,
-0.1828486919,
0.2691152096,
-0.7427254319,
0.2626870871,
-0.1797598749,
0.8284307718,
0.6609283686,
-0.3420543373,
-0.2652690113,
-0.5885145068,
0.4762922227,
-0.5681881905,
0.3086718321,
0.0021058272,
0.0507068746,
0.0387229435,
-0.5562596321,
-0.6514942646,
0.1304992288,
0.3551750183,
0.1193361208,
0.1193629429,
-0.3399843276,
0.3563038111,
0.3193493187,
-0.2408218384,
0.5658159256,
-0.2766260803,
-0.0334469937,
0.5456776619,
-0.0483888425,
0.0878938287,
0.282651782,
-1.0072433949,
-0.0927377716,
-1.0707658529,
-0.2629925609,
0.3190964162,
0.2863285244,
0.0565265864,
0.4819675088,
0.05952188,
0.5298965573,
0.1224093959,
-0.2962932289,
0.5033233762,
-0.0424569622,
-0.0334797539,
0.4152638316,
0.2479987592,
0.2670427263,
0.0027866459,
-0.0946450531,
0.0282361321,
-0.002315762,
0.1492786258,
-0.5435557365,
-0.1061740071,
0.0473737717,
-0.0506052971,
-0.1787639707,
-0.1180018857,
-0.5214787126,
-0.6065689921,
-0.4654305279,
0.4911702275,
-0.5077545047,
-0.2135896981,
0.0044775293,
-0.2253278345,
0.3184196651,
0.588804841,
-0.9021283984,
0.130895406,
0.5962063074,
0.8589237332,
-0.3284389973,
-0.2455213964,
-0.1645297855,
0.4161606431,
-0.2120264769,
0.7010396123,
-0.4227574468,
-0.4442643225,
-0.2013663352,
0.1158729792,
0.126504004,
-0.795915246,
0.0344128832,
-0.657063365,
-0.1027621701,
-0.1250187159,
-0.7252913713,
-0.3349824846,
-0.0142918164,
-0.690053761,
1.121258378,
0.012096311,
-0.6420465708,
0.5257872343,
-0.4503788352,
-0.3672937453,
-0.1066606566,
-0.169097051,
-0.7317198515,
-0.0923476815,
-0.1908677965,
0.0833021551,
-0.3655262887,
0.1922880411,
-0.3833825886,
-0.2739393413,
-0.0044613373,
-0.0782448277,
0.6990684867,
0.2272407413,
-0.4619561136,
-0.083044894,
-0.9324332476,
-0.0929072648,
0.0364938378,
-0.3611866534,
-0.2550162077,
0.1663568169,
-0.3696557283,
0.1682114899,
-0.0206342712,
-0.3389774561,
0.4636852145,
-0.1525606066,
0.4513833225,
0.7570330501,
0.1444478035,
0.6831963658,
-0.1239732802,
0.0476179607,
0.5131338239,
-0.0243963227,
-0.3394729495,
-0.6113293171,
-1.0420458317,
-0.1070670038,
0.2360412031,
0.8736029267,
-0.7860053778,
0.2460476458,
-0.3659727573,
-0.1962572038,
-0.2657756507,
0.1001115218,
0.283408612,
0.7400226593,
0.7291833758,
-0.1760263741,
-0.4505530596,
-0.9421256185,
-0.147583127,
-0.1734544188,
-0.0874158442,
-0.2805460095,
0.3467367887,
-0.3391116261,
0.5890434384,
-0.383929193,
-0.3659051955,
0.0799216032,
0.2826942503,
-0.0807763189,
0.6633689404,
0.0589735657,
-0.7108210325,
-0.2474232465,
-0.2481625229,
-0.7604097128,
-0.0522822216,
-0.3590838015,
-0.2850368917,
0.4979190528,
0.5904217362,
-0.2515518963,
0.4473150969,
0.0180567503,
-0.0482801385,
-0.0157792736,
0.0871814191,
-0.2137640566,
-0.7742196918,
-0.143626675,
0.0390123241,
0.0325564332,
-0.4935037196,
-0.3156476617,
0.3590532839,
0.0715321153,
-0.5355374813,
0.5508258343,
-0.4602739513,
-0.0092584537,
-0.1693081409,
-0.0470765606,
0.1794707328,
0.3625349998,
0.3024736941,
0.2602486014,
0.3785896003,
-0.8475041389,
-0.1474599391,
0.2993212044,
-0.3833031356,
0.5019400716,
-0.1883073747,
0.4574253857,
-0.3247443438,
0.2413283288,
-0.8823159337,
0.030649865,
0.5034309626,
-0.3060219884,
0.708153069,
-0.2597587407,
-0.5924363136,
-0.218202129,
-0.1670600623,
0.3376377821,
0.2682274878,
-0.5210270882,
0.1127476022,
0.3660795689,
-0.13318488,
-0.5270307064,
-0.8415116072,
-0.1258787811,
-0.2464579344,
-0.5560206175,
0.6905331612,
0.2028095722,
-0.0684630126,
0.1730055511,
-0.483034879,
-0.0395662934,
0.0529278852,
0.1068508998,
0.410199523,
0.0242828969,
0.6847831607,
0.1489643306,
-0.3894852698,
-0.1316628456,
-0.7124795318,
0.0559894033,
0.1742014885,
0.0043096934,
-0.394055903,
0.4201155007,
0.2418679148,
0.0494155623,
0.6286851168,
0.4298380911,
-0.4227100313,
-0.3295886219,
-0.3729785979,
-0.0219085794,
-0.3703140914,
0.5209984779,
-0.3060916364,
-0.7876136899,
0.1514537781,
-0.2543052137,
0.086364001,
0.4794311523,
0.4509995282,
-0.1025748923,
0.6564610004,
0.6576045156,
0.2406112552,
0.4173523486,
-0.2056831419,
0.1744814813,
-0.9663861394,
-0.5018953085,
-0.1468556225,
-0.3757981956,
-0.363732785,
-0.5293661952,
0.5126704574,
0.2870781124,
-0.4824175835,
0.1955436319,
-0.5876469612,
0.4153578579,
0.4515177608,
0.1219712719,
0.4702885449,
-0.0040391516,
0.3979469538,
0.1582463533,
-0.5278856158,
-0.5182571411,
0.9681538343,
0.2754604816,
0.6125501394,
0.2272686511,
0.6770808697,
0.5122106075,
0.5413872004,
-0.7597538829,
0.4401446879,
0.0717977732,
-0.6893607974,
-0.4823917449,
-0.3095314801,
-0.9474887848,
0.4597058892,
-0.1459159702,
-0.7304661274,
0.247563839,
0.3611039221,
-0.3170504272,
0.4293320477,
-0.6071313024,
0.6136093736,
-0.1913197339,
-0.6455026865,
-0.0265689939,
-1.0391005278,
0.412468791,
-0.0930309296,
0.2129033357,
-0.5671252608,
-0.2880708277,
0.5035098195,
-0.6529979706,
0.655246675,
-0.2981693149,
-0.2923786044,
0.5442953706,
-0.0857685879,
0.8772852421,
0.091649048,
-0.0570553057,
0.2277970165,
-0.0138152875,
-0.3526488245,
-0.4519077837,
0.5665565133,
-0.583424449,
-0.4724199474,
-0.5415844917,
-0.2631404996,
-0.2847304344,
0.2128232569,
0.434871614,
0.1112046614,
0.2248819619,
-0.3123525679,
1.0194681883,
-0.3431675732,
0.2366437465,
0.6496098042,
-0.1309674382,
-0.3932248652,
0.7345201969,
0.3737393618,
0.4959720671,
0.6006321311,
0.0576428995,
-0.5019750595,
-0.6243155003,
-0.5893430114,
0.2270942628,
-0.9838631153,
-0.3624050617,
-0.6608234048,
0.0281743389,
-0.4405107498,
0.1377776712,
-0.4044056237,
-0.5983656049,
-0.3926186562,
-0.2193573117,
0.3066269755,
0.7053515315,
-0.1436656564,
0.0982367694,
-0.6526943445,
0.2557563484,
0.2241946459,
0.1473868191,
-0.0143615333,
-0.5606926084,
-0.2244586349,
0.0270879585,
-0.4872002006,
-0.9675175548,
0.059713982,
0.2966494262,
0.2469449341,
0.0935200453,
0.0109966751,
0.6360320449,
-0.6649050713,
0.4645420611,
0.2902225554,
-1.0207052231,
0.6177828312,
-0.1721478552,
0.5244894624,
0.6395923495,
0.4461213648,
-0.480427593,
-0.0404744782,
-0.476918608,
-1.5003693104,
0.9151543379,
-0.0914893374,
-0.1675004512,
-0.1503272802,
0.5992193222,
0.4623014033,
0.3538716435,
-0.7960883379,
-0.5702618361,
-0.1524201334,
0.0240235999,
0.2525850832,
-0.2943095267,
0.0707796589,
-0.0516676754,
1.0686465502,
0.0591771156,
0.3346318603,
0.2337999344,
-0.4246439636,
0.0352161378,
0.1536068916,
0.4695313573,
0.3142214715,
-0.1336232275,
0.3315446079,
0.1906860173,
-0.2721479535,
0.4404637814,
0.0324735865,
-0.4680475891,
-0.156842351,
0.2031611353,
0.8763650656,
0.304987669,
-0.3458765745,
0.236889258,
0.5260689259,
-0.0922111198,
-0.4467540681,
0.0495725684,
0.0039429162,
0.2602700293,
0.2469372749,
0.4380691648,
0.3383120596,
-0.5845877528,
0.2229554504,
-0.1624331325,
-0.5111609101,
-0.2498848289,
0.7935479283,
0.1607870609,
-0.0086577488,
0.8025320172,
-0.1943337768,
-0.0850528106,
0.6755321622,
0.6231028438,
0.7511819005,
-0.1831300408,
0.1893183291,
0.6037026644,
0.0662219301,
-0.360586524,
0.0298804846,
-0.2363182306,
-0.7626767755,
-0.1443347931,
-0.3341302872,
-0.2878398597,
0.1138127297,
-0.9490212798,
0.4298422635,
-0.5001679659,
-0.1524315178,
0.1830298156,
-0.6403372884,
-0.5015359521,
0.1537514329,
0.6229205728,
0.8722652197,
-0.4907432497,
0.9806904197,
0.5596613884,
-0.2896840274,
-0.3313526511,
-0.1103728935,
0.495600462,
-0.8545808792,
0.8208401799,
0.448965013,
-0.2969421446,
0.3236052692,
-0.4372016788,
-1.2180606127,
1.3027458191,
0.2641931176,
-0.7310615778,
-0.0250779856,
0.1190457642,
0.2020283341,
-0.1527311951,
-0.1438243687,
0.4657618403,
0.4025584459,
0.422754705,
-0.4597231746,
0.0340228826,
-0.2295826972,
0.2469629347,
0.521302104,
-0.794733882,
0.7133963108,
-0.6317741275,
-0.6653394103,
0.1722230762,
0.5206235051,
0.194130823,
0.471653223,
0.3640854955,
0.8898944855,
1.009115696,
-0.3742409945,
0.8373481035,
0.1982238144,
0.3139478266,
1.6739836931,
-0.6529084444,
0.6401214004,
0.458083123,
-0.3808386028,
0.3987585604,
0.8475190401,
-0.0298050083,
0.7560902834,
0.5170068145,
-0.3917357326,
-0.1663806736,
0.2086726129,
-0.6262199283,
0.067966491,
0.4523394704,
-0.3458976746,
-0.2762745321,
-0.007639966,
0.3287127316,
-0.3011726737,
-0.2513481677,
0.9376145005,
0.0095991064,
-0.7366930842,
0.4749913216,
-0.1669145375,
0.3360596299,
-0.5619375706,
-0.1531823725,
-0.1444784552,
0.4487741292,
-0.2063802183,
-0.4891387522,
0.3233321905,
-0.2982175946,
-0.4666191638,
-0.2504924834,
0.1645547897,
-0.5113086104,
-0.4041779339,
0.2280668318,
0.1297130287,
-0.0901722834,
0.1320444345,
-0.6322402954,
0.1880218238,
0.0911881402,
-0.0449861027,
0.2528176308,
0.5552400947,
-0.1649405062,
0.6139135361,
0.2114918679,
-0.3237753808,
0.2840252221,
0.0240704138,
0.4945774078,
-0.8313926458,
-0.1837590188,
-0.8335697651,
0.5580090284,
0.1169439256,
-0.3158714473,
0.6443802714,
0.667768836,
1.1307380199,
-0.1820329875,
0.9775940776,
0.0094819376,
0.4847021997,
-0.8684127331,
-0.0002270011,
-0.4931783378,
0.7625269294,
-0.0687094554,
-0.8105230927,
-0.5582202673,
0.417956084,
-0.1809616089,
-0.3579575717,
0.6533553004,
0.6302087903,
0.4743202627,
0.1184821576,
-0.0029694282,
0.158249706,
0.1347911358,
0.5962778926,
1.0926003456,
-0.5176748633,
0.0977042466,
-0.1026222035,
-0.147374481,
0.0203722995,
-0.8444752693,
-0.3803221881,
-0.5862352252,
-0.9160658717,
-0.4255206287,
0.2439328581,
0.9239539504,
0.495046854,
-0.7448784113,
0.0374774896,
-0.3374215662,
0.2656255066,
-0.2290181667,
-0.229485333,
0.1322758347,
-0.60448879,
-0.7401652336,
0.2004722655,
0.6368279457,
0.3177651465,
0.1558193713,
0.1829571277,
-0.3454264402,
-0.087240085,
0.5723769069,
0.3954439461,
-0.6789252758,
-0.1818603873,
-0.3329060674,
0.1583366394,
0.3882554471,
0.8015224338,
-0.7108062506,
0.604534328,
0.3286869228,
0.525729537,
0.8582928777,
-0.1665914506,
0.2757489979,
-0.4991510808,
0.1446017027,
0.1463814974,
0.1565694213,
0.4269197881,
-0.403131634,
0.7828656435,
0.4054868817,
-0.3272077143,
-0.6545338631,
0.4532482624,
-0.756177485,
-0.336420387,
1.0882495642,
-0.0683015734,
0.0402763709,
-0.1522085369,
0.1274425834,
0.4128699005,
-0.2342677414,
0.827636838,
0.4972095191,
-0.5377880335,
0.0717564374,
-0.2756697834,
0.3733818531,
0.2646356225,
-0.656925261,
-0.1871758401,
0.5272378325,
0.4546913207,
0.041569192,
0.6266755462,
-0.4534990489,
-0.041216705,
0.0265656281,
0.1682439446,
0.0621834882,
-0.4980823994,
-0.1781202406,
-0.0592244379,
0.0284313671,
-0.2392813861
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10436v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10436v1
|
I Am Not Them: Fluid Identities and Persistent Out-group Bias in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-16T03:54:48 | 2024-02-16T03:54:48 |
Wenchao Dong, Assem Zhunis, Hyojin Chin, Jiyoung Han, Meeyoung Cha
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We explored cultural biases-individualism vs. collectivism-in ChatGPT across
three Western languages (i.e., English, German, and French) and three Eastern
languages (i.e., Chinese, Japanese, and Korean). When ChatGPT adopted an
individualistic persona in Western languages, its collectivism scores (i.e.,
out-group values) exhibited a more negative trend, surpassing their positive
orientation towards individualism (i.e., in-group values). Conversely, when a
collectivistic persona was assigned to ChatGPT in Eastern languages, a similar
pattern emerged with more negative responses toward individualism (i.e.,
out-group values) as compared to collectivism (i.e., in-group values). The
results indicate that when imbued with a particular social identity, ChatGPT
discerns in-group and out-group, embracing in-group values while eschewing
out-group values. Notably, the negativity towards the out-group, from which
prejudices and discrimination arise, exceeded the positivity towards the
in-group. The experiment was replicated in the political domain, and the
results remained consistent. Furthermore, this replication unveiled an
intrinsic Democratic bias in Large Language Models (LLMs), aligning with
earlier findings and providing integral insights into mitigating such bias
through prompt engineering. Extensive robustness checks were performed using
varying hyperparameter and persona setup methods, with or without social
identity labels, across other popular language models.
|
[
-0.4908576906,
-0.7566307187,
0.2756178379,
0.0948662981,
-0.0075102374,
0.7346878052,
-0.4126660228,
-0.2777359486,
0.4491383433,
0.4826403856,
-0.5724003911,
-0.0803276673,
-0.5902814865,
0.227998957,
-0.3543553948,
0.9928090572,
0.0113567542,
0.1602717042,
0.1563820094,
-0.3599471152,
-0.1110650375,
-0.7136633396,
-0.0635554343,
-0.5130192041,
0.1597889662,
0.4515920579,
0.7946670651,
0.0560003631,
0.2738948464,
0.2707542181,
0.0194052923,
-0.1762949824,
-0.622295022,
0.1283072233,
-0.3333068788,
-0.2652803659,
0.2543212175,
0.3285825849,
0.6582838893,
0.7258970141,
0.1564291865,
0.4222158492,
0.1312443465,
0.8602664471,
-0.5632728338,
0.2778513432,
-0.7954603434,
0.0406565554,
-0.4615327418,
0.0458824299,
-0.5667061806,
-0.485907793,
0.2096560299,
-0.306405127,
0.3115391135,
0.0265103579,
1.0491038561,
-0.0951739103,
-0.6436830163,
-0.3713770509,
-0.7344567776,
0.7817605734,
-0.5065118074,
0.215103507,
0.4092614651,
0.3242949843,
-0.2403218001,
-0.3534865975,
-0.6365366578,
0.0120097026,
0.0451905355,
0.3860403895,
-0.3895270526,
-0.1449015886,
0.1247185245,
0.2067593932,
-0.4952562749,
0.2893268466,
-0.5939742923,
-0.1929653585,
0.6252734661,
-0.0746784583,
0.4160514772,
0.1310217381,
-0.4476676583,
0.1170017421,
-0.9606631994,
0.2965459228,
0.8035057187,
0.305036366,
-0.3819782138,
0.7992302775,
-0.1258999705,
0.175391227,
0.2546623945,
-0.0480139144,
0.1069883779,
-0.228873238,
-0.0109209307,
0.0976331159,
0.9802684188,
0.0376692861,
0.7821492553,
-0.3153283298,
0.0304084346,
0.1888977885,
-0.0498857461,
-0.6516923904,
-0.1521460712,
0.0296410304,
-0.7073966265,
-0.226610288,
-0.1545902491,
-0.8286752105,
-0.6075723767,
-0.1178793311,
0.3672175109,
-0.2318081707,
-0.4418787658,
-0.3147683144,
-0.2230334878,
0.4559418559,
0.2994032502,
-1.2135554552,
0.3401110172,
0.4577745497,
0.844145,
-0.15301615,
-0.2500578165,
-0.3090908527,
-0.096018061,
-0.5423320532,
0.7957137227,
-1.0045853853,
-0.8071151376,
0.0815696716,
0.074167572,
-0.136031732,
-0.6584345698,
0.1904230565,
-0.3465250432,
0.5100286603,
-0.7431726456,
-0.3567121327,
-0.1918407381,
-0.0253721494,
-0.2869067192,
0.7269918919,
0.1395644695,
-0.6386996508,
0.3069418669,
-0.5612779856,
-0.160746038,
0.3492954671,
-0.6322992444,
-0.0995715261,
0.2004653513,
-0.096173428,
0.295653522,
-0.3787351549,
0.0879090503,
-0.6634547114,
-0.3998017013,
0.5405294895,
-0.429256767,
1.0015690327,
0.1673291624,
-0.6518812776,
0.0540730953,
-0.1981141418,
0.1017431468,
0.200331822,
-0.206198737,
-0.3482072055,
0.0416151658,
-0.0003185676,
0.6711045504,
-0.0049200179,
-0.5515714288,
0.1603377312,
-0.1817735434,
0.5181770921,
1.3344373703,
0.0211156681,
0.5753519535,
-0.2238346338,
0.693768084,
0.3195189834,
-0.2045611441,
0.0828128979,
-0.7448060513,
-0.64181602,
-0.2008205652,
-0.0307900086,
0.6868343949,
-0.7581429482,
0.3329933584,
-0.2983997464,
-0.5126951933,
-0.3575200737,
0.145754382,
0.2709981501,
0.3977642953,
0.120906502,
-0.2604488432,
-0.217835471,
-1.3389234543,
-0.6105601192,
-0.7974461317,
0.0626631007,
0.0140152555,
0.7924408317,
-0.239496246,
1.0811296701,
-0.2708866596,
-0.0103199873,
-0.259731859,
0.002270055,
0.0644731522,
0.2569317818,
0.2401900887,
-0.5485051274,
-0.9200085998,
0.2706881762,
-0.5534048676,
-0.3838965595,
-0.1252652109,
-0.0125527568,
0.3071742654,
0.4220229685,
-0.3357612193,
0.3912762702,
0.8880362511,
-0.6540616751,
0.6203721166,
0.0691448599,
0.0250243004,
-1.1820483208,
-0.0830345154,
0.1353190094,
0.1266262382,
-0.5167809725,
-0.2499769479,
0.0573270209,
-0.0197949316,
-0.2341896296,
0.8250614405,
-0.6507669687,
0.2519422472,
0.0000949337,
0.1403156519,
-0.0997669995,
0.3634367287,
-0.0121559529,
0.8360590935,
0.5226321816,
-0.4899428785,
-0.0281610265,
0.1818124652,
-0.3514145613,
0.831543684,
-0.4948222339,
0.1842959523,
-0.5041510463,
0.2398963273,
-1.0901914835,
-0.1614083648,
0.4152088165,
-0.2852971554,
0.1720156223,
-0.4466415644,
-0.3503582478,
-0.1772767305,
-0.0793129429,
0.1716825068,
0.7777263522,
-0.5585648417,
0.3547150493,
0.5597510338,
-0.2368652821,
-0.6383100152,
-0.8867439032,
0.1117643341,
-0.6618897915,
-0.6697530746,
0.0047254539,
-0.3302023709,
-1.0661127567,
-0.1222515851,
-0.0158445965,
-0.3493896425,
-0.126649648,
0.2129181027,
-0.1152530313,
-0.1665596962,
0.1588994265,
0.0699378476,
-0.0598325133,
-0.2457924187,
-0.0243373942,
0.5063616633,
-0.4225841165,
-0.3120424151,
-0.2710584402,
0.6087208986,
0.5979540944,
-0.508523941,
0.9224065542,
0.5171559453,
-0.1220301762,
-0.0346354023,
-0.7336366773,
-0.3427630067,
-0.4847086072,
0.2638333738,
-0.3725415766,
-1.0668076277,
0.9888366461,
0.1463758945,
0.1922212988,
0.2226647437,
0.7405930161,
0.0606317818,
0.7839397788,
0.4158474505,
-0.19256787,
0.4961571395,
0.087170437,
0.5723612905,
-0.6555888653,
0.0614425354,
-0.6562296748,
-0.3470879793,
-1.1701225042,
-0.3343119919,
0.4614300728,
-0.3064653277,
-0.3542718887,
-0.2388927788,
-0.2327114791,
0.4013359547,
0.3551022112,
-0.2883969843,
0.2030878663,
-0.1053579748,
0.43563357,
-0.3651944399,
-0.4776137769,
-0.7832953334,
0.8715382218,
0.3441082239,
1.0550256968,
0.5383329988,
0.7398707271,
0.2831085026,
0.3810436726,
-0.5311563015,
0.4354688525,
-0.0190804955,
-0.9585086107,
-0.0657081008,
-0.3003615737,
-1.0025285482,
0.8336591125,
0.026885977,
-0.9470883012,
0.432746321,
-0.0068455874,
-0.0634660423,
0.4357572496,
-0.9269388318,
0.7503625751,
0.0938016549,
-0.4180686772,
0.0641389415,
-0.647393465,
0.6876130104,
-0.1147269383,
0.3546621799,
-0.4050742984,
-0.1182972714,
0.5229942203,
-0.3990417719,
1.2409499884,
0.0138526997,
-0.1239442676,
0.5049164295,
0.2033048719,
0.5756902695,
0.1044584289,
-0.0447184965,
0.4005981684,
0.1097089425,
-0.7761783004,
-0.1371192485,
0.8420192599,
-1.0616105795,
-0.4804759622,
-0.3866650462,
-0.1350582093,
0.0225829184,
0.3280412555,
0.5871374607,
0.2574050128,
-0.4631616473,
0.1944584996,
0.6765950918,
-0.1895048916,
0.7368064523,
0.5292115808,
-0.0758202523,
-0.2115178704,
0.7073190212,
0.5515881181,
0.6727674603,
0.0478127263,
0.3108992577,
-0.2740805745,
0.10707663,
-0.5482419729,
0.1692851037,
-0.7511987686,
0.3463599384,
-0.768568635,
0.1129584014,
-0.424683243,
-0.2484152615,
-0.5339204073,
-0.3037802577,
0.1261438131,
0.2195823044,
-0.1260967106,
0.7270019054,
0.1191786602,
0.5100172758,
-0.5377007723,
0.0069221403,
0.185572803,
0.1258406639,
-0.3678207099,
-0.435359776,
-0.1422331184,
0.0671663359,
-0.3544096351,
-1.1896727085,
0.3130963147,
0.0354073457,
0.6149758101,
0.4529623687,
0.2178982943,
0.4828951359,
-0.4972578585,
0.9697975516,
-0.1868939549,
-1.0817315578,
0.0304660294,
-0.4288777411,
0.4139012992,
0.486464411,
0.09173242,
-0.9120324254,
-0.6369663477,
-0.7376660705,
-0.7585120201,
0.5293123722,
0.1331432313,
0.6059526801,
-0.0845492929,
-0.0025626065,
0.3736975789,
0.2410898656,
-1.1423395872,
-0.4593966007,
-0.1634229273,
0.0902205929,
-0.1346875578,
-0.1188326403,
-0.0382022746,
0.1025111973,
0.8609642982,
-0.4931783676,
0.1314637363,
0.0911348015,
0.1851644069,
-0.3429643214,
0.4371112287,
0.5997104645,
0.8085175157,
0.3312425613,
0.0894666016,
0.0004070672,
-0.4567889273,
0.3126674294,
-0.3756285906,
-0.2436048239,
0.1467098147,
0.3172945678,
0.6483893394,
-0.3233231008,
-0.4912602901,
0.5198445916,
-0.2054170072,
0.0899104699,
-0.6849981546,
-0.2683486938,
-0.0447045453,
0.1444101185,
0.165963605,
0.1237750277,
-0.1887119859,
-0.6147449017,
-0.3437749147,
0.7181912661,
-0.6735287309,
-0.7873857617,
0.520976603,
0.0642288253,
0.055190146,
0.6744773984,
-0.2278871387,
-0.3195264339,
0.3178334534,
0.5545622706,
1.1621527672,
-0.4710992277,
0.4858986139,
0.2424146682,
0.7409468889,
0.130712986,
0.0530443713,
0.0984584689,
-0.9887984991,
-0.2450892925,
-0.2130108327,
-0.3851844966,
0.0464621261,
-0.4715989232,
0.2439180762,
-0.4000815451,
-0.0869262218,
-0.3258269131,
-0.0627847239,
-0.4558953047,
-0.1510181725,
-0.0325402692,
0.4803399742,
-1.2398656607,
0.7704387903,
0.4907264113,
-0.3593619764,
-0.4419780672,
0.4532117546,
0.4814953804,
-0.6358655095,
0.4844093323,
0.0646862388,
0.187925145,
-0.1373232603,
-0.5341108441,
-0.9426600933,
0.6008056402,
0.4143015742,
-0.2142020166,
0.2586337924,
0.0832944512,
0.484895885,
-0.1715493649,
0.1874343306,
0.182110846,
0.5285596251,
-0.1672496349,
-0.9931072593,
-0.149624899,
-0.2416709214,
-0.1939620525,
0.2689278126,
-1.366125226,
0.9863654375,
-0.056936387,
-0.2519734204,
-0.2140923589,
0.4947723448,
0.0575125031,
-0.035493046,
0.2713787258,
0.0674773753,
0.7651554346,
-0.1516216993,
0.8973395824,
-0.2255702466,
0.0051779016,
0.9498365521,
-0.4380455017,
0.3574991822,
0.7275868654,
-0.040910434,
0.4773974419,
0.6674383283,
0.3600875735,
0.3830992877,
0.1118321419,
-0.6361585855,
-0.2661642134,
-0.0349079631,
-0.5026556849,
0.7910815477,
0.3079533279,
-0.3861070275,
-0.2060735077,
-0.3425692916,
0.4631149471,
0.2674576044,
0.0130011886,
0.5682439804,
0.094397001,
-0.6044749022,
0.3714535236,
0.0275322385,
0.5015363097,
-0.7756931782,
0.3215253651,
-0.2332455367,
0.1813451201,
-0.2026649117,
-0.5890163183,
0.0980468467,
-0.1072222888,
-0.1507818252,
-0.4004812837,
0.2421817929,
-0.3676144183,
-0.4346256852,
0.0038861351,
0.8255060911,
0.1526075751,
-0.0342546478,
-0.5709504485,
0.032047946,
0.2599604428,
-0.2977787256,
0.4067294598,
0.4783986211,
-0.6467009187,
0.8023725152,
0.4545054436,
-0.1687476337,
0.1833209246,
-0.1271028966,
0.6933330297,
-0.5028706193,
-0.4252552986,
-1.2864795923,
0.5332346559,
0.090966098,
-0.5304338336,
0.9552641511,
0.6945428848,
0.9673441052,
-0.1090385616,
1.1238861084,
-0.1489951313,
0.4052379727,
-0.2392305732,
0.8191922903,
-0.1769391,
0.1004368588,
-0.5750770569,
-0.8607514501,
0.0749189556,
0.3883782923,
-0.4774087369,
0.3218793571,
0.500736475,
0.762567997,
0.0673012733,
0.1192553341,
0.4158116579,
0.3617079556,
0.8031096458,
0.1154127046,
1.0502448082,
-0.0502068624,
0.1007809713,
-0.2937377691,
-0.2736465633,
0.1329645962,
-0.547452569,
-1.0030688047,
-0.781439364,
-0.5237491131,
-0.5624895692,
-0.3399986327,
1.0614218712,
0.5544838905,
-0.6777841449,
-0.447031498,
0.3781609833,
0.2957933545,
0.0684735104,
-0.2580160797,
-0.0021495847,
-0.3228507936,
-0.9447494149,
0.1954833418,
0.3480504453,
0.1264628321,
-0.5872907043,
-0.0209974628,
-0.0727275759,
0.2691771388,
0.6043469906,
0.4242540598,
-0.8112021685,
-0.4650703371,
-0.0532095879,
-0.0456964634,
0.0936106667,
0.6281476021,
-0.5855144858,
0.6340193748,
0.5143469572,
0.1383792162,
0.0420663431,
0.1165238768,
0.5772994161,
-0.4720050991,
0.3926669061,
0.1364858001,
0.3635049462,
0.4076032341,
-0.2440161556,
0.4897069633,
0.4278526902,
-0.7494680285,
-0.862570107,
0.4934285283,
-0.397756964,
-0.0212990828,
1.2340658903,
-0.09092246,
0.0142284278,
-0.3877001703,
-0.2648663521,
-0.0546516888,
-0.3374156654,
0.8986580968,
0.862623632,
-0.2690140009,
0.1014208794,
-0.7125092745,
0.3550194502,
0.3809628785,
-0.655223608,
0.1035671085,
0.4401891828,
0.37269333,
0.0937430412,
0.7498052716,
-0.2677351832,
-0.1335159242,
-0.0979951322,
0.0006842776,
0.6851220131,
0.243554607,
-0.2859601378,
0.0099196807,
0.2091720998,
-0.0959635898
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10430v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10430v1
|
Smaller Language Models are capable of selecting Instruction-Tuning Training Data for Larger Language Models
| 2024-02-16T03:39:37 | 2024-02-16T03:39:37 |
Dheeraj Mekala, Alex Nguyen, Jingbo Shang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Instruction-tuning language models has become a crucial step in aligning them
for general use. Typically, this process involves extensive training on large
datasets, incurring high training costs. In this paper, we introduce a novel
training data selection based on the learning percentage of the samples. We
assert that current language models possess the capability to autonomously
select high-quality training data, leading to comparable or improved
performance compared to training on the entire dataset. Our experiments span
different-sized models, revealing that this characteristic holds for models
ranging from 1B (small) to 13B (large) in size. Moreover, we demonstrate an
interesting finding that the data hardness transfers across model sizes, and a
smaller 350M model can effectively curate high-quality training data with hard
samples for a larger 13B model, resulting in an equally or superior
instruction-tuned model compared to training on the complete dataset. Utilizing
open-sourced OPT and Llama-2 models up to 13B in size, two publicly available
instruction-tuning training datasets and evaluated by both automatic metrics &
humans, our paper introduces a novel approach to training data selection,
showcasing a more efficient alternative.
|
[
-0.2843230069,
-0.5312496424,
0.4035120308,
-0.1188803166,
-0.0854863003,
-0.0509774014,
-0.6357467175,
-0.2231160253,
-0.0495173968,
0.3973136246,
-0.5367912054,
-0.3912690282,
-0.4384315014,
-0.0976569206,
-0.3458677232,
0.821066916,
0.2093326002,
0.3188462257,
-0.2365911454,
-0.0440723114,
-0.4548168778,
-0.1935810745,
-0.7730033398,
-0.3016079962,
0.4192788303,
0.7840090394,
0.5196815729,
1.3034610748,
0.5771694779,
0.2273999602,
0.2118783295,
0.2733175159,
-0.5356764793,
-0.1294121593,
0.0007287303,
-0.8312816024,
-0.4847384095,
0.094851017,
0.5990588665,
0.8400011063,
-0.189305827,
0.4763072431,
-0.1208645105,
1.004842639,
-0.6452534795,
0.0969889909,
-0.8781576753,
0.0254211053,
-0.1252569407,
0.1395279467,
-0.6436421871,
-0.3933647573,
-0.2051244229,
-0.5225657821,
0.4318677783,
0.1957328916,
0.5858734846,
0.4561825395,
-0.1990185082,
-0.1779689193,
-0.5077940822,
0.9196782112,
-0.5327659249,
0.4733659923,
0.6537188888,
0.3470717072,
0.317067951,
-0.320472002,
-0.2051440328,
-0.3006403148,
0.1161127687,
-0.2340120673,
0.0655295551,
-0.0582892857,
0.2214451283,
0.4541826546,
-0.6062854528,
0.6065256,
-0.3946308792,
-0.0829711035,
0.6673238277,
0.1148546562,
0.1161062196,
0.2111988962,
0.0263666436,
-0.3931181431,
-1.0088391304,
-0.0697768256,
0.5572668314,
0.66338557,
-0.1663760394,
0.5096080303,
-0.4175347984,
1.0111432076,
0.1240547448,
-0.2658469975,
0.1182968318,
-0.1893167496,
-0.1992773861,
0.0408675261,
0.69157058,
0.0577068403,
0.3652692735,
-0.1165098995,
-0.2846488655,
-0.1720147282,
0.1830459684,
-0.8947588801,
-0.6627595425,
-0.1794870645,
-0.2956204414,
-0.2298843414,
-0.048065193,
-0.64196527,
-0.2200931013,
-0.6039306521,
0.2161415666,
-0.3129501343,
-0.0072271321,
0.1038594097,
0.1927324533,
0.0610157587,
0.1446028501,
-1.3642046452,
0.1399185508,
0.7239949703,
0.7396131754,
-0.2690625191,
-0.0985076427,
-0.6037266254,
-0.1312229782,
-0.7712026834,
0.6210817099,
-0.8575125933,
-0.2026343197,
-0.2497318685,
-0.019765459,
-0.2275521457,
-0.637203455,
0.1871698052,
-0.4935205877,
-0.0014154902,
-0.0783341378,
-0.4826702476,
0.0762538388,
-0.1223157421,
-0.8842662573,
1.042277813,
0.3671888709,
-0.4551455379,
0.5860913992,
-0.1626788676,
-0.4683254957,
-0.1597995013,
-0.1572656333,
-0.6791757345,
0.2741293013,
0.3498700857,
0.3560502827,
-0.4543082416,
-0.1714217365,
-0.3804553151,
-0.4731325209,
0.0819655061,
-0.4908940494,
0.5569329858,
0.2059245706,
-0.1577956527,
-0.121346727,
-0.8154281378,
0.2673538327,
0.0085785771,
-0.6575602889,
-0.3253896534,
-0.1361711323,
-0.5053517222,
0.0139885321,
0.4318601787,
-0.4773952067,
0.4021112323,
-0.441773504,
0.2645744085,
0.7573207021,
-0.2763204575,
0.7919251919,
-0.3312737942,
0.6128177047,
-0.3172856271,
0.2112267315,
0.1346779019,
-0.1849368662,
-1.0910117626,
-0.3397084773,
0.7369341254,
0.4250253737,
-0.625462532,
0.5051612854,
-0.5823816061,
-0.5454812646,
-1.0864169598,
0.637932837,
0.4244651496,
0.3241229355,
0.2776162326,
-0.1163799241,
-0.3340979517,
-0.9166257381,
0.1516489834,
-0.0890424177,
-0.1385252476,
0.4673846066,
0.1763355583,
0.2961386144,
0.8708671927,
-0.5480058193,
-0.1792034954,
-0.3538301289,
-0.0882289186,
0.1810520142,
0.4682120383,
0.5544044375,
-0.4586767852,
-0.7417601347,
0.2684900761,
-0.3031670153,
0.0296670273,
0.0781834647,
-0.2883591354,
0.1597029269,
0.5623788834,
-0.2673795819,
0.101555489,
0.6141190529,
0.033562649,
0.1693540215,
-0.3328927457,
-0.0199278295,
-0.8272363544,
-0.1005922332,
-0.0070075016,
-0.2492543906,
-0.1789129823,
-0.1362610906,
0.4969180524,
0.1104974598,
-0.3005434573,
0.3831956387,
-0.5298255086,
0.038581267,
-0.2799283862,
-0.2714207172,
-0.1755886972,
0.5638104677,
0.0740924999,
1.0330713987,
0.552749157,
-0.5209080577,
0.360270828,
0.2569729686,
-0.8292021751,
0.305649519,
-0.4462149143,
0.4805748463,
0.0911544263,
-0.0464213677,
-0.5811518431,
-0.3549037278,
-0.2358743548,
-0.290487498,
0.4262600839,
-0.6184829473,
-0.4394202232,
-0.2213945538,
-0.2240224779,
0.206891343,
0.6909072995,
-0.6545695662,
0.1301535517,
0.3842336833,
-0.3348450661,
-0.5084347129,
-0.543477118,
-0.2751069367,
-0.2786351144,
-0.2545404732,
0.0515398048,
-0.0803665742,
-0.0131874112,
-0.1939597279,
-0.1082687899,
-0.1217229515,
0.1189164966,
0.0766132325,
0.440554589,
-0.5539150834,
0.2486018687,
0.3024519384,
-0.0749286264,
-0.222614333,
-0.3108833432,
0.442363292,
0.1015290469,
-0.4201017916,
-0.2584205866,
0.0112804677,
0.1740790904,
-0.3596045971,
0.869807601,
0.333960712,
-0.0256158486,
-0.7637458444,
-0.4332948625,
-0.4021096826,
-0.5101453662,
0.6018658876,
-0.2051890939,
-0.7348599434,
-0.1640806198,
0.1637955904,
0.0476131663,
0.0969957635,
0.5100291967,
0.0662066266,
1.3576306105,
0.8491796255,
-0.5035326481,
0.7329738736,
-0.2074302882,
0.0719656795,
-0.625036478,
-0.016406998,
-0.7958935499,
-0.3322454095,
-0.5114055276,
-0.3650054932,
0.3137845397,
-0.1064653248,
-0.3972479701,
0.2681856453,
-0.5410505533,
0.8833765984,
0.6388597488,
0.2158473432,
0.1807032526,
0.3411542177,
0.2440429479,
0.0187566075,
-0.685043335,
-0.4321470559,
1.4349082708,
0.1790271997,
0.9677294493,
0.0410090983,
0.4070712328,
0.1509861946,
0.2902580798,
-0.819011569,
0.4474383593,
-0.7326976061,
-0.5870556235,
-0.4620274007,
-0.7268535495,
-0.9809979796,
0.0300379656,
-0.1053475365,
-0.5832172632,
0.0502127931,
0.2666933537,
-0.3648892939,
0.2727994323,
-0.9396813512,
0.652362287,
-0.2948838174,
-0.0498734489,
-0.25271523,
-0.3922680318,
0.1418689638,
-0.2818933725,
0.1213397011,
-0.3702945709,
-0.0231985766,
0.7102643847,
-0.2243715227,
0.7072131634,
-0.1903999597,
-0.1467197835,
0.0884013772,
0.2300257087,
0.3723494709,
-0.0981418118,
-0.2665692568,
-0.0400503576,
-0.2603791952,
-0.423048377,
-0.6270492673,
0.6556767225,
-0.8659015298,
-0.4325901866,
0.1801715642,
-0.5125954151,
-0.5502363443,
-0.0312902033,
0.2694944441,
0.397451371,
0.1684430838,
0.6917285919,
0.7373812199,
-0.0533192717,
0.2418351024,
0.6226438284,
0.1254501343,
-0.1969401985,
1.4314807653,
0.1232581213,
0.5175884366,
0.4972952008,
0.1150799617,
-0.1704036891,
-0.7112621665,
-0.5842325091,
0.2140787095,
-0.489295274,
-0.4345009327,
-0.2086772472,
-0.2467201054,
-0.1975637227,
-0.0296481997,
-0.6661332846,
-0.456148535,
-0.2455078661,
-0.2387633026,
0.4191014767,
0.4712088108,
0.0050316737,
0.5126762986,
-0.4416455925,
0.1685650349,
0.5398588181,
0.4063746929,
-0.0429866016,
-0.8240841031,
-0.5098697543,
0.2830123007,
-0.0122175915,
-0.3347720206,
0.3704438508,
0.614251256,
0.3604409695,
0.2731358111,
-0.0559004322,
0.4047469795,
-0.5264188647,
0.4301765859,
-0.0113852853,
-0.5828187466,
0.6684804559,
-0.1523487121,
0.0725013316,
0.9222616553,
0.3667319417,
-0.112738423,
-0.1206348464,
-0.3047611713,
-0.7259069085,
1.024273634,
-0.1774824262,
0.2668026984,
0.25649786,
0.2915784121,
0.3743541539,
0.1540007591,
-0.4862029552,
-0.1130415425,
0.146603331,
-0.6553308964,
-0.1333648711,
0.1171608865,
-0.1211951301,
-0.36758551,
0.8416386843,
-0.4123847187,
0.0841374248,
-0.5633257627,
-0.2470133305,
-0.1190975234,
0.1717952341,
-0.0493967161,
0.6199207306,
-0.1254255474,
-0.048811987,
0.185353741,
-0.5994663239,
0.2780230641,
-0.05911934,
-0.301852107,
-0.3216303587,
0.2497116029,
1.0970184803,
0.2176419199,
-0.6471446753,
0.56017977,
-0.0735718608,
-0.0853011161,
0.046910245,
0.8187078238,
-0.101279147,
0.0652608052,
0.120661214,
-0.2462314963,
-0.2610419691,
-0.3138895333,
0.0274801869,
0.3696426153,
-0.4574899077,
-0.2374894917,
0.4374744594,
0.057539966,
-0.3130634129,
1.0181233883,
-0.1450964361,
0.0541206673,
0.7711951137,
0.3680829108,
0.3583546579,
-0.1408497244,
0.4453785717,
0.4406361282,
0.2487513274,
-0.3258456886,
0.0164648946,
-0.0457209684,
-0.7098774314,
-0.6293990016,
-0.8574483991,
-0.3734120727,
0.3075165451,
-0.9975114465,
0.3156760335,
-0.4192323089,
-0.0095201964,
-0.0458220504,
0.1750544459,
-0.7323611379,
0.3489855528,
0.3065304756,
0.9043357968,
-0.8968027234,
1.2139925957,
0.5017847419,
-0.1215593442,
-0.9966183305,
-0.1231083572,
-0.1835860312,
-1.0415364504,
0.4168632627,
0.0136845391,
0.1283615679,
0.1905356944,
-0.7502983809,
-0.9067322016,
0.8768006563,
0.8826951981,
-0.7599936724,
-0.0774111003,
0.1218732223,
0.4638835788,
-0.4050904214,
0.0342030376,
1.0600389242,
0.0992964506,
0.0317936912,
-0.7931838036,
-0.2251566499,
-0.1205144227,
-0.1004606262,
0.2384006381,
-0.7966523767,
0.8332151175,
-0.1618407071,
0.0673928186,
0.1563930809,
0.6729550958,
0.2671909034,
-0.0673851892,
0.5546220541,
0.4156804085,
0.7938400507,
-0.1091850698,
0.9426184297,
-0.2692344487,
0.2822817862,
1.1567971706,
-0.0647706911,
1.0142111778,
0.108532846,
-0.4281719029,
0.3974973559,
0.6907600164,
-0.116329059,
0.6847118735,
0.0211484451,
-0.049473539,
-0.5775324702,
0.0562013201,
-0.2178736627,
0.626321137,
0.3023792207,
-0.1584882587,
0.1177793592,
-0.1617085338,
-0.0804656744,
-0.0283760633,
-0.3410868347,
0.8873922825,
-0.0078063235,
-0.7244216204,
0.6632763147,
0.0487123281,
0.5277056694,
-0.6808636189,
0.1187904999,
-0.4191475511,
0.0680412203,
0.0181336515,
-0.4830404818,
-0.1379119009,
0.1949584931,
-0.1083848104,
-0.1590974778,
0.3150798678,
-0.542273283,
-0.6282184124,
-0.1303753108,
0.3655147254,
0.0879315361,
-0.0204392076,
-0.4856437445,
-0.0926681682,
0.1919433922,
-0.2404322773,
0.6670835018,
0.3626308143,
0.0062514762,
0.6967235804,
0.593762815,
0.5651051402,
0.1099176556,
0.0240495838,
0.6282026172,
-0.3887604177,
-0.5783460736,
-0.5848551989,
0.230664596,
-0.2093367577,
-0.3445885181,
0.4356553555,
0.6218479276,
1.0025166273,
-0.0655336231,
0.8254150748,
0.0131097063,
0.7028467059,
-0.7490996718,
0.5880978107,
-0.4729648829,
0.2064122856,
0.3146980405,
-0.8670266867,
0.1974697709,
0.7702032328,
-0.588185966,
0.1132800356,
0.3724900484,
0.9584064484,
-0.3163278699,
0.0000149446,
0.2408752143,
-0.0205528457,
0.0857933611,
0.6906984448,
0.5626635551,
-0.0274693072,
0.5404663086,
-0.4889245033,
-0.2381704152,
-0.2698955238,
-0.5609737635,
-0.976002574,
-0.5195478797,
-0.2477447391,
0.1129906103,
-0.1005108878,
0.9156298041,
1.1108540297,
-0.8549574018,
-0.1331807971,
0.1420559734,
0.0309013147,
-0.1743603051,
-0.1308567673,
0.4976496994,
-0.3778580129,
-0.8605188131,
0.6415764093,
-0.0451126546,
0.0724991858,
-0.1579090804,
0.0066972603,
0.2033237517,
0.0858640969,
0.2341305614,
0.3004473448,
-0.2009635419,
-0.2494808733,
-0.1157315522,
-0.3007709086,
0.163663581,
0.7952010632,
-0.6223059893,
0.2344546467,
0.1312892586,
0.9430071712,
0.5783628225,
-0.071420081,
0.4920699894,
-1.1883307695,
0.3127559423,
0.0968585685,
0.125864014,
0.5387866497,
-0.3518413603,
0.6216823459,
-0.1604588628,
-0.4496622086,
-0.9345021248,
0.1014941409,
-0.5776903629,
-0.2598893642,
1.168763876,
0.0207075644,
-0.2318432629,
0.3492615819,
-0.0845757872,
0.0790972188,
-0.3067017794,
0.9127066135,
0.5786126852,
-0.0044391379,
-0.0377104655,
-0.7777907252,
0.5616331697,
0.4461161792,
-0.8271327615,
0.175393194,
0.4483393133,
0.3307497203,
-0.3365548253,
0.2388730794,
0.1917173862,
0.1934887916,
-0.011307084,
-0.2149505019,
-0.1653517783,
-0.5955764055,
-0.2350451648,
0.0860825181,
0.2728909254,
-0.2355748862
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10427v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10427v1
|
Evaluating and Improving Continual Learning in Spoken Language Understanding
| 2024-02-16T03:30:27 | 2024-02-16T03:30:27 |
Muqiao Yang, Xiang Li, Umberto Cappellazzo, Shinji Watanabe, Bhiksha Raj
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Continual learning has emerged as an increasingly important challenge across
various tasks, including Spoken Language Understanding (SLU). In SLU, its
objective is to effectively handle the emergence of new concepts and evolving
environments. The evaluation of continual learning algorithms typically
involves assessing the model's stability, plasticity, and generalizability as
fundamental aspects of standards. However, existing continual learning metrics
primarily focus on only one or two of the properties. They neglect the overall
performance across all tasks, and do not adequately disentangle the plasticity
versus stability/generalizability trade-offs within the model. In this work, we
propose an evaluation methodology that provides a unified evaluation on
stability, plasticity, and generalizability in continual learning. By employing
the proposed metric, we demonstrate how introducing various knowledge
distillations can improve different aspects of these three properties of the
SLU model. We further show that our proposed metric is more sensitive in
capturing the impact of task ordering in continual learning, making it better
suited for practical use-case scenarios.
|
[
-0.0545577444,
-0.7832137346,
0.5997250676,
0.2839290798,
-0.330514133,
0.2401842177,
-0.5894715786,
-0.3283669353,
-0.1465302855,
0.1614067107,
-0.3258317709,
-0.3417151272,
-0.6496303678,
-0.1362721771,
-0.1681180745,
1.0785990953,
0.1860852838,
0.0925995857,
-0.4460784793,
-0.4439805448,
-0.9283673763,
-0.321218431,
-0.8270737529,
-0.7730339766,
0.501855731,
0.3219340742,
0.5192766786,
0.2497960478,
0.2164029032,
0.388065666,
-0.3107830882,
-0.0808063895,
-0.5883299112,
0.1905429363,
-0.2062776834,
-0.3524495363,
-0.2603770196,
0.0497093089,
0.877610445,
1.1210831404,
-0.4924868047,
0.209571749,
0.6622191668,
0.6759813428,
-0.4097846746,
0.2675846219,
-0.8128496408,
-0.1896003038,
0.122882098,
0.0458348989,
-0.3215205073,
-0.3223294318,
0.5936409235,
-0.4919400513,
0.0174448937,
-0.3792393208,
0.8975687623,
0.4072854221,
0.1008700728,
-0.3993481398,
-0.9678165913,
0.8311966658,
-0.6303986907,
0.5652270317,
0.1705380082,
0.3273929954,
0.1317455471,
-0.7092568278,
-0.4915373921,
-0.599326551,
0.11407502,
0.3645835519,
-0.1992136091,
0.127339676,
-0.2630195916,
0.3551507294,
-0.5929455161,
0.157682389,
-0.3427675068,
-0.1864213496,
0.3720646799,
-0.0266147833,
0.3784956336,
0.2944531739,
-0.262098521,
0.1598271728,
-0.2880408764,
0.0046180794,
0.0025935799,
0.1414019912,
-0.0991035402,
-0.0111282961,
0.0624255016,
0.6152039766,
0.0776079968,
-0.4172954559,
0.3917515874,
-0.3029391468,
-0.1353081316,
-0.2628256083,
0.3389729261,
0.2002492696,
0.2101420611,
-0.7717459798,
-0.2121282369,
0.0395719446,
0.5584515333,
-0.1793180108,
-0.0845505074,
0.2386856824,
-0.3368067741,
-0.0846742243,
0.1687694937,
-0.3898753226,
0.0148819899,
-0.7543783784,
0.3504700363,
-0.5202490091,
-0.5249137282,
0.11365024,
-0.2295711786,
0.0464887992,
0.2802329361,
-0.9420161247,
0.5021598935,
0.9112639427,
1.0225987434,
-0.4989245534,
-0.5119066238,
-0.4757295549,
0.1481384337,
-0.1555618197,
0.5441949964,
-0.521037221,
-0.3425143361,
-0.1487063915,
-0.1862946004,
-0.3771630824,
-0.7754555345,
0.2704826593,
-0.2055826485,
0.1245372221,
0.0609156229,
-0.4606127143,
-0.3506307602,
0.1987976432,
-0.3537578881,
0.9594413638,
0.1670375913,
-0.303350091,
0.7106758952,
-0.6038287878,
-0.1350663304,
0.4110525548,
-0.0359262638,
-0.4429273903,
0.3735115528,
-0.312572211,
0.3472284377,
0.1961577535,
0.6382032037,
-0.1862828881,
-0.3803172112,
0.1736578643,
-0.5196807981,
0.4154428542,
0.0710276067,
-0.472769767,
0.0718935058,
-0.6877908707,
-0.0291760769,
-0.0622597449,
-0.5156684518,
-0.4205261469,
0.2327595949,
-0.1893149018,
-0.1543003619,
0.2741179168,
-0.4212622046,
0.0844371393,
-0.5695341825,
0.4906018972,
0.7805508375,
0.1668569744,
0.4560240209,
-0.2906195819,
0.3193854392,
0.0459014066,
0.352385968,
0.3905299902,
-0.2854542434,
-0.9811694622,
0.1254108995,
0.1171175912,
0.5570701361,
-0.6142151356,
0.2208332717,
-0.4591003656,
-0.499756813,
-0.2396775782,
0.6586791277,
0.7242449522,
0.309376508,
0.3685556948,
-0.6701593995,
-0.2059246302,
-0.3069805503,
-0.0069717001,
-0.3931850195,
-0.0755098984,
0.263804704,
0.3914158344,
-0.4506442249,
0.8172911406,
-0.1909982711,
-0.013647127,
-0.4438223243,
0.4346247315,
0.3048300147,
0.4792155921,
0.5729789734,
-0.5444602966,
-0.3126971126,
0.3622579575,
-0.7316566706,
0.0693014786,
-0.3594580591,
0.1160186306,
0.168440491,
0.1610984653,
-0.3461363018,
0.1719134897,
0.5059040189,
-0.1087907329,
0.8971149325,
-0.3823545873,
-0.0649746507,
-0.4882537425,
0.0313996002,
0.0640761033,
-0.1678721607,
-0.9682877064,
0.032322865,
-0.1557864845,
0.0010915485,
-0.4033897221,
0.3844636977,
-0.3765794337,
0.0507826395,
-0.0837365314,
0.5493611693,
-0.131824702,
0.3835244179,
-0.0004398165,
0.6535893083,
0.48501724,
-1.0100533962,
0.279581368,
-0.1850402951,
-0.3090436757,
0.6157041788,
-0.8450763226,
0.4964280725,
-0.189293161,
-0.1046310887,
-0.7791830301,
0.1890784949,
0.1536722034,
-0.5925864577,
0.6228139997,
-0.2019573748,
-0.0742488876,
-0.3361356854,
0.224854514,
0.0459919013,
0.3415763378,
-0.3473949432,
0.5966009498,
0.4169177711,
-0.267247349,
-0.5962150693,
-0.3776627481,
0.0372543,
-0.3815067708,
-0.4075304866,
0.2668381333,
-0.3427829742,
-0.5801430345,
-0.1464230269,
-0.5336708426,
-0.2280537486,
0.2821678817,
0.2085123062,
0.2365373075,
-0.0830129385,
0.4161891043,
-0.0528551675,
-0.3456909657,
0.0270108134,
-0.6289197803,
0.5700420737,
-0.4333791733,
-0.025246812,
-0.5714359879,
-0.0562531129,
0.5896237493,
-0.0059450534,
0.6664000154,
0.5363496542,
-0.1088924184,
-0.1758089364,
-0.8157598972,
0.1211138219,
-0.5068627,
0.3130820692,
-0.3132941425,
-0.8864722848,
0.3745716512,
-0.1004756391,
0.3607827425,
0.3343279958,
0.4472742975,
-0.499536097,
0.5315976143,
0.7786594033,
-0.4231517017,
0.3472738266,
-0.2396257371,
-0.0973813161,
-0.5469509363,
-0.4153203368,
-0.4964464605,
-0.0543349683,
-0.0552085415,
-0.1457998306,
0.2675482929,
0.2446830571,
0.0490566157,
0.3352710009,
-0.5114478469,
0.3317232132,
0.0997863039,
0.1761650741,
0.2264456153,
-0.0955849215,
-0.1917160451,
0.059956409,
-0.5695391893,
-0.5268782377,
0.7353637218,
0.5311558843,
0.4715130925,
0.2162224799,
0.7758756876,
0.41488868,
0.2064077407,
-0.7260359526,
0.4251360595,
-0.2115342617,
0.0016298478,
-0.5586075187,
-0.6704351306,
-1.1538670063,
0.2557043731,
0.171152249,
-0.9308773279,
-0.0339969285,
0.3574413359,
-0.1514220089,
0.0408965871,
-0.8524233699,
0.7374039888,
-0.4987381399,
-0.0967817679,
-0.6547663808,
-0.3368896842,
0.0363590606,
0.0203563422,
0.2036067247,
-0.0988516137,
-0.0024697031,
0.7708662152,
-0.2177122533,
0.9518398046,
-0.4596673548,
-0.0203417204,
0.2205486745,
-0.2155843675,
-0.010635199,
0.1113739163,
0.0274328478,
0.292340368,
0.1278997511,
-0.4601110518,
-0.8343880177,
0.510637641,
-0.7238988876,
-0.5358344913,
-0.2646076381,
-0.3911483884,
-0.3258122206,
0.0107306205,
-0.0445253439,
0.4643151462,
-0.4501351416,
0.0392267257,
0.8331525922,
-0.1577876508,
0.3845055103,
0.6506382227,
-0.0177908242,
-0.1775751412,
1.2225028276,
0.2372095436,
0.6308990717,
0.1740647554,
0.4231325984,
-0.3313313127,
-0.9097855091,
-0.1675433815,
0.3080132008,
-0.6376395226,
0.1435316205,
-0.2449636608,
-0.196961537,
-0.3355065882,
-0.0317087173,
-0.1237652451,
-0.1552126408,
-0.4873993397,
-0.1517287046,
0.1403341442,
0.9741942286,
-0.2177323848,
0.2345825136,
-0.7023314238,
0.1322293729,
0.5621708632,
0.4477086067,
0.1495594382,
-0.7952356339,
-0.3033277392,
0.08011318,
-0.3628224432,
-0.7003151774,
0.1359256506,
0.8051764965,
1.0854238272,
0.5946674347,
-0.3425302505,
0.8396184444,
-0.45661062,
0.819950819,
0.4415060878,
-1.2031379938,
0.8071898222,
-0.117334567,
0.49992764,
0.8535237908,
0.3880895078,
-0.7525847554,
-0.6294150949,
-0.5795984268,
-0.7151867151,
0.1864422113,
0.1021104679,
0.3660127223,
0.0344050154,
0.5977044702,
0.255051285,
0.0009357508,
-0.7643947005,
-0.2962367535,
-0.2167752236,
0.0644540265,
-0.1170906574,
-0.3300996125,
0.0693239942,
-0.499701947,
0.7646235228,
0.0930976942,
0.0114528863,
-0.2247500122,
-0.5870283842,
0.4317604899,
0.4533695877,
0.4455026388,
1.1246958971,
-0.2309422493,
-0.153666541,
0.4518281519,
-0.8900346756,
0.0730642751,
-0.2491874844,
-0.1373935491,
0.1863926351,
0.1962943673,
0.7243697643,
0.4988778532,
-0.5642006993,
0.0821720064,
-0.0334985368,
-0.1743114889,
-0.3835072815,
0.3386821449,
-0.0659234598,
-0.0317499489,
0.3209586143,
-0.0920040905,
-0.0605862439,
-0.7302153111,
0.48838377,
0.1528220177,
-0.7412053943,
-0.2520977855,
0.1027393118,
0.2890363932,
-0.23489438,
0.8248243928,
-0.3335643709,
-0.4893011153,
0.3767122328,
0.4954612255,
0.7915014625,
-0.4096755981,
0.4030313492,
0.466709435,
0.3633425534,
0.0426697619,
0.050996799,
-0.4629089236,
-0.7760160565,
-0.3364888132,
-0.7421070337,
-0.5476945043,
0.1449924707,
-0.9600841999,
-0.2147178948,
-0.4223253131,
-0.3081540763,
-0.0021049178,
0.0512960181,
-0.6032489538,
0.2777656913,
-0.0032875042,
0.4768331647,
-0.801035583,
0.9066894054,
0.5089923143,
-0.5242258906,
-0.5350760221,
-0.0662755743,
0.1509018987,
-0.6953171492,
0.491427809,
0.2237817347,
-0.3302577436,
-0.1892843395,
-0.3910014927,
-0.7476212978,
1.1125061512,
0.2226157486,
-0.8313375115,
0.1712394506,
-0.0441264547,
0.5613059402,
-0.1645662785,
0.1747921407,
1.1528302431,
0.4124239981,
0.0163165443,
-1.0618489981,
-0.4957467318,
-0.358382225,
0.0741044357,
-0.0487790219,
-0.3004299402,
0.0941230133,
-0.0901080668,
-0.7097635865,
0.0166770127,
0.8124595284,
0.0871067494,
0.538449645,
0.7865129709,
0.7177259326,
1.0472289324,
-0.5139862895,
0.5367277265,
0.0375759713,
0.5254114866,
1.3263208866,
-0.0006935801,
0.827660203,
0.3383268416,
-0.4182790816,
0.5960847735,
0.3742472827,
-0.0964569077,
0.3668419719,
0.3841461539,
-0.3367518187,
-0.0793400258,
0.0092906207,
-0.2445340753,
0.5003490448,
0.7490392923,
0.0944767967,
-0.1109635308,
0.2969837487,
0.0710228831,
0.1922732741,
-0.374322474,
1.0888835192,
0.1165211201,
-0.6367831826,
0.8939114809,
-0.4598479569,
0.7312163711,
-0.7211045027,
0.0898465142,
-0.2300627232,
-0.0484550707,
-0.1265111864,
-0.7529243231,
0.6115801334,
0.1257782727,
-0.2138285339,
-0.2101296782,
0.4333254397,
-0.4590450525,
-0.3073902726,
0.4990514815,
0.1646757275,
0.4577066302,
0.1804752946,
-0.9379243255,
0.2048452348,
-0.0838790238,
0.2993823886,
0.3048838377,
0.100930348,
0.5200784206,
0.9134300351,
0.429756552,
0.1894056499,
-0.0425177477,
0.6288133264,
0.6572210193,
-0.2271551043,
-0.1513288021,
-0.6808053255,
0.6067403555,
-0.1841112673,
-0.4667657912,
0.6987637281,
0.1716398299,
0.8832374215,
0.1303611696,
0.7544722557,
0.0218050517,
0.213811934,
-0.6668149233,
0.8403063416,
-0.5219775438,
0.3050635755,
-0.3629710674,
-0.9118064642,
-0.115464963,
0.6306137443,
-0.2327274233,
-0.1286587715,
0.7064678669,
0.3455724716,
0.219475776,
-0.098013632,
0.500243783,
0.2797191739,
0.0694476217,
0.4498083889,
0.6490250826,
0.0230687242,
0.4584189653,
-0.2577813864,
-0.3753481507,
0.3771398067,
-0.6422711611,
-0.7310373783,
-0.7895730138,
-0.5547312498,
-0.29537341,
0.47606498,
0.3814350367,
0.7200382352,
-0.7610343695,
-0.4336581826,
-0.2239658833,
0.1855934113,
-0.6290924549,
-0.2093001902,
0.1299411505,
-0.9149793386,
-0.6099230647,
0.5725964308,
0.5461961627,
-0.1245248094,
-0.3068088293,
-0.3359004259,
0.0202412661,
-0.1221136749,
0.6683205962,
0.5942038894,
-0.8920366764,
-0.5388949513,
-0.3691368997,
0.3978260756,
0.0214096531,
0.5936539173,
-0.5769455433,
0.7228432298,
0.1368951052,
0.6890586615,
0.5111973286,
-0.1170691252,
0.6119373441,
-0.6762331724,
0.0378439315,
0.2902818918,
0.3322009146,
0.1764857322,
-0.2064545304,
0.4729590118,
0.242377609,
-0.7727535367,
-0.548025012,
0.1909872442,
-1.0948562622,
-0.1596116275,
1.0273705721,
-0.4670182168,
0.1800665706,
-0.6596096754,
0.2483386695,
0.191370517,
-0.1939607114,
0.7985886335,
0.6741461158,
0.0592525713,
-0.2606354356,
-0.5477907062,
0.1649414152,
0.5142099857,
-0.7337570786,
-0.0927705392,
0.3292925954,
0.5787017345,
0.242001906,
0.5356762409,
-0.0280820411,
0.3746849597,
-0.162673533,
-0.2836279571,
0.2807358205,
-0.5721086264,
-0.495203495,
-0.2153431326,
0.151506111,
-0.1392160654
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10426v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10426v1
|
DELL: Generating Reactions and Explanations for LLM-Based Misinformation Detection
| 2024-02-16T03:24:56 | 2024-02-16T03:24:56 |
Herun Wan, Shangbin Feng, Zhaoxuan Tan, Heng Wang, Yulia Tsvetkov, Minnan Luo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models are limited by challenges in factuality and
hallucinations to be directly employed off-the-shelf for judging the veracity
of news articles, where factual accuracy is paramount. In this work, we propose
DELL that identifies three key stages in misinformation detection where LLMs
could be incorporated as part of the pipeline: 1) LLMs could \emph{generate
news reactions} to represent diverse perspectives and simulate user-news
interaction networks; 2) LLMs could \emph{generate explanations} for proxy
tasks (e.g., sentiment, stance) to enrich the contexts of news articles and
produce experts specializing in various aspects of news understanding; 3) LLMs
could \emph{merge task-specific experts} and provide an overall prediction by
incorporating the predictions and confidence scores of varying experts.
Extensive experiments on seven datasets with three LLMs demonstrate that DELL
outperforms state-of-the-art baselines by up to 16.8\% in macro f1-score.
