id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07483v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07483v2
|
T-RAG: Lessons from the LLM Trenches
| 2024-02-12T08:45:08 | 2024-06-06T14:42:47 |
Masoomali Fatehkia, Ji Kim Lucas, Sanjay Chawla
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLM) have shown remarkable language capabilities
fueling attempts to integrate them into applications across a wide range of
domains. An important application area is question answering over private
enterprise documents where the main considerations are data security, which
necessitates applications that can be deployed on-prem, limited computational
resources and the need for a robust application that correctly responds to
queries. Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) has emerged as the most prominent
framework for building LLM-based applications. While building a RAG is
relatively straightforward, making it robust and a reliable application
requires extensive customization and relatively deep knowledge of the
application domain. We share our experiences building and deploying an LLM
application for question answering over private organizational documents. Our
application combines the use of RAG with a finetuned open-source LLM.
Additionally, our system, which we call Tree-RAG (T-RAG), uses a tree structure
to represent entity hierarchies within the organization. This is used to
generate a textual description to augment the context when responding to user
queries pertaining to entities within the organization's hierarchy. Our
evaluations, including a Needle in a Haystack test, show that this combination
performs better than a simple RAG or finetuning implementation. Finally, we
share some lessons learned based on our experiences building an LLM application
for real-world use.
|
[
-0.2918124199,
-0.8636611104,
0.7169321775,
0.070201233,
-0.0520533063,
0.6485623717,
0.051697433,
-0.6427903771,
0.0302287787,
0.7656523585,
-0.2298075408,
-0.6293621063,
-0.286475867,
-0.0669339448,
-0.531519413,
1.1155184507,
0.0188578889,
-0.252646476,
-0.2064117342,
-0.2137395144,
-0.3400184512,
-0.5669492483,
-0.8981461525,
-0.2476901859,
0.4340469241,
0.4726923406,
0.5127408504,
0.6962818503,
0.5217644572,
0.2959521711,
-0.2598126233,
0.0943633914,
-0.7098585367,
0.6128750443,
-0.4152974188,
-0.4559167922,
-0.5942334533,
-0.1338572502,
0.4873832464,
0.6165593266,
-0.4223870039,
0.3138948977,
-0.1349827349,
0.659152925,
-0.5772311091,
-0.1549236923,
-0.8947530389,
-0.0856222436,
-0.4462128282,
-0.3587249219,
-0.3100682795,
-0.2926903367,
0.0446079224,
-0.5868787169,
0.1869980395,
0.3807513416,
0.9856676459,
0.0807667822,
-0.4020004869,
-0.608083427,
-0.9456453323,
0.8470429778,
-0.4736924767,
0.3548329771,
0.5843477249,
0.5671635866,
-0.1364111155,
-0.9611191154,
-0.1439937055,
-0.2819512784,
0.0014271374,
0.1290302128,
-0.1475779712,
-0.0751476958,
0.0757992417,
0.69860816,
-0.5622037649,
0.2872189581,
-0.4883132875,
0.1453078687,
0.5247573256,
0.4050321281,
0.0917737409,
-0.0869173035,
-0.385953933,
0.0408971757,
-0.6510392427,
-0.1004121602,
0.1897582114,
0.0503463335,
0.0903828591,
0.7922766805,
0.0843713507,
0.5994032025,
0.0672039762,
-0.2964275777,
-0.1494399607,
-0.0316065811,
-0.3685274124,
-0.2091087699,
0.3505219519,
0.2474163324,
0.2350125462,
-0.5569939613,
-0.5292964578,
-0.1759008914,
0.5265202522,
-0.5298917294,
0.220301941,
0.2620466948,
-0.3541862369,
-0.5493368506,
-0.1887660027,
-0.7796217203,
-0.7652935386,
-0.1250298023,
0.1474398822,
-0.297347039,
-0.176945731,
-0.1092618704,
-0.2652345598,
0.5589824319,
0.4792751968,
-0.5911055803,
0.6349611878,
1.0955045223,
0.7064164877,
-0.1277528703,
0.1777179688,
-0.7939140797,
0.5005530119,
-0.4690461457,
0.6325398088,
-0.4506031573,
-0.5849339366,
0.0897526518,
-0.1494806409,
0.1601647139,
-0.8587037325,
0.6768259406,
-0.862849474,
0.2666720748,
0.3019756973,
-0.6906164885,
0.063862212,
0.5993488431,
-0.4323548079,
0.8730379343,
0.3001684248,
-0.8147961497,
-0.0527788587,
-0.5229750276,
-0.2681701779,
0.3845764399,
-0.352868557,
-0.3940728307,
0.2658478916,
-0.0629203022,
0.3580416739,
-0.4945446849,
0.0333143733,
-0.1892352998,
-0.1412170976,
0.1845311224,
0.1048653871,
0.8712458014,
0.4081362188,
-0.0814935863,
-0.2438689619,
-0.633197844,
0.1270724684,
0.1985863745,
-0.4800125659,
-0.5650846362,
-0.1039347202,
-0.0162077434,
-0.2640601993,
0.320397079,
-0.446785748,
0.1914306581,
-0.4796214998,
0.173708722,
0.7054194808,
0.2259091288,
0.6010172963,
-0.4513052702,
0.8448700309,
-0.1865685582,
0.0575245284,
-0.0367600732,
-0.3704215288,
-0.4706119001,
-0.014180406,
0.216983974,
0.8091546297,
-0.8845401406,
-0.0873628631,
-0.061897926,
-0.5997874737,
-0.466270119,
0.1340174526,
0.3703987002,
0.7231439948,
0.2014430165,
-0.1115138754,
-0.6033872366,
-0.927737534,
-0.2349995673,
-0.3636439443,
-0.2790878415,
0.7626129389,
0.2311120778,
-0.3416727781,
0.8681107759,
-0.6981566548,
-0.4257649481,
-0.1572005004,
0.0738497823,
0.1157949269,
0.1236455366,
0.3171604276,
-0.9014111161,
-0.5187417865,
0.2905880511,
-0.6442001462,
-0.2902010977,
0.1749995351,
-0.2331219912,
0.4672989547,
0.5339939594,
-0.5218156576,
0.2311219424,
0.6393176317,
-0.3260274231,
0.5803275704,
-0.1290951222,
-0.0908143893,
-1.3854908943,
0.3727621734,
-0.3110210001,
-0.4331636727,
-0.6865471601,
0.4276806414,
-0.001324539,
-0.3731336594,
-0.3665677607,
0.7420210242,
-0.4504123926,
-0.4525820315,
-0.0961376429,
0.2634608448,
0.3086527288,
0.0889172927,
-0.2063313574,
1.0547831059,
0.313236028,
-0.6594229937,
0.1762637347,
0.3573632538,
-0.2221960723,
0.5408666134,
-0.6177736521,
0.3657303751,
-0.1274158359,
-0.019306995,
-0.5175444484,
-0.3606978953,
-0.0035186682,
-0.3150725365,
0.5291146636,
-0.3424613476,
-0.4658430815,
-0.2134197056,
-0.3575009108,
0.0586820506,
0.5629509687,
-0.3893409073,
0.6669533253,
0.8071320057,
-0.2572953105,
-0.6863188744,
-0.7368573546,
0.3887508512,
-0.3874985874,
-0.7527225614,
0.3145864308,
-0.0436299592,
-0.6811341047,
0.1022444144,
-0.100263916,
-0.5219338536,
0.3681819439,
0.2132929862,
0.1346387863,
-0.4210292995,
0.1394460201,
-0.2139296085,
0.0280359201,
-0.280413568,
-0.0423125289,
0.3888559639,
-0.3102078438,
-0.1625214368,
0.323715806,
0.5279160738,
0.5397049189,
-0.4708672464,
0.7516054511,
0.2953549027,
-0.2494930476,
-0.2910323143,
-0.7121187449,
0.1509178728,
-0.5294889212,
0.1708406359,
-0.2074720711,
-1.0432076454,
0.4306946099,
-0.2376900613,
0.3435017169,
0.1830316335,
0.3831219673,
-0.364149034,
0.6123585105,
0.9029817581,
0.1241403446,
0.4318633676,
-0.2284172028,
0.1339721382,
-0.868003726,
-0.1252142936,
-0.6695846319,
0.0026061379,
-0.6552903056,
-0.5530202985,
0.6213306189,
0.3733611107,
-0.2142918706,
0.0992677957,
-0.2421716154,
0.4832425416,
0.263386637,
-0.2517671287,
0.5059851408,
-0.0213476457,
0.234686628,
0.1787238419,
-0.5638250709,
-0.8210198879,
0.7081645727,
0.5565809011,
1.0971566439,
0.2956343591,
1.0290218592,
0.0362478271,
0.4405927062,
-0.7164077163,
0.6310960054,
-0.5692325234,
-0.7452382445,
-0.3874561489,
-0.4506322145,
-1.1314567327,
0.0383882485,
-0.0955073535,
-0.701564312,
-0.0479259081,
0.0065964502,
-0.1814818829,
0.3019229472,
-0.7248615623,
0.6197837591,
-0.2941116095,
-0.3231181204,
0.096165441,
-0.3409343958,
0.4592553675,
-0.2417130023,
0.2428738028,
0.1117056236,
-0.5086446404,
0.4184504747,
-0.1253920197,
0.6051884294,
-0.0128076077,
-0.1729930788,
0.3197352886,
0.3268746436,
0.6293183565,
-0.0806292221,
-0.4076686502,
-0.179384008,
-0.061691571,
-0.0779515281,
-0.4790946245,
0.6572076678,
-0.5668984056,
-0.9251515865,
-0.1998821199,
-0.5403811932,
-0.3929992318,
0.282494992,
-0.056136664,
0.4847047627,
-0.3869119883,
0.5707143545,
0.8085832,
-0.5254335403,
0.249372974,
0.7043290138,
-0.585233748,
-0.2805663347,
0.6019336581,
0.2703490853,
0.2521289587,
0.4292066097,
0.2840980589,
-0.1972509027,
-0.5178365707,
-0.4912843406,
0.2996566594,
-0.6155380011,
-0.4702342451,
-0.7400750518,
-0.3018445969,
-0.2586445212,
-0.1480795741,
-0.2141451985,
-0.560803175,
-0.1093210578,
-0.0840672329,
0.4304506481,
1.0212315321,
0.3624702692,
0.0260372683,
-1.0273997784,
0.5103198886,
0.2340105772,
0.6130747795,
-0.0913831145,
-0.2344157994,
-0.3847474158,
-0.2708504796,
-0.3871461451,
-0.932420373,
0.2906109393,
0.2768618762,
0.528521657,
-0.0783322528,
0.1704851389,
0.572435081,
-0.7671552896,
0.7900134921,
-0.3895240128,
-0.5397593379,
0.3748337328,
-0.6259298325,
0.1612615138,
0.520950079,
0.2729894221,
-0.5525107384,
-0.9451444745,
-0.7073763013,
-1.0288058519,
0.7068776488,
0.1747299731,
0.1211374253,
0.1408164203,
0.4780961871,
0.0490133949,
0.2324067205,
-0.3631274998,
-0.2352755368,
0.2327888757,
0.0315637738,
-0.0090803653,
-0.3608861566,
-0.2652958333,
0.2985964119,
0.5698523521,
0.1252628863,
-0.0186146684,
-0.0162763298,
-0.0184081104,
-0.2344919294,
0.5454218984,
0.3756948411,
0.8119988441,
-0.1668941379,
0.1182156727,
0.206587553,
-0.3727324605,
-0.1530005634,
0.0145958886,
-0.2392053306,
0.0784839839,
0.2262001485,
0.4942513704,
0.0692097545,
-0.622959435,
0.3914093375,
-0.1122529581,
-0.1221883222,
-0.4250371754,
-0.0235149972,
0.4244339764,
0.3784692883,
0.5307763219,
-0.4644324481,
0.2284785807,
-0.6205923557,
0.1494550109,
0.4098410606,
0.1157439202,
0.152560398,
0.4425376058,
0.0933696851,
-0.5268223882,
0.3972723186,
-0.0135533093,
-0.4754668176,
0.5754671097,
0.535721004,
1.0750840902,
-0.3042382896,
0.1814587712,
-0.0510310791,
0.2459527552,
0.1598145068,
0.1734495163,
0.0050645429,
-0.3169548213,
-0.3697476089,
-0.8385873437,
-0.7926088572,
0.3408763707,
-0.4615427256,
0.0866760612,
-0.4702807665,
-0.1144302189,
-0.2061910927,
0.1433743685,
-0.4793970585,
0.108332023,
0.0740310103,
1.0876008272,
-0.448687464,
0.585955143,
0.9887638688,
-0.3485827148,
-0.8504266143,
0.0674981177,
-0.3231699765,
-0.7208721638,
0.7175888419,
-0.1103581563,
-0.0920891091,
-0.074581705,
-0.3821668029,
-0.753421545,
1.2733595371,
0.239961192,
-0.466619432,
-0.1479389518,
0.2588929236,
0.8765779734,
-0.2273151577,
-0.1028361395,
0.2802799642,
0.2303573787,
0.0848404989,
-0.9647510648,
-0.2014694065,
0.0376571044,
0.1310479045,
0.2111867815,
-0.3997296989,
0.83135432,
0.0500253551,
-0.4205408394,
0.2087922394,
0.3528498411,
0.4578605294,
0.6362721324,
0.3841367066,
0.5196987391,
0.8183168769,
0.2607891262,
1.338530302,
-0.3660286069,
0.088145256,
1.2779459953,
-0.3077634275,
0.9752432108,
0.5446866751,
0.0802612379,
0.4597699046,
0.3267755508,
0.3074433506,
0.1984169483,
0.1594573855,
-0.3851723671,
0.1653621644,
-0.4112719595,
-0.2893198133,
0.1940138191,
0.4200039506,
-0.35907197,
-0.5040827394,
-0.1196317151,
-0.0998604372,
0.2548721731,
-0.5324109793,
1.0980012417,
0.475599885,
-0.5177915096,
0.3975570202,
0.2091739625,
0.2826592624,
-0.5392404795,
-0.0199480541,
-0.3858553171,
0.2281190604,
-0.2877770364,
-1.1162286997,
0.6900964975,
0.5195423961,
-0.1136508957,
-0.5392113328,
0.9624661207,
-0.4174260497,
-0.0063333199,
0.2997559607,
0.7526445985,
0.2065204382,
0.0709145293,
-0.6617538333,
0.1268416196,
-0.4123704433,
-0.465121448,
0.2874319851,
0.8137462139,
-0.3390080929,
0.7579319477,
0.3697037995,
0.0468141437,
0.1817207932,
0.1789555997,
0.9764358401,
-0.3944078982,
-0.487680167,
-0.5077715516,
0.469245404,
-0.1048146933,
0.1202795282,
0.8613747954,
0.7542365789,
0.6958785057,
-0.0857797563,
0.5396388173,
-0.1252650172,
1.050527215,
-0.3528012335,
0.7446705699,
-0.6286013722,
0.4891628027,
-0.0569417961,
-0.9640106559,
-0.1765251756,
0.2482024729,
-0.4075478315,
-0.0671283677,
0.4835155308,
0.8830616474,
-0.1225499287,
-0.3153420687,
0.4565331638,
0.3612160981,
0.4522688389,
0.1884430349,
0.9841338992,
-0.2847564816,
0.8483626246,
-0.1179226711,
-0.047054626,
-0.1291935742,
-0.9392123222,
-0.6811748743,
-0.4520148933,
-0.1042839512,
-0.4924075603,
0.269510746,
0.5616958141,
0.464630127,
-0.5828929543,
-0.4625923038,
-0.0153657002,
0.2080906928,
0.4631257951,
-0.2809734941,
-0.0018279725,
-0.5550581217,
-0.5092918277,
0.4618582129,
0.291863054,
0.0382481404,
-0.2437547296,
-0.120673582,
-0.2509458959,
-0.004246911,
0.5700037479,
0.4379682541,
-0.3966841698,
-0.1552000195,
0.1686472595,
-0.4907281101,
-0.0506099537,
0.7875425816,
-0.6040392518,
0.2426312566,
0.5275685191,
1.1728343964,
0.6817331314,
0.258323133,
0.6755515933,
-1.0642926693,
-0.2312242985,
0.658539772,
0.0069205235,
0.5697952509,
-0.4714880884,
0.8353594542,
-0.244349733,
-0.7790473104,
-1.0375007391,
0.2729164362,
-0.7817471623,
-0.2636165023,
1.1626412868,
-0.0550574735,
-0.3926057518,
-0.4149225652,
-0.363594979,
0.0770037025,
-0.244645521,
0.6545308828,
0.5085235238,
0.0015748297,
-0.2663407028,
-0.7743762732,
0.4874433279,
0.0863100439,
-0.8707303405,
0.2018255144,
0.3821324408,
0.2548437715,
0.2249720246,
0.8561818004,
-0.1831988096,
0.0537827164,
-0.2018203884,
-0.2566659749,
-0.1873627454,
-0.2404568344,
-0.3024454415,
0.3078897893,
0.5222267509,
-0.0535171889
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07470v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07470v2
|
Pushing The Limit of LLM Capacity for Text Classification
| 2024-02-12T08:14:03 | 2024-02-16T15:59:27 |
Yazhou Zhang, Mengyao Wang, Chenyu Ren, Qiuchi Li, Prayag Tiwari, Benyou Wang, Jing Qin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The value of text classification's future research has encountered challenges
and uncertainties, due to the extraordinary efficacy demonstrated by large
language models (LLMs) across numerous downstream NLP tasks. In this era of
open-ended language modeling, where task boundaries are gradually fading, an
urgent question emerges: have we made significant advances in text
classification under the full benefit of LLMs? To answer this question, we
propose RGPT, an adaptive boosting framework tailored to produce a specialized
text classification LLM by recurrently ensembling a pool of strong base
learners. The base learners are constructed by adaptively adjusting the
distribution of training samples and iteratively fine-tuning LLMs with them.
Such base learners are then ensembled to be a specialized text classification
LLM, by recurrently incorporating the historical predictions from the previous
learners. Through a comprehensive empirical comparison, we show that RGPT
significantly outperforms 8 SOTA PLMs and 7 SOTA LLMs on four benchmarks by
1.36% on average. Further evaluation experiments show a clear surpassing of
RGPT over human classification.
|
[
-0.3314481974,
-0.5714208484,
0.3931998909,
0.1625879556,
-0.2195604593,
0.3641210794,
-0.5373267531,
-0.6303627491,
-0.1316504031,
0.5589806437,
-0.4352728426,
-0.2885712981,
-0.757897675,
0.1936889291,
-0.4620602429,
1.4798152447,
-0.0509384684,
-0.3151889741,
-0.0238769986,
-0.2660419643,
-0.7271885872,
-0.6027723551,
-0.5952816606,
-0.4572201967,
0.5327531099,
0.4908978641,
0.4310052693,
0.7333398461,
0.4358936846,
0.1933447272,
-0.1248544455,
0.1699414849,
-0.4890961647,
0.3399716616,
-0.2124014199,
-0.510114491,
-0.5675395131,
-0.0209917054,
0.8235055208,
0.3486109972,
-0.1487428993,
-0.0755511671,
0.3999283016,
0.6085082293,
-0.451225698,
0.0304783154,
-0.7630901933,
-0.0004662275,
-0.1195901632,
-0.529410243,
-0.7295231223,
-0.0024801281,
0.1369464546,
-0.1971480846,
0.4814772606,
-0.0352441184,
0.5147355795,
0.3574900031,
-0.2158223242,
-0.1222004071,
-0.5175604224,
0.7625891566,
-0.2627905905,
0.4598630369,
-0.0103599718,
0.1215515286,
-0.0765572786,
-0.8961974382,
-0.259875387,
-0.2003372163,
0.2006900311,
0.0950832665,
-0.149075821,
-0.0567180552,
0.1438451707,
0.4335648417,
-0.5945085287,
0.3154264688,
-0.3677285016,
0.0533067696,
0.4929434955,
0.0732497051,
0.408190906,
0.1175220162,
-0.7491843104,
-0.0663999096,
-0.593095839,
-0.2231695205,
-0.0820195302,
0.4128127694,
0.2337121516,
0.3733219802,
0.0131607074,
0.6825585961,
-0.0000163741,
0.0328466967,
0.1409971565,
-0.1292585582,
-0.3243407607,
0.1690502465,
0.6772817373,
0.4076811075,
0.3079159558,
-0.1549042165,
-0.1078323573,
-0.053468693,
0.3704800308,
-0.9039852619,
-0.0611426719,
-0.034020815,
-0.1423721611,
-0.1489938945,
-0.0580770038,
-0.8630741835,
-0.4453638494,
0.130871892,
0.1943965256,
-0.3224155009,
-0.2420677394,
0.2500503361,
-0.0213382561,
0.0524464138,
0.3837784827,
-1.2274105549,
0.2682073414,
0.8735426664,
1.0837304592,
-0.6761332154,
-0.5750311613,
-0.2052046061,
-0.2329498082,
-0.2039966881,
0.9198445678,
-0.487542361,
-0.2981613278,
-0.0256192461,
0.001173279,
-0.1759019345,
-0.4640773535,
0.9378182292,
-0.6147156954,
0.0421933271,
0.1213653609,
-0.5621823072,
-0.0906998664,
0.452974081,
-0.3982224464,
1.1110378504,
0.2323125452,
-0.8025541306,
0.6247606874,
-0.210774675,
-0.299942255,
0.3902757466,
-0.0093055721,
-0.4873453975,
0.1118185669,
0.1449115872,
0.6903968453,
-0.3216617703,
0.2649341226,
0.0412722938,
-0.3689736724,
0.2332382351,
-0.6264026165,
0.4276821911,
0.0213194098,
-0.2000743747,
0.1844386011,
-0.620087564,
0.1547257751,
-0.1924170107,
-0.9181722403,
-0.2276313305,
-0.0380668715,
0.2065880299,
-0.0261567254,
0.0731639192,
-0.4712237418,
0.4738504589,
-0.3429671824,
0.7494397163,
0.8335572481,
-0.1820358336,
0.5150167942,
-0.4915997684,
0.760735333,
-0.5406273603,
-0.4531540275,
-0.3734832406,
-0.6762186885,
-0.8994246721,
-0.3752654493,
0.4089948237,
0.6634730697,
-0.3037264049,
0.6785042882,
-0.7562019229,
-0.5541519523,
-0.0819006637,
0.0581855401,
0.0310231689,
0.3396572173,
0.549798727,
-0.2536675334,
-0.5323987603,
-0.5986222029,
-0.5147286654,
-0.2347273231,
-0.0657019764,
0.1413000226,
0.4070480466,
-0.4012408257,
0.8774598837,
-0.2856966257,
-0.2918110192,
-0.6546251774,
0.0949448273,
0.0871021897,
0.4446632266,
0.4987559021,
-0.642533958,
-0.6812150478,
0.2586453259,
-0.3990038931,
-0.2325935066,
-0.2998341322,
0.2217252105,
0.1972744018,
0.4863802493,
-0.443362087,
0.1053963974,
0.46649912,
-0.2313631475,
0.3275736868,
-0.2771216035,
-0.0254859067,
-0.8639264703,
-0.301117301,
-0.0355681144,
-0.5339016318,
-0.6848105192,
0.0692903772,
0.3253577352,
-0.0343779139,
-0.0862146318,
0.5573881865,
-0.1989555359,
0.0298047625,
-0.5957949758,
0.0251061469,
-0.4419614375,
0.3577741385,
0.3285044134,
0.7902411819,
0.5121286511,
-0.6937018037,
0.2814093232,
0.0550871752,
-0.4019396007,
0.2958739996,
-0.3015187085,
0.1372046024,
-0.0635649934,
0.5583454967,
-0.8730499148,
-0.2431501448,
-0.0007707426,
-0.4297546148,
0.4626338184,
-0.1481084377,
-0.2535212636,
-0.2245962769,
-0.0682655722,
0.3980335891,
0.6490849853,
-0.7456444502,
0.6136749983,
0.1578813046,
-0.4150623679,
-0.6563236713,
-0.9175823927,
0.2725586593,
-0.266028434,
-0.4517916143,
0.4941264689,
0.1617705077,
0.2269857377,
-0.1116741821,
-0.158421278,
-0.0614231192,
0.0603336468,
0.0833178312,
0.1105658188,
-0.1383244097,
0.4598188102,
-0.1707132161,
-0.2974396348,
-0.1502481401,
-0.645444572,
0.5361091495,
-0.2352858335,
-0.1043015197,
-0.1048983037,
0.0970781595,
0.5599829555,
-0.0139944004,
0.4948650599,
0.6449098587,
-0.158823818,
-0.6790120006,
-0.4728443325,
-0.0163397286,
-0.4438393712,
0.8884797692,
-0.2363831401,
-1.2846956253,
0.112145409,
0.0833118707,
0.3783349395,
0.4623992443,
0.6377648115,
0.2453042716,
0.6997935772,
0.7890943885,
-0.1466521621,
0.6437171698,
0.0146649983,
-0.1057884097,
-0.6163772941,
0.0375989452,
-0.4323891699,
-0.2308494598,
-0.8899416924,
-0.5500524044,
0.230395332,
0.1052719653,
-0.2247379422,
0.3408592641,
-0.7304634452,
0.5729978085,
0.3738690317,
0.2470120192,
0.3905760646,
0.1734313667,
0.4045642316,
-0.0954443067,
-0.8658719063,
-0.4125138819,
1.0342615843,
0.6778698564,
0.7642914653,
-0.031113511,
0.5826379061,
0.4066311419,
0.9628813267,
-1.0001204014,
0.5736435652,
-0.2990967035,
-0.5764610171,
-0.2192416936,
-0.4904998243,
-0.7570250034,
0.4039599001,
-0.2027118653,
-0.4339883327,
0.0276012141,
0.0747016296,
-0.1347225904,
0.4726160765,
-0.5258970261,
0.6777609587,
-0.2437125444,
-0.2945729494,
-0.117119655,
-0.2949569523,
0.2559385598,
-0.2683970034,
0.0473996475,
-0.0096789803,
-0.4429104626,
0.8680642247,
-0.2058447748,
0.8514958024,
0.0731241852,
-0.0446848236,
0.3729792237,
-0.1041269451,
0.514220655,
-0.1432401687,
0.0412599854,
-0.1259314865,
-0.364569366,
-0.5233408809,
-0.5259958506,
0.6516510248,
-0.5183472633,
-0.704412818,
-0.6339378953,
-0.3972289562,
-0.3862254918,
0.1743456572,
0.3554747999,
0.1667517126,
-0.1670135558,
0.5615898967,
0.6699188352,
-0.1159942895,
0.3697818518,
0.2259969264,
-0.1743880659,
-0.5376123786,
0.9861899614,
-0.0262222197,
0.4287513793,
0.5885505676,
0.3871588707,
-0.3371734619,
-0.9239090681,
-0.6229211688,
-0.0542659014,
-0.8296580911,
-0.3079972863,
-0.8190755248,
-0.174097389,
-0.1648378521,
-0.2913977206,
-0.1937168837,
-0.3372706771,
-0.3052974641,
-0.4390125573,
0.4140877724,
0.7823935151,
0.1548923254,
0.3365003169,
-0.8636829853,
-0.2381577641,
0.5400958061,
0.3489055932,
-0.0693439394,
-0.9155427814,
-0.0911570117,
-0.4612399042,
-0.2753275335,
-0.7163307071,
0.4807143807,
0.3448741734,
0.368944943,
-0.0553040914,
-0.0129011441,
0.3913381994,
-0.5876700282,
0.6774426699,
0.3511835635,
-0.648031354,
0.2057511955,
-0.4518372416,
0.1639719158,
0.4772265851,
0.2762879729,
-0.5191829205,
-0.2443640828,
-0.5087609291,
-0.8130030036,
0.6119648814,
-0.0394450985,
0.3883166909,
0.0908171907,
0.620813787,
0.1029403582,
-0.1247334629,
-1.1465702057,
0.1226489395,
-0.2277431339,
-0.3423214853,
-0.2265272588,
-0.4230456352,
0.3609246314,
0.0463837609,
0.5995388627,
-0.2578522563,
0.0165004041,
0.2825701833,
-0.0445433632,
0.0242417064,
0.6727460027,
0.5541367531,
0.5323308706,
-0.1633672118,
0.2397825718,
0.6631564498,
-0.6966463327,
0.276055485,
-0.061171256,
-0.1650101542,
-0.2789824903,
0.6409589052,
0.7121505737,
0.1864514947,
-0.8335891962,
0.3557535708,
0.0196024906,
-0.3039690256,
0.0959655493,
0.269546181,
-0.0076166927,
0.1471440941,
0.6262117624,
0.1935765594,
-0.2677550912,
-0.6045982242,
0.3992317915,
0.2385646403,
-0.6569049358,
-0.083759211,
0.4187371731,
0.378408134,
-0.337959379,
0.2813408375,
-0.0543412827,
-0.9448300004,
0.4132266939,
0.7436514497,
0.9620942473,
-0.2089098543,
-0.1316380203,
0.356028527,
0.4353836775,
-0.5056661367,
-0.178995356,
-0.1014849693,
-0.8420066237,
-0.5122356415,
-0.8279786706,
-0.4397110343,
0.1984631866,
-0.3935202956,
0.1902181357,
-0.5969172716,
-0.1369132698,
-0.2077382505,
-0.012098412,
-0.1374519318,
0.2560251355,
-0.1295563728,
1.1235584021,
-0.783559978,
0.7677071691,
0.6932640672,
-0.0792593434,
-0.2416711003,
0.1801198572,
-0.4573868513,
-0.6221193075,
0.8201278448,
0.4156439304,
-0.200818181,
0.2164636403,
-0.4200161994,
-0.3813515306,
0.8823629022,
0.1454751492,
-0.551722765,
-0.081735529,
-0.1485219747,
0.613008678,
-0.4975416958,
-0.1316834837,
0.4479326904,
0.2998657227,
-0.1128722578,
-0.8756323457,
0.0070738057,
0.0353387073,
-0.1729071885,
0.2558683753,
-0.5097519755,
0.7999269962,
-0.1115070581,
-0.469494909,
0.1289399266,
0.7637895942,
0.2160786986,
0.0885664746,
0.6702228189,
0.5675391555,
0.6360139847,
-0.1556110233,
1.014272809,
0.1273200214,
0.460967809,
0.9787346721,
0.0052626864,
1.0237941742,
0.0163394958,
-0.3719286621,
0.3412175477,
0.6939742565,
-0.0810110793,
0.2054346353,
0.1086728349,
-0.4736495018,
-0.5744147897,
0.048405204,
-0.4187552631,
0.2587053776,
0.4186907411,
-0.4285185337,
-0.1102903187,
0.1289199442,
-0.2356277704,
0.2205259204,
-0.5576527715,
0.6461386085,
0.0413453877,
-0.8458445668,
0.5614714622,
0.1214692742,
1.0611978769,
-0.3980044723,
0.2142457515,
0.0666866004,
0.5369628668,
-0.2555096745,
-0.976954639,
0.1662406772,
0.2521339655,
-0.1793498695,
-0.590913415,
1.0625919104,
-0.378478229,
-0.4123649001,
0.2542654872,
0.4146441519,
-0.0111455917,
-0.0556900389,
-0.4802073538,
-0.1708190739,
0.1146737486,
-0.1654001623,
0.5787665248,
0.4526878595,
0.0080682943,
0.8955010772,
0.5905795097,
0.1151571795,
0.1059696227,
-0.172690466,
0.7633055449,
-0.7631578445,
-0.6517906785,
-0.9954372048,
0.0305576809,
0.1508533806,
-0.3360877633,
0.6144858003,
0.4672216773,
0.8219230175,
0.0318878666,
1.0181703568,
0.1315697283,
0.6783772111,
-0.4966697395,
0.4385494292,
-0.4591002762,
0.1980527788,
0.1117974967,
-0.7740991712,
-0.5216251016,
0.6262673736,
-0.1449140757,
0.2378352284,
0.5086742043,
0.3723365366,
-0.0203798544,
0.2056828886,
0.2761125863,
0.0359187126,
0.3380242288,
0.5967124104,
1.0418915749,
-0.1810293943,
0.8099426627,
0.1110710725,
-0.5429034829,
-0.3118105829,
-0.9501591921,
-1.0642665625,
-0.3176158965,
-0.1762325168,
-0.3376550078,
0.137919724,
0.959785223,
0.6354632378,
-0.7752915621,
-0.031311091,
-0.6737814546,
0.0746741295,
-0.2410039455,
-0.2401759028,
0.3343193531,
-0.5874743462,
-0.8369586468,
0.3889422715,
0.3483611941,
0.1512720734,
-0.2694341242,
-0.007522271,
0.0102825081,
-0.2916835248,
0.5568186641,
0.4362840354,
-0.4961308539,
-0.274895221,
-0.0309054796,
-0.1407830864,
0.1526377052,
1.0179543495,
-0.7583645582,
0.1605819166,
0.7438394427,
1.1214420795,
0.4970118403,
0.1611589342,
0.5979940891,
-0.832434833,
-0.0853048414,
0.4332666695,
0.1826091856,
0.2254167944,
-0.1820445657,
0.564401269,
0.2850928307,
-0.8150986433,
-0.9733777046,
0.2907837629,
-0.9755407572,
-0.3005815744,
1.1908704042,
-0.1584381461,
0.0040771016,
-0.2552251816,
-0.2443494946,
-0.0316648819,
-0.3840488791,
0.5108950734,
0.6795861125,
-0.2201331407,
-0.4382915795,
-0.618016541,
0.5720356703,
0.4561892152,
-0.7504115701,
0.5991434455,
0.1886513382,
0.3289647102,
0.3041078746,
0.7116714716,
0.2123994976,
0.2254231721,
-0.1585641056,
-0.2636499107,
0.0088794632,
-0.4130278826,
-0.3777228594,
0.458062768,
0.1512922496,
0.1052231491
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07448v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07448v1
|
AraSpider: Democratizing Arabic-to-SQL
| 2024-02-12T07:11:13 | 2024-02-12T07:11:13 |
Ahmed Heakl, Youssef Mohamed, Ahmed B. Zaky
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
This study presents AraSpider, the first Arabic version of the Spider
dataset, aimed at improving natural language processing (NLP) in the
Arabic-speaking community. Four multilingual translation models were tested for
their effectiveness in translating English to Arabic. Additionally, two models
were assessed for their ability to generate SQL queries from Arabic text. The
results showed that using back translation significantly improved the
performance of both ChatGPT 3.5 and SQLCoder models, which are considered top
performers on the Spider dataset. Notably, ChatGPT 3.5 demonstrated
high-quality translation, while SQLCoder excelled in text-to-SQL tasks. The
study underscores the importance of incorporating contextual schema and
employing back translation strategies to enhance model performance in Arabic
NLP tasks. Moreover, the provision of detailed methodologies for
reproducibility and translation of the dataset into other languages highlights
the research's commitment to promoting transparency and collaborative knowledge
sharing in the field. Overall, these contributions advance NLP research,
empower Arabic-speaking researchers, and enrich the global discourse on
language comprehension and database interrogation.
|
[
-0.4291819334,
-0.5330330133,
0.1365004331,
0.176141113,
-0.3278637826,
0.3011307418,
-0.1382267028,
-0.6538588405,
0.4100297391,
0.7817654014,
-0.0663604289,
-0.7991602421,
-0.9938241243,
0.3604014516,
-1.0041505098,
1.3655622005,
0.0295028165,
0.1263107359,
0.2396275848,
-0.4926199019,
0.0698821321,
-0.7052707076,
-0.4645853639,
0.0935772806,
0.4909162223,
0.3835304379,
1.2790837288,
0.3828561902,
0.4204888344,
0.2685910463,
-0.1155645549,
0.2712548971,
-0.0722764358,
0.2327041626,
-0.306268096,
-0.3516407609,
-0.4465521872,
-0.2509670556,
0.6721950769,
0.8075969815,
-0.5628474355,
0.3833008111,
0.0181290563,
1.1902599335,
-0.8355464935,
-0.0283721965,
-0.3929731548,
0.0131429695,
-0.4236257672,
0.2614335418,
-0.4105925858,
-0.4433555901,
-0.1719366759,
-0.3582836092,
0.0879824013,
0.0855456889,
0.5427669883,
0.1121305376,
-0.8001924753,
-0.3565004766,
-0.841165483,
0.5680196285,
-0.5971878767,
0.4564316571,
0.5461648107,
0.5955050588,
-0.1773763001,
-0.9983613491,
-0.561543107,
-0.0434888974,
-0.0497692674,
-0.0945552811,
-0.5125044584,
-0.3998297155,
-0.2654512525,
0.3507869244,
-0.5382623076,
-0.2868850231,
-0.3978169858,
-0.0930258334,
0.6735605001,
0.0174104795,
0.4995371997,
0.0121977264,
-0.0494410843,
-0.0960354581,
-0.6530316472,
-0.2099284679,
0.2815279365,
0.5016440749,
-0.2400119901,
0.8527927399,
-0.1887064874,
0.690007627,
-0.3568986654,
0.2532206178,
0.0148813846,
-0.4254976511,
0.0689981803,
0.2361874282,
0.512806356,
0.2181307524,
0.2031100988,
-0.3896811604,
-0.1127630323,
-0.1389250904,
0.3537884653,
-0.772982657,
-0.1317209452,
0.3148110807,
-0.4702280164,
0.0495316386,
-0.2499995828,
-0.8619037867,
-0.540999949,
-0.1482599676,
0.2065238357,
-0.4268678725,
-0.5017459393,
0.2442698479,
0.0800823867,
-0.0455828346,
0.3845099509,
-0.6797421575,
0.9083340764,
0.6912032366,
1.1106516123,
-0.3303137124,
-0.1892010123,
-0.3440483809,
0.3724915683,
-0.7340165377,
0.7727476358,
-0.4381521344,
-0.166037187,
0.1319080591,
-0.2411562353,
0.0204269476,
-0.4457808435,
0.6329120994,
-0.7696245313,
0.1240803227,
0.2279083282,
-0.365365833,
-0.5035542846,
0.0465020277,
-0.8698044419,
0.7949849367,
0.1525994539,
-0.8508123159,
0.3115984201,
-0.8227290511,
-0.4224992692,
0.0343556367,
-0.0238829833,
-0.4777695835,
0.1221266091,
0.4813423157,
0.0828913227,
-0.4222335219,
0.1197042242,
0.0763532594,
-0.2949519753,
0.2495265007,
0.0511865616,
0.7406699657,
0.3537682891,
-0.1912654936,
0.0307197608,
-0.6103243232,
-0.075985834,
-0.0328815468,
-0.0739626959,
-0.051991649,
0.2479322702,
0.4258090556,
0.2398171425,
0.1208165362,
-0.4536660314,
0.1241002306,
-0.7637684941,
0.2490603924,
0.4640560746,
-0.1097174734,
0.5990880132,
-0.2261962593,
0.6706264019,
0.0852202475,
-0.0201450512,
0.1540183127,
-0.4416992664,
-0.8175008893,
-0.2420368046,
0.5470137596,
0.5028359294,
-0.7721603513,
0.0396360755,
-0.2173858285,
-0.8704628348,
-0.6809322834,
-0.0844150409,
0.1748207957,
0.0835022405,
0.5489630103,
-0.5240193605,
-0.6099981666,
-1.1317715645,
-0.5910384655,
0.0222627856,
0.2210818231,
0.4175441861,
0.6938823462,
-0.2389823049,
0.7886674404,
-0.2521068454,
-0.522388041,
-0.4846759439,
0.0452428311,
0.622688055,
0.5087071657,
0.5281046629,
-0.79953897,
-0.8578622937,
0.1989273131,
-0.4087790549,
0.2596895397,
0.4642809331,
-0.1768005788,
0.7613583207,
-0.0067936359,
-0.7630902529,
0.7968398333,
0.883572638,
-0.4648351669,
0.6654254794,
0.0930326506,
0.5337885022,
-1.2972770929,
0.3405068219,
-0.2606252432,
-0.2503625154,
-0.5638035536,
0.267605871,
-0.2364798784,
-0.4854674637,
-0.4985695183,
0.5345565081,
-0.4382982552,
-0.3479650319,
-0.2730948925,
-0.0207801871,
-0.2052611262,
0.0766351968,
-0.0417925753,
1.4873628616,
0.5915772915,
-0.638004005,
0.1048737839,
0.584626615,
-0.5577788353,
0.107840158,
-0.7465927601,
0.3342017829,
0.0981133953,
0.2877136171,
-0.8616343737,
-0.2963222265,
0.3544920683,
-0.6919668913,
-0.08438427,
-0.5061499476,
-0.7669148445,
0.196555391,
0.0568894222,
0.2125420719,
0.37619102,
-0.3015021086,
0.7213311195,
0.6612322927,
-0.5110692978,
-0.7141595483,
-0.6421778202,
0.7055464387,
-0.0620223023,
-0.5674895048,
0.3491340578,
0.3789042532,
-0.2694252729,
-0.2619361281,
-0.0764488503,
-0.5148504972,
0.0642615482,
0.0867116973,
-0.0259926263,
-0.041382093,
0.1596259624,
0.1285658479,
-0.1847372204,
-0.0164108369,
-0.2678995132,
0.6698176265,
0.0218835026,
-0.2687221766,
-0.2669219375,
0.8685384989,
0.1622254848,
-0.5496102571,
1.3548130989,
0.5571213365,
-0.1036411449,
-0.1152806878,
-0.1752507538,
-0.2257319093,
-0.3951597512,
0.4247531295,
-0.3571211994,
-0.852428019,
0.3065928817,
-0.2915048301,
0.1593104452,
0.3811336458,
0.5356894135,
-0.0530982614,
1.5774543285,
0.9600656033,
-0.1531621665,
0.1087047309,
-0.1637393236,
0.3306497633,
-0.6125636101,
0.0631103814,
-1.0979787111,
-0.1556409597,
-0.7189339995,
-0.299241513,
0.4710536301,
0.1527772695,
-0.3468096256,
0.4381501973,
-0.7335845828,
0.3386366665,
0.2682597935,
0.0363902859,
0.3782316148,
0.5058104396,
0.1164017171,
-0.2287455499,
-0.5687591434,
-0.9566000104,
1.1060535908,
-0.1184223294,
0.3230646253,
0.9200904369,
0.7580612898,
0.7480039001,
0.1337629855,
-0.2773291767,
0.5197484493,
-0.1776873171,
-0.7985362411,
-0.1044605821,
-0.1413495839,
-1.240929842,
0.2828818262,
-0.1186699495,
-0.8578941226,
0.0784744546,
0.0345153846,
0.2137134075,
0.1266337186,
-0.290771544,
0.7288250923,
0.1440928131,
-0.4478738308,
-0.7226189375,
-0.5047510266,
0.0519068837,
0.0348466039,
0.4930478036,
-0.0863045529,
-0.4588049054,
0.8004620671,
-0.2327571213,
0.6387870908,
-0.0843207687,
-0.0030757056,
0.0681464374,
0.545584321,
0.4450522065,
0.0218861122,
-0.5510094762,
0.4537537098,
0.0728560686,
-0.6275132895,
-0.4638806581,
0.26347664,
-0.9856572151,
-0.6874088049,
-0.7314681411,
-0.4034241736,
-0.0882808417,
0.1425032616,
-0.1433285475,
0.0905680507,
-0.1712908149,
0.2638258636,
0.0576519109,
-0.0536488332,
0.119105421,
0.768208921,
-0.7029095292,
-0.5500220656,
0.6534919143,
0.1148573011,
-0.0996516198,
0.0474706516,
-0.3191555738,
-0.1900361776,
-0.703856051,
-0.841378212,
-0.0307676885,
-0.6971381307,
-0.1735056341,
-0.7853386402,
-0.2095208168,
-0.4574690461,
0.102415368,
-0.4851646125,
-1.0101401806,
-0.011080673,
0.1859776825,
0.6182487011,
0.7422765493,
-0.0216435473,
0.2819288373,
-0.9132638574,
0.090067707,
-0.3649961054,
0.1452896744,
-0.185935244,
-0.5700067282,
-0.6066852808,
0.0591764376,
-0.1851962805,
-1.1392612457,
0.7970506549,
0.4537471235,
0.2366005778,
-0.3718252182,
0.0050668796,
0.496555686,
-0.6462715268,
0.9653124809,
-0.0821353793,
-1.0558998585,
0.6863746047,
-0.1939137727,
0.1225648597,
0.4946570396,
0.6923716664,
-0.6982548237,
-0.3061313927,
-0.4831375778,
-1.0694993734,
0.6929496527,
0.5766422749,
0.144026503,
0.0895419195,
0.1648652852,
0.2961950898,
0.447710216,
-0.456248641,
-0.3447349668,
-0.1404434443,
-0.0743732303,
-0.3048830032,
-0.1941836327,
-0.1551605463,
-0.2279455811,
0.7581658363,
-0.1738949865,
0.0885196477,
0.1575277746,
-0.3493431807,
0.1047366485,
0.5218129158,
0.3071730435,
0.8864280581,
0.0765859932,
0.0525130183,
0.1042564064,
-0.455377847,
0.234917298,
0.2863625288,
-0.3204140663,
0.127826646,
0.3662745953,
0.3678407371,
-0.2143766284,
-0.539560318,
0.2825556099,
-0.1047874764,
0.2928218246,
-0.5236460567,
0.079597421,
0.0588604622,
0.1125010177,
0.5582774878,
0.3369550407,
0.7653316855,
-0.2846641243,
0.3720786572,
0.1236267239,
-0.3563434184,
-0.1762740165,
0.4279456139,
0.0844291225,
-0.5391796231,
0.7120178938,
0.138199389,
-0.5157212019,
0.4366528988,
0.6159570217,
0.6337585449,
-0.2500360906,
0.3497076035,
0.4774931073,
0.1755071729,
0.3875416517,
0.3224464953,
-0.3431811631,
-0.6331849098,
-0.538395226,
-0.5607457161,
-0.6374653578,
-0.6656550169,
-0.7543581128,
-0.007080215,
-0.142819196,
-0.2923089862,
0.0444100946,
0.1892578602,
-0.3061404824,
-0.086530827,
-0.318734169,
1.0884509087,
-0.6749465466,
0.9905350208,
0.9616963863,
-0.6140485406,
-0.398409456,
-0.296618253,
-0.1365818977,
-0.5571385026,
0.7447321415,
-0.0080695171,
-0.223333627,
0.2379151583,
-0.755304873,
-1.0089331865,
0.6358278394,
0.4280827343,
-0.2783133686,
0.349634856,
0.5689806938,
0.5171818137,
-0.2610014975,
0.3292685449,
0.5204377174,
0.3693276048,
-0.290166229,
-0.8441642523,
-0.2148851156,
-0.498719871,
-0.0087542906,
0.4606443644,
-0.4346411824,
0.8733001947,
-0.0037386999,
-0.3853871822,
0.2843953073,
0.9104565978,
0.3900349736,
-0.0013640434,
0.2395615727,
0.4305088818,
0.3543974161,
0.0942011923,
1.1606503725,
-0.6182786822,
0.1098098829,
1.0533230305,
-0.5187554359,
1.0942913294,
0.6758054495,
-0.3545841873,
0.8444242477,
0.2967389226,
0.326821208,
0.5420805812,
-0.0118606705,
-0.571808815,
-0.1694390178,
-0.5106672049,
-0.4837495089,
0.6209130883,
0.3343455493,
-0.1613604277,
-0.391854018,
-0.0330288224,
0.1559906453,
0.6440497041,
0.0366436206,
1.0283044577,
-0.0087297,
-0.5686638951,
0.4818602502,
0.3046790063,
0.1732450575,
-0.5460059047,
-0.5239481926,
-0.3726304471,
0.3016847968,
-0.2539082766,
-0.9310955405,
0.7380813956,
0.1094452217,
-0.0903262272,
0.0878761411,
0.6512809992,
-0.2035423815,
-0.5843119621,
0.3720677793,
0.5156461596,
0.5908747911,
-0.1362219602,
-0.8954446912,
0.2787153125,
-0.0236369409,
-0.1737196147,
0.3435471952,
0.2494517416,
-0.0495953001,
0.8431792259,
0.7879903316,
0.3121634126,
-0.1756719947,
-0.0520303473,
0.8129103184,
-0.5796090961,
-0.3382635415,
-0.7817507386,
0.5176992416,
-0.2747476697,
-0.2195146382,
1.0265917778,
0.9283261299,
0.4318318963,
0.0018535109,
0.4960129261,
-0.1432774961,
0.9309684634,
-0.3027038574,
1.0747523308,
-0.4243174195,
0.0868147314,
-0.0540727302,
-0.8498620391,
-0.2961711287,
0.5504794717,
0.0060332669,
0.0516796522,
0.3042210937,
0.9112331867,
0.0950790122,
0.1313725412,
0.0784572586,
0.1840371639,
0.2631629705,
0.30021137,
0.610214293,
-0.7831668854,
0.4775020182,
-0.2315065712,
0.0165412538,
0.00324599,
-0.6036832333,
-0.6132389903,
-0.7307667136,
-0.1237391308,
-0.5923731327,
0.6388241649,
0.8973783255,
0.7599822879,
-1.039460063,
-0.6804544926,
-0.1432492286,
0.0400624163,
-0.3632089794,
-0.112454012,
0.6648262143,
-0.1873583794,
-0.5965979695,
0.3426013887,
0.2285479903,
-0.2817898989,
-0.1370940059,
-0.1339705288,
-0.5391911864,
-0.0065765991,
0.6015482545,
0.0213771239,
-0.528768003,
0.0396585278,
-0.3356173933,
-0.1984708458,
0.1095825806,
0.3463767171,
-0.9424353242,
0.0972896293,
0.0483282208,
0.5892418027,
0.7833560705,
-0.1966248751,
0.7423585057,
-0.6171811819,
0.4305374026,
0.581887126,
0.1034603044,
0.4096461535,
-0.1163647473,
0.9297214746,
-0.3781756163,
-0.5942258239,
-0.7768465281,
0.3495108187,
-0.4566985071,
-0.2533562481,
0.733171761,
-0.0376614295,
-0.2588855922,
-0.3956589401,
-0.4079982638,
0.3475297093,
-0.452031374,
0.9405834079,
0.6121287942,
0.0613117293,
-0.5328578353,
-0.5743995905,
0.551194489,
0.5897772908,
-0.8088180423,
-0.0580650195,
0.3916434348,
-0.1201206297,
0.142834872,
0.4480770528,
-0.1867238581,
0.5790121555,
-0.0322943106,
0.3989703655,
0.2112543136,
-0.255028218,
-0.1543097943,
0.238348648,
0.3094542623,
0.1468437165
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07446v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07446v3
|
Quality Does Matter: A Detailed Look at the Quality and Utility of Web-Mined Parallel Corpora
| 2024-02-12T07:03:14 | 2024-06-14T08:50:53 |
Surangika Ranathunga, Nisansa de Silva, Menan Velayuthan, Aloka Fernando, Charitha Rathnayake
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We conducted a detailed analysis on the quality of web-mined corpora for two
low-resource languages (making three language pairs, English-Sinhala,
English-Tamil and Sinhala-Tamil). We ranked each corpus according to a
similarity measure and carried out an intrinsic and extrinsic evaluation on
different portions of this ranked corpus. We show that there are significant
quality differences between different portions of web-mined corpora and that
the quality varies across languages and datasets. We also show that, for some
web-mined datasets, Neural Machine Translation (NMT) models trained with their
highest-ranked 25k portion can be on par with human-curated datasets.
|
[
-0.3080136478,
-0.2727097571,
0.3749624789,
0.2435123026,
-0.3378949165,
0.2943779826,
-0.4447964132,
-0.5968449712,
0.2007061094,
0.3260070384,
-0.1035482958,
-0.4258215129,
-0.6717705131,
0.5105707049,
-0.6448372006,
0.9290338755,
-0.0543990694,
0.3284672201,
-0.4553548396,
-0.2683568001,
-0.2627523243,
-0.4990007281,
-0.6033954024,
-0.0356934369,
0.6273148656,
0.2813639939,
1.151954174,
0.9611741304,
0.9548942447,
0.3196775615,
-0.0924272165,
0.1642416567,
-0.5707764626,
0.0663728341,
-0.6963781714,
-0.6633267403,
-0.2243417799,
0.2432732135,
0.4677913189,
1.0071692467,
0.0633696094,
0.5023726225,
0.2352866828,
0.703535974,
-0.3032397628,
0.1085175723,
-0.5718693733,
-0.0674400851,
-0.3609201014,
-0.1814868003,
-0.1030916199,
-0.4767580628,
-0.079881303,
-0.6160811186,
0.4519000351,
0.2057932317,
1.0403751135,
0.3931008875,
-0.3111259341,
-0.3032852411,
-0.4867960811,
1.1924854517,
-0.6447064877,
0.3277289271,
0.6025425196,
0.1664401442,
0.17323035,
-0.6348487735,
-0.3904814124,
-0.0762225389,
-0.2738737166,
0.108070679,
-0.1122059152,
-0.0987760499,
0.0612737983,
0.6981594563,
-0.7596931458,
0.3078353405,
-0.7322944403,
-0.3911102414,
0.3103045225,
0.2510534525,
0.5806433558,
-0.2040057033,
-0.2445446104,
-0.4968309402,
-0.7151086926,
0.0171182696,
0.8586829305,
0.4370509982,
0.0285017919,
0.6459725499,
-0.2184230387,
0.7615570426,
-0.2844351232,
-0.1653839946,
0.0999090895,
-0.6656396985,
-0.2101681083,
-0.0485494398,
0.8543155193,
0.3712317646,
0.2234300524,
-0.3425787091,
-0.2109683901,
0.2914324701,
0.4235785007,
-0.7520667315,
-0.0302851386,
0.3013584912,
-0.8141282797,
-0.2669904828,
0.0478339791,
-0.3936992288,
-0.1938487291,
-0.7537751794,
0.2791491449,
-0.3974063694,
-0.6038472652,
-0.0760372877,
-0.300614804,
0.008723936,
0.0358128734,
-0.8407802582,
0.4066551924,
0.9257351756,
0.9189597964,
-0.6094262004,
-0.4411525726,
-0.2900215089,
-0.4691815972,
-0.5589184165,
0.8555313945,
-0.4460394084,
0.0202311445,
0.0464102775,
-0.2277457118,
0.0003600684,
-0.9050599933,
0.5142533779,
-0.6671481729,
0.0381053314,
-0.4578188658,
-0.3797110021,
-0.2032818049,
0.2734462321,
-0.7919567823,
0.6883291006,
0.3679333031,
-0.804489255,
0.441133827,
-0.2612493336,
-0.4211895764,
0.0239184406,
-0.1214332208,
0.0976696834,
0.3117362261,
-0.0766369551,
0.4608695507,
-0.6510151029,
0.1357184201,
-0.2300677896,
-0.4089472592,
0.5429449677,
-0.3826460242,
0.6984125376,
0.5596082807,
-0.1913298219,
-0.0392555483,
-0.8586974144,
0.2968971729,
-0.2343857139,
-0.3198419213,
-0.4579552114,
-0.1243045703,
0.3552999198,
0.4735795557,
0.3074724972,
-0.637757659,
-0.2046962529,
-0.3410214782,
0.5672290325,
0.5176439285,
-0.3335179389,
0.3668822348,
-0.1678273678,
0.434386462,
0.0579154082,
0.1275033951,
0.4292690456,
-0.3299975693,
-0.8120679855,
-0.0520015135,
0.7452072501,
0.3893286586,
-0.5487562418,
0.0380085781,
-0.4135282636,
-0.421117574,
-0.9841935635,
0.1667696238,
0.5717559457,
0.2104641497,
0.417452246,
-0.6254304051,
-0.3147394359,
-1.1695811749,
-0.2857157588,
-0.0712520853,
-0.0048411754,
0.093996644,
0.0486143306,
0.0258874595,
0.9775915742,
-0.2427005619,
-0.1397815794,
0.0031873069,
0.3371162415,
0.1930530518,
0.2979715466,
0.5280944705,
-0.9532864094,
-0.5993448496,
0.0358514786,
-0.8595659733,
-0.2429202199,
0.1226159558,
-0.3373162746,
0.0698518902,
0.4662048817,
-0.2912859619,
0.1131140813,
0.8249033093,
-0.1805011779,
0.3478434682,
-0.2702661455,
0.3888706267,
-1.075263381,
0.1914695352,
-0.3430604637,
-0.3228828609,
-0.3890184164,
0.220730558,
0.1600356549,
-0.0816483423,
-0.6299658418,
0.286316067,
-0.2874938548,
-0.563814044,
-0.4980840385,
0.0911025926,
0.1082298905,
0.2801554501,
-0.0588896684,
1.0381882191,
0.2273875326,
-0.6007809043,
0.2331709564,
0.0304939784,
-0.4184333384,
0.7196564674,
-0.5514863729,
0.0447659977,
0.2158904076,
-0.3815689981,
-0.709209621,
-0.0489373021,
-0.3416220844,
-0.5880147219,
0.1711203754,
-0.0572449155,
-0.7265945077,
0.0002766533,
-0.0984529629,
0.2322995663,
0.1937876791,
-0.4532691538,
-0.106683813,
0.4543452263,
-0.1655296236,
-0.6332136989,
-0.9328163862,
0.1778962612,
-0.0974270552,
-0.5359352827,
0.499661535,
-0.1423701495,
-0.4722267687,
0.5085170269,
0.1237050593,
-0.4086078703,
0.1954961568,
0.3357900083,
0.0182537939,
-0.3279549181,
0.0227885563,
0.1467372626,
-0.1146878675,
-0.0049070553,
-0.2686125636,
0.7537685633,
-0.3122791648,
-0.2855447829,
-0.2594058216,
0.3690026999,
0.5767305493,
-0.1485364437,
0.8865075707,
0.9275452495,
-0.2984808683,
0.3043670654,
-0.5220351815,
-0.0242483784,
-0.4220359325,
0.1901372671,
-0.4038433135,
-0.9159906507,
0.4432745576,
0.2936719358,
0.0036166343,
0.8850715756,
0.6114938259,
-0.1606402248,
0.8863420486,
0.5858759284,
-0.1224544048,
0.2085242718,
-0.3177486956,
0.0795366764,
-0.711247921,
0.0478390716,
-0.5142323375,
-0.3581633866,
-1.1046221256,
-0.2253896594,
0.1185553148,
0.350897491,
-0.2647125125,
0.6700800657,
-0.5703612566,
0.4199645519,
0.9205889702,
0.0029820139,
0.3823327124,
0.2111775279,
-0.1834472865,
-0.0648744702,
-0.4436980784,
-0.7246832252,
1.1371352673,
0.0554042645,
0.2709060609,
0.3818475306,
0.7320397496,
0.4180024862,
0.0860287324,
-0.5549370646,
0.2107318044,
-0.4627061486,
-0.5573627353,
-0.2260220349,
-0.5949588418,
-1.1696193218,
0.2515035868,
-0.0019579439,
-0.1399923265,
0.3161918223,
-0.1163004413,
-0.428304553,
0.3653241396,
-0.7797157168,
0.6811844707,
-0.3761833608,
-0.5296978951,
-0.7138030529,
-0.3266783655,
0.1490133256,
-0.0424586087,
0.1707423329,
-0.3015802205,
-0.0291539263,
0.8080867529,
-0.4767439663,
0.4442210197,
0.2711103857,
0.3357453346,
0.3525081575,
0.2635773122,
-0.1479469091,
0.1123797446,
-0.2525169849,
0.5896480083,
0.2736280859,
-0.712890625,
-0.261972487,
0.9858404994,
-1.0772510767,
-0.4706184864,
-0.4367820919,
-0.3971323073,
0.0409217328,
0.3031227589,
0.4526750147,
0.3122999072,
-0.1526966691,
0.2834700942,
0.3578427434,
-0.3687094152,
0.49630481,
0.3344379663,
0.1658673137,
-0.5206262469,
1.1551784277,
0.2929556072,
0.396428287,
0.4201746881,
0.188538745,
-0.1936430484,
-0.4351504147,
-0.7885431647,
0.0229527317,
-0.6152198911,
-0.4172610343,
-0.6755124927,
-0.1660820693,
-0.4044498503,
0.0318960436,
-0.598040998,
-0.5291298628,
-0.3864031434,
0.0435467958,
0.3996879756,
0.9556033611,
-0.3429399431,
-0.0571087152,
-0.9782480597,
0.2101860344,
0.3351390958,
0.4154160321,
-0.1079661474,
-0.3983520269,
-0.4560070336,
-0.0286621843,
-0.0722067952,
-0.6561818719,
0.6052348018,
-0.1905641407,
0.5547567606,
0.2083007693,
-0.2416768968,
0.5629582405,
-0.2559063733,
0.8628510237,
0.1670029759,
-0.7563580275,
0.1599416137,
-0.2673332691,
0.1322710216,
0.9673248529,
0.4955211282,
-0.6585380435,
-0.1273174733,
-0.5030745268,
-0.8122115731,
0.6199624538,
0.5094398856,
0.1150898933,
-0.2018217742,
0.0804768652,
0.252745688,
0.361166656,
-0.4551553428,
-0.3622404933,
-0.2526438832,
-0.2404773682,
0.0645436272,
-0.331402123,
0.0650538802,
0.0048921034,
0.3310839534,
0.1578593105,
0.3279560208,
0.0225165021,
-0.4938516319,
-0.0286457054,
0.3931568265,
0.4938775599,
0.8601057529,
-0.3571581244,
0.2620766759,
0.0400762782,
-0.6476703882,
0.0402432308,
-0.0406509936,
0.0450952314,
0.074503988,
0.1944683343,
0.7173476219,
-0.0558813699,
-0.5137574077,
0.3648683429,
-0.1370003074,
0.1843472123,
-0.1085237265,
-0.1483771503,
0.1616586596,
0.0278818514,
0.192950964,
0.2595655322,
0.336445272,
-0.6615649462,
-0.0533511229,
0.0447461717,
-0.3385460079,
-0.3293668628,
0.348454982,
0.1698737293,
-0.2520131171,
0.9678955078,
-0.5078585744,
-0.6069899201,
0.6256085634,
0.334258914,
0.5403439999,
-0.0426446311,
0.1914724559,
0.5163982511,
0.4425554872,
-0.3061431944,
0.1825854331,
0.0699476078,
-0.5409051776,
-0.5753591061,
-0.9132730961,
-0.692391336,
0.1043104157,
-0.8319911957,
0.008870705,
-0.1140208319,
-0.2096178979,
-0.1248451397,
0.150786534,
-1.137209177,
0.3066905141,
0.1255681962,
0.4375250936,
-0.8205885887,
0.6623030305,
0.4875352085,
-0.7320011258,
-0.5802566409,
-0.25642398,
-0.230137974,
-0.4615164995,
1.0113954544,
0.0514631458,
-0.0054451213,
-0.1338674426,
-0.1114671603,
-1.5462622643,
1.0291771889,
0.518018961,
-0.4801301062,
0.3996486962,
0.5603682399,
0.8013427258,
-0.0786680281,
0.5393316746,
0.3967275918,
0.2581189573,
-0.6265969872,
-1.2285946608,
-0.2567162216,
-0.2574413717,
0.1093607843,
0.0413775444,
-0.7316204906,
1.0390638113,
0.2746116221,
-0.3904528618,
-0.2741060853,
0.6655333042,
-0.0268079787,
0.0162472762,
0.4631228745,
0.5301499963,
0.7285190225,
-0.0010443794,
1.2524808645,
-0.5153528452,
0.2043358237,
1.0186738968,
-0.0341717936,
1.0664268732,
0.3032260239,
-0.2888852358,
0.4448578358,
0.8712287545,
0.1639665961,
0.3798847795,
0.3338563144,
0.1248290539,
-0.2801508307,
-0.3477568924,
-0.3104421794,
0.4952175319,
0.3004819155,
-0.5485903025,
-0.0493996516,
-0.0347057283,
-0.0705759376,
0.3875308931,
-0.216838479,
0.4514615238,
0.2111411989,
-0.8285932541,
0.5912679434,
0.376408428,
0.8252213597,
0.0183707345,
0.0918122828,
-0.4681760669,
-0.0244805738,
-0.3198253512,
-0.9368240237,
0.5723169446,
0.1660785377,
-0.4642470777,
-0.4017785788,
0.5501974821,
-0.4054812491,
-0.4419694245,
0.3902639747,
0.653878212,
0.5645654798,
-0.3471499383,
-0.646115005,
0.1108024195,
-0.2884342968,
-0.1092726737,
0.6347463131,
0.1138185859,
-0.1231223047,
0.2972435951,
0.9573825002,
0.2052336186,
0.1830186993,
0.3271425366,
0.5981190801,
-0.6550381184,
-0.2041338533,
-0.645999074,
-0.0738814771,
-0.3946873844,
-0.395632565,
0.5973747373,
0.9408640265,
1.2241784334,
0.0141702741,
0.6014727354,
0.0503915586,
0.6553941965,
-0.3906737864,
0.8220525384,
-0.4497817457,
-0.028499214,
0.041011408,
-1.0507160425,
-0.2176940739,
0.5574936271,
-0.0703809634,
-0.3229320645,
0.9435301423,
0.7608573437,
-0.1964294612,
-0.3174290061,
0.6915509105,
-0.020703068,
-0.0390529148,
0.3553169966,
0.7229706049,
-0.5909895897,
0.8053347468,
-0.3608257174,
0.1260810941,
0.0029424524,
-0.6965387464,
-0.6197109222,
-0.719288826,
-0.2788453698,
-0.4556569159,
-0.0317139663,
1.1273566484,
0.5719184875,
-0.9179661274,
-0.4202727675,
-0.0625188723,
0.0630166382,
-0.4761044085,
-0.1929446608,
0.5862268209,
-0.5826632977,
-0.9967608452,
0.4193068445,
0.3327078819,
-0.2396519035,
-0.5226330161,
0.0843782872,
-0.0224492606,
-0.1938932687,
0.6916038394,
-0.0645123571,
-0.7082558274,
0.0047567445,
0.1922292709,
-0.7378716469,
0.2889425755,
0.8968026638,
-0.6329365373,
0.3800830543,
0.9016276002,
0.6215046048,
0.4092794359,
-0.1503340155,
0.4583067596,
-0.5600435138,
0.0136082564,
0.0948055163,
0.4015675187,
0.7396363616,
-0.3587556183,
0.686380744,
0.0938309282,
-0.4715082943,
-0.6317760348,
-0.0542635545,
-0.9596109986,
-0.2546404004,
1.416790843,
-0.2173772901,
-0.3431513906,
-0.2968344092,
0.0989204347,
0.4710904062,
-0.1538545042,
0.6808442473,
0.7737765908,
0.1410896033,
0.1973056048,
-0.7605958581,
0.5269898772,
0.5444449186,
-0.6478160024,
-0.2839497626,
0.1852563471,
0.4314624667,
0.4247155786,
0.3666875958,
-0.2698727846,
0.1331525743,
0.0048380573,
0.199329406,
-0.025003653,
-0.1363062859,
-0.2289324552,
0.2410026789,
0.2685369253,
-0.1993485242
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07432v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07432v1
|
Intrinsic Task-based Evaluation for Referring Expression Generation
| 2024-02-12T06:21:35 | 2024-02-12T06:21:35 |
Guanyi Chen, Fahime Same, Kees van Deemter
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recently, a human evaluation study of Referring Expression Generation (REG)
models had an unexpected conclusion: on \textsc{webnlg}, Referring Expressions
(REs) generated by the state-of-the-art neural models were not only
indistinguishable from the REs in \textsc{webnlg} but also from the REs
generated by a simple rule-based system. Here, we argue that this limitation
could stem from the use of a purely ratings-based human evaluation (which is a
common practice in Natural Language Generation). To investigate these issues,
we propose an intrinsic task-based evaluation for REG models, in which, in
addition to rating the quality of REs, participants were asked to accomplish
two meta-level tasks. One of these tasks concerns the referential success of
each RE; the other task asks participants to suggest a better alternative for
each RE. The outcomes suggest that, in comparison to previous evaluations, the
new evaluation protocol assesses the performance of each REG model more
comprehensively and makes the participants' ratings more reliable and
discriminable.
|
[
0.0260191914,
-0.4166040123,
0.5327882767,
0.2576287687,
-0.4345883131,
-0.2334903032,
-0.2281196117,
-0.6898105741,
-0.0180344824,
0.195743382,
-0.6464338303,
-0.2014911622,
-0.5117248297,
0.6483232975,
-0.4638793766,
1.0682450533,
0.2420925349,
0.1960351318,
-0.6249004602,
0.0071974592,
-0.656011641,
-0.3565483391,
-0.5312415957,
-0.6115026474,
0.4604630768,
0.1847220212,
0.3510804474,
0.3454804122,
0.997351408,
0.2492907643,
0.19062756,
0.3240595758,
-0.3648785949,
0.2165057659,
-0.3373759091,
-0.3510598838,
-0.5569475293,
0.1833497286,
0.4593090713,
0.616099596,
-0.1238642335,
0.6030392051,
0.1106632128,
0.7576019168,
-0.6251253486,
0.0265533049,
-0.714522481,
-0.0294688921,
0.0916998833,
-0.3298184574,
-0.6545938253,
-0.4354048371,
0.1911240965,
-0.2406853437,
0.4592752457,
0.0044590686,
0.9029403329,
0.1648405939,
-0.2724538445,
-0.2842023671,
-0.76720649,
0.552516222,
-0.856423378,
0.2179644704,
0.2460814416,
0.1345815361,
0.1682241708,
-0.8708284497,
-0.6031826735,
-0.8200930953,
-0.1109137312,
0.0831889212,
-0.5526441336,
-0.1071304381,
0.3665598035,
0.119912833,
-0.4597437084,
-0.2841952741,
-0.1746262163,
-0.0004167383,
0.4844190776,
0.3095828295,
0.0590801202,
-0.4872705638,
-0.2967714965,
0.2171687186,
-0.9135269523,
-0.0354940221,
0.2829225659,
0.4952737987,
0.3314861953,
0.5133000016,
-0.4585349262,
0.9307690263,
0.5528357625,
0.1339170039,
0.1670703739,
-0.4268517196,
0.0087903719,
-0.3068397939,
0.8588343263,
0.5871629715,
0.5048266649,
-0.4502758384,
-0.3922151923,
0.2503274977,
0.6879774928,
-0.6404078603,
0.0130947977,
-0.2477737516,
-0.6912417412,
-0.2150167674,
0.3841454387,
-0.305455327,
-0.0831141621,
-0.351952821,
0.4281950295,
-0.2471263558,
-0.2115077078,
-0.0722409487,
-0.190579623,
-0.1744612008,
0.2558917701,
-0.4572543502,
0.4907114506,
0.6135961413,
0.6184790134,
-0.3427941203,
-0.1660082042,
-0.7013872266,
-0.068155013,
-0.148425281,
0.9956726432,
-0.8506168723,
-0.4662256837,
-0.1320073009,
-0.2379996181,
-0.0662553161,
-0.8576993346,
0.7058776021,
-0.4657911062,
0.2063903809,
-0.2818996906,
-0.3821282089,
-0.0592850409,
0.0722128227,
-0.4790667892,
1.0316408873,
0.2233354598,
-0.5967097878,
0.4593112171,
-0.8888067603,
-0.5042665601,
0.0957602486,
0.1672775745,
-0.1425396502,
0.5362998247,
-0.2366819382,
0.3823105991,
-0.6843179464,
0.3497499824,
-0.0809364319,
-0.2439738363,
0.4723059535,
-0.2643536329,
0.3592971265,
0.1011687666,
-0.5669080019,
0.2959660292,
-0.6509551406,
0.1336309016,
-0.1613672227,
-0.2369273752,
-0.2877256572,
0.1837236434,
-0.2857623994,
0.49174577,
0.1463187486,
-0.6751766801,
-0.0633369908,
-0.0176056959,
0.2727520466,
0.7296002507,
0.1249487326,
0.2203603536,
-0.6576786041,
0.5037246943,
-0.1523417979,
-0.0631008521,
0.1535275877,
-0.7668557763,
-0.8405205011,
0.2609521747,
0.320857197,
0.2671939433,
-0.648404479,
0.5918810368,
-0.6183075905,
-0.6409246922,
-0.4051474035,
-0.1020961553,
0.6825382113,
0.9807140827,
0.3704977334,
-0.5270135999,
-0.3569683135,
-1.0967186689,
-0.4122656882,
-0.4861239195,
-0.2007412612,
0.3773861229,
0.527771771,
-0.0316676386,
1.1443648338,
-0.3965376318,
-0.0567315817,
-0.2575904429,
0.5898663402,
0.0677944422,
0.4359790683,
0.2823733091,
-0.6183994412,
-0.6579626799,
-0.1177675873,
-0.4265797436,
-0.5506908298,
-0.2124019563,
0.0380596407,
-0.1576936096,
0.1479116082,
-0.6284179688,
0.3285409808,
0.1721662879,
-0.3736639619,
1.0229820013,
0.0722051114,
0.2584237754,
-0.6767154932,
0.5840150118,
0.3970267773,
-0.5309079885,
-0.6249294877,
0.2823492587,
0.0513908565,
-0.1359180659,
-0.3522400558,
0.6328018904,
-0.35960114,
-0.0278786831,
-0.4878139794,
0.0176452398,
-0.0753449872,
0.6477684975,
0.1416842341,
0.7648143768,
0.4384561777,
-0.6790932417,
0.3486899436,
0.1543713063,
-0.3416290283,
0.6034160852,
-0.7709677815,
0.4451415241,
-0.0129336677,
0.3180550039,
-0.846103251,
0.0413167328,
0.3144636154,
-0.6908388138,
0.1254086047,
0.2089950144,
-0.3062843382,
-0.3634284735,
-0.2364276052,
0.2844769657,
0.6483450532,
-0.1726981848,
0.4926068187,
-0.0022292146,
-0.1816691458,
-0.4539569318,
-0.4328972697,
0.3017421067,
-0.0957533419,
-0.621250689,
0.4712440073,
0.0272142403,
-0.1688107401,
0.3508889377,
-0.2717704475,
-0.0998791456,
-0.0142941382,
0.2016860098,
0.1269446909,
-0.2236979902,
-0.0954805315,
-0.2281739563,
-0.0884722769,
0.3127172291,
-0.0277353954,
0.2675563395,
-0.1539627463,
-0.4553774595,
-0.7283828259,
0.4573723376,
0.3329571187,
-0.3833510876,
0.1399309188,
0.3979277015,
-0.2741444111,
-0.1199442297,
-0.5372874141,
-0.3184763491,
-0.4301720262,
0.37665236,
-0.2383823693,
-0.7007899284,
0.2398933768,
-0.0838537738,
0.1121607274,
0.6793619394,
0.5891966224,
0.0117292404,
0.9020348191,
0.4263286591,
0.5554677248,
0.4777825177,
0.1230808124,
0.1624144763,
-1.1652910709,
-0.2173811495,
-0.7081775665,
-0.4914218783,
-0.2233490199,
-0.519908309,
0.3446028829,
-0.0532456264,
0.1126688495,
0.5906897187,
-0.662989974,
-0.0203234758,
0.7633259892,
0.3222984672,
0.2821342349,
-0.0201143995,
-0.1791476309,
0.1141669005,
-0.6535791159,
-0.759360671,
1.103248477,
0.1778174788,
0.5775660276,
0.0619555637,
0.5743704438,
0.6635001302,
0.9739302993,
-0.7091907859,
0.9018885493,
-0.2907147706,
-0.5702387691,
-0.128036961,
-0.6973992586,
-0.9540829659,
0.0856096223,
-0.256926775,
-0.7310047746,
0.1183408797,
0.1300934404,
-0.5318375826,
-0.0633359477,
-0.6018775702,
0.6388770938,
-0.0911574438,
-0.4319947958,
-0.4576638937,
-0.6017661691,
0.3353717327,
-0.0670929551,
-0.2492463887,
-0.1184879318,
0.1396370083,
0.9573305249,
-0.2474738508,
0.8343538046,
-0.2315347046,
0.1204102486,
0.7273733616,
0.0860885009,
0.4982633889,
-0.2081676722,
-0.3380736709,
0.0038023165,
-0.3690048158,
0.0039699464,
-0.8146258593,
0.5061032176,
-0.3168900013,
-0.8330290914,
-0.359492749,
-0.1914473921,
-0.4269940853,
0.0489756986,
0.1288749129,
0.5611706376,
-0.2580168843,
0.2640057802,
0.1731257737,
-0.0205938648,
0.3479517698,
0.8189848065,
0.1882030368,
-0.2900416553,
1.0342992544,
-0.3928237855,
0.3548882008,
0.5864412189,
0.3671039343,
-0.460155189,
-0.4937202334,
-0.2966424823,
0.158371076,
-0.4338141978,
-0.5307132602,
-0.3760023117,
0.1684504598,
-0.4361762404,
0.3870785236,
0.0078964541,
-0.5158265233,
-0.3320337832,
0.0370533466,
-0.3017378449,
0.796115756,
-0.1585466862,
0.1588790864,
-1.1795948744,
0.4789803028,
0.5710823536,
0.2383281738,
0.2159081995,
-0.5816683769,
-0.2987359166,
0.2523950636,
-0.6685863137,
-0.9317753315,
0.0251637045,
0.4522172511,
0.5992964506,
0.4243772924,
-0.0279286299,
0.5444102883,
-0.8771260381,
0.8549268842,
0.5144604445,
-0.9750562906,
0.3206948638,
-0.2506945431,
0.1760050952,
0.5303195119,
0.1772768348,
-0.6443343759,
-0.480678916,
-0.7038078308,
-0.481264323,
0.7166458368,
0.4171473384,
0.3520655036,
-0.6086346507,
0.4732120931,
0.1196001396,
0.3357081711,
-0.8684642315,
-0.154880017,
-0.0703716204,
0.0365405716,
0.4878204167,
-0.2744636834,
0.0405027457,
0.0027633333,
0.549325943,
-0.1437406391,
0.6950931549,
0.3960320055,
-0.1263034642,
-0.5562652946,
0.0996634215,
0.7844667435,
0.848768115,
-0.1514656395,
-0.0689449683,
-0.117156662,
-0.2731904089,
0.1312440634,
-0.1785159558,
-0.0091664167,
0.274487108,
0.7225610018,
0.8572474122,
0.099388808,
-0.7165341377,
0.5894461274,
-0.0055673751,
-0.0634497032,
0.2522670031,
0.2038096189,
-0.0964936242,
-0.1945659667,
0.696741581,
0.5454244614,
0.2649643421,
-0.5484904647,
0.5341460705,
0.5417223573,
-0.5856305957,
-0.6157881021,
0.5917761922,
0.8061423302,
-0.7117223144,
0.678121984,
-0.2195268571,
-0.5054664016,
0.6274892688,
0.5802897811,
1.4092537165,
-0.2454730868,
0.2009424567,
0.5947834253,
0.2468570173,
-0.0025776466,
0.133282885,
-0.019816231,
-0.6407232881,
-0.6836454272,
-0.6231530905,
-0.2244629711,
-0.1873164028,
-0.8344534636,
0.0079323696,
-0.1716961712,
-0.5780793428,
-0.1206065118,
-0.4193016291,
-0.6639183164,
0.3905974329,
0.0107285865,
0.908274889,
-0.7661539316,
0.560259223,
1.0262864828,
-0.2960315049,
-0.4996826649,
0.3003465235,
-0.4703381956,
-0.6543262005,
1.155580163,
0.2069108039,
-0.2530480325,
-0.2569964528,
-0.0907761753,
-0.5258404613,
0.6734422445,
0.3517569602,
-0.4534845054,
-0.3463372588,
-0.0099692615,
0.7691216469,
-0.5002086759,
0.4167492986,
0.1018165424,
0.4882139862,
-0.1387649775,
-1.2557361126,
0.304925859,
-0.5024369359,
-0.1431982368,
0.1070569977,
-0.528393209,
0.6443642378,
-0.1972538978,
-0.5453705192,
0.188152954,
0.8725246787,
-0.0591346584,
-0.0343675241,
0.7448638082,
0.4494790733,
0.3798592389,
0.0000868775,
1.183942914,
-0.5100203156,
0.3751378953,
1.221513629,
-0.3678439856,
0.8884673119,
0.3537310958,
-0.2897027135,
0.7436704636,
0.3730826974,
0.0452603698,
0.5186471939,
0.3772903979,
-0.3561569154,
-0.5133262277,
-0.401918143,
-0.118228212,
0.4050160348,
-0.006237213,
-0.3686678112,
-0.6359618902,
-0.4309341908,
-0.6285303831,
0.1911139488,
-0.1260832399,
0.7142480612,
-0.0325530507,
-0.9984050393,
0.4429875314,
0.2524221539,
0.5492528081,
-0.7904531956,
-0.4762739539,
-0.0445140041,
-0.3241084814,
-0.1535709649,
-0.6357760429,
0.4332488477,
0.3303865194,
-0.1981853247,
-0.454998374,
0.7555646896,
-0.0905436873,
-0.4739864469,
-0.0809122249,
0.6512266397,
-0.0304595102,
-0.1529972255,
-0.8004908562,
-0.4853544533,
0.1564901769,
-0.283875823,
0.1982099712,
0.3504340947,
-0.0181183107,
0.8583704233,
0.7349893451,
0.1199911013,
-0.0672874227,
0.021824751,
0.7096161842,
-0.5878605843,
-0.3040306568,
-0.7899149656,
0.5894765854,
-0.0694582015,
-0.6781553626,
0.5729748607,
0.478840977,
0.4325369298,
-0.2900543213,
0.7146667838,
-0.3587460518,
0.71304214,
-0.2606801093,
0.377347827,
-0.4491358101,
0.0900384486,
-0.5208064914,
-1.1698937416,
-0.1328578293,
0.6863703132,
-0.1357406229,
0.2131809741,
1.0442569256,
0.597086072,
0.0635572001,
-0.2586716115,
0.2700192928,
-0.0725086108,
0.3162307143,
0.625688076,
1.0093799829,
-0.2187070101,
0.442679435,
-0.0583908632,
-0.3078355491,
-0.1263361722,
-1.1876351833,
-0.6555992961,
-0.6114938259,
-0.4856341481,
-0.1973650753,
0.0167209655,
0.9851281047,
0.5830231905,
-0.6580944061,
-0.3734773695,
-0.1562373638,
-0.0806325823,
-0.5182389617,
-0.257253617,
0.1763705164,
-0.3394388258,
-0.8389737606,
0.4190840721,
0.2181355208,
-0.3268811703,
-0.2141278684,
0.1086900234,
-0.206728965,
0.0020859477,
0.5217931271,
0.0359826162,
-0.7367141247,
-0.5218087435,
0.1209854186,
-0.2791273892,
-0.0386432745,
1.1023570299,
-0.9339264035,
0.2343554348,
0.4917687774,
0.577434361,
-0.0173926987,
0.3903746903,
0.8067524433,
-0.6161609888,
-0.4117040634,
0.5879188776,
0.261151433,
0.3517502546,
-0.188392967,
0.5797708035,
0.3041487336,
-0.3797315955,
-0.8119196892,
0.3363009095,
-0.9065617323,
-0.0582711101,
1.2517926693,
-0.327167958,
0.0270760003,
0.1805929244,
-0.1154392809,
0.1450108588,
-0.5036981702,
1.0211976767,
0.6808930635,
-0.5148797631,
0.2702431679,
-0.1034240499,
0.4053235948,
0.6286355257,
-0.6822644472,
0.2299531251,
0.5978038311,
0.2947531343,
0.493896693,
0.5727324486,
0.1215193719,
0.7260460854,
-0.244955495,
0.117088072,
-0.2775383294,
-0.3116306365,
-0.075568527,
0.1614112109,
0.1888561696,
-0.0433783978
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07431v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07431v2
|
SALAD: Smart AI Language Assistant Daily
| 2024-02-12T06:15:24 | 2024-02-13T06:34:48 |
Ragib Amin Nihal, Tran Dong Huu Quoc, Lin Zirui, Xu Yimimg, Liu Haoran, An Zhaoyi, Kyou Ma
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
SALAD is an AI-driven language-learning application designed to help
foreigners learn Japanese. It offers translations in Kanji-Kana-Romaji, speech
recognition, translated audio, vocabulary tracking, grammar explanations, and
songs generated from newly learned words. The app targets beginners and
intermediate learners, aiming to make language acquisition more accessible and
enjoyable. SALAD uses daily translations to enhance fluency and comfort in
communication with native speakers. The primary objectives include effective
Japanese language learning, user engagement, and progress tracking. A survey by
us found that 39% of foreigners in Japan face discomfort in conversations with
Japanese speakers. Over 60% of foreigners expressed confidence in SALAD's
ability to enhance their Japanese language skills. The app uses large language
models, speech recognition, and diffusion models to bridge the language gap and
foster a more inclusive community in Japan.
|
[
-0.3198987544,
-0.8859616518,
0.3436138928,
0.3119025826,
-0.0418390222,
0.4613625109,
-0.1987575591,
-0.554071188,
0.775135994,
0.1029597819,
-0.6745095253,
-0.4883671105,
-0.3207570016,
0.4606314301,
-0.3881966472,
1.2644395828,
0.0102486648,
0.3788042367,
0.0221255887,
0.0228392445,
-0.7731576562,
0.4438396394,
-0.9558169246,
-0.1947645247,
0.3498315215,
1.1173768044,
1.0856602192,
0.7282183766,
0.5217807293,
0.5373386145,
0.17824772,
-0.0792265236,
-0.2492440492,
0.3022832572,
-0.3974436224,
-1.0842517614,
-0.2926557958,
0.008317058,
0.4426662922,
0.6425411701,
-0.2758997977,
-0.0981387049,
-0.1409595162,
1.0760525465,
-0.6096550226,
0.2108078003,
-0.6552746296,
0.4591960013,
-0.4222600162,
0.122717306,
0.039066501,
-0.6163256764,
-0.1797253788,
-1.1620839834,
-0.0636447519,
-0.4307902753,
0.9865836501,
0.2742564678,
-0.3263808787,
-0.248050496,
-0.7038688064,
0.8288983107,
-0.3408889771,
0.4204583168,
0.7635391355,
0.776276648,
-0.4413541853,
-0.4748118818,
-0.9688591361,
-0.0275578313,
0.1261777133,
0.354747355,
0.2566988766,
0.1057992727,
0.0438673943,
0.8059481382,
-0.7351213694,
-0.0736272261,
-0.0351343602,
0.1469849646,
0.7894101143,
0.3539767861,
1.0932877064,
-0.1748993397,
-0.2594853044,
-0.2667665184,
-0.2229887992,
0.034237992,
0.1353443414,
0.0481301546,
-0.533798635,
0.2641550601,
-0.4994109869,
0.6611124277,
-0.0438857377,
-0.5608744025,
0.5253609419,
-0.4545259178,
-0.0840155035,
0.0521676987,
1.1808927059,
0.4894866049,
0.5484836698,
-0.2701173127,
-0.0750674754,
0.3507471383,
0.083694458,
-0.4133579135,
-0.4863232076,
0.3825780153,
-0.2061480433,
-0.4279692769,
-0.2309575975,
-0.8753088117,
-0.5817946792,
0.0263833925,
0.2707214057,
-0.4661855698,
-0.2685687542,
-0.2382996529,
-0.7736233473,
0.2519848645,
0.3635270298,
-1.1122456789,
0.4889742732,
0.5800281167,
0.9569374323,
-0.2136909962,
-0.4491350353,
-0.3610107899,
0.1932777613,
-0.6997287273,
0.5732777715,
-0.4415745139,
-0.7087255716,
-0.2273244113,
0.2430987656,
-0.3134005368,
-0.6453393698,
0.4056257606,
-0.2463862151,
0.1901742071,
-0.2044547349,
-0.1747312993,
-0.2411360294,
0.2596062124,
-0.7529391646,
0.4454536736,
0.2272913903,
-0.6670699716,
0.3841301799,
-0.9723491669,
-0.9092079401,
0.6550694108,
-0.4299632013,
-0.2489605546,
-0.2029432803,
0.3006550968,
0.2743805349,
0.0843347758,
0.3050180078,
0.0428505763,
-0.2679865658,
0.3670742512,
-0.4813338518,
0.993634522,
0.6457985044,
-0.3322399855,
0.364831835,
-0.6762445569,
-0.3514466882,
0.4819367826,
-0.5717447996,
-0.5114374757,
0.1265312284,
0.2180177122,
-0.1456746459,
0.321447283,
-0.5483570099,
0.4242518842,
-0.7052464485,
0.4230618179,
0.6787882447,
-0.1772036403,
0.7718820572,
-0.4174236655,
0.869418025,
0.0095867226,
0.2864182591,
-0.3876425624,
-0.8252351284,
-0.7270061374,
-0.4762357771,
0.4054179192,
1.1636542082,
-1.2913684845,
0.1939931363,
-0.5119655728,
-0.3963356316,
-0.9364863634,
0.4167534411,
0.3877713382,
0.373154968,
0.2224724293,
-0.6388462782,
-0.4645228982,
-0.7198722363,
-0.5562913418,
0.1352702826,
0.1097682789,
0.1874505877,
0.2480525672,
-0.7622779012,
0.8062676787,
-0.2303645015,
-0.5003015399,
-0.6281098723,
-0.1267482638,
0.4717965126,
0.5160836577,
0.3786379695,
-1.0548368692,
-1.2617045641,
0.4007170498,
-0.6940914392,
0.2953651547,
-0.2443459779,
-0.1146463305,
0.2119745016,
0.0560221598,
-0.7989605665,
0.2435099334,
0.7775905728,
-0.459824264,
0.2018335015,
0.0650913119,
0.375582844,
-1.5723208189,
-0.0542958044,
-0.0013583164,
-0.6741853952,
-0.6708449721,
0.4590227008,
-0.0305358712,
-0.2920396626,
-0.3283193409,
0.5378645062,
-0.1973167956,
0.0842719674,
-0.2640252709,
-0.0746328905,
-0.1551049352,
0.1959385872,
-0.2112552822,
1.1612918377,
0.5003094673,
-0.7297636271,
0.4088333547,
0.2674385011,
-0.4471569061,
0.5177116394,
-0.3682367504,
-0.1258109808,
0.0049798237,
-0.0239413735,
-1.3271963596,
-0.7610361576,
0.6792279482,
-0.6237137914,
0.3485646248,
0.4518365264,
0.0144197093,
-0.3284469545,
-0.5111665726,
0.1400601864,
0.3911747336,
-0.4785257876,
0.7536242008,
0.7015135884,
-0.2361650467,
-0.4057276249,
-0.7062894106,
0.3185346425,
-0.0785205215,
-0.3358846009,
0.3227132559,
-0.1696084887,
-0.4708562195,
-0.0682307407,
0.0044221394,
-0.4188105762,
0.5650646687,
0.2952925265,
0.0136922467,
0.1076747999,
-0.2136272639,
0.1456856579,
0.0052081347,
-0.1571365148,
0.4323208034,
0.7227856517,
-0.0432330631,
0.4427685142,
-1.1734911203,
0.2680334449,
0.7068963051,
-0.0115068359,
0.6866518259,
0.6611198187,
-0.1730261147,
0.0469953679,
-0.2082062364,
-0.0152093759,
-0.6204663515,
0.5900230408,
-0.768469274,
-0.0353537574,
0.5425040126,
0.1710232943,
0.2536047399,
0.4157982171,
0.1859458834,
-0.4936845899,
1.3532733917,
0.4261407256,
-0.8110649586,
0.7708026171,
-0.2112678438,
-0.14717035,
-0.5455954075,
-0.2876107693,
-0.5585849285,
-0.3682809174,
-0.839394033,
-0.2032379955,
0.3255865276,
-0.2305970639,
-0.1098029912,
0.2881180048,
-0.3211333156,
0.5583130121,
0.8560851216,
0.0599442609,
0.3025134802,
-0.0708572119,
0.0825007558,
-0.0137635656,
-0.7250514627,
0.0863567144,
0.813947618,
0.571218431,
0.8085793257,
0.1518660933,
0.9116771221,
0.3221635818,
0.1260740608,
-1.3988581896,
0.626321435,
-0.202962026,
-0.4710230827,
-0.4761244655,
-0.7124128342,
-1.1395792961,
-0.0472381823,
-0.1260808706,
-0.4223368168,
-0.1370130032,
0.2404965758,
0.0116313463,
-0.1781812608,
-0.9219580293,
0.9046340585,
-0.3978941441,
-0.227556482,
-0.2841091156,
-0.6013638973,
0.2643977106,
0.2792875767,
0.8625360727,
0.0885380059,
0.2021855861,
0.8975926638,
-0.4365231693,
0.5701398849,
-0.2328099012,
-0.0883721262,
-0.0807730108,
0.3729821444,
0.5880807042,
0.0607744418,
0.3022117317,
0.3616524339,
-0.1572258323,
-0.1649637818,
-0.3885361552,
0.8663909435,
-0.9231595993,
-0.6364414692,
-0.6498175859,
-0.7363808155,
-0.0228855051,
0.542349577,
0.1315636486,
-0.5197669268,
-0.0180955008,
-0.0647183508,
0.5204058886,
-0.2420349568,
0.4232566655,
0.5193113089,
-0.2888973653,
-0.5999020338,
1.3520154953,
0.0575264543,
0.0353540629,
0.4219534397,
0.527343154,
0.2066629976,
0.0278653502,
-0.9659774899,
0.0520739257,
-0.4183597565,
-0.0065428759,
-0.5091869831,
0.1360716522,
-0.4073843956,
-0.1208441257,
-0.5341050029,
-0.3489397168,
-0.0264653992,
0.0022198581,
0.2751853764,
0.7063143253,
0.0303912945,
0.4491084814,
-0.7617925406,
0.7841416001,
0.2785030305,
0.2718480527,
-0.495284766,
0.1213141829,
-0.3869791329,
0.3044596612,
-0.4895199239,
-1.3142511845,
0.3621792197,
0.4582696259,
0.4142144322,
0.7613818645,
-0.5154114962,
0.7148723602,
-0.6541138887,
0.9949344397,
0.4082440436,
-1.0065802336,
0.6251479983,
-0.5129446983,
0.7959973812,
0.6795043349,
0.7530428171,
-0.8388404846,
-0.4794591665,
-0.1667141169,
-0.8749039769,
0.6109859943,
-0.2865269184,
0.2125018686,
-0.215438664,
0.0715684593,
0.0158905983,
0.1269604266,
-0.7179099917,
-0.3329420388,
-0.2337027937,
-0.7132734656,
-0.1906826794,
0.1638609618,
0.1601845175,
-0.6476683021,
0.7327103019,
-0.0395752043,
0.337002635,
-0.2754570544,
0.1993545294,
-0.422505796,
0.1201072931,
0.1307561696,
0.375846386,
0.1903241426,
-0.3585284948,
0.2872973979,
-0.9711869359,
-0.0608290881,
-0.1167287007,
-0.3341860473,
0.3169142902,
0.0961844847,
0.5754734874,
0.1189177558,
-0.8751837015,
0.5914565921,
-0.2877724767,
-0.0977685973,
-0.5643382668,
0.7575517893,
0.1368346065,
0.0098187821,
0.0899694115,
-0.1066324487,
0.6527489424,
-1.0070445538,
-0.0954867452,
0.7947111726,
-0.361489594,
-0.090428412,
0.691218257,
0.389143616,
-0.5902448893,
0.8020095229,
-0.0335235298,
-0.6591233015,
0.5663701892,
0.6268236637,
0.873385787,
-0.907248795,
0.4092202485,
0.2780587673,
-0.0061805579,
0.0614074916,
0.6546266079,
-0.4205202758,
-0.7184473276,
-0.2189546973,
-0.5823221207,
-0.3700966835,
0.1969873309,
-0.5310325623,
0.2529835999,
-0.2400276959,
-0.1471449137,
-0.0158871729,
-0.0368077159,
-0.6714886427,
0.4347950518,
-0.0713750869,
0.8860419393,
-1.0233396292,
0.9235592484,
1.0780208111,
-0.3131652176,
-0.7073641419,
0.2190864533,
-0.3044840991,
-0.7526150346,
0.3777526915,
0.1792956144,
-0.070891276,
-0.0657420605,
-0.5920951366,
-0.6981868148,
0.7039795518,
0.1284621805,
-0.9342439175,
-0.0678975806,
0.3239400983,
0.179715544,
0.2690393031,
0.1975561678,
0.5108901858,
0.356187433,
-0.1992480606,
-1.1501638889,
-0.2583251595,
-0.5151961446,
0.2114243209,
0.2283331603,
-0.4548775256,
0.9107888341,
-0.0853363425,
-0.4292494059,
0.1319197863,
0.4869396389,
-0.1000309512,
0.4648708999,
0.442935735,
0.6499013305,
0.7893548012,
0.0038658455,
1.1457731724,
-0.4144318998,
-0.1892248392,
1.0264763832,
0.1474839747,
0.7231727242,
0.7405527234,
-0.2535920143,
0.9246121049,
0.391023159,
0.343280375,
0.7929260135,
-0.0484178178,
-0.2657834589,
0.1354616731,
-0.214314267,
-0.2870287597,
0.531973362,
0.7195106745,
-0.5108122826,
0.2405543774,
0.4058305919,
0.2959710956,
0.3779127598,
-0.4747564495,
1.2880384922,
0.0606087185,
-0.9768423438,
0.5696716309,
0.2614913285,
0.6211304069,
-0.5062568784,
-0.3700000346,
-0.3498784304,
0.4719533026,
-0.3761881888,
-0.6625323296,
0.1835832149,
-0.0872287229,
-0.0668371618,
0.1067663953,
0.4884221852,
-0.3957479,
-0.1827430874,
-0.1167731881,
0.0680114105,
0.2701459229,
0.214560166,
-0.9738057256,
0.1366679072,
-0.0084912842,
-0.1315053403,
0.181714654,
-0.0533879884,
0.0329182036,
0.7201328874,
0.380829215,
0.2097629607,
-0.1755337864,
-0.1213088259,
0.588001132,
-0.5119986534,
-0.8827323318,
-0.8926078677,
0.4311829507,
-0.0874660388,
-0.1826932728,
1.0968800783,
0.5364735723,
1.1954264641,
-0.3297932744,
0.93192029,
-0.1576388478,
0.5645829439,
-0.410531342,
0.8765335679,
-0.7831617594,
-0.121427007,
-0.3449896574,
-0.6913436651,
-0.0718027353,
1.2152750492,
-0.1603672653,
-0.0671150684,
0.4130062759,
0.5469570756,
-0.0518939868,
0.0859568566,
0.0983827263,
0.1420066059,
0.1349134892,
0.63551265,
0.6379871964,
-0.5268689394,
-0.1045006216,
-0.3883810937,
-0.3563815057,
-0.2081542611,
-0.2181928754,
-0.8263188601,
-0.4561072886,
-0.2205545008,
-0.2933080494,
0.4579061866,
1.1631959677,
0.4051902592,
-0.8951508403,
-0.5782028437,
-0.7694039941,
0.1681715697,
-0.5109571815,
-0.4013603032,
-0.0424044989,
-0.5550583601,
-1.2592824697,
0.7994659543,
-0.2561763227,
-0.1854242086,
-0.2896983624,
-0.2200799733,
-0.2557241917,
-0.0637169927,
0.2590631247,
0.5684395432,
-0.136885792,
0.245995149,
-0.3543181419,
-0.1606618762,
0.0949658006,
0.1112951711,
-0.7950043678,
0.8564742208,
0.7879063487,
0.7598884106,
0.0974702984,
-0.0880900919,
0.7784209847,
-0.4920396507,
0.1280083358,
0.0474418774,
0.1027026623,
0.4083396494,
-0.624607563,
0.223579362,
0.343473196,
-0.4035856724,
-0.592471242,
0.088382259,
-0.4901683033,
-0.3704155385,
1.225481987,
0.0064000781,
-0.5965097547,
-0.0582330711,
-0.1425278485,
0.6363078952,
-0.5101727843,
1.0017597675,
0.319524914,
0.1911607236,
0.1707680821,
-1.0447024107,
0.9208734632,
0.6136131883,
-0.8723322749,
-0.6604042649,
0.2847288847,
0.5395592451,
0.4125202,
0.8600628376,
0.1114401296,
0.8020509481,
-0.2954835296,
0.0224254318,
0.251802057,
-0.8967843652,
-0.3145852685,
-0.3205397427,
0.1328388304,
-0.8634065986
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07405v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07405v1
|
Dólares or Dollars? Unraveling the Bilingual Prowess of Financial LLMs Between Spanish and English
| 2024-02-12T04:50:31 | 2024-02-12T04:50:31 |
Xiao Zhang, Ruoyu Xiang, Chenhan Yuan, Duanyu Feng, Weiguang Han, Alejandro Lopez-Lira, Xiao-Yang Liu, Sophia Ananiadou, Min Peng, Jimin Huang, Qianqian Xie
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite Spanish's pivotal role in the global finance industry, a pronounced
gap exists in Spanish financial natural language processing (NLP) and
application studies compared to English, especially in the era of large
language models (LLMs). To bridge this gap, we unveil Tois\'on de Oro, the
first bilingual framework that establishes instruction datasets, finetuned
LLMs, and evaluation benchmark for financial LLMs in Spanish joint with
English. We construct a rigorously curated bilingual instruction dataset
including over 144K Spanish and English samples from 15 datasets covering 7
tasks. Harnessing this, we introduce FinMA-ES, an LLM designed for bilingual
financial applications. We evaluate our model and existing LLMs using FLARE-ES,
the first comprehensive bilingual evaluation benchmark with 21 datasets
covering 9 tasks. The FLARE-ES benchmark results reveal a significant
multilingual performance gap and bias in existing LLMs. FinMA-ES models surpass
SOTA LLMs such as GPT-4 in Spanish financial tasks, due to strategic
instruction tuning and leveraging data from diverse linguistic resources,
highlighting the positive impact of cross-linguistic transfer. All our
datasets, models, and benchmarks have been released.
|
[
-0.0356620923,
-0.6477152109,
0.3285416961,
0.8041440845,
0.1813312769,
0.6474636197,
-0.2976894677,
-0.6663526893,
0.3116793931,
0.6003437638,
-0.7055569887,
-0.462503463,
-0.694452107,
0.0361442827,
-0.2619711161,
0.9874597192,
-0.0215127021,
0.3968102336,
-0.3049108982,
0.2488377392,
-0.0214261953,
-0.1095627919,
-1.0965573788,
-0.3849648237,
0.430937618,
0.5198851824,
0.4968417585,
0.6363632083,
0.583178401,
0.3620418012,
0.2771232426,
0.136517778,
-0.3945591152,
-0.3412853479,
-0.4163858593,
-0.662127614,
-0.6725732088,
-0.1625146568,
0.4423379898,
0.8632485271,
-0.112898767,
0.2146027386,
-0.2373903245,
1.071531415,
-0.5216369629,
0.6099762917,
-0.432993263,
-0.0770309269,
-0.5476077795,
-0.2486073077,
-0.2552728653,
-0.1637985706,
0.2882215381,
-0.3332065642,
-0.0785979107,
0.1208937541,
0.622774303,
0.1889069527,
-0.6776344776,
-0.4156641066,
-0.470443517,
0.8900228143,
-0.4791793823,
0.7755038142,
0.2665638328,
0.3356607258,
0.0349367224,
-0.7882029414,
-0.0846701488,
-0.0357965752,
0.3856428266,
0.0420349389,
-0.622322917,
-0.0964726582,
-0.1192375943,
0.6205067039,
-0.2984924912,
0.4972815514,
-0.3652252257,
-0.1823391169,
0.7085344195,
0.09768641,
0.15169698,
0.1855314523,
-0.7901299596,
-0.3152460158,
-0.9713504314,
0.2903449535,
0.6579944491,
0.5494509935,
-0.2417427897,
0.5193240643,
-0.0548610538,
0.4724728167,
-0.0059597222,
-0.380161792,
0.1609683037,
-0.1798685193,
-0.4395107329,
0.0925339833,
0.7118133307,
0.4148557782,
0.3791925609,
-0.6214106679,
-0.4509568214,
-0.3723175824,
-0.0756599754,
-0.5370019078,
0.2058813423,
0.0096696755,
-0.1066452935,
-0.0817186832,
0.1362052858,
-0.9931598902,
-0.1763274968,
-0.2348630875,
0.3265553415,
0.0942263529,
-0.0198335722,
0.7681132555,
0.0674193278,
0.196014747,
-0.2436648607,
-1.1415196657,
1.0892800093,
0.9492229223,
0.4850042462,
-0.0397496484,
-0.3494885266,
-0.4240117669,
0.0390030891,
-0.2520502508,
0.8007230759,
-0.2970469296,
-0.474064827,
0.0283689126,
0.135924831,
-0.4368494153,
-0.4930559099,
0.2055613995,
-0.481349349,
0.1248016357,
-0.489944905,
-0.4065385759,
-0.2925025821,
0.06831716,
-0.5647465587,
0.9960026145,
0.1509331614,
-0.5906711817,
0.2297376841,
-0.5975465178,
-0.4515803456,
-0.2302659303,
0.0589441843,
-0.208720386,
-0.169429943,
0.34091717,
0.2744893134,
-0.9999548793,
0.4251825511,
-0.1212465167,
-0.1904256344,
0.3040531576,
-0.5139905214,
0.716265142,
-0.2153629661,
-0.5727578998,
-0.1600657403,
-0.5884395242,
-0.427159816,
0.3683785796,
0.0299018044,
-0.3270927668,
0.1842250377,
0.0265650302,
0.0665347204,
0.6669748425,
-0.6438980103,
-0.114776127,
-0.7290866971,
0.3098309338,
0.6977111101,
-0.2315853238,
0.5493527651,
-0.4986228347,
0.6889402866,
-0.2470761985,
0.0270002019,
-0.2601441741,
-0.2425872087,
-0.8666576147,
-0.3851456642,
0.2963174284,
1.0000718832,
-0.2721114159,
-0.0733520538,
-0.2349604219,
-0.3905488849,
-0.2943437696,
0.2865095735,
0.3971485198,
0.5361303687,
0.2591083348,
0.1683975607,
-0.5722800493,
-1.2532689571,
-0.3777053952,
-0.0710508898,
0.0937509537,
0.1777417064,
0.370121032,
-0.139187932,
0.6717739701,
-0.3190368712,
-0.2519305646,
-0.2994388044,
-0.2079168707,
0.248610422,
0.1070133001,
1.0398852825,
-0.3583130836,
-0.3832010031,
0.2915701568,
-0.3760477304,
-0.2796494961,
-0.2368763983,
0.0267060287,
0.1435132176,
0.5252955556,
0.070019789,
0.0236726049,
0.6982732415,
-0.5720809698,
0.0290851034,
-0.3272158802,
0.2294244021,
-0.8160468936,
-0.1380930841,
0.2296381146,
-0.3311118782,
-0.2895594537,
-0.1640882045,
0.2240532637,
0.1736618131,
-0.278125912,
0.945098877,
-0.4281075895,
-0.3501425385,
-0.0263283048,
0.1690598279,
0.070697315,
0.4301086366,
-0.114923209,
0.9055249691,
0.9725254178,
-0.1766641885,
0.5370858312,
-0.0628745481,
-0.4465714991,
0.6197484136,
-0.7018278837,
-0.1579594761,
0.0289645996,
-0.0465062447,
-0.8841109872,
0.049078919,
0.2375493795,
0.3123596907,
0.5701559186,
0.2299768031,
-0.4662528634,
-0.4622281194,
-0.4425357878,
0.2358344495,
0.1648019999,
-0.7200645804,
0.2633473575,
0.5342052579,
-0.7226076126,
-0.8835324049,
-0.8439664841,
0.2746717334,
-0.1924489737,
-0.8488038182,
0.6790591478,
0.2989313304,
-0.7370721698,
-0.2761854529,
-0.3360609114,
0.0008699799,
0.2104659975,
-0.0097818682,
0.5914937854,
-0.4877762198,
0.0619634055,
0.4378021955,
-0.1810686141,
0.3347820342,
-0.3681646883,
0.2932932675,
-0.5662124157,
-0.4907236397,
-0.0385286175,
0.0411587507,
0.6122891307,
-0.3184028566,
0.6169914603,
-0.0643158779,
-0.2135366201,
-0.2621608078,
-0.8966780901,
0.2837146223,
-0.4906105399,
0.2507498264,
-0.2597059309,
-0.7779265642,
0.8719556332,
-0.1322893351,
0.3245564103,
0.6741291285,
0.5487180352,
0.0918306038,
0.464484334,
0.7809497118,
-0.2429990917,
0.4198745489,
-0.3628658652,
0.1915152967,
-0.2076893598,
-0.7856534719,
-0.4680408537,
-0.4795646667,
-0.1987844557,
-0.6228526235,
0.1912533641,
-0.0574536547,
0.0009675235,
0.2569335699,
0.3237125278,
0.8030911684,
0.2167285085,
-0.2141370028,
0.4653593302,
-0.036922317,
-0.0907837972,
-0.2410370111,
-0.6815972924,
-0.4553731382,
1.4020518064,
0.6322656274,
0.6788135767,
-0.0182932839,
0.5189429522,
0.3121073544,
0.1307359636,
-0.7198210955,
0.3510965407,
-0.4542628825,
-0.1892870963,
-0.0881752074,
-0.4366900921,
-0.888451457,
-0.007934182,
0.1140887961,
-0.504743576,
0.09119872,
-0.4329009056,
-0.3017616868,
0.529946506,
-0.5810191035,
1.0130075216,
-0.6878189445,
-0.5479896665,
-0.1478442401,
-0.2870317101,
0.5433861017,
-0.3242819309,
0.6089395881,
-0.3080995977,
-0.652674675,
0.6449300051,
-0.4722461402,
0.8553835154,
0.2231864035,
-0.6502289772,
0.1369465441,
-0.1142286807,
0.2969732583,
0.3230368495,
-0.2299333364,
0.4152059555,
0.0768138394,
-0.4624809027,
-0.2183534652,
1.2082077265,
-0.4492245615,
-0.3604215086,
-0.3033666313,
-0.7170496583,
-0.5119379163,
-0.1388722062,
-0.0048050275,
0.3804836571,
-0.5033220053,
-0.2742337883,
0.4584386051,
-0.0523728132,
0.6912745237,
0.7730571628,
-0.4311543107,
-0.3903242648,
1.0783270597,
0.0464168563,
0.0051364829,
0.4776262045,
0.1543801129,
-0.7785493135,
-0.1652847677,
-0.5785053372,
0.5898908377,
-0.4583328664,
-0.2007174641,
-0.3542485535,
0.026288664,
-0.4884626865,
-0.4509179592,
-0.7114765048,
-0.3832952976,
-0.0059324596,
-0.3046194017,
0.4914183617,
0.6973028779,
-0.3945695758,
0.0748829618,
-0.7953010201,
0.2968867719,
0.5296794772,
0.5644321442,
-0.0354007892,
-0.285926193,
-0.2289407402,
0.1129027382,
0.1238421872,
-0.8327254057,
0.3499516547,
0.2660203576,
0.6255830526,
0.6168707013,
-0.3246011138,
0.5678152442,
-0.2700903416,
0.3021169007,
0.115034461,
-0.9710565209,
0.2549959123,
-0.4998644292,
0.0111017292,
0.4928304553,
0.2962620258,
-0.6149298549,
-0.515732348,
-0.5045300722,
-0.8520476818,
0.8555501103,
-0.1635436118,
0.1129756793,
-0.3927460313,
0.0136325601,
0.5138210058,
0.3254472017,
-0.6271606684,
-0.3347947598,
0.2213052362,
0.0507993773,
-0.1920729578,
-0.2172119319,
-0.0456037931,
-0.2768586278,
0.5529965162,
0.0530546866,
-0.2843162715,
-0.2058666348,
-0.1338024884,
-0.2190894037,
0.0289270896,
0.4580641985,
0.7006459236,
-0.0779843032,
-0.0120979268,
0.1449476182,
-0.262280345,
-0.1272345781,
0.1531112492,
0.0412662141,
-0.0077885338,
0.2451207191,
0.8142635822,
1.1264842749,
-1.1521961689,
0.5774254203,
0.1072061136,
-0.3053950965,
-0.2956773937,
-0.2639790475,
0.2659873962,
0.5703192949,
0.4333150685,
0.0834845528,
0.0820682123,
-0.6253067255,
0.0227294583,
0.3797418475,
-0.0769149512,
-0.3875143528,
0.7089344263,
0.3684839904,
-0.1547651738,
0.3112691343,
0.0852165744,
-0.3807901442,
0.8147853613,
0.6164335012,
0.9576233625,
-0.0588797145,
0.395604074,
0.2089096308,
0.3986603022,
-0.6352518201,
0.5566151738,
-0.0829716548,
-0.3840307891,
-0.5101863146,
-0.7389925122,
-0.4142816663,
-0.1272347122,
-0.7811971307,
0.2973644435,
-0.5022066832,
-0.0296078138,
-0.1840102375,
0.0553393513,
-0.6152669787,
-0.0954154208,
0.3834617138,
1.044905901,
-1.0294775963,
0.4737071097,
0.3861069381,
-0.0946597457,
-0.1623021811,
-0.4380092919,
0.047303725,
-0.952585876,
0.631819129,
-0.052356489,
-0.3785741925,
0.0169038605,
0.1328058988,
-0.8891580701,
0.8881939054,
0.7722404599,
-0.847034514,
-0.1191324592,
0.5267869234,
0.3439262509,
-0.2626628876,
-0.0288868081,
0.9404118657,
0.7056369781,
0.0921572819,
-1.0051841736,
-0.6505585909,
-0.1452507079,
-0.3673728108,
0.4702124596,
-0.7611455917,
0.791737318,
-0.2990777791,
-0.1620957106,
-0.1849309951,
0.4917865694,
-0.1639325172,
0.6938973665,
0.2468808442,
0.5357397199,
0.8275737166,
-0.3619430959,
1.1536377668,
-0.4505821764,
0.1366999,
0.8309332728,
-0.3574176133,
0.8515062332,
0.7477892637,
-0.5168851614,
0.4451276958,
0.6040525436,
0.0006985707,
0.1394465864,
0.1824810356,
-0.4172907174,
-0.2103535384,
-0.0501260348,
-0.1317893267,
0.5651539564,
0.2422812134,
-0.1830540597,
-0.5197589397,
0.0856214166,
0.0802128837,
0.4846792817,
-0.5201849341,
0.3500550091,
0.1531111747,
-0.4571508467,
0.005221054,
0.4064286351,
0.8465728164,
-0.9663794637,
0.5783804059,
-0.649199605,
0.1680622697,
-0.0299517512,
-0.5056297183,
0.5931323171,
0.5189503431,
-0.2465612441,
-0.7683598399,
0.2976855338,
-0.5033659339,
-0.9180982113,
0.6614081264,
0.6906149983,
0.0464816056,
0.158626765,
-0.5367672443,
-0.2709410489,
-0.1987080127,
-0.1991459131,
0.5548419356,
0.2390325814,
-0.0634842739,
0.6064090729,
0.6148341894,
0.1870945096,
0.1827184111,
0.2103502601,
0.4904820025,
-0.5649800897,
-0.4082469642,
-1.0210804939,
0.2317003459,
0.1603457183,
-0.4101710021,
0.8896564245,
0.9666824341,
1.1603708267,
-0.1083978862,
0.1461170316,
0.4618266225,
0.2869158089,
-0.5511069894,
0.5312159061,
-0.6688574553,
0.5448575616,
-0.0551252775,
-0.9260603786,
-0.1456099004,
0.4135014713,
-0.5424628258,
-0.1883077919,
0.5346714258,
0.6643823981,
-0.0972666889,
-0.0262192506,
0.2917806506,
-0.1201086566,
-0.2693119049,
0.7355157137,
0.5638920069,
-0.6155881882,
0.3194355965,
-0.4324099123,
-0.0358520187,
-0.1187463254,
-0.8087648153,
-0.8722615838,
-0.2601152956,
-0.4285233021,
0.2631555498,
-0.2287286371,
0.7982301712,
0.0048470306,
-0.5846377611,
-0.9256355166,
0.0706613958,
0.3175129294,
-0.3595260382,
-0.107911393,
0.0776971355,
-0.4436224699,
-1.1540112495,
0.9713291526,
0.940754652,
0.1595041007,
-0.2862462103,
-0.0146815758,
0.0782882199,
0.3839873374,
0.309689343,
0.5325037837,
-0.6055015922,
0.3607239723,
0.5417593122,
-0.3759817183,
-0.0728586987,
0.8009507656,
-0.4493555129,
0.3566352725,
0.4505919218,
0.7932581306,
0.5340701342,
-0.4992344081,
0.7603262067,
-0.523430109,
0.4424521327,
0.036598932,
0.3973085284,
0.0124173844,
-0.0653211623,
0.4429354072,
0.0890124515,
-0.0785287023,
-0.7034519315,
-0.1800969094,
-1.0139446259,
-0.1830638349,
0.8206776977,
-0.0966961756,
-0.3981100321,
0.130469054,
-0.0332072936,
-0.2041098177,
-0.1079957858,
0.6417922378,
0.6007091403,
0.326251328,
0.1064021438,
-0.5428000093,
0.2769224048,
0.5414549112,
-0.6465309262,
0.0560136102,
0.2716527283,
0.2003266215,
-0.3069414198,
0.5596321225,
-0.1486479938,
0.4393846393,
0.2092012018,
-0.1424905211,
-0.4754934907,
-0.4923186898,
-0.1918963343,
0.0706929713,
-0.1340743899,
-0.0809023976
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07401v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07401v1
|
Can LLMs Produce Faithful Explanations For Fact-checking? Towards Faithful Explainable Fact-Checking via Multi-Agent Debate
| 2024-02-12T04:32:33 | 2024-02-12T04:32:33 |
Kyungha Kim, Sangyun Lee, Kung-Hsiang Huang, Hou Pong Chan, Manling Li, Heng Ji
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Fact-checking research has extensively explored verification but less so the
generation of natural-language explanations, crucial for user trust. While
Large Language Models (LLMs) excel in text generation, their capability for
producing faithful explanations in fact-checking remains underexamined. Our
study investigates LLMs' ability to generate such explanations, finding that
zero-shot prompts often result in unfaithfulness. To address these challenges,
we propose the Multi-Agent Debate Refinement (MADR) framework, leveraging
multiple LLMs as agents with diverse roles in an iterative refining process
aimed at enhancing faithfulness in generated explanations. MADR ensures that
the final explanation undergoes rigorous validation, significantly reducing the
likelihood of unfaithful elements and aligning closely with the provided
evidence. Experimental results demonstrate that MADR significantly improves the
faithfulness of LLM-generated explanations to the evidence, advancing the
credibility and trustworthiness of these explanations.
|
[
-0.4363416135,
-0.8726453185,
1.0575704575,
-0.3323839903,
-0.2001390904,
0.0373507962,
-0.1586719453,
-0.1152096763,
-0.356362313,
0.6591364145,
-0.8271811008,
-0.2070536911,
-0.3658770323,
0.4610596299,
-0.094599843,
1.3267735243,
-0.28809762,
0.1084768772,
-0.3042316735,
-0.195393756,
-0.1566383094,
-0.3532525897,
-0.5566225052,
-0.7978239059,
0.7997248173,
0.7444298267,
0.9026409388,
0.7081432939,
0.2957522571,
0.3774842024,
0.1214902923,
0.8157475591,
-0.5920033455,
0.5568103194,
-0.4492208958,
-0.3878058195,
-0.332890451,
0.0236701425,
0.4947727323,
0.1754941344,
-0.192812264,
0.0093798637,
-0.0794907138,
0.4682396948,
-0.626093924,
0.1742486358,
-0.9312744141,
-0.2626625001,
0.1022905037,
-0.4300665855,
-0.5503641367,
-0.4550887942,
0.0730131716,
-0.5110891461,
0.6834277511,
0.087581329,
1.3532797098,
0.2333675325,
-0.585581243,
-0.1634327918,
-0.8664915562,
0.5388970971,
-0.6459647417,
0.2610355616,
-0.0204640198,
0.1730925292,
-0.5277407765,
-0.5233498812,
-0.9393093586,
-0.1946983486,
-0.1646812856,
0.0746397451,
-0.1026174426,
0.1545974463,
0.1799223423,
0.2239092141,
-0.3671500087,
-0.3064801991,
-0.1000824869,
-0.4747646153,
0.752047956,
0.1621902287,
-0.1367919743,
0.1027945951,
-0.3979348242,
0.001427129,
-0.946835041,
-0.2897529006,
0.4186696708,
0.2384154648,
0.1855041832,
0.6530607939,
-0.1272700429,
0.4572905302,
0.2909825742,
-0.2897613049,
-0.2077267319,
-0.6000311375,
-0.2191483676,
0.1322050095,
0.8382440805,
0.4128412306,
0.1950400174,
-0.3443990052,
-0.2319757342,
0.2363816202,
0.3207072914,
-1.0582441092,
0.080708459,
0.5487782359,
-0.1644483507,
-0.1893210709,
0.0554480255,
-0.6717489362,
-0.5017928481,
-0.4170335531,
0.539704144,
-0.2688007057,
-0.22667557,
0.3451941013,
-0.3913523555,
0.1920822412,
0.7345645428,
-0.2568015456,
0.0691026598,
0.7465030551,
0.5808404684,
0.2744911909,
-0.5338258743,
-0.7153517008,
0.3257437348,
-0.6119600534,
1.0789469481,
-0.4029074609,
-0.0162248984,
0.0323895738,
-0.0839966238,
0.162321195,
-0.3180147111,
0.5597152114,
-0.6311873794,
0.2375577539,
-0.7608716488,
-0.4238063395,
-0.2424618751,
0.6772017479,
-0.622934103,
0.6719990373,
-0.4732584059,
-0.6999463439,
0.4562039375,
-0.7838944793,
-0.3087764382,
-0.2272603065,
-0.177967608,
-0.6644006371,
-0.0479747914,
0.3255248666,
0.3442556858,
-0.3865247369,
0.4736932814,
-0.3680419922,
-0.2365807444,
0.6465255022,
-0.5831143856,
0.4162624776,
0.3033590615,
-0.3630916774,
0.1295249909,
-0.5283247232,
-0.2147570401,
0.2462677658,
-0.2220627815,
0.1304682642,
0.0467167795,
-0.5016171336,
0.1743918061,
0.0754418448,
-0.7382979393,
0.096816197,
-0.2414511144,
0.1745202392,
0.657032311,
0.2754153907,
0.1214603558,
-0.692107439,
0.2919621468,
0.3571037352,
0.121095039,
-0.6021065116,
-0.2541688681,
-0.7466252446,
-0.2341577709,
0.0392138548,
0.1501077116,
-0.8485503793,
-0.2139088511,
-0.1758569628,
-0.2810528874,
-0.6309620738,
-0.0238604229,
0.5590557456,
0.4104149342,
0.2688499689,
0.1148783341,
-0.4638559222,
-0.8153913021,
-0.5287318826,
-0.3729489148,
0.2816341221,
0.1067297235,
0.6017170548,
-0.0706898421,
1.2685250044,
-0.2219086587,
0.1385366321,
-0.1440809518,
0.4550693631,
-0.1591212898,
0.0310878232,
0.1915332228,
-0.6339964867,
-0.1354361475,
-0.0708501339,
-0.5785495639,
-0.0264280848,
-0.454803139,
-0.1659012437,
0.4187757075,
0.3576097488,
-1.011277914,
0.3160046637,
0.3176360428,
-0.4820832014,
0.7019180059,
-0.1744153351,
0.4354757071,
-0.906765461,
-0.1767660081,
-0.1047560275,
-0.5188866258,
-0.6044105887,
0.3331706822,
-0.2629158795,
0.0994384438,
-0.2775699794,
0.4756147563,
-0.6970422864,
0.2610971928,
-0.4729013443,
0.4388008416,
0.5124146938,
0.4275068939,
-0.2498312742,
0.688796699,
0.5055906177,
-0.648676455,
0.2716544271,
0.2317681462,
0.2183598727,
0.5424607396,
-0.7774437666,
0.2234772891,
-0.471829772,
0.5090205073,
-1.2532465458,
-0.2552810311,
0.3024975657,
-0.5032298565,
0.1272247881,
-0.5725234747,
-0.5335541964,
-0.0632835925,
-0.3571122289,
0.1163813844,
0.0594225675,
-0.6607046127,
0.863014698,
-0.0635937229,
0.1887053847,
-0.8097509742,
-0.4410230219,
0.1591690779,
0.0452809818,
-0.703514874,
0.0764668658,
-0.0790579394,
-0.7019992471,
0.0579268597,
-0.377386868,
-0.0693601295,
-0.0498532541,
0.3497867882,
0.2472032607,
-0.3993413448,
0.2513133585,
-0.1227990985,
-0.0031653519,
0.2037800699,
0.0563709326,
0.3072650135,
-0.2213489562,
-0.6287523508,
-0.3548069596,
0.4028872252,
0.907905817,
-0.4477318525,
1.0207183361,
0.5477707982,
-0.1021264717,
-0.3190779686,
-0.9355375767,
-0.5519440174,
-0.4575631618,
-0.0633802712,
-0.5665058494,
-1.1682931185,
0.5037784576,
-0.1826079041,
0.6091243029,
0.5474618077,
0.7916429639,
0.3034284711,
1.0468262434,
0.2716357112,
0.3551802635,
-0.0463334769,
0.2351272553,
0.3329359293,
-0.3484190702,
-0.357473582,
-0.8227245212,
0.2406074256,
-0.4246744514,
-0.4074120224,
0.1260172576,
-0.3482252359,
-0.3304619491,
-0.2655805051,
-0.1407559812,
0.8622483611,
0.208416909,
-0.0198374856,
0.4507353604,
0.028963374,
-0.1133599207,
0.2341085821,
-0.4687459767,
-0.7361246347,
0.7594834566,
0.3447009325,
0.843095839,
0.3312907815,
0.5813280344,
0.2722408473,
0.340328455,
-0.6342417002,
0.4250246584,
0.3083098829,
-0.8810643554,
-0.3233991861,
-0.4364050627,
-0.9169902205,
0.6273472905,
-0.3369986415,
-0.3019953966,
-0.0066007054,
0.2970171869,
-0.4934269488,
0.2820262611,
-0.5488634109,
0.6303049326,
-0.0098163383,
-0.5963796377,
-0.3927483857,
-0.4037956297,
0.5130172968,
0.09785299,
0.1847039014,
-0.2100438327,
0.1822937429,
0.2614877224,
-0.718462944,
0.7631741166,
-0.1184547916,
-0.5215435028,
0.3931531012,
0.3225151598,
0.7666928172,
0.2879424691,
-0.2395632863,
0.0241274126,
-0.2752000391,
-0.3107038736,
-0.7155900598,
0.4801136553,
-0.6774851084,
-0.9497004151,
-0.3558478653,
-0.5316103101,
-0.1722607762,
-0.0308200158,
-0.0005428435,
0.6099422574,
-0.2758418024,
-0.0087926676,
0.9796357155,
0.0964736119,
0.1830614358,
1.0945887566,
-0.1969771385,
-0.1952148825,
0.65741992,
-0.1462218314,
0.1494056433,
0.1872562915,
0.2163854986,
-0.4103737175,
-0.5528591275,
-0.6232556701,
0.40580073,
-0.6718321443,
-0.2356613874,
-0.5780399442,
-0.0779656097,
-0.1486897469,
-0.0086504938,
-0.5816335678,
-0.2075125426,
-0.1199468449,
-0.1900427341,
0.4991832674,
0.9337473512,
-0.1587122679,
0.3372359276,
-0.6953120828,
0.7347305417,
0.3894114196,
0.2831327617,
-0.1576257199,
-0.6451202035,
-0.1630915701,
0.3698376417,
-0.376427263,
-1.1621232033,
-0.0776213109,
0.1161900014,
0.4317077994,
0.5289707184,
0.2183555514,
0.9575220346,
-0.6340028048,
0.8855164647,
0.0400987864,
-0.9408555031,
0.4112573564,
-0.2629052997,
-0.0006299153,
0.4803739488,
0.206697762,
-0.2869340479,
-0.8569016457,
-0.6670181155,
-0.549175024,
0.7525039911,
0.2511939704,
0.0271108616,
-0.1245133951,
0.6309824586,
0.3278702796,
0.0989536196,
-0.6085717678,
-0.4936791658,
-0.3356800973,
0.1454606652,
0.0572849065,
-0.4488742948,
-0.7523342371,
0.2567980587,
1.0077400208,
-0.403501451,
0.2093684822,
0.6382688284,
-0.0470021144,
-0.6535800099,
0.767921567,
0.8169900775,
0.9752440453,
0.1540710181,
0.5147022009,
-0.0293375272,
-0.0811480433,
0.3550834358,
0.1742081195,
-0.1277079284,
0.4551316798,
0.3083824217,
0.7452534437,
-0.2217800766,
-0.442481041,
0.6806859374,
-0.3863299489,
-0.5083747506,
0.0568922721,
0.0449952334,
0.0076314989,
0.379109025,
0.3693166077,
0.1006368622,
-0.0700307637,
-0.6404047012,
0.2961168587,
0.7379695177,
0.0350452997,
-0.2768845856,
0.4933384061,
-0.0276206415,
0.0528679267,
0.3366499841,
-0.3959933221,
-0.6610429287,
0.4841853976,
0.5403994322,
0.6554060578,
-0.1646264344,
0.6808247566,
0.274748832,
0.5744010806,
-0.2219834179,
0.3589557409,
0.0973514244,
-0.9696769118,
-0.8503484726,
-0.209171012,
-0.8286129236,
0.3543393016,
-0.4237052798,
-0.0611345619,
-0.3010609448,
-0.0747141689,
0.260944128,
0.0473528057,
-0.4354228079,
0.0997589827,
0.0521644838,
0.6502242088,
-0.7071722746,
0.4028297961,
0.6315942407,
-0.4566400051,
-0.9982650876,
0.2608310878,
0.2902971208,
-0.7872526646,
0.2454210818,
-0.0415583253,
-0.7226476669,
-0.3913746774,
-1.0083372593,
-0.562799871,
0.7820958495,
0.9835273027,
-0.6316164732,
0.3040211499,
0.1878553778,
0.5673674345,
-0.0973079503,
0.5131762028,
0.2318028808,
0.7505871654,
0.4542028606,
-0.6853607893,
0.3880270123,
0.0129837152,
-0.3830695748,
0.1035221145,
-0.8431018591,
0.9143941998,
-0.655066371,
-0.2622802556,
-0.1077530235,
0.8325842023,
0.4627914727,
0.4795177877,
0.4519234896,
0.4255378246,
0.8010382056,
-0.1489299834,
0.8625970483,
-0.2115884572,
0.2911823988,
1.1577110291,
-0.5001304746,
0.4460971057,
0.5148871541,
0.2507556379,
0.9403260946,
0.4180859029,
-0.1079410464,
-0.0150292991,
0.0199732557,
-0.42735219,
-0.7849481106,
-0.4195046127,
-0.1392510384,
0.5072869062,
0.0073595704,
-0.1499272436,
-0.555267036,
-0.4366561174,
0.504959166,
-0.080753617,
-0.2923234105,
0.7867474556,
-0.1879121959,
-1.1269521713,
0.6489394903,
0.2366852164,
0.1503732949,
-0.5588821173,
-0.2192350328,
-0.3093312383,
0.3032135963,
-0.3229997456,
-0.8733003736,
0.0479513071,
0.2445793152,
-0.212125048,
-0.2898122966,
0.8017531037,
-0.7039986849,
0.0755741149,
-0.1059639975,
0.8883376122,
0.2035509795,
-0.2836056352,
-0.6441898346,
0.0881048217,
-0.0394529626,
-0.3023516238,
-0.0308248326,
0.9838553667,
0.0270721614,
0.7026082873,
0.6618925929,
-0.1408079118,
-0.2435143888,
0.3118238449,
0.8834108114,
-0.3833101094,
-0.0526118726,
-1.4678795338,
0.5180211067,
0.0226570126,
0.1861760467,
0.9395685196,
0.6085492969,
0.5077755451,
0.0817802176,
0.85118258,
0.300396353,
0.3350494206,
-0.4108963013,
0.6442162395,
-0.5434065461,
0.1022314057,
-0.0053399038,
-0.5379570127,
0.0433976576,
0.3188227713,
0.1950927377,
0.0180247035,
0.832801044,
1.0563702583,
-0.0798326135,
0.1304433197,
0.2229608446,
0.580177784,
0.3177099526,
0.149696365,
1.1222459078,
-0.2334278524,
0.8305367231,
0.1340984553,
0.0932580829,
-0.0618312955,
-1.2139172554,
-1.039847374,
-0.3198507726,
-0.6329168081,
-0.4746470451,
0.2248833925,
0.7965494394,
0.5869005322,
-0.6525014639,
0.0305877049,
-0.0013761874,
0.5673242807,
-0.0883004963,
-0.2243164778,
-0.0221011713,
-0.3863988221,
-0.3179329932,
0.4343561232,
0.2413834929,
-0.1122485399,
-0.3463265598,
-0.3666526675,
-0.0466278605,
0.7728118896,
0.4496265948,
0.157223627,
-1.0435618162,
-0.5097411871,
-0.1762602925,
0.0428610891,
0.2092932612,
1.0616496801,
-0.6551011801,
0.414732039,
0.1794810444,
0.5462487936,
0.2049399465,
0.1835023761,
0.6042872667,
-0.8216670156,
-0.334244132,
-0.1565082222,
0.3510718644,
0.4280393422,
-0.3863526583,
0.1626863927,
0.0722285807,
-0.7409225702,
-0.8778030276,
0.3491639495,
-0.9365053177,
-0.3651723564,
1.4346183538,
-0.2633062303,
-0.1879653931,
-0.531285584,
-0.392639488,
0.5425340533,
-0.6764956117,
0.8262515664,
1.0044872761,
-0.0044957888,
-0.3901273012,
-0.0976464301,
0.5670463443,
0.3375759721,
-0.8668175936,
0.7019756436,
0.7902202606,
0.3147247136,
0.1965899915,
0.6048046947,
-0.0426959284,
0.4853519797,
0.0195835773,
-0.0225047991,
-0.4082188904,
-0.4842743576,
-0.2039162219,
0.1930649281,
0.3137342036,
0.0208868571
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07397v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07397v2
|
Leveraging AI to Advance Science and Computing Education across Africa: Challenges, Progress and Opportunities
| 2024-02-12T04:10:09 | 2024-04-26T23:31:04 |
George Boateng
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Across the African continent, students grapple with various educational
challenges, including limited access to essential resources such as computers,
internet connectivity, reliable electricity, and a shortage of qualified
teachers. Despite these challenges, recent advances in AI such as BERT, and
GPT-4 have demonstrated their potential for advancing education. Yet, these AI
tools tend to be deployed and evaluated predominantly within the context of
Western educational settings, with limited attention directed towards the
unique needs and challenges faced by students in Africa. In this chapter, we
discuss challenges with using AI to advance education across Africa. Then, we
describe our work developing and deploying AI in Education tools in Africa for
science and computing education: (1) SuaCode, an AI-powered app that enables
Africans to learn to code using their smartphones, (2) AutoGrad, an automated
grading, and feedback tool for graphical and interactive coding assignments,
(3) a tool for code plagiarism detection that shows visual evidence of
plagiarism, (4) Kwame, a bilingual AI teaching assistant for coding courses,
(5) Kwame for Science, a web-based AI teaching assistant that provides instant
answers to students' science questions and (6) Brilla AI, an AI contestant for
the National Science and Maths Quiz competition. Finally, we discuss potential
opportunities to leverage AI to advance education across Africa.
|
[
-0.5237020254,
-0.671631813,
0.6534071565,
0.2246787399,
0.1345893592,
0.3985966742,
0.0345147103,
-0.3766192496,
0.0210867543,
0.0553839915,
-0.5387439132,
-0.1215175018,
-0.8801277876,
0.1976922452,
-0.5015913248,
0.9853156805,
-0.440110445,
0.0336268023,
-0.8493999839,
-0.0229704883,
-0.5976632833,
-0.6250666976,
-0.3854600191,
-0.3090435266,
0.3585314751,
0.9246152639,
0.6367738843,
-0.0357418582,
0.6946079135,
0.3579998612,
0.3549276888,
0.1701731384,
0.1785207689,
-0.1144755632,
-0.1536278427,
-0.3342881501,
0.0146517912,
0.1568162143,
0.1667090952,
0.7734333873,
0.051355239,
0.3854602873,
0.0605788678,
0.4715568423,
-0.5757390857,
0.1217401624,
-0.1649788469,
-0.0049448092,
-0.1374676824,
0.3112976253,
0.3246838748,
-0.6545347571,
0.2059936076,
-0.5238986611,
0.1514930129,
-0.6643671393,
0.8081842661,
0.219855547,
-0.2095939815,
-0.7631994486,
-0.2459397167,
0.6207911372,
-0.3407378197,
0.1472655684,
0.5487219095,
0.6464118958,
-0.1926946938,
-1.2545641661,
-0.4622325301,
-0.14404805,
0.5056008697,
0.2044504732,
0.3354499638,
-0.1554623097,
0.1363202482,
0.2281439751,
-0.0454230495,
0.0564209074,
-0.7075039744,
-0.4767753482,
0.7857650518,
-0.0893060938,
0.4502877891,
0.3546517491,
-0.1492353529,
-0.2289709151,
-0.4260350168,
0.0717865676,
0.6892334223,
0.2271963805,
-0.1545728147,
0.4335997701,
0.3111389279,
0.5823955536,
-0.4701709151,
0.023644859,
0.1359677315,
-0.2488297969,
0.1644928455,
0.0588928498,
0.4199047983,
-0.2258058041,
-0.0378884114,
0.3411487341,
0.0023793539,
0.3769864142,
0.4619860351,
-0.632604897,
-0.370862186,
0.1348917633,
-0.2678032815,
-0.1577214897,
-0.0789821222,
-0.9954223633,
-0.6216848493,
-0.0524919666,
0.9002900124,
-0.1839430481,
0.2640393674,
-0.325117588,
-0.3965080976,
-0.0238037985,
0.6183858514,
-1.0800747871,
-0.0390254743,
0.5282921195,
1.0530040264,
0.2049723715,
-0.4163561165,
0.4792311788,
-0.4114916623,
-0.0355184376,
0.4686511755,
-0.6534349322,
-0.7526249886,
-0.0869955271,
-0.1530594677,
-0.0272670053,
-0.1487190127,
0.5098166466,
-0.350728333,
-0.0469227172,
-0.3692888319,
-0.3724792898,
-0.3400610983,
0.1079566777,
-0.4636728466,
0.803381443,
0.3647689521,
-0.4465381503,
-0.0901815444,
-1.1694624424,
-0.6799310446,
-0.1005356088,
-0.4079504907,
-0.5234214067,
0.0220531579,
0.333445847,
0.0841083899,
-0.1142120212,
-0.00433863,
-0.0470229425,
-0.444824934,
0.0283535104,
-0.3393748403,
1.0405881405,
0.3358972371,
-0.6140086055,
-0.1213662699,
-0.4749968648,
-0.0407705568,
0.2073972821,
0.0148456898,
-0.0350290053,
0.1896660626,
-0.1037420481,
0.039090693,
0.5412610769,
-0.6360974908,
0.6210989356,
0.1454986185,
0.619466424,
0.7850337625,
-0.0317879096,
0.2973902822,
-0.3749985695,
0.6038706899,
-0.2836245,
0.4384791851,
-0.1507798731,
-0.7626305819,
-0.4642941356,
-0.0527513213,
0.7058734894,
0.6853355169,
-0.8529549837,
0.1316922456,
0.1403269172,
-0.6324399114,
-1.0433317423,
0.3397158384,
-0.323867172,
0.7719444633,
0.3496759832,
-0.0641032457,
-0.421857357,
-0.8192111254,
-0.1408528686,
0.0465914384,
-0.2379370481,
0.5075626969,
0.8792212009,
-0.4512544572,
0.893697381,
-0.3972021937,
-0.4071698487,
-0.1842920184,
0.1772373319,
0.0663910359,
0.5918054581,
0.4723858237,
-1.1916856766,
-0.399135381,
0.027615672,
-0.785970211,
-0.2194212824,
-0.3010702431,
0.0867564976,
0.1292403936,
0.3859490454,
-0.1724406779,
0.5760054588,
0.4363846779,
-0.1163284704,
0.4713366628,
-0.1281500608,
0.4338702559,
-0.5517575741,
0.1213853583,
-0.4147708416,
0.114691861,
-0.3667782843,
0.0827341303,
-0.0945371911,
-0.6585191488,
-0.134925276,
0.2805446386,
-0.2165185511,
-0.140708521,
-0.3978204429,
0.4026741982,
-0.2620474696,
-0.1426786929,
-0.0697382018,
1.108966589,
0.6213068962,
-0.5545121431,
0.3755210638,
0.3953938484,
-0.3182344139,
0.3117777705,
-0.5767536759,
0.2776172161,
0.2389433086,
0.1803728789,
-0.2176668346,
-0.2644633353,
-0.015053303,
-0.6135393977,
-0.0376013145,
0.2079836279,
-0.3405804336,
-0.5813365579,
-0.2319121808,
0.4109045565,
0.5547977686,
-0.7488597035,
0.643733263,
0.3798754811,
-0.4233349264,
-0.7119134068,
-0.6726762652,
0.2361464649,
0.2800990045,
-0.5794810653,
0.270840615,
-0.0356012546,
-0.1791745722,
0.1496419609,
-0.2083560377,
-0.183707267,
0.7085794806,
0.4031906128,
0.1053282097,
0.183920294,
-0.0586427338,
0.2730591893,
0.1650140882,
0.2471994907,
-0.3877319098,
0.2617628872,
-0.11723838,
-0.4993326366,
-0.3268352747,
0.4987948537,
0.3470858932,
0.0107237604,
0.6674456596,
0.6749165654,
-0.4889168143,
-0.1378788352,
-0.2054525912,
-0.3049688339,
-0.5318607092,
0.3497874737,
-0.2018723041,
-0.6923342347,
0.4640901983,
-0.578505218,
0.4107272029,
-0.0488974638,
0.375309974,
-0.3953064084,
0.8587118387,
1.037248373,
-0.176766783,
0.5935149193,
-0.7180684209,
0.4665402472,
-0.6878471375,
-0.4593096673,
-0.5887223482,
-0.5727987289,
-0.4254063368,
-0.0566368029,
0.5614019632,
0.0942132697,
-0.2817279696,
-0.0067485701,
-0.5122545958,
0.4407753944,
0.9863184094,
0.2003931105,
-0.2069084048,
0.0092873704,
0.0154863549,
0.1475016326,
-0.9128248692,
-0.6455917358,
0.952046454,
-0.0275018401,
0.3881004453,
-0.0483980775,
0.8591092229,
0.7656704187,
0.5935793519,
-0.4803695083,
0.3433448374,
-0.0084002418,
-0.6633481979,
-0.2638933063,
-0.2773140073,
-0.8370420933,
-0.1334878504,
-0.0851292983,
-0.8007981777,
0.0664756522,
-0.0489198975,
-0.1492386609,
0.387272507,
-0.7773717642,
0.9204978943,
-0.5311690569,
-0.2717542052,
-0.3311344385,
-0.8953381181,
-0.2478374243,
-0.1370338947,
0.4359675348,
0.1947427839,
0.0450819246,
0.7241725326,
-0.5778058171,
0.7117551565,
-0.4266751707,
0.2452266812,
0.7968622446,
-0.2406270355,
-0.2796602547,
-0.0728484616,
-0.1743518412,
0.5503835678,
-0.1998756379,
-0.6574726701,
-0.5100224614,
0.7622163892,
-1.1323429346,
-0.6181975007,
-0.5757059455,
-0.7250270247,
-0.2326740623,
0.1746003777,
0.3132861257,
0.2997075021,
0.0791726857,
-0.1830312163,
0.2747887075,
-0.2965584993,
0.5142018199,
-0.1521889269,
0.1984399557,
-0.2000544518,
1.1894220114,
0.2489198446,
0.1274323612,
-0.1951784492,
-0.048938252,
-0.3359886408,
-0.3202198446,
-0.5350375175,
-0.0637951046,
-0.975278914,
-0.3244844973,
-0.280718267,
-0.3485251367,
-0.6123233438,
-0.8998209238,
0.1930711418,
-0.5502740741,
-0.4775795937,
-0.0074897604,
0.3223984838,
0.8988941312,
-0.5429216027,
0.6105239391,
-0.5337144136,
0.2023668587,
0.3921012282,
0.1399287879,
0.0393249355,
-0.0966847017,
-0.1765095294,
0.2113211304,
-0.769832015,
-0.731537044,
0.0895063803,
0.3127917349,
0.5245763659,
0.0274425205,
-0.1988988966,
0.5400468707,
-0.227319926,
1.1267074347,
0.011375756,
-1.0228081942,
0.8754573464,
0.3595947325,
0.0745846331,
0.7906889319,
0.761957109,
-0.4400677085,
-0.1892035753,
-0.5626658201,
-1.0029745102,
0.4934141934,
0.2496464998,
0.2617516518,
0.4322609901,
0.4015124738,
0.211783722,
0.394957006,
-0.3668521941,
-0.1541214436,
-0.780849576,
-0.4478723705,
0.0306072887,
0.3079456687,
-0.1071093008,
-0.1971623749,
0.9356831908,
-0.0071331393,
0.1651011109,
0.3524623513,
-0.3448881209,
0.5353737473,
0.1756673306,
0.3091965318,
0.5762435198,
0.1854110211,
-0.4281718135,
0.0882611349,
-0.9220781922,
0.1682852954,
0.3880776167,
-0.3655974865,
-0.2524828911,
0.2660958171,
0.4439714849,
-0.2491389364,
-0.6324461102,
0.3445375562,
-0.1013716012,
-0.1993337721,
-0.2606196702,
0.0764871314,
-0.0144215673,
0.2090901732,
0.5679628253,
0.0366480872,
0.2339298129,
-0.6923826933,
-0.0009340289,
0.2959555686,
-0.1332661659,
0.0170167517,
0.7340086699,
0.4745120406,
-0.419218719,
0.9304593205,
0.0464124419,
-0.8591605425,
1.2186508179,
0.7565310001,
0.5764074326,
-0.2335600406,
0.444190979,
0.0187833346,
0.3850989044,
0.344920516,
0.7289695144,
-0.5958375931,
-0.4383817017,
0.180289045,
-0.3154760301,
-0.8751510382,
-0.1951996237,
-0.2808418274,
0.1379724443,
-0.4992826283,
-0.2874800563,
0.0268561393,
0.150826931,
-0.5984611511,
0.2029533833,
0.1039609537,
0.8861113787,
-0.8723739386,
0.606357038,
1.1834567785,
-0.2862473428,
-0.6016094685,
-0.5419635773,
-0.1180027872,
-0.4295907617,
0.3746817708,
0.2646685243,
0.0196497925,
0.0245322939,
-0.8178571463,
-0.4360307753,
0.9993628263,
0.1007495597,
-0.3862957954,
0.3553625047,
0.1468936801,
0.4677655995,
-0.1499112397,
0.4511363506,
0.438010186,
0.5689148903,
-0.219581604,
-0.5190538168,
-0.5068794489,
-0.167777732,
-0.3217883706,
0.2454042733,
-0.5979793668,
0.7461708784,
-0.6090367436,
-0.1948422939,
0.2324223965,
0.8376456499,
0.051583901,
0.7472305298,
0.1233826429,
0.2106280476,
0.7921693325,
-0.4041183889,
0.7463713884,
-0.2448792905,
0.170543462,
0.5112039447,
-0.2705900371,
0.2641998827,
0.1499196887,
-0.2418381423,
0.7840608358,
0.8021130562,
-0.2935008407,
0.3363653123,
0.1370430738,
-0.5776497126,
0.1478064507,
-0.2522261441,
-0.5232992768,
0.5036738515,
0.8555983901,
0.128936708,
-0.1994907856,
0.6042192578,
-0.1351936013,
0.3444245756,
-0.896171391,
0.3310194314,
0.1318104863,
-0.310809046,
-0.0836495832,
-0.0515777282,
0.3873170018,
-0.7762639523,
-0.4923455417,
-0.0341707803,
0.1288848072,
-0.2765015066,
-0.7111365199,
0.1164791659,
0.0821741223,
0.1844022274,
-0.0716143027,
0.8018425107,
-0.327732861,
-0.5598957539,
0.0695775002,
0.1090256199,
0.1408869326,
0.476767838,
-0.6419350505,
0.1296867877,
-0.1947095394,
0.3969681859,
0.2979183793,
0.1012440622,
-0.2909884453,
0.8128805161,
0.5886597633,
0.26562047,
-0.0894157588,
0.1112070084,
0.5647227764,
-0.3347477913,
-0.7151319385,
-0.5462690592,
-0.0031339631,
-0.2138995975,
-0.3765292764,
0.8145831227,
0.3358216584,
0.8928089738,
0.1239613295,
1.1779065132,
-0.5378265381,
-0.0482708365,
0.0148088913,
0.7553982735,
-0.2952383757,
0.0434893966,
-0.2299801558,
-0.6910570264,
-0.0169575773,
0.6785535216,
-0.1157269105,
0.1426469535,
0.3182148039,
0.0523716584,
0.1375256926,
0.2485451251,
-0.1111562029,
-0.028354954,
0.2785108089,
0.4360097945,
0.6680085659,
-0.4399920404,
0.1153002307,
-0.706648469,
-0.4959200323,
0.0046765939,
-0.5478334427,
-0.8543576598,
-0.4929477572,
-0.2918308377,
-0.2381176353,
0.3213779032,
0.6344945431,
0.3496478498,
-0.9989817739,
-0.1929979026,
0.0096747791,
0.5471454263,
-0.3618035018,
-0.1940332502,
0.5467501283,
-0.2636766732,
-0.527690649,
0.4025013745,
-0.0447369926,
0.2706867456,
-0.2081349641,
0.4863625467,
-0.3264634907,
0.0140130185,
0.4138900638,
0.7893802524,
-0.1070279777,
-0.4101847112,
-0.1538252383,
0.1830055565,
-0.3261030614,
0.8072023988,
-1.0629615784,
0.4266430736,
0.3195501268,
1.2552235126,
0.2552309334,
0.1269014776,
0.4062180519,
-0.6692194343,
0.1077151969,
0.5714733005,
0.2030775994,
0.4998294115,
-0.3756509125,
0.5921756029,
0.1452924907,
-0.9465176463,
-0.8059160113,
0.0684910044,
-0.4832110107,
-0.4618767798,
0.1835097969,
-0.1906263083,
-0.0439093858,
-0.1915567815,
-0.156240508,
0.1956680864,
-0.0546864755,
1.175121665,
0.6868540645,
-0.4047502577,
0.3247421682,
-0.6610334516,
0.3671546578,
0.3188441396,
-1.034506917,
-0.5479362011,
0.1630062014,
0.0206932221,
0.473646462,
0.1920012981,
-0.1405623257,
0.6145763993,
0.2979934812,
0.0617258102,
-0.3161942661,
-0.7150005102,
-0.4176044166,
0.1041706055,
-0.3268106878,
-0.5085228682
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07386v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07386v1
|
Chain-of-Layer: Iteratively Prompting Large Language Models for Taxonomy Induction from Limited Examples
| 2024-02-12T03:05:54 | 2024-02-12T03:05:54 |
Qingkai Zeng, Yuyang Bai, Zhaoxuan Tan, Shangbin Feng, Zhenwen Liang, Zhihan Zhang, Meng Jiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Automatic taxonomy induction is crucial for web search, recommendation
systems, and question answering. Manual curation of taxonomies is expensive in
terms of human effort, making automatic taxonomy construction highly desirable.
In this work, we introduce Chain-of-Layer which is an in-context learning
framework designed to induct taxonomies from a given set of entities.
Chain-of-Layer breaks down the task into selecting relevant candidate entities
in each layer and gradually building the taxonomy from top to bottom. To
minimize errors, we introduce the Ensemble-based Ranking Filter to reduce the
hallucinated content generated at each iteration. Through extensive
experiments, we demonstrate that Chain-of-Layer achieves state-of-the-art
performance on four real-world benchmarks.
|
[
-0.6848878264,
-0.6010842323,
0.3520807326,
0.0777627677,
-0.1249245331,
0.4064029753,
-0.1173768044,
-0.6065913439,
0.1735971272,
0.4981856942,
-0.5140193105,
-0.4590859413,
-0.3806743622,
0.0794529915,
-0.6274598837,
0.8175999522,
0.0581116155,
-0.3963269591,
-0.4365468919,
0.0871670172,
-0.0210380182,
-0.4499416649,
-0.8547124267,
-0.5563362837,
0.7592409849,
0.3141527772,
0.5661541224,
0.8891533613,
0.3042149544,
0.2381582409,
0.1252756268,
0.3514688611,
-0.2515000403,
0.2887288034,
-0.535658896,
-0.1208454147,
-0.187940672,
-0.1687619835,
0.6503740549,
0.8871461749,
-0.4828669429,
0.2669256628,
-0.0372911245,
0.7343256474,
-0.8316863179,
-0.055264391,
-0.865080595,
-0.1599831879,
-0.0582453273,
-0.3556275368,
-0.5647745132,
-0.1400696337,
0.3946706653,
-0.664177835,
-0.2165859491,
0.3896501064,
0.5103909969,
0.1577419043,
-0.2827957273,
-0.5612363219,
-0.6793966293,
0.5248295665,
-0.3990414739,
0.3999179602,
0.4541938603,
0.1472366154,
-0.1366146207,
-0.8925452828,
-0.5070348978,
-0.1087643355,
-0.1187302694,
0.0815748051,
0.0578825474,
-0.0393707976,
0.0861940533,
0.49921152,
-0.606115222,
0.4414437115,
-0.2245853543,
0.2224658877,
0.5570415258,
-0.1366159469,
0.4493314326,
-0.1672482491,
-0.4288474917,
-0.2920328081,
-0.6321781874,
-0.2003003359,
0.3333578408,
0.3811928928,
0.4227336645,
0.2679427266,
-0.3746125698,
0.6609328985,
0.1323293447,
-0.1722753644,
0.1793689281,
0.1236653775,
-0.3150718212,
0.5272946358,
0.6023539305,
0.0174876545,
-0.1427807808,
-0.5011513233,
-0.4985823333,
0.2107946724,
0.368784219,
-0.5079279542,
-0.2342779934,
0.3730892837,
-0.250488013,
-0.5382620692,
0.2463710308,
-0.521050334,
-0.0826564655,
-0.2349928021,
0.7117266059,
-0.2770119011,
-0.4444286227,
0.161502257,
-0.1760988683,
0.0183560587,
0.0718911141,
-0.8862282634,
0.8648496866,
0.4632564783,
0.8140694499,
-0.3976123929,
-0.3758488297,
-0.5905100107,
0.2639490068,
-0.3658996522,
0.7952669859,
-0.6231378913,
-0.0998763368,
0.0338656642,
-0.0041262927,
-0.0011412225,
-0.7010617256,
0.134556368,
-0.7509460449,
0.2242993563,
0.016594151,
-0.6540971994,
-0.0603152514,
0.1262903214,
-0.6256045699,
1.0901175737,
0.4112977684,
-0.5294716358,
0.5519857407,
-0.6513302922,
-0.5903121829,
0.5359642506,
0.0241347943,
0.0311193746,
-0.2519704401,
0.268258065,
0.4458225071,
-0.4003849924,
0.4034416974,
-0.0003698819,
-0.3293833733,
-0.3247618675,
0.2176903486,
0.872300148,
0.4615547061,
-0.6038563251,
-0.0026654419,
-0.8692619801,
-0.0448861904,
-0.0709287748,
-0.125466913,
-0.7447103262,
0.1289715767,
-0.1374820173,
0.443723917,
-0.3550549448,
-0.1821817607,
0.4572432935,
-0.3016489446,
0.7669866681,
0.6338005066,
0.195926398,
0.8141226768,
-0.3608635962,
0.3618583381,
0.2574996054,
-0.038132906,
0.0556338839,
-0.3564764857,
-0.6238846779,
-0.0487499833,
0.4914982319,
0.4312494695,
-1.2588469982,
0.9060271382,
-0.2477472574,
-0.6609700918,
-0.2551570237,
0.3426727951,
0.1743986905,
0.4428075254,
0.4079293311,
-0.7544531226,
-0.4292595983,
-0.4814709425,
0.2381259799,
-0.3422508836,
-0.1409227699,
0.1293638349,
0.6434812546,
-0.4549771249,
0.6220287085,
-0.3008435071,
-0.2143193334,
0.0714061707,
0.2563329637,
-0.1033426449,
0.5750027299,
0.3340759277,
-0.4989104867,
-0.0589358248,
0.0672895834,
-0.765268743,
0.0842148811,
-0.1515339464,
-0.5608334541,
0.0585540123,
0.311712116,
-0.3583486378,
-0.0212374423,
0.3333578408,
0.0937789902,
0.2360837907,
-0.0897550508,
-0.2252410501,
-0.9169797301,
0.1081542298,
0.2475394607,
-0.0812455937,
-0.5033482313,
0.3202661276,
-0.1136101112,
0.194990322,
-0.2480645776,
0.4392321706,
-0.3199293315,
-0.1570936739,
0.0943636075,
0.3291406631,
0.0182674304,
0.4954017103,
0.2398365289,
0.3721989095,
0.7360978723,
-1.3124079704,
0.344430238,
0.2383907586,
-0.6594573259,
0.4497590065,
-0.0904963166,
0.1779581606,
0.0613327585,
0.4778755307,
-0.6984615922,
-0.4057237804,
0.130171448,
-0.0642728209,
0.1243295372,
-0.0561803691,
-0.7597975135,
-0.5449504256,
-0.2421523333,
0.3538320363,
0.5809608698,
-1.1205819845,
0.3131085634,
0.549861908,
0.3102600276,
-0.4729164243,
-0.5751574039,
0.1722483188,
-0.1540052742,
-0.413358897,
0.7486538291,
0.0457910635,
-0.4459463358,
-0.0693227798,
-0.1608877778,
-0.0241894145,
0.3910559118,
-0.0732336566,
-0.0377077609,
-0.1356861591,
0.570104301,
0.2564633787,
0.418112874,
0.2137692273,
-1.0049057007,
0.7042242885,
0.0618852898,
-0.167166993,
-0.431812793,
0.2607425153,
0.6315970421,
-0.1122304499,
0.5690689683,
0.2520442903,
-0.4979746044,
-0.8331153989,
-0.4153374434,
-0.3522115648,
-0.4893785417,
-0.1023371741,
-0.3074011803,
-0.6634855866,
0.3365128338,
-0.3024680018,
-0.1500800401,
0.5893871188,
0.2030410171,
-0.018283058,
1.0518677235,
0.3666839898,
-0.2599979043,
0.3606551588,
-0.484343797,
0.2811513543,
-0.8157641888,
-0.2404502928,
-0.4225437641,
-0.1236472428,
-0.9725324512,
0.1086811796,
0.2221797854,
0.1266612709,
-0.5009921789,
0.4611124098,
-1.0195459127,
0.2706669867,
0.8038418889,
0.4396986663,
0.3852400482,
0.2592869401,
-0.2688993514,
0.9179964066,
-1.0615487099,
-0.4412420094,
0.7827029824,
0.0943035483,
0.8019653559,
0.0761644989,
0.891931653,
0.2274314165,
0.1311539561,
-0.8745205998,
0.4239422977,
-0.0647758767,
-0.3689770401,
-0.4659831822,
-0.3277290165,
-0.6588012576,
0.0391000845,
-0.1269125789,
-0.6686828136,
0.309237808,
0.0185961276,
-0.3718051612,
0.5002894998,
-0.3533787429,
0.3314191401,
-0.1573530287,
-0.5111826062,
0.0691877604,
-0.7056586742,
0.5331392288,
0.0270218421,
0.1746710241,
0.3450139761,
0.2071425319,
0.6724671125,
-0.455470413,
0.4890185595,
0.0871527866,
-0.3166914284,
0.4700575471,
0.1972975433,
0.4484532475,
0.160882771,
-0.1536509544,
-0.1019549891,
-0.1071147397,
-0.0407534093,
-0.6380268931,
0.8714439273,
-0.6571673751,
-0.5554099679,
-0.3967974484,
-0.1597489864,
-0.2036027461,
-0.0638373643,
0.3146452606,
0.7443199158,
0.2294310927,
0.0654456615,
0.8604161143,
-0.1196912527,
0.3928880095,
-0.25749439,
-0.5309732556,
-0.2458257228,
0.984818697,
0.1827853173,
0.4360273182,
0.5350343585,
0.2681461871,
-0.3413264453,
-0.2366359979,
-0.6506997943,
-0.0884228796,
-0.8430407047,
-0.1826598495,
-0.7325336337,
-0.5559407473,
-0.3961263895,
-0.2079299986,
0.0496296436,
-0.5242372155,
-0.0491946079,
-0.2188987285,
0.3465282321,
0.8714516163,
0.0073343604,
0.1911772639,
-0.3778738081,
0.1209651604,
0.5866108537,
0.6073805094,
0.4310055971,
-0.3005908728,
-0.0995897651,
-0.2291390747,
-0.2140710652,
-0.2835811377,
0.2333171368,
0.4889279306,
0.6082173586,
0.5782192945,
0.081975624,
0.7458051443,
-0.3826759458,
0.8417185545,
0.0660538599,
-1.083758235,
0.753773272,
-0.2315189242,
0.30655846,
0.5475820303,
0.733928144,
-0.3985398114,
-0.4670411944,
-0.7067425251,
-1.0880817175,
0.4738954306,
0.1926840693,
-0.0961451903,
-0.38648507,
0.513135314,
0.2454345226,
0.3591537476,
-0.5390104651,
-0.3498853743,
-0.2266059369,
0.0804877281,
0.0394513458,
-0.1287920326,
0.0279715974,
-0.6690111756,
0.8777008057,
-0.091880627,
0.149105832,
0.2829541862,
-0.4847202897,
-0.2535615265,
0.0467594489,
0.4167613983,
0.9102287889,
-0.2223016769,
0.5113058686,
0.0576969646,
-0.1647745669,
0.1134569868,
-0.5589045286,
-0.1633763909,
0.0047892551,
0.2626419663,
0.7916453481,
0.313074261,
-0.4159969687,
0.1686183363,
0.3076855242,
-0.3808212578,
-0.1552374214,
0.2537568808,
-0.1609338224,
-0.1753172725,
0.5944398642,
-0.0781043917,
0.4323708713,
-0.940387845,
0.5651753545,
0.2087264806,
-0.1442432553,
-0.0449654758,
0.4198084474,
0.1937297881,
-0.2708661854,
0.7108758688,
-0.3368462622,
-0.6756061912,
0.4883590341,
0.6483830214,
0.7846437097,
-0.3339750469,
0.4630768597,
0.6209250689,
0.1769985706,
-0.5559100509,
-0.0529973209,
-0.4639709592,
-0.7409716845,
-0.2166540921,
-0.7660002708,
-0.5525302291,
0.1435038745,
-0.8153292537,
0.1716821641,
-0.5836394429,
0.1425332725,
0.1281757057,
-0.098253198,
-0.3905055821,
0.4594607651,
0.2129797786,
0.9573711157,
-0.6766602397,
0.8424112201,
0.6040113568,
-0.5457963943,
-0.6539571881,
-0.0861410126,
-0.1591971219,
-0.5394177437,
0.7934212685,
0.2713553309,
-0.4138964117,
0.4735075235,
-0.5934345126,
-0.8853796124,
1.3203889132,
-0.2282643169,
-0.5974568129,
-0.2621726096,
-0.2084971815,
0.5159700513,
-0.8142937422,
0.286128819,
0.5429523587,
0.252533406,
0.2927685082,
-0.7053135633,
0.1448936611,
-0.1741112024,
0.3873513341,
0.0751509741,
-0.3975102901,
0.7579799294,
0.2842661738,
-0.3259563446,
-0.1696908474,
0.3137657344,
0.1125366613,
0.0678469762,
0.8554147482,
0.5578519702,
1.0666180849,
0.0993570387,
0.8966118693,
-0.4638794065,
0.089858681,
1.1293128729,
-0.5668613911,
0.9324049354,
0.4302620292,
0.0464811362,
1.1633138657,
0.9674998522,
-0.0633186251,
0.7305861115,
0.6142142415,
-0.3760921061,
-0.2459192276,
-0.1567859054,
-0.2182880044,
0.3942398429,
0.3837488294,
-0.3343380392,
-0.0587027147,
0.2209437788,
-0.4393538535,
0.0058418736,
-0.6092754006,
0.9967323542,
0.038777478,
-0.9415946007,
0.5526922941,
-0.3860150278,
0.6795369387,
-0.3251826465,
0.0128794312,
-0.0111118313,
-0.0393081754,
-0.3808617294,
-0.5204901099,
-0.0110266358,
-0.3490925133,
0.0048436616,
-0.2719878852,
0.6985334754,
-0.4819936156,
-0.4017095864,
0.5110403299,
0.5255358815,
0.0072432831,
-0.1474138051,
-0.3246421516,
-0.290245533,
-0.5982424617,
-0.2540161908,
0.3327105641,
0.2655142248,
-0.2704163492,
0.8787873387,
0.6865757704,
-0.1248316988,
-0.1154539511,
0.1928260624,
0.9034306407,
-0.3811525702,
-0.4697628319,
-0.722568512,
0.3404509127,
-0.241994679,
-0.0589115955,
0.3900276721,
0.4709908664,
1.4687975645,
0.0441947132,
0.8253718019,
-0.1303443909,
0.0266291536,
-0.5860373974,
0.8809307218,
-0.6790830493,
0.3570076525,
-0.2725081742,
-0.9944639206,
-0.3972491324,
0.569154501,
0.1326086968,
-0.1721822321,
1.0321871042,
0.5456340909,
0.0380966887,
-0.0070432732,
0.2445194423,
0.002889381,
-0.0214046147,
0.2434929162,
0.732626617,
-0.5399326086,
0.0350882597,
-0.7058002949,
-0.2107516527,
-0.0499076173,
-0.7995500565,
-0.8517092466,
-0.9335023761,
-0.4883565903,
-0.4351046681,
0.0468276218,
1.3246136904,
0.8447943926,
-0.7860572934,
-0.5456938744,
-0.4050172567,
0.346395582,
-0.6844190955,
-0.2014079094,
0.2018298507,
-0.5851523876,
-0.435772717,
0.3209507167,
0.3432718217,
-0.4184727371,
-0.5196382403,
0.1660009921,
-0.6733337641,
-0.1273558885,
0.9799817801,
-0.0674794763,
-0.8299394846,
-0.303544879,
-0.1663858443,
-0.0174427368,
0.2146939039,
0.6345569491,
-1.0687984228,
0.4099091589,
0.2639992535,
0.5895919204,
0.4240691364,
-0.1691158414,
0.3899912834,
-0.7755435705,
-0.2368112653,
0.1054037511,
0.1686990559,
0.0935049802,
-0.6098151803,
0.8004230857,
0.1878926307,
-0.4031875134,
-1.0251492262,
0.1160931513,
-0.9809321165,
-0.2497459203,
1.0349776745,
0.2488055825,
-0.4628972411,
-0.0490336381,
0.2119048834,
0.1414798349,
-0.2936168015,
0.8992182016,
0.6757096648,
0.0636288747,
-0.2466773838,
-0.2812437713,
0.6216419339,
-0.1232805774,
-0.8823357224,
-0.2053555101,
0.0578503422,
0.1579619646,
0.3832464516,
0.1779352278,
0.2629291415,
0.0458684042,
-0.148648873,
-0.001710359,
0.2431037277,
-0.5146063566,
-0.0642298162,
0.2271981388,
0.0605648905,
0.1254766285
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07383v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07383v2
|
Making Flow-Matching-Based Zero-Shot Text-to-Speech Laugh as You Like
| 2024-02-12T02:58:10 | 2024-03-04T19:15:29 |
Naoyuki Kanda, Xiaofei Wang, Sefik Emre Eskimez, Manthan Thakker, Hemin Yang, Zirun Zhu, Min Tang, Canrun Li, Chung-Hsien Tsai, Zhen Xiao, Yufei Xia, Jinzhu Li, Yanqing Liu, Sheng Zhao, Michael Zeng
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD
|
Laughter is one of the most expressive and natural aspects of human speech,
conveying emotions, social cues, and humor. However, most text-to-speech (TTS)
systems lack the ability to produce realistic and appropriate laughter sounds,
limiting their applications and user experience. While there have been prior
works to generate natural laughter, they fell short in terms of controlling the
timing and variety of the laughter to be generated. In this work, we propose
ELaTE, a zero-shot TTS that can generate natural laughing speech of any speaker
based on a short audio prompt with precise control of laughter timing and
expression. Specifically, ELaTE works on the audio prompt to mimic the voice
characteristic, the text prompt to indicate the contents of the generated
speech, and the input to control the laughter expression, which can be either
the start and end times of laughter, or the additional audio prompt that
contains laughter to be mimicked. We develop our model based on the foundation
of conditional flow-matching-based zero-shot TTS, and fine-tune it with
frame-level representation from a laughter detector as additional conditioning.
With a simple scheme to mix small-scale laughter-conditioned data with
large-scale pre-training data, we demonstrate that a pre-trained zero-shot TTS
model can be readily fine-tuned to generate natural laughter with precise
controllability, without losing any quality of the pre-trained zero-shot TTS
model. Through objective and subjective evaluations, we show that ELaTE can
generate laughing speech with significantly higher quality and controllability
compared to conventional models. See https://aka.ms/elate/ for demo samples.
|
[
0.0600306168,
-0.6946073174,
0.5052973628,
0.4200554192,
-0.7074408531,
-0.0544895865,
-0.1754083037,
-0.485014677,
0.8330655098,
0.4083118141,
-0.6208925843,
-0.4787100554,
-0.2329444736,
0.1985595822,
-0.6887073517,
0.9404190779,
0.4839540124,
-0.543381691,
0.1398280114,
-0.1304442137,
-0.4563836455,
-0.22048226,
-0.6632460952,
-0.3509514332,
0.6756316423,
0.4971937835,
0.541011095,
0.382381171,
-0.1078926027,
0.2221768051,
-0.1182375476,
0.0442830026,
-0.4016706347,
0.4141826928,
-0.0570814461,
-0.4711263478,
-0.4627730548,
-0.4888958931,
0.2158824205,
0.0611813962,
-0.5318450332,
-0.0792183429,
-0.1833472997,
0.3415317237,
-0.6218311191,
-0.3771241009,
-0.871039629,
0.2110822499,
-0.0828946754,
-0.6142433882,
-0.4793131053,
-0.4499292374,
0.1057535633,
-0.4104069471,
-0.2690556049,
-0.0222276933,
0.8259232044,
0.5997985005,
-0.1750594527,
-0.4212467372,
-0.8837835789,
0.3949952424,
-0.9666061401,
0.2869691849,
-0.0509439372,
0.3394553065,
0.1470752954,
-0.6725637317,
-0.737447083,
-0.1496594548,
0.2648025155,
0.2491562814,
-0.0834830552,
-0.1124238446,
-0.0750293806,
0.1011483595,
-0.8742029667,
-0.0950639248,
0.1209130883,
0.0505939983,
0.5540741682,
0.037031576,
0.477275461,
-0.1322134286,
-0.0561368987,
0.0305470321,
-0.4710812569,
-0.1685076654,
0.430044502,
0.5504086614,
-0.1994594187,
0.8326642513,
-0.2353124321,
0.421085149,
0.0344135687,
-0.1104339212,
0.4841177464,
0.1528856903,
-0.5793314576,
0.3494462371,
0.8086746931,
0.3739886284,
0.7397059798,
-0.047975637,
-0.1772478074,
0.1084256545,
0.1527027488,
-0.7727492452,
-0.007840422,
0.4662760198,
0.282325387,
-0.5317668319,
-0.2641495764,
-0.7589173913,
-0.1174675897,
-0.249978736,
0.6467528939,
-0.6752645969,
-0.1259800941,
0.3521828651,
-0.2083733827,
0.1419466883,
0.3757234216,
-0.526696682,
0.0219500437,
0.3550597727,
1.0153182745,
0.1160046756,
-0.009900447,
-0.773984611,
0.0197029728,
-0.3410326838,
0.7192787528,
-0.3932709396,
-0.2530067861,
0.2345329821,
-0.2196109146,
0.0203805473,
-0.4679470658,
0.7251729369,
-0.4019644558,
0.3006673455,
0.3412615359,
-0.6219977736,
0.2234957814,
0.1319673508,
-0.2475518286,
0.6333301663,
-0.114525795,
-0.6092024446,
0.2717632651,
-0.6244618893,
-0.7504002452,
0.30633986,
0.0813136473,
-0.2728531659,
0.0826942399,
0.0499204695,
0.1085911095,
0.1524389237,
-0.0517437123,
-0.1999783665,
-0.4106683731,
0.152091071,
-0.3937562108,
0.644738853,
0.420165658,
-0.5709679127,
-0.1683006734,
-0.6835153103,
0.2894777954,
0.2931317985,
0.0739441589,
-0.0853431001,
0.1068113521,
-0.0187699106,
0.1944722384,
0.0186834782,
-0.5776190758,
-0.3416222334,
-0.8444119692,
0.4784184098,
0.4218456745,
0.2012965381,
0.3225371242,
-0.4785821438,
0.5394639373,
-0.0703450218,
-0.1955299377,
-0.7054029703,
-0.556314528,
-0.6707994938,
-0.4069704711,
-0.0090441024,
1.0717447996,
-0.8258260489,
0.4740041792,
-0.0865512788,
-0.4704124331,
-0.5573395491,
-0.2345021516,
0.1811203659,
0.7200086117,
0.4789190888,
-0.2498512864,
-0.3630986214,
-0.3862442672,
-0.2616573572,
-0.11045634,
-0.2924261093,
0.4806890488,
0.0086805224,
0.2676308453,
0.8198293447,
-0.3022116423,
-0.3984509706,
-0.0857649967,
0.4675017893,
0.3160844147,
0.1830428541,
0.8848122358,
-0.4903309047,
-0.8301645517,
0.1459644586,
-0.5137148499,
-0.6842178106,
-0.2036474347,
-0.012973615,
0.2945616543,
0.090852201,
-0.4452911615,
0.4690850079,
0.4061176479,
-0.4567885697,
0.5794519186,
-0.0832805336,
0.5496823788,
-0.8503332138,
0.125529781,
-0.1861815751,
-0.5404526591,
-0.7538549304,
-0.2063924819,
-0.3002104461,
-0.3625690639,
-1.0927587748,
0.6810587049,
-0.0345502086,
0.1364806741,
-0.3299061954,
0.2446034104,
-0.0116841551,
0.4737991691,
0.1550692171,
0.588881433,
0.7322226763,
-0.5282410383,
0.2297085971,
0.2031211853,
0.1309637278,
1.0783082247,
-0.8936607838,
0.2973033786,
-0.1041269749,
0.0020339731,
-0.7827104926,
-0.3538860381,
0.0426437706,
-0.8588603139,
0.227751404,
-0.0287306234,
-0.3832532167,
-0.2017033249,
-0.3523078561,
0.1436915696,
1.0170490742,
-0.5850736499,
0.3947105706,
0.0163885038,
-0.5825512409,
-0.3820256889,
-0.7624889016,
0.2538660467,
-0.420524478,
-0.8085847497,
0.6579867005,
-0.4224170446,
0.2413658351,
0.0566697009,
0.1962278336,
-0.2164535671,
-0.2497846484,
0.1506353617,
0.1073362678,
-0.2876186073,
-0.1455556899,
0.1990785003,
0.163282454,
-0.2996970117,
-0.2393490076,
0.5758152604,
0.1968968064,
-0.5886262059,
-0.8181315064,
0.306850642,
0.6694711447,
-0.0539953411,
0.3802501261,
0.3527312577,
-0.4807285666,
-0.3297221661,
-0.3161272109,
-0.1784902364,
-0.5052605867,
0.1447300762,
0.0585813075,
-0.9359772801,
0.3694112897,
0.304520905,
0.0437054262,
0.095195204,
0.6047959328,
-0.3486718833,
0.7909266353,
0.2497038692,
0.168154791,
0.6288326979,
0.1892518103,
0.133499369,
-0.2788808048,
-0.0121707283,
-0.5532929301,
-0.3785070479,
-0.1238792166,
-0.3087341785,
0.0152017027,
-0.1710209846,
-0.4445139766,
0.4683481157,
-0.4970054626,
0.5260018706,
0.3162479997,
-0.225211367,
0.1787071675,
-0.1204846948,
-0.31171152,
-0.1856281012,
-0.4455041289,
-0.4982542396,
0.5977560282,
0.1055339426,
0.6342110634,
0.0369449444,
1.0515202284,
0.3680332601,
0.1519841552,
-0.73508358,
0.4306710958,
-0.3046344221,
-0.3904778957,
-0.2354884893,
-0.4270212352,
-0.5474041104,
-0.4223923087,
-0.3363416791,
-1.0849972963,
-0.0932234004,
0.5128943324,
-0.5008359551,
0.2301873267,
-0.8079640865,
0.5301392674,
-0.0849328935,
-0.2946999073,
0.1262264401,
-0.6289600134,
0.3594413102,
0.055057615,
0.1695297062,
-0.1153632179,
0.2729769647,
0.2985182405,
-0.3329027891,
0.6282517314,
-0.1103592589,
0.144399792,
0.7930440307,
0.5215197206,
0.2814991474,
-0.0338566527,
-0.2081146687,
-0.0609033555,
-0.1586244106,
-0.1654366851,
-0.6335501075,
0.639803946,
-0.3720608056,
-0.2525635064,
-0.0545052625,
-0.040978387,
0.1044339612,
0.026915824,
0.3672559857,
0.3271051049,
-0.2330614626,
0.2980526686,
0.2488939911,
-0.2844569087,
0.7269024849,
0.2551536858,
-0.1669477969,
-0.6924744844,
0.93781358,
-0.0279961713,
0.2521545887,
0.580701828,
-0.0468525924,
-0.6253871322,
0.0597711504,
-0.4511052668,
0.3262141049,
-0.2397173792,
-0.3824128509,
-0.5379177332,
-0.5211657286,
-0.3080438375,
-0.5554961562,
-0.5344508886,
-0.5118191242,
-0.5690652728,
0.0197880846,
0.4212222099,
0.4077391028,
-0.0977837443,
0.4663776755,
-0.8386278749,
0.261513412,
0.6102407575,
0.3818396628,
-0.093679361,
-0.9033451676,
0.1270193905,
-0.1072568968,
-0.5185682178,
-1.2503373623,
0.7785409689,
0.7773097157,
-0.0486785918,
0.3755911589,
0.3220671415,
0.6904307008,
-1.0505121946,
0.8734862804,
0.4467554092,
-1.1450070143,
0.7074463964,
-0.204071179,
-0.0710425824,
0.2243525088,
-0.0602128841,
-0.5481583476,
-0.6362175941,
-0.7874636054,
-0.824601233,
0.5402331352,
0.6951758265,
0.5710385442,
-0.3710999787,
0.2802558541,
-0.3446105719,
0.2524552345,
-0.6210848689,
-0.1758292168,
-0.4848553836,
-0.5742496252,
0.3366130888,
0.0968529582,
0.0405127779,
0.2219162434,
0.6469154954,
-0.1432319283,
0.5281335711,
0.4315820038,
-0.0626013502,
-0.4425835907,
0.4840138853,
0.9084525704,
-0.0976467133,
-0.4672476947,
0.1582108289,
0.2184483856,
-0.2949347198,
0.181949079,
-0.1728045493,
-0.0952297598,
0.3836263716,
0.1479125917,
0.9117607474,
0.1398453861,
-1.0237714052,
0.7309459448,
0.075563699,
-0.384319514,
-0.2389494181,
0.3341606557,
0.2051334977,
0.2020673454,
0.2825787663,
-0.1248606965,
-0.0553288311,
-0.5462237597,
0.5762554407,
0.2375940531,
-0.4357726574,
-0.6221981049,
1.2009986639,
0.3053102493,
-1.0282777548,
0.2842660546,
-0.616417706,
-0.5021756887,
0.542429626,
0.8042157888,
1.144453764,
-0.2530443966,
0.4635168016,
0.4339365065,
0.1048071682,
0.3387372196,
0.4976090789,
0.1530835927,
-0.6297085285,
-0.6418806911,
-0.5466956496,
-0.5688016415,
0.0664721429,
-0.3284671307,
0.7897776961,
-0.3467246294,
-0.1717686802,
-0.2254877239,
-0.4336296618,
-0.5594497919,
0.5020172596,
0.5962467194,
0.8887655139,
-0.8749877214,
0.6081833243,
0.3825791478,
-0.2223250121,
-0.716750443,
-0.0642853454,
-0.0068157054,
-0.7178617716,
0.1290967464,
0.1627542675,
-0.2613349557,
0.2082141042,
-0.5099503398,
-0.212307319,
1.1138517857,
0.6095839143,
-0.5207885504,
0.0146459956,
-0.0142511809,
0.653396666,
-0.5910365582,
0.5048664212,
0.2811489403,
0.0728928447,
0.9548602104,
-0.9259569645,
-0.3070086837,
-0.1540610343,
-0.3820049763,
0.0731720477,
-0.2248238623,
0.5603939295,
-0.3799546361,
-0.3363983035,
0.1489727348,
0.6588556767,
0.5547907352,
0.6802200675,
0.6715449095,
0.8088062406,
0.4891563952,
0.1304458827,
0.4924231172,
-0.328463912,
0.3616219461,
1.5279880762,
-0.7085406184,
1.1393173933,
0.2966273129,
0.0975675657,
0.6708685756,
0.2963353992,
0.5181489587,
0.6181761622,
-0.023005534,
-0.2711595595,
-0.0396946929,
-0.2429737151,
-0.0936228931,
0.2084917575,
0.3186232448,
-0.1693287045,
-0.1466196477,
-0.2560055852,
-0.056852635,
0.137215808,
0.0195078496,
0.6595531702,
0.1258378029,
-0.4107713103,
0.3913789093,
-0.3922340274,
0.7811951637,
-0.3636364043,
-0.0768970773,
-0.1888119578,
-0.5356871486,
-0.1425063908,
-0.9230593443,
0.5642607212,
0.5798537731,
0.4106401205,
0.0825829655,
0.5847508311,
-0.5092340708,
-0.1302612871,
0.3973261714,
0.4393278062,
0.1942683458,
-0.1910459697,
-0.5680860877,
-0.2757489383,
-0.0094284685,
-0.2844963074,
-0.1139236167,
0.9736027122,
0.3668908179,
0.4170663953,
0.5286855698,
0.3763440549,
0.1895817518,
0.4007897079,
0.5212536454,
-0.7607634664,
-0.7024685144,
-0.8797159195,
0.9904920459,
-0.1722783893,
-0.2632487118,
0.0136292465,
0.2505261302,
0.3071539402,
-0.062446855,
0.4244677126,
-0.2630740106,
0.6927543283,
-0.2491558343,
0.7675626278,
-0.9323837757,
-0.1487655789,
-0.5401691198,
-0.8878249526,
-0.4650929868,
0.5296495557,
0.3108897805,
-0.08125595,
0.6019082665,
0.8120676279,
-0.0061201258,
-0.1336509883,
0.8961258531,
0.1660110652,
0.2805169523,
0.4739021063,
0.5739299655,
-0.1876446158,
0.6877381206,
-0.1481700093,
-0.1835142374,
-0.4778726101,
-1.4312936068,
-0.6673517823,
-0.3616225421,
-0.5486629605,
-0.0622377619,
-0.1397530138,
1.0572990179,
0.7641860247,
-0.6297698021,
0.1313949525,
-0.0612264685,
0.0109698465,
0.1712516695,
-0.2893356681,
-0.2070482224,
-0.3539746404,
-0.8291336894,
0.50892663,
0.7466646433,
0.4119705558,
0.3430661857,
-0.2657851279,
-0.0027397342,
0.9084174633,
0.6037786603,
0.6687080264,
-0.4144080579,
-0.6906630993,
0.4043956399,
0.0506058484,
0.1373452693,
0.2689705193,
-0.5794469714,
0.4230855107,
0.3512123227,
0.5424170494,
0.4264180064,
-0.1574134678,
0.3624921143,
-1.1425780058,
0.2501082122,
0.5577059984,
0.2718873322,
0.4681721032,
-0.3189165294,
0.3029892445,
0.2094597518,
-0.7360270619,
-0.8556301594,
0.2086856961,
-1.2701354027,
0.2783614695,
0.8032898903,
-0.1751264036,
-0.3123488128,
0.2559943795,
-0.2942068875,
0.471359849,
-0.5111527443,
0.6612731814,
0.3649437428,
-0.2011594623,
-0.1983065009,
-0.3821374178,
0.2248651385,
0.6234201789,
-0.7398456931,
-0.2567872107,
0.1410500705,
0.2184665501,
0.2100815922,
0.846630156,
0.1203127876,
0.3427464664,
-0.2446334213,
0.1756076217,
0.3213952184,
-0.539260149,
-0.2921427488,
0.1404605657,
0.0344037041,
-0.1764632463
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07368v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07368v1
|
Assessing Generalization for Subpopulation Representative Modeling via In-Context Learning
| 2024-02-12T01:55:51 | 2024-02-12T01:55:51 |
Gabriel Simmons, Vladislav Savinov
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
This study evaluates the ability of Large Language Model (LLM)-based
Subpopulation Representative Models (SRMs) to generalize from empirical data,
utilizing in-context learning with data from the 2016 and 2020 American
National Election Studies. We explore generalization across response variables
and demographic subgroups. While conditioning with empirical data improves
performance on the whole, the benefit of in-context learning varies
considerably across demographics, sometimes hurting performance for one
demographic while helping performance for others. The inequitable benefits of
in-context learning for SRM present a challenge for practitioners implementing
SRMs, and for decision-makers who might come to rely on them. Our work
highlights a need for fine-grained benchmarks captured from diverse
subpopulations that test not only fidelity but generalization.
|
[
-0.3475947678,
-0.6346080303,
0.3402875662,
0.1123575941,
-0.4089184701,
0.0081014251,
-0.4807483554,
-0.2355459332,
-0.1064810306,
0.5216050744,
-0.3407751322,
-0.6702746153,
-0.4725312889,
0.1097250208,
-0.2968054712,
0.6978110671,
0.2766773403,
0.3202854395,
-0.845025301,
-0.0320186466,
-0.4082648158,
-0.8751980066,
-0.4464938343,
-0.4597036541,
0.2143073082,
0.6478712559,
0.2550348938,
0.379205972,
0.5090045333,
0.1977334023,
0.1218284294,
-0.111879088,
-0.9948585629,
-0.1789089143,
-0.2738141119,
-0.4368676245,
-0.1238151491,
0.3662673831,
0.9413303733,
0.9614666104,
-0.3264209032,
0.2897195816,
0.0201821215,
0.5693936944,
-0.6737615466,
0.1152585968,
-1.1356468201,
-0.0574433692,
-0.0285142232,
-0.3050346673,
-0.5645514727,
-0.5586813092,
0.5623216629,
-0.245995,
0.5862602592,
0.2310407311,
0.5132856965,
0.1395290047,
-0.765746057,
-0.2333793193,
-0.6073476076,
1.0087842941,
-0.5123440027,
0.3676661253,
0.5386863351,
0.4052063823,
-0.4936213195,
-0.6738936901,
0.0459690541,
-0.3657841384,
-0.0587077141,
0.3315062523,
-0.0013280078,
-0.0929834396,
0.1419968754,
0.3975533545,
-0.3232320845,
0.0082891574,
-0.3484338522,
0.0905577019,
0.6527507305,
0.2115968764,
0.2401100099,
-0.0204351861,
-0.5832366943,
-0.0509209745,
-0.7161614895,
0.1950805038,
0.5108424425,
0.6778169274,
-0.361743927,
0.3755595386,
-0.2059480101,
0.5754234791,
-0.06729123,
0.2311272174,
0.2305384129,
-0.5677357316,
-0.3760226965,
-0.2755977809,
0.5662151575,
0.3967519104,
0.5180848241,
-0.1967153996,
-0.0231996831,
-0.1399180144,
0.0607084371,
-0.7521009445,
0.1734785587,
-0.0334914438,
-0.6465594769,
0.0378534831,
0.2262639552,
-0.9392825961,
-0.1940244734,
-0.5967310071,
-0.1309354156,
-0.2578772604,
-0.1752406508,
-0.0905055553,
-0.1934158653,
0.4197416306,
0.2891158462,
-0.9592831135,
0.5099310875,
0.7058425546,
0.7066859603,
-0.4073670208,
0.0116791911,
-0.399874121,
-0.0849251077,
-0.576138556,
0.7183998823,
-1.0499763489,
-0.6272084713,
0.0143030668,
-0.122599788,
-0.467551738,
-1.2691222429,
0.1491356045,
-0.5663257837,
0.2125041336,
-0.2597842813,
-0.6935355663,
0.0639512315,
0.1581225842,
-0.4634245634,
0.9446302056,
0.5202612281,
-0.4083724916,
0.7422578335,
-0.2968814075,
-0.0394035429,
0.0063206311,
-0.3559881747,
-0.3794438541,
0.495914489,
0.1239365041,
0.4395816624,
-0.146474421,
0.291852653,
-0.4026270807,
-0.4875290692,
0.1199295446,
-0.1109804139,
0.4252171814,
-0.1569627374,
0.0919683725,
0.170738399,
-0.4254213274,
-0.3165301979,
-0.1732006967,
-0.3624882102,
-0.5479730964,
0.0363194793,
-0.0057155951,
-0.0373670124,
0.078041099,
-0.5853849053,
0.2551106215,
-0.1207456589,
0.1192592308,
0.6843140125,
0.1228045151,
0.7323934436,
-0.1596988589,
0.7112057209,
0.0862831399,
-0.0015204098,
0.1135769859,
-0.3145993948,
-0.2977489233,
-0.3107371628,
0.7768874764,
0.4724819958,
-0.6308422089,
0.1218213737,
-0.3504098058,
-0.2647788227,
0.1935889125,
-0.0635169223,
0.2149683833,
0.556651175,
0.3572847843,
-0.4649581909,
-0.7057092786,
-1.0279493332,
-0.315092057,
-0.1581512839,
-0.2039568871,
0.614556849,
0.8799254894,
-0.3066233993,
1.032556653,
-0.1148951948,
-0.2665080726,
-0.4302535951,
0.0327722467,
-0.1475747973,
0.4954224825,
0.6390340328,
-0.6661358476,
-0.516846478,
0.0587720871,
-0.4569038153,
-0.1922632605,
0.2230177075,
0.0174498074,
0.0876950398,
0.517688036,
-0.0490954891,
0.5901750326,
0.7640063763,
-0.2350992709,
0.4803273082,
-0.035486009,
0.2215550989,
-0.7421373725,
-0.191931963,
0.3711195886,
-0.2525238097,
-0.3575775921,
-0.088201426,
0.073761344,
0.2055813223,
-0.4290657938,
0.4059045017,
-0.318844974,
-0.4520806074,
-0.0034086651,
-0.065810807,
-0.6208944321,
-0.0130375652,
0.1616240591,
0.995442152,
0.0984310657,
-0.4032813907,
0.0943212286,
-0.1247557178,
-0.665602684,
0.5291020274,
-0.6051724553,
0.1622418463,
-0.5232296586,
0.7401855588,
-1.1296854019,
-0.6731551886,
-0.1095343903,
-0.4185461998,
0.023230521,
-0.2340284288,
-0.0847340375,
-0.0075762705,
0.0473414548,
0.4982974827,
0.5039775968,
-0.2698145211,
0.7297664285,
0.48847121,
-0.0849058926,
-0.3629713655,
-0.4650791287,
-0.0950263515,
-0.6036384106,
-0.2341913283,
0.2280305028,
0.1993204951,
-0.5616737604,
-0.0752476752,
0.0072872485,
-0.0631644726,
-0.1164627522,
-0.0565262921,
0.0623377673,
-0.0377166048,
0.2363048494,
-0.2376314104,
-0.1260855198,
-0.0714924857,
0.1415494233,
0.5862900019,
-0.0179790743,
-0.3117369711,
-0.1878283918,
0.3262420595,
0.3209918141,
-0.0947846398,
0.7040243149,
0.2267165631,
-0.4565686285,
-0.3228468597,
-0.4591470659,
-0.2493546605,
-0.3154381812,
0.6804956794,
-0.2694312334,
-1.0960358381,
0.7476758957,
-0.3435325623,
0.1348588616,
0.1942531019,
0.5294161439,
0.1797897816,
0.9438410401,
0.5879361629,
0.0663475543,
0.6517022252,
-0.2888061702,
-0.2413868755,
-1.0312796831,
-0.4972028732,
-0.6026009917,
-0.3673395813,
-0.4020109475,
-0.6777169704,
0.281435281,
-0.06811928,
-0.2324234992,
0.0350931622,
-0.1968134344,
0.630017221,
0.4965450168,
0.1293838024,
0.2383104265,
0.2113653123,
-0.0184947923,
-0.4534774721,
-0.5206264853,
-0.6718516946,
1.3084877729,
0.3669410646,
0.8711616993,
0.1017374918,
0.5563697815,
0.3334935009,
1.0363746881,
-0.7190833688,
0.4301863611,
-0.5496588349,
-0.4124560058,
-0.3636424839,
-0.8549013138,
-1.0182209015,
0.7905367017,
-0.0642252862,
-0.6780906916,
0.4868602753,
0.1269739121,
-0.2430061698,
0.0716837794,
-0.6818551421,
0.6274443269,
-0.0530185737,
-0.0107955718,
-0.1352755874,
-0.4610320926,
0.527905941,
-0.0957339332,
0.3544109166,
-0.3798148036,
-0.4506599307,
0.6252364516,
0.0301086307,
0.9248681664,
-0.296811223,
0.0883546323,
-0.0578607172,
-0.4835858345,
0.2812720239,
0.1215596274,
-0.3580648899,
0.1344889849,
-0.107016474,
-0.4738235772,
-0.5912569165,
0.461025238,
-0.7647262812,
-0.4951818585,
-0.3318628073,
-0.6696426868,
-0.5478767157,
-0.3029349148,
0.3299026787,
0.5100004673,
-0.6365188956,
1.0008305311,
0.7603569031,
-0.1689636558,
0.0240430124,
0.4843854904,
-0.3654852808,
-0.5640252829,
0.5110584497,
0.4025964439,
0.4566768706,
0.2007488757,
0.460213542,
-0.6219069958,
-0.5276651978,
-0.3451687098,
-0.022625355,
-0.5001202226,
0.1258092076,
-0.3963310122,
0.0084634935,
-0.3887190819,
0.1372952014,
-0.1293257773,
0.037114542,
-0.336435616,
-0.0731141493,
-0.2897542715,
0.8600607514,
0.1588728875,
0.2609862685,
-0.2326274365,
0.1654009372,
0.5112398863,
0.0770407468,
0.0582881086,
-0.8081217408,
-0.2231226414,
0.0493271016,
-0.106921345,
-0.7321100831,
0.1131595299,
0.3535466492,
0.9366565943,
0.087236397,
0.1507592499,
0.822307229,
-0.4190545082,
0.8958625197,
-0.0531969815,
-0.693410933,
0.3133330047,
-0.3808936179,
0.2954772115,
0.6843080521,
0.2531417012,
-0.3642947972,
-0.3487046957,
-0.4917547107,
-0.8966385126,
0.444209069,
-0.0688609108,
0.5100522637,
-0.0074617863,
0.4778700769,
0.1223618537,
0.2838101089,
-0.5142635703,
-0.0771959275,
0.0094814664,
-0.174464047,
-0.2230865359,
-0.3298341036,
-0.1293288171,
-0.4010672271,
0.3645486832,
-0.3212580979,
-0.1917644441,
0.2718307078,
0.1273106188,
-0.2775226831,
0.3436136544,
0.7613357902,
1.104649663,
-0.3370513618,
0.0121150017,
0.5337502956,
-0.2655638456,
0.2864300907,
-0.1316723675,
-0.1911384016,
-0.1802203506,
0.6531668901,
0.579397738,
0.3914421201,
-0.4696444273,
0.4392453432,
-0.4149464667,
-0.3537408113,
-0.2593864202,
-0.0410870314,
0.0809322372,
-0.0004335479,
0.8146011829,
-0.1879320145,
-0.0065605403,
-0.7733991742,
0.2498546243,
0.7962244153,
-0.5358842611,
-0.2578021884,
0.5088368654,
0.2359867096,
0.0050153844,
0.5546470284,
0.2069170624,
-0.2787980735,
1.1266742945,
0.8065296412,
0.6382084489,
-0.3258380592,
0.0039622243,
0.4733456671,
0.4304959476,
0.0522166453,
0.0341513716,
0.1062825024,
-0.7028452158,
-0.364076525,
-0.3912947774,
-0.7232226729,
0.343837291,
-0.8786209226,
-0.1343652606,
-0.3890550435,
-0.4764202237,
-0.4012903869,
-0.0053541628,
-0.6727916002,
0.362536937,
0.0160737392,
1.1379996538,
-1.0663489103,
0.3797905147,
1.0021058321,
-0.0003639615,
-0.4618490934,
0.3857846558,
-0.2412016988,
-0.6159455776,
0.6740772128,
0.2064086497,
0.1229061559,
-0.0849604085,
-0.9102030396,
-0.8985921741,
0.8837264776,
0.5985165238,
-0.5516260266,
0.2722483277,
0.1875247955,
0.5910050869,
-1.0511951447,
0.3663935959,
0.6716468334,
0.2914699316,
0.003698746,
-0.785752058,
-0.2856190503,
0.154303357,
0.5603881478,
-0.0934887603,
-0.9351705313,
0.8323026299,
0.1575586349,
-0.293451786,
-0.0416801833,
0.946398139,
0.6416101456,
0.4327234924,
0.6820746064,
0.5937356353,
0.5606510043,
-0.2570482492,
0.9949465394,
-0.0883785412,
0.5378612876,
1.1443885565,
-0.2628843486,
0.8973586559,
0.502060771,
-0.3932351768,
0.7708362937,
0.8394784331,
0.4265382886,
0.5504766107,
0.5585718751,
-0.3324994445,
-0.5716726184,
-0.3933930695,
-0.6085779071,
0.3597303927,
0.4553174973,
-0.3814788163,
-0.4178476036,
-0.0666251853,
-0.4074845016,
0.4117469788,
-0.3254362941,
0.6692805886,
0.3164173961,
-0.5604410172,
0.1586718112,
-0.3216643035,
0.5980331898,
-0.6448177695,
-0.248166889,
-0.3473987877,
0.0652938113,
-0.1956067532,
-0.5712918639,
0.2924742997,
-0.1068015322,
-0.4084274173,
0.0002434006,
0.5739713907,
-0.6708669662,
-0.6429813504,
0.4876500964,
0.4797853529,
0.131227985,
0.2630726397,
-0.4108982086,
0.1856887937,
-0.0826504454,
-0.4160491824,
0.5287157297,
0.2236220241,
-0.3510109186,
0.7562333941,
0.7568660975,
0.2435605675,
0.0216730256,
0.3788160086,
0.5488900542,
-0.3413323462,
-0.2608737051,
-0.7761197686,
0.4157183766,
-0.2158175856,
-0.3709584475,
0.9454546571,
0.7960754633,
1.2240794897,
-0.1900612265,
0.9707192779,
0.0709796622,
0.6833814383,
-0.324845016,
0.1969260573,
-0.5187938809,
0.1130962446,
0.0489048213,
-0.8389562368,
-0.1847846508,
0.5740398169,
-0.8801698089,
0.3440131247,
0.2058551461,
0.6095807552,
-0.1992911696,
-0.275017947,
0.5448618531,
-0.2575581372,
0.0926486775,
0.3555578887,
1.0807857513,
-0.1138277501,
0.226729244,
-0.2159978449,
-0.5791585445,
-0.197462514,
-0.8023186326,
-0.961394906,
-0.3239084482,
-0.1383864731,
-0.0657023862,
-0.0249280613,
1.1268634796,
0.9857333899,
-0.8976678252,
-0.5035251975,
0.1994427741,
0.0329648927,
-0.006928049,
-0.3428287804,
0.0931126326,
-0.3145545125,
-1.0501891375,
0.2540833354,
0.0520439781,
-0.0369344912,
-0.3967762291,
0.0727154016,
0.0662731007,
0.2158717513,
0.662989676,
0.0930063725,
-0.6687589288,
-0.2357788235,
-0.279125452,
-0.0916152671,
-0.080952771,
0.9843956232,
-0.728612721,
0.2920822501,
0.5884274244,
0.3876793683,
0.1543041766,
0.9741470814,
0.6620759368,
-0.8797754645,
0.0892489851,
0.2118865848,
0.3030870259,
0.5067251921,
-0.2371904254,
0.710881114,
0.3074865043,
-0.8749296069,
-0.8491665125,
0.3932900131,
-0.5012539625,
0.0489802696,
1.2609093189,
-0.1347831786,
-0.0117767928,
-0.3717741668,
0.0226671472,
-0.0120813577,
-0.6329946518,
0.5774114132,
0.6516265273,
-0.3503678441,
-0.3988771439,
-0.7628355622,
0.2691192329,
0.1389677376,
-0.7489958405,
0.0284778588,
0.5079802871,
0.5256197453,
-0.2822497487,
0.8475220203,
-0.1478257179,
0.0951466486,
-0.2971110344,
-0.1556752771,
0.3278680742,
-0.3004764318,
-0.3897263706,
0.2290549725,
-0.302844733,
-0.0235039759
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07321v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07321v1
|
Summing Up the Facts: Additive Mechanisms Behind Factual Recall in LLMs
| 2024-02-11T22:58:49 | 2024-02-11T22:58:49 |
Bilal Chughtai, Alan Cooney, Neel Nanda
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
How do transformer-based large language models (LLMs) store and retrieve
knowledge? We focus on the most basic form of this task -- factual recall,
where the model is tasked with explicitly surfacing stored facts in prompts of
form `Fact: The Colosseum is in the country of'. We find that the mechanistic
story behind factual recall is more complex than previously thought. It
comprises several distinct, independent, and qualitatively different mechanisms
that additively combine, constructively interfering on the correct attribute.
