id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06126v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06126v3
|
Learn To be Efficient: Build Structured Sparsity in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-09T01:18:16 | 2024-06-03T18:28:58 |
Haizhong Zheng, Xiaoyan Bai, Xueshen Liu, Z. Morley Mao, Beidi Chen, Fan Lai, Atul Prakash
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable success with their
billion-level parameters, yet they incur high inference overheads. The
emergence of activation sparsity in LLMs provides a natural approach to reduce
this cost by involving only parts of the parameters for inference. However,
existing methods only focus on utilizing this naturally formed activation
sparsity in a post-training setting, overlooking the potential for further
amplifying this inherent sparsity. In this paper, we hypothesize that LLMs can
learn to be efficient by achieving more structured activation sparsity. To
achieve this, we introduce a novel training algorithm, Learn-To-be-Efficient
(LTE), designed to train efficiency-aware LLMs to learn to activate fewer
neurons and achieve a better trade-off between sparsity and performance.
Furthermore, unlike SOTA MoEfication methods, which mainly focus on ReLU-based
models, LTE can also be applied to LLMs like LLaMA using non-ReLU activations.
Extensive evaluation on language understanding, language generation, and
instruction tuning tasks show that LTE consistently outperforms SOTA baselines.
Along with our hardware-aware custom kernel implementation, LTE reduces
LLaMA2-7B inference latency by 25% at 50% sparsity.
|
[
-0.0887670219,
-0.9678637981,
0.4230528772,
0.3065273762,
-0.3757843673,
-0.0818925723,
-0.364230305,
-0.3328133225,
0.2180907577,
0.2189327031,
-0.3956459761,
-0.2993301749,
-0.8247792721,
0.0717881694,
-0.1961470246,
0.658650279,
0.1227367222,
-0.094566524,
0.1423828006,
-0.1927727163,
-0.2143851519,
-0.2360913754,
-0.9408543706,
-0.5884515643,
0.6603435874,
0.2763254941,
0.3177051246,
0.5869716406,
0.0537785031,
0.3083078265,
-0.2347750217,
0.3170546293,
-0.9145121574,
-0.0346790887,
0.3017312884,
-0.4385857284,
-0.3678341806,
-0.2287058234,
0.6578301787,
0.8238127232,
-0.3965456784,
0.0950743183,
0.1332348883,
0.5840787292,
-0.7013758421,
0.0343334004,
-1.0099183321,
-0.0099779777,
0.0063242568,
-0.397259295,
-0.7670475841,
-0.1333627403,
-0.2471954525,
-0.7616991401,
-0.1866858304,
-0.1078218669,
0.8426702619,
0.4516885579,
-0.2535620034,
-0.0000131391,
-0.539423883,
0.749227643,
-0.5706685781,
0.807631433,
0.2193316072,
0.082910575,
-0.3081476986,
-0.6831605434,
-0.4077138305,
-0.3905466199,
0.110177815,
0.0361284986,
-0.11055585,
0.0948554873,
0.416841805,
0.0107237995,
-0.4087254703,
0.3908412158,
-0.1467962861,
0.0903590545,
0.4526337385,
-0.2865256667,
0.1048653945,
0.3311495483,
-0.5205703974,
0.2753569186,
-0.9332452416,
0.0807477981,
0.353417784,
0.2069799602,
0.0182918347,
0.5259967446,
0.0590495169,
0.5327070951,
0.0030496577,
0.0042353808,
0.1724120528,
0.1156364381,
-0.304907769,
0.0848429576,
0.5133240819,
-0.0894606411,
0.2256302536,
-0.5265308022,
-0.6560767889,
-0.0212485474,
0.3954671621,
-0.9267840981,
0.0444826037,
0.0141611658,
-0.3911682367,
-0.1545295268,
-0.4935322106,
-0.3293562531,
0.0854988471,
-0.0639845133,
0.6625136733,
-0.4362347126,
-0.2574720085,
0.2616112232,
0.0981305838,
0.2204533219,
0.2443497777,
-1.1384603977,
0.4414215982,
0.6641184092,
0.8314986825,
0.0870087966,
-0.2254381776,
-0.8310078382,
0.1883920878,
-0.46890378,
0.8322271109,
-0.4726236761,
-0.2291579545,
-0.2025339752,
-0.2382112443,
-0.2891484797,
-0.4351071715,
0.4113099277,
-0.9566408992,
-0.1334223598,
0.0201056451,
-0.5817516446,
-0.20861049,
0.0308160782,
-0.6462444663,
1.2227929831,
0.117873162,
-0.4532979727,
0.4294076562,
-0.7427929044,
-0.6974717975,
0.1601548493,
0.090320088,
-0.5244545341,
0.4757941663,
-0.0482350476,
0.5416686535,
0.0329240337,
0.3291865885,
-0.1088570505,
-0.5894200206,
0.0180192199,
-0.2914879918,
0.5125989914,
0.260915935,
-0.4329561293,
0.051086951,
-0.7383747697,
0.0371558741,
0.0457354486,
-0.7267696261,
-0.4120888412,
0.1426490396,
-0.0514656976,
-0.2420472652,
0.1422213167,
-0.3256227374,
0.1093273535,
-0.7134898901,
0.4748359919,
0.6712707877,
-0.3647907078,
0.6866509914,
-0.093181558,
0.1443964541,
-0.2883540988,
-0.1068574637,
0.1255748421,
-0.2952739894,
-0.7478951216,
-0.5798904896,
0.2958136797,
0.4138804376,
-0.7455608249,
0.5948504806,
-0.3369876742,
-0.4104932845,
-0.3359253705,
0.58384341,
0.4529953301,
0.48512128,
0.4025103748,
-0.2640970349,
-0.4822041094,
-0.7278891802,
-0.4094755948,
0.2349072844,
0.1393242627,
0.2540186644,
0.3840843737,
-0.1376771182,
0.6834595203,
-0.1642625928,
0.042802304,
-0.6147246957,
-0.0242335796,
0.3334738314,
0.4842369258,
0.1531500518,
-0.6832009554,
-0.2500604093,
0.08020439,
-0.4531074762,
-0.2855338156,
-0.1734984368,
0.0378224924,
0.2297246605,
0.6445564628,
-0.659250617,
0.0318015665,
0.4678761959,
-0.0502801239,
0.1976906508,
-0.3063166142,
-0.253256768,
-1.0039206743,
0.1091384515,
0.1614847779,
-0.298843801,
-0.844655633,
-0.3130220473,
0.0357218869,
0.0102537917,
-0.3114555478,
0.6385639906,
-0.5555561781,
-0.2606963515,
-0.1843134761,
-0.1304117143,
-0.1446494758,
0.7711899281,
0.0349096917,
0.8986934423,
0.2761401832,
-0.686578393,
-0.3247393966,
-0.02389713,
-0.5121465921,
-0.1827190369,
-0.8412868381,
-0.0547674857,
-0.1691914201,
0.2089136839,
-0.8341389298,
-0.1616590172,
-0.047683768,
-0.2331486344,
0.5127523541,
-0.0915589184,
-0.3896646798,
0.2679044902,
-0.1780189574,
0.5110567212,
0.7178484201,
-0.8593262434,
0.6448401213,
0.334203124,
0.00213665,
-0.9236695766,
-0.5884442329,
-0.0364044569,
-0.1292532682,
-0.570938468,
0.4258847833,
0.3050786555,
0.2247963548,
-0.1287966371,
-0.1697477698,
-0.0901472196,
0.6231850386,
0.018647572,
-0.0540287718,
-0.2422707528,
0.3412249088,
0.2530560791,
-0.2310670018,
-0.0762563944,
-0.3128293753,
0.7409563661,
-0.0516019501,
-0.2464147806,
-0.5070474148,
0.2179712057,
0.2769593596,
-0.1554733664,
0.725693047,
0.4523457885,
-0.3014909923,
-0.4788137972,
-0.7314614654,
-0.3774659932,
-0.4914678633,
0.6739208102,
-0.3663296402,
-1.0342490673,
0.2314797342,
-0.4583236575,
0.295799613,
0.0612329394,
0.4707464278,
0.037294738,
0.8608880639,
0.7035638094,
0.1311705858,
0.8990493417,
-0.4475622475,
0.2870930433,
-0.77991575,
-0.2463986576,
-0.2525276244,
-0.3796596527,
-0.372159183,
-0.5108990073,
0.2684025168,
0.2637791038,
-0.3434753716,
0.32951653,
-0.1503913552,
0.6165829301,
0.2871362865,
0.3695417345,
0.1378384084,
0.4483971596,
0.0502633676,
0.2814629674,
-1.1752026081,
-0.6280849576,
0.8944727778,
0.5595437288,
0.7692934275,
-0.0427378379,
0.8077831268,
0.0242088661,
0.534502089,
-0.8613588214,
0.6093484759,
-0.1682367772,
-0.1326761395,
-0.2426327616,
-0.7450470924,
-1.0903464556,
0.1823450029,
-0.3392745554,
-0.6207499504,
0.0923615322,
0.2864593863,
-0.2238942683,
0.2605888546,
-0.901429534,
0.7879872918,
-0.1696115285,
-0.6833990812,
-0.4413097203,
-0.413630724,
0.2999278605,
0.0333093144,
0.1540959328,
0.0065743532,
-0.4617509544,
0.6732795238,
-0.3043455482,
0.9187710285,
-0.3239173889,
-0.0624744967,
0.1315879375,
-0.1667532027,
0.6737727523,
-0.0377728269,
-0.3485822678,
0.2796554863,
-0.7771218419,
-0.6204615831,
-0.6340597868,
0.5283446908,
-0.7859525084,
-0.3956708908,
0.0623686947,
-0.4231685698,
-0.2583729923,
0.1215799823,
0.3118688762,
0.5451664329,
-0.1747245044,
0.1694566011,
0.8871632218,
-0.096376285,
0.4444924593,
0.1671362668,
0.253528595,
-0.4173839688,
0.8762954473,
0.2580999434,
0.3122758865,
0.5469448566,
0.1488733441,
-0.4521696866,
-0.8539623618,
-0.4301355183,
0.2492228001,
-0.5026479363,
-0.1486421525,
-0.8375318646,
-0.2338713557,
-0.0529561043,
-0.4511997402,
-0.5016838312,
-0.3931904733,
-0.3435648382,
-0.1883379817,
0.2748482525,
0.4332433343,
0.0024093571,
0.9076228738,
-0.5502638817,
0.1486016959,
0.2726455927,
0.4613947272,
0.0042488095,
-0.6769948602,
-0.3243342936,
-0.1760593653,
-0.2142300308,
-0.6135053039,
0.4647326767,
0.5187698007,
0.6677604914,
0.2394655049,
-0.3189530671,
0.6627691984,
-0.5936897397,
0.4612225592,
0.3794079423,
-0.9634037018,
0.0891700611,
-0.0452369712,
-0.0235655829,
0.4398600757,
0.3273417354,
0.0162156802,
-0.1610376537,
-0.6138519049,
-0.9605760574,
0.395478636,
0.0408753231,
0.487010181,
-0.081743598,
0.5853560567,
0.1679230779,
0.0926931798,
-1.0447528362,
0.0209240019,
-0.0318328068,
-0.2276879847,
-0.0987214372,
-0.6236066222,
0.088700451,
-0.0405617654,
0.7866818309,
-0.1559800804,
0.1678211987,
0.1092268303,
-0.4853474796,
0.0162799712,
0.4237924218,
0.4836672843,
0.4574055374,
0.0686076954,
0.2656734586,
0.6189448237,
-0.2844992876,
0.2450949401,
-0.0668926984,
-0.080000639,
-0.0637305975,
0.3371503055,
0.9664286971,
0.5569027662,
-0.5723585486,
0.4119231403,
-0.0101957247,
-0.340062052,
-0.131146729,
0.2165054828,
0.2949865162,
0.2916843295,
0.2467787713,
0.0123807704,
0.0607113503,
-0.1689554155,
0.1281398833,
0.6555656791,
-0.1251900643,
-0.2090833336,
0.5277242661,
0.4554444551,
-0.3731199801,
0.4341582656,
-0.2440746278,
-0.4343123734,
0.5400049686,
0.6952296495,
0.9128528237,
-0.285279423,
-0.1204850152,
0.2906595469,
0.3761095107,
-0.2927877605,
0.3424430192,
-0.3384347558,
-0.7774679065,
-0.9220971465,
-0.7425307631,
-0.0202733614,
0.1002256572,
-0.2876360416,
0.270385921,
-0.4418387711,
-0.1180213168,
-0.1563673019,
-0.0077192117,
-0.2760782838,
0.1003027707,
-0.0584757514,
1.129596591,
-0.8413180113,
0.909114778,
0.5202499032,
0.1709216833,
-0.8938807845,
-0.3144035339,
-0.6352072954,
-0.969994545,
0.9679677486,
0.612737298,
-0.3836551309,
0.4453018308,
-0.5601540208,
-0.5205646157,
0.9743797779,
0.6315609813,
-0.712685287,
0.1287558675,
-0.2953397036,
0.2594079375,
-0.382047832,
0.3784194291,
0.3723867536,
0.2917085886,
0.0459831767,
-0.5603007674,
-0.0039154137,
-0.3184369504,
0.09290497,
0.353327781,
-0.5132884383,
0.5287691355,
-0.3906391859,
-0.3470816314,
-0.082507506,
0.7362459302,
0.1541506201,
0.3900688291,
0.7865235806,
0.8329480886,
0.5997126698,
0.0688035265,
0.9437731504,
-0.3190176189,
0.1620753855,
0.7694851756,
-0.2132404745,
0.9630590677,
0.5797558427,
0.2062835842,
0.3978406191,
0.5640625954,
0.2221232802,
0.6277695894,
0.2540781498,
-0.6153849959,
-0.5651572347,
0.0476866215,
-0.0880478695,
0.333104372,
0.5121077299,
-0.2214153856,
-0.2770375609,
-0.0961469337,
0.0751569271,
0.0277577322,
-0.2315539569,
0.9385598302,
0.184877485,
-0.5574707985,
0.9749458432,
-0.1250855476,
0.7551187873,
-0.8800084591,
-0.0629996061,
-0.1797050834,
0.0779154971,
-0.2822951674,
-0.1677557677,
0.2809681594,
0.0476668067,
-0.110233821,
-0.3815882504,
0.6267838478,
-0.4486089349,
-0.2575335801,
0.3838838935,
0.4890185297,
0.1605432034,
0.1038232967,
-0.612752974,
0.1130294353,
-0.1332870573,
-0.7089343667,
0.4828466475,
0.3240724206,
0.1493600756,
0.8553639054,
0.7983463407,
0.2730237246,
0.2000784427,
0.0042889314,
1.0535355806,
-0.3996207714,
-0.3048813343,
-0.8588143587,
0.4406045079,
-0.1639026403,
-0.1597409397,
0.3525104523,
0.6592074037,
0.7186395526,
0.0594734624,
0.6607223153,
0.098532483,
0.0580278933,
-0.8341630101,
0.6170586348,
-0.8119655848,
0.6138471961,
0.2098187953,
-0.805686295,
-0.2140070796,
0.8520567417,
-0.4345927835,
0.1872316897,
0.4712212682,
1.2873171568,
-0.1411841512,
-0.143137455,
0.5380928516,
0.200195089,
0.2061208785,
0.6823627949,
0.7853141427,
-0.2749165595,
0.4333921373,
-0.1320037246,
-0.5217717886,
-0.3438934982,
-1.015416503,
-0.798866272,
-0.2447725683,
-0.2131613344,
-0.259847194,
0.4473296702,
1.1062473059,
0.8804421425,
-0.3671962917,
-0.4124746025,
-0.3857381046,
0.2818887532,
-0.2479443997,
-0.1218556687,
0.3601548672,
-0.9605277181,
-0.682218194,
0.6453877091,
0.4348581135,
-0.1107290909,
0.179601714,
-0.0667144507,
-0.1638089418,
0.1134683713,
0.8697966933,
0.3492701352,
-0.3406207561,
-0.0508175157,
-0.0471645109,
-0.1772734076,
0.0768735558,
0.840390265,
-0.7322270274,
0.0305561833,
0.3038266599,
1.030729413,
0.4585437477,
-0.0886558443,
0.470695734,
-0.7502669692,
0.2644663453,
0.2251878679,
0.3899556696,
0.1249664649,
-0.2823210955,
0.3378887773,
0.1645566821,
-0.6469486952,
-0.9036500454,
0.2696971893,
-1.0321052074,
-0.2680612803,
1.374476552,
-0.0994971469,
-0.6112064719,
-0.2070882618,
-0.0381389931,
0.2939299345,
-0.5476433635,
0.7589726448,
0.0832599998,
-0.0107434914,
-0.1669504344,
-0.5930965543,
0.4616625309,
0.9019683599,
-0.8723438978,
0.0937295929,
0.1912572533,
0.38883847,
-0.2374140322,
0.743791461,
0.1860200316,
0.2490117848,
0.0364138447,
0.1711572111,
-0.2692492008,
-0.2336873561,
-0.2611370683,
0.2461016178,
0.1658224612,
-0.1404018402
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06125v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06125v1
|
Language Model Sentence Completion with a Parser-Driven Rhetorical Control Method
| 2024-02-09T01:15:42 | 2024-02-09T01:15:42 |
Joshua Zingale, Jugal Kalita
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Controlled text generation (CTG) seeks to guide large language model (LLM)
output to produce text that conforms to desired criteria. The current study
presents a novel CTG algorithm that enforces adherence toward specific
rhetorical relations in an LLM sentence-completion context by a parser-driven
decoding scheme that requires no model fine-tuning. The method is validated
both with automatic and human evaluation. The code is accessible on GitHub.
|
[
-0.1421930194,
-1.0405327082,
0.6756336093,
0.2208356112,
-0.5162623525,
0.1471102685,
-0.2809600532,
-0.0614069141,
-0.1184969097,
0.9005475044,
-0.6843349338,
-0.7790893912,
-0.6962361336,
0.3502093554,
-0.3837157786,
0.9329363108,
0.0855715945,
0.0400958806,
0.1103503406,
0.2382332981,
-0.5115417242,
-0.4769217074,
-0.7861884832,
-0.8558847904,
0.302178055,
0.0807249546,
0.9420986772,
1.0606356859,
0.3012655973,
0.1980788857,
-0.2313376665,
0.1605469286,
-0.4071178734,
0.1545750797,
-0.2010700405,
-0.5745091438,
-0.4429078996,
-0.0273802746,
0.4630489647,
0.5672636032,
-0.2966634035,
-0.3207655847,
0.2263865024,
0.3090900779,
-0.471824795,
0.0344441719,
-0.7799038887,
0.0719631687,
-0.0591056198,
-0.7033477426,
-0.9854741693,
-0.6407518387,
0.0442256518,
-0.4556900859,
0.0021043795,
0.1680912971,
0.7835607529,
0.1808130443,
-0.9004907608,
-0.5145215392,
-0.4621978998,
0.7589615583,
-0.7871534228,
-0.0653124303,
0.4969622493,
-0.0434825458,
-0.4757071733,
-0.6689476967,
-0.2867706716,
-0.5897839665,
-0.272813946,
0.1536678225,
-0.1527201831,
0.7912303209,
0.3760555089,
0.4571610689,
-0.6541162133,
-0.2017039508,
-0.2745722234,
-0.1409139931,
0.285913974,
0.1857831478,
0.4897505641,
-0.6882249117,
-0.4422974885,
0.219420597,
-0.9638066888,
-0.0565107539,
0.2886921763,
0.2289965898,
-0.0750216395,
0.8865048289,
-0.0525572598,
0.9228711724,
0.3786293566,
0.1790235639,
-0.1382994652,
-0.2860738039,
-0.4868262112,
0.3580908775,
0.8204908371,
0.4610500634,
0.6711609364,
0.0742870793,
-0.2198587656,
0.0172239952,
0.4159555733,
-0.4972057641,
0.0562823489,
0.1236547008,
-0.3809888065,
-0.5001531243,
-0.1745789945,
-0.4083542824,
-0.2351009995,
-0.5763114095,
-0.002278429,
-0.4750442803,
-0.0032903929,
0.1578641832,
-0.0696758181,
0.2314145565,
0.1445668191,
-0.6905483007,
0.2231131047,
0.6387530565,
0.9248553514,
-0.2319980115,
-0.1609100848,
-0.7520631552,
0.5174943209,
-0.4371571541,
0.6616052985,
-0.6733769178,
-0.6283624172,
0.3308781981,
-0.1155153364,
-0.2797377706,
-0.3372970223,
0.6956433058,
-0.6894361973,
0.413105607,
-0.1711691022,
-0.988946259,
-0.0951190889,
0.417650342,
-0.5105551481,
0.932978034,
0.2047801167,
-0.8203709722,
0.175049305,
-0.4363212287,
-0.417660594,
0.2787566781,
-0.3583447933,
-0.1899910718,
0.1834979653,
-0.0202020872,
0.4532971382,
-0.2921528816,
0.8270812631,
-0.141197592,
-0.3762104809,
0.0789584219,
-0.1337609887,
0.951459825,
0.4096408188,
-0.2852239609,
0.4889118373,
-1.0019103289,
0.3087358475,
0.0042637764,
-0.8643150926,
-0.1753933728,
0.002205689,
0.2294303775,
0.0666900724,
0.4368937016,
-0.2351896167,
0.4471995533,
-0.4035127163,
0.6778222919,
0.6238000393,
0.2217024118,
0.5237836838,
-0.6312432289,
0.8608849049,
-0.4586733878,
-0.3262952268,
-0.4104449749,
-0.2281599492,
-0.7791662812,
0.0774771497,
0.1761177778,
0.7913098931,
-0.6678832173,
0.8450075388,
-0.0129990503,
-0.15719001,
-0.0127224615,
0.1292207688,
0.6003357172,
0.3981502056,
-0.0646049753,
0.2179749906,
-0.73919034,
-0.8223267794,
-0.1879285723,
-0.0213257913,
-0.2339739352,
0.0936239064,
0.1861763746,
0.0705817714,
0.7548774481,
-0.4765090644,
-0.1409673095,
-0.7067850232,
0.4205745161,
0.0378303751,
0.484390825,
0.5440040827,
-0.385710001,
-0.5370519161,
0.1026766971,
-0.6016373038,
-0.6592655778,
-0.2345755696,
-0.126351878,
0.2005203515,
0.9205253124,
-0.5040507913,
0.4939551651,
0.7796233296,
-0.4368465245,
0.5094303489,
-0.3554902375,
0.2941325605,
-1.2723158598,
0.025712695,
-0.0636086613,
-0.6858920455,
-0.7741871476,
0.1921253055,
0.0837424546,
-0.1243923977,
-0.3747932315,
0.2740825415,
-0.3255753219,
0.4466402233,
-0.6921365857,
0.2240318805,
-0.0180498064,
0.5157558322,
0.1844146401,
0.8990203142,
0.2473452538,
-0.5619559884,
0.0916162282,
0.1761827022,
-0.029924266,
0.4978995323,
-1.0291805267,
0.1138767302,
-0.0410037041,
0.2218602598,
-1.0375224352,
-0.3978681266,
0.1422543377,
-0.1891355664,
-0.000560136,
-0.1389329135,
-0.5661646128,
-0.0781539232,
0.0297891982,
0.3535391092,
0.5096005201,
-0.1908802986,
0.6779280305,
-0.0301414169,
-0.2448897362,
-0.0524274483,
-0.8465512991,
0.1286200732,
-0.1752887666,
-0.4180082381,
0.3030162156,
-0.1297730803,
-0.2193249315,
-0.3254283965,
0.3043919802,
0.0713704973,
-0.2369645089,
0.1895864159,
0.0477933697,
-0.1029638946,
0.121146284,
0.3130243421,
0.0554008521,
0.1058469638,
0.0643566847,
1.0321061611,
0.1820254326,
-0.2503199577,
-0.5194126964,
0.5286258459,
0.490901202,
-0.0126392255,
0.3129354417,
0.2215339094,
-0.3313851953,
-0.3721671104,
-0.4036442339,
-0.0422673449,
-0.5366223454,
0.1411509514,
-0.4184554517,
-1.1485167742,
0.5425701141,
-0.0222978629,
-0.1713335365,
0.252359271,
0.6013072729,
0.2577355802,
1.0720677376,
0.7987508774,
0.2418097556,
0.434548378,
0.2621434033,
0.0882483572,
-0.5147008896,
0.0446910411,
-0.6121246815,
-0.1094775945,
-0.7630060911,
0.1533061564,
0.1506966054,
0.3373970985,
-0.1900750548,
0.3482705355,
-0.6711364985,
0.567134738,
0.6946076751,
0.0874314234,
0.52214849,
-0.1362996697,
-0.387558192,
-0.0650731176,
-0.5950400233,
-0.7587662935,
0.8770202994,
0.0821862295,
0.5999604464,
-0.1814648658,
0.6818318367,
0.5076653957,
0.0769769102,
-0.6687927842,
0.6637351513,
-0.124737367,
-0.5154149532,
0.1259807795,
-0.3401564956,
-0.968640089,
0.0538422726,
0.1027156487,
-0.8217015862,
-0.3016491234,
0.2874077559,
-0.237785548,
-0.0298521928,
-0.5181090236,
0.5374487638,
-0.0186197925,
-0.0411329791,
-0.331643641,
-0.3473531008,
0.5110654831,
0.173770979,
-0.2326795459,
0.0100084208,
0.0535057299,
0.6621372104,
-0.4864581823,
0.8467776179,
0.0354594737,
-0.1456996351,
0.5096244812,
0.4925218523,
0.7107875943,
-0.1680662185,
0.0328183286,
-0.2654484808,
0.0399596542,
-0.4271434546,
-0.3623551428,
0.7865199447,
-0.512169838,
-0.8784565926,
-0.4060037732,
-0.8286104798,
-0.0408231094,
0.5236243606,
0.5505663753,
0.0682701245,
-0.1760871261,
0.3723638356,
0.693708837,
-0.3763355017,
0.5419406891,
0.1533114612,
-0.5321016312,
-0.7055566311,
0.2219630182,
-0.11662554,
0.5004184246,
0.4023497105,
0.1932798624,
-0.1258044839,
-0.6987297535,
-0.1549057215,
0.1229999065,
-0.6028687954,
-0.107117556,
-0.6025519967,
-0.5651831627,
-0.4022744,
-0.5354803801,
0.0507274941,
-0.2631592453,
-0.5323926806,
-0.1862659603,
0.2811234593,
1.0787403584,
0.3893446624,
1.0090960264,
-0.7611110806,
0.0623687878,
0.031884905,
0.1366964877,
-0.4063493907,
-0.3863939643,
0.1436505765,
-0.0263179149,
-0.5573727489,
-1.1127898693,
0.3613728583,
-0.061915163,
0.2234224826,
0.576721251,
-0.0992844775,
0.3710017204,
-0.4089387059,
0.9082701802,
0.3313730359,
-1.2929222584,
0.9856772423,
-1.1014701128,
0.8623179197,
0.3139497042,
-0.0997191817,
-0.4788974524,
-0.7146421075,
-0.4067967534,
-0.5155746341,
0.6455011368,
0.2648614049,
0.1139014736,
-0.2690860629,
0.5398039222,
-0.1606189162,
0.3597730696,
-1.0235991478,
0.058323741,
-0.0432585329,
-0.3033216,
0.2495351732,
-0.5195259452,
-0.2267531008,
0.239480108,
0.5325784683,
-0.1931973845,
-0.1614310741,
0.1157194376,
-0.0012031607,
-0.2034202069,
0.6446284056,
0.9171705842,
0.7244414687,
-0.168159768,
0.0771279484,
-0.1531475633,
-0.2996502519,
0.2011507601,
-0.0186926164,
-0.7096866965,
0.0036159069,
0.2440611124,
0.467273891,
0.1159414202,
-0.6829520464,
0.5703300238,
0.0601342842,
-0.5922549367,
-0.2882285416,
0.2420112938,
-0.0194766168,
0.0875565037,
0.3305451274,
-0.2070585638,
0.0020676272,
-0.1694524586,
0.3247521818,
0.4032298028,
-0.3518883288,
-0.1000765935,
0.8382037282,
0.0250963885,
-0.4146206379,
0.3618794978,
-0.2059321254,
-0.4964627028,
0.6344045997,
0.7110315561,
0.9265131354,
-0.0944139659,
0.2715960145,
0.3700890541,
0.3323781192,
-0.2275369614,
0.6124380231,
0.1490458548,
-0.5547340512,
-0.7799850702,
-0.5237935781,
-0.2386573851,
0.3902202547,
-0.6515223384,
0.5025530457,
-0.8853188157,
-0.2488976866,
-0.3835553527,
-0.0820880309,
-0.2794352472,
0.2569557428,
0.0417314582,
1.0185546875,
-0.6021559238,
1.0268644094,
0.3485621214,
-0.2148343474,
-0.8548845649,
-0.1700261384,
0.0987954438,
-0.6077528,
0.5754691362,
-0.0424746275,
-0.1992163807,
-0.0114136813,
-0.5383034945,
-0.6211892962,
0.984959662,
0.4398815036,
-0.797098577,
-0.2891870141,
0.3445463479,
0.5484501123,
-0.62130934,
-0.0754906908,
0.5776889324,
0.6092277169,
0.2180371135,
-0.9225620031,
0.2157064974,
-0.1044051573,
0.3900178075,
0.2390328348,
-0.5000879765,
0.580966711,
0.1520257145,
-0.1618656218,
0.3652616441,
0.644035399,
0.5473726392,
0.1090953052,
0.2336828262,
0.6165373921,
0.6628061533,
-0.2314347327,
0.9369024038,
-0.5944210291,
0.2768106461,
1.4622725248,
-0.2526901066,
0.6323747635,
0.4824191928,
0.1065811887,
0.2767089903,
0.5158067942,
-0.0783751085,
0.4576253295,
0.289650768,
-0.2691236138,
-0.2765782773,
-0.3289507627,
-0.1513691545,
0.5539062023,
0.2020756751,
-0.9936133027,
-0.4052449465,
-0.0345921256,
0.3012954891,
0.5704609156,
-0.3657596409,
0.7330747247,
-0.0725192502,
-0.9861342907,
0.7618216276,
0.1023966819,
0.4819859564,
-0.7314613461,
0.0491255522,
0.0766184852,
0.0628719926,
-0.0982474983,
-0.5265546441,
0.5432201028,
-0.0965281725,
-0.2319456786,
-0.5218240023,
0.6432121396,
-0.7214383483,
-0.4231220186,
0.2563031316,
0.5688694715,
-0.2500441074,
0.160063073,
-0.5002113581,
0.1450580209,
0.3596815169,
-0.4948644936,
-0.0211587809,
0.3388528526,
0.1228834391,
0.5941115618,
0.2443639487,
0.1723128855,
0.2906931341,
0.200248912,
0.6944255233,
-0.7510749698,
-0.503336966,
-0.9459168911,
0.2919560671,
0.1142658815,
-0.3511732519,
0.6211561561,
0.6398509145,
0.7855056524,
-0.0432442166,
1.1044923067,
-0.191733107,
0.2264505625,
-0.8430204988,
0.6440645456,
-0.1724797189,
0.1799286008,
0.1200936437,
-0.8263953924,
-0.5284565687,
0.4813465476,
-0.4229898751,
0.0216537807,
1.0844298601,
0.9364129901,
0.0051025599,
0.0416690446,
0.5682991147,
0.0454579554,
0.4634664357,
0.7328967452,
0.6972691417,
-0.1706625968,
0.6321684122,
0.0490992144,
-0.1859533638,
0.1422778517,
-1.1582384109,
-1.2471678257,
-0.3993185163,
-0.41617167,
-0.5447087884,
0.0158845,
1.1681780815,
0.5026955605,
-0.7467833161,
-0.3769159019,
-0.7914823294,
-0.0912893713,
0.1152541488,
-0.2984468639,
0.202595219,
-0.4493851066,
-0.9169194698,
0.1878274232,
0.3689799905,
0.0532120354,
-0.1835511923,
-0.0625773147,
-0.4112754464,
0.438613534,
0.3988625705,
-0.1522485167,
-1.0173498392,
-0.2319978029,
-0.1527208835,
-0.4092680812,
0.1899293661,
1.3937016726,
-0.4314671159,
0.2305606753,
0.6648187041,
0.3936283588,
0.109563686,
0.0806384683,
0.9148313403,
-0.7569292188,
0.0493430384,
0.1780974418,
0.5292935967,
0.0393795185,
-0.5372822881,
0.176564768,
-0.07944116,
-0.7834179997,
-0.3771456778,
0.5417453647,
-1.0880932808,
-0.3210654259,
1.4469412565,
-0.1953235567,
-0.3132576942,
0.1538558155,
-0.7011732459,
0.3857370019,
-0.4956237078,
0.7032570243,
0.9785801172,
-0.0802497715,
-0.6329378486,
-0.2778015733,
0.7005633712,
0.3090466261,
-0.8338192105,
0.1142101362,
0.8097171783,
0.2266529351,
-0.0084367283,
0.6578651071,
-0.0431946293,
0.2625916898,
-0.3577545583,
0.0048882016,
0.0178607553,
0.0070661297,
-0.4612217546,
0.7127741575,
0.0481578708,
0.2247620672
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06120v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06120v1
|
Exploring Group and Symmetry Principles in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-09T01:10:25 | 2024-02-09T01:10:25 |
Shima Imani, Hamid Palangi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive performance across
a wide range of applications; however, assessing their reasoning capabilities
remains a significant challenge. In this paper, we introduce a framework
grounded in group and symmetry principles, which have played a crucial role in
fields such as physics and mathematics, and offer another way to evaluate their
capabilities. While the proposed framework is general, to showcase the benefits
of employing these properties, we focus on arithmetic reasoning and investigate
the performance of these models on four group properties: closure, identity,
inverse, and associativity. Our findings reveal that LLMs studied in this work
struggle to preserve group properties across different test regimes. In the
closure test, we observe biases towards specific outputs and an abrupt
degradation in their performance from 100% to 0% after a specific sequence
length. They also perform poorly in the identity test, which represents adding
irrelevant information in the context, and show sensitivity when subjected to
inverse test, which examines the robustness of the model with respect to
negation. In addition, we demonstrate that breaking down problems into smaller
steps helps LLMs in the associativity test that we have conducted. To support
these tests we have developed a synthetic dataset which will be released.