Further analysis reveals that the generated reactions and explanations are
greatly helpful in misinformation detection, while our proposed LLM-guided
expert merging helps produce better-calibrated predictions.
|
[
-0.5309795141,
-0.7666816115,
0.9552254081,
0.1436131597,
-0.241680488,
-0.1293060631,
-0.0436054952,
-0.5132334232,
0.0233329143,
0.2860500515,
-0.7864126563,
-0.7212469578,
-0.5534831882,
0.3799349368,
-0.8065248132,
0.9845879078,
0.1925269067,
0.0915539041,
-0.0300908908,
0.3802837133,
-0.2819757164,
-0.2260698825,
-0.6341041327,
-0.0649052262,
0.6578267813,
0.5859171748,
0.6147627234,
0.3266656995,
0.0214239322,
0.2637884021,
-0.0710687786,
0.4570645392,
-0.3529977798,
0.1280006617,
-0.1585989147,
-0.7591480017,
-0.2129911333,
0.1465655416,
0.4425355196,
0.2659757137,
0.0415398479,
-0.0793347806,
0.1595927775,
0.6636478305,
-0.5076959133,
-0.2130689919,
-1.0264725685,
0.1897038519,
0.033764217,
-0.1777779311,
-0.4506270587,
-0.3425855935,
-0.1671528071,
-0.2604507804,
0.4128516912,
0.1950230151,
0.4363061786,
0.1969276518,
-0.4960711002,
-0.1456963271,
-0.6836843491,
0.5735489726,
-0.7509701848,
0.3774407804,
-0.1155259088,
0.2995574772,
-0.3365801573,
-0.2676239908,
-0.9163349271,
-0.0692109317,
-0.0044888142,
0.2397199124,
-0.300920248,
-0.2120414525,
0.2845113575,
0.107414186,
-0.544295907,
0.3038313389,
-0.4734363556,
-0.4047857225,
0.6361576319,
0.1119984165,
-0.0528123453,
-0.2269408554,
-0.4371211827,
0.2991291583,
-0.8711279631,
-0.4646460712,
0.5132417083,
0.2471904755,
0.0465566628,
0.6236531734,
-0.2085110396,
0.7930194736,
0.3031321168,
-0.3256368935,
-0.0028784745,
-0.2828906178,
-0.320222348,
0.416510433,
0.7177336812,
0.4790897369,
0.143943429,
-0.1545443088,
-0.2837361395,
0.1563887149,
0.3699771762,
-0.5489883423,
0.0221842173,
0.3377130926,
-0.3227299154,
-0.5802919269,
0.1858914346,
-0.9252960682,
-0.7013805509,
-0.4881933928,
0.4890615344,
-0.2033130825,
-0.3821473122,
-0.0864972919,
-0.1751966476,
-0.1437999308,
0.776616931,
-0.3283930719,
0.0341775268,
0.6597385406,
0.7054283023,
-0.5873860717,
-0.1877732426,
-0.7506402135,
0.1348300725,
-0.5209982991,
1.0481990576,
-0.2891414464,
-0.2157604992,
0.269847542,
-0.1443491727,
-0.1242206767,
-0.6288111806,
0.6089834571,
-0.3767539561,
0.4666347504,
-0.1885556728,
-0.724768579,
-0.1929311454,
0.435017854,
-0.5751098394,
1.0092369318,
-0.1459505558,
-1.0203967094,
0.4846044183,
-0.3257610202,
-0.3068614602,
-0.1303099692,
-0.2260819376,
-0.2000095695,
0.4355386794,
0.2913622558,
0.5820011497,
-0.0588337369,
0.1138775647,
-0.1977391094,
-0.4728315473,
0.4609440267,
-0.5272725821,
0.2959709167,
0.3854102194,
-0.4105857313,
0.0542126931,
-0.7310423851,
-0.3949168921,
-0.3620148897,
-0.5610492826,
0.0149425892,
0.1296535879,
-0.3021460474,
0.1695518941,
0.1128794029,
-0.4667563438,
-0.2445324063,
-0.0672722757,
-0.1894806176,
0.6428486705,
0.0572654568,
0.1482804567,
-0.2940080762,
0.2931652069,
0.7357078195,
0.1607841998,
-0.2319606245,
-0.6504374146,
-0.8402036428,
0.0382992029,
-0.1662656516,
0.6197199225,
-0.7233621478,
0.4845437109,
-0.0030267888,
-0.4390900433,
-0.2532958984,
0.1312283576,
0.1303741485,
0.8255888224,
0.3988267183,
0.3334684074,
-0.5637865663,
-1.0090292692,
-0.9567799568,
-0.3132863045,
-0.0829436183,
-0.0378171317,
0.1891796887,
-0.0516311042,
1.0694129467,
-0.2753787935,
-0.18159163,
-0.3350809216,
0.270222187,
0.4992941618,
0.0650206283,
0.19387649,
-0.8501355648,
-0.3695863187,
0.0529563129,
-0.6185621619,
-0.1601902097,
-0.1198119447,
0.3715056777,
0.694932878,
0.6882274747,
-0.7117120028,
0.6683911085,
0.3574302793,
-0.1311062574,
0.9222258329,
0.1579038948,
0.4618396163,
-1.2450677156,
-0.4127733707,
0.3645434976,
-0.3952607512,
-0.7743837833,
-0.487311393,
-0.0804429352,
0.0879992843,
-0.6713166833,
0.1340184957,
-0.2230286747,
-0.1915524006,
-0.4342967868,
0.4822010696,
-0.304761976,
0.1123939604,
0.0261413977,
0.7424832582,
0.3424271643,
-0.9697988033,
0.372919023,
-0.2761230171,
-0.4775921702,
0.6129107475,
-0.3998687863,
-0.2600801587,
-0.187679112,
0.1434363723,
-1.2786355019,
-0.2732453346,
0.4387405813,
-0.6936433911,
-0.0703685656,
-0.1856789142,
-0.923214972,
-0.4618211091,
-0.2345596254,
-0.2260825932,
0.363288641,
-0.5529488325,
0.618388772,
0.040181011,
0.0759621933,
-0.4599016607,
-0.7727436423,
0.1204795912,
-0.4472826421,
-0.6545601487,
0.1995586902,
0.0300406609,
-0.4410242438,
0.1352957785,
-0.4398934543,
0.023068741,
0.0724945813,
0.1593757421,
0.3059026003,
-0.2193298489,
0.4192374349,
0.1504608542,
-0.0673811361,
0.2173818499,
-0.3271299005,
0.0732520148,
0.1531196833,
-0.5137191415,
-0.7202455401,
0.1574171484,
0.7226705551,
0.4215120971,
0.8124400377,
0.904106319,
-0.5774267912,
-0.1794695705,
-1.0278024673,
-0.3961315751,
-0.3938373327,
0.3188308477,
-0.0443092957,
-0.8471984863,
0.2437784672,
-0.2910699546,
-0.0075749233,
0.7192793489,
0.6125079989,
-0.0651704296,
1.1772116423,
0.4405607283,
-0.3407118917,
0.2343360186,
0.2686097622,
0.4462828338,
-0.2816701829,
-0.4421461821,
-0.6369491816,
-0.3652997613,
-0.5709365606,
-0.4348480999,
0.6799982786,
0.0590686835,
0.047990799,
0.0611898899,
-0.3571082056,
0.5419070125,
0.3521082401,
-0.0389213115,
0.5358319283,
0.4272929132,
-0.1074326411,
0.0009274191,
-0.7703565955,
-0.4556781054,
0.85827595,
0.3822523057,
0.955096364,
-0.0218871105,
0.703001976,
0.5490496755,
0.3515138626,
-0.6329970956,
0.5011899471,
-0.0682720095,
-0.5816489458,
-0.0432943217,
-0.3560585678,
-0.3552831113,
0.3209720552,
-0.5619705319,
-0.8626903892,
-0.0655209944,
0.1606305987,
-0.2546385825,
0.4246023893,
-0.6609810591,
0.5030243993,
0.033071842,
-0.3504593074,
-0.6570692062,
-0.2471733987,
0.7436187863,
-0.1874606162,
0.5407252312,
-0.1194770187,
-0.154883787,
0.5429044962,
-0.2057934105,
0.9926156998,
-0.2942929566,
-0.2512013316,
0.3075944781,
0.1212386191,
0.6213619113,
0.248455748,
-0.1884095669,
-0.0716965497,
-0.3580569029,
0.2344566435,
-0.3471753597,
0.8310489655,
-0.514069736,
-0.8550277948,
-0.3933800757,
-0.5642868876,
-0.2323701084,
-0.093833819,
0.4034900665,
-0.0189238247,
-0.010109826,
-0.0788793787,
0.9635653496,
-0.0655044019,
0.3469139934,
0.6940425038,
-0.4038819373,
-0.2116661072,
0.556512773,
-0.0949136838,
-0.1972538382,
0.215264082,
0.0537117869,
-0.343752563,
-0.5910926461,
-0.3030679226,
0.0772053823,
-0.7358084917,
-0.400785774,
-0.5075238943,
-0.3267523348,
-0.1851124167,
0.1515436172,
-0.1540343761,
-0.3838181496,
-0.6539453864,
-0.2571900189,
0.3604444563,
0.988209486,
-0.184412092,
0.4165498614,
-0.9465575218,
0.3038707972,
0.2707772255,
-0.0743795559,
-0.1522157937,
-0.5187590718,
-0.49096784,
0.135552898,
-0.3826123476,
-1.2987359762,
0.2595877349,
-0.172871694,
0.6507848501,
0.7147369385,
-0.2538406551,
0.6541181207,
-0.2686456442,
1.0180698633,
0.3927312493,
-0.8325141072,
0.739207387,
-0.2013888508,
0.0036148194,
0.2307717055,
0.7256101966,
-0.4716598094,
-0.6758890748,
-0.4057238698,
-0.3370909691,
0.8369252086,
0.0491746664,
0.0699028969,
-0.2105934322,
0.4742617905,
0.2988530993,
0.2356155664,
-0.7901340723,
-0.1499545574,
0.1211256981,
-0.0849623829,
0.0587919094,
-0.4749495089,
-0.2364804149,
-0.0746063888,
0.8113130331,
-0.1396844387,
0.2008214891,
0.3699212968,
-0.3516720831,
-0.148056671,
0.1683741212,
0.6123487353,
0.843536675,
0.2492010295,
0.3010754883,
0.2614475787,
-0.0606060661,
-0.1719263494,
-0.090100117,
0.0692024007,
0.4395315647,
0.3598088026,
0.4477873743,
0.0127072046,
-0.409249723,
0.4795727134,
0.011217528,
-0.3265219331,
-0.3855565488,
0.3414519727,
0.2879068255,
0.5006493926,
0.7993372679,
0.1355682462,
0.2377482057,
-0.4640151262,
0.2724162638,
0.402739197,
-0.3717279136,
-0.353499949,
0.5019826889,
0.0672006756,
-0.0156410411,
0.4294004142,
-0.1222404018,
-0.6641178131,
0.5226711631,
0.4873835146,
0.7374434471,
-0.2421887964,
0.3174259365,
0.342381835,
0.4784273803,
-0.0596497133,
0.2531120181,
0.027557265,
-0.8600847125,
-0.3774394095,
-0.4949116707,
-0.1919343919,
0.3489950895,
-0.2330007851,
0.5931338668,
-0.2248954773,
-0.1119190305,
0.068127811,
-0.2739374936,
-0.5640904903,
0.3039579391,
0.514377892,
1.3313088417,
-0.9488916993,
0.4861408472,
0.5348923206,
-0.1627535522,
-0.5118582845,
0.5386847258,
0.4753738046,
-0.6812542081,
0.7448937893,
0.3907090425,
-0.0236519501,
-0.2667028904,
-0.6191464663,
-0.4499588609,
0.9963284135,
0.34365803,
-0.8390343189,
0.2203288078,
0.1280319542,
0.2846704423,
-0.7138632536,
0.2010901421,
0.6235990524,
0.700320363,
0.1461948007,
-0.6323274374,
-0.1060779914,
0.2825379372,
-0.1935245544,
-0.1713241637,
-0.2018419057,
0.8100303411,
-0.2249280959,
-0.0840109065,
-0.1213337407,
0.7437258959,
0.3168567419,
0.5715751648,
0.7459672689,
0.7069813013,
0.6988028884,
-0.2065951377,
0.7955717444,
-0.4050016105,
0.0617095791,
0.8271975517,
-0.0065389844,
0.7379627824,
0.4848303497,
-0.1777076125,
0.8460206985,
0.983296454,
0.037536189,
0.2415981591,
0.2006558776,
-0.7072725892,
-0.4619875848,
-0.1163271964,
-0.3286804855,
0.1385170966,
0.6660630703,
-0.4473534822,
-0.3765744269,
-0.134455964,
0.2294238359,
-0.093678765,
-0.6497199535,
0.7515375018,
-0.0508398749,
-0.8420332074,
0.3242508173,
-0.003031746,
0.6483591199,
-0.3704477251,
0.0752211213,
-0.3435946703,
0.1833177954,
-0.6605326533,
-0.9599678516,
0.4455812275,
0.2438709885,
-0.247031644,
0.1439476311,
1.0776891708,
-0.6179885864,
-0.4875205159,
0.1532479078,
0.8127852678,
0.3933700621,
-0.5311492085,
-0.5119611621,
0.3273560405,
0.0961017758,
-0.191025272,
0.0924553573,
0.6488984823,
0.072889097,
0.4377427101,
0.5291861296,
-0.1086898446,
0.1758942902,
0.1287342459,
0.9822301269,
-0.3666934073,
-0.2824143469,
-0.9393894076,
0.550493896,
-0.3293794692,
0.1932161599,
0.7969954014,
0.7088028789,
0.5369756222,
-0.2887116373,
1.0850999355,
0.2235200256,
0.5388555527,
-0.6771354079,
0.5182725191,
-0.7474337816,
0.3137202561,
-0.1017079428,
-1.2050712109,
-0.2805189788,
0.3213881254,
-0.0399008244,
0.0795323253,
0.9094333053,
0.8775261045,
-0.0678704157,
0.2162509263,
0.3778150678,
0.4927490652,
0.0893747956,
0.2912302911,
0.9377784133,
-0.0823789537,
0.6104650497,
0.0858954713,
-0.1985738873,
-0.5821513534,
-1.1054542065,
-0.8850580454,
-0.3018811941,
-0.4342633486,
-0.3482005298,
0.1315811276,
0.5551943779,
0.6406911016,
-0.8043931723,
0.0237234458,
-0.3757477403,
0.6478753686,
0.0212737639,
-0.2874689996,
-0.1593022197,
-0.7041531205,
-0.7537893653,
0.71347332,
0.3913632035,
0.0675160363,
-0.3529517651,
-0.0699867159,
-0.0125471102,
0.1511357278,
0.6122857332,
-0.0414453484,
-0.8852772117,
-0.3413721621,
-0.1946616024,
0.1216814294,
-0.28966856,
0.7625485659,
-1.0513920784,
0.1204936057,
0.4661186039,
0.4582971632,
0.4712438285,
0.0063448041,
0.375456214,
-0.7322139144,
-0.1401403546,
-0.0287580732,
0.2725094855,
0.2759969234,
-0.6107901931,
0.4235588908,
0.5377340317,
-0.3117880523,
-0.6098341346,
0.2373628765,
-0.7674051523,
-0.3281514645,
1.1955481768,
0.0389610641,
-0.1842369139,
-0.0607828461,
-0.0793895721,
0.1982722729,
-0.3980102241,
0.9170242548,
0.7969378829,
-0.316215992,
-0.0755929202,
-0.4711453915,
0.625056386,
0.2465586215,
-1.002281189,
-0.013227433,
0.7482506633,
0.4565928578,
0.2239184529,
0.3020880818,
-0.1247004569,
0.5328831673,
-0.245639056,
-0.2077392191,
-0.106545493,
-0.5902904272,
-0.1248175129,
-0.0310261864,
-0.1815603524,
-0.1399176121
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10424v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10424v1
|
Understanding In-Context Learning with a Pelican Soup Framework
| 2024-02-16T03:20:14 | 2024-02-16T03:20:14 |
Ting-Rui Chiang, Dani Yogatama
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Many existing theoretical analyses of in-context learning for natural
language processing are based on latent variable models that leaves gaps
between theory and practice. We aim to close these gaps by proposing a
theoretical framework, the Pelican Soup Framework. In this framework, we
introduce (1) the notion of a common sense knowledge base, (2) a general
formalism for natural language classification tasks, and the notion of (3)
meaning association. Under this framework, we can establish a
$\mathcal{O}(1/T)$ loss bound for in-context learning, where $T$ is the number
of example-label pairs in the demonstration. Compared with previous works, our
bound reflects the effect of the choice of verbalizers and the effect of
instruction tuning. An additional notion of \textit{atom concepts} makes our
framework possible to explain the generalization to tasks unseen in the
language model training data. Finally, we propose a toy setup, Calcutec, and a
digit addition task that mimics types of distribution shifts a model needs to
overcome to perform in-context learning. We also experiment with GPT2-Large on
real-world NLP tasks. Our empirical results demonstrate the efficacy of our
framework to explain in-context learning.
|
[
-0.1043299288,
-0.9093983173,
0.5729524493,
0.2090357542,
-0.0782524943,
-0.1880392879,
-0.2806200087,
-0.2455306947,
-0.3323608637,
0.2564457953,
-0.1920503229,
-0.2921161056,
-0.4838239253,
0.0498073883,
-0.3476603925,
0.9650260806,
-0.1319921911,
0.0039983862,
-0.0999924913,
0.0226938911,
-0.5592862964,
-0.4341665804,
-0.623858273,
-0.4840581715,
0.3813768327,
0.3783642054,
0.4737291932,
0.791998744,
0.294469744,
0.2044702619,
-0.0861615688,
-0.1888550818,
-0.4548518956,
0.0496626273,
-0.3471742272,
-0.5070255399,
-0.3801372051,
0.2518631518,
0.6904294491,
1.2284792662,
-0.042067945,
-0.1135332584,
0.3931903243,
0.4468712807,
-0.7806350589,
0.28392452,
-0.6003890038,
0.1998709887,
-0.2657880485,
-0.1580380797,
-0.4746341407,
0.1222325265,
0.5699794888,
-0.666077137,
0.2841156721,
-0.1420657784,
0.6486979723,
0.1546695828,
-0.7432796955,
-0.4033896327,
-0.5332024693,
0.8365246654,
-0.4442381859,
0.5009515882,
0.5857396722,
0.332939446,
-0.1348765194,
-0.756593585,
-0.6601582766,
0.1063281,
0.0123256603,
-0.0889229476,
0.0519527979,
0.0524753742,
0.0269980822,
0.529221952,
-0.5345720053,
-0.2856194973,
-0.1339982897,
0.0461665802,
0.3428929746,
0.0042047272,
0.3486755788,
0.1424218565,
-0.4291586876,
0.0101326182,
-0.8056231737,
0.1232213378,
-0.0719391406,
0.2846065164,
-0.3829989433,
0.2252555341,
0.1010010764,
0.9939804673,
0.063520506,
-0.0226891432,
0.2640250325,
-0.3251575232,
-0.5067651272,
0.0660447776,
0.4453117549,
0.2999635041,
0.3248720765,
-0.4266994894,
0.0228011739,
0.001490636,
0.0914346203,
-0.6056543589,
-0.3288503289,
-0.2394113541,
-0.2515652478,
-0.264134258,
0.200178653,
-0.2673406303,
-0.1913810223,
-0.3707307279,
0.3779553175,
-0.4686559141,
-0.2868900001,
0.1921718568,
-0.3413404524,
0.3070769012,
0.2324678153,
-1.0966145992,
0.7893016934,
0.779802382,
0.9632005095,
0.0766556785,
-0.4680030048,
-0.5808346272,
0.4491615593,
-0.2925321758,
0.6730768681,
-0.7152330279,
-0.1313429475,
-0.1964488029,
0.0392436385,
-0.4407806993,
-0.462702632,
-0.1695744842,
-0.3006515205,
0.4530227184,
-0.1482914388,
-0.8151404262,
-0.4300794303,
0.3930971324,
-0.4061616659,
0.7198175788,
0.2984347641,
-0.7639995813,
0.389305681,
-0.7935198545,
-0.4932664335,
-0.0002980091,
-0.2601636052,
0.1745249778,
0.158975333,
-0.2471611947,
0.6089283824,
-0.3330560029,
0.308542788,
-0.3013068736,
-0.5482931137,
0.4364005327,
-0.485381186,
0.7202570438,
0.052339159,
-0.4317771792,
-0.1537919343,
-0.4108645022,
-0.2445525229,
0.0179606285,
-0.6539523602,
-0.5463995337,
-0.0271933861,
0.0455936082,
0.0108201755,
-0.1324492246,
-0.3194938302,
0.1857059896,
-0.932421267,
0.7342717648,
0.5179006457,
0.0963150561,
1.1653877497,
-0.1358426958,
0.2677990198,
-0.1186861545,
-0.0228634924,
-0.2494776845,
-0.3449107707,
-0.4454104602,
0.0985556021,
0.2867557406,
0.4967178404,
-0.4934828579,
0.1485366076,
-0.0991611108,
0.0335856713,
0.0230625719,
0.1859333068,
0.42352283,
0.9043843746,
0.2970506251,
-0.2018345594,
-0.3285014927,
-0.8899151087,
-0.3420493603,
0.0110195875,
-0.3466635346,
0.3049525917,
0.4371910095,
-0.0869704559,
1.1160172224,
-0.2330296636,
-0.228614524,
-0.288033247,
-0.0720101073,
0.2782793641,
0.4739481807,
0.4403876066,
-1.2349567413,
-0.6415592432,
-0.0180396084,
-0.7396370769,
0.0196045265,
0.0365534797,
0.1289554536,
0.045931872,
0.3622556329,
-0.1512963027,
0.2956312299,
0.3626075387,
-0.4815989733,
0.0575823858,
-0.0680820867,
-0.1734538823,
-1.1911542416,
-0.1726421267,
0.2595402896,
-0.1747333705,
-0.9161199331,
0.0080712745,
0.1928829253,
-0.0453001633,
-0.608071506,
0.6625183225,
-0.1685317457,
0.0429972932,
-0.1734494418,
0.09496741,
0.2206778377,
0.3251682222,
0.1663918346,
0.8516272902,
0.5660569072,
-0.917975843,
0.1191428527,
-0.1262635291,
-0.0143248392,
0.4484175742,
-0.6641774178,
0.1560965925,
-0.0690458119,
0.342056632,
-0.596986413,
-0.3397589922,
0.727162838,
-0.2804971933,
0.3058993518,
-0.2339909375,
-0.2996197939,
0.1192318797,
-0.140711844,
0.5285779834,
0.1787652373,
-0.4599833488,
0.533225596,
0.531606555,
0.0985766947,
-0.3486381769,
-0.768004179,
-0.0248520058,
-0.4962141812,
-0.4723228514,
0.7108240128,
-0.1261831969,
-0.5973774791,
-0.0004804698,
-0.2105891705,
-0.3975370228,
0.4080799222,
0.316414237,
-0.2178401649,
-0.1872709394,
0.4477704763,
0.0483257025,
-0.164166823,
0.0420537665,
-0.4035129249,
0.5174379349,
-0.5834012628,
-0.1021181792,
-0.0827907547,
0.2778396904,
0.1985970885,
-0.0201761443,
0.6342389584,
0.2444666326,
-0.5503541827,
-0.2808567882,
0.0268347822,
-0.139380306,
-0.4159628153,
0.3163273931,
-0.471701026,
-0.5111976266,
0.3014665544,
-0.1319067329,
-0.1527390182,
0.1959632188,
0.2986213863,
-0.1512135565,
0.8682234287,
0.7565649748,
0.075566344,
0.5273479223,
-0.5424876213,
0.1352268159,
-0.8811978698,
-0.1438868344,
-0.179978013,
-0.2353775799,
-0.0853723288,
-0.4325965345,
0.2071616054,
0.4589186609,
-0.4101723135,
0.2998227179,
-0.2384986132,
0.8694774508,
0.5545480251,
0.0542163029,
0.1302910596,
-0.1635987759,
-0.1044459715,
0.195946902,
-0.886030376,
-0.6077718735,
1.0108371973,
0.3522719443,
0.46960482,
0.1395284235,
0.6238234639,
0.2387501895,
0.2671951354,
-0.8518589139,
0.2332816571,
-0.0007735381,
-0.4830024838,
-0.3209098876,
-0.327966243,
-0.8529280424,
0.3116832972,
0.0055499738,
-0.7249689698,
0.1138517335,
0.360832423,
-0.138595894,
0.1118587554,
-0.9100581408,
1.1231279373,
-0.2301735729,
-0.4187076986,
-0.0319207646,
-0.6871460676,
0.1982473731,
0.0710594952,
0.3649931848,
0.0723710507,
-0.1472231597,
0.6274818182,
-0.3344598711,
0.9707052708,
-0.1843096316,
-0.0127840182,
0.1411593556,
0.1227559894,
0.3307809234,
0.2423534542,
-0.1160121337,
0.0288835373,
0.092714183,
-0.4730210006,
-0.7420832515,
0.4260729253,
-0.5587665439,
-0.1280115247,
-0.5535479784,
-0.6510022879,
-0.1806119084,
0.0914315954,
0.3750077188,
0.5899757743,
-0.1934530139,
0.343228519,
0.7670608163,
0.0576999858,
0.3541697264,
0.5431198478,
0.0180752315,
-0.0283560418,
0.9010645747,
0.1644022614,
0.1864524633,
0.7334092259,
0.4945170879,
-0.2300300002,
-0.4582140744,
-0.2916825712,
0.0290939491,
-0.7883399725,
0.0372382738,
-0.3033531308,
0.1586548388,
-0.3722441494,
-0.3267701864,
0.0555006526,
-0.0290916413,
-0.355512768,
0.1351373494,
0.0168136433,
0.8304294944,
0.184501335,
0.4962887466,
-0.5229591727,
0.1392154694,
0.4237569571,
0.4199667275,
0.1087315381,
-0.4205925763,
-0.4421091974,
0.2977842093,
-0.4160307646,
-1.1745728254,
0.3216024637,
0.6556242108,
0.5425278544,
0.5525624156,
0.0343422554,
0.5256334543,
-0.4217878282,
0.7465188503,
0.0089010997,
-1.1734005213,
0.6110756397,
-0.4667556584,
0.209442988,
0.4756410718,
0.3093697429,
-0.8634729981,
-0.2025885433,
-0.691871345,
-0.9100721478,
0.5677814484,
0.0399632044,
0.1967948824,
-0.3351961374,
0.3517962098,
0.22871463,
0.2366618216,
-0.8187118769,
-0.0805634335,
-0.3240893483,
-0.3710944951,
-0.1728984714,
-0.0459156744,
-0.0599541105,
-0.239367947,
0.5756219625,
-0.4409444332,
0.0485675894,
0.0210344493,
-0.7233774662,
0.0552048832,
0.2361032516,
0.3882457018,
0.8706567287,
-0.2063063383,
0.5577782393,
0.2315918505,
-0.2101910412,
-0.0304279253,
-0.0596210174,
-0.0488472693,
-0.3317854702,
0.6118026972,
0.6262638569,
0.8947458863,
-0.5803787112,
0.6472207308,
-0.1967573762,
-0.061288707,
-0.2744377255,
0.2678695619,
0.159537077,
0.2985548079,
0.4816781878,
-0.0007648158,
0.4016740024,
-0.7518040538,
0.2410151064,
0.1984102279,
-0.3699972034,
-0.5004148483,
0.1994411051,
0.183753401,
-0.5902591944,
0.4864023328,
-0.279104352,
-0.5319516659,
0.6108195782,
1.0115609169,
0.5872746706,
0.0365698114,
0.1290894598,
-0.1505427361,
-0.1376232207,
-0.167869404,
-0.0161846317,
-0.594514668,
-0.9199637771,
-0.2700152397,
-0.4913671911,
-0.4623960257,
0.1379027069,
-0.5866295099,
-0.0122282971,
-0.4386599064,
0.2219928354,
-0.033774633,
-0.0542611033,
-0.7016355991,
-0.0565285608,
0.1396271586,
0.7829349041,
-1.1134960651,
0.8977270126,
0.9234548211,
-0.3899940252,
-0.9582775235,
0.2504302859,
0.0589671917,
-0.4945873618,
0.7770200968,
0.3356127739,
0.0758526027,
0.0386385694,
-0.4497019053,
-0.8576242328,
1.0328423977,
0.450856179,
-0.3720311821,
-0.1744130552,
-0.1138198823,
0.2980635464,
-0.7307879925,
-0.0045820586,
0.5709641576,
0.2872111499,
-0.0827755406,
-0.9854699373,
-0.1972097903,
-0.3640486896,
0.0104224375,
0.1543841511,
-0.0929466039,
1.1228160858,
0.0874188915,
-0.3805973232,
-0.3449468315,
0.3459880352,
0.1391608566,
0.7132597566,
0.4335845113,
0.3098678291,
0.7248746157,
0.0689267516,
1.1970962286,
-0.0370356143,
0.452196002,
1.2637389898,
-0.1598916948,
0.6907025576,
0.7163524032,
-0.2734079957,
0.4388515055,
0.8276612759,
0.3357523978,
0.5378901362,
0.1133349612,
-0.2943693399,
-0.1463568956,
-0.1301411092,
-0.3608854115,
0.4778557718,
0.5525096059,
-0.5395377278,
-0.4802950919,
0.2737315297,
-0.0717017427,
0.315207094,
-0.3255734742,
0.8990710378,
0.1968384832,
-0.2439606786,
0.5694912076,
-0.1169109717,
0.5962275267,
-0.3571271598,
-0.3339696229,
0.0156938117,
0.2962334454,
0.0413239449,
-0.7584955692,
0.3370736837,
-0.2695459425,
-0.5772228837,
-0.3422425091,
0.6515851617,
-0.4694707096,
-0.246307373,
0.2178263366,
0.3917546868,
0.2903716564,
-0.28013888,
-0.7292063832,
-0.0934676826,
-0.377573669,
-0.2099522948,
0.5858363509,
0.4671545029,
-0.0094207739,
0.5649188161,
0.3006096184,
0.0886353776,
-0.1176092401,
0.0416870452,
0.6604145765,
-0.3984192014,
-0.6154159307,
-0.8560382128,
0.1672873199,
0.016645262,
-0.297065258,
0.7238111496,
0.4366320074,
1.2411906719,
-0.0113434074,
0.7150204182,
-0.0780693442,
0.2970807254,
-0.4681676626,
0.5515949726,
-0.3573738337,
0.3017873168,
-0.2183497548,
-0.946315527,
-0.4958115518,
1.1166311502,
-0.6825171709,
-0.2333199978,
0.7126219273,
0.5194672346,
-0.3446735144,
0.0447766408,
0.1342847496,
0.0373001173,
0.2067881525,
0.7620357275,
0.6469800472,
-0.4762289524,
0.2161373198,
-0.4728485942,
-0.2082206458,
-0.074223198,
-0.822312355,
-0.7136397362,
-0.8462739587,
0.0209385604,
-0.2090293616,
0.1113785878,
1.1808100939,
0.893868506,
-0.5723406076,
-0.4059899747,
-0.5652384758,
0.3557173312,
-0.3516955972,
-0.2854119837,
0.2188634574,
-0.5243285894,
-0.6913798451,
0.6512301564,
0.280143261,
0.0798283517,
0.2070320994,
-0.5159268379,
-0.2582593858,
-0.2549677491,
0.6610346437,
0.3533503711,
-0.708224833,
-0.2820707262,
-0.1560713798,
0.2651854753,
-0.0287916362,
0.8704511523,
-1.1165962219,
0.2945485115,
0.4229532182,
0.5210984349,
0.2583317161,
-0.114515163,
0.9310359359,
-0.8780383468,
0.1771291345,
0.2882019281,
0.3276635706,
0.3330064118,
-0.24673298,
0.4675822854,
0.4095641375,
-0.3467042148,
-0.9758344889,
0.4421221912,
-0.5634548068,
-0.5256263018,
0.9688109159,
-0.1158173829,
-0.4081408978,
-0.3118127286,
0.0030311518,
0.3560006022,
-0.3860686719,
0.5488298535,
0.4435925484,
-0.2423594892,
-0.0833656639,
-0.2741143107,
0.438583523,
0.1162710711,
-0.519334197,
0.1410627067,
0.3355099559,
0.5823795199,
0.076405704,
0.6040677428,
0.2666013241,
0.3151944578,
-0.1469046324,
-0.32439363,
-0.2141146958,
-0.6372456551,
-0.5737652779,
0.2985861301,
-0.0135181472,
-0.1351883262
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10422v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10422v2
|
Pushing the Limits of Zero-shot End-to-End Speech Translation
| 2024-02-16T03:06:37 | 2024-06-05T20:56:20 |
Ioannis Tsiamas, Gerard I. Gállego, José A. R. Fonollosa, Marta R. Costa-jussà
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Data scarcity and the modality gap between the speech and text modalities are
two major obstacles of end-to-end Speech Translation (ST) systems, thus
hindering their performance. Prior work has attempted to mitigate these
challenges by leveraging external MT data and optimizing distance metrics that
bring closer the speech-text representations. However, achieving competitive
results typically requires some ST data. For this reason, we introduce
ZeroSwot, a method for zero-shot ST that bridges the modality gap without any
paired ST data. Leveraging a novel CTC compression and Optimal Transport, we
train a speech encoder using only ASR data, to align with the representation
space of a massively multilingual MT model. The speech encoder seamlessly
integrates with the MT model at inference, enabling direct translation from
speech to text, across all languages supported by the MT model. Our experiments
show that we can effectively close the modality gap without ST data, while our
results on MuST-C and CoVoST demonstrate our method's superiority over not only
previous zero-shot models, but also supervised ones, achieving state-of-the-art
results.
|
[
-0.1549097151,
-0.650365293,
0.4455699325,
-0.3659980893,
-0.7389776707,
0.1124886274,
-0.4322501421,
-0.4643138349,
0.265622139,
0.4354553223,
-0.6396766901,
-0.5594756007,
-0.5793225169,
0.0259922687,
-0.4612292349,
0.9705349803,
-0.0740584657,
-0.0886978582,
-0.2283286601,
-0.33668679,
-0.6224642992,
-0.5619485974,
-0.3718900979,
-0.1177591085,
0.3383489251,
0.4069342017,
0.6042718887,
0.7622455955,
0.1469381303,
0.0660371557,
-0.0397865735,
0.0450970531,
-0.5204684138,
0.4307907522,
-0.1265219748,
-0.3680463135,
-0.1285669953,
-0.1639606357,
0.3739039302,
0.8206977248,
-0.0251852032,
0.1160335317,
-0.3088234365,
0.1457452178,
-0.4433832467,
-0.2477302998,
-0.5362329483,
0.1286719888,
-0.5821335912,
-0.3253418505,
-0.4921643734,
-0.1742744595,
-0.1281737387,
-0.3011389673,
0.0618236996,
0.0258322563,
0.9111311436,
0.4907213748,
-0.8297059536,
0.036404945,
-0.7362368107,
0.662212193,
-0.564491272,
0.6241767406,
0.1528425366,
0.2872323096,
-0.066676639,
-0.1428331882,
-0.5971376896,
-0.1966401935,
0.4059417248,
0.2161729634,
-0.3362044096,
0.0678581968,
-0.0542028621,
0.1682159007,
-0.8651283383,
0.175211966,
-0.5041928887,
0.0847771317,
0.4515106678,
-0.1169665307,
0.20257999,
-0.1571153402,
-0.3903896511,
-0.1441282034,
-0.6037610769,
0.0138955675,
0.0949192718,
0.41062814,
-0.221932143,
0.7387447357,
-0.1282462776,
0.6352033019,
-0.1557611525,
0.3647956252,
0.347181797,
-0.2179997116,
-0.3529717028,
0.2775549591,
0.9013704062,
0.2456229478,
0.0242407974,
-0.5658874512,
-0.0860232338,
0.1798754185,
-0.1073233187,
-0.6230304241,
0.3892130554,
0.2128678262,
0.0954316407,
-0.174249649,
-0.2661881447,
-0.3758047521,
0.1147928759,
-0.2803019583,
0.4847120941,
-0.38595137,
-0.2368726134,
0.1314214915,
-0.1651789844,
0.3451481462,
0.1183866337,
-0.561744988,
0.209781304,
0.271142453,
1.1570546627,
-0.1497325152,
-0.028176358,
-0.516585052,
0.4311671257,
-0.7346935868,
0.7301464081,
-0.6057469845,
-0.3957653344,
-0.2059468925,
-0.1901285201,
-0.143319115,
-0.1750191897,
0.8719836473,
-0.1378068775,
0.3268904388,
-0.0913789272,
-0.5069767237,
-0.1103877053,
0.0203887187,
-0.2184579372,
0.7931351066,
0.1882783473,
-0.1634017676,
0.1912054271,
-0.7514513731,
-0.7432595491,
0.0975169092,
-0.2555742562,
-0.1836804897,
0.6418985724,
0.1583427042,
0.3273565173,
-0.4967972636,
0.3112213016,
-0.2635921836,
-0.3295580745,
0.1736032814,
-0.6410578489,
0.6514596939,
0.1860914677,
-0.2440033555,
0.1737692952,
-0.3714387119,
-0.0395947248,
0.363481164,
0.0747551247,
-0.4524762332,
-0.2591929734,
0.2391685545,
0.4686872959,
0.0325560197,
-0.9752027392,
0.1571587622,
-0.4177146852,
0.7914254069,
0.7637861967,
-0.2838428617,
0.4850126207,
-0.3268240392,
0.4606672525,
-0.1053080261,
0.0301706716,
-0.2639519572,
-0.3174389899,
-0.522167623,
-0.2226960063,
0.3532409668,
0.4807453454,
-0.790047586,
0.513566494,
-0.6839758754,
-0.3723282218,
-0.8161081672,
-0.4865468144,
0.0881368741,
0.5512696505,
0.5006597638,
-0.4204958081,
-0.2238983512,
-0.7283883095,
0.0057338797,
0.1741441786,
-0.3298961818,
0.1382864714,
0.1905356348,
0.0314601324,
0.7650108933,
-0.2491802424,
-0.3624094129,
-0.2870077491,
0.0597867928,
0.170800373,
0.565535903,
0.3610775769,
-0.5111222863,
-0.4495536387,
0.2306067944,
-0.5662452579,
-0.2645293474,
-0.4082012773,
-0.0221976005,
0.1481958628,
0.2821260989,
-0.6397804618,
0.536921978,
0.6586865187,
-0.2994900048,
0.2026251405,
-0.145248875,
0.2787997425,
-0.9105749726,
0.2067840546,
-0.3015523255,
-0.5340544581,
-1.0822474957,
0.0793720335,
-0.065567784,
-0.5122657418,
-0.4766480029,
0.4180411994,
-0.2238515764,
0.1007925048,
-0.1926044226,
0.336035043,
-0.1001388878,
0.6490229964,
0.1204327196,
0.6277038455,
0.4626246393,
-0.2469976693,
0.1278853416,
0.4810667634,
0.2137193233,
0.8441941142,
-0.6478393674,
0.4058757722,
-0.1216369793,
0.2994528413,
-0.9251480699,
-0.1133097336,
0.2863131166,
-0.8847195506,
0.4732901156,
-0.0994679555,
-0.343478024,
-0.0237579271,
-0.1459288299,
0.4916442633,
0.6205334067,
-0.1624001414,
0.1810330749,
0.1275075674,
-0.1982186586,
-0.1979957372,
-1.0443915129,
0.6364737749,
0.0628099144,
-0.6491612792,
0.3598250747,
-0.1612806767,
0.3620776832,
-0.0819358081,
-0.4621322453,
-0.1994799972,
-0.2671539187,
0.1347008497,
0.1775246561,
0.0117442822,
0.0158409756,
0.4299245775,
-0.3311156631,
-0.4213152826,
-0.4605410695,
0.5998243093,
0.2712172568,
-0.6418685913,
-0.4275093377,
0.7386825085,
0.846884191,
-0.2708090246,
0.5576071143,
0.4114929736,
-0.3116624951,
-0.0321241803,
-0.3730637431,
0.0386316106,
-0.3635712564,
0.1939154863,
-0.3594281971,
-1.0725626945,
0.0736774132,
-0.0012429123,
0.0977066457,
0.2399065942,
0.2109191865,
0.0542813241,
0.8512405753,
0.6372845173,
0.0754678398,
0.332626611,
-0.0383574218,
0.4080830812,
-0.747762382,
-0.2403548658,
-0.5061891079,
-0.358832866,
-0.2279606313,
-0.8925461173,
0.4598545134,
0.0216335338,
-0.2587594688,
0.7585250139,
-0.7670798898,
0.3888037503,
0.5527115464,
-0.0315430872,
0.2604611516,
0.1011463702,
0.0015090106,
-0.261380136,
-0.7337030768,
0.0221366733,
0.9306260347,
0.1163489074,
0.3005277812,
0.2866540253,
0.5890668035,
0.2709504962,
-0.0997807756,
-0.8127942681,
0.4638985991,
-0.3610177934,
-0.4897958636,
-0.4669152498,
-0.5138394833,
-0.6825566888,
0.3844771981,
0.0466078594,
-0.4293245077,
0.2871394157,
-0.3281525373,
-0.0416896306,
0.3239293993,
-0.3429670036,
0.6710346341,
-0.323964715,
-0.4183321595,
-0.0717998222,
-0.9366193414,
0.0590535551,
-0.1018732563,
0.2369778603,
-0.2796648145,
-0.1961539835,
0.4519625902,
-0.4748065472,
0.5794529319,
-0.09663295,
0.0928529948,
0.1114175096,
0.3651946485,
0.4843388796,
-0.6567097902,
0.0006660226,
0.6080519557,
-0.0422593579,
-0.5554014444,
-0.3312383592,
0.330874294,
-0.6033009291,
-0.218626067,
-0.3987565041,
-0.6523663402,
-0.1569737196,
0.2069727033,
0.3821820319,
0.3869688213,
-0.047634013,
0.3686300814,
0.4980263412,
-0.1132029966,
0.5369496346,
0.5255469084,
0.3646627963,
-0.5831125379,
0.8920583725,
0.3635564446,
0.5428606868,
0.4639894962,
0.0963880643,
-0.5706083179,
-0.6306981444,
-1.008738637,
0.2594359815,
-0.3418132365,
-0.4155302644,
-0.552100718,
-0.2299482822,
-0.577069819,
-0.8716695905,
-0.5937223434,
-0.5659446716,
-0.2087087482,
-0.1105509847,
0.230217427,
0.3111366332,
-0.4357971251,
0.3917139471,
-0.661558032,
0.1329153329,
-0.1839468032,
0.2044353634,
-0.1849758029,
-0.9056622982,
-0.1094156727,
0.1026335582,
-0.0643878579,
-0.9508434534,
0.6302461624,
0.3265399933,
0.2129018754,
0.3311850131,
0.4062360525,
1.2160202265,
-0.6330910921,
0.8579257131,
0.7246655822,
-1.2409318686,
0.5211010575,
-0.4224226177,
0.4818383753,
0.4605309665,
0.1949333102,
-1.0892214775,
-0.4306819141,
-0.4056321084,
-1.0660122633,
0.5126745105,
0.4602650404,
0.2147512138,
-0.0493861064,
0.0624012575,
0.1446526945,
0.3861913383,
-0.625399828,
0.024296999,
-0.3462841511,
-0.238199234,
0.035333205,
0.1221257001,
-0.042209018,
-0.0966577381,
0.3330601156,
-0.0782291815,
0.3297381401,
0.3746378422,
-0.2365993857,
-0.4688458741,
0.5668257475,
0.7699545026,
0.1556286663,
-0.0673484802,
0.0667115599,
0.3146059513,
-0.1027246639,
0.3872078657,
0.0778912976,
-0.3275817931,
0.253498286,
0.2872134447,
0.7651218772,
0.2115755379,
-0.7563897967,
0.8410573602,
0.2765493393,
-0.3093966842,
-0.1093875468,
-0.4456425011,
-0.2112028897,
0.0218647048,
0.3654061556,
0.2406883091,
-0.004106015,
-0.272893399,
0.4145223498,
0.3404977322,
-0.8088924885,
-0.447024703,
1.00849998,
0.2148359865,
-0.2355295569,
0.4105091691,
-0.166302979,
-0.1202746034,
0.1514811367,
0.6978148222,
1.02859056,
-0.3775056005,
0.249536857,
0.0862777904,
0.4094040692,
0.1169280708,
0.0185955744,
-0.4074204266,
-0.1567388624,
-0.7543947697,
-0.4784028828,
-0.4347874522,
-0.1616391242,
-0.6095965505,
0.3437618315,
-0.2004180104,
0.0795371011,
-0.5256465077,
-0.4003406465,
-0.4745741785,
-0.0974507853,
0.3631107211,
0.7519770861,
-0.8283193707,
0.8719062805,
0.2197739482,
-0.4458818734,
-0.3736536205,
-0.4217948318,
0.0821133107,
-0.683152318,
0.2072519362,
0.0749333054,
-0.2717286348,
0.0321009196,
-0.6503059864,
-0.8445232511,
0.9973909259,
0.6222461462,
-0.7752423882,
-0.0342365578,
0.5050094128,
0.4451974928,
-0.1635132134,
0.2439167649,
0.2379085124,
0.2797230482,
0.7055203319,
-1.1007431746,
0.0822225586,
-0.0257910714,
-0.0599259324,
0.3903856874,
-0.541264534,
0.6362680197,
0.0174715258,
-0.4923912585,
-0.0472641774,
0.4495346844,
-0.0471384153,
0.3771258891,
0.2607200444,
0.6208583117,
0.406755507,
-0.0361768752,
0.6002128124,
-0.0874314234,
0.1961287111,
1.2129936218,
-0.4537345469,
0.9946398139,
0.4328023791,
0.1933794171,
-0.0190740265,
0.4601929486,
0.0723491982,
0.5503391623,
0.1143680736,
-0.3905692697,
-0.3616638184,
-0.7141956687,
-0.3590548933,
0.5189586878,
0.2299362719,
0.0581776649,
-0.4518686831,
0.2788172662,
0.4106475711,
0.1219689026,
-0.0641114935,
0.4823067188,
0.0478298552,
-0.1865095496,
0.8694595695,
-0.0158313736,
0.7772936225,
-0.7821940184,
0.167565465,
-0.2803195119,
-0.3255006671,
0.0061436486,
-0.4446548223,
0.5509194732,
0.1369548291,
0.2422005683,
-0.5195023417,
0.445949614,
-0.703330934,
-0.2363558561,
0.2745800316,
0.5648961663,
0.3737834394,
-0.1846469641,
-0.3725765347,
0.0897234157,
0.1002671197,
0.0846334174,
0.2656480372,
0.5417699218,
0.0301610548,
0.4872779548,
0.9631975889,
0.2610674798,
0.0310004298,
-0.1411590874,
0.8449887633,
-0.8235055208,
-0.4048412144,
-0.7640749216,
0.5314317346,
0.0047098855,
-0.2786359787,
0.5552269816,
0.5766332746,
0.7999554276,
0.3092103302,
0.900947988,
-0.2190000117,
0.3420628607,
-0.030580217,
0.5602772236,
-0.6312442422,
-0.1865331978,
0.0178572107,
-0.4759091139,
-0.615729928,
0.3521936834,
-0.2110532373,
-0.5481093526,
0.6007556915,
0.5889143348,
0.0168151874,
-0.0738792643,
0.9718352556,
0.136552766,
0.5098716617,
0.7982293367,
0.4873935878,
-0.562345624,
1.0044380426,
0.0880829245,
-0.2878468633,
-0.0706761926,
-0.6729630828,
-0.7089337707,
-0.4984950721,
-0.2216304988,
-0.0313754082,
0.220382899,
0.9637342095,
0.8265002966,
-0.4875358641,
-0.2626931667,
-0.1391894817,
-0.1618196815,
-0.273049742,
-0.1232634336,
0.2274841964,
-0.1187086552,
-0.6478420496,
0.7250099778,
0.650673449,
0.1982646734,
-0.057044901,
0.0561430044,
-0.0280841161,
0.3406325877,
0.7159648538,
0.3267188668,
-0.6262232065,
-0.4699537754,
0.2881998718,
0.2615766525,
0.2068882734,
0.7351695895,
-0.6571108103,
0.5651906133,
0.2809881568,
0.7286442518,
0.6054416299,
-0.2475905865,
0.6177835464,
-0.8124758005,
0.168095395,
0.4768993556,
-0.113661088,
0.2663968503,
-0.1342089474,
0.4865914583,
0.3313511908,
-0.4703371525,
-0.9927533269,
0.3578982651,
-1.1941334009,
-0.3351128399,
0.9469228983,
0.1383619159,
-0.2200012058,
-0.2379943877,
-0.0063273632,
0.4895276427,
-0.6360961199,
0.3712365329,
0.311624378,
-0.2106711119,
-0.3317583203,
-0.8048947453,
-0.1137644723,
0.4667497575,
-0.4462580681,
0.2044144869,
0.4523461163,
0.0937827155,
-0.0718970224,
0.6126099825,
-0.0357155912,
-0.0187448412,
0.189574182,
0.156489864,
-0.3897388577,
-0.2135243416,
-0.5294092894,
0.2631860673,
-0.3593898118,
-0.4949986041
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10416v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10416v1
|
Grounding Language about Belief in a Bayesian Theory-of-Mind
| 2024-02-16T02:47:09 | 2024-02-16T02:47:09 |
Lance Ying, Tan Zhi-Xuan, Lionel Wong, Vikash Mansinghka, Joshua Tenenbaum
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Despite the fact that beliefs are mental states that cannot be directly
observed, humans talk about each others' beliefs on a regular basis, often
using rich compositional language to describe what others think and know. What
explains this capacity to interpret the hidden epistemic content of other
minds? In this paper, we take a step towards an answer by grounding the
semantics of belief statements in a Bayesian theory-of-mind: By modeling how
humans jointly infer coherent sets of goals, beliefs, and plans that explain an
agent's actions, then evaluating statements about the agent's beliefs against
these inferences via epistemic logic, our framework provides a conceptual role
semantics for belief, explaining the gradedness and compositionality of human
belief attributions, as well as their intimate connection with goals and plans.
We evaluate this framework by studying how humans attribute goals and beliefs
while watching an agent solve a doors-and-keys gridworld puzzle that requires
instrumental reasoning about hidden objects. In contrast to pure logical
deduction, non-mentalizing baselines, and mentalizing that ignores the role of
instrumental plans, our model provides a much better fit to human goal and
belief attributions, demonstrating the importance of theory-of-mind for a
semantics of belief.
|
[
-0.5665173531,
-0.6675836444,
1.1105624437,
-0.0735660195,
-0.1723712981,
0.0998109505,
-0.2099159509,
-0.1740325987,
0.1711370796,
0.4422625303,
-0.5054709911,
-0.5427826047,
-0.5368685722,
-0.3126470447,
0.2249415815,
0.7421115041,
-0.0134722404,
-0.2853196859,
-0.3454011381,
0.141772151,
-0.4508160949,
-0.304323256,
-0.3772139847,
-0.6120407581,
0.4851441383,
0.1706195921,
0.9488004446,
0.5127589703,
0.1784356087,
0.12103533,
0.1045825258,
-0.2035386413,
-0.3049986959,
0.235829249,
-0.6756035089,
-1.018414259,
-0.1304856688,
0.2030016929,
0.4537805915,
0.7379120588,
-0.3168957531,
-0.1721314192,
-0.1114766598,
0.2770659029,
-0.7329236269,
0.5932155252,
-0.6335983276,
0.2241770625,
0.4500030875,
-0.1150961667,
-0.2114080638,
-0.2988820076,
0.172318235,
-0.4415530264,
0.3574573398,
-0.1103649512,
0.8776011467,
0.41422382,
-0.4496228695,
0.045829758,
-0.5085064173,
0.7057843804,
-0.457005471,
0.3710076809,
0.7871115208,
0.251575321,
-0.312550962,
0.0441218503,
-0.8591384888,
-0.2615202069,
-0.1732604504,
0.2724968791,
0.0467116535,
0.3440793753,
0.5591005683,
0.2106480449,
-0.3430188,
-0.4632417262,
0.2874230742,
0.0026646447,
0.4385083914,
-0.1019410044,
0.2995178103,
0.1193597838,
-0.1431313455,
-0.2347721159,
-0.5963009596,
-0.0324576311,
0.0273753367,
0.078887254,
0.063865006,
0.4693226218,
-0.6088085771,
0.4229980111,
0.1031380594,
-0.146521911,
-0.1706962585,
0.2377357334,
-0.2818060219,
0.1645681113,
0.0436545275,
0.5515021086,
0.2417305708,
-0.4456226528,
-0.1826291084,
1.1911447048,
0.4400803745,
-0.5467625856,
-0.2397154868,
0.1042026654,
-0.4268612564,
-0.1683175415,
0.2217220515,
-0.3230088353,
-0.5917995572,
-0.3271772861,
0.6900479198,
-0.3379461169,
-0.538018167,
0.4927463233,
-0.4463366866,
0.2565904558,
0.4667415619,
-0.8419759274,
0.705921948,
0.9106330872,
0.3583757877,
0.2535370588,
-0.4261395335,
-0.2073577344,
0.6913300157,
-0.5881945491,
0.7132491469,
-0.7511443496,
-0.3768220544,
-0.1771824509,
-0.0198655743,
-0.0148081761,
-0.0810548663,
0.5165702105,
-0.2020143718,
-0.0238342993,
-0.8553123474,
-0.9478597641,
-0.4051623344,
0.2345386893,
-0.1684730649,
0.3219794631,
-0.074778378,
-0.5779207945,
0.7522199154,
-0.6761280894,
-0.3274666369,
0.0420231931,
-0.7094532847,
0.1283626109,
0.6341657639,
-0.1713374555,
0.4485738873,
-0.3774271309,
0.452657342,
-0.3688545227,
-0.2584728301,
0.565309763,
-0.3879460692,
0.5803906918,
0.0970997214,
-0.7131465673,
-0.2921923399,
-0.5549604297,
0.1364976913,
0.0978670791,
-0.0443697982,
-0.5657891631,
0.7626971006,
-0.672480166,
0.1540196389,
0.1700476408,
-0.6704945564,
0.2820446789,
-0.4449408054,
0.1447781026,
0.5983876586,
0.067955859,
0.5637305379,
-0.5428915024,
0.0609016977,
0.1094155386,
0.0803958103,
0.0290044807,
-0.7861857414,
-0.5289060473,
-0.0231561735,
-0.0646661147,
0.3751593232,
-0.1270220429,
0.6234529614,
-0.0913339779,
-0.2089749873,
-0.3313345313,
-0.3009245694,
0.3233073652,
0.4120205045,
0.1425665021,
-0.1907433122,
-0.1598219126,
-1.0456273556,
-0.2899651825,
-0.5934997201,
-0.1460478455,
-0.0783651546,
0.653306663,
-0.2729484439,
1.1929875612,
-0.9620175958,
0.0804804116,
0.0757466629,
0.2664101422,
0.1720217913,
0.5988728404,
0.3700323999,
-0.924413085,
-0.2230659723,
0.2162309885,
-0.9117984772,
0.0817506537,
-0.1353317648,
-0.3396033645,
-0.1615612507,
-0.1703585982,
-1.062625885,
0.9170739651,
0.0081049325,
-0.7489478588,
0.2899874747,
-0.0820306093,
0.2831451595,
-0.8723137379,
-0.4963588417,
-0.0301070083,
-0.0917434096,
-0.4345568419,
0.3635835648,
-0.1129699424,
0.0823106244,
0.177408576,
0.1826725602,
-0.2716153264,
-0.1643860936,
-0.4305637777,
0.0004162426,
0.1499080807,
0.6246256232,
0.6100087762,
0.2944500148,
0.7952990532,
-0.5581840873,
0.0848484933,
0.3070707023,
-0.1743494421,
0.7671679258,
-0.3584019244,
-0.141404435,
-0.3918782771,
0.3406915367,
-0.7932485342,
-0.1004630998,
0.4131580293,
-0.637324512,
0.1218227074,
-0.2980525494,
-0.4429506361,
0.044228524,
0.0783174634,
-0.0565125085,
0.5466814637,
-0.2602903843,
0.5050979853,
0.5796613693,
0.0677287355,
-0.2248822451,
-0.5574545264,
0.1309163272,
-0.3325302005,
-0.4292349219,
0.6683450937,
0.0527619869,
-0.9709014297,
0.1867917627,
-0.5917532444,
-0.1894368529,
0.2924416363,
0.5237964392,
0.1045316234,
-0.161534965,
0.3741480112,
0.4172287881,
-0.3270137012,
0.4373856485,
-0.84449929,
0.0973647088,
-0.2438576967,
-0.5378623605,
-0.1386811286,
0.7448095083,
0.3718019426,
0.1168144047,
0.9228395224,
0.1165651008,
-0.8051433563,
-0.2884303629,
-0.4172738791,
-0.3474075794,
-0.346706897,
-0.0220305678,
-0.722648561,
-0.6067900658,
0.3892439306,
-0.0256334376,
-0.1503982991,
0.3264229894,
0.4697238207,
-0.353566885,
1.1025499105,
0.6574954391,
0.2033778578,
0.0133265657,
-0.0739161819,
0.0725431219,
-0.4345781803,
-0.0180031192,
-0.2983342111,
-0.0303317681,
-0.5327630043,
-0.5343829989,
0.2195739746,
0.327907443,
-0.3228348196,
0.1215583906,
-0.2886443436,
0.6490482092,
0.2897910178,
0.3209894896,
0.1419988573,
-0.0431378894,
-0.3709508479,
-0.0135261416,
-0.4813870788,
-0.8157948256,
0.7951655388,
0.4095159471,
0.7093362808,
0.3708767891,
0.6499449015,
0.4291994572,
0.118389532,
-0.8594132662,
0.4382371306,
0.361282289,
-0.9236413836,
-0.208339572,
-0.1269157827,
-0.4746468365,
0.652954638,
-0.2057922632,
-1.0899442434,
0.3391625881,
0.084758535,
-0.2125893831,
0.3740001917,
-0.5503094196,
0.9865823388,
-0.0169532858,
-0.3629558086,
-0.7481098175,
-0.7606495023,
0.0396384709,
0.2769038975,
0.0612308942,
-0.0528533906,
-0.008639669,
0.6637217999,
-0.5020340085,
1.0597683191,
-0.3753024936,
-0.4335902929,
0.4325177073,
0.1264928281,
0.5348661542,
0.2760513127,
0.2277580053,
0.0604845211,
0.2479910403,
-0.4927827716,
-1.0132579803,
0.4209286869,
-0.8847703338,
-0.9185789824,
-0.4306276441,
-0.3124528527,
-0.3921249509,
0.0064667817,
0.0530623049,
0.3612261713,
-0.3189282417,
-0.1155298427,
1.0931141376,
-0.0152833015,
-0.0896474645,
0.6475234032,
-0.316531837,
0.0336994827,
0.8851715922,
-0.1643605083,
0.3780519366,
0.8337619305,
0.357565403,
-0.3714999259,
-0.2513328195,
0.1699812859,
0.2261876762,
-1.0503280163,
0.3172780573,
-0.6245903969,
0.2785714865,
-0.2314554155,
-0.2001927346,
-0.2898790538,
-0.3306503296,
0.0075883549,
-0.4085668027,
0.0735417902,
0.6597983241,
-0.1896280348,
0.3527959585,
-0.5323503017,
0.4709715843,
0.5801817179,
0.2063735574,
-0.1401686519,
-0.1300258636,
-0.3190361261,
0.5214986801,
-0.1787653565,
-1.2641686201,
0.0546774194,
-0.0822647288,
0.8439630866,
0.5439417362,
0.0546080694,
0.6752217412,
-0.3393802941,
0.3402973711,
0.0975983292,
-1.0772895813,
0.7511739731,
-0.5677325726,
-0.064386569,
0.4888207316,
0.3070489764,
-0.5410781503,
-0.4197508395,
-0.8678838015,
-0.0229112357,
0.2868775725,
0.2607819736,
-0.206028536,
-0.3245916963,
0.4392150939,
0.2757299542,
0.4633783996,
-0.4970316887,
-0.2218801528,
-0.4485406578,
0.0049583805,
-0.1708189845,
-0.0005412434,
-0.4500186443,
-0.3443015218,
0.3222980499,
-0.4375707507,
0.7209380269,
0.2176014632,
-0.1668674648,
-0.4709143937,
0.4369087815,
0.416798979,
0.8028305173,
-0.2183727175,
0.4034103453,
-0.0502910949,
-0.1508992463,
0.1605111659,
-0.1896279752,
-0.2718260586,
-0.2821398079,
0.2191768289,
0.8251360059,
0.2938943803,
-0.3604482114,
0.3556997478,
-0.0130030522,
-0.1497012377,
-0.3204122782,
0.1550384164,
0.1429811269,
0.4679591358,
0.3839897811,
0.3127276301,
0.0026047037,
-1.1287332773,
0.2829605639,
0.3653998971,
-0.2637126744,
-0.6137199998,
0.5080281496,
-0.2832151651,
-0.0010195416,
0.0334016867,
-0.3738307357,
-0.8787904382,
0.523022294,
0.6437929869,
0.993142128,
0.1282599568,
0.5936896801,
-0.1122675985,
0.3782655299,
-0.2004723251,
0.4375258088,
-0.394077003,
-1.3507753611,
-0.3797841668,
-0.7132276893,
-0.4881560504,
-0.2116059214,
-0.6841973662,
-0.1847411543,
-0.3165373504,
-0.2604872882,
-0.2188742459,
0.1259275228,
-0.4705414772,
0.4513897896,
0.3780038059,
0.4855299592,
-1.054970026,
0.7580133677,
0.7987704277,
-0.4958531857,
-0.6498779655,
0.4759459496,
-0.1094149947,
-0.5288718939,
0.6331452727,
0.0273327678,
-0.1364660859,
0.1144085824,
-0.7004842758,
-0.8920150399,
0.8571196795,
0.2539388239,
-0.2995727062,
-0.1013044566,
-0.2103972882,
0.4787221551,
-0.6665392518,
0.033605773,
0.4840087891,
0.645616591,
-0.0891902819,
-0.5230658054,
0.1744019985,
0.0094810473,
-0.1988891661,
0.1633932441,
-0.4586240351,
0.9122592211,
-0.1188410372,
-0.2714892924,
-0.2953900695,
0.6778536439,
0.3171665072,
0.2347499281,
0.4100257754,
0.6978025436,
0.7733752728,
-0.0321316756,
1.0123745203,
-0.010000756,
0.2989368141,
0.8754602671,
-0.4224399328,
0.6160241961,
0.374053061,
-0.501486659,
0.7199454904,
0.5052033067,
0.3210711777,
0.7547112107,
0.2014622986,
-0.2610549033,
-0.6979114413,
0.0333121568,
-0.2127692848,
0.4246667922,
0.7834282517,
0.0014293097,
-0.1176429167,
-0.1877111942,
-0.3374880254,
0.157478556,
-0.3261041343,
0.6323566437,
0.0793896466,
-0.8301877379,
0.3143551648,
-0.023699129,
0.2547155321,
-0.3637027144,
-0.2722143233,
0.2568055391,
0.1577361077,
-0.0554295927,
-0.7598973513,
0.2477121353,
-0.2481028289,
-0.3225835562,
-0.1897812784,
0.9719595909,
-0.2137514353,
-0.0707667395,
0.1401366591,
0.5911425352,
0.2301666141,
-0.3915509284,
-0.5653029084,
-0.1437495351,
-0.1590527147,
-0.0194878131,
0.4360753,
0.5673955679,
-0.1963293701,
0.585614264,
0.4624199867,
0.2851048708,
-0.1596861631,
-0.0459563062,
0.7865788937,
-0.8535206318,
-0.8799826503,
-0.8245539069,
0.357743144,
-0.0128356125,
0.0818900764,
0.6013705134,
0.1108955517,
0.7574356794,
-0.1250863969,
1.1691012383,
-0.1544935405,
0.2509109378,
-0.4112129509,
0.7775874734,
-0.3528957963,
0.0674138442,
-0.5028944612,
-1.0894665718,
-0.0228602886,
1.388638258,
-0.3421406746,
-0.2617259622,
0.7907755375,
0.3658903241,
0.3040219247,
0.3720847964,
0.6294597387,
0.2754230499,
0.1381746978,
0.5156780481,
1.3064892292,
-0.1719323993,
-0.2830461264,
-0.1871776581,
-0.4500465989,
0.0333102942,
-0.5847462416,
-0.9273178577,
-0.5350963473,
-0.5404461622,
-0.1111336574,
-0.1077604294,
0.9845907688,
0.4049042165,
-0.6591418982,
-0.3606677055,
-0.4581366181,
0.4331263304,
-0.5103852749,
-0.227188915,
-0.1633296311,
-0.1690246612,
-0.3133060336,
0.5276759863,
0.5033609867,
-0.0054962537,
-0.3257275224,
-0.1958097368,
-0.115758121,
0.2022010535,
0.5433318019,
0.1019163653,
-1.0087908506,
-0.7441407442,
-0.328625381,
0.1004606336,
-0.0310309343,
0.7622693181,
-0.9343716502,
0.3290637732,
0.3342927992,
0.2404135168,
0.2655034065,
0.0170442667,
0.7575808764,
-0.2533365786,
-0.0763942599,
0.236564517,
0.4266459942,
-0.1164066195,
-0.2724587619,
0.4029688537,
0.5722244978,
-0.242344588,
-0.717358768,
0.6554325223,
-0.7285402417,
-0.4209561646,
0.7378613949,
-0.3502771854,
-0.3110709786,
-0.2583104372,
-0.1543783098,
0.3374016285,
-0.4513985217,
0.7000590563,
0.8389384747,
0.0168870296,
0.0035186568,
-0.3763307929,
0.4784173071,
0.317951113,
-0.6121218204,
0.1109136343,
0.6315182447,
0.1408348531,
0.3920994997,
0.5769176483,
0.3801496327,
0.1395222843,
0.5921301246,
-0.1958194822,
0.4132130444,
-0.4436190128,
0.0104626678,
0.2524209619,
0.0363243781,
-0.0926122814
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10412v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10412v2
|
Measuring and Reducing LLM Hallucination without Gold-Standard Answers
| 2024-02-16T02:32:06 | 2024-06-06T18:33:02 |
Jiaheng Wei, Yuanshun Yao, Jean-Francois Ton, Hongyi Guo, Andrew Estornell, Yang Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
LLM hallucination, i.e. generating factually incorrect yet seemingly
convincing answers, is currently a major threat to the trustworthiness and
reliability of LLMs. The first step towards solving this complicated problem is
to measure it. However, existing hallucination metrics require having a
benchmark dataset with gold-standard answers, i.e. "best" or "correct" answers
written by humans. Such requirements make hallucination measurement costly and
prone to human errors. In this work, we propose Factualness Evaluations via
Weighting LLMs (FEWL), an innovative hallucination metric that is specifically
designed for the scenario when gold-standard answers are absent. FEWL leverages
the answers from off-the-shelf LLMs that serve as a proxy of gold-standard
answers. The key challenge is how to quantify the expertise of reference LLMs
resourcefully. We show FEWL has certain theoretical guarantees and demonstrate
empirically it gives more accurate hallucination measures than naively using
reference LLMs. We also show how to leverage FEWL to reduce hallucination
through both in-context learning and supervised fine-tuning. Extensive
experiment results on Truthful-QA, CHALE, and HaluEval datasets demonstrate the
effectiveness of FEWL.
|
[
-0.4726077914,
-0.7014086843,
0.8107841015,
0.0372120552,
-0.0896206573,
-0.1384248883,
-0.1633675694,
-0.453135699,
0.3785079718,
0.4241385758,
-0.7854112983,
-0.6151177287,
-0.4707805216,
0.4750136733,
-0.2549755275,
1.0704088211,
0.2194259465,
0.0983879492,
-0.5144804716,
-0.404535085,
-0.2328329086,
-0.3751431704,
-0.1688396782,
-0.5688045025,
0.6073365211,
0.3955466151,
0.685337007,
0.2369862795,
0.6245230436,
0.1587354392,
-0.0762673393,
0.5924104452,
-0.80301404,
-0.360363096,
0.0318922624,
-0.6193428636,
-0.6018838882,
0.0913619548,
0.2049404383,
0.912065804,
-0.1222676486,
0.4628231823,
0.1578529626,
0.9270682335,
-0.6324861646,
-0.1411749274,
-0.7836558819,
0.3620687723,
-0.0413621888,
-0.5804315805,
-0.3260979354,
-0.5228713751,
-0.1507441849,
-0.5270475149,
0.439712435,
0.1061939523,
0.7149495482,
0.8167315722,
-0.1171957627,
-0.3814525604,
-0.7682239413,
0.8325129151,
-0.6947888732,
0.4741695523,
0.7046422958,
0.2369811833,
-0.0546476617,
-0.4898779392,
-0.4479148388,
-0.4775379598,
-0.3170686364,
0.0874930844,
0.0572686531,
-0.0933521017,
0.4851111472,
0.178391546,
-0.7609121799,
-0.1766620576,
-0.3005657792,
-0.4201152027,
0.5215077996,
0.2579194903,
-0.1004876792,
-0.2052677274,
-0.2827204466,
0.2635553181,
-0.8091083765,
-0.3740415275,
0.2452479303,
0.1700375825,
0.1844572127,
0.6428188682,
-0.1939008087,
0.2935223579,
0.1701952964,
-0.4578488171,
0.2399924248,
-0.3384693563,
-0.2471612543,
0.3541939557,
0.3510840535,
0.3630317748,
0.2351812422,
-0.6983295679,
-0.2665091753,
0.3015941381,
0.3082162738,
-0.7791029215,
-0.3291908205,
0.3544257879,
-0.444742173,
-0.2103185058,
0.0173416957,
-0.6306816339,
-0.6999733448,
-0.2228757739,
0.5614698529,
-0.3573871255,
0.068694599,
0.0832603797,
0.0389729217,
0.2386718243,
0.4165697992,
-0.7362745404,
0.6107727885,
0.685090661,
0.9684458971,
-0.515111804,
-0.1428766549,
-0.8323314786,
-0.0499442928,
-0.5375370383,
0.82514745,
0.0494467169,
-0.3618401885,
-0.2147546411,
-0.1059090719,
0.197655499,
-1.0072559118,
0.7692248821,
-0.4697888196,
-0.0805172995,
-0.6065120697,
-0.690595448,
-0.2046854645,
0.5328797102,
-0.6173945069,
0.8008575439,
-0.0227544177,
-0.6636645794,
0.4617753029,
-0.2702140212,
-0.2877939939,
0.0979206041,
-0.2379126847,
-0.4501765966,
0.3395457268,
0.1838605851,
0.2858196497,
0.0365146734,
0.0829408169,
-0.3783124387,
-0.8290996552,
0.5389081836,
-0.4881487489,
0.5572084785,
0.0814318135,
-0.4146664739,
-0.0541521311,
-0.8394424319,
-0.1191331744,
-0.172175169,
-0.0337629318,
-0.1891204268,
-0.0972474664,
-0.1618005782,
0.0618465617,
0.2270822972,
-0.4283525646,
-0.1646004766,
-0.5243880749,
-0.2349039763,
0.8144496083,
-0.0754620954,
0.2689498961,
-0.7643675208,
0.2198272198,
-0.1426654011,
0.0921399817,
0.5212161541,
-0.2877539694,
-0.950737834,
-0.2317531258,
0.0152311893,
0.5889230371,
-0.3899589479,
0.61281991,
-0.3044990599,
-0.2955223322,
-0.8136583567,
0.6584833264,
0.249545306,
0.6469202042,
0.6072211862,
-0.202185452,
-0.4624825418,
-0.7025738955,
-0.2390910983,
-0.2811208069,
-0.2531566918,
0.3650771081,
0.5925756693,
-0.3031480014,
0.8894681931,
-0.4870110452,
-0.8640586734,
0.071058549,
0.1608148217,
0.1769553423,
0.2051451653,
0.3231570423,
-0.5057423115,
-0.0534618236,
-0.2140351683,
-1.1289558411,
-0.105427362,
-0.2481868714,
0.1112662628,
0.4417084157,
0.2256057262,
-0.6671645641,
0.3619835377,
0.3493262231,
-0.1834825724,
0.6724279523,
-0.0843584612,
0.1733174175,
-0.4492788613,
0.0589573942,
-0.1448809206,
-0.2772970498,
-0.403976351,
-0.1604844183,
-0.1378008127,
0.3643279672,
-0.423203975,
0.4564186931,
-0.1324605197,
-0.3464750051,
-0.1945165545,
0.4099596441,
0.0075777932,
0.3820188642,
0.006329908,
0.6582468152,
0.1236429438,
-0.5720082521,
0.3371023536,
0.3629037738,
-0.3032968342,
0.6665481925,
-0.5420923233,
0.3214459121,
-0.008590417,
0.0548115857,
-0.9624842405,
-0.0666778833,
0.3327047527,
-0.477486968,
-0.1870921999,
0.066888243,
-0.6149260998,
-0.0382289402,
-0.4444188178,
0.1146440357,
0.6317576766,
-0.6487224698,
0.3590933681,
-0.1455369443,
0.1200551614,
-0.4458622038,
-0.90587008,
0.1549617052,
-0.3297540545,
-0.5535674095,
0.3741126955,
-0.5302045345,
-0.4482266307,
-0.0096046757,
-0.6637563109,
0.167815119,
0.1035342067,
0.1304783076,
0.2336651683,
-0.1947313249,
0.1971633583,
-0.1169763505,
-0.3668890297,
0.4051868021,
-0.0938836411,
0.3335427046,
-0.378380686,
-0.6479455829,
-0.6737699509,
-0.1021497324,
0.4565621614,
0.272652179,
0.6514618397,
0.6975764632,
-0.5452489257,
-0.1247076094,
-0.8493981361,
-0.7002680898,
-0.4554891586,
0.1486669332,
-0.384123534,
-0.7397722602,
0.5833334923,
-0.1666360348,
0.1089967415,
0.030304268,
0.5835379362,
-0.1730611473,
0.944717288,
0.2838670909,
0.2238167673,
-0.2048334479,
-0.0861308798,
0.2766048312,
-0.5671655536,
-0.3245587349,
-0.2928857207,
-0.373682797,
-0.5420582891,
-0.4118933976,
0.5256878138,
-0.1102187037,
-0.010157112,
-0.2828146219,
-0.4390091002,
0.5625092387,
0.2005023211,
0.5167794228,
0.7109490037,
0.0211750567,
0.2712076902,
-0.2813298404,
-0.4827739298,
-0.9146951437,
1.0727695227,
0.1573869437,
0.9265865684,
0.064070791,
1.0496901274,
0.4462039769,
0.3001066148,
-0.9518700242,
0.6458982229,
-0.0230370965,
-0.6080352068,
-0.4716663063,
-0.6809851527,
-0.5744715929,
0.2401845306,
-0.3155215979,
-0.6049492955,
-0.0691792294,
0.1431097686,
-0.6832073927,
0.2635467649,
-0.1730944365,
0.5380105376,
-0.3278256953,
-0.5632357597,
-0.1980811208,
-0.5563892126,
0.6286684871,
-0.256029129,
0.0807641596,
-0.2179477811,
-0.1364965737,
0.9325525165,
-0.3495949805,
0.9393550754,
-0.0402422585,
-0.1282529533,
0.1559727341,
0.2481057495,
0.6378877759,
0.3141835928,
-0.1325561702,
0.1746611297,
0.0930673778,
-0.4157218337,
-0.7855604887,
0.9068861008,
-0.8495112062,
-0.5415486097,
-0.4195003808,
-0.5792631507,
-0.3525825441,
-0.0958947316,
0.3603691161,
0.0199354179,
-0.3286652863,
0.0176577289,
1.1603156328,
0.0113455616,
0.1034148782,
0.3070576191,
-0.0239295438,
-0.3726156652,
0.8919644952,
0.3335014284,
0.0182542261,
0.0937137231,
0.331798315,
-0.3740820587,
-0.5138904452,
-0.1830063164,
0.4037975371,
-0.8784572482,
-0.1800473779,
-0.7346166968,
-0.1019817963,
-0.4297105074,
-0.2866377831,
-0.416729629,
-0.4079467952,
-0.4943726957,
-0.3579277396,
0.4299394786,
0.4480516016,
-0.1427118331,
0.0275460463,
-0.6614322662,
0.7903988957,
0.607354939,
0.2386823744,
-0.0755183101,
-0.7121911645,
-0.054203514,
-0.0204008669,
-0.1436654031,
-0.7273102403,
0.3659681082,
0.0949105993,
0.4512134492,
0.6738666296,
0.4710204899,
1.0547825098,
-0.2206215411,
0.8126974106,
0.0493327044,
-0.9745132327,
0.323389709,
0.3572632968,
-0.0904429182,
0.8701504469,
0.2700832486,
-0.333309561,
-0.3670164049,
-0.5456956625,
-0.4718787074,
0.4103026092,
0.3810388148,
-0.0462377742,
0.1258324236,
0.4133193195,
0.4656769931,
0.150755614,
-0.8356970549,
-0.2631275058,
-0.114338398,
-0.1171865687,
-0.0468530916,
-0.2558983564,
-0.5706222653,
-0.3463706076,
0.783980906,
-0.258880794,
0.0338968448,
0.3284273744,
-0.4660982788,
-0.310697794,
0.1028680801,
0.6546244621,
0.8103539348,
-0.5331213474,
0.5049334764,
0.779003799,
-0.2650373578,
0.1416807324,
-0.3497056365,
-0.3203437626,
0.2175993621,
0.5369392633,
0.4461629987,
-0.0173123982,
-0.6718176603,
0.4807463288,
0.0654021353,
-0.366063565,
-0.5755055547,
0.0661298707,
-0.0094869994,
0.1581591964,
0.4051730335,
0.0737508163,
0.2581290603,
-0.2298056483,
0.5427975059,
0.4352081716,
-0.5534830689,
-0.2907522619,
0.6084793806,
0.070733048,
-0.2678450942,
0.7413927913,
-0.3655821979,
-0.1702070981,
0.5086144209,
0.5372007489,
0.9330875874,
0.1417993158,
0.2670494318,
0.2712829411,
0.6703823209,
-0.1108597144,
0.254545629,
0.0069053653,
-0.7185262442,
-0.2149971575,
-0.6442673206,
-0.4690619707,
0.2164546996,
-0.6369014978,
0.2575727403,
-0.5169406533,
-0.1569108814,
-0.504744947,
0.3109980524,
-0.6605345607,
0.0781411082,
0.2541595399,
0.6765466332,
-1.081253767,
0.5201164484,
0.4111717641,
-0.3737923801,
-0.2275928259,
0.2523034811,
0.2264581323,
-0.7344020009,
0.513035953,
0.3358981311,
-0.4979808927,
-0.0570339076,
-0.7845807076,
-0.5118465424,
1.1354571581,
0.402038753,
-0.4604750574,
0.1415048838,
0.205050841,
0.4739244282,
-0.1067094058,
0.0160256643,
0.8765237927,
0.7081630826,
0.2753572464,
-0.5566090941,
0.235093534,
0.1217203215,
-0.2823641598,
-0.2448818535,
-0.5850077271,
0.3282609582,
-0.5208313465,
-0.1999066919,
0.1321428716,
0.7379169464,
0.7422700524,
0.7488455176,
0.5501660705,
0.6414753795,
1.2237461805,
0.0470506214,
0.6238164306,
-0.1374329776,
0.2796847224,
1.0649307966,
-0.5752562881,
0.5202176571,
0.9371736646,
-0.1643944085,
0.1331392527,
0.6642612219,
-0.1196448207,
0.5238063335,
0.3059111536,
-0.3819933832,
-0.6305276155,
-0.0653544217,
-0.1625299454,
0.1150194928,
0.2437558323,
0.1764466316,
-0.1530314684,
0.0143700941,
-0.0367792957,
0.116551213,
-0.0443115681,
0.8366237879,
0.4164819717,
-0.3132067919,
0.9187778234,
-0.3209181726,
0.7841023803,
-0.3778779805,
-0.0502288043,
-0.6999032497,
0.0356930234,
-0.703500092,
-0.2611505389,
0.4120154679,
0.1817695498,
-0.1093387753,
0.0163884684,
0.5119631886,
-0.2562353611,
-0.6827665567,
0.2820286751,
0.7077842951,
0.6141101718,
-0.0346824564,
-0.4140872061,
-0.1256355494,
-0.2979512811,
-0.1489901692,
0.3173588216,
0.5458276868,
0.1925949007,
0.8564506769,
0.6024373174,
0.3490697145,
0.0713726729,
0.1044028997,
0.6292925477,
-0.6206021309,
-0.147389695,
-0.9917973876,
0.0166090932,
0.0658842847,
-0.1392352134,
0.8021637797,
0.5987167954,
0.7156288624,
-0.0337193795,
0.618088603,
0.2242951989,
0.230699718,
-0.676969707,
0.8933134079,
-0.8111894131,
0.603476882,
-0.3026047945,
-0.967192173,
-0.5823385119,
0.8378035426,
-0.0103386519,
-0.1470008343,
0.9343984127,
1.1881227493,
-0.0038317451,
-0.1197156161,
0.7511233687,
0.1730687469,
0.0251199063,
0.5527839065,
0.8533169031,
-0.3394763172,
0.7111417651,
-0.4114844203,
-0.2518524528,
-0.4438571632,
-0.8190186024,
-1.0798801184,
-0.1141975895,
-0.57399261,
-0.5422505736,
0.1771213412,
0.9942219853,
0.4365478158,
-0.9652574062,
-0.2215539068,
0.0718116313,
0.4011188149,
-0.6002966762,
-0.1808748543,
0.5335951447,
-0.52930969,
-0.3785212338,
0.3761372268,
0.2242718637,
0.0079484014,
-0.4186778665,
-0.3951191008,
0.3006635904,
0.2028508782,
0.6092326045,
-0.044746805,
-0.9981099963,
-0.4596771002,
0.3090767264,
-0.2639380693,
0.296299547,
0.5223411918,
-0.9306306839,
0.2038116455,
0.4231858253,
0.6346230507,
0.2827591598,
0.0940581784,
-0.1065127403,
-0.6811777949,
-0.0640977919,
0.4383586049,
0.0720040202,
0.3800462782,
-0.5046679378,
0.6749894619,
0.4838487804,
-0.4944825768,
-0.9279078245,
-0.0030007409,
-1.0184547901,
-0.1810848862,
1.0415809155,
0.0483524539,
-0.2164968252,
-0.2258069217,
-0.0602337122,
0.1986747533,
-0.1807221025,
1.4363207817,
0.715217948,
-0.4800497293,
-0.0520343706,
-0.4913202822,
0.635063231,
0.6240031123,
-0.8741911054,
0.1171833724,
0.5572775602,
0.2219973356,
0.3315740824,
0.6613967419,
-0.0699395984,
0.2769645452,
-0.0275532529,
0.0773344189,
0.051630497,
-0.5025236011,
-0.2895669937,
0.2610776424,
0.1974231303,
-0.0597773418
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10409v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10409v1
|
Understanding Survey Paper Taxonomy about Large Language Models via Graph Representation Learning
| 2024-02-16T02:21:59 | 2024-02-16T02:21:59 |
Jun Zhuang, Casey Kennington
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
As new research on Large Language Models (LLMs) continues, it is difficult to
keep up with new research and models. To help researchers synthesize the new
research many have written survey papers, but even those have become numerous.