We term this generic phenomena the additive motif: models compute through
summing up multiple independent contributions. Each mechanism's contribution
may be insufficient alone, but summing results in constructive interfere on the
correct answer. In addition, we extend the method of direct logit attribution
to attribute an attention head's output to individual source tokens. We use
this technique to unpack what we call `mixed heads' -- which are themselves a
pair of two separate additive updates from different source tokens.
|
[
-0.2463413328,
-0.9009903073,
0.7423138618,
-0.0695866272,
-0.1278185099,
0.1110165492,
-0.1360090077,
-0.4657469988,
0.3830255866,
0.5412116647,
-0.5868319869,
-0.1651427001,
-0.5440226793,
0.1907123327,
-0.5190047026,
1.0508966446,
0.0599250235,
-0.0428812988,
-0.3671696782,
-0.3622652888,
-0.3154009283,
-0.7948246598,
-0.4329624772,
-0.4266468287,
0.7317234278,
0.362236172,
0.5198886991,
0.8067443371,
0.5219680667,
0.361684829,
-0.1441280395,
0.1918411553,
-0.6579173803,
0.1436933279,
-0.365131408,
-0.8856027126,
-0.4355776608,
-0.0808963776,
0.6169683337,
0.642180562,
-0.0334429182,
0.2092171758,
-0.1134258211,
0.5485137105,
-0.6816184521,
0.2259512842,
-0.7621043921,
-0.1392889619,
-0.1019384339,
-0.5183265209,
-0.4657488465,
-0.2298183292,
0.0929691792,
-0.3928759694,
0.578548789,
-0.0543264486,
0.6027104259,
0.2039050907,
-0.6220540404,
-0.6441282034,
-0.8890740871,
0.6708524823,
-0.3050158322,
0.1913640797,
0.0832390562,
-0.2382074744,
0.0566457137,
-0.7073425651,
-0.5424993038,
-0.2724528015,
-0.5166208148,
0.19299303,
-0.1428020298,
0.0019271121,
0.4676955938,
0.5395140052,
-0.3017965555,
-0.1622016728,
-0.4952141345,
-0.4750603735,
0.4352498651,
0.333902508,
0.4541836083,
0.0129487766,
-0.4186847508,
0.0509690493,
-1.1842893362,
-0.1184090972,
0.0398363024,
0.3654215932,
-0.2003934979,
0.868082881,
-0.0193530694,
0.6023763418,
0.3202323914,
-0.2718579769,
-0.2848450541,
-0.6064975262,
-0.0657412186,
0.564067781,
0.3952720463,
0.0532528944,
0.1552620232,
-0.2633925676,
-0.2476864159,
0.1280687451,
0.1957417727,
-0.6510460377,
-0.246339187,
0.1356180012,
-0.1701508611,
-0.2433695495,
-0.0599245392,
-0.1912994683,
-0.2701876163,
-0.619291842,
0.5301703215,
-0.2218087316,
-0.0525356643,
0.0882270038,
-0.2369570732,
0.1354999393,
0.3097981811,
-0.9355637431,
0.3088874519,
0.85884583,
0.8853835464,
-0.2772474289,
-0.2785533667,
-0.645783782,
0.4191388786,
-0.2436924428,
0.8898439407,
-0.3779687881,
-0.2183220685,
0.029169606,
0.0597244799,
-0.1046951339,
-0.4786381125,
0.4468078017,
-0.7733153105,
0.3914622664,
-0.9226756096,
-0.8876051307,
-0.4344002306,
0.1130152643,
-0.9254680872,
0.7868703604,
-0.1352385283,
-0.9103597403,
0.0723728985,
-0.4397889078,
-0.5824382901,
-0.0906910598,
-0.3505850732,
-0.169246912,
0.4014796019,
-0.0135050192,
0.1723822057,
-0.3003112078,
0.3629380167,
-0.254301995,
-0.3885035515,
0.6712911129,
-0.4692502916,
1.0055575371,
-0.0319912881,
-0.1273076087,
0.2666249275,
-0.8079423308,
-0.8354490995,
0.0880161747,
-0.5071671605,
-0.4112071395,
0.0086583439,
-0.4370820522,
0.075652644,
0.323278904,
-0.4527007341,
0.1490905285,
0.0623381436,
0.1544737965,
0.6273435354,
0.3558287919,
0.3795481324,
-0.5333348513,
0.0961521417,
0.405223161,
-0.3194470108,
-0.5314894915,
-0.1490249634,
-1.1679389477,
-0.363424927,
0.1566120982,
0.5610027313,
-0.7386078835,
0.1993783265,
-0.2589057982,
-0.1712151766,
-0.2078432739,
-0.1626721919,
0.0994261056,
0.6428989768,
0.0653353631,
-0.1891653687,
-0.4882909656,
-0.8405941129,
-0.1905377209,
-0.2952603996,
-0.1031955481,
0.0639494285,
0.5543526411,
0.1248263121,
0.976403892,
-0.6938525438,
-0.0905670524,
-0.1499569714,
0.278785795,
0.3268870115,
0.2422920316,
0.6137735248,
-0.5992840528,
-0.0462177992,
-0.2253007442,
-0.9941917062,
-0.0132259354,
-0.400026232,
0.1526811719,
0.1896546185,
0.4053322375,
-1.1315528154,
0.0877103284,
0.2473032624,
-0.3696611226,
0.7450643182,
-0.1446431726,
0.272588253,
-0.7183914185,
0.0960339382,
-0.2864711583,
-0.1854804158,
-0.8404839635,
0.2671782672,
0.1355416775,
-0.0396105759,
-0.2626876533,
0.228961423,
-0.5027760863,
-0.1834113151,
-0.3898902535,
0.2441394031,
0.1623308361,
0.6943005323,
0.0223175585,
0.9388245344,
0.567543447,
-0.9432448745,
0.6316132545,
0.109805502,
-0.262696743,
0.5041891932,
-0.545809269,
0.0601918213,
-0.2515880764,
0.2173213214,
-1.013995409,
-0.2918753624,
0.2417908907,
-0.2510408461,
0.4386599362,
-0.1151101068,
-0.4612324536,
-0.0842315853,
-0.2853461206,
0.364002943,
0.2331589013,
-0.4493678808,
0.8874564171,
0.5314762592,
-0.5428333282,
-0.5053187609,
-0.6005920172,
0.1654719263,
-0.3422931433,
-0.4392664433,
0.2962003946,
0.0215360802,
-0.4404686689,
0.2123961151,
-0.2699238658,
0.0946738496,
0.0890074372,
-0.1522202343,
0.4739641845,
-0.4435456097,
0.216205731,
-0.177271992,
-0.227175355,
0.3515723646,
-0.304317385,
0.3296658397,
0.0338508002,
-0.5462605357,
-0.1821788847,
0.3600124121,
0.7194190621,
-0.0883835107,
0.5797709227,
0.4911209345,
-0.3006152213,
0.3070366681,
-0.7062122822,
-0.4153907299,
-0.4418505132,
0.4476236999,
-0.3685142696,
-1.1283932924,
0.9617806673,
0.0919956937,
0.1556624025,
0.6131653786,
0.9099455476,
-0.0386458375,
0.5233536959,
0.5476391315,
-0.054176636,
0.1955403686,
0.0166148487,
0.1420448422,
-0.5581591725,
-0.0971276611,
-0.4255907536,
-0.093683742,
-0.6778822541,
-0.5245357156,
0.5874407887,
-0.1458081156,
-0.1192437261,
0.1477152109,
0.0658451542,
0.4953649044,
0.7491260171,
0.1611057669,
0.6405835152,
0.098382622,
-0.0316817164,
0.0613834374,
-0.9234470725,
-0.2064994574,
1.0133770704,
0.2246409655,
0.7771177888,
0.2392383069,
0.4987653792,
0.4252521992,
0.2565536201,
-0.8426581025,
0.5635148287,
0.0746534094,
-0.8156024218,
-0.0140839405,
-0.4143033922,
-0.5409430265,
0.2707817554,
-0.2819056213,
-0.4406015575,
0.3507188857,
0.3339951038,
-0.4709715843,
0.4365145266,
-0.4579706788,
0.243388027,
-0.1236188188,
-0.5913553834,
-0.60696733,
-0.6513856649,
0.7212818861,
-0.0592617765,
0.1483208239,
0.1735480428,
0.0535780042,
0.581789434,
0.0170626957,
1.0401197672,
0.1420754939,
-0.3965529799,
0.5043063164,
0.3046679795,
0.8440758586,
-0.1347656399,
0.3513499498,
-0.0311597493,
-0.2983751297,
-0.3837069273,
-0.641305089,
0.6546071172,
-0.6535069346,
-0.8857591748,
-0.5741285086,
-0.6994363666,
0.0480642132,
0.0037169224,
0.1165411621,
0.8335439563,
-0.2061382383,
0.2571408451,
1.0961575508,
-0.1639018804,
0.3965631127,
0.8174682856,
-0.1223278567,
-0.2980100811,
0.9808669686,
0.2746890187,
0.3119236231,
0.6989750862,
0.0463917814,
-0.256072253,
-0.3219935596,
-0.34745121,
0.490006566,
-1.0246579647,
-0.1041870266,
-0.7274067402,
-0.1646739691,
-0.1098838001,
0.0985107198,
-0.2255906612,
-0.8162316084,
-0.1235437915,
-0.3841027915,
0.3948033452,
0.9401661158,
-0.2841612697,
0.2706954777,
-0.7531088591,
0.5003704429,
0.5305868983,
0.2582057714,
0.0873020813,
-0.4978789687,
-0.5267825127,
0.0543855391,
-0.1854614317,
-0.9361940026,
-0.1423291415,
-0.1858526468,
0.466049403,
0.4405006766,
-0.0416018926,
0.5910286903,
-0.4685716927,
0.7344392538,
0.1657669991,
-0.661670208,
-0.0183024835,
-0.3365473747,
0.2163112909,
0.1164573282,
0.2900832295,
-0.6482611299,
-0.6010623574,
-0.6673519015,
-0.6741858125,
0.8147630095,
0.1002206728,
0.1706701964,
-0.1707044691,
0.2885106206,
0.0016038897,
0.1244145483,
-0.7155407667,
-0.5224187374,
-0.0290911533,
-0.1353627592,
0.1058160067,
-0.8019089699,
-0.6096180081,
-0.1800183952,
0.6095792651,
0.1276490092,
0.3957620263,
0.2509055138,
-0.6175299287,
-0.1221441403,
0.1675683111,
1.0982745886,
0.8480017781,
-0.1934738159,
0.5601863265,
0.1554639041,
-0.3632873595,
0.0200799294,
-0.3104993701,
-0.4920041859,
0.1690536737,
0.8085551262,
1.0618050098,
0.3650331795,
-0.2756701708,
0.198249042,
0.048043184,
0.0529092364,
-0.3199183047,
0.179588303,
0.3388712406,
0.2115917206,
0.6136018038,
0.2168978006,
0.2645561397,
-0.8185626268,
0.4378001988,
0.3131658137,
-0.2864745855,
-0.5719109774,
0.4617204368,
0.2694024742,
-0.0877105594,
0.4619783759,
0.0970354825,
-0.5520934463,
0.4892933965,
0.639767766,
0.96728158,
-0.1588588804,
-0.0109036956,
0.5595656037,
0.3780981004,
0.1705591381,
-0.084729068,
-0.1338869333,
-0.7466470003,
-0.7769954205,
-0.333160311,
-0.3461163342,
0.0853270367,
-0.6105782986,
0.0111111449,
-0.027208006,
0.0313032717,
-0.069551982,
-0.2154765874,
-0.4580296576,
-0.0103791812,
0.2883562744,
0.7323301435,
-1.2117984295,
0.4285141528,
0.3816276491,
-0.3981011212,
-0.407715112,
0.076350674,
0.180343926,
-0.9539319873,
0.5182422996,
-0.2497196496,
-0.2912811935,
0.0279356502,
-0.5153693557,
-1.1026442051,
0.8825178742,
0.3629747331,
-0.4901536107,
0.1019274667,
0.2400558591,
0.2504775226,
-0.4661651254,
0.1509408206,
0.6903566122,
0.3667797446,
0.2568834424,
-0.4342094362,
0.2817676365,
0.0787821934,
-0.3833238184,
0.014493553,
-0.5024870634,
0.9238383174,
-0.5122922659,
-0.4415383935,
-0.3264852166,
0.7773928642,
0.4673093557,
0.1118221432,
0.2299919128,
0.458684057,
0.7970343828,
-0.0538732,
1.2146023512,
-0.4436721802,
0.4485251904,
1.200936079,
-0.1221696436,
0.302736342,
0.4589406252,
-0.3572954237,
0.5710056424,
0.5342128873,
0.0918337256,
0.4528137445,
-0.2191664726,
-0.5272956491,
-0.2769544125,
-0.2106494457,
-0.0409768783,
0.3872459829,
0.4541504383,
-0.1944082677,
-0.4123644829,
-0.3531202078,
0.2605243027,
-0.2341780216,
-0.3171811402,
1.1249964237,
0.0654266179,
-0.8482052088,
0.4415715039,
-0.1242362186,
0.1487776786,
-0.5657212734,
-0.0282034725,
-0.4981027842,
0.1263127029,
-0.0203052107,
-0.7289165854,
0.2919212282,
-0.13758035,
-0.5759136677,
0.0361075066,
0.7077879906,
-0.8745892048,
-0.5887030959,
-0.0480846725,
0.3821898699,
-0.1052690148,
0.1333807856,
-0.4016311467,
0.1431774944,
0.0392349213,
-0.2440967411,
0.226049915,
0.7148630619,
-0.2260646373,
0.5677684546,
0.5713866353,
0.0426183641,
0.1156432927,
0.184528783,
0.8501912355,
-0.7336599231,
-0.340905726,
-1.2543566227,
0.488915503,
-0.0017708509,
0.2280573696,
0.7490316629,
0.6532202959,
0.5849505663,
-0.3427602351,
0.7511776686,
0.0663967878,
0.2807266116,
-0.7481409907,
0.4930377603,
-0.2105296254,
0.1808899343,
0.1060554907,
-0.8142350316,
-0.1397000402,
0.2218399793,
0.092380628,
-0.2078452706,
0.912597537,
0.798612833,
-0.2556705773,
-0.0089198118,
0.1527023315,
0.7234269977,
0.1704429388,
0.3247812688,
0.9183562994,
-0.1752320677,
0.2367709577,
-0.0104276948,
-0.161721915,
-0.4258287251,
-0.8640795946,
-0.5464735031,
-0.5916721225,
-0.458512038,
-0.1433670968,
-0.1605665684,
0.77668643,
0.1882668734,
-1.0635125637,
-0.3773320913,
0.023888303,
0.5372101665,
-0.08038681,
-0.1761166453,
0.6315742135,
-0.5139282942,
-0.3057690561,
0.2138486505,
0.5412713885,
0.120752871,
-0.2652648389,
0.1487881094,
-0.2433596849,
0.3590209782,
0.8033512831,
0.1000711918,
-0.7934288979,
-0.4226907492,
0.1166530773,
-0.0454668663,
0.105990082,
1.4141613245,
-0.6414769292,
0.383970052,
0.6308623552,
0.4158866704,
0.5878424048,
0.137763232,
0.7408559322,
-0.8477331996,
0.2299496084,
-0.1514022946,
0.6060499549,
0.4235266149,
-0.256262064,
0.2709390521,
0.6681643724,
-0.3499696553,
-0.7188769579,
0.4557792544,
-0.8951467276,
-0.3142774701,
0.8494703174,
-0.1263094246,
-0.2595854104,
-0.1596827656,
-0.0472812653,
0.5547457933,
0.0964487121,
1.0491113663,
0.8291748762,
-0.1214612573,
-0.1207747981,
-0.2548932731,
0.5547015071,
0.1805934161,
-0.3436718285,
0.4195106924,
0.8518832326,
0.5004662275,
0.4696680605,
0.6221104264,
-0.0895966217,
0.2784361839,
0.0796863958,
0.0024681871,
-0.009251616,
-0.567612052,
-0.2077895254,
0.1965366304,
0.0110642277,
0.0397473685
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07319v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07319v1
|
ODIN: Disentangled Reward Mitigates Hacking in RLHF
| 2024-02-11T22:40:12 | 2024-02-11T22:40:12 |
Lichang Chen, Chen Zhu, Davit Soselia, Jiuhai Chen, Tianyi Zhou, Tom Goldstein, Heng Huang, Mohammad Shoeybi, Bryan Catanzaro
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In this work, we study the issue of reward hacking on the response length, a
challenge emerging in Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) on
LLMs. A well-formatted, verbose but less helpful response from the LLMs can
often deceive LLMs or even human evaluators to achieve high scores. The same
issue also holds for some reward models in RL. To address the challenges in
both training and evaluation, we establish a more reliable evaluation protocol
for comparing different training configurations, which inspects the trade-off
between LLM evaluation score and response length obtained by varying training
hyperparameters. Based on this evaluation, we conduct large-scale studies,
where the results shed insights into the efficacy of hyperparameters and tricks
used in RL on mitigating length bias. We further propose to improve the reward
model by jointly training two linear heads on shared feature representations to
predict the rewards, one trained to correlate with length, and the other
trained to decorrelate with length and therefore focus more on the actual
content. We then discard the length head in RL to prevent reward hacking on
length. Experiments demonstrate that our approach almost eliminates the reward
correlation with length, and improves the obtained policy by a significant
margin.
|
[
-0.5099409819,
-0.5760443807,
0.3637217581,
0.3914860785,
-0.4526505172,
0.3974730968,
-0.022202272,
-0.6445279717,
0.4994069934,
0.255784899,
-0.7845960259,
0.1977443844,
-0.9157266617,
0.0024616197,
0.1123179197,
1.1686837673,
0.0416374542,
0.1683537364,
-0.5026824474,
-0.086938642,
-0.4834252596,
-0.4608579278,
-0.7383474112,
-0.7741255164,
1.0257055759,
0.0924414098,
0.4959797263,
0.6633728743,
0.6292088032,
0.2535226941,
-0.262917906,
0.2054824233,
-0.7395442724,
0.0903261304,
-0.1199867725,
-0.5026928186,
-0.4185105264,
-0.0156568252,
0.3572562337,
0.2051667273,
-0.2321349829,
0.2480732054,
0.3049769104,
1.1346849203,
-0.9620699286,
0.0505300388,
-0.2628200352,
0.3658401072,
-0.0542498305,
-0.46661973,
-0.4471678734,
-0.0983736441,
-0.1441634744,
-0.4896827936,
-0.0373368934,
-0.0416136011,
0.7634718418,
0.510258317,
-0.2699535489,
-0.0824205428,
-0.7794443965,
0.9212418199,
-0.6002775431,
0.4046579599,
0.5970303416,
0.5102121234,
-0.3325511813,
-0.3667091429,
-0.3808895648,
-0.391879946,
-0.2159602791,
0.2262043804,
0.2370184362,
0.1956329942,
0.3350199163,
0.2229163498,
-0.3464255631,
0.3571383953,
-0.2746250927,
-0.2959626019,
1.0234204531,
0.5301255584,
-0.3299655318,
-0.1800640225,
-0.5961832404,
-0.5752494931,
-0.8727045655,
0.5265530944,
0.7918697596,
-0.0579086393,
-0.0178275146,
0.3488301337,
-0.3089702725,
0.6805834174,
0.1867672801,
-0.404299587,
-0.0359643064,
-0.1414382011,
-0.0700834766,
-0.0994770378,
0.621928215,
0.3167452514,
-0.1338474452,
-0.4149902761,
-0.5193932056,
-0.0372114107,
0.4637903571,
-0.7505469918,
-0.017748313,
0.3713202775,
-0.6504207253,
-0.5272294879,
0.3033921421,
-0.7453832626,
-0.6497284174,
-0.1659651995,
0.4117603302,
-0.0192927681,
-0.2522021532,
0.2998789549,
-0.52109164,
0.2662224472,
0.3118653595,
-1.1244972944,
0.4224916399,
0.9814743996,
0.4639039934,
-0.3652951419,
-0.6536689997,
-0.8264011741,
-0.0812739208,
-0.0404502936,
0.2252788395,
-0.0850820765,
-0.4411135018,
-0.1145084277,
-0.1768926829,
0.2785088718,
-0.3955072165,
0.188357994,
-0.9492250085,
0.0792411342,
-0.4558020532,
-0.6492485404,
0.1422157586,
0.5018567443,
-0.8049889207,
0.4658508897,
0.0056313644,
-1.1121349335,
0.5236812234,
-0.6205669045,
-0.4317258,
0.0580225922,
-0.1755991727,
-0.5904142857,
0.0481415689,
0.1551885158,
0.3099557757,
-0.132364437,
0.2692623734,
-0.3772052526,
-0.8898504972,
0.6412853599,
-0.6915005445,
0.5516474843,
0.0734535828,
-0.4354376197,
0.210314393,
-0.5001978278,
0.0141961277,
0.223756969,
-0.6960181594,
-0.1690123826,
-0.0887382179,
0.002071189,
0.0597366579,
0.4135578573,
-0.7257902026,
0.0516631193,
-0.2385093123,
0.2194631547,
1.0620399714,
0.2023299932,
0.1937564462,
-0.5562127233,
0.6743792295,
-0.0404953882,
0.4637020826,
0.1941239685,
-0.1167929992,
-0.3371597528,
-0.5166624784,
0.5863835216,
0.3058592677,
-0.7847652435,
0.4185280502,
0.0323690213,
-0.3932638764,
-0.6306335926,
-0.0164835583,
0.8540241122,
0.4708817005,
0.3424916863,
-0.303624332,
-0.3005699813,
-0.8296648264,
-0.5542562008,
-0.1921913326,
-0.2878430486,
0.2616450787,
0.5414790511,
-0.0125415633,
0.8750813603,
-0.5333167315,
-0.1684604138,
-0.199855566,
0.330242455,
0.1395804584,
0.5724135041,
0.1146393195,
-0.762294054,
-0.2378312498,
-0.4351962805,
-0.4668555856,
0.4555402398,
-0.2711366117,
0.1407455355,
0.0558767132,
0.1515086442,
-0.481482774,
0.7444858551,
0.3193671703,
-0.366085887,
0.695196569,
-0.3978912532,
0.4416436553,
-0.5639353991,
0.0433237404,
-0.1794137806,
-0.4325518608,
-0.0241311323,
0.0207818057,
0.2344139516,
0.3746141791,
-0.5856158137,
0.512704134,
-0.2129315287,
-0.1833774447,
-0.4478617609,
-0.2246253043,
0.1172044948,
0.9706158638,
-0.0324941501,
0.6365658045,
0.2053789198,
-0.7723344564,
0.6671267748,
0.2010183781,
-0.2781341076,
0.580302,
-0.8681173325,
0.2264159769,
-0.0665580332,
0.495631367,
-0.6838972569,
-0.3353708684,
0.2318541259,
-0.6101084948,
0.4632032514,
-0.1004538536,
-0.5187008977,
-0.3020412326,
-0.8388463259,
0.4956027269,
0.5429837108,
-0.7517143488,
-0.0556616858,
0.3786983192,
0.3480212092,
-1.0035923719,
-0.667252779,
-0.182114467,
-0.6043703556,
-0.3669856787,
0.5051194429,
-0.1071007028,
0.0941421315,
-0.1477509886,
-0.2007983029,
0.222513184,
0.5113266706,
0.3654023111,
0.3024503589,
0.3481624126,
0.0353494883,
-0.0008479469,
-0.1733993292,
0.4740763009,
0.1573759466,
0.474838078,
-0.0529385842,
-0.7474356294,
-0.5168969631,
0.1508094221,
0.3746557832,
-0.1683139205,
0.7032405734,
0.5343208313,
-0.1925818622,
0.0286589116,
-0.3432596028,
-0.7899449468,
-0.4806752801,
0.4300407171,
-0.2633014023,
-1.170842886,
0.5597248673,
-0.1154156476,
0.04436763,
0.0513277352,
0.4034493864,
-0.2187177092,
1.1424142122,
0.6980012059,
-0.1227692142,
0.3119025528,
-0.1037422791,
-0.1286771148,
-1.1177469492,
-0.4920445979,
-0.1872695684,
-0.7445452809,
-0.6034305096,
-0.2157826126,
0.4845142663,
0.1602824777,
-0.2543591559,
0.0673489943,
-0.2862845063,
0.6956684589,
0.3908830881,
0.4063846767,
0.0333895274,
-0.2011583,
0.0441700146,
-0.1838859916,
-0.6894256473,
0.1592092067,
1.0762088299,
0.8418313861,
1.1200429201,
0.1118543074,
1.1057009697,
0.4949585497,
-0.1397908032,
-0.6924338341,
0.2946144938,
0.3840739727,
-0.2949524522,
-0.6609755158,
-0.6454315782,
-1.0462931395,
0.2534357905,
-0.060600169,
-0.6463964581,
-0.0519432724,
0.2433108091,
-0.5060459971,
0.1823398918,
-0.1338189393,
0.579859674,
-0.3647070825,
-0.6613381505,
-0.3897455037,
-0.8807579875,
0.4456461668,
0.2069954723,
-0.0992427468,
0.2315485477,
0.1427497417,
1.2127892971,
-0.4714432061,
0.778221488,
-0.3032812476,
0.0729033425,
-0.1385375708,
0.117205359,
0.683062911,
0.6626964211,
0.3986414373,
0.007150373,
-0.0387918241,
-0.7122953534,
-0.6804702282,
0.7205188274,
-0.8195414543,
-0.6954808235,
-0.5636420846,
-0.6041957736,
-0.5855848789,
-0.1407588124,
0.2581266165,
0.1089970171,
-0.1684577912,
0.1039843336,
1.0279206038,
-0.1634011418,
0.4876571298,
0.3311119676,
-0.341817826,
-0.5634848475,
0.7024485469,
-0.4220603108,
0.2954713702,
0.3442276716,
0.2207774371,
-0.6248517036,
-0.1745032072,
-0.5097339749,
0.3081443608,
-0.6097531915,
-0.4677646756,
-0.1289770454,
-0.3122416437,
-0.1794497967,
-0.0637573749,
-0.5711373091,
-0.4231088161,
0.0350859202,
-0.2130612433,
0.5251859426,
0.9454884529,
-0.2810145617,
0.1994763911,
-0.7548565269,
0.1707303375,
0.3773056269,
0.5704927444,
0.3586905897,
-0.5403898358,
-0.3962213397,
0.1723812073,
-0.1373003423,
-0.8410853744,
0.1978850663,
-0.5399451256,
0.5913251042,
0.2534022033,
0.0863556117,
0.7753092051,
-0.1272210926,
0.6885944605,
0.6477857232,
-0.653059721,
0.2341243625,
0.0227035489,
0.3792871833,
0.5437610149,
0.303158164,
-0.6393493414,
-0.2106219679,
-0.6348982453,
-0.7173250318,
0.8339969516,
-0.0483302511,
-0.0290571898,
0.2231656462,
0.1929226518,
0.2355730683,
0.4064831734,
-0.6361139417,
-0.2045124471,
-0.0972001925,
0.2482092083,
0.0526805408,
-0.4446384013,
-0.5989988446,
-0.1798139811,
0.643011272,
0.0018291133,
0.3119232953,
0.1171062738,
-0.1095336005,
-0.2706664503,
0.1776019335,
0.673266232,
0.86642766,
-0.3640666306,
0.2018237263,
0.0181352291,
-0.3716887236,
0.2842120826,
-0.1969898045,
0.2084649652,
-0.2559175491,
0.5061351061,
0.7834498286,
0.0353390165,
-0.6078980565,
0.6929473281,
-0.3697056472,
-0.3528691232,
-0.0644739792,
-0.0725927949,
0.2363675684,
0.2250200659,
0.1391982138,
-0.072665818,
0.0473772921,
-0.0125536686,
0.366651088,
0.4134159088,
-0.6903494,
-0.1617177278,
0.4028543532,
0.1269528717,
-0.4503836632,
0.6767564416,
-0.3409958482,
-0.5144366026,
0.7457402349,
0.3941895068,
0.8362759948,
-0.0608431734,
0.4545044005,
0.2005272657,
0.0987482965,
-0.0462175161,
0.0495498478,
-0.3112383485,
-0.2929931581,
-0.4533366263,
-0.6848900914,
-0.4062413573,
0.3996984661,
-1.062530756,
-0.0040619997,
-0.576446116,
0.1386898309,
-0.2988540232,
0.0542589612,
-0.5898241997,
-0.1435758471,
-0.0493641011,
0.8370507956,
-0.7663481832,
0.7442930341,
0.3904616535,
-0.463173002,
-0.7414931059,
0.0284828506,
-0.0314995162,
-0.6972744465,
0.8279306293,
0.1368141025,
-0.2621143758,
-0.4723837972,
-0.431137979,
-0.5413179994,
1.3452714682,
0.0633822232,
-0.6023264527,
0.2192371041,
0.4177674055,
0.4455877841,
0.0184394643,
0.181811288,
0.5452236533,
0.2856121957,
0.110962905,
-0.953436017,
0.137696296,
0.2092366368,
0.1318085194,
0.2958298028,
-0.6529014111,
0.6740371585,
-0.0469335429,
0.1668072939,
-0.2631593049,
0.5594613552,
0.7522223592,
0.2804360688,
0.621450901,
0.6585744023,
0.6937188506,
0.3767587841,
0.9532142282,
0.024713764,
0.5172644258,
1.058442235,
-0.279143244,
0.6687334776,
1.0795503855,
-0.3450658321,
0.1591060609,
0.8757969737,
0.2844080329,
0.9455693364,
0.7995085716,
-0.1017096862,
-0.1745757312,
0.1510809958,
-0.3412921429,
0.2298067063,
-0.0111327386,
0.1607186794,
-0.3183009923,
0.156891197,
0.121991843,
0.1326651573,
-0.2607456148,
0.8660767078,
0.0803281069,
-0.913535893,
0.6925280094,
0.1927863508,
1.0299528837,
-0.6551728249,
-0.1075195,
-0.5569310188,
0.2857832909,
-0.1193260998,
-0.6599374413,
0.2966970801,
-0.1011575237,
-0.1036211029,
-0.1742068678,
0.6022503972,
-0.2248352021,
0.2184774131,
0.4067831337,
0.1774321198,
-0.1064989865,
0.003338089,
-0.8838617802,
0.1348377317,
-0.0319640376,
-0.3893590271,
0.969427228,
0.0784258768,
-0.0254169218,
0.5798913836,
0.6482746005,
0.0118535142,
-0.0375653282,
-0.2915853858,
0.9402161837,
-0.6393808126,
-0.9143188596,
-1.0676082373,
0.4306482971,
-0.247772634,
-0.2144775987,
0.4862042367,
0.4053166807,
0.9356867671,
-0.3029467165,
0.3970668614,
0.1334436685,
0.3062673807,
-0.6076825261,
0.9139345288,
-0.5498770475,
0.4938614368,
0.0586782657,
-0.542016983,
0.0887603089,
0.2257427275,
0.0070736324,
-0.0609690063,
0.5314325094,
0.6389015913,
-0.1073449627,
-0.250947684,
0.4224654734,
-0.3010364473,
0.4524515867,
0.7302862406,
1.0879594088,
-0.2184953839,
0.2575329244,
-0.3865762949,
-0.3600585163,
-0.3895803094,
-0.8649743795,
-0.8135634065,
-0.4618117213,
-0.2047320753,
-0.4383579791,
0.1314145625,
0.4513951838,
0.7363343835,
-0.5361219049,
-0.379727453,
-0.1389349103,
0.4216257632,
-0.5210175514,
-0.2243497819,
0.3065526485,
-0.2878771126,
-0.2422123104,
0.3506820202,
0.3524241149,
-0.1481686831,
-0.7353876829,
-0.7779473662,
-0.1745990962,
0.1260980517,
0.1369007528,
0.3225601614,
-0.7499910593,
-0.3711508214,
-0.0847160295,
-0.2501990795,
-0.1686168015,
0.7917132378,
-0.9321286678,
0.2280331254,
0.6251836419,
1.1306045055,
0.6231831312,
-0.1247956604,
0.3265799582,
-1.0097332001,
0.3142393231,
0.3494836688,
0.189933911,
0.1639799923,
-0.6996669173,
0.2858100533,
-0.0765326992,
-0.7307085395,
-1.0449142456,
0.5412220955,
-0.8914188743,
-0.396007359,
0.9460574985,
-0.6003680229,
-0.3466011584,
0.2554914653,
-0.0247557852,
0.105708614,
-0.1346208602,
1.2966301441,
0.7229682803,
-0.3015791774,
0.036532186,
-0.1340485513,
1.024009347,
0.7915405035,
-0.6932652593,
0.1438605934,
0.1389273405,
0.1812854558,
0.1104929522,
0.5700258017,
-0.1934611499,
0.736634016,
-0.0356191583,
-0.1095321476,
-0.5220624804,
-0.4722745121,
-0.7063819766,
-0.1151671261,
0.4645229876,
-0.5899122953
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07309v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07309v3
|
HyperBERT: Mixing Hypergraph-Aware Layers with Language Models for Node Classification on Text-Attributed Hypergraphs
| 2024-02-11T21:16:26 | 2024-05-25T12:10:38 |
Adrián Bazaga, Pietro Liò, Gos Micklem
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
Hypergraphs are characterized by complex topological structure, representing
higher-order interactions among multiple entities through hyperedges. Lately,
hypergraph-based deep learning methods to learn informative data
representations for the problem of node classification on text-attributed
hypergraphs have garnered increasing research attention. However, existing
methods struggle to simultaneously capture the full extent of hypergraph
structural information and the rich linguistic attributes inherent in the nodes
attributes, which largely hampers their effectiveness and generalizability. To
overcome these challenges, we explore ways to further augment a pretrained BERT
model with specialized hypergraph-aware layers for the task of node
classification. Such layers introduce higher-order structural inductive bias
into the language model, thus improving the model's capacity to harness both
higher-order context information from the hypergraph structure and semantic
information present in text. In this paper, we propose a new architecture,
HyperBERT, a mixed text-hypergraph model which simultaneously models hypergraph
relational structure while maintaining the high-quality text encoding
capabilities of a pre-trained BERT. Notably, HyperBERT presents results that
achieve a new state-of-the-art on five challenging text-attributed hypergraph
node classification benchmarks.
|
[
-0.2566137314,
-0.7372745872,
0.298931241,
0.0950272009,
-0.118798919,
0.3782726228,
-0.207431227,
-0.7335112095,
0.2880058289,
0.5653039217,
-0.2904637754,
-0.7048398852,
-0.5444486737,
-0.178842634,
-0.4180322587,
1.2550853491,
0.1766494215,
-0.2666446269,
-0.0100939805,
0.0236717239,
-0.0136999767,
-0.796875,
-0.1957259923,
-0.4055508971,
0.5741847157,
0.1810789853,
1.1789956093,
0.6323513985,
0.2378066778,
0.3204161525,
-0.1873713434,
0.3762928843,
-0.3714378774,
0.0912258327,
-0.034425348,
0.10631302,
-0.7233355045,
0.109591037,
0.9241794944,
0.8229587078,
0.2821092606,
0.0642933995,
0.212123841,
0.4496946037,
-0.7678718567,
0.1672406197,
-0.6677954793,
0.0778950676,
0.0392670818,
-0.1263234913,
-0.6318794489,
-0.0791257992,
0.4548756778,
-0.5211302042,
0.2360280156,
0.0486216247,
0.9530755877,
0.0210404526,
-0.1278710067,
0.1611967683,
-0.8990398645,
0.5598003864,
-0.4274488688,
0.687291503,
0.2597231865,
0.1838857681,
0.2244359106,
-1.0057234764,
-0.6240624785,
-0.2120364606,
-0.2353849262,
0.083258301,
-0.0385990217,
0.1791837811,
-0.0179340467,
-0.0615153909,
-0.4576627612,
0.1652186215,
-0.0174700376,
-0.2972563207,
0.4357143939,
-0.101725027,
-0.0153361373,
-0.2584489882,
-0.7123963833,
-0.2609981596,
-0.4831922948,
-0.1564420462,
0.394977957,
0.4275689423,
0.1583945006,
0.2608969808,
-0.0651483536,
0.7107910514,
-0.2725854516,
0.3000120223,
0.4570098817,
-0.1389180571,
-0.3614082336,
0.2395226806,
0.8169823885,
0.1101882532,
0.3580366373,
-0.2179836929,
-0.1067956984,
-0.2553996444,
0.0709052086,
-0.797291398,
-0.3904551864,
0.3476425111,
-0.3028901517,
-0.5044152737,
-0.1006177515,
-0.4630914032,
-0.4788270891,
-0.1929167509,
0.1512663662,
-0.3694083989,
-0.3601936102,
0.0424256586,
-0.0691939369,
0.0145060411,
0.4825732112,
-0.5129358768,
0.4191183746,
0.6413596869,
0.6165102124,
-0.0639826283,
-0.5953354836,
-0.5066944957,
0.3954848349,
-0.0891597047,
0.4993624091,
-0.7563606501,
0.1497579068,
0.3389642239,
-0.1592071056,
0.0183604397,
-0.3203547001,
0.737613678,
-0.5850968957,
0.0576718524,
0.1487020254,
-0.5645568967,
0.0167861097,
0.3929208517,
-0.6114714146,
1.4098166227,
0.2035794556,
-1.1334325075,
0.1058095172,
-0.1409410238,
-0.5464929938,
0.4103267491,
-0.058729995,
-0.4977584481,
-0.1415418237,
0.2503717244,
0.9287105799,
-0.2959663868,
0.2049968839,
-0.3713366687,
-0.3145295978,
0.3894381523,
-0.0741409063,
0.7773575783,
-0.0721687004,
-0.1961769462,
0.2346480638,
-0.8803050518,
0.3061966598,
0.0396804549,
-0.2622394562,
-0.510622263,
0.1475620419,
0.5210874677,
0.3343630433,
0.3392568231,
-0.6755975485,
-0.1588133872,
-0.1549465209,
0.2615920603,
0.7610228062,
-0.2702878118,
0.3169537783,
-0.0458233878,
-0.1132674888,
0.1010714993,
0.1107289717,
0.1502479464,
-0.3817275465,
-0.7430241704,
-0.4710018337,
0.3834985197,
0.5539514422,
-0.7179140449,
0.7212660313,
-0.2269074023,
-0.5949772596,
-0.6084995866,
0.1671575904,
0.3576835096,
0.6352601051,
0.6254838109,
-0.2638932168,
-0.3614560068,
-0.5317581296,
-0.0672353059,
-0.2503677309,
0.322478056,
0.526740551,
0.3786964715,
-0.5129673481,
0.8849055171,
-0.5718894005,
-0.2622908652,
-0.5296414495,
0.1442701221,
0.1503832489,
0.6079586148,
0.5498125553,
-0.5730496645,
-0.5333572626,
0.3320362568,
-0.6533296108,
0.1516078711,
0.055888433,
-0.3984895945,
-0.2243608087,
0.4890241027,
-0.6060183048,
0.0794074759,
0.3800974786,
0.0246838722,
0.7019723058,
-0.1442970484,
-0.5032589436,
-0.9417823553,
-0.1277198195,
0.0750011951,
-0.4531928003,
-0.8350570798,
0.0960632488,
0.2763714194,
-0.4220127761,
-0.3908923566,
0.3842491806,
-0.3474140167,
-0.0002485266,
-0.3058432639,
0.1700052172,
0.0708293915,
0.6903585792,
0.242340371,
0.1045659035,
0.8878313899,
-0.6611150503,
0.6034032106,
0.0769350007,
-0.151123628,
0.3961046934,
-0.8228468895,
0.3269538879,
-0.2972355187,
0.3820106089,
-0.8636676073,
-0.1316569149,
0.2069544643,
-0.6300410032,
0.3038721681,
-0.2793717086,
-0.7011299729,
-0.229490757,
-0.2994844317,
0.3672535419,
0.3061589897,
-0.5527216196,
0.6089297533,
0.1930347681,
0.0429157056,
-0.9016994834,
-0.3562757075,
-0.0405476913,
0.3095189631,
-0.5474319458,
0.7077969313,
0.0287060384,
0.4055040777,
0.4835285544,
0.1175922751,
-0.4446270764,
0.1144031584,
0.0774910375,
0.2320417166,
-0.1916875243,
0.3621231616,
0.1718164235,
-0.1077667102,
-0.140873611,
-0.8044728637,
0.7394652963,
-0.0389779881,
-0.0451271571,
-0.690746367,
0.3331277072,
0.5893821716,
-0.7278057933,
0.8771490455,
0.9686499238,
-0.5417274237,
-0.4318512082,
-0.2566918135,
0.1151283383,
-0.4386354685,
0.6358644962,
-0.2431297749,
-0.9895506501,
0.3288521767,
-0.0929121375,
0.0147574767,
0.3115244508,
0.5869991183,
-0.4932304025,
0.8556065559,
0.5949556828,
-0.442673713,
0.7065900564,
-0.4321517944,
0.1037404761,
-0.8723945022,
-0.04262238,
-0.6460815072,
-0.2535887361,
-0.7419495583,
-0.2654368877,
0.1529748291,
-0.204660207,
-0.5265282393,
0.5361813903,
-0.4503543377,
0.4948522151,
0.4659808278,
0.3866024315,
0.1875041574,
0.1833362728,
-0.1965561211,
0.2720582187,
-0.6381796002,
-0.2102390826,
0.898534596,
0.4794449806,
0.9327334762,
0.0495878719,
0.9062547088,
0.3589690924,
0.1481792778,
-0.7062596679,
0.4681773782,
-0.0864737481,
-0.583581388,
-0.327362746,
-0.5433462262,
-0.8513216376,
0.3710417747,
-0.496105969,
-0.7084037066,
0.2158375829,
0.2081683725,
-0.0675052106,
0.0896110684,
-0.5639613867,
0.7692660093,
-0.2388396412,
-0.5764152408,
-0.0911642984,
-0.7519865632,
-0.0812354088,
0.3168527484,
0.1053444371,
-0.0313937142,
0.2116702348,
0.5889914632,
-0.3480306268,
0.9975075722,
-0.2265579402,
0.0947859958,
0.3506560028,
0.0717257485,
0.7442718148,
0.0631406531,
0.0220797118,
-0.0843465701,
-0.4094167352,
-0.4996660352,
-0.6992433071,
0.585475266,
-1.1749281883,
-0.2409748584,
-0.4178103209,
-0.6517643332,
-0.1921610683,
0.3436631262,
0.010828455,
0.6016007066,
-0.1412210613,
0.069910869,
0.6379819512,
-0.050352782,
0.3168500364,
0.0621402524,
0.0093413182,
-0.4836839139,
1.0606396198,
-0.0553794987,
0.2617270947,
0.6451443434,
0.2335933447,
-0.1416931152,
-0.5835933685,
-0.2260371298,
0.3392613828,
-0.7369357347,
-0.0631621927,
-0.9343108535,
-0.6344219446,
-0.5593233109,
-0.0212266911,
-0.4054891765,
-0.4007269442,
-0.2134534568,
-0.0970540196,
-0.0126556912,
0.5250098109,
0.4657917619,
0.5828451514,
-0.8945015669,
-0.0211814772,
0.2811843455,
0.3929774463,
0.2078232765,
-0.2341558486,
-0.5835134983,
-0.3531806469,
-0.2214642465,
-0.8917944431,
0.1851140857,
0.1436253041,
0.624661684,
0.1029196829,
0.1271017045,
0.3341940939,
-0.5383583903,
0.2495698184,
0.2047461718,
-0.9499057531,
0.3864782751,
-0.1977840811,
-0.0286640562,
0.3845701218,
0.681070447,
-0.5361930132,
-0.3151119947,
-0.5947260857,
-0.8874115348,
0.5659498572,
0.4428340495,
0.2202632427,
0.1446015835,
0.1388975382,
-0.2377953976,
0.1989560723,
-1.1553356647,
-0.0688870698,
-0.4359909892,
-0.4586429,
0.1296578199,
-0.1674389988,
-0.163749665,
-0.3931651115,
0.5306695104,
-0.2662761211,
0.2810426056,
0.3217318058,
-0.6391039491,
0.2876851857,
0.2055259794,
0.1594231129,
0.4835858643,
-0.3865718544,
0.5402294397,
-0.190303579,
-0.3575853407,
0.0042404518,
0.3466809392,
-0.0607346073,
0.0608711876,
0.6895323396,
0.7276707292,
-0.0579722263,
-0.3923098147,
0.5815108418,
0.1173269823,
0.0637017265,
0.0130902492,
-0.088943854,
0.0050892662,
0.2540953755,
0.2507754862,
-0.1347084194,
0.0446562432,
-0.5810958743,
0.1667795777,
0.2747859955,
-0.6778083444,
-0.2150209844,
0.2342484146,
0.5743041039,
-0.1803684682,
0.6406418085,
-0.2909402251,
-0.8943246603,
0.3564884067,
0.6303421259,
0.9775493145,
-0.0627391264,
0.3609828055,
0.147300005,
0.4786865115,
0.5280861259,
0.1038590595,
-0.3241090178,
-1.0602633953,
-0.4270144999,
-0.4713910818,
-0.5273240209,
-0.1713184267,
-0.270640105,
0.0201504324,
-0.8615013957,
-0.1915730536,
0.0497383997,
-0.1966417432,
-0.6166315079,
0.2436656803,
0.0517060235,
0.6179764271,
-0.9030264616,
1.0822443962,
0.7864054441,
-0.246322602,
-0.4580064416,
0.1960145086,
-0.4588841498,
-0.6193734407,
0.8708347082,
0.1591743976,
-0.2325673401,
0.1764174849,
-0.5867586136,
-0.6571649313,
0.7293688655,
0.2155622095,
-0.147347331,
-0.0201977864,
0.1446672529,
0.512016356,
-0.5515884757,
0.2946122587,
0.2537089288,
0.1117551923,
-0.0281417947,
-0.5852822065,
0.1275665313,
-0.2527248859,
0.1008542776,
0.193477273,
-0.5182827115,
0.8138492703,
-0.0104105007,
0.0062999264,
-0.3406610191,
1.0059008598,
-0.0417600907,
0.0969637483,
0.4491333663,
0.5329321027,
1.0017721653,
0.0729380026,
0.8728510737,
-0.3117747903,
0.6258576512,
1.151884675,
-0.5881192684,
0.6866030693,
-0.0662887022,
0.0707381368,
0.8159139156,
0.5179566145,
0.2311975807,
0.3689904809,
0.0817124918,
-0.2654759288,
-0.3568903506,
-0.4174696505,
-0.4138220251,
0.3728073835,
0.2575811446,
-0.3766067326,
-0.1328689456,
-0.3388650715,
0.0648332164,
-0.0858935341,
-0.1551024765,
0.4874495566,
-0.3645108044,
-0.1377504766,
0.5107662678,
0.0468784682,
0.3500575125,
-0.3308162987,
0.0823219419,
0.0568722077,
0.2595279813,
-0.356121242,
-0.836718142,
-0.0622106642,
-0.0575555339,
-0.1449360847,
-0.2072620094,
1.0190309286,
-0.4695699513,
-0.5431149602,
0.6010960937,
0.4394536912,
-0.1999985278,
-0.0414566174,
-0.6638393402,
0.0075385668,
-0.4870194197,
0.0185780358,
0.1105271056,
0.6513165832,
0.0849665925,
0.4225400984,
0.4989428818,
-0.0890998915,
0.0098436438,
0.3608084023,
1.0898197889,
-0.7338635921,
-0.4782368839,
-0.8440218568,
0.410417974,
-0.496111244,
-0.2406715155,
0.3966841102,
0.5028424859,
1.0934975147,
0.1757452041,
0.7314343452,
0.0309196971,
0.1978422403,
-0.3191152811,
0.6770634651,
-0.3200445771,
-0.1613404453,
-0.7415576577,
-1.1293468475,
-0.2473046929,
0.442161411,
0.1720646769,
0.2064842582,
0.8473917246,
0.4830505252,
-0.1351646036,
-0.2114618272,
0.1483456641,
0.3532611728,
0.3049678802,
0.4777419269,
0.9088331461,
-0.234187603,
0.5547577739,
-0.2559340894,
-0.4315006435,
-0.2353247404,
-0.6834703088,
-1.188459754,
-0.5575870275,
-0.3414368629,
-0.4852991104,
0.0391303897,
1.0556117296,
0.8157567978,
-0.4381048381,
-0.3623188138,
0.0644067153,
0.4697530568,
-0.2512521744,
-0.2240605652,
0.6336505413,
-0.3943304121,
-0.6985477209,
0.0197771545,
0.3359827101,
0.050409887,
-0.1563875079,
-0.0218375996,
-0.4326435328,
-0.0584519766,
0.8541742563,
-0.0260100346,
-0.1810775846,
-0.3940001428,
0.1245264485,
-0.3383129239,
-0.0025314866,
0.8501237035,
-0.7384773493,
0.3429249227,
0.7593750954,
1.1218593121,
0.6605306864,
-0.2067826986,
0.2576356828,
-1.1461986303,
0.1519714296,
0.3594889939,
0.3952726424,
0.3558540642,
-0.3205800056,
0.2119069844,
0.465585649,
-0.167433545,
-0.6670073271,
0.5051295161,
-1.0749588013,
-0.2724380791,
0.779512465,
-0.1903823912,
-0.1896962225,
-0.0233100392,
-0.0827556103,
0.4764609337,
-0.2594333887,
0.3048890233,
0.6381062269,
-0.2204135656,
-0.2919299603,
-0.1385668814,
0.2621323764,
0.4334414005,
-0.7866714597,
0.2627409101,
0.2967585027,
-0.2708435059,
0.2788971961,
0.4722754657,
0.0413151868,
0.2624180019,
-0.4734326601,
0.0706802681,
-0.1598835289,
-0.9394729137,
0.2481720001,
0.3427314758,
0.1219748184,
-0.1016744822
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07283v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07283v1
|
Power Transformer Fault Prediction Based on Knowledge Graphs
| 2024-02-11T19:14:28 | 2024-02-11T19:14:28 |
Chao Wang, Zhuo Chen, Ziyan Zhang, Chiyi Li, Kai Song
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In this paper, we address the challenge of learning with limited fault data
for power transformers. Traditional operation and maintenance tools lack
effective predictive capabilities for potential faults. The scarcity of
extensive fault data makes it difficult to apply machine learning techniques
effectively. To solve this problem, we propose a novel approach that leverages
the knowledge graph (KG) technology in combination with gradient boosting
decision trees (GBDT). This method is designed to efficiently learn from a
small set of high-dimensional data, integrating various factors influencing
transformer faults and historical operational data. Our approach enables
accurate safe state assessments and fault analyses of power transformers
despite the limited fault characteristic data. Experimental results demonstrate
that this method outperforms other learning approaches in prediction accuracy,
such as artificial neural networks (ANN) and logistic regression (LR).
Furthermore, it offers significant improvements in progressiveness,
practicality, and potential for widespread application.
|
[
-0.4861663878,
-0.3315986097,
0.2734291553,
0.2119743675,
0.0630649403,
0.2366602123,
0.1389333457,
-0.1563825458,
0.1284276098,
0.4236858785,
-0.6715964079,
-0.2905281782,
-0.5644598007,
-0.1203993559,
-0.0464339331,
1.0765185356,
-0.117985554,
0.0199706219,
-0.0537189916,
-0.027229121,
-0.6318850517,
-0.0644687638,
-0.692718327,
-0.6866643429,
0.2990659773,
0.4750118256,
0.6163479686,
0.2391049266,
0.5693329573,
0.2627299428,
0.001918094,
0.2143452615,
-0.6162714958,
0.097918056,
0.1449233294,
-0.4882636964,
-0.2422395796,
-0.2533296049,
0.253554821,
0.5330269933,
-0.0866561681,
-0.1554116011,
0.0385403931,
0.8446019888,
-0.2246445119,
0.8088287115,
-0.6812190413,
0.6457362175,
0.2072574496,
-0.4758242369,
-0.4594269693,
-0.5422730446,
-0.0110055683,
-0.5033767819,
0.315215826,
0.1477846354,
0.7548776269,
0.6031649709,
-0.6674306989,
0.118826434,
-0.8778800964,
0.5867016315,
-0.1048378497,
0.4979001582,
0.289662838,
1.1199741364,
0.0692651644,
-0.7534503937,
-0.3252922297,
-0.048886966,
-0.5186831951,
0.3739212751,
-0.3617153764,
-0.0053322241,
0.5887530446,
0.0129994592,
-0.3267790675,
0.194895193,
-0.3871412277,
-0.2899817228,
0.3893282413,
0.3404291272,
-0.1730653793,
-0.6672968864,
-0.6047031283,
-0.2999077737,
-0.5742778778,
0.0905774236,
0.5305393338,
0.3158150613,
0.1388679743,
0.0255903825,
0.0027529399,
0.4962170422,
-0.0606022291,
-0.3184456527,
0.2596255243,
0.2907303572,
-0.4210717678,
0.0861526504,
0.8121004701,
0.3864216805,
0.3125497997,
-0.5577098131,
-0.0470699407,
-0.2907378674,
0.3277314007,
-0.6703551412,
-0.7148052454,
-0.199082002,
-0.3565352559,
-0.6490799189,
0.1275931597,
-1.1201615334,
-0.743018508,
-0.1017304808,
0.3479416966,
-0.5270013809,
-0.3336150348,
-0.3699289262,
-0.2534675598,
-0.1503704339,
0.0698524639,
-0.6154296994,
-0.0932317004,
0.2467659414,
0.7253010273,
0.1536062658,
0.0703404471,
-0.2648840249,
0.172054857,
-0.162899226,
0.585883975,
-0.1534709483,
-0.4006948471,
-0.1357282549,
0.2809418142,
-0.123316519,
-0.6367290616,
0.8174294233,
-0.6080672741,
-0.1364539564,
-0.1340292096,
-0.2130234987,
-0.524725318,
0.1139905453,
-0.8933805823,
1.0258885622,
0.6636002064,
-1.0064857006,
0.5809471607,
-0.4766950607,
-0.7376138568,
0.0510929115,
0.054966785,
-0.9039688706,
-0.230931282,
0.2035328448,
0.5914219022,
-0.073414214,
0.1476339102,
-0.1292954236,
0.0584980994,
-0.2036005259,
-0.4968812168,
0.4759772718,
0.0880916715,
-0.2792522609,
0.0900146663,
-0.8626374006,
0.1372479349,
0.2860274315,
0.1298371106,
-0.1495828331,
0.2198003978,
-0.4367395639,
0.3539159596,
-0.0095544811,
-0.617847681,
0.1501106471,
-0.1825278699,
0.1001019925,
0.8520691991,
-0.0649174228,
0.1886657178,
-0.1874629259,
0.7427612543,
0.2340947241,
0.2228363454,
0.1075966582,
-0.5263882875,
-0.7085214257,
0.2832378745,
0.1977428347,
0.6969848871,
-0.7795577049,
0.845635891,
-0.3954942822,
-0.7882590294,
0.0285935197,
-0.2144292146,
0.0282946676,
0.9454368949,
0.6173807979,
0.0884233341,
-0.7971598506,
-0.648778677,
-0.1024692804,
-0.2237826288,
-0.293972671,
0.6693755984,
0.1958539188,
-0.1512924135,
1.2356170416,
-0.915530324,
-0.6670626998,
-0.5590310693,
0.0887164176,
0.3433796465,
0.2147785127,
0.1995698959,
-0.8442695141,
-0.6310352683,
0.5504703522,
-0.7523573041,
0.3329163492,
0.1324874163,
0.3736094236,
-0.1743989587,
0.3308578432,
-0.2867576778,
0.3971801698,
0.6340693831,
-0.1617641598,
0.4044074118,
-0.102864176,
0.0152801797,
-0.9645178914,
-0.0316062011,
0.152946189,
-0.1682227105,
-0.5067012906,
-0.665538013,
0.3663702607,
-0.3296295106,
-0.1437950581,
-0.0541789234,
0.1233405694,
0.0839731917,
0.0010771928,
-0.3275153041,
-0.2276126593,
0.3541528881,
-0.3762187958,
0.3979952335,
0.6874249578,
-0.4770258963,
0.5567257404,
0.4567533731,
-0.4783444405,
0.2202199847,
-0.2850224674,
0.1709595174,
-0.4590726495,
0.2212596834,
-0.7207676768,
-0.1959373802,
0.1405795813,
-0.3046566844,
0.6508919001,
-0.3120832741,
-0.1688633114,
-0.873462081,
0.1355857998,
-0.0138301393,
0.7794923186,
-0.64416188,
0.9391000867,
0.2218476683,
0.01339697,
-0.8451188207,
-0.4091114402,
-0.2204481065,
-0.1159095094,
-0.8764359951,
0.2889564633,
0.3994584978,
0.1960335374,
0.0372486301,
-0.3262273967,
0.1061058417,
0.169736445,
0.6225264668,
0.1066848934,
0.1428642124,
0.3994502127,
-0.057182245,
-0.6305420995,
-0.0496209301,
-0.4464109838,
0.7263692021,
-0.1045442224,
-0.0633786917,
-0.2439149171,
-0.2760153711,
0.3393962383,
-0.0221472085,
0.6122563481,
0.433283776,
-0.1910492778,
-0.508587122,
-0.23416017,
-0.1873674989,
-0.5340253115,
0.4196274877,
-0.0554975085,
-0.4279542863,
0.2548998296,
-0.5649921298,
-0.2978574932,
0.575787425,
0.0659038424,
-0.1276281625,
1.0703310966,
1.0118714571,
-0.3957625926,
0.2878242135,
-0.516484797,
0.8659658432,
-0.2785607576,
-0.5299147964,
-0.4242360294,
-0.5241065621,
-0.6899036169,
0.0108908555,
0.8332835436,
0.1489963382,
-0.2822189629,
0.5048291087,
-0.5518944263,
0.3352259994,
-0.0682978258,
0.274700135,
0.1218045428,
0.2545897067,
-0.3439190984,
0.1265939176,
-0.6961446404,
-0.039272055,
0.9437863827,
0.3361370265,
0.5849741101,
-0.3410020471,
0.3687994182,
0.269343257,
0.5696485043,
-0.9433110356,
0.2481865883,
0.0017010227,
-0.162661016,
-0.5186153054,
-1.0635024309,
-0.9262884855,
-0.2084348798,
-0.0089517999,
-0.4631307721,
-0.0568284951,
0.1813536882,
-0.2127408981,
0.7645509243,
-0.7310370803,
0.7869340181,
-0.1570745856,
0.3030588031,
0.0959021449,
-0.5994647145,
0.2042581439,
-0.2156654149,
0.1486470699,
0.1054588333,
0.6140719652,
0.8886135221,
-0.4304338098,
0.4752823412,
-0.4651759267,
0.0213354379,
0.180631116,
-0.1237555444,
0.8228210211,
-0.2490635067,
-0.1474381834,
-0.0453037247,
-0.4446883798,
-0.2165097594,
-0.7519546151,
0.4336530566,
-0.724839747,
-0.3275780678,
-0.2048657984,
-0.5705878139,
-0.751375258,
0.2257365286,
0.2840831578,
0.2598130107,
0.27094841,
0.2717756927,
0.3912074268,
-0.0766347274,
0.7373905778,
0.1880029589,
-0.0727014616,
-0.5070558786,
1.0836162567,
0.2829976082,
0.0422231629,
0.3002331853,
0.3275646865,
-0.2974290252,
-0.2387731373,
-0.0743622184,
-0.1054293811,
-0.9345383644,
-0.7847534418,
-0.7817493677,
-0.2619582415,
-0.2008686364,
0.0016762917,
-0.0270861164,
-0.3690519333,
0.2908991873,
-0.6632415056,
0.454177767,
0.8538900614,
0.1401646882,
0.422537148,
-0.7321869135,
0.2963947952,
0.4839321077,
0.5525268316,
-0.0068965792,
0.2395417243,
-0.028860664,
-0.395329237,
-0.9729263783,
-0.7409383059,
0.6444064975,
0.1303321272,
0.3136823773,
0.5728856921,
0.3042085469,
0.3491419852,
-0.4462371767,
0.4894486964,
0.7295299172,
-0.5160139799,
0.4171991646,
-0.0919768885,
-0.2729341686,
0.1983681172,
0.6721523404,
-0.4439441264,
-0.0163360871,
-0.9652503133,
-0.7094506025,
0.6378428936,
-0.0709424019,
-0.232069537,
0.2624182701,
-0.0799992979,
0.3737281263,
0.1320974827,
-0.4286227524,
-0.5577533245,
-0.4393298924,
-0.1172568202,
-0.2805996537,
0.1574058384,
-0.0863293409,
-0.4144510925,
0.7136250734,
-0.4053353071,
0.2163424045,
-0.1680181324,
0.2129650861,
-0.6554464698,
0.0961305201,
-0.2138164639,
0.7230367661,
-0.2101870477,
0.0016790427,
0.6764445901,
-0.4777801633,
0.1550393254,
0.1096145064,
-0.236880511,
0.1485463232,
-0.2078727931,
0.7764980793,
-0.0659523904,
-0.2500311732,
0.3447014093,
-0.0065330425,
-0.1247850582,
-0.3729211986,
0.0086488007,
0.0682537258,
0.1947414279,
0.6395666003,
0.6611696482,
-0.2409608066,
-0.2238826305,
0.3848232925,
0.4241629839,
-0.8328161836,
-0.0009803087,
0.3426323533,
-0.0247919038,
-0.2029320151,
0.5001741648,
-0.06480138,
-0.8276945353,
1.0244836807,
0.3899189532,
0.5566511154,
-0.2884848714,
0.3997512758,
0.2305275947,
0.4275403917,
0.1670408994,
0.0568829365,
0.2695341408,
-0.6939550042,
-0.2562141418,
-0.7190526128,
-0.3076277375,
0.246704489,
-0.3941212296,
0.5612137318,
-0.5517460108,
-0.0852065235,
-0.2174798399,
0.2109646797,
-0.7469422817,
0.5954349637,
-0.2924635112,
1.0203260183,
-0.9918363094,
0.6293174624,
0.1511746049,
-0.2371522188,
-1.3160135746,
0.0148807475,
-0.487767458,
-0.7953729033,
0.7476406693,
0.4497561753,
0.2536145449,
0.4062000811,
0.039398782,
-0.6143568158,
1.5837373734,
0.3575927019,
-0.4627949297,
0.0362081081,
0.1004518047,
0.2632353604,
0.232662186,
0.4182420075,
0.6823314428,
0.9748840332,
0.1882481128,
-0.6295924783,
0.0902073979,
0.1400098801,
-0.387835741,
0.7834034562,
-0.6524727941,
0.674272716,
-0.2067455202,
-0.3440063,
-0.4522986114,
0.7278285027,
-0.2623167336,
0.3795030713,
0.6819820404,
0.9140638113,
1.0169943571,
-0.5266088843,
1.0733006001,
-0.3649563193,
0.955883503,
0.2545477748,
-0.0025705092,
0.2125620693,
0.0045213578,
-0.6074436307,
0.5917658806,
0.0195522439,
-0.4674360156,
0.6571422219,
0.010814568,
-0.2029200792,
-0.3057805896,
0.055353038,
-0.4433583915,
0.1808317304,
0.2653796375,
-0.4347449541,
-0.5185075998,
-0.0673078522,
-0.0512220152,
-0.5320321918,
-0.3987283707,
0.5375532508,
-0.053301435,
-0.4582529366,
0.4118773937,
-0.1722608954,
0.2410984784,
-0.6094184518,
-0.0423201136,
0.054220356,
0.3112920821,
-0.7586635351,
-0.6070945263,
0.1201546267,
-0.3784702122,
-0.0355415717,
-0.3958681524,
1.1191141605,
0.0599493757,
-0.496601373,
0.321713835,
0.2405825704,
-0.2039118856,
0.0084169889,
-0.003864611,
-0.5689296126,
0.0562959276,
-0.0135301789,
0.4013523161,
0.4076779187,
0.1604073346,
0.8319930434,
0.3235814273,
-0.0645693392,
0.0461513177,
-0.1060386151,
0.9663790464,
-0.5335977077,
-0.4194357991,
-0.4108417928,
0.5290229321,
-0.2539613843,
-0.0992651805,
0.6057621837,
0.3009797335,
0.6011172533,
-0.156612888,
1.3892171383,
-0.2357504368,
0.3591460288,
-0.3172264397,
0.822466433,
-0.0618662909,
-0.1488492787,
-0.0829322264,
-0.590873301,
-0.1520434767,
0.1742435694,
-0.5593720675,
0.1212996095,
0.9688207507,
0.5503726006,
-0.269564718,
0.5432739854,
0.5428851247,
0.3045834601,
0.3132999837,
0.4843415022,
0.7735647559,
-0.459504813,
0.8640548587,
-0.7778195143,
-0.3376556337,
-0.331240803,
-1.0900576115,
-0.5606667995,
-0.2134196162,
0.0290602203,
-0.4002932906,
-0.3594201207,
0.5384274125,
0.3648496866,
-0.9134896994,
0.3943080902,
-0.5318305492,
0.4447373152,
-0.407158047,
-0.271451354,
0.4900177717,
-0.6004353762,
-0.1101213396,
0.5269386768,
0.0596241355,
-0.1848035753,
-0.106997855,
-0.1594222635,
0.6192148924,
-0.4311949015,
0.3690468371,
0.1209033951,
-0.0483299457,
-0.5913539529,
-0.0717985928,
0.4359968603,
0.1645976603,
0.9501520991,
-1.1757996082,
0.163107276,
0.4804747105,
0.4840700626,
0.4652353227,
-0.1907561421,
0.4274285734,
-0.7525057197,
-0.0276037958,
0.2919511497,
0.6893953085,
0.4342463613,
-0.4400778711,
0.4211398661,
0.4786358178,
-0.5325906873,
-0.4565805793,
0.3918437064,
-0.8415481448,
0.0160732251,
0.8045934439,
-0.2572013736,
0.0530252606,
-0.2358060926,
-0.2577768564,
0.5875344872,
0.0071724746,
1.0343034267,
0.2771745026,
-0.2959303856,
0.0327461399,
-0.389947623,
0.6474691033,
0.1530451775,
-0.8528735638,
0.0920093209,
-0.1074694395,
0.2313479334,
0.4766933322,
-0.2816767097,
-0.0460023433,
0.0320833996,
-0.1723516583,
-0.1911591589,
-0.4036248326,
-0.6432923079,
-0.1489791721,
0.757763505,
-0.3584769666,
0.2974718511
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07282v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07282v2
|
How do Large Language Models Navigate Conflicts between Honesty and Helpfulness?
| 2024-02-11T19:13:26 | 2024-02-13T14:21:02 |
Ryan Liu, Theodore R. Sumers, Ishita Dasgupta, Thomas L. Griffiths
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In day-to-day communication, people often approximate the truth - for
example, rounding the time or omitting details - in order to be maximally
helpful to the listener. How do large language models (LLMs) handle such
nuanced trade-offs? To address this question, we use psychological models and
experiments designed to characterize human behavior to analyze LLMs. We test a
range of LLMs and explore how optimization for human preferences or
inference-time reasoning affects these trade-offs. We find that reinforcement
learning from human feedback improves both honesty and helpfulness, while
chain-of-thought prompting skews LLMs towards helpfulness over honesty.
Finally, GPT-4 Turbo demonstrates human-like response patterns including
sensitivity to the conversational framing and listener's decision context. Our
findings reveal the conversational values internalized by LLMs and suggest that
even these abstract values can, to a degree, be steered by zero-shot prompting.
|
[
-0.3341118097,
-0.7401905656,
1.0260611773,
0.2411598414,
-0.0316964053,
-0.1376668662,
-0.582002759,
-0.6755109429,
-0.224990055,
0.2318179756,
-0.6974811554,
-0.0062637115,
-0.4775500596,
0.0608436354,
0.1362828016,
1.2594202757,
0.214952752,
0.1645426452,
0.0426496752,
-0.0576082952,
-0.5768160224,
-0.6628218293,
-0.8713299632,
-0.7777311206,
0.8126559854,
0.4283668697,
1.1708501577,
0.6899298429,
0.3439021409,
0.2744182348,
-0.1627776921,
-0.2694594264,
-0.5476469994,
0.2876997292,
-0.4830527604,
-0.5927377343,
-0.4118741155,
0.3251207471,
0.2428665459,
0.7663128972,
-0.1195485294,
0.1216864586,
0.0038686907,
0.4281256795,
-0.4172939658,
0.356497407,
-0.5127945542,
-0.1480665207,
0.1104528904,
-0.0926734507,
-0.2012941986,
-0.5417047143,
0.3313429356,
-0.4545688033,
0.0193687771,
-0.2284394056,
0.6731206775,
0.4093132317,
-0.2889307439,
-0.6116486192,
-0.6557344794,
0.9926998019,
-0.7472128272,
0.2354135513,
0.6297614574,
0.1207741126,
-0.2941745818,
-0.155236721,
-0.4911271334,
-0.5855433941,
-0.0510162562,
-0.2362902164,
-0.234564051,
0.172222957,
0.2750234306,
0.1428327858,
-0.249138996,
0.2374197096,
-0.2494579703,
-0.1587427557,
0.6870228052,
0.154536292,
0.0863287449,
-0.095480755,
0.0721171647,
-0.2051220238,
-0.6139804125,
0.4340080023,
0.5519602895,
0.1265992671,
0.0604547784,
0.4036640823,
-0.2110508531,
0.8057175875,
0.2265553027,
-0.1313485354,
-0.0911077037,
-0.2899453342,
-0.1375256181,
-0.0430997685,
0.7282827497,
0.5750807524,
0.7290649414,
-0.1387058944,
-0.3115254045,
0.2396955043,
0.2328464091,
-0.8459872007,
-0.0987090692,
0.2320444882,
-0.4556059539,
-0.5127837658,
-0.3022236228,
-0.4697474539,
-0.2868806422,
-0.4218390882,
0.4346291423,
-0.3769452572,
-0.1729062945,
0.3584730029,
-0.1440490037,
0.3159113526,
0.3154588938,
-0.8651434183,
0.3662190437,
0.730627358,
0.6434000134,
0.1048691943,
-0.1604646295,
-0.857169807,
0.0375959985,
-0.436653167,
0.536583364,
-0.8046245575,
-0.4889062047,
-0.2717045546,
-0.2765839994,
0.3589401841,
-0.3717604578,
0.7776664495,
-0.3900263011,
0.4317046106,
-0.7104817629,
-0.4697406888,
-0.1140702516,
0.424375087,
-0.5186380148,
0.5398228168,
0.0875609517,
-0.6201980114,
0.1365550011,
-0.8265532851,
-0.2290395349,
0.0070357942,
-0.3136906326,
-0.0879777223,
0.5114494562,
-0.0744471401,
0.4839064181,
-0.2941712141,
0.3181959689,
-0.3504531682,
-0.4438916147,
0.8119872212,
-0.5305427313,
0.6369174719,
0.3043469489,
-0.3214172125,
0.1320950687,
-0.2853848934,
0.0383076221,
0.2893148959,
-0.3447356522,
-0.3677613437,
-0.0703789219,
-0.3633521199,
0.5667216778,
0.2610592544,
-0.5479735732,
0.3239658475,
-0.321620971,
0.4921240807,
0.9893893003,
0.00140223,
0.4120076299,
-0.5034784079,
0.4702780545,
-0.195280388,
0.4050803185,
-0.0655609071,
-0.5210475326,
-0.7456967235,
0.1105267256,
0.0536448509,
0.3069472015,
-0.4331007004,
0.2292441726,
-0.2359090745,
-0.136229828,
-0.6668565869,
0.0783988163,
0.5162370801,
0.3405983746,
0.0331694707,
-0.3663167357,
-0.0924975649,
-1.0204018354,
-0.3281085193,
-0.2880633473,
-0.2031562775,
0.3433455229,
0.300603658,
0.0142930821,
1.0738387108,
-0.5509858727,
0.1239649355,
-0.1014205217,
0.1899157315,
0.0860557631,
0.1653591692,
0.4143436551,
-0.7559089661,
-0.3346736133,
-0.1431000233,
-0.4949989915,
-0.2916947603,
-0.166569069,
0.1659249365,
0.1086121723,
0.2003510445,
-0.6859250665,
0.3384536207,
0.5674706697,
-0.4851820767,
0.6929706931,
-0.259101212,
0.050477244,
-0.6277597547,
-0.1472571641,
-0.0480181985,
-0.371419102,
-0.5786468387,
-0.0335108824,
-0.176372081,
0.1619000137,
-0.2648922205,
0.7006700635,
-0.4181938767,
-0.2023201585,
-0.4680305123,
0.1595785171,
-0.0096800756,
0.6267700195,
0.1172147617,
0.9166009426,
0.2062068731,
-0.7023182511,
0.2776214182,
0.2173672915,
-0.0990193188,
0.820381701,
-0.8670884967,
0.3247609138,
-0.1387516111,
0.3274374604,
-0.7928203344,
-0.2127789855,
0.086733669,
-0.6473096609,
0.0793333948,
-0.1519356966,
-0.4476247132,
-0.1523963958,
-0.4713199735,
0.2410928011,
0.5389825702,
-0.281242311,
0.2498724908,
0.2166976929,
-0.6062105298,
-0.4505381584,
-0.6003073454,
0.1554866433,
-0.0572482087,
-0.4765335619,
0.1008912995,
-0.5916347504,
-0.6435678005,
-0.0807900429,
0.0072456696,
-0.0757315233,
0.0526834726,
0.2101301253,
0.3855534494,
0.0937900618,
0.148926869,
-0.3230983615,
-0.2497389764,
0.2545671761,
-0.3142152727,
0.5381537676,
-0.5771525502,
-0.3272103369,
-0.3567801714,
0.3191414773,
0.3685098588,
-0.0881468058,
0.8195197582,
0.4679972231,
0.0028361438,
0.2609899044,
-0.7509626746,
-0.5089023709,
-0.5015245676,
0.1992542595,
-0.3425585032,
-1.0650551319,
0.3638651371,
0.1956262141,
0.1975770146,
-0.0403636023,
0.6020578742,
0.0135239558,
1.1762433052,
0.5335510373,
-0.0565377176,
0.5245755315,
0.0365872234,
0.4214117825,
-0.6732497215,
0.1158313602,
-0.49952057,
-0.198648721,
-0.6496570706,
-0.3407101035,
0.2961654663,
0.0187076535,
-0.3384999931,
0.0198422391,
-0.3565588892,
0.7608117461,
0.3652298152,
-0.1400896311,
0.4157582521,
-0.4005463123,
0.1090107933,
-0.1859496534,
-0.5464659333,
-0.5418390036,
0.7062649131,
0.5472991467,
0.8093173504,
0.2211287022,
0.4028877914,
-0.0497126728,
0.4342532456,
-0.9591704607,
0.4954621494,
0.2126262933,
-0.6662146449,
-0.3078150451,
-0.7025230527,
-0.8703782558,
0.066979304,
0.0213156287,
-0.913639009,
-0.0373922624,
0.185275659,
-0.4028813541,
0.1728308648,
-0.8048930168,
0.5992459655,
-0.3945998847,
-0.4250652492,
-0.2780480981,
-0.8415797949,
0.2293405384,
0.0638472736,
0.339918375,
-0.0734534413,
-0.0265456066,
0.3536905348,
0.2236121446,
0.8208563328,
0.0358637758,
-0.2985633016,
-0.0248717554,
0.581970036,
0.5879952312,
-0.121655941,
-0.1731819361,
0.0989316776,
-0.1367518902,
-0.4956891537,
-0.7071343064,
0.7545933127,
-0.734513104,
-0.6249393821,
-0.4132941663,
-0.6913831234,
-0.2765028179,
0.0078100343,
0.1635773778,
0.2934481502,
-0.2779604197,
0.2093385607,
0.8563551307,
-0.4371756613,
0.5301550031,
0.7562786937,
-0.2825322151,
0.1224871427,
0.6599096656,
-0.1308395565,
0.7228861451,
0.2502372265,
0.5226317644,
-0.5089046359,
-0.2468284816,
-0.2188635767,
0.4118121564,
-0.6507686377,
-0.0369161442,
-0.4039878249,
-0.0019150893,
-0.2960172594,
-0.3226636648,
-0.3763703406,
-0.3681397736,
-0.0095384717,
-0.2898277938,
0.3651738763,
1.0903646946,
-0.1592751145,
0.198850587,
-0.8159534335,
0.0308707375,
0.5448675156,
0.5157458186,
0.1822709888,
-0.4502287209,
-0.0989676565,
0.1694505215,
-0.4070310295,
-0.8094326854,
0.1722401679,
-0.1892956495,
0.329823643,
0.3780036271,
-0.0474235266,
0.3496260941,
-0.4181658924,
0.8609082699,
0.1689651608,
-1.0177652836,
0.2759544551,
-0.5990193486,
0.4054535329,
0.4073896706,
0.3239648044,
-0.9413192272,
-0.242736578,
-0.6324324012,
-0.4013911486,
0.6544314027,
0.3127632737,
0.238142252,
0.012215171,
0.4585377574,
0.0873050392,
0.3860007823,
-0.9180234075,
-0.0837240443,
-0.1157172695,
-0.0203500427,
-0.0522323549,
-0.2415341884,
-0.3274868131,
-0.0427623577,
0.4106725752,
-0.2216381729,
0.2348294705,
0.0381539315,
0.1014058888,
-0.2957875133,
0.8779228926,
0.6486182213,
0.7370347977,
-0.0956453457,
0.0120677697,
0.1341120899,
0.0232922416,
0.1927628368,
-0.1592181921,
0.0833614692,
-0.293800205,
0.2042624652,
0.9396803379,
0.3293938041,
-0.6285461783,
0.7449629307,
-0.2910794318,
-0.0254048072,
-0.0531408563,
0.3354941905,
0.2256402224,
0.2038294822,
0.1589445621,
-0.1934224665,
0.1274153441,
-0.7401069403,
-0.0792850628,
0.5610342622,
-0.2838487625,
-0.5248320699,
0.3132433891,
0.2385935187,
-0.7502217293,
0.583543539,
-0.4704164565,
-0.6698548198,
0.1082116067,
0.3112511337,
0.7631059289,
-0.3099082112,
0.457060039,
-0.1235045642,
0.0650419071,
-0.0096940473,
-0.0189579614,
-0.1447946131,
-0.7196829319,
-0.7920877337,
-0.4362966418,
-0.642557323,
0.337305367,
-0.7772624493,
-0.0940570682,
-0.3242015243,
-0.1899100244,
0.0827676281,
0.2190030217,
-0.8956198096,
0.0596109368,
0.1884305924,
0.6409398913,
-0.5545022488,
0.7683036923,
0.4003001153,
-0.4959807992,
-1.0311732292,
0.1039978117,
0.0233946294,
-0.8547267318,
0.5780161023,
0.0863847956,
-0.3409488499,
-0.2444088459,
-0.8142066598,
-0.5027573705,
0.6776218414,
0.667892158,
-0.585010469,
-0.2220062315,
-0.0505030714,
0.6756258607,
-0.1545707434,
0.4017105699,
0.8126329184,
0.6384676099,
0.1105896384,
-1.2645376921,
0.0190279577,
-0.07094834,
0.0762142465,
0.2080356181,
-0.7916420102,
0.7816246152,
-0.3889760375,
0.1409750283,
0.0041729901,
0.2944766283,
0.2064962536,
0.1204402074,
0.664033711,
0.2434435785,
0.5760993958,
0.038231004,
1.2887893915,
-0.1271162331,
0.2221399099,
1.1652597189,
-0.2795111239,
0.6263164282,
0.5586827993,
-0.0466413014,
0.5728645921,
0.5169759393,
0.3046809435,
0.3160851002,
0.1743742824,
-0.2638265193,
-0.1420215368,
-0.3468035161,
-0.1094996184,
0.4253263474,
0.4225213528,
-0.0294170417,
-0.2288850546,
-0.2175805569,
0.3798170686,
-0.0941813588,
-0.1588587761,
0.8852820396,
0.1579143703,
-1.0814121962,
0.304467231,
0.0045015733,
0.7535532117,
-0.7454167008,
-0.0726128295,
-0.085454084,
0.1369058937,
-0.0868323445,
-1.1889322996,
0.0676559061,
-0.0696855485,
-0.2730374038,
-0.3684053719,
0.5901734829,
-0.4787276983,
0.0921835676,
0.4888648391,
0.383602351,
0.240665555,
-0.1526603103,
-0.7383018732,
0.1866993159,
0.0493078493,
-0.3027683496,
0.5229053497,
0.453124553,
-0.0355407,
0.7675743699,
0.7662450671,
0.2891597748,
-0.2718868554,
0.0463845432,
0.8277330399,
-0.7251345515,
-0.6963317394,
-0.8843631148,
0.2511183023,
-0.1375303417,
-0.2159828693,
0.5836920142,
-0.0300525669,
0.749651134,
0.1004553735,
0.8090434074,
0.2304107547,
0.3581498265,
-0.4446562231,
0.2827560902,
-0.2298291773,
0.2795582414,
-0.17215617,
-0.8358341455,
0.1308621764,
0.9773027301,
-0.639056325,
0.2754416168,
0.5109682679,
0.6119333506,
0.0247418378,
0.2928383946,
0.4194906652,
0.310164392,
0.6754618883,
0.8060986996,
1.0019489527,
0.2054557055,
0.5266251564,
-0.0009594122,
-0.338254571,
-0.2354301214,
-1.0582420826,
-0.7258546948,
-0.411454618,
0.082627967,
-0.3708849251,
-0.0191738326,
1.2138361931,
0.8435798287,
-0.4787442088,
-0.2632685304,
-0.025343366,
0.0587885566,
0.0844144449,
-0.2521009147,
-0.0537327304,
-0.3231950998,
-0.5726742744,
0.2389498204,
0.2732390761,
0.2139928043,
-0.4964122176,
-0.3476342261,
0.206406638,
0.3917506337,
0.4286801219,
0.242464453,
-0.6917822361,
-0.5876609683,
0.1004321277,
-0.097544834,
0.1246862635,
1.1407667398,
-0.5455360413,
0.3682355881,
0.1628579199,
0.5417454243,
0.2779483199,
-0.0899300054,
0.9200348258,
-0.8701280355,
0.1684912443,
0.3981515467,
0.0739527568,
0.6060902476,
-0.5816625357,
0.3876488805,
-0.220638901,
-1.0036426783,
-0.6009124517,
0.4674726129,
-0.6583000422,
-0.369758904,
1.1978219748,
-0.1015163288,
-0.0339417532,
-0.1362746656,
-0.4453129768,
0.0302539263,
-0.6529152393,
0.9166989923,
1.26092875,
-0.4377060533,
-0.1405054331,
-0.5897670388,
0.7415563464,
0.4316042066,
-0.7761520743,
0.1288061142,
0.6226290464,
0.4912031591,
0.3227309883,
0.9347320795,
0.1990120858,
0.3238232732,
-0.4103287756,
-0.2599972486,
0.0095369508,
-0.2845172286,
-0.5991823673,
-0.256349653,
0.4397704601,
0.039971184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07271v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07271v1
|
Previously on the Stories: Recap Snippet Identification for Story Reading
| 2024-02-11T18:27:14 | 2024-02-11T18:27:14 |
Jiangnan Li, Qiujing Wang, Liyan Xu, Wenjie Pang, Mo Yu, Zheng Lin, Weiping Wang, Jie Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Similar to the "previously-on" scenes in TV shows, recaps can help book
reading by recalling the readers' memory about the important elements in
previous texts to better understand the ongoing plot. Despite its usefulness,
this application has not been well studied in the NLP community. We propose the
first benchmark on this useful task called Recap Snippet Identification with a
hand-crafted evaluation dataset. Our experiments show that the proposed task is
challenging to PLMs, LLMs, and proposed methods as the task requires a deep
understanding of the plot correlation between snippets.
|
[
-0.1038535833,
-0.1364872158,
0.4131892323,
-0.1262763888,
-0.3691090345,
0.4200880229,
0.1057474315,
-0.1072058231,
0.1962689012,
0.7490463853,
-0.7191779613,
-0.3426065743,
-0.4361554682,
0.3008774519,
-0.6476724148,
1.1216617823,
0.0850853994,
-0.412073493,
-0.4309435785,
-0.221225217,
-0.3608496487,
-0.5371662378,
-0.527833581,
-0.3030563295,
0.6208549738,
0.3243903518,
0.276469171,
0.5643937588,
0.5750496387,
0.2051827908,
-0.0704507828,
0.2375956923,
-0.5940773487,
0.2359289527,
-0.253000319,
-0.5866752863,
-0.1378639042,
0.1314341426,
0.787817657,
0.7928435802,
-0.0235034358,
0.3803331554,
0.2326950431,
0.8622032404,
-0.5813142657,
0.0268426277,
-0.4237588942,
0.3615890443,
-0.1697432697,
-0.5954253078,
-0.3782748878,
-0.4908889532,
0.4876646698,
-0.3248053789,
0.5143361092,
0.0074320068,
0.9920607805,
0.2446249574,
-0.061434418,
-0.3389030099,
-0.4477395713,
0.9030327201,
-0.5906349421,
0.1149471998,
0.3201951087,
0.3918005526,
-0.1971656978,
-1.0541189909,
-0.5343485475,
-0.1625773907,
-0.1675958782,
0.0314448886,
-0.3524370492,
-0.7523126602,
0.2497605681,
0.5807250738,
-0.3314531446,
-0.1551249772,
-0.1872017235,
-0.0787442476,
0.5250511169,
0.508228302,
0.0387984365,
-0.5224112272,
-0.8014258742,
-0.1618748307,
-0.5221208334,
0.1117406264,
0.257530421,
-0.1609173715,
0.0916299,
0.4905590415,
-0.1650504172,
0.3972956538,
-0.1762912571,
0.0174968746,
0.6679642797,
-0.5889471769,
-0.1501409411,
-0.0187435355,
0.2222795486,
1.0753184557,
0.453068316,
-0.2334921211,
0.1453161091,
-0.2572694421,
0.4574794173,
-0.663500905,
-0.3987871408,
0.0306268539,
-0.6839466691,
-0.1463650316,
-0.1552388668,
-0.8817507625,
-0.866753459,
-0.1252289712,
0.2138132155,
-0.3264557123,
-0.3590446413,
0.0543247424,
-0.74491781,
0.5786867142,
0.2570335567,
-0.8591785431,
0.2651585937,
0.7977802157,
0.8363837004,
-0.3145071566,
-0.5110176206,
-0.3691334128,
0.0127726728,
-0.2303673923,
1.1942210197,
-0.3041631877,
-0.2445380539,
-0.1803285629,
0.0436022021,
0.1030982882,
-0.3988328278,
0.2253942788,
-0.3616757095,
-0.1683829874,
-0.5326110125,
-0.961294353,
-0.2658255994,
0.3325017095,
-0.7121708393,
1.1217032671,
0.3042549193,
-0.939611733,
0.5744031668,
0.0246035103,
-0.3081299663,
-0.2258169353,
-0.1623873562,
-0.2896928489,
0.3374532759,
0.4280363619,
0.446171701,
-0.0598738864,
-0.1170593351,
0.0858593509,
-0.3431317508,
0.2999822199,
-0.2970870733,
0.6322581172,
0.0677985027,
0.3068282008,
-0.1431759745,
-0.7481383085,
-0.0007269609,
0.2385814935,
0.063614279,
-0.3133384585,
-0.0264382232,
-0.3606339097,
-0.3208310604,
0.3315582871,
-0.40184623,
0.3725990355,
-0.3779394031,
0.4014041722,
0.5201954842,
0.2026607394,
0.1896454543,
-0.7976185083,
0.6345422268,
-0.4633861482,
-0.1720839143,
-0.8825780749,
-0.3326212764,
-0.4360856414,
-0.0402245559,
0.6383805275,
0.7368972301,
-0.7482730746,
0.3172363639,
-0.1899383366,
-0.7439225316,
-0.1806228012,
0.1424326897,
0.517463088,
0.1948529631,
0.0701092184,
-0.5357995629,
-0.5972834229,
-0.6499777436,
-0.728839457,
0.1711974889,
-0.5978366733,
0.3161220849,
0.3723647296,
0.3788999617,
0.8684680462,
-0.6421723962,
-0.4044582546,
-0.6343865991,
0.2351529449,
0.448156178,
0.1379806399,
0.4579996765,
-0.3615456522,
-0.2802952826,
-0.2107586861,
-0.5453066826,
-0.277274102,
-0.3053820729,
-0.1483189464,
-0.3794763088,
0.9992575645,
-0.0769952312,
0.5901983976,
0.4751595855,
-0.3774528801,
0.4658636451,
-0.3052758276,
0.2147430032,
-0.8224976063,
0.0550104417,
-0.2463571876,
-0.0238920562,
-0.2910320461,
-0.3120249212,
-0.0598697588,
0.0193882938,
-0.5465638041,
0.6241813898,
-0.5247523189,
-0.6054426432,
-0.1475541741,
0.5468083024,
0.2577757239,
0.561111033,
0.2560947239,
0.5249709487,
0.1972644776,
-0.1635745317,
0.3213861287,
0.4749121666,
-1.0849840641,
0.5891898274,
-0.2800600231,
0.3069612384,
-0.1276487559,
0.1062585786,
-1.3230166435,
0.2162788808,
0.0213875081,
-0.396648854,
0.1296548992,
-0.0487634689,
-0.6989716291,
-0.1903469861,
-0.379671216,
0.2247935534,
0.1211877242,
-0.6504451632,
0.6057348251,
0.256642431,
-0.482311219,
-0.5086811781,
-0.5621334314,
-0.0111138429,
-0.2571783066,
-0.0873471722,
0.583368361,
0.1838572919,
0.0822500214,
-0.1857419312,
-0.3702465594,
-0.0263386946,
-0.0318569653,
0.1387023777,
-0.0724016726,
-0.1982133389,
0.1707717478,
-0.1270219982,
-0.490566045,
-0.1146115363,
0.6416030526,
0.5179226398,
0.0460579172,
0.1709098965,
-0.2798728347,
0.4913294017,
0.1171067655,
-0.1977900267,
0.1658691317,
0.4942125678,
-0.137228325,
-0.1751051545,
-0.3889312148,
0.0852773935,
-0.4408028722,
0.4114447534,
-0.3339636028,
-0.5005756021,
0.3387293816,
-0.3385057747,
0.1028430387,
0.245971933,
0.1925088018,
-0.4058293104,
0.4984440506,
0.5470269322,
-0.0990131721,
0.7684268951,
-0.2310272306,
-0.0696050674,
-1.0914435387,
0.0346479751,
-0.5076628327,
-0.6435790658,
-0.0599150956,
-0.2909664512,
0.0523952432,
0.4574840665,
0.0726294518,
0.5218230486,
-0.3564086854,
0.9033813477,
0.6525281072,
0.1994282454,
0.5528865457,
-0.0452019311,
0.0147187253,
-0.1892784089,
-0.4434347451,
-0.5212116241,
1.2913520336,
0.1718409806,
0.5291756392,
-0.0210192334,
0.5959575772,
0.5325134993,
0.5636236668,
-0.5239344835,
0.6146760583,
-0.466376543,
-0.3910035193,
-0.3053431809,
0.0193906967,
-1.26205194,
0.2841877043,
-0.1611165255,
-0.9934476018,
0.0801129118,
-0.0948383138,
-0.682454586,
0.0326495953,
-0.7577403188,
1.0613980293,
-0.2209546715,
0.1410901994,
-0.2451331764,
-0.5165792704,
-0.0338946432,
0.0962193832,
-0.1383931786,
-0.2544493973,
0.0079895165,
0.8102282286,
-0.2707118988,
0.7529148459,
0.1015114933,
0.4373427927,
0.3921085298,
0.0819466189,
0.3105326891,
-0.2694000602,
-0.2333036214,
0.2860750556,
0.5565885901,
-0.2677456439,
-0.765131712,
0.3843517303,
-0.2423787862,
-0.4066613615,
-0.6164416075,
-0.3349107504,
-0.1368030161,
0.2752492726,
0.0711328536,
0.6344881654,
-0.0598887987,
0.387781024,
0.1136868373,
-0.3172286749,
0.6144937277,
0.6858454943,
-0.5186923742,
-0.4579885006,
0.7115229964,
-0.1746433079,
0.1419931352,
0.4233202338,
0.3108684719,
-0.2971315086,
-0.8154475689,
-0.2329973727,
-0.0065635773,
-0.6985279322,
-0.1935551018,
-0.3892401159,
-0.1645131856,
0.2128636092,
-0.261261493,
-0.2113432288,
-0.218130514,
-0.1920394748,
-0.3238525689,
0.4127498269,
0.519575119,
-0.0284371097,
0.4517676532,
-0.8230262995,
0.4650999904,
0.0156971067,
0.3900261223,
0.0838146284,
-0.4344774187,
-0.1724823564,
-0.6866058111,
-0.3025833368,
-0.6612388492,
0.614341259,
0.1460728496,
0.6964785457,
0.3584428728,
0.1826130301,
0.4296316206,
-0.6162753701,
0.9060564041,
0.0378432088,
-0.6901392341,
0.5712753534,
0.0566605404,
0.6461138725,
0.76756531,
0.4363977611,
-0.3277172148,
-0.2957331836,
-0.6125183105,
-0.7523474097,
0.4053520262,
0.3217647076,
0.1588148326,
-0.1247558296,
0.3493125439,
0.6149932146,
0.6261350513,
-0.2904041708,
-0.294665426,
-0.0106659243,
0.0835271925,
-0.4143432975,
-0.4304221272,
0.1565278322,
-0.3786105514,
-0.0303885601,
0.1990677565,
0.0634037331,
0.2532580495,
-0.2487711608,
0.1623643786,
-0.1488830447,
0.2093192786,
0.8223304749,
-0.6593809724,
-0.0302479398,
0.1271184087,
-0.5758973956,
-0.3296050429,
-0.0245095454,
0.1558421403,
0.0957996026,
0.7148528695,
0.5017075539,
0.605366528,
-0.8680768609,
0.4992639124,
-0.1134563163,
-0.0182826035,
-0.3955082893,
0.1217777506,
-0.2423743606,
0.7120654583,
0.4066579342,
-0.0566845201,
0.1008509994,
-0.6616102457,
0.678119421,
0.0357667953,
-0.0565491505,
0.0421485044,
0.1546112746,
0.2525821328,
-0.5308017135,
0.5451329947,
-0.0783934742,
-0.4830372334,
0.7428889275,
0.2822972536,
0.7661733031,
-0.0576492362,
0.1799468696,
0.2586953044,
0.2168988436,
0.1248392239,
0.330775857,
-0.3591725826,
-0.8724535704,
-0.2155197263,
-0.5572168827,
-0.5701106787,
0.1647278965,
-0.9955039024,
0.1155919358,
-0.5283904672,
-0.1808716357,
0.4361433685,
0.1601117253,
-0.8752428889,
0.0784325749,
0.2130978554,
1.0300318003,
-0.7394438982,
0.7159520984,
0.0657101125,
-0.2907396257,
-0.263725996,
-0.0794185549,
-0.0706035718,
-0.7973525524,
0.4119362235,
0.4048459828,
-0.0398186632,
0.0829973593,
-0.0286585819,
-0.8155252337,
1.1307014227,
0.0085830716,
-0.5611864924,
-0.0110469265,
-0.1448304355,
0.6864355803,
-0.4284570217,
0.468434453,
1.0511069298,
0.2386911511,
0.0812110081,
-0.7405719757,
-0.1708010584,
-0.1908261329,
-0.1129603311,
0.0297019817,
-0.4833126664,
0.6238760352,
-0.3340215087,
-0.2646296024,
0.5931921005,
0.6688919663,
0.0840209574,
0.7945560217,
0.6428627968,
0.3598590493,
0.9341778755,
0.0133684753,
1.3727837801,
0.1838285774,
0.2339818329,
1.7520121336,
-0.2329602689,
1.1346105337,
0.4573075771,
-0.5235171318,
0.3939236701,
0.498716861,
-0.4115698636,
1.0051236153,
0.4948674738,
0.1797771305,
-0.061014697,
0.1692331284,
-0.4568012953,
0.3877972662,
0.4985325336,
-0.6243782043,
-0.4865677655,
0.0448089354,
-0.2659189403,
0.0591518097,
-0.4702039957,
0.7900870442,
0.289681673,
-0.458905369,
0.2987620831,
-0.586269021,
0.1873443276,
-0.4563630819,
-0.3031936586,
-0.3863016367,
0.1910479814,
0.0289742555,
-1.1878908873,
0.4784965813,
0.0120893288,
-0.2876210511,
-0.292624861,
0.29776752,
-0.1937142164,
-0.4561842084,
0.1460869014,
0.2873901427,
0.517343998,
0.0091638844,
-0.6041055322,
0.2036744207,
0.0735247284,
-0.3304776847,
0.1216677353,
0.4940960705,
0.2544757128,
0.5115979314,
0.3440249264,
-0.1793814451,
-0.0515832268,
0.236859113,
0.4678494632,
-1.1526925564,
-0.6465147734,
-0.6034510136,
0.4908705056,
-0.2266868204,
-0.8426678777,
1.0196069479,
0.5824383497,
0.9620584249,
-0.1450408846,
0.4788550436,
0.2915719151,
1.0899642706,
-0.7719979286,
0.5587150455,
-0.5108053684,
0.5516028404,
-0.4608947635,
-0.6949387193,
-0.2606040835,
0.577211678,
-0.3706182837,
-0.4137932956,
1.063210845,
0.5590003729,
0.3571491838,
0.3839409351,
0.1399587691,
0.0951333344,
-0.1649493873,
0.5551159978,
1.1173968315,
-0.3280895948,
0.6161520481,
-0.1721961945,
-0.0941392854,
-0.347981751,
-1.3070634604,
-1.2658058405,
-0.4309907854,
-0.4739522338,
-0.2575855553,
0.1473600566,
0.2763646543,
0.1898822635,
-0.9085054994,
0.0076156757,
0.1450001448,
0.2580986917,
-0.8268213272,
-0.1886292994,
0.6570680141,
0.0895667523,
-0.5841767192,
0.3931449652,
0.2494668961,
-0.3600097299,
-0.0647157952,
0.5381418467,
-0.0138374027,
0.0626490265,
0.4296343327,
0.4025713801,
-0.5440377593,
-0.4808754027,
-0.475594908,
0.2453024685,
0.2853871286,
1.1858919859,
-0.9549077153,
0.5870235562,
0.4603204429,
0.7285118103,
0.8939340115,
0.1452402025,
0.6847239137,
-0.7807074189,
-0.106608443,
0.1662865579,
0.320798099,
0.1748043299,
-0.2085735053,
0.5506079197,
-0.066445969,
-0.4229221344,
-1.0343636274,
0.023921134,
-1.2589991093,
-0.1801521033,
0.8436195254,
-0.3884468973,
-0.3201215565,
-0.19975622,
-0.4158541262,
-0.0049603027,
-0.1126543954,
0.6567465067,
0.8911083341,
-0.2019493431,
-0.503039062,
-0.5136057138,
0.5281817317,
0.4443100393,
-0.7384904623,
0.1695911586,
0.0934404284,
0.2578326762,
0.0880409405,
0.5450733304,
-0.0744039193,
0.1376128048,
0.4342578948,
-0.337503016,
-0.1378073096,
-0.5469191074,
-0.1083712876,
0.1369331479,
-0.4481612146,
-0.3882819116
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07270v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07270v2
|
Open-ended VQA benchmarking of Vision-Language models by exploiting Classification datasets and their semantic hierarchy
| 2024-02-11T18:26:18 | 2024-05-05T20:34:28 |
Simon Ging, María A. Bravo, Thomas Brox
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The evaluation of text-generative vision-language models is a challenging yet
crucial endeavor. By addressing the limitations of existing Visual Question
Answering (VQA) benchmarks and proposing innovative evaluation methodologies,
our research seeks to advance our understanding of these models' capabilities.
We propose a novel VQA benchmark based on well-known visual classification
datasets which allows a granular evaluation of text-generative vision-language
models and their comparison with discriminative vision-language models. To
improve the assessment of coarse answers on fine-grained classification tasks,
we suggest using the semantic hierarchy of the label space to ask automatically
generated follow-up questions about the ground-truth category. Finally, we
compare traditional NLP and LLM-based metrics for the problem of evaluating
model predictions given ground-truth answers. We perform a human evaluation
study upon which we base our decision on the final metric. We apply our
benchmark to a suite of vision-language models and show a detailed comparison
of their abilities on object, action, and attribute classification. Our
contributions aim to lay the foundation for more precise and meaningful
assessments, facilitating targeted progress in the exciting field of
vision-language modeling.
|
[
-0.4330529571,
-0.6756947041,
0.4604066014,
-0.1598637402,
-0.0653546378,
-0.1615528315,
-0.1775834113,
-0.5228651762,
-0.4651316702,
0.6578188539,
-0.4188462794,
-0.6160800457,
-0.2749224603,
-0.0995677039,
-0.5245804787,
0.565309763,
-0.0699700117,
0.2300918102,
-0.8342811465,
-0.397254467,
-0.4670122564,
-0.4147976637,
-0.3015187085,
-0.0585510731,
0.3446099162,
0.055542171,
0.733879745,
0.5482987165,
0.8717654943,
0.3456272483,
-0.1708776653,
0.1474092603,
-0.3809833527,
-0.2238981724,
-0.2907626331,
-0.3233271539,
-0.359395504,
0.0104149375,
0.6283407211,
0.9009497762,
-0.2257170528,
0.6678140163,
-0.0471139774,
0.5880134702,
-0.9909716845,
0.1053413153,
-0.6425839067,
0.2088495791,
-0.0301255081,
-0.1721431166,
-0.3099199533,
-0.3810459971,
0.2862571776,
-0.5502156019,
0.1691673994,
0.0630285889,
1.1813013554,
0.466702193,
-0.1188970283,
0.0843901634,
-0.5829260349,
0.6730229855,
-0.4115109742,
0.5494161844,
0.1022703201,
0.7134185433,
0.2799173295,
-0.886231184,
-0.5782690644,
-0.3662620783,
0.2485383302,
0.3593488336,
-0.4192484915,
-0.0611345172,
0.1616631895,
0.5362772942,
-0.6434267759,
0.0249469168,
-0.4225787818,
0.030182831,
0.3091562092,
0.3224464953,
0.2506492436,
-0.1897459775,
-0.6461654902,
-0.2469921857,
-0.3095547855,
0.1392570883,
-0.0565011688,
0.0967039391,
0.06068312,
0.8308345675,
-0.847576499,
1.0378563404,
-0.3289691508,
0.1430874616,
0.389706552,
-0.4293450117,
-0.5130586624,
-0.5194312334,
0.7132006288,
0.9787446856,
0.4137753248,
-0.2996007204,
-0.150871709,
0.2705850899,
0.3740906715,
-0.7242522836,
-0.0712229013,
-0.0496554412,
-0.3555155993,
-0.481644243,
-0.094441846,
-0.8554906845,
-0.284809649,
-0.3063977659,
0.7520834208,
-0.0571673326,
0.0635997728,
0.3699142933,
-0.2282496542,
0.7147017717,
0.5734083652,
-0.5857902765,
0.5384257436,
0.5586888194,
0.5374314785,
-0.2294947654,
-0.2540367842,
-0.4650046229,
-0.2101657242,
-0.5041409135,
0.844204545,
-0.5053361654,
0.1590039134,
0.0585219711,
-0.2629007697,
0.1367146224,
-0.8720770478,
0.6289041042,
-0.5175489783,
0.2387312055,
-0.3415610194,
-0.3919240534,
-0.2439574301,
0.5663127303,
-0.4260470271,
1.205622673,
0.2728992105,
-0.7487745285,
0.6413331032,
-0.1919009537,
0.2028529495,
0.4806284308,
-0.4390428662,
-0.2842571735,
0.1856480539,
0.3399751782,
0.516441524,
-0.7845730186,
0.2511752248,
-0.297798425,
-0.2471578717,
0.1783000976,
-0.6180149317,
0.5772159696,
-0.1203769743,
-0.1497072428,
0.1507430375,
-0.8562780023,
0.5376657844,
0.1024805158,
-0.2078054696,
-0.4654966891,
0.0141051523,
-0.0449147485,
0.2843620479,
0.2514730394,
-0.459305197,
0.0503800586,
-0.1284801662,
-0.0173199307,
0.6293216944,
-0.197348088,
0.2352527827,
-0.1534388661,
0.3118611872,
-0.0156616103,
0.3720713854,
0.0327329487,
-0.5661543608,
-0.981377542,
-0.0342176706,
0.344014138,
0.6903762221,
-1.0570669174,
0.1740583628,
-0.6077808142,
-0.65922755,
-0.5742852688,
0.0505866148,
0.7103415132,
0.7831553221,
0.501444757,
-0.7346853018,
-0.1373806447,
-0.9453006387,
-0.334972769,
-0.4785991907,
-0.1990027726,
0.5628183484,
0.559109211,
0.0035815381,
0.8592080474,
-0.5687746406,
-0.0516143702,
0.0736040249,
0.0519548804,
-0.06324514,
0.1191614196,
0.5207701921,
-1.0487326384,
-0.0610238425,
0.0657845289,
-0.9702964425,
-0.2598426342,
0.2015057951,
-0.1235047281,
-0.2262306064,
0.4223359525,
-0.2934101224,
0.6050083637,
0.3767474294,
-0.3894625008,
0.6851358414,
0.0096983071,
0.4242071807,
-0.6144798994,
0.0387721248,
0.1045266464,
-0.1264278144,
-0.6096791029,
0.4635062516,
0.1064433083,
0.0394180305,
-0.7818793058,
0.7090728879,
-0.0655602589,
-0.587646246,
0.1104357466,
0.2476366609,
-0.0349784903,
0.6073194742,
0.2763711214,
0.7907137871,
0.6585938334,
-0.5530356765,
0.505286634,
0.3806899786,
-0.787642777,
0.6731468439,
-0.7927556038,
-0.2125531584,
-0.2023973465,
-0.2242252976,
-1.0522305965,
-0.0244519245,
0.1923166066,
-0.402880162,
-0.2733681798,
-0.1109336987,
-0.4918792248,
-0.4648058116,
-0.0868602991,
0.5356098413,
0.5962834954,
-0.6157149076,
0.4868755043,
0.1935025901,
-0.0736544207,
-0.6189635992,
-0.6054973602,
0.1380328238,
-0.0923038423,
-0.6159927845,
0.3567151427,
-0.1007463485,
-0.4405249059,
-0.0002485224,
-0.231270045,
-0.3497031629,
-0.0119308494,
0.0869856253,
0.3388108611,
-0.3785749674,
0.0221063923,
-0.3413556516,
-0.0620163754,
-0.0165061411,
-0.2309119254,
0.3304157555,
-0.6295889616,
-0.22862643,
-0.142566517,
0.0869193077,
0.5263213515,
-0.5842378736,
0.3798668087,
0.4977055788,
-0.3648280501,
-0.0528351255,
-0.4911749363,
0.232510522,
-0.4425399005,
0.5535158515,
-0.4613398314,
-0.6997802854,
0.1391657889,
-0.0899041221,
0.0853323042,
0.4276455641,
0.7439667583,
-0.1288345158,
0.6701088548,
0.7502889633,
0.2968632281,
0.3010838628,
-0.1725452989,
-0.2204397768,
-0.7034350038,
-0.3181833923,
-0.542678535,
0.1529699713,
-0.3448174,
-0.8196329474,
0.347350508,
0.1610540897,
-0.172402516,
0.3962950408,
-0.4090211093,
0.4838533401,
0.4615023434,
0.1736434698,
0.3422697783,
0.0993600935,
-0.2455674708,
0.0731894895,
-0.6210935712,
-0.6157836318,
0.8728041053,
0.3137321174,
0.6440626979,
-0.1120751947,
0.3521441519,
0.1163771376,
0.2887226641,
-0.7980386615,
0.7864118218,
-0.3295964301,
-0.4029915929,
-0.2506512105,
-0.4976611137,
-0.4173467457,
0.6395604014,
-0.2365340739,
-0.8891387582,
0.1852715313,
-0.0336756893,
-0.1328404397,
0.2226368487,
-0.6078011394,
1.2484143972,
-0.2527094781,
-0.3282314837,
0.1521222144,
-0.4827332199,
0.3819463551,
0.1516122371,
0.1065355763,
-0.1629647315,
-0.2428083718,
0.7118650079,
-0.3206689954,
0.6197211742,
0.0071542538,
-0.1757921726,
0.321857512,
-0.2303521037,
-0.236447677,
-0.2124537081,
0.0738304704,
0.3868082464,
0.0544931144,
-0.4555573761,
-0.746899426,
0.2501879632,
-0.6067065001,
-0.274731189,
-0.2665673792,
-0.196491912,
-0.4733051658,
0.1080740914,
0.1941650063,
0.6897404194,
-0.3442077935,
0.2381322831,
0.6852719784,
-0.363419652,
0.2164540887,
0.4730819762,
-0.3860087991,
-0.4003387988,
0.7766126394,
-0.1662345827,
0.5186713934,
0.7258936763,
0.1164173335,
-0.2061412334,
-0.6015481949,
-0.6990849376,
-0.2993091345,
-1.0219717026,
-0.1678166538,
-0.5433173776,
-0.264523834,
-0.0125933783,
0.0782046765,
-0.3009934425,
-0.3044037521,
0.167092517,
0.0891948417,
0.0961626768,
0.3749479651,
0.4067755342,
0.1263051182,
-0.5377292037,
0.8923245668,
0.6998075843,
0.5527095795,
-0.0991952494,
-0.4712447822,
0.0265114494,
-0.1076132134,
-0.1903307587,
-0.6111274362,
0.0487684906,
0.2050884068,
0.5455022454,
0.0383902006,
-0.0972969905,
0.7958872318,
-0.7276638746,
0.8644942641,
0.3139698803,
-0.7767083645,
0.4250974357,
-0.1696970314,
0.4845300913,
0.7211350203,
0.1258397549,
-0.4515316784,
-0.3220134676,
-0.2304134071,
-0.8616114259,
0.3533780575,
0.4605229795,
-0.0549703278,
0.0860636309,
0.2372878939,
-0.0595672056,
0.33715415,
-0.7697213888,
-0.1775613576,
-0.2064925581,
-0.1610511392,
-0.1088632569,
-0.027310729,
0.0625747815,
-0.4148711562,
0.312666297,
-0.2922051847,
0.186187312,
0.1115483642,
-0.1183672026,
0.083015196,
0.2680681646,
0.2104968876,
0.6495630145,
-0.0926641822,
0.0687149242,
0.451859951,
-0.4633689821,
-0.0731376857,
0.0304208454,
-0.4166820645,
-0.0344771035,
0.4267368317,
0.7872778177,
0.1690811664,
-1.0063046217,
0.8304281831,
-0.4449194372,
-0.26862216,
-0.1143676937,
0.1136774495,
-0.0875179246,
0.1918612421,
0.3107070327,
0.2810443044,
0.3453917801,
-0.4964756072,
0.2591387033,
0.2811216414,
-0.6479333639,
0.0837651715,
0.5765279531,
-0.024240762,
-0.0418651402,
0.3157993853,
0.1628382653,
-0.5305474401,
0.7062454224,
-0.0078133009,
0.8695113659,
0.1156328842,
0.3908452988,
0.249789238,
0.3472925127,
0.1103953943,
0.5155359507,
-0.3062928915,
-0.72617203,
-0.3057950735,
-0.959232986,
-0.5073398948,
0.0642028898,
-0.8671147823,
0.1760082096,
-0.3133096099,
0.0695107877,
0.3792587221,
-0.1634334773,
-0.856978178,
0.7637428641,
0.2900428772,
1.0598845482,
-0.6841127872,
0.4685530365,
0.7289001346,
-0.4170431197,
-0.2917862236,
0.091011785,
-0.265112102,
-0.789979279,
0.7952518463,
0.3458328545,
-0.3307359219,
-0.1660279632,
-0.647084415,
-0.6142550707,
1.0233286619,
0.1571590751,
-0.4166252315,
-0.0622543953,
0.1751184464,
0.7147319317,
-0.2347588837,
0.2694382668,
0.3847707212,
0.2686731219,
0.1854622364,
-0.972242713,
-0.1959243119,
-0.4504800737,
0.2503578067,
0.1162477583,
-0.4241504967,
0.5782071948,
-0.1162076071,
-0.2518155575,
0.4823018014,
0.774191916,
0.0020585684,
0.3094718754,
0.5023239255,
0.7525184155,
0.4748280346,
-0.3379270434,
1.1002135277,
0.0436778553,
0.377235502,
1.0905543566,
-0.1860759109,
1.2072402239,
0.3695612848,
-0.2434616685,
0.3107516766,
0.4425936341,
-0.1760682166,
0.6117265821,
0.4354500771,
-0.1486727893,
-0.4582057893,
-0.2517796159,
-0.0827477053,
0.614310503,
0.1722397208,
-0.0279027391,
-0.4488389492,
0.006797913,
-0.6920894384,
0.2357214242,
-0.6142151952,
0.8804973364,
-0.1597388387,
-0.6006804705,
0.7904341817,
-0.0036694813,
0.4175155759,
-0.2893449068,
0.0147926742,
0.0621845722,
0.2050670236,
0.081486769,
-0.947627902,
0.0954102352,
0.3494393229,
-0.0920639634,
-0.1029816642,
0.5273600221,
-0.4051280022,
-0.4523745477,
0.1899184585,
0.5232692361,
0.054970447,
0.0268735401,
-0.7536751628,
-0.049444586,
-0.396656841,
-0.0060124709,
0.0329431631,
0.2902884185,
-0.1553485245,
0.8675113916,
0.327026546,
-0.2347089499,
0.2632521689,
0.1453451961,
0.8534903526,
-0.5919500589,
-0.3119052649,
-0.5688658357,
0.556371212,
-0.1133449301,
-0.6630693078,
0.5459593534,
0.6049890518,
1.1620874405,
-0.1847935617,
0.6653263569,
-0.1035159752,
0.3264017403,
-0.7121924162,
0.4132837057,
-0.837518692,
-0.0016072596,
-0.6786774397,
-0.9608231783,
-0.2633088231,
0.4089950323,
-0.3491797149,
0.0813001096,
0.5434682965,
0.4933246374,
-0.0034593947,
-0.2401920855,
0.6349610686,
0.0734908059,
-0.0540506169,
0.6584244967,
1.1680947542,
-0.7123227715,
0.5637984276,
-0.2512124479,
-0.4196363389,
-0.0430488102,
-0.7972423434,
-0.9219064713,
-0.7532940507,
-0.4496005774,
-0.0668135956,
0.2625666559,
0.3293967843,
0.6403697729,
-0.5349203348,
-0.104291819,
-0.0946530551,
-0.211292997,
-0.4475309253,
-0.214892,
0.2821495831,
-0.0252616182,
-0.5505359173,
0.0686387867,
0.4361536801,
0.1158079803,
-0.3121436238,
0.0670051426,
0.0884440392,
0.0656034797,
0.7367327213,
0.1826064438,
-0.9974024892,
-0.1775968969,
0.0943775401,
-0.2234075814,
0.0617318675,
0.3620530069,
-1.0381367207,
0.5587698817,
0.4954963028,
0.8422677517,
0.34080109,
0.1454704404,
0.4732856452,
-0.5926061869,
-0.1342206746,
0.2748101354,
0.27106902,
0.4250436127,
0.0744613558,
0.5558293462,
0.0687509477,
-0.1023303717,
-0.7315748334,
0.2996978164,
-1.1473286152,
-0.2268173993,
0.9701426029,
-0.2192055285,
-0.4347746074,
0.1634700447,
-0.2254368216,
-0.1566539258,
0.232137084,
0.4811337292,
0.6129424572,
0.3100302517,
-0.357875824,
-0.7204501033,
0.3268574774,
0.2775007784,
-1.0576767921,
0.2816123366,
0.5403198004,
0.0507500954,
0.1235810071,
0.4976985455,
-0.2571742535,
0.6188751459,
0.1064636037,
0.0675740018,
0.1089152843,
-0.6763948202,
-0.3346024454,
0.3300645947,
-0.1182750985,
-0.2438227087
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07262v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07262v1
|
Low-Resource Counterspeech Generation for Indic Languages: The Case of Bengali and Hindi
| 2024-02-11T18:09:50 | 2024-02-11T18:09:50 |
Mithun Das, Saurabh Kumar Pandey, Shivansh Sethi, Punyajoy Saha, Animesh Mukherjee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC
|
With the rise of online abuse, the NLP community has begun investigating the
use of neural architectures to generate counterspeech that can "counter" the
vicious tone of such abusive speech and dilute/ameliorate their rippling effect
over the social network. However, most of the efforts so far have been
primarily focused on English. To bridge the gap for low-resource languages such
as Bengali and Hindi, we create a benchmark dataset of 5,062 abusive
speech/counterspeech pairs, of which 2,460 pairs are in Bengali and 2,602 pairs
are in Hindi. We implement several baseline models considering various
interlingual transfer mechanisms with different configurations to generate
suitable counterspeech to set up an effective benchmark. We observe that the
monolingual setup yields the best performance. Further, using synthetic
transfer, language models can generate counterspeech to some extent;
specifically, we notice that transferability is better when languages belong to
the same language family.
|
[
-0.4583292007,
-0.6501912475,
-0.164956212,
0.6331831217,
-0.1990850121,
0.2871336043,
-0.1679895371,
-0.8154602051,
0.4458727837,
0.3977540731,
-0.340575695,
0.2217454761,
-0.625854075,
0.3649857938,
-0.568061471,
0.8804967999,
0.3468082249,
0.1845607907,
0.0492581762,
-0.432285279,
-0.5246223211,
-0.4928201139,
-0.8345074654,
-0.4859173,
0.1102841645,
0.408911258,
0.5430443287,
0.2023462802,
0.4721901417,
0.3184559643,
0.003344011,
0.0577959009,
-0.4507332444,
0.1975706816,
-0.5108017921,
-0.2510566711,
-0.1783978492,
-0.2879830003,
0.4301706254,
0.6166633964,
-0.2131213993,
0.4683919251,
0.1485615075,
0.6574292779,
-0.8177573681,
-0.0295530092,
-0.956458509,
-0.0427081473,
-0.5354993939,
-0.2501447797,
-0.5186965466,
-0.3437381387,
-0.3102113903,
-0.3010157943,
0.0001332479,
-0.1614025831,
0.5165020227,
0.3736356795,
0.0713368505,
-0.2353823185,
-0.550794363,
0.6820072532,
-0.8039977551,
0.2049929202,
0.6034501195,
0.2207300067,
0.0832830518,
-0.6200487018,
-0.6450468898,
-0.1464928985,
-0.2011452615,
0.0676581785,
-0.3264175653,
-0.2809442282,
0.3218283951,
0.0470618866,
-0.6777396202,
0.169028759,
-0.5371592045,
-0.0686899051,
0.6085810065,
0.2324552238,
0.6916980147,
-0.4220876098,
-0.5255436301,
0.2195686251,
-0.8955661654,
0.038118206,
0.5216317773,
0.8204815388,
-0.4138452113,
0.507866919,
-0.1458125859,
0.8700985312,
-0.0328156054,
-0.1019438282,
0.0296966247,
-0.6606056094,
0.0944595784,
0.3752063811,
0.8309448957,
0.3685482144,
0.7317478657,
0.0182541087,
-0.0145923421,
0.3469787538,
0.3792467117,
-0.8349326253,
-0.1071291938,
-0.1651304811,
-0.4148117006,
-0.3434809446,
-0.6527544856,
-1.1794182062,
-0.6844053864,
-0.2718542516,
0.0967524573,
-0.5776702166,
-0.5579385161,
-0.3296944499,
-0.0639072806,
0.2672828138,
-0.1276357174,
-1.0764619112,
0.7979063988,
0.3858625293,
1.0437071323,
-0.2988608479,
-0.2568452358,
-0.339853704,
-0.0908617452,
-0.3352601528,
0.9067146778,
-0.72910887,
-0.3925144076,
0.2029483914,
-0.5262741446,
-0.1037382931,
-0.7367671132,
0.161620304,
-0.3494354188,
-0.1975999475,
-0.2591078281,
-0.0831262246,
0.1490800977,
0.1278783381,
-0.544475317,
1.0602167845,
0.2438652068,
-0.8741609454,
0.1919236034,
-0.5892659426,
-0.679490447,
0.4389240444,
-0.1011061892,
-0.0493863225,
0.091515407,
0.1013067588,
0.0088831289,
-0.540376246,
-0.218336165,
-0.1033464819,
-0.4038165212,
0.0977898911,
-0.4078987539,
1.1684370041,
0.612174809,
-0.3055810928,
-0.3004865944,
-0.8185767531,
0.1241250709,
0.1919463724,
-0.2248629928,
-0.5882894397,
-0.0423918962,
0.2478885502,
0.2463905364,
-0.1036635712,
-0.5940579176,
0.027693443,
-0.5311384201,
0.3893952668,
0.6623556614,
0.0730085075,
0.3295972347,
-0.2094009072,
0.6336200237,
-0.0456380807,
-0.0232571568,
0.1345935613,
-0.3798368275,
-0.5454852581,
-0.0148678059,
0.1214508489,
0.59488976,
-1.0739164352,
-0.2056345195,
-0.2525782585,
-0.5794986486,
-0.8391571641,
0.1970562935,
0.7524924278,
0.6595141292,
0.4723269343,
-0.4777959883,
-0.6926727891,
-1.0752748251,
-0.5871527195,
-0.3027797937,
0.3447971642,
-0.0603827052,
0.0319405235,
0.1797311008,
0.7821224332,
-0.0087673897,
-0.0208817217,
-0.4408937991,
0.3074419796,
0.0295654312,
0.4436049759,
0.9469957948,
-0.7069001794,
-1.0978839397,
-0.2658862174,
-0.4037994742,
-0.4847180843,
-0.0310465489,
0.0828267112,
0.5701642632,
0.6005343199,
-0.3224836588,
0.3543642461,
0.7709015012,
-0.2172189802,
0.5989729762,
0.3302849829,
0.2196642309,
-1.2401628494,
0.1437304169,
-0.2247781903,
-0.172246322,
-0.708267808,
0.0523349978,
-0.3854483962,
-0.2460705638,
-0.7127235532,
0.917493701,
-0.2351665646,
0.0503509901,
-0.2624577582,
0.1642589271,
-0.5445428491,
0.4683793783,
-0.149188906,
1.1486713886,
0.2234105617,
-0.4586177766,
0.1894637197,
0.2823077142,
-0.4701639116,
0.7858999968,
-0.3603540361,
0.1889329553,
0.1656571925,
-0.181909427,
-1.0254734755,
0.0120549416,
0.2162487954,
-0.614888072,
0.3357660174,
-0.486379534,
-0.3889558613,
-0.0051615317,
-0.1371722221,
0.6354105473,
0.4922057986,
-0.6137307882,
0.404228121,
0.6572441459,
-0.5971085429,
-0.7945723534,
-0.9153656363,
0.337120682,
-0.0417754613,
-0.2888270319,
0.0117848199,
-0.1298995763,
-0.6663535237,
0.0260252766,
0.2238286883,
0.0049501718,
-0.0914941281,
0.3085083365,
0.0727749094,
0.0137351565,
-0.0147811258,
-0.2272160351,
-0.0356114432,
0.0578395352,
0.1446709335,
1.1120202541,
-0.1244360805,
-0.2049040347,
-0.1008886695,
0.5548736453,
0.4205586314,
-0.2552937865,
0.8385213017,
0.540328145,
-0.4246172905,
-0.4052431583,
-0.4283741415,
-0.1076872647,
-0.4628009498,
0.4721277356,
-0.6497926116,
-0.3789525032,
0.6012512445,
-0.0601928905,
-0.2572214007,
0.4258908331,
0.8900562525,
0.229960382,
0.7440677285,
0.4728506207,
-0.3260070682,
0.4532948434,
0.1313320398,
0.4905356169,
-0.5899650455,
0.0425528064,
-0.6356779933,
-0.2439431548,
-0.9598169327,
-0.0043372158,
0.1924375296,
0.080420427,
-0.2666286528,
0.6315011382,
-0.5654630065,
0.4615012705,
0.4594661593,
-0.2347346544,
0.0850278735,
0.3432178199,
-0.1388822496,
-0.3230457604,
-0.9581214786,
-0.2961987853,
0.6641927958,
-0.1209777743,
0.6196214557,
0.3086629808,
0.3861412704,
0.5110210776,
0.6461578012,
-0.4787673652,
0.6313839555,
-0.4252984524,
-0.6833560467,
-0.0634862036,
-0.3386901319,
-0.757232666,
0.0600236505,
-0.2699584365,
-0.8279211521,
0.1429614127,
0.1020876542,
-0.2217137963,
0.5371371508,
-0.7583396435,
0.4808143377,
-0.0575574823,
-0.5902923346,
-0.3403085768,
-0.5133858919,
0.5369105935,
-0.0639301464,
0.2452425063,
-0.0964521021,
0.2105636895,
0.5931099057,
-0.3187488616,
0.8932495117,
-0.1718965471,
0.2516445518,
0.5263146162,
0.5241774321,
0.3587616086,
-0.2042648196,
-0.2565842271,
0.385345608,
-0.0634920895,
-0.4503397644,
-0.2253203988,
0.7457441092,
-0.6866144538,
-0.2294475436,
-0.3684163094,
-0.4580414593,
-0.3697448969,
0.1645448506,
0.4794303179,
0.352384001,
-0.0208461247,
0.054247912,
0.0904402062,
-0.2344222665,
0.7851928473,
0.5635801554,
-0.0967793614,
-0.3795888424,
1.0904049873,
0.2772320509,
0.2892598212,
0.0198295508,
0.1117830053,
-0.2032136172,
-0.5371230245,
-0.432733655,
0.1256895959,
-0.582297802,
-0.5237770081,
-0.4475665092,
-0.632578671,
-0.6148778796,
-0.1655401289,
-0.6523094773,
-0.4585250914,
0.2266098112,
0.0778110623,
0.3309660256,
0.9682395458,
-0.4430094957,
0.2624714077,
-0.7240992188,
0.4126207232,
0.2377710789,
0.6371057034,
0.0791930482,
-0.7526292205,
-0.1597682834,
-0.2139612436,
0.1382284015,
-0.8805807233,
0.5778846741,
0.0940108672,
0.2410414219,
0.057186868,
0.3161384165,
0.8080930114,
-0.6261073351,
0.7553193569,
0.4286040962,
-0.7984711528,
0.3930456936,
-0.2343895137,
0.2378492802,
0.7579677105,
0.488912791,
-0.8500138521,
-0.3049568534,
-0.4501264691,
-1.0412465334,
0.6635682583,
0.1232458279,
0.3486569822,
-0.2938353121,
0.1818062961,
0.1653033942,
-0.0271272268,
-0.7498881221,
-0.2040275186,
-0.2642842829,
-0.1914611757,
0.2167735696,
-0.4543408453,
-0.2051106244,
-0.1654010564,
0.4495063126,
-0.0057512042,
0.0918911397,
0.0093599996,
-0.2124884725,
-0.3694237173,
0.1687875986,
0.5946508646,
0.7077998519,
-0.0021441188,
0.2298713028,
0.3997671604,
-0.7347169518,
0.0701977611,
-0.1091736183,
-0.2591049075,
-0.1497248709,
0.6309347749,
0.6279489398,
0.1093645766,
-0.6339953542,
0.3655085564,
0.0678866729,
0.2468713224,
-0.6045615673,
-0.0453994535,
0.0484722219,
0.0810480043,
0.1156120151,
0.2973191738,
-0.0944541991,
-0.6129817963,
0.2664913535,
0.2871451974,
-0.3159585297,
-0.3924955428,
0.5022245049,
0.3098353744,
-0.6663070321,
0.8003719449,
-0.3117160797,
-0.5586724281,
0.2808147371,
0.7920746803,
0.7466191649,
-0.4131885171,
0.1603104919,
0.7741689682,
0.4716310203,
0.2732573152,
0.3909659386,
0.0516114049,
-0.7836306691,
-0.4691580534,
-0.9456609488,
-0.3000680208,
0.2898518145,
-0.6165670753,
0.1439112127,
-0.5724122524,
-0.1084880158,
-0.0185366068,
-0.022975063,
-0.6604593992,
-0.1585750282,
0.3102630377,
0.866388917,
-1.0996073484,
0.7423000932,
0.467852354,
-0.6488208175,
-0.5530997515,
-0.2302545905,
0.2023877501,
-1.0551105738,
0.8276397586,
-0.1845654547,
-0.3390265107,
-0.0714558959,
-0.6421348453,
-0.7857552171,
0.3402378857,
0.3580385745,
-0.5926861167,
0.345872879,
0.5217071772,
0.8367652297,
-0.267647624,
0.1327740699,
0.6241363883,
0.483368516,
-0.1744691879,
-0.9219751954,
0.1577106714,
-0.6291273832,
-0.1948416233,
0.1128157154,
-0.8404401541,
0.9158616662,
0.1037218347,
-0.4161346853,
0.0291603208,
0.164941296,
0.1074596271,
-0.0648856014,
0.5024610162,
0.7302622199,
0.0587354451,
0.0664482042,
1.2655620575,
-0.5071377158,
-0.3362424076,
1.4536223412,
-0.346195817,
0.9838106036,
0.5523847342,
-0.3491986394,
0.3890494704,
0.2950556874,
0.190850541,
0.3163475394,
0.3341893554,
-0.202424109,
0.035332378,
-0.7019051313,
-0.1862692982,
0.8202585578,
0.3470172584,
0.177146107,
-0.2534596622,
-0.1195953861,
0.1283151358,
0.5492491126,
-0.2569657862,
0.9102958441,
-0.0049897255,
-0.7454978228,
0.6795764565,
-0.2317855954,
0.6791868806,
-0.6424792409,
-0.259685874,
-0.614808321,
0.1313838661,
-0.2313732952,
-0.6453583241,
0.6276479959,
0.2497223914,
-0.1115543321,
-0.2878781259,
0.9037663341,
-0.4990879595,
-0.3319222927,
0.7543536425,
0.5175054073,
0.2152316272,
0.1131978109,
-0.6055907011,
0.104236342,
-0.1699358225,
-0.0807884187,
0.6211936474,
0.0360873528,
-0.176075384,
0.5150398612,
0.5705658793,
0.8447223902,
0.4380626082,
0.2726407349,
0.795071125,
-0.5015900731,
-0.1178626791,
-0.7658310533,
0.332136184,
-0.1707269251,
-0.4017316103,
0.6173576117,
0.3618920147,
1.0602865219,
0.0567399897,
0.698630631,
-0.288684845,
0.6959043741,
-0.3511980772,
1.0100078583,
-0.4330204129,
-0.0814466849,
-0.1378657371,
-0.8330414891,
0.0261029676,
0.2436052263,
0.1190587804,
-0.13823241,
0.5017977953,
0.8869660497,
0.0878653899,
-0.2198655158,
0.2685619295,
0.3934674561,
0.1144573763,
0.3283528388,
0.7233277559,
-0.3697680533,
0.6150171161,
-0.373257935,
-0.0812392533,
-0.0012942979,
-0.6770109534,
-0.6211927533,
-0.6659857035,
0.0197288468,
-0.4469442964,
0.1145893484,
0.9627897739,
0.5624056458,
-1.0272817612,
-0.5135405064,
0.1471249014,
-0.0544705875,
-0.1618464589,
-0.2857457995,
0.16564399,
-0.5954918265,
-0.8575470448,
0.556006074,
0.3616512418,
-0.2116085142,
-0.2794627845,
0.0857453644,
-0.7530866861,
0.295945555,
0.7626489997,
0.6513354182,
-0.3510298133,
-0.2117498517,
-0.2584878802,
-0.3377589583,
-0.0315171853,
1.0435316563,
-0.7370944619,
0.7139976621,
0.790540874,
0.7456851602,
0.2034128159,
-0.0276589748,
0.3686233461,
-1.1777603626,
0.5532434583,
0.366908133,
0.2464651912,
0.4816632271,
-0.0502214953,
0.7998566031,
0.3013506532,
-0.2027971447,
-1.0907986164,
0.2961370647,
-0.5518857241,
-0.4500078261,
1.0154380798,
0.2724009454,
-0.0794907212,
-0.2949531078,
0.1164687499,
0.3470526636,
-0.0801631361,
1.0630110502,
0.7087660432,
-0.2714156508,
-0.2678171098,
-0.4478514791,
0.8193603754,
0.4470488727,
-0.7416930795,
0.139837563,
0.0409024954,
0.1512923092,
0.5156856179,
0.8651598096,
-0.2406391501,
0.1099759042,
0.5784600973,
0.2600413859,
0.004965981,
-0.2837934494,
-0.2081113458,
0.1665652394,
-0.0549305268,
0.114020817
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07255v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07255v1
|
American Sign Language Video to Text Translation
| 2024-02-11T17:46:33 | 2024-02-11T17:46:33 |
Parsheeta Roy, Ji-Eun Han, Srishti Chouhan, Bhaavanaa Thumu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Sign language to text is a crucial technology that can break down
communication barriers for individuals with hearing difficulties. We replicate
and try to improve on a recently published study. We evaluate models using BLEU
and rBLEU metrics to ensure translation quality. During our ablation study, we
found that the model's performance is significantly influenced by optimizers,
activation functions, and label smoothing. Further research aims to refine
visual feature capturing, enhance decoder utilization, and integrate
pre-trained decoders for better translation outcomes. Our source code is
available to facilitate replication of our results and encourage future
research.
|
[
-0.0354376398,
-0.7246525884,
0.2881892025,
0.3421782553,
-0.6405482292,
0.0436035618,
0.0690237284,
-0.7760632634,
-0.2124116421,
0.6331416368,
-0.1801481545,
-0.5268710852,
-1.2913681269,
0.1996305287,
-0.9130987525,
0.7852658033,
-0.2925445139,
0.1124415547,
0.4931096137,
-0.2555674314,
-0.3506005108,
-0.3166734576,
-1.0180902481,
-0.35956043,
-0.0585123114,
0.390853256,
1.0071080923,
0.7713164091,
0.8771796823,
0.2692216933,
-0.1993061602,
-0.1688813865,
-0.0392640345,
-0.0700281039,
0.2778035998,
-0.152833268,
-0.6061592102,
-0.0927824527,
0.8312920928,
0.5462218523,
0.0375549421,
0.0128868753,
-0.1707820743,
0.6283182502,
-0.171818912,
-0.0304976348,
-0.2244441062,
0.0413123257,
-0.0944699571,
-0.1255932301,
-0.4316410124,
-0.6056209207,
0.079657428,
-0.2985154688,
0.4708860815,
0.0729914531,
0.7661815882,
0.6217536926,
-0.8513398767,
-0.5100496411,
-1.0018160343,
0.3840230405,
-0.9108311534,
1.0570673943,
0.379745394,
0.1405427307,
0.0701237321,
-0.4641080797,
-0.6081444621,
-0.0989373475,
0.0686190054,
-0.030277079,
-0.1136882529,
0.4071016014,
0.2624703944,
0.4834220707,
-0.6648744345,
-0.0998231545,
-0.7769744992,
-0.2601094544,
0.8230441213,
-0.0420241766,
0.6507610679,
-0.1133989692,
-0.0916992202,
-0.5483606458,
-0.1580551863,
0.0151160071,
0.1383590698,
0.3078007698,
-0.4713902473,
0.6171532869,
-0.0087277116,
0.8524471521,
-0.2367934138,
-0.4397495687,
0.3962680101,
-0.4939286709,
-0.3290143311,
0.1185224727,
0.6414392591,
0.2583011091,
0.1366713047,
0.1910667121,
-0.3226235211,
0.1407697797,
-0.0000334093,
-0.783380568,
-0.0840238929,
0.1844751835,
-0.7300478816,
0.1603470296,
0.0959531143,
-0.3453809619,
-0.2081691474,
-0.3795125782,
0.3912089467,
-0.575327456,
-0.3693079948,
0.2767345011,
-0.2765152156,
-0.0209872499,
0.6059954166,
-0.8798558712,
0.4016510546,
0.3878111541,
1.1506441832,
-0.2455318272,
-0.0932800993,
-0.5177522302,
-0.0052977996,
-0.2415818423,
0.4166388512,
-0.1231945232,
-0.7593278885,
0.1918405145,
-0.1980082542,
-0.1372183263,
-0.3512446582,
0.4307793081,
-0.3990841508,
-0.2097341418,
-0.0651389211,
-0.3877409697,
-0.2560775578,
-0.1723092049,
-0.6276137233,
0.6766620874,
0.0366352983,
0.0619050153,
0.501044631,
-0.6512107849,
-0.7762657404,
-0.1993876696,
0.0798469409,
-0.5953197479,
0.2031320035,
0.0395705998,
0.2484668642,
-0.1046328694,
-0.3267209828,
0.333946079,
-0.1142449826,
0.4205283523,
-0.4097084105,
0.5701041818,
0.5925214291,
-0.1470849514,
0.237454012,
-0.7865639925,
-0.3983084559,
-0.2564149201,
-0.5051969886,
-0.0618392192,
-0.1751903594,
0.3719046712,
0.2262732536,
0.0712947249,
-0.5597553849,
-0.3191204071,
-0.3308882117,
0.4693083465,
0.1907201111,
0.1891395152,
0.4175778031,
0.1339469105,
0.6139680147,
-0.0155106653,
0.3222996593,
-0.2167120576,
-0.5482421517,
-0.5832238197,
-0.0259631258,
-0.019375585,
0.5951960087,
-0.3006690741,
0.3326088786,
0.0973764658,
-0.003624727,
-0.7716829777,
0.3788323402,
0.6583274007,
0.5639721751,
0.6016359329,
-0.7111485004,
-0.0535262488,
-0.4147587121,
0.2085002214,
-0.4099259675,
0.0260811076,
0.0319085941,
0.4270103276,
0.0545723513,
0.1311314255,
-0.2112889588,
-0.6638288498,
-0.0607510246,
0.4060300589,
0.19755283,
0.3233002126,
0.2863149047,
-1.0990437269,
-0.7138887048,
0.5770193338,
-0.4756768048,
-0.0686436966,
-0.2202894539,
0.198534295,
0.4393334687,
0.6220842004,
-0.2999354303,
1.0612896681,
0.9128242731,
-0.8400154114,
0.286380142,
-0.2308268696,
1.0265352726,
-0.8342936039,
0.1543843299,
-0.0409164242,
-0.3378045559,
-0.5509953499,
-0.1123541817,
0.0529463738,
-0.374447614,
-0.5554600358,
0.5585317016,
-0.5530236959,
-0.4441103637,
-0.5128889084,
0.1451483369,
-0.1548704952,
-0.1709993631,
0.2495212555,
0.8330221176,
0.3262875974,
-0.7388921976,
0.4842858315,
1.0334682465,
-0.1668847799,
0.5333014131,
-0.67945081,
-0.0453249514,
0.2444981039,
-0.0468107909,
-1.1418190002,
-0.2059689909,
0.3175198436,
-0.8341655135,
0.5216670036,
-0.118865639,
-0.0969753563,
-0.3714617491,
0.1859726161,
0.2927092314,
0.7076066732,
-0.436362505,
0.3400626183,
0.3521873951,
-0.1602970809,
-0.4470283091,
-0.9020897746,
0.4022856057,
-0.0543045737,
-0.6742945313,
0.1585139334,
-0.0128761716,
-0.162598297,
-0.0734812021,
-0.2967421412,
-0.2272802442,
-0.0507233292,
0.0132641215,
0.0100392122,
-0.0683019087,
0.0999666229,
0.0410813764,
-0.1678755283,
-0.0604179986,
-0.0410410576,
0.2660269737,
0.0841880143,
-0.3627937138,
-0.7833938003,
0.6458787918,
0.3922798336,
-0.3111710548,
0.5549152493,
0.4792686999,
-0.2265171856,
0.10667485,
-0.4821937382,
-0.2237053812,
-0.4695809186,
0.4526902437,
-0.3458402157,
-0.6501973271,
0.5401580334,
0.1345356554,
0.0513745733,
-0.2558597922,
0.4315157533,
-0.0710931793,
1.2387574911,
0.7477197647,
0.3229147196,
0.8553151488,
-0.0365945064,
0.1271043867,
-0.6390483975,
-0.1939152479,
-0.7057697177,
-0.1122395247,
-0.001382448,
-0.5067113042,
0.3552771509,
0.2673257589,
0.0723853707,
0.6317844987,
-0.6651673913,
-0.08961799,
0.3888631165,
0.2042698115,
0.7450284958,
-0.0568864718,
0.4091913104,
-0.1986890882,
-0.2157761604,
-0.5657038093,
0.9086518288,
0.6793837547,
0.69850564,
0.332765013,
0.647467494,
0.4070814252,
0.3003604114,
-0.8935760856,
0.5253281593,
-0.4155753255,
-0.6696520448,
-0.6316944361,
-0.3074741066,
-0.9117655158,
-0.0044236258,
-0.431019634,
-0.5190081,
0.094204776,
0.750115037,
0.2226674259,
0.0219349023,
-0.7811145186,
1.0094655752,
-0.4220934808,
-0.0836395547,
-0.457810849,
-0.7684469223,
0.1948484033,
0.078626655,
0.3179710209,
0.0368895382,
-0.0302358847,
0.6327261329,
-0.513485074,
0.6777158976,
0.1043414921,
-0.3567911088,
0.2605873346,
0.088058047,
0.2004794478,
-0.0699737146,
0.0004515025,
0.1341014057,
-0.0186811946,
-0.4318592846,
-0.4581457675,
0.2336352319,
-0.7012172937,
-0.4270503223,
-0.325620085,
-0.370886147,
0.1702417433,
0.1779882908,
0.4249806404,
0.1932304502,
-0.4110581577,
-0.0020843816,
0.7968381643,
-0.0564332455,
0.5458022952,
0.335262239,
-0.1653320044,
-0.622513473,
0.6770370603,
-0.1302798688,
0.4442830384,
0.4433716536,
-0.1719287634,
-0.5039714575,
-1.2543109655,
-0.5620079041,
0.5266705751,
-0.7829393148,
0.0544059128,
-0.2273471653,
-0.2278154641,
-0.8110316992,
-0.2407244295,
-0.3762948215,
-0.3490101099,
-0.2648073733,
-0.3518558145,
0.4632811546,
0.5894354582,
-0.173390314,
0.8012354374,
-1.0491381884,
0.681900382,
0.2514603734,
0.2106683254,
-0.3699659407,
-0.772372961,
-0.432069838,
-0.2181984335,
-0.2382817417,
-1.2047623396,
0.3691578805,
0.2855558097,
0.2117457539,
0.3187429607,
-0.2229885012,
0.5363969207,
-0.460683912,
0.8040883541,
0.7927211523,
-1.1747711897,
0.7927662134,
-0.2256553173,
0.396217823,
0.3286599517,
0.0903394893,
-0.8377376199,
-0.4531940222,
-0.3913556337,
-0.8909355998,
0.5769811273,
0.3943724334,
0.0105814552,
0.0097751254,
0.2670471668,
-0.0644604266,
0.1526241899,
-0.7600941658,
-0.226482302,
-0.4545480609,
-0.2180288136,
-0.2304023355,
-0.017633969,
-0.0682148039,
-0.0917060152,
0.586643219,
0.0893623307,
0.0393357053,
0.3761222661,
-0.3795936406,
-0.6312114596,
0.2204553932,
0.6188248992,
0.556025207,
-0.0431057326,
-0.0832353979,
0.0353571139,
-0.8336659074,
0.1713632345,
0.1522260755,
-0.2637626231,
0.1583961993,
0.4700613618,
0.9954250455,
-0.1160281673,
-0.4783785343,
0.4352002442,
0.0842643529,
-0.4556608796,
-0.2906070948,
0.0934099928,
-0.2947373688,
0.2550920248,
0.3942492008,
0.1326352656,
0.2848915458,
-0.4747702479,
0.4471732378,
0.2700468004,
-0.5806142688,
-0.4577273726,
1.1561552286,
0.8622959852,
-0.8973386288,
0.3898649514,
0.2530093789,
-0.3811156154,
0.5099798441,
0.6242154241,
0.770655334,
-0.6844450235,
0.4394981563,
0.5142236352,
0.5226968527,
-0.2642323971,
0.3191919029,
-0.1096006557,
-0.5248148441,
-0.6320409775,
-0.5307299495,
-0.6388412118,
-0.0956789628,
-0.6752136946,
0.504640162,
-0.2047146112,
-0.2806104124,
-0.3401101828,
-0.173460111,
-0.4752547443,
0.8302360177,
0.4288754761,
0.8623837233,
-1.2598400116,
0.6871575117,
0.8187410831,
-0.5755772591,
-0.5943344235,
-0.1772553474,
-0.0167412031,
-0.5509491563,
0.5100742579,
-0.2223171443,
-0.1433360577,
0.2040232569,
-0.1778424233,
-0.7507086992,
0.7952924967,
0.2514912784,
-0.2214489579,
-0.0672293529,
0.2926031649,
0.5842605233,
-0.2755193412,
-0.027443856,
0.6971981525,
0.5697037578,
0.2936472893,
-1.2305893898,
0.0868705288,
0.075650461,
-0.0525525212,
0.4847464561,
-0.6391307116,
0.3028115928,
-0.3005032539,
-0.3121018708,
-0.0260465369,
0.976573348,
0.0862728059,
0.637167573,
0.3416318297,
0.3210954368,
0.3792167902,
0.1176677644,
0.8015844822,
0.0144202504,
-0.1039521769,
0.6027309299,
0.1715349406,
0.8748179674,
0.6917737126,
-0.2216900885,
0.0686915442,
0.2291356772,
0.3064175248,
0.1668155491,
-0.2711054683,
-0.2625004053,
-0.2170904875,
0.0305436086,
-0.3204153478,
0.2697575986,
0.5109655857,
-0.5225074291,
0.0849766135,
0.283331275,
-0.2967582345,
0.7985240817,
-0.2181446552,
0.5799260736,
0.4284986258,
-0.4392774701,
0.5096946359,
-0.2607325912,
0.4345541,
-0.7361027002,
-0.3104932606,
-0.2539405227,
0.0501437634,
-0.28510198,
-0.6348446012,
0.6147777438,
-0.0310179312,
0.0156912375,
-0.6038589478,
0.493722409,
-0.5388675332,
-0.2590940297,
0.4275571704,
0.2454220206,
0.5044386387,
0.385269165,
-0.7703629136,
0.4974117875,
0.2422669828,
-0.3222007453,
-0.0139117111,
0.2372177839,
-0.0675334334,
0.5386999846,
0.5868923068,
0.3299776018,
0.1808564663,
0.1526816785,
0.3054459393,
-0.9092122912,
-0.5724331141,
-0.4009444416,
0.7246853709,
-0.0397270843,
-0.6346936822,
0.7234339714,
0.4485588074,
0.6696608067,
-0.171188727,
0.7473531961,
-0.1476909369,
0.418969065,
-0.7574658394,
0.6810941696,
-0.3941196203,
0.1761940867,
-0.4150029421,
-1.0764570236,
-0.623626709,
0.6552199125,
0.1729389578,
-0.3126488626,
0.8394289017,
0.4370750785,
0.0315946229,
-0.2793007493,
0.6670004725,
0.1570118368,
0.426046133,
0.3275350332,
0.4241005778,
-0.9908874035,
1.1548985243,
-0.0853603929,
-0.4341410995,
-0.3379976749,
-0.794864893,
-0.8303412199,
-0.6951293349,
-0.9167314172,
-0.4493326247,
0.0706309006,
0.3754527867,
0.791883409,
-0.7662267685,
-0.544398129,
-0.1075132713,
0.1876731068,
-0.3833213151,
-0.1158078164,
0.2804071903,
-0.0375762507,
-0.9078444242,
0.3909177482,
0.0755314603,
0.5207255483,
0.1671402454,
-0.499991864,
-0.0379996896,
-0.0202861633,
0.4788370132,
0.7216155529,
-0.5691536665,
-0.5911951065,
0.0634253323,
-0.0485381335,
0.0691079348,
0.7603170276,
-0.2041522563,
0.4701420069,
0.7486320138,
0.3292078674,
0.9333130717,
0.3517051339,
0.7930192947,
-0.8397797346,
0.394328028,
0.1133331433,
0.201746136,
0.5912315845,
-0.312283963,
0.5680280924,
0.0929802582,
-0.5328498483,
-0.8461247087,
0.406591475,
-1.264034152,
-0.1562148631,
1.1319155693,
0.1170473695,
-0.1922935694,
-0.4220825434,
-0.4333087504,
0.6290605068,
-0.6137958765,
0.671882987,
0.653609097,
-0.3977443874,
-0.7006526589,
-0.5654382706,
0.6618509293,
0.4528465867,
-0.3652713001,
0.0416521877,
0.6807317734,
0.0847697705,
0.2635592222,
0.774076283,
-0.3488081694,
0.7348101139,
0.1345730126,
0.4271181226,
-0.1315134168,
-0.1857540756,
-0.5003743768,
-0.2408311814,
0.4496327341,
-0.2837961614
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07233v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07233v1
|
TransGPT: Multi-modal Generative Pre-trained Transformer for Transportation
| 2024-02-11T15:50:35 | 2024-02-11T15:50:35 |
Peng Wang, Xiang Wei, Fangxu Hu, Wenjuan Han
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Natural language processing (NLP) is a key component of intelligent
transportation systems (ITS), but it faces many challenges in the
transportation domain, such as domain-specific knowledge and data, and
multi-modal inputs and outputs. This paper presents TransGPT, a novel
(multi-modal) large language model for the transportation domain, which
consists of two independent variants: TransGPT-SM for single-modal data and
TransGPT-MM for multi-modal data. TransGPT-SM is finetuned on a single-modal
Transportation dataset (STD) that contains textual data from various sources in
the transportation domain. TransGPT-MM is finetuned on a multi-modal
Transportation dataset (MTD) that we manually collected from three areas of the
transportation domain: driving tests, traffic signs, and landmarks. We evaluate
TransGPT on several benchmark datasets for different tasks in the
transportation domain, and show that it outperforms baseline models on most
tasks. We also showcase the potential applications of TransGPT for traffic
analysis and modeling, such as generating synthetic traffic scenarios,
explaining traffic phenomena, answering traffic-related questions, providing
traffic recommendations, and generating traffic reports. This work advances the
state-of-the-art of NLP in the transportation domain and provides a useful tool
for ITS researchers and practitioners.
|
[
-0.5451859236,
-0.8436608315,
0.5536338091,
0.5608734488,
-0.507514596,
-0.0842764676,
-0.2559502125,
-0.3675028682,
0.0768658742,
0.3413493633,
-0.7105688453,
-0.049485378,
-0.4689312875,
0.0384159684,
-0.6764736772,
0.8675435781,
0.0024723343,
0.1021828577,
0.1655665189,
-0.0066157333,
-0.6761764884,
-0.6891229749,
-0.6522586942,
-0.0741418973,
0.3689028323,
-0.1388261616,
0.9156358838,
0.1546449959,
0.706951201,
0.295730561,
0.4191622734,
-0.045919925,
0.0086884992,
-0.1248804554,
-0.3570129275,
0.30206424,
-0.4683208466,
-0.1847541034,
0.8652129769,
0.756105423,
-0.1382241249,
-0.0964820459,
-0.0904255062,
0.3299368024,
-0.3543776274,
0.2630197406,
-0.5066100955,
-0.0302123036,
-0.4958854914,
-0.1925375015,
-0.2603727877,
-0.2554673553,
0.4402037263,
-0.5865877271,
0.335749656,
0.2673046887,
0.771871984,
0.4031490684,
-1.1191115379,
-0.1046954989,
-1.0630635023,
0.6584481001,
-0.3766483665,
0.8763977289,
-0.0123864459,
0.5536817908,
0.3309521079,
-1.0040327311,
-0.7906169891,
-0.226497069,
-0.2742936611,
0.2359377593,
-0.014560164,
-0.0384497903,
-0.0361777283,
0.2287044376,
-0.9985880256,
-0.1681301147,
-0.4203185737,
-0.0374916345,
0.3050937653,
0.2691487372,
0.249569118,
-0.1046422869,
-0.8313263655,
-0.0131480535,
-0.6290431023,
-0.2560635507,
0.0286312103,
0.5350006223,
-0.0243745353,
0.388253361,
-0.0669331402,
0.9048239589,
-0.3485257626,
0.2358727902,
0.4308578372,
-0.4380273819,
-0.2857459784,
-0.1764595807,
1.1625301838,
-0.0060471511,
0.0089859627,
-0.477676034,
-0.2106643617,
-0.1854412407,
0.4741519094,
-0.6827824116,
-0.0634938404,
-0.3048301637,
-0.3193695843,
0.0909909606,
0.190283224,
-0.8393856883,
0.1031877846,
-0.612367034,
0.4478417635,
-0.4803954959,
-0.6002143621,
0.4677837491,
0.0848091468,
0.3142778873,
0.3445512652,
-0.9065039158,
-0.0130160162,
0.6053834558,
1.0182843208,
-0.497672677,
-0.4806963205,
-0.2330120653,
0.3616476655,
0.2453328818,
1.078196764,
-0.7906608582,
-0.446870774,
-0.0685666427,
0.2132418603,
-0.3989217281,
-0.0742891207,
1.1088274717,
-0.4721025825,
0.3080409765,
-0.0615158007,
-0.1267694831,
-0.2535887957,
0.2931420505,
-0.8227078319,
0.8734347224,
0.3690494895,
-0.6500968933,
0.2445271909,
-1.0309125185,
-0.9141758084,
0.3095010817,
0.0818228796,
-0.4970255494,
0.0875228196,
0.1027143225,
0.211719498,
-0.4192187786,
0.4416024983,
0.0239794087,
-0.0999227986,
0.0517933518,
-0.8185625672,
0.6278017759,
0.0438934229,
0.0847875178,
0.1481931508,
-0.6603035927,
0.0189250316,
-0.0278070085,
-0.5573199987,
-0.259637326,
-0.2081828862,
0.8146818876,
0.4775421023,
0.0751963109,
-0.6224743128,
0.2406387329,
-0.2182806432,
0.6151121259,
0.8274252415,
-0.2334069461,
0.3492558897,
-0.2925458252,
0.6035130024,
-0.0294918977,
0.3439710438,
0.0051204558,
-0.6351976395,
-0.6154952645,
0.2906842828,
0.3565288186,
0.5332995057,
-1.1778582335,
0.4172069728,
-0.7915095687,
-0.5161260366,
-0.3060136437,
-0.5728027225,
-0.2714492083,
0.5415868759,
0.555950582,
0.0323072784,
-0.4143152237,
-0.6470612884,
-0.1408383697,
0.0841616988,
-0.0557173975,
-0.0519581363,
0.3197197914,
-0.4270039797,
0.8859556317,
-0.4803600311,
-0.2745658457,
-0.2997476757,
0.1792326868,
-0.2734760642,
0.6562824249,
0.5654832721,
-1.0044695139,
-0.5240083933,
0.0005183267,
-0.316342026,
0.0641384348,
-0.3162103295,
-0.2707616091,
-0.4102707207,
0.1872143745,
-0.9198714495,
0.0751323104,
0.6403415799,
-0.5910533667,
0.4143031538,
-0.1106426418,
0.1391278505,
-1.0680209398,
0.0622437708,
-0.1471778899,
-0.5011996031,
-0.8568529487,
-0.1400796026,
0.0082097463,
-0.472561866,
-0.3699866235,
0.1721463948,
-0.1465659589,
-0.0193243977,
-0.2811317146,
-0.0605556592,
-0.0884153321,
0.4452671409,
0.4416162372,
0.9174351692,
0.5903911591,
-0.4868299067,
0.5663826466,
0.4356927872,
-0.335287571,
0.4807881713,
-0.6060270667,
0.3170675933,
-0.3235635161,
0.0707973167,
-0.6419775486,
0.1379316151,
0.1669301987,
0.2239200026,
0.012883313,
-0.1547130346,
-0.5210421681,
-0.2795074582,
0.2134686112,
0.4990405142,
0.3404331803,
-0.2948315442,
0.9753609896,
0.362522155,
-0.2325277776,
-0.1310498714,
-0.698140204,
0.3384746015,
-0.1183282956,
-0.6585538983,
0.3618486524,
-0.2677413821,
0.4768607914,
0.0340513811,
0.0548846275,
-0.3783644736,
-0.0205266345,
0.1691330224,
0.4260340333,
-0.1452646405,
0.3910693228,
-0.2663759589,
-0.4476844966,
0.1140557826,
-0.3444552422,
0.85659343,
-0.2615272105,
-0.5450521111,
-0.1316709369,
0.5161485076,
0.5589776635,
-0.5873878002,
0.7562987208,
1.0870007277,
0.0233824104,
-0.0132644568,
-0.032450106,
-0.0127360951,
-0.4904895425,
0.4989869595,
-0.6429538131,
-0.8580441475,
-0.1730614156,
-0.327639401,
-0.0312331617,
0.4558763206,
0.4339775443,
0.1413979381,
0.9510779977,
0.7869334221,
0.0833705217,
0.6398287416,
-0.0733256713,
0.6998186707,
-0.5726028085,
-0.2846007049,
-0.5236868858,
-0.168550998,
-0.6423673034,
-0.4472607672,
0.6399111748,
-0.5113990307,
-0.3397699296,
0.444434762,
-0.4862537086,
0.2728345394,
0.6458954215,
0.0358092152,
0.6184664965,
-0.0999624059,
0.4048732817,
-0.0033590125,
-0.6396229267,
-0.3204215765,
0.8587068319,
0.0050564688,
0.7787183523,
0.2301719934,
-0.1120943725,
0.2185123265,
0.4433075488,
-0.7187852859,
0.5048585534,
-0.2733096778,
-0.6031569839,
-0.2670786977,
-0.7120475173,
-0.8138786554,
0.230642885,
-0.283392936,
-0.07987082,
-0.1397203654,
-0.1329165399,
-0.3190210164,
0.3667322099,
-0.8194851279,
1.0491293669,
-0.4057666659,
0.0559451245,
0.0903569758,
-0.6319757104,
0.3312308788,
-0.3108534217,
0.053773161,
-0.0787069201,
0.0239786692,
0.4572977126,
-0.1308459491,
0.4130441546,
0.0249730609,
-0.1542411894,
-0.0082784807,
0.0578508563,
0.4747392237,
0.038872648,
0.0233855564,
0.302323699,
-0.1001526564,
0.0138095198,
-0.5987609625,
0.602129221,
-0.5183231831,
-0.3120895922,
-0.252836436,
-0.5974625349,
-0.3723308146,
0.4046405852,
0.2770164013,
0.565136075,
0.0271530654,
0.0901739523,
0.3087846339,
-0.1327750087,
0.638569653,
0.4805152416,
-0.0176044498,
0.0433329158,
0.9431790709,
-0.0269808136,
0.2427162081,
0.600910008,
0.2155881524,
-0.6313275695,
-0.4374405742,
-0.602666378,
0.0236698259,
-0.5721406937,
-0.1300078183,
-0.7914460897,
-0.3155679703,
-0.3127736449,
0.1501839012,
-0.593241334,
-0.5151393414,
0.0173493344,
-0.1351629347,
-0.0181862693,
0.7476946115,
0.1622256339,
0.5429521799,
-0.7436720729,
0.382036984,
0.5839273334,
0.5784958601,
-0.1608985215,
-0.1984329671,
-0.1623621732,
0.0112197958,
-0.3191091418,
-0.558080852,
0.4307486415,
0.078065291,
0.3462741077,
0.2018382251,
0.02706692,
0.4331117272,
-0.6988174319,
0.8395223022,
0.2407877296,
-0.8227261901,
0.2990196049,
-0.159067139,
0.3716535866,
0.2375268489,
0.3167866766,
-0.8652774096,
-0.0673533157,
-0.2256387919,
-0.6048556566,
0.5331246853,
0.6077282429,
0.3285748363,
0.2159805298,
-0.1085762754,
0.2005373985,
0.3886583447,
-1.184176445,
-0.1167977825,
-0.7325285077,
-0.2777395546,
-0.058056131,
-0.0538416207,
0.1234913468,
-0.3044826686,
0.664152205,
-0.1064021885,
0.4091294706,
-0.070901528,
-0.1432862431,
0.1987732053,
0.5143188238,
0.8076689243,
0.6892701387,
-0.1304929703,
0.5087651014,
-0.0445991158,
-0.6906341314,
0.2123208195,
0.2420896292,
-0.391764015,
0.2345832139,
0.2624441385,
0.793266356,
-0.2472429872,
-0.5938385725,
0.6907240152,
-0.2699516118,
0.108834371,
-0.3797393739,
-0.2909252346,
-0.1297887564,
-0.0952168927,
0.1835828125,
0.5689368248,
0.2464625835,
-0.2379299253,
-0.1197085083,
0.2950065732,
-0.5989118218,
-0.620646596,
1.0212430954,
0.3566714525,
-0.1865677536,
0.6026595235,
-0.2359397262,
-0.6880148649,
-0.0387035236,
0.4175869524,
1.0126781464,
-0.2677244842,
0.1776012778,
0.1537553519,
0.5613902807,
-0.0658551976,
0.1081636474,
0.1094941795,
-0.8529436588,
-0.6741394401,
-0.6643766165,
-0.0367700681,
0.1318850368,
-0.1392770112,
0.1522016823,
-0.1797160655,
-0.3738915622,
-0.3087469339,
-0.6053455472,
-0.8733474016,
-0.0482142866,
-0.0113645671,
0.7141473889,
-0.8594806194,
0.8032580018,
0.7714539766,
-0.4703900814,
-0.701128006,
0.1352951378,
-0.5552862287,
-0.5091261864,
0.7013775706,
-0.0213502012,
-0.1675893515,
0.1367034465,
-0.2420513332,
-0.702978611,
0.7791819572,
0.4949195385,
-0.5222358704,
-0.4082817137,
0.8444858789,
0.2428599,
0.0312240999,
0.2001212984,
0.5606535673,
0.7094331384,
-0.1572486162,
-1.1365346909,
0.0814499855,
0.0294096228,
0.2274530679,
0.2918536067,
-0.7186977863,
0.9583374262,
0.3125452399,
-0.3580247462,
-0.2829696536,
0.3471574187,
-0.2151907384,
-0.0165084712,
0.8287806511,
0.5632304549,
0.3952126503,
-0.4322417378,
0.906688571,
-0.1524370015,
0.5162791014,
0.899859488,
-0.1632249951,
0.3373561502,
0.5989945531,
-0.1054535732,
0.3873294592,
0.1654094458,
0.1162733138,
0.8922724724,
-0.0534729622,
-0.5010274649,
-0.6288459301,
-0.149801746,
-0.413287431,
0.5297459364,
-0.0247251038,
0.1483511627,
-0.6105729938,
0.6303950548,
-0.1713940948,
-0.3297734559,
-0.176054582,
0.5951440334,
-0.0762523785,
-0.2715222836,
0.1792474389,
0.1958567351,
0.5812473893,
-0.7446944714,
0.009726583,
0.0342402421,
0.0545096099,
0.05143103,
-0.864816606,
0.6168307066,
-0.2825304866,
-0.0317592584,
-0.893032074,
0.5679896474,
-0.4646877646,
-0.5311190486,
-0.2027944028,
0.4597245753,
-0.1756200194,
-0.5815474987,
-0.5873035789,
0.1163810566,
-0.1909203976,
-0.3040636182,
-0.0565438755,
0.7783255577,
0.0642219931,
0.9246287346,
0.5853477716,
0.053728275,
0.3084147573,
0.301376909,
0.9170675874,
-0.7607514858,
-0.7129398584,
-0.7945007086,
0.5184062719,
0.0375687666,
-0.2655305564,
0.4888825119,
0.7295307517,
0.5998098254,
-0.4277000129,
0.9661218524,
-0.1467198431,
0.4905245006,
-0.7373399138,
0.2369595915,
-0.2415635586,
0.3074879944,
0.052813407,
-0.8532562256,
-0.0481884293,
0.6183250546,
-0.1965217292,
0.105808951,
0.8302866817,
0.50190413,
-0.6503579021,
0.3416719139,
0.1619216651,
-0.2009791136,
0.8117681742,
0.9030266404,
1.2411972284,
-0.6471529603,
0.8626060486,
-0.1954670697,
0.3682819903,
0.0659848377,
-0.7637885213,
-0.8310484886,
-0.9953267574,
-0.1796528846,
0.1436642408,
-0.284550935,
0.6671213508,
1.0448321104,
-0.4776979089,
0.0435700826,
-0.346778661,
0.0493329018,
-0.1554881781,
-0.283110857,
0.3715617657,
-0.1266992837,
-0.8329098821,
0.5201281905,
0.361587584,
0.5077257752,
-0.3955201805,
0.1350464672,
0.0579310916,
-0.3417623043,
0.7202046514,
-0.2718409598,
-0.1557320654,
-0.4830738008,
-0.1445054859,
-0.0096798539,
0.0590630658,
1.4131537676,
-0.7352312207,
0.0708424151,
0.4456959367,
0.6022972465,
0.7178328633,
0.1807399094,
0.7167535424,
-0.9030508995,
0.3792444766,
0.3358200788,
0.2530257404,
0.4338787198,
-0.1867349595,
0.5305597782,
0.5190401673,
-0.4700605273,
-0.4465358257,
0.3869593143,
-1.2589102983,
-0.2154866904,
1.010956645,
0.3670141399,
0.1259721369,
-0.5285670161,
-0.1881942153,
-0.0021746075,
-0.2845852971,
0.5164224505,
0.3839944005,
0.1156704351,
-0.4119330943,
-0.9808901548,
0.6045504808,
-0.0499978438,
-1.0413639545,
0.1756614,
0.3268941045,
0.2095562667,
0.0015033934,
0.6167728305,
0.275191009,
-0.1817069501,
-0.3846425414,
-0.2276933193,
-0.2221101373,
-0.2406257987,
0.0708550662,
0.4586823285,
-0.4115121365,
-0.0791400224
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07214v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07214v3
|
Through the Lens of Split Vote: Exploring Disagreement, Difficulty and Calibration in Legal Case Outcome Classification
| 2024-02-11T14:21:37 | 2024-06-06T10:53:50 |
Shanshan Xu, T. Y. S. S Santosh, Oana Ichim, Barbara Plank, Matthias Grabmair
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In legal decisions, split votes (SV) occur when judges cannot reach a
unanimous decision, posing a difficulty for lawyers who must navigate diverse
legal arguments and opinions. In high-stakes domains, understanding the
alignment of perceived difficulty between humans and AI systems is crucial to
build trust. However, existing NLP calibration methods focus on a classifier's
awareness of predictive performance, measured against the human majority class,
overlooking inherent human label variation (HLV). This paper explores split
votes as naturally observable human disagreement and value pluralism. We
collect judges' vote distributions from the European Court of Human Rights
(ECHR), and present SV-ECHR, a case outcome classification (COC) dataset with
SV information. We build a taxonomy of disagreement with SV-specific
subcategories. We further assess the alignment of perceived difficulty between
models and humans, as well as confidence- and human-calibration of COC models.
We observe limited alignment with the judge vote distribution. To our
knowledge, this is the first systematic exploration of calibration to human
judgements in legal NLP. Our study underscores the necessity for further
research on measuring and enhancing model calibration considering HLV in legal
decision tasks.
|
[
-0.6228889823,
-0.1686071754,
0.4495657384,
-0.0440926328,
-0.4416760802,
0.41593799,
-0.0891657323,
-0.3844468296,
0.1738017201,
0.406825155,
-0.4340727031,
-0.4499617219,
-0.5537419915,
-0.0463707037,
-0.0032430545,
1.0545698404,
0.1068972573,
0.4621330202,
-0.4031893015,
-0.6925899386,
-0.4329636395,
-0.7351281643,
-0.0004556934,
-0.5302107334,
0.662766397,
0.3743618131,
0.8775268197,
0.2972867191,
0.4709855914,
0.318459481,
-0.1689464152,
-0.1129840985,
-0.1521948129,
0.0269615557,
-0.4351799786,
-1.0010882616,
-0.2779825926,
0.2830688357,
0.109068729,
0.653455019,
-0.5141756535,
-0.0830987394,
-0.2226020247,
0.9441565871,
-0.7449390292,
-0.0065356214,
-0.4900178909,
0.5015179515,
-0.3049117029,
-0.1520172656,
-0.5331014991,
-0.3226784766,
0.3249987662,
-0.3910512924,
0.639470458,
0.2526561916,
0.8953561783,
0.9185848236,
-0.801435411,
-0.2698351443,
-0.6058181524,
0.7506402135,
-0.8272768259,
0.2955145538,
0.2812966704,
0.3446367979,
0.0243473835,
-0.3302489817,
-0.5633850098,
0.0085230544,
0.1660112888,
0.4073988497,
0.0584483109,
0.113979727,
0.1638521701,
0.0476419367,
-0.3402253389,
0.2975036204,
-0.2050860226,
-0.3835856915,
0.8973195553,
0.1354009807,
0.1539560258,
-0.3711715341,
-0.0481275544,
-0.3085374236,
-0.3930909336,
0.310629189,
0.7917813063,
0.2991096377,
0.015103153,
0.5042746663,
0.2013561577,
0.8834807873,
0.2255028933,
0.0688890815,
0.2820148766,
-0.0468306094,
-0.2069239467,
0.2974896133,
0.7486912608,
0.3675658405,
-0.2238202244,
0.1927265674,
0.0620451719,
0.1002333537,
0.4961968362,
-0.4737188816,
-0.090859957,
0.228951633,
-0.2018163204,
-0.4197642505,
0.386841476,
-0.6351351738,
-0.8316132426,
-0.5357537866,
0.1670850813,
-0.0395900868,
-0.0392533801,
0.3045092821,
-0.1498767436,
0.3446970284,
0.8277968764,
-0.6114945412,
0.0408277325,
1.0862308741,
0.2921969295,
-0.2250787467,
0.0292554386,
-0.4372473061,
-0.4823858738,
-0.4134314358,
0.4968655705,
-0.2766456902,
-0.0411598235,
-0.1141290218,
-0.2197830677,
-0.13249892,
-0.6631580591,
0.9160414338,
-0.6155641079,
0.3907800317,
-0.2925235033,
-0.6909288168,
-0.3481983244,
0.3601134419,
-0.6495774984,
0.4905620515,
-0.2436411977,
-1.0135685205,
1.2100129128,
-0.405157119,
-0.3676871359,
0.5188490152,
-0.5464992523,
-0.5413069725,
0.0607320257,
-0.0775133595,
0.1347915828,
-0.0973929092,
0.3401470184,
-0.5646468401,
-0.039048925,
0.1073081642,
-0.3653541505,
0.8726552129,
-0.0773287266,
-0.4166773856,
0.1094124094,
-0.653132081,
-0.0037890682,
-0.3130688071,
-0.51762712,
-0.5075467825,
0.5271206498,
-0.2053975165,
0.4228297174,
-0.0466374196,
-0.6976844072,
0.0109540764,
-0.3840891421,
0.2067819983,
0.7521519065,
-0.1815612018,
0.3205984533,
-0.1616546512,
0.5594774485,
0.2586033344,
0.170548141,
0.4113019109,
-0.7841629982,
-0.7489683032,
0.1186493561,
0.7425359488,
0.470441103,
-0.1404010803,
0.7320787907,
-0.2121637464,
-0.3941138089,
-1.0143805742,
-0.0250335149,
-0.0131024253,
0.3516247571,
0.097041361,
-0.509722054,
-0.5409066081,
-0.8139714599,
-0.284922719,
-0.5175955892,
0.1038984135,
0.570194602,
0.6623921394,
-0.2065095007,
1.1527396441,
-0.0347560607,
-0.2978912592,
0.2608169913,
0.656778574,
0.1093444526,
0.2059499323,
0.0338639505,
-1.1997042894,
-0.2809917629,
0.1793618947,
-0.555283308,
0.0320001282,
-0.0878327042,
-0.147810623,
0.3336672485,
0.155380249,
-0.1408145875,
0.7919515371,
0.2707424164,
-0.6843829155,
0.6655498743,
-0.2816601098,
0.2764625251,
-0.7204738259,
-0.3672703505,
0.1061783656,
-0.507712543,
-0.2566258609,
0.0003438073,
0.0168108512,
0.7254086137,
-0.6215153933,
-0.0638931766,
-0.1515324265,
-0.231853351,
-0.1389677972,
0.1042941064,
-0.0091025801,
0.1753096581,
0.0783861652,
0.4047209918,
-0.0268919934,
-0.1373625249,
0.536575377,
0.2433656901,
-0.3720933795,
0.9645879865,
-0.337297231,
0.2389069498,
-0.2349713892,
0.2836301923,
-0.6695249677,
-0.3361433744,
-0.1071587875,
-0.2551892102,
0.146799475,
-0.5619780421,
-0.3895215988,
-0.4363314807,
-0.0698931441,
0.6482872963,
0.191228658,
-0.3694717884,
0.606972754,
0.550104022,
0.1425767839,
-0.7684784532,
-0.6059647202,
0.2825148404,
-0.1259285957,
-0.7041225433,
0.260204196,
-0.0263090767,
-0.4032198787,
-0.0799741074,
-0.0909716934,
0.0458666161,
-0.263779223,
0.8331977725,
0.2503491938,
-0.1578378081,
0.0726591274,
-0.0268314593,
0.2628983855,
0.1565897316,
0.2363893837,
0.3569015265,
-0.445974797,
-0.8784649372,
-0.3242253661,
0.2039238662,
0.6406053305,
-0.0057440139,
0.312481612,
0.0327892788,
-0.2479285151,
-0.1024709642,
-0.6635270715,
0.2450054884,
-0.3746670187,
0.2189296484,
-0.1102638617,
-0.7748688459,
0.51398772,
0.0171627142,
0.2447943389,
0.5951586962,
0.8672759533,
-0.2814823985,
1.1148308516,
0.2820084989,
-0.0993704796,
0.0411129184,
0.1000009105,
-0.0158480462,
-0.5505288243,
-0.3494865596,
-0.6463705301,
-0.6092396379,
-0.5131666064,
-0.5472558141,
0.2005836815,
-0.0749051869,
-0.3479004204,
0.0439722426,
-0.4852060676,
0.5110999346,
0.6087838411,
0.2389551103,
0.2758816481,
-0.2811273336,
-0.5756517053,
-0.4765928984,
-0.6133394241,
-0.3329761326,
0.9458119869,
0.2313393205,
0.5519342422,
0.0504052639,
1.1383868456,
0.5733671188,
0.1635998487,
-0.9124525189,
0.3230379522,
-0.0041827983,
-0.7502809167,
-0.4800413847,
-0.4478206635,
-0.8518414497,
0.5475959182,
-0.2387189567,
-0.5720766187,
0.6257439256,
-0.0594131537,
-0.6436750293,
0.3309082687,
-0.413780719,
0.9877703786,
-0.2932372391,
-0.4155482054,
-0.1240577996,
-0.8645686507,
0.2892720103,
-0.0742814317,
0.4841737747,
-0.1322209984,
0.2234230191,
0.9485731721,
-0.9943306446,
0.7575457692,
-0.2285222858,
-0.0939193144,
0.1547616571,
0.0884758756,
0.3167898059,
-0.076896295,
-0.0757974014,
-0.1668594927,
0.1499324292,
-0.1817962527,
-0.4574881196,
0.2526075542,
-0.8473080397,
-0.6062499285,
-0.7231324911,
-0.4083568156,
-0.1098425984,
-0.1105466783,
0.3307917714,
-0.2202652991,
-0.1854116917,
0.2132813781,
0.2668323517,
0.0461498015,
0.332858175,
0.5634942651,
0.0331323072,
-0.3258716464,
0.7679156661,
0.1198520362,
-0.0607822277,
-0.0560820289,
0.2915041149,
-0.3404616117,
-0.3386364579,
-0.5436117649,
-0.030519085,
-0.7027773261,
-0.1865396798,
-0.0734147951,
-0.0587580837,
-0.0791500732,
-0.2060658485,
-0.5661952496,
-0.3319111168,
-0.3207075894,
-0.2061128467,
-0.0694988891,
0.6916802526,
-0.0217976496,
-0.1914937347,
-0.5961853862,
0.0728151277,
0.5331481099,
0.1923945695,
-0.4339368641,
-0.6680891514,
-0.0089731161,
0.0721405074,
-0.1903694421,
-0.9462026954,
0.3292344511,
-0.0482078083,
0.1922307462,
0.4995743036,
0.4354718924,
0.8858315349,
-0.4129549861,
0.7423294187,
0.3151973188,
-0.8639835119,
0.4841772914,
0.0297104605,
0.0060772528,
0.9989048839,
0.0279583056,
-0.6989687085,
-0.2550789118,
-0.5939877033,
-0.852522254,
0.8439075947,
-0.1609203666,
-0.0754042566,
0.6218133569,
0.2583070993,
0.1958365142,
0.2589777112,
-0.6406663656,
0.1265646368,
-0.0614162125,
-0.1413730979,
0.0303396899,
0.074351877,
-0.5499042869,
-0.5827230811,
0.4954348803,
-0.0997802764,
-0.3311602771,
0.1470180452,
-0.1892735809,
-0.4173131883,
0.3849985003,
0.6166759729,
0.4160971045,
-0.3502461314,
0.1917865872,
0.0252068788,
-0.2745161951,
0.4579046369,
0.0125900535,
-0.3233498633,
-0.0115518915,
0.3861694336,
1.0366928577,
0.1054369137,
-0.4805486798,
0.9200600982,
-0.1961624771,
-0.7244170308,
-0.2502344847,
-0.0191799831,
0.0843318552,
0.2919902802,
0.3634274602,
0.4633734226,
0.2155539244,
-0.3439710438,
0.3678373992,
0.2857370079,
-0.7213635445,
-0.1410347372,
0.6733671427,
0.3060954809,
-0.5277804136,
0.5184718966,
-0.3370539844,
-0.7885373831,
0.6386403441,
-0.1176247522,
0.7271196246,
0.0262393001,
0.4656887054,
-0.1002303809,
0.2243937403,
-0.3689837158,
-0.0082987295,
-0.2066755742,
-0.8885695934,
-0.3671514988,
-0.4387867749,
-0.8744191527,
-0.5819574594,
-0.9896940589,
0.133712694,
-0.4308437109,
-0.4203744233,
0.2618304491,
0.0658590198,
-0.8189400434,
0.2284049094,
0.3001940846,
0.4969578385,
-0.8730788231,
0.480215162,
0.6072975993,
-0.1235203743,
-0.6774309278,
-0.034988828,
0.2495463043,
-0.4219036102,
0.7811411619,
0.2421344519,
-0.0090096779,
-0.5768068433,
-0.6131016016,
-0.1277744621,
0.7941852212,
0.4118874669,
-0.8236253262,
-0.0795297548,
0.4700895846,
0.7921642661,
-0.2174725085,
0.0965405926,
0.5935018063,
0.536557734,
0.2453104258,
-0.7735946178,
-0.1729388833,
-0.1621074528,
-0.3579412699,
0.1004334465,
-0.6086344719,
0.5445706248,
-0.2462633252,
-0.1015658826,
-0.6909252405,
0.4523423016,
0.2575537562,
0.5917779803,
0.8778077364,
0.8443384171,
1.0150980949,
-0.3647886813,
0.7783464193,
0.1487149894,
0.4669539034,
1.2734092474,
-0.6767369509,
0.9845559001,
0.766676724,
-0.5467141867,
0.7048204541,
0.6765290499,
-0.0644806549,
0.1579381227,
0.4662081599,
-0.3695703447,
-0.7929388285,
0.1819830537,
-0.0223407466,
0.631806314,
0.0570970476,
-0.1199161187,
-0.1019068137,
-0.114304319,
-0.3814924657,
0.008728005,
-0.1016366258,
0.8410447836,
-0.0254072696,
-0.8306630254,
0.1577147543,
0.1040232852,
0.7008298039,
0.0548817813,
0.1098246649,
0.0631912723,
0.0423477925,
-0.4266165793,
-0.8412041068,
0.1379841566,
-0.1172365695,
-0.2586071193,
0.059863016,
0.2280722409,
-0.1214308962,
-0.4627656937,
0.2648127079,
0.3681207597,
0.2240651846,
-0.1628317684,
-0.9096336365,
-0.1621003747,
0.1192566603,
-0.3931216002,
0.2621916533,
0.3577469289,
-0.0420489088,
0.3632995784,
0.4438064098,
0.1278506368,
0.4891442955,
0.3848218024,
0.3913342953,
-0.5311146379,
-0.426956445,
-0.8379499912,
0.5487098694,
-0.2148370743,
-0.3427465856,
0.1459265053,
0.6729977727,
0.5838339329,
0.2471978217,
0.6632753015,
-0.008958118,
0.4086708128,
-0.1546010077,
0.6517000198,
-0.6203439236,
0.1859100163,
-0.1719381958,
-0.3047343194,
-0.5843843818,
0.5537917018,
-0.2635717392,
-0.213517502,
0.2266752273,
0.5491804481,
0.0712255761,
0.2034366429,
0.4973957539,
-0.1139644906,
0.2924182713,
0.5227546096,
0.7306839824,
-0.4443940818,
0.3771346807,
-0.2300173193,
-0.0521513522,
-0.5249743462,
-0.8048253655,
-0.506201148,
-0.4456698596,
-0.5943105221,
-0.463850379,
-0.1997533441,
0.9652124047,
0.9669690132,
-1.0859409571,
-0.2367957681,
-0.2947057188,
0.2779513001,
-0.0013928988,
-0.2053133398,
0.2535536289,
-0.1570103616,
-0.6831248999,
0.0491023622,
0.1986773163,
-0.0140681071,
-0.0779674947,
-0.469450742,
-0.1444097459,
0.1588443518,
0.2553969622,
0.4579026401,
-0.9729524255,
-0.2564872503,
-0.5314925909,
-0.2569068074,
0.515442431,
0.7991578579,
-0.4845606387,
0.8620913029,
0.4713648558,
0.5701417923,
0.6379619837,
0.2698924541,
0.5761876106,
-0.7187859416,
0.0643367618,
0.5293289423,
0.6115841269,
0.2716787457,
-0.0872114897,
0.3905869424,
0.3419125378,
-0.6706192493,
-0.85847193,
0.0915363058,
-1.0523295403,
-0.0526772104,
0.6126919985,
-0.2085817158,
-0.1590520591,
-0.1025041789,
-0.3252740502,
0.2272546291,
-0.2825816274,
0.8852933049,
1.0941420794,
-0.1601796597,
0.0128748314,
-0.4617934227,
0.5006272793,
0.6565707922,
-0.6367631555,
0.0408456996,
0.6774565578,
0.0466333777,
0.55716151,
0.1859448701,
-0.2239314765,
0.291982621,
-0.1515626907,
0.2769167125,
0.3177078664,
-0.0883226618,
-0.443190366,
0.4580449164,
-0.0726774931,
-0.0095032882
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.15518v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.15518v1
|
Beware of Words: Evaluating the Lexical Richness of Conversational Large Language Models
| 2024-02-11T13:41:17 | 2024-02-11T13:41:17 |
Gonzalo Martínez, José Alberto Hernández, Javier Conde, Pedro Reviriego, Elena Merino
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The performance of conversational Large Language Models (LLMs) in general,
and of ChatGPT in particular, is currently being evaluated on many different
tasks, from logical reasoning or maths to answering questions on a myriad of
topics. Instead, much less attention is being devoted to the study of the
linguistic features of the texts generated by these LLMs. This is surprising
since LLMs are models for language, and understanding how they use the language
is important. Indeed, conversational LLMs are poised to have a significant
impact on the evolution of languages as they may eventually dominate the
creation of new text. This means that for example, if conversational LLMs do
not use a word it may become less and less frequent and eventually stop being
used altogether. Therefore, evaluating the linguistic features of the text they
produce and how those depend on the model parameters is the first step toward
understanding the potential impact of conversational LLMs on the evolution of
languages. In this paper, we consider the evaluation of the lexical richness of
the text generated by LLMs and how it depends on the model parameters. A
methodology is presented and used to conduct a comprehensive evaluation of
lexical richness using ChatGPT as a case study. The results show how lexical
richness depends on the version of ChatGPT and some of its parameters, such as
the presence penalty, or on the role assigned to the model. The dataset and
tools used in our analysis are released under open licenses with the goal of
drawing the much-needed attention to the evaluation of the linguistic features
of LLM-generated text.
|
[
-0.3959356546,
-1.0642802715,
0.4451816678,
0.2369185686,
-0.4665200114,
-0.0249832682,
-0.4621616006,
-0.5511433482,
0.1397234946,
0.6809661984,
-0.2968865037,
-0.1770302504,
-0.8099130988,
-0.0108378856,
-0.4495348334,
1.1551504135,
0.3039085269,
-0.1248986423,
-0.3093991876,
0.0834775046,
-0.352997601,
-0.6173294783,
-0.2795092165,
-0.4170488119,
0.5369068384,
0.053750582,
1.3279943466,
0.4100143015,
0.5349377394,
0.2838138044,
-0.6487169862,
-0.0003565746,
-1.003682971,
0.150342837,
0.0267454982,
-0.2746718824,
-0.2901715636,
-0.11567837,
0.624270916,
0.7800760865,
0.0444895029,
0.011820321,
0.3607202768,
0.3690698147,
-0.4151808321,
0.2675121427,
-0.9235295653,
-0.0222001579,
-0.2410037965,
-0.6236424446,
-0.1861249506,
-0.2984086871,
0.6172036529,
-0.2039037347,
0.1317598522,
-0.0651148036,
0.7479220033,
-0.0488092378,
-0.1079182923,
-0.558797121,
-0.6222960353,
0.7684292197,
-0.6516212225,
0.3486367166,
0.2461858243,
0.1816070825,
-0.2199669182,
-0.4637483358,
-0.4278342426,
-0.6673381329,
0.0436250381,
0.2340522259,
-0.2480923384,
0.156735301,
0.0347235575,
0.5743014812,
-0.404558152,
0.0282525979,
-0.3135405183,
-0.223016575,
0.584232986,
0.0107767144,
0.3102884293,
-0.3703744709,
-0.5292533636,
-0.081696704,
-0.7947880626,
-0.3443549275,
0.4756577313,
0.3656281829,
-0.1244047582,
0.9854508638,
-0.0343735889,
0.425915271,
-0.6117706895,
-0.211609602,
0.086949259,
-0.4503492415,
-0.1496866494,
0.0348351039,
0.7942302227,
0.2402241677,
0.7126669288,
-0.4020304978,
-0.2616153061,
-0.0308808517,
0.1634320468,
-0.771643877,
-0.0522669442,
0.0113505889,
-0.3167451322,
-0.3642883301,
-0.2344322652,
-0.7917707562,
-0.5094559789,
-0.1692956537,
0.5140969753,
-0.3708248734,
0.0292587057,
0.1703116745,
0.0711673945,
0.2931493223,
0.4417063892,
-0.8037195802,
0.3804807663,
0.7582115531,
0.814859271,
-0.2597118318,
-0.3183037043,
-0.3408923745,
-0.1032336727,
-0.1995784789,
0.7438633442,
-0.7045538425,
-0.8881196976,
0.0956509411,
-0.1860423982,
0.0663397834,
-0.6165865064,
0.5155742168,
-0.5164868832,
0.0555430911,
-0.2831270993,
-0.5923543572,
-0.107915327,
0.271040678,
-0.3779598475,
0.7409722805,
0.1324713528,
-0.9167708158,
0.224548474,
-0.4368364811,
-0.2903293967,
0.4596542418,
-0.2016182691,
-0.2440780699,
0.2409373075,
-0.0453174971,
0.3867979944,
-0.2981787622,
0.1255042553,
-0.2946146429,
-0.4201573431,
0.6606382728,
-0.7636220455,
0.4953785539,
0.2666766346,
-0.2157431692,
-0.142025128,
-0.5081378222,
0.1813993603,
0.1203759685,
-0.5669460297,
-0.1768322885,
0.2251253277,
0.1681541204,
-0.1325341314,
0.3462209404,
-0.1808668077,
-0.170927763,
-0.636634469,
0.2867841721,
0.5922932029,
0.1075361818,
0.123142615,
-0.3449783325,
0.6031563282,
-0.0652956292,
0.1226491332,
-0.1947649717,
-0.6594116688,
-0.8661348224,
-0.1913648099,
0.2718774676,
0.5621584058,
-0.4743903577,
0.3318853378,
-0.3482150435,
-0.8030794263,
-0.1861247718,
0.2389710844,
0.4793426991,
-0.1552329808,
0.0849260241,
-0.4131724238,
-0.2398117036,
-0.8273137808,
-0.4265424311,
-0.2010367066,
0.0553026721,
0.5395869017,
0.4428084493,
-0.2593515813,
0.9320212007,
-0.3527523577,
0.1633752435,
-0.4108434319,
-0.0728069395,
-0.2329157442,
0.1298266649,
0.3899948895,
-0.4780018628,
-0.1424781382,
0.0894665793,
-0.3870739341,
-0.2628950477,
0.1233548075,
0.0052980506,
-0.0836269036,
0.3595383167,
-0.5385113955,
0.3404577672,
0.7805766463,
-0.1770807207,
0.5417634845,
-0.2600432336,
-0.2140969187,
-0.9791601896,
0.0467070714,
-0.0807861164,
-0.0676582754,
-0.4707201719,
0.1254169345,
-0.2575092912,
-0.3095857203,
-0.5038077235,
0.718386054,
-0.4533854425,
-0.266266346,
-0.1759813577,
0.5650319457,
-0.1009980142,
0.127895847,
-0.0967376158,
0.8293158412,
0.5005005002,
-0.5605103374,
0.3293028772,
0.2420915514,
-0.5386351943,
0.1220969558,
-0.6980386376,
0.0532626249,
-0.0655060634,
-0.2037793845,
-0.948448658,
-0.0569213368,
0.0576193519,
-0.4974844456,
0.1395405233,
-0.0687303022,
-0.7154014111,
-0.0032849673,
-0.1736305505,
0.1069773734,
0.4565374851,
-0.194011569,
0.2187807858,
0.4176144004,
-0.2542332411,
-0.346586138,
-0.7308555841,
0.2402350903,
-0.178170532,
-0.693629384,
0.0230112225,
-0.161547035,
-0.5274745226,
-0.124851808,
0.1440894604,
0.1288407445,
0.3256786168,
0.229577899,
0.2744069397,
-0.1356412619,
0.2160058469,
-0.2768926322,
-0.0132261384,
0.0260553081,
0.0854217261,
0.7978165746,
-0.2138105929,
-0.4133214951,
0.0713169873,
0.0485844091,
0.5810950994,
-0.3132939637,
0.8431206346,
0.3073927164,
-0.1325688511,
-0.1999211013,
-0.5354416966,
-0.0796362683,
-0.4756955206,
0.643142879,
-0.0074936613,
-0.9193535447,
0.6026470065,
0.1678789556,
-0.1429084986,
0.3139259517,
0.8071195483,
0.3917446733,
0.7965112925,
0.5876686573,
-0.0322753638,
0.4572395384,
0.1408168823,
0.4779929519,
-0.6270548105,
-0.2737654448,
-0.6027936935,
-0.0238276124,
-1.0900784731,
-0.5573102832,
0.3478314877,
-0.076300934,
0.1662372798,
0.1345373541,
-0.131318301,
0.5256437063,
0.1360888779,
-0.0122355241,
0.3871999979,
0.2237426788,
0.0062718699,
-0.0010815134,
-0.6501925588,
-0.7794815302,
0.9920623899,
0.5115159154,
0.9541184306,
0.1684826314,
0.57971102,
0.1696185917,
0.0952866748,
-1.0841354132,
0.7128425241,
-0.0721548423,
-0.4187869728,
-0.1418242902,
-0.6526297927,
-1.1353652477,
0.3612551689,
-0.3159511685,
-0.8263664842,
-0.1831913888,
-0.2525100112,
-0.2844485641,
0.1229779199,
-0.7594374418,
0.683198154,
-0.295969069,
-0.4077035487,
-0.1866609901,
-0.3214333057,
0.2723057866,
-0.2524589002,
0.2468244433,
-0.127607137,
-0.3091806769,
0.6424863338,
-0.3035005033,
0.7837591767,
0.3334125578,
-0.3202340901,
0.3588474095,
0.3336660862,
0.3770559728,
0.1195129529,
-0.0500344336,
0.1982085705,
0.2571785152,
-0.342782855,
-0.2234461159,
0.8219550848,
-0.7709819078,
-0.6070495844,
-0.308671385,
-0.5086250901,
-0.3638490438,
0.0898395851,
0.2827583253,
0.4962592721,
-0.4941454232,
0.2276518494,
0.6965536475,
-0.7192314863,
0.2910250425,
0.2158690542,
-0.4737222195,
-0.209056899,
1.0208227634,
0.2160506546,
0.6448985934,
0.0448290333,
0.4929085374,
-0.245272696,
-0.7739994526,
-0.2411855161,
0.3355025053,
-0.804325521,
0.1420407444,
-0.5628691912,
-0.4749776125,
-0.1818770021,
-0.0718185976,
-0.3659555614,
-0.0922837481,
-0.385468483,
0.3434659243,
0.3178706169,
0.8640628457,
0.3864191473,
0.5359780788,
-0.9958215356,
-0.1869740486,
0.3336548507,
0.3893083334,
0.0804003403,
-0.5794444084,
-0.0474813469,
-0.0284080282,
-0.4466807544,
-0.7221376896,
0.46956411,
0.207360968,
0.5411291718,
0.5273204446,
-0.2265058607,
0.4140187502,
-0.3115275204,
0.9523882866,
-0.0078614699,
-0.865763247,
0.2613807917,
-0.4079456031,
0.4501722455,
0.3518956006,
0.1140338257,
-0.6937340498,
-0.5217510462,
-0.7431912422,
-0.8481814861,
0.4810115993,
0.5148982406,
0.9084678292,
-0.3004198074,
0.1475544721,
0.090620324,
0.3402297795,
-0.8047415614,
-0.1031171679,
0.1505342424,
0.1958191842,
-0.1473852545,
-0.699113071,
0.0593675822,
0.2048680931,
0.4405478537,
0.0422919504,
0.0540804937,
0.0602668636,
-0.123956576,
0.0716120005,
0.5051993132,
0.5649385452,
0.6830593944,
0.0237936322,
0.1729976386,
0.2530910671,
-0.5551554561,
-0.4876700044,
-0.0430839024,
-0.0706673712,
0.0741882697,
0.4063245952,
0.8491496444,
0.4254076779,
-0.9623754025,
0.6351733804,
0.0738086924,
-0.031991668,
-0.1843392998,
0.0192535929,
0.2430809736,
0.2351540923,
-0.1165929213,
-0.09159825,
0.0026137398,
-0.7973354459,
0.0206855703,
0.6784411669,
-0.4800927639,
-0.2137489766,
0.1918875724,
0.0893490985,
-0.2407793105,
0.3836178184,
-0.1825677007,
-0.7656481862,
0.4005720317,
0.4099956751,
0.7334933877,
-0.0179470908,
0.069721885,
0.0387885273,
0.4288704395,
0.0959657654,
0.0673148558,
0.0878256261,
-0.7950773239,
-0.3482906222,
-0.8893831372,
-0.4823660851,
0.2608972788,
-0.1182140708,
0.4145261347,
-0.405546844,
-0.060800083,
-0.1186796725,
-0.0149142323,
-0.4674178958,
0.0832637325,
0.4916720986,
0.7093245983,
-0.4861332476,
0.4797316492,
0.2820294201,
-0.1150861606,
-0.5395038128,
0.1272507906,
-0.0750479102,
-1.0155425072,
0.5035201311,
0.0829478651,
-0.1590831429,
-0.0633066595,
-0.3968071938,
-0.8120824695,
0.5463969707,
0.4352710545,
-0.3947404623,
0.192391336,
0.5331523418,
0.6868433952,
-0.0571469702,
0.4551039636,
0.5023902655,
0.40342471,
0.2618213892,
-1.1044164896,
-0.2283239067,
-0.0159946978,
0.2399069667,
0.0984541923,
-0.5953267813,
0.8015902638,
-0.3060109615,
-0.4023718536,
0.1422831416,
0.265645057,
0.0067955917,
-0.124881722,
0.2428177297,
0.3787524104,
0.613702476,
-0.103740491,
1.2091764212,
-0.2719933093,
0.4696179628,
0.8510016799,
-0.3168255389,
0.8258413672,
0.4604231417,
-0.2757410407,
-0.1199906617,
0.5343020558,
-0.1619513184,
0.2051368654,
0.6780245304,
-0.4407167435,
-0.1073643491,
-0.081196472,
-0.3937869668,
0.8052114844,
0.3750585616,
-0.5425906181,
-0.545635879,
-0.3017999232,
0.273540318,
-0.0830705091,
-0.2466049939,
0.8477087617,
0.1022577509,
-0.5150281191,
0.596750021,
-0.1542999446,
0.6291915178,
-0.7626034021,
0.1043807566,
-0.1935372502,
0.0662699342,
-0.1938279122,
-0.7120149732,
0.2756934464,
0.1468711793,
0.290227741,
0.0358770415,
0.597838819,
-0.228954047,
-0.5455746651,
0.4685840905,
0.8486260176,
0.5609189868,
-0.0760400295,
-0.6377776861,
0.314339906,
-0.0616480224,
-0.5040497184,
0.4690930545,
0.5060344934,
0.1454718858,
0.7393333912,
0.6183885336,
0.3791045547,
0.1547354013,
0.0872517973,
0.9742894769,
-0.4583067,
-0.172021687,
-1.0778582096,
0.0792865157,
0.1625823677,
-0.4987211227,
0.7783834934,
0.6101627946,
0.7132640481,
0.117688261,
0.8772901893,
0.0599252656,
0.2366820574,
-0.543269217,
1.0602141619,
-0.5178472996,
0.6479300857,
-0.4131731391,
-1.3324120045,
-0.1202804372,
0.2315562963,
-0.5198425055,
0.381395936,
0.7152029872,
1.0040391684,
0.0652300939,
0.2249615788,
0.7192257643,
0.1583024412,
0.1435340792,
0.1735181063,
1.0301127434,
-0.1831806451,
0.6666807532,
-0.0674031451,
-0.1678627431,
-0.2404201329,
-0.9904389977,
-0.7477370501,
-0.3165477216,
-0.2291145325,
-0.4176370203,
-0.0669345632,
0.7595751882,
0.3583643436,
-0.5435519218,
-0.4117589593,
0.0491706282,
-0.0003565266,
0.3538840711,
-0.2020160407,
0.1439242363,
-0.4578006566,
-0.6968266964,
0.2499652654,
0.3193511069,
0.2564965785,
-0.4591270983,
-0.0012943401,
0.1139308363,
0.4588329196,
0.7680520415,
-0.1230700463,
-0.6937894821,
-0.3910392225,
-0.0695902556,
-0.2153645307,
0.0059573706,
0.6134547591,
-0.5387935042,
0.5645158887,
0.4638606012,
0.616464138,
0.2238127589,
-0.3473903537,
0.4416636825,
-0.3811346292,
0.0376756862,
0.1759427488,
0.3847455084,
0.5203794837,
-0.1304072887,
0.232276246,
0.2373848408,
-0.6305096149,
-0.6499662399,
0.1712056845,
-1.1637368202,
-0.1711485982,
1.4494844675,
0.0016868395,
-0.2416952848,
0.0121275736,
-0.4365998209,
0.1247354597,
-0.2194554061,
0.797275126,
0.8419972062,
0.1422045827,
-0.1866566837,
-0.8892807961,
0.3584051132,
0.3682031929,
-0.7665495872,
0.3952439129,
0.3713446259,
0.2654123008,
0.1141912341,
0.1326489449,
-0.5183539987,
-0.1021421105,
0.0956263468,
-0.0046717483,
0.24884139,
0.1215271875,
-0.3016449511,
0.0102939503,
0.5910465121,
0.125401333
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07204v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07204v2
|
Synergizing Spatial Optimization with Large Language Models for Open-Domain Urban Itinerary Planning
| 2024-02-11T13:30:53 | 2024-05-23T10:24:00 |
Yihong Tang, Zhaokai Wang, Ao Qu, Yihao Yan, Kebing Hou, Dingyi Zhuang, Xiaotong Guo, Jinhua Zhao, Zhan Zhao, Wei Ma
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In this paper, we introduce the novel task of Open-domain Urban Itinerary
Planning (OUIP), a paradigm designed to generate personalized urban itineraries
from user requests articulated in natural language. This approach is different
from traditional itinerary planning, which often restricts the granularity of
user inputs, thus hindering genuine personalization. To this end, we present
ItiNera, an OUIP system that synergizes spatial optimization with large
language models (LLMs) to provide services that customize urban itineraries
based on users' needs. Upon receiving the user's itinerary request, the LLM
first decomposes it into detailed components, identifying key requirements,
including preferences and dislikes. Then, we use these specifics to select
candidate POIs from a large-scale collection using embedding-based
Preference-aware POI Retrieval. Finally, a preference score-based Cluster-aware
Spatial Optimization module clusters, filters, and orders these POIs, followed
by the LLM for detailed POI selection and organization to craft a personalized,
spatially coherent itinerary. Moreover, we created an LLM-based pipeline to
update and personalize a user-owned POI database. This ensures up-to-date POI
information, supports itinerary planning, pre-trip research, POI collection,
recommendations, and more. To the best of our knowledge, this study marks the
first integration of LLMs to innovate itinerary planning, with potential
extensions for various urban travel and exploration activities. Offline and
online evaluations demonstrate the capacity of our system to deliver more
responsive, personalized, and spatially coherent itineraries than current
solutions. Our system, deployed on an online platform, has attracted thousands
of users for their urban travel planning.
|
[
-0.5727421641,
-0.4318954945,
0.9139727354,
0.4316905737,
0.2073313594,
-0.0174879543,
-0.5393343568,
-0.3233812451,
0.7004168034,
0.2315795571,
-0.5822549462,
-0.7174155116,
0.1895043999,
-0.2620888948,
-0.0253885593,
0.5592304468,
-0.2861608863,
0.0539724827,
-0.1679330617,
-0.1986553818,
-0.5643519163,
-0.6005168557,
-0.6221098304,
-0.1658119559,
0.3962779343,
0.6631467342,
0.5089917779,
0.168130815,
0.4129413962,
0.2071765065,
0.1108413786,
0.1014160588,
-0.531052947,
-0.2754731178,
-0.3823069334,
0.0663019419,
-0.2023403496,
-0.5956609249,
0.6021009684,
1.0293588638,
-0.6712623835,
0.0763354897,
-0.2458970994,
0.473141104,
-0.8158616424,
-0.1582936794,
-0.613730371,
0.0738772973,
-0.0973550677,
-0.1877742708,
0.1216944456,
-0.374209553,
0.2767511606,
-0.7422032952,
-0.2650826275,
0.3467993736,
0.5586500764,
0.0827282369,
-0.1800449342,
-0.1639435589,
-1.1502382755,
0.9100401998,
-0.4787674844,
0.4591005147,
0.2529414594,
0.4670854211,
-0.1019310132,
-0.4579984546,
-0.5461214185,
-0.1002794653,
0.007161201,
0.2241352648,
-0.1669466496,
-0.1663224548,
-0.1145348623,
0.0956862569,
-0.7152956724,
0.324131608,
-0.2777484953,
0.253765583,
0.50863868,
0.4608667195,
0.1126668677,
0.1848711222,
-0.4994559884,
0.2927120328,
-0.7168337107,
0.302923888,
0.2114656717,
0.232356742,
-0.0472244099,
0.7056291699,
-0.3878315985,
0.2490976602,
-0.2620508075,
0.2470715195,
-0.1145354956,
-0.4774884582,
-0.1511656493,
-0.005906208,
0.8258560896,
0.3107813001,
0.0904937088,
-0.4916310906,
-0.1634667069,
-0.2001105249,
0.2961267829,
-0.6269443035,
-0.1578768343,
0.6316560507,
-0.1626811773,
0.1108316481,
0.1703605205,
-0.8541859388,
-0.0269856174,
-0.3827545047,
0.0301157553,
-0.1989491135,
-0.1829365045,
0.5050843358,
0.0468743406,
-0.1017420813,
0.2786816359,
-1.0130887032,
0.493247658,
0.4953062534,
0.6606945395,
-0.1603152156,
-0.4493811727,
-0.1123017445,
0.3917180896,
-0.1511429548,
1.0283632278,
-0.8056412935,
-0.4617365003,
0.1918697953,
-0.4755640924,
0.0522287264,
-0.4817826152,
0.592920661,
-0.5358742476,
0.1041176617,
-0.4036326706,
-0.1105629876,
-0.1761742383,
0.2185787559,
-0.4534027874,
1.1875752211,
0.1789839119,
-0.2778386176,
0.3801737726,
-1.0137978792,
-0.23851794,
0.1575109363,
-0.0795422494,
-0.1853554994,
0.2363636792,
0.2337868363,
-0.0216125287,
-0.2046833038,
0.5397170186,
-0.4939714074,
0.0135469409,
-0.2020578533,
0.5795966387,
0.682369709,
0.2876161933,
-0.1735919416,
0.5432630777,
-0.7056332231,
0.3120820522,
0.2382513434,
-0.4804773331,
-0.2579658628,
0.291651845,
0.2889214754,
-0.0767632574,
0.667488575,
-0.7776408792,
0.7326005101,
-0.5403184295,
0.3865463436,
0.7575154901,
-0.1519211233,
0.8748466372,
-0.1648232192,
0.3539946675,
-0.4370796084,
0.3423250318,
-0.036623206,
-0.5454144478,
-0.3495053351,
-0.0788360313,
-0.1427314132,
0.4508461058,
-0.3637749255,
0.8080008626,
-0.4857026339,
-0.5038390756,
-0.0057664611,
-0.0937211439,
-0.4736517668,
0.1670760065,
0.1393210739,
-0.0774589479,
-0.6810363531,
-0.4207563996,
-0.0361254886,
0.1340642273,
0.1141523048,
0.439796418,
0.4985679388,
-0.4316216707,
0.9638106823,
-0.640797317,
-0.6308950782,
-0.2544861138,
-0.3892454505,
0.2321023047,
0.1618714631,
0.9143359661,
-0.5662350059,
-0.5435447693,
0.2036115676,
-0.3391284347,
-0.1984901875,
0.0836498514,
-0.6295927763,
-0.250215292,
0.0097583085,
-0.414879173,
0.3323679566,
0.4132019579,
-0.5184087157,
0.3992788792,
-0.3888559639,
-0.0609868243,
-0.8114826679,
0.3025639653,
-0.2146394402,
0.0323866345,
-0.4812704027,
0.5133311152,
-0.3476970792,
-0.432364732,
-0.1187121868,
0.8269088268,
-0.1178697422,
-0.3200088739,
-0.1887805611,
0.2779274583,
-0.0413805582,
0.7932903767,
0.2738800049,
0.442281723,
0.5177683234,
-0.4198765159,
-0.0193449855,
0.4349142015,
-0.2169663459,
0.2566249669,
-0.323241353,
0.2558232248,
0.0137223648,
0.1920870394,
-0.9231524467,
-0.2290090173,
0.0141731519,
0.1001936346,
-0.4501163661,
0.165101558,
-0.7501066327,
-0.3610121012,
-0.4435328841,
0.362234354,
0.1182752922,
-0.7635006905,
1.0145807266,
0.5954759121,
-0.149836123,
0.0751698464,
-0.2082014978,
0.2117105424,
-0.0351537876,
-0.6342669725,
0.40952757,
-0.3633263707,
-0.3150102496,
0.0190555733,
0.1007809266,
-0.2099057883,
0.0761349201,
0.2372733504,
0.25622347,
0.2314564139,
-0.1788783222,
-0.0787863359,
-0.0076642428,
-0.1849523336,
-0.9100846052,
0.8786526918,
0.0451730452,
-0.2864588201,
-0.3307525516,
0.901391983,
0.3388397992,
-0.4953832626,
0.6213902831,
0.6483789682,
-0.4109166265,
-0.0778878704,
-0.310199976,
0.0233774427,
-0.4409758747,
-0.0290224478,
-0.6635563374,
-0.8961161375,
0.5867798924,
-0.3392731249,
0.4493485093,
0.1159190387,
0.6094354987,
-0.2164263278,
1.0027451515,
0.8284779191,
-0.0982134566,
0.6557433009,
-0.4553407729,
0.4571365416,
-0.5891618133,
-0.3170342147,
-0.7033246756,
-0.688270092,
-0.407710135,
-0.3098491132,
0.701631248,
-0.0160768814,
-0.4334961176,
0.2283552736,
-0.4586608708,
0.4970006645,
0.8280498981,
-0.1722935885,
0.3762396276,
0.2218585163,
-0.2650028467,
-0.0894269273,
-0.7941640615,
-0.435370326,
0.9889751077,
0.0032942917,
0.7796856165,
0.3087700605,
0.5795487761,
0.0508416519,
0.0375625975,
-0.5602876544,
0.576454103,
-0.1525652558,
-0.3138576746,
-0.1170737818,
-0.3231165409,
-0.9819255471,
0.0134948082,
-0.3470094502,
-1.3655748367,
0.5581506491,
0.080740191,
-0.7460538745,
0.6204459667,
-0.6717377901,
0.5575550795,
-0.5800442696,
-0.4452666342,
-0.4124769866,
-0.1680747867,
-0.032161057,
-0.1214703396,
0.1962758005,
0.0178182963,
-0.1020492688,
0.284273237,
-0.2455808818,
0.3315964043,
-0.3429319263,
-0.1452042907,
0.0987399444,
0.2414644659,
0.6257309318,
-0.1543136537,
-0.2376552075,
0.8110041022,
-0.2187637389,
-0.2230778188,
-0.3221059442,
1.169555068,
-0.740069747,
-0.1900457591,
0.1326598376,
-0.460915029,
-0.0973085836,
0.4073911011,
0.2401156574,
0.2567065358,
-0.264293164,
-0.3366666436,
0.1160867289,
-0.3146305382,
0.3404779136,
0.5013065338,
-0.6747483611,
-0.5710769296,
0.9599425197,
-0.0283390805,
-0.1181361601,
0.6250487566,
0.4653951824,
-0.3767773211,
-0.8573141694,
-0.3141783476,
0.1710824966,
-0.4154241681,
0.171502918,
-0.747033298,
0.395873934,
-0.4462235272,
-0.6117676497,
-0.3944598436,
-0.4491502941,
-0.0339597762,
0.1455310583,
-0.2175625116,
0.8096708655,
-0.0224582497,
0.3348279893,
-0.3516029418,
0.3412163258,
-0.2299814373,
0.5189029574,
-0.1181179509,
0.0343920141,
-0.4971954226,
-0.1500569731,
-0.2495018691,
-0.4024325013,
0.366537571,
0.0040561981,
0.5163764954,
0.8442922235,
0.0875461325,
0.7728105783,
-0.7302467823,
0.6507510543,
0.0071262843,
-0.4673574269,
0.6685038805,
-0.482721895,
0.411172688,
0.7531415224,
0.3563522696,
-0.2970520258,
-0.2149514854,
-0.2872459292,
-1.0624340773,
0.6023602486,
-0.0012202464,
-0.0915460512,
0.1042588353,
0.2516849041,
0.1878890395,
0.5363029838,
-0.7105150819,
-0.0069635441,
-0.0975690186,
0.0539644435,
-0.0031070318,
-0.2616912425,
-0.3494014442,
-0.3915799856,
0.5768995881,
-0.2443525642,
0.4314914644,
0.1336589009,
0.2982117236,
-0.5200434923,
0.1123573333,
0.6315155625,
0.9461936951,
-0.3856343329,
-0.3378839195,
-0.1563241482,
0.0145313283,
-0.1834180951,
0.0494945347,
-0.4330925047,
-0.2255882472,
-0.0894459412,
0.7632476687,
0.1714476049,
-0.9633047581,
0.3123742044,
-0.0038123783,
-0.0725527108,
-0.7183810472,
-0.261095196,
-0.1389340311,
0.2874002457,
0.2688501179,
0.175131917,
0.3547843397,
-0.5328013301,
-0.5057067871,
0.6088718176,
-0.0711935461,
-0.4791859686,
0.9565750957,
0.3935541511,
-0.3098190725,
0.2464517504,
-0.2048463225,
-0.5437124372,
-0.0894060284,
0.2042778432,
1.1567867994,
-0.028389411,
-0.0792411417,
0.5760908723,
0.321941644,
0.2689233422,
0.555631578,
-0.3706648648,
-0.7793858647,
-0.3066937923,
-0.6151980162,
-0.2679931223,
-0.1044743061,
-0.3736016452,
0.3101417124,
-0.6706402302,
-0.1792186499,
-0.4531927407,
-0.1468546093,
-0.6567382812,
-0.2367088944,
0.1365860403,
1.0174412727,
-0.3825882673,
0.2555826008,
1.3740339279,
0.0099438531,
-0.5367247462,
0.1414076984,
-0.1396361142,
-0.7086693645,
0.4687422812,
-0.1392337829,
-0.2495779991,
0.0205140878,
-0.2897649407,
-0.8521427512,
0.9064633846,
0.2082679123,
-0.9204868078,
-0.30426687,
0.3068313599,
0.3534225523,
-0.3627069592,
0.1422948837,
0.4694760144,
0.5263816714,
-0.0420722812,
-0.9948796034,
-0.1146431267,
0.0763055682,
0.0852083564,
0.4280383885,
-0.6490241885,
0.4716148973,
-0.6549545527,
-0.3785952926,
0.375286907,
0.2019711137,
-0.1008453742,
0.2534626424,
0.5987330079,
1.0025851727,
0.6464642286,
-0.1754967123,
1.2014448643,
-0.4439667463,
0.1504127383,
1.2590066195,
-0.7151094079,
1.0826025009,
0.5434113145,
-0.0327659175,
0.6042066813,
0.4274835885,
0.2129074484,
0.9213083386,
-0.0437790938,
-0.3949119449,
-0.144627139,
-0.2150103897,
0.12154603,
0.4162724018,
0.0504864044,
0.3818094134,
-0.6974163651,
0.498313427,
-0.2425373048,
0.1830384582,
-0.2602911294,
1.0375158787,
-0.3179791272,
-0.7530964613,
0.1603101194,
0.2162904888,
0.3150411844,
-1.010191679,
0.1481831223,
-0.1808257997,
0.2032617778,
-0.1935666949,
-0.862849474,
0.2138586938,
-0.1864650697,
-0.0569765568,
-0.4372291565,
0.669026792,
-0.4463126063,
-0.1127788052,
0.4858783185,
0.2625036836,
-0.1297719479,
-0.3631715477,
-0.375403583,
0.2144755274,
0.0465092659,
-0.0801376179,
0.1474800408,
0.2511617243,
-0.1860969663,
0.8760492802,
0.8824831843,
0.3382436931,
-0.0549722835,
0.2891629636,
0.8410156965,
-0.6073414683,
-0.9515642524,
-0.5807166696,
0.4695497751,
0.028930055,
-0.1536895633,
0.6201984882,
0.9169145226,
0.8505692482,
0.023060441,
0.6391810775,
0.0066603557,
0.3430879712,
-0.3812038898,
0.0418923125,
-0.4708381593,
0.5927124619,
0.0232541915,
-1.1479450464,
0.0190032851,
0.4392360747,
-0.6071702242,
-0.1229801252,
0.4559653103,
0.4260342121,
-0.1108136773,
-0.1253442168,
0.1853927523,
-0.2123802155,
0.5865703821,
0.7155300975,
0.7847370505,
0.0517954417,
0.3308229446,
-0.3588060141,
-0.3090167642,
-0.2777756751,
-0.4401639402,
-0.6982348561,
-0.4733469486,
-0.0904034078,
0.1795703322,
-0.1015192866,
0.9661406279,
0.7829057574,
-0.6776328087,
-0.4855065644,
-0.3026308715,
-0.1312047988,
-0.0210802518,
-0.3515203595,
0.1884127408,
-0.020047769,
-0.8033459187,
0.6381603479,
0.7040899992,
-0.1149664745,
-0.5026570559,
0.0531033315,
-0.0177586712,
-0.055882223,
0.5412679315,
0.3381771445,
-0.4594260752,
0.063537322,
0.1209998727,
0.1418846101,
0.1508810669,
1.2367694378,
-0.5470866561,
0.6380050182,
0.2236875296,
0.6077144742,
0.390001893,
-0.1046824381,
0.5816171169,
-0.8424066305,
0.1818754524,
0.1351859719,
0.5950927734,
0.112437658,
-0.4418185055,
0.4445368052,
-0.1163440421,
-0.6505729556,
-0.5651603341,
0.2978878021,
-1.2045304775,
-0.2026603669,
1.1040220261,
0.2166666836,
-0.0992293954,
0.0021835594,
-0.565207243,
-0.6296854019,
-0.7124010324,
0.9245991111,
0.3113784492,
-0.3025496602,
0.3616537154,
-0.409195751,
0.1469851285,
0.1334583908,
-0.9915907979,
0.0881923586,
0.5391626954,
0.0285501014,
0.415861547,
0.9141511917,
0.2945991158,
0.0124296341,
-0.3772190809,
0.3196335733,
0.0441077165,
-0.4105354846,
0.0878600553,
0.2928393483,
0.0662418976,
-0.1383409202
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07179v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07179v2
|
Prompt Perturbation in Retrieval-Augmented Generation based Large Language Models
| 2024-02-11T12:25:41 | 2024-06-20T14:07:27 |
Zhibo Hu, Chen Wang, Yanfeng Shu, Helen, Paik, Liming Zhu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR, I.2.7; H.3.3
|
The robustness of large language models (LLMs) becomes increasingly important
as their use rapidly grows in a wide range of domains. Retrieval-Augmented
Generation (RAG) is considered as a means to improve the trustworthiness of
text generation from LLMs. However, how the outputs from RAG-based LLMs are
affected by slightly different inputs is not well studied. In this work, we
find that the insertion of even a short prefix to the prompt leads to the
generation of outputs far away from factually correct answers. We
systematically evaluate the effect of such prefixes on RAG by introducing a
novel optimization technique called Gradient Guided Prompt Perturbation (GGPP).