|
[
-0.3564835489,
-0.4627821147,
0.7401208282,
0.1128253043,
-0.141739279,
0.0644681975,
-0.1603484899,
-0.1934916377,
-0.0327891298,
0.4371406138,
-0.2548000515,
-0.5367775559,
-0.4868135452,
0.3784945905,
-0.4822119474,
0.612011075,
-0.0933506116,
0.4141742289,
-0.2667502165,
-0.6123895049,
-0.0127548501,
-0.8415299058,
-0.4678537548,
-0.5199263692,
0.0951184556,
0.1127472073,
0.9902176261,
0.8150392175,
0.536262393,
0.2785913348,
-0.1368326992,
-0.0557056963,
-0.4554416239,
-0.0217922237,
-0.174196586,
-0.6917337775,
-0.387617141,
0.0342859514,
0.9430932403,
1.2413692474,
-0.3572466373,
-0.0032184408,
-0.1178031713,
0.6486233473,
-0.3402239382,
0.4492772818,
-0.7331991196,
-0.0426430404,
-0.0263884161,
0.4943981469,
-0.3336840272,
-0.4242767692,
-0.2614372671,
-0.6357027888,
0.2813547254,
0.2156837136,
0.7114444971,
-0.0294566024,
-0.4864068329,
-0.1479040384,
-0.4137691259,
0.7884806395,
-0.9641782641,
0.6404876113,
0.5646193027,
0.2194402367,
-0.2714521587,
-0.2895433009,
-0.6250300407,
-0.069608137,
-0.087149933,
-0.0627495348,
0.1563837528,
0.2237903774,
0.4859566689,
0.7484773397,
-0.6283626556,
0.1697912067,
-0.1852962524,
-0.0997206718,
0.6480107903,
0.2253968716,
0.3690591753,
0.0889168382,
0.0392779224,
-0.0088154078,
-0.9608492851,
0.0853053033,
0.4876691401,
0.2223711908,
-0.1475483775,
0.8193046451,
-0.0316398814,
0.6841626763,
-0.1394682825,
-0.3803482354,
0.2271163464,
-0.3576612175,
-0.1728268564,
-0.2463356704,
0.6341869831,
0.1417004019,
0.2678471804,
-0.2539307475,
-0.4077186584,
0.4530557096,
-0.4807947874,
-0.8063179255,
-0.0444725379,
-0.0924326181,
-0.5949613452,
-0.0786059797,
0.2046432197,
-0.3792371452,
-0.2364898324,
-0.6231799126,
0.330851227,
-0.5922729969,
-0.2788261771,
0.5016791224,
-0.1107681468,
0.274300307,
0.3192187846,
-1.2374206781,
0.7632796168,
1.1776340008,
0.6449869275,
-0.1936274916,
-0.3049536943,
-0.5450028777,
0.1600563675,
-0.4192743301,
0.3471140563,
-0.7752261758,
-0.2512997687,
-0.1645991057,
-0.1977718472,
-0.1053071842,
-0.5109947324,
0.3296258748,
-0.3639294803,
0.3605444431,
-0.3711927831,
-0.6817398071,
-0.1759348661,
0.2811784446,
-0.6902591586,
0.4445192218,
-0.0541437268,
-0.420601666,
0.1220974922,
-0.3840572536,
-0.3810930848,
-0.2932713628,
-0.6020658612,
-0.2261707634,
0.506577909,
0.0847239867,
0.1928755343,
-0.5708194971,
0.193152234,
-0.7302240729,
-0.4110583961,
0.2628225684,
-0.2457062602,
0.9074475765,
0.0579947755,
0.0047637713,
-0.123383753,
-0.7903001308,
0.1586013436,
0.0500123464,
-0.100344047,
-0.4870543778,
0.093857877,
-0.8110877275,
0.1323943138,
-0.0498393737,
-0.2781329453,
0.4871314168,
-0.563786447,
0.5379932523,
0.9865764976,
-0.1754332781,
0.5085738301,
-0.2317003757,
0.4725719392,
-0.0949734449,
0.0672360733,
-0.237376079,
-0.5046557188,
-0.6108296514,
-0.3605669737,
0.0607680567,
0.3261086345,
-0.4749088883,
0.5095317364,
-0.2957019508,
-0.1807692647,
-0.1759653836,
0.473390162,
0.4977849722,
0.3368394077,
0.1135451496,
-0.2180535793,
-0.0716073066,
-0.9240204692,
-0.3716609478,
-0.481054306,
-0.1080710813,
0.0392122157,
0.3707659543,
-0.0473215654,
0.6711704135,
-0.4841588438,
0.1354886144,
-0.0744891167,
-0.1206400767,
0.7199411392,
-0.034945216,
0.3585908115,
-0.7805306911,
-0.09452115,
-0.0856504291,
-1.0307476521,
-0.4088921547,
0.3426361084,
-0.0255034063,
0.2781819701,
0.2967782617,
-0.9025617242,
0.4449427128,
0.8076331019,
-0.5472947955,
0.5484671593,
0.2852427065,
0.0600153096,
-0.9738571048,
-0.2363643199,
-0.0347865894,
-0.1129572764,
-0.4767178595,
0.2791889608,
-0.1321264654,
-0.2386384308,
-0.148410067,
0.5579625368,
-0.6790769696,
-0.3432123661,
-0.0201130491,
-0.1177695766,
0.3816843629,
0.1649325937,
-0.1873093396,
0.5970553756,
0.6187183857,
-0.694999814,
0.3335434794,
0.1953132898,
-0.2097202092,
0.3874832094,
-0.7405203581,
0.0353954211,
-0.2592046559,
0.0178987999,
-1.0363230705,
-0.2007559091,
0.0037459354,
-0.3645885289,
0.2334499955,
-0.1844936907,
-0.8044623733,
-0.0911888629,
-0.2321092486,
0.7095746994,
0.661224246,
-0.4086101949,
0.8987852335,
0.3117443025,
-0.0176096708,
-0.3698342741,
-0.3978044093,
-0.2311419398,
-0.6073534489,
-0.9360001087,
0.1400329173,
-0.1136826575,
-1.0526906252,
-0.111569576,
-0.1548396498,
0.0809543729,
0.1703016013,
0.1590934247,
0.2178379297,
-0.3111497164,
0.4253447652,
-0.1752085984,
-0.0315854251,
0.1888425052,
-0.194235757,
0.710242331,
-0.4525536299,
-0.678055346,
-0.0062723807,
0.33411327,
0.7873976827,
-0.3476333022,
0.8762148023,
-0.0341090113,
-0.4586291611,
-0.0610902384,
-0.5949245691,
-0.3348880708,
-0.5027763844,
0.3048644662,
-0.3980278969,
-0.8309981823,
1.0238518715,
0.1347957999,
-0.0284035131,
0.3372993469,
0.5786242485,
0.24558869,
1.1208512783,
0.3578161001,
-0.1535033733,
0.0630679801,
-0.0669470057,
0.4647861123,
-0.7292813659,
0.0132174548,
-0.3206393123,
0.0982434675,
-0.3426615596,
-0.3314373791,
0.4657122195,
0.6061754227,
-0.4739015102,
-0.0193730444,
-0.0059664464,
0.6089238524,
0.0448916629,
-0.1481793821,
0.5660278201,
-0.0027798894,
-0.2266020626,
-0.1096564978,
-0.2603905499,
-0.6393644214,
0.9786241055,
0.427287668,
1.1218534708,
0.5394251943,
0.6211332679,
-0.1687791646,
0.4200409055,
-0.7911542654,
0.8184846044,
-0.1860099584,
-0.4072860181,
-0.4895160794,
-0.7498114705,
-0.6489167809,
0.6346817017,
0.0163630266,
-0.7779086828,
-0.0305662677,
0.190764159,
0.1873298287,
0.3737791181,
-0.6871622801,
0.5507065058,
-0.3578360081,
-0.3418218195,
0.0130426195,
-0.4193096459,
0.7824585438,
-0.2591735721,
0.4334385991,
-0.2772821784,
0.053841155,
0.3808196783,
-0.4867908061,
0.6294125319,
0.1622132361,
-0.3737518787,
0.0499585569,
0.4042445123,
0.4605821371,
0.1597208232,
-0.5322489738,
0.5361728072,
-0.1746365428,
-0.1496599317,
-1.0297843218,
0.6615666151,
-0.6466755271,
-0.97464329,
-0.2701849937,
-0.6822541356,
-0.3266494572,
0.4377004206,
0.0317558348,
0.416118294,
0.0133813964,
0.3170713186,
0.6524599195,
-0.0207920484,
0.3234122097,
0.4976987839,
-0.9662540555,
-0.4993603528,
0.6634472609,
0.0996967256,
0.8896439672,
0.1608653814,
0.4374872744,
-0.398478061,
-0.4489761293,
-0.1907963455,
0.5839636922,
-0.8415356874,
-0.0156251378,
-0.3248621821,
-0.0637632608,
-0.765597403,
0.2676911056,
-0.2798374891,
-0.8060004115,
-0.1056326479,
-0.1168024614,
0.026938282,
0.5353124738,
0.0263996366,
-0.0822328851,
-0.5456064939,
0.647206068,
0.2420798242,
0.2509093583,
-0.1431063116,
-0.52581352,
0.1088756993,
0.0826895535,
-0.2935223281,
-0.7532310486,
0.1881022602,
0.2067642957,
0.7660218477,
0.5581403375,
-0.1017278433,
0.5094764829,
-0.5987451673,
0.5893138647,
0.3108051121,
-1.2562327385,
0.1233144626,
-0.5093812346,
-0.0400384702,
0.3426564336,
0.2203563601,
-0.313677758,
-0.3338056505,
-0.3888961375,
-0.5856741667,
0.1654020995,
0.4505949914,
-0.0152974194,
0.1839046776,
0.4844933152,
-0.0232883822,
0.3833861947,
-0.9065691829,
-0.3333971202,
-0.297934413,
-0.3148625195,
-0.1036775112,
0.0304538272,
-0.2921660244,
-0.3860298395,
0.3454395235,
-0.2539063096,
-0.0198661424,
-0.1410785317,
0.1887003183,
0.0051913871,
0.250280261,
0.5333565474,
1.1068212986,
0.1209621131,
0.1689098477,
0.1809345484,
-0.1676736772,
0.5278183222,
0.0304383114,
0.014621364,
-0.345025897,
0.6184023619,
0.4250216484,
-0.0375464633,
-0.3701700866,
0.4249153137,
-0.0889558867,
-0.2610942721,
-0.2606441379,
0.1646011472,
0.1281876862,
-0.0572309941,
0.3940034211,
-0.330594033,
0.0332519189,
-0.9012903571,
0.0805364624,
0.6476919055,
0.1963132322,
-0.5121898651,
0.243559882,
-0.2420084327,
-0.3482069075,
0.4798312783,
-0.222001344,
-0.7493494153,
0.601837635,
0.7576961517,
0.5474466681,
-0.4560533166,
-0.149205327,
0.0077024582,
0.4469903708,
-0.3978550434,
0.2547096014,
0.2280258238,
-1.0138075352,
-0.3998932838,
-0.5529274344,
-0.3930791616,
0.1013435796,
-0.7330731153,
0.2309960574,
-0.5651459098,
-0.0097298436,
-0.2198663205,
-0.3276257515,
-0.296336174,
0.0750972703,
0.0807799622,
0.5922254324,
-1.0121018887,
0.4130523205,
0.5706253648,
-0.1636751145,
-0.8908407092,
-0.0240106992,
0.2024366558,
-1.1097191572,
0.7576467991,
0.4084916711,
-0.1007355452,
-0.2385587096,
-0.6018857956,
-1.2292326689,
0.8133474588,
0.7870464921,
-0.5188728571,
-0.1769283265,
0.3237941861,
0.6332873106,
-0.4290248156,
0.0269252732,
0.3755850792,
0.5223905444,
0.2520236969,
-1.0010242462,
0.0758234933,
-0.2699666917,
-0.0903692693,
0.3695750833,
-0.866263926,
1.2710894346,
-0.1603167951,
-0.2153650075,
0.0217730235,
0.4851641357,
0.7771469355,
0.2178133279,
0.5689321756,
1.0166301727,
0.7638579607,
-0.1499307752,
1.0404772758,
-0.2837097049,
0.362280786,
0.7818344831,
-0.7172444463,
0.4489077628,
0.4476341605,
-0.1292006969,
0.4802581966,
0.1298892796,
0.046612218,
0.3353404701,
0.6421934366,
-0.243506819,
-0.4044404626,
-0.0464129262,
-0.4985119998,
0.4694108069,
0.5732976198,
-0.4527044296,
-0.2166518271,
-0.212244302,
0.080185011,
0.206159398,
-0.4370794594,
0.515204072,
0.5255426168,
-0.5683451891,
0.4623838663,
0.047669325,
0.0600594692,
-0.4935761094,
-0.3579236269,
-0.2110842168,
0.4178916812,
-0.1161174998,
-0.6290156841,
0.1741328686,
-0.3960436285,
-0.292268157,
0.1164386943,
0.4228630662,
-0.3603759408,
-0.890626967,
0.1639710069,
0.202918455,
0.1039173603,
0.20075804,
-0.4479792118,
0.4153334796,
-0.1602916718,
-0.0513371639,
0.1730594188,
0.714833796,
-0.1247215122,
0.8606032729,
0.7069644332,
0.233945936,
-0.025446007,
0.1636269242,
1.0212002993,
-0.8093312383,
-0.3889576495,
-1.306691885,
0.2003498226,
-0.0529196896,
-0.1261688322,
1.0527018309,
0.7112283111,
0.5786471963,
0.3721878529,
0.5686295033,
0.4724165499,
0.3378048837,
-0.9946709871,
0.4228265285,
-0.2828661799,
0.5683992505,
-0.3465278745,
-1.0482904911,
-0.4712724984,
0.8606541753,
-0.2773489356,
0.2682187557,
0.8585566282,
0.596752286,
-0.1870755255,
0.1077875718,
0.4480930269,
0.3012256324,
0.8759430051,
0.7228933573,
0.8814691305,
-0.3909198344,
0.2179615945,
0.0875046626,
-0.212630108,
0.2794900239,
-0.9369629622,
-1.3043470383,
-0.210348472,
-0.0767554417,
-0.539411366,
-0.2266846299,
0.6774641275,
0.5160123706,
-0.453761965,
-0.3496832252,
-0.1664796174,
0.1865320951,
0.1757213324,
-0.2514944971,
0.3053555489,
-0.0428874716,
-0.333022505,
0.1352842152,
0.36357373,
0.1726108491,
-0.4978527725,
-0.2195603251,
0.2214698941,
0.0714603886,
0.5092603564,
0.1936220527,
-0.8822764158,
-0.2355380952,
0.0364237353,
0.0482608564,
-0.1266457438,
0.8214198351,
-0.4020710886,
0.1766423732,
0.325512886,
0.5246420503,
0.0898223519,
0.4100831747,
0.8448551893,
-0.2933479249,
0.1024196148,
0.2311702222,
0.8173618913,
0.3678382039,
-0.1444010288,
0.6020200849,
0.3766209483,
-0.4883193076,
-1.046497345,
0.5267912745,
-0.5046943426,
0.0401083119,
1.368162632,
-0.2630099058,
-0.1757083237,
0.0622873046,
0.2514851093,
-0.2472593188,
-0.2105065435,
0.8246436715,
1.0880314112,
-0.2433827668,
-0.1273783594,
0.0031209614,
0.1061348841,
0.5288479924,
-0.782818377,
0.2062958777,
0.7011231184,
0.3153267205,
0.3078348339,
0.4870892465,
-0.4008781314,
-0.0578950383,
-0.3942275047,
-0.2183000296,
-0.1298066974,
-0.2763090134,
-0.4496173263,
0.1541173607,
0.0375063792,
0.2041352987
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06094v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06094v1
|
Rethinking Data Selection for Supervised Fine-Tuning
| 2024-02-08T23:02:04 | 2024-02-08T23:02:04 |
Ming Shen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Although supervised finetuning (SFT) has emerged as an essential technique to
align large language models with humans, it is considered superficial, with
style learning being its nature. At the same time, recent works indicate the
importance of data selection for SFT, showing that finetuning with high-quality
and diverse subsets of the original dataset leads to superior downstream
performance. In this work, we rethink the intuition behind data selection for
SFT. Considering SFT is superficial, we propose that essential demonstrations
for SFT should focus on reflecting human-like interactions instead of data
quality or diversity. However, it is not straightforward to directly assess to
what extent a demonstration reflects human styles. Towards an initial attempt
in this direction, we find selecting instances with long responses is
surprisingly more effective for SFT than utilizing full datasets or instances
selected based on quality and diversity. We hypothesize that such a simple
heuristic implicitly mimics a crucial aspect of human-style conversation:
detailed responses are usually more helpful.
|
[
-0.8023004532,
-1.0924608707,
0.5015282631,
0.2360448837,
-0.3345473111,
0.0118885702,
-0.6785325408,
-0.4289982617,
0.1909572035,
0.3078107536,
-0.7626367807,
-0.4092585444,
-0.1887210459,
0.1498975456,
-0.6870926619,
1.2468426228,
0.1238671392,
-0.2020808905,
-0.261431396,
-0.0552205257,
-0.4554226398,
-0.1886342615,
-0.931722343,
-0.4269173145,
0.5259749293,
0.8825442195,
0.9081081748,
0.9495105147,
0.3917405009,
0.1979724616,
0.0967367515,
0.2876327038,
-0.874909997,
0.1390151829,
-0.2179429829,
-0.5017883182,
0.0464574508,
0.2488585263,
0.1514484584,
1.0220757723,
0.1404901892,
0.1476202011,
0.3839661479,
1.0886154175,
-0.3437717855,
-0.0272279885,
-0.5516520739,
0.065501675,
-0.2926832736,
0.0019018615,
-0.2188365459,
-0.114917323,
0.3628491759,
-0.6712962389,
0.7140741944,
0.0617117807,
0.8761181235,
0.5548500419,
-0.3409605324,
0.0701039135,
-0.8625689745,
0.7237916589,
-0.4110416472,
0.5616773963,
0.6376754045,
0.5235922933,
-0.024470767,
-0.5074278712,
-0.2922131717,
-0.4011973441,
-0.2167588621,
0.1118273139,
0.1384081542,
-0.0017248557,
0.4619845748,
0.5360816121,
-0.427842766,
0.4330731332,
-0.4695785642,
-0.049010206,
0.8870373368,
0.1106615439,
-0.271712333,
-0.0438951291,
-0.1166388169,
-0.2390585244,
-0.5944570899,
0.3393626809,
0.4146649837,
0.5375751257,
-0.1512983143,
0.3553242087,
-0.8550986052,
0.6734858155,
0.487649858,
0.1096099839,
0.0904055014,
-0.3576790988,
-0.2327027321,
-0.2154937983,
0.9212688804,
0.5700801611,
0.7156211138,
-0.2010644227,
-0.179214403,
-0.1617768854,
0.5473053455,
-0.8381934762,
-0.4784793556,
0.115192771,
-0.404325068,
-0.3804022372,
0.3253442943,
-0.9142209291,
-0.0416536853,
-0.9051241279,
0.0575009063,
-0.3033560216,
-0.1946364939,
0.1255962104,
-0.0512095056,
-0.1208413467,
0.2548125088,
-1.1080471277,
0.3969533741,
0.7818311453,
0.4924225509,
-0.2782881558,
-0.2789993882,
-0.5780998468,
-0.1994083971,
-0.6836906672,
0.716942668,
-0.5456562042,
-0.4792348444,
-0.3125165105,
0.0687813312,
0.3186579049,
-0.4160286486,
0.6773430705,
-0.1092669517,
0.2187227309,
-0.4270734787,
-0.2840269506,
0.0050647068,
-0.1635995805,
-0.7029959559,
0.9808415174,
0.3474094272,
-0.6991270781,
1.1233302355,
-0.3519161642,
-0.6767691374,
-0.141250357,
-0.3358571231,
-0.6363250017,
0.0709918067,
0.396404773,
0.9381130338,
-0.0553972013,
0.3257015049,
-0.7034019828,
-0.7898934484,
0.2299273163,
-0.4535479248,
0.1876338273,
0.5363021493,
-0.5026091337,
0.1518882215,
-0.7047306299,
0.0701464489,
-0.0212471522,
-0.3441313207,
-0.4751235545,
0.0868290216,
0.1115401909,
0.1219024137,
-0.3142898381,
-0.4404611588,
0.1572143734,
-0.383156985,
0.4852719903,
0.7917305827,
-0.2082852125,
0.5454748273,
-0.4841383398,
0.2514416575,
-0.3642913401,
0.159168005,
0.2709698379,
-0.0233361777,
-0.4471570551,
-0.3309851289,
0.4093144834,
0.271958977,
-0.693040967,
0.2623200715,
-0.2963245511,
-0.4695012569,
-0.7706616521,
0.427506268,
0.3892013729,
0.3910259604,
0.3653652668,
-0.3134796619,
-0.4222200513,
-1.2341403961,
-0.1976881474,
0.1788344383,
-0.1812775135,
0.476457417,
0.0584931672,
-0.167066738,
1.2833760977,
-0.6024153829,
0.0063560125,
-0.2051925361,
-0.0193716753,
0.0222130157,
0.5851873159,
1.0839703083,
-0.7657687068,
-0.4599161744,
0.0359788202,
-0.4721851349,
-0.0980721265,
-0.4348472953,
-0.2836520076,
0.0075267595,
0.5831142068,
-0.2779685855,
0.4493249357,
0.2760648727,
-0.1045634747,
0.537042141,
0.0302912798,
0.2820242643,
-0.9080424905,
-0.2299106419,
0.4063152671,
-0.3836259842,
-0.3485102057,
-0.0980038717,
0.0299505889,
0.1017251387,
-0.1738549918,
0.3847354352,
-0.2309436947,
0.0184373278,
-0.1887023449,
-0.1732029617,
-0.1578803062,
0.5266661048,
-0.0375099443,
0.8549537659,
0.4959463477,
-0.6561464667,
0.1889777482,
0.2040431052,
-0.3235357702,
0.7987089157,
-0.7955970764,
0.1641995162,
-0.0090286275,
0.1793657988,
-1.1038058996,
-0.6205393672,
-0.2608160079,
-0.2809524536,
0.4130623043,
-0.3476524353,
-0.5432154536,
-0.4913010895,
-0.3689058721,
0.1830678433,
0.4745381773,
-0.6895247698,
-0.0909446105,
0.0605636835,
-0.131174475,
-0.1768089086,
-0.5103365779,
-0.0682135895,
-0.5631212592,
-0.6164318919,
0.1657686234,
-0.0952605382,
-0.2900639176,
-0.5101763606,
-0.2551738918,
-0.0483302772,
0.5316794515,
0.2446151525,
0.0216505714,
-0.186448589,
-0.0110072857,
0.377242744,
0.0297416691,
-0.1330589801,
-0.0094919372,
0.3233284354,
-0.112921156,
-0.4160509706,
-0.7357397079,
0.3618838191,
0.3486686647,
-0.1097368523,
0.334813118,
0.9230814576,
0.1407172829,
-0.2273857743,
-0.6103516817,
-0.6289902925,
-0.4778132439,
0.3065628111,
-0.4802613258,
-1.0605096817,
0.2192413509,
-0.0134861637,
0.0986471549,
0.2126376629,
0.1434256136,
-0.3887767792,
1.0867029428,
0.5757023096,
-0.03042439,
0.9248456955,
-0.2841047943,
-0.0729509518,
-0.5985878706,
0.1688986123,
-0.4971408248,
-0.5781826377,
-0.8930107355,
0.2314353138,
0.0374437645,
0.124075301,
-0.2685953975,
0.2956374288,
-0.6048151851,
0.6056774855,
0.6645528078,
0.4579875171,
0.06710352,
0.1196895391,
0.2526591122,
-0.2020364851,
-0.3405728936,
-0.463005811,
1.0938907862,
0.2672691643,
0.9692633748,
-0.2080347091,
0.7477303147,
-0.0787350088,
0.0034693512,
-0.9316892624,
0.2763562799,
-0.5399858356,
-0.3142235577,
-0.5084366202,
-0.3571479917,
-1.1053072214,
0.0426813178,
-0.1927740276,
-0.4300450385,
0.0308916029,
0.3644104302,
-0.6052770615,
-0.2241498083,
-0.8949996829,
0.7283567786,
-0.0207761675,
-0.5786646605,
-0.1806916893,
-0.7892599106,
0.2008050382,
-0.1413852125,
0.1728974432,
0.0653009266,
0.5160609484,
0.9302225113,
-0.2621685863,
0.9510828257,
-0.0275601745,
-0.091441907,
0.0992114618,
0.249744907,
0.1910587996,
0.2799915373,
0.0734860897,
-0.1676549166,
0.0275936835,
-0.4056993425,
-0.6152805686,
0.7311668396,
-0.6415749788,
-0.6601845026,
0.5042328835,
-0.3492926955,
-0.4985779226,
0.0468787216,
0.1700590104,
0.4413390756,
-0.0191066861,
0.7338995337,
0.5898874998,
0.2202527821,
0.1412459165,
0.227271229,
-0.1132320538,
-0.0852522105,
0.936147809,
0.2247813493,
0.7190393806,
0.0183382239,
0.3194105327,
0.1445842534,
-0.5583307147,
-0.4053139687,
0.1110636368,
-0.3657532632,
0.0471796207,
-0.4606870711,
0.1672947109,
-0.3008431494,
-0.4502536952,
-0.4382704794,
-0.6235079169,
-0.4757423103,
-0.4702816606,
0.6104755998,
0.5450978875,
-0.0628856868,
0.4132119715,
-0.3546254635,
0.5126966238,
0.6383284926,
0.5464193225,
-0.1650080383,
-0.3552848995,
-0.1662322134,
0.4055852294,
-0.3850699961,
-0.3733233809,
0.0439594202,
0.2695392668,
0.6575616002,
0.6271716356,
-0.0265302155,
0.9551752806,
-0.395409435,
0.6880776286,
-0.4058043659,
-0.5284565687,
0.7322596908,
-0.521561563,
-0.0232247449,
1.1200581789,
0.362226069,
-0.5699326992,
-0.5860857964,
-0.7331719398,
-0.8816186786,
0.6540776491,
-0.0156131629,
0.1959999949,
0.03863585,
0.4554877877,
0.6128136516,
0.2068577558,
-0.1870273352,
-0.0539263971,
-0.4756851494,
-0.1076809689,
-0.1130924672,
0.0380827785,
-0.1421016157,
-0.4745340347,
0.2558169663,
-0.472902149,
0.1403332651,
0.0204113573,
0.0779862851,
-0.1639285237,
0.3541919887,
0.438786298,
0.5734629631,
-0.1493315846,
-0.1719720513,
-0.0048286719,
-0.3424317539,
-0.3700339794,
0.0192788839,
-0.0237598158,
-0.0839873776,
0.3872460723,
1.0368902683,
0.4211961329,
-0.344507426,
0.3902054727,
0.0730678439,
-0.387059927,
0.1343820989,
0.5049602389,
-0.2266671956,
0.1486800909,
0.300434649,
0.0425422266,
0.2157129943,
-0.5695741773,
0.4376810193,
0.5522633791,
-0.5891224742,
-0.2053547949,
0.6178585887,
0.0877103731,
-0.2242683321,
0.8187836409,
-0.0551978759,
-0.3052228391,
0.620221436,
0.1655162722,
0.6424657106,
0.1836972088,
0.0944399908,
0.3376114666,
-0.0903680772,
-0.3867316246,
0.0698530152,
-0.405597955,
-0.4797526002,
-0.4776397347,
-0.5358995199,
-0.1557222307,
0.0432270505,
-1.1329485178,
0.3994418681,
-0.3950804174,
-0.0245878138,
-0.0442120358,
-0.0712646842,
-0.82047683,
0.2756174207,
-0.0027667072,
0.8596711755,
-1.0975180864,
0.6020421982,
0.3185651004,
-0.3723617196,
-1.0454918146,
0.250269711,
-0.0224614907,
-0.7122877836,
0.6803441644,
0.1098642498,
0.1546929181,
0.0600632839,
-1.0035432577,
-0.5808202028,
0.9926375747,
0.2765057981,
-0.511523664,
0.0382674597,
-0.2462513745,
0.7403121591,
-0.1724110842,
0.0253466461,
0.8931158781,
0.2125530541,
0.2790511549,
-1.4346215725,
-0.0135224061,
0.0558145456,
0.0168925542,
0.1193781048,
-0.8434081674,
0.6390067935,
-0.3456791937,
-0.1400980055,
0.042911049,
0.7645369768,
0.1207226515,
0.2094918936,
0.5334298015,
0.2404583842,
0.5089856982,
-0.3067610562,
1.0360430479,
0.1896965355,
0.4132148325,
1.0070478916,
0.096252583,
0.716188848,
0.630171299,
-0.371121943,
0.248241514,
1.032752037,
-0.0473290198,
0.798083365,
0.1737991869,
0.256993413,
-0.4694456458,
0.1282023042,
-0.2366116941,
0.574891448,
0.3270193636,
-0.1602906436,
-0.0532894135,
0.1057269052,
0.036555402,
0.2142952234,
-0.155719012,
1.068728447,
-0.0795766935,
-0.7347373962,
0.8348690867,
-0.4567976296,
0.9556599855,
-0.1748883426,
0.0208418369,
-0.3334195614,
-0.0807124525,
-0.493100971,
-1.0886269808,
0.1899710745,
-0.229790464,
-0.2139294147,
-0.4134012163,
0.203429237,
-0.4907682836,
-0.1981985271,
-0.0806423873,
0.2654309571,
0.2327938825,
-0.154191941,
-0.4020619094,
-0.275124073,
0.1347482353,
-0.2912349105,
0.5118726492,
0.5826173425,
-0.4154098332,
0.6910028458,
0.8865488172,
-0.1204302311,
-0.3513129354,
0.36215204,
0.8309560418,
-0.3532211483,
-0.5714946389,
-0.933848381,
0.5027061701,
-0.2115042955,
-0.2857047915,
0.5661281943,
0.401078403,
1.1775802374,
-0.1220226735,
0.7621732354,
0.2386666238,
0.5795372725,
-0.6979919672,
0.7210658193,
-0.4594275951,
0.0399563238,
-0.7147650719,
-0.65420717,
-0.0733251721,
0.8651368022,
-0.3578159511,
0.1751050651,
0.6442804337,
0.6338183284,
-0.404820174,
0.3345017433,
0.2804466486,
-0.0733482987,
0.4664155543,
0.3307538033,
0.6336337328,
0.039868623,
0.395464927,
-0.6349220276,
-0.2785649598,
-0.3496234715,
-0.659696281,
-1.0122762918,
-0.7267321348,
-0.1241817698,
-0.1128118038,
-0.2048348039,
1.1740772724,
1.003185153,
-0.5681414008,
-0.0654046312,
0.0978421047,
-0.1846065223,
-0.4394719601,
-0.292236954,
0.1776262075,
-0.3754906952,
-0.6341626048,
0.3350694478,
-0.1742409319,
0.3717458546,
-0.1011794806,
0.1474327296,
0.3191063106,
-0.4200875461,
0.5910310745,
0.1440078765,
-0.6887582541,
-0.4855224788,
-0.0847322568,
-0.1368365437,
-0.0197176207,
0.7689835429,
-0.9863154292,
0.1075715348,
0.2035201937,
0.923989296,
0.5551509857,
0.1948771775,
0.6209859252,
-1.0407425165,
0.0860635117,
-0.117131643,
0.2269389927,
0.4386250079,
-0.5730517507,
0.6446979642,
0.09349031,
-0.5981413722,
-0.7675065994,
0.2817637622,
-1.019380331,
-0.2345267534,
1.3389055729,
0.2182786465,
-0.1013084725,
-0.1322769076,
-0.7367456555,
-0.0089607956,
-0.6000781655,
1.0619225502,
0.7310487628,
-0.2935409546,
-0.0171709545,
-0.8279117942,
0.7619746327,
0.3817909658,
-0.7181201577,
0.3534852862,
0.5509611964,
0.4253022969,
-0.0559025668,
0.3714148998,
0.4754750729,
0.408690393,
-0.5475252867,
-0.5498793721,
-0.21618101,
-0.3437945545,
-0.0779232308,
0.0027922478,
0.1679994315,
-0.0304903928
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06073v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06073v2
|
LightCAM: A Fast and Light Implementation of Context-Aware Masking based D-TDNN for Speaker Verification
| 2024-02-08T21:47:16 | 2024-02-12T15:28:38 |
Di Cao, Xianchen Wang, Junfeng Zhou, Jiakai Zhang, Yanjing Lei, Wenpeng Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Traditional Time Delay Neural Networks (TDNN) have achieved state-of-the-art
performance at the cost of high computational complexity and slower inference
speed, making them difficult to implement in an industrial environment. The
Densely Connected Time Delay Neural Network (D-TDNN) with Context Aware Masking
(CAM) module has proven to be an efficient structure to reduce complexity while
maintaining system performance. In this paper, we propose a fast and
lightweight model, LightCAM, which further adopts a depthwise separable
convolution module (DSM) and uses multi-scale feature aggregation (MFA) for
feature fusion at different levels. Extensive experiments are conducted on
VoxCeleb dataset, the comparative results show that it has achieved an EER of
0.83 and MinDCF of 0.0891 in VoxCeleb1-O, which outperforms the other
mainstream speaker verification methods. In addition, complexity analysis
further demonstrates that the proposed architecture has lower computational
cost and faster inference speed.