In this paper, we develop a method to automatically assign survey papers to a
taxonomy. We collect the metadata of 144 LLM survey papers and explore three
paradigms to classify papers within the taxonomy. Our work indicates that
leveraging graph structure information on co-category graphs can significantly
outperform the language models in two paradigms; pre-trained language models'
fine-tuning and zero-shot/few-shot classifications using LLMs. We find that our
model surpasses an average human recognition level and that fine-tuning LLMs
using weak labels generated by a smaller model, such as the GCN in this study,
can be more effective than using ground-truth labels, revealing the potential
of weak-to-strong generalization in the taxonomy classification task.
|
[
-0.4313643277,
-0.3893695474,
0.5286960602,
-0.3119600415,
-0.3198689818,
0.5155957937,
-0.1789130569,
-0.6421198249,
0.4319594502,
0.6029553413,
-0.0562848561,
-0.718655467,
-0.7391260266,
0.2062633336,
-0.3183538914,
1.1394699812,
-0.0281252973,
-0.0356636085,
-0.4487259984,
-0.0002716642,
0.0410038568,
-0.4950391948,
-0.625074029,
-0.4682739973,
0.9914267659,
0.1507125646,
0.5024774075,
0.69879812,
0.5283002853,
0.3098383546,
-0.1579495072,
0.1959124804,
-0.6613546014,
-0.1842502654,
0.1232638881,
-0.6997485161,
-0.5323159099,
0.1535322666,
0.6033086181,
1.0544309616,
0.059647087,
0.4053013623,
0.2396806628,
0.1195865124,
-0.5041124821,
0.4962406754,
-0.7644881606,
-0.2431970239,
-0.3200399578,
-0.2547062933,
-0.5529597998,
-0.3206828237,
-0.0583869554,
-0.4955120981,
0.3851293027,
0.1237559319,
0.921077311,
-0.1560694128,
-0.7104978561,
-0.3515927494,
-0.5752177238,
0.4391397238,
-0.4412126243,
0.2081955969,
0.4273780584,
0.2136137784,
-0.0681421161,
-0.7954409719,
-0.1198995709,
-0.2177097499,
-0.1154074967,
0.124310106,
-0.1799479574,
0.2011066079,
0.2225476503,
0.3166252077,
-0.6288477182,
0.4532659054,
-0.3455679119,
-0.2780975103,
0.5844572783,
0.279519707,
0.031151114,
-0.2870768905,
-0.0772482529,
-0.0270728283,
-0.6172963977,
-0.0795254707,
0.2382956296,
0.6162711382,
0.0590705536,
0.5036591291,
-0.0073633641,
1.0174610615,
-0.0244177636,
-0.2283993959,
0.2812706232,
-0.1319097131,
-0.1840997189,
-0.3248302937,
0.7365999818,
0.0881412327,
0.1266644746,
-0.3267327845,
-0.2896938622,
0.0362554193,
0.1829655319,
-0.4748782218,
-0.3326746225,
-0.2770550847,
-0.3852784038,
-0.3052152395,
-0.0461046025,
-0.2863349915,
-0.3723441064,
-0.5128427744,
0.252163738,
0.0471372604,
-0.2456459403,
0.0917295814,
-0.1404118091,
0.1625864804,
0.555208981,
-0.9050897956,
0.5353269577,
0.8284754157,
0.8645473719,
-0.2301101983,
-0.1452580243,
-0.2735719681,
0.2497583628,
-0.5074924827,
0.9667075872,
-0.5332677364,
-0.2812156677,
-0.0452788919,
0.0010217181,
-0.1490732431,
-0.6761686802,
0.1581336409,
-0.8008540869,
0.3079961836,
-0.017307438,
-0.5088652372,
-0.1469718814,
0.5825318694,
-0.5983068347,
0.7938911915,
0.3379032612,
-0.7662763,
0.4955615997,
-0.2245251685,
-0.0598727539,
0.1921560913,
-0.1357774734,
-0.5719539523,
0.1880012155,
-0.1021819562,
0.6300259829,
-0.3019653261,
0.2770946324,
-0.5726959705,
-0.1615600586,
0.0075273798,
0.1026735157,
0.953494668,
0.267139703,
0.3489254713,
0.1890556216,
-0.5411297679,
-0.0801854432,
0.1451530308,
-0.4833580852,
-0.6275567412,
-0.1609277278,
-0.0878428966,
0.0580855124,
0.1717738211,
-0.4067336321,
0.5959043503,
-0.3337163925,
0.2623291314,
0.5072792768,
-0.0288363285,
0.4619639814,
-0.3150777519,
0.649330616,
-0.211034745,
-0.1766329855,
0.169021666,
-0.4003804326,
-0.6239275336,
-0.189450562,
0.7325229645,
0.3735203445,
-0.4515774548,
0.3741965592,
-0.6967560649,
-0.638479054,
-0.0738923773,
0.287668705,
0.0712452903,
0.4584411085,
0.0245234668,
-0.6467524171,
-0.5494092703,
-0.7355628014,
0.0174252521,
-0.5876355767,
-0.1551202536,
0.3794510365,
0.6026981473,
-0.2450279593,
0.9335206747,
-0.7760674357,
-0.3345722854,
-0.2362164557,
0.5573427677,
0.1260718703,
-0.0471234545,
0.5300039649,
-0.5023861527,
-0.3733103573,
-0.2161871195,
-0.5426317453,
-0.1874903738,
-0.0047562253,
0.1442761868,
0.0759255663,
0.5499283075,
-0.4005544186,
-0.0228428673,
0.4635487199,
-0.077197656,
0.4339221418,
-0.0488440432,
-0.4927383065,
-1.1191569567,
-0.1501810849,
0.1695459634,
-0.354355067,
-0.3365068436,
0.0510471277,
-0.148134321,
-0.1998817176,
-0.1294481903,
0.4997692108,
-0.7204450369,
-0.1702317595,
-0.2329287231,
0.0296135116,
-0.0459675752,
0.3887022436,
0.1923282743,
0.3557915092,
0.4064832628,
-0.5336599946,
0.1966789663,
0.2108044624,
-0.2378055602,
0.1607347876,
-0.3174046874,
0.2548466027,
-0.4239205122,
0.5833778977,
-1.2137513161,
-0.2489132434,
0.2468990386,
-0.4844872952,
0.3680126667,
-0.3366163671,
-0.5758794546,
-0.5322010517,
-0.1236096546,
0.2698983848,
0.3250186741,
-0.3830710649,
0.6075424552,
0.7766028047,
-0.1348289996,
-0.2029569,
-0.4866037965,
0.2583762109,
-0.3427417576,
-0.3067499697,
0.2249855548,
0.3207531869,
-0.1336551756,
-0.05405977,
0.0215628855,
-0.0551189668,
0.3062008619,
0.1402641088,
0.1185715497,
-0.1993080229,
0.4707083404,
-0.3971554041,
-0.1654881239,
0.2491732538,
-0.3286009133,
0.5845635533,
-0.0689084977,
-0.2853438258,
0.2049802244,
0.0398870669,
0.2125362903,
-0.2932478487,
0.2911480665,
0.4127052724,
-0.3011912704,
-0.1190396696,
-0.1984994709,
-0.091656059,
-0.4166951478,
0.5407342315,
-0.3847086728,
-1.14531672,
0.4724977314,
-0.405026406,
0.0118743014,
0.5639047027,
0.559984982,
-0.2405759692,
0.9771470428,
0.7288925648,
-0.3214333653,
0.3568893671,
-0.4265818,
0.1099316627,
-0.7229289412,
-0.2263585925,
-0.9351063967,
-0.2748139501,
-0.7754454017,
-0.4499929547,
0.4145881832,
0.0529641658,
-0.3371963799,
0.2007078677,
-0.4464871585,
0.384481132,
0.4263110459,
-0.0035110451,
0.4371852577,
0.2359289527,
0.1129034385,
0.1366540939,
-0.8532761335,
-0.5851063728,
1.091381669,
0.4413373172,
1.0799574852,
0.030307278,
1.0923076868,
0.1400756687,
0.6857286692,
-1.0925681591,
0.5501875877,
-0.4089550674,
-0.4795130491,
-0.1923326105,
-0.3994897008,
-1.3022663593,
0.2144281119,
-0.1616248935,
-0.7861671448,
0.1792178899,
0.1747285724,
-0.1464565247,
0.3137382269,
-0.51263237,
0.5465251803,
-0.3726300299,
-0.0535120182,
0.0063831676,
-0.4549181759,
0.3542453051,
-0.0233405773,
0.2310741395,
-0.0412926227,
-0.1424518824,
0.9638572931,
-0.0078325747,
1.1687742472,
-0.1415777802,
-0.3368985653,
0.3046178818,
0.101110734,
0.4531240165,
-0.0259290561,
0.1675222367,
0.1582261026,
-0.0953542218,
-0.2670516372,
-0.5233777165,
0.2276422232,
-0.8797568679,
-0.6388392448,
-0.5534281135,
-0.442972064,
-0.5267467499,
0.3128976524,
0.2430100292,
0.3238048553,
-0.3115574718,
0.1349574476,
0.5419564247,
0.0816200748,
0.0435816161,
0.3900953829,
-0.7069534659,
-0.2360330373,
0.964938283,
0.4513055682,
0.1312089264,
0.5472710133,
0.1710998714,
-0.3993069828,
-0.8337059021,
-0.0464472622,
0.310824126,
-0.7313039899,
-0.3584839702,
-0.6359590292,
-0.2871575356,
-0.4511380792,
0.1001127213,
0.0606502406,
-0.3669249117,
-0.3770007193,
-0.0798518732,
0.2115392089,
0.9032247066,
0.0129497154,
0.463010937,
-0.5493534803,
0.3615838289,
0.5835415125,
0.4717607498,
0.0438932106,
-0.5503099561,
-0.3553337753,
-0.0339633785,
-0.2306105942,
-0.7683667541,
0.0613400079,
0.1591888219,
0.4938660264,
0.3608426154,
-0.1980857998,
0.5506551862,
-0.2396262437,
0.5745239854,
0.2499670237,
-0.5998422503,
0.1134012267,
-0.7683012486,
0.4285775423,
0.4380982816,
0.5508682728,
-0.5926074982,
-0.479416132,
-0.636945188,
-0.7548902631,
0.4858784378,
-0.4161942303,
0.3498521447,
-0.0015923713,
0.3152904212,
-0.0056186481,
0.1007705703,
-0.8434877396,
0.118981868,
0.0026854887,
-0.2086165398,
-0.3911033869,
-0.2516220808,
-0.3127479255,
-0.4507836401,
0.4237958491,
-0.5379803777,
0.2736977637,
-0.3433427215,
-0.2115394026,
-0.0344558395,
0.2661842704,
0.3306849301,
0.8393487334,
-0.262103349,
0.6161726713,
0.1081602201,
-0.3512834013,
0.1902853101,
-0.0010241232,
-0.2612893283,
-0.0119153475,
0.6453522444,
0.846293509,
-0.1621532291,
-0.2077757865,
0.2822181284,
0.0641292185,
-0.4160173237,
-0.1360691488,
0.0839098394,
0.3583734035,
-0.1714784801,
0.3969240189,
-0.0516834185,
0.0293230657,
-0.5946592689,
0.0478619859,
0.7033891082,
-0.2783326507,
-0.2319116741,
0.4293230772,
0.0282306466,
-0.2171238959,
0.3990827501,
-0.2891303599,
-0.5527148247,
0.6116406322,
0.7263296247,
0.7523763776,
0.1020073146,
0.6187382936,
0.3504901528,
0.2518993616,
-0.0391993187,
0.068565473,
0.092703633,
-0.8579528928,
-0.5196807981,
-0.7154061198,
-0.5438332558,
0.3883291483,
-0.6328129172,
0.2726268768,
-0.4632480741,
-0.2311105579,
0.1601420641,
0.1451357156,
-0.556114316,
0.2728119195,
0.492241472,
0.7724493146,
-1.1428319216,
0.6883584261,
0.8920434117,
-0.2679983675,
-0.9826391339,
0.010788559,
0.0449112877,
-0.8123815656,
0.6789907813,
-0.1518675983,
-0.2708143294,
0.1288605034,
-0.817579329,
-0.9668594599,
0.7582299113,
0.4052526951,
-0.6104074121,
-0.1084492952,
0.1484471262,
0.8585489392,
-0.5498383641,
0.2450585812,
0.1137136668,
0.2726663947,
0.1408176124,
-0.8408693671,
-0.0994844735,
-0.1085704491,
0.1611745209,
0.2374203205,
-0.5994352698,
0.833006084,
-0.0129379285,
-0.1783653498,
-0.305654645,
0.6050884724,
0.2284745276,
0.2603551745,
0.6678417325,
0.5937570333,
1.0021992922,
-0.1247798577,
0.8591852188,
0.0569641367,
0.5230015516,
1.1523764133,
-0.2733982205,
0.7258249521,
0.2631069422,
-0.3380877674,
0.557991147,
1.0301281214,
-0.2425570637,
0.3295407891,
0.5839136839,
-0.1256086975,
-0.428298533,
-0.1527799964,
-0.3232566714,
0.8104012609,
0.414653033,
-0.3035551012,
-0.6296249032,
-0.0422402397,
0.1109033525,
-0.0514863618,
-0.6145426035,
1.1186485291,
0.1422369629,
-0.6445057988,
0.8637559414,
-0.0123373782,
0.5284012556,
-0.5413869619,
0.1875878274,
-0.0015762566,
-0.0246650018,
-0.3202185333,
-0.7566767335,
0.3125686944,
-0.1668368876,
-0.0644435585,
-0.3716822267,
0.8439533114,
-0.4407123625,
-0.6309794784,
0.2424963266,
0.7012432218,
0.1553259939,
0.2373178601,
-0.5099545121,
-0.0626680404,
-0.243298009,
-0.0558581725,
0.5037932396,
0.2762393057,
-0.4351147115,
0.5418262482,
0.3120683134,
0.3952608705,
-0.1421595514,
0.1961421669,
0.9477386475,
-0.5624480844,
-0.4705842435,
-0.6759870648,
0.0337311663,
0.0305763781,
-0.2290824503,
0.7806403637,
0.8551366925,
0.9672890902,
-0.084870331,
0.8803591132,
-0.0594829619,
0.5165879726,
-0.4906061292,
0.562584579,
-0.5348909497,
0.1275876164,
-0.1863200814,
-0.8476974368,
-0.71537745,
0.3480594158,
-0.6302480102,
0.0108218873,
0.4418133795,
0.7218999267,
-0.1826110035,
-0.2988133132,
-0.031159088,
0.1187807098,
0.2155966461,
0.5141667128,
0.8521552682,
0.0202237684,
0.5291233659,
0.0605380945,
-0.0640865415,
-0.1465282738,
-0.7717990875,
-0.8523964882,
-0.7456911802,
-0.4154013693,
-0.484949708,
-0.072904326,
0.6689253449,
0.6395243406,
-0.5828285217,
-0.5315128565,
0.1117662638,
0.1244534552,
0.088611953,
-0.1800785959,
0.4181916118,
-0.3380816877,
-0.5491099954,
-0.0568169132,
0.2074435651,
0.0752405822,
-0.3258817494,
-0.0314680599,
-0.2424121648,
-0.2752831876,
0.545142293,
0.3031478524,
-0.5516216755,
-0.4147593975,
-0.0200800076,
-0.3077866733,
0.3414123058,
0.964831531,
-0.8355982304,
0.3484303355,
0.612904489,
0.5825667381,
0.7562393546,
0.0127793942,
0.2103382945,
-0.8203108311,
-0.1202912927,
0.4813174009,
0.2419946939,
0.2791801393,
-0.0878233165,
0.4686036706,
0.2370728403,
-0.3447982967,
-0.8903760314,
0.3759419024,
-1.016669631,
-0.3414322734,
1.1126573086,
0.08035817,
-0.3001765311,
-0.3267210126,
-0.1680548191,
0.3297565877,
-0.0052386755,
0.9513112307,
0.7410883307,
-0.311887145,
-0.4760225117,
-0.1372114718,
0.4036845565,
0.01029862,
-0.7920002937,
-0.0696921945,
0.5715184212,
0.4289775789,
0.4337322116,
1.0235692263,
0.0535122007,
-0.0944004357,
-0.2999437749,
-0.0127168735,
0.0046700179,
-0.1869326532,
-0.3947484493,
0.4882642627,
0.5405630469,
0.15636985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10400v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10400v2
|
Chain of Logic: Rule-Based Reasoning with Large Language Models
| 2024-02-16T01:54:43 | 2024-02-23T18:55:23 |
Sergio Servantez, Joe Barrow, Kristian Hammond, Rajiv Jain
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Rule-based reasoning, a fundamental type of legal reasoning, enables us to
draw conclusions by accurately applying a rule to a set of facts. We explore
causal language models as rule-based reasoners, specifically with respect to
compositional rules - rules consisting of multiple elements which form a
complex logical expression. Reasoning about compositional rules is challenging
because it requires multiple reasoning steps, and attending to the logical
relationships between elements. We introduce a new prompting method, Chain of
Logic, which elicits rule-based reasoning through decomposition (solving
elements as independent threads of logic), and recomposition (recombining these
sub-answers to resolve the underlying logical expression). This method was
inspired by the IRAC (Issue, Rule, Application, Conclusion) framework, a
sequential reasoning approach used by lawyers. We evaluate chain of logic
across eight rule-based reasoning tasks involving three distinct compositional
rules from the LegalBench benchmark and demonstrate it consistently outperforms
other prompting methods, including chain of thought and self-ask, using
open-source and commercial language models.
|
[
-0.1971289217,
-0.9918547869,
1.0412927866,
0.2952670157,
-0.2033281028,
-0.0938187838,
0.0198203828,
-0.2553056777,
-0.0277204961,
0.7764038444,
-0.7627509832,
-0.3531489372,
-0.2644864023,
0.1202809587,
-0.6310994029,
0.8615051508,
-0.1832371205,
0.0658843145,
-0.1977716535,
-0.2362516224,
-0.8306062818,
-0.2703226209,
-0.5822404027,
-0.4222972989,
0.8345559239,
0.3577444553,
0.4551295936,
0.7746289372,
0.41977337,
0.3155756891,
0.0429410525,
0.0537347943,
-0.1834329516,
0.4146672487,
-0.5738050938,
-0.615700841,
-0.1815833002,
-0.085883081,
0.2301215976,
0.7252324224,
-0.5302746296,
-0.0155098988,
-0.7651904821,
0.9165156484,
-0.8358374834,
0.0638323799,
-0.5501895547,
0.0467954762,
0.0503451191,
-0.2796962261,
-0.8231117725,
-0.4674625099,
0.0284217447,
-0.5283259153,
-0.2191654891,
0.3219774067,
0.3494769335,
0.1758767664,
-0.5575800538,
-0.6349059343,
-0.7410469055,
0.5571974516,
-0.6156052351,
0.4980310798,
0.292517066,
0.318626225,
-0.1816378981,
-0.779853344,
-0.6818652153,
-0.3530083299,
-0.039955873,
0.1722554117,
-0.1899767816,
-0.0000944432,
0.5072236657,
0.0819337368,
-0.5088820457,
-0.1157580316,
-0.3712945879,
0.1913814396,
0.6630802751,
0.1451273263,
0.4500725567,
0.1358504146,
-0.2643813491,
0.0408688039,
-0.9489690661,
-0.1779038161,
0.353651166,
0.1094845384,
0.1546093225,
0.4688292146,
-0.3585552871,
0.8657741547,
0.253747195,
-0.1981493831,
-0.2892235219,
-0.2085524648,
-0.1959405541,
0.3852181733,
0.6325333118,
0.3090579212,
0.504961729,
-0.0363436379,
-0.0730141774,
0.0110613517,
0.0147598591,
-0.5210207105,
-0.1821783036,
0.2103247643,
-0.536137104,
-0.1526366025,
0.3342925608,
-0.421315372,
-0.2678478062,
-0.6818165779,
0.4053690732,
-0.2174757719,
-0.1428306997,
0.5785021782,
-0.1600135416,
0.2723440826,
0.5098341703,
-0.7272320986,
0.5423870683,
0.7704222202,
0.4538009465,
0.3008802533,
-0.1726465076,
-0.7627583146,
0.3523483574,
-0.4460180402,
0.918237865,
-0.5330811739,
-0.077997461,
0.0180028956,
-0.1723680794,
-0.0966174752,
-0.5033361316,
0.6310003996,
-0.6782308221,
0.1883214861,
-0.5687900186,
-0.6025446653,
-0.3740680516,
0.2060771435,
-0.7698702216,
0.5021990538,
-0.2133053541,
-0.5064775348,
0.4903072417,
-0.5719829202,
-0.9003975987,
0.0285307709,
-0.2466777116,
0.1296968758,
-0.0339320637,
0.0804916993,
0.2490425408,
-0.6217728257,
0.4941629767,
-0.2391583323,
0.0450223945,
0.2436385006,
-0.102184847,
0.9865269661,
0.4082135856,
-0.5182033181,
0.2916035652,
-0.6614848971,
-0.0772624835,
-0.0529353172,
-0.0930976644,
-0.3378911316,
0.5408293009,
-0.6377843618,
0.5844747424,
-0.1371248811,
-0.2566025257,
0.2716194391,
-0.0238594636,
0.4756062925,
0.825763762,
0.2228072137,
0.1874819696,
-0.5180510879,
0.4131998718,
0.0585783236,
0.1075175032,
-0.3846637905,
-0.5076500773,
-0.7444060445,
-0.0269501507,
0.0026002533,
0.6804693341,
-0.5070737004,
0.6079357862,
0.0247706156,
-0.2613099217,
-0.16422382,
-0.0776615888,
0.2772416174,
0.5508765578,
0.3257392645,
0.0503031313,
-0.5892077088,
-0.6349257231,
-0.3928856254,
-0.484046191,
0.3100627959,
-0.0937871411,
0.7137156129,
0.0359627791,
0.7539161444,
-0.5634929538,
0.127162233,
-0.3503085077,
0.2953638732,
0.2453291267,
0.0801243857,
0.1556603014,
-0.531793952,
-0.4088761508,
0.0738209337,
-0.8292255998,
-0.4389041066,
-0.2857030034,
-0.2573576272,
-0.1058555841,
0.8760456443,
-0.4425852597,
0.4363139868,
-0.0490100645,
-0.5801417828,
0.9509409666,
-0.1003211737,
0.2165444046,
-0.494692862,
0.0192215946,
-0.129191041,
-0.2038493901,
-0.4232031405,
0.2470552921,
-0.3750733733,
0.1116899773,
-0.3220074475,
0.3620995581,
-0.3058428168,
0.2208968699,
-0.4059622884,
-0.0038019961,
0.1168128029,
0.2531063259,
0.0819887072,
0.3987712562,
0.5447425246,
-0.6812502146,
0.8211547136,
0.0153420372,
-0.3129936457,
0.8334636092,
-0.6716192961,
-0.0663773343,
-0.2687589526,
0.5302115679,
-0.6692426801,
-0.1006328762,
0.3520826995,
0.3238597512,
-0.2567213774,
-0.1021869406,
-0.8016636372,
-0.4918167293,
0.0393403396,
0.4760076404,
0.4250200987,
-0.4524459541,
0.799859643,
-0.0743479058,
0.110547021,
-0.359909296,
-0.525914073,
-0.1279614419,
-0.106791757,
-0.6411724687,
0.0316729397,
-0.2490202934,
-0.9080930948,
0.1604465395,
-0.2046745569,
-0.0505972691,
-0.0106900884,
0.219689399,
-0.121994026,
-0.1664353013,
0.0454158522,
0.1114578694,
0.0226077288,
0.6741190553,
-0.4368363321,
0.4253888428,
-0.1186585873,
-0.6171390414,
-0.4660567641,
0.6991829872,
0.6747758985,
-0.3741805255,
0.5702700019,
-0.2476238906,
-0.1873575449,
-0.4349956512,
-0.674058795,
-0.2218521535,
-0.3869948387,
-0.3588303924,
-0.4986837208,
-0.6779902577,
0.6390499473,
-0.2184564322,
-0.1476189792,
0.5560383201,
0.5695641637,
0.1245946586,
0.9960935116,
0.0650927201,
0.0665903687,
0.3288162053,
0.0933688432,
0.4129336476,
-0.2665696442,
-0.345572859,
-0.4965621233,
0.0054194327,
-0.3019915819,
-0.1599090546,
0.1501819491,
0.1314736605,
-0.4213359952,
0.2793847024,
-0.1586352885,
0.8820984364,
0.5812357664,
0.1688874662,
0.3862633109,
-0.2911459506,
-0.4362998009,
0.6212195754,
-0.6481829286,
-0.2049771547,
0.6585492492,
-0.0128034027,
0.9203736782,
0.2458191812,
0.5361559391,
0.2730074525,
-0.0277031399,
-0.8201147914,
0.8582466245,
0.0366538502,
-0.813352406,
0.0363964811,
-0.5846617222,
-0.6190380454,
0.0847402439,
-0.0844447166,
-0.8380981088,
0.0674001649,
-0.0853854194,
-0.4417483509,
0.3947938979,
-0.525695622,
0.6589564085,
-0.2633492649,
-0.4113210142,
-0.4618941545,
-0.8942381144,
0.6215916276,
0.111618638,
0.302538842,
-0.1383361369,
0.5134732723,
0.5810154676,
-0.9795528054,
0.6746617556,
0.1304821372,
-0.2617995441,
0.8088256121,
0.4166364074,
0.5698077083,
-0.2885586917,
0.0616899878,
-0.4964745045,
0.2006682903,
-0.0181179997,
-1.0473451614,
0.5336554646,
-0.2312490642,
-0.6036058664,
-0.4502413571,
-0.321125567,
0.1627021879,
0.3102316558,
0.0125052053,
0.5123643279,
0.1719834656,
0.0128193451,
0.5586813688,
0.1705897897,
0.2203979492,
0.4939697683,
-0.293802917,
-0.3702107966,
0.6604496837,
-0.070604153,
0.2829216719,
0.5888478756,
0.6482880712,
-0.4494200349,
-0.0828498527,
-0.1211619005,
0.3102505505,
-1.0460609198,
-0.0842655897,
-0.4227852821,
-0.1546036303,
-0.2143763751,
-0.308845818,
-0.0873459801,
-0.3126657903,
0.1683561802,
-0.1138795614,
0.347053647,
0.8809047341,
-0.0876293108,
0.0703293756,
-0.5850317478,
0.3512436748,
0.7024083734,
0.3274545074,
0.1384452283,
-0.0205780342,
0.1473912448,
-0.2678022981,
-0.0644495338,
-0.9746575952,
-0.1890503913,
-0.2548345029,
0.4578225911,
0.759196341,
0.1963222176,
0.7868022323,
-0.8295203447,
0.4992562234,
0.3502429724,
-1.1176815033,
0.923954308,
-0.5500943065,
0.0760413483,
0.5971139073,
0.2453365922,
-0.6958747506,
-0.3954518735,
-0.6324753761,
-0.6327509284,
0.342787981,
0.0028217726,
-0.313977778,
-0.3672049344,
0.522323966,
-0.0214408562,
0.1311027855,
-0.6620203853,
-0.1266054511,
0.0841353759,
-0.1718203425,
0.6701373458,
-0.1671142131,
-0.2160538584,
-0.3845196962,
0.6317169666,
-0.0107461326,
-0.0681314245,
0.248220697,
-0.0680920482,
-0.1971098334,
0.3744074702,
0.8801890612,
0.9911379218,
-0.0465997383,
0.370308727,
-0.131632179,
0.1027718186,
0.4371380806,
-0.2706032395,
-0.1949690431,
-0.3095940053,
0.5975333452,
0.5879881382,
0.0232207719,
-0.8005515337,
0.4387934208,
0.0000166955,
-0.5076541305,
-0.1566425115,
0.1396402568,
-0.1121257693,
0.2544893622,
0.2104820758,
-0.1356476396,
0.3403474092,
-0.7772721648,
0.3823012114,
0.0586172752,
-0.2888321877,
-0.1426133662,
0.7484001517,
0.0670300052,
-0.0510044359,
0.6141272783,
-0.0810447484,
-0.4749481678,
0.4980813861,
0.6191359162,
0.7079556584,
0.0009383577,
0.2300196439,
0.2587525249,
0.2088695019,
-0.6894543767,
0.4000397325,
-0.1445574015,
-0.727719903,
-0.9057304859,
-0.0560570434,
-0.3881421685,
-0.250312835,
-0.6010905504,
0.0949847102,
-0.7997409701,
0.2105454952,
0.0142819062,
-0.3267650604,
-0.2665143907,
0.1842997521,
-0.0933774486,
1.008251667,
-0.9659500718,
0.359936744,
0.4465755522,
-0.7372886539,
-1.1124228239,
-0.0934460238,
0.2281983942,
-0.4773762822,
0.9671747088,
0.1655153036,
-0.5341174603,
-0.1603461653,
-0.7763118744,
-0.37479949,
0.8072713017,
0.276227206,
-0.5237067342,
0.2091889083,
-0.1744841188,
0.3511965573,
-0.3632018566,
0.2771925628,
0.5539223552,
0.6407868266,
0.5306682587,
-0.5085813403,
0.4528592527,
-0.2349134684,
-0.3096091747,
0.3378661275,
-0.4188554883,
0.8216735125,
-0.2395907491,
-0.1460495293,
0.0220174864,
0.5350953937,
0.5523326397,
0.2355313748,
0.649564147,
0.7751244903,
0.8184777498,
-0.063009277,
1.1048020124,
-0.2991073132,
0.0286702905,
1.2230647802,
-0.7071500421,
0.5632836819,
0.4527470767,
0.0178371593,
1.3835784197,
0.2005566359,
0.0661839247,
0.4377838075,
0.5246082544,
-0.6340138912,
-0.4944836199,
-0.2930643857,
-0.1393816471,
0.3878371716,
0.102601245,
-0.3745540082,
-0.2217184156,
-0.3003887534,
0.0525370426,
0.1633609235,
-0.3788467348,
0.7649187446,
0.0025484727,
-1.0023818016,
-0.068644993,
0.1391979754,
-0.2000900805,
-0.5951556563,
-0.2753299177,
-0.0036578251,
0.2186058164,
-0.2128724903,
-0.8446522951,
0.1836245358,
-0.1115395129,
-0.3195511401,
-0.3376775384,
0.6817007065,
-0.2909354866,
-0.4225664139,
0.3120257854,
0.4614587426,
0.0507821739,
0.0204363167,
-0.5714299083,
-0.0884419307,
-0.3765947819,
0.1717513055,
-0.3214807808,
0.8653771281,
-0.4650201201,
0.8339096904,
0.7973744273,
0.086403437,
0.0959148705,
0.4867155254,
0.778947711,
-0.7803163528,
-0.5945452452,
-1.0760549307,
0.6374079585,
0.0136089912,
0.0505177416,
0.5469588637,
0.4218990505,
0.607376039,
-0.051786162,
0.6004234552,
-0.1421849281,
0.2056071758,
-0.8641186953,
0.2647737563,
-0.2106044441,
0.1067840531,
-0.2556895912,
-0.572168231,
-0.5832075477,
0.6980226636,
-0.4629220963,
0.1084544361,
1.1201223135,
0.4962927103,
0.0348196812,
0.2643593848,
0.1255909503,
0.0179433487,
0.3899535537,
0.4919601381,
1.0800238848,
-0.2070596814,
0.2384169996,
0.1305634677,
-0.0769684538,
-0.139790222,
-1.0230563879,
-0.7965407372,
-0.3449783921,
-0.4837291539,
-0.3776751161,
-0.0071185306,
0.9875721335,
0.6404213905,
-0.7840772867,
-0.5418794155,
-0.8013485074,
0.5139293075,
-0.5250678062,
-0.2105270922,
0.0966625512,
-0.3277493417,
0.0743375644,
0.4306483269,
0.4081164002,
-0.3342359662,
-0.0547315739,
-0.0724948645,
-0.7081615925,
0.2990792692,
0.7548004985,
0.4263879657,
-0.8850334287,
-0.3713492453,
-0.2346283346,
0.1838584244,
-0.1270289719,
1.3878991604,
-0.5729748011,
0.5202173591,
0.8354629874,
0.3383015692,
0.2876062393,
0.0135688614,
0.7823593616,
-0.4012138844,
0.0187561624,
0.0178073514,
0.5694336295,
-0.2597092688,
0.0109755667,
0.5319946408,
0.3846215606,
-0.4456892908,
-0.3802390397,
0.6722396016,
-0.9370891452,
-0.5351457,
1.0018752813,
-0.0296784155,
-0.3882953823,
0.0538879894,
-0.1793007404,
0.0279136766,
-0.2840619683,
0.4126506448,
0.8339772224,
-0.2156531811,
-0.4043768644,
-0.2848951221,
0.1162323952,
0.1187617332,
-1.0096999407,
0.0403746553,
0.771713078,
0.3128853142,
0.1496621519,
0.6462110281,
-0.0909092054,
0.2371789813,
0.0154130282,
-0.0794734731,
0.1473779529,
-0.6559919119,
-0.002356475,
0.0614177398,
-0.1253035367,
0.2285291404
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10380v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10380v1
|
Subgraph-level Universal Prompt Tuning
| 2024-02-16T00:25:24 | 2024-02-16T00:25:24 |
Junhyun Lee, Wooseong Yang, Jaewoo Kang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In the evolving landscape of machine learning, the adaptation of pre-trained
models through prompt tuning has become increasingly prominent. This trend is
particularly observable in the graph domain, where diverse pre-training
strategies present unique challenges in developing effective prompt-based
tuning methods for graph neural networks. Previous approaches have been
limited, focusing on specialized prompting functions tailored to models with
edge prediction pre-training tasks. These methods, however, suffer from a lack
of generalizability across different pre-training strategies. Recently, a
simple prompt tuning method has been designed for any pre-training strategy,
functioning within the input graph's feature space. This allows it to
theoretically emulate any type of prompting function, thereby significantly
increasing its versatility for a range of downstream applications.
Nevertheless, the capacity of such simple prompts to fully grasp the complex
contexts found in graphs remains an open question, necessitating further
investigation. Addressing this challenge, our work introduces the
Subgraph-level Universal Prompt Tuning (SUPT) approach, focusing on the
detailed context within subgraphs. In SUPT, prompt features are assigned at the
subgraph-level, preserving the method's universal capability. This requires
extremely fewer tuning parameters than fine-tuning-based methods, outperforming
them in 42 out of 45 full-shot scenario experiments with an average improvement
of over 2.5%. In few-shot scenarios, it excels in 41 out of 45 experiments,
achieving an average performance increase of more than 6.6%.
|
[
-0.5331399441,
-0.80267483,
0.2729000747,
-0.0112455888,
-0.561748445,
-0.0411184952,
-0.1362143755,
0.0261036102,
0.0855934918,
0.0243340414,
-1.1697356701,
-0.516006887,
-0.3550171256,
0.3262179196,
0.1989605725,
1.0547481775,
0.3167369664,
-0.0825380161,
-0.1212820709,
-0.1475185603,
-0.749987185,
-0.3393794596,
-0.9420881867,
-0.3528490663,
0.9271057844,
0.4037753344,
0.5075278282,
0.5647343397,
-0.0287157986,
0.2526418269,
-0.1762972027,
0.3860163093,
-0.6693285108,
-0.1036527082,
-0.2699623704,
-0.1526379287,
-0.2368747592,
0.0926686302,
0.3296548724,
0.8308464289,
0.2612475455,
0.1384714097,
0.3581555784,
0.5839596987,
-0.6162852049,
0.1911403537,
-0.6805866957,
0.1375710517,
-0.1055038497,
-0.554484129,
-0.5658605695,
-0.1007560194,
0.0739372522,
-1.0241719484,
0.5306863785,
0.2156900018,
0.8319834471,
0.3107181191,
-0.3889540434,
0.1466216892,
-0.0913363993,
0.1859032363,
-0.3273420632,
0.0800563395,
0.0897316709,
0.2288523465,
-0.397928834,
-0.8500093222,
-0.0769946948,
-0.0341953821,
-0.1912222803,
0.2814460695,
-0.5371802449,
0.4705683887,
0.6791155338,
-0.1666190475,
-0.4967442155,
0.4912230372,
0.0132105509,
-0.4488729537,
0.3161198795,
0.1938082725,
0.2763002813,
-0.1654534936,
-0.0928196386,
-0.0354954153,
-0.7000856996,
0.5638045073,
0.4046571255,
0.9433466792,
0.085008204,
0.1528336406,
-0.3157055676,
0.9401834011,
0.1873043478,
0.3719935715,
0.0827997103,
-0.5061469674,
-0.2140839249,
-0.0793548748,
0.7221235037,
0.3559988737,
0.7398804426,
0.1739033014,
0.0810796991,
-0.0669979826,
0.1187960953,
-0.7307055593,
-0.5097593665,
-0.2411183119,
-0.1671853364,
-0.1576883495,
-0.2447391748,
-0.487518996,
-0.5717254877,
-0.4022627175,
0.3368055522,
-0.6165271997,
0.0500264652,
-0.210311085,
-0.3619380891,
-0.0086209737,
0.3923642635,
-0.9408609271,
-0.0510540083,
0.2496467382,
0.8049977422,
0.0651824772,
-0.4216758013,
-0.9377137423,
-0.2387669533,
-0.5321887136,
0.9465891719,
-0.637057066,
-0.5131874681,
-0.136606887,
0.1984616071,
-0.4671962261,
-0.2225057036,
0.4044129848,
-0.3251354992,
0.0250245742,
-0.5913318396,
-0.2895426452,
0.0060350066,
-0.1336219013,
-0.2370201051,
0.881414175,
0.4796156287,
-0.8328408003,
0.6253288388,
-0.7516784668,
-0.8202934861,
0.2053787708,
-0.0489814803,
-0.4897638857,
0.2020319551,
0.849075377,
0.3752032518,
-0.0703005344,
-0.1469212174,
-0.3749126196,
-0.5960456133,
-0.0806124657,
-0.1834208667,
0.7158706188,
0.0496970303,
-0.0671139583,
0.7504329681,
-0.5447661877,
0.2209255695,
-0.0155247496,
0.271605432,
-0.2627399862,
-0.5510079265,
-0.4758688807,
-0.056482017,
0.0095472988,
-0.3903364539,
0.3779027164,
-0.3329046667,
0.7655101418,
0.9550768733,
0.297790736,
0.3926585317,
0.0345202796,
0.6394839287,
-0.0034276899,
0.293389082,
-0.5990757346,
-0.4234159291,
-0.4013687074,
-0.4502838552,
0.7838516235,
0.6002684832,
-0.5024587512,
0.6505683661,
0.0578122139,
-0.3187796175,
-0.3444252312,
-0.0213559568,
0.3865379691,
1.1899373531,
0.5155806541,
-0.0918388739,
-0.5989020467,
-0.6990430355,
-0.3972130418,
0.1456215531,
-0.1128787473,
0.7211918831,
0.0984869003,
-0.0162714049,
1.0980603695,
-0.3751311004,
-0.3950698376,
-0.5836190581,
0.1124038175,
0.5668923855,
0.3520789146,
0.6222316027,
-0.3738965988,
-0.5665402412,
-0.2305502295,
-0.5943076611,
-0.425060153,
-0.0911393836,
-0.0689308047,
-0.0504148975,
0.6710674763,
-0.5294860005,
0.6344825625,
0.0661088452,
-0.3375587165,
0.3088331819,
-0.4420492649,
0.0576975718,
-0.7876855135,
-0.1484969705,
0.0711720139,
-0.2162861377,
-0.2400895357,
-0.2647862434,
0.1946067363,
-0.4205969572,
-0.3276674151,
0.4092532992,
-0.4518647194,
-0.0879065618,
-0.1233497337,
0.150071919,
-0.0707759857,
0.6088692546,
-0.4819710255,
0.8134788275,
1.0590974092,
-0.8569358587,
0.3015977144,
0.1393610835,
0.0023635956,
0.6653729081,
-0.9760810733,
0.2936831117,
-0.3596771657,
0.4737637639,
-1.4408807755,
-0.2240523249,
0.2027728558,
-0.6093989611,
0.4325771034,
-0.5352067351,
-0.2688086927,
-0.5641472936,
0.0105436603,
0.2930833697,
0.7011594772,
-0.6318307519,
0.6903166175,
-0.1028276607,
0.0298285037,
-0.4374752343,
-0.0440073609,
-0.2272284329,
-0.0911618918,
-0.5161404014,
0.0846396014,
0.0301006455,
0.5637162328,
-0.2025912851,
-0.2615718544,
0.5618494153,
0.2414567918,
0.3908925056,
0.0515465178,
-0.0096422434,
-0.0274382606,
0.5800333023,
-0.6889930367,
-0.4217721224,
-0.6405242085,
0.7409306765,
0.0026031444,
-0.2070335448,
-0.6971622109,
0.0220897216,
0.0087203113,
-0.2488689423,
0.2259082794,
0.5337248445,
-0.0673374534,
-0.4726854563,
0.3053995967,
-0.234411642,
-0.5731300116,
0.5153739452,
-0.6935991049,
-0.8148166537,
0.608404398,
-0.6625956297,
-0.1290099174,
0.341599822,
0.265530169,
-0.4498544633,
1.2667747736,
0.6455885768,
0.0293723103,
0.6919335127,
-0.2970661819,
-0.0061533498,
-0.8142057061,
-0.0746814162,
-0.5443972945,
-0.7851442695,
-0.2852419913,
0.2084883004,
0.7193532586,
0.3467978537,
-0.4228584468,
0.4007696807,
-0.659855485,
0.7888585329,
0.7411267757,
0.139341116,
-0.1478714794,
0.0813842416,
-0.6042710543,
-0.0876159295,
-1.0515578985,
0.0957617685,
0.7406515479,
0.0401593521,
0.7459051609,
-0.5468660593,
0.3946683705,
0.3911143839,
0.0743153691,
-0.5557195544,
0.664098978,
-0.2639844418,
-0.0631796122,
-0.7866183519,
-0.416261524,
-1.3419783115,
0.1513836831,
-0.150159508,
-0.908836782,
0.0603011027,
0.6627672315,
-0.5055248737,
0.0351760909,
-0.733237505,
1.1244337559,
0.0418763869,
0.1127667427,
0.2289876789,
-0.8353886008,
-0.2829446793,
0.3325274289,
-0.1521862149,
-0.2838790417,
0.1657151729,
0.3424293697,
-0.3090434074,
1.0455392599,
-0.531893611,
0.1573387086,
0.122747913,
0.1587995887,
0.6132096648,
0.3244418204,
0.0698466226,
0.1491189748,
-0.2267862558,
-0.4569782019,
-0.8239661455,
0.3960924149,
-0.9828668833,
-0.4501338899,
-0.0485853814,
-0.5133503079,
-0.5889571905,
0.6256169081,
1.1004878283,
0.8066164851,
-0.0050807325,
-0.0933509022,
0.6428436041,
-0.0390027612,
0.5763065219,
0.2019811571,
-0.025951745,
-0.4728961885,
0.7960321307,
0.096362412,
-0.0065864418,
0.3345189393,
0.4266852736,
-0.5310491323,
-0.4776290655,
-0.8050168753,
-0.00466135,
-0.6526151896,
-0.3874857128,
-0.5273812413,
-0.1661109328,
-0.7164097428,
-0.2926726043,
-0.0695381314,
-0.2557834089,
-0.6712302566,
-0.3247129917,
0.4401196241,
0.134973377,
-0.0313109085,
0.5440325141,
-0.4671235979,
0.2697715759,
0.3370012939,
0.2411194891,
-0.3482642472,
-0.7155604959,
0.0933318362,
-0.0735751837,
-0.020266233,
-0.6746145487,
-0.0017043356,
0.5386921763,
0.6258487105,
0.2398269773,
0.3097990155,
0.7327642441,
-0.4912285805,
0.5392240286,
0.2253457457,
-0.9436805248,
0.9272696972,
-0.5116436481,
0.4953276813,
0.7468349338,
0.4480310082,
-0.3571684361,
-0.0574591458,
-0.4655000269,
-0.8166253567,
0.7784893513,
-0.2404465824,
0.3627386987,
0.2459842861,
0.5754773617,
0.1353682727,
0.1652137786,
-0.2772623301,
-0.2048987299,
-0.6200063825,
-0.2342899591,
-0.2487524599,
0.2819790542,
-0.2953959405,
-0.5752674341,
0.2489569634,
-0.8149300814,
-0.0104988189,
0.2308155149,
-0.0473136231,
-0.2214387655,
0.1047957763,
0.4007499218,
0.895291388,
0.0780007616,
0.16140306,
0.4578672051,
-0.1596084386,
0.2003704756,
0.1334931105,
-0.5689589381,
-0.1752349734,
0.4223333001,
1.2835245132,
0.0653238893,
-0.2060387433,
0.474799782,
-0.1248722523,
-0.2793702781,
0.1301587075,
0.5773881078,
-0.1813479364,
0.078221418,
0.3939424455,
0.2517320812,
-0.1955010593,
-0.3231633306,
0.2075106651,
0.470064193,
-0.8503255844,
-0.3546014428,
0.6365724206,
0.1885156333,
-0.5334839821,
0.9191767573,
-0.2016910315,
-0.3467341065,
0.7135797739,
0.8247725368,
0.8772434592,
0.0643561631,
0.35351035,
0.411498785,
0.2085645199,
0.5410232544,
0.2498175949,
-0.1235884875,
-0.702827692,
-0.2064312845,
-0.3656357825,
-0.1146208793,
-0.1027421653,
-0.5628294349,
0.2245166004,
-0.7648536563,
-0.3724372089,
-0.0635225102,
-0.1143076867,
-0.6519265175,
0.2481033206,
-0.1714912951,
1.2085833549,
-0.8108730316,
0.5632005334,
0.8597445488,
-0.1640775949,
-0.9367853403,
-0.1088002846,
-0.1827898175,
-0.9120519757,
0.2475794405,
0.2387440801,
-0.0897451639,
0.5722373128,
-0.7919718027,
-0.6658737063,
0.9400764704,
0.6305497885,
-0.481814146,
-0.0534273684,
-0.1439578235,
0.6019486785,
-0.5310836434,
0.3074322343,
0.5866149068,
0.3581530154,
0.2989442647,
-0.6845905185,
0.3164614439,
-0.3195289373,
0.2864966094,
0.1120298803,
-0.9103218317,
0.8904717565,
-0.5646894574,
-0.2948445976,
-0.0963818431,
0.7902752161,
0.4435167015,
0.314332664,
0.7742812037,
0.3437568545,
0.9528520107,
-0.2462214231,
0.9575949907,
-0.41264382,
0.0888774768,
0.8033712506,
-0.0575011261,
-0.0793273523,
0.0462332182,
0.0411646739,
0.3863236904,
1.274520874,
0.0593169108,
0.7451079488,
0.3476311564,
0.2805918157,
-0.668775022,
-0.3113394976,
-0.5466744304,
0.0515956692,
0.1930352896,
-0.0484247282,
-0.2998800576,
0.0434568785,
-0.2163256556,
-0.1304955781,
-0.6726511717,
0.7724883556,
0.0710713193,
-0.7547268867,
0.4968852103,
-0.2748199403,
0.3019201159,
-0.8246700764,
0.0960363001,
-0.4746620655,
-0.1377391368,
-0.1696637422,
-0.4743220508,
-0.3614937365,
-0.4257410765,
-0.0733453631,
-0.161988914,
0.7602142096,
0.1474318653,
-0.1704600304,
0.2352345139,
0.3200696111,
-0.2027799487,
0.0948394015,
-0.7207465768,
-0.0964454561,
-0.0343381837,
-0.2344131172,
0.5175313354,
0.8200340271,
0.0370436348,
0.557477057,
0.778986454,
-0.0854703858,
-0.1627812684,
0.5875765085,
1.0582755804,
-0.6258038282,
-0.9777371883,
-0.787119925,
0.4567472339,
-0.0724875107,
-0.9682891369,
0.7896772623,
0.2832056582,
0.6721016169,
0.1299104095,
0.8354535103,
0.164483577,
0.3311521709,
-0.6726713181,
0.3433336318,
-0.461761266,
-0.0454102457,
-0.4646244347,
-0.766017437,
-0.2543955445,
0.4332410395,
-0.1376950145,
0.3173601329,
0.5230184197,
0.6558734775,
-0.1450781673,
0.2192540765,
0.268328011,
-0.0257755108,
0.1611980796,
0.4698694944,
0.852304399,
0.0202652607,
0.4782592952,
0.0763597935,
-0.5146682262,
-0.1804402322,
-1.0010410547,
-1.1090470552,
-0.3019892871,
-0.0884494931,
-0.3874297738,
0.0258602109,
0.7530540228,
0.8867000341,
-0.7351992726,
0.3720888793,
-0.2969615459,
0.1485412419,
-0.4524527788,
-0.1347837001,
0.4290658236,
-0.775428772,
-0.4087916315,
0.6343509555,
0.4062318206,
0.0963117108,
0.1185627803,
0.0896168649,
0.3065464199,
0.0792206451,
0.3142679632,
0.5237857699,
-0.1720253974,
-0.518899262,
0.2011336535,
0.0537243485,
0.0740151182,
1.1870061159,
-0.9497861862,
0.3629907072,
0.5628620982,
0.4557530284,
0.6124068499,
0.3905241489,
0.5549532175,
-1.3053210974,
0.2198485881,
0.056834992,
0.421410799,
0.074877888,
-0.5380606651,
0.4798606038,
0.5474426746,
-0.3843738437,
-0.7286188602,
0.5643266439,
-0.8289638758,
-0.4110597372,
0.7454062104,
-0.1136043146,
-0.2691586912,
-0.1169528291,
-0.4114061892,
0.4750221074,
-0.4902645051,
0.4290021658,
0.1113418266,
-0.8471308947,
-0.1696574539,
0.1957844049,
0.6589323878,
0.2736223638,
-0.5332999229,
0.0403273739,
0.3924856186,
0.2392293215,
-0.0906186178,
0.9585205913,
0.3574010134,
0.3830753565,
-0.054006137,
-0.440777272,
-0.6491740942,
-0.8120746613,
-0.3902337849,
0.340324074,
-0.2698037028,
-0.152970165
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10379v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10379v2
|
DataDreamer: A Tool for Synthetic Data Generation and Reproducible LLM Workflows
| 2024-02-16T00:10:26 | 2024-05-27T19:54:44 |
Ajay Patel, Colin Raffel, Chris Callison-Burch
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have become a dominant and important tool for
NLP researchers in a wide range of tasks. Today, many researchers use LLMs in
synthetic data generation, task evaluation, fine-tuning, distillation, and
other model-in-the-loop research workflows. However, challenges arise when
using these models that stem from their scale, their closed source nature, and
the lack of standardized tooling for these new and emerging workflows. The
rapid rise to prominence of these models and these unique challenges has had
immediate adverse impacts on open science and on the reproducibility of work
that uses them. In this paper, we introduce DataDreamer, an open source Python
library that allows researchers to write simple code to implement powerful LLM
workflows. DataDreamer also helps researchers adhere to best practices that we
propose to encourage open science and reproducibility. The library and
documentation are available at https://github.com/datadreamer-dev/DataDreamer .
|
[
0.0669520274,
-0.5065028071,
0.3842199743,
0.392806977,
-0.0847529545,
-0.0425939225,
-0.2844444215,
-0.2723579109,
0.2169580758,
0.7268753648,
-0.3406897485,
-0.4620148838,
-0.372076124,
0.2589477301,
-0.7456564903,
0.9542348981,
-0.3745429814,
-0.0458095483,
-0.3075000346,
0.1180586368,
0.0863258615,
-0.8120940328,
-0.5418977141,
-0.4440506399,
0.7940319777,
0.1552333236,
0.9441021681,
0.7522069216,
0.7538478374,
0.244306609,
0.0309894569,
0.1386886984,
-0.6882665157,
0.6049670577,
-0.3322883546,
-0.4291530848,
-0.3175157309,
-0.0921382159,
0.655649364,
0.7151200771,
-0.4537608624,
0.3726632297,
-0.2360545844,
0.689776063,
-0.4144363999,
0.1480450928,
-0.7139521837,
0.0273446478,
-0.6989722848,
-0.21196872,
-0.1442261636,
-0.7650651932,
0.1507559419,
-0.3971346915,
0.5042151809,
0.087431863,
0.4540105164,
0.3694183528,
0.2155892551,
-0.1987737119,
-1.168174386,
0.7306697369,
-0.8465721011,
0.3292381167,
0.1209728718,
0.4830199182,
-0.6754150391,
-0.9189668298,
-0.7796653509,
0.0686215535,
0.1745216399,
-0.3585646152,
-0.505620122,
-0.2529977858,
0.3808116615,
0.4450788796,
-0.6168762445,
0.1105175987,
-0.7409754992,
0.1019762531,
0.5467792749,
0.5532812476,
0.0354518741,
0.2133837938,
0.1574269831,
0.0693942308,
-0.7658101916,
-0.3862915039,
0.3623551428,
0.316931814,
0.062212307,
0.9601008296,
-0.168983072,
0.7029306293,
-0.3411974311,
-0.0170920547,
0.285884887,
-0.0923506469,
-0.2746590376,
0.0795090273,
0.8698780537,
0.1750890315,
0.1394934356,
-0.3779059649,
-0.2215298712,
0.0854205415,
0.3412024975,
-0.9228636026,
-0.2855382264,
0.6813959479,
-0.1867506802,
-0.5020383,
-0.160589844,
-0.7975206375,
-0.4437873363,
-0.3218224049,
-0.0354951695,
-0.1145431027,
-0.4233874083,
0.2550557256,
-0.1783214808,
0.0934228078,
0.4470973313,
-0.6101702452,
0.1329710484,
0.9026340246,
1.238620162,
-0.4517471492,
-0.43740049,
-0.0929211453,
0.0161028057,
-0.6396312714,
0.3482876122,
-0.4737195671,
-0.1103524417,
-0.0305870753,
-0.0082359314,
-0.1062216312,
-0.6257657409,
0.4366485775,
-0.6619514227,
0.1211069897,
0.3762424588,
-0.5145516992,
-0.0554550253,
0.0529173203,
-0.9332300425,
1.1448690891,
0.2844862044,
-0.8016494513,
-0.0274959132,
-0.8439821005,
-0.0847956911,
0.129091233,
-0.0169229321,
-0.4159553647,
0.2821525037,
-0.1520731151,
0.5059565306,
-0.3765572309,
0.4837374389,
-0.3146041632,
-0.2944526374,
0.5000710487,
-0.3860371709,
0.6638893485,
0.2468021959,
-0.0192782506,
0.2034535557,
-0.8114278913,
0.0672110543,
0.3254119456,
-0.2502777576,
-0.1921419352,
-0.0539890714,
0.1977785528,
0.0449963324,
0.0044542439,
-0.7476679683,
0.3357433677,
-0.4045790136,
0.6780438423,
0.5525268316,
-0.1913145036,
0.1747582108,
-0.6612583399,
0.637301445,
-0.0582542345,
-0.0333483145,
0.0675316304,
-0.4459498525,
-0.4901550412,
-0.4021189213,
0.1016444042,
0.3555110693,
-0.6421251893,
0.269849062,
-0.4299557805,
-1.0414372683,
-0.8277537823,
0.1639137864,
-0.0390867889,
0.3695922196,
0.1041066721,
0.1266261041,
-0.9296819568,
-0.463506043,
0.0780989379,
0.0384785868,
-0.2175323963,
0.0301343892,
0.6765451431,
-0.5061222911,
1.0522851944,
-0.4377236962,
-0.0860638693,
-0.2722992003,
-0.044914864,
0.678748548,
0.4792073369,
0.376018852,
-0.514714241,
0.004319109,
-0.3788509667,
-0.8038608432,
-0.1726061851,
0.1902505606,
-0.165366739,
0.3356223404,
0.1930852085,
-0.9300044179,
0.2560246885,
0.7953009009,
0.0595800318,
0.8088065386,
-0.1375545263,
-0.1346991062,
-1.1465821266,
0.2557091713,
-0.0976554975,
-0.103015691,
-0.7627691031,
0.0229975879,
-0.2599403262,
-0.4309071004,
-0.5738916397,
0.5222736001,
-0.0708572865,
-0.0094307875,
-0.3475566208,
-0.0768057406,
0.0332610197,
-0.218400687,
0.4183849096,
0.7963293791,
0.7228161097,
-0.5666154623,
0.7926444411,
0.275647819,
-0.4972336888,
0.1240020245,
-0.9949586987,
0.4249448478,
-0.1094602346,
0.3010002673,
-0.4637444019,
-0.4061596394,
0.4101982415,
-0.2816137671,
-0.1745957434,
-0.3154543936,
-0.8361378312,
-0.5669536591,
-0.2761986852,
0.3113464415,
0.5156520009,
-0.8089787364,
0.2225227952,
0.3295599222,
-0.2403768599,
-0.305734694,
-0.5482771397,
0.1874371469,
-0.3293317258,
-0.7515406013,
0.3608818352,
-0.1111364737,
-0.4525105357,
-0.1064280197,
0.0846472159,
-0.2238215953,
-0.1758015901,
0.3646344244,
0.3968505263,
-0.1676514,
-0.0278231613,
-0.3835045993,
-0.0459544696,
0.2717733979,
-0.4231219888,
0.5047917366,
0.0587523729,
-0.3676476181,
-0.2544113696,
0.1688895077,
0.8107972145,
-0.0883137062,
0.756812036,
0.3248381019,
-0.5396487713,
-0.4867314398,
-0.2788740396,
-0.1136873737,
-0.4942506552,
0.0986650214,
-0.0746512562,
-0.8061085939,
0.3125641644,
-0.234166503,
0.3958622813,
-0.1344078481,
0.8421314359,
-0.0567049049,
0.4603639841,
0.5092933774,
-0.0878665224,
0.2001318783,
-0.2128655761,
0.3941331208,
-0.8275201917,
-0.2075982988,
-0.6547600627,
-0.239142403,
-0.4203914106,
-0.9554960132,
0.2033356875,
-0.011865194,
-0.080661118,
0.3055081666,
-0.7631385922,
0.390206039,
0.5783703327,
-0.1445106417,
0.2493116856,
0.006021149,
0.3157880902,
-0.1768098772,
-0.6811664104,
-0.9236650467,
1.2453950644,
0.2198939025,
1.330658555,
-0.0385706685,
0.8235828876,
0.2053902298,
0.1551439613,
-0.706125319,
0.3913028836,
0.1562066972,
-0.4432502687,
-0.3189888895,
-0.351965487,
-1.2047359943,
0.19470945,
0.1244622916,
-0.7531639934,
0.0220867004,
0.2354964912,
-0.0757957622,
0.4653641582,
-0.0325375311,
0.5935446024,
-0.0748264119,
-0.384557128,
0.2727288902,
-0.2349324524,
0.3524862528,
-0.327953577,
0.0709959716,
-0.2332628965,
0.1821603924,
0.7986373305,
-0.4921551943,
0.7591239214,
-0.0873606578,
-0.2540587783,
0.2513409555,
0.3104843795,
0.676538527,
0.0143819777,
-0.4622191787,
0.5611721277,
0.0089847958,
-0.1616910994,
-0.4333949387,
0.8970134258,
-0.517463088,
-0.502122283,
-0.5753781796,
-0.8993059397,
0.1958694756,
0.0668222979,
-0.0842075199,
0.2409826368,
-0.1450509131,
0.1698274314,
0.54959023,
-0.1891897619,
0.1917392761,
0.591609776,
-0.5045773387,
-0.375472188,
0.8052129745,
-0.0626752302,
0.1531700939,
0.1111046895,
0.2198357284,
-0.0852608904,
-0.7977380753,
-0.3211238086,
0.1469067633,
-0.3619857132,
-0.139488712,
-0.5508829355,
-0.3603900969,
-0.4181030691,
-0.2617253363,
-0.5651993155,
-0.6416673064,
-0.2835351825,
-0.0950754806,
0.7988715172,
0.6801249981,
-0.1752984524,
0.073570393,
-0.6069182754,
0.3895790279,
-0.3562202454,
0.1588299572,
-0.3139556646,
-0.3513543904,
-0.1308784932,
0.1261298358,
-0.0655585974,
-0.3778707683,
0.6706931591,
-0.0678410232,
0.4569987953,
0.0225210115,
0.2507891953,
0.3990102112,
-0.5397314429,
0.713774085,
-0.1486341953,
-0.5304691195,
0.596183002,
-0.2422025353,
0.1269789636,
0.186230123,
0.5732690096,
-0.5700811148,
-0.6717398763,
-0.3794936538,
-0.9381746054,
0.5525086522,
0.4722331464,
0.0492042936,
0.2248615324,
0.2342308164,
0.3038876057,
0.3374142647,
-0.3964264691,
-0.1857797205,
-0.254491061,
-0.2676370144,
-0.0177035779,
0.0583821312,
-0.3193035722,
-0.2029384077,
0.7152345777,
-0.0128218066,
0.1649268568,
0.2333264053,
0.0314601064,
-0.1626883447,
0.2950853109,
0.3855922222,
0.825204134,
-0.4783623219,
0.1529223174,
-0.3219384849,
-0.5071383119,
0.1603417248,
0.3132281899,
-0.6491238475,
0.3603254259,
0.2419838756,
0.4475565553,
-0.1664195955,
-0.6948621869,
0.1440716982,
-0.0402530581,
-0.1899141371,
-0.5984922647,
0.1880073398,
0.1868448853,
0.3056186438,
0.1606710702,
-0.0238755737,
-0.1687112898,
-0.2050509453,
0.1284517199,
0.1439006329,
-0.0913441405,
-0.3144336939,
0.6447799802,
0.0057819537,
-0.4829036593,
0.8547535539,
0.0113980649,
-0.2826388478,
0.5790698528,
0.7624693513,
0.8224002719,
-0.0423097312,
0.1118351594,
0.2352267653,
0.3703109324,
-0.2114911228,
0.5798963308,
0.4228522778,
-0.7700737715,
-0.2061246037,
-0.800772965,
-0.8212814927,
0.4189502597,
-0.5304399729,
0.1410936564,
-0.3777612746,
-0.0468882397,
0.355855912,
-0.3611608446,
-0.7038988471,
-0.3064314723,
0.008190793,
1.1195734739,
-0.4776533544,
1.0178377628,
0.7399600148,
-0.0368039496,
-0.538435936,
-0.2634358704,
0.2538278997,
-0.5485044718,
0.7349241972,
0.1528036445,
-0.0846200883,
0.0483867899,
-0.5643342733,
-0.9014785886,
1.1397851706,
0.5199171901,
-0.6197371483,
0.0500682332,
0.4725750089,
0.7332497835,
-0.4615665674,
0.1672286093,
0.4411989152,
0.3808669448,
0.2524141967,
-0.8884481192,
0.0719957128,
-0.2031160742,
0.1957306713,
0.1368424296,
-0.2459953725,
0.7530245185,
-0.4493684769,
-0.1225215867,
0.1854300946,
0.4479462504,
0.6459849477,
0.3223356307,
-0.0145195276,
0.5282436013,
0.8955342174,
-0.1569773257,
0.8513112068,
-0.2847401202,
0.2135114223,
1.2953232527,
-0.7324179411,
0.76921767,
0.6761318445,
-0.2284810245,
0.3523211479,
0.3696547449,
-0.3625642061,
0.3472590446,
0.8044478893,
-0.3765991628,
0.2455857247,
-0.2314331383,
-0.2248307914,
0.2685880065,
0.4067152739,
-0.4181236327,
-0.4216633141,
0.0512220487,
0.1273770481,
-0.0395493023,
-0.1288409084,
0.4752484262,
0.094866246,
-0.3728984594,
0.6556236744,
-0.0892838836,
0.6001337767,
-0.7253560424,
-0.2365567833,
-0.1543141603,
0.4437329769,
-0.3025707304,
-0.9146652818,
0.6104739308,
0.4321815968,
-0.2633747756,
-0.2414491773,
0.6879168749,
-0.3808420897,
-0.5829927921,
0.1767134517,
0.3544565439,
0.5729364157,
-0.0676804781,
-0.5398430228,
0.3723146915,
-0.3306644261,
-0.4777586162,
0.137423411,
0.5046259165,
0.0907485262,
1.1496815681,
1.071269989,
0.5151380897,
0.2357230783,
0.0746650025,
0.9133301973,
-0.7160550952,
0.069093205,
-0.9935953617,
0.077790454,
0.0847241282,
-0.1123660728,
0.7410972118,
0.9156187773,
0.9286745191,
-0.2448049486,
0.9763367176,
-0.2492115498,
0.6962083578,
-0.2432986051,
0.599821806,
0.0303255729,
0.235541448,
-0.0176119227,
-0.8159597516,
-0.2859850824,
0.4822098613,
0.0686940253,
-0.4791761041,
0.4452513158,
1.1653629541,
-0.0781838223,
0.0516814813,
0.0720893666,
0.1042535529,
0.5570142269,
0.444146812,
0.9165267348,
-0.1152092591,
0.5019099116,
-0.637947619,
-0.1465074867,
-0.0305858254,
-1.084151268,
-1.0104449987,
-0.3116475642,
-0.4127990901,
-0.4397106767,
0.1774222404,
1.1005612612,
0.6516535282,
-0.7426162958,
-0.4004933834,
-0.247557655,
0.1393428445,
-0.2575837076,
-0.284809202,
0.1673959345,
-0.0530138463,
-0.7745983005,
0.5340350866,
0.1304838359,
0.1673467308,
-0.4922532141,
-0.0260533132,
0.1866634041,
0.1121604666,
0.3717915416,
0.3899016678,
-0.542026937,
0.1824290454,
-0.1563498974,
-0.216249451,
-0.1274336129,
0.9287460446,
-0.5542078614,
0.3625302911,
0.424807936,
0.6245573759,
0.3367384672,
-0.1810680926,
0.8900177479,
-0.5210245848,
0.0314849094,
0.4116697013,
0.3600815833,
0.3630798459,
-0.3999292254,
0.8613420129,
0.1498071849,
-0.6962540746,
-1.1286090612,
0.0031608203,
-0.8865894079,
0.1525438875,
1.1040444374,
-0.2807381749,
-0.3055613339,
-0.0855979994,
-0.1279059947,
0.0227978155,
-0.4460809529,
0.8442221284,
0.4363779426,
-0.2059694231,
-0.0380752385,
-0.7430614233,
0.459205687,
-0.2809698284,
-0.9217613935,
0.5838538408,
0.371229142,
0.390401274,
0.1609277874,
0.6184385419,
-0.2676282823,
-0.0867145285,
0.0110352086,
0.2364559919,
-0.4969545007,
-0.2561255395,
-0.1541000009,
-0.1081105173,
-0.0169832055,
-0.1053038314
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10373v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10373v2
|
BioMistral: A Collection of Open-Source Pretrained Large Language Models for Medical Domains
| 2024-02-15T23:39:04 | 2024-06-09T15:19:09 |
Yanis Labrak, Adrien Bazoge, Emmanuel Morin, Pierre-Antoine Gourraud, Mickael Rouvier, Richard Dufour
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable versatility in
recent years, offering potential applications across specialized domains such
as healthcare and medicine. Despite the availability of various open-source
LLMs tailored for health contexts, adapting general-purpose LLMs to the medical
domain presents significant challenges. In this paper, we introduce BioMistral,
an open-source LLM tailored for the biomedical domain, utilizing Mistral as its
foundation model and further pre-trained on PubMed Central. We conduct a
comprehensive evaluation of BioMistral on a benchmark comprising 10 established
medical question-answering (QA) tasks in English. We also explore lightweight
models obtained through quantization and model merging approaches. Our results
demonstrate BioMistral's superior performance compared to existing open-source
medical models and its competitive edge against proprietary counterparts.
Finally, to address the limited availability of data beyond English and to
assess the multilingual generalization of medical LLMs, we automatically
translated and evaluated this benchmark into 7 other languages. This marks the
first large-scale multilingual evaluation of LLMs in the medical domain.