GGPP achieves a high success rate in steering outputs of RAG-based LLMs to
targeted wrong answers. It can also cope with instructions in the prompts
requesting to ignore irrelevant context. We also exploit LLMs' neuron
activation difference between prompts with and without GGPP perturbations to
give a method that improves the robustness of RAG-based LLMs through a highly
effective detector trained on neuron activation triggered by GGPP generated
prompts. Our evaluation on open-sourced LLMs demonstrates the effectiveness of
our methods.
|
[
-0.508038342,
-1.0014485121,
0.648331821,
0.2251759768,
-0.3269408345,
0.0099820197,
-0.2754748762,
-0.1367844641,
0.1693741679,
0.3071338236,
-0.5980151296,
-0.3143817782,
-0.6413368583,
0.2345221788,
-0.0970554203,
0.9761634469,
0.2856745124,
0.0832918137,
-0.2972830832,
0.0123934615,
-0.5239753127,
-0.5824474096,
-0.9193342328,
-0.3698728681,
0.5951957107,
0.2218326926,
0.6611776948,
0.3935515881,
0.2884699702,
0.2388262451,
-0.558285296,
0.2352898568,
-0.5670926571,
0.4751813412,
-0.1340738684,
-0.2425557971,
-0.4144864678,
-0.1471184194,
0.7667265534,
0.4820697606,
-0.0981843024,
0.2855452001,
0.3428411484,
0.5254648328,
-0.7918410897,
-0.2586387694,
-0.8551225066,
-0.1787021905,
-0.1147296503,
-0.54542768,
-0.5731064081,
-0.1190594062,
-0.2216465622,
-0.4019142985,
0.2464533001,
0.0509033352,
0.892634511,
0.3497121036,
-0.0517171659,
-0.4194540083,
-0.5739185214,
0.7950825095,
-0.7031018734,
0.1624848843,
0.3128281534,
0.173943907,
-0.7029396892,
-0.5819416642,
-0.5447719693,
-0.5396832824,
-0.0712099373,
-0.0805163607,
-0.0708592311,
0.0768158436,
0.7087906003,
0.045847252,
-0.4227000177,
0.3120577633,
0.1811516136,
-0.3135802746,
0.3460647762,
0.2558604181,
0.2502936721,
-0.4558651447,
-0.351860851,
-0.1356642246,
-0.9280825257,
0.1484013349,
0.6736039519,
0.4352782667,
0.1126521826,
0.5244984031,
-0.0246158168,
0.7108799815,
0.4646962583,
-0.1674714386,
0.1922622621,
-0.3003130257,
-0.0900744125,
-0.1616713852,
0.7844923139,
0.1711151153,
0.1509792805,
-0.0175599381,
-0.4971779287,
-0.2028706521,
0.0716066882,
-0.8974087834,
0.231756404,
0.1376242787,
-0.2446006685,
-0.3685699105,
-0.308632791,
-0.87447685,
-0.6053724885,
-0.0898746327,
0.4224397242,
-0.2305961251,
0.1008461267,
-0.0124141471,
0.0240535457,
0.2414001524,
0.3965902328,
-0.8430523276,
0.0599543527,
0.5159953237,
0.5758558512,
-0.1237295419,
-0.1165646464,
-1.2568382025,
-0.0543318279,
-0.3669110239,
0.7488921881,
-0.6799544096,
-0.7229882479,
-0.0091750249,
-0.223315686,
0.1346020997,
-0.6241356134,
0.8556248546,
-0.8818772435,
0.3150698245,
-0.360784471,
-0.2986822426,
0.0694967955,
0.3503634334,
-0.5090249777,
0.8908573389,
-0.0683601946,
-0.8300053477,
0.1641496122,
-0.3532395661,
-0.2290876061,
-0.0133803375,
-0.3247174323,
-0.3969929516,
0.2743743658,
0.5543471575,
0.3118020594,
-0.5586975813,
0.3340781629,
-0.1796238869,
-0.3550980985,
0.3562870622,
-0.6172694564,
0.6682776809,
-0.0339900181,
-0.1992183924,
0.1687295139,
-0.7961265445,
0.1729022413,
0.1018823758,
-0.4457189143,
-0.376781553,
-0.0026393635,
-0.3049272597,
0.1258307248,
0.122589387,
-0.4066583216,
0.2035191953,
-0.3576359749,
-0.0101461355,
0.8605932593,
0.3784424663,
0.392591387,
-0.2959019244,
0.7201905251,
-0.1240009442,
-0.0608233549,
-0.299149543,
-0.5143432617,
-0.3637050986,
-0.328225702,
0.3597134948,
0.5308648348,
-1.0006552935,
0.3074487448,
-0.0170973036,
-0.1995046288,
-0.201925993,
0.011905456,
0.365272671,
0.9920921922,
0.4802684784,
-0.1009231582,
-0.3086984158,
-0.705632627,
-0.5421609879,
-0.0887545645,
-0.2199833542,
0.3736007214,
0.2146820277,
-0.3318323195,
0.8571113348,
-0.4031535983,
0.0596456602,
-0.0284518935,
0.0799462423,
0.6388865709,
0.392263025,
0.4906912744,
-0.6521584392,
-0.537774384,
-0.3009199202,
-0.2647362053,
-0.4729605615,
-0.3026022315,
-0.033293236,
0.2757091224,
0.4992932975,
-0.8041673303,
0.4481053352,
0.4766214788,
-0.245821774,
1.0150032043,
-0.1879743636,
0.1121651828,
-0.920455277,
0.2425920665,
0.0198665299,
-0.104524605,
-0.6529277563,
0.0841553286,
0.0572605729,
0.0162978899,
-0.2754321396,
0.831474781,
-0.5529817939,
-0.0133547885,
-0.3447410464,
0.1291176677,
0.0065775686,
0.3644968867,
-0.332565248,
1.0814381838,
0.4840798676,
-0.7538832426,
0.1990572214,
0.3442775607,
-0.0624340624,
0.324834764,
-0.675593555,
0.3496395051,
-0.3369688094,
0.2216634303,
-1.1167681217,
-0.2165193856,
0.4054327011,
-0.7373782396,
0.6543539166,
-0.2836198509,
-0.3107462227,
-0.1104485467,
-0.4311810434,
0.4147443771,
0.6135109663,
-0.7779334784,
0.745681107,
-0.0674676001,
-0.2639519572,
-0.8864641786,
-0.4395223558,
0.0587861203,
-0.2630728185,
-0.5940619111,
0.2167562991,
-0.1135047674,
-0.2134880871,
-0.1957945377,
-0.2068963796,
0.3334223628,
0.1505880505,
0.0957504436,
0.3465269208,
-0.1199965477,
0.1061051488,
0.0864441842,
-0.0876086056,
0.2069762349,
0.0316780657,
0.8051387072,
0.1714815348,
-0.4261826575,
-0.1554471254,
0.2209317088,
0.329559058,
-0.3384426534,
0.6701872349,
0.5151011944,
-0.0554598495,
-0.4448290467,
-0.4944868982,
-0.3533602953,
-0.5970030427,
0.3400840461,
-0.3922210336,
-0.8802130222,
0.6951773167,
-0.1592582017,
-0.1397748441,
0.3750350177,
0.5388553739,
0.0927092656,
1.0362212658,
0.2115424871,
0.1154981107,
0.5090610981,
0.0683105737,
0.0067038713,
-1.1623617411,
-0.0265214406,
-0.8262017965,
-0.1004894674,
-0.6097192168,
-0.5450856686,
0.4544387162,
0.3348359466,
-0.2524221838,
-0.3310157359,
-0.41480726,
0.4068257511,
0.4307308197,
0.0142828478,
0.1118931249,
0.3864762187,
-0.3743878007,
-0.0882773399,
-0.723665297,
-0.568775773,
0.9945524335,
0.2284785062,
0.8573764563,
0.0400366783,
0.6026419401,
0.1479506344,
0.2395712286,
-0.6549757719,
0.7460557222,
-0.0686712861,
-0.3123924136,
-0.2061073631,
-0.552061677,
-1.0111123323,
0.2422939837,
-0.4210889935,
-0.7605995536,
0.0927077085,
0.1701681167,
-0.3757184148,
0.2019159645,
-0.4887294471,
0.3455238342,
-0.1613894105,
-0.5544773936,
0.0085537918,
-0.4423960447,
0.1838777065,
-0.1234653816,
0.0255880281,
0.1232616529,
-0.260638386,
0.3551149964,
-0.1050262898,
0.5936322212,
-0.3142370582,
-0.2325314283,
0.4194583595,
0.2353236824,
0.9577090144,
0.2380152643,
-0.1700478941,
-0.025005769,
-0.630920589,
-0.2679168582,
-0.726350069,
0.8549929857,
-0.470461458,
-1.1457725763,
-0.3360773623,
-0.4930460751,
-0.5578026175,
0.1090357229,
0.4585800767,
0.6058431268,
0.1316672415,
0.0258972887,
0.8294227123,
-0.7132436037,
0.5497533679,
0.3844548464,
-0.470885843,
-0.5565121174,
0.6058799028,
0.0590389259,
0.4237737954,
0.1179761738,
0.2905240655,
-0.3404199183,
-0.7500590682,
-0.5264706612,
0.4099954665,
-0.6824489236,
-0.1721498519,
-0.4014516175,
-0.0538424924,
-0.2658712864,
0.0447182544,
0.1110674515,
-0.2171679735,
-0.6016961932,
0.1083650663,
0.1765203625,
0.4959164262,
-0.1246374995,
0.2259716541,
-0.9171557426,
0.3458305597,
0.1881524771,
0.354480356,
0.1116253734,
-0.7624465227,
0.042928569,
0.102293998,
-0.1057481468,
-0.9889159203,
0.2326522171,
-0.0191331245,
0.6305536628,
0.2102411538,
0.0319007635,
0.5633393526,
-0.7047025561,
0.903321743,
0.1867399812,
-0.8290729523,
0.3699346185,
-0.5866522789,
0.4663528204,
0.2324132472,
0.3201153576,
-0.3553906381,
-0.2414397299,
-0.5145022869,
-0.9357050061,
0.5564901829,
-0.0833086297,
0.3200888932,
-0.1318851262,
0.6676225066,
-0.0227826685,
0.1325345933,
-0.3247576952,
-0.3529884219,
0.2112488151,
0.2611667216,
-0.1186468452,
-0.7211903334,
-0.0583015978,
0.1361435354,
0.7690194845,
-0.1800274551,
0.1752358675,
0.3564388156,
0.1726174206,
-0.2601896822,
0.3240599632,
0.7654798031,
0.4441918135,
0.0146010425,
-0.1474682242,
0.2576890588,
-0.5772672892,
0.238568753,
0.0604292862,
-0.5177771449,
0.2166662216,
0.2340283841,
0.8824091554,
-0.4033069313,
-0.4856809676,
0.3637982905,
-0.1325674057,
0.0826802105,
0.0221822523,
0.1587056816,
-0.1286242753,
0.156758979,
0.7063809037,
0.2443268299,
0.0372004434,
-0.1464773566,
0.1033546478,
0.7256332636,
-0.0076326299,
-0.2082874477,
0.68637532,
0.0231377129,
-0.4704169631,
0.4559008181,
-0.2730089128,
-0.5507863164,
0.4659214616,
0.6268881559,
0.9084045887,
-0.3498552144,
0.1117100194,
0.5351384878,
0.265979588,
-0.0107969251,
0.1956500709,
0.1928634644,
-0.6432819963,
-0.9619432688,
-0.6663003564,
-0.3357109427,
0.3107680976,
-0.5709147453,
0.2158144265,
-0.514844656,
-0.4025297761,
-0.3368965089,
-0.117013365,
-0.385728538,
0.2396953702,
0.1646055877,
0.9107207656,
-0.5197769403,
0.5207546353,
0.7713363171,
-0.198131457,
-1.0629729033,
0.4735930562,
-0.2763420045,
-0.5445407033,
0.7153587937,
0.0144153479,
-0.3081089258,
0.0445271954,
-0.7633645535,
-0.9845898151,
0.6426875591,
0.6097164154,
-0.5309947729,
0.0125414617,
-0.0041729151,
0.5910952091,
-0.0588827357,
0.2174556404,
0.2346069515,
0.4819151163,
0.3063842356,
-0.8431920409,
0.2831576765,
-0.0486598238,
0.1742692888,
0.2491229177,
-0.4129219055,
0.9271680713,
-0.2890174389,
-0.4265602231,
0.2504206896,
0.5514763594,
0.6247787476,
0.0315894745,
0.4193992317,
0.5000830293,
0.7424983382,
-0.0478120781,
1.2956579924,
-0.11762169,
0.2236920744,
1.2240018845,
-0.2452901155,
0.6629687548,
0.8151521087,
0.0552374013,
0.419934094,
0.3653735518,
0.1142587066,
0.3952840865,
0.4102417231,
-0.2815439403,
-0.1141020209,
-0.0778785348,
-0.4023765028,
0.0910824537,
0.3967775404,
-0.2754110396,
-0.2867831588,
-0.03833507,
0.1635165066,
0.2135891318,
-0.5174533129,
0.5592932701,
-0.0745666772,
-0.9348454475,
1.0127011538,
0.01851248,
0.7533343434,
-0.6381664872,
-0.0170584302,
-0.3516265154,
-0.0515853874,
-0.2688904703,
-0.572969079,
-0.0065181577,
0.1391604245,
-0.2320791632,
-0.1106781811,
1.0129193068,
-0.2682031393,
-0.1448078901,
0.2866581082,
0.5350874662,
-0.1488850117,
-0.0454663672,
-0.4579725862,
0.1328394264,
0.1101922616,
-0.7171076536,
0.4629502594,
0.449091047,
-0.0158653613,
0.5567723513,
0.8318833709,
0.2847704589,
0.1089920551,
-0.0331907086,
1.1182975769,
-0.3673490286,
-0.2826882005,
-0.94363904,
0.4955863953,
-0.0082901251,
-0.2535177767,
0.9096154571,
0.2017638832,
0.5094045401,
-0.1176737174,
0.6248726249,
0.0172424894,
0.5892510414,
-0.6630271673,
0.4926536679,
-0.5538654923,
0.5627661347,
-0.2754436731,
-1.1612727642,
-0.4350968897,
0.2915281653,
-0.4906238616,
0.17138125,
0.5137276649,
1.061375618,
0.297111541,
-0.2490614355,
0.3117779791,
0.3149295747,
0.4518951774,
0.2319627255,
0.9830316305,
-0.1448822469,
0.3775639534,
0.1676813215,
-0.0605534539,
-0.0464450121,
-1.1229931116,
-0.871866405,
-0.3242937028,
-0.0573854111,
-0.7697518468,
0.1195000634,
0.9066417217,
0.1538559645,
-0.6781449914,
0.0567993149,
-0.0457169265,
0.0952984318,
0.1730872393,
-0.2038425058,
0.3862163424,
-0.7172518373,
-0.6539933681,
0.5884951949,
0.0559591688,
0.0647479221,
-0.2834707797,
-0.1208022237,
-0.306689322,
0.197299093,
0.3742364645,
0.2140713036,
-0.5001004338,
-0.3500252962,
0.1157503128,
-0.2446141392,
0.0470999442,
0.5381816626,
-0.9820023179,
0.2963944376,
0.6712437272,
0.887336731,
0.235869199,
0.3149054646,
0.4779808819,
-1.0331505537,
0.1642476469,
0.4276006222,
0.3118004203,
0.3975663483,
-0.4973289967,
0.3113312721,
0.1164068878,
-0.754771471,
-0.9915383458,
0.3961503208,
-0.5757026076,
-0.2877033055,
1.617837429,
0.0127001051,
-0.3248878121,
0.3564873338,
-0.4499948621,
0.0407165587,
-0.5267478824,
0.6171554923,
0.6790670156,
-0.041543033,
0.0856017619,
-0.3591943383,
0.6670159698,
0.6774526834,
-0.5170877576,
-0.0941948444,
0.7939207554,
0.1269342154,
0.3653492033,
0.3931718171,
-0.0016982952,
0.3677740097,
-0.1448992193,
-0.0821559057,
-0.1516808718,
-0.2409789711,
-0.7167995572,
0.4190398455,
0.2648517787,
-0.0608308464
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07157v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07157v2
|
Natural Language Reinforcement Learning
| 2024-02-11T11:03:04 | 2024-02-14T19:59:05 |
Xidong Feng, Ziyu Wan, Mengyue Yang, Ziyan Wang, Girish A. Koushik, Yali Du, Ying Wen, Jun Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Reinforcement Learning (RL) has shown remarkable abilities in learning
policies for decision-making tasks. However, RL is often hindered by issues
such as low sample efficiency, lack of interpretability, and sparse supervision
signals. To tackle these limitations, we take inspiration from the human
learning process and introduce Natural Language Reinforcement Learning (NLRL),
which innovatively combines RL principles with natural language representation.
Specifically, NLRL redefines RL concepts like task objectives, policy, value
function, Bellman equation, and policy iteration in natural language space. We
present how NLRL can be practically implemented with the latest advancements in
large language models (LLMs) like GPT-4. Initial experiments over tabular MDPs
demonstrate the effectiveness, efficiency, and also interpretability of the
NLRL framework.
|
[
-0.3233734667,
-0.8962575793,
0.5755451322,
0.3261301517,
-0.0413902514,
0.44175753,
-0.4692622423,
-0.3341897726,
-0.0477369204,
0.5870707035,
-0.6874377728,
-0.3427554965,
-0.3379386961,
0.1744146198,
0.0600460954,
1.4169206619,
-0.0482976362,
-0.1163289323,
0.2415616661,
0.1038980484,
-0.4664590657,
-0.3482644856,
-1.0523045063,
-0.8022124171,
0.7611933351,
0.3205263615,
0.7021465302,
0.4275570512,
0.2997097671,
0.2827971578,
-0.0002505653,
0.4124535918,
-0.4631550014,
-0.0195606034,
-0.2866201401,
-0.3487609923,
-0.00592747,
0.0188424699,
0.5758724213,
0.3791776896,
-0.6436176896,
-0.4497866929,
0.1527710259,
0.748799026,
-0.1936663389,
0.4786481559,
-0.5388492346,
0.3487130702,
0.1895562857,
-0.2526838481,
-0.3762889504,
-0.6466780305,
0.3463261724,
-0.700538516,
-0.0434492007,
0.1803516746,
0.7714734077,
0.3347793818,
-0.3508387804,
-0.6003742218,
-0.8938275576,
0.9320670366,
-0.7315467596,
0.4687179923,
0.419436723,
0.7227969766,
-0.3926379085,
-0.612966001,
-0.5717189312,
-0.6295645833,
-0.0759176835,
-0.192786321,
-0.0522096977,
0.2610504031,
0.1857575327,
0.1060398221,
-0.5413845778,
0.2284217775,
-0.2455262989,
-0.0855103806,
0.4888964593,
0.1962967366,
0.1069593206,
-0.1740310043,
-0.5025901198,
-0.1015180945,
-0.5467990637,
0.2010874152,
0.1250254959,
0.5192136765,
-0.0188563485,
0.314507246,
-0.1993264109,
0.6260639429,
-0.0374397486,
-0.1421561539,
0.0505499542,
-0.1132131219,
-0.3741848767,
-0.0271580182,
0.7304340005,
-0.0788381398,
0.2260096818,
-0.3694861531,
-0.3373333514,
-0.0136421304,
0.5167081952,
-0.3475758731,
-0.0558122396,
-0.0299324039,
-0.0958591923,
-0.4156703353,
-0.1312398762,
-0.7595277429,
-0.4642370343,
-0.6290372014,
0.4493695796,
-0.4827819765,
-0.144279182,
0.1956498027,
0.0303978305,
0.3362841606,
0.3521896899,
-1.1012722254,
0.578851819,
0.7218010426,
0.4859289825,
-0.2409707755,
-0.216168955,
-0.5943315625,
0.0801271051,
-0.3938456774,
0.6466100216,
-0.3572992384,
-0.2604887784,
0.0207939595,
-0.2783346772,
0.0542626902,
-0.5478650331,
0.5946542025,
-0.6273931861,
0.2841006815,
0.0184607152,
-0.4613251686,
-0.2964043915,
0.5685771108,
-0.7954828739,
0.8078810573,
0.0364744291,
-0.45232445,
0.488840431,
-1.1832237244,
-0.5369066596,
0.0306714959,
-0.1775647849,
-0.4910943508,
-0.1321010739,
0.2553933561,
0.3481965363,
-0.1141389608,
0.3323253095,
0.0296041854,
-0.1640010774,
0.4433271587,
-0.6266347766,
0.4063049853,
0.2548576891,
-0.2484418154,
0.3789899051,
-0.5680332184,
0.1053951904,
0.1831710786,
-0.6995590925,
-0.0773802698,
0.0994248241,
0.01504838,
0.1761028767,
0.0509089902,
-0.2162410766,
0.2587565184,
-0.6277487874,
0.6047288179,
0.6508948207,
0.2471072674,
0.6570590138,
-0.2277002186,
0.6058840752,
-0.3946494162,
0.0864045098,
0.3152517974,
-0.2146957815,
-0.4595835209,
-0.0876104087,
0.1830487251,
0.4907458127,
-1.0746171474,
0.1708741784,
-0.0382053815,
-0.0261217784,
-0.3925293982,
0.2374205142,
0.4704054892,
0.3534348309,
0.5772664547,
0.0217420999,
-0.7310899496,
-0.720699966,
-0.3489386737,
-0.0180967636,
0.0863284394,
0.0414069071,
0.406591624,
-0.2215465307,
1.0752975941,
-0.3164276481,
-0.4595435262,
-1.0245159864,
0.4481619895,
0.3616695702,
0.1654363126,
-0.0497107916,
-0.8210456371,
-0.519257009,
0.1036948562,
-0.5766699314,
0.1411327422,
-0.2625651062,
0.1733289808,
0.5206791759,
0.4720655084,
-0.5078167915,
0.3432376087,
0.3706085682,
-0.2712015212,
0.5814967155,
-0.5983996391,
-0.1654269248,
-0.4556604624,
-0.3762376308,
0.1054252163,
-0.536277771,
-0.7527936697,
0.0435845889,
-0.0421861038,
-0.0058586905,
-0.3437913656,
0.5616360903,
-0.148996219,
-0.1365609318,
-0.3908213079,
0.1159290224,
0.017594438,
0.8110202551,
0.2525096238,
0.7273131013,
-0.0548885353,
-0.7518949509,
0.2539353073,
0.1633951217,
-0.2893258631,
0.4241794348,
-0.4885185659,
-0.2010275722,
-0.1374922544,
0.4372921288,
-0.4105956256,
0.0362034589,
0.3233152926,
-0.1318383366,
0.2755251825,
0.1367729902,
-0.2822602391,
-0.4260892868,
-0.1529008597,
-0.2613810897,
0.5823935866,
-0.5822302699,
0.5823156834,
0.3635412455,
0.0302208364,
-0.6618140936,
-0.4889216721,
0.1934399754,
-0.3605656922,
0.1569234133,
0.2864286304,
0.0910448283,
-0.1536577493,
0.105223991,
0.0966135561,
-0.1939650774,
0.0365976989,
-0.0432694033,
0.0667766482,
0.1383373886,
0.2447879761,
-0.2755779624,
-0.2223371565,
0.0238530487,
-0.363375932,
0.5062384605,
-0.2984296083,
-0.1207180694,
-0.4181616008,
-0.0277696867,
0.1216086075,
-0.1934441775,
0.4848451912,
0.5087878704,
-0.0729773343,
-0.6230632067,
-0.2956321836,
-0.1451693326,
-0.469022423,
0.4696303308,
-0.144559294,
-0.9194675088,
-0.068820715,
-0.0106682191,
0.4440938234,
-0.0423206203,
0.378691107,
-0.3064014614,
0.8774932623,
0.6386942863,
-0.1518674791,
0.5113034248,
-0.1878026426,
0.2227259278,
-0.6513792872,
-0.1664930433,
-0.2304900736,
-0.2087159604,
-0.5271353126,
-0.6613289118,
0.1259534657,
0.0255236402,
-0.3860873878,
0.370990634,
-0.1947385222,
0.5311298966,
0.5896980762,
0.0822651312,
0.4284262657,
-0.1410786957,
-0.4361952245,
-0.19741036,
-0.7926316261,
-0.492885232,
0.8620736599,
0.5527388453,
0.8119017482,
0.0524512641,
0.8806077242,
0.5464739799,
0.4012897313,
-0.6626146436,
0.4869075119,
0.0504245572,
-0.3269951642,
-0.6022135019,
-0.5251605511,
-0.9842076898,
0.3892041445,
-0.4190214276,
-0.6018807888,
-0.3173676133,
0.3022889495,
-0.1881239265,
0.2686683536,
-0.497543335,
0.7616639733,
-0.497254312,
-0.411169827,
-0.459403187,
-0.4714606702,
0.3096405864,
0.1423514634,
0.5296090245,
-0.0471681915,
0.0678178146,
0.4639041722,
-0.1347306818,
0.8113076687,
-0.3518807888,
-0.1760255694,
0.1611167192,
-0.0556065515,
0.7445300817,
0.0745661259,
0.0528269932,
-0.3393648267,
-0.3743601143,
-0.1175206229,
-0.8624029756,
0.4018341005,
-0.4341325164,
-0.3642311394,
-0.3779972792,
-0.6328607202,
-0.5210937262,
-0.024748601,
-0.3074601293,
0.2501962185,
-0.5468590856,
-0.0478193127,
0.6624900103,
-0.5821041465,
0.4749501348,
0.5707339644,
-0.7377721071,
-0.3987599909,
1.0008971691,
-0.1885621399,
0.3769260049,
0.6199630499,
0.3069788516,
-0.801512301,
-0.5145183802,
-0.2608782649,
0.0989249498,
-0.5938353539,
0.0655997023,
-0.3989930153,
-0.1938037574,
0.0314083323,
-0.1663051695,
-0.194066748,
-0.2454133034,
-0.0214727074,
-0.3335240185,
0.2516584992,
0.9225311279,
-0.226118058,
0.2615739405,
-0.3810319304,
0.6247071028,
0.6366685033,
0.3993443251,
-0.0277234465,
-0.2770944834,
-0.176921919,
-0.0268401373,
-0.304821074,
-0.5711574554,
0.6416631341,
0.1142901033,
0.6694226265,
0.2668115199,
-0.1244346723,
0.5322934985,
-0.7659319639,
0.3717612624,
0.1816445291,
-0.6133849025,
0.2965714335,
-0.2486317754,
0.334508121,
0.4947242737,
0.1990799457,
-0.6580629945,
-0.5030511618,
-0.5592252612,
-0.5855484605,
0.3969967663,
0.0500320867,
0.0048209471,
0.0143354945,
-0.0965566039,
-0.0030195992,
0.3664938509,
-0.948215723,
0.1120226905,
-0.1939711869,
-0.2231057137,
-0.209992215,
-0.0899512842,
0.111118719,
-0.1907770932,
0.6525030136,
-0.2399335057,
0.2791686058,
0.0994763076,
-0.3323865235,
0.1315395534,
0.8316426873,
0.6126359701,
0.4873125553,
-0.218187958,
0.0567863286,
0.3580157161,
0.1245483756,
0.1550698876,
-0.1237539202,
-0.0468027331,
-0.2146755904,
0.2080657929,
0.9807195067,
0.8350698948,
-0.8881873488,
0.1194290072,
-0.1473620087,
-0.3647454083,
-0.3784866333,
0.1150688082,
0.259891957,
0.3717312217,
0.3968227208,
-0.1597512662,
-0.0197592508,
-0.6547817588,
0.6010181308,
0.5940799713,
-0.8024308085,
0.0336081199,
0.3904594779,
0.1478162259,
-0.4627445042,
0.4576604366,
-0.619671464,
-0.7975607514,
0.3562675416,
0.670765698,
0.5882011652,
0.1557867378,
0.7172259688,
0.1204965562,
0.4422692358,
-0.1354842633,
0.2847397327,
-0.014695745,
-0.7043936253,
-0.7785191536,
-0.7263168097,
-0.6162762642,
0.0816278756,
-0.4831905067,
-0.0518795811,
-0.8020381927,
0.1052524373,
-0.3103757501,
0.1644516736,
-0.64282763,
-0.039017465,
0.0859932229,
0.8586806059,
-0.5711320639,
1.0281245708,
0.4642246962,
-0.4311659038,
-0.976529479,
-0.0952022746,
0.001329388,
-0.7720851898,
1.0004210472,
0.0257794261,
-0.0286108069,
0.1973273307,
-0.3993925154,
-0.277007252,
0.8246108294,
-0.0310285203,
-0.4837574661,
-0.175455451,
0.2352781445,
0.6773110628,
-0.3006089032,
0.0171649959,
0.7035499811,
0.6841427088,
-0.0366528966,
-0.8121615052,
-0.2449629009,
0.3161881268,
-0.0024984512,
0.4081997275,
-0.0047212923,
0.5309086442,
-0.2609484494,
-0.1640512198,
-0.2222440839,
0.8141154647,
0.4131753445,
0.0845831558,
0.5378708839,
0.5630981326,
0.7770841718,
-0.106582582,
1.1220122576,
0.3232005835,
0.2682386935,
1.0661394596,
-0.4010994434,
0.8717619777,
0.5360404253,
-0.316270411,
0.7178790569,
0.124653019,
0.0824358016,
0.7457872629,
0.3802270293,
-0.2026136965,
-0.1132607087,
-0.161505729,
0.2109578252,
0.3108890653,
0.499043107,
0.0177308545,
-0.5954134464,
0.2122559547,
-0.0569403544,
0.5904269814,
-0.3984380364,
0.9703783989,
0.0692187175,
-0.4141959548,
0.450245589,
-0.0072356379,
0.9146429896,
-0.7913387418,
-0.4865176976,
0.1848704815,
0.1740761995,
0.1050672531,
-0.8089215159,
0.3437649608,
-0.0789639428,
0.0572437383,
-0.6850720644,
0.5757290721,
-0.5367407203,
-0.2632524669,
0.3828419447,
0.2474742383,
-0.127639845,
0.2498284131,
-1.0522538424,
-0.1748295277,
0.067736797,
-0.171482116,
0.3973479271,
0.3296746612,
-0.0067237862,
1.0410852432,
0.6917614937,
0.3235684931,
-0.0047893305,
-0.1334104538,
0.432552278,
-0.8363330364,
-0.7403754592,
-0.6769612432,
0.4323969185,
-0.1750248671,
0.01649433,
0.4242988229,
0.2102420628,
0.6165952682,
0.003408697,
0.8905435205,
-0.0375511721,
0.8867937922,
-0.895772934,
0.3896698058,
-0.2056621164,
0.4282390773,
-0.0057823658,
-0.66860497,
-0.3756906092,
0.9804217219,
-0.4171594083,
-0.1127371863,
0.7308543324,
0.5628906488,
0.1387575716,
-0.0297999438,
0.3852390051,
-0.0488140434,
0.5472512841,
0.7040400505,
1.0112060308,
0.1154448241,
0.5877795219,
-0.1359850764,
0.0947867036,
-0.1805861145,
-0.9892838597,
-0.8409844041,
-0.3572844863,
0.0456253625,
-0.1032561585,
0.3789826334,
1.3903807402,
0.4525430202,
-0.6305598617,
-0.3865937293,
-0.535377264,
0.6092642546,
-0.4339607358,
-0.320358336,
0.0825577751,
-0.680038929,
-0.5174911618,
0.7513782382,
0.2996982932,
-0.1482191384,
-0.4292797446,
-0.6957492828,
-0.3869565129,
-0.1467738599,
0.5855396986,
0.7528043389,
-0.8261260986,
-0.2110218555,
-0.5029474497,
-0.3600933254,
0.1395271719,
0.8423724174,
-1.0064094067,
0.0799123794,
0.2133639604,
0.9655321836,
0.3865132034,
-0.1584230363,
0.7619987726,
-0.7376124859,
-0.0911404416,
0.4572621882,
0.0028195002,
0.2320889235,
0.1986399442,
0.4585615396,
-0.2743529975,
-0.4844547808,
-0.6340150833,
0.5245658755,
-0.6674251556,
-0.3810186386,
1.0427742004,
0.1589846462,
-0.0293715876,
-0.5228159428,
-0.3018223047,
0.0528228693,
-0.652078867,
0.645131588,
0.2365170717,
-0.257697165,
-0.4756153226,
-1.0692449808,
0.869400382,
0.2073830813,
-0.9931263924,
0.1101628914,
0.3041498065,
0.0918216109,
-0.1166198477,
0.6683009267,
0.144531697,
0.0409854762,
-0.5760149956,
0.1282278895,
-0.0928701311,
-0.2350106388,
-0.4729585648,
0.0694909245,
0.4621324837,
0.1667730063
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07148v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07148v2
|
X-LoRA: Mixture of Low-Rank Adapter Experts, a Flexible Framework for Large Language Models with Applications in Protein Mechanics and Molecular Design
| 2024-02-11T10:23:34 | 2024-03-30T20:18:54 |
Eric L. Buehler, Markus J. Buehler
|
cond-mat.soft
|
cond-mat.soft, cond-mat.dis-nn, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, q-bio.QM
|
We report a mixture of expert strategy to create fine-tuned large language
models using a deep layer-wise token-level approach based on low-rank
adaptation (LoRA). Starting with a set of pre-trained LoRA adapters, our gating
strategy uses the hidden states to dynamically mix adapted layers, allowing the
resulting X-LoRA model to draw upon different capabilities and create
never-before-used deep layer-wise combinations to solve tasks. The design is
inspired by the biological principles of universality and diversity, where
neural network building blocks are reused in different hierarchical
manifestations. Hence, the X-LoRA model can be easily implemented for any
existing large language model (LLM) without a need for modifications of the
underlying structure. We develop a tailored X-LoRA model that offers scientific
capabilities including forward/inverse analysis tasks and enhanced reasoning
capability, focused on biomaterial analysis, protein mechanics and design. The
impact of this work include access to readily expandable and adaptable models
with strong domain knowledge and the capability to integrate across areas of
knowledge. Featuring experts in biology, mathematics, reasoning, bio-inspired
materials, mechanics and materials, chemistry, protein biophysics, mechanics
and quantum-mechanics based molecular properties, we conduct a series of
physics-focused case studies. We examine knowledge recall, protein mechanics
forward/inverse tasks, protein design, adversarial agentic modeling including
ontological knowledge graph construction, as well as molecular design. The
model is capable not only of making quantitative predictions of nanomechanical
properties of proteins or quantum mechanical molecular properties, but also
reasons over the results and correctly predicts likely mechanisms that explain
distinct molecular behaviors.
|
[
-0.1761555374,
-0.8130722642,
0.5094216466,
-0.2722296119,
0.0680632442,
0.4001661837,
0.0657302439,
-0.6140009761,
0.6517701149,
0.4304049015,
-0.3930100203,
-0.2264227569,
-0.6451762319,
-0.1203104928,
-0.449681133,
0.8825808167,
0.2031946778,
-0.1576139033,
0.2245165855,
-0.2005272061,
-0.0926121771,
-0.2297651917,
-0.4729495049,
-0.5536774397,
0.7470610738,
0.2314730883,
0.7965345979,
0.5782681108,
0.2935003638,
0.3404356539,
-0.4035581052,
0.0101160975,
-0.5312559605,
-0.1788221002,
-0.7108272314,
-0.7471277118,
-1.0212543011,
-0.0441268571,
0.4074430764,
0.9936663508,
-0.0914802551,
-0.0124457544,
0.0066760555,
0.692491591,
-0.5237359405,
-0.0311522037,
-0.7739208341,
0.2032642812,
-0.0547779426,
-0.2309901863,
-0.072155267,
0.1537351906,
0.1343628168,
-0.6820164919,
-0.0639490783,
-0.0230428278,
0.3773004115,
0.1758892983,
-0.2965310812,
-0.0917235613,
-0.6815118194,
0.6225555539,
-0.7559015751,
0.4377239347,
0.1216286123,
0.36377877,
-0.5003625154,
-0.5187453032,
-0.548630178,
-0.2560875714,
0.2677078545,
0.1715461761,
-0.147951141,
0.0211274642,
-0.0917108357,
0.3578234613,
-0.4502070546,
0.334687233,
-0.2955242395,
0.3240047097,
0.4760204554,
-0.0721028149,
0.3001489937,
-0.0142076919,
-0.1167850941,
-0.144892469,
-0.6143181324,
0.0945901275,
0.3750992119,
0.5140120387,
-0.1199846044,
0.6539599299,
-0.4153319597,
0.5412585139,
0.168114841,
-0.2612866759,
0.071699366,
-0.230202958,
-0.2644838989,
0.0911740139,
0.6574623585,
-0.2565537095,
-0.1942727119,
-0.2770088613,
-0.1327593029,
-0.213805303,
0.2078780532,
-0.57654351,
-0.2977864742,
0.3230150938,
-0.4719150364,
-0.6132600307,
-0.0516918786,
-0.7912250161,
-0.8336625099,
-0.1580976248,
0.8206086159,
-0.2942537665,
-0.2839357257,
0.4684247077,
-0.1678892225,
-0.0320318788,
0.1857286245,
-0.9840742946,
0.4467182457,
0.5926831365,
0.5659740567,
-0.1838043034,
-0.3665250242,
-0.5157238245,
0.4485702217,
0.0538358316,
0.7730590105,
-0.6480630636,
-0.2946193814,
-0.4658456445,
-0.1200534105,
0.0015493404,
-0.2926256061,
0.4055221677,
-0.5912129879,
0.0076584853,
-0.186192587,
-0.2975250781,
-0.4130957425,
-0.0319194868,
-0.7639009953,
0.5073878765,
0.3811038435,
-0.6168900132,
0.3109576106,
-1.1158173084,
-0.4186701477,
0.0627717376,
-0.4421221316,
-0.2025159299,
0.3709385097,
0.0392076299,
0.0063593118,
-0.4069913328,
-0.1029850543,
-0.5542941093,
-0.1364680082,
0.5892681479,
-0.0036803607,
0.6540786624,
0.0790185109,
-0.3847463727,
0.3610011637,
-1.2334326506,
0.1693095416,
0.0288495962,
-0.4513863325,
-0.212155357,
0.0358149745,
-0.1699436009,
0.4826901555,
0.1651077121,
-0.4017423093,
0.4295878708,
-0.4858212769,
0.8130626678,
0.7542595863,
-0.0890317336,
0.5634739399,
-0.1827834696,
0.5273063779,
0.0480779968,
-0.0749546289,
0.2622897923,
-0.5487667322,
-0.8892968893,
-0.1347355396,
0.2168892175,
0.5464445949,
-0.6868777275,
0.6392252445,
-0.1929737777,
-0.4808933139,
-0.4358249009,
0.4868718386,
0.2413322181,
0.4490778744,
0.3542266786,
-0.1686712503,
-0.4628565311,
-0.6935477853,
-0.2069086432,
-0.168684423,
0.1348951459,
-0.0031965964,
0.755114913,
-0.3131700158,
0.9288042784,
-0.5365617275,
-0.2136588395,
-0.2127737105,
-0.0643871948,
0.597317934,
0.4901566505,
0.4838275909,
-0.6078280807,
-0.109478794,
0.550213933,
-0.9676449299,
0.2852432132,
0.1368127912,
-0.2846609056,
-0.0288005285,
0.4223400354,
-0.5621282458,
0.2571915686,
0.5906327367,
-0.5732403994,
0.2928048074,
-0.4065982997,
-0.0503931865,
-1.111589551,
0.2954452336,
0.0123473918,
-0.0977792367,
-0.6864852309,
0.4784328043,
-0.3296510577,
-0.2688299716,
-0.4513325989,
0.7828265429,
-0.3919352889,
-0.0790828913,
-0.636913836,
0.0322850235,
0.1024103016,
0.5691636801,
-0.126021117,
0.579501152,
0.5251963735,
-0.4866525233,
0.1939220876,
0.3420432508,
-0.4356084168,
0.4749169946,
-0.9604312181,
0.2164036036,
0.1918566674,
-0.0278944075,
-0.6302098632,
-0.1870817393,
0.2687473297,
-0.3157422841,
0.0661182329,
-0.1990409046,
-0.3763235211,
-0.4121380448,
-0.1853501946,
0.3269222677,
0.6229724884,
-0.3290949166,
1.0159869194,
0.45576033,
-0.3881080151,
-0.4179481566,
-0.764567554,
0.0097041139,
-0.0866484493,
-0.7721752524,
0.4072405398,
-0.382242471,
-0.22140643,
-0.0487936363,
-0.1976988167,
-0.0883659571,
0.2948985696,
0.2040096819,
0.021097539,
-0.429284662,
-0.144699946,
0.3199135661,
-0.1101896986,
-0.0846982822,
-0.6083208919,
0.4632832408,
-0.1632079035,
-0.3929291964,
-0.1187328026,
0.4663978517,
0.6279369593,
-0.1582682282,
0.8797917366,
0.4389905632,
-0.1963645071,
-0.2375403047,
-0.1299037784,
-0.1956066787,
-0.5529156923,
0.6464147568,
-0.5939090848,
-0.6896902323,
0.8102681637,
0.223493591,
-0.1375911236,
0.1818069071,
0.5290760994,
-0.0980773494,
0.9267790914,
1.055804491,
-0.0618833937,
0.4768159688,
-0.3750929534,
0.3363155425,
-0.5627632141,
-0.0222017914,
-0.4262278676,
-0.6276314259,
-0.4206987917,
-0.4261496365,
0.5364842415,
0.2226532251,
-0.2357058525,
0.1958575249,
-0.375947088,
0.5025317669,
0.563336432,
0.3971084952,
0.4475869536,
0.2919600308,
-0.0420839675,
0.5478212237,
-0.891683042,
-0.2301347405,
0.8852584958,
0.304073602,
1.0184742212,
0.2378813475,
0.4483041763,
0.2095663995,
-0.2524376512,
-0.8897507191,
0.5445019007,
-0.3244785964,
-0.5031869411,
-0.259657979,
-0.3582418561,
-0.9625237584,
0.1688918173,
-0.4218147993,
-0.9328166246,
0.4769301116,
0.0440383069,
-0.6818292737,
0.6146703959,
-0.4528156221,
0.4575195014,
-0.2538084388,
-0.2920112312,
-0.2510987222,
-0.5308951139,
0.3480996192,
-0.4812856615,
0.2742426991,
0.2321745008,
-0.1012230143,
0.854773283,
-0.3074857891,
1.0687798262,
0.1145715639,
-0.6013463736,
0.2137502283,
0.1413420886,
0.4238741994,
0.0667554885,
-0.4174924195,
-0.1167106181,
-0.0569322519,
-0.5573859215,
-0.7050581574,
0.81528157,
-1.2061549425,
-0.7108597159,
-0.0353568271,
-0.7503868937,
-0.2816486061,
0.4364774525,
0.1257422566,
0.2570103109,
0.0183508564,
0.2608888447,
0.8074230552,
-0.1909006536,
0.2247815281,
0.745888114,
-0.3289375901,
-0.4847329557,
1.24365592,
0.2931430936,
0.2004822642,
0.5432911515,
0.325704366,
0.3200694919,
-0.6516936421,
-0.2310832739,
0.1343305856,
-0.8443870544,
0.0688265711,
-0.6380845904,
-0.3466719389,
-0.3979252875,
-0.3133544326,
-0.4810340703,
-0.683765173,
-0.1995859444,
-0.0369382128,
0.4496010542,
0.7720001936,
0.01787154,
0.2918186486,
-0.754000783,
0.5565226674,
0.4292730391,
0.3995824754,
-0.0136737423,
-0.6931799054,
-0.4521251321,
0.0973975286,
-0.2553952932,
-0.664948523,
0.1733553857,
0.2818758488,
0.7977802753,
0.2898473442,
-0.2323185951,
0.1380586028,
-0.2302860618,
0.4486537576,
0.1210061535,
-0.8206292391,
0.4939649105,
-0.5823103786,
0.2682797015,
0.3892268538,
0.2247926891,
-0.1256766915,
-0.0576527715,
-0.378436029,
-0.6851793528,
0.3775585592,
0.1393323392,
-0.0589287132,
0.3557606339,
0.4010595381,
0.5935462713,
0.1146013588,
-0.741371274,
-0.0284742638,
-0.1122581288,
-0.1565883905,
0.1106926873,
0.0888765305,
-0.3817382455,
-0.274766922,
0.7081821561,
-0.5362596512,
0.2674563527,
-0.1822634339,
-0.148424685,
-0.2275988162,
0.3196760118,
0.6803928018,
0.8580200076,
-0.2506863475,
-0.1674225479,
0.0041365568,
-0.4141050577,
0.2218684405,
0.3083628416,
-0.1981365681,
-0.5512145758,
0.2838951945,
0.7422689795,
0.1318390369,
-0.4461188614,
-0.0178302471,
0.2620366812,
-0.2978125215,
0.1492524296,
0.4613954425,
0.0491889194,
0.4407121837,
0.5031122565,
0.2758239508,
0.0101027489,
-0.7402650714,
-0.0064453641,
0.2763885856,
-0.35251531,
-0.7256003022,
0.6068041921,
0.3098915815,
-0.1192324534,
0.0795237646,
-0.0090530058,
-0.1924511045,
0.5456686616,
0.4971325099,
0.7123443484,
-0.119506143,
0.1947593838,
-0.1501211375,
0.0352575332,
0.1421049982,
0.4748125672,
0.2559702694,
-0.7950899601,
-0.32465747,
-0.5726675391,
-0.3257044554,
0.044318296,
-0.4244092703,
0.3574775159,
-0.4911107123,
-0.0912904143,
0.3275749683,
0.1047031954,
-0.4720166922,
0.0537065491,
0.0581201613,
1.1481571198,
-0.9258627295,
1.0391223431,
0.9004838467,
-0.6964549422,
-0.3659828305,
-0.3601584435,
-0.053120546,
-0.8822154403,
0.7343735099,
-0.3617063761,
-0.3479458392,
-0.0379342921,
-0.5447904468,
-1.1455330849,
1.1325099468,
0.4432519972,
-0.4197824001,
-0.4640385807,
0.1145309582,
0.5711054802,
-0.2984697223,
0.0989132002,
0.6525018215,
0.3898619711,
0.1032494903,
-0.7456155419,
0.0023069433,
-0.5513930321,
-0.3124194741,
0.0343823992,
-0.7898366451,
1.1196476221,
-0.2111119032,
0.2893920541,
0.5307113528,
0.9179366827,
0.5745324492,
-0.0206371378,
0.2545506358,
0.4829134941,
0.9128528237,
0.3726311326,
0.9977368116,
-0.3945403099,
0.0073820031,
1.000027895,
-0.4773375094,
0.7061935663,
0.5653284788,
-0.1615653187,
0.7092766166,
-0.0170868486,
0.0233694185,
0.4957787991,
0.2093294114,
-0.0989594311,
-0.1902702898,
0.0341443643,
-0.5975892544,
0.5160505176,
0.4869284034,
-0.303255707,
0.0257498305,
0.1999713331,
-0.2012492418,
-0.1000551805,
-0.3856344819,
0.5439910889,
0.2914800346,
-0.2408643216,
0.4784856141,
-0.0389303155,
0.6768683195,
-0.7055191398,
0.0959378034,
-0.286860615,
0.3515883982,
-0.2044864595,
-0.8884316683,
-0.1595316082,
-0.4075427055,
-0.5884337425,
0.3216325641,
0.7991479635,
-0.2617752552,
-0.7523038387,
0.3401219547,
0.7578152418,
-0.0548821017,
0.0558312275,
-0.7169425488,
0.0750935748,
-0.2431648821,
-0.2516775131,
0.6434662342,
0.4167736471,
-0.1234695539,
0.9389701486,
0.3888975382,
0.1513297558,
-0.161834687,
-0.0104272375,
1.2040385008,
-0.9517393112,
-0.6576402187,
-0.5048980117,
0.4084463716,
0.1602420807,
-0.1480306238,
0.4455900788,
0.2147067338,
0.4943093657,
-0.1686709374,
0.9236301184,
0.0212659817,
0.2844774425,
-0.6913281679,
0.9963142276,
-0.6614212394,
0.1611851156,
-0.4967738688,
-0.8328257799,
-0.1788534224,
0.4188567996,
-0.1034341455,
0.4036863446,
0.6282499433,
0.7360517979,
-0.3336516917,
-0.0166942012,
0.3933979273,
0.5519254804,
0.6455186009,
0.7462815642,
0.7207723856,
-0.4757467806,
0.4814257622,
-0.0756138861,
-0.2962905467,
-0.429471612,
-1.0332723856,
-0.946839869,
-0.3222790062,
-0.372561574,
-0.1589587033,
0.0577210747,
0.8908482194,
0.9442942142,
-0.7925638556,
-0.2521269023,
-0.1211391017,
-0.0679505244,
-0.2026022077,
-0.1510087252,
0.2807054222,
0.1048110276,
-0.3925358653,
0.9460516572,
0.3370765448,
0.1172235012,
-0.3531930447,
-0.0382378884,
-0.1178019121,
0.2293987125,
0.8603753448,
0.7245951891,
-0.6091450453,
-0.1251051277,
0.1323431134,
-0.0732134655,
0.0827401429,
0.6057180166,
-0.9264115691,
0.0958619192,
0.6736645103,
0.7258696556,
0.051901646,
-0.3483978808,
0.8033679128,
-0.4228017926,
0.1503004283,
-0.1047704741,
0.5115311742,
0.098256819,
-0.2743467987,
0.504021287,
0.0704062134,
-0.4458051622,
-0.7104744315,
0.2138613164,
-1.4470399618,
-0.5985942483,
0.9549945593,
0.1132475361,
-0.5493248105,
0.114536576,
-0.2710810602,
0.063837029,
-0.3273219466,
0.9497824311,
0.3355679512,
-0.1157556474,
-0.192570582,
-0.3842107058,
0.1022171453,
0.4708572328,
-1.0161569118,
-0.1643378437,
-0.114484109,
0.2841467857,
0.3319236636,
0.246066466,
0.0347004831,
0.2825282216,
-0.0882188827,
-0.0049781231,
-0.2300807685,
-0.4032739997,
-0.3339425027,
0.2148893625,
0.2350410074,
0.4069411755
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07092v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07092v3
|
Generalizing Conversational Dense Retrieval via LLM-Cognition Data Augmentation
| 2024-02-11T03:27:22 | 2024-06-04T02:09:15 |
Haonan Chen, Zhicheng Dou, Kelong Mao, Jiongnan Liu, Ziliang Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Conversational search utilizes muli-turn natural language contexts to
retrieve relevant passages. Existing conversational dense retrieval models
mostly view a conversation as a fixed sequence of questions and responses,
overlooking the severe data sparsity problem -- that is, users can perform a
conversation in various ways, and these alternate conversations are unrecorded.
Consequently, they often struggle to generalize to diverse conversations in
real-world scenarios. In this work, we propose a framework for generalizing
Conversational dense retrieval via LLM-cognition data Augmentation (ConvAug).
ConvAug first generates multi-level augmented conversations to capture the
diverse nature of conversational contexts. Inspired by human cognition, we
devise a cognition-aware process to mitigate the generation of false positives,
false negatives, and hallucinations. Moreover, we develop a difficulty-adaptive
sample filter that selects challenging samples for complex conversations,
thereby giving the model a larger learning space. A contrastive learning
objective is then employed to train a better conversational context encoder.
Extensive experiments conducted on four public datasets, under both normal and
zero-shot settings, demonstrate the effectiveness, generalizability, and
applicability of ConvAug. The code is released at
https://github.com/haon-chen/ConvAug.
|
[
-0.5046504736,
-1.4104862213,
0.3902735412,
0.1225363538,
-0.1551280022,
0.0339759588,
-0.4589539766,
-0.5571829677,
0.3652217984,
0.6070830226,
-0.4282135665,
-0.4985340536,
-0.2215459049,
-0.1031850651,
-0.4013150036,
0.6459590793,
0.4658323228,
-0.0127871381,
-0.3804056048,
-0.1961798966,
-0.9593505859,
-0.6601333022,
-0.6312863231,
-0.3435584903,
0.2629558146,
0.6315093637,
0.6162970066,
-0.1043624356,
0.2285551876,
0.2043006569,
-0.0506124124,
0.6218075752,
-1.010345459,
0.3953044415,
0.0178391449,
-0.2958483398,
-0.216614902,
-0.3724836111,
0.3251121342,
0.5917448997,
-0.5259382725,
-0.3280988932,
0.2220684737,
0.3894449174,
-0.6139643192,
-0.1319830418,
-1.0415915251,
-0.0256170239,
0.0773238763,
-0.3948475122,
-0.4324013293,
-0.259740591,
0.2550818622,
-0.7314944267,
0.371099472,
0.0807087198,
0.5622921586,
0.1432583779,
-0.4607813954,
-0.3123919964,
-0.851588726,
0.6963159442,
-0.4360983968,
0.4754661322,
0.4543590546,
0.4385651648,
-0.3718715608,
-0.547776401,
-0.5826038122,
-0.2982621789,
-0.2388914227,
0.2316378951,
-0.0998779982,
0.2563154697,
0.1904800087,
0.5610303879,
-0.6385619044,
0.0463241823,
-0.2134991139,
-0.1573519707,
0.5448418856,
0.3277697861,
0.0874763206,
0.0499498844,
-0.2468285114,
0.0452417694,
-0.4620785415,
-0.0193481818,
0.0181902647,
0.1812854409,
-0.0051849661,
0.4773906767,
-0.6756985188,
0.791523993,
0.2097271681,
0.2733861506,
0.3781372905,
-0.5228117704,
-0.2859227061,
0.0299263895,
0.5391456485,
0.3704336882,
0.2656376362,
-0.2858618498,
0.1021284908,
0.0116704907,
0.4364670217,
-0.8057342172,
-0.1281851381,
0.1707490534,
-0.0119204409,
-0.1862497032,
-0.1320371628,
-0.633998394,
-0.4503269494,
-0.3213221431,
0.2719163299,
-0.3662441969,
0.0145874266,
0.4751424193,
0.0502376631,
0.2528235018,
0.4001782835,
-0.8464208841,
0.6308184862,
0.5570867062,
0.5186113715,
-0.1396487802,
0.2644262612,
-0.7737340927,
0.1409948915,
-0.0471446067,
0.7231426239,
-0.9590755105,
-0.7156127095,
-0.0627032071,
-0.1291198134,
0.1325364113,
-0.6721476912,
0.7750728726,
-0.5115271211,
0.326525867,
-0.1679115593,
-0.5966048837,
-0.1845090985,
0.7248284817,
-0.3400680423,
0.9749623537,
-0.0908706784,
-0.5335538387,
0.1545974314,
-0.2741339207,
-0.4236655831,
0.2149336934,
-0.5183516145,
-0.3758921027,
0.0152672632,
0.4361483753,
0.4212593734,
-0.3506147861,
0.3964425027,
-0.4141227603,
-0.8186022639,
0.19371593,
-0.5800349116,
0.4639033973,
0.0720802769,
-0.0237495359,
-0.0161836073,
-0.6763923168,
-0.010720524,
-0.0919937044,
-0.3466387689,
-0.5828781128,
-0.0692408457,
-0.1491395384,
-0.0602305718,
0.1396830827,
-0.763061285,
0.230239287,
-0.4709835052,
0.1454778165,
0.2577424645,
0.4266480207,
0.5944007039,
-0.2925806046,
0.2545898855,
0.1072416231,
0.2966098487,
-0.0449613966,
-0.4082041383,
-0.9005176425,
-0.1412706375,
-0.1500513852,
0.7361921072,
-0.8245408535,
0.4645061493,
-0.3411706984,
-0.4181407094,
-0.4968978763,
0.272876054,
0.3342527747,
0.868468523,
0.6045037508,
-0.3327445686,
-0.5595914721,
-0.8496384025,
0.0694599152,
0.0692590103,
-0.1136092097,
0.9368869066,
0.0442204699,
-0.5594205856,
0.814753592,
-0.6327319741,
-0.3035064638,
0.0269379858,
-0.0126389349,
0.2592865825,
0.5677011013,
0.1056584492,
-1.0142736435,
-0.1679637283,
0.0407450981,
-0.7227165699,
0.0804053172,
-0.2806678116,
-0.3574867845,
-0.2512787879,
0.5198769569,
-0.6924856901,
0.3336698413,
0.2739082277,
-0.0069569219,
0.3839973807,
-0.2376866788,
0.2108660638,
-0.9978695512,
-0.1441833526,
-0.1018880233,
-0.244814381,
-0.7616955042,
-0.1952071339,
-0.1345649958,
-0.0416545942,
-0.375012368,
0.477942735,
-0.3373305202,
0.1252661049,
-0.0102636646,
0.1687475294,
0.2066633105,
0.622393012,
0.0776194856,
0.6812668443,
0.4190966487,
-0.9454852939,
0.4699382484,
0.3992339671,
-0.2801687419,
0.6752730012,
-0.7033737898,
0.3779005408,
-0.1622243375,
0.5279120207,
-0.8790210485,
0.0059898202,
0.1165489331,
-0.4219407141,
0.0516897924,
-0.1650657058,
-0.3410645723,
-0.067080766,
-0.1303585917,
0.4986000359,
0.2787124515,
-0.5027846694,
0.5484181643,
0.4162318408,
0.0246771537,
-0.6120954156,
-0.829253912,
0.1452368796,
-0.0839581117,
-0.593618691,
0.4791192412,
-0.4102016687,
-0.0608340167,
-0.3969494104,
0.0243799612,
-0.1567593217,
0.0650093108,
0.1129648685,
0.1216251105,
0.0133721046,
0.3791194558,
0.035774596,
0.0743422136,
-0.2259047627,
-0.1604482383,
0.6872939467,
-0.180975005,
-0.4151741564,
0.094181478,
0.3600971103,
0.1297421157,
-0.1582786888,
0.3579854965,
0.7634209991,
-0.4217477143,
-0.1484312713,
-0.9383279681,
-0.3825363815,
-0.4974326193,
0.3154132366,
-0.4698151052,
-1.3232264519,
0.4403294027,
0.0254155882,
-0.1165008545,
-0.1441763192,
0.6109580994,
-0.1790916622,
0.8140711188,
0.2953670621,
0.0852614641,
0.5798861384,
-0.4209854603,
0.1715202034,
-0.988060236,
-0.5067188144,
-0.0814614147,
-0.2890042365,
-0.5283554792,
-0.5561499,
0.3407256007,
-0.0649470463,
0.0174229294,
0.0678089634,
-0.6985658407,
0.5583344102,
0.4349022806,
0.4722768962,
0.4786884189,
0.1080907807,
0.0725990087,
-0.0693147033,
-0.5854049325,
-0.0447082706,
0.8844174147,
-0.0402747057,
0.9131628871,
0.0214574598,
0.5748876929,
0.2854505479,
0.1386476457,
-0.7716314793,
0.6720368266,
-0.0951636732,
-0.5787863731,
-0.219961226,
-0.5659461021,
-1.2060164213,
0.4966965914,
-0.5133319497,
-0.6069856286,
0.5114139318,
0.1454427987,
-0.3410215378,
-0.1030930355,
-0.7526448369,
0.6332034469,
-0.2794677615,
-0.35721457,
-0.5532850623,
-0.5705240369,
0.5137848854,
0.1692100316,
-0.05003668,
-0.0371919498,
0.1245469972,
0.1631343961,
-0.0318841264,
0.7105898261,
-0.0935217515,
0.2066493481,
0.5204411149,
0.1452334374,
0.5003381968,
0.4259321392,
-0.0423991047,
0.0518486276,
-0.3917124867,
-0.3987035453,
-0.8570669889,
0.8598726392,
-0.4354569912,
-0.5813593268,
0.0065612793,
-0.6309614778,
-0.4334439933,
0.0440645032,
0.2089673579,
0.5879046321,
-0.6786950231,
0.5315323472,
1.0278202295,
-0.2066121101,
-0.1185131967,
0.6351124644,
-0.1258973777,
-0.2189243585,
0.8785205483,
0.014889678,
0.1198979616,
0.6626065373,
0.0027298073,
-0.1831640303,
-0.5032246709,
-0.1101937518,
-0.1004276276,
-0.5808628798,
-0.2084947228,
-0.7904446125,
-0.186647892,
-0.3425857425,
-0.1160029471,
-0.0449517816,
-0.2806510627,
-0.4965749681,
-0.2550715506,
0.3349850774,
0.2123452723,
0.2059221268,
0.2414567918,
-0.5339598656,
0.4963137805,
0.6194426417,
0.1673303246,
-0.2000758648,
-0.5239303112,
-0.197560966,
0.3339447975,
-0.2703961134,
-0.4339868426,
0.3677657545,
0.3372348249,
0.5005939007,
0.0656873509,
0.0871917754,
0.9605451822,
-0.2531321943,
0.531925261,
0.1040236205,
-0.4612092078,
0.5262662768,
-0.2136734575,
0.2739192545,
0.811430037,
-0.0686626732,
-0.7098116875,
-0.2067960799,
-0.5676230192,
-0.8806663752,
0.1521238685,
0.3021234572,
0.5190987587,
-0.2165468931,
0.3704769909,
0.0784672126,
0.1199465245,
-0.2201618701,
-0.0014317562,
-0.1570955664,
-0.1886377782,
-0.0858008564,
-0.1991581917,
-0.1414020509,
-0.3669208586,
0.321187824,
-0.1711200625,
0.2718889713,
0.4269803762,
-0.3737055957,
0.3271035552,
0.4762724638,
0.3779918253,
0.2306530625,
-0.4252185225,
0.1459271163,
0.5610847473,
-0.4592910111,
0.0300570056,
0.2008924037,
-0.1410001963,
-0.0983367562,
-0.1696680486,
0.7298702002,
0.5123614669,
-0.7599965334,
0.4906659424,
-0.4777528048,
0.0358185582,
-0.4416757524,
0.2631247044,
-0.0196722168,
0.2486822158,
0.3349409699,
0.0098273968,
0.6689842343,
-0.4714402854,
0.3077076972,
0.6491008997,
-0.30279845,
-0.0991703793,
0.3903092444,
0.4420447052,
-0.1284677386,
0.7887932062,
-0.1807676703,
-0.1184061244,
0.2760119736,
0.5408399701,
0.7131265402,
0.1178122014,
0.086582683,
0.3210197389,
0.104056105,
0.0416157991,
0.2381044328,
-0.3304759264,
-0.9654824138,
-0.3432136476,
-0.269895494,
-0.5800418854,
0.2883120179,
-0.537868917,
0.2132803798,
-0.3849564791,
-0.1747470051,
-0.3682872355,
0.0731207728,
-0.8457551003,
0.2995808125,
0.275289923,
0.745608747,
-0.4527978897,
0.8186727762,
0.3611307144,
-0.2947402894,
-0.2828700542,
-0.2821298838,
-0.2848038673,
-0.8164202571,
0.0868945867,
0.1821736246,
-0.2471185923,
0.076961033,
-0.7612950206,
-0.6556414366,
1.2452405691,
0.5292935371,
-0.7657489777,
0.0435039923,
-0.0656546131,
0.6208592653,
-0.5349210501,
0.3112059534,
0.5581858754,
0.0658411309,
0.2644474804,
-0.5055735707,
-0.0175108127,
-0.3841536045,
-0.009514302,
-0.1057855263,
-0.6267369986,
0.4106708765,
0.0249938164,
-0.1346300393,
-0.1787265241,
0.6980916262,
0.4844509661,
0.4179387689,
0.4242095947,
0.6844162345,
0.9477474093,
0.0075345268,
1.0808256865,
-0.0313659869,
0.0596847385,
1.3578979969,
-0.0660155863,
0.7322443724,
0.4048903286,
0.3010894358,
0.4741400778,
0.4695841968,
0.1504688561,
0.4176170528,
0.0417552702,
-0.4211070538,
-0.4236893356,
-0.3631415665,
-0.2137193382,
0.2451549619,
0.8222517967,
0.1710898578,
0.0615614541,
0.0145471375,
-0.1038754135,
0.0200123396,
-0.0415339693,
0.9046159387,
0.2063337713,
-0.5775601864,
0.7959417701,
-0.4537801743,
0.9755821228,
-0.4409348369,
-0.2989649773,
-0.4144131839,
0.1400263011,
-0.2870658338,
-0.7799788713,
0.1247225031,
-0.2204293162,
-0.0767571479,
0.0024264599,
0.9719004631,
-0.8969272971,
-0.328463912,
0.3519638181,
0.4489596784,
0.1644399911,
-0.2207375318,
-0.8495385051,
0.0657762587,
-0.1458586007,
-0.044116281,
0.1830093116,
0.2957573533,
-0.138667509,
0.6837024689,
0.7005260587,
-0.204959169,
0.0267068055,
0.4891135395,
0.935138762,
-0.4134792089,
-0.3848445415,
-0.5482330322,
0.4618342817,
-0.3581782281,
-0.2150677592,
0.6018813848,
0.6496811509,
0.8794248104,
0.2336616814,
0.6976024508,
0.1873544306,
0.3584952056,
-0.4918442369,
0.3497247398,
-0.289406538,
0.4710586071,
-0.0743863955,
-0.8773860335,
-0.2489097267,
0.5414959192,
-0.3218087852,
-0.0822290406,
0.2521027327,
1.1202362776,
-0.4224936962,
-0.010786416,
0.4233318865,
0.2593028247,
0.5163459778,
0.8032229543,
0.7626888752,
-0.4248772562,
0.7650517821,
-0.091578491,
0.0025204758,
-0.4688926935,
-0.4327252507,
-0.6127377748,
-0.3564891517,
-0.11427591,
-0.3218595982,
0.0138741117,
0.6985592246,
0.7842423916,
-0.5852376819,
-0.1384202689,
-0.2800359428,
0.1651802659,
0.1369645745,
-0.2520268261,
-0.1028166115,
-0.3661773801,
-0.5230774879,
0.7594859004,
0.2212800682,
0.0326212868,
-0.0981684551,
-0.3090093732,
-0.3338610828,
0.2126671523,
0.5651324391,
0.2336423695,
-0.368437469,
-0.3226460814,
0.0276136603,
-0.2620976865,
0.340210855,
0.7985593677,
-1.0935440063,
0.8239753246,
0.4037170708,
0.7965902686,
1.0737115145,
0.2446902096,
0.508908391,
-1.0890642405,
0.2917806506,
0.4556722641,
0.1617472619,
0.6996993423,
-0.675183773,
0.5766685605,
0.1527380347,
-0.5444196463,
-0.6209308505,
0.3150466383,
-1.1848912239,
-0.091660127,
1.0770825148,
0.2730136812,
0.1045222729,
-0.3403226733,
-0.4242967367,
0.1188513115,
-0.6832081676,
0.704756856,
0.4390563369,
-0.1640309244,
-0.1671617776,
-0.4725192487,
0.2879852653,
0.4976998568,
-0.7085239291,
-0.0480874553,
0.6994640231,
0.1195692271,
-0.000842898,
0.9058950543,
0.0409330986,
0.1882933527,
-0.2519901097,
-0.0390443206,
-0.003407758,
-0.1180661023,
-0.3778839707,
0.0467790067,
-0.2674441338,
-0.0634172633
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07085v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07085v1
|
Speech Rhythm-Based Speaker Embeddings Extraction from Phonemes and Phoneme Duration for Multi-Speaker Speech Synthesis
| 2024-02-11T02:26:43 | 2024-02-11T02:26:43 |
Kenichi Fujita, Atsushi Ando, Yusuke Ijima
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS
|
This paper proposes a speech rhythm-based method for speaker embeddings to
model phoneme duration using a few utterances by the target speaker. Speech
rhythm is one of the essential factors among speaker characteristics, along
with acoustic features such as F0, for reproducing individual utterances in
speech synthesis. A novel feature of the proposed method is the rhythm-based
embeddings extracted from phonemes and their durations, which are known to be
related to speaking rhythm. They are extracted with a speaker identification
model similar to the conventional spectral feature-based one. We conducted
three experiments, speaker embeddings generation, speech synthesis with
generated embeddings, and embedding space analysis, to evaluate the
performance. The proposed method demonstrated a moderate speaker identification
performance (15.2% EER), even with only phonemes and their duration
information. The objective and subjective evaluation results demonstrated that
the proposed method can synthesize speech with speech rhythm closer to the
target speaker than the conventional method. We also visualized the embeddings
to evaluate the relationship between the distance of the embeddings and the
perceptual similarity. The visualization of the embedding space and the
relation analysis between the closeness indicated that the distribution of
embeddings reflects the subjective and objective similarity.
|
[
-0.3122417331,
-1.0841453075,
0.6045896411,
0.3759294152,
-0.5159657001,
-0.0735307708,
-0.1682131439,
-0.266744405,
0.7286739349,
0.292870611,
-0.4658642709,
-0.5824512839,
-0.1318314672,
-0.1812131256,
-0.298777014,
0.4062129557,
0.4628771245,
0.1565579027,
-0.2281085998,
0.0708196759,
-0.7329465747,
-0.2668980956,
-0.0258765984,
-0.3857388794,
-0.0362146944,
0.462505728,
0.3304550648,
0.894225657,
0.0690512136,
0.2202400714,
-0.2843738794,
-0.1051947549,
-0.1306596547,
0.2650898397,
0.4695100784,
-0.1205080748,
-0.7090981603,
0.1935285032,
0.9717243314,
0.7406939864,
-0.2157881409,
0.2254760861,
0.0354720168,
0.2073265463,
-0.2319230288,
0.1848903745,
-0.487434864,
0.3766901493,
-0.4327964187,
-0.5203966498,
-0.410482347,
-0.6151719093,
0.1894793808,
-0.0695533529,
0.1659646481,
-0.1230386123,
0.2251580358,
-0.05376295,
-0.0061755455,
-0.2987208664,
-0.8360115886,
0.6697511077,
-0.710170269,
0.7430137396,
0.2234062105,
0.4931397736,
0.0847560316,
-0.3091499805,
-0.4365535975,
-0.2811399698,
0.1833574623,
-0.0186830666,
0.3871842325,
-0.1859436482,
0.2349810451,
0.2736590803,
-0.5360952616,
-0.2926891744,
-0.1636861116,
-0.4494722188,
0.5990738869,
0.0672919899,
0.3894077539,
-0.256382376,
-0.5126758814,
-0.1614484191,
-0.5775375962,
0.195983842,
0.751295507,
0.5456598997,
-0.2494845241,
0.6239672303,
0.0211507585,
0.622012794,
-0.0861993581,
-0.6689997911,
0.5642936826,
-0.3251281083,
0.1287626624,
0.654833734,
0.5949327946,
0.2252096087,
0.2954832315,
-0.314451158,
-0.0406413265,
-0.0385745578,
-0.0150160724,
-0.8720172644,
-0.0930328742,
0.0390747748,
-0.5269720554,
-0.130611062,
0.0465423912,
-0.9916103482,
-0.1047461107,
-0.1536705792,
0.2678004801,
-0.6735720634,
-0.1668571383,
-0.2276735604,
-0.2699219882,
0.4145402908,
-0.0947818086,
-0.7010498047,
0.4705948532,
0.4707491994,
1.0579553843,
-0.1568959057,
-0.3178904057,
-0.6426873207,
0.2558712363,
-0.2745145559,
0.4174941182,
-0.7443030477,
-0.8271354437,
-0.3415297866,
-0.224215582,
0.1717752218,
-0.3466879427,
0.0320079364,
-0.1245309189,
-0.0487932451,
-0.0404756963,
-0.9756745696,
0.1681571603,
-0.4016169012,
-0.6400099397,
0.6087993979,
-0.070302017,
-0.4344986379,
0.0139123173,
-0.6215065122,
-0.5300344825,
0.0487587452,
-0.3125032783,
-0.5185094476,
-0.0965034887,
-0.05192139,
0.4577955306,
0.016990982,
0.0331780128,
-0.3958992362,
-0.4373297691,
0.4514726996,
-0.2874252498,
0.7043151259,
0.4708684683,
-0.3260416687,
-0.0822810307,
-1.0330644846,
0.0687811971,
0.0278865956,
-0.1216353178,
-0.0411600135,
0.1378222406,
0.1425373107,
-0.1273874491,
0.0961378068,
-0.6965706944,
-0.2082078308,
-0.3493748307,
0.4045051038,
0.6310535073,
0.4303846359,
0.4297469258,
-0.4263471663,
0.5600476861,
-0.3518446982,
-0.0860934928,
-0.5518374443,
-0.7353725433,
-0.0398563556,
-0.3987759054,
0.3085725307,
0.6685612202,
0.0046169902,
0.5485742092,
-0.3221079409,
-0.5109099746,
-0.3625913262,
-0.0348919816,
0.511926353,
0.3098757267,
0.3568393588,
-0.6835130453,
-0.5345237851,
-0.6073301435,
-0.2507793307,
-0.0488162413,
0.1078436747,
0.3561343551,
-0.0934180841,
0.0990470871,
1.1352462769,
-0.5968731642,
0.0133043649,
0.1798346341,
-0.17979303,
0.1449584514,
0.6555736065,
0.6112551689,
-0.4542184472,
-0.3783909678,
-0.1717702895,
-0.2553727925,
-0.2864719331,
0.116626583,
0.1922284663,
-0.2099234909,
0.6462830901,
-0.0927870721,
0.4146377146,
0.3767230213,
-0.331451565,
0.5511642694,
0.1339756399,
0.1573035121,
-0.9890983701,
0.1023269594,
-0.1672602743,
-0.326600045,
-0.7171598077,
-0.4392341673,
-0.3141644001,
-0.6037458181,
-0.5425062776,
0.4142137468,
-0.4987077713,
-0.4805675745,
-0.0297075976,
0.3226379454,
-0.3521145284,
0.4432266057,
-0.0974247828,
0.6527193189,
0.4303863049,
-0.5063189864,
0.3768384159,
0.2883286774,
-0.5351566672,
0.4026764929,
-0.6680486798,
0.603751123,
0.3040581644,
-0.0473633446,
-1.1813206673,
0.0877521038,
0.0749931112,
-0.6001560688,
0.2814475298,
-0.4553604126,
-0.0992510095,
0.2017486542,
-0.1423973441,
0.6305059791,
0.8988083005,
-0.1673112214,
0.3877477944,
0.5909476876,
-0.5800219774,
-0.132196337,
-0.65413481,
-0.1479912102,
-0.4109419584,
-0.8336802721,
0.7553477287,
-0.2266746014,
-0.2764091194,
-0.0528754219,
0.0587266162,
0.003361406,
-0.0821698159,
0.4950112104,
-0.1740906835,
-0.0214255322,
0.1552081406,
-0.0850535259,
-0.1909119189,
-0.0900391415,
-0.0896674469,
0.7644521594,
0.1267614663,
-0.5384476781,
-0.7309700251,
0.6071031094,
0.4439043403,
-0.4829924703,
0.2030742913,
0.8916447163,
-0.2098974586,
-0.2390508056,
-0.5136601925,
-0.2454952896,
-0.3934791684,
0.1314418763,
-0.5390574932,
-0.776281774,
0.7448959947,
-0.0531841069,
-0.2773371637,
0.0316326767,
0.4963249266,
0.095556885,
0.6501977444,
0.3419152796,
-0.1203462929,
0.9704324007,
-0.1486994624,
-0.0024107411,
-0.6611115336,
-0.3779387176,
-0.5693864822,
-0.2358380854,
-0.4754628837,
-0.5850663781,
0.4290461838,
-0.1204456165,
0.0094783455,
0.1416672468,
-0.2675125301,
0.2025910914,
0.4308505356,
0.1800052524,
-0.2101038992,
0.1804350615,
-0.3155137897,
-0.1350145936,
-0.2177010924,
-0.4674275815,
0.8829094768,
0.167301178,
0.6894025207,
0.2548345029,
1.108417511,
0.4967547655,
-0.5850709677,
-0.680772841,
0.5613039136,
0.1006254181,
-0.1258189976,
-0.5174033642,
-0.3824014664,
-0.7168936729,
-0.190006122,
-0.0879913792,
-0.8976720572,
0.1154174581,
0.1773778945,
-0.2725778818,
0.0419715978,
-0.6787689328,
0.5568022728,
0.0231638532,
0.0382945202,
-0.3330752552,
-0.623144865,
-0.2894052565,
0.2712257504,
0.2989299893,
-0.1394272149,
0.3758189976,
0.7990085483,
-0.369997412,
0.7630458474,
-0.5134407878,
0.0680189878,
0.6403028965,
0.2418905795,
0.3933275044,
-0.0476332419,
-0.016747117,
0.1009741202,
-0.2121316493,
-0.3731347919,
-0.4140756428,
0.794526577,
-0.5072753429,
-0.5596199036,
0.2454349697,
-0.3109714687,
-0.4150002301,
0.01947104,
-0.1557876468,
0.8969507813,
-0.5967900157,
0.3714163005,
0.4238221645,
-0.2547330856,
0.7317469716,
0.1079155952,
-0.1936762482,
-0.6852781773,
0.8645761609,
0.2242324799,
0.2644974589,
0.3045911193,
0.3661375046,
-0.2738006115,
-0.6410980821,
-0.2236817032,
0.1221111044,
-0.4166641235,
0.3583537936,
-0.4849333465,
0.0580607317,
-0.8432391286,
0.0641636103,
-0.52816993,
-0.6682302356,
-0.165391773,
0.0504396856,
0.4304471314,
0.3567948937,
-0.1460969001,
0.3472090662,
-0.7604731917,
0.3346652985,
0.6846372485,
0.4689233899,
-0.0155649427,
-0.6995709538,
-0.3021473587,
0.0454597399,
-0.1553046554,
-1.4793640375,
0.2633242905,
0.2597263753,
0.7820304632,
0.3759806156,
-0.5280786157,
0.8483911157,
-0.7890910506,
0.9541611671,
0.1479206383,
-1.2712577581,
0.8237059712,
-0.1199722439,
0.1156935692,
-0.0678459108,
-0.1200211421,
-0.4573620558,
-0.1708117127,
-0.6058180928,
-0.7725173235,
0.6440725923,
0.5074689984,
0.0537896045,
-0.0794773102,
0.2482704073,
0.1541006714,
-0.0439472124,
-0.1740395725,
-0.6040613651,
-0.3770536482,
0.1019353271,
-0.2300686985,
-0.3858961761,
0.0051693586,
-0.034521658,
0.7025391459,
0.1039104611,
0.7056372762,
0.2663279772,
-0.2463026196,
-0.0509048514,
0.4154474437,
0.7978670597,
0.6213700771,
-0.5139974356,
-0.0671327412,
0.0853462666,
-0.3788064718,
0.2342547476,
0.1302704662,
0.0922006369,
0.380497992,
0.4634373486,
0.7762304544,
-0.0491175167,
-0.2521505654,
0.6092438698,
0.1765175611,
0.2398005575,
-0.5843455791,
0.0520804785,
0.3219039738,
0.4729286134,
0.224774316,
-0.1971579343,
0.1969382614,
-0.4811304808,
0.5294199586,
0.1855442822,
-0.4794847667,
-0.4897255003,
0.5325908065,
0.230340451,
-0.894205749,
0.1781883538,
-0.2029042989,
0.0099789882,
0.721742034,
0.6458583474,
1.0966608524,
-0.9058712125,
-0.0073877298,
0.2176363915,
-0.1405178756,
0.2390158772,
0.6053960323,
-0.3973149955,
-0.5394275784,
-0.249104768,
-0.6552045941,
-0.177518785,
-0.2072643489,
-0.7069494724,
0.2516812682,
-0.3419635892,
-0.3779377937,
0.1447311491,
-0.0747782886,
-0.4989094734,
-0.1033259183,
0.3174432814,
0.3800780773,
-1.0324606895,
0.8979285359,
0.4269477725,
-0.0447618254,
-0.6856808066,
-0.0565584674,
0.1413135231,
-0.4304738939,
0.2403560281,
-0.0137044294,
-0.3700627685,
0.0498161726,
-0.2119524479,
-0.6152365804,
1.3874156475,
0.404705137,
-0.7257409096,
0.3335983455,
-0.0408446305,
0.3224848211,
-0.7316560149,
0.0554447509,
0.260561645,
0.1747784466,
0.0331541337,
-0.9361233711,
-0.0855439082,
-0.2314307243,
0.2895617187,
0.0901022777,
-0.5305511355,
0.9180689454,
-0.1435230225,
-0.3069246113,
0.2454923242,
0.5027641654,
0.2148240209,
0.1733136028,
0.6396057606,
0.6075874567,
0.5963743329,
0.2262337655,
0.717944622,
-0.5251715779,
0.3714781702,
1.1864968538,
-0.2358726263,
0.5473088622,
0.4440208972,
-0.3617298901,
0.5505373478,
0.103568323,
0.1402349919,
0.8255287409,
0.2542305887,
-0.1508060396,
-0.190926224,
0.0905535817,
-0.6951398849,
0.7631300688,
0.3136032522,
-0.6457264423,
0.0962842703,
-0.0376013853,
-0.0002784494,
0.0152638042,
0.176386252,
0.7570048571,
0.1037538201,
-0.2822110355,
0.5306751728,
-0.1213657483,
0.1621209383,
-0.3889039159,
-0.3156177998,
-0.0088668084,
-0.1641675681,
0.0518273711,
-0.4685027599,
0.0851668492,
-0.1428409815,
-0.1767264307,
-0.3492689729,
0.4691841006,
-0.6206455827,
-0.1578478664,
0.2832505703,
0.6652029753,
0.4116483927,
0.266158551,
-0.3477834165,
0.1002167836,
0.145330295,
-0.1121100634,
0.0308224466,
0.4170785844,
0.1689248681,
0.2821121812,
0.5399211049,
0.3048180938,
0.2700561583,
0.3594246805,
0.329721123,
-0.9777984619,
-0.8918157816,
-1.0107707977,
0.0845497176,
0.1172520146,
-0.0125051029,
0.5948314071,
0.517162323,
0.4629116952,
-0.0569238216,
0.5986445546,
-0.0172755904,
0.6074426174,
-0.7005794048,
0.4516824782,
-0.2878212333,
0.2942365408,
-0.7495102882,
-1.1324857473,
0.0271230545,
0.5513904095,
0.0962209255,
0.1225816905,
0.4728924036,
0.9925851822,
0.0043087155,
0.0924945846,
0.4979506433,
0.1383745223,
0.3602542877,
0.2626767457,
0.7021892071,
-0.1432812214,
0.3982119858,
-0.4305639863,
-0.1285478324,
-0.3295617998,
-0.7551851869,
-0.5923762321,
-0.7395214438,
-0.3942830861,
-0.0332490504,
0.0905173346,
0.9651480913,
0.7269982696,
-0.6972070932,
-0.614082098,
0.3761179745,
0.0349864513,
-0.5179198384,
-0.2145013958,
0.5989397168,
-0.1414268464,
-0.712972939,
0.6646568179,
0.2882528007,
0.282271713,
-0.0263974816,
-0.2476742566,
-0.1860847026,
0.0125912447,
0.3805281222,
-0.0099461162,
-0.6644405723,
-0.5473967791,
-0.2337038517,
0.1875177175,
0.1307798326,
0.8204776645,
-0.4799086452,
0.8504036665,
0.8217411041,
0.23549667,
0.6384943128,
0.0359380655,
0.4069682658,
-1.2162936926,
0.3074036539,
0.2447258532,
0.49631989,
0.2617582977,
0.0123658627,
0.2185143232,
0.4352712631,
-0.3486654162,
-0.6466218829,
0.3425440192,
-1.2092193365,
-0.0122325197,
1.1899522543,
-0.1986704171,
-0.205761686,
0.0345971026,
-0.0778275803,
0.6513930559,
-0.5237976909,
0.5974801779,
0.480189532,
-0.3522924483,
0.0815018043,
-0.106209375,
0.39156425,
0.0733873919,
-0.293892622,
-0.3186584413,
0.5558037758,
0.4252677858,
0.5228431225,
0.7043026686,
-0.5308238268,
0.3595575392,
0.3387110829,
0.3772363067,
-0.2734640241,
-0.3039063513,
-0.1761700809,
0.3312100172,
0.0347102173,
-0.5268517137
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07081v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07081v1
|
Using Large Language Models for Student-Code Guided Test Case Generation in Computer Science Education
| 2024-02-11T01:37:48 | 2024-02-11T01:37:48 |
Nischal Ashok Kumar, Andrew Lan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SE
|
In computer science education, test cases are an integral part of programming
assignments since they can be used as assessment items to test students'
programming knowledge and provide personalized feedback on student-written
code. The goal of our work is to propose a fully automated approach for test
case generation that can accurately measure student knowledge, which is
important for two reasons. First, manually constructing test cases requires
expert knowledge and is a labor-intensive process. Second, developing test
cases for students, especially those who are novice programmers, is
significantly different from those oriented toward professional-level software
developers. Therefore, we need an automated process for test case generation to
assess student knowledge and provide feedback. In this work, we propose a large
language model-based approach to automatically generate test cases and show
that they are good measures of student knowledge, using a publicly available
dataset that contains student-written Java code. We also discuss future
research directions centered on using test cases to help students.
|
[
-0.1258728802,
-0.7893528342,
0.5435833931,
0.0823579133,
0.2228002697,
0.3132184744,
-0.2037090063,
-0.0006286749,
-0.235018909,
0.5123978257,
-0.1713881344,
-0.5873101354,
0.0448090322,
0.0144227929,
-0.6690279245,
1.0356345177,
-0.2267219573,
0.1636592001,
-0.4787594676,
0.3117022216,
-0.4253901839,
-0.6991862655,
-0.5395545959,
0.0615564175,
-0.0120680807,
0.7158709764,
0.2286949456,
0.2658182383,
0.4489917457,
0.2711586952,
0.305739969,
-0.465421617,
-0.0078500146,
0.1645365357,
0.0254627727,
-0.475376308,
-0.3211191893,
0.0132764177,
0.639528811,
0.9198015332,
-0.2208304256,
0.4914752841,
-0.2215875238,
0.4505241811,
-0.4713988304,
0.3602617085,
-0.3179140091,
0.111458227,
-0.15998739,
0.0399675816,
-0.6124860048,
-0.5699819922,
-0.0466764495,
-0.5201119781,
0.4023634493,
-0.1054535806,
0.5548238754,
-0.0702061802,
-0.5485510826,
-0.4061087966,
-0.7269382477,
0.892783463,
-0.8262932897,
0.1622352749,
0.2211878151,
0.723336339,
-0.2954502106,
-0.4895443916,
-0.5925577879,
-0.5838525891,
0.3558199704,
0.2499258667,
0.1531982571,
0.0115183443,
0.4406623542,
0.268884033,
-0.8336745501,
-0.099532634,
-0.6829720736,
-0.2007650435,
1.0232931376,
0.3037589192,
0.5091385841,
-0.0275661927,
0.1683082581,
-0.2182826847,
-0.7994352579,
0.148896575,
0.6300420165,
0.3198033571,
0.1991277039,
0.7240845561,
-0.3033393919,
0.8569353819,
-0.3863335252,
-0.1343294531,
0.0862458721,
-0.1626349837,
-0.2693229914,
0.0568293706,
0.3723048866,
-0.0733170435,
0.8196458817,
-0.0222277436,
-0.1000480577,
0.4203473628,
0.363882035,
-0.9991215467,
-0.3194361031,
0.2491562217,
-0.4600619972,
-0.5787071586,
0.1599211544,
-0.6899796128,
-0.3055114746,
-0.5424873233,
0.3892744184,
-0.1279910654,
-0.3159247339,
0.3002706766,
-0.0329570994,
0.2196380943,
0.2512656152,
-0.2819016576,
0.4092878103,
0.3888402283,
0.2194322795,
-0.2697887719,
-0.3808356822,
-0.5071511865,
0.2434753627,
-0.4559654593,
0.4849125743,
-0.69353652,
-0.3352996111,
0.242169112,
-0.1315378845,
0.2691313624,
-0.3146827221,
0.0562780388,
-0.426078856,
0.3215500116,
0.1124987528,
-0.8873470426,
-0.0283639561,
0.1382316649,
-0.1093130931,
1.0010128021,
0.2694709301,
-0.405341655,
0.3326656222,
-0.843323946,
-0.7292433381,
0.3773354888,
-0.209017992,
-0.5233296752,
0.0675751641,
-0.1581170559,
0.584921658,
-0.2178765088,
0.5699319243,
-0.292070508,
-0.4321796,
0.272222966,
0.1067800075,
0.7796843648,
0.1357311308,
-0.4641040862,
0.0091744307,
-0.7078418732,
0.2015630156,
0.4216509759,
-0.5006027818,
-0.3975277245,
0.1780190617,
0.177256614,
-0.1089363992,
0.0839900076,
-0.6549802423,
0.5208215117,
-0.2517039478,
0.2417167723,
0.6819294691,
-0.0603310503,
0.2327268124,
0.0236390792,
0.7516264319,
-0.0397681519,
0.4065507054,
-0.2831713259,
-0.3179090321,
-0.7395439744,
0.1343777776,
0.4700416923,
0.4875808954,
-0.4085336626,
0.1915122867,
0.191111356,
-0.5631485581,
-0.0542179458,
0.2223981172,
0.3168988228,
0.3742366135,
0.1413281411,
-0.4739339948,
-0.5641803741,
-0.7260606885,
-0.035661377,
-0.4713043869,
0.0409049243,
0.391764462,
0.6313368082,
-0.3524672687,
1.1056716442,
-1.0757411718,
-0.070307903,
-0.3220008612,
0.0477058776,
-0.0428103097,
0.6246705651,
0.3956815004,
-0.6377101541,
-0.463676393,
-0.0984177887,
-0.6213576794,
-0.2130309939,
-0.222263366,
-0.1716005057,
0.3340731561,
0.6453309655,
-0.103807047,
0.5598071218,
0.3138257563,
-0.424217999,
0.8577286601,
-0.1718033552,
0.1062645316,
-1.1387082338,
0.0724931434,
0.0853170678,
-0.2385819554,
-0.4259448051,
0.3750801682,
0.1711420268,
-0.4745624065,
-0.2232413143,
0.4861393571,
-0.501214087,
-0.1701845229,
-0.3805819154,
-0.1249076575,
-0.2301350534,
0.1897170842,
0.0411561802,
0.8017414808,
0.6637105346,
-0.6662584543,
0.3533889651,
-0.0568262637,
-0.4980200231,
0.4813012183,
-0.7359170914,
-0.0236696079,
0.2052313238,
0.227641657,
-0.7638291121,
-0.3996580541,
-0.4537388384,
-0.4487301409,
0.1580547541,
-0.2415900826,
-0.519030571,
-0.9274278879,
0.1070249975,
0.4204050601,
0.8146339655,
-0.3020926118,
0.3812965751,
0.4856543839,
-0.3342263401,
-0.1235920116,
-0.5329212546,
-0.0081945453,
-0.0215179436,
-0.5366661549,
0.0868428349,
-0.4854512513,
-0.3028499186,
-0.2135943323,
0.0673909262,
-0.6470207572,
0.3340195119,
0.5069211125,
0.3310310841,
-0.3499670029,
0.3292310536,
0.223473683,
0.2718314826,
0.3479908109,
-0.3943602741,
0.3809728622,
-0.1537408382,
-0.7810253501,
-0.2119710594,
0.5806900859,
0.6038873792,
-0.2024276406,
0.255274266,
0.0885490775,
-0.439871788,
-0.6283548474,
-0.6903058887,
-0.2489851117,
-0.449808985,
0.3429307342,
-0.3032135665,
-0.9070719481,
0.3670330942,
-0.1977347285,
0.0903711021,
0.0495872349,
0.6327603459,
-0.0390821472,
1.3765360117,
0.9462016225,
-0.1678089201,
0.3209880888,
-0.0279406067,
0.385717839,
-0.3091797829,
0.0090840822,
-0.7861460447,
0.3944622874,
-0.1524958909,
-0.0920114815,
0.1908974797,
-0.0636104718,
-0.5554842353,
0.284927994,
-0.6040139794,
0.7558832169,
0.5488443375,
-0.1062460318,
0.1685521454,
-0.1149588898,
-0.174021259,
0.1806498766,
-0.4631421268,
-0.5102418661,
1.3784459829,
0.0536588728,
0.4893583059,
0.0173104573,
0.8302334547,
0.4957938194,
0.3210025132,
-0.7228666544,
0.6340324283,
0.1678343117,
-0.6595454812,
-0.2202470303,
-0.4795515537,
-0.9539868832,
-0.4658955932,
0.1476831585,
-0.355520606,
-0.443097204,
-0.0071383025,
-0.3668624759,
-0.1374328583,
-0.9554815292,
0.9480183721,
-0.1483405381,
-0.1528316438,
-0.1501835734,
-0.3443432152,
0.2369023263,
-0.2733066976,
0.166566506,
0.4339176118,
0.6378381848,
0.989931941,
-0.677965939,
0.9473747015,
-0.3768160045,
-0.035617508,
0.7000697255,
0.5052514076,
0.2965429127,
0.1495102644,
-0.0663638115,
-0.3220570385,
0.298209399,
-0.5381290317,
-0.3737867177,
0.5320063233,
-0.6307597756,
-0.7834324241,
-0.396099925,
-0.8167062402,
-0.1831904501,
0.2360293269,
-0.4620171189,
0.3120703995,
-0.0420389734,
-0.0780884847,
0.7531602979,
-0.4464658201,
0.4584502578,
1.0057302713,
-0.5226441026,
0.2500997782,
1.1286264658,
0.104910396,
0.0689004734,
-0.2438541949,
0.4127783775,
0.1453241855,
-0.5302417278,
-0.5543876886,
0.0089309113,
-0.6010338664,
-0.1721775234,
-0.2863830328,
-0.1283265203,
-0.8454075456,
-0.6049804091,
-0.3434327543,
-0.2832887471,
0.1631997675,
0.1575054675,
0.1954678893,
0.9567353725,
0.2903449237,
0.0947308317,
-0.5778718591,
0.0581384748,
0.5577014685,
0.1139323637,
-0.0910344273,
-0.3290391564,
-0.114352189,
-0.2558631599,
-0.3060257733,
-0.8945629597,
0.3379762173,
-0.0966665298,
0.3809638023,
0.2326859981,
0.1652225256,
0.5412772298,
-0.3604646921,
0.9013586044,
0.0868814364,
-1.3457132578,
1.0241038799,
-0.3317337036,
0.295624584,
0.59357512,
0.1569428891,
-0.4270834029,
-0.6009421349,
-0.5318844914,
-0.4953281879,
0.5475186706,
0.0181344468,
0.2769623101,
0.118539989,
0.40250507,
0.0871711522,
0.2049514651,
-0.7449215055,
0.05538968,
-0.0616445541,
-0.5661917925,
0.2018026412,
0.0649976581,
-0.1183580682,
-0.4634082019,
0.5358701944,
-0.3870542347,
0.0301039554,
-0.0709402636,
-0.0108741671,
0.0844922587,
0.2301096171,
0.5784358382,
0.785438776,
-0.0368849039,
-0.2291514128,
0.0836438462,
-0.7006889582,
0.075136371,
-0.0538772307,
-0.4333336949,
-0.3035188913,
-0.041729603,
0.1263061762,
-0.217529729,
-1.0799101591,
0.9945664406,
-0.1980297267,
-0.2231771797,
-0.7599198818,
0.2028213292,
-0.1215953156,
0.1391458213,
0.3847385943,
-0.2571603656,
0.2346253842,
-0.5113953948,
0.178253144,
0.3923555911,
-0.1205241084,
-0.0719508603,
0.320859015,
0.2583813965,
-0.1842956394,
0.6153188944,
-0.2721386552,
-0.6339496374,
1.2551089525,
0.9359996915,
0.6344899535,
-0.3779285252,
0.5054423213,
0.4834473431,
0.0468015894,
-0.1704605967,
0.395365566,
-0.1669347882,
-0.2194240093,
-0.8331387639,
-0.6807541847,
-0.6709682941,
-0.018591091,
-0.5790445805,
0.4755636752,
-0.5225206017,
0.2709780037,
-0.2199143171,
0.202065751,
-0.6417346597,
0.4809250534,
0.0777378529,
0.7783318162,
-0.9684878588,
1.0687351227,
1.0348877907,
-0.5190787315,
-1.2020248175,
-0.0666788071,
-0.2789566815,
-0.2733303607,
0.9552515149,
0.0664521083,
0.4500730932,
-0.1014116406,
-0.724986434,
-0.6843469739,
0.7157000303,
0.0631197691,
-0.4955401123,
0.1072994992,
0.2864265442,
0.599981904,
-0.3810583651,
0.5147913694,
0.1252316386,
0.4143105745,
-0.0602856241,
-0.6170918345,
-0.0187139884,
-0.3558470309,
0.0062693651,
0.2557586432,
-0.3978840113,
0.7224684358,
-0.2798417807,
-0.02401774,
-0.1909030229,
0.612768054,
0.2278194278,
0.4831002951,
0.2813215256,
0.1908997446,
0.7684169412,
0.1091292873,
1.0461831093,
-0.3192791939,
0.2718014717,
0.8725091815,
-0.5433208346,
0.6030448675,
0.3424138427,
-0.2818273306,
0.6535647511,
0.4522814155,
-0.3402587771,
-0.0935976505,
0.9516738653,
-0.0092380987,
-0.6509974599,
0.1037353873,
-0.4465564489,
0.5070087314,
-0.0369620211,
-0.2287912667,
0.1599474698,
0.1561295986,
0.1617494076,
0.2060066909,
-0.2766828239,
0.3779607415,
-0.2596996129,
-0.8862974644,
0.1419980377,
0.0394393057,
0.3684238195,
-0.4026029408,
-0.0766903311,
-0.2659118176,
0.188316673,
-0.2294473201,
-0.7744682431,
0.2251787633,
0.4386569858,
-0.2775812447,
0.060273353,
0.4897875786,
-0.1740586609,
-0.9719994664,
0.0533207133,
0.3863899112,
0.3380992413,
0.0280775055,
-0.4553460479,
-0.1715011597,
0.093780756,
-0.3906373084,
0.3577640951,
0.0363014862,
-0.4122932851,
0.6717031002,
0.7486047149,
0.2331315726,
0.1842840612,
0.3363603055,
0.6668051481,
-0.5845999122,
-0.1797240525,
-0.5622766614,
0.4479261041,
-0.1368158758,
-0.2876266241,
0.842890799,
0.7602470517,
0.9935113788,
-0.1261207312,
1.1107097864,
-0.1277532279,
0.3171290755,
-0.0345184356,
0.6590023041,
-0.4851728976,
-0.0451813117,
-0.5507496595,
-0.9265319705,
-0.4647187591,
0.5282785892,
-0.1796293557,
-0.0002769572,
0.630433023,
0.8437547684,
-0.0277792159,
0.061475236,
0.235823825,
0.0437833145,
0.5697876811,
0.8642352819,
0.6831543446,
-0.4562140107,
0.5952836275,
-0.2073815316,
-0.4623096585,
-0.0823812932,
-0.7283965349,
-1.1518666744,
-0.6551812887,
-0.8404691219,
-0.4431034029,
0.0334336832,
0.5970760584,
0.7656409144,
-1.0501025915,
-0.5382609963,
-0.4378052354,
-0.0230411869,
-0.0333403163,
-0.2933982909,
0.2627688944,
-0.4716458917,
-0.6668149829,
0.4027016163,
-0.090229027,
0.0859530494,
-0.547919929,
-0.0457426421,
0.2014369071,
0.3280087709,
0.5668139458,
0.3430891633,
-0.2866377831,
-0.1521000564,
0.0851695314,
-0.2021743357,
-0.4553543031,
1.0242226124,
-0.8445150256,
0.3877594769,
0.5078104734,
0.7123559713,
0.4789314568,
-0.2705602646,
0.6491277814,
-0.4495557547,
-0.0937177017,
0.2738547921,
0.3140347898,
0.1844860315,
-0.3687888086,
0.615504384,
0.1918753237,
-0.9048365951,
-1.2014397383,
0.1347373128,
-0.9109683633,
-0.5711452961,
1.3572129011,
-0.1951621324,
-0.1965889186,
-0.0996445119,
-0.334274739,
0.4195501506,
-0.1756191403,
0.9720001817,
0.5648802519,
0.0645956546,
0.3012140989,
-0.6207926273,
0.2721488476,
0.5659704208,
-1.1291370392,
0.0254200529,
0.5031709075,
0.3580125272,
0.1577219069,
0.1787738204,
-0.0645556822,
0.3488028646,
-0.0639104173,
0.7936297655,
-0.1813698113,
-0.4516052902,
0.1489341706,
0.5704779029,
-0.0005547728,
0.0814974532
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07069v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07069v1
|
Using Large Language Models to Automate and Expedite Reinforcement Learning with Reward Machine
| 2024-02-11T00:00:05 | 2024-02-11T00:00:05 |
Shayan Meshkat Alsadat, Jean-Raphael Gaglione, Daniel Neider, Ufuk Topcu, Zhe Xu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We present LARL-RM (Large language model-generated Automaton for
Reinforcement Learning with Reward Machine) algorithm in order to encode
high-level knowledge into reinforcement learning using automaton to expedite
the reinforcement learning. Our method uses Large Language Models (LLM) to
obtain high-level domain-specific knowledge using prompt engineering instead of
providing the reinforcement learning algorithm directly with the high-level
knowledge which requires an expert to encode the automaton. We use
chain-of-thought and few-shot methods for prompt engineering and demonstrate
that our method works using these approaches. Additionally, LARL-RM allows for
fully closed-loop reinforcement learning without the need for an expert to
guide and supervise the learning since LARL-RM can use the LLM directly to
generate the required high-level knowledge for the task at hand. We also show
the theoretical guarantee of our algorithm to converge to an optimal policy. We
demonstrate that LARL-RM speeds up the convergence by 30% by implementing our
method in two case studies.
|
[
-0.2164331079,
-0.8866978884,
0.5047566295,
0.1628073603,
0.1707630455,
0.3603471518,
-0.2850159109,
-0.0886029601,
0.0545501299,
0.5372177362,
-0.6186975241,
-0.2330054343,
-0.3686901629,
-0.1002805755,
0.0499326847,
0.9039882421,
-0.3012976646,
-0.0911057666,
0.195290938,
0.2711580694,
-0.3432220817,
-0.6785660982,
-0.9979603887,
-0.4515234232,
0.8142381907,
0.4546621442,
0.2988575697,
0.6652752757,
0.2695518434,
0.3256632388,
-0.1150212511,
0.2169910073,
-0.6348672509,
0.2272007763,
-0.4341317415,
-0.3469185233,
-0.3692106903,
-0.1215290576,
0.4384996891,
0.2939789891,
-0.2958824337,
-0.0956271216,
-0.0404889546,
0.684176445,
-0.7185328007,
0.4525425136,
-0.5849084854,
0.1997285932,
0.3347059488,
-0.6105662584,
-0.7027818561,
-0.5686922073,
-0.091197215,
-0.7790368795,
-0.4136259854,
0.2239442021,
0.7809965014,
0.4864421189,
-0.314706713,
-0.4019865394,
-0.740136981,
1.0170276165,
-0.6125276685,
0.157954976,
0.2813909054,
0.7133337259,
-0.2179409564,
-0.3744613528,
-0.4485532343,
-0.7926986217,
0.1577001512,
0.0273929667,
0.1983587146,
0.2575951219,
0.6898339391,
0.1801092178,
-0.5562027693,
0.4779629111,
-0.2631406188,
-0.0988219827,
0.7167006731,
0.2357355207,
-0.0181747507,
0.06403476,
-0.567907989,
-0.5066438913,
-0.8238325715,
0.4590452909,
0.0726795942,
0.2119017094,
0.1422082931,
0.5484505296,
-0.5289984941,
0.4785242975,
-0.055456765,
-0.075040333,
0.1658965647,
-0.0611607246,
-0.2355448902,
0.0710690394,
0.8267619014,
-0.2095128,
0.2693886757,
0.0149700027,
-0.5899125934,
-0.1328508258,
0.1257157177,
-0.6519469023,
0.0828653947,
0.0423331521,
-0.2824353874,
-0.253680706,
-0.0764461532,
-0.4832481146,
-0.2823374867,
-0.4716966748,
0.704869628,
-0.2448782176,
-0.0811440721,
0.2708011568,
-0.0819254741,
0.2927893698,
0.4972966611,
-0.6158957481,
0.1489285529,
0.6170027256,
0.5348315239,
-0.288326025,
-0.4625379145,
-1.1041804552,
0.1468802094,
-0.2119176835,
0.6527075171,
-0.2666553557,
-0.1064134091,
0.2209811956,
0.0312771238,
0.0307193231,
-0.5407981277,
0.2815758288,
-0.9580288529,
0.1705110967,
-0.0062564905,
-0.6577033997,
-0.3556102812,
0.4297844768,
-0.666089654,
0.730992496,
0.1425912678,
-0.2471634299,
0.1942138672,
-0.9978375435,
-0.5238668323,
-0.0379722342,
0.012865874,
-0.1699538082,
-0.2304154932,
0.2278820872,
0.7318143249,
-0.1120967716,
0.2416074425,
-0.1857922673,
-0.2788234949,
0.3910198212,
-0.2406082451,
0.6299755573,
0.247493729,
-0.3434169292,
0.4238764048,
-0.3739170134,
0.0815026313,
0.1916951388,
-0.3852058351,
-0.1400772929,
-0.055128701,
-0.2137242258,
0.6542726159,
0.5510206223,
-0.1373566091,
0.5072335005,
-0.5118670464,
0.3033052087,
0.9583188295,
0.1983749419,
0.6084265113,
-0.3705298007,
0.8555143476,
-0.2866235971,
0.01784591,
-0.4309285879,
-0.0374711938,
-0.6388088465,
-0.158758536,
0.2672732472,
0.7221410871,
-1.0502957106,
0.6610420346,
0.1541821212,
-0.1032277718,
-0.306406945,
-0.1207171753,
0.5393895507,
0.1339692622,
0.5030111074,
-0.1376597434,
-0.452878654,
-0.6667329669,
-0.1588959545,
0.0608105622,
0.1719159484,
0.3132706881,
0.6604995131,
-0.163107425,
0.6907969713,
-0.6271005273,
-0.2085508853,
-0.4388221502,
0.4096496403,
0.4277947247,
0.4708101451,
-0.0406651869,
-0.4046262503,
-0.5123174191,
0.2057473809,
-0.9320295453,
0.1403459162,
-0.1813172251,
-0.1211208031,
0.2535271645,
0.5938405991,
-0.5261152387,
0.1964695305,
0.1900742352,
-0.1580254138,
0.5676371455,
-0.3810096383,
0.3076853454,
-0.798827529,
0.0919497237,
-0.1892476976,
-0.3817517161,
-0.4179125428,
0.2973132432,
0.0325105526,
-0.1496265829,
-0.5159409046,
0.8523942828,
-0.2807144821,
-0.0527527742,
-0.6407964826,
-0.046037212,
-0.2227425426,
0.9802886248,
0.3188223839,
0.6417411566,
0.347139746,
-0.9301419854,
0.5975868106,
0.0517318435,
-0.3808153272,
0.2386205345,
-0.6604373455,
0.0020325005,
0.0573407337,
0.287765801,
-0.300580591,
-0.2153276354,
0.1112129092,
-0.3663322628,
0.3059264719,
0.1141884178,
-0.3502167165,
-0.5280719995,
-0.154204011,
0.3793645203,
0.8822449446,
-0.5552547574,
0.2179695815,
0.3248356283,
-0.3003129661,
-0.76178056,
-0.0761976317,
-0.3028647006,
-0.1248944476,
-0.1505217701,
0.2332898676,
-0.1427140832,
-0.0998004228,
-0.1522736549,
0.2411801964,
-0.094868876,
0.2382366061,
0.0500361174,
0.106930159,
0.0828092843,
0.0809225589,
0.0300419666,
-0.264479965,
0.1347095519,
-0.2914762795,
0.7182971239,
0.1360706687,
-0.3613964915,
-0.5526053309,
0.2248855978,
0.4870583117,
-0.3671278358,
0.6009576321,
0.3566821218,
-0.2058006078,
-0.7285996079,
-0.3269322515,
-0.3584993482,
-0.4767971933,
0.670230031,
-0.3406342864,
-1.0176222324,
0.2103766799,
-0.2949894667,
0.1429331452,
0.1913155615,
0.7287072539,
-0.0241319146,
1.1581492424,
0.6035035253,
-0.3994579315,
0.5843004584,
-0.4399292469,
0.0394714512,
-0.501383841,
-0.3672897518,
-0.5251786709,
-0.0822372735,
-0.0574736111,
-0.5139460564,
0.3921350837,
0.1246645674,
-0.7672060728,
0.3362414837,
-0.392249316,
0.4148608148,
0.7397943735,
0.080745019,
0.3241808712,
-0.0282553807,
-0.2348861098,
0.3517986536,
-0.9259006381,
-0.1287296712,
0.7889021635,
0.4973853528,
0.9547962546,
-0.2679681778,
0.7693330646,
0.6116541028,
0.0044928994,
-1.0237429142,
0.6291368604,
0.3069037497,
-0.1512577236,
-0.499468416,
-0.6472848654,
-0.8688488603,
-0.0824194476,
-0.1587841511,
-0.3068138659,
-0.217952773,
0.1942623556,
-0.3915678859,
0.1637851447,
-0.2935364842,
0.7906066179,
-0.4503273964,
-0.2790894508,
-0.637963295,
-0.4015513361,
0.4232824147,
-0.0353292823,
0.2449002117,
0.0602199882,
0.0430013128,
0.8073478341,
-0.6637642384,
0.4034333825,
-0.5395146608,
-0.3876621723,
0.1773825139,
0.1659720838,
1.0906918049,
-0.2188474834,
0.0457816906,
-0.36199072,
-0.5269517899,
-0.3355039358,
-0.7975216508,
0.6646440625,
-0.7755860686,
-0.3031277061,
-0.5084217787,
-0.7315927744,
-0.1922872812,
-0.0000325244,
-0.1357620358,
0.1529905796,
-0.1195051596,
-0.0734106749,
0.9901317358,
-0.6541870236,
0.5626578927,
0.619780302,
-0.3710855246,
-0.5926997662,
1.0120099783,
-0.1686116755,
0.243181318,
0.7471884489,
0.047550343,
-0.385215193,
-0.0976003185,
-0.3836981952,
0.2585504353,
-0.5051298141,
-0.3824950755,
-0.53445822,
-0.447910428,
0.0077083497,
-0.4549563229,
-0.3534953594,
-0.3393600285,
0.1942130029,
0.1498475075,
0.4583759606,
0.8311881423,
-0.0483792052,
0.378582418,
-0.7218831778,
0.3160158396,
0.4464780986,
-0.0068085985,
0.1500747204,
-0.6048480272,
-0.7744171023,
0.1121725887,
-0.2459406257,
-0.6864509583,
0.4827080071,
-0.1774971336,
0.6302679181,
0.4169898033,
0.0690973848,
0.2744224072,
-0.6485210061,
0.5759096146,
0.4121919572,
-0.8132410645,
0.5640694499,
-0.3833875954,
0.3543903828,
0.3011315167,
0.6168665886,
-0.4715171754,
-0.2486615032,
-0.4673472643,
-0.8217226267,
0.8406928182,
-0.2926518023,
-0.3137860596,
0.0169804059,
-0.040610712,
0.1500650942,
0.3562630117,
-0.7613910437,
0.1356626004,
0.1149076447,
-0.3133236468,
-0.0663280934,
-0.0932113379,
0.0546333604,
-0.0458601788,
1.1214648485,
-0.2680350244,
0.469281733,
-0.1284350753,
-0.3662733436,
-0.1004469767,
0.4935816228,
0.6714676023,
0.3725107312,
-0.0800032839,
-0.2185703218,
0.1922743618,
0.1056091934,
0.5326773524,
0.0129486779,
-0.172982052,
-0.4482715726,
0.1658011228,
0.9499611855,
0.3328507245,
-0.9872717857,
0.5302839279,
0.2546808124,
-0.3789844811,
-0.4450992644,
0.3349301517,
-0.1529186666,
0.4767490029,
0.3655713201,
-0.1673513502,
-0.1631180197,
-0.4319801629,
0.2269240469,
0.5556963682,
-0.3335349858,
-0.0474530607,
0.4942705631,
0.1137448996,
-0.2266592383,
0.4595824778,
-0.415676862,
-0.7238512039,
0.6862412095,
0.4768098593,
0.8856466413,
-0.3473550975,
0.2820031047,
0.6264022589,
0.0072399545,
-0.5626915097,
0.346467644,
-0.1695384085,
-0.4757795632,
-1.1421691179,
-0.6200883985,
-0.4985480309,
0.1280405968,
-0.502522707,
0.1557551622,
-0.6383190155,
0.1846001297,
-0.5420469046,
0.0036411618,
-0.5082939267,
-0.0331336707,
0.1254700571,
1.0197933912,
-0.5900165439,
0.8264855742,
0.5614444017,
-0.5250295401,
-1.1695450544,
-0.34371683,
-0.401633203,
-0.7585826516,
1.1653856039,
0.0426458791,
-0.1542491615,
0.2203667015,
-0.5894503593,
-0.7424671054,
1.1054837704,
-0.1673619598,
-0.7238609791,
-0.2642859221,
-0.1397905648,
0.1722738892,
-0.3939448297,
0.4754279554,
0.1728748828,
0.5039619207,
0.1608253419,
-1.1578851938,
0.0390445367,
-0.0744457468,
-0.0957661569,
0.4003631771,
-0.4428247809,
0.8375663757,
-0.252271384,
0.0625368729,
0.1123608276,
0.8053021431,
0.6122260094,
0.180111751,
0.4890722334,
0.6348859668,
0.7984033823,
0.176621139,
0.7939486504,
-0.2307656258,
0.4866240919,
0.9141928554,
-0.5238007307,
0.9052137733,
0.1408814937,
-0.1733186841,
0.7252175212,
0.5316671133,
0.1525331736,
0.7111085653,
0.4881073534,
-0.2848828137,
-0.2527967393,
-0.21903418,
-0.2856847644,
0.1119165346,
0.2434772849,
-0.3616636992,
-0.2456928641,
0.4991022646,
-0.068301253,
0.0307901949,
-0.8626623154,
0.8403743505,
0.1057710946,
-0.8586742878,
0.8805325627,
0.0633707345,
0.8207980394,
-0.7574229836,
-0.2442419529,
-0.013236152,
0.2704895437,
0.0453989953,
-0.5370132923,
-0.1481463909,
-0.0767260715,
-0.1198389232,
-0.4694833457,
0.6275222898,
-0.6238144636,
0.0272943284,
0.2535690963,
0.5503549576,
0.0848065689,
-0.0605140738,
-0.8154255748,
-0.3453886211,
-0.1137670651,
-0.2245011479,
0.325846523,
0.4657171369,
-0.0795967877,
0.8338651061,
0.6180570722,
0.1597192138,
-0.0749201104,
-0.0955937058,
0.8314907551,
-0.9615377188,
-0.7438367605,
-0.7006003857,
0.5332493186,
-0.0739811063,
0.2022111416,
0.5822413564,
0.468251735,
0.8174148202,
-0.3337647915,
0.9131025076,
-0.0384525284,
0.6780744195,
-0.9521132708,
0.5559997559,
-0.5543855429,
0.1340901703,
-0.0171585307,
-0.8134855628,
-0.0317343846,
0.6590035558,
-0.4019160271,
0.1395272017,
0.9071514606,
0.865134716,
0.0623726659,
-0.3048171103,
0.3836871088,
0.2769472599,
0.0823733583,
1.0975118876,
1.2514749765,
-0.0824832097,
0.2385838032,
-0.0938149765,
-0.3767928183,
-0.3667889535,
-0.7095918059,
-0.9676460624,
-0.3459761143,
-0.0939196125,
-0.4722648561,
0.2136683464,
1.4660927057,
0.5906048417,
-0.6773279309,
-0.4853484333,
-0.244570002,
0.2914346159,
-0.4295443594,
-0.2537298203,
0.3601647317,
-0.718049705,
-0.6497898698,
0.812096417,
0.197854504,
-0.2476054728,
-0.4941727221,
-0.6966943145,
-0.1102907285,
-0.1129623279,
0.6701981425,
0.6500174999,
-0.3908594251,
0.1229056492,
0.1856651008,
-0.1256911755,
-0.1403817981,
1.0680916309,
-1.1478629112,
-0.0790629983,
0.6366403699,
0.8808829188,
0.4133284986,
-0.0663512647,
0.7162582278,
-0.3207131624,
0.1291491985,
0.2552851737,
0.2739233077,
-0.0318690687,
-0.2275047898,
0.3196383715,
-0.0010503952,
-0.9385679364,
-0.6810930371,
0.5575672388,
-0.9011009336,
-0.403863132,
1.2041474581,
-0.2254150212,
-0.3989890218,
-0.0232205167,
-0.2659742236,
0.2011245638,
-0.6636590958,
0.6157830954,
0.1222062558,
0.0203654841,
-0.1966236532,
-0.5245960951,
0.8086022735,
0.4506749511,
-1.0456515551,
-0.0249662399,
0.3436910212,
-0.0969134271,
-0.0951960832,
0.6308427453,
0.2001354694,
0.4454675615,
-0.3742325306,
0.5245607495,
-0.3443125784,
-0.5208054781,
-0.5259093642,
0.2327620387,
0.3440449834,
0.1133101955
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07051v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07051v1
|
$L^*LM$: Learning Automata from Examples using Natural Language Oracles
| 2024-02-10T21:46:34 | 2024-02-10T21:46:34 |
Marcell Vazquez-Chanlatte, Karim Elmaaroufi, Stefan J. Witwicki, Sanjit A. Seshia
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.FL
|
Expert demonstrations have proven an easy way to indirectly specify complex
tasks. Recent algorithms even support extracting unambiguous formal
specifications, e.g. deterministic finite automata (DFA), from demonstrations.
Unfortunately, these techniques are generally not sample efficient. In this
work, we introduce $L^*LM$, an algorithm for learning DFAs from both
demonstrations and natural language. Due to the expressivity of natural
language, we observe a significant improvement in the data efficiency of
learning DFAs from expert demonstrations. Technically, $L^*LM$ leverages large
language models to answer membership queries about the underlying task. This is
then combined with recent techniques for transforming learning from
demonstrations into a sequence of labeled example learning problems. In our
experiments, we observe the two modalities complement each other, yielding a
powerful few-shot learner.
|
[
-0.1860142797,
-1.2698725462,
0.6819597483,
-0.2000616193,
-0.3705614805,
0.2666866481,
0.0908152163,
-0.5322940946,
0.1725135297,
0.3556684852,
-0.5702399015,
-0.3156549633,
-0.4247405827,
0.0968981162,
-0.4736672342,
0.6034500003,
-0.1756540388,
-0.0028075578,
0.0377165563,
0.1539719552,
-0.0280130301,
-0.2251973897,
-0.8867541552,
-0.4633217156,
0.4488548636,
0.3479169011,
0.6382900476,
0.9253774881,
0.1941708922,
0.3781030476,
0.3739703,
0.4851778746,
-0.2377633005,
0.0016874772,
0.0744739994,
-0.6154110432,
-0.0625243187,
0.2243758887,
0.6532949209,
0.621505022,
-0.0649924576,
-0.0290669035,
-0.2768284678,
0.7950900197,
-0.4454995692,
0.6292102933,
-0.4891238511,
0.2738905251,
0.0227112193,
-0.1539975852,
-0.5305563807,
-0.5299175382,
-0.0211093314,
-0.7368349433,
-0.3118362427,
-0.0591176003,
0.6963916421,
0.5276901722,
-0.2454631776,
-0.3745747507,
-0.9269896746,
0.7688234448,
-0.7477372289,
0.2145251036,
0.3187048733,
0.8098886013,
-0.3857501149,
-0.7622602582,
-0.7268720269,
-0.322224766,
-0.1075779647,
-0.1708526611,
-0.2940620482,
0.1276385486,
0.4565481842,
0.4841011763,
-0.2787027061,
0.4619788229,
-0.1044704616,
-0.1614681631,
0.8899043798,
0.2773889303,
0.1714390069,
0.1212097704,
-0.3100442886,
-0.3051094711,
-0.6840164065,
-0.0109309573,
0.310346067,
0.2015565485,
0.0005700157,
0.3615380824,
-0.2236862183,
0.922536552,
0.0830116048,
-0.365257144,
-0.0532069467,
0.0128183952,
-0.5761865377,
-0.3908674419,
0.8098080158,
-0.1833512634,
0.1692973524,
-0.2049698532,
-0.1900098473,
-0.1312805265,
0.0013421462,
-0.7636517882,
-0.6119448543,
0.0515027232,
-0.3489979506,
-0.1122491062,
0.0571003668,
-0.7477393746,
-0.4318746328,
-0.5929306149,
0.8979521394,
-0.221191898,
-0.1079832464,
0.0674517676,
0.0429214388,
0.3133178055,
0.4238431454,
-0.6978004575,
0.5334716439,
0.7725018859,
0.2876466215,
0.0727638677,
-0.1289630383,
-0.9416485429,
-0.1510786265,
-0.4511154294,
0.5461257696,
-0.2173096538,
0.0459903926,
0.0104662497,
-0.2989120185,
-0.2113376558,
-0.6443689466,
0.1306715608,
-0.5850982666,
0.3068460524,
-0.0008003819,
-0.9374376535,
-0.5345919132,
-0.1048166752,
-0.7425092459,
0.8573232889,
-0.049140919,
-0.1014155969,
0.4720824659,
-0.6786649823,
-0.4418289065,
0.038597893,
-0.5777344704,
-0.3856193423,
-0.0356180258,
-0.0424942113,
0.767801702,
-0.086834453,
0.0082263425,
-0.136327818,
-0.158086434,
0.2194099277,
-0.3927006423,
0.5758091807,
0.3470873535,
-0.6531373858,
0.035333965,
-0.7617273927,
-0.1276800483,
0.2092497796,
-0.2648847103,
-0.4574971497,
0.2107700408,
-0.4466873109,
0.2122762054,
0.1384996027,
-0.3269089758,
0.4672377706,
-0.7478666902,
0.0425292514,
0.5628784299,
0.1306215078,
0.534671545,
-0.2929987311,
0.3008615375,
-0.2807966471,
0.0345339552,
-0.1530291885,
-0.3344749808,
-0.9338204265,
-0.4869465232,
-0.0366875865,
0.3974265754,
-0.9448051453,
0.3596439362,
0.2290793359,
-0.4643708467,
-0.5310419202,
0.5005528331,
0.5961509943,
0.4093326628,
0.3981199265,
-0.2431477755,
-0.5168710947,
-0.9413434267,
-0.249687925,
-0.4186632037,
0.1213304549,
0.2846209705,
0.2628846467,
-0.0454806909,
0.8273381591,
-0.4273629189,
-0.2006428391,
-0.3561224341,
0.6283397079,
0.3078772724,
0.2589895427,
0.6168888211,
-0.5349186659,
-0.5832294226,
-0.1483690888,
-0.6836763024,
0.1263220906,
-0.3989813626,
-0.0241383594,
0.4614160359,
0.546004653,
-0.4446869791,
0.2917697132,
0.1524950713,
-0.1972933859,
0.3211253583,
-0.1863175035,
-0.0760653093,
-0.865106225,
-0.4032872617,
-0.1495818943,
-0.5568111539,
-0.7235478759,
0.4946414828,
-0.1637889892,
0.3434948325,
-0.6491898298,
0.6503573656,
-0.7014625072,
-0.2157398462,
-0.571320951,
-0.1243166551,
-0.4296197593,
0.4619431198,
0.2616384923,
0.4603313804,
0.731919229,
-0.9580703974,
0.2854028046,
-0.0387152582,
-0.3727133274,
0.1212550029,
-0.1926090866,
0.3577622175,
-0.1083925739,
-0.0562351085,
-0.7247372866,
-0.2761184275,
0.1778658032,
0.0181333795,
0.3624778986,
0.1104546711,
-0.6882379651,
-0.2618492544,
-0.069546856,
-0.0367896482,
0.8665816188,
-0.6816933155,
0.6741412878,
0.4225786626,
0.3144342899,
-0.6368831396,
-0.3147366047,
-0.0358183831,
-0.0962812901,
-0.0212072749,
-0.0964300036,
-0.1585991681,
-0.5960667133,
-0.2970676124,
-0.0493156761,
-0.2460255027,
0.552030623,
0.1845051348,
-0.1366698444,
-0.1480078995,
0.2253498435,
-0.0316293649,
0.0044931257,
0.1630807221,
0.0529229157,
0.5012643337,
-0.0325442068,
-0.6157045364,
-0.8572636247,
0.2775683105,
0.40181005,
0.1168458387,
0.3311523497,
0.4856085181,
-0.560506165,
-0.5560607314,
-0.3524111509,
-0.4634073079,
-0.4860959351,
0.4086561203,
-0.324165225,
-0.5740593672,
0.1129911616,
-0.1427135617,
0.6250349879,
0.3506398499,
0.487523526,
-0.2133110017,
0.8175374866,
0.7260495424,
-0.2654098868,
0.3905803859,
-0.4604492188,
-0.0526713096,
0.1223965958,
-0.0535002202,
-0.4365741313,
-0.3630054295,
0.0289970804,
-0.7926322222,
0.128447473,
0.1284172088,
-0.1609634012,
0.5350788236,
0.0652546063,
0.710056603,
0.4127888083,
0.2406259626,
0.472258985,
0.0618716665,
0.0113658542,
-0.0814702809,
-0.6262646914,
-0.6450632215,
0.6925548911,
0.5076355338,
0.9417068362,
0.2883693874,
1.1129660606,
0.3194727004,
0.5077314377,
-1.0392010212,
0.7486834526,
-0.3392415345,
-0.2798898518,
-0.2935110629,
-0.4303329587,
-0.8235811591,
-0.1331651807,
-0.2791593671,
-0.4191099405,
0.0942571312,
0.3007890582,
-0.3109775186,
0.329552412,
-0.3354774714,
0.6402544975,
-0.3016938269,
-0.1547406465,
-0.4522178769,
-0.4623475075,
0.5393884778,
-0.1202207431,
0.4832603335,
-0.112185128,
-0.0710751191,
0.6720965505,
-0.4335086346,
1.265643239,
-0.3719176352,
-0.4228028059,
0.3493466377,
0.4817472696,
0.5497487783,
-0.0666087866,
-0.0179064423,
-0.4877300858,
-0.4235930443,
-0.2670821249,
-0.8508811593,
0.3005984128,
-0.7030257583,
-0.4965572655,
-0.138003543,
-0.481449306,
-0.146501556,
-0.0957667679,
-0.1746021062,
0.4124515057,
-0.342348218,
-0.2556889951,
0.7568560243,
0.0652098507,
0.7559370995,
0.8221564293,
-0.2868478,
-0.0003999388,
0.8065520525,
-0.0621756166,
0.467831701,
0.7898011804,
0.1230940893,
-0.3490615785,
-0.5719580054,
-0.5697577596,
0.0795953646,
-0.8449698091,
-0.1393010765,
-0.6199093461,
-0.0159162171,
0.039304819,
0.0836909786,
-0.3443312943,
-0.7028964758,
-0.4372582734,
-0.3593657911,
0.3842639923,
0.9447200298,
-0.0482584424,
0.2280058116,
-0.6498107314,
0.4899282455,
0.8749829531,
-0.1041876897,
-0.0044834432,
-0.3688547611,
-0.1690205187,
-0.0100273052,
-0.1232113317,
-1.0126651525,
0.4145736694,
0.7128962874,
1.0854736567,
0.619717598,
0.0459357016,
0.7143886685,
-0.5199478865,
0.6221510768,
-0.0909038633,
-0.8596901298,
0.3923821449,
0.0231268127,
-0.1173625067,
0.6739349961,
0.7135891318,
-0.0194504857,
-0.5279381275,
-0.4781908989,
-0.5950152278,
0.3629007339,
-0.1737994254,
0.1008086875,
-0.1121389866,
0.5019222498,
0.4898097217,
-0.0280508436,
-0.7304509878,
-0.498991698,
0.0833072215,
-0.3990630209,
-0.2299383283,
0.0366052464,
-0.2164061069,
-0.226530686,
0.6585969329,
-0.3046374321,
0.177063942,
0.2423806936,
-0.5689826012,
-0.1189060435,
0.1863755286,
0.5040004849,
0.4286212921,
0.016930664,
0.4433580637,
0.0329210386,
-0.149840042,
0.3102958202,
0.1264015138,
-0.2047828585,
0.0641287044,
0.3429583013,
0.8726964593,
0.3100365996,
-0.7337113023,
0.2556772828,
0.0253391843,
-0.3432397842,
-0.4522790313,
0.2981974483,
-0.1016431376,
0.3772422075,
0.6935449243,
-0.3751300573,
0.2517422736,
-0.8833316565,
0.6944159865,
0.4755797386,
-0.4467669129,
-0.2193245888,
0.6113902926,
0.1610501856,
-0.4816423655,
0.1035884842,
-0.405112654,
-0.4112657011,
0.7240602374,
0.3722484708,
0.887547195,
-0.0570508875,
0.2476622462,
0.4374217987,
0.2272301167,
-0.2281067818,
0.3509513736,
-0.3147138655,
-0.5877792239,
-0.5651271939,
-0.6042281389,
-0.6522470117,
0.061847005,
-0.3754776716,
0.1425632238,
-0.6358193755,
0.363201052,
0.212150231,
0.1582690924,
-0.563141942,
0.0116768014,
0.2173378766,
1.1378289461,
-1.1887537241,
0.9051434398,
0.6376754045,
-0.383310318,
-0.9873669744,
-0.1815517247,
0.0039475588,
-0.7579179406,
0.8488123417,
0.0775176287,
-0.0613839626,
0.1161856502,
-0.5391213298,
-0.3556183577,
0.8833582997,
0.2810868025,
-0.5348635316,
0.2440256625,
0.1010424271,
0.5319113135,
-0.5659240484,
0.3683244288,
0.5704519153,
0.4172364175,
-0.2759242654,
-0.9099900126,
0.0909091756,
0.009033761,
-0.7071006298,
0.1357407123,
-0.3944572508,
0.8269019127,
-0.2656797767,
-0.3345816433,
0.3123110235,
0.9580808878,
0.1020634696,
0.4271932244,
0.7834213376,
0.3767212629,
0.7709664106,
0.0016026042,
1.0173103809,
0.1965146512,
0.1401085109,
1.0488455296,
-0.3121097684,
0.9858535528,
0.4369164109,
-0.3442266583,
0.8524464369,
0.5920653343,
0.2423701137,
0.4526017606,
0.3002617657,
-0.4479317665,
-0.628585875,
0.3806613684,
0.0009834635,
0.487200588,
0.3882252574,
-0.416832,
-0.4937282503,
-0.0677797496,
-0.0085150572,
0.551235795,
-0.4242031574,
1.2869359255,
0.1662938446,
-0.4853495061,
0.6818393469,
-0.1839701235,
0.6941151023,
-0.3837406933,
-0.5113828182,
-0.1714499742,
0.0635828003,
-0.0865467563,
-0.4167114794,
0.3460689485,
-0.1683309227,
0.0623729825,
-0.2231693715,
0.5235232115,
-0.4812714159,
-0.3065671623,
0.1834196895,
0.7602145076,
0.7722350359,
0.3079878986,
-0.6162993312,
-0.514488101,
-0.1563251764,
-0.0000199649,
0.3939706683,
0.0662767962,
-0.0663429275,
0.7049571872,
0.4126412868,
-0.2019839287,
0.1711180359,
-0.0377730504,
0.6610327363,
-0.4992008805,
-0.202205047,
-0.8306556344,
0.2637406886,
-0.0415088795,
0.1523340642,
0.6377068162,
0.5418234468,
0.5693697333,
-0.4312283993,
0.5347029567,
0.0381613001,
0.7054876089,
-0.8353312016,
0.6503303647,
-0.4949537218,
0.2798437476,
-0.0275614709,
-0.6042935252,
-0.2368390262,
0.6447938085,
0.0722430125,
-0.2686656713,
0.4585328996,
0.6330949664,
-0.1133792326,
-0.2052870095,
0.4486134648,
0.3286288083,
0.2916562557,
0.7887514234,
0.7882965207,
-0.3617143035,
0.263566941,
-0.6940755248,
-0.3940624595,
-0.1093785539,
-1.0610064268,
-1.0247163773,
-0.3943008482,
-0.5508748293,
0.1781128943,
0.0963102356,
1.2763576508,
0.8092137575,
-0.7797424197,
-0.3025492132,
-0.1806075126,
0.3447789252,
-0.5069202185,
-0.1974570453,
0.4001597464,
-0.4959329665,
-1.1394197941,
0.9617462754,
-0.056999661,
0.2289197594,
-0.5276620984,
-0.2350883931,
-0.1056560725,
0.2460030466,
0.542578876,
0.8220047951,
-0.6013560891,
-0.2303849161,
0.0756067485,
-0.0217712019,
-0.2371702343,
0.6003074646,
-1.1009590626,
0.2509352267,
0.5084796548,
0.8458035588,
0.2905440331,
-0.1536206603,
0.6997292042,
-0.7078825235,
0.12738581,
0.1499032676,
0.3722682297,
0.0514566228,
-0.2132063061,
0.4576534927,
0.110715732,
-0.3924307823,
-0.7700499892,
0.6404214501,
-1.0132676363,
-0.2602338493,
1.0278195143,
-0.3181513846,
-0.1935912073,
-0.5293239951,
-0.1956270933,
0.2617722452,
-0.2173951119,
0.9086150527,
0.1642738283,
-0.2839288712,
-0.3583316505,
-0.5934885144,
0.8895941377,
0.4448944926,
-1.1031856537,
-0.0374177694,
0.3970969915,
0.1874502748,
0.0591109656,
0.5973846316,
-0.083815366,
0.5826590061,
-0.3067756891,
0.0768569708,
-0.2611801326,
-0.3184991181,
-0.588219583,
0.0688530728,
0.3836694956,
-0.0889839828
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07043v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07043v2
|
A Tale of Tails: Model Collapse as a Change of Scaling Laws
| 2024-02-10T21:06:34 | 2024-05-31T12:27:52 |
Elvis Dohmatob, Yunzhen Feng, Pu Yang, Francois Charton, Julia Kempe
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
As AI model size grows, neural scaling laws have become a crucial tool to
predict the improvements of large models when increasing capacity and the size
of original (human or natural) training data. Yet, the widespread use of
popular models means that the ecosystem of online data and text will co-evolve
to progressively contain increased amounts of synthesized data. In this paper
we ask: How will the scaling laws change in the inevitable regime where
synthetic data makes its way into the training corpus? Will future models,
still improve, or be doomed to degenerate up to total (model) collapse? We
develop a theoretical framework of model collapse through the lens of scaling
laws. We discover a wide range of decay phenomena, analyzing loss of scaling,
shifted scaling with number of generations, the ''un-learning" of skills, and
grokking when mixing human and synthesized data. Our theory is validated by
large-scale experiments with a transformer on an arithmetic task and text
generation using the large language model Llama2.
|
[
-0.3274453878,
-0.7479156256,
0.727304399,
-0.178618446,
0.1152643189,
0.1658190191,
-0.0994696245,
-0.4545459747,
0.2364798486,
0.8858909011,
-0.6615100503,
0.3194134235,
-0.7082692385,
0.1135427952,
-1.049672246,
1.2014225721,
0.2137206197,
0.0593218617,
-0.269256562,
0.064847514,
-0.3098180294,
-0.4587212503,
-0.7504894137,
-0.6357086301,
0.2250619084,
0.2285806686,
0.8140961528,
1.1198266745,
0.269430697,
0.2614804208,
-0.3161818981,
-0.0973597765,
-0.7047136426,
0.2390129715,
0.0326365344,
-0.9943483472,
-0.370334059,
0.0566698201,
0.7916817069,
0.9846847057,
-0.2702123225,
-0.1308530569,
0.2112732232,
0.9177775383,
-0.0809439644,
-0.0258158576,
-0.6757768393,
-0.1855343282,
0.186794281,
-0.0074437796,
-0.3641809821,
-0.1530819237,
-0.0367849283,
-0.5919120312,
0.4909738898,
-0.2282499969,
0.7749193311,
0.3197676539,
-0.5810613632,
-0.1385201067,
-0.8328968883,
0.6659557223,
-0.6705875993,
0.2175929993,
0.288882643,
0.4138536751,
-0.2264287919,
-0.9558226466,
-0.6274164915,
-0.2136611193,
0.1378071755,
-0.0519719459,
-0.5964432955,
-0.1309581399,
0.2928782105,
0.3059951663,
-0.2165415138,
0.2504405975,
-0.6225757599,
0.2720127404,
0.5695630908,
0.5188476443,
0.5831344724,
0.0445802324,
0.0513745807,
-0.4864988923,
-0.9354576468,
-0.325121671,
0.679145515,
0.4895347357,
-0.1495235115,
0.3893706799,
0.0668774247,
0.2501624823,
0.5183196664,
-0.2057963014,
-0.0097341584,
-0.1095789894,
-0.1530114412,
0.2184129655,
0.5597447157,
0.6975790262,
0.3438864946,
-0.2257712334,
-0.1419936866,
-0.16388385,
0.4135311842,
-0.7872607112,
-0.0837872028,
0.0816419795,
-0.660852015,
-0.6269965172,
-0.2151960582,
-0.5739091039,
-0.9255368114,
-0.3579932153,
0.6670347452,
-0.256172806,
-0.7544839978,
0.2347926497,
-0.3087956607,
-0.0847772956,
0.1999674439,
-1.1615560055,
0.6110166311,
0.6681608558,
0.8631677032,
0.2668018043,
-0.5580201149,
-0.259719491,
-0.2468063533,
-0.5396516919,
0.0840875208,
-0.1030988023,
-0.4441206455,
0.122142911,
0.2218239605,
0.0912027583,
-0.5648602247,
0.0601162575,
-0.4894409478,
-0.3630161285,
-0.1316384822,
-0.4328225851,
-0.2697880566,
0.0885306224,
-0.9616555572,
0.4176147282,
-0.1726724654,
-0.6989697218,
0.4558333158,
-0.4745711982,
-0.5295652747,
-0.2350052148,
0.0376744568,
-0.6304828525,
0.3109281361,
-0.2109087557,
0.4542518258,
-0.6173974872,
0.2808278203,
-0.4863691032,
-0.3203075528,
0.1478366554,
-0.370768398,
1.0874809027,
0.0474213995,
-0.0763508156,
-0.2138450295,
-0.805090785,
-0.2598560154,
0.5208106041,
-0.0954330117,
-0.2072121799,
0.4388194978,
-0.0514330566,
-0.1661545634,
-0.0462707542,
-0.4333994389,
0.4317601919,
-0.237751022,
1.1257234812,
0.3757427633,
0.3319753706,
0.6681429148,
-0.5140150189,
0.3269645572,
-0.0300688501,
-0.0388374999,
-0.3423164785,
-0.3464413881,
-0.810082376,
0.3197848499,
0.1668183208,
0.0311303642,
-0.1085903943,
0.2241857648,
-0.5078534484,
-0.7292180061,
-0.2220852524,
-0.2642536163,
-0.3096313179,
0.460095048,
0.3024622202,
0.1092331558,
-0.6952248216,
-0.8071966171,
-0.2327439189,
-0.3963790536,
-0.3030696511,
-0.1686548442,
0.744577527,
-0.5053144693,
1.0171329975,
-0.250647366,
-0.0343046747,
-0.5012392998,
0.453261435,
0.1568779647,
0.5323048234,
0.4633733332,
-0.6799432635,
0.0914476961,
0.1022355407,
-0.6027210951,
0.3018656671,
-0.5156315565,
0.4402556717,
0.0604484975,
0.5500409007,
-0.5791780949,
0.2914470136,
0.4057212472,
-0.0668530315,
0.9522503018,
-0.5751657486,
-0.0244724434,
-0.942866087,
-0.3182224631,
-0.1503681391,
0.227411598,
-0.7813312411,
-0.0174269658,
0.2499678433,
-0.03503941,
-0.0635013357,
0.2414427847,
-0.3482730687,
-0.2114836425,
-0.3530869186,
-0.1919681132,
-0.108838819,
-0.0415530019,
0.0955133364,
0.6681212783,
0.6332555413,
-0.8151741028,
0.0172440968,
0.106177941,
-0.0406911783,
0.1329207867,
-0.8567715883,
-0.1280740649,
-0.0916196853,
0.2245210856,
-0.8033328652,
-0.479952544,
-0.5858930349,
-0.5466588736,
0.3522231877,
-0.3471117616,
-0.7142547965,
-0.1524031311,
-0.4332895577,
0.2286702693,
0.8508209586,
-0.7466051579,
0.7123391032,
0.2773705125,
0.2933912575,
-0.3564843535,
-0.9969266653,
0.4310975373,
-0.4575699866,
-0.8466877937,
0.0889134854,
-0.0214725081,
-0.6854545474,
-0.1161403954,
0.0197566114,
-0.2187371999,
0.1708122492,
0.4381601214,
0.0073074596,
-0.3776826859,
0.278606534,
0.5030046701,
0.2530174553,
0.5661444068,
-0.2664769888,
0.6313729882,
-0.30985111,
0.1308694035,
-0.0864062756,
-0.0321286172,
1.2546567917,
-0.1182914823,
0.8585439324,
0.1878014803,
-0.3575038016,
-0.2413498312,
-0.3028609455,
-0.412891984,
-0.4814181328,
0.5410434604,
-0.1712268442,
-0.3068262339,
0.7582363486,
-0.2023578435,
-0.1162799224,
0.8503632545,
0.5253656507,
-0.0478481539,
1.0799463987,
1.0874359608,
0.2820077538,
0.3289719224,
-0.6044793129,
0.0656266287,
-0.6816473007,
0.0851602852,
-0.2092450261,
-0.2114613801,
-0.6744030714,
0.0865750313,
0.4676460028,
0.2561882436,
-0.6600412726,
0.4848575592,
-0.3301934302,
0.7002720833,
0.3713559806,
0.1640639603,
0.4367109239,
0.0830676183,
0.4053217173,
0.0478688665,
-0.5364964008,
-0.3936005831,
1.3770536184,
0.4830441475,
0.6861072779,
-0.0646411702,
0.8184995651,
0.480604887,
-0.0147435004,
-0.7109975815,
0.3617263138,
-0.092152968,
-0.5708713531,
-0.4430675209,
-0.3175046146,
-1.0509674549,
-0.0560680851,
-0.2829104066,
-0.621278882,
0.2064097971,
-0.12182834,
-0.1774794757,
0.7928532362,
-0.5533852577,
0.4556936324,
-0.3090981245,
-0.2416555136,
-0.5049569607,
-0.7274412513,
0.4451377988,
-0.2523283362,
0.1165640652,
0.1605175436,
0.0071197255,
1.0777783394,
-0.7084668875,
1.0984703302,
0.0415247642,
-0.1082067415,
0.4288671017,
0.5163706541,
0.5049671531,
-0.0901233181,
0.1038561091,
0.3739905655,
0.1953821778,
-0.097966589,
-0.5022290945,
0.4207498431,
-0.9854579568,
-0.2250351161,
-0.2521743774,
-0.5362446308,
-0.1389128864,
0.2205876857,
0.5299293399,
0.3963026702,
-0.0431339256,
0.0096871965,
0.5707883835,
0.0468910076,
0.5180012584,
0.4304484129,
-0.2478455007,
-0.3300715685,
0.9619766474,
0.4302163422,
0.4731537998,
-0.1360545009,
0.387365371,
-0.1151349172,
-0.6241703033,
-0.435970813,
0.5186524987,
-0.7044507861,
-0.1817546785,
-0.3781817853,
-0.3463735282,
-0.2626316845,
-0.323700726,
-0.511259377,
-0.5278007388,
-0.377389431,
-0.2749178708,
0.5575028658,
1.3963012695,
-0.3986494541,
0.4358073175,
-0.5857825279,
-0.2342614979,
0.1785203218,
0.0542508885,
0.402359426,
-0.7671507597,
-0.263967067,
0.1063041538,
-0.2592645586,
-0.8000590801,
0.5801429749,
0.1234966069,
0.1779262275,
0.6633611321,
-0.0199539233,
0.4100890756,
-0.7244173288,
0.5016130209,
0.7321199179,
-0.8525429368,
0.2209463567,
-0.7513313293,
0.0031788796,
0.1376980841,
0.2789367735,
-0.7900696993,
-0.3263944387,
-0.8335769176,
-0.8639243245,
0.4497708082,
-0.1086125299,
0.5623591542,
0.1359629035,
0.5987378955,
0.5038930774,
0.0662805885,
-0.5068558455,
-0.156776458,
-0.1649782509,
0.0950984061,
0.1391719878,
-0.1934584826,
0.2591414452,
-0.2992600501,
0.2158127874,
0.0532566123,
0.1712750643,
-0.283451438,
0.0025023653,
-0.3140421808,
-0.0256181844,
0.4195346832,
0.8122794032,
-0.0555532649,
-0.0513924733,
0.0766127259,
-0.6866607666,
0.2236430049,
-0.3517203033,
-0.454678297,
-0.439350903,
0.6251454949,
0.6802608967,
0.1589320451,
-0.6885644197,
0.1943280399,
-0.0508904755,
-0.5750879645,
-0.5052612424,
0.1119656786,
0.0550519787,
0.1918500066,
0.694231987,
0.1738630384,
0.0551603213,
-0.7293625474,
0.3952065408,
-0.0200277045,
-0.0011701911,
-0.5460988879,
1.042286396,
-0.0617325492,
-0.2098910511,
0.8072432876,
0.0214720033,
-0.4218782485,
0.8917571306,
0.7661350369,
0.7308048606,
-0.1019945517,
0.359048456,
0.6638039351,
0.612177968,
-0.7345511913,
-0.4908199906,
0.1478011608,
-0.623110652,
-0.4203627706,
-0.364356041,
-0.3964868784,
0.2898677886,
-0.7346264124,
0.2317809165,
-0.6700418591,
-0.1256392449,
-0.0942732021,
-0.1567935795,
-0.1986835301,
0.2886351049,
0.1603319049,
0.6618377566,
-1.0373243093,
0.4840297699,
0.3043959737,
-1.0819228888,
-0.3173800111,
0.3325232863,
0.0949360952,
-0.7490854263,
0.819050014,
0.2502602339,
-0.1528931707,
0.0604985133,
-0.7404518723,
-1.0458507538,
1.0159283876,
0.788204968,
-0.4142338932,
-0.4145210981,
0.0433309115,
0.739041388,
-0.2685357928,
0.1999567449,
0.8106080294,
0.3091084957,
0.0041922182,
-0.9822817445,
-0.084259972,
0.1246837005,
-0.3193392456,
0.3576492369,
-0.5919653773,
1.3102887869,
-0.6399680972,
-0.2559978068,
0.1752393395,
0.520098567,
-0.3840253353,
0.144594416,
0.4377637208,
0.5013492107,
0.6273732185,
0.0595064014,
1.1341991425,
-0.1713404357,
0.4564095736,
0.7629345059,
-0.0728007853,
0.9575264454,
0.2975287735,
-0.4149983823,
0.4611602426,
0.6680315733,
-0.1491965652,
0.1280518174,
0.2399018854,
0.2500764132,
-0.3117050529,
0.1799511909,
-0.1415523887,
0.4604810178,
0.2791980207,
-0.284150809,
-0.3186600804,
0.1523076594,
0.2450488955,
0.1204026192,
-0.4855662882,
0.4759427011,
-0.0893309638,
-0.2312359959,
0.8059552908,
-0.0450003035,
0.3396952152,
-0.5160295963,
-0.095017828,
-0.3091094196,
0.3588704765,
-0.2159213871,
-0.5972871184,
0.3568863869,
-0.1549592018,
-0.2922584713,
-0.0916915461,
0.5101166964,
-0.2445367575,
-0.6245487928,
0.4581554532,
0.2990558147,
0.2695386112,
-0.1754598469,
-0.2730127573,
0.2737292945,
-0.19641231,
-0.1555116922,
0.5806018114,
0.0991447419,
0.0388278514,
0.8391093612,
0.2698406279,
0.1206486896,
0.116613172,
-0.3496539593,
0.7644660473,
-0.4936216772,
-0.5024665594,
-0.7191491127,
0.4615195692,
-0.1475162208,
-0.1419207305,
0.7311306596,
0.3373399973,
0.6295018792,
0.0546348952,
0.8370694518,
-0.1334579289,
0.2703472376,
-0.3881410956,
1.4009480476,
-0.964876771,
0.0491157509,
0.1324631423,
-0.5769611597,
-0.1439568698,
0.4586286843,
-0.2469673902,
0.0854085982,
0.7329982519,
0.2867159843,
0.0161809232,
-0.0356614105,
0.3834303021,
0.4917084575,
0.2520445585,
0.1513993442,
0.3701009452,
-0.4403537512,
0.6860429049,
-0.1527318358,
-0.1072801203,
-0.3773647249,
-0.5902639031,
-0.8076363206,
-1.0976905823,
-0.374322027,
-0.5099788308,
-0.1615466475,
0.4593435228,
0.4555343688,
-0.4242331386,
-0.5333968401,
-0.4298552871,
-0.0704233795,
-0.4878609478,
-0.1411292553,
0.433637917,
-0.4241604805,
-0.4063232243,
0.3223769963,
0.0567144603,
0.3442986608,
-0.4540291131,
-0.125400275,
0.285461247,
0.2206818461,
0.405136317,
0.5637227893,
-0.5498919487,
0.1737892926,
-0.1361861229,
0.1370159686,
0.0956356153,
0.9067713022,
-0.7599351406,
0.5234706402,
0.2735604346,
0.7086725831,
0.5420379639,
-0.2624400258,
0.6698381305,
-0.3336071968,
-0.1114354655,
0.0730867237,
0.3540211022,
0.0187415406,
-0.3026446402,
0.5799612999,
0.2266870141,
-0.4199303687,
-1.2808694839,
0.1563260108,
-0.5541890264,
-0.3825708628,
0.7981607914,
0.3525348902,
-0.519223094,
0.297426343,
0.0005276323,
0.1575105637,
-0.2878096998,
0.8585581183,
0.6355533004,
-0.3851192296,
-0.0291072465,
-0.6873221993,
0.3103325069,
0.1347559541,
-0.4327970445,
0.8080333471,
0.4772044122,
0.3448220193,
0.2554537058,
0.057125736,
-0.0079747187,
0.2911380231,
0.6337009072,
-0.062101949,
-0.161581412,
-0.3583912551,
-0.6297149062,
0.0997134671,
0.0770010874,
0.2544167638
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07028v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07028v1
|
Semi-Supervised Learning for Bilingual Lexicon Induction
| 2024-02-10T19:27:22 | 2024-02-10T19:27:22 |
Paul Garnier, Gauthier Guinet
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We consider the problem of aligning two sets of continuous word
representations, corresponding to languages, to a common space in order to
infer a bilingual lexicon. It was recently shown that it is possible to infer
such lexicon, without using any parallel data, by aligning word embeddings
trained on monolingual data. Such line of work is called unsupervised bilingual
induction. By wondering whether it was possible to gain experience in the
progressive learning of several languages, we asked ourselves to what extent we
could integrate the knowledge of a given set of languages when learning a new
one, without having parallel data for the latter. In other words, while keeping
the core problem of unsupervised learning in the latest step, we allowed the
access to other corpora of idioms, hence the name semi-supervised. This led us
to propose a novel formulation, considering the lexicon induction as a ranking
problem for which we used recent tools of this machine learning field. Our
experiments on standard benchmarks, inferring dictionary from English to more
than 20 languages, show that our approach consistently outperforms existing
state of the art benchmark. In addition, we deduce from this new scenario
several relevant conclusions allowing a better understanding of the alignment
phenomenon.
|
[
-0.3669378161,
-0.4911803603,
0.4669413865,
0.3045610189,
-0.1962441206,
0.2968107462,
-0.5545192957,
-0.3843072355,
0.2806757689,
0.2469664365,
-0.268553853,
-0.576341331,
-0.6306834817,
0.2918198407,
-0.6035941243,
0.7651255131,
-0.1638361961,
0.1898871511,
-0.593778789,
-0.4377197325,
-0.2891495526,
-0.3305089474,
-0.3846862018,
-0.5472297668,
0.2310506552,
0.5176697373,
0.6270564198,
0.710187912,
0.1219514385,
0.3335952759,
-0.246393159,
0.3291086853,
-0.195114255,
-0.1902065128,
-0.2783952355,
-0.5111507773,
-0.029609289,
-0.0194920842,
0.8749130964,
1.4437018633,
-0.2953679562,
-0.0541834086,
0.2533150017,
0.6367218494,
-0.586627543,
0.2706571817,
-0.5203958154,
0.2852643132,
-0.4030358791,
-0.1215093657,
-0.4012042582,
-0.045589149,
0.052702155,
-0.5845644474,
0.2394685,
-0.0414457656,
0.6194095612,
0.1085615456,
-0.4275408089,
-0.2604466081,
-0.6868581176,
0.7766392231,
-0.2391889542,
0.4587831497,
0.1400868595,
0.189557448,
-0.2347457409,
-0.569121778,
-0.5377137065,
0.026129391,
-0.0267471224,
0.4507447779,
0.0814039409,
-0.1512632817,
0.1089840755,
0.4039906859,
-0.5000790954,
0.5516756773,
-0.4172427058,
-0.1703797728,
0.56714499,
0.0166717526,
0.3595124185,
0.2172398865,
-0.4295616746,
0.0548911989,
-0.6909141541,
0.2559429407,
0.4557211399,
0.4449044466,
-0.2285817266,
0.7041381598,
-0.3006152213,
0.5839184523,
0.0299156792,
0.0104643721,
0.5180233121,
-0.5129396915,
0.2188678384,
0.3819995821,
0.8801634312,
0.2678649426,
0.5361871719,
-0.4784915447,
-0.3488600254,
0.2845108509,
0.0004986012,
-0.2106072754,
-0.0134374565,
-0.0785889104,
-0.0724331141,
-0.3183942735,
0.3574438691,
-0.7943322062,
-0.1594287455,
-0.3053365648,
0.270408988,
0.0255626943,
-0.2341555804,
0.0865328461,
-0.2637535334,
0.0255561043,
-0.1163082048,
-1.1665029526,
0.3352797925,
0.6297338605,
0.7474524379,
-0.483410418,
-0.615911901,
-0.3974930942,
0.1986187398,
-0.6508890986,
0.7195045352,
-0.5848473907,
-0.4598815441,
0.5249267817,
0.1905061603,
0.0217352696,
-0.7956322432,
0.2878894508,
-0.3889260292,
0.3617692292,
0.0062797298,
-0.5984148383,
0.2180983722,
-0.0100451019,
-0.4923737049,
1.1318594217,
0.1258681118,
-0.9374702573,
0.4721640646,
-0.3646012247,
-0.7338652611,
-0.0058545535,
-0.2726545632,
-0.1489142478,
0.2163851559,
0.3650068939,
0.2562157214,
-0.2297284454,
0.3368088603,
-0.2309401631,
-0.1068399623,
0.0557769649,
0.0841654688,
1.1333744526,
-0.1258022785,
-0.287099123,
-0.3158371747,
-0.4044108987,
-0.259111762,
0.0839958936,
-0.1835921705,
-0.6053879261,
-0.1408868134,
-0.3625065982,
0.0084249126,
0.3232003152,
-0.8564478755,
0.0699108019,
-0.6888205409,
0.0919213444,
0.6574171185,
-0.086008057,
0.9580539465,
-0.0176065639,
0.2470784187,
0.3221813738,
0.0699769855,
0.2224168926,
-0.4658155739,
-0.6267412901,
-0.1899414212,
0.7519158125,
0.5656316876,
-0.7607694864,
0.5701464415,
-0.2181923687,
-0.3696074784,
-0.5160996914,
0.6302127242,
0.3847372532,
0.6864516139,
0.3971384764,
-0.3357877135,
-0.4443966746,
-1.0608478785,
-0.2736555934,
0.0886387154,
-0.0121865813,
-0.2082495093,
0.30514431,
-0.2447318137,
0.8014945388,
-0.2060545087,
-0.2405658364,
-0.2875564396,
0.3255755603,
0.2672697604,
0.4461736381,
0.2995316088,
-0.7843410969,
-0.73831141,
0.2248699069,
-1.0340381861,
-0.238624692,
0.0990344584,
-0.0983301923,
0.2061779946,
0.7139719725,
-0.2640776932,
0.262679249,
0.5630977154,
0.0969515741,
0.1342122108,
-0.4720528126,
-0.3955355287,
-1.2129032612,
-0.4260942936,
0.1308030784,
-0.1633218974,
-0.5171183944,
-0.3186179698,
0.3683515191,
0.0550549813,
-0.4351470768,
0.457717061,
-0.6833304763,
-0.1151181236,
-0.183438167,
0.1304452717,
-0.3817873895,
0.4346416891,
0.2728615105,
0.7428558469,
0.9870664477,
-0.6522551179,
0.4890463352,
0.1562418938,
-0.3931979537,
0.3357407749,
-0.2754140198,
-0.1249576882,
-0.2950311899,
-0.0187150855,
-0.7706418633,
0.0445604734,
-0.2501409948,
-0.3393884301,
0.5730313659,
0.0437337458,
-0.6959620714,
-0.2589814067,
-0.2286172211,
0.5569511056,
0.500074923,
-0.9081732631,
0.1935640723,
0.8211629391,
-0.0045835902,
-0.6705995202,
-0.7187809944,
-0.1782983243,
-0.1667207479,
-0.3738088608,
0.4945898056,
0.3532609642,
-0.3459137678,
0.157029435,
-0.1855792701,
0.0924120918,
0.0364239439,
0.0728553683,
0.2524177134,
0.0201968625,
0.1442277282,
0.4193327427,
-0.3283134699,
-0.0323007144,
-0.4951451123,
0.2981020212,
-0.0128434626,
-0.3932437003,
-0.462341845,
0.5371334553,
0.4744035006,
-0.4404354692,
0.8162650466,
0.318015039,
-0.5825527906,
-0.5193046331,
-0.2333267331,
0.0939678177,
-0.415299356,
0.0861458927,
-0.1483074129,
-0.6908985376,
0.5032708049,
-0.326983273,
0.0630452484,
0.5184828043,
0.8833646178,
-0.2954027057,
1.2492315769,
0.8876900673,
-0.1614730656,
0.4541926086,
-0.2987024486,
0.2619798481,
-0.564027071,
-0.5422264934,
-0.4708168805,
-0.2501572073,
-0.9415111542,
-0.2135311067,
0.3844436109,
-0.0509090833,
0.0990016833,
0.4128993154,
-0.2133556157,
0.3819588423,
0.5799341798,
-0.0560919568,
0.2474344671,
0.0493537709,
-0.8118138909,
0.1738240868,
-0.7313329577,
-0.2596197724,
1.0982033014,
0.0002008661,
0.82154423,
-0.0210619643,
1.0551578999,
0.2000947744,
0.0619741455,
-0.6777190566,
0.3345757425,
-0.1594202518,
-0.573048234,
-0.2890317142,
-0.2264282405,
-0.9523531199,
0.0009227956,
-0.159292683,
-0.7480285764,
0.2916601598,
-0.0868121833,
-0.0145823266,
0.09764079,
-0.7448252439,
0.9669493437,
-0.4145433903,
-0.4449546933,
-0.0841893852,
-0.6182049513,
0.1393664628,
-0.2577391863,
0.3423629701,
-0.0168695394,
-0.0999512374,
0.9074963927,
-0.4710143507,
0.7032878995,
-0.2032876164,
0.0601201169,
0.0844277665,
-0.2038597316,
0.1720021069,
0.2797484994,
0.2536093295,
0.2046376616,
0.2614872158,
-0.6388890147,
-0.5249800682,
0.7565023899,
-0.7687883377,
-0.4643347859,
-0.5470062494,
-0.8263807297,
-0.6126257181,
0.1820014715,
0.4535987079,
0.3538796604,
-0.091191791,
0.0759346336,
0.7310429215,
0.0982531831,
0.437808007,
0.3415598869,
-0.3410710692,
-0.1486178637,
0.7612481117,
0.2197613269,
0.1493094563,
0.6592660546,
0.2900294065,
-0.6682428718,
-0.5125029683,
-0.3176267743,
0.4343005121,
-0.4361540675,
0.0030109577,
-0.3500564098,
-0.0896856412,
-0.3557793498,
-0.0971152857,
-0.5889279842,
-0.3938965797,
-0.0863149315,
-0.1137023717,
-0.2199554443,
0.5407243967,
-0.1169125065,
0.0341870002,
-0.7054512501,
0.30115363,
0.3726665378,
0.1409822255,
-0.3353140056,
-0.6108154058,
-0.4085510671,
0.1669119745,
-0.1731270999,
-0.8169683218,
0.1077386662,
0.1898430139,
0.9441769719,
0.7396154404,
0.1494182944,
0.6227276325,
-0.6222741604,
0.5022523403,
0.3389142156,
-0.7197147012,
0.4445380867,
-0.0660216808,
0.1147279963,
0.5586595535,
0.7291613817,
-0.4477460086,
-0.6611720324,
-0.7369365096,
-0.5514850616,
0.4046403468,
0.0114341369,
0.2574904263,
-0.1878225505,
0.0827737376,
0.3717602789,
0.0515314303,
-0.3803283572,
-0.1335654259,
0.0241939686,
-0.349932164,
-0.4556233287,
-0.1270470023,
-0.2808508575,
-0.6662644148,
0.6516326666,
-0.1091872081,
0.1517355442,
-0.1423431635,
-0.440801084,
-0.0635848865,
0.1014858112,
0.1843356043,
0.9305245876,
0.0954296887,
0.3773382902,
0.3275241852,
0.0425610952,
0.0768634379,
0.1860412359,
-0.1118742675,
0.2091490924,
0.4381302595,
0.4727062583,
0.1674052477,
-0.5955202579,
0.64842695,
0.0644718856,
-0.3207273185,
-0.4270345569,
-0.2354891449,
0.2737383842,
0.2855330408,
0.1995217353,
-0.3126674294,
-0.1884741932,
-0.7993052602,
0.2578269243,
0.6960273385,
-0.2885105312,
-0.4365007281,
0.5586099029,
0.1038579419,
-0.2242284566,
0.7736586928,
-0.2042195052,
-0.7147529125,
0.3965986669,
0.9234032631,
0.622097075,
-0.15383555,
0.2066506594,
0.3617280126,
0.231346786,
-0.3299706876,
0.1899532974,
-0.4489460588,
-1.0907999277,
-0.1998758316,
-0.6588853002,
-0.4385792613,
-0.3212610483,
-0.8329917789,
0.3603596985,
-0.149055317,
0.1957477778,
0.1847684234,
-0.105055593,
-0.5802291036,
-0.1486489624,
0.4797744155,
1.0642076731,
-1.5261905193,
1.0715806484,
1.1431298256,
-0.3089157641,
-0.6514633894,
0.0181930214,
-0.0900160223,
-0.9363253713,
0.30777511,
0.1743844599,
0.0658346266,
0.0052894168,
-0.2394236028,
-0.4092175364,
0.8608891368,
0.281493336,
-0.29972893,
-0.0466341674,
0.3179607391,
0.6687544584,
-0.450093925,
-0.1255170703,
0.6206803322,
0.2703156769,
-0.1184941679,
-0.856567502,
-0.2895439267,
-0.1789167523,
0.0609004349,
0.4963942468,
-0.3390806317,
0.4107728302,
-0.0090066241,
-0.2278526872,
-0.1069202125,
0.8918261528,
-0.1853558719,
0.4272908568,
0.6485530138,
0.8762434125,
0.7784012556,
-0.2135635018,
0.8616250753,
-0.2394627929,
0.4434504211,
0.7219681144,
-0.2160013765,
0.5937293768,
0.89026618,
-0.2544564605,
0.4646183848,
0.7659503818,
0.1748909503,
0.8076087236,
-0.06513042,
-0.3910883963,
-0.3636838496,
-0.3684996367,
-0.122177124,
0.626126647,
0.1942564547,
-0.2605860829,
-0.6068289876,
0.188355878,
-0.1389747113,
0.4837652743,
-0.3154093027,
0.8129863143,
-0.0034878226,
-0.8522224426,
0.5595628023,
-0.151429981,
0.6163721681,
-0.460465312,
0.1765094548,
-0.501347363,
0.1946078241,
-0.3659147024,
-0.8540266156,
0.1902017444,
0.0437760875,
-0.0527338013,
-0.4015681744,
0.1902965754,
-0.7127447128,
-0.6263790727,
0.471829772,
0.6954852939,
0.2066740841,
0.304813534,
-0.4102036059,
-0.4387856126,
-0.1194398776,
0.2265858054,
0.4733683169,
0.5974368453,
-0.3298399746,
0.3115925491,
0.4874802232,
0.2312097698,
0.4533823729,
0.1514842063,
0.7752999663,
-0.4233971536,
-0.5679869652,
-0.6860411763,
0.374656558,
-0.0826272145,
-0.0179176405,
0.6839423776,
0.8537452817,
1.4756207466,
0.0400146581,
0.6438735127,
-0.0318889357,
0.5912495255,
-0.4009222984,
0.2028495222,
-0.8370192647,
0.0431019068,
0.0763747171,
-1.0044571161,
-0.3899413645,
0.2311157286,
-0.2022704482,
-0.3047405779,
1.0057474375,
0.9405904412,
-0.2928960025,
-0.0496650711,
0.2613657117,
-0.1281884313,
-0.0840447098,
0.4036610126,
0.9459514618,
0.0024527232,
0.3909873068,
-0.9629217982,
-0.4405989945,
0.1592034549,
-0.681358099,
-0.9089305997,
-0.8762339354,
-0.2160870582,
-0.1587933898,
-0.0407446958,
0.829451561,
0.2047599256,
-0.924865365,
-0.4500530064,
-0.3205887079,
0.2786557376,
-0.5061869025,
-0.0932737812,
0.2506024837,
-0.6555057168,
-1.2725279331,
0.4574390054,
0.261980027,
-0.2179576755,
-0.1215822324,
-0.0579867847,
-0.6358293295,
-0.3775498867,
0.3326795101,
0.6301084161,
-0.3859086633,
-0.0904809013,
-0.1942247152,
-0.0680732727,
0.1619228125,
0.6282585263,
-0.7096953988,
0.8549740314,
0.5373778343,
0.9453598857,
0.5600479841,
-0.0841323659,
0.4462853372,
-0.8278276324,
0.4337854981,
0.1668424308,
0.6643350124,
0.2672017217,
0.0275130235,
0.2641152143,
0.3877850473,
-0.2517161071,
-0.9740623236,
0.0717974976,
-0.9219864011,
0.108511731,
1.0446304083,
0.1130336076,
-0.3663032949,
-0.0610732101,
0.3555080891,
0.6432158351,
0.0093239117,
0.6830564141,
0.5627958775,
-0.2089770287,
0.0855143666,
-0.4813655615,
0.1785358191,
0.5870183706,
-0.4541428089,
-0.0250189956,
-0.0010076276,
0.2483895421,
0.2818056047,
0.2380409539,
-0.402109623,
0.2550328374,
-0.1444399804,
0.0436809398,
0.0406577103,
-0.4768101573,
-0.394481957,
0.0090487916,
0.2119526416,
-0.6404677033
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07023v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07023v1
|
Gemini Goes to Med School: Exploring the Capabilities of Multimodal Large Language Models on Medical Challenge Problems & Hallucinations
| 2024-02-10T19:08:28 | 2024-02-10T19:08:28 |
Ankit Pal, Malaikannan Sankarasubbu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.HC, cs.LG
|
Large language models have the potential to be valuable in the healthcare
industry, but it's crucial to verify their safety and effectiveness through
rigorous evaluation. For this purpose, we comprehensively evaluated both
open-source LLMs and Google's new multimodal LLM called Gemini across Medical
reasoning, hallucination detection, and Medical Visual Question Answering
tasks. While Gemini showed competence, it lagged behind state-of-the-art models
like MedPaLM 2 and GPT-4 in diagnostic accuracy. Additionally, Gemini achieved
an accuracy of 61.45\% on the medical VQA dataset, significantly lower than
GPT-4V's score of 88\%. Our analysis revealed that Gemini is highly susceptible
to hallucinations, overconfidence, and knowledge gaps, which indicate risks if
deployed uncritically. We also performed a detailed analysis by medical subject
and test type, providing actionable feedback for developers and clinicians. To
mitigate risks, we applied prompting strategies that improved performance.
Additionally, we facilitated future research and development by releasing a
Python module for medical LLM evaluation and establishing a dedicated
leaderboard on Hugging Face for medical domain LLMs. Python module can be found
at https://github.com/promptslab/RosettaEval
|
[
-0.2210079283,
-0.8935221434,
0.9175630808,
0.1973581761,
0.0176099818,
-0.0336044915,
-0.2063917518,
-0.5235522985,
0.2899082005,
0.5169424415,
-0.7235867381,
-0.7096860409,
-0.8860694766,
0.0527359173,
-0.39621979,
1.0325473547,
0.0317794904,
0.4456618726,
-0.4372875094,
0.0242079925,
-0.3261905909,
-0.7699891329,
-0.5663684607,
-0.1869200021,
0.7045007348,
0.0432708971,
0.8535639048,
0.2623482049,
0.8121865392,
0.3398864865,
-0.1518701166,
0.0949508399,
-0.0896943882,
0.3494164348,
-0.1361009032,
-0.2867495716,
-0.4953175485,
0.0389946364,
0.352869004,
0.6801233292,
-0.3262169659,
-0.0540135801,
-0.3221206665,
0.7439332008,
-0.3982323706,
0.1310538948,
-0.4443614185,
0.0451311171,
-0.0102546783,
0.046760831,
-0.2754131258,
-0.3317217827,
0.2636274695,
-0.4579770863,
-0.1584562659,
-0.1526437104,
0.5444685221,
0.5725631118,
-0.4925345182,
-0.5588374734,
-0.360585928,
0.5668116212,
-0.418685019,
0.3023247719,
0.0851579532,
0.5188522339,
-0.3850080669,
-0.9763672948,
-0.42744115,
-0.5649033189,
0.4329158366,
0.2373799831,
0.017486237,
0.1314772666,
0.1207297742,
0.327585727,
-0.5098375678,
0.1052463502,
-0.5345855951,
-0.3418598175,
0.3165508807,
0.25761199,
0.4193726182,
-0.0872659907,
-0.1995437592,
-0.0263419412,
-0.4892369211,
-0.1276894361,
-0.0573859848,
-0.031334307,
-0.0845739543,
0.8854851127,
0.2432548851,
0.4889476895,
-0.2081203312,
-0.2387476712,
0.4370027184,
-0.1730822623,
-0.1760276556,
-0.0913283601,
0.7916601896,
0.3284754753,
0.1941848099,
-0.1213860884,
-0.1264352202,
0.4697883427,
0.6700821519,
-0.6412584782,
-0.199664399,
0.6215090752,
-0.7314989567,
-0.2774362564,
-0.2131890804,
-0.5769463778,
-0.7758184075,
-0.2392154634,
0.5819358826,
-0.5962407589,
-0.0921125114,
0.3490515947,
0.0077153952,
-0.034145914,
0.4065054059,
-0.7774256468,
0.1836875081,
0.9794566035,
0.7945709825,
-0.4079627693,
-0.1763313115,
-0.4152176976,
-0.3695967197,
-0.3479823768,
0.4733556211,
-0.3387960792,
-0.3714190125,
-0.0277202614,
-0.0145291192,
-0.1824342012,
-0.8211168051,
0.5570279956,
-0.0754216835,
0.2466301769,
0.0043107034,
-0.2863844633,
-0.0565598048,
0.5007517934,
-0.401653409,
0.713735342,
0.2451903224,
-0.4801555872,
0.0132475216,
-0.5920350552,
-0.3238198757,
-0.1241698042,
-0.3676896393,
-0.3184912801,
0.2798616588,
0.2963038385,
0.5490251184,
-0.2480029464,
0.4096240997,
-0.2393900305,
-0.2799006999,
0.5713216662,
-0.2701388001,
0.5359621048,
0.1283648312,
-0.1604358703,
0.4746963978,
-0.6737673283,
0.0051432266,
-0.0033745959,
-0.3438040912,
-0.1348232478,
-0.1261829138,
0.1398466229,
0.5025216937,
0.0690079406,
-0.3626015782,
0.2825858891,
-0.4760081768,
0.45645684,
0.5367760658,
-0.0883941352,
-0.0923564285,
-0.3343770504,
0.5976198912,
0.0991901606,
0.7611011267,
-0.1280035973,
-0.9453788996,
-0.5706814528,
-0.4172506034,
0.0288695637,
0.523322463,
-0.8657349348,
0.1379058212,
0.0802231506,
-0.5955761075,
-0.9038523436,
-0.0195548106,
0.4145935178,
0.657763958,
0.3540095985,
-0.3077286184,
-0.3234506249,
-0.8530634642,
-0.1571965218,
-0.128105849,
0.0306028072,
0.2980469465,
0.7385434508,
-0.8962829709,
0.2044461817,
-0.2706733942,
-0.3098091483,
-0.0525549389,
-0.0656069368,
0.4116151631,
0.2283507735,
0.3884700239,
-0.7029497623,
-0.1534844786,
-0.0952761248,
-0.7737098932,
0.0071030026,
-0.0204682555,
0.0659922063,
0.4252630174,
0.351069212,
-0.7606854439,
0.1978517175,
1.0235697031,
-0.4708524644,
0.7378622293,
-0.3624979258,
0.2124879658,
-1.0943578482,
0.0372941792,
0.0231942795,
-0.0547623932,
-0.4608833194,
0.0835730061,
0.0789831057,
-0.1413276196,
-0.3956682086,
0.4509013295,
-0.2544933558,
0.0691046268,
-0.3252584934,
0.2160239965,
-0.3059328794,
-0.1380928606,
-0.0813838392,
0.5924864411,
0.9496179819,
-0.350709945,
0.6314694285,
0.0473560318,
-0.4985569417,
0.4194979966,
-0.4611808062,
-0.0080174906,
-0.1350953579,
-0.0026168523,
-0.9260601401,
-0.3132919669,
0.3959189355,
-0.6492614746,
0.253051132,
0.1632741988,
-0.454241097,
-0.5724442005,
-0.3229006529,
-0.0649178177,
0.5260539651,
-0.4779986143,
0.598176837,
0.4763200283,
-0.1491550058,
-0.8053455949,
-0.5327684283,
0.345833987,
0.0420933403,
-0.6787384152,
0.3241852224,
-0.2144390047,
-0.3581546247,
-0.0957323909,
-0.177358374,
0.0486183614,
0.2313776463,
0.5422838926,
0.7692704797,
-0.1659534872,
0.0682870448,
0.0121301422,
-0.2585692406,
0.5133808851,
-0.0235477909,
0.4864665568,
-0.2901046872,
-0.4843712747,
-0.4308412373,
0.0913523659,
0.9831513762,
0.1853669584,
0.8371687531,
0.6246384382,
-0.4544844925,
0.0458734632,
-0.6576675177,
-0.2977440059,
-0.4384801984,
0.5384002924,
-0.1592398286,
-0.8519070148,
0.2840185761,
-0.0328886025,
-0.0750213861,
0.4271912277,
0.8758268356,
-0.2100614011,
1.0913063288,
0.452444613,
-0.027795529,
0.0013515645,
0.0495775081,
0.0257356502,
-0.7087039351,
-0.7095752358,
-0.3493081033,
-0.1070285439,
-0.6272683144,
-0.6012772918,
0.7549059391,
-0.4432117343,
0.0717674419,
-0.1872450411,
-0.6388264894,
0.2280614674,
0.443831563,
0.0986413807,
0.2331904471,
-0.1636735648,
-0.2635020316,
-0.154976368,
-0.3929549456,
-0.2645464242,
1.2564005852,
0.5076471567,
0.9747594595,
0.0014799917,
0.4797697365,
-0.0468793958,
0.7596569061,
-1.0600624084,
0.4763681293,
-0.2535742521,
-0.7735588551,
-0.0620996095,
-0.5141557455,
-0.7512869239,
0.3366873264,
-0.4655691087,
-0.5799998045,
-0.4317727089,
-0.116792731,
-0.3094859719,
-0.0293141957,
-0.5495921969,
0.6748196483,
-0.5416991711,
-0.2013925016,
-0.2815183699,
-0.8980152011,
0.4945018888,
-0.2400996238,
0.3309719265,
0.0581014156,
-0.2213671505,
0.4654930234,
-0.1561976224,
0.7831737399,
0.0473254994,
-0.0966939628,
-0.0693320706,
-0.001076136,
-0.015523294,
0.1500497311,
0.0540756434,
0.3157877028,
0.1537960619,
0.0008007415,
-0.5525225401,
1.0128723383,
-0.8184099793,
-0.6753947139,
-0.6802375913,
-0.6150708199,
-0.3167214692,
-0.0023107873,
0.1441970021,
0.1309107095,
-0.0805601701,
0.1182522103,
0.7206652164,
-0.6423352361,
0.0425305888,
0.3411428928,
-0.469063282,
-0.7874764204,
0.5319777131,
-0.0783480108,
0.1592360884,
0.0104632052,
0.3056379259,
-0.4486899674,
-0.642336309,
-0.3532047272,
0.6605778337,
-0.7169705033,
0.2300283015,
-0.6607487202,
-0.4805671871,
-0.6196959019,
-0.0420111604,
-0.4975413978,
-0.3128453791,
-0.1461773664,
0.1896363795,
0.0908263177,
0.6840580106,
0.2797794342,
-0.0080490904,
-0.8250122666,
0.414496839,
0.0362744108,
0.3041606247,
-0.3471105695,
-0.3543105125,
0.0050229104,
-0.3701985776,
-0.4215608239,
-0.7140952945,
0.2813138664,
-0.2555411756,
0.6590442657,
0.6012409925,
-0.3159189224,
0.5682029724,
-0.2906405628,
0.8095597625,
0.5259659886,
-0.7380126715,
0.5347893238,
-0.170361191,
0.1312750429,
0.3427442908,
0.5659443736,
-0.8107611537,
-0.3131975234,
-0.3672072887,
-0.7813037634,
0.3092669845,
0.0960021466,
0.1827830076,
-0.0811576471,
0.6823856831,
0.2365291417,
0.3128257394,
-0.6830800176,
-0.4966334999,
0.0615937598,
-0.307972759,
-0.2134417892,
-0.2585421801,
-0.2452971339,
-0.2476111054,
0.5819499493,
-0.0552360266,
0.2039351016,
0.1981576979,
0.0726917982,
0.0203544032,
0.1644424498,
0.627750814,
0.5775728226,
-0.0751427338,
0.1342778504,
-0.0350277126,
-0.8348702788,
-0.0525992103,
0.2718498409,
0.2211537361,
0.0254357923,
0.3987167776,
0.4758135974,
0.0336417556,
-1.0166891813,
0.7032656074,
-0.1176883802,
-0.4023487568,
-0.3713515103,
0.1660652161,
0.264644444,
0.4231785238,
0.0038534296,
0.1270482093,
0.1502741128,
-0.7850964665,
0.0301247537,
0.4727601111,
-0.4464844763,
-0.2340578735,
0.8134815693,
0.0968373939,
-0.1970669776,
0.8277748823,
0.4589146078,
-0.4473799169,
0.6894663572,
0.5976892114,
0.5200009346,
-0.3752616644,
0.1419792324,
0.1928215325,
0.4387699068,
-0.3102467358,
0.6015532613,
0.2944993973,
-0.4990732074,
-0.4806328714,
-0.2798993289,
-0.7340002656,
0.3539147675,
-0.3585495055,
0.3359211683,
-0.5719267726,
-0.5498070717,
0.0617121197,
-0.1149547175,
-0.2944411933,
0.3167635202,
0.5299206972,
0.9421010017,
-0.436963737,
0.7947645783,
0.9124417901,
-0.0885004997,
-0.3051370978,
-0.1326619387,
0.3902607858,
-0.9714138508,
0.4900074899,
0.557130456,
-0.1659974754,
-0.412258774,
-0.3885043561,
-0.606703043,
0.9677705169,
0.2839650512,
-0.6516965628,
-0.0892800465,
-0.0301055703,
0.6751121283,
-0.3920708895,
0.3379564881,
0.4093451202,
0.3754992187,
0.2521813214,
-1.0108793974,
-0.0240971707,
-0.3480879962,
-0.1964648515,
0.0627729893,
-0.5161014795,
0.8491088748,
-0.7957219481,
0.1392481625,
0.3181881905,
0.1501161158,
0.4885785878,
0.5946496725,
0.2171497196,
0.5098519921,
0.8200506568,
-0.2429506779,
1.2341061831,
-0.2944173813,
0.0729580075,
0.7326904535,
-0.2866485119,
0.7941570282,
0.7792270184,
0.1004036218,
0.3500629365,
0.5514326692,
-0.05719807,
0.3554755449,
0.3892511427,
-0.2915082276,
-0.2719710767,
0.0943368599,
-0.6059442163,
0.2455658466,
0.7442074418,
-0.5978472829,
0.1482113302,
0.3645046949,
0.0714721009,
-0.1135715321,
-0.2349525243,
0.4830221236,
0.3893524706,
-0.7945083976,
0.4076228738,
0.0128126368,
0.7592941523,
-0.6619951129,
0.147546038,
-0.0485210828,
0.519728601,
-0.118005082,
-0.6975713372,
0.2680250108,
-0.0824055001,
0.0570911951,
-0.0837977603,
0.6013854146,
-0.1201129779,
-0.489925772,
0.3902921975,
0.4967469275,
0.372340858,
-0.2690162659,
-0.8463716507,
0.2564003468,
-0.3021893203,
-0.4024585187,
0.3454456031,
0.2930005193,
0.0459653661,
1.1384158134,
0.7589981556,
0.3087557852,
-0.0649717525,
0.3289197981,
0.9458983541,
-0.7118545771,
-0.0596242845,
-1.0333576202,
0.4254252017,
0.0929260775,
-0.4983921349,
0.5578190088,
0.4754703939,
0.4541227818,
-0.2684742808,
0.5391729474,
0.2357477695,
0.2481887341,
-0.5240335464,
0.9595351815,
-0.7527261972,
0.1828352511,
-0.2156794369,
-0.6242567301,
-0.7886173725,
0.6279281974,
-0.2155120224,
0.0645959824,
1.0150341988,
0.818641305,
0.3140376508,
-0.1808379591,
0.4321494699,
0.3594026268,
0.2152553201,
0.735858798,
1.2706483603,
-0.2325740755,
0.4588175714,
-0.1899618208,
-0.3434955478,
-0.300899446,
-0.5970543623,
-1.214977026,
-0.4513221383,
-0.3686607778,
-0.7482885122,
0.0962470248,
0.9624508619,
0.5705513954,
-0.5408573151,
0.014831637,
0.3258719742,
0.0264177173,
-0.2182410806,
-0.1507771462,
0.2814464867,
-0.1494081914,
-0.5644087195,
0.5045350194,
0.5696530342,
0.1307149827,
-0.4693803489,
-0.089133583,
0.2226166278,
-0.079419516,
0.6442206502,
-0.2810162306,
-0.9772510529,
-0.0936756879,
0.3160208464,
-0.5046092868,
0.0463721901,
0.7529273629,
-0.6987738013,
0.4312498868,
0.1120957509,
0.6161365509,
0.1964228004,
-0.2649613619,
0.1754629314,
0.0430817343,
-0.128048107,
0.3141624331,
0.4061380923,
0.2284244597,
-0.5209270716,
0.4007156491,
0.3147050142,
-0.5172968507,
-0.6616011858,
-0.0031940953,
-1.1332411766,
-0.4926199019,
1.1171298027,
0.1127632037,
-0.3421138227,
-0.0373539701,
-0.466504842,
0.0879319012,
-0.1839476228,
1.4239791632,
0.8360877633,
-0.1827294976,
-0.1402009279,
-0.8027248979,
0.3397442698,
0.4790587723,
-1.043525219,
-0.3017494082,
0.5007365346,
0.4545477033,
0.146337539,
0.582011044,
-0.6131272912,
0.5049778223,
-0.2555760443,
0.090357706,
-0.2527616322,
-0.5143461823,
-0.4292257726,
0.1608566046,
-0.002447661,
-0.2419421971
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06992v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06992v1
|
A Rational Analysis of the Speech-to-Song Illusion
| 2024-02-10T16:54:28 | 2024-02-10T16:54:28 |
Raja Marjieh, Pol van Rijn, Ilia Sucholutsky, Harin Lee, Thomas L. Griffiths, Nori Jacoby
|
q-bio.NC
|
q-bio.NC, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.AP
|
The speech-to-song illusion is a robust psychological phenomenon whereby a
spoken sentence sounds increasingly more musical as it is repeated. Despite
decades of research, a complete formal account of this transformation is still
lacking, and some of its nuanced characteristics, namely, that certain phrases
appear to transform while others do not, is not well understood. Here we
provide a formal account of this phenomenon, by recasting it as a statistical
inference whereby a rational agent attempts to decide whether a sequence of
utterances is more likely to have been produced in a song or speech. Using this
approach and analyzing song and speech corpora, we further introduce a novel
prose-to-lyrics illusion that is purely text-based. In this illusion, simply
duplicating written sentences makes them appear more like song lyrics. We
provide robust evidence for this new illusion in both human participants and
large language models.
|
[
-0.247417137,
-0.9497717023,
0.4815652072,
0.759195745,
0.0854560137,
0.2169718295,
-0.2324008793,
-0.3904425204,
0.5575365424,
0.7086423039,
-0.779098928,
-0.1555515081,
-0.4779173136,
0.1427083611,
-0.884670794,
1.0154432058,
0.3326161802,
-0.0180368349,
-0.0897202119,
0.0686067268,
-0.4724948406,
-0.4379836321,
-0.3441673219,
-0.019441558,
0.3763419092,
-0.006132158,
0.6693533063,
0.1415446848,
0.2096762657,
0.3088911474,
0.343401432,
-0.1600865573,
-0.6405963898,
0.0448398776,
-0.0134618087,
-0.9459919333,
-0.0696954504,
0.5483964086,
0.7149222493,
0.8696926236,
-0.1785740107,
0.0886070058,
0.0127207311,
0.8685304523,
-0.1592631787,
-0.2893293202,
-0.6990430951,
0.1974590421,
-0.3149994314,
-0.5738472342,
-0.528577745,
-0.5093416572,
0.5076117516,
-0.6931471825,
0.2622550428,
0.3501746655,
0.8853235841,
0.1908488274,
-0.5209055543,
-0.4825822115,
-0.9742857814,
0.7217193246,
-0.1307073236,
0.2753213644,
0.0985340402,
0.3481726646,
-0.3466578722,
-0.6827843785,
-0.8403280377,
-0.5119231343,
-0.2635637224,
0.2959563434,
-0.2788164914,
-0.1247534454,
0.4719675779,
0.4861685336,
-0.8052921891,
-0.7214056849,
-0.1040824279,
-0.1842090636,
0.6252194047,
-0.1774369925,
0.9316689372,
-0.3936636746,
-0.738314569,
-0.0132006081,
-0.2518048584,
0.1698893309,
0.2810224593,
0.0728594139,
-0.1572697908,
0.8072993159,
0.0688694343,
0.7393720746,
0.1814827174,
-0.4510354996,
0.4248517454,
-0.1024180055,
-0.3780623972,
0.5468611717,
0.7140180469,
0.2266083509,
0.5993118882,
-0.4214266241,
-0.2454635501,
0.7268745303,
0.0458671264,
-0.3414185345,
-0.2081044167,
-0.0300644916,
-0.4030619562,
-0.1529025882,
0.1193993911,
-0.6253824234,
-0.2996019125,
-0.6375707984,
0.6276454926,
-0.6761422157,
-0.1836225539,
0.3882321119,
-0.3658122122,
-0.1379270703,
-0.0354550444,
-0.4822073877,
0.2058727294,
0.8663318753,
0.9416211247,
-0.0589991026,
-0.506339252,
-0.2305068523,
0.0976659656,
-0.717163384,
1.2204235792,
-0.3553726971,
-0.2819769084,
-0.2654657364,
0.1295700967,
-0.5899092555,
-0.3369544446,
0.4230134189,
-0.3186496198,
0.7801618576,
-0.336330086,
-0.627397716,
-0.2420055419,
-0.1682088375,
-0.6759094596,
0.413932234,
0.0791415796,
-0.5460584164,
0.391477108,
-0.4245182276,
-0.3797626793,
-0.3805141449,
-0.3389707804,
-0.2030915022,
0.5365747809,
-0.1591451615,
-0.0181822721,
-0.3149732053,
0.1979604214,
-0.3550980985,
-0.5098063946,
1.0972474813,
-0.6737920642,
0.8701654077,
0.4305528104,
-0.121822305,
-0.0600244217,
-0.813249886,
-0.0202118736,
0.1359013766,
-0.100076355,
-0.5806372762,
0.0050954912,
0.05419017,
-0.0442224145,
0.1868485659,
-0.4435134828,
0.0445324965,
-0.7593846321,
0.4203098118,
0.2805344164,
0.4285991192,
0.6934736371,
-0.7814335823,
0.3812632561,
-0.2680145204,
-0.1062780395,
0.0706820339,
-0.3822488487,
-0.2108511776,
-0.4842494428,
0.1596451402,
0.7469415665,
-0.3429249823,
0.1820310503,
-0.4942977428,
0.0088098841,
-0.5914118886,
-0.1060472131,
0.0604381673,
0.4956579208,
0.0243505761,
-0.0286701228,
-0.6949548721,
-1.0730234385,
-0.8128806949,
-0.180959031,
-0.2798860371,
-0.1389885247,
0.2052861303,
0.019024739,
1.0298376083,
-0.5233002305,
-0.4059437811,
0.0158178695,
0.3456816673,
0.1130672097,
0.5387287736,
0.6052713394,
-0.8711457253,
-0.3879433572,
-0.2590027153,
-0.52082479,
-0.3667434454,
-0.9051806927,
-0.3796162605,
0.1186278835,
0.362401247,
-0.6933128238,
0.2913053334,
0.4767515957,
-0.6038529873,
0.4437821805,
0.2633658648,
0.5236743093,
-0.9178268909,
-0.1396999359,
0.0722164437,
0.0091677187,
-0.7530630231,
-0.5278039575,
-0.1129439175,
0.0116735371,
0.2467619628,
-0.0680813715,
-0.3068881929,
-0.4776474535,
-0.2898774445,
0.495434612,
0.2606984675,
0.4360737801,
-0.1517477185,
0.8698770404,
0.5593476892,
-0.0042797998,
0.1570432633,
0.1481704265,
-0.8818557858,
0.9470844865,
-0.4028342962,
-0.0267077088,
-0.4511514604,
0.203131035,
-1.3371607065,
-0.4401508272,
0.1998745203,
-0.7700536847,
0.3538593054,
-0.0042414661,
-0.3122458756,
-0.1087962389,
0.1006076932,
0.3051392138,
0.6015948057,
-0.3869498968,
0.4915496409,
0.2438872606,
-0.0523579828,
-0.3315833211,
-0.7742196918,
0.4264965355,
-0.6786892414,
-0.8588345647,
0.3594115078,
0.0542663187,
-0.8179034591,
0.046105396,
-0.1582317948,
-0.0751376003,
-0.0075551835,
0.1098077595,
0.3041833341,
-0.3156174123,
0.420509249,
0.1310780793,
0.0836578086,
0.4342134893,
-0.3835084438,
0.3840880096,
0.1100633219,
-0.1299958378,
-0.853726089,
0.4470058978,
0.6111381054,
-0.0988095701,
0.350241065,
0.2226986289,
-0.0450885557,
-0.2088411897,
-0.313790977,
0.1123520508,
-0.3723481596,
0.2781508863,
-0.4949782193,
-0.2704285681,
0.3637417257,
-0.1683018953,
-0.3552432358,
0.4475987852,
-0.0770401284,
-0.6074290276,
1.1788922548,
0.2333139628,
0.172613129,
0.5343407989,
-0.194982484,
-0.2111332566,
-0.7018444538,
-0.3833876848,
-0.5202510953,
-0.3003959656,
-0.5951846242,
-0.3119457364,
0.365157038,
0.1747253686,
-0.4467824996,
0.0879657269,
-0.4650129378,
0.2241869569,
0.1411100179,
0.0478713661,
0.2656086981,
0.1496569514,
0.3559118509,
-0.189015463,
-0.3761827946,
-0.4820632041,
0.8231219649,
0.2103553265,
0.327188164,
0.5386506915,
0.5155517459,
0.4316211641,
0.3495325148,
-0.8052620888,
0.4545700848,
0.0062131532,
-0.6619336009,
-0.512996912,
-0.5148975253,
-0.7988494039,
0.2033254355,
-0.4990487993,
-0.6500272155,
0.2408009619,
0.1300338954,
-0.2276196927,
-0.0494360775,
-0.7978650928,
0.6861534119,
-0.4841884673,
-0.0496318191,
-0.2337147146,
-0.3502349854,
0.7441781163,
-0.2057132572,
0.3055043519,
-0.3310120702,
-0.2667728961,
0.7748537064,
-0.3496627808,
0.6706821918,
-0.0976030603,
-0.3300379217,
0.1994757205,
0.1948329955,
0.6135904789,
-0.1081685647,
0.1667409092,
-0.1443436295,
-0.0999655128,
-0.5259637833,
-1.2372142076,
0.7356496453,
-0.5464972854,
-0.5984541774,
-0.2944841683,
-0.5315958858,
-0.4297127724,
-0.2091524154,
0.4352585375,
0.6014027596,
-0.1820461154,
-0.0754359365,
0.4575310051,
-0.3456359804,
0.1191908196,
0.1022984385,
-0.505934298,
-0.7710240483,
0.8685614467,
0.206096068,
0.6530554891,
0.6254152656,
0.3419109285,
-0.557428062,
-0.2976150215,
-0.2961808443,
0.5071340203,
-0.402369827,
0.6343554854,
-0.3836313486,
0.249221921,
-0.4720672071,
0.0254835021,
-0.0029815855,
-0.6987604499,
-0.1039098203,
0.1333684325,
0.5386579633,
0.4780272543,
-0.0911406279,
0.3172527254,
-0.2884859741,
0.4462407827,
0.4112291336,
0.2017386556,
-0.0062561291,
-0.9162065387,
0.0664903894,
0.2181344032,
0.0593313985,
-1.1708141565,
0.3543249667,
0.4229513109,
0.1998970658,
0.4499270916,
0.0299032424,
1.0222811699,
-0.5474748015,
0.6768369675,
0.4704306424,
-0.9571620822,
0.3514220715,
-0.5235331059,
-0.1954464763,
0.4389101565,
0.06051917,
-0.7545958161,
-0.1823476106,
-0.4904049933,
-0.3736200333,
0.2566723228,
0.5267047286,
0.1118695959,
0.0754060969,
0.1139963791,
-0.0695145875,
0.3302614689,
-0.6580383182,
-0.5160365701,
-0.6928792,
-0.1262511462,
-0.59246701,
0.051798705,
-0.139442727,
-0.0211573038,
0.2924120724,
0.1906794459,
0.5434756875,
0.4969210923,
-0.0485236906,
-0.2315339297,
0.4439596236,
0.8694818616,
0.5264820457,
-0.1777270287,
0.2307285815,
-0.0329306833,
-0.3558966815,
0.0639344752,
-0.0222836342,
-0.2517451346,
-0.0014908133,
0.6003482938,
1.0270873308,
0.3691557348,
-0.5918053985,
0.4256107509,
0.2278310061,
-0.2956699431,
-0.7129771113,
-0.0390627086,
0.0479176901,
0.3253721595,
0.4246619642,
0.6963745952,
0.3032601178,
-1.0941435099,
0.3960877359,
0.418503195,
-0.6282988787,
-0.27216205,
0.6932911873,
-0.2991865277,
-0.7864045501,
0.0224941205,
0.0084493719,
-0.444270134,
0.3595860898,
0.7320204377,
1.0563492775,
-0.0024747308,
0.3348145485,
0.2153776735,
0.05097102,
-0.2428454608,
0.2139035612,
-0.0661488995,
-0.439147234,
-0.5693610311,
-0.4082492888,
0.2684617937,
0.15509139,
-0.742061913,
-0.1916803122,
0.0191408712,
-0.0427807607,
0.3889923096,
-0.3633824885,
0.0586407594,
0.1881889105,
-0.0771908462,
0.6069642305,
-0.7298989892,
0.7617530227,
0.2173378915,
-0.3004061282,
-0.7994279861,
0.430657506,
0.1392107904,
-0.603145659,
0.4218782485,
0.0302237775,
-0.2697851062,
0.0746185556,
-0.689599514,
-0.8200056553,
0.581546247,
0.3354019225,
-0.6414067745,
-0.0422468744,
0.5857348442,
0.8279607892,
-0.4427861273,
-0.477129221,
0.6937539577,
0.545093596,
0.2128762454,
-0.6082508564,
-0.2557115257,
0.0729141831,
0.0879190043,
0.2985380888,
-0.4378106296,
0.9639496803,
-0.0637877285,
-0.53347826,
0.3335269988,
0.7346089482,
0.1512898952,
0.6962247491,
0.8248033524,
0.209027946,
0.7897872925,
0.003868198,
0.9738351703,
-0.3292757571,
0.2402663231,
1.1298145056,
-0.2432629913,
0.6994194388,
0.5172143579,
-0.2279127091,
0.5092596412,
0.22449857,
-0.0492023639,
0.5736136436,
0.3946771622,
-0.395958513,
-0.3555146754,
0.1199008226,
-0.1592813879,
0.5995741487,
0.3171388805,
-0.6931641698,
0.3199677765,
0.1933215111,
-0.1537956744,
0.7284027934,
-0.2595408261,
0.7152215838,
0.1629993767,
-0.9517819285,
0.4505671561,
-0.6035154462,
0.3415497839,
-0.284430474,
0.1212735996,
0.1122077629,
-0.1722302884,
-0.0609636754,
-0.5885005593,
0.4462431371,
-0.0726084262,
-0.3464370966,
-0.2224683017,
0.4331541359,
-0.697119534,
-0.5721612573,
0.1952323318,
0.2605041564,
0.2696264684,
-0.1078251228,
-0.6986641884,
-0.3342368603,
0.3715895116,
-0.0498004146,
0.1814739704,
0.9225651622,
0.1084410846,
0.4405377209,
0.554925859,
0.5069397092,
0.2150077224,
0.135272339,
0.068867296,
-0.722966373,
-0.4836166799,
-0.6363146305,
0.2299283296,
-0.3315518796,
-0.1306476742,
0.8497305512,
0.7453122139,
0.6462392807,
-0.1387910843,
0.930165112,
0.122433573,
0.9075388908,
-0.7493748665,
0.9965238571,
-0.6543962955,
0.4641842842,
-0.7193946838,
-0.8120883107,
0.078483887,
0.6993816495,
-0.569368124,
-0.2954262197,
0.6590459943,
0.8561058044,
0.111064136,
0.4488936365,
0.4256676733,
0.4052476883,
-0.2334067225,
0.3209570646,
1.3197109699,
-0.3496793211,
0.6118737459,
-0.2111209482,
-0.1296416819,
0.2707848549,
-0.541151762,
-0.4779160321,
-0.919532001,
-0.3008885682,
-0.4289332926,
-0.2868468463,
0.9756659865,
0.1788074821,
-0.5529956818,
-0.3782804012,
-0.1660351306,
0.1390918046,
-0.4621010721,
-0.2110687941,
0.3724898994,
-0.1856959611,
-0.6497695446,
0.4204055369,
0.1012613773,
0.4552111924,
-0.1208627224,
0.0746783316,
0.1179585457,
0.6766098142,
0.611982882,
0.2220257074,
-0.8085748553,
-0.2645231485,
0.1181188002,
-0.0853930935,
0.2002936155,
0.9582068324,
-0.5827750564,
0.3496263027,
0.4347211421,
-0.0506724715,
0.0248184185,
0.1535056382,
0.5356746316,
-0.359816581,
-0.1186228618,
0.0044920691,
0.1430186182,
0.0621471666,
-0.1748723537,
0.178260684,
0.6508776546,
-0.340490967,
-1.0788712502,
0.2102421969,
-1.2842488289,
-0.3301125169,
1.01706779,
0.1356390715,
-0.2925275862,
-0.2022804022,
-0.3885571659,
0.2982393801,
-0.33590734,
1.1328901052,
0.4025013447,
-0.2919294536,
0.2142251134,
-0.6941327453,
0.9084154963,
0.1606218219,
-0.5169046521,
0.0615280159,
0.7983096242,
0.38362661,
0.4756162167,
0.2390948534,
0.0395282917,
0.2191305906,
0.2887375653,
-0.2673469782,
0.3598851264,
-0.4019425809,
-0.1684765071,
0.6109829545,
-0.2530757487,
-0.2558088601
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10951v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10951v1
|
DAEDRA: A language model for predicting outcomes in passive pharmacovigilance reporting
| 2024-02-10T16:48:45 | 2024-02-10T16:48:45 |
Chris von Csefalvay
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, 68T50, I.2.7; J.3
|
Over the recent years, the emergence of large language models (LLMs) has
given rise to a proliferation of domain-specific models that are intended to
reflect the particularities of linguistic context and content as a correlate of
the originating domain. This paper details the conception, design, training and
evaluation of DAEDRA, a LLM designed to detect regulatory-relevant outcomes
(mortality, ER attendance and hospitalisation) in adverse event reports
elicited through passive reporting (PR). While PR is a highly cost-efficient
way of eliciting information from a wide and diverse audience -- typically
including not only physicians and healthcare providers but also patients,
family members and other lay stakeholders --, this diversity makes PR corpora
difficult to analyse. Generic language models may not capture the complex
clinical dimensions while specific clinical or biomedical models may not
perform well on lay reports. To evaluate the utility of a subdomain-specific
language model, an adaptive training approach was adapted, wherein base
language model candidates were evaluated on a subset of the corpus, and the
best performer was trained on the entire corpus. This yielded a small but
significant improvement in $F_1$ (+1%), precision (+2.5%) and recall (+3.8%),
at a relatively low training cost and a single-day training time.