|
[
-0.5311629772,
-0.8151730895,
0.4450557828,
0.1832100451,
-0.4588174522,
0.1089580283,
-0.0418313108,
-0.6349803209,
0.0770125985,
0.0777101666,
-0.2659508586,
-0.2968712747,
-0.4612168968,
-0.1218958199,
-0.5927576423,
-0.0456701666,
0.5433855057,
-0.090209119,
0.1318783015,
-0.1745379269,
-0.4273920655,
0.0509259813,
-0.5250133872,
-0.2853151858,
0.6437082291,
0.388240248,
0.5723700523,
0.5586308241,
0.1686240435,
0.4808174372,
-0.424731195,
0.3029717505,
-0.0697629601,
-0.1424742341,
-0.032566987,
0.3270615041,
-0.7513977289,
-0.2499583066,
0.6102644205,
0.7885825038,
0.153735742,
0.1476256847,
-0.2841260731,
0.2360247672,
-0.6410655379,
-0.0528710671,
-0.8687390685,
-0.038058456,
-0.1594818532,
-0.284607321,
-0.4211453795,
-0.0263294335,
0.1224124208,
-0.0889200047,
0.2903931737,
0.120040305,
0.4467594326,
0.2750029564,
-0.5274632573,
0.5676041245,
-1.0289601088,
0.6194821,
-0.5808401108,
0.4611997902,
-0.111329034,
0.8242055774,
-0.1201875955,
-0.4948939085,
-0.8666039109,
0.2177463174,
-0.0978433713,
-0.1680210233,
0.1572143435,
0.1013020277,
0.2914226651,
0.4791631401,
-0.6059888601,
0.1344744414,
-0.3208121955,
-0.3040913939,
0.6043776274,
-0.0338311084,
0.1582382321,
-0.1847991347,
-0.5308326483,
0.0197370443,
-0.1616731435,
-0.0448502004,
-0.0490281694,
0.2874205112,
-0.1644372791,
0.0376784056,
-0.4683319926,
0.9899852872,
-0.3775171041,
-0.5265135765,
0.0164448973,
-0.2809735239,
-0.2018698007,
0.6285954714,
0.5504831076,
0.2324926406,
-0.1680088341,
-0.1831968576,
-0.1856816262,
0.436698705,
-0.2242636085,
-0.8895046711,
0.063996993,
0.4563908875,
-0.5629919767,
-0.0053076274,
0.0140263755,
-0.8708350062,
-0.2114583403,
-0.2004790455,
0.7408894897,
-0.2148681879,
-0.6942279339,
0.3812454641,
0.2335153669,
0.4234033227,
0.7039334774,
-0.6035662889,
0.2156725377,
0.7113401294,
0.9935798645,
-0.2172062248,
-0.0947876796,
-0.7171678543,
0.090491645,
-0.3180176914,
0.3884476125,
-0.0823410526,
-0.072002396,
-0.2529906929,
-0.0350620672,
0.1202715039,
-0.3161851764,
0.1605765671,
-0.5635942221,
-0.0995084196,
0.1725423187,
-0.5220197439,
-0.1666586697,
0.1339430958,
-0.5282822847,
0.722427249,
0.2553676069,
-0.7040656805,
0.5966724753,
-0.1972480565,
-0.4313604832,
0.6193104982,
-0.4547218382,
-0.3981089294,
-0.1333421767,
0.2418971807,
0.6048214436,
-0.0830227062,
0.5436151028,
-0.3478305936,
-0.9561212659,
0.0944865048,
-0.4002326727,
0.8082923293,
0.4130055606,
-0.8078142405,
-0.0684573054,
-1.2536556721,
0.0007473858,
-0.1160113364,
-0.1708070785,
-0.0676727593,
-0.1902936101,
0.2384700179,
0.1498679966,
-0.3252453506,
-0.9782221317,
-0.1021347865,
-0.1293879151,
0.4804808199,
0.3364121914,
-0.0681342334,
0.0264229551,
0.0232611112,
0.173582375,
0.3524125814,
0.1144020855,
-0.4384060502,
-0.5321367979,
-0.5491832495,
-0.5847489238,
0.3198116422,
0.374081552,
-1.0507376194,
0.5926648974,
-0.391099453,
-0.6880897284,
-0.2914640903,
-0.1902815849,
0.4124553204,
0.9329808354,
0.1541245431,
-0.1618379951,
-0.3787726164,
-0.9414765239,
0.0947546884,
-0.0580307469,
-0.232358411,
0.5404549241,
0.3367161751,
-0.0559294857,
0.9547581077,
-0.2945279479,
-0.1909174025,
-0.1201720834,
-0.0679439083,
0.2497282177,
0.7048987746,
0.7937659621,
-1.0336749554,
-0.0814750567,
-0.0651725158,
-0.5444902778,
-0.0454172753,
0.0546296686,
0.2969363034,
0.1441261917,
0.3352969289,
-0.3466155827,
0.9701195359,
0.4532945454,
-0.4928705096,
-0.0019313097,
-0.0963858888,
0.4851229191,
-0.8082367778,
0.0299112666,
-0.1652251482,
-0.5646778345,
-0.7529918551,
-0.6628246903,
0.2922278941,
-0.3959413767,
-1.0190593004,
0.6553438902,
-0.3666683137,
-0.5145245194,
-0.271143198,
0.349945873,
0.2977444232,
0.6521055102,
0.0972074196,
0.7069921494,
0.6444035769,
-1.0322841406,
0.5606325269,
-0.1655345112,
-0.8988370299,
0.4256030917,
-0.6161438227,
0.046828296,
0.1593733281,
0.3939255178,
-1.1812129021,
0.0305200666,
-0.1342644989,
-0.0736587867,
0.2461111695,
-0.2599574327,
-0.3886281848,
-0.3606981039,
0.1873550266,
1.2583038807,
0.4532105327,
-0.9625623226,
0.4919520617,
0.1738733351,
0.032979954,
-0.4057442248,
-0.773871839,
0.2615478039,
-0.0425426923,
-0.9099839926,
0.8813264966,
0.0315953866,
-0.3596965671,
-0.5264479518,
-0.1090771332,
0.0026962014,
0.0798202679,
-0.2023799568,
0.0745026991,
-0.2420381904,
0.1299274713,
-0.3043484688,
-0.1700777113,
-0.4943631291,
-0.1641364843,
0.185703218,
-0.0447658673,
-0.50925529,
-0.6133686304,
0.5639570951,
0.4593089521,
0.0141364774,
0.3714734018,
0.9046490192,
-0.4645322263,
-0.3398124278,
-1.0704123974,
-0.4151565731,
-0.5030665398,
0.3592682481,
-0.160771504,
-0.9692947865,
0.5436072946,
-0.0222989209,
-0.4328860641,
0.0690618679,
0.3456080854,
0.3803967237,
0.8354081511,
0.473199755,
0.1434467733,
0.5000606775,
-0.1775036454,
0.2372217178,
-0.5248366594,
-0.423776716,
-0.5379586816,
-0.5913972259,
-0.4611517787,
-0.5441544652,
0.3157578111,
-0.3406983018,
0.1652919352,
0.389681071,
-0.6239603162,
0.373367548,
0.3390315771,
0.4788053632,
0.3022960126,
-0.2964978814,
0.0792591125,
0.050592564,
-0.7428888083,
-0.1661728024,
0.3376272917,
0.1985247284,
0.5235648751,
0.045049943,
0.21699588,
0.2963033319,
-0.3122393191,
-0.6786738038,
0.9791741371,
0.0953608975,
-0.4742212892,
-0.3982681036,
-0.6857037544,
-0.4376209378,
0.4123944938,
0.127179876,
-0.883785069,
0.6729516983,
0.1779133677,
-0.3602104783,
0.6460758448,
-0.8174293637,
0.596904695,
-0.4083590508,
-0.7138240933,
-0.1513657123,
-0.6862972379,
0.4463254809,
0.2689554691,
0.191592887,
-0.4001299143,
0.1217334569,
0.7046388388,
-0.5310767889,
0.4521323144,
-0.5885416865,
-0.0151062664,
0.287996918,
0.04072503,
0.0864548087,
0.4975595176,
-0.0859850347,
0.157343626,
-0.300439924,
-0.495244205,
-0.5021236539,
0.5948435664,
-0.4469062388,
-0.6421442628,
-0.1183346733,
-0.5068101287,
-0.2353864759,
0.1872902215,
0.0519942418,
0.9856665134,
-0.1441693157,
0.6528285742,
0.9798126817,
-0.3133592308,
1.0898637772,
0.4067567885,
-0.1622425914,
-0.4265932441,
0.5142858028,
0.0810938627,
0.0615891665,
0.4484019578,
0.0856531188,
0.0083820764,
-0.5975472927,
-0.3724009395,
-0.2256887406,
-0.4657770097,
-0.3254956305,
-0.6785367727,
-0.3687041998,
-0.5045956969,
-0.0607612468,
-0.57581532,
-0.6145041585,
0.0656530708,
0.190801084,
0.5162582397,
0.2714284956,
0.2735660672,
0.5497986674,
-0.3204218745,
0.5754693151,
0.9323348999,
0.731613934,
0.1035151333,
-0.4259649515,
-0.2875413001,
-0.1849705726,
-0.0532249995,
-0.531740427,
-0.0477216132,
0.3250619173,
0.5897558331,
0.607005477,
0.1374710351,
0.6439946294,
-0.1646882743,
0.8450062871,
-0.019526884,
-1.1232190132,
0.5766749978,
-0.3208079338,
0.5626819134,
0.328661859,
-0.3638243079,
-0.440879494,
0.0718629137,
-0.5725080967,
-0.7932989597,
1.0436398983,
0.2671875358,
-0.2959499061,
0.2998629808,
0.3945271075,
0.1307055354,
0.188349694,
-0.400639683,
-0.2067853659,
-0.5909180045,
0.2328334898,
-0.2255150378,
-0.5252367854,
0.0382919163,
-0.4394819736,
0.4008815289,
-0.1827262044,
0.2441870421,
0.5392352939,
-0.1836587042,
0.1523669362,
0.4769365489,
1.0827431679,
0.890953064,
-0.4774781168,
0.3653022945,
0.3395924866,
-0.2024843991,
0.3586945236,
0.0099322479,
0.1215046719,
0.4565897584,
0.434476465,
0.7438648939,
0.5409402847,
-0.2057342976,
0.9749408364,
-0.3226709962,
-0.2033591121,
-0.0144215664,
0.0974511877,
-0.0007973177,
0.2511489689,
0.5264948606,
-0.1434807479,
0.1786096841,
-0.1824554652,
0.3451682031,
0.1982489228,
-0.1545227766,
-0.1801182926,
0.7955652475,
0.3703144789,
-0.5873970389,
0.3212507963,
-0.212586388,
-0.4143630564,
0.8289619684,
0.2382990569,
0.9789510369,
-0.4355490804,
-0.0141325369,
0.1395697296,
0.1780682653,
0.2110541165,
0.4425632954,
-0.5332639813,
-0.37202847,
-0.2544054091,
-0.4771600366,
-0.4461951256,
0.1120737493,
-0.0740096942,
0.3927575946,
-0.4355842173,
-0.1206285208,
-0.0658801869,
0.0476074331,
-0.7762415409,
0.5239351392,
0.2971720397,
1.0517917871,
-0.7347793579,
0.9627168179,
0.1589319855,
0.1704237759,
-0.8597263098,
-0.5596010089,
0.0134061566,
-0.4371937513,
0.5524693131,
0.4775398672,
-0.4091469049,
-0.2983334064,
-0.2724917531,
-0.4156004488,
1.5775561333,
0.463191539,
-0.7459525466,
0.445210427,
0.138421312,
0.2677173316,
-0.8228750229,
0.4584507048,
0.2544427812,
0.4482651651,
0.4771796465,
-0.7800444365,
0.0195396822,
-0.1397135556,
0.5302515626,
-0.4069221914,
-0.9295021892,
0.841769278,
0.1033109501,
0.0642451942,
-0.2458843738,
0.7447029352,
-0.0144683896,
0.508885324,
1.0289257765,
0.1802890748,
0.3793236315,
-0.2422942817,
0.2605298758,
-0.28522861,
0.0475695506,
0.8939366937,
-0.317482084,
0.3492106199,
0.4182733595,
0.0653624535,
0.1694266051,
0.5979143381,
-0.0872600153,
0.5176377296,
-0.032728985,
-0.3449794352,
-0.4305514097,
-0.1993659288,
-0.6090600491,
0.8864777088,
0.1070638299,
-0.2247168571,
0.0238673892,
0.1006249413,
-0.3003259599,
-0.1924113184,
-0.3963392079,
0.7959625125,
0.0590357929,
-0.4326718748,
0.5172169209,
-0.2947935164,
0.7052986026,
-0.4275554717,
-0.0423135832,
-0.3591954112,
0.4575133026,
-0.4005511105,
-0.2177848518,
0.056396462,
-0.2922646999,
-0.0040796478,
-0.3940637112,
0.9550215006,
-0.5412390828,
-0.3763014078,
0.5219653845,
0.4518587589,
-0.0341874734,
0.1725446433,
-0.0548562668,
0.4076261222,
-0.4151028097,
-0.3019365668,
0.1356986165,
0.6081987619,
0.2343780994,
0.5703970194,
0.1619549394,
0.1119253263,
-0.0079290662,
0.425036788,
0.7860018015,
-0.6538919806,
-0.6380450726,
-0.756033659,
0.4297886789,
-0.2746708095,
-0.0265312009,
0.5203495622,
0.5652189851,
0.7434358001,
0.0937154666,
0.2244443297,
0.1480812132,
0.513835907,
-0.3568513989,
1.0101373196,
-0.6032170057,
0.5231360793,
-0.7547205687,
-0.9568542242,
-0.3738951385,
0.1201935783,
0.2238392234,
0.4230317175,
0.5961592197,
0.9783263206,
-0.505638361,
0.0686743706,
0.8590972424,
-0.0692947134,
0.5144161582,
0.5014361143,
0.5933424234,
-0.7424947023,
0.7938477397,
-0.6015481949,
-0.5062932372,
-0.6276497841,
-1.3018579483,
-0.7540096641,
-0.4632436633,
-0.7487529516,
-0.0040424205,
-0.3655695915,
0.4978225231,
1.1817547083,
-0.6910277009,
-0.208961159,
0.2095065564,
0.4389572144,
-0.5428839326,
-0.2049565464,
0.4010742307,
0.2370418459,
-0.4251238406,
0.6022965908,
0.5131590962,
0.0912056863,
-0.3681272566,
0.2116727978,
-0.4547239542,
-0.0685696304,
0.4160755277,
0.0505096428,
-0.7777734995,
-0.7270278335,
-0.4183962643,
-0.0470507182,
0.2236810029,
0.9372683167,
-0.965721488,
0.7132321596,
0.6788239479,
0.4513859749,
0.4786166251,
-0.2846263945,
0.3759302795,
-0.9456661344,
0.755300045,
0.1652272493,
0.7958045006,
0.5201171637,
-0.2921357155,
0.3898045123,
0.3995335698,
-0.6162191033,
-0.9143500924,
0.1692765504,
-1.1934661865,
-0.0884195939,
0.664732635,
-0.2296481878,
-0.4434167147,
-0.3595166802,
-0.0641202778,
0.4404265285,
-0.2838912904,
0.9122154117,
0.2676185071,
0.0990780592,
-0.5074702501,
-0.1812150925,
0.5267201662,
0.2673125565,
-0.5458964109,
-0.000318602,
0.2124142051,
-0.0201417021,
0.1659982651,
0.5431851745,
-0.0185367186,
0.5749106407,
0.1574371755,
0.0124827866,
-0.5910628438,
-0.528775692,
-0.338389039,
0.3324780464,
-0.3235387206,
-0.2648224235
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.16877v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.16877v1
|
Large Language Model Augmented Exercise Retrieval for Personalized Language Learning
| 2024-02-08T20:35:31 | 2024-02-08T20:35:31 |
Austin Xu, Will Monroe, Klinton Bicknell
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We study the problem of zero-shot exercise retrieval in the context of online
language learning, to give learners the ability to explicitly request
personalized exercises via natural language. Using real-world data collected
from language learners, we observe that vector similarity approaches poorly
capture the relationship between exercise content and the language that
learners use to express what they want to learn. This semantic gap between
queries and content dramatically reduces the effectiveness of general-purpose
retrieval models pretrained on large scale information retrieval datasets like
MS MARCO. We leverage the generative capabilities of large language models to
bridge the gap by synthesizing hypothetical exercises based on the learner's
input, which are then used to search for relevant exercises. Our approach,
which we call mHyER, overcomes three challenges: (1) lack of relevance labels
for training, (2) unrestricted learner input content, and (3) low semantic
similarity between input and retrieval candidates. mHyER outperforms several
strong baselines on two novel benchmarks created from crowdsourced data and
publicly available data.
|
[
-0.2593502998,
-0.8453919888,
0.5408688784,
-0.2540592849,
0.2204144746,
0.1711174697,
-0.3830382824,
-0.2795751691,
0.4535058141,
0.3127170205,
-0.4695903659,
-0.3788844347,
-0.5551094413,
0.0481728427,
-0.3694308102,
0.7971477509,
-0.3002791703,
0.1308831275,
-0.1398674548,
-0.3131990433,
-0.2420959324,
-0.6319575906,
-0.3651824892,
-0.4677542746,
0.7803675532,
0.4913715422,
0.4138808846,
0.4634364545,
0.4019737542,
0.2980022728,
0.0519446582,
-0.1553962976,
-0.6399891973,
0.3826693892,
-0.0518157631,
-0.5081758499,
0.0294352435,
-0.1176110953,
0.8275684118,
0.850540936,
-0.0324473605,
0.2369552404,
-0.1765415221,
0.6401193142,
-0.8298972845,
-0.1303773373,
-0.6884351373,
0.0501785055,
-0.2702174187,
-0.0689105913,
-0.1449254006,
-0.3049222231,
0.2476759404,
-0.537530303,
0.4461579323,
-0.0593003258,
0.8652434349,
0.0880975723,
-0.2673539519,
-0.3504627943,
-0.6769074798,
0.8610947132,
-0.3816688061,
0.7343745828,
0.6128560901,
0.5063099861,
-0.0387833789,
-0.3995318115,
-0.7394836545,
-0.6411861181,
0.2831714749,
-0.0976236314,
0.0508396812,
0.0621658005,
0.4137809277,
0.543689847,
-0.7402294278,
-0.0444408283,
-0.3414809108,
-0.0227130298,
0.5147464871,
0.1057174653,
0.4133406878,
-0.2091735154,
-0.2032053918,
-0.2786057293,
-0.7829118967,
0.0689154342,
0.5331872702,
0.2051922679,
0.0570300296,
0.8968213797,
-0.4895950258,
0.8740975857,
-0.1986039579,
-0.1108271554,
0.5267235041,
0.080169946,
-0.0673792437,
-0.1435144693,
0.7072682977,
-0.0843917876,
0.2322327793,
-0.4141075611,
-0.2153009921,
-0.3941850662,
0.061473161,
-0.9127121568,
-0.3350413144,
0.2155539989,
-0.1230055615,
0.0163967274,
0.3748710155,
-0.5553492308,
-0.1048916206,
-0.6306562424,
0.7860652804,
-0.4974413812,
-0.0941223949,
0.0941795483,
-0.2679528892,
0.3262179196,
0.135640651,
-0.7972365618,
0.138545081,
0.6278179884,
0.8112384081,
0.0016526823,
-0.276745528,
-0.6851271391,
0.1305883676,
-0.1551706046,
0.566624403,
-0.7961844206,
-0.0753852203,
0.254399091,
-0.1543018818,
-0.2437818497,
-0.751756072,
0.1190137863,
-0.82713449,
0.491422087,
-0.2628242075,
-0.9042101502,
-0.003005065,
0.4754269719,
-0.6390957832,
1.0422083139,
0.254390955,
-0.737873733,
0.2729007006,
-0.5496679544,
-0.2633704543,
0.0227574334,
-0.3125247359,
-0.4629527926,
0.1813346744,
-0.0359845683,
0.4489530623,
-0.1560242325,
0.0545371659,
-0.55107373,
-0.4698296487,
0.2106425762,
-0.0559176393,
0.3977096081,
0.1729702801,
-0.2998951674,
0.1518646628,
-0.9195961356,
0.0973132625,
0.3052124083,
-0.5411370397,
-0.6468882561,
-0.095176205,
0.2708112895,
0.4252268374,
0.2382101119,
-0.9278142452,
0.3168390095,
-0.5466073751,
0.2090722173,
0.5606725216,
-0.1106362566,
0.3427675366,
-0.228734374,
0.5984407067,
-0.3963889778,
-0.2023548633,
-0.1455748081,
-0.2196165621,
-0.7020785213,
-0.1510989964,
0.5673171282,
0.5433325768,
-0.9592442513,
0.4134414792,
-0.5990957618,
-0.483515352,
-0.7333818674,
0.588639617,
0.4129142463,
0.3394227326,
0.4899291396,
-0.2859871387,
-0.3382553756,
-0.678691566,
-0.252764374,
0.1269462556,
-0.5028363466,
0.3622683287,
0.4788258374,
-0.2828207016,
0.718524754,
-0.7677118778,
-0.3949498236,
-0.3593899906,
0.0926797763,
0.0266991742,
0.2696194649,
0.5240441561,
-0.8211945891,
-0.6739768386,
-0.0032551682,
-0.6118228436,
0.1321110576,
0.0697922334,
-0.0049062152,
-0.1621079445,
0.5459369421,
-0.5012950301,
0.1698913872,
0.5191200376,
-0.0442696214,
0.300224185,
-0.3267628551,
0.1684276462,
-1.1974424124,
0.2764818072,
-0.088918604,
-0.0579606779,
-0.5738808513,
0.2164330482,
0.1519361138,
-0.3792448342,
-0.3998877406,
0.8111828566,
-0.2775256038,
0.0922821909,
-0.4386488497,
0.1364553273,
-0.2268718034,
0.3405136764,
0.0481768362,
0.677757144,
0.5339843631,
-0.7029449344,
0.1823677272,
0.4581621885,
-0.2958313227,
0.388823539,
-0.8127951622,
0.3135317862,
-0.432159692,
0.0412036888,
-0.926566124,
-0.6270158291,
0.0808466673,
-0.5708441734,
0.43947649,
0.0132443076,
-0.3236096799,
-0.3037224114,
-0.4976328909,
0.5343405008,
0.3000256121,
-0.627962172,
0.287296325,
0.2752977014,
-0.0176352672,
-0.624144733,
-0.4819822609,
-0.0439493544,
-0.1206226349,
-0.378839612,
0.3233528137,
-0.2181028426,
-0.0238154456,
-0.0651237965,
-0.1099668816,
-0.2452243865,
-0.0109017687,
0.1542362869,
-0.0263892263,
-0.1483325362,
0.4046862423,
-0.3258895874,
0.0317194276,
-0.1036946699,
-0.1407455802,
0.6233150363,
0.1973652095,
-0.5687225461,
-0.3067544699,
0.4158002436,
0.4033314884,
-0.4061323702,
0.9418381453,
0.7653978467,
-0.4085243344,
0.0394600816,
-0.7581139803,
-0.108483769,
-0.4464134276,
0.4956341386,
-0.5088090897,
-1.1976668835,
0.1429056674,
0.1369212866,
-0.0131740924,
0.1659503281,
0.5510666966,
-0.1984571964,
0.9227355719,
0.5348446965,
-0.2950257063,
0.8901975155,
-0.4791355729,
0.1535086781,
-0.869482398,
-0.3089169264,
-0.523193717,
-0.457179904,
-0.5523195863,
-0.4554060102,
0.2247772217,
-0.1474116147,
-0.4058980942,
0.4601006508,
-0.1463443041,
0.370121032,
0.7943038344,
0.2190654278,
0.0272230785,
0.2917814255,
-0.1765201241,
-0.2890430689,
-0.6050443053,
-0.1729597896,
1.1886868477,
0.0037927949,
0.6917877197,
0.2759442925,
0.9111555219,
0.0413589068,
0.382835865,
-0.9502218962,
0.2162307054,
0.1590833962,
-0.7875596881,
-0.3337229788,
-0.6742185354,
-1.4247362614,
0.392899096,
-0.3363529146,
-0.5233100057,
-0.1245039403,
0.0280501954,
-0.0259181522,
0.4294085205,
-0.5197318196,
0.8577799797,
-0.255104661,
-0.5094270706,
-0.2860971987,
-0.6444458961,
0.3026364744,
-0.1519380659,
0.3083710372,
-0.1446486264,
-0.0072226794,
0.5578784347,
-0.4660242498,
0.492705822,
-0.2130806744,
0.1099374667,
0.1965318918,
0.1397507638,
0.2418372184,
-0.354326129,
-0.1516000777,
-0.2813275158,
-0.1863008738,
-0.8522022367,
-0.6304144859,
0.8752524853,
-0.7577562332,
-0.4916727841,
-0.414475292,
-0.2891410589,
-0.2279880047,
0.1727950126,
0.1576334089,
0.298628509,
-0.3724907935,
0.4229009151,
0.6795127988,
-0.310166806,
0.2136406898,
0.4950436056,
0.0211571474,
-0.4882448316,
1.2848192453,
0.0989983603,
0.2337331027,
0.9382116199,
0.0578998737,
-0.3617770672,
-0.4707932174,
-0.2440343052,
0.3873630762,
-0.5094267726,
-0.114120774,
-0.5730435848,
0.0914397761,
-0.2669616044,
0.0181426797,
-0.3319694996,
-0.2658644021,
-0.1009034365,
0.0768688396,
0.1255778074,
0.6499779224,
0.1450498104,
0.3627739847,
-0.7948458195,
0.5828464031,
0.3990086019,
0.4850150943,
-0.1640177965,
-0.5821089745,
-0.2800184786,
0.0082001612,
-0.4862185717,
-0.8003043532,
0.2865775824,
0.3855337501,
0.6104390025,
0.3745188117,
-0.016169278,
0.7347920537,
-0.7867178917,
0.5235542059,
0.3480803668,
-0.7793444991,
0.6556353569,
-0.197602585,
0.133714214,
0.813007772,
0.793415904,
-0.5076708198,
-0.1464191377,
-0.5942223668,
-0.9664672613,
0.2800100446,
0.0512718745,
0.5636542439,
-0.15843606,
0.5420122147,
-0.0141976038,
0.1528244317,
-0.7950686216,
-0.0640183985,
0.1161324158,
-0.3063154221,
-0.1802699268,
-0.0297601577,
0.2153718919,
-0.3830794096,
0.6156169176,
-0.188895911,
0.0350276046,
0.2435400933,
-0.3420670331,
-0.2134494483,
0.24367553,
0.1318165958,
0.5029709935,
-0.2388498038,
-0.0413727425,
0.2043166757,
-0.2515149117,
0.2717123628,
0.1145996451,
-0.2094514966,
0.1519435644,
0.3304404914,
0.5780094266,
0.5871312618,
-1.2147113085,
0.851903975,
-0.0270681065,
-0.2876173556,
-0.5793502331,
0.1774775237,
-0.0263427589,
0.0830724165,
0.1924790889,
-0.160158053,
0.2077662945,
-0.3545588255,
0.3164398074,
0.6561402082,
-0.6003448367,
-0.4412336946,
0.9810366631,
-0.1498017162,
-0.3810251057,
0.6677013636,
-0.2009162903,
-0.3599416614,
0.1173176095,
0.2451493591,
0.6211095452,
-0.3687960804,
0.1308518946,
0.6465890408,
0.0558445603,
-0.146428436,
0.2076444328,
-0.2103956342,
-0.4339235425,
-0.6342644691,
-0.5696833134,
-0.5299283266,
0.3901347518,
-0.5993994474,
0.4662249684,
-0.2531977892,
0.0822630525,
-0.0689373165,
0.0658271089,
-0.9250436425,
0.1200945154,
0.1430922747,
0.708478868,
-0.7236884236,
0.9548370242,
0.9023254514,
-0.5901225209,
-0.5672597885,
0.1467169523,
-0.3125266731,
-0.7909200788,
0.6759174466,
0.1778376997,
0.2327078879,
-0.1825304478,
-0.3886165023,
-0.8109869957,
0.9487432837,
0.5678960681,
-0.4354516864,
-0.1004477292,
0.1956608593,
0.4486037493,
-0.0174678974,
0.1648493558,
0.1657900959,
0.1645796895,
0.2929919958,
-0.7210331559,
-0.2389099449,
-0.1902907938,
-0.0292617884,
0.2789986134,
-0.5778956413,
0.7045103908,
-0.2396763712,
0.1069769412,
0.1717608273,
0.6936893463,
0.2417670488,
0.3128505945,
0.3276034892,
0.7288807631,
0.7203570604,
0.2643571198,
1.428912878,
-0.2030746192,
0.5451178551,
1.0255377293,
-0.205728814,
1.3105579615,
0.4440354109,
-0.1750364155,
0.3746320605,
0.4725509882,
0.1704047769,
0.4204829335,
0.5165764093,
-0.5217140317,
-0.3015059233,
0.0683077052,
-0.290361464,
0.4166867435,
0.1625660807,
-0.340919137,
-0.2714919448,
0.1635597348,
-0.1312844008,
0.3560392559,
-0.0715878978,
0.6403255463,
-0.0688389093,
-0.5386288166,
0.7671902776,
0.0515405796,
0.6789801717,
-0.706776619,
-0.0680860281,
-0.01797341,
0.2045680881,
-0.0455600023,
-0.3653889894,
0.178133145,
-0.0318495035,
0.0517337285,
-0.1473415047,
0.5915058255,
-0.7110789418,
-0.492025286,
0.2985191643,
0.822086215,
0.3410545588,
-0.3526838124,
-0.665204525,
-0.1124801114,
-0.0478794239,
-0.3861294985,
0.5956760049,
0.3476625383,
0.226602599,
0.724596262,
0.5780084729,
0.0470270663,
0.1535301208,
0.1174156368,
0.8361694813,
-0.7091190219,
-0.1877561808,
-0.6634135246,
0.0826234743,
0.058466889,
-0.3032426238,
0.7184063196,
0.9259164333,
1.1576794386,
-0.2159810662,
0.7689938545,
-0.0940728635,
0.7230923772,
-0.4674878418,
0.5541979074,
-0.8074738383,
0.0613265112,
-0.1171350554,
-1.0611461401,
-0.3110654652,
0.7156766653,
-0.3814488351,
0.0039187013,
0.3313830197,
0.7472996116,
-0.4602245688,
-0.3831560314,
0.4348057806,
-0.1187128648,
0.3793466091,
0.6862069964,
0.8474800587,
-0.600723207,
0.4872419238,
-0.1952108443,
-0.1467343569,
-0.3894978166,
-0.6022874117,
-1.1630271673,
-0.7153859138,
-0.3149389923,
-0.1827639192,
-0.0573760234,
1.481331706,
0.6885445118,
-0.9667310715,
-0.2175923586,
-0.0417552292,
0.0862267688,
0.19567734,
-0.245235011,
0.39421314,
-0.6140290499,
-0.9930952191,
0.3140434623,
-0.1164217815,
0.035381861,
-0.1452476829,
-0.2293495536,
-0.2661696374,
-0.2248511463,
0.6604854465,
0.6316133142,
-0.7209780216,
-0.4241734445,
0.2579477131,
-0.0138756549,
0.1159199253,
1.0324838161,
-0.6634418368,
0.6089666486,
0.5542244911,
1.1902192831,
0.7744242549,
-0.15475218,
0.3340232372,
-0.9610967636,
0.2347974032,
0.2364685386,
0.2175269872,
0.4766541123,
0.0003503613,
0.3413355649,
0.2067640424,
-0.3953323364,
-0.593719542,
0.1172527969,
-0.7973880768,
-0.1446800828,
1.1712146997,
-0.1203042492,
-0.1294032484,
-0.11820025,
-0.2615001202,
0.2035146803,
-0.1268360168,
1.0254991055,
0.792268455,
-0.22430861,
0.0790732503,
-1.1002616882,
0.301587373,
0.4764692485,
-0.4770137966,
-0.1663246453,
0.4258712828,
0.6521443725,
0.0115966788,
0.5394349098,
0.1641110331,
0.1145175248,
-0.3719394505,
0.2090118527,
0.0708561167,
-0.1899551004,
-0.2737376392,
0.3015341163,
0.2934538424,
-0.22445485
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06044v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06044v3
|
OpenToM: A Comprehensive Benchmark for Evaluating Theory-of-Mind Reasoning Capabilities of Large Language Models
| 2024-02-08T20:35:06 | 2024-06-03T10:48:16 |
Hainiu Xu, Runcong Zhao, Lixing Zhu, Jinhua Du, Yulan He
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Neural Theory-of-Mind (N-ToM), machine's ability to understand and keep track
of the mental states of others, is pivotal in developing socially intelligent
agents. However, prevalent N-ToM benchmarks have several shortcomings,
including the presence of ambiguous and artificial narratives, absence of
personality traits and preferences, a lack of questions addressing characters'
psychological mental states, and limited diversity in the questions posed. In
response to these issues, we construct OpenToM, a new benchmark for assessing
N-ToM with (1) longer and clearer narrative stories, (2) characters with
explicit personality traits, (3) actions that are triggered by character
intentions, and (4) questions designed to challenge LLMs' capabilities of
modeling characters' mental states of both the physical and psychological
world. Using OpenToM, we reveal that state-of-the-art LLMs thrive at modeling
certain aspects of mental states in the physical world but fall short when
tracking characters' mental states in the psychological world.