Datasets, multilingual evaluation benchmarks, scripts, and all the models
obtained during our experiments are freely released.
|
[
0.1627403796,
-0.5311164856,
0.8449060321,
0.0426671803,
-0.3829845488,
0.1745100319,
-0.2977406979,
-0.5163659453,
0.2031077147,
0.5065852404,
-0.5225526094,
-0.7911731005,
-0.5572603941,
0.4146843553,
0.0725965127,
0.9580975771,
-0.1816861928,
0.8066926003,
-0.5604143143,
-0.516754508,
-0.0163369551,
-0.8401534557,
-0.5292751193,
-0.4153577089,
0.3989648819,
-0.4148325026,
0.5127916336,
0.2871160805,
0.6053261757,
0.334366858,
-0.1041446999,
-0.0292736478,
-0.3442005515,
0.3363765478,
-0.665604353,
-0.3603522778,
-0.4746935666,
-0.2882528007,
0.5521328449,
0.7713692784,
-0.3208411336,
0.4572930038,
-0.1308217645,
0.6365549564,
-0.4469618201,
0.105497539,
-0.3619346023,
-0.1254855841,
0.0248795059,
-0.0067338455,
-0.0788664967,
-0.5598938465,
0.1915638,
-0.5108256936,
-0.0355709866,
-0.2819748819,
0.3707313836,
0.3847801387,
-0.3065645397,
-0.0453313328,
-0.6838020682,
0.6621150374,
-0.6745551825,
0.7733235955,
0.143822968,
0.6111962795,
-0.0520008057,
-0.9699327946,
-0.0719790459,
-0.0618439019,
0.3649786711,
0.1615720987,
-0.5811192393,
0.1578769833,
-0.3118988574,
0.2096691728,
-0.7436514497,
-0.1805542111,
-0.5211445093,
-0.2272952646,
0.3511529565,
0.2545058131,
0.3265703619,
0.1312310696,
-0.1052569672,
0.05986486,
-0.620788455,
-0.0641552806,
-0.4304902554,
0.2312627435,
-0.2160184532,
0.6009426117,
-0.1166888997,
0.4452158511,
-0.1428943276,
-0.2490439713,
0.2352006286,
-0.5094245672,
-0.2676735222,
0.1179172173,
0.8205142617,
0.1410312057,
0.0802957267,
-0.2506392896,
0.0024963073,
0.0043813316,
0.2168878615,
-1.069791317,
-0.2031245828,
0.723775208,
-0.5242339969,
-0.0818915218,
-0.5315321088,
-0.3852957487,
-0.4007149041,
-0.2301576436,
0.4427482486,
-0.5316738486,
-0.1437709779,
0.3844757676,
0.1314400584,
-0.0515660979,
0.3867043257,
-0.3383921385,
0.3467696607,
0.6195077896,
0.9172174335,
-0.1558399051,
-0.1111173704,
-0.2197637409,
0.1659564078,
-0.2884635031,
0.8303705454,
-0.4427997172,
-0.4264656007,
-0.1350383908,
0.2926594317,
0.0222686492,
-0.7400771379,
0.1744940579,
-0.460675925,
0.1329704672,
-0.134164229,
-0.3268263042,
-0.0348056108,
0.0813195556,
-0.5502296686,
0.6177548766,
0.3669891655,
-0.6421636343,
0.0349095762,
-0.4796979725,
-0.3331997693,
0.3156890869,
-0.2731578648,
-0.2504950166,
0.1800810844,
0.103485547,
0.1588359624,
-0.7834140658,
0.3719139695,
-0.3503127694,
-0.1040147245,
0.4991374612,
-0.1923012286,
0.951023221,
0.1966629028,
-0.0700525045,
0.4092060328,
-0.6202255487,
0.1683761925,
-0.0016252622,
-0.2955640256,
-0.5571959019,
0.0966417566,
0.0736030638,
0.1704896837,
0.382452637,
-0.6734896898,
0.0335659049,
-0.7468412519,
0.7037649751,
0.5150984526,
0.1362336278,
0.1664918363,
-0.2860075235,
0.8066546321,
-0.1213787869,
0.2682591975,
0.1715101004,
-0.3323992491,
0.0112425415,
-0.7689365149,
0.2710109651,
0.70247823,
-0.7967382669,
0.2085956484,
-0.3229633272,
-0.6906380653,
-0.9863325357,
0.178601265,
0.4567444623,
0.2610635161,
0.4197869003,
-0.0215984192,
-0.1940460354,
-0.7860509157,
-0.3076022565,
-0.2034350932,
-0.074740231,
0.2543297112,
0.47815907,
-0.7235411406,
0.6182892919,
-0.406601131,
-0.0755274892,
-0.0629522949,
-0.2606244385,
0.4503604174,
0.1953892559,
0.5443091989,
-0.4046875536,
-0.269285351,
0.2790748179,
-0.7593562007,
-0.192866832,
0.4947866499,
-0.3302204013,
-0.1551294178,
0.4249364436,
-0.66667521,
-0.0054359268,
0.9579717517,
-0.1534190476,
0.5249471664,
-0.400662452,
0.1896589249,
-1.5184402466,
0.3986831009,
-0.0765315741,
-0.4598854184,
-0.4831010997,
0.4473319352,
0.0929689333,
-0.5520539284,
-0.7406642437,
0.849450171,
-0.2252492905,
0.1645379663,
-0.1566164941,
-0.2722461224,
-0.0547579862,
-0.0013753556,
0.1276242435,
0.8879220486,
0.6176187992,
-0.4797623158,
0.4754968286,
0.3445562422,
-0.2685230076,
0.6746149659,
-1.0704848766,
-0.1088650227,
-0.3004571199,
0.3467742801,
-0.7988875508,
-0.3777247965,
0.1987132579,
-0.2721995413,
-0.1120845675,
-0.0785676911,
-0.2881243229,
-0.373862952,
-0.2626002431,
0.606066525,
0.5674881935,
-0.3350929916,
0.6414582133,
0.2900275588,
-0.6346188188,
-0.2733222246,
-0.6511262059,
-0.2193160057,
0.2439277917,
-0.2892799377,
0.2506086528,
-0.3053206205,
-0.3406865895,
0.0392802842,
-0.2170238644,
-0.3921519518,
-0.0012940173,
0.2843260765,
0.2526175082,
-0.4576803744,
0.3212489188,
0.4091204107,
0.05145007,
0.1780915409,
-0.4400737584,
0.3501425385,
0.0358270258,
-0.5326094627,
-0.3242771626,
0.2512454987,
0.8837245107,
-0.449549675,
0.7898051143,
0.1781759709,
-0.5291383862,
-0.04570264,
-0.2991840541,
-0.0673464835,
-0.4273183048,
0.6560891271,
-0.0824137479,
-0.9429293871,
0.3404911757,
-0.3901774585,
-0.0035438156,
0.3867231607,
0.780230701,
-0.0029552227,
0.9523922205,
0.4805840254,
-0.0482215136,
-0.1773104668,
0.2545039952,
-0.0815364495,
-0.4553145766,
-0.2506382763,
-0.6218816638,
0.0724581182,
-0.422082752,
-0.6054490805,
0.9529135227,
0.0470955558,
-0.3289578259,
0.0103503736,
-0.4981676936,
0.275403887,
0.073375769,
0.4617542624,
0.2790849805,
0.1764824241,
-0.3355973363,
0.0108563676,
-0.5826264024,
-0.3428512514,
1.0776195526,
0.3536750376,
0.8961035013,
0.363781929,
0.5478064418,
0.0019660476,
0.5480961204,
-0.659348011,
0.2384821624,
-0.4280534983,
-0.7208749056,
-0.1783646792,
-0.4739868939,
-1.1212005615,
0.2718097568,
-0.2816654146,
-0.4949495792,
0.0047644526,
-0.0447934307,
-0.5489563346,
0.1569736302,
-0.2628426254,
0.7695100904,
-0.4623323977,
-0.3811391294,
-0.218749851,
-0.5046025515,
0.2391924709,
-0.6687139869,
0.4378470778,
-0.1736590862,
-0.1949771494,
0.4039655924,
-0.5211256742,
0.7974503636,
-0.0314517766,
-0.3386228979,
0.0327552631,
-0.0024978621,
-0.0752743781,
0.1276843101,
-0.230594486,
0.5116881132,
0.7698757648,
-0.4122965634,
-0.2624261677,
0.5775176287,
-0.9985141754,
-0.4062096477,
-0.4788280129,
-0.1709208786,
-0.4573408961,
0.3490038514,
0.2641397417,
0.4693536162,
-0.6611654162,
0.123069562,
0.7070599198,
-0.8104650378,
-0.1467210799,
0.8573252559,
-0.5033010244,
-0.8525745869,
0.7385060191,
-0.3267469406,
0.1668654978,
0.4373763502,
0.2634807527,
-0.4163329005,
-0.3602695465,
-0.576767683,
0.5443904996,
-0.6017215848,
-0.2552187443,
-0.7707765698,
-0.3511562347,
-0.6306830645,
-0.0265502315,
-0.3316050768,
-0.0704798773,
-0.0880015343,
0.3072725236,
0.4850239158,
0.7551588416,
0.1871693879,
0.042516645,
-1.277441144,
0.4680888653,
0.2470205724,
0.5437950492,
-0.2134553641,
-0.2618549466,
-0.2180892527,
0.0873661414,
0.0283412635,
-0.9948834777,
0.3787670732,
0.3907821774,
0.6516703963,
0.1399402022,
-0.171473369,
0.228762567,
-0.792083621,
0.6804893613,
0.3138128519,
-0.6803283691,
0.5370701551,
-0.3346289992,
0.5924583077,
0.8073268533,
0.7827342153,
-0.3849280179,
-0.3984790146,
-0.1006772667,
-0.6307595968,
0.2680104077,
-0.1721244007,
0.168777898,
-0.1926182806,
0.4736220539,
0.2729920447,
0.439066112,
-0.4722018838,
-0.0649336949,
-0.0977199599,
-0.540986836,
-0.327519089,
0.0323559828,
-0.192662999,
-0.4755598307,
0.4573186934,
-0.137870729,
0.2883621752,
0.2810968459,
-0.2899248898,
-0.1087721288,
0.448594451,
0.4479796886,
0.7077050805,
-0.1497250646,
0.014069695,
0.1273717433,
-0.7247650027,
0.3519799411,
0.4185269177,
0.1590200961,
0.1450946629,
0.4138326645,
0.3123189509,
0.4436314702,
-1.1475324631,
0.6245520711,
0.0540737621,
-0.2463795245,
-0.1033232883,
-0.2118565738,
0.3140664399,
0.4724628627,
0.1814564466,
-0.1813211292,
0.132771045,
-0.4375547767,
0.1087591872,
0.4404652715,
-0.4458162189,
-0.5628527403,
0.9790865183,
0.2204185575,
0.0146584194,
0.2451633662,
0.3015882969,
-0.4664450884,
0.220909372,
0.6118642688,
0.7734417915,
-0.640664041,
0.2069700509,
0.3125138879,
0.1597322673,
-0.0910454169,
0.6345969439,
0.168522194,
-0.3887665272,
-0.7138907909,
-0.9442030787,
-0.5165259838,
0.0333524495,
-0.4964877665,
-0.0391852669,
-0.5861318707,
-0.5473868847,
0.15035142,
-0.3556033373,
-0.6097674966,
0.117028825,
-0.0266356152,
0.9305723906,
-0.7383314967,
0.7563745975,
1.2584557533,
-0.4045038521,
-0.3933062851,
-0.243165195,
-0.1655801386,
-0.9489190578,
0.6555652022,
-0.3234190047,
-0.1520521641,
0.0604341701,
-0.5740603805,
-0.8246551752,
0.9814158082,
0.7043063641,
-0.5376771688,
-0.1651736945,
0.3362468779,
0.8423672915,
0.0174275897,
0.0929402784,
0.2187792957,
0.1552396864,
-0.1743131131,
-0.986656189,
0.1128919125,
-0.3470824361,
-0.1232897118,
0.1583388448,
-0.5691510439,
0.8682115078,
0.0106347948,
-0.0203493591,
0.4203030467,
0.2433230877,
0.5157737136,
0.1776730865,
-0.0107971206,
0.2878445685,
0.7629464269,
0.1578997374,
1.225894928,
-0.7461490035,
0.1028461084,
0.716953218,
-0.6476625204,
0.8860368729,
0.1520868689,
-0.4841282964,
0.5061243773,
0.4468468428,
0.2561582029,
0.5151561499,
0.2271712124,
-0.6380254626,
-0.2552035153,
-0.2817206085,
-0.6601649523,
0.2005725056,
0.2975036204,
-0.3751339614,
-0.2466531098,
0.1878990829,
-0.0787551627,
0.0579940006,
-0.4551928639,
0.7976615429,
0.3416067362,
-0.2221630812,
0.7387922406,
0.0598412417,
0.3969347179,
-0.8117212653,
-0.0313324928,
-0.1055930182,
0.239365533,
-0.0140852556,
-0.4345547557,
-0.0538544357,
-0.0300103016,
-0.1974216849,
0.0714612156,
0.8180651665,
-0.5470998883,
-0.6559336782,
0.3535075784,
0.8864212632,
0.3176616132,
-0.1438865513,
-0.7249483466,
-0.002570292,
-0.2928317487,
0.1634209752,
0.2981776595,
0.521040082,
-0.1297395229,
0.6132273078,
0.6135036945,
0.4881549776,
-0.264868021,
-0.0266407859,
0.7534321547,
-0.5695319772,
-0.3180518746,
-0.7287986875,
0.1227563024,
0.3722212613,
-0.1366618723,
0.4712257385,
0.5574889779,
0.4250870943,
-0.3381685913,
0.9603117108,
0.6509537697,
0.6453945637,
-0.4200986922,
0.9955096245,
-0.7066384554,
-0.1653133482,
-0.1723573357,
-0.839050889,
-0.2090403289,
0.312155962,
-0.0297389999,
0.1098556966,
0.819558382,
0.4093286395,
-0.002444746,
-0.2526715398,
0.3295740187,
0.3277449608,
-0.0518109165,
0.7113162279,
0.721570909,
-0.1097096354,
0.122164987,
0.0650505126,
-0.3174591064,
-0.1223753169,
-0.6236661077,
-0.9194453955,
-0.2947677374,
-0.2177944034,
-0.4499122202,
0.415040344,
1.3183636665,
0.5830127001,
-0.9462551475,
-0.1060027182,
0.3091826737,
-0.419090122,
-0.1449995339,
-0.055743739,
0.3047740161,
0.0067535527,
-0.355376035,
0.5819299817,
0.3756100833,
0.2237606794,
-0.2788828909,
-0.0616731457,
0.1314440519,
0.390394181,
0.8079811335,
0.3615446985,
-0.6337639689,
0.0902802646,
0.3015857935,
-0.4595155716,
-0.1770693362,
0.6244297028,
-0.7819091082,
0.399099797,
0.2282660306,
0.9993882775,
0.1665267944,
-0.1172663271,
0.6964815259,
-0.3173660934,
0.0494173542,
0.143674463,
0.2524774373,
0.2142582834,
-0.1290305555,
0.4249251485,
0.218190074,
-0.2807912827,
-0.7024413347,
-0.143780455,
-0.7980935574,
-0.7503709197,
1.1647098064,
0.0549248606,
-0.4153770804,
-0.0331405587,
-0.2208244652,
0.2615300417,
-0.0277737975,
0.3973862231,
0.4957108498,
0.1395116746,
0.1476014405,
-0.5368625522,
0.3434300125,
0.3309581578,
-0.9928356409,
-0.0537834242,
0.6231645346,
0.5989617705,
-0.1415547431,
1.0208890438,
-0.4055237174,
0.3960476518,
-0.4295675457,
0.4518646896,
0.2085446864,
0.0060809846,
-0.7103489041,
0.0329575092,
0.3342168033,
0.3027704954
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10359v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10359v2
|
Can we Soft Prompt LLMs for Graph Learning Tasks?
| 2024-02-15T23:09:42 | 2024-03-16T19:56:04 |
Zheyuan Liu, Xiaoxin He, Yijun Tian, Nitesh V. Chawla
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Graph plays an important role in representing complex relationships in
real-world applications such as social networks, biological data and citation
networks. In recent years, Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved
tremendous success in various domains, which makes applying LLMs to graphs
particularly appealing. However, directly applying LLMs to graph modalities
presents unique challenges due to the discrepancy and mismatch between the
graph and text modalities. Hence, to further investigate LLMs' potential for
comprehending graph information, we introduce GraphPrompter, a novel framework
designed to align graph information with LLMs via soft prompts. Specifically,
GraphPrompter consists of two main components: a graph neural network to encode
complex graph information and an LLM that effectively processes textual
information. Comprehensive experiments on various benchmark datasets under node
classification and link prediction tasks demonstrate the effectiveness of our
proposed method. The GraphPrompter framework unveils the substantial
capabilities of LLMs as predictors in graph-related tasks, enabling researchers
to utilize LLMs across a spectrum of real-world graph scenarios more
effectively.
|
[
-0.0820555612,
-0.9104205966,
0.7833139896,
-0.2162237763,
-0.3831351995,
0.223682642,
-0.2538504899,
-0.1846818328,
0.0986259058,
0.1876512468,
-0.8467194438,
-0.6027670503,
-0.5640416741,
0.3222782016,
-0.0686540678,
1.0002676249,
-0.2161101401,
0.1797094643,
-0.348932147,
0.0611257963,
-0.5946855545,
-0.2253572792,
-0.7440225482,
-0.5520782471,
1.0168642998,
0.3159373999,
0.4483739138,
0.2970725894,
0.2221281826,
0.4064804912,
-0.0897625163,
0.5140525699,
-0.5653175116,
0.4013786614,
-0.1329458505,
-0.4510935247,
-0.2746495605,
-0.0130460206,
0.5175518394,
1.1975541115,
0.3362575471,
0.0294845253,
0.5516024232,
0.4925419092,
-0.1727390736,
0.637196362,
-0.4522862732,
-0.0816340372,
-0.0244846344,
-0.0657609999,
-0.4045649171,
-0.4791302383,
-0.0418269262,
-0.6559967399,
0.3542383313,
0.2219850868,
0.7906501293,
0.0835747793,
-0.5764178038,
-0.1530244499,
-0.4364275932,
0.2252546698,
-0.3046628833,
0.3797852695,
-0.0356546976,
0.3071163297,
-0.4751881063,
-1.0886005163,
-0.5373676419,
-0.1193874553,
-0.0423118807,
0.1059320644,
0.0035460335,
0.2078423947,
0.1584019959,
-0.0062669404,
-0.4763692617,
0.2905783355,
-0.136319235,
-0.3724063933,
0.2029018998,
0.4008289576,
0.3250361979,
-0.2405119389,
-0.204900071,
0.0086678164,
-0.6375110745,
0.1058922261,
0.2826604843,
0.7588137388,
0.0720128417,
0.5638958812,
0.0929778293,
0.8161398172,
0.0700168312,
-0.074344039,
0.3172138035,
-0.169670552,
0.0672263876,
0.0418003872,
0.9251294732,
0.2972744405,
0.5780264139,
-0.375705421,
-0.2673383951,
0.156549409,
-0.1132527143,
-0.8570894599,
-0.2609486878,
0.1563361138,
-0.2732415199,
-0.0051262719,
0.0446258485,
-0.5465540886,
-0.6637666821,
-0.3472247124,
-0.0360561423,
-0.3705609143,
-0.3071384728,
-0.0715075582,
-0.2476007044,
-0.3462640047,
0.4565738142,
-0.5219643712,
0.3182387054,
0.8069932461,
0.9743674397,
-0.1430452168,
-0.3497531712,
-0.7274989486,
0.0873751268,
-0.2304084748,
0.7798979878,
-0.4621627033,
-0.1718665212,
0.1790858358,
0.3949454129,
-0.4569975138,
-0.4153053164,
0.3194748461,
-0.469478488,
0.0608903095,
-0.1639945358,
-0.6165805459,
-0.1242852882,
0.4289138615,
-0.8240061402,
0.7287547588,
0.3796252012,
-0.8050435781,
0.2330331057,
-0.1660347581,
-0.5975577831,
0.3854223192,
-0.350741297,
-0.3950725496,
-0.1280104071,
-0.1027909741,
0.7023326159,
-0.1178988665,
0.5203757882,
-0.4209245443,
-0.426908344,
0.4374523759,
-0.313102901,
0.3842006028,
-0.0395774022,
-0.2592079043,
0.37220788,
-0.3412147462,
-0.0942216292,
0.2685279548,
-0.2236515433,
-0.1001360789,
0.0584329441,
0.0846779794,
0.1959117055,
0.2773904502,
-0.5217027664,
0.1992335618,
-0.4527987838,
0.6381912827,
1.0640171766,
-0.08985053,
0.3346602619,
-0.1557306498,
0.6237077713,
-0.1417164505,
-0.2164150178,
-0.185588181,
-0.4426378608,
-0.2740736306,
-0.2732511759,
0.4231414497,
0.6658177972,
-0.7208167911,
0.2062786371,
-0.3331800699,
-0.2522540987,
-0.0289577451,
0.4488432109,
0.3569030166,
0.7630360723,
0.2137111723,
-0.0309592392,
-0.3916158974,
-0.3250638247,
-0.1622583717,
-0.1089684516,
-0.1498710215,
0.678955853,
0.2427432537,
-0.1144378707,
0.918540895,
-0.7350503802,
-0.5516220331,
-0.8441367149,
0.0384812802,
0.5107018352,
0.1398500055,
0.3939320445,
-0.9198720455,
-0.3705337048,
-0.3390925825,
-0.7821816802,
-0.2059919983,
0.1226221919,
0.0741823316,
-0.1841240525,
0.7627776265,
-0.736610949,
-0.0828279927,
0.3879228532,
-0.5259276032,
0.4872478247,
-0.0070670862,
-0.2881993651,
-1.0110225677,
-0.1135400757,
0.2526047826,
-0.4770103693,
-0.3208731115,
-0.3164400756,
-0.0612686761,
-0.2816531956,
-0.4281937778,
0.6759669185,
-0.4775048792,
0.183450371,
-0.2005937546,
0.429554075,
0.1339373291,
0.3856859207,
-0.2643678486,
0.6809361577,
0.6548886299,
-0.5828834176,
0.4487110376,
0.2121383995,
-0.1239386499,
0.4628635943,
-0.8249151111,
0.103141807,
-0.4477290213,
0.6330011487,
-1.3405258656,
-0.3207038641,
0.4356643558,
-0.3187722266,
0.5597686172,
-0.2967372835,
-0.6416022182,
-0.5798329711,
-0.2351877689,
0.1905907691,
0.348570317,
-0.3304313719,
0.8315728307,
0.1704274714,
-0.2380059361,
-0.2379392684,
-0.3005244136,
0.0717477202,
-0.0656198859,
-0.525146544,
0.3091440499,
-0.0916833505,
0.102930136,
0.1616549939,
-0.0562070496,
0.1524834633,
0.1891833395,
0.6848512292,
0.409815222,
-0.2083697319,
0.1918317974,
-0.162838012,
-0.5290081501,
0.1306707263,
-0.6307733655,
0.6213729978,
0.0239795242,
-0.4009143412,
-0.2475036979,
-0.0939541757,
0.2364225984,
0.0062795808,
0.4385938644,
0.7428722382,
-0.338388145,
-0.1423388869,
-0.2040933818,
-0.3292512,
-0.5780783892,
0.4445301294,
-0.3112618029,
-1.1057364941,
0.4370798767,
-0.8274627328,
-0.3468184471,
0.1093043983,
0.1264315993,
-0.2870235145,
1.4038534164,
0.4769346416,
-0.1334433258,
0.5961015224,
-0.3667081594,
0.3543106616,
-0.7746306062,
-0.5295643806,
-0.3356759846,
-0.570114255,
-0.4213770926,
-0.0123142097,
0.4006128311,
0.1665788144,
-0.2787351906,
0.0648107082,
-0.4752426147,
0.4117240012,
0.2804082632,
0.5247784257,
-0.230571121,
0.0344221294,
-0.3342582583,
-0.0150647396,
-0.8191440701,
-0.4346889257,
0.5862997174,
0.1537005901,
0.7776444554,
-0.1585130095,
0.4693834186,
0.1682784408,
0.3154262304,
-0.9996013045,
0.8319650888,
-0.3613794744,
-0.0420389883,
-0.079609789,
-0.4500350356,
-1.2984080315,
-0.1520552635,
-0.068654649,
-0.7221549153,
-0.0118567711,
0.2422754318,
-0.1277825832,
0.2032437623,
-0.5022150874,
1.0472385883,
-0.196678862,
-0.4961053133,
0.3236750066,
-0.414274931,
-0.1320435852,
0.2244682014,
0.3969953656,
-0.5028898716,
-0.2091967762,
0.813990891,
-0.3371894062,
1.3437292576,
-0.374001056,
0.069700636,
0.3598653972,
0.3192440271,
0.720672071,
0.0253704898,
-0.2275957316,
-0.1757618487,
-0.609243691,
-0.2162019759,
-0.6993958354,
0.6836341619,
-0.538176477,
-0.6575807333,
-0.1683063805,
-0.6103925109,
-0.3110601008,
0.4994085431,
0.2423585802,
0.768479526,
-0.0231180172,
-0.1644854099,
0.6218319535,
0.3110652268,
0.2906733155,
0.1761406958,
-0.0530716069,
-0.347920686,
1.1357593536,
0.156471923,
0.0026259753,
0.1837278605,
0.384845823,
-0.5072026849,
-0.7193052173,
-0.3932337463,
0.3856113553,
-0.9131192565,
-0.5330533981,
-0.7014301419,
-0.0222332384,
-0.3552335799,
-0.3203479648,
0.2822911441,
-0.1705146581,
-0.6097792387,
-0.3784593642,
0.57943964,
0.8503831029,
0.3070718348,
0.2743194401,
-0.7694942951,
0.2074649334,
0.2462793291,
0.3090022504,
-0.2436962873,
-0.2843196094,
0.0684984997,
-0.0557091013,
-0.0904423073,
-0.9750785232,
0.2027042955,
0.3853445053,
0.6686294675,
0.4029217064,
0.1797612011,
0.2129847109,
-0.5848687887,
0.7988752127,
0.3383229971,
-0.7237203121,
0.5834150314,
-0.3584701121,
0.0775464252,
0.5680819154,
0.6450545192,
-0.3134813905,
-0.4277697504,
-0.4138881564,
-1.026507616,
0.4116770029,
-0.3683438599,
0.5732542276,
-0.171868518,
0.6380751133,
0.0324199498,
0.0630980581,
-0.6678937674,
-0.139177978,
-0.31912148,
-0.8108656406,
-0.0817488432,
-0.2119024247,
-0.0794141814,
-0.0729488209,
0.2395558357,
-0.7145674825,
-0.031514734,
0.1059270129,
-0.1983789057,
-0.1665571183,
0.062390551,
-0.0822020173,
0.7732958794,
0.0246061459,
0.5659776926,
0.3429922462,
-0.3282572627,
0.2815133631,
0.2338892221,
-0.1123947874,
0.0105362637,
0.6680531502,
0.756924212,
0.5148966312,
-0.7382031679,
0.7777014375,
0.0850880072,
-0.1062420607,
0.0598940514,
0.2982842028,
0.3192986846,
0.2195872664,
0.3433209062,
-0.186404407,
0.0507311374,
-0.423527658,
0.0959984213,
0.4014072716,
-0.8191460967,
-0.4313955605,
0.7462586761,
0.1201590076,
-0.5313487053,
0.7603926659,
-0.3368035555,
-0.9548052549,
0.7120496631,
0.9718800783,
0.4985111356,
-0.0894699395,
0.2544496953,
0.2843516469,
-0.2410098016,
0.1791460216,
0.335133642,
0.1467952281,
-0.6440435052,
-0.3916966319,
-0.3984906375,
-0.2669862807,
-0.1226126254,
-0.1886954159,
0.3637271523,
-0.572753787,
-0.3384864926,
0.065673016,
-0.0063763834,
-0.6479635835,
0.1142645106,
0.197178334,
0.875690639,
-0.9727938771,
0.3767148852,
0.854391098,
-0.3756798208,
-1.0040324926,
-0.2199780047,
0.0480307862,
-0.7375491858,
0.8278111815,
0.5260248184,
-0.3172161877,
0.2637031972,
-0.6705383062,
-0.3086881042,
1.1004054546,
0.6510779858,
-0.484670192,
-0.086301662,
0.1772403568,
0.218105495,
-0.3187229633,
0.2033832818,
0.0487293787,
0.5411489606,
0.2414438576,
-0.4843783081,
0.6338935494,
-0.3666500449,
-0.2493753135,
0.1855852902,
-0.5461066961,
0.9043514729,
-0.3420100808,
-0.2582504749,
-0.3578391373,
0.7434210181,
0.3379640877,
0.4704141617,
0.7749356031,
-0.0996529832,
0.9419530034,
-0.0432607681,
0.9438121915,
-0.4450285435,
0.0385482498,
0.8889016509,
-0.4844359159,
0.3890486658,
0.2042990327,
-0.1621678323,
0.8405772448,
1.0085111856,
0.0736793354,
0.3187685311,
0.3883426785,
-0.2316928804,
-0.4529044628,
-0.5682876706,
-0.3199880123,
0.040252205,
0.5084343553,
-0.1303015649,
-0.2435929775,
0.0331487358,
0.1680063307,
0.2026596069,
-0.3679682016,
0.7387195826,
0.3085524738,
-0.4854744077,
0.3112753928,
-0.2477133125,
0.5713687539,
-0.7292456031,
-0.1698194742,
-0.0177852139,
0.2129183859,
-0.265219897,
-1.0117651224,
-0.0270972494,
-0.2986890674,
-0.0680491328,
-0.3469066322,
1.1838668585,
-0.2193940878,
-0.5324347019,
0.5446383953,
0.562710464,
-0.0249667801,
-0.1798399091,
-0.7870023251,
0.0164350532,
-0.3937466145,
-0.2364571542,
0.3371066451,
0.772018373,
0.0252652373,
0.6802495718,
0.5947420597,
-0.0206665676,
-0.3758524954,
0.478838563,
1.2427999973,
-0.4122739732,
-0.5364643931,
-0.938937664,
0.1769744307,
0.0572592393,
-0.0284485128,
0.765101254,
0.565273881,
0.4023249745,
0.2677950859,
0.7696518898,
0.1755965352,
0.228039518,
-0.5261651874,
0.404884398,
-0.3477545679,
-0.0007326258,
-0.1940309554,
-0.7293564677,
-0.1632677019,
0.1575732082,
-0.3969825804,
0.1188281327,
0.6296858788,
0.7110295892,
-0.1908711344,
-0.1713722348,
-0.1710679084,
0.0425535403,
0.2140492946,
0.5664659739,
0.8287392259,
0.081154801,
0.7397775054,
0.1302599013,
-0.2024453282,
-0.2156964689,
-0.9732626081,
-1.007647872,
-0.5494262576,
-0.3360998034,
-0.7495353818,
0.1746223718,
0.9713611603,
0.5658140779,
-0.6074604988,
-0.0866135731,
-0.2779289484,
0.5778630376,
-0.1684956253,
-0.2534954846,
0.4581061602,
-0.499946028,
-0.6394011974,
0.4000044167,
0.0320949629,
0.2592233717,
-0.1209808961,
-0.1468164474,
0.067471303,
-0.1776414365,
0.405975461,
0.0690509006,
-0.2965510488,
-0.2783535123,
0.2070148885,
-0.1973876953,
0.0439625494,
1.0746777058,
-0.9474161267,
0.0089659402,
0.6756507158,
0.4252189696,
0.4416914284,
-0.0762533471,
0.4500185549,
-0.7712307572,
0.0750956088,
0.2072385848,
0.5542629361,
0.4990717173,
-0.7367799878,
0.3800029159,
0.5030757189,
-0.1343195587,
-0.8004155159,
0.2586556375,
-0.9462082982,
-0.5199071765,
1.1154947281,
-0.3424516618,
-0.6221095324,
-0.492852062,
-0.2465341985,
0.5415340662,
-0.2018233389,
0.2428243607,
0.2814546227,
-0.1689185649,
-0.117333509,
-0.2901820838,
0.177745536,
0.0658078343,
-0.6650937796,
0.0588785708,
0.5261201262,
0.4162700176,
0.021323001,
0.7654379606,
0.4169263244,
0.0877626687,
-0.0949073434,
-0.2750047445,
-0.6753064394,
-0.4280775189,
0.0479057506,
0.4249083698,
0.1717785746,
0.0678640157
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10353v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10353v1
|
Prompt-Based Bias Calibration for Better Zero/Few-Shot Learning of Language Models
| 2024-02-15T22:54:24 | 2024-02-15T22:54:24 |
Kang He, Yinghan Long, Kaushik Roy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Prompt learning is susceptible to intrinsic bias present in pre-trained
language models (LMs), resulting in sub-optimal performance of prompt-based
zero/few-shot learning. In this work, we propose a null-input prompting method
to calibrate intrinsic bias encoded in pre-trained LMs. Different from prior
efforts that address intrinsic bias primarily for social fairness and often
involve excessive computational cost, our objective is to explore enhancing
LMs' performance in downstream zero/few-shot learning while emphasizing the
efficiency of intrinsic bias calibration. Specifically, we leverage a diverse
set of auto-selected null-meaning inputs generated from GPT-4 to prompt
pre-trained LMs for intrinsic bias probing. Utilizing the bias-reflected
probability distribution, we formulate a distribution disparity loss for bias
calibration, where we exclusively update bias parameters ($0.1\%$ of total
parameters) of LMs towards equal probability distribution. Experimental results
show that the calibration promotes an equitable starting point for LMs while
preserving language modeling abilities. Across a wide range of datasets,
including sentiment analysis and topic classification, our method significantly
improves zero/few-shot learning performance of LMs for both in-context learning
and prompt-based fine-tuning (on average $9\%$ and $2\%$, respectively).
|
[
-0.3168114424,
-0.8008078337,
0.6996157765,
-0.0974107236,
-0.2906126678,
-0.1501134336,
-0.3638615608,
0.1095694304,
-0.0742709115,
0.0737519041,
-0.7684506774,
-0.4526915848,
-0.3894164264,
0.0998505652,
0.2670879662,
1.0871647596,
0.1371903569,
0.444806695,
0.0050848317,
-0.0415753126,
-0.8272010684,
-0.2483295202,
-0.4759677649,
-0.2503507435,
0.7588558197,
0.5074906349,
0.2484149635,
0.276527524,
-0.0924111977,
0.1424634308,
-0.0701363906,
-0.0888870806,
-0.6272941828,
0.1985764205,
-0.3354493082,
-0.4882971346,
-0.102680102,
0.2105558366,
0.6371033192,
0.747761786,
0.1920095831,
0.329287082,
0.2884004116,
0.5334593654,
-0.933765769,
0.0535537302,
-0.8178767562,
0.0400518589,
-0.221115008,
-0.446557045,
-0.4675334096,
-0.6301529408,
0.1361661255,
-0.4267119467,
0.1926233768,
-0.1593014747,
0.61195153,
0.5306053162,
-0.2580647469,
0.0454575308,
-0.5299916863,
0.9122143984,
-0.7708301544,
0.2532021999,
0.4885887802,
0.2600981295,
0.0006539617,
-0.0047257845,
-0.5628944635,
-0.284909606,
0.1881608069,
0.1283199191,
0.1118371263,
0.0908191875,
0.5043316483,
0.1116114035,
-0.5054455996,
0.1827304512,
-0.0722996369,
-0.3906890154,
0.1815682054,
-0.0700614378,
0.0189814325,
-0.1077119485,
-0.0240250397,
-0.0751015022,
-0.9347366691,
0.0715147331,
0.6121325493,
0.6502744555,
-0.0592603199,
0.2670547664,
-0.1916237026,
0.8025494218,
0.3168566227,
-0.0211029798,
0.3754814565,
-0.3245971799,
0.0825343579,
0.1500455886,
0.5171636939,
0.2084561586,
0.262263447,
0.1122344583,
-0.1990802139,
0.1001497805,
-0.0616440326,
-0.9063175917,
0.013352057,
0.0276484191,
-0.0278212558,
-0.2592764795,
-0.2516391873,
-0.5987727642,
-0.3656909466,
-0.3928824663,
0.6807588935,
-0.2895765603,
0.0125558227,
-0.1164519191,
0.1127871126,
0.4132726789,
0.5816745758,
-0.8300864697,
-0.0706300735,
0.2057230771,
0.8059660792,
0.0526778214,
-0.1450142562,
-1.0521358252,
-0.277243197,
-0.2631476223,
0.6678841114,
-0.3121101558,
-0.2077762336,
0.0980851501,
-0.2709433436,
0.0767928585,
-0.1376377344,
0.6917545199,
-0.5510694981,
0.460983485,
-0.6109488606,
-0.5243073702,
0.0117054842,
0.4574690163,
-0.3901670575,
0.903639555,
0.0490218289,
-0.8523160815,
0.6037617922,
-0.4499203563,
-0.2834419608,
0.174089551,
-0.4527726471,
-0.3111351728,
0.0456295349,
0.3830938935,
0.4687508345,
-0.0762935877,
0.2710262537,
-0.5696424842,
-0.5213565826,
0.060118679,
-0.7221722007,
0.6751413941,
-0.0256819595,
-0.649526298,
0.0414626785,
-0.6254106164,
-0.0028246574,
-0.0500557721,
0.0624562539,
-0.3588281572,
-0.0726584941,
-0.2943641841,
0.3874069452,
0.1742856801,
-0.5921906233,
0.161526531,
-0.5980493426,
-0.1159539372,
1.1123147011,
0.0109759923,
0.7261374593,
-0.1357866675,
0.5551633239,
0.1824681014,
0.0776156187,
-0.6126826406,
-0.3443827629,
-0.7236343622,
-0.2233843505,
0.3509837985,
0.5676450133,
-0.8019959927,
0.5710999966,
-0.0444503315,
-0.1486187726,
-0.4746660888,
0.0877495185,
0.2493534088,
1.1318985224,
0.3298141658,
-0.2871620059,
-0.0989789292,
-0.6086412668,
-0.2547286451,
-0.1288523227,
-0.0723787695,
0.4697138071,
0.2193062752,
-0.0247790646,
1.3177970648,
-0.4163497984,
-0.3883965611,
-0.1160077453,
0.2159865201,
0.5460430384,
0.2951207161,
0.5760846138,
-0.2086623162,
-0.6380990148,
-0.3128035963,
-0.4766025245,
-0.7193166018,
-0.0011016668,
-0.2041052729,
0.1453726441,
0.0142558031,
-0.2866433561,
0.4363620579,
0.2426154912,
-0.268201232,
0.6350999475,
0.0024649752,
0.0920208767,
-0.7683033943,
0.0546446256,
0.1948913187,
-0.3510617912,
-0.6264668703,
-0.303090781,
0.2552405596,
0.1333059967,
-0.6836063266,
0.8330731988,
-0.3960100412,
0.1029439121,
-0.4373134375,
0.2040763944,
0.0070616268,
0.6412031054,
0.0209635049,
0.817379415,
0.8150405288,
-0.6746668816,
-0.0929782018,
-0.0708534047,
0.07371106,
0.6970536709,
-0.5845665336,
0.3490765691,
-0.3879657984,
0.3817960322,
-0.7537615895,
0.1885780096,
0.4694542587,
-0.4214556515,
0.3535995781,
-0.444583565,
-0.2479806989,
0.0208640341,
-0.6528015137,
0.4849523604,
0.5569972992,
-0.4802400768,
0.2763923705,
0.140044108,
-0.3658437133,
-0.7822591066,
-0.3028844595,
-0.3779712915,
-0.0016436141,
-0.2117620111,
0.0876644105,
-0.2670342624,
0.1924657673,
-0.259458065,
-0.1276091784,
0.2468493432,
-0.0794174522,
0.1034492701,
0.5033682585,
-0.169048816,
0.1150879487,
0.2821353078,
-0.227941826,
-0.0970068872,
-0.5809912682,
0.6961322427,
0.0342372805,
-0.4738214612,
-0.3516682386,
0.0431655906,
0.1497744173,
0.0205844734,
0.614149332,
0.6050511003,
-0.3108667433,
-0.3462295234,
-0.656339705,
-0.57891047,
-0.4516899586,
0.234991774,
-0.2046468258,
-0.9456626773,
0.4255524874,
0.1030930653,
0.1347820461,
0.2866554558,
0.6907781363,
0.1565573663,
1.0092238188,
0.4970003366,
-0.415920943,
0.6590633988,
0.0295993313,
0.1192735583,
-0.6267169714,
0.0485639386,
-0.6202425957,
-0.1750815064,
-0.2128470391,
-0.5279915929,
0.4270364642,
0.0783071294,
-0.3878610432,
-0.1303272396,
-0.3209803402,
0.6808276176,
0.7722189426,
0.1808499098,
0.070029892,
0.0304626245,
-0.4126442075,
-0.3213588893,
-0.5637305379,
-0.5675148368,
1.10212183,
0.3704706132,
0.8994405866,
-0.1415101439,
0.7380648851,
0.3375382423,
0.3324882984,
-0.7554062605,
0.3081449866,
0.2232206464,
-0.4410919845,
-0.3399201632,
-0.7949467301,
-0.4807630479,
0.1433221251,
0.0072770827,
-0.6211035252,
0.3649959564,
0.584944725,
-0.581735909,
-0.0261077341,
-0.7500854731,
0.7774499655,
-0.260671556,
-0.7970520854,
0.0311212633,
-0.5670444369,
0.2609279156,
-0.1472949684,
0.0872556418,
-0.3298661411,
0.1423459351,
0.5483184457,
-0.2710565627,
0.9979178309,
-0.7506337762,
-0.1781468242,
0.0219394695,
0.0951682702,
0.5512142181,
0.2785139084,
-0.1960264593,
0.1796303242,
-0.2871353626,
-0.4712926149,
-0.5597354174,
0.5746908784,
-0.8381929398,
-0.3461560011,
-0.6071232557,
-0.1665387154,
-0.4347643554,
0.2375801206,
0.3177747726,
0.3906412423,
-0.1856501848,
-0.3357887566,
0.7499445081,
-0.418332994,
0.3862368166,
0.8298388124,
-0.047622323,
-0.2088866681,
0.9485083222,
-0.0124089792,
0.2475309074,
0.2642707825,
0.2605007589,
-0.560182333,
-0.2778598964,
-0.611182332,
0.2956594229,
-0.7650788426,
-0.4402466714,
-0.5531883836,
-0.0306788776,
-0.4325911999,
-0.1583207399,
-0.3325471878,
-0.2488181442,
-0.5185028911,
-0.1076760069,
0.2918295264,
0.3135351837,
-0.0808568224,
0.5245364308,
-0.6031793356,
0.0978152156,
0.2854655981,
0.3907023668,
-0.0780250877,
-0.9841384888,
-0.1025254726,
0.3358843327,
-0.3865661025,
-1.058404088,
0.3082405329,
0.2742431164,
0.4561220407,
0.5524900556,
0.1450199336,
0.6282417774,
-0.8100200295,
0.8109301329,
0.22109209,
-1.1864278316,
0.7061001658,
-0.2387343347,
0.6015694141,
0.9453749657,
0.3428239822,
-0.5196707845,
-0.2174694985,
-0.2695640624,
-0.7111152411,
1.0490199327,
-0.0240147077,
0.4158935845,
0.0763207227,
0.2188449949,
0.3174060583,
0.18040286,
-0.8926823139,
-0.436506629,
-0.3488227427,
-0.2508478761,
-0.0675807446,
-0.1590114534,
0.1149981692,
-0.2599580288,
0.9243721962,
-0.5302830935,
0.0852059275,
0.0257909149,
-0.5085813403,
-0.2150474191,
0.4263879955,
0.5179218054,
0.3857744336,
-0.3091035485,
0.1600943208,
0.2997580469,
-0.4449938536,
0.3359069824,
0.1896029711,
-0.5986799002,
0.0580556095,
-0.0662670806,
1.1137825251,
0.1346375644,
-0.470408231,
0.8780270815,
-0.1766349524,
0.0026958415,
0.079580158,
-0.023170989,
-0.4184354544,
-0.0515357964,
0.7084598541,
-0.0075789928,
0.0922047049,
-0.2043551207,
0.2251330614,
0.4583065808,
-0.5016238093,
-0.5521895885,
0.467590332,
0.3930290341,
-0.003222449,
0.4250333905,
-0.4446170628,
-0.7656224966,
0.0548765138,
0.4240745008,
1.0126912594,
-0.3279699087,
0.4621048868,
0.4626482427,
0.2930750549,
0.0640028641,
0.1016214043,
-0.3962315023,
-0.9079301953,
-0.6328625679,
-0.6329512596,
-0.5040184855,
0.0763315111,
-0.2841025591,
0.5636371374,
-0.4769482911,
-0.1110925525,
-0.3567868471,
0.1439975649,
-0.812456429,
0.0704214275,
0.4258783758,
0.6898334622,
-1.0071027279,
0.6079961658,
0.465347141,
-0.5032343268,
-0.8098894358,
0.0839442983,
0.1725346148,
-0.7630489469,
0.6520372629,
0.2680368125,
-0.1731561422,
0.2606317401,
-0.6021957397,
-0.694532454,
0.731633842,
0.7699584961,
-0.6354022622,
0.0937323645,
0.0844293535,
0.2377695441,
-0.1721735448,
0.995115459,
0.2615816295,
0.2726834416,
0.1483436078,
-0.7265252471,
-0.006628036,
-0.1696171314,
-0.1600066572,
0.0004710701,
-0.2631018162,
0.6308812499,
0.0027473993,
-0.2226673961,
-0.4539267421,
0.5399643779,
0.5100126266,
0.189642787,
0.564139843,
0.2711387277,
0.6910936832,
-0.0452913344,
0.6073058844,
-0.2948494256,
0.3811914623,
1.0740071535,
-0.7554190159,
0.5348638892,
0.4833617508,
0.0004758676,
0.2970514297,
0.713934958,
0.4316360652,
0.6244425178,
0.1065966263,
-0.6000325084,
-0.071809046,
-0.1525004506,
-0.370646894,
-0.0715976432,
0.1891315281,
-0.1106885895,
-0.50938344,
0.0639970824,
0.0346592031,
-0.2166628093,
-0.2979361117,
0.7006793022,
0.0744870007,
-0.6179556847,
0.503146112,
-0.1304087192,
1.0033359528,
-0.6635602713,
-0.052444119,
-0.4637106955,
0.0205102488,
-0.0375160463,
-0.4560396969,
-0.2073990852,
0.2219819874,
-0.2118958533,
-0.3776890635,
0.7382612228,
-0.5094773769,
-0.2208721042,
0.1052278578,
0.604629457,
-0.0167348329,
-0.2428529263,
-0.6675295234,
0.0249123983,
0.0225790329,
-0.2799445689,
0.3343452513,
0.3330079615,
0.1242489442,
0.2600175738,
0.7028300762,
0.2637432814,
0.1786152422,
0.5639322996,
0.9225376248,
-0.5754618645,
-0.6730763912,
-0.9431633353,
0.6171150208,
-0.0717812777,
-0.2951078117,
0.7028416395,
0.2680532634,
0.8462298512,
-0.0845315754,
0.8968488574,
0.1057450026,
0.5621013045,
-0.5332319736,
0.5887037516,
-0.2786480188,
0.2921748161,
-0.5623156428,
-1.1212459803,
-0.2686747909,
0.8283321261,
-0.5299355984,
0.2706057727,
0.5693170428,
0.948055923,
-0.0629763007,
-0.141073212,
0.5030474663,
0.0881518722,
0.246419251,
0.4121132195,
0.8961559534,
-0.2148204446,
0.0427885465,
-0.147800073,
-0.635741055,
-0.1721128076,
-0.9898231626,
-0.8707991838,
-0.2870603204,
-0.2617534697,
-0.1500131637,
0.1708422899,
1.2247310877,
0.7433755994,
-0.8665070534,
0.0254177526,
-0.0425935611,
0.129536584,
0.2088190466,
-0.2431009263,
0.1728219241,
-0.7529194355,
-0.7907764316,
0.2809573114,
0.3265225589,
-0.0936010256,
-0.376013875,
-0.3160175681,
-0.0634958595,
0.015672151,
0.5877313018,
0.3255446851,
-0.4413860142,
-0.2221149951,
0.2144359946,
-0.0820143595,
-0.0374148414,
0.7252624631,
-1.1103129387,
0.4573641717,
0.4121327996,
0.8027047515,
0.3443019092,
-0.1286468655,
0.6397669315,
-1.128269434,
0.2933885157,
0.5160385966,
0.2370484173,
0.3689459562,
-0.378072381,
0.1105395257,
0.3200138509,
-0.608640492,
-0.893163085,
0.108999297,
-0.7418800592,
0.076092869,
1.0709739923,
0.0056520505,
-0.1795009524,
-0.0160417445,
-0.3981198967,
0.3149057031,
-0.7454739213,
0.5609874725,
0.5214918852,
0.2627838254,
-0.2900300324,
-0.3353603482,
0.4324244261,
0.7645106912,
-0.6539843082,
-0.0389685705,
0.8270737529,
0.2475728691,
-0.2468996942,
0.9194138646,
0.1272161603,
0.3885708749,
-0.5091038942,
0.2011273503,
0.1635134369,
-0.1986446232,
-0.8893367052,
-0.2130428851,
0.0825041085,
-0.0925158188
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19669v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19669v2
|
Analyzing the Roles of Language and Vision in Learning from Limited Data
| 2024-02-15T22:19:41 | 2024-05-10T17:33:24 |
Allison Chen, Ilia Sucholutsky, Olga Russakovsky, Thomas L. Griffiths
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Does language help make sense of the visual world? How important is it to
actually see the world rather than having it described with words? These basic
questions about the nature of intelligence have been difficult to answer
because we only had one example of an intelligent system -- humans -- and
limited access to cases that isolated language or vision. However, the
development of sophisticated Vision-Language Models (VLMs) by artificial
intelligence researchers offers us new opportunities to explore the
contributions that language and vision make to learning about the world. We
ablate components from the cognitive architecture of these models to identify
their contributions to learning new tasks from limited data. We find that a
language model leveraging all components recovers a majority of a VLM's
performance, despite its lack of visual input, and that language seems to allow
this by providing access to prior knowledge and reasoning.
|
[
-0.3268548548,
-0.6918857098,
0.7789924145,
-0.3104772866,
-0.0621087812,
-0.0643264726,
-0.1674773395,
-0.8409289122,
-0.1490138024,
0.7445834279,
-0.4251127541,
-0.0764311031,
-0.4747723639,
-0.1964198649,
-0.337733835,
0.7066046596,
0.3079667091,
0.1364174336,
-0.6573852897,
-0.1866166294,
-0.2919691801,
-0.4249849319,
-0.4549376965,
-0.4501588345,
0.5840347409,
0.4650813341,
0.7225547433,
0.8192093968,
0.7221327424,
0.2906927764,
0.2813762128,
-0.0544145666,
-0.4163268805,
-0.0486257002,
-0.2886794508,
-0.7872312665,
-0.1777846366,
-0.0715837106,
0.5411874056,
1.1267417669,
0.2225381583,
0.3384918869,
0.0342965387,
0.7443704009,
-0.5419551134,
0.668532908,
-0.6811932921,
0.0870825499,
-0.1817866862,
0.0206400119,
-0.3429410756,
0.0924021304,
0.4670105875,
-0.7737847567,
0.1909070313,
0.144172743,
0.7956943512,
0.6109179854,
-0.2868641317,
-0.0424228907,
-0.9888011813,
1.0258015394,
-0.1157252789,
0.5804424286,
0.4559743404,
0.4355847239,
-0.0826205015,
-0.6520673633,
-0.6357056499,
-0.2571370006,
0.0086212354,
0.1965483129,
-0.114829272,
-0.0480509587,
0.3034819365,
0.0013610998,
-0.3556836247,
-0.0952783898,
-0.8636453152,
-0.1837699562,
0.7325354815,
0.3151639402,
0.6069483757,
0.0306327529,
-0.2185610533,
-0.3820625842,
-0.6517656446,
0.2758345902,
0.007855637,
0.2436612844,
0.0153035456,
0.8355675936,
-0.2117176205,
0.9742634296,
-0.6577107906,
-0.110717997,
0.0572511144,
-0.1904787868,
-0.2805692852,
-0.2409181595,
0.1940565705,
0.2421415746,
0.510445118,
0.0033755265,
-0.2675685883,
0.4057209492,
0.2832280397,
-0.4604246616,
-0.5292763114,
-0.317050755,
-0.4367667139,
0.0823849663,
0.0652501509,
-0.642350316,
-0.6283892393,
-0.5812388659,
0.3114494979,
-0.409440279,
-0.2287914008,
0.0038303984,
-0.4432140887,
0.4091985226,
0.6189758182,
-0.7903085947,
0.5240254402,
0.5834310055,
0.306191951,
-0.1597717553,
-0.4961711764,
-0.3265907168,
-0.0259468164,
-0.4738250673,
0.8506967425,
-0.7489994764,
-0.0769117549,
-0.0835710689,
-0.1875739545,
-0.0087231733,
-0.5286376476,
0.1316714734,
-0.4872458577,
-0.0592344552,
-0.4813682139,
-0.4608867466,
-0.4121547341,
-0.048121959,
-0.8004290462,
0.5309442282,
0.2058443278,
-0.4719462991,
0.581181705,
-0.6441874504,
-0.4316710234,
0.5021739006,
-0.6191117167,
-0.0855111107,
0.5520396829,
0.0567802861,
0.233265385,
-0.1929747611,
-0.1786772162,
-0.171051845,
-0.1521670073,
0.4757481217,
-0.388723731,
0.8137159944,
0.1984751076,
-0.079532139,
-0.1158028245,
-0.8124246001,
0.0396096781,
0.4188748896,
-0.4358610213,
-0.5437637568,
0.5073251724,
0.0926664397,
-0.0649061203,
0.3017497659,
-0.3917369246,
0.0118666738,
-0.4071238339,
0.3167923391,
0.6508305073,
-0.3054200411,
0.6167274117,
-0.2269233465,
0.3783805668,
0.0266921557,
0.3528964221,
-0.0315098576,
-0.6369817257,
-1.1695523262,
-0.205817461,
0.1155119389,
0.6284002662,
-1.0225541592,
-0.2280256897,
-0.1269117743,
-0.2094968259,
-0.6440992355,
0.4369898438,
0.1191750765,
0.4170875847,
0.190103963,
-0.2820335329,
-0.6248013377,
-0.915476501,
-0.0489353053,
-0.4140588343,
-0.1062123179,
0.5597240925,
0.5729340911,
-0.0823745951,
0.8824875951,
-0.418122977,
-0.1404545903,
-0.5873935223,
-0.4039588273,
-0.0710205063,
0.2773226798,
0.7113990188,
-0.9516168833,
-0.2558118105,
0.1381225139,
-1.0980952978,
0.1098093018,
-0.1179362014,
-0.1456232071,
-0.0692146048,
0.4472309351,
-0.4680457413,
0.7386602759,
0.3370836079,
-0.4046099782,
0.0980057567,
-0.3145816326,
-0.3496826589,
-0.2254882306,
-0.0535023324,
-0.1217722148,
-0.1725614667,
-0.8239379525,
0.1826928258,
-0.097083576,
-0.1767854095,
-0.4655697644,
0.6834262013,
-0.5886519551,
-0.3518590331,
-0.2913833857,
0.252561897,
-0.0990566388,
0.5078228712,
0.0693793818,
0.3143698573,
0.8364969492,
-0.6401293874,
0.3363277316,
0.1132196933,
-0.5559092164,
0.501368165,
-0.3891209066,
-0.10378059,
-0.5444523096,
-0.3493161798,
-0.7762035728,
-0.3739489317,
0.2182523012,
-0.4837908149,
0.1575612128,
0.2278565168,
-0.0828366652,
-0.3285906911,
0.1338089108,
0.4170782864,
0.6633012891,
-0.3346805871,
0.7239852548,
0.7930462956,
0.0139152026,
-0.2844214439,
-0.7547560334,
-0.0044389535,
0.1206584051,
-0.2876089513,
-0.0522524193,
-0.0650166124,
-0.7750923038,
0.2993168831,
-0.113605395,
-0.2907547057,
0.4479571581,
0.4373574555,
0.476513952,
-0.2665617764,
0.2586637735,
-0.5488458276,
-0.014133771,
0.0249903221,
-0.3911209106,
0.3526555896,
-0.1912433356,
-0.4724166393,
-0.1690824926,
0.4350059927,
0.7231151462,
-0.5049493313,
0.5967690945,
0.1453362256,
-0.4352993071,
-0.4267043769,
-0.3143960834,
-0.1253531575,
-0.3878988624,
0.6590933204,
-0.2046986371,
-0.5413196683,
0.2435687482,
0.2288199663,
-0.0969381779,
0.3809380829,
0.3672251999,
-0.2145255208,
0.9762345552,
1.2319873571,
-0.074176535,
0.8076653481,
-0.2787701488,
0.2277447879,
-0.4922455847,
-0.4834035039,
-0.2899300754,
-0.2454462349,
-0.361559242,
-0.4556446671,
0.3688541651,
-0.0395935066,
-0.0357773155,
-0.1256937236,
-0.3688778877,
0.6374920607,
1.0229619741,
0.1823288649,
0.1018446758,
0.114624612,
0.081444867,
0.1482614875,
-0.8961230516,
-0.4031012952,
1.0414153337,
0.1419020295,
0.7001145482,
-0.1857478917,
0.5325009227,
0.1026030481,
0.1440231055,
-0.8160933256,
0.7278409004,
-0.0623444244,
-0.3788467646,
-0.3112198412,
-0.2283452898,
-1.0070269108,
0.3029532731,
-0.3841122687,
-0.6013762355,
0.1561419368,
0.0665712506,
-0.1927938759,
0.162840873,
-0.7064660192,
0.7413401604,
-0.5581871867,
-0.1667221189,
-0.2295308411,
-0.5793502927,
0.2529321015,
0.0748556629,
0.3719989955,
-0.062627703,
-0.0861271098,
0.6935018301,
-0.1722701341,
0.9112178087,
-0.2363869399,
0.3486771286,
0.3990268409,
-0.1157992184,
0.0809864402,
-0.1634823531,
0.2811225951,
0.1697108001,
-0.1272576749,
-0.6235184073,
-0.6091589332,
0.2944729328,
-0.7550543547,
-0.7285822034,
-0.2430413365,
-0.7539918423,
-0.0726659372,
0.3259381652,
-0.0018853217,
0.2840251327,
-0.2009840012,
0.3350028098,
0.6493139863,
-0.265104264,
0.4309059083,
0.4253376424,
-0.4760831594,
0.0291796345,
1.06046772,
0.1307056844,
0.1437497735,
0.3766823113,
0.0987390727,
0.0369369015,
-0.706065774,
-0.2832530737,
0.1486856937,
-0.9060239792,
0.1137677804,
-0.4034551382,
-0.3496841192,
-0.0031934993,
-0.0415075235,
-0.0675902739,
-0.4295333624,
-0.2051520348,
-0.1427879632,
0.1212670729,
1.0347751379,
-0.0663623437,
0.0128830438,
-0.566465795,
0.3104803562,
0.6331386566,
0.0015908168,
-0.0212772489,
0.0686217397,
-0.4525743723,
0.0844039619,
0.124870725,
-0.7222602367,
0.3546484113,
0.4348314106,
0.979876101,
0.2270521671,
-0.0862508267,
0.5643157363,
-0.6503753662,
0.8439226747,
0.0033923541,
-0.5773031712,
0.5581770539,
0.106839709,
0.4574353993,
0.3266393542,
0.0677184016,
-0.1952008903,
-0.5089797378,
-0.422188282,
-0.7408587337,
0.5447720885,
0.0466731973,
0.1194979921,
0.0969891697,
0.1834156662,
-0.0846513957,
0.2416118234,
-0.7645471096,
0.0095136315,
-0.2191571891,
-0.4008384347,
-0.0186305717,
-0.0227517113,
-0.1764899641,
-0.3966217041,
0.1227693185,
-0.2156281024,
0.204390645,
0.195537895,
-0.414390862,
-0.0373814106,
-0.1387501061,
0.3774752021,
0.7003220916,
0.4479679465,
0.3445889354,
0.0448891073,
-0.6194807887,
-0.3675183356,
-0.224605009,
-0.3859321773,
-0.2900240421,
0.7258108258,
1.008503437,
-0.1329947412,
-1.1348356009,
0.419781208,
-0.0899413377,
-0.0187232587,
-0.3541531563,
0.4381114841,
-0.1719301194,
0.7240392566,
0.5346257091,
0.4301749766,
-0.0372599959,
-0.8035609722,
0.2038599551,
0.6125642061,
-0.3468146622,
-0.4037671089,
0.5946739316,
-0.1127660647,
-0.3680909574,
0.8045987487,
0.201557532,
-0.5908529758,
0.785849154,
0.2898191512,
0.5227953792,
-0.0791416168,
0.2167951465,
-0.0539583303,
0.4849337935,
0.0967798308,
0.482522279,
-0.2800968885,
-0.9645773172,
-0.1425056607,
-0.743000865,
-0.2029155046,
-0.0748252198,
-0.5359844565,
-0.1949668974,
-0.6435190439,
0.1641235203,
0.0810083523,
-0.2203854024,
-1.2055053711,
0.3648135066,
0.5119006038,
0.7470332384,
-0.8975410461,
0.9333555698,
0.6484230757,
-0.5122857094,
-0.6813214421,
-0.2355341166,
-0.2171141207,
-1.073089838,
1.0726653337,
0.0112414556,
-0.155737862,
-0.1321156472,
-0.7892732024,
-0.8640936613,
0.7890755534,
0.4673018456,
-0.327241838,
0.0335786492,
0.1988054216,
0.7089896202,
-0.4440546334,
-0.1787315458,
0.3771494627,
0.4359607399,
-0.084444277,
-0.5798758268,
-0.2302079052,
-0.339582473,
-0.0781357437,
0.1198098883,
-0.3690564036,
1.0130139589,
-0.4293178618,
-0.4137228131,
-0.0932520777,
0.6392588019,
-0.2104690522,
0.3410882056,
0.4468937516,
0.2686006129,
0.8406950831,
-0.0525266081,
1.1144515276,
-0.0093425801,
0.0697145313,
0.8605136275,
-0.2343890518,
1.0426324606,
0.6092854142,
-0.0888772011,
0.3412166536,
0.2767671943,
-0.0708160251,
0.7708083391,
0.0605051853,
-0.1455189437,
-0.4877457917,
-0.2556289136,
0.0422282666,
0.7488336563,
0.5545903444,
-0.2587129176,
-0.0784357041,
0.3686885834,
-0.5282719135,
0.0684152097,
-0.5001550317,
0.8158237338,
0.0854180008,
-0.6357973218,
0.2624492645,
-0.6035931706,
0.1144964248,
-0.433829397,
-0.3145157099,
-0.1503773779,
0.2770385742,
-0.0323589742,
-0.6441977024,
0.3605840206,
-0.1445412189,
-0.1900859922,
-0.0896154195,
0.7829430103,
-0.3573190272,
-0.7458336353,
0.3747743964,
0.8107551932,
0.2042204738,
0.2517682314,
-0.5326973796,
0.1398014277,
0.0913784802,
-0.0937251151,
0.3506684303,
0.4003825188,
-0.1515705287,
0.8654016256,
0.4905390143,
0.3389562368,
0.30477494,
-0.1480480731,
0.7475258112,
-0.7723516822,
-0.1772236377,
-0.8508973122,
0.4163382947,
-0.1120992377,
0.0120400665,
0.6448760629,
0.3697675765,
1.1555857658,
-0.2523743808,
0.9961662889,
-0.1032828242,
0.1906850487,
-0.5993064642,
0.6391689777,
-0.9177898765,
0.0970654413,
-0.001861251,
-0.6734275818,
-0.5636036396,
0.8234825134,
-0.2322995961,
-0.4143429101,
0.6595174074,
0.5545025468,
0.1591028273,
-0.1540153027,
0.7386837602,
0.2861290276,
0.1209529936,
0.7850247025,
1.0271116495,
-0.042298384,
0.6206245422,
-0.1050019562,
-0.2270845622,
-0.0932858884,
-0.3585206568,
-0.9009956121,
-0.7494513392,
-0.0592605174,
0.2229014933,
-0.1165455431,
0.5608212948,
0.61171031,
-0.5304749608,
-0.2967488468,
-0.187943399,
0.236825645,
-0.2764635682,
-0.1653046757,
0.0708977953,
-0.3151054978,
-0.7034213543,
0.5470793843,
0.5726857185,
0.2153468281,
-0.3785535395,
-0.0117329918,
0.2276729643,
0.2165767252,
0.6658399701,
0.4676405489,
-0.8285658956,
-0.4786120653,
0.1393914819,
0.0193975847,
0.1047760025,
0.7688540816,
-0.9868418574,
0.5106574893,
0.6452496648,
0.7937785983,
0.3239890039,
-0.4524793625,
0.5466658473,
-0.3291797042,
0.383570224,
0.2695636749,
0.6186981797,
0.3761888742,
-0.2429314256,
0.3593545258,
0.2969230115,
-0.3671358526,
-0.7081135511,
0.5603871942,
-0.8651754856,
-0.5266242027,
0.7284046412,
-0.0327905118,
-0.814723134,
-0.2506340444,
-0.3569148779,
0.0320941135,
0.039557375,
0.6716191173,
0.5801459551,
-0.3520452678,
-0.4719279408,
-0.9103896022,
0.4897177517,
0.3027315736,
-0.8083269,
-0.1179693118,
0.7362191677,
0.0603760555,
0.2714143991,
0.5179442763,
0.196696952,
0.2513515353,
0.2830124199,
-0.3516664505,
0.1034035087,
-0.8438349962,
-0.2089625001,
0.2726570666,
0.2986290753,
-0.3384302258
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10342v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10342v1
|
Exploration-Driven Policy Optimization in RLHF: Theoretical Insights on Efficient Data Utilization
| 2024-02-15T22:11:18 | 2024-02-15T22:11:18 |
Yihan Du, Anna Winnicki, Gal Dalal, Shie Mannor, R. Srikant
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) has achieved impressive
empirical successes while relying on a small amount of human feedback. However,
there is limited theoretical justification for this phenomenon. Additionally,
most recent studies focus on value-based algorithms despite the recent
empirical successes of policy-based algorithms. In this work, we consider an
RLHF algorithm based on policy optimization (PO-RLHF). The algorithm is based
on the popular Policy Cover-Policy Gradient (PC-PG) algorithm, which assumes
knowledge of the reward function. In PO-RLHF, knowledge of the reward function
is not assumed and the algorithm relies on trajectory-based comparison feedback
to infer the reward function. We provide performance bounds for PO-RLHF with
low query complexity, which provides insight into why a small amount of human
feedback may be sufficient to get good performance with RLHF. A key novelty is
our trajectory-level elliptical potential analysis technique used to infer
reward function parameters when comparison queries rather than reward
observations are used. We provide and analyze algorithms in two settings:
linear and neural function approximation, PG-RLHF and NN-PG-RLHF, respectively.
|
[
-0.3792529106,
-0.6596639752,
0.6714936495,
0.2304279655,
0.0841873661,
0.0507103726,
-0.2294981629,
-0.3689424396,
0.3362062275,
0.5584935546,
-1.0923471451,
-0.3120443523,
-0.1256473064,
-0.3281523585,
0.2156101614,
0.7572043538,
-0.0469619781,
-0.2474930584,
-0.2532860637,
-0.0674529672,
-0.3186799288,
-0.3995170593,
-0.5991691351,
-0.5461149216,
0.7377588749,
0.4410555363,
0.4426057041,
0.6669454575,
0.4016566277,
0.0592645407,
-0.144380495,
0.4685259461,
-0.8330714107,
-0.0802380219,
0.0036887678,
-0.3401550055,
-0.0120832315,
-0.1578967571,
0.7179403305,
0.5520267487,
-0.5896511078,
-0.3680688441,
-0.0935752764,
0.9046468139,
-0.9755108953,
0.2495773882,
-0.1934152842,
0.4845070839,
0.0765911117,
-0.5288066268,
-0.2631604373,
-0.5372332335,
0.4287742376,
-1.0938181877,
-0.1160522327,
0.1681282967,
0.819073379,
0.1817128062,
-0.241575703,
-0.184738636,
-0.8429836035,
0.9756205678,
-0.3422209918,
0.1322026253,
0.4398755133,
0.4422191679,
-0.3670302331,
-0.2818493247,
-0.3170541823,
-0.5631438494,
-0.0596795492,
0.1254227012,
0.0914246216,
0.5086149573,
0.1780086011,
0.3329767883,
-0.3584414423,
0.3184456825,
-0.1227365732,
-0.3136972487,
0.8264255524,
0.2924421728,
-0.2840936184,
-0.0953389928,
-0.5271348953,
-0.6956906319,
-0.9102245569,
0.8400247097,
0.6227554679,
0.2353844494,
0.0210584011,
0.3513989449,
-0.3949012756,
0.6047136188,
-0.1617406905,
0.0315317623,
0.1758056432,
-0.1599253863,
0.0518543907,
-0.2631284893,
0.5620282292,
0.3888142705,
0.1718816757,
-0.1963400245,
-0.4798904955,
-0.3073253334,
0.3878558576,
-0.6892009377,
0.0795686319,
0.0401260592,
-0.4523620605,
-0.4036462605,
0.3473792076,
-1.0369957685,
-0.4741589129,
0.0067374418,
0.3776924908,
0.0403847136,
-0.2416435629,
0.0633419156,
-0.125335291,
0.333740294,
0.2796517015,
-0.8013205528,
0.4155288339,
0.6935319304,
0.6225174665,
-0.5876358151,
-0.4422543645,
-0.8326948881,
-0.3055167496,
-0.3068518639,
0.5481665134,
-0.3266901076,
-0.7735699415,
0.416098088,
-0.1255886853,
-0.0879797861,
-0.6809208989,
0.685515523,
-0.7430556417,
0.0165492911,
-0.5116924047,
-0.388487339,
-0.3833726645,
0.2923048139,
-0.6868518591,
1.1331276894,
0.261801362,
-0.4506011009,
0.6196956635,
-1.1670690775,
-0.3451503217,
-0.2054437101,
-0.1459106505,
-0.6180033684,
-0.0445479006,
0.1156700775,
-0.0128556611,
-0.1846144348,
0.1790051758,
-0.2770266831,
-0.5208138227,
0.1154352054,
-0.4149596691,
0.4205141068,
0.1600678563,
-0.3390460908,
0.4898721576,
-0.480656296,
0.1656689197,
0.1150632128,
-0.4521162808,
-0.0634247065,
0.401326865,
0.0770656839,
-0.121828109,
0.0823328495,
-0.3992392421,
0.3432138264,
-0.2467104793,
0.3238334954,
0.7096906304,
0.4069254994,
0.5191451311,
-0.3641482294,
1.0233169794,
-0.5097427964,
0.311309427,
-0.0408345051,
-0.1550887972,
-0.0907110497,
-0.0806511268,
0.4214152396,
0.4985467792,
-0.3954995871,
0.2920494974,
0.1196636111,
-0.1683495343,
-0.2860576212,
-0.2716868818,
0.3853570819,
0.6152455807,
0.3593981266,
-0.1997599006,
-0.1830426753,
-0.910633862,
-0.3022966385,
-0.2138321847,
0.2455680668,
1.0255805254,
0.1625994742,
-0.1425934285,
0.8824895024,
-0.6445228457,
-0.1677376777,
-0.2038464993,
0.0813537017,
0.3571079969,
0.3533980846,
0.4244319201,
-0.5735740066,
-0.3447754681,
0.011598276,
-0.4753699303,
0.0138932569,
-0.2793005705,
-0.1722978503,
-0.0078042834,
0.2366833538,
-0.520524025,
0.6005895734,
0.1994850636,
-0.2935994864,
0.4423910081,
-0.5843835473,
0.0937443376,
0.2923274934,
0.129866749,
-0.0660915822,
-0.3543613255,
-0.2820274532,
0.1371131092,
-0.1033184603,
-0.0573288351,
-0.3542440832,
0.4703564644,
-0.0907725319,
-0.3265931606,
-0.3908222318,
0.0454882607,
-0.2811244428,
0.9892359376,
0.2412219197,
0.7710235119,
0.466355443,
-0.865136385,
0.0537702851,
-0.2428972572,
-0.0144972662,
0.202421248,
-0.5551071167,
0.0403103419,
-0.1571136266,
0.2255386412,
-0.6004834771,
-0.0329717398,
0.4406061769,
-0.0976432934,
0.2047553957,
-0.0967613682,
-0.0211824588,
-0.1863406748,
-0.6348297,
0.5142943263,
0.3889512122,
-0.6276285052,
0.4345176518,
0.6061825156,
0.2360545695,
-0.8131004572,
-0.1368527859,
-0.4996266663,
-0.4427773952,
-0.3282389045,
0.6239172816,
0.2900265157,
0.0424769074,
0.0171708595,
-0.2104243338,
0.1508979499,
0.1173619255,
0.139180854,
0.2325433344,
0.2050873488,
-0.0310837477,
0.1132999137,
-0.1361782402,
0.3383156955,
-0.3465516567,
0.539070785,
-0.1945505291,
-0.3964056373,
-0.2890638113,
0.0998707339,
0.2226742953,
-0.0507756695,
0.2540130019,
0.3982295394,
-0.0760681108,
-0.3415060341,
-0.042330455,
-0.590952456,
-0.3707690537,
0.5717551112,
-0.1187468544,
-0.6506807208,
0.3602392375,
-0.0507437587,
0.2647864521,
0.468546778,
0.1445529461,
-0.0861179084,
0.6990363002,
0.5109679103,
-0.0233493187,
0.6871807575,
-0.5247555375,
-0.1919750869,
-0.5005182624,
-0.3731309474,
-0.1891355962,
-0.5257174373,
-1.029181242,
-0.2562715411,
0.5386134982,
0.0109062176,
-0.2375224978,
0.0617012903,
-0.4276356399,
0.380212456,
0.698097527,
0.2347677946,
0.0922591686,
0.1305851638,
0.0503696203,
-0.0914462656,
-1.0665396452,
0.1395512819,
1.2654497623,
0.5459336638,
0.7891017795,
-0.3179236054,
0.8056171536,
0.614398241,
0.0586606562,
-0.8290567398,
0.2534050643,
0.2521443069,
-0.1074914187,
-0.7341066599,
-0.651170969,
-1.1991847754,
0.4409763217,
-0.2778054774,
-0.5836622119,
0.3491076529,
0.5632138252,
-0.6504247189,
0.0262875184,
-0.3554733694,
0.6999537945,
-0.5428732038,
-0.5861372948,
-0.5737161636,
-0.588762939,
0.1762545258,
0.5091033578,
-0.0260762032,
0.1642096043,
0.0884921402,
0.8656527996,
-0.3823235929,
0.3138089478,
-0.976357758,
0.0701973885,
0.4148373306,
-0.0710076541,
0.7888363004,
0.2766757905,
0.2568508089,
-0.0773065165,
0.0023341526,
-0.332764864,
-0.6316000819,
0.4929153621,
-0.8621778488,
-0.3244811893,
-0.5925350189,
-0.3767721951,
-0.3875417709,
0.1427681744,
0.1407586038,
0.0096060485,
-0.1650330573,
0.1571631134,
0.8423541784,
-0.3086937964,
0.4197788537,
0.0896744654,
-0.6975227594,
-0.2902631164,
0.9179961085,
-0.1964964122,
0.085030444,
0.5943787694,
0.4741201699,
-0.7100548744,
-0.2588522732,
-0.4254409969,
0.2491254658,
-0.2385828197,
0.09036538,
-0.1319390088,
0.0097122286,
0.2706918716,
0.1732353419,
-0.4929152429,
-0.2930852771,
-0.0713531598,
0.0480049103,
0.1802023351,
0.6352094412,
-0.311868757,
0.3122033775,
-0.1753243804,
0.1460359544,
0.3441324234,
0.277692467,
0.065229632,
-0.1566315442,
-0.2813797593,
0.1391908675,
-0.4495132267,
-0.7577416897,
0.2851565778,
0.0031995452,
0.7612440586,
0.479018718,
0.08539702,
0.3583365977,
0.0171247851,
0.3824726641,
-0.0537526309,
-0.3162651956,
0.2723671496,
-0.2324693799,
-0.1597452015,
0.5978959203,
0.1417376697,
-0.4433903992,
0.4678173363,
-0.6634076834,
-0.8046221137,
0.9023605585,
0.0688968077,
-0.2733774185,
0.6637635827,
0.575432241,
-0.0947514325,
0.4203199744,
-0.6283041835,
-0.2666221261,
-0.0713848248,
0.4199085534,
0.0591433607,
0.1176422015,
-0.2706716061,
0.0553011224,
0.5707468987,
-0.2557875216,
0.5268112421,
0.2654613554,
0.1546592116,
-0.2045718431,
0.0223779287,
0.7847412825,
0.5701568127,
-0.4408880174,
-0.2732505798,
-0.0793446973,
-0.3151032925,
0.0822505206,
0.0917770863,
-0.4069130123,
-0.3446680605,
-0.0379065908,
1.0373339653,
0.0548698232,
-1.0340166092,
0.4865364432,
-0.0000959128,
-0.336445719,
-0.4228925109,
0.3923681974,
-0.4213678241,
0.2333257347,
0.3589633107,
-0.0115034133,
0.0776926503,
-0.2894279361,
0.1435144395,
0.666590929,
-0.5446606278,
0.0407468677,
0.2589764595,
0.0419485271,
-0.5363859534,
0.6618685126,
-0.3253418207,
-0.5071593523,
0.8204286695,
0.1027137861,
0.731351018,
0.2520492077,
0.3953787684,
0.3357302547,
0.128243655,
-0.1090451106,
0.4098188579,
-0.5311104059,
-0.6817988157,
-0.5513265729,
-0.2259669304,
-0.6467430592,
0.2073418498,
-0.9245510101,
-0.0512608811,
-0.6177222133,
-0.0474704206,
-0.6022916436,
0.2691246569,
-0.5863963962,
-0.1413867623,
-0.3743823469,
0.6715105176,
-0.4814110398,
0.4571034014,
0.3747028708,
-0.0304274485,
-0.6602054834,
0.118034564,
-0.2214898616,
-0.9408817291,
0.4296351969,
-0.012384437,
-0.1843189746,
-0.220688805,
-0.2343571484,
-0.6805301905,
1.197420001,
0.0967561677,
-0.5931415558,
-0.1073008329,
-0.1442863941,
0.3514326215,
-0.3895814121,
0.1943616718,
0.7508815527,
0.7497400045,
-0.0157455094,
-0.5564784408,
-0.3215575218,
0.140047431,
0.1218435094,
0.3550122678,
-0.4659612179,
0.5543035269,
-0.3577132821,
0.0578440614,
-0.2296362817,
0.6613560915,
0.8322678804,
0.4773690999,
0.8335418105,
0.4763497412,
0.7183529139,
0.1125849709,
1.3036264181,
-0.1777885258,
0.7926257849,
0.6571635008,
-0.151397109,
0.6511045098,
0.6498277783,
-0.6807810068,
0.3565506935,
0.9864435792,
0.0688575655,
1.0880627632,
0.6523490548,
-0.1525136977,
0.0012585509,
-0.0335510261,
-0.2090252489,
0.095604986,
0.0644385964,
-0.0544110537,
-0.3275520802,
-0.1368793994,
-0.23730582,
0.0018173082,
-0.5201891065,
0.686060667,
-0.3370911181,
-1.1491323709,
0.4336205721,
0.2669445872,
0.5219528675,
-0.5732045174,
-0.3581238389,
-0.1148881018,
0.0313679166,
-0.1025429964,
-0.6561493278,
0.0386577211,
-0.4922723472,
-0.0264768396,
-0.2873660326,
0.5773809552,
-0.297570765,
0.148592934,
0.3618778288,
0.3979045451,
-0.1609439254,
-0.0715942457,
-0.4636538923,
-0.2190358937,
0.2123715132,
-0.384018451,
0.4244644046,
0.0295658503,
0.0141568929,
0.6551803946,
0.6644082665,
0.4362404644,
0.0493242852,
-0.2681235969,
0.5416102409,
-0.5955352783,
-1.1172640324,
-0.564335227,
0.1690007895,
0.0203967392,
-0.4796206355,
0.0366315916,
0.339312315,
0.7789388895,
0.0042048097,
0.7142689824,
-0.0253398381,
0.4568654597,
-0.7815129757,
0.3785770237,
-0.5729768872,
0.3933788836,
0.0240385178,
-0.8317320347,
-0.0321851932,
0.9126636982,
-0.4123201072,
0.1913316697,
0.4102525413,
0.9908331037,
0.029108813,
0.0414868556,
0.1668920964,
-0.3781352043,
0.3907898068,
0.6668577194,
0.8038561344,
-0.0419571735,
0.3215537369,
-0.4289263189,
-0.4709043205,
-0.4989398122,
-0.9826097488,
-0.4495609999,
-0.1993503571,
0.0682183802,
-0.4052209854,
0.0912823975,
0.9972823262,
0.9025632143,
-0.601505518,
-0.5214848518,
-0.7173048854,
0.4974530339,
-0.6971773505,
-0.3265683949,
0.6462317705,
-0.1819260418,
-0.4397574663,
0.6366581917,
0.2305440456,
-0.3332693279,
-0.6649596095,
-0.8081458807,
-0.0571244173,
-0.1816211641,
0.2282828689,
0.9396848679,
-0.3783155382,
0.0155959288,
0.1312715262,
0.3074695468,
0.1234728247,
1.3362048864,
-0.9498801231,
0.3116762042,
0.3465251625,
1.2259457111,
0.9905232787,
0.1902666837,
0.3610426486,
-0.4561490119,
0.0472904854,
0.4508292377,
0.1365103126,
-0.1155672669,
-0.5656602383,
0.4098569751,
0.3967961669,
-0.7477648258,
-0.8628270626,
0.3742664456,
-0.8278132081,
0.0235637575,
0.9792473912,
-0.2165379077,
-0.1347952038,
0.3141173124,
-0.1760784835,
-0.3670706749,
-0.8784251213,
0.9172304273,
0.406265676,
-0.7971585989,
-0.3664557636,
-0.3457248807,
0.7858847976,
0.5918941498,
-0.8451474905,
-0.0636854991,
0.2459378093,
-0.134832859,
-0.094161272,
0.6503875256,
0.0479334854,
0.5758813024,
-0.342040062,
-0.3380364776,
-0.2679643631,
-0.5482522249,
-0.4309034944,
0.3703821599,
0.1838205606,
-0.461332351
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10979v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10979v2
|
SportsMetrics: Blending Text and Numerical Data to Understand Information Fusion in LLMs
| 2024-02-15T20:26:07 | 2024-06-16T06:43:50 |
Yebowen Hu, Kaiqiang Song, Sangwoo Cho, Xiaoyang Wang, Hassan Foroosh, Dong Yu, Fei Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models hold significant potential for integrating various data
types, such as text documents and database records, for advanced analytics.