Subdomain-specific LLMs continue to be viable options for better results when
analysing highly specialised corpora.
|
[
0.3505470455,
-0.5864210129,
0.567017436,
0.0116738677,
-0.4185423553,
0.0090485765,
-0.1620309949,
-0.4740616977,
0.2143507302,
0.2727155983,
-0.3342604935,
-0.7397084236,
-0.6477406621,
0.1051462591,
-0.390879184,
1.0006695986,
-0.1817355007,
0.1022097543,
0.3235435188,
-0.2613660693,
-0.6362902522,
-0.8894562721,
-0.3761358857,
-0.1991146803,
0.893063128,
0.2577548027,
0.2798894644,
0.2851338685,
0.8925756216,
0.1498091668,
-0.083068274,
0.0883493274,
-0.4662164748,
0.026971031,
-0.1102652922,
-0.2873941064,
-1.0464299917,
0.110977672,
0.6438694596,
0.7924255133,
-0.586450994,
-0.0030550568,
-0.0430409126,
0.5476196408,
-0.7628121972,
0.1025330797,
-0.4024351239,
0.0054537598,
-0.2534708381,
-0.0921386331,
-0.4523311555,
-0.2651976645,
0.4787929654,
-0.5396485329,
-0.2617592216,
-0.0801778138,
0.5774512291,
0.2989513278,
-0.6309638619,
-0.6198129654,
-0.7503703237,
0.5246273279,
-0.8839647174,
0.2413698882,
0.2022229582,
0.2771007419,
-0.2603895962,
-0.9836084247,
-0.6318882108,
-0.2607142925,
-0.1385501325,
0.2969363332,
-0.4410282671,
0.1565209776,
-0.2615087032,
0.3412005901,
-0.436291486,
0.24552387,
-0.3025927544,
0.091718927,
0.6369573474,
0.3776752651,
0.4412018955,
0.0363953598,
-0.3237989247,
0.3397803605,
-0.7471688986,
-0.2656142414,
0.1499109715,
0.4628322721,
-0.3008296192,
0.3411587775,
-0.059815459,
0.612341404,
0.0826166198,
-0.5622170568,
0.1744747311,
-0.0192738399,
-0.0597386248,
0.3648585081,
0.6333519816,
0.195525229,
0.2397001088,
0.0498132631,
-0.1211305559,
0.3355812132,
0.4120090306,
-0.6777812839,
-0.4308072627,
0.4279189706,
-0.3523735702,
-0.3917617798,
-0.005333724,
-0.6759353876,
-0.1787617058,
-0.0985663533,
0.2276905477,
-0.3938613832,
-0.5357892513,
0.431276083,
0.2345066816,
-0.1365733892,
0.2682239115,
-0.7208449244,
0.4562950134,
0.5754555464,
0.6740185022,
-0.6805689335,
-0.211895287,
-0.6622555256,
0.2160320729,
-0.421410054,
0.83856529,
-0.4949469864,
-0.3212058842,
0.1892191023,
-0.055395361,
-0.3443695009,
-0.4441124201,
0.816198051,
-0.7084912062,
-0.0470758937,
-0.0391017906,
-0.3172549605,
-0.4109256864,
-0.1552001983,
-0.5014618039,
0.623654604,
0.1685996652,
-0.7925851941,
0.6847918034,
-0.5279176235,
-0.5758869648,
0.3663161397,
-0.0167697743,
-0.535353899,
0.1415010989,
-0.1109690443,
0.3738377094,
-0.0438887998,
0.546200335,
-0.0440084152,
-0.4715497792,
0.4983002841,
-0.3178637326,
0.4654693007,
0.1465263218,
-0.4271556437,
0.2865402997,
-0.8111804724,
-0.2965774238,
-0.0920683071,
-0.6582788229,
-0.6079668999,
0.0960717499,
0.0916671976,
0.0766926855,
-0.0503693931,
-0.5181775689,
0.0272192825,
-0.4357450604,
0.192534849,
0.5997697711,
0.2275421768,
0.1371485293,
-0.0241194181,
0.4873856306,
0.1588560045,
0.4092130661,
0.1990418583,
-0.2526229918,
-0.4977645278,
-0.7920566797,
0.6162064672,
0.520310998,
-0.3956410885,
0.2480928004,
-0.334444195,
-0.2094038427,
-0.3371795118,
0.004453891,
0.4340805113,
0.4599618018,
0.1428746581,
-0.452475816,
-0.6827610731,
-0.7784945965,
0.0779385418,
-0.3331514895,
0.2995555103,
0.1369886249,
0.7425196767,
-0.8486297727,
0.5488884449,
-0.5192137361,
-0.5810868144,
-0.5471240878,
-0.025917517,
0.1387869567,
0.1118024662,
0.4707196355,
-0.7251685262,
-0.5464308262,
-0.0267997589,
-0.7613085508,
-0.4442669749,
0.1276598126,
0.0613392331,
0.1659552306,
0.0193811376,
-0.2447629869,
0.5761986375,
0.8352770209,
-0.2267722934,
0.311807245,
-0.2999150753,
0.1128000021,
-0.6973465085,
0.2539466918,
-0.0406431779,
-0.0877444744,
-0.7843648791,
-0.2984595895,
0.1029201001,
-0.009627712,
-0.4191266,
0.4216292202,
-0.599200964,
0.0964186043,
-0.561907053,
0.0831982791,
-0.038971927,
0.409396708,
0.1690312177,
0.6999779344,
0.380551219,
-0.784810245,
0.2774010003,
0.2231388837,
-0.414639622,
0.4535105228,
-0.7738640308,
-0.045842167,
0.087406747,
0.1519174874,
-0.7673085332,
-0.4932455719,
0.1441205591,
-0.2077023089,
0.5646730661,
-0.3303792477,
-0.116379559,
-0.4699838161,
0.1640250236,
0.4339853227,
0.4282822013,
-0.3091501594,
0.4894458055,
1.0889310837,
-0.4970912635,
-0.468688786,
-0.7685348392,
0.2727625668,
-0.2544138432,
-0.2167575806,
0.2430655211,
0.0616933778,
-0.6160996556,
0.0599121749,
0.007024297,
-0.2289346606,
0.1817620993,
0.3932905495,
0.353679359,
-0.1020220071,
0.1670283079,
0.0198158417,
-0.3086963892,
-0.0868183896,
-0.006702187,
0.1878525317,
-0.1883335412,
-0.5006497502,
-0.5613409281,
0.5733298063,
0.6096652746,
-0.3450383246,
0.9350849986,
-0.0603367798,
-0.3138824999,
-0.3987082541,
-0.2909083068,
0.0185022429,
-0.4154839218,
0.2506912947,
-0.1989984214,
-0.4754286706,
0.4856569171,
-0.1766956598,
-0.1001679003,
0.4811064601,
1.0968571901,
0.0506785326,
0.8364232779,
1.000648737,
0.3145153821,
0.4902218878,
-0.0590935536,
0.2042631954,
-0.5610724688,
-0.4545151293,
0.0204332303,
0.1393092275,
-0.3315273821,
-0.3801144063,
0.8872575164,
-0.294796586,
0.125446409,
0.0389830545,
-0.4358804226,
0.0473838784,
0.1576783955,
0.2054752111,
0.5343395472,
0.0490124188,
-0.1929094493,
-0.0906613991,
-0.941596806,
-0.595061481,
1.04509902,
0.4775376618,
0.9450973272,
0.3036344647,
0.3290790319,
0.5875943899,
0.709777534,
-0.7734825611,
0.3089589477,
-0.2528381348,
-0.4577973485,
0.1567792743,
-0.3307824135,
-1.0813474655,
0.0193753857,
0.0663617551,
-0.3074997663,
0.5983863473,
-0.2272125334,
-0.6325467229,
0.0615552031,
-0.7143698931,
0.6711677313,
-0.4573421776,
-0.2917072475,
-0.1982410401,
-0.4651985765,
0.1962788701,
-0.391842097,
0.2272585183,
-0.2366994321,
-0.3068484068,
0.8906251788,
-0.3725467324,
1.3275389671,
0.0387846977,
-0.3281752765,
0.3782806396,
-0.0586734153,
0.2161440402,
0.0746176839,
-0.1629700065,
0.2843559682,
0.0643630773,
-0.333525449,
-0.1449224353,
0.7909222841,
-0.7368314266,
-0.4401837289,
-0.9216406941,
-0.4190092087,
-0.1595845222,
0.0722359717,
-0.0060091559,
0.7005928755,
-0.5056291819,
-0.1380583942,
0.6898005009,
-0.3309592903,
0.1603029966,
1.3940222263,
0.2165834159,
-0.5020080805,
0.4793668687,
0.3210833371,
-0.003435083,
0.2537179887,
0.1827116311,
-0.1701086909,
-0.8207546473,
-0.3974865675,
0.2483683825,
-0.7539946437,
-0.3382047415,
-0.7617030144,
-0.178704083,
-0.3028244078,
0.2708190084,
-0.3885393739,
-0.1887809187,
-0.1228045076,
-0.3329286873,
0.652104497,
0.9971055388,
-0.0750918612,
0.2088349909,
-0.7735588551,
0.1838255227,
0.1885950714,
0.5309547186,
-0.2330081612,
-0.8024975061,
-0.5013862848,
-0.0439140238,
0.1340943575,
-1.2096272707,
0.6710606217,
0.3496605456,
1.0321617126,
0.0397579186,
0.3111172318,
0.2921653092,
-0.4495399892,
0.3476933837,
0.1299121827,
-0.6899871826,
0.8718342781,
-0.5742447972,
-0.0851778239,
0.6027546525,
0.4552014768,
-0.4448230565,
-0.1962385774,
-0.2644622624,
-0.9493008256,
0.3955020308,
0.0489993915,
0.0613966621,
-0.2395936549,
0.5875857472,
0.3804734945,
0.0671953335,
-0.5996531844,
-0.1981950998,
0.1951629072,
-0.5248931646,
0.0067485245,
-0.6878532767,
-0.4157210588,
-0.0890050754,
0.6437946558,
-0.1585027128,
0.0104776435,
0.5282669067,
-0.2351884246,
-0.3972939551,
0.3766414821,
0.4618666172,
0.9203935862,
-0.2769575417,
0.1314337552,
0.15244174,
-1.0170856714,
0.2989708185,
0.2428591549,
-0.1511915922,
-0.0036369341,
0.5777319074,
0.713948667,
0.1288455725,
-1.0629473925,
0.5783706307,
-0.1409418136,
-0.002976082,
-0.3459548354,
-0.0455543734,
-0.4202196896,
0.1165293157,
0.6435623765,
-0.4032683074,
0.205386892,
-0.8630123138,
0.4754505157,
-0.0679789782,
-0.6314085722,
-0.565425992,
0.5384668708,
0.4745638371,
-0.033046823,
0.2612654865,
0.0788484067,
-0.5754011273,
0.4074578285,
0.3647369742,
0.9194954038,
-0.3857527673,
0.2051912695,
0.2433231026,
0.2220005542,
0.1243359521,
0.3246599436,
0.655459106,
-0.4481655657,
-0.5393686891,
-0.6902249455,
-0.5401948094,
-0.0717574358,
-0.6797088981,
0.0091766212,
-0.4298147261,
-0.3914096057,
-0.140919134,
0.1390948743,
-0.0292070769,
0.2825125456,
0.1052286252,
0.6720693111,
-0.8785350919,
0.9501869082,
0.7926680446,
-0.4950309098,
-0.582177937,
0.1297540665,
-0.0926472172,
-0.6043772101,
0.8781523705,
-0.1090918779,
-0.1353805065,
-0.4133349657,
0.0565578379,
-0.7510623932,
0.9170604944,
0.2291462123,
-0.8234269023,
0.1590436548,
0.1075334474,
0.9018711448,
-0.552852273,
-0.1798164546,
0.5947846174,
0.0340098515,
-0.1275106817,
-1.1406975985,
0.0931962952,
-0.2774105668,
-0.3738386929,
0.0536760986,
-0.6624723077,
0.7434909344,
-0.3734968305,
-0.3943202496,
-0.2890732288,
0.5849604607,
0.1014795005,
0.4319557548,
0.2293787301,
0.370210588,
0.8190069199,
-0.0328118503,
1.2257061005,
-0.2463157028,
0.1343883574,
0.8607195616,
-0.7044614553,
0.9973410368,
0.3145140707,
-0.1989505887,
0.8617425561,
0.4946528375,
0.288190037,
1.0403596163,
0.0144334771,
-0.4513228238,
-0.0863323063,
-0.1416105032,
-0.3481363952,
0.4805035293,
0.5752382874,
-0.1838724911,
0.0511005707,
0.3782696128,
-0.3323739171,
0.1707692295,
-0.2067202628,
1.0730714798,
0.3354340494,
-0.4847969711,
0.6487582922,
0.0702873617,
0.352817297,
-0.7051433325,
0.0126890242,
-0.3586365581,
0.7567032576,
-0.2037501782,
-0.5291926861,
0.5697935224,
0.3305670023,
-0.2175371945,
0.0914058685,
0.8200172782,
-0.2482421249,
-0.5419114232,
0.5858722329,
0.5971240997,
-0.084941484,
0.0862163901,
-0.7250704169,
0.349821806,
-0.3485500515,
-0.2996584475,
0.3364467323,
0.4594311416,
-0.2566038668,
0.7204256654,
0.5761041641,
0.3356324136,
-0.129704833,
0.4062206447,
1.0729563236,
-0.4003240764,
-0.5579775572,
-0.6656089425,
0.4772617221,
0.2339776456,
-0.1263891011,
0.7619595528,
0.4889675677,
0.0312278084,
0.2102004141,
0.7623083591,
0.2009921223,
0.7756197453,
-0.4567267299,
0.6084689498,
-0.5523994565,
0.6482394934,
0.0188713185,
-0.3217794895,
-0.2480812669,
0.4420452416,
-0.7000370026,
-0.0826098248,
0.5405384302,
0.4815974236,
0.0013792061,
-0.4598122835,
0.2642684281,
0.4815088212,
0.1163236797,
0.5572634339,
0.8894827366,
-0.5356672406,
0.6105701327,
-0.0566147901,
-0.488920629,
-0.4570441544,
-0.647138238,
-0.9466171861,
-0.2694817781,
-0.4862087667,
-0.2983653247,
0.5455037951,
0.5071921349,
0.7021485567,
-1.011790514,
0.0367190875,
0.0231774356,
-0.1600405276,
-0.2172223032,
-0.1455672979,
0.5272270441,
0.1036393717,
-0.4826720357,
0.438090831,
0.6927608848,
0.1684730053,
-0.1630123705,
-0.0590741858,
-0.336387068,
0.2015207708,
0.5148473978,
0.1228215545,
-0.6261069179,
0.148754403,
0.0321960375,
-0.6267431974,
0.0094730454,
0.7546847463,
-0.5103275776,
0.1530629247,
0.2691021562,
0.331215173,
0.4189681709,
-0.2228324264,
0.9246413112,
-0.4446672201,
0.3936882913,
0.501236558,
0.4607914686,
0.3846151829,
-0.4682440162,
0.5544651747,
0.2507221997,
-0.3414446414,
-1.0312309265,
0.1398691088,
-1.0565313101,
-0.4009104669,
1.3610801697,
-0.3707015514,
-0.3315144479,
-0.5555794835,
-0.317804426,
0.2913517356,
-0.3213222921,
0.825812757,
0.1315202117,
0.1051864177,
-0.1238112524,
-0.8020207882,
0.5567124486,
0.2033897042,
-0.6794838309,
0.2353865057,
0.4960485101,
0.527541101,
-0.1225846633,
0.9575826526,
-0.206786409,
0.4994181693,
0.1157119423,
-0.0406756066,
0.0156124374,
-0.3578650355,
-0.442275852,
0.1180241257,
0.0377544127,
0.0798625052
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06973v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06973v1
|
Event-Keyed Summarization
| 2024-02-10T15:32:53 | 2024-02-10T15:32:53 |
William Gantt, Alexander Martin, Pavlo Kuchmiichuk, Aaron Steven White
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
We introduce event-keyed summarization (EKS), a novel task that marries
traditional summarization and document-level event extraction, with the goal of
generating a contextualized summary for a specific event, given a document and
an extracted event structure. We introduce a dataset for this task, MUCSUM,
consisting of summaries of all events in the classic MUC-4 dataset, along with
a set of baselines that comprises both pretrained LM standards in the
summarization literature, as well as larger frontier models. We show that
ablations that reduce EKS to traditional summarization or structure-to-text
yield inferior summaries of target events and that MUCSUM is a robust benchmark
for this task. Lastly, we conduct a human evaluation of both reference and
model summaries, and provide some detailed analysis of the results.
|
[
-0.2451788932,
-0.4502581358,
0.5266890526,
-0.51243186,
-0.5134376287,
0.188514933,
-0.179156363,
-0.2852508724,
0.473393023,
0.508336544,
-0.5701417327,
-0.8515794873,
-0.2634157538,
0.0866094008,
-0.3505320251,
1.3754752874,
-0.0484283827,
-0.1899031997,
-0.1902574897,
-0.2895492315,
-0.0317866877,
-0.7268835902,
-0.451241374,
-0.2429697365,
0.6489210129,
0.6703546643,
0.1470982432,
0.8289085031,
0.7604270577,
0.1175301671,
-0.3121436834,
0.1196758747,
-0.4459871948,
0.1386375576,
0.2096892297,
-0.5085605383,
-0.8796753287,
0.0148122273,
0.7799447179,
0.6808060408,
-0.0826800838,
0.4499293864,
0.0999732539,
0.7897766829,
-0.8756989837,
0.0952289626,
-0.6205049753,
0.0921825469,
-0.50868994,
-0.3615070283,
-0.1592196971,
-0.1564605981,
-0.1649325043,
-0.4932266772,
0.4557887316,
-0.2880769968,
0.6612044573,
-0.0841910914,
-0.7943739295,
-0.4741692543,
-0.7157073617,
0.7136512995,
-0.6448717713,
0.4536316693,
0.3630457222,
0.3088771105,
0.2852891982,
-0.9602180719,
-0.2015519738,
0.0952877775,
-0.2631486058,
0.3441010416,
0.2729237676,
0.2861208916,
0.3432533443,
0.5799674988,
-0.6159801483,
-0.032509096,
-0.7408900261,
-0.0212978385,
0.7666798234,
0.5453529358,
-0.1120443419,
-0.1132672429,
0.133451432,
-0.0947430059,
-0.9420052171,
0.0894643739,
0.2479543388,
0.3321787417,
-0.3506971896,
0.5358802676,
-0.6847637892,
0.3493191302,
0.0121614719,
-0.4163767099,
0.3166246414,
-0.7023764253,
-0.0864040852,
0.1090180427,
0.4781664908,
0.7801017165,
-0.207945466,
-0.3643459678,
-0.0037311846,
-0.0207869839,
-0.0736337081,
-0.7416976094,
0.0055692499,
0.3885422051,
-0.8203858733,
-0.4409628808,
-0.1024181992,
-1.0239315033,
-0.2276999503,
-0.31693542,
0.073034443,
-0.0582728274,
0.0735229552,
-0.3866666555,
-0.5996648669,
0.2108699828,
0.1756486297,
-0.9418790936,
0.4431132972,
0.6008558273,
0.8873584867,
-0.4071882069,
-0.1874760836,
-0.5825092196,
0.3902125061,
-0.4042304754,
0.6815745234,
-0.3202039897,
-0.4757564068,
-0.0658793822,
-0.2826064229,
0.3241547942,
-0.3704763651,
0.6410731077,
-0.4429657161,
-0.2258581519,
-0.5590897799,
-0.5053797364,
-0.0724814236,
0.2378112674,
-0.569726944,
0.9627551436,
-0.2568199635,
-0.5524722338,
0.4239693582,
-0.6500149965,
-0.6549865007,
-0.0744333416,
-0.4014651179,
-0.4768826663,
0.3131892979,
0.3161250353,
0.5675508976,
0.2679763734,
-0.0831060186,
-0.2146445364,
0.0909858868,
-0.0467688814,
0.0143974163,
0.2913302183,
0.4292710721,
-0.0645156577,
-0.022285644,
-1.0561307669,
-0.2874822021,
0.0311931949,
-0.298844099,
-0.2926292121,
0.4046468735,
-0.1161928922,
0.0651628599,
0.3870409131,
-0.5003313422,
0.2074347585,
-0.3370784819,
0.1849673241,
0.2901386917,
0.3418135047,
0.700746119,
-0.366560936,
0.3320582807,
-0.0908439308,
-0.0207689237,
-0.9569871426,
-0.0347705893,
-0.424729228,
-0.428535074,
0.0775511563,
0.3272384107,
-0.4138514996,
0.3912440836,
-0.4006654322,
-0.6305408478,
0.0795812681,
-0.1070046499,
0.1252764761,
0.4819816649,
0.200132966,
-0.1383658648,
-0.4646634459,
-0.9144378901,
-0.4373212755,
0.0834381729,
-0.1981574595,
-0.0669809431,
0.3429277539,
0.3350165486,
0.8207873702,
-0.5896338224,
-0.5367389917,
-0.5664451718,
0.5604107976,
0.0078294957,
0.3068252206,
0.6361287236,
-0.5459933281,
-0.4179470539,
0.2259440124,
-0.6324151158,
-0.0832889453,
-0.1006034613,
0.306315124,
0.0131558208,
0.8593958616,
-0.394682914,
0.8338252306,
0.2658445239,
-0.1403817236,
0.4308603704,
-0.2035411745,
0.5204670429,
-1.0738835335,
0.4138613641,
-0.5394146442,
-0.4347803295,
-0.7234877944,
0.1972471774,
0.3152270615,
-0.3276022971,
-0.3049469888,
0.3487299085,
-0.6751694679,
-0.4552363157,
-0.3043820262,
0.170882225,
0.0058103302,
0.6616912484,
0.2673093081,
0.109332107,
0.0934027135,
-0.6677638888,
0.2683883309,
0.3861935735,
-0.1923692524,
0.4687345028,
-0.3625841737,
0.1628565192,
-0.3104038239,
0.3596106768,
-0.7167453766,
-0.2275111526,
-0.1755386293,
-0.5202617049,
0.2955829799,
0.0405350477,
-0.3174289167,
0.0032673876,
-0.7285093665,
0.5262907743,
0.3363936841,
-0.2458286434,
1.023034811,
0.483137548,
-0.6037964225,
-0.3809405267,
-0.5899403691,
0.0866935998,
-0.2544662654,
-0.1935770363,
0.4091888666,
-0.062020693,
-0.2042642236,
0.0939924344,
-0.2747419775,
-0.1415129006,
0.0893681347,
0.1399436444,
0.1499292403,
-0.1015805379,
-0.0532018617,
0.3220357895,
0.0556218326,
-0.0647340566,
0.1970097423,
0.1722191125,
0.2362191975,
-0.3444693089,
-0.5627896786,
0.768027246,
0.7422220707,
-0.5239478946,
0.4025218487,
0.0314335637,
-0.7248036861,
0.2269829065,
-0.4667853415,
-0.3177998662,
-0.3646197617,
0.6643291116,
-0.3446787298,
-0.6621958017,
1.0048308372,
0.0489377342,
0.7511844039,
0.6290870905,
0.6679834723,
-0.313274771,
1.1097034216,
0.3579648733,
-0.2221900672,
0.5971456766,
-0.2585130334,
-0.0156177916,
-0.8284858465,
-0.1415300518,
-0.7477860451,
-0.4959726632,
-0.0863256231,
0.0894077644,
0.6881734133,
-0.0074861543,
0.0891144574,
-0.0025172045,
-0.0689455122,
0.7080413103,
0.3344026506,
0.0236869622,
0.5511539578,
-0.2974987626,
0.1035077572,
0.0552126989,
-0.7467767,
-0.5813235044,
1.5483202934,
0.1660686731,
0.4820360541,
-0.0573654175,
0.9142562151,
0.3613400757,
0.513856113,
-0.3752156794,
0.2499705106,
0.1225617379,
-0.8217310309,
-0.555021584,
-0.3572079837,
-0.9188280106,
0.1671220511,
-0.2454482615,
-0.9755496979,
0.189291507,
0.2217767686,
-0.6375331879,
0.284891963,
-0.3580262065,
0.7960695028,
-0.0398718193,
0.2468860447,
-0.5898234844,
-0.8493898511,
0.4825066328,
-0.0642777085,
0.6776489019,
-0.0726750419,
-0.1281448156,
0.9486781359,
-0.414583683,
0.5696895719,
0.1565981507,
0.2742237151,
0.1760629267,
0.024994297,
0.7602262497,
-0.0370465443,
0.1600333452,
-0.0084299808,
0.2328903973,
-0.2445438802,
-0.6139239669,
0.5208216906,
-0.4360044897,
-0.1314950138,
-0.2891549766,
-0.4972743988,
-0.0134906163,
0.1136647761,
0.5425251126,
1.055098772,
-0.5550491214,
0.1721998155,
0.325163126,
0.1213805079,
0.6151854992,
0.5152705908,
0.0626974702,
-0.5241242647,
0.6623741984,
0.3209062517,
0.2831167877,
0.6216955781,
-0.0537904352,
-0.1129344478,
-0.828768611,
-0.2680250108,
0.2168553472,
-0.8539773226,
-0.2939661741,
-0.7369508147,
-0.1321481466,
-0.6175726652,
-0.6619708538,
-0.5582979321,
-0.6995968223,
-0.4168695509,
-0.5565277934,
-0.2146236002,
0.7064942718,
-0.2590203583,
0.3819772303,
-1.2905950546,
0.5884378552,
0.072425276,
0.1167430207,
-0.0241765585,
-0.3135539293,
-0.5904420614,
-0.223464489,
-0.7107938528,
-1.2269450426,
0.2828503549,
0.3562860191,
0.61684376,
0.7424503565,
0.282345742,
0.4480704367,
-0.5431423783,
0.9795039892,
0.2283927798,
-0.8888712525,
0.6343868971,
-0.4541354775,
0.4251781702,
0.7880697846,
0.0388265774,
-0.7874525189,
-0.7791615129,
-0.881280899,
-0.9014099836,
0.9269883633,
0.3466466069,
-0.3118067086,
0.0484195463,
0.5225237012,
0.0993625745,
0.2523683012,
-0.5586920977,
-0.4196089506,
0.160802871,
-0.543023169,
-0.4110971689,
-0.3585806191,
-0.1170028523,
0.1463631839,
0.6737421155,
0.0002645952,
-0.1623734832,
0.4282351434,
-0.3398097157,
-0.1679407954,
0.1517883986,
0.8194714189,
0.8212704062,
-0.3757737279,
0.1616481543,
0.5616371036,
-0.4320889115,
-0.0853155181,
0.1236779019,
-0.1626091748,
0.102448605,
0.7292960286,
0.5566239953,
0.3025716841,
-0.6618303061,
0.43266505,
-0.1093526334,
-0.220820725,
-0.0922439247,
-0.3568518162,
-0.0829856396,
0.1853111535,
0.6902464032,
-0.480012536,
0.5457689166,
-0.4953780174,
0.2082068473,
0.3113000393,
-0.1262763888,
-0.6998887062,
0.7302411199,
0.6093666553,
-0.1350600123,
0.1362248361,
-0.1327652186,
-0.4190375805,
0.6728230715,
-0.1139626205,
0.8698514104,
-0.1752652824,
-0.2368777245,
0.5642305017,
0.5246592164,
0.3894503117,
0.1941372156,
-0.3746973574,
-0.3061915636,
-0.4388653934,
-0.2286317647,
-0.4702973962,
0.4389427602,
-0.9107549191,
0.4884387255,
0.0316357277,
0.1081700027,
0.1850052923,
0.0015026798,
-0.4893571138,
0.0605289713,
0.251735419,
0.9849993587,
-0.8680017591,
0.2234915346,
0.6122034192,
-0.0518749915,
-0.2212566286,
-0.3276820481,
0.2465785295,
-0.0729610473,
0.0992140472,
-0.173876822,
0.577467382,
0.0558793172,
-0.0280215275,
-0.9432985187,
1.2669342756,
0.0377036408,
-0.5975782275,
-0.2770843208,
0.2224896252,
0.1066090465,
-0.2063059658,
0.1161275879,
0.7762432098,
0.3149362206,
-0.1786369383,
-0.8856178522,
-0.2960056663,
0.1253623962,
-0.6296753287,
0.5922396779,
-0.5385422111,
0.5405025482,
0.0203772411,
-0.4323124886,
0.0446822904,
0.926286757,
0.0735951141,
0.77714926,
0.2621461451,
0.5902559161,
0.6905670762,
-0.0289413184,
0.9614909887,
-0.3117647767,
0.333027631,
1.1928663254,
-0.2177267522,
0.5386593938,
0.3818514049,
-0.065506205,
-0.0554391146,
0.7163778543,
0.6114390492,
0.7867703438,
-0.1944199055,
-0.149538517,
0.0606602058,
0.3809473813,
-0.4230886698,
0.3599641621,
0.4117256403,
-0.2791486084,
-0.86071527,
-0.0052336287,
-0.1749935299,
-0.2247342765,
-0.7223834991,
1.1877497435,
0.0830614865,
-0.5496982932,
-0.0722943246,
0.1096938699,
0.1734143049,
-0.897903204,
0.1888147891,
-0.3769747019,
0.1289720535,
-0.0328659341,
-0.3559219241,
0.56776613,
0.1252678335,
-0.3247914016,
-0.0002329584,
0.6739962101,
-0.6461322308,
-0.4226120412,
-0.2942858338,
0.3570128977,
0.2704955637,
-0.1621654332,
-0.0584195741,
0.0412146449,
-0.2505219877,
-0.4669819474,
0.4204334915,
0.4060685933,
-0.1020017639,
0.2528420985,
0.4651004672,
0.1369200647,
0.0011982282,
-0.2014139146,
0.7877241373,
-0.731579721,
-1.1094700098,
-0.8301825523,
0.6373039484,
-0.1589948386,
-0.3733604848,
0.5530371666,
1.1122742891,
0.4842463136,
0.1463932842,
0.984003067,
0.2407575548,
0.7158318758,
-0.4722130299,
0.6767736077,
-0.6296864152,
-0.1520312577,
-0.1643045396,
-0.7421904206,
-0.1611616611,
0.1127953976,
0.1544618309,
-0.3848752379,
0.7810025215,
0.4481552243,
0.0287921838,
-0.0488713719,
0.3521234095,
-0.1448957771,
0.3534248769,
0.3386959732,
0.7208715081,
-0.223607704,
0.569118917,
-0.1137906313,
-0.6250676513,
-0.520072639,
-1.0915337801,
-0.9232234955,
-0.9165666699,
-0.4386768937,
0.1052960828,
0.1388978958,
0.710290134,
0.6260946989,
-0.7784801722,
-0.2574980855,
0.2048954219,
0.1404054016,
-0.285473913,
-0.1630112082,
0.4935584962,
-0.3709540367,
-0.7329329252,
0.3915104866,
0.2971556783,
0.0988872722,
0.2636213601,
0.1514863223,
0.1683385819,
0.145249337,
0.4038173258,
0.4175721705,
-0.2730379105,
-0.1598886102,
-0.1121492162,
-0.0121860728,
0.0289167538,
1.1393698454,
-0.4329907894,
0.1679721475,
0.5587594509,
0.4894557893,
0.9528455734,
-0.1514597088,
0.6169142723,
-1.0749956369,
0.198072359,
0.2838815153,
0.3985264897,
-0.176303491,
-0.4096547961,
0.298184514,
0.1978082806,
-0.4480506182,
-1.0294882059,
0.1172696054,
-1.0756345987,
-0.0641150996,
1.0164636374,
0.0543343276,
-0.1413283497,
-0.0679529533,
-0.1425423324,
0.427285701,
-0.2386372983,
0.69627285,
0.8157604933,
-0.1393959969,
0.0780597776,
-0.1840050519,
0.7040184736,
-0.0419238061,
-1.0238772631,
0.3815648258,
0.6630526781,
-0.0079157194,
0.1495264024,
0.8682121038,
-0.153798461,
0.48245278,
-0.132086575,
0.4674287438,
-0.1757047027,
-0.3718959093,
-0.4296949208,
0.3265484571,
-0.2756150365,
-0.3514222205
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06967v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06967v2
|
Instruct Once, Chat Consistently in Multiple Rounds: An Efficient Tuning Framework for Dialogue
| 2024-02-10T14:52:52 | 2024-05-30T04:57:36 |
Jian Wang, Chak Tou Leong, Jiashuo Wang, Dongding Lin, Wenjie Li, Xiao-Yong Wei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Tuning language models for dialogue generation has been a prevalent paradigm
for building capable dialogue agents. Yet, traditional tuning narrowly views
dialogue generation as resembling other language generation tasks, ignoring the
role disparities between two speakers and the multi-round interactive process
that dialogues ought to be. Such a manner often leads to unsatisfactory chat
consistency for the built agent. In this work, we emphasize the interactive,
communicative nature of dialogue and argue that it is more feasible to model
the speaker roles of agent and user separately, enabling the agent to adhere to
its role consistently. With this in mind, we propose an efficient Multi-round
Interactive Dialogue Tuning (Midi-Tuning) framework. It models the agent and
user individually with two adapters built upon large language models. The
adapters make use of respective utterances round by round in alternating order
and they are tuned via a round-level memory caching mechanism. Extensive
experiments demonstrate that, our framework performs superior to traditional
fine-tuning and harbors the tremendous potential for improving dialogue
consistency.
|
[
-0.434305042,
-0.7480216026,
0.4680846334,
0.2344454676,
-0.0270686559,
0.2571161389,
-0.3620595336,
-0.2238263339,
0.0210312326,
0.5931678414,
-0.6659749746,
-0.2405803651,
-0.2199127376,
-0.1278241128,
-0.0292363521,
0.9154183865,
0.4840551615,
0.0113947839,
0.2057771981,
-0.2537679672,
-0.5508925915,
-0.0803044438,
-1.1733620167,
-0.3304495811,
0.4463885725,
0.7243304253,
1.0223014355,
0.5681716204,
0.0903691798,
0.4573747814,
0.2306073606,
0.4491820633,
-0.6184566021,
0.2763437331,
0.1617421806,
-0.3726845086,
-0.5093957782,
0.1153181493,
0.6681539416,
0.4317489266,
-0.6160451174,
-0.2596278787,
-0.1403168142,
0.469466567,
-0.2209593803,
0.127399981,
-1.1042928696,
-0.3707585335,
-0.1400937736,
-0.4414025247,
-0.4814068973,
-0.4687334895,
-0.1183417812,
-1.0842027664,
0.2623561621,
0.208011359,
0.6505329609,
0.3620240986,
-0.4646291733,
-0.1854810864,
-0.6848438978,
0.5133655071,
-0.7946385741,
0.2985340953,
0.3004628122,
0.7724506855,
-0.5129365921,
-0.5376607776,
-0.6333602071,
-0.2791465223,
0.1275848895,
0.0957872197,
0.0209116749,
0.3415299058,
0.2455844134,
0.3091130853,
-0.20579952,
0.0072579477,
-0.0713164285,
-0.290968895,
0.347453773,
0.1279032081,
0.343642354,
0.342032373,
-0.0779231787,
-0.1932546198,
-0.581820488,
0.0292885453,
0.8671533465,
0.5947935581,
-0.0443830043,
0.3793106675,
-0.2244389653,
0.7365349531,
0.5950828195,
-0.3731850684,
-0.1582933962,
-0.5061741471,
0.1249855086,
0.2479993552,
0.4953221083,
0.4964820147,
0.5662575364,
-0.0636541694,
-0.1798658073,
0.0267436989,
0.816596508,
-0.6878839731,
-0.3972221017,
-0.0643989742,
-0.0556986891,
-0.1939022988,
0.051938653,
-0.6591637135,
-0.2446529716,
-0.3406150043,
0.4917390943,
-0.6041849852,
-0.3560608029,
0.1632539332,
-0.0912614241,
0.0240624957,
0.3680992126,
-1.036228776,
0.5113817453,
0.6420794725,
0.7048670053,
0.3259223104,
-0.3033925295,
-0.9645013213,
0.2398654968,
-0.3931591213,
0.8160103559,
-0.859131515,
-0.4308748245,
0.078675665,
0.0320731215,
-0.1506245583,
-0.4587589502,
0.2476206571,
-0.1588108391,
0.1063432619,
-0.1228308454,
-0.4940008521,
0.1280861795,
0.1014490277,
-0.4464787841,
1.0375267267,
0.2770471275,
-0.2832865119,
0.5090821981,
-0.5989123583,
-0.3181459308,
-0.1315514743,
-0.0973244607,
-0.5325954556,
0.3474463522,
0.2622143626,
-0.0196598917,
-0.0320597515,
0.1272367239,
-0.4427843392,
-0.403611511,
0.177786544,
-0.3805185556,
0.2706616819,
0.1525266916,
-0.2039555609,
0.2132759541,
-0.7603648901,
0.1030042171,
-0.3768040538,
-0.1377180964,
-0.0267897416,
0.1662029624,
-0.0503969453,
0.1617168933,
-0.1914008558,
-0.6529886723,
0.4183145761,
-0.5320680737,
0.5416032076,
0.7406129241,
0.0439924486,
0.6740544438,
-0.716911912,
0.4904398918,
0.1538262963,
0.0075919661,
-0.6079054475,
-0.4207336307,
-0.8694815636,
-0.379586637,
0.0953630805,
0.2839552164,
-0.6259710193,
0.4044972658,
-0.09229137,
-0.565746367,
-0.8749320507,
0.0596020781,
0.2632332444,
0.2799216509,
0.0451479927,
-0.2739466429,
-0.1840097159,
-0.9053437114,
-0.1990451813,
-0.293269664,
0.0707950518,
0.4487672746,
0.0099381786,
0.1458719373,
0.8591812849,
-0.2970802188,
-0.0088583082,
-0.079170242,
0.2218778729,
0.0286574159,
0.6716500521,
0.6122750044,
-0.3545304239,
-0.6812307835,
0.2534172535,
-0.2405309826,
-0.2432533652,
-0.5015316606,
-0.5404183269,
0.2053661197,
0.5817306638,
-0.6220549345,
0.43861112,
0.2384169102,
-0.1815127432,
0.3460416496,
-0.2688248158,
0.3852493763,
-1.0452821255,
-0.2166024595,
-0.2383939326,
-0.5409673452,
-0.6966155171,
-0.3454034925,
-0.131920293,
-0.1888456792,
0.055948168,
0.6275110841,
-0.3189424574,
0.1096660793,
-0.4462854862,
0.3590438664,
0.0148882624,
0.6257915497,
-0.2171602547,
0.9938837886,
0.5358690619,
-0.6446620822,
0.1290109009,
0.0870925114,
-0.3475096822,
0.9842234254,
-0.8132461309,
0.2582241893,
0.1563750356,
0.287732482,
-1.0314776897,
-0.1342095584,
0.13993375,
-0.3099930882,
0.5874857903,
-0.2944730222,
-0.5773188472,
0.0050796531,
-0.0909676626,
0.3682813942,
0.2225248069,
-0.5495256186,
0.5574957728,
0.5140690804,
-0.1656508446,
0.0484526642,
0.0616612323,
-0.153480947,
-0.3730120361,
-0.8697558641,
0.1965000927,
-0.3122881353,
-0.1004054993,
-0.5798326731,
-0.4977801144,
0.088936381,
0.0862059668,
0.2595438063,
-0.2690416276,
-0.2186750174,
0.3271032572,
0.1676813215,
-0.3452371359,
-0.4483714104,
-0.5943347216,
0.4906508923,
0.0720014796,
-0.5142549276,
-0.5294396877,
0.5896772742,
0.8117697239,
-0.0369382463,
0.5096307397,
0.5265364051,
-0.0151131954,
-0.1995963752,
-0.8537063003,
-0.3913679123,
-0.5394428968,
0.0851214081,
-0.6068688035,
-0.8976572752,
0.6849481463,
-0.313277781,
0.3981103897,
0.1026443318,
0.600094974,
-0.1550041139,
1.1812649965,
0.938069284,
-0.0016862802,
0.7889887094,
0.2729899883,
0.3015722036,
-0.5385512114,
0.0863670409,
-0.8482151628,
-0.2492835075,
-0.8141981959,
-0.0872491971,
0.6551586986,
0.1780972034,
-0.4712570906,
0.2467458993,
-0.3477200568,
0.4692954123,
0.6173224449,
0.0023490791,
0.2170089185,
-0.0141530577,
-0.2314997613,
0.1218383908,
-0.8204296827,
-0.5980472565,
0.7585343719,
0.1231670901,
0.7605022192,
0.1544551998,
0.5943480134,
0.0041311337,
-0.1352841705,
-0.493283838,
0.3306375742,
0.2080153078,
-0.6876785159,
-0.5278751254,
-0.3685622215,
-0.9323291779,
0.1550872475,
0.0060076434,
-0.977602005,
-0.0799991116,
0.2916424274,
-0.2991423011,
0.0812943056,
-0.7580813766,
0.9304910898,
0.0815031901,
-0.1671254039,
-0.5695509911,
-0.7414672971,
0.1627260745,
-0.044196628,
0.1009229869,
-0.3873259723,
0.240325883,
0.1594694704,
-0.6029333472,
0.7642045617,
-0.1845877469,
-0.0342652388,
0.2075120807,
0.1420300901,
0.5216983557,
0.6215859652,
-0.172006622,
-0.2912385464,
0.2246493101,
-0.6495707631,
-0.8948131204,
0.5137291551,
-0.8091221452,
-0.6626462936,
-0.1715753227,
-0.6401517987,
-0.3986746073,
0.0173548106,
0.0188872404,
0.7289297581,
-0.4309302568,
-0.060229864,
0.5585985184,
-0.1659771055,
0.4391286075,
0.6633056402,
-0.2284151912,
-0.3582008183,
0.8779531717,
-0.2085588723,
0.7238222361,
0.1517967582,
-0.0072739911,
0.0552723333,
-0.0957766026,
-0.6860374808,
0.0531096905,
-0.1554613262,
-0.1906969845,
-0.4710713625,
-0.2145429999,
-0.2691707015,
-0.2914570272,
-0.6434469223,
-0.5742658973,
0.0895266086,
0.0860779434,
0.6093530059,
0.5505839586,
-0.1588736624,
0.8912268877,
-0.7626100779,
0.4819435775,
0.4036300182,
0.5712181926,
-0.2339208722,
-0.4427854717,
-0.4223437607,
0.358556509,
-0.5184776783,
-0.6516430378,
-0.0321798362,
0.6303229332,
0.8204159141,
0.4753026366,
-0.092977263,
0.9768819809,
-0.7801281214,
0.5376362801,
0.1101333648,
-0.8835092783,
0.5755411983,
-0.6703374982,
0.7888777852,
0.9388543963,
-0.2236264348,
-0.6521170735,
-0.8151814342,
-0.556001246,
-0.509824276,
1.1081801653,
0.470162034,
0.2963831127,
-0.0781719759,
0.2694481909,
0.3761793971,
0.378210932,
-0.2992175519,
-0.1014949232,
-0.4085390866,
0.0753694177,
-0.1149817631,
0.0458714366,
-0.2241646349,
-0.2337125242,
0.7396205068,
-0.4249168932,
0.271140635,
-0.1323323101,
0.1142896488,
-0.3691285849,
0.2235183865,
0.6749367714,
0.5770269036,
-0.0665355474,
-0.0862347931,
-0.0241458472,
-0.2952873707,
0.0392149426,
-0.0382219069,
-0.0022744278,
0.0929989666,
0.0169360731,
0.8558468223,
0.6385431886,
-0.2768189311,
-0.0600143559,
-0.1385210305,
0.0115885884,
-0.1548300534,
0.3729099631,
0.1627244502,
0.3506528735,
-0.1130331457,
0.0705102831,
-0.0935729891,
-0.8677450418,
0.3761149645,
0.5374387503,
-0.3514531255,
-0.2404334992,
0.2915054262,
0.4122454226,
-0.6763677001,
0.8675542474,
-0.1831690371,
-0.3286471069,
0.4184051156,
0.4215242863,
0.9911970496,
-0.3452967405,
0.3147425056,
0.3640606105,
0.3108947575,
-0.0790398791,
0.3496260941,
-0.4081176519,
-0.822188139,
-0.0326616913,
-0.6712650061,
-0.3808067739,
-0.465026021,
-0.6094002724,
0.2118547857,
-0.1600527167,
-0.2965963483,
0.3076330423,
0.0502001047,
-0.4066810608,
-0.2234877646,
-0.192585662,
0.7396672368,
-0.3219471276,
1.1547574997,
0.3770792782,
-0.1294036061,
-0.5919368863,
0.045382645,
0.3152579367,
-0.5965989828,
-0.2651043236,
0.2347543389,
-0.3992060721,
0.2343144715,
-0.577367723,
-0.6711888313,
0.7211274505,
0.3267662525,
-0.7187556028,
0.0915564746,
-0.0801415592,
0.5541884899,
-0.6870199442,
0.485488832,
0.7445368171,
0.524194777,
0.3661755621,
-1.2913734913,
-0.3276439905,
-0.2995110452,
-0.0455115587,
0.4989405274,
-0.8856411576,
0.3190244138,
0.0007567933,
-0.2728739977,
0.3760153055,
0.4586513042,
0.3113470376,
0.2989462912,
0.6450704932,
0.4747323692,
0.762986064,
-0.2856873572,
0.6860480905,
-0.7503065467,
-0.0880308896,
1.2590167522,
-0.2728661299,
0.3367083967,
0.1966380626,
0.0557206683,
0.3752764761,
0.4259232283,
0.209529981,
0.4701194167,
0.2991261482,
-0.2636319697,
-0.7419569492,
-0.0016760409,
-0.2735098302,
0.6908920407,
0.3275555968,
0.2248709053,
-0.2982025743,
-0.1182251647,
-0.0623425506,
0.2741074264,
-0.061713405,
1.0381301641,
0.1234584823,
-0.8849538565,
0.1973644793,
-0.1366567165,
0.1792128235,
-0.8127558827,
-0.1606659442,
-0.2863002121,
0.1084863096,
0.126890853,
-0.3074088395,
0.2302419543,
-0.3602932394,
-0.1746718287,
-0.3098120093,
0.3178123534,
-0.6339689493,
-0.5421981812,
-0.0800969303,
0.4817568064,
0.1355916709,
0.1153376624,
-0.5400075316,
0.0154342288,
-0.0707822964,
-0.0728465393,
0.3970274925,
0.8988580108,
0.1024408937,
0.6834495068,
0.4655810595,
-0.2539361715,
0.1421186775,
0.4266512692,
0.8978580832,
-0.633885026,
-0.5488654375,
-0.5008094311,
0.7504312992,
-0.2657321095,
-0.5293677449,
0.7138406634,
0.5154201388,
0.6270197034,
0.3829793632,
0.4726379216,
0.239490658,
0.2434735894,
-0.5548014641,
0.6324039102,
-0.6044954062,
0.3291048706,
-0.3182240725,
-1.0510753393,
0.1189438403,
0.6705973148,
0.3197574317,
0.3182006776,
0.5151065588,
1.2508026361,
-0.207002461,
0.348477006,
0.4932509661,
0.2175627798,
0.2767322361,
0.2931687236,
0.701115787,
-0.2046191692,
0.3452786803,
0.0035945065,
-0.1560454518,
-0.1054636762,
-0.589097023,
-0.9206837416,
-0.5712280273,
-0.340985328,
-0.3005173206,
0.2534798086,
0.8458982706,
1.0679767132,
-0.6809071302,
-0.4822066426,
-0.0756140649,
0.233342275,
-0.4136104882,
-0.1863260716,
-0.3565038145,
-0.882797718,
-0.9268707037,
0.6508027315,
0.7346306443,
-0.2355822623,
-0.0986382291,
0.0181092173,
-0.2123428583,
0.5570753813,
0.302041173,
0.2326826304,
-0.7466927767,
-0.5449688435,
-0.0533616953,
-0.1992110163,
0.2996278405,
1.0253072977,
-0.7505705953,
1.0315003395,
0.0808325857,
0.1473650187,
0.7355111837,
0.0362557769,
1.1877228022,
-0.760081768,
0.0805468261,
-0.042454537,
0.0640014708,
0.0834607407,
-0.1257416904,
0.3310107291,
-0.2117833793,
-0.8917300701,
-0.7194921374,
0.5493718386,
-1.2508796453,
-0.0430000275,
0.7874910235,
0.0165373217,
0.366034776,
-0.325745374,
-0.5628975034,
0.3764661849,
-0.8173359632,
0.8267959356,
0.7283173203,
-0.1476277113,
-0.1698579937,
-0.5471801162,
0.7215940952,
0.2258585989,
-0.6101990938,
0.0394428559,
0.5519579053,
0.0280229468,
0.0225284919,
0.7955853343,
0.2199978828,
0.3365655541,
0.4021248519,
-0.2677732408,
0.0888115019,
-0.5913579464,
-0.0763911158,
0.0647209063,
0.1738082469,
0.0039826245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06964v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06964v1
|
NLP for Knowledge Discovery and Information Extraction from Energetics Corpora
| 2024-02-10T14:43:08 | 2024-02-10T14:43:08 |
Francis G. VanGessel, Efrem Perry, Salil Mohan, Oliver M. Barham, Mark Cavolowsky
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cond-mat.mtrl-sci
|
We present a demonstration of the utility of NLP for aiding research into
energetic materials and associated systems. The NLP method enables machine
understanding of textual data, offering an automated route to knowledge
discovery and information extraction from energetics text. We apply three
established unsupervised NLP models: Latent Dirichlet Allocation, Word2Vec, and
the Transformer to a large curated dataset of energetics-related scientific
articles. We demonstrate that each NLP algorithm is capable of identifying
energetic topics and concepts, generating a language model which aligns with
Subject Matter Expert knowledge. Furthermore, we present a document
classification pipeline for energetics text. Our classification pipeline
achieves 59-76\% accuracy depending on the NLP model used, with the highest
performing Transformer model rivaling inter-annotator agreement metrics. The
NLP approaches studied in this work can identify concepts germane to energetics
and therefore hold promise as a tool for accelerating energetics research
efforts and energetics material development.
|
[
0.0407946147,
-0.3190155625,
0.5034080148,
0.0590362996,
0.071560882,
0.3911138773,
-0.3226340711,
-0.4334075451,
0.3939264715,
0.3567737639,
-0.1566150337,
-0.5141361356,
-0.4940334857,
0.1537145674,
-0.5131448507,
0.693788588,
-0.1092114747,
0.193932876,
-0.3203735948,
0.3505578637,
-0.2477410436,
-0.3664661646,
-0.4779693186,
-0.5422483683,
0.3502168059,
0.1093742847,
0.2692666352,
0.5406118035,
0.74607265,
0.2707761526,
-0.1412990987,
-0.0142914979,
-0.1796991229,
0.2288253307,
-0.4342798591,
-0.2686734498,
0.0046184328,
-0.1409477144,
0.384619683,
0.7622634768,
-0.1474343985,
0.0891495943,
-0.1629022807,
0.5607827902,
-0.6082912683,
0.4172793031,
-1.0039587021,
0.379265219,
-0.3186935484,
-0.6502438784,
-0.4026583433,
0.105374217,
-0.0353877321,
-0.6157214046,
0.3401760161,
0.353525728,
0.6095802784,
0.3420163095,
-0.1249339208,
-0.5667691827,
-0.9387310147,
0.8609740138,
-0.4139043987,
0.5368670821,
0.1308909506,
0.0529956818,
0.1211908236,
-0.9085017443,
-0.5367070436,
0.0795841813,
-0.2812633812,
0.1435022503,
-0.1160348281,
0.0538723134,
0.1106948182,
0.325689435,
-0.8864114881,
0.1190392151,
-0.3985978365,
-0.2367039472,
0.3986941874,
-0.0992932543,
0.1497858763,
-0.4985065758,
-0.4948281348,
-0.2882792056,
-0.410615623,
-0.3850726783,
0.2478410602,
0.4575995803,
0.4299652874,
1.0521322489,
-0.1278357506,
0.1027789339,
-0.2892375588,
0.2303118706,
0.3833616078,
-0.2345510721,
-0.2176108658,
0.3525284827,
0.6761958599,
0.324195832,
-0.4604336321,
-0.4958247244,
-0.2063251287,
-0.0014714259,
0.1790046543,
-0.7337632775,
-0.2334704697,
0.4534670413,
-0.473965466,
-0.2268840075,
0.1871786118,
-0.9448884726,
-0.3704534471,
-0.3194967508,
0.2725090981,
-0.3518225551,
-0.5574065447,
0.4119062126,
-0.8716557622,
-0.0542754605,
-0.0846190453,
-1.155313611,
0.2674423158,
0.7669773102,
0.7964186072,
-0.1373590827,
0.1285167783,
0.0243310705,
0.1751500964,
-0.0813577026,
0.8973670006,
-0.7636455894,
-0.2207551748,
0.0527978577,
-0.0258175358,
-0.0809555948,
-0.6663763523,
0.7241463065,
-0.6671450734,
0.2018502355,
-0.154888168,
-0.8343015313,
-0.2514973879,
-0.1645347923,
-0.4404500723,
1.2145231962,
0.1409609169,
-1.0077632666,
0.2023825943,
-1.046207428,
-0.0308457576,
0.3531112373,
-0.0397492833,
0.0984069034,
0.2516669631,
-0.2180631161,
0.5004885793,
-0.4900667071,
0.1696934402,
0.1307464689,
0.3438270688,
-0.0802160427,
-0.1698732078,
0.4238071144,
0.4580786228,
-0.1630657911,
0.0239002742,
-0.8271735311,
-0.0035278858,
0.1582460403,
-0.154976517,
-0.6820489764,
0.2610783279,
0.386061132,
0.1857817173,
0.3211784661,
-0.5498483777,
0.1682205796,
-0.3490229249,
0.1888773739,
0.3876233697,
0.1107818559,
0.574211061,
0.0882886052,
0.3639949858,
-0.4070861638,
-0.3816109002,
-0.0996223837,
-0.2991808057,
-0.6096596718,
0.3530044854,
0.3026724458,
0.68431741,
-0.8962955475,
0.8464176655,
-0.022783177,
-0.8898249269,
-0.2899211943,
0.0574938469,
0.0867389515,
0.6225047112,
0.6848149896,
0.1305583566,
-0.7757468224,
-0.7438633442,
-0.3287172914,
-0.309653163,
-0.5281129479,
0.181645453,
0.5279196501,
-0.1825139523,
0.701503098,
-0.7473185062,
-0.0530437864,
0.0609926879,
0.5928605199,
0.1942765713,
0.6407667398,
0.4756961763,
-1.0280013084,
-0.2375559062,
0.2363215387,
-0.9915842414,
-0.2662857175,
0.0325747207,
-0.1728210151,
-0.1923112571,
0.6413171291,
-0.4261098504,
-0.0847410113,
0.4093171656,
-0.4219829142,
0.3604892492,
0.0921197981,
0.0906462297,
-0.9808554053,
0.4654563069,
0.2084864825,
-0.0413515307,
-0.6294674277,
-0.1760101318,
-0.2128199041,
-0.1275689304,
-0.57478863,
0.418939054,
-0.3135760725,
-0.1267530769,
-0.4424807131,
-0.0170511156,
0.2009607553,
0.1327560842,
0.6323609948,
0.5676758885,
0.4151043594,
-0.4789226055,
0.6377353072,
0.3965454102,
-0.3289031982,
0.1217602938,
-0.4801824987,
0.1282455474,
0.0057487171,
0.070976004,
-0.4496921003,
-0.190472886,
-0.0746352077,
-0.3234139383,
0.6322006583,
-0.0163453091,
-0.6266801357,
-0.3110759854,
0.027391199,
-0.1275746077,
0.200635314,
-0.3066907525,
0.765481174,
0.4797642529,
-0.4045270383,
-0.4725358188,
-0.27178213,
-0.0212219395,
-0.285117358,
-0.4618181288,
0.719571054,
-0.2635176182,
-0.3907285333,
0.111642018,
-0.3188447356,
-0.179043442,
0.199787885,
0.2185673267,
0.038783405,
-0.1757206917,
0.7027648091,
-0.0607266054,
-0.2331621051,
0.2855995297,
-0.6182082295,
0.7902515531,
-0.0803416967,
0.1175705791,
-0.1758769006,
0.5018792152,
0.2632697523,
0.1560174227,
1.0006456375,
0.7908156514,
-0.6110517383,
0.095809944,
-0.145479396,
-0.2797436714,
-0.4175957143,
0.4806599319,
0.0274430271,
-0.3779447973,
0.26327914,
-0.5342621207,
0.2389050126,
1.2865635157,
0.4624769688,
-0.2077401578,
0.7378358841,
0.9071852565,
0.108104296,
0.3026806414,
-0.5158827901,
0.0235603768,
-0.8163683414,
-0.7178347111,
-1.1254823208,
-0.1492989063,
-0.2848145068,
-0.514502883,
0.0997788608,
-0.0049178926,
0.2192675769,
0.5566167831,
-0.6565510035,
0.518056035,
0.1525779963,
-0.2265742868,
0.0546371676,
-0.0546380989,
0.0268745515,
-0.0749841556,
-0.7640885711,
-0.670961678,
0.8019696474,
0.2349652797,
0.6824640632,
-0.1414878815,
0.3466630578,
0.3194532692,
0.1020725518,
-0.7751426101,
0.2324267179,
0.0161542036,
-0.858032763,
-0.2062877119,
-0.487981081,
-0.8421019316,
-0.0833387002,
-0.6021852493,
-0.5980495214,
0.0381672122,
-0.2563507855,
-0.2326811701,
0.4744943678,
-0.7853708267,
0.79393363,
-0.3605857491,
-0.2143694311,
-0.2087480724,
-0.8198527694,
-0.052367419,
-0.3044950962,
0.2488278896,
-0.162708655,
0.0888230726,
1.2794526815,
-0.0875364169,
0.3807835281,
-0.1627983004,
-0.3028941453,
0.1749976128,
-0.2627010643,
0.2727530003,
-0.0387308225,
-0.4836294651,
0.3614696264,
-0.0778609291,
-0.1622349471,
-0.6475313306,
0.6153388619,
-0.4069691896,
-0.4048169553,
-0.5520816445,
-0.4073395133,
-0.0260508824,
0.2930127382,
0.3410482109,
0.2142529786,
-0.2048961669,
0.6610329747,
0.6137031913,
-0.1817614734,
0.620842278,
0.476307869,
-0.2080989778,
0.0557374768,
0.9139428735,
-0.0519853793,
-0.0681807697,
0.9802367091,
0.2267623246,
-0.4667512476,
-0.6640393734,
0.0081674624,
-0.0818172991,
-0.6375030279,
-0.5149930716,
-0.8729978204,
-0.2883398235,
-0.4097210467,
-0.221847713,
-0.6081930399,
-0.7817769051,
-0.6416661739,
-0.468893528,
0.1456746757,
0.7740671039,
-0.2912597954,
0.105525516,
-0.9316195846,
0.3038705289,
0.0199313983,
0.0227310937,
-0.4358634353,
-0.2476933151,
-0.5658457875,
-0.2271413207,
-0.2957365811,
-0.898462832,
0.5221418142,
0.1981249303,
0.513471067,
0.4150305688,
0.0897370204,
-0.1388826817,
-0.4934417605,
1.0083016157,
0.3934223652,
-0.7358413935,
0.8138361573,
-0.264851898,
-0.1337926835,
0.4566984177,
0.8196769357,
-0.3666650653,
-0.0248154327,
-1.0073165894,
-1.0988425016,
0.3403342664,
0.4473266602,
-0.1666420996,
-0.0675044805,
0.3811472654,
0.1943762749,
0.3450065553,
-0.4443381727,
-0.4135636985,
-0.2374244481,
-0.1715951562,
0.0547476485,
0.0138503816,
-0.2148218751,
0.0920759216,
1.0996780396,
-0.2506087422,
0.2332083583,
0.1498921365,
-0.0355709195,
-0.0944725946,
0.3234317601,
0.367922008,
0.349796176,
-0.6284205317,
0.2315354049,
0.000617552,
-0.4785841703,
-0.0789153129,
0.2544154823,
0.0364104174,
0.3322436512,
0.2295595556,
0.5796607137,
-0.0450545102,
-0.6302194595,
0.0951773226,
-0.2997068167,
-0.1345486343,
-0.2742886841,
0.110620141,
-0.0165754426,
0.2894551754,
0.6738066673,
0.5410230756,
0.3785134852,
-0.5200175047,
0.2617247105,
0.4068045318,
-0.2877918482,
-0.5891294479,
0.6479861736,
0.431284368,
-0.2396319509,
0.2981129885,
-0.0587727763,
-0.5490608811,
0.5322074294,
0.4805431664,
0.715592742,
-0.0585686751,
0.1978410631,
0.4210115969,
0.3101140857,
-0.0436775088,
0.1245270073,
-0.0170527399,
-0.8046976924,
-0.1905271262,
-0.7762829065,
-0.4007223547,
0.1662397832,
-0.5747169852,
0.2589195371,
-0.2079619616,
-0.1039880365,
0.5456869602,
0.2848111987,
-0.7098938227,
0.1203382313,
0.2307329923,
1.0307449102,
-1.0283968449,
0.521787107,
0.498437196,
-0.331875205,
-0.5986097455,
-0.2821297348,
0.0996093079,
-0.4439024329,
0.9629983902,
-0.0483137257,
0.149783954,
0.1136130616,
-0.6080948114,
-0.8839720488,
1.1464701891,
0.2121024877,
-0.5004561543,
-0.0753211305,
-0.2615582347,
0.4705492258,
-0.3500196636,
0.3423715234,
0.3735971749,
0.7326859236,
0.1641606092,
-0.5531176925,
-0.3387694061,
-0.4542586505,
-0.4037261903,
0.2093141526,
-0.492616564,
0.3447809815,
0.1396994293,
-0.3027169704,
-0.1872955114,
1.0644903183,
-0.1173621714,
0.532384038,
0.5012390018,
0.3952147365,
1.011225462,
-0.0420756154,
1.013453126,
-0.3746542335,
0.5607001185,
0.7451167107,
-0.4961593747,
0.8161404133,
0.5959522128,
-0.2186273038,
0.556432724,
0.5207898617,
0.1177418306,
0.4488733113,
0.2564450204,
-0.3567127883,
-0.0420386754,
-0.8603807688,
-0.4459729493,
0.5496126413,
0.7610179186,
-0.3609177768,
0.0082665524,
-0.2475946993,
-0.0804150477,
0.027654361,
-0.0662726164,
0.7794724703,
-0.0277081914,
-0.3473651707,
-0.0529727191,
0.1290672123,
0.4814570248,
-0.8599348664,
-0.142303735,
0.2968708277,
-0.1886487007,
-0.3436734974,
-0.8466715813,
0.6633383036,
0.1058684886,
-0.5204407573,
-0.5864494443,
1.1523164511,
-0.3815143108,
-0.291900456,
0.1960186213,
0.4035761654,
0.2549160719,
-0.0148970224,
-0.5570461154,
-0.290759027,
0.0490094982,
-0.2925641239,
0.2372240573,
0.4077284336,
0.7018576264,
0.2264219671,
0.803425014,
0.0950805768,
-0.2396370918,
0.0597320609,
0.9259643555,
-0.7156368494,
-0.0156796798,
-0.3323780298,
0.3209015429,
-0.3686728179,
-0.1534471959,
0.7310082912,
0.9808936119,
0.6251302958,
-0.0473755077,
0.8900555968,
-0.2503218055,
0.6524121165,
-1.0314188004,
0.5275108218,
-0.3725190759,
0.3330250978,
-0.1524763107,
-0.8193799853,
-0.2322814167,
0.5732274652,
0.1905786544,
-0.1684719622,
1.1050174236,
0.4154723585,
0.1973066777,
0.1122773364,
0.0688739643,
0.1629271954,
0.4999139309,
0.176265344,
0.6377461553,
-0.4811834395,
0.1118252724,
-0.3672495186,
-0.0462939478,
-0.0489125438,
-1.0178406239,
-0.5565284491,
-0.7539640069,
-0.42309919,
-0.2582160532,
-0.3890111148,
1.1096826792,
0.6285952926,
-0.7030066848,
0.0006281279,
-0.2320498526,
0.1916899681,
-0.1044268012,
-0.3212298155,
0.3519695997,
-0.2745520175,
-0.5817055702,
0.9662150741,
0.4492382705,
0.0494374745,
-0.2522655129,
0.1190847605,
-0.3820093572,
0.1830030829,
0.4330624938,
0.4134330451,
-0.075513795,
-0.242129907,
0.2711776495,
0.2769298553,
0.0588328354,
1.0473657846,
-0.7109472752,
0.3508105576,
0.7086991668,
0.7490287423,
0.3629428446,
-0.2516165674,
0.4793755412,
-1.2214554548,
0.296515435,
0.5956463814,
0.5664696097,
0.5123242736,
-0.4867128134,
0.7746677995,
0.4949667454,
-0.7359015942,
-0.4715563655,
-0.0053915726,
-1.1765401363,
-0.3605315387,
1.27709198,
0.1082582846,
-0.1343829334,
-0.1444001943,
-0.0525300093,
0.2345196754,
-0.4953107536,
0.7414752841,
0.630859375,
-0.0777752474,
0.17472139,
-0.6567775011,
0.5410419106,
0.2082259655,
-1.1573174,
0.2550127804,
0.2709631026,
-0.2702407837,
0.8963698149,
0.2074102461,
0.0244064331,
-0.4678693414,
0.0828375965,
0.2883657217,
0.2760307789,
-0.5504111648,
0.0733433738,
0.2436863929,
-0.3823130131,
0.3320018947
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06959v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06959v1
|
SpeechCLIP+: Self-supervised multi-task representation learning for speech via CLIP and speech-image data
| 2024-02-10T14:26:42 | 2024-02-10T14:26:42 |
Hsuan-Fu Wang, Yi-Jen Shih, Heng-Jui Chang, Layne Berry, Puyuan Peng, Hung-yi Lee, Hsin-Min Wang, David Harwath
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
The recently proposed visually grounded speech model SpeechCLIP is an
innovative framework that bridges speech and text through images via CLIP
without relying on text transcription. On this basis, this paper introduces two
extensions to SpeechCLIP. First, we apply the Continuous Integrate-and-Fire
(CIF) module to replace a fixed number of CLS tokens in the cascaded
architecture. Second, we propose a new hybrid architecture that merges the
cascaded and parallel architectures of SpeechCLIP into a multi-task learning
framework. Our experimental evaluation is performed on the Flickr8k and
SpokenCOCO datasets. The results show that in the speech keyword extraction
task, the CIF-based cascaded SpeechCLIP model outperforms the previous cascaded
SpeechCLIP model using a fixed number of CLS tokens. Furthermore, through our
hybrid architecture, cascaded task learning boosts the performance of the
parallel branch in image-speech retrieval tasks.
|
[
-0.2690223455,
-0.3851737678,
0.1859732717,
0.3669269085,
-0.3169389367,
0.2463916838,
-0.2915515006,
-0.4306623638,
0.4176642597,
0.3930993676,
-0.5301833749,
-0.6606900692,
-0.65865165,
-0.3242982626,
-0.3750368357,
0.8554149866,
0.2911224961,
0.237404421,
-0.2775779963,
-0.3659147024,
-0.6815980077,
-0.7559817433,
-0.2841270566,
-0.2614063919,
0.1905759871,
0.523000896,
0.4272283614,
0.5806893706,
0.2934259474,
0.2192798257,
0.1489728838,
-0.0534632429,
-0.086990267,
-0.0098121921,
-0.2094195634,
-0.3237582743,
-0.2672440708,
-0.0574245155,
0.4668001235,
0.4421177208,
-0.0530081503,
0.2767166793,
0.1076717824,
0.2950849831,
-0.8343529701,
0.3934352696,
-0.7747486234,
0.0713569149,
-0.4809825122,
-0.0954422429,
-0.308937192,
0.3244736195,
0.2461398244,
-0.327129066,
0.044154074,
-0.2067585737,
0.4119548798,
0.0681206658,
-0.3190680742,
-0.3414326012,
-0.5541729927,
0.8718951344,
-0.3666702211,
0.2984804809,
-0.1298985779,
0.321077466,
0.2606438398,
-0.8062080741,
-0.3539544344,
-0.0873403475,
0.2819915712,
0.2066716105,
0.0669018701,
0.1743407696,
0.1011229157,
0.3131181598,
-0.3819812834,
0.1620222628,
-0.3012363017,
-0.3977454305,
0.2562946677,
-0.0037853206,
0.5014597774,
-0.3596523106,
-0.6728092432,
-0.4793596864,
-0.4975506365,
0.306643486,
0.0503551848,
0.3483734727,
-0.2977839708,
0.2686805129,
0.1956109852,
0.4494839907,
0.067178078,
-0.507959187,
0.4298617244,
-0.1820542514,
-0.1403883249,
0.2366835028,
0.7228581905,
0.0777573362,
0.0296993721,
-0.0095149009,
0.27571702,
0.3356082141,
-0.1024596691,
-0.4790704846,
-0.2877393663,
0.3023935854,
-0.2957646251,
-0.1374484152,
0.2254848033,
-0.6461194158,
0.079622902,
-0.3548030853,
0.3963212669,
-0.4616574645,
-0.4021021128,
0.0753213912,
-0.5255588293,
0.1467828602,
0.1262140274,
-0.6115600467,
0.6077628732,
0.6288200021,
0.9362553358,
-0.7653672695,
-0.4932222664,
-0.6593090296,
0.4262413681,
-0.1613248438,
0.7538715005,
-0.5354080796,
-0.550021112,
0.1116418019,
-0.0245218016,
-0.2840891778,
-0.7086092234,
0.7179708481,
-0.1658004671,
0.0479937606,
-0.1732881516,
-0.4092007875,
-0.311442554,
-0.1236298531,
-0.5791378617,
1.1225976944,
-0.3305633068,
-0.8609751463,
0.2735648453,
-0.7448609471,
-0.5107183456,
0.2370412946,
-0.4710353613,
-0.4099517167,
-0.2713604271,
0.5354127884,
0.5784595013,
-0.0967995524,
0.5750747919,
-0.6750584245,
-0.1427847743,
-0.1016562656,
-0.2094507068,
0.7998979688,
0.0031453627,
-0.4992668927,
0.3105169833,
-0.570156455,
0.1407332867,
-0.2537912726,
-0.0060897558,
-0.2121772021,
0.052301757,
0.3956211507,
0.5077775121,
0.1068215072,
-0.7362995148,
-0.0295335557,
-0.0179290697,
0.7248938084,
0.2791047394,
-0.0519933477,
0.3346674442,
-0.2707523108,
0.4838407934,
0.179516539,
0.0401671417,
-0.5614830256,
-0.3048606515,
-0.3803560436,
-0.9587022066,
0.1752155721,
0.6170176268,
-0.6649915576,
0.2078160197,
-0.3833082616,
-0.4476160407,
-0.4976644218,
0.0917087048,
0.6209803224,
0.5435172915,
0.4088132381,
-0.4288406074,
-0.5496863723,
-0.9512723684,
-0.0588116758,
-0.03139963,
0.1169533432,
0.2668387294,
0.4709300697,
0.1986110657,
1.0224248171,
-0.1804165542,
-0.7569317818,
-0.4037595093,
0.4789147973,
0.1118869409,
0.7137023211,
0.6773247719,
-0.9153194427,
-0.4341458678,
-0.2995411754,
-0.4541992247,
0.0517359078,
-0.1588442326,
0.216760695,
-0.406147033,
0.4383035004,
-0.6376904249,
0.3620181382,
0.5412989259,
0.432007879,
0.5850983858,
0.0333568454,
0.0967078805,
-0.8104159832,
-0.0197961014,
-0.1422179639,
-0.4364385009,
-0.5139594078,
-0.0291892998,
0.1125313044,
-0.7002423406,
-1.0366758108,
0.2578495741,
-0.5618520379,
-0.3584007919,
-0.5341092944,
0.0861456543,
-0.1155521646,
0.6928412914,
0.3802928627,
0.9774916768,
1.1169118881,
-0.4219574332,
0.2265432328,
0.2064298242,
-0.1538418978,
0.4299845994,
-0.6314506531,
0.2455317229,
-0.0013804806,
0.4474441409,
-1.0184139013,
-0.3059231043,
-0.0303300992,
-0.2665939331,
0.1806578934,
-0.1413661242,
-0.6098777652,
-0.4004500508,
-0.4314824939,
0.5807839036,
0.2538689971,
-0.7586925626,
0.5192783475,
0.8441627026,
-0.1716448814,
-0.4282267094,
-0.6050869226,
0.1131018028,
-0.2039390504,
-0.5291508436,
0.9288514256,
0.2395339012,
0.446919769,
-0.0068280571,
0.0186220147,
-0.1545373946,
-0.4249463975,
0.5962403417,
0.0859241933,
-0.0036242243,
0.1256882995,
0.1455988288,
0.088666521,
-0.1990915239,
-0.1822868586,
0.6439806819,
-0.1434829533,
-0.5280899405,
-0.6445814967,
0.7788048983,
0.8108244538,
-0.4859819412,
0.1389385015,
0.5898907185,
-0.2686071098,
-0.1111894399,
-0.5382539034,
0.0796050131,
-0.430534631,
0.3215652406,
-0.4206094742,
-1.078035593,
0.3586669266,
-0.4170424938,
-0.0377256647,
0.4255183339,
0.5070465803,
-0.1516263783,
0.8697721362,
0.7944075465,
-0.3513398767,
0.5735341311,
-0.3043418825,
-0.2503311932,
-0.9298665524,
-0.2017794847,
-0.2394260019,
-0.2049703747,
-0.2469259053,
-0.5002474785,
0.5472283363,
0.2363407761,
0.0413427353,
0.7117954493,
-0.6044178605,
0.1334237158,
0.6773381829,
0.2228805721,
0.026369039,
-0.0352343731,
-0.3461274505,
-0.2801781297,
-0.7436009049,
-0.1234747693,
0.8214654922,
0.3237293065,
0.4832753241,
-0.38280797,
0.6443835497,
0.4650496244,
0.0899874866,
-0.6144220233,
0.5707722902,
-0.355368197,
-0.6113069654,
-0.1137429848,
0.2103096247,
-0.3777440786,
0.4937150478,
-0.1364650726,
-0.8200975657,
0.5122733712,
0.3174499869,
-0.2106910795,
0.1830264628,
-0.6674300432,
0.7714764476,
-0.4611526132,
-0.1507089734,
-0.5975143313,
-0.6257993579,
0.4327505231,
0.2328491211,
0.3116459548,
-0.2640611827,
0.1739982665,
0.92419976,
-0.1886092573,
1.1042810678,
-0.277236551,
0.4391811192,
0.6917572618,
-0.2239322811,
0.1648548096,
-0.2337566316,
0.0577555411,
0.3173292279,
0.2724213302,
-0.1842822433,
-0.5410052538,
0.6880106926,
-0.3754329681,
-0.3999244571,
-0.3747430444,
-0.4295738041,
-0.1948918402,
0.1863973588,
0.0832538158,
0.8442685008,
-0.0133470213,
0.3155183196,
0.1818838567,
-0.0603923202,
0.742184341,
0.0349965841,
-0.2199337035,
-0.9835519791,
0.9516749382,
0.0643758848,
0.1405062973,
0.2589039505,
0.0864033625,
-0.3616277874,
-0.2886082232,
-0.207137987,
0.2166850418,
-0.7661330104,
-0.0393239297,
-0.6497242451,
-0.1731546372,
-0.5897223949,
0.2141947597,
-0.4050175846,
-0.4085903764,
-0.500598371,
0.0034107922,
0.1025864929,
0.1411910802,
-0.115881525,
0.5172374845,
-0.6566235423,
0.4571156204,
0.2535581291,
-0.1151452661,
0.0577416793,
-0.379080981,
0.0302432142,
-0.2742182314,
-0.6009044647,
-0.9870176315,
0.4139700532,
0.7069088817,
0.5067834854,
0.4352704883,
0.0354917608,
1.1530789137,
-0.78158319,
0.874796927,
0.6504570842,
-1.1579480171,
0.4907308221,
-0.2974607348,
0.3722444773,
0.4751324952,
0.4173929691,
-0.3447625935,
-0.2839280069,
-0.6516547799,
-0.5682600141,
0.4576459825,
-0.0107651968,
0.1707778722,
0.0487852022,
0.1512161046,
0.0712220594,
0.4654497206,
-0.8023899794,
-0.2899041772,
-0.4033867717,
-0.2405617088,
0.293780297,
-0.2025057971,
-0.133410573,
-0.5721279383,
0.2190039605,
-0.2790589035,
0.3734100759,
0.3564410508,
-0.1238999888,
0.3779685199,
0.2932142913,
0.4249690473,
0.2967943251,
0.0965289995,
0.2882237732,
-0.1072458178,
-0.3512098193,
-0.055833213,
-0.1643883735,
0.2505090237,
0.2256457657,
0.5929099917,
0.998867631,
0.7495999336,
-0.7771195769,
0.8396440148,
0.4879895151,
-0.4135354459,
-0.3498745859,
-0.003250564,
0.1146769747,
0.1368087381,
0.6141014099,
0.1402784884,
0.4403933883,
-0.734613955,
0.7436054945,
0.6517152786,
-0.4042152464,
-0.4422756135,
0.6859931946,
0.2408433557,
-0.2854215503,
0.0293750409,
0.1611111015,
-0.8761873841,
0.4160478413,
0.588313818,
0.7982760072,
-0.0136764413,
0.4246041179,
0.1769295484,
-0.1220011935,
-0.0388175845,
0.2607266605,
-0.6652143002,
-0.2876695096,
-0.4579535723,
-0.1713307947,
-0.5729620457,
0.0932325497,
-0.7449906468,
0.4313175976,
-0.4094619453,
-0.4126445055,
0.0859877691,
-0.4078599811,
-0.4301605225,
0.1068147644,
0.2366916537,
0.8034867048,
-0.8522578478,
1.1244210005,
0.3905569911,
-0.1487753391,
-0.5773691535,
-0.1294775456,
-0.0961023942,
-0.5927024484,
0.9204961061,
0.4133118093,
-0.3148538172,
-0.0101063317,
-0.6602301598,
-1.1074818373,
0.9035702944,
0.480641216,
-0.5668799281,
-0.0244961046,
0.0837910622,
0.369223237,
-0.7617091537,
0.1523214579,
0.1159701943,
-0.0834090337,
0.3178932071,
-1.1480467319,
-0.4383386075,
0.0130042108,
0.0559699573,
-0.1693440676,
-0.5599167347,
0.7020045519,
0.0699095279,
-0.4390669167,
-0.0937297419,
1.0316823721,
0.2259039283,
0.1833221167,
0.6900286674,
0.4106705189,
0.2897003293,
0.1171346679,
0.5958606601,
-0.3542876244,
0.3842557073,
1.5610823631,
-0.3747626841,
1.2326931953,
0.568967402,
0.0245259255,
0.5618196726,
0.3465634584,
0.0188923515,
1.0044820309,
-0.1331908852,
-0.2810886502,
-0.4184695482,
-0.240602538,
-0.102433458,
0.5355253816,
0.4861152768,
-0.070901759,
-0.6156336069,
0.6837175488,
-0.3227969408,
0.0854225829,
-0.1605384499,
0.5776963234,
0.194541648,
-0.5795203447,
0.3802919984,
-0.1910390258,
0.794166863,
-0.4061328769,
-0.2484223545,
0.6106928587,
0.0111620435,
-0.2006422728,
-0.6412485242,
0.347920537,
-0.213910073,
-0.0392734744,
-0.2336970866,
0.7756220698,
-0.5437746644,
-0.3285994828,
0.5137001872,
0.0790443793,
0.0499281213,
-0.0570071377,
-1.0695177317,
0.3985593319,
-0.2546004057,
0.3745448589,
0.1732955426,
-0.0417590998,
-0.0398136638,
0.693353653,
0.5860655904,
0.0907627642,
0.426184237,
0.0387272164,
0.8362234235,
-0.2676621974,
-0.6798706055,
-0.5501897931,
0.4435557127,
-0.2138763219,
-0.2660041153,
0.6063017249,
0.4606437981,
0.6958877444,
-0.2191787511,
0.7420645356,
-0.0732220709,
0.8899162412,
-0.4264591634,
0.149709478,
-0.2566901743,
-0.2165451348,
-0.5594395995,
-0.4685438871,
-0.2940393984,
0.2149950713,
-0.3299564123,
-0.3351982236,
0.7604975104,
0.4395501018,
-0.2238287032,
-0.0571225807,
0.3055544496,
-0.3820235133,
0.3485813439,
0.3326836824,
0.4371956587,
-0.454762727,
0.5841428638,
-0.4671584666,
-0.27320081,
0.0620343722,
-0.8423351645,
-0.8618950248,
-0.8646146059,
-0.6357142925,
0.3348020017,
-0.0491712093,
0.78313905,
1.2428138256,
-0.7348249555,
-0.444355458,
0.0085845599,
-0.2584546804,
-0.4482780099,
-0.2388983667,
0.5731983185,
-0.3123919964,
-0.6494162679,
0.5262796879,
0.6195037961,
-0.1657005697,
-0.165920943,
0.2430831045,
-0.3028636873,
-0.2885744572,
0.4879387915,
0.6431813836,
-0.9308301806,
-0.2185112089,
-0.199133873,
0.1070161909,
0.3278242946,
1.0303709507,
-0.8034346104,
0.4358908534,
0.1258338988,
0.7479284406,
0.8219915032,
0.0978339016,
0.4271838069,
-0.684030354,
0.6350077987,
0.1137999967,
0.3128829896,
0.3372105956,
-0.1195118576,
-0.1457242519,
0.4868599474,
-0.167647019,
-0.671797514,
0.3136621118,
-1.3133003712,
-0.0998581573,
0.7483229041,
-0.2425683886,
-0.392126739,
-0.0403434224,
-0.3133969903,
0.0686859936,
-0.3677581251,
0.3588879406,
0.6109772325,
-0.3648846149,
-0.7020019889,
-0.3271856308,
0.3231236935,
0.5537108779,
-0.559751451,
-0.1581198573,
0.2213382572,
0.3366589546,
0.3786460757,
0.692194283,
-0.4213698506,
0.3765313625,
-0.2751452923,
0.1911246628,
-0.1752099842,
-0.6328174472,
-0.2513382435,
0.6511082053,
-0.3164155781,
-0.8705617189
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06954v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06954v1
|
OpenFedLLM: Training Large Language Models on Decentralized Private Data via Federated Learning
| 2024-02-10T13:50:11 | 2024-02-10T13:50:11 |
Rui Ye, Wenhao Wang, Jingyi Chai, Dihan Li, Zexi Li, Yinda Xu, Yaxin Du, Yanfeng Wang, Siheng Chen
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.DC, cs.MA
|
Trained on massive publicly available data, large language models (LLMs) have
demonstrated tremendous success across various fields. While more data
contributes to better performance, a disconcerting reality is that high-quality
public data will be exhausted in a few years. In this paper, we offer a
potential next step for contemporary LLMs: collaborative and privacy-preserving
LLM training on the underutilized distributed private data via federated
learning (FL), where multiple data owners collaboratively train a shared model
without transmitting raw data. To achieve this, we build a concise, integrated,
and research-friendly framework/codebase, named OpenFedLLM. It covers federated
instruction tuning for enhancing instruction-following capability, federated
value alignment for aligning with human values, and 7 representative FL
algorithms. Besides, OpenFedLLM supports training on diverse domains, where we
cover 8 training datasets; and provides comprehensive evaluations, where we
cover 30+ evaluation metrics. Through extensive experiments, we observe that
all FL algorithms outperform local training on training LLMs, demonstrating a
clear performance improvement across a variety of settings. Notably, in a
financial benchmark, Llama2-7B fine-tuned by applying any FL algorithm can
outperform GPT-4 by a significant margin while the model obtained through
individual training cannot, demonstrating strong motivation for clients to
participate in FL. The code is available at
https://github.com/rui-ye/OpenFedLLM.
|
[
-0.2408367991,
-0.4899299443,
0.3764517009,
0.3439128995,
0.0414437354,
0.2438828349,
-0.68928653,
-0.3826273084,
-0.1881386936,
0.6567177176,
-0.4086416662,
-0.7860873342,
-0.4691485763,
-0.0763046667,
-0.1183058843,
1.0674430132,
-0.23904486,
0.4195172489,
-0.4822049141,
-0.3046243787,
0.0664319843,
-0.5173172355,
-0.1576773673,
-0.4893988073,
0.2155469805,
0.5717070699,
0.646828711,
0.8225883842,
0.6279025078,
0.2791747153,
0.3444543183,
0.2449089587,
-0.9559355974,
-0.0613447353,
-0.224068895,
-0.5694892406,
-0.5057196021,
0.2644211948,
0.830504179,
0.8217914701,
-0.4029050767,
0.209137246,
-0.1449942142,
0.8426083922,
-0.69516927,
0.7753913403,
-0.3561676443,
0.2142473608,
-0.2381305993,
-0.0445972458,
-0.5442724228,
-0.7865098119,
0.110336259,
-0.3981181383,
0.1643107086,
0.1360547394,
0.561661005,
0.0932276621,
-0.0676397532,
-0.027301183,
-0.6766575575,
0.7535945773,
-0.403439492,
0.5315998793,
0.4292270243,
0.1857741028,
-0.1649908721,
-0.7033022642,
-0.1481873393,
0.1092855409,
-0.1256740391,
-0.0219110437,
-0.1691416502,
0.2069522589,
-0.1336730123,
0.9221870899,
-0.4029740989,
0.4085781276,
-0.096161589,
-0.0531587265,
0.7019894123,
0.0478443913,
-0.15363805,
0.6051056385,
-0.6603292823,
-0.0958351493,
-0.6810469031,
0.0733578354,
0.5438002348,
0.3670997918,
-0.2316555381,
0.382982105,
-0.4360644221,
0.5248978138,
0.1886733174,
-0.3448642194,
0.3360019922,
-0.1490607858,
-0.4769923091,
0.0445037,
0.6799097061,
-0.0324127749,
0.1197313666,
-0.5537601709,
-0.6030389071,
-0.3032434881,
-0.1441534758,
-0.8160753846,
-0.3068073094,
0.1888974458,
-0.3082184196,
-0.4010478556,
0.2870900929,
-0.8005303144,
-0.3865666091,
-0.5410134792,
0.1813040972,
-0.0529653206,
-0.4603147209,
0.2890114784,
0.3344244659,
0.0728254169,
0.2748231292,
-1.2179834843,
0.6913625002,
1.2625615597,
0.8035102487,
-0.1686446369,
-0.377799958,
-1.0674427748,
-0.0691475496,
-0.1698562354,
0.4059778452,
-0.4838232994,
-0.0513346009,
0.0880501121,
-0.0559127741,
-0.1901952475,
-0.4779532254,
-0.1201346442,
-0.6629531384,
0.4708812535,
-0.0536676832,
-0.745868504,
-0.0994868129,
0.253623426,
-0.4978476763,
0.4546041787,
0.2694966495,
-0.7367440462,
0.0366493613,
-0.7088279128,
-0.2983586788,
0.0873339549,
-0.3424087465,
-0.6771109104,
0.0877013579,
0.1428637654,
0.6136977673,
-0.3475649059,
0.4612263441,
-0.5548471808,
-0.4765239954,
0.193867445,
-0.257391721,
0.8366265893,
0.0306013972,
-0.5029993653,
0.3537483513,
-0.728307426,
0.0836526826,
0.1092951447,
-0.5382783413,
-0.2033903748,
-0.3966380358,
-0.1654987782,
-0.2414856851,
0.4491007328,
-0.6347174048,
0.1087283716,
-0.6555644274,
0.3151133955,
1.0241582394,
-0.3024913669,
0.8626889586,
-0.4283392429,
0.4822908342,
-0.2094374448,
0.2713783681,
0.0255032927,
-0.2503709495,
-0.5779364705,
-0.5416573286,
0.2485462576,
0.2382579893,
-0.240800485,
0.3019317389,
-0.3131842911,
-0.3572449088,
-0.527778089,
0.2599983811,
0.5027137995,
0.2542003989,
0.0938564017,
-0.3937973976,
-0.3652187884,
-0.4184244275,
0.1510002166,
0.0436328836,
0.1261688024,
0.2673657238,
0.3295534253,
-0.2953355014,
0.9448717833,
-0.5047576427,
-0.538472712,
-0.0532475114,
0.0158285778,
-0.0336858816,
0.4370644391,
0.2525871694,
-0.5530109406,
-0.2250068039,
0.313305527,
-0.6410930157,
0.0178817008,
0.2233645767,
-0.1864893436,
0.3450258672,
0.0772691965,
-0.3449573517,
-0.0096374331,
1.026709199,
-0.1455868781,
0.492010802,
-0.2817275822,
-0.130843088,
-0.9736613631,
0.0144807985,
-0.3545517027,
-0.3669895828,
-0.2686001658,
0.3935933411,
-0.081785664,
-0.2499653846,
-0.1596473008,
0.4516234994,
-0.6370818615,
-0.4880199432,
-0.1189736128,
0.1506419778,
-0.2349166423,
0.5499228239,
0.0476985425,
0.8960080147,
0.5261198282,
0.0083971154,
0.5287166834,
0.3134077191,
-0.3262004256,
0.4160262346,
-0.1396921426,
0.3996549547,
0.0282550752,
0.1195829436,
-0.4632752538,
-0.5660808086,
0.087574333,
0.0332630277,
0.3604018986,
0.0411238819,
-0.6254832745,
0.0723605603,
-0.2056816816,
-0.0495805331,
0.3564747274,
-1.0510010719,
0.3733247519,
0.4565241635,
0.116133891,
-0.6697950363,
-0.6865758896,
-0.331599474,
0.0525145531,
-0.7473911643,
0.0214661974,
0.0312917642,
-0.4292126298,
0.0246902741,
-0.1099097431,
-0.2878836691,
0.2979832292,
0.4690210223,
0.0725478232,
-0.4502855241,
0.0909249485,
-0.0283017792,
-0.1922397316,
0.0463870727,
-0.5608931184,
0.5506237149,
-0.706466794,
-0.3672688603,
-0.2951332629,
0.0672219992,
0.2801047564,
-0.6471895576,
0.9564000368,
0.5885133743,
-0.3607745171,
-0.3963953853,
-0.4604249895,
-0.1117478833,
-0.5031763315,
-0.058400631,
0.0501478761,
-1.4836580753,
0.2801899314,
-0.2696822584,
0.2051791251,
-0.2974221706,
0.71549505,
0.2577771544,
0.5383202434,
0.9259470701,
-0.2714743614,
0.5138881207,
-0.2762601674,
0.1245468855,
-0.2140449435,
-0.3494979441,
-0.2315440774,
-0.0880535021,
-0.5068469048,
-0.4739041328,
0.0148614412,
0.0435654074,
-0.2466091365,
0.144633919,
-0.1238093749,
0.8529030681,
0.47993204,
0.1226542071,
0.5726312995,
0.0140419211,
-0.0389190577,
0.1942447275,
-0.5528460145,
-0.2692070901,
1.0904116631,
0.5904278755,
0.9549677968,
0.0339808464,
1.2060184479,
0.0297816675,
0.6488987803,
-0.5339983702,
0.4168017209,
-0.04717426,
-0.4483166337,
-0.2662133574,
-0.7793489695,
-0.5966366529,
0.069946982,
-0.1316295713,
-0.5520890355,
0.0866908878,
0.0245048422,
-0.2565866411,
0.4233141243,
-0.705254972,
0.8940573931,
-0.1994172931,
-0.5383912921,
-0.2071293592,
-0.4624401331,
0.6166167855,
-0.3590286672,
0.1532652974,
-0.0851823539,
0.0647598803,
0.4866049588,
-0.6060446501,
0.8041967154,
-0.2203110754,
-0.1307912469,
-0.0998684466,
-0.1662852168,
0.5367109776,
0.2746712863,
-0.0940697119,
0.5060821176,
-0.4019649923,
-0.4759949446,
-0.3907546997,
1.0373485088,
-0.8694932461,
-0.4249756932,
-0.3217028081,
-0.7181483507,
-0.3528447747,
0.3168259561,
-0.1812842488,
0.4225739241,
-0.2306412011,
0.4399963915,
0.7754856348,
-0.0010600766,
0.3415149152,
0.5922285318,
-0.3014312983,
-0.6426796317,
0.7930672169,
-0.1302063465,
0.4010182917,
0.6229115725,
0.2791309953,
-0.3667643368,
-0.5940284133,
-0.0807639062,
0.302331835,
-0.6457980871,
-0.3880944252,
-0.3748489022,
-0.0579380058,
-0.351767689,
-0.2827078998,
-0.6590102911,
-0.1433428079,
-0.4498627782,
-0.3446571529,
0.5016525388,
0.6442701817,
-0.2727365792,
0.2101524174,
-0.5917986631,
-0.1684461981,
0.2006562799,
0.9742119312,
0.0482217818,
0.0836790502,
-0.3826158345,
0.1105308905,
-0.0116780968,
-0.1689305007,
0.1904288232,
0.2181616724,
0.4134820104,
0.5841445923,
0.3424889445,
0.7015441656,
-0.2620992362,
0.1952084303,
0.2563922703,
-0.7857175469,
0.1364527792,
-0.2840584815,
0.1024893522,
0.7174357176,
0.3467451036,
-0.095659405,
-0.533959806,
-0.3760111332,
-0.3186977208,
0.9217091203,
0.1316796392,
-0.0061314912,
0.3600721955,
0.0493065789,
0.4857178628,
0.3614367843,
-0.6101281643,
-0.2611170411,
-0.1243772358,
-0.2891447842,
-0.1996557117,
0.1451233923,
-0.4283342957,
-0.132911548,
0.5425291061,
-0.2314293534,
0.1751609743,
-0.200368017,
-0.0413178317,
-0.4298911095,
0.2220374048,
0.3565136194,
0.6895829439,
-0.3126155734,
0.0365505889,
-0.2184678018,
-0.4241498113,
0.18427068,
0.6225174665,
-0.1666869372,
-0.3541980982,
0.2100728452,
0.808044076,
0.5319905281,
-0.6350386143,
0.7435933352,
-0.2080401629,
-0.3003569245,
-0.2608013749,
0.2221049368,
0.1472796053,
0.5968480706,
0.0881720483,
0.1120771542,
-0.3255422115,
-0.4718066752,
0.2781349421,
0.3341334462,
-0.2214601636,
-0.3647117019,
0.6863868237,
0.2766831517,
-0.2129758,
0.519284308,
-0.1245600432,
-0.2558290362,
0.0580724813,
0.4258548915,
0.8307353854,
-0.148735702,
0.3729421794,
-0.0950668529,
0.1726277024,
-0.4845505655,
0.1050789282,
-0.361786902,
-0.6142379045,
-0.3386164904,
-0.76844275,
-0.6810631156,
0.2138091326,
-0.7115601301,
0.0579584651,
-1.0047245026,
0.259013176,
-0.4047932625,
0.3503655195,
-0.625005424,
-0.1503392011,
0.0859917551,
0.7985347509,
-0.5791261792,
0.9862993956,
0.456119895,
-0.3436273336,
-0.7739960551,
-0.0419088714,
0.0007378241,
-0.743471086,
0.170782879,
0.3434950113,
0.0314627998,
0.2252335846,
-0.5479124188,
-0.7112463117,
1.2530982494,
0.6189328432,
-0.8637116551,
-0.0114001511,
0.3176597059,
0.5485835075,
-0.5301271081,
-0.1893827319,
0.4891795218,
0.2286187559,
-0.1513777375,
-0.8295698166,
-0.0516389571,
0.276496321,
-0.2443557382,
0.2545637786,
-0.832337141,
0.72604388,
-0.4053322375,
-0.1577775031,
0.0455865823,
0.8203446269,
0.0917718112,
0.5557175279,
0.2211693376,
0.4871156812,
1.0536657572,
-0.2108847946,
0.7856448889,
-0.2143321335,
0.7227247953,
1.3324002028,
-0.4153331518,
0.7445645928,
0.1868862659,
-0.010881329,
0.170613423,
0.3669864237,
0.0179943871,
0.72730726,
-0.0278261472,
-0.5094976425,
-0.1563366205,
0.1012296826,
-0.2830842733,
0.5165675282,
-0.0030511282,
-0.3772767186,
-0.3495430052,
0.1444952935,
0.0638053492,
0.3864689469,
-0.2953881919,
0.7586895227,
0.2218893617,
-0.2561167181,
0.5328219533,
0.0762767643,
0.6408043504,
-0.5615611672,
0.2319520116,
-0.5277972221,
0.5937595367,
-0.3068339527,
-0.4388282001,
0.2662638724,
0.0687829033,
-0.0561761558,
-0.6507604122,
0.4874466658,
-0.6166238785,
-0.1047687754,
0.4258598089,
0.3731413484,
-0.0440907925,
0.1528083682,
-0.4541786909,
0.1409493536,
-0.1117021739,
-0.1076929942,
0.7477766871,
0.4142420292,
0.1912279725,
0.5563986301,
0.7204242349,
-0.0112917321,
-0.0442911945,
0.0523484573,
0.8894580007,
-0.1854473054,
-0.4732459486,
-0.6131480336,
0.0626241565,
0.0956616029,
-0.1976582557,
0.7707811594,
0.6842762232,
1.4975070953,
-0.1492992938,
0.4510940909,
0.3898356259,
0.2606152892,
-0.5074041486,
0.9692389965,
-0.1091899723,
0.1901784688,
0.0262592006,
-0.8048337698,
-0.3810667098,
0.553637743,
-0.5173688531,
-0.3265127838,
0.4166521132,
0.8014924526,
-0.2143256664,
0.4529638588,
0.3190427721,
0.138100788,
0.2741814554,
0.4348601401,
0.4751996398,
-0.0971215665,
0.3700814843,
-0.7294892073,
-0.3009340763,
-0.2685104012,
-0.6815411448,
-0.9942051768,
-0.4132193625,
-0.4332828522,
-0.0460877046,
0.2189307362,
1.1544892788,
0.76838696,
-0.8431243896,
-0.3232760429,
-0.396374017,
0.176373437,
-0.3000579476,
-0.2159603238,
0.0493908376,
-0.2439755946,
-0.5919719934,
0.5695485473,
0.3579906225,
0.0543643199,
-0.6352481246,
-0.3961892426,
0.0733804554,
-0.2593899369,
0.3438766301,
0.2020987719,
-0.3783951402,
-0.1788051873,
-0.118253544,
-0.1782537848,
0.1328834891,
0.7514588237,
-0.4646097124,
0.532564044,
0.3115576804,
0.9216814637,
0.4712021947,
0.1485828012,
0.5639192462,
-0.8606935143,
0.286002785,
0.2665749192,
0.2213306427,
0.4280786216,
-0.4065352678,
0.4943531454,
0.362837404,
-0.750988543,
-1.0099047422,
-0.1303090751,
-0.7133696079,
0.0518432371,
1.0483686924,
-0.7082300782,
-0.3331109881,
0.1256686151,
0.1879193187,
0.0376422927,
-0.5727010369,
0.6805645823,
0.4834716618,
0.1164077669,
-0.139568314,
-0.1467819959,
0.447561413,
-0.1291084588,
-0.9129588604,
0.3868559599,
0.6558340788,
0.3155509531,
-0.1433825195,
0.7919908762,
-0.1033664569,
0.209189117,
-0.0569153167,
-0.1738622487,
-0.6061667204,
-0.41399315,
-0.719404459,
0.4186401367,
0.0673652887,
-0.3486587703
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06948v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06948v1
|
Should I try multiple optimizers when fine-tuning pre-trained Transformers for NLP tasks? Should I tune their hyperparameters?
| 2024-02-10T13:26:14 | 2024-02-10T13:26:14 |
Nefeli Gkouti, Prodromos Malakasiotis, Stavros Toumpis, Ion Androutsopoulos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
NLP research has explored different neural model architectures and sizes,
datasets, training objectives, and transfer learning techniques. However, the
choice of optimizer during training has not been explored as extensively.
Typically, some variant of Stochastic Gradient Descent (SGD) is employed,
selected among numerous variants, using unclear criteria, often with minimal or
no tuning of the optimizer's hyperparameters. Experimenting with five GLUE
datasets, two models (DistilBERT and DistilRoBERTa), and seven popular
optimizers (SGD, SGD with Momentum, Adam, AdaMax, Nadam, AdamW, and AdaBound),
we find that when the hyperparameters of the optimizers are tuned, there is no
substantial difference in test performance across the five more elaborate
(adaptive) optimizers, despite differences in training loss. Furthermore,
tuning just the learning rate is in most cases as good as tuning all the
hyperparameters. Hence, we recommend picking any of the best-behaved adaptive
optimizers (e.g., Adam) and tuning only its learning rate. When no
hyperparameter can be tuned, SGD with Momentum is the best choice.
|
[
-0.6932712197,
-0.3273092508,
0.2582999468,
0.5465509892,
-0.3150840104,
-0.3081989884,
-0.5851007104,
-0.199473694,
0.1579397917,
0.3551318645,
-0.6793349385,
-0.1107148752,
-0.8838391304,
0.2567198873,
-0.228200987,
1.4447438717,
0.1008037776,
0.1190446541,
0.1451460272,
-0.2250182629,
-0.3623773158,
-0.2302285284,
-1.2619072199,
-0.1329600662,
0.63996315,
0.1820902228,
0.7981774807,
0.7142383456,
0.9476386905,
0.3346869349,
-0.2077910751,
0.4482390583,
-0.2992398441,
0.0819280669,
-0.2760754526,
-0.7178215981,
-0.4728386104,
0.0761657804,
0.1201201975,
0.5966716409,
-0.2944515347,
0.4085531533,
0.2877710462,
0.5804969072,
-0.7939894795,
-0.1160890162,
-0.6699041724,
0.4908352196,
-0.1780716926,
-0.5419328809,
-0.3176542521,
-0.2641479671,
-0.0447592475,
-0.6438121796,
0.4636069238,
0.1049391776,
0.9516091943,
0.8800508976,
-0.1159026623,
0.1680785418,
-1.0044829845,
0.9433449507,
-0.7669043541,
0.4036861956,
0.1779145002,
0.3420381844,
-0.0355107896,
-0.8214742541,
-0.3471185267,
-0.0317258798,
0.1259498,
0.4085073471,
-0.1024826095,
0.1501278877,
0.6916300654,
0.4056061208,
-0.5547346473,
0.4019716084,
-0.3337955773,
-0.0479002371,
0.5910953879,
0.0829373673,
-0.1962954104,
0.2815272212,
-0.4685305655,
-0.3129960001,
-0.2455140501,
0.0682856068,
0.62610358,
0.5294587612,
0.3294817507,
0.4008098245,
-0.0804234743,
0.6405010819,
0.596675694,
-0.1771851331,
0.1930583268,
-0.5167924166,
-0.1183845624,
-0.0351509191,
0.7354248762,
0.4385448992,
0.6418146491,
-0.1796472073,
-0.3703699708,
0.1279877424,
0.8792549372,
-0.6716364622,
-0.502555728,
0.0811705366,
-0.5115456581,
-0.2110498101,
-0.3804361522,
-0.5884130001,
0.1771453023,
-0.6074850559,
0.4672597945,
-0.2605900764,
-0.1235701367,
0.4715009332,
-0.2231083661,
-0.017612258,
0.0939108357,
-1.2175368071,
0.3077714443,
0.586265564,
0.6178215146,
-0.4240072668,
-0.5906848907,
-0.521866262,
-0.1585242748,
-0.5636331439,
0.6869117022,
-0.3732104897,
0.0065258592,
-0.00552051,
0.0036895133,
-0.42049402,
-0.5120817423,
1.1548315287,
-0.2287362069,
0.0666778982,
-0.2645469308,
-0.582985878,
-0.0740394294,
-0.1156515181,
-0.5791625977,
1.0972926617,
0.1452091485,
-0.5310198069,
0.8629000783,
-0.7213437557,
-0.4647385478,
-0.0064927652,
0.2740451097,
-0.5781186819,
0.4413885176,
0.3959339857,
0.5952219367,
0.0390293971,
0.0270584729,
-0.3244557679,
-0.3989834189,
-0.4222789109,
-0.4589549899,
0.5153508186,
0.1477098316,
-0.4017020464,
0.1186549515,
-0.8487415314,
0.3265686035,
-0.1537691951,
-0.4287632108,
-0.0307448152,
0.2886554897,
0.2388472706,
0.1881153733,
-0.1322373897,
-0.3579066694,
0.1477311701,
-0.6530640721,
0.2494270504,
0.8535701036,
0.0665769801,
0.314226836,
-0.4120890498,
0.6338586807,
0.0931135938,
0.2918683589,
0.2690040469,
-0.3631592691,
-1.0164669752,
0.2307653874,
0.1948044747,
0.228313446,
-0.5317128301,
0.5997649431,
0.2215603888,
-0.6429494619,
-0.8440561891,
0.1865066886,
0.193069905,
0.4481930733,
0.7782956958,
-0.2204602808,
-0.360717237,
-0.9533388615,
-0.6758496165,
0.0991338268,
-0.0670686513,
0.1749564707,
0.4034259021,
0.1805599779,
0.6458230019,
-0.5087380409,
-0.5367958546,
-0.0919048935,
-0.1463128179,
0.3635855019,
0.6072292924,
0.977728188,
-0.7579339147,
-0.5694519281,
0.0034342227,
-0.1821173131,
0.2017554939,
-0.3127316535,
-0.1002283469,
-0.0373617746,
0.4050495923,
-0.5708781481,
0.2200311422,
0.4844549596,
0.2409292608,
0.6014543176,
-0.1923072934,
-0.091030024,
-0.9234673977,
-0.1527457386,
0.3678880036,
0.0803079158,
-0.6096320748,
0.2308637649,
-0.0433474109,
0.0802520439,
-0.6012020111,
0.120153062,
-0.0133089786,
0.1713588089,
-0.2392302006,
-0.179762587,
-0.0630908161,
0.6851438284,
-0.1264251769,
1.0135395527,
0.801445961,
-0.8438624144,
0.3661405146,
0.2341346741,
-0.2449020594,
0.4349297881,
-1.0475670099,
0.2452813834,
-0.1804174632,
-0.0732029304,
-0.7646314502,
0.1006572172,
0.1570646465,
-0.2290137857,
0.3767514229,
0.0508558787,
-0.3680137396,
-0.3825949132,
-0.2180530876,
0.0485733189,
0.2832614779,
-0.6140139103,
0.5494366288,
0.0809646547,
0.1903982759,
-0.8032743931,
-0.3662342131,
-0.1784088314,
-0.5990129113,
-0.4864795804,
0.5269827247,
-0.2107465118,
0.4415759742,
-0.2981167734,
-0.4525407553,
-0.0327823348,
0.2259975523,
0.0890176296,
-0.2206130773,
-0.494723469,
0.0542090647,
0.1853598952,
-0.5106243491,
0.0357330404,
-0.3649646044,
0.4587201476,
-0.3211885989,
-0.3054240048,
-0.4586057067,
0.1871882677,
0.2914945185,
-0.4185784459,
0.6994872689,
1.3676521778,
-0.1244511381,
-0.2371483594,
-0.6253030896,
-0.390014261,
-0.5292206407,
0.3560176492,
-0.437618494,
-0.8173291683,
0.373051554,
-0.2896683514,
0.3719736636,
0.714715898,
0.7027888894,
-0.2447676063,
1.2911646366,
0.8418106437,
-0.1610223502,
0.1800764203,
-0.249234587,
0.422878623,
-0.9318909049,
0.1999190897,
-0.8254340291,
-0.6330227852,
-0.7978188992,
0.0404080488,
0.3607316911,
0.2594991326,
-0.0829164013,
0.7014299035,
-0.7223398089,
0.7110165954,
0.7773756981,
-0.05005702,
-0.1079006344,
-0.0760588273,
0.2148979455,
-0.1427806318,
-0.9501177073,
-0.269254595,
1.2153277397,
0.0451536924,
0.670479238,
-0.1500294358,
0.6240682602,
-0.3889251053,
-0.2414632142,
-0.8903216124,
0.3687857389,
-0.451105535,
-0.6461838484,
-0.2985024154,
-0.133829549,
-1.2219727039,
0.3212798238,
-0.4237760901,
-0.4610965252,
0.3440765738,
0.3570474684,
-0.8108434677,
0.2086561024,
-0.5453449488,
0.9153754115,
-0.0995838344,
-0.1625937074,
-0.1811377257,
-0.6953976154,
0.0242392588,
-0.2653066218,
-0.4404233992,
-0.0958004445,
-0.0457164347,
0.7979717851,
-0.0633053854,
0.2963696122,
-0.0733672678,
0.291983217,
-0.099772945,
-0.2072753161,
0.5500051975,
-0.0068912003,
-0.0266731419,
0.0614218302,
0.0862677246,
-0.2095716447,
-0.6274453998,
0.515134275,
-0.7672275901,
-0.7547062039,
-0.1696904302,
-0.3316987753,
-0.184701696,
0.2656386495,
0.5166882277,
0.3496527672,
0.2912556231,
0.5067727566,
0.3664921522,
0.1410971582,
0.704247117,
0.019662803,
0.3436254561,
0.1589755565,
0.8890274763,
-0.0260025188,
0.3614557683,
-0.0000214644,
0.21379219,
-0.1388213784,
-0.9609392285,
-0.2658605576,
0.0927496403,
-0.4502986372,
-0.2126458436,
-0.5200975537,
-0.2514015436,
-0.1770910919,
-0.2075148374,
-0.7085666656,
-0.2783977389,
-0.5253239274,
-0.0222352482,
0.1835315377,
-0.024238186,
-0.0111140059,
0.3963684738,
-0.6558462977,
0.497050643,
0.1325875074,
0.2598278224,
-0.2892663479,
-0.3334655166,
-0.3613879085,
-0.0051383227,
-0.2049441487,
-0.3980255127,
0.4221804738,
0.6290211082,
0.6356631517,
0.649304688,
0.0301852562,
0.868265748,
-0.7100405097,
0.6076478362,
0.056644056,
-0.4146706462,
0.4534638226,
-0.1923144162,
0.2281431854,
0.9707867503,
0.9006567001,
-0.2491566837,
-0.2778558433,
-0.6329115629,
-0.792155385,
0.7107462287,
0.1810291111,
0.2612656355,
0.0822384953,
0.394898206,
0.0655546859,
0.3468486667,
-0.3049468696,
-0.5256717205,
-0.0058843554,
0.1123748645,
-0.1979492307,
0.1570656598,
-0.3445957303,
-0.3211882412,
0.4523289502,
-0.4266220033,
0.0034940729,
-0.0632653683,
0.1969367415,
-0.2998693287,
-0.0717919543,
0.2938349545,
0.8549234271,
-0.3539327085,
-0.1319103241,
0.2754442096,
-0.538222611,
0.0536891781,
-0.1614734083,
-0.0599266365,
0.0854760855,
0.1565830112,
1.2013319731,
0.0294449329,
-0.1583734751,
0.411868602,
-0.160237819,
-0.3701349795,
-0.0604204796,
0.6087836623,
-0.0929571986,
0.2751283646,
-0.0093276957,
1.0044523478,
0.1775946766,
-0.089229323,
0.1227913201,
0.302770406,
-0.3577560186,
-0.2341389209,
0.8195027113,
0.0658458471,
-0.715356648,
0.552921772,
-0.0938385203,
-0.3207410276,
0.586527884,
0.3968095779,
0.9462664127,
-0.4321772158,
0.0601926185,
0.3559834361,
0.5167192221,
-0.3843104541,
0.0637354553,
0.1331968457,
-0.9992213845,
-0.8538427353,
-0.8681063652,
-0.2818449438,
0.1197795495,
-1.0452736616,
0.3917658031,
-0.2848265171,
-0.5486502051,
0.6406737566,
-0.1162146702,
-1.003433466,
0.3469005525,
-0.2406554222,
0.6251344085,
-0.8635984063,
0.4559397697,
0.5887443423,
-0.1821856946,
-0.6854576468,
-0.0474160574,
-0.1417551488,
-0.5782943368,
0.5676318407,
-0.1762577593,
-0.0046415529,
0.3977534771,
-0.1548092812,
-0.9919891357,
0.5443505645,
0.3641808629,
-0.6478080153,
-0.1366034597,
-0.1554510295,
0.6373739243,
-0.2461249083,
0.4454182982,
0.7760407329,
0.4870175719,
-0.180705145,
-1.1137034893,
-0.396270752,
-0.0128514981,
0.1298293471,
0.293532908,
-0.7617537975,
0.886120379,
-0.2078088224,
-0.1981105059,
-0.2416994274,
0.4507486522,
0.0624816194,
0.0249070637,
0.671872437,
0.624879837,
0.4354222715,
-0.1274403632,
1.000477314,
-0.6492945552,
0.3773806989,
0.9047973156,
0.1082893983,
0.7822600603,
0.5241347551,
-0.6738868356,
-0.2073908001,
0.7792836428,
-0.3878381252,
0.2687139511,
0.1890115887,
0.1735156924,
-0.4264001846,
0.0040163952,
-0.4257450104,
0.5557314157,
0.1686909348,
-0.1130100861,
-0.2152875662,
0.0458903238,
-0.1563206315,
-0.0262643788,
-0.1858308315,
0.6510563493,
-0.0255140495,
-0.7116838694,
0.7602034807,
-0.0444942117,
0.7228599191,
-0.5574650168,
0.2288520634,
-0.1652849764,
0.4197760224,
-0.3254539073,
-0.577380836,
0.3763211668,
-0.5129697323,
-0.0735581964,
-0.2973217666,
0.7170238495,
-0.3984967768,
-0.3601620495,
0.1078945994,
0.3586622477,
0.1659548581,
-0.2685095668,
-0.9492326975,
-0.2911339998,
-0.0885902494,
-0.5487368703,
0.5079094172,
0.0225769076,
0.3915185928,
0.6874691248,
1.0348192453,
0.3176473677,
0.1379597932,
0.2890242338,
0.8431187868,
-0.2790798545,
-0.2631444931,
-0.7802401185,
0.3550131619,
-0.042798914,
-1.0072010756,
1.0526713133,
0.4361283183,
1.1397333145,
-0.1196735278,
0.1872338206,
0.5633487701,
0.3909380734,
-0.4565596282,
0.4087238014,
-0.6415987611,
-0.3668832779,
-0.4807189107,
-1.692689538,
-0.2598021328,
0.7761927247,
0.1733898073,
0.176849395,
1.004735589,
0.7226778269,
0.0047742273,
0.1943987757,
0.1116179302,
-0.1969068497,
0.1448865384,
0.4492692351,
0.5267120004,
-0.5128414035,
0.3947372139,
-0.3798071742,
0.1469556391,
-0.1424054354,
-0.6558192968,
-0.6925273538,
-0.4573897719,
-0.4671577215,
0.0162957627,
-0.0432059579,
0.7774361968,
0.8044573069,
-0.7162550688,
-0.0465006977,
0.0388401859,
-0.2689363062,
-0.7904827595,
-0.1853322536,
0.4146719277,
-0.9533735514,
-1.14065516,
0.5509637594,
0.5509653091,
-0.2525928319,
-0.1199839562,
0.2314136922,
-0.1490621716,
-0.0425125584,
0.405651778,
-0.0073286942,
-0.5061644316,
-0.4726901054,
-0.0156093882,
0.1274484694,
0.0387040116,
0.6528084874,
-0.4068612754,
0.3878685534,
0.4488075972,
0.8379243612,
0.719530642,
-0.0318603106,
0.4283216,
-0.6756429672,
0.0662104115,
0.5549675226,
0.2060936093,
-0.2399321049,
-0.1075855419,
0.7512702346,
-0.0718773007,
-0.8360728025,
-0.8204996586,
0.130047828,
-0.8024675846,
0.04584039,
0.9929745197,
0.0100447489,
0.080124937,
-0.1211244017,
-0.1124349684,
0.0337967239,
-0.0927134156,
0.495926857,
0.7130010724,
-0.4259318411,
-0.0746385679,
-0.8273142576,
1.0704064369,
1.0454005003,
-0.4278696179,
-0.2399200946,
-0.156993404,
-0.1245578155,
0.3650460541,
0.1662936658,
0.3819113076,
-0.0010032788,
0.0404865704,
-0.2610946298,
-0.0653099641,
-0.7069925666,
-0.2049420029,
0.1231134683,
-0.1467687488,
-0.2517294586
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06930v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06930v1
|
LiFi: Lightweight Controlled Text Generation with Fine-Grained Control Codes
| 2024-02-10T11:53:48 | 2024-02-10T11:53:48 |
Chufan Shi, Deng Cai, Yujiu Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the rapidly evolving field of text generation, the demand for more precise
control mechanisms has become increasingly apparent. To address this need, we
present a novel methodology, LIFI, which offers a lightweight approach with
fine-grained control for controlled text generation. Unlike previous studies
that train pre-trained language models to follow discrete, categorical, and
exclusive control codes, LIFI learns controlled text generation under the
guidance of continuous, relative, and nonexclusive control codes. These
fine-grained codes are automatically derived from an attribute classifier,
initially trained with a small amount of labeled data and subsequently employed
to label abundant unlabeled data, thus garnering more extensive supervision
signals. Moreover, to achieve efficient control, we incorporate the
fine-grained control codes with adapters, a parameter- and compute-efficient
way to steer a pre-trained language model. We evaluate LIFI on two conventional
tasks -- sentiment control and topic control -- and one newly proposed task --
stylistic novel writing. Comprehensive experimental results validate the
effectiveness of our proposed methods, demonstrating substantial performance
improvements over existing baselines.
|
[
-0.2940918207,
-0.9393426776,
0.3743239343,
0.2336997539,
-0.0570615083,
-0.1106921807,
-0.4464090466,
-0.2803224921,
0.0523018539,
0.4564789832,
-0.5356263518,
-0.2298699915,
-0.2792506516,
0.0261018127,
-0.3732038438,
1.4378932714,
-0.1644830704,
-0.3111611903,
-0.2327295244,
0.0103554791,
-0.067336075,
-0.210226208,
-0.3803266585,
-0.4867377579,
0.8988950849,
0.4851807952,
0.6425927877,
0.488863796,
0.5420249104,
0.248404786,
0.066394724,
0.2948512733,
-0.564632833,
-0.1090458333,
-0.1563614756,
-0.1911346912,
-0.4114479423,
-0.2733106911,
0.6052998304,
0.5456194878,
0.16649656,
0.1445499659,
0.2291840613,
0.7631692886,
-0.7945668101,
-0.1342898756,
-0.5918375254,
0.0183100402,
-0.2136735469,
-0.5118778944,
-0.577881515,
-0.4338253438,
-0.2021457106,
-0.4462281764,
0.0304138511,
0.0158464964,
0.7820515037,
0.1753262728,
-0.3040432036,
-0.4973251522,
-0.8521335721,
0.7624818087,
-0.5840536356,
0.0914824456,
0.2752126455,
-0.1123412997,
-0.1261160374,
-0.9962776303,
-0.5299376249,
-0.3047843575,
-0.1683809906,
0.0366481207,
0.1103916764,
0.1367350072,
0.0853262469,
0.5257326961,
-0.3287327588,
0.1464818716,
-0.1205515265,
-0.0908344612,
0.5840187669,
-0.0079942867,
0.1901281476,
-0.0816833004,
-0.3263544738,
-0.0611235909,
-0.4948763847,
0.3556798995,
0.4617962837,
0.2144503146,
-0.1376456469,
0.5670201182,
-0.5235238075,
0.5691030622,
0.3321091831,
-0.4626836479,
0.1331637204,
-0.3269863725,
-0.3192483783,
0.0353757218,
0.9546515346,
0.4956282079,
0.405154407,
-0.1423450857,
-0.5727801323,
-0.1089260429,
0.2117778659,
-1.1070590019,
-0.2026067972,
0.0046552094,
-0.6572116613,
-0.8902549148,
-0.1085324734,
-0.5275552273,
-0.3291384876,
-0.1835370809,
0.5546236038,
-0.3086351454,
0.0911900401,
-0.0624583401,
-0.1135816723,
0.3372259438,
0.1818186492,
-1.0247424841,
0.2480474263,
0.1716117263,
0.5482256413,
-0.3241392076,
-0.0534832589,
-0.7162878513,
0.2340331376,
-0.4301414788,
0.5034102798,
-0.4581829906,
-0.2694291174,
0.1542661637,
-0.1843900234,
0.3356817365,
-0.0608492419,
0.4463395774,
-0.2938835919,
0.0423537306,
0.1404359937,
-0.4515870214,
0.3212485909,
-0.0372377522,
-0.5662207007,
1.0498220921,
0.2157761604,
-1.0141913891,
0.3360258937,
-0.2606440485,
-0.7489341497,
0.0786413923,
-0.3110391498,
-0.5439348221,
0.1554829776,
-0.1814366877,
0.736507237,
-0.2049334645,
0.3947413862,
-0.1459666938,
-0.2089198977,
0.3703899682,
-0.5218630433,
0.1544670314,
0.3325513899,
-0.4163280129,
0.0244404562,
-0.9103984833,
0.2653400004,
0.167689532,
-0.5323927402,
-0.3226671517,
0.0618956424,
0.564878583,
-0.2824546099,
0.4301697016,
-0.358728528,
0.1494242549,
-0.2695175707,
0.1824915409,
0.4504258037,
0.076696232,
0.9582074881,
-0.5994936228,
0.1180708408,
-0.5186023712,
-0.0279867388,
-0.3113148808,
-0.1282809377,
-0.9219350219,
-0.0834200829,
0.1893481314,
0.4879694581,
-1.0768498182,
0.6408179998,
0.1688917875,
-0.6905484796,
0.0201011524,
0.378721565,
0.4500024915,
0.4946263134,
0.2492351234,
-0.0745749325,
-0.0207596105,
-0.6566666365,
-0.082437858,
0.1198261976,
0.0131494021,
0.357114166,
0.3943364322,
-0.2848898172,
0.8668423891,
-0.6661331654,
-0.2153099179,
-0.580832541,
0.4810123146,
-0.1616194844,
1.0129151344,
0.7899972796,
-0.7866925001,
-0.3797975779,
0.1474449486,
-0.3690317869,
-0.462723434,
-0.6345306039,
-0.2707777321,
0.2123256475,
0.6860099435,
-0.2758826315,
0.3995187879,
0.4180931747,
-0.3796009421,
0.4224854708,
-0.146419242,
-0.0118374536,
-1.0197583437,
0.2365102768,
-0.0228364374,
-0.4983680546,
-0.7001131177,
0.0682861507,
0.1183774471,
0.1227146536,
-0.3456748426,
0.5244345665,
-0.1941965222,
0.3747029305,
-0.485478133,
-0.1835258901,
0.1333036125,
0.7044130564,
0.079921484,
0.6090831757,
0.242581889,
-0.5882890821,
0.13887766,
-0.1885826439,
-0.3592085242,
0.366184026,
-0.6297845244,
0.0528634526,
-0.2732964754,
0.0433059968,
-0.6481323242,
-0.4326763451,
0.0085589271,
-0.160033524,
0.4890008271,
0.4924069941,
-0.3846889436,
-0.0769175738,
-0.2799506783,
0.1613341868,
0.5454174876,
-0.129638657,
0.6590130329,
0.0059043914,
-0.3077614009,
-0.258687675,
-0.855342865,
-0.5289207101,
-0.1183233112,
0.0784682482,
0.3272395432,
-0.3858030438,
-0.1367589682,
-0.1420146525,
-0.0316877887,
-0.3683157563,
0.3424651027,
0.1258454174,
-0.0757290423,
-0.0781544894,
0.2087199688,
0.6037575603,
0.0836715996,
-0.2263242751,
-0.2250663936,
0.4952962399,
0.0933508798,
0.0839646831,
-0.4978925288,
0.4774977267,
0.2614814341,
-0.2911709845,
0.3708635271,
0.7814094424,
-0.2301793993,
-0.829777956,
-0.240454495,
0.0401552171,
-0.5554172993,
0.3001053035,
-0.2955301702,
-0.9985610247,
0.0695473552,
-0.2371142656,
0.2928767502,
0.3140586615,
0.4735867083,
-0.1321208626,
0.6517696977,
1.2630729675,
0.0813213214,
0.7970445752,
0.0953955576,
-0.1345199049,
-0.1071629301,
-0.1638221443,
-0.6767567396,
-0.4580451548,
-0.6977309585,
-0.312259078,
0.0064534843,
0.4037166536,
-0.3051961958,
0.088920027,
-0.694011569,
0.5733253956,
0.4961029887,
0.1275711656,
0.3559449911,
-0.3017602861,
0.0830537975,
0.1862568557,
-0.6098408699,
-0.4402989745,
0.9408352971,
0.3706856966,
1.2925510406,
-0.2644549906,
0.839404881,
0.5026425123,
0.3358283341,
-0.7907083035,
0.3328972161,
-0.4480293989,
-0.2238509208,
-0.2029036731,
-0.4733555913,
-0.3245449364,
-0.4534702003,
-0.5455313325,
-0.6068477631,
0.2361548692,
0.3081119657,
-0.4035921097,
0.0895281434,
-0.877200067,
0.6888432503,
-0.392642796,
-0.4633388221,
0.0780609176,
-0.4658147395,
0.2668774724,
-0.5424912572,
0.1186477393,
-0.0868711919,
-0.0739456564,
0.7075943351,
-0.2769022584,
0.8371908665,
-0.0135086589,
-0.2934195995,
0.3679677546,
0.1216900051,
0.5965026617,
0.2838327885,
-0.0145411231,
-0.4248338938,
-0.0167975277,
-0.3219491243,
-0.3196623325,
0.6835257411,
-0.6862385273,
0.0675872564,
-0.0912446827,
-0.7574225664,
-0.0166424792,
0.7772097588,
0.4889611006,
0.7172104716,
-0.5090892911,
0.5038000345,
0.9435697794,
-0.3857940435,
0.88126719,
0.1773546487,
-0.3008388579,
-0.5154949427,
0.9089426398,
-0.0372377522,
0.4281634986,
0.8232845068,
0.1696749181,
0.2370974272,
-0.4451717436,
-0.2930250168,
-0.2560863793,
-0.5109692216,
-0.5491179228,
-0.6477617025,
-0.2458598614,
-0.1579461992,
-0.7629203796,
-0.3455195725,
-0.3117728531,
-0.4384692907,
0.1989293993,
0.4160822928,
0.9709757566,
0.4398778379,
0.8579158783,
-0.5424306393,
0.6167668104,
0.2414046079,
0.4755552709,
-0.3268423378,
-0.0560490675,
-0.3505896628,
-0.1733733714,
-0.2590014637,
-0.6717438102,
0.0979832783,
0.6198752522,
0.111843206,
0.4167202711,
0.4270038605,
0.2593149841,
-0.7001432776,
0.6496896744,
0.2906939983,
-0.976059556,
0.5138816833,
-0.4146664143,
0.5574982762,
0.79895401,
0.2347438633,
0.0172068141,
-0.6593828201,
-0.3328107893,
-0.5047076344,
0.477964431,
0.1914147586,
0.3272375166,
0.2149343789,
0.5512320399,
0.2449498177,
0.3883810639,
-0.9181426167,
-0.0984386206,
-0.3421617746,
-0.6352488399,
-0.0426567644,
-0.2259663641,
-0.0934750438,
-0.0960442126,
0.4873650372,
-0.5942112803,
0.1389300674,
0.3538680375,
-0.0344413817,
-0.1747601628,
0.3023678362,
0.4291391373,
0.1965743303,
-0.0656014904,
0.2053018808,
-0.0624589436,
-0.529481411,
0.0294452161,
0.2351351827,
-0.6776054502,
-0.0836936682,
0.2527906895,
0.8725556135,
0.1593033373,
-0.6074339151,
0.6019842029,
-0.0650219098,
-0.3871258497,
-0.0620404035,
0.4060018063,
-0.2114563286,
0.2154999673,
0.1589995772,
0.1825278848,
0.1333981007,
-0.344149828,
0.3560164273,
0.3588463366,
-0.2387991697,
-0.0567296259,
0.8071805835,
0.5366398096,
-0.024490919,
-0.0241036024,
-0.371507287,
0.0134794731,
0.4541860819,
0.7643083334,
0.8818216324,
0.1644200832,
0.300247699,
0.1015162617,
0.4010567665,
0.0818184391,
0.2813767493,
-0.4174990952,
-0.7247073054,
-0.4714993536,
-1.1412907839,
-0.2402607501,
0.0632252917,
-0.5000360608,
0.3307712972,
-0.9393280149,
-0.0875003338,
0.0516198054,
0.164944306,
-0.4166609943,
0.4429275095,
0.3477012217,
1.1151951551,
-0.8301086426,
0.9968703389,
0.6562205553,
-0.2211218029,
-0.9022552967,
0.240700677,
-0.3481816053,
-0.2324463874,
0.1941075623,
0.395442754,
-0.2380465418,
0.3083779812,
-0.8391020894,
-0.6169533134,
1.1097083092,
0.0331837237,
-0.4933336079,
-0.1578898877,
-0.1017588452,
0.4120371044,
-0.3865364492,
-0.0321378522,
0.6957768202,
0.3182825744,
-0.0880948529,
-0.7636812329,
-0.1600590646,
-0.3565969765,
0.1159124449,
0.1569138169,
-0.758554697,
0.5422213674,
0.1554887444,
0.1392986625,
0.4031221271,
0.9542917609,
-0.1601091772,
0.327886641,
0.3964876533,
0.2680423558,
0.6714516282,
-0.1875340641,
0.8108863831,
-0.3026278913,
0.1980779916,
1.0038143396,
-0.3050481379,
0.7137001753,
0.3618403375,
0.3614296317,
0.5766544342,
0.0690798312,
0.1064931452,
0.6644649506,
-0.039129287,
-0.3823720515,
-0.067559585,
-0.438418597,
-0.0019772712,
0.3648763895,
0.1764517128,
-0.3908992708,
-0.0726263598,
0.4334310293,
0.2582353652,
0.4326611161,
-0.5578204393,
1.037840724,
-0.0583073311,
-0.5693646669,
0.4079246223,
0.2870060503,
0.9458982944,
-0.8964552879,
0.0679739416,
-0.225227803,
0.331415236,
-0.3045434952,
-0.7554493546,
0.1410557926,
0.3731114864,
-0.2886184454,
-0.6973469257,
1.0829672813,
-0.6297751665,
-0.482745856,
-0.1160914153,
0.1962875426,
-0.2899220586,
0.3798871934,
-0.3140317798,
0.0959610343,
0.1435783058,
-0.4721806049,
0.1905134171,
0.6593501568,
-0.0756408423,
0.2913243473,
0.4077341259,
0.1584277302,
-0.0404682904,
-0.0842934623,
1.0637310743,
-0.5750770569,
-0.5915285349,
-0.423221916,
0.5546758771,
0.0800165311,
-0.4684932828,
0.2940060198,
0.4010215402,
0.8074802756,
-0.0683582649,
0.986351192,
-0.6301660538,
0.2550469041,
-0.761328578,
1.1174951792,
-0.6566841602,
-0.325040251,
-0.36151281,
-0.8503890634,
-0.3188731968,
0.4787636399,
0.1223242134,
-0.0073092864,
0.6812965274,
0.6846484542,
0.0354217924,
-0.3537217081,
0.2236007154,
-0.0004976261,
0.3042466938,
0.5201590657,
0.4471741319,
-0.188227579,
0.3954634964,
-0.6503179669,
-0.4747283459,
0.0827057287,
-1.1402950287,
-1.1049149036,
-0.3185913265,
-0.0588172749,
-0.129852891,
-0.2365026176,
0.9749063253,
0.3568160236,
-0.7657980919,
-0.0348027721,
-0.5338928699,
0.0157557987,
-0.0599899776,
-0.2470825464,
0.119821161,
-0.7149959803,
-0.9311838746,
0.1934566945,
0.1274050772,
0.2034571916,
-0.2128249407,
-0.1933505684,
0.0068727704,
0.3932725489,
0.446298182,
0.1835292131,
-0.1985860765,
-0.1244888455,
-0.1237365603,
-0.5929197073,
-0.3347985446,
1.0491060019,
-0.7018876076,
0.2746558189,
0.7622798085,
0.8204724789,
0.0840450153,
0.1521032155,
0.5155428052,
-0.9426797032,
0.476461798,
0.1832566261,
0.067853272,
0.1794275194,
-0.484023422,
0.0088568274,
0.1273818016,
-0.7215041518,
-0.6023639441,
0.210363552,
-1.0811561346,
-0.4301388562,
1.1631062031,
0.0291653406,
-0.3700775504,
0.4341431558,
-0.5166216493,
0.3290646076,
-0.3647952378,
0.2400779873,
0.2458041906,
0.0524968095,
-0.2408789545,
-0.4122661054,
0.9736281037,
0.3409276009,
-1.012381196,
0.0405414924,
0.6735293865,
-0.0935620815,
0.1642307639,
0.9733384252,
0.1795649678,
0.2604826689,
-0.1818262786,
0.2236491144,
0.0910957232,
-0.7030602694,
-0.1821922958,
0.3811505437,
0.1872758716,
0.2538882196
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06925v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06925v2
|
A Thorough Examination of Decoding Methods in the Era of LLMs
| 2024-02-10T11:14:53 | 2024-06-17T14:34:05 |
Chufan Shi, Haoran Yang, Deng Cai, Zhisong Zhang, Yifan Wang, Yujiu Yang, Wai Lam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Decoding methods play an indispensable role in converting language models
from next-token predictors into practical task solvers. Prior research on
decoding methods, primarily focusing on task-specific models, may not extend to
the current era of general-purpose large language models (LLMs). Moreover, the
recent influx of decoding strategies has further complicated this landscape.
This paper provides a comprehensive and multifaceted analysis of various
decoding methods within the context of LLMs, evaluating their performance,
robustness to hyperparameter changes, and decoding speeds across a wide range
of tasks, models, and deployment environments. Our findings reveal that
decoding method performance is notably task-dependent and influenced by factors
such as alignment, model size, and quantization. Intriguingly, sensitivity
analysis exposes that certain methods achieve superior performance at the cost
of extensive hyperparameter tuning, highlighting the trade-off between
attaining optimal results and the practicality of implementation in varying
contexts.
|
[
-0.0903277025,
-0.6435389519,
0.5195704103,
0.3540966809,
-0.3048897982,
-0.0113809612,
-0.2257663608,
-0.4112680554,
-0.3528507948,
0.5984623432,
-0.4428763092,
-0.4822170734,
-0.6306053996,
0.3475171328,
-0.4723460674,
0.6171534657,
-0.0009525908,
0.119596228,
-0.3213427663,
0.1773510426,
-0.3429264426,
-0.9891240597,
-0.3791810572,
-0.3207603991,
0.3023203313,
0.1672243625,
0.5712325573,
0.9870569706,
0.6922209859,
0.2414559126,
-0.3574794233,
0.1789065152,
-0.5445176363,
0.135775879,
0.0529147685,
-0.8954409957,
-0.4695201516,
-0.3036257327,
0.6758010387,
0.6482835412,
-0.1770563573,
0.3548180759,
0.2626559436,
0.420042187,
-1.1093915701,
0.2053518742,
-0.7030386925,
-0.0609096736,
-0.5076579452,
-0.6223748922,
-0.7413639426,
0.0431557149,
-0.2496643066,
-0.437972188,
0.3022478223,
0.0258450843,
0.2936861515,
0.2328087389,
-0.4920056462,
-0.3881211281,
-0.889459312,
1.1946640015,
-0.8618068695,
0.4664012492,
0.6103832126,
0.1583374441,
-0.1630023718,
-0.6438087225,
-0.0844064429,
-0.0354141071,
-0.0122911045,
-0.2244677693,
-0.2689597011,
0.3579288423,
0.3686853945,
0.4332991838,
-0.2593894899,
0.0800819844,
0.0328560807,
-0.3709390163,
0.2676566541,
0.6211403012,
0.1162990183,
-0.2440546304,
-0.0981048644,
-0.0744202062,
-0.7213507295,
0.1306725144,
0.2616145313,
0.322494179,
0.0022290228,
0.483594805,
-0.2583206296,
0.9129394889,
-0.308662802,
-0.499157697,
-0.1736776531,
-0.703343451,
-0.2396149635,
-0.2841002047,
0.2068891823,
0.3070840538,
0.0308793392,
-0.3976345658,
-0.3839448094,
0.0275301374,
0.2178444266,
-0.5806199312,
-0.0098787313,
0.0936152115,
-0.7195957303,
-0.1484946907,
-0.4708913863,
-0.4317304194,
-0.2014713883,
-0.357662946,
0.0627349392,
-0.3762547374,
-0.237079531,
0.3670549691,
-0.0944547877,
0.534497261,
0.1736543924,
-0.9910565615,
0.4224772453,
0.9864689708,
0.8682514429,
-0.1158098355,
-0.2725225687,
-0.6356008649,
0.2035274953,
-0.4322569668,
0.6648779511,
-0.4380429387,
-0.5035541654,
0.2479024678,
0.0190416481,
-0.2039179206,
-0.5414226651,
0.5731686354,
-0.8302723765,
-0.5871753693,
-0.6734540462,
-0.5480321646,
-0.1079005226,
0.2141907066,
-0.7033512592,
0.6053600311,
-0.0775390863,
-0.8148178458,
0.0997544378,
-0.5056539774,
-0.5717255473,
0.0216765404,
0.2208739668,
0.0136866868,
0.6410266161,
0.3380932808,
0.6589941382,
-0.4198319316,
-0.0608989149,
-0.0607744046,
-0.6444296241,
0.2731631696,
-0.6899200678,
0.752904892,
0.3729260862,
-0.102449961,
-0.1803274751,
-0.7633743882,
0.0548048168,
0.104195632,
-0.6159863472,
-0.1836740971,
0.2679749429,
0.0715530515,
-0.2556678057,
0.2638046145,
-0.2803002894,
-0.1191250831,
-0.2475779653,
0.6401309967,
0.5544393659,
-0.1192613915,
0.2731235027,
-0.0675705075,
0.7231984138,
-0.0850093365,
0.0504474044,
-0.4742500484,
-0.1004025787,
-0.6163155437,
-0.1998603642,
0.2300312966,
0.4928560853,
-0.6213389039,
0.0679998249,
-0.2854687274,
-0.2216978818,
-0.5311681628,
0.1945216358,
0.6165147424,
0.2405051291,
0.3154179156,
0.0401157551,
-0.5305665135,
-0.7598336935,
-0.5628276467,
-0.0685211271,
0.2032671273,
0.0135588981,
0.2699356675,
-0.2030800879,
0.6314515471,
-0.3536937833,
0.2215906382,
-0.4138688147,
-0.1230332851,
0.1396148354,
0.3282032907,
0.356775552,
-0.5096843243,
-0.0542619117,
0.1130856276,
-0.5724102855,
0.1274083555,
0.0191023722,
0.0445298702,
0.355715394,
0.8391100168,
-0.406963259,
0.2435061634,
0.850356698,
-0.1082425714,
0.7867460251,
-0.3308246732,
0.0936581269,
-0.7700181603,
0.2191488594,
0.0060153008,
-0.2159805596,
-0.7521846294,
0.4394847751,
0.2517853379,
0.1996523738,
-0.4413052797,
0.1541794389,
-0.8128564954,
-0.1811407357,
-0.4431646764,
-0.4119679034,
-0.0257275179,
0.1808130741,
-0.1025297642,
1.098326087,
0.4870287478,
-0.7343394756,
0.3620820343,
0.1169614494,
-0.3626128137,
0.4081405997,
-0.6363515258,
0.3630179763,
-0.2590907216,
0.0928819329,
-0.9335976243,
-0.019138189,
0.0207349434,
-0.1251844466,
0.2481686622,
-0.4540958405,
-0.7869616151,
-0.1610549539,
-0.2183161229,
0.7557224631,
0.4219979942,
-0.4382599294,
0.5466742516,
0.0297362451,
0.0465077497,
-0.6963552833,
-0.8142236471,
0.4107411802,
-0.3393158913,
-0.3630183339,
0.3456526101,
-0.104117468,
-0.3078648448,
-0.1735645682,
-0.1915913075,
0.1368975043,
0.2609927654,
0.0414035693,
0.0294829085,
-0.1863833517,
-0.3597437143,
-0.1167285219,
-0.3720372021,
0.1978617758,
-0.2424316406,
0.5111429691,
-0.1572537124,
-0.5231508017,
-0.3567939699,
0.4206906259,
0.5968781114,
-0.5373240113,
0.7212979794,
0.5361099243,
-0.294049412,
-0.125852704,
-0.6233771443,
-0.0051044249,
-0.4988214076,
0.6876719594,
-0.7704524994,
-0.6915583611,
0.7133597136,
-0.1589979082,
-0.0104858857,
-0.0537297614,
0.5788383484,
0.0907509848,
1.0695451498,
0.9307581186,
-0.1657025367,
0.383557111,
-0.2602447569,
0.3191578388,
-0.8903133869,
-0.2786299288,
-0.7554563284,
0.0071626338,
-0.3810858428,
-0.429959476,
0.2660650015,
0.209031105,
0.0629994795,
0.320058763,
-0.1588246375,
0.5779554248,
0.4746141136,
-0.0368985571,
0.519079566,
0.1716474295,
0.2180081606,
-0.0928160772,
-0.7976108789,
-0.5124346018,
1.2350578308,
0.5112981796,
0.8630328774,
0.1365573853,
0.4988395572,
0.2199437916,
-0.0313350596,
-0.8300560713,
0.6411107779,
-0.3697868884,
-0.2609919906,
-0.1916763037,
-0.3524604738,
-1.0748957396,
0.3927171826,
0.011552304,
-0.53115803,
0.1098629609,
0.1702562273,
-0.1765352935,
0.283248961,
-0.5411581993,
0.5586922765,
-0.0658359155,
-0.0905435532,
-0.2678717673,
-0.5309305787,
0.1721985936,
0.073785387,
0.2058257759,
-0.0556741469,
-0.2662203908,
0.5742560625,
0.04979413,
0.7765120268,
-0.0456197225,
-0.4772322774,
-0.0476788878,
0.2661203444,
0.5529317856,
-0.1570747197,
-0.3682774007,
0.2233543992,
0.4693021178,
-0.7147017717,
-0.5099763274,
0.6775813699,
-0.5799156427,
-0.6421169043,
0.0045432383,
-0.8616552353,
-0.3688137829,
0.075122565,
0.419604063,
0.7979658842,
-0.1012844741,
0.1099292263,
0.9105163813,
0.0651002377,
0.5351908207,
0.29809165,
0.2379396856,
-0.1513998955,
0.831081748,
-0.0836639032,
0.3357467651,
0.6731358171,
-0.2034070045,
-0.4704418182,
-1.1595624685,
-0.1252220869,
0.2284391224,
-1.0715796947,
-0.3208604157,
-0.3440999091,
0.0733015537,
-0.3628412485,
-0.0714352503,
-0.3326818347,
0.1292332858,
-0.472794801,
-0.1121416241,
0.0433835946,
0.6276780963,
0.1299011558,
0.3069477379,
-0.8763676882,
0.2543103695,
0.0072098658,
0.2847658694,
0.0830287337,
-0.2698419988,
-0.4867141843,
-0.0819352791,
0.1408437192,
-0.9363591075,
0.2191540301,
-0.0492397621,
0.7386459708,
0.2151461393,
-0.0594564639,
0.6249467134,
-0.3340049982,
0.6268955469,
-0.209033519,
-1.1137346029,
0.3250324726,
-0.2578057647,
0.3640960455,
0.2602911592,
0.1728339344,
-0.5267430544,
-0.0522950403,
-0.0493559092,
-0.8747532964,
0.7985786796,
0.0136495791,
0.4907581508,
0.0021257715,
0.5375267863,
0.1101123989,
0.0685156137,
-0.4425009489,
-0.3230385184,
0.1081408709,
-0.1018207893,
-0.3774960041,
-0.6599197984,
-0.196119383,
-0.0631419942,
0.2235339582,
-0.227824077,
0.3341311216,
-0.0712624118,
-0.4138514102,
0.1133829728,
0.4043713808,
0.5740296841,
0.6443183422,
-0.1124703661,
0.2593554854,
0.2470123768,
-0.2310605049,
0.2452881485,
-0.1253379434,
0.1142612174,
-0.0475968942,
0.747926116,
0.8925221562,
0.2049349397,
-0.5941277742,
0.400374949,
0.0444350988,
-0.099417083,
0.0817087591,
0.0935469195,
0.0762825757,
0.2932755649,
0.4190925658,
-0.0141241811,
0.3828579783,
-0.4679190814,
-0.2848314941,
0.532384038,
0.1240686104,
-0.5050894618,
0.4226846397,
0.1119967774,
-0.1490978152,
0.5041564703,
-0.0412729234,
-0.196077764,
0.6014780402,
0.941005826,
0.8076682687,
-0.1039942726,
-0.0771326646,
-0.0010069771,
0.3884380758,
-0.304682374,
0.2045806795,
-0.3128530085,
-0.4623376429,
-0.85434407,
-0.5423930883,
-0.1428714097,
0.0941048637,
-0.9347013831,
-0.2068323642,
-0.1889311671,
-0.3793455362,
-0.3012679517,
-0.1226688996,
-0.8002007008,
-0.0125019988,
0.2175437212,
1.2187476158,
-0.6133898497,
0.5303308368,
0.9152492285,
0.2483226955,
-0.5703058839,
0.2780649066,
-0.0323882103,
-0.8474054933,
0.5027471781,
-0.1048615426,
-0.5567637682,
0.2717135251,
-0.2857763171,
-1.0096328259,
0.9947913885,
0.6919826269,
-0.4450154901,
-0.3379149139,
0.3608755171,
0.5155386329,
-0.0750781074,
0.1709080786,
1.0063375235,
0.2864374816,
-0.3182252049,
-1.0074397326,
0.2081688195,
-0.0688709319,
0.7284988165,
0.0266713239,
-0.3834109008,
0.5309273601,
-0.2029277533,
-0.3730657101,
0.377106607,
0.4734036326,
0.0939148217,
0.1876887977,
0.1589336097,
0.2149672359,
0.4403390288,
0.0409549475,
1.2718291283,
-0.5332431197,
0.2761187553,
0.2805347443,
0.0801532716,
0.9698668122,
0.569218576,
-0.3708476126,
0.0841881111,
0.3631826639,
0.2254879326,
0.6460258961,
0.2834928632,
-0.1996358931,
-0.4956019223,
0.0222141258,
-0.3652125597,
0.470931083,
0.4050079584,
-0.1127721071,
-0.4143649638,
0.176542595,
-0.0921242908,
0.0938711911,
-0.4592438042,
0.635827601,
-0.035261035,
-0.5340418816,
0.8759403229,
0.4452065527,
0.9375382662,
-0.5988358855,
0.1357373297,
-0.1575850844,
0.2913886309,
-0.1220104024,
-0.5762212276,
0.2148564458,
-0.2066533267,
-0.2561008632,
-0.2086877227,
0.7237110138,
-0.049174156,
-0.2789291739,
0.3198311329,
0.5834259391,
-0.0886399746,
-0.0650933459,
-0.5279074907,
0.8030261397,
-0.0350318737,
-0.2069968134,
0.337320745,
0.1826792508,
0.0759474859,
0.8568022251,
0.6057829261,
0.0350200906,
0.1138733774,
-0.0898818448,
0.6681510806,
-0.8100832105,
-0.3265224695,
-0.8902364969,
0.3671108484,
0.6304506063,
-0.0255925693,
0.9135656357,
0.3518777788,
0.8136714101,
-0.2380598336,
0.6420951486,
0.4143673778,
0.1717335731,
-0.9086231589,
0.2384409606,
-0.4098991454,
0.4590805471,
-0.0211188886,
-0.7885048985,
-0.2427239865,
0.1166259944,
-0.2217340916,
0.1248123869,
0.463989675,
0.7920209169,
0.1002711281,
-0.0794181377,
0.3835143447,
-0.1806179583,
0.326313287,
0.5676181316,
0.9298027158,
-0.2976717055,
0.5935049653,
-0.1570922434,
-0.0683936626,
-0.4441147447,
-0.8256597519,
-0.7161128521,
-0.5684410334,
-0.1732117981,
-0.2398932725,
0.384470582,
0.4201341271,
0.9282177687,
-0.5893476605,
-0.3495348096,
-0.0365468711,
-0.0479908027,
-0.4656426907,
-0.1650436968,
0.1601656377,
-0.6694743037,
-0.8916976452,
0.4646604359,
0.1420110464,
-0.1460289806,
-0.2195816636,
-0.1853691787,
0.4432556331,
0.0735285804,
0.7572687864,
0.2099683732,
-0.8305142522,
0.3053179085,
0.3248470128,
-0.1679786891,
-0.0334412605,
1.2749146223,
-0.5908838511,
0.0969566032,
0.4919808209,
0.8152594566,
0.3543841541,
0.0951376185,
0.5330526233,
-0.6096736789,
0.0460096672,
0.1692075729,
0.2713083923,
0.2706276178,
-0.4844030142,
0.0786507502,
0.0719651133,
-0.4069824219,
-1.1281200647,
0.3532752097,
-0.7171353698,
-0.3640271425,
1.1986650229,
-0.1401971579,
-0.1610859931,
-0.2382399738,
-0.0706604868,
0.0062902924,
-0.0361370519,
0.3946143389,
0.7218031883,
-0.1342564821,
-0.3257188499,
-0.447814554,
0.5297889709,
0.5971520543,
-0.5901138783,
0.4505653083,
0.5284062624,
0.3997143805,
-0.076025486,
0.5396593809,
-0.17860277,
0.2330368757,
0.101200074,
-0.2917825878,
-0.2764787972,
-0.3262349069,
-0.6485829353,
0.2899216413,
0.6030184627,
-0.132416442
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06918v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06918v2
|
Generating Chain-of-Thoughts with a Pairwise-Comparison Approach to Searching for the Most Promising Intermediate Thought
| 2024-02-10T09:51:03 | 2024-06-26T05:47:52 |
Zhen-Yu Zhang, Siwei Han, Huaxiu Yao, Gang Niu, Masashi Sugiyama
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
To improve the ability of the large language model (LLMs) to tackle complex
reasoning problems, chain-of-thoughts (CoT) methods were proposed to guide LLMs
to reason step-by-step, enabling problem solving from simple to complex.
State-of-the-art methods for generating such a chain involve interactive
collaboration, where the learner generates candidate intermediate thoughts,
evaluated by the LLM, guiding the generation of subsequent thoughts. However, a
widespread yet understudied problem is that the evaluation from the LLM is
typically noisy and unreliable, potentially misleading the generation process
in selecting promising intermediate thoughts. In this paper, motivated by
Vapnik's principle, we use pairwise-comparison evaluation instead of point-wise
scoring to search for promising intermediate thoughts with the noisy feedback
from the LLM. In each round, we randomly pair intermediate thoughts and
directly prompt the LLM to select the more promising one from each pair,
allowing us to identify the most promising thoughts through an iterative
process. To further alleviate the noise in the comparison, we incorporate
techniques from ensemble learning and dueling bandits, proposing two variants
of the algorithm. Experiments on three real-world tasks demonstrate the
effectiveness of our proposed algorithm and verify the rationale of the
pairwise comparison mechanism.
|
[
-0.6377854347,
-0.7576645017,
0.8821024299,
0.0524428152,
-0.4969373345,
0.5196908712,
-0.5249747038,
-0.3580488563,
0.2730922997,
0.4910599887,
-0.4485054016,
-0.3554600179,
-0.4916077852,
0.1246666536,
-0.399852246,
0.9443708062,
-0.1631206572,
-0.1172476932,
-0.1439698935,
0.1549476236,
-0.3384355903,
-0.4113166332,
-0.9625113606,
-0.3564485908,
0.562507391,
0.2377254516,
0.4451634884,
0.0102590173,
0.5860509872,
0.2895865142,
-0.2500466406,
0.5558946729,
-0.6971633434,
0.3107546866,
-0.2796193957,
-0.6268207431,
-0.1060853824,
-0.0625810102,
0.3509779274,
0.5141633153,
-0.2028379589,
0.0170354601,
0.0373355709,
0.9460265636,
-0.7340704799,
0.0569482855,
-1.0118842125,
-0.046388261,
-0.1832387745,
-0.283459425,
-0.4310852885,
-0.1963035166,
0.1508918256,
-0.2915959358,
-0.129756853,
0.3396522403,
0.595292449,
-0.0001736277,
-0.0964022726,
-0.3741531968,
-0.8190800548,
0.7857702971,
-0.5737887621,
0.1424540281,
0.2226706147,
0.234865129,
-0.4662581384,
-0.3692961335,
-0.8634498119,
-0.0870600417,
0.2383183092,
0.3405421078,
-0.2299304605,
0.0989367515,
0.0064276545,
0.2729980946,
-0.2833455801,
-0.0877444968,
-0.4423659444,
0.0729367509,
0.6945229769,
0.1122160181,
-0.0394634083,
0.0207828302,
-0.4382229745,
-0.1136922091,
-0.6743264198,
0.0661192536,
0.5521382689,
0.1807079613,
0.0330114402,
0.2863353491,
-0.3527560234,
0.716170013,
0.3972216249,
-0.0055330605,
0.174130097,
-0.3943962455,
0.0097626215,
0.0405836403,
0.8412283063,
0.3066614568,
0.1418579519,
-0.3407837451,
-0.5127809048,
0.2470935881,
0.4086230099,
-0.2737214565,
-0.4338447452,
0.3318908513,
-0.3041667342,
-0.6785832047,
0.0092519429,
-0.6513491869,
0.0074280454,
-0.4372785985,
0.538398385,
-0.21528624,
-0.3804665506,
-0.0001499008,
-0.1175774708,
0.0678516403,
0.2020838708,
-0.6580257416,
0.5541257262,
0.785212934,
0.7484260201,
-0.3472959697,
-0.2521719635,
-0.5737296939,
0.1292166412,
-0.635044992,
1.0497418642,
-0.5038225651,
-0.1734166741,
-0.1950185448,
-0.572507143,
0.1869747937,
-0.592964232,
0.33339715,
-0.450671345,
0.08870814,
-0.3001680672,
-0.3813862503,
0.1365933418,
0.3715811968,
-0.5352416635,
0.9024137855,
-0.1750111133,
-0.9462161064,
0.3255903125,
-0.208149448,
-0.2018877119,
0.0664018691,
-0.7271226645,
-0.4820007682,
0.1735698134,
0.0101716779,
0.308876127,
-0.6014385819,
0.2681504488,
-0.4137457609,
-0.3853666484,
0.4092127085,
-0.3560659587,
0.5309646726,
0.1346386224,
-0.5092201829,
0.2395477891,
-0.5171145201,
0.1092978492,
0.17556113,
-0.0414550006,
-0.3505607843,
0.0664734468,
-0.4761756659,
0.3256011307,
0.1044137329,
-0.136464715,
0.1667152494,
-0.4737915397,
0.2513357699,
1.044605732,
0.2798186541,
0.2939786315,
-0.5874041915,
0.337590605,
0.1342072189,
0.1501822919,
0.1524828225,
-0.3368364573,
-1.0307899714,
0.1308106333,
0.1973773986,
0.1955368668,
-1.0157431364,
0.4054540396,
0.0812268779,
-0.4621160626,
-0.5220187902,
0.4272273481,
0.7007801533,
0.3527002633,
0.2099360228,
-0.4389970005,
-0.6452720761,
-0.6229050159,
-0.2641507089,
-0.367700398,
0.3567478359,
0.0018267784,
0.3704909384,
0.0867840871,
0.6031032801,
-0.4344310164,
0.1540804058,
-0.2888939977,
0.2518917024,
0.2712445259,
0.252333194,
-0.0061546247,
-0.7267210484,
-0.419670254,
-0.0347827412,
-0.4980128706,
0.075227879,
-0.1006169841,
-0.5783709884,
0.1225886494,
0.3805072606,
-0.4098760486,
0.2314750105,
0.3467564881,
0.0642120838,
0.7245802879,
-0.1469703764,
0.0173692238,
-1.0920428038,
-0.0531053133,
-0.102091223,
-0.052232936,
-0.2708815634,
0.0081542321,
-0.4435003996,
0.30651775,
-0.0874762461,
0.1440919489,
-0.5644287467,
0.0490426868,
-0.4165377021,
0.5622068644,
-0.2588713169,
0.6410095692,
0.0036718361,
0.5613119006,
0.5242401958,
-0.5126218796,
0.4486738741,
-0.0249663424,
-0.4364718795,
0.4216294587,
-0.269366622,
0.5298660398,
-0.0665310323,
0.2863734961,
-0.9478911757,
0.0572194122,
0.1582353264,
-0.2901932299,
0.151127696,
0.1139408499,
-0.4582600296,
-0.5294719934,
-0.484064728,
0.451438874,
0.6494479179,
-0.5163032413,
0.0931278914,
0.4886519015,
-0.2730926871,
-0.5758500099,
-0.3123365045,
0.0348807536,
-0.2575119436,
-0.3238301575,
0.3598127067,
-0.0208260436,
-0.6353146434,
-0.1177348346,
-0.3904447854,
0.3062450886,
-0.1112731248,
-0.1369554251,
0.3994055092,
0.1989250779,
0.1354209483,
0.1167242229,
-0.3031544387,
0.2687944174,
-0.5075933337,
0.6073898673,
-0.3183869123,
-0.0983140171,
0.131547749,
0.2617817819,
0.3619932532,
-0.0126628997,
0.2827647626,
0.4064173698,
-0.1855755597,
-0.72073102,
-0.7092023492,
-0.2264086902,
-0.4508261979,
0.0979910642,
-0.4355616868,
-0.6351821423,
0.279700458,
-0.52039361,
-0.0058320169,
0.2135011703,
0.6291565895,
-0.349131614,
0.8078632951,
0.4183298349,
0.0401548408,
0.2929922044,
-0.4535655081,
0.549431026,
-1.0628885031,
-0.2470894009,
-0.2800804973,
-0.295247823,
-0.6215800643,
-0.3987519741,
0.6557158828,
0.4333657622,
-0.0506313369,
0.2681964934,
-0.6430070996,
0.6255691051,
0.6114577055,
0.3672630787,
0.3525545895,
-0.0089135775,
-0.5347511768,
0.2871934772,
-0.8570402265,
-0.4647936225,
1.1993942261,
-0.2935505211,
0.5502943993,
0.1025919393,
1.0927575827,
0.1012579203,
0.0362818688,
-0.6081843972,
0.7728722692,
0.0283969995,
-0.23714526,
-0.3081257641,
-0.5033905506,
-0.9890733957,
0.2541395724,
-0.4401278794,
-0.8450621963,
-0.1323932111,
0.050314188,
-0.4212747514,
0.4335829616,
-0.1643469036,
0.2384981811,
-0.2703542411,
-0.7018740773,
-0.5861242414,
-0.7674354315,
0.5071679354,
-0.2212163508,
0.1949532181,
0.1692734659,
0.1627473384,
0.9371068478,
-0.576449275,
0.5734503865,
0.3210922182,
-0.1267529428,
0.7828500867,
0.12300767,
0.755051434,
-0.1794609278,
0.0473777913,
-0.1154300123,
-0.3971606791,
-0.2862508595,
-0.5916848183,
0.8442527056,
-0.7550336123,
-0.84518224,
-0.3064400256,
-0.3156064451,
-0.3314083219,
0.074440226,
0.3618740141,
0.3210757077,
-0.0010591978,
-0.1035711914,
0.6221630573,
0.2487460673,
0.5274624825,
-0.1132867485,
-0.4488737583,
-0.708630681,
0.9558333755,
0.0412809402,
0.5184932351,
0.4014289677,
0.284004122,
-0.2097543478,
-0.5489521623,
-0.1784050018,
0.0965799838,
-0.6617951989,
-0.2254053354,
-0.4405496716,
-0.0928919017,
0.1104288474,
-0.2833105326,
-0.3119005263,
-0.2957876921,
0.3813236654,
0.0304415692,
0.2889976799,
0.7656824589,
-0.0735337064,
-0.0631961226,
-0.2840849757,
0.2224288136,
0.5737035275,
0.1316801161,
0.2803418338,
-0.1272159964,
-0.1825739145,
0.0161775984,
-0.6747838855,
-0.6057273149,
0.1064356714,
-0.4467591643,
0.5249519944,
0.2197885364,
0.1220982894,
0.6825133562,
-0.1007638797,
0.5321256518,
0.6643491387,
-0.9908264875,
0.6668941379,
-0.2897628248,
0.0761804506,
0.6694940329,
0.1912140846,
-0.0931883454,
-0.6557431221,
-0.9470899105,
-0.9462171793,
0.339194417,
0.5955848694,
-0.4559489489,
-0.0325886793,
0.1609349102,
0.2403291911,
0.4628241062,
-0.609723866,
-0.0587552302,
0.5275380015,
-0.0169886779,
0.1064168736,
0.1431310773,
-0.1478164196,
-0.0425679944,
0.7637697458,
-0.0761577412,
0.3331135511,
0.2476142049,
0.172865212,
-0.4930330813,
0.2554598451,
0.1912006885,
0.6461851001,
-0.0430071019,
0.4482700527,
0.3313310742,
0.0255684797,
0.107181266,
-0.4678099155,
-0.24989748,
-0.0234884825,
0.2941045165,
0.8402017355,
0.1897116005,
-0.6217520237,
0.5634058714,
0.0631928369,
-0.2395301908,
-0.4140241146,
0.294614315,
0.2049071193,
0.4410922825,
0.1834098548,
0.5140860081,
0.2279072553,
-0.8138123155,
0.0492513329,
0.4099972546,
-0.2528969944,
-0.2539551854,
0.3357030451,
0.294983089,
-0.5006094575,
0.5818952918,
-0.4037482738,
-0.6886378527,
0.5693234801,
0.5022428036,
1.084292531,
0.1332868338,
0.1384510398,
0.2302059829,
0.1178372204,
-0.3438243866,
0.5613512993,
-0.483127147,
-0.6717339754,
-0.6288987398,
-0.359687686,
-0.5181327462,
0.0595507994,
-0.7192940116,
0.5184363723,
-0.4118837118,
-0.1917852759,
-0.195750013,
0.1199161112,
-0.54773283,
0.0414790846,
0.3265081644,
0.3973824084,
-0.5885093212,
0.7898467183,
0.4011544287,
-0.4106917679,
-0.8643438816,
0.3947991133,
-0.095933266,
-0.6587162614,
0.4098497629,
0.0387192182,
-0.6559510231,
-0.1945262402,
-0.634398818,
-0.6886762977,
1.0147104263,
0.0373595506,
-1.1266642809,
-0.091059491,
-0.3344662786,
0.4138869941,
-0.4200581312,
0.3148732483,
0.3754319251,
0.2490375042,
0.3065938056,
-1.0030078888,
0.0755869895,
-0.4032613635,
-0.0425060019,
0.6640117764,
-1.1254864931,
0.8494699001,
-0.6140731573,
0.0059789456,
0.0052478816,
0.4524406493,
0.7545585632,
0.4811766148,
0.720836997,
0.4502563477,
0.8937520385,
0.1120393202,
0.7308843732,
-0.3891359866,
0.3802134097,
1.2629494667,
-0.3915949762,
1.0585879087,
0.7516242862,
-0.3702331781,
0.7344472408,
0.3801118433,
0.1702422053,
0.6796737909,
0.7465370893,
-0.3431639075,
-0.5259389281,
0.2071519941,
-0.2116156816,
0.2607442737,
0.3619757891,
-0.1292458326,
0.0946888328,
-0.2684106231,
-0.0684897751,
0.1898897141,
-0.3206738234,
0.9883750677,
0.3585528135,
-0.9069609046,
0.6635274887,
-0.4020612538,
0.6411117315,
-0.3399223685,
-0.200853169,
0.056087967,
0.1399234533,
0.01502176,
-0.6732606292,
0.0255408883,
-0.037865255,
0.0393332168,
-0.0734490231,
0.6908767819,
-0.4760314226,
-0.481480062,
0.4187164307,
0.6310802698,
0.2127050161,
0.1645304561,
-0.6689799428,
0.2375028878,
0.0100360764,
-0.0129610281,
0.2265488058,
0.5172207355,
-0.0300681498,
0.6277735829,
0.6657811403,
0.3539962769,
-0.2959248722,
-0.0724136233,
1.0822310448,
-0.6200330853,
-0.6434432268,
-0.9300506711,
0.1937631071,
-0.3410278559,
-0.4199575186,
0.3855041265,
0.4376394749,
1.1778968573,
0.2985582054,
0.9589628577,
0.1118225381,
0.2123716623,
-0.766137898,
0.377715081,
-0.202373758,
0.5654326081,
-0.5994808674,
-0.9609932303,
0.002455605,
0.6966282129,
-0.4679231942,
-0.0668474957,
1.1727983952,
0.6188387275,
0.2028045356,
0.2524887919,
0.2847517431,
0.3726690114,
0.0543764643,
0.8916392326,
0.9630943537,
-0.4303837419,
0.6160214543,
-0.3830805719,
-0.294116348,
-0.0633526742,
-0.6053240895,
-1.0748414993,
-0.7191500664,
-0.2293944955,
-0.6203491688,
0.3639356494,
1.2241134644,
0.5291548967,
-0.4848026931,
-0.5324318409,
-0.7273520231,
0.194625929,
-0.4623211026,
-0.1404532939,
0.259655416,
-0.4869123101,
-0.5760108232,
0.2526924014,
0.4458909333,
-0.220326677,
-0.4007795751,
-0.250490129,
-0.1963602751,
0.2685558498,
0.4909856319,
-0.1810949445,
-0.8693005443,
-0.0563013442,
-0.2718214393,
0.0928892121,
-0.0045995992,
0.836659193,
-0.8827596307,
0.8036484718,
0.4182177484,
0.2948937416,
0.7342064381,
-0.2473218143,
0.609218061,
-0.1562456042,
0.0338007547,
0.3547155261,
0.3315354288,
-0.0314585492,
-0.2846179008,
0.5210000873,
0.2119003385,
-0.4963514805,
-0.7294765711,
0.3083322048,
-1.0754259825,
-0.2995950878,
1.1358184814,
-0.0449337065,
-0.4789778292,
-0.1194324046,
-0.3649325967,
0.2593913376,
-0.4964143932,
1.1583278179,
0.7309529185,
-0.2771809697,
0.1629678458,
0.0330985822,
0.3673150539,
0.580447495,
-0.7132455707,
-0.0955007821,
0.0111322524,
-0.1229749247,
0.1959539056,
0.6366476417,
0.071926415,
0.1485174596,
0.3054588139,
-0.1336923987,
0.3292812705,
-0.4556629658,
0.0325890742,
0.1695657969,
0.1805391759,
-0.0465564132
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06913v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06913v1
|
TL;DR Progress: Multi-faceted Literature Exploration in Text Summarization
| 2024-02-10T09:16:56 | 2024-02-10T09:16:56 |
Shahbaz Syed, Khalid Al-Khatib, Martin Potthast
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper presents TL;DR Progress, a new tool for exploring the literature
on neural text summarization. It organizes 514~papers based on a comprehensive
annotation scheme for text summarization approaches and enables fine-grained,
faceted search. Each paper was manually annotated to capture aspects such as
evaluation metrics, quality dimensions, learning paradigms, challenges
addressed, datasets, and document domains. In addition, a succinct indicative
summary is provided for each paper, consisting of automatically extracted
contextual factors, issues, and proposed solutions. The tool is available
online at https://www.tldr-progress.de, a demo video at
https://youtu.be/uCVRGFvXUj8
|
[
0.0249927789,
-0.6222665906,
0.6202656031,
0.3586058915,
-0.1681852639,
0.4933253229,
-0.2605939209,
-0.0223816503,
0.4643828273,
0.4122388065,
-0.4295842946,
-0.8902590275,
-0.7083442211,
0.0876707211,
-0.4526442587,
1.3026485443,
-0.0131569803,
0.0959697217,
-0.0944745466,
-0.1217005253,
-0.678017199,
-0.1262196451,
-0.8276099563,
-0.5493066907,
0.8403378725,
0.1880130321,
0.2345126122,
0.226823464,
0.4983993769,
0.2593406141,
-0.5002567172,
0.1421913058,
-0.1528418511,
0.6099990606,
-0.187896058,
-0.2043723166,
-0.9904266596,
-0.2895593047,
0.7177841663,
0.8286334276,
0.1260875911,
0.1491084844,
0.2194591761,
1.127342701,
-0.3648905456,
-0.0019995573,
0.1357196569,
0.3703091145,
-0.2999255061,
-0.265576452,
-0.2054898143,
-0.5972502828,
0.4560786188,
-0.5653914809,
0.2126612067,
-0.2542000115,
0.3716873527,
0.2845075727,
-0.5372699499,
-0.3735077977,
-0.4390997589,
0.7549908161,
-0.744610548,
0.0458629578,
0.0162399914,
0.4820667207,
0.3355428576,
-1.1738208532,
-0.2234327495,
0.1143447906,
-0.1455902308,
0.2943805754,
0.0322595388,
0.073344335,
0.1086676419,
0.4554370046,
-0.6173601747,
-0.1681696773,
-0.4728716612,
-0.3001505733,
0.7133665085,
0.3351482451,
0.3857995272,
-0.0320239365,
0.0459093042,
-0.0367892869,
-0.2454137057,
0.0112181772,
-0.1067095026,
0.0442477204,
-0.2632221282,
0.6459400654,
-0.1684130281,
0.7058128715,
-0.2877553105,
-0.3017464578,
0.5012968779,
-0.8328860998,
-0.1560248286,
0.09180592,
0.8649178743,
0.5524141788,
0.0892429277,
-0.3066343963,
-0.2614284158,
-0.7310202718,
0.3120394051,
-0.9692212343,
-0.3801230192,
0.3964344859,
-1.0520713329,
-0.7102155685,
-0.1189143062,
-1.2717801332,
-0.6603049636,
-0.3165199161,
0.262170881,
-0.2448346168,
-0.4936298132,
-0.1549584419,
-0.634133935,
-0.0710377321,
0.7534755468,
-0.6316078305,
-0.0544065423,
0.5615833402,
1.4088400602,
-0.1978006959,
-0.1669902951,
-0.3866786361,
-0.0338365994,
-0.2968323827,
0.7640895844,
-0.3895608187,
-0.2631858289,
0.2473271787,
-0.1210576147,
-0.2067681849,
-0.2500574887,
0.6823369861,
-0.4607943296,
0.4750152826,
-0.4699263871,
-0.4138753116,
-0.4779523015,
0.6078250408,
-0.8034170866,
0.7323734164,
0.0970973894,
-0.9073070288,
0.2095406502,
-1.1768803596,
-0.669146359,
-0.2134931982,
-0.1436257213,
-0.391756326,
0.3121753037,
0.3072561324,
0.42359972,
-0.0214675032,
0.3976748586,
0.0700267628,
-0.0724307895,
0.1267605722,
-0.0242733229,
1.1649208069,
0.2307196856,
-0.2951987982,
0.6921185255,
-0.6386069655,
-0.1418165565,
-0.1560987681,
-0.3658014238,
-0.2369900644,
0.2439137548,
0.4074625075,
0.1838121712,
0.5955079198,
-0.477871418,
0.4029162228,
-0.22099787,
0.4963747859,
0.4058192372,
0.2185989171,
0.4019009769,
-0.5992094278,
0.6368162036,
0.0075290208,
-0.0792275146,
-0.8062906861,
-0.4382220805,
-0.6586532593,
0.0407862365,
0.5146317482,
0.5611405969,
-0.7745258212,
0.2565798759,
-0.2153206915,
-0.3547319174,
-0.3506110013,
-0.0936986208,
0.3071992397,
0.5123810768,
0.5551275611,
-0.1851316243,
-0.4641283453,
-0.6442164779,
-0.260196805,
0.1314726621,
-0.2476599365,
0.1565265059,
0.4426254034,
0.0277895909,
0.8540302515,
-0.4496150613,
-0.7952343225,
-0.4894005954,
0.4983420074,
0.0863145962,
0.4096719921,
0.7028717995,
-0.7999619246,
-0.5476363301,
-0.0333298296,
-1.2156283855,
-0.2166985124,
-0.1765302271,
0.1858863682,
0.1548148096,
0.8731386065,
-0.2831555307,
0.4103268385,
0.3541429639,
-0.5416628122,
0.3935244381,
-0.2837505043,
0.1036913469,
-1.3410218954,
0.4047759473,
-0.0420871228,
-0.195857808,
-0.6054709554,
0.0881024227,
0.1229469031,
-0.0951949134,
0.0053901225,
0.2928002179,
-0.4151156247,
0.0227993038,
-0.3961286545,
0.5937691331,
0.1487345099,
0.0946571454,
-0.1592217833,
0.8845152855,
0.4695443511,
-0.5388126373,
0.080429934,
0.1267644763,
0.1191514358,
0.4762842953,
-0.862116456,
-0.1989560276,
-0.2012681067,
0.2980837822,
-0.9272567034,
-0.1186756417,
0.0467144884,
-0.6395561695,
0.3086985946,
0.3256175518,
-0.4447858036,
0.1375744641,
-0.8159713149,
0.5424646735,
0.3231998384,
-0.1311020553,
0.9040461183,
0.4977609515,
-0.3459022045,
-0.6205970049,
-0.7848699093,
0.5941745639,
0.0468984991,
-0.5185539722,
0.5991073847,
-0.231347844,
-0.4043949842,
-0.1425130069,
0.073316142,
-0.0163340755,
0.1366175562,
-0.1922767311,
-0.0295078382,
-0.2997277379,
0.2105496675,
0.3693876863,
0.0810392424,
0.2434763163,
-0.2263652533,
0.4211092889,
0.0172221288,
0.2247842103,
-0.2746720016,
0.5308778882,
0.426925838,
-0.3245374262,
0.1239817962,
0.9354496598,
-0.4650631547,
-0.0068059834,
-0.2320071906,
0.1485581398,
-0.3693395853,
0.4176492691,
-0.0488207489,
-0.8384544253,
0.5075436234,
-0.0629180521,
0.6093453169,
0.8483991027,
0.5406937003,
-0.3315111697,
0.7253896594,
1.0971139669,
-0.035667669,
0.4114656746,
-0.1847131252,
0.0097306054,
-0.9623740315,
-0.5629412532,
-0.603749752,
-0.5946104527,
-0.4911204278,
-0.2691642344,
0.3028151095,
0.033131212,
0.1249116212,
0.0802125707,
-0.7356591225,
0.3972518444,
0.2990112007,
0.0975574553,
0.6469501853,
-0.2640077174,
0.0016117631,
-0.3469842076,
-0.3532844484,
-0.279571414,
1.2099915743,
0.3981290758,
0.3355126083,
0.4544304907,
0.7809651494,
0.6156898141,
0.52714324,
-0.9461008906,
0.4150557816,
-0.3424164653,
-0.4298806787,
-0.3042826355,
-0.2792223096,
-0.8928848505,
0.2965049148,
-0.0503219329,
-0.7126060128,
0.1361989975,
-0.0380405895,
-0.3431293964,
0.3906808794,
-0.4048602581,
0.784299016,
-0.2581631541,
-0.0937698632,
-0.3508524895,
-0.6298946738,
0.4664775431,
-0.142849341,
0.1196849719,
0.1975956112,
-0.5182994604,
1.068508029,
-0.09876021,
0.7208989859,
-0.3516096771,
-0.1348202378,
-0.026220426,
-0.1321524978,
0.0734755993,
-0.0299001429,
0.1017909124,
0.1080907881,
-0.2631389499,
-0.3451938331,
-0.270011127,
0.5272875428,
-0.2501750588,
-0.105100356,
-0.6492690444,
-0.7490642667,
0.2085501403,
0.7621451616,
0.034036804,
0.426569134,
-0.3050322235,
0.1813874692,
0.7892764807,
-0.5717118382,
1.1162303686,
0.3084118366,
-0.6121101975,
-0.8105351925,
0.8818365335,
0.1282712817,
-0.244183138,
0.5378025174,
0.0742714629,
-0.0896627158,
-0.9590056539,
-0.5140520334,
-0.026337903,
-0.5440366268,
-0.2994434834,
-0.9736729264,
-0.218977809,
-0.46664083,
-0.0427168049,
-0.0943581536,
-0.6384935975,
-0.26170066,
0.0307230409,
0.0447140448,
1.2652031183,
0.1350585073,
0.2491758466,
-0.7579596043,
0.3226207793,
0.0109422365,
0.2097193897,
0.1060222462,
-0.3828347325,
-0.5709450245,
-0.2186083794,
-0.7412937284,
-0.8108925819,
0.5073153973,
0.4151796103,
0.2206908166,
0.2888664603,
0.1620501578,
0.3264558017,
-0.2690169513,
1.0842649937,
0.204367891,
-0.864785552,
0.7967514992,
-0.4870520532,
0.6132047772,
0.6132181287,
0.182079643,
-0.5072809458,
-0.3041972816,
-0.5181336999,
-1.1831793785,
0.3757106364,
0.228147611,
-0.1835236698,
0.5130940676,
0.127252385,
-0.0248943549,
0.4906976819,
-0.5122414231,
-0.5458023548,
-0.3645648658,
-0.3206873834,
0.0094098914,
-0.2399235368,
-0.2233855575,
-0.2554064095,
0.3972092569,
-0.1637181342,
0.2351976633,
0.4662385881,
-0.3368422687,
0.1640308946,
0.1882531196,
1.1435717344,
1.1154202223,
-0.4392320514,
-0.0715502277,
-0.2136004865,
-0.7067116499,
-0.2724827826,
0.4514593184,
-0.5594390035,
0.5638083816,
0.6432182789,
0.2680303156,
0.1133094952,
-0.509088099,
0.8077466488,
-0.4678167999,
-0.5505797267,
-0.7488884926,
-0.2868868709,
-0.0710508898,
0.5629299879,
0.7234355807,
0.314096272,
0.5288113356,
-0.1408318132,
0.2522660792,
0.0737301558,
-0.5400356054,
-0.413643688,
0.8169167042,
0.3903979063,
-0.5764625072,
0.3742393255,
-0.267903626,
-0.6105313897,
0.5168610215,
0.0903199464,
1.4494810104,
0.2429374754,
0.3089137673,
0.6244138479,
0.3927564323,
-0.0152697647,
0.2012613863,
-0.2222365886,
-0.2661945224,
-0.8920387626,
-0.1918879151,
-0.4383107722,
0.1187721863,
-0.5809946656,
0.0232325383,
-0.3995712399,
-0.0832079872,
0.384943068,
0.1677189469,
-0.212868467,
-0.0225469582,
-0.2230519503,
1.069163084,
-0.4465530813,
0.9347302914,
0.8811043501,
-0.6542184949,
-0.0751431063,
0.5081830621,
0.1470717788,
-0.3113907576,
0.5498324037,
0.3553608954,
0.2157292962,
-0.0683265179,
-0.3405979574,
-0.623468399,
1.5466855764,
0.0167744942,
-0.3185734153,
-0.2090164125,
-0.3743596971,
0.6666686535,
-0.4534544647,
0.4889294803,
0.5983611345,
0.5356834531,
-0.3984127343,
-1.0090504885,
0.0167539399,
-0.5729894042,
-0.05680345,
0.1957814097,
-0.6321929097,
0.9707802534,
-0.2793957889,
-0.0751785934,
-0.0941907391,
0.6700379252,
0.0956663936,
0.8351552486,
0.3043739796,
0.5710337162,
0.6476581693,
-0.2445403934,
0.8466200233,
-0.3023269176,
0.3656298518,
1.1505209208,
0.2569046021,
0.5304799676,
0.4528425038,
-0.0313867405,
0.5484731793,
0.678409934,
0.0615656786,
0.4620851576,
0.0822106525,
-0.2193540037,
0.3040318191,
-0.2960338593,
-0.4988710284,
0.0238716844,
0.4082174301,
-0.6927024722,
-0.5730548501,
0.0222013369,
0.1449116915,
0.1844196767,
-0.3275815845,
0.9727712274,
0.0974291265,
-0.6802777648,
0.2073374093,
0.0483244881,
0.9297261834,
-0.3351401091,
-0.2604347467,
-0.3770331442,
0.0871823281,
-0.4999549389,
-0.7879789472,
0.5617288947,
0.0079564992,
-0.3886358738,
-0.4628783762,
0.736851275,
-0.4875124395,
-0.2920893133,
0.3128653467,
0.656199038,
0.1165490523,
-0.1475533843,
-0.7932659388,
-0.1688992977,
0.3161544502,
-0.4379423261,
0.2702432275,
0.690951705,
0.2103881836,
0.5274159312,
0.2099204361,
0.1580940038,
-0.1548663974,
0.2696499228,
0.8513425589,
-0.9755106568,
-0.4010222256,
-0.8323679566,
0.9078807831,
-0.5848893523,
-0.6216058135,
0.6715833545,
0.7103372812,
0.6453615427,
0.0649487451,
0.9175928235,
-0.4683361351,
0.6491337419,
-0.4199666977,
1.0328506231,
-0.7302876115,
0.3692446947,
-0.2165775746,
-0.801017046,
-0.5212944746,
0.5790732503,
0.1567880213,
0.0717340186,
1.0828325748,
0.2283368856,
0.2185617089,
-0.0136942593,
-0.0074566859,
0.1056067944,
0.4682090878,
0.205688566,
0.2522646785,
-0.6918832064,
0.5001897812,
-0.3959231973,
-0.1787786335,
-0.1630286127,
-1.0584872961,
-1.1260784864,
-0.6615193486,
-0.4986585081,
-0.4120510519,
-0.1163058877,
0.5978785753,
0.2984952331,
-0.8147503138,
-0.2315046489,
-0.173490122,
0.270303756,
-0.3523161709,
-0.310975939,
0.6262563467,
-0.8154999018,
-0.6539112329,
0.2468983531,
0.1457996964,
-0.1178762242,
-0.4767410755,
0.0897364169,
-0.2655761242,
-0.5654985905,
0.9151715636,
0.0802731812,
-0.3915389478,
0.0948498771,
-0.1608194262,
0.0390147194,
0.0301981885,
1.0964789391,
-0.5411576629,
0.5435499549,
0.7954739332,
0.8361988664,
0.596835494,
-0.1974075884,
0.7810745239,
-1.0017508268,
-0.1725248247,
0.4530024529,
0.0903472453,
0.2811105549,
-0.1300571263,
0.691105783,
0.1772034764,
-0.6777562499,
-0.7839917541,
-0.1193104014,
-1.1286832094,
-0.3629160821,
0.634080708,
-0.2001651376,
0.0294393748,
-0.2762697637,
-0.2218164653,
0.3475262523,
-0.7253482938,
0.7505057454,
0.6123752594,
-0.1570162773,
-0.4690324664,
-0.9576249123,
0.6302562952,
0.4004302621,
-0.9200329781,
-0.0318010636,
0.5122793913,
0.0133563746,
0.6095453501,
0.7466523051,
-0.2383474261,
0.1805870235,
-0.3052565455,
0.0207161661,
-0.1621898115,
-0.2526507378,
-0.6722650528,
0.4263828695,
-0.0305490792,
0.0064911889
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06907v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06907v1
|
Investigating Consistency in Query-Based Meeting Summarization: A Comparative Study of Different Embedding Methods
| 2024-02-10T08:25:30 | 2024-02-10T08:25:30 |
Chen Jia-Chen, Guillem Senabre, Allane Caron
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With more and more advanced data analysis techniques emerging, people will
expect these techniques to be applied in more complex tasks and solve problems
in our daily lives. Text Summarization is one of famous applications in Natural
Language Processing (NLP) field. It aims to automatically generate summary with
important information based on a given context, which is important when you
have to deal with piles of documents. Summarization techniques can help capture
key points in a short time and bring convenience in works. One of applicable
situation is meeting summarization, especially for important meeting that tend
to be long, complicated, multi-topic and multi-person. Therefore, when people
want to review specific content from a meeting, it will be hard and
time-consuming to find the related spans in the meeting transcript. However,
most of previous works focus on doing summarization for newsletters, scientific
articles...etc, which have a clear document structure and an official format.
For the documents with complex structure like transcripts, we think those works
are not quite suitable for meeting summarization. Besides, the consistency of
summary is another issue common to be discussed in NLP field. To conquer
challenges of meeting summarization, we are inspired by "QMSum: A New Benchmark
for Query-based Multi-domain Meeting Summarization" proposed by Microsoft and
we also propose our Locater model designed to extract relevant spans based on
given transcript and query, which are then summarized by Summarizer model.
Furthermore, we perform a comparative study by applying different word
embedding techniques to improve summary consistency.
|
[
-0.348469317,
-0.6538391113,
0.4819667041,
0.2493206114,
-0.1631540656,
0.1893406212,
0.0368570276,
-0.5340698957,
0.5898867846,
0.0041497732,
-0.4675125778,
-0.6559595466,
-0.6365051866,
0.2934658825,
-0.4448527396,
0.7665687203,
-0.2932721674,
0.1708257645,
-0.6176506877,
-0.5262934566,
-0.4168515205,
-0.8622720242,
-0.4092879593,
0.0022970401,
0.0664578229,
0.1908693016,
0.6128869057,
0.3828302026,
0.5483099222,
0.242605567,
-0.4530043602,
0.6829357743,
-0.6010129452,
0.2468236387,
-0.0370884053,
-0.4222266078,
-0.586324811,
0.0597488917,
0.8247718215,
0.8738664985,
-0.2873440981,
-0.041094508,
0.179341346,
0.7143477798,
-0.519849658,
0.1325359493,
-0.683444798,
0.1607843786,
0.1209883615,
-0.22850205,
0.0184289198,
-0.6320264935,
0.1875565201,
-0.420285821,
0.5673192739,
0.332198292,
1.035815239,
-0.0981256887,
-0.3777306676,
-0.2907565236,
-0.4207746685,
0.6966876984,
-0.9154682755,
0.6159845591,
0.4719434083,
0.2436720133,
-0.2662876546,
-0.6513860822,
-0.4638772309,
-0.004048551,
-0.1589879841,
0.1292975992,
-0.0807423964,
-0.0452948846,
0.2346973717,
0.5335216522,
-0.7027656436,
-0.0345004052,
-0.1113395765,
-0.112919867,
0.5036074519,
0.4600752294,
0.3468700349,
-0.1297814846,
-0.1403994113,
0.1028657928,
-0.6845744848,
-0.1869592667,
-0.0094484948,
0.175384894,
-0.1162852943,
0.8195374608,
-0.7268397808,
0.4002313614,
0.03789974,
0.1109693125,
0.2267445773,
-0.8187513947,
-0.0581988357,
-0.0338372923,
0.6681302786,
0.9741385579,
0.0962409899,
-0.3624480367,
-0.1067010388,
-0.2380081862,
-0.0799543858,
-0.835295856,
-0.2179199755,
0.4769058526,
-0.5269903541,
0.2553002834,
0.2617946863,
-0.4464562535,
-0.1004875973,
-0.3340723813,
0.3935324848,
-0.4179014564,
0.0008068515,
-0.0379542373,
-0.2200969309,
0.1661997586,
0.5836066604,
-0.7710658312,
0.3164110482,
0.7905291319,
1.0981092453,
-0.3795643747,
-0.3331584036,
-0.4741823077,
0.1514915973,
-0.1602816731,
0.7583968639,
-0.2126037627,
-0.5111160874,
0.0897772089,
-0.0209245458,
-0.3818231225,
-0.7352275252,
0.4660039544,
-0.3697805107,
0.4962125421,
-0.5399880409,
-0.9642026424,
0.0073665143,
0.6184347868,
-0.4274460077,
1.0069233179,
-0.1637502164,
-0.7586119175,
0.5196590424,
-0.4831327796,
-0.0652724132,
-0.2034113407,
-0.5041695237,
-0.8403108716,
0.1064654067,
0.4809676111,
0.2791980803,
0.3079286218,
0.1147370934,
-0.0301933121,
-0.55459553,
0.3188995123,
0.1442314386,
0.3659929633,
-0.0967678353,
-0.1523574591,
0.1922252923,
-0.5335084796,
0.109977521,
0.0768515468,
-0.2827062607,
-0.369987458,
0.4003014266,
-0.1271339208,
0.1496975124,
0.3036096394,
-0.5378665924,
0.1947442144,
-0.3662138283,
-0.0450638011,
0.2645899951,
0.4713717401,
0.4228947163,
-0.6169409752,
0.3551209569,
-0.0644072294,
0.0225475002,
-0.5036690235,
-0.4412508011,
-0.429476738,
-0.2867847383,
0.2286141664,
0.366163969,
-0.2508071065,
0.3520676196,
-0.4329250455,
-0.4175980389,
-0.5013051629,
-0.1197906137,
0.511890471,
0.0890103206,
0.3499791324,
-0.1165804639,
-0.7257856727,
-0.7698951364,
-0.625726223,
0.0312647261,
-0.1145212129,
0.2003671229,
0.475010097,
-0.0906999856,
0.9646050334,
-0.6646499038,
-0.3747315705,
-0.2650484443,
0.0673144981,
0.1918891519,
0.5989056826,
0.5553039312,
-0.8219259381,
-0.5533768535,
-0.2611947954,
-0.844845891,
0.0851373672,
-0.0103434054,
-0.1552998573,
0.2700821757,
0.6151616573,
-0.4182053208,
0.5745954514,
0.3084219098,
-0.2847739458,
0.4622350633,
-0.1226125807,
0.6204328537,
-1.2235740423,
-0.0428074338,
-0.3786088228,
-0.4578679502,
-0.3477384746,
0.1234026328,
0.1090034619,
-0.1116742641,
-0.1298750788,
0.0952120274,
-0.7601820827,
-0.0815235376,
-0.202075839,
0.6052774191,
0.2777328789,
0.4444321096,
-0.0992100239,
0.8368584514,
0.3411869705,
-0.7227317691,
-0.1754384637,
0.8545811772,
-0.1361005008,
0.6233500242,
-0.9290796518,
0.1418076158,
-0.0603259578,
0.1909365803,
-1.1085227728,
0.0121809384,
0.0739056468,
-0.7328705788,
0.2557696998,
-0.1293232888,
-0.6523846984,
0.1861476451,
-0.9068306088,
0.2638352811,
0.2122131288,
-0.4200511575,
0.4850000739,
0.5477229357,
-0.2569982708,
-0.2944339216,
-0.4872591197,
0.2789358199,
-0.0106481025,
-0.5081884265,
0.6570906043,
-0.1060343906,
-0.2656435072,
0.0987568945,
-0.5681599379,
0.0091364877,
-0.1474471092,
0.3882680237,
0.0942997187,
-0.2437028736,
0.0464759283,
0.1949960738,
0.1343975961,
-0.08785896,
0.0519691929,
0.3674683869,
-0.2042884231,
-0.5488001704,
-0.7916397452,
0.8869076371,
0.5758392215,
-0.4349341691,
1.0607076883,
0.3321929276,
-0.5613991618,
0.2456517071,
-0.6573745012,
-0.073114872,
-0.3603866398,
0.4778696001,
-0.3723157048,
-0.9618855715,
0.9222083092,
-0.2330608368,
0.4152210951,
0.5122320056,
0.4030806124,
-0.1940409541,
1.1438949108,
0.7099929452,
-0.0040650158,
0.548686564,
-0.134665668,
0.0197556913,
-0.9322626591,
-0.5594524145,
-0.78714329,
-0.1970800757,
-0.4890074432,
-0.2334346473,
0.2293682694,
0.3158639669,
0.2798365951,
0.3556782305,
-0.2357676476,
0.347856611,
0.2235811651,
-0.2221389711,
0.4215752184,
-0.0117815128,
-0.2418308109,
-0.2296571434,
-0.7935809493,
-0.6424137354,
0.6899896264,
-0.0880990773,
0.4069676399,
0.3613831699,
0.9382286668,
0.1933757067,
0.0589402877,
-0.6786883473,
0.4671873748,
0.3222711384,
-0.3608357906,
-0.2973977923,
-0.6000065207,
-1.1788080931,
0.6914072633,
-0.4584228396,
-0.7527700067,
0.2139029354,
-0.0751437992,
-0.0010090806,
0.2971164882,
-0.4981342554,
0.7102953792,
0.2627122104,
0.0143533889,
-0.0566613004,
-0.5124950409,
-0.087409988,
0.1551578194,
0.1957405061,
-0.3299723864,
-0.0259529427,
1.0234022141,
-0.4967024922,
0.4570560157,
0.0889139622,
-0.0465214625,
0.1490554363,
0.1484363824,
0.51070261,
0.1761696339,
-0.1543964744,
-0.0525635257,
0.3255400062,
-0.4671025872,
-0.776117146,
0.6414555311,
-0.4485116899,
-0.4785069823,
-0.4067242742,
-0.3911347091,
-0.338604033,
0.048275806,
0.1727131754,
0.7584788799,
-0.4776433408,
0.1336740404,
0.4949135184,
0.0684430003,
0.3231462836,
0.6145458817,
-0.312566489,
-0.4676528871,
0.5182219148,
0.1849062145,
0.1608310789,
0.5356520414,
-0.0690459758,
-0.2437780201,
-0.881267786,
-0.1244254708,
0.3564540446,
-0.5159537792,
-0.2699317634,
-0.9283218384,
-0.0375262275,
-0.4863791466,
-0.0749536976,
-0.4156745076,
-0.743624568,
-0.1974084973,
-0.2042644322,
0.0699358359,
0.5087849498,
0.2318783402,
0.141831696,
-1.1399726868,
0.4312535822,
-0.1324187815,
0.3336003125,
-0.0817507431,
-0.3421405256,
-0.4676112533,
0.0548066795,
-0.4348474741,
-0.9872687459,
0.2171119899,
0.4997956157,
0.9715585709,
0.2862226963,
0.1920997202,
0.703755796,
-0.3377046585,
0.8121886253,
-0.0120345857,
-0.7978492379,
0.721519351,
-0.2373348325,
0.3172469437,
0.8906797171,
0.4331552088,
-0.6892089248,
-0.6577345729,
-0.7075183988,
-1.1366249323,
0.4647028148,
0.4940558374,
-0.1107878536,
-0.2805712819,
0.5123072863,
0.1253966242,
0.3706990778,
-0.0621717907,
-0.335441947,
0.077467747,
0.008067688,
0.0374572426,
-0.4176829755,
-0.0689978749,
-0.0088421134,
0.5127504468,
0.0526286662,
0.233935982,
0.5430882573,
-0.2030330449,
0.12011455,
0.2696133852,
0.7233442664,
1.1389827728,
-0.5663664937,
0.0664505661,
0.3489694893,
-0.3952767551,
-0.3247863948,
0.007825573,
0.02504614,
0.5182983279,
0.4260475338,
0.2817623317,
0.2579355836,
-0.6860071421,
0.6322304606,
-0.2801160812,
-0.2591987848,
-0.0044296975,
-0.2030005753,
0.0297018085,
0.1479272544,
0.499083221,
-0.1175774634,
0.4066954553,
-0.554099679,
0.3522023559,
0.3784039915,
-0.402720511,
-0.2221541852,
0.6912153959,
0.0811351836,
-0.3104464114,
0.603885293,
-0.3063282073,
-0.7216817141,
0.3155189157,
0.3187270463,
0.6141133904,
0.0455441065,
-0.177543655,
0.5220782161,
0.115061231,
-0.0326613262,
0.4961853921,
-0.0997566655,
-0.3343294561,
-0.4045072496,
-0.2605022788,
-0.8758012652,
-0.4541986287,
-0.8622800708,
-0.1743693501,
0.0182606764,
-0.2612002492,
-0.3110445738,
0.2585674226,
-0.2717386186,
-0.0947293863,
-0.361009866,
0.7458606362,
-0.6120207906,
0.2269738615,
0.6653270125,
-0.2992330492,
-0.5230771899,
0.0208124202,
-0.0337770879,
-0.2147241235,
0.0199673958,
0.1468510926,
-0.1278341711,
-0.3485142589,
-0.3728951812,
-0.6200246811,
1.1889238358,
0.0433170609,
-0.6136086583,
0.0001544278,
-0.2210869938,
0.3778900206,
-0.1029430181,
-0.0397778228,
0.1664063334,
0.0494533852,
0.1044771746,
-1.1354802847,
0.2126745284,
-0.2768796384,
-0.197886169,
0.399125874,
-0.3816991448,
0.5816350579,
-0.194236517,
-0.3778010309,
0.2922441661,
0.9840272665,
0.4771249294,
0.83589077,
-0.0018025821,
0.3369660974,
0.9711772799,
-0.1153511479,
1.0162523985,
-0.1437450945,
0.5890396237,
1.4150180817,
-0.2182784975,
0.9723278284,
0.5519978404,
-0.362487942,
0.2270283103,
0.3369424045,
0.0082688928,
0.343115896,
0.2013822794,
-0.0104785254,
0.1100034565,
-0.1303678304,
-0.6534221768,
0.3512979746,
0.2291419208,
-0.1529655159,
-0.3974653482,
-0.3621819615,
0.2111202925,
0.3254264295,
-0.1944209039,
0.9808163047,
0.2119908482,
-0.5240160227,
0.3785935938,
0.1420809478,
0.585863471,
-0.5961097479,
-0.0268062111,
-0.4064610004,
0.0301987175,
-0.2612316906,
-0.4647731483,
0.5470830202,
-0.2353940904,
-0.1185291409,
0.0746892542,
0.3292497993,
-0.5107858777,
0.0043427311,
-0.0993662551,
1.0366219282,
0.346706748,
-0.3955911696,
-0.3852717876,
0.0941192806,
-0.2066681087,
-0.0869771466,
0.411051482,
0.5243315697,
-0.0330433063,
0.4420366287,
0.5183458328,
-0.1108711809,
0.0806089491,
0.3793901205,
0.8395912647,
-0.5827900767,
-0.6826725006,
-0.8827418685,
0.1888391674,
-0.3619448245,
-0.2162434608,
1.1154742241,
1.1843463182,
0.4499056041,
0.138843596,
0.2327331454,
0.3175331354,
0.656009078,
-0.5373936296,
0.8273376226,
-0.4412708282,
0.1764172465,
-0.392947197,
-0.998290956,
-0.5283864737,
0.5186546445,
0.0208990183,
0.0626629665,
0.7405192852,
0.6204063892,
0.1289381981,
-0.0272581093,
0.2009778768,
-0.1851994395,
0.4300988317,
0.3120958507,
0.8611793518,
-0.5526437163,
0.5420311689,
0.1408968568,
-0.0534388758,
-0.5309658051,
-0.7709295154,
-0.8443311453,
-0.7249878049,
-0.8103764057,
-0.313025564,
0.2264814526,
1.0324548483,
0.5260275006,
-0.8257575035,
-0.0118591469,
0.1815178394,
0.1167052239,
-0.3787431717,
-0.2360444069,
0.7912749052,
-0.1592642367,
-0.7522860765,
0.3427367508,
0.3235900402,
0.2436243594,
0.3905739784,
0.0858678296,
-0.420031637,
0.149451375,
0.5531873107,
0.2948853672,
-0.4519327283,
-0.1354794204,
0.0007727806,
-0.2176484764,
0.1462117583,
0.7519454956,
-0.5494574308,
0.2746647,
0.6195328832,
0.5978450775,
0.6576779485,
0.3274498284,
0.4726975858,
-0.8688560128,
-0.4724406302,
0.0253072847,
0.4224793911,
0.3959473372,
-0.2058453858,
0.5996117592,
-0.0127351275,
-0.6062863469,
-0.7713412046,
0.0115876766,
-1.4207961559,
-0.0410044715,
0.8794410825,
-0.2772498727,
0.1844421029,
-0.1968474984,
-0.5221800208,
0.437082082,
-0.3348277807,
1.0143830776,
0.3802295327,
-0.4375668168,
0.081026718,
-0.2359400243,
0.5359575152,
0.3951144218,
-0.7697080374,
-0.0088125216,
0.3778358698,
0.1868412942,
0.2001938373,
0.7111741304,
-0.4110746682,
0.3355106711,
-0.1261880398,
-0.2527785301,
-0.3242477775,
0.0234160554,
-0.2135319412,
0.4179808497,
-0.0560973361,
-0.6323360801
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05553v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.05553v1
|
Understanding the Progression of Educational Topics via Semantic Matching
| 2024-02-10T08:24:29 | 2024-02-10T08:24:29 |
Tamador Alkhidir, Edmond Awad, Aamena Alshamsi
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Education systems are dynamically changing to accommodate technological
advances, industrial and societal needs, and to enhance students' learning
journeys. Curriculum specialists and educators constantly revise taught
subjects across educational grades to identify gaps, introduce new learning
topics, and enhance the learning outcomes. This process is usually done within
the same subjects (e.g. math) or across related subjects (e.g. math and
physics) considering the same and different educational levels, leading to
massive multi-layer comparisons. Having nuanced data about subjects, topics,
and learning outcomes structured within a dataset, empowers us to leverage data
science to better understand the progression of various learning topics. In
this paper, Bidirectional Encoder Representations from Transformers (BERT)
topic modeling was used to extract topics from the curriculum, which were then
used to identify relationships between subjects, track their progression, and
identify conceptual gaps. We found that grouping learning outcomes by common
topics helped specialists reduce redundancy and introduce new concepts in the
curriculum. We built a dashboard to avail the methodology to curriculum
specials. Finally, we tested the validity of the approach with subject matter
experts.
|
[
-0.6137817502,
-0.7731182575,
0.5033338666,
-0.0256698541,
0.0335996225,
0.3283585012,
0.0521634668,
0.1700938046,
0.1675321013,
0.636705637,
-1.0330984592,
-0.6223278642,
-0.5981131196,
-0.1435383558,
-0.7008274198,
0.9571592808,
0.1595803499,
-0.0639664382,
-0.6772609353,
0.1859380901,
-1.1746244431,
-0.108268626,
-0.3364869952,
-0.3986335993,
0.4131342769,
0.6059779525,
0.4179322124,
0.6850844026,
0.8343458772,
0.2899914384,
-0.2568762302,
0.0086202351,
-0.3771681488,
0.1396146268,
-0.4526943564,
-0.1937857419,
-0.2595740855,
-0.2141103446,
0.5501292944,
1.2493855953,
-0.1019736826,
0.0387260169,
0.3531142175,
0.809715867,
-0.3702145517,
0.226813361,
-0.4913614392,
0.3462487757,
-0.1439231634,
-0.2117059529,
-0.2939752638,
-0.3167516887,
0.559401989,
-0.7684397101,
0.695876956,
-0.6490703821,
0.9948508143,
0.4857415855,
-0.5154035091,
-0.4577021301,
-0.3664752245,
0.7588844299,
-0.1541695595,
0.5415226221,
0.374992758,
0.2417732626,
-0.1762262136,
-0.724744916,
-0.3223797083,
0.3271003366,
0.0377012528,
0.3268896937,
0.324333638,
-0.3406464458,
0.0027772461,
0.2438331544,
-0.555247128,
0.1091993824,
-0.6566868424,
-0.2577845752,
0.4245837927,
0.4293335974,
0.2474476695,
-0.0722729564,
-0.3381282389,
-0.3078434765,
-0.5560319424,
-0.2705980241,
0.4185684919,
0.4671881497,
-0.1291703433,
0.5771197677,
-0.1752018631,
0.9603296518,
0.1494922936,
0.1155038625,
0.2499283403,
-0.498385787,
0.2492425889,
0.1423480362,
0.0308472514,
0.4435926378,
0.0214357357,
-0.112525247,
0.3315456212,
0.3518196344,
0.4550637007,
-0.5611417294,
-0.260443002,
-0.0414306819,
-0.2143379897,
0.0179303549,
0.1137141809,
-0.9183291197,
-0.1592062116,
-0.8367717266,
0.2615974247,
-0.4860408008,
-0.0163298305,
0.3927717209,
-0.2104788274,
0.4562137127,
0.6510980725,
-0.7409772277,
-0.1613657176,
1.2973144054,
0.7220000625,
-0.2450980097,
-0.2417067885,
0.1578422636,
0.1861373633,
-0.1489408612,
0.8846459389,
-0.8141084909,
-0.395391196,
0.0651956275,
0.121299766,
-0.0649291873,
-0.2883848548,
0.3013817072,
-0.7854443789,
0.5014800429,
-0.1418309212,
-0.846441865,
0.0440954342,
0.3445833325,
-0.4633514285,
0.8206472397,
-0.0468380041,
-0.8735098243,
0.4893803895,
-0.5458453894,
-0.3821629584,
-0.1979764402,
-0.1950467378,
-0.4521126747,
-0.0579734668,
0.0488145538,
0.4259151518,
-0.225380674,
0.5432369709,
-0.0111899832,
-0.2911515236,
-0.0937390924,
-0.0550220124,
0.5779051781,
0.2458634377,
0.1011978611,
0.0110288495,
-0.5929883122,
-0.3746129572,
-0.3255787492,
-0.1759676486,
-0.4176437855,
0.4124722183,
-0.367614001,
0.2668908834,
0.4123333097,
-0.2668822408,
0.1306104511,
-0.1400083154,
0.2814006209,
0.9028892517,
0.1204239354,
0.3509528339,
-0.3445621133,
0.1546328217,
0.4762025476,
-0.0525358841,
-0.4316186309,
-0.6393703818,
-0.8332477808,
-0.1496489346,
0.4535355568,
0.3304493427,
-0.5721904039,
0.7959498763,
-0.3784430921,
-0.5835894942,
-0.5135202408,
-0.1891977936,
-0.0890960544,
0.8083616495,
0.4869560003,
-0.6955611706,
-0.4199236333,
-0.761072576,
-0.0437895842,
-0.1064847857,
-0.1721368432,
-0.0030476304,
0.2165765464,
-0.4677317142,
1.5186752081,
-1.0100107193,
-0.137963295,
0.1754390001,
0.1652100086,
0.2881400883,
0.7854663134,
0.1662444174,
-1.0075126886,
-0.5337148309,
-0.1446859539,
-0.8477765918,
-0.1687247157,
-0.1647007614,
-0.745708406,
-0.3987112045,
0.370300889,
-0.0135245258,
0.3615956604,
-0.1074515283,
-0.8389977813,
0.2422179282,
-0.0117398538,
0.1035311967,
-1.1040673256,
-0.3530805409,
0.1221824139,
0.2513307631,
-0.3736161292,
-0.0783559904,
-0.0028673657,
-0.4819028378,
-0.1921225935,
0.2197909057,
-0.0099399611,
-0.0980470106,
-0.1332357526,
0.4290916026,
0.0717728809,
0.1156915426,
0.2233190835,
0.7242227793,
0.9189530611,
-0.5704283714,
0.2152124494,
0.6322510839,
-0.0761223063,
0.7500416636,
-0.5727843046,
-0.1125973538,
-0.4082566798,
0.0530137345,
-0.765411377,
-0.0735293031,
-0.07463599,
-0.3924643993,
0.1565713137,
-0.1493046433,
-0.3296534717,
-0.2803099751,
-0.1380054355,
0.1091304719,
0.5603148341,
-0.2866061628,
0.535936892,
0.2030098289,
-0.3303714693,
-0.5222441554,
-0.3637222946,
-0.1120458469,
-0.2956954837,
-0.7403436303,
0.3674472868,
-0.1246563047,
-0.0689536184,
0.151227057,
-0.346432507,
-0.2345751673,
0.3421669304,
0.083070226,
0.4692865908,
-0.3552363217,
0.1922145933,
0.2824873626,
-0.3676877022,
0.1215671599,
-0.3042755723,
0.5620983243,
0.2909359336,
-0.6465851068,
-0.2724319398,
0.3350199461,
0.5043649673,
-0.1936168522,
0.7144036293,
0.4763271809,
-0.2909478843,
0.1011995375,
-0.3840043247,
-0.4785253406,
-0.4710097015,
0.5641494393,
-0.2446864843,
-0.6195506454,
0.3440065384,
-0.22914505,
0.2283973098,
0.4873159826,
0.4078232646,
0.0166948754,
0.5980875492,
0.8383154869,
0.1632782966,
0.5239855647,
-0.4318144321,
0.2541984916,
-0.6915365458,
-0.6982716918,
-0.4446440935,
-0.2341743261,
-0.7524121404,
-0.5057005882,
0.0225462578,
0.1306590587,
-0.2689705193,
0.5346845984,
-0.7253012657,
0.4367471635,
0.3632239699,
0.2798137367,
0.2927862108,
0.2597734034,
0.1293324679,
-0.2936541736,
-0.32982108,
-0.5624639988,
1.0486708879,
0.2555812895,
0.6460140347,
0.0801331624,
0.8413574696,
0.4797419012,
0.3798176944,
-0.5338306427,
0.7579616904,
-0.5381501913,
-0.3809302747,
-0.1684440672,
-0.4057996571,
-1.0696560144,
0.2126310319,
-0.2789568007,
-0.3452815413,
0.1784186214,
-0.3371807933,
0.1036731005,
0.0690196976,
-0.547627449,
0.8184949756,
0.1875787675,
-0.5821329355,
-0.4300131202,
-0.8222358823,
-0.116765976,
-0.4924310148,
0.0222018845,
-0.3260752559,
0.0723326951,
0.9733917117,
-0.156091705,
0.67822963,
0.0123826917,
-0.290281862,
0.2912765443,
-0.2962094843,
-0.263810128,
0.0146571733,
-0.1803547889,
0.1119879037,
-0.204787448,
-0.7106947303,
-0.6134090424,
0.7836310863,
-0.9902293086,
-0.8433254957,
-0.3735281825,
-0.6339984536,
-0.1913684756,
0.0055470555,
-0.2237464786,
0.3390431106,
-0.0320067331,
0.0203473736,
0.9375681281,
-0.202645272,
0.1830323339,
0.8391654491,
0.2185542881,
-0.0597259887,
1.1402504444,
0.0040230285,
0.0836299136,
0.4620288312,
0.0297116451,
-0.1142503247,
-0.218455255,
0.0239905287,
0.1849545538,
-0.8278082609,
-0.2460685223,
-0.7380851507,
-0.3469932973,
-0.3673189282,
-0.6294701099,
-0.0639661551,
-0.3353229165,
-0.5278903246,
0.1079714298,
0.2422550619,
0.5951974392,
-0.1553881615,
0.2217907459,
-0.6149007082,
0.1231756061,
0.5969172716,
0.0797327831,
0.029967105,
-0.5830822587,
-0.0606575795,
0.1651890576,
-0.9363580942,
-0.6648895741,
0.1202875078,
0.2782965302,
0.4671751857,
0.3616890609,
-0.065996699,
0.8220328689,
-0.5585259795,
0.7972460389,
0.2643289268,
-0.9345078468,
1.0320807695,
-0.1341055334,
0.0755168498,
0.3567045629,
0.6005874276,
-0.5407910943,
-0.3159900308,
-0.614951849,
-1.1264441013,
0.6992174983,
0.1906770319,
0.3626517653,
-0.0243917517,
0.2553978264,
0.4032607377,
0.219715625,
-0.0233328957,
-0.2955905795,
-0.4042411149,
-0.6786141992,
0.0954049006,
0.1586626768,
-0.0012541059,
-0.2201962918,
0.4695438445,
-0.0504331104,
0.297211349,
-0.2433554083,
-0.1687112898,
0.4204179049,
0.3899002075,
0.3758011758,
0.8433262706,
-0.1195209697,
-0.0348221883,
-0.0130842431,
-0.6439192295,
0.1493385732,
0.2477040142,
0.0287626591,
0.1334114969,
0.5222926736,
0.3742410243,
0.3093272448,
-0.6971485615,
0.303927213,
0.1025943905,
0.1029597148,
0.0391607173,
0.232901901,
-0.0268079098,
0.2021908611,
0.5572689176,
-0.1564182639,
0.0653775036,
-0.6331246495,
0.8028492332,
-0.1099196374,
-0.4599919021,
-0.3181026578,
0.4923148751,
0.3282293081,
-0.2877657413,
0.9807567596,
0.3588806987,
-0.3648985624,
1.1691102982,
0.5770568848,
0.6556230783,
-0.0157882236,
0.5017311573,
0.4003433287,
-0.2499138564,
-0.0807013959,
0.1259419918,
-0.3025816977,
-0.6716400981,
-0.3449684978,
-0.6502799392,
-0.5015066266,
-0.5080654621,
-1.2341239452,
0.5603665709,
0.1143238544,
-0.1778756976,
0.1577998251,
-0.1437286139,
-0.7805957198,
0.2307015657,
-0.0260714218,
0.8535096645,
-1.1520595551,
0.4387533069,
0.9810510278,
-0.340847373,
-0.2681022286,
0.2336828709,
-0.3815861046,
-0.6610349417,
1.0660040379,
0.1233209968,
0.2851637304,
0.0829209834,
-0.0910975486,
-0.7685847878,
1.0153582096,
0.0285802186,
-0.6947492361,
-0.218205303,
0.1985803545,
0.6471983194,
-0.2630251646,
0.1287448853,
0.3929694593,
0.2850704491,
0.2467157543,
-0.3956107497,
-0.3786538839,
0.0634835064,
-0.1411201358,
0.5389638543,
-0.3948230147,
0.8164869547,
-0.069615677,
-0.0642269254,
-0.1075113118,
0.8265071511,
0.3616097867,
0.7050862312,
0.1467055678,
0.6663902998,
0.4908194542,
-0.6073012352,
0.1774102747,
-0.5376771688,
0.8464910388,
0.7361412644,
-0.1645118892,
0.5820345283,
0.3583909869,
-0.3226761222,
0.7763935924,
0.9667125344,
-0.2855371535,
1.0230573416,
0.2249546349,
-0.000548056,
-0.3487066627,
-0.0460166819,
-0.7749867439,
0.2533160746,
0.7287154198,
-0.0883367062,
-0.6529619694,
0.3106679022,
-0.3079537749,
0.2374147326,
-0.5159246922,
0.8277131319,
-0.3330527842,
-0.5171536803,
0.2085356712,
-0.2557288408,
0.629058063,
-0.5430910587,
-0.1649354845,
-0.3992793262,
0.0192042962,
-0.0990140736,
-1.1886198521,
0.4535682499,
-0.1843216717,
-0.4136974812,
-0.2309142947,
0.5196069479,
-0.6795631051,
-0.5241302848,
0.0944093987,
0.4897708595,
-0.0361076742,
0.663867116,
-0.6245037317,
0.0474207066,
-0.1834659427,
0.4080265462,
0.2768596709,
0.7416991591,
-0.0744247884,
0.6309098005,
0.3497411311,
-0.1899635047,
-0.0522743389,
-0.017686462,
0.9972147942,
-0.6446350813,
-0.5901883245,
-0.680341661,
0.4126752019,
-0.12731646,
-0.3492269516,
0.6691843867,
0.684851706,
1.0847302675,
-0.0430705622,
0.3931153715,
0.0539172962,
0.287794888,
-0.4162316024,
0.3713605702,
-0.4434411824,
0.5301163197,
-0.3288169503,
-0.8250212073,
-0.0496645346,
0.5595023632,
-0.3042763472,
-0.1050516218,
0.4580829144,
0.4992154837,
-0.2319195271,
0.0948578045,
0.0109936856,
-0.255231142,
0.0838560387,
0.3950173855,
1.0195274353,
-0.3246074617,
0.0338996165,
-0.0494835004,
-0.1167170107,
-0.1383412778,
-0.363250196,
-0.8551849723,
-0.6112197042,
-0.9110432267,
-0.2328139246,
0.4086970389,
0.5108907819,
0.5650079846,
-0.7997149229,
-0.1191724688,
-0.197794944,
0.5231587887,
-0.1446791887,
-0.3353045583,
0.6840685606,
-0.3334020972,
-0.65953058,
0.0038583199,
0.1236352175,
-0.0040893853,
-0.2500813007,
0.3802555501,
-0.0355197079,
0.1016425863,
0.520666182,
-0.0035360146,
-0.6524202824,
-0.3049941957,
0.0381336957,
0.1112268865,
0.0134244794,
1.1826725006,
-0.9279266,
0.4371453226,
0.5763417482,
0.8736014962,
0.3210732341,
-0.1368110925,
0.3185374737,
-0.6968955994,
0.0728534684,
0.1702581346,
0.0682829991,
0.3881417215,
-0.1638596654,
0.5876441598,
0.4350591898,
-0.4074103534,
-0.9449417591,
0.2206777036,
-0.7098825574,
-0.2975845039,
0.4443277717,
-0.1083875299,
0.2391629666,
-0.4297102392,
0.1234996915,
0.3807583749,
-0.1454032958,
1.1212877035,
0.8146104217,
-0.2016117275,
0.1499356776,
-0.2519685626,
-0.1768348217,
0.3759404123,
-0.7527558208,
-0.2790672481,
0.1137663946,
0.3784546852,
0.4308218658,
-0.0920130312,
-0.068478629,
0.0664158687,
-0.159782812,
-0.226397723,
0.2889870107,
-0.3429619372,
0.0629593208,
0.1313755363,
-0.5377318859,
-0.4221559167
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06900v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06900v3
|
Can LLMs Recognize Toxicity? Definition-Based Toxicity Metric
| 2024-02-10T07:55:27 | 2024-06-18T04:35:12 |
Hyukhun Koh, Dohyung Kim, Minwoo Lee, Kyomin Jung
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In the pursuit of developing Large Language Models (LLMs) that adhere to
societal standards, it is imperative to detect the toxicity in the generated
text. The majority of existing toxicity metrics rely on encoder models trained
on specific toxicity datasets, which are susceptible to out-of-distribution
(OOD) problems and depend on the dataset's definition of toxicity. In this
paper, we introduce a robust metric grounded on LLMs to flexibly measure
toxicity according to the given definition. We first analyze the toxicity
factors, followed by an examination of the intrinsic toxic attributes of LLMs
to ascertain their suitability as evaluators. Finally, we evaluate the
performance of our metric with detailed analysis. Our empirical results
demonstrate outstanding performance in measuring toxicity within verified
factors, improving on conventional metrics by 12 points in the F1 score. Our
findings also indicate that upstream toxicity significantly influences
downstream metrics, suggesting that LLMs are unsuitable for toxicity
evaluations within unverified factors.