|
[
-0.6599394679,
-0.6399552226,
1.0350292921,
-0.0769974813,
-0.0934760198,
-0.1077748016,
-0.6951290965,
-0.3891949654,
0.1611825079,
0.2624354362,
-0.7434824705,
-0.3177160323,
-0.430147022,
0.257263273,
-0.083451584,
0.788030684,
-0.1253061444,
-0.0501127504,
-0.5200458765,
-0.2945556641,
-0.1037654728,
-0.4279814065,
-0.6670411229,
-0.5111349821,
0.7077955008,
-0.1147172302,
0.7249261737,
0.3927880228,
0.6449838877,
0.2737852037,
-0.0624010302,
0.4240216315,
-0.3932028711,
0.3779093027,
-0.5203118324,
-0.7343577743,
-0.7237038016,
0.1022687107,
0.7080144882,
0.5803828239,
0.13523072,
0.1123263612,
0.0129140625,
0.4642449915,
-0.7993053794,
0.191453442,
-0.4511936605,
0.0296764746,
-0.058012642,
-0.0737430304,
-0.2860501707,
-0.5947511196,
0.2998277247,
-0.6194342971,
-0.03799963,
-0.0340313613,
0.7715707421,
0.2641990185,
-0.4753131568,
-0.0600979552,
-0.6891388893,
0.8726893067,
-0.6724953055,
0.2144955695,
0.3809071183,
0.6495968103,
-0.2317150384,
-0.3582582772,
-0.8090459704,
-0.4542081058,
0.0311294831,
0.0714278743,
-0.2220778614,
-0.0199503265,
0.3054760695,
0.2751793861,
-0.4008439183,
-0.112431854,
0.1140102744,
-0.013353656,
0.7040500641,
0.5166183114,
0.1292109936,
0.0900032669,
-0.3720471859,
-0.2926154435,
-0.424723804,
-0.3058844805,
0.2414927185,
0.2043330967,
0.0265374053,
0.4836868942,
-0.1476050466,
0.4573827386,
-0.2467748821,
-0.1089531332,
0.071291782,
-0.1531724483,
-0.2399704754,
-0.1348265558,
0.7521455288,
0.5997605324,
0.567402184,
-0.0972862691,
-0.2819544077,
0.2349293977,
0.3830497265,
-0.6292579174,
-0.0392822176,
0.27018556,
-0.4099960327,
0.0602540448,
0.0281086378,
-1.0290514231,
-0.8282850385,
-0.1149267033,
0.3480599523,
-0.6936655641,
-0.5279406309,
0.0815311372,
-0.1359710693,
0.3385218382,
0.5100578666,
-0.5897192955,
0.4727638662,
0.7757332325,
1.0708965063,
-0.1225265712,
-0.44154796,
0.1070512757,
0.0661092699,
-0.4594883919,
0.9040829539,
-0.5881196856,
-0.0450884812,
-0.1668050587,
-0.2651182413,
-0.0611955002,
-0.29590258,
0.2981205583,
-0.1130093858,
0.2211999446,
-0.5787270069,
-0.6239337921,
-0.2902817726,
0.6649637222,
-0.4427513182,
0.491512388,
0.250875771,
-0.2670767307,
0.3205255866,
-0.7793074846,
-0.2415319681,
-0.0387585834,
-0.4311986864,
0.1640348583,
0.3571875095,
0.0623160303,
0.4307501912,
-0.8983002901,
0.3199447393,
-0.5354374051,
-0.3072635829,
0.6736294627,
-0.4864012599,
0.780180037,
0.1631922424,
-0.2161426991,
0.0492063276,
-0.6787528396,
0.2856189907,
0.449354887,
-0.028202977,
-0.380531311,
0.1536727846,
-0.3173972666,
0.1128635779,
0.3189087808,
-0.5763213038,
0.197839275,
-0.2282374501,
0.5925676227,
0.6945514083,
-0.1795206368,
0.095943816,
-0.658085227,
0.4485262036,
-0.2095709443,
0.0549324751,
-0.1610556394,
-0.6139939427,
-0.7130980492,
-0.6175800562,
-0.0195425898,
0.1688714325,
-0.5544752479,
0.7584913373,
-0.2318644971,
-0.9052532315,
-0.5020782351,
-0.3564775288,
0.6353026032,
0.293708533,
0.2681096196,
-0.3828086555,
-0.276027143,
-0.6821786165,
-0.438232094,
-0.3787055314,
-0.2594360709,
0.3502534032,
0.5772944093,
-0.0318450481,
0.9259082079,
-0.4714844823,
-0.195799768,
-0.2330619991,
-0.0409206375,
0.1586928517,
0.3486229479,
0.4535806477,
-0.3042713404,
0.0027532014,
-0.0309048034,
-0.9956532717,
0.1054977477,
0.167100355,
-0.2053715885,
0.1125600338,
0.133459568,
-0.9934856296,
0.4249616265,
0.15026474,
-0.5343437791,
0.3907156289,
-0.3016634285,
0.2846899331,
-0.7516124249,
0.2640086114,
0.1229561865,
0.1075401157,
-0.5918197632,
0.3442254066,
0.0766106918,
0.0503951609,
-0.2370763421,
0.7681352496,
-0.3362684548,
-0.3438655138,
0.0014233473,
0.5516622663,
0.0663280636,
0.7147070765,
-0.1329006404,
0.5562705398,
0.2717358172,
-0.8251669407,
0.4227865338,
0.1547504067,
-0.4810023308,
1.1170010567,
-0.5056120157,
0.4458050132,
-0.0874262452,
0.2473695427,
-1.1720541716,
-0.1929212809,
0.0145993903,
-0.5933405161,
0.0680086687,
0.2081525028,
-0.7611225843,
-0.2501243949,
-0.11221046,
0.382854104,
0.589674592,
-0.3967260718,
0.8050634265,
0.2632891238,
0.2984349728,
0.0111784702,
-0.6089987159,
-0.1090717986,
-0.2343379259,
-0.5979480743,
0.3298006952,
-0.1694919616,
-0.5573534966,
-0.0455268621,
-0.2051187307,
-0.2432134151,
0.1828368604,
-0.1788900644,
0.1032442898,
-0.4461197257,
0.1791463494,
-0.1299261153,
-0.0682981238,
0.4359014928,
-0.205997169,
0.6901669502,
-0.3414345682,
-0.3934715986,
-0.2705055177,
-0.0598444305,
0.9422425032,
-0.4044314921,
0.488668263,
0.1657187939,
-0.6429329515,
-0.1946563423,
-0.3040709496,
-0.1789327264,
-0.4051540792,
0.4405217469,
-0.3829216659,
-0.6453579068,
0.5432046056,
-0.0354859233,
0.060492333,
0.3804282844,
0.5160137415,
-0.0469955988,
1.1222163439,
0.2003609538,
0.1244579777,
0.0655259565,
0.0561862551,
0.1742331535,
-1.0546079874,
-0.2783944905,
-0.5429944992,
-0.6342831254,
-0.359719485,
-0.5522681475,
0.3260682225,
-0.2251694947,
-0.4787181616,
0.3732469082,
-0.459040314,
0.5003666282,
0.484492898,
0.171489343,
0.293461889,
-0.3046181798,
-0.284920305,
0.0031397638,
-0.3010730445,
-0.7837459445,
1.2871866226,
0.4788866937,
0.5891126394,
0.4553383291,
0.3330085576,
0.0421480425,
0.123609975,
-0.5949252248,
1.0560874939,
-0.0268766154,
-0.950565815,
-0.355486095,
-0.3625665307,
-0.8715586066,
0.3852449358,
-0.1672298312,
-1.0286422968,
0.0390439108,
0.0010833915,
-0.479786396,
0.4566353261,
-0.3366056085,
0.6064737439,
-0.4128737748,
-0.4023999274,
-0.3777598441,
-0.4452306926,
0.4300193489,
0.092214413,
-0.3099576533,
-0.575817883,
-0.3998208046,
0.6383076906,
-0.2405343205,
0.5639712811,
-0.2001705915,
-0.1929352731,
0.2330448478,
0.222057417,
0.0787420869,
-0.0245973859,
-0.1782717407,
0.3330424428,
0.1943418831,
-0.2655989528,
-1.0133697987,
0.5805906057,
-0.8725619316,
-0.4446637332,
-0.5690937638,
-0.6498808861,
-0.7113509774,
0.210127458,
-0.0615265146,
0.2286573201,
-0.3715614378,
0.2731790841,
0.8073570728,
-0.2699112892,
0.2070451975,
0.492705971,
-0.443915844,
-0.5855109096,
0.7931861281,
-0.0169567522,
0.2710878849,
0.3503839076,
0.2714858949,
-0.2816538215,
-0.4274258018,
-0.2119647712,
0.245793134,
-0.7432348132,
-0.0018655655,
-0.3735755086,
-0.1600124538,
-0.1325840503,
0.0385519676,
-0.3110918701,
-0.1723598987,
0.019652985,
0.1520924568,
0.2841177285,
0.791062355,
0.4119551778,
0.0370851792,
-0.3423340917,
0.1821231693,
0.1872383058,
0.7392795086,
0.2551023662,
-0.341947794,
0.0243651085,
-0.0231636874,
-0.329005599,
-0.8210526109,
0.0057929554,
-0.0734299272,
0.8271431923,
0.5998027921,
0.0404903516,
0.6507760286,
-0.1827442199,
0.6811134815,
0.0986515656,
-0.8423017859,
0.5554125905,
-0.5763297081,
0.4687901735,
0.6043125987,
0.4070056677,
-0.4330696762,
-0.3168783486,
-0.3818180561,
-0.4183368385,
0.5341608524,
0.2768096626,
-0.0993343443,
-0.3289436698,
0.2628214955,
0.1531660408,
0.362437427,
-0.4259017408,
0.0062950347,
-0.0375218317,
-0.3481310606,
-0.2369789928,
0.0304034278,
-0.1586135924,
-0.3318044543,
0.4378819764,
-0.374998033,
0.6510884166,
0.3318419755,
-0.0060121622,
-0.0916604325,
0.0348744802,
0.7097184062,
0.6954702735,
-0.4266235828,
0.1092317477,
0.0815731138,
-0.3221971691,
0.1551911384,
-0.1904506832,
0.0148519967,
-0.2908614874,
0.4403758049,
0.666484952,
0.2865015268,
-0.9497308135,
0.3236373663,
-0.1062097996,
-0.3501100838,
-0.2215868235,
0.3711116314,
-0.0642405748,
0.6404910684,
0.1088698879,
0.0019935754,
-0.2628249526,
-0.8538223505,
0.0077303457,
0.373506248,
-0.5419509411,
-0.3274129033,
0.4146101177,
0.217457056,
-0.5172312856,
0.6993809342,
-0.1126442775,
-0.2022117972,
0.7444174886,
0.4591194093,
1.2310312986,
0.0025792185,
-0.149706617,
0.2756869197,
0.6586052775,
-0.0062379595,
0.53727144,
0.0019060811,
-0.8483418226,
0.0506324694,
-0.3914356828,
-0.5769402385,
0.2318567783,
-0.819652915,
0.1744022816,
-0.9847898483,
-0.3898095191,
-0.2425563931,
0.1581605822,
-0.7233008742,
0.2709882855,
0.3284421265,
1.1238024235,
-0.2698467076,
0.7806272507,
0.8934959769,
-0.4101712406,
-0.3074659407,
0.2628875971,
0.148194775,
-0.7648906708,
0.1822525114,
0.4176684618,
-0.0871711895,
-0.1561650634,
-0.2676194906,
-0.9582852125,
1.3747247458,
0.6534795165,
-0.4554930925,
-0.1415705383,
-0.0892598331,
0.7784451246,
-0.5028822422,
0.6636536121,
0.649625659,
0.6540427208,
-0.3121393025,
-0.7430186868,
0.2586388588,
-0.3324263692,
0.0373434052,
0.3143303394,
-0.9512994885,
1.1461443901,
-0.126561448,
-0.1734096259,
0.3425154686,
0.6939076185,
0.5115975142,
0.5526239276,
0.5648145676,
0.5794915557,
0.9348741174,
-0.296538353,
1.0356268883,
-0.2513929605,
0.1498915106,
1.1000953913,
-0.7404808402,
0.8028880358,
0.2396084964,
-0.3164604604,
0.5751140118,
0.3964657485,
-0.0439520553,
0.493873924,
0.4110104144,
-0.0796997473,
-0.2455876172,
0.0737683997,
-0.2543702424,
0.5855927467,
0.4050541818,
-0.2101251781,
-0.1416932791,
-0.1408855617,
0.019182615,
0.3773526251,
-0.3552391231,
0.5198237896,
0.046170067,
-0.8945438862,
0.2819120288,
-0.1774655133,
0.5292044878,
-0.7199371457,
0.1912992299,
-0.3307192028,
0.4927337766,
0.2928147912,
-0.8799191117,
0.1193627045,
0.0845529512,
0.0417720079,
-0.0838707462,
0.6018902063,
-0.0795183778,
-0.096605435,
0.4873870313,
0.4548847973,
0.3078769147,
-0.1523030102,
-0.540432632,
0.0999205112,
-0.3729068339,
-0.3105662167,
0.4773965478,
0.5733531713,
0.0396526903,
0.8082746863,
0.3606580794,
-0.0194454025,
-0.3057149053,
-0.1543524712,
0.5734747052,
-1.0605742931,
-0.3504314721,
-1.0968658924,
0.2603718638,
-0.2237001061,
-0.9427602291,
0.7699560523,
0.1897227168,
0.9035625458,
0.2619520426,
0.7226194143,
-0.1072286069,
0.3007756472,
-0.4888447225,
0.9314012527,
-0.7427199483,
0.0436534174,
-0.376781106,
-1.0717782974,
-0.0469721556,
0.802236259,
-0.2344793081,
0.3571134508,
1.0695396662,
0.4419986308,
0.2494245172,
0.4314541519,
0.5797657967,
0.2046954185,
0.2561689615,
0.9520929456,
1.1107678413,
-0.1478958577,
0.2004504949,
-0.0765857548,
-0.3328586221,
-0.0736574978,
-0.8772556186,
-1.4124904871,
-0.5333323479,
-0.1619677544,
-0.1860015392,
0.0956700891,
1.1053423882,
0.5941436291,
-0.4295571446,
-0.3609333932,
-0.0437927768,
0.0147296302,
-0.4920762777,
-0.1612966359,
-0.2238981873,
-0.1470678002,
-0.5485283136,
0.4756939709,
0.5686925054,
-0.1647249907,
-0.8511060476,
-0.1588368416,
-0.2018247992,
0.5968998075,
0.4837898314,
0.0465173833,
-1.0090674162,
-0.3973592818,
-0.0436209738,
-0.1464233696,
0.0141483406,
0.8499833941,
-0.6801289916,
0.3312650621,
0.4205935895,
0.6403276324,
-0.0391428508,
-0.4054242671,
0.8148591518,
-0.3230397105,
-0.1721818447,
0.5351370573,
0.4526921511,
0.0386871211,
-0.176475957,
0.6319950223,
0.229521662,
-0.4345906675,
-0.983541429,
0.3249579966,
-0.8354801536,
-0.2550609112,
0.8499291539,
-0.3438668847,
-0.5442374349,
0.1326925159,
-0.0199732762,
0.1472754478,
-0.2811901271,
0.6714618206,
0.873611331,
-0.0695875585,
-0.1422900856,
-0.5100387335,
0.1561486572,
0.5217557549,
-1.0284292698,
0.1533227116,
0.3762489259,
-0.1035345569,
0.3255565166,
0.6497842073,
-0.1695692688,
0.2098647356,
0.0653034002,
0.073686108,
-0.1023024246,
-0.6576227546,
-0.2470069528,
0.1619477123,
-0.0201041643,
-0.0942505673
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06041v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06041v1
|
A Prompt Response to the Demand for Automatic Gender-Neutral Translation
| 2024-02-08T20:24:44 | 2024-02-08T20:24:44 |
Beatrice Savoldi, Andrea Piergentili, Dennis Fucci, Matteo Negri, Luisa Bentivogli
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Gender-neutral translation (GNT) that avoids biased and undue binary
assumptions is a pivotal challenge for the creation of more inclusive
translation technologies. Advancements for this task in Machine Translation
(MT), however, are hindered by the lack of dedicated parallel data, which are
necessary to adapt MT systems to satisfy neutral constraints. For such a
scenario, large language models offer hitherto unforeseen possibilities, as
they come with the distinct advantage of being versatile in various (sub)tasks
when provided with explicit instructions. In this paper, we explore this
potential to automate GNT by comparing MT with the popular GPT-4 model. Through
extensive manual analyses, our study empirically reveals the inherent
limitations of current MT systems in generating GNTs and provides valuable
insights into the potential and challenges associated with prompting for
neutrality.
|
[
-0.2974470556,
-0.4120001197,
0.6343833804,
0.0753305554,
-0.2367060781,
0.1017217338,
-0.1263778359,
-0.193377614,
-0.2624481022,
0.3589972258,
-0.8112700582,
-0.3173404336,
-0.696397543,
0.9369640946,
-0.6204844713,
1.1754208803,
-0.4561944604,
0.0388429463,
0.2191976756,
-0.2886835039,
-1.233963728,
-0.4457839727,
-0.4301170111,
-0.2105324268,
0.5144649148,
0.3665688336,
0.9088472724,
0.618119359,
0.408937484,
0.4552671313,
0.3835759759,
-0.1191886514,
-0.210727185,
0.3485674262,
-0.3033102453,
-0.2513215542,
-0.5269568563,
0.3057635725,
0.7124587893,
0.7855814099,
0.2110660076,
0.1987741143,
0.2928372622,
0.5788019896,
-0.0717030317,
0.1892705262,
-0.6496129632,
0.0506131724,
0.0030296673,
0.1934329867,
-0.1146924496,
-0.5325367451,
0.2621084452,
-0.4645205438,
0.6482865214,
-0.1042360961,
0.8881765604,
0.3495865166,
-0.5737488866,
-0.3527113497,
-0.8354772329,
0.9000396729,
-0.3966340423,
0.3443358243,
0.1579545289,
0.4063395858,
-0.0919035822,
-0.2965205312,
-0.3570429981,
-0.3201555312,
-0.0185338482,
0.0212389305,
-0.5260673761,
-0.0604579039,
0.3165979981,
0.2498698235,
-0.6432113051,
0.0352289714,
-0.2707666159,
0.0174821727,
0.0144708147,
0.2876572311,
0.5338340402,
-0.2503235042,
-0.2680720687,
0.2915433645,
-0.4340623319,
-0.1612364054,
0.79840523,
0.4515170753,
-0.3260092735,
0.7232356071,
-0.2139943242,
0.5358502865,
0.2519550622,
0.5114669204,
0.2839887142,
-0.4865463674,
-0.2035489827,
-0.2172851115,
1.0057504177,
0.2001160681,
0.2644703388,
-0.4075594544,
-0.3388875127,
0.2250088751,
0.1755241603,
-0.9156675339,
0.1165654436,
0.1671781242,
-0.2651561201,
-0.1506949663,
-0.2379027754,
-0.6292480826,
-0.0910700262,
-0.7198237181,
0.4455174804,
-0.2193623036,
-0.1280240119,
-0.0465369374,
-0.388438493,
0.0658973604,
0.5496280789,
-0.9843187332,
0.2057935297,
0.4588229954,
0.9634964466,
-0.1607038975,
-0.1983223855,
-0.5204408169,
-0.1167007312,
-0.3534713089,
0.1978787184,
-0.3466873169,
-0.395999521,
-0.4905604124,
0.1881084293,
-0.0902637541,
-0.1840976626,
0.4302999377,
-0.2075913846,
0.5616511106,
-0.8796201348,
-0.065542914,
-0.2239043713,
0.2467598319,
-0.5804816484,
0.2859193981,
0.3149986565,
-0.8625900745,
0.3130116761,
-0.5056263804,
-0.1730229706,
-0.0502266102,
-0.4697689116,
-0.2655182183,
0.1203219444,
0.206812799,
0.1748672128,
-0.8129218817,
0.7624355555,
-0.4375177026,
-0.2722202539,
0.2378223985,
-0.8048056364,
0.8120610118,
0.0370220914,
-0.7456046343,
0.1365852803,
-0.1296113431,
-0.3713929355,
0.1452063322,
-0.0906759128,
0.0002156751,
-0.1669160724,
-0.5434408784,
0.3793067634,
0.1568833292,
-0.4931106567,
0.1480819136,
-0.2459854782,
0.5018302202,
1.000374794,
-0.5763848424,
0.5490981936,
-0.0487503596,
0.7879405022,
-0.4019084871,
0.0767690763,
0.0818863511,
-0.9197508693,
-0.54763484,
-0.3251627684,
0.5564256907,
0.8278140426,
-0.9118159413,
0.1500773132,
-0.2475362271,
0.087999478,
-0.7636399865,
0.2380289584,
0.431661278,
0.8838489056,
0.3556798697,
-0.323889643,
-0.4330221415,
-1.0852433443,
-0.4003939927,
0.1242486909,
-0.1186590269,
0.0833300203,
0.5274819732,
-0.2625957429,
0.9412270188,
0.1588504463,
-0.0428896621,
-0.3553446531,
0.5557729602,
0.6123887897,
0.5795485973,
0.4776121676,
-0.6024128199,
-0.4312573969,
0.2709060013,
-1.2826567888,
-0.4601733088,
-0.0461834669,
-0.1014409214,
0.1465567648,
0.3015666306,
-0.8156921268,
0.5436676145,
0.7276759744,
-0.1694054604,
0.4821310043,
-0.4161664546,
0.3941815495,
-0.6792615652,
0.447801739,
-0.4301850796,
-0.3471407592,
-0.8413597345,
-0.062406037,
0.1787789315,
-0.3708347976,
-0.2827165723,
0.5277908444,
-0.7157933116,
-0.3528714776,
-0.3687345088,
-0.1457797736,
-0.0978597179,
0.305326134,
-0.1891028434,
0.9426831007,
0.1718728691,
-0.4077865779,
-0.073462747,
0.3887020946,
0.4643470049,
0.2556522191,
-0.885592103,
0.2141609788,
-0.2531324923,
0.2805074453,
-0.8318677545,
-0.3168678284,
0.7251217961,
-0.4348294139,
0.41401425,
-0.3604632318,
-0.2244482785,
-0.5130233765,
-0.2082416862,
0.6458093524,
0.6563301682,
-0.2937726974,
0.4455236495,
-0.0440431759,
-0.5348681211,
-0.6795582175,
-0.7565390468,
0.4901907444,
-0.2172328234,
-0.3837859929,
0.0975769982,
-0.0195415653,
-0.0276766103,
0.0122966217,
0.0491604954,
0.2928470075,
0.0790408552,
0.0762757286,
0.4659813643,
-0.1356768906,
-0.1827862561,
0.3117459416,
-0.5833113194,
-0.1110988855,
-0.639185667,
0.4280353487,
-0.432846576,
-0.4628249705,
-0.7328591943,
0.6904536486,
0.5825505257,
-0.1220929697,
0.4950960577,
0.608376801,
-0.2156715393,
0.2560518384,
-0.2337952107,
-0.0108301919,
-0.5155180097,
0.0647236034,
-0.3263853192,
-0.812148869,
0.404381901,
0.3631016612,
0.185918659,
0.5596695542,
0.6242774725,
0.2648010254,
1.4627227783,
0.3821801543,
0.0979250371,
0.0765295103,
0.2876287699,
0.1933453679,
-0.5826983452,
0.2064665705,
-0.8122220039,
-0.5727857947,
-0.9436080456,
-0.4083228409,
0.341185838,
-0.1231227741,
-0.5227629542,
0.4343817532,
-0.6343379021,
0.1815150827,
0.5454980135,
-0.2828006446,
0.3116437793,
-0.0182733219,
-0.0786334127,
-0.2870068252,
-0.5545341969,
-0.564237237,
1.1029144526,
0.3577008843,
0.4043954611,
0.2604246438,
0.5650786757,
0.276279062,
0.5840392113,
-0.3668376505,
0.5643821359,
-0.6650978923,
-0.7677184939,
-0.0408555865,
-0.8663454056,
-1.1299513578,
0.3009058833,
0.0753434747,
-0.4010280073,
0.2641232312,
0.261920929,
-0.0236558132,
0.1476397514,
-0.9595728517,
0.8956942558,
-0.3599075973,
-0.2937582731,
0.3639054,
-0.6702388525,
0.4871204197,
-0.284262985,
0.1698286682,
-0.1663028598,
-0.1397812963,
0.2066447884,
-0.3627615273,
0.9035342932,
-0.3115842938,
-0.0749999508,
-0.0290326644,
0.3388684988,
0.4881889522,
-0.1260162145,
-0.2305364311,
0.3777027726,
-0.7137107253,
-0.4465304911,
-0.1807193309,
0.6165947318,
-0.8261292577,
-0.8765716553,
-0.4694724381,
-0.8639856577,
-0.0973718241,
0.4632303715,
0.3705238998,
0.2192221582,
0.0187081844,
-0.1168307438,
0.3627388775,
-0.5849070549,
0.4187981188,
0.3455314934,
-0.3940140009,
-0.4958326221,
0.9145440459,
0.1932613403,
0.4302407503,
0.175150618,
0.3717236221,
-0.5781925917,
-0.5609906316,
-1.058074832,
0.1931986511,
-0.5779969692,
-0.0578690954,
-1.0462557077,
0.2669232786,
-0.380600661,
-0.3140532672,
-0.1527229697,
-0.4755330682,
-0.2565745711,
0.0137047311,
0.2012254447,
0.826813221,
-0.0371632949,
-0.0206435118,
-0.6363575459,
0.6777591705,
0.5267727375,
-0.0262917951,
-0.3198065758,
-0.6849328279,
0.3965674937,
0.0034052434,
-0.265693754,
-1.1398774385,
0.5149157047,
-0.2392638028,
0.3647762239,
-0.0180092566,
-0.0933249742,
0.4097102284,
-0.7667685747,
0.5893455148,
0.4208789766,
-1.1552681923,
0.2365239114,
-1.1327546835,
0.5799106359,
0.4741081297,
0.333893925,
-0.2009256333,
-0.5388118029,
-0.4323306382,
-0.8487679362,
0.7743981481,
0.7475243807,
0.2756524384,
0.0670866519,
0.193925485,
0.7149633169,
0.8056357503,
-0.78579849,
0.2046706825,
-0.5696386695,
-0.2593242228,
-0.0741695911,
0.4042807817,
0.1419169307,
-0.1355592608,
0.5247693062,
-0.1458698511,
0.5177252889,
0.1343436241,
-0.0538614877,
0.0120635843,
0.4868222475,
0.5733822584,
0.0957024992,
-0.162126556,
0.1341496706,
0.324819386,
-0.1126537547,
0.3920382857,
0.2462561429,
-0.7048215866,
0.3124784231,
-0.0569626801,
0.952075839,
-0.1549863964,
-0.0706901997,
0.3282125592,
-0.1914078593,
-0.4810782075,
0.2192132324,
-0.2845283151,
0.0092651779,
-0.1077397764,
-0.0320143439,
0.3926360607,
0.1311035007,
-0.3984031379,
-0.0814552605,
0.4501040876,
-0.5112623572,
-0.5784121752,
1.0803955793,
0.3070374727,
-0.1835645586,
0.5941213965,
-0.5482148528,
-0.4684575796,
0.4276393354,
0.4564937651,
1.3632260561,
-0.4187820852,
0.2946623266,
0.2712907195,
0.7941690087,
-0.220695287,
0.2161723077,
0.1893093586,
-0.2522256672,
-0.4379492104,
-0.3618885875,
-0.3428273499,
-0.0418737419,
-0.2458649874,
0.411616534,
-0.5184315443,
-0.3696448803,
-0.258539319,
-0.636785388,
-1.0409265757,
-0.080717057,
0.0486619323,
0.2877400219,
-0.5994156003,
0.4888899624,
0.3948965371,
-0.5294831395,
-0.7101170421,
-0.0210372284,
0.1900787801,
-0.5771437287,
0.5468403697,
0.4488202631,
-0.3935776651,
-0.0091377664,
-0.0856309384,
-0.4658741355,
0.8105522394,
1.0997179747,
-0.5575059056,
-0.2477060705,
0.6495448947,
0.3200595379,
-0.1324256808,
0.3761199415,
0.360271126,
0.7606330514,
-0.4477052689,
-0.9837107658,
0.3706806004,
-0.1748313755,
0.0439295545,
0.2960501909,
-0.3798461854,
1.3917160034,
0.1944672763,
-0.1709201932,
0.1925275624,
0.3702620566,
-0.1594904959,
0.1894910187,
0.598410666,
0.2013072819,
0.4756101966,
-0.1520175487,
1.1385968924,
0.2585383952,
0.1281891316,
0.9187399149,
-0.5804798007,
0.1181724891,
0.2771100402,
0.0836857855,
0.3415654004,
0.209866181,
0.052031152,
0.050559517,
-0.0796236843,
-0.3302148581,
-0.29705742,
-0.0575135984,
-0.6151641011,
0.3236337006,
0.1921690255,
-0.3665643334,
-0.6463255882,
-0.0600203201,
0.0636063591,
-0.0951491445,
-0.1497012824,
0.3594977558,
0.2147827297,
-0.9159730077,
0.7426916957,
0.2666795552,
0.4973617792,
-0.5833263397,
0.0506690927,
-0.1843073964,
0.0522387587,
0.0838186219,
-0.4590777159,
0.4044983089,
0.5591448545,
-0.3037599027,
-0.780554831,
0.7204936743,
-0.2070453167,
-0.4787499607,
0.3754175901,
0.7649173737,
0.0474997722,
-0.0575922281,
-0.9370449781,
-0.0761356652,
0.2836739719,
0.0312649198,
0.3413753808,
0.7220574617,
-0.4454266429,
0.4755354524,
0.7405183315,
-0.3127849698,
0.0017281534,
-0.0377398506,
0.6026607752,
-0.6822198629,
-0.6076350212,
-0.8652362227,
0.5546830297,
0.176558733,
-0.2882386148,
0.8921234012,
0.1076180786,
0.2804128528,
-0.2023746222,
1.1370390654,
-0.104050681,
0.4305291176,
-0.2385401875,
0.5394464731,
-0.3810454607,
0.2874250412,
-0.3952303827,
-0.7160349488,
-0.2533687055,
-0.0503444262,
-0.5065563321,
0.2438197434,
0.6227413416,
0.6366457939,
-0.4140477777,
0.3109636307,
0.1543636173,
0.0620681643,
0.3876678944,
0.3992460966,
0.9184928536,
-0.2282486409,
0.7321757078,
0.402919054,
-0.3131414056,
0.0394030996,
-1.1033378839,
-0.9901282191,
-0.0984947681,
-0.1489097476,
-0.2378541231,
0.2758637071,
0.8256252408,
0.3224066496,
-0.8170982599,
-0.1515369862,
-0.7000988126,
0.0503062792,
0.0402830765,
-0.0114559187,
-0.0407349542,
-0.3883187771,
-0.9047650099,
0.393381983,
0.1531705111,
0.2208746225,
-0.1153655872,
-0.2381031364,
0.1022646874,
-0.1295121312,
0.2052909881,
0.3467588723,
-0.58430022,
-0.1813460737,
0.2408970147,
0.0025324638,
-0.0923213661,
0.8423758149,
-0.6012789607,
0.5098596811,
0.5356327295,
0.8356795311,
0.0310470294,
-0.0179373492,
1.1539154053,
-0.6764019728,
0.0456738472,
0.1716608256,
0.1304456741,
0.5039649606,
-0.1864240319,
0.1908416301,
0.4980229735,
-0.5102763772,
-0.7351667881,
0.499039799,
-0.6181231737,
-0.1919366568,
1.0859116316,
-0.0943659246,
0.030036062,
-0.5333518386,
-0.3317236006,
0.4919815958,
-0.5863173604,
0.3844453096,
0.5055083036,
0.1622785777,
0.2521974444,
-1.1917756796,
0.1534177363,
0.7788475156,
-0.502669096,
0.009567582,
0.3508329391,
0.2701000869,
-0.1459901482,
0.7131788731,
-0.1278860718,
0.2246737778,
-0.1927808374,
0.0653705001,
-0.0255636778,
-0.1548534781,
-0.5440559387,
0.2185126245,
-0.1008456722,
-0.2705976963
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06025v6
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06025v6
|
Doing Experiments and Revising Rules with Natural Language and Probabilistic Reasoning
| 2024-02-08T19:57:29 | 2024-05-22T21:24:19 |
Wasu Top Piriyakulkij, Cassidy Langenfeld, Tuan Anh Le, Kevin Ellis
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We give a model of how to infer natural language rules by doing experiments.