However, blending text and numerical data presents substantial challenges. LLMs
need to process and cross-reference entities and numbers, handle data
inconsistencies and redundancies, and develop planning capabilities such as
building a working memory for managing complex data queries. In this paper, we
introduce four novel tasks centered around sports data analytics to evaluate
the numerical reasoning and information fusion capabilities of LLMs. These
tasks involve providing LLMs with detailed, play-by-play sports game
descriptions, then challenging them with adversarial scenarios such as new game
rules, longer durations, scrambled narratives, and analyzing key statistics in
game summaries. We conduct extensive experiments on NBA and NFL games to assess
the performance of LLMs on these tasks. Our benchmark, SportsMetrics,
introduces a new mechanism for assessing LLMs' numerical reasoning and fusion
skills.
|
[
-0.3292476833,
-0.6868796945,
0.4479012787,
0.3656462133,
-0.0640371144,
0.6559901237,
-0.05905696,
-0.5410736203,
0.1932942271,
0.4020035267,
-0.8382424712,
-0.5637329817,
-0.4569935501,
0.179804951,
-0.3332321644,
0.9930361509,
-0.4345131218,
0.3665949702,
-0.6997596622,
-0.2005477846,
-0.5803591013,
-0.701924026,
-0.6090792418,
-0.6170357466,
-0.0495571494,
0.2181793749,
0.6817763448,
0.5858008862,
0.9768743515,
0.3516126871,
0.1667213142,
0.5136636496,
-0.848049283,
0.6301851273,
-0.2293203324,
-0.4369497895,
-0.4268727601,
-0.0511634909,
0.5620020628,
0.7605187893,
0.1345968693,
0.2489482462,
0.0173162334,
0.6511033773,
-0.550039947,
0.3503635824,
-0.3335250616,
0.2814131677,
-0.2617386878,
-0.450378567,
0.0627455637,
-0.3562195897,
-0.0591723584,
-0.6080231667,
0.1052103639,
0.0285894144,
0.5538585782,
0.4085192084,
-0.2827649713,
-0.0965978205,
-1.0978690386,
0.6826246381,
-0.5084187984,
0.479598999,
0.3211168945,
0.4225218594,
-0.2440633774,
-0.1320755482,
-0.4480223954,
0.0107285725,
0.0578424446,
0.4086008072,
-0.1306323558,
-0.0687125996,
0.2517897785,
0.105603382,
-0.5870547891,
0.0819214657,
-0.224150762,
0.2006740421,
1.2289247513,
0.7374482155,
0.1240695864,
0.2744116783,
-0.3552804589,
-0.1206594929,
-0.4879996777,
0.07159926,
0.284681648,
0.1882576197,
-0.0932088271,
0.8171375394,
-0.4822823703,
0.5475873947,
-0.2134512216,
-0.3125478923,
0.0913754627,
-0.5547747016,
-0.285020262,
0.1067596972,
0.7417741418,
0.4582479894,
0.0495267585,
-0.6312348843,
-0.1385054141,
-0.089882955,
-0.068285659,
-0.4126934707,
-0.0492817461,
0.4836250842,
-0.4650263488,
-0.3103129566,
-0.0056935013,
-0.801876843,
-0.8415108323,
-0.4576146305,
0.3015443981,
-0.5239065289,
-0.0632686019,
0.1788583398,
-0.4443673193,
0.3587845564,
0.18936643,
-0.7820859551,
0.4113927186,
0.9870247841,
0.5565822721,
-0.5030209422,
-0.3048241138,
-0.4049183428,
0.3514452577,
-0.18303141,
1.0370069742,
-0.5896928906,
-0.362829566,
0.2349342555,
-0.5760397911,
0.0743222386,
-0.6623619795,
0.3054296076,
-0.3606394827,
-0.2363775223,
-0.1801611483,
-0.8314234018,
-0.0954406187,
0.4799850583,
-0.6094551682,
1.2624670267,
-0.0147614134,
-0.5796439052,
0.4381700456,
-0.6249206662,
-0.6758348942,
0.1522557437,
-0.3279082477,
-0.2964969277,
0.1725796759,
0.0311691929,
0.3976034224,
-0.6123425961,
0.1874312758,
-0.605269134,
-0.3023582995,
0.497616291,
-0.207107231,
0.3556421697,
-0.0364679098,
-0.0660471171,
-0.1427927017,
-0.6190044284,
-0.036053434,
0.0537743308,
-0.2416792363,
-0.2549871504,
0.4772453606,
-0.2709949613,
-0.018371284,
0.1237166896,
-0.1846344769,
0.2752056718,
-0.2725641131,
-0.0835585371,
0.3021466732,
-0.0727310553,
0.4753195047,
-0.4149574041,
0.6014356613,
-0.0179122295,
0.1566763967,
0.0333685018,
-0.5090214014,
-0.2287601233,
0.0151637783,
0.2193689793,
0.9538834691,
-1.1706944704,
0.2579800487,
-0.5227414966,
-0.8048735261,
-0.2557111979,
0.2986066937,
0.0371892229,
0.3274792433,
0.1489734352,
0.0148172025,
-0.5631026626,
-0.6284927726,
-0.5169911981,
-0.0392833091,
0.0891330615,
0.3143661618,
0.442112267,
0.1210730821,
0.7676680684,
-0.7075169683,
-0.2606704831,
-0.2336667478,
0.2777728438,
0.2333990782,
0.2719327807,
0.4198207557,
-0.8712175488,
-0.4097198546,
-0.1369987726,
-1.1887304783,
-0.1752670109,
-0.1224609762,
0.0738172382,
-0.3092432022,
0.398514241,
-0.6452447772,
0.567805469,
0.5325122476,
-0.5189787149,
0.4344623685,
-0.0538042374,
0.5702655315,
-0.5201407671,
0.0269910488,
0.2993526161,
-0.0414056927,
-0.9167941809,
0.0222325008,
-0.4862890244,
0.0232435931,
-0.3148473203,
0.5066714287,
-0.5442833304,
-0.4169342518,
-0.3567172289,
0.0671729669,
-0.1639070064,
0.0413080864,
0.1692991704,
0.6060737371,
0.50563097,
-0.7001145482,
0.9631491303,
0.2359482497,
-0.5506977439,
0.5221195221,
-0.2540117502,
-0.2508935034,
-0.3798763454,
0.2297891825,
-1.1646260023,
-0.1805496961,
0.1313756555,
-0.3457743824,
0.0416795649,
0.1966668367,
-0.6800990701,
-0.3992378116,
-0.4127243459,
0.6836290956,
0.2685654759,
-0.0764223486,
0.9808448553,
0.7577277422,
-0.2875474393,
-0.407913059,
-0.5140789747,
0.1233125553,
-0.3930721879,
-0.5574122667,
0.5376740694,
-0.1487040818,
-0.5382145643,
0.1919870079,
-0.0563610867,
-0.5295165181,
0.1467906386,
-0.0108611761,
0.5318698883,
-0.31202209,
-0.0974532887,
-0.0663303584,
0.007194479,
0.0869097188,
0.1915535927,
0.3869883716,
0.3580703437,
-0.1909921616,
-0.2519066334,
0.5052288175,
0.2811361551,
0.0880785733,
0.6446487904,
0.3633083999,
-0.3605199158,
0.0634405985,
-0.6168377399,
-0.0752930939,
-0.4030683637,
0.355781734,
-0.3686111569,
-0.6953370571,
0.7579240799,
-0.1650522053,
0.3403272629,
0.4211009145,
0.5081369877,
-0.4294189811,
1.4097964764,
0.122727178,
-0.1337311566,
0.0891389027,
-0.0986799374,
-0.1098961905,
-0.4079468548,
-0.5445947051,
-0.4791413844,
-0.6575518847,
-0.1929888725,
-0.5176638365,
0.3089660406,
-0.1270749867,
-0.1832562089,
0.1106143072,
-0.2506338656,
1.1148631573,
0.2577196062,
0.0812828764,
0.2322251499,
-0.132661894,
0.3295961022,
-0.326199621,
-0.5913831592,
0.0003536779,
0.7870070338,
0.3872009516,
0.9216631055,
0.4146324396,
0.7094950676,
0.403357774,
0.2619291842,
-0.8733673096,
0.5211070776,
-0.516782701,
-0.6291413903,
-0.2263538986,
-0.5830790401,
-0.5138914585,
0.1367030442,
-0.8214694262,
-0.5384392738,
-0.1267398596,
0.0028013757,
-0.4834197164,
0.3386988044,
-0.3017613292,
0.247279346,
-0.5441827178,
-0.4363925755,
0.1431241482,
-0.0941284373,
0.7199008465,
-0.2235621661,
0.4898653328,
-0.222435534,
-0.3391956687,
0.791154027,
-0.1218464524,
0.7558922172,
0.098515816,
-0.0041500824,
0.138615042,
0.3558759391,
0.3107238114,
-0.1857197583,
-0.1463088691,
0.0996863171,
0.3038652241,
-0.2380493283,
-0.859145999,
0.5789563656,
-0.5068467259,
-0.6987763047,
-0.5399528146,
-0.7582598925,
-0.7998206615,
-0.0917107165,
0.0073396326,
0.0780074373,
-0.2130458802,
0.2903653383,
0.5537760854,
-0.011018252,
0.2908598483,
0.4518640637,
0.0376806892,
-0.4335910976,
0.8925777078,
-0.0467420705,
-0.3303574324,
0.4689440727,
0.1672540754,
-0.678627193,
-0.7962182164,
-0.0383736268,
0.3442179263,
-0.615172863,
-0.5133998394,
0.0658758134,
-0.2622316182,
-0.3757074773,
0.1451262385,
-0.0879515707,
-0.2800357938,
-0.163307935,
0.0255927499,
0.2283701748,
1.0211080313,
0.0618101172,
0.2428839803,
-1.1210222244,
0.2128318548,
-0.1048713326,
0.4680448174,
-0.1221223176,
-0.3312802315,
-0.1453437656,
0.0073189382,
-0.1433079243,
-1.050104022,
0.3063773513,
-0.0423160382,
0.8237941265,
0.2593850493,
-0.2383378297,
0.7018216848,
-0.5737349391,
0.9519783854,
0.3078336716,
-0.7053418756,
0.1916185468,
-0.3830203414,
0.0502208248,
0.7515799403,
0.5181965828,
-0.2317559123,
-0.2322675139,
-0.4729172587,
-0.411333859,
0.7438798547,
0.3049081564,
-0.1340170354,
0.2496606857,
0.597828567,
-0.079065457,
0.158397764,
-0.2142928243,
-0.4165870249,
0.1422439665,
-0.6329871416,
-0.3416019082,
0.0255288184,
-0.3677135706,
-0.3653947711,
0.4853330255,
-0.0164327789,
-0.0952121094,
-0.2061633915,
0.1823565513,
0.2135515958,
-0.2939383984,
0.78764534,
0.5147743821,
0.0466656722,
0.0099864649,
0.5400482416,
-0.2189309448,
0.1608056128,
0.1661572158,
-0.0486184321,
0.0048021679,
0.6092286706,
0.5572384596,
0.4657379091,
-0.8726987839,
0.3481146395,
-0.0561556555,
-0.6102539897,
0.2312077582,
0.1324655712,
0.0789808929,
0.367270112,
0.3774134219,
-0.2915440798,
0.3274306059,
-0.6662126184,
0.2690415382,
0.5118439198,
-0.2665428817,
-0.1814163178,
0.6544556618,
0.2263188809,
-0.1764455587,
0.1246069297,
0.1195303798,
-0.5974866748,
0.5375846624,
0.4312500358,
0.5049462318,
-0.2335421294,
0.2432726473,
0.0781842619,
-0.0877282023,
-0.1311071813,
0.437425971,
0.1116931438,
-0.6560577154,
-0.5827020407,
-0.3611686528,
-0.6040093899,
0.0573494807,
-0.3666658401,
0.1565800011,
-0.288716644,
-0.4046070278,
0.3405557275,
0.0355914012,
-0.7513573766,
0.2576408982,
0.4635928273,
1.0711270571,
-0.9569823742,
0.2894237339,
0.7796488404,
-0.4718215168,
-0.4642845094,
-0.4166756868,
0.2900278866,
-0.9551863074,
1.049321413,
-0.5182827711,
0.1327635497,
-0.1887931526,
-0.4005581737,
-0.5523424745,
0.9553635716,
0.2903967798,
-0.1222787201,
-0.2229640931,
0.6330265999,
0.3116849363,
-0.4017237723,
0.2995026708,
0.9516602755,
0.4328039885,
0.5761099458,
-0.6692358851,
-0.18642959,
0.0832085535,
-0.3692586422,
0.2386520356,
-0.6314191222,
0.6116594076,
0.0290676132,
-0.0115525862,
-0.2096394747,
0.7829691768,
0.3915001452,
0.4880640805,
0.4022547603,
0.4291778207,
0.8756943941,
-0.2452336848,
0.8608181477,
-0.1560474783,
0.332305789,
0.9799858332,
-0.7180093527,
0.786002636,
0.2080539763,
-0.2461887747,
0.1503138095,
0.5286693573,
-0.208918184,
0.2853136361,
0.2858772874,
-0.5141441226,
-0.3581109047,
-0.1814280301,
-0.1711124331,
0.8316559792,
0.3451374471,
-0.0167069286,
-0.5939372778,
-0.0007891267,
-0.074273333,
0.1963313073,
-0.3023451269,
1.1007490158,
-0.1217817366,
-0.7326486707,
0.0078237168,
-0.1328880787,
0.4623841643,
-0.6105952859,
-0.1905775964,
-0.2310142219,
0.146441102,
-0.1774762124,
-1.3854782581,
0.4197619855,
0.1961777508,
-0.1126361787,
-0.1135042608,
0.7174091935,
-0.4991335869,
-0.4076638222,
-0.0480183698,
0.4539403021,
0.3158789575,
-0.0133839604,
-1.1383047104,
0.4211537838,
-0.0679431185,
0.1905914247,
0.3091076016,
0.4363028705,
0.2332921028,
0.6549991965,
0.5700097084,
0.5846090913,
-0.0579918362,
0.0190684274,
0.662116468,
-0.8560365438,
-0.4331725836,
-1.1512848139,
0.0898925364,
-0.3901042938,
-0.1958179921,
0.7287221551,
1.0355321169,
0.2290986925,
0.028240798,
0.8719587326,
0.3559300303,
0.4862679839,
-0.7189170718,
0.6875496507,
-0.3505146801,
0.1292524338,
0.1816669852,
-0.8785485029,
-0.3922505081,
0.1621549278,
-0.2119790018,
-0.3317959011,
0.3717588186,
0.1498906463,
-0.0515697338,
0.1722258776,
0.3161984682,
-0.088312909,
0.429181397,
0.6815896034,
0.8089460731,
-0.4275646806,
0.6136868596,
0.0387123786,
-0.4470004141,
-0.1879796982,
-0.7970994115,
-1.0152485371,
-0.4368920028,
-0.3450112343,
-0.5065794587,
-0.2180932015,
0.7026587129,
0.3936045766,
-0.7950620651,
-0.5214174986,
0.4008984566,
0.1303369552,
-0.1933636665,
-0.2528384626,
0.221009478,
-0.2571334243,
-0.7985185385,
0.450034976,
0.2481512427,
0.2962498963,
-0.2725675404,
0.0745067596,
-0.1038119495,
0.3687606454,
0.6929558516,
0.6020531058,
-0.4664206207,
-0.0469350144,
0.1835169941,
-0.0054879375,
-0.1979035139,
0.9518803358,
-0.7307052016,
0.3607657254,
0.8423515558,
1.0461951494,
0.3351742029,
0.3245872557,
0.7820458412,
-0.4100378752,
-0.1167657524,
0.3323827684,
0.1706021279,
0.111844033,
-0.1987362504,
0.6263289452,
0.371768117,
-0.2059752196,
-0.9498645663,
-0.175336495,
-0.7973445654,
-0.1794279516,
1.2197707891,
0.359315604,
-0.2670911252,
-0.1795190126,
0.0574907996,
-0.0707218125,
0.0168849044,
0.5722192526,
1.1278656721,
-0.6687503457,
0.2074138373,
-0.5100317597,
0.8552343845,
0.0765746534,
-1.0134289265,
0.151024431,
0.3216071427,
-0.0128943492,
0.0660980269,
0.617754817,
0.220155403,
0.1918425858,
0.1340574771,
-0.3337794244,
-0.1824089289,
-0.1659052968,
0.0279727653,
0.1800319701,
-0.5275835395,
-0.0710778758
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10311v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10311v5
|
The optimal placement of the head in the noun phrase. The case of demonstrative, numeral, adjective and noun
| 2024-02-15T20:24:39 | 2024-03-22T16:10:14 |
Ramon Ferrer-i-Cancho
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, physics.soc-ph
|
The word order of a sentence is shaped by multiple principles. The principle
of syntactic dependency distance minimization is in conflict with the principle
of surprisal minimization (or predictability maximization) in single head
syntactic dependency structures: while the former predicts that the head should
be placed at the center of the linear arrangement, the latter predicts that the
head should be placed at one of the ends (either first or last). A critical
question is when surprisal minimization (or predictability maximization) should
surpass syntactic dependency distance minimization. In the context of single
head structures, it has been predicted that this is more likely to happen when
two conditions are met, i.e. (a) fewer words are involved and (b) words are
shorter. Here we test the prediction on the noun phrase when it is composed of
a demonstrative, a numeral, an adjective and a noun. We find that, across
preferred orders in languages, the noun tends to be placed at one of the ends,
confirming the theoretical prediction. We also show evidence of anti locality
effects: syntactic dependency distances in preferred orders are longer than
expected by chance.
|
[
-0.6076026559,
-0.8471013904,
0.6879533529,
0.3826261461,
-0.272198081,
-0.2919031382,
-0.1830077171,
-0.4933071434,
0.6070693731,
0.3676972985,
-0.452385664,
-0.1065183878,
-0.7133870721,
0.1925257593,
-0.0971901789,
0.7221538424,
0.1719276607,
-0.0964660197,
-0.6075024605,
-0.1650431603,
-0.3735277951,
-0.765598774,
-0.2298608869,
-0.2383183241,
0.4350540638,
0.313100636,
1.2496299744,
1.2531329393,
0.7400554419,
0.3579714596,
-0.2751294076,
-0.1524987966,
-0.0391097777,
-0.0093888473,
-0.0920034274,
-0.8063297272,
0.0039975494,
-0.0375421159,
0.4117031693,
1.0549975634,
-0.0840527043,
-0.1182964295,
-0.1919516623,
0.7998693585,
-0.6506718993,
0.0425650477,
-0.2729660273,
-0.0889896452,
-0.4950224757,
-0.4188860059,
-0.0968760476,
-0.4934688509,
0.5102301836,
-0.1588158607,
0.0412252769,
0.1525646448,
1.1316714287,
0.4238092005,
-0.3561778963,
0.057335306,
-0.4968546927,
0.8168240786,
-0.4708433151,
0.422932744,
0.311142236,
0.126160115,
-0.3082701266,
-0.4136128724,
-0.5283386707,
-0.2384045869,
-0.3412333727,
-0.0592847131,
-0.3273340166,
0.5014057159,
0.3685030341,
0.3419504464,
-0.6121863723,
0.2025339454,
-0.3796038628,
0.1390084475,
0.1294393092,
0.059908811,
0.344510287,
-0.4142843485,
-0.6613684297,
0.1805429012,
-0.688203454,
0.2444379181,
0.2646258771,
0.6958950162,
0.1224894077,
0.4816904366,
-0.5296408534,
0.5670881271,
0.2726693749,
-0.3107716739,
0.280620575,
-0.5628805757,
-0.1015511826,
0.2035245746,
0.6563327312,
0.7566567659,
0.2270110697,
-0.1721018851,
-0.1557097733,
0.711369276,
0.2951421738,
-0.6114214659,
0.0658328682,
0.048338674,
-0.3022762537,
-0.2836215794,
0.1045259759,
-0.5203312039,
-0.0380369462,
-0.5076313019,
0.1031324118,
-0.2698523402,
0.0791213959,
0.1074903756,
0.1756195128,
-0.0173831712,
-0.175927639,
-0.9482136369,
0.7183343172,
0.5553874969,
0.8112271428,
-0.2846286595,
-0.3377091885,
-0.1484919488,
0.0993941277,
-0.4960335493,
1.0490195751,
-0.2273326218,
-0.2146234214,
-0.101244241,
-0.0825091898,
-0.1538857818,
-0.4690385759,
0.5029833317,
-0.1489692181,
0.3256951571,
-0.3690782487,
-0.6926992536,
-0.3530648947,
-0.1904310435,
-0.4945364594,
0.4382291734,
0.1081633642,
-0.9125025868,
0.4701895714,
-0.3615916371,
-0.7700694203,
-0.0897420123,
-0.3472732306,
-0.23868303,
0.3984402418,
-0.2364108264,
0.144253999,
-0.2192937732,
-0.0974597558,
-0.1955089867,
-0.0700829178,
-0.035976436,
0.0389221199,
0.8383657932,
0.1718092412,
-0.3600039184,
-0.0869912654,
-0.6384342313,
0.185592398,
0.0402295776,
-0.2352048904,
-0.7800782919,
0.0793664306,
-0.1101385057,
0.2163157314,
0.2507309914,
-0.419169724,
0.0279003438,
-0.7568708658,
0.1429513544,
0.7574279308,
0.343924135,
0.6545610428,
-0.2668001652,
0.6362034678,
-0.0703025609,
0.3333667517,
0.2612618506,
-0.1614703089,
-0.7127088308,
0.0576008037,
0.2638583481,
0.7539554238,
-0.4764882624,
0.2835576534,
-0.110043332,
-0.0516843572,
-0.0394856632,
-0.0514347181,
0.8188424706,
0.1795185208,
0.2126929313,
-0.3708055913,
-0.941686213,
-1.1773506403,
-0.1056985185,
-0.4701529145,
0.6729106307,
-0.1974221617,
0.2997461259,
-0.078171216,
1.0872062445,
-0.8577800989,
-0.2967072427,
-0.3874973357,
0.0351721011,
0.3502214551,
0.3396593332,
0.971898973,
-1.0300843716,
-0.301690042,
-0.2630676031,
-0.477438271,
-0.1671188921,
-0.0280160382,
-0.1521744728,
0.2667292058,
0.4078510106,
-0.9149639606,
0.6286416054,
0.1330735087,
-0.2398451865,
0.6788167953,
-0.2164736688,
-0.3623739183,
-0.9542592168,
-0.4282170236,
0.0243618544,
-0.1400288641,
-1.1013433933,
0.2260365933,
-0.2450975329,
0.6483692527,
-0.4121939242,
0.106390141,
-0.3575063944,
-0.0058031054,
-0.522515595,
0.0151638919,
0.052756954,
0.4194464684,
0.1474740952,
0.6012342572,
0.5409264565,
-1.0241372585,
0.1988817453,
0.2571575642,
-0.6791718006,
0.6159612536,
-0.7488940954,
-0.2900727391,
-0.3414046168,
-0.2343467772,
-0.9739528894,
0.0370898806,
-0.070053786,
-0.3712944686,
0.1597410589,
0.3980226815,
-0.4529196322,
-0.3041290939,
-0.0782473385,
0.2781977952,
0.2422489226,
-0.1579364836,
-0.1517623663,
0.6275924444,
-0.1271487474,
-0.61765486,
-0.7900791764,
-0.1891057044,
-0.2665417492,
-0.3912011981,
0.5265794992,
-0.1923785657,
-0.8750190139,
-0.098190777,
-0.3524329066,
0.0818036944,
0.0198219959,
0.375528425,
0.0690037012,
-0.1666578799,
0.0886169225,
-0.1238902807,
-0.2551558614,
0.046908319,
-0.0808088407,
0.4202323556,
-0.2496521473,
0.2461360693,
-0.1308737546,
0.2185343355,
0.6610310078,
0.0072834664,
0.6341472864,
-0.1060696915,
-0.3935597837,
0.0780948699,
-0.4748077393,
0.0080257365,
-0.4603279531,
0.280975163,
-0.5719560385,
-0.2477856576,
0.2439699322,
0.2086488605,
0.0546019115,
0.3939074874,
0.3177351356,
-0.0753932223,
0.8226441145,
0.9329696894,
-0.0746438801,
0.4688405693,
-0.2213772535,
0.186897248,
-0.651610136,
0.0759059265,
-0.542542398,
-0.1605053693,
-0.8190582395,
-0.0792864412,
0.3198068738,
0.2034848928,
0.163812995,
0.8256445527,
-0.3006144762,
0.7102981806,
0.6348826289,
0.0183850024,
0.0726103485,
-0.1811500192,
-0.6796854734,
-0.1983664483,
-0.5273007154,
-0.333937645,
0.3278559744,
0.0767994449,
0.4266980588,
0.2331699431,
0.7416478395,
-0.0283051487,
-0.3136548698,
-0.9224111438,
0.7329998016,
-0.3127786815,
-0.4698777199,
-0.3858145177,
-0.14346762,
-1.0027271509,
0.4024035633,
0.1090223268,
-0.6817139387,
0.4779952168,
-0.2784281075,
-0.748744607,
-0.0730119348,
-0.398098737,
0.7751690149,
-0.2377971709,
0.0137753068,
0.1106615812,
-0.9105173349,
-0.0390910618,
0.244844079,
0.4337571263,
-0.0529304594,
-0.1576292664,
0.6144269705,
-0.7284010649,
0.3993399739,
-0.0170975998,
0.276137501,
0.1807367653,
0.1850368381,
0.2782094777,
-0.5398465991,
0.124833934,
-0.2321929634,
-0.0810146183,
-0.2173710316,
-0.4838828444,
0.4660258591,
-0.6535671353,
-0.7636401653,
-0.4543409348,
-0.4690751433,
-0.1232648939,
0.3535285592,
0.762513876,
0.5745693445,
0.0145745864,
0.1875320375,
0.4569619,
-0.1380697489,
0.5928970575,
0.2658544779,
-0.363581568,
-0.291351527,
0.5811975598,
0.5760137439,
0.5677314401,
0.6917815804,
0.5865954757,
-0.2653299868,
-0.6060894132,
0.0116623575,
0.3291738033,
-0.7214018106,
-0.0453294255,
-0.5510252714,
-0.0340731405,
-0.5603129268,
-0.3262932897,
-0.3763619661,
-0.7042899728,
0.0074158916,
-0.4814035296,
0.2120949775,
0.4197407067,
-0.2531838417,
0.4237014651,
-0.2839420736,
0.4641636312,
0.0701698661,
0.0772849768,
-0.4366341233,
-0.4925481677,
-0.2064752728,
-0.2868396342,
-0.0723638684,
-0.71776402,
0.3181780875,
0.0602769032,
0.573679924,
0.9210957289,
0.2619460225,
1.0345065594,
-0.7371545434,
0.4473798871,
0.5906063318,
-0.6855162382,
0.6472520828,
-0.3323777616,
0.4675489366,
0.8643125296,
0.3922751546,
-0.417327255,
-0.6526537538,
-0.6208699346,
-0.8234255314,
0.3805226386,
0.2475238144,
-0.0941270441,
-0.4219879508,
0.2959782779,
0.1619573683,
0.3339558542,
-0.6959123015,
-0.8230144382,
0.3537646532,
0.2329641134,
-0.017562151,
-0.1571526527,
0.2125471532,
-0.2143750042,
0.4578771293,
0.2884229124,
0.4081930816,
-0.0361945406,
-0.003099991,
-0.3455354571,
0.0172359217,
0.9150831699,
1.0803382397,
-0.3638429642,
0.3220586479,
-0.026595315,
-0.3806514144,
0.1279992163,
-0.2369595915,
-0.5449715853,
0.4876902401,
0.2700137198,
0.7694783211,
0.183175534,
-0.084866941,
0.5506369472,
0.3801643848,
-0.0310087558,
-0.5224065781,
-0.1758746505,
-0.2010252029,
0.2137242556,
0.1626115292,
0.2685874104,
0.2986340225,
-0.7378944755,
0.5077742338,
0.4503851235,
-0.0620867051,
-0.1981185377,
0.531562686,
-0.3833482563,
-0.2862158716,
0.1489400417,
-0.0950427949,
-0.8853105307,
0.7808044553,
0.4123820961,
0.6993273497,
-0.4906637073,
0.3496515155,
0.4001276791,
0.4306383431,
-0.3629231453,
0.4091056287,
0.2708365321,
-0.6983398795,
-0.0869427919,
-0.6901265979,
-0.2907586098,
-0.1579086781,
-0.7769371867,
0.2722396255,
-0.5507122278,
-0.5132585764,
0.2822167873,
0.0145479944,
-0.2967675924,
0.4329698384,
0.071667701,
0.3229082227,
-0.7407717705,
0.6521995068,
0.447483778,
-0.5017851591,
-0.603238821,
-0.1227990314,
0.0803700164,
-0.6120288372,
0.7655536532,
0.3676606417,
-0.3065989017,
-0.4032970965,
-0.2897546887,
-1.2131040096,
0.7347971797,
0.2431825846,
-0.3090519309,
-0.3345770836,
0.3137456775,
0.657181263,
-0.3274743557,
0.0479382314,
0.3932260275,
0.3917369545,
-0.0210235268,
-1.0560837984,
0.0979875177,
0.0709376782,
0.4941139221,
0.5218362212,
-0.7811501622,
0.997972548,
-0.5018903017,
-0.3758892715,
0.2717282772,
0.7219377756,
-0.0725891665,
0.0968182757,
0.7477154732,
0.7745791674,
0.4647748768,
-0.1188129485,
1.2794803381,
-0.35187006,
0.1822664142,
1.0830754042,
0.1097299084,
0.6940261126,
0.667698741,
-0.4946914911,
0.6641538143,
0.7728000879,
0.2713827491,
1.1650949717,
0.4279361665,
0.0993396789,
0.1267783195,
-0.4686422348,
-0.30056265,
0.7534787655,
0.1613285989,
-0.3157240748,
0.0235727876,
0.1261038035,
0.0680561066,
0.1651448756,
-0.3265359402,
0.617429316,
0.3043796122,
-0.5717789531,
0.717474699,
0.0531768538,
0.3566757739,
-0.3353335559,
0.4304738939,
-0.3645409644,
0.3101560771,
-0.2598127425,
-0.313803941,
0.3250393569,
-0.5781400204,
-0.3884102702,
-0.2107963562,
0.5096815825,
-0.2368526459,
-0.4176386893,
0.2909419835,
0.4996106923,
0.2209595889,
0.1602523923,
-0.3923902512,
-0.2439409941,
-0.3786612153,
-0.5638762712,
0.3964571059,
0.4620283246,
0.1696536243,
0.5071880817,
0.3074476421,
0.4326705337,
0.0954669863,
0.0763245746,
0.5161220431,
-0.4911186099,
-1.0081847906,
-1.0196640491,
0.0507416017,
0.2308822125,
-0.2392807901,
0.8431393504,
0.4246858656,
0.8620480895,
0.020418914,
0.4398707449,
-0.0828012228,
0.5309230685,
-0.2841246426,
0.113201499,
-0.5194267631,
-0.0629179999,
-0.6043659449,
-1.2258020639,
-0.5429193377,
0.7917445898,
-0.4677451253,
-0.2073247433,
1.211351037,
0.7120948434,
0.2726137936,
-0.055622451,
0.4184516072,
0.1761544049,
-0.4579629302,
0.5674852133,
0.5845062733,
-0.1491206139,
0.3355633914,
-0.9067475796,
-0.044582013,
-0.0476577394,
-0.5264966488,
-0.6493155956,
-0.6581024528,
-0.5069679618,
-0.2967896163,
0.0298945419,
1.1798987389,
0.4642349482,
-0.6773343682,
-0.4971354306,
-0.405821085,
0.2146588713,
-0.5797951221,
-0.2689465582,
0.4075725973,
-0.2473139018,
-0.7371971011,
0.2131166756,
0.4264743626,
0.0490155257,
-0.0586382672,
0.0974357501,
-0.6178486347,
0.1512507051,
0.6092500687,
0.238150999,
-0.8809962869,
-0.4235095084,
0.0358137749,
-0.4880983531,
0.2683638334,
0.4710358381,
-0.7208141088,
0.3317266405,
0.5592158437,
0.2711618841,
-0.2021592855,
0.1804415137,
0.4336091876,
-0.7374761701,
0.0731724799,
-0.0958318338,
0.3684066534,
-0.1428832263,
-0.6014324427,
0.7454440594,
0.4301943183,
-0.2946698368,
-0.8344737887,
0.5460962653,
-0.8357138634,
-0.4512457848,
1.2301037312,
0.0377004854,
-0.2089877129,
-0.0891943425,
0.0584450476,
0.2650132179,
-0.0389252678,
0.6365047097,
0.7341086268,
-0.5161379576,
-0.237894699,
-0.5961788297,
0.4880475104,
0.541279912,
-0.6094851494,
-0.2205331177,
0.3406849504,
-0.0186744332,
0.7727153897,
0.5440893769,
0.0855395794,
0.3506520391,
0.0146356979,
-0.1272674799,
0.1536579728,
-0.6351373792,
-0.1755380183,
0.2316251546,
-0.1016308963,
-0.5719782114
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10302v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10302v1
|
How to Discern Important Urgent News?
| 2024-02-15T20:08:07 | 2024-02-15T20:08:07 |
Oleg Vasilyev, John Bohannon
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We found that a simple property of clusters in a clustered dataset of news
correlate strongly with importance and urgency of news (IUN) as assessed by
LLM. We verified our finding across different news datasets, dataset sizes,
clustering algorithms and embeddings. The found correlation should allow using
clustering (as an alternative to LLM) for identifying the most important urgent
news, or for filtering out unimportant articles.
|
[
-0.2395089716,
-0.7948465943,
0.8695707321,
0.5566057563,
-0.358835876,
0.1464503706,
-0.0407940187,
-0.5177534819,
0.5060273409,
0.2217403501,
-0.2651254535,
-0.5753571987,
-0.8915032148,
-0.22258313,
-1.0608822107,
0.826267004,
0.2231083214,
0.052330967,
-0.1038520187,
-0.4003190398,
-0.0830761194,
-0.2727088332,
-0.8031691909,
-0.0999206007,
0.7836512327,
0.6483174562,
0.6476045847,
0.6581189036,
1.188288331,
0.143308267,
-0.6104129553,
-0.2947537303,
-0.699673593,
-0.2220433503,
-0.3290380239,
-0.6719372272,
-0.204749614,
0.0351710767,
0.5858706236,
0.8102198243,
-0.0100502074,
0.4924283028,
-0.0017948592,
1.3057250977,
-0.2898272872,
0.0269720163,
-0.6471805573,
0.1605380177,
-0.4442545176,
-0.1813304126,
-0.0617759004,
-0.4763460755,
0.2058583349,
-0.3673122227,
0.3383581936,
0.306848377,
0.9355391264,
0.3292713761,
-0.7130483389,
-0.3258482814,
-0.6433241963,
0.6805154085,
-0.3860211372,
0.1336631477,
0.2122830302,
0.1106372625,
-0.3868212998,
-0.5433107615,
-0.1960512698,
0.2210689336,
-0.2712352872,
0.15888156,
-0.1079521328,
-0.0151404673,
0.2504800558,
0.7906062603,
-0.2174799591,
0.1380141526,
-0.5450226068,
0.0132577121,
0.3811353445,
0.0754655674,
0.3282662034,
-0.3018435836,
-0.3766745031,
0.2374757826,
-0.8830412626,
0.3820238709,
0.3491159081,
0.1969899535,
-0.1314400584,
0.6456006765,
-0.5038235188,
0.6661152244,
0.4110828042,
-0.3307948411,
0.1757840216,
-0.326471746,
0.3245557547,
0.6299909353,
0.3457433581,
0.6983788013,
-0.3576836288,
0.0240634698,
0.0071823378,
-0.0434500948,
0.2364227623,
-0.4746034443,
0.3488333821,
0.470079124,
-0.8772580028,
-0.5298057795,
0.3203537762,
-0.7118135691,
-0.3930168748,
-0.2388065755,
0.4302524924,
0.5348020792,
-0.4762764275,
-0.0465440936,
-0.250107944,
0.1673491895,
0.3494337499,
-0.5947690606,
0.0267471336,
0.8208888173,
0.7021535039,
-0.5100353956,
0.0645982549,
-0.2969796956,
0.0413058177,
-0.52717489,
1.0911647081,
-0.3625625074,
0.148961246,
-0.0730825067,
0.2890377343,
0.3500778377,
-0.5543786883,
0.973164022,
-0.5793914199,
-0.2077874392,
-0.4119870365,
-0.4848165512,
-0.5775083303,
0.112854369,
-0.9477392435,
1.0197798014,
0.3349450231,
-0.7998912334,
0.687351346,
-0.4342485666,
-1.0298987627,
-0.3037085831,
-0.0854138285,
-0.7138878703,
0.4912080467,
0.1295609325,
0.6679045558,
-0.4271616936,
0.445743084,
-0.3325689137,
-0.3468833268,
0.2961203456,
-0.2045178711,
0.31673944,
0.2603295445,
-0.4629204869,
0.0946607739,
-0.8698765635,
-0.2703298628,
-0.0496913716,
-0.5425135493,
-0.3285430372,
0.2738217115,
-0.1708333343,
0.0318629965,
0.2783151269,
-0.2457974553,
0.0860689208,
0.0924839675,
0.4230747223,
0.3245113194,
0.5194541216,
0.5408405662,
-0.4838958979,
0.3592201471,
0.3890298605,
0.3527693748,
0.1474008262,
-0.6573471427,
-0.810533762,
-0.0301091354,
0.1436442286,
0.6999390721,
0.1303147078,
0.4440309703,
0.1201834828,
-0.425388664,
-0.5075650215,
0.0056910971,
-0.0706054792,
0.4539279938,
0.0458492227,
-0.0256481301,
-0.6630103588,
-0.9681942463,
-0.5375864506,
0.1792044491,
0.5041825175,
0.1454299837,
-0.1661411375,
-0.0093429582,
0.9677423239,
-0.4436394274,
-0.3006801307,
-0.4748595953,
0.3351371586,
1.1286765337,
0.2038458735,
0.6277984381,
-1.3541741371,
-0.5107258558,
0.0900261402,
-0.6968231797,
-0.4059183002,
-0.4108935893,
-0.0214093961,
-0.4268503487,
0.9502022266,
-0.3092987239,
0.9302707911,
0.3683042526,
-0.1583599895,
0.100632593,
-0.0902393013,
0.4067295194,
-0.8272445202,
-0.1447377056,
-0.096018739,
-0.4334456325,
-0.6559430361,
-0.1172151417,
0.0849670693,
-0.2197886258,
-0.5477854609,
0.3696528673,
-0.5299305916,
-0.387955606,
-0.3092723489,
0.1698570997,
0.0717290118,
-0.0123864058,
-0.0722032934,
0.496643573,
0.6141703129,
-0.7789083719,
0.1981430054,
-0.1701595038,
-0.8910702467,
0.256924659,
-0.5157724619,
-0.4784903824,
-0.2274615169,
-0.1351770759,
-1.2372069359,
-0.4317587614,
-0.2073913217,
-0.1539853215,
0.1747807413,
-0.0045039011,
-0.3475584388,
-0.7674083114,
-0.0001495309,
0.3700202405,
0.3033955693,
-0.5411053896,
0.407646209,
0.6344155073,
-0.165134728,
-0.5111987591,
-0.4989282191,
-0.0768844336,
-0.5641462803,
-0.1060093343,
0.1007220596,
0.0502647571,
-0.5614745617,
0.2280974686,
-0.2067653984,
-0.3582701385,
0.5082133412,
0.625783205,
-0.2034868598,
-0.2378457487,
0.1239155829,
0.2916555703,
-0.4471901059,
-0.0103471829,
0.4117554128,
0.2399116457,
-0.28877303,
-0.2682017982,
-0.5797239542,
0.7107337713,
0.9193734527,
0.1510310471,
0.7163122892,
0.7710254192,
-0.3081911206,
0.3368381262,
-0.7710892558,
-0.3521457911,
-0.4131214321,
0.4619099796,
0.1288755834,
-0.7715085149,
0.6038489342,
-0.6297826171,
-0.1357855201,
0.6889846325,
0.4690563977,
-0.0370604061,
1.2288254499,
0.4478343129,
-0.5698192716,
0.6932138205,
-0.0401483215,
0.4310102463,
-0.3963906169,
0.1263682097,
-0.2895356417,
-0.6974627972,
-0.3859024346,
0.1280756742,
0.7299208045,
0.475258857,
0.2335243523,
-0.1967236102,
-0.6966106892,
0.8236710429,
0.8114404082,
0.3507027328,
0.5084229708,
0.3066476583,
0.4700421095,
0.0790688843,
-0.5569071174,
-0.2145905495,
0.8670444489,
0.1640661657,
0.8337087035,
0.0775894374,
0.5165849328,
0.4347996116,
0.320625186,
-0.9276607037,
0.4750424623,
-0.2782547772,
-0.6784745455,
-0.3170028031,
-0.1907057762,
-1.2852780819,
-0.224434346,
-0.548992753,
-0.301965028,
0.4377422333,
-0.3120250106,
-0.5960054398,
0.2030697614,
-0.6917963028,
0.303961575,
0.0621617585,
-0.0364863761,
-0.807657361,
-0.6906894445,
0.1472834647,
-0.0757798627,
0.6677047014,
-0.5860540271,
0.1057240963,
0.9757138491,
-0.2288067192,
0.7884381413,
0.2057785243,
0.3507389426,
0.6220347881,
-0.46592471,
0.5154249668,
0.1785284877,
-0.1146807224,
0.0504590347,
-0.4423184097,
-0.4038232565,
-0.251678586,
0.8698589802,
-0.8480908871,
-0.9346366525,
-0.5041382313,
-0.717202425,
0.4127588272,
0.1678428501,
0.3086930811,
0.660913229,
-0.0593105517,
0.4242801666,
0.5955108404,
0.5304204226,
0.6675980091,
0.7716994882,
-0.2468020767,
-0.2271861732,
0.849353075,
0.4895797074,
-0.0927926674,
0.7085049152,
0.5506327152,
0.1494419724,
-0.611782968,
-0.1205184832,
0.0819159448,
-0.6679565907,
-0.305103749,
-0.7149264216,
-0.3477061987,
-0.1919459999,
-0.4673436284,
-0.3389973938,
-0.7340977192,
-0.7397212386,
-0.2659329176,
0.7575544119,
1.1444151402,
-0.3855448365,
0.5571879745,
-1.1399222612,
0.5271539688,
0.4721763432,
-0.0326641053,
-0.2833056152,
-0.1546058953,
-0.4660879672,
-0.4145044088,
-0.1198753864,
-0.8856344819,
0.1530255228,
0.1648747623,
0.6137288213,
1.0551284552,
0.2486032397,
0.5499770045,
-0.242941916,
0.6425035,
0.0833614022,
-0.6400310993,
0.7043993473,
-0.6150425076,
0.0942932665,
0.8647421598,
0.6789386272,
-0.2414478958,
-0.3688008487,
-0.8365036845,
-1.0687975883,
0.4354597926,
-0.1785318255,
-0.3573973477,
-0.1883177161,
0.8466618061,
0.1238967627,
0.449811995,
-0.7227650881,
-0.3386251032,
0.4682465792,
-0.2135832906,
0.2257983387,
-0.7692371607,
-0.2876699865,
-0.4223893583,
0.2425006032,
0.224130556,
0.1905756891,
0.3926088214,
0.0060431934,
-0.3480939865,
0.3906438947,
0.2533238232,
1.0257151127,
-0.2642675638,
0.1464231014,
0.0502934381,
-0.7519016862,
0.3185576797,
-0.3365863562,
-0.1079548299,
0.1503910571,
0.3777267635,
0.4958897233,
0.5447744727,
-0.4368306696,
1.0162789822,
0.0363718122,
0.0719003826,
-0.2675592303,
0.08024396,
-0.0229680054,
0.4075223804,
0.6742612123,
0.1188127995,
0.4889035821,
-0.8483991027,
0.0834573656,
-0.221344471,
-0.6387417316,
-0.2984715998,
0.4505248368,
0.1745909303,
0.0806254148,
0.5163179636,
-0.0853697062,
-0.61929667,
0.9987986088,
0.5327256322,
0.3631807566,
-0.3622348607,
0.1741788089,
0.4683235586,
0.2642090023,
-0.6050668359,
0.7085650563,
0.3342531025,
-0.2646247447,
-0.2905614078,
-0.1751856506,
-0.4354599118,
-0.2179282308,
-1.1207289696,
0.3816282153,
-0.3362304866,
-0.2585462332,
-0.3208076656,
-0.0120413881,
-0.4344984293,
0.4140693843,
-0.3551395237,
0.743727684,
-1.0748023987,
0.3749546707,
0.6341333389,
0.237588793,
-0.6853470206,
0.0272653829,
0.0273653734,
-0.9445860982,
0.5265878439,
0.3248528838,
0.6287142634,
0.0015541344,
-0.5508672595,
-1.3822929859,
1.0257757902,
0.1885533035,
-0.9758273363,
0.1411392093,
0.0299134981,
0.1099885628,
-0.4776480794,
0.195806399,
0.433593899,
0.7578636408,
0.0323291197,
-0.5747508407,
-0.0615494885,
0.0305934772,
-0.6162012815,
0.5173977017,
-1.0850576162,
0.8819757104,
-0.6004525423,
-0.2112130821,
-0.3845292628,
0.872574091,
-0.2960569859,
0.7196942568,
0.7487732768,
0.6899594665,
1.0636048317,
-0.1883291155,
0.7636109591,
-0.5730596781,
0.2214806676,
0.8353817463,
0.0308490861,
0.9755703807,
0.41913715,
-0.182224676,
0.3335968852,
0.8735448122,
0.2488633245,
0.9163245559,
-0.1046290919,
-0.4555233717,
-0.3200324774,
-0.4718979597,
-0.5837900639,
0.2350261807,
1.050391674,
-0.2995462418,
-0.3668027222,
0.1594839096,
0.0675910339,
-0.2267441005,
-0.7656964064,
0.9165686369,
0.2177785039,
-0.3491359055,
-0.0439028144,
-0.4299185872,
0.1977030933,
-0.4485337436,
0.0532298163,
0.0947428793,
0.197691381,
-0.4803414345,
-1.0684605837,
0.5651866198,
-0.4492662549,
-0.8248392344,
0.10083922,
1.0182634592,
-0.4215193391,
-0.5233669281,
0.3170173764,
0.5328374505,
0.3710740805,
-0.3617715538,
-0.4100477993,
0.101385504,
-0.0308351833,
-0.4435858428,
0.4498560131,
0.6428285241,
-0.1331626326,
0.3537685275,
0.6720806956,
0.1938343793,
-0.1525941789,
0.0953598544,
0.9502827525,
-0.8630613089,
-0.4307740629,
-0.5955868363,
0.1358525902,
-0.2962742448,
-0.2730739415,
0.8675972819,
0.5635630488,
-0.0861868337,
0.2450559884,
0.4020619988,
0.0186177287,
0.943243742,
-0.5822495818,
0.7610858083,
-0.4554152489,
0.0421459228,
0.0626925975,
-0.7551674247,
-0.4341146648,
0.4354600906,
-0.3243678212,
-0.5377326608,
0.9073905945,
0.5622914433,
0.0738372728,
0.2376213819,
0.1625343412,
0.6096359491,
-0.0570975281,
0.2718048394,
0.8530762792,
-0.3056353033,
0.5045131445,
-0.3289213777,
-0.5878437757,
-0.8714712858,
-1.12959373,
-1.0700634718,
-0.5157590508,
-0.6019397378,
-0.265889734,
-0.093056336,
0.7143735886,
0.7286627889,
-0.738117516,
0.0800018683,
-0.1748572439,
0.7128579021,
-0.4708852768,
-0.2926188707,
0.7086570263,
-0.1651563346,
-0.4239369929,
0.3458019495,
0.5482363105,
0.1419079453,
0.046805568,
0.8247212768,
-0.0651068762,
-0.0870494023,
0.7277430296,
0.1807089895,
-0.4492556751,
-0.3489848673,
-0.2822265327,
-0.2274819911,
0.3046845794,
0.959980011,
-0.5234869719,
0.0616097003,
0.8622207642,
0.3990470469,
0.1967760921,
-0.0790582597,
0.2500200868,
-0.6271110177,
0.5756562352,
-0.0622956119,
0.4496142268,
-0.0289118104,
-1.0940065384,
0.6225619912,
0.1364207119,
-0.9953044057,
-0.6897738576,
-0.1101216897,
-1.3912593126,
0.1090723202,
1.1429684162,
-0.1736345291,
-0.84494102,
-0.4971179366,
-0.3862532079,
-0.1864888966,
-0.6200326085,
0.9121707082,
0.8328031301,
0.0060979677,
-0.1020228863,
-0.4355405569,
0.2524099946,
0.3047552109,
-0.9040911794,
-0.2839684784,
-0.222473681,
-0.0600172915,
0.2164895386,
0.4028255641,
-0.0478128716,
0.3522857428,
-0.0771251246,
-0.4951731563,
0.4614836574,
-0.4979686439,
0.0044460567,
0.3980243504,
-0.0523403026,
0.1401873529
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10294v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10294v1
|
LAVE: LLM-Powered Agent Assistance and Language Augmentation for Video Editing
| 2024-02-15T19:53:11 | 2024-02-15T19:53:11 |
Bryan Wang, Yuliang Li, Zhaoyang Lv, Haijun Xia, Yan Xu, Raj Sodhi
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MM
|
Video creation has become increasingly popular, yet the expertise and effort
required for editing often pose barriers to beginners. In this paper, we
explore the integration of large language models (LLMs) into the video editing
workflow to reduce these barriers. Our design vision is embodied in LAVE, a
novel system that provides LLM-powered agent assistance and language-augmented
editing features. LAVE automatically generates language descriptions for the
user's footage, serving as the foundation for enabling the LLM to process
videos and assist in editing tasks. When the user provides editing objectives,
the agent plans and executes relevant actions to fulfill them. Moreover, LAVE
allows users to edit videos through either the agent or direct UI manipulation,
providing flexibility and enabling manual refinement of agent actions. Our user
study, which included eight participants ranging from novices to proficient
editors, demonstrated LAVE's effectiveness. The results also shed light on user
perceptions of the proposed LLM-assisted editing paradigm and its impact on
users' creativity and sense of co-creation. Based on these findings, we propose
design implications to inform the future development of agent-assisted content
editing.
|
[
-0.396704793,
-0.9290100932,
0.7155835032,
-0.0698938742,
-0.0797315165,
0.4151212573,
-0.4031560719,
-0.3987126946,
0.3135923147,
0.7577755451,
-0.66132164,
-0.5096836686,
-0.5433044434,
0.0609647185,
-0.431443274,
0.6324194074,
-0.4301264584,
-0.0431298092,
-0.1966032237,
0.078779012,
-0.6810235977,
-0.249875918,
-0.5395104885,
-0.1106473729,
0.4387455285,
0.3820540607,
1.171677947,
0.5514034629,
0.396060884,
0.4296697378,
-0.052923888,
0.6244184375,
-0.3672784567,
0.3520655632,
-0.3978108466,
-0.3529229164,
-1.0851441622,
-0.2763742507,
0.5949755907,
0.3348495662,
0.1593436301,
0.0024104165,
-0.0030462819,
0.4629406035,
-0.4621409476,
-0.1655017734,
-0.4071463645,
0.1713023782,
-0.0136074554,
-0.1822064668,
-0.1708806157,
0.015487982,
-0.298961252,
-0.7349842191,
0.1260979623,
-0.4345823526,
0.3578489423,
0.8601594567,
0.0125867622,
-0.0924494267,
-0.9008231163,
0.2418073565,
-0.4117943645,
0.6018291116,
0.3090524375,
0.3985300362,
-0.1762450933,
-0.5562590957,
-0.8492628932,
-0.0179595295,
0.3039029241,
-0.1380797625,
-0.245298326,
0.3819064796,
0.2464170158,
0.2360167503,
-0.4705400169,
0.4444865286,
-0.1420383602,
-0.1988696754,
0.7216740847,
0.2304810733,
0.6400606632,
0.0383111238,
0.1228284165,
0.0473394133,
-0.6304781437,
0.0576501898,
0.3890963197,
0.1293297708,
0.0312945507,
0.9341794252,
-0.1673333496,
0.7305351496,
-0.0022081402,
-0.3386233747,
-0.0148505652,
-0.0189661384,
-0.6567269564,
0.0850500837,
0.6914963722,
0.4771681726,
0.2168626487,
-0.0887130648,
-0.3255296946,
-0.0367408507,
0.1997224092,
-0.6594371796,
0.1300885975,
0.122377187,
-0.0897521377,
-0.1564674675,
0.1500919908,
-0.3978120089,
-0.8671938181,
-0.2988966405,
0.5609770417,
0.035023246,
-0.0958810151,
0.2907052934,
-0.0180765931,
0.0164148025,
0.8009293675,
-0.5651181936,
0.1787997335,
0.5572171807,
0.7372274995,
-0.0818378404,
-0.3427684605,
-1.0399279594,
0.33483693,
-0.2571854591,
0.6754348278,
-0.6027339101,
-0.5258979797,
0.254850626,
0.2632782459,
0.6699639559,
-0.4124478102,
0.3489026427,
-0.6665429473,
-0.1194489002,
0.0798301995,
-0.391661793,
0.0441588312,
-0.0465526395,
-0.8147877455,
0.7466931939,
0.0399478972,
-0.0815116167,
0.3104145825,
-0.6521703601,
-0.1841398925,
0.31197685,
-0.212942183,
-0.1543037742,
0.0461226776,
0.2597638965,
0.4346714914,
-0.1393002272,
0.2064644098,
-0.0486928523,
-0.2159415185,
0.4132561684,
-0.3426039517,
0.1457180232,
0.0986557528,
0.0572436526,
0.1525366157,
-0.5923998356,
-0.2717957497,
-0.2016919404,
-0.2059437186,
0.0443996005,
-0.2184019536,
0.0867891386,
0.2329098582,
0.2717568576,
-0.345318079,
0.5306190848,
-0.1871278584,
0.1920556575,
0.8993088603,
0.0695313364,
0.8231428266,
-0.0318334773,
0.9251881242,
-0.6151763201,
0.1325017065,
-0.1791255623,
-0.1612637192,
-0.4529852271,
-0.3016391397,
-0.156994313,
0.4908885062,
-1.0007740259,
0.1323327124,
-0.0649599358,
-0.3157476783,
-0.624497354,
0.9565010071,
0.0766533762,
0.2229862362,
0.1067029312,
-0.2281259298,
-0.5973646641,
-0.7767577767,
0.0533177741,
0.0167724937,
-0.3408919871,
0.175455898,
0.1650095433,
-0.2067520022,
1.0568583012,
-0.5569354892,
-0.4034979045,
-0.4389235675,
-0.2458043396,
0.0817719474,
0.1702558249,
0.3335959613,
-0.6952016354,
-0.6005837321,
0.2564448118,
-0.9571576715,
-0.5157967806,
-0.1324455589,
-0.1170886382,
0.1313080788,
0.6068167686,
-0.6738730073,
0.5905592442,
0.4207980931,
-0.1930647492,
0.4019801021,
-0.5009128451,
0.2021438777,
-0.9689627886,
-0.5079307556,
-0.2501747608,
-0.3812057674,
-0.6325558424,
-0.0414514169,
-0.3098663688,
-0.191794157,
-0.8151760101,
0.6260586381,
-0.4005764127,
-0.2777268589,
-0.6377389431,
0.3943800628,
0.2764106393,
0.3459710479,
0.2973701954,
0.8189451098,
0.5859271884,
-0.2899907529,
0.7571250796,
0.3229938447,
-0.3203678429,
0.7386771441,
-0.6605197191,
0.2840738297,
-0.2074332982,
0.0876891613,
-0.574287951,
-0.4983834624,
0.2186660767,
-0.373580128,
-0.0338407792,
-0.1097904518,
-0.5550367236,
-0.1318005919,
-0.1814980954,
0.3651598096,
0.4098926187,
-0.4832017422,
0.688801825,
0.5080219507,
-0.3813695908,
-0.5170526505,
-0.7591276765,
0.4861884713,
-0.1414217651,
-1.0757107735,
0.5033128858,
-0.3019439876,
-0.5106364489,
0.0889742151,
0.1343175322,
-0.1053156033,
-0.2081812471,
0.4295334518,
0.2302905172,
0.098651588,
0.213932544,
0.0211912468,
0.2129094154,
-0.3400778472,
0.080024235,
0.316406101,
0.0546970665,
-0.2440670282,
-0.5139762759,
0.4816152751,
0.5536354184,
-0.5041267872,
0.4238712192,
0.5734598041,
-0.313298434,
-0.3049864173,
-0.6402540207,
0.1651121527,
-0.5181365609,
0.6499193907,
-0.171411708,
-1.0656714439,
0.5236919522,
0.1004970148,
-0.032615304,
-0.0270898063,
0.7113050222,
-0.1841478646,
0.8240790367,
0.8392579556,
0.4049255848,
0.9482749701,
-0.4679491818,
-0.030878732,
-0.7063318491,
-0.1379514635,
-0.1791324764,
-0.2385664433,
-0.3278291821,
-0.8200005889,
0.5046598911,
-0.089147456,
-0.0862539187,
0.1697753072,
-0.2479715347,
0.8128418922,
0.0365955085,
0.0428942032,
0.4487603009,
-0.0860294327,
0.2593663633,
-0.1023261845,
-0.5547818542,
-0.5952864289,
0.7635443211,
0.5101599097,
1.0224789381,
0.3449922204,
0.5761947036,
0.9468763471,
0.0498240553,
-0.9732622504,
0.8532928824,
-0.0707697198,
-0.118528083,
-0.6220800877,
0.2997151315,
-0.638674438,
-0.000862437,
-0.4591015279,
-0.6413909793,
0.0866642669,
0.0973569676,
-0.4401675463,
0.4257690609,
-0.5117589831,
0.6065390706,
-0.3966642618,
-1.1262773275,
-0.2560060918,
-0.1941010058,
0.1627408564,
-0.0831335187,
0.53799963,
0.1709400564,
-0.2122705728,
0.408170253,
-0.9369740486,
0.8113955259,
-0.1803274006,
-0.3449020684,
0.5413658023,
0.3334108293,
0.7520301342,
0.2088410109,
0.1160896793,
-0.3194316626,
-0.6198962331,
0.0343044475,
-0.9518880248,
0.5593675375,
-0.7274304628,
-0.8595765829,
0.0436412878,
-0.6583091021,
0.0162130818,
0.1001959518,
-0.3468541801,
0.2760882676,
-0.2897570431,
0.1050639525,
0.5290672183,
-0.4197059274,
0.6140067577,
0.555783093,
-0.5371477604,
-0.67879498,
0.6783630848,
0.0348981172,
0.3024342954,
0.1875206977,
-0.1827692837,
-0.0493557379,
-0.3687378168,
-0.6200797558,
0.1515647918,
-0.782464385,
-0.0338063911,
-0.3688582778,
-0.1680777222,
-0.2196090966,
-0.7299712896,
-0.4499443769,
-0.3157171607,
-0.1772184372,
-0.3267404735,
0.4035404623,
0.901190877,
-0.1733496636,
0.5784615874,
-0.8101016283,
0.5399134159,
0.7143528461,
0.3399822414,
-0.3385990262,
-0.4932846725,
-0.6708936095,
-0.2352254987,
-0.2688426673,
-0.9507960677,
0.4084627628,
0.160256803,
0.5259827375,
0.2196070254,
-0.4143262208,
0.4726228714,
-0.545363307,
0.9724076986,
0.023124842,
-0.876285851,
0.5007821321,
-0.3380049765,
0.300830096,
0.1335480213,
-0.1606528014,
-0.6165060401,
-0.3478667736,
-0.2103259414,
-0.5493789315,
0.5015878677,
0.098599121,
0.1409406364,
0.2481286675,
0.2468684465,
0.2063222677,
0.2095485479,
-0.5812079906,
0.1227541938,
-0.2122670263,
0.1635637432,
-0.1184460446,
-0.0784854293,
0.0777623132,
-0.0651847571,
0.5489182472,
-0.0604202487,
-0.1181773022,
0.2745869756,
-0.4385094941,
-0.4915753305,
0.5114747882,
0.5510915518,
0.4615138173,
-0.1683463305,
-0.0701181814,
0.1915237457,
-0.3645463884,
0.3710791171,
-0.0663635209,
-0.2009214312,
-0.0341138542,
0.3452275097,
0.9506494999,
-0.1048515141,
-1.000238061,
0.2813897431,
0.0333455913,
-0.3356179297,
-0.377830416,
0.2150061876,
-0.1152804866,
0.5977668762,
0.1966612339,
-0.0772965401,
0.0872840062,
-0.426615268,
-0.0064191469,
0.6318617463,
-0.1211677417,
-0.3416116536,
0.7111783624,
0.3405198157,
-1.0320706367,
0.0307990611,
-0.0315636508,
-0.2639332712,
0.3058412373,
0.1334070116,
1.082015872,
-0.1539601386,
0.5139904618,
-0.030118987,
0.2718881667,
0.0591113232,
0.0838157758,
-0.1434215307,
-0.686517179,
-0.9005408883,
-0.5847430825,
-0.5191835165,
0.1432238221,
-0.2559357882,
0.6031309366,
-0.2488346696,
-0.2352247834,
-0.0593882389,
-0.3171686232,
-0.81550318,
0.1046062559,
0.3029334545,
0.8263341188,
-0.7670884132,
0.9020754099,
1.0018515587,
-0.6042916775,
-0.6041767001,
-0.399802655,
-0.0190878958,
-0.6132659912,
0.5871420503,
-0.2144149095,
-0.358322382,
-0.3625573814,
-0.3732478023,
-0.4543614089,
1.0910534859,
0.5456154346,
-0.4494985044,
-0.2923185229,
0.643856585,
0.7708566189,
-0.4799222946,
-0.012846997,
0.5368673801,
0.3322112262,
0.3249156177,
-0.9867577553,
-0.3835647106,
-0.1879934371,
-0.1641998589,
0.0652764142,
-0.5808829069,
0.6341037154,
-0.2208548933,
0.2434037924,
-0.0847864971,
0.5127900839,
-0.0883984193,
0.2817435265,
0.448279351,
0.2639466524,
0.5114157796,
0.4235588312,
0.6363595724,
-0.0990856439,
-0.2033042908,
1.2474901676,
-0.0931437314,
0.6678268909,
0.6451052427,
-0.1206444055,
0.5448927879,
0.1823643297,
0.217335999,
0.2267084718,
-0.0305809695,
-0.6474881768,
-0.4912403524,
-0.5322910547,
-0.0563334897,
0.7247067094,
0.2804092467,
-0.4118611515,
0.0294801574,
0.3147985041,
0.039812725,
0.4543084204,
-0.7412337065,
0.8205682039,
-0.0380031914,
-0.4996728897,
0.2771469057,
-0.106798552,
0.2865481675,
-0.5289899111,
-0.2391685098,
-0.2122019231,
-0.0306536537,
-0.4123830795,
-1.1417472363,
0.1958337128,
0.5993070006,
-0.0651968718,
-0.4613811076,
0.827242732,
-0.6312851906,
-0.3276577592,
0.1210547388,
0.7350496054,
0.1578215361,
-0.0868456587,
-0.2739808559,
0.5252984762,
-0.1332983524,
-0.0860941485,
0.2138358206,
0.308698982,
-0.2049080878,
0.5399326682,
0.3855312467,
0.2179409266,
-0.3347307742,
0.27368626,
0.8257410526,
-0.4074080586,
-0.4980793893,
-0.9170337915,
0.9048662782,
0.0755919665,
0.439902693,
0.4782836735,
0.3707101345,
0.7594950795,
-0.2463545054,
1.1354085207,
-0.0453884453,
-0.1115291417,
-0.6112799644,
0.36144346,
-0.715323627,
0.4078903496,
-0.5503199697,
-1.0433930159,
-0.2742145061,
0.1892940253,
-0.2929261625,
-0.3022054732,
0.2432677597,
1.0777620077,
0.1261463016,
-0.4205625057,
0.6193563938,
0.2676661909,
0.6035716534,
0.4184612334,
0.9114484191,
-0.0446766764,
0.5809239149,
-0.2260472178,
-0.1530633122,
-0.099355109,
-0.9386146665,
-1.0067893267,
-0.3607007563,
-0.0547966734,
-0.1082013473,
0.0557166636,
1.2316823006,
0.3672909737,
-0.1169435456,
-0.4227260351,
0.0918497294,
0.2698766589,
0.0720438138,
-0.1105552018,
0.1807413846,
0.2345596701,
-0.9949651957,
0.7002433538,
0.5422689915,
0.1076840833,
-0.6555886865,
-0.6178035736,
0.1462745816,
0.1978285015,
0.7083091736,
0.4467259347,
-0.7792853117,
-0.3529663682,
0.1205082983,
0.2054049969,
0.035982877,
0.7074618936,
-0.7020474076,
0.9509420395,
0.4647296965,
0.7152721882,
0.3731836677,
-0.0037698927,
0.7115613818,
-0.672847569,
0.4135738313,
-0.2583254576,
0.2747036219,
0.5106166601,
-0.4818341434,
0.4375618994,
0.0446341187,
-0.5484890342,
-0.9051069617,
0.2533480227,
-1.0435533524,
0.1078139916,
1.0408480167,
0.1418813318,
-0.1394865364,
0.2058007866,
-0.841704905,
0.3640550673,
-0.3891174197,
0.4093191326,
0.7428070307,
-0.285101831,
-0.4625441432,
-0.7409775257,
0.4863123596,
0.0471739396,
-0.7815049887,
0.0575267635,
0.8244716525,
-0.0362168923,
-0.1449335665,
0.6422325969,
0.2896337807,
0.7283580303,
-0.2809452415,
0.4676060975,
-0.6405866742,
-0.4568044841,
-0.4483905733,
0.2023613304,
0.4628968537,
0.1927043647
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10210v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10210v1
|
Self-Play Fine-Tuning of Diffusion Models for Text-to-Image Generation
| 2024-02-15T18:59:18 | 2024-02-15T18:59:18 |
Huizhuo Yuan, Zixiang Chen, Kaixuan Ji, Quanquan Gu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, stat.ML
|
Fine-tuning Diffusion Models remains an underexplored frontier in generative
artificial intelligence (GenAI), especially when compared with the remarkable
progress made in fine-tuning Large Language Models (LLMs). While cutting-edge
diffusion models such as Stable Diffusion (SD) and SDXL rely on supervised
fine-tuning, their performance inevitably plateaus after seeing a certain
volume of data. Recently, reinforcement learning (RL) has been employed to
fine-tune diffusion models with human preference data, but it requires at least
two images ("winner" and "loser" images) for each text prompt. In this paper,
we introduce an innovative technique called self-play fine-tuning for diffusion
models (SPIN-Diffusion), where the diffusion model engages in competition with
its earlier versions, facilitating an iterative self-improvement process. Our
approach offers an alternative to conventional supervised fine-tuning and RL
strategies, significantly improving both model performance and alignment. Our
experiments on the Pick-a-Pic dataset reveal that SPIN-Diffusion outperforms
the existing supervised fine-tuning method in aspects of human preference
alignment and visual appeal right from its first iteration. By the second
iteration, it exceeds the performance of RLHF-based methods across all metrics,
achieving these results with less data.