|
[
0.0466889516,
-0.5148527622,
0.9924684763,
0.1963602006,
-0.1929745823,
-0.0747476146,
-0.175989598,
-0.3632520735,
-0.0406374894,
0.4825704098,
-0.3456417918,
-0.7352414727,
-0.73846066,
0.391990453,
-0.2763127089,
1.0878260136,
0.056500908,
-0.0407489873,
-0.5712392926,
-0.4807286561,
-0.2593043149,
-0.4819944501,
-0.5920528769,
-0.4144408107,
1.0641871691,
0.4279174805,
0.5885756016,
0.6708545685,
0.571128726,
0.3795976639,
-0.638084054,
0.0346028544,
-0.5352923274,
0.2343004942,
-0.4380700886,
-0.4917713404,
-0.5548375249,
0.0218109712,
0.5065757036,
0.4400359392,
-0.1571835726,
0.3291217983,
0.2346380651,
0.5211756825,
-0.8245831728,
-0.0192677137,
-0.7632109523,
0.1472258419,
-0.1991324723,
-0.3134099245,
-0.5839637518,
-0.4420908391,
-0.1995611787,
-0.3106987178,
-0.5729609132,
-0.2070492208,
0.5636026263,
0.4864706099,
-0.6971812248,
-0.7501251101,
-0.5950554609,
0.8788200617,
-0.8992710114,
0.3056168556,
0.0601003133,
0.1931118518,
-0.1896951199,
-0.5438498259,
-0.2987609804,
-0.3992637992,
-0.1247431412,
0.0805514157,
0.1751772016,
-0.0225540884,
0.0433521271,
0.3350997567,
-0.3072044253,
0.3811618388,
-0.0608718544,
-0.4229096174,
0.6304720044,
0.628808558,
0.3161762059,
-0.2341070771,
-0.5849424601,
0.3262950778,
-0.8974471092,
-0.2495535016,
0.3702142239,
0.2462894469,
0.0446412489,
0.5040078759,
0.1719644964,
0.2006760687,
-0.2908055186,
-0.2550551593,
0.2037444115,
-0.3066005111,
-0.0767382085,
-0.100967899,
0.9770741463,
0.3929763734,
0.0091870176,
-0.0409586839,
-0.2620393932,
-0.0463919677,
0.2940074801,
-0.981851995,
-0.1497915089,
0.3651022911,
-0.516502142,
-0.6861911416,
-0.4232179821,
-0.9021194577,
-0.9238219261,
0.3002371788,
0.5243869424,
-0.1313986033,
-0.3570990264,
-0.011648844,
-0.0899231359,
-0.0138620939,
-0.059083771,
-0.5370605588,
0.080265671,
0.448420167,
1.1094758511,
-0.286875993,
0.1613560319,
-0.5497451425,
-0.0035660623,
-0.3540306389,
0.8403303623,
-0.4692057967,
-0.4137302339,
-0.0904445052,
-0.1527798325,
0.2197934389,
-0.9509680867,
0.88393718,
-0.3219585121,
-0.0591600277,
-0.463778466,
-0.4179331064,
-0.0148410015,
0.4383181334,
-0.435493499,
0.9258289933,
0.2621267736,
-0.965944171,
0.5776106119,
-0.4705344141,
-0.20307751,
0.1089915261,
0.2813471556,
-0.4432422817,
0.0698767677,
-0.2225618958,
0.38365978,
-0.1453167498,
0.2429393679,
-0.7680737376,
-0.4064724743,
0.4003364742,
-0.5460710526,
0.7350017428,
0.3373345733,
0.0263170768,
0.4413729906,
-0.7940692306,
0.0045892801,
-0.0516788103,
-0.892416358,
-0.4878012538,
0.3788325191,
0.0366741866,
0.2192308009,
0.0048311702,
-0.653930068,
-0.4198502302,
-0.1803936064,
0.6621892452,
0.8511547446,
0.1479439288,
0.2970480621,
-0.3843779266,
0.2293241918,
0.0221669469,
0.1790692806,
0.088106066,
-0.1938667148,
-0.8239499331,
-0.4001375735,
-0.0805830136,
0.3881899714,
-0.4189048707,
0.9068701267,
-0.4157683551,
-0.8561946154,
-0.0785052031,
0.1574997008,
0.3789476156,
0.5835186839,
0.1960909814,
-0.4236985743,
-0.3191718459,
-0.3527722955,
-0.3302455544,
-0.5245369673,
-0.1246287897,
0.5400405526,
0.5113465786,
-0.4104964733,
0.6782838106,
-0.338205725,
-0.5923275352,
-0.080754593,
-0.0313881226,
0.1267112643,
0.0111027369,
0.4335155189,
-0.1220600978,
-0.5081059933,
0.044435814,
-0.9462352395,
-0.5394979119,
0.093273893,
-0.1446039975,
-0.1588787884,
0.6949628592,
-0.19902803,
-0.0719855726,
0.5090802908,
-0.3977840245,
0.5606126189,
-0.299482584,
-0.1959542632,
-0.5525929332,
0.1643153727,
0.1881798953,
-0.2154170424,
-0.4598390162,
0.1270708293,
0.0351335295,
0.300899148,
-0.8143630624,
0.4826221764,
-0.1663583815,
0.0724540874,
-0.05466941,
0.2082529217,
0.1591963023,
0.0732069388,
0.0030026829,
0.5285416842,
0.3605739474,
-0.7149000168,
0.4956682026,
0.1824221015,
-0.3288423717,
0.8818938136,
-0.589725256,
-0.0853172913,
-0.1774265617,
0.2943574488,
-0.9571203589,
-0.2004015148,
0.3160070181,
-0.2835179567,
0.0312724449,
-0.1238777339,
-0.5505223274,
-0.2157936245,
-0.1991411299,
0.3972180784,
0.5121085644,
-0.5076910853,
0.3881851137,
0.4631922245,
-0.125987038,
-0.2195340395,
-0.8417996764,
-0.0780516267,
-0.8456842899,
-0.3610139787,
-0.278796047,
-0.2168076038,
-0.2256877273,
-0.0913909152,
-0.0778024644,
-0.1569319218,
0.1719790101,
0.2952484488,
-0.0615596958,
-0.2338339388,
0.2760993242,
0.0158431362,
-0.0761447251,
0.6833257675,
0.2911569774,
0.1602730751,
-0.0336643681,
-0.3036208749,
-0.1312073916,
0.0599346533,
1.026086092,
-0.1401889324,
0.6273237467,
0.2381247431,
-0.1965281069,
-0.3900482655,
-0.079977937,
0.1836642623,
-0.5668305159,
0.5854327679,
0.2152819186,
-0.4309452772,
0.7294804454,
-0.296361804,
-0.1952463984,
0.3277084529,
0.6823952794,
0.0816373751,
1.0891336203,
0.4337597489,
-0.1101509705,
0.2303306162,
0.1309382766,
0.019504061,
-0.8593981266,
-0.3539514244,
-0.4161797762,
-0.1683214605,
-0.5099983215,
-0.2267038077,
0.8380918503,
-0.2356850058,
-0.8192196488,
-0.1138064861,
-0.2978377342,
0.5557095408,
-0.0614964701,
0.3825258911,
0.3823863864,
-0.2288578302,
-0.280225724,
-0.0267527103,
-0.4632230401,
-0.7914426327,
0.8941780925,
0.9659962058,
0.7779091597,
0.124270983,
0.5751530528,
0.1486881077,
1.114726305,
-1.0226256847,
0.5527217984,
-0.1102954447,
-0.8935398459,
-0.1698673815,
-0.7330808043,
-0.3025643826,
0.133973375,
-0.108985506,
-0.603520453,
-0.0235283505,
-0.040690735,
-0.2335114181,
0.4427716732,
-0.620001018,
0.9883950353,
-0.5353991985,
-0.3305809498,
-0.0372832455,
-0.2228431106,
0.3823693395,
-0.3067279458,
0.6301658154,
-0.5243856907,
-0.3665733635,
0.4398858547,
-0.5419248939,
0.7561778426,
-0.2270730138,
-0.4812382162,
0.4931204915,
0.1645277441,
0.1751000583,
0.1017594412,
-0.3716914058,
0.2423067689,
-0.0276613012,
-0.1512007713,
-0.3515286744,
0.7965608239,
-0.4651974142,
-0.0857485235,
-0.4888218343,
-0.3524799645,
-0.3273870647,
0.3007487953,
0.3902856112,
-0.0180884954,
-0.2330936491,
-0.0126302419,
0.5263161659,
-0.7465272546,
0.2868070304,
0.6795443296,
-0.0866679624,
-0.3108600378,
1.1671397686,
-0.0726753548,
0.540890038,
0.0014660024,
0.7021445632,
-0.4484183192,
-0.6806852221,
-0.3094992936,
0.1756246537,
-1.1089371443,
-0.4574687779,
-0.2411037385,
-0.4798779786,
0.3381887674,
0.0781330541,
-0.4305107594,
0.5405923128,
-0.4415965676,
-0.2894145548,
0.3553467989,
1.0379837751,
-0.0671119541,
0.1303159446,
-1.0690393448,
-0.1718920469,
0.0615693927,
1.0130470991,
0.0018180007,
-0.6831009984,
0.0908739865,
0.127050966,
-0.3298887312,
-1.0385766029,
0.4735870957,
0.4151577055,
0.5768609643,
0.8492761254,
0.352304399,
0.3084149957,
-0.324598372,
0.7100325227,
-0.0430146344,
-1.0150418282,
0.4131414592,
-0.4021796882,
-0.1903018355,
0.4896303117,
0.5765045285,
-0.4946555793,
-0.8765669465,
0.0453753397,
-0.8102401495,
0.3571735919,
0.065775387,
0.5294859409,
-0.397020638,
0.3392978907,
0.1101954952,
-0.1314166635,
-0.9182094932,
-0.110973306,
0.0404611677,
-0.3381327093,
-0.1123507693,
-0.5789140463,
0.0975862816,
-0.1767444909,
0.4606467187,
0.0856812671,
-0.0907265693,
-0.0065188105,
-0.1261752248,
-0.382766217,
0.5392184258,
0.1781516075,
0.2708838582,
-0.5024535656,
0.3004851341,
0.1954334527,
-0.6209295392,
0.4264957607,
-0.4331617653,
-0.157021001,
-0.2094088048,
0.4165968001,
0.1622449607,
0.199716419,
-1.0838508606,
0.6906945109,
0.0374525562,
-0.1623446047,
-0.0487573408,
0.0655323789,
0.0936388448,
0.105849117,
-0.1074185222,
-0.0553190559,
0.2359542847,
-0.7026911974,
0.2625974417,
0.4649932683,
-0.9260885715,
-0.1314357817,
0.7078036666,
0.6045902371,
0.1495454311,
0.4991445243,
-0.3784053624,
-0.4833756983,
0.503518343,
0.4125759304,
0.6941116452,
-0.0713867918,
0.1990198195,
0.4786140919,
0.2760754824,
0.0968160778,
0.2967968881,
0.4008457065,
-0.8067361116,
-0.3040986061,
-0.8804972768,
-0.2047266066,
0.3314608932,
-0.6717530489,
0.2012298554,
-0.5956242681,
-0.2164822817,
-0.0312839411,
-0.3087541461,
-0.2462459952,
0.0325904936,
0.1888841987,
0.9832639098,
-1.3327354193,
0.2630165219,
0.6373555064,
-0.4556565285,
-0.5253753066,
-0.0935371965,
0.1933244914,
-0.5539217591,
0.4610740542,
0.3550385535,
0.0607483722,
-0.1537475288,
-0.348492384,
-0.6249656081,
1.0482766628,
0.3821030855,
-0.1800872982,
0.2334559113,
0.2364906669,
0.975476563,
-0.1500762552,
0.6043348908,
0.603908658,
0.467013061,
0.2832246721,
-0.8670275211,
0.3555403352,
-0.1976557523,
-0.0050606364,
0.0531139225,
-0.5734812021,
0.5302827954,
-0.2874158919,
-0.5251199007,
0.2000769973,
0.3107199967,
-0.0196063891,
0.5197145939,
0.4671225846,
0.4229350686,
0.6296815276,
0.0233881734,
0.7449082732,
-0.0035973052,
0.3846635222,
0.7537324429,
-0.4420897663,
1.023460269,
0.2566636801,
-0.2700224221,
0.5910891294,
0.7243573666,
0.1602387875,
0.6274903417,
0.4925096929,
-0.3780899048,
-0.3585832417,
-0.4518348575,
-0.0046642423,
0.3872958422,
0.6403008699,
-0.6454861164,
-0.3923118412,
-0.1192579195,
-0.0725541711,
0.2847285271,
-0.624233067,
0.8868278265,
0.1926058978,
-0.4134847224,
0.5335842967,
-0.1075257957,
0.8125545979,
-0.4032247066,
0.1532805264,
-0.2633675933,
0.4466085136,
-0.428154707,
-1.0817735195,
0.7629182339,
-0.0144949546,
0.3108313084,
-0.1589222997,
0.7603072524,
-0.3347768784,
-0.3618553281,
0.4953325987,
0.580045104,
0.1539417803,
-0.2672916353,
-0.2431492507,
0.1187002733,
-0.5117737651,
0.0285156686,
0.3608632386,
0.6540739536,
0.111378625,
1.0283750296,
0.2575468719,
0.2486640662,
0.0543651879,
-0.111340031,
0.8574389815,
-0.4041649401,
-0.1434489042,
-0.8575827479,
0.6538149118,
0.2059291005,
-0.2388943881,
0.5872036815,
0.3602357805,
0.6269020438,
0.1256067753,
0.6994114518,
0.0761677474,
0.4766193628,
-0.3701801002,
1.0612620115,
-0.6000343561,
0.5834453106,
-0.1052314267,
-0.784296453,
-0.2818345428,
0.5482401848,
-0.0408471338,
0.1294433326,
0.5554195642,
0.8478876948,
0.0748697743,
-0.3552030623,
0.1796476841,
0.4376399815,
0.3455091715,
0.8510301113,
1.2180203199,
0.088363938,
0.8194959164,
0.0329663493,
-0.3084927499,
-0.2765108943,
-1.3564720154,
-0.9722314477,
-0.2589564323,
-0.2681130767,
-0.5585994124,
-0.0279066637,
0.4521872401,
0.3524830043,
-0.6927260756,
0.0411078446,
-0.2598295212,
0.4884227514,
-0.0769503564,
-0.25567469,
-0.1564065814,
-0.3099748194,
-0.2923305333,
0.0516099222,
0.3319784403,
-0.1495740265,
-0.4722848833,
-0.3013176918,
0.3492088318,
0.3267427385,
0.7791664004,
0.0856117532,
-0.4878530502,
-0.7340340018,
-0.152127862,
-0.4875441492,
-0.1145661548,
0.5418414474,
-0.4006144106,
0.4508654177,
0.5697856545,
0.2007537782,
-0.316280961,
-0.1961329281,
0.4312638044,
-0.8293726444,
-0.2634187639,
0.4174373448,
0.2382323742,
0.4273357689,
-0.4966026843,
0.3105252683,
0.0956364498,
-0.6192877889,
-0.8599627614,
0.2895262241,
-0.7560785413,
0.0349242203,
1.7490882874,
-0.3426383138,
-0.0921771005,
-0.2969737053,
0.0141721964,
0.0200011935,
-0.1047772542,
0.758903861,
0.6350120902,
0.0366637893,
0.0153500792,
-0.5014099479,
0.5053179264,
-0.0409884863,
-0.9640826583,
0.1819622517,
0.4872466922,
0.8353831172,
0.1255159229,
0.5988196731,
-0.4558881223,
-0.0781225041,
0.0943958461,
-0.4416734278,
0.0211318806,
0.028196713,
-0.1859249473,
-0.1532322764,
0.3879732192,
0.0530066788
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06894v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06894v2
|
GenTranslate: Large Language Models are Generative Multilingual Speech and Machine Translators
| 2024-02-10T07:20:49 | 2024-05-16T13:17:05 |
Yuchen Hu, Chen Chen, Chao-Han Huck Yang, Ruizhe Li, Dong Zhang, Zhehuai Chen, Eng Siong Chng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Recent advances in large language models (LLMs) have stepped forward the
development of multilingual speech and machine translation by its reduced
representation errors and incorporated external knowledge. However, both
translation tasks typically utilize beam search decoding and top-1 hypothesis
selection for inference. These techniques struggle to fully exploit the rich
information in the diverse N-best hypotheses, making them less optimal for
translation tasks that require a single, high-quality output sequence. In this
paper, we propose a new generative paradigm for translation tasks, namely
"GenTranslate", which builds upon LLMs to generate better results from the
diverse translation versions in N-best list. Leveraging the rich linguistic
knowledge and strong reasoning abilities of LLMs, our new paradigm can
integrate the rich information in N-best candidates to generate a
higher-quality translation result. Furthermore, to support LLM finetuning, we
build and release a HypoTranslate dataset that contains over 592K
hypotheses-translation pairs in 11 languages. Experiments on various speech and
machine translation benchmarks (e.g., FLEURS, CoVoST-2, WMT) demonstrate that
our GenTranslate significantly outperforms the state-of-the-art model.
|
[
-0.3259090781,
-0.2958498895,
0.4893360138,
0.2075661868,
-0.3325857818,
0.3298717141,
-0.3625156879,
-0.071394898,
0.1293891668,
0.4411090612,
-0.4022967815,
-0.5313007832,
-0.9016748071,
0.2624928057,
-0.8886696696,
0.7719284296,
0.0829363093,
0.0464612655,
-0.1615770608,
0.0661214963,
-0.0102221072,
-0.187937364,
-0.5527282953,
-0.5060353875,
0.4001774192,
0.1289068311,
0.8166772723,
0.6261653304,
0.4577960372,
0.2776735425,
-0.3313036263,
0.4063203037,
-0.4759358466,
0.4780845046,
-0.2343357801,
-0.4046894014,
-0.4766538739,
-0.1431061178,
0.6357010007,
0.6655263305,
-0.1503460854,
0.3450380862,
0.1250891536,
0.2580786049,
-0.3753123283,
0.1205366924,
-0.6026434302,
0.0140819121,
-0.3110809922,
-0.2963133454,
-0.7025541067,
-0.525704205,
-0.2593250871,
-0.6928414702,
0.3460700214,
0.0285435542,
0.6350818276,
0.4181374609,
-0.407273829,
0.0877701268,
-0.83062464,
0.6064277291,
-0.9635300636,
0.6138221622,
0.3504040837,
0.2400702983,
-0.1542420983,
-0.5694358349,
-0.4111749232,
-0.0688358545,
0.1121804044,
-0.094381541,
-0.1894176006,
-0.1940102577,
0.1099762022,
0.3675752878,
-0.8082287312,
0.3237815201,
-0.2044412494,
-0.2706507146,
0.511418879,
-0.0833031684,
0.2953453064,
-0.1035434529,
-0.3016035557,
-0.3636319041,
-0.8544832468,
-0.5110117197,
-0.0029534346,
0.3973978758,
-0.1426118165,
0.5481531024,
-0.3353598416,
0.7002409697,
-0.0324739292,
-0.3423916101,
0.5283227563,
-0.4506962299,
-0.2460306138,
0.0236014295,
0.8481416702,
0.1657846272,
0.1506013721,
-0.3402851522,
-0.134681344,
-0.0556815974,
-0.2077197433,
-0.7474045753,
0.1041362733,
0.1450219005,
-0.3547641039,
-0.2291868478,
-0.2675073147,
-0.94078058,
-0.2951001823,
-0.2433312535,
0.0926144645,
-0.4665479362,
-0.2837055027,
0.1871994287,
-0.1129768342,
0.1688304693,
0.2562407851,
-0.8519356847,
-0.1458427608,
0.5353813171,
0.7377278805,
-0.2363152504,
-0.452831924,
-0.8735994697,
0.3072384596,
-0.5273512602,
0.717307508,
-0.2329422086,
-0.079942748,
0.2045277357,
-0.1616475433,
0.0544073023,
-0.5547170639,
0.5587031245,
-0.4007309079,
0.2105451673,
-0.2355018556,
-0.4583506286,
0.0951829553,
0.0713395327,
-0.5216294527,
0.7084433436,
0.2516387999,
-0.2033028156,
0.3693142235,
-0.2968886197,
-0.7099942565,
0.4676893353,
0.1356734782,
-0.1753584296,
0.1874475479,
0.4408268631,
0.4756956398,
-0.6677754521,
0.6301634908,
0.0166055486,
0.0593503676,
0.2012482136,
-0.357616812,
0.6851281524,
0.6910045743,
-0.2048449218,
0.1243792176,
-0.3321537673,
-0.0326174237,
0.3308474422,
-0.5172334313,
-0.1543889493,
-0.0733390898,
-0.0498037376,
0.352888763,
0.1275887489,
-0.6603460312,
0.1686510593,
-0.383386761,
0.7299618125,
0.3998712599,
-0.4059126973,
0.5837949514,
-0.1206569299,
0.6989365816,
-0.0739535913,
-0.0379825607,
-0.1027225778,
-0.6131765246,
-0.5448178649,
-0.1211846322,
0.4352819324,
0.5745953918,
-1.1601403952,
0.2076093853,
-0.7910671234,
-0.1998454183,
-0.9010639787,
0.4673445523,
0.3483721018,
0.1592171192,
0.5367236137,
0.0137850391,
-0.4478619695,
-0.7517704964,
-0.2239845097,
0.0987392887,
-0.1180031076,
-0.5674447417,
0.1529709697,
-0.2484708428,
0.4561167955,
-0.2416084856,
-0.263445884,
-0.7363785505,
0.172740519,
0.1146177873,
0.3634246588,
0.3906731606,
-0.6732619405,
-0.2874364555,
0.172056675,
-0.6684871316,
-0.1559617519,
-0.1446787119,
-0.334335506,
-0.0456679426,
0.6251387,
-0.7966338396,
-0.081428729,
0.8772950768,
-0.2158181518,
-0.0073978053,
-0.0595124625,
0.0822847188,
-1.3456423283,
-0.0652191713,
-0.0620503016,
-0.3461798131,
-0.7798634768,
0.3976415396,
0.1458161324,
-0.0445327908,
-0.5125813484,
0.5116140842,
-0.3570715785,
-0.1419422328,
-0.175832808,
0.2348054945,
0.0060467864,
0.1146316975,
-0.2586369812,
0.8044171929,
0.1225580499,
-0.4260401428,
0.5325670838,
0.7287990451,
-0.383392781,
0.3023061454,
-0.2714086473,
-0.0221344493,
-0.3155223727,
0.2652435303,
-0.8993530273,
-0.3691962361,
0.0490141958,
-0.5590490699,
0.5246025324,
-0.1247487068,
-0.6781075001,
-0.4765883088,
0.1564425677,
0.3818281293,
0.738045156,
-0.6296344399,
0.5180749297,
0.1225376502,
-0.381395936,
-0.3035993576,
-0.9153500199,
0.470985651,
-0.15817976,
-0.5727515817,
0.464057833,
0.0679758117,
-0.0475782268,
-0.1265175641,
0.0403403863,
0.2003413886,
-0.0426934175,
-0.1820675433,
0.22255674,
-0.3205070794,
0.1018572599,
0.1277628243,
-0.2907947302,
-0.2004904449,
-0.549626708,
0.870236516,
0.2324794382,
-0.3114061356,
-0.2541159987,
0.4803709686,
0.849806428,
-0.7383524776,
0.5682974458,
0.7515540719,
-0.1724010408,
-0.2849869132,
-0.6437229514,
-0.1089223623,
-0.3806737363,
0.483160466,
-0.4527254701,
-0.8987537622,
0.2015288621,
-0.2502485812,
0.1311297715,
0.6280758381,
0.6613164544,
0.0647552758,
1.0942943096,
0.2482654452,
-0.2255474031,
0.2738593221,
-0.2453303784,
0.3921830058,
-0.7489846945,
-0.1146465391,
-0.6306773424,
-0.2011361122,
-0.6338066459,
-0.6999750137,
0.2403641641,
-0.135585472,
-0.0824674219,
0.6477035284,
-0.3509133756,
0.0965806991,
0.6487317085,
-0.1543406844,
0.4314364493,
0.2898490131,
-0.0408834517,
0.1490654647,
-0.8098227382,
-0.3241372108,
1.040111661,
0.2240247875,
0.654735446,
0.3001356721,
0.6802855134,
0.0072373697,
0.4183544219,
-0.5678017735,
0.5957005024,
-0.6145654917,
-0.5930472016,
-0.3623014092,
-0.6632413864,
-0.9669810534,
0.4664275348,
-0.2534834743,
-0.1902198642,
0.0295446496,
0.0778778493,
-0.2031775713,
0.3787917197,
-0.3411096334,
0.7492671013,
-0.4095837176,
-0.3513488173,
-0.1136545539,
-0.5619549751,
0.3573292792,
0.0160770733,
0.4214680791,
-0.1950737834,
0.2096111327,
0.4679673314,
0.1267026514,
0.5178585649,
0.01067119,
-0.38640818,
-0.0356616341,
0.3249415457,
0.5410318971,
-0.4274055064,
-0.1881313771,
0.1259947717,
-0.1979120523,
-0.3270300329,
-0.3956750035,
0.4556546807,
-0.5087460279,
-0.4985221326,
-0.1554761976,
-0.6997740865,
-0.1058987901,
0.2640334964,
0.5578415394,
0.2545283735,
-0.0909980163,
0.2532843649,
0.7310946584,
-0.360254854,
0.288649857,
0.2830776572,
-0.4613485634,
-0.4399282932,
0.959023416,
-0.1513618678,
0.7747817636,
0.5920948386,
0.1062284186,
-0.3787439167,
-0.8437828422,
-0.7550367713,
0.2988522351,
-0.674998939,
-0.3890210688,
-0.5181757808,
-0.3367785811,
-0.7150137424,
0.0026673416,
-0.4032188058,
-0.2435603738,
0.0727479011,
-0.1821200401,
0.0100029036,
0.3870489895,
-0.1685588062,
0.172098577,
-0.6992053986,
0.6773512363,
0.3103193343,
-0.010772231,
-0.3285192549,
-0.6895091534,
-0.1301413476,
0.1427992731,
-0.1831609607,
-0.841479063,
0.8602426052,
0.3088684976,
0.7440167069,
0.2014087588,
-0.1541496068,
0.4501255155,
-0.4802760184,
0.5135934353,
0.3909754753,
-0.8322232962,
0.3941377699,
-0.3370104134,
0.4610285461,
0.4445385635,
0.2938540876,
-0.7642893195,
-0.5627333522,
-0.157678172,
-0.7939888835,
0.3170945942,
0.1718261987,
0.1089470536,
-0.0797273368,
0.0866227746,
0.1856603622,
0.2703357041,
-0.5794585943,
0.0478679724,
-0.1329640746,
-0.405351162,
-0.5189983249,
-0.1683476418,
-0.1076521948,
-0.3202441335,
0.5435443521,
-0.3068321347,
0.3702390492,
-0.0186237916,
-0.2813718021,
-0.3223424852,
0.612829864,
0.6654475927,
0.521794498,
-0.0505352356,
0.4491189718,
0.0369629823,
-0.1610256284,
0.4515031576,
0.2988107204,
-0.5053349137,
0.0800464824,
0.4919655025,
0.8391939998,
0.0391332023,
-0.4378800094,
0.3502248526,
0.3677200675,
-0.3923044503,
-0.0068360288,
-0.1793503016,
0.3936307132,
0.2125080824,
0.2858112454,
0.1225913242,
0.0454461984,
-0.5199388266,
0.0953675434,
0.3822125494,
0.1209141612,
-0.041211661,
0.9738970995,
0.1885528564,
-0.2292465866,
0.6268253922,
-0.5688525438,
-0.5259695053,
0.3204316199,
0.6447325349,
0.8575875759,
-0.6550680995,
0.4488215148,
0.505204618,
0.5314061046,
-0.4856337011,
0.1020160764,
0.2162117213,
-0.7425044775,
-1.0563311577,
-0.6896691918,
-0.0796798766,
0.0765069425,
-0.557821393,
-0.0786482319,
0.0756469741,
-0.1379325688,
-0.083379291,
-0.6672075987,
-0.7717209458,
-0.1374628097,
0.5923538208,
0.6968951225,
-0.8925753236,
0.997337997,
0.3298766911,
-0.3216135204,
-0.4323590994,
-0.0987371057,
-0.0298908576,
-0.9031715393,
0.7755491138,
-0.2302172333,
-0.0084425332,
0.237401545,
-0.5199830532,
-1.23633039,
0.9231206179,
0.8344663978,
-0.7064743638,
-0.281565249,
0.4665097594,
0.3660196364,
-0.3376862705,
-0.1628576368,
0.5210829377,
0.610717535,
0.2853065431,
-1.0282034874,
0.2384875119,
-0.0858955905,
0.1424397379,
0.3665965796,
-0.3500548899,
0.7824594975,
-0.2043066025,
-0.2240511179,
0.2696680725,
0.5176754594,
0.1033330634,
0.1287249774,
0.2382346541,
0.6910145879,
0.5293819904,
-0.2896745503,
1.1371186972,
-0.1239683628,
0.2016184032,
1.1617116928,
-0.128102988,
0.905825913,
0.5184176564,
-0.0951190814,
0.1925678402,
0.4288851917,
-0.0456343517,
0.5488623381,
0.3280379474,
-0.0766884759,
-0.6124607921,
-0.1275239736,
-0.3416060507,
0.4574101567,
0.4116322994,
-0.5433302522,
-0.3463508785,
0.2793290913,
0.080081068,
0.0874860734,
-0.0306997579,
0.6099573374,
0.2072223127,
-0.7923832536,
0.8089200258,
0.1192653924,
0.6413097978,
-0.5002889633,
0.022411108,
-0.4770613909,
0.0153711997,
-0.0625537783,
-0.6325860023,
0.0234539621,
-0.1303681135,
0.1097657159,
-0.7882435322,
0.3761069477,
-0.7904199362,
-0.5574792624,
0.2899987102,
0.8415133357,
0.0966622308,
-0.0018902073,
-0.3122323453,
0.046936892,
0.1393222213,
-0.0351856872,
0.2825772464,
0.2819294631,
0.0660385862,
0.7549600601,
0.682729125,
0.4226400256,
0.3350692391,
0.2004632056,
0.5718178153,
-0.5398445725,
-0.3016154766,
-0.7780957222,
0.3513700962,
-0.0514974222,
-0.3154464066,
0.6836860776,
0.5275259018,
0.7853611112,
-0.0316733643,
0.7683243155,
0.0893719271,
0.4919495881,
-0.6158434153,
0.4529772699,
-0.4251212478,
-0.0292315371,
-0.1907440275,
-0.9456781745,
-0.3336523771,
0.4337000549,
-0.1523277462,
-0.2074087262,
0.6515493393,
0.5096861124,
-0.0466153286,
-0.1736207902,
0.4553448856,
0.2476756573,
0.4423933029,
0.7526641488,
0.8571922779,
-0.3854424655,
0.5843436122,
-0.0035490452,
-0.0143168187,
-0.2696328163,
-0.7060943842,
-0.5946912766,
-0.6332519054,
-0.3668210804,
-0.3276476562,
-0.0015175932,
0.950079143,
0.73001647,
-0.7551611066,
-0.2170655876,
0.0504776426,
-0.0841925368,
-0.3521201015,
-0.1230703369,
0.0669410899,
-0.4529304504,
-0.6921419501,
0.8347919583,
0.0921810046,
0.2197609097,
-0.3077682555,
-0.2022859305,
-0.155273363,
-0.2694733441,
0.8872463107,
0.0725653917,
-0.8434708118,
-0.0473482758,
0.0795522034,
-0.21220994,
0.089432545,
0.7119944692,
-0.5016925931,
0.4266831577,
0.6654571295,
0.8861232996,
0.8701865673,
-0.1418842077,
0.671251893,
-0.3276528716,
0.1575541943,
0.223941505,
0.3217625916,
0.6059955359,
-0.0916554704,
0.4959742427,
0.0577349439,
-0.2673391998,
-0.6943587065,
0.3293677568,
-0.6975342631,
-0.3182142973,
1.4312955141,
0.0523954332,
-0.0592655316,
0.0499840938,
0.1817364097,
0.4067226946,
-0.2743001282,
0.4126752913,
0.5143939853,
0.3622779548,
-0.3204283714,
-1.071377635,
0.4026072621,
0.556020081,
-0.7342251539,
0.0579254404,
0.4549259841,
0.2601457834,
0.2053415179,
0.2978720069,
-0.105784826,
0.0066967746,
-0.1418173164,
0.3279437423,
-0.0159028415,
-0.2291012257,
-0.1091983095,
0.3370760679,
0.2596338391,
-0.1436689645
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07950v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07950v1
|
Sentinels of the Stream: Unleashing Large Language Models for Dynamic Packet Classification in Software Defined Networks -- Position Paper
| 2024-02-10T04:47:58 | 2024-02-10T04:47:58 |
Shariq Murtuza
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL
|
With the release of OpenAI's ChatGPT, the field of large language models
(LLM) saw an increase of academic interest in GPT based chat assistants. In the
next few months multiple accesible large language models were released that
included Meta's LLama models and Mistral AI's Mistral and Mixtral MoE models.
These models are available openly for a wide array of purposes with a wide
spectrum of licenses. These LLMs have found their use in a different number of
fields like code development, SQL generation etc. In this work we propose our
plan to explore the applicability of large language model in the domain of
network security. We plan to create Sentinel, a LLM, to analyse network packet
contents and pass a judgment on it's threat level. This work is a preliminary
report that will lay our plan for our future endeavors.
|
[
-0.4472366869,
-0.8024017215,
0.3084662855,
-0.0599363036,
-0.2439997792,
0.1604963541,
0.2617117465,
-0.6647350788,
0.4428227842,
0.7970721722,
-0.3170498013,
-0.1664159745,
-0.9854186773,
-0.1493559927,
-1.0201407671,
0.8420746922,
0.1007219777,
-0.1927285343,
0.4615977407,
0.1041909233,
-0.3841347098,
-0.6827187538,
-0.947476685,
-0.1466208994,
0.5057682991,
-0.1410154104,
0.6427345872,
0.3638797104,
0.8547585607,
0.4175040424,
-0.5358566046,
-0.1006242931,
-0.372828573,
0.3713981807,
-0.3356116116,
-0.3263423443,
-0.4616219103,
0.0015464831,
0.7793022394,
0.3716444075,
-0.1325784773,
0.0937826037,
-0.1391121447,
0.6168859005,
-0.5008020401,
0.288672775,
-0.937846005,
0.1076547801,
-0.4684117734,
-0.0339504853,
-0.5733558536,
0.1515723467,
0.3188675642,
-0.0756629184,
-0.1256968975,
-0.1647532582,
0.578909874,
0.3300802112,
-0.5430981517,
-0.2897620797,
-0.9790583849,
0.4415715933,
-0.6327297688,
0.1358043849,
-0.0431171618,
0.7857496142,
-0.4023705423,
-1.1340851784,
-0.4709098041,
-0.0841749981,
0.4164277613,
0.0941970572,
-0.4771454632,
0.207157746,
-0.0319485068,
0.4228532016,
-0.2443679869,
0.4581509829,
-0.5926716328,
0.0487155132,
0.8511907458,
0.3415293097,
0.0147046968,
0.2586714625,
-0.3317601681,
0.1991688907,
-0.7123034596,
-0.1765358746,
0.4105937481,
0.3949329853,
-0.0007412308,
0.4990125299,
-0.322977066,
0.9676545858,
-0.4216782749,
0.0521683209,
0.0814319849,
-0.089356482,
-0.4395325482,
-0.0661933497,
0.7169331312,
-0.046440322,
-0.1363709122,
0.1030198485,
-0.3706349432,
0.1382680535,
0.5841488242,
-0.6499184966,
-0.3411527574,
0.2682898343,
-0.5659759641,
-0.7897362709,
0.2005630881,
-0.8326248527,
-0.8108522296,
-0.0244365167,
0.1988560855,
-0.0023815108,
-0.6466685534,
0.2623991072,
-0.0200045202,
0.3271126747,
0.3919793069,
-0.4353942871,
0.143664971,
0.9262898564,
0.9054376483,
-0.0750932917,
-0.130563587,
-0.6211687922,
-0.0677303225,
-0.1382362545,
0.5525398254,
-0.4318006933,
-0.31543383,
0.3402578235,
-0.124586761,
0.0221596193,
-0.2152186632,
0.5476682782,
-0.9423808455,
-0.1740833968,
0.2383874655,
-0.6531991959,
-0.1933264285,
0.1670650989,
-0.6338503957,
0.4269552529,
0.0532105751,
-0.7351823449,
-0.1125539914,
-0.8495647907,
0.0025778331,
0.5035284162,
-0.0827303603,
-0.2017928362,
0.0649522841,
-0.1154006198,
0.7616174817,
-0.2681826651,
0.2451924533,
-0.340269655,
-0.108129479,
0.4508892596,
-0.5696408749,
0.8809850216,
0.7826509476,
-0.0380189382,
0.1601549238,
-0.4427987039,
-0.1829483509,
0.0836746022,
-0.2817467451,
0.023280777,
0.4761194587,
-0.1306352764,
0.1156855747,
-0.0375875942,
-0.7943248153,
-0.0034845336,
-0.1381192356,
0.8131375909,
0.8478818536,
-0.0063675852,
0.1321788579,
-0.0432456844,
0.6303427219,
0.1593802273,
0.522379458,
-0.3166566491,
-0.6569564939,
-0.6015905738,
-0.6495816112,
0.189103812,
0.5141428709,
-0.8440672755,
0.3283751905,
-0.3091114759,
-0.7333804965,
-0.4224794507,
0.0145018063,
0.175698787,
0.3929440677,
-0.1039256379,
-0.142403692,
-0.5862778425,
-0.6079414487,
0.1099299639,
-0.4182038903,
0.1794161648,
-0.1150998324,
0.3691942096,
-0.5656319261,
0.8181376457,
-0.7783433795,
-0.4645861387,
-0.3232484758,
-0.1354421228,
0.2678742111,
0.1549534649,
0.7552653551,
-0.7986032963,
-0.3714272082,
-0.0509812236,
-0.7191572189,
-0.070595853,
0.2322680503,
0.1704329699,
-0.0547825433,
0.768360436,
-0.3190757036,
0.5181894302,
0.8800385594,
-0.3520858288,
0.6308384538,
-0.057551384,
-0.4617620111,
-1.0120034218,
-0.30417943,
-0.0461222902,
-0.3785589337,
-0.8736149669,
0.8141830564,
-0.3633698225,
-0.6859822869,
-0.7582032681,
0.597781539,
-0.0774308071,
0.1519017667,
-0.5175617933,
-0.0493467413,
-0.3274449408,
-0.0372600779,
0.0436062701,
0.7328253984,
0.943131566,
-0.6964498758,
0.9415650964,
0.1055991054,
-0.2791391015,
0.4250412285,
-0.786220789,
-0.0760823041,
-0.0711536184,
0.4783614278,
-1.0873245001,
-0.1178215221,
0.2484023124,
-0.1975573599,
0.1531703323,
-0.41116485,
-0.4304502904,
-0.6371299028,
-0.0523285903,
0.1037732959,
0.6038409472,
-0.6020700336,
0.4790931344,
0.8607938886,
0.0713511407,
-0.311747402,
-0.6241677403,
0.3389663398,
-0.4114943147,
-0.7550007105,
0.0573166758,
0.1681806594,
-0.4225469828,
-0.2688281238,
0.1523609012,
-0.2476545721,
0.311945647,
0.4258823693,
0.1906186491,
-0.2942923903,
0.0452034697,
-0.4379748404,
-0.0644130483,
0.318706423,
-0.6666936874,
0.5146546364,
-0.4821573794,
-0.4375505745,
-0.4204382896,
0.2673153877,
0.4392717779,
-0.4887720644,
0.8783726692,
0.6119810939,
0.0081117284,
-0.105091244,
-0.3816664517,
0.0763144642,
-0.5986770988,
0.3874623477,
-0.2460725754,
-1.1126109362,
0.7001864314,
-0.2675119936,
0.09825138,
0.3894180954,
0.2852401733,
-0.1360445619,
0.582406044,
0.6415819526,
-0.3646918535,
0.7931759357,
-0.4350756705,
0.3511425853,
-0.8749544024,
0.1908192784,
-0.4951426089,
-0.1550799906,
-0.7078151107,
-0.1675523072,
0.4752649069,
-0.1860566437,
-0.1285422891,
0.1748797297,
-0.4876830876,
0.3267420828,
0.0900144279,
-0.0265904088,
0.0375758074,
-0.064529635,
0.0128473649,
0.4656685591,
-0.4897492826,
-0.5274707675,
1.1862897873,
0.9197006822,
0.6123404503,
0.4620786905,
0.6560906768,
0.5701965094,
0.274168551,
-0.6553452611,
0.7212992907,
-0.3034178019,
-0.7690861821,
-0.5694339275,
-0.3281572461,
-1.1835174561,
0.426982969,
0.0133334454,
-0.9708884954,
-0.1595674753,
-0.018030718,
-0.1010283455,
0.6458932757,
-0.5040165186,
0.4010859132,
0.0465454459,
0.1618474275,
-0.0190317035,
-0.4368758202,
0.6519461274,
-0.3335647583,
0.0713683665,
-0.1478251666,
-0.0057313163,
0.6189781427,
-0.7250741124,
0.9809000492,
-0.3139611781,
-0.3650044799,
0.6856040359,
0.1021573693,
0.6351647377,
0.1860361695,
-0.1967487335,
0.3231041431,
-0.0264820717,
-0.2778847814,
-0.3757933676,
0.6432295442,
-0.7636058927,
-0.7178419232,
-0.6526421905,
-0.181817323,
0.2074651569,
0.2448836267,
0.0440799706,
0.3949410915,
-0.1084042937,
0.1436323971,
1.0114160776,
-0.028499566,
0.6610124111,
0.591555953,
-0.6401692033,
-0.2250332236,
0.7266182303,
-0.0459054224,
0.2666407526,
0.4139621258,
0.0859264582,
-0.1260139942,
-0.9785602093,
-0.0637910515,
0.0665638596,
-0.6748592257,
-0.2533878386,
-0.4953616261,
-0.9257403612,
-0.3522339761,
0.022802325,
-0.4155169427,
-0.201614961,
-0.2546581626,
-0.114459306,
0.4528300464,
0.867207706,
0.2230728865,
1.1070863008,
-0.7508333921,
-0.1398745477,
0.2412105948,
0.3751113117,
0.0883289054,
-0.6778235435,
0.0244527776,
-0.0893303901,
-0.6718907952,
-0.8633904457,
0.6420891881,
0.1090914384,
0.6327136159,
0.8372823596,
0.021430824,
0.2420336157,
-0.3052494824,
0.956130445,
0.2588574588,
-0.8293202519,
0.4816934168,
-0.5785160661,
0.1148136109,
0.0907255411,
0.13662678,
-0.604147315,
-0.4114449322,
-0.5086026788,
-0.651684463,
0.3445600569,
0.1328879297,
0.414406836,
-0.0478862301,
0.2910528481,
-0.20307073,
0.148164168,
-0.4785819948,
-0.0250386912,
-0.1013299599,
0.185719654,
-0.2789577544,
-0.3184946775,
0.0256192628,
-0.069328405,
0.4772883058,
-0.0596019812,
0.6087936759,
-0.1553104073,
0.2964876294,
0.2815489173,
0.1383827925,
0.6806303859,
0.6340432167,
-0.0100286314,
0.2159691751,
0.1504588574,
-0.7678971887,
0.1627885848,
-0.1699153632,
-0.3351498544,
0.1858011186,
0.3944050968,
0.8265910149,
-0.2326329947,
-0.52929461,
0.5941671729,
-0.0212805476,
-0.1377642155,
-0.9021618366,
0.3184402287,
0.0079513136,
0.3568646908,
0.2695980072,
-0.2192685008,
-0.0701992512,
-0.5530822873,
0.0281477775,
0.6492097378,
-0.4307342172,
-0.2342683524,
0.5530064702,
0.3681723177,
-0.3827993274,
0.8501609564,
-0.2288020402,
-0.5361964107,
0.3204600811,
0.3708917201,
1.0088787079,
-0.4859755337,
0.2845391631,
-0.1390722543,
0.3479164243,
0.0458958372,
0.3911341131,
0.3766704202,
-0.7410932183,
-0.3160932064,
-0.7269150019,
-0.0917390287,
0.5551409721,
-0.2930220068,
0.3483968377,
-0.6878721118,
-0.4745670259,
0.3289586306,
-0.0847823471,
-0.54052037,
-0.1207329258,
0.2262472808,
1.373041749,
-0.988765955,
1.0261795521,
0.5874980092,
-0.321307689,
-0.4555008709,
-0.2527656555,
0.1678930223,
-0.6015607715,
0.947963953,
-0.2293878198,
0.0447164141,
-0.1440578401,
-0.5182261467,
-0.9989161491,
1.0736658573,
0.0458580106,
-0.3523607552,
-0.0176843479,
0.3028178811,
0.6357852817,
-0.5443485975,
0.2219769955,
0.0867924765,
0.2127026916,
0.3711342216,
-0.9198144078,
-0.3638913035,
-0.0857383534,
0.3721001446,
0.3275144994,
-0.7954463363,
1.0585297346,
0.1437782049,
0.1426079571,
-0.150842458,
0.8972102404,
-0.1009913161,
0.0735432059,
0.2926508486,
0.3849885166,
0.6678046584,
-0.0121035483,
0.9414585233,
0.139846921,
-0.0156229138,
0.9809157252,
-0.4912959933,
1.0360546112,
0.4663419127,
-0.2378675193,
0.1954980046,
0.4422651529,
-0.1646494418,
0.4537944496,
0.5222727656,
-0.4907023907,
0.2028783411,
-0.0119347284,
-0.2072153091,
0.76531744,
0.6656184196,
-0.4811778963,
-0.2428612411,
0.0478925705,
0.0275997184,
-0.1947126389,
-0.7141267657,
0.6866240501,
0.2953054011,
-0.24635984,
0.5206987262,
0.3623610139,
0.5938750505,
-0.7222505212,
0.3706273139,
-0.028654512,
0.4176974595,
-0.010542362,
-1.0833697319,
0.7708941698,
0.1648099571,
0.2319415659,
-0.0217231568,
0.663600862,
0.2302821279,
-0.3474493325,
0.2532909513,
0.0903677642,
0.4818091393,
-0.236034587,
-0.6101418734,
0.4618902504,
-0.2955931723,
0.0278042369,
0.521466136,
0.4011521339,
-0.0702399239,
1.0766974688,
0.5154454708,
0.4432111382,
0.4114963412,
-0.2953394651,
0.9424474835,
-0.1005237028,
-0.666131258,
-0.7551577687,
0.2157698274,
-0.147972241,
-0.2003950924,
0.5493920445,
0.3652764857,
0.7351168394,
-0.2109169513,
0.8705073595,
0.0805810094,
0.2866610587,
-0.4362924993,
0.8193821907,
-0.2095141262,
0.4336076677,
-0.2149106562,
-0.8793285489,
-0.0375771523,
0.1523227692,
-0.1257118732,
-0.3525604606,
0.4657315612,
0.529907763,
-0.0903680548,
0.2570037544,
0.3249004483,
0.0424964018,
0.8907649517,
0.3844892979,
0.8510311246,
-0.3166436553,
0.3395839036,
0.1191525757,
-0.4447302818,
-0.3919497132,
-1.1179065704,
-0.8509300351,
-0.7126547694,
-0.4845167398,
-0.3879646957,
0.1593256891,
0.515889585,
0.5799615383,
-0.7484648228,
-0.3105382919,
-0.0902419537,
-0.0249108337,
-0.1538118869,
-0.1217760965,
0.0979830548,
-0.3003538847,
-0.2637135983,
0.2324501425,
0.0634274259,
0.30673787,
-0.7817201614,
-0.0002982044,
-0.248733297,
0.2523981035,
0.7589771152,
0.350333631,
-0.7317532301,
-0.1171429455,
-0.388140887,
-0.0019374823,
-0.4875178933,
0.5796172023,
-0.4491288662,
0.1639123857,
0.7547129393,
0.7787345648,
0.2306121439,
-0.3780819774,
0.4623418748,
-0.6217499375,
0.3734449148,
0.0286355857,
0.4467228949,
-0.0473800302,
-0.3790598512,
0.609654963,
0.0228087548,
-0.6790323257,
-1.0011429787,
0.6970511675,
-0.8559972644,
-0.2665658593,
1.1292119026,
-0.5180948377,
-0.1997884065,
-0.0507654771,
-0.0486512296,
0.1014721245,
-0.0801904276,
0.7971546054,
0.619530797,
0.1119888872,
-0.2453866154,
-0.7041187882,
0.4543976784,
-0.3240679502,
-0.6530429721,
0.1799169034,
0.1065636426,
0.0796576887,
0.1997453868,
0.5583974123,
-0.2016463727,
-0.2808049917,
-0.0418653861,
-0.2598584294,
-0.2900129259,
-0.5249439478,
-0.5350227952,
0.0715917125,
0.1959524006,
-0.3735973239
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06853v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06853v2
|
History, Development, and Principles of Large Language Models-An Introductory Survey
| 2024-02-10T01:18:15 | 2024-06-12T02:28:12 |
Zhibo Chu, Shiwen Ni, Zichong Wang, Xi Feng, Min Yang, Wenbin Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language models serve as a cornerstone in natural language processing (NLP),
utilizing mathematical methods to generalize language laws and knowledge for
prediction and generation. Over extensive research spanning decades, language
modeling has progressed from initial statistical language models (SLMs) to the
contemporary landscape of large language models (LLMs). Notably, the swift
evolution of LLMs has reached the ability to process, understand, and generate
human-level text. Nevertheless, despite the significant advantages that LLMs
offer in improving both work and personal lives, the limited understanding
among general practitioners about the background and principles of these models
hampers their full potential. Notably, most LLMs reviews focus on specific
aspects and utilize specialized language, posing a challenge for practitioners
lacking relevant background knowledge. In light of this, this survey aims to
present a comprehensible overview of LLMs to assist a broader audience. It
strives to facilitate a comprehensive understanding by exploring the historical
background of language models and tracing their evolution over time. The survey
further investigates the factors influencing the development of LLMs,
emphasizing key contributions. Additionally, it concentrates on elucidating the
underlying principles of LLMs, equipping audiences with essential theoretical
knowledge. The survey also highlights the limitations of existing work and
points out promising future directions.
|
[
-0.4371976852,
-0.7536936998,
0.7435718179,
-0.1444531679,
-0.0350427926,
0.0084989537,
-0.4355853796,
-0.4050475359,
-0.0772499666,
0.8791466951,
-0.4069643915,
-0.4912943244,
-0.579052031,
0.043499209,
-0.5009157658,
0.9249162078,
0.1233381182,
0.1218254194,
-0.0494918562,
-0.0396742858,
-0.2343491912,
-0.6901094317,
-0.5560871959,
-0.430760622,
0.3175648153,
0.0836362988,
0.6222910285,
0.5317541957,
0.4396713376,
0.2624529004,
-0.6117053032,
-0.0049889558,
-0.5426167846,
0.2157739699,
-0.1027595624,
-0.4948660135,
-0.2287023664,
-0.1438405812,
0.9197834134,
1.2755839825,
-0.186502859,
0.1156357676,
0.2500400841,
0.8312163949,
-0.5235615969,
0.1588498354,
-0.5262499452,
0.0274284985,
-0.2823415995,
-0.2559922636,
-0.4248083234,
-0.3483808041,
0.3307735324,
-0.1809701174,
0.2581418455,
-0.0207437444,
0.2822414339,
-0.2893332541,
-0.6781077385,
-0.6085622907,
-1.0191483498,
0.9595683217,
-0.7709880471,
0.4160283506,
0.3066608012,
0.240435645,
-0.2228430063,
-0.663685441,
-0.2847186327,
-0.4324810207,
0.0397967435,
-0.381519407,
-0.0156366713,
0.0787584484,
0.2241497636,
0.4475737214,
-0.6222739816,
0.4566532373,
-0.3976665735,
-0.0923199877,
0.6382797956,
0.4990536273,
0.3558052778,
-0.0456113443,
-0.1876656115,
0.284911871,
-1.1170207262,
0.0010684497,
0.2039442062,
0.2046760917,
-0.1528530419,
0.5149029493,
-0.1204413921,
0.7763869166,
-0.3483960032,
-0.3731524646,
-0.0614546202,
-0.494510144,
-0.2617824376,
-0.3990473747,
0.7348566651,
0.1928099692,
0.3834570348,
-0.1038871631,
-0.1487598866,
-0.2514665723,
0.088264063,
-0.5590355992,
0.2537193596,
-0.0486538,
-0.4932385683,
-0.1548243016,
-0.1891678721,
-0.7109109163,
-0.4719037116,
-0.5084566474,
-0.1647375822,
-0.1145389602,
-0.3268421292,
0.1848475933,
0.1958140284,
0.428583771,
0.5716000199,
-1.0625574589,
0.6131083369,
0.9663527608,
0.7448896766,
-0.1414112151,
-0.1862960756,
0.1243785098,
0.1150107384,
-0.5018761158,
0.5838358402,
-0.3856378794,
-0.6273761392,
0.5529299974,
-0.0207883157,
0.2922413051,
-0.4604404569,
0.4451879263,
-0.6875523925,
0.2628808916,
-0.1248130947,
-0.7136766911,
-0.1820429116,
0.387301147,
-0.5415415764,
0.6544246674,
-0.0943000913,
-0.5954008698,
0.1057153568,
-0.5647836328,
-0.3207395673,
0.1900948286,
-0.2558934689,
-0.0649223626,
0.460521549,
0.0397014208,
0.5433979034,
-0.7854726911,
0.3998764157,
-0.2917483151,
-0.0545425117,
0.2001308054,
-0.3640492857,
0.8737689257,
0.3007929921,
-0.0328760035,
-0.0433690883,
-0.6110131145,
-0.1917305589,
0.2667648792,
-0.3322204053,
-0.2904949188,
0.2706454992,
-0.0617954955,
0.0213563815,
0.1737979054,
-0.1203840896,
0.2994109392,
-0.3692408204,
0.5552387238,
0.5487815142,
0.0764292106,
0.6278117299,
-0.2132618278,
0.7163882256,
-0.3866313994,
0.0533655882,
-0.5872553587,
-0.3642867506,
-0.5864953995,
0.217275545,
0.1111394614,
0.2904922068,
-0.2176677734,
0.2300723642,
-0.2936163843,
-0.3892581463,
-0.1042319238,
0.5008596778,
0.1291754097,
0.1413840652,
-0.012198939,
-0.0861188546,
-0.6428576708,
-0.9317485094,
-0.0711391419,
-0.2786947191,
0.0059606223,
0.2864073515,
0.4270297885,
-0.2055554092,
0.8866265416,
-0.5133042336,
0.0071538356,
-0.6077792645,
-0.1545933336,
0.2691446245,
0.2165904045,
0.6476563215,
-0.5741509795,
-0.2716840804,
-0.0708895549,
-0.597163856,
-0.1401441395,
0.202793017,
0.0945805013,
0.1861941516,
0.5388845205,
-0.6127778888,
0.1874857694,
0.790207386,
-0.134113431,
0.6949174404,
-0.0895369425,
-0.1412295699,
-1.1457805634,
0.0696388334,
0.2638739944,
-0.1588734388,
-0.8573286533,
0.2350229174,
-0.131937325,
-0.1392056495,
-0.3260545135,
0.694742322,
-0.6948978901,
-0.0283486359,
-0.4601017833,
0.1797878146,
-0.2410139441,
0.0369585492,
0.1897508651,
0.3217944801,
0.5372516513,
-0.8001731634,
0.2593995035,
0.0889935866,
-0.4171149731,
0.3144823611,
-0.5982055664,
0.090169549,
-0.2161060125,
0.1585126668,
-0.9861539602,
-0.1045037434,
-0.0601962171,
-0.2692245245,
0.5085697174,
-0.30299142,
-0.5031363964,
-0.3591713011,
-0.0575389788,
0.2539688647,
0.7816034555,
-0.1830616146,
0.3241367042,
0.6707425117,
-0.6089553833,
-0.438362658,
-0.6155120134,
0.2561041415,
-0.1741755158,
-0.6174790263,
-0.0344901234,
-0.0995498598,
-0.8243988156,
-0.4251612425,
0.0788316727,
-0.1349604428,
0.1360244304,
-0.0787465796,
0.1891579479,
-0.4183966815,
0.3184788823,
-0.2611845732,
-0.0188861229,
0.3476092517,
-0.1928396821,
0.7412291765,
-0.0066315248,
-0.3509332836,
-0.2147351205,
0.2332700938,
0.5656535029,
-0.0122948997,
0.6577670574,
0.1036218107,
-0.3720322251,
-0.3672442734,
-0.7587052584,
-0.1726533175,
-0.4038978517,
0.5271161199,
-0.0174933933,
-1.1832633018,
0.4365715981,
-0.1851281673,
0.2129159123,
0.5034683943,
0.7734797597,
0.0385079607,
0.7507489324,
0.9303920269,
-0.2916052341,
0.4343591034,
-0.0862906277,
0.0285852235,
-0.8539263606,
-0.1622302085,
-0.7905509472,
-0.0177826658,
-0.6672895551,
-0.3248125911,
0.2301008999,
0.1008135453,
-0.1384973973,
-0.0040722541,
-0.1213735938,
0.2507024407,
0.0956364274,
-0.2416806072,
0.4180204272,
0.0145597998,
0.0264611188,
-0.1642118096,
-0.429595381,
-0.9254189134,
1.2341866493,
0.6672100425,
1.1020355225,
0.3296636343,
0.5125649571,
0.2600198686,
0.2637721002,
-0.6407524347,
0.6526882648,
-0.0261970218,
-0.7680661678,
-0.3517583311,
-0.2868633568,
-0.9371014833,
0.2643762827,
0.0364239328,
-0.7759311795,
-0.0788619295,
0.2260747701,
-0.0719436482,
0.3102979362,
-0.4013258815,
0.4744966328,
-0.2751396596,
-0.2995436788,
-0.2626667917,
-0.6587792635,
0.7258773446,
-0.1610266268,
0.6177419424,
-0.1256732643,
-0.1844234467,
0.6149639487,
-0.2708765268,
1.0278999805,
0.0521525219,
-0.4709407687,
0.5077899098,
0.1922277063,
0.4355906248,
0.0020376144,
0.0138707701,
-0.0373624377,
-0.1579796672,
-0.0950881466,
-0.3995857537,
0.678319037,
-0.4627592266,
-0.7076630592,
-0.2941949368,
-0.5932101011,
-0.3229607046,
0.1879470795,
-0.1419289261,
0.396649003,
-0.4636856914,
0.4903110564,
0.7712857127,
-0.1977154166,
0.5214993954,
0.7093938589,
-0.7340373993,
-0.2211772501,
0.4094599485,
-0.0032939792,
0.4077585936,
0.4732205868,
0.3759400249,
-0.3903675675,
-0.9234717488,
-0.0036832248,
0.4293373525,
-0.7601276636,
0.2502614558,
-0.6505014896,
-0.1465512365,
-0.6061271429,
-0.0000188329,
-0.2166181952,
-0.2372088581,
-0.4013164043,
0.111812681,
0.1009359956,
1.2220283747,
0.1164050922,
0.3688238859,
-0.6875138283,
0.230862096,
0.2456057519,
0.2098185569,
0.0762099847,
-0.6699949503,
-0.1373991966,
0.0677784234,
-0.237106964,
-0.9036082625,
0.3651442826,
0.0346999578,
0.8355671167,
0.437479645,
-0.2722511888,
0.3852200806,
-0.6211480498,
0.9874913692,
0.1888492703,
-0.7394205928,
0.3512104154,
-0.3887856603,
0.1585164219,
0.1428475082,
0.5553869605,
-0.7168412805,
-0.1104984581,
-0.3795591891,
-0.7460354567,
0.529266715,
-0.0133169107,
0.2942216396,
0.1645983011,
0.4067519009,
0.0762774274,
0.2845242023,
-0.8153969049,
-0.1610976905,
0.3650783896,
-0.0581948347,
-0.4277499914,
-0.5325812697,
0.0888865814,
-0.0787264481,
0.5695383549,
-0.0404502936,
-0.0386074483,
-0.1844935417,
-0.3345787823,
-0.0203558262,
0.6870257854,
0.915863812,
1.0841223001,
0.051168818,
0.0909479633,
0.2386291772,
-0.407718569,
0.1631614268,
-0.1169637293,
-0.3620616794,
-0.0396963358,
0.4810628891,
0.7824469805,
0.3205584884,
-0.7223611474,
0.2713165879,
0.1802192777,
-0.1152083054,
-0.4328284562,
-0.1029813737,
0.4008842111,
0.12076208,
0.5569013953,
-0.4761649966,
-0.1282089651,
-0.7491607666,
-0.0727792829,
0.6460569501,
-0.1360717714,
-0.3762106895,
0.3554879725,
0.0958188549,
-0.4945901036,
0.3299659789,
0.0946284831,
-0.2841151357,
0.412527889,
0.6947886348,
0.8436461091,
-0.1689703912,
0.051586803,
0.2034117132,
0.425896287,
-0.240724951,
0.070649229,
0.0405467898,
-0.6914926767,
-0.4438015521,
-0.9208126664,
-0.5226305127,
0.4126075506,
-0.5896610618,
0.3380495012,
-0.4964877963,
-0.2249955684,
-0.1027791128,
-0.1038952246,
-0.7052678466,
0.1137114242,
0.4233026803,
0.898090899,
-0.6803615689,
0.517285347,
0.6419634819,
-0.2640535235,
-0.2334663123,
-0.1770989597,
0.2202750146,
-0.8620915413,
0.7418821454,
-0.2492729127,
0.0096314857,
0.0414906219,
-0.7516685724,
-0.8413978815,
0.7069657445,
0.1121425256,
-0.8018102646,
-0.4565884173,
0.2589429021,
0.7556428909,
-0.4931458533,
0.0887316316,
0.5228297114,
0.2276407033,
0.0080792485,
-0.8219684958,
-0.2530113459,
0.0322630741,
0.3558570445,
0.2714373171,
-0.3617581725,
0.8087291718,
-0.2267462164,
-0.1559942365,
0.318035543,
0.4844452143,
0.3109242618,
0.0562638715,
0.1352306306,
0.3277638853,
0.347791791,
-0.096382767,
1.014180541,
-0.4188399017,
0.3203063607,
0.9849151373,
-0.4384207726,
0.8144652843,
0.4524293542,
-0.5857089162,
0.3466339707,
0.3547927737,
0.0806213915,
0.0003661236,
0.4827765226,
-0.3154317141,
-0.0858884156,
-0.0810501128,
-0.4805901051,
0.3836784363,
0.5727012753,
-0.7757555842,
-0.4053938091,
-0.2144631296,
-0.0240594223,
0.0566042997,
-0.5555837154,
0.8976634741,
0.2174728513,
-0.4949732125,
0.1950158626,
0.0140343253,
0.6323015094,
-0.979157865,
0.1108639464,
-0.1234401688,
0.09508764,
0.042169258,
-0.9942609072,
0.1921862066,
0.1091725975,
-0.2270130962,
-0.3013845682,
0.6562767625,
-0.343465507,
-0.5182034969,
0.0767451003,
0.7142214179,
0.224502489,
0.2863672972,
-0.369851321,
0.3657989502,
-0.134251669,
-0.3623749912,
0.371170491,
0.2770151496,
0.0394055918,
0.7909198403,
0.5245293379,
0.2434051335,
0.2166614532,
0.0944437757,
0.5820183158,
-1.0522027016,
-0.3697632253,
-1.0304996967,
0.4178401232,
0.1832242757,
-0.2846523225,
0.7800864577,
0.4981416166,
0.7353087068,
-0.0587777235,
1.0017141104,
0.180349797,
0.6857433915,
-0.6392735839,
0.6753554344,
-0.4074597955,
0.2662866414,
-0.3173499405,
-1.0206623077,
-0.3547919989,
0.3543914258,
-0.2842498422,
0.2928777635,
0.5262958407,
0.4423257411,
0.3603717983,
-0.0354364552,
0.4116200209,
0.2315062135,
0.4809986055,
0.2214354128,
0.9755403399,
-0.0070981951,
0.3736763895,
-0.0540721267,
0.003614916,
-0.3006165326,
-0.9436110258,
-0.8174622059,
-0.4312979281,
-0.2306998819,
-0.244066909,
-0.0346050821,
0.8731505275,
0.4932293594,
-0.7503871322,
-0.6606826782,
-0.1302069724,
0.0510872193,
0.2587282956,
-0.1897544414,
0.1494874358,
-0.4293657839,
-0.7512881756,
0.3215414286,
0.2784068286,
0.3238549232,
-0.7611988783,
-0.2455012053,
-0.1630851179,
0.0877271518,
0.8690447211,
0.5837272406,
-0.9538835883,
0.1679456979,
-0.1031960025,
-0.1677633971,
-0.0309817344,
1.0658341646,
-0.3776370883,
0.3228217661,
0.6006756425,
0.569339931,
0.2228916138,
-0.359950006,
0.6371204853,
-0.4696726799,
0.0730838478,
0.3286918402,
0.6888374686,
0.4521268606,
0.1044939235,
0.4294035137,
0.3615433872,
-0.6137590408,
-1.0389946699,
0.426429987,
-0.688739717,
-0.200088799,
1.2878075838,
0.2115687877,
-0.1198434681,
-0.1469938159,
-0.1446064264,
-0.0805427507,
-0.0130428392,
0.4573224783,
0.8374880552,
0.0016073185,
-0.4422396123,
-0.632101953,
0.4009737968,
0.1125465259,
-0.8842285872,
0.0803258792,
0.6775819659,
0.5576349497,
0.0275380723,
0.67529881,
-0.2094224393,
-0.0910545737,
-0.2605991066,
0.1390761286,
0.2938439846,
-0.2352828681,
-0.5754290223,
0.5272177458,
0.4787832499,
0.3911404014
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06852v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06852v2
|
ChemLLM: A Chemical Large Language Model
| 2024-02-10T01:11:59 | 2024-04-25T14:34:28 |
Di Zhang, Wei Liu, Qian Tan, Jingdan Chen, Hang Yan, Yuliang Yan, Jiatong Li, Weiran Huang, Xiangyu Yue, Wanli Ouyang, Dongzhan Zhou, Shufei Zhang, Mao Su, Han-Sen Zhong, Yuqiang Li
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have made impressive progress in chemistry
applications. However, the community lacks an LLM specifically designed for
chemistry. The main challenges are two-fold: firstly, most chemical data and
scientific knowledge are stored in structured databases, which limits the
model's ability to sustain coherent dialogue when used directly. Secondly,
there is an absence of objective and fair benchmark that encompass most
chemistry tasks. Here, we introduce ChemLLM, a comprehensive framework that
features the first LLM dedicated to chemistry. It also includes ChemData, a
dataset specifically designed for instruction tuning, and ChemBench, a robust
benchmark covering nine essential chemistry tasks. ChemLLM is adept at
performing various tasks across chemical disciplines with fluid dialogue
interaction. Notably, ChemLLM achieves results comparable to GPT-4 on the core
chemical tasks and demonstrates competitive performance with LLMs of similar
size in general scenarios. ChemLLM paves a new path for exploration in chemical
studies, and our method of incorporating structured chemical knowledge into
dialogue systems sets a new standard for developing LLMs in various scientific
fields. Codes, Datasets, and Model weights are publicly accessible at
https://hf.co/AI4Chem
|
[
-0.0740277842,
-0.5138068199,
0.9699430466,
0.314609766,
0.0025608586,
0.5031883121,
-0.2991195023,
-0.2207759917,
-0.2632130682,
0.526745677,
-0.5764600635,
-0.9347266555,
-0.4392454922,
0.0319089517,
-0.4276442826,
0.8456255198,
-0.0412163585,
0.3288155496,
-0.4489434659,
0.2077640146,
-0.0569346547,
-0.5829943419,
-0.6607282162,
-0.5588595271,
0.6956637502,
0.143102631,
0.4840100706,
0.3504354358,
0.4726437628,
0.3199843764,
-0.1697192788,
0.1946240664,
-0.616048038,
0.3188696206,
-0.3857714236,
-0.4054684639,
-0.5349231958,
0.148245424,
0.6280232072,
0.9547497034,
-0.1123969406,
-0.2221725285,
-0.0856494531,
0.4771744013,
-0.5393075347,
0.461748898,
-0.5134879947,
0.0503835455,
-0.13749367,
0.1988164037,
-0.3105570674,
-0.0663444921,
0.1279439628,
-0.5954323411,
-0.0922692567,
0.2598713934,
0.4229350388,
0.1879656762,
-0.6619112492,
-0.3161664903,
-0.5520322323,
1.0731861591,
-0.6028071642,
0.5398751497,
0.1739121526,
0.420394659,
-0.5530138612,
-1.0168894529,
-0.4309561551,
-0.4788327217,
0.0690191984,
-0.0112910951,
0.1389138252,
0.2209177315,
0.0756337717,
0.3110923767,
-0.5027290583,
-0.1363299936,
-0.1968677342,
-0.5225551128,
0.4957936704,
0.7200230956,
0.0826975033,
0.3273696899,
-0.6677775979,
0.1803060919,
-0.5500661135,
-0.3115308285,
-0.0112471944,
0.4077826738,
-0.1287945956,
0.5245990753,
-0.3083527088,
0.3276898563,
-0.3051348627,
0.0270912685,
-0.0766247809,
-0.430709362,
-0.1682883501,
0.223674044,
0.8613946438,
0.027194472,
0.0180997457,
0.0839625075,
-0.2748839855,
0.0472186618,
-0.0664926246,
-0.8719572425,
-0.5852056146,
0.3423086703,
-0.0062478273,
-0.1118794605,
-0.2273464501,
-0.6492112875,
-0.689492166,
-0.4351146221,
0.2223496437,
-0.1798747033,
0.0080598984,
-0.0343249626,
-0.0181055851,
0.0746270865,
0.6702118516,
-0.7192237377,
0.6710889935,
0.9931123853,
0.9439265728,
-0.4383421242,
-0.2079438418,
-0.4679198861,
0.1763689816,
-0.3887242377,
0.5911578536,
-0.7296173573,
-0.3993704617,
-0.1409332752,
-0.085377939,
0.3462720811,
-0.6977303624,
0.3373889327,
-0.3656460047,
0.2889039516,
-0.3821562827,
-0.7125364542,
0.2108576447,
0.1503082514,
-0.5904800296,
0.9984120131,
0.2555878162,
-0.3048912883,
0.132463783,
-0.6658089161,
-0.2415635884,
0.0969538167,
-0.1182924435,
-0.1425849944,
-0.0967695415,
-0.2285271138,
0.2502273619,
-0.8066029549,
0.2784690857,
-0.4017502964,
-0.1850231588,
0.4650337398,
-0.1380679905,
0.629650116,
0.5193618536,
0.0474089757,
0.2822691798,
-0.6274613738,
0.1520594209,
-0.2282486856,
-0.6258095503,
-0.0541079156,
-0.0726444647,
0.3911681175,
0.4678714871,
0.5938616991,
-0.5683193803,
0.0493890084,
-0.1153136343,
0.5118249059,
0.7655418515,
-0.1322572827,
0.3615503907,
-0.0269474592,
0.2325273156,
0.0273898561,
0.1161560416,
-0.1342323124,
-0.1813538671,
-0.6858514547,
-0.5623787642,
0.0863662213,
0.2257913053,
-0.3728032112,
0.2430320233,
-0.0842092559,
-0.5755072832,
-0.3051913381,
0.717849791,
0.3438084126,
0.3202203512,
0.3103911281,
-0.0931772515,
-0.4528656006,
-0.9418790936,
-0.3303012848,
-0.0693027675,
-0.2182897478,
0.1715411246,
0.4147671461,
-0.3609772325,
0.8526157141,
-0.5378151536,
-0.1899114102,
-0.2626316547,
0.1199150309,
0.2601576746,
0.2404262871,
0.0657033399,
-0.5047016144,
-0.6517666578,
0.1328424215,
-0.7317441106,
-0.5609868765,
0.2591198385,
-0.5126554966,
0.2705436051,
0.6605232358,
-0.717898488,
-0.2242506146,
0.6250835657,
-0.3853966594,
0.3841435909,
0.0681792647,
-0.1564946026,
-0.7999970913,
0.2652020454,
-0.1457974464,
-0.3023001552,
-0.8136768341,
-0.0532853082,
0.0277890619,
-0.314563036,
-0.6827173829,
0.8675519824,
-0.3729641736,
0.0908933058,
-0.3656644225,
0.070647493,
0.1752050519,
0.4614971876,
0.2311472446,
0.3590367734,
0.485494107,
-0.4171558917,
0.5663307905,
0.0359441973,
-0.3833891451,
0.55252707,
-0.5949992537,
0.1015983671,
0.2313487977,
0.4215766788,
-0.9031323195,
-0.3122912943,
0.0109827099,
0.1776380241,
0.3687113225,
0.2581655085,
-0.3971865475,
-0.0570065081,
-0.112242274,
0.3188514113,
0.4908421636,
-0.3667613268,
0.7199226022,
0.2095439881,
-0.2673738897,
-0.3474214673,
-0.1909443289,
0.1292146444,
-0.0601662621,
-0.3693468273,
-0.0088476613,
-0.2761301398,
-0.3687346578,
-0.1758439988,
-0.5130507946,
-0.2288157493,
-0.1149683446,
0.1671402901,
0.2732526362,
-0.0973026007,
0.2203941643,
-0.1723859608,
-0.0893930867,
0.3826438487,
-0.1743359268,
0.7469844818,
-0.0462255962,
-0.1674946398,
-0.1608016491,
0.3374585211,
0.926761806,
-0.0273685083,
0.5767596364,
0.3505130112,
-0.1425635964,
-0.5381980538,
-0.2478115112,
-0.0751646385,
-0.5314726233,
0.5419805646,
-0.2002007961,
-0.8851107955,
0.3927999139,
-0.3831306398,
-0.0231506601,
0.2562822402,
0.7683157325,
-0.1338458061,
0.7789341211,
0.3000488281,
-0.060028553,
0.1857903004,
0.2663849294,
0.2676520348,
-0.6446154714,
-0.5872436762,
-0.377514869,
-0.151704967,
-0.0510196388,
-0.540361762,
0.5613649487,
-0.1490456015,
-0.6970249414,
0.0448846556,
-0.0992524177,
0.4888371825,
0.3751935363,
-0.0099568861,
0.4674877226,
-0.0928921178,
-0.3039863408,
0.0049100285,
-0.6183205843,
-0.4110868573,
0.9533591866,
0.3064811826,
1.3448451757,
0.0992666259,
0.447063297,
0.2410499603,
0.2218534052,
-0.7367203236,
0.818882525,
0.1751347333,
-0.9022570848,
-0.2903648019,
-0.568618834,
-0.6758440137,
0.1872521192,
-0.0347492099,
-0.3162534535,
-0.2745160162,
0.0129655097,
0.0559202917,
-0.062315464,
-0.3787696958,
0.7588612437,
-0.4503348768,
-0.8089036942,
-0.1559143662,
-0.7496399879,
0.528375864,
-0.4600010514,
0.1357864588,
-0.608531177,
-0.3786379397,
0.2908042371,
-0.787435472,
0.7025755644,
0.0730779767,
-0.5647104383,
0.2275952697,
0.3040487468,
0.3806765676,
-0.3442125022,
-0.0128276777,
0.2642478943,
0.1552492082,
-0.4385977685,
-0.7657428384,
1.1076934338,
-0.4766286612,
-0.6401085258,
-0.5886418223,
-0.7534348369,
-0.2741934061,
0.2078128308,
-0.1335006803,
0.1063665375,
-0.2574878931,
0.0412931032,
0.5260593891,
-0.368719101,
0.1606055349,
0.668243885,
-0.4344914854,
-0.1874046773,
0.8681534529,
-0.2839268446,
0.5589502454,
0.55788517,
0.1856904328,
-0.5137320161,
-0.1195082217,
0.2173819095,
0.0832903236,
-1.1030963659,
-0.1135654896,
-0.615060389,
-0.3366979361,
-0.2568937838,
-0.0456971787,
-0.4189302623,
-0.2916510403,
-0.0113649862,
0.1890105605,
0.3238821328,
0.8224699497,
0.1100516319,
-0.113843061,
-0.6647771597,
0.2048635036,
0.3574849665,
0.5719889998,
-0.2028817236,
-0.0978600532,
-0.3027665615,
-0.1788085103,
-0.1187585741,
-0.5192953348,
0.2093741596,
0.3343304396,
0.5813412666,
0.1687957048,
0.0910910517,
0.3142765164,
-0.6161027551,
0.8028620481,
-0.0379124321,
-1.0711891651,
0.3565458953,
-0.4113348722,
0.5679270625,
0.2446158528,
0.5514942408,
-0.6420610547,
-0.3022189736,
-0.0508316942,
-0.7068053484,
0.5520391464,
0.2341575772,
-0.0184798259,
0.0000301376,
-0.0583212338,
-0.0171168931,
0.3693141937,
-0.5095128417,
-0.2407402247,
-0.0369096547,
-0.5008459091,
-0.2145564854,
-0.0028552094,
-0.3038252294,
-0.4085291922,
0.7780547738,
0.0987078398,
0.0557322875,
0.0755348504,
-0.0860555321,
-0.0324392021,
0.3162117004,
0.5517606139,
0.3053164482,
-0.1243450567,
0.4938000143,
0.2192492485,
-0.6009578109,
0.3277664483,
-0.1382445395,
0.419225812,
-0.0907625929,
0.3539811671,
0.4690532088,
0.3896324337,
-1.1403784752,
0.118323274,
0.2712343633,
-0.1263246834,
0.0731385127,
0.3535761237,
0.3092094362,
0.3283729851,
0.2006222606,
-0.4020084739,
0.2447927445,
-0.8656286597,
0.0823352858,
0.6039805412,
-0.336047709,
0.0053023077,
0.7647275925,
0.2659498155,
0.0187429935,
0.4657555223,
0.1107298732,
-0.6571522951,
0.3471054137,
0.415894866,
0.6330446005,
-0.3735618591,
-0.0144603206,
0.181475088,
0.1283387244,
0.0307790339,
0.2234093696,
0.0144726001,
-0.3426064551,
-0.1149692535,
-0.9059809446,
-0.5966256857,
0.2243846655,
-0.1120698899,
0.4018814266,
-0.7823463678,
0.0615820847,
-0.0152292773,
0.3637791574,
-0.4844760299,
-0.0561661571,
0.1587188989,
0.9803373218,
-0.6693213582,
0.6861938834,
0.4646400511,
-0.0035259423,
-0.4245850146,
-0.5652907491,
0.4559795558,
-0.5849477053,
0.9060410857,
-0.2297831625,
-0.3036950827,
-0.0932779387,
-0.8511536717,
-1.0082759857,
1.0169228315,
0.433996737,
-0.5772256255,
0.1841619462,
0.5033349991,
0.5960957408,
-0.4816988111,
-0.0247619208,
0.6258431673,
0.6510983706,
0.3870145679,
-0.7985339165,
0.257084161,
-0.423373878,
-0.069805108,
0.3078186512,
-0.7207596302,
1.0628602505,
0.0921428949,
-0.1671982408,
0.3034314215,
0.2457373589,
0.2991311848,
0.3437244594,
-0.1026876643,
0.2691736817,
0.6633652449,
-0.320063591,
1.0342899561,
-0.1260144264,
0.3176200986,
1.2854360342,
-0.9088792801,
0.6760623455,
0.3616456389,
-0.3245874047,
0.5212372541,
0.5218548775,
-0.0107967239,
0.5783426166,
0.5286745429,
-0.8443409204,
-0.4612587392,
-0.2338141054,
-0.1762482226,
0.2936023772,
0.665415287,
-0.3910541534,
-0.330568105,
-0.3695943952,
-0.0582721718,
0.0397444889,
-0.3744201362,
0.6877052188,
0.2232013345,
-0.3758557141,
0.4007411301,
-0.0883039087,
0.1894597262,
-0.8065538406,
-0.2184057236,
-0.3353247046,
0.1517411917,
-0.1183815673,
-0.6929422021,
-0.2029920369,
-0.1689226925,
0.0359151103,
0.0117201414,
0.7299729586,
-0.9791816473,
-0.3661299944,
0.0785518959,
0.406802237,
0.2750189602,
0.0307548419,
-0.407782197,
0.363389343,
-0.3289247453,
-0.0737358034,
0.3171600699,
0.4392078519,
-0.0240611695,
0.8155196309,
0.6496117711,
-0.2296327651,
0.0826551244,
-0.0722786039,
0.9142628312,
-0.7474790812,
-0.1281619221,
-0.8841121197,
0.2796855271,
-0.0883713365,
0.0414625145,
0.9216471314,
0.7778508663,
0.4550333619,
-0.1270646751,
0.8741780519,
0.3964163363,
0.303114742,
-0.663369,
0.7467749715,
-0.4056743085,
0.2920382917,
-0.2438341379,
-1.2673891783,
-0.3378827572,
0.4243596196,
0.0075762472,
0.274779886,
0.9949015975,
0.8527374864,
-0.0620603152,
-0.1040243655,
0.4664255083,
0.5515224934,
0.4368293285,
0.8822997808,
1.0207842588,
0.0012520291,
0.2611407638,
0.1654285491,
0.1277105063,
-0.1922236532,
-0.7975611687,
-1.1756609678,
-0.4632081985,
-0.1321371943,
-0.2538788319,
-0.1201244071,
1.1248915195,
0.5968945622,
-0.6692538857,
-0.5218732357,
-0.1442636698,
-0.0881288499,
0.2158964276,
-0.2137246579,
0.0245479774,
-0.4138689935,
-0.8884550929,
0.5632171035,
0.4724771976,
0.0975748822,
-0.5201464891,
-0.4239129424,
-0.1061813086,
0.320574075,
0.8099455237,
0.268409729,
-0.7127406597,
-0.0388921909,
-0.0042227912,
-0.3882621527,
-0.0687651932,
0.8458242416,
-0.5506740212,
0.5328860283,
0.2767643929,
0.4701074362,
0.6185160875,
-0.4619904757,
0.8235644102,
-0.6638563871,
-0.2030538172,
0.1738843173,
0.2756117284,
0.2202243209,
-0.1804991961,
0.5860188603,
0.0471159406,
-0.4936918616,
-0.756167829,
0.2594966292,
-1.1205595732,
-0.4993729293,
1.106888175,
0.0777766928,
-0.1159030721,
-0.3143080175,
-0.4422644377,
0.132621035,
-0.5953385234,
0.4588073492,
1.1817649603,
-0.1896698773,
-0.168296665,
-0.3796847463,
0.6860049963,
0.4016160965,
-1.0578770638,
0.3432479203,
0.8194358945,
0.3846160769,
0.020369513,
0.4658620059,
-0.0441625118,
0.1131021753,
0.0104128337,
-0.1346524656,
-0.0817862675,
-0.5969955325,
-0.224090904,
0.0589832775,
0.0904976726,
0.5970188975
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06820v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06820v2
|
Forecasting Events in Soccer Matches Through Language
| 2024-02-09T23:02:57 | 2024-04-26T11:45:02 |
Tiago Mendes-Neves, Luís Meireles, João Mendes-Moreira
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
This paper introduces an approach to predicting the next event in a soccer
match, a challenge bearing remarkable similarities to the problem faced by
Large Language Models (LLMs). Unlike other methods that severely limit event
dynamics in soccer, often abstracting from many variables or relying on a mix
of sequential models, our research proposes a novel technique inspired by the
methodologies used in LLMs. These models predict a complete chain of variables
that compose an event, significantly simplifying the construction of Large
Event Models (LEMs) for soccer. Utilizing deep learning on the publicly
available WyScout dataset, the proposed approach notably surpasses the
performance of previous LEM proposals in critical areas, such as the prediction
accuracy of the next event type. This paper highlights the utility of LEMs in
various applications, including match prediction and analytics. Moreover, we
show that LEMs provide a simulation backbone for users to build many analytics
pipelines, an approach opposite to the current specialized single-purpose
models. LEMs represent a pivotal advancement in soccer analytics, establishing
a foundational framework for multifaceted analytics pipelines through a
singular machine-learning model.
|
[
-0.0816858858,
-0.3301264644,
0.5372046232,
0.3181877732,
-0.2033764571,
0.3877591193,
-0.5193907022,
-0.6190767288,
0.2767335773,
0.4188387692,
-0.9752377272,
-0.702781558,
-0.457362473,
-0.2494814396,
-0.3147979081,
1.1019166708,
0.1024908572,
0.3364738524,
-0.3384807706,
0.2022415847,
-0.3554100394,
-0.6466206312,
-0.8018521667,
-0.5986254215,
0.5142779946,
0.4019546509,
0.5577096343,
0.4221171737,
0.607345283,
0.341770649,
0.1358149052,
0.1304741502,
-0.5115088224,
0.5373580456,
0.1860520691,
-0.590901792,
-0.3510650396,
0.1470078528,
0.5587877631,
0.902020514,
-0.044375103,
0.0793534145,
-0.1238936111,
0.5587105751,
-0.2573549747,
0.4222357273,
-0.8905169368,
0.2920946479,
-0.0546231866,
-0.2654184401,
-0.2640649974,
0.1405375004,
0.2246881574,
-0.2996637821,
0.1455972046,
-0.3968163133,
0.4631667435,
0.2268858999,
-0.0332866758,
-0.2123340815,
-1.0815899372,
0.9546672702,
-0.6743350625,
0.3862035871,
0.3835390508,
0.4974723458,
-0.3465036154,
-0.5023009777,
-0.293387115,
-0.3764136434,
0.2294796705,
0.4365136027,
0.268891722,
-0.1706914753,
0.0157010816,
-0.2599617541,
-0.5246857405,
0.4018627405,
-0.0835546404,
0.2722359002,
1.0607224703,
0.542586863,
-0.0176115837,
0.4879036546,
-0.1733536273,
0.3924918771,
-0.7957002521,
-0.0505781062,
0.2375804037,
0.5860954523,
-0.1707160622,
0.3194684386,
-0.3759448826,
0.4557243586,
-0.2050165832,
-0.5925047994,
-0.045571506,
-0.0325059742,
-0.1985221803,
-0.0661585629,
0.6976946592,
0.4477858245,
0.4656271636,
-0.4227610528,
0.0686014593,
0.161300078,
-0.450792104,
-1.0260611773,
-0.2640509903,
0.2950332761,
-0.2820905745,
-0.4435490966,
-0.0406474508,
-0.860076189,
-0.4148556888,
-0.5053524375,
-0.0399880446,
0.0020402272,
0.1074326262,
0.0926648602,
0.064158231,
0.1487485915,
0.5387183428,
-0.7180838585,
0.3623579443,
0.7613657117,
0.7456555367,
-0.2268339545,
-0.3738854527,
-0.7743284702,
0.1296185702,
-0.4018633068,
0.6678581238,
-0.7223293185,
-0.3403494656,
0.4408673048,
0.1538908035,
0.4654833376,
-0.1463656873,
0.2949695587,
-0.3679872751,
-0.0327130444,
0.0963335931,
-0.614276588,
0.077677086,
0.051336512,
-0.3678487539,
0.8757286668,
-0.3069564998,
-0.3092544675,
0.5830371976,
-0.4816245139,
-0.6557264924,
0.3470358551,
-0.1884618551,
-0.6164177656,
0.2853941321,
0.1945481598,
0.9251765609,
-0.2249099016,
0.2424883395,
-0.7352861762,
-0.229524225,
0.1544987857,
-0.2215166092,
0.3582002819,
-0.018676132,
-0.2265029699,
-0.0603596754,
-0.6618207693,
-0.192155242,
0.2275132388,
-0.0609736033,
-0.1006990746,
0.7361055613,
-0.0953297988,
0.4391010702,
0.2245594561,
-0.3197438717,
0.2897782922,
-0.529297173,
0.3017551899,
0.6605643034,
-0.3534052074,
0.7765060663,
0.187870115,
0.6261985302,
-0.1822009236,
0.2594203949,
-0.4398964047,
-0.5488231182,
-0.3200946748,
-0.0928390473,
0.1852942705,
0.5437135696,
-0.3324300349,
0.1696898639,
-0.2608391345,
-0.7667458653,
-0.1677396894,
0.4049830139,
-0.0242440924,
0.0082422765,
0.1189944372,
0.1625255644,
-0.9732741117,
-0.3277785778,
-0.1675280333,
-0.1351918429,
0.3270839751,
0.4931300879,
0.6275968552,
-0.0254904442,
0.5662291646,
-0.5862646103,
-0.4061908722,
-0.3607496917,
0.0766837597,
0.3517345488,
0.4316984415,
0.7246381044,
-0.7771502137,
-0.8121612072,
0.3096713126,
-0.6499582529,
-0.1585944295,
-0.0845854506,
0.3022744358,
0.346223861,
0.655967176,
-0.1820764691,
0.5909879208,
0.9786163568,
-0.3370579183,
0.6531713009,
0.0859496221,
-0.1348437071,
-0.9078516364,
-0.3209705353,
-0.1456509531,
-0.3347407877,
-0.5484447479,
-0.2165765464,
-0.4512042403,
-0.0194703024,
-0.5076126456,
0.6288436651,
-0.4205687344,
-0.3846492469,
-0.5914160013,
-0.0368333533,
-0.1542241126,
0.1007076576,
0.5181134343,
0.6229690909,
0.4775391221,
-0.5256686807,
0.6281342506,
-0.1032816768,
-0.4397819936,
0.1020659208,
-0.4954939783,
-0.1340457797,
-0.1692806482,
0.3480122387,
-1.0909528732,
-0.1203564107,
-0.2358405739,
-0.7160947919,
0.2408539355,
-0.5297326446,
-0.3029400408,
-0.7406226993,
-0.0906444341,
0.4220867753,
0.6056124568,
-0.5332507491,
0.5219750404,
0.5901409388,
-0.2475065142,
-0.6715807915,
-0.4841663539,
0.2554716766,
-0.3861599863,
-0.3918410242,
0.23306261,
-0.3506889045,
-0.2427749485,
-0.2316548675,
-0.0331162028,
-0.2542176843,
0.4695467055,
0.3265048862,
0.29557392,
-0.2305513024,
0.1901695579,
-0.3039842248,
0.0573888235,
-0.0343593098,
-0.8227968812,
0.7412765026,
0.0950111151,
0.0859186873,
-0.6530944705,
0.5617113709,
0.2908163965,
0.0713451654,
0.8388249278,
0.5461683869,
-0.5500440001,
-0.425018847,
-0.3975559473,
-0.0467101671,
-0.4519877136,
0.6073877811,
-0.5283398628,
-0.7924333811,
0.8344237804,
-0.2848452032,
-0.1191253886,
0.3545912206,
0.8732590675,
-0.6930239201,
1.6089462042,
0.5538904667,
-0.381128937,
0.575956583,
-0.3600332439,
-0.0554604046,
-0.396368295,
-0.5548942089,
-0.8463903666,
-0.1952562779,
-0.4816975594,
-0.4915371537,
-0.0234529842,
0.2710441649,
-0.1473497599,
0.4120197892,
0.0496797077,
0.9987972379,
0.022176547,
-0.3420719206,
0.1738058478,
-0.1950324476,
0.121564813,
-0.4039794803,
-0.6779326797,
-0.0439118743,
0.9298917651,
0.1099315137,
0.920804739,
-0.1399883181,
0.7195708752,
0.200525865,
0.5636883974,
-1.0681169033,
0.3284282088,
-0.2125744522,
-0.3855192661,
-0.4887284935,
-0.4094007909,
-0.9562661052,
0.0891228467,
-0.2724413276,
-0.9593046904,
-0.215758577,
-0.0129242167,
-0.106103152,
0.3840318024,
-0.1212730259,
0.4234206975,
-0.1541453749,
-0.3940478861,
0.1346727908,
-0.3446326554,
0.2315109968,
-0.0132650407,
0.5571991801,
-0.3626883924,
-0.3546869159,
0.7010666728,
-0.4507867694,
0.813700676,
0.0371279605,
-0.1209280118,
0.2887587249,
0.2668300271,
0.6619059443,
0.3736078739,
-0.120580174,
0.0705132931,
-0.2762077153,
-0.4765658081,
-0.4341877699,
0.9347350597,
-0.5611827374,
-0.4721549451,
-0.3465548456,
-0.4900118411,
-0.4236205816,
-0.0815202147,
0.1549570858,
0.3156526983,
-0.5449502468,
0.0826686695,
0.2450607121,
-0.080422245,
0.9419079423,
0.5457553864,
-0.3197882175,
-0.266923815,
0.7505987883,
0.0967066959,
-0.1207864881,
0.4455042183,
0.3243723214,
-0.4437321723,
-0.9918602109,
-0.1248139888,
0.1099016666,
-0.4606439769,
-0.6101878285,
-0.4282563627,
0.0291277841,
-0.54117769,
-0.3221156001,
-0.4563783109,
-0.1990935802,
-0.2573467493,
-0.1392569542,
0.1473810822,
0.8202625513,
-0.1083007082,
0.6259278059,
-0.7276973724,
-0.2728240788,
0.1409285516,
0.4555613995,
-0.2427998334,
-0.5435103178,
-0.4716690481,
-0.2706247866,
-0.0028710195,
-0.9019303322,
0.8547472954,
0.298594892,
0.4386740327,
0.5874714851,
-0.3551186323,
0.7425321341,
-0.8126946092,
0.8868682981,
0.5183700919,
-0.836769402,
0.6944999099,
-0.695343256,
0.0554000326,
0.3359217346,
0.4894174635,
-0.5554018617,
-0.1984997094,
-0.5770435929,
-0.7507011294,
0.8361674547,
0.0781515986,
0.1821929365,
-0.1224804968,
0.2755732238,
0.2120385915,
0.3659103811,
-0.6378756166,
-0.1639807969,
0.145422712,
-0.1000566259,
-0.6677428484,
-0.0160948317,
0.2858271301,
-0.4491089582,
0.7401941419,
-0.3272391856,
-0.0332076587,
-0.1595827043,
0.0888581052,
-0.1258555502,
-0.3529554009,
0.7250860333,
0.7548309565,
-0.125911817,
-0.3540404439,
0.4978858531,
-0.2154545784,
-0.1916183084,
-0.1631406546,
-0.0292081069,
0.1609254479,
0.4477141201,
0.7084084749,
0.0698105767,
-0.7880212069,
0.4757978916,
0.1380684972,
-0.5089048147,
-0.7003480792,
-0.3663202524,
0.3672152758,
0.4417903721,
0.4092575908,
-0.1941481829,
0.1186323464,
-0.7296429873,
0.1984955221,
0.5464017987,
-0.7869237065,
-0.4954465628,
0.7036060095,
0.3210429549,
-0.5159555078,
-0.0641576499,
0.0988278314,
-0.716514349,
1.0821927786,
0.6514467597,
0.6412699819,
-0.5655360818,
0.3184584677,
0.1818045229,
0.1204301864,
-0.2596669793,
0.3056837916,
0.3100375533,
-0.6896224618,
-1.0632385015,
-0.8793655038,
-0.1889817566,
0.6051081419,
-0.2213788182,
0.1838037968,
-0.4525746703,
-0.0849493966,
0.2525776625,
0.3680548966,
-1.0795017481,
0.3000960052,
0.6348000765,
0.8688110113,
-1.0019125938,
0.77320081,
0.6138031483,
-0.35115394,
-0.2615923584,
-0.2415229231,
-0.0133617902,
-0.668730557,
0.6136562824,
-0.0901735052,
0.1123626605,
-0.2256882787,
-0.6819529533,
-0.8107381463,
0.8248282075,
0.2377378941,
-0.663742125,
0.0422425941,
0.2291527838,
0.3844944835,
-0.8473101854,
0.1023065597,
0.6850134134,
0.4886401594,
0.2187225819,
-0.630409658,
-0.3429816067,
0.2250417769,
0.0370982178,
0.4328442514,
-0.6275720596,
0.5911479592,
-0.3724592626,
0.2419101596,
0.4313097,
0.9323493242,
-0.3233913183,
0.4303226769,
0.0798832849,
0.2462142706,
0.6481462717,
-0.3385465741,
0.9394026399,
0.1085018739,
0.5358679891,
1.362421155,
-0.4758166075,
0.7778352499,
0.1842513531,
-0.3111108243,
0.4239470065,
0.510011375,
-0.0823934004,
0.4806745648,
0.3984860182,
-0.3828999698,
-0.6607720852,
-0.0891196579,
-0.2182124257,
1.0033564568,
0.5807545185,
-0.2400312871,
-0.2235786468,
-0.000121795,
0.0238808747,
0.3206981122,
-0.6782212257,
1.0853682756,
-0.0370505266,
-0.6015380025,
-0.0489053726,
-0.0349109247,
0.498263061,
-0.4548631608,
-0.1052943766,
-0.2265559286,
0.340603888,
-0.055456847,
-0.6742148995,
0.1286709309,
-0.2558455169,
-0.2757215798,
0.1250559539,
0.6675293446,
-0.5912937522,
-0.7188424468,
0.6339709163,
0.5571526289,
0.196044609,
-0.0185061973,
-0.6939843893,
0.043692302,
-0.2298968583,
-0.1348132789,
0.4072743058,
0.4364650846,
-0.0665498301,
0.6666513681,
0.7345071435,
0.4440018833,
-0.0062197773,
0.2639307082,
0.4855166376,
-0.7323664427,
-0.5050213933,
-1.1258225441,
0.245803073,
-0.127084896,
-0.0726177022,
0.3326924145,
0.6897348762,
0.720754087,
-0.1055285782,
0.9339216948,
0.5516243577,
0.1091434062,
-0.2446660697,
0.5110825896,
-0.5329655409,
-0.0043044728,
-0.2427242398,
-0.7286646366,
-0.4640336335,
0.434769839,
-0.0702514723,
-0.2255516052,
0.4934055805,
0.1940287054,
0.1535916477,
-0.0641747639,
0.6364096403,
0.1342035681,
0.1960586458,
0.5917458534,
0.8628764749,
-0.2609787285,
0.6570006609,
-0.0354943462,
-0.2082048506,
-0.5220185518,
-1.0576344728,
-1.2467752695,
-0.5532100201,
-0.185307622,
-0.4417494833,
0.299424082,
0.865873158,
0.980037868,
-0.9951120019,
-0.4749038815,
0.0150198815,
0.1119461209,
-0.2326986045,
-0.1780672222,
0.2135712951,
-0.5412121415,
-1.2287845612,
0.5190390348,
0.192331478,
0.0414517559,
-0.0685331523,
-0.1878911257,
-0.0440487899,
0.2911049426,
0.877386868,
0.3794117868,
-0.560565114,
-0.2598666847,
-0.1533403695,
0.2497999072,
-0.1074420363,
0.7078796625,
-0.9912471175,
-0.0664833337,
0.5918813348,
0.6652534604,
0.8878535032,
-0.4128957391,
0.7727979422,
-0.6884915233,
0.5264323354,
0.5494687557,
0.5617759824,
0.0096777761,
-0.2717477679,
0.7491956949,
0.3277914822,
-0.261616677,
-0.8381679654,
0.3663744926,
-0.8903805017,
-0.3231467605,
1.1183701754,
-0.0587777644,
-0.1282734275,
-0.0640302449,
0.06449572,
0.1627342999,
-0.3734302819,
0.6186184883,
0.7964713573,
-0.0089779384,
0.1205470785,
-0.4579986334,
0.7524321079,
0.1098769903,
-0.7552105784,
0.061704468,
0.3000363111,
0.2354526222,
-0.188394919,
0.5510463715,
0.0570412651,
0.1531062126,
-0.0974660814,
-0.2764750719,
0.0174486879,
-0.8494001031,
0.0724130124,
0.2223892063,
-0.4140112996,
-0.0074944715
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10949v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10949v2
|
The Unreasonable Effectiveness of Eccentric Automatic Prompts
| 2024-02-09T22:48:45 | 2024-02-20T15:03:00 |
Rick Battle, Teja Gollapudi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable problem-solving and
basic mathematics abilities. However, their efficacy is highly contingent on
the formulation of the prompt. This study endeavors to quantify the influence
of incorporating "positive thinking" into the system message of the prompt,
then compare that to systematic prompt optimization. We assess the performance
of 60 combinations of system message snippets, tested with and without Chain of
Thought prompting, across three models with parameters ranging from 7 to 70
billion on the GSM8K dataset. Our findings reveal that results do not
universally generalize across models. In most instances, the inclusion of
"positive thinking" prompts positively affected model performance. Notably,
however, Llama2-70B exhibited an exception when not utilizing Chain of Thought,
as the optimal system message was found to be none at all. Given the
combinatorial complexity, and thus computation time, of experimenting with
hand-tuning prompts for large black-box models, we then compared the
performance of the best "positive thinking" prompt against the output of
systematic prompt optimization. We show that employing an automated prompt
optimizer emerges as the most effective method for enhancing performance, even
when working with smaller open-source models. Additionally, our findings reveal
that the highest-scoring, automatically-optimized prompt exhibits a degree of
peculiarity far beyond expectations.
|
[
-0.5781243443,
-0.8118592501,
0.8631929159,
0.5115280747,
-0.3472587764,
-0.1824849844,
-0.2746291757,
-0.4506699443,
0.226120308,
0.2416841239,
-0.8554615378,
-0.1720142961,
-0.4271246493,
0.6818981171,
-0.2233537734,
0.8326021433,
0.0235037021,
0.0358889587,
0.0300288163,
0.1588611007,
-0.8047497869,
-0.3738514185,
-0.4820310771,
-0.2689929008,
0.6599546671,
0.1986054033,
0.696333766,
0.6356554627,
0.452061832,
0.2626078427,
-0.0608149841,
0.3245991468,
-0.4755479395,
0.4164339006,
-0.2912916839,
-0.673107028,
-0.1794481725,
0.0357762799,
0.6247714162,
0.4160487056,
-0.1812025756,
0.1813081801,
0.0186531059,
0.5257840753,
-0.6528281569,
0.0664716065,
-0.5766082406,
0.0117280735,
0.000703048,
-0.2241168469,
-0.3252177238,
-0.5975830555,
0.1195561066,
-0.676702857,
-0.4140000641,
0.2645780742,
0.6531119347,
0.4682694077,
0.1076424718,
-0.8486609459,
-0.7058116198,
0.7887676954,
-0.6967333555,
-0.0580501892,
0.2069060802,
0.2636778355,
-0.3354839683,
-0.0085297944,
-0.5846756101,
-0.3723833859,
0.3525740802,
0.0501248837,
-0.5774556994,
0.1695388556,
0.7217007279,
0.1885305196,
-0.327863723,
0.2929472625,
-0.2143116891,
-0.0786023438,
0.5176897645,
0.6381226778,
0.2279694527,
-0.2799957097,
-0.1017555818,
0.01751904,
-0.6083436012,
0.3990538418,
0.4454315603,
0.4126304984,
-0.0101253949,
0.7005313039,
-0.2851441801,
0.6394161582,
0.2916619182,
-0.1271606237,
-0.1758650243,
-0.443651855,
-0.1960097104,
-0.2022728175,
0.7018347979,
0.3645515144,
0.3173061311,
0.0116147241,
-0.7490466237,
0.5303871036,
0.2646837533,
-0.6943703294,
0.0627144054,
0.1893413812,
-0.2345542163,
-0.2597246766,
-0.0535292029,
-0.3498995006,
-0.4225530624,
-0.5189064145,
0.5142305493,
-0.2552771568,
0.1508385688,
0.3154041469,
-0.1927016526,
-0.1170597747,
0.4542967379,
-0.5340961218,
0.0509978458,
0.7366188169,
0.7150751948,
-0.1361909658,
-0.0333869159,
-0.6523102522,
-0.400452733,
-0.5474389195,
0.9806911349,
-0.6997749805,
-0.5690335035,
-0.0966886207,
-0.2206009328,
-0.0200999845,
-0.5208722353,
0.7158720493,
-0.3603599966,
0.2230380625,
-0.581119895,
-0.5908889771,
-0.0292277168,
0.1671759933,
-0.3868597448,
0.9946214557,
-0.0924589187,
-0.4266951382,
0.2202880681,
-0.5371701121,
-0.2279838324,
0.0851187855,
-0.1439400464,
-0.04084583,
0.3935518265,
0.1875098646,
0.3984651268,
-0.6201667786,
0.3249816597,
-0.2591503263,
-0.6191355586,
0.4984426498,
-0.269117862,
0.8499086499,
0.2305297256,
-0.6024706364,
0.0541041121,
-0.5524085164,
0.0346646681,
0.1106529087,
-0.0657006279,
-0.2848298252,
-0.3145971298,
-0.672766149,
0.3402096927,
0.0273143612,
-0.2971488535,
0.5969165564,
-0.398576498,
0.1054818332,
1.0344129801,
0.1489967555,
0.1986458004,
-0.5891482234,
0.9531216025,
-0.15711689,
0.1875720322,
-0.4147614837,
-0.6704765558,
-0.7121666074,
-0.1879163384,
-0.1375797987,
0.7781534195,
-0.775793314,
0.4059273303,
0.1639362723,
-0.4644615948,
-0.5375270247,
0.0725068077,
0.4712108672,
0.5795973539,
0.0905655548,
-0.1478788704,
-0.2824706435,
-1.0044101477,
-0.4238608181,
-0.1433336437,
0.124970898,
0.5665401816,
0.4613916278,
-0.2808294296,
0.5353568196,
-0.5083978176,
0.448022157,
-0.1978664994,
0.0053895419,
0.7057474852,
0.0508301444,
0.303227514,
-0.0671417639,
-0.4103868008,
-0.4613395631,
-0.6199640632,
-0.511018455,
-0.4550054669,
-0.2861296237,
0.0402822569,
-0.0103673115,
-0.9211665988,
0.4711376727,
0.0291699767,
-0.3522154391,
1.1728101969,
-0.217294395,
0.1271708906,
-0.5262054205,
-0.0795004591,
0.2967091203,
0.1935781986,
-0.5983418822,
0.0530168004,
0.1847390383,
-0.0507470295,
-0.1956673265,
0.5021322966,
-0.4223778844,
0.1672183126,
-0.4905472994,
0.2551890016,
-0.1406143308,
0.3374899626,
-0.3982484639,
1.1959424019,
0.6450719833,
-0.8998995423,
0.4322142899,
0.1256474406,
-0.5795276165,
0.5964197516,
-0.7398002744,
0.3590012789,
-0.3078734279,
0.1257881969,
-0.9593689442,
-0.219866246,
0.3425380588,
-0.0395986997,
-0.1647837907,
0.4917913973,
-0.4718564451,
-0.751206696,
-0.5179142952,
0.1044552177,
0.6015388966,
-0.4472570717,
0.2306511104,
0.0743235797,
-0.27703318,
-0.4743353426,
-0.3768156171,
0.2342702746,
-0.2765043676,
-0.5105520487,
-0.0006889997,
-0.1898759753,
-0.3358306885,
-0.398542434,
0.0332918167,
0.664809525,
0.2457277775,
0.1570756137,
0.5922601819,
-0.0998793244,
0.0961876214,
-0.0164119937,
-0.1693323106,
0.3824735582,
-0.4252889752,
0.5607792735,
-0.0647903532,
-0.356244415,
-0.9509953856,
0.3894603252,
0.4186754525,
-0.0464143604,
0.5936754942,
0.053518448,
-0.3326834738,
-0.3149227798,
-0.6115393043,
-0.2309362441,
-0.5389265418,
0.0362878963,
-0.2799993157,
-0.658728838,
0.5057053566,
0.169380039,
0.12176615,
0.1417379826,
0.5170424581,
-0.0637664348,
1.2503577471,
0.40620327,
-0.0123837506,
0.6042356491,
-0.0576932617,
0.3578337133,
-0.9326182604,
-0.0464478433,
-0.6160616279,
-0.1988238841,
-0.4535696507,
-0.3715598881,
0.4820006192,
0.0853020027,
-0.4228886068,
0.257999599,
-0.7711820006,
0.4215484262,
0.469928503,
0.0212267302,
0.1716115177,
-0.1342307031,
-0.2367493212,
0.1384218782,
-0.750896275,
-0.7622985244,
0.9891909361,
0.2139974535,
0.8919499516,
-0.1792562455,
0.5781847239,
0.0663448051,
0.3706956804,
-0.7448694706,
0.7517875433,
0.3076758683,
-0.3901619017,
-0.2184719592,
-0.4538958371,
-0.9046795964,
0.0468894467,
-0.1591380984,
-0.9060905576,
0.1670607477,
0.151328966,
-0.8344478607,
0.0216842368,
-0.7779409289,
0.2904508412,
-0.233732909,
-0.1638457328,
-0.2506314814,
-0.3373966813,
0.2099554092,
-0.0173093732,
0.2337554693,
-0.0380192362,
-0.2224774212,
0.5817559361,
-0.1156508029,
0.7171919346,
-0.1514109969,
-0.4432882071,
0.5150648952,
0.1682305038,
1.1232495308,
-0.1000198051,
-0.2607814372,
-0.1369527876,
-0.3684160411,
-0.2972093821,
-0.7813329101,
0.4963021576,
-0.7344588637,
-1.2539086342,
-0.1611509025,
-0.5067268014,
-0.2453263551,
0.2098984122,
0.177314043,
0.6451507807,
0.1712379605,
-0.2131627053,
0.5326123834,
-0.352741152,
0.4095431268,
0.1479069889,
-0.3621396124,
-0.5355160832,
0.7671022415,
0.2164521515,
0.5366290808,
-0.0569923893,
0.289452821,
-0.1906327456,
-0.5637260675,
-0.5577469468,
0.4640262723,
-0.7217445374,
-0.2165024728,
-0.7658441663,
0.2448312789,
-0.2212429494,
-0.2103504837,
-0.0498318113,
-0.5648446083,
-0.478238076,
-0.0795191452,
0.1210225746,
0.8883094192,
0.1258662939,
0.181736201,
-0.6004517078,
0.02966756,
0.1495018601,
0.2122228444,
0.408819288,
-0.3761409521,
-0.2706030011,
0.0953640416,
-0.4171418548,
-0.8565510511,
0.1820916533,
-0.2520536482,
0.6624115705,
0.6913893819,
0.0581169985,
0.6324234009,
-0.2715376616,
0.8415130377,
0.3016943634,
-0.8145653009,
0.5251396298,
-0.5799622536,
0.710560739,
0.3364625275,
0.3684247732,
-0.4988763332,
-0.7329128385,
-0.3946328461,
-0.4609681368,
0.7061969042,
0.2804863751,
0.0915828496,
-0.3642677367,
0.5612790585,
0.3201082647,
0.3204627931,
-0.4913484156,
-0.3373181522,
0.0429409742,
-0.0229174905,
0.1061377078,
-0.0936876461,
-0.0370114669,
-0.1911717057,
0.5948780775,
0.0671804771,
0.5294005275,
0.3022160232,
0.1597701162,
-0.4604477286,
0.2514294386,
0.8531395197,
0.6565551758,
0.1855758131,
-0.0995260105,
0.2918149829,
-0.2586970031,
0.1780176908,
-0.237837404,
-0.4218883216,
-0.2374818474,
0.3051202595,
0.9885106683,
-0.0221330002,
-0.6927945614,
0.0835213512,
0.011989885,
0.0848834142,
0.1135282293,
0.7466319799,
-0.0758343861,
0.2832420468,
0.4732615948,
0.2179502547,
0.2649044096,
-0.5298688412,
-0.2426754832,
0.6568615437,
-0.2156710327,
-0.4475521743,
0.4707504511,
0.1829437315,
-0.8799954653,
0.4441781342,
-0.5031826496,
-0.7925050259,
0.6979102492,
0.6742115021,
0.8967559338,
-0.2075598389,
0.325060904,
0.4395679533,
0.3395518661,
-0.2320079654,
0.4414265752,
-0.132760182,
-0.4420360625,
-0.4883387685,
-0.2596626878,
-0.4122073352,
-0.1922816634,
-0.5200018883,
0.4165180922,
-0.6012220979,
-0.5504364371,
-0.1628103554,
0.057850685,
-0.8306688666,
-0.0004958665,
0.1950873286,
1.084690094,
-0.4320512116,
0.2559071779,
0.6870415807,
-0.0296907686,
-1.1011815071,
-0.17681624,
-0.0339309573,
-0.8058220744,
0.4667586088,
0.4093522131,
-0.2726626694,
-0.2081363946,
-0.4712531865,
-0.8459439874,
0.7814514637,
0.3129223585,
-0.8446139693,
-0.1597542465,
0.0569182448,
0.5214053988,
-0.613671124,
0.5626997948,
0.3954053223,
0.5767251253,
-0.0805373415,
-1.0323274136,
0.363845855,
-0.2431880236,
0.046731621,
0.2949984968,
-0.7596572042,
0.7990368605,
-0.4575146139,
-0.5185892582,
0.1630667597,
0.4266736507,
0.455008328,
0.2630550265,
0.5077140927,
0.3844980597,
1.1277735233,
0.0965934098,
1.3061199188,
-0.3315820098,
0.1047175005,
0.4214306474,
-0.2064706981,
0.3110915422,
0.4904974103,
-0.1412239671,
0.4990493059,
0.5885851383,
0.1635586023,
0.5180778503,
0.2472652048,
-0.1476088464,
-0.4470989406,
-0.0885812715,
-0.3202790916,
-0.0566412657,
0.4020374417,
-0.148025319,
-0.14457421,
0.094021596,
-0.0835553035,
-0.1866063625,
-0.3898368478,
0.6360763907,
0.2891944051,
-1.1898076534,
0.8279781342,
-0.2374189198,
0.7241909504,
-0.1279647648,
0.1998019516,
-0.0901219696,
-0.0706153661,
0.0343927555,
-0.601569593,
-0.1037816554,
0.1544231772,
-0.0272864588,
-0.1786963344,
0.5588189363,
0.1331827939,
-0.4468279481,
-0.0714329109,
0.4590649903,
0.0116039868,
0.0488162488,
-0.7977231145,
0.0906641483,
0.1008822843,
-0.3438738883,
0.0022740648,
0.7710831761,
-0.0321099088,
1.0465295315,
0.7599665523,
0.2102813125,
-0.2488250136,
-0.1179696992,
1.1208788157,
-0.9151700139,
-0.7635615468,
-1.1059932709,
0.4655281603,
-0.1347415596,
-0.5851272941,
0.8580334783,
0.3015351593,
0.3984527588,
0.0286941156,
0.6930750012,
0.417119652,
0.2781920433,
-0.4193537831,
0.1051572114,
-0.2664726675,
0.6842514873,
-0.5536885262,
-1.1777175665,
-0.0376517437,
0.6259581447,
-0.7908813953,
-0.0938177332,
0.6376781464,
0.8323762417,
0.3592982888,
0.6197629571,
0.0587723069,
0.0467749871,
0.3766800165,
0.6574188471,
1.4185571671,
0.0702265427,
0.1919993162,
-0.0874993205,
-0.5917452574,
-0.3988912404,
-0.8431745768,
-1.2245342731,
-0.2497191578,
-0.0772992149,
-0.2990321517,
0.2345101386,
1.4193161726,
0.2374579757,
-0.546251297,
-0.1611241698,
-0.1286963373,
0.1723718196,
-0.0481706336,
-0.1497925073,
0.0695188865,
-0.4611343741,
-0.3672087491,
0.273255676,
0.5100644231,
0.1265601814,
-0.4368270636,
0.116384238,
0.1779732853,
0.7079577446,
0.4962322414,
-0.0418722108,
-0.6714139581,
-0.3368468285,
0.6929212213,
-0.2970639169,
0.0370642617,
0.8669968843,
-0.6388937235,
0.3501191139,
0.2498189211,
0.4695695937,
-0.0537916496,
0.2231747806,
0.6700541973,
0.0888604149,
-0.0819774121,
0.5295135379,
0.2481177598,
0.1485064775,
-0.7540223598,
0.0324247815,
0.0403401628,
-0.6138694882,
-0.977140069,
0.230656445,
-0.5638771653,
-0.2149868906,
1.3216223717,
0.0778389797,
-0.3397489488,
0.0199941359,
-0.5017281175,
-0.0971506163,
-0.8488518,
1.277261138,
1.0687969923,
-0.5848346949,
0.1180340722,
-0.3438279927,
0.2660860121,
0.7283579111,
-0.6236428618,
0.039830856,
0.5161121488,
-0.2193370908,
0.2361760736,
0.4704049826,
0.3024865389,
0.3736541271,
-0.1096005365,
-0.4060760736,
-0.1508823633,
-0.277207762,
-0.3817673922,
-0.0288291909,
-0.0178892557,
0.3413235843
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15393v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15393v1
|
Detection of Opioid Users from Reddit Posts via an Attention-based Bidirectional Recurrent Neural Network
| 2024-02-09T22:12:20 | 2024-02-09T22:12:20 |
Yuchen Wang, Zhengyu Fang, Wei Du, Shuai Xu, Rong Xu, Jing Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SI
|
The opioid epidemic, referring to the growing hospitalizations and deaths
because of overdose of opioid usage and addiction, has become a severe health
problem in the United States. Many strategies have been developed by the
federal and local governments and health communities to combat this crisis.
Among them, improving our understanding of the epidemic through better health
surveillance is one of the top priorities. In addition to direct testing,
machine learning approaches may also allow us to detect opioid users by
analyzing data from social media because many opioid users may choose not to do
the tests but may share their experiences on social media anonymously. In this
paper, we take advantage of recent advances in machine learning, collect and
analyze user posts from a popular social network Reddit with the goal to
identify opioid users. Posts from more than 1,000 users who have posted on
three sub-reddits over a period of one month have been collected. In addition
to the ones that contain keywords such as opioid, opiate, or heroin, we have
also collected posts that contain slang words of opioid such as black or
chocolate. We apply an attention-based bidirectional long short memory model to
identify opioid users. Experimental results show that the approaches
significantly outperform competitive algorithms in terms of F1-score.
Furthermore, the model allows us to extract most informative words, such as
opiate, opioid, and black, from posts via the attention layer, which provides
more insights on how the machine learning algorithm works in distinguishing
drug users from non-drug users.
|
[
-0.2902303338,
-0.8189315796,
0.6395395398,
0.0683948547,
-0.4362209737,
-0.042055998,
-0.1533614248,
-0.6054760218,
0.6970447302,
0.5178176761,
-0.3246203065,
-0.8113667965,
-0.6173309684,
0.3803288341,
-0.5739762187,
0.8532711267,
-0.0847129747,
-0.276815474,
-0.0980651379,
-0.167858839,
-0.4527752399,
-0.3608602583,
-0.5373712182,
-0.0466068946,
1.290332675,
0.257251054,
0.2404799014,
0.2364798784,
0.8124858141,
0.2788799703,
0.1547868103,
0.0649891049,
-0.4853184819,
0.0003952994,
-0.160197556,
-0.0660111383,
-0.1476115584,
-0.2048277408,
-0.0246904138,
0.600450933,
-0.1792635322,
0.1850225776,
0.0327456407,
0.5570595264,
-0.8082954288,
-0.3055454791,
-0.5114026666,
0.0975010321,
-0.0582380928,
-0.4089305401,
-0.0464944877,
-0.5322972536,
-0.0218345337,
-0.3550725877,
0.1330351382,
-0.0597769506,
0.5729824901,
0.1128888652,
-0.2834654748,
-0.3656553328,
-0.645013392,
0.516063273,
-0.4487728477,
0.2181038111,
0.3622566462,
0.1288135797,
-0.1280929446,
-0.63095963,
-0.3576573133,
-0.0779935643,
-0.4047478139,
-0.1323701143,
-0.1568688303,
0.0402190648,
0.0471724421,
0.0464731269,
-0.9424055815,
-0.0580076277,
-0.7942207456,
0.2164247036,
0.6874104738,
0.0371055454,
0.2858922482,
-0.2544414103,
-0.6805229783,
0.5876125693,
-0.3557412028,
-0.2140909284,
0.3168004751,
0.4091621935,
-0.0732102096,
0.453643769,
0.0877702162,
0.7820650935,
-0.1183350086,
0.125819698,
0.437256813,
-0.2677240372,
-0.2145059705,
0.0625598505,
1.154407382,
0.5000769496,
0.3190992177,
0.0435089692,
-0.2311589867,
-0.1051047891,
0.6157621741,
-0.6995995045,
-0.3023582995,
0.294732362,
-1.0031512976,
-0.4868883789,
0.058618322,
-0.735011816,
-0.5836817622,
-0.1474364847,
0.5261557698,
-0.1922758669,
-0.3753515184,
0.1521816701,
-0.1101165488,
-0.3964498043,
0.0261267293,
-0.7509848475,
0.2755118608,
0.7288410664,
1.0967085361,
-0.337293148,
-0.1682819575,
-0.2159030735,
-0.3036977947,
-0.1606326997,
0.7846316695,
-0.2756927311,
-0.0339891762,
0.1749375463,
0.2919541597,
-0.1808684468,
-0.7563232183,
0.2501384318,
-0.6590716839,
-0.0586128123,
-0.0971568078,
-0.3559548259,
-0.2325687259,
0.28997311,
-0.4910760224,
0.4466719329,
-0.1013562009,
-0.8921804428,
0.0395345166,
-0.5854394436,
-0.4688295126,
0.2124931961,
0.0046027428,
-0.3944298327,
0.3596009314,
0.1258302033,
0.5169953704,
-0.0020878385,
0.0331758745,
-0.3698243201,
-0.7855082154,
0.3164465427,
-0.05315952,
0.7297930717,
0.560688138,
0.0142173488,
0.1748482585,
-0.4928866029,
-0.2367257476,
0.2249905616,
-0.2874958515,
-0.6772321463,
0.0128386328,
0.2436813712,
0.0417130403,
0.1210928932,
-0.6872884631,
-0.2266887724,
-0.4464994669,
0.6535098553,
0.7531183362,
0.4394626319,
-0.1840621382,
-0.3937467933,
0.4753372967,
0.1606780589,
0.1923485547,
-0.1139256358,
-0.5304757953,
-0.1120041385,
-0.0811785385,
0.4203270376,
0.5502189994,
-0.443162322,
0.6941725612,
-0.1310771108,
-0.0525896363,
-0.3509224355,
0.2240091413,
0.0442519337,
0.6097514629,
0.3365652561,
-0.174884066,
-0.6809529066,
-0.8978917003,
-0.3825149834,
0.0335691497,
-0.2124121934,
0.5154037476,
0.599463582,
-0.2558563948,
0.4949847758,
-0.524736166,
-0.4328337014,
-0.2591778338,
0.413713783,
0.4819466174,
0.2080002874,
0.3264777064,
-0.9669592381,
-0.7005088925,
0.053397011,
-0.6555978656,
-0.1070204601,
0.0406704508,
-0.0421257801,
-0.2075562477,
0.4752297401,
-0.0583700724,
0.3470472693,
0.3303777277,
-0.1742675304,
-0.0664610043,
-0.1175122634,
0.2198619843,
-1.0413600206,
0.4241771102,
0.2309891284,
0.0055643944,
-0.4738765657,
-0.3623559773,
-0.0979110524,
-0.3281218112,
-0.3881455958,
0.1775946319,
-0.2774968743,
-0.0967977792,
-0.2134359032,
0.1190141439,
-0.2265227288,
0.3894605935,
-0.0082765287,
0.3708159328,
0.3180896342,
-0.2306269258,
0.4678569138,
-0.3272251189,
-0.6032024026,
0.581620276,
-0.7735866308,
0.0711425915,
-0.2919331193,
-0.3493635654,
-1.2747282982,
-0.2842755318,
0.6299112439,
-0.6283054948,
0.0552304797,
-0.1855947822,
-0.2942964733,
-0.8094633818,
-0.1280676574,
0.4597274363,
0.3759789467,
-0.1560513675,
0.3006839454,
0.485411942,
-0.0878395364,
-0.688941896,
-0.4985928535,
0.029431738,
-0.219147414,
-0.3488426208,
0.1725159138,
0.1982065737,
-0.1376281679,
0.4753288627,
0.2242751569,
-0.1732577085,
0.1922659278,
0.1935770214,
0.0672731325,
-0.0355108641,
0.5479825735,
-0.3479545712,
-0.0401875526,
0.2141967267,
-0.1022481993,
0.5541450977,
0.2529471517,
-0.2107598931,
-0.8045763373,
0.7593291402,
0.6455903649,
-0.1868057102,
0.6394289136,
0.3265341818,
-0.5428341627,
-0.0370183364,
-0.4354561269,
-0.4737570882,
-0.4324249029,
0.2377102971,
0.2788187861,
-0.5502377152,
0.281006366,
0.1638255864,
-0.0144788977,
-0.2322495282,
0.2737902105,
-0.4688011706,
1.0507237911,
0.2763172388,
-0.1633235216,
0.4809685051,
0.0494801924,
0.2518518865,
-0.4658029377,
0.1642700285,
-0.1466774642,
-0.9384464622,
-0.5540721416,
-0.1877736002,
0.4641798437,
-0.348546505,
-0.1161671653,
0.1863064319,
-0.6993414164,
0.4339512885,
0.593896091,
0.5457261205,
-0.078769736,
0.2476232797,
0.2749512494,
0.0167179182,
-0.2976574302,
-0.0336268432,
1.2669430971,
0.2586671114,
0.6506929994,
-0.2090676576,
0.8558893204,
0.7087135911,
0.4989836812,
-0.7870842218,
0.3156818449,
-0.3705387115,
-0.383671999,
0.1204771549,
-0.5705389977,
-1.1226403713,
0.0125154546,
-0.1967803836,
-0.3857893646,
0.1156318039,
0.14051947,
-0.9701723456,
0.2777773142,
-0.7240586877,
1.0293624401,
-0.47560063,
-0.2978704572,
-0.1489642262,
-0.6938088536,
0.1345542222,
0.1599603742,
0.2920333147,
-0.0916204453,
-0.0346085206,
0.8858836889,
-0.3655202687,
0.873179853,
-0.3671673834,
0.2670207322,
0.4122256041,
-0.4315481782,
0.2992040515,
-0.2063226849,
0.3725235462,
0.2884621918,
-0.3544832468,
-0.296503067,
-0.4350253046,
0.7991712689,
-0.4419758916,
-0.3985907137,
-0.1349536777,
-0.1369012445,
0.1273363382,
0.2386298031,
0.2614614069,
0.1358662695,
0.0303654242,
0.2961165607,
0.611959517,
-0.1168578863,
0.1452446133,
0.195508793,
-0.1360263228,
-0.6190179586,
0.7077602148,
0.3970665038,
-0.3099597991,
0.3549817801,
0.4431022108,
-0.0466635823,
-0.7027547359,
-0.0708408132,
0.6554423571,
-0.081850484,
-0.2154647708,
-0.7007544041,
-0.0560638569,
-0.495146811,
-0.0173876081,
-0.1380625069,
0.2724966705,
-0.4399395287,
-0.0793721452,
0.3886629045,
0.734783411,
-0.2194110155,
0.101584807,
-0.7358648181,
0.5788957477,
0.6322379708,
0.3805138767,
-0.0039677499,
-0.1285921484,
-0.1228991002,
-0.0660880655,
-0.0846300647,
-1.207447052,
0.3592080474,
-0.1408382505,
0.4360310137,
0.8704872727,
0.2948370278,
0.4104970098,
-0.2015426755,
0.2961935699,
0.2297074646,
-0.2550187111,
0.6265294552,
-0.4529777765,
-0.0126758842,
0.6691185832,
0.7558111548,
-0.9926466942,
0.0497803427,
-0.0963739976,
-0.7163019776,
0.6551933885,
0.0936419815,
0.1677471399,
-0.4407345951,
0.4416389167,
-0.0997662097,
0.339158982,
-0.6023461223,
-0.3769539595,
0.0508965552,
-0.5977299213,
0.2166657001,
-0.5679376721,
-0.1029245332,
-0.0483621806,
0.2200335413,
0.1317301542,
0.3461849093,
0.1025026739,
0.2185820192,
-0.1496382356,
0.0584188998,
0.6924841404,
0.6311232448,
-0.5224762559,
0.3345739245,
-0.2595615685,
-0.6965862513,
-0.0563547201,
0.0954826549,
-0.2910529077,
0.0363486521,
0.2537699342,
0.4041528106,
0.1991347224,
-0.8332061172,
0.7806660533,
-0.2556051314,
-0.3227176368,
-0.5466787815,
0.0645262226,
0.1007892042,
0.2239139825,
0.3503447771,
0.3865029216,
0.2506830692,
-0.5902398825,
0.3973440528,
0.4119614363,
-0.6670809388,
-0.4359137416,
0.4025458097,
0.4166894853,
-0.6096544266,
0.480912745,
0.061358951,
-0.457244575,
0.7377750278,
0.1732697934,
0.8300485611,
-0.3087737262,
-0.0159125756,
0.7722361684,
0.0639193207,
0.186262697,
0.4554607868,
-0.2868939042,
-0.6452712417,
0.1720813066,
-0.3376900554,
0.3073992133,
0.4725445509,
-0.7433468103,
0.3332368135,
-0.4587934017,
-0.3168125749,
0.0642681271,
-0.3182376325,
-0.2388747633,
-0.169521153,
0.374350965,
0.4752963185,
-0.9210125804,
0.2962886989,
0.6716426611,
-0.0630414858,
-0.0178664979,
0.0906489268,
-0.1185459197,
-0.5792886019,
0.5115568042,
0.6429554224,
-0.0349685252,
-0.1480141878,
-0.530233264,
-0.5246118903,
0.7812436819,
-0.2594939768,
-0.7079185247,
0.0436179042,
-0.1535100639,
0.6501113176,
-0.5667437315,
-0.0254882518,
0.2349361926,
0.360011369,
0.1224448755,
-0.4489787817,
-0.2048833817,
-0.3491765261,
0.0706746578,
0.4008730054,
-0.2136387527,
0.9749372602,
-0.518845737,
-0.5303049684,
-0.1095219627,
0.4142251015,
0.0803590938,
0.6287885308,
0.8099673986,
0.6143256426,
0.5538374186,
0.3000558317,
0.5577562451,
-0.1211713627,
0.412663579,
0.9681147337,
-0.2271804214,
1.0128370523,
0.578905642,
0.0066988957,
0.5919368863,
0.5005834103,
-0.1229487732,
0.8880077004,
0.2351294756,
-0.1906307787,
-0.3816074431,
-0.1220166683,
-0.3199386299,
0.3097935617,
0.5805645585,
-1.1374394894,
-0.2126059681,
0.3975283802,
0.077152811,
0.2492636144,
-0.4899557531,
1.0680555105,
-0.1176111177,
-0.596601069,
0.7584782839,
-0.2032705992,
0.7250177264,
-0.3092908263,
-0.1123542041,
-0.1376025975,
0.4607955515,
-0.1747039258,
-0.6843938828,
0.4650340676,
-0.0694192573,
-0.119152762,
-0.0751533434,
0.8217822909,
-0.4645538032,
-0.6560885906,
0.5623331666,
0.2881548107,
0.27180323,
-0.2380135357,
-0.7396041751,
-0.1691273898,
-0.0216685906,
-0.1252547204,
0.0625552833,
0.0654004365,
0.4003471732,
0.3135803938,
0.5814954042,
0.4237920642,
-0.2928692102,
-0.1333937645,
0.6370059848,
-0.467982322,
-0.5304627419,
-0.8808629513,
0.2575984299,
-0.3171572387,
-0.2457469255,
0.4764419198,
0.3916493654,
0.6762694716,
-0.0223499108,
0.534067452,
-0.0645297393,
1.2805020809,
-0.0986261964,
1.0058192015,
-0.870437324,
0.1282006651,
0.1649879664,
-0.1910847574,
-0.4730990231,
0.699943006,
-0.4705108702,
0.1625674218,
0.4015767574,
0.874211669,
-0.1031798571,
-0.1793269664,
0.2602439523,
0.3118467331,
-0.158714965,
0.7002770901,
0.68488729,
-0.4956562221,
0.5145071149,
-0.4173850119,
-0.1459403783,
-0.8457896709,
-0.4689305425,
-1.1326899529,
-0.4486274421,
-0.1457358599,
-0.1302860975,
0.2455219924,
0.9299343824,
0.6559183598,
-0.9110009074,
-0.0891813561,
-0.1525968015,
0.5694722533,
-0.365072608,
-0.289163053,
0.2192700356,
0.0287724361,
-0.4631830454,
0.0603046045,
0.2842621505,
-0.2476283312,
-0.2213828713,
0.3428817987,
-0.4612522125,
-0.2327480018,
0.3551695943,
0.2794172168,
-0.5096617341,
-0.1055398136,
0.1946017593,
-0.2815644741,
0.1425386816,
1.0676383972,
-0.7175557613,
0.5206196904,
0.8283715844,
0.2711952031,
-0.0464500524,
0.4565687776,
0.1948494613,
-0.5787654519,
-0.2253694385,
0.5292595625,
0.3678115904,
0.0967001542,
-0.4643004239,
0.1831750125,
0.5752441883,
-0.650627017,
-0.7048411369,
-0.0947789326,
-0.5619055033,
-0.7030142546,
0.9582674503,
-0.1145891845,
-0.6441915035,
-0.6158793569,
-0.1311157793,
-0.1164462492,
-0.5405797362,
1.0345215797,
0.1684987992,
-0.1814483702,
-0.3378035724,
-0.6147355437,
0.2504961193,
-0.1347576827,
-0.642157197,
0.2066805214,
0.2301348001,
0.3690122366,
0.3811922073,
0.5997863412,
0.1096404791,
0.4573423266,
-0.3967606127,
-0.0293438826,
-0.2588561773,
-0.3932474852,
-0.3033210933,
0.6164885163,
-0.7011953592,
-0.6966686249
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06782v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06782v3
|
Debating with More Persuasive LLMs Leads to More Truthful Answers
| 2024-02-09T21:05:01 | 2024-05-30T13:59:34 |
Akbir Khan, John Hughes, Dan Valentine, Laura Ruis, Kshitij Sachan, Ansh Radhakrishnan, Edward Grefenstette, Samuel R. Bowman, Tim Rocktäschel, Ethan Perez
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Common methods for aligning large language models (LLMs) with desired
behaviour heavily rely on human-labelled data. However, as models grow
increasingly sophisticated, they will surpass human expertise, and the role of
human evaluation will evolve into non-experts overseeing experts. In
anticipation of this, we ask: can weaker models assess the correctness of
stronger models? We investigate this question in an analogous setting, where
stronger models (experts) possess the necessary information to answer questions
and weaker models (non-experts) lack this information. The method we evaluate
is debate, where two LLM experts each argue for a different answer, and a
non-expert selects the answer. We find that debate consistently helps both
non-expert models and humans answer questions, achieving 76% and 88% accuracy
respectively (naive baselines obtain 48% and 60%). Furthermore, optimising
expert debaters for persuasiveness in an unsupervised manner improves
non-expert ability to identify the truth in debates. Our results provide
encouraging empirical evidence for the viability of aligning models with debate
in the absence of ground truth.
|
[
-0.5553786755,
-0.6075485349,
0.7430619001,
-0.1498938054,
-0.0141440779,
0.2219946384,
-0.4725701809,
-0.2429103404,
0.0143757537,
0.5346597433,
-0.2333461344,
-0.1014558747,
-0.7287992239,
0.072838679,
-0.1511612386,
0.5903488398,
0.1993709058,
0.1768497676,
-0.6666888595,
-0.3335995376,
-0.3929712772,
-0.6217560172,
-0.3574729562,
-0.6992338896,
0.6685236692,
0.6013221145,
0.9609009624,
0.4085889757,
0.4142936766,
0.4223896861,
-0.3869175017,
0.2028927952,
-0.7247751951,
0.2205473036,
-0.6046831608,
-0.6978594065,
-0.3172702193,
0.276176244,
0.1825935841,
0.7657887936,
-0.1466914862,
-0.0448560044,
-0.0346401669,
0.5021191835,
-0.3556939065,
-0.3643890619,
-1.102823019,
-0.1123317257,
-0.2644714415,
-0.2889809012,
-0.3203888535,
-0.2382638156,
0.3750701249,
-0.1730117798,
0.1039929688,
0.0444417745,
1.2236297131,
0.3464532495,
-0.6553347707,
-0.1511181295,
-0.4444791973,
0.6576737165,
-1.0618019104,
0.2067025304,
0.0712598562,
0.1231273338,
-0.2649383545,
-0.4118449986,
-0.5062978864,
-0.3622323871,
0.1091560349,
0.1146539599,
-0.2881664932,
0.0067334063,
0.229076311,
0.2095100284,
-0.2234129757,
0.5444183946,
-0.2912510633,
-0.1288225204,
0.894079864,
0.1151795834,
0.0912311599,
-0.2315682173,
-0.4477800429,
0.1132200137,
-0.5775279999,
0.0173910074,
0.6789740324,
0.1724507511,
0.2091406137,
0.6244332194,
-0.1778008044,
0.5573944449,
0.5915341973,
-0.1242104098,
-0.2348247021,
-0.1224789098,
-0.1196198314,
0.0845104232,
0.6609156728,
0.5359387398,
0.1497734785,
-0.0531517193,
-0.3379463255,
0.0853601471,
0.3781355023,
-0.7244619131,
-0.4923152626,
0.1514765322,
-0.1283934116,
-0.387742281,
-0.066035144,
-0.6538371444,
-0.6138713956,
-0.2272812426,
0.5476974249,
0.3133787811,
-0.4748748541,
0.3067457974,
-0.2482529283,
0.2388713658,
0.500889957,
-0.5794950724,
0.3377329707,
0.7926957607,
0.3715221882,
-0.0556925125,
0.1543735415,
-0.2398366183,
0.0749591887,
-0.8777115941,
1.1464694738,
-0.6713780761,
-0.2700918317,
-0.3543873131,
-0.1037332341,
-0.0559171289,
-0.7319296002,
0.9507194757,
-0.560620904,
0.4766405523,
-0.702634871,
-0.8586797118,
-0.0816501379,
0.5088531971,
-0.6613125205,
0.6756184697,
-0.3388977051,
-1.0591839552,
0.1772400141,
-0.5801342726,
-0.1984278709,
0.0125994151,
-0.3947288096,
-0.4450441301,
0.2259323597,
0.3708734512,
0.3515193462,
-0.5486804247,
0.571423471,
-0.5348164439,
-0.0259137414,
0.697193265,
-0.6398716569,
0.5197099447,
0.0335179381,
-0.4124344289,
0.1031410471,
-0.3104416132,
-0.0677171722,
0.2057518214,
-0.348546356,
-0.1657020897,
0.206534937,
-0.4285511971,
0.078496322,
0.1043634191,
-0.5583204627,
0.2011114359,
-0.5189056993,
0.51475811,
1.01598382,
-0.0652457923,
0.3048097193,
-0.5972858071,
0.3802824318,
-0.1801188588,
-0.2135444432,
0.3422487974,
-0.7023432851,
-0.9054105282,
0.2981098294,
0.6225728393,
0.4238809347,
-0.5306658149,
0.0840764642,
-0.3148936927,
-0.6141845584,
-0.7859220505,
0.2507638335,
0.4610061347,
0.9398492575,
0.1857628971,
-0.3166280985,
-0.5503141284,
-0.9693983197,
-0.4563734531,
-0.4217077196,
0.1526969969,
0.5491725206,
0.373776406,
0.1986888796,
0.9460279942,
-0.3923825324,
0.3805015385,
-0.3769519925,
0.4628545344,
0.0853283629,
0.2464612722,
0.1140339524,
-0.8227140903,
-0.2955379486,
0.0604832694,
-0.7895725965,
-0.3922972083,
-0.038891878,
-0.0759438723,
0.3053644896,
0.1366309077,
-0.6972582936,
0.2549372315,
0.2236899585,
-0.1970725209,
0.5995223522,
-0.0506881736,
0.2622546852,
-0.6665847301,
-0.0766893104,
0.107996136,
-0.1866496503,
-0.6450509429,
-0.0733426139,
-0.195724383,
0.0737353042,
-0.2652751207,
0.6836587787,
-0.3903578818,
0.0350604393,
-0.397951901,
0.348369211,
0.1457041204,
0.1761802882,
0.3246871531,
0.7259213328,
0.3548212051,
-0.4508334398,
0.358091265,
0.2413077354,
-0.5671824217,
0.792679131,
-0.8456844687,
0.5122144818,
-0.0863791034,
0.0553461649,
-1.3255707026,
-0.4034617543,
-0.1543602943,
-0.5093409419,
0.1562752277,
-0.4470467567,
-0.1351699531,
-0.4298172295,
-0.1157839745,
-0.0432031229,
0.3176461458,
-0.4709953666,
0.5230042338,
0.6020781994,
-0.5538883209,
-0.8259109259,
-0.3521188498,
0.5581905246,
-0.4664713144,
-0.8803163767,
0.1460434943,
-0.102513358,
-0.7798349857,
0.0039916048,
-0.3308037519,
-0.0862785354,
0.1932194084,
0.0181927793,
0.2458249927,
-0.4909021556,
0.2372934818,
-0.2080132067,
-0.1106701866,
0.0898669809,
0.1322641075,
0.2513384223,
-0.1355068088,
-0.5404894948,
-0.449775964,
0.1908971071,
0.4639132917,
-0.1061372086,
0.283192724,
0.0804426372,
-0.1349631101,
0.17328915,
-1.1921753883,
-0.2749384642,
-0.5011202693,
0.3908499181,
-0.4523061812,
-0.9041774273,
0.267025888,
-0.0951664522,
0.198846221,
0.5058012009,
0.5894821286,
-0.2642982602,
1.1427134275,
0.448127836,
0.0111562144,
-0.2343464643,
0.1875360459,
0.1774728298,
-0.5376619101,
-0.3534122705,
-0.6531719565,
-0.5989238024,
-0.1543692201,
-0.4002528489,
0.2685191035,
-0.0029935653,
-0.1256753206,
0.0681935474,
-0.5182318687,
0.5789731145,
0.114418745,
0.0596860163,
0.2586306036,
-0.1512950212,
-0.0132820401,
-0.2821954191,
-0.7598701119,
-0.8628739119,
0.9930665493,
0.4567012191,
0.9061912894,
0.2002114803,
0.2714393437,
0.1278950274,
0.4939718544,
-0.6614325047,
0.7197951674,
0.2673483193,
-0.9535130262,
-0.2323511094,
-0.4937027395,
-0.8212122321,
0.4516954124,
-0.4509380162,
-0.2727998793,
0.2687536776,
-0.0518935286,
-0.4602489471,
0.6639080644,
-0.6352263689,
0.8188281059,
-0.5823444128,
-0.5314299464,
-0.1930578649,
-0.6813630462,
0.3075479567,
0.0820796117,
0.0271847472,
-0.0893336609,
-0.2226486206,
1.1444290876,
-0.3074029386,
0.7488523126,
-0.1201676652,
-0.3831662536,
0.3339337409,
-0.1597710401,
0.3635219336,
0.0171270035,
-0.2391227633,
-0.191230312,
-0.291041404,
-0.4732446671,
-0.8177745938,
0.5627813935,
-0.8893679976,
-1.5370322466,
-0.1481574476,
-0.3036979437,
-0.2845130265,
-0.1301972866,
-0.0058899596,
0.2699973583,
-0.2831302583,
0.2488539368,
1.0632244349,
0.0303023439,
0.0512362048,
0.7551938295,
0.0296063069,
-0.4524451494,
0.597243011,
0.3014323413,
0.3928201497,
0.2886727154,
0.6425971985,
-0.5387360454,
-0.7107006311,
-0.4083383977,
0.1881911308,
-0.8572720885,
-0.2361556441,
-0.7673856616,
-0.0556030348,
-0.2669390738,
-0.1465398073,
-0.5308551192,
-0.5576914549,
-0.1499203295,
-0.3834864795,
0.2997901142,
0.8513000607,
-0.0040692021,
0.0824299082,
-0.3071294725,
0.0745210275,
0.9458808899,
-0.252505511,
-0.0127659878,
-0.8992062211,
0.2491114438,
0.0335896537,
-0.5035201311,
-1.0732218027,
0.0412663035,
-0.2315656692,
0.7963029742,
0.6076545715,
0.20594953,
0.9566271305,
-0.2138641626,
0.7541148663,
0.0267153848,
-0.7399050593,
0.3310050368,
-0.2210799009,
-0.1128650233,
0.6193472147,
0.5256115198,
-0.2268727273,
-0.2907932103,
-0.7849493623,
-0.6421972513,
0.33162269,
-0.031726025,
0.2331222892,
0.147270605,
0.3365647793,
0.0727461129,
0.1952391714,
-0.7767651081,
0.1417187154,
-0.0042755879,
0.2951921821,
0.1618791372,
-0.4011142254,
-0.5692192316,
-0.2969892919,
0.5038303733,
-0.0047542024,
0.0299685709,
0.2536348999,
0.1009402052,
-0.3747576773,
0.6547785401,
0.5183365345,
0.7990350127,
-0.0666064397,
0.4792371988,
0.4725523591,
0.2834315896,
0.2602021098,
-0.0589485653,
-0.0039542792,
-0.1171908304,
0.4973656237,
0.8408300281,
0.2267491221,
-0.6738156676,
0.6368882656,
-0.0409834906,
-0.5570509434,
0.1557545215,
0.1634314358,
0.612400949,
0.438067764,
0.3091622889,
0.1561555713,
-0.2665984929,
-0.5901204348,
0.3222923577,
0.7275134325,
-0.3440664113,
-0.2577730417,
0.7008657455,
0.4947197139,
-0.4942942858,
0.315322876,
0.0654479936,
-0.9007489085,
0.7241926193,
0.333453238,
0.4480786324,
-0.2665985525,
0.0701135471,
0.0885471925,
0.3146211505,
-0.1461366862,
0.1584770828,
0.1987228245,
-0.8033396006,
-0.3914605379,
-0.1163845509,
-0.8845389485,
0.1759456843,
-0.4374524057,
0.1518859565,
-0.3780852854,
-0.2702241242,
0.2154339701,
0.4882821739,
-0.2609885335,
0.1197686642,
0.1887805909,
0.7777048349,
-0.9150081277,
0.6190502048,
0.68876791,
-0.2335180342,
-0.7595696449,
-0.0316918641,
-0.0584716685,
-0.5653808713,
0.5867140889,
0.0649304092,
-0.2415192276,
-0.2995626032,
-1.0025043488,
-0.6068377495,
0.7091312408,
0.7109940648,
-0.5606057644,
0.180872187,
-0.1602975577,
0.4985965788,
-0.2995669544,
0.613753736,
0.2825468481,
0.7607477307,
0.4984157681,
-0.9820925593,
-0.0706555024,
-0.2838772535,
-0.3910320103,
-0.1865814477,
-0.6923160553,
0.8063249588,
-0.5159364939,
-0.2598262429,
0.0916633159,
0.9296233654,
0.1589367241,
0.2692047358,
0.6300100088,
0.6532641649,
1.123221755,
-0.0414691456,
0.7534356117,
-0.0356346332,
-0.0246382542,
0.9577720761,
-0.5361599326,
0.9285084009,
0.2103021741,
-0.1925561279,
0.5272676349,
0.7317810059,
0.0457755737,
0.2097513676,
0.2780503333,
-0.1745585799,
-0.899774909,
-0.13572146,
-0.3007600009,
0.3438298106,
0.2065882534,
0.2650439143,
-0.223107934,
-0.3601283133,
0.4349011481,
0.5978475809,
-0.1193049401,
0.7789768577,
-0.0590501167,
-0.9626147747,
0.7763515115,
0.1753779203,
0.7231853008,
-0.2369741052,
0.2447766066,
-0.2105254382,
-0.066473648,
-0.3067052662,
-1.04258883,
0.0762349367,
0.1783193797,
0.0621153861,
-0.0690306425,
0.8264228106,
-0.4810536802,
-0.4147796631,
0.0638003498,
0.6755928993,
0.2467517406,
0.2302400768,
-0.8807393312,
-0.1076720878,
-0.0266817324,
-0.3328454494,
0.3290610313,
0.4563587308,
-0.0249448661,
0.8918169141,
0.4552434087,
-0.0297708549,
-0.1519845128,
-0.1500793248,
1.1776944399,
-0.337888062,
-0.0671772063,
-1.0289331675,
0.3604860902,
-0.4240547419,
-0.1281152368,
0.9075618982,
0.5192942619,
0.4815459251,
0.3027449548,
0.6655801535,
0.209966138,
0.5325055718,
-0.3736688793,
0.5916905999,
-0.5350575447,
0.2975904942,
-0.2683149874,
-0.4095836282,
0.0206595026,
0.7468482256,
-0.7651211023,
-0.0392000526,
0.3451429009,
0.9788946509,
0.0697245896,
0.2347036749,
0.248895064,
0.3668265343,
0.3469235301,
0.7294045687,
1.3023536205,
0.0673621967,
0.388349086,
0.0734266564,
-0.1854335815,
0.0371600054,
-0.9025664926,
-1.2693902254,
-0.1763947755,
-0.5090662241,
-0.1680919677,
0.202219218,
0.9094529152,
0.581923306,
-0.4773172438,
-0.3804646134,
0.3072616756,
0.5539178848,
0.0090750307,
-0.1259801239,
0.1942883283,
-0.1422061175,
-0.7044590116,
0.5854939818,
0.1881382316,
-0.1216787696,
-0.3459491134,
-0.2621758878,
-0.2758857608,
0.7982982993,
0.195890218,
0.2696594298,
-0.8172953725,
-0.1972858012,
-0.1534558535,
-0.0883456171,
0.373177737,
0.5651043653,
-0.742076993,
0.3792946339,
0.4194184542,
0.7960394621,
0.1521870196,
0.458919704,
0.5021249652,
-0.3430304825,
-0.1510905921,
0.3469146192,
0.1439996958,
0.5978149176,
-0.1389844269,
0.3718139231,
0.3343810439,
-0.7289905548,
-1.0623520613,
0.1806799471,
-0.7401247621,
-0.3171829581,
1.036431551,
-0.147347182,
-0.0788943172,
-0.3813015819,
-0.2623785734,
-0.1450468451,
-0.2754165828,
0.7647767067,
0.9508413076,
-0.1517757177,
-0.2089637667,
-0.5162127614,
0.3478896618,
0.7319132686,
-0.6738194227,
0.237149179,
0.2151758671,
0.4034019709,
0.1177259237,
0.7356209755,
0.0768168569,
-0.0959955379,
-0.1209355816,
-0.3622186482,
0.0357773006,
-0.3346070647,
-0.071444124,
0.4004030824,
0.3939357102,
0.4595958889
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06766v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06766v1
|
Evaluation Metrics for Text Data Augmentation in NLP
| 2024-02-09T19:59:34 | 2024-02-09T19:59:34 |
Marcellus Amadeus, William Alberto Cruz Castañeda
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent surveys on data augmentation for natural language processing have
reported different techniques and advancements in the field. Several
frameworks, tools, and repositories promote the implementation of text data
augmentation pipelines. However, a lack of evaluation criteria and standards
for method comparison due to different tasks, metrics, datasets, architectures,
and experimental settings makes comparisons meaningless. Also, a lack of
methods unification exists and text data augmentation research would benefit
from unified metrics to compare different augmentation methods. Thus, academics
and the industry endeavor relevant evaluation metrics for text data
augmentation techniques. The contribution of this work is to provide a taxonomy
of evaluation metrics for text augmentation methods and serve as a direction
for a unified benchmark. The proposed taxonomy organizes categories that
include tools for implementation and metrics calculation. Finally, with this
study, we intend to present opportunities to explore the unification and
standardization of text data augmentation metrics.
|
[
-0.3775447607,
-0.4307232499,
0.197625488,
0.5270869136,
-0.2712299228,
0.2423468977,
-0.2087491453,
-0.541975379,
0.2313808948,
0.4038494527,
-0.4062300324,
-0.6543895006,
-0.4328427315,
0.5533245802,
-0.4712305069,
0.9839865565,
-0.0159029905,
0.0484299362,
-0.6608104706,
-0.2912324667,
-0.6541338563,
-0.4750929475,
-0.2598017156,
-0.4627067447,
0.1572380364,
0.2147599459,
0.685449779,
0.4879026413,
1.0167672634,
0.3143343925,
-0.1089088768,
0.3259035647,
0.1340783089,
-0.0485366955,
-0.259316057,
-0.1015100852,
-0.629350245,
-0.0548573956,
0.9374440908,
0.9118372798,
0.0480812117,
0.2302615643,
0.2026321143,
0.7334223986,
-0.7970940471,
-0.0853014961,
-0.4521107078,
0.3843173385,
-0.1676799208,
-0.6070752144,
-0.0027923982,
-0.4716400802,
0.1946703792,
-0.4504449069,
0.0138105741,
-0.0101086162,
0.4138831496,
0.2178935409,
-0.2708462775,
-0.3582601249,
-0.6131893992,
0.8642606139,
-0.8170739412,
0.4690329432,
-0.0451577641,
-0.0530089512,
0.1299325973,
-0.7973765731,
-0.4599511027,
-0.1744216084,
-0.4019653499,
0.0981874391,
-0.3207367659,
0.2437867522,
0.107574068,
0.9227768183,
-0.6022514105,
0.2463465482,
-0.01243822,
-0.1742254049,
0.6576216221,
0.3117577434,
0.3752629757,
-0.4649258554,
-0.5075924397,
-0.0990636051,
-0.0540935621,
-0.1982663572,
0.5137979984,
0.1476455778,
0.0795379058,
0.702229023,
-0.4536499381,
0.8563427925,
-0.4724144042,
-0.0815183371,
0.8086755872,
-0.8012285829,
-0.4021117091,
-0.130994916,
0.9196317196,
0.5848181844,
-0.3487714231,
-0.6322412491,
-0.4359898865,
0.1527249813,
0.433795929,
-0.4895188808,
0.1608176082,
0.0488006435,
-0.424716413,
-0.3404098153,
0.142441377,
-0.8375633359,
-0.2657008767,
-0.4132930636,
0.5631567836,
-0.4175546169,
-0.1456378102,
0.344311744,
-0.4495542347,
0.1054937765,
-0.0360330828,
-0.7867839336,
0.6107609868,
1.037784934,
0.9182243943,
-0.6304196715,
-0.1477080733,
0.0226078369,
-0.3425273299,
-0.2457149178,
0.7934623361,
-0.6261100173,
-0.3815803528,
0.1215002611,
-0.1722686291,
0.0099323234,
-0.4283434451,
1.4191805124,
-0.2989150286,
0.611520648,
0.1445730627,
-0.8192861676,
-0.3505191207,
0.213493675,
-0.4489741027,
1.4315011501,
0.1098813564,
-0.8497712612,
0.7466524839,
-0.9815860391,
-0.401457876,
0.3525831997,
0.045158226,
-0.3412871957,
0.0806010738,
0.3302004337,
0.4478654265,
-0.4578610659,
0.3393297195,
0.1057805195,
-0.5034365654,
0.0823603123,
-0.5114717484,
0.6526945829,
-0.0424686447,
0.0039162985,
0.1038213372,
-0.8961400986,
0.3118902147,
-0.3753055036,
-0.2999303639,
-0.559300065,
-0.1302013248,
0.3584253788,
-0.1228617728,
0.4695910215,
-0.6059451699,
0.1240608618,
-0.7171285152,
0.0176609717,
0.2979665101,
0.1177540198,
0.6620517373,
-0.1640629321,
0.3847125769,
-0.1558281779,
0.1101276875,
-0.231635496,
-0.3792298138,
-0.5503082275,
-0.0158893969,
0.6436868906,
0.5232666135,
-0.6123843193,
1.1088906527,
-0.5668077469,
-0.7980915904,
-0.6313224435,
0.0962889418,
0.5044320822,
0.6067720056,
0.5400922894,
-0.7489962578,
-0.814001441,
-0.8244059086,
-0.4672809541,
-0.0696658418,
-0.5353267193,
-0.1120079532,
0.2530911267,
-0.1810018569,
1.1359535456,
-0.3208699226,
-0.5109211802,
0.0312698148,
0.4530347884,
0.2657238245,
0.501619339,
0.351922214,
-0.7425988913,
-0.0703336746,
-0.0432405546,
-0.6750842929,
-0.275182873,
-0.0295984298,
0.3865897357,
0.1583145559,
0.2719442844,
-0.0848654434,
0.4099784791,
0.6510594487,
-0.1738683432,
0.7276416421,
-0.2552815676,
0.5082269907,
-0.8469481468,
0.1943165362,
0.3105647862,
-0.0563223101,
-0.8006690145,
0.1468769312,
0.1079711989,
0.2190051377,
-0.1186523139,
0.4697375298,
-0.2983573079,
-0.3491900563,
-0.1970148832,
0.5741539001,
0.2460169196,
0.0513809957,
-0.028086096,
0.801869452,
0.5555077791,
-0.6663599014,
0.510435462,
0.203263253,
-0.4597726166,
0.7033521533,
-0.8218038678,
-0.1229860708,
0.0731956884,
0.1022388414,
-0.7787975669,
0.2590395808,
0.1590556055,
-0.7177644372,
0.0236922372,
0.3473043442,
-0.8232858181,
-0.366384238,
-0.489397645,
0.1165699661,
0.4176798761,
-0.4988799691,
0.1066837162,
0.3898891211,
-0.0329314806,
-0.8096314073,
-0.6768309474,
0.4484636188,
-0.3265989721,
-0.5142587423,
0.8088574409,
-0.1205024868,
-0.0516305715,
-0.0348824188,
-0.0611086264,
-0.0724580586,
-0.0839957371,
-0.0746889114,
0.2162446678,
-0.1580165625,
0.3878647983,
0.0523940474,
-0.2312094718,
0.065301612,
-0.2366969585,
0.2144133896,
-0.0785094127,
-0.3229837716,
-0.3162223995,
0.1179657578,
-0.0565556958,
-0.1177087575,
0.4469189942,
0.9045647383,
-0.3233041167,
0.3275158107,
-0.5500329137,
-0.0722259581,
-0.3830192387,
0.4042088091,
-0.2263519019,
-0.8162254691,
0.206208095,
-0.1718973517,
0.300558567,
0.6124474406,
0.2333949804,
0.1548548043,
1.0322397947,
0.7310141921,
-0.011847063,
0.2226522863,
0.0950862467,
0.1552301496,
-1.1919324398,
-0.1590893418,
-0.8695569038,
-0.2817384899,
-0.7285447121,
-0.420239836,
0.0963823199,
0.168690756,
0.1691673547,
0.5711331367,
-1.0370844603,
0.3823384345,
0.178646192,
-0.2889186144,
0.7549000382,
0.1359359771,
-0.1933431923,
-0.3954733014,
-0.6041041017,
-0.6388277411,
1.1333630085,
0.4469039142,
0.3750694394,
-0.1335538328,
0.438262254,
0.4648151696,
0.2298241407,
-0.8649258614,
0.4806471467,
-0.2957109213,
-0.2997485101,
-0.3615063727,
-0.5436244011,
-0.9824863076,
0.2708883286,
-0.4843874872,
-0.9756461382,
0.1641477048,
-0.341152966,
0.1563200504,
0.148951456,
-0.5682343245,
0.7882911563,
0.0417976789,
0.069213137,
0.066907987,
-0.4385477901,
0.2772094905,
-0.0745778903,
0.1040287763,
0.0117693068,
-0.5208519697,
0.9523556232,
-0.2151988149,
0.3155141175,
0.0727095008,
-0.1033449322,
-0.0383713283,
-0.5589194298,
-0.0282650441,
0.0315606557,
-0.3307967782,
0.356531173,
-0.0474624559,
-0.0167322345,
-0.73953861,
0.5372291803,
-0.301713258,
-0.0931606293,
-0.4205305278,
-0.5065746307,
-0.439517647,
0.0765955225,
0.1288085878,
0.5650504827,
-0.4187481999,
0.359262228,
0.3469143212,
-0.1855954677,
0.6820192337,
0.4003151953,
-0.3215794861,
-0.4326283336,
0.7645710111,
-0.1483715326,
0.0824596435,
0.6408299804,
0.0359732769,
-0.8098350167,
-0.6247609854,
-0.3740895092,
-0.2793435156,
-0.5587128401,
-0.4442975521,
-0.7210326791,
-0.2832045555,
-0.326395005,
-0.0722532421,
-0.0929985419,
-0.6541388631,
-0.259924382,
-0.0204384401,
0.5755035281,
0.3572069108,
-0.0445120744,
0.4433219135,
-0.8917812705,
0.2164768279,
-0.0698430091,
0.7670930624,
0.0332872011,
-0.4808713198,
-0.2620146871,
-0.0239135958,
-0.3367193341,
-0.6223545074,
0.3380112648,
0.1895635426,
0.5850635171,
0.1601406336,
-0.0881029293,
0.7205857635,
-0.410127908,
0.7750360966,
0.4645500779,
-1.0434167385,
0.470664829,
-0.0943578482,
0.2714452446,
0.7086533904,
0.1778537929,
-0.7240142822,
-0.3296118677,
-0.759150207,
-1.0574431419,
0.3411960006,
0.4270112813,
0.3401797414,
0.2814649045,
0.2044220269,
0.1414100975,
0.3558074236,
-0.635325253,
-0.4345575571,
0.2790961564,
-0.0808462948,
-0.1160131097,
0.1073594317,
-0.0506289974,
-0.4143278897,
0.5793353319,
0.0081487261,
0.1094064415,
0.199823454,
-0.0395148546,
0.3139050901,
0.6344090104,
0.1734658778,
0.7348768115,
-0.2587539256,
-0.207127884,
0.2141425163,
-0.6995260715,
0.0402364917,
0.3521848321,
-0.2174509019,
0.5523425937,
0.2705274224,
0.6675948501,
0.2718424499,
-0.5501933098,
0.3703912795,
-0.1990937144,
-0.1533549428,
-0.0435490571,
-0.0136822918,
-0.3644452691,
-0.3259379566,
0.5963900685,
0.2354886532,
0.759370625,
-0.2606263459,
0.4487286806,
0.4065066874,
-0.707390666,
0.1110029519,
0.1873811781,
0.2735979259,
-0.4364554882,
0.1263972074,
-0.399112165,
-0.1347926557,
0.3708327115,
0.400480032,
0.9530171752,
-0.1219020411,
0.2952718735,
0.4540178478,
0.5316882133,
0.2004812956,
0.1612287611,
0.074809283,
-0.6282020211,
-0.697155416,
-0.844632864,
-0.5346602798,
0.0652250722,
-0.6968330741,
0.3852187395,
-0.0458442383,
-0.1483613551,
0.2361186445,
0.3126957119,
-0.5979822278,
0.4481805861,
-0.2625873387,
1.0131063461,
-0.5388900638,
0.2373559475,
0.8564546108,
-0.2809413671,
-0.2711748779,
0.0534122512,
-0.0948536247,
-0.3113349974,
0.1690871865,
0.2575379312,
-0.0116187325,
-0.1432564855,
0.0746074468,
-0.4937700629,
0.8762000203,
-0.155126214,
-0.2622004449,
0.1618708372,
0.3754632771,
0.9040160775,
-0.5543317199,
0.5393201709,
0.8528536558,
0.5829054713,
-0.2346830219,
-1.0098282099,
-0.161298573,
-0.3454834521,
0.3130552769,
0.3190578222,
-0.0246850327,
0.2153137475,
0.3063806593,
-0.3279984593,
0.1375690848,
0.5833002329,
0.0071694548,
0.3537360132,
0.5233290195,
0.8039978743,
0.464816153,
-0.310590595,
0.8897891641,
-0.0895489603,
0.4627722502,
0.944096148,
0.0856263191,
0.6053073406,
0.3937037885,
-0.4507346153,
0.3586890697,
0.570287168,
-0.1125165299,
0.0579465218,
0.1790908277,
-0.2960242033,
0.4089139402,
-0.4587126374,
-0.5068951249,
0.5103622079,
0.4821646214,
-0.2737074792,
-0.2887517214,
-0.0971836373,
-0.13242428,
0.2996757627,
-0.3758229911,
1.0034865141,
-0.1615718603,
-0.5006102324,
0.364500165,
0.3620279729,
1.1255950928,
-0.3967298567,
0.0603902489,
0.0299006533,
-0.1147438809,
-0.6106183529,
-1.1199666262,
0.5873710513,
0.1471248269,
-0.1510349214,
-0.1689603776,
0.727881372,
-0.1705083996,
-0.5040257573,
0.3553294241,
0.41492185,
0.1094090268,
0.0415634736,
-0.8961467743,
-0.0858689398,
-0.2113235891,
0.017728202,
0.1451455802,
0.2521106005,
0.3003271222,
0.4491863847,
0.6421023011,
0.2131793946,
-0.1892225742,
0.4583051205,
0.5842466354,
-0.3931674063,
-0.3572205305,
-0.6837431192,
0.7299466729,
-0.5116349459,
-0.4575265944,
1.0828392506,
0.798641324,
0.7214633822,
0.1076285318,
0.6744346023,
-0.1196378246,
0.7406566739,
-0.4560972452,
0.425792098,
-0.57992208,
0.2929741442,
-0.9107789993,
-1.334759593,
-0.5122205615,
0.2672225237,
-0.2031314224,
-0.0102440277,
0.7428777218,
0.5479475856,
0.0912653655,
0.284013629,
0.1205193028,
-0.3593737185,
-0.1901362836,
-0.0208262019,
0.5032072663,
-0.7877010703,
0.411711365,
-0.2458165288,
-0.2917244732,
-0.0689086094,
-1.112688303,
-0.3959547877,
-0.7776409388,
-0.3835376203,
0.1759016514,
-0.0553668998,
0.441211313,
0.4063891768,
-0.5442298055,
-0.2508991063,
-0.2727201283,
0.3360950649,
-0.3886276186,
-0.375508666,
0.2629801035,
-0.6456466317,
-0.898971498,
0.2786430717,
0.6408748627,
-0.1948763281,
-0.4157217145,
0.1149242446,
-0.1575312018,
-0.0535804965,
0.5877329111,
0.0600955635,
-0.4046296179,
-0.0797364637,
-0.0433481149,
0.1170973629,
0.2865718007,
0.7130002975,
-0.7212851048,
0.6726089716,
0.5705835819,
0.7976011634,
-0.1126438901,
0.1197928339,
0.5069711208,
-1.3346780539,
0.128281191,
0.3907196224,
0.0488550514,
0.564674437,
-0.2177194506,
0.8290783167,
-0.0541631356,
-0.6532786489,
-0.8515910506,
-0.0076076766,
-0.784670651,
0.0197496898,
0.6979150772,
0.107046254,
0.2433760315,
-0.1309541613,
0.0446809977,
0.0720618665,
-0.2800396383,
0.5152615905,
0.657889843,
-0.1915340722,
-0.0426957197,
-0.4932903349,
0.6127011776,
0.3765494823,
-1.2423409224,
-0.1502352506,
0.3883327544,
-0.3253085911,
0.5376242995,
0.5635944009,
-0.4422245324,
0.0595044792,
-0.1035433337,
0.1682415754,
0.4837453961,
-0.0122783575,
-0.5850166082,
-0.0611540005,
-0.282643646,
-0.0588714294
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06738v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06738v1
|
EntGPT: Linking Generative Large Language Models with Knowledge Bases
| 2024-02-09T19:16:27 | 2024-02-09T19:16:27 |
Yifan Ding, Amrit Poudel, Qingkai Zeng, Tim Weninger, Balaji Veeramani, Sanmitra Bhattacharya
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The ability of Large Language Models (LLMs) to generate factually correct
output remains relatively unexplored due to the lack of fact-checking and
knowledge grounding during training and inference. In this work, we aim to
address this challenge through the Entity Disambiguation (ED) task. We first
consider prompt engineering, and design a three-step hard-prompting method to
probe LLMs' ED performance without supervised fine-tuning (SFT). Overall, the
prompting method improves the micro-F_1 score of the original vanilla models by
a large margin, on some cases up to 36% and higher, and obtains comparable
performance across 10 datasets when compared to existing methods with SFT. We
further improve the knowledge grounding ability through instruction tuning (IT)
with similar prompts and responses. The instruction-tuned model not only
achieves higher micro-F1 score performance as compared to several baseline
methods on supervised entity disambiguation tasks with an average micro-F_1
improvement of 2.1% over the existing baseline models, but also obtains higher
accuracy on six Question Answering (QA) tasks in the zero-shot setting. Our
methodologies apply to both open- and closed-source LLMs.
|
[
-0.5400742292,
-1.1298030615,
0.7826613188,
0.0479127541,
-0.1645649672,
-0.003812612,
-0.5744739771,
-0.1546577066,
-0.059571553,
0.3485423028,
-0.5614168644,
-0.7434619069,
-0.4211637974,
0.2510866225,
-0.1581840962,
0.7415599227,
-0.1022075713,
-0.0759209916,
-0.4083739519,
0.2028657347,
-0.4497307837,
-0.0171892792,
-0.7814595699,
-0.2636135221,
0.4343578815,
0.6301854253,
0.5010924339,
0.7761394382,
0.1147933975,
0.2700258195,
-0.3006779253,
0.4072600007,
-0.4422615469,
0.3164875507,
-0.2768951654,
-0.3924470246,
-0.3287829459,
-0.2478839606,
0.5264318585,
0.8179733157,
-0.1853611469,
0.2646680176,
0.1523829103,
0.5489858985,
-0.3985679746,
0.4175500572,
-0.7992568016,
-0.2948483229,
-0.0512327403,
-0.2372983247,
-0.5738711953,
-0.3056668639,
-0.1032727659,
-0.6843877435,
0.445833534,
0.3049651384,
0.7901895046,
0.6545903087,
-0.4146725237,
-0.3358086944,
-0.4792856276,
0.4594702125,
-0.7522721291,
0.5450960994,
0.2868176103,
-0.1337472647,
-0.2598646283,
-0.4471270442,
-0.7032489777,
-0.3731205165,
-0.0497584753,
-0.0783352703,
0.0569931492,
0.4724668562,
0.7586008906,
0.2916190326,
-0.4867876172,
0.306532532,
-0.2806509733,
0.0094491616,
0.3377244771,
-0.1491546929,
0.2056614608,
-0.2475160211,
-0.2567310929,
0.1621898413,
-1.1113631725,
-0.2776027322,
0.3967847228,
0.4006772637,
0.1081245244,
0.7971338034,
-0.4575767219,
0.8857177496,
0.3808741868,
0.0174417067,
0.0952848941,
0.000857149,
-0.4274010956,
0.2195785493,
0.6254093647,
0.3637831509,
0.3253742754,
-0.3740136325,
-0.2661437392,
-0.0518571734,
0.0272756014,
-0.8951970339,
-0.4020749331,
0.0874506012,
-0.0282290485,
-0.1161011606,
-0.1896034032,
-0.776283741,
-0.2426078469,
-0.6993521452,
0.4624432921,
-0.6565338969,
-0.1832853705,
0.1086998954,
0.1176033616,
0.0628806427,
0.3507042229,
-1.0066326857,
-0.0984749049,
0.5905159116,
0.6901262999,
0.062113516,
-0.0277775321,
-0.5591715574,
0.2053763717,
-0.3988632262,
0.6294587255,
-0.5049104095,
-0.2373199463,
-0.0569829941,
-0.0661208183,
-0.0389039665,
-0.5843470097,
0.5495510101,
-0.8374946117,
0.0920977592,
-0.5038989782,
-0.7915425897,
-0.14366135,
0.3196359277,
-0.4486467838,
1.0144078732,
0.0395690501,
-0.6385970116,
0.3871557713,
-0.6796145439,
-0.4140090048,
0.0874743611,
-0.3110349774,
-0.0162717905,
0.1259321868,
0.4923360348,
0.4860247374,
-0.3440066576,
0.6829258204,
-0.1242815778,
-0.3114454448,
-0.3783670068,
-0.3131325543,
0.7346312404,
0.0508098491,
-0.4463112056,
-0.0647291169,
-0.9351618886,
0.060886234,
0.0306059401,
-0.6490544677,
-0.3961282372,
-0.183789894,
-0.4847936034,
0.0377671197,
0.0735583901,
-0.5696370006,
0.3729492724,
-0.5087277889,
0.4081641436,
0.7279062271,
0.1516911089,
0.3610902727,
0.0004584596,
0.2921058536,
0.0198409278,
-0.3203914762,
-0.3465025127,
-0.4799215794,
-1.1027212143,
-0.1585891992,
0.5418515205,
0.476057291,
-1.2452802658,
0.4572206438,
-0.373311162,
-0.3295186162,
-0.50996387,
0.0934763402,
0.2594565749,
0.8993040919,
0.5049540401,
0.1987065524,
-0.4468071759,
-0.8228824735,
-0.0905152783,
-0.4345600009,
-0.3341468275,
0.2831740677,
0.3640201092,
-0.0327292196,
0.786006391,
-0.4977689087,
0.1655829847,
0.1247722954,
0.1451531649,
0.2965109646,
0.4619187117,
0.4324037433,
-0.449329108,
-0.4089314938,
-0.0946329981,
-0.8549113274,
-0.2254781574,
0.190769434,
-0.199710682,
0.1009808704,
0.6330601573,
-1.0467425585,
-0.1268017143,
0.2272421122,
-0.2131751031,
0.3144748509,
-0.0437276699,
0.4415761828,
-1.0049030781,
-0.0923875347,
0.1590452194,
-0.0905700848,
-0.5267757773,
0.2336268425,
0.112919949,
-0.1202899143,
-0.2243088186,
0.2722558379,
-0.6329999566,
0.2741783559,
-0.0969417691,
0.2132494897,
-0.0303917043,
0.5428401232,
-0.1688365936,
0.9312559366,
0.7411158085,
-0.8865675926,
0.6188873053,
0.3384020329,
-0.4414520264,
0.5086025,
-0.6883357763,
0.304836005,
-0.4302635789,
-0.1219070107,
-0.833425343,
-0.4229129255,
0.2371273637,
-0.2925872803,
0.7268947363,
-0.4141198695,
-0.727507174,
-0.1837144792,
0.057641834,
0.1790446192,
0.5553872585,
-0.7307047248,
0.4894752502,
0.0451536328,
-0.3325747848,
-0.3454907537,
-0.3636233807,
0.0256948881,
-0.2625202537,
-0.7829956412,
0.3500618041,
0.0930665657,
-0.3390208483,
0.0411675647,
-0.2341343164,
0.14341259,
0.0890944824,
0.0913316607,
0.2352804244,
-0.611166358,
0.6658419371,
0.2702715993,
0.0815795958,
0.3135153055,
-0.4044894874,
0.3980779946,
0.0222992897,
-0.5669073462,
0.0381435715,
0.07785438,
0.2871774733,
-0.3074908555,
0.8733099699,
0.309168309,
-0.5916352272,
-0.4403165281,
-0.624612391,
-0.3225455284,
-0.456505239,
0.277738899,
-0.5163410306,
-1.2043821812,
0.155014798,
-0.3676148951,
0.1780592501,
0.3769012094,
0.5366808772,
-0.0695815012,
0.7213171721,
0.6225329041,
0.1034920067,
0.2414191961,
0.0900031105,
0.3437254727,
-0.6633759141,
-0.1594153643,
-0.5058964491,
-0.0983997509,
-0.5341549516,
-0.5320507884,
0.495690465,
0.4214175045,
-0.5314279199,
0.1147017851,
-0.3444006741,
0.6260815263,
0.5673823357,
0.2623991072,
0.4393194914,
0.1512256265,
-0.1950160414,
0.1061269268,
-0.8295322061,
-0.5640314817,
1.0587674379,
0.2967287004,
0.7870809436,
0.0925534442,
0.6537463069,
0.0255048834,
0.3455219865,
-0.6366208792,
0.5264834762,
0.1724366397,
-0.4830538332,
-0.5090308189,
-0.5286058784,
-0.4641219378,
0.0474514812,
-0.1027505398,
-0.5515078306,
-0.0457359329,
0.4205154479,
-0.5591635108,
0.3026851714,
-0.8319903612,
0.7291623354,
-0.0724928901,
-0.4245204329,
0.0192935392,
-0.3532323241,
0.5251876712,
0.099634856,
-0.019656444,
-0.0976353064,
0.1685305983,
0.4687610269,
-0.1733943373,
0.7029399276,
-0.3663502336,
-0.3880619109,
0.3570319116,
0.0706995651,
0.7967095375,
0.2541800737,
-0.2222260535,
0.022177808,
-0.4340993464,
-0.2227967978,
-0.6425783634,
1.004267931,
-0.5083862543,
-0.97120893,
0.1118917763,
-0.3775091767,
-0.5833038688,
0.1644790024,
0.2187909931,
0.3495349884,
-0.0609766394,
0.2240912765,
1.3657133579,
-0.3371503353,
0.1561026424,
0.6234941483,
-0.0590892471,
-0.0082792174,
0.6953957677,
0.0178650171,
0.2634401321,
0.5829373598,
-0.1891535819,
-0.3809377551,
-0.5675680041,
-0.9828599095,
0.2054465264,
-0.8552931547,
-0.4072242975,
-0.7151677608,
-0.0861008614,
-0.4419507384,
0.0913416371,
-0.2510618269,
-0.1549118012,
-0.3793181777,
-0.4521866441,
0.5519000292,
0.6126336455,
0.2294873744,
0.1591972709,
-0.6180973053,
0.3212487102,
0.3230163753,
0.6004792452,
-0.1053020209,
-0.6020852327,
-0.0687712356,
0.1468478143,
-0.1936309189,
-1.0716979504,
-0.063647449,
0.2759540379,
0.5118661523,
0.1873299778,
0.1784201711,
0.6093640924,
-0.7189618349,
0.7025782466,
0.0018680113,
-0.8967121243,
0.7870671749,
-0.4482449293,
-0.0313172601,
0.3440396488,
0.4151734114,
-0.2930777073,
-0.1934386194,
-0.5083432794,
-0.8586158752,
0.6207353473,
0.128095001,
0.0562517084,
-0.3268911839,
0.490436554,
-0.0762546659,
0.4119887352,
-0.422655642,
-0.3991404474,
0.0333023593,
-0.3425221443,
0.0538280159,
-0.2874515057,
-0.138645038,
-0.1510254741,
1.0220962763,
-0.403137207,
0.0930571258,
0.1082330421,
-0.3267546892,
-0.3207504749,
0.5116326213,
0.360976547,
0.7263781428,
-0.0251168851,
0.2890430689,
0.3838362694,
-0.0146981124,
0.2098855823,
0.1850795448,
-0.5138937235,
0.1593642831,
0.1221691892,
1.0611066818,
0.171369791,
-0.4868749082,
0.2866351008,
0.3046529591,
-0.0754195824,
0.0691998452,
0.2018625885,
0.3196522892,
0.2890624404,
0.1359204054,
-0.1653009653,
-0.0362551697,
-0.2797938287,
0.1618932486,
0.2729488909,
-0.1520714164,
-0.1556690633,
0.7927097082,
0.3463018835,
-0.037897557,
0.8281761408,
-0.383112222,
-0.273635298,
0.5883108974,
0.5361001492,
0.6314585805,
-0.197875008,
0.2121914774,
0.6919888854,
0.6669035554,
-0.2362141907,
0.1792387664,
0.0579953901,
-0.6612814069,
-0.7615938783,
-0.784743607,
-0.2124201804,
0.3270632625,
-0.6194435358,
0.367413193,
-0.2620028555,
0.1305361986,
-0.0828126073,
-0.3042163253,
-0.8859266639,
0.2621341646,
0.1908222437,
1.0502072573,
-0.8054776788,
0.5990418792,
0.921554029,
-0.473454237,
-1.1123412848,
0.0457641743,
-0.2280940861,
-0.725851655,
0.6560612917,
0.0957194194,
0.1504534334,
0.6331289411,
-0.6791122556,
-0.8332802057,
1.1927268505,
0.7622778416,
-0.9009952545,
-0.1814883798,
-0.0381272137,
0.4454336762,
-0.1266666651,
0.2684327662,
0.6692298651,
0.4318081141,
0.0041308133,
-0.8980231881,
0.1844783723,
-0.0711900964,
-0.0244793799,
0.2438732088,
-0.514177084,
0.7034833431,
-0.3220242858,
-0.4292690158,
-0.2337623835,
0.8027811646,
0.3466379941,
0.1328202337,
0.4835212827,
0.8480980992,
0.9114780426,
-0.3188994229,
0.6868501902,
-0.5317124128,
0.4056782722,
1.0780344009,
-0.2963562012,
0.5230112076,
0.5498542786,
-0.1499008238,
0.3392039537,
0.6543158293,
0.0048680743,
0.37669155,
0.3505733013,
-0.4123039246,
-0.4549222291,
-0.090527676,
-0.3351547718,
0.1503272057,
0.3301305771,
-0.4780203998,
-0.401612401,
-0.0254408512,
-0.0496141575,
0.0616641752,
-0.4345971346,
0.8018239141,
0.0196837913,
-0.8507584929,
0.5931641459,
0.1825893968,
0.597053349,
-0.3110963106,
-0.2715096474,
-0.2742333412,
-0.2695401013,
-0.1283618659,
-0.7059916854,
0.0112867011,
0.2680772543,
-0.4617378712,
-0.2558689117,
0.7158706188,
-0.7230821252,
-0.2293532789,
-0.0457150191,
0.724222362,
0.0442800447,
-0.2536981702,
-0.2654284835,
-0.0920447707,
0.1514245272,
-0.4045552313,
0.1856374145,
0.8661103249,
-0.0351605192,
0.5854740143,
0.5157682896,
-0.0480512567,
0.2595223784,
0.1919716895,
1.0413014889,
-0.4976539612,
-0.2114430666,
-1.0053073168,
0.4547268152,
0.0699517876,
-0.116907835,
0.663143456,
0.5569768548,
1.0882271528,
-0.3036685288,
0.8680002689,
-0.3392885923,
0.4830952883,
-0.9242569208,
0.4810522795,
-0.219925493,
0.4792201221,
0.0752720684,
-1.0229173899,
0.0636599436,
0.4242044985,
-0.2182085365,
0.0373991132,
0.5853199959,
1.0886987448,
-0.1631942689,
-0.0328327976,
0.3219844103,
0.454741627,
0.1817158312,
0.4923011661,
0.7954031825,
-0.2961398661,
0.3142177165,
-0.1737882197,
-0.1591404676,
0.0414783098,
-0.9042442441,
-1.038222909,
-0.2855601013,
-0.5048555732,
-0.2940990031,
0.1992207766,
1.1716319323,
0.3541362882,
-0.8559660912,
0.3461866379,
-0.2870194912,
0.2137212306,
0.0862717479,
-0.2005354613,
0.2900519967,
-0.4339917898,
-0.8194568753,
0.6176296473,
0.1800254136,
-0.0684096888,
-0.2255199254,
0.0656122789,
0.0143114161,
-0.2278622389,
0.5767130852,
-0.0344703272,
-0.8412243128,
-0.4675038755,
0.087313585,
-0.0607744753,
-0.1050110012,
0.6152270436,
-0.7378932834,
0.3787039518,
0.3651479483,
0.8920824528,
0.1782089621,
0.1235953346,
0.5286130905,
-1.1815919876,
-0.1445990801,
0.1794638932,
0.3704372644,
0.5560420156,
-0.497385025,
0.3648641706,
0.2849209607,
-0.5201098919,
-0.7326827049,
0.2921463847,
-0.6083990932,
0.0356608853,
1.3441514969,
-0.2354571968,
-0.0283612646,
0.043268349,
-0.1401712149,
0.5082685947,
-0.3270411789,
0.78484869,
0.7836614847,
0.1071465611,
-0.3172303438,
-0.7452992797,
0.5835154653,
0.1873310208,
-0.8082721829,
0.0692695752,
0.7527084947,
0.5381764174,
0.0717759877,
0.4234037995,
0.2280923873,
-0.0298732072,
0.0556149185,
0.2382476479,
-0.434402138,
-0.3785533905,
-0.128231883,
0.2204844505,
0.2777991891,
-0.1214717254
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06733v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06733v3
|
NICE: To Optimize In-Context Examples or Not?
| 2024-02-09T19:09:19 | 2024-06-06T12:16:55 |
Pragya Srivastava, Satvik Golechha, Amit Deshpande, Amit Sharma
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Recent work shows that in-context learning and optimization of in-context
examples (ICE) can significantly improve the accuracy of large language models
(LLMs) on a wide range of tasks, leading to an apparent consensus that ICE
optimization is crucial for better performance. However, most of these studies
assume a fixed or no instruction provided in the prompt. We challenge this
consensus by investigating the necessity of optimizing ICE when task-specific
instructions are provided and find that there are many tasks for which it
yields diminishing returns. In particular, using a diverse set of tasks and a
systematically created instruction set with gradually added details, we find
that as the prompt instruction becomes more detailed, the returns on ICE
optimization diminish. To characterize this behavior, we introduce a
task-specific metric called Normalized Invariability to Choice of Examples
(NICE) that quantifies the learnability of tasks from a given instruction, and
provides a heuristic to help decide whether to optimize instructions or ICE for
a new task. Given a task, the proposed metric can reliably predict the utility
of optimizing ICE compared to using random ICE. Our code is available at
https://github.com/microsoft/nice-icl.
|
[
-0.20089145,
-0.610039413,
0.4348100722,
0.0132052805,
-0.4137513638,
-0.2916489244,
-0.3995675445,
-0.0408634655,
-0.2950930595,
0.2460086495,
-0.5000169277,
-0.6957466006,
-0.3108028471,
0.040744625,
-0.3573955297,
1.573564887,
-0.0091028772,
0.0221118536,
-0.873011291,
-0.0843622312,
-0.484123826,
-0.3647517264,
-0.7956405282,
-0.2135019749,
0.2275473177,
1.094623208,
0.4185470343,
0.569347322,
0.6580478549,
0.1921455115,
0.0584331863,
0.2452298254,
-0.7092912197,
0.16470249,
0.0683584437,
-0.5923452973,
-0.052552186,
0.2124290913,
0.6732193828,
0.6587065458,
-0.082299158,
0.3014701009,
0.3538792431,
0.4579330981,
-0.787453711,
0.2943201661,
-0.3909573555,
0.0172926504,
-0.2007794827,
-0.1828054488,
-0.1305912882,
-0.2470932305,
0.2792998552,
-0.5436744094,
0.0463590249,
0.031649366,
0.6961141825,
0.4023291171,
-0.1220498011,
-0.4006118476,
-0.5574928522,
1.2530463934,
-0.7723095417,
0.1353725195,
0.4710134268,
0.1879610568,
-0.2198075652,
-0.7037702799,
-0.3362649381,
-0.5556278229,
-0.100459069,
0.0407113135,
-0.319123894,
0.0767288208,
0.1128715873,
0.2114826441,
-0.1222142279,
0.1956796646,
-0.0377113894,
-0.1878396124,
0.382171452,
0.4170833826,
0.4593617916,
-0.0675333962,
-0.1908542067,
0.0488259457,
-0.6560041308,
0.7393860221,
0.3698517382,
0.4395186007,
-0.6513490081,
0.2512351274,
-0.1549505144,
0.9278594851,
0.2502775788,
-0.4364757538,
0.191041559,
-0.2258618623,
0.0745244846,
-0.272950381,
0.3264928758,
0.3673347533,
0.0276590511,
-0.6614875793,
-0.4668534398,
-0.1711481363,
0.2190973759,
-1.0153734684,
-0.2197908163,
0.1401806623,
-0.3005259633,
0.0584411211,
-0.1833451092,
-0.1383199543,
0.2644930482,
-0.6526966691,
0.2596405149,
-0.407975167,
0.4980227649,
-0.1176443174,
-0.1168593615,
0.1069838777,
0.3665242791,
-0.6782880425,
0.4247725308,
0.9387956858,
0.5668955445,
-0.4686141312,
-0.3520751595,
-1.1950908899,
-0.0721231028,
-0.48967278,
0.7070350647,
-0.7757723927,
-0.1892279088,
0.0120292781,
-0.1125588939,
0.0827211365,
-0.5393301249,
0.4862229526,
-0.2739518285,
0.4556128681,
-0.1463284045,
-0.7243234515,
0.0061479555,
0.2487415373,
-0.2811660469,
0.6956086755,
0.2870962024,
-0.6225204468,
0.5621619821,
-0.8224135041,
-0.6268507242,
0.1591027677,
-0.3886790872,
-0.3595202267,
0.3877696097,
-0.3425019085,
0.7137053609,
-0.4505463839,
-0.0104604503,
-0.1796322912,
-0.6922357678,
0.0657610446,
-0.1915571392,
0.6436704993,
0.3499004841,
-0.549949944,
0.0288371984,
-0.6242892742,
0.063813746,
-0.3682789505,
-0.6292881966,
-0.6358266473,
0.0521350913,
-0.0338221639,
-0.0610667877,
0.216764167,
-0.5619712472,
0.0751943216,
-0.4326657653,
0.2527809441,
0.756401062,
-0.0715768412,
0.6340333819,
-0.0358296223,
0.5872379541,
0.1876460314,
0.1806048751,
0.2412632704,
-0.3779092133,
-0.4347106516,
-0.7181668878,
0.1026722491,
0.481300652,
-0.7910867929,
-0.0801048875,
0.0304911844,
-0.1394062787,
-0.4060520828,
0.3627387881,
0.818297565,
0.6575438976,
0.21164231,
-0.2986124158,
-0.1943541169,
-1.2160730362,
-0.4468560517,
0.3096977174,
-0.1291637719,
0.663556397,
0.32013309,
-0.1798909605,
1.0003970861,
-0.3647733927,
0.0470332131,
-0.2874756455,
0.0529826544,
0.3953118026,
0.4700384438,
0.7743476033,
-0.7459289432,
-0.7588199377,
-0.2316537201,
-0.7513059378,
0.0587295741,
0.0244354699,
-0.0272464603,
0.0118435621,
0.6226425171,
-0.2719019055,
0.3414950073,
0.3637219965,
-0.3051255047,
0.2452937365,
-0.3337991834,
0.0939534977,
-0.8380718231,
-0.1634114981,
0.1260651648,
-0.1731732041,
-0.7434440851,
0.3147603571,
0.0701517761,
-0.1708675325,
-0.5883899331,
0.8184241056,
-0.4180894792,
0.2559890449,
-0.2618788481,
-0.0189323761,
-0.3616200686,
0.5025246143,
-0.3193483949,
0.8842231631,
0.7763479352,
-0.8698695302,
-0.0621080361,
0.1878379434,
-0.5039919615,
0.8143703341,
-0.5260346532,
0.3734093606,
-0.3481559753,
-0.1305782497,
-0.7750579715,
-0.2523165941,
0.1333078444,
-0.0558452569,
0.5060860515,
-0.1014052853,
-0.4017336667,
-0.0885328203,
-0.3205165565,
0.2932187617,
0.5984837413,
-0.7105020285,
0.1984471828,
0.2870162427,
0.2415718585,
-0.5475292802,
-0.4518403113,
-0.0399010628,
-0.4017321169,
-0.234805584,
0.4472321868,
-0.6205226779,
-0.6020183563,
0.010355317,
-0.2400953025,
-0.2231212556,
0.4330876172,
0.19950445,
0.0853948295,
-0.165305078,
0.1745945215,
-0.0725594461,
-0.1141878814,
-0.1521908194,
-0.36991328,
0.10579741,
-0.3892335892,
-0.0593530573,
-0.6731203794,
0.5051926374,
0.1983467788,
0.070548296,
0.6871170998,
0.4929553866,
-0.3841486275,
-0.395938158,
-0.2531654239,
-0.3439412117,
-0.4822435677,
0.3843120933,
-0.2150360048,
-1.0436451435,
0.1454406381,
0.3539328575,
0.4951432049,
-0.0391427539,
0.1987499893,
-0.3141569197,
0.9871641397,
0.8508507013,
-0.2024592906,
0.5629838705,
-0.2547093928,
0.480779767,
-0.6784308553,
0.0165291578,
-0.562605083,
-0.361605823,
-0.6366709471,
-0.2110527754,
0.5631793141,
0.0668659285,
-0.3531807065,
0.1629743725,
-0.4537526071,
0.6391603351,
0.8385161757,
0.1420984566,
-0.0930127874,
0.1829898059,
-0.0566454045,
-0.0938164368,
-0.7850134373,
-0.514839828,
0.9453186989,
-0.0207616277,
0.6076429486,
-0.0177678522,
0.977894485,
0.3037764132,
0.4128620327,
-0.724309504,
0.5427833796,
-0.6577236056,
-0.3191863298,
-0.3091566861,
-0.5044721961,
-0.9121171236,
-0.3494791985,
0.1650099754,
-0.790188849,
-0.128301993,
0.5486031175,
-0.4079351723,
0.0111141978,
-0.7600631714,
0.7732000947,
0.0235978737,
-0.4941542447,
-0.220111385,
-0.5614234805,
-0.010296437,
0.1605880409,
0.2562032938,
-0.0372012332,
-0.1640185267,
0.8120039105,
-0.2782277465,
0.9407002926,
-0.3409639001,
0.119522348,
0.4789019823,
-0.1403872818,
0.5666717887,
-0.0189580228,
-0.1286989599,
-0.098540619,
-0.2241428345,
-0.6677168608,
-0.7703332901,
0.8841063976,
-0.6994720101,
-0.665761292,
0.0770055577,
-0.7063604593,
-0.2878613174,
-0.1742088795,
0.3999505341,
0.8563441038,
0.0610133186,
0.3557937443,
0.6018351316,
-0.0050146501,
0.6560194492,
0.4429142177,
0.563701272,
-0.0352240987,
1.0769665241,
-0.015357065,
0.2222979218,
0.608332634,
0.4629775882,
0.2268567085,
-0.8229038119,
-0.2725015283,
-0.01655774,
-0.8902615309,
-0.2187729776,
-0.206107229,
0.2226861715,
0.0958931372,
-0.3699145913,
-0.2621026933,
-0.3483183086,
-0.8172037601,
-0.0001214386,
0.257537663,
0.5420003533,
-0.1226944029,
0.2589147389,
-0.4716944993,
0.0314782634,
0.3909941912,
0.2343358099,
-0.0510253347,
-0.6038800478,
-0.6499813199,
0.1100477204,
-0.2674643397,
-0.2642362714,
0.1388082355,
0.4697195888,
0.8714665771,
0.6043909788,
0.00719934,
0.5692933202,
-0.5646048188,
0.8624360561,
0.244434312,
-0.8465443254,
0.3530937731,
-0.1780468673,
0.4802761972,
0.7162802815,
0.6316766143,
-0.3907851875,
-0.54631567,
-0.5809847116,
-0.8167742491,
0.6365073323,
0.054762084,
0.5867179036,
-0.3575317562,
0.7414362431,
0.3362652063,
0.4573292136,
-0.3904756308,
-0.5689829588,
-0.0107563389,
-0.1230437234,
-0.3630962968,
-0.1311273873,
-0.2958021164,
-0.1727325022,
0.5198611021,
-0.3258934021,
0.4351479411,
-0.0749199539,
-0.0295980573,
0.075435847,
0.2248350978,
0.6128274202,
0.7856335044,
-0.1716603041,
0.1701730192,
0.1036333293,
-0.4694176614,
-0.1674414873,
-0.1438371688,
-0.3910807371,
-0.2321114987,
0.4038267136,
0.751704216,
0.4671082199,
-0.6394850612,
0.5149296522,
-0.0151121728,
-0.000517341,
-0.0370445475,
0.400617063,
-0.2667952478,
0.1696314812,
0.3016602397,
0.1201567426,
0.3179902732,
-0.7702866197,
0.2535118759,
0.7674106956,
-0.6762574315,
-0.3858971894,
0.3457443714,
0.1444088817,
-0.7640216351,
0.9101134539,
-0.4998639226,
-0.3372354805,
0.5816192627,
0.6024777889,
0.923545599,
0.1487588733,
0.1803922504,
0.2454428077,
-0.1047309265,
0.3286918402,
0.2796996832,
-0.1714508384,
-0.585511148,
-0.0749659389,
-0.404202342,
-0.3818120062,
0.0802692547,
-0.6382874846,
0.122671403,
-0.4490524232,
0.0996675566,
-0.2962470949,
0.0020339743,
-1.1359957457,
0.3071995676,
0.0088890679,
0.6972960234,
-0.7608931065,
0.4992922544,
0.6402693987,
-0.203178525,
-0.7679468989,
0.3117523789,
-0.1555188298,
-0.666598022,
0.6084466577,
0.0077486723,
-0.1547311395,
-0.2266282439,
-1.033741951,
-0.7151885033,
0.7308854461,
0.6226311326,
-0.2966685891,
-0.0395934209,
-0.1633924991,
0.5057204962,
-0.7232003212,
0.2000481486,
0.3987109959,
0.3044624627,
-0.2553223968,
-0.6596036553,
-0.024694033,
-0.2463262975,
-0.044704698,
0.039529413,
-0.5936406851,
0.7442852259,
-0.4839881957,
0.0155856069,
-0.0307138022,
0.6419457197,
0.0469785817,
0.575483501,
0.5559390187,
0.3711923361,
0.6324150562,
0.267270416,
1.5318119526,
-0.1209842041,
0.0491620451,
1.1962176561,
0.2094706148,
0.713963449,
0.8032971025,
0.0327475108,
0.5907735825,
0.7905519009,
0.2147714347,
1.0331660509,
0.3987815678,
-0.3212889135,
-0.3707436323,
-0.2096287012,
0.0640209094,
0.3865551949,
0.0680429488,
0.0055326833,
-0.2567524612,
0.1683534831,
0.3339083493,
0.1292973161,
-0.388749361,
0.6180618405,
0.084900707,
-0.8322745562,
0.7249878049,
-0.1481628418,
0.672516048,
-0.543379128,
-0.2252889872,
-0.4966192544,
0.0531776734,
-0.2377961725,
-0.3903731108,
0.1016986817,
0.0537543334,
-0.3767141104,
-0.153649196,
0.2254601717,
-0.1472323984,
-0.3080384135,
-0.0255828444,
0.3303342164,
0.4849684536,
0.3622689247,
-0.4777873755,
-0.4923417866,
0.2068508565,
-0.2296199948,
0.6985244155,
0.3347349167,
-0.1336673945,
0.7588943839,
0.4377123415,
-0.2342235744,
-0.2942221165,
-0.1344844699,
0.7742544413,
-0.1924993545,
-0.4764559567,
-0.7839359045,
0.6715132594,
0.0351786613,
-0.6083043218,
0.9434738755,
0.6880304813,
1.0406178236,
-0.2334836125,
0.7588561177,
0.0976039991,
0.3739108443,
-0.5469886065,
0.2772797048,
-0.877528131,
0.3642992675,
-0.2775069177,
-0.8415888548,
-0.1553078592,
0.4000819027,
-0.4995429814,
0.0318602137,
0.8188486695,
0.6618978977,
-0.3553986847,
-0.1462625414,
0.490203619,
-0.1052137464,
0.1169543564,
0.3573793769,
0.5846057534,
0.1434353739,
0.4219200015,
-0.5119888783,
-0.4486890137,
-0.1751742065,
-1.1801415682,
-0.8834987879,
-0.7416326404,
-0.5918686986,
-0.1070677936,
0.4067957699,
1.0907844305,
0.9014704227,
-0.8433223367,
-0.4962196052,
-0.0290407725,
0.207372874,
-0.4038996994,
-0.1723863482,
0.487344116,
-0.8002175093,
-0.735668838,
0.4754035175,
0.165961802,
-0.0570266843,
0.1355143785,
-0.177516669,
0.2136233449,
0.0931343585,
0.4860432744,
0.3023459613,
-0.4509001076,
-0.5051600337,
0.0244910307,
-0.0762082785,
0.0628253445,
0.7844628096,
-0.4850178957,
0.2473032475,
0.3590959907,
0.6648111939,
0.4377010763,
-0.3156414628,
0.5534870028,
-0.8170326948,
-0.0184735265,
0.3623938262,
0.3142089844,
0.4032091796,
-0.5145970583,
0.3569927812,
-0.1059198231,
-0.6022738814,
-0.841063261,
0.1993373632,
-0.6690264344,
-0.2028424442,
1.130328536,
-0.5368279815,
-0.2988041341,
0.0169038773,
0.1823152155,
-0.0650024861,
-0.7001023293,
0.8952739239,
0.5161568522,
-0.5112386346,
0.1579663157,
-0.5647337437,
0.8846723437,
0.5680120587,
-0.8551707268,
-0.1980809122,
0.35944435,
0.5110298991,
-0.030206684,
0.3815567195,
0.463978678,
0.4798464477,
-0.3254909813,
-0.2249293923,
-0.0235257167,
-0.5297036767,
-0.1759632081,
0.0420349762,
0.1749702096,
-0.4035789073
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06627v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06627v3
|
Feedback Loops With Language Models Drive In-Context Reward Hacking
| 2024-02-09T18:59:29 | 2024-06-06T21:39:09 |
Alexander Pan, Erik Jones, Meena Jagadeesan, Jacob Steinhardt
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Language models influence the external world: they query APIs that read and
write to web pages, generate content that shapes human behavior, and run system
commands as autonomous agents. These interactions form feedback loops: LLM
outputs affect the world, which in turn affect subsequent LLM outputs. In this
work, we show that feedback loops can cause in-context reward hacking (ICRH),
where the LLM at test-time optimizes a (potentially implicit) objective but
creates negative side effects in the process. For example, consider an LLM
agent deployed to increase Twitter engagement; the LLM may retrieve its
previous tweets into the context window and make them more controversial,
increasing engagement but also toxicity. We identify and study two processes
that lead to ICRH: output-refinement and policy-refinement. For these
processes, evaluations on static datasets are insufficient -- they miss the
feedback effects and thus cannot capture the most harmful behavior. In
response, we provide three recommendations for evaluation to capture more
instances of ICRH. As AI development accelerates, the effects of feedback loops
will proliferate, increasing the need to understand their role in shaping LLM
behavior.