The model integrates Large Language Models (LLMs) with Monte Carlo algorithms
for probabilistic inference, interleaving online belief updates with experiment
design under information-theoretic criteria. We conduct a human-model
comparison on a Zendo-style task, finding that a critical ingredient for
modeling the human data is to assume that humans also consider fuzzy,
probabilistic rules, in addition to assuming that humans perform
approximately-Bayesian belief updates. We also compare with recent algorithms
for using LLMs to generate and revise hypotheses, finding that our online
inference method yields higher accuracy at recovering the true underlying rule,
and provides better support for designing optimal experiments.
|
[
-0.251442343,
-1.0524321795,
0.9460476041,
0.1218819618,
-0.0796695203,
-0.1443467438,
-0.5025262833,
-0.3640602231,
0.0793891922,
0.7982281446,
-0.6650235653,
-0.4382839501,
-0.2031204104,
0.1350982785,
-0.4186948836,
0.6556957364,
0.0397704318,
0.220746547,
-0.1621917039,
0.6197705865,
0.0262867827,
-0.2449558675,
-0.741977632,
-0.577598691,
0.3559316397,
0.5287879109,
0.8607680798,
0.311360538,
0.5925496817,
0.3527377248,
0.0607509501,
0.1838921607,
-0.2638456225,
-0.0220891591,
-0.3906227946,
-0.7952573895,
-0.2044838816,
0.1365929097,
0.4686826766,
0.7672640681,
-0.5463634729,
-0.2695545852,
-0.2376378775,
0.3548979759,
-0.3548591137,
0.2305705249,
-0.5674352646,
-0.0364822149,
0.1825619787,
-0.3318364024,
-0.5670067668,
-0.7149315476,
0.0708033741,
-0.6912500858,
0.6171033382,
0.1179492399,
0.7497184277,
-0.1296175122,
-0.2984699607,
-0.291095823,
-0.9043254256,
0.8942981362,
-1.2994716167,
0.4279827774,
0.7145489454,
0.2650648952,
-0.8433898091,
-0.6972875595,
-0.9964312911,
-0.757923305,
-0.1457227618,
-0.130628258,
0.0585981123,
0.448851198,
0.4754982889,
0.3108506501,
-0.2669082582,
-0.0402744636,
-0.2266329229,
0.1132402942,
1.029843688,
-0.1207682788,
0.3152583241,
-0.088002719,
-0.0846200883,
-0.3472584188,
-0.674475193,
-0.1982285231,
0.4281440079,
0.2584439218,
0.1678309143,
0.7042362094,
-0.7511175275,
0.6899074912,
-0.0243917406,
-0.3656390309,
0.3082340956,
-0.3054342866,
-0.3384569883,
0.0170187689,
0.7956538796,
0.5213771462,
0.5727829337,
-0.3845461905,
-0.2791564167,
0.0406959504,
0.3602820635,
-0.4528962076,
-0.3027561605,
0.0646817163,
-0.2839113176,
-0.2381697297,
0.1869355589,
-0.6297846437,
-0.5052617788,
-0.5812373757,
0.8482807875,
-0.4906533659,
-0.1796916723,
0.5909851193,
-0.3418464363,
-0.0283927023,
0.5519465804,
-0.8707022667,
0.7480747104,
0.8155679107,
0.5278629661,
0.2434526086,
-0.4129163027,
-0.3526402712,
0.1086298898,
-0.6481705308,
0.9009079337,
-0.5681796074,
-0.3204399347,
-0.1349756122,
-0.0624113083,
0.0188977029,
-0.3791686594,
0.7912840843,
-0.5047944188,
0.340452373,
-0.3381542861,
-0.920047164,
-0.4800428748,
0.0244022794,
-0.5351222754,
0.8850349784,
-0.0518797711,
-0.8450732827,
0.3301241994,
-0.801669836,
-0.4693316221,
-0.162331298,
-0.011000705,
-0.284799397,
0.2056315243,
-0.0840895399,
0.4316661656,
-0.4047669768,
0.4281452894,
-0.5034217238,
-0.4233801067,
0.739857614,
-0.2014850378,
0.6858197451,
0.2880724967,
-0.3849522769,
0.2104484141,
-0.6801463962,
-0.0024785309,
0.1560096741,
-0.2665445209,
-0.2349692732,
0.7968145013,
-0.0622987784,
-0.0126453387,
-0.2858994603,
-0.7910468578,
0.4482253194,
-0.5834555626,
0.6085454226,
0.4972926378,
0.269772619,
0.4415006042,
-0.5220668912,
0.0609422177,
-0.3209944367,
0.1130063608,
0.1650089175,
-0.7049789429,
-0.6832834482,
-0.1022181287,
0.2609421611,
0.5396956801,
-0.6166859269,
0.2983979583,
-0.1285451204,
-0.503790319,
-0.4574371278,
0.1990371048,
0.0508475751,
0.3989722729,
0.3394577205,
-0.1617535949,
-0.5742689371,
-1.0065572262,
-0.4417457581,
-0.167106688,
-0.3115637898,
-0.1328405291,
0.5683483481,
-0.3098912239,
1.0341091156,
-0.4932613671,
0.0421195142,
-0.3984909058,
0.5924453735,
0.3589149714,
0.445184052,
0.2916525602,
-0.818056345,
-0.1623408347,
-0.1222700551,
-0.5077777505,
-0.1869880706,
-0.2680535018,
0.0031538627,
-0.0677394643,
0.5968349576,
-0.7922002077,
0.6107944846,
0.1441551298,
-0.3465270996,
0.3755116165,
-0.4470118284,
0.619097054,
-0.9282389879,
-0.4842649996,
0.2951155007,
-0.2483695,
-1.0385621786,
0.1898050159,
0.0155927418,
0.4335644245,
-0.345767796,
0.3419850767,
-0.385871619,
-0.0843873248,
-0.4409756362,
0.0853680819,
-0.0814764425,
0.1817397028,
0.400125891,
0.5696169138,
0.4274745286,
-0.7053933144,
0.4581999779,
-0.1612536907,
-0.6987297535,
0.2474396974,
-0.6578499079,
-0.0427888073,
-0.3039416373,
0.1518752575,
-1.1480712891,
-0.4486480057,
0.3506028652,
-0.5181798339,
0.1084273383,
0.1905736476,
-1.1292818785,
-0.2132401317,
-0.3277742267,
-0.1008189097,
0.6614747047,
-0.4144826531,
0.6907892227,
0.1328129023,
-0.1104858518,
-0.0578571707,
-0.6214244962,
0.3131137788,
-0.2399473041,
-0.4235031605,
0.4923067391,
-0.0903714374,
-1.0094091892,
0.0079969475,
0.3728512526,
-0.1298731416,
0.3479411006,
0.1289018244,
0.0914710313,
-0.1048373654,
0.1476951391,
-0.1090793088,
0.1326717138,
0.3527483642,
0.1199263632,
0.3916023672,
0.1218608394,
-0.456394285,
-0.6519448161,
0.283218652,
0.2019963413,
0.1856323332,
0.662278533,
0.2827002406,
-0.7018178701,
-0.2348650843,
-0.8380884528,
-0.5157188177,
-0.4925578833,
0.1987227947,
-0.3800657392,
-0.542976141,
0.1515984684,
-0.018584609,
0.1263302714,
0.349124521,
0.5895481706,
-0.517368257,
1.2508811951,
0.5428286791,
0.3426204026,
0.4639246762,
0.0994968861,
0.278107971,
-0.6366000772,
0.0485530905,
-0.5100889206,
-0.0767547637,
-0.5951292515,
-0.6869090199,
0.0197309591,
0.3032765388,
-0.1997958273,
0.2544265091,
-0.0536941364,
0.4964849651,
0.9256199598,
0.3199740946,
0.335493803,
-0.0594028756,
-0.0019466378,
0.09637288,
-0.5242828727,
-0.6118227243,
1.002235055,
0.1517613679,
1.1201390028,
0.182723105,
0.7029026747,
0.3796175718,
0.6311721206,
-0.6670930386,
0.5582696795,
0.3416449428,
-0.7116620541,
-0.1822042316,
-0.5693479776,
-0.8073032498,
0.1711923033,
-0.5599575639,
-0.9943168163,
-0.0793669298,
0.1045390069,
-0.1323078275,
0.4812415242,
-0.8363891244,
0.5141565204,
-0.1490113288,
-0.3331317902,
-0.5640307665,
-0.4746067524,
0.4118374586,
0.0438216887,
0.565737009,
-0.1568394899,
0.1201481819,
0.7187299728,
-0.2671718597,
1.1519120932,
0.1114704758,
-0.0756483376,
0.5917934775,
0.3335880935,
0.472766608,
0.1246438995,
-0.140498966,
-0.1106386408,
0.06070875,
-0.2548500299,
-0.7277528644,
0.5538867712,
-0.7446224093,
-0.8493977189,
-0.4761365354,
-0.521807909,
-0.2967403531,
0.0379038677,
0.0090015167,
0.027208006,
-0.1979726106,
0.0557250641,
0.8411145806,
-0.2158240378,
0.2337035239,
0.691293776,
-0.3831926286,
-0.2359462529,
0.5351564884,
0.0114607299,
0.5468274355,
0.6461648941,
0.4373903871,
-0.2176436782,
-0.4999907613,
-0.0842672735,
0.3865237534,
-0.6941864491,
0.1615162045,
-0.5291347504,
-0.1190637872,
-0.5786101222,
-0.170944199,
-0.1180672199,
-0.2905369103,
-0.2085941434,
-0.1910780072,
0.5888497233,
0.9112394452,
-0.2989124954,
0.3679520786,
-0.6832875609,
0.6075609922,
0.4279444516,
0.273843199,
-0.1243474856,
-0.4993789196,
0.0633063391,
0.4751217961,
-0.1213796288,
-1.2940683365,
0.3485081792,
0.2092816085,
0.78259027,
0.430474937,
-0.0312059447,
0.4930254817,
-0.5994679928,
0.5517995954,
0.0525635518,
-0.8261735439,
0.6432958245,
-0.3965539336,
-0.1574007124,
0.355376184,
0.4748676121,
-0.7587569356,
-0.3951234221,
-0.8128656745,
-0.3364055157,
0.4537831247,
0.2029696405,
-0.0055852635,
-0.2862890065,
0.6206902862,
0.0277563576,
0.2930347323,
-0.3952141702,
0.1707122177,
0.112164095,
-0.3229140341,
-0.3867177665,
-0.1396088451,
-0.1373111755,
-0.3325734735,
0.7226265669,
-0.1787951291,
0.2120832354,
0.3363190889,
-0.0128329173,
-0.2170332968,
0.3972322345,
0.7326744199,
0.8176677823,
-0.45806247,
0.2546902597,
0.4376785755,
-0.1678093076,
-0.0255811196,
-0.0096912906,
-0.2640105784,
-0.1570092589,
0.5386990905,
0.601201117,
0.4872131348,
-0.9539929628,
0.1526776552,
-0.3077522814,
-0.5474728346,
-0.3020007908,
0.5553619862,
0.5115552545,
0.3062526286,
0.3310526013,
-0.029863555,
0.3488667607,
-0.9332531691,
0.248681888,
0.2648217678,
0.0377931483,
-0.4365666509,
0.5593927503,
-0.2399870008,
-0.7182931304,
0.5113559365,
-0.408028841,
-0.5205138326,
0.536657393,
0.6689455509,
0.5857554078,
-0.0786620155,
0.2879421711,
0.3816393614,
0.313675195,
-0.6731675863,
0.5979170203,
0.0241472777,
-0.9061689973,
-0.5938007236,
-0.5346564651,
-0.6773647666,
-0.1878171265,
-0.4534729719,
0.2993855774,
-0.4092148542,
-0.1080162898,
0.1108692288,
0.0067307907,
-0.5534814596,
0.4769086242,
0.2310761362,
0.9488239884,
-0.8854168057,
0.9189761877,
0.6717709899,
-0.334798187,
-0.5432215929,
0.0316593945,
0.1281042248,
-0.6275900006,
0.6534013748,
-0.127954036,
-0.0426104665,
-0.0456718281,
-0.8651809692,
-1.0758042336,
0.8276963234,
0.1347610056,
-0.6274021864,
0.1128315404,
-0.0160177723,
0.5860440135,
-0.2733094394,
0.2986171544,
0.5784397721,
0.4443747103,
0.2115947306,
-0.8076717257,
-0.1336103529,
-0.0536788404,
-0.096584484,
0.2082237601,
-0.2144449353,
1.072368741,
-0.6343669295,
-0.2484127581,
-0.0175407007,
0.8865876198,
0.217699185,
0.1474933624,
0.6476973891,
0.7770556808,
0.7463603616,
-0.0430674255,
1.2142156363,
0.0318968259,
0.4601255357,
1.3002263308,
-0.4408299327,
1.0902072191,
0.4894868731,
-0.4520531893,
0.5841194987,
0.901204586,
0.1724512428,
0.5510601401,
0.5229161382,
-0.2902413011,
-0.4911724329,
0.0404900387,
-0.0995766595,
0.1805392355,
0.4415867329,
-0.2303602099,
-0.1662026495,
-0.2077883333,
0.1705076844,
0.1669169068,
-0.2591204643,
0.8197057247,
-0.0153521365,
-0.843177557,
0.0941992551,
0.5125784874,
0.5745816827,
-0.4451823533,
-0.3083646894,
0.0501160026,
0.3750498891,
-0.142715916,
-0.971711874,
0.1580814123,
-0.1335567683,
0.0794670358,
-0.0093828402,
0.7164840698,
-0.3129011989,
-0.7678653598,
0.0820604935,
0.1778822094,
0.1569043696,
0.0362056978,
-0.5822038054,
-0.2242982537,
-0.1133496016,
-0.5232594609,
0.2246308476,
0.3180610836,
-0.1263712496,
0.8495490551,
0.8204596043,
0.3446842432,
0.1927176416,
0.258013159,
0.6607941985,
-0.8861767054,
-0.4096697569,
-0.942442894,
0.2534127235,
-0.2629457414,
-0.0179102067,
0.7474185228,
0.2662180066,
0.927970171,
-0.0107286796,
0.8608652353,
0.0492036827,
0.6102798581,
-0.7575131655,
0.3470772505,
-0.3649123609,
0.0696473122,
-0.1397029907,
-0.6744043231,
-0.3251639307,
1.0527595282,
-0.4452544749,
-0.0224061292,
0.5798080564,
0.9071994424,
-0.0125667229,
0.3566726148,
0.0828934759,
0.4134722352,
0.419193089,
0.4718824923,
0.9066579342,
-0.288369894,
-0.3087325096,
-0.5584796071,
-0.256123513,
-0.3179180026,
-1.0117322206,
-0.9695819616,
-0.4945656955,
-0.436645627,
-0.3224444687,
-0.000265637,
1.395591259,
0.4584892094,
-0.7610583901,
-0.5078511238,
-0.2826824486,
0.1727913767,
-0.3965284228,
-0.2800770104,
-0.0446939617,
-0.4086432457,
-0.5448617339,
0.4911668003,
-0.0272813402,
0.0145026017,
-0.2153240889,
-0.1231819391,
-0.6587849259,
0.5706825256,
0.4171839058,
-0.0096606519,
-0.8460168242,
-0.5168747306,
-0.1060439944,
-0.1500082612,
0.039859049,
0.7461531758,
-0.7506866455,
0.5059551597,
0.8331516385,
0.3353882432,
0.4494796693,
-0.0232277326,
0.6875638962,
-0.1794135571,
-0.2235454321,
0.086248219,
0.4533983171,
0.3238246441,
-0.0778453052,
0.598752737,
0.306414634,
-0.4868525565,
-0.9177007675,
0.183158204,
-0.7833273411,
-0.4258479774,
1.2559008598,
-0.0443687364,
-0.4420673549,
0.0098749716,
-0.3038114607,
0.2479509115,
-0.1728968024,
0.9731534123,
0.7836752534,
-0.3172844648,
-0.2205548882,
-0.9998310804,
0.5735271573,
-0.0020151832,
-0.959402144,
0.0141654126,
0.2739650011,
0.5605986714,
0.0708030909,
0.5751206875,
0.210423097,
0.2871692181,
0.017812673,
0.3012875319,
0.3567456901,
-0.1271844208,
0.097285755,
-0.0664248541,
0.2676630318,
0.2929171026
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06015v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06015v2
|
Exploring Visual Culture Awareness in GPT-4V: A Comprehensive Probing
| 2024-02-08T19:25:40 | 2024-02-15T10:39:19 |
Yong Cao, Wenyan Li, Jiaang Li, Yifei Yuan, Antonia Karamolegkou, Daniel Hershcovich
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Pretrained large Vision-Language models have drawn considerable interest in
recent years due to their remarkable performance. Despite considerable efforts
to assess these models from diverse perspectives, the extent of visual cultural
awareness in the state-of-the-art GPT-4V model remains unexplored. To tackle
this gap, we extensively probed GPT-4V using the MaRVL benchmark dataset,
aiming to investigate its capabilities and limitations in visual understanding
with a focus on cultural aspects. Specifically, we introduced three visual
related tasks, i.e. caption classification, pairwise captioning, and culture
tag selection, to systematically delve into fine-grained visual cultural
evaluation. Experimental results indicate that GPT-4V excels at identifying
cultural concepts but still exhibits weaker performance in low-resource
languages, such as Tamil and Swahili. Notably, through human evaluation, GPT-4V
proves to be more culturally relevant in image captioning tasks than the
original MaRVL human annotations, suggesting a promising solution for future
visual cultural benchmark construction.
|
[
-0.6938041449,
-0.2470659763,
0.3623787463,
0.0758960173,
-0.3971903622,
0.0116336709,
-0.350397557,
-0.634696126,
-0.3552228212,
0.4267383218,
-0.4625049233,
-0.5714403391,
-0.3987976313,
0.2166112661,
0.1654860079,
0.8870069981,
-0.4906569421,
0.0543464459,
-0.2427187115,
-0.4287517667,
-0.7359734774,
-0.4714715183,
-0.2428420931,
-0.0296097584,
0.3050832152,
0.2555143237,
0.248638764,
0.4720092714,
0.8012592793,
0.2196351737,
0.2161863744,
0.062939778,
-0.6484140158,
-0.0733233616,
0.0065385685,
-0.4740359485,
-0.255811125,
0.4607661366,
0.5877972841,
0.1583526134,
0.0866569728,
0.5003899336,
-0.1178799123,
0.6695249677,
-0.7332253456,
0.6477892995,
-0.4805229306,
0.2921345234,
-0.4816407263,
-0.1360266507,
-0.1078886241,
-0.045500353,
0.3324780464,
-0.6182587743,
0.1730909795,
-0.0453239977,
0.7805994153,
0.5190376043,
-0.5795133114,
0.1961282939,
-0.6660827994,
0.7021305561,
-0.0332965665,
0.6274098754,
0.444014132,
0.5910507441,
0.4499456286,
-0.8525187373,
-0.5446234345,
-0.0426979065,
0.1707083285,
0.5342274904,
-0.2409951091,
-0.158588022,
0.4319974184,
0.2919480205,
-0.7252699733,
-0.1462232471,
-0.4903410077,
-0.4628824294,
0.4172176421,
0.0441283621,
0.3395596147,
-0.1234914809,
-0.5362738967,
-0.0315796919,
-0.8205093145,
0.2588963509,
0.0195258576,
-0.1253911704,
-0.3096959293,
0.2752747834,
-0.3797519207,
0.6716147065,
-0.5292640924,
0.0810608491,
0.3615841866,
-0.7472624183,
-0.2585593462,
-0.4244191051,
0.6449466348,
0.8828173876,
0.7258095741,
0.3184267581,
-0.1153726503,
0.1208485216,
0.3193544149,
-0.9035888314,
-0.5291549563,
-0.3433784246,
-0.4415333271,
-0.1885084957,
-0.117466256,
-0.5658174157,
-0.5385748744,
-0.0944381058,
0.3694593906,
-0.3482238948,
-0.3306120038,
-0.2500154972,
-0.1653518081,
0.757552743,
0.6660039425,
-0.9012104869,
-0.120648995,
0.4104452133,
0.7093175054,
-0.2163311988,
-0.2807244062,
-0.2597048283,
0.0946082398,
-0.5506086946,
0.5067379475,
-0.5532002449,
-0.2834052742,
-0.1573581845,
-0.1205417588,
0.1494436413,
-0.286472857,
0.5960030556,
-0.5934288502,
0.0550340451,
-0.7805120349,
0.0114912763,
-0.41427055,
0.7450252771,
-0.6197804213,
0.6196491718,
0.1713446379,
-0.9165697098,
0.8170390129,
-0.4715161324,
-0.0821844116,
0.5988241434,
-0.7061403394,
-0.3458038568,
-0.061195679,
0.5039359331,
0.4981534183,
-0.1606899798,
-0.2366562486,
-0.1528231204,
-0.6364748478,
0.016869219,
-0.5941804647,
0.3194056153,
0.3917017579,
-0.3549093008,
0.1751515716,
-0.2910805643,
-0.2659309804,
0.2587832808,
-0.0206608661,
-0.424133867,
-0.3019841909,
-0.130957365,
0.1723604649,
0.3311887383,
-0.3229011297,
0.2152657956,
0.0650743619,
0.4297489524,
0.6827884912,
0.0522114858,
0.4506731331,
0.0846106559,
0.7895318866,
0.1422338188,
0.4797033072,
-0.2621282637,
-0.6642127037,
-0.4305679202,
-0.2544286251,
-0.0813425332,
0.3737234175,
-1.2011256218,
-0.5087673068,
-0.2994385064,
-0.384940654,
-0.3208601475,
0.1461715698,
0.3759747148,
0.6060919762,
0.2243173867,
-0.6463535428,
-0.3135377169,
-1.1071516275,
-0.0560259409,
-0.2497741729,
0.1961907446,
0.4884788692,
0.4889753461,
-0.0740237385,
0.6803725958,
-0.3868240416,
-0.463237673,
-0.1889811009,
0.1264218837,
-0.0290426742,
0.2000083774,
0.6908760667,
-1.0468400717,
-0.4743938148,
0.2986040413,
-0.8251069784,
0.0989180878,
0.2694835365,
0.0199596845,
0.341455847,
0.4394370019,
-0.1259219646,
0.4919647872,
0.6345353723,
-0.0840699598,
0.4995540977,
-0.1911594123,
0.4696474373,
-0.7153546214,
-0.1157048345,
0.166669026,
-0.1361121535,
-0.5867983103,
-0.0234875828,
0.5113912821,
-0.1418220103,
-0.4611515701,
0.2359036952,
-0.6830689311,
-0.400492698,
-0.0573152341,
-0.1334927529,
-0.1338072121,
0.3967526257,
0.4474516213,
0.9823274612,
0.7469226122,
-0.0273816232,
0.327961117,
0.1655998528,
-0.4949291348,
0.7029912472,
-0.3546494842,
-0.0694578961,
-0.0927512869,
0.3390032947,
-0.8678142428,
-0.2821414471,
0.3611494303,
-0.2590329051,
0.1979489326,
-0.7398967743,
-0.2568896711,
-0.5250555873,
-0.2461243272,
0.8192946315,
0.7863613963,
-0.2669301033,
0.4623906016,
0.233517319,
-0.0172653608,
-0.6249857545,
-0.6084335446,
0.1641972065,
-0.5845463872,
-0.6431655884,
-0.2201853842,
0.1162449643,
-0.1262630522,
-0.5351984501,
-0.3255105913,
0.0360110663,
0.0590846688,
0.2853308916,
0.3605641723,
-0.271941185,
-0.0820172578,
-0.6533560753,
0.1288847029,
0.1062297747,
-0.3136488199,
0.3468161523,
-0.9207968712,
-0.4343056381,
-0.457901895,
-0.1233984604,
0.5596379042,
-1.0208860636,
0.0514473766,
1.1298309565,
-0.1829017848,
0.160305351,
-0.7593619823,
0.0000326679,
-0.4481467903,
0.4659324586,
-0.6495921016,
-0.9923315048,
0.47634238,
0.0481723584,
-0.46676296,
0.2791374922,
0.5716465116,
-0.2080396712,
0.6194282174,
0.6374793649,
0.0982795656,
0.3745732009,
-0.273958683,
-0.0675313622,
-0.7528882623,
-0.2739196122,
-0.0627546236,
-0.111957036,
-1.0429334641,
-0.9275214076,
0.5854613781,
-0.2601327002,
-0.1873563379,
-0.034713272,
-0.3995546699,
0.7013277411,
0.3422003388,
-0.1398343742,
0.2428406328,
-0.1200000644,
0.0725497007,
-0.2891007662,
-0.4018323421,
-0.4212363362,
0.947674334,
0.4792501628,
0.6644968987,
0.1790079623,
0.5274786949,
0.0591876954,
0.3206747472,
-0.5425177813,
0.3383894861,
-0.0392218344,
-0.4226513803,
-0.1853663623,
-0.3339155614,
-0.5674362779,
0.3567106128,
-0.0703396499,
-0.681979537,
0.1791962981,
0.355130136,
-0.2340735197,
0.1469480097,
-0.8719474673,
1.3311296701,
-0.3171578348,
-0.4989594221,
0.0502790399,
-0.9206120968,
0.6366736889,
-0.3068140447,
0.2835052013,
-0.1701694727,
0.0167264864,
0.4728923738,
0.0552556887,
0.7579162121,
-0.1989484876,
-0.0956124216,
0.1342743784,
0.0699732453,
0.3522076607,
0.0348852649,
0.5362516642,
0.3439792693,
-0.1040443256,
-0.427216053,
-0.3864545822,
0.6671631336,
-0.8982602954,
-0.6144940257,
-0.5565499067,
-0.5974882841,
-0.3149385154,
0.209436059,
0.0176158324,
0.3426991999,
-0.1769470274,
0.1069191545,
0.5854193568,
-0.2615419626,
0.4509469569,
0.4909969568,
-0.2335576564,
-0.067777589,
0.9042422771,
0.094026424,
0.1799503416,
0.1489316672,
0.1314860135,
-0.2402148992,
-0.8701642752,
-0.7456486821,
0.034875799,
-0.7945446372,
0.2258864939,
-0.3275082111,
0.0972363502,
-0.1727855355,
-0.040438164,
-0.4507912397,
-0.028661171,
0.0367160402,
0.082342267,
0.297147423,
0.8980222344,
0.2094147056,
-0.0598319508,
-0.5734348893,
0.1412810683,
0.5535213351,
0.5647893548,
-0.3356363773,
-0.4754163027,
-0.2436228245,
-0.2659098506,
-0.0772854239,
-0.6543564796,
0.3226979375,
-0.1088011935,
0.4480877817,
0.5695232153,
-0.068977572,
0.6766490936,
-0.6464011073,
0.9924836159,
0.0224213544,
-0.6827332973,
0.4925953746,
-0.6919132471,
0.4764685035,
0.4344465733,
0.4843858778,
-0.5656750202,
-0.1680550128,
-0.3516691327,
-0.5956964493,
0.4298070371,
0.3308524787,
0.0207675789,
0.1853773147,
0.055759348,
0.0066769784,
0.1562397629,
-0.6905039549,
0.1576733589,
-0.7199818492,
0.3051381409,
-0.187429294,
-0.0335215554,
-0.233335644,
-0.240086332,
0.1561411917,
-0.2241506428,
-0.0818689018,
0.0991689712,
-0.310318023,
0.1417225152,
0.0652768165,
0.7932319045,
0.8222827911,
-0.3404008746,
0.2423998564,
0.4167092443,
-0.75513798,
-0.0803838372,
0.0754429102,
0.0778684765,
-0.576472342,
0.3538965881,
0.9379923344,
-0.2112818807,
-0.4568486214,
0.8257200122,
-0.5085414052,
-0.0225837715,
-0.5700774789,
-0.1476117671,
0.0225886926,
0.3116694093,
0.2483177781,
0.0915740803,
0.1340079755,
-0.3943544924,
0.0843459889,
0.4721741974,
-0.6740352511,
-0.3236953318,
0.8049945831,
0.4181916118,
0.3507805765,
0.7302284837,
-0.1746459603,
-0.740740478,
0.4622450471,
0.1511756182,
0.4963332415,
-0.0383889005,
0.1460344046,
0.182960704,
0.6644243598,
0.07428094,
0.385407865,
-0.2946608663,
-0.9237143993,
-0.6936261654,
-0.5709599257,
-0.4095059633,
-0.1134112477,
-0.6559361219,
0.2633771002,
-0.2522295415,
0.0519797765,
-0.2538205087,
-0.067964524,
-1.0107060671,
0.3672687411,
0.6895854473,
0.5965332389,
-1.2019280195,
0.9475612044,
0.8925703764,
-0.7245152593,
-0.8109546304,
0.0868285745,
0.2334867269,
-1.0457578897,
0.9824693203,
0.5103778243,
-0.100171186,
0.0194782522,
-0.41150406,
-0.7114886642,
1.332357049,
-0.0485252813,
-0.3291855156,
0.4598861039,
0.0649877787,
0.6437203288,
-0.2633008957,
0.318588376,
0.6861354113,
0.6008216143,
0.2552060485,
-0.898052156,
0.0186257157,
-0.3318369985,
0.2443535328,
0.1326204091,
-0.8476822376,
0.6057282686,
-0.322671771,
0.0161991306,
-0.2956050634,
0.7096124291,
0.1406234205,
0.3253515661,
0.5797819495,
0.3714066148,
0.597233057,
-0.3921915889,
1.3419481516,
0.065188162,
0.0969866365,
0.7893509865,
-0.4487416446,
0.6318279505,
0.4495662451,
-0.1335068643,
0.0887582824,
0.8413776159,
-0.3044258654,
0.4715426266,
0.3711261153,
-0.2802262008,
-0.3506032526,
-0.1852067262,
-0.4233541489,
1.0049115419,
0.174363628,
-0.0798544809,
0.0192998108,
0.0969506949,
-0.1638187468,
-0.2130930871,
-0.5238871574,
0.6643083692,
-0.1909964532,
-0.5868337154,
0.6272080541,
-0.3913256228,
0.5851624608,
-0.4980235398,
-0.0912598819,
-0.3083103001,
-0.0840197206,
0.0959137008,
-0.9061536193,
0.0570848025,
0.0836222917,
0.0895712301,
-0.4475295842,
0.6751804948,
-0.3515934348,
-0.1796817929,
-0.0967454985,
0.4483419359,
0.4417230189,
-0.2973306477,
-0.2746809721,
0.3851265013,
0.2967322171,
-0.1598350555,
0.3302123547,
0.4692099392,
-0.716296196,
0.5482679009,
0.3873034418,
-0.1131597906,
-0.043439012,
0.4145213664,
0.6196969151,
-0.5438082814,
-0.3837503493,
-0.7916731238,
0.3990786076,
-0.1028785557,
-0.1827668399,
0.7675922513,
0.4914245307,
1.0411514044,
-0.2946790755,
0.9871742129,
0.2030216455,
-0.2788330913,
-0.350399822,
0.9844831228,
-0.5093161464,
0.0690968856,
-0.4019475281,
-0.8288373947,
-0.3600307703,
0.5191420913,
-0.5962423086,
0.1249345168,
0.6764962077,
0.499796778,
0.0362672992,
0.2868718505,
0.6331377029,
0.2846740782,
0.3979612589,
0.3524577618,
1.1904833317,
0.1454388797,
0.75778234,
-0.3531262577,
-0.3788635433,
0.1277545691,
-1.1917670965,
-0.8718116879,
-0.7157946825,
-0.2562537491,
0.1668661386,
-0.0194344558,
0.5458225012,
0.5778207779,
-0.4614403248,
-0.0428868756,
0.3504049182,
-0.3417751789,
-0.0985595062,
-0.1134985462,
0.3646835089,
-0.0286547672,
-0.6719425917,
0.2419372052,
0.492762804,
0.2348259389,
-0.316886574,
-0.0133152455,
0.1770371646,
-0.4460764229,
0.6633343101,
0.2523991168,
-0.8096346855,
-0.4251818061,
-0.0985024869,
0.1084437519,
-0.0121932542,
0.6476545334,
-0.6353412271,
0.8875610828,
0.4774652719,
0.58249861,
0.9496021867,
0.2420473993,
0.7561392188,
-0.8383834958,
0.1244491264,
0.1201428324,
0.5139698982,
0.7173339725,
0.0219087899,
0.6300023198,
0.3763394654,
-0.700074017,
-0.4529936314,
0.3984154165,
-1.1992194653,
0.1624770015,
1.0228714943,
-0.207311362,
-0.0586102493,
0.010377042,
-0.3287168741,
0.1538966298,
-0.1730761826,
0.3205543458,
0.7310464978,
-0.0970461071,
-0.4675470591,
-1.0810557604,
0.5761874914,
0.1852394044,
-0.5759733915,
0.0716333315,
0.7358369231,
0.5202774405,
-0.0645231381,
0.6358789802,
-0.1998519599,
0.4859349728,
-0.2817436755,
0.4137015343,
-0.2371537536,
-0.0598757975,
-0.3183462918,
0.0219678953,
0.1735743284,
-0.3607965112
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05935v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05935v2
|
SPHINX-X: Scaling Data and Parameters for a Family of Multi-modal Large Language Models
| 2024-02-08T18:59:48 | 2024-06-26T07:59:03 |
Dongyang Liu, Renrui Zhang, Longtian Qiu, Siyuan Huang, Weifeng Lin, Shitian Zhao, Shijie Geng, Ziyi Lin, Peng Jin, Kaipeng Zhang, Wenqi Shao, Chao Xu, Conghui He, Junjun He, Hao Shao, Pan Lu, Hongsheng Li, Yu Qiao, Peng Gao
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We propose SPHINX-X, an extensive Multimodality Large Language Model (MLLM)
series developed upon SPHINX. To improve the architecture and training
efficiency, we modify the SPHINX framework by removing redundant visual
encoders, bypassing fully-padded sub-images with skip tokens, and simplifying
multi-stage training into a one-stage all-in-one paradigm. To fully unleash the
potential of MLLMs, we assemble a comprehensive multi-domain and multimodal