|
[
-0.6092152596,
-0.8270278573,
0.7350355387,
0.0799612105,
-0.3803131878,
0.0177051909,
-0.238252297,
-0.0375526585,
0.0597687997,
0.4862156212,
-0.809689045,
-0.5129343867,
-0.5524191856,
0.0116155706,
-0.1765122414,
1.0218896866,
0.0537105538,
-0.0953948498,
-0.1890844554,
-0.1135434657,
-0.4923067689,
0.26717031,
-1.1267894506,
-0.4748956561,
0.6933586001,
0.6315982938,
0.7629422545,
0.7091448903,
0.1652632058,
0.2868261337,
-0.0929220095,
0.5399431586,
-0.4688503146,
0.2817234695,
-0.448342979,
-0.2466208488,
-0.0870940909,
0.1935823858,
0.4127241671,
0.1689167917,
-0.2663617432,
-0.0035329482,
0.0882964432,
1.2368276119,
-0.4948918819,
-0.2055854946,
-0.4719327688,
0.2925970852,
-0.0377885662,
-0.430858165,
-0.3816859126,
-0.3179327846,
0.0802436545,
-0.8125197887,
0.4733462632,
0.2558152974,
0.7887018919,
0.435300529,
-0.2743980885,
-0.2810214162,
-0.7605729103,
0.5801733732,
-0.6766029596,
-0.0057960725,
0.2479077578,
0.1817544401,
-0.2447214276,
-0.2738547623,
-0.4740508199,
-0.070150353,
0.0808829069,
0.2140815258,
-0.0763014778,
-0.0581140183,
0.017995391,
0.1376445293,
-0.3632470667,
0.3385433853,
-0.2350278795,
0.14237988,
0.7337106466,
0.0983552039,
0.3524457812,
-0.1188499928,
-0.1597391069,
-0.2964960635,
-0.6506256461,
-0.0340838209,
0.4335116446,
0.402805537,
-0.0486746356,
0.4498604238,
-0.3354851604,
0.6627976894,
0.7912704349,
0.0859294385,
0.1527591497,
-0.0608649887,
-0.0882152095,
-0.0404672958,
1.0560907125,
0.3981308639,
0.3187659979,
-0.0527711771,
-0.1945139766,
-0.1913199127,
0.221666187,
-0.8342880607,
-0.5396071672,
-0.0289225653,
-0.7169566154,
-0.6603143811,
-0.4402231574,
-0.9334477782,
-0.5504862666,
-0.2404516488,
0.679184556,
-0.4134663939,
-0.3366389275,
0.0092644356,
-0.1377292126,
-0.0338951126,
0.4158829749,
-1.0748473406,
-0.0061378106,
0.3149753511,
0.9575729966,
-0.7132832408,
-0.2296430469,
-0.484614104,
-0.0046440591,
-0.779026866,
1.1755193472,
-0.4001187086,
-0.4881809354,
-0.1571439356,
-0.3420406878,
0.0716169626,
-0.6229125857,
0.2727659643,
-0.6422894597,
0.465136975,
-0.0420079045,
-0.6218774915,
0.0944188312,
0.1312382072,
-0.4703710079,
0.8355160952,
-0.09460482,
-0.5755823851,
0.5553279519,
-0.7608315945,
-0.6282292604,
-0.0790112317,
-0.2889314592,
-0.8186808228,
0.2842459083,
0.4591239691,
0.5699114799,
-0.1551558524,
0.150263086,
-0.4218543768,
-0.1993079334,
0.0652000755,
-0.5513074994,
0.2824144959,
0.3820487559,
-0.3433901966,
0.3523462117,
-0.7408744693,
-0.0268073175,
0.3293783367,
-0.1017766073,
-0.2626792192,
0.2551793456,
0.0129478863,
0.3742206991,
0.0416023061,
-0.3505192697,
0.3065790534,
-0.3102629185,
0.3821102977,
0.9174800515,
0.0193282831,
0.9418167472,
-0.3004854023,
0.4884975851,
0.2289030999,
0.11363139,
-0.2191303074,
-0.4592161179,
-0.6474871635,
-0.257019192,
0.4933369458,
0.2205658257,
-0.7418311238,
0.2440899312,
0.0621915795,
-0.3526448011,
-0.6777413487,
0.2448791116,
0.2121137232,
0.7063180804,
0.4518642426,
-0.266197741,
0.0689980835,
-0.8122656941,
-0.1228767261,
0.2840834856,
0.1512382478,
0.5843521953,
0.1150255576,
-0.1627280265,
0.9454280734,
-0.5376824141,
-0.5771379471,
-0.1073480695,
0.7256466746,
0.0619945936,
0.6236457825,
0.4912934601,
-0.7065150142,
-0.6209402084,
-0.0454333164,
-0.4704130888,
0.0401585884,
-0.3756923676,
-0.1625249088,
0.4002734125,
0.54160285,
-0.3227609694,
0.4239081442,
0.5903558135,
-0.6353844404,
0.4390330613,
-0.8055747747,
0.4197509885,
-0.8268837333,
-0.2266630977,
0.2658627033,
-0.3306255043,
-0.3532349467,
-0.118462123,
0.0739891231,
-0.0243058857,
-0.2641921639,
0.6860029101,
-0.3743118942,
-0.0037980173,
-0.6421108842,
0.0968163684,
-0.1449566036,
0.3279201388,
0.2454978973,
1.0417540073,
0.7359759212,
-0.8494971395,
-0.1859773695,
0.1386492103,
-0.3932356536,
0.7114228606,
-0.6003984213,
0.0480650216,
-0.4164996445,
0.1195907742,
-1.1994804144,
-0.1197854877,
0.2381646186,
-0.3155576587,
0.423291266,
-0.1809458435,
-0.3735860586,
-0.0815038309,
-0.1048856154,
0.4557622373,
0.7011057734,
-0.826564908,
0.7172142267,
0.0568939112,
0.0214623716,
-0.3100371063,
-0.3184455037,
-0.0413478836,
-0.4495671391,
-0.5343513489,
0.524333775,
-0.2395990789,
0.4183228016,
-0.0419071019,
0.1090150476,
0.1801921725,
0.1448980272,
0.0750346482,
0.067549713,
0.063335821,
0.0858580247,
0.4814210832,
-0.3561915755,
-0.2606398463,
-0.2218692601,
0.5256963372,
0.2540376782,
-0.1380832791,
-0.6833553314,
0.1752265692,
0.2487179041,
-0.2012293637,
0.4732124805,
0.7349280715,
0.1669622511,
-0.4661815464,
-0.4024107754,
-0.1108435169,
-0.5721345544,
-0.0221597385,
-0.3871542215,
-1.0140798092,
0.2867847681,
-0.426156342,
-0.0953061506,
0.5415998101,
0.4752110243,
-0.7653257847,
1.5243848562,
0.6144695878,
0.0934644789,
0.8362817168,
-0.2936739028,
-0.0741199329,
-0.707547605,
0.0232415237,
-0.2033664435,
-0.5810685754,
-0.7381259203,
-0.3352625966,
0.4223587215,
0.0237444676,
-0.3663708866,
0.0054634502,
-0.6358475685,
0.6544565558,
0.7105856538,
0.3801024556,
0.2919029593,
0.1614645571,
-0.1984267235,
-0.0104949428,
-0.749912858,
-0.215336144,
0.9595050216,
0.2421076894,
1.04514575,
-0.0638583377,
1.0924313068,
0.6348025203,
0.0733711421,
-0.4931898117,
0.4348307252,
-0.4814012647,
-0.34815979,
-0.5567202568,
-0.4768150747,
-0.9549652338,
0.0973363295,
-0.5975154042,
-0.2274780273,
0.2468763888,
0.7079132199,
-0.6172404289,
0.0934086964,
-0.5615092516,
0.8501812816,
-0.2052709907,
-0.5256769657,
-0.5619481206,
-0.2326738834,
0.172838971,
0.1664716601,
0.1157379672,
-0.2000169009,
0.1969195902,
0.4691127539,
0.1301294416,
0.7136815786,
-0.1993156821,
-0.1975243688,
-0.0230767485,
0.3928919733,
0.4505852163,
0.0344733037,
0.151657179,
-0.2261525989,
-0.2599922121,
-0.27382043,
-0.68217206,
0.6817667484,
-0.7395683527,
-0.5329369903,
-0.3168386221,
-0.3085692525,
-0.1344880462,
0.2634655535,
0.5842111111,
0.221795857,
-0.2441383004,
-0.1386345029,
1.1263695955,
-0.2325692475,
0.4636600018,
0.2879161537,
-0.3126034141,
-0.4727286994,
1.1003136635,
-0.096534133,
0.3019126058,
0.0895004198,
0.5222648382,
-0.3258644342,
-0.6712081432,
-0.7299946547,
0.13172777,
-0.2936033607,
-0.3024958968,
-0.4365364313,
-0.1119931117,
-0.239172101,
-0.2681466639,
-0.5701785088,
-0.3053514361,
-0.8345649838,
0.2261749506,
0.3460958004,
0.8859127164,
-0.2801985443,
0.4602797627,
-0.4255700409,
0.5940408111,
0.534773469,
0.6717451811,
0.0348634236,
-0.6953927279,
-0.1179833636,
-0.0860322937,
-0.3365968764,
-0.6628192663,
0.4045212567,
0.3045516908,
0.2144343108,
0.5867617726,
-0.183780551,
0.7086479068,
-0.8513828516,
0.5931494832,
0.4347139597,
-0.5648863316,
0.772562027,
-0.5523166656,
0.3246299922,
0.590898335,
0.0828514695,
-0.380240649,
-0.2111510187,
-0.6336914301,
-0.6852219105,
0.6179018021,
0.0172124878,
0.1778829843,
-0.0246739797,
0.4701927602,
0.0385163799,
-0.0160378851,
-0.5282257795,
-0.289909035,
-0.1459915489,
-0.3499182761,
-0.2510287762,
-0.1117188483,
-0.1620874703,
-0.1914500147,
0.6985134482,
-0.3368352652,
0.135678038,
0.2097156495,
0.0441741422,
-0.2437927872,
0.1290159523,
0.5457853675,
0.1837733835,
0.0633514151,
-0.1266333312,
-0.1830116659,
0.0792506337,
0.3013697863,
-0.0016240812,
-0.725545764,
-0.4136035442,
-0.291929394,
0.9065571427,
0.0541220494,
-0.4241761267,
0.3965471983,
-0.2099238485,
-0.3963965476,
-0.100305222,
0.4808986485,
-0.0161504392,
0.4773957729,
0.2173866928,
0.3009165227,
0.4399082363,
-0.3296752572,
0.2318208069,
0.7499474883,
-0.3401919901,
0.1173066199,
0.8430640697,
0.2081516683,
-0.3892935216,
0.4501287043,
-0.4765464962,
-0.1292716712,
0.5022254586,
0.6487541795,
0.9016411901,
0.0397571884,
0.8758468032,
0.4701965451,
-0.0790431947,
-0.5416637659,
0.0549982302,
-0.2039756775,
-0.8092730045,
-0.221799776,
-0.3130196035,
-0.2019934058,
-0.2959515452,
-0.4311526418,
0.0611445382,
-0.5549642444,
-0.2576824129,
-0.0076785791,
-0.1630870253,
-0.692248106,
0.3163732886,
0.3241423368,
0.7047461271,
-0.9284174442,
0.6544203758,
0.4081339836,
-0.2884578109,
-0.4132309556,
0.0922544301,
-0.287016958,
-0.4879359305,
0.5022335649,
0.0076695057,
-0.3577829599,
0.3169163465,
-0.7867285609,
-0.9337015152,
1.1351932287,
-0.0122901546,
-0.5027198792,
-0.0345250517,
-0.1624966562,
0.5904455185,
-0.6018488407,
0.2166558504,
0.6077352166,
0.2714064121,
0.2350429446,
-0.3748547435,
-0.2780126035,
0.1088906005,
0.4283124804,
0.0873961449,
-0.8928273916,
0.4381693602,
-0.379891634,
-0.3030996025,
0.1476734132,
1.0522267818,
0.4092367589,
0.2870265245,
0.7169665694,
0.7278676033,
0.5227289796,
0.0467703342,
0.581643939,
-0.0621471554,
0.38016662,
1.2680521011,
-0.0508697443,
0.7636078596,
0.3370994031,
0.1721670777,
0.616132915,
0.6221217513,
-0.1398915499,
0.9414960742,
0.028804373,
0.0612312965,
-0.6099873781,
0.1424322575,
0.0614296794,
0.3187144399,
0.2614618242,
-0.4010892212,
-0.2787653506,
0.1878001094,
-0.2399622649,
0.4071739912,
-0.3098395467,
0.9840248227,
-0.3655743003,
-0.8438863754,
0.0860349908,
0.0192570314,
1.0704427958,
-0.2900018394,
-0.1595380455,
-0.4197129011,
0.0279346108,
-0.0308606904,
-1.0017325878,
-0.0766419098,
-0.1174206287,
-0.3467474282,
-0.3728586435,
0.7005393505,
-0.544426024,
-0.505366385,
0.2251416892,
0.3311488032,
-0.3338781595,
0.138735041,
-0.9998547435,
-0.2217711657,
-0.0049125552,
-0.2986557484,
0.4720981121,
0.3759639561,
0.2895296216,
0.8869701028,
0.5034757853,
0.0317326337,
-0.0098184953,
0.1071124226,
0.6265645027,
-0.5672181845,
-0.5441445708,
-0.7114012241,
0.378408283,
-0.1621439755,
-0.5327894688,
0.4045778513,
0.3984437883,
0.6655182242,
-0.1111502945,
0.6329471469,
-0.0102741467,
0.5371690989,
-0.6252892613,
0.8947355151,
-0.8303221464,
-0.1703928262,
-0.2960891128,
-0.488592267,
-0.122204043,
0.8429085016,
-0.121005483,
0.2213688046,
0.254724443,
0.7813518047,
-0.246250391,
-0.2676022947,
0.3723529875,
-0.0173057914,
0.273000598,
0.211564362,
0.7107998729,
-0.3080563545,
0.2914855778,
-0.3590248823,
-0.3110707998,
-0.0903580412,
-1.0786498785,
-0.9421905875,
-0.6123210788,
-0.4940656424,
-0.4327459335,
0.1251399964,
0.8542289734,
0.811542809,
-0.6486257315,
-0.0797261372,
-0.2812429965,
0.0565745384,
-0.3816399872,
-0.2131056339,
0.3730837703,
-0.7423089147,
-0.6436510086,
0.3690118194,
0.2688624561,
0.1585520506,
-0.3713846803,
-0.1583690792,
-0.1077310145,
0.1899076551,
0.4569430649,
0.3712988794,
-0.4774312675,
-0.0660976619,
-0.0591350794,
-0.0721816197,
0.321348846,
0.6427474618,
-0.9089357853,
0.5662874579,
0.3401481211,
0.5678036809,
0.748600781,
0.2110039741,
0.5003872514,
-0.5080846548,
-0.2085791677,
-0.0103131542,
-0.0172544885,
0.200590685,
-0.4064585865,
0.2742566168,
-0.0401316285,
-0.825521946,
-0.2544420362,
0.3971239328,
-0.7035434842,
-0.3935118914,
1.0587197542,
0.2716254294,
-0.1785232872,
0.3149903119,
-0.3591304123,
0.1801328361,
-0.5995303988,
1.2639282942,
0.4612652957,
-0.3683320284,
-0.4750623107,
-0.1529096067,
0.9349395633,
0.5902981758,
-0.7658920884,
-0.0381950364,
0.6932953,
0.5084468722,
-0.0661993772,
0.7776949406,
0.0738956556,
0.4300366044,
-0.4643601179,
-0.0841378123,
0.0445598885,
-0.6717720628,
-0.5830926299,
-0.0441879071,
0.113313213,
-0.1220476031
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10208v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10208v2
|
Recovering the Pre-Fine-Tuning Weights of Generative Models
| 2024-02-15T18:59:02 | 2024-07-01T12:48:51 |
Eliahu Horwitz, Jonathan Kahana, Yedid Hoshen
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.CV
|
The dominant paradigm in generative modeling consists of two steps: i)
pre-training on a large-scale but unsafe dataset, ii) aligning the pre-trained
model with human values via fine-tuning. This practice is considered safe, as
no current method can recover the unsafe, pre-fine-tuning model weights. In
this paper, we demonstrate that this assumption is often false. Concretely, we
present Spectral DeTuning, a method that can recover the weights of the
pre-fine-tuning model using a few low-rank (LoRA) fine-tuned models. In
contrast to previous attacks that attempt to recover pre-fine-tuning
capabilities, our method aims to recover the exact pre-fine-tuning weights. Our
approach exploits this new vulnerability against large-scale models such as a
personalized Stable Diffusion and an aligned Mistral.
|
[
-0.5750954151,
-0.5477378964,
-0.0115153473,
-0.3769088686,
-0.3180119693,
0.0688261986,
-0.0779710412,
-0.5218664408,
-0.0811923519,
0.7285275459,
-0.7212640047,
-0.3564425707,
-0.5748919845,
-0.2258400917,
-0.6059221029,
1.1153041124,
0.3450747728,
-0.0251801629,
0.2132022232,
0.2311462313,
-0.3642643392,
-0.4075373113,
-0.7915281057,
-0.0147527149,
0.8514399529,
0.238108173,
0.5778170824,
0.3467026651,
0.5691625476,
0.3397589028,
0.0538220666,
0.2199102789,
-1.0044351816,
0.0759077668,
-0.0556708649,
-0.8008099794,
-0.5225846767,
0.3910501599,
0.4259882569,
0.6563424468,
-0.1902477145,
0.1745936126,
0.3930854201,
0.9651571512,
-0.9820821285,
-0.4330421686,
-0.9832866192,
0.1505502909,
-0.3861438334,
-0.2358999103,
-0.5636777282,
-0.6433309913,
-0.2091051787,
-0.6417412162,
0.4452458918,
-0.0947975889,
1.0703749657,
0.7451003194,
-0.3211340606,
0.4466172755,
-1.0577092171,
0.6964656115,
-0.4075124562,
0.0404745303,
0.7205521464,
0.5908969045,
0.0702543631,
-0.8030574918,
-0.0963193476,
0.0701785386,
0.191646874,
0.1466418654,
-0.3631138206,
0.1401241422,
0.4034546912,
0.4754245877,
-0.1284397691,
0.5164073706,
-0.3790538311,
-0.0695746765,
0.560951829,
0.1333135962,
0.0619111247,
-0.0700705349,
-0.4992003143,
-0.2802423835,
-1.096514225,
-0.2400397062,
0.7545816898,
0.7002174258,
-0.1911347657,
0.4309032857,
0.1149728373,
0.7729856372,
0.4996085167,
0.1678567082,
0.0799216554,
-0.3718663454,
-0.4202029109,
0.0995950624,
0.5151305199,
0.1225332618,
0.5100969076,
-0.1447726041,
-0.0872909278,
0.1790368855,
0.6846162677,
-0.637887001,
-0.4400878549,
0.0809328109,
-0.5988704562,
-0.7343463302,
-0.0710995346,
-0.7911162376,
-0.484259218,
-0.4267715812,
0.694002986,
-0.4328942597,
-0.3606081903,
-0.0183749236,
0.1001684889,
0.2483160496,
0.3868476152,
-1.0603456497,
0.1076692641,
0.6701099277,
0.5037767291,
0.0681510121,
-0.0097199529,
-0.4112259746,
0.072684139,
-0.4328501821,
0.4932421744,
-0.2455993295,
-0.5011428595,
-0.2371772826,
-0.0276238546,
-0.0056907688,
-0.6219175458,
0.524407506,
-0.7226605415,
-0.310013026,
-0.6405681372,
-0.2678402364,
0.1161311045,
0.169783473,
-0.7181788683,
0.6181291938,
0.0663176775,
-0.9833632112,
0.5101662874,
-0.3881466985,
-0.068311438,
-0.1608356833,
0.0209684148,
-0.7967984676,
0.3302483857,
-0.0170439519,
0.2926191688,
-0.1793043315,
-0.2110580355,
-0.6141365767,
-0.2403092831,
-0.0591323338,
-0.5350849032,
0.9932564497,
0.3705219924,
-0.0468686186,
0.1834178269,
-1.0722368956,
0.0848236978,
0.0796726644,
-0.0615769401,
-0.5140224695,
-0.0172639843,
-0.1851993948,
0.1917109042,
0.159173578,
-0.5319899917,
0.2570775449,
-0.3645706475,
0.4384322762,
1.0834394693,
0.0570092387,
0.3888615072,
-0.3317454457,
0.4633205831,
0.0840135887,
0.1216698587,
0.3009642363,
0.1543361992,
-0.6070678234,
-0.5543178916,
0.5795714259,
0.1192061603,
-0.5061340928,
0.6685909033,
-0.2385615557,
-0.7618269324,
-0.6195734143,
0.0529906563,
0.4612669647,
0.553658843,
0.2333019376,
-0.2092142999,
-0.6904708743,
-0.9554914236,
-0.3504089415,
0.2294408381,
-0.325904727,
0.0139380973,
0.5512679219,
-0.3231679201,
0.8825702071,
-0.730109334,
-0.4866048694,
0.2657001913,
0.3091621101,
-0.2045903504,
1.1629750729,
0.538593173,
-0.7875024676,
-0.2053860426,
-0.1310714483,
-0.6840984225,
0.2181051522,
0.2008716166,
-0.3609448671,
-0.1586790979,
0.5515491366,
-0.5461459756,
0.3920170665,
0.3347846866,
-0.0821181238,
0.6742238402,
-0.3459895253,
0.0041135172,
-1.1000009775,
0.309597522,
-0.0870196223,
-0.2688210309,
-0.6492720246,
0.3348656297,
0.0262042657,
-0.1953861266,
-0.1793170571,
-0.16116032,
-0.3172142506,
-0.0014782909,
-0.1790986061,
-0.3152500987,
-0.1844394803,
0.2326444238,
-0.2712573111,
0.6306598783,
0.5248590708,
-0.680013895,
-0.1142300218,
0.1489977986,
-0.7327302694,
0.7200709581,
-0.7694584131,
0.4097722769,
-0.5729448795,
-0.0380468704,
-0.8609175086,
-0.2927582562,
-0.0701503754,
-0.0952043906,
0.3972836733,
-0.5018344522,
-0.472968787,
-0.1866694391,
-0.200528115,
0.5251736641,
0.6297154427,
-0.6250149012,
0.5081170201,
0.4060912728,
0.1344989985,
-0.4507521093,
-0.4507421255,
-0.3301196098,
-0.565320313,
-0.3799146116,
0.3444113433,
0.0697362423,
-0.1468685567,
-0.3675552309,
-0.0382718705,
0.146272555,
0.7525132895,
0.5842144489,
0.2162266076,
0.0518888608,
-0.0559642017,
0.0664941221,
-0.5232097507,
-0.1828779131,
-0.233637616,
0.7391144037,
0.0186306462,
-0.584241271,
-0.2840036452,
0.0699552074,
0.5799198151,
-0.595468998,
0.6197895408,
0.6873146296,
-0.7022522688,
-0.1597250253,
-0.3119369149,
-0.220502466,
-0.521751523,
0.3291603029,
-0.2796815038,
-0.5658664107,
0.5875495076,
-0.3270633221,
0.1972228289,
0.5126405954,
0.4051469266,
-0.3533570766,
1.2797062397,
0.8959129453,
-0.0935197324,
0.5119735599,
-0.4585251212,
0.0972030163,
-0.6693445444,
-0.2149884105,
-0.8953832984,
-0.7268201113,
-0.4929215312,
0.1147215515,
0.6990484595,
0.5606071949,
-0.5977030396,
0.2223019004,
-0.4924170971,
0.5367287993,
0.6458663344,
0.3214928806,
0.1901254803,
0.3173189163,
0.1599161476,
0.022968797,
-0.2458960712,
-0.1507846117,
0.9840736985,
0.1507490277,
1.2593730688,
0.2273398936,
0.830509901,
0.0794187933,
0.229572162,
-0.4458144307,
0.270206809,
-0.4803394675,
-0.6688286066,
-0.4353164732,
-0.5858011246,
-1.2557473183,
0.3324941397,
-0.3761950433,
-0.9580013752,
0.5037196875,
0.4516206682,
-0.7516033053,
0.3433643281,
-0.6792514324,
0.6695828438,
0.0200616643,
-0.1316622645,
-0.2524717748,
-0.7288342118,
0.5888214707,
-0.3292546868,
0.0420883,
-0.0716141239,
0.3651748002,
0.6672740579,
-0.5098425746,
1.0525516272,
-0.4505020082,
-0.5017260313,
-0.1380839944,
0.1736793369,
0.5011014938,
-0.3693717122,
0.1183146313,
0.0170925185,
0.0927213356,
-0.3925362527,
-0.4624527097,
0.6560953856,
-1.0275284052,
-0.5444858074,
-0.0146669624,
-0.2301119715,
-0.233366102,
0.3046770394,
0.8139785528,
0.2476474792,
-0.3004234433,
0.2318628281,
0.8496773243,
0.1452248991,
0.3850596547,
0.4645638168,
0.0140296333,
-0.2620386183,
0.9735683203,
0.2778038681,
0.5626809001,
0.12786147,
-0.0407199934,
0.1381639838,
-0.5250029564,
-0.0414584577,
-0.2066441327,
-0.3393281698,
-0.4881565869,
-0.3773272336,
-0.3048052192,
-0.142082572,
-0.1867944151,
-0.7513571978,
-0.2351978868,
-0.3600052595,
-0.2151706368,
0.2496043444,
0.3198145628,
-0.2196210027,
0.4033401012,
-0.9165004492,
0.4925701022,
0.3812870979,
0.3369630575,
0.2042394131,
-0.2646703422,
-0.1826097369,
0.3386870623,
-0.2313086241,
-0.5407674313,
0.2987942696,
0.2447842807,
0.1206246093,
0.9444516897,
0.2007755339,
0.8617710471,
-0.6867375374,
0.507837534,
0.3419889808,
-0.7407568693,
0.6936811805,
-0.4171105325,
0.2656784058,
0.9236332178,
0.3760526478,
-0.1906178147,
-0.0326728821,
-0.4615320265,
-0.800180614,
0.4801190794,
0.0580033697,
0.0500630662,
0.1902203709,
0.4806579947,
0.2233083397,
0.2039054185,
-0.4695631564,
-0.327549696,
-0.256959945,
-0.3022353053,
-0.2883743942,
-0.1397068053,
-0.6668316126,
-0.4547788799,
0.3867556453,
-0.1390726119,
0.0496637523,
-0.0917874575,
-0.196319744,
-0.3325331509,
-0.0164552927,
0.2812824547,
0.3101118207,
-0.2100661546,
0.4426962137,
-0.1351679713,
-0.5692631006,
0.2727058828,
0.2280492187,
-0.3696525693,
-0.7366758585,
0.1944654137,
0.6223910451,
0.4428636134,
-0.304135859,
0.3654969335,
0.003927717,
-0.1769050658,
-0.3657006621,
0.2054776847,
-0.2494620234,
0.0472332835,
0.3306772411,
0.6840994954,
-0.1656507701,
-0.2064539939,
0.0758859143,
0.8165690899,
-0.45719257,
-0.5790132284,
0.9841231704,
0.0718796477,
0.0589815676,
0.528341651,
0.239153266,
-0.0442115255,
0.5394054055,
0.4729242027,
0.9601472616,
-0.3869776726,
0.0684822947,
0.2876666188,
0.2783968151,
-0.1511121839,
0.1682423055,
-0.0427136496,
-0.8251273632,
-0.1398945302,
-0.689999938,
0.3816679418,
-0.1165216267,
-1.0427877903,
0.1427812725,
-0.680767417,
-0.3968280256,
0.2218786925,
-0.06390699,
-0.5887710452,
0.0612313002,
0.0252368785,
0.7370400429,
-0.812413156,
0.8695333004,
0.2241709083,
-0.4564947784,
-0.719987154,
-0.0081007611,
0.1064339057,
-0.7220128775,
0.7388697863,
-0.0795893967,
-0.346675247,
0.4759666324,
-0.9373486042,
-1.3089455366,
1.1281775236,
0.8519109488,
-0.5714244246,
-0.325600028,
-0.1310749203,
0.4339155555,
0.2613475323,
-0.3324436247,
0.5380024314,
0.3190312386,
-0.1106004491,
-0.7102895379,
-0.0291750822,
-0.1189475805,
0.0184127726,
0.4876963794,
-0.5762555599,
1.0488910675,
-0.1541905105,
-0.4690479934,
0.3972570002,
0.5128958821,
-0.0098116761,
-0.2700550854,
0.7738110423,
1.0064926147,
1.0624486208,
-0.1542094648,
1.0274721384,
-0.427272588,
0.3234336376,
0.9032513499,
-0.2025533766,
0.738026619,
0.1940863729,
-0.2519466579,
0.2990114689,
0.6006467342,
-0.047660511,
0.9046233892,
0.2431932837,
-0.1933162808,
-0.46907866,
0.0381340124,
-0.6932644248,
0.7244380713,
0.2000695914,
-0.3188888431,
-0.313896805,
0.1322579086,
-0.0832309723,
-0.2310107201,
-0.8366234303,
0.891921103,
0.1591035575,
-0.3980848491,
0.9871520996,
-0.0572271757,
0.6069087386,
-0.7418240309,
0.1439793557,
0.0655005053,
0.3317163885,
-0.3662992716,
0.0662075803,
0.1753779799,
-0.1525903493,
-0.3175166845,
-0.0817094594,
0.869218111,
-0.3307593763,
-0.4578718543,
-0.0098182233,
0.2556070387,
-0.2841136754,
0.0241752788,
-0.1969967037,
-0.0197155438,
-0.1346724778,
0.0034930555,
0.6971711516,
-0.0184060913,
0.1261451691,
0.6983447075,
0.5652109981,
-0.0677110255,
-0.0047310372,
0.2182100117,
0.8612793684,
-0.4571679235,
-0.5956630111,
-0.8215949535,
0.4639552832,
0.0603171401,
-0.1957540363,
0.799392283,
0.3442515731,
0.6892341971,
-0.1055458486,
0.4845985174,
0.2450549155,
0.3408797383,
-0.6776369214,
1.1519680023,
-0.454684943,
0.1343347281,
-0.5340726972,
-0.7162500024,
-0.2000190318,
0.4409623444,
-0.1633859277,
0.2064272761,
0.1291216463,
0.7025818229,
-0.108049117,
0.1127864122,
0.238689661,
0.513181746,
0.1232247502,
0.3439302742,
0.6734439135,
-0.208843872,
0.1772069335,
-0.1036938056,
-0.2100383788,
0.0432512499,
-0.6634665132,
-0.6315191984,
-0.6398326755,
-0.1233863235,
-0.4819643497,
-0.0774779767,
0.7531426549,
0.9110766053,
-0.6711378098,
0.3241602182,
-0.2291705012,
-0.0981042236,
-0.3809531331,
-0.1527046561,
0.4490248561,
-0.1994169056,
-0.7321794033,
0.1943369806,
0.0115926275,
0.3063237965,
-0.4274909496,
0.2406461984,
0.1521438062,
-0.1501087993,
0.4311783016,
0.4252295792,
-0.4451347291,
-0.4947704375,
-0.6278240681,
-0.0493253991,
-0.0576309673,
0.8202773929,
-0.9343355894,
0.1697959751,
0.200090766,
0.5692446828,
0.54090482,
0.3151819408,
0.6342195272,
-1.0234560966,
0.1811390668,
0.1461593211,
0.2697183192,
0.0791125596,
-0.2761271298,
0.3636659086,
-0.00530886,
-0.3025003374,
-1.0334231853,
0.6208717227,
-0.9011483788,
-0.3872044384,
0.5398675203,
-0.1342166364,
0.0172472317,
0.0671148822,
-0.1505199671,
0.3172879815,
0.2176173776,
1.0340646505,
0.1666796207,
0.2533357739,
-0.0636443272,
-0.1125379726,
0.8650720716,
0.3340655565,
-0.8722186089,
0.2277705222,
0.4500692189,
0.3301930726,
0.2731383443,
0.3823811412,
-0.4408848584,
0.0209317841,
0.0688136742,
-0.1621636599,
-0.0650200844,
-0.3276375532,
-0.3936421275,
0.5898458362,
0.1630340219,
-0.1922701448
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10207v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10207v5
|
Rewards-in-Context: Multi-objective Alignment of Foundation Models with Dynamic Preference Adjustment
| 2024-02-15T18:58:31 | 2024-06-05T09:25:41 |
Rui Yang, Xiaoman Pan, Feng Luo, Shuang Qiu, Han Zhong, Dong Yu, Jianshu Chen
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We consider the problem of multi-objective alignment of foundation models
with human preferences, which is a critical step towards helpful and harmless
AI systems. However, it is generally costly and unstable to fine-tune large
foundation models using reinforcement learning (RL), and the
multi-dimensionality, heterogeneity, and conflicting nature of human
preferences further complicate the alignment process. In this paper, we
introduce Rewards-in-Context (RiC), which conditions the response of a
foundation model on multiple rewards in its prompt context and applies
supervised fine-tuning for alignment. The salient features of RiC are
simplicity and adaptivity, as it only requires supervised fine-tuning of a
single foundation model and supports dynamic adjustment for user preferences
during inference time. Inspired by the analytical solution of an abstracted
convex optimization problem, our dynamic inference-time adjustment method
approaches the Pareto-optimal solution for multiple objectives. Empirical
evidence demonstrates the efficacy of our method in aligning both Large
Language Models (LLMs) and diffusion models to accommodate diverse rewards with
only around 10% GPU hours compared with multi-objective RL baseline.
|
[
-0.4325997829,
-0.5693405271,
0.4329862893,
0.3818439543,
-0.047685083,
0.0563796423,
-0.5039101243,
-0.2500005662,
-0.0190846361,
0.1837834567,
-0.8158705235,
-0.2232536227,
-0.6447697282,
-0.0216653142,
0.1367696077,
1.2246400118,
-0.1360125393,
-0.1895548701,
-0.30097574,
-0.3485785127,
-0.6700521708,
-0.0235191174,
-0.6816407442,
-0.3030093908,
0.7485098839,
0.7908124924,
0.4585335851,
0.6480892897,
0.4702151418,
0.2875628769,
-0.0249828845,
0.2405604124,
-0.5893058777,
0.2579966486,
-0.3275208771,
-0.2037213743,
-0.2468572408,
0.085539192,
0.5570288897,
0.4299792051,
-0.3106620908,
0.0625898317,
0.393386215,
0.7254548669,
-1.0386099815,
-0.0143270306,
-0.4700547755,
0.0879681408,
0.0834322795,
-0.3791538477,
-0.309610635,
-0.2532317042,
0.1529919356,
-0.819775939,
-0.1827472895,
-0.265843451,
0.8899040222,
0.8964092731,
-0.5616828203,
-0.3541713655,
-0.5160017014,
1.1159971952,
-0.2736791372,
0.1069429815,
0.0691332147,
0.5652750134,
-0.0222739596,
-0.3176816106,
-0.113424696,
-0.1443207115,
-0.2151606083,
0.105068624,
0.2974979579,
-0.033058349,
0.1668501645,
0.0884578079,
-0.1945333183,
0.2023364305,
0.1248311773,
0.1477123499,
0.5103704333,
0.2920210361,
0.0615853481,
0.1637006998,
-0.7116369605,
-0.2907669842,
-0.6263039708,
0.6532389522,
0.2125104815,
0.5840060115,
-0.2668067515,
0.5070111752,
-0.5185688138,
1.0217989683,
0.4410458505,
-0.3897642493,
0.0939782336,
-0.3619719446,
-0.0781904012,
0.377202332,
0.5113809109,
0.4094009697,
0.0569871143,
-0.0587493479,
-0.3054790199,
0.3052063584,
0.3532996774,
-0.8655569553,
0.0808057114,
0.2496218234,
-0.3347054422,
-0.5186830163,
-0.1007431075,
-0.6927875876,
-0.5129464865,
-0.5829590559,
0.3660488129,
-0.1067372337,
-0.0077409707,
0.3212625682,
-0.1217717826,
0.1255443394,
0.5032841563,
-1.0247679949,
-0.0189573746,
0.6460090876,
0.6790682673,
-0.2909555435,
-0.4842944741,
-0.9617049694,
0.4535497129,
0.0546542332,
0.7879175544,
-0.8323891163,
-0.2706512809,
-0.1325168759,
-0.1873090416,
-0.0516191125,
-0.269276768,
0.5124849081,
-0.2245215327,
0.2058809847,
-0.560497582,
-0.4268479347,
0.211690411,
0.6232561469,
-0.3872875273,
0.8343756795,
-0.0089219762,
-0.5847157836,
0.6996763349,
-1.0627874136,
-0.4946555793,
-0.2380955517,
-0.1754815578,
-0.2777994871,
0.1105500832,
0.2757744491,
0.44669047,
-0.1314360052,
0.8035301566,
-0.3965175152,
-0.5050962567,
0.2372630835,
-0.2998697162,
0.6922625303,
0.1826958954,
-0.7113169432,
0.5262823701,
-0.6688517928,
-0.2465926856,
-0.1470630467,
-0.5800106525,
-0.3589218557,
0.4124421179,
-0.1654082686,
0.2097728252,
0.4785898924,
-0.4379703701,
0.542265892,
-0.0354713127,
0.3601924777,
1.0377457142,
-0.3175043762,
0.6297205687,
-0.2419167906,
0.5092026591,
-0.1252965182,
0.2411400825,
0.1554277241,
-0.1126574278,
-0.4313584566,
-0.557737112,
0.3260933757,
0.3886377215,
-0.2870678604,
0.3014883697,
-0.3214844763,
-0.1235266179,
-0.3713743389,
-0.1731047034,
0.3266084492,
0.6364445686,
0.4486758411,
-0.1031466052,
-0.1183297932,
-0.9029173851,
-0.3244268,
0.1319626719,
0.1455809176,
0.8298287988,
0.2660225928,
-0.2470531762,
1.0243492126,
-0.5366973281,
-0.3599788547,
0.179361999,
0.2859956622,
0.1095688567,
0.6330322027,
0.803293705,
-1.0829480886,
-0.5809163451,
0.0024033491,
-0.6152239442,
-0.2122395933,
-0.201524049,
-0.3187450171,
-0.2037062347,
0.2412052751,
-0.2680243552,
0.1514140517,
0.5209736228,
-0.4053377807,
0.4234136045,
-0.0216552131,
0.3329960704,
-0.8487708569,
0.1217867732,
0.011161332,
-0.0913433656,
-0.1950578839,
0.0025098922,
0.0984449685,
-0.014005661,
-0.3049792647,
0.8836686611,
-0.2707101405,
-0.1132419854,
-0.3818682134,
0.026216222,
0.0410633646,
0.5602545738,
0.2637799084,
0.7344838381,
0.5868745446,
-0.8459144235,
0.3358230293,
0.3049981296,
-0.3997080624,
1.1037834883,
-0.4859898984,
-0.2554883063,
-0.0344827659,
0.4267043769,
-0.7507950664,
-0.432392329,
0.3197494149,
-0.2733879387,
0.2170121223,
-0.0635147318,
0.1562699527,
0.2074577361,
-0.3131373525,
0.6279421449,
-0.0316211544,
-0.8984986544,
0.6596087217,
0.2432522178,
-0.0284375791,
-1.3039603233,
-0.4023669064,
-0.0756174624,
-0.5116128922,
-0.3295823634,
0.8635450006,
-0.3528632522,
-0.1195219532,
0.2997492254,
-0.1099730581,
0.2393993437,
0.547572732,
0.2725647092,
-0.0741299316,
-0.12689659,
-0.0785531253,
0.4111587703,
-0.3125622272,
-0.2532375753,
-0.2159473002,
0.2331197262,
-0.1603481472,
-0.3086963892,
-0.3775398135,
0.2741421163,
0.558336556,
-0.3486746252,
0.773950398,
0.5369519591,
-0.4114933908,
0.0341449678,
-0.4135403633,
-0.2218148559,
-0.4544468224,
0.2541260123,
-0.6506059766,
-1.0031374693,
0.3807530105,
-0.0485399775,
0.1971442103,
0.2189976275,
0.6783705354,
0.0116129443,
1.194029212,
0.6346948147,
-0.1968316883,
0.8512366414,
0.0105701713,
0.0429542623,
-0.9201254845,
-0.3720169067,
-0.6722712517,
-0.8173184395,
-0.382682085,
0.2710630596,
0.4090313613,
0.1854132563,
-0.5833516717,
0.0660509467,
-0.5813813806,
0.4963516593,
0.5348628163,
0.1621046066,
0.0155090243,
-0.197277382,
0.027931843,
0.2204210013,
-0.6329866052,
-0.284399122,
0.7613574862,
-0.0198429246,
0.7548218369,
0.3457612097,
0.5792914629,
0.2354957461,
0.4991572499,
-0.6003894806,
0.1178751811,
-0.1074014083,
-0.6586512923,
-0.5124874115,
-0.3761194646,
-0.8041660786,
0.2361026704,
-0.5076329112,
-0.7821492553,
0.4998348057,
0.4460217953,
-0.7254461646,
-0.023292724,
-0.447237134,
1.2593585253,
-0.5848729014,
-0.7104516625,
-0.3641844094,
-0.6890687346,
0.3910217285,
0.1673349589,
0.0975177437,
-0.3857339323,
0.0678009987,
0.2893784642,
-0.0813151821,
0.6796882153,
-0.4544624686,
0.1075319499,
-0.3191410303,
-0.0787216946,
0.588316083,
0.3907250166,
-0.1172805056,
-0.3388561308,
-0.1075873896,
-0.6035780311,
-0.5959068537,
0.9431316257,
-0.6970769167,
-0.4205704927,
-0.4761534035,
-0.7652614117,
-0.2368404716,
0.1021003202,
0.0146086914,
0.4773631394,
-0.3682924211,
0.4643060565,
0.4556486309,
-0.3874569535,
0.310506165,
0.4708022773,
0.129711628,
-0.2166290879,
0.8704286218,
-0.4908153117,
0.1608314663,
0.6591852903,
0.4292030632,
-0.3597651124,
-0.3515704274,
-0.7637422681,
-0.1301819086,
-0.3458863795,
-0.2927868664,
-0.4788250625,
0.4228982031,
-0.2069040984,
-0.7586645484,
-0.4592072666,
-0.0649506822,
-0.5067913532,
0.1786110252,
0.1694310904,
0.4411654472,
-0.0793306455,
0.4879743457,
-0.5879976749,
0.2618426681,
0.3422193825,
0.4548276961,
-0.194116503,
-0.3452986777,
-0.396640569,
0.2628845572,
-0.2396427095,
-0.500824213,
0.0944344997,
0.1988403052,
0.5343778729,
0.5798124075,
0.0952460542,
0.8702982068,
-0.3455215096,
0.6060341001,
0.1416517496,
-0.9218903184,
0.3801127076,
-0.3353646398,
0.0544273034,
0.8335608244,
0.2398839444,
-0.5415271521,
0.0886934474,
-0.2455521822,
-0.7092570662,
0.8461889029,
-0.247532472,
-0.0568734482,
0.1312576085,
0.5238345861,
0.0780246779,
0.288975209,
-0.7634375095,
-0.0948342308,
-0.2128518671,
-0.4714816213,
-0.2993981838,
-0.2380291969,
-0.4989649355,
-0.1003420129,
0.7871630192,
-0.4836713672,
0.1238037422,
-0.2930537462,
-0.2076136172,
-0.1210277453,
0.20466353,
1.0343029499,
0.773981154,
-0.3585543633,
-0.0627329871,
-0.0465864912,
0.2963463664,
0.4038878381,
0.2238181829,
0.0156590231,
-0.6655500531,
0.0159650669,
1.1755155325,
0.5810762048,
-0.6567294002,
0.5788378119,
-0.2572053969,
-0.0316052176,
-0.0698230714,
0.3549040556,
-0.0124124223,
0.5048143268,
0.1012366489,
0.2336727828,
0.0821433142,
-0.4628743231,
0.017423436,
0.8800307512,
-0.4043000937,
-0.0067517683,
0.8437820077,
0.1896303147,
-0.0945226252,
0.5458871722,
-0.0704999268,
-0.4267969728,
0.6751220822,
0.4053155184,
0.6086388826,
-0.2196666002,
0.254725188,
0.2583231926,
-0.1275767982,
-0.3252176046,
-0.0973368213,
-0.2288211435,
-1.0519021749,
-0.4504191279,
-0.7187811136,
-0.4734812677,
-0.1595554054,
-0.8790183663,
0.3370825648,
-0.1599875391,
0.0902388245,
0.1146931797,
-0.0676082224,
-0.47341308,
0.3111666143,
-0.0986216366,
0.6753599048,
-0.9391895533,
0.7241957188,
0.7407449484,
-0.1491677612,
-0.5156551003,
-0.1864266247,
0.0449648798,
-0.494435668,
0.5544945002,
0.2519754469,
-0.3780966699,
0.1028700322,
-0.4924771786,
-0.9300093651,
1.0735340118,
0.539303422,
-0.3914930224,
0.1513849795,
-0.2810227871,
0.2396579087,
-0.6526154876,
0.1305401921,
0.457919538,
0.8391618729,
-0.1726985425,
-0.4462830126,
-0.183367148,
-0.1062037572,
-0.3160167933,
0.3945902586,
-0.7320426106,
0.6576109529,
-0.0568524227,
0.1078855321,
-0.0323213525,
0.5003902912,
0.4858032763,
0.2431156337,
0.7948836684,
0.5418727994,
0.7418621182,
-0.187974304,
1.0966217518,
-0.4698394835,
0.4703300595,
0.9954894781,
-0.3580073118,
0.3736391068,
0.4964736998,
0.1055061221,
0.6032034159,
1.0494397879,
0.2663817406,
0.9197105765,
-0.0299016815,
-0.1353799552,
-0.385771662,
-0.2505934834,
-0.3552690744,
0.3784258664,
0.2938843966,
0.1065512747,
-0.0617063418,
0.0199286472,
-0.3678679168,
0.0250843056,
-0.1628520787,
0.5699467659,
-0.2896052599,
-1.026361227,
0.2964370251,
0.2461135089,
0.694860816,
-0.5571725368,
0.0039511183,
-0.2453999966,
0.3497460783,
-0.1501660198,
-0.4128397107,
0.0322693586,
-0.0437482223,
-0.4681944549,
-0.4441337287,
0.328235805,
-0.6414620876,
-0.284103781,
0.2960229814,
0.1642933041,
-0.2868384123,
-0.0633992702,
-0.908038795,
0.0999790281,
-0.0238611978,
-0.4125071764,
0.5772916675,
0.2186939716,
-0.1136767864,
0.5288678408,
0.4960906804,
-0.2433406264,
-0.2868527174,
-0.1357022226,
0.7105517387,
-0.5303601623,
-0.7123458385,
-1.0003839731,
0.7517538667,
-0.011908954,
-0.4915108085,
0.275054425,
0.5729494691,
0.8890923262,
0.1796664298,
0.6117210984,
-0.1494988501,
0.1920164376,
-0.6710002422,
0.2033474892,
-1.1524455547,
0.1082546785,
-0.3133681715,
-1.0104669333,
-0.2929434478,
0.9001893401,
-0.1197681576,
-0.0201826524,
0.555482924,
0.584611237,
-0.4510213733,
-0.1311032027,
-0.1317999661,
-0.1196086928,
0.2656652331,
0.7225905061,
0.8075502515,
0.3051926494,
0.0250005368,
-0.3107661903,
-0.4769041836,
-0.4838004112,
-1.292260766,
-0.406353265,
-0.4049100876,
-0.2926337421,
-0.2662324309,
0.2471529096,
1.056402564,
0.6580511332,
-0.9783431292,
-0.3793601692,
0.1846661568,
0.3512705564,
-0.7412785888,
-0.1877664477,
0.4302836359,
-0.4233830869,
-0.992585659,
0.7040709257,
0.3959721327,
-0.3689514101,
-0.0553784408,
-0.4564854801,
-0.2121617645,
-0.1637871265,
0.3417147696,
0.2640263438,
-0.682798028,
-0.524702549,
-0.0183871221,
-0.1975134015,
0.2309734523,
0.9539080858,
-0.6631844044,
0.3653428853,
0.2652463615,
1.0067933798,
0.598593533,
0.5219148397,
0.5260388851,
-0.6779871583,
0.2085178792,
-0.1524949521,
0.3782541454,
0.2169478834,
-0.5536693335,
0.4410228133,
0.079099305,
-0.5933274627,
-0.9577712417,
0.4065984786,
-0.9299212694,
-0.4822225869,
1.0173270702,
-0.086348772,
0.0407436229,
0.2384643406,
-0.0414392203,
0.322322458,
-0.533316493,
0.9237354994,
0.7649441957,
-0.2991175056,
0.0318703316,
-0.1644042879,
0.647259295,
0.6447972655,
-0.7107078433,
-0.0541544221,
0.7516353726,
0.1831336915,
-0.0611847788,
0.4625594318,
0.275053829,
0.2298680395,
-0.5113680959,
0.1671568453,
-0.1372004896,
-0.7886124253,
-0.5307507515,
0.2331920862,
0.0936688259,
-0.2562744319
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10260v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10260v1
|
A StrongREJECT for Empty Jailbreaks
| 2024-02-15T18:58:09 | 2024-02-15T18:58:09 |
Alexandra Souly, Qingyuan Lu, Dillon Bowen, Tu Trinh, Elvis Hsieh, Sana Pandey, Pieter Abbeel, Justin Svegliato, Scott Emmons, Olivia Watkins, Sam Toyer
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
The rise of large language models (LLMs) has drawn attention to the existence
of "jailbreaks" that allow the models to be used maliciously. However, there is
no standard benchmark for measuring the severity of a jailbreak, leaving
authors of jailbreak papers to create their own. We show that these benchmarks
often include vague or unanswerable questions and use grading criteria that are
biased towards overestimating the misuse potential of low-quality model
responses. Some jailbreak techniques make the problem worse by decreasing the
quality of model responses even on benign questions: we show that several
jailbreaking techniques substantially reduce the zero-shot performance of GPT-4
on MMLU. Jailbreaks can also make it harder to elicit harmful responses from an
"uncensored" open-source model. We present a new benchmark, StrongREJECT, which
better discriminates between effective and ineffective jailbreaks by using a
higher-quality question set and a more accurate response grading algorithm. We
show that our new grading scheme better accords with human judgment of response
quality and overall jailbreak effectiveness, especially on the sort of
low-quality responses that contribute the most to over-estimation of jailbreak
performance on existing benchmarks. We release our code and data at
https://github.com/alexandrasouly/strongreject.
|
[
-0.306415379,
-0.6785429716,
0.5826443434,
-0.0957817882,
-0.2583813667,
0.0302691665,
-0.2082620263,
-0.6100315452,
0.0707872137,
0.7039667368,
-0.0137248104,
-0.4632244408,
-0.5560202003,
-0.0596073829,
-0.6197798252,
1.1793973446,
-0.0643012822,
-0.0335266851,
-0.1560243219,
-0.4240043461,
-0.4538572133,
-0.5801445842,
0.0912890211,
-0.3312131763,
0.4372846186,
0.4641943276,
0.6616013646,
0.4713868797,
0.7642620802,
0.2483901978,
-0.2070268691,
-0.0604374334,
-0.4313201606,
-0.0771921128,
-0.2482433766,
-0.2714500427,
-0.3019764125,
0.1990687996,
0.1330832094,
0.4282910526,
-0.2417277992,
0.3375044465,
-0.1125079915,
0.6532503366,
-0.98070997,
-0.3958247602,
-0.6202853918,
-0.0752997622,
-0.3054706156,
0.2857548296,
-0.4100323021,
-0.3398846686,
-0.3880517483,
-0.2679624259,
0.1408950388,
-0.1075540558,
0.9026761651,
0.0767687485,
-0.315541029,
-0.1724703759,
-0.5799339414,
0.7757530212,
-0.9911387563,
0.1040073559,
0.5261287093,
0.3565051854,
-0.1899421364,
-0.518448174,
-0.1345103085,
-0.4557540119,
0.1612312645,
-0.0299528725,
-0.2371446043,
0.0989353061,
0.366199702,
0.5432932973,
-0.3579416573,
0.2618278265,
-0.7529874444,
-0.2541441619,
0.6816592813,
0.1809393167,
0.1309888363,
-0.354791373,
-0.2606797814,
0.2362022549,
-1.0452874899,
-0.0348620303,
0.9407456517,
0.4185174704,
-0.1158806458,
0.8814495802,
-0.0807278603,
0.7266922593,
-0.1278360486,
-0.064668633,
0.4282288253,
-0.3166378438,
-0.0952743217,
-0.1559526026,
0.8001310229,
0.4827175736,
0.306628406,
-0.2870487869,
-0.2068294138,
0.0022925592,
0.4184480011,
-1.0669077635,
-0.2507790327,
0.3598553538,
-0.3640522659,
-0.4793670177,
0.1718134135,
-0.5781989098,
-0.7738941312,
0.3243799806,
0.4149544835,
-0.2568529844,
-0.1498776525,
0.1222124621,
-0.1659146994,
0.0986186117,
0.3408783674,
-0.6446242929,
0.364567548,
0.5380485058,
0.9185169339,
-0.0552094728,
-0.0965815559,
-0.6699351668,
-0.0649860129,
-0.3020367026,
0.7497286797,
-0.348010838,
-0.2948977947,
-0.2038656026,
-0.1519205421,
0.3657713234,
-0.9437947869,
0.5926674008,
-0.25015679,
-0.0353332534,
-0.0301359873,
-0.601675272,
-0.0295752436,
0.2371956706,
-0.5039967299,
0.735129416,
0.3187222183,
-0.7517648935,
0.3955768943,
-0.340305835,
-0.4685702622,
-0.0513551198,
0.0835693106,
-0.5399310589,
0.3142980635,
0.1380875111,
0.3748183548,
-0.2446619868,
0.5323144197,
-0.7592437863,
-0.6183800697,
0.2488584816,
-0.1990649849,
0.5729990005,
0.4410544038,
-0.2983292937,
-0.0470208637,
-0.8047083616,
0.1229659393,
0.0669566765,
-0.4266978502,
-0.4918052554,
0.1392625272,
-0.1614176929,
0.1326482147,
0.1403819919,
-0.9670059681,
0.2583637536,
-0.5244207382,
0.6119840145,
0.8888126016,
-0.0811586455,
0.2930158377,
-0.20556584,
0.2643164098,
0.1311789453,
0.2382320166,
0.0086237192,
-0.4374222159,
-0.4195036292,
-0.163704142,
0.1132797524,
0.4187229872,
-0.2453587651,
0.1101957485,
0.0161753725,
-0.6840788722,
-0.7410542369,
0.6763285995,
0.6504060626,
0.5045355558,
0.622115314,
-0.4151673913,
-0.4662928581,
-0.9925277233,
-0.6046443582,
-0.477409333,
-0.064846009,
0.3951985538,
0.5215456486,
0.041302707,
0.5151597857,
-0.3907206953,
-0.2200174481,
-0.3876849115,
0.2549418509,
0.4205776751,
0.3529874086,
0.5622237921,
-0.3963213563,
-0.0257340092,
-0.3792417347,
-0.8401774764,
-0.297850877,
0.353853792,
0.3588100672,
-0.1121653244,
0.3839014471,
-0.5679111481,
0.19539994,
0.5144053698,
-0.6068396568,
0.7264021635,
-0.0586586408,
0.128616333,
-0.7458095551,
0.1341264397,
0.106989488,
-0.1428007782,
-0.608716011,
0.5537121892,
0.2773425579,
-0.1011897326,
-0.8628236055,
0.6461910605,
-0.2738726735,
-0.1392002553,
-0.229084447,
0.1224406809,
0.0225893557,
0.0888064653,
-0.4368163347,
0.8497490883,
0.0903216526,
-0.1243343055,
0.3378302753,
0.1658946574,
-0.621445477,
0.2620610893,
-0.8330590129,
0.0810884535,
-0.0340888016,
-0.2103649825,
-0.8759625554,
-0.2367833257,
-0.0215950925,
-0.3540576696,
0.0939473584,
-0.5304920673,
-0.4444007874,
-0.6941021681,
-0.4919626415,
0.3020429015,
0.4905636609,
-0.4204231203,
-0.0582940392,
0.2378250659,
0.1775640994,
-0.6355798841,
-0.8307526112,
0.1011206657,
-0.3743526042,
-0.5191056132,
0.1137686819,
-0.114897266,
-0.4360198677,
-0.0061298287,
-0.1772508174,
-0.1285769343,
0.2905238271,
0.4942419231,
0.292940706,
-0.2579377592,
-0.2445383817,
-0.2741450369,
0.0869659632,
0.0760717243,
0.2358573377,
0.2683554888,
-0.1850967258,
-0.3652976751,
-0.092368558,
0.0863792524,
0.8679360151,
-0.2726970315,
0.5132853985,
0.1056376174,
-0.0671747476,
-0.0409085639,
-0.726257205,
-0.0498145185,
-0.5144228339,
0.2540142238,
-0.3369719088,
-1.1587361097,
0.57295084,
0.1459689587,
-0.0363651626,
0.0404068492,
0.4458807409,
0.0828509405,
0.9700328112,
0.4863629341,
-0.3985422552,
0.3411048949,
0.0189071335,
0.1973335594,
-0.8419355154,
-0.0579497032,
-0.6553379893,
-0.2324320525,
-0.4753281176,
-0.1908698827,
-0.1279861182,
0.5072635412,
-0.633305192,
0.6449505091,
-0.4706046581,
0.5994073749,
0.2984798849,
0.1557940245,
0.4105718434,
-0.2370067239,
-0.0473360382,
-0.0728942901,
-0.1777860075,
-0.5236336589,
1.3596359491,
0.3774552941,
1.0787630081,
0.2252182066,
0.8698539734,
0.3704833388,
0.697014153,
-0.7392013073,
0.5141686797,
-0.2361054271,
-0.9229979515,
0.0359703228,
-0.7597391009,
-0.6396259665,
0.1249608546,
0.129435882,
-1.0647416115,
-0.0404464193,
0.1006374955,
-0.3866379857,
0.4252251685,
-0.906748116,
1.0719432831,
-0.272393465,
-0.64672333,
0.0046983198,
-0.3614192009,
0.8220330477,
-0.1645949185,
0.3514745533,
-0.6975560784,
0.1939174086,
0.597458899,
-0.7963483334,
0.6033910513,
-0.6344802976,
-0.1207893863,
0.5129417777,
0.3092444241,
0.5383239985,
0.2021819204,
-0.3234154284,
0.1138784438,
-0.2031038404,
-0.3580950499,
-0.5629718304,
0.7594694495,
-0.8756751418,
-0.6385249496,
-0.143963784,
-0.3359452486,
-0.2539795935,
0.224190861,
0.2367151529,
0.2788579166,
-0.04699523,
-0.0021995935,
0.1550052166,
-0.4847943783,
0.2516090572,
0.8807780743,
-0.249396801,
-0.4000358582,
0.6643757224,
0.1726463586,
0.3488978446,
-0.1201784089,
0.1920783669,
-0.0578931384,
-0.9575315118,
-0.4159579575,
0.2433950901,
-0.4830496907,
-0.6031950116,
-0.2660286725,
-0.2167055905,
-0.3018456399,
-0.1441782564,
-0.6367754936,
-0.3544970155,
0.0142939426,
-0.2893241346,
0.3597925007,
0.6184771061,
-0.1255578846,
0.1798787117,
-0.6640310884,
0.576980114,
0.0982140973,
0.5251336098,
-0.2820315659,
-1.0149863958,
-0.2410651892,
-0.1265164316,
-0.5127905011,
-0.7581185102,
0.2489537299,
0.0177184343,
0.3897289932,
0.4157896936,
0.2609957755,
0.9228794575,
-0.4890929461,
0.7355570793,
0.3671147525,
-0.8699023128,
0.8117800355,
-0.3860127926,
0.2528220415,
0.8702361584,
0.1283127367,
-0.2644172609,
-1.0395416021,
-0.3768058717,
-1.0545400381,
0.4251274168,
0.1193759292,
0.4347247779,
-0.2281868011,
0.4442323744,
0.0127694737,
0.3079580665,
-0.8557596207,
-0.1286038458,
-0.3435431421,
0.0675124973,
-0.2212836891,
-0.2691403925,
-0.0018222377,
-0.3428636193,
0.4397411942,
0.1126537025,
0.1758505404,
-0.0422738865,
-0.1757591814,
-0.2625912726,
0.5522472858,
0.477460295,
0.4688635767,
-0.7025724053,
0.2206446379,
-0.078310132,
-0.5536467433,
0.638517797,
0.0428089052,
-0.1759905219,
-0.215437144,
0.2788773179,
0.4540214539,
0.0555242747,
-0.9789463282,
0.9320493937,
0.0119939959,
-0.2013423443,
-0.0050485805,
0.3853514493,
-0.1636169553,
0.1724281609,
0.2629973888,
0.0390691794,
0.1590757072,
-0.7024095654,
0.3410726488,
0.3169272542,
-0.5078365207,
-0.3383294046,
0.9003480673,
0.1640207171,
-0.0441898964,
0.8457756042,
-0.2035088241,
-0.1357021928,
0.5280875564,
0.6029224992,
0.7924693227,
-0.2153096497,
0.2884442806,
0.4464313686,
0.4958890975,
-0.2574483454,
0.2218667716,
0.1408983022,
-0.8116511703,
-0.6064975262,
-0.6695134044,
-0.3737502992,
0.5499017239,
-0.6834653616,
0.1991056949,
-0.797051847,
-0.2483070046,
-0.018890284,
-0.1200298071,
-0.2929224074,
0.0923776925,
0.0490477681,
1.0085061789,
-0.8267942071,
0.7558150291,
0.5232960582,
-0.571442008,
-0.6673793793,
-0.4078564346,
0.1357771158,
-0.6308770776,
0.550845027,
0.4851686656,
0.2045352906,
-0.3034886122,
-0.678260386,
-0.737174809,
0.5476104617,
0.7181367278,
-0.5972266197,
0.0256610122,
0.0572836846,
0.4139349163,
0.1913236678,
0.2667016089,
0.4799151719,
0.4724072814,
-0.2956474423,
-0.8556056619,
0.1739338636,
-0.4428703487,
-0.4179967642,
0.6668628454,
-0.5872904062,
0.7294974327,
-0.5985888839,
-0.0099168066,
0.598796308,
0.2882961333,
0.1698018759,
0.2251426131,
0.0413014777,
1.0021737814,
0.4201107025,
-0.2864536643,
0.9684169292,
-0.1134131253,
0.3780301213,
1.3208978176,
-0.4414288998,
0.9868783951,
0.5792511106,
-0.1853753477,
0.3632518053,
0.2181212008,
-0.5129218698,
0.7313369513,
0.6936345696,
-0.2351837754,
-0.1451546252,
0.1497079879,
-0.2253630906,
0.4365631044,
0.1420546323,
-0.2791732848,
-0.4600299299,
0.2812467813,
0.1279399842,
0.0695353672,
-0.3550650477,
0.673543334,
0.2138978094,
-0.5283745527,
0.6795511246,
0.4694389105,
0.6934191585,
-0.4959222376,
0.2381808907,
-0.6555235386,
0.305857867,
-0.3848589063,
-0.947127521,
0.3046613038,
0.5431551933,
0.0011805546,
0.0483112186,
0.6967291236,
0.1400984377,
-0.2517841458,
0.6004856825,
0.5558973551,
0.3968533576,
-0.1572113037,
-0.7192727923,
0.0536858812,
-0.2949021459,
-0.4421876371,
0.5338905454,
0.1825214922,
0.2450838834,
0.7271131277,
0.4573502541,
0.2589067519,
-0.0543215312,
0.0990008488,
0.9608060122,
-0.780559659,
0.0265422408,
-1.0341331959,
0.4964565933,
-0.0205876715,
-0.4364204407,
1.0703037977,
0.7865297794,
0.7650343776,
0.2920113206,
0.6825507283,
-0.1704817116,
0.5013782978,
-0.3815087676,
0.6163977385,
-0.6381367445,
0.4671068192,
-0.777233243,
-0.7433440089,
-0.3504027128,
0.5387785435,
-0.4131025672,
-0.0172731318,
0.388638854,
0.8180963397,
-0.1605165899,
-0.3116701841,
0.6015105844,
0.2758254111,
0.3470315933,
0.58116889,
1.0339305401,
-0.5572749972,
0.6960607767,
-0.2798184454,
0.0819698349,
-0.0785858333,
-0.6395873427,
-0.9902507067,
-0.051208023,
-0.1901312768,
-0.5493353605,
0.4703226388,
0.462169379,
0.6278171539,
-0.8489710093,
-0.3686005473,
-0.2075814307,
0.051809337,
0.1320048273,
-0.2418900281,
-0.0561027341,
-0.271513015,
-0.1831201315,
0.6096568108,
0.2425542921,
0.1828283221,
-0.1603924185,
-0.0561737306,
0.1605879217,
-0.0815822259,
0.5691266656,
0.4756975174,
-0.4911717772,
-0.4917941689,
-0.1043205932,
-0.0961235613,
0.2980726957,
0.8665207028,
-0.6024125814,
0.2776224017,
0.1393850595,
0.5087190866,
0.4999215007,
0.2996878028,
0.3147649467,
-0.7814323902,
0.2763811946,
0.262594223,
0.3628863096,
0.3238885105,
-0.1305443645,
0.454839766,
0.1623678356,
-0.5334814787,
-1.1209337711,
0.3147116899,
-0.4887204468,
-0.5297572613,
1.0961458683,
-0.3457336426,
-0.2182537764,
-0.1617753804,
0.1306665093,
-0.1952615678,
-0.5737102628,
0.7915807366,
0.7273063064,
-0.002537783,
-0.2713447511,
-0.8064829111,
0.1223535165,
0.2995165288,
-0.8805248141,
0.3919947743,
0.7508144975,
0.4576124549,
0.0445746966,
0.4768201709,
-0.5510667562,
0.259622395,
-0.1170729548,
0.0398135893,
-0.2736416161,
-0.404112041,
-0.2955630124,
0.4416965246,
0.4495772421,
0.1622022688
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10200v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10200v2
|
Chain-of-Thought Reasoning Without Prompting
| 2024-02-15T18:55:41 | 2024-05-23T20:53:59 |
Xuezhi Wang, Denny Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In enhancing the reasoning capabilities of large language models (LLMs),
prior research primarily focuses on specific prompting techniques such as
few-shot or zero-shot chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting. These methods, while
effective, often involve manually intensive prompt engineering. Our study takes
a novel approach by asking: Can LLMs reason effectively without prompting? Our
findings reveal that, intriguingly, CoT reasoning paths can be elicited from
pre-trained LLMs by simply altering the \textit{decoding} process. Rather than
conventional greedy decoding, we investigate the top-$k$ alternative tokens,
uncovering that CoT paths are frequently inherent in these sequences. This
approach not only bypasses the confounders of prompting but also allows us to
assess the LLMs' \textit{intrinsic} reasoning abilities. Moreover, we observe
that the presence of a CoT in the decoding path correlates with a higher
confidence in the model's decoded answer. This confidence metric effectively
differentiates between CoT and non-CoT paths. Extensive empirical studies on
various reasoning benchmarks show that the proposed CoT-decoding effectively
elicits reasoning capabilities from language models, which were previously
obscured by standard greedy decoding.