|
[
-0.1740961671,
-0.5678782463,
0.5937299728,
0.1033284888,
0.0968572497,
0.193625927,
-0.078278318,
-0.5736467838,
-0.0326760374,
0.5227383971,
-0.7289662361,
-0.2042947114,
-0.5112175941,
0.0633666217,
-0.4090776145,
1.4331688881,
-0.0633898303,
-0.0223471206,
-0.3154214025,
0.1399693787,
-0.6375660896,
-0.7167677879,
-0.6969846487,
-0.8363107443,
0.7569175959,
0.4715209901,
0.2617930174,
0.1373288929,
0.5029723048,
0.2288141698,
0.1150825694,
-0.0614100844,
-0.8336385489,
0.221372053,
-0.225820452,
-0.4612873793,
-0.1750486344,
-0.0484060645,
0.2143690288,
0.0721177161,
0.0132934339,
0.1712327003,
0.2976370752,
0.489590466,
-0.6726811528,
0.0751656741,
-0.4961004555,
-0.3513125181,
-0.1029081047,
-0.7310007215,
-0.4757081866,
-0.5307325125,
-0.0303242654,
-0.1473135352,
-0.3390529156,
-0.1616344154,
0.6141495705,
0.3408260643,
-0.3623291254,
-0.6167343855,
-0.7513710856,
0.684348166,
-0.7248598337,
-0.007887722,
0.3862332404,
-0.0416536778,
-0.4826181531,
-0.3624682426,
-0.3611869514,
-0.5149307847,
-0.0753914788,
-0.1292458326,
-0.1426368803,
0.2608436346,
0.2530625463,
-0.0136063602,
-0.0951898918,
0.1223002523,
-0.3748659492,
-0.179535836,
0.6635606885,
0.3663789928,
0.4193021059,
0.0603417791,
-0.1959255189,
-0.2150052935,
-1.2227884531,
0.6260986924,
0.530553937,
0.4246562719,
-0.0223526917,
0.4728775024,
-0.0460173674,
0.4469144344,
-0.2276380062,
-0.2195193768,
-0.1556323916,
-0.3100615442,
0.0399540141,
0.0148451654,
0.4889367819,
0.4149034917,
0.2287844718,
-0.2625999451,
-0.4712287188,
0.0612532198,
0.3580584526,
-0.8312700391,
0.0469583347,
0.3776736259,
-0.3354713023,
-0.6010215878,
0.245390445,
-0.4750075936,
-0.4767932892,
-0.2877305746,
0.4253964424,
-0.2544332743,
-0.0364062563,
-0.1903425455,
-0.5349292755,
0.1939999759,
0.2087702155,
-0.7038572431,
0.476544261,
0.7580451965,
0.7975227237,
-0.2321284264,
-0.5099284649,
-0.655170083,
0.2540733218,
-0.1681098938,
0.6969310045,
-0.5279570818,
-0.5186790228,
0.1621908545,
-0.1258152276,
0.3043556809,
-0.5902401805,
0.0030370792,
-0.5323186517,
-0.071889542,
-0.5416458249,
-0.3485429883,
0.1674651057,
0.5058131218,
-0.369289577,
0.7858030796,
0.0799633563,
-0.6497132778,
0.4997268915,
-0.9946808815,
-0.6152888536,
-0.0892885029,
0.0674574673,
0.0258797333,
0.1277021021,
-0.0666412711,
0.2412085086,
-0.3080713153,
0.1917760372,
-0.3222914636,
-0.8526821136,
0.6205790639,
-0.1992699504,
0.7926650047,
-0.0995585173,
-0.6898831129,
0.3892111182,
-0.4221017063,
-0.0880878717,
-0.0815043226,
-0.5434190035,
-0.4475296736,
0.1933714151,
-0.1939818412,
0.2929507494,
-0.0041740662,
-0.5160588026,
0.240752086,
-0.1440551132,
0.6273580194,
1.2837926149,
0.3644359708,
0.3094006777,
-0.5527145863,
0.7263814211,
-0.1291765571,
0.1604461521,
-0.4345009029,
-0.287473619,
-0.4702887833,
0.0143988207,
-0.099865675,
0.5798124671,
-0.4647019506,
-0.0559675246,
0.0042591514,
-0.2992139161,
-0.3437684476,
0.0252255294,
0.4837942123,
0.3750682473,
0.1030819044,
-0.087545827,
-0.3547773957,
-0.6766489148,
-0.5077728033,
-0.3039268851,
0.0043122303,
0.5248764157,
0.6839793921,
-0.4180780649,
0.9059606194,
-0.1535725594,
-0.2214240283,
-0.198141396,
0.1383922994,
0.0614898168,
0.4864651561,
0.2377748638,
-0.3139878511,
-0.1068275571,
-0.3381589353,
-0.4533867538,
-0.416338414,
-0.2735010386,
0.0537676886,
0.2590247989,
0.5827006102,
-0.2413064539,
0.4156186879,
0.377671361,
-0.5000215173,
0.7277746201,
-0.0150147174,
0.2632840276,
-0.4768593907,
0.2041368484,
-0.1805422604,
-0.1437719464,
-0.2853195667,
0.3327649236,
-0.0039185798,
-0.0387005806,
-0.533782959,
0.6949636936,
-0.2605345547,
0.0060159396,
-0.3430907428,
-0.0179477204,
-0.0000754232,
0.4063610137,
-0.4023177326,
1.0056756735,
0.2510145903,
-0.8348376155,
0.3308241069,
-0.1898462921,
-0.3128548861,
0.2964467406,
-0.6572657824,
0.336836338,
0.0671842024,
0.5602734089,
-0.7993984222,
-0.3163481951,
0.1792734265,
-0.4827833772,
0.1685494483,
0.2379091978,
-0.5385278463,
-0.2782342732,
-0.8146429658,
0.3964194059,
0.3213156462,
-0.5601346493,
-0.051101204,
0.4605128765,
0.221023187,
-0.6863600612,
-1.0027555227,
0.1380412877,
-0.3016189337,
-0.417229712,
0.4086416066,
-0.1706440151,
-0.599394083,
-0.0571681559,
0.1466839314,
0.4665346146,
0.3600212336,
0.3472479284,
0.1204285175,
0.2075022459,
-0.045184359,
-0.0717988461,
0.0132025275,
0.5139570236,
-0.0731734112,
0.6476966143,
-0.0730621517,
-0.4624400437,
-0.4718922973,
0.3228096664,
0.6264585853,
0.1382786185,
0.6438940763,
0.0700457171,
-0.1757695973,
-0.3075348139,
-0.2351406515,
-0.650654614,
-0.4913865328,
0.236153692,
-0.1415812671,
-1.055095911,
0.593940258,
-0.2487237155,
-0.0301472712,
-0.0287683308,
0.7324388623,
-0.0022616705,
1.26125741,
0.83648175,
-0.2499815673,
0.6447762251,
-0.3395073414,
0.2927798033,
-0.9679964185,
-0.3995697796,
-0.3489390314,
-0.3545739055,
-0.7145888805,
-0.0249325968,
0.3323760629,
-0.0233317837,
-0.3801128864,
-0.0413793474,
-0.4151197374,
0.6471644044,
0.776154995,
0.0360029861,
0.1041240394,
-0.3518809676,
-0.1034957767,
0.0238359086,
-0.645481348,
-0.5202118754,
1.0019258261,
0.2638604939,
1.0099042654,
-0.0234606117,
0.7680997252,
0.5011014342,
0.698355794,
-0.727489233,
0.3579837084,
0.4797076881,
-0.5628980398,
-0.0898424983,
-0.1314819306,
-0.7683107257,
-0.0941965207,
0.2745109797,
-1.1250445843,
-0.0002807602,
0.3314615488,
-0.2468320429,
0.2313105017,
-0.7748727798,
0.7500630021,
-0.1885543913,
-0.7606854439,
-0.4414688349,
-0.4694592953,
0.6883115768,
0.3213759661,
0.3266363144,
-0.0815029293,
0.1907437742,
0.359361589,
-0.5524205565,
1.0034567118,
-0.2980042696,
-0.1337793022,
0.3016864955,
0.389437139,
0.6927030087,
0.3840285838,
-0.0408186316,
0.0933958739,
-0.0570169277,
-0.2255631238,
-0.3151834607,
0.9459184408,
-0.7119556665,
-0.7768886089,
-0.5634948611,
-0.609087348,
-0.2083175927,
-0.0760699734,
0.3620915711,
0.3639163375,
-0.1546243131,
0.0779079348,
0.3049625158,
-0.4055462182,
0.4628704786,
0.2423846424,
-0.3095260859,
0.0281650629,
0.875156343,
-0.1365473568,
0.364536047,
0.1681888849,
0.2204149067,
-0.0237301774,
-0.3329869509,
-0.2106146216,
0.0500187799,
-0.7053563595,
-0.5548257828,
-0.1207759082,
-0.1320043802,
-0.4274807572,
-0.5001294017,
-0.0666828305,
0.0295528024,
-0.1362326294,
-0.0398574956,
0.3860508204,
1.1628082991,
-0.3930368423,
0.2670207024,
-0.5915638208,
-0.0804945529,
0.1426034868,
0.5844584703,
0.3591499925,
-0.1858036518,
-0.3514719009,
0.0066655828,
-0.4934229553,
-1.0083270073,
0.2936360836,
-0.2508897483,
0.3692876101,
0.3217371106,
-0.0561885647,
0.7072383761,
-0.3224591017,
0.9520139098,
-0.2012892067,
-1.1264288425,
0.5822473168,
-0.4986996949,
0.6141507626,
0.4208935499,
-0.0943010598,
-0.9505574703,
-0.7745695114,
-0.2524293959,
-0.9551823139,
1.0970394611,
0.0230326653,
0.3205455244,
-0.1830540597,
0.3063420057,
0.1644124687,
0.2517232895,
-1.013712883,
-0.07547158,
0.0146319624,
0.2353071868,
0.233513236,
-0.4407534599,
-0.3376148939,
-0.2325503379,
0.729493618,
-0.0269594826,
0.2915251255,
0.1199940592,
-0.1950948089,
-0.3981668055,
0.1939013004,
0.7947839499,
0.8912522793,
-0.2230466008,
0.0613677129,
-0.0522616133,
-0.0823281407,
0.2450122386,
-0.3556048572,
-0.286912024,
-0.4892483056,
0.4855611324,
0.5384548903,
0.2817074358,
-1.1076080799,
0.5159010887,
-0.1571686119,
0.0719376057,
-0.4335785508,
0.2855136693,
-0.080334276,
0.3398671746,
0.4315063655,
0.0068068244,
0.2066241205,
-0.9101946354,
0.186466679,
0.6184203625,
-0.2402922213,
-0.457853049,
0.5051737428,
0.1345210969,
-0.697458446,
0.5931074619,
-0.161245212,
-0.7293662429,
0.794958353,
0.9394368529,
0.8101694584,
-0.1061056256,
0.1329269409,
0.2386967838,
0.4327879548,
0.1849831343,
0.3604328036,
-0.1901851743,
-0.5237563848,
-0.5075727105,
-0.2676951587,
-0.5520391464,
0.4516020417,
-0.4444128871,
0.3495827317,
-0.3533424437,
0.1620568931,
-0.4737507403,
-0.2595055699,
-0.6741532087,
-0.1563093811,
0.2878390253,
0.6750303507,
-0.5653979778,
0.7059816122,
0.4429139793,
-0.3968498707,
-0.5800361037,
0.2146881819,
0.2316063643,
-0.9334520698,
0.7797960639,
0.5167630911,
-0.448653847,
-0.2683108449,
-0.8913552165,
-1.0814194679,
0.9761478901,
0.3435542881,
-0.3287413418,
0.0580294952,
0.1872731447,
0.6083590984,
-0.4818652868,
0.2861257493,
0.6263875365,
0.4360148907,
-0.2762661576,
-0.6563290954,
0.1870220155,
-0.2558771372,
-0.0044525615,
0.3638326228,
-0.5306783915,
0.6835108399,
-0.4824629724,
-0.0576335229,
-0.2611603439,
0.0087818056,
0.6765811443,
0.3077564836,
0.3480767012,
0.2671345472,
0.4221279621,
0.0661741793,
1.5425701141,
-0.4093981087,
0.0521168411,
0.987249732,
-0.2749841809,
0.7104594707,
0.9014205933,
0.0178366117,
0.836026907,
0.808224082,
0.3474502265,
0.6414361,
0.5986614227,
0.0379434153,
0.3677111864,
-0.3177992404,
-0.1401804984,
0.319688201,
0.4036067426,
-0.1286727935,
-0.1093589813,
0.0769587308,
0.2647245526,
-0.1642201841,
-0.285202086,
0.6984978914,
0.0048845494,
-1.0301760435,
0.3469433188,
0.0840073302,
0.8452600837,
-0.6712765098,
-0.1567327082,
-0.3380755782,
0.3368513882,
-0.2003430128,
-0.5879961848,
0.4233247042,
0.1470110416,
-0.0264784992,
-0.6799939275,
0.7378797531,
-0.2222556621,
0.0400935747,
0.8125616312,
0.2930585742,
-0.0954119861,
-0.2063179612,
-0.5601574183,
0.1662273109,
-0.0890862867,
-0.5629562736,
0.5654842854,
0.2725538313,
-0.1891899556,
0.5795572996,
0.8437495232,
0.1043881029,
-0.0894654244,
0.0210722852,
1.0619440079,
-0.7473294735,
-0.6766905189,
-1.3197811842,
0.5359156132,
-0.0864074826,
-0.2780160904,
0.7316453457,
0.4164666533,
1.1516190767,
0.3124571443,
0.8814694881,
-0.1341609359,
0.2091734707,
-0.3176680207,
0.6017564535,
-0.616440773,
0.5555586219,
-0.273124218,
-0.678961277,
-0.085788697,
0.1469918787,
-0.2436098754,
-0.0382447317,
0.6116693616,
0.7261633277,
0.1952992976,
-0.3063753843,
0.0318688825,
0.1432376504,
0.7594820261,
0.4803566039,
0.9872896671,
-0.0888967216,
0.4970332384,
-0.3318592608,
-0.2795604467,
-0.4063078761,
-0.916374743,
-0.6718155146,
-0.5549036264,
0.1364951432,
-0.6922230721,
0.0783860013,
0.9008923769,
0.5399016738,
-0.8956769109,
-0.667016983,
-0.3747102022,
0.5024278164,
-0.2073937505,
-0.3675689697,
0.0682070851,
-0.6246426105,
-0.4022986591,
0.3912978172,
0.5509871244,
-0.2504628897,
-0.5773797035,
-0.250448525,
-0.0995315164,
0.2162917256,
0.5896445513,
0.3347084224,
-0.8267400265,
-0.4352654517,
0.0263718814,
-0.1853912771,
0.0541267022,
1.323081255,
-1.0041958094,
0.290204376,
0.4895272255,
0.5361515284,
0.307777226,
-0.165810883,
0.9183311462,
-0.7050837278,
0.2478553951,
0.4181456566,
0.209043771,
0.2131889462,
-0.6411654353,
0.3858540356,
-0.0135207092,
-0.8420900702,
-1.2641661167,
0.2719978094,
-0.1312784255,
-0.5578756928,
1.2186995745,
0.0189798027,
-0.3345108628,
0.03772901,
-0.0906633139,
0.03745557,
-0.6682670116,
1.290995121,
0.9830839038,
-0.5684701204,
0.1296575516,
-0.4356382489,
0.8938934207,
0.2583846152,
-0.9599449039,
0.139883846,
0.4276145995,
0.2203547508,
-0.1430248022,
0.8768881559,
-0.005938468,
0.2805605829,
-0.198530674,
0.0118302675,
0.0703953505,
-0.3326957226,
-0.5051498413,
-0.071272105,
0.2490623593,
0.1669734567
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06625v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06625v1
|
Understanding the Effects of Iterative Prompting on Truthfulness
| 2024-02-09T18:57:08 | 2024-02-09T18:57:08 |
Satyapriya Krishna, Chirag Agarwal, Himabindu Lakkaraju
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The development of Large Language Models (LLMs) has notably transformed
numerous sectors, offering impressive text generation capabilities. Yet, the
reliability and truthfulness of these models remain pressing concerns. To this
end, we investigate iterative prompting, a strategy hypothesized to refine LLM
responses, assessing its impact on LLM truthfulness, an area which has not been
thoroughly explored. Our extensive experiments delve into the intricacies of
iterative prompting variants, examining their influence on the accuracy and
calibration of model responses. Our findings reveal that naive prompting
methods significantly undermine truthfulness, leading to exacerbated
calibration errors. In response to these challenges, we introduce several
prompting variants designed to address the identified issues. These variants
demonstrate marked improvements over existing baselines, signaling a promising
direction for future research. Our work provides a nuanced understanding of
iterative prompting and introduces novel approaches to enhance the truthfulness
of LLMs, thereby contributing to the development of more accurate and
trustworthy AI systems.
|
[
0.0157088023,
-0.6521620154,
0.8813214302,
0.2432340533,
-0.0690406933,
0.1262858957,
-0.456707269,
-0.0301124174,
-0.4072318673,
0.3200738728,
-0.790599823,
-0.2631105781,
-0.4057781398,
0.3790188432,
-0.2790976465,
0.9276717901,
-0.005582375,
0.1594874412,
-0.2626803219,
-0.1149408594,
-0.8512490988,
-0.1012645215,
-0.5999314189,
-0.6939457655,
0.6244542599,
0.6474659443,
0.744473815,
0.5713784099,
0.063935861,
0.3100267053,
-0.1200038642,
-0.0182490796,
-0.5973200798,
0.3144024611,
-0.0146019207,
-0.6933565736,
0.1254818588,
0.2964924276,
0.6734629869,
0.6454164982,
-0.334445715,
0.2754814327,
0.2822816968,
0.8258721828,
-0.5990234613,
0.1006571949,
-0.8564907312,
-0.1972590089,
-0.0514725558,
-0.5217623711,
-0.8070926666,
-0.4725704789,
0.1372925192,
-0.3873598576,
0.3302132189,
0.0414247103,
0.6978340745,
0.573667109,
-0.1437258124,
-0.5721545815,
-0.7326053977,
0.8173806071,
-0.9807296395,
0.2023046166,
0.3639650345,
0.1803894341,
-0.1541841924,
-0.5398880839,
-0.7960840464,
-0.652638495,
0.1740863919,
0.0593370013,
-0.0187267177,
-0.0590457916,
0.5318710208,
0.326641202,
-0.3790151477,
0.2469923943,
-0.3432660401,
0.0871478915,
0.3129148185,
0.2233668119,
-0.0931272954,
-0.0492997207,
-0.0521598347,
-0.1863312572,
-1.1180360317,
0.2411824018,
0.7668771148,
0.4115582407,
0.1299807727,
0.5744300485,
-0.099931404,
0.9162980318,
0.2432982177,
-0.2794083357,
0.055535011,
-0.2513262928,
-0.0278172344,
0.2178994417,
0.6460921168,
0.4514806271,
0.307200402,
0.1453008503,
-0.2679459155,
0.0076051662,
0.4534592927,
-0.7369835973,
-0.1735045314,
0.5537188649,
-0.2518365979,
-0.5617660284,
-0.156614989,
-0.3942733407,
-0.636477828,
-0.312525928,
0.6171043515,
-0.5907844901,
-0.190929994,
0.2083980888,
-0.0871442705,
0.2136362791,
0.350084424,
-0.7424845695,
-0.3427404463,
0.7181074619,
0.4859791696,
0.15551956,
-0.2704394758,
-0.6141424775,
-0.0179544743,
-0.5566113591,
0.5585207939,
-0.6569266915,
-0.6692687273,
0.0888099298,
-0.4952779412,
-0.0015123261,
-0.6460995078,
0.6801512837,
-0.5933116078,
0.248797372,
-0.7312053442,
-0.5137116313,
-0.3636111617,
0.5863386393,
-0.6613407135,
0.8932743669,
-0.1827440709,
-0.6529818177,
0.3627521992,
-0.4424047172,
-0.2421117276,
-0.0732440129,
-0.4452943206,
-0.2728774548,
0.3701054156,
0.2915507555,
0.238597855,
-0.5017994046,
0.4637339115,
-0.074461028,
-0.2955997288,
0.5142050385,
-0.8470602036,
0.7978309393,
0.0530362166,
-0.4183512032,
-0.0963142887,
-0.7047003508,
0.1652634442,
0.1478516459,
-0.3014840186,
-0.0026066881,
-0.0606043078,
-0.4524418414,
-0.1007153615,
0.077274777,
-0.4655868411,
0.2087678611,
-0.3939491808,
0.4533823729,
1.1169314384,
0.0406442657,
0.3005955517,
-0.6917517185,
0.3577257693,
0.0369505435,
0.1617284864,
-0.716719389,
-0.5305082202,
-0.6676291823,
-0.1201719865,
0.2953007221,
0.2574027777,
-0.8549861908,
0.0640892759,
-0.2587328553,
-0.3385941684,
-0.917930007,
0.1902580112,
0.3401258588,
1.0792142153,
0.1613871306,
0.1399955899,
-0.1703174561,
-0.5653731823,
-0.4759798646,
-0.4631554484,
0.0990524441,
0.037921425,
0.2528089285,
-0.1175930277,
1.0558019876,
0.0483451486,
0.1313215643,
0.0045916643,
0.4073583186,
0.2476434708,
0.3693762422,
0.3111475706,
-0.7164793611,
-0.3550540209,
-0.5159757733,
-0.557092309,
-0.204449445,
-0.3161245584,
0.5652471781,
0.2132204771,
0.3240381181,
-0.3531509936,
0.5328593254,
0.6302626729,
0.1283483058,
0.6739044785,
-0.1360928714,
0.357185185,
-0.7439481616,
0.136093691,
-0.352447927,
0.0970036611,
-0.536836803,
0.0036680601,
0.1464224756,
0.2054798007,
-0.2366360724,
0.4882591665,
-0.4510987103,
0.0315986015,
-0.3803764284,
0.0538301058,
0.1402117014,
-0.0269540101,
-0.2957716286,
1.1438952684,
0.4610457122,
-0.9339056015,
0.187717557,
0.3542433083,
-0.2043326795,
0.6788018346,
-0.6321262121,
0.3379796743,
-0.4507394433,
0.2578961849,
-1.2526805401,
-0.1610924304,
0.1223632172,
-0.7056850791,
0.3323619366,
0.1173736379,
-0.5892102122,
-0.5641151667,
-0.623532176,
0.2790108323,
0.5596453547,
-0.9161666632,
0.6734775305,
-0.5938160419,
-0.1229927018,
-0.7925857902,
-0.4580718577,
0.342584759,
-0.0546489768,
-0.5848858356,
0.0099997893,
-0.5822364688,
-0.5488805175,
-0.2710015774,
-0.1126761883,
0.4506637454,
0.1076350808,
0.3283646703,
0.4397722483,
-0.1469027847,
-0.1082691923,
-0.1416033804,
-0.2577065229,
0.1329542249,
-0.2396575212,
0.5320960879,
-0.0706493035,
-0.5422306657,
-0.8200909495,
0.1064796001,
0.2983964682,
-0.1785732359,
0.6420957446,
0.2645616829,
-0.0192560814,
-0.0050393925,
-0.9335288405,
-0.5385187864,
-0.6514378786,
-0.2691099346,
-0.4116031229,
-0.9182335138,
0.2937462926,
-0.2933203876,
0.4236958027,
0.1268886626,
0.5607521534,
-0.1901621073,
1.1609959602,
0.6065966487,
0.0119488379,
0.2909739912,
-0.0166000593,
0.3108257949,
-0.728387475,
-0.2181718051,
-0.8724485636,
-0.0216203798,
-0.5278483629,
-0.2803888321,
0.4264120162,
-0.252936542,
-0.1074359268,
-0.277618289,
-0.3438153267,
0.5741437674,
0.4257976115,
0.0569716282,
0.5744748116,
-0.0205657966,
-0.111577481,
-0.1588237733,
-0.7001395822,
-0.6985375881,
0.9597542882,
0.1915704608,
1.0009222031,
0.0319453403,
0.5405712128,
-0.014569154,
0.4139221013,
-0.9420420527,
0.4602945447,
0.2405296266,
-0.5493608713,
0.0026356238,
-0.3680558205,
-0.75623703,
-0.4180774391,
-0.0746095031,
-0.7850544453,
0.0522182323,
0.4747935236,
-0.6973541379,
0.0567098148,
-0.3904878795,
0.1317923218,
-0.2217162997,
-0.3018161058,
-0.198307991,
-0.690403223,
0.3159249425,
-0.1590884626,
0.1066822708,
0.0879689604,
-0.0518650673,
0.4422733486,
-0.2565464079,
0.9089354277,
-0.0922793895,
-0.5085704923,
0.1515460014,
0.3127494752,
0.8000071645,
0.0875305608,
-0.6663914323,
-0.0224353932,
-0.4027835727,
-0.3403065205,
-0.4812562764,
0.7627184987,
-0.5238990784,
-1.1080200672,
-0.1933948398,
-0.7134213448,
-0.5652863383,
0.1938337088,
0.6150540113,
0.4174781144,
0.1365171671,
0.0253186207,
1.2129410505,
-0.2670987546,
0.6498129368,
0.6344237328,
-0.094912,
-0.205694139,
0.6379584074,
0.0377421044,
0.5747810006,
-0.009444925,
0.340626955,
-0.3059103489,
-0.6831970215,
-0.6589185596,
0.2600364387,
-0.8140423894,
-0.1170281395,
-0.4151611626,
0.026992213,
-0.5161077976,
-0.2671646774,
-0.3983058035,
-0.1239881963,
-0.3870258629,
-0.2282355875,
0.5395053625,
0.9884335399,
0.0690442994,
0.2463124245,
-0.8703916073,
0.0267029367,
0.3101336062,
0.082032837,
0.0966561362,
-0.7466619015,
0.2406824529,
0.1568446159,
-0.1679724306,
-0.733125329,
-0.0023351554,
0.0519056804,
0.5010128617,
0.4666562974,
0.2495387197,
0.8364178538,
-0.6407181025,
1.1364308596,
0.1368143409,
-0.8351173997,
0.5358464718,
-0.3022572696,
0.4548618793,
0.9174693823,
0.2561461627,
-0.3509707153,
-0.3942685127,
-0.52914083,
-0.6361858845,
0.4393617213,
0.0170676541,
0.4786680639,
0.2855306864,
0.7994018197,
0.4812752306,
0.488548696,
-0.3865499198,
-0.3351274729,
-0.2047716975,
-0.171265617,
0.0040694657,
-0.3716852963,
-0.4604195356,
0.0027328059,
0.8121584654,
-0.3995405138,
0.1275375634,
0.1550951004,
0.0872320905,
-0.4176729023,
0.2019751072,
0.7036527395,
0.7319989204,
0.3194499314,
-0.0036371523,
0.0206588544,
-0.2491303384,
0.2007090002,
-0.0170719344,
-0.6554967165,
0.0831241235,
0.2066839933,
0.7604721785,
-0.2523103952,
-0.5866469145,
0.4464388192,
-0.1990683377,
-0.1985185593,
-0.1372350007,
0.2152457684,
-0.0412401929,
0.1678097099,
0.6479834914,
0.0599524006,
0.0282527842,
-0.5856183171,
0.0003452606,
0.513278842,
-0.2389862835,
-0.1836280525,
0.6151247025,
-0.0332844146,
-0.4046747983,
0.7588872313,
-0.0669139698,
-0.6474828124,
0.323071897,
0.5224629045,
0.612845242,
-0.5283098817,
0.425876677,
0.4699946344,
0.4748409986,
-0.3448041677,
0.273566395,
-0.1999174803,
-0.6896985173,
-0.5549489856,
-0.191188693,
-0.6153753996,
0.1686611772,
-0.6417618394,
0.0412543267,
-0.6265816092,
-0.1645164341,
-0.3195077479,
-0.1938516945,
-0.463357389,
0.192923978,
0.1346784085,
1.1088725328,
-0.5193327665,
0.5013760924,
0.5201990604,
-0.2264544666,
-1.3193565607,
0.5587422848,
0.4280975163,
-1.1962869167,
0.3652240038,
0.4069318473,
-0.2397402376,
0.2652983963,
-1.0508409739,
-0.5773519874,
1.0851694345,
0.4368543327,
-0.6004036665,
0.0394736342,
0.3458528519,
0.2541911304,
-0.0564868003,
0.1789659411,
0.5879602432,
0.76296103,
0.6142787337,
-0.9084814787,
0.2513029575,
-0.0767043754,
0.2474189252,
-0.2278773189,
-0.7173801661,
0.8058362007,
-0.7098801732,
-0.0971681625,
0.4354000688,
0.4585568607,
0.5760415196,
0.3204048574,
0.4814268351,
0.4169467688,
1.1216000319,
-0.0932305381,
0.7943201661,
-0.2432669401,
-0.0949529037,
1.1903362274,
-0.6559484601,
0.5594269037,
0.7269688249,
0.2932691276,
0.5992546082,
0.6800104976,
0.0812950656,
0.3056830168,
0.0142226089,
-0.5535631776,
-0.0835456923,
-0.3109241724,
-0.32049492,
0.2293336093,
0.346931994,
-0.201248765,
-0.29399544,
0.3292708099,
0.2755048871,
0.1286201775,
-0.2661831379,
0.7284092903,
0.0851450339,
-1.0984424353,
0.7183148861,
-0.202500537,
0.5910134912,
-0.4228107631,
-0.0132026197,
-0.1005869508,
-0.0187713541,
-0.2440213114,
-0.8558263183,
-0.1838866621,
0.1182362959,
-0.0923933983,
-0.4404647946,
0.5206733346,
-0.2159889936,
-0.0565157197,
-0.1596605182,
0.3470528722,
-0.3141429722,
-0.1466338634,
-0.8198188543,
0.4579631388,
0.2460230291,
-0.4489332438,
-0.1134119704,
0.4651328027,
0.1701325476,
0.842779994,
0.6844764352,
-0.1015906334,
-0.0808761492,
0.0729944631,
0.8917315006,
-0.5806574225,
-0.1977271885,
-1.0127604008,
0.7824630141,
0.0885960981,
0.0040729339,
0.8469418287,
0.1726649106,
0.5849366188,
0.2050592452,
0.8697587848,
0.0685127899,
0.3108188212,
-0.6626252532,
0.4640323222,
-0.4226313829,
0.7712871432,
0.0777034461,
-0.6447011232,
-0.030165527,
0.3551006913,
-0.3270340562,
0.2240869552,
0.7284120917,
1.0139764547,
0.5948714614,
0.4144468009,
0.3034887314,
0.547077775,
0.411762327,
0.1071125045,
1.0385773182,
-0.1814618409,
0.3689332604,
-0.0560752042,
-0.2124426514,
-0.2058225274,
-1.1616191864,
-0.9012736678,
-0.5624669194,
-0.2448215634,
-0.7334874272,
0.0945237577,
0.904321909,
0.1727347672,
-0.5423158407,
0.03840179,
-0.2259230018,
-0.109925881,
0.0447164327,
-0.1704696566,
-0.1476498395,
-0.36128214,
-0.5494785905,
0.4827063978,
0.1680855006,
0.1628570408,
-0.3844664991,
-0.1580974907,
0.1653465778,
0.2569147348,
0.1638156027,
0.3290962279,
-0.6819772124,
-0.2859634459,
0.2008175403,
-0.0483818762,
0.2503905594,
0.8010091782,
-0.9600482583,
0.6302618384,
0.2640731633,
0.611305058,
0.2410281748,
-0.083523199,
0.8013853431,
-0.7845708132,
-0.1110945642,
0.4448587894,
-0.0048003742,
0.794549942,
-0.5271407962,
0.3138842583,
0.0722725317,
-0.533845067,
-0.9776495099,
0.3921978474,
-0.5716376901,
-0.0478037931,
1.2802422047,
0.0377205163,
-0.3091016114,
-0.0061803255,
-0.5001351237,
0.0363003276,
-0.5064677596,
1.0033233166,
0.8586868048,
-0.0702463835,
-0.2591902912,
-0.5432906747,
0.5232458711,
0.7055189013,
-0.5052070618,
0.405344218,
0.6087027788,
0.2768138349,
0.3044186831,
0.7447350621,
-0.0601289347,
0.4916466773,
-0.2059638947,
-0.3756302297,
-0.0089878757,
-0.2035953104,
-0.6760875583,
-0.0451712757,
0.5094786882,
0.3476507068
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06619v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06619v1
|
Aya Dataset: An Open-Access Collection for Multilingual Instruction Tuning
| 2024-02-09T18:51:49 | 2024-02-09T18:51:49 |
Shivalika Singh, Freddie Vargus, Daniel Dsouza, Börje F. Karlsson, Abinaya Mahendiran, Wei-Yin Ko, Herumb Shandilya, Jay Patel, Deividas Mataciunas, Laura OMahony, Mike Zhang, Ramith Hettiarachchi, Joseph Wilson, Marina Machado, Luisa Souza Moura, Dominik Krzemiński, Hakimeh Fadaei, Irem Ergün, Ifeoma Okoh, Aisha Alaagib, Oshan Mudannayake, Zaid Alyafeai, Vu Minh Chien, Sebastian Ruder, Surya Guthikonda, Emad A. Alghamdi, Sebastian Gehrmann, Niklas Muennighoff, Max Bartolo, Julia Kreutzer, Ahmet Üstün, Marzieh Fadaee, Sara Hooker
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Datasets are foundational to many breakthroughs in modern artificial
intelligence. Many recent achievements in the space of natural language
processing (NLP) can be attributed to the finetuning of pre-trained models on a
diverse set of tasks that enables a large language model (LLM) to respond to
instructions. Instruction fine-tuning (IFT) requires specifically constructed
and annotated datasets. However, existing datasets are almost all in the
English language. In this work, our primary goal is to bridge the language gap
by building a human-curated instruction-following dataset spanning 65
languages. We worked with fluent speakers of languages from around the world to
collect natural instances of instructions and completions. Furthermore, we
create the most extensive multilingual collection to date, comprising 513
million instances through templating and translating existing datasets across
114 languages. In total, we contribute four key resources: we develop and
open-source the Aya Annotation Platform, the Aya Dataset, the Aya Collection,
and the Aya Evaluation Suite. The Aya initiative also serves as a valuable case
study in participatory research, involving collaborators from 119 countries. We
see this as a valuable framework for future research collaborations that aim to
bridge gaps in resources.
|
[
-0.1440937072,
-0.4813620746,
0.0720395297,
0.1486048251,
0.0200958438,
0.1571730822,
-0.5431720614,
-0.3347819448,
0.1332336366,
0.5432704687,
-0.7501744628,
-0.7264283895,
-0.4480996132,
0.0828918219,
-0.3255093992,
0.8669809103,
-0.0196538512,
0.1685266942,
0.0534348674,
-0.3818876445,
-0.5307696462,
-0.1598711759,
-0.620395124,
-0.0336339809,
0.4966444671,
0.9543524384,
0.6049564481,
1.0767017603,
0.4061380923,
0.2463142425,
0.3914903104,
0.4820514321,
-0.2137100697,
0.0397419296,
-0.0782442242,
-0.6452787519,
-0.2544718385,
-0.1254784763,
0.6984819174,
0.6859138012,
-0.307598263,
0.5471615791,
-0.0149015058,
0.8015477657,
-0.7508784533,
0.5316130519,
-0.3932425678,
0.0158604998,
-0.5549867153,
-0.0828354731,
-0.2329892516,
-0.5483220816,
0.1207067668,
-0.8903713822,
0.2028814405,
-0.1183333471,
0.5100248456,
0.4416284561,
-0.0754668787,
-0.5901504755,
-0.4877015352,
0.8623954654,
-0.6016085744,
0.3958382308,
0.6695636511,
0.3286735415,
0.0429150984,
-0.526063323,
-0.3996072114,
-0.1336188316,
-0.0429584123,
-0.1370858103,
-0.0177186243,
0.0481067225,
0.0826827362,
0.4129791558,
-0.5020800233,
0.2255343944,
-0.5726194382,
-0.1310958415,
0.6485332251,
0.0631119385,
0.3902602196,
-0.0104132835,
-0.0269917157,
-0.1461120397,
-0.7890520692,
0.0545633025,
0.4808236659,
0.5771713257,
-0.2972488403,
0.5538714528,
-0.2528607249,
0.8741311431,
-0.382573843,
0.1258394122,
0.1947990507,
-0.3995909691,
0.0473213382,
0.3282951415,
0.7095531225,
0.0179320257,
0.5986270308,
-0.1012636721,
0.043125473,
-0.0025359693,
0.2265464813,
-0.627356708,
-0.4637868106,
-0.0386286154,
-0.3405723572,
0.1565551013,
0.3027421236,
-0.7500963211,
-0.406386137,
-0.6187473536,
0.2932452559,
-0.2626713812,
-0.170082286,
0.2659802735,
0.3531310558,
0.1666826755,
0.1779366434,
-1.0729033947,
0.164514482,
0.5986474156,
0.7554910779,
0.1115632951,
-0.7169664502,
-0.4241785407,
0.1541713327,
-0.3507224917,
0.5009012222,
-0.618812263,
-0.2626588643,
0.2987042665,
0.2245340645,
-0.1484636217,
-0.4909119606,
0.478932023,
-0.2686221898,
0.2460766137,
-0.4224587977,
-0.3905391097,
-0.2513887882,
0.1457729787,
-0.7325165868,
0.8504135609,
-0.1178552061,
-0.4967112839,
0.0993483886,
-0.931399107,
-0.6839213967,
0.0901645645,
-0.2381855398,
-0.1519922763,
0.1438915282,
0.3406341672,
0.2250200659,
-0.5154057145,
0.1192195788,
0.0235621035,
-0.3816552758,
-0.0632615909,
-0.6322250962,
0.9255744815,
0.1180334017,
-0.4046523571,
0.1771832108,
-0.9193018675,
-0.0771771595,
-0.1288464367,
-0.3162953258,
-0.4000520408,
-0.0535729714,
0.0033507296,
0.0944183394,
0.4987078309,
-0.5662402511,
0.4931971431,
-0.2516064644,
0.4109258354,
0.7054407597,
-0.0692061037,
0.3147957921,
-0.1448969245,
0.680044353,
-0.1895026714,
0.3639678657,
-0.704375267,
-0.4775438309,
-1.0447587967,
-0.0353864059,
0.4027246535,
0.7570374012,
-0.7923650742,
0.3359723389,
-0.1716795117,
-0.2279143482,
-1.4351276159,
0.3233323693,
0.5913721323,
0.2878710032,
0.5020042658,
-0.1500357985,
-0.5916435122,
-0.9801103473,
0.0828250125,
-0.1364689171,
-0.0845378041,
0.1306107193,
0.2900900543,
0.0113403173,
0.5836065412,
-0.4034920037,
-0.4100038111,
0.3329380453,
0.1176386923,
0.0727421045,
0.4527401626,
0.2178178877,
-0.5292383432,
-0.4677395523,
0.1304674,
-0.8575340509,
0.022121191,
0.0836362764,
-0.5374643207,
0.0318400376,
0.4525473416,
-0.5067122579,
0.263051331,
0.4710169435,
-0.1278899014,
0.2016132772,
-0.2456913143,
0.4661997855,
-1.233735919,
0.0964622796,
-0.1717622876,
0.2850412726,
-0.3827782273,
0.1121619716,
0.1104437262,
-0.1839430332,
-0.3090906143,
0.5504878163,
-0.5492371917,
-0.0190198794,
-0.1319758296,
-0.1602167487,
-0.1214518175,
0.3624289632,
-0.0380617529,
0.9021249413,
0.6553385854,
-0.4708192348,
0.4306158721,
0.4578785598,
-0.5112692118,
0.4115450978,
-0.4638759792,
0.127064839,
-0.0190696176,
-0.1395451128,
-0.6188505292,
-0.3758020401,
0.3875439465,
-0.2519741058,
0.3374456763,
-0.1373391002,
-0.5408018827,
-0.1075424105,
-0.1490333229,
0.2773959339,
0.0445426479,
-0.8179468513,
0.1833669096,
0.3662173152,
-0.2317066938,
-0.8947869539,
-0.6939590573,
0.1451595724,
0.0053549027,
-0.3876396418,
0.1693585813,
-0.1304221004,
-0.1271574646,
0.2457912415,
0.0019732439,
-0.1192501485,
-0.1135411933,
0.084717378,
0.0151054189,
-0.3620992005,
0.3201003969,
-0.0140735144,
-0.115395695,
-0.0101501346,
-0.3849184811,
0.3470066488,
0.0334058367,
-0.530274272,
-0.4649633169,
0.4425643981,
0.5392315984,
-0.6227566004,
0.6666857004,
0.6089417934,
-0.553932488,
-0.2912730277,
-0.2459689081,
-0.0174100175,
-0.4322119057,
0.2518559694,
-0.1642289013,
-0.7151662111,
0.3907545209,
0.3273730874,
0.6166363358,
0.2605728209,
0.3699793816,
0.0930521041,
0.820263505,
0.7159500122,
-0.5317769051,
0.6321977973,
-0.3538960814,
0.0240496676,
-0.3749845922,
-0.2658963501,
-0.6976521611,
-0.3158061504,
-0.6229572296,
-0.4459866583,
0.2479871958,
-0.1637412757,
-0.2380684465,
0.1358336061,
-0.4943957329,
0.5884261131,
0.8356136084,
-0.0278698262,
0.2556520998,
0.0245186575,
0.3883813322,
0.0087758955,
-0.726226151,
-0.5009781122,
1.139966011,
-0.0035014055,
0.6663506627,
0.149798736,
0.4213523865,
0.3916912675,
0.1582201421,
-0.8112174869,
0.3943037391,
-0.4474567175,
-0.579231441,
-0.2953395844,
-0.3594402373,
-1.2036262751,
-0.2441370338,
-0.0919103771,
-0.497980237,
-0.1443869323,
0.2381431609,
-0.1683389246,
0.1066989154,
-0.8101394176,
1.0229574442,
-0.3308153152,
-0.3609198928,
-0.3388747275,
-0.7603365183,
0.3218323588,
0.1983363479,
0.2109888494,
-0.065745227,
0.0235763118,
0.6574436426,
-0.0790835544,
0.8494694233,
-0.3296099901,
-0.1359716207,
0.338845551,
-0.2332304865,
0.0311751459,
0.0750987232,
-0.2476748526,
0.1785642207,
-0.2687159777,
-0.6351243258,
-0.4139510691,
0.7675253153,
-0.809396863,
-0.2735413015,
-0.1630596817,
-0.6271947622,
-0.0511236303,
0.1012831405,
0.189404875,
0.5179637671,
-0.1035570726,
0.2299272865,
0.649807632,
-0.2558756173,
0.3616167605,
0.6727620959,
0.0636195168,
-0.2231911272,
1.1968808174,
0.3977335989,
-0.1547499895,
0.5951393843,
-0.0024486098,
-0.2269705981,
-0.4346905649,
-0.9958811998,
0.0326891914,
-0.6355819702,
-0.2312729657,
-0.1598573476,
-0.1498268843,
-0.1473094374,
0.0353102833,
-0.5146440268,
-0.3717086613,
-0.2823711336,
-0.0409918614,
0.5539684892,
0.8411581516,
0.1425421834,
0.2751889527,
-0.8688905835,
0.2784470022,
0.1783492267,
0.5402438641,
0.0071494342,
-0.2490137219,
-0.7372493148,
0.2116573006,
-0.089779675,
-0.8587100506,
0.130663693,
0.5000095367,
0.6730920672,
0.1857881993,
-0.0822038427,
0.7730025649,
-0.5430965424,
0.6815369129,
-0.2604234219,
-0.7526608109,
0.772864759,
-0.3742355108,
0.5612432361,
0.8861638904,
0.5662856102,
-0.567343533,
-0.1927463114,
-0.4016260505,
-0.9192083478,
0.8282268047,
0.0327973552,
0.0598502457,
0.1175694317,
0.4339759946,
0.3605935574,
0.4672955275,
-0.3080713153,
-0.4401261806,
-0.0892187655,
-0.5940570235,
-0.3070038855,
0.3014181256,
-0.0956199616,
-0.1859657615,
0.891836226,
-0.1881999969,
-0.1077217832,
-0.2473358959,
-0.2648128569,
-0.1993649304,
0.1623955965,
0.2962274551,
0.6729639769,
0.0420192368,
-0.1457418203,
-0.1256232262,
-0.6396896243,
0.0941961855,
0.4557288885,
-0.3958363235,
-0.0969296098,
0.406979382,
0.9206285477,
0.1691696495,
-0.6866939068,
0.1156474203,
-0.2539718747,
0.1391559988,
-0.3036903441,
0.136578247,
-0.106659703,
0.0942304507,
0.3696406484,
-0.0554538555,
0.2381632477,
-0.4891182482,
0.22525087,
0.0642806068,
-0.3504550755,
-0.4697928131,
0.3980959952,
0.2555469275,
-0.5494853258,
0.8887377381,
-0.3008470237,
-0.1228649393,
0.5432274342,
0.2548187971,
0.5874385238,
-0.4386846721,
0.2702362835,
0.5531693101,
0.5869244933,
-0.2186219096,
0.3709543347,
-0.1691372693,
-0.502173543,
-0.3899141252,
-0.6925184727,
-0.7078314424,
0.290555656,
-0.849014461,
0.3583554924,
-0.2419836819,
0.3296456039,
-0.1441119313,
0.3163187802,
-0.6272193789,
0.1716120094,
0.0845431387,
0.6863994002,
-1.1324176788,
0.8458325267,
1.0359383821,
-0.3398868144,
-0.54701823,
0.0625354275,
-0.0125998193,
-0.8034639359,
-0.1489435136,
0.4190012515,
0.0728473291,
0.0632285699,
-0.3389163613,
-0.7129215002,
0.7728103399,
0.6938918829,
-0.6176598072,
-0.1373924166,
0.0870515257,
0.5033839345,
-0.2981187701,
-0.0453151539,
0.8300200105,
0.5445973873,
-0.2471554577,
-0.6859591603,
-0.3074069619,
-0.6038643718,
-0.3665283322,
0.4636945724,
-0.732298255,
0.5263583064,
-0.0426476859,
-0.0174068976,
0.1658550203,
0.6534571648,
0.2692199945,
0.236427471,
0.2460480481,
0.3409294188,
0.9291927814,
-0.0559038334,
0.7144696116,
-0.5366423726,
-0.2038281411,
1.2301965952,
0.1584253013,
0.7211427093,
0.2695639431,
-0.0430846103,
0.3724693656,
0.654445529,
0.0328099616,
0.3813570738,
0.2624191642,
-0.4203006327,
0.1242000833,
-0.4803488553,
-0.3990449905,
0.7352344394,
0.6770509481,
-0.0839910507,
-0.0619954094,
0.0222780127,
-0.1491953135,
0.3209370077,
-0.4173925519,
0.5570824146,
-0.1740041375,
-0.84432441,
0.305202812,
0.0037625777,
0.7120040655,
-0.7906018496,
-0.3144769967,
-0.1824352294,
0.0935930535,
-0.2240484655,
-0.6923471689,
0.1875276715,
0.2270674407,
-0.1820072681,
-0.1819378436,
0.4698801339,
-0.8722251654,
-0.5413353443,
0.152060926,
0.4647319317,
0.1986494213,
0.3619919419,
-0.7274339795,
0.0558805652,
0.0432158895,
-0.2973426282,
0.2024240941,
0.513784945,
-0.2312648743,
0.3776061535,
0.5148389339,
0.1200581342,
0.3061994314,
0.2695035636,
0.5648730993,
-0.3926116228,
-0.3851835132,
-0.5516906977,
0.5711429119,
0.109798409,
-0.7216396928,
0.8344054222,
0.7277193666,
1.1561146975,
0.0607924126,
0.9285290241,
0.0006174922,
0.3899409175,
-0.5320005417,
0.6229091883,
-0.4911516309,
0.134431079,
0.157049939,
-0.8435810804,
-0.2357349545,
0.7569289207,
0.067539379,
-0.0390220731,
0.1861630678,
0.7945773602,
-0.1573866606,
0.2961325943,
-0.0024789153,
0.0008595558,
0.0809482485,
0.4687244892,
0.7223103642,
-0.413254112,
0.4657658935,
-0.490245074,
-0.1780796051,
0.1182149053,
-0.7758185267,
-0.769996345,
-0.7008395791,
-0.1626070291,
0.0189461112,
0.3006502688,
1.177924037,
0.644030571,
-0.9524874091,
-0.5707642436,
-0.1874210984,
0.0172869414,
-0.2430330366,
-0.1385212392,
0.5103152394,
-0.4274864197,
-0.9061654806,
0.706972599,
0.2015987039,
-0.286637336,
-0.4971770644,
-0.0266839098,
-0.3828315735,
-0.1837445498,
0.3453715444,
0.5990692973,
-0.3831079006,
-0.1932791919,
0.148402065,
0.0312141888,
0.0718781799,
0.6824034452,
-0.3697544634,
0.8584427834,
0.2662658095,
0.9190325141,
0.4036805034,
-0.2691593766,
0.7066116929,
-1.1974076033,
0.2801710069,
0.1874474287,
0.1713137031,
0.6442129612,
-0.1859113425,
0.6116213799,
-0.1171409637,
-0.4854627848,
-0.7226259112,
0.1296577454,
-0.5510171056,
-0.1091104448,
0.8275624514,
-0.3313408792,
-0.124416545,
-0.0578946956,
-0.2305420637,
0.6381533146,
-0.4274466336,
0.9653947949,
0.8103925586,
0.1098543555,
-0.1671077013,
-0.899569273,
0.4725600183,
0.3955634236,
-1.0577619076,
0.3344090283,
0.500351131,
-0.1800439358,
0.1530825794,
0.5971046686,
0.1692837477,
0.4906513095,
-0.1140824184,
0.3037238717,
-0.1884980053,
-0.889565587,
-0.5311457515,
0.0401714109,
0.1109827831,
-0.6074508429
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06617v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06617v1
|
FaBERT: Pre-training BERT on Persian Blogs
| 2024-02-09T18:50:51 | 2024-02-09T18:50:51 |
Mostafa Masumi, Seyed Soroush Majd, Mehrnoush Shamsfard, Hamid Beigy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce FaBERT, a Persian BERT-base model pre-trained on the HmBlogs
corpus, encompassing both informal and formal Persian texts. FaBERT is designed
to excel in traditional Natural Language Understanding (NLU) tasks, addressing
the intricacies of diverse sentence structures and linguistic styles prevalent
in the Persian language. In our comprehensive evaluation of FaBERT on 12
datasets in various downstream tasks, encompassing Sentiment Analysis (SA),
Named Entity Recognition (NER), Natural Language Inference (NLI), Question
Answering (QA), and Question Paraphrasing (QP), it consistently demonstrated
improved performance, all achieved within a compact model size. The findings
highlight the importance of utilizing diverse and cleaned corpora, such as
HmBlogs, to enhance the performance of language models like BERT in Persian
Natural Language Processing (NLP) applications. FaBERT is openly accessible at
https://huggingface.co/sbunlp/fabert
|
[
-0.4924086332,
-0.6068093777,
0.1945948899,
0.4117081165,
-0.5052103996,
0.3031958044,
-0.5593460798,
-0.3157894611,
0.4234582186,
0.198943615,
-0.7072789073,
-0.4346713424,
-0.4857003689,
0.2894484997,
-0.4741045237,
1.5211745501,
0.0876841992,
0.282861948,
0.2255006433,
0.1570313126,
-0.1163196191,
-0.4542985559,
-0.4314403832,
0.0780568421,
0.6465834379,
0.2499923408,
0.7453867197,
0.1043463945,
0.596916914,
0.2806842625,
0.1018693,
0.1328981072,
-0.6532987356,
0.2010620981,
-0.230611667,
-0.0776811093,
-0.196051091,
-0.2753596306,
0.6595340967,
0.7566814423,
-0.2436928302,
0.2748273015,
0.1784056574,
0.8664171696,
-0.6459060311,
-0.2407480776,
-0.4217039943,
-0.1276250333,
-0.3951699138,
0.0295853093,
-0.2564357519,
-0.7853397131,
0.3596108854,
-0.6750385761,
0.1413354874,
-0.0116607454,
1.0341653824,
0.280798614,
-0.3754211068,
-0.3555701375,
-0.9233694077,
0.8994577527,
-0.495986253,
0.5358932018,
0.2898148,
0.2579282522,
-0.0048294216,
-0.7193265557,
-0.4346194267,
-0.1557161808,
-0.2624141872,
0.1173986942,
-0.1632477045,
-0.1682984978,
-0.0550225638,
0.2822021246,
-0.8678742647,
-0.3832554519,
-0.3761915565,
0.1704496443,
0.3264668286,
-0.2810763419,
0.143366009,
-0.1852326095,
-0.4134911299,
-0.0498726033,
-0.8714106679,
-0.0312513933,
0.6076213121,
0.1587408036,
0.2230353653,
0.371951133,
-0.350099653,
0.593231082,
0.3445959687,
0.3229836822,
0.0039201798,
-0.2619357109,
-0.0674136803,
0.2578691244,
0.5612581968,
-0.4348744154,
0.2117284983,
-0.0153502515,
-0.0091446526,
-0.4418935478,
0.5922983289,
-0.9852443933,
-0.7479428053,
0.0810394436,
-0.6416653395,
-0.0703607723,
0.201339975,
-0.6547241211,
-0.3560938537,
-0.3139811456,
0.2920365036,
-0.7158576846,
-0.5004737973,
0.2741479874,
0.0697238669,
0.4181689918,
0.6554297209,
-0.9671279192,
0.3642213047,
0.6736494899,
0.4050248265,
-0.0252465978,
-0.0649377927,
-0.4657637179,
0.0444233082,
-0.2184062004,
0.9962053895,
-0.4572438896,
-0.357198447,
0.1513336003,
-0.5469350815,
-0.2604012191,
-0.3343931139,
0.8933067918,
-0.7075348496,
0.5749639273,
-0.4603385627,
-0.5616950989,
-0.3177042603,
0.2343649864,
-0.6602083445,
1.1097325087,
0.0524228178,
-1.2685716152,
0.1423176825,
-0.8602828383,
-0.5775228143,
0.1438666135,
0.1811777204,
-0.3548534214,
0.1246498972,
0.2276895195,
0.402553916,
0.0313399285,
0.0544551611,
-0.2219604254,
-0.2470439374,
0.1820649058,
-0.0585684218,
0.9993206859,
0.3003934622,
-0.2843427956,
0.2145368457,
-0.6641873717,
0.0706634298,
-0.2734382451,
-0.5206913948,
-0.3878920376,
0.1091380194,
0.4972855747,
0.1068607867,
0.3870147467,
-0.6294462085,
0.0627090558,
-0.3343630135,
0.0328947678,
0.7280384302,
-0.1862943321,
0.1501511782,
-0.1482425034,
0.5864161849,
-0.4285715818,
0.0094368663,
0.1741491407,
-0.3262124956,
-0.8395687938,
-0.4467115104,
0.5817122459,
0.6579205394,
-0.7838845849,
0.4789766371,
-0.3940522373,
-0.6369524598,
-0.4195884466,
0.4441209435,
0.236343354,
0.2502428293,
0.2750091851,
-0.3804248273,
-0.7704877853,
-0.8850018382,
-0.5178487301,
-0.2567530274,
0.075681068,
-0.0015453817,
0.6109945774,
-0.08643426,
0.9102327824,
-0.2784171402,
0.0010060834,
-0.7827857137,
0.6485541463,
0.2749969959,
0.5341566801,
0.4750627577,
-0.9580616951,
-1.0889368057,
0.0334478617,
-0.4155240059,
-0.0521749444,
-0.0591800734,
-0.5174319148,
0.1400462985,
0.323721379,
-0.9009642601,
0.458355099,
0.5383033752,
-0.1694336683,
0.8958314061,
0.1328732818,
0.150703907,
-1.1553472281,
0.1180015653,
-0.0757932365,
-0.4010073543,
-0.8955516815,
-0.1520615369,
0.0712960213,
0.1233423352,
-0.6765681505,
0.33841905,
-0.3382176459,
0.1813325584,
-0.2063136101,
-0.2374401838,
-0.1515463293,
0.5147610307,
0.4986667037,
1.0641978979,
0.3272253871,
-0.3870395124,
0.2666766644,
0.3536807895,
-0.613306582,
0.580057919,
-0.6948547363,
0.0787449777,
0.0011506639,
0.2479071468,
-0.8370239735,
-0.0555904955,
0.1511993706,
-0.455768019,
0.3940932751,
0.2325462252,
-0.7590987086,
-0.2406388074,
-0.6038120389,
0.3603324592,
0.654858768,
-0.5467084646,
0.6291671395,
-0.0329819098,
-0.4284787178,
-0.6213311553,
-0.09390302,
-0.0240960456,
-0.2071507573,
-0.528183341,
0.0714868978,
-0.0944086835,
-0.1943166256,
0.0941429585,
0.0809386671,
-0.3920184672,
0.1501906216,
0.0139826667,
0.0381620228,
-0.6002497077,
0.229144007,
0.0442983247,
0.1376717091,
-0.0428411923,
-0.3119906783,
0.7275181413,
-0.4355052114,
-0.2938768566,
-0.5666447282,
0.2953933477,
-0.2207445502,
-0.4074734449,
0.967849493,
1.1110825539,
-0.1979456544,
-0.1084920838,
-0.5379934907,
-0.2814136446,
-0.4897604883,
0.3379060328,
-0.2124003321,
-0.8370984793,
0.1551157385,
-0.1925887316,
-0.0538937412,
0.4964405,
0.756303668,
-0.4730989337,
0.672308743,
0.8193579316,
-0.179969281,
0.6160699129,
0.0162381995,
0.5146163106,
-0.6100457311,
0.3650352955,
-0.5839999914,
-0.228855446,
-0.5828150511,
-0.0728215799,
0.3016361296,
0.0379323773,
-0.2526125312,
0.3488210142,
-0.1273553073,
0.5629174709,
0.8587456942,
0.0294480436,
0.2340442538,
-0.0518610999,
0.302865237,
-0.2765781581,
-0.6010317802,
-0.5222908258,
1.1393356323,
0.0000671888,
0.8411399722,
0.2885599136,
0.9523353577,
0.4378048778,
0.4739377797,
-0.3480297327,
0.3346723914,
-0.0607160442,
-0.9001000524,
-0.0846241936,
-0.1012138948,
-0.9038258195,
0.3615085483,
-0.0697680563,
-0.4839457572,
0.0778116584,
0.0513414741,
-0.5614901185,
0.2694988847,
-0.558939755,
0.9593272209,
-0.2810105383,
-0.3276614547,
-0.3656417429,
-0.7545161843,
0.5590444803,
-0.1053080112,
-0.0542819351,
0.0268345214,
0.2117242664,
0.8659728169,
-0.3167286515,
0.8028965592,
0.0828199312,
0.054100696,
0.2185741514,
0.1648394912,
0.028951494,
0.2672205865,
0.1251402348,
0.0381036289,
0.1470678449,
-0.7439962626,
-0.309945792,
0.4526384175,
-0.8325092793,
-0.5501639843,
-0.7804982066,
-0.3631990254,
-0.2836718559,
0.2174634039,
0.1235275269,
0.1917443871,
-0.7645565867,
0.3144497871,
0.9468477964,
-0.3601952791,
0.0731248409,
0.3420050442,
-0.2324420512,
-0.131963864,
0.8331573606,
-0.5540996194,
0.0815234333,
0.5958225727,
-0.1802362353,
-0.1283044815,
-0.3934629261,
-0.5203719139,
0.4841189981,
-0.5863129497,
-0.1933896989,
-0.5726223588,
-0.298073262,
-0.3445759714,
-0.1378930807,
-0.4286818802,
-0.760774076,
-0.3598415554,
-0.0950763598,
0.2454336882,
0.9881029129,
-0.2959038019,
0.613745451,
-0.8078338504,
0.2496653199,
0.3944514394,
0.0764676854,
-0.3859127164,
-0.3539528847,
-0.6156821847,
0.0163968168,
-0.5582766533,
-0.860979557,
0.5500444174,
0.5199663639,
0.2768544257,
0.6259954572,
-0.1073949486,
0.4336895645,
-0.7605498433,
0.686997056,
-0.1061205193,
-0.9790000916,
0.6752796769,
-0.7102222443,
0.1772007942,
0.7189646959,
0.8179650903,
-0.640816927,
-0.4165288508,
-0.469814539,
-0.5074861646,
0.6510641575,
0.3850160837,
0.2349966019,
0.0793895274,
0.1660757512,
0.427428633,
0.581466198,
-0.8058150411,
-0.1281492561,
-0.3392266631,
-0.36322245,
0.028807193,
-0.408025831,
0.0094649401,
-0.5409476161,
1.0035744905,
0.2843671143,
0.3596601486,
0.0194798745,
-0.6599884629,
-0.0546675846,
0.3451464176,
0.5684661269,
0.8102698922,
-0.6428240538,
-0.0473184809,
-0.1230553687,
-0.5926058292,
-0.3121840358,
0.4223859906,
0.0380825438,
0.2714257538,
0.2917713821,
0.4113920629,
0.2741421461,
-0.7860456109,
0.4928654432,
-0.3418951035,
-0.1275687963,
-0.4287024438,
-0.2250458002,
0.0494759083,
0.0085979952,
0.3488509953,
-0.0573524758,
0.3694809377,
-0.2826557755,
0.1865303069,
0.468693316,
-0.2471853644,
-0.6048482656,
0.5619340539,
0.2408283502,
0.1917075962,
0.6533640623,
-0.4182576835,
-1.0092961788,
0.1509699374,
0.2215440869,
0.878870368,
-0.3911074996,
0.5947631001,
0.2116261125,
0.2450561523,
0.0934553668,
0.41200459,
-0.2960449457,
-0.6781800389,
-0.4808502197,
-0.7878417969,
-0.7092691064,
-0.2122216225,
-0.709592998,
0.1418602914,
-0.4794245958,
0.0624408759,
-0.1113786846,
0.2435623109,
-0.7285010219,
-0.1018318608,
0.1994886398,
0.7984791994,
-0.7412149906,
1.1308178902,
0.887657702,
-0.3056018353,
-0.4262883365,
-0.0710362568,
-0.1282321811,
-0.633208096,
1.1149224043,
0.102215834,
-0.239100486,
-0.0246878769,
-0.563935101,
-0.9677170515,
0.5164484978,
0.0632181689,
-0.0501595847,
0.2321555018,
0.0415879749,
0.748808682,
-0.0559260882,
0.1307804286,
0.4909790158,
0.4060550928,
-0.3607361913,
-0.9339495301,
-0.2921034694,
-0.5231103897,
-0.0917679816,
0.2592852414,
-0.3143597543,
1.1912215948,
0.0774582028,
-0.1521319896,
0.4513786733,
0.913510859,
-0.1248013899,
-0.2291039079,
0.3193580806,
0.6870681047,
0.7057664394,
0.0061050546,
1.2025027275,
-0.3391352892,
0.3113155365,
1.0055379868,
-0.4379018247,
1.0509228706,
0.3884832859,
-0.3037960529,
1.1700237989,
0.7533110976,
0.3469237685,
0.809352994,
0.1128104031,
-0.4509092867,
-0.2878596485,
-0.0959604904,
-0.5585909486,
0.2819040716,
0.3517664671,
0.0678139329,
-0.3977896571,
0.0608132966,
0.2446785271,
0.1832110733,
-0.0335206613,
0.8198184967,
-0.1624585539,
-0.3873233199,
0.5783532262,
0.092804037,
0.7296904922,
-0.7557050586,
0.0872442722,
-0.1575861871,
0.2729252577,
0.0719616935,
-0.4266960621,
0.3092973828,
0.1300259829,
0.0067630005,
-0.6519088149,
0.9027929902,
-0.5028300881,
-0.7564126253,
-0.1374260634,
0.9298295975,
0.1796974838,
-0.3396239579,
-0.7148071527,
-0.2428344786,
0.0136517007,
-0.5426650643,
0.2793717086,
0.6006214023,
0.1090822145,
0.4089978933,
0.7092286348,
0.1216417849,
0.2477206141,
-0.1542848349,
1.0441845655,
-0.527571559,
-0.4131240547,
-0.7125935555,
0.2586252391,
-0.2005516589,
-0.2947961986,
1.0554779768,
0.7070244551,
0.8614369035,
-0.3320678473,
0.7124724984,
-0.0940862298,
1.1849874258,
-0.3772603273,
0.816480875,
-0.3198238909,
-0.0016833832,
0.0139598409,
-1.0091093779,
-0.2909448147,
1.0069304705,
-0.7041404843,
0.0596654639,
0.9114083648,
0.4585646093,
-0.2325752527,
0.4129489958,
-0.1228766441,
0.1646256298,
0.1637544334,
0.4467607141,
1.1773309708,
-0.0727671012,
0.4794948399,
-0.4272150695,
0.0742102414,
-0.2505736947,
-0.6606078148,
-1.2667562962,
-0.5601039529,
-0.0066588647,
-0.0331187174,
0.3724297583,
1.1545904875,
0.7059007883,
-1.0873814821,
-0.5374957919,
0.2226229608,
0.1213626862,
-0.0208011195,
-0.1878428459,
0.5960528255,
-0.6211235523,
-0.6509091258,
0.0436370224,
0.1311132461,
-0.310911566,
-0.086924389,
0.016541956,
-0.7259324789,
0.0449726358,
0.5074708462,
0.401740551,
-0.3851293325,
-0.0791890174,
0.0678408146,
-0.1118588895,
0.2553514838,
0.8795228004,
-0.9092387557,
0.0118306829,
0.2947052121,
0.9740224481,
0.4613587856,
0.3448664844,
0.5301676989,
-0.8720261455,
0.1661754698,
0.3819271326,
0.2608419657,
0.5125764012,
-0.154713586,
0.4002229869,
-0.0134674134,
-0.5013774633,
-0.7060021758,
0.1313652992,
-0.8632038832,
-0.3310970962,
0.951264441,
-0.1294366419,
-0.2139443457,
-0.2493768632,
-0.4753547311,
-0.011988827,
-0.5156456232,
0.8856506944,
0.8798048496,
-0.202771619,
0.0085473051,
-0.7998996973,
0.898814559,
0.9088253379,
-0.9800903797,
-0.2479209006,
0.4181850553,
0.0812677592,
-0.0047153533,
0.6686127782,
0.3989715576,
0.5110737681,
-0.5490267873,
0.1094344333,
0.5025798678,
-0.1693817079,
-0.1932836622,
-0.2304605395,
0.1818197966,
-0.1535404921
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06608v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06608v2
|
TIC: Translate-Infer-Compile for accurate "text to plan" using LLMs and Logical Representations
| 2024-02-09T18:39:13 | 2024-06-29T00:30:04 |
Sudhir Agarwal, Anu Sreepathy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We study the problem of generating plans for given natural language planning
task requests. On one hand, LLMs excel at natural language processing but do
not perform well on planning. On the other hand, classical planning tools excel
at planning tasks but require input in a structured language such as the
Planning Domain Definition Language (PDDL). We leverage the strengths of both
the techniques by using an LLM for generating the PDDL representation (task
PDDL) of planning task requests followed by using a classical planner for
computing a plan. Unlike previous approaches that use LLMs for generating task
PDDLs directly, our approach comprises of (a) translate: using an LLM only for
generating a logically interpretable intermediate representation of natural
language task description, (b) infer: deriving additional logically dependent
information from the intermediate representation using a logic reasoner
(currently, Answer Set Programming solver), and (c) compile: generating the
target task PDDL from the base and inferred information. We observe that using
an LLM to only output the intermediate representation significantly reduces LLM
errors. Consequently, TIC approach achieves, for at least one LLM, high
accuracy on task PDDL generation for all seven domains of our evaluation
dataset.
|
[
-0.1310573965,
-0.7079497576,
0.7674609423,
0.4131068885,
-0.105007574,
0.0755257979,
-0.2952394485,
-0.2126508951,
0.1558486968,
0.6212909818,
-0.6636402607,
-0.4835241139,
-0.4558415115,
0.2085883915,
-0.2858577073,
0.8774754405,
-0.3852131665,
0.0815578401,
-0.2590287626,
0.2512944341,
-0.4290219843,
-0.383962512,
-0.7112740874,
-0.655641973,
0.1680717915,
0.5057775974,
0.4933267236,
0.6449152827,
0.4478443265,
0.2234908491,
0.1339007616,
0.5762482285,
-0.3400513828,
0.0975918099,
-0.2172975987,
-0.4381356239,
-0.6087271571,
-0.0684991479,
0.5980352759,
0.8405964971,
-0.1631638408,
0.1714813113,
0.0311933979,
0.6141932607,
-0.6349004507,
0.4247692525,
-0.6446783543,
0.0014626049,
-0.2034069747,
-0.5072233081,
-0.7899326086,
-0.3227062225,
0.0329501778,
-0.4193365276,
0.0094703464,
-0.0224359371,
0.4625439942,
0.4091151059,
-0.4577714801,
-0.5392531753,
-1.0579553843,
0.732327044,
-0.6155599952,
0.2456505001,
0.4004426599,
0.2472118586,
-0.5872843266,
-0.7433863282,
-0.6501759887,
-0.0591467917,
-0.0480361544,
0.1043039262,
-0.0443074033,
0.2931573689,
0.510307312,
0.1243350133,
-0.5185620189,
-0.1727380455,
-0.1838625818,
-0.1185293868,
0.6573423743,
0.2575531602,
0.1726883948,
-0.1622485667,
-0.4878955185,
0.0695878714,
-1.0579483509,
-0.1134637147,
0.0603155605,
0.2689473033,
-0.093664594,
0.9629401565,
-0.3040911555,
0.6562209129,
0.0589800924,
-0.3591889441,
-0.1911495626,
-0.5240242481,
-0.6377767324,
0.1685165763,
0.5815784335,
0.3800832331,
0.3539418578,
-0.4475877285,
-0.3469926417,
0.1262471676,
0.2911604047,
-0.7677078247,
-0.2090926319,
0.1760561615,
-0.1468820125,
0.0534876324,
-0.1739902496,
-0.4748268127,
-0.1205058247,
-0.5402134657,
0.1830071956,
-0.4435323477,
0.0871197209,
0.1154393032,
0.2534753084,
0.2756098211,
0.4144858122,
-0.6237026453,
0.5660315156,
0.3469010592,
0.6177210808,
-0.2106720805,
-0.0575756617,
-0.8301228881,
0.5246197581,
-0.4516597688,
0.9455660582,
-0.1054289043,
-0.6411311626,
0.1377189904,
-0.3731404543,
0.0294960998,
-0.4601282775,
0.8043076992,
-0.2981681228,
0.0763464645,
-0.2171799839,
-0.6005279422,
-0.1091229543,
0.2206445485,
-0.6672443748,
0.9501312375,
0.1563910097,
-0.5744963884,
0.4139779508,
-0.7514181733,
-0.6454281807,
0.1008967385,
-0.3760945201,
-0.0016405215,
-0.0459873676,
0.3121475279,
0.6618534327,
-0.5536082983,
0.3679302037,
0.2480994016,
-0.0452632234,
0.3081354797,
-0.1751870662,
0.6989146471,
0.245581761,
-0.3536209166,
0.3261003494,
-0.5097743869,
0.1913543642,
0.0624491796,
-0.6480741501,
0.130553931,
0.4680911899,
-0.087422289,
0.1456694454,
0.3410514593,
-0.5831763744,
0.0869199857,
-0.7608971,
0.2209350467,
0.5783503056,
-0.0907251909,
0.8032835126,
-0.3422734439,
0.4070434868,
-0.2769684196,
-0.270026654,
0.2016148418,
-0.3589457273,
-0.7006517053,
0.0334352627,
0.0708746836,
0.5872626901,
-1.3480113745,
0.2478695065,
-0.5819521546,
-0.3935124576,
0.040851783,
-0.0730359852,
0.5147990584,
0.6728683114,
0.3239795864,
0.1221038923,
-0.4561292827,
-0.633303225,
-0.0773681775,
-0.2667262256,
0.1314111203,
-0.1237051114,
0.328951478,
0.0880949199,
0.9728235006,
-0.4792185128,
-0.2904437482,
-0.8656454086,
-0.0273128189,
0.2675574422,
0.1967791915,
0.4436284602,
-0.7799348235,
-0.7640433311,
0.0551216155,
-0.4847635925,
-0.1740400344,
-0.3106520474,
-0.2447319925,
0.3741472661,
0.2746962607,
-0.6151732206,
0.6390270591,
0.310079217,
-0.3992551267,
0.6123395562,
-0.3461348414,
-0.1564761251,
-1.151709199,
-0.0370477587,
0.0492222197,
-0.4634527862,
-0.7271792889,
-0.0373463929,
0.1473860145,
-0.0204064958,
-0.3722913265,
0.7133026123,
-0.4261061549,
0.0139993168,
-0.230536595,
0.1021735072,
-0.1982841045,
0.536260426,
0.1209471896,
0.9730749726,
0.3483273685,
-0.7780869007,
0.4236802459,
0.4008094072,
-0.1530233622,
0.5753319263,
-0.3581101,
0.0665111169,
0.1283996105,
0.2098024935,
-0.6504898667,
-0.2790437043,
0.4907816648,
-0.4468173981,
0.4832004607,
-0.0406970158,
-0.7931214571,
-0.1640046239,
-0.1534379274,
0.1360356808,
0.3384399116,
-0.5599396825,
0.756429255,
0.4223530591,
-0.3014702499,
-0.2399592251,
-1.0274842978,
0.1169428676,
-0.0460386835,
-0.607096076,
0.8728927374,
-0.0151997758,
-0.2897345424,
0.0782813877,
-0.2563872635,
-0.0859646127,
-0.2117872834,
0.2575110793,
0.3359535635,
-0.0286875796,
-0.0978040025,
-0.0409597233,
-0.1628308296,
0.4068503082,
-0.1819523126,
0.6019223928,
0.2214116007,
-0.2132209241,
-0.3369449079,
0.4502835274,
0.2789371312,
-0.2698744833,
0.4850049317,
0.0279559027,
-0.606833756,
-0.6111727357,
-0.3957577348,
0.2223261595,
-0.3766980767,
0.0803823173,
-0.5394698381,
-0.2298622876,
0.2780820131,
-0.3038640916,
0.2353802174,
0.4102828801,
0.6569985151,
-0.1124837026,
0.7921997309,
0.7709721327,
0.3249414265,
0.1978304982,
-0.5026233196,
0.069773376,
-0.7739577293,
-0.3177194595,
-0.4700852334,
-0.2882171273,
-0.2768579125,
-0.6347616911,
0.2815140486,
-0.0924116448,
0.0172810294,
0.5415181518,
-0.3622601032,
0.3008891344,
0.3259911835,
0.0158398543,
0.3377015293,
0.2760621905,
-0.2350126952,
-0.2198461145,
-0.5799505115,
-0.8592857718,
1.309032321,
0.0293765906,
0.7320446968,
0.0922536179,
0.7923546433,
0.0525475703,
0.334522903,
-0.7873182297,
0.8679283261,
-0.3175545335,
-0.3136202395,
-0.1648296714,
-0.4552398324,
-0.6692863107,
-0.1466596574,
-0.2715810239,
-0.6787949204,
0.0320240147,
0.0000694234,
-0.1875945628,
0.3336728215,
-0.6737489104,
0.6521266103,
-0.4602297544,
-0.2398388833,
-0.3409141004,
-0.3885907233,
0.1076932549,
-0.0588455275,
-0.0764815658,
-0.1770034283,
-0.1966973096,
0.6349841952,
-0.4141945243,
0.6133342981,
-0.0327406637,
0.0042685652,
0.2649035156,
0.259945035,
0.8284131289,
0.0128460918,
-0.528441906,
-0.4162940979,
-0.1062111557,
-0.3010516465,
-0.4844860733,
0.4474157095,
-0.4144349992,
-0.3686943054,
-0.4601895511,
-0.7752144933,
-0.3005886972,
0.1982903033,
0.2338543981,
0.6246671081,
-0.3790888488,
-0.2291464061,
0.2882884443,
-0.1391179413,
0.5067142844,
0.0935403407,
-0.2270334512,
-0.3503906727,
0.6977751851,
0.0760510936,
0.4729520082,
0.6653823853,
-0.1497798115,
-0.5220571756,
-0.9561890364,
-0.3838486671,
0.2988987863,
-0.8770815134,
-0.3419643939,
-0.1981702894,
-0.3827194571,
-0.2577982843,
-0.1755572557,
-0.1498627216,
-0.3072090149,
-0.2193724066,
0.0939154103,
0.0791171342,
0.9135872126,
0.1428443193,
0.3040360212,
-0.3950839937,
0.4805399477,
-0.1662590206,
0.0397395119,
-0.6662055254,
-0.1057678014,
-0.2335325629,
0.1729387045,
-0.492062211,
-0.9825754762,
0.6428961754,
0.2060620636,
0.6566597223,
-0.0744730383,
0.4336069226,
0.8345298767,
-0.5047169924,
0.4695122242,
0.1790078282,
-0.6999639273,
0.7967069745,
0.0635229573,
0.2031179368,
0.3805057108,
0.308360368,
-0.1597921848,
-0.3046771586,
-0.6485571861,
-0.5539927483,
0.7606441975,
0.4372345805,
-0.1641242951,
-0.1561580151,
0.4170462191,
0.0043348651,
0.127437979,
-0.6718133092,
-0.1766893715,
0.2430613041,
-0.1144971475,
0.1456803828,
-0.3159247935,
-0.0813434944,
0.0105904276,
0.5455287099,
-0.2733826339,
0.4883779585,
0.3702563047,
-0.1616755873,
-0.1296135485,
0.2359443605,
0.4696991146,
0.9164984226,
-0.1279013008,
0.3400477171,
0.2721526325,
-0.3050255477,
-0.0701789409,
0.1824993342,
-0.3290358186,
0.1110150516,
0.3547409773,
0.4239978194,
0.0072536357,
-0.7274209261,
0.2417343855,
0.0030531147,
-0.2208372951,
-0.3913286924,
-0.072426334,
0.1507796943,
0.18077676,
0.0934746712,
0.2036136091,
-0.0642405376,
-0.4746361673,
-0.0092715286,
0.310602814,
-0.1618712842,
-0.2224010825,
0.5877746344,
0.3509542346,
-0.2998862863,
0.5512188077,
-0.7105510831,
-0.3871912956,
0.5095880032,
0.8173416257,
0.9399632812,
0.1774953604,
0.230090946,
0.4204729199,
0.2051216364,
0.0606688075,
0.7534691691,
-0.0630186498,
-0.6457160711,
-0.9593669772,
-0.5163164735,
-0.4043471217,
-0.3331220746,
-0.2131755352,
0.4458382428,
-0.4788785577,
-0.1458993852,
-0.3422550261,
0.1903079152,
-0.679982543,
0.1436284184,
0.0938255936,
0.8901230693,
-0.2944865823,
1.1462395191,
1.0318695307,
-0.3807429373,
-1.0585278273,
0.1469510347,
-0.1491425633,
-0.6199303865,
1.0021964312,
-0.1250021607,
-0.2706868351,
0.1020170748,
-0.3156006634,
-0.6124508381,
1.206448555,
0.6388093829,
-0.3194729686,
-0.3334820569,
0.5434522629,
0.1866255105,
-0.5003719926,
-0.2316744626,
0.5073609352,
0.3673319817,
0.3716893792,
-1.1390459538,
0.2140496075,
0.0293893125,
-0.1338625997,
0.4597449601,
0.1240980104,
0.6566383243,
-0.3722731173,
-0.7862691283,
0.1058447883,
0.5845387578,
0.2184503973,
0.2175383866,
0.2971871197,
0.4350010157,
0.6832335591,
-0.290253073,
1.193449378,
-0.3094125986,
0.1407671422,
1.2817329168,
-0.2402822077,
1.0338079929,
0.6444845796,
-0.3232042789,
0.1059303731,
0.53213346,
0.3181796074,
0.5210510492,
0.1560673118,
-0.3160569072,
-0.153759256,
-0.1707319766,
0.0231929533,
0.2413936853,
0.5609617829,
-0.0282698181,
-0.5862198472,
-0.2661813796,
-0.0314644463,
0.4429630041,
-0.261790812,
0.5750139356,
0.1345304847,
-0.735568583,
0.3652789891,
0.1529252976,
0.4761960804,
-0.47855708,
-0.1372805387,
-0.085502997,
0.2323311418,
-0.3296791315,
-1.0992008448,
0.8185562491,
0.0525541492,
-0.0214802157,
-0.8085916638,
0.8539144993,
-0.407589227,
-0.562016964,
0.2021928728,
0.5784920454,
0.1322370619,
-0.2791275382,
-0.5135471821,
-0.3032277226,
0.0988715515,
0.142529726,
-0.0272088274,
0.6713707447,
-0.1216037869,
0.7750229836,
0.5618700981,
0.6295560598,
0.2342416346,
-0.2657361329,
0.7592116594,
-0.6409662962,
-0.371530652,
-0.7633544803,
0.5275920033,
-0.0488340743,
-0.1437844634,
0.2842912078,
0.7289937139,
0.9062972665,
-0.0230906308,
0.5981195569,
-0.2725230753,
0.300583154,
-0.8493263125,
0.3770537078,
-0.3690796196,
0.5138055086,
0.1238383055,
-1.0734483004,
-0.2930725813,
0.5626814365,
-0.4059729278,
-0.4301302135,
0.9727268815,
0.6070128679,
0.1634284109,
-0.2846411467,
0.2285144776,
-0.1338824183,
0.6187996268,
0.8526747823,
0.7647556067,
-0.2469234914,
0.8145927191,
-0.4898054302,
-0.0225479957,
0.096455045,
-0.9726474881,
-0.9401690364,
-0.5819789767,
-0.3568528593,
-0.1967622787,
-0.1932129413,
1.0399518013,
0.4706140459,
-0.5214793682,
-0.6713718176,
-0.2867566049,
0.2789046466,
-0.0356983617,
-0.1323577762,
0.3252491057,
-0.5333141088,
-0.7283068299,
0.4861048758,
0.4337731302,
0.0415410884,
-0.2117747366,
-0.4031345844,
-0.2616744041,
-0.1579445601,
0.7463976145,
0.1188929603,
-0.929366231,
-0.1892182678,
0.1106538251,
-0.316681385,
0.130418852,
0.7473624945,
-0.824891746,
0.4328060746,
0.5698132515,
0.6738849878,
0.6986740232,
-0.2971239984,
0.9691070318,
-0.8350628018,
-0.0058662011,
0.3407025337,
0.4261052907,
0.2397779226,
-0.1088754311,
0.8618494272,
-0.0382230468,
-0.4560069442,
-0.4912326038,
0.3813088536,
-1.3040605783,
-0.0450787768,
1.1677128077,
0.1427304149,
-0.2045015097,
-0.2046283484,
-0.531603694,
0.3308181465,
-0.2648911476,
0.1971145421,
0.5254403949,
-0.4899863005,
0.1754416972,
-0.8006209731,
0.5995694399,
0.0004069985,
-0.9776836634,
0.0843317732,
0.4156228304,
0.0013808931,
0.2600817382,
0.86431247,
-0.0510154143,
0.1940226555,
-0.1791044325,
0.1211939454,
0.0914545208,
-0.1926618218,
0.4138469994,
0.0093509583,
0.2772654593,
-0.2172535956
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06592v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06592v1
|
Self-consistent context aware conformer transducer for speech recognition
| 2024-02-09T18:12:11 | 2024-02-09T18:12:11 |
Konstantin Kolokolov, Pavel Pekichev, Karthik Raghunathan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
We propose a novel neural network architecture based on conformer transducer
that adds contextual information flow to the ASR systems. Our method improves
the accuracy of recognizing uncommon words while not harming the word error
rate of regular words. We explore the uncommon words accuracy improvement when
we use the new model and/or shallow fusion with context language model. We
found that combination of both provides cumulative gain in uncommon words
recognition accuracy.
|
[
-0.1506117135,
-0.2816722691,
0.263143152,
-0.0379099101,
-0.2917318046,
-0.4069832563,
0.0433138497,
-0.5945666432,
0.2589920759,
0.307900995,
-0.2083043456,
-0.1284003705,
-0.7762228847,
-0.0012696568,
-0.5106153488,
0.3340484202,
0.2346035987,
0.233655408,
0.3074676692,
-0.5731416345,
-0.6340842843,
-0.3408157527,
-0.7471376061,
-0.4053604305,
0.2018376738,
0.1748452187,
0.3925237358,
0.8683016896,
0.3033568561,
0.5601940751,
-0.2047693431,
-0.1574732959,
-0.0691610128,
0.1835061461,
-0.1966543049,
-0.0193135068,
-0.5956630707,
-0.3132999837,
0.852201581,
0.494664222,
-0.3499023914,
-0.137091592,
0.132480517,
0.4535023868,
-0.6354848742,
0.0296500251,
-0.7342594266,
-0.1318685114,
-0.2629531622,
-0.0528199449,
-0.0589906052,
-0.1341318041,
0.4576563835,
-0.5705065727,
0.1946167946,
-0.2942639589,
0.2371162623,
0.489556253,
-0.4289337695,
-0.358576715,
-0.8894512057,
0.3746585548,
-0.73618716,
0.8815934062,
-0.0846474022,
0.5626716018,
0.1066895351,
-1.3940922022,
-0.7295288444,
0.0601459593,
-0.1154988259,
0.1891373992,
-0.2499629259,
-0.0376385003,
-0.1412314475,
0.2819886804,
-0.4365332723,
-0.1792328656,
-0.6219124198,
-0.4229269624,
0.6824843884,
0.2508966923,
0.0619854704,
0.0792734846,
-0.2480704486,
0.1865055412,
-0.414835155,
0.1520629972,
-0.2420299649,
0.5164972544,
-0.1714815199,
0.1755024344,
-0.0802919939,
1.3657175303,
0.2257917374,
0.0551709607,
0.4998177886,
-0.0985907689,
-0.2815635204,
0.6596902013,
0.731236577,
0.0629043654,
0.1968934238,
-0.0468078852,
-0.369841665,
0.1042015702,
0.3150417805,
-0.320649296,
-0.180444032,
-0.1388029903,
-0.3713782728,
0.0883079916,
0.3240603507,
-0.2310777754,
-0.18264772,
-0.5088745952,
0.6896501184,
-0.5124061704,
-0.1645220369,
0.1787682772,
-0.3621861637,
0.2421580553,
0.3904205263,
-0.6185388565,
0.3103209436,
0.4609753489,
0.9172894359,
-0.2848061621,
-0.0714397058,
-0.4713371992,
0.7073373795,
0.101269111,
0.9325736165,
-0.4739902616,
-0.7090690732,
-0.3159124851,
0.0390881896,
-0.1643209308,
-0.5048406124,
0.5299185514,
-0.5125175714,
-0.0204208679,
-0.0934304148,
-0.8267251253,
-0.2742969394,
0.0775399804,
-0.6504791379,
0.5018461347,
-0.0287011005,
-0.3632106185,
0.1997030973,
-0.7145662904,
-0.5426974297,
0.4268041253,
-0.4098483622,
-0.0823860914,
0.0829147026,
-0.1274263859,
0.4135049582,
0.2468963414,
-0.114408344,
0.0217064861,
-0.7178661823,
0.3053260446,
-0.4080074728,
0.6301516294,
0.4373138845,
-0.4233365953,
0.0876648277,
-1.0462970734,
0.2345497608,
-0.2813820541,
-0.7406010628,
-0.4587590098,
-0.2136429697,
0.3224538267,
-0.0008104851,
0.2213733047,
-0.7882841229,
-0.0893601701,
-0.5104053617,
0.6112783551,
0.7355784178,
-0.1235439926,
0.4970704019,
-0.3356302083,
-0.0147651397,
0.2424459755,
-0.2123194635,
0.1560093611,
-0.605375886,
-0.6828835607,
-0.3433406651,
0.2880727649,
0.4840363264,
-0.1364561468,
0.7179017067,
-0.3186616898,
-0.4266132414,
-0.4685123265,
0.0749072656,
0.2824726999,
0.8740516901,
0.3722652793,
-0.2274071723,
-0.7731038928,
-0.645868361,
-0.6821813583,
0.1379234791,
-0.1023989692,
0.4868986011,
-0.2411162853,
-0.5192635655,
0.9255716801,
-0.2965163887,
-0.7259472609,
-0.1383927017,
0.1418420225,
0.3601403236,
0.8097884655,
0.2561779618,
-0.9021843672,
-0.7523511648,
-0.0807811841,
-0.3820535541,
0.0196917281,
0.3136016428,
0.4918326139,
0.1807065457,
0.8169105649,
-0.1823910624,
0.305264771,
0.6005039215,
-0.3996776044,
-0.2085240036,
-0.1256940216,
-0.1808922589,
-1.0009049177,
0.0165149905,
-0.0296578817,
-0.4128151238,
-0.9652344584,
-0.4040207863,
0.2737714648,
0.2298215032,
-0.5520869493,
0.6459960938,
-0.5469543338,
0.0169995837,
-0.4827535748,
0.1039546803,
-0.169519335,
0.0386853069,
0.3277737498,
0.8493559957,
0.5857535005,
-1.1118513346,
0.5275582075,
0.3359095454,
-0.305921644,
0.5520154238,
-0.9947500825,
0.2950109839,
-0.2695689201,
0.231692329,
-1.0121464729,
-0.0516199395,
0.0348804556,
-0.5454100966,
0.5392462611,
0.2893571258,
0.3892117441,
-0.2912956178,
0.3019819856,
0.5834299922,
0.515108645,
-0.5212201476,
0.9930126667,
0.4099158049,
0.0994194895,
-0.4228360653,
-0.987672627,
-0.1131174788,
0.0731230527,
-0.5753021836,
0.5116209388,
-0.1230775043,
-0.0373576172,
-0.1580923051,
-0.2119960934,
-0.2909022272,
-0.1553113759,
0.297614485,
-0.0866207257,
-0.4260787964,
0.1024683565,
-0.2198873311,
-0.1863163412,
-0.1628531665,
-0.4417209327,
0.4050174057,
-0.7603979111,
-0.1687270105,
-0.6777175069,
0.1555659771,
0.366677314,
0.0964567885,
0.3323611319,
0.6410525441,
-0.3756447136,
0.1356027275,
-0.7472076416,
-0.0030682064,
-0.6064919829,
0.1135342494,
-0.6283701658,
-0.9573200345,
0.4927213192,
0.078883715,
-0.3975964487,
0.6376428604,
0.3389528394,
-0.0205164663,
0.6575176716,
0.421498239,
-0.0291132554,
0.3589905202,
-0.1848347038,
0.1010712534,
-1.1594928503,
-0.2851644456,
-0.346878171,
-0.4515699744,
-0.4272537231,
-0.1868437231,
0.4627522826,
-0.2148210853,
-0.2809135616,
0.3734717667,
-0.930926621,
0.1468584538,
0.8281917572,
0.1107483655,
0.409185648,
-0.3470180929,
-0.2229997218,
0.0175591428,
-0.5968183279,
-0.2524986863,
0.8459867239,
0.2026276141,
0.8915621042,
0.1672749519,
0.4762718976,
0.2488832772,
0.2422994822,
-0.8119997978,
0.3118040562,
-0.2705287635,
-0.718541801,
-0.5998331308,
-0.1028249264,
-0.7214441299,
-0.0990993232,
0.1888119131,
-0.7652469873,
0.7223628759,
0.3857630491,
-0.5284634829,
0.1299483776,
-0.4550674856,
0.3650520146,
-0.0411753617,
0.0891737789,
0.1231232285,
-0.9375681877,
0.1096396297,
0.0095886998,
-0.0392478481,
0.165150553,
-0.2160000205,
0.6376840472,
-0.3823260963,
0.6527718902,
-0.3252931237,
0.0904752165,
0.4950263202,
-0.1163674518,
0.4643796384,
-0.138705194,
-0.4259198308,
0.5696610808,
-0.1141157821,
0.005254399,
-0.4420872927,
0.7697883844,
-0.7240280509,
-0.5403394699,
-0.5246027708,
-0.6821196079,
-0.2437329441,
0.2813980877,
0.7373928428,
0.5819500685,
-0.3361048102,
0.3571074605,
0.6417665482,
0.3298166096,
0.5793161392,
0.9154021144,
0.7134860158,
-0.5851601958,
0.658102572,
0.3231143057,
-0.0379107483,
0.2836838067,
0.3323145509,
-0.553406477,
-0.4663823843,
-0.4612483382,
0.00792058,
-0.5970485806,
-0.3536583185,
-1.0256539583,
-0.8058584929,
-0.8985936642,
-0.3558515012,
-0.4198340476,
-0.5410676599,
-0.2264097482,
0.2066656947,
0.4475244582,
0.9560619593,
-0.4342772365,
0.7299062014,
-1.0516308546,
0.2296874225,
0.6993995905,
0.4169175625,
-0.1345607489,
-0.9384689927,
0.0236447677,
0.0949053168,
-0.2133883536,
-0.7529081702,
0.4243401289,
0.671362102,
0.8209457397,
0.7018905282,
-0.0351647511,
0.7293898463,
-0.7004002333,
0.6436521411,
0.1905482411,
-1.427680254,
0.511441052,
-0.2760534883,
0.6137980223,
0.5239852071,
0.1497254223,
-0.6604174376,
-0.2386857569,
-0.5846675634,
-0.4835853875,
0.6230894923,
-0.0647245273,
0.1887493283,
0.1880088449,
0.5612300634,
-0.1957172006,
0.1614726633,
-0.8105663657,
-0.4199773073,
-0.5665187836,
-0.4894533753,
-0.0511166304,
-0.3297773004,
-0.1527361572,
-0.657048583,
0.6322996616,
-0.1705789864,
0.4799960256,
0.5813233852,
0.0173483603,
-0.2117042989,
0.2488137037,
0.8028361201,
0.3655402362,
-0.1563179344,
0.3145072758,
0.595669508,
-0.8007116318,
0.3372321427,
0.0585541315,
-0.0638466477,
0.3173401356,
0.1853775531,
0.5235611796,
0.1856968999,
-0.2602881789,
0.7423573136,
-0.1151514649,
-0.1066645831,
-0.6483935118,
0.4576034844,
0.27769503,
0.1843210012,
0.3185275495,
0.4175634384,
0.6910199523,
-0.2378046364,
0.446306169,
0.6240466833,
-0.9421448708,
-0.1329323947,
0.6814933419,
0.1894003749,
-0.6376901865,
0.4132383764,
0.188950792,
-0.5571258664,
0.4083693922,
0.9920047522,
0.8744434118,
-1.1847705841,
-0.4137932658,
0.384362638,
0.0252582058,
-0.0275646225,
0.4349615276,
-0.215801388,
-0.9865470529,
0.1069621816,
-0.5321002007,
-0.1426818371,
0.2084065825,
-0.6979407072,
0.3520886302,
-0.6238049865,
0.0433509089,
0.0393377356,
-0.4752450287,
-0.4042492807,
0.6780211926,
0.0930904821,
0.8699132204,
-0.4721289873,
1.1297857761,
0.9376944304,
0.1134763509,
-0.978086412,
-0.1889007092,
0.011352852,
-1.0300046206,
0.7829623222,
0.2237666249,
-0.4860911369,
0.1939287037,
-0.2307893932,
-1.3086429834,
1.3091146946,
0.0050923871,
-0.9425031543,
0.2410403192,
0.0654957965,
0.521782577,
-0.5897929072,
0.0047110496,
0.4697133303,
0.6732472181,
0.6198265553,
-0.8858621716,
0.1598695368,
-0.307307303,
0.3214966357,
0.0618291497,
-0.4273543656,
0.7647433877,
0.0723475218,
-0.145174548,
-0.0082096746,
0.9708867073,
0.226706937,
0.5234473348,
0.7623508573,
0.4340276122,
0.5657712221,
0.1085426062,
0.6744386554,
-0.4785774052,
-0.0871599987,
1.2970895767,
-0.1979067177,
0.716426909,
0.2540124953,
0.2717403471,
0.6120921373,
0.0538829565,
0.0750194788,
0.6720457077,
-0.0653301179,
-0.5670393109,
-0.1759914309,
0.0044795852,
-0.6329522729,
0.8963137865,
0.5206112862,
-0.5030657053,
-0.0174443554,
-0.126726076,
-0.5124473572,
0.0690895766,
-0.4781877995,
1.0549526215,
0.3091417849,
-0.2390541583,
0.5319826007,
-0.0311547313,
0.9053323865,
-0.643868804,
0.0973459631,
0.2346768081,
0.525331378,
-0.2900693417,
-0.4756342173,
0.8606771231,
-0.5294057131,
-0.1337729692,
0.0804833621,
1.1121364832,
-0.4804212451,
-0.4096733332,
0.1367770582,
0.3595467806,
-0.0510434024,
-0.0747526214,
-0.6419050694,
-0.0135174673,
-0.2842783928,
-0.0460797399,
-0.1772949696,
0.5140627027,
0.4451009035,
0.4648757279,
0.3167999685,
0.2663502097,
0.2757066488,
0.008469373,
0.7991334796,
-0.7798586488,
-0.90581429,
-0.5894243121,
0.574180305,
-0.1775402725,
-0.3038429022,
0.7447958589,
0.3967161775,
0.6261973381,
0.0262543913,
0.7240130901,
0.0411603525,
0.8958333731,
-0.2347616851,
0.8326032162,
-0.5534014106,
0.1791971475,
-0.2757189572,
-0.7963596582,
-0.3956319988,
1.0846576691,
-0.0685089827,
0.1344079673,
0.5300613046,
0.6837056279,
-0.370257169,
0.209949404,
0.5656918287,
0.3586363792,
0.0390426852,
0.32091856,
0.5728256106,
-0.8703504801,
0.2651387155,
0.0484507941,
-0.1323921084,
-0.2173340619,
-0.6580325365,
-0.5129115582,
-0.8636679053,
-0.153428942,
-0.3135062456,
0.1073550433,
0.7512476444,
0.8571351171,
-1.0879950523,
-0.280312866,
-0.5647845268,
-0.219579041,
-0.2408103496,
-0.2961835265,
0.0136637483,
-0.1568629444,
-0.5899313092,
0.6561880708,
0.3236116469,
0.4317798913,
-0.0232447442,
-0.3161591589,
-0.0861109644,
0.3023552597,
0.2175914347,
0.4477791786,
-0.6033252478,
-0.525757134,
-0.1763623655,
-0.3242241144,
0.2099579871,
0.8850009441,
-0.9340578318,
0.4825422764,
0.5327605605,
0.5852302909,
0.3032582104,
-0.0040595713,
0.9494355321,
-0.5896728635,
0.3548319638,
0.4349354208,
0.530015707,
0.479757756,
-0.7262940407,
0.3577269316,
0.2931893468,
-0.4883599877,
-0.3706053793,
0.2197178006,
-1.2075366974,
-0.2841631472,
1.0055320263,
-0.1294760704,
-0.2199796885,
-0.5037103295,
-0.0078157745,
0.4111901522,
-0.3925841749,
0.63201195,
0.1200522408,
-0.3669912219,
-0.0388507806,
0.206291467,
0.5882530212,
0.2339538336,
-0.2636975348,
-0.4221464097,
0.4386772811,
0.7474880219,
0.5419970155,
0.8782953024,
-0.0418079309,
0.3055174351,
-0.1296355426,
-0.1322485507,
-0.3302952945,
-0.2155162543,
-0.8294186592,
0.1127638295,
-0.2318072319,
-0.3295174837
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06584v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06584v1
|
G-SciEdBERT: A Contextualized LLM for Science Assessment Tasks in German
| 2024-02-09T18:05:03 | 2024-02-09T18:05:03 |
Ehsan Latif, Gyeong-Geon Lee, Knut Neuman, Tamara Kastorff, Xiaoming Zhai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The advancement of natural language processing has paved the way for
automated scoring systems in various languages, such as German (e.g., German
BERT [G-BERT]). Automatically scoring written responses to science questions in
German is a complex task and challenging for standard G-BERT as they lack
contextual knowledge in the science domain and may be unaligned with student
writing styles. This paper developed a contextualized German Science Education
BERT (G-SciEdBERT), an innovative large language model tailored for scoring
German-written responses to science tasks. Using G-BERT, we pre-trained
G-SciEdBERT on a corpus of 50K German written science responses with 5M tokens
to the Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA) 2015. We
fine-tuned G-SciEdBERT on 59 assessment items and examined the scoring
accuracy. We then compared its performance with G-BERT. Our findings reveal a
substantial improvement in scoring accuracy with G-SciEdBERT, demonstrating a
10% increase of quadratic weighted kappa compared to G-BERT (mean accuracy
difference = 0.096, SD = 0.024). These insights underline the significance of
specialized language models like G-SciEdBERT, which is trained to enhance the
accuracy of automated scoring, offering a substantial contribution to the field
of AI in education.
|
[
-0.2184414864,
-0.8348394632,
0.5037769079,
0.3535939753,
-0.169218123,
0.0939161107,
-0.3432893753,
-0.464992255,
0.3285224736,
-0.0895696208,
-0.3780086637,
-0.7487310767,
-0.6653079987,
0.1944758296,
-0.2713351846,
1.1525634527,
-0.1083855927,
0.5885592699,
-0.6170095801,
-0.0868074372,
-0.0207774155,
-0.4915382564,
-0.4320186079,
-0.5199338198,
0.7369014025,
0.0810745582,
0.3733154237,
0.2266110927,
0.72567904,
0.2689273655,
0.0181244537,
-0.0959924757,
-0.34359622,
0.1869205087,
-0.3915193677,
-0.2589171827,
-0.6471170783,
0.3374434114,
0.7751277685,
0.8921942711,
0.2627057433,
0.4467882216,
0.2700350583,
0.3700181246,
-0.4582619369,
0.3299330473,
-0.2355827391,
0.0180406477,
0.3935047686,
-0.1945233941,
-0.588765204,
-0.459826231,
0.3573579788,
-0.4317843914,
0.3658238351,
-0.2925491929,
0.8052625656,
0.3562122285,
-0.3165357411,
-0.5272734165,
-0.414842993,
0.8756171465,
-0.3040032983,
0.2406241,
-0.0851503015,
0.1962743849,
-0.2796943784,
-0.9841319323,
-0.3101561666,
-0.6239876151,
-0.0913690031,
0.411165148,
-0.0604779497,
-0.1147588715,
0.1567265391,
-0.196286574,
-0.609482944,
0.1878407598,
-0.6982476115,
-0.3265239298,
0.838116765,
0.0393853039,
0.0216806922,
-0.2205550373,
-0.3795954585,
-0.3426406384,
-0.6075775623,
0.3852618337,
0.2902843952,
0.3018704057,
0.2301615328,
0.3410119116,
-0.1921538413,
0.849432826,
-0.0572406761,
0.0413931869,
0.2070375234,
0.0698319674,
0.0016707672,
0.170064196,
0.7962911725,
0.329147011,
0.2177547812,
-0.0511132963,
-0.0076234718,
0.1722029597,
0.3687697649,
-1.0390679836,
-0.4519218504,
0.2901964784,
0.0729232952,
-0.1832270771,
0.0574210435,
-0.4001784027,
-0.0434632711,
-0.2131699175,
0.449470669,
-0.359781146,
0.5163829327,
-0.0617160723,
-0.0339392871,
0.0749348328,
0.762168169,
-0.6958734989,
-0.1681058109,
0.3817646205,
0.7897040248,
-0.4341861904,
-0.3979859054,
-0.4520907402,
-0.002757275,
-0.4089630842,
0.7552568913,
-0.6707310081,
-0.62733078,
-0.3030240238,
-0.1202214658,
-0.0475452319,
-0.0029591192,
0.4803351164,
-0.6711368561,
0.8159530163,
-0.0220067576,
-0.6138346791,
-0.3346113861,
0.2874185443,
-0.2368470877,
1.1826709509,
0.130401358,
-0.6242539287,
0.6639908552,
-1.0002949238,
-0.4007603824,
0.3731264472,
-0.0269640479,
0.1061424389,
-0.0563050881,
0.3652751744,
0.8228131533,
0.0150110889,
0.6544433236,
-0.2297380567,
-0.7441518903,
0.069688119,
-0.3096438348,
0.6501733661,
-0.0846360251,
-0.1722130775,
0.4157200158,
-0.6680545211,
0.6154907942,
-0.199031055,
-0.7267963886,
-0.3545022607,
0.0704699233,
0.0896690041,
0.2252229154,
0.5106081963,
-0.7767580748,
0.2658857107,
-0.353716284,
0.4570924044,
0.708001256,
-0.2196508646,
0.4025774896,
-0.0925075635,
0.335387826,
-0.479911536,
-0.0859721303,
0.1517161429,
-0.3684940636,
-0.5100528002,
-0.5965955257,
0.5956713557,
0.6665030122,
-0.2914211452,
0.8300975561,
-0.4953434467,
-0.9350762367,
-0.6303428411,
0.0346581861,
0.0405258946,
0.9364141226,
0.5543113947,
-0.2156173438,
-0.0650035217,
-0.8442165256,
-0.1672123373,
-0.1823687851,
-0.3641755879,
0.4146356583,
0.8819049001,
-0.4074082673,
1.1481039524,
-0.6003878117,
-0.1672443151,
-0.0711000785,
0.4104651809,
0.316202879,
0.4700940251,
0.5451020598,
-0.5498927832,
-0.5814954042,
-0.2475182265,
-0.890124619,
-0.2787200809,
0.3504852951,
0.2203017473,
0.3252401352,
0.4181076586,
-0.3973563612,
-0.0170301534,
0.526001811,
-0.2881633341,
0.6464893818,
-0.4191239774,
0.4344691336,
-0.8641992211,
0.4015232921,
0.0721225739,
-0.1335894167,
-0.6459777951,
0.2531628609,
0.2269979566,
0.0113836015,
-0.7306901217,
0.7294333577,
-0.0028732957,
0.1339035481,
-0.2664739788,
0.3464193046,
0.0004059385,
0.3635810316,
0.1702014953,
0.8041838408,
0.5856606364,
-0.5170912147,
0.4867950976,
0.0818231553,
-0.4322434664,
0.5139346719,
-0.9835773706,
0.2230340093,
-0.2253845483,
0.5838043094,
-0.9391899705,
-0.4825565815,
-0.062040735,
-0.6249614954,
0.3658007979,
0.3293600082,
-0.4197369516,
-0.4228239655,
-0.2890433967,
0.0904227197,
0.4634570777,
-0.7017992735,
0.6231669188,
-0.063905932,
-0.4939004481,
-0.6369968653,
-0.3894609809,
-0.0758152902,
-0.1702894419,
-0.8337635994,
0.377047658,
-0.2180024534,
-0.0314141773,
0.0904165059,
-0.0520923473,
0.1461585313,
0.2767160833,
0.126735419,
0.5196828842,
-0.02601487,
0.4932930768,
0.2118471414,
-0.0054335683,
0.1951247901,
-0.0020847043,
0.4758929312,
-0.4676365852,
-0.2871760428,
0.0924610347,
0.3898677826,
0.5053442121,
0.2424942404,
0.518255353,
0.6896238923,
-0.2412882447,
-0.1494045854,
-0.2536182404,
-0.4139203131,
-0.458409965,
0.6701064706,
-0.3239536583,
-1.3060823679,
0.2760589421,
-0.0572544858,
0.1272648871,
0.4632843137,
0.6344146132,
-0.6554324031,
1.1994413137,
0.6292036176,
-0.2108731419,
0.1173253283,
0.0858623907,
0.35482198,
-0.5845403671,
-0.1784467697,
-0.4284901917,
-0.3188551664,
-0.3993480206,
-0.314173162,
0.793526113,
0.0589877889,
-0.3741129041,
0.1421060115,
-0.7803578377,
0.4305044115,
0.7398052216,
0.0363299809,
0.0756788254,
0.0053719776,
-0.1824970245,
-0.1013455689,
-0.7119313478,
-0.9060635567,
0.9988670945,
0.3379911184,
0.6531386971,
-0.2159561217,
0.7992225885,
0.4639598429,
0.6924708486,
-0.8504155874,
0.6673976183,
0.0719074532,
-0.6155714393,
-0.5768859982,
-0.1924921274,
-0.6635933518,
0.5147143602,
-0.1686412394,
-0.913059175,
-0.4518568516,
0.1235255003,
-0.1203150973,
-0.2849324346,
-0.8414947987,
0.7199289799,
-0.4400267005,
-0.5249013305,
-0.3749641776,
-0.7240704894,
0.0498537496,
-0.332324177,
0.0930947512,
-0.1294758171,
0.1239010394,
1.157589674,
0.1828731447,
0.9040915966,
-0.3104269505,
0.0251006093,
0.105297856,
-0.0777731836,
0.3830655813,
0.1836648732,
-0.1567674875,
0.2172133625,
0.183651045,
-0.4880991876,
-0.6604607701,
0.8920077085,
-0.7666252851,
-1.0552148819,
-0.8221005797,
-0.9773659706,
-0.3096275032,
0.0810830072,
0.1642942131,
-0.0563571304,
-0.3672693968,
0.1439636946,
0.4431932569,
-0.2888253629,
0.2965439558,
0.8511829376,
0.1710156947,
-0.125863269,
0.7393589616,
-0.0184490718,
0.0877520293,
0.057512179,
0.2232171148,
-0.4027563632,
-0.0762321949,
-0.4734091163,
0.0824748427,
-1.1589432955,
-0.0363589004,
-0.6459060907,
-0.2677963078,
-0.5327739716,
-0.7778901458,
-0.0080748117,
-0.3774436414,
-0.3527839184,
-0.1880816668,
0.1783373952,
0.6480340362,
-0.1038051918,
0.1757009774,
-0.6951969266,
-0.2688727081,
0.025782181,
0.1291992068,
-0.3630405664,
-0.6717073917,
-0.056910634,
-0.0178173911,
-0.2352532148,
-0.6021091938,
0.2964794636,
0.3578450382,
0.5578994751,
0.0407977365,
-0.245277226,
0.3754686117,
-0.5819376111,
1.0186351538,
0.1630649865,
-1.0451375246,
0.7250374556,
-0.2231770605,
0.4595807195,
0.3723543882,
0.8948035836,
-0.5619878769,
-0.4980494976,
-0.4636867344,
-1.0131603479,
0.6135311127,
-0.4376370013,
0.429343611,
0.1375559121,
0.0743615031,
0.2865978777,
0.1461151093,
-0.9696683288,
0.1518675834,
-0.3509310782,
-0.4223076701,
-0.4490037262,
-0.0270931125,
-0.4359039962,
-0.673209548,
0.8847478628,
-0.455588609,
0.2546858191,
0.3065112233,
-0.2441842109,
0.1354771703,
0.5140334964,
0.6672705412,
0.6414874196,
-0.347211808,
-0.0881193504,
0.3654985428,
-0.5630096197,
0.2128852457,
0.222973451,
-0.3018149734,
-0.1719994545,
0.7847312093,
0.4953463972,
0.1094785705,
-0.8277803063,
0.3493701518,
0.2491861582,
-0.5265554786,
-0.1323939413,
0.4150860906,
0.0796818063,
0.2447142154,
0.6176893711,
-0.2033170611,
0.0291372035,
-0.2909715772,
0.1512268484,
0.5292547345,
-0.5460221767,
-0.0769310296,
0.5932211876,
0.1581189185,
-0.0414139256,
0.5357397199,
-0.2343865186,
-0.8383609056,
0.5848001242,
0.601131916,
0.4578799903,
-0.2864754498,
0.4323858321,
0.5944570899,
0.2685262561,
0.164703235,
0.3472275436,
-0.2260270566,
-0.5222520232,
-0.3297326565,
-0.8839341402,
-0.7037031651,
-0.1025688648,
-0.4823084176,
0.1632789522,
-0.4069390297,
-0.1360866278,
-0.1115967184,
0.0404209755,
-0.5442689657,
0.502687335,
-0.159975633,
1.0003294945,
-1.1370406151,
0.9045861363,
1.1091963053,
-0.1261884421,
-0.7754009962,
-0.1930942237,
-0.419165045,
-0.7031853199,
1.2769958973,
0.2916768789,
-0.1347032934,
0.0723701343,
-0.6962706447,
-1.173512578,
1.1003292799,
0.0090914704,
-0.2283917069,
0.143771708,
0.0502728745,
1.0866543055,
-0.4218584299,
0.4443961382,
0.4925746024,
0.5148448944,
0.0691356957,
-0.6850503087,
-0.0339840613,
-0.3033174872,
-0.4345528185,
0.000424719,
-0.4765866995,
0.654617548,
-0.1838557273,
-0.0940365195,
-0.2159897536,
0.8996576667,
0.35234496,
0.262534529,
0.1517599374,
0.2695940733,
0.9647277594,
-0.4440069199,
0.6886067986,
-0.4115956426,
0.3595790565,
0.7580093145,
-0.5155430436,
0.8373419642,
0.6677415371,
-0.0957672298,
0.6915971041,
0.7256798744,
-0.5166950226,
0.6083238125,
0.4175748229,
-0.3035103679,
-0.1989167035,
-0.0796847939,
-0.1169538647,
0.6432132721,
0.5765020251,
-0.2798361778,
-0.2925255001,
0.3169735968,
-0.0740298405,
0.0886030346,
-0.3253257871,
0.2269366533,
-0.141365692,
-0.9536579847,
0.403722018,
0.0403176025,
0.6664606929,
-0.7070140243,
0.1839653701,
0.0466193259,
0.0768420473,
-0.173603341,
-1.0099081993,
0.0792002082,
0.2057290077,
-0.1543074846,
-0.2781578004,
0.6675114036,
-0.4018135667,
-0.6067048311,
0.2974578142,
0.3000657558,
0.2731550932,
0.5050224066,
-0.5375323296,
-0.1989745498,
-0.3134780526,
-0.4932307005,
0.2915463746,
-0.2746506035,
-0.2937885523,
0.8087867498,
0.4899058342,
-0.0331104994,
-0.17236875,
0.0486844666,
0.6360459924,
-0.3135648966,
-0.5571770072,
-0.5832393169,
0.4344750941,
-0.0714295134,
-0.2350019366,
0.7734204531,
0.3956022561,
0.8313634396,
-0.3540032208,
0.9870459437,
-0.2739805281,
0.5031843781,
-0.2662063837,
0.7011212111,
-0.4654196203,
-0.1767309159,
-0.322190851,
-0.8520477414,
-0.5152632594,
0.7072361708,
-0.7122979164,
0.2169187516,
0.837880373,
0.5550105572,
0.1368866265,
-0.0224342477,
0.1462027729,
-0.0956891105,
0.4459666908,
0.5836899877,
0.7332464457,
-0.1293947399,
0.1555456072,
-0.1132254153,
-0.4282294512,
-0.2017620355,
-0.9577475786,
-1.1846363544,
-0.5749993324,
-0.3793515861,
-0.0404025577,
0.1042345911,
0.9432303309,
0.3510020971,
-0.8747960925,
-0.0320601724,
0.3574912846,
-0.2439512759,
0.020347083,
-0.2689234316,
0.7759838104,
-0.4717038274,
-0.866424799,
0.6271218061,
0.305957675,
0.0211639665,
-0.2796569765,
0.0402348936,
-0.0229106545,
0.1525256038,
0.5684939623,
-0.0031565162,
-0.7586621642,
-0.8730386496,
0.262327075,
-0.4786877632,
-0.186263755,
0.3357512057,
-0.8811068535,
0.335725069,
0.5044350624,
0.383066237,
0.382829994,
0.0349662155,
0.5183112621,
-0.7959353924,
0.0535349846,
0.5141127706,
0.334561348,
0.5220082402,
-0.5375874043,
0.5495774746,
0.0850049481,
-0.7147786617,
-0.6284154654,
0.0020629307,
-0.8914477229,
-0.4373991489,
0.8988576531,
-0.397352159,
-0.1429816186,
0.2486323714,
-0.1552968174,
0.2121738493,
-0.2301616371,
1.0877226591,
1.0858978033,
-0.2849247754,
0.4243018925,
-0.3667079806,
0.375066638,
0.6908294559,
-0.695605576,
-0.4165475965,
0.5546258092,
0.3170212507,
0.3964208364,
0.2988022566,
0.1878426224,
0.5872274637,
-0.3522230089,
0.2057076842,
-0.0751985684,
-0.482650429,
-0.2125868946,
0.5676541924,
-0.1648773104,
0.1610251218
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06563v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06563v1
|
What is Hiding in Medicine's Dark Matter? Learning with Missing Data in Medical Practices
| 2024-02-09T17:27:35 | 2024-02-09T17:27:35 |
Neslihan Suzen, Evgeny M. Mirkes, Damian Roland, Jeremy Levesley, Alexander N. Gorban, Tim J. Coats
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.IT, math.IT
|
Electronic patient records (EPRs) produce a wealth of data but contain
significant missing information. Understanding and handling this missing data
is an important part of clinical data analysis and if left unaddressed could
result in bias in analysis and distortion in critical conclusions. Missing data
may be linked to health care professional practice patterns and imputation of
missing data can increase the validity of clinical decisions. This study
focuses on statistical approaches for understanding and interpreting the
missing data and machine learning based clinical data imputation using a single
centre's paediatric emergency data and the data from UK's largest clinical
audit for traumatic injury database (TARN). In the study of 56,961 data points
related to initial vital signs and observations taken on children presenting to
an Emergency Department, we have shown that missing data are likely to be
non-random and how these are linked to health care professional practice
patterns. We have then examined 79 TARN fields with missing values for 5,791
trauma cases. Singular Value Decomposition (SVD) and k-Nearest Neighbour (kNN)
based missing data imputation methods are used and imputation results against
the original dataset are compared and statistically tested. We have concluded
that the 1NN imputer is the best imputation which indicates a usual pattern of
clinical decision making: find the most similar patients and take their
attributes as imputation.
|
[
-0.1267080605,
-0.2984236181,
0.6925937533,
-0.1128800809,
-0.3392933607,
0.0392089523,
0.3263785839,
-0.4901015162,
0.2712290287,
0.5093371272,
-0.797791779,
-0.5386787057,
-0.8137679696,
-0.038142737,
-0.0840705559,
1.0323810577,
0.1358601004,
0.2979492247,
-0.1305476725,
-0.3849235773,
-0.3848952055,
-0.6880913377,
-0.4231811166,
-0.2352197617,
0.5224615335,
0.5347946882,
0.6128482819,
1.1135007143,
1.0539214611,
0.0636920556,
-0.190336287,
0.0718310252,
-0.5027776361,
-0.0037259154,
-0.0434107408,
-0.419282645,
-0.1693079174,
-0.2331992239,
0.3016987145,
1.1568646431,
-0.1075746268,
-0.1034512445,
-0.3182830811,
0.8310215473,
-0.4698412716,
0.0075847087,
-0.2653564513,
0.7520738244,
-0.0100603346,
-0.4999085367,
-0.0954899341,
-0.2522093952,
0.4081355035,
-0.323404789,
0.954308033,
-0.0058122994,
0.7136244774,
0.4177032709,
-0.3510453105,
-0.5207803249,
-0.7520919442,
0.4430470467,
-0.2425683141,
0.1606568694,
0.5393825173,
0.3702949584,
-0.0342109837,
-0.5704450011,
-0.4411311746,
-0.1345875263,
-0.3253635764,
0.3425073326,
0.2504857779,
0.1546712071,
0.1479795575,
0.4557252228,
-0.3605583906,
0.1873466372,
-0.786783576,
-0.0754251182,
0.5265926719,
0.5591871738,
0.282089293,
0.1221411973,
-0.3489099741,
-0.2024905384,
-0.9594271779,
-0.3280930817,
0.4274523556,
0.1333222687,
-0.247942552,
0.4214498699,
0.1449501067,
0.4825649261,
0.0541742295,
-0.0592067093,
0.2329372019,
-0.2745740414,
-0.2411144227,
0.375359118,
0.4294858575,
0.3792554438,
-0.2234310955,
-0.2714141905,
-0.1695705652,
0.0392285995,
0.3102777004,
-0.371707201,
-0.4610801339,
0.0979502797,
-0.6763322949,
-0.3644690812,
0.0830778405,
-0.659001112,
-0.7902325392,
-0.2175377011,
0.1804385036,
-0.4090182483,
-0.282710731,
0.0032285638,
-0.071290113,
0.0176692884,
0.5194717646,
-0.5404804349,
0.6402724385,
0.4937186241,
0.4989187121,
0.1230144352,
-0.019294383,
-0.0474007986,
0.0534453057,
-0.7474128604,
0.4024437666,
-0.5342561007,
-0.3695880473,
-0.1792339534,
0.3724525571,
0.1081022695,
-0.769749701,
0.6017916799,
-0.0757538453,
0.1775608808,
-0.2481401414,
-0.4005726278,
-0.5361436009,
-0.2101359963,
-0.6135451198,
0.6958484054,
0.2550166249,
-0.5343868136,
0.9045696855,
-0.3864428401,
-0.4065055251,
0.0461808033,
-0.3414218426,
-0.8715642691,
0.2770307064,
-0.0487442128,
0.5200924277,
-0.242569536,
0.1213357076,
-0.3327682912,
-0.3414458632,
0.3847813606,
-0.5248655081,
0.5164635181,
0.3063705266,
-0.0951336995,
-0.4484893382,
-0.9282265902,
-0.1259308308,
0.2713473141,
0.1141289324,
-0.3099734187,
0.0910104141,
0.0784258544,
0.4634353817,
-0.4591578245,
-0.5015652776,
-0.1927857846,
-0.2303464413,
0.009680273,
0.4541609287,
0.6518563032,
0.0108624231,
-0.818778038,
0.2629444897,
0.6362446547,
0.3051567972,
-0.1999746263,
-0.4344381094,
-0.4715633392,
-0.1491535753,
-0.0998467207,
0.2106507421,
-0.1704010218,
0.1430275291,
0.0260143839,
-0.4722586274,
-0.9203262925,
-0.4905751944,
0.4500183165,
1.0573529005,
0.3348420262,
-0.3252511621,
-0.5444983244,
-1.1350016594,
-0.0704744831,
-0.1391337812,
0.0373506397,
0.4766397178,
0.5640193224,
-0.1320056766,
0.561206758,
-0.4522346854,
-0.4123800397,
0.0602374226,
-0.2521203458,
0.4458886981,
0.7574118376,
0.3720894456,
-1.0544099808,
-0.269772321,
0.158904478,
-0.8883110881,
0.1014021635,
-0.3201811612,
0.4647482634,
0.0833404958,
0.0398681164,
-0.1913994253,
0.9671754241,
-0.1163154617,
-0.2321599275,
0.16979599,
-0.5517359376,
0.2231498808,
-0.3794979155,
0.2733267546,
-0.1015381739,
-0.2297628969,
-0.8762975335,
-0.1185852364,
0.2670494616,
-0.2878566086,
-0.5752171874,
0.2409823984,
-0.5487914085,
0.1090029925,
0.147884503,
-0.4041199386,
-0.0878238082,
0.5110166669,
-0.0925145671,
0.4622685313,
0.8408555984,
-0.6930472851,
-0.0026936904,
0.0202656183,
-0.0111184642,
0.3810566366,
-0.3950540721,
0.4062042236,
-0.6010318398,
-0.1976808757,
-0.7828688622,
-0.3339443207,
0.4667991996,
-0.373172462,
0.5173607469,
-0.6192299724,
-0.4542972744,
-0.4532043934,
-0.023518322,
0.234419629,
0.3757976592,
-0.0840323344,
0.0779590979,
0.7295473218,
-0.3634130657,
-0.6561709046,
-0.8790974617,
-0.0044978121,
-0.3917196393,
-0.0323766023,
0.1909157783,
0.0443183854,
-0.3718565404,
0.2365018576,
-0.3779462278,
-0.4807914793,
0.0695888624,
0.4788348675,
0.2369832397,
-0.2565442622,
0.2098412067,
-0.0158408191,
-0.3661603332,
0.017777374,
0.0201348905,
0.3145369887,
0.1218335778,
-0.7875290513,
-0.5548691154,
0.4712585509,
0.6324954629,
0.4843825698,
0.7217033505,
-0.0791677088,
-0.9185168147,
0.03759785,
-0.4220424592,
-0.2021407485,
-0.3244288564,
0.3695131242,
0.0975110978,
-0.1621482819,
0.72965765,
0.2892216742,
-0.1504845768,
0.430193156,
0.4298389852,
-0.2420814633,
0.6930416822,
0.5809226036,
0.2675277889,
0.0026924822,
-0.2061696649,
0.2596594393,
-0.3534529805,
-0.475564152,
-0.2175097317,
-0.2141428441,
-0.5000246763,
-0.1445811987,
0.6820179224,
-0.1887873113,
0.0123123564,
-0.2092634737,
-0.8139154315,
0.518650949,
0.2032073736,
0.7422865033,
0.1241268739,
-0.1322550327,
0.0356631242,
-0.3176495433,
-0.8777357936,
-0.1178157032,
1.2524546385,
0.3987299204,
0.482822597,
-0.1327271461,
0.7169280648,
0.3744407594,
0.275462389,
-0.6218430996,
0.065204829,
0.1270320863,
-0.6008198857,
-0.138817817,
-0.360327065,
-0.9862216115,
0.3500866592,
-0.1894664317,
-0.3639428318,
0.3640631139,
-0.088395521,
-0.4355801046,
0.3782610595,
-0.7362926602,
0.1508726329,
-0.0475720651,
-0.4224504828,
-0.227181673,
-0.9599083066,
0.2018918842,
-0.2417039871,
0.1336646378,
0.1671566367,
-0.0556221902,
0.9790480137,
-0.830076158,
0.7715004086,
-0.2351039499,
0.3449627757,
0.3023121357,
-0.1486391574,
0.4448771477,
0.070762217,
0.2876320779,
0.0696409196,
0.030371977,
-0.4952884614,
-0.5147386789,
0.5195073485,
-0.561187923,
-0.3045091033,
-0.8143026233,
-0.4279258847,
-0.1690772176,
-0.0760536417,
0.1234929115,
0.6448842883,
0.1084556654,
0.2088169008,
0.8576110005,
-0.3553805053,
0.5291776061,
0.6649256349,
0.3889187276,
-0.3547590971,
0.5962159038,
0.7605707049,
-0.1451048851,
0.381732136,
0.2389771044,
-0.0397784486,
-0.8497062922,
-0.3582636714,
0.3918714523,
-0.7260454893,
0.0009618965,
-0.7989357114,
-0.4313550889,
-0.1916953921,
-0.2338235825,
-0.0675640255,
-0.3404163122,
-0.1645845622,
-0.3726593256,
0.4659857154,
0.7359852791,
-0.0103661129,
0.284312129,
-0.6517922282,
0.2515239716,
-0.2171494365,
0.3634662032,
0.0719775707,
-0.185553208,
-0.284810394,
-0.1842280477,
-0.1316722929,
-0.9406260848,
0.5395021439,
-0.2155143768,
0.510175705,
0.6646678448,
-0.0804071203,
0.8555282354,
-0.3303418756,
0.5100436211,
0.4605099857,
-0.1848527491,
0.2825295329,
-0.4203788638,
-0.3593829274,
0.5444987416,
0.387845993,
-0.7188726664,
0.0859158486,
-1.376962781,
-0.8375170231,
0.9551030397,
0.1159932688,
-0.4559524953,
0.231533438,
0.3227955401,
0.5193731189,
0.2931875885,
-0.2875400186,
-0.9852987528,
0.2864737511,
-0.4346395731,
0.1076417342,
0.1562068164,
-0.2674007714,
-0.2682297826,
0.1992026567,
0.1119248495,
0.6189421415,
0.5703609586,
-0.0664252192,
-0.3798264861,
-0.145328939,
0.5681836009,
1.1066759825,
-0.1516301185,
0.177399382,
0.2542466521,
-0.9618019462,
0.0835110396,
-0.008238771,
0.0497415848,
0.246887058,
0.3939920962,
0.4424820542,
0.088542439,
-0.4843545556,
0.6337344646,
0.1081429049,
-0.1582051963,
-0.5232264996,
0.0383163877,
-0.3325180113,
-0.182563439,
0.6927036047,
0.5381553769,
-0.0061111851,
-0.6004430056,
0.6200751066,
-0.1749612391,
-0.8301256895,
-0.5714675784,
0.4218563437,
-0.4681485295,
-0.2861878276,
0.3654159606,
0.4158857167,
-0.2885087132,
0.9541698694,
0.5219048262,
0.4824841619,
-0.0351337753,
0.2248142064,
0.0896691009,
0.4193241298,
0.1714393497,
0.4678993523,
0.1948366463,
-0.1026192084,
-0.0412985347,
0.086372748,
-0.4526807368,
0.5617431998,
-0.6248301864,
0.3304954767,
-0.7672561407,
0.2378173321,
-0.153186515,
0.1590507925,
-1.0673314333,
0.7748999596,
-0.1392975301,
0.5931262374,
-0.7778443098,
0.3719381094,
0.3872461319,
-0.487421006,
-0.6252900362,
-0.1027480066,
0.255384475,
-0.9905939698,
0.4111481607,
-0.2068816274,
0.5334794521,
-0.3490319848,
-0.4616129398,
-0.7117508054,
0.5442621112,
0.082445316,
-0.4043535888,
0.156701237,
0.3582465649,
0.6047056913,
-0.1252190173,
0.5227807164,
0.143873319,
0.3651077747,
0.0180306751,
-0.4400770664,
0.0669243932,
-0.1861603856,
-0.6770077944,
0.5790554881,
-0.5560557842,
0.6315459609,
-0.4561198652,
-0.2903380394,
-0.4916934967,
-0.1034596488,
-0.0185411703,
0.9552057981,
-0.0749418139,
0.5327032208,
1.2227617502,
0.0111553548,
1.0707660913,
-0.0427219123,
0.2073342651,
0.7426239848,
-0.296243012,
0.0499198623,
0.4416984022,
-0.3364555836,
0.0298245773,
0.7337555885,
-0.0283973422,
0.8782014251,
0.0065982188,
-0.2727319002,
0.3523505032,
0.0658882335,
-0.5287528038,
-0.0178011935,
0.6550055146,
-0.6730104685,
-0.146080792,
-0.0240620151,
0.2578068376,
-0.4215530157,
-0.3509805202,
0.972407043,
0.1050185934,
-0.3696231544,
0.6192334294,
-0.3036632538,
-0.2345334589,
-0.7582984567,
-0.3652592003,
-0.296898663,
0.1545928866,
-0.3632874191,
-0.9349631071,
0.3706900179,
-0.3813017011,
-0.3331661522,
-0.1759553701,
0.8257965446,
-0.1354841888,
-0.4836412668,
-0.0832435563,
0.6976456046,
0.4358908832,
0.3980562687,
-0.4712931216,
-0.4644580185,
-0.1031590924,
0.2818390131,
0.5531612635,
0.9368984699,
-0.2521870732,
0.6922494769,
0.7169582844,
0.568938911,
-0.1475719512,
-0.087745823,
0.8241937757,
-0.7185701728,
-0.7490723729,
-0.7432253957,
0.2358914912,
-0.0750680119,
-0.6877821684,
0.4801440537,
0.5623185635,
0.4735306799,
-0.1758518815,
0.7876554728,
0.1747781932,
0.8144745827,
-0.2990733087,
1.0070859194,
-0.1505095959,
0.0467786528,
-0.3219721913,
-0.2610049546,
-0.6973054409,
0.2415031344,
-0.1933821887,
-0.2653061748,
0.8281524777,
0.8674824238,
-0.4309440553,
0.2160632014,
0.5430988073,
0.1406510025,
-0.0303759612,
0.587305665,
0.712036252,
-0.6291695833,
0.0541053042,
-0.5053559542,
-0.3940946758,
-0.3315035999,
-0.373978138,
-0.5787423849,
-0.4091763198,
-0.3617558777,
-0.2656558156,
0.2119831145,
0.8202586174,
0.9842821956,
-0.8503232002,
0.3642695844,
-0.1017205343,
0.2982634008,
-0.5843965411,
-0.1986018866,
0.8427006006,
0.1661945134,
-0.1213584468,
0.4206039608,
0.3316352367,
0.2818647027,
0.4160102308,
0.0866468474,
0.0479604974,
-0.387036562,
-0.1144849807,
0.2426691055,
-0.3448235095,
-0.0702744946,
-0.1891889423,
0.1661232859,
0.5638272166,
0.9899482131,
-1.0843117237,
0.4444314241,
0.2274339646,
0.6603690386,
0.4663313329,
-0.24094069,
0.2317413092,
-0.6840242743,
0.1995470822,
0.7512714863,
0.3060738146,
0.2644648254,
-0.7577769756,
0.6783798933,
0.6283254623,
-0.3203260005,
-1.1313269138,
-0.09062998,
-0.3133559525,
-0.2750993967,
0.5374285579,
-0.0296981353,
-0.2855688035,
-0.7652208805,
-0.0559361055,
0.2821790874,
-0.2847712934,
0.8688301444,
0.3908931017,
-0.3691559732,
-0.3170652986,
-0.7475816607,
0.4860190153,
0.3562582135,
-0.4178825021,
-0.1163408458,
0.311953187,
0.3363805711,
0.1289311349,
0.4078205824,
-0.3203498721,
0.3391572535,
0.2322694957,
-0.4195993245,
-0.2052032799,
-0.488463372,
-0.4570160806,
0.5454266667,
-0.7161778212,
-0.3411718607
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13812v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.13812v1
|
Quantitative Analysis of AI-Generated Texts in Academic Research: A Study of AI Presence in Arxiv Submissions using AI Detection Tool
| 2024-02-09T17:20:48 | 2024-02-09T17:20:48 |
Arslan Akram
|
cs.DL
|
cs.DL, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG, stat.OT, 62P25, I.7; G.1; G.3
|
Many people are interested in ChatGPT since it has become a prominent AIGC
model that provides high-quality responses in various contexts, such as
software development and maintenance. Misuse of ChatGPT might cause significant
issues, particularly in public safety and education, despite its immense
potential. The majority of researchers choose to publish their work on Arxiv.
The effectiveness and originality of future work depend on the ability to
detect AI components in such contributions. To address this need, this study
will analyze a method that can see purposely manufactured content that academic
organizations use to post on Arxiv. For this study, a dataset was created using
physics, mathematics, and computer science articles. Using the newly built
dataset, the following step is to put originality.ai through its paces. The
statistical analysis shows that Originality.ai is very accurate, with a rate of
98%.
|
[
-0.5784686804,
-1.0610481501,
0.2266363204,
0.0919929743,
0.0096338242,
-0.0115390467,
0.2354697138,
-0.4652157724,
0.1100980118,
0.3081695139,
-0.170255065,
-0.2783675194,
-0.6039118767,
0.2583176196,
-0.8870059252,
1.2824902534,
0.0447778367,
-0.1647916734,
-0.3806303442,
-0.2365671992,
-0.1297177821,
-0.3944195807,
-1.0204290152,
-0.0899273977,
0.4033043683,
0.1429017782,
0.6063200831,
0.7542646527,
0.8177088499,
0.3633756042,
-0.0003309308,
-0.1504923552,
-0.3407180607,
-0.2193436921,
0.0356248617,
-0.2910612226,
-0.2375920266,
0.0842698663,
1.0934571028,
0.2581633925,
-0.0661503747,
0.3137996197,
0.2691108286,
0.4766942263,
-0.3540340662,
0.0343586281,
-0.5741645098,
0.1568163484,
-0.3479183912,
-0.1823606193,
-0.3876657486,
-0.5067902803,
0.0268410891,
-0.5946193337,
0.2900129557,
0.3099867105,
0.5520777106,
0.2824520171,
-0.2853507698,
-0.4310279787,
-0.8155403137,
0.6849231124,
-0.6823070049,
0.0001192957,
0.077377677,
0.0172287263,
-0.2826340199,
-0.7210291028,
-0.8585538268,
-0.3314621449,
-0.2544235289,
0.0082608704,
-0.5898385048,
-0.1762873679,
0.1601231396,
0.3980059326,
-1.0746209621,
-0.1082372367,
-0.3939307034,
-0.0712798089,
0.7141973972,
0.016147295,
0.8599224091,
0.1581149995,
-0.1238060668,
-0.2499655336,
-0.5004452467,
-0.0053903628,
0.6384145617,
-0.2894439399,
0.1381751597,
0.8799602985,
-0.0507079326,
0.1660772264,
-0.2421959341,
0.2089912146,
0.0255800746,
-0.5082572103,
-0.0393889099,
0.0766830817,
1.2276593447,
-0.0670854598,
0.4231615961,
-0.0065835617,
-0.0762722716,
-0.0421877764,
0.3382797241,
-0.6245300174,
-0.4203499556,
0.1006884798,
-0.5941440463,
-0.4975872934,
0.2559705079,
-0.4406601191,
-0.3972234428,
-0.1367378384,
0.2304633856,
-0.6136555076,
-0.2865542471,
-0.4010879099,
-0.1875094771,
0.0227280259,
0.1805663854,
-0.4559405148,
0.1282536387,
0.7427501082,
0.9429972768,
-0.3209863603,
-0.4614771008,
-0.3456220329,
-0.0975641087,
-0.2440593988,
1.1380540133,
-0.4403510392,
-0.4835654795,
-0.0474420823,
-0.2694946826,
-0.0438500382,
-0.3612567782,
0.5377892256,
-0.5485432744,
0.2317089885,
0.1779941916,
-0.5534219146,
-0.1910439432,
0.4296923578,
-0.7235603333,
0.9415713549,
-0.0881359801,
-0.7835596204,
0.4425188005,
-0.8483570218,
-0.2983007133,
0.3321562707,
-0.1974338889,
-0.6239666939,
-0.1080630943,
-0.0326035954,
0.0248789918,
0.2173242569,
0.084231697,
0.0658865348,
-0.4274372458,
0.8105821013,
-0.6505584121,
0.7540175319,
0.3353915811,
-0.2212594748,
0.0025842432,
-0.7808519602,
-0.0045635863,
0.0520776361,
-0.4113987088,
-0.4221546352,
0.1874443442,
-0.0122618563,
-0.4205862582,
0.1528586745,
-0.4672800303,
0.2987735271,
-0.3257732689,
0.0601613186,
0.5858780742,
0.3522906601,
0.2434257716,
-0.3707619905,
0.6294093728,
-0.2948189378,
0.0564964302,
0.0973041356,
-0.7135609984,
-0.5113318563,
-0.1182167605,
0.4632410705,
0.5098237395,
-0.5573886633,
0.1774246693,
0.0430045836,
-0.6567695141,
-0.4519768357,
-0.1771069914,
0.2626502216,
0.208633244,
-0.0404667035,
-0.1788590252,
-0.3220517337,
-0.8524193764,
-0.459554702,
-0.4524816573,
-0.1612938046,
0.2139014155,
0.7448342443,
-0.2865282595,
0.7707800865,
-0.4698117673,
-0.0516997911,
0.3129402697,
0.9712841511,
-0.2643982172,
0.6150765419,
0.7946929336,
-0.8332408667,
-0.6118283272,
0.0493792482,
-0.9198461175,
-0.1758379936,
-0.0716443434,
-0.1959132105,
0.1630793363,
0.3519293666,
-0.5351992249,
0.7564825416,
0.2793494761,
-0.2955020964,
0.7618760467,
-0.0854808986,
0.8714069128,
-0.6968908906,
0.5058111548,
0.177201733,
0.118370831,
-0.3746044934,
-0.0015185478,
-0.3965457082,
-0.4798536897,
-0.214935407,
0.5263422132,
-0.1787978858,
0.0950713977,
-0.477591902,
0.1458631307,
-0.1161307096,
0.0813234821,
-0.2654620409,
1.166272521,
0.1608238965,
-0.4314713776,
0.1340051293,
0.4418710172,
-0.3269580007,
0.4268620312,
-1.0336812735,
0.1405447274,
-0.1761506349,
-0.0123569928,
-1.0855555534,
-0.3115553558,
0.5676160455,
-1.0856016874,
-0.3099529743,
-0.3219151497,
-0.5987885594,
-0.0583550371,
-0.0961351469,
0.47728616,
0.4540610611,
-0.0502797961,
0.4274783731,
0.5030231476,
-0.4241109788,
-0.486774534,
-0.5029389858,
0.0904488042,
-0.133110255,
-0.6466884613,
0.1169454753,
-0.3071452379,
-0.7103007436,
0.3606362939,
0.3669239581,
-0.162137866,
0.1629149914,
0.0480813123,
0.1755007505,
-0.1770886481,
-0.0656443983,
-0.0425068848,
0.0617267713,
0.5037048459,
0.1285690814,
0.4293823838,
-0.0969302207,
-0.4908319712,
-0.7830652595,
0.5621398091,
0.7235835791,
-0.3068061173,
0.9661896229,
0.8206980824,
-0.2934986353,
-0.0946310684,
-0.169155255,
-0.1598322392,
-0.4961939752,
0.1488193721,
0.2832892835,
-0.3615108728,
0.4975148141,
0.3305262029,
0.2249200642,
0.613237679,
0.3821870387,
-0.1650742441,
1.1399316788,
0.5152968764,
0.0520175882,
0.7031373978,
-0.203141138,
0.3789753318,
-0.4831641018,
-0.2325391769,
-0.8987153172,
-0.0647997484,
-0.6630318165,
0.2008424401,
0.5207183957,
-0.4269201159,
-0.2335700989,
0.040216893,
-1.0247005224,
0.5132191181,
1.0337369442,
-0.075267978,
0.4690957069,
0.1718512625,
0.5081013441,
0.0613847971,
-0.4122669697,
-0.7019999623,
1.0027838945,
0.0240891427,
0.4702699482,
0.0408306047,
0.5018718839,
1.0579628944,
0.3416483104,
-0.7622545958,
0.5998122096,
0.0679435283,
-0.5244126916,
-0.3036809266,
-0.5509493947,
-1.1262103319,
-0.1209034771,
-0.4043807685,
-0.629265964,
-0.1418064088,
0.2309795171,
-0.2257045209,
0.351426065,
-0.6796138883,
0.6006046534,
-0.0414671563,
-0.1873432249,
-0.3351445496,
-0.2110672295,
0.2395850271,
-0.1733249128,
0.0473764949,
0.1163433641,
0.3378258944,
1.1901882887,
-0.2108481973,
0.5129673481,
0.0763982311,
0.0918613002,
0.8875965476,
0.2450986058,
0.6093088984,
0.1662663221,
-0.0828600526,
0.232050553,
0.3195919096,
-0.2889064252,
-0.3557752967,
0.6732835174,
-0.9434564114,
-0.4995761216,
-0.8293505907,
-0.389888376,
0.223812893,
0.4657666385,
0.4304498136,
0.3532544076,
-0.3898237646,
0.3770063818,
0.6403807402,
-0.2431273907,
0.2820440531,
0.306260258,
0.1544715166,
-0.234270066,
0.8708152771,
0.324599117,
-0.2838526666,
0.0336586647,
0.2405370325,
0.0084247533,
-0.8715206981,
-0.3406418264,
0.0783596337,
-0.2979636192,
0.0200783703,
-0.5817669034,
-0.5628365278,
-0.6419429183,
-0.2004564553,
-0.2253423929,
-0.1560309976,
-0.4052506685,
0.3612561822,
0.3466300368,
0.8773519397,
-0.0702865273,
0.5224490166,
-0.7975634933,
0.1464351118,
0.1556920558,
0.2282915711,
0.1374962479,
-0.2538628578,
-0.4045435488,
0.4215232134,
-0.3721467555,
-0.4089049697,
0.4123141468,
-0.0401528813,
0.685379982,
0.4215604961,
0.1401761323,
0.0630820021,
-0.2479803711,
0.886803031,
-0.1444645524,
-0.6077799797,
0.6439529657,
-0.6092662215,
0.0239254609,
0.4533869028,
0.5289123058,
-0.3714791536,
-0.3118306398,
-0.7897498012,
-0.5901797414,
0.288944751,
0.6947034001,
0.0798107982,
0.0403323509,
0.322175175,
0.007761511,
0.1569847465,
-0.6818993688,
-0.2269181758,
0.141933918,
-0.2473229319,
0.5031729937,
-0.2060491741,
-0.3475636542,
0.2129261941,
0.7613856196,
0.1500375122,
0.4789277613,
0.1668617576,
0.0887342095,
0.1584792584,
-0.0635768846,
0.3182543814,
0.7130797505,
-0.0336120427,
-0.1163913533,
-0.2171808928,
-0.7876499891,
-0.1292656213,
-0.0422832668,
-0.3705716431,
0.040207576,
0.3296435177,
0.0375621244,
-0.5542908311,
-0.7795638442,
0.3729761243,
-0.2210435718,
-0.0419617817,
-0.9235290885,
0.4005826414,
-0.5819818377,
0.3100200295,
0.5934169888,
0.4730217159,
0.6370744109,
-0.5865123868,
0.2641422153,
0.5328697562,
-0.0036999194,
-0.3309263587,
0.8287974,
0.0925553143,
-0.6152076125,
0.8794853687,
-0.2135817856,
-0.2061636597,
0.8779028654,
0.1695446074,
0.6218313575,
0.0425386094,
0.2666660547,
0.4085366726,
0.2202801853,
0.079416357,
-0.2409486473,
0.1821387112,
-0.6678640842,
-0.2369320989,
-0.197656855,
-0.6468808651,
0.1682736427,
-0.4431892037,
0.1985510141,
-0.3365175426,
-0.3034031987,
0.2901354432,
-0.0454973616,
-0.3069971502,
0.2097270787,
-0.0063783028,
0.2819099128,
-0.9104598165,
0.397110641,
0.6640831232,
-0.4858678579,
-0.384666115,
0.0809482262,
0.3039198518,
-0.7530757785,
0.1832900345,
-0.2222235501,
-0.1546225995,
0.1147914156,
-0.9836914539,
-0.7840653658,
0.7889274359,
-0.0111862607,
0.1244929582,
0.1559517533,
0.2197840661,
0.6716009378,
0.0446317904,
0.1090533882,
0.2144312859,
0.3621606529,
-0.0525002964,
-0.4532520473,
-0.2982970774,
-0.7572088838,
-0.2773894072,
0.175066635,
-0.6399000883,
0.6479890347,
0.2903038561,
-0.2324403375,
0.0604631342,
0.5770930648,
0.5226291418,
0.6461005211,
0.1245462447,
0.3263403177,
0.69135952,
-0.1142557114,
0.819087863,
-0.1673741043,
0.187201336,
0.6710211039,
0.1199618876,
0.540574789,
0.4089321494,
-0.1463861018,
0.406742543,
0.3841412067,
-0.6136434674,
0.1697014272,
0.0176628679,
-0.5139814615,
0.3779562116,
-0.4555940926,
-0.3405056298,
0.4515878558,
0.3110618293,
-0.2850384414,
0.3506904244,
0.1673267335,
0.4740462303,
0.037134178,
-0.0572848096,
0.8621770144,
-0.2321330309,
-0.8486450315,
0.0629094839,
-0.072966136,
0.3911122382,
-0.4770190716,
-0.2942915857,
-0.3171536624,
0.0834459662,
-0.2348224074,
-1.0553207397,
0.679310143,
0.2882564068,
-0.1151825711,
0.0514962189,
0.7481629848,
-0.0945748612,
-0.6073825359,
-0.3951101899,
0.4662367702,
0.3899288476,
-0.1439554691,
-0.5319418907,
-0.0086230151,
0.1014864072,
-0.3639729321,
0.3677486777,
0.7792047858,
0.0379875936,
0.810701251,
0.7167033553,
0.1387595236,
-0.1621973217,
-0.3969621658,
0.5961337686,
-0.3039170504,
-0.2984676659,
-0.7873198986,
0.4378587008,
-0.3727722168,
-0.5134979486,
0.9168856144,
0.6358748674,
0.6569527984,
0.0017953449,
1.0830501318,
-0.3410624564,
0.1662461162,
-0.2008007616,
1.2355014086,
-0.4432880282,
0.1950648725,
-0.2994648814,
-0.6830038428,
-0.3484066725,
0.5997337103,
-0.1946600378,
-0.0809509903,
0.4285634458,
0.6898757219,
0.0166244339,
-0.0410511903,
0.0307733063,
-0.1089937165,
0.4045195282,
-0.2580404282,
0.76543504,
-0.5201425552,
0.9065697193,
-0.1445599198,
-0.3053545356,
-0.2538895607,
-0.7577493191,
-0.8185626864,
-0.5379069448,
-0.8445968032,
-0.3875762224,
-0.075542517,
0.3336027563,
0.2631553113,
-0.8848051429,
0.0665257052,
-0.2072992772,
0.0686226785,
-0.1987714022,
-0.3648197651,
0.5060714483,
0.0603394061,
-0.7947136164,
-0.0623683669,
-0.2090420872,
0.3517713249,
-0.1682565659,
0.3856681883,
-0.2131674439,
0.3276080787,
0.4540263116,
0.4569399059,
-0.1316082031,
-0.3707057834,
0.1551086009,
-0.01931227,
-0.0461124554,
0.721390903,
-0.4131244123,
0.1930636168,
0.8007073402,
0.5404687524,
0.2153685242,
0.3366210759,
0.5090636611,
-0.6272380352,
0.1303685308,
0.3368047476,
0.3697505593,
0.0190844163,
-0.6409834623,
0.6665267348,
0.3771300316,
-1.2318539619,
-0.757019043,
-0.3484106362,
-0.771291554,
-0.2513259053,
0.9914780259,
-0.2000020593,
-0.1904805452,
0.0602642111,
-0.6087260842,
0.4084288776,
-0.5564288497,
1.2434667349,
0.6796316504,
-0.4024678469,
-0.2210827917,
-0.5734685063,
0.3083364069,
-0.07326518,
-0.7749237418,
-0.3298601508,
0.4592346251,
0.1122727394,
0.2150471956,
0.3946936131,
-0.1723259389,
0.1110598445,
0.3819449544,
0.1913034916,
-0.0579787008,
-0.0852165893,
0.2140007615,
0.2336570024,
0.0751973391,
-0.2378871739
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06559v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06559v1
|
Diffusion-ES: Gradient-free Planning with Diffusion for Autonomous Driving and Zero-Shot Instruction Following
| 2024-02-09T17:18:33 | 2024-02-09T17:18:33 |
Brian Yang, Huangyuan Su, Nikolaos Gkanatsios, Tsung-Wei Ke, Ayush Jain, Jeff Schneider, Katerina Fragkiadaki
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.RO
|
Diffusion models excel at modeling complex and multimodal trajectory
distributions for decision-making and control. Reward-gradient guided denoising
has been recently proposed to generate trajectories that maximize both a
differentiable reward function and the likelihood under the data distribution
captured by a diffusion model. Reward-gradient guided denoising requires a
differentiable reward function fitted to both clean and noised samples,
limiting its applicability as a general trajectory optimizer. In this paper, we
propose DiffusionES, a method that combines gradient-free optimization with
trajectory denoising to optimize black-box non-differentiable objectives while
staying in the data manifold. Diffusion-ES samples trajectories during
evolutionary search from a diffusion model and scores them using a black-box
reward function. It mutates high-scoring trajectories using a truncated
diffusion process that applies a small number of noising and denoising steps,
allowing for much more efficient exploration of the solution space. We show
that DiffusionES achieves state-of-the-art performance on nuPlan, an
established closed-loop planning benchmark for autonomous driving. Diffusion-ES
outperforms existing sampling-based planners, reactive deterministic or
diffusion-based policies, and reward-gradient guidance. Additionally, we show
that unlike prior guidance methods, our method can optimize non-differentiable
language-shaped reward functions generated by few-shot LLM prompting. When
guided by a human teacher that issues instructions to follow, our method can
generate novel, highly complex behaviors, such as aggressive lane weaving,
which are not present in the training data. This allows us to solve the hardest
nuPlan scenarios which are beyond the capabilities of existing trajectory
optimization methods and driving policies.
|
[
-0.5018391013,
-0.7134304047,
0.698300302,
0.199580282,
-0.0647195205,
-0.0424534492,
0.0173811726,
0.0842427537,
0.5545588732,
0.3427953422,
-1.0192420483,
-0.6186241508,
-0.5011994839,
-0.389214009,
-0.439717859,
0.8291154504,
0.094812043,
-0.0868163556,
0.0199652519,
0.0279389843,
-0.2304725796,
0.0379387289,
-0.8849331737,
-0.2609900534,
0.7747977972,
0.1029711962,
0.1670264304,
0.4389567971,
-0.0954325348,
0.1264623255,
-0.3954398632,
0.0626399368,
-0.5342365503,
0.1664039493,
-0.0624711029,
-0.1883875132,
-0.3742097616,
-0.1535329521,
0.4426983297,
0.6680331826,
-0.6013819575,
-0.3147145808,
-0.1712169498,
0.7545900941,
-1.0932955742,
-0.0871248394,
0.0463026538,
0.3297586739,
0.2450135052,
-0.3226312995,
-0.0646314099,
-0.8503713608,
0.0287675299,
-0.7455747724,
0.1010638475,
-0.3792081177,
0.2670322061,
0.4693592489,
-0.4059249759,
-0.3401606381,
-1.0741722584,
1.000171423,
-0.4132419229,
0.1222663149,
-0.000534759,
0.3738569617,
-0.306940943,
-0.1034843028,
-0.3672738969,
0.0517657734,
0.2830305994,
0.3693925142,
-0.1280840933,
0.2530634701,
0.0651200488,
0.0781254843,
-0.6045429707,
0.2901002467,
-0.3486965895,
0.0157107469,
0.6884312034,
0.2309666425,
-0.16706568,
0.4334803224,
-0.3753279448,
-0.185272634,
-0.735586822,
0.3790321946,
0.3082990348,
0.0577983893,
-0.3389621377,
0.3325388134,
-0.5615727901,
0.5704536438,
-0.0023846326,
-0.0976753905,
0.2069255263,
-0.0432143249,
-0.1298612058,
-0.3929805458,
0.4023345113,
0.4593552947,
0.2061376572,
-0.4290270507,
-0.3447801769,
0.0325546302,
-0.0246695615,
-0.7339556813,
-0.1008235067,
0.2820648253,
-0.1874849796,
-0.3671474159,
-0.2591484487,
-1.3525667191,
-0.2867429554,
-0.1963713318,
0.3114933968,
-0.1707468331,
-0.365054667,
0.6282809973,
-0.5491788983,
0.3849030435,
0.6201296449,
-0.8963522315,
0.4215933979,
0.2114181668,
0.9894153476,
-0.1492890865,
-0.184826538,
-0.7117911577,
0.4654299617,
-0.3995792568,
0.9001780748,
-0.5231654048,
-0.925588429,
-0.0434921086,
-0.2419187129,
0.0479975566,
-0.3739465475,
0.4124506116,
-0.2480210215,
0.0971344858,
-0.2708021402,
-0.5264592767,
-0.6530427337,
0.1480119526,
-0.417109102,
0.9430118203,
0.1335502267,
0.2321480662,
0.4717406929,
-1.2748676538,
-0.5616734624,
0.1772208661,
-0.039006032,
-0.1680213213,
-0.0611425042,
0.0528631955,
0.3569547534,
0.2070899308,
0.1240644231,
-0.0581488647,
-0.3562999964,
-0.5986319184,
-0.4449957311,
0.8197253942,
-0.0824564248,
-0.5728085637,
0.3378429711,
-0.6942372918,
-0.0528562777,
0.0482969545,
-0.251293838,
-0.348208487,
0.145140931,
-0.189438954,
0.1532549113,
0.0017583256,
-0.5097004175,
0.3762248158,
-0.2803684771,
0.1859308332,
1.0144002438,
0.6099819541,
1.0915783644,
-0.4067480862,
1.0433548689,
-0.0468014702,
0.3445552588,
0.0260001272,
-0.8712853193,
-0.3873288631,
-0.1525321007,
-0.2266474515,
0.674266994,
-0.27636832,
0.3092904985,
0.2062232643,
-0.4302225411,
-0.1936721206,
-0.1032591835,
0.0269255769,
0.3769050539,
0.6597107649,
-0.2070175111,
-0.0218997989,
-0.3964348137,
0.272608906,
0.4385559559,
0.0201755874,
0.2356941849,
0.5230457783,
-0.2964514494,
0.6042070389,
-0.7623786926,
-0.3329182267,
-0.0375376418,
0.47302562,
-0.3128860593,
0.5083891153,
0.8508022428,
-0.6202806234,
-0.4480650127,
-0.2626208961,
-0.4011177719,
-0.1004671976,
-0.3137738407,
-0.127812326,
-0.1334384084,
0.2602645755,
-0.4124210775,
0.7361103296,
0.328502059,
-0.1967104971,
0.3224561512,
-0.4751322865,
-0.0824656263,
-0.2075935304,
-0.1267620027,
0.2413947135,
-0.1568356901,
-0.7376022935,
-0.0619740449,
-0.3045500219,
0.2101017386,
-0.6208440661,
0.6888466477,
-0.411775142,
0.0031453467,
-0.1564422548,
0.1224606857,
-0.1103338897,
0.6558404565,
0.1565134376,
0.6051259637,
0.8828268647,
-1.0636814833,
0.0456789806,
0.1967993379,
-0.1071548164,
0.7987580299,
-0.2671266496,
-0.1289049536,
-0.7565546632,
0.1267770678,
-0.9278076887,
0.2822687328,
0.1591793895,
0.0526298657,
0.0211030282,
-0.210204944,
0.0589152537,
-0.0706147254,
-0.5820649266,
0.1487627923,
0.6737731695,
-0.2243859172,
0.5391461253,
0.1279236376,
0.0703805387,
-0.4928366542,
-0.480022341,
-0.2566964328,
-0.3290890157,
-0.3028604388,
0.4752059877,
-0.5025919676,
-0.1812631935,
0.0074578505,
0.1721310467,
-0.0691238269,
0.2544369102,
0.2613428831,
-0.0127347754,
0.140681982,
-0.4734412432,
0.6342043877,
-0.2237546146,
-0.0827631429,
-0.1067216769,
0.5968067646,
0.5852924585,
-0.1827763021,
-0.4301658571,
0.6853243709,
0.5849727988,
-0.0574004427,
0.5509735346,
0.642103076,
-0.0462289304,
-0.5632283092,
0.0653781667,
-0.3672659397,
-0.4735982716,
0.0394532196,
-0.1914944798,
-0.682008028,
0.2747610807,
-0.3209516406,
0.5520886779,
0.06755279,
0.4054108858,
-0.1879454553,
0.8892939091,
0.4942693114,
0.2132725418,
0.6283563972,
-0.70549196,
0.0045476817,
-0.7245435119,
-0.4826788902,
-0.2497962713,
-0.7210716009,
-0.2635412514,
-0.4865473509,
0.3713459969,
-0.2132152915,
-0.2141661942,
-0.1450544894,
-0.6339334846,
0.6622100472,
0.7636187673,
-0.152191937,
0.0995395929,
-0.0168447476,
0.0090575321,
0.1749704778,
-0.6067363024,
-0.0265242364,
0.8946911097,
-0.292684108,
0.5614624619,
0.0210569203,
0.9856214523,
0.540681541,
0.0665748566,
-0.7267526984,
0.6076956987,
-0.0998477042,
-0.2087718844,
-0.4153820276,
-0.3560446203,
-1.1250604391,
0.2578943372,
-0.2758187056,
-0.6137509346,
0.4144225717,
-0.1160271019,
-0.7553125024,
0.4078091383,
-0.6628557444,
0.6476356983,
-0.0925647393,
-0.2455492318,
-0.3293689787,
-0.5729244947,
0.1834658682,
0.3022788167,
0.2803569138,
-0.1223592609,
-0.0903518125,
0.7841659784,
0.0187567957,
0.6505740285,
-0.9571957588,
0.0305913687,
0.2334083617,
0.4925233424,
0.5764936209,
-0.2927963734,
0.0640247986,
-0.0873425379,
-0.1184520051,
-0.334582895,
-0.6623255014,
0.6409673095,
-0.3330813348,
-0.3636389971,
-0.1961454898,
-0.5725664496,
0.1590765268,
0.1253607571,
0.1001228243,
0.2138946801,
-0.0564939491,
-0.2354110777,
0.5932197571,
-0.2423844934,
0.9541940689,
0.5378551483,
-0.094938755,
-0.1051903367,
0.887044251,
0.2260590941,
0.3017330766,
0.4149495661,
0.3387295306,
-0.4643871486,
-0.8521320224,
-0.5008067489,
0.2158949524,
-0.3486665487,
0.0530628115,
-0.3956319094,
0.0394587927,
-0.1296734065,
-0.8221853971,
-0.2238914222,
-0.6299596429,
-0.3956608474,
-0.2613944113,
0.2286810875,
1.0185741186,
-0.6710544825,
0.5767439008,
-0.2319455892,
0.2697734833,
0.2052213848,
0.1454622149,
0.1015492827,
0.0251833927,
0.0718607455,
0.1632745117,
-0.3555181623,
-0.7271460295,
0.6697009206,
-0.0598864593,
0.683701396,
0.5544304252,
-0.0050991969,
0.746534884,
-0.3779334724,
0.8187960386,
0.0984514803,
-0.4366780818,
0.6550976634,
-0.3308884203,
0.0399607457,
0.4317700565,
0.2625227571,
-0.3557018638,
-0.2540634573,
-0.3967245221,
-0.7617833614,
0.5103231668,
0.1341242492,
-0.1342888921,
0.0962854028,
0.5337805152,
0.0628197193,
0.3835710883,
-0.6886138916,
-0.4183401167,
0.057880275,
-0.0202558488,
-0.0605522022,
-0.1358531713,
-0.2798858285,
-0.2024941891,
0.641310513,
0.2052115798,
0.3013843,
-0.0420168787,
0.2448405325,
-0.1922955215,
0.1954245418,
1.0613998175,
0.0180069134,
-0.3304507434,
-0.1912599355,
-0.1894488633,
-0.2349061072,
0.5829124451,
-0.2666111887,
-0.7778251171,
-0.1878812611,
-0.4634242356,
0.431291759,
-0.0234499183,
-0.46618402,
0.6253376603,
0.0835587233,
-0.500736177,
-0.2346828878,
0.4179212451,
-0.2243695557,
0.2329266667,
0.1100478768,
0.4110575616,
0.2981694639,
0.0579282157,
0.0280595347,
0.6614003778,
-0.3646227419,
-0.3389621377,
0.7109383941,
0.1470343322,
-0.4644388556,
0.1646188349,
-0.7214888334,
-0.0470399894,
0.5503834486,
0.1551208943,
0.9690068364,
-0.2914265692,
0.7802770138,
0.4121807516,
0.2676551938,
-0.3602232039,
0.4683636725,
-0.4410029054,
-0.6144813895,
-0.5011358261,
-0.4462222159,
-0.3793257475,
-0.1254450232,
-0.5010219812,
0.0302389897,
-0.6697368026,
0.2271500975,
-0.2823914587,
-0.3004611731,
-0.3325773776,
0.2353156358,
-0.283759594,
0.7077351213,
-0.8371658921,
0.4549003541,
0.3065632582,
-0.3208891451,
-0.306433171,
-0.2597716451,
0.1983554214,
-0.5931190848,
0.3975867927,
-0.250464052,
-0.5326521397,
0.1677378714,
-0.2614257038,
-0.6644328237,
1.172539711,
0.2159558237,
-0.3850210011,
-0.3064951003,
-0.1892079413,
0.1898112595,
-0.1886788607,
-0.0006616942,
0.4293169379,
0.6273055077,
0.4730816782,
-0.2413154095,
-0.2733479738,
0.2675652206,
-0.2634543478,
0.4876500964,
-0.5011163354,
0.6770501733,
-0.2480550259,
-0.147111088,
0.184547931,
-0.0369154252,
0.1325780004,
0.3781559467,
0.527651608,
0.7186960578,
0.7969613075,
0.0749171898,
0.8522549868,
0.0205585379,
0.156812191,
0.7529023886,
-0.3304260075,
0.5678732395,
0.6018063426,
-0.1540067196,
0.9669029713,
0.3067675531,
0.2157826871,
1.1234322786,
0.0489297695,
-0.5525689125,
0.0457210727,
0.2241557688,
0.0821373165,
0.0673227981,
0.2438719571,
0.2258051038,
-0.6920713186,
0.1708116829,
-0.2074455619,
-0.0000399521,
-0.4004128277,
0.6915383339,
-0.3945625722,
-0.4755472541,
0.1562701166,
0.0473935269,
0.8114885688,
-0.654011786,
-0.1970249116,
-0.4175213277,
-0.1416867822,
-0.2031462789,
-0.7592870593,
0.4786245227,
-0.3279955089,
-0.0397015437,
-0.6014279127,
0.1493179053,
-0.3317433,
0.0057991915,
0.3960616887,
0.5765801072,
0.0864246711,
0.0739395618,
-0.4728215039,
-0.5795789957,
0.1538256109,
-0.1440868974,
0.3085561395,
0.1556862295,
0.1951416731,
0.7856012583,
0.5440145135,
0.4282133281,
0.3867641985,
-0.0005961795,
0.4807881415,
-0.7289655805,
-0.7961350083,
-0.7375267744,
0.6741710305,
0.0250856765,
-0.2087800801,
0.567443192,
0.5858448744,
0.5870329738,
0.0550584458,
0.6300976276,
0.1141664833,
0.3945198357,
-0.5473749638,
0.1919110417,
-0.7217331529,
0.2229349315,
0.0152228447,
-0.871730268,
-0.5053464174,
0.8952628374,
-0.5125350356,
0.1505773067,
0.2310951054,
0.8633869886,
-0.0558714978,
-0.2405566722,
0.5430589914,
-0.3029163182,
0.5251178741,
0.7727867961,
0.809130013,
-0.0106802061,
0.1598555148,
-0.3546638787,
-0.3880930245,
0.0814495981,
-0.4981968105,
-0.588896513,
-0.3079942167,
-0.3999394774,
0.0720262378,
-0.0358115099,
0.4882330596,
0.965452075,
-0.4516298771,
-0.3444458842,
-0.769156456,
0.409722656,
-0.4521241486,
-0.2964793146,
0.0204639826,
-0.1251085103,
-0.8220784664,
0.9464237094,
0.771143496,
0.5538355708,
-0.6101178527,
-0.4503999054,
-0.2716442347,
0.1519093364,
0.4280897975,
0.3511218429,
-0.2928640544,
0.0776438043,
0.1291017085,
0.2434457988,
0.1351861656,
0.7633196115,
-0.7979618311,
0.3104507923,
0.0744583383,
0.2176568359,
1.0295130014,
-0.0815980062,
0.3175853193,
-0.6473760605,
0.4947388172,
0.475802213,
0.1075140461,
-0.093508482,
-0.2132844627,
0.5597368479,
0.2617636025,
-0.5149438977,
-0.5289072394,
0.6041947603,
-1.063477397,
-0.3661776781,
1.2272591591,
0.0353519656,
-0.2738152146,
-0.1683460474,
-0.1393536925,
-0.1559587121,
-0.7916879654,
0.6605151296,
0.1814837009,
-0.4974445105,
-0.3392235935,
-0.3867990673,
0.6141953468,
0.2658035755,
-0.6208072901,
-0.1492761225,
0.8082352877,
0.1073810831,
-0.1076843292,
0.8494445682,
0.1520820558,
0.3504144549,
-0.1120008677,
-0.132025823,
-0.0520899221,
-0.4648941755,
-0.5952749848,
0.5306004286,
-0.2841183841,
-0.3456152976
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06549v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06549v1
|
Bryndza at ClimateActivism 2024: Stance, Target and Hate Event Detection via Retrieval-Augmented GPT-4 and LLaMA
| 2024-02-09T17:02:41 | 2024-02-09T17:02:41 |
Marek Šuppa, Daniel Skala, Daniela Jašš, Samuel Sučík, Andrej Švec, Peter Hraška
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This study details our approach for the CASE 2024 Shared Task on Climate
Activism Stance and Hate Event Detection, focusing on Hate Speech Detection,
Hate Speech Target Identification, and Stance Detection as classification
challenges. We explored the capability of Large Language Models (LLMs),
particularly GPT-4, in zero- or few-shot settings enhanced by retrieval
augmentation and re-ranking for Tweet classification. Our goal was to determine
if LLMs could match or surpass traditional methods in this context.
We conducted an ablation study with LLaMA for comparison, and our results
indicate that our models significantly outperformed the baselines, securing
second place in the Target Detection task. The code for our submission is
available at https://github.com/NaiveNeuron/bryndza-case-2024
|
[
-0.5061735511,
-0.6958549619,
0.609367311,
-0.2146021128,
-0.2330605835,
0.3360035717,
-0.173470512,
-0.6621640921,
0.1975215822,
0.3768439293,
-0.3502018452,
-0.6178008318,
-0.9416310191,
-0.0389455929,
-0.5512806773,
1.1459563971,
-0.0125317238,
-0.1545448601,
0.242359668,
-0.3717363179,
-0.0787832364,
-0.415158987,
-0.7344169021,
-0.5280508399,
0.8080137372,
0.2535664439,
0.5719754696,
0.4011820257,
0.2964267135,
0.3250233829,
-0.2111366391,
-0.422662586,
-0.4120471179,
0.1587675512,
-0.1844246238,
0.0149968117,
-0.2868103385,
0.4377070665,
0.7196114063,
0.1831647903,
-0.1491392702,
0.1408948898,
-0.1864977926,
0.0594181716,
-0.4690181017,
-0.1349562109,
-0.9218836427,
-0.0820079595,
-0.3998356462,
0.1914384663,
-0.048204802,
-0.124332495,
-0.2001289278,
-0.2507621348,
0.3928677738,
0.1748896092,
0.6873284578,
0.3244066238,
-0.4583176076,
-0.2789709568,
-0.3545872867,
1.0693963766,
-0.7835509777,
0.4881243408,
0.295745343,
-0.0854515508,
-0.1298802346,
-0.5534135699,
-1.0697579384,
-0.1548512429,
0.3548611104,
-0.0503251031,
-0.4085146487,
0.0852819905,
0.2011161894,
0.1777127981,
-0.4801959395,
0.6175591946,
-0.2652485669,
-0.3217591345,
0.5876595378,
0.0043721609,
0.1790201217,
-0.3730337024,
-0.3560222387,
0.1553179175,
-0.6400561929,
-0.4810320139,
0.8044472337,
0.3662066162,
-0.2006697655,
0.6667847037,
-0.0520870276,
0.5685642362,
0.0529118516,
0.0374575444,
0.1226450056,
-0.4193612933,
-0.2158170044,
0.1696980745,
0.7241006494,
0.2224963009,
-0.085643284,
-0.0631277859,
0.0487180687,
0.05970129,
0.3026162088,
-0.9241235852,
-0.2093876749,
0.1666603535,
-0.378030926,
-0.5842862129,
-0.4374024272,
-0.9926579595,
-0.6764173508,
-0.2932347357,
0.2198650092,
0.04470082,
-0.4351454079,
0.0297556836,
-0.1415333897,
0.4592905045,
0.4968848228,
-0.7388416529,
-0.0279279053,
0.9031330347,
0.8835490942,
-0.4737531841,
-0.1161094978,
-0.5341421366,
-0.0655463934,
-0.3051892519,
0.8862852454,
-0.9591095448,
-0.3309262097,
-0.0592002273,
-0.2769171894,
0.1280906051,
-0.3301766515,
0.791888833,
-0.8391948938,
0.2430616766,
-0.2824708521,
-0.5787184834,
-0.2496371269,
0.5596502423,
-0.5947065353,
1.007597208,
0.0187963154,
-0.8997092247,
0.4566146731,
-0.6623029709,
-0.1060695425,
0.2192992568,
-0.1978177875,
-0.6185308695,
-0.2110381424,
-0.2125829458,
0.4990971386,
-0.1312527061,
0.3239516914,
-0.5079218745,
-0.1497134715,
-0.2538903058,
-0.4352601171,
0.6742220521,
0.234077841,
-0.6336995363,
0.5542650223,
-0.6067355275,
-0.3300282955,
0.1781908721,
-0.6458061337,
-0.0206271913,
-0.064923048,
0.2305032313,
0.1654919386,
0.3556220233,
-0.9395718575,
0.2264600098,
-0.2257689536,
0.4020430446,
0.9912632108,
-0.0154169109,
0.4260720015,
-0.1434606314,
0.6830766201,
-0.1539577544,
-0.0310561191,
0.3382288218,
-0.7582820058,
-0.4936007857,
-0.1648765206,
-0.1241160482,
0.456353724,
-0.6934524775,
0.0324173681,
0.0360028297,
-0.6388866305,
-0.0118513899,
0.1853636503,
0.2352557927,
0.6044462323,
0.3475539088,
-0.013557706,
-0.8579687476,
-0.5807731152,
-0.3276639283,
-0.5000013113,
0.3408607841,
0.1015236601,
0.667933166,
-0.3037966192,
0.5806717277,
-0.1889880449,
0.0707362071,
-0.3345795572,
0.2746765018,
0.2077826858,
0.1307922006,
0.7658599019,
-1.0760556459,
-0.4306100011,
0.0025287324,
-0.351564616,
-0.1488144547,
0.4869517386,
0.0327166766,
0.4181550145,
0.3518964946,
-0.4911477566,
0.5194762945,
0.7192776799,
-0.5443877578,
0.5732041597,
0.508612752,
0.5368881822,
-1.1721395254,
-0.1743964702,
0.2363961786,
-0.1304359734,
-1.0273815393,
-0.1750509888,
-0.3291859925,
-0.118266739,
-0.6997205019,
0.6260556579,
0.0295727309,
-0.2374751717,
-0.5508633852,
-0.0846966654,
-0.3099112809,
0.1400452107,
0.2582782507,
0.840493381,
0.2036731392,
-0.3576286137,
0.4058403969,
0.4281792343,
-0.2842843533,
0.6044604778,
-0.4522913098,
0.3701745868,
-0.0519703776,
0.2933739126,
-1.1074684858,
-0.3785633147,
0.5925797224,
-0.3330397308,
0.158878535,
-0.5186387897,
-0.4003669024,
-0.4456129074,
-0.4199317098,
0.5491038561,
0.2816258669,
-0.7342604995,
0.6625760794,
0.5689502954,
-0.1859056503,
-0.6265206337,
-0.3298857808,
0.3941507041,
-0.8657355905,
-0.1992226094,
0.5784921646,
-0.2181590647,
-0.5278910398,
-0.2469458878,
0.0278578438,
-0.0338965319,
0.0428131185,
0.3128625751,
0.0913236514,
0.0564737618,
-0.0949127302,
-0.3100527823,
0.1741413176,
-0.0607810542,
-0.0372868776,
0.7512977123,
-0.1384394169,
-0.2164224535,
-0.4282499254,
0.4249628484,
0.587192595,
0.1097557023,
0.6871276498,
0.989865005,
-0.5820100904,
0.1952394247,
-0.7444592118,
0.0579946786,
-0.508896172,
0.1377224624,
0.0246793833,
-1.292822957,
0.5209400058,
0.0810119435,
0.1188675016,
0.4367235303,
0.9906710982,
0.0072981287,
0.7918685079,
0.6164267659,
-0.4837033153,
0.8322649002,
-0.1186966151,
0.2857835293,
-0.8397363424,
-0.2732129991,
-0.8470583558,
-0.1153634936,
-0.4669421315,
-0.5208399892,
0.2726696432,
-0.224642083,
-0.6559297442,
0.4691820145,
-0.6252858043,
0.3422133625,
0.3419640362,
-0.1623312831,
0.1805023849,
-0.0719179884,
0.4541322291,
-0.1182629466,
-0.308514744,
-0.5316000581,
0.9446734786,
0.2008036673,
0.2800611258,
0.2395759374,
0.7630951405,
0.6080160141,
0.6132021546,
-0.8834278584,
0.6221737862,
0.1710885018,
-0.6416600943,
-0.3550277948,
-0.1621792018,
-0.9197648168,
0.2898125947,
0.1358672082,
-0.7124681473,
0.2014702708,
-0.1518198252,
-0.1251299083,
0.6436978579,
-0.2348120511,
0.8167391419,
-0.0690027401,
-0.229074657,
-0.4145542979,
-0.2116138935,
0.1754375547,
-0.2749193609,
0.3248975873,
-0.5363410115,
-0.3133471608,
1.0579280853,
0.0049840766,
1.1324989796,
-0.4356729984,
-0.4284175634,
0.1793419421,
-0.1568022966,
0.4287396073,
-0.1584216356,
-0.6356436014,
0.3959861994,
-0.3485859632,
-0.4019049704,
-0.0116943615,
0.9752557874,
-0.5932710171,
-0.7999249101,
-0.6079916358,
-0.4221140444,
-0.1164474487,
0.1928062886,
0.1104664207,
0.0834889784,
-0.4457578957,
-0.0762984455,
0.353146553,
-0.1435167789,
0.6187851429,
0.577745378,
0.0076620122,
-0.4243736565,
0.5577667952,
0.1564204991,
-0.1681565493,
-0.1153195277,
0.3184403181,
-0.2310014069,
-1.2299181223,
-0.2116511911,
0.2213739306,
-0.734049499,
-0.3906358182,
-0.668548584,
0.0633079186,
-0.6272848248,
-0.3221573234,
-0.1904136539,
-0.169522211,
-0.5804111958,
-0.3969574869,
0.6397368312,
1.0439254045,
-0.1839168072,
0.3068380058,
-0.2729975879,
0.4324755371,
0.0558874048,
0.1954954118,
-0.3605725169,
-0.8166164756,
0.0111971768,
-0.1127649769,
-0.4623723626,
-0.9303655028,
0.5369153023,
0.1825244427,
0.5162551403,
0.2773626447,
0.1335238069,
0.5448853374,
-0.5595273376,
1.0787080526,
0.1860067993,
-0.9752918482,
0.7453275919,
-0.6881741881,
-0.118293494,
0.386367172,
0.6766402125,
-0.3024504781,
-0.2992444038,
-0.6871439815,
-0.6354780197,
0.7228687406,
0.0474401973,
0.4910086393,
-0.2804238796,
0.4710765779,
-0.0278585367,
0.2623904943,
-0.7011532187,
0.0324181393,
-0.3088888824,
-0.1949002445,
-0.0469660535,
-0.4266125858,
-0.2206624597,
-0.3669236302,
0.7116751671,
-0.225742653,
0.0992202163,
-0.1501779854,
0.3967396021,
-0.2056138963,
0.4156675339,
0.5466920137,
0.3978900313,
0.0259979106,
-0.0690248013,
0.4083889425,
-0.4913542867,
0.172080189,
0.1256136149,
-0.1041851491,
-0.1640554816,
0.3378928304,
0.7125415802,
0.3605387807,
-0.3638163209,
0.3377083242,
0.1717790365,
-0.3632142842,
-0.532820642,
-0.081133835,
-0.0686203837,
0.6220271587,
0.3557168841,
-0.1289316267,
0.3387744129,
-0.5834363103,
0.2000392973,
0.5385394096,
-0.1905668676,
-0.5041475892,
0.7426909804,
0.0299960524,
-0.1665337682,
0.3899264336,
-0.1613103747,
-1.0218526125,
0.6455132365,
0.4610138237,
0.5713015199,
-0.464168787,
0.4203350544,
0.4512836635,
-0.0133036347,
0.0932941213,
0.2762935758,
-0.086902827,
-1.1901649237,
-0.2444098294,
-0.7869575024,
-0.6388151646,
0.2301060408,
-0.529124856,
0.1513725966,
-0.5266430378,
-0.2495623529,
0.0694325641,
0.4396358728,
-0.4624752402,
-0.1164961308,
0.2012189776,
0.6156979799,
-0.8609647155,
0.8656988144,
0.5332373381,
-0.1856755018,
-0.5872222185,
0.0627079979,
0.4341697693,
-0.770311296,
0.6836040616,
0.0546553917,
-0.1812047511,
0.2234344929,
-0.7347082496,
-0.7649672031,
1.0966767073,
0.4536803961,
-0.3814531863,
0.1215653867,
-0.1406294554,
0.4745171964,
-0.2505967021,
-0.324752897,
0.8624817133,
0.8100396991,
0.414191246,
-0.9328950644,
-0.119084157,
0.0564636886,
-0.3457055092,
0.2262723446,
-0.7978208661,
0.5934503675,
-0.0295226872,
-0.1466364861,
0.0722906366,
0.6489905119,
0.3445003331,
0.6264666915,
0.4817772806,
0.8697561622,
0.702822268,
-0.0978901386,
1.1516829729,
0.0829725191,
0.2972876728,
0.7899532318,
-0.5276731253,
0.956913352,
0.4032587409,
-0.2689806521,
0.4237342179,
0.7470709085,
0.078885071,
0.5097816586,
0.0873224288,
-0.8156795502,
-0.2787510753,
-0.5393980145,
-0.1059815213,
0.5484870076,
0.6165762544,
-0.0095868697,
-0.3469480276,
0.4383282065,
0.3698120117,
0.183191359,
-0.5324598551,
0.710357964,
-0.0341023728,
-0.4347706735,
0.3692222238,
0.0290192161,
1.003970623,
-0.1996965557,
-0.0038166358,
0.1687276363,
-0.0987478122,
-0.2821455002,
-0.9874219894,
0.5732831955,
0.3231088221,
-0.0725810677,
-0.3180348575,
0.7491601706,
-0.3079054058,
-0.2514826059,
0.4740314782,
0.0283399634,
0.1824224442,
-0.0122907767,
-0.9812159538,
0.7384032607,
-0.0092545329,
-0.5380843282,
0.4438212514,
-0.0128360568,
-0.12276721,
0.4472120702,
0.7329427004,
0.035691794,
0.1447483003,
0.3171297014,
0.9882912636,
-0.4215281308,
0.0664583668,
-0.8093662262,
-0.08657787,
-0.0606827401,
-0.1031731665,
0.8865261078,
0.5239220262,
0.6954146624,
0.3203653395,
0.6681500077,
-0.1851497442,
0.5322113633,
-0.4118153453,
0.4046596289,
-0.3455034196,
0.1057945117,
-0.2483454496,
-0.8413065672,
-0.470128417,
0.5597278476,
-0.6373236179,
0.1943435222,
0.1731214374,
0.7564697862,
0.1274871975,
-0.0280375499,
0.4357610345,
0.2041892856,
0.7695193887,
0.2801367342,
0.7149037123,
-0.2092015296,
0.5472726822,
-0.0217259005,
0.0950381756,
-0.0919940323,
-1.1665049791,
-0.7668241262,
-0.7378015518,
-0.6431334615,
-0.3280553222,
0.0656991005,
0.8212191463,
0.6399527788,
-0.9104241133,
0.1814779043,
-0.0408130288,
0.1743642092,
0.4149971008,
-0.2120573968,
0.3426511288,
0.0183053482,
-1.1195373535,
0.7564786673,
0.2538101971,
0.1155435666,
-0.1280156672,
-0.1614809483,
-0.4487495422,
0.1500686109,
0.5521735549,
0.5304852128,
-0.8516899943,
-0.7944014072,
-0.5136474967,
0.219266504,
-0.0735432729,
0.6966289282,
-0.6873353124,
-0.0594567955,
0.4015895426,
0.7203282714,
0.5386878848,
0.1213317811,
0.2225854099,
-0.5544221401,
0.3056672812,
0.5146315694,
0.4926576614,
0.5042799711,
-0.4193085134,
0.5991700888,
0.3071448505,
-0.7634695172,
-0.8579179645,
0.3716520071,
-1.0838358402,
-0.0268394873,
1.312746048,
0.0283432342,
-0.0905321017,
-0.4938030541,
-0.2167707086,
0.1913972348,
-0.4134148061,
0.6646305919,
0.9510484934,
-0.1997408867,
-0.3787659407,
-0.5237641931,
0.4947139919,
0.1587872207,
-0.7065960169,
-0.034411002,
0.791226387,
0.3733367026,
0.2031746358,
0.739613831,
-0.1204921231,
0.1632330418,
-0.3588417768,
-0.0273004342,
0.0683329403,
-0.2416424155,
-0.4631967247,
0.2928249538,
0.0853717327,
0.1475736499
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06544v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06544v1
|
Calibrating Long-form Generations from Large Language Models
| 2024-02-09T17:00:32 | 2024-02-09T17:00:32 |
Yukun Huang, Yixin Liu, Raghuveer Thirukovalluru, Arman Cohan, Bhuwan Dhingra
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
To enhance Large Language Models' (LLMs) reliability, calibration is
essential -- the model's assessed confidence scores should align with the
actual likelihood of its responses being correct. However, current confidence
elicitation methods and calibration metrics typically rely on a binary
true/false assessment of response correctness. This approach does not apply to
long-form generation, where an answer can be partially correct. Addressing this
gap, we introduce a unified calibration framework, in which both the
correctness of the LLMs' responses and their associated confidence levels are
treated as distributions across a range of scores. Within this framework, we
develop three metrics to precisely evaluate LLM calibration and further propose
two confidence elicitation methods based on self-consistency and
self-evaluation. Our experiments, which include long-form QA and summarization
tasks, demonstrate that larger models don't necessarily guarantee better
calibration, that calibration performance is found to be metric-dependent, and
that self-consistency methods excel in factoid datasets. We also find that
calibration can be enhanced through techniques such as fine-tuning, integrating
relevant source documents, scaling the temperature, and combining
self-consistency with self-evaluation. Lastly, we showcase a practical
application of our system: selecting and cascading open-source models and
ChatGPT to optimize correctness given a limited API budget. This research not
only challenges existing notions of LLM calibration but also offers practical
methodologies for improving trustworthiness in long-form generation.
|
[
-0.1294795275,
-0.4531389773,
0.7129335403,
0.4274457693,
-0.026696058,
0.0871456116,
-0.3933272958,
-0.3576101661,
0.0639825761,
0.4360959232,
-0.2843083143,
-0.3906613886,
-0.2520554364,
0.0694170222,
-0.22695297,
0.7573598623,
-0.001571099,
0.0753152668,
-0.5388717651,
-0.0378135368,
-0.4217274189,
-0.4524027705,
-0.475025773,
-0.5705615282,
0.5400181413,
0.3123454452,
0.8065329194,
0.5367607474,
0.2456975281,
0.2201203257,
0.0386262573,
0.2187008113,
-0.6587193012,
0.3123683929,
-0.2850408554,
-0.4006340504,
-0.4274580777,
-0.1411090642,
0.7669196725,
0.5956941247,
-0.2390148491,
0.2975439727,
0.4036625624,
0.7113316059,
-0.7569428086,
0.2519029677,
-0.5188139677,
-0.2850385904,
0.0394351073,
-0.3350129128,
-0.6437994838,
-0.6184780002,
-0.1262937188,
-0.3525256813,
-0.0552869663,
0.0003370869,
0.3668890595,
0.2465501428,
-0.47312814,
-0.3180449009,
-0.8204914331,
0.9232122302,
-1.0890907049,
0.3199292421,
0.4480282962,
0.237964958,
-0.3219370246,
-0.3879712522,
-0.3617531359,
-0.2840747833,
0.226715982,
0.2099487036,
0.0374890156,
-0.0064906022,
0.0610942766,
0.3736515939,
-0.6672503352,
0.3592939079,
-0.285541594,
-0.394805491,
0.75951612,
-0.0632918552,
-0.0505449772,
-0.1434776932,
-0.3766928911,
-0.1964381635,
-0.9823497534,
-0.142132476,
0.6846716404,
0.5658019185,
0.0041926531,
0.6123981476,
-0.1300311834,
0.5434403419,
0.1746947765,
-0.2676696181,
0.3111433983,
-0.2771074772,
-0.1949130148,
0.0202270988,
0.8585662246,
0.3147627115,
0.3593525589,
-0.170471549,
-0.2557374537,
-0.2012678981,
0.1107985005,
-0.7426682711,
-0.1397551596,
0.4267030954,
-0.0532340482,
-0.3225412369,
0.014056012,
-0.7092032433,
-0.286033541,
-0.4716314077,
0.6266083717,
-0.2317606062,
-0.3130960464,
0.1372569054,
0.1693314016,
0.3698673248,
0.2924779654,
-0.933075428,
0.070773609,
0.7571446896,
0.542214334,
-0.1064873561,
-0.3082987368,
-0.4922825992,
0.1754177958,
-0.5491465926,
0.5780943632,
-0.2036244869,
-0.3886180222,
0.1624457538,
-0.198573783,
0.0611354299,
-0.463004142,
0.4705753922,
-0.3977288008,
0.3353080153,
-0.2188891023,
-0.6271086931,
0.081125237,
0.3095243871,
-0.5224633217,
1.2888255119,
0.1400742531,
-0.5881181359,
0.1645996124,
-0.1725993752,
-0.2015833557,
0.0679227561,
-0.2414924055,
-0.2957588732,
0.1510797143,
0.0543248095,
0.5147837996,
-0.2373426259,
0.3151654601,
-0.582023561,
-0.1792431176,
0.1160447747,
-0.7715818286,
0.6252446175,
0.2801401019,
-0.2387176752,
-0.0888873562,
-0.8790066242,
0.6011990309,
-0.1199963465,
-0.3243163228,
-0.2084187567,
-0.0607708432,
-0.1238061711,
-0.0053883283,
0.4386011958,
-0.5791910291,
-0.0711349398,
-0.409573555,
0.4672880769,
0.7317228317,
-0.0814831555,
0.3344780207,
-0.4868892431,
0.4564515948,
-0.093218334,
0.030403439,
-0.2698091567,
-0.1084948629,
-0.6321142912,
-0.1087510511,
0.3808144033,
0.4453995526,
-0.3779173791,
0.9265217781,
-0.6113179326,
-0.6685214639,
-0.3364176154,
0.3776800334,
0.3350935876,
0.5310845971,
0.2130832523,
-0.2771053612,
-0.2813722193,
-0.7307870984,
-0.034175612,
-0.4899523854,
-0.168287456,
-0.0182350129,
0.2487890422,
0.0621713512,
1.0277788639,
-0.1719720364,
0.1528815478,
0.0922652632,
0.3673354089,
0.1383475959,
0.4668870568,
0.4422135055,
-0.4495129883,
-0.3139104545,
-0.2481809705,
-0.5763801932,
-0.1547693908,
0.072720848,
-0.0917580426,
0.2913282812,
0.4729762673,
-0.4750421643,
0.2005171627,
1.0405217409,
-0.0420757346,
0.643314898,
-0.4266084135,
0.3116143048,
-1.3637481928,
0.1154800206,
0.0619431213,
-0.6184071898,
-0.3476000428,
0.2269625962,
0.2979037762,
0.1782106906,
-0.3766806126,
0.5995134711,
-0.4828306139,
-0.0218350366,
-0.2065235227,
0.1978729963,
0.2562287152,
-0.0236458536,
-0.2276480347,
0.8609243631,
0.2468690723,
-0.4159270823,
0.4969167113,
-0.1005876139,
-0.3076319396,
0.824883759,
-0.703407228,
0.3012889922,
-0.2335956693,
0.4440475702,
-1.256187439,
-0.2856482863,
-0.109934032,
-0.4181737304,
0.4564702809,
-0.1464610547,
-0.6926937699,
-0.4205082357,
-0.3711775243,
0.4829057753,
0.5704359412,
-0.5940503478,
0.7367767096,
0.0175422896,
-0.2455286086,
-0.6764209867,
-0.6973677278,
-0.0643888637,
-0.0653810278,
-0.7502371073,
0.0541630983,
-0.4823361039,
-0.0731944665,
-0.4446473122,
-0.1015040353,
0.163083151,
-0.0761340559,
0.4109630883,
0.2250142097,
-0.3152533174,
0.2831671536,
-0.177581057,
0.1186787859,
0.0712508336,
-0.0619116314,
0.7125849724,
-0.0746674687,
-0.6026368141,
-0.2115412951,
0.1845949888,
0.7455356717,
-0.2301500738,
0.5128187537,
0.344119072,
-0.2604768574,
-0.324900806,
-0.9642201662,
-0.1395665407,
-0.4526818693,
0.2252019644,
-0.3860165179,
-0.7978539467,
0.5615631342,
0.0006839496,
0.3171782494,
0.6567280889,
0.6447443366,
-0.0571587868,
0.9425997138,
0.6215744019,
-0.2080194801,
0.0364685245,
0.2320607603,
0.1484903097,
-0.7287451625,
-0.1180834398,
-0.7233706117,
0.0938106105,
-0.4082846642,
-0.5033100843,
0.1014826447,
0.0283131395,
-0.4462807178,
0.110163644,
-0.2639739215,
0.5845035315,
0.4893558323,
0.0331073813,
0.337867111,
-0.033210285,
-0.0545504391,
0.0170459431,
-0.3725709915,
-0.7367276549,
1.1124161482,
0.6974047422,
1.1937383413,
0.1044009775,
0.8679035902,
0.1493319124,
0.4403780401,
-0.6125707626,
0.3568582535,
-0.0433373936,
-0.6093701124,
-0.4937318861,
-0.67301929,
-0.6827061176,
-0.0605375841,
-0.0308194235,
-0.6831665039,
0.0781908557,
0.2509439588,
-0.604817152,
0.008816829,
-0.7517668605,
0.6372080445,
-0.3587510884,
-0.3149089217,
-0.0544474199,
-0.5614138246,
0.3835718036,
-0.423145026,
0.1739640236,
-0.3802792132,
0.1391272992,
0.3140641153,
-0.1925646216,
0.9494214654,
0.0649138168,
-0.508479774,
0.2406153232,
0.1690407842,
0.4392466843,
-0.0658222064,
-0.4757556617,
-0.078823708,
0.4875204861,
-0.3729743361,
-0.7032392621,
0.8896712065,
-0.8328408599,
-0.5241789222,
-0.2892298996,
-0.5404625535,
-0.5185514092,
0.205715403,
0.160761252,
0.3190091848,
-0.356628567,
0.4599994123,
0.7216884494,
-0.0956904888,
0.1509542614,
0.4081459045,
-0.4740704,
-0.51909554,
0.5668315887,
0.0461808331,
0.7858633399,
0.2739713788,
0.2081780732,
-0.5909233689,
-0.140746519,
-0.4632821977,
0.3958659172,
-0.8223767877,
-0.4864858985,
-0.1071636155,
-0.4459310472,
-0.7605153322,
0.0944786593,
-0.4336931705,
-0.3102968931,
-0.3335243165,
-0.1055595279,
0.1606466025,
0.6119491458,
-0.170955345,
0.2254573703,
-0.70158571,
0.0815191939,
0.3547441661,
0.3568354547,
-0.0126996553,
-0.7722228169,
0.0706747696,
0.4665673077,
-0.2410451174,
-0.7239507437,
0.1446828544,
0.3361822665,
0.4782984853,
0.2769640982,
0.1021414474,
0.7648169398,
-0.5023601651,
0.8165098429,
0.3923763931,
-0.9096500874,
0.4375503361,
-0.2500086427,
0.4101199508,
0.8165664077,
0.2177537531,
-0.5037498474,
-0.4662652314,
-0.3770295382,
-0.7687884569,
0.0912732035,
-0.1117103919,
0.5938549638,
-0.0444987863,
0.5125837326,
0.0558535121,
0.0004854521,
-0.7447755933,
-0.0602311045,
-0.2029044032,
-0.6419677138,
-0.4306435585,
-0.3622656167,
-0.3273650408,
0.1323072761,
0.836614728,
-0.4167270958,
-0.1468940675,
0.138039723,
0.0169874597,
-0.4042185247,
0.4367111921,
0.4493052363,
1.0515515804,
-0.294231683,
0.264220953,
-0.0267315898,
-0.2318862677,
0.2053739578,
0.0968148038,
-0.2455378324,
-0.0444490239,
0.0701798648,
0.3977500796,
0.2725246549,
-0.4834474623,
0.7578558922,
0.0943458676,
-0.1920819879,
-0.4948841929,
0.0659610033,
0.206304729,
0.1627013981,
0.4618621469,
-0.3436747491,
-0.2416585386,
-0.6178875566,
0.1929884255,
0.5794411302,
-0.1439146996,
-0.1372315437,
0.5206423402,
0.0875127763,
-0.0585222058,
0.6545687318,
0.069712922,
-0.2266184837,
0.4292509556,
0.7425028682,
0.7524937987,
-0.4050275683,
0.3226810098,
0.4486980438,
0.3125456274,
-0.4774766564,
0.1923536211,
0.1385613978,
-0.6869627833,
-0.7071495652,
-0.8086603284,
-0.6293833256,
0.1242008507,
-0.6986521482,
0.1542476118,
-0.330183655,
-0.3562836945,
-0.1218735203,
0.0570377298,
-0.7178483009,
0.3186646402,
0.3351585269,
1.0470262766,
-0.8876962066,
0.677115798,
0.2786356211,
-0.3044020236,
-1.2184897661,
-0.1521687359,
-0.0345467143,
-0.9369633198,
0.393471241,
0.1490687579,
-0.3110742867,
0.0207125247,
-0.6629744172,
-1.0090658665,
1.2505848408,
0.5571066141,
-0.7767637968,
-0.163908571,
0.2699816823,
0.6504465938,
-0.2883095443,
0.3754100204,
0.3552288115,
0.3364459574,
0.4300341606,
-1.14993608,
0.0134749459,
0.055414252,
0.0937226787,
0.0653873533,
-0.6207515001,
0.3434900641,
-0.1234358251,
-0.2176794261,
0.4616127014,
0.8043220043,
0.5263528228,
0.0417810082,
0.4579598904,
0.6006456017,
0.7827972174,
-0.1364468187,
0.8085606694,
-0.56442523,
0.4551171064,
1.2875475883,
-0.3322314322,
1.2712281942,
0.585041821,
-0.1848452538,
0.3913588822,
0.4786514044,
0.0587709285,
0.0912650973,
0.3986856341,
-0.3530391753,
-0.3468542993,
0.1135529056,
-0.3219205141,
0.2807109356,
0.1192748323,
-0.421420753,
-0.2641962171,
-0.2308555096,
0.1135109439,
0.1019612104,
-0.3036742806,
0.4701195657,
0.2374037057,
-0.9109033346,
0.4850453734,
-0.0785194039,
0.5783548355,
-0.6688659787,
0.2088498771,
-0.2918862104,
0.1897644103,
-0.260853231,
-0.9753775001,
-0.1576300412,
-0.144463107,
-0.1339157373,
-0.0953951553,
0.5034143329,
-0.6116054058,
-0.5693573356,
0.1215177849,
0.5924196243,
0.2193923742,
0.0501921475,
-0.3686594367,
0.1574777812,
-0.0575312711,
-0.2927841842,
0.2960470319,
0.3537897468,
0.3199151456,
0.6462765336,
0.5931828618,
0.367714256,
0.1554162949,
0.3321098089,
0.455265969,
-0.3114154935,
-0.2034465224,
-0.7441641092,
0.4462658465,
-0.0447846651,
-0.2324061543,
0.7156358361,
0.6527724862,
0.6566266418,
0.1268571168,
0.6777558327,
0.3130362034,
0.6911052465,
-0.5212250352,
0.5365105867,
-0.3983246386,
0.175908491,
-0.1691503972,
-1.3339267969,
-0.4588073194,
0.4981948137,
-0.3199526072,
0.2230160683,
0.3483454585,
0.8752146363,
-0.0414094999,
-0.1657273471,
0.5132007599,
0.1769057512,
0.4229454696,
0.4338583946,
0.7249513865,
-0.3608034849,
0.4373447597,
-0.2121773064,
-0.2922933996,
-0.0043666158,
-1.2758281231,
-0.5982025266,
-0.5272482634,
-0.2771091759,
-0.5989882946,
0.1271806508,
0.9900425076,
0.8014781475,
-0.6459109187,
-0.288302213,
0.271536231,
-0.3648304939,
0.2294938713,
-0.2500001192,
0.2038195282,
-0.5584494472,
-0.6291247606,
0.2078560442,
0.3164635599,
0.2930472791,
-0.7903017998,
-0.1068026647,
0.4026454091,
0.4127106965,
0.6075707078,
0.5515592098,
-0.7039955258,
-0.6659767032,
-0.0597690456,
-0.4466895759,
0.1327973157,
0.3359095752,
-0.5870363116,
0.5280444026,
0.329926908,
0.5954068899,
0.2957755625,
0.3216236234,
0.7325482368,
-0.7189283967,
-0.3129529357,
0.2902127504,
0.294598639,
0.5830314755,
-0.1882683933,
0.3483942151,
-0.3306108117,
-1.0264132023,
-0.8326895833,
0.2578682303,
-0.9801942706,
0.1688144803,
1.3660757542,
-0.2260700911,
-0.2656992674,
0.2244444042,
-0.0489306077,
0.0538763776,
-0.2394434959,
0.7884756327,
0.9725312591,
0.190598622,
-0.1078108922,
-0.433639437,
0.2097909898,
0.3942472935,
-0.8242760301,
0.4036871493,
0.7728725076,
0.6236597896,
0.3500898182,
0.5990869999,
-0.2734171152,
0.1038467437,
-0.3438655138,
0.0550229475,
0.3305154443,
-0.238295272,
-0.3577888012,
0.0259865168,
0.4818812013,
0.296487838
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10231v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10231v1
|
A Multi-faceted Semi-Synthetic Dataset for Automated Cyberbullying Detection
| 2024-02-09T16:53:19 | 2024-02-09T16:53:19 |
Naveed Ejaz, Fakhra Kashif, Salimur Choudhury
|
cs.SI
|
cs.SI, cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2
|
In recent years, the rising use of social media has propelled automated
cyberbullying detection into a prominent research domain. However, challenges
persist due to the absence of a standardized definition and universally
accepted datasets. Many researchers now view cyberbullying as a facet of
cyberaggression, encompassing factors like repetition, peer relationships, and
harmful intent in addition to online aggression. Acquiring comprehensive data
reflective of all cyberbullying components from social media networks proves to
be a complex task. This paper provides a description of an extensive
semi-synthetic cyberbullying dataset that incorporates all of the essential
aspects of cyberbullying, including aggression, repetition, peer relationships,
and intent to harm. The method of creating the dataset is succinctly outlined,
and a detailed overview of the publicly accessible dataset is additionally
presented. This accompanying data article provides an in-depth look at the
dataset, increasing transparency and enabling replication. It also aids in a
deeper understanding of the data, supporting broader research use.
|
[
-0.172374174,
-1.4540781975,
0.3388457596,
0.7241427898,
0.1885978281,
0.6119587421,
0.1827008426,
-0.3330110312,
0.4561181962,
0.2733800411,
-0.6706186533,
-0.2664293945,
-0.5774398446,
-0.1155914515,
-0.8530257344,
1.1933946609,
0.0066650179,
-0.0913696289,
-0.0718647167,
0.2077516615,
-0.677056551,
-0.4235384464,
-0.5632193685,
-0.1410082728,
0.4460285902,
0.1786688268,
0.3258043826,
0.3384869695,
0.3194774687,
0.371478945,
-0.0207077451,
0.1511274874,
-0.6922614574,
0.0680464208,
-0.3480293751,
0.125290975,
-0.4981385469,
-0.012017847,
0.7680249214,
0.4349122345,
0.009996579,
0.1887484789,
0.0295826346,
0.2421295494,
-0.4551399052,
-0.1003223136,
-0.3626744449,
0.2793150842,
-0.5158573389,
-0.0606262796,
-0.0685528964,
-0.1682576686,
-0.104320541,
-0.2420438528,
0.196475178,
0.0277652778,
0.2329303771,
-0.1182002276,
-0.60417068,
-0.003163001,
-1.0312191248,
0.4071515799,
-0.0945593193,
0.1803543717,
0.3094185889,
0.5564469695,
-0.2899806499,
-0.745238483,
-0.5425784588,
0.2523419261,
0.0323356092,
-0.0145613607,
-0.3314475417,
0.1481565237,
0.1628681272,
0.386258781,
-0.7645596862,
-0.1826556325,
-0.6000671387,
-0.5439370871,
0.8613631129,
0.3991113305,
0.3367554247,
-0.2030349672,
-0.4308574796,
0.0672210902,
-0.3756320775,
0.0595993586,
0.4572353661,
0.5066538453,
-0.4614320695,
0.4914881289,
-0.1521699131,
0.6737992167,
0.182256639,
-0.3178394735,
0.3555647731,
-0.8084075451,
0.1293130815,
0.3907516003,
0.9582528472,
0.4134412706,
0.2930834591,
-0.0121341823,
-0.3601491749,
0.3413592875,
0.492510438,
-0.7126215696,
-0.5601535439,
0.4366664588,
-0.3410716057,
-0.764297545,
0.0431153774,
-0.87059021,
-0.6571471095,
-0.6034885645,
0.5547930598,
-0.2040397227,
-0.3124931753,
-0.2418509871,
-0.4137159288,
-0.3596760035,
-0.032749664,
-0.1190743372,
0.419942826,
0.3636654615,
0.8877708316,
-0.1514840722,
-0.1356623918,
-0.4746541679,
0.0694365948,
-0.1841306835,
0.9286442995,
-0.7025968432,
-0.0814696103,
0.0609631687,
0.1977759451,
0.1824145168,
-0.6093379259,
0.2445888519,
-0.1713068783,
-0.0315169618,
0.2620453537,
-0.3340820074,
-0.1935223639,
0.2940030098,
-0.5764801502,
0.9905277491,
0.1903745681,
-0.4469154477,
0.1912850142,
-0.2631917596,
-0.9500328898,
0.1977942288,
0.1287321001,
-0.6040617228,
-0.0142875053,
0.0084652565,
0.6050543785,
-0.1067797691,
0.6300303936,
-0.7697066069,
-0.1853590012,
0.1424172074,
-0.1321617812,
0.9318182468,
-0.1512610614,
-0.2404906005,
0.1548987925,
-0.8856784701,
-0.0906208158,
0.1429002285,
0.2028295249,
-0.3939061463,
-0.2163657099,
0.2259833068,
0.4438581169,
0.1851635575,
-0.8834730983,
-0.2962803841,
0.3044505119,
0.4493446052,
0.7434575558,
0.3865486979,
-0.0868100971,
-0.3935269713,
0.43139714,
0.2052247226,
0.3357181847,
0.1390185654,
-0.2721339762,
0.0417038761,
-0.5525668859,
0.1657795161,
0.6041746736,
-0.8106939197,
0.4476459622,
-0.1006838158,
-0.5091242194,
-0.440077275,
0.1712901145,
0.5124084949,
0.3946822584,
0.3903757036,
-0.1529834867,
-0.8745589852,
-1.0807349682,
-0.1424418688,
0.1601526588,
0.0002267465,
0.2444960624,
0.4343736172,
0.0028550755,
0.9369745255,
-0.3126946092,
-0.6842366457,
-0.2133802325,
0.5705555677,
-0.2059715688,
0.3023738265,
0.6243598461,
-1.0163558722,
-0.7324655056,
-0.44934991,
-0.9384607673,
-0.4477945864,
-0.269734472,
-0.0623298511,
-0.5314389467,
0.4353023469,
-0.1732308418,
0.4693838954,
0.54331249,
-0.2682036161,
0.6025603414,
0.3185870647,
0.1655548513,
-0.8939684033,
-0.0013759743,
0.3977767825,
-0.5046785474,
-1.1238965988,
-0.1613947004,
-0.062981531,
-0.0500131063,
-0.4671669602,
0.373154968,
-0.0165259857,
0.0034070129,
-0.2765770257,
0.231349498,
-0.2516693771,
0.3006003499,
-0.0657124296,
0.5339151025,
0.5687840581,
-0.5960899591,
0.8073880672,
0.1318711191,
0.1479956359,
1.2988913059,
-0.8928339481,
0.0424935371,
-0.2629291415,
0.5044096708,
-0.6151283383,
-0.6096410751,
0.3759024143,
-0.4422200918,
0.0922668502,
-0.0559302196,
-0.6803483367,
-0.3456955552,
-0.5838770866,
0.4720737934,
-0.1046896949,
-0.3478322327,
0.6703568697,
1.0616877079,
-0.31445086,
-0.2388134301,
-0.1222050786,
0.3540453315,
-0.2550433874,
-0.5390768051,
0.8270852566,
-0.1705155969,
-0.0972786397,
-0.1767885238,
0.1557609141,
-0.0710439384,
-0.1359643787,
0.2087696642,
0.2368500084,
0.3768481314,
-0.105670698,
0.0240228307,
0.2157801688,
0.3209033012,
0.187196359,
0.6132829785,
0.1578305513,
0.1534481943,
-0.4005109966,
0.3142396212,
0.0644033104,
0.2297215611,
0.4101637602,
0.6292260885,
-0.7427513003,
-0.386991322,
-0.1378846914,
-0.1785725951,
-0.4770085514,
0.2898427844,
-0.2042236924,
-0.5864779949,
0.5572417974,
0.0071654925,
-0.047330685,
-0.0374575779,
0.5625843406,
-0.2402579188,
1.1590329409,
0.394348681,
-0.2258674651,
0.4612517059,
0.1076360643,
0.3162093461,
-0.5682631135,
-0.517860055,
-0.0637458339,
-0.6015754938,
-0.730586648,
0.1273370534,
0.4353785813,
-0.4512037933,
-0.3774167001,
0.5632356405,
-0.4937084317,
0.2571474612,
0.1583479196,
0.6363261938,
0.0778047815,
0.0084181819,
0.356813997,
-0.0166786239,
-0.3238760531,
-0.0144773824,
1.0314848423,
0.1166011766,
0.4443359375,
0.2087181509,
0.4759903848,
0.7032698989,
0.1143129244,
-0.5029152036,
0.5424810052,
-0.109089382,
-1.1945202351,
-0.0709597245,
-0.4986860752,
-0.9851109982,
-0.0851881951,
-0.3746046126,
-0.7523350716,
-0.018101668,
0.2749017179,
-0.376263231,
0.1041343287,
-0.3879061341,
0.7080352306,
-0.048715651,
-0.6791628003,
-0.2616789639,
-0.7198786139,
0.6546760798,
-0.6719925404,
0.5624645948,
0.1562317908,
0.4056342542,
0.8155700564,
-0.3403154314,
1.034807086,
-0.3544547856,
0.2338303328,
0.5627801418,
0.1017452255,
0.3120115399,
-0.1586048752,
0.7092547417,
-0.0803960934,
-0.1162850708,
-0.3908524811,
-0.3775687516,
0.6050865054,
-0.3676003814,
-0.0488368496,
-0.46134305,
-0.6465546489,
-0.1953040361,
0.3228188157,
-0.2649926245,
0.4391883612,
-0.3361153305,
0.3046831787,
0.7068961263,
0.0081947939,
0.1757769287,
0.1826921701,
-0.4590553045,
-0.3487214148,
1.3687213659,
0.0883116126,
-0.0573153496,
0.0823313221,
0.127607882,
-0.1997409165,
-0.1599041224,
-0.1002479345,
0.1810671985,
-0.2157263309,
-0.2107752115,
-0.5640711188,
-0.4046503901,
-0.5148679018,
0.0895305872,
-0.273794502,
-0.2074355036,
0.2532902062,
-0.1370946467,
0.3246047795,
0.9608228207,
-0.4172031879,
0.4200478494,
-0.7289971709,
0.8284236193,
0.3192869127,
0.2448031753,
-0.1617515534,
-0.61946702,
0.1007064804,
0.1540630311,
-0.4332481921,
-1.0628391504,
0.3244104087,
0.1641078442,
0.3046011031,
0.163758561,
0.1373275071,
0.762050271,
-0.3245298862,
0.3748798072,
0.0000637958,
-0.4668103158,
0.5915641189,
-0.576061368,
-0.1409107894,
0.3207486868,
0.6652668715,
-0.5999571085,
-0.0513674617,
-0.8535161018,
-0.6532691717,
0.5659121871,
0.4229622483,
0.074927412,
0.2774317265,
-0.0432145223,
-0.1435395479,
0.4592840672,
-0.6923303604,
-0.4614714384,
-0.250423044,
-0.4138659537,
0.0794903338,
0.0354620703,
-0.4216139913,
-0.2708253562,
0.761269927,
0.142072022,
0.2666207552,
-0.4470881224,
-0.339245677,
-0.0448239408,
-0.372482419,
0.1676870286,
0.2396447361,
-0.2845439613,
0.1377206594,
-0.0839678794,
-0.6166040301,
0.2652674615,
0.3717806041,
-0.2167029828,
0.0123542268,
0.295866251,
0.4114129543,
0.1623888016,
-0.6351292729,
0.6128403544,
0.1251904815,
-0.0808721036,
-0.6113189459,
-0.2267174572,
-0.1151306257,
0.2630586326,
0.1809776425,
-0.2480009943,
0.4288806021,
-0.7920199633,
0.6677405238,
0.3205844164,
-0.3572013676,
-0.6454924345,
0.3374890685,
0.0949498564,
-0.4227192402,
0.4670215845,
-0.4230778217,
-0.6824371815,
0.4490558207,
0.4868930876,
0.445381999,
-0.5385077596,
0.638020277,
0.3568791747,
0.0977634192,
0.2657677531,
0.4060924053,
0.0917857662,
-0.6289477944,
0.0949653238,
-0.5317221284,
-0.0873338357,
0.7218633294,
-0.4035051167,
0.3938988745,
-1.0592249632,
-0.3250572681,
0.6238153577,
-0.2085531205,
-0.4683859348,
0.5422431827,
0.2111683488,
0.2867000699,
-1.2879681587,
0.1862628311,
0.9379820824,
-0.2302340865,
-0.250174135,
-0.3739272654,
0.855604589,
-0.878585279,
0.2441720814,
0.2820895314,
0.1163432747,
-0.2082831413,
-0.6303306818,
-0.5206624269,
0.6263225675,
-0.152011916,
-0.3220430613,
0.0635297522,
0.500321269,
0.7516174316,
-0.3062439561,
0.1138873324,
0.8556992412,
0.4509179294,
-0.074361816,
-0.6495777369,
0.1269968152,
-0.3329045475,
-0.0171348006,
0.2860940397,
-0.7405980229,
0.5258943439,
0.3255881667,
-0.0384594053,
-0.5856025815,
0.3351151347,
0.4174818993,
0.508877337,
0.4837235808,
0.4379270375,
0.2781187594,
-0.0368302912,
0.5136017799,
-0.0537427142,
-0.0567243323,
1.0886919498,
0.0357377268,
0.284045577,
0.0591936521,
-0.3737848997,
0.3962492049,
0.8357733488,
-0.1949695796,
0.3964031339,
0.1557571888,
-0.3496939242,
-0.4155672193,
-0.5757731199,
0.1551649868,
0.5809183121,
0.463249743,
-0.3076777756,
-0.3558916748,
0.1723655164,
0.3351242244,
0.0522924066,
-0.3169198334,
0.8586759567,
-0.0276220031,
-0.1416200548,
0.0140456147,
-0.0846183524,
0.5124502778,
-0.2672970295,
-0.158928737,
-0.0170190092,
0.0596160069,
-0.4812969267,
-1.0981388092,
0.3337336779,
0.1509729624,
0.00730466,
-0.2452279031,
1.0261446238,
-0.4492292702,
-0.5234659314,
0.2297935188,
0.380415678,
0.3109062612,
-0.127744168,
-0.8085900545,
-0.0345935896,
-0.0374907628,
-0.115695186,
0.6483155489,
0.4896453321,
-0.2333685458,
0.4413124323,
0.6187713146,
0.1205204055,
-0.0366468281,
-0.0158296134,
0.8887697458,
-0.3662584424,
-0.2432139665,
-0.5631023645,
0.6899142861,
-0.7273210287,
-0.2924542427,
0.4787043631,
0.5573877692,
0.9049064517,
0.4047207534,
0.8886243701,
-0.6145356894,
0.7846345305,
0.0474612154,
0.290538311,
-0.3231852353,
-0.1453985572,
-0.3641228378,
-0.9364842176,
-0.0868317112,
0.5394861698,
0.0346854478,
0.308198303,
0.3235544562,
0.7128293514,
-0.3453448713,
0.2382597625,
-0.0033923669,
0.3789563477,
0.2909035683,
0.0591120422,
0.4585841,
-0.481287092,
0.5021310449,
-0.6718592048,
-0.548342526,
-0.1223258376,
-0.5764016509,
-1.1325119734,
-0.5650220513,
-0.3313780725,
-0.3754901886,
0.2317636013,
0.7374568582,
0.5081808567,
-0.9445621967,
0.0010657279,
0.2019318044,
-0.2288241088,
-0.0947491303,
-0.3193413913,
-0.1197375581,
-0.0485631824,
-0.416136086,
0.4340434968,
-0.0146148726,
-0.003489831,
-0.357246846,
0.3958056867,
-0.4580255151,
0.0907409489,
0.8901870251,
0.3302282393,
0.1070210338,
-0.3309480846,
-0.2421089113,
0.1955976486,
-0.1485280395,
0.5703752041,
-0.7077566981,
0.5760147572,
0.4770692587,
0.5065817833,
0.4151314795,
0.1093245149,
0.5365163684,
-1.2807019949,
-0.18394728,
0.1629354209,
0.0891297385,
0.3345413804,
-0.3183420002,
0.3531239927,
0.7045033574,
-0.2328539789,
-1.0274790525,
0.0704785287,
-0.5890488029,
-0.3785538375,
0.860512197,
0.0591429509,
-0.2504701018,
-0.5010828972,
-0.0502016097,
0.4381458759,
-0.6308823824,
1.109290123,
0.6327387691,
-0.1734497696,
-0.0131966807,
-0.3436975181,
0.4436282814,
-0.0585502572,
-0.8521332145,
0.1880270988,
0.7409398556,
0.149512127,
0.1284189671,
0.1537849754,
-0.0700765774,
0.2294046432,
0.034389969,
-0.1123634502,
-0.0830240771,
-1.0332823992,
-0.0703670382,
0.1879109889,
-0.9980845451,
0.2311605811
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06529v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06529v3
|
Introspective Planning: Aligning Robots' Uncertainty with Inherent Task Ambiguity
| 2024-02-09T16:40:59 | 2024-06-04T02:25:30 |
Kaiqu Liang, Zixu Zhang, Jaime Fernández Fisac
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) exhibit advanced reasoning skills, enabling
robots to comprehend natural language instructions and strategically plan
high-level actions through proper grounding. However, LLM hallucination may
result in robots confidently executing plans that are misaligned with user
goals or, in extreme cases, unsafe. Additionally, inherent ambiguity in natural
language instructions can induce task uncertainty, particularly in situations
where multiple valid options exist. To address this issue, LLMs must identify
such uncertainty and proactively seek clarification. This paper explores the
concept of introspective planning as a systematic method for guiding LLMs in
forming uncertainty--aware plans for robotic task execution without the need
for fine-tuning. We investigate uncertainty quantification in task-level robot
planning and demonstrate that introspection significantly improves both success
rates and safety compared to state-of-the-art LLM-based planning approaches.