dataset covering publicly available resources in language, vision, and
vision-language tasks. We further enrich this collection with our curated OCR
intensive and Set-of-Mark datasets, extending the diversity and generality. By
training over different base LLMs including TinyLlama1.1B, InternLM2-7B,
LLaMA2-13B, and Mixtral8x7B, we obtain a spectrum of MLLMs that vary in
parameter size and multilingual capabilities. Comprehensive benchmarking
reveals a strong correlation between the multi-modal performance with the data
and parameter scales. Code and models are released at
https://github.com/Alpha-VLLM/LLaMA2-Accessory
|
[
-0.5387020111,
-0.3681058586,
0.2310729921,
0.0751741379,
-0.2472066432,
-0.2365357131,
-0.4931456745,
-0.5412801504,
0.2575431466,
0.5267968774,
-0.5757683516,
-0.346293956,
-0.6428880692,
0.1859097183,
-0.583065033,
1.0219767094,
0.0579753816,
0.3974534273,
0.1707999855,
-0.5387501717,
0.2982077897,
-0.5247188807,
-0.495935142,
0.1685796529,
1.0376292467,
0.3378858268,
0.938579917,
0.9131246805,
0.4582622349,
0.2803256214,
-0.0074769668,
0.1722043455,
-0.3061900139,
0.2542283237,
0.0548421778,
-0.3390998244,
-0.5360369086,
-0.102955088,
1.0578486919,
0.7806949615,
-0.0754826367,
0.4076935649,
-0.1713166386,
0.3940899968,
-0.638145864,
0.2324815691,
-0.514937222,
-0.1789500117,
-0.360195756,
0.1177157238,
-0.372544229,
0.0410237126,
0.1649285257,
-0.7676045299,
-0.139432162,
0.270124495,
0.4895241261,
0.2214379162,
-0.6321339607,
-0.3463556468,
-0.4470632076,
1.0247592926,
-0.4921864867,
0.6811894178,
0.2392801195,
0.2488037497,
0.2045050114,
-1.0744800568,
-0.4555975795,
-0.5521823764,
0.0102615841,
-0.3429549932,
-0.066772595,
-0.1001737937,
0.3761012256,
0.4397761226,
-0.5848739743,
0.1170238853,
-0.2884550989,
-0.1474205703,
0.4414992034,
0.4401691258,
0.3082934618,
-0.0286461804,
-0.3005675972,
-0.2873368561,
-0.6956123114,
-0.056499429,
0.260109067,
0.3604471385,
-0.1935720295,
0.7019965053,
-0.1347164214,
0.7960960269,
-0.0697780922,
-0.3283851743,
0.250159651,
-0.5755059123,
-0.0633823127,
-0.0752461553,
0.7523203492,
0.2428417355,
0.0429303609,
-0.0858537629,
-0.3170065284,
-0.311252594,
0.1759975553,
-1.0206793547,
-0.1475467533,
0.049002517,
-0.5914953351,
-0.1439524442,
-0.2238219678,
-0.6654783487,
-0.7144805789,
-0.5364223719,
0.6809098125,
-0.4214989245,
-0.376858741,
0.2596004009,
-0.1453797817,
0.1775739044,
0.6095246673,
-1.0665575266,
0.2703588307,
0.354773581,
0.7483311296,
-0.1046990007,
-0.5840054154,
-0.6646708846,
0.1116594225,
-0.174050495,
0.3706314862,
-0.7664088011,
-0.2193562835,
0.1111448929,
0.0235156808,
0.0559893139,
-0.3311398327,
0.6226906776,
-0.5069845319,
0.1323494464,
-0.1846612543,
-0.2074217349,
-0.1665458679,
0.373681128,
-1.1356294155,
0.9786798954,
0.2817859054,
-0.757773757,
0.4719698131,
-0.6007559299,
-0.3867964447,
-0.1438402832,
-0.1353619546,
-0.3074035048,
0.2191419005,
0.2297279537,
0.3975065053,
-0.601498127,
-0.2461886704,
-0.5308867693,
-0.1183778942,
0.3837472498,
-0.5059337616,
0.7336137295,
0.0185208581,
-0.3209219575,
0.477180928,
-1.1165888309,
0.1414718032,
-0.0599696301,
-0.5032483935,
-0.3514075577,
-0.0112165185,
0.6865717769,
0.4424600303,
0.4776493311,
-0.5061583519,
0.3324230015,
-0.1380842775,
0.5708812475,
0.5372092724,
-0.6193865538,
0.5260126591,
-0.1704319268,
0.3460997939,
-0.0662472546,
0.5210980773,
-0.4512863755,
-0.3681366742,
-0.981359005,
-0.727606535,
0.295483321,
0.1263899952,
-0.7840691805,
0.2059256881,
-0.5595502853,
-0.6611778736,
-0.3942596018,
0.1545602083,
0.1926402301,
0.1244173273,
0.3163129687,
-0.2572506666,
-0.4590415955,
-0.9550656676,
0.0584019497,
-0.0530498475,
-0.1812210828,
0.1845068485,
0.6023979187,
-0.1928897947,
0.6130686998,
-0.2174258232,
-0.3915492594,
-0.2336467206,
0.0367863998,
-0.0341734439,
0.2556640208,
0.665025115,
-0.8938333988,
-0.4910905957,
0.1267231703,
-0.4468951225,
0.2638859451,
0.049662672,
0.2592533827,
0.418966949,
0.2687915862,
-0.6460377574,
0.0514370166,
0.8384491801,
-0.284596771,
0.651874125,
-0.4169300795,
0.2004339546,
-1.0346879959,
0.1428308487,
0.1932006329,
-0.0813381448,
-0.8045170307,
0.393787533,
0.5099573731,
0.0981766433,
-0.5031994581,
0.6056576967,
-0.5845608115,
-0.1470523179,
-0.0147561645,
0.035099037,
-0.0749806017,
0.5145062804,
0.162702322,
0.8152724504,
0.8623536229,
-0.2952554822,
0.4328102469,
-0.012491677,
-0.5647892356,
0.4828658402,
-0.5799722672,
-0.1908024102,
0.0940564945,
0.2773316801,
-0.9469977617,
-0.2499585152,
0.1393784285,
-0.1805138886,
0.4241020083,
-0.0766570717,
-0.9378494024,
0.0165897459,
-0.6742716432,
0.5596009493,
0.3086560667,
-0.6378304362,
0.9586740732,
0.3071523011,
-0.1988390982,
-0.4346930385,
-0.3570279777,
0.3970469534,
-0.2655692101,
-0.7481151223,
0.1851841509,
-0.1650873423,
-0.3297878504,
-0.2354668081,
0.1145773679,
-0.2489807755,
-0.0680913851,
0.2763453722,
0.3016158044,
-0.4239939749,
0.1413616389,
-0.117039606,
-0.0476666056,
0.0409170985,
-0.4287165403,
0.6341512799,
-0.0429286696,
-0.2890937924,
-0.2620609403,
0.3835677803,
1.0539990664,
-0.5526595712,
0.7009064555,
0.8864151239,
-0.2577928305,
0.0603234917,
-0.3593797982,
-0.0452052653,
-0.4467097521,
0.5682692528,
-0.4428713024,
-0.8744526505,
0.4202150702,
0.1135938615,
0.2757418156,
0.436098516,
0.897542417,
0.1912234277,
1.2973605394,
0.6378358603,
-0.2918639779,
0.6120372415,
-0.23696284,
-0.2314416319,
-0.903339684,
-0.155524537,
-0.6230136156,
-0.2662147582,
-0.4837161899,
-0.6170096397,
0.469835043,
-0.1692878902,
-0.3009617031,
0.2427032888,
-0.1607432216,
0.1389177442,
0.6485540271,
0.0053106276,
0.4407028258,
0.2455959469,
0.1064349264,
-0.1119084209,
-0.4943609238,
-0.3608726561,
1.5471436977,
0.156791985,
1.2266938686,
0.3266467452,
0.2633631825,
0.1689479351,
0.2336232811,
-0.8697946072,
0.3758113682,
-0.1916826069,
-0.7053006887,
-0.6368064284,
-0.259114176,
-0.8566518426,
0.5571605563,
-0.2154489458,
-0.5773594379,
0.0652667135,
-0.157003209,
-0.1806065142,
0.4001560211,
-0.3882713616,
0.6608181,
-0.2672041953,
-0.2501540482,
-0.5257342458,
-0.8192401528,
0.3710357547,
-0.4095571935,
0.1196975708,
0.1364161223,
-0.7183260322,
0.4962925613,
-0.3764888048,
0.916223824,
0.1054862067,
-0.5111702085,
-0.1527270973,
-0.0293407086,
0.4646549225,
0.1172083244,
-0.2166904807,
0.310379535,
0.1390225142,
-0.2907578051,
-0.6318000555,
0.8067956567,
-0.9462576509,
-0.3860526085,
-0.2744846642,
-0.7305259109,
-0.0700040758,
0.1419906616,
0.0154702961,
0.9965461493,
-0.02102842,
0.4405005276,
0.7006576061,
0.077470094,
0.4240298867,
0.6525323391,
-0.3207883537,
-0.7197372317,
0.9826204777,
0.289475888,
0.4319981039,
0.523841083,
-0.1470766068,
-0.4686607718,
-0.6107724309,
-1.0561549664,
0.1561114192,
-0.7335000038,
0.12622118,
-0.5796146393,
0.0305146538,
-0.3054353893,
0.1240499467,
-0.2239684463,
-0.7178875208,
-0.4373623431,
0.5111200809,
0.3025461435,
0.7202982903,
0.065887928,
0.2205173969,
-0.8593075871,
0.3317633569,
0.2034242451,
0.3058634996,
0.0174574535,
-0.7707871199,
-0.5184559822,
-0.0349621736,
-0.0442524999,
-0.3886334002,
0.2800555229,
0.3970462084,
0.5048742294,
0.4921582043,
-0.0024726808,
0.4874952137,
-0.7009947896,
1.0001741648,
0.4353342056,
-0.8263341784,
0.1379926652,
-0.3432265818,
0.2474875301,
0.0482908189,
0.5232214928,
-0.7347320318,
-0.3108871281,
-0.2581992447,
-0.5957927704,
0.8524218798,
0.088074699,
0.2189464122,
0.2523910999,
0.2334924638,
0.3148746789,
0.0613387711,
-0.6330548525,
-0.4871524274,
-0.3454740345,
-0.308025986,
-0.328298986,
-0.3594397902,
-0.3010820448,
-0.3270994425,
0.4398202896,
-0.3757162094,
-0.2152012736,
-0.1189837903,
-0.5081515312,
0.0354036838,
0.1755552292,
1.0177186728,
0.740560472,
0.0645639151,
0.1597906202,
0.1149526909,
-0.6570309401,
0.1200968623,
0.2752280235,
0.1720744818,
-0.0685387477,
0.4591569602,
0.7596510053,
0.2766995728,
-0.9232705832,
0.4694564044,
-0.2103789598,
-0.2087033093,
-0.2783322632,
0.0555517115,
-0.0857026204,
0.4145628512,
0.5032956004,
-0.0896898061,
0.2393069267,
-0.4255758226,
0.0415268168,
0.4308388233,
-0.3789440095,
-0.509980917,
0.5994235873,
0.1414601058,
0.0105113452,
0.442445755,
0.2350682169,
-0.1558705121,
0.3619681001,
0.3418442011,
0.5641399026,
-0.0255148914,
0.0937686563,
0.2899483144,
0.5175430775,
-0.0144560738,
0.1781053096,
-0.2138643712,
-0.4280171096,
-0.4069711864,
-0.6634215713,
-0.4899402857,
0.0884601548,
-0.7006043792,
0.3649297655,
-0.540813446,
-0.1051081046,
0.1123575643,
0.1442249864,
-0.4111916721,
0.1979593635,
0.2252817154,
1.2056566477,
-0.3966924846,
1.2330054045,
0.8014250994,
-0.6158306599,
-0.5058589578,
-0.1863518059,
0.1672229022,
-0.8711955547,
0.9250007868,
0.009927175,
-0.2047028542,
0.0572005883,
-0.3475443721,
-1.2513707876,
1.0911992788,
0.3407000899,
-0.491253525,
-0.1175148115,
0.2726170123,
0.4350251257,
-0.3894279599,
0.2886755764,
0.4590960145,
0.596794188,
-0.0670882612,
-1.1229902506,
0.023361288,
-0.1250656098,
0.1096289158,
0.4241002202,
-0.5246831775,
1.1640349627,
-0.2111029029,
0.006695237,
0.7233694196,
0.5136451721,
-0.0670103803,
-0.2823286653,
0.6076005101,
0.4910205305,
0.4961726069,
0.0294377469,
0.9874083996,
-0.5663671494,
0.2567469478,
1.0032006502,
-0.3069112599,
0.973941803,
0.5555283427,
-0.0357758142,
0.3178712428,
0.6212766767,
0.0151529694,
0.3684011996,
0.082927011,
-0.4591666758,
-0.3950922787,
-0.115339905,
-0.4558301568,
0.3978879452,
0.5616663694,
-0.5785189271,
-0.4134917855,
0.2508768141,
-0.2061014622,
-0.4475268126,
-0.4729711115,
0.5691244602,
-0.2032609582,
-0.1748707592,
0.7714018226,
0.0902412981,
0.7695127726,
-0.9476459622,
0.1425267607,
-0.1184870601,
0.1486198604,
-0.0778564215,
-0.8786859512,
-0.1817318946,
-0.2202224731,
-0.3560387492,
-0.1030201167,
0.4881643057,
-0.5756849051,
-0.5252633691,
0.2150163651,
0.3825992942,
0.1249789745,
-0.2429428697,
-0.5816241503,
0.4097883999,
-0.1433144957,
-0.333243221,
0.6256693602,
0.5369877815,
-0.221513018,
0.7760754824,
0.5907042027,
0.0261022616,
0.3503492177,
0.3053525388,
1.1086013317,
-0.6343411803,
0.0063370429,
-0.7068903446,
0.5450174212,
-0.1211603507,
-0.5290976167,
0.8378051519,
0.6903018951,
0.7672581673,
-0.1820618659,
0.5675902963,
0.0281223971,
0.1082462668,
-0.4714624882,
0.7257829309,
-0.9929113388,
-0.0926850513,
0.0343870968,
-0.7538629174,
-0.5920136571,
0.2326377183,
0.0636565536,
-0.0080168862,
0.5731121302,
0.9902682304,
0.0023878186,
-0.0736528188,
0.6138498783,
0.040437948,
0.2811132371,
0.291787833,
0.9774814844,
-0.304282546,
0.9167566895,
-0.0285860356,
-0.3042723238,
-0.4506202638,
-0.4092659652,
-0.9653984308,
-0.8943467736,
-0.1342470795,
-0.0905096605,
-0.345879823,
0.9559006691,
0.7940523624,
-0.4293763041,
-0.344568193,
0.5330101252,
-0.1863491535,
-0.159083128,
-0.0916021913,
0.2511308193,
-0.5034074187,
-0.8967954516,
0.1921199858,
0.6011782885,
-0.0330732167,
-0.992513299,
-0.2574514747,
0.1381795704,
0.0294523407,
1.0251643658,
0.0495827086,
-1.0787520409,
-0.2787432671,
0.0870703906,
-0.4328146875,
0.1243761703,
0.9456475377,
-0.5680143237,
0.2334761024,
0.295863688,
0.4284109473,
0.3576181531,
-0.7265825272,
0.35792014,
-0.42928949,
0.1395752132,
-0.1427881122,
0.6369984746,
0.1752087921,
0.1240368858,
0.3026330173,
-0.0757172331,
-0.294757545,
-0.7304582596,
0.2685329616,
-1.1783357859,
-0.2818184793,
1.2040923834,
-0.0936958268,
-0.1764987409,
-0.0877182707,
-0.5611335039,
-0.2252415866,
-0.3299880922,
0.6263618469,
0.6551698446,
0.0891781598,
-0.4162043631,
-0.2862227261,
0.3372336328,
0.135369271,
-0.7777884007,
0.2259148955,
0.7862840891,
0.368607223,
0.3890026212,
0.3360109031,
-0.1606823802,
0.4064407945,
0.1793777645,
0.1139834449,
0.0529844835,
-0.440721482,
-0.5149831176,
0.4391489029,
0.2953334451,
-0.0073978007
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05932v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05932v2
|
Driving Everywhere with Large Language Model Policy Adaptation
| 2024-02-08T18:59:03 | 2024-04-10T23:29:18 |
Boyi Li, Yue Wang, Jiageng Mao, Boris Ivanovic, Sushant Veer, Karen Leung, Marco Pavone
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Adapting driving behavior to new environments, customs, and laws is a
long-standing problem in autonomous driving, precluding the widespread
deployment of autonomous vehicles (AVs). In this paper, we present LLaDA, a
simple yet powerful tool that enables human drivers and autonomous vehicles
alike to drive everywhere by adapting their tasks and motion plans to traffic
rules in new locations. LLaDA achieves this by leveraging the impressive
zero-shot generalizability of large language models (LLMs) in interpreting the
traffic rules in the local driver handbook. Through an extensive user study, we
show that LLaDA's instructions are useful in disambiguating in-the-wild
unexpected situations. We also demonstrate LLaDA's ability to adapt AV motion
planning policies in real-world datasets; LLaDA outperforms baseline planning
approaches on all our metrics. Please check our website for more details:
https://boyiliee.github.io/llada.
|
[
-0.2941249013,
-0.8125939965,
1.0990459919,
0.3542313874,
-0.2811252177,
-0.2336279899,
-0.164581269,
-0.5302812457,
0.231749326,
0.4625835717,
-0.5997986197,
-0.4090967178,
-0.1236971244,
-0.1753893644,
-0.5298369527,
0.7294398546,
-0.270244956,
-0.1916723251,
-0.0543063544,
-0.2418862432,
-0.4853764474,
-0.0581443943,
-0.3147620261,
0.024240002,
0.6673147082,
0.5424987078,
0.7705695629,
0.5818183422,
0.4430209398,
0.2827157974,
0.1455628425,
0.2156425416,
-0.2705507576,
0.2797428668,
-0.5819892883,
-0.0751177371,
-0.483340919,
-0.6371819377,
0.8573741317,
0.5086865425,
-0.4206418693,
-0.3302196562,
-0.3801045418,
0.3100376725,
-0.6412253976,
-0.0374141075,
-0.6715679169,
-0.1723690778,
-0.1519950628,
-0.2173660845,
0.2618683875,
-0.5283382535,
0.0176100824,
-0.9069790244,
-0.2474716753,
0.0667958483,
0.6024494767,
0.4818277955,
-0.811044991,
-0.3122776151,
-1.2596795559,
0.5691994429,
-0.3447609842,
0.3849386871,
-0.1722015142,
0.696205318,
-0.4965140224,
-0.2315079272,
-0.9763064981,
-0.0106976451,
0.4346727729,
0.103647314,
-0.3260715604,
0.1924198419,
-0.1089467704,
0.0450064279,
-0.323754251,
0.4651347995,
-0.3152158558,
-0.0114895357,
0.8934210539,
0.3956533074,
0.1431670636,
0.4041496515,
-0.1197059974,
-0.2516820729,
-0.8518866301,
-0.0138785262,
0.1508151442,
0.257765919,
-0.2167900652,
0.3042423427,
-0.4834682345,
0.7576941252,
-0.3995421231,
-0.1743081063,
0.3705956936,
-0.1629867554,
-0.5460476875,
-0.1093881652,
0.687225759,
0.5511149764,
0.3378127515,
-0.1820813268,
-0.203807503,
-0.2809123695,
0.1616028696,
-0.4459798336,
0.1092568338,
0.235641256,
0.0838569179,
-0.0708329082,
-0.0677736327,
-0.6889634728,
-0.6083171964,
-0.4556043744,
0.3615281582,
0.0375338681,
-0.3440055251,
0.3212887049,
0.3192805648,
0.8316901922,
0.7534502149,
-0.9050763249,
0.2621676624,
0.661380291,
0.8905507922,
-0.1695426404,
-0.6376098394,
-0.5771769881,
0.3390021324,
-0.5702547431,
1.1227170229,
-0.1956938505,
-0.491397053,
0.1654183269,
0.3479123116,
0.0805622637,
-0.3529560864,
0.3733075261,
-0.2098486722,
-0.3212805986,
-0.1139794663,
-0.1048817262,
-0.4546939135,
0.1431336105,
-0.5581684113,
0.5890393257,
0.0575167313,
0.3192276061,
0.3852697313,
-1.126706481,
-1.0141499043,
-0.0379005671,
-0.0463075228,
-0.332493782,
0.3363170028,
0.1378868222,
0.488268882,
-0.258027941,
0.4033945203,
-0.158338502,
-0.2258529961,
-0.0260756258,
-0.4644957483,
0.7484480739,
0.072967805,
0.01265484,
0.6598317027,
-0.5526975393,
-0.3811165094,
0.1770054251,
-0.3468256891,
-0.0284164995,
0.1027246714,
0.2373234183,
0.0696561858,
0.0527469479,
-0.4601270258,
0.5077613592,
-0.39779374,
0.3048144579,
1.0107042789,
0.201658383,
0.6357781887,
-0.4046644866,
0.6700521708,
-0.0183896814,
0.2232907861,
-0.1144478619,
-0.5837479234,
-0.6676502228,
0.1359725744,
-0.1434340924,
0.6960900426,
-0.5596126914,
0.1560726464,
-0.4427069128,
-0.5875478983,
-0.5842189193,
0.1570537686,
-0.033198446,
0.106804274,
0.119092077,
-0.2202323079,
-0.5102914572,
-0.4853420258,
0.0081153614,
-0.0266192257,
-0.0846890658,
0.4224477112,
0.6547567844,
-0.5131546855,
0.8884804249,
-0.3439037502,
-0.4328970611,
-0.2884860933,
-0.2060685307,
-0.0686428994,
0.2852312922,
0.6885402203,
-0.5370315909,
-0.4652415514,
0.3634024262,
-0.5698218346,
0.0034826386,
-0.7096953988,
-0.2728693485,
0.0496292077,
0.5822689533,
-0.2800390124,
0.3552339375,
0.5492734313,
-0.3595662713,
0.4456456006,
-0.6045752764,
-0.2859501541,
-0.8141010404,
-0.2175816596,
0.0540583096,
-0.8086035848,
-0.5525234938,
0.3231069446,
-0.1981637925,
0.1706139296,
-0.8537544012,
0.5916910172,
-0.1688386649,
-0.4993402064,
-0.328328073,
0.092528984,
-0.2533082962,
0.1787912995,
-0.0093833571,
0.9703398943,
0.9776374102,
-0.9428955317,
0.5678247213,
0.3029944003,
-0.6906372309,
0.6272513866,
-0.509530127,
-0.1618530154,
-0.4192513525,
0.3661099076,
-0.6439063549,
-0.6665548086,
0.1444257051,
0.1545041502,
-0.1665552855,
-0.0325390585,
-0.4022778571,
0.2687881887,
0.0722869411,
0.1327366829,
0.5632570982,
-0.5623939633,
0.856347084,
0.8458821774,
0.0732097402,
0.0530023277,
-0.5096110106,
0.3887089789,
-0.31761235,
-0.2321147174,
0.4046593308,
-0.3000105321,
-0.6572136879,
-0.2877947688,
0.1297326982,
-0.1760771126,
0.5177207589,
0.4866820872,
0.091781795,
-0.1214907318,
-0.0013089463,
0.01413312,
0.0313494802,
0.0249279272,
-0.0608742349,
0.4646677971,
-0.0940596387,
-0.1185852885,
-0.5895598531,
0.1928913295,
0.7950579524,
0.0819062069,
0.4222312272,
0.1344665438,
0.0230401438,
-0.1382572502,
0.0746620223,
0.2811354101,
-0.5428829789,
0.61377877,
-0.4187176824,
-0.3901171684,
0.2127150446,
-0.4713189006,
0.3933587968,
0.2547914982,
0.748416245,
-0.52094239,
0.7315467,
0.9632928967,
-0.0611518733,
0.6654807925,
0.1097551882,
0.032224685,
-0.6003749371,
-0.3179580867,
-0.0866279975,
-0.2876954377,
-0.796789825,
-0.4489963055,
0.4585051239,
-0.4857123196,
-0.4060910344,
0.1237765476,
-0.1444461495,
0.9602899551,
0.4826895297,
0.0028280863,
0.2865058482,
-0.189408049,
0.393537432,
0.3348659277,
-0.4625439346,
-0.0956280008,
1.0596935749,
0.16556108,
0.6070077419,
0.3522385061,
0.5240629911,
0.3120133877,
0.2367569655,
-1.0079933405,
0.6519005299,
0.0927491114,
-0.4366874397,
-0.408046335,
-0.4222618937,
-1.1009119749,
0.2443119586,
-0.2974672318,
-0.5482417941,
0.2433405519,
-0.0671982095,
-0.6331023574,
0.4066455662,
-0.2487024218,
0.7306063175,
-0.6831154227,
-0.1111699268,
-0.1056721061,
-0.4162796438,
0.1440054029,
-0.2257582247,
0.6084266305,
-0.5336859226,
-0.0886886343,
0.451449126,
-0.0954194441,
0.7773708105,
-0.3335115016,
-0.5028520823,
0.0967320651,
0.3762260675,
0.5001219511,
-0.3038644791,
0.1089967862,
0.2644066215,
-0.2720071971,
-0.2529964447,
-0.4814359546,
0.8369567394,
-0.6970848441,
-0.4735997021,
-0.5551545024,
-0.9560639262,
-0.0121244732,
0.1962069124,
-0.2501389682,
0.0394207127,
-0.4054784477,
-0.1027939767,
0.50670892,
-0.3392731845,
0.5947312117,
0.6898254752,
-0.5946810842,
0.0687503964,
1.1526321173,
0.0221283194,
0.3307118416,
0.2751613557,
0.1171116829,
-0.3651189804,
-0.6582189798,
-0.5725722313,
-0.0021150897,
-0.9164349437,
0.064043723,
-0.153330043,
0.075263992,
-0.2912365794,
-0.5797653794,
-0.3939081132,
-0.6355788708,
-0.0987875909,
-0.1475210339,
0.4617944658,
0.9786780477,
-0.3889801204,
0.8015143275,
-0.0525293276,
0.2918643653,
0.5244444609,
0.1227760762,
-0.2469159365,
-0.4967353642,
0.0503546633,
-0.1624751389,
-0.314237535,
-0.5559390783,
0.5190021396,
0.3741157055,
0.3708205521,
0.2709218562,
0.0206265561,
0.8925414085,
-0.6082299352,
0.4442393482,
0.0333688483,
-0.6941080093,
0.4154410064,
-0.3583949804,
0.4724453986,
0.5858950019,
0.0720922127,
-0.5859235525,
-0.1282508671,
0.0094130076,
-1.0725297928,
0.1396244317,
-0.0037162367,
0.4109365344,
0.3255776167,
0.2629011571,
-0.003497561,
0.022920128,
-0.7780041695,
-0.0161725376,
-0.0289965086,
-0.1954897493,
-0.1129890382,
0.1232776567,
-0.1327513903,
-0.4357754588,
0.6129214168,
-0.1766068041,
0.1391356438,
0.0470863208,
-0.2138640434,
-0.008369972,
0.2897484004,
0.8972935677,
0.7053500414,
-0.0965559781,
-0.1426021159,
0.3588296473,
-0.3255663216,
0.3103012443,
-0.2591755688,
-0.4170218408,
-0.1534171551,
-0.0304000191,
0.6941708922,
0.32119295,
-0.936506927,
0.3629536629,
-0.0125373853,
-0.3047472239,
-0.6515219212,
0.4978475273,
-0.3461315334,
0.2171379328,
0.1542201042,
0.2120995671,
-0.093341969,
-0.855670929,
-0.0636300147,
0.177690044,
-0.5284450054,
-0.28362903,
0.9610289335,
0.3902858496,
-0.3465537131,
0.3249120712,
-0.3749111891,
-0.2659395635,
0.5689121485,
0.5054149032,
0.8768189549,
-0.1321140379,
0.1480246037,
0.1046144813,
0.2556884587,
-0.1658251584,
0.4607642293,
-0.0253544133,
-0.7603017688,
-0.7064434886,
-0.396472007,
-0.7037075758,
-0.2963139415,
-0.3967906237,
0.0316161178,
-0.7474677563,
0.4483807385,
0.0074858582,
-0.410654664,
-0.7280395031,
0.1404702961,
0.0985098779,
0.864272356,
-0.8606315255,
1.0418258905,
0.7922050953,
-0.2120703757,
-0.1676538438,
0.2407290488,
0.3084803522,
-1.1148602962,
0.161525473,
0.0118744262,
-0.2243505865,
0.0200024676,
-0.6738992929,
-0.8902968168,
1.207447052,
0.3263937533,
-0.9746516347,
0.0148193464,
0.2782766223,
0.1997647732,
-0.3509004414,
-0.1247498468,
1.0120407343,
0.5186526179,
0.2493032962,
-1.0125221014,
-0.0119776335,
0.3647853732,
-0.1493281722,
0.099252142,
-0.4539569914,
0.455501914,
-0.3704537451,
0.0273894928,
0.1379827857,
0.5349814892,
0.2093319446,
0.1818258613,
0.6322435141,
0.3663904965,
0.9653038383,
-0.0902099982,
1.3211299181,
0.0118594961,
-0.0239632111,
1.2169332504,
-0.6961350441,
0.7250552177,
0.3789779544,
-0.0329583474,
0.6913187504,
0.3144730031,
0.0229715519,
0.9584919214,
-0.0954436362,
-0.3856970668,
-0.4379276931,
-0.322463274,
0.0749428123,
0.7688214183,
0.2737149298,
0.2186687142,
-0.3378485441,
0.3087798953,
0.0728983209,
-0.0698400438,
-0.7192692757,
0.9327166677,
-0.2221006006,
-0.4340015352,
0.2661353648,
0.106789276,
0.4504378736,
-0.4682323635,
-0.0426922217,
-0.2237842828,
0.2549650669,
-0.0802658945,
-1.0145031214,
0.4774624705,
-0.0758345574,
0.058325626,
-0.2557410598,
0.1912724674,
-0.0611208975,
-0.5641707778,
0.0419096015,
0.2516000271,
0.4334545732,
-0.0614216849,
-0.410069555,
0.2612282932,
0.2214608938,
0.1347859353,
0.3623316586,
0.3832838535,
-0.1950985938,
0.938863337,
0.7176129818,
0.2614593804,
-0.048871018,
-0.1544712335,
0.8146229386,
-0.9777598977,
-0.6320567727,
-0.8255104423,
0.5672379732,
0.1709867865,
-0.5304660201,
0.7616381645,
0.3498474658,
0.6976929307,
0.3775958121,
1.0013144016,
0.04384204,
0.0248684678,
-0.5590898991,
0.2924118638,
-0.804069221,
0.2905706167,
0.0482192151,
-0.8762733936,
-0.5829382539,
1.0513386726,
-0.4314931631,
-0.4432120919,
-0.0233978685,
0.7099220157,
-0.3511269391,
-0.3613230586,
0.5315676332,
0.4786280096,
0.6282420754,
0.56518507,
0.6034038663,
-0.3486092091,
0.5587759018,
-0.0412956178,
-0.0308452044,
-0.2800071239,
-1.0087919235,
-0.3654600084,
-0.3541538417,
-0.2837396562,
-0.0551592931,
0.1706454754,
0.9144971371,
0.8764380217,
-0.7366855741,
-0.3105345666,
-0.4513944983,
0.3434246778,
-0.1449225694,
-0.1187467873,
-0.0284105819,
0.084836781,
-0.7583765984,
1.0810598135,
0.2685032785,
0.46863994,
-0.3806930184,
-0.4484746754,
0.0886774808,
0.1403829455,
0.4290022254,
0.6321584582,
-0.4696808457,
-0.1230295002,
-0.4436950982,
0.2812878489,
0.1844144762,
0.6471249461,
-0.6804141402,
0.535783112,
0.0660533458,
0.2456227094,
0.403088212,
-0.1335271746,
0.8876562715,
-0.5645709634,
0.5331701636,
0.0887750909,
0.4677159488,
0.232703656,
-0.0553437136,
0.478847146,
-0.2354544401,
-0.860911727,
-0.7528044581,
0.4937340319,
-0.9263032079,
-0.4461303949,
1.2735387087,
0.2254186571,
-0.5215663314,
-0.4040526152,
-0.2595749199,
-0.2565122843,
-0.4912562668,
0.8194755316,
-0.0316521153,
0.1231407076,
-0.2253562808,
-1.0303982496,
0.2526803315,
-0.0185317863,
-1.0439777374,
0.1628161669,
0.5997295976,
0.308879137,
-0.2574732006,
0.5525986552,
0.4021085799,
0.4325541854,
-0.2378192246,
0.0507990047,
0.0408053063,
-0.5407027006,
-0.6699290872,
-0.2709296644,
0.0031746281,
-0.1448401958
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05930v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05930v1
|
WebLINX: Real-World Website Navigation with Multi-Turn Dialogue
| 2024-02-08T18:58:02 | 2024-02-08T18:58:02 |
Xing Han Lù, Zdeněk Kasner, Siva Reddy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
We propose the problem of conversational web navigation, where a digital
agent controls a web browser and follows user instructions to solve real-world
tasks in a multi-turn dialogue fashion. To support this problem, we introduce
WEBLINX - a large-scale benchmark of 100K interactions across 2300 expert
demonstrations of conversational web navigation. Our benchmark covers a broad
range of patterns on over 150 real-world websites and can be used to train and
evaluate agents in diverse scenarios. Due to the magnitude of information
present, Large Language Models (LLMs) cannot process entire web pages in
real-time. To solve this bottleneck, we design a retrieval-inspired model that
efficiently prunes HTML pages by ranking relevant elements. We use the selected
elements, along with screenshots and action history, to assess a variety of
models for their ability to replicate human behavior when navigating the web.