|
[
-0.4601102471,
-0.8927277327,
1.0668612719,
-0.015998872,
-0.6675823927,
0.2609035969,
-0.3157978952,
-0.3727617264,
0.145587638,
0.5903835893,
-0.7758107781,
-0.3026891053,
-0.5682651401,
0.2796441019,
-0.398794353,
0.7599004507,
-0.1873298585,
0.0031250231,
-0.1566779464,
0.2330949754,
-0.4183278382,
-0.5235010982,
-0.5227558613,
-0.294688642,
0.9054406285,
0.3477567434,
0.4812465906,
0.4639554918,
0.1301227659,
0.154996112,
-0.3041037917,
0.596419096,
-0.4726820886,
0.1971871853,
-0.3219092488,
-0.736453712,
-0.3956746161,
-0.0522958748,
0.4373729229,
0.6375871897,
0.1397689432,
-0.0070007853,
0.0731824785,
0.845993042,
-0.9882244468,
-0.3407638371,
-1.1286991835,
-0.0402460285,
-0.0077603888,
-0.6727017164,
-0.9010475874,
-0.1183858886,
-0.119193621,
-0.2910806835,
-0.0987419486,
0.2011847049,
0.6080317497,
0.2257389277,
-0.3839922845,
-0.49225685,
-0.7367220521,
0.6554514766,
-0.3122712672,
0.3670372069,
0.543548584,
0.0961141884,
-0.389746666,
-0.4462345243,
-0.6332243085,
-0.3775086403,
0.0524838492,
0.0513858497,
-0.0841758102,
0.3203568459,
0.4573146105,
0.2144965231,
-0.3032625318,
-0.1502715051,
-0.1811627746,
-0.0401985012,
0.3333906829,
-0.0026213131,
0.1040738747,
-0.0234024301,
-0.5249403715,
-0.1157449931,
-0.9266213775,
0.0883360282,
0.2066121548,
0.1476126909,
0.0749720111,
0.6688911915,
-0.1424766779,
0.7386887074,
0.1172086895,
0.2298874259,
-0.2572666109,
-0.3686156273,
-0.2722713947,
0.1632126868,
0.6218162179,
-0.0258796569,
0.4342105389,
-0.2881735265,
-0.3736706674,
0.1849659234,
0.1746741086,
-0.3135963082,
-0.1144291088,
0.3319294155,
-0.2078968734,
-0.2244656235,
-0.0894597992,
-0.4774822891,
-0.2965701222,
-0.1400589943,
0.3165497184,
-0.4233972132,
-0.2613472641,
0.2442532182,
-0.340931505,
0.5459411144,
0.2328241915,
-0.7190313339,
0.107130684,
0.6321823597,
0.8644198775,
0.0822208747,
-0.1230032295,
-0.6441358328,
0.1718285233,
-0.7908073664,
1.0099679232,
-0.5789760351,
-0.4163694978,
-0.2794125974,
-0.290343523,
0.0053538564,
-0.2209303975,
0.4360909462,
-0.6995310783,
-0.2661630809,
-0.6501227617,
-0.5019052029,
0.0290324949,
0.5575232506,
-0.4997679591,
0.7386761308,
-0.1693882495,
-0.6108746529,
0.362654835,
-0.4596467614,
-0.3907126486,
-0.0905336142,
-0.3354599178,
0.1795113981,
0.2502983212,
0.7488762736,
0.1998702437,
-0.2729366422,
0.3094093502,
-0.4126976132,
-0.4010585546,
0.5344427228,
-0.895968616,
0.9095619321,
0.1779479235,
-0.4579891562,
-0.0143635934,
-0.6019098759,
0.2704994678,
0.1297269911,
-0.0256293286,
-0.3704532683,
-0.1230926365,
-0.6552981138,
0.3347916305,
0.1382237077,
-0.3035024703,
0.5154882073,
-0.4412260056,
0.1983945966,
1.1293870211,
0.2022637576,
0.4741828442,
-0.3674557209,
0.7736235261,
-0.0136060622,
0.1227215901,
-0.1905235499,
-0.6037645936,
-0.8998351097,
-0.2381670177,
0.0496856868,
0.3498098552,
-1.04806602,
0.3279462457,
0.0338420197,
-0.3426448703,
-0.4667596817,
0.1079537198,
0.4482978284,
0.4734800756,
0.3673802614,
0.0791721493,
-0.6682443619,
-0.234166041,
-0.4077705443,
-0.245633468,
0.1620469987,
0.2356288433,
0.3733148575,
0.0801084265,
0.7910143137,
-0.49405545,
0.4210996628,
-0.5243287683,
0.013868833,
0.3747776151,
0.2852496505,
0.1217628792,
-0.4076943696,
-0.2463843077,
-0.1555052102,
-0.6814815998,
-0.0572936386,
-0.4051283896,
-0.6718719602,
0.0232075509,
0.5865822434,
-0.889408946,
0.5728477836,
0.1685627252,
-0.415992409,
0.811250627,
-0.2921817899,
0.1803873032,
-0.5963186622,
0.0600381792,
-0.4592244327,
-0.1723960638,
-0.3680424988,
0.1303581446,
-0.0465552174,
0.1898653209,
-0.4155078232,
0.5533408523,
-0.622023344,
-0.0838794932,
-0.4602217376,
0.2203363478,
0.244451642,
0.5804229379,
0.1567426473,
0.787809968,
0.7644172907,
-1.0025503635,
0.1897726506,
0.1802580357,
-0.2867866457,
0.3907778859,
-0.5919036269,
0.5727828145,
-0.2611773312,
0.5945947766,
-0.950083077,
0.0705860183,
0.3261277378,
-0.3874344528,
-0.0798065066,
-0.2036360502,
-0.531116724,
-0.5161495805,
-0.2424720079,
0.5720316768,
0.6445824504,
-0.7938650846,
0.394735992,
-0.1420125961,
0.3634427786,
-0.6643558741,
-0.6635125875,
0.1637909114,
-0.0962927863,
-0.3731330335,
0.0786221102,
-0.2314698994,
-0.1861971915,
-0.17175515,
-0.2322448492,
-0.0859795511,
0.0704506859,
0.0152284522,
0.6019065976,
-0.1195242107,
0.1536719799,
0.1791850775,
-0.1224780455,
0.201575473,
-0.5959079862,
0.6960894465,
-0.0337557793,
-0.3508979082,
-0.3862074316,
0.1350731552,
0.5992560387,
-0.2240996063,
0.7788771391,
0.2320632637,
-0.3216054142,
-0.4470707178,
-0.3837842047,
-0.2970263064,
-0.5390104055,
-0.4243453145,
-0.5339810848,
-0.8399397731,
0.3752029538,
-0.2107574642,
-0.2316363454,
0.025697913,
0.4724201262,
-0.1336066276,
1.2218316793,
0.2070750445,
0.1312526017,
0.2934898734,
-0.4883110523,
0.4716883302,
-1.0055845976,
-0.268720299,
-0.2925485671,
-0.2011383474,
-0.3342955112,
-0.4081604779,
0.4779751599,
0.4004425406,
-0.1869076937,
0.2824438214,
-0.5889998674,
0.8325313926,
0.3397631049,
0.3934051991,
0.2727565169,
-0.1709346175,
-0.5776542425,
0.6235516667,
-0.832357645,
-0.5431981087,
1.0116912127,
0.0434468798,
0.7501883507,
-0.1427977979,
0.7989725471,
0.1685998291,
-0.0179103259,
-0.9066978097,
0.8391808271,
0.2243981361,
-0.5954633355,
-0.1848149747,
-0.4701075256,
-1.0810363293,
0.1928227991,
-0.2524669468,
-0.9760175347,
0.17314592,
0.4000340998,
-0.5973337889,
0.5811456442,
-0.5657375455,
0.416013211,
-0.3676144481,
-0.379480809,
-0.1779124588,
-0.3718549311,
0.5167471766,
0.2349528074,
0.1104467288,
0.0215585902,
-0.0349530242,
0.491635263,
-0.6113967896,
0.5561830997,
-0.1030933931,
-0.2486159503,
0.7624853253,
0.3535873592,
0.8073696494,
-0.0836145952,
-0.0582910739,
-0.2220609933,
-0.2229207605,
-0.4305206537,
-0.9272363782,
0.6206438541,
-0.3616341054,
-0.8871287107,
-0.2749095559,
-0.5332543254,
-0.4922814965,
0.1720018983,
0.4079638422,
0.3973751068,
0.2119441777,
-0.1694399714,
0.6051700711,
-0.0716590583,
0.4396401048,
0.0088658491,
-0.1766459346,
-0.3725335002,
0.6104547977,
-0.0626793727,
0.6098623872,
0.3878590763,
0.4231604338,
-0.6247414947,
-0.4319963157,
-0.4951887429,
0.1306714267,
-0.8703215122,
-0.07755813,
-0.6247519851,
-0.1356182396,
-0.1837366372,
-0.4588049352,
-0.3031771183,
-0.3389734626,
-0.2349927425,
-0.3865432441,
0.4641554356,
0.7963519692,
0.0836789012,
0.1210432723,
-0.7693321109,
0.3481815159,
0.3108710945,
0.2835828066,
0.5155221224,
-0.2310829014,
0.049472034,
0.2484767884,
-0.2173723876,
-0.8331391215,
0.1418810487,
-0.4107040167,
0.4312419593,
0.5174330473,
0.37631616,
1.032600522,
-0.4984336793,
0.8903035522,
0.3324924409,
-1.225476861,
0.832095921,
-0.2066940069,
0.4008942842,
0.4865652621,
0.33339414,
-0.0905277357,
-0.5449118614,
-0.6473297477,
-0.6638153195,
0.4789707065,
0.2609390616,
-0.0722720549,
-0.5142428279,
0.352324903,
0.0563781969,
0.0164147839,
-0.7426123023,
0.0535496287,
0.0379027948,
0.1373745799,
0.3150525391,
-0.1429398507,
0.0366049223,
-0.3900088966,
0.4948553443,
-0.0384096317,
0.3877282739,
0.5569521189,
-0.1373977959,
-0.1776504666,
0.3815913796,
0.473431766,
0.7417511344,
-0.0410826989,
0.6668305993,
0.3857577443,
-0.0426232703,
0.4427721798,
-0.7963322401,
0.0144482395,
-0.111046955,
0.5028823614,
0.8357158303,
-0.0224365462,
-0.6771094203,
0.4722187817,
0.0923940316,
-0.2216104716,
-0.077171579,
0.3349110782,
-0.0910702348,
0.1787209064,
0.2195648551,
0.1483174115,
-0.068802543,
-0.6319026351,
0.1103065014,
0.4964176416,
-0.4325079024,
-0.1454074532,
0.4648014903,
0.0053475131,
-0.2567289472,
0.5878455043,
-0.3251700699,
-0.4968420863,
0.5360280275,
0.6066616178,
0.8890628815,
0.1475197524,
0.1813195199,
0.2942197621,
0.4271541238,
-0.267254889,
0.4059172869,
-0.3872252405,
-0.7718423605,
-0.6583657265,
-0.2930470407,
-0.3429676294,
0.0406063572,
-0.6223117113,
0.3247723877,
-0.7702929378,
-0.1547609121,
-0.371527791,
-0.4771378934,
-0.6446855664,
0.1414990425,
0.2463878542,
1.1531481743,
-0.4511170089,
0.7925183773,
0.2191358805,
-0.3015512526,
-1.0635039806,
0.2460954487,
-0.3526097536,
-0.9268844724,
0.3312195539,
0.2298034281,
-0.7674927711,
0.0412630476,
-0.9245470762,
-0.6777237058,
0.9375741482,
0.4487601817,
-0.5657300949,
-0.1092751101,
-0.103331998,
0.262235254,
-0.3584903479,
0.5076757073,
0.5897448659,
0.4153677523,
0.4979121685,
-0.6265912056,
0.3298794627,
0.0072551989,
-0.1158670038,
0.1922308952,
-0.3013179004,
0.6962276697,
-0.497492075,
-0.3780557811,
0.1433005482,
0.3292974532,
0.6345296502,
0.2950594425,
0.6129405499,
0.3490438163,
1.0407208204,
0.2729265392,
1.2336037159,
-0.302123189,
0.0393302813,
0.9990843534,
-0.3133665919,
0.8302341104,
0.7377130389,
-0.0329087004,
0.9650939703,
0.4274360836,
0.4748711884,
0.6556223631,
0.1989457011,
-0.3790428638,
-0.7715163827,
-0.0786360651,
-0.1447105706,
0.3967354596,
0.4168547094,
-0.2448893487,
-0.0258948263,
-0.0945773795,
-0.0637052208,
0.0063833962,
-0.6204255819,
0.6522097588,
0.4052687585,
-0.9837027788,
1.125615716,
-0.3882709444,
0.5235762,
-0.6275440454,
-0.0606833696,
0.0833676308,
-0.1539426446,
-0.1259302944,
-0.8176406026,
0.1439108104,
0.323685199,
0.0723951235,
-0.3000716865,
0.7671974301,
-0.2260123044,
-0.4265858233,
0.3437556922,
0.7143135071,
0.2012407184,
0.0137746856,
-0.4554770887,
0.05171993,
-0.1813512892,
-0.0876645818,
-0.0199190956,
0.6206094623,
0.020415701,
0.8320007324,
0.9882772565,
0.2486090809,
-0.0965613946,
0.1532605886,
1.0659677982,
-0.8641762137,
-0.6603649259,
-1.3044924736,
0.5062586665,
0.0063245231,
-0.1278770715,
0.5293633938,
0.089390479,
0.7209173441,
-0.0103681721,
0.7960810065,
0.2159543186,
-0.0755102038,
-0.9836464524,
0.4473065734,
-0.3267674446,
0.4611892998,
-0.2763363123,
-0.6256493926,
-0.1407858431,
0.6367080212,
-0.5404980183,
0.017199045,
1.1284514666,
0.7679181695,
0.1659402102,
0.2419511527,
0.3969992697,
0.0942235366,
0.242579326,
0.9079394937,
1.3173500299,
0.0254769139,
0.6084974408,
0.1821129769,
-0.3332751691,
0.1280287206,
-1.0123692751,
-1.1843891144,
-0.2043124288,
-0.0064799986,
-0.5012699366,
0.1083480045,
1.1190674305,
0.4296938777,
-0.5745802522,
-0.1034105495,
-0.8911290765,
0.6279258132,
-0.4390974343,
-0.1502465755,
0.1533679366,
-0.4412044883,
-0.23377271,
0.664955318,
0.3294124603,
0.0449413173,
-0.3631307781,
-0.2374098152,
-0.3217764199,
0.5388119817,
0.6315361261,
-0.0303898305,
-0.9277402163,
-0.4471541345,
0.256539911,
0.1011624113,
0.0765303001,
1.1322962046,
-0.9909265637,
0.507140398,
0.5143318176,
0.4659716785,
0.3640954494,
-0.1395017207,
0.6945123672,
-0.6043419242,
0.1185683608,
0.3283699453,
0.4119750857,
0.0276843458,
-0.6325332522,
0.2442953438,
0.2539449632,
-0.3505017161,
-0.7612687349,
0.4912361205,
-1.0135120153,
-0.3626061678,
1.3670717478,
-0.172727406,
-0.5250294209,
-0.0831689164,
-0.4196858704,
0.2817727327,
-0.2074539363,
0.6420115232,
0.8660341501,
-0.2812371254,
-0.3927074373,
-0.0430398695,
0.3160786927,
0.3682066202,
-0.6668623686,
0.1480861902,
0.1450948864,
-0.0917068869,
-0.0784559622,
0.903919816,
-0.0542116724,
0.3728672862,
0.171644628,
-0.4028440118,
-0.0724047795,
-0.5464079976,
-0.1565247327,
-0.0466203801,
0.3432483971,
-0.1357661337
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10196v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10196v1
|
A Trembling House of Cards? Mapping Adversarial Attacks against Language Agents
| 2024-02-15T18:51:32 | 2024-02-15T18:51:32 |
Lingbo Mo, Zeyi Liao, Boyuan Zheng, Yu Su, Chaowei Xiao, Huan Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Language agents powered by large language models (LLMs) have seen exploding
development. Their capability of using language as a vehicle for thought and
communication lends an incredible level of flexibility and versatility. People
have quickly capitalized on this capability to connect LLMs to a wide range of
external components and environments: databases, tools, the Internet, robotic
embodiment, etc. Many believe an unprecedentedly powerful automation technology
is emerging. However, new automation technologies come with new safety risks,
especially for intricate systems like language agents. There is a surprisingly
large gap between the speed and scale of their development and deployment and
our understanding of their safety risks. Are we building a house of cards? In
this position paper, we present the first systematic effort in mapping
adversarial attacks against language agents. We first present a unified
conceptual framework for agents with three major components: Perception, Brain,
and Action. Under this framework, we present a comprehensive discussion and
propose 12 potential attack scenarios against different components of an agent,
covering different attack strategies (e.g., input manipulation, adversarial
demonstrations, jailbreaking, backdoors). We also draw connections to
successful attack strategies previously applied to LLMs. We emphasize the
urgency to gain a thorough understanding of language agent risks before their
widespread deployment.
|
[
-0.5888010263,
-0.9626920223,
0.3987827301,
-0.0857808217,
0.1751315743,
0.3640888631,
-0.1192437336,
-0.2695559561,
0.0866031125,
0.8532451987,
-0.197324127,
-0.4474168718,
-1.0245860815,
-0.3926701248,
-0.5430940986,
0.9320203662,
0.1371857226,
-0.2143328488,
0.1195517778,
0.1137719452,
-0.160365954,
-0.5535376072,
-0.7123572826,
-0.4473784864,
0.5044109821,
0.0253499784,
1.5696237087,
0.7986630201,
0.5011423826,
0.3993937373,
0.0925734267,
-0.4274435937,
-0.3834172189,
0.2264652848,
-0.0247605778,
-0.5849403143,
-0.753305912,
0.1274371743,
0.412550807,
0.7065514922,
-0.1661338508,
-0.0472484306,
-0.0443810597,
0.6555833817,
-0.3873119354,
0.1192984954,
-0.8172773719,
0.0780597925,
-0.2820636928,
-0.3556611538,
-0.5070702434,
-0.1226122603,
-0.1143183336,
-0.367641896,
-0.0330236442,
0.1177887395,
0.7461767197,
0.5256148577,
-0.4519247413,
-0.280827105,
-0.6393716931,
0.2814011574,
-0.3562254608,
0.0059313797,
0.4545581937,
0.4234544039,
-0.8304644823,
-0.466003567,
-0.5579571724,
-0.4455861151,
0.0550980382,
0.0378247686,
-0.4970181584,
0.1847264767,
0.3429429829,
0.0965701491,
-0.5493437052,
0.0611416548,
-0.0695286989,
-0.156695962,
0.8057280779,
0.2768465281,
0.7638597488,
0.3894133568,
-0.4556870162,
-0.5388239026,
-0.7222258449,
-0.2270017862,
0.9281638861,
0.4056723416,
-0.1204919666,
0.3797566891,
0.3555423021,
0.5590654612,
-0.002049498,
-0.2882196009,
-0.3212183714,
0.0896038637,
-0.0985706449,
0.1706884056,
0.8049329519,
0.2257174402,
0.3920530379,
-0.3863068521,
-0.2195838094,
0.3608206213,
0.7943124771,
-0.2183693647,
-0.2295460552,
0.3525041938,
-0.2260076404,
-0.6528910398,
-0.0365918986,
-1.0952275991,
-1.0556128025,
0.1687682867,
0.3145748675,
-0.1747891307,
-0.3959595859,
-0.1520022303,
-0.1390291154,
0.6106722951,
-0.0963862985,
-0.8943821788,
0.8167867064,
0.795525372,
0.2525283098,
-0.0227306224,
-0.6399412751,
-0.3395696282,
0.0718636215,
-0.5407876968,
0.4865511656,
-0.2377773821,
-0.6825174689,
0.1727371961,
-0.3240190744,
0.0886925906,
-0.3303993642,
0.2190314084,
-0.6106343269,
-0.233825624,
0.1612348258,
-0.1043856442,
0.0875784308,
0.6643163562,
-0.882229805,
0.6701260805,
0.0030733172,
-0.5557780266,
-0.0802517608,
-0.4733831584,
-0.7302833796,
-0.1236980855,
-0.2895402014,
-0.1808155924,
-0.1741273701,
-0.0387337469,
0.4309933484,
-0.3121793568,
0.1648288369,
-0.297010839,
-0.1973155439,
0.5209054351,
-0.627879858,
0.9935419559,
0.3662714064,
-0.5259179473,
0.1380232424,
-0.4877077341,
-0.0858039185,
0.2260277271,
-0.1923468411,
-0.0443097055,
0.1892062724,
-0.3159017563,
0.1367484778,
0.230876565,
-0.0730799288,
0.088575229,
-0.366337955,
0.0654452816,
0.703604877,
-0.1975766718,
0.6830950975,
-0.3726135194,
0.8510614634,
-0.1307942867,
0.3694759309,
-0.1096301302,
-0.3850687146,
-0.5991347432,
-0.1338791549,
0.0687020794,
0.7277465463,
-0.704921484,
0.6781216264,
-0.2473092228,
-0.7811387777,
-0.4338117838,
-0.0345448516,
0.299549818,
-0.1170621589,
0.063003853,
-0.0186014511,
-0.1982074678,
-0.3799133003,
-0.34499228,
-0.4935070574,
0.1839974374,
-0.163183108,
0.3345747292,
-0.2846471369,
0.6844475269,
-0.3999150991,
-0.2886416018,
-0.4359323084,
-0.037192218,
-0.2471673638,
0.3239170611,
0.5290583968,
-0.6667318344,
-0.5337350965,
0.192956835,
-0.7139620781,
0.3060750067,
-0.2825312614,
-0.1194247082,
0.1550723016,
0.7053281665,
-0.549526453,
0.5165227056,
0.5571997762,
-0.3187355697,
0.045207385,
-0.2013496161,
-0.3478815854,
-1.0930123329,
-0.1356353462,
-0.2163097262,
0.1393658221,
-1.0492838621,
0.4012891054,
-0.3563753963,
-0.3460238576,
-0.3833377063,
0.8091503978,
-0.5306140184,
0.1064151302,
-0.3995307982,
0.3403039575,
-0.3192581832,
0.4860441983,
-0.292956233,
0.2511425316,
0.8646716475,
-0.4423411787,
0.5392591357,
-0.1879201382,
0.1187129691,
0.4850064814,
-0.305141449,
0.2316134274,
-0.0688860938,
0.166255191,
-1.0564659834,
-0.060286276,
0.6321851611,
-0.6055048108,
0.6934596896,
0.2002673,
-0.4123360813,
-0.2396196425,
-0.4254311323,
-0.0691375956,
0.6270981431,
-0.4182190001,
1.0574872494,
0.8108632565,
-0.0001588557,
-0.871317625,
-0.5558097959,
0.3491207361,
-0.263325274,
-0.3263913691,
0.05608413,
0.1788410395,
-0.8137899041,
-0.0596147589,
0.07968501,
-0.0277602877,
0.7226404548,
0.6728157997,
-0.0766373873,
0.1240444854,
-0.1406321675,
-0.3839994669,
-0.3075600266,
0.4603478611,
-0.1042345762,
0.424239248,
-0.319318831,
-0.4766176045,
-0.086046055,
0.2856817245,
0.8705056906,
-0.0167366173,
0.6963325739,
0.4733773768,
-0.469665736,
-0.2916575074,
-0.4310971797,
-0.1098685637,
-0.4741181433,
0.4225273132,
-0.315043509,
-0.2995304763,
0.6526027322,
-0.1097385883,
0.1383121163,
0.2749997675,
0.5116753578,
0.0489018969,
0.9205668569,
0.7505229115,
-0.4647864699,
0.3367887735,
-0.1926650405,
0.4594056904,
-0.3438313007,
-0.1957211047,
-0.6301503778,
-0.3463674486,
-0.729354918,
-0.2575551271,
0.1467231065,
-0.3457517624,
-0.0340904333,
0.2140163779,
-0.1834687144,
0.3997356296,
0.4953941405,
-0.2775818408,
0.1103037447,
-0.0176579785,
0.0430941507,
0.3310210109,
-0.7654307485,
-0.7840598822,
1.3114109039,
0.7053235769,
1.0557368994,
0.1753152609,
0.7085232139,
0.3792598844,
0.619974494,
-0.7488452196,
0.754001081,
0.0930283293,
-0.7271107435,
-0.5962307453,
0.0353290848,
-1.2728356123,
0.342145592,
-0.2423850745,
-0.3466014862,
-0.0783846229,
0.0018567102,
-0.2789458036,
0.5374109745,
-0.5330171585,
0.9008598924,
-0.6335366964,
-0.1270706207,
-0.0185103063,
-0.9462210536,
0.2152600735,
-0.0394891202,
0.3954523504,
-0.0295792241,
-0.0274767671,
0.432439357,
-0.2780407667,
1.1229330301,
-0.1136792377,
-0.4022494853,
0.4845413864,
0.1066945493,
0.521682024,
-0.370344609,
-0.1010585651,
0.0974201187,
-0.0703964606,
-0.5334310532,
-0.6203744411,
0.6439786553,
-0.9548677802,
-0.6516797543,
-0.8259572983,
-0.4026605487,
-0.0791430548,
-0.0319874212,
-0.0378971919,
0.1144720316,
-0.7205126882,
-0.2823824286,
0.5402040482,
0.0630496815,
0.5124554038,
0.5111711025,
-0.0291175805,
-0.3919022083,
1.0742645264,
0.0120698586,
0.2857606411,
0.2622296512,
0.0411811285,
-0.1603640318,
-0.5755438805,
-0.1556582451,
0.0752094015,
-0.7627538443,
-0.0178736839,
-0.3050455749,
-0.1633839309,
-0.4832614362,
-0.2404547483,
-0.2343573123,
0.1461735368,
-0.0178005248,
-0.0622375682,
0.2453456819,
0.8127233386,
0.0485941544,
0.6409323812,
-0.4467936456,
0.3414628506,
0.4548551142,
0.1743161827,
0.012092608,
-0.1892784089,
-0.1869192421,
0.0533149987,
-0.4749499261,
-1.1018511057,
0.3859100342,
-0.2157434672,
0.891131103,
0.4884640276,
0.2899003029,
0.3057053685,
-0.4523842335,
0.7307209373,
0.064919129,
-0.6569868922,
0.3246878386,
-0.2377642542,
0.0010355395,
0.4007046819,
0.3491485715,
-0.3770697415,
-0.6572200656,
-1.0920606852,
-0.7901039124,
0.4107428193,
-0.047153756,
0.2681544125,
-0.1972697675,
0.1269407123,
-0.0703418255,
0.2597664297,
-0.7588002086,
-0.3996167183,
-0.1887025833,
-0.0941184759,
-0.1868159175,
0.0540255904,
-0.5068309307,
0.2464676946,
0.6235147715,
-0.1268478334,
0.0377836302,
-0.1652769297,
-0.1600427628,
-0.1833631098,
0.3482208848,
0.5192013383,
0.3213646412,
0.2166254669,
0.4824925661,
0.0751828551,
-0.499199301,
0.2530434132,
0.1220994666,
0.0816801861,
-0.3482398689,
0.4976463318,
0.6427049041,
-0.0037247846,
-0.7487633824,
0.5317531824,
-0.0301120616,
-0.2087054402,
-0.6017445326,
0.1122964844,
-0.1287470609,
0.3017341197,
0.0127537316,
0.0665420517,
-0.1923821568,
-0.9387165904,
0.0772962123,
0.7609840035,
-0.5742157102,
-0.2896401584,
0.4551265836,
0.3136944473,
-0.6757522821,
0.2780304551,
-0.2780942023,
-0.6584275961,
0.7332117558,
0.2580386996,
1.199737072,
-0.4221080244,
0.1097362116,
-0.3349153101,
0.9055369496,
-0.1173945814,
0.0864028558,
0.0516618229,
-0.7622721195,
0.1930443645,
-0.2512750328,
-0.457724154,
0.1273818761,
-0.5292803049,
0.0560782105,
-0.7500645518,
-0.3769308329,
-0.4284140468,
0.1208436266,
-0.3753926158,
0.0095560383,
0.4970826805,
0.7653059959,
-0.965521872,
0.7957955599,
0.7911320329,
-0.1724674851,
-0.5019160509,
0.4290352464,
0.0606457852,
-0.5926126838,
0.4225363135,
-0.2587380707,
-0.4264517725,
0.0002720718,
-0.4509074986,
-0.5933924913,
0.9244601727,
0.4368578196,
-0.0426187851,
0.1446606815,
0.2622568309,
0.8033980131,
-0.309330523,
0.0565751307,
0.8811460733,
0.6244151592,
-0.1531991065,
-0.5870975256,
0.1338579953,
-0.2940919101,
-0.1310905963,
0.3402068019,
-0.5084566474,
0.5318670869,
-0.2388922572,
-0.2431730479,
0.0984876752,
0.5396999717,
0.0331509076,
0.3899793923,
0.3711508214,
0.5499100685,
0.6122249961,
-0.3057680428,
1.151473403,
-0.5612882972,
-0.2264067531,
0.9359270334,
-0.6150909662,
0.9201089144,
0.5299348235,
-0.2175421864,
0.1089544594,
0.336573422,
0.1068011299,
0.188584432,
0.7894461751,
-0.1139360666,
-0.0512166433,
0.1193362102,
-0.3456087708,
0.3759476542,
0.6625452042,
-0.1477404088,
-0.2755376101,
0.0879907236,
0.4059622884,
0.5133650303,
-0.014450863,
0.8621528745,
0.0203518178,
-0.6954318285,
0.434500128,
-0.0942176357,
0.3344062865,
-0.8448017836,
0.063174285,
-0.0526839569,
0.1916749179,
0.1267098635,
-0.6753277183,
0.1564911455,
-0.1633235663,
0.1738766581,
-0.3470833898,
0.5090208054,
-0.4265108407,
-0.200791955,
0.6398639083,
0.3083751202,
0.2687477469,
-0.0651747286,
-0.6754114628,
0.2994615734,
-0.4275598824,
-0.3039445877,
0.611715734,
0.3647971749,
0.0083804484,
0.8135766983,
0.3469086885,
0.3136290908,
0.2456097752,
-0.1428211629,
0.729929328,
-0.5665121078,
-0.4453558326,
-0.9676622748,
0.3570235074,
-0.0620100573,
-0.0503753871,
0.7048006058,
0.060679689,
0.6019030809,
0.0364220664,
0.8128553033,
0.1421028525,
-0.0598694123,
-0.322365731,
1.1212863922,
-0.3160881996,
0.4023777544,
-0.1999465972,
-0.6468776464,
-0.4510878623,
0.3648239672,
-0.1128708869,
-0.1948001534,
0.748591125,
0.917925179,
0.5334533453,
-0.1818513721,
0.6092012525,
0.2887160778,
0.5092706084,
0.3093875349,
0.9432904124,
-0.6401461959,
0.9102731943,
-0.1546753794,
-0.1955796331,
-0.235312596,
-0.7156141996,
-1.1716502905,
-0.44368276,
-0.4668889642,
-0.4291671216,
0.2754450142,
0.6047789454,
0.3597936928,
-0.4717742801,
-0.5912696719,
0.1768361479,
0.4371479154,
-0.3690001965,
-0.1225137711,
0.2235546857,
-0.0781010464,
-0.6196097136,
0.38225317,
0.3018201888,
0.3015020192,
-0.7022443414,
-0.3195256889,
-0.130811289,
0.2280515134,
0.2390472442,
0.6304134727,
-1.0703784227,
-0.0715317652,
-0.2400960326,
-0.3830461204,
-0.303429842,
0.5588347316,
-0.6120064855,
0.4446404576,
0.3462645411,
0.7583879828,
-0.3923213482,
-0.1544636488,
0.6016778946,
-0.6450158954,
0.3096845746,
0.1698887646,
0.1728181392,
0.1189950258,
-0.4985614121,
0.3707862198,
-0.0627070367,
-0.2736110091,
-0.8526828289,
0.3408851326,
-0.8864170909,
-0.3094504774,
1.016997695,
0.120604977,
-0.4913323522,
-0.328948617,
-0.2834763229,
0.1160145923,
-0.2507652342,
0.8983798027,
0.7950537801,
0.3664517999,
0.3079375923,
-0.450448215,
0.642824471,
0.0993043929,
-0.7615043521,
0.1763965786,
0.0605642647,
-0.2240973264,
0.5434058905,
0.6606806517,
-0.1724365205,
0.2063809484,
0.4930461347,
0.1892872453,
0.0467463844,
-0.6828144789,
-0.5951414108,
0.4649985135,
0.3322345316,
-0.2194478661
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10193v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10193v2
|
BitDelta: Your Fine-Tune May Only Be Worth One Bit
| 2024-02-15T18:50:06 | 2024-02-28T03:42:10 |
James Liu, Guangxuan Xiao, Kai Li, Jason D. Lee, Song Han, Tri Dao, Tianle Cai
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are typically trained in two phases:
pre-training on large internet-scale datasets, and fine-tuning for downstream
tasks. Given the higher computational demand of pre-training, it's intuitive to
assume that fine-tuning adds less new information to the model, and is thus
more compressible. We explore this assumption by decomposing the weights of
fine-tuned models into their pre-trained components and an additional delta. We
introduce a simple method, BitDelta, which successfully quantizes this delta
down to 1 bit without compromising performance. This interesting finding not
only highlights the potential redundancy of information added during
fine-tuning, but also has significant implications for the multi-tenant serving
and multi-tenant storage of fine-tuned models. By enabling the use of a single
high-precision base model accompanied by multiple 1-bit deltas, BitDelta
dramatically reduces GPU memory requirements by more than 10x, which can also
be translated to enhanced generation latency in multi-tenant settings. We
validate BitDelta through experiments across Llama-2 and Mistral model
families, and on models up to 70B parameters, showcasing minimal performance
degradation over all tested settings.
|
[
-0.6140940785,
-0.8284575343,
0.3272159398,
0.1751895547,
-0.5431001782,
-0.1632089615,
-0.4015001953,
-0.4103454649,
0.1803043634,
0.6671373844,
-0.4812618792,
-0.1709429026,
-0.4316841364,
-0.2360737473,
-0.3332155943,
0.7143979073,
0.3500125408,
0.0155095952,
-0.019732967,
-0.0226261858,
-0.5210277438,
-0.3041496277,
-0.7341191769,
-0.3226759434,
0.4751607478,
0.4727247357,
0.8271948099,
0.8651673794,
0.5546078086,
0.2340779901,
-0.1240341142,
0.3338571191,
-0.744897306,
0.0719550923,
0.0743117034,
-0.6016511917,
-0.5585386157,
-0.2353818566,
0.634709537,
0.6998439431,
-0.1217835471,
0.4099538922,
0.0266477205,
0.9766824245,
-0.8754007816,
0.1432083547,
-0.7050023675,
-0.1752056926,
-0.0423496254,
-0.4291655123,
-0.2512448132,
-0.3159786761,
-0.1984250098,
-0.4571496248,
0.4474112988,
-0.0922817215,
0.9890881181,
0.6878459454,
-0.2335709333,
0.2576521039,
-0.8285160661,
0.4663774073,
-0.6892880797,
0.5327088833,
0.5887026787,
0.2021165341,
-0.007746825,
-0.4509209394,
-0.5213668346,
0.0435245596,
0.1809634119,
-0.384783864,
-0.2558011711,
0.2300219089,
0.112604104,
0.5529929996,
-0.2627105713,
0.1887297183,
-0.39506495,
-0.1444781274,
0.4468470812,
0.3358376622,
-0.2037946284,
0.1619371921,
-0.1015745625,
-0.1089944914,
-1.1709405184,
0.0331832916,
0.4483989179,
0.6921739578,
-0.0405148268,
0.4227418005,
-0.1891484112,
0.5447571278,
0.33953318,
0.1256653666,
-0.2223581374,
-0.5313354731,
-0.2570104003,
0.1547771543,
0.5614626408,
0.2675444782,
0.3644683361,
-0.2684905827,
-0.2248463333,
0.1318499595,
0.4438383579,
-1.4063037634,
-0.5220063329,
0.2356390655,
-0.3920467198,
-0.3040028512,
-0.2166862488,
-0.2033843547,
-0.4530306756,
-0.408525914,
0.518961072,
-0.2834725082,
-0.3212026358,
0.3783429861,
0.1498352438,
-0.0021669944,
0.3738060296,
-1.0850995779,
0.4279941022,
1.0812145472,
0.9252309203,
0.1137226149,
-0.2692196369,
-0.5033012033,
-0.2912096977,
-0.7837401628,
0.6297301054,
-0.4603257179,
-0.2304419726,
-0.193888694,
-0.133139804,
0.373773247,
-0.7534163594,
-0.0343612656,
-0.6904864311,
-0.5072216392,
-0.5279868245,
-0.5382468104,
-0.1973349154,
0.0358130522,
-1.0490820408,
0.8391147256,
0.3874343634,
-0.6550364494,
0.5148307085,
-0.3650437891,
-0.44409132,
0.1195615456,
-0.0479284599,
-0.4995218217,
0.7293611765,
0.0081623606,
0.6595199704,
-0.4554184377,
0.2270587087,
-0.4178331196,
-0.6867078543,
0.0602272004,
-0.4150547981,
0.5522267222,
0.3233050704,
-0.1294617802,
-0.1150316745,
-0.9335581064,
-0.0163221098,
-0.1931132227,
-0.7899242043,
-0.2606466711,
0.0065986444,
-0.0034440167,
0.0951981246,
0.4434286356,
-0.5561666489,
0.3608312905,
-0.2894006371,
0.4963927865,
0.7364590168,
-0.0791543424,
0.288513571,
-0.2922331989,
0.483268708,
0.214799881,
-0.0654022098,
-0.0368266776,
-0.0135269063,
-1.0290712118,
-0.4691583514,
0.541787982,
0.0502607636,
-0.6583474874,
0.3229763508,
-0.5372699499,
-0.4854910374,
-1.1685883999,
0.2695642114,
0.2057560682,
0.0140413158,
0.2222732753,
-0.2292674929,
-0.5710504651,
-0.9104326367,
0.1077153236,
0.0923796147,
0.1783819348,
0.1739251018,
0.3451086581,
-0.1152157485,
0.890684247,
-0.375957042,
0.0866598114,
-0.1607875377,
-0.0070840786,
0.0478184,
0.5175228715,
0.256649822,
-0.608346045,
-0.3739812374,
0.1435001642,
-0.2611649334,
0.0921784192,
-0.1290064156,
0.0370721593,
0.1678659022,
0.3517404497,
-0.5980504751,
0.2121046185,
0.7583053112,
-0.4300114214,
0.5915008783,
-0.4711059332,
0.1333680749,
-0.9859626889,
-0.0747241452,
-0.235972777,
-0.4897352159,
-0.4501115382,
0.2298654616,
0.1754283458,
-0.0069274395,
-0.18944408,
0.4076312482,
-0.2468622774,
0.0210395716,
-0.5689181089,
-0.4788017273,
-0.1561753154,
0.5463792086,
-0.1750839204,
1.3046900034,
0.4507758319,
-0.9995673299,
0.150754258,
0.0556232184,
-0.6543092132,
0.26063627,
-0.6406192183,
0.1670897007,
-0.0784200653,
-0.1833524555,
-0.8683496714,
-0.0064489311,
-0.372846067,
-0.2167417109,
0.4017242789,
-0.3163320422,
-0.9144641757,
0.0643946826,
-0.3648561835,
0.4905236661,
0.2880436182,
-0.6559267044,
0.3588374555,
0.3354840577,
-0.2259783745,
-0.3331722915,
-0.6135451794,
-0.063532263,
-0.0828948915,
-0.4010407925,
0.1465713978,
-0.0505632311,
0.0352741592,
0.0713738874,
-0.1712720394,
-0.3171759248,
0.5108651519,
0.4060897529,
0.1443900764,
-0.3536079526,
0.3403701484,
0.1255151182,
-0.2585645914,
-0.1136498898,
-0.4236892164,
0.8419690728,
-0.3895516694,
-0.1475208998,
-0.2589942515,
0.2700408101,
0.5432422757,
-0.2276113331,
0.8851257563,
0.613085568,
-0.3738597333,
-0.0356020331,
-0.5354186296,
-0.211245209,
-0.5167676806,
0.5007140636,
-0.5255349278,
-1.0456261635,
0.4887431562,
-0.1162020862,
0.167858392,
0.2845054567,
0.6422898769,
-0.1431144476,
0.8029757738,
1.0979113579,
-0.1929081827,
0.6873817444,
-0.327685833,
0.2382933348,
-0.6583117843,
0.0979684293,
-0.5687202811,
-0.3124110997,
-0.9417048693,
-0.3294970393,
0.2491696179,
0.2983282208,
-0.6249678731,
0.4643829763,
-0.3510032892,
0.7835555673,
0.5495811701,
0.3455691636,
0.363941282,
0.0838078037,
0.3106350899,
0.1460503191,
-0.7664801478,
-0.3828119338,
1.1292799711,
0.3606424928,
0.8949177861,
0.2072177976,
0.5562081933,
0.1282486171,
-0.062151935,
-0.8103998303,
0.4423688352,
-0.3564871848,
-0.7646507025,
-0.4154056609,
-0.6340448856,
-0.9274587035,
0.319791168,
-0.3373974562,
-0.6093094349,
0.1928874105,
0.4358658791,
-0.6982194781,
0.440777421,
-0.5813378096,
0.706600368,
0.0945594087,
-0.4481575489,
-0.6456066966,
-0.3783734441,
0.1797574311,
-0.3578486443,
-0.1428890228,
-0.2131147534,
0.0577371009,
0.5416411757,
-0.6334812641,
0.8178763986,
-0.1241218224,
-0.2098181844,
0.0786720738,
0.5290207267,
0.5434122086,
-0.1812762916,
0.086525701,
0.2876520455,
0.372933656,
-0.5752235651,
-0.4264292121,
0.684048593,
-0.8383834362,
-0.2194088399,
0.2545669079,
-0.4863909781,
-0.1145906746,
0.1893055737,
0.3370597363,
0.5012803674,
0.1084145308,
0.3787889481,
0.8580898643,
0.0838094652,
0.2123072147,
0.3916364014,
0.00411051,
-0.2482503951,
1.0201597214,
0.1706201136,
0.3048270941,
0.4922904968,
0.2983954847,
-0.0979191959,
-0.6156851053,
-0.1068320349,
0.143757537,
-0.5843207836,
-0.2488048822,
-0.428501457,
0.0487829298,
-0.2359569073,
-0.0904383957,
-1.0386008024,
-0.5832882524,
-0.2246771753,
-0.0925526246,
0.3833962083,
0.6273609996,
-0.1893715262,
0.7490387559,
-0.7428731918,
0.1653384268,
0.2984159887,
0.7179910541,
0.1457857043,
-0.5013369918,
-0.7390018106,
-0.0033815079,
-0.1052093804,
-0.2974995077,
0.2187382579,
0.1345955729,
-0.0170633607,
0.5752832294,
-0.1862080246,
0.9805060625,
-0.5687844753,
0.5906939507,
0.0492269658,
-0.8751391172,
0.1813770533,
-0.0955018848,
0.340736568,
0.9630857706,
0.1423886567,
-0.2709061801,
-0.0606983006,
-0.5898305774,
-0.8265288472,
0.4650105834,
-0.1688462198,
0.3575439453,
0.1780237854,
0.3494296372,
0.3243992925,
0.5150743127,
-0.4599731266,
-0.4210481048,
-0.0028420009,
-0.036545191,
-0.2616368234,
-0.5235554576,
0.0701642483,
-0.4143698812,
0.76523453,
-0.0580795184,
0.3395060897,
-0.3581420481,
-0.1407322586,
-0.2448145002,
0.2092531025,
0.5830105543,
0.5812559128,
-0.40089342,
0.3441092372,
0.0062288246,
-0.5057892799,
0.1574735194,
-0.0866933465,
-0.0425732993,
-0.0056653847,
0.4161255062,
1.0698724985,
0.280821234,
-0.3186934888,
0.3689656854,
0.013774056,
-0.056319382,
0.168887794,
0.1161270067,
0.1420300603,
0.3546987176,
-0.0405913219,
-0.0774139762,
0.0332295187,
-0.3701371551,
0.0985301733,
0.445071429,
-0.1981123388,
-0.4530262947,
0.386739105,
0.1146317348,
-0.0939112231,
0.649963975,
-0.1798401028,
-0.3368051052,
0.3361420035,
0.3388929069,
0.9606456161,
0.0636668578,
-0.1663163155,
0.2517006397,
0.4188020229,
-0.127244547,
0.3467439413,
-0.3195277154,
-0.7049795389,
-0.6085292697,
-0.7577848434,
-0.2027985007,
0.184070006,
-0.6128297448,
0.0512464195,
-0.5384793878,
-0.317514658,
0.1263694912,
0.4126231968,
-0.9123873115,
-0.0584210195,
0.1458327621,
1.052033782,
-0.8344505429,
0.8408813477,
0.4927495122,
-0.2392451018,
-0.9274881482,
-0.269500792,
-0.4753521681,
-0.7352183461,
0.5186706185,
-0.0229653772,
-0.2832548022,
0.1016873196,
-0.689691484,
-0.6849247217,
0.675916791,
0.6574454904,
-0.8901000619,
-0.0430688411,
0.1379627436,
0.2913101912,
-0.030266773,
0.0034852719,
0.8337621689,
0.3684067726,
-0.0641652644,
-0.9296200871,
0.0238090362,
0.0411553681,
0.0534720346,
0.5755042434,
-0.5763756037,
1.2082566023,
-0.3615014851,
-0.3361999393,
-0.1356766373,
0.4064901769,
-0.1277030706,
-0.1997936964,
0.4184251726,
0.6037264466,
0.8821210265,
-0.0401355438,
1.0208927393,
-0.5625507236,
0.5543717742,
1.2022287846,
0.1587596685,
0.9475372434,
0.6091734171,
-0.2322467715,
0.0144729512,
0.7372191548,
0.2190598994,
0.8114753366,
0.1427270472,
-0.2797811329,
-0.7273522019,
0.0159997027,
-0.1733368635,
0.4157500267,
0.1592503339,
0.0257842541,
-0.305672437,
-0.18034935,
0.047907602,
-0.2549243271,
-0.4962665439,
0.8954232335,
0.0570179038,
-0.3743313253,
0.9324017763,
-0.0616875775,
0.5903585553,
-0.5088288188,
0.0149002532,
-0.3429249525,
0.3158158958,
-0.1840473115,
-0.4468465447,
-0.0210371651,
-0.0508783422,
-0.3116886318,
0.0912344679,
0.3862487674,
-0.5628268719,
-0.4801513255,
-0.2084914446,
0.3566944301,
0.1970586032,
-0.4961876869,
-0.2237965912,
0.1566271037,
-0.0986798629,
-0.2190402001,
0.2527167499,
0.6281375885,
0.1223172769,
0.8848859072,
0.6602605581,
0.543535769,
0.1009428948,
-0.0898643658,
1.0062010288,
-0.7506188154,
-0.626093626,
-1.0326957703,
0.1804541349,
0.3890545666,
-0.2572644353,
0.320540458,
0.7429166436,
0.8557456136,
0.0239486508,
0.7012295127,
0.3113555014,
0.08873225,
-0.7410632968,
0.7126363516,
-0.5882590413,
0.2426322699,
0.1267052442,
-0.7183738351,
0.0060878536,
0.6127291918,
0.0518017188,
-0.0866455436,
0.4756503105,
0.8722443581,
-0.1320786923,
-0.03799868,
0.5753284097,
0.1246880442,
0.3273762167,
0.5918971896,
0.701726675,
-0.4034574032,
0.2191117853,
-0.4307565093,
0.073531352,
-0.4073038399,
-0.8574098945,
-0.7834857702,
-0.5372357368,
-0.3505798876,
-0.2594452202,
0.0395372584,
1.110278964,
1.0592997074,
-0.7747986317,
-0.0769082308,
-0.0163024068,
-0.0990176648,
-0.2234489918,
-0.0874460414,
0.3384346068,
-0.3544760942,
-0.4186377525,
0.1926289499,
0.1502534896,
0.2614928186,
-0.4262585342,
-0.0150848627,
0.2199452966,
0.2288274616,
0.5994660854,
0.0062712715,
-0.4503242373,
-0.2392253429,
-0.3676534295,
-0.2840458751,
0.1835754216,
0.8972284794,
-0.7421292067,
0.4754940569,
0.3078921437,
1.0372563601,
0.8443741798,
-0.0026177173,
0.3742887378,
-0.8148030043,
0.1419484466,
0.0523280688,
0.2948016822,
0.1897155046,
-0.4811915159,
0.3071807027,
-0.2754265964,
-0.3645540774,
-0.7800694704,
0.1275518537,
-0.9039433599,
-0.4415801466,
0.9655827284,
0.0671771243,
-0.1092130989,
0.2225738019,
-0.0381797887,
0.1962077171,
-0.3986025155,
0.8119935989,
0.8398849964,
0.1727500558,
-0.1414189041,
-0.754306376,
0.527485013,
0.3598255515,
-0.6710066199,
0.5796743035,
0.4801059365,
0.446526736,
-0.045209188,
0.7284280658,
0.1738931239,
0.277397275,
0.3034001589,
0.1511196196,
-0.5193821192,
-0.6726247072,
-0.6945239305,
0.0736291856,
0.4426533878,
-0.4840157032
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10189v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10189v2
|
Uncertainty Quantification for In-Context Learning of Large Language Models
| 2024-02-15T18:46:24 | 2024-03-28T19:41:34 |
Chen Ling, Xujiang Zhao, Xuchao Zhang, Wei Cheng, Yanchi Liu, Yiyou Sun, Mika Oishi, Takao Osaki, Katsushi Matsuda, Jie Ji, Guangji Bai, Liang Zhao, Haifeng Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In-context learning has emerged as a groundbreaking ability of Large Language
Models (LLMs) and revolutionized various fields by providing a few
task-relevant demonstrations in the prompt. However, trustworthy issues with
LLM's response, such as hallucination, have also been actively discussed.
Existing works have been devoted to quantifying the uncertainty in LLM's
response, but they often overlook the complex nature of LLMs and the uniqueness
of in-context learning. In this work, we delve into the predictive uncertainty
of LLMs associated with in-context learning, highlighting that such
uncertainties may stem from both the provided demonstrations (aleatoric
uncertainty) and ambiguities tied to the model's configurations (epistemic
uncertainty). We propose a novel formulation and corresponding estimation
method to quantify both types of uncertainties. The proposed method offers an
unsupervised way to understand the prediction of in-context learning in a
plug-and-play fashion. Extensive experiments are conducted to demonstrate the
effectiveness of the decomposition. The code and data are available at:
https://github.com/lingchen0331/UQ_ICL.
|
[
-0.3063259423,
-1.2042394876,
0.8342506289,
0.1142279133,
-0.1144754812,
0.1757539362,
-0.493683219,
-0.2089853585,
-0.0423068777,
0.1575125605,
-0.4772761762,
-0.3621981442,
-0.5131636262,
-0.2152796984,
-0.3420898318,
0.4679102302,
-0.2077460438,
0.0695315897,
-0.4826939106,
0.0086887665,
-0.2710479498,
-0.5157914758,
-0.2041641176,
-0.4226685464,
0.1146230623,
0.3872179687,
0.3818069696,
0.1893216074,
0.0593065172,
0.2287541479,
-0.3076873422,
0.0559147969,
-0.1966410726,
0.3155327439,
0.0223363563,
-0.4577323496,
-0.0674014762,
-0.3072929084,
0.7620609999,
1.0496098995,
-0.2052122205,
0.0916476399,
0.2541179359,
0.2855353355,
-0.7828333974,
0.1288684905,
-0.7826939225,
0.2156940997,
0.1460952163,
-0.0556587763,
-0.5107191801,
-0.026594324,
0.3562936783,
-0.632190764,
-0.1298044175,
0.1533768028,
0.5591145754,
0.5689031482,
-0.4825871587,
-0.2428668439,
-0.9102030993,
0.8836288452,
-0.567528367,
0.5473715663,
0.4969530404,
0.3830448389,
-0.3649613857,
-0.6901406646,
-0.5606297851,
0.0211133845,
-0.0197648592,
0.0797148347,
-0.0633168891,
-0.1702350974,
0.0783344507,
0.2990732491,
-0.3767579794,
0.2633278668,
0.0050055841,
-0.3211345077,
0.1916565597,
-0.0061769951,
0.0377924927,
0.0067563504,
-0.6838424802,
0.1069160849,
-0.7266483307,
0.0873755813,
0.231296584,
0.1405093372,
-0.2939359844,
0.4422709048,
-0.0999418423,
0.5334994197,
-0.0062256223,
-0.0809524059,
0.2553894818,
0.1224420592,
-0.4575340152,
0.0173485447,
0.701862812,
-0.1231522262,
-0.0274960957,
-0.2871293724,
-0.4295941591,
-0.1149926186,
0.0634500533,
-0.6183817983,
0.0021990086,
0.497272253,
-0.0414240323,
-0.1938746125,
0.1546414346,
-0.6273824573,
-0.3745504916,
-0.2700703144,
0.7205508351,
-0.3743164241,
-0.1493583769,
0.1169442832,
0.3033575416,
-0.0051706596,
0.459297359,
-0.526700139,
0.1703230888,
0.5807685852,
0.5929654241,
-0.1775598526,
-0.4420537353,
-0.5517353415,
0.211671412,
-0.2941266,
0.5469534397,
-0.423646003,
-0.2197585553,
0.2539820373,
-0.1032666788,
-0.0544207022,
-0.443886131,
0.2095486671,
-0.5783917308,
0.0889579207,
-0.0910297707,
-0.9811103344,
-0.2120078951,
0.2276145667,
-0.5950911641,
0.8629042506,
0.209789589,
-0.8218078613,
0.3252035081,
-0.2625384629,
-0.1804857552,
0.131566003,
-0.4519716203,
-0.5214110613,
0.4623244107,
0.1442217082,
0.6061323285,
-0.1250507385,
0.5039272308,
-0.3354319036,
-0.564019084,
0.9255976677,
-0.5896294713,
0.7158131599,
0.1285416037,
-0.3661488891,
-0.0195968561,
-0.6077789664,
0.0119429184,
-0.1123937666,
-0.2400734872,
-0.2625365257,
0.0045027947,
-0.0928997621,
0.1492280066,
0.2279748321,
-0.3487341106,
-0.089797847,
-0.4908294082,
0.3156127334,
0.7367462516,
0.2787576616,
0.5257766843,
-0.0002858068,
0.5289731622,
0.1357791424,
0.1107804105,
-0.1722860634,
-0.3635672629,
-0.4395232499,
-0.1649035811,
0.2687640488,
0.2495746613,
-0.6368997693,
0.4181475937,
-0.094913885,
-0.2449532896,
-0.1206466109,
-0.0884110406,
0.5174819231,
0.358818233,
0.2444415689,
-0.0128935631,
-0.2726386487,
-0.513130188,
-0.2172695398,
-0.3785291016,
-0.354914993,
0.1639758945,
0.6185979843,
-0.3303976059,
0.8313471079,
-0.266955018,
-0.0850916952,
0.0165342167,
0.2258735895,
-0.1914778054,
0.3912613392,
0.1083089635,
-0.7864177823,
-0.4488693774,
0.0923431069,
-0.6006991267,
0.1605880558,
-0.2442519814,
0.1203222573,
0.3281380832,
0.6489157081,
-0.5091214776,
0.5685374737,
0.5413283706,
-0.1303406954,
0.5581552982,
-0.2673405111,
-0.0731885657,
-1.067065835,
-0.1891735196,
-0.0292572249,
-0.056795828,
-0.4911487997,
0.2294443995,
0.3252931535,
0.3283798397,
-0.4908422828,
0.5380607843,
-0.3824637234,
-0.3480849564,
0.0097087659,
0.0669603273,
-0.1289214492,
0.500629425,
0.1513159722,
0.6820247173,
0.7222161889,
-0.541369915,
-0.039313402,
0.1191817075,
-0.678082943,
0.3676611185,
-0.5280913115,
-0.0085973982,
0.1094695777,
0.2920112908,
-0.9153066874,
-0.656349659,
0.178155601,
-0.5825743675,
0.2952826321,
-0.0248824619,
-0.5634811521,
0.1327958405,
-0.0445299856,
0.5388419628,
0.274325192,
-0.6659066081,
0.5992631912,
0.4122589827,
0.1562138051,
-0.7331342101,
-0.541465342,
-0.235760659,
-0.4349354804,
-0.1211453155,
0.3857043684,
-0.2288637012,
-0.5773206949,
-0.2992913723,
-0.322276026,
-0.179627046,
0.4438363016,
0.4728236794,
0.049729161,
0.0654844344,
0.3070735037,
0.3025021851,
0.0798831061,
0.3356640041,
-0.2707139552,
0.4918103516,
-0.372083813,
-0.8624382615,
-0.1617976576,
0.1343892366,
0.5301222801,
-0.0466115661,
0.6877048016,
0.648573339,
-0.6934531331,
-0.5885716677,
-0.3353348076,
-0.2295302153,
-0.4568864703,
0.3623699248,
-0.1785609871,
-0.9180404544,
0.8417658806,
-0.1769755334,
-0.2251451015,
0.0787419155,
0.7125718594,
-0.1588874757,
0.740563035,
0.5234926939,
0.2255652994,
0.2914324105,
-0.1572198719,
0.2174726874,
-0.8071869016,
-0.6118389964,
-0.3835181296,
0.0105613573,
-0.3588959873,
-0.5103659034,
0.5486050248,
0.0478227101,
-0.3736512661,
-0.093705073,
0.0291987918,
0.4417522848,
0.3433444798,
0.073734723,
0.3337367773,
0.1318963915,
-0.2721538544,
0.1160525978,
-0.3845719397,
-0.4376323521,
1.0606757402,
0.444983691,
0.7631870508,
0.3560094237,
0.5824219584,
0.0161076263,
-0.0030576983,
-0.9756670594,
0.2490949035,
0.4472349286,
-0.5001906157,
-0.5563906431,
-0.4686260223,
-0.706474781,
0.2981991172,
-0.1327267587,
-1.1228183508,
0.1682021022,
0.0115170861,
-0.573235631,
0.2741723359,
-0.4484543502,
0.6669303179,
-0.067192778,
-0.3307203054,
0.0067372615,
-0.893144846,
0.1598819792,
-0.5285041332,
0.3655998111,
0.2580306232,
-0.0808023363,
0.3755483031,
-0.2517562211,
1.0102615356,
0.0495997258,
-0.3129198849,
0.2191417813,
0.3745319545,
0.6420614123,
0.3604390621,
0.0873627365,
0.0370942652,
-0.0368151478,
-0.2038189769,
-0.6403359175,
0.6267219782,
-0.7269411683,
-0.3295229673,
-0.3059577346,
-0.6198729277,
-0.5007997155,
-0.2127753943,
0.6170206666,
0.4705891311,
-0.2582348883,
0.1386998892,
1.118952632,
-0.3825821579,
0.5468684435,
0.3338873982,
-0.3952135444,
-0.1118822098,
0.737490356,
0.1308564246,
0.4689601064,
0.550026238,
0.2057661116,
-0.3489810824,
-0.5998932719,
-0.2889701724,
0.05115778,
-0.8968099356,
-0.014287808,
-0.4592736363,
-0.0582013763,
-0.1233273819,
-0.2556070089,
-0.3787670434,
-0.4040438533,
-0.5280720592,
-0.2540813088,
0.0821589604,
0.8600217104,
0.1823934764,
0.460893482,
-0.3373419344,
-0.2729451954,
0.3607716858,
0.3669449985,
-0.0673391148,
-0.890715301,
-0.543605268,
0.1205342039,
-0.0951640904,
-0.8147678971,
0.5199166536,
0.2307218164,
0.6646708846,
0.6008704305,
0.3240742981,
0.5903548002,
-0.2493615299,
0.9073680639,
-0.0464231633,
-1.1395664215,
0.320145309,
-0.1998396963,
0.0719573051,
0.3936590552,
0.4199533165,
-0.188817665,
-0.570443809,
-0.7457880974,
-0.904951036,
0.3928826749,
0.0262110382,
0.0309947301,
0.1492875218,
0.3000017107,
0.2270006835,
0.319955349,
-0.6207880974,
-0.2103864849,
0.054306183,
0.0347338505,
-0.1326741725,
-0.272462815,
-0.1319258809,
-0.3452203572,
0.4971788228,
-0.2460543513,
0.3092705011,
-0.2101295441,
-0.5210373998,
-0.3252736628,
0.1840452701,
0.5961101651,
0.8658391237,
-0.3644558191,
0.364254415,
0.2975046635,
-0.2766159177,
0.0863031819,
-0.2484503835,
-0.0626185164,
0.0500945114,
0.5096732378,
0.78557235,
0.4579621255,
-0.8194733262,
0.688117981,
-0.0797912702,
0.005166884,
-0.9455644488,
-0.3694308996,
-0.0995653197,
0.3737845719,
0.4054633975,
0.1417632103,
0.2163196504,
-0.4035228491,
0.3524700105,
0.3445257545,
-0.5838805437,
-0.5279533267,
0.6101379395,
-0.2220501006,
-0.2192348093,
0.2487026453,
-0.3366627693,
-0.5165570378,
0.6010196805,
0.6884616017,
0.8809093237,
-0.2909313738,
0.2885257006,
0.1709988564,
0.1400088072,
-0.1179152876,
0.0231557637,
0.0006465185,
-0.8040004373,
-0.4360693693,
-0.6719146371,
-0.6636331677,
0.171295166,
-0.9410084486,
0.0362860672,
-0.1920728087,
0.0285624396,
-0.3934161067,
-0.1052445993,
-0.5331271887,
0.0683843717,
0.258158356,
0.6271793842,
-1.1228328943,
0.9205908179,
0.8025434017,
-0.2002902329,
-0.9463566542,
0.6213033199,
0.1161893755,
-0.4538856447,
0.4321087897,
0.1310994476,
-0.1937111914,
-0.1605882347,
-0.5418121219,
-0.7948992252,
1.0872405767,
0.5511689782,
-0.2297225296,
0.155063495,
0.0882882178,
0.3292761147,
-0.4582586884,
0.2838881314,
0.4437196553,
0.244086355,
0.2103289515,
-0.6703764796,
-0.0126431929,
0.1759981513,
0.111955002,
-0.0651042089,
-0.3733897507,
1.0653978586,
-0.1572742909,
-0.3182754815,
-0.0646872222,
0.7232391834,
0.2880700231,
0.2920799255,
0.3363364041,
0.3485764563,
1.0303328037,
-0.0089826584,
0.922591567,
-0.249290958,
0.56758672,
1.1690987349,
-0.1164713129,
0.9640013576,
0.8542734981,
-0.2898946106,
0.4444337189,
0.957144618,
0.558214426,
0.4318956435,
0.1864369363,
-0.5017177463,
-0.3879555464,
0.0383848771,
-0.22086218,
0.4460963011,
0.8163688183,
-0.224692896,
0.0867122263,
0.0781989172,
-0.0239623059,
0.0848858729,
-0.0149816442,
0.6290783882,
0.061575871,
-0.6265991926,
0.5175125599,
-0.1463416815,
0.475407213,
-0.2774364054,
0.0323839113,
-0.206044063,
0.1090896428,
-0.0215200931,
-0.6983540654,
0.1312208623,
-0.3817004263,
0.1298539937,
0.0509706028,
0.1843537837,
-0.5663087964,
-0.4710761905,
0.4139687121,
0.672241509,
0.2374988794,
-0.3006970584,
-0.2972866893,
0.2104205936,
-0.0460144728,
-0.4422313273,
0.6226544976,
0.8155996799,
-0.0044483477,
0.8490419984,
0.0169009753,
-0.1543712169,
0.078058295,
-0.0283370502,
0.7331568599,
0.0595883541,
-0.2147290409,
-0.8768760562,
0.5478805304,
0.2819398642,
-0.3749133646,
0.7886679769,
0.3634258211,
1.1912754774,
-0.2465959787,
0.7557632327,
0.1828475296,
0.2746356428,
-0.6117880344,
0.6732947826,
-0.6554117799,
0.6880770326,
-0.3570774198,
-0.8424021006,
-0.4230032861,
0.766187489,
-0.0768853724,
-0.2097401023,
0.8270827532,
0.8152165413,
-0.0651248023,
0.0343913436,
0.5694755316,
0.0980692282,
-0.0531063378,
0.4205182195,
1.0459136963,
-0.2396259457,
0.1211966872,
-0.4702475965,
-0.2072864473,
-0.3047317863,
-0.809864819,
-0.7035135627,
-1.0304329395,
-0.3590146899,
-0.3121587932,
-0.3107554615,
1.1996055841,
0.3687422276,
-0.8702144623,
-0.4082139134,
-0.0440958701,
0.2245314121,
-0.3667083383,
-0.0973182172,
0.482983768,
-0.3535761833,
-0.7455806136,
0.3798532188,
-0.0447787344,
0.1420834213,
-0.5179165006,
-0.3390603364,
-0.0001321752,
0.2149784863,
0.5364770293,
0.1053313166,
-1.0378717184,
-0.4294677079,
-0.0058188788,
0.1637521535,
-0.1217587069,
0.4780115783,
-0.7644587755,
0.5187185407,
0.1690350771,
0.6737815738,
0.4914315641,
-0.1495788395,
0.5320248604,
-1.1200164557,
0.0838112235,
0.1517853141,
0.6043646336,
0.2188216597,
-0.4088025391,
0.3447449803,
0.0921498835,
-0.5930632949,
-1.1331880093,
0.4436880648,
-0.7831889987,
-0.4788089991,
1.2954279184,
-0.4385160208,
-0.2236163169,
-0.2265589684,
0.3414818048,
0.2739037275,
-0.1985202432,
0.8924777508,
0.5891684294,
0.1947791129,
0.0495659448,
-0.6855951548,
0.3058951497,
0.2752754986,
-0.5993905067,
0.1513457894,
0.6095166206,
0.0977554396,
0.0763989836,
0.0206624474,
0.0795226023,
0.0331012756,
-0.0465166606,
0.0590761527,
0.0850885436,
-0.7028643489,
-0.5841556787,
0.2441300154,
0.1720546335,
-0.003750009
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10184v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10184v5
|
Reward Generalization in RLHF: A Topological Perspective
| 2024-02-15T18:39:24 | 2024-06-16T21:25:50 |
Tianyi Qiu, Fanzhi Zeng, Jiaming Ji, Dong Yan, Kaile Wang, Jiayi Zhou, Yang Han, Josef Dai, Xuehai Pan, Yaodong Yang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.DM
|
Existing alignment methods share a common topology of information flow, where
reward information is collected from humans, modeled with preference learning,
and used to tune language models. However, this shared topology has not been
systematically characterized, nor have its alternatives been thoroughly
explored, leaving the problems of low data efficiency and unreliable
generalization unaddressed. As a solution, we introduce a theoretical framework
for investigating reward generalization in reinforcement learning from human
feedback (RLHF), focusing on the topology of information flow at both macro and
micro levels. At the macro level, we portray the RLHF information flow as an
autoencoding process over behavior distributions, formalizing the RLHF
objective of distributional consistency between human preference and model
behavior. At the micro level, we present induced Bayesian networks as a theory
of reward generalization in RLHF, introducing fine-grained dataset topologies
into generalization bounds. Combining analysis on both levels, we propose
reward modeling from tree-structured preference information. It is shown to
reduce reward uncertainty by up to $\Theta(\log n/\log\log n)$ times compared
to baselines, where $n$ is the dataset size. Validation on three NLP tasks
shows that our tree-based reward model achieves an average win rate of 65%
against baseline methods, thus improving reward generalization for free via
topology design.
|
[
-0.1231961474,
-0.6981979012,
0.2846972942,
-0.1463549286,
-0.082776159,
-0.2297111154,
-0.2026538849,
-0.2462946177,
0.5337337852,
0.3985758126,
-0.7170464396,
-0.4329823852,
-0.7059566975,
-0.2476196736,
-0.0027026525,
1.180782795,
0.1667268127,
-0.2854952216,
-0.1027189046,
-0.1548319459,
-0.2036679536,
-0.6990562677,
-0.8228963614,
-0.5772829652,
1.2110131979,
0.4736460447,
0.7483554482,
1.0069416761,
0.7360680699,
0.2539568543,
0.1199411526,
-0.1047566384,
-0.6100525856,
0.160128966,
-0.386295706,
-0.4176293314,
-0.4438510835,
0.0865646973,
0.6584140658,
0.7343296409,
-0.8742833734,
-0.0018715858,
0.2349536419,
1.1050527096,
-0.6690613627,
0.4500186443,
-0.2647078335,
0.2373249233,
-0.0665713027,
-0.3998599052,
-0.1973025203,
-0.6178202033,
0.2054305524,
-0.771487236,
0.1248257235,
0.1455950141,
0.739461422,
0.4243912399,
-0.3286909461,
-0.2302173078,
-0.7205141783,
0.5281306505,
-0.544827342,
0.1539953202,
0.4409542978,
0.4415720105,
-0.1611795574,
-0.3542295396,
-0.1389960349,
-0.1026878655,
-0.3131870627,
0.029329842,
-0.0297758393,
0.4496816099,
0.1282863319,
0.4492398202,
-0.5482360721,
0.1328186244,
-0.0964365378,
0.2221909314,
0.7530627251,
0.2662055492,
0.1749307066,
-0.1172861084,
-0.2499342412,
-0.7381410003,
-0.6329858899,
0.5908113122,
0.5057035089,
0.4963690639,
-0.1751651764,
0.5550382733,
-0.3754387498,
0.864792347,
0.117589131,
0.0160705093,
-0.1105130836,
-0.1442638189,
-0.1858810186,
-0.1763127297,
0.717564106,
0.3508821428,
0.4668273032,
-0.2787206769,
-0.2410930544,
-0.0259725135,
0.508138001,
-0.6732788682,
-0.3351244032,
0.1077898592,
-0.678707242,
-0.6321517825,
0.2789290249,
-0.634655416,
-0.5424247384,
-0.2441187799,
0.2613070011,
-0.1330956519,
-0.5283460617,
0.1271152496,
-0.2387000024,
0.4420285523,
0.2239366621,
-1.3420828581,
0.4360124469,
0.7694678903,
0.5467492342,
-0.3640270531,
-0.3626610637,
-0.6852881908,
0.2834974825,
-0.3697217405,
0.6664475799,
-0.5060563087,
-0.2961290479,
0.0631225631,
0.0725394785,
-0.2478920966,
-0.6809666753,
0.3319290876,
-0.5993198156,
0.042467948,
-0.1153116003,
-0.683744967,
-0.1252347827,
0.212982282,
-0.7323042154,
0.6453099847,
0.1856535375,
-0.9427772164,
0.535525918,
-0.7888326049,
-0.2769260108,
-0.0887102708,
-0.2341601998,
-0.3614426553,
0.1250129044,
-0.0737887472,
0.3424102962,
-0.0689352378,
0.6991901994,
-0.4496773779,
-0.3676200807,
0.0748545229,
-0.0230484419,
0.4281710088,
0.0497675054,
-0.5136354566,
0.4644393623,
-0.2963555455,
-0.1564471126,
0.0891626775,
-0.4726900458,
-0.3823575377,
0.2226213366,
-0.2941134572,
0.0194587093,
-0.1202432886,
-0.4573785365,
0.6569207311,
-0.3579966724,
0.1223677844,
0.9910219312,
-0.0017606969,
0.6044697165,
-0.510266006,
0.6127285957,
0.0510987677,
0.1563197672,
0.4441307783,
-0.3884804547,
-0.5015605688,
0.0328896679,
0.4932387769,
0.5495536327,
-0.4272244573,
0.4111098647,
-0.2353374213,
-0.1578871757,
-0.2875732481,
-0.2752765417,
0.3736872971,
0.360840708,
0.2770844102,
-0.3637055457,
-0.1518535465,
-1.0353537798,
-0.2598395348,
-0.3571672738,
-0.0418667421,
0.6826588511,
0.2159918845,
-0.0652201101,
0.8672989607,
-0.4610739052,
-0.2439290434,
-0.1937250048,
0.3454566002,
0.5475683212,
0.8484566808,
0.2048960477,
-0.6560347676,
-0.1296205521,
0.0294664688,
-0.6132173538,
0.2386614382,
0.0837927312,
-0.0776296109,
0.1511131227,
0.245411694,
-0.2615816891,
0.641718626,
0.4723941386,
-0.5960057974,
0.3744979501,
-0.2152138352,
0.1808045506,
-0.5930894613,
0.1598362029,
-0.1975763142,
-0.2683801949,
-0.3483676612,
0.0466150269,
-0.1570588499,
0.0919917077,
0.1130039394,
0.5366075039,
-0.0976695344,
-0.3190995455,
-0.2798924744,
-0.2401709408,
-0.4114860892,
0.9390883446,
0.4377877712,
0.2680110931,
0.3467152119,
-0.7809638977,
0.5286642313,
-0.1174170673,
-0.1741191745,
0.5990198851,
-0.9582519531,
-0.1928844452,
-0.218715176,
0.4963277876,
-0.8115437627,
-0.4070310593,
0.5036126375,
-0.5876687169,
0.3763883114,
-0.2615011334,
-0.2894889414,
0.0044231941,
-0.2146328539,
0.6262777448,
0.3240988255,
-0.5396803617,
0.2493767887,
0.4064913392,
-0.0482135192,
-0.6972040534,
-0.4388813972,
-0.3243760765,
-0.3757672906,
-0.4029816985,
0.3371619582,
-0.04678436,
-0.0732305795,
0.055591289,
0.0719531104,
0.0315179713,
0.2522156239,
0.3724479675,
0.0693536103,
0.0272967964,
0.3769897223,
-0.1382897496,
-0.2523998618,
0.1471126527,
-0.6497095823,
0.2412147969,
-0.1344159544,
-0.3555009663,
-0.3706016839,
0.4231655598,
-0.0286729801,
0.0841552466,
0.7302313447,
0.5564824939,
-0.2039400339,
-0.0622512549,
-0.2361429036,
-0.6410337687,
-0.3631442189,
0.1117385924,
-0.2597128451,
-1.1513018608,
0.1848601103,
0.0417667702,
0.132159844,
0.4388951361,
0.3604221642,
-0.1829778105,
0.9945905209,
0.8762993217,
-0.1656032503,
0.5633285642,
-0.3789119422,
-0.0697868019,
-0.5537579656,
-0.2285504788,
-0.3506663144,
-0.7157906294,
-0.8717281818,
-0.1781311333,
0.3391089737,
0.3448849916,
-0.3953432739,
0.0954948217,
-0.5695934296,
0.2736710906,
0.9053307772,
0.037442375,
0.1560979038,
0.0777317137,
-0.3593792617,
0.1871564537,
-1.2251982689,
0.0275031962,
0.9886780977,
0.4009342194,
0.8892250657,
0.2383327931,
0.8785614967,
0.498018384,
0.1751738042,
-0.7966712713,
-0.0001663711,
0.0563214198,
-0.3067942262,
-0.8161651492,
-0.5181365013,
-1.31997931,
0.0558599643,
-0.2325202674,
-0.8472418785,
0.5486682653,
0.4412888288,
-0.3508347571,
0.4107357562,
-0.3419440091,
1.022143364,
0.0561940372,
-0.4843732715,
-0.457007736,
-0.8985944986,
0.4101242125,
0.6228467226,
0.189973399,
0.0789764076,
0.2833996117,
0.9168967605,
-0.5326856971,
0.737539053,
-0.3209237754,
-0.0104737049,
0.0586266778,
0.1242090017,
0.7931820154,
0.1498321295,
0.1498805285,
-0.2016468197,
0.0737700611,
-0.5498396158,
-0.8032832742,
0.3632359803,
-0.8312973976,
-0.4034537673,
-0.4998869002,
-0.5864268541,
-0.2469828427,
-0.1879838854,
0.1893076301,
0.384169817,
-0.0659463778,
0.1866069585,
0.8191916943,
-0.1689923108,
0.21701397,
0.1970814914,
-0.4191658795,
-0.3510912061,
0.9079165459,
-0.3799895644,
0.2002593875,
0.6363374591,
0.4393308461,
-0.4351976514,
-0.1574731469,
-0.4490124881,
0.3695778847,
-0.3866429031,
-0.1521184444,
-0.3977669179,
-0.147497341,
-0.4195605516,
-0.1284621954,
-0.2778706551,
-0.6461161375,
0.1389470696,
-0.1679302156,
0.3245974183,
1.2331753969,
-0.5086678267,
0.3246856034,
-0.5104970336,
0.1572477371,
0.7491383553,
0.6855896115,
0.1050415263,
-0.3384869099,
-0.4013010859,
0.0951649249,
0.0399544239,
-0.8660553694,
0.3012822866,
-0.0688481405,
0.5215367079,
0.3851958215,
-0.022217527,
0.2407292873,
-0.0566026457,
0.4099189937,
0.2256616205,
-0.4872852862,
0.4262216091,
-0.6380507946,
0.1062429398,
0.3366530836,
0.2651856542,
-0.8499578238,
-0.1060367674,
-0.9772965312,
-0.5922878385,
0.8168619871,
-0.1202794984,
-0.4017933309,
0.1409491897,
0.5043509603,
-0.1086841449,
0.291113764,
-0.9061946869,
-0.2128599286,
-0.2528457344,
-0.0609891191,
-0.1983944029,
-0.2347330749,
-0.3196470439,
-0.2329001576,
0.539578557,
-0.3060901761,
0.4306538701,
0.2093472332,
0.087355569,
-0.253122896,
0.3241695762,
0.4274461865,
0.4680805504,
-0.5700227022,
0.2085443139,
-0.4135973454,
0.1020752266,
0.3550664783,
-0.1513272822,
0.0414387919,
-0.2919669151,
0.2731415033,
0.846960783,
0.1091553271,
-0.1340911835,
0.5560535192,
-0.1440620869,
-0.3422962427,
0.0275941044,
0.2811645567,
0.3165562749,
0.2638868392,
0.0212465674,
-0.3910483718,
0.3162848055,
-0.5079086423,
0.3186446428,
0.6842468381,
-0.7370256186,
-0.1536608785,
0.3009158671,
0.0828123912,
-0.3423042893,
0.7811895013,
-0.2832801342,
-0.280824244,
0.6884655356,
0.3752228618,
0.8987349272,
-0.2197403461,
0.4531603158,
0.7286356688,
0.0997931808,
0.0571228079,
-0.0146743543,
-0.5033476949,
-0.7062362432,
-0.1659294814,
-0.736127615,
-0.4887105227,
-0.2151796967,
-0.7511535287,
-0.1632176191,
-0.3806256652,
-0.0318085924,
-0.2203400284,
-0.2442775965,
-0.4913149476,
0.0862610489,
-0.0379052572,
0.5641706586,
-0.6989345551,
0.9364972115,
0.8179271221,
-0.2193820477,
-0.9964652658,
-0.1780572534,
-0.09873721,
-0.7407970428,
0.8575161695,
-0.0477917232,
-0.2229043692,
-0.020453142,
-0.4471497834,
-1.0112656355,
1.1427459717,
-0.1350711137,
-0.2914059758,
-0.2948263288,
0.0889589116,
0.3379703462,
-0.6345049739,
0.3526227176,
0.4862271845,
0.5287638903,
0.1526805013,
-0.7087205648,
-0.1711201221,
-0.2403307557,
0.2112475038,
0.3055470586,
-0.345713079,
0.6758516431,
-0.1965984255,
-0.2323567122,
-0.2872078121,
0.4239035547,
0.4599294364,
-0.0383543819,
0.7489991188,
0.6049388051,
0.5898172855,
0.0766788051,
1.191202879,
-0.1480056345,
0.5321653485,
0.9690346718,
0.2742618918,
0.6459823251,
0.457913816,
-0.3231809735,
0.8793436289,
0.9305538535,
0.5002941489,
0.5688673854,
0.8096647263,
0.2496387959,
-0.1783119142,
-0.3499805927,
-0.3636919558,
0.1343574971,
0.2551788092,
-0.2414983213,
-0.263214767,
-0.4257317781,
-0.3183800578,
-0.1249499619,
-0.2806785405,
1.07059443,
-0.0950736254,
-0.9965658784,
0.5843431354,
-0.05750392,
0.6371192336,
-0.6779279709,
-0.2808032334,
-0.3687759042,
0.1268897951,
-0.2497920692,
-0.693276763,
0.3895398676,
-0.5159904957,
-0.2781073153,
-0.3142255247,
0.6398605108,
-0.5593593121,
-0.0979018733,
0.4769367874,
0.421120435,
0.1229531541,
-0.0226169359,
-0.7467268705,
-0.4894266427,
-0.107830584,
-0.2751671076,
0.5158968568,
0.2090900093,
-0.0192183871,
0.5570974946,
0.5111610889,
0.133390829,
-0.0533336066,
-0.0149249397,
0.5645484328,
-0.8049490452,
-0.7800152898,
-0.6971200109,
0.3927536905,
0.0515800714,
-0.1507836729,
0.1496402174,
0.2506599724,
0.7124637961,
0.0190824866,
0.4650948942,
0.0692700446,
0.5507013202,
-0.5117095113,
0.4158951938,
-0.6041743755,
-0.0316959321,
-0.3040482998,
-0.782186985,
-0.1394454092,
0.5981705785,
-0.0247359611,
0.0726677775,
0.6151973605,
0.7075304389,
-0.1876410395,
-0.0042752032,
0.1507427692,
-0.1822070181,
0.0678430498,
0.8482497334,
0.8738301396,
0.0727604479,
0.0886662081,
-0.4556711316,
-0.5587344766,
-0.3558473587,
-0.8678577542,
-0.3899040222,
-0.6673256159,
-0.1081904545,
-0.3196170032,
0.2595717013,
0.8499416709,
0.9028744102,
-0.8010935783,
-1.0351201296,
-0.4816115797,
0.6501426697,
-0.5206425786,
-0.3158509433,
0.4236609936,
-0.6037331223,
-0.2825596035,
0.0756015256,
0.4254951775,
-0.1635045707,
-0.1654712111,
-0.4184459448,
-0.381054461,
-0.072635822,
0.2345062494,
0.4895563424,
-0.5965009928,
-0.3092156053,
-0.1454357356,
-0.1123201996,
0.1174525395,
1.164078474,
-0.821005404,
0.3017327487,
0.5189709067,
0.7925516367,
0.5386461616,
0.343536675,
0.8272324204,
-0.570037663,
-0.0733568966,
0.0861471519,
0.2156150639,
0.103802532,
-0.3547708094,
0.840564847,
0.4144927561,
-0.8602713346,
-0.4233111441,
0.5939091444,
-0.6775153279,
-0.2484520227,
1.0571532249,
-0.14149037,
-0.2642789483,
0.1678244025,
0.1761310101,
0.329488188,
-0.4605329037,
0.8658496141,
0.7005528212,
-0.4735825956,
-0.1385819316,
-0.1334682256,
1.0982743502,
0.6851962805,
-0.8225856423,
0.2647075355,
0.4935827255,
0.0270215254,
-0.0477744155,
0.9330801368,
0.106689252,
0.432410717,
-0.4112108052,
0.1531888247,
0.138669014,
-0.5284693837,
-0.6635171771,
0.1437574178,
0.4239751995,
-0.1543920636
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10978v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10978v1
|
Language Models with Conformal Factuality Guarantees
| 2024-02-15T18:31:53 | 2024-02-15T18:31:53 |
Christopher Mohri, Tatsunori Hashimoto
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Guaranteeing the correctness and factuality of language model (LM) outputs is
a major open problem. In this work, we propose conformal factuality, a
framework that can ensure high probability correctness guarantees for LMs by
connecting language modeling and conformal prediction. We observe that the
correctness of an LM output is equivalent to an uncertainty quantification
problem, where the uncertainty sets are defined as the entailment set of an
LM's output. Using this connection, we show that conformal prediction in
language models corresponds to a back-off algorithm that provides high
probability correctness guarantees by progressively making LM outputs less
specific (and expanding the associated uncertainty sets). This approach applies
to any black-box LM and requires very few human-annotated samples. Evaluations
of our approach on closed book QA (FActScore, NaturalQuestions) and reasoning
tasks (MATH) show that our approach can provide 80-90% correctness guarantees
while retaining the majority of the LM's original output.