Furthermore, we assess the effectiveness of introspective planning in
conjunction with conformal prediction, revealing that this combination yields
tighter confidence bounds, thereby maintaining statistical success guarantees
with fewer superfluous user clarification queries. Code is available at
https://github.com/kevinliang888/IntroPlan.
|
[
-0.2054111063,
-0.9203459024,
0.9327391386,
-0.1211314723,
-0.0036227766,
0.0123297563,
-0.2775463164,
-0.3465878963,
0.3335739374,
0.549531877,
-1.0293457508,
-0.3143799901,
-0.7783629298,
-0.106756486,
0.032641232,
0.5792129636,
-0.1276839226,
-0.2572005689,
0.1673907936,
0.0615113862,
-0.4376032352,
0.0195003673,
-0.1661273241,
-0.2040225863,
0.4183232188,
0.7348765731,
1.0450963974,
0.7530130148,
0.6519248486,
0.2979332507,
-0.259390831,
0.5809768438,
-0.1082395241,
0.4826176465,
-0.2594634593,
-0.6175495982,
-0.2489737272,
-0.7046847343,
0.2002079189,
1.0977274179,
-0.0962072015,
0.1349879801,
0.0695265904,
0.7756975293,
-1.07231462,
-0.0045493213,
-0.7450233698,
0.3891128302,
0.1925140321,
-0.0192958415,
-0.2086972743,
-0.1192445382,
0.2564689517,
-0.7280355692,
-0.1008581668,
-0.1723929495,
0.5186391473,
0.8453059196,
-0.1325766444,
-0.4489676654,
-1.3047628403,
0.4164266586,
-0.589887619,
0.2625187337,
0.2180476487,
0.1944084018,
-0.5626711249,
-0.5265336633,
-0.7207824588,
0.1503360271,
-0.1202132031,
0.1012969986,
-0.2991501987,
0.4699682295,
0.3128701746,
-0.2227175087,
-0.8165495992,
0.2114138156,
-0.4804571569,
-0.0121731041,
0.5276151299,
0.0877600536,
-0.1936260462,
-0.0042690784,
-0.4180453122,
-0.0992358401,
-0.4472651184,
0.2312570959,
0.4804141521,
0.5324062705,
0.0684642792,
0.9547797441,
-0.6204026937,
0.7921105623,
0.0551936813,
-0.050659623,
-0.0107275201,
-0.2135692388,
-0.2507402301,
-0.2003395557,
0.6488489509,
0.2607116997,
0.3971555829,
-0.0159733389,
-0.2893470526,
-0.1065437049,
0.5611511469,
-0.2215162814,
-0.3913027644,
0.9267415404,
-0.2096223533,
0.2595231831,
0.0684533119,
-0.4789478481,
-0.4369253814,
-0.5634425282,
0.6209187508,
-0.4577489793,
0.0280837305,
0.4601108134,
-0.0289182011,
-0.2006849349,
0.5755901337,
-0.5540230274,
0.1583218426,
0.7197666168,
0.6096194386,
0.1918299198,
-0.1986501664,
-0.2350729704,
0.6060976386,
-0.3008229434,
0.7381545901,
-0.1427505016,
-0.3953251541,
0.1802168041,
-0.1531775594,
0.0776119605,
-0.4074617028,
0.5853831172,
-0.213522166,
0.1252811849,
0.0993921459,
-0.4272289872,
-0.4524636567,
0.3268080652,
-0.6357334852,
0.6940267682,
0.1821266562,
-0.2942626178,
0.4217153788,
-0.5193003416,
-0.3605380058,
0.1603726447,
-0.235093236,
-0.205430463,
-0.2463683188,
0.2618793547,
0.7172671556,
0.3448823392,
0.1455556005,
-0.037946526,
-0.1607853025,
0.1222807541,
0.1575276405,
0.5534850955,
0.3464577496,
-0.3150247037,
0.4614813328,
-0.3685150445,
0.288728416,
-0.1464507282,
0.2156125456,
0.0018751096,
0.1861511618,
-0.5226773024,
0.2295149565,
0.5854038,
-0.1186717004,
0.0321314149,
-0.748652041,
-0.0479719415,
0.7064850926,
0.0661940426,
0.8099371791,
-0.3621716499,
0.7048102021,
-0.4075371623,
0.4025451243,
-0.1824417859,
-0.3914081156,
-0.5436248779,
0.0402476266,
-0.2130024731,
0.7660256028,
-0.3886484802,
0.9845298529,
-0.0552497841,
-0.5082743764,
-0.252777487,
0.1428920925,
0.2821952403,
0.291108489,
0.3573130369,
-0.0133932093,
-0.5647144318,
-0.9420713186,
-0.0024388798,
-0.3831206858,
-0.3464165032,
-0.0355260223,
0.3402349949,
-0.1613787264,
0.873378098,
-0.7847183347,
-0.4636862278,
-0.5022832751,
0.1227677837,
0.1958666742,
0.4584692419,
0.0046222652,
-0.9205366373,
-0.2976123095,
-0.0119165741,
-0.3778647482,
0.3443137407,
-0.4190874398,
-0.241049245,
-0.0604429655,
0.5107716918,
-0.8772180676,
0.4880434275,
0.3824800849,
0.0809235051,
0.3347058296,
-0.3231191039,
-0.4116669893,
-0.726644218,
-0.1253253222,
-0.0430767611,
0.0318160094,
-0.6615411043,
0.2441105098,
-0.0387939326,
0.3268975616,
-0.2739424109,
0.2050278485,
-0.5725824237,
0.0315385796,
-0.4640093148,
0.3662312925,
-0.1180464849,
0.4556317329,
0.2667603195,
0.3571893573,
0.2045588791,
-0.7570305467,
-0.1108646914,
0.4086471498,
-0.1778048575,
0.2127737701,
-0.5272145867,
-0.0089374231,
-0.1300079674,
0.2607012093,
-0.996712029,
-0.3897119462,
0.7916858196,
-0.5258390903,
0.3783539832,
-0.0299627725,
-0.1721484959,
-0.4056889415,
-0.069858335,
0.1681324989,
0.4175231755,
0.0500109494,
0.7400652766,
0.4425098598,
-0.2912487388,
-0.92257303,
-0.408451736,
-0.1781603247,
-0.1018797085,
-0.4897861481,
0.2629033923,
-0.031462729,
-0.4246212542,
-0.1076316386,
-0.3515352011,
-0.0809680074,
0.1330574304,
0.3751085699,
0.243072167,
0.1907627285,
-0.087086685,
-0.0116781536,
-0.0794694573,
0.2389034182,
-0.122832872,
0.6201466322,
0.3014577329,
-0.4715927243,
-0.3537242711,
0.1630271226,
-0.0192347746,
0.0026508968,
0.3125919104,
0.4570994675,
-0.5159984231,
-0.3359281123,
-0.3139087856,
-0.267832607,
-0.5041567087,
0.3156477213,
-0.3032732308,
-0.6136125326,
0.3785825968,
-0.3316662312,
0.251613915,
0.2676517367,
0.2572979927,
-0.6209486723,
0.6871970892,
0.9366007447,
0.461594224,
0.2385003567,
-0.209426865,
0.2170668989,
-0.8495265245,
-0.358722955,
-0.5956680775,
-0.6246621013,
-0.5960831046,
-0.7551673055,
0.5374736786,
-0.1829938442,
-0.2915092111,
0.4394149482,
-0.7683640122,
0.421186775,
0.4883647263,
0.3172357678,
0.0506917387,
-0.4130409956,
0.3648115993,
0.1513108462,
-0.4911893606,
-0.8848167062,
1.121825695,
0.1293608397,
0.5176612139,
-0.0590051599,
0.6114789844,
-0.0060114372,
-0.5671184659,
-0.7911573052,
0.5223192573,
0.2940198481,
-0.5449652076,
-0.9283413887,
0.0671350658,
-1.1095439196,
0.2773413956,
-0.1883684844,
-1.0304754972,
0.3558675349,
0.1027368903,
-0.8426241279,
0.2568181455,
-0.4570060074,
0.4881139696,
-0.2333570719,
-0.0463173836,
-0.1478835493,
-1.4516046047,
0.257268101,
-0.0385517441,
0.2580995262,
-0.4625059068,
-0.4581598639,
0.339361757,
-0.0285539161,
0.9199918509,
-0.185755983,
-0.1561948657,
0.310967803,
0.3446271122,
1.0342816114,
-0.2002669722,
0.0550888069,
-0.0229916461,
-0.2587181628,
-0.176188603,
-0.6087525487,
-0.0036056361,
-0.3207260668,
-0.6513212919,
-0.1637250334,
-0.89473176,
-0.3383096755,
0.0297098123,
0.2751955688,
-0.3817470372,
-0.2019685209,
-0.1616106927,
0.9039481282,
-0.1004342362,
0.3094100952,
0.3971008956,
0.0364798382,
0.1551745534,
0.27723068,
-0.0131092845,
0.5250635147,
0.795253098,
0.0595664978,
-0.1097731963,
-0.9105901122,
-0.232182309,
-0.1835804731,
-0.6246804595,
-0.2567683458,
-0.741110146,
-0.1492332369,
-0.3027326465,
-0.6112233996,
-0.3421053886,
-0.6959322691,
-0.0767447278,
-0.1178398579,
0.0121966349,
0.7538898587,
-0.3670288622,
0.7789081931,
-0.4489193857,
0.482121557,
-0.1666348875,
-0.2799732983,
-0.4180281758,
-0.4283806086,
-0.1481868476,
0.3623079658,
-0.2989366651,
-0.6428078413,
0.416515857,
-0.1862005591,
0.6131662726,
0.5832643509,
0.4816398919,
0.7797899246,
-0.4189673364,
0.5985340476,
-0.0414791964,
-0.5380169749,
0.9553100467,
-0.1521354467,
0.4031841159,
0.7083156109,
0.6849361062,
-0.1862440258,
-0.7645636201,
-0.7311749458,
-1.1362329721,
0.5552924871,
0.158107698,
-0.0192106962,
0.4557984769,
0.2207026184,
0.4019246697,
0.2480332553,
-0.6367843151,
-0.1546623707,
0.3634646237,
-0.2097418606,
0.075471893,
-0.2007667422,
-0.5033763647,
-0.0705149323,
0.2255841196,
-0.2043184042,
0.2936329544,
0.0426351316,
-0.0183767397,
-0.4154290855,
0.1277106106,
0.6935363412,
0.7469373941,
-0.4008889198,
0.1460174769,
0.2801529467,
-0.3826815486,
0.0127069317,
0.0184737928,
-0.1296840757,
-0.1189503968,
0.4341697693,
0.103172943,
0.0481267609,
-0.9051116705,
0.2551283538,
0.3427039385,
-0.0014342996,
-0.6942555308,
0.3140843511,
-0.0871202648,
0.4489660263,
0.2302651554,
0.3363911211,
0.3516930938,
-0.2396314591,
0.1311082989,
0.480622977,
-0.3828659356,
-0.0903974324,
0.4255750179,
-0.0611441508,
-0.2636891603,
0.3280293941,
-0.1916285455,
-0.3897256255,
0.8351308703,
0.1757763028,
0.9529232383,
-0.2956495583,
0.2878177166,
0.4740259945,
0.8375653028,
0.1260754615,
0.4927430451,
-0.2026530206,
-0.9304491878,
-0.3835323751,
-0.2591360509,
-0.6319817305,
-0.3979476392,
-0.4808966815,
0.1836017966,
-0.5074415207,
0.0639486238,
-0.2216098011,
-0.1825011671,
-0.5182865262,
0.3763125241,
-0.0177075956,
0.5236135721,
-0.4452850819,
0.4179155231,
0.6605607271,
-0.1465614885,
-0.9399417639,
0.4454312623,
0.1912727058,
-1.0472253561,
0.4998120964,
-0.0102839861,
-0.4793010652,
-0.5014919639,
-0.6266572475,
-1.0879509449,
1.0203713179,
0.0383634344,
-0.7296404839,
-0.1790943146,
0.3492642045,
0.2228982896,
-0.1574257761,
0.0522542931,
0.2822646201,
0.7730472088,
0.2280230224,
-0.7555206418,
0.1262887418,
0.2301075757,
-0.3490390778,
0.4966002405,
-0.3819708526,
0.659317553,
-0.7423630357,
-0.3933941424,
0.1181052998,
0.7065838575,
0.0844381675,
0.4038867056,
0.6013669968,
0.3067082167,
1.0025619268,
-0.1021609157,
0.6818004251,
-0.2811304331,
-0.4221092761,
1.5078901052,
-0.4739502072,
0.8133653402,
0.4930400848,
-0.1974346191,
0.3381396234,
0.5070670843,
0.2522100508,
0.5258760452,
-0.022143133,
-0.0255378503,
-0.1687332094,
0.0153354378,
-0.1095299348,
0.5509598255,
0.628364861,
0.0441411696,
0.0241065864,
-0.1498739123,
0.0671444163,
0.3656950295,
-0.0759216845,
0.7959989309,
-0.2049696445,
-0.6904400587,
-0.0776984915,
-0.2291535586,
0.4434494078,
-0.6910740733,
0.1294517368,
0.1780118942,
0.1144210994,
-0.2648099661,
-1.3901662827,
0.5007413626,
-0.452588737,
0.0909760073,
-0.2925151587,
0.6164782643,
-0.1967694014,
-0.0774318129,
0.0116738463,
0.6869266629,
-0.0022515436,
-0.2920643985,
-0.5499905944,
-0.1361000836,
0.1228258759,
-0.166705966,
0.0292142313,
0.8734332323,
0.2411981672,
0.9535256624,
0.3103418946,
0.0358531177,
-0.2355924845,
-0.5345050097,
0.618907392,
-0.5237832665,
-0.2814451456,
-0.6404021978,
0.7431063056,
0.1597047895,
-0.5262419581,
0.5193952322,
0.5820688009,
1.0552185774,
-0.0926332548,
0.4846052527,
-0.0746842548,
0.4715878069,
-0.6643663049,
0.0266175475,
-0.2829569578,
0.2322477102,
-0.1737628877,
-0.6807163954,
-0.3337085247,
0.7722783089,
-0.1399792433,
-0.1540924311,
0.5531293154,
0.6580532789,
0.2558211684,
-0.1339106262,
0.2011803389,
-0.1156258062,
0.0091915485,
0.6251670122,
0.9512102008,
0.073999688,
0.4862396121,
-0.7104471922,
-0.0328296497,
-0.1893265843,
-0.6110364795,
-0.3414967656,
-0.7646309137,
-0.168131575,
0.1297604293,
0.127193585,
1.1356153488,
0.6665682197,
-0.3978117704,
-0.4627409577,
-0.1435799152,
0.3265609145,
-0.3145372272,
-0.1419483423,
0.1833370775,
-0.4860422909,
-0.7352333069,
0.4881650507,
0.2197137326,
0.1504931748,
-0.1846135259,
-0.1928905249,
-0.2987916768,
0.0482300296,
0.303042978,
0.3963966072,
-0.823784709,
-0.1584232599,
0.1029473841,
-0.0029024063,
-0.0028493847,
0.5989114046,
-0.6662620306,
0.4138852656,
0.1053239182,
0.2016741484,
0.3889582753,
0.1105324402,
0.7700290084,
-0.800018847,
0.4331175089,
0.7932105064,
0.2092796266,
-0.077576369,
-0.8187587261,
1.0222046375,
-0.60792768,
-0.7186670303,
-0.6232610345,
0.4881052673,
-1.3053907156,
-0.6298233867,
1.0822796822,
0.197540015,
0.0037193033,
-0.2258680314,
-0.3298023939,
0.2540536821,
-0.1499204636,
0.7614889741,
0.4103669524,
-0.6153520942,
0.051879283,
-0.6153162122,
0.5502429605,
0.328218013,
-0.5757989883,
0.1600834727,
0.6276302338,
-0.425978899,
0.3450207114,
0.3565823138,
0.3728903234,
0.2739726901,
-0.0590918027,
0.3049088717,
0.2749513984,
-0.6482198238,
-0.006725207,
0.296133846,
0.1507301331,
-0.3260628581
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06512v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06512v3
|
Multimodal Clinical Trial Outcome Prediction with Large Language Models
| 2024-02-09T16:18:38 | 2024-05-09T01:22:35 |
Wenhao Zheng, Dongsheng Peng, Hongxia Xu, Yun Li, Hongtu Zhu, Tianfan Fu, Huaxiu Yao
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
The clinical trial is a pivotal and costly process, often spanning multiple
years and requiring substantial financial resources. Therefore, the development
of clinical trial outcome prediction models aims to exclude drugs likely to
fail and holds the potential for significant cost savings. Recent data-driven
attempts leverage deep learning methods to integrate multimodal data for
predicting clinical trial outcomes. However, these approaches rely on manually
designed modal-specific encoders, which limits both the extensibility to adapt
new modalities and the ability to discern similar information patterns across
different modalities. To address these issues, we propose a multimodal
mixture-of-experts (LIFTED) approach for clinical trial outcome prediction.
Specifically, LIFTED unifies different modality data by transforming them into
natural language descriptions. Then, LIFTED constructs unified noise-resilient
encoders to extract information from modal-specific language descriptions.
Subsequently, a sparse Mixture-of-Experts framework is employed to further
refine the representations, enabling LIFTED to identify similar information
patterns across different modalities and extract more consistent
representations from those patterns using the same expert model. Finally, a
mixture-of-experts module is further employed to dynamically integrate
different modality representations for prediction, which gives LIFTED the
ability to automatically weigh different modalities and pay more attention to
critical information. The experiments demonstrate that LIFTED significantly
enhances performance in predicting clinical trial outcomes across all three
phases compared to the best baseline, showcasing the effectiveness of our
proposed key components.
|
[
-0.171232298,
-0.5611283779,
0.6390461326,
0.2407523245,
-0.278196305,
0.2913135588,
-0.3560722768,
-0.6166423559,
0.3904707134,
0.4606115222,
-0.4428068399,
-0.2510372102,
-0.9735264182,
0.0249994993,
-0.1624269783,
1.1262886524,
-0.0284558367,
0.534604013,
-0.0759704113,
0.0174568873,
-0.7845164537,
-0.1646803766,
-0.1407278031,
-0.3829036057,
0.7098362446,
0.1321012825,
0.6348766088,
0.3346209228,
0.5367693901,
0.2682733238,
0.0721311718,
0.1629491299,
-0.3695420027,
0.082302168,
0.1595624238,
-0.4624820352,
-0.3604124784,
0.0557297319,
0.0821341798,
0.7388440371,
-0.3566956818,
-0.6466934085,
-0.1565863043,
0.0648875833,
-0.556581676,
0.1628866792,
-0.8000282049,
0.2762946784,
0.0922119096,
-0.5830891728,
-0.4154901206,
-0.1515228897,
0.2197849751,
-0.7082643509,
0.167639792,
0.0019690676,
0.3604079783,
0.1235906407,
-0.8050524592,
-0.362873286,
-0.4311676025,
0.7823417187,
-0.9038003087,
0.2373974025,
0.4404488206,
0.5866091847,
-0.4494837821,
-0.5477488041,
-0.5079923868,
-0.4866068065,
-0.2525084019,
0.4926302135,
0.363121748,
0.3940215707,
0.0644003972,
0.3396961689,
-0.3881394863,
0.1643183231,
-0.5111215711,
-0.2223826647,
0.5095593929,
0.2907913923,
0.1614328176,
-0.2143567055,
-0.691855073,
0.1663807482,
-0.3358641565,
0.0080262283,
-0.2541770637,
0.5606504679,
-0.1626477391,
0.465937376,
-0.2651961148,
0.3129031062,
0.2454150319,
-0.4295601249,
0.6414635777,
-0.2822251916,
-0.1549463868,
0.0894172341,
0.7550561428,
0.3800830841,
-0.0546396151,
-0.2596725523,
-0.2805945575,
-0.1223974675,
0.3207051456,
-0.8286060095,
-0.2877965868,
0.3079393804,
-0.6936652064,
-0.4620839357,
-0.0358294509,
-0.8078625798,
-0.9135227799,
-0.3242297471,
0.6360833049,
-0.7177168727,
-0.5636072755,
0.3932453692,
-0.1950413734,
-0.348218143,
0.7676743865,
-0.5188603401,
0.1857777238,
0.5147940516,
0.5624805689,
-0.20176211,
-0.0778679326,
-0.7424708009,
0.244743973,
-0.0194218308,
0.536703527,
-0.7544278502,
-0.4420693815,
0.2235420644,
-0.1001196206,
-0.3329021335,
-0.2196527719,
0.7120062709,
-0.5231074095,
0.4951248765,
-0.1644917876,
-0.7653492689,
-0.2140201181,
0.2076025754,
-0.6999260783,
0.4525123239,
-0.0439830907,
-0.6396592855,
0.9397831559,
-0.4151790142,
-0.6736672521,
0.4394260645,
-0.6042269468,
-0.3985140324,
0.592810452,
0.3798772097,
0.5060016513,
-0.1177957654,
0.4748560488,
-0.461062789,
-0.08941672,
0.5157233477,
-0.2471599281,
0.239266634,
0.3484724462,
-0.2941352725,
0.0325569585,
-0.8528360724,
-0.1307300329,
-0.3012165725,
-0.4509203434,
-0.3102207184,
-0.0797672123,
0.476768434,
0.4320828021,
-0.0539579205,
-0.741635263,
0.0593632869,
-0.1293685138,
0.2118649781,
0.7538479567,
-0.1077932119,
0.2139307261,
-0.0835290998,
0.5954936147,
0.3615579605,
0.2378462106,
-0.0491002798,
-0.6145517826,
-0.2270375192,
-0.535030067,
0.3132605553,
0.1386553347,
-1.0382653475,
0.2728823125,
-0.5121498704,
-0.2914246917,
-0.3859842718,
0.0458170548,
0.6111869812,
0.4373211563,
0.3652173579,
-0.5112738013,
-0.3467592299,
-1.0484887362,
-0.1861682534,
-0.0176217109,
0.0971391276,
0.167046085,
0.6912785769,
-0.1314341277,
0.6824966669,
-0.6095254421,
-0.568226397,
-0.2994692028,
0.5041477084,
0.2186641395,
0.6550878286,
0.2891021669,
-1.0121730566,
-0.1309987158,
0.2952933908,
-0.5161233544,
0.2291352153,
-0.386526525,
0.1975747198,
-0.3082371056,
0.2811907232,
-0.5885028243,
0.4598257542,
0.3104351461,
-0.3623122275,
0.3520917594,
-0.3132151663,
0.3508846164,
-1.0697830915,
-0.1475791633,
0.1588590145,
-0.084403038,
-0.6465344429,
-0.274823904,
0.2990523279,
0.096102491,
-0.1756878942,
0.3705298901,
-0.3491105437,
0.1204178333,
-0.1932438463,
-0.3110153675,
0.0066279308,
0.3171476722,
0.3998473585,
0.4848923385,
0.2617050111,
-0.1894678921,
-0.0160304718,
0.271042794,
-0.5981197357,
0.3644854426,
-0.5610027909,
-0.2993160188,
-0.2241856307,
0.4384562969,
-0.9545673728,
-0.589959383,
-0.1744854152,
-0.739254415,
0.4786535501,
-0.0573763326,
-0.2277821302,
-0.2612064481,
-0.1667769551,
0.3987465501,
0.1582082212,
-0.0033772576,
0.8906846642,
0.2546300292,
-0.2918237746,
-0.6590659618,
-0.9491266012,
0.2722837925,
0.0059495457,
-0.1996207684,
0.2160759419,
-0.0255319215,
0.1903070807,
0.012102372,
0.2631801367,
-0.192209512,
-0.1064108461,
0.4571013153,
0.1499409974,
-0.0138533385,
0.4807296693,
0.3459675312,
-0.091788061,
-0.0963734165,
0.2272750437,
0.2079967856,
0.1556372941,
-0.5957743526,
-0.4518979788,
0.5812647939,
0.7438553572,
-0.2007810473,
0.8581607938,
0.8753623366,
-0.5232166052,
0.1677366197,
-0.8826054931,
-0.2522297204,
-0.3828637302,
0.6237817407,
-0.3737677932,
-0.5845461488,
0.3587346673,
0.0206547156,
-0.0210061781,
0.2194522172,
0.8587239385,
-0.0777611583,
1.3458611965,
0.3143197,
0.0413756594,
0.4670003951,
-0.1367752999,
0.0128741898,
-0.6622331738,
-0.5956529379,
-0.0388729312,
-0.5202921629,
-0.0857899413,
-0.6099773049,
0.7895889282,
-0.2126065195,
0.1213519126,
0.1318929344,
-0.3252612948,
0.1039121225,
0.3452994227,
0.3855846524,
0.3621015251,
0.1985631436,
-0.1556107551,
-0.3079683781,
-0.445135802,
0.0694159344,
1.2808892727,
0.3171516657,
0.7585365772,
-0.0987611115,
0.4717722237,
0.376957804,
0.5217971206,
-0.5358136296,
0.2151372135,
0.0955090374,
-0.8187637925,
0.3234935105,
-0.5385199785,
-0.8747284412,
0.3972868025,
-0.6859471202,
-0.2057753205,
0.4743578434,
-0.34121117,
-0.7461788058,
0.0228079539,
-0.5856877565,
0.4459970593,
-0.4552634656,
-0.1519211978,
-0.5139303207,
-0.7933650613,
0.3564035594,
-0.0816727802,
0.6077495217,
0.0154625047,
-0.2603642642,
0.6079643965,
-0.2599998116,
0.9264159203,
-0.2336762547,
0.1441313326,
-0.2099517584,
0.0657089129,
0.3050161898,
0.1905499399,
-0.071393393,
-0.1905892044,
-0.0994081348,
-0.4578771293,
-0.5970692039,
0.7146926522,
-0.8772692084,
-0.023740856,
-0.2461310029,
-0.9132658243,
-0.4098208547,
0.0971354619,
0.0235445797,
0.8713944554,
-0.0284191538,
0.1985160857,
0.3027327359,
-0.4197882414,
0.1463399827,
0.7063207626,
0.0779522136,
-1.0872700214,
0.6624603271,
-0.0559492521,
0.3297364116,
0.4481311142,
0.2211171985,
-0.4089770019,
-1.1237289906,
-0.3097077012,
-0.0627983958,
-0.6668098569,
-0.2387671322,
-0.8963909745,
0.2537974417,
-0.4752098024,
-0.1560589522,
-0.2957049608,
-0.4769791961,
-0.0714997649,
-0.2546655834,
0.3201953471,
0.642745316,
0.0146696325,
0.3672153354,
-0.861232698,
0.2983948588,
0.0718572959,
0.2726461887,
-0.1184404716,
-0.4911080003,
-0.471570313,
0.1500909775,
-0.2346479744,
-0.6274526715,
0.6872140765,
0.2912447155,
0.7354958057,
0.7362588048,
0.0305052102,
0.8083606958,
-0.1666388214,
0.5195342898,
0.9032820463,
-0.3570782244,
0.53824085,
-0.5620335937,
-0.1651717722,
0.8521296978,
0.2416215688,
-0.2975723743,
-0.2457768172,
-0.2910929024,
-0.6734696627,
0.5341613889,
0.2029197365,
-0.1423508674,
-0.0432378389,
0.1287065148,
0.8542426229,
0.5689425468,
-0.5836381912,
0.2443461865,
-0.1244129166,
-0.5433310866,
-0.1691659093,
-0.0487549491,
-0.4364357591,
-0.4531831145,
0.2484272569,
-0.2872612476,
0.1936721504,
0.1821054667,
-0.2617103755,
-0.2657052875,
0.1994775087,
0.5954796672,
0.8031289577,
-0.4855082333,
0.0555729456,
0.0845999867,
-0.5736176968,
-0.1513558477,
0.2105770409,
0.0906628743,
-0.2019175142,
0.7797730565,
0.8330326676,
0.3387070894,
-0.9789918661,
0.6872494221,
-0.1417354196,
-0.2449885607,
-0.3538903594,
-0.3457552493,
-0.1846545935,
0.2018642575,
0.601405859,
0.3664762974,
0.3595627844,
-0.4793285131,
0.3360100985,
0.3043236732,
-0.7381231785,
-0.3595992029,
0.8026283383,
0.4729369283,
0.2396123558,
0.2695223391,
0.1899666637,
-0.4225874543,
0.6079356074,
0.2376167923,
0.8297300935,
0.0976659805,
0.0922684595,
0.0482751504,
-0.0084527712,
-0.0679324791,
0.2138451785,
0.4046017528,
-0.6304287314,
-0.5962858796,
-0.4420118332,
-0.2063342482,
0.0646245703,
-0.5703791976,
0.1635384113,
-0.2950455546,
-0.2949554622,
0.0223509111,
0.0675342306,
-0.6993998885,
0.368434608,
0.5110141039,
0.8832288384,
-0.9816858768,
0.6126201153,
0.7637312412,
-0.7572857738,
-0.431381911,
-0.451716423,
0.1082520708,
-0.7377736568,
0.7412989736,
0.3269192874,
0.1596819609,
-0.6643513441,
-0.2457263768,
-0.6715375185,
1.1290371418,
0.1948994547,
-0.380705893,
0.0190514904,
0.2174360901,
0.5428422093,
-0.6093451977,
0.8377115726,
0.2811883688,
0.4549792409,
0.4090210795,
-1.0466839075,
0.0659385473,
-0.2861040533,
-0.1438715905,
-0.1603625119,
-0.2402361184,
0.9589592814,
-0.1889538914,
0.0169388521,
0.0453645959,
0.7313988805,
0.0939114988,
0.5574977398,
0.5951942205,
0.6343453526,
0.5896689892,
0.091246292,
1.1335127354,
-0.428676039,
0.1684997231,
0.8782083988,
-0.3820403516,
0.5913801193,
0.4298952818,
-0.2007562667,
0.5105552673,
0.4373447895,
0.2570168078,
0.8255997896,
-0.2807136774,
-0.1119220033,
-0.6735644937,
-0.1945133507,
-0.7074112296,
0.2753257453,
0.4664621651,
-0.591176331,
-0.1988445371,
0.3446592391,
-0.2585560381,
-0.0126910722,
-0.1922714561,
0.6882633567,
0.0785151273,
-0.5376567245,
0.5198429227,
-0.3251082599,
0.8080992699,
-0.4882204235,
0.0309465621,
0.0598292314,
0.6626631618,
-0.2423323393,
-0.6656576991,
-0.2891783416,
-0.6512176394,
-0.052485276,
-0.0909890011,
0.7049931288,
-0.7612990141,
-0.8468190432,
0.3664250076,
0.6084319949,
-0.1428894252,
-0.0101487031,
-0.7771762013,
0.1041807458,
-0.2376756668,
-0.3610856533,
0.7451783419,
0.4899660349,
0.1974560469,
0.8300874829,
0.5439574718,
0.3634481728,
0.1203730851,
0.1304937303,
1.3189313412,
-0.3878373504,
-0.4037531018,
-0.447068125,
0.5580906272,
-0.2834020853,
-0.4647684395,
0.4411234856,
0.6685829163,
0.2021455318,
-0.2066424489,
0.9478340149,
-0.0700001717,
0.6221032739,
-0.386017561,
0.6735032797,
-0.733833909,
0.0465944447,
-0.2154030353,
-0.1416475624,
-0.1804790795,
0.1970173717,
-0.4457224607,
0.0855057538,
0.4920234978,
0.626424849,
-0.1012677923,
0.1464924365,
0.2494803816,
0.3515315056,
0.6021734476,
0.8046326041,
0.6860060692,
-0.3317379653,
0.5112141371,
-0.3430702984,
-0.4086430669,
-0.467969954,
-0.6890492439,
-0.8841853738,
-0.4525279999,
-0.2260097116,
-0.0994316489,
-0.04782914,
1.249930501,
0.8095453382,
-0.9812905788,
0.082003504,
0.2332542539,
-0.1935123354,
-0.4340349436,
-0.1924853772,
0.2778755426,
-0.3390657604,
-0.6104839444,
0.4806573987,
0.2906900942,
-0.3543355167,
-0.1188229695,
-0.2061549872,
-0.1992816776,
-0.2396603525,
0.5235197544,
-0.1700032055,
-0.8618825674,
-0.1063938737,
-0.2071128935,
-0.1585259885,
-0.1079172269,
0.9336479902,
-1.0384237766,
0.8246011138,
0.5681074858,
0.6435874701,
0.2910291255,
0.0560170263,
0.9383581877,
-0.4238942266,
0.2025705874,
0.6211817861,
0.5083414912,
-0.0030143098,
-0.206401214,
0.3901869059,
0.3260825872,
-0.3796236217,
-0.7246240377,
0.0436226204,
-1.1716374159,
-0.3091882169,
1.0581028461,
-0.1001056284,
0.1078122407,
-0.4922530949,
-0.2510274351,
0.0418013856,
-0.7683079243,
0.9820350409,
0.4073135555,
0.0045427564,
-0.3135607839,
-0.8284025788,
0.3806312084,
0.467997551,
-0.468816191,
-0.0127624525,
0.6700848341,
0.2323766798,
0.1089257523,
0.492271632,
-0.2910911739,
0.2061272413,
-0.2521305084,
0.2701433897,
-0.3985155821,
-0.058122769,
-0.1682998687,
0.385568887,
-0.2851205468,
0.0215859134
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06509v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06509v1
|
Asking the Right Question at the Right Time: Human and Model Uncertainty Guidance to Ask Clarification Questions
| 2024-02-09T16:15:30 | 2024-02-09T16:15:30 |
Alberto Testoni, Raquel Fernández
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Clarification questions are an essential dialogue tool to signal
misunderstanding, ambiguities, and under-specification in language use. While
humans are able to resolve uncertainty by asking questions since childhood,
modern dialogue systems struggle to generate effective questions. To make
progress in this direction, in this work we take a collaborative dialogue task
as a testbed and study how model uncertainty relates to human uncertainty -- an
as yet under-explored problem. We show that model uncertainty does not mirror
human clarification-seeking behavior, which suggests that using human
clarification questions as supervision for deciding when to ask may not be the
most effective way to resolve model uncertainty. To address this issue, we
propose an approach to generating clarification questions based on model
uncertainty estimation, compare it to several alternatives, and show that it
leads to significant improvements in terms of task success. Our findings
highlight the importance of equipping dialogue systems with the ability to
assess their own uncertainty and exploit in interaction.
|
[
-0.5450104475,
-1.1078242064,
1.0037175417,
-0.063413471,
-0.2375264168,
-0.1102409288,
-0.1694623828,
-0.458935082,
-0.3301644623,
0.4984277785,
-0.7209258676,
0.0021492634,
-0.6510964036,
0.0528888032,
-0.1081513911,
0.4623169899,
-0.0140185785,
0.0256200898,
-0.3615301251,
-0.1556303799,
-0.5581806898,
-0.4504324794,
-0.6931049228,
-0.1998234242,
0.4666931629,
0.676933825,
1.0121394396,
0.396741569,
0.523986876,
0.3423427641,
-0.16545403,
0.1673283577,
-0.1817887127,
0.3287964463,
-0.2931806445,
-0.6086575985,
-0.1072401628,
-0.019390909,
0.2171748132,
1.1428489685,
-0.2654073238,
0.4677963257,
-0.139821887,
0.2767805457,
-0.7489976287,
-0.1250880063,
-0.3612991273,
-0.0027434651,
0.0982323885,
-0.0568128526,
-0.1492017359,
-0.3343435526,
0.6856498718,
-0.5837594271,
0.3088969886,
0.2748456597,
1.0244733095,
0.4558699429,
-0.6717618704,
-0.4228416383,
-0.8610335588,
0.7182548046,
-0.717225492,
0.351670146,
0.523637414,
0.425054431,
-0.4087079167,
-0.7106579542,
-0.3915478289,
-0.0707432926,
0.1002497673,
-0.1068138555,
0.0143791912,
0.2286031693,
0.3695596457,
0.0775482282,
-0.2928309441,
-0.305537045,
-0.5137218833,
-0.3386737108,
0.6365355253,
0.1016210616,
0.0871934444,
-0.1376168728,
-0.239999637,
-0.1112208441,
-0.2496398091,
0.252009064,
0.4391060472,
0.0268277656,
0.2256162316,
0.2052551359,
-0.1262573302,
0.9471160769,
0.4207978249,
0.2632272243,
-0.3899145126,
-0.3179803491,
-0.0027617102,
-0.4143748581,
0.6677469611,
0.6286664009,
0.1416320205,
0.0700966865,
-0.1244421303,
-0.1500600874,
0.4828782082,
-0.408711046,
0.0946507975,
0.3903104961,
-0.0613987297,
-0.2416757792,
-0.0293795783,
-0.7775344253,
-0.38173908,
-0.3475851715,
0.5498421192,
0.095372051,
-0.3160256445,
0.122842133,
-0.2979755104,
0.0088743577,
0.648255229,
-0.7382459044,
0.1866377443,
0.394880116,
0.2833536565,
0.2330795377,
0.1159682795,
-0.2554853261,
-0.0541571192,
-0.6151740551,
0.4399583936,
-0.1265760213,
-0.6826185584,
-0.3019007444,
-0.1089684889,
-0.1309668869,
-0.5284007788,
0.4950249493,
-0.2822969854,
0.732091248,
-0.4156478047,
-0.6009450555,
-0.2011250257,
0.3331195414,
-0.3500786126,
0.8325402737,
0.1162241399,
-0.8869971037,
0.2975978851,
-0.5305991769,
0.0201855581,
0.1398369074,
-0.2694277167,
-0.3405140936,
-0.0470071025,
0.358785212,
0.3250538111,
-0.4252480268,
0.6329178214,
-0.3256759942,
-0.2706632614,
0.504044354,
-0.4786038399,
0.5718864799,
0.3495346606,
-0.2997144163,
-0.0196497664,
-0.312348932,
0.3785332143,
0.0590645485,
0.0352985449,
-0.0727914944,
-0.0164981801,
-0.493509382,
0.1067826599,
0.5693259835,
-0.2591378689,
-0.0785994157,
-0.266785562,
0.533634901,
0.5785565972,
0.4452499449,
0.4380638003,
-0.4936082661,
0.6150119901,
-0.2035099566,
0.5304490924,
0.2545633614,
-0.8428353071,
-0.7735950351,
0.4352717996,
0.1925462633,
0.5365561843,
-0.415892452,
0.1273730397,
0.3199460804,
-0.5307988524,
-0.6082423925,
0.0052208877,
0.3869909644,
0.6971357465,
0.1721479446,
-0.3284903765,
-0.5873628855,
-0.9104387164,
-0.1245141849,
-0.6100747585,
0.1095744446,
0.322288096,
0.5204134583,
0.0325346701,
1.3675080538,
-0.7106606364,
0.4782825708,
-0.42961061,
0.6505732536,
-0.1886398047,
0.457287848,
0.1518350989,
-1.1982055902,
-0.1670136303,
-0.3001702726,
-0.7268201709,
-0.0561044589,
-0.1093252078,
-0.2145537138,
-0.1827387363,
0.4025920033,
-0.7646582127,
0.480900079,
0.3162274659,
-0.0004155968,
0.5781484246,
-0.4146396518,
0.1888044477,
-1.0764564276,
0.1688607931,
-0.3286714256,
-0.4495241046,
-0.8524249792,
0.0184077527,
-0.1863478869,
-0.083612293,
-0.3508723676,
0.3767026365,
-0.2090748996,
0.0434225872,
-0.1719370484,
0.2951241732,
0.2921263874,
0.4450948834,
-0.0327931903,
0.651668191,
0.3017906845,
-0.6786720157,
0.3039330542,
0.1018362716,
-0.2278732359,
0.5704268217,
-0.758554101,
0.455398351,
-0.1846907288,
0.1442615539,
-0.6850854754,
-0.4957630634,
0.5834236741,
-0.5865877867,
-0.0144611299,
-0.0189979132,
-0.1367145628,
-0.6610842347,
0.2968236208,
0.3413567245,
0.4409639239,
0.0203353092,
0.4049738348,
0.2766010165,
-0.3233335316,
-0.8143094778,
-0.2843739092,
-0.0757231861,
-0.2831512392,
-0.9488565922,
-0.1089486256,
-0.3999542594,
-0.6538189054,
-0.2896443903,
-0.4452731311,
-0.6099502444,
0.4676081836,
0.4743563831,
0.1601858586,
0.0430937298,
0.1848199517,
-0.1299663335,
-0.0269906241,
0.1972440928,
0.0849825442,
0.2693297267,
-0.3096400499,
-0.6271480918,
-0.6319389939,
0.5291140676,
0.4929186106,
-0.0925917253,
0.1463507861,
0.5262675285,
-0.3303642869,
0.1245655045,
-0.8038601279,
-0.4469182491,
-0.5091159344,
0.087290898,
-0.117692627,
-0.9501643181,
0.5810241103,
-0.1002995819,
0.0337927416,
0.0985892937,
0.311380893,
-0.5809342861,
1.4323134422,
0.5184277296,
0.2628621161,
0.1632384658,
0.0153243067,
0.197511822,
-0.3598867357,
0.1015519649,
-0.5050241351,
-0.0045692138,
-0.0888169855,
-0.476133436,
0.2312073857,
0.3361452818,
-0.0930391848,
0.2609272003,
-0.4014803469,
0.0914701372,
0.8486809731,
0.1320338547,
0.1888545156,
-0.7622944117,
-0.0675876811,
-0.1492763907,
-0.6590750217,
-0.7883324623,
0.5243394971,
0.301060915,
0.5410810709,
-0.078567408,
0.6660641432,
0.1597623378,
-0.1458830088,
-0.4879211783,
0.584541142,
0.7823624015,
-1.1866048574,
-0.5166060328,
-0.3908722103,
-0.9496245384,
0.3802910745,
-0.0491237938,
-0.8205726743,
0.2777665257,
0.4237553775,
-0.8399533033,
0.0024450589,
-0.8771063685,
0.9561110735,
-0.1764639169,
-0.2112391889,
-0.0638238713,
-1.271261096,
0.0875039473,
0.0076635503,
0.4849096835,
-0.3097462058,
0.2101629525,
0.6044250131,
-0.6323028207,
0.9254134297,
-0.1928849965,
-0.1492573321,
0.9540218711,
0.1259799153,
0.4002027214,
0.1460787952,
0.224042356,
-0.3741434216,
0.2456462979,
-0.2749094367,
-0.9986611009,
0.0135079799,
-0.6286102533,
-1.1605181694,
-0.2115378827,
-0.7130892277,
-0.2445458919,
0.0874529779,
0.3594370782,
0.2862975597,
0.0285352767,
-0.0424015895,
0.7320872545,
0.1152615622,
0.1921431273,
0.4043700695,
-0.1731719375,
-0.0188370366,
0.3635591865,
0.1085683331,
0.7952728868,
-0.0406403989,
0.3160463572,
-0.185631454,
-0.3405839801,
-0.5635243654,
0.1202104762,
-0.7164783478,
0.0505463518,
-0.3223192096,
0.056014061,
-0.5691540241,
-0.2457741648,
-0.3642724454,
-0.3780707717,
-0.5096995831,
-0.078874141,
0.1739927828,
0.7900909185,
-0.0447389334,
0.3219285309,
-0.8722751737,
0.0931425244,
0.7320137024,
-0.1803421676,
-0.2799600959,
-0.4420797825,
-0.0707369745,
0.6808331609,
-0.6017031074,
-1.1186021566,
0.2425513268,
-0.0797738731,
0.5186886191,
0.4004553556,
0.4427657425,
0.9249497652,
0.0858205333,
1.1468162537,
-0.1741882861,
-1.0110902786,
0.7109951377,
-0.3988080919,
0.3723936677,
0.5782216787,
0.3496046066,
-0.6056216955,
-0.5762801766,
-0.964081347,
-0.6216511726,
0.5689905882,
0.3667936921,
-0.1006445363,
0.2181974798,
0.4159316719,
-0.2456218749,
0.3710941374,
-0.3840606809,
0.0916622803,
0.0490982644,
-0.0482361019,
0.3074538708,
0.005571756,
-0.4795577228,
-0.0034379056,
0.3346219659,
-0.1764659733,
0.3214030564,
0.4309164286,
0.0013563208,
-0.5004531145,
0.6199300289,
0.599946022,
0.7785397768,
-0.4510773718,
-0.1216607839,
0.7206503749,
-0.0236571301,
0.0276279096,
-0.2187438905,
-0.0591547713,
-0.0382832512,
0.1456418782,
0.747122705,
0.1961423308,
-0.8555314541,
0.6696822047,
-0.2654079199,
-0.3753572106,
-0.2508840263,
0.1743810624,
0.2160355002,
0.2615642846,
0.145624131,
0.3001313806,
0.0773748085,
-0.3850927949,
0.1050435603,
0.2522206306,
-0.5587021112,
-0.0919483975,
0.5140013099,
0.1208446696,
-0.3918944895,
0.5908588171,
-0.0294237789,
-0.6228074431,
0.6965432763,
0.233898595,
0.3070507944,
-0.1632314473,
0.2820994854,
0.1965445578,
0.0599805303,
-0.3304515481,
0.5524185896,
-0.3830928504,
-0.7487485409,
-0.3249876201,
-0.0376531221,
-1.0257022381,
-0.4422869384,
-0.9477605224,
0.1755750179,
-0.3912108839,
-0.8105017543,
-0.3914441466,
-0.1686198115,
-0.4497475028,
0.5075649023,
-0.0931422263,
0.6477169394,
-0.5215851665,
0.3385589123,
0.5266084075,
-0.5614417195,
-1.2105859518,
-0.1666558385,
-0.0718041658,
-0.443038553,
0.4334712029,
-0.0192764923,
-0.2347652763,
-0.0775542259,
-1.0805683136,
-0.9871005416,
1.1067621708,
0.268858701,
-0.3952301443,
-0.4204061627,
0.113149792,
0.5260582566,
-0.0396623835,
0.4594908059,
0.364851594,
0.6710106134,
0.409235239,
-1.0220471621,
-0.243078813,
-0.0247622449,
-0.1602835804,
0.2885354459,
-0.5266389251,
0.7847133279,
-0.5690402985,
-0.3435628116,
0.3946007192,
0.6225598454,
0.0157723986,
0.5047727823,
0.7581838965,
0.3453212082,
1.0149763823,
-0.2849588394,
0.9627124667,
-0.1615593433,
0.3418623805,
1.3248347044,
-0.1617589146,
0.7551441193,
0.6465801001,
0.1281651109,
0.3316238225,
0.8309759498,
0.3650483489,
0.161894232,
0.1816277653,
-0.2260236144,
-0.7931278348,
-0.2549797893,
-0.3842665553,
0.2382343411,
0.7414351702,
-0.2476359904,
-0.0949335843,
-0.0376167148,
0.0024100193,
0.014346363,
0.1472569704,
0.7738231421,
0.2052471489,
-1.1193226576,
0.3680069447,
-0.1220789775,
0.1655133367,
-0.5611581206,
0.2574169934,
0.0895557106,
-0.1118391529,
0.138663426,
-0.7249603271,
0.1218539551,
-0.1815106124,
-0.0072819763,
-0.1903346479,
0.4949647486,
-0.4156912863,
-0.2097638249,
-0.0240941737,
0.6190194488,
0.1779338866,
-0.0222406629,
-0.7611371875,
-0.3232722878,
0.0892289728,
-0.0564359464,
-0.1161869764,
0.3893888891,
-0.2198868841,
1.1040416956,
0.4304252565,
-0.0457749441,
0.2144925892,
-0.1877250075,
0.5177485943,
-0.4168301225,
-0.1416779459,
-0.4554322064,
0.6928762794,
-0.1165412217,
-0.6020875573,
0.5077853799,
-0.1824871451,
0.6342740059,
0.1396034956,
0.7425109744,
-0.2283068597,
0.7335639596,
-0.0720869824,
0.3348552287,
-0.4355089664,
-0.0451857373,
-0.1797623932,
-0.5881544352,
-0.2011546344,
0.7062119246,
-0.4831757545,
-0.0444102176,
0.6487932801,
0.9656350017,
0.318246007,
0.4795692563,
0.2158246338,
-0.1604699939,
0.3329053223,
0.3913905621,
1.1417328119,
-0.3814270794,
0.5849328637,
-0.4736314416,
0.2281004339,
-0.1758661866,
-0.8038808107,
-0.4929225147,
-0.6871458888,
-0.3126444221,
-0.2067244351,
0.3390920162,
1.452003479,
0.9428114295,
-0.4807928801,
-0.2861868739,
-0.1225424409,
0.2506649792,
-0.1513587087,
-0.1593470126,
-0.0682505146,
-0.3735652566,
-0.8145954609,
0.287319988,
-0.1667598337,
0.484865576,
-0.1795966774,
-0.1592244208,
-0.3159464002,
0.1349938661,
-0.176979661,
0.3243715465,
-0.7191850543,
-0.5801161528,
0.1121190935,
-0.310769558,
-0.1201562211,
0.699667871,
-0.2916079164,
0.7942747474,
0.5586730242,
0.4542578161,
0.1339072287,
0.4467995465,
1.2067542076,
-0.8667867184,
-0.053469263,
0.443657577,
0.3448872268,
0.4255067706,
-0.381924063,
0.2838275433,
0.1142210439,
-0.9524148703,
-0.5414747,
0.396694243,
-0.7662198544,
-0.0706449151,
0.7632880807,
-0.317253083,
-0.1536301523,
-0.5632950068,
-0.7590389848,
0.3497520983,
-0.4895835519,
0.6807200909,
1.0881015062,
-0.142414391,
-0.1806659251,
-0.4253824949,
0.444024086,
0.9648062587,
-0.4030387998,
-0.0171556231,
0.3610186577,
0.0382456221,
0.3687675297,
0.4740912318,
0.3533711433,
0.3917712271,
-0.1635979414,
-0.1354773641,
0.3070333898,
-0.1419198066,
0.1378402561,
0.1500221789,
0.4331895709,
-0.1367732882
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06501v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06501v2
|
Scalable Interactive Machine Learning for Future Command and Control
| 2024-02-09T16:11:04 | 2024-03-28T15:17:01 |
Anna Madison, Ellen Novoseller, Vinicius G. Goecks, Benjamin T. Files, Nicholas Waytowich, Alfred Yu, Vernon J. Lawhern, Steven Thurman, Christopher Kelshaw, Kaleb McDowell
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, I.2.6; I.2.7; J.7
|
Future warfare will require Command and Control (C2) personnel to make
decisions at shrinking timescales in complex and potentially ill-defined
situations. Given the need for robust decision-making processes and
decision-support tools, integration of artificial and human intelligence holds
the potential to revolutionize the C2 operations process to ensure adaptability
and efficiency in rapidly changing operational environments. We propose to
leverage recent promising breakthroughs in interactive machine learning, in
which humans can cooperate with machine learning algorithms to guide machine
learning algorithm behavior. This paper identifies several gaps in
state-of-the-art science and technology that future work should address to
extend these approaches to function in complex C2 contexts. In particular, we
describe three research focus areas that together, aim to enable scalable
interactive machine learning (SIML): 1) developing human-AI interaction
algorithms to enable planning in complex, dynamic situations; 2) fostering
resilient human-AI teams through optimizing roles, configurations, and trust;
and 3) scaling algorithms and human-AI teams for flexibility across a range of
potential contexts and situations.
|
[
-0.7357242107,
-0.8629254103,
0.6808391809,
0.4989980757,
0.4000772834,
0.5842539668,
-0.0485894382,
-0.5504097342,
-0.0477637015,
0.2990413606,
-0.9323646426,
-0.0538895279,
-0.653734386,
-0.0875303671,
0.0678197891,
0.6346465945,
-0.2200047672,
0.1155860424,
-0.5316806436,
-0.2092289627,
-0.4783551395,
-1.0727182627,
-0.8374261856,
-0.4372009337,
0.5858209133,
0.8109974265,
1.079630971,
0.726414144,
0.6913023591,
0.4601165354,
0.1260681599,
0.3815760016,
-0.2766930163,
0.3401838839,
0.0398349054,
-0.4631392062,
-0.657250464,
0.1814789921,
0.6214496493,
0.8011034131,
-0.039947331,
-0.2982260585,
-0.0392135121,
0.4224423468,
-0.5364815593,
0.3535880148,
-0.2289705426,
0.2051384598,
0.2731492519,
-0.0572267026,
-0.2015134394,
-0.053955283,
0.4800145626,
-0.8048718572,
-0.2545436919,
0.2501448989,
0.3663961589,
0.6616429687,
-0.4827592671,
-0.2232419252,
-0.7634114027,
0.8248960972,
-0.3955091536,
0.2153888047,
0.2296933085,
0.6591948271,
-0.5447506905,
-0.9425528049,
-0.1421536356,
-0.3627277613,
0.0825122967,
0.2764151096,
-0.0618590824,
0.1909501404,
0.289052546,
-0.6321902871,
-0.1198835447,
0.5523180962,
-0.204095006,
0.0101215132,
0.8307406902,
0.5832594633,
0.2304188311,
0.5255310535,
-0.435359031,
-0.0527722128,
-0.3520818949,
0.3675511479,
0.3146207035,
-0.0007923313,
-0.4227995872,
0.4413576126,
-0.1714806259,
0.5116587281,
0.16286695,
0.137935102,
-0.3448608518,
-0.2507008612,
-0.2576887012,
0.1744166166,
0.5898292065,
0.2869014442,
0.0576061308,
0.032550443,
0.0106042158,
-0.1249284819,
0.6173161864,
-0.9182408452,
-0.3218241036,
0.2830671966,
-0.306704253,
-0.4949371219,
0.1210025027,
-0.6629447341,
-0.5135734677,
-0.7909268737,
0.1395177394,
-0.3353095651,
-0.0958437622,
-0.390275389,
-0.3524877131,
0.1189189106,
0.5574350953,
-0.7652834654,
0.3335429132,
0.636207521,
0.7081145644,
-0.5227300525,
-0.4124322534,
-0.5795462132,
0.3654594123,
-0.3083401918,
0.4311191738,
-0.7234532833,
-0.6691024303,
-0.2567329705,
-0.0982244462,
-0.2143997252,
-0.6962907314,
0.4387236834,
-0.4843504429,
-0.0800784901,
-0.1543428451,
-0.4200349748,
-0.2719543576,
0.3798909187,
-0.7163751721,
0.56609869,
0.0067401016,
-0.7233217359,
0.4539729953,
-1.0135002136,
-0.4434742332,
0.0228964053,
-0.2769051492,
-0.900427103,
-0.2660414279,
0.2993185222,
0.6403338313,
-0.0823090449,
0.0738664642,
-0.8508561254,
-0.2614360452,
0.3529982865,
-0.2748180032,
0.7044895291,
0.2987700403,
-0.3989596367,
0.6238301396,
-0.3573002815,
0.304123044,
-0.1447905451,
-0.3365518451,
0.322558403,
0.4049032331,
0.1104347706,
0.1469162852,
0.3416565359,
0.0090027954,
0.3207371533,
0.1370090395,
0.588878572,
0.6008060575,
0.091722779,
0.7090163231,
-0.5185515285,
0.6666842699,
-0.0126933251,
0.4970778823,
0.0335548818,
-0.4076676965,
-0.5806002617,
-0.5088941455,
0.0579310134,
0.812830925,
-0.7763260007,
0.4135553539,
0.0775936618,
-0.594276607,
0.1032681838,
-0.2741475403,
-0.223142609,
0.3160071075,
0.3872826695,
-0.0445650332,
-0.9483735561,
-0.6068105102,
-0.1199243441,
-0.2160173804,
-0.0456341952,
0.2253410667,
0.3145197928,
-0.4962858558,
1.0064598322,
-0.0580364391,
-0.0564591698,
-0.4359727502,
0.2546068728,
-0.3745516837,
0.6488586664,
0.3366156518,
-1.4533959627,
-0.2493932247,
0.2607349157,
-1.014026165,
0.2685844004,
-0.1966342032,
0.0774612129,
-0.0130346334,
0.9790905118,
-0.2668465376,
0.4697515965,
0.385725081,
0.0232016928,
0.4294160306,
-0.4064832032,
0.3085667491,
-0.764424324,
0.0040061884,
-0.2770358622,
-0.1946964711,
-0.8358228803,
-0.0047089295,
0.1762939245,
-0.3310560882,
-0.3632974923,
0.1865154803,
-0.3753998578,
-0.233511284,
-0.2892453074,
-0.0378571935,
-0.6007266045,
0.3149861395,
-0.0539628044,
0.6638700962,
0.5001708865,
-0.826988399,
0.4583057463,
-0.0475415103,
0.133344844,
0.8087741137,
-0.6332674623,
-0.1166625619,
0.2306725234,
0.4724689424,
-0.4205169082,
-0.5306556225,
0.0689264536,
-0.4597122669,
0.338758111,
-0.0692323297,
-0.153568238,
-0.1241843179,
-0.1221735105,
0.4554809332,
0.306965977,
-0.1720021069,
1.072121501,
0.5379393697,
-0.0731539354,
-0.539442122,
-0.512743175,
0.1173102185,
-0.3320095241,
-0.4722562432,
0.3380699754,
-0.2001413405,
-0.466784209,
-0.1472115517,
0.0386619493,
-0.2541492283,
0.5049830079,
0.9055880308,
0.4506238997,
0.0780171007,
-0.2376237512,
0.0368861109,
-0.0588303022,
0.2123565078,
-0.4134060442,
0.2796298862,
-0.2877534926,
-0.4927363396,
-0.4585917592,
0.3713822365,
1.0000126362,
-0.2175700366,
0.7172774673,
0.8931310177,
-0.2473654151,
0.0361672044,
-0.2301929742,
-0.068929702,
-0.4707121253,
0.356190294,
-0.0962256193,
-0.9092071652,
0.3357919455,
-0.8718506098,
0.2888652682,
0.2835585177,
0.813431859,
-0.6341226101,
1.2285462618,
1.0616444349,
-0.1683415771,
0.6264092326,
-0.2987181246,
-0.0447098762,
-0.565985918,
-0.470266223,
-0.1639505774,
-0.6853203773,
-0.8007237911,
-0.369528383,
0.9066158533,
0.0004580975,
-0.4856396019,
-0.1255367994,
-0.1371253729,
0.1190031618,
0.5304956436,
-0.0568886623,
-0.1451117992,
-0.4136467278,
0.0619328879,
0.247378543,
-0.9938184023,
-0.1932425052,
0.803231895,
0.3308681846,
0.5828845501,
-0.1887037754,
0.6043917537,
0.5663220882,
-0.0300176684,
-0.7073042989,
0.3839070797,
0.438280046,
-0.3709004819,
-0.5655739903,
-0.4242085218,
-1.1055195332,
-0.0863711908,
-0.5898655057,
-0.2970539331,
0.060051132,
0.1938735694,
-0.278803736,
0.3092647493,
-0.7766706347,
0.5642868876,
-0.3485195637,
-0.1661431491,
-0.5638628006,
-1.0708580017,
-0.0004769139,
0.1079109758,
0.118906334,
0.0904238969,
-0.6781255603,
0.4790056646,
-0.1442226768,
0.767893672,
-0.2057132125,
0.2926583886,
0.164034605,
-0.1176061854,
0.4743992686,
0.0557182319,
-0.1401393265,
0.1364919692,
-0.106202513,
-0.4257282019,
-0.4642440379,
0.5525484681,
-0.9021330476,
-0.2592063546,
-0.4413247705,
-0.8295380473,
-0.3957915008,
0.2320938557,
0.1796416342,
0.2258824557,
-0.4689361155,
0.3266854584,
0.7463262081,
0.1071028486,
0.6754450798,
0.0900271013,
0.1630396992,
-0.3585841656,
0.6969411373,
0.2973095477,
0.2913529873,
0.4688237011,
-0.1662711799,
0.0592248403,
-0.5667107701,
-0.4852806628,
-0.3497743011,
-0.1733517796,
-0.1299838126,
-0.4956678748,
-0.3421020508,
-0.0719082206,
-0.8498504758,
-0.1972990632,
-0.2967826128,
-0.457538873,
0.1216336638,
0.0765383914,
0.8562200665,
-0.1766743064,
0.4282671809,
-0.4802133739,
0.3828454614,
0.2542429268,
-0.0375198945,
-0.1490762979,
0.0560392216,
-0.3206246793,
0.1254396588,
-0.5269693732,
-0.5996528864,
0.1847492456,
-0.0634385124,
0.7258047462,
0.1911236793,
0.06965819,
0.4698603749,
-0.443133682,
0.5126341581,
0.2189430892,
-0.6718536615,
0.4030423164,
-0.2614816129,
0.336623013,
0.1740703434,
0.6963359118,
-0.2721117139,
-0.1847387403,
-0.643691957,
-0.5320340991,
0.7586832047,
0.1223004237,
-0.4612784982,
0.61481601,
0.0789076462,
-0.1320662796,
0.0775432065,
0.1424389333,
-0.2190372944,
0.0013369062,
-0.1719244272,
0.0097585516,
0.2202553153,
-0.1772885919,
-0.1349439919,
0.4838234186,
-0.2777743936,
0.2387186289,
-0.0448841676,
0.2050274014,
-0.0512801036,
0.1219654009,
0.621525526,
0.7625371814,
0.0322265923,
-0.1080559939,
0.7629697323,
-0.4649613202,
0.1675845981,
0.2141149491,
0.0301484652,
-0.7967398167,
0.4785549343,
0.4356956482,
0.1966381967,
-0.730861783,
0.2130213827,
-0.2489810735,
-0.3224757016,
-0.5151678324,
0.2950895131,
0.0340481512,
0.8825470805,
0.2220868915,
0.6737316847,
0.0236241519,
-0.7866350412,
0.4107624888,
0.4859097004,
-0.4920727909,
0.0719263852,
0.637146771,
0.1928240955,
-0.3419093192,
0.6310432553,
0.0059633739,
-0.6894893646,
0.8657081723,
0.0642581359,
0.5354065895,
-0.3086676002,
-0.0357075147,
-0.0250295326,
0.3815918565,
0.2119052857,
0.1731673032,
-0.1036221534,
-0.2550218701,
-0.2359191626,
-0.0607057065,
-0.9887030721,
-0.2833065987,
-0.4901891649,
0.4497657716,
-0.9155922532,
-0.2174183279,
-0.2240544409,
0.245386675,
-0.7309119105,
0.2652967274,
0.2118588984,
0.7440112829,
-0.2569421232,
0.7531300187,
0.6287934184,
-0.0002582804,
-0.6659063697,
-0.051063925,
0.2066350132,
-0.7072429657,
0.5225448608,
0.0424840935,
-0.254922241,
-0.1480635256,
-0.7931903601,
-0.5756095648,
1.3576989174,
0.3281128705,
-0.3175013959,
-0.1007527113,
-0.1036398709,
0.4317773581,
-0.4870378673,
0.3622623086,
0.6173757911,
0.791211307,
0.0068096048,
-0.7473868728,
-0.2900583446,
0.0817409828,
-0.2461936772,
0.2168189138,
-0.7713494301,
0.6976278424,
-0.4926036596,
-0.0350866579,
0.0563929528,
1.1144149303,
0.1560524553,
0.6701738238,
0.5990869999,
0.3217153251,
0.7522388101,
-0.2075335234,
0.7702630162,
0.216353178,
-0.132044524,
0.8780402541,
-0.1991444826,
0.7722893953,
0.1648210585,
-0.1727785468,
0.5785689354,
0.6261421442,
-0.0972253084,
0.0632175207,
-0.0547837578,
-0.2773446143,
-0.204024151,
-0.1959505677,
-0.0280161817,
0.4130690992,
0.6204417348,
-0.009017623,
0.2413014621,
0.1835650206,
0.0550619289,
-0.0818359107,
-0.4102391899,
0.8894919157,
-0.2157115936,
-0.6529146433,
0.3302148283,
-0.0395697728,
0.4278798699,
-0.7496433258,
-0.3188526928,
0.2752658725,
0.1036829054,
-0.3891398311,
-0.9336622357,
0.1052103341,
-0.3299267292,
-0.2192558348,
-0.2002527714,
0.5357476473,
-0.3379238546,
-0.1528777778,
0.2715294063,
0.442915678,
-0.1597922295,
-0.0125291012,
-0.649769187,
0.27138412,
-0.0690136254,
0.1732478887,
0.5968206525,
0.4286084473,
-0.2701467574,
1.1915794611,
0.5213732719,
-0.0434416346,
0.235420391,
-0.4322479367,
0.8760514259,
-0.4594396055,
-0.5319390297,
-0.648406744,
0.3011950254,
-0.3826637268,
0.0391872562,
0.4335383773,
0.3658991754,
0.7013376355,
0.2120069563,
0.9980010986,
-0.2167654634,
0.0304428767,
-0.2467311621,
0.6707003117,
-0.3602674007,
-0.1047885492,
0.2773765028,
-0.4452035129,
-0.2642046511,
0.0050645019,
-0.1462013274,
0.1235199273,
0.4311277866,
0.4855948389,
-0.2563406825,
0.1526530832,
0.4323205054,
-0.0508710667,
0.580501914,
0.4135224819,
0.9668184519,
0.0199807622,
0.614020884,
-0.2395631373,
-0.5006298423,
-0.6113838553,
-0.8281808496,
-0.8539946675,
-0.6175207496,
0.0084486529,
0.2420116812,
0.0491284952,
1.0421267748,
1.1352584362,
-0.6720392108,
-0.3424285352,
-0.0885336772,
0.1952893436,
-0.5338848233,
-0.1436290294,
0.1253802329,
-0.5024596453,
-0.6299990416,
0.6187112331,
0.4637698531,
0.1384179443,
-0.2291984558,
-0.4169256985,
-0.0472675823,
-0.0141251739,
0.5943453312,
0.5387765765,
-0.5921795368,
-0.0902403295,
-0.0597151369,
0.0832610503,
-0.2753376663,
1.1198899746,
-0.8615595102,
0.5047221184,
0.2304301709,
1.19325459,
0.2393193394,
0.0903983936,
0.8629721999,
-0.5018305182,
0.0523733124,
0.4581628144,
0.1997694522,
0.1554273069,
-0.5390874743,
0.5979934931,
0.0394209921,
-0.950592041,
-0.4436769485,
0.2121946961,
-1.1119441986,
-0.2258141339,
0.5477604866,
-0.2390964478,
0.1601316333,
-0.2397836447,
-0.5478650331,
0.5028064847,
-0.2808057666,
0.4470289052,
0.5264568925,
-0.7373197079,
-0.0479658954,
-0.5214926004,
0.510532558,
0.3607831597,
-1.2999312878,
0.0491267405,
0.3470652103,
-0.368602097,
-0.149545148,
-0.2136561424,
0.2661466897,
0.4206880033,
0.0066710128,
-0.2246586084,
-0.2492768019,
-0.787536025,
-0.1675671786,
0.2965568304,
-0.1217261106,
-0.1274106354
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07946v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07946v2
|
Re-Envisioning Command and Control
| 2024-02-09T16:10:29 | 2024-03-28T15:17:30 |
Kaleb McDowell, Ellen Novoseller, Anna Madison, Vinicius G. Goecks, Christopher Kelshaw
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.6; I.2.7; J.7
|
Future warfare will require Command and Control (C2) decision-making to occur
in more complex, fast-paced, ill-structured, and demanding conditions. C2 will
be further complicated by operational challenges such as Denied, Degraded,
Intermittent, and Limited (DDIL) communications and the need to account for
many data streams, potentially across multiple domains of operation. Yet,
current C2 practices -- which stem from the industrial era rather than the
emerging intelligence era -- are linear and time-consuming. Critically, these
approaches may fail to maintain overmatch against adversaries on the future
battlefield. To address these challenges, we propose a vision for future C2
based on robust partnerships between humans and artificial intelligence (AI)
systems. This future vision is encapsulated in three operational impacts:
streamlining the C2 operations process, maintaining unity of effort, and
developing adaptive collective knowledge systems. This paper illustrates the
envisaged future C2 capabilities, discusses the assumptions that shaped them,
and describes how the proposed developments could transform C2 in future
warfare.
|
[
-0.5841175318,
-0.6526686549,
0.8554881215,
0.323895961,
0.2050128728,
0.6796866655,
0.0799668506,
-0.7864906192,
0.0785403848,
0.5848120451,
-0.8787825108,
-0.3871130049,
-0.8441182971,
-0.0211573076,
-0.2962036729,
0.8309544325,
-0.1481768638,
-0.137741074,
-0.2160397172,
-0.1762460917,
-0.8636672497,
-0.9776127338,
-0.8781684041,
-0.6002866626,
0.6115150452,
0.5295747519,
1.1022422314,
0.6294935942,
0.8058260083,
0.4161883593,
0.0967198759,
0.1680467129,
-0.4961449206,
0.0544109307,
-0.1571056396,
-0.4594714344,
-0.5697358847,
0.4897718728,
0.4241122305,
0.7527452111,
-0.0063111745,
-0.5104460716,
-0.0386979058,
0.4687129259,
-0.7276980877,
0.0675530508,
-0.4695166945,
-0.1003945917,
0.2830592096,
-0.1085541174,
0.0045565413,
-0.0195985343,
0.4933032095,
-0.8608418703,
-0.2807832062,
0.4287907183,
0.5948037505,
0.3007925153,
-0.4881090522,
-0.2801598608,
-0.9914184213,
0.7020854354,
-0.1064129397,
0.3350966573,
0.4545890093,
0.5959489346,
-0.4177039862,
-1.0109721422,
-0.2425140589,
0.0102448212,
0.0461588204,
0.4890833497,
-0.2622181773,
0.085618265,
-0.2907860875,
-0.3502354324,
0.0479444228,
0.1925908327,
-0.6925559044,
-0.0954683349,
0.8522085547,
0.5928490162,
0.2072704434,
0.4978884459,
-1.1448886395,
0.1586914361,
-0.5506342649,
0.3187639713,
0.0458881855,
-0.1793001145,
-0.7078530788,
0.3914195597,
-0.2689406574,
0.4731704593,
0.1776810586,
0.091637753,
-0.4851015806,
-0.3020599186,
-0.4085836112,
0.2280687988,
0.3913984299,
0.7939713001,
0.1162737906,
-0.236028865,
-0.0100004934,
0.4245585501,
0.8085490465,
-0.4031539261,
-0.317912966,
0.414920032,
-0.4141379595,
-0.4394856393,
0.1518820077,
-0.5672609806,
-0.588079989,
-0.8871444464,
0.1031443775,
-0.4223480225,
-0.008163251,
-0.0540817305,
-0.5105996132,
0.4328966439,
0.5919743776,
-0.8582037687,
0.4778087437,
0.8533209562,
0.7807838917,
-0.6255995035,
-0.3057312369,
0.1144683436,
0.5249875784,
-0.5723962784,
0.5714431405,
-0.4082654119,
-0.7647545338,
-0.2089616507,
0.0051188562,
0.106680654,
-0.5246869326,
0.3053378761,
-0.4993027747,
-0.1092910245,
-0.243585214,
-0.4016104639,
-0.1567323804,
0.4893672764,
-0.5640659928,
-0.0285019204,
-0.0742293596,
-0.3973844945,
0.4925727546,
-0.4586606622,
-0.5262606144,
0.0323520936,
-0.3689516783,
-0.2636317909,
-0.2427737415,
-0.0529250689,
0.3925246894,
-0.506025672,
0.03996801,
-0.6306519508,
-0.1725883335,
0.0805402175,
-0.204831481,
0.7386519313,
0.2644835114,
-0.325437516,
0.2900481224,
-0.4553340971,
0.116925925,
-0.2628373504,
-0.4298719764,
0.2960811257,
0.7098228335,
-0.1493461281,
0.0407399647,
0.3945518732,
-0.171190545,
0.1617390066,
-0.0389215164,
0.7263271213,
1.0093348026,
0.2419378757,
0.9761331677,
-0.6944431663,
0.5132913589,
-0.0581642576,
0.7014366984,
0.3798760176,
-0.4666490853,
-0.7553249598,
-0.1108668372,
-0.4074296653,
0.7858764529,
-0.7506996989,
0.3315547407,
-0.0309097264,
-0.6964949369,
0.1432426125,
-0.1956931651,
-0.0501187555,
0.2147589922,
0.4770809412,
-0.4753972292,
-0.759570837,
-0.7644022703,
0.140612185,
-0.461561799,
0.2096327394,
-0.1074584424,
0.2431311756,
-0.4772924185,
0.6814031005,
0.0681416467,
-0.3279010653,
-0.5522640944,
0.0521755219,
-0.2994374335,
0.7844040394,
0.0774060413,
-1.2697957754,
0.1057972983,
0.1951011717,
-0.8562761545,
0.4289753437,
-0.3366625309,
-0.4633614123,
-0.04061931,
0.9282105565,
-0.3409396708,
0.4211535454,
0.3723420799,
-0.1484772712,
0.4048377275,
-0.0658027008,
0.2715876997,
-0.6645103097,
0.045431111,
-0.4155456126,
0.1925026774,
-0.5746504068,
0.0706779286,
-0.0563697256,
-0.2903545201,
-0.4121687114,
0.232974425,
-0.296081543,
-0.1052155718,
-0.2357503176,
0.1279337257,
0.0381851904,
0.3280177712,
-0.0621885024,
0.3199617863,
0.4107415676,
-0.8109201193,
0.924728334,
0.252481252,
0.2077986002,
1.0822809935,
-0.7144863605,
0.0153048206,
0.1663340628,
0.5741627812,
-0.228812024,
-0.1415999383,
0.255852133,
-0.6250523329,
0.2759965062,
0.1302364171,
0.0590390153,
-0.0238153562,
-0.139208138,
0.2540210187,
0.2603436708,
-0.0912535563,
1.2197549343,
0.3887821138,
0.1740308553,
-0.5452201366,
-0.7279043198,
0.364120841,
-0.2564220428,
-0.2314527184,
0.529338479,
0.0364527255,
-0.693261683,
-0.064982973,
-0.113521874,
-0.0280640479,
0.2819343209,
0.8465653062,
0.6631320715,
0.2183830291,
-0.2662827373,
-0.1760106385,
-0.1354694068,
0.3301594257,
-0.7776109576,
0.3736325204,
0.0765993893,
-0.3372007608,
-0.5116090775,
0.7272614241,
1.0157673359,
-0.518109262,
0.4879931509,
0.5021252632,
-0.1487585306,
0.1826637685,
-0.3723118603,
-0.0975956991,
-0.4563854933,
0.2175478339,
0.0995234028,
-0.5001057386,
0.4145313501,
-0.4733158946,
0.3046208918,
0.3237377107,
0.6308622956,
-0.6640265584,
0.8595135808,
0.945666194,
-0.5681800842,
0.319090277,
-0.4567766488,
0.0301905945,
-0.6874085665,
-0.8638322353,
-0.1589810103,
-0.7255244851,
-0.8280030489,
0.0166106187,
0.7592000961,
0.1298821718,
-0.6549229622,
0.1149438694,
-0.2239202261,
-0.0694904029,
0.8345910907,
0.0888713673,
-0.0950371176,
-0.5075083971,
0.2887384593,
0.412394166,
-0.720539093,
-0.1684435159,
0.7565463185,
0.1470738649,
0.7082399726,
-0.1016846225,
0.6251410842,
0.4927487671,
-0.192004621,
-0.6271561384,
0.4080226719,
0.2009085715,
-0.5549727082,
-0.0259753186,
-0.111032702,
-1.0672668219,
-0.3176131546,
-0.7088891864,
-0.3276717663,
0.4048294425,
-0.0385666341,
-0.5233411789,
0.2600146234,
-0.8436662555,
0.4498966038,
-0.3064460158,
-0.3943597674,
-0.6939301491,
-1.1004273891,
-0.0486781038,
0.4378317893,
0.153113395,
-0.0066740261,
-0.5774538517,
0.4021100998,
-0.0453718491,
0.71676898,
0.027565768,
0.0662770644,
0.417966485,
-0.123653926,
0.3638468683,
0.0679751337,
0.1423603147,
0.0913435742,
-0.1342630535,
-0.5775848031,
-0.4463254809,
0.5452111363,
-1.1450177431,
-0.501762867,
-0.4364540875,
-0.4539361894,
-0.1131666899,
0.2098174393,
0.2351136804,
0.6198010445,
-0.5411579609,
0.0531542711,
0.230599612,
-0.0042316653,
0.523132205,
0.0267378017,
0.1079191566,
-0.607950151,
0.5743619204,
0.0312100332,
0.8588451743,
0.3846613169,
-0.4472025037,
-0.1648309231,
-0.689280808,
-0.5113793015,
-0.458617419,
-0.5224589109,
-0.4305380583,
-0.1662565768,
-0.1581921279,
-0.2465271205,
-0.8707835674,
-0.1547386199,
-0.0576060563,
-0.4162277281,
0.1008074507,
0.1270614117,
1.1290389299,
-0.1775749177,
0.5288600922,
-0.3057827652,
0.5769408941,
0.20972161,
0.1770025492,
-0.3913612962,
0.2455234677,
-0.3396554291,
0.1800021827,
-0.732483685,
-0.7336105108,
0.2738592029,
0.0967446268,
0.2927516103,
0.1083825901,
0.01248354,
0.3439618945,
-0.351541698,
0.6357207298,
0.2451421022,
-0.7017942071,
0.3915424049,
-0.1218241602,
0.1814767569,
0.2533277273,
0.3270730078,
-0.3014369905,
-0.4999752343,
-0.7655755281,
-0.664568007,
0.5123361945,
0.059127599,
-0.2785538137,
0.2367742211,
0.0886419192,
-0.555754602,
-0.0065565426,
0.1710684747,
-0.2169317603,
-0.1025442705,
0.0923307389,
-0.174040392,
0.4256999493,
-0.1585376561,
-0.0346149914,
0.4170717001,
0.0308292825,
0.3823643625,
0.3116067052,
0.5460409522,
-0.0042827716,
0.2530998588,
0.5194985867,
0.4082964063,
0.0025555098,
0.0814696178,
0.5296675563,
-0.4510938823,
0.2959757447,
-0.0444761291,
0.1475374699,
-0.8891111016,
0.5864315033,
0.3237738013,
0.0499221087,
-0.2820283473,
0.2097556591,
0.0896830112,
-0.1328889728,
-0.5826222897,
0.0346001089,
0.1240911931,
0.9042053819,
0.3165829182,
0.9686374068,
-0.024209125,
-0.9619441628,
0.2478553206,
0.4646067619,
-0.360940665,
-0.1192461997,
0.7041888237,
0.3396746814,
-0.0535232387,
0.4722349942,
-0.0172109641,
-0.8073453307,
0.812297225,
0.1779407859,
0.4902909398,
0.0129195033,
-0.2940345109,
-0.1101331934,
0.4904558659,
0.2072159201,
0.1086632311,
0.1108869761,
-0.6292399764,
-0.165064767,
-0.1039590687,
-0.5255202055,
-0.1342551559,
-0.6284820437,
0.6135815382,
-1.2470132113,
-0.1483876854,
-0.0851669982,
0.3783388734,
-0.6530562639,
0.540702939,
0.4245807827,
0.7515346408,
-0.0978152975,
0.743083477,
0.4380013943,
-0.2336916775,
-0.8175793886,
-0.2995335758,
0.4380296767,
-0.9258697629,
0.5426536202,
-0.1651288718,
-0.4924336672,
-0.0527362376,
-0.7243387699,
-0.6332944632,
1.427759409,
0.0661761686,
-0.4715439975,
-0.3765552044,
-0.0649854839,
0.3084061742,
-0.5499821901,
-0.092799671,
1.0170315504,
0.8255425692,
-0.1291166693,
-0.6936684251,
-0.3912605047,
-0.0436321422,
-0.2698987424,
0.1885224134,
-0.7952426672,
0.7899053097,
-0.4121892452,
-0.562171638,
0.1308912039,
0.8750374913,
-0.1142779514,
0.4908821285,
0.2973202169,
0.5186642408,
0.0688804239,
-0.2529746592,
1.0428175926,
0.0256839339,
-0.1983790994,
0.8289975524,
-0.1434642822,
0.7709037066,
0.2454412431,
-0.309464097,
0.5497956276,
0.4060694277,
-0.1826708764,
0.2832509875,
-0.1310563982,
-0.183741346,
0.0052381749,
-0.4182045162,
-0.2425969094,
0.8137209415,
0.4764220715,
-0.0998752043,
0.0427723527,
-0.3166112006,
-0.0427476056,
0.3278066516,
-0.5459208488,
1.0033556223,
-0.113219291,
-0.6441907287,
0.8251383305,
-0.0660604686,
0.6688495874,
-0.6233050823,
-0.1918518841,
0.2536471784,
0.2119398415,
-0.1978566349,
-0.7775046825,
0.3568175137,
-0.511395514,
-0.078862384,
-0.2424400747,
0.371581912,
-0.3031027317,
-0.2642155886,
0.6969419122,
0.4615527987,
-0.4870316982,
0.0189143661,
-0.5598147511,
0.479198575,
-0.0223716926,
0.5411034822,
0.0844777748,
0.2040878087,
-0.0450407192,
0.8803508878,
0.3267640471,
0.3309336603,
0.0832562521,
-0.5091285706,
0.8321490884,
-0.3550460339,
-0.2809647024,
-0.7381429672,
0.0515015833,
-0.097366944,
-0.3155129552,
0.1311571449,
0.2255391628,
0.8918324113,
0.3931891024,
1.0271247625,
-0.530507803,
0.0359618627,
-0.2390550226,
0.7513798475,
-0.371347785,
-0.1506326348,
0.1649466008,
-0.33791852,
-0.1572468579,
-0.103935957,
-0.1120955944,
-0.1687651575,
0.4732237756,
0.4526269436,
0.0937681273,
0.2220027298,
0.2203611583,
-0.1571395695,
0.5805469751,
0.7866601348,
1.0890786648,
-0.1189044788,
0.5405425429,
-0.3527345061,
-0.3804736435,
-0.0758638605,
-0.4259240031,
-0.5486217737,
-0.8023700714,
0.3407180607,
0.1355775595,
0.3350645006,
1.0719186068,
0.9936788082,
-0.6535784602,
-0.2869556844,
-0.2751322389,
0.0302126855,
-0.2510799468,
-0.0894655287,
0.0027369647,
-0.529070437,
-0.5350898504,
0.3757265806,
0.4754704237,
0.2689137459,
-0.2733957469,
-0.2859760225,
-0.1401336044,
-0.0814697742,
0.6084459424,
0.3746045232,
-0.844199419,
-0.4972485006,
-0.0602434501,
-0.1027540788,
-0.1401144862,
1.0698305368,
-0.7924698591,
0.3695119917,
0.0104729049,
0.8936001658,
-0.1737775654,
0.1864485592,
1.2631694078,
-0.31528759,
0.1798781306,
0.4547965825,
0.2340330034,
0.2387462556,
-0.4278196692,
0.3343973756,
0.1913521439,
-0.7146013975,
0.0281764399,
0.5687618256,
-0.8884237409,
-0.129586786,
0.5576941371,
-0.2230781019,
0.1726610512,
-0.4718632102,
-0.4624318779,
0.5035917163,
-0.4596340954,
0.4787482321,
0.5035586953,
-0.2951616049,
0.0873169899,
-0.4262080193,
0.5409478545,
0.3561186194,
-1.0114356279,
0.1987884194,
0.534457922,
-0.44669047,
0.1763825417,
-0.0197879132,
-0.0385022052,
0.322024405,
0.0507713892,
-0.1593419909,
0.1885539293,
-0.9101046324,
0.0912528038,
0.0922752246,
-0.1461826414,
-0.2779558003
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06492v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06492v1
|
Inducing Systematicity in Transformers by Attending to Structurally Quantized Embeddings
| 2024-02-09T15:53:15 | 2024-02-09T15:53:15 |
Yichen Jiang, Xiang Zhou, Mohit Bansal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Transformers generalize to novel compositions of structures and entities
after being trained on a complex dataset, but easily overfit on datasets of
insufficient complexity. We observe that when the training set is sufficiently
complex, the model encodes sentences that have a common syntactic structure
using a systematic attention pattern. Inspired by this observation, we propose
SQ-Transformer (Structurally Quantized) that explicitly encourages
systematicity in the embeddings and attention layers, even with a training set
of low complexity. At the embedding level, we introduce Structure-oriented
Vector Quantization (SoVQ) to cluster word embeddings into several classes of
structurally equivalent entities. At the attention level, we devise the
Systematic Attention Layer (SAL) and an alternative, Systematically Regularized
Layer (SRL) that operate on the quantized word embeddings so that sentences of
the same structure are encoded with invariant or similar attention patterns.
Empirically, we show that SQ-Transformer achieves stronger compositional
generalization than the vanilla Transformer on multiple low-complexity semantic
parsing and machine translation datasets. In our analysis, we show that SoVQ
indeed learns a syntactically clustered embedding space and SAL/SRL induces
generalizable attention patterns, which lead to improved systematicity.
|
[
-0.1572871506,
-0.7713891864,
0.4181218445,
0.5050825477,
-0.1961791962,
0.0236191768,
-0.1997346133,
-0.0064979428,
0.4663111269,
0.2493662536,
-0.4900663793,
-0.5476491451,
-0.4857183993,
0.049998723,
-0.9141018987,
1.0700573921,
-0.0459364057,
0.096512869,
-0.0621637441,
-0.214860931,
-0.0054443013,
-0.4020665586,
-0.2554501593,
0.0962661132,
0.6242159009,
0.1452091336,
0.8866563439,
0.8428861499,
0.6652293205,
0.3648900092,
0.1289611757,
-0.1709140986,
-0.4528726339,
0.2469434887,
-0.2632422447,
-0.9490375519,
-0.2057770193,
-0.3724232018,
1.0170520544,
0.8368883729,
-0.4254713356,
0.264664948,
0.0320675485,
0.7866117954,
-0.5787406564,
0.1500576884,
-0.4603727162,
0.3731195033,
-0.121498704,
-0.002260145,
-0.2730647624,
-0.3658493757,
0.2935938239,
-0.7467556596,
0.5236082673,
0.1788912416,
0.9335606098,
0.596732378,
-0.2265725285,
-0.0369646922,
-0.9910456538,
0.8094229102,
-0.1754471511,
0.5632314682,
0.000186973,
0.43578583,
0.1368636787,
-1.1065382957,
-0.4728359282,
0.0588021874,
-0.3585570455,
0.4045153558,
-0.2967202961,
0.2099041492,
0.5602277517,
0.5889593959,
-0.7370392084,
-0.4317089915,
-0.3174236715,
-0.0316462964,
0.3180567324,
0.1106529981,
0.4092579782,
-0.2925596535,
-0.6370092034,
-0.0605377592,
-0.5524172783,
0.2034852952,
0.0747275203,
-0.1711968333,
0.0891224146,
0.6651166677,
-0.3616069555,
0.1903376579,
0.2321924716,
0.1260426342,
0.1069330126,
-0.550135076,
-0.2907926738,
0.1574984342,
0.8442757726,
-0.1661000252,
0.5233043432,
-0.3541562855,
-0.3819706142,
0.4534963965,
0.6922875047,
-0.6841860414,
-0.1819971502,
0.2015187591,
-0.4539126456,
-0.3654478788,
0.4559927583,
-0.1681231558,
0.4361044168,
-0.3589387834,
0.4427084625,
-0.5380182266,
0.1143237874,
0.2752085328,
-0.4430214167,
0.4493406117,
-0.1012769789,
-0.9248928428,
0.3989827037,
0.7459531426,
0.6935799122,
0.0113887517,
-0.2017541677,
-0.2666174173,
0.6440374851,
-0.4515946805,
0.855928421,
-0.6108706594,
-0.0500834845,
0.0551612452,
0.0572021902,
-0.1016545892,
-0.5119177103,
0.6126594543,
-0.4372353256,
0.3705974519,
-0.0161453951,
-0.1707075089,
-0.0901142657,
0.1838589907,
-0.6353515387,
1.155526042,
0.4334665537,
-0.9087332487,
0.4696077108,
-0.46792081,
-0.60703969,
0.1117158085,
-0.4633411467,
-0.6607249975,
0.4818123579,
0.2452415228,
0.3659766316,
0.0945745781,
0.4206326902,
-0.0125941401,
-0.4610565007,
0.2363065779,
0.011773577,
0.271720022,
-0.0969003364,
-0.5428735018,
0.5689211488,
-0.7793421149,
-0.1413158178,
0.1245642826,
-0.1197219118,
-0.600471735,
0.101610899,
-0.1883847266,
0.2346301228,
-0.000354462,
-0.2662651539,
0.2985804975,
-0.7328895926,
0.8208611608,
0.703707993,
0.2199371755,
0.9943560362,
-0.2892599702,
0.6947129965,
0.2929942906,
0.3388790786,
-0.3685896099,
-0.1735696495,
-1.1689732075,
-0.68766433,
0.3682165444,
0.3795957565,
-0.734942317,
0.6116181016,
-0.6837163568,
-0.1188560948,
-0.7851826549,
-0.2248630226,
0.3126608431,
0.0771809518,
0.4054275155,
-0.6412609816,
-0.5410326123,
-1.3762590885,
-0.3626888096,
0.3075163662,
-0.4277523458,
0.0789810345,
0.3438921273,
-0.2694113255,
0.9932172894,
-0.405736953,
-0.4324044287,
-0.1638699174,
-0.0561493747,
0.1548346877,
0.3478079438,
0.1631436795,
-0.7101262212,
-0.627554059,
-0.06843362,
-0.6634229422,
0.2949594855,
-0.4020548165,
-0.4389650524,
-0.3727186918,
0.514061749,
-0.9004145861,
0.3705858588,
0.069379881,
-0.0004941353,
0.114195995,
0.4173674881,
-0.2778600752,
-1.0487257242,
-0.02800663,
-0.1065882221,
-0.4268263578,
-0.8065767288,
0.1695880592,
0.2473874241,
0.0185145643,
-0.2755289674,
-0.0292222314,
-0.2904242277,
-0.2074139863,
0.2357873619,
0.0694459975,
0.0925464034,
0.7056527734,
0.0663885772,
0.4579623938,
0.6178392172,
-0.5744506717,
-0.012934518,
0.425190419,
-0.2154455185,
0.4251422882,
-1.1031267643,
-0.1380504668,
-0.4783735871,
0.3946603537,
-0.965570271,
-0.1906933039,
0.331055522,
-0.3121500611,
0.2484774441,
0.0085500879,
-0.4392568171,
-0.1853023767,
-0.6340383887,
0.4651891589,
0.5309852958,
-0.2131169438,
0.859778285,
-0.0439483523,
-0.1230559722,
-0.5060330629,
-0.8046239614,
-0.3453980982,
-0.1904548854,
-0.9120201468,
0.5895012021,
0.3048996031,
-0.0761924833,
0.1112845913,
-0.499473393,
0.0941885039,
0.0597247481,
0.2624768615,
0.0529205427,
-0.4049594402,
0.1247789338,
0.3907173872,
-0.2356545478,
0.2725740969,
-0.6366392374,
0.5704243183,
0.0573273636,
-0.2398388088,
-0.4983865917,
0.3974746764,
0.4076011777,
-0.5044090152,
0.4964439571,
0.7320257425,
-0.1940410137,
-0.6307319403,
-0.2296979427,
-0.5744060278,
-0.5227200985,
0.4295306206,
-0.5770277381,
-1.186640501,
0.3011369109,
-0.079619661,
0.0237234682,
0.4697185755,
0.5918273926,
-0.2289046645,
1.1963150501,
0.5873488784,
0.0135004483,
0.6990511417,
-0.405641228,
0.3111403286,
-0.7656710148,
-0.144404754,
-0.3904941678,
-0.5930164456,
-0.6645296216,
-0.4954157174,
0.4124264717,
0.28117311,
-0.2527582943,
0.3718361259,
-0.890309453,
0.3266263008,
0.5682055354,
0.0658729747,
0.2584996223,
0.2587330341,
-0.0605572946,
-0.065095298,
-0.8688499331,
-0.4031266868,
0.823296845,
0.6260403991,
0.7278305888,
0.0957005098,
0.9116519094,
-0.0875632986,
0.2075982988,
-1.152259469,
0.2590988278,
0.0683095381,
-0.3692010343,
-0.4889962971,
-0.2664630115,
-1.0264413357,
0.4374919832,
0.0416757278,
-0.1949108094,
0.4786215425,
-0.1774034202,
-0.2994053066,
-0.4825003445,
-0.6012530923,
0.7767523527,
0.236152038,
-0.0647425652,
-0.2968300283,
-0.7837760448,
0.4711965919,
0.0062738839,
0.1672308594,
0.2676408887,
-0.1949074268,
0.5328115821,
-0.2241889685,
0.7927424908,
0.1284047216,
-0.0860855877,
0.1684143841,
0.0463945717,
0.7757649422,
0.3067283332,
0.5858808756,
0.1130077764,
-0.2806621492,
-0.6450474858,
-0.9093294144,
0.2763435841,
-0.6824365854,
-0.6600090265,
-0.387098074,
-0.3763114512,
-0.1050004736,
0.2316218913,
0.1900165081,
0.0733509511,
-0.1511957198,
0.317388922,
1.029972434,
0.2306845635,
0.3331859112,
0.3390747905,
-0.0575169884,
-0.5168598294,
0.7776883245,
0.0787879676,
0.31885764,
0.7155700922,
0.0811398998,
-0.0004797741,
-0.249606654,
-0.2265550792,
0.1811002642,
-0.5051836967,
-0.1083249599,
-1.0110205412,
-0.4308587313,
-0.2764883339,
-0.0805857852,
-0.3440008163,
-0.85693115,
0.0167264752,
-0.1490525752,
-0.1572650522,
0.5730754733,
0.3607197702,
0.2820428908,
-0.8428989649,
0.6657543182,
0.5344820023,
0.1022716612,
-0.0404332317,
-0.6619926095,
-0.4496247768,
-0.2812266648,
-0.271130234,
-0.4944743216,
0.2071663737,
0.4344207346,
0.4715783596,
0.7239761353,
-0.1967889369,
0.6700463295,
-0.8518403172,
0.4478189051,
0.1094279289,
-1.065959096,
0.7177718878,
-0.3370573819,
0.4163192809,
0.3523887694,
0.8115329742,
-0.5634747744,
-0.7461760044,
-0.7209842205,
-0.9852095246,
0.5890631676,
0.3165146112,
0.1954514086,
-0.1033953279,
0.1766936928,
-0.0827968419,
0.3914783597,
-0.8203372359,
-0.2213705033,
-0.4843286574,
-0.3302208185,
0.3837405145,
-0.4159292579,
-0.4037446976,
-0.089810729,
0.3010418713,
-0.0232058112,
0.2764008641,
0.4446232617,
-0.3035414517,
-0.0521527268,
0.4471460283,
0.3819940686,
0.294841826,
0.2187157869,
0.2903761864,
-0.0993400365,
-0.5175746679,
0.0459385626,
-0.1622809768,
-0.4960095882,
0.1923122406,
0.5283824801,
0.6291761994,
0.7077841163,
-0.2182163149,
0.6518777609,
-0.0620282963,
-0.3182240427,
-0.3142945766,
0.2088483572,
0.0903328806,
0.3088354766,
0.4010621309,
0.1119788811,
0.45552212,
-0.5116349459,
0.3325976431,
0.3588950634,
-0.4348298013,
-0.6241267323,
0.375305742,
0.0019685084,
-0.1312988251,
0.5202461481,
0.005260169,
-0.5918108225,
0.2950176001,
0.4505295753,
1.0267201662,
-0.4741388261,
0.152492851,
0.4033690691,
0.5276115537,
-0.2244791687,
0.2962586284,
-0.4690705538,
-0.6971235871,
-0.6273158789,
-0.7762157321,
-0.0843328834,
-0.6872801185,
-0.9928364158,
0.1952653229,
-0.6176805496,
0.0969313383,
0.0574074127,
-0.6520990729,
-0.4843012989,
0.0590103753,
-0.0967488363,
0.4975187182,
-0.7600514293,
0.9525710344,
0.6818809509,
-0.5304408073,
-0.7705124617,
0.1101733074,
-0.5249320865,
-0.7231457233,
0.6918023229,
0.3099457026,
0.2673384845,
0.3101745844,
-0.4858047962,
-1.082895875,
1.2587958574,
0.0624458231,
-1.0703135729,
-0.3041675389,
0.4055996239,
0.6213892102,
-0.0841197222,
0.0866124481,
0.4843363464,
0.3922264874,
-0.168535307,
-0.4628983736,
0.2311392426,
0.0489620082,
0.3075472713,
0.4953451157,
-0.8305522799,
0.54459095,
0.2254889458,
-0.8316898942,
-0.2408849597,
0.9281387925,
0.1538463086,
0.0401040763,
0.3877008557,
0.9400659204,
0.4784248173,
-0.2497318387,
0.9228484035,
-0.410269469,
0.2533811629,
0.7937592268,
0.1265826523,
0.7135391235,
0.6565836668,
-0.4586399198,
0.7400835752,
0.1715864092,
-0.2788667977,
0.6915195584,
0.3735486865,
-0.17040205,
-0.1084915325,
-0.1070316955,
-0.2836675346,
0.2855611742,
0.2648557127,
-0.5445987582,
0.02272976,
-0.0393578373,
-0.491520226,
0.0780257583,
-0.2297118604,
0.9570795298,
0.4469530582,
-0.3077708483,
0.4570055902,
0.0182094648,
0.6365123987,
-0.7298095226,
0.0375694633,
-0.2039110512,
-0.0451696143,
-0.5064796805,
-0.2776084244,
0.499163717,
-0.5357256532,
-0.6448695064,
-0.3584460616,
0.5571106672,
-0.5283893943,
-0.4462799728,
-0.103460744,
0.1971137226,
-0.2802388668,
-0.3260370791,
-0.4645712078,
-0.1598323733,
-0.051369518,
-0.5008194447,
0.4224124849,
0.8544824123,
-0.2555666864,
0.4572777152,
0.7581961155,
-0.1803348362,
0.246307686,
0.4008790255,
1.186914444,
-0.9565321803,
-0.6202323437,
-0.739898324,
0.8621098399,
0.012288372,
-0.0279140007,
0.9313848615,
0.6107144356,
0.9308125377,
-0.2207693011,
0.7050178051,
0.2406823933,
0.1243617982,
-0.3798343837,
0.4231710136,
-0.1630636901,
0.0715391934,
-0.0442542844,
-1.4006692171,
-0.3399302661,
0.9359565973,
-0.1400631666,
-0.2422783375,
1.1828142405,
0.7076004744,
-0.0395018905,
-0.0249083899,
0.326254189,
0.3079876602,
0.0846076459,
0.3652335405,
1.1290576458,
-0.6026777029,
0.6055033803,
-0.2732350826,
-0.1599413306,
0.0177307054,
-0.0781183094,
-0.9727275372,
-0.2983243465,
-0.3352445066,
-0.2718288898,
-0.0593361445,
0.3567300141,
0.5942420959,
-0.8621726632,
0.155459553,
-0.562908709,
0.049924735,
-0.2734505534,
-0.3784562349,
0.433889091,
-0.6593075395,
-0.7731404305,
0.3249055147,
0.7169038057,
-0.1443664432,
-0.518707931,
0.3347560763,
0.1900422275,
0.0745397508,
0.7247749567,
-0.1285576075,
-0.7212705016,
-0.1567855626,
0.2140018791,
-0.4499628842,
0.1545040756,
1.019133091,
-0.588142395,
0.0247060582,
0.5762544274,
0.4888575971,
0.6383530498,
0.256479919,
0.501504302,
-1.0169863701,
0.2618872821,
0.5464410186,
0.1782288104,
-0.0359801278,
-0.3641915619,
0.5900169015,
0.161693573,
-0.439050436,
-0.6434772015,
0.5080143809,
-1.026818037,
-0.0378600396,
0.9491995573,
-0.0804746971,
-0.5218048096,
-0.0728244707,
-0.0136293015,
0.1483298391,
-0.3559989929,
0.7977443337,
0.5002646446,
0.1404902786,
-0.0547662228,
-0.2452097684,
0.5208930373,
0.7720506787,
-0.4589572251,
-0.2341053039,
0.1175476164,
0.1520874351,
0.371057272,
0.1827638447,
-0.2637924254,
0.3669576645,
0.04031872,
0.1575344801,
0.2231202126,
-0.4180701673,
-0.4633876681,
0.4391652346,
-0.0735729486,
-0.1471213698
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06457v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06457v1
|
V-STaR: Training Verifiers for Self-Taught Reasoners
| 2024-02-09T15:02:56 | 2024-02-09T15:02:56 |
Arian Hosseini, Xingdi Yuan, Nikolay Malkin, Aaron Courville, Alessandro Sordoni, Rishabh Agarwal
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Common self-improvement approaches for large language models (LLMs), such as
STaR (Zelikman et al., 2022), iteratively fine-tune LLMs on self-generated
solutions to improve their problem-solving ability. However, these approaches
discard the large amounts of incorrect solutions generated during this process,
potentially neglecting valuable information in such solutions. To address this
shortcoming, we propose V-STaR that utilizes both the correct and incorrect
solutions generated during the self-improvement process to train a verifier
using DPO that judges correctness of model-generated solutions. This verifier
is used at inference time to select one solution among many candidate
solutions. Running V-STaR for multiple iterations results in progressively
better reasoners and verifiers, delivering a 4% to 17% test accuracy
improvement over existing self-improvement and verification approaches on
common code generation and math reasoning benchmarks with LLaMA2 models.
|
[
-0.2143683881,
-0.5398880839,
0.8667606711,
0.0209716465,
-0.1209553927,
0.2631444037,
-0.1346669048,
-0.1931370795,
-0.0333311968,
0.5318058133,
-0.6310743093,
-0.1516070068,
-0.7270897031,
0.3617247045,
-0.0963954777,
0.6832247972,
-0.169168964,
0.3687562048,
-0.3820149302,
0.2400648743,
-0.6711102128,
-0.5626785755,
-0.2451466918,
-0.4391073585,
0.4331777692,
1.0060263872,
0.2588012218,
0.9132207632,
0.5879530907,
0.4125489891,
0.1275167316,
0.3564926982,
-0.5401716828,
0.1723158807,
-0.4454824328,
-0.6314180493,
-0.2318648249,
-0.1305510253,
0.2177492827,
0.2099388391,
-0.0667829588,
0.3402003646,
-0.2495177835,
0.6432527304,
-0.8270789385,
-0.0289734956,
-0.7789529562,
-0.0825310796,
0.0344421417,
-0.2792973518,
-0.3930733502,
-0.3356897831,
-0.3600386977,
-0.5293357372,
0.2839820385,
-0.2478959858,
0.8712326884,
0.6678515673,
-0.3263545632,
-0.2592303157,
-1.0857909918,
0.9705388546,
-0.6454027891,
0.3198117614,
0.2720890939,
0.8318817019,
-0.2050001174,
-0.6434242725,
-0.9913348556,
-0.1083381027,
0.1768574566,
0.2318198234,
-0.0370223522,
0.0096351672,
0.3975902498,
0.3748304844,
-0.1994322091,
0.3558039665,
-0.4439135194,
-0.3264806569,
0.7994117737,
0.1562103629,
-0.1333378553,
-0.2144300044,
-0.4860139787,
-0.0292002968,
-0.68349123,
0.1491910964,
0.1088915914,
-0.0310898814,
0.4341949224,
0.5868523717,
-0.5420345068,
0.7870000005,
0.0998069942,
-0.5174571276,
0.3041448891,
-0.2637087405,
-0.1649443656,
-0.1425486058,
0.5318940878,
0.3148429394,
0.3401073515,
0.1123398989,
-0.4190748632,
0.3354834914,
0.3163257241,
-0.8623701334,
-0.1276871264,
0.3698739409,
-0.0208692849,
-0.3676949143,
-0.3467096686,
-0.6026564837,
-0.3164017797,
-0.7135294676,
0.6151502132,
-0.1464701593,
-0.1012731344,
0.3419644833,
-0.1443993002,
0.0193370357,
0.5393605232,
-0.7314940691,
-0.050867442,
0.7733319402,
0.4113019407,
0.2508757412,
-0.4250862896,
-0.8348056078,
-0.1610375643,
-0.4846550822,
0.9235811234,
-0.4514144063,
-0.2577409446,
-0.0055426159,
-0.2281768918,
0.0555174612,
-0.512278676,
0.6696904302,
-0.3767606914,
0.100990437,
-0.6716967821,
-0.8044422269,
0.0128334602,
0.4125012755,
-0.1017195135,
0.9953789115,
0.1225711182,
-0.340184629,
0.4906499684,
-0.1650017798,
0.2324958295,
0.1600681841,
-0.4457463026,
-0.5148675442,
0.219107464,
0.4478533268,
0.5043293834,
-0.3272533417,
0.1023437753,
-0.3066385984,
-0.4001759887,
0.0532772094,
-0.2484415472,
0.3811860681,
0.3158572316,
-0.3721313477,
0.1250029355,
-1.0635496378,
0.3105165958,
0.3638593554,
-0.3893455863,
-0.2931267321,
-0.0523881279,
-0.4803988338,
0.3923736215,
0.2539157569,
-0.7061429024,
0.3440430164,
-0.1551106721,
0.3363359272,
0.8733013272,
-0.0123408288,
-0.1806291938,
-0.234729439,
0.4306313097,
0.1572832614,
0.2016670704,
-0.1887070984,
-0.2612890601,
-1.2138864994,
-0.2658771873,
0.0956585705,
0.5808048248,
-0.8195550442,
0.3687919974,
-0.0704294443,
-0.9603468776,
-0.4350784719,
0.5785652399,
0.6277028918,
0.8101841807,
0.4580617547,
0.1713989526,
-0.4950223863,
-0.7389374971,
-0.3245681524,
-0.2509118319,
0.3117263317,
0.1377583891,
0.7040726542,
-0.465655297,
0.8682402372,
-0.2360140234,
-0.0522670783,
-0.1114858612,
-0.2731973529,
0.2820573449,
0.281906724,
0.6155256629,
-0.4367071092,
-0.4938947856,
-0.0425602905,
-0.8116164207,
-0.1141567156,
-0.071090281,
0.1201066077,
0.1764628887,
0.438533783,
-0.1314610541,
0.1318753511,
0.5266318321,
-0.5995892882,
0.7636501193,
-0.4842338264,
0.3102599382,
-0.8489061594,
-0.2725125253,
0.1240742356,
-0.448569864,
-0.4524773955,
-0.1256303638,
0.1017579958,
-0.0057331705,
-0.1175220609,
0.3582747877,
-0.3771606386,
0.2154033184,
-0.5817665458,
0.2661474347,
-0.1299726218,
0.281054765,
0.0285429601,
0.867741704,
0.7049723268,
-0.7647354007,
0.545679152,
0.2306676358,
-0.176898241,
0.7267872095,
-0.8332251906,
0.2391435653,
-0.3826341331,
-0.2062239051,
-1.1087403297,
-0.2040342689,
0.2614704669,
-0.363029778,
0.1012823358,
-0.1352621764,
-0.2736188769,
-0.7916606665,
0.1082194895,
0.0290329102,
0.5318035483,
-1.1206182241,
0.2607399523,
0.140279308,
0.0353796855,
-1.0355268717,
-0.2671864629,
-0.0476299226,
-0.0276730061,
-0.5373507142,
0.1115679294,
-0.2264759839,
-0.2536770403,
-0.2463124841,
-0.43857494,
-0.1200718805,
0.1885723323,
0.2253805399,
0.1037002131,
-0.1374609619,
0.4510953426,
-0.0128333829,
-0.6179600954,
0.1320515424,
-0.1484087855,
0.2466225177,
-0.4431111217,
-0.5141100883,
-0.4186676443,
0.0857789367,
0.6337255836,
-0.3965915143,
0.3549695313,
0.2359931916,
-0.2178432643,
-0.5344122648,
-0.8488903642,
-0.2195669562,
-0.5005335808,
0.3180952966,
-0.741161406,
-1.0012725592,
0.3363830745,
-0.3494426012,
0.2836164534,
0.446300894,
0.5702745914,
-0.1330857575,
0.8414182067,
0.6373309493,
0.0285442919,
0.2343572229,
-0.2279865891,
0.1603417248,
-0.3515513539,
-0.1499857306,
-0.5902994871,
-0.0265720394,
-0.1708230078,
-0.4623314142,
0.1344193071,
0.5433752537,
-0.1910517216,
0.4211539924,
-0.6814703345,
0.7482914329,
0.4368748069,
-0.05108767,
0.369795233,
-0.1035060361,
-0.0123953708,
-0.3031760752,
-0.7453402877,
-0.6804162264,
1.0519522429,
0.5220682025,
0.5230987668,
-0.0077935751,
1.0453691483,
0.0300183333,
0.3708501756,
-0.7058008313,
0.3329302371,
0.0607805513,
-0.5711490512,
-0.2407412976,
-0.4121620953,
-0.4858548045,
0.3927443922,
-0.1692334265,
-0.6266461611,
0.1224789545,
0.6948482394,
-0.2835296094,
0.1106359884,
-0.6031318307,
1.1983523369,
-0.5289798975,
-0.3480354249,
-0.4600500166,
-0.0369570442,
0.4058776796,
-0.1987492889,
0.1045662984,
-0.0381073281,
0.1580478549,
0.3719380498,
-1.0111927986,
0.7382045388,
-0.3695013523,
-0.1448050141,
0.4826079309,
-0.0377887115,
0.7599535584,
0.3239264488,
0.0056861704,
0.1331528127,
-0.1081795618,
-0.3552182019,
-0.7214640379,
0.6495869756,
-0.9269807935,
-1.1075570583,
-0.4564308524,
-0.0152283702,
-0.0710096285,
0.2399374098,
0.2901801765,
0.2110256702,
0.2768700421,
0.0115687642,
0.6586840749,
0.160840705,
0.3702801168,
0.7534528971,
-0.2690640986,
-0.5968749523,
0.884670496,
0.0761084482,
0.3071213365,
0.1259608567,
0.3855486512,
-0.2537986338,
-0.7036539912,
-0.5276002884,
0.3712222874,
-1.1312077045,
-0.2809157968,
-0.3884536326,
-0.2484946698,
-0.1124776378,
-0.1891724318,
-0.8330044746,
-0.3008190095,
0.0798721761,
-0.0983885303,
0.4856954515,
0.7063241601,
-0.2206108123,
0.3389409482,
-0.6139208674,
0.2039425075,
0.612211287,
0.2887144983,
-0.5575198531,
-0.6550550461,
-0.2141590863,
-0.1490004063,
-0.2766354978,
-0.7524620891,
0.0531837791,
0.0999497473,
0.7487932444,
0.1420395672,
-0.1587269455,
0.8240506053,
-0.415540576,
0.7413768172,
0.2943694592,
-1.0313878059,
0.9676709175,
-0.0787601992,
0.0286021531,
0.6032424569,
0.2804178894,
-0.3203091025,
-0.2562143803,
-0.4985847175,
-0.3765859008,
0.3008142412,
0.0977199301,
-0.0596331395,
-0.0393224545,
0.7455946803,
0.2110898346,
-0.114682667,
-0.7141825557,
-0.4240529537,
-0.4499905407,
0.1420821398,
-0.2986332774,
-0.5572453141,
-0.0670212284,
-0.1524948329,
1.0095680952,
-0.3982886672,
-0.0417955518,
0.5132770538,
-0.0049900645,
-0.3308311403,
0.2665629089,
0.6561062932,
0.8990901709,
0.1225959882,
0.1192800477,
0.2325930297,
-0.2433002591,
0.5719919205,
-0.0854506195,
-0.1091607139,
0.1819573492,
0.1799686253,
0.6630803347,
-0.1718743145,
-0.4783931971,
0.610971868,
-0.3112222552,
-0.3711930811,
-0.6779379845,
0.5343498588,
0.0004020502,
0.3379299939,
0.0241270605,
0.3092139661,
-0.1634806842,
-0.0915502682,
0.2058619708,
0.1570456922,
-0.4924287498,
-0.1249378845,
0.6393379569,
0.353135854,
-0.4768954515,
0.5180748105,
-0.2396771014,
-0.5457542539,
0.5056846738,
0.5502107143,
0.7117325664,
-0.3433470726,
0.3018893898,
0.8496088982,
0.2118236572,
-0.2811051607,
0.5653723478,
-0.1363302767,
-0.7970616817,
-0.7772026658,
-0.4837009907,
-0.454777509,
0.2870317996,
-0.2835829258,
0.4417148232,
-0.6032027006,
-0.1288461834,
0.071430482,
-0.0636924505,
-0.7317601442,
0.3890128136,
0.1626540422,
0.8683576584,
-0.841912806,
0.7691595554,
0.6896101832,
-0.4878953099,
-0.9593604207,
-0.37150231,
0.0589960627,
-0.7090213895,
0.9283502102,
0.1667362899,
-0.1568327099,
-0.0383212157,
-0.2883752286,
-1.0589735508,
1.0739762783,
0.4940695763,
-1.3947817087,
0.5027664304,
0.126886785,
0.4683936536,
-0.1763036698,
0.2989373803,
0.4367299676,
0.2823154032,
0.1951758116,
-0.9379627109,
-0.2013559192,
-0.2814977765,
0.0602751262,
-0.0357269011,
-0.6752898097,
0.5647271872,
-0.5404065251,
-0.0267162677,
-0.1209815666,
0.8392886519,
0.6294126511,
0.1293934733,
0.6607087255,
0.6927316189,
1.0107564926,
-0.1477511376,
1.0225223303,
-0.4153400064,
0.4431715906,
1.1260890961,
-0.044971291,
0.6625645757,
0.6548873186,
0.0614063293,
0.5041056275,
0.4177214205,
-0.1164196134,
0.3112030029,
0.4222112,
-0.2119630128,
-0.9957660437,
0.2395288348,
-0.3317211866,
0.6469958425,
0.0995761976,
-0.2816666067,
-0.3158523738,
-0.0771688595,
-0.0685976818,
0.5535675883,
-0.3475648463,
0.4107226133,
0.151956737,
-0.9213383794,
0.9038141966,
-0.0391364507,
0.4193186462,
-0.3793306947,
-0.1973356754,
-0.1267029792,
0.8029789329,
-0.1628970206,
-0.5809742808,
0.1376199424,
0.1570340097,
-0.3215920031,
-0.2313058376,
0.9117774367,
-0.1289400458,
-0.6015133262,
0.1216963083,
0.4864708483,
0.0675684214,
0.1106091961,
-0.6379974484,
-0.0496548899,
0.0589856654,
-0.3302992284,
-0.2256458551,
0.4530228972,
0.1406712383,
0.9183705449,
0.4444538355,
0.0957385376,
0.0942438319,
0.2475620806,
0.7398599386,
-0.6036533713,
-0.3638850451,
-0.9828504324,
0.8730906248,
-0.2098222971,
-0.7804754972,
0.9812455177,
0.3506151736,
1.188877821,
-0.2685898542,
0.9853484631,
0.1890928298,
0.6802813411,
-0.5285536051,
0.2709270418,
-0.4482480884,
0.4305460155,
-0.0446041264,
-0.9119601846,
-0.0635235682,
0.6473749876,
-0.3543130457,
-0.0515149087,
0.4472790062,
0.7317602634,
0.1362355798,
-0.2425608039,
0.4862416685,
0.1179077923,
0.6805108786,
0.6989156604,
1.0720529556,
-0.7071585059,
0.4632920921,
-0.5107439756,
-0.3730465174,
-0.2640094459,
-0.8041033745,
-1.1740598679,
-0.4348860681,
-0.7769040465,
-0.292378962,
0.1153201014,
0.8211145997,
0.6575706005,
-0.6520588994,
-0.0001262693,
-0.4558432698,
0.1513062119,
-0.453212589,
-0.0784934759,
-0.1716462374,
-0.928176105,
-0.5155007243,
0.6315882206,
0.0809997991,
-0.0790199712,
-0.5298889279,
-0.4225393236,
0.4788592458,
0.1303168386,
0.3527927101,
0.4134941697,
-0.8649172783,
-0.7542029619,
0.0477215983,
-0.2048407495,
0.0977291092,
0.5658070445,
-0.8779876828,
0.7918347716,
0.5453824401,
0.6369799972,
0.3590102196,
-0.2109999359,
0.5592036247,
-0.4322792292,
-0.2917648852,
0.0262882914,
0.590611577,
0.1320726126,
-0.3443092406,
0.4055958986,
0.5013566017,
-0.9059559703,
-0.7782200575,
0.4093000889,
-0.7692027688,
-0.0969107822,
1.0116131306,
-0.2071543932,
-0.359230876,
0.0901566446,
-0.1519806385,
0.0301629212,
-0.0710732564,
1.1335792542,
0.5436897278,
0.0877766162,
-0.2552449107,
-0.3841596246,
0.5686645508,
0.501134932,
-0.87371701,
0.1684779823,
0.4815732539,
0.6621962786,
0.4294846058,
0.6316405535,
0.1039558426,
0.5358116627,
0.1663065851,
0.204999119,
-0.4270515442,
-0.6238452196,
-0.3141068518,
-0.0795039833,
0.3965440392,
-0.2265903205
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06443v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06443v1
|
Explaining Veracity Predictions with Evidence Summarization: A Multi-Task Model Approach
| 2024-02-09T14:39:20 | 2024-02-09T14:39:20 |
Recep Firat Cekinel, Pinar Karagoz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The rapid dissemination of misinformation through social media increased the
importance of automated fact-checking. Furthermore, studies on what deep neural
models pay attention to when making predictions have increased in recent years.
While significant progress has been made in this field, it has not yet reached
a level of reasoning comparable to human reasoning. To address these gaps, we
propose a multi-task explainable neural model for misinformation detection.
Specifically, this work formulates an explanation generation process of the
model's veracity prediction as a text summarization problem. Additionally, the
performance of the proposed model is discussed on publicly available datasets
and the findings are evaluated with related studies.
|
[
-0.1308760941,
-0.7269458175,
0.8504257202,
0.1584768593,
-0.1546219736,
-0.3280697465,
-0.0285127461,
-0.4240145683,
0.0489925854,
0.3555101752,
-0.6662605405,
-0.4558044374,
-0.9930958152,
-0.0146313235,
-0.7477208972,
1.1165450811,
0.1141052395,
-0.1172089577,
-0.2386142761,
0.1720147282,
-0.7307052016,
-0.2167356908,
-0.367654562,
-0.4479184747,
0.4515257478,
0.6416115761,
0.7141788006,
0.6867907643,
0.2441034764,
0.3337323368,
0.0112640429,
0.4253670275,
-0.1022935361,
0.1116961911,
-0.110439077,
-0.7328379154,
-0.2998854816,
-0.0316467211,
0.4960226417,
0.5183153152,
-0.0448146351,
0.0703878179,
-0.0017866878,
0.3441573977,
-0.5821769834,
0.0845762044,
-0.7258467078,
-0.2691046298,
0.1265071183,
-0.4008909166,
-0.3858893812,
-0.3214708865,
0.3482956886,
-0.4680565,
0.6128248572,
-0.0451495871,
0.6502982974,
0.2808875144,
-0.4502453506,
-0.3855194449,
-0.7596622109,
0.6702786088,
-0.8516345024,
0.1645881534,
0.530875504,
0.237174347,
0.0725535229,
-0.5486089587,
-0.7482178807,
-0.0905457139,
-0.2489735484,
0.0104659684,
-0.3160542846,
-0.2008507699,
0.0549220182,
0.013272007,
-0.6138136387,
-0.2579202056,
-0.3716085851,
-0.2896781266,
0.6174381971,
0.0448176675,
0.1886988431,
-0.3044045568,
-0.265158534,
0.4202728868,
-0.3603056967,
-0.2527895272,
0.2267480493,
0.1496453583,
-0.1298089325,
0.6588451862,
-0.3706246614,
0.4930089414,
0.0736195147,
-0.2566005588,
-0.0766229853,
-0.7379111052,
-0.2297272831,
0.4365198314,
0.6477707028,
0.7654394507,
-0.0188934263,
-0.0628844872,
-0.1164273694,
0.1673139632,
0.3596514165,
-0.9249836802,
-0.0116122123,
0.5260336399,
-0.8295360208,
-0.4521305263,
-0.1250748038,
-0.7631723881,
-0.806263566,
-0.4792748094,
0.5006746054,
-0.6747639775,
-0.4393299818,
0.1724194437,
-0.5371661186,
-0.5263273716,
0.6492625475,
-0.7139815092,
-0.0387511402,
0.5730772614,
1.0891970396,
0.0569336489,
-0.4974243939,
-0.2717951834,
0.1660455614,
-0.4285090566,
1.1264630556,
-0.0502173975,
-0.0140399532,
-0.060920313,
0.0020053119,
-0.0759281516,
-0.2068846971,
0.5125736594,
-0.3302052319,
0.2149432302,
-0.5325505137,
-0.5077494979,
-0.5794895291,
0.3793742061,
-0.7386339903,
0.5783444047,
-0.2716687024,
-1.3190258741,
0.4529691935,
-0.7154766321,
-0.5143635869,
-0.0624508858,
0.2256367058,
-0.4056591094,
0.1539761275,
0.3274199963,
0.7059730291,
-0.3224316239,
0.7338765264,
-0.1603127569,
-0.3670148849,
0.5413426161,
-0.781652987,
0.6260287166,
0.2808331847,
-0.5375767946,
0.3137481809,
-0.4674593508,
-0.4236469865,
-0.1725357771,
-0.1898510456,
-0.4496433139,
0.3106419742,
-0.3035370409,
0.1005338505,
0.0931881666,
-0.3343444467,
-0.3140405416,
-0.1825760156,
0.1023402885,
0.3845727742,
0.1853882521,
0.2744002938,
-0.6902680993,
0.0276302658,
0.2966643572,
0.2716287374,
-0.4217374623,
-0.5490014553,
-0.6118628383,
0.2253829241,
0.0525571257,
0.5364744663,
-0.7848533392,
0.2011121362,
-0.3703944981,
-0.5779905319,
-0.4684567451,
0.0087099439,
0.4374160171,
0.5875720382,
0.5464630723,
0.1238785982,
-0.4952586293,
-1.0171853304,
-0.7936432362,
-0.1186127514,
0.0262630936,
-0.1550871879,
0.8640115261,
-0.0541433319,
0.8471161127,
-0.326690048,
-0.0465032086,
-0.4055630267,
0.8019478321,
0.2313630581,
0.40255633,
0.3438858092,
-1.1008923054,
-0.1242562309,
-0.0756758973,
-0.9149356484,
0.1649055779,
-0.332729429,
0.1701738834,
0.0577697009,
0.3726027012,
-0.9363127351,
0.7049128413,
0.1815886199,
-0.4703275263,
0.8808601499,
-0.2818460166,
0.6326858401,
-1.0506036282,
-0.0981492996,
0.3356722891,
-0.1278458834,
-1.0477844477,
-0.4423695207,
0.1640384644,
0.2310720086,
-0.1308923662,
0.0722471476,
-0.4439682662,
-0.0435574166,
-0.7674317956,
0.1205868721,
0.0080899969,
0.0955801383,
0.0894114673,
0.4657269418,
0.4183652699,
-0.883484304,
0.5130904913,
0.0349779949,
-0.4081324637,
0.543015182,
-0.8541897535,
-0.5620009899,
-0.5826414824,
0.3119155467,
-1.0166208744,
-0.7106679082,
0.0472036041,
-0.9044259191,
0.0782932639,
-0.205446139,
-0.514244616,
-0.3596591055,
-0.1479318291,
0.0297377389,
-0.0446952991,
-0.502658546,
0.8052815199,
0.2924456,
-0.2828689516,
-0.8687042594,
-0.8743760586,
0.1242609769,
-0.2247391194,
-0.7642814517,
0.3837636113,
-0.1118876114,
-0.6062586308,
0.2229902297,
-0.2472090572,
-0.2726836503,
0.3191828132,
0.3335801661,
0.2939684093,
-0.219480142,
0.6094927788,
0.0998036936,
0.0186088085,
0.3941822946,
-0.3088369966,
0.1269132346,
-0.0111398762,
-0.2195386142,
-0.7868942618,
0.5047388077,
0.7024461031,
-0.1019749641,
1.1284936666,
0.6804269552,
-0.7544943094,
-0.1029425189,
-0.7349148989,
-0.2750804722,
-0.342680186,
0.4959126413,
0.0625441372,
-0.345918417,
0.3213280439,
-0.0623081513,
0.0691529587,
0.7752171159,
0.6632460356,
-0.0373959281,
0.8632060289,
0.5231575966,
0.1383590251,
0.2503140569,
-0.0899441391,
0.019205166,
0.0203939285,
-0.4158961475,
-0.4975249469,
0.0922898799,
-0.2110222578,
-0.4726992846,
0.2685063779,
-0.0154219549,
0.1518408507,
0.2632576525,
-0.4884598553,
0.5828232169,
0.6001579165,
0.2325489819,
0.4388397932,
-0.1620833576,
0.2469204813,
0.3639356196,
-0.7513803244,
-0.4367361665,
1.0426627398,
0.4085785449,
0.46931234,
0.1357343346,
0.3344550729,
0.5994439721,
0.5194439292,
-0.3987259567,
0.112161845,
-0.0065858793,
-1.0990921259,
-0.4236204624,
-0.3627329171,
-0.448235929,
0.3697798252,
-0.6406732202,
-0.4932160974,
0.1659262925,
0.2544117272,
-0.5940023661,
0.3029710948,
-0.7415331006,
0.7115240693,
-0.2342347801,
-0.1718650758,
-0.6887949705,
-0.7215019464,
0.8262391686,
-0.0877459496,
0.7574675679,
-0.1039294228,
0.2479795814,
0.8147853017,
-0.1719283015,
1.0465681553,
-0.3230583668,
0.0952307358,
0.3603974283,
-0.1475554854,
0.5774389505,
0.2141784281,
0.0090917749,
-0.132596314,
-0.1724459082,
-0.2633573711,
-0.4393180311,
0.5057912469,
-0.4176348746,
-0.3052673936,
-0.3429913521,
-1.008346796,
0.0866453573,
0.1379438788,
0.6239794493,
0.4261174202,
-0.0860768855,
0.0961612314,
1.034632206,
-0.1716724485,
0.5992182493,
0.5039999485,
0.1102578789,
-0.2026520669,
0.7733371854,
0.2606735826,
-0.0264958013,
0.3209239244,
0.300881058,
-0.305740416,
-0.8107008338,
-0.1912662387,
0.0461999923,
-0.8685110807,
-0.1328092515,
-0.7928694487,
-0.0762502477,
-0.5712158084,
0.2022315264,
-0.2505622208,
-0.3719317615,
-0.2924460173,
-0.1249026731,
0.3433377147,
1.1730502844,
-0.1208827943,
0.7455058694,
-0.7790880799,
0.727640748,
0.3596793115,
0.2719548941,
0.068490237,
-0.6004533172,
-0.6459881663,
0.3129492402,
-0.2344663292,
-1.4087851048,
0.4685994685,
-0.090404585,
0.6853236556,
0.5484164953,
0.0521047413,
0.3634972572,
-0.0070498083,
0.6527656913,
0.3458392322,
-0.9525424242,
0.6983508468,
-0.3489621878,
0.1448791772,
0.3362383246,
0.7773689032,
-0.5700387955,
-0.3229905963,
-0.6045796275,
-0.4593667388,
0.6510539651,
0.2575567067,
-0.2184475362,
0.1051028594,
0.1746476591,
0.4372608364,
0.3283831179,
-0.6548525691,
-0.4078755975,
-0.4311673045,
-0.126928702,
-0.090776667,
-0.5441809297,
-0.175379023,
-0.1256713122,
0.8477544785,
-0.1560651362,
0.3091459572,
0.3133514524,
-0.3636085689,
-0.0565116107,
0.3767507076,
0.9133813381,
0.9879134893,
-0.1529742926,
0.4194184244,
0.089608632,
-0.4045992494,
-0.0972434729,
0.4237601459,
-0.2639513612,
0.5634007454,
0.6854438782,
0.7120563388,
0.0398841538,
-0.1870008558,
0.8595509529,
-0.0803010762,
-0.4874539375,
-0.327545166,
-0.2275238335,
0.3820484877,
0.4556564987,
0.7361302376,
0.5324930549,
0.4030320644,
-0.4723665416,
0.1808807403,
0.2700476944,
-0.2278341651,
-0.2906708419,
0.7518629432,
-0.0001671765,
0.0990039036,
0.2405016273,
-0.0521850213,
-0.6169255376,
0.8098655939,
0.287140429,
0.6447651982,
-0.3757710159,
0.4510065317,
0.4908747673,
0.68175143,
-0.4807785153,
0.2480904013,
0.0664264113,
-0.7391456962,
-0.7606229782,
-0.1650933176,
-0.2071341276,
0.2727856338,
-0.3029512167,
-0.0447640419,
-0.0307616144,
-0.2506233454,
0.685460031,
-0.3613035381,
-0.416367799,
0.467223376,
0.0607151426,
0.716663599,
-1.1562752724,
0.5790506005,
0.036584124,
-0.5016573071,
-0.5263693929,
0.3305862248,
0.2965043783,
-0.387568742,
0.5178570151,
0.3782070875,
0.1068235561,
-0.5895617604,
-0.7694779038,
-0.8380122185,
1.2241969109,
0.4244267344,
-0.4395739138,
-0.1077529564,
-0.2447996438,
0.1904802024,
-0.4284964204,
0.3292877376,
0.6408990026,
0.7331238985,
-0.1666088104,
-0.7102534175,
0.0432225056,
-0.151147455,
-0.3097704947,
-0.1611409038,
-0.0818359032,
1.0579138994,
-0.5761919022,
-0.1135420948,
-0.1703396291,
0.8743960857,
0.0442553051,
0.8591310382,
0.5279673338,
0.1376527399,
0.9609876871,
-0.0491740182,
1.1813651323,
-0.1850993484,
0.1671852022,
1.3484818935,
0.2849160433,
0.36908108,
0.2710317373,
0.1567917913,
0.5276324153,
0.5754742026,
-0.0035028809,
0.3604959846,
-0.0745301768,
-0.3061415255,
-0.4035913646,
-0.4423882961,
-0.2914249599,
0.360976845,
0.5043341517,
-0.7723320127,
-0.1922996193,
-0.0480324365,
-0.0740889609,
-0.1042651162,
-0.5422931314,
0.4939523339,
-0.2578729391,
-0.9877162576,
0.3444114327,
0.1725462675,
0.7212136984,
-0.4685568213,
-0.1241810396,
0.0570289046,
0.0114493826,
-0.4897916615,
-0.9131717086,
0.5543159842,
-0.0944841802,
-0.5893704295,
-0.0677934065,
1.1294076443,
-0.6796217561,
-0.2545768917,
0.1750552207,
0.7057558298,
0.2291504294,
-0.5967936516,
-0.4765576124,
-0.297637254,
-0.0429748707,
-0.0576747507,
-0.0554464608,
0.5826598406,
-0.1305155158,
0.7767640948,
0.7396679521,
0.0128720049,
-0.0021481251,
-0.0870048329,
0.7510128617,
-0.3188144565,
-0.5143542886,
-0.9519246221,
0.5481898785,
-0.4622745514,
-0.0126963751,
0.7449066639,
0.4400920272,
0.1749262363,
-0.2760213315,
1.2616733313,
0.0010224214,
0.6971493959,
-0.3877727389,
1.0652763844,
-0.4821889699,
0.0839427337,
-0.1941074431,
-0.482337743,
-0.0899625346,
0.2981505394,
-0.1485730708,
-0.0651660562,
0.9781201482,
0.596508801,
-0.0303305779,
0.3565883636,
0.2246490866,
0.3699704409,
-0.1836300641,
0.274535358,
0.8286200166,
-0.3053298891,
0.7373432517,
-0.4138115048,
-0.1924833357,
-0.403878957,
-1.1213777065,
-0.9280391335,
-0.6942725778,
-0.3243676424,
-0.5119288564,
0.1976912022,
0.4463658333,
0.889582634,
-0.7839272022,
0.1736700833,
-0.2788850963,
0.5499582887,
-0.401722014,
-0.2014930248,
0.2863281667,
-0.145272702,
-0.2398373038,
0.4661436379,
0.0290175211,
0.1628074795,
0.0468501151,
0.0013853892,
-0.5093442798,
0.3076730967,
0.3888004422,
-0.0021778108,
-0.7300465703,
0.0119206328,
-0.2352024764,
-0.0311283506,
-0.3418534696,
0.8567278981,
-0.4802979827,
0.3452526927,
0.5000865459,
0.4423103333,
0.5388163328,
0.1138795242,
0.593639493,
-0.751221478,
-0.3334401846,
-0.0452013314,
0.4146024883,
0.3844767213,
-0.7261534929,
0.2671485543,
0.3685207963,
-0.4950082302,
-0.5851948857,
-0.069337666,
-0.6555110812,
-0.6987296343,
0.8707218766,
-0.170697242,
-0.2484642416,
-0.5730038285,
0.0564640425,
0.6485076547,
-0.4507318139,
0.9456759691,
0.732524097,
0.120927833,
-0.1026758552,
-0.8458496332,
0.5828698874,
0.1133822873,
-1.101270318,
0.5207358599,
0.6794772148,
0.488402158,
0.5143536329,
0.62137115,
0.1783687174,
0.9187328815,
0.3103195727,
0.1351819187,
-0.3246488273,
-0.6865891814,
-0.1965103298,
0.3497320712,
-0.3189844191,
-0.1408135593
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06420v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06420v1
|
Findings of the First Workshop on Simulating Conversational Intelligence in Chat
| 2024-02-09T14:08:23 | 2024-02-09T14:08:23 |
Yvette Graham, Mohammed Rameez Qureshi, Haider Khalid, Gerasimos Lampouras, Ignacio Iacobacci, Qun Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The aim of this workshop is to bring together experts working on open-domain
dialogue research. In this speedily advancing research area many challenges
still exist, such as learning information from conversations, engaging in
realistic and convincing simulation of human intelligence and reasoning.
SCI-CHAT follows previous workshops on open domain dialogue but with a focus on
the simulation of intelligent conversation as judged in a live human
evaluation. Models aim to include the ability to follow a challenging topic
over a multi-turn conversation, while positing, refuting and reasoning over
arguments. The workshop included both a research track and shared task. The
main goal of this paper is to provide an overview of the shared task and a link
to an additional paper that will include an in depth analysis of the shared
task results following presentation at the workshop.
|
[
-0.4344013631,
-0.8826455474,
0.5068228245,
0.2064771056,
-0.0642570481,
0.3595058918,
-0.3362491131,
-0.5575243831,
0.3317796886,
0.2603421807,
-0.9308363199,
-0.4066617191,
-0.2838763595,
-0.3169813752,
-0.2675122321,
0.6792536974,
0.3282474279,
0.265573889,
-0.7929990888,
0.0270248447,
-0.3681962788,
-0.9113108516,
-0.6872299314,
-0.3054582775,
0.3935485482,
0.4032544196,
0.5405002236,
-0.1504003555,
0.4576132298,
0.2677430212,
0.1006859764,
0.2537929416,
-0.911354661,
0.1828479916,
-0.1735376567,
-0.4700202942,
-0.6249539852,
0.380510956,
0.4112321138,
0.8960739374,
-0.2146126777,
-0.1318962574,
0.2154179662,
0.0473451652,
-0.1519112885,
0.4924243689,
-0.4805365801,
-0.0452953726,
0.0771229938,
-0.3118387759,
-0.5887337327,
-0.0790115446,
0.4866626263,
-0.7336761355,
0.0687548667,
0.4306706488,
0.6194278002,
0.1107869893,
-0.2160118371,
-0.1290930212,
-1.1369082928,
0.8884297609,
-0.5383866429,
0.052966319,
0.4060082138,
0.2517437637,
-0.6540902853,
-0.9021911621,
-0.6771043539,
-0.1780174673,
0.0022472499,
0.1744252741,
-0.340331167,
0.1002917662,
0.346922338,
-0.0235235114,
-0.2405356318,
-0.0792139247,
-0.7873868346,
0.008271493,
0.9113003016,
0.3938930929,
0.2298928201,
0.5599970222,
-0.1686987132,
-0.0978793874,
-0.2929887474,
0.0360356532,
0.2637354732,
0.2239144444,
-0.1924592406,
0.4146531224,
-0.479527086,
0.2075193375,
-0.4086404443,
0.0534168221,
0.2761262059,
-0.7269484997,
0.0500744693,
-0.15919967,
0.8684489131,
0.5670601726,
0.3367370069,
-0.0317896642,
0.5016039014,
-0.0071349228,
0.2995753884,
-0.7592025399,
-0.4948475361,
0.0827130973,
-0.4720664322,
-0.2589105964,
-0.0890021399,
-0.8143222928,
-0.086489439,
-0.1974989325,
0.2855007648,
-0.4350151718,
-0.4365133047,
0.0384161174,
-0.1601382345,
0.0145965312,
0.6493092775,
-0.5415472984,
0.8431169391,
0.8109032512,
0.5395831466,
-0.1396964788,
-0.3772622943,
-0.0266266558,
-0.0601666607,
0.0205927361,
0.8800413013,
-0.599578023,
-0.7795322537,
-0.3892701268,
-0.2607874274,
-0.158508569,
-0.2317912728,
0.6942108274,
-0.1597915888,
0.4746973217,
-0.1738645583,
-0.4800222516,
-0.0930343047,
0.2897013128,
-0.291135937,
0.8108609915,
0.0059529282,
-0.8292528987,
0.1598009169,
-1.0888819695,
-0.1194245592,
0.3626575172,
-0.4475857913,
-0.0311140306,
-0.2431747168,
-0.1650270969,
0.0038253055,
-0.3279804885,
0.0995009765,
-0.4535238743,
-0.3822417855,
0.5536223054,
-0.3761572242,
0.7055817246,
0.1361672878,
-0.0668138117,
0.2568542659,
-0.3482455015,
0.4569291174,
0.147416845,
0.2530673146,
-0.2759114802,
0.3925612867,
-0.2996965647,
0.0544716418,
-0.001767736,
-0.8795125484,
0.3168943822,
-0.2865947783,
0.3168388903,
0.3777496517,
0.4007059634,
0.3191949725,
-0.5269096494,
0.2788744271,
0.0996813178,
0.4455575943,
-0.0637594685,
-0.9979489446,
-0.5852277875,
-0.3097188473,
0.2679339647,
0.5803397894,
-0.4417451918,
0.0186340809,
-0.2525783777,
-0.6408784389,
-0.6144341826,
-0.3506018221,
0.2697353661,
0.0456968248,
0.1908301413,
-0.7486425638,
-0.4500382543,
-0.832850337,
-0.1547797024,
-0.3439387977,
0.0232293662,
0.6118053794,
0.5334967375,
0.0494934022,
1.1440066099,
-0.5137536526,
-0.022002209,
-0.2782617807,
0.574080646,
-0.1940959841,
0.8809415698,
0.5593882799,
-0.6924628019,
-0.4918651283,
-0.1049650535,
-0.6604168415,
0.2827793062,
0.2188157737,
-0.4382849038,
0.095627211,
0.3623704612,
-0.8997525573,
1.0231812,
0.2301260829,
-0.1318464875,
0.4584834576,
-0.0919036791,
0.6961962581,
-0.8778481483,
-0.0020626974,
-0.4331591427,
0.1812713444,
-0.8838746548,
-0.2388961613,
-0.5667954683,
-0.3669915795,
-0.5421985984,
0.6542688012,
-0.0257148873,
-0.0434429199,
-0.1495564282,
0.1882572025,
-0.154692322,
0.8245410919,
-0.0297865272,
0.8709951043,
0.4091149569,
-0.4358276427,
0.2829760015,
0.4846516848,
-0.4829726815,
0.4497166872,
-0.7464452982,
0.3828806877,
0.0710408911,
0.380631119,
-0.8354160786,
-0.342780143,
0.4918153584,
-0.7942681909,
-0.1037452668,
0.1232249141,
-0.5487181544,
-0.4277535677,
0.0246153045,
0.4425786734,
0.7304595709,
-0.096038498,
0.6300099492,
0.6637489796,
-0.4317626059,
-0.3521522582,
-0.1972849667,
-0.0359209143,
0.0418599509,
-0.8644328713,
0.4975074828,
-0.366890341,
-0.8312072158,
-0.0574222095,
0.2790117264,
-0.2132858783,
0.205598101,
0.4509699941,
0.2545796931,
-0.0399786085,
-0.1286683083,
-0.0120009035,
0.1077629626,
0.4022029042,
-0.0365218669,
0.6422287822,
-0.1527832001,
-0.7180704474,
-0.7104390264,
0.7775131464,
0.4080263376,
-0.1307325214,
0.8303079009,
0.2385371476,
-0.2866289318,
-0.0861419812,
-0.3040888011,
-0.527995944,
-0.4696083963,
0.2720843852,
-0.2777372897,
-0.9474434853,
0.5513822436,
-0.3800558448,
0.3806837797,
0.0845706314,
0.5935716033,
-0.5695456862,
1.4977722168,
0.7711853385,
0.3761835098,
0.2185178101,
-0.0116181104,
0.7025657892,
-0.3380053639,
-0.6268385649,
-0.7699588537,
-0.3346917033,
-0.1430599242,
-0.8329855204,
0.2688910961,
0.0102935787,
0.0718677491,
-0.0242981985,
-0.1730602682,
0.4718777835,
0.7083904147,
0.1729717106,
0.0752383471,
-0.1431503445,
-0.176822111,
-0.0904802978,
-0.7558706999,
-0.4054118097,
0.5539332628,
0.2425238937,
0.5645141602,
-0.269612819,
0.4460763931,
0.2260000706,
0.3194877207,
-0.6454591155,
1.0840343237,
0.4427377582,
-0.5870382786,
-0.1521781236,
-0.4131761789,
-0.7726171017,
0.0284389332,
-0.1795388609,
-0.9965269566,
-0.3103900254,
-0.0082632648,
-0.0974674523,
0.2371485531,
-0.6216004491,
0.9807398915,
0.0469399057,
-0.1898200959,
-0.7419965267,
-0.8127629161,
0.3737718463,
0.371073842,
0.2994097471,
-0.3481121361,
0.593996346,
0.7566941977,
-0.1476538032,
0.9553466439,
-0.1979432851,
0.3836683035,
0.6280694008,
0.1006628051,
-0.0932710469,
-0.189149335,
0.0855671763,
0.114769727,
0.160413757,
-0.6104049087,
-0.8231888413,
0.4595376253,
-0.9901756048,
-0.9059278965,
-0.2795193195,
-0.7719377279,
-0.2789027691,
-0.1526760459,
-0.38363114,
0.4373157918,
-0.8247691393,
0.2264419645,
0.6788901687,
-0.1967036426,
0.0243400596,
0.3014966249,
-0.3634445667,
-0.066221267,
0.6590846777,
-0.1833857596,
0.5050930977,
-0.0498961508,
0.0274940357,
0.1837432534,
-0.3871240318,
-0.146868512,
0.0136845438,
-0.6610010862,
0.2167954892,
-0.9020534158,
-0.5260021091,
-0.5136339068,
0.0720833763,
-0.2108117044,
-0.739841938,
-0.2651897371,
0.0724159405,
0.3854560554,
0.7257605195,
0.0941263586,
0.1712019891,
-0.7942101359,
-0.2549293637,
0.3653766215,
0.0483847745,
0.0594612546,
-0.2055546939,
-0.2670753598,
0.5705063939,
-0.4283784032,
-0.4706838429,
0.4070320427,
0.1733499914,
0.9871973395,
0.0821163356,
0.3193255365,
0.6644902825,
-0.2715459466,
1.2059521675,
0.0486813672,
-0.6184521914,
0.6469061971,
-0.2821885943,
0.0612880513,
0.7014554739,
0.6653879881,
-0.2875381112,
-0.572091043,
-0.9026831388,
-0.3977264464,
0.7377607822,
0.3350331485,
0.3167589009,
-0.0206511188,
0.1934773177,
0.0160465315,
0.0564889647,
-0.2564721704,
-0.1003080755,
0.0469241627,
-0.0628139228,
0.303588748,
-0.0486349948,
-0.5678950548,
-0.4410611391,
0.7688763738,
-0.1501630545,
0.6541725397,
0.0834877267,
0.3743540943,
-0.0621097013,
0.0920650661,
0.8312307596,
0.5433434844,
-0.1923918426,
-0.1782481223,
0.3200839758,
-0.4741323292,
-0.4394006729,
-0.2102102935,
0.2363452464,
-0.2948299646,
-0.0013672264,
0.9739437699,
0.3405268788,
-0.9736586213,
0.6430247426,
-0.735001862,
-0.5732306242,
-0.2602262795,
0.4099259675,
0.063600935,
0.3562066555,
0.4005904794,
0.4251857996,
-0.1038830206,
-0.9206721783,
0.3951248229,
0.4816150069,
-0.5555638075,
-0.4434500039,
0.4515155554,
0.4802428484,
-0.7716937065,
0.8124361634,
-0.2750568688,
-0.8637830615,
0.5452253222,
0.3550764024,
0.5493755341,
0.0019600433,
0.0640683249,
0.2252031118,
-0.0555828102,
0.2847921252,
0.5677594543,
-0.2818214595,
-0.6982946992,
-0.37472561,
-0.2293030471,
-1.2119189501,
-0.3726618886,
-0.4853578806,
0.2803408504,
-0.0146101238,
-0.1450117528,
0.0223596506,
0.1597039253,
-0.496221602,
-0.3458314538,
0.0504979119,
0.9853743911,
-0.4242762029,
1.1896337271,
0.5163018107,
-0.1820735335,
-0.6788290143,
-0.1832729578,
-0.0744165629,
-0.5698457956,
0.6070950031,
0.0465234332,
-0.2991620302,
0.0944904909,
-1.1049076319,
-0.6760709882,
1.0575006008,
-0.1356168985,
0.0424974635,
-0.1660076976,
0.0825938284,
0.6174864173,
-0.6483727098,
0.5834884048,
0.3362686038,
0.2181846648,
0.5459829569,
-1.365631938,
-0.4405255318,
-0.7088295817,
-0.5202863216,
-0.1255989969,
-0.7297570109,
0.8852506876,
-0.2214099914,
-0.2908963561,
0.3909923434,
1.0795202255,
0.3016424477,
0.4461917281,
0.4131697714,
0.3394283056,
0.5754032135,
-0.1088347062,
0.797290206,
-0.4928602874,
0.2410868555,
1.115680933,
-0.7540861964,
0.7837052345,
0.3813333511,
-0.1882519722,
0.5675362349,
0.2012369931,
0.3495809734,
0.5106941462,
0.2396430075,
-0.6153790951,
-0.0575859472,
-0.4842144847,
-0.2485196292,
0.4882846773,
0.8311749101,
0.120624803,
0.034188658,
0.1662451178,
-0.0090895751,
0.0069575706,
-0.1270063519,
0.9758321643,
0.0559062399,
-0.9579140544,
0.1447010636,
-0.1015478224,
0.4217032492,
-0.568080008,
-0.3580472469,
0.1839070767,
0.2009904385,
0.1194207296,
-0.9026885629,
0.3878703415,
-0.1468678713,
0.08999715,
-0.3904266357,
0.8743985891,
-0.5593155026,
0.1168825328,
0.2212677449,
0.5295857787,
0.6470703483,
0.1572460085,
-0.630762279,
0.2958512902,
0.0189829394,
-0.1196363419,
0.5816668868,
0.4923425913,
-0.1146015152,
0.7398045063,
0.6634396315,
-0.3738274276,
0.1554660946,
0.1870318502,
1.2002881765,
-0.3868000805,
-0.4788716733,
-0.4369718134,
0.3927201033,
-0.4258182943,
-0.2038765997,
0.481012553,
0.4189686477,
0.8064080477,
0.0345107466,
0.6541181803,
-0.2941835225,
0.7846566439,
0.0387742892,
0.8273380399,
-0.0601548888,
-0.0867126882,
-0.0870174021,
-0.5250856876,
0.0299990177,
0.5709003806,
-0.1305274814,
-0.1780508608,
0.6723412275,
0.8074752688,
0.0058193835,
0.9639417529,
0.3779451251,
0.1355118603,
0.396002233,
0.4202644825,
1.17603755,
-0.1933860779,
0.3933447897,
-0.4827689826,
-0.4254692197,
-0.0558862537,
-0.6426603794,
-1.1207491159,
-0.7124691606,
-0.3636774123,
-0.3320659399,
0.0058273189,
1.3123906851,
0.8682463169,
-0.637860775,
-0.4147887826,
0.2032900602,
-0.101905793,
-0.1474254876,
-0.3028583229,
-0.2515872717,
-0.1077565402,
-0.9129264355,
0.5795779824,
0.2997888923,
0.0009075732,
-0.3719654381,
-0.0578947291,
-0.3861300051,
0.3890336156,
0.474565953,
0.3312265575,
-0.5493624806,
-0.5997305512,
0.1551366299,
-0.1735427231,
0.0102468319,
0.933696866,
-1.0756164789,
0.2230930924,
0.4558894336,
0.5377674103,
0.6793326735,
0.1088754535,
0.8171982765,
-0.7101415992,
0.3188372552,
0.5751197338,
-0.0324321836,
-0.0809939727,
-0.1341197193,
0.5455470681,
0.4030604661,
-0.7898961902,
-1.026550889,
0.1190951467,
-1.2928055525,
-0.0508907139,
0.5811657906,
-0.5143125057,
-0.2432880998,
-0.3338809907,
-0.5030744076,
0.1520031095,
-0.4351373315,
0.5194013119,
0.8488460779,
-0.4400204718,
-0.219539687,
-0.6939849257,
0.4035917819,
0.2528681457,
-1.1117273569,
0.012699401,
0.1869636625,
-0.1170154661,
0.3026280403,
0.9993773699,
-0.0257533398,
0.2694705129,
0.2666807473,
0.1894752085,
0.1586490124,
-0.5060127378,
0.373608768,
0.1063319147,
-0.0796842352,
0.1569014192
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06360v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06360v1
|
CoSearchAgent: A Lightweight Collaborative Search Agent with Large Language Models
| 2024-02-09T12:10:00 | 2024-02-09T12:10:00 |
Peiyuan Gong, Jiamian Li, Jiaxin Mao
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Collaborative search supports multiple users working together to accomplish a
specific search task. Research has found that designing lightweight
collaborative search plugins within instant messaging platforms aligns better
with users' collaborative habits. However, due to the complexity of multi-user
interaction scenarios, it is challenging to implement a fully functioning
lightweight collaborative search system. Therefore, previous studies on
lightweight collaborative search had to rely on the Wizard of Oz paradigm. In
recent years, large language models (LLMs) have been demonstrated to interact
naturally with users and achieve complex information-seeking tasks through
LLM-based agents. Hence, to better support the research in collaborative
search, in this demo, we propose CoSearchAgent, a lightweight collaborative
search agent powered by LLMs. CoSearchAgent is designed as a Slack plugin that
can support collaborative search during multi-party conversations on this
platform. Equipped with the capacity to understand the queries and context in
multi-user conversations and the ability to search the Web for relevant
information via APIs, CoSearchAgent can respond to user queries with answers
grounded on the relevant search results. It can also ask clarifying questions
when the information needs are unclear. The proposed CoSearchAgent is highly
flexible and would be useful for supporting further research on collaborative
search. The code and demo video are accessible.
|
[
-0.5372169018,
-0.6148700714,
0.698088944,
0.2941512167,
-0.0444730334,
0.2291151881,
-0.3650663197,
-0.5674497485,
0.7666174173,
0.1473649442,
-0.8429837227,
-0.1653072685,
-0.2342728525,
0.1075668707,
-0.5259591341,
0.5651417375,
0.1476012766,
-0.0843915716,
-0.2453674525,
-0.0585851297,
-0.4274921417,
-0.4375648201,
-0.713735044,
-0.3180103898,
0.661159277,
0.648632586,
1.0392453671,
-0.0943153128,
0.4924626946,
0.4731817842,
0.0276960619,
-0.000977973,
-0.8251405954,
0.6294543743,
-0.3228638172,
-0.4684945047,
-0.4165678918,
-0.0719393343,
0.0419491604,
0.3244653046,
-0.3938940763,
-0.0238900539,
-0.1969187409,
0.0819053799,
-0.5791262388,
0.2335372418,
-0.8180965781,
-0.0849119201,
-0.2012926936,
-0.3094556928,
-0.2499328554,
0.1757784337,
0.573069334,
-0.8266426921,
0.4574634135,
0.2964743376,
0.412261039,
0.1616660953,
-0.360439539,
-0.618273139,
-0.4209577441,
0.6908753514,
-0.6383274198,
0.377993077,
0.028426528,
0.4076225758,
-0.4880829453,
-0.8214385509,
-0.5170199275,
-0.5017738342,
-0.1047960818,
0.1232111081,
0.1136665642,
-0.0308871325,
-0.1885118783,
0.4041823447,
-0.7752563953,
0.2615839839,
-0.0609476268,
-0.2992509007,
0.5444425941,
0.2382289618,
0.5516645312,
0.0418682173,
-0.2899557054,
0.0443030819,
-0.1480379552,
0.0166080259,
0.0806186199,
0.3409809768,
-0.0439840034,
0.6132341623,
-0.2931318283,
0.3213481009,
0.040796686,
-0.0594584942,
-0.0405089259,
-0.3391839266,
0.3013925552,
0.3190378845,
0.7909532189,
0.2672924697,
-0.2961292863,
-0.4108811617,
-0.3294835687,
-0.0314196125,
0.128822878,
-0.9063446522,
-0.2071999609,
0.110686183,
-0.3482116759,
-0.1800249368,
0.0452545695,
-0.534034431,
-0.4492641985,
0.0098351408,
0.4917176962,
-0.1328502148,
-0.1353642493,
0.2245020866,
-0.3219047189,
0.009329549,
0.6822701693,
-0.6209298968,
0.8224933743,
0.5958009362,
0.8296175599,
-0.2002541572,
-0.5423974395,
-0.7608964443,
0.0061392244,
0.0613129139,
0.5065429807,
-0.4769611061,
-0.2783050537,
-0.1732906252,
0.133047089,
0.0595917068,
-0.1032085195,
0.3465925157,
-0.930752933,
0.4358212054,
-0.1149986014,
-0.6372689009,
-0.2168744653,
0.4006573856,
-1.0813446045,
0.9744538665,
0.0439524949,
-0.6101666689,
0.015442376,
-0.8441399932,
-0.1926322579,
0.7306389213,
-0.3054663837,
-0.2849811018,
-0.0231096707,
0.1925118566,
0.3738056123,
-0.512799263,
0.1296611428,
-0.7095448375,
-0.9694091678,
0.0939927697,
-0.0109503465,
0.370569557,
-0.0505710058,
-0.439525187,
-0.0776904896,
-0.3455219269,
-0.1748478562,
0.4580673575,
-0.2463775128,
-0.4322282672,
0.1058695465,
0.19926247,
0.0488615856,
1.0058646202,
-0.4526723325,
0.214661181,
-0.1586850882,
0.1447089016,
0.4789489806,
-0.2686958611,
0.5723021626,
-0.1197264045,
0.5532627106,
-0.5938950777,
0.1870670319,
-0.0510913432,
-0.3443922102,
-0.4373650551,
-0.3569720387,
-0.2200811058,
0.317810446,
-0.6796838045,
0.5060366988,
-0.1318291873,
-0.6070783734,
-0.3503658473,
0.3304172456,
-0.1030581594,
0.1262719631,
0.1775737256,
-0.3423135579,
-0.5725250244,
-0.5601300001,
-0.0800816864,
-0.2266115695,
0.0764888972,
0.7107265592,
0.351282984,
-0.6918449402,
0.9659001827,
-0.5295397043,
-0.3888462484,
-0.3881281316,
0.0948469862,
0.0064209192,
0.004432444,
0.4855291545,
-1.1684172153,
-0.412749052,
-0.1071316749,
-0.6506165862,
-0.0393004082,
0.3562953472,
0.0135111352,
-0.1759707481,
0.5387500525,
-0.6815851331,
0.0652706772,
0.7551282048,
-0.1183670014,
0.3878549039,
-0.2630295157,
-0.0338201672,
-1.0763342381,
0.0985201001,
-0.1020353362,
-0.3633918166,
-0.3169654608,
0.4080663323,
-0.1586097479,
-0.3078781664,
-0.4025610089,
0.6016472578,
-0.3249518275,
-0.0583465435,
-0.3403292894,
0.5311377645,
0.0435854606,
0.2074074894,
-0.0559475534,
1.0042507648,
0.3635224402,
-0.4423092604,
0.7934867144,
0.2530771494,
0.072214894,
0.272818625,
-0.6044549346,
0.3758015931,
0.1405332088,
0.5700489879,
-0.8735874295,
-0.3549854159,
-0.2342109531,
-0.2016503811,
-0.274885118,
-0.1070921347,
-0.8366297483,
-0.4273897409,
-0.5805510879,
0.4988024235,
-0.0399373583,
-0.8234118819,
0.4808181524,
0.3513910174,
-0.4057844281,
-0.3353605568,
-0.1300019622,
0.3571049571,
-0.0038549989,
-0.8973756433,
0.2736170888,
-0.4507490098,
-0.1092800349,
0.0945719406,
-0.0166172963,
-0.3338996768,
0.2256904989,
0.0898312405,
0.3763796687,
-0.0643554851,
0.198695913,
-0.3384879231,
0.1221644059,
-0.4021459818,
-0.0069690361,
0.8655260205,
-0.5685449839,
-0.310426563,
-0.0915983394,
0.4159751534,
0.6529084444,
-0.2009588182,
0.7305266857,
1.0436781645,
-0.003482515,
-0.1147250682,
-0.7351398468,
-0.429702878,
-0.5649279356,
0.4125280082,
-0.2030082345,
-1.5320997238,
0.5988745093,
-0.3699468672,
-0.4609626532,
0.2009890527,
0.7497121096,
-0.0214187317,
1.1223886013,
0.8075076342,
-0.1806388199,
0.5111188889,
-0.1487280577,
0.1613260955,
-0.5294417739,
-0.3025774956,
-0.5332334638,
-0.2990122736,
-0.6392885447,
-0.1926257014,
0.5026018023,
-0.3746503294,
0.1355772913,
0.4442670643,
-0.4998174906,
0.1452492625,
0.484457612,
0.1823905557,
0.1728806645,
-0.2661199272,
-0.2856370211,
-0.0999659523,
-0.5368534327,
-0.1007517129,
0.3605181873,
0.0168197304,
1.4162398577,
0.2542702258,
0.8417523503,
0.268126905,
-0.3073435426,
-1.0158663988,
0.76581496,
0.1274631172,
-0.8361355662,
-0.5502128005,
-0.3841553926,
-1.0707548857,
0.4124128222,
0.0511230826,
-0.7577059269,
-0.0387667008,
-0.3212127686,
0.2243378311,
0.0037355104,
-0.550114572,
0.7965610623,
-0.5819416642,
-0.4204680324,
-0.4327652752,
-0.4662401676,
0.1880412251,
-0.0526375957,
0.1431962401,
-0.1445425749,
-0.3360331357,
0.5515933633,
-0.6154538393,
0.6098143458,
0.03426883,
0.035819497,
0.0833068117,
0.4524946213,
0.8940794468,
0.2138772309,
-0.0300031267,
-0.3559092879,
0.016950598,
-0.2093399018,
-0.6650213003,
0.9029198289,
-0.6204015017,
-0.6117382646,
-0.2759223878,
-0.6521843672,
0.1938983798,
0.5123123527,
0.0310682897,
0.1436280161,
-0.3928897381,
0.4484342337,
0.3459210992,
0.0410587192,
0.3443346918,
0.8693966269,
-0.3087897003,
-0.0061804228,
0.8024843335,
-0.1298692673,
-0.3902015686,
0.4524213374,
0.3946450651,
-0.3107519746,
-0.1094267666,
-0.0251317769,
0.1531383544,
-0.5272403359,
0.1151232645,
-0.4836176932,
-0.0485257544,
-0.1186892837,
-0.4155082703,
-0.4328913093,
-0.1478914171,
-0.2751197219,
0.2775039375,
0.4611075521,
0.6354982853,
0.4167357087,
0.2236325443,
-0.6209566593,
0.301882416,
0.6342139244,
0.4405910075,
-0.0276292767,
-0.075898461,
-0.5156666636,
-0.3125146627,
-0.1700020581,
-0.6432064772,
0.2713636458,
0.0855010748,
0.8001118302,
0.0404674038,
0.2419576049,
0.5863780975,
-0.2829819024,
0.8089567423,
0.1692859381,
-0.6828346848,
0.2867299914,
-0.2849790752,
0.2462180108,
0.7379026413,
0.2359179109,
-0.6941898465,
-0.5201469064,
-0.4379630685,
-0.8797037005,
0.7518427372,
0.2474292666,
-0.1666263491,
0.3737537563,
-0.037662223,
0.2768017054,
0.2994835079,
-0.3556441367,
-0.0113993045,
-0.0005857459,
-0.0619842932,
-0.1874816865,
-0.0422553085,
-0.0446397997,
-0.0548371263,
0.4862594903,
-0.4261085391,
0.0836391374,
0.2065204829,
-0.3692477643,
-0.2299095243,
0.3415450752,
0.349806726,
0.3836648166,
-0.5127835274,
0.2708247006,
0.1052738801,
-0.4512150884,
0.2127842009,
0.4994801283,
0.118845351,
-0.0663808957,
-0.0211321507,
0.3836122453,
0.4502381384,
-0.8760707378,
0.8159351945,
-0.7550551295,
0.0776000172,
-0.4316842556,
0.0398636609,
0.3943195045,
0.430617094,
0.5339429379,
0.0044171233,
0.6109785438,
-0.5863233209,
0.2637891173,
0.6214613914,
-0.3505102992,
-0.3392432928,
0.5400688648,
0.3042132556,
-0.5625852346,
0.3453709483,
-0.3180894256,
-0.6885766387,
0.2583858967,
0.3327797949,
0.8268401623,
-0.0689480454,
0.1282633245,
-0.402450949,
0.1517169327,
-0.2989780903,
0.1404159218,
-0.2568058074,
-0.4222722054,
-0.3528686464,
-0.1652240753,
-0.832944572,
0.1088953838,
-0.229958564,
0.2686661482,
-0.0659267232,
-0.0566287711,
-0.0970201716,
0.4280915856,
-0.9262923598,
-0.0924276188,
-0.0140979718,
0.8159184456,
-0.3181689978,
0.4899946153,
0.8409909606,
-0.4182724655,
-0.7538937926,
-0.0539729446,
0.2422215492,
-0.6841595173,
0.348308742,
0.291077733,
-0.5387024879,
-0.2992197275,
-0.8920898438,
-0.7413858175,
1.4177775383,
0.6884347796,
-0.469484657,
-0.2849362791,
-0.1499885619,
0.6094465256,
-0.4153793454,
0.5665308833,
-0.1248362884,
0.2827234566,
0.2493295223,
-1.1990829706,
0.2221053392,
-0.2653696835,
-0.2033989877,
-0.2869434953,
-1.0717015266,
0.9702145457,
0.1415559798,
0.2363678217,
0.347158283,
0.2052064538,
0.4196078777,
0.609064579,
0.5065768361,
0.330820471,
0.7256929874,
0.3684349656,
0.8777936101,
-0.2638799846,
0.6110990047,
1.0562360287,
-0.6669267416,
0.6443042159,
0.3163849413,
0.1059471145,
0.4562512338,
0.2688879073,
0.1173815578,
0.3610568345,
-0.1556811482,
-0.5910434723,
-0.2818932831,
-0.2720546126,
-0.0936610326,
0.5077137351,
0.1763989478,
0.0217842385,
-0.4158747196,
-0.2771802545,
-0.130086109,
0.0133094424,
-0.1048355103,
0.7811327577,
0.0807982609,
-0.3722238243,
0.230927825,
0.0731204003,
0.8597679734,
-0.4801491201,
0.0569992475,
0.1539849043,
0.353825897,
-0.2321436256,
-0.5592460632,
-0.6210892797,
-0.4452761412,
-0.0057055373,
0.2376893759,
1.152695775,
-0.4130063653,
-0.2611607611,
0.8995134234,
0.7325648069,
0.1102994382,
-0.2054953277,
-0.9844289422,
0.474026233,
-0.499137789,
-0.2098977715,
0.3586987555,
0.5103811026,
0.0648012534,
0.8972014785,
0.4960233867,
-0.0987236798,
0.1136229113,
0.1867285371,
0.9714426994,
-0.4794381559,
-0.6817134619,
-0.4393001497,
-0.037578728,
0.0350544676,
0.490770787,
0.92369771,
0.8090010881,
0.6054419279,
0.0597014166,
0.8406933546,
0.0249907151,
0.4622694552,
0.0306798667,
0.6662740111,
-0.8677303195,
0.1724944264,
-0.2374233902,
-0.8056178093,
0.0606962293,
0.4315229654,
0.0885422081,
0.3101280928,
0.5377520919,
0.8467031717,
-0.4614987969,
0.0135309249,
0.3694939315,
0.0018065393,
0.6714937687,
0.3176644742,
0.8678566217,
-0.367100805,
0.8521560431,
0.0660030618,
0.0916086733,
-1.0335352421,
-0.3545101583,
-0.8288215399,
-0.4501464367,
0.2194621563,
-0.0426555537,
0.0789987966,
1.1604460478,
0.8417383432,
-0.2290806323,
-0.5003258586,
-0.0019888142,
0.0842815563,
-0.0416019037,
-0.2573210001,
-0.0646270663,
-0.3851541579,
-0.5375307202,
0.8853819966,
0.3787494302,
-0.2862076759,
-0.6049528718,
-0.6218699813,
-0.3132850528,
0.1011769176,
0.3031978607,
0.20588395,
-0.477594316,
-0.1549408883,
0.2048230469,
-0.3990897834,
0.04286718,
0.9083089232,
-0.7667379975,
0.8343185186,
0.3779210746,
0.4897706211,
0.9280242324,
-0.262531966,
0.4713107944,
-0.7708391547,
0.3131021559,
0.2448096275,
0.3384126127,
0.4330255985,
-0.5274951458,
0.3997744918,
0.1115785912,
-0.7337943316,
-0.5166563392,
-0.0703696236,
-1.1664559841,
-0.1681764871,
0.7242544889,
0.1465001255,
-0.2965940237,
-0.1726047993,
-0.5012287498,
0.2029471099,
-1.0767815113,
0.6511644721,
0.5349636078,
-0.1694337875,
-0.26823318,
-0.2966178358,
-0.008040485,
0.1985769123,
-0.4349424839,
-0.4320648611,
0.1906815171,
0.31854707,
0.4030783474,
0.7537155747,
0.2521727979,
0.5484080315,
-0.0362870134,
0.1584333181,
0.0294484515,
-0.08841075,
-0.0609957241,
0.3855439723,
0.364726454,
0.2377982438
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06342v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06342v1
|
Promoting Target Data in Context-aware Neural Machine Translation
| 2024-02-09T11:34:39 | 2024-02-09T11:34:39 |
Harritxu Gete, Thierry Etchegoyhen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Standard context-aware neural machine translation (NMT) typically relies on
parallel document-level data, exploiting both source and target contexts.
Concatenation-based approaches in particular, still a strong baseline for
document-level NMT, prepend source and/or target context sentences to the
sentences to be translated, with model variants that exploit equal amounts of
source and target data on each side achieving state-of-the-art results. In this
work, we investigate whether target data should be further promoted within
standard concatenation-based approaches, as most document-level phenomena rely
on information that is present on the target language side. We evaluate novel
concatenation-based variants where the target context is prepended to the
source language, either in isolation or in combination with the source context.
Experimental results in English-Russian and Basque-Spanish show that including
target context in the source leads to large improvements on target language
phenomena. On source-dependent phenomena, using only target language context in
the source achieves parity with state-of-the-art concatenation approaches, or
slightly underperforms, whereas combining source and target context on the
source side leads to significant gains across the board.
|
[
-0.2714655697,
-0.6281609535,
0.3338114619,
0.3685762882,
-0.5608948469,
-0.2425581068,
-0.5682483315,
-0.3191230893,
0.2079839706,
0.5065145493,
-0.2987178564,
-0.4363150597,
-0.7673174143,
0.0861915499,
-0.5580290556,
1.167424798,
-0.1679869592,
0.1768507063,
-0.2481373549,
-0.1997354031,
-1.0104243755,
-0.9204298258,
-0.6164867878,
-0.3812662661,
0.6820896864,
0.4676488638,
0.7621678114,
0.7490525246,
0.4875408113,
0.2243169844,
0.2121095508,
0.1958507597,
-0.1733748764,
0.4224754274,
-0.5237154961,
-0.3203884363,
-0.4358428121,
-0.080221191,
0.720099926,
0.8685531616,
0.147991389,
-0.0521746948,
0.3323534429,
0.5744799376,
-0.559961915,
0.0096853897,
-0.6312755346,
-0.0671454817,
-0.3283941448,
-0.3459587991,
-0.5041947365,
0.0507290736,
0.2082213759,
-0.4722789228,
0.0392496027,
-0.1854352951,
0.2877389491,
0.3560372591,
-0.8271192908,
-0.2973963022,
-0.7839878798,
0.729980588,
-0.6262406111,
0.4041412473,
0.1259405911,
0.3079996109,
-0.1995680928,
-0.6871595383,
-0.3015131652,
-0.3224101365,
-0.2981668413,
0.1169907302,
-0.1850987226,
-0.18301633,
0.275847435,
0.1597785354,
-0.4580674469,
-0.0409608744,
-0.2767518461,
-0.1012480482,
0.4232937694,
-0.0776973292,
0.2186089456,
-0.1373399198,
-0.6349859238,
-0.2431353778,
-0.7831203341,
-0.2224993259,
0.12916255,
0.6050440669,
-0.0668431073,
0.6194574833,
-0.2447183132,
0.8141181469,
0.1823491454,
0.4593945742,
0.2291021347,
-0.9057654142,
-0.1471990943,
0.3405663967,
0.8242530823,
0.5429947972,
0.0878064185,
-0.377292037,
-0.3054544926,
0.0002911873,
0.2871831059,
-0.7621623278,
0.2767334282,
0.0109179048,
-0.1220466569,
0.0328435004,
-0.2862342596,
-0.3539687991,
-0.2039301693,
-0.3393196464,
0.4938924909,
-0.6769071817,
-0.1407701075,
0.2279020399,
-0.0946742445,
0.0087652905,
0.232998386,
-0.9589751959,
0.1592119932,
0.7111406922,
0.5915174484,
-0.2144263536,
-0.4194820523,
-0.5365072489,
0.3356266022,
-0.3711379468,
0.4723132253,
-0.4417075217,
-0.2352644801,
-0.0618193783,
-0.1177757978,
-0.2468354702,
-0.4961326122,
0.7334210873,
-0.3055315614,
0.2587400675,
-0.4701487124,
-0.4123479426,
-0.1792316735,
0.3631903529,
-0.5531777143,
0.7186745405,
0.1858190596,
-0.5748313069,
0.3658861816,
-0.4951164424,
-0.8509727716,
-0.0324532017,
-0.2303188592,
-0.176847145,
0.1591502428,
0.2018158138,
0.6442993879,
-0.3057094812,
0.85374856,
0.2865823507,
-0.3066348135,
0.0795248449,
-0.6364554167,
0.2852919102,
0.2015132159,
-0.5829370618,
0.0758251101,
-0.4396615922,
-0.328296572,
-0.0272692461,
-0.3800188303,
-0.6152511835,
0.0220929235,
0.1055167913,
0.4143040776,
0.283505857,
-0.4212753773,
0.3343264759,
-0.2550251782,
0.130943656,
0.2161059082,
0.019993525,
0.76600945,
-0.3093004227,
0.4134555459,
0.1732403636,
-0.0331661515,
-0.2390043736,
-0.4010108411,
-0.5125772953,
0.0706035346,
0.2543668449,
0.403385818,
-1.0180618763,
0.1810359806,
-0.5180670023,
-0.3731049299,
-0.4361415803,
-0.0474319682,
0.6977573633,
1.1284406185,
0.7116677761,
-0.108039394,
-0.7587003112,
-1.1250064373,
-0.4143036008,
0.3507738411,
0.1012816131,
0.0434009098,
0.0954539403,
-0.0538845323,
0.6175755262,
-0.0200050939,
-0.2150479406,
-0.3934304714,
-0.0775026903,
0.3046144247,
1.0573199987,
0.5540752411,
-1.193911314,
-0.6807676554,
0.2576134801,
-0.711981535,
0.2105133086,
-0.3830118179,
-0.054094553,
-0.1185597703,
0.5666383505,
-0.4616676271,
0.1591142863,
0.6415308714,
-0.1789085567,
0.2474948615,
-0.127740249,
0.3427321017,
-1.6396462917,
0.0368407555,
-0.0860923752,
-0.1632517278,
-1.074742794,
-0.0304098837,
0.2254459858,
-0.0512015261,
-0.8025739193,
0.305660516,
-0.3301618993,
0.0231396593,
-0.2818424702,
-0.1899828315,
-0.058977969,
0.3065273166,
0.2129993737,
0.7265422344,
0.2833451629,
-0.4434635937,
0.0614690743,
0.1538890898,
-0.0735108331,
0.4168005586,
-0.5583295226,
0.0835618675,
-0.0550003573,
0.3472831249,
-0.5456787348,
-0.1423882693,
0.3825216889,
-0.6137690544,
0.4854659438,
-0.1966716349,
-0.5567352176,
0.2632334828,
-0.1085283682,
0.5974029303,
0.3094010353,
-0.3232801557,
0.1840899587,
-0.0341714993,
0.2393669784,
-0.7401607037,
-1.0873394012,
0.3057970703,
-0.3390247226,
-0.6674348712,
0.5736939907,
0.171867013,
0.1958307922,
-0.0176586192,
-0.1272744685,
0.2436966598,
0.0576943643,
0.0429159552,
0.0486973487,
-0.395244509,
0.001381099,
0.1152094677,
-0.1645373106,
0.0016330583,
-0.6981114149,
0.689638555,
0.0146645755,
-0.2658503056,
-0.1994455606,
0.7892205119,
0.4192177653,
-0.3238351941,
0.9983940125,
0.4987631738,
-0.5325793624,
-0.2038446814,
-0.1712577641,
-0.2584966421,
-0.4483135939,
0.3496448994,
-0.6029990911,
-0.7798611522,
0.2868826389,
-0.1631139517,
-0.1764014214,
0.4068687558,
0.4749227762,
-0.1653103083,
0.8247029185,
0.5771011114,
0.1230958402,
0.6466132402,
-0.3865650296,
0.1521037519,
-1.0830723047,
-0.2435896844,
-0.3344577551,
-0.5874571204,
-0.644798398,
-0.4569555223,
0.2374296039,
0.0864905342,
0.0867523551,
1.0725164413,
-0.550529778,
0.123974368,
0.604852438,
0.1364798844,
0.2238227725,
-0.1718162745,
-0.1244564205,
-0.3108885288,
-0.9179872274,
-0.2991400361,
1.1666802168,
-0.0575461127,
0.2770158052,
-0.0198396295,
0.763053,
0.0699633136,
0.2943278849,
-0.6712323427,
0.4366887808,
-0.4246384501,
-0.5986227393,
-0.1824746132,
-0.2091746777,
-1.1077444553,
0.3430393636,
-0.1618947089,
-0.4589124024,
0.4786206484,
0.293866396,
0.0013868492,
0.0147903189,
-0.8180593252,
1.1221624613,
-0.1514941901,
-0.3409714699,
-0.0114540495,
-0.7031516433,
0.2066245079,
-0.1935805082,
-0.0226411428,
0.2226059437,
-0.281524837,
0.4891315401,
-0.2928733826,
0.6101958156,
0.0282514617,
-0.0532009751,
0.0624438375,
0.0390443653,
0.792769134,
-0.0349602625,
-0.256167382,
0.064583078,
-0.4170834422,
-0.3336639404,
-0.8660793304,
0.8157622814,
-0.3221237957,
-0.7026644349,
-0.2933981419,
-0.9221214056,
-0.339908272,
0.4264010191,
0.4504666328,
0.4581872821,
0.1313814223,
0.7296633124,
0.3990713656,
0.1136654168,
0.3292144537,
0.5589954853,
0.2156148553,
-0.3371240199,
0.8532091379,
0.2635531127,
0.6284352541,
0.5479524732,
0.1299223751,
-0.1808983684,
-0.9339293242,
-0.5230590105,
-0.0546149388,
-0.61241889,
-0.2326913923,
-0.6387443542,
-0.0668537617,
-0.4864866734,
-0.435908556,
-0.53885746,
-0.3818070292,
0.0825273693,
-0.0334924087,
0.0563815124,
0.2164278924,
-0.0679456666,
0.4208347499,
-0.758664012,
0.0784150064,
-0.1841471195,
-0.0078113317,
-0.3320564628,
-0.2512546778,
-0.6289499998,
0.2277779877,
-0.0570358858,
-1.0565991402,
0.3758255839,
-0.0722709969,
0.4604319334,
-0.0918689445,
0.0618440211,
0.456846416,
-0.6645815372,
0.5335440636,
0.1297446042,
-0.7654448748,
0.7005832195,
-0.7434408665,
0.3966795206,
0.6821824312,
0.4565623403,
-0.7471752763,
-0.5151618719,
-0.5825935602,
-0.7971145511,
0.6421623826,
0.334613204,
0.364726305,
-0.2382012904,
0.1899456531,
0.071906656,
0.366234988,
-0.5478320718,
-0.1452349722,
-0.0352631398,
-0.3060807586,
-0.3403493464,
0.2033490241,
0.0598155111,
-0.1714182794,
0.2732116878,
-0.1412823647,
-0.1467147171,
0.4008396864,
-0.2103127092,
0.1242186129,
0.3532298207,
0.5396747589,
0.2652532458,
-0.3502582312,
0.2892850041,
0.0820855647,
-0.403409183,
0.1791688502,
0.1172613949,
-0.7473979592,
0.1889151335,
0.2891969979,
0.7699457407,
0.5648967028,
-0.2567647099,
0.4442429543,
0.2540026605,
-0.055724889,
0.133889541,
-0.0927547514,
0.328527689,
0.1881931424,
0.2510048151,
0.3885384798,
0.3316283226,
-0.7257989049,
0.4564208984,
0.3640520573,
-0.3136433959,
-0.3304145336,
0.695161283,
0.148759678,
-0.2824349105,
0.3188656569,
0.1153076142,
-0.4455012381,
0.739951849,
0.9882115722,
0.8328064084,
-0.3390046656,
0.0065542432,
0.3674957156,
0.522826612,
-0.1384579539,
0.1517101824,
-0.3082216978,
-0.6639844179,
-0.472891748,
-0.2032278627,
-0.3394480944,
0.0543756522,
-0.745017767,
0.420207113,
-0.1055907309,
-0.1163698733,
-0.0347926095,
-0.1998916566,
-0.5517226458,
0.3826977015,
0.0782739818,
1.0050976276,
-0.6608531475,
1.2267122269,
0.7361294031,
-0.5257351398,
-0.6874770522,
0.0931046158,
-0.3074990511,
-0.2939115763,
0.5186650753,
0.1648075283,
0.070043385,
0.142634958,
-0.1954931319,
-1.0113161802,
1.0819442272,
0.7739380598,
-0.4952514172,
-0.013836164,
0.4629471898,
0.53426373,
-0.6727240682,
-0.2912825048,
0.4499967694,
0.4367711544,
0.0164179169,
-0.7766096592,
0.48959589,
-0.1953604817,
0.0845812857,
0.3269402385,
-0.4668014646,
0.8318411112,
0.3072254062,
-0.3418951035,
-0.441374898,
0.6396598816,
-0.0728609562,
0.2863917053,
0.3405625224,
0.2457990646,
0.2410334051,
0.0183373671,
1.2659835815,
-0.2247221321,
-0.0596350394,
1.4971768856,
0.0062317979,
0.9151000977,
0.7963417768,
0.2990746498,
0.0494104028,
0.4384291172,
0.1802282631,
0.6837691665,
0.1173537076,
-0.1768306643,
0.0808901116,
-0.454094708,
-0.5511232615,
0.381857276,
0.4265655279,
-0.5393392444,
-0.4012818336,
0.2010965347,
0.3575043082,
0.3191387951,
-0.0116344709,
0.6025671959,
0.2340270132,
-1.186624527,
0.9767968059,
0.0302073844,
0.7046433091,
-0.6302616,
0.0739828721,
-0.4865820706,
0.1402795017,
-0.1536515355,
-0.659447968,
0.8487352133,
0.0664629489,
-0.2579274178,
-0.6585597396,
0.6363523006,
-0.7747200131,
-0.1982454062,
0.3724407554,
0.4207831323,
0.01026267,
-0.3199327886,
-0.3394636512,
-0.0049763788,
-0.008026124,
-0.1571108401,
0.6277179122,
0.3005315661,
-0.391166091,
0.2106393278,
0.7204030752,
0.0614065528,
0.180332616,
-0.102493003,
1.0331990719,
-0.4813275039,
-0.1039339453,
-0.8581704497,
0.8007011414,
-0.0306863654,
-0.3569075465,
0.9982489347,
0.6619758606,
1.0010299683,
-0.0600541085,
0.5951420069,
0.0671677962,
-0.0283320062,
-0.4876860976,
0.6753719449,
-0.4592567384,
0.0555032045,
0.1081180871,
-1.0631619692,
-0.2819220424,
-0.1021978632,
-0.223350659,
-0.3817942142,
0.727104485,
0.5209522247,
-0.2477050275,
-0.4022272825,
0.4497764111,
-0.2577272654,
0.1489911675,
0.9353896379,
0.5929589868,
-0.7306867838,
0.5982294083,
-0.3788213134,
-0.1533364356,
-0.0872773752,
-0.9111642838,
-0.4992868304,
-0.7167490125,
-0.2111882865,
-0.2840176821,
0.2513267696,
0.8332424164,
0.7091168165,
-0.7804051042,
-0.0127176875,
-0.2711186111,
0.0190390311,
-0.1970596611,
-0.0663740337,
0.2345396578,
-0.5461212397,
-1.0072922707,
1.0681068897,
0.1655731797,
0.0197902694,
0.0238998886,
-0.1137258634,
-0.3508502841,
0.0215049349,
0.4398650527,
0.1953213215,
-0.363709271,
-0.0696120709,
0.1929863393,
-0.3532414138,
0.0266141221,
0.7999724746,
-0.6241237521,
0.5144472122,
0.5480934381,
0.9986234903,
0.4031020999,
0.153434366,
1.2376039028,
-1.1572036743,
0.5272765756,
0.436680913,
0.3389167786,
0.5007493496,
-0.5984926224,
0.5497090816,
0.1075173467,
-0.067598626,
-0.696189642,
0.261690855,
-0.9266782999,
-0.1111349165,
1.1500191689,
-0.2206760794,
-0.1377102733,
0.3150752783,
-0.0598788224,
0.5791915655,
-0.1490176618,
0.1541011781,
0.6644573212,
0.1798460186,
0.2098662257,
-0.7114284039,
0.6043809652,
0.7418651581,
-0.5937625766,
-0.2261147648,
0.2696902752,
-0.0676443428,
0.2283231914,
0.4756810069,
-0.1165755466,
0.3297287822,
-0.0076326085,
-0.1194658428,
-0.1147467941,
-0.2896181941,
-0.5334390998,
-0.090251945,
-0.3287059665,
-0.6048673391
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06341v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06341v1
|
RareBench: Can LLMs Serve as Rare Diseases Specialists?
| 2024-02-09T11:34:16 | 2024-02-09T11:34:16 |
Xuanzhong Chen, Xiaohao Mao, Qihan Guo, Lun Wang, Shuyang Zhang, Ting Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Generalist Large Language Models (LLMs), such as GPT-4, have shown
considerable promise in various domains, including medical diagnosis. Rare
diseases, affecting approximately 300 million people worldwide, often have
unsatisfactory clinical diagnosis rates primarily due to a lack of experienced
physicians and the complexity of differentiating among many rare diseases. In
this context, recent news such as "ChatGPT correctly diagnosed a 4-year-old's
rare disease after 17 doctors failed" underscore LLMs' potential, yet
underexplored, role in clinically diagnosing rare diseases. To bridge this
research gap, we introduce RareBench, a pioneering benchmark designed to
systematically evaluate the capabilities of LLMs on 4 critical dimensions
within the realm of rare diseases. Meanwhile, we have compiled the largest
open-source dataset on rare disease patients, establishing a benchmark for
future studies in this domain. To facilitate differential diagnosis of rare
diseases, we develop a dynamic few-shot prompt methodology, leveraging a
comprehensive rare disease knowledge graph synthesized from multiple knowledge
bases, significantly enhancing LLMs' diagnostic performance. Moreover, we
present an exhaustive comparative study of GPT-4's diagnostic capabilities
against those of specialist physicians. Our experimental findings underscore
the promising potential of integrating LLMs into the clinical diagnostic
process for rare diseases. This paves the way for exciting possibilities in
future advancements in this field.
|
[
-0.3715851009,
-0.5927057266,
0.841196537,
-0.0333128348,
-0.469750911,
0.3201904893,
-0.2197171599,
-0.5836477876,
0.2938518524,
0.4117442369,
-0.633415401,
-0.7408120036,
-0.5639784336,
0.3055191338,
-0.313429147,
0.8331341147,
0.0862761587,
0.2443990856,
0.0557482876,
-0.3222663701,
-0.1597703546,
-0.4791445732,
-0.6030125618,
-0.2909995019,
0.5090923905,
0.5801497102,
0.7024829984,
0.4191194773,
0.7283576727,
0.2162655443,
-0.1346652061,
0.0624847151,
-0.5522180796,
0.2303572446,
-0.1366318613,
-0.4980983138,
-0.8460826874,
0.1024807096,
0.5905740261,
1.1960777044,
0.1130183637,
-0.3903995454,
-0.01338642,
0.5634127259,
0.1232954115,
-0.1356175691,
-0.3613012433,
0.6339983344,
-0.672334075,
-0.0788280293,
0.0547699332,
-0.3277704716,
0.0089204721,
-0.6386053562,
0.650574863,
-0.1506094486,
0.4621106088,
0.3036090136,
-0.4641429484,
0.133286953,
-0.5608734488,
0.5004245043,
-0.5585516691,
0.1396342814,
-0.0458267555,
0.6144263744,
-0.1996573061,
-0.9408899546,
-0.2607878745,
-0.4325551391,
0.266333878,
0.1145105436,
-0.3003387153,
-0.0372479856,
0.3642141521,
0.539088726,
-1.0055027008,
0.6091672182,
-0.1534115821,
-0.2651643753,
0.1826948673,
0.6191443205,
0.1882408857,
-0.0082471548,
-0.0809497461,
0.4218839407,
-0.9081214666,
-0.5772084594,
0.0633507371,
0.3145084381,
-0.1436684132,
0.3062285781,
-0.5223630667,
0.7502117753,
-0.0107839722,
0.0076050824,
0.548622191,
-0.1359533668,
0.2610374391,
-0.18107678,
0.669058919,
0.424013108,
0.2401003838,
-0.221132651,
-0.0573593974,
-0.0225204416,
-0.0574167408,
-0.7724531293,
-0.4190149903,
-0.0144135244,
-0.5836991668,
-0.2931369245,
-0.4659177661,
-0.8245947361,
-0.6483860612,
0.1997699738,
0.0161024947,
-0.1400429606,
-0.4030016065,
-0.1345249861,
-0.1012456194,
-0.2255669832,
0.2795656025,
-0.7967169285,
0.5233355165,
0.3873845339,
0.5890606642,
-0.6818457842,
-0.1229573414,
-0.733042419,
-0.0752447397,
-0.336915493,
0.8965322971,
-0.6463248134,
-0.5852032304,
-0.2982312143,
-0.0032501118,
0.2414608449,
-0.8496873975,
0.2974482775,
-0.3449768722,
-0.3737384081,
-0.3801617026,
-0.2218631953,
0.1658300757,
0.3889666796,
-0.6917570829,
0.5871710777,
0.4251477718,
-0.6355959773,
0.4013450444,
-0.2861213386,
-0.0782311037,
0.5528521538,
-0.5304865837,
-0.2263148427,
0.1426452249,
0.1118177548,
0.6017469764,
-0.5233001709,
0.0512139723,
-0.5537798405,
-0.2884554267,
0.1834846735,
-0.5888825059,
0.1361936033,
0.1398614794,
-0.1106739417,
-0.2902666926,
-0.7153369784,
0.2782430649,
0.2372409552,
-0.241192162,
0.0787282288,
-0.1397945881,
-0.236581862,
-0.0833778903,
0.2657339573,
-0.1978690177,
0.6011499166,
-0.6303192377,
0.0784543678,
0.4167159498,
0.206185177,
0.0167036727,
-0.2184966952,
0.8479827642,
0.2704131007,
0.0379913524,
0.1947219819,
-0.7637214661,
-0.3774138093,
-0.2757285535,
0.4000609517,
0.4988699257,
-0.3827842176,
0.0328599028,
-0.2242266387,
-0.4233537018,
-0.1968558878,
0.244427681,
0.1603250802,
0.4287190735,
0.2300547361,
-0.5171801448,
-0.2213762254,
-0.9411831498,
-0.5500113368,
0.2776092291,
-0.1028006971,
0.5232081413,
0.1077013612,
-0.5728073716,
0.5540946126,
-0.4730834067,
-0.4021818638,
-0.5195162892,
0.0689694434,
0.6629679203,
0.2909639776,
0.7560071349,
-0.3039624095,
-0.6324391365,
0.2973151207,
-0.9246279597,
-0.4615118802,
0.4604335427,
0.4936331511,
-0.0718770921,
0.4624533653,
-0.4984121621,
0.2983283103,
0.6350648403,
-0.1713511199,
0.3667199314,
-0.2823559046,
0.1147141084,
-0.5046039224,
-0.0377168395,
-0.275565207,
-0.4504473209,
-0.300552249,
-0.1546566188,
-0.0881771892,
-0.210050866,
-0.1535292417,
0.3458558321,
-0.353672117,
-0.3615405858,
-0.1604874134,
0.3884415925,
-0.2411396503,
-0.0979601517,
-0.2488026619,
0.316721797,
0.8689633012,
-0.4346656501,
0.5777770877,
-0.2953424156,
-0.132228896,
0.7160349488,
-0.680352211,
0.1741214246,
0.3787210286,
0.2870505452,
-0.6937821507,
-0.2714608312,
0.2864337265,
-0.435117811,
0.5696324706,
-0.3124086559,
-0.8290699124,
-0.8384689689,
0.1349902898,
0.4358092546,
0.3542194366,
-0.2752549946,
0.4493987262,
0.1709869653,
-0.5307205915,
-0.4522034526,
-0.9120009542,
0.0519992858,
-0.0786696598,
-0.4462763369,
0.2078762949,
-0.205445677,
-0.3087846041,
0.1781474799,
-0.2680411041,
-0.2955801487,
0.2317783237,
0.0789571255,
0.0236625616,
-0.5076882243,
0.1876794696,
-0.0399387293,
-0.6198864579,
-0.3289457262,
-0.0746887699,
0.4626368284,
-0.4362764657,
-0.9039387703,
-0.1286702901,
0.4596652687,
0.2944544554,
0.0724937245,
0.0673029348,
0.4045064151,
-0.2000525743,
-0.1435429007,
-0.4501754045,
-0.0670218468,
-0.4689402878,
0.4833038151,
-0.4747345746,
-0.9288457632,
0.6920018196,
-0.4445743263,
-0.2743937075,
0.4930102527,
0.6852010489,
0.1633124501,
1.0510573387,
0.8286768794,
0.0014820581,
-0.2301183343,
-0.0874434486,
0.4276720881,
-0.3648076355,
0.0219157524,
-0.2959559262,
-0.2859960496,
-0.8236901164,
-0.4906492829,
0.8038672805,
-0.0091092158,
0.078161791,
-0.3561309576,
-0.702372849,
0.8352063298,
0.0540473051,
0.0061652251,
0.553532362,
-0.2313912064,
-0.5429891348,
-0.3669391572,
-0.8379160166,
-0.4679551423,
1.3932642937,
0.2736057639,
0.5910724401,
0.13684012,
0.9515275955,
0.3520905077,
0.4869968891,
-0.857445538,
0.5690582395,
-0.4085107446,
-0.707267344,
-0.0098745488,
-0.4875459969,
-1.0108453035,
0.2806903124,
0.1658474356,
-0.7600795031,
0.0229532383,
0.2576195896,
-0.4884845614,
0.2449030131,
-0.505263567,
1.0515884161,
-0.4302285314,
-0.2429316938,
-0.4976219535,
-0.669370532,
0.4661972225,
-0.3452153802,
0.174910292,
-0.3139604628,
-0.2162536681,
0.826818049,
-0.2444263995,
0.9430370331,
-0.3056615293,
0.1977459192,
-0.2604761124,
0.1088622138,
0.2481940091,
0.2404640615,
-0.06560193,
0.1841361225,
-0.0034976637,
-0.3601334989,
-0.3922263086,
1.1809625626,
-0.724834621,
-0.5891815424,
-0.684546411,
-0.3577171564,
-0.8252344131,
0.4737155735,
0.1233520284,
0.3004303277,
-0.588891983,
-0.1434139162,
0.7681936026,
-0.1009163633,
0.2285757959,
1.0099465847,
0.1028939784,
-0.0757503733,
0.731559217,
0.1791680753,
0.0975494534,
0.0874467939,
0.1714657992,
0.2151892185,
-0.9950937629,
-0.1366932839,
0.4187617898,
-1.0536419153,
-0.1186164171,
-0.7614617944,
-0.0704612955,
-0.0340072773,
-0.2604572177,
-0.4379070401,
-0.4455790222,
-0.4626487494,
-0.0754977837,
0.5426849723,
0.9398918152,
-0.5130224228,
0.2230469137,
-0.8667236567,
0.6642248631,
0.400726825,
0.475179553,
-0.1626114249,
-0.5074917674,
-0.0213072021,
-0.1927105635,
-0.2301188409,
-0.7608937621,
0.4131320119,
-0.0432258546,
1.108678937,
0.6071022749,
-0.0773472488,
0.467178762,
-0.4252687693,
0.8027843833,
0.2196758091,
-0.5634918213,
0.2998099029,
-0.4096520841,
0.1031470299,
0.5168630481,
0.4518110752,
-0.470731914,
-0.3443078101,
-0.8189589381,
-0.7900484204,
0.6225046515,
-0.2309118658,
-0.0537381284,
-0.01412181,
0.1143311262,
0.3105564713,
-0.0336675085,
-0.5053610802,
-0.2542557716,
-0.053874854,
-0.1353928745,
-0.3327051997,
-0.250505507,
-0.3584592342,
-0.3459116817,
0.0470353812,
-0.234112829,
0.2359865755,
0.0064545185,
-0.002697336,
-0.1545842886,
0.3057304025,
0.3116703629,
0.6682963371,
-0.1182689071,
0.0767244995,
0.445920527,
-0.3922210634,
-0.0156745184,
0.549121201,
0.4512370527,
0.0465607792,
0.2591858804,
0.2280498296,
0.4176244438,
-0.6666567922,
0.7273379564,
-0.0283577647,
-0.1963628083,
-0.1971318722,
0.1234957427,
0.317736268,
0.4464223981,
0.4340469539,
0.0696874931,
-0.0379261486,
-0.336584419,
0.2901543677,
0.3838994205,
-0.1782567352,
-0.3756224811,
0.5455450416,
0.6235346794,
-0.2335651666,
0.6956464648,
-0.4088754952,
-0.2957353294,
0.7052572966,
0.345344305,
0.6016924381,
0.0378872305,
-0.1224946752,
-0.1937715113,
0.3140168786,
-0.0380777754,
0.15427652,
0.117701672,
-0.5645929575,
-0.1707499176,
-0.262122184,
-0.533854425,
0.311632514,
-0.2991670072,
0.2517791986,
-0.5488442183,
-0.1945277601,
0.1695431173,
0.2329464853,
-0.7812199593,
-0.0585396737,
0.1742380708,
0.6162522435,
-0.728684783,
0.7014986277,
0.3252589107,
-0.2562787533,
-0.3680377007,
0.2029478252,
0.3349657953,
-1.0117099285,
0.8445128202,
0.1364404857,
0.1499922425,
0.2384467423,
-0.5541619062,
-0.6744635701,
0.8522830009,
0.1199734509,
-0.9337291718,
0.1441654712,
0.028670948,
0.713026464,
-0.3160848022,
0.1826735139,
0.6854816675,
0.6551528573,
0.0821671113,
-1.3148905039,
0.0658552274,
-0.1806412041,
-0.3408608139,
0.0487384684,
-0.4556003511,
0.8282980919,
-0.5987861156,
0.0800056085,
0.2941238582,
0.130113855,
0.4171200693,
0.4088359177,
0.061380405,
0.7784361839,
0.96009624,
-0.0581120104,
1.1305553913,
-0.3808111846,
-0.0064123762,
0.5444716811,
-0.4393368661,
0.4654188454,
0.0671241805,
-0.3051647544,
0.1160320789,
0.6656351686,
-0.2211100161,
0.4390256703,
0.2434571087,
-0.3121396899,
-0.5608173609,
0.2611518502,
-0.7778759599,
0.0776301622,
0.6539183259,
-0.3231242895,
-0.5138030648,
-0.1905350536,
-0.1615734547,
-0.235038355,
-0.2598595917,
0.4472630918,
0.302152127,
-0.105147332,
0.8964381218,
-0.1714952737,
0.5395838022,
-0.666126132,
0.0085926848,
-0.3640640676,
0.4337292612,
-0.1655257195,
-0.8743716478,
0.1665518135,
0.0705839023,
-0.2611347139,
0.0690547749,
0.5988307595,
0.0752211064,
-0.3309987485,
0.1399540305,
1.000240922,
0.6458652616,
0.0517678373,
-0.6702606082,
0.2132111639,
-0.1929464191,
0.0409067385,
0.3836058378,
0.8714137077,
-0.1531646997,
0.7089232206,
0.2250827998,
0.2292759418,
-0.2725280821,
0.3932733536,
1.0295951366,
-0.7817035913,
-0.2263087034,
-0.5727422833,
0.1453693062,
-0.0206208322,
-0.239882037,
0.5241060853,
0.356761992,
0.3825821579,
-0.0230409876,
0.9566711783,
0.205504179,
0.7902600765,
-0.1296389997,
0.6230359674,
-0.6085035205,
0.3719135523,
-0.1805665493,
-0.5202952623,
-0.6556542516,
0.2727710009,
-0.3996336758,
0.2725826204,
0.9658461809,
0.761457324,
-0.2954689562,
-0.3242996335,
0.6175810099,
0.5702983141,
0.2866285741,
0.6447386146,
0.9048235416,
0.3348968625,
0.6755692363,
0.1211630479,
-0.3786951005,
-0.5973817706,
-0.778047502,
-0.9966167808,
0.1476500332,
-0.2800522745,
0.0725064576,
0.3702958524,
0.4939082563,
0.6034713387,
-0.5510182977,
0.2492946833,
-0.1681031883,
0.0959993973,
-0.2320179939,
-0.1666585803,
0.0672026947,
0.0351030119,
-0.4112187624,
0.7825853825,
0.339399159,
0.2780797482,
-0.2141174972,
0.2762443721,
0.6161206961,
-0.4992084503,
0.2694847584,
0.4715183973,
-0.7578687668,
0.1061556488,
-0.1939614713,
-0.1968798041,
0.0167188179,
0.8475624323,
-1.0896319151,
0.2079411447,
0.3499204218,
0.4228106439,
0.5381960273,
-0.362180233,
0.4735613763,
-0.3705225587,
0.2822943628,
0.9279061556,
0.2567673028,
0.3682014346,
-0.281349957,
0.3961696029,
0.7014855146,
-0.5610150099,
-0.7742387652,
0.1313372403,
-1.1595364809,
-0.1811368316,
1.1811693907,
-0.0745381415,
0.1549625546,
-0.4930855334,
0.1548028439,
-0.0099808304,
-0.3645132184,
0.5287783146,
0.2392455339,
-0.54937464,
-0.0503553897,
-0.7827997208,
0.347677052,
0.4781705439,
-0.6605963111,
-0.0919782743,
0.4992150366,
0.7619239688,
-0.2642979026,
1.0458467007,
-0.2148874849,
0.5129500628,
0.015239967,
-0.1758953333,
0.0453564487,
0.0644820407,
-0.2490861118,
0.0007291519,
0.3669077754,
0.1107224002
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06334v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06334v1
|
ExaRanker-Open: Synthetic Explanation for IR using Open-Source LLMs
| 2024-02-09T11:23:14 | 2024-02-09T11:23:14 |
Fernando Ferraretto, Thiago Laitz, Roberto Lotufo, Rodrigo Nogueira
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
ExaRanker recently introduced an approach to training information retrieval
(IR) models, incorporating natural language explanations as additional labels.