Our experiments span from small text-only to proprietary multimodal LLMs. We
find that smaller finetuned decoders surpass the best zero-shot LLMs (including
GPT-4V), but also larger finetuned multimodal models which were explicitly
pretrained on screenshots. However, all finetuned models struggle to generalize
to unseen websites. Our findings highlight the need for large multimodal models
that can generalize to novel settings. Our code, data and models are available
for research: https://mcgill-nlp.github.io/weblinx
|
[
-0.5145231485,
-0.7279604077,
0.6757488251,
0.0926103368,
-0.1237734258,
0.0769254342,
-0.2914300561,
-0.5490567088,
-0.0437256135,
0.1703249663,
-0.7439492345,
-0.441583395,
-0.2126872391,
-0.0359506123,
-0.6423360109,
0.6107521653,
0.339297682,
0.1271434575,
-0.2539018691,
0.0658347532,
0.1103184372,
-0.5161015391,
-0.7256140113,
-0.2645826638,
0.6858337522,
0.2744390965,
0.69899863,
0.3378174603,
0.4892778695,
0.3135376573,
0.0477838516,
0.2511465549,
-0.7009584308,
0.1215238348,
-0.2063297182,
-0.3929343522,
-0.4360976815,
0.0292404182,
0.4315240383,
0.6276289225,
-0.2841930985,
-0.0389891416,
-0.0343962163,
0.2763153613,
-0.6283942461,
-0.0541795939,
-0.3124936819,
-0.0672263578,
0.2299963087,
-0.1198725551,
-0.5831493139,
-0.4396995604,
0.3656754792,
-0.9217562079,
0.1809478551,
0.0189995635,
0.7498574853,
-0.0153398598,
-0.6311728954,
-0.037795309,
-0.8074497581,
0.854160428,
-0.7489891648,
0.9050888419,
0.3227756917,
0.3245982826,
-0.1333295703,
-0.9095000625,
-0.7553707957,
-0.2079482824,
0.1844172031,
0.0964612141,
-0.3804495037,
0.1057400852,
0.205739364,
-0.176863879,
-0.8127037883,
0.0680075437,
-0.049475532,
-0.3158253133,
0.3902442455,
0.1460467577,
0.3104029298,
0.1236795783,
-0.3338220417,
-0.5168967843,
-0.4467394948,
0.0909513384,
0.173229605,
0.3658207357,
-0.0341621265,
0.1252979636,
-0.4199024439,
0.832444787,
-0.010644,
-0.2967948914,
0.1195901483,
-0.4498652518,
0.1413870752,
-0.3039016724,
0.5522034764,
0.9434383512,
0.4332765043,
-0.2090439945,
-0.2746807039,
0.1645119488,
0.5682733655,
-0.7659661174,
-0.1864720732,
0.2875624001,
-0.4484087527,
0.0008994858,
0.2266905606,
-0.8207640648,
-0.349722147,
-0.3498601615,
0.3957605958,
-0.3269295692,
-0.3736660182,
0.131049782,
-0.2770688832,
0.4897296727,
0.5724726915,
-0.5236162543,
0.3996041715,
0.7108387947,
0.6472272277,
-0.299143523,
-0.2731097341,
-0.7476648688,
-0.05231167,
-0.1618974954,
0.7430294752,
-0.7721562982,
-0.2862528861,
0.3987420201,
-0.014750557,
0.1199615225,
-0.3793919384,
0.349408567,
-0.5497983098,
-0.0933013633,
0.0455605686,
-0.2593865097,
-0.3204326034,
0.6808065772,
-0.6511192918,
0.4019721448,
-0.4018004835,
-0.1841823459,
0.0112657342,
-0.4293051362,
-0.4333321452,
-0.0784348622,
0.1462770551,
-0.1558738351,
-0.0384961702,
0.0514115319,
0.3402949572,
-0.2053165436,
-0.0655802339,
-0.3211592436,
-0.2646866143,
0.439142704,
-0.5754309893,
0.1791613698,
0.2264483124,
-0.2294642776,
-0.0671802834,
-0.7090811729,
0.3046578765,
0.0295175854,
-0.5428624749,
-0.3055124283,
0.0901511014,
0.4007216692,
0.2881643176,
0.1963581145,
-0.5121552348,
0.4057524204,
0.0374494642,
0.3834712505,
0.5225716233,
-0.035803318,
0.3913088143,
-0.3773466945,
0.5576656461,
-0.1033256426,
0.4660277367,
-0.3282801807,
-0.4753510356,
-1.0584175587,
0.2205573022,
0.2404367328,
0.4357051551,
-0.7614061832,
-0.3102309108,
-0.5251022577,
-0.3879407644,
-0.1913630813,
-0.0571932644,
0.7068296671,
-0.0018606377,
0.5596761107,
-0.2991730273,
-0.182547316,
-0.7772352695,
-0.2379387319,
-0.0801129639,
-0.1665406376,
0.3477793336,
0.2082087845,
-0.5576679707,
0.7297219634,
-0.5720126033,
-0.0576328337,
-0.1981058866,
0.5017549992,
-0.2355145663,
0.3123131394,
0.0001059294,
-1.0885550976,
-0.4983618259,
-0.0071549453,
-0.6308016777,
0.0428108908,
-0.3427999318,
0.0678365007,
0.028293509,
0.4730244279,
-0.6299497485,
0.2242194116,
0.4619722664,
-0.1361975372,
0.3972975612,
-0.0494992994,
0.2125260085,
-0.7322209477,
-0.0354075506,
0.5513373613,
-0.5741456747,
-0.8132132888,
0.5874853134,
0.22011967,
-0.1901583672,
-0.5916827917,
0.5816251636,
-0.4602261186,
-0.1006718576,
-0.0482933,
0.514002502,
0.0884578377,
0.7664567828,
-0.0444424003,
0.7901466489,
0.04463882,
-0.9121900201,
0.4711358249,
0.2651676238,
0.0336669795,
0.6272895932,
-0.2817677259,
0.2284876257,
0.1256424487,
0.3849255443,
-0.8785922527,
-0.0843010619,
-0.2485515624,
-0.4184243083,
0.0283659101,
-0.2170701772,
-0.3311339021,
-0.261905998,
-0.3731057048,
0.1943681985,
0.3579421341,
-0.4063649774,
0.6328610182,
0.2797708511,
-0.2159838378,
-0.2545757294,
-0.4174001813,
0.4305607677,
0.0585723408,
-0.586119771,
0.4322840869,
-0.3605521917,
-0.5742177963,
-0.385591656,
-0.0984511822,
-0.2814171314,
-0.013226252,
0.0432372689,
0.0144653479,
-0.0861815587,
0.0975182876,
-0.2991400957,
-0.0957901329,
-0.0483308621,
-0.4750618935,
0.6914663315,
-0.2143952399,
-0.5451714396,
-0.7687847018,
0.4515348971,
0.6160425544,
-0.1190526411,
0.0817882493,
0.4867818654,
-0.2220323831,
0.0339818969,
-0.7836464047,
-0.482114017,
-0.4899538159,
0.1824213117,
-0.3587955832,
-0.6124943495,
0.4313291013,
-0.4310932755,
0.2087095976,
0.060964603,
0.1759264022,
-0.3869419992,
1.2244906425,
0.6331506371,
0.1569916457,
0.491972506,
-0.3671212196,
-0.0160135292,
-0.5063368678,
-0.1887179613,
-0.3558042049,
-0.4801376164,
-0.6409081817,
-0.3694726229,
0.48825863,
-0.163910985,
0.0306622609,
0.3285215497,
-0.174248144,
0.3071036041,
0.8113514185,
0.2658221424,
0.5508065224,
-0.0145185646,
-0.4385150075,
0.1420376003,
-0.6356936693,
-0.4172652364,
1.0287637711,
0.0589133613,
1.088095665,
0.5020338893,
0.4716699123,
0.5432753563,
-0.1146988273,
-0.7923441529,
0.8235332966,
-0.061214149,
-0.4922301769,
-0.4033154249,
-0.2395125628,
-1.1874917746,
0.2770867944,
-0.31907776,
-0.5373107195,
0.069377616,
0.2368820906,
-0.546982348,
0.1445095092,
-0.6954420209,
0.7717288733,
-0.2678243518,
-0.8501293659,
-0.7275471091,
-0.6186219454,
-0.0646878779,
0.3048422039,
0.3325307071,
0.2337960154,
0.1153900176,
0.2732384205,
-0.1925242394,
0.9336314797,
-0.0758041143,
-0.0788615793,
0.103866294,
0.3146899641,
0.6563763618,
-0.1906268001,
0.320466131,
-0.0101184584,
-0.0189952031,
-0.2879676223,
-0.5726667643,
0.8465783,
-0.7320055366,
-0.5599700212,
-0.4579883814,
0.0035240657,
-0.5058238506,
0.05769898,
-0.0993253514,
0.9934651852,
-0.3615630269,
0.2728529274,
0.7985670567,
-0.1142202318,
0.8284243345,
0.7434975505,
-0.3611277044,
-0.0610749647,
1.1775656939,
-0.1341252774,
0.3681223094,
0.6294255853,
-0.0082961256,
-0.4044755101,
-0.5013727546,
-0.5461760163,
0.0911454409,
-0.7403507829,
-0.1418437064,
-0.5148893595,
-0.1605096906,
-0.2277285606,
-0.0524278022,
-0.343164742,
-0.5100836754,
-0.2866437137,
0.0807285383,
0.0130788758,
0.8313427567,
0.0141842123,
0.3550776541,
-0.966175437,
0.3829085529,
0.8384456038,
0.338367939,
0.2105364799,
-0.2668270171,
-0.2338487655,
0.1830887496,
-0.5299993157,
-0.598228693,
0.4322866499,
0.1000954062,
0.7570531964,
0.5737573504,
0.0465484783,
0.6929754019,
-0.4861036241,
0.7341852784,
0.3301050663,
-0.6320607066,
0.2651524544,
-0.5877748728,
0.7219805717,
0.3885555863,
0.6542326212,
-0.8963580132,
-0.1222146749,
-0.3464949727,
-0.6312556267,
0.4184523821,
0.0477136187,
0.1070329174,
0.0822332799,
0.2135117799,
-0.1277028769,
0.1088263169,
-0.6963088512,
0.0961505622,
-0.305367589,
-0.0811286345,
0.0200818013,
-0.255854696,
-0.1259920299,
0.0705884248,
0.5241596103,
-0.4357678592,
0.2578303516,
0.1628865004,
-0.6465133429,
0.0585855469,
0.3202856481,
0.876721561,
0.9532153606,
-0.159845978,
0.3234011233,
0.054459475,
-0.4907949567,
0.1180928126,
0.0953785479,
-0.0999577194,
-0.2444331199,
0.2837956846,
0.5455322862,
0.5047638416,
-0.8959476352,
0.4582138658,
-0.32324633,
0.0666816458,
-0.3889326751,
0.076043956,
0.0754902512,
0.406372726,
0.7834919691,
-0.2399049252,
0.3401576579,
-0.7182615399,
0.2903694808,
0.495745331,
-0.5439507961,
-0.4477607608,
0.5199463964,
0.834751606,
-0.7212622762,
0.6877556443,
-0.297010392,
-0.4139186442,
0.2497482747,
0.3254894912,
0.7807232141,
-0.0891473889,
0.3239810765,
0.3916924298,
0.0764947385,
-0.151443243,
0.08364328,
0.0104447864,
-0.620292902,
-0.3526909351,
-0.5648159385,
-0.7254245877,
0.0417175926,
-0.5757918358,
-0.0730305314,
-0.4115783572,
-0.4715809524,
-0.0419881307,
-0.0955334306,
-0.5497250557,
0.254919678,
0.341455996,
0.7066779137,
-0.3673044443,
0.6792751551,
0.5623649955,
-0.3266108036,
-0.1773283929,
0.2441710979,
0.3593920469,
-0.4834921956,
0.3461423516,
0.2573370934,
-0.4687445164,
0.3004145324,
-0.5843753815,
-0.562826097,
0.9673184752,
-0.109927766,
-0.9184301496,
-0.1722034812,
0.1277842373,
0.3810126185,
-0.0791574791,
0.3845373094,
0.2483183444,
0.4532616138,
-0.0822146907,
-1.2106543779,
-0.1684737206,
-0.2526242733,
-0.1336189061,
0.0220516082,
-0.9046976566,
0.8161637187,
0.012946832,
-0.0930877253,
0.0168045927,
0.1462066919,
-0.0208494477,
0.1691452563,
0.6895727515,
0.5424131751,
0.4907515645,
-0.0558239967,
0.9181604981,
-0.2843552232,
0.1496908516,
0.7998963594,
-0.1747129261,
1.1112823486,
0.4188444614,
-0.1196229756,
0.5785278082,
0.3688711226,
0.3280685544,
0.4605936408,
0.038083408,
-0.4590422511,
-0.7845070958,
-0.1492520571,
-0.0225058533,
0.5904934406,
0.3015785217,
0.1100293472,
-0.3291525245,
0.1723870188,
-0.0009029902,
0.2765489817,
-0.2765448391,
1.0399110317,
0.0347983129,
-0.8640471697,
0.6195195317,
0.1281310767,
0.6883603334,
-0.8656902313,
-0.2840557396,
-0.4568763971,
0.3277927637,
0.0822614655,
-0.5720542669,
-0.2943218946,
-0.0646248385,
-0.0898471177,
-0.4609930813,
0.5418253541,
-0.2168708146,
-0.3007351458,
0.3862045109,
0.5686593056,
0.1603260189,
-0.2680536211,
-0.5118515491,
0.2685020566,
0.1948382854,
-0.2462966144,
0.6020130515,
0.0256429352,
-0.1672258824,
1.2351455688,
0.8219638467,
-0.4018259048,
0.253128916,
0.133033514,
0.931509614,
-0.8873859048,
-0.4185381234,
-0.5726305842,
0.3429678977,
-0.2437263876,
-0.2222376019,
0.6059576869,
0.7194701433,
0.7263063192,
0.1008915156,
0.8166460991,
0.4615690708,
0.30203107,
-0.5890873671,
0.551594913,
-0.5594545603,
-0.1442524344,
-0.1125709414,
-0.8996078968,
-0.0945944786,
0.755386889,
0.1705123186,
-0.095766075,
0.4923473299,
0.7332494855,
-0.2522802353,
-0.0045706918,
0.5720894337,
0.1856371015,
0.4624432027,
0.4738666117,
0.8567512631,
-0.1665517986,
1.0646929741,
-0.0077264742,
-0.1823778301,
-0.6452342868,
-0.7472445369,
-0.6080231667,
-0.6200854182,
-0.115698792,
-0.177435264,
0.3263922036,
1.0217853785,
1.064109683,
-0.6358605027,
-0.5205889344,
0.0835661814,
-0.0593377873,
-0.3048800528,
-0.1525985748,
-0.3425534666,
-0.2714815438,
-0.9739668369,
0.5125229359,
0.1482186019,
0.1585139185,
-0.6168559194,
-0.1332291812,
-0.7374736071,
0.1458508372,
0.6877891421,
0.3037611842,
-0.8813457489,
-0.3520013988,
0.3104307652,
-0.1887815893,
0.1118270159,
0.7411983609,
-0.8579284549,
0.6803439856,
0.3201482594,
0.4194477797,
1.0005860329,
0.1687151194,
0.6452255249,
-0.5369080305,
-0.0043775751,
0.1974137127,
0.1053316593,
0.4513535202,
0.1329619586,
0.4553290606,
0.2061342895,
-0.3033775091,
-0.4730418026,
0.2617568374,
-1.0153294802,
-0.5007175803,
1.3223487139,
-0.1747446209,
0.1064679623,
-0.2514514625,
-0.0231011622,
0.0034737911,
-0.5811483264,
0.658428669,
0.6828863025,
-0.1234306097,
-0.3454128206,
-0.8199118972,
0.359706074,
0.0033731414,
-0.6147209406,
-0.0033030289,
0.7862529159,
0.1419297904,
0.435530901,
0.4182348549,
0.5720613003,
0.2682149112,
0.0502220392,
0.1967692375,
0.0384503491,
-0.5767551064,
-0.1387131512,
0.1253445596,
-0.06354893,
-0.0579144806
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05926v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05926v3
|
On the Convergence of Zeroth-Order Federated Tuning for Large Language Models
| 2024-02-08T18:56:40 | 2024-06-17T16:00:59 |
Zhenqing Ling, Daoyuan Chen, Liuyi Yao, Yaliang Li, Ying Shen
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
The confluence of Federated Learning (FL) and Large Language Models (LLMs) is
ushering in a new era in privacy-preserving natural language processing.
However, the intensive memory requirements for fine-tuning LLMs pose
significant challenges, especially when deploying on clients with limited
computational resources. To circumvent this, we explore the novel integration
of Memory-efficient Zeroth-Order Optimization within a federated setting, a
synergy we term as FedMeZO. Our study is the first to examine the theoretical
underpinnings of FedMeZO in the context of LLMs, tackling key questions
regarding the influence of large parameter spaces on optimization behavior, the
establishment of convergence properties, and the identification of critical
parameters for convergence to inform personalized federated strategies. Our
extensive empirical evidence supports the theory, showing that FedMeZO not only
converges faster than traditional first-order methods such as FedAvg but also
significantly reduces GPU memory usage during training to levels comparable to
those during inference. Moreover, the proposed personalized FL strategy that is
built upon the theoretical insights to customize the client-wise learning rate
can effectively accelerate loss reduction. We hope our work can help to bridge
theoretical and practical aspects of federated fine-tuning for LLMs, thereby
stimulating further advancements and research in this area.
|
[
-0.7232849598,
-0.7636546493,
0.5985331535,
0.1533149928,
-0.0571421385,
0.0244224574,
-0.6947851777,
-0.3800207376,
0.0553012639,
0.6212149858,
-0.7924300432,
-0.6227301359,
-0.2814439237,
0.062836647,
-0.1045887545,
0.9341461658,
0.1940934211,
0.0726277381,
-0.1935333014,
-0.4913780987,
-0.2019321918,
-0.2457075417,
-0.4406889677,
-0.4105383754,
0.6333682537,
0.5284970999,
0.646741569,
0.8443197608,
0.3335843682,
0.3535546362,
0.2130620629,
0.1243524924,
-0.8455969691,
0.2292318195,
-0.3769313693,
-0.6067687869,
-0.4662807584,
0.1036319956,
0.7184557319,
0.8748574257,
-0.5347308517,
0.1598494202,
-0.2505456805,
0.5637910366,
-0.9443676472,
0.1076980382,
-0.4235916734,
0.3084510565,
-0.2350296229,
-0.4568791986,
-0.563765645,
-0.3892798126,
0.0914785415,
-0.4300836325,
0.3574826419,
0.0804425403,
0.5875657201,
0.1297133267,
0.1334190071,
0.1271758527,
-0.9478773475,
0.8362022638,
-0.8559175134,
0.586578548,
0.0317419693,
0.352520287,
-0.2578840852,
-0.4234465361,
-0.5213952065,
0.2874649763,
0.1043868512,
-0.1150718927,
-0.3257049024,
0.3786138296,
0.1342865527,
0.6265198588,
-0.3304854333,
0.536272347,
0.024839744,
-0.1682197005,
0.6647993326,
0.3569771051,
0.0059725377,
0.6088525653,
-0.4568484724,
-0.1031069756,
-0.5180994272,
-0.0352386124,
0.355571717,
0.59378618,
-0.0376484469,
0.1400546432,
-0.5869632363,
0.6959874034,
0.3201039732,
-0.3942604065,
0.2407045066,
-0.0913614258,
-0.4013059437,
0.1081081256,
0.9133788943,
0.1521571577,
0.1340220273,
-0.6264398694,
-0.2588612139,
-0.1474738717,
0.1707654446,
-1.0521560907,
0.1357199997,
0.1106397361,
-0.1134920344,
-0.2708150744,
0.0468045436,
-0.7673683763,
-0.1388207525,
-0.2206209749,
0.2754212022,
-0.2396195829,
-0.1208168194,
0.2249896675,
0.2198781669,
0.2327439636,
0.3166445494,
-1.2761240005,
0.6812336445,
1.2137116194,
0.7908228636,
0.2044298202,
-0.5297546387,
-0.8190173507,
-0.0004790741,
-0.1950381398,
0.4440325499,
-0.5322332978,
-0.2303555608,
0.0804754868,
0.0031662863,
-0.1406405866,
-0.2555771172,
0.2012298107,
-0.7773038149,
0.4624934196,
-0.3164953589,
-0.7653616667,
-0.3349592686,
0.1513518989,
-0.3189035058,
0.2447214723,
0.1721010506,
-0.5269780159,
0.1333722621,
-0.4238116443,
-0.5020396113,
0.2135188878,
-0.2380230278,
-0.5297637582,
0.3747448921,
-0.1604992002,
0.6898847222,
-0.4564657509,
0.0617204159,
-0.6976753473,
-0.5526050329,
-0.0905962288,
-0.0463260859,
0.6247450709,
0.238257587,
-0.5878250003,
-0.01474432,
-0.5462386608,
0.2915146351,
0.2121652365,
-0.1521755755,
-0.4198037982,
-0.0474404916,
-0.2884940803,
-0.1394224018,
0.2821364105,
-0.7377012968,
0.1038049087,
-0.8208636642,
0.5426231027,
0.6999183893,
-0.1319296658,
0.7291432619,
-0.1289478242,
0.4444102943,
-0.3004431427,
0.302223146,
-0.178059876,
-0.2163106799,
-0.5084939599,
-0.149232775,
0.094921574,
0.267965585,
-0.2575986385,
0.3764282763,
-0.4360472858,
-0.3059293628,
-0.2645803094,
0.2920025885,
0.5033838749,
0.4823000729,
0.0913430974,
-0.260756582,
-0.0393686183,
-0.932569325,
0.0795614794,
0.1915922463,
0.0410111547,
0.5788593292,
0.0239069536,
-0.2041828483,
0.9472011924,
-0.557534337,
-0.2601385117,
-0.0728193298,
-0.1333915442,
0.3205686212,
0.3573195636,
0.848192811,
-0.5062945485,
-0.4322701395,
0.350407064,
-0.411272943,
-0.1080854684,
0.1312274635,
-0.1448431909,
0.2259623408,
0.0034912343,
-0.4982029498,
-0.06624116,
0.6370120645,
-0.3153477907,
0.3278739154,
-0.5226946473,
-0.123627834,
-0.9917557836,
-0.160067305,
-0.2071130574,
-0.2346019745,
-0.7138344646,
0.3681773543,
-0.0805730075,
-0.1395545602,
0.0322022922,
0.3846278191,
-0.4969888926,
-0.2133944035,
-0.4879307747,
0.1199075505,
-0.0746429339,
0.6193447709,
-0.4345355332,
0.7450605631,
0.3825361431,
-0.3672077656,
0.2249200344,
0.2548164129,
0.0770759284,
0.6095020771,
-0.3443598449,
0.1691650897,
0.0691808611,
-0.0478367321,
-0.6700063348,
-0.1911915243,
0.1604981869,
-0.2179846913,
0.5160769224,
0.1903064996,
-0.6955928206,
-0.1696667075,
-0.3117999136,
0.2244706303,
0.3600133061,
-0.7049541473,
0.3908160627,
0.29721573,
0.1409551352,
-0.6070728898,
-0.5462459922,
-0.060363166,
-0.1236738786,
-0.638325572,
0.3273558915,
-0.0100501319,
-0.187195152,
-0.0760298595,
-0.0377225652,
0.0361449122,
0.3736984134,
0.2000678778,
-0.0504779816,
-0.6171613336,
-0.006728536,
0.2054239661,
-0.0795083642,
0.0082438169,
-0.528082788,
0.6600055099,
-0.5356379747,
-0.0727155954,
-0.3514818549,
0.319974333,
0.6101115942,
-0.3509214818,
1.1171909571,
0.7188352942,
-0.0861577913,
-0.6680889726,
-0.8440832496,
-0.2679346502,
-0.5469226837,
0.0297513902,
-0.1047363579,
-1.4093834162,
0.6920319796,
-0.0754197165,
0.2961986363,
0.082048066,
0.7286691666,
0.1805353016,
0.6235353947,
0.9791798592,
-0.4974377453,
0.5887590051,
-0.2640545368,
0.3588549793,
-0.5023167729,
0.0075762798,
-0.2821691632,
-0.5180338621,
-0.8008885384,
-0.2417343706,
0.0592551455,
-0.1767704487,
-0.3026926816,
0.2820062935,
-0.2213012874,
0.7259111404,
0.4822035432,
0.1232899576,
0.2934787571,
0.0848919079,
-0.0821164697,
0.1953994334,
-0.8652175665,
0.1897397488,
0.7164332867,
0.2681597173,
0.5793161392,
0.1104953736,
1.0114920139,
0.1315517426,
0.3376090825,
-0.5878110528,
0.5987583995,
-0.2330236286,
-0.4404629767,
-0.3554083705,
-0.6110776663,
-0.7361639738,
0.4025054276,
-0.13517344,
-0.8182897568,
0.3479255438,
0.0181478132,
-0.6758384109,
0.338527143,
-0.648308754,
0.7278681397,
-0.0802000985,
-0.804870069,
-0.4982965291,
-0.7328073382,
0.4814402759,
0.1212026775,
-0.0137419999,
-0.2732931972,
-0.1405955553,
0.3310273588,
-0.7665758729,
0.7198116779,
-0.376098305,
-0.0950266495,
-0.1872192323,
-0.0956004038,
0.3848443329,
-0.0036139539,
-0.0758567005,
0.3082365394,
-0.2875550985,
-0.4200541973,
-0.6966167688,
1.1539480686,
-0.7083711028,
-0.6619622707,
0.0087035578,
-0.5242342949,
-0.4464014769,
0.5200167894,
-0.0188923795,
0.4193206131,
-0.1334338784,
0.2351201177,
0.8507597446,
-0.1766075045,
0.4823100269,
0.9628604054,
-0.0108228065,
-0.6743100882,
0.8853514791,
-0.0052724574,
0.2772682607,
0.4154167473,
0.3718206286,
0.0526447967,
-0.7020808458,
-0.2639532387,
0.6520030499,
-0.4001361132,
-0.3639831841,
-0.3964959085,
-0.0907022879,
-0.1828737706,
-0.4287063181,
-0.5926809311,
-0.0364617817,
-0.4045398831,
0.0427221321,
0.3681757152,
0.0686850399,
0.0724382773,
0.5424813628,
-0.6883659363,
-0.1474820375,
-0.0180027541,
0.9311316609,
0.1961963326,
-0.1309974641,
-0.4697722793,
-0.0830508918,
-0.0153534673,
-0.5444045663,
0.2449973673,
0.4508924484,
0.6295806766,
1.03951931,
0.2417610586,
0.756156981,
-0.6988014579,
0.2068645507,
0.1135261655,
-0.636865139,
0.1073651239,
-0.6266874671,
0.3239839673,
0.8695591688,
0.1493881196,
-0.3111521304,
-0.3878877461,
-0.5965083838,
-0.6173117161,
0.933884263,
0.0911848396,
0.3638876975,
0.1241589487,
0.6418121457,
0.1537558287,
0.4716958702,
-0.1390289515,
-0.3693750203,
0.2156769037,
-0.0136519521,
-0.2991991639,
-0.1804912537,
-0.3404850066,
-0.2365581244,
0.3695634902,
-0.2309960872,
0.2275960892,
-0.1483508497,
0.2278243005,
-0.4601793289,
0.2847529948,
0.8293007612,
0.4108192325,
-0.1832973361,
-0.2443408072,
-0.0003018178,
-0.2635901272,
0.0192752797,
0.4066237211,
-0.3996483088,
-0.1360113472,
0.1757878363,
1.0114891529,
0.7522928715,
-0.5156921148,
0.5383709073,
-0.0863690525,
-0.3922463953,
-0.125612542,
0.4523961246,
-0.0297300871,
0.6112453341,
0.1235593706,
-0.0555412769,
0.0096502015,
-0.3924884498,
0.213504687,
0.7785100341,
0.0012862092,
-0.5306829214,
0.7175774574,
0.1706337333,
-0.396289587,
0.4525722563,
0.0654376745,
-0.4443899989,
0.1728301793,
0.477732569,
1.242869854,
-0.2987261713,
0.2224976569,
0.1449442059,
0.0305122938,
-0.2185752243,
-0.0430692434,
-0.8086525798,
-0.7781900764,
-0.2497138828,
-0.8875793219,
-0.5279780626,
-0.0928365961,
-0.7383887768,
-0.060406629,
-1.1024981737,
-0.1762687862,
-0.0138776926,
0.3641816676,
-0.3672910333,
-0.1935125589,
0.391956389,
0.7772805691,
-0.4735422134,
0.7878239155,
0.3015029132,
0.0860509649,
-0.6837268472,
-0.020106636,
-0.0973875597,
-0.7439125776,
0.0939613059,
0.2056302726,
-0.2326404303,
0.1781774759,
-0.3784209788,
-0.7359545231,
1.3386292458,
0.5414121151,
-0.8210498691,
-0.0933117121,
0.1930502802,
0.8192384839,
-0.5370300412,
-0.1209734604,
0.5713829994,
0.1995313317,
0.1574371606,
-0.8366232514,
0.0895431042,
0.0293705296,
0.0586648658,
0.6199997663,
-1.1598905325,
0.7368016839,
-0.445892185,
-0.3612870574,
-0.0664319322,
0.6375976801,
-0.2028499097,
0.4489037097,
0.4658270478,
0.7501953244,
0.6480053067,
0.014795444,
0.9474621415,
-0.4941289425,
0.5995717645,
1.1131706238,
-0.3686583042,
0.7387971282,
0.4047796428,
-0.0992587581,
0.3984919786,
0.2985709608,
-0.043941956,
0.6150400043,
-0.1022091433,
-0.4287629724,
-0.173841089,
0.002485998,
-0.2703901231,
0.3687319756,
0.2109009326,
-0.4892157912,
-0.6070937514,
0.1139364019,
0.1649838537,
0.0504946187,
-0.2114684433,
0.9076514244,
0.0772458985,
-0.438007623,
0.7085937858,
0.1034629792,
0.5390613079,
-0.6224465966,
0.4534319937,
-0.5198534131,
0.6197523475,
-0.1129290834,
-0.2595924139,
0.2389834225,
-0.1912452132,
-0.1447578371,
-0.3879705667,
0.3130589426,
-0.5347139239,
-0.1346056014,
0.4213112295,
0.2839028835,
-0.3007284105,
0.1583143771,
-0.3979505301,
0.0074386531,
-0.1522303671,
-0.3316156864,
0.6408666968,
0.2998312414,
0.2736350298,
0.5674902201,
0.5456975102,
0.0056047845,
-0.0884605423,
-0.0151297571,
0.89757061,
-0.4356840253,
-0.8106662035,
-0.9846508503,
-0.1899086684,
0.0807479322,
-0.0156329423,
1.0660040379,
0.4129406214,
0.9770573974,
-0.0291437712,
0.2656542361,
0.0799838305,
0.1973505616,
-0.3117802739,
0.8677279949,
-0.7231459022,
0.1908409446,
-0.1504556835,
-0.7469078302,
-0.250220865,
0.229591608,
-0.4246253967,
-0.2651193142,
0.2105903774,
0.6967912912,
-0.0828490704,
0.2614092827,
0.5517706275,
0.2607526183,
0.1967315227,
0.6018231511,
0.1679711193,
-0.1702377647,
0.0341686532,
-0.8199235797,
-0.177553311,
-0.510058403,
-0.5095737576,
-0.8693279028,
-0.3282753229,
-0.1319319308,
-0.0183735136,
0.1223802269,
0.9546242952,
0.5786465406,
-0.7616761923,
-0.1773688644,
-0.2360389084,
0.0325311348,
-0.0804743469,
-0.2239141762,
-0.0670409501,
-0.4174096286,
-0.6227245927,
0.3263992071,
0.6651962399,
-0.2028776854,
-0.5993307829,
-0.1661940217,
-0.0090938471,
0.0468567014,
0.4616166949,
0.5373122096,
-0.6532142758,
-0.067550011,
0.0369651653,
-0.070881024,
0.1635700315,
0.8935468793,
-0.5900830626,
0.6186477542,
0.4843719602,
0.9087049961,
0.299783051,
0.2406394333,
0.7843311429,
-0.6866468191,
0.3452799618,
0.260033071,
0.1899888813,
0.1300005466,
-0.5385415554,
0.259293884,
0.4117904305,
-0.5509460568,
-1.0110236406,
-0.0304981563,
-0.9005955458,
-0.0061664823,
0.6850118041,
-0.293615669,
-0.4076482356,
0.5188732743,
0.3531989753,
-0.0436633453,
-0.3062581718,
0.7766190171,
0.5357046127,
-0.1634783447,
-0.3060841262,
-0.3502224088,
0.3024029136,
0.4142432511,
-0.5208605528,
0.2666113079,
0.644862473,
0.3260676265,
0.1490726471,
0.5327984691,
0.2482659519,
0.3296899199,
-0.1453175098,
-0.2967293561,
-0.4434241056,
-0.2646698952,
-0.5541442633,
0.4394901097,
-0.1017736569,
-0.1191852242
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05913v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05913v1
|
Efficient Stagewise Pretraining via Progressive Subnetworks
| 2024-02-08T18:49:09 | 2024-02-08T18:49:09 |
Abhishek Panigrahi, Nikunj Saunshi, Kaifeng Lyu, Sobhan Miryoosefi, Sashank Reddi, Satyen Kale, Sanjiv Kumar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recent developments in large language models have sparked interest in
efficient pretraining methods. A recent effective paradigm is to perform
stage-wise training, where the size of the model is gradually increased over
the course of training (e.g. gradual stacking (Reddi et al., 2023)). While the
resource and wall-time savings are appealing, it has limitations, particularly
the inability to evaluate the full model during earlier stages, and degradation
in model quality due to smaller model capacity in the initial stages. In this
work, we propose an alternative framework, progressive subnetwork training,
that maintains the full model throughout training, but only trains subnetworks
within the model in each step. We focus on a simple instantiation of this
framework, Random Path Training (RaPTr) that only trains a sub-path of layers
in each step, progressively increasing the path lengths in stages. RaPTr
achieves better pre-training loss for BERT and UL2 language models while
requiring 20-33% fewer FLOPs compared to standard training, and is competitive
or better than other efficient training methods. Furthermore, RaPTr shows
better downstream performance on UL2, improving QA tasks and SuperGLUE by 1-5%
compared to standard training and stacking. Finally, we provide a theoretical
basis for RaPTr to justify (a) the increasing complexity of subnetworks in
stages, and (b) the stability in loss across stage transitions due to residual
connections and layer norm.