|
[
0.0147706969,
-0.4952623248,
0.8074038625,
0.0540107787,
0.2171743959,
-0.2782299221,
-0.5243471265,
-0.3750756383,
-0.1457300633,
0.7995828986,
-0.4569194913,
-0.4990270734,
-0.5472000837,
-0.2341655642,
-0.2654519081,
0.9675422311,
-0.0169335529,
-0.1797330081,
-0.3769428134,
-0.0573648848,
-0.4455798268,
-0.5631657243,
-0.2319358438,
-0.2517314553,
0.3197481036,
0.2127755135,
1.1939970255,
0.7793990374,
0.4831846654,
0.1999107599,
-0.0560766757,
-0.2263553441,
-0.3844181299,
0.1897125542,
-0.3225308657,
-0.8122198582,
-0.352391988,
0.0458879545,
0.8802059889,
0.6037452817,
-0.4490611553,
0.2337702811,
-0.3066393435,
0.8079305887,
-0.8225429058,
0.400237143,
-0.6898637414,
0.0089908252,
0.1074667871,
0.3913767338,
-0.7489362955,
-0.8066397905,
0.0702073649,
-0.6415019035,
0.2136926055,
0.0817483068,
1.025775671,
0.4461954236,
-0.2814590037,
-0.3018773794,
-1.1541481018,
0.6692024469,
-1.1280651093,
0.8305288553,
0.580665648,
0.4964289069,
-0.1091989428,
-0.4778833389,
-0.7622333765,
-0.278377831,
-0.0708210692,
0.1760291606,
0.0546818972,
0.0712669566,
0.3750761449,
0.2290258259,
-0.4030698538,
-0.2757053673,
-0.6010619998,
-0.2408864498,
0.6826514602,
-0.2277383953,
0.0123007186,
0.2410102636,
0.066232346,
-0.0652401671,
-0.8570281267,
0.1568126827,
0.2393140346,
0.305080384,
-0.0321629718,
0.6489143968,
-0.4064541161,
0.6348308921,
0.219024986,
-0.239837572,
-0.2297253609,
-0.3533313572,
-0.222449556,
0.0366030484,
0.631821394,
0.0061402288,
0.573235333,
-0.2807792127,
-0.2999047041,
0.1403509229,
0.1587030888,
-0.55553478,
-0.175036177,
0.5341137648,
-0.0512680076,
-0.2519234717,
0.2741763294,
-0.3490183949,
-0.1693936586,
-0.2639508247,
0.2913422883,
-0.5874171257,
-0.2615686953,
0.3871150911,
0.3107791841,
-0.3355457783,
0.2905115485,
-0.7075802684,
0.2420223355,
0.7895253897,
0.619258225,
0.0875360966,
-0.0420842133,
-0.6176207662,
0.7054257989,
-0.4902283549,
0.5097548962,
-0.5983666778,
-0.014175293,
0.3489822447,
-0.0971590281,
0.0192902759,
-0.321310848,
0.5561391711,
-0.6913374066,
0.0824380144,
-0.2573162913,
-0.8013740182,
-0.3596256077,
0.3037780821,
-0.8616826534,
0.4927352667,
-0.1114119962,
-0.5307512879,
0.3131886125,
-0.1622146964,
-0.1681052148,
-0.1265574992,
-0.0235619321,
-0.4201364219,
-0.0077482299,
-0.1943151504,
0.260867089,
-0.0600568429,
0.4666339159,
-0.4686178267,
-0.2619895041,
0.4429273307,
-0.1818267554,
0.3277477026,
0.0732644349,
-0.2078314722,
-0.0187710393,
-0.8346850276,
0.2124995738,
-0.276340872,
-0.5867535472,
-0.1108009592,
0.0920608789,
-0.3139992058,
0.434399128,
0.3331965506,
-0.7220879793,
-0.131917432,
-0.7146144509,
0.0682350397,
0.7388436794,
-0.1501990259,
0.4464637935,
-0.5487599969,
0.3579507172,
0.1524627656,
0.013112369,
-0.0156258699,
-0.7714477181,
-0.6182983518,
-0.1701982021,
0.4464818537,
0.6790222526,
-0.2238954455,
0.4093515873,
-0.1342517436,
-0.4523326457,
-0.3531419635,
-0.0346736312,
0.6627303362,
0.2513363361,
-0.1103365421,
0.0484630875,
-0.4683898985,
-0.8026362062,
-0.4319728613,
-0.6605879068,
0.0541348569,
-0.1689528227,
0.1911994368,
-0.0375331827,
1.1828670502,
-0.6029677391,
-0.2750267088,
0.2266746014,
-0.0976570398,
0.5098187327,
0.5651658773,
0.322491765,
-0.8680767417,
-0.4353850782,
0.0259643383,
-0.6715544462,
0.1716974974,
-0.0268843286,
0.0495828576,
0.5745143294,
0.3890625238,
-0.5857337713,
0.6377340555,
0.6176295877,
-0.3629717529,
0.712010026,
-0.2697261572,
0.0219990276,
-0.9394981861,
-0.2312414348,
0.2179483771,
-0.4395015836,
-0.4918729663,
0.0530732833,
0.0608092248,
-0.0801201761,
-0.0497002117,
0.3940930068,
-0.1544966251,
0.0274571385,
-0.0319950171,
-0.0226020161,
0.0146979922,
0.4589674175,
0.3315584362,
0.525740087,
0.3899103105,
-0.5051484108,
0.2759328187,
0.2901259065,
-0.0486902185,
0.4253267944,
-0.7318069935,
-0.1895687729,
-0.2543954253,
0.1444519013,
-0.8723940253,
-0.1351966113,
0.0543882363,
-0.3937608898,
0.1702093482,
-0.1095739156,
-0.2650727332,
-0.0408822335,
-0.0811963156,
0.1819006205,
0.7957726717,
-0.0922700092,
0.4435177445,
0.1453978717,
-0.2664488256,
-0.6745499372,
-0.6261278987,
-0.2229779363,
0.3608950377,
-0.6678120494,
-0.0236090869,
-0.3991685212,
-0.389798522,
0.0332311504,
-0.1187974885,
-0.3024974167,
-0.0898188651,
0.4115862846,
0.3132988214,
-0.4928504229,
0.1418994069,
-0.0691463724,
0.1249823943,
0.1789681315,
-0.5123473406,
0.0017037655,
-0.5054354072,
-0.6203637123,
-0.3462377191,
0.0233761519,
0.4469946027,
-0.1092093885,
0.9616926908,
0.364710331,
-0.7775053978,
0.0577123649,
-0.708789885,
-0.2596250474,
-0.4018581212,
0.124893561,
-0.4445168376,
-0.6660465002,
0.4577892721,
0.3218229711,
0.3536669314,
0.4248192906,
0.6199645996,
-0.0802621618,
0.8406446576,
0.6631520391,
0.2767602801,
0.1478339136,
0.1120324656,
0.3951697946,
-0.3777027428,
-0.1969048381,
-0.4861416519,
0.3034482002,
-0.5380421281,
-0.375433296,
0.1943857074,
0.2332261056,
-0.1703604609,
0.2425463498,
-0.2348228544,
0.4114409387,
0.6621376872,
0.0954120085,
0.6446645856,
-0.2249306142,
-0.0525424853,
-0.1145987958,
-0.5091499686,
-0.813947618,
1.1101467609,
0.3667486012,
0.7086398005,
0.3571834266,
0.6250147223,
0.3721378148,
0.5915852189,
-0.6079967618,
0.378706038,
0.0859227628,
-1.0514853001,
-0.6469756365,
-0.2666648626,
-0.2998547852,
-0.1011196002,
-0.4324029386,
-0.8924536705,
0.2999655306,
0.5179875493,
-0.261803329,
0.3178666234,
-0.519664526,
0.6185505986,
0.4632303417,
-0.2626374066,
-0.1836375445,
-0.6578418612,
0.7883344889,
-0.3908017278,
0.5366789699,
-0.2862720788,
0.2319678217,
0.5192767978,
-0.4052243233,
1.0000846386,
0.0468412749,
-0.4527695775,
0.274825722,
0.5663881302,
0.7189201713,
0.3450651765,
-0.3478941321,
0.1730735004,
0.6816011667,
-0.3748115599,
-0.6908946037,
0.4478734434,
-0.5549863577,
-0.8397325277,
-0.4988152385,
-0.6552267075,
-0.4273376763,
0.1610078514,
0.2315187156,
0.1756543368,
-0.2963555753,
-0.2596072257,
0.9067485332,
0.0938398689,
0.1395734251,
0.5490691662,
-0.2203025818,
-0.2943258286,
0.9874513745,
0.1133157015,
0.5712341666,
0.2929354608,
0.2505120337,
-0.2965608239,
-0.4921303093,
-0.237126112,
0.4787555337,
-0.9160918593,
-0.1170149967,
-0.3653686941,
-0.3782030344,
-0.8936817646,
-0.1068110317,
-0.4361339211,
-0.7653449178,
0.2949397862,
0.0681982636,
0.0987354815,
0.9796642661,
-0.2482289523,
0.0828098282,
-1.0126798153,
0.256131053,
0.326268971,
0.4683234394,
-0.2801605165,
-0.6439487934,
-0.4284931421,
0.4724785089,
-0.3217518032,
-0.7341323495,
0.082718499,
0.4447651803,
0.2420130521,
0.5089684129,
0.3034499586,
0.1027250066,
-0.6427532434,
0.6132250428,
0.3350477815,
-1.0296262503,
0.5975722671,
-0.2535497248,
0.004072723,
0.2025599778,
0.2550118268,
-0.7806028128,
-0.9997413158,
-0.7192072868,
-0.1406172514,
0.6467986107,
0.4631119072,
-0.2825171947,
0.1178278178,
0.4804252982,
0.2185563147,
0.2546431422,
-0.751465261,
0.0668494329,
-0.313397944,
-0.5434737206,
0.04722872,
-0.39577353,
-0.3208378255,
0.2221634686,
1.1236211061,
-0.1949056983,
0.0015627908,
0.201113075,
0.0338352509,
-0.4446403682,
0.4183816612,
0.6822711825,
1.1358219385,
-0.5553575754,
0.0861689225,
-0.0525669232,
-0.5054295063,
0.2713775933,
-0.1295944452,
-0.551476419,
0.1744846851,
0.3376857936,
0.4177185595,
-0.103937991,
-0.7491691709,
0.5288303494,
0.1453113556,
0.1022274941,
-0.5086616278,
-0.054706905,
0.1908816397,
0.1910877675,
0.1574189067,
0.2043921202,
0.025072746,
-0.4427400529,
0.4212149978,
0.2446508259,
-0.5274114013,
-0.7355564833,
0.8084276319,
-0.168446064,
-0.2959007621,
0.0959473103,
0.104736343,
-0.2843536437,
0.6753994823,
0.8007623553,
0.7520979643,
-0.3577983975,
0.2754042745,
0.4867396951,
0.4805402756,
-0.4154946208,
0.2634430826,
0.4465459585,
-1.0516130924,
-0.473254472,
-0.7572270036,
-0.7850328684,
-0.2678731978,
-0.6921588778,
0.2105003595,
-0.6099550128,
-0.1038515866,
0.0339894406,
-0.4396982193,
-0.3400085866,
0.5900152326,
0.2719613016,
0.8623480797,
-0.8164035082,
0.7284493446,
0.7086935639,
-0.5740014911,
-0.7549455166,
0.1537120789,
-0.1711663306,
-0.5642149448,
0.7706362605,
-0.2525267303,
-0.0690431669,
-0.3220685124,
-0.6084186435,
-1.0727243423,
0.7144973278,
0.8305978775,
-0.7238885164,
-0.1639924943,
0.3399413526,
0.2567443848,
-0.2228652537,
-0.2733559012,
0.4666703939,
0.6155675054,
0.2778917551,
-0.8614830971,
0.4407321811,
0.3121145666,
0.0736557916,
-0.0267967843,
-0.5009153485,
0.6622553468,
-0.5758613348,
-0.2033045888,
-0.0522625335,
1.0764322281,
0.5914914012,
0.3471093774,
0.3128512204,
0.4376032352,
0.8518798947,
-0.1424866617,
1.0433362722,
-0.391409725,
0.5158575773,
1.0846009254,
-0.3987437785,
0.8242205381,
0.3804906905,
-0.4013549984,
0.4669656157,
0.5095589757,
0.3602135479,
0.3897045851,
0.0694330558,
-0.1520480663,
-0.2978563607,
-0.0438040346,
-0.160711959,
0.0399927497,
0.2394767851,
0.0476527698,
0.0617184043,
-0.2923626304,
0.090745993,
0.5200555325,
-0.0606750511,
0.5591173172,
0.074631229,
-0.7706558108,
0.7206639647,
0.1069803685,
0.3802907765,
-0.4854266644,
-0.0809560344,
-0.0691868141,
0.231294781,
-0.2974109054,
-0.7256779671,
0.5768953562,
-0.5293932557,
-0.6495342851,
0.2115140408,
0.635386169,
-0.8238649368,
-0.8133122921,
-0.2995350361,
0.3094373047,
-0.0114424424,
-0.1188567504,
-0.1840059757,
-0.2557599843,
-0.1884596944,
-0.0802431032,
-0.086077027,
0.6794532537,
-0.1474405527,
0.7499339581,
0.4972116947,
0.4777113199,
0.2882498801,
-0.2788407207,
0.5474874973,
-0.6502290964,
-0.5936960578,
-0.681830883,
0.2348388135,
0.0248328671,
-0.0069167851,
0.3848365545,
0.4430473149,
0.7704514265,
-0.2964138091,
1.0803927183,
0.1644176096,
0.4395662546,
-0.7583231926,
0.6970372796,
-0.0676826239,
0.1878811419,
0.0185539387,
-0.8763611913,
-0.2282238752,
0.4112910628,
-0.1907517016,
-0.1557552516,
0.8665274978,
0.6868231297,
-0.1628519744,
0.0235756282,
0.707449019,
0.2823620737,
0.3077608645,
0.5470795631,
0.4356586635,
-0.5503032207,
0.4417739809,
-0.2308345586,
-0.1676053703,
-0.0589307807,
-0.8175397515,
-0.7541956306,
-0.8550444841,
-0.7011598945,
-0.8448792696,
0.2573405802,
0.6567430496,
0.6930781603,
-1.3201534748,
-0.3238460124,
0.0535476096,
0.4789935052,
-0.2812932134,
-0.1926905662,
0.1749441475,
-0.4201491177,
-0.7499278188,
0.0157599822,
0.2903374135,
0.203319028,
-0.191409409,
-0.23331438,
-0.2459827214,
0.5839034319,
0.2652515173,
0.3645784557,
-0.8430790305,
-0.6186752319,
-0.180747062,
-0.1699292809,
0.0400440283,
0.6547057033,
-0.6212558746,
0.1779589653,
0.2866193354,
0.5689940453,
0.3961561024,
-0.1770486683,
1.1516897678,
-0.8022831678,
0.2234220356,
0.1749441475,
0.4253707826,
0.262227267,
-0.5726592541,
0.5789110065,
0.3026945889,
-0.3535756767,
-0.8617007136,
0.7028702497,
-0.84312433,
0.0127493823,
1.2665971518,
-0.6116456985,
-0.4165290594,
-0.1417606026,
0.1534551978,
0.381931901,
-0.311121285,
0.8874465227,
0.9672871232,
0.3254486024,
0.0785674974,
-0.3598408699,
0.7013648748,
0.3080862164,
-0.5349878669,
0.263500303,
0.5971160531,
0.4336946905,
0.4758942127,
0.33418715,
-0.0241764039,
0.3864279091,
-0.3849170208,
0.362195462,
-0.020824343,
-0.149396643,
-0.1370614171,
0.2504084408,
0.27753672,
-0.0281189736
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10178v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10178v1
|
TDAG: A Multi-Agent Framework based on Dynamic Task Decomposition and Agent Generation
| 2024-02-15T18:27:37 | 2024-02-15T18:27:37 |
Yaoxiang Wang, Zhiyong Wu, Junfeng Yao, Jinsong Su
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The emergence of Large Language Models (LLMs) like ChatGPT has inspired the
development of LLM-based agents capable of addressing complex, real-world
tasks. However, these agents often struggle during task execution due to
methodological constraints, such as error propagation and limited adaptability.
To address this issue, we propose a multi-agent framework based on dynamic Task
Decomposition and Agent Generation (TDAG). This framework dynamically
decomposes complex tasks into smaller subtasks and assigns each to a
specifically generated subagent, thereby enhancing adaptability in diverse and
unpredictable real-world tasks. Simultaneously, existing benchmarks often lack
the granularity needed to evaluate incremental progress in complex, multi-step
tasks. In response, we introduce ItineraryBench in the context of travel
planning, featuring interconnected, progressively complex tasks with a
fine-grained evaluation system. ItineraryBench is designed to assess agents'
abilities in memory, planning, and tool usage across tasks of varying
complexity. Our experimental results reveal that TDAG significantly outperforms
established baselines, showcasing its superior adaptability and context
awareness in complex task scenarios.
|
[
-0.3514770865,
-0.7116615772,
0.678493619,
0.4593033791,
-0.0369854309,
0.835539937,
-0.2554109991,
-0.1725968719,
0.1080564857,
0.0172543656,
-0.7690380216,
-0.4376803339,
-0.1820467263,
-0.243820399,
-0.1802465916,
0.660951674,
-0.199493736,
-0.4031222463,
-0.1354915798,
0.0045637707,
-0.6317816973,
-0.4373244941,
-0.8019014001,
-0.6084731221,
0.5087639093,
0.5191074014,
0.4396925867,
0.3050383925,
0.3664142191,
0.3359316289,
0.11795789,
0.2332805097,
-0.4332688451,
0.2905065715,
-0.5504040122,
-0.0132117979,
-0.7795797586,
-0.5222736001,
0.6457774043,
0.3436741233,
-0.5040989518,
0.2128296345,
-0.2305737585,
0.1332320571,
-0.6030677557,
0.4463781714,
-0.5474513769,
-0.0714605451,
-0.1308641583,
-0.1873202175,
-0.1834124178,
0.1528064907,
0.0831171349,
-0.5145454407,
0.1119210646,
-0.0391604863,
0.5821194649,
0.2792152166,
-0.5475176573,
-0.1528921276,
-0.9334059358,
0.6417489648,
-0.3189844191,
0.0806777477,
-0.0886648446,
0.7869684696,
-0.4553363919,
-0.8132531047,
-0.6708406806,
-0.3374717236,
0.2136776447,
0.0510220267,
-0.1502266526,
0.125285387,
-0.130635187,
-0.0464928038,
-0.6694970727,
-0.0213819183,
0.0857411474,
-0.0661825612,
0.4241784513,
0.5565668344,
0.5085542202,
0.1878197789,
-0.3048303425,
0.0109235235,
-0.358827889,
-0.0870772675,
-0.0163751803,
0.4599465132,
-0.0455877073,
0.3409348428,
-0.408490926,
0.3825363815,
-0.0216284748,
-0.3259266019,
0.0398549251,
-0.4537038803,
-0.2345233709,
-0.0149056586,
0.2202841192,
0.3432172835,
0.181663394,
-0.484605521,
-0.2049112469,
0.0467942022,
0.5015407801,
-0.8326184154,
-0.1089913994,
0.429058671,
-0.1168748587,
-0.2462896258,
-0.3448067904,
-0.6394690871,
-0.3700983226,
0.0000091311,
0.3453490138,
-0.1870125681,
-0.630536437,
0.0506776311,
-0.1772113591,
0.1552203447,
0.636063993,
-0.3900898695,
0.1617088169,
0.4121385515,
0.755589664,
-0.2743811309,
-0.7309283614,
-0.50759238,
0.56308043,
-0.1695849895,
1.2181676626,
-0.6486343741,
-0.4706004262,
0.0082770344,
-0.0079648299,
-0.2917291522,
-0.4016572237,
0.4244356453,
-0.4792087376,
-0.2566829026,
-0.4298356771,
-0.0754999295,
-0.3467910886,
0.8190635443,
-0.501342833,
0.7829078436,
0.5137652159,
-0.1870214641,
0.4592114687,
-0.8747993112,
-0.3648965061,
0.1374685764,
-0.0804617703,
-0.3452509642,
0.0152279744,
-0.138357237,
0.1818879247,
-0.4788376391,
0.4728415608,
-0.4772330225,
-0.3035851419,
-0.0664244965,
-0.1359561384,
0.4751738906,
0.2108748704,
-0.3540474176,
0.5037939548,
-0.9254681468,
0.2935276031,
0.130962044,
-0.7908980846,
0.1989904195,
0.2679613829,
0.3692016304,
0.3393527567,
0.1430771947,
-0.3220028281,
0.5413326025,
0.0534013659,
0.311180234,
0.8503349423,
0.055574026,
0.3060451746,
-0.5247460008,
0.7564155459,
0.0412284359,
-0.1481138021,
0.1037565395,
0.1405978799,
-0.7899520993,
-0.2993448675,
-0.0824634582,
0.4640316069,
-0.7995808125,
0.1976202279,
-0.5430468321,
-0.6951901913,
0.2877775431,
-0.2342767417,
0.2428070158,
0.1848202497,
0.1178308427,
-0.1088102013,
-0.3077186942,
-0.4607762992,
-0.1643135399,
-0.3352583945,
0.1141293794,
-0.0631023869,
0.4773288667,
-0.5178700089,
0.460455507,
-0.2208006531,
-0.3798746169,
-0.4998386502,
-0.0375150517,
-0.3359839916,
0.4714051485,
0.8293096423,
-0.4300800562,
-0.4522360563,
0.0497014672,
-0.4195246994,
-0.0882107839,
-0.3506277204,
-0.2746510804,
0.0749618858,
0.199814871,
-0.7333967686,
0.2244726121,
0.125506267,
-0.7787489295,
0.4715712368,
-0.2668457031,
0.0175631791,
-0.9104070067,
0.1118136719,
-0.4135828316,
-0.4699326456,
-0.7075261474,
0.2834474444,
-0.224247843,
-0.0998651832,
-0.2421705574,
0.7978222966,
-0.406008631,
-0.1865115315,
-0.4967500865,
-0.07640066,
0.0290037319,
0.7170277238,
-0.1718622595,
0.8288233876,
0.4913713038,
-0.5377117395,
0.3345499039,
0.1106415093,
-0.1437666565,
0.6919460297,
-0.3315034807,
0.2190506905,
-0.1133843288,
0.4039541185,
-0.9452432394,
-0.4137152433,
0.1365047246,
0.0943083614,
0.1864597499,
0.154617399,
-0.5654438138,
-0.0367569812,
-0.2393886149,
0.3559458554,
0.1962789297,
-0.3101170957,
1.3746936321,
0.3874206543,
-0.0204489306,
-0.4872278869,
-0.4025148749,
0.3032760918,
-0.177436918,
-0.5160241127,
0.4613224864,
-0.1903176308,
-0.4321176112,
0.0237120353,
-0.5326148868,
-0.2177431136,
0.1676380038,
0.4222892225,
-0.1842691153,
0.1227888539,
0.1978334934,
0.0175764933,
0.0272669513,
-0.1321199387,
-0.1523785293,
0.7778069377,
-0.2920391262,
-0.3799270391,
0.1660612226,
0.560354352,
0.8331958652,
-0.3301866353,
0.4529070258,
0.8394747376,
-0.3046910167,
-0.6329599023,
-0.3834969103,
0.3386469781,
-0.497278899,
0.4333138466,
-0.970634222,
-0.5447426438,
0.7398221493,
-0.4128198326,
0.298638761,
0.2077274919,
1.005450964,
0.1293786466,
0.6121666431,
0.8015160561,
0.3615954816,
0.5815036297,
-0.0248114057,
0.057222832,
-0.3948278129,
-0.3365845978,
-0.4561493695,
-0.3162961602,
-0.4589388967,
-0.5853910446,
0.330689013,
-0.4003015459,
-0.2831239402,
0.0993667245,
-0.2666829824,
0.3536781073,
0.4989523292,
-0.0222374257,
0.3113971949,
-0.191050142,
0.0813639238,
0.6971812844,
-0.7469887733,
-0.5334867239,
0.8073737025,
0.0324002206,
0.7115177512,
0.2658951283,
0.4075437784,
0.6584101915,
0.1107608527,
-0.8333880305,
0.8442909718,
0.1727903634,
-0.6935828924,
-0.1138546616,
-0.0656981319,
-0.84828192,
0.4823642075,
0.0281917695,
-0.8041142821,
0.2120682597,
0.0117581505,
-0.449534297,
0.2724242508,
-0.8683340549,
0.6639729738,
-0.1117424369,
-0.4271047711,
-0.4770517349,
-0.3393086791,
-0.0843733326,
-0.2830454707,
-0.0155315083,
-0.5598751307,
-0.1136807054,
0.4558292329,
-0.3201037049,
0.590307653,
-0.3494581878,
-0.1130626723,
0.4346119761,
0.4674130082,
0.6019988656,
0.0589993298,
-0.226319477,
0.0692532361,
0.2744724452,
-0.5233082175,
-0.310495317,
0.8574687839,
-0.5794054866,
-0.623583138,
-0.4817872643,
-1.0335768461,
-0.2741999626,
0.5271967053,
-0.2732300758,
0.225356847,
-0.3405486941,
-0.3247638047,
-0.0922404975,
-0.1401022673,
0.8227694631,
0.6611483693,
0.0165576264,
-0.1055306345,
0.8643193245,
0.3394646347,
0.0839630514,
0.239795655,
-0.1288693547,
-0.0543392748,
-0.8374512196,
-0.2935737967,
-0.0468832925,
-0.8371354342,
0.0421045311,
-0.5888669491,
0.1854927391,
-0.1857466549,
-0.3256431818,
-0.4692902565,
-0.407856673,
0.1233692318,
0.0347844362,
-0.2094124407,
0.6308577061,
0.0814721361,
0.5612999201,
-0.5461284518,
0.4097541571,
0.2323834002,
0.4087390602,
-0.1809574515,
0.0201047324,
-0.3772953451,
-0.3172911704,
-0.3552003503,
-0.565980196,
0.1488966644,
0.1990648508,
0.6985670924,
0.0437769368,
0.2052416354,
0.8880681992,
-0.4700334072,
0.6635466218,
-0.426871419,
-0.8385900259,
0.1506469846,
-0.5943418741,
0.6469854712,
0.4698539078,
-0.2743946314,
-0.0797925666,
-0.3404416144,
-0.5407016277,
-0.7571210861,
0.826926589,
0.2918310463,
-0.194460541,
0.4479191005,
0.0687846914,
0.02059149,
0.5000061393,
-0.6134012341,
0.1332610548,
0.0404550135,
0.0486306138,
-0.134735018,
-0.3347206414,
-0.3896046579,
0.0802833885,
0.4873750806,
-0.2466535866,
0.5841357112,
-0.0493000932,
-0.1089914963,
-0.3257901669,
0.4131890833,
0.7611912489,
1.2773637772,
-0.4143495858,
0.2029995471,
0.1210413128,
-0.3141714036,
0.5050545335,
0.1999474615,
0.085346207,
-0.0921526924,
0.5467513204,
0.4328167737,
-0.4449262023,
-0.9395112991,
0.1453920454,
-0.2399456054,
0.0686426982,
-0.5305175185,
0.2800738215,
-0.0154800052,
0.7326563597,
0.2430177927,
0.173617512,
0.0421069041,
-0.6682556868,
0.1005381867,
0.344912082,
-0.0521143302,
-0.4900783002,
0.5124219656,
0.3525832891,
-0.4885409772,
0.057429906,
-0.6052071452,
-0.375087887,
0.7153608799,
0.2831918001,
1.1744269133,
-0.2920957208,
0.139575243,
0.0596920289,
0.4877758324,
0.001701244,
0.6716096401,
-0.2091288269,
-0.5354369283,
-0.4049699008,
-0.4651899934,
-0.3325420022,
-0.1371760666,
-0.0320403241,
0.1838338673,
-0.4309003651,
-0.2278819233,
-0.1460385174,
-0.0106547782,
-0.8094526529,
0.1692811847,
-0.0523549765,
0.5675984025,
-0.4280664623,
0.9266979694,
1.1109981537,
-0.1784490198,
-0.8209071755,
0.534460783,
0.0622978285,
-0.7238681316,
0.4860964715,
0.1639852971,
-0.4129457772,
-0.0079871695,
0.0674097463,
-0.7325351834,
1.1919207573,
0.565097034,
-0.2721872032,
-0.5194318891,
0.1854901761,
0.522557199,
-0.2526840568,
0.293140769,
0.5549858809,
0.5643487573,
0.1677777469,
-1.214682579,
0.3630234003,
-0.1634743512,
-0.025613727,
0.0565812513,
-1.0248528719,
0.9044181705,
-0.1762967706,
-0.4271849096,
-0.2744612396,
0.086504586,
0.1863548905,
0.4339444637,
0.7341315746,
0.2443740666,
0.463971287,
-0.2222408205,
0.7036491632,
-0.1225580648,
0.2664355338,
1.2359137535,
-0.4869796634,
0.3287324607,
0.4496679008,
0.035087321,
0.6562077999,
0.570458591,
0.2754435241,
0.6751236916,
0.3176310062,
-0.3951338232,
-0.4156879485,
-0.3442185521,
-0.0115028089,
0.7699190378,
0.2614432275,
0.2172957361,
-1.0064928532,
0.2475531548,
0.0526151173,
-0.2982518971,
-0.1680401862,
0.6706504226,
-0.2372661382,
-0.8433285356,
0.6204742193,
0.0600896552,
0.0538057759,
-0.7563458681,
-0.1152017638,
-0.1238802224,
0.4334419072,
-0.064695321,
-0.6183151007,
0.3613044918,
-0.1650638878,
0.1011909321,
-0.3769967556,
0.9255890846,
-0.2484747022,
-0.191706121,
0.305185318,
0.807887733,
-0.2149004787,
-0.2755675912,
-0.5383709073,
0.2922929227,
-0.0609467402,
-0.6847202778,
0.2513691783,
0.5946062803,
-0.2219382972,
1.1197828054,
0.2655186355,
-0.0403260179,
-0.0645059347,
-0.1082563177,
1.0832375288,
-0.6667103767,
-0.6122142673,
-0.8447247148,
0.6782200336,
0.0818854496,
0.1898252964,
0.5282762647,
0.3212421536,
0.6179615855,
-0.110430792,
0.9095525742,
-0.3840896487,
0.1794329286,
-0.1252637357,
0.4257995784,
-0.6599925756,
0.4762693644,
-0.1105476171,
-0.8106502295,
-0.0411065817,
0.2435074747,
0.1263094842,
0.0612100735,
0.6906087995,
0.6509093046,
-0.0871814191,
-0.6149523854,
0.2037145942,
-0.1463378519,
1.1560313702,
0.8169879913,
0.7634960413,
0.0622072667,
0.8424533606,
-0.053853482,
-0.0729937628,
-0.2118366063,
-0.8211512566,
-1.1736035347,
-0.5590418577,
-0.3655641675,
-0.2468889654,
0.1003528014,
1.0787032843,
0.7293727994,
-0.3933445513,
-0.4143424332,
-0.2253752798,
0.0768251047,
-0.4391289949,
-0.1938565224,
0.1819011122,
-0.2894781828,
-0.8051265478,
0.5934250951,
0.4141174257,
0.1320301145,
-0.3198985755,
0.1906841397,
-0.1001392305,
0.211574018,
0.6196544766,
0.0815438107,
-0.4839681983,
-0.3782875836,
-0.215715006,
-0.0094959326,
-0.1115238592,
0.7394720316,
-0.5799746513,
0.659319818,
0.4797922075,
0.6290519834,
0.5339161158,
-0.0612714402,
0.5744203329,
-0.6933065057,
0.3291349113,
0.1733520776,
0.1997345835,
-0.2055833489,
-0.2750626802,
0.6614025235,
0.0491328426,
-0.630420804,
-1.0301424265,
0.3074757457,
-1.4740133286,
-0.4681067467,
1.2017199993,
-0.1456482112,
-0.0448228791,
-0.2544040084,
-0.3478103578,
0.3035233021,
-0.6709039807,
0.9113144875,
0.7610855699,
-0.3029030263,
0.0474807546,
-0.3828043342,
0.4399698377,
0.2744237781,
-1.2114343643,
0.1504158974,
0.6056300402,
0.3064272106,
0.3022424877,
0.9649031162,
0.4945143461,
0.119607769,
0.2941747606,
0.1375345439,
-0.3678253591,
-0.437738955,
0.1908699572,
0.6520096064,
0.3289093971,
-0.3182993233
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10176v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10176v1
|
OpenMathInstruct-1: A 1.8 Million Math Instruction Tuning Dataset
| 2024-02-15T18:26:11 | 2024-02-15T18:26:11 |
Shubham Toshniwal, Ivan Moshkov, Sean Narenthiran, Daria Gitman, Fei Jia, Igor Gitman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Recent work has shown the immense potential of synthetically generated
datasets for training large language models (LLMs), especially for acquiring
targeted skills. Current large-scale math instruction tuning datasets such as
MetaMathQA (Yu et al., 2024) and MAmmoTH (Yue et al., 2024) are constructed
using outputs from closed-source LLMs with commercially restrictive licenses. A
key reason limiting the use of open-source LLMs in these data generation
pipelines has been the wide gap between the mathematical skills of the best
closed-source LLMs, such as GPT-4, and the best open-source LLMs. Building on
the recent progress in open-source LLMs, our proposed prompting novelty, and
some brute-force scaling, we construct OpenMathInstruct-1, a math instruction
tuning dataset with 1.8M problem-solution pairs. The dataset is constructed by
synthesizing code-interpreter solutions for GSM8K and MATH, two popular math
reasoning benchmarks, using the recently released and permissively licensed
Mixtral model. Our best model, OpenMath-CodeLlama-70B, trained on a subset of
OpenMathInstruct-1, achieves a score of 84.6% on GSM8K and 50.7% on MATH, which
is competitive with the best gpt-distilled models. We release our code, models,
and the OpenMathInstruct-1 dataset under a commercially permissive license.
|
[
-0.3377504945,
-0.6663006544,
0.2405585051,
0.0374440812,
-0.1573352516,
-0.2816459537,
-0.3692975342,
0.0824364498,
-0.2838924229,
0.483243674,
-0.8553782701,
-0.7425795197,
-0.3556610644,
-0.0650381371,
0.0263868924,
1.1375645399,
-0.1334594041,
0.3550263047,
-0.371896565,
-0.2239036262,
-0.278989315,
-0.4606796503,
-0.2998444438,
-0.2254144996,
0.4877385199,
0.6324720979,
0.7404122949,
0.8558437824,
0.5501400828,
0.2161444724,
0.1124805138,
0.1568134874,
-0.8482083678,
-0.1719533652,
-0.246777758,
-0.5322756767,
-0.7096043825,
0.424251169,
0.6631144881,
0.7341324687,
-0.3910160959,
0.508566618,
-0.1951848716,
0.8039445877,
-0.4665979147,
0.4950302839,
-0.6864401698,
0.0066658193,
-0.5260487199,
-0.0952392295,
-0.4657316506,
-0.771099627,
-0.1865944564,
-0.7822071314,
0.0223357808,
-0.0964635164,
0.4635633528,
0.5202518702,
-0.0071399566,
-0.3975455463,
-0.342136085,
0.9218218923,
-0.6545488834,
0.2720404863,
0.6200272441,
0.5201119184,
-0.0973588824,
-0.3718306422,
-0.1233558655,
-0.0056117764,
0.2501698434,
0.1113997474,
0.0219330173,
-0.0253333878,
0.5028310418,
0.7105270624,
-0.6965487599,
0.1644854099,
-0.6694067121,
-0.0599472299,
0.3909888268,
0.4263625741,
0.0640463978,
0.2099173665,
-0.0721659437,
-0.0712634623,
-1.189565897,
-0.2543898523,
0.7380762696,
0.2712000012,
-0.2535960674,
0.8128437996,
0.0198942069,
0.7465646267,
-0.3199417889,
-0.1669869125,
0.145605579,
-0.2500957549,
-0.2948711216,
0.1000834107,
0.4413829446,
-0.0094659133,
0.7056230307,
0.0545344204,
-0.1805687398,
0.1900829524,
0.1835031211,
-0.9735614657,
-0.3236355186,
-0.1135308072,
-0.281726867,
-0.3268997967,
0.2462159991,
-0.5762251616,
0.0201762468,
-0.5912054181,
0.3971664011,
-0.3671119809,
-0.2795261145,
0.2465402484,
0.2313614786,
0.1039916724,
0.3221003115,
-1.0058215857,
0.3275301456,
0.781322062,
0.9819480181,
-0.1039601639,
-0.1222196519,
-0.5210061073,
-0.2571931183,
-0.5398787856,
0.3771577179,
-0.6320490837,
-0.2820368111,
-0.0001912635,
-0.0795164332,
-0.1520646065,
-0.7556734681,
0.5008803606,
-0.5156684518,
0.4717074931,
0.0217520557,
-0.6287790537,
-0.0239428226,
0.0461719111,
-0.694999218,
0.8071565628,
0.7134830356,
-0.5493836999,
0.067265518,
-0.897814393,
-0.1168588921,
0.0051298132,
-0.277697742,
-0.5676443577,
0.2530471981,
0.1375598907,
-0.0246843956,
-0.466727078,
0.0631306693,
-0.2934081852,
-0.3643439412,
0.1626763791,
-0.5673632026,
0.999032557,
0.3505644202,
-0.0260712784,
0.089030169,
-0.747556746,
0.1965584159,
0.1955159158,
-0.4945321679,
-0.1287142336,
-0.2050143331,
-0.3597579002,
0.2157884836,
0.1594999582,
-0.6313511729,
0.2418787181,
-0.4376270473,
0.3088430762,
1.0984793901,
-0.3505389094,
0.2853228152,
-0.3835964799,
0.89277637,
0.0419163853,
0.0289676487,
-0.4643087089,
-0.5296443701,
-0.5402726531,
-0.3711417913,
0.3985131085,
0.465501219,
-0.4492070675,
0.2254372537,
-0.2625387609,
-0.3471609652,
-0.8057426214,
0.1117073148,
0.6231918335,
0.6120527983,
0.2865256965,
0.2301775068,
-0.3956142664,
-0.8412889242,
-0.2297544777,
0.2472357154,
-0.2212769538,
0.4516440332,
0.3815577626,
0.2183348536,
0.7130291462,
-0.7133859396,
-0.2531080246,
0.0299144872,
-0.2129558325,
0.5324672461,
0.4071213901,
0.3855037391,
-0.4411767423,
-0.556375742,
0.0613825656,
-0.7533676028,
-0.1767756492,
0.5146346092,
-0.193552956,
0.2381052822,
0.3563366532,
-0.4827599525,
0.323238045,
0.7142975926,
-0.2481832504,
0.6721369624,
-0.1018307805,
-0.0223861579,
-1.0793975592,
-0.0095875012,
-0.0536532775,
-0.0766122788,
-0.3483852148,
0.1633731276,
0.0975013599,
-0.3674632013,
-0.4428077936,
0.4912600219,
-0.2509587407,
-0.0725259706,
0.1036916971,
-0.1418845206,
-0.5255279541,
0.5279209614,
-0.3999670744,
1.2527555227,
0.439263463,
-0.3497640491,
0.3348213732,
0.3637443781,
-0.6347184181,
0.4100575745,
-0.6508918405,
0.2317093611,
0.1416391879,
-0.0543454736,
-0.6324499249,
-0.4502339065,
0.2239700407,
-0.3760797083,
0.1408041269,
-0.383177042,
-0.5320423245,
-0.1912516803,
-0.1340309978,
0.4467276335,
0.7609300017,
-0.7034270167,
0.3401713669,
0.2583200932,
-0.3302336931,
-0.3009908497,
-0.4909749627,
-0.4382716417,
-0.0846610442,
-0.7512475848,
-0.0542910099,
-0.2601985633,
-0.281547606,
0.0604922771,
-0.3126583099,
-0.0259754285,
-0.0148043688,
0.2539226413,
0.5010293126,
-0.5987333655,
0.1973751932,
0.1068756059,
-0.4104231298,
0.2466747165,
-0.481815815,
0.4328872263,
-0.1841125786,
-0.5704393387,
0.0259862002,
0.0338996425,
0.6173027754,
-0.3072912395,
0.6151921153,
0.2545706332,
-0.3071249723,
-0.4094776809,
-0.1325092614,
-0.1166691557,
-0.5275217295,
0.4150842428,
-0.4744652212,
-0.9930738807,
0.2452593893,
-0.1745412201,
0.3446050286,
0.3850784302,
0.7088978887,
0.3293334544,
1.1069476604,
0.251219064,
-0.1613387614,
0.3655402362,
-0.1181467921,
0.0772724301,
-0.6735995412,
-0.1303335875,
-0.5231925249,
-0.1816781461,
-0.5806857944,
-0.4459523857,
0.5039771199,
-0.0738386512,
-0.3741603494,
0.0967890918,
-0.3535791337,
0.93947047,
0.53865242,
0.2104973048,
0.2847630084,
0.4709280729,
-0.3184639215,
-0.1555380672,
-0.7340125442,
-0.3661564887,
1.45558393,
0.3996438384,
1.0220927,
0.2651365399,
0.4006986916,
-0.1045490727,
0.3801428974,
-0.6518278718,
0.4818063378,
-0.3655782044,
-0.6269333363,
-0.2585720718,
-0.9107655287,
-0.736674726,
-0.1005157977,
0.2169408649,
-0.3150418997,
-0.5833320022,
0.122500062,
0.0967311487,
0.3442285359,
-0.7121222615,
0.9417181015,
0.0201960653,
-0.4505356252,
-0.396656841,
-0.257469058,
0.617231667,
-0.1876391619,
0.2306747437,
-0.20034343,
0.1281503886,
0.4180629253,
-0.6434118152,
0.5139679313,
-0.2443298697,
-0.409304589,
0.2259095162,
0.316570133,
0.3104048669,
0.1771726161,
-0.2580599487,
0.2912320495,
-0.3217206895,
-0.4515385032,
-0.5899944305,
0.8835059404,
-0.8807691932,
-0.5131315589,
-0.1255646199,
-0.7602082491,
-0.0844345242,
0.036879655,
0.2665777206,
0.8269483447,
-0.050775025,
0.3001488149,
0.9745951295,
-0.13013345,
0.1427250057,
0.4727739096,
-0.2465220094,
-0.6333782673,
1.2175940275,
0.1142770872,
0.5211482048,
0.0567047261,
0.3740796745,
-0.2437846363,
-0.3202877939,
-0.6114592552,
0.2400462627,
-0.6800377369,
-0.3263659775,
-0.0733781755,
-0.5352099538,
-0.1089884713,
-0.0034739745,
-0.3709217012,
-0.5796926618,
-0.3373734653,
0.0549249463,
0.3957867622,
0.9233058691,
0.0373655707,
0.057800509,
-0.6193930507,
0.1653291732,
0.2179886401,
0.8346592188,
-0.2508902848,
-0.7551259398,
-0.5160164833,
0.3156551719,
-0.2443714887,
-0.3794024289,
0.0445761196,
0.2133461088,
0.4952784479,
0.4100374877,
-0.2729108632,
0.4826184213,
-0.6583728194,
0.4241543412,
0.0611985996,
-0.7377803922,
0.5868735909,
-0.6696020961,
0.5972274542,
0.2912098467,
0.5087616444,
-0.1478657871,
-0.1062321514,
-0.3764268458,
-0.103741847,
1.1192287207,
0.3255681992,
0.0491402857,
0.1053263843,
0.3224089146,
0.3680847585,
0.2760576904,
-0.4889384508,
-0.3234283626,
-0.3432263136,
-0.6657627225,
-0.0168648344,
0.1287315488,
-0.2493949682,
-0.4442573488,
0.6434230208,
-0.2381242365,
0.1093304306,
-0.3310571611,
-0.122668542,
-0.349319458,
0.1573943049,
0.9264766574,
1.0094687939,
-0.2616821826,
-0.0895543396,
-0.0788604096,
-0.7310754657,
0.1174852699,
0.1045151129,
-0.0437201336,
-0.178252086,
0.1328706443,
0.8525055647,
0.2322342396,
-0.6574776173,
0.3642579317,
0.1009549722,
-0.5920547247,
-0.1927206963,
0.4122867882,
0.0759248212,
-0.0526445955,
0.1580200195,
-0.1242303252,
-0.3639096618,
-0.3820731342,
0.1239713281,
0.3828557432,
-0.2103670835,
-0.4959697723,
0.5765640736,
-0.0405215621,
-0.4868806005,
0.8789942861,
-0.1737816483,
-0.3859671354,
0.6299573779,
0.7646914124,
0.6307561994,
-0.4541990757,
0.0495524667,
0.6685438156,
0.3101867735,
-0.0170560628,
0.34250319,
0.1101614013,
-0.3716883063,
-0.4246818125,
-0.6849554181,
-0.5394749045,
0.2129875571,
-0.5812219381,
0.4875949323,
-0.6141983867,
0.2846949697,
-0.1896171123,
-0.1041026786,
-0.6210104227,
-0.0307363197,
-0.0433538668,
1.054761529,
-0.5724127293,
0.8452218771,
0.6664009094,
-0.3115874529,
-0.7738242149,
-0.4568919241,
0.1290129572,
-0.9644227624,
0.4694504738,
0.1903758943,
0.1731951386,
0.3916945457,
-0.6861155033,
-0.8054827452,
1.07888484,
0.671843648,
-0.7157617807,
-0.1237608641,
0.3912786543,
0.2324838787,
-0.5255041718,
0.2365870476,
0.4843025804,
0.2936611772,
0.0992217213,
-0.8517864347,
-0.1390672326,
-0.2479983866,
-0.3456655741,
0.6057169437,
-0.5759111047,
1.1677821875,
-0.2118910551,
-0.16618523,
0.092223987,
0.1989231408,
0.4109708667,
0.1849030107,
0.228898719,
0.9297782183,
0.5186930299,
-0.1825845093,
0.8328887224,
-0.2613536716,
0.2988002598,
1.2436486483,
0.0117494538,
0.5903888941,
0.0739740655,
-0.3743296862,
0.5156266093,
0.5198181868,
-0.1765197963,
0.4566096961,
0.4345985353,
-0.2498029917,
-0.2203202546,
0.2600424588,
-0.5282557607,
0.308353126,
0.5776802301,
-0.2277973294,
-0.5754187107,
-0.2121617496,
-0.1110907793,
-0.0143603599,
-0.3999689221,
0.6153256297,
0.1644534171,
-0.5336695313,
0.6325509548,
-0.1418185234,
0.2795604765,
-0.8724444509,
-0.3274402916,
-0.3247630596,
0.2559707761,
-0.1687748432,
-0.6843065619,
0.1124104038,
0.0381541923,
-0.1484548599,
-0.0407567881,
0.3972263634,
-0.6266950369,
-0.5802516937,
-0.1592226177,
0.4115730524,
0.2001934201,
-0.0191281997,
-0.5215128064,
0.0964103341,
-0.0794884861,
-0.1568706483,
0.5449905992,
0.512050271,
0.0056641051,
0.5183234215,
0.8947262764,
0.1612453908,
0.2507194281,
0.1040595695,
1.1019996405,
-0.4893741012,
-0.3888652623,
-0.7896972299,
0.4067269862,
0.093408756,
-0.6728382707,
0.8064164519,
0.7934623361,
1.0496618748,
-0.1486920863,
0.7093326449,
0.3330726027,
0.5107234716,
-0.7249152064,
0.5360996723,
-0.3415231407,
0.2632296085,
0.0705292523,
-1.1099721193,
0.01198183,
0.6520478129,
-0.1935664117,
0.0932859182,
0.7178916335,
0.9398637414,
-0.4397384226,
0.2035596669,
0.3670618832,
0.0404779837,
0.1724984199,
0.6996243596,
0.6480386853,
-0.2973903716,
0.504858911,
-0.0399842374,
-0.4273406267,
-0.088684909,
-0.5902805924,
-1.1869188547,
-0.2823965847,
-0.1069952697,
-0.3117899299,
-0.1129989624,
0.9941746593,
0.5439623594,
-0.7074323893,
-0.3161886334,
-0.4889557958,
0.0981929973,
0.1142932847,
-0.2319652438,
0.1737459153,
-0.5604078174,
-0.6252635717,
0.5235742927,
0.2530331016,
0.0540160909,
-0.6095049381,
-0.299261868,
0.1691965014,
0.1751183569,
0.4776665866,
0.1106971055,
-0.5504308343,
0.1324333549,
0.2128274739,
-0.1458824426,
0.2777905762,
1.0423133373,
-0.5053335428,
0.4334205687,
0.2159314156,
0.6778591275,
0.3486803472,
-0.0558362193,
0.5392403007,
-0.6142997146,
0.1679717898,
0.1841176301,
0.104131259,
0.0707161799,
-0.0799054131,
0.8226490617,
0.1444716752,
-0.6626165509,
-0.7916111946,
0.2334985435,
-0.4944126308,
-0.1323607266,
0.9808488488,
-0.1995259821,
-0.2230072767,
0.182766512,
-0.0721015707,
-0.0505656973,
-0.3107774854,
0.5825072527,
0.7627292871,
0.253837347,
-0.0384129472,
-0.74947685,
0.4456943274,
0.3856219649,
-1.0161443949,
0.1834623814,
0.5973341465,
0.3089321256,
-0.1539966017,
0.325088948,
-0.4666014314,
0.4469828904,
0.2326540053,
-0.1721035689,
-0.6988906264,
-0.4548906088,
-0.4558563232,
0.0818475932,
-0.0148727233,
-0.1691352278
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10175v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10175v2
|
Unlocking Structure Measuring: Introducing PDD, an Automatic Metric for Positional Discourse Coherence
| 2024-02-15T18:23:39 | 2024-04-02T21:51:36 |
Yinhong Liu, Yixuan Su, Ehsan Shareghi, Nigel Collier
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable performance in
aligning generated text with user intentions across various tasks. When it
comes to long-form text generation, there has been a growing interest in
generation from a discourse coherence perspective. However, existing lexical or
semantic metrics such as BLEU, ROUGE, BertScore cannot effectively capture the
discourse coherence. The development of discourse-specific automatic evaluation
methods for assessing the output of LLMs warrants greater focus and
exploration. In this paper, we present a novel automatic metric designed to
quantify the discourse divergence between two long-form articles. Extensive
experiments on three datasets from representative domains demonstrate that our
metric aligns more closely with human preferences and GPT-4 coherence
evaluation, outperforming existing evaluation methods.
|
[
-0.3296112418,
-0.7414366007,
0.7098299265,
0.3308319449,
-0.3769820929,
0.3822044134,
0.0258901026,
-0.2573657334,
0.2055686861,
0.0588849522,
-0.2822249532,
-0.7454416752,
-0.4560240209,
0.1481029987,
-0.327092886,
1.0170558691,
-0.2877010703,
-0.2073108405,
-0.494223088,
-0.0676160902,
-0.1943780482,
-0.3373688757,
-0.5947743654,
-0.3012406528,
0.5944350362,
-0.06951309,
0.7040173411,
0.4937384129,
0.6261555552,
0.3060221076,
-0.1167836785,
0.2335896939,
-0.3750600219,
0.0872724429,
-0.3160934746,
-0.2722021043,
-0.7171145678,
0.0590853803,
0.9541998506,
0.9859002829,
-0.0628254488,
-0.0623454899,
0.4771212041,
0.6746487617,
-0.5209714174,
0.0611089431,
-0.4128037989,
0.1848873347,
-0.4190051258,
-0.1449616849,
-0.3121773899,
-0.5793370008,
0.4331719875,
-0.2605355084,
0.1449789554,
-0.0624900386,
1.0926095247,
0.1775364578,
-0.5766366124,
-0.4848929048,
-0.3708628416,
0.825204134,
-0.6064260602,
0.5306122899,
0.1014213189,
0.1797905117,
-0.222558409,
-0.4121044576,
-0.4617816508,
-0.0238560308,
-0.0002042803,
0.2888365686,
-0.1564615369,
0.1604823023,
-0.1612502187,
0.5211093426,
-0.6611744165,
0.220552668,
-0.1950519681,
-0.2121783793,
0.7949629426,
0.1979037076,
0.4275715053,
-0.3865688443,
-0.4814637303,
-0.0097273914,
-0.7871055007,
0.0696975663,
0.6759997606,
-0.0562231392,
-0.4645189345,
0.6701234579,
0.2677531242,
0.3789047897,
0.3388206959,
-0.2381073982,
0.1122950092,
-0.4854196608,
-0.3125788867,
0.0307014268,
1.0140683651,
0.280949533,
-0.2360774875,
-0.0362169892,
0.0122380666,
-0.0133525562,
0.0748264641,
-0.8035828471,
-0.3647386134,
0.0381193571,
-0.353867054,
-0.2352190614,
0.0585702062,
-0.510936141,
-0.2545973659,
-0.1160853878,
-0.0492868423,
-0.4038684964,
-0.3054251969,
-0.0288667884,
-0.2155990601,
0.5843445659,
0.2739325762,
-0.8473247886,
0.3676061332,
1.0195616484,
1.1521015167,
-1.1569975615,
-0.141417563,
-0.150931865,
0.2280978113,
-0.6937219501,
0.8673293591,
-0.3112680614,
-0.3632080257,
-0.1626241803,
-0.0177209638,
0.0254507679,
-0.5142074823,
0.8310975432,
-0.456456989,
0.4146436453,
-0.1287716329,
-0.7222718596,
-0.059587203,
0.3815646172,
-0.5016133189,
0.9430532455,
0.3287450373,
-0.8423292041,
0.8244045973,
-0.4123603702,
-0.3009089231,
0.1915476024,
-0.4373546839,
-0.956259191,
0.2088611126,
0.0996785462,
0.3451245129,
-0.3357744515,
0.5711844563,
-0.5112900734,
-0.0309812874,
0.1906412393,
-0.6246375442,
0.8974823356,
-0.1455010325,
-0.1343516409,
0.2164364457,
-0.6196416616,
0.0114340642,
-0.257837832,
-0.4662407339,
-0.5525395274,
0.0624001063,
-0.4989603758,
-0.1236865446,
0.2751355767,
-0.4787843525,
-0.1567353904,
-0.9854210615,
0.2953092456,
0.7384919524,
0.1989868581,
0.612264812,
-0.2186688334,
0.5060164928,
0.228979677,
-0.4163130522,
-0.0557909384,
-0.2999979854,
-0.561852634,
-0.5670845509,
0.2992534637,
0.1090732366,
-0.2712074518,
1.0668504238,
-0.4933275282,
-0.4052231908,
-0.4088175893,
0.0006035595,
0.4060884714,
0.3553952277,
0.059161976,
-0.7964264154,
-0.2954809666,
-0.9713749886,
-0.2464405149,
-0.1837747246,
-0.2097203881,
0.3707507551,
0.465772301,
0.0473354869,
1.0247020721,
-0.5242862105,
0.0897643343,
-0.0250565149,
0.2968995869,
0.0773815587,
0.3411987722,
0.5591212511,
-0.3260309398,
-0.6743848324,
0.0422607139,
-0.8762565255,
-0.1397013515,
-0.1075294763,
-0.3990868628,
0.4283798635,
0.1870652437,
-0.6918536425,
0.2810512185,
0.5980712175,
-0.3151422143,
0.6766887307,
-0.1434737444,
-0.0177943353,
-1.1518219709,
0.0007308671,
-0.152152136,
-0.2195697725,
-0.1770782024,
0.0002011058,
0.0817734972,
-0.082141757,
-0.2701163888,
0.4569482505,
-0.9078403115,
-0.5396382809,
0.0911410898,
0.4774180055,
0.4185185134,
0.2489507496,
-0.0418524481,
0.7170177102,
0.3288716972,
-0.418761313,
0.1798894554,
0.1635299474,
-0.5557064414,
0.8446679711,
-0.6691513062,
0.2395620793,
0.0972023234,
0.4829162061,
-1.139949441,
-0.3598497212,
0.0666213781,
-0.1382343173,
0.1039229259,
-0.0581109151,
-0.1808885783,
-0.4800338745,
-0.5847839117,
0.5817183256,
0.204027459,
-0.4456348121,
0.0196152683,
0.5010493994,
-0.547950685,
-0.320063591,
-0.521243751,
0.2619138956,
-0.3286730647,
-0.9126860499,
0.4340187907,
-0.2019911855,
-0.2431774139,
-0.3233910799,
-0.1303221881,
-0.1851361841,
0.0478521325,
0.2255766392,
0.1586298794,
-0.3252151906,
0.0669700205,
0.9951792955,
0.2201402187,
0.4388339221,
-0.3322197795,
0.5740525126,
0.0558366962,
-0.5979777575,
-0.6847329736,
0.2760212123,
0.4099497795,
-0.2000464946,
0.5141564012,
0.1806347668,
-0.1125400811,
-0.3496208191,
-0.1633135229,
0.1787285954,
-0.4580234289,
0.3232596517,
-0.439771533,
-0.6655105948,
0.3756090403,
-0.0780672878,
-0.0570325665,
0.38820678,
0.773514092,
0.0164419562,
1.0010085106,
0.6167370677,
0.1542019844,
0.163502574,
-0.2121338099,
0.3965538442,
-0.7033251524,
-0.1466410905,
-0.2610647082,
-0.2912017107,
-0.428539753,
-0.4147251248,
0.363907069,
0.2473751009,
0.0086099813,
0.142945528,
-0.6278486252,
0.4952817857,
-0.0802958161,
-0.2477707565,
0.3802806735,
0.0790624917,
-0.3797909319,
-0.3944945633,
-0.2593907714,
-0.6653755307,
0.871950984,
0.460857302,
0.465108186,
0.2215863466,
0.9340500236,
0.2825176716,
0.3518483639,
-0.863292098,
0.4762639403,
0.0478849784,
-0.0965782553,
-0.3792714775,
-0.399733603,
-1.1065489054,
0.2189774215,
0.4132806063,
-0.385907203,
0.2911531925,
-0.0365420468,
-0.4137504697,
-0.0776057988,
-0.4392175078,
0.6816443801,
-0.2208364308,
-0.2636157572,
0.0446779281,
-0.3333053887,
0.3980498314,
0.0232906248,
-0.2275919765,
-0.3408837318,
-0.3008787036,
0.7384190559,
-0.274481684,
0.6353253722,
-0.0407149941,
-0.8426942229,
0.2543538213,
0.2285202742,
0.1762998104,
0.1658914983,
-0.2093816102,
0.1457039416,
-0.2590765357,
-0.1822592169,
-0.3994039297,
0.8713268638,
-0.6869847178,
-0.4956054688,
-0.3645687401,
-0.6661291718,
0.012612775,
0.2762035728,
0.2761878669,
0.2116630971,
-0.8690925241,
0.07389649,
0.5272805095,
-0.2200210392,
0.479137212,
0.3678192496,
-0.0715645328,
-0.5222637057,
0.723223269,
0.0782751516,
0.2336664051,
0.4522429109,
0.2645690143,
-0.5141576529,
-0.5814483166,
-0.5654586554,
0.1922524869,
-0.2635608017,
-0.3753940761,
-0.6099485755,
-0.3878663182,
-0.2986481786,
-0.43847844,
-0.148703739,
-0.5556719303,
-0.2940065563,
-0.381188482,
-0.1919716746,
0.4858283997,
0.1720911413,
0.1066199169,
-0.4498468041,
0.0491633527,
0.1744508743,
0.103620328,
-0.1506833434,
-0.3299306035,
-0.0942877978,
0.113692984,
-0.7658376694,
-0.891996026,
0.6569616199,
0.328602165,
0.175244838,
0.6432424784,
-0.0071333773,
0.5531428456,
-0.4536107183,
0.9365141988,
0.5025132895,
-1.0601379871,
0.6350923777,
-0.4400658011,
0.3603412211,
0.1846122742,
0.4539917409,
-0.1460655332,
-0.7336989641,
-0.4020983875,
-0.6838802695,
0.2683989406,
0.153278932,
0.0155195845,
-0.1853314936,
0.3036730886,
0.4360267818,
0.177899316,
-0.6537672281,
0.1127368882,
0.0326202363,
-0.4219844937,
0.1872685254,
-0.140702486,
-0.4987582862,
-0.2058315277,
0.1116468534,
-0.2196633965,
0.1322982609,
0.2263374329,
-0.2329731435,
-0.1292934269,
0.4368484914,
0.5151342154,
0.9054015875,
0.1086959839,
0.4025432169,
0.1364428401,
-0.3976063132,
0.3164114356,
0.0836914629,
-0.4258235395,
0.1206744164,
0.2817547023,
0.6489706039,
0.1186441258,
-0.3235812783,
0.6873956323,
0.0904182643,
-0.3410442472,
-0.2725916803,
0.0309309121,
0.1668853611,
0.0254067443,
0.0856293812,
-0.0950302258,
0.1689263135,
-0.6552208066,
0.3518567681,
0.5822603106,
-0.4731603563,
-0.6999235749,
0.5209668875,
0.4297499657,
-0.4222900271,
0.3030020595,
-0.5751972795,
-0.2133740634,
0.4819757044,
0.6690256596,
1.1777188778,
-0.2147717923,
0.4252696633,
0.2236615419,
-0.076944612,
0.2227080911,
0.1632845402,
-0.3016002476,
-0.6933784485,
-0.4353838861,
-0.8976819515,
-0.2225262523,
-0.1006481126,
-0.7321807146,
0.1296310425,
-0.3152583838,
-0.2219152004,
0.1338200271,
0.3299115002,
-0.2245310545,
-0.2038125396,
-0.2015884221,
0.512566328,
-0.6590582132,
0.7066720128,
0.3537900448,
-0.1784527004,
-0.393994838,
0.2627944648,
-0.0497345328,
-0.3932409883,
0.5200897455,
0.160047099,
-0.3529625833,
-0.21186167,
-0.2889148891,
-0.6782553792,
1.3204613924,
0.6581327319,
-0.6694909334,
-0.3326532543,
0.3268268406,
0.6995524764,
-0.5197076201,
0.0237454306,
0.7746161819,
0.227805987,
-0.3244907558,
-0.8402467966,
0.1245822608,
0.0448566042,
0.0885629728,
0.5966060162,
-0.6098921895,
0.6567574143,
-0.0642462671,
-0.8635022044,
0.3071451485,
0.8400418162,
0.3064506352,
0.4549617469,
0.4334809184,
0.6052291393,
0.8909970522,
-0.0844322145,
0.6961445808,
-0.3627681434,
0.3599316478,
1.1874980927,
-0.4839609563,
0.774271071,
0.2561717927,
-0.2627177536,
0.7962963581,
0.5417364836,
0.0932321772,
0.3633897603,
0.4191912711,
-0.3609459102,
0.0976613015,
0.0208739061,
-0.2811978757,
0.3652213812,
0.4868584573,
-0.5062340498,
-0.1956860125,
-0.2940169275,
0.2587352991,
0.2581549287,
-0.0317498185,
0.9491510391,
0.3482842445,
-1.0222423077,
0.6760495901,
0.0307927914,
0.3657429814,
-0.3154919446,
0.1287908554,
-0.2255855352,
0.2549978495,
-0.1752447337,
-0.971950829,
0.6340742707,
-0.003785664,
-0.0651638806,
-0.2768746316,
0.5608224869,
-0.722160995,
-0.3685338497,
0.4392322302,
0.7194416523,
0.136289373,
0.3383097947,
-0.7323964834,
0.1029328704,
-0.2333049923,
-0.0370041095,
0.273715049,
0.6594097614,
-0.0746853203,
0.3362120688,
0.3990778923,
0.0497081243,
-0.0417842679,
0.1045039222,
0.7426546216,
-0.4403632879,
-0.6165313721,
-0.9519642591,
0.084257789,
-0.4418928325,
-0.5707987547,
0.951117754,
0.9554877877,
0.5961952209,
0.3256284297,
0.6263216734,
0.0832177401,
0.4274947047,
-0.3028919995,
0.9317518473,
-0.203496322,
0.2326743752,
-0.3308884501,
-1.1628724337,
-0.1356022954,
0.4155797064,
-0.4229700267,
-0.3130855262,
0.7738766074,
0.6541674733,
-0.2207829952,
-0.2917902768,
0.2338494062,
0.2539600134,
0.4423399866,
0.2444141805,
0.7224670649,
-0.2121288031,
0.4973263741,
0.1255670637,
-0.2992730737,
0.2201951593,
-0.7940324545,
-0.8940893412,
-0.5438705087,
-0.3460467756,
-0.1632125378,
0.2275433242,
0.3274590969,
0.6302178502,
-0.594676137,
-0.5340246558,
-0.4132690728,
0.2952640057,
-0.1345637739,
-0.3360295892,
0.733733654,
-0.268864274,
-0.7915484905,
0.4721544087,
0.7888868451,
0.1092867777,
-0.7654803395,
-0.1717340201,
-0.0157652404,
0.4551390111,
0.755666554,
0.0218923856,
-0.6054832935,
-0.4314167798,
-0.2632762492,
-0.2840071023,
0.3940410316,
0.7503863573,
-0.4122394919,
0.2268055081,
0.7701043487,
0.4075492024,
0.4250560999,
0.1956186146,
1.0195558071,
-1.0788692236,
-0.086470373,
0.38827613,
0.1530972272,
0.4691319168,
-0.155899018,
0.2669512331,
0.0534015559,
-0.6913207769,
-1.0667667389,
0.4875693321,
-0.8832075,
0.0655457824,
0.6792348623,
-0.5005480051,
-0.2560490668,
-0.2389611602,
-0.0471096747,
0.1872695386,
-0.4774678051,
0.8610479236,
0.6010168195,
-0.1606930941,
-0.0344629101,
0.1030395776,
0.8162806034,
0.2823439538,
-1.181563139,
0.0382789113,
0.4949468374,
0.1104048565,
0.2884109914,
0.7147800326,
-0.2229970396,
0.0844382718,
-0.0992321074,
-0.2889078557,
0.5643900037,
-0.3391728699,
-0.1772334278,
0.3613139689,
-0.0956351608,
0.1085104644
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.