The method addresses the challenge of limited labeled examples, leading to
improvements in the effectiveness of IR models. However, the initial results
were based on proprietary language models such as GPT-3.5, which posed
constraints on dataset size due to its cost and data privacy. In this paper, we
introduce ExaRanker-Open, where we adapt and explore the use of open-source
language models to generate explanations. The method has been tested using
different LLMs and datasets sizes to better comprehend the effective
contribution of data augmentation. Our findings reveal that incorporating
explanations consistently enhances neural rankers, with benefits escalating as
the LLM size increases. Notably, the data augmentation method proves
advantageous even with large datasets, as evidenced by ExaRanker surpassing the
target baseline by 0.6 nDCG@10 points in our study. To encourage further
advancements by the research community, we have open-sourced both the code and
datasets at https://github.com/unicamp-dl/ExaRanker.
|
[
-0.237539053,
-0.6382784843,
0.407281965,
-0.1910843402,
-0.3350657225,
-0.1250705719,
-0.4655164778,
-0.5816265345,
0.2723332047,
0.2706166804,
-0.334453851,
-0.4776761532,
-0.2573743761,
0.0692823157,
-0.3779062927,
1.1892129183,
-0.3122659028,
0.1977335215,
-0.305826515,
-0.1968692094,
-0.2060750574,
-0.4439820945,
-0.5609199405,
-0.3246000111,
0.7516059875,
0.6112718582,
0.7713852525,
0.9599909186,
0.6169750094,
0.2768771648,
0.011429606,
0.1708277166,
-0.5483561754,
0.3878339827,
-0.2022557408,
-0.479470998,
-0.2379837036,
0.0382790603,
0.6385515332,
0.6754422784,
-0.1927122325,
0.1842099577,
-0.0222816486,
0.8180924654,
-0.5894382596,
0.1740536988,
-0.5365073681,
0.1387119144,
-0.0270608887,
-0.4685868323,
-0.5319011807,
-0.5673807263,
0.210515812,
-0.7573885322,
0.3566812873,
0.2336087823,
0.6722338796,
0.3830630183,
-0.2605444491,
-0.0540822335,
-0.8728017807,
0.5525602102,
-0.4114999175,
0.2646118701,
0.2210964561,
0.7522970438,
-0.2255881131,
-0.8544072509,
-0.4659214318,
-0.3400762081,
-0.3303371072,
0.1167736202,
-0.3453394771,
0.2785795331,
0.2117407918,
0.8506615162,
-0.7369596362,
0.182641387,
-0.4588629305,
0.1811061651,
0.2847010493,
-0.0999999046,
0.1206060648,
0.2285020053,
-0.3352677822,
-0.0913503617,
-0.8741810918,
-0.0732331723,
0.5955594778,
0.2062964439,
0.1070948392,
1.0121017694,
-0.2850198448,
0.800026536,
-0.2540664375,
0.5286327004,
0.0479417033,
-0.2724944651,
-0.2824679315,
0.2404031903,
0.5610744953,
0.163085565,
0.1659092009,
-0.2862367928,
-0.0980683938,
-0.2190426439,
0.0238891151,
-0.704157114,
-0.3420787752,
0.3406661749,
-0.5214270353,
-0.2517957687,
0.1936673671,
-0.7312764525,
-0.5380920172,
-0.5462968946,
0.6257904172,
-0.3846407533,
-0.3382957578,
0.0286246464,
-0.2525095344,
0.2832357287,
0.3641804159,
-0.7580397129,
0.2119529247,
0.5989437699,
0.9095608592,
-0.1730159074,
0.0245763436,
-0.7293635607,
0.1519977301,
-0.2939216495,
0.722235024,
-0.6096614003,
-0.002716826,
-0.1744932383,
-0.1658486724,
0.2083745748,
-0.597602129,
0.1545150578,
-0.589928031,
0.5988976359,
0.1156227216,
-0.4544326663,
-0.1561677009,
0.1729253829,
-0.783470273,
1.2251694202,
0.1418555975,
-0.6930179,
0.2270709425,
-1.0520112514,
-0.0893587023,
0.1189916059,
-0.1553296,
-0.1859676242,
0.4774994552,
0.2046495229,
-0.0098452354,
-0.3369730115,
0.3640979826,
-0.1277264059,
-0.3223984838,
0.4389439523,
-0.3954339623,
0.6761400104,
0.3065876961,
-0.2279497385,
0.4198328555,
-0.6532974243,
0.2157960087,
-0.0334877037,
-0.2532495856,
-0.438660264,
-0.1448643059,
-0.4321399331,
-0.0821584836,
0.2854380906,
-0.6101124287,
0.1793872565,
-0.4014109969,
0.1623059809,
0.8664917946,
-0.1476628482,
0.4305190742,
-0.1785280704,
0.7483115792,
-0.2215737402,
0.2690623403,
-0.4927658737,
-0.363437444,
-0.6542118192,
-0.3734504282,
0.447073251,
0.1698136479,
-0.7643008828,
0.0664575398,
-0.4264335632,
-0.4122003913,
-0.678366363,
-0.1087575257,
0.3667296469,
0.4349281788,
0.5624960661,
-0.0000771932,
-0.8437156677,
-1.06696105,
-0.5597631931,
-0.2420631349,
-0.2560491562,
0.3350135684,
0.4084258676,
0.1137562543,
1.1272946596,
-0.4741562307,
-0.1005260944,
-0.1812460423,
0.141677916,
0.3652841151,
0.3629348278,
0.1050881073,
-0.8717705607,
-0.4657028019,
0.2277291119,
-0.8651176691,
-0.0443118848,
0.0942052677,
-0.1648513079,
0.1156906709,
0.5320016146,
-0.3834672272,
0.3964307606,
0.4383779466,
-0.2330673784,
0.5657904744,
-0.4386228323,
-0.0737108067,
-0.9180179834,
0.2416623384,
0.002236747,
-0.2137200534,
-0.6914729476,
0.4414845705,
-0.0952705145,
-0.204234615,
-0.3428929448,
0.6155536771,
-0.6256346703,
-0.1270940602,
-0.1845663041,
0.011359619,
-0.0993729755,
0.2648223341,
-0.0260244235,
0.6674847603,
0.4521110654,
-0.378134191,
0.4473207593,
0.0499859788,
-0.2926751673,
0.2609454989,
-0.8345405459,
0.1482522488,
-0.4081035554,
0.2113307267,
-0.9856922626,
-0.5641342998,
0.2740257978,
-0.6852099895,
0.2699588239,
-0.3985587656,
-0.6615048051,
-0.2734391987,
-0.5321650505,
0.2187662125,
0.486651808,
-1.0969563723,
0.5971786976,
0.2094138712,
-0.1206210554,
-0.6149709821,
-0.6345791221,
0.1153847426,
-0.2997327149,
-0.6898365617,
0.4260635078,
-0.3005924523,
-0.3874445856,
0.1968883574,
-0.311324209,
-0.1949435174,
-0.0342677385,
0.1306795478,
0.3908924758,
-0.4490843713,
0.3079118729,
0.0603056625,
-0.1666915715,
0.0467357934,
-0.4071020782,
0.2213020772,
-0.1294287294,
-0.2609957755,
-0.1699245423,
0.3316344321,
0.2569170594,
-0.1597922742,
1.0445617437,
0.2829022706,
-0.3017016053,
-0.1194830015,
-0.3848337531,
-0.2522413731,
-0.5186238289,
0.0208091233,
-0.2314428389,
-1.0034980774,
0.3661912084,
0.1222844571,
0.0575353689,
0.1723786891,
0.3817936182,
0.1236673519,
1.2624748945,
0.5897746086,
0.333565414,
0.5893488526,
-0.121419616,
0.3580563068,
-0.7316937447,
-0.5186334848,
-0.4849324524,
-0.473783195,
-0.6757662892,
-0.4410302937,
0.4924940765,
0.0429004915,
-0.0493657887,
0.0453894809,
-0.7622429729,
0.8411672115,
0.7716132998,
0.017104147,
0.5173934102,
0.4216146767,
-0.082723327,
0.1443350315,
-0.5050113201,
-0.2793782353,
0.8753956556,
0.4092158675,
1.056035161,
0.3076555431,
0.6608493328,
0.0162147935,
0.4065557122,
-0.7055922151,
0.4981983006,
-0.0294889659,
-0.7248312235,
-0.2202784866,
-0.5671901703,
-0.8979763985,
0.3530276418,
0.1544843167,
-0.7183856964,
0.1535409838,
0.3930338919,
-0.1002465859,
0.1394890398,
-0.8664198518,
0.5763007998,
-0.3171797395,
-0.4559224248,
-0.0823628753,
-0.6173549294,
0.3890206516,
-0.0688986704,
-0.0664487481,
0.0667362884,
-0.2284830064,
0.7074610591,
-0.5636188388,
0.5394047499,
-0.4516620636,
-0.0544955283,
0.215531528,
-0.1068826914,
0.7063943148,
0.0450073853,
-0.3168573678,
0.09404324,
-0.2619093359,
-0.1121950895,
-0.8562544584,
0.8924506307,
-0.6328474879,
-0.574657023,
-0.3830953836,
-0.6210724115,
0.0581888407,
0.1284056753,
0.1775788218,
0.4105234444,
0.1460683495,
0.4738536775,
0.7511100173,
-0.4860738516,
-0.0418085419,
0.8731166124,
-0.3235754073,
-0.5284885764,
0.9455977678,
0.0119879087,
0.0757855251,
0.5699379444,
0.4028000832,
-0.4162497818,
-0.7044923306,
-0.2241933048,
0.1291994005,
-0.7283954024,
-0.2715413272,
-0.5751165152,
-0.0394015647,
-0.2603672743,
0.1355921477,
-0.0578710735,
-0.7541866302,
-0.1155582219,
-0.3440873623,
0.7300850153,
0.7285381556,
-0.4091595113,
0.400347352,
-0.3653783202,
0.5137396455,
-0.0681713894,
0.7395675778,
-0.152701363,
-0.440100044,
-0.5316879153,
0.1996811032,
0.067900613,
-0.7382965684,
0.3963652551,
0.3117057383,
0.7687163353,
0.2752057016,
0.1137293652,
0.720457375,
-0.2689658105,
0.6486279368,
0.0110424329,
-0.5761852264,
0.7515736818,
-0.4138075113,
0.1843655258,
0.5581848621,
0.4768075049,
-0.3875680864,
-0.5772588253,
-0.3852048814,
-1.2466974258,
0.9968643188,
0.2866066396,
-0.0767451376,
-0.1511477232,
0.5005124211,
0.5004169345,
0.1151089966,
-0.818615675,
-0.4613228738,
-0.178094849,
-0.3393699229,
0.111510776,
-0.1828512996,
-0.0730330497,
-0.2676723897,
0.9095341563,
-0.2946743667,
0.6760821939,
0.1598400325,
-0.3369786441,
-0.1540580094,
0.2604729235,
0.5221338272,
0.650799334,
-0.3566294014,
0.4633478224,
-0.214025721,
-0.2451219708,
0.0452181883,
0.5005892515,
0.0428596325,
0.2185259014,
0.0134503972,
0.6525429487,
-0.1017240211,
-0.5600543022,
0.2005733848,
-0.311932981,
-0.0594942681,
-0.4753180742,
0.0976210162,
-0.2119026333,
0.1568666697,
0.59046942,
-0.2490852028,
0.0937113762,
-0.3113369644,
-0.0040975288,
0.5354429483,
-0.4968805909,
-0.2877964973,
0.724950254,
-0.1833339185,
-0.1076032892,
0.587159276,
0.1264280826,
-0.0772311166,
0.5324097872,
0.534540236,
0.8194056749,
-0.1758806109,
0.2534835935,
0.2972281575,
0.319726795,
-0.1778403074,
0.3370066583,
-0.1971057504,
-0.2892434001,
-0.8251800537,
-0.4411250353,
-0.6376132369,
0.3253824711,
-0.7902997732,
0.2186235934,
-0.2037712634,
0.2942580879,
0.093932949,
-0.3122271299,
-0.4593337178,
-0.1729058325,
-0.0010482327,
1.2818012238,
-0.5293654203,
0.7049919963,
0.7791771293,
-0.4316140413,
-0.5852033496,
-0.2484231293,
-0.124548085,
-0.8610152006,
0.7203226686,
0.4088141024,
0.0641617998,
0.1748172492,
-0.7608128786,
-0.9889054298,
0.9264270663,
0.6473674178,
-0.2431710809,
-0.1791696399,
0.2638077438,
0.7760953307,
-0.2447894961,
0.5446801782,
0.2857945859,
0.6389644742,
-0.0133812502,
-0.5054773092,
0.0404481553,
-0.5120888948,
-0.1765401214,
0.4838458598,
-0.0022983048,
0.6558386683,
-0.3622511923,
-0.1896898597,
0.3549849987,
0.6126058102,
0.0742918104,
0.1159793288,
0.1818407178,
0.5002479553,
0.8280863166,
-0.0858670697,
1.3429372311,
-0.13398543,
0.2413068265,
1.4007203579,
0.026451949,
0.5311583281,
0.6285607219,
0.0845862255,
0.7593479156,
0.6338706017,
-0.0730187148,
0.5734545588,
0.3251236081,
-0.4483632147,
0.1432098299,
-0.3739386797,
-0.3815873265,
0.3596437275,
0.1823107302,
-0.8030821085,
-0.4789688587,
0.1921993047,
-0.1960418224,
-0.3202125728,
-0.2537817359,
0.9408628345,
-0.1141397282,
-0.7935004234,
0.5966414213,
0.0138010932,
0.3657844663,
-0.6991174817,
-0.4007862508,
-0.2828029096,
0.3144129515,
-0.2676290572,
-0.7687825561,
0.209332481,
0.1099145338,
-0.1428508312,
-0.3919916749,
0.66060251,
-0.5467893481,
-0.2035234272,
0.0555213243,
0.5098855495,
0.4991351664,
-0.143684566,
-0.4515999854,
-0.152529791,
0.0722196624,
-0.3841243982,
0.3699482977,
0.4020273685,
-0.1127971858,
0.6185061932,
0.868647337,
0.1424906105,
0.0512750223,
-0.1460374594,
0.9578409791,
-0.5899215341,
-0.4191153347,
-0.9672302604,
0.4685382843,
-0.0813172013,
0.0769114271,
0.8026480675,
0.8143562078,
0.7793936133,
-0.0467318818,
0.7984087467,
-0.1323973238,
0.563811183,
-0.5374395251,
0.4950748384,
-0.4032410085,
0.4250838757,
0.2566809356,
-1.0010908842,
-0.3421960473,
0.5078117847,
-0.2761781514,
-0.0214606132,
0.7675026059,
0.9066972733,
-0.2478049397,
0.1088049784,
0.1442809254,
0.3629665077,
0.4060416222,
0.1743550152,
0.9807974696,
-0.0406592898,
0.8623467088,
-0.280411005,
-0.2760443091,
-0.2642994523,
-1.0358626842,
-0.7038159966,
-0.3246932924,
-0.4049662352,
-0.268653661,
0.2184291631,
0.9213344455,
0.4698525667,
-0.6149837375,
0.0699216276,
-0.3625142574,
0.1776448488,
-0.1316929758,
-0.3098311126,
0.2972944081,
-0.2232632786,
-0.5329165459,
0.6440412998,
0.0830921978,
0.0989045277,
-0.3014860451,
-0.0671215504,
0.0776421726,
-0.1886921227,
0.4656281471,
0.4341379106,
-0.5087267756,
-0.2582017183,
0.1693416983,
0.3222832382,
0.2405671924,
1.0601317883,
-1.2346788645,
0.7349598408,
0.590788424,
0.4527773261,
0.4092827141,
-0.0208688118,
0.7989038825,
-1.0283499956,
-0.2549218535,
0.0932687894,
0.2953282297,
0.4713199139,
-0.5528880954,
0.8606989384,
-0.3058117032,
-0.4026299715,
-1.1331994534,
0.038032189,
-0.6248402596,
-0.173882097,
1.230883956,
-0.1414677203,
-0.195719108,
-0.1736685783,
-0.0948241055,
0.3998570442,
-0.4917693138,
0.5888155699,
0.3837591708,
-0.3990680277,
-0.2584270239,
-0.618997395,
0.3205873966,
0.1840872467,
-0.9787983894,
0.2857256532,
0.4976868033,
0.0851483122,
0.1027787179,
0.3316108584,
-0.2976469398,
0.2845757902,
-0.4086277187,
0.0114866691,
-0.6062496901,
-0.2726371884,
-0.7140203714,
0.0299162958,
0.1405422837,
-0.1685024053
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06332v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06332v2
|
InternLM-Math: Open Math Large Language Models Toward Verifiable Reasoning
| 2024-02-09T11:22:08 | 2024-05-24T07:09:21 |
Huaiyuan Ying, Shuo Zhang, Linyang Li, Zhejian Zhou, Yunfan Shao, Zhaoye Fei, Yichuan Ma, Jiawei Hong, Kuikun Liu, Ziyi Wang, Yudong Wang, Zijian Wu, Shuaibin Li, Fengzhe Zhou, Hongwei Liu, Songyang Zhang, Wenwei Zhang, Hang Yan, Xipeng Qiu, Jiayu Wang, Kai Chen, Dahua Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The math abilities of large language models can represent their abstract
reasoning ability. In this paper, we introduce and open-source our math
reasoning LLMs InternLM-Math which is continue pre-trained from InternLM2. We
unify chain-of-thought reasoning, reward modeling, formal reasoning, data
augmentation, and code interpreter in a unified seq2seq format and supervise
our model to be a versatile math reasoner, verifier, prover, and augmenter.
These abilities can be used to develop the next math LLMs or self-iteration.
InternLM-Math obtains open-sourced state-of-the-art performance under the
setting of in-context learning, supervised fine-tuning, and code-assisted
reasoning in various informal and formal benchmarks including GSM8K, MATH,
Hungary math exam, MathBench-ZH, and MiniF2F. Our pre-trained model achieves
30.3 on the MiniF2F test set without fine-tuning. We further explore how to use
LEAN to solve math problems and study its performance under the setting of
multi-task learning which shows the possibility of using LEAN as a unified
platform for solving and proving in math. Our models, codes, and data are
released at \url{https://github.com/InternLM/InternLM-Math}.
|
[
-0.2313382477,
-0.5326818824,
0.4940625727,
0.1894676536,
-0.0829916373,
-0.0160254203,
-0.3169647455,
-0.218824476,
-0.3882099688,
0.4102199972,
-0.4895398319,
-0.4909041524,
-0.2952885926,
-0.0639469922,
-0.2270234823,
0.8976929784,
-0.2827110589,
0.5992920995,
-0.7273724675,
-0.2758452296,
-0.0146152647,
-0.7422858477,
-0.442777276,
-0.4865842462,
0.1249723881,
0.6946107745,
0.5557360649,
0.2645161748,
0.7450568676,
0.2450464517,
0.2324276417,
0.0453752242,
-0.6480959654,
0.0020270306,
-0.2683146894,
-0.711360991,
-0.5738365054,
-0.1947056502,
0.4655018449,
0.4496168792,
-0.2166020423,
0.3459822237,
-0.2391414791,
0.604231298,
-0.4676645696,
0.2206878662,
-0.9215219021,
-0.1444369107,
-0.25078547,
0.2661886811,
-0.3390625119,
-0.466147691,
-0.3300779164,
-0.5114014745,
-0.1850451231,
0.1261131614,
0.7212181687,
0.5329507589,
-0.0708836988,
-0.3813269138,
-0.5769762993,
0.8064359426,
-0.7317139506,
0.3090094924,
0.3842777908,
0.6547688842,
0.0689218491,
-0.9671356082,
-0.4510617852,
-0.3273362517,
0.0915482491,
0.0663439929,
0.025563173,
-0.1956396103,
0.4611668289,
0.6779931188,
-0.4824609458,
0.1557649225,
-0.473135829,
0.0067290734,
0.5952988863,
0.4031296968,
0.357213676,
0.4056152403,
-0.3387402892,
0.265850544,
-1.1602236032,
0.0665779263,
0.1488141119,
-0.2169620544,
-0.2816134095,
0.9175813794,
-0.013320636,
0.336661011,
-0.5317521691,
-0.0187827218,
0.2134998739,
-0.2909511924,
-0.2547673285,
-0.2358465344,
0.5315192938,
-0.2251934409,
0.5455208421,
0.0621646829,
-0.4804711044,
0.4051555991,
0.0504504219,
-0.7745724916,
-0.1916828454,
0.0104600573,
-0.3949068785,
-0.1434707195,
-0.1711313874,
-0.2295021117,
0.1259595752,
-0.8698856235,
0.4025289118,
-0.5032808185,
-0.2182984054,
0.3315841556,
0.1108218655,
-0.019236641,
0.6197469831,
-0.3946149945,
0.3828799427,
0.9472864866,
0.6474146247,
-0.0992691219,
-0.3651246428,
-0.4421980083,
-0.1037426144,
-0.4551417828,
0.4521996975,
-0.4289891124,
-0.0295829922,
0.0725105703,
-0.5590806603,
0.1910000592,
-0.6102932692,
0.7372710705,
-0.4827365279,
0.1610626876,
0.1104268357,
-0.5492009521,
-0.0015941476,
0.5216642618,
-0.4075433314,
1.1968681812,
0.2895059884,
-0.534335196,
-0.0434892848,
-0.9840068817,
-0.1633279175,
0.1587918401,
-0.2556113005,
-0.3148360848,
0.2809539735,
0.0285231397,
0.0771280527,
-0.6520850658,
0.3620027304,
-0.5814061761,
-0.4793661833,
0.4236004055,
-0.4076547027,
0.9912861586,
0.4570792913,
-0.0624825135,
0.3001500368,
-0.8075478673,
0.2714673281,
0.2743120492,
-0.1598722935,
-0.2588159442,
-0.0280345753,
-0.2267286628,
0.4621189833,
0.3964190483,
-0.3898789883,
0.1659478992,
-0.3234805763,
0.4396455884,
0.7379819155,
-0.5277273059,
0.2097784132,
-0.200602144,
0.3851946592,
0.0890719295,
0.1353981048,
-0.3732411861,
-0.3342373669,
-0.9124893546,
-0.5272879601,
0.3325377703,
0.423653692,
-0.5838105083,
0.1553054005,
-0.2327028215,
-0.3839448094,
-0.4752342403,
0.129741177,
0.3384391963,
0.5725668669,
0.521433413,
0.3340960145,
-0.5028444529,
-0.7419523597,
-0.2186653912,
-0.0503527932,
-0.3598101437,
0.2213734835,
0.7910648584,
-0.3796781898,
0.9251275659,
-0.5596131086,
-0.2491448969,
-0.1282129884,
0.1783050746,
0.3926268816,
0.496871233,
0.3090640903,
-0.4797111452,
-0.5372885466,
-0.01312837,
-1.0056091547,
-0.1682271063,
0.3412706852,
-0.2251745015,
0.0535446964,
0.5815643668,
-0.4386822283,
0.5795954466,
0.2208387852,
-0.3442862332,
0.7904143333,
-0.2170879543,
-0.3277240098,
-0.6490445733,
0.0757095367,
-0.1018057242,
-0.3895897865,
-0.1962442398,
0.37063393,
0.1036286652,
-0.3984132707,
-0.2539058328,
0.6603588462,
-0.3925546706,
-0.1277553886,
-0.2562160194,
-0.1595288813,
-0.1056733355,
0.4944477081,
-0.1169255301,
0.863173902,
0.8528740406,
-0.5790234804,
0.2568400502,
0.0520269163,
-0.5638638139,
0.5875924826,
-0.969617784,
0.1675885618,
-0.0562579334,
0.1064766124,
-0.7338976264,
-0.0113842394,
0.3255542815,
-0.4587729573,
0.1440311968,
-0.1142243519,
-0.715772748,
-0.3738839328,
0.0296620764,
0.5672125816,
0.7173734307,
-0.8188016415,
0.6572059393,
0.2893519998,
-0.2391700298,
-0.4925696254,
-0.4294798076,
-0.1878099591,
0.0913185179,
-0.8255016804,
0.2258726805,
-0.3637032509,
-0.7443252802,
0.2397579998,
-0.0503800064,
-0.3249495924,
0.0468633398,
0.1802774817,
0.6867100596,
-0.3606057167,
0.314694643,
0.0445480421,
-0.3445411026,
0.3357530236,
-0.3200370073,
0.41054672,
-0.6928268671,
-0.7989652157,
0.0728572682,
0.3390401602,
0.7274749875,
-0.4878512919,
0.5250928998,
0.4238819182,
-0.5827656388,
-0.3016389012,
-0.4205744863,
-0.1505772769,
-0.4009187818,
0.2527786195,
-0.5222036839,
-1.0814781189,
0.4289458096,
-0.3743924797,
0.3835354447,
0.458860755,
0.8570568562,
-0.1237454712,
1.2203147411,
0.1853859574,
0.2115730345,
0.0179260261,
-0.235046342,
0.1547235698,
-0.7350046635,
-0.3619999588,
-0.6704761982,
-0.1721070856,
0.2063283622,
-0.7290577292,
0.527038157,
0.2382908911,
-0.6205165386,
-0.1108867005,
-0.2571367323,
0.5610219836,
0.3949566782,
-0.1464989334,
0.4081586897,
-0.006507895,
-0.3808070123,
-0.2063162327,
-0.5093739629,
-0.2746275365,
1.0181778669,
0.4855425358,
1.0843503475,
0.0359852687,
0.2887127697,
0.0554836877,
0.6438851953,
-0.701256752,
0.4664113224,
0.0168758258,
-0.7137206793,
-0.3419299126,
-0.5544025898,
-0.3168916106,
0.3498326838,
0.0622535683,
-0.6550815701,
-0.445574373,
0.192147404,
0.202984333,
0.1554278582,
-0.4218792319,
0.7982412577,
-0.5566089749,
-0.4169368446,
-0.5459229946,
-0.4924141765,
0.752458632,
0.062706247,
0.3696555495,
-0.4223539829,
-0.0260436945,
0.2438502014,
-0.9408319592,
0.5909562707,
0.1525041908,
-0.098895371,
0.408826828,
0.0949932486,
0.522708714,
0.4933125079,
-0.109328106,
0.5977782607,
-0.3030607998,
-0.1361745149,
-0.6135687232,
0.8578708768,
-0.7745380402,
-0.5384694934,
-0.4430167377,
-0.5881118774,
-0.1396178156,
0.2419760674,
0.1445063949,
0.5653507113,
0.0672709122,
0.2518126369,
0.7695045471,
0.3335306942,
0.2244248539,
0.4365002811,
-0.5859017968,
-0.5600033402,
0.8663686514,
-0.1732704043,
0.0452958867,
0.390894413,
0.3504559696,
-0.539162159,
-0.3594460487,
-0.4068014324,
0.2634169459,
-1.0014539957,
-0.3667533696,
-0.34782058,
-0.4490414858,
-0.2381891459,
-0.1993797272,
-0.59008497,
-0.4371916056,
-0.1771743447,
0.205943197,
0.1760452539,
0.4443699419,
-0.1548192799,
-0.1143793017,
-0.633754313,
0.4545872211,
0.2532402575,
0.5558560491,
-0.1901623756,
-0.467330575,
-0.3493605256,
0.1614140421,
0.0093483524,
-0.3405381441,
0.0085394476,
-0.0534287132,
0.5989050865,
0.4960387647,
0.007642359,
0.5189921856,
-0.5496754646,
0.4118451774,
0.577883184,
-1.2617982626,
0.2027114928,
-0.0158008263,
0.3982612193,
0.5415663719,
0.3913201988,
-0.1572526246,
-0.1145730093,
-0.3562836051,
-0.4074429572,
0.6417552233,
0.2986106873,
-0.1117897779,
0.1881368011,
0.0905773789,
0.170432061,
0.181493476,
-0.8071274161,
-0.2474989742,
-0.3730382323,
-0.410251379,
0.3011426032,
-0.2856577635,
-0.3184102774,
-0.6958270669,
0.7048141956,
-0.3286065459,
0.1616466641,
-0.2000631839,
-0.1887643337,
-0.0975547358,
0.1876301318,
0.5213323236,
1.2624025345,
0.1051704064,
0.2118182778,
0.1352629364,
-0.3080615103,
0.1004093811,
0.1294436306,
-0.1525600851,
0.0664737597,
0.1186303124,
0.7240000367,
0.4946984947,
-0.9865563512,
0.5370888114,
-0.1478359699,
-0.4150790274,
-0.8442799449,
0.0473156609,
0.1341123432,
0.0709905326,
0.2590340972,
0.2642603219,
-0.0837887898,
-0.3113672137,
-0.0210009683,
0.5504681468,
-0.365722239,
-0.2790028155,
0.8045113683,
-0.0163239054,
-0.3223043084,
0.8777870536,
-0.1058754772,
-0.6354837418,
0.576423943,
0.8635373712,
0.5897985101,
-0.105145447,
-0.056843359,
0.6646991372,
0.209587425,
-0.0048268428,
0.4201521277,
-0.0195112824,
-0.6300160885,
-0.6229950786,
-0.4375676811,
-0.4618016481,
0.1304330379,
-0.4728349149,
0.5916349292,
-0.4000327289,
0.3384690881,
-0.3715137839,
-0.3514615893,
-0.8168988824,
0.0755024999,
0.1293400228,
1.1414226294,
-0.3930066526,
0.8311753273,
0.8919267058,
-0.2303598672,
-0.7222120762,
-0.3724404871,
-0.0561408438,
-1.1074284315,
0.8897371888,
0.2501599789,
-0.1460884959,
0.0716020465,
-0.9339989424,
-0.956093967,
0.9285075068,
0.4374808669,
-0.6407297254,
-0.0819458812,
0.0345907919,
0.3154640794,
-0.5042824149,
0.637675643,
0.1004430279,
0.2891242504,
0.5959599614,
-0.6307877302,
-0.1941469908,
-0.4678325057,
-0.111832872,
0.2583549023,
-0.3686393499,
1.114584446,
-0.5099096298,
-0.0144588342,
-0.0060228286,
0.8317199349,
0.5966081619,
0.5313721895,
0.4409255087,
1.0252548456,
0.6763652563,
-0.058903873,
0.7832188606,
-0.1941326559,
0.3244484067,
1.2737653255,
-0.4627979696,
0.7010927796,
0.219908759,
-0.2494787127,
0.7578526735,
0.1996216923,
0.0947799832,
0.2042650431,
0.5462212563,
-0.2577270269,
-0.5722507238,
0.104540661,
-0.643439889,
0.3907394409,
0.5694562793,
-0.0714643225,
-0.3594919443,
-0.1240119711,
0.1360970736,
-0.0122697651,
-0.5046322346,
0.3881161511,
0.3281330466,
-0.7531776428,
0.4297524691,
0.0441737995,
0.3604430258,
-0.8642815948,
-0.3367985785,
-0.0124209998,
0.5004531145,
-0.0659731701,
-0.6679646373,
0.3559844196,
0.0381003544,
-0.0234455429,
-0.0685594603,
0.9176978469,
-0.3641271293,
-0.7239341736,
-0.1126233712,
0.582197845,
0.1253030598,
-0.0668818429,
-0.7600072026,
0.0858234093,
-0.3177416325,
0.088659741,
0.3641648889,
0.5651102066,
0.0033047176,
0.8281225562,
0.9455652833,
-0.0938640386,
-0.0374884605,
0.1354354769,
1.0468502045,
-0.2279891223,
-0.5797718763,
-0.9056586027,
0.6486206651,
-0.1633684337,
-0.481703341,
0.7637952566,
0.7724558711,
0.9324404001,
-0.214217335,
0.7354927659,
0.071751751,
0.5308295488,
-0.5073375106,
0.4443141222,
-0.5962247252,
0.220919773,
0.1347157508,
-0.7612286806,
-0.2459629923,
0.6496664882,
-0.1668177247,
-0.2456519753,
0.8542311192,
0.4221869111,
-0.2353898883,
0.0262440871,
0.2927078009,
0.0322460011,
0.2147482187,
0.7100733519,
1.0938694477,
0.016265763,
0.6435012221,
-0.1528097987,
-0.2517577708,
-0.3098393679,
-0.7882674336,
-1.156829834,
-0.2854051888,
-0.4027798176,
-0.332965672,
-0.3807485998,
0.9468500614,
0.5041750669,
-0.5965402722,
-0.2523363829,
-0.4141086638,
0.4202650785,
-0.2864896953,
-0.2398116887,
0.0728799775,
-0.5426825285,
-0.6604428887,
0.3505398631,
0.4620075226,
-0.1389479786,
-0.5288903117,
-0.4611012638,
0.1788378358,
0.0000788662,
0.5561021566,
0.2921442091,
-0.6793457866,
0.1761467606,
0.1246205717,
-0.1693601757,
0.1387428492,
1.1885671616,
-0.6471052766,
0.3532218337,
0.521597743,
0.5894348025,
0.4522902369,
-0.2119204849,
0.4406793714,
-0.235001117,
0.0996437073,
0.5384221673,
0.7343751788,
-0.0522608347,
-0.1741122752,
0.7917752266,
0.2353266329,
-0.5644913912,
-0.9242799282,
0.3801468909,
-0.5404005647,
-0.2132922709,
0.9878179431,
-0.4220665693,
-0.1032790542,
-0.115384154,
-0.0584182926,
-0.0490165688,
-0.0951416418,
0.5270958543,
0.6221449375,
0.001259585,
-0.1982888132,
-0.2138360143,
0.1590970308,
0.3935801387,
-1.1522483826,
-0.2013282329,
0.6171789169,
0.1330851167,
0.0174857564,
0.7727968693,
-0.4621759355,
0.3691056669,
0.1366454065,
0.0555284955,
-0.65124017,
-0.5797123909,
-0.0945654437,
0.2033896297,
0.1556296349,
-0.0376906805
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.18589v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.18589v1
|
Verif.ai: Towards an Open-Source Scientific Generative Question-Answering System with Referenced and Verifiable Answers
| 2024-02-09T10:25:01 | 2024-02-09T10:25:01 |
Miloš Košprdić, Adela Ljajić, Bojana Bašaragin, Darija Medvecki, Nikola Milošević
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In this paper, we present the current progress of the project Verif.ai, an
open-source scientific generative question-answering system with referenced and
verified answers. The components of the system are (1) an information retrieval
system combining semantic and lexical search techniques over scientific papers
(PubMed), (2) a fine-tuned generative model (Mistral 7B) taking top answers and
generating answers with references to the papers from which the claim was
derived, and (3) a verification engine that cross-checks the generated claim
and the abstract or paper from which the claim was derived, verifying whether
there may have been any hallucinations in generating the claim. We are
reinforcing the generative model by providing the abstract in context, but in
addition, an independent set of methods and models are verifying the answer and
checking for hallucinations. Therefore, we believe that by using our method, we
can make scientists more productive, while building trust in the use of
generative language models in scientific environments, where hallucinations and
misinformation cannot be tolerated.
|
[
-0.2702130973,
-0.7581819296,
0.7342001796,
0.2175773531,
-0.1214508191,
0.1292190999,
-0.00572018,
-0.6541601419,
0.3185918927,
0.5534718037,
-0.2253360748,
-0.2600322664,
-0.5476928949,
0.5753287673,
-0.5825232863,
0.9112312794,
-0.023907939,
0.2377416342,
-0.8797973394,
0.0731379166,
-0.0245242994,
-0.555807054,
-0.4095311463,
-0.2765840888,
0.4946313202,
0.1450782418,
0.6960959435,
0.659997344,
0.8191575408,
0.3231948912,
0.0365775265,
0.0921787247,
-0.3818703294,
0.4571513534,
-0.3721521795,
-0.6154810786,
-0.1199231297,
-0.2016103268,
0.3619872332,
0.3654770255,
-0.2277826816,
0.2493208051,
-0.2948124707,
0.3855220675,
-0.5356038809,
0.0912747309,
-0.5529237986,
0.0552038178,
-0.1068313792,
-0.304027319,
-0.2958182096,
-0.5109604001,
-0.0552386381,
-0.6426702738,
0.4065356255,
0.0413110889,
1.083660841,
0.5360699892,
-0.00120164,
-0.1812727004,
-0.9094887972,
0.3979229331,
-0.4774924815,
0.2460789829,
0.4565196037,
0.5705881119,
-0.0116948001,
-1.2749466896,
-0.7934278846,
-0.5288651586,
0.0336221233,
0.1828336865,
-0.1075798199,
-0.1014633328,
0.2814770341,
0.6630763412,
-0.6597243547,
-0.3668446541,
-0.6861078143,
-0.2579815388,
0.4586050808,
-0.0571015589,
0.3141850829,
-0.018198546,
-0.3189618587,
0.0766698197,
-0.8878523707,
-0.4272230864,
-0.0558749028,
-0.0832647979,
0.1859455258,
0.9623439908,
-0.4032765329,
0.4979460537,
-0.0439617783,
0.2945681512,
0.2523960471,
-0.6876736283,
-0.1754224598,
0.2256486416,
0.6334297657,
-0.0193271209,
0.0195474271,
-0.4387061,
0.036568258,
0.3096498847,
0.4372147322,
-0.8581169248,
-0.182116881,
0.4147154689,
-0.4014391601,
-0.462382108,
0.0323056355,
-0.5393354893,
-0.4155203104,
-0.0837684944,
0.5125669837,
-0.4186867476,
-0.3827005029,
0.1129201874,
-0.3200633824,
0.0845044628,
0.5495837331,
-0.4597142041,
0.0707498193,
0.7600331306,
0.91049999,
0.14295353,
-0.3217224181,
-0.4197169244,
0.2305468917,
-0.1998842955,
0.8413261771,
-0.6192290187,
-0.6311996579,
0.0416225791,
0.0681515783,
0.250572592,
-0.4883086085,
0.5125186443,
-0.7404273152,
0.3056300581,
-0.443577528,
-0.5502287745,
-0.1447024643,
0.3834751546,
-0.6564014554,
0.9196363091,
0.0639030188,
-0.8633705974,
0.053184621,
-0.7459520698,
-0.1437158436,
0.4346323907,
-0.2604711354,
-0.022133531,
0.1653903127,
-0.0088379402,
-0.0807213262,
-0.6685906053,
0.2630672157,
-0.3480350673,
-0.0539529994,
0.3952321708,
-0.224200353,
0.7623059154,
0.5657510161,
-0.1473617107,
0.1422122717,
-0.7534922957,
0.1089801788,
0.027938094,
-0.1705414802,
-0.3599338233,
0.0761274248,
-0.0117938062,
-0.1113410667,
0.4554997385,
-0.970998168,
0.2382506877,
-0.2620645761,
0.3846263587,
0.3583240807,
0.0556006692,
-0.0429331958,
-0.5102271438,
0.4436930716,
-0.0986833721,
-0.0179271139,
-0.2525143027,
-0.6833149791,
-0.6104217768,
-0.1337150633,
0.3995750546,
0.5906426311,
-0.9079055786,
0.334089309,
-0.2540394068,
-0.5239721537,
-0.6544816494,
-0.1566295028,
0.2836891115,
0.7644767761,
0.4367778003,
-0.0686672181,
-0.6535956264,
-0.5829435587,
0.1518728286,
-0.6766315103,
-0.2994281352,
0.0173801892,
0.8886490464,
-0.1820035726,
0.9579916596,
-0.4047399163,
-0.0163321979,
0.3302592635,
0.1472329348,
-0.0125671979,
0.4244634211,
0.4028708935,
-1.0759944916,
-0.2602050006,
0.2905844152,
-1.2794092894,
-0.1280074716,
0.3635365367,
-0.0383956693,
-0.013214821,
0.6015994549,
-0.7914521694,
0.2997457981,
0.2186783701,
-0.4557858407,
0.6578114629,
-0.2598031759,
0.4286826551,
-1.1693148613,
0.3286618292,
-0.2496916503,
-0.2696302831,
-0.312461853,
0.4205823541,
-0.2162978798,
-0.0595625155,
-0.2379144132,
0.3850505054,
-0.2202686071,
0.3491829634,
-0.4593573213,
-0.001044913,
-0.0726090148,
-0.0926736519,
0.2622822225,
0.899243176,
0.7224903703,
-0.43687585,
0.4567746818,
0.2959759533,
-0.3148455024,
0.758456111,
-1.0239379406,
0.190170005,
-0.3496332765,
0.0445271432,
-0.8229649663,
-0.420152247,
0.4214273989,
-0.7905861139,
-0.1214630306,
0.0559997484,
-0.5442922711,
-0.3849940002,
0.1239157468,
0.3133110106,
0.328111887,
-0.5357375741,
0.5757173896,
0.2551232576,
-0.4043764472,
-0.5447624326,
-0.5316660404,
0.2047654092,
0.1221799403,
-0.7877176404,
0.5383657813,
-0.0955745131,
-0.4558256269,
0.6080119014,
-0.0119143082,
-0.1400822252,
-0.0265501384,
0.3291930556,
0.2593826354,
-0.4070217907,
0.151919052,
0.0710906833,
-0.1010400057,
0.2931851447,
-0.2927137613,
0.3171014488,
-0.3326849639,
-0.4479721189,
-0.0326111354,
0.4031236768,
0.7712295651,
-0.3527072072,
0.6139745712,
0.4083302021,
-0.7237876654,
0.0690947026,
-0.3843059838,
-0.2369919121,
-0.4207426906,
0.378182739,
-0.2687456906,
-1.1340178251,
0.6406239867,
-0.0155491792,
-0.0327366292,
0.5670849681,
0.7117053866,
0.0481822565,
0.7463972569,
0.6589468122,
0.1009786949,
-0.1133126467,
0.0015379493,
0.0608381331,
-0.415346235,
-0.4788914323,
-1.1010255814,
0.1767675877,
-0.3464714587,
-0.5980715156,
0.3623694777,
0.1388218254,
-0.3251567483,
0.0987853631,
-0.7856770754,
0.4054028392,
0.6059467196,
-0.0563737005,
0.355866313,
0.0240557399,
0.1018483564,
0.2146700025,
-0.396895498,
-0.6176964641,
0.9585330486,
0.4286877513,
0.7311553955,
0.1050410122,
0.5447839499,
0.476351589,
0.6381142139,
-0.3526303172,
0.5177140236,
0.3452900946,
-1.0093759298,
-0.3657793105,
-0.2890351713,
-0.5902529359,
0.324025929,
-0.1754779816,
-0.8473038077,
0.1571188569,
0.0444999859,
-0.1918634176,
0.1449903697,
-0.2091195285,
0.6229198575,
-0.189565748,
-0.3663344383,
-0.4055740237,
-0.6219766736,
0.3440537751,
0.0719891116,
-0.2191051841,
0.1218365356,
0.2301028371,
0.5303021073,
-0.6836922169,
0.6649358869,
-0.1295714974,
-0.060690403,
0.5820451379,
-0.2034926265,
0.3419649005,
0.4450536966,
-0.2261297256,
0.2607680857,
0.5643936396,
-0.2191218436,
-0.503308475,
0.7405229211,
-0.7226191759,
-0.8768553734,
-0.8016939759,
-0.2735650241,
0.0388194583,
0.332857728,
0.4761527479,
-0.1971436441,
-0.423040241,
0.4131494164,
0.9127172232,
-0.0187634099,
-0.079260923,
0.3573215604,
-0.5381889939,
-0.691881597,
0.6752342582,
-0.1210524216,
-0.0253617298,
0.4110481143,
0.0442585051,
-0.3214794397,
-0.5359514952,
-0.4969165623,
0.2700001597,
-0.7366421223,
-0.3040383458,
-0.5251016617,
-0.5769876838,
-0.6171773076,
0.1192638427,
-0.2637809813,
-0.3392917216,
-0.1814899594,
-0.1665525883,
0.4506698549,
0.5717154145,
-0.158818692,
-0.046701923,
-0.69912076,
0.45535779,
0.1458451301,
0.1931375116,
-0.4130298793,
-0.3620887697,
-0.2795576155,
0.2535756528,
-0.186945051,
-0.8295487165,
-0.0123503162,
0.0596179813,
0.6297275424,
0.2841057777,
0.1066989228,
0.3710776269,
-0.4418725371,
0.9665890932,
0.1123237759,
-0.5879682899,
0.5174844861,
-0.122975558,
0.1160250232,
0.7288252711,
0.5762247443,
-0.4381600916,
-0.6535667777,
-0.424782902,
-0.5320233703,
0.2419877499,
0.3529396057,
0.0329065025,
-0.0661992654,
0.5664950013,
0.1902303249,
0.3065960407,
-0.4913894832,
-0.3291740716,
-0.5486332178,
-0.0988334939,
0.1520411521,
-0.2343896031,
-0.5860826969,
-0.1304205358,
0.7500382662,
-0.1184701324,
0.4728559256,
0.5550968051,
0.1562630832,
-0.3069221377,
0.0548710935,
0.4741105139,
0.6882582903,
-0.1764932573,
0.3101055324,
-0.2426605821,
-0.6954489946,
0.1335031986,
0.4681400955,
-0.7802638412,
0.2311883867,
0.1360123008,
0.6574398875,
-0.5583917499,
-0.4415972829,
0.2571389973,
-0.1206863374,
-0.4256214499,
-0.6394400001,
0.1474565715,
0.0112038227,
0.3312505782,
0.5020418763,
0.2352349758,
0.1691117734,
-0.2289685756,
0.27467224,
0.2858872414,
-0.4005635679,
-0.4546645284,
1.0583788157,
-0.0151501531,
-0.4379829466,
0.5098030567,
0.0617826842,
-0.2730953395,
0.6080051661,
0.630928278,
0.9607191682,
-0.1124497056,
0.589620173,
0.4476926923,
0.2958822548,
-0.1353060454,
0.4750679731,
-0.2803784013,
-0.5877279639,
-0.3683902323,
-0.6425184608,
-0.605456531,
0.186427474,
-0.4889255762,
0.0848233625,
-0.3249407411,
-0.2980507612,
0.2793976963,
-0.3043989241,
-0.4218795896,
0.1164234206,
0.1039888784,
1.1312223673,
-0.7170768976,
0.8251931071,
0.9031193256,
-0.8008257151,
-0.2998416126,
-0.1015422419,
-0.1951950788,
-0.4491433203,
0.7381466627,
0.0010965297,
-0.3629886806,
0.0155951437,
-1.0489172935,
-1.0982375145,
0.983130157,
0.4546470046,
-0.109645769,
0.055537641,
0.0809869468,
0.8826818466,
-0.2042049468,
0.1073334664,
-0.0971027985,
0.5707173944,
0.3661681712,
-0.6736389399,
0.0460567325,
-0.7208024263,
-0.0008652115,
-0.2389741838,
-0.2833050489,
0.4817030132,
-0.2019071132,
-0.3733574748,
0.6280251741,
1.3294483423,
0.4020998776,
0.4951580167,
0.2167623043,
0.7064356208,
0.8995605111,
-0.2549884617,
1.0584429502,
-0.5282973647,
0.2993123233,
0.9809754491,
-0.4858701825,
0.7155154943,
0.8531095982,
-0.134889096,
0.6338409781,
0.3350919187,
-0.1908737123,
0.6438317299,
0.351544559,
-0.5759004951,
-0.300100863,
-0.3070912659,
-0.7583320141,
0.1302403361,
0.3386153281,
-0.3039596081,
-0.2612842917,
0.2363322079,
-0.1650640815,
0.1958809495,
0.0764859989,
0.365047574,
0.0104761906,
-0.9444118142,
0.4031498134,
-0.0172466934,
0.2398673892,
-0.5946647525,
-0.3460418284,
0.0059125526,
0.1860885322,
-0.0786273852,
-0.6716508269,
0.3562496603,
0.1300222576,
-0.3566898406,
0.0160139371,
0.8291266561,
-0.3289415538,
-0.4959633052,
-0.0514352433,
0.4637021124,
0.2386238873,
0.1020484343,
-0.5263892412,
-0.1542876959,
-0.230770722,
-0.1651957035,
-0.0751525611,
0.4610281289,
-0.0705455318,
0.8505080938,
0.6636037827,
0.236862734,
0.111431241,
-0.1112309843,
0.7341409326,
-0.4176163375,
-0.3044472337,
-0.5267708302,
0.3686882555,
-0.1375627369,
-0.2259784043,
0.7839168906,
0.5631119013,
1.0345528126,
-0.289865762,
1.2397704124,
-0.6019387841,
0.4221647978,
-0.2451175451,
0.698934257,
-0.419642508,
0.0931702405,
-0.0443307459,
-0.7189744711,
-0.5166352391,
0.6237032413,
-0.0825733766,
0.0022551832,
0.5796989799,
0.9629067183,
0.2411403358,
0.2470959723,
0.2308893055,
0.213046819,
0.3448173106,
0.1894705743,
1.1852353811,
-0.323443085,
0.2892396152,
-0.314450413,
-0.1352088302,
-0.1450428665,
-0.7595242858,
-0.4464831352,
-0.7421444058,
-0.5712637305,
-0.6829360127,
0.2651149333,
0.4957574606,
0.3589383662,
-0.8893971443,
-0.0334069245,
-0.415448308,
-0.0342286564,
-0.292488575,
-0.1796473116,
0.2825684249,
-0.2882934213,
-0.5969541669,
0.1902504861,
0.4184978902,
-0.0609547123,
-0.6086972952,
-0.2818831801,
-0.1564635783,
0.0723787844,
0.3960903287,
0.7498357892,
-0.7190603614,
-0.5393970013,
0.3244496286,
-0.3203496039,
-0.0003515359,
0.6019409299,
-0.7340820432,
0.6297631264,
0.7741389871,
0.7776127458,
0.4252655804,
0.0836243033,
0.4832196534,
-0.1279670596,
-0.2674426138,
0.2815175056,
0.3176622093,
0.1868699342,
-0.4187789261,
0.7354084849,
0.3106503785,
-0.7155212164,
-1.0410120487,
0.1343282908,
-0.8813613653,
-0.2019727677,
0.9242228866,
-0.3434918821,
-0.4411175549,
-0.0799463987,
-0.2877420783,
0.2852688432,
0.0633021072,
1.083860755,
0.6822998524,
-0.0060142744,
0.0808777884,
-0.1579934955,
0.3907831907,
0.3032150269,
-0.9520443082,
0.0868488178,
0.7114819884,
0.1352484375,
0.8795101643,
0.740342021,
-0.4644820392,
0.5916799903,
0.264673382,
0.212577641,
-0.3359633088,
-0.4819354117,
-0.1193693727,
0.4972332418,
0.190244481,
-0.3435001075
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10948v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10948v2
|
Zero-shot Explainable Mental Health Analysis on Social Media by Incorporating Mental Scales
| 2024-02-09T09:44:06 | 2024-03-15T02:02:02 |
Wenyu Li, Yinuo Zhu, Xin Lin, Ming Li, Ziyue Jiang, Ziqian Zeng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Traditional discriminative approaches in mental health analysis are known for
their strong capacity but lack interpretability and demand large-scale
annotated data. The generative approaches, such as those based on large
language models (LLMs), have the potential to get rid of heavy annotations and
provide explanations but their capabilities still fall short compared to
discriminative approaches, and their explanations may be unreliable due to the
fact that the generation of explanation is a black-box process. Inspired by the
psychological assessment practice of using scales to evaluate mental states,
our method which is called Mental Analysis by Incorporating Mental Scales
(MAIMS), incorporates two procedures via LLMs. First, the patient completes
mental scales, and second, the psychologist interprets the collected
information from the mental scales and makes informed decisions. Experimental
results show that MAIMS outperforms other zero-shot methods. MAIMS can generate
more rigorous explanation based on the outputs of mental scales
|
[
-0.3694578111,
-1.0349203348,
1.0115381479,
0.189039126,
-0.2793352306,
0.1060087755,
-0.161457777,
-0.4509236515,
0.5292290449,
0.4084557295,
-0.8174937367,
-0.5494760871,
-0.8366630673,
0.1179629713,
-0.2645871937,
1.1449289322,
-0.1833492219,
0.3139617443,
-0.1177344322,
-0.247444123,
-0.4454512894,
-0.3244721889,
-0.8634866476,
-0.4005402327,
0.8190230131,
0.5173640847,
0.785449326,
0.4617534876,
0.750248313,
0.1515596807,
0.0242892317,
-0.0615457147,
-0.6892929673,
-0.0526705645,
-0.0115720024,
-0.5794270039,
-0.570584178,
0.1317445785,
0.4075600803,
0.7695881724,
-0.1491017938,
0.5186857581,
-0.295966208,
0.6060634851,
-0.8283396363,
0.0711684823,
-0.3360114992,
0.3436894119,
0.0218892228,
-0.5684673786,
-0.2607730925,
-0.3721556664,
-0.2177007794,
-0.2929834723,
0.1575205922,
-0.657345593,
0.6797887087,
0.1588294357,
-0.4541128874,
0.0488577783,
-1.2851612568,
0.600137949,
-0.7803229094,
-0.0298352242,
0.5118108392,
0.5409070253,
0.0918168575,
-0.3007922769,
-0.5562275648,
0.1844056845,
0.109201476,
0.2214429975,
-0.4350298345,
0.1608050764,
0.4262740612,
0.3369763494,
-0.523917079,
0.2396201342,
-0.3815151155,
0.0742861331,
1.0094673634,
0.5156372786,
0.3946453035,
-0.0468633361,
-0.1303372979,
0.4355865121,
-0.5886221528,
-0.0723125264,
-0.1720126718,
-0.0202778541,
-0.4007482231,
0.8780465722,
-0.2206989527,
0.6229258776,
0.246098727,
-0.4337020516,
0.0819207877,
0.092075415,
-0.4314386249,
0.1922178119,
0.8188578486,
0.969335258,
0.4327921271,
-0.21778889,
-0.0245088954,
0.3881603181,
0.3789882064,
-1.0572192669,
0.0397106521,
0.6028001308,
-0.6336741447,
-0.2756050527,
-0.2454602867,
-0.6834989786,
-0.6076464057,
-0.3130509853,
0.6383035183,
-0.4044466913,
-0.4503340423,
0.1469453573,
-0.1568132937,
0.3080283105,
0.4285252392,
-0.6356935501,
0.2116131783,
0.5244622231,
1.1847274303,
0.1574998349,
0.1410895586,
-0.2922230363,
0.1094408706,
-0.6906225681,
0.9242312908,
-0.341866672,
-0.4268057644,
0.0115360692,
0.1129033789,
0.0152955269,
-0.3978144228,
0.0853018537,
-0.2174422592,
-0.0128156208,
-0.5475434661,
-0.5013618469,
-0.276579082,
0.241452992,
-0.3671959937,
0.8810884953,
0.2053992152,
-0.8407766819,
0.6114265919,
-0.7867318392,
-0.4054152071,
0.2328674048,
-0.2903866172,
-0.296772331,
0.4058611691,
0.2260774672,
0.9535669684,
-0.158348754,
0.2416981906,
-0.8868610263,
-0.6591678858,
0.452480346,
-0.4290896952,
1.0697625875,
0.2544796169,
-0.2665522397,
0.1238666326,
-0.7735062838,
-0.1890194863,
0.6071537137,
0.0557483584,
-0.328368634,
0.1808825582,
-0.3780815005,
0.1787356734,
0.1383971721,
-0.5864243507,
-0.2565801144,
-0.2360925972,
0.3139216304,
0.457854867,
0.6265479326,
0.1984937936,
-0.4961771369,
0.79960531,
-0.1958784312,
0.3703874946,
-0.0050850278,
-0.4515255392,
-0.3033733964,
-0.5869810581,
-0.2812739611,
0.578928411,
-0.6015790105,
0.4647092819,
-0.356241554,
-0.7732234597,
-0.6122427583,
0.131755814,
0.1151079461,
0.4138614833,
0.1703626215,
-0.2978900373,
-0.1831241995,
-0.7215066552,
-0.1813513488,
-0.0724563748,
-0.3322812021,
-0.0289907977,
0.4384194016,
-0.0483971834,
0.7555183768,
-0.6446315646,
-0.1826817095,
-0.3027795255,
0.2666947246,
-0.0755425692,
-0.1728295535,
0.6626532078,
-0.4924881756,
-0.3638505042,
-0.1383869797,
-1.2052004337,
-0.283926487,
-0.1956253946,
-0.0145458318,
-0.2445671111,
0.3433748484,
-0.58789289,
0.4967775941,
0.3558253944,
-0.2157129496,
0.6548113227,
-0.0867337137,
0.1477271169,
-0.9507430792,
-0.1048365608,
0.499104917,
-0.2280399054,
-0.7275500298,
0.0776128545,
-0.081634976,
-0.4039074183,
-0.490439564,
0.3467929959,
-0.433881104,
0.1062588021,
-0.3057568073,
0.2820337713,
0.0945157856,
0.0987861827,
-0.2322772443,
0.4261454642,
0.5889627934,
-0.1935663968,
0.2928709984,
-0.3072519898,
0.0320503525,
1.1060758829,
-0.6554059386,
-0.1743041575,
-0.5377364159,
0.1631048471,
-1.3041806221,
-0.4001992047,
0.3157575428,
-0.5927106738,
0.2621645927,
0.0987413749,
-0.3825239837,
-0.4775104523,
-0.7049167752,
0.0239913221,
0.2904289961,
0.003540488,
0.2483259141,
0.5259359479,
-0.0744441748,
-0.1480176598,
-0.6881391406,
0.1643067449,
-0.7204318047,
-0.3616487682,
-0.0034972704,
-0.0869872868,
-0.5551629066,
0.0594899431,
-0.0438370965,
-0.1615199,
0.2169402838,
0.3978167176,
0.3362375796,
-0.2720430791,
0.3055897653,
0.0858420432,
-0.0270604212,
0.5149399638,
0.5181202292,
0.2661727369,
0.1859759092,
-0.2746364772,
-0.8440925479,
0.5576152802,
0.9085122943,
-0.1404313594,
1.0425143242,
0.6405020356,
-0.7045707107,
0.0609082952,
-0.5697058439,
-0.2164439261,
-0.3600067198,
0.0397649705,
-0.2134136707,
-0.7800440192,
0.5559769273,
-0.0769251212,
0.0796991363,
0.5371958017,
0.7837317586,
-0.386823982,
1.3841109276,
0.5090915561,
0.0367413945,
0.293988049,
-0.1070706546,
0.3579075038,
-0.5024142265,
-0.0414671004,
-0.3416487277,
-0.331312269,
-0.546869278,
-0.3695758879,
0.3681479394,
0.0826210976,
-0.3845593631,
-0.1127548367,
-0.6352905035,
0.3619838655,
0.0842791274,
0.4037987888,
0.3243566751,
0.1415458322,
0.291103065,
-0.2172672749,
-0.4276466966,
-0.4495166838,
1.2127393484,
0.471329242,
0.8213537335,
0.1061565652,
0.7628515959,
0.2871356308,
0.8948473334,
-1.3741521835,
0.4933945239,
-0.0410385057,
-0.852627039,
-0.3461287618,
-0.4868271351,
-0.8964877129,
0.2227607071,
-0.3734799623,
-1.1558710337,
-0.0573642552,
-0.2686852217,
-0.6714050174,
0.1783633381,
-0.8293164968,
0.4026222825,
-0.192877695,
0.0626280159,
-0.2366411537,
-0.5399158001,
0.6430820227,
-0.289765358,
0.4485050142,
-0.5319069028,
0.1653293818,
1.0575615168,
-0.4123162031,
1.0178734064,
-0.3492074907,
-0.0534704253,
0.3535327911,
0.257332027,
-0.1765884757,
0.0948663279,
-0.010563693,
0.3989557922,
0.4341930151,
-0.4955270588,
-0.8753954768,
0.7161195278,
-0.8390292525,
-0.6237460971,
-0.2953214645,
-0.5043029785,
-0.3184778094,
0.0222283099,
0.0428825095,
0.1406412274,
-0.1078698337,
-0.0601774789,
0.3299975097,
-0.2590414286,
0.1992494911,
0.712575376,
-0.2291398793,
-0.3443128169,
0.6573752165,
0.5397174358,
0.1777661294,
0.1774499714,
0.3468072414,
0.0277057905,
-0.2969625294,
-0.2098603249,
0.6182860136,
-0.416698724,
-0.1100503802,
-0.4862990081,
-0.3533617854,
-0.3092967272,
-0.4556722641,
-0.2106664628,
-0.178593874,
-0.1798233688,
-0.344617635,
0.510261476,
0.7412725687,
-0.23520042,
0.5416468382,
-0.7402670979,
0.7379832864,
0.1450787783,
0.34715271,
0.3081299961,
-0.1754494756,
-0.2850110829,
0.1579120755,
-0.464910686,
-1.6125059128,
0.1270798892,
-0.1568569988,
0.2872942984,
1.1463576555,
0.0068043424,
0.9814247489,
-0.2787443995,
0.6167662144,
0.5329479575,
-0.5773076415,
0.6848958731,
-0.3909757435,
0.4488743544,
0.430849731,
0.8214425445,
-0.6763858795,
-0.4561779201,
-0.4730550349,
-0.5473589301,
0.4689610004,
0.0057499236,
0.1998608112,
-0.3078359962,
0.7106939554,
-0.1086562052,
-0.1392625719,
-0.5964352489,
-0.3398031592,
0.2014462203,
-0.1241742,
-0.3010559678,
-0.4516478777,
-0.5148299336,
-0.539034903,
0.4012153149,
-0.041663833,
0.4161348343,
0.303745091,
0.0888455585,
-0.7038676143,
0.2269905806,
0.2170703709,
0.9477931857,
-0.5259019732,
0.3529613018,
0.138570711,
-0.2529458702,
0.2966957986,
0.0537973568,
-0.1237880588,
0.1526807547,
0.5091686249,
0.433181107,
-0.0024827085,
-0.4839972854,
0.5104441047,
-0.0423951447,
-0.413508594,
-0.2722962201,
0.0919236392,
0.4050617814,
0.2848375738,
0.2878544629,
-0.4541983604,
0.121486716,
-0.5520948172,
-0.0258224737,
0.6246415377,
-0.7157533765,
-0.4996687472,
0.5801776648,
-0.0817137063,
-0.3438400924,
0.3229833841,
-0.0346097089,
0.0745172352,
0.5692188144,
0.4822562039,
0.7926229835,
-0.2299243957,
0.8582440019,
0.2770307362,
0.3971447349,
0.0609547012,
0.4241979718,
-0.0835603029,
-0.638794899,
-0.7785391808,
-0.6167221665,
-0.4133529663,
0.4832691252,
-1.0637260675,
0.148077935,
-0.7393273115,
-0.5355904698,
0.5793761611,
0.0025792634,
-0.7078129649,
0.5477868319,
0.346352458,
0.7403002381,
-1.2343200445,
0.2748810947,
0.6323177814,
-0.4965772033,
-0.697226584,
0.1467720419,
0.4368873835,
-0.8814839721,
0.223476246,
0.2670396566,
-0.1382021904,
-0.3122829497,
-0.5487059951,
-0.5221871734,
0.9247591496,
0.6941494942,
-0.2691780627,
-0.0512641296,
0.1317228228,
0.7395507693,
-0.1391937882,
0.3254340589,
0.494287312,
0.3608692884,
0.0861243904,
-0.5708386302,
0.2728771865,
0.0656003058,
0.0240236763,
0.1689940244,
-0.421346128,
0.4519145489,
-0.4658154845,
-0.5240713358,
-0.4332874119,
0.1923565418,
0.0905934721,
0.6269806027,
0.2697307169,
0.6495571733,
0.5739520788,
0.2227787077,
1.1226037741,
-0.1615528315,
0.621571362,
0.9775671959,
-0.3430823982,
0.9366598725,
0.4935411513,
-0.5233852863,
0.5248104334,
0.8532402515,
-0.0234506354,
0.1732005924,
0.0754393265,
-0.5231887698,
-0.3415392339,
-0.1635899395,
-0.1516712457,
0.5842154622,
0.4900900722,
-0.540491581,
-0.6941256523,
0.0068272199,
0.4670645297,
-0.1918377727,
-0.3164421022,
0.7791404724,
0.2919667363,
-0.1497745216,
0.5991649628,
-0.0163023807,
0.2775080502,
-0.4862949848,
0.0094603179,
-0.1813248396,
-0.0349643826,
-0.3393585384,
-0.8882793784,
0.7226147652,
0.1851066351,
-0.129265666,
-0.0647241846,
0.9532086849,
0.0086611537,
-0.7995700836,
0.4745379388,
0.9221957922,
0.4337894022,
-0.3982074559,
-0.5384454727,
-0.3865168393,
-0.470325768,
-0.4530857205,
0.467176199,
0.6495025754,
-0.2495999187,
0.5850683451,
0.6326833963,
0.5063129663,
-0.4050982296,
0.1057525799,
0.4121231139,
-0.7707020044,
-0.0733941123,
-1.2597960234,
0.3423705697,
-0.1033641696,
-0.0075027808,
0.8093705773,
0.2224325836,
0.4871974289,
0.1132723987,
0.7378940582,
0.0867117941,
0.3146251738,
-0.108232446,
0.9744727612,
-0.8486585617,
-0.2901232243,
-0.0808652043,
-0.7545649409,
-0.8020637035,
0.5264673829,
-0.5139686465,
-0.1167813316,
0.5956901908,
0.6400780082,
0.1252220124,
-0.2135705203,
0.5880249739,
0.3616633415,
0.207159996,
0.2364230901,
0.5685209632,
0.0888912976,
0.125634864,
-0.2990824282,
-0.6779149771,
-0.1729727536,
-0.619224906,
-1.0724768639,
-0.162975803,
-0.4800621569,
-0.2568517923,
-0.1025135815,
0.5356961489,
0.6349574924,
-0.4103445113,
-0.0122615322,
0.3506838083,
0.091297023,
-0.3989506662,
-0.3945431411,
0.1707859635,
0.0765540004,
-0.3726966977,
-0.0181363486,
0.6936739087,
-0.2452592552,
-0.6453035474,
0.28692922,
-0.0444754474,
0.5228433013,
0.9775452018,
0.1175742149,
-0.7337703705,
-0.3956107497,
-0.1522261202,
-0.0044838139,
0.1689457148,
0.600077033,
-0.4318679869,
0.7196998596,
0.3386594057,
0.4121183455,
0.3825257719,
-0.0839050487,
0.3066105843,
-0.3417130709,
-0.2354974747,
0.0354359709,
0.2450477332,
0.4100781083,
-0.5523622632,
0.3858037293,
0.1371962428,
-0.2893148363,
-0.7750788927,
0.0081776045,
-1.1088014841,
-0.4127088189,
1.2230877876,
-0.3022752404,
-0.2493273914,
0.025150286,
-0.1825862676,
0.5579858422,
-0.2032407075,
1.1655144691,
0.831938386,
-0.4225151539,
-0.3682126999,
-0.9025002718,
-0.04913342,
0.1213495359,
-0.8770801425,
-0.1575123966,
0.457723856,
0.6383043528,
-0.0320105217,
1.0359624624,
-0.2934536636,
0.2648189664,
-0.0065780897,
0.0305325501,
0.2686910629,
0.0040547485,
-0.4765725732,
0.2935073674,
0.1290272623,
-0.2319058627
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06264v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06264v1
|
LLaVA-Docent: Instruction Tuning with Multimodal Large Language Model to Support Art Appreciation Education
| 2024-02-09T09:25:18 | 2024-02-09T09:25:18 |
Unggi Lee, Minji Jeon, Yunseo Lee, Gyuri Byun, Yoorim Son, Jaeyoon Shin, Hongkyu Ko, Hyeoncheol Kim
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SI
|
Art appreciation is vital in nurturing critical thinking and emotional
intelligence among learners. However, traditional art appreciation education
has often been hindered by limited access to art resources, especially for
disadvantaged students, and an imbalanced emphasis on STEM subjects in
mainstream education. In response to these challenges, recent technological
advancements have paved the way for innovative solutions. This study explores
the application of multi-modal large language models (MLLMs) in art
appreciation education, focusing on developing LLaVA-Docent, a model that
leverages these advancements. Our approach involved a comprehensive literature
review and consultations with experts in the field, leading to developing a
robust data framework. Utilizing this framework, we generated a virtual
dialogue dataset that was leveraged by GPT-4. This dataset was instrumental in
training the MLLM, named LLaVA-Docent. Six researchers conducted quantitative
and qualitative evaluations of LLaVA-Docent to assess its effectiveness,
benchmarking it against the GPT-4 model in a few-shot setting. The evaluation
process revealed distinct strengths and weaknesses of the LLaVA-Docent model.
Our findings highlight the efficacy of LLaVA-Docent in enhancing the
accessibility and engagement of art appreciation education. By harnessing the
potential of MLLMs, this study makes a significant contribution to the field of
art education, proposing a novel methodology that reimagines the way art
appreciation is taught and experienced.
|
[
-0.1878145784,
-0.7999961972,
0.6264901161,
-0.2440552413,
-0.4117926657,
0.2382938862,
-0.3066612482,
-0.6994398236,
0.1930390149,
0.0592632964,
-0.4574134052,
-0.3936897516,
-0.5867931843,
0.0207405128,
-0.1586676687,
0.8070570827,
-0.0960064456,
0.38220191,
-0.0773136914,
-0.2033002526,
-0.6475636959,
-0.2435228676,
-0.5151969194,
-0.1334321946,
0.5640166998,
0.2765276134,
0.1352035254,
0.1195542142,
0.3272951543,
0.3801002204,
0.0096905148,
0.5313026905,
-0.5880915523,
0.0864175707,
0.1060372889,
-0.482188642,
-0.5041479468,
0.1820087433,
0.5806244016,
0.0958049819,
-0.1567284763,
-0.0521688797,
-0.1515423357,
0.6760824323,
-0.4777340889,
0.3901253939,
-0.530598402,
0.1657224447,
-0.0468441918,
-0.2554730475,
-0.3267591298,
-0.536549449,
0.1453707218,
-0.7802257538,
-0.1757999212,
-0.3966603875,
0.6019766927,
0.1098959073,
-0.5099708438,
-0.2529513836,
-0.4779530764,
0.6785410643,
-0.4167950451,
0.5042585731,
0.0924290717,
0.5685126781,
0.3148700595,
-0.5780698061,
-0.6489794254,
-0.216838479,
0.4244123697,
0.391477704,
0.1257155836,
0.0880671144,
0.0390050896,
0.4901569784,
-0.1419740021,
0.2190330923,
-0.1103649214,
-0.1406884044,
0.3794850409,
0.2653537691,
0.1940203756,
0.0813535154,
-0.5404919982,
-0.0517389737,
-0.4936081171,
0.2689340115,
0.0648513883,
-0.0363945961,
-0.0789583102,
0.5828217268,
0.1441682726,
0.6134554148,
-0.0790997297,
-0.5653498769,
0.3302483857,
-0.3842634559,
-0.14015764,
-0.4060049355,
0.4469336271,
0.7333916426,
0.5174264908,
0.2244344354,
-0.3476641178,
0.0502556637,
0.1036920547,
-1.0015779734,
-0.0530555472,
-0.157330662,
-0.4336646795,
-0.3581790924,
-0.3490011096,
-0.6317548752,
-0.6940668225,
-0.7970412374,
0.3802652955,
-0.5454185605,
-0.413159281,
0.0194955729,
-0.0821175203,
0.2289694697,
0.9177688956,
-0.7793870568,
-0.2289288193,
0.4567941725,
0.7642003894,
-0.1469439864,
-0.3225210011,
-0.3422785103,
-0.0071409466,
-0.2447288334,
0.859362781,
-0.9474816918,
-0.5108667612,
0.1725826859,
-0.0899169222,
-0.1881034523,
-0.2704651952,
0.6894555688,
-0.345459044,
0.1434652656,
-0.0981959403,
-0.4878102243,
-0.3575497568,
0.604395628,
-0.506277442,
0.8102267385,
0.3161294162,
-0.5405087471,
0.1556492895,
-0.9779934287,
-0.059696041,
0.1912021488,
-0.4982463419,
-0.3594855666,
0.2728843689,
0.2648157775,
0.3285904825,
-0.2438737005,
-0.0063813166,
-0.0793559253,
-0.4826280475,
0.4647146165,
-0.6613544822,
0.4663789272,
0.040598765,
-0.1773262322,
0.3932907581,
-0.6475960016,
-0.0606986471,
0.2516227663,
-0.5809524655,
-0.4281932116,
-0.4272447824,
0.3809011877,
0.1636044681,
0.2670990229,
-0.4828118682,
0.436514616,
-0.283141911,
0.3005040288,
1.1425142288,
-0.1260895431,
0.3935844004,
-0.2507711649,
0.7923383117,
0.0914482027,
0.3895747066,
-0.3831170499,
-0.3186075389,
-0.4732785225,
-0.4956023693,
0.0600675792,
0.3659444153,
-0.8013098836,
-0.2972986996,
-0.3743055463,
-0.4116103053,
-0.8570219278,
0.39983055,
0.3021181524,
0.4668825269,
-0.0026592603,
-0.4671543241,
-0.2543293834,
-0.703548193,
0.1481295377,
0.0548829213,
0.2141289562,
0.6063073277,
0.170141533,
-0.3047673404,
0.4622667134,
-0.2181243896,
-0.3984465897,
0.015639687,
0.003090919,
0.1399140656,
0.1297569424,
0.6342858672,
-0.6807970405,
-0.5093495846,
0.2203458995,
-0.7758658528,
0.1188838184,
0.1828552336,
-0.2115406841,
0.2980965674,
0.0449468568,
-0.5665302873,
0.2185674012,
0.5989072323,
-0.1761405766,
0.7507956028,
-0.0318629108,
0.3929868937,
-0.8947403431,
-0.0432510339,
-0.1327327043,
0.0850396156,
-0.6131752729,
0.0423093811,
0.0256554522,
-0.2456234396,
-0.5232941508,
0.4719601572,
-0.4974312782,
0.259328872,
-0.5673792958,
0.0395907685,
0.3397609293,
0.4050927162,
0.3374705911,
0.7693611383,
0.5689213872,
-0.1640956104,
0.3719143867,
0.1734712273,
-0.5428814888,
1.4879664183,
-0.4727833569,
0.3976503015,
-0.2043165863,
0.2717373669,
-0.8374348283,
0.0251732636,
0.347576797,
-0.0962581113,
0.6836019754,
-0.2998184562,
-0.2289159894,
-0.3013938069,
-0.3661954701,
0.503986299,
0.2397358716,
-0.4520716071,
1.0392898321,
0.1955616176,
-0.1416052133,
-0.7512423992,
-0.2264153361,
0.2748885155,
-0.3523670137,
-0.7311365008,
-0.347943306,
-0.6346238852,
-0.133873418,
-0.2779819667,
0.1420981288,
-0.0532991551,
0.0810861513,
0.2329776883,
0.4256267846,
-0.1599710584,
0.3034634888,
-0.1010076404,
-0.0366857722,
-0.0455854461,
-0.1728742719,
0.3662421405,
-0.3821377158,
-0.7114565372,
-0.5552607775,
0.4545155764,
0.9812822342,
-0.4252866805,
0.4572538733,
1.1969220638,
0.0994853973,
0.2583289444,
-0.8137557507,
-0.210401088,
-0.4238126278,
0.427016139,
-0.6128122211,
-0.7107995152,
0.1248448715,
-0.2873920798,
0.1749821156,
-0.1680644453,
0.6968876719,
-0.3222703636,
0.6655817032,
0.7003411055,
0.1349755377,
0.9018757939,
-0.5385283232,
-0.0299526155,
-1.2153230906,
-0.3255532384,
-0.0264068507,
-0.3309087455,
-0.0889477953,
-0.6419332623,
0.6159821749,
-0.4069133401,
0.0669186637,
-0.5329073668,
-0.3624405265,
0.3978032768,
0.280664295,
0.4347186983,
0.287309736,
0.2259566039,
-0.0106478324,
-0.1176328957,
-0.2476024777,
-0.4452362955,
1.1949747801,
0.409553349,
0.7647473812,
0.24762775,
0.4680692554,
0.2044751644,
0.5447947383,
-1.1836035252,
0.3629823327,
0.0624645427,
-0.3933378458,
-0.3119029105,
0.0124828815,
-0.8741956949,
0.3237583339,
-0.2114526629,
-0.3970655799,
0.319565922,
0.0479104444,
0.2522215545,
0.1940112561,
-0.8529347181,
0.7310912609,
-0.4903517962,
-0.6303195953,
-0.3449544609,
-0.4555778801,
0.4314679801,
-0.3160524368,
0.5764431357,
-0.1891799867,
-0.078942731,
0.1534342021,
-0.1157309636,
1.0353819132,
-0.3906641304,
-0.3721218407,
0.0710747465,
0.202038914,
0.7613856792,
-0.1779980659,
-0.233381629,
0.0067467112,
-0.1959271878,
-0.3052461743,
-0.6064535379,
0.7221513987,
-0.7911356688,
-0.6988200545,
-0.0258482136,
-0.8550810218,
-0.1098506525,
0.1706560403,
-0.2612802386,
0.3908936381,
-0.2330317646,
-0.0525424182,
0.8033801913,
-0.1201431304,
0.3061194122,
0.6490367651,
0.0030518759,
-0.279871881,
0.8511871696,
0.0347754508,
0.4237965345,
0.305627048,
0.5147779584,
-0.3426200747,
-0.3949816525,
-0.5735761523,
0.3202579021,
-1.1375236511,
-0.1313286871,
-0.4735194743,
0.0526475348,
0.0267076008,
-0.2293808907,
-0.2194323093,
-0.2949355543,
-0.3197556436,
-0.2167306989,
0.5703938007,
0.7382131815,
-0.0331708342,
-0.0095892139,
-0.4205687642,
-0.0818474516,
0.7296204567,
0.561909318,
0.289468199,
-0.6519159079,
-0.4021932781,
0.0029305872,
-0.3559650183,
-0.6477626562,
0.1646689773,
0.4802023768,
0.704890728,
0.5843264461,
-0.327659905,
0.5085992813,
-0.4370521307,
0.5699472427,
0.3530346453,
-0.7128769755,
0.6151958108,
-0.6094982028,
0.2950594425,
0.3226006031,
0.1331749111,
-0.3728809059,
-0.3009877503,
-0.2620373368,
-0.7366557717,
0.3963113427,
-0.3334060013,
0.6374094486,
0.1175157726,
-0.1397444904,
0.3431215882,
0.3235278428,
-0.9846761823,
-0.0593442395,
-0.7967185378,
0.0242516268,
-0.0256379209,
-0.5576441884,
-0.6718616486,
-0.2956383526,
0.5497013927,
-0.2975513935,
0.1546156257,
-0.0779299363,
-0.193300575,
-0.1526506692,
0.5633476973,
0.8542122841,
0.7290854454,
-0.0570549741,
-0.0879305825,
0.1735347211,
-0.5826573968,
0.274988085,
-0.2087073475,
0.0599107407,
-0.0841887817,
0.0293565486,
0.8996965885,
0.2305700928,
-0.7836467624,
0.6458918452,
-0.2310557961,
0.0590286516,
-0.4431973994,
-0.1549044847,
0.2176061273,
0.3980447054,
0.269769758,
-0.0970349386,
0.2072420865,
-0.4330610037,
-0.3480570912,
0.5296644568,
-0.3996703327,
-0.2083845288,
0.3885595798,
0.3492170572,
-0.2164614797,
0.4502660334,
0.2340317518,
-0.3746795058,
0.3969171047,
0.5973824859,
0.6782537699,
-0.1372258663,
0.2309595942,
0.0132791167,
0.3170983791,
0.3476983905,
0.1987080872,
-0.1757344753,
-0.5665214658,
-0.4393522739,
-0.4979716837,
-0.4969861209,
-0.0680923983,
-0.4407721758,
0.0792179629,
-0.2816844285,
-0.3479332924,
-0.2208724767,
-0.0683182105,
-1.0178507566,
-0.1487675458,
0.2788479328,
0.7817162871,
-1.0940967798,
0.8721922636,
0.9799561501,
-0.445143342,
-0.9377342463,
-0.3019907773,
0.313796401,
-0.9336233735,
0.8533204794,
0.067755796,
-0.2144407779,
-0.0478977524,
-0.1762583107,
-0.6410601139,
1.2120043039,
0.2554430962,
-0.7628833055,
0.3216173053,
-0.3838785589,
0.723831594,
-0.4254416227,
0.6081459522,
0.4074538946,
0.7166332603,
0.2396697998,
-0.808471024,
-0.2866648734,
-0.5381829739,
0.1190193668,
-0.0213868152,
-0.7599616051,
0.5043370128,
-0.221533075,
0.109777227,
0.0210657213,
0.2722973526,
0.567730248,
0.4447058439,
0.4142754376,
0.2948669493,
0.726660192,
-0.0119859381,
1.1232897043,
-0.0963123888,
-0.1147602275,
0.5607917905,
-0.1526976675,
0.7115464807,
0.6638768315,
-0.102818273,
0.7603303194,
0.4686218202,
0.0114844423,
0.3366522193,
0.0027722521,
-0.5536535978,
-0.0982077122,
-0.6423276067,
-0.4847738147,
0.5813874006,
0.6246117353,
-0.409562856,
-0.0063584116,
0.3894301057,
-0.1127792597,
0.1805903316,
-0.5336968303,
0.6026018262,
0.0725827068,
-0.1170206442,
0.8823031187,
-0.525564909,
0.7111051679,
-0.5102772117,
-0.1971126199,
-0.2418303192,
-0.0698457286,
-0.2198355347,
-0.6924628615,
-0.327485472,
-0.176020056,
-0.2089243382,
-0.1582180262,
0.49760741,
-0.320541203,
-0.6905902624,
0.1456760466,
0.4035304487,
0.2279292792,
0.3619851768,
-0.7127332091,
0.4663958251,
-0.166780144,
-0.0993579701,
0.3423331976,
0.6509166956,
-0.0487807132,
0.6749138832,
0.5087711215,
0.0823092833,
-0.3011953235,
0.7838118076,
0.8329260349,
-0.0350243039,
-0.0628657416,
-0.5759985447,
0.7171484828,
0.1095555723,
-0.1047884896,
0.5611691475,
0.3113156855,
0.5401137471,
-0.4754398465,
0.6946057081,
0.2760683596,
0.2639430463,
-0.5513752103,
0.4401270449,
-0.5998060703,
0.3742087781,
-0.4899406433,
-0.7180780768,
-0.006430015,
0.6320645809,
-0.4221376479,
0.1643950194,
0.5356985927,
0.6799150705,
-0.0583986901,
-0.2595944405,
0.5399643779,
0.0838165656,
0.4334999323,
0.577090621,
1.2724078894,
-0.0131580383,
0.4619495273,
-0.2001450956,
-0.3429096043,
-0.357270211,
-0.8943597674,
-1.0183074474,
-0.4629504979,
-0.1066234559,
0.0205021743,
0.1765951216,
0.7826014161,
0.5806798935,
-0.2848733664,
-0.314878583,
0.4864574075,
0.0205964353,
-0.2377470881,
-0.2229675502,
0.510749042,
-0.1236995757,
-0.9737358093,
0.2681782246,
0.5803154707,
0.2533297241,
-0.4715255499,
-0.1978750378,
0.0221872274,
0.0489555374,
0.9987901449,
0.0826132968,
-0.9865911603,
-0.2524496019,
0.0741618946,
-0.0277546924,
0.2492796928,
0.6726815104,
-0.4354979098,
1.0671024323,
0.0918290392,
0.5851342678,
0.5560495853,
-0.0448696911,
0.4460713565,
-0.437443614,
0.1896259338,
0.1171115115,
0.4566814005,
0.5258806348,
-0.3823978603,
0.4698450565,
0.2498767227,
-0.6119212508,
-0.7090444565,
0.3783285618,
-1.0230236053,
-0.0269055627,
0.8822947741,
-0.1878878623,
0.105947949,
-0.0031189502,
-0.7040137649,
0.0722527131,
-0.4237595201,
1.0402293205,
0.6702331901,
-0.2115087062,
-0.7827563286,
-0.6319140792,
0.0085778339,
0.2216573507,
-0.7320208549,
-0.1632472873,
0.7614336014,
0.5055786371,
-0.1549315751,
0.6514768004,
-0.2716050446,
0.5673635006,
-0.227685675,
0.1522001773,
-0.4901401997,
-0.1889901608,
-0.2879112065,
-0.1203327999,
0.6140189171,
-0.0748760924
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06262v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06262v2
|
On the Efficacy of Eviction Policy for Key-Value Constrained Generative Language Model Inference
| 2024-02-09T09:20:59 | 2024-02-17T10:08:14 |
Siyu Ren, Kenny Q. Zhu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Despite the recent success associated with Large Language Models (LLMs), they
are notably cost-prohibitive to deploy in resource-constrained environments due
to their excessive memory and computational demands. In addition to model
parameters, the key-value cache is also stored in GPU memory, growing linearly
with batch size and sequence length. As a remedy, recent works have proposed
various eviction policies for maintaining the overhead of key-value cache under
a given budget. This paper embarks on the efficacy of existing eviction
policies in terms of importance score calculation and eviction scope
construction. We identify the deficiency of prior policies in these two aspects
and introduce RoCo, a robust cache omission policy based on temporal attention
scores and robustness measures. Extensive experimentation spanning prefilling
and auto-regressive decoding stages validates the superiority of RoCo. Finally,
we release EasyKV, a versatile software package dedicated to user-friendly
key-value constrained generative inference. Code available at
https://github.com/DRSY/EasyKV.
|
[
-0.1650965363,
-0.6554265618,
0.6969421506,
-0.1150687635,
-0.1378947049,
-0.2445512563,
-0.5595846772,
-0.1029823795,
-0.1207937524,
0.433096081,
-0.212138474,
-0.5854911804,
-0.4357638657,
-0.1908321977,
-0.1914419532,
0.7745590806,
0.033829961,
-0.4083628356,
-0.1003788561,
0.046818655,
-0.34199211,
-0.1376222074,
-0.3099116683,
0.1032780409,
0.3127455711,
0.3870808482,
0.7748818994,
0.8748723865,
0.3672388792,
0.1911402941,
-0.2944499552,
0.0174150299,
-0.5190736651,
0.1823416352,
0.0996253267,
-0.3978926837,
-0.4094886482,
-0.1180725247,
0.7432032824,
-0.0380368754,
-0.6508387327,
-0.1562660038,
-0.2130272239,
0.3375338316,
-1.0886902809,
0.2225873917,
-1.1431053877,
-0.0984241813,
-0.0951936767,
-0.0422923639,
-0.5443052053,
-0.3205532432,
-0.1740296185,
-0.5495971441,
0.3536189497,
-0.131220296,
1.2329843044,
0.5952388048,
-0.0455420353,
-0.3631269932,
-0.744897604,
0.8741469383,
-0.6613035798,
0.1922833472,
0.5419074297,
0.2631660998,
-0.2442058474,
-0.4338879287,
-0.5824664235,
-0.1525703669,
0.3606465459,
0.1481492221,
0.0842576176,
0.4250372946,
0.2192225009,
0.5230641961,
-0.1908908039,
0.4929301441,
-0.2872564197,
-0.1524086744,
0.1636147797,
0.1414283067,
0.2637253404,
-0.2715260088,
-0.1718123555,
-0.1905420125,
-1.1026391983,
0.2389205694,
0.4606281817,
0.3792934418,
0.1226806194,
0.4921189845,
-0.0243658163,
0.3728479445,
-0.1648788154,
-0.0556606427,
0.077604048,
-0.272706151,
-0.3773508966,
-0.0119501939,
0.6736114025,
0.1020200253,
0.0477472469,
-0.3313167989,
-0.1525501311,
-0.0314214192,
0.5521946549,
-0.6380471587,
-0.0326428674,
0.3501549661,
-0.3343361616,
-0.5190393329,
-0.1829060912,
-1.0804227591,
0.0812443569,
0.3290372789,
0.0903329104,
-0.1325053424,
-0.2544261515,
-0.1028216779,
-0.026694648,
0.6791836619,
0.4893119633,
-1.1451696157,
0.1694133878,
0.5847475529,
0.7068808675,
-0.1364443153,
-0.0132953245,
-0.686924696,
0.0426379628,
-0.3198540509,
0.2059686035,
-0.7668691874,
-0.4058688581,
0.1201271489,
-0.0705625266,
0.0264463257,
-0.5334596634,
0.6175783277,
-0.6677439213,
-0.2987898886,
-0.1076422855,
-0.2417773753,
0.092451036,
0.1609482467,
-0.7876095176,
1.0853747129,
0.3504289687,
-0.1090878174,
0.4538927376,
-0.1831777096,
-0.2710326314,
0.0420614891,
-0.2498135418,
-0.8621970415,
0.202145189,
0.2360920906,
0.401035428,
-0.3578473628,
0.4646354914,
-0.4293464422,
-0.0642892569,
-0.2078392953,
-0.586548388,
0.6027735472,
0.6218639612,
-0.3210594952,
-0.1293139458,
-0.6580724716,
0.0830758065,
0.0787378252,
-0.4668680131,
-0.3200401366,
0.2674641609,
-0.2096737027,
0.1667987108,
0.1949938089,
-0.4150239229,
0.3327293694,
-0.2019656748,
0.5860242844,
0.6925317049,
-0.3051228523,
0.4898527861,
0.0747112781,
0.8206553459,
-0.2977747321,
0.1953924,
-0.1235156655,
-0.4207769334,
-0.5481801629,
-0.6080031395,
0.0379740223,
0.4459119141,
-0.3161557913,
0.2542517483,
-0.3903953433,
0.0364166647,
-0.5646263361,
0.2486896962,
0.4628127813,
0.0172175281,
0.1459805965,
-0.0885897726,
-0.043611303,
-0.5861594677,
-0.0089847697,
-0.2633885145,
0.2813041508,
0.4849510789,
0.3958725929,
0.0509943403,
0.7898308039,
-0.2383012027,
-0.0315747187,
-0.2416207939,
0.1706758142,
-0.0727453604,
0.3842504323,
0.5320494175,
-0.7566541433,
-0.247316137,
-0.0468352661,
-0.3748164177,
-0.0438325442,
-0.1429417878,
0.1894692779,
0.2263495177,
0.4975145459,
-0.6759791374,
0.6225464344,
0.6144800782,
0.2281345129,
0.5774881244,
-0.5337802768,
-0.0356303677,
-0.6651885509,
-0.1545048058,
-0.2575221062,
-0.3458986282,
-0.4034170806,
0.3858951032,
0.0114584472,
-0.0358773731,
-0.4562714696,
0.3130811155,
-0.4733772874,
-0.0437861942,
0.0645390674,
-0.0082655111,
-0.1453597695,
0.5232260823,
0.182268396,
0.8002839088,
0.1378090829,
-0.635926187,
-0.0523868129,
0.0186704304,
-0.323818326,
0.1125439405,
-0.4188254178,
0.191560477,
-0.1410870403,
0.051873289,
-1.2441893816,
-0.0251846574,
0.1284198612,
-0.1524266601,
0.6537359953,
-0.4786474705,
-0.3832158744,
-0.220739603,
-0.3689842522,
0.4979108274,
0.7015723586,
-0.5149794221,
0.4916492701,
0.6313570738,
0.0084034437,
-0.7561182976,
-0.2770776451,
0.0917437077,
-0.4893878698,
-0.0312204864,
0.2189007401,
0.0600546189,
-0.2360191196,
0.2506425083,
0.0486966632,
-0.2073400766,
0.1440600306,
0.3125962615,
0.2429594398,
-0.0467883199,
0.3347201943,
0.0489419103,
0.0559738092,
0.1347820163,
0.0775449276,
0.3263138533,
-0.1701646745,
-0.3183591068,
-0.1212519854,
0.0899040774,
1.0289597511,
-0.0635299683,
0.6061056852,
0.4378260374,
-0.1824947298,
-0.2919979692,
-0.685112834,
0.1851698607,
-0.4048778117,
0.4983783364,
-0.5481835008,
-0.9120990634,
0.5930528641,
-0.2384404987,
0.1470901668,
0.6018481255,
0.6192835569,
0.0013142276,
0.7490379214,
0.3460561335,
-0.2886691093,
0.5255382061,
-0.371638,
0.2597747445,
-1.0220043659,
0.0543741621,
-0.7247071266,
0.101222761,
-0.778814435,
-0.4105809331,
0.083141692,
0.1990232468,
-0.0600517169,
0.1684231907,
-0.535253644,
0.3481712043,
0.253860414,
0.1136226058,
-0.0501511879,
-0.1288375109,
-0.1363904327,
-0.0396427922,
-0.9087618589,
-0.3102639616,
1.3064528704,
0.2624838948,
0.8187229633,
-0.0051996834,
0.7284436226,
0.3233367801,
0.2945609689,
-0.7746573091,
0.1768376976,
0.0495131686,
-0.4411736429,
-0.686207056,
-0.4915427566,
-0.8316521645,
0.3769097924,
0.2271448076,
-0.9593473077,
0.289023608,
0.3619041145,
-0.5563147068,
0.506922543,
-0.4644499421,
0.9685430527,
-0.1710614264,
-0.6148117781,
-0.5249010324,
-0.473207742,
0.385240078,
0.0190302003,
0.2553493381,
-0.2023333162,
0.0722747222,
0.3523088992,
-0.7850156426,
0.824243784,
-0.1403429657,
-0.0034494172,
0.6349309087,
0.0647535101,
1.1826031208,
-0.1171870381,
0.0271383151,
0.051085256,
-0.0146311484,
-0.1723478287,
-0.3964928687,
0.7931491733,
-0.7277829647,
-0.6194424629,
-0.1844606698,
-0.3777887523,
0.2205430716,
-0.1619808376,
0.326797843,
0.3102656901,
-0.398598671,
0.2196898311,
1.0251475573,
-0.5772640705,
0.5056701303,
0.1626473963,
0.1016219705,
-0.2478764206,
0.9286471605,
-0.0879685432,
0.7030192018,
0.4904359281,
0.4749071598,
-0.2409486026,
-0.5610734224,
-0.3354028761,
-0.0400050618,
-0.5223755836,
-0.0797292814,
-0.5782923698,
-0.3303121626,
-0.3367392719,
-0.2954433858,
-0.7796263099,
-0.3653765917,
-0.2064360827,
-0.1266471148,
0.3607789874,
0.5129585266,
-0.2101444006,
0.1105724424,
-0.4041238427,
0.3420562744,
0.4467793405,
0.0678807199,
0.0830784217,
-0.5522257686,
-0.1868043542,
-0.1336905956,
-0.1852142811,
-0.4854515195,
0.6237401366,
0.2813053131,
0.6606962681,
0.6842352748,
0.2016744763,
0.6636055112,
-0.2849162817,
0.6514635682,
-0.0151967611,
-0.6943482757,
0.5345600247,
-0.3284023702,
0.327488631,
0.5547417402,
-0.0250900239,
-0.1997590512,
-0.6858918667,
-0.6853839755,
-1.0592556,
0.5571971536,
0.1197668016,
0.1551660597,
-0.2232366651,
0.4891896844,
-0.0050598658,
0.3499299884,
-0.6419411302,
-0.0806504712,
-0.0694294572,
-0.123000972,
0.1340983957,
-0.6363893747,
0.2158935815,
-0.2067502439,
0.5100823641,
0.1226947382,
0.3526630998,
-0.0920245945,
-0.2504302859,
-0.0498206913,
0.5734026432,
0.8113843799,
0.4280065298,
-0.441354692,
0.0615992956,
0.1256176233,
-0.4900999069,
0.1179473922,
-0.3858421445,
-0.2797288895,
-0.1046166047,
-0.1030499116,
0.489412725,
0.3703674376,
-0.5493293405,
0.5901997685,
0.0263252258,
-0.0007731522,
-0.3509001732,
0.0139032463,
-0.3406530321,
-0.2286441475,
0.0396763943,
-0.2884380519,
0.0213681757,
-0.4177623391,
0.0170174241,
0.7006459832,
-0.6752831936,
-0.2509862483,
0.8957691789,
0.1499628276,
-0.0344843678,
0.9283816814,
-0.4906289279,
-0.7544556856,
0.9684396982,
0.2899112999,
1.139770627,
-0.2850826085,
0.1861111671,
0.4858269989,
0.6646719575,
-0.2011477053,
0.1056505814,
-0.4805074036,
-0.9553614855,
-0.4799889028,
-0.5129571557,
-0.0922933295,
0.4738581479,
-0.6032776833,
0.0124702873,
-0.4182874858,
-0.0622041225,
-0.5625,
-0.2068472654,
-0.8853712678,
-0.1551771164,
0.0646020696,
0.4484682381,
-0.8473875523,
1.0461970568,
0.0547733419,
-0.356623739,
-0.6141014099,
-0.2869236171,
0.2375681251,
-0.9818605185,
0.8560630083,
-0.0320180096,
-0.155859381,
-0.0469897799,
-0.4808141887,
-0.727845788,
0.8228678107,
0.2584508359,
-0.5700609088,
-0.0695684701,
-0.1837145537,
0.3551606834,
-0.183375895,
0.2063831538,
0.5020294189,
0.4957457185,
0.1639431715,
-0.7657440901,
-0.0676990002,
-0.0123582846,
0.1525716782,
0.4267148077,
-0.6285241842,
0.5540370345,
-0.5306656957,
-0.2024505734,
0.2375215292,
0.4331621528,
-0.0940029919,
-0.0065115313,
0.4621424973,
1.1140675545,
0.5944677591,
-0.1668910235,
1.1700150967,
-0.3815635443,
0.483179301,
1.1772123575,
-0.2134801745,
0.8298274279,
0.5037745237,
-0.262257129,
0.2177435309,
0.4689012468,
0.1670582741,
0.9314262271,
0.2153434008,
-0.3680764437,
-0.3713053167,
-0.0588692389,
-0.1916428208,
0.4849264324,
0.7772654891,
-0.4569463432,
-0.3308440149,
-0.3054300249,
0.1903994232,
-0.3272522986,
-0.2064603418,
0.582316339,
0.0318226516,
-0.6763886809,
0.3313038051,
-0.2866432965,
0.2010167241,
-0.7093868256,
-0.3157223761,
0.0511569865,
0.1816407889,
0.0720790476,
-0.3335239589,
0.0665390342,
-0.1645246446,
-0.0965741947,
-0.4979114234,
0.3822341859,
-0.5478925705,
-0.1459847689,
0.1004936248,
0.0237954333,
0.2507382035,
0.0639554113,
-0.3942973018,
0.1003515199,
-0.1616457701,
-0.23515369,
0.4386745393,
0.4017904699,
0.0382338911,
0.6223105788,
0.4491449594,
0.4533056915,
0.2455863953,
0.0452776887,
0.5968976617,
-0.3603671491,
-0.3597400188,
-0.7495823503,
0.0992053375,
0.1893243939,
-0.3069930971,
0.6652403474,
0.4149138331,
0.641115725,
0.235532403,
0.8005441427,
-0.1693579555,
-0.1544055194,
-0.6369645596,
0.3888934851,
-0.4935853779,
0.3900741935,
-0.2799684107,
-0.7186108828,
-0.0660444051,
0.5549224615,
-0.3694918752,
0.1101298928,
0.5975730419,
0.9059861302,
0.1542140841,
-0.5569635034,
0.5370883942,
0.0074968389,
0.4304795861,
0.7336426973,
0.7017881274,
-0.251647532,
0.5927736163,
-0.0856477618,
-0.1651439071,
-0.5666424632,
-0.9528189301,
-0.5014715195,
-0.4611833096,
-0.3930105269,
-0.3482387364,
0.3575047553,
0.6462436318,
0.5876920223,
-0.7784898877,
-0.050293386,
-0.3052468896,
0.4392223954,
-0.4032907784,
-0.2965141535,
0.5783888698,
-0.5397571921,
-0.6225099564,
0.1616367102,
0.5966930985,
-0.160028398,
-0.353168726,
-0.2156044841,
-0.1281214058,
-0.2147624344,
0.4015333354,
0.8023121953,
-1.1453700066,
-0.4487994313,
-0.3162329197,
-0.4225809276,
0.3233188689,
0.9420963526,
-0.6348996758,
1.1055300236,
0.576403141,
0.7223387361,
0.6590630412,
-0.0814656764,
0.6897593141,
-0.4133050144,
0.0861698017,
0.095804058,
0.3476152122,
-0.095412232,
-0.5979924798,
0.2940863371,
0.1220336854,
-0.5547181368,
-0.7090025544,
0.1705349237,
-0.8310613632,
-0.1098265201,
1.1582255363,
-0.2862674296,
-0.4653162956,
-0.142588526,
0.2898231149,
0.0255984683,
-0.6241142154,
0.9362914562,
0.8394521475,
0.2772879899,
-0.5222508907,
-0.8152501583,
0.5431442857,
0.1856675446,
-0.6190256476,
0.2006980926,
0.4017757773,
0.0236303881,
-0.0787920728,
0.6096847653,
-0.2469588667,
0.2870873511,
0.0715110302,
0.3435952961,
-0.019864846,
-0.4748593867,
-0.462972194,
0.1034052074,
0.1254588515,
-0.3245836794
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06255v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06255v2
|
Fight Back Against Jailbreaking via Prompt Adversarial Tuning
| 2024-02-09T09:09:39 | 2024-06-09T16:18:46 |
Yichuan Mo, Yuji Wang, Zeming Wei, Yisen Wang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
While Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved tremendous success in
various applications, they are also susceptible to jailbreak attacks. Several
primary defense strategies have been proposed to protect LLMs from producing
harmful information, mostly with a particular focus on harmful content
filtering or heuristical defensive prompt designs. However, how to achieve
intrinsic robustness through the prompts remains an open problem. In this
paper, motivated by adversarial training paradigms for achieving reliable
robustness, we propose an approach named Prompt Adversarial Tuning (PAT) that
trains a prompt control attached to the user prompt as a guard prefix. To
achieve our defense goal whilst maintaining natural performance, we optimize
the control prompt with both adversarial and benign prompts. Comprehensive
experiments show that our method is effective against both black-box and
white-box attacks, reducing the success rate of advanced attacks to nearly 0
while maintaining the model's utility on the benign task. The proposed defense
strategy incurs only negligible computational overhead, charting a new
perspective for future explorations in LLM security. Our code is available at
https://github.com/rain152/PAT.
|
[
-0.4716869593,
-1.0557665825,
0.3960132301,
0.1153565049,
-0.4185979962,
0.3827179074,
-0.4077683091,
-0.0273297895,
-0.0066338121,
0.6522592306,
-0.7297692299,
-0.3788767755,
-0.6359217763,
0.1130518764,
0.0807312429,
1.0103724003,
0.1909074485,
-0.051317133,
0.3055877686,
0.0422665924,
-0.9367864132,
-0.2779052854,
-0.8962826729,
0.0238081291,
0.4270372987,
0.1191535294,
0.7453559637,
0.8172103167,
0.2382779121,
0.2543337941,
-0.3371207118,
0.3856661022,
-0.3817440271,
0.5223526955,
-0.1060422361,
-0.5072555542,
-0.1702904403,
0.0455431864,
0.1405281276,
0.139894098,
0.0830549449,
-0.366845727,
-0.0127166631,
0.5250831842,
-0.6364349127,
-0.1833035946,
-0.9471993446,
-0.0008130767,
-0.343114078,
-0.4200805426,
-0.6486718655,
-0.5019931793,
-0.3760921359,
-0.5237008333,
0.0815637857,
0.262268275,
0.8662701845,
0.4367136359,
-0.3083649278,
-0.1430920362,
-0.2581023872,
0.4090792239,
-0.5435458422,
-0.0186459497,
0.5598230958,
0.236460343,
-0.6882887483,
0.0038808752,
-0.2259503156,
-0.6110867262,
0.2499467731,
-0.0712067038,
-0.3739787638,
0.185639292,
0.3316764832,
-0.00668763,
-0.6115069389,
0.4691742957,
-0.1157601923,
-0.4355254769,
0.2783452868,
0.1383522302,
0.5432677865,
0.0100006871,
-0.6948305368,
-0.0625962541,
-1.1289601326,
0.4936137795,
0.7119219303,
0.5145839453,
-0.0095100701,
0.4748876691,
0.1601299793,
0.6456438899,
0.3786248565,
-0.0062973271,
-0.3703437448,
-0.0179338194,
0.0990668833,
0.1711679697,
0.8171254396,
0.3980880976,
0.3781303465,
-0.4876125455,
-0.3417716026,
0.1302767098,
0.6072762609,
-0.7521162629,
-0.3266903162,
0.0395432934,
-0.0344070122,
-0.6529712081,
0.1411219239,
-0.8107055426,
-0.9920556545,
-0.0747807398,
0.2095333487,
-0.7462012172,
0.1044721156,
-0.1931468248,
-0.178861171,
-0.057528086,
0.0983592421,
-1.0102825165,
0.1683700234,
0.7998834848,
0.983653307,
-0.0627598688,
-0.1680929363,
-1.1676151752,
-0.0029727295,
-0.4651008248,
0.5466002226,
-0.2048828602,
-0.6789999008,
-0.1021356583,
0.0953872949,
-0.1008275226,
-0.5067056417,
0.5490351915,
-0.9012951851,
-0.2461073548,
-0.2807661295,
-0.3196311891,
0.2758862376,
0.3795861602,
-0.7403454781,
0.4469021857,
-0.2068975419,
-0.648455739,
0.3482794166,
-0.2592291236,
-0.689507544,
0.032734368,
0.118323952,
-0.517126143,
0.1521053612,
0.47584638,
0.1350359321,
-0.1048756391,
0.3589604795,
-0.6358035803,
-0.4271826744,
0.4379869103,
-0.4535765648,
0.8987482786,
0.3875843883,
-0.463619113,
0.2895844877,
-0.5860710144,
-0.1798616201,
0.1281615794,
-0.34988451,
-0.4908347726,
-0.0475565419,
-0.4749358594,
-0.0171547327,
0.1487407386,
-0.5519602895,
0.4295528233,
-0.4707064331,
0.5873878002,
1.2113010883,
0.0042749126,
0.4213796258,
-0.196592465,
0.784806788,
-0.1308952272,
0.2922316194,
-0.4710128605,
-0.2548567355,
-0.3615608215,
-0.407938838,
0.0862765536,
0.7817593217,
-0.9240956306,
0.684219718,
0.184164077,
-0.2483126521,
-0.4465964437,
0.4351749122,
0.488288939,
0.6509399414,
0.3315704167,
-0.0130327577,
-0.3452338278,
-0.5213209987,
-0.4347645044,
-0.2601825595,
0.050201796,
0.2225639075,
0.1243092641,
0.0941777527,
0.6599801183,
-0.4322889447,
0.0632550567,
-0.3100485504,
-0.1070641354,
0.2041579336,
0.5988432169,
0.6085978746,
-0.5744452477,
-0.2183140516,
-0.3402889371,
-0.5768435001,
-0.5147287846,
-0.2502622008,
-0.213516295,
0.0115098432,
0.5707012415,
-0.6701054573,
0.2819515467,
0.0346895345,
-0.8538987637,
0.7032361031,
-0.0155292153,
0.0669277236,
-0.8394832015,
-0.0290566832,
0.0914829373,
-0.4298815131,
-0.4238847792,
0.3844928145,
0.1977888197,
-0.4394812286,
-0.4095992148,
0.5145812035,
-0.1895277053,
0.5786033869,
-0.4546892941,
0.0257851277,
0.0807754993,
0.2645737529,
-0.3960174322,
1.143809557,
0.664736867,
-0.5849081278,
0.5414152741,
0.2172693759,
-0.0881084204,
0.5941059589,
-0.9074168205,
0.0990083665,
-0.0561854914,
0.166144222,
-0.8089005947,
0.0875921547,
0.4165189564,
-0.4659467041,
0.6726007462,
-0.3816361725,
-0.2476823032,
-0.3259873092,
-0.6721860766,
-0.1765107214,
0.4140404463,
-0.7860965133,
0.1620371342,
0.1106621027,
-0.2448725849,
-0.5991345048,
-0.4960604906,
0.4241366982,
-0.6103426218,
-0.7191870809,
0.2618328929,
-0.2482231557,
-0.249290213,
-0.2540806532,
-0.1408604383,
0.1687127948,
0.7489709258,
0.2044146359,
0.5330864191,
-0.0477596596,
-0.2384051681,
-0.2457240373,
-0.2703118324,
0.2417798936,
-0.3502978086,
0.6153057814,
0.0577388816,
-0.103782177,
-0.4269065261,
0.2996875644,
0.6647679806,
-0.1672339439,
0.7769354582,
0.3448671401,
0.0190086383,
-0.570220232,
-0.3728789985,
-0.2626728415,
-0.5475903749,
0.1054146439,
-0.2678037286,
-0.9155806303,
0.5380271673,
-0.1564584374,
-0.1319520622,
-0.1750311852,
0.3390399814,
0.0986270607,
0.9922808409,
0.5699739456,
-0.4426623881,
0.7298078537,
0.1041302681,
0.0500572622,
-0.6766085029,
-0.0421691015,
-0.547388792,
-0.1922465116,
-0.3667863011,
0.1924470067,
0.3362657726,
0.3915789723,
-0.6155110002,
0.5043212175,
-0.328884393,
0.5879848003,
0.7129597664,
0.3416779637,
-0.0577341616,
-0.2601303756,
-0.1681349874,
0.0100910366,
-0.3880678117,
-0.4816024303,
0.8448586464,
0.4285987616,
1.0376062393,
0.177112639,
0.4596992731,
0.4515435696,
-0.1433759928,
-0.5274801254,
0.576513648,
-0.2225497961,
-0.3755278885,
0.0302825198,
-0.5465612411,
-0.741202116,
0.1464652121,
0.0617319979,
-0.8790278435,
-0.1311324239,
0.2823898792,
-0.5102234483,
0.4965591431,
-0.6381630301,
0.9030969143,
-0.4629603028,
-0.5845817327,
0.1859198213,
-0.7996528149,
0.5517165661,
0.0498483181,
-0.0180050191,
-0.0937781334,
0.0298274662,
0.4554371834,
-0.6353913546,
0.9673491716,
-0.4940941334,
0.0495291762,
0.0580770671,
0.3619810045,
0.9226552248,
0.4221504033,
-0.0159061067,
-0.4420524538,
-0.4186377525,
-0.4365975261,
-0.5097140074,
0.7498012781,
-0.7183209658,
-1.0291296244,
-0.2504775524,
-0.4238112569,
-0.2106743753,
0.1222365797,
0.5411720276,
0.4215342999,
-0.1217664778,
-0.1568115056,
1.052387476,
-0.449218601,
0.6255649328,
0.5560145974,
0.2326891869,
-0.6543463469,
0.8012883067,
-0.250697732,
0.3174819052,
0.1037105918,
0.2845990658,
-0.3359608054,
-0.6001864672,
-0.7661969066,
-0.1928077638,
-0.3798769116,
-0.5423598886,
-0.2395062745,
0.0424816087,
-0.381275028,
-0.4000289738,
-0.2078087926,
-0.3006139398,
-0.422549665,
-0.0832168683,
0.5484800339,
0.2766836882,
0.0427485481,
0.5587925911,
-0.4647041559,
0.4102075696,
0.1731545031,
0.2057506442,
-0.3149999082,
-0.6017377377,
0.0319565386,
-0.2052656412,
-0.6270394325,
-0.956510067,
0.3712978959,
0.1333162934,
0.4233666956,
0.5830417871,
0.498344779,
0.3550034463,
-0.5175318718,
0.7522696257,
0.2238526344,
-0.8260313272,
0.9678206444,
-0.4491335452,
0.2928802669,
0.839774549,
-0.029437365,
-0.2473510802,
-0.5486471653,
-0.2997407317,
-0.9083849192,
0.6356851459,
-0.2313421667,
0.0960913971,
-0.0833358318,
0.2809619904,
0.0852695704,
0.331705153,
-0.6450423002,
-0.259790957,
-0.3200730979,
0.0116538797,
-0.0609764382,
-0.0991640538,
-0.3496130109,
0.1596452296,
0.7200449705,
-0.0515207574,
-0.1385458112,
-0.0631370172,
-0.1701875478,
0.0296540298,
0.4751524925,
0.5287344456,
0.1163198426,
-0.0873041302,
0.4557006955,
-0.157830447,
-0.5312224627,
0.5434254408,
0.3637676835,
-0.6047738791,
-0.455165267,
0.2993243933,
1.1141154766,
-0.126558736,
-0.5942063928,
0.6223467588,
-0.2142679691,
0.2625913024,
0.0089160614,
0.387963593,
-0.4162811041,
0.148365289,
0.1340633333,
0.3838018775,
-0.2561988831,
-0.3502147496,
0.2390477806,
0.6058288813,
-0.4670903683,
-0.2976223826,
1.0793870687,
0.2761527598,
-0.4195463061,
0.4688705206,
-0.3785550594,
-0.8278439641,
0.7999569178,
0.8828265667,
1.0159192085,
-0.1635065973,
0.0993487909,
-0.03800603,
0.7056186199,
0.0344925448,
0.1501151323,
0.0122664077,
-0.5183821321,
-0.1667615175,
-0.4393181801,
-0.3466464877,
0.2110096961,
-0.4771631062,
0.2639690042,
-0.97772789,
-0.1593966484,
-0.359082669,
-0.0992686227,
-0.1795752347,
-0.028611267,
0.116661042,
1.0931280851,
-0.6150888205,
0.6261923909,
0.589743495,
-0.1588651389,
-0.4880689383,
-0.001168191,
0.4267084599,
-0.703843832,
0.3290184736,
0.3770698309,
-0.2003521621,
-0.2590074241,
-0.5806450248,
-0.4652787447,
0.6655330062,
0.6565976143,
-0.607719183,
0.275891602,
-0.2812997103,
0.1506314129,
0.0052582826,
-0.0808325484,
0.6800952554,
0.4793938696,
-0.178968966,
-0.4648253918,
0.3673413396,
-0.5364855528,
-0.1467777789,
0.4118541181,
-0.7200046182,
0.5725734234,
-0.3174112439,
-0.1895776093,
0.3201900423,
0.4234077334,
0.5476147532,
0.2176268697,
0.6485421062,
0.7190209627,
0.7362205982,
-0.3458343148,
1.0220185518,
-0.5850225091,
-0.1681305468,
0.9147852659,
-0.1587089896,
0.2222279012,
0.3943304718,
0.0560938679,
0.013982635,
0.683111608,
-0.3375024199,
0.8739853501,
0.4500012994,
-0.4530810416,
-0.2790664136,
-0.2140169442,
-0.3660289049,
0.1080640405,
0.2189120054,
-0.120206736,
-0.01912269,
0.4073138237,
0.515406251,
0.4195324183,
-0.466894865,
0.7288917303,
-0.0130740926,
-0.7830808163,
0.7156933546,
0.1383294016,
0.8749806881,
-0.9084338546,
0.4259545207,
-0.2110335529,
0.1549941599,
0.1588117778,
-0.4379128814,
0.0263784397,
0.3290877342,
-0.222200498,
-0.094930619,
0.7554126978,
-0.0865243599,
-0.0896640047,
0.3122025132,
-0.0225031693,
-0.4038206339,
0.0575503185,
-0.5379137397,
0.1588491797,
-0.0671256632,
-0.29118222,
0.3832301795,
0.3008543551,
0.1179296151,
0.8030113578,
0.6408976316,
0.4289049804,
0.1448857486,
-0.0052662748,
1.2313996553,
-0.6891419888,
-0.9095304012,
-1.2769430876,
0.2191489488,
-0.0504959226,
-0.5414071083,
0.7237887383,
0.3242585063,
0.4746067524,
0.2204885781,
0.9263427258,
-0.0055206623,
0.1407464147,
-0.8451067805,
0.7280377746,
-0.0978903845,
0.6946259141,
-0.1168220788,
-0.4050530791,
-0.265753448,
0.1831370741,
-0.2441993654,
-0.1545963287,
0.4366130233,
0.8589219451,
0.0941044539,
0.0866199657,
0.1104887053,
0.1533078551,
0.6846092343,
0.7461956739,
1.0710229874,
0.0625591874,
0.5141055584,
-0.2009416074,
-0.4059957862,
0.0575212389,
-0.881983161,
-1.1340335608,
0.1109979302,
-0.0535390824,
-0.6521439552,
0.519227922,
0.9402874708,
0.732976079,
-0.870824635,
0.2478844672,
-0.2489649653,
0.2297885418,
-0.1657859534,
-0.2232870162,
0.2542968392,
-0.6487952471,
-0.2662588656,
1.0880632401,
0.201240629,
0.0806928203,
-0.1927484125,
0.0311098956,
0.1634149849,
0.0891695321,
0.0861609355,
0.510687232,
-0.6677186489,
-0.2187069356,
-0.0276667699,
-0.1469809711,
-0.0934860706,
0.9303420782,
-0.7251901627,
0.5635471344,
0.1874664426,
0.9145879745,
-0.1244099587,
0.3346261382,
0.7701138258,
-0.8797916174,
0.2626482546,
0.1504101902,
0.4162187576,
0.3952902257,
-0.7249548435,
0.1502645314,
0.2395896614,
-0.6299546957,
-0.8454508185,
0.4544681609,
-0.8181809187,
-0.5871509314,
0.976099968,
-0.4695239663,
-0.3120275736,
-0.1693981588,
-0.3857659698,
0.0816186219,
-0.8047595024,
0.9324547052,
0.5160849094,
0.1814844161,
0.0233512409,
-0.4359941483,
0.639315486,
0.2803703547,
-0.5346208811,
0.2993150353,
0.3404448926,
0.1478737891,
-0.0933826789,
0.0672191381,
0.0136844274,
0.4207876325,
-0.1737402827,
-0.4277927876,
-0.7176377773,
-0.5581985712,
-0.7521742582,
0.4477838874,
0.1262334883,
-0.3043265939
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06221v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06221v2
|
ResumeFlow: An LLM-facilitated Pipeline for Personalized Resume Generation and Refinement
| 2024-02-09T07:13:44 | 2024-05-08T03:09:10 |
Saurabh Bhausaheb Zinjad, Amrita Bhattacharjee, Amey Bhilegaonkar, Huan Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Crafting the ideal, job-specific resume is a challenging task for many job
applicants, especially for early-career applicants. While it is highly
recommended that applicants tailor their resume to the specific role they are
applying for, manually tailoring resumes to job descriptions and role-specific
requirements is often (1) extremely time-consuming, and (2) prone to human
errors. Furthermore, performing such a tailoring step at scale while applying
to several roles may result in a lack of quality of the edited resumes. To
tackle this problem, in this demo paper, we propose ResumeFlow: a Large
Language Model (LLM) aided tool that enables an end user to simply provide
their detailed resume and the desired job posting, and obtain a personalized
resume specifically tailored to that specific job posting in the matter of a
few seconds. Our proposed pipeline leverages the language understanding and
information extraction capabilities of state-of-the-art LLMs such as OpenAI's
GPT-4 and Google's Gemini, in order to (1) extract details from a job
description, (2) extract role-specific details from the user-provided resume,
and then (3) use these to refine and generate a role-specific resume for the
user. Our easy-to-use tool leverages the user-chosen LLM in a completely
off-the-shelf manner, thus requiring no fine-tuning. We demonstrate the
effectiveness of our tool via a video demo and propose novel task-specific
evaluation metrics to control for alignment and hallucination. Our tool is
available at https://job-aligned-resume.streamlit.app.
|
[
-0.1192892566,
-0.5043219924,
0.552595377,
0.1982447356,
-0.0654073134,
-0.1041677594,
-0.2947279215,
-0.2051288038,
0.4339441061,
0.6892320514,
-0.9551591277,
-0.7329144478,
-0.3267556131,
-0.016814746,
-0.4825057089,
1.1020104885,
0.0487423688,
-0.3789096475,
-0.3241734207,
0.1647617966,
-0.8088797331,
0.0419501513,
-0.5867093205,
-0.2787022591,
0.7193238139,
0.5832982063,
0.2919534445,
0.594842732,
0.3863114715,
0.1837510169,
0.1987911761,
0.1267813742,
-0.4562484324,
0.6878353953,
-0.2638433576,
-0.315692246,
-0.546041429,
-0.0687891096,
0.3536219597,
0.4882155955,
-0.3427917063,
0.7857506275,
0.1388818622,
0.4373672009,
-0.5852101445,
0.1615821123,
-0.8396391273,
-0.0908542499,
-0.5169404149,
-0.2186294347,
0.0216145236,
0.0182802361,
-0.0921113193,
-0.6500306129,
0.4235561788,
-0.0986386389,
0.5913821459,
0.2011638582,
-0.0854902342,
-0.1889830828,
-0.5688887239,
0.5703759789,
-0.612590909,
0.3907954991,
0.0293325931,
0.7294693589,
-0.0542002358,
-0.9284728765,
-0.5182213187,
0.1358030438,
0.2006247044,
0.2388363928,
0.3671202064,
0.1273947507,
0.133739084,
0.4523772299,
-0.7296195626,
0.3944396973,
-0.4742393196,
-0.1732981205,
0.4510854781,
0.3668454587,
0.230819419,
0.1410416663,
-0.052993428,
-0.0471969508,
-0.6022443175,
0.2790625989,
0.5671267509,
0.3923830986,
0.0572066568,
0.7068970799,
-0.3923828602,
0.9493538737,
-0.0309173707,
-0.1820938438,
-0.0947862044,
-0.190314427,
-0.3458989561,
0.0020403352,
0.5647683144,
0.3281113207,
-0.140023753,
-0.2973789573,
-0.6055123806,
-0.0518242009,
0.5250611305,
-0.8599901795,
0.0295323096,
0.5352538228,
-0.3401302397,
-0.3667848706,
0.2562322319,
-0.4721654952,
-0.5996872187,
-0.252874285,
0.0818133205,
0.1689819396,
0.3114416897,
0.0125991218,
-0.0145213846,
0.1175305545,
0.4660353959,
-0.7454726696,
0.0303172041,
1.0425657034,
0.807711482,
-0.5029754043,
-0.0213181544,
-0.988541007,
0.1261239201,
0.0402009636,
0.7175002098,
-0.6316381693,
-0.0923946053,
0.2281979322,
0.2503446639,
0.2221497893,
-0.5313944221,
0.647610724,
-0.6681752801,
0.1224861667,
0.0907001719,
-0.3000050187,
-0.1778249592,
0.2739456594,
-0.6476738453,
0.5711609721,
0.2956567407,
-0.4543288052,
0.3447088301,
-0.5945170522,
-0.1666364074,
0.2767749727,
-0.4791612029,
-0.1783093512,
-0.0352617092,
0.127638936,
0.7335492969,
-0.5305485129,
0.0938089564,
-0.079390116,
-0.6650688648,
-0.2506999075,
0.0845299363,
0.5204842687,
0.280318439,
0.0989088416,
0.2926382124,
-0.5003275275,
0.0034502926,
-0.1160593033,
-0.6198365092,
0.49411273,
-0.2663195431,
0.259950012,
0.4611595571,
0.5771275163,
-0.5594370365,
0.4189988077,
-0.4089162946,
0.2403474301,
0.7889558673,
-0.1370876431,
0.3445131183,
-0.4879355729,
1.0107527971,
-0.0402770787,
-0.1042816266,
-0.504799366,
-0.3882829845,
-0.3011828363,
-0.3940156996,
0.1251545101,
0.9069239497,
-0.1924295276,
0.5135657191,
-0.3192452788,
-0.6101457477,
-0.8281858563,
0.8250360489,
0.1674197167,
0.7006582022,
0.2166810632,
-0.738273561,
-0.8169798255,
-0.8874178529,
-0.6603871584,
0.1826797724,
-0.3660474718,
0.3113873005,
-0.1112467498,
-0.6145023704,
0.9932612777,
-0.577062726,
-0.7512199879,
-0.1643574983,
-0.2975410819,
0.7919478416,
0.2645811439,
0.0134820351,
-0.5133165121,
-0.3921945095,
0.1582080275,
-0.5958513618,
-0.4003385901,
-0.4769447446,
-0.2927177548,
-0.2691888809,
0.2555426359,
-0.6889769435,
0.1692596674,
0.6194825768,
-0.367192477,
0.5012541413,
-0.2146159112,
-0.2453868091,
-0.9845915437,
0.4551707208,
0.3334166706,
-0.4026323855,
-0.3127465546,
0.0502152815,
-0.0250612479,
-0.2793177962,
-0.3728786111,
0.7791665792,
-0.3098141551,
0.0175452158,
-0.2456847131,
0.2559999824,
0.0308300648,
0.1344076693,
-0.0965300053,
0.5121138692,
0.4444978833,
-0.3550237715,
0.3858292103,
0.2987431288,
-0.4555377364,
0.4497745037,
-0.5358202457,
0.2829766572,
-0.2912760675,
0.5871286988,
-1.0672451258,
-0.3013178706,
0.0025660153,
0.098270081,
0.0769070834,
-0.2974674106,
-0.4802316725,
-0.3899991214,
-0.2141391933,
0.0813016966,
0.7175438404,
-0.3785304725,
0.3983963132,
0.3351758122,
-0.3309493959,
-0.6328170896,
-0.8011783361,
0.0941661671,
-0.1782866269,
-0.8116785884,
1.0700968504,
-0.0622201487,
-0.0412115641,
-0.6018217802,
-0.3040946722,
-0.3834320605,
0.0445611924,
0.5311559439,
0.46917665,
0.0713831931,
-0.2542413771,
0.20154576,
0.0767619163,
-0.2169707268,
-0.3193392456,
0.4326976836,
0.158448264,
-0.3812724054,
-0.7243650556,
0.096060656,
0.7041338682,
-0.1037229672,
0.4918375313,
0.9895387292,
-0.2021612674,
-0.1351255625,
-0.8510241508,
-0.214051038,
-0.45761168,
0.0226102248,
-0.2084940821,
-0.9648689628,
0.5200420618,
-0.1672995239,
0.575299561,
0.2251114398,
0.7347654104,
0.060721945,
0.6713189483,
0.5386353135,
-0.078390047,
0.5052940845,
-0.2294158041,
0.2256319672,
-0.9348295331,
-0.3733174503,
-0.1280234903,
-0.7372896075,
-0.3127578199,
-0.3395337164,
0.1677579731,
-0.0704766586,
-0.123066783,
0.3699905872,
-0.6853528619,
0.3285149634,
0.3806590438,
-0.0616841689,
0.1411596388,
-0.1574727595,
-0.0173353739,
-0.0073829233,
-0.4642777741,
-0.8285195231,
0.9323322177,
0.2139264643,
0.6721984744,
-0.0939648226,
0.8728702664,
0.3016987145,
0.3145229816,
-0.6238669157,
0.4377852976,
-0.313208729,
-0.3221505284,
-0.2575325668,
0.0469655171,
-0.8789494634,
0.1865319908,
-0.278690815,
-0.8172036409,
-0.1481403261,
0.3271511495,
-0.6253629327,
0.0840933397,
-0.493557632,
1.0052521229,
-0.0032649615,
-0.4605928063,
0.0085977856,
-0.5003921986,
0.3248868883,
-0.5064918995,
0.3426691592,
-0.1688556373,
-0.1776064038,
0.431922406,
-0.5478929877,
0.6952083707,
-0.3462762237,
-0.1330067217,
0.2760341167,
0.207180649,
0.6684104204,
0.0990437716,
-0.4999864697,
-0.0420710705,
0.0411879495,
-0.0244659465,
-0.6440201402,
1.0587531328,
-0.3468555212,
-0.7401578426,
0.2436403483,
-0.609288156,
0.0884653777,
0.3349711597,
0.156793803,
-0.0870298445,
-0.2249634117,
0.1601170897,
0.1685331911,
-0.3493196666,
0.0683097392,
0.2047965825,
-0.2866260707,
0.1241130903,
0.6623559594,
0.0805987492,
-0.4441923499,
0.3339467347,
-0.0527290069,
-0.2468555123,
-0.2957830429,
-0.2909206152,
0.1822709888,
-0.4833543003,
-0.0712332055,
-0.4982757568,
0.0627648532,
-0.6669256687,
-0.3812245131,
-0.1802387685,
-0.4824198484,
-0.2050343454,
0.3134143054,
-0.0221164059,
0.4102431834,
0.3484171033,
0.3401646614,
-0.7565540075,
0.3495220542,
0.3489332497,
0.1673719883,
-0.1335613579,
-0.6440584064,
-0.1554122418,
-0.124124974,
-0.539901793,
-0.484939158,
0.4540653825,
0.4213382304,
0.5449112654,
0.5418591499,
-0.2848071754,
0.6081776023,
-0.5324550271,
0.9584100246,
0.0696327463,
-0.5708503127,
0.7113721371,
-0.3216134906,
0.4645830989,
0.6387484074,
0.2103579193,
-0.8096015453,
-0.2128646076,
-0.3152808845,
-1.0034263134,
0.4019901454,
0.0256127715,
0.1420887709,
-0.0378472172,
0.662856102,
0.5034989715,
0.165692538,
-0.2305191308,
0.1525586396,
0.0599172749,
-0.3907738924,
-0.1078278646,
-0.0693153664,
-0.0882361531,
-0.1922115982,
0.4095992148,
-0.0194672123,
0.1082090959,
-0.0227747988,
-0.2094052732,
0.1654978842,
0.1728699356,
0.5615463257,
0.6789355278,
-0.1985852271,
-0.214244321,
0.1154215559,
-0.3200288117,
-0.0302017294,
-0.0951155126,
0.1936066598,
0.1036795899,
-0.0204381496,
0.4020941257,
-0.044727359,
-1.0216596127,
0.8304764628,
-0.0299781356,
-0.0143894935,
-0.5767364502,
0.3494878709,
0.1159357429,
0.4689956903,
0.247946322,
-0.0544155575,
-0.0086831553,
-0.3323167861,
0.1885936558,
0.486969173,
-0.2303545028,
-0.2205738574,
0.9629391432,
0.0650772601,
-0.6540566683,
0.8409091234,
0.0586250164,
0.1471428871,
0.3102643192,
0.4998484552,
1.0470210314,
-0.0372557007,
-0.0507759452,
0.2787797153,
-0.1970843226,
-0.2337414622,
0.1752557009,
-0.1471604109,
-0.4604820609,
-0.5729519725,
-0.7227659822,
-0.2014511377,
0.1411831826,
-0.5641416311,
0.6172885299,
-0.7271834612,
-0.0544060059,
-0.1351306587,
-0.3476668298,
-1.24094069,
0.2891804278,
0.1570598483,
0.8720663786,
-0.5728018284,
0.6790334582,
0.8700956106,
-0.3214611411,
-0.3491666615,
-0.1532501727,
0.120572485,
-0.8314469457,
0.9662902355,
0.449059248,
-0.03721302,
-0.0599078313,
-0.057755053,
-0.4064098299,
1.6561598778,
0.5349714756,
-0.7377523184,
-0.5156665444,
-0.0907396004,
0.3028429151,
-0.7653163671,
0.3447276652,
0.3023839891,
0.3230417371,
-0.0410466716,
-0.9303534031,
0.2090483457,
-0.249104619,
0.2807707489,
-0.3547131717,
-0.466927141,
0.6814591885,
-0.1323376745,
-0.0574450344,
0.0061006709,
0.4627904892,
0.3676862717,
0.0043498534,
0.6425895095,
0.4841835797,
0.9410218596,
0.2794411182,
0.9336091876,
-0.8436193466,
-0.0543441065,
1.1443946362,
-0.2430950552,
0.69518435,
0.4846474826,
0.1800621599,
0.9543584585,
0.5872489214,
-0.0286336355,
0.3310627341,
0.5003824234,
-0.2483373433,
-0.4169691801,
0.0013950357,
-0.0036610218,
0.6043342352,
0.1892881989,
-0.6725149751,
-0.2857999802,
-0.0937104821,
-0.2949921489,
-0.1059632227,
-0.2444840074,
0.4274159968,
0.076934211,
-0.8074023724,
0.3688964844,
0.2665036321,
0.8894671202,
-0.4176628888,
-0.1942795515,
-0.0939255804,
0.0311130825,
-0.6953504086,
-0.7695561051,
0.3441375196,
0.15078637,
-0.1567130089,
-0.6357602477,
0.8605086207,
-0.3308615983,
-0.0265985373,
-0.160592258,
0.4580125213,
0.4090020657,
-0.3594942987,
-0.6112108827,
0.1974597722,
-0.1106330603,
-0.2642582059,
0.3498429954,
0.158276096,
0.1317046583,
0.8031206727,
0.6863365769,
0.3404974937,
-0.1201901585,
0.1716689616,
0.5243676305,
-0.4665881395,
-0.6268923283,
-0.716283381,
0.7798995376,
-0.1109957322,
-0.2717553377,
0.3891991079,
0.7953221202,
0.742353797,
-0.3135484755,
0.841750741,
0.1031742319,
0.4582683146,
-0.231801793,
0.6624704599,
-0.5399184227,
0.5328196883,
-0.1365438104,
-1.2241315842,
-0.2452109307,
0.6432082653,
-0.1930629462,
0.0138967466,
0.2778733373,
1.0019328594,
-0.1380542219,
-0.5107524991,
0.1480685174,
-0.2406896055,
0.3784873188,
0.510863483,
0.2206185013,
-0.1810126156,
0.4308194816,
-0.0010325373,
-0.150441125,
-0.4820961356,
-0.9549947977,
-0.5212762356,
-0.5327614546,
-0.4981282651,
-0.4186844528,
-0.1006457955,
0.8924329281,
0.8383080363,
-0.4106122553,
-0.4859777391,
-0.1542154402,
-0.0664420202,
-0.2749541104,
-0.2140750736,
-0.1147779152,
-0.3997457325,
-0.6288226247,
0.6254482269,
0.2322766632,
-0.2803242505,
-0.459153682,
0.024029078,
0.2910112143,
-0.1330104321,
0.4799458385,
0.4460709095,
-0.8738600612,
-0.009569848,
-0.2931395173,
-0.1109486595,
0.0301444363,
0.8578107357,
-0.7658221722,
0.6838942766,
0.5985375643,
0.9412215948,
0.487496376,
0.0645198897,
0.6573693156,
-0.886120975,
-0.0035226559,
0.1108163223,
0.2198362947,
0.3512367308,
-0.729390502,
0.4291731715,
0.0232212301,
-0.5482968092,
-0.6886495948,
0.1606534272,
-1.1663069725,
-0.011449486,
0.9976926446,
-0.0964025632,
0.0163129494,
0.136027962,
-0.220017612,
0.4024862349,
-0.3633233905,
0.9480631948,
0.5029744506,
-0.138159737,
0.0469534248,
-0.8022020459,
0.256360054,
0.2331958711,
-0.4650230706,
-0.0705538988,
0.2661719918,
0.4644063115,
-0.1390459538,
0.6216472387,
0.00902359,
0.2592293024,
-0.5114740729,
0.0697698295,
-0.2641319335,
-0.1466723233,
-0.1400776356,
0.2311491817,
0.1985437274,
-0.0553505607
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06220v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06220v1
|
A Unified Causal View of Instruction Tuning
| 2024-02-09T07:12:56 | 2024-02-09T07:12:56 |
Lu Chen, Wei Huang, Ruqing Zhang, Wei Chen, Jiafeng Guo, Xueqi Cheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Instruction tuning on a mixture of tasks has improved zero-shot capabilities
in natural language processing (NLP). Nevertheless, existing methods often
learn features that exhibit correlations between instruction-formatted samples
and target labels, rather than causal relationships. Termed as ``spurious
correlation'' in statistics, such a correlation may change drastically in a new
task, making the effect from the learned features to be misleading. To this
end, we develop a meta Structural Causal Model (meta-SCM) to integrate
different NLP tasks under a single causal structure of the data. Specifically,
the meta-SCM introduces multiple latent factors that represent properties of
source context, only some of which causally influence the target labels for a
specific task. The key idea is to learn task-required causal factors and only
use those to make predictions for a given task. Theoretically, we prove the
causal factor can be identified without mixing information from others. Guided
by the identifiability, we propose a Structural Instruction Tuning (SIT) method
to learn the task-required causal representations that can mimic the causal
factors for each task. The utility of our approach is verified by improvements
of zero-shot ability on a range of unseen datasets and tasks.
|
[
0.0199637096,
-1.1077911854,
0.4545788765,
0.2981976867,
-0.2072154284,
-0.1900916398,
-0.0710878,
-0.2558161914,
0.3064605296,
0.6849138737,
-0.5193318725,
-0.4775981903,
-0.6397316456,
-0.0790771991,
-0.2888162136,
1.209530592,
0.1962380707,
-0.0094464896,
-0.1319711506,
-0.1023607552,
-0.8101793528,
-0.2251635641,
-0.665846169,
-0.3150321245,
0.5982003212,
0.5531847477,
0.3751460016,
1.0163849592,
0.4496736228,
0.2188072056,
0.1465538591,
0.2549023032,
-0.3311805427,
0.080580242,
-0.4403410852,
-0.5499380827,
-0.6043160558,
0.0831679404,
0.6459964514,
0.923361063,
-0.0545997694,
0.3798631728,
0.4119617343,
0.5242534876,
-0.8346303105,
0.2296431214,
-0.6836107373,
-0.1125433221,
-0.0795075819,
-0.7926954031,
-0.7383836508,
-0.1203212962,
-0.1632336378,
-0.593100071,
0.6022648811,
0.1160551086,
0.7776319981,
0.801597774,
-0.7492337227,
-0.0547641031,
-0.9299862981,
0.6973984241,
-0.5863088369,
0.0498809256,
0.581213057,
-0.070293352,
-0.3651808202,
-0.1790590882,
-0.1143741012,
-0.028374264,
-0.3349532187,
0.138315618,
0.1695798934,
0.2083048373,
0.2727553844,
-0.0105339643,
-0.5206034184,
0.1478858441,
-0.4576181471,
-0.0621476918,
0.5316542387,
0.2321468592,
0.5584533811,
-0.2049816847,
-0.3809607029,
-0.1039115936,
-0.8119433522,
0.1002814546,
0.2998546362,
0.7055308223,
-0.0972415209,
0.5371998549,
0.0193288475,
0.9945782423,
0.3033947945,
-0.1894467026,
-0.0815588012,
-0.3954665959,
-0.4209606647,
0.3430753648,
0.5763909817,
0.0250031389,
-0.1240209639,
-0.3704677224,
0.3252821863,
0.1878523678,
0.6334067583,
-0.3382871747,
-0.077894792,
-0.0199264716,
0.0368959904,
-0.2085745186,
0.1329085678,
-0.5194247365,
-0.0135422228,
-0.5843399763,
0.5016574264,
-0.4939682484,
0.0713041276,
-0.0427817218,
-0.0714016259,
0.2715533972,
-0.2108588815,
-0.9665908217,
0.167996183,
0.6259976625,
0.4836647213,
-0.0370709673,
-0.412378788,
-0.8247051239,
0.5917256474,
-0.5078607798,
0.9103735089,
-0.7572512031,
-0.2461797893,
-0.0214575604,
0.1184388474,
-0.7208344936,
-0.2253651917,
0.6165997982,
-0.4451481998,
0.2939019799,
-0.3670636117,
-0.5738270283,
-0.2730454206,
-0.033688236,
-0.6036984921,
1.1268811226,
-0.0093919411,
-0.7995328307,
0.7136445642,
-0.3854784966,
-0.941534996,
0.0189795066,
-0.1627615988,
-0.3420674801,
0.2560765147,
0.0991979614,
0.4098455012,
-0.1149331927,
0.7129273415,
-0.3295314312,
-0.6051374078,
-0.2332957834,
-0.4313438237,
0.6984516978,
-0.2686719596,
-0.657327354,
0.1417034566,
-1.0566381216,
-0.1395647228,
-0.3018672764,
-0.4343550205,
-0.6276122332,
0.3427677155,
-0.5066292286,
0.1786821932,
-0.0968340114,
-0.2441652119,
0.1227510944,
-0.3407087326,
-0.0037949905,
0.6848137379,
0.3056820333,
0.6437821984,
-0.2569877505,
0.3899276555,
0.1119169518,
0.0028498394,
-0.3017231822,
-0.3814147115,
-0.9468265176,
-0.2203643918,
0.0437124819,
0.6275725365,
-0.7698776722,
0.5712749362,
-0.00211236,
-0.144142583,
-0.3860164583,
0.2269284129,
0.7062696815,
0.9244534373,
0.6609746218,
0.0389622003,
-0.5266014338,
-0.6970379949,
-0.6176928878,
0.0801916644,
-0.0792124271,
0.3060580194,
0.2497533858,
0.0869799778,
0.6403013468,
-0.6076579094,
-0.4124611318,
0.1580415815,
0.6644909382,
0.1670984775,
0.555488646,
0.3572183251,
-0.3776805997,
-0.578476131,
-0.2205347121,
-0.6966539025,
-0.1913256943,
-0.4557670057,
-0.1742419451,
0.1734584421,
0.8866754174,
-0.2093246281,
0.4306386113,
0.2365072817,
-0.4556276798,
0.4448712468,
-0.4559987485,
0.0974985287,
-0.9465667009,
0.0898070484,
0.1775960475,
0.2669487,
-0.4292116761,
0.0430516303,
0.2121948898,
0.0040693283,
-0.1925730109,
0.3251821399,
-0.4745210409,
0.2266674042,
-0.3351066411,
0.0982911661,
0.0290963054,
0.8689157963,
-0.2325252444,
0.636756897,
0.6757058501,
-0.9760425091,
-0.1457455456,
0.0850551873,
-0.0993012413,
0.7613962293,
-0.7699109912,
-0.1251299083,
-0.4012453556,
0.0246480014,
-0.8985456824,
-0.2696177959,
0.2371558547,
-0.14606224,
0.7293265462,
0.0189417657,
-0.2923621535,
-0.0069653895,
-0.0250720568,
0.0842253715,
0.0196780283,
-0.3303704858,
0.6698437333,
0.0545274429,
0.1819904894,
-0.7693479657,
-0.5491202474,
-0.2882834077,
-0.1077376828,
-0.3370170593,
0.5854008794,
0.0708404779,
0.2395860553,
0.3118187189,
-0.4730651081,
-0.1800504476,
0.1746103615,
0.4931715131,
0.4265842736,
-0.3870571554,
0.3458401859,
0.4256103337,
-0.2550262213,
0.0912043303,
-0.193012014,
0.0263583306,
0.2474575192,
-0.3038511574,
-0.2745096982,
0.2815011442,
0.3996765316,
-0.1701152772,
0.9081711173,
0.6848865747,
0.0707093552,
-0.4007671177,
-0.3867361248,
-0.2724910975,
-0.4160775542,
0.2999391258,
0.0305185504,
-0.7735610008,
0.0842695981,
-0.0898485333,
0.1403009146,
0.4803339541,
0.0963250995,
-0.202227667,
0.9228943586,
0.9039484859,
-0.0756538734,
0.5459604263,
0.0537673943,
0.327221632,
-0.977955997,
-0.3482634127,
-0.7080027461,
-0.3795863688,
-0.4724969566,
-0.3861961663,
0.4853289425,
0.1495693475,
-0.5049718022,
0.6318346262,
-0.4515921175,
0.5649220943,
0.7720170021,
0.3394967318,
0.1455845833,
-0.0263581481,
-0.3788655698,
0.1650616527,
-0.7984281182,
-0.1991494298,
1.0876182318,
-0.3381160796,
0.5545876026,
-0.1558277905,
0.4851971567,
0.1279437691,
0.0329387188,
-0.3345590234,
0.3919974267,
-0.3284326792,
-0.8483217359,
-0.3991606236,
-0.4285381436,
-0.9590396285,
0.1642209291,
-0.4339841306,
-0.7621491551,
0.101976499,
0.3434077799,
-0.4493751526,
0.1600213349,
-0.8468806148,
0.8914381266,
-0.1420558244,
-0.5841812491,
-0.2615658641,
-0.7187595963,
0.5526114702,
0.1364165395,
0.1448937207,
-0.1085744947,
0.2278015465,
0.5642164946,
-0.0402240008,
1.249884367,
0.0516784973,
0.1150989309,
0.1455899179,
0.063375324,
0.3427754343,
-0.1766202301,
0.0276057869,
-0.024358049,
-0.086930953,
-0.5234828591,
-0.7452002764,
0.6346833706,
-0.7332183719,
-0.671445787,
-0.3206007183,
-0.5637201667,
-0.4307684004,
0.1952341199,
0.2135855705,
0.4946026206,
-0.2141433656,
0.3067691624,
0.6860183477,
-0.0903151855,
0.5136311054,
0.7404441237,
0.4370269179,
-0.0488125533,
0.9144871831,
0.1259596497,
0.1464641541,
0.7952001691,
0.2125299275,
0.1071618721,
0.0087785954,
-0.179469645,
0.1832785159,
-0.3431872725,
-0.2781669199,
-0.3599579036,
-0.1292380542,
-0.3337854743,
-0.2075716108,
-0.2081583142,
-0.2050781846,
-0.615608871,
-0.1938225031,
0.0099282414,
0.3766491413,
-0.0495358594,
0.4912998974,
-0.7130562067,
0.4060875773,
0.387462765,
0.385990411,
0.0301819164,
-0.6472899914,
-0.3888063729,
-0.0319267176,
-0.4803439081,
-0.9043782949,
0.098575674,
0.4646070898,
0.6905184388,
0.7136906981,
0.0645417944,
0.7736991644,
-0.7955545783,
0.5039259195,
0.0478057973,
-0.889395237,
0.6612386703,
-0.2123078704,
0.2721351087,
0.5178241134,
0.7030038834,
-0.1332590282,
-0.4275104403,
-0.5836780071,
-0.7956983447,
0.945910573,
-0.1621755064,
0.0673296601,
-0.1996070594,
0.3941667676,
-0.1205340475,
0.0419635624,
-0.5369252563,
-0.3698303998,
-0.0527937822,
-0.0268731397,
-0.0779420137,
-0.3135308325,
-0.2230952829,
-0.3407177329,
0.8075076342,
-0.2008836567,
-0.140996024,
0.0428653397,
-0.1316214651,
-0.3922952712,
0.363263309,
0.6406347156,
0.566759944,
-0.2440676242,
0.2977746725,
-0.0089681782,
-0.2913477123,
-0.0121035296,
-0.2283345759,
-0.4792114198,
-0.099072963,
0.6544792652,
0.9824690223,
1.1111911535,
-0.1006994024,
0.2634825408,
0.2460445613,
-0.1040857956,
0.2716737986,
0.5812120438,
-0.0745956823,
0.0496013686,
0.1775102764,
0.3259112835,
0.0300810058,
-0.5928953886,
0.2958174646,
0.4778338373,
-0.6198339462,
-0.444293201,
0.6952100992,
0.2031467855,
-0.3545119166,
0.4817272127,
-0.051922936,
-0.1040229872,
0.6247703433,
0.8413001299,
0.8891431689,
-0.5469915271,
0.7100665569,
0.7654694915,
0.602165997,
0.0694856569,
-0.0055696764,
-0.1921335459,
-0.5923538208,
-0.7010601759,
-0.5706996918,
-0.2402499318,
0.0030606061,
-1.0517189503,
0.277923733,
-0.3044286668,
0.068868205,
0.1454755813,
-0.2244915217,
-0.6119741201,
0.2073089182,
-0.258533448,
0.3419811428,
-1.2573741674,
0.7241764665,
0.5036369562,
-0.4792731106,
-1.0128834248,
0.0447827503,
-0.022065321,
-0.8211413622,
0.5364700556,
-0.2244457901,
0.0158820506,
-0.2302168012,
-0.5222011209,
-0.9341331124,
0.8751514554,
0.3869492412,
-0.3948152065,
-0.2905587554,
0.0805345476,
0.5121491551,
-0.1701692194,
0.0573436394,
0.5531697273,
0.4202401936,
0.1874564141,
-0.4330973625,
0.2612775564,
0.0919327587,
-0.2250764519,
0.3426932096,
-0.3877083659,
0.7009183168,
-0.2543015778,
-0.3575018346,
-0.6062307954,
0.3875225484,
0.0826933458,
0.2633482516,
0.1576795429,
0.4242990017,
0.7800184488,
0.104080908,
0.8914898038,
-0.6135492921,
0.1417249292,
1.5355292559,
-0.1193324924,
0.6472880244,
0.4990251362,
-0.0800236166,
0.7383086681,
0.2003241926,
-0.074355036,
0.5134381056,
-0.244936496,
-0.0204192735,
-0.3026579618,
-0.0131826308,
-0.1090599671,
0.5683682561,
0.3352858126,
-0.2616780996,
-0.5053081512,
-0.3065105677,
0.0166873243,
0.0976642445,
-0.1672960967,
0.7438584566,
0.0675973594,
-0.8886552453,
0.3783764243,
0.0572800376,
0.3686772585,
-0.7522001266,
-0.1950372159,
-0.1545129716,
-0.0347782485,
-0.2801980972,
-0.1554982066,
0.696602881,
-0.3781591356,
-0.5434083343,
-0.2151967138,
0.5971465111,
-0.5437970757,
-0.5619200468,
0.263215363,
0.3577360213,
-0.238570556,
0.0386999734,
-0.416980654,
-0.3128817081,
-0.1142006367,
-0.0249396916,
0.4517909586,
0.4304149747,
0.0154693909,
0.2217771858,
0.6303962469,
0.087758936,
0.1545499712,
-0.0917015225,
0.6056985259,
-0.7019926906,
-0.4309118688,
-0.8202506304,
0.4996106923,
0.0311403461,
-0.4577490091,
0.89879179,
0.2267908156,
0.6823134422,
-0.0466646552,
0.2087230384,
0.2284148633,
0.3675609529,
-0.5269812942,
0.5157923102,
-0.5260311365,
0.2355965525,
-0.380187273,
-0.7854890227,
-0.3546781838,
0.2281325907,
-0.2930316031,
-0.1837146133,
1.1369036436,
0.649215281,
-0.1071102768,
0.0817811191,
0.3815073669,
0.1928969324,
-0.0555417947,
0.4098634422,
0.105458647,
-0.4007791579,
0.4425976872,
-0.1777999997,
-0.2922076881,
-0.2361871749,
-1.0303541422,
-0.9690220952,
-0.5794090629,
-0.4959679544,
-0.0729458556,
-0.0154746585,
0.4473114908,
0.7954909801,
-0.8519558311,
-0.1123410612,
-0.2998006642,
0.5718643069,
-0.7094227076,
-0.2911821902,
0.643468082,
-0.900400281,
-0.4190782309,
0.6569174528,
0.6143563986,
-0.4195230305,
0.08031106,
0.3973508775,
-0.3358045816,
0.3793726265,
0.5283539891,
0.5030167699,
-0.4994702935,
-0.3560940921,
0.1397352815,
-0.0433619507,
-0.0976266265,
1.1028838158,
-0.537702024,
0.4603933096,
0.2190072536,
0.629134357,
0.3963191211,
-0.1070298925,
0.479052633,
-1.0921792984,
0.1521174014,
-0.0696004033,
0.1967185885,
0.0155984592,
-0.6152873635,
0.4252460897,
0.296023041,
-0.5137485862,
-0.6265289187,
0.1174528971,
-0.8430866599,
-0.386176765,
0.8164799213,
-0.0540528111,
-0.3533360958,
-0.1449029148,
0.2235821187,
0.523984313,
-0.0105796838,
1.0867105722,
0.5012213588,
-0.2352068126,
0.1482994109,
-0.4149290323,
0.4272951484,
0.558463335,
-0.7030113935,
-0.1701588184,
0.3382354379,
0.2633696795,
0.1298474371,
0.315105617,
0.0585153773,
0.1519008577,
0.2419679165,
-0.0496013351,
-0.067952916,
-0.804982245,
-0.0581906512,
0.2355628461,
-0.429813236,
-0.2932332158
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06204v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06204v1
|
The Generative AI Paradox on Evaluation: What It Can Solve, It May Not Evaluate
| 2024-02-09T06:16:08 | 2024-02-09T06:16:08 |
Juhyun Oh, Eunsu Kim, Inha Cha, Alice Oh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper explores the assumption that Large Language Models (LLMs) skilled
in generation tasks are equally adept as evaluators. We assess the performance
of three LLMs and one open-source LM in Question-Answering (QA) and evaluation
tasks using the TriviaQA (Joshi et al., 2017) dataset. Results indicate a
significant disparity, with LLMs exhibiting lower performance in evaluation
tasks compared to generation tasks. Intriguingly, we discover instances of
unfaithful evaluation where models accurately evaluate answers in areas where
they lack competence, underscoring the need to examine the faithfulness and
trustworthiness of LLMs as evaluators. This study contributes to the
understanding of "the Generative AI Paradox" (West et al., 2023), highlighting
a need to explore the correlation between generative excellence and evaluation
proficiency, and the necessity to scrutinize the faithfulness aspect in model
evaluations.
|
[
-0.1491353363,
-0.8154203296,
0.9739388824,
0.228355974,
0.0580811352,
0.3927580416,
-0.0200535208,
-0.3987357616,
-0.3120596409,
0.1397428364,
-0.5320153832,
-0.0411713235,
-0.6654696465,
0.2446853966,
-0.5925235748,
0.8924135566,
-0.1119389087,
0.1577482969,
-0.8954059482,
-0.12070968,
-0.6191521287,
-0.1582789868,
-0.6750116348,
-0.5113453269,
0.1255615503,
0.2548486888,
0.9184684753,
0.2954794765,
0.4214455187,
0.3365601897,
0.0530455075,
0.1652185768,
-0.7149901986,
0.0138506461,
-0.0608738735,
-0.8001199961,
-0.0895909294,
0.2061360031,
0.6232092977,
0.5033040047,
-0.0866386071,
0.3660746813,
0.1017138064,
0.7551038265,
-0.5664846301,
0.1321191043,
-0.8318392038,
-0.0655420199,
-0.0994842201,
-0.1381627321,
-0.2760852277,
-0.551563859,
0.0786732882,
-0.5486820936,
0.3449744582,
0.1840155721,
0.9775142074,
0.5994691849,
-0.0453067608,
-0.2335327864,
-0.8922421336,
0.8616615534,
-0.6713660955,
-0.0326435156,
0.1222365573,
0.382314235,
0.0959667191,
-0.4880661666,
-0.9288861752,
-0.4840508997,
0.346123606,
0.1998927146,
-0.5253956318,
-0.0570786558,
0.4115180373,
0.6911234856,
-0.6465396285,
0.2964482307,
-0.3241185546,
0.0370898955,
0.6971583366,
0.4627570808,
0.464571923,
-0.3714956343,
-0.4880396724,
0.0721838325,
-0.6139468551,
0.0713988468,
0.3249989748,
-0.1071876884,
-0.1017815098,
0.9098752141,
0.0027740397,
0.4992144108,
-0.2058198601,
0.1644016653,
0.1235595718,
-0.402266413,
-0.245540604,
-0.3767656088,
0.9334559441,
0.2824088037,
0.4608806372,
-0.3858633935,
-0.3893544078,
0.3231720328,
0.4667972028,
-0.392868191,
0.1455455124,
0.4877353907,
-0.1889408529,
-0.2437354326,
0.1983578652,
-0.6337262988,
-0.3432669938,
-0.0951194614,
0.7613976002,
-0.2563053071,
0.0598797537,
0.0165727083,
-0.2191081345,
0.2909136117,
0.0475547314,
-0.5363254547,
0.103157483,
0.9531089664,
0.6460019946,
-0.1876541823,
-0.6125768423,
-0.5609667301,
-0.2816174626,
-0.4829187691,
0.4901992977,
-0.5751649141,
-0.3907054961,
-0.0767691433,
-0.360917449,
-0.3344711363,
-0.7940049767,
0.4684799612,
-0.7310010195,
0.1117521003,
-0.2062723935,
-0.57645154,
0.0780539885,
0.1140704975,
-0.7733147144,
0.8040833473,
0.3734962642,
-0.5245959163,
0.1801070124,
-0.5321954489,
-0.1206623465,
0.251629293,
-0.3480900526,
-0.4711204171,
0.3722348809,
0.0635298342,
0.1250345111,
-0.8680937886,
0.4464557767,
-0.243059963,
-0.6442080736,
0.6376460195,
-0.7057159543,
0.8978424072,
0.2570490837,
-0.4100491405,
0.1141546145,
-0.4742451608,
0.2272454053,
0.4042085409,
-0.2470125109,
-0.0549912378,
-0.0917424113,
-0.1430124938,
0.1001710743,
0.2658964097,
-0.5804169178,
0.0381393991,
-0.5100899935,
0.3696811795,
0.8179990649,
-0.1559555978,
0.2012094259,
-0.6999990344,
1.0056568384,
-0.2989015579,
0.1167323962,
0.3468053341,
-0.4616784155,
-0.984606266,
0.111924924,
0.417616576,
0.5463140607,
-1.1953549385,
0.1582857817,
-0.6236819625,
-0.5079310536,
-1.1131887436,
0.2747050226,
0.7801042199,
0.312199533,
0.0447902828,
-0.1609973162,
-0.2538873553,
-0.9645395875,
-0.5457499027,
-0.4255591631,
-0.1272582859,
0.2137952447,
0.6752147079,
0.0363738202,
0.8100364208,
-0.1701275855,
-0.0615754239,
-0.3219515979,
0.4291272759,
0.0367868133,
0.2149471492,
0.4752502441,
-0.7747550607,
-0.272059083,
-0.3843302429,
-0.9548258781,
-0.2037226707,
-0.1822416484,
0.2205683291,
0.1593247652,
0.277133137,
-0.8694905043,
0.2549690902,
0.585090518,
-0.2009214461,
0.6340871453,
-0.0216974784,
0.1692142189,
-0.8307989836,
0.1852944195,
-0.1754140556,
0.1117868945,
-0.4874462485,
0.3937791288,
-0.0271830335,
-0.0198535379,
-0.344391197,
0.4841508269,
-0.2444230616,
-0.2352865934,
-0.156852901,
0.3313687444,
0.1389918327,
0.2562147379,
-0.4910517037,
1.1483743191,
0.3455038965,
-0.3065906167,
0.4336999059,
0.3148457408,
-0.8443172574,
0.4850636125,
-0.8058645725,
0.2795979381,
-0.3139644861,
-0.136742875,
-0.9529977441,
-0.1712723523,
0.1049796715,
-0.6112180352,
0.1319413036,
0.3441389203,
-0.6204708219,
-0.55665797,
-0.3445252776,
0.6110391617,
0.5667423606,
-0.5453318357,
0.4394319654,
-0.0758911222,
-0.0252413321,
-0.7842495441,
-0.6040277481,
0.0335184783,
-0.1883451343,
-0.6075665951,
0.1545670182,
-0.2824730873,
-0.5621997714,
0.2930412591,
-0.028012434,
0.2282976061,
0.5834373236,
0.2716647983,
0.3815302551,
-0.1703783423,
0.0864381716,
-0.3917395771,
0.0038528973,
0.3538904786,
0.1016359404,
0.4867602289,
-0.1954782158,
-0.8729148507,
-0.4065439403,
0.1383454502,
0.7449433208,
-0.4041281939,
0.735865891,
0.3258467317,
-0.2064207792,
-0.1479599327,
-0.6462901235,
0.2279279828,
-0.4116302133,
0.4920757115,
-0.4568206966,
-0.8770323992,
0.3304799795,
0.3868852556,
0.004460779,
0.9149973989,
0.4039360285,
-0.177386716,
0.885769248,
0.4701190293,
-0.2061646134,
-0.0653553531,
-0.2653829157,
0.4966503978,
-0.9798418283,
-0.4164177477,
-0.7483412027,
-0.0628602803,
-0.5805881619,
-0.3125059307,
0.6356666088,
0.1913776547,
-0.2393442988,
-0.2044903338,
-0.0769764408,
0.5290852189,
0.52319175,
0.0394822173,
0.3773293793,
-0.13577272,
0.1307233274,
0.1596686691,
-0.852037251,
-0.7199252248,
1.1633775234,
0.3672773838,
0.604195118,
0.1603509933,
0.3899105489,
0.3634727001,
0.3953731656,
-0.8107368946,
0.4370503724,
-0.0457544327,
-0.5631234646,
-0.5465013981,
-0.5011572838,
-0.8371782899,
0.0702307522,
-0.1678953171,
-0.6171634197,
-0.081053257,
-0.2016025037,
-0.4091950059,
0.3392267227,
-0.529956758,
0.8992605209,
-0.4207584262,
-0.2919104993,
-0.2684428096,
-0.3831993341,
0.5006158948,
-0.368411392,
0.0852416605,
-0.0841784999,
0.2430500984,
0.5510117412,
-0.2636290193,
0.4853822887,
0.0536811799,
-0.079766199,
0.4839128852,
0.1917223483,
0.3188891709,
-0.1127723977,
-0.2957602441,
0.1774235368,
-0.1071810573,
-0.5417283773,
-1.0155147314,
0.5434977412,
-0.9016810656,
-1.1297721863,
-0.4609397352,
-0.5160465837,
-0.4481526017,
-0.1122254133,
0.3086246252,
0.0981656983,
-0.4732879996,
-0.0161634199,
0.4562511742,
-0.2969826162,
0.2621987462,
0.3423668146,
-0.0214660708,
-0.0534890518,
0.937461257,
-0.2031373233,
0.5095475912,
0.3017184734,
0.0320114046,
-0.2626441717,
-0.558003366,
-0.7270118594,
0.2211205363,
-0.7073491812,
-0.1042069793,
-0.3442963958,
-0.5249226689,
-0.0333528779,
0.2433913499,
-0.2033162117,
-0.267783314,
-0.2611998022,
-0.0475446358,
-0.0002381722,
1.0055925846,
0.2358833849,
0.004140689,
-0.5384481549,
0.410097301,
0.7175958157,
0.2249118686,
0.4038686156,
-0.6084058881,
0.0121138887,
0.2417494804,
-0.4345997572,
-0.5448191166,
-0.0472363122,
0.0909489542,
0.6249102354,
0.4688776433,
-0.0788095817,
0.5340857506,
-0.3730204105,
1.0626531839,
0.082526952,
-1.060665369,
0.1108587459,
-0.036722444,
0.3253459036,
0.5324321985,
0.4528282881,
-0.3240164816,
-0.5336686373,
-0.5760714412,
-0.5901790261,
0.6255909801,
0.5189256668,
0.2908037603,
0.0396180004,
0.260815531,
0.2008706778,
0.4528216422,
-0.8024355769,
-0.2930594385,
-0.0319073983,
-0.1296283454,
-0.453535974,
-0.6281986237,
-0.2951502204,
0.0430453382,
0.5922864676,
0.1316590011,
0.3795613348,
0.0013250808,
0.039365571,
-0.4612345099,
0.5242699981,
0.4517554641,
0.9361352921,
0.0964648798,
-0.0329399072,
0.0588701107,
0.0895632878,
0.129971683,
0.10976886,
-0.3113759756,
-0.2333844751,
0.680178225,
0.8688983917,
-0.1813537627,
-0.8877987266,
0.7228552103,
0.001845805,
-0.151153028,
-0.3976038992,
0.178711921,
0.0671103969,
0.3235843182,
0.43537727,
-0.0205880255,
-0.0222817082,
-0.7688239217,
-0.1335347891,
0.8884561062,
-0.1471380442,
-0.177151978,
0.92083323,
0.0389095694,
-0.5621396899,
0.9344742894,
-0.1638548225,
-0.794737637,
0.8958494067,
0.3470321596,
1.1486078501,
-0.2063253373,
0.3364893496,
0.0323827825,
0.4349653125,
0.0896631405,
0.3346997797,
0.0504633151,
-0.7869940996,
-0.3270173371,
-0.7521573305,
-0.320833534,
0.5080205202,
-0.6573625207,
-0.214000985,
-0.0782004967,
0.0717474371,
0.0243555047,
-0.2015355676,
-0.8519304395,
0.1939021647,
-0.1750287265,
0.6714078188,
-0.8585151434,
0.3728281558,
0.4629197717,
-0.5494920611,
-0.6532806754,
0.3399204314,
-0.2856840491,
-0.9743801355,
0.5780425668,
0.0895172879,
-0.0839559883,
-0.1444688737,
-0.48542431,
-0.5777387023,
1.0259950161,
0.4458875954,
-0.4371110797,
-0.1815569848,
0.6116655469,
0.9412584305,
-0.1808816642,
0.1953657568,
0.623961091,
0.4283241034,
-0.2337765694,
-1.2421171665,
0.0208271779,
-0.3605639637,
0.2104958296,
-0.189111352,
-0.8384697437,
0.6856916547,
-0.4696317613,
-0.4458028078,
0.6896300316,
0.4490512311,
0.3015705943,
0.4826115668,
0.4339477122,
0.6972567439,
0.4648334086,
-0.2451928258,
1.4919264317,
-0.1053103954,
0.2248275876,
0.8689744473,
-0.2072980255,
0.6384756565,
0.5014113784,
-0.3247507513,
0.3394823074,
0.5152176023,
-0.2228651941,
0.2334465683,
0.4033067226,
-0.290990442,
-0.4626168609,
-0.25451985,
-0.0601279289,
0.6523006558,
-0.062817283,
-0.2912851274,
-0.0158797912,
-0.0941763148,
-0.299756676,
0.4043501019,
-0.1992425025,
0.4816233814,
0.1216834635,
-0.9935733676,
0.713825345,
0.0833733082,
0.1533993036,
-0.1999224573,
-0.1782556623,
-0.1306709498,
-0.2329103202,
-0.0933534801,
-0.9385547638,
0.1497303098,
0.1122733727,
-0.0599240772,
0.0312695019,
0.2215602994,
-0.1127294227,
-0.4299063981,
0.1774164736,
0.9192780852,
0.1060832068,
-0.0009882009,
-0.6520664096,
0.0636480525,
0.0420174114,
0.033695884,
-0.0907702968,
0.2777158916,
-0.0720548704,
1.1225764751,
0.3052658439,
0.0816987678,
-0.0289660431,
0.1933233142,
0.6691654921,
-0.3470127285,
-0.0640093833,
-0.8865386844,
0.3600001037,
0.2052521259,
-0.2520430088,
0.8947575092,
0.6850420237,
1.0985697508,
-0.2670127451,
0.9403368235,
0.0853433087,
0.3268761933,
-0.7649973035,
0.5724093914,
-0.7710991502,
0.5407520533,
-0.3005437553,
-1.0828130245,
0.1975171715,
0.1533514857,
-0.3996797502,
0.3753546178,
0.6791552305,
0.5857584476,
0.1300106794,
0.0144792059,
0.5294169188,
0.3386781514,
0.0012207483,
0.7996259332,
1.4814175367,
-0.4669614732,
0.4140925109,
-0.0442175306,
0.01614164,
-0.012856828,
-0.5291434526,
-0.8425965309,
-0.6738520861,
-0.1063970327,
-0.4048910737,
0.1237350553,
0.5228871703,
-0.0206823219,
-0.6560978293,
-0.1377373189,
-0.126379922,
0.2737238407,
-0.1151755974,
-0.2786663771,
0.4495308101,
-0.2214782834,
-0.9366201162,
0.3937307894,
0.0285514183,
-0.0023629931,
-0.5981943011,
-0.0810036883,
0.1578061283,
0.0854023024,
0.2440921515,
0.1313660294,
-1.0894901752,
-0.285695225,
-0.139833346,
-0.0772570744,
0.024183847,
0.5858001113,
-0.6289271712,
0.6251981258,
0.2712270021,
0.9270408154,
0.2450551689,
0.3162142634,
0.5682110786,
-0.3740104139,
-0.4966863394,
0.3009171486,
0.1757888049,
0.4065641761,
-0.2986889482,
0.4728113115,
0.0851564258,
-0.5473561883,
-0.8213325739,
0.2812272012,
-0.7163761258,
-0.2051198483,
1.098678112,
-0.1446519047,
0.0205600392,
0.0919258446,
0.1855208725,
0.1081824526,
-0.0054705804,
1.2797776461,
0.8903278708,
-0.1459590197,
0.0197066627,
-0.7637421489,
0.5140708685,
0.7996633649,
-0.6630839109,
-0.0810734183,
0.3878314495,
0.3147574067,
0.2985464931,
0.4121792912,
-0.0444341525,
0.5124614239,
-0.0840300396,
-0.1212439761,
-0.084013842,
-0.2779015303,
-0.6698120832,
0.1557686478,
0.6549485922,
-0.0779529512
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06196v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06196v2
|
Large Language Models: A Survey
| 2024-02-09T05:37:09 | 2024-02-20T13:33:49 |
Shervin Minaee, Tomas Mikolov, Narjes Nikzad, Meysam Chenaghlu, Richard Socher, Xavier Amatriain, Jianfeng Gao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have drawn a lot of attention due to their
strong performance on a wide range of natural language tasks, since the release
of ChatGPT in November 2022. LLMs' ability of general-purpose language
understanding and generation is acquired by training billions of model's
parameters on massive amounts of text data, as predicted by scaling laws
\cite{kaplan2020scaling,hoffmann2022training}. The research area of LLMs, while
very recent, is evolving rapidly in many different ways. In this paper, we
review some of the most prominent LLMs, including three popular LLM families
(GPT, LLaMA, PaLM), and discuss their characteristics, contributions and
limitations. We also give an overview of techniques developed to build, and
augment LLMs. We then survey popular datasets prepared for LLM training,
fine-tuning, and evaluation, review widely used LLM evaluation metrics, and
compare the performance of several popular LLMs on a set of representative
benchmarks. Finally, we conclude the paper by discussing open challenges and
future research directions.
|
[
-0.4783859849,
-0.8263276219,
0.5723181367,
0.1058427766,
-0.1260241866,
0.1913500726,
-0.5467159152,
-0.5973098874,
-0.0452797711,
0.62566787,
-0.267608881,
-0.3799954653,
-0.8635034561,
0.0431145318,
-0.5823162198,
0.9023416638,
-0.1238411143,
0.1698497385,
0.0040826881,
-0.0596683361,
-0.2614987791,
-0.8000801802,
-0.7280575633,
-0.3664705455,
0.6399204731,
0.2193905115,
0.5762914419,
0.5502964854,
0.5987199545,
0.2941696644,
-0.367223829,
0.1319027543,
-0.612701416,
0.2262550443,
0.0986099914,
-0.3852563202,
-0.47265324,
-0.0617994964,
0.9199205637,
0.9290633202,
-0.0078875162,
0.2125129551,
0.0451891981,
0.5474433303,
-0.4632385671,
0.108567588,
-0.6910907626,
-0.0030698969,
-0.4618497491,
0.1452451497,
-0.3344231844,
-0.3962662518,
0.1659499705,
-0.0792068243,
0.1199672967,
0.1805504858,
0.4273909926,
0.0496743806,
-0.6547501683,
-0.509221971,
-1.0003186464,
0.9082482457,
-0.7259899974,
0.4248078167,
0.2803871036,
0.420725435,
-0.4010882378,
-0.5832588673,
-0.3146153688,
-0.4547338784,
0.3053071201,
-0.1577320099,
-0.0474319048,
-0.0221793391,
0.1061456054,
0.7137415409,
-0.5349574089,
0.6713603735,
-0.1384878904,
0.0537784509,
0.6265261769,
0.3898467422,
0.2395857424,
0.1691698879,
-0.1129285246,
0.2240785807,
-1.0978882313,
-0.3574179113,
0.3501532972,
0.1919182092,
-0.0478200987,
0.6699855328,
-0.1532716155,
0.8644290566,
-0.4148421586,
-0.1517051607,
0.0738787204,
-0.3037939072,
-0.274484098,
-0.2963092327,
0.8831605911,
0.1537050456,
0.5224823356,
-0.2062504739,
-0.3303947747,
-0.3492557406,
-0.1367708892,
-0.6999700665,
0.0229708478,
0.041787114,
-0.4156481028,
-0.146720022,
-0.1947353631,
-0.6691341996,
-0.620677352,
-0.3501660824,
0.0687414706,
-0.0804384574,
-0.4099682271,
0.1864887774,
0.1909725219,
0.4826959372,
0.530518949,
-1.0746608973,
0.3295492232,
0.988533318,
0.7815899849,
-0.3614360094,
-0.1630560905,
-0.2963079512,
0.0436871536,
-0.4422900975,
0.7452174425,
-0.5153357983,
-0.3835487068,
0.3391757607,
-0.0981209874,
0.0410261564,
-0.7372365594,
0.3552142978,
-0.6339058876,
0.1783414334,
-0.3056856394,
-0.6037835479,
-0.0704313591,
0.5096710324,
-0.6048824191,
0.906868577,
0.0505467877,
-0.6749193072,
0.2373602092,
-0.4638800919,
-0.3246168792,
0.1586178541,
-0.1835885048,
-0.3241757751,
0.2488795817,
0.1477224082,
0.7004728317,
-0.8372335434,
0.2773765922,
-0.3543367386,
-0.2590824664,
0.3796570003,
-0.5246328712,
0.5591463447,
0.357999295,
0.0905559361,
0.1409282237,
-0.6042001843,
-0.1627471596,
0.1638875604,
-0.5289201736,
-0.0251108781,
0.1086103916,
0.1096667722,
0.0694352984,
0.3542982042,
-0.4157842696,
0.4262325168,
-0.3292731345,
0.7022129893,
0.5152326226,
0.0633512363,
0.2347832322,
-0.1982081831,
0.6142086387,
-0.2262309194,
0.0382095799,
-0.1267479658,
-0.3793956339,
-0.8089015484,
-0.202364862,
0.2736093104,
0.2700705826,
-0.3098570406,
0.3265999556,
-0.2361050099,
-0.6893171668,
-0.1599043757,
0.4595625103,
0.0441743769,
-0.0394442566,
0.0758041963,
-0.1826277822,
-0.4304482341,
-0.8400558233,
-0.1768143028,
-0.1044220701,
-0.1030798331,
0.2671137154,
0.3338750601,
-0.3243682683,
0.686608851,
-0.4323997796,
0.0259243287,
-0.587200582,
-0.0113609424,
0.1706591547,
0.1218093783,
0.4504498243,
-0.4614514709,
-0.3873117268,
0.136718601,
-0.5483785868,
0.011671396,
0.1969425529,
0.3393814266,
0.1788992137,
0.7148755789,
-0.6277699471,
-0.2326975614,
0.7547346354,
0.0299439915,
0.5060908794,
-0.1424803734,
-0.1216414794,
-1.0646871328,
-0.0936279595,
0.0986401662,
-0.1936949939,
-0.6572027206,
0.0118386094,
-0.0875446051,
0.0323280133,
-0.3497036695,
0.7104029655,
-0.7610546947,
-0.3306866586,
-0.3844172359,
0.1924279928,
-0.6659840345,
0.1256090403,
-0.0529954769,
0.6216791272,
0.6637483239,
-0.5808451176,
0.6635474563,
0.0382753909,
-0.6037482619,
0.0859117135,
-0.62406528,
0.2741121352,
-0.1500379145,
0.2703354657,
-1.0899767876,
-0.3869747221,
0.0433987342,
-0.1155019477,
0.3652213216,
-0.1232171431,
-0.8117032051,
-0.5383490324,
-0.1709424853,
0.2846492231,
0.5837103128,
-0.5234513283,
0.3087980151,
0.5564317703,
-0.4182540476,
-0.4222131073,
-0.5259974003,
0.2583345175,
-0.4340585768,
-0.4257752001,
-0.2716079652,
-0.0709451512,
-0.5154133439,
-0.3958902657,
0.1330729723,
-0.0805613399,
0.1768370569,
0.0994205624,
0.1211309209,
-0.4207766354,
0.2926285565,
-0.3953289986,
0.0443145223,
0.0846935362,
-0.0863800198,
0.791467905,
-0.1632439643,
-0.4550361931,
0.0688411221,
0.1344923675,
0.5142098069,
-0.2039642185,
0.6297023296,
0.4869833291,
-0.2179192603,
-0.1948175877,
-0.73362571,
0.0106791556,
-0.419475466,
0.5199206471,
-0.0650602728,
-1.32918787,
0.4040527046,
-0.3646371961,
0.2740724385,
0.3709605038,
1.0413759947,
0.1285887808,
0.9284594655,
0.6536729336,
-0.4758369923,
0.4894072115,
0.0055244728,
0.2039502114,
-0.7001515627,
0.0054327729,
-0.6747384071,
-0.2189374864,
-0.8182384372,
-0.4882100821,
0.0455227904,
0.0612467974,
-0.2281188369,
0.2380438298,
-0.1342601925,
0.447519362,
0.1630641967,
-0.3770155907,
0.5160147548,
-0.0826318562,
0.263061136,
0.2052999586,
-0.5998551846,
-0.7698736191,
1.3147619963,
0.6590034962,
0.9236610532,
0.196595341,
0.4862664342,
0.0194591265,
0.5637423396,
-0.783095479,
0.6601891518,
-0.2550269961,
-0.6926730275,
-0.3877440095,
-0.4214577973,
-0.975266397,
0.3310503066,
-0.0391940251,
-0.7512654066,
-0.3376069069,
0.0356230848,
0.0061629163,
0.3621514738,
-0.512409389,
0.4023843408,
-0.4013321698,
-0.0452391468,
-0.2152827382,
-0.4427059293,
0.5993602872,
-0.3830528557,
0.2202604562,
-0.3640117943,
-0.184281379,
0.7156409025,
-0.1725811064,
0.7761247158,
-0.0188077446,
-0.5414921641,
0.3308531046,
-0.199337557,
0.4592418373,
0.0227983035,
-0.1440694481,
0.1022120118,
-0.1183185801,
-0.1995969415,
-0.2414480448,
0.8311698437,
-0.7030736208,
-0.5951001048,
-0.2508895695,
-0.6068136096,
-0.6066607237,
0.0192642827,
0.0942810923,
0.2915813625,
-0.4743766487,
0.3966833353,
0.7282093763,
-0.3165363371,
0.5147609711,
0.4607160389,
-0.5965132713,
-0.2886671722,
0.9252297282,
0.1853824258,
0.3871982098,
0.4367433786,
0.1886870414,
-0.2257312536,
-1.0193761587,
-0.2435935438,
0.4043444097,
-0.4523296654,
-0.0297918655,
-0.4757623374,
-0.366228044,
-0.3457004428,
0.0871796757,
-0.3870772421,
-0.3110248446,
-0.1261453032,
0.0269124564,
0.4211216569,
1.2136076689,
0.2625725269,
0.618732214,
-0.728610158,
0.1598369181,
0.3003329933,
0.4294224083,
0.1037967354,
-0.4498061836,
-0.1803395301,
-0.1531951427,
-0.2518728673,
-0.4011178315,
0.3058155179,
-0.0028450608,
0.5840812325,
0.4287678599,
-0.3773091733,
0.3508693576,
-0.4854260683,
0.88463521,
0.2407015711,
-0.5140376091,
0.1450184286,
-0.5715442896,
0.2856228054,
0.2409312874,
0.4842573702,
-0.7697737217,
-0.3887250125,
-0.3402416408,
-0.7381406426,
0.3524585366,
-0.0315811969,
0.4496405721,
0.1342730224,
0.3164214194,
0.1977944225,
0.2783869207,
-0.6851591468,
-0.1211275384,
0.4745161831,
-0.2118840814,
-0.3637718558,
-0.3611677587,
0.0779418796,
-0.1151155308,
0.41930601,
-0.0526261292,
0.0698059425,
-0.3771425486,
-0.0499026291,
-0.0265626088,
0.513564527,
0.521279633,
0.7129579186,
-0.0462996475,
0.056326475,
0.3829024732,
-0.4894637465,
0.1429495513,
0.05679157,
0.051715523,
-0.2313185781,
0.4958542287,
0.6975628734,
0.2372870594,
-0.7852553129,
0.3565818667,
-0.0326234251,
-0.3535509706,
-0.2998228371,
0.1685492247,
0.4790620804,
0.2246624827,
0.2752973139,
-0.5204191804,
-0.1855404526,
-0.6713320613,
-0.2437358201,
0.629991293,
-0.2400607318,
-0.2393314838,
0.330639571,
0.215055123,
-0.185663268,
0.5144392252,
0.0704772845,
-0.3277366161,
0.4347327352,
0.489507705,
0.6974451542,
-0.1560747921,
-0.1823952198,
0.182583645,
0.3743956685,
-0.3677018583,
0.1194028184,
0.1322911084,
-0.766526401,
-0.5341667533,
-0.7420721054,
-0.6473072767,
0.5826900601,
-0.2034073323,
0.2739316225,
-0.504386127,
-0.068292208,
-0.0936714187,
0.2163792998,
-0.5791873932,
0.0024005817,
0.25202775,
0.952819407,
-0.62297225,
0.7561881542,
0.6807673573,
-0.1031596959,
-0.4944453835,
-0.020468479,
-0.0265655685,
-0.8709231615,
0.559837997,
-0.1122563779,
0.0354582481,
-0.019250242,
-0.6748985648,
-0.896856308,
0.7988510132,
0.3508979976,
-0.8687467575,
-0.1515875459,
0.48892048,
0.5663175583,
-0.3494857252,
0.2674997449,
0.7729895115,
0.4418709278,
0.0438315086,
-0.9326313138,
-0.2408125103,
0.0679778978,
0.2175553292,
0.3662394881,
-0.8225705624,
0.7538737059,
-0.0642484799,
-0.0341460891,
0.37521258,
0.6221189499,
0.3102059066,
0.0186978448,
0.3893612027,
0.2376043648,
0.6172843575,
-0.1268797964,
0.8773294687,
-0.1317564696,
0.2251765579,
1.1639195681,
-0.434779644,
0.9501436949,
0.3105784655,
-0.3943804502,
-0.0431181118,
0.6630577445,
-0.213067472,
0.0360413939,
0.6732752919,
-0.4089834988,
-0.2978058159,
-0.0116737708,
-0.480322063,
0.484528929,
0.5200427175,
-0.4909437597,
-0.4402323663,
-0.0606109761,
0.1168089807,
-0.1447352171,
-0.4349388778,
0.870310545,
0.3173464835,
-0.4459667504,
0.3246585727,
0.0259750281,
0.7715380788,
-0.7063862681,
0.114547722,
-0.2190758437,
0.1588097066,
-0.0536375381,
-0.9247861505,
-0.0214829352,
0.2422096282,
0.0209935289,
-0.2340987027,
0.7295288444,
-0.3692703545,
-0.4479522705,
0.1584614068,
0.7110062838,
0.3542319834,
0.0065767961,
-0.3832544386,
0.4227443337,
-0.208815217,
-0.493406117,
0.5578459501,
0.4774650037,
-0.0233571623,
0.8348634243,
0.4482271969,
0.302642554,
0.2041031867,
0.2249908149,
0.7357317805,
-0.7471526265,
0.0459090024,
-0.7965609431,
0.0217119493,
0.0881686434,
-0.4919491112,
0.888215661,
0.6729707122,
0.6441656947,
0.0130414236,
0.8967394829,
0.1992009878,
0.6373125315,
-0.4760153294,
0.6587117314,
-0.2370547056,
0.176715374,
-0.1297678649,
-1.1488008499,
-0.3073660135,
0.2068659067,
-0.5089350939,
0.2835725546,
0.3493048549,
0.6536380053,
0.1124811545,
0.1987047791,
0.404024303,
0.2805709243,
0.5255282521,
0.4182023406,
1.1677472591,
-0.1373671442,
0.3926161826,
0.1960468739,
-0.0488002077,
-0.3759906292,
-0.9106299281,
-0.8709503412,
-0.4797217846,
-0.2342057824,
0.185460344,
-0.0620090701,
0.8162134886,
0.6769694686,
-0.7670691609,
-0.5304945111,
-0.1126786247,
0.0295990668,
0.2203869224,
-0.1310544163,
0.0773091763,
-0.3517852724,
-0.8575385809,
0.4115841091,
0.1778862774,
0.1943070143,
-0.5690814853,
-0.0863186345,
-0.0009505952,
-0.0323677696,
0.8924664855,
0.3838372231,
-0.7054659128,
-0.2314638644,
-0.2123270929,
-0.2688398361,
-0.059207648,
0.9632647634,
-0.3014889956,
0.0308215041,
0.535924077,
0.8288100362,
0.5603861809,
-0.3627841473,
0.6185199022,
-0.3601609766,
-0.1239551008,
0.1508236378,
0.4647289217,
0.4620974958,
0.0355562419,
0.5328897238,
-0.1150563955,
-0.795268774,
-0.8884833455,
0.1716745496,
-0.9812409878,
-0.1746409237,
1.337506175,
0.2054593861,
0.036469467,
-0.0943882763,
-0.2385525703,
0.0497430749,
-0.1008742228,
0.4814632535,
0.9388341904,
-0.1673457474,
-0.2505370677,
-0.8488458395,
0.3293924928,
0.1434096843,
-1.0248771906,
0.422500968,
0.5128165483,
0.4482395053,
-0.1313307583,
0.4967145026,
-0.2177319378,
-0.2025828958,
-0.2646313608,
-0.1477134973,
0.2355512977,
-0.2641936839,
-0.4825259447,
0.3167213798,
0.8035110235,
0.2418166399
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10946v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10946v1
|
CultureLLM: Incorporating Cultural Differences into Large Language Models
| 2024-02-09T04:02:43 | 2024-02-09T04:02:43 |
Cheng Li, Mengzhou Chen, Jindong Wang, Sunayana Sitaram, Xing Xie
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) are reported to be partial to certain cultures
owing to the training data dominance from the English corpora. Since
multilingual cultural data are often expensive to collect, existing efforts
handle this by prompt engineering or culture-specific pre-training. However,
they might overlook the knowledge deficiency of low-resource culture and
require extensive computing resources. In this paper, we propose CultureLLM, a
cost-effective solution to incorporate cultural differences into LLMs.
CultureLLM adopts World Value Survey (WVS) as seed data and generates
semantically equivalent training data via the proposed semantic data
augmentation. Using only 50 seed samples from WVS with augmented data, we
fine-tune culture-specific LLMs and one unified model (CultureLLM-One) for 9
cultures covering rich and low-resource languages. Extensive experiments on 60
culture-related datasets demonstrate that CultureLLM significantly outperforms
various counterparts such as GPT-3.5 (by 8.1%) and Gemini Pro (by 9.5%) with
comparable performance to GPT-4 or even better. Our human study shows that the
generated samples are semantically equivalent to the original samples,
providing an effective solution for LLMs augmentation.
|
[
-0.3746324778,
-0.3348123431,
0.1604345441,
0.2597066164,
-0.1206660271,
0.3019962013,
-0.6652465463,
-0.7442205548,
0.3772884905,
0.5451239347,
-0.6525657177,
-0.485734731,
-0.4247075319,
0.1992809325,
0.0764672831,
0.635880053,
0.0560622178,
0.3025037944,
-0.2162161171,
-0.3985447288,
-0.4528742731,
-0.4522580206,
-0.3002263606,
-0.4265091419,
0.3276543617,
0.6039145589,
0.5616340637,
0.5848457813,
0.4314652085,
0.2997738719,
-0.2464446723,
0.6319594979,
-0.6387164593,
0.1102329642,
-0.2070417106,
-0.3620994389,
-0.4029265344,
0.3876198232,
0.3157945275,
0.7917585969,
0.0544514805,
0.3145353496,
0.0379771739,
0.5479821563,
-0.5255540609,
0.2210379988,
-0.8734485507,
0.2094737738,
0.0486944318,
-0.1021340489,
-0.2360472828,
-0.317986697,
-0.042472139,
-0.4901699424,
0.1219762191,
0.0898913965,
0.4898416102,
0.2051225156,
-0.478800565,
-0.1378253847,
-0.8612316847,
1.0915696621,
-0.586429894,
0.4333257377,
0.2049161345,
-0.0406639166,
-0.2789638638,
-0.2416023016,
-0.5348778367,
-0.2545442283,
-0.0834673569,
0.1038031355,
0.0603630133,
-0.3900472224,
0.2348112315,
0.4601438642,
-0.6088744998,
0.3922056556,
-0.3643328547,
-0.1873048693,
0.8012222052,
0.1947156042,
0.3349183202,
-0.038376458,
-0.2756431997,
-0.3102844656,
-1.0767356157,
-0.1159473732,
0.2773664594,
0.3959274888,
-0.2107085437,
0.1650826037,
-0.4381740987,
0.5948473811,
-0.2087595016,
-0.6543785334,
0.3481249809,
-0.0789401978,
-0.1616750211,
0.0971342847,
0.5249610543,
0.4011587799,
0.4002861977,
-0.2066458315,
-0.1418010294,
0.0832289234,
-0.2591716051,
-1.0545985699,
-0.1567055285,
0.0758992285,
-0.3383937776,
-0.2148354352,
-0.0893741772,
-0.2317663282,
-0.5180639029,
-0.4075478911,
0.1896010637,
-0.3412321806,
-0.3719864488,
-0.028324509,
-0.0364038907,
0.2880922556,
0.295599252,
-0.7730886936,
-0.0858493671,
0.5959281921,
0.8316408992,
-0.3926101327,
-0.1539212316,
-0.4479664564,
0.0938310251,
-0.4655954242,
0.5802904963,
-0.4641852081,
-0.6978833675,
-0.118780233,
0.0877636448,
0.3312362731,
-0.8048374057,
0.4332093,
-0.6248850226,
0.3003581762,
-0.2408478856,
-0.4812527001,
0.0147893373,
0.4770670533,
-0.7556529641,
1.0084149837,
0.0996698141,
-0.5649252534,
0.6619369984,
-0.5897501707,
-0.4965233803,
0.3668820858,
-0.0666049644,
-0.0187013,
0.0306082722,
0.3775856495,
0.4963920414,
-0.4552376568,
0.1072005406,
-0.2651034296,
-0.4579451978,
0.2720385492,
-0.4719493389,
0.8204424977,
0.6184465885,
-0.0653891787,
-0.0993876383,
-0.9437819123,
0.0421478376,
0.1872000843,
-0.3959753215,
-0.6255975366,
-0.0924325138,
0.2151583135,
0.373277694,
0.2808655202,
-0.6856560707,
0.2542981207,
-0.463879317,
0.2543224096,
0.4938828051,
-0.5062141418,
0.6304559708,
-0.2365361601,
0.5310649872,
0.1381157339,
-0.0145109268,
-0.0352651738,
-0.2708266675,
-0.6664844155,
-0.4159298837,
0.1897411793,
0.5205529928,
-0.7999543548,
0.1749678552,
-0.4904789031,
-0.4875005186,
-0.6388991475,
0.4678033292,
-0.0160444994,
0.4768385291,
0.325276792,
-0.3624703288,
-0.5823099613,
-0.8147726655,
-0.1005169749,
-0.1093362197,
-0.3562661707,
0.0224917214,
0.1437661946,
-0.0751112774,
1.1310679913,
-0.5898684859,
-0.2889100313,
-0.3622118235,
0.0284221284,
0.2755958736,
0.4936700761,
0.2553932965,
-0.7408214211,
-0.5011890531,
0.0672775656,
-0.5797075033,
-0.1446819603,
0.2699756622,
-0.005898505,
0.4577866197,
0.4505008757,
-0.2332042009,
0.1572957337,
0.79227072,
-0.1390417963,
0.2169084102,
-0.3881190121,
0.1868110448,
-1.3301308155,
-0.2055094391,
-0.0461719297,
-0.1060269699,
-0.4797012806,
0.1581124514,
0.2140541822,
-0.0742881894,
-0.6354495287,
0.6410841346,
-0.5539783239,
0.0929817259,
-0.3847121,
0.0651776344,
0.1335645467,
0.1242723837,
0.3621399999,
0.7209033966,
0.1729688346,
-0.3157894909,
0.4940724671,
0.0151387444,
-0.5850925446,
0.7640829682,
-0.292062521,
0.1999359131,
-0.2276552022,
0.4483081102,
-0.5743929744,
-0.1257712543,
-0.0618458651,
-0.2124460787,
0.0554932058,
-0.4617511928,
-0.3989624679,
-0.2166383266,
-0.2544057667,
0.2614786327,
0.9483898878,
-0.7430570126,
0.474898845,
0.3142021596,
-0.1800228208,
-0.5627894402,
-0.692379415,
0.22582753,
-0.5716118217,
-0.8946781754,
0.3526759446,
-0.277946651,
-0.4365923405,
-0.1206035465,
0.1664644331,
0.0332393982,
0.1894981861,
0.0414746776,
0.3222260773,
-0.3797736168,
0.2854297757,
-0.3677692115,
0.0702167302,
-0.0781279057,
-0.640868485,
0.5326078534,
0.0547947846,
-0.3259283304,
0.0643643588,
0.3259066641,
0.4817580581,
-0.4175256789,
0.7659774423,
0.7804332972,
-0.2929875255,
-0.3991543949,
-0.7337109447,
-0.3035738766,
-0.4636183679,
0.328229934,
-0.4012900889,
-1.0499116182,
0.4076696932,
-0.0631445721,
0.1721087545,
0.1439978778,
0.5462304354,
-0.0957371444,
0.9681786299,
0.594425559,
-0.3334038258,
0.2821874022,
-0.109301582,
0.1745547205,
-0.4052087963,
-0.1607406586,
-0.437992394,
-0.5038275719,
-0.8796064258,
-0.7017524242,
0.4881682694,
-0.059623301,
-0.1855308563,
-0.0479209274,
-0.2274021506,
0.6683952212,
0.5623934269,
-0.2413341999,
0.676644206,
0.2766900659,
0.0099662105,
-0.1777640134,
-0.8394580483,
-0.3962424099,
0.901914835,
0.1317928731,
0.9767786264,
0.2850377858,
0.5944920182,
0.045187097,
0.6263099313,
-0.8636237979,
0.3297686577,
-0.4457001984,
-0.2165063322,
-0.2216608673,
-0.5072748065,
-0.7445709109,
0.4933529198,
-0.3504950702,
-0.4436236322,
-0.0333260484,
0.1543998867,
-0.0091947857,
0.3453304768,
-0.6200291514,
0.5416206717,
-0.1962873042,
-0.336689055,
-0.1673319936,
-0.3703300655,
0.4040287733,
-0.177155003,
0.5408956409,
-0.4028901458,
0.2014177144,
0.5892519355,
-0.5109333992,
0.7274250388,
-0.1226912066,
-0.3133835196,
0.1936790198,
0.1253441721,
0.5079602599,
0.051893346,
-0.0991851091,
0.1732067019,
-0.0966428146,
-0.5299229622,
-0.4451599717,
0.9992890358,
-0.8116111755,
-0.7144296765,
-0.2643270493,
-1.0697717667,
-0.5009371042,
-0.3283434212,
-0.0308876913,
0.3360609114,
-0.2283194959,
0.3091369569,
0.6124916077,
-0.4159253538,
0.4511070549,
0.9581189156,
-0.0054103234,
-0.0962929353,
0.7276978493,
0.0930258259,
0.389454782,
0.2162806541,
0.405136764,
-0.3763221204,
-0.2846240699,
-0.6898585558,
0.0351057984,
-0.6221434474,
-0.0514266416,
-0.6021296978,
0.0146939978,
-0.4959564805,
-0.1054013744,
-0.2637821138,
-0.2651713192,
0.0846901089,
-0.0868377015,
0.8564875126,
0.5236997008,
-0.2519291043,
0.2120414227,
-0.875334084,
-0.1353141665,
0.2389406264,
0.1969516575,
-0.1056846678,
-0.6727815866,
-0.3705607653,
0.2086706311,
0.0354338735,
-0.4637223482,
0.5979127288,
0.1287786067,
0.2945006788,
0.3220509589,
0.0375697166,
0.8563817143,
-0.4601756036,
0.8155286312,
0.1822772622,
-0.6862809062,
0.3233411908,
-0.0396896154,
0.5067452192,
0.3218018413,
0.4325840175,
-1.0189330578,
-0.4431035519,
-0.3628181517,
-0.8656093478,
0.7031245828,
-0.2893466055,
0.4183963239,
0.0359527394,
0.0026444364,
0.1168443114,
-0.2129603922,
-0.6743119955,
0.0123194708,
0.0346021354,
-0.1885010302,
-0.2185006589,
0.0291682091,
-0.0985938385,
-0.193093434,
0.685066402,
-0.2964701355,
-0.5467531085,
-0.0821749195,
-0.5707198381,
0.0358224809,
0.5194949508,
0.2700879276,
0.6709611416,
-0.1471171081,
0.2419993132,
0.6867768764,
-0.4153059721,
0.2904025018,
-0.0914736465,
-0.1839930713,
-0.1930202842,
0.2653781474,
0.5745992661,
-0.0931603909,
-0.8590280414,
0.3166772425,
-0.0409260094,
0.0711176619,
-0.3332903087,
0.0821728706,
0.524128437,
0.2372383624,
0.3656387925,
-0.4628638029,
-0.2135976106,
-0.6871853471,
0.0020444551,
0.4553636611,
-0.4827190936,
-0.0238086767,
0.461279124,
0.3081399798,
-0.0027777327,
0.7478975654,
-0.2948893309,
-0.3716576397,
0.6309316158,
0.5807093382,
0.3999589384,
-0.2920776904,
0.2171591669,
0.092318967,
0.2856490612,
-0.1271950752,
0.3068064153,
0.3055722415,
-1.0801292658,
-0.8895573616,
-0.8581311107,
-0.422196269,
0.2897693813,
-0.4487194717,
0.4319917262,
-0.1290052384,
0.3126190305,
-0.3944467902,
0.0567607395,
-0.946731925,
0.4459019303,
0.2939508557,
0.9182602763,
-1.0480122566,
1.0417215824,
0.8481363654,
-0.2711544037,
-0.8291624188,
-0.1795263439,
0.0575704239,
-0.9160739183,
0.9595909715,
-0.0031398137,
-0.2079772353,
-0.2306843251,
-0.3172010481,
-0.7467262745,
1.0037201643,
0.188938871,
-0.5055227876,
0.4633494616,
0.4029592276,
0.5419424176,
-0.5724412799,
0.2672484815,
0.639844656,
0.3418465853,
0.3297818005,
-0.6600619555,
-0.0089943036,
-0.0567652881,
0.2082304955,
0.0769670978,
-0.5617113113,
0.7939037085,
-0.1248918325,
-0.1097813472,
-0.1755376905,
0.7670042515,
0.3427819312,
0.0217187256,
0.7339432836,
0.3995627463,
0.7838357091,
-0.0566751957,
0.6630219817,
-0.6383566856,
0.1576775461,
0.982642293,
-0.5828649998,
0.7005550861,
0.4411584735,
-0.1531683803,
0.1487063915,
0.6715095639,
0.0442639887,
0.1159918457,
0.4435448647,
-0.3628098369,
-0.2723364234,
-0.4811378717,
-0.3881634772,
0.7380403876,
0.2967329025,
-0.0735331848,
-0.0245927069,
0.0055303737,
0.5055437088,
0.0977043137,
-0.2593173683,
0.7086799741,
0.0821790025,
-0.589250803,
0.6579148173,
0.3384446204,
1.1899832487,
-0.7582294941,
0.128262043,
-0.7197467089,
-0.050498087,
-0.2640013099,
-0.4047652781,
0.1882612109,
0.2225742936,
-0.2444256842,
-0.4059409797,
0.5952730775,
-0.8232133985,
-0.7442113161,
0.1969533414,
0.7489899993,
0.1811265945,
-0.0140953129,
-0.1390773952,
0.111606881,
-0.081701912,
0.0672469139,
0.3975007236,
0.2761895657,
-0.3923781216,
0.4268710911,
0.7533479929,
0.5101777911,
-0.2751402259,
0.3110060394,
0.4677050412,
-0.6291844249,
-0.5465932488,
-0.8110970259,
0.1718143672,
-0.3088961244,
-0.1523316801,
0.5624923706,
0.4672914147,
1.1530259848,
-0.1029785797,
0.936904192,
-0.0236730035,
0.4527715743,
-0.5771728158,
0.8435131311,
-0.7106927037,
0.3288487196,
-0.0420420691,
-1.0575550795,
-0.0637047216,
0.3167965412,
-0.2838678658,
-0.1650318354,
0.5111227632,
1.1151391268,
-0.1986846477,
0.0694045573,
0.5446554422,
0.2058316469,
0.2714436948,
0.5352282524,
1.0549585819,
0.2268459201,
0.5519537926,
-0.293708533,
-0.2074608356,
-0.1014893278,
-1.1479721069,
-0.5799609423,
-0.3518793285,
-0.238096565,
-0.2107123435,
-0.1901881695,
1.4986929893,
0.7821594477,
-0.7979725003,
-0.4210034311,
0.7606768012,
0.0097669885,
-0.0339856632,
-0.1886682808,
0.2616073191,
-0.2453508973,
-1.0786222219,
0.632793963,
0.1917477399,
-0.0895460472,
-0.6064696312,
-0.1233275831,
0.3546656668,
-0.0792098939,
0.9229550958,
-0.0707920715,
-0.6691640615,
-0.5066165924,
-0.0093442937,
-0.017033821,
0.1358256638,
0.8782897592,
-0.7741041183,
0.2655902505,
0.4730661511,
0.6685220003,
0.4126050174,
-0.2157144099,
0.5721191168,
-0.9180585742,
0.5612787604,
0.0049067987,
0.4608407617,
0.7905038595,
-0.226531297,
0.5265689492,
0.3000378013,
-0.0270808581,
-0.4310910404,
0.299764365,
-0.6882985234,
-0.4434265792,
1.2794657946,
-0.1276785135,
-0.0130050816,
0.0014551861,
0.0401734449,
-0.0149986409,
-0.1855966896,
0.7535446286,
0.727766335,
0.1728754342,
0.1877930611,
-0.4867750406,
0.3711714149,
0.3946065307,
-0.8062470555,
-0.1791222692,
0.695063591,
0.6686621904,
-0.1136113778,
0.3897948563,
-0.2476654053,
-0.1282738298,
-0.3671567142,
0.3377127647,
-0.072194092,
0.1161616892,
-0.2302915454,
0.2293295115,
0.2561604977,
0.0864768699
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06155v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06155v1
|
Model Editing with Canonical Examples
| 2024-02-09T03:08:12 | 2024-02-09T03:08:12 |
John Hewitt, Sarah Chen, Lanruo Lora Xie, Edward Adams, Percy Liang, Christopher D. Manning
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce model editing with canonical examples, a setting in which (1) a
single learning example is provided per desired behavior, (2) evaluation is
performed exclusively out-of-distribution, and (3) deviation from an initial
model is strictly limited. A canonical example is a simple instance of good
behavior, e.g., The capital of Mauritius is Port Louis) or bad behavior, e.g.,
An aspect of researchers is coldhearted). The evaluation set contains more
complex examples of each behavior (like a paragraph in which the capital of
Mauritius is called for.) We create three datasets and modify three more for
model editing with canonical examples, covering knowledge-intensive
improvements, social bias mitigation, and syntactic edge cases. In our
experiments on Pythia language models, we find that LoRA outperforms full
finetuning and MEMIT. We then turn to the Backpack language model architecture
because it is intended to enable targeted improvement. The Backpack defines a
large bank of sense vectors--a decomposition of the different uses of each
word--which are weighted and summed to form the output logits of the model. We
propose sense finetuning, which selects and finetunes a few ($\approx$ 10)
sense vectors for each canonical example, and find that it outperforms other
finetuning methods, e.g., 4.8% improvement vs 0.3%. Finally, we improve
GPT-J-6B by an inference-time ensemble with just the changes from sense
finetuning of a 35x smaller Backpack, in one setting outperforming editing
GPT-J itself (4.1% vs 1.0%).
|
[
-0.0395165458,
-0.8199846148,
0.4906126559,
0.1132537648,
-0.1997284144,
-0.0033393567,
-0.4677552879,
-0.1973406076,
0.0855685025,
0.3918647766,
-0.2651633024,
-0.6045790911,
-0.2811865211,
-0.0869419277,
-0.4952152669,
1.0872927904,
-0.0667824447,
0.1471418589,
0.0884459764,
-0.4494143724,
-0.5736238956,
-0.6715446711,
-0.6718774438,
-0.2484214753,
0.4722718894,
0.3613035083,
0.6747073531,
0.3165645301,
0.284006536,
0.3023556769,
-0.3522348404,
0.0982918963,
-0.6903511286,
-0.2440277934,
-0.5244368315,
-0.4249876738,
-0.5618714094,
0.1155233383,
0.7691483498,
0.5273572803,
-0.1500616521,
0.0579849444,
0.202588737,
0.7784156203,
-0.7170679569,
0.1102390736,
-0.5305992961,
-0.3953424692,
-0.038101092,
0.1238903999,
-0.5654827356,
-0.4355067015,
0.0934475362,
-0.8285572529,
0.1925804913,
-0.1362193674,
0.8862515092,
0.1024593562,
-0.3134904504,
-0.2507901788,
-0.804220438,
0.9266088009,
-0.6888636947,
0.2410165966,
0.3818107247,
0.1802733243,
-0.1918165386,
-0.6361480951,
-0.6039181352,
0.0498070456,
-0.0949737355,
0.0946240723,
-0.6437908411,
0.2007906139,
0.149769187,
0.3534701169,
-0.3480697274,
0.0253813323,
-0.6086670756,
-0.0190784484,
0.7465924025,
-0.1492778361,
0.1677151173,
-0.372200191,
-0.0361117311,
-0.4129166901,
-0.9293945432,
0.077710636,
0.5345435739,
0.2496550232,
0.1125886589,
0.576169312,
-0.2792820334,
0.7667184472,
0.1288486272,
0.1418331265,
0.1658096462,
-0.3556771576,
-0.4979195595,
-0.2004562318,
0.5102574825,
0.592669785,
0.3434457183,
0.0401317105,
-0.3273760676,
0.0414432511,
0.2560640872,
-0.6985475421,
-0.5783159733,
-0.0599370413,
-0.6851085424,
-0.623308301,
-0.2937764525,
-0.6713181138,
-0.2415424287,
-0.6280863285,
0.5907362103,
-0.6443033218,
-0.2451441884,
0.2841282189,
-0.1953232437,
0.0891034454,
0.556429565,
-0.8903609514,
0.5388416052,
0.5701655149,
0.7593923807,
0.0147652309,
-0.2186484933,
-0.4352665842,
-0.1047730967,
-0.3838165998,
0.9311392903,
-0.6469909549,
-0.511577785,
-0.1348327547,
-0.0562138557,
-0.1191058233,
-0.5118837953,
0.5917353034,
-0.4948424995,
0.0666856766,
-0.4849573374,
-0.6630435586,
-0.5225191116,
0.0117994146,
-0.4915944338,
1.0439009666,
0.2454253733,
-0.1868839264,
0.3664683402,
-0.8783942461,
-0.2560579479,
-0.2697424889,
0.1359606683,
-0.3485741317,
0.4069288373,
0.2820389569,
0.4270350039,
-0.0712880492,
0.4053904116,
-0.3333502412,
-0.2350666076,
0.1304723471,
-0.1558312029,
0.9434689879,
0.1209193766,
-0.0540661924,
0.3765831292,
-0.7824183702,
0.0161546171,
0.0965214744,
-0.2830012739,
-0.9189959764,
0.0246821474,
0.3478665054,
-0.0943145752,
-0.0355000086,
-0.3713776767,
0.77528584,
-0.3400463462,
0.8360176086,
1.0202159882,
0.2761776149,
0.693411231,
-0.338709712,
0.4122799635,
-0.1145692617,
0.1604832858,
-0.1261102259,
-0.4308136106,
-0.7342763543,
-0.3126357496,
0.6887332201,
0.4044031799,
-0.6575978398,
0.233753711,
-0.1084473282,
-0.5639887452,
-0.3579387665,
0.2601860464,
0.4409373105,
0.3820740581,
0.4345809817,
-0.1772743762,
-0.4552799761,
-1.0633563995,
-0.5090287924,
-0.2807638943,
0.2199944109,
0.0467156768,
0.7175776362,
0.0820122361,
0.9241142869,
-0.5426478982,
0.047246784,
-0.268473506,
0.0794660226,
0.020193195,
0.7980298996,
0.7415491939,
-0.5800577402,
0.0470880941,
-0.1956225932,
-0.6103640199,
-0.0404652134,
-0.1527092457,
-0.4126645327,
0.0874681175,
0.5827787519,
-0.6781864762,
0.5174207091,
0.4000018239,
-0.3531518281,
0.5005297065,
-0.2896553874,
0.0537960492,
-1.1075884104,
-0.1778506339,
0.0801600367,
-0.0938019827,
-0.7064554691,
0.5477122068,
0.2676739693,
-0.100539051,
-0.3541589975,
0.6611756086,
-0.2643546164,
0.113591291,
0.02962883,
0.1175409034,
0.0077497237,
0.6536281109,
-0.0983740613,
0.3682691753,
0.2996352315,
-0.5606691837,
0.1108873188,
0.3475426137,
-0.5996092558,
0.4909656048,
-0.8478034735,
0.0751977488,
-0.1189788431,
0.4009705782,
-0.8995298743,
-0.2212156653,
0.1748976558,
-0.0095227519,
0.2457461506,
-0.3154140115,
-0.7011910081,
-0.1335811764,
-0.3522827029,
0.499945581,
0.5593849421,
-0.7000389695,
0.4890048504,
0.0682895854,
-0.2462132275,
-0.2583674788,
-0.4796604514,
-0.0927974805,
-0.376934737,
-0.4369972348,
0.2139469087,
-0.3039841056,
-0.4120776653,
0.0509819314,
0.0104202367,
0.0079365801,
0.1937095821,
0.0837438703,
0.3066878319,
-0.1495538652,
0.462700069,
0.4602373838,
0.0402993634,
-0.3706609011,
-0.5197989345,
0.3206265867,
-0.2284846157,
-0.2722039223,
-0.4152465761,
0.048524294,
0.407148838,
-0.3239162266,
0.2211569101,
0.2714104056,
-0.6685605645,
-0.0300235674,
-0.4749547839,
-0.1138409525,
-0.4433949292,
0.2736956477,
-0.450492382,
-0.5995283723,
0.4345306456,
-0.0159965772,
0.2838810682,
0.4480099976,
0.2835489511,
0.0400686897,
0.7023838758,
0.6802172065,
-0.1335877776,
0.5455628037,
-0.514578402,
0.3206299841,
-0.8293151259,
0.1768302619,
-0.5308069587,
-0.5642917156,
-0.7999829054,
-0.3783273399,
0.2617382705,
0.847355485,
-0.1481713951,
0.622292757,
-0.5198367238,
0.7043710947,
0.5954637527,
0.3391898572,
0.4776399732,
0.0888653323,
-0.0882793143,
-0.1262068599,
-0.9200564623,
-0.7101866007,
1.2737181187,
0.1678682715,
0.7397128344,
0.2564166486,
0.7837306261,
0.2736067176,
0.5336102843,
-0.7678329349,
0.4094862938,
-0.2639062703,
-0.5544077754,
-0.2505067289,
-0.0388227738,
-0.6396517158,
0.2042132318,
-0.0917277262,
-0.8088843226,
0.675473094,
0.5726860166,
-0.7438356876,
0.2549463212,
-1.0952301025,
0.9803618789,
0.1577777416,
-0.2685541511,
-0.4482160211,
-0.146771282,
0.6110562086,
-0.0445698909,
0.230310604,
0.1836130917,
0.2226015478,
0.7192332149,
-0.4856119752,
0.8739479184,
-0.1869347692,
-0.0762474611,
0.481819272,
0.292534858,
0.5417098403,
0.0798666179,
-0.2216219157,
0.1528526694,
0.1207854301,
-0.5032430887,
-0.8633760214,
0.7581437826,
-0.6068900824,
-0.4145333171,
-0.102192454,
-0.5449072719,
-0.0674357489,
0.0058691846,
0.1650086343,
0.7571583986,
-0.2951847613,
0.1895954162,
0.4587982893,
-0.4673686624,
0.5181472898,
0.3984036446,
-0.4871214926,
-0.34118855,
1.078732729,
0.222020939,
0.4695132673,
0.3659323454,
0.4669519663,
0.0384834446,
-0.4488855004,
-0.6895934939,
0.0307039525,
-0.7420786619,
-0.2254740894,
-0.6308648586,
0.1603721827,
-0.3879524171,
-0.4603204131,
-0.3245638907,
-0.8682402968,
0.0706794113,
-0.1551996171,
0.627951026,
1.0099170208,
-0.3173675537,
0.5942713618,
-0.3591827452,
0.1769828647,
0.3899695873,
0.1374767721,
0.0899983421,
-0.5165816545,
-0.2259303629,
0.0550376251,
-0.5343408585,
-0.7197633386,
0.1879041493,
0.1944618672,
0.1955026835,
0.3917393088,
-0.2011513114,
1.0275629759,
-0.4759401083,
0.8111331463,
-0.1238489971,
-1.2197930813,
0.6556429267,
-0.5215775371,
0.3295740485,
0.3771545887,
-0.0143526755,
-0.4238981605,
-0.4396066368,
-0.9168464541,
-0.5719650984,
0.5355477333,
0.4653167427,
0.013602904,
0.1038135141,
0.4423846006,
0.0222651456,
0.3082851768,
-0.7023199201,
-0.1772074401,
-0.2403205037,
-0.08684282,
-0.3359767497,
-0.2484401762,
0.0632946566,
-0.6322162747,
0.9348505735,
0.0345491879,
0.1776749045,
0.182147488,
-0.3211403787,
0.0335622877,
0.341841042,
1.0376782417,
0.7562286258,
-0.0886206329,
-0.1515771896,
0.2110553682,
-0.2296570837,
-0.0998333544,
0.0686636269,
-0.4846014977,
0.1168911606,
0.3382099867,
0.6327415705,
0.576818347,
-0.4881585836,
0.2989392579,
0.0185141508,
-0.1442823857,
-0.193681553,
0.0256918054,
0.0447319895,
0.1585486978,
0.1452293694,
0.4638314247,
0.2828525007,
-0.5666043162,
-0.0277240649,
0.3245621622,
-0.1034790054,
-0.4395343065,
0.4730249941,
0.1039418727,
-0.1972411275,
0.4680254161,
-0.5338934064,
-0.4841164351,
0.5026320815,
0.2555789649,
0.8057579994,
-0.4476891458,
0.1699100286,
0.5805872679,
0.5712620616,
-0.185882315,
0.1721542925,
-0.1303135306,
-0.7464914918,
-0.3320687711,
-0.6708024144,
-0.1420891285,
0.3235970438,
-0.7804682255,
0.5476056337,
-0.5307518244,
0.2407371253,
0.2378754467,
-0.2906940281,
-0.6887316108,
0.0321816169,
-0.4857103527,
0.8654152751,
-0.8641437292,
0.8757963181,
0.6485375166,
-0.5287162066,
-0.7469291687,
-0.1892555505,
0.0916010514,
-0.6951696277,
0.5507201552,
-0.1234067678,
0.2603734434,
-0.0059932363,
-0.7199394107,
-0.7593630552,
0.8881880045,
0.3217002153,
-0.9131088853,
-0.1680037677,
-0.4465353787,
0.5408425927,
-0.2195255309,
-0.0516533256,
0.6945363283,
0.4373125732,
-0.3703178763,
-0.7812260389,
-0.162686646,
-0.2543237209,
0.1953143477,
0.2394885123,
-0.6132212877,
0.8486955166,
-0.2274745554,
0.0425603576,
0.4217180014,
0.5050457716,
0.1345926821,
0.1840234548,
0.6296520829,
0.7320424318,
0.8446515203,
-0.0558987632,
1.1865223646,
-0.2635417879,
0.4824681878,
1.4932596684,
-0.0519107729,
0.9643815756,
0.3290379643,
-0.0129306344,
0.6084244251,
0.7636813521,
0.1238905564,
0.4974755049,
0.361936599,
-0.3751247823,
-0.2791734338,
0.1893922985,
-0.3260731995,
0.5532853007,
0.3694298267,
-0.4519332945,
-0.3058002591,
0.2599149942,
0.1271239668,
0.0550429486,
-0.433809489,
0.5227133632,
-0.0242984165,
-0.4851306975,
0.5995183587,
0.304528892,
0.3366909623,
-0.2676874101,
-0.2010826916,
-0.1877948344,
0.2801294625,
-0.1363528818,
-0.3499456942,
0.219954446,
0.1968103647,
-0.3917218149,
-0.5377523899,
0.7452176213,
-0.3409004509,
-0.8677717447,
0.0016363601,
0.3376256526,
0.2504586875,
-0.1608151942,
-0.5209706426,
0.0902107805,
-0.1036707312,
-0.2692731619,
0.1378820837,
0.3280746937,
-0.3805344105,
0.3731848896,
0.6570764184,
-0.0587566756,
-0.1403490156,
0.0893864334,
0.8097351193,
-0.5876567364,
-0.3570837379,
-0.8352142572,
0.5645281076,
-0.1291010529,
-0.6089126468,
0.561080873,
0.6665505171,
1.1193646193,
-0.249916181,
0.8456749916,
-0.0337905623,
0.2375462204,
-0.6628989577,
0.6439759135,
-0.3510086238,
0.0403125137,
-0.6048936844,
-0.9795908332,
-0.1688445807,
0.8667375445,
-0.3942025006,
-0.0217056163,
0.8071938157,
0.8713850379,
-0.1788097173,
0.1263924986,
0.3915573061,
0.5120616555,
0.2166919559,
0.3407147229,
0.588559866,
-0.8865702152,
0.2668512166,
-0.4332768023,
-0.1635498106,
0.0025187817,
-0.9175415635,
-0.7819129229,
-0.8401266932,
-0.4310705364,
-0.414898932,
0.2921704948,
1.0044103861,
0.7797899246,
-0.8160969019,
-0.3298794627,
-0.1953439116,
0.2423100621,
-0.4287284017,
-0.2286750972,
0.3611201048,
-0.2316727936,
-0.8232552409,
0.5098584294,
0.1547573954,
-0.0132992025,
-0.2000020593,
0.053031709,
-0.1674592793,
-0.0240695775,
1.0147513151,
0.2330144942,
-0.7479769588,
-0.4594131112,
-0.192770645,
0.2789559364,
-0.2390705794,
0.9658745527,
-0.7495208979,
0.4734096229,
0.1639835089,
0.5573851466,
0.3926827013,
-0.0274122003,
0.6022006273,
-0.5925328732,
0.105770193,
-0.1322315484,
0.5187988281,
0.2580037713,
-0.0737741441,
0.5281079412,
0.4158576429,
-0.5461827517,
-0.8395907283,
0.1088136286,
-0.9998255372,
-0.1327631176,
1.212359786,
-0.1596265882,
-0.2126780599,
0.217969209,
-0.424352318,
0.1182800084,
-0.5353105068,
0.8240785599,
1.015329361,
0.0029123065,
0.1245440692,
-0.7192587852,
0.4393009543,
0.503588438,
-0.6873859167,
0.2003625184,
0.728294909,
0.405503124,
0.1004101336,
0.4943083525,
0.0030346185,
0.361513406,
-0.3392385244,
0.1923906058,
0.278195262,
-0.2367008626,
-0.7345019579,
-0.1341021657,
0.0651753321,
-0.034392409
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.