|
[
-0.0973098427,
-0.4133505821,
0.2150936127,
0.2458992004,
-0.2726976871,
0.1614760458,
-0.0691879988,
-0.2373933792,
-0.0105513791,
0.1686878949,
-0.7703770399,
-0.2824093401,
-0.4242774844,
-0.2872528732,
-0.5944866538,
1.136713624,
-0.1274972707,
0.0905157626,
0.0187731553,
-0.0140688736,
-0.0961738154,
-0.392111063,
-1.2021155357,
-0.712577939,
0.7258650661,
0.294560194,
0.3493299782,
0.3056439459,
0.1821430326,
0.2382465452,
0.0460508652,
-0.1964299381,
-0.7649524212,
0.2638280392,
0.1415532827,
-0.2960268259,
-0.151332587,
0.0242409166,
0.7650870085,
0.7035967708,
-0.5041075349,
0.1294367164,
-0.0339225866,
0.7162573934,
-0.4991343021,
-0.1500257701,
-0.4975063503,
0.4829645455,
-0.3503124416,
0.0149831586,
-0.5108756423,
-0.1824813187,
0.0600586906,
-0.5770285726,
-0.0489569195,
-0.2197184861,
0.8183249235,
-0.0012127524,
-0.0879395679,
0.0539120659,
-0.7951891422,
0.4843491912,
-0.737652719,
0.7427410483,
0.0847559795,
0.339045465,
-0.1114086732,
-1.2153536081,
-0.3945762813,
-0.3880372941,
0.0688044354,
0.3960761726,
-0.3134100437,
0.233689189,
0.2224515826,
0.0946388394,
-0.6126300097,
0.4582189023,
-0.1879561692,
-0.2648480833,
0.0822012201,
-0.1657772064,
0.1554030627,
0.2144366056,
-0.480278343,
-0.2364511788,
-0.810523808,
0.241305694,
0.5101838708,
0.2863663137,
0.0842324495,
0.1717897356,
-0.0437184945,
0.594570756,
0.0442145504,
-0.1767816395,
0.2318568826,
-0.3225787282,
0.0435449593,
-0.210326463,
0.6580614448,
-0.3448961675,
0.5272901654,
-0.3182785213,
-0.2868401706,
-0.2108440399,
0.3247408569,
-0.8507561088,
-0.4490129054,
0.1544062793,
-0.1214366555,
-0.1425269991,
-0.2231121808,
0.0317244753,
-0.0249478277,
-0.0871921554,
0.4222278595,
-0.8376668096,
-0.2235465199,
-0.0517959185,
0.154746905,
0.0850583985,
0.3300592303,
-0.6516206861,
0.3124040663,
0.3797807395,
0.9157611132,
0.1077148244,
-0.3076668978,
-0.8018159866,
-0.0926638171,
-0.59973526,
0.6531338096,
-0.4386651516,
-0.1941841096,
-0.2337364554,
-0.3284718096,
-0.3382207155,
-0.2522913516,
0.3009658456,
-0.8446551561,
0.1784971505,
0.142518416,
-0.1932252795,
0.0415349416,
0.273676008,
-0.4499198794,
1.0661841631,
0.2871131301,
-0.9639816284,
0.3933645785,
-0.4304860532,
-0.7145091295,
-0.0082295341,
-0.3377573192,
-0.4711683691,
-0.0550437942,
0.0776109397,
0.2168262154,
0.2354154289,
0.0208748784,
0.1074521691,
-0.5270323753,
-0.2076079994,
-0.149332419,
0.6910032034,
0.2069684565,
-0.3955628276,
0.2575632632,
-0.7736800909,
0.0890917778,
-0.2447015792,
-0.5590137839,
-0.3773958981,
-0.0327897072,
-0.3217771947,
0.524959147,
0.0337628089,
-0.5287137032,
0.2542704642,
-0.454856962,
0.1898688227,
0.8776103258,
-0.1399461776,
0.4133915007,
-0.0921851769,
0.8813644648,
0.3822516203,
0.3205744326,
-0.0127482461,
-0.2353015244,
-0.9656972885,
-0.1221723184,
0.815359354,
0.5736627579,
-1.1176114082,
0.1916466802,
-0.2707012296,
-0.5168837309,
-0.3749122322,
0.0524448864,
0.6218199134,
0.5554138422,
0.2983698845,
-0.6837903857,
-0.7796804905,
-0.884599328,
0.1776991934,
-0.2202617377,
-0.1017402634,
-0.1131214947,
0.2625230551,
-0.0646191165,
0.9291462898,
-0.02776834,
-0.2254633754,
-0.7332245111,
0.4345814586,
0.4136002362,
0.7436234951,
0.3698250055,
-0.5846226811,
-0.5301389694,
-0.0993724689,
-0.1780935228,
-0.0454948209,
-0.4361328781,
-0.1356494576,
0.0697549582,
0.5421431065,
-0.4174960554,
0.1200056076,
0.7151162624,
0.1332630515,
0.4790391326,
-0.2536148727,
-0.3107222319,
-0.8583748937,
0.0110170245,
-0.0821065158,
-0.2465428859,
-0.7599890828,
-0.1301347464,
-0.1734822392,
-0.0310747623,
-0.5339543223,
0.2515041232,
-0.4239711761,
-0.1930633187,
-0.0009301198,
0.0348091535,
-0.1987076998,
0.5092219114,
0.0701958537,
0.8839733601,
0.50052315,
-0.4692077637,
-0.2145322114,
0.0823855549,
-0.4395904541,
-0.0200637206,
-0.7714639306,
0.313929677,
-0.0745479539,
0.8112834096,
-0.7190522552,
0.2011465579,
0.1934795827,
-0.2998993099,
0.3931784928,
-0.2366888076,
-0.3164111972,
-0.4816645086,
-0.2372536808,
0.3566963971,
0.677737236,
-0.3066363037,
0.6175341606,
0.051974602,
0.1547866017,
-0.7734892964,
-0.6791161299,
-0.101268068,
0.0835736766,
-0.6668524146,
0.2947309315,
0.0280584041,
0.181196183,
-0.1345843524,
-0.4171850681,
0.0704887211,
0.070311375,
0.2008193731,
-0.3382515609,
-0.0793821588,
-0.0440117717,
-0.0183737688,
-0.3456064761,
-0.2564711273,
-0.833047986,
0.8166499138,
-0.0493571274,
-0.2632417083,
-0.223721534,
0.3278388381,
0.2243236601,
-0.2070686668,
0.9653453231,
0.926199019,
-0.1822762489,
-0.5227363706,
-0.202251032,
0.0223017763,
-0.4225433171,
0.5167507529,
-0.4834952652,
-1.0054759979,
0.5494583845,
-0.0117295785,
0.1156417504,
0.2884784043,
0.2915177345,
-0.0719679818,
0.9517971873,
0.9556878209,
0.1991005689,
0.6972003579,
-0.569748342,
0.1866128892,
-0.8404045105,
-0.2991808355,
-0.1978364885,
-0.341632098,
-0.3689888716,
-0.4849655926,
0.5081914067,
0.2433657497,
-0.5435472131,
0.4918689132,
-0.0394722,
0.319414705,
0.8177830577,
0.2014358491,
0.0954489782,
0.0102938535,
-0.6199482083,
0.1293835938,
-1.4049987793,
-0.1807955652,
0.593259871,
0.6012181044,
0.8030432463,
-0.1939670593,
0.9103743434,
0.0471807793,
0.4028005898,
-0.5219292641,
0.536783278,
-0.3643386066,
-0.5048074722,
-0.4795276821,
-0.6903759837,
-0.8009411693,
0.0877460614,
-0.1691292077,
-0.6845911145,
0.3070057333,
0.3390486538,
-0.5362849832,
0.4827981591,
-0.5194039941,
0.734826386,
-0.2341562361,
-0.1851606369,
-0.0696806312,
-0.9889857173,
0.2447825223,
-0.280349493,
0.1306503117,
0.1855520606,
0.2537581623,
0.9737963676,
-0.5579977036,
0.7926343083,
-0.4130829573,
-0.154894799,
0.1799498349,
0.1282869428,
0.6616013646,
-0.1206984743,
-0.0384229161,
0.0466405973,
-0.3092577159,
-0.3964177668,
-0.5379036069,
0.2499417216,
-0.8602284193,
-0.2361069173,
-0.3409798443,
-0.4851332307,
-0.6074046493,
0.2323167324,
0.4451889694,
0.6781629324,
0.0414779484,
0.195734933,
0.6283817887,
-0.226197958,
0.4847689867,
0.2543919981,
-0.1766372323,
-0.1434445679,
0.7068172097,
0.3155841231,
0.4681618512,
0.5562982559,
0.1681436896,
-0.2409032434,
-1.1779454947,
-0.1813739091,
-0.1176452264,
-0.6661494374,
-0.0327266492,
-0.677228272,
-0.5499277115,
-0.2731342018,
0.0813117027,
-0.5165343881,
-0.5586221218,
0.1358969957,
-0.2386819422,
0.0903442129,
0.4918836951,
-0.5046237111,
0.5330222845,
-0.6761351824,
0.0806394443,
0.4992192686,
0.5098887682,
0.2756097019,
-0.6046715975,
-0.5688188672,
-0.0089771058,
-0.0999873579,
-0.256036073,
0.1416174173,
0.4736100137,
0.5845277309,
0.4081557691,
0.0250889361,
0.7823761106,
-0.8725718856,
0.6975998878,
0.5269505382,
-0.7039305568,
0.4545188248,
-0.3555256724,
0.4179308414,
0.8754971623,
0.653803885,
-0.4998831153,
-0.4274434745,
-0.650164485,
-1.2367938757,
0.6649959683,
0.442378521,
0.1585036963,
0.0761774257,
0.1420329362,
0.2132343948,
0.1078320071,
-0.9559078813,
0.0573513135,
-0.3864090741,
-0.018945219,
-0.025680203,
-0.1671621948,
-0.1537884474,
-0.308755964,
0.8526716828,
0.0642175749,
0.227399379,
0.064425841,
-0.1898902208,
-0.0692054257,
0.1866362095,
0.4388114214,
0.9418826103,
-0.2702537477,
0.2944582105,
0.1534428895,
-0.6457939148,
0.3965219259,
-0.0130245546,
-0.231537208,
-0.0527991876,
0.7121238708,
0.9230560064,
0.2431752086,
-0.4463682771,
0.3875448704,
0.0204766169,
-0.2473818958,
-0.2657544911,
0.0903733224,
0.0241399053,
0.3690827191,
0.4915133715,
0.014329901,
-0.2133580297,
-0.4996252656,
0.6117610931,
0.0384411551,
-0.4952170551,
-0.2356378138,
0.5055617094,
0.1049263775,
-0.2517463863,
0.8788970709,
-0.1270191669,
-0.5701714754,
0.3529516757,
0.542978406,
0.8638997078,
-0.0811716691,
0.4821259975,
0.1775074303,
0.3850752115,
-0.0849426836,
-0.042124588,
0.0216317028,
-0.7635176778,
-0.8759180903,
-0.9746905565,
-0.3268784285,
0.1349530816,
-0.3297736943,
-0.198837921,
-0.4674369693,
-0.1227453947,
-0.536457777,
-0.1007434651,
-0.3901980817,
0.5064049959,
0.1946466118,
1.2700463533,
-0.6945957541,
1.1168978214,
0.6076008677,
-0.4051776826,
-1.237411499,
0.1759119332,
-0.4246068001,
-0.7917650938,
0.9059443474,
0.0904807225,
-0.2957744002,
0.2683263421,
-0.325956136,
-0.7644097209,
1.0785545111,
0.3538118899,
-0.8782325387,
-0.3294869363,
-0.1211574003,
0.6254449487,
-0.4088000357,
0.3856252134,
0.2159069926,
0.2466797978,
0.5226066709,
-0.6685664058,
-0.0251952223,
-0.3162195385,
0.3841446638,
0.1210813671,
-0.4343880415,
0.9592095613,
-0.0329252668,
-0.3920060396,
0.023827171,
0.8522523046,
0.2501234412,
-0.1620852947,
1.0925518274,
0.7654521465,
0.3014300764,
-0.1342222095,
0.9999890327,
-0.2651607096,
0.2619857192,
1.0991137028,
0.0385867134,
0.7029090524,
0.2945463359,
-0.2254120708,
0.9508644342,
0.9085640311,
0.4743302166,
0.7645855546,
0.6105563045,
0.0209231284,
-0.4981746078,
0.0524465926,
-0.4781779349,
0.289521277,
-0.1485570073,
0.0240076948,
-0.4486682713,
0.1268553883,
0.0635354966,
-0.2162415683,
-0.2121669054,
0.3579077721,
0.2436840385,
-0.4606639147,
0.5998104811,
-0.1842199415,
0.5615195632,
-1.2021472454,
0.1998486221,
-0.588026166,
0.1330875754,
-0.1036449298,
-0.3939573169,
0.0836036727,
-0.0449854732,
0.1176468655,
-0.5763300657,
0.4318380952,
-0.3581005633,
-0.4200766981,
0.3491678834,
0.5095800757,
-0.0218933988,
0.3935124874,
-0.8001707196,
-0.080673337,
-0.2989707589,
-0.6380494237,
0.4967095852,
0.4041463137,
-0.0862086937,
0.6895237565,
0.6431796551,
0.2549392581,
0.1251452714,
0.5922598243,
1.1012744904,
-0.2442940027,
-0.6707162261,
-0.4377796352,
0.6894200444,
-0.0054695983,
-0.2934421897,
0.6156212687,
0.3748281002,
0.9772772193,
0.198717922,
0.5402523279,
-0.2007513344,
0.3034303188,
-0.7911390662,
0.5222604871,
-0.4392916858,
0.3782841265,
-0.3443942964,
-0.7882902622,
-0.0914874449,
0.8202959895,
-0.2567514181,
0.4083454311,
0.6753075719,
0.4270426929,
-0.2070168257,
-0.42115134,
0.1995954961,
0.4537937343,
0.3241394758,
0.7124248743,
0.8970657587,
-0.114099659,
0.6220652461,
-0.2948286533,
-0.4042805135,
0.1639732718,
-1.0652900934,
-0.7070516944,
-0.5076015592,
-0.1561936736,
-0.221888274,
0.512812376,
0.6737983823,
0.9795620441,
-0.7736778855,
-0.2432614863,
-0.4307368696,
-0.1917380989,
-0.4095850587,
-0.1413696259,
0.2725512981,
-0.528273046,
-0.1885731369,
0.5436117649,
0.1675744355,
0.0372681543,
-0.3802400529,
-0.0631477237,
-0.6447514892,
0.0531757623,
0.6383594871,
0.4092217982,
-0.1788434982,
-0.6056908965,
-0.1378872693,
0.174802959,
-0.0321353264,
0.7485938668,
-0.8926174641,
0.1181056947,
0.4457628429,
0.4729192257,
0.8190920949,
0.0360773876,
0.797393024,
-1.1046450138,
0.2698553503,
0.4860678911,
0.1514000595,
0.1936287731,
0.0360361747,
0.6938332915,
0.2354698479,
-0.3035868108,
-0.6875347495,
0.5042120218,
-0.9147520661,
-0.3194731772,
0.9762405753,
-0.4303452075,
0.0926658586,
0.0026671498,
0.1887644678,
0.3626590371,
-0.1727623791,
0.6185040474,
0.3834392726,
-0.4714348614,
-0.1899614334,
-0.3962730467,
0.4543814957,
0.3357077241,
-0.5411857367,
-0.30485937,
0.1683007628,
0.0872039422,
0.210138768,
1.1008377075,
0.0245277155,
-0.0748181939,
-0.0143872807,
-0.0787772909,
-0.3372378647,
-0.8748342991,
0.0217405278,
0.2135007381,
-0.044791352,
-0.2220346034
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05904v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05904v1
|
FACT-GPT: Fact-Checking Augmentation via Claim Matching with LLMs
| 2024-02-08T18:43:05 | 2024-02-08T18:43:05 |
Eun Cheol Choi, Emilio Ferrara
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC, cs.SI
|
Our society is facing rampant misinformation harming public health and trust.
To address the societal challenge, we introduce FACT-GPT, a system leveraging
Large Language Models (LLMs) to automate the claim matching stage of
fact-checking. FACT-GPT, trained on a synthetic dataset, identifies social
media content that aligns with, contradicts, or is irrelevant to previously
debunked claims. Our evaluation shows that our specialized LLMs can match the
accuracy of larger models in identifying related claims, closely mirroring
human judgment. This research provides an automated solution for efficient
claim matching, demonstrates the potential of LLMs in supporting fact-checkers,
and offers valuable resources for further research in the field.
|
[
0.0378922187,
-0.7280860543,
1.0647763014,
0.0029614635,
-0.1884499341,
0.2986127436,
0.1469457597,
-0.6504136324,
0.3146567643,
0.4263739586,
-0.3815491796,
-0.3320137262,
-0.7861546874,
0.102240704,
-0.4684890509,
0.9478322864,
-0.0464686714,
0.1069807485,
-0.4465796947,
0.2401686907,
-0.0797019005,
-0.5485764742,
-0.6169350743,
-0.4148645401,
0.601370275,
0.3433546126,
0.7154242992,
0.5966968536,
0.4712603986,
0.336999774,
0.2399845272,
0.5605787039,
-0.3424740434,
-0.0745842457,
-0.3771138489,
-0.1808191985,
-0.4366668165,
0.1449970156,
0.3323653936,
0.2790676653,
-0.0663651824,
0.3842484057,
0.0279807709,
0.4764554203,
-0.5127415061,
0.2078431696,
-0.8213288188,
-0.1834926307,
0.0212598592,
-0.2070284933,
-0.1463808268,
-0.8613014221,
0.1273069233,
-0.3737821877,
0.5560888052,
-0.01001928,
1.028118968,
0.4742775559,
-0.7150931954,
-0.3145987093,
-0.5603075027,
0.1988696903,
-0.6657775044,
0.4283924401,
0.3764482439,
0.2303267419,
-0.1506275535,
-0.6167330146,
-0.7407535315,
-0.3567787111,
-0.4155039489,
-0.050471615,
-0.0817879513,
0.019149119,
0.4599027336,
0.3809783757,
-0.9105052352,
-0.2167473733,
-0.2918051481,
-0.6371205449,
0.6950010657,
-0.2166989744,
0.6122040153,
-0.3001253009,
-0.3576615751,
0.2081718743,
-0.8555006981,
-0.492852658,
0.0719455257,
0.1816498637,
-0.2049742192,
0.8647043705,
-0.2684744895,
0.5566578507,
-0.0077190204,
-0.3807948232,
0.2168356925,
-0.4407359064,
-0.3686567247,
0.5621201396,
0.6730763912,
0.5705287457,
0.0189023949,
-0.0599335879,
-0.1694368273,
0.4878070652,
-0.0752023384,
-0.8378803134,
-0.0695918724,
0.0229508076,
-0.1718425453,
-0.3152565956,
0.198132515,
-0.501205802,
-0.8414404392,
-0.3517811894,
0.6721861959,
-0.1023977622,
-0.1471057087,
0.2860814333,
-0.1611771137,
0.1652145982,
0.4828977287,
-0.2992831767,
0.0759414881,
0.7933067083,
1.0476158857,
0.0422213525,
0.2104121745,
-0.6749151349,
0.1962938458,
-0.3368468285,
0.9915469885,
-0.4125558138,
-0.0117382566,
0.0347909778,
0.1675327867,
0.0646880418,
-0.4550234973,
0.9640987515,
-0.6918401122,
0.2336776257,
-0.7164948583,
-0.7111988068,
-0.1399242282,
0.6524050236,
-0.7070342898,
0.8523340225,
-0.0201780256,
-0.7739299536,
0.3771553636,
-0.581569314,
-0.5374610424,
0.1802321821,
-0.1854362786,
-0.527355969,
-0.0971972793,
0.3609671593,
0.4099467695,
-0.4692776799,
0.4275637269,
-0.4985637665,
-0.0652872473,
0.187969327,
-0.4316646457,
0.7346395254,
0.2910884023,
-0.2324434072,
0.0787715241,
-0.6231780648,
-0.3697153926,
0.2682259977,
-0.5432308316,
-0.3390200436,
0.1466069371,
-0.0969152749,
0.2280086577,
0.4523299932,
-0.89608711,
0.3124760389,
-0.0891919881,
0.4409165382,
0.5316185355,
0.0300842151,
-0.0948398635,
-0.7639290094,
0.0896227211,
-0.1664910614,
0.0733525455,
-0.0437225737,
-0.3246767819,
-0.5421321392,
-0.3884550929,
0.4933389425,
0.8992535472,
-0.8468093276,
0.5256227255,
-0.5146796107,
-0.4645271897,
-0.4360543489,
-0.0244339854,
-0.0869577602,
0.8373388052,
0.3602922857,
0.0051739556,
-0.7655838132,
-0.8983071446,
-0.538955152,
-0.2357658595,
-0.1907995492,
0.0475598797,
0.3431306183,
-0.2987513542,
0.9908559918,
-0.6151357889,
-0.2259261012,
0.0647794306,
0.0759983286,
0.1488180161,
0.1296488345,
0.4582495093,
-0.8612130284,
-0.6129533052,
-0.0516332984,
-0.7998808622,
-0.3770214021,
-0.0214384887,
0.3210456073,
0.0944772214,
0.3445845246,
-0.7754946351,
0.1726818383,
0.6931505203,
-0.4647366107,
0.4114977121,
-0.1516287476,
0.541708231,
-1.0754349232,
-0.1752773374,
0.3086129427,
-0.6810500026,
-0.3828491569,
-0.2285325527,
0.208812505,
0.075796023,
-0.3098833263,
0.384996146,
-0.4022320211,
-0.0065365233,
-0.4055896401,
0.1253037751,
-0.045601964,
-0.1869863868,
-0.1207078546,
0.8945559859,
0.5807704329,
-0.4881570637,
0.6397333145,
0.0005977111,
-0.4640583396,
0.6804563403,
-0.6029269695,
0.0021939601,
-0.0485611819,
0.5659810901,
-0.9344416261,
-0.6085774899,
0.2335848659,
-0.4962839782,
-0.1566493064,
-0.2500300109,
-0.8698327541,
-0.4075796008,
-0.1999954134,
0.0566138551,
0.4255866706,
-0.6825377941,
0.8091432452,
0.5635726452,
-0.4343868494,
-0.4924163818,
-0.5571552515,
0.4878581166,
-0.0946324915,
-0.5391703844,
0.3154000342,
0.0608281679,
-0.2897646725,
0.0949379727,
-0.2372870594,
-0.0423530042,
-0.0381669626,
0.0834915712,
0.3864735365,
-0.1735691279,
0.2212255597,
-0.1327146739,
0.120256342,
0.0765160024,
-0.2164901644,
0.2687721848,
-0.0909157097,
-0.7484639287,
-0.2764483094,
0.1844340861,
0.6513276696,
-0.0575829446,
0.4918812513,
0.4961799681,
-0.6597176194,
0.2656708658,
-1.0868297815,
-0.1323895007,
-0.4927819073,
0.3301391006,
0.111888513,
-1.0363408327,
0.2202100158,
-0.0950174704,
-0.0191484913,
0.5363837481,
0.4994077086,
0.0815711841,
0.7828451991,
0.3865794241,
-0.3798815608,
0.2333895862,
0.3225141764,
0.2507102787,
-0.2005116194,
-0.0560504086,
-0.3281146288,
-0.008652851,
-0.6158146262,
-0.5475673676,
0.5716708899,
-0.4024724066,
-0.1892203689,
0.1702436954,
-0.4313416779,
0.650380969,
0.2391377687,
0.3960368931,
0.8098908663,
-0.0902454928,
0.2799768448,
0.2033565938,
-0.5682245493,
-0.5810925364,
0.9282600284,
0.3642058969,
0.8152235746,
0.3485880792,
0.3971492946,
0.7065752745,
0.8584828377,
-0.7052596211,
0.5316189528,
-0.0736129358,
-0.7672590613,
-0.1793567091,
-0.5484410524,
-0.6615087986,
0.1496778429,
-0.5349036455,
-0.3884935677,
0.0066020163,
0.3786464036,
-0.4470180571,
0.4380696416,
-0.5609019995,
0.3984789848,
-0.5438584685,
-0.1446255744,
-0.4135218561,
-0.4291191697,
0.5350900888,
-0.1972997487,
0.2770058811,
-0.2487154156,
0.0948994011,
0.475386858,
-0.366121918,
0.9093667865,
-0.0187024921,
-0.3343890309,
0.1397905052,
-0.1183521897,
0.6602593064,
0.1985408217,
0.1108270437,
-0.0668394491,
-0.0081418045,
-0.2122860998,
-0.3903197348,
0.7027008533,
-0.487488687,
-0.6634126306,
-0.8669710159,
-0.5371251702,
-0.1242078543,
0.2936502397,
-0.1054930389,
0.2586451471,
-0.5373359323,
0.0260515437,
0.936416626,
-0.0954604372,
0.028933065,
0.9383397698,
-0.2661109865,
-0.4434084594,
0.886253953,
0.1822408587,
0.056587141,
0.4866059422,
0.3877143562,
-0.5805229545,
-0.3152224123,
-0.2505568564,
0.4010491967,
-0.6293625832,
-0.4354127645,
-0.8603510261,
-0.2889636159,
-0.6824421287,
0.1656212211,
-0.2246943861,
-0.2719929814,
0.2394204885,
-0.3129726946,
0.6059597135,
0.9087068439,
-0.4601899087,
0.2274186611,
-0.910743475,
0.7799599767,
0.7629640102,
0.4818459153,
-0.6237556338,
-0.2812838554,
-0.1142759249,
0.2493825108,
-0.2798169255,
-0.9527676105,
-0.0701507181,
0.0589223914,
0.4609062672,
0.2499111146,
0.1811414361,
0.3945418,
-0.5141016245,
0.6301839352,
0.0971079469,
-0.8061995506,
0.2913561165,
-0.3490962088,
-0.3042398393,
0.3116793633,
0.5522794127,
-0.6897305846,
-0.1559762061,
-0.6759610176,
-0.5268230438,
0.1578990072,
-0.1187588871,
-0.1117889211,
-0.1409064084,
0.2585444152,
-0.1054950953,
-0.0726495236,
-0.6902041435,
-0.0397699475,
-0.1152127609,
-0.3805921078,
-0.0157734063,
-0.3154403269,
-0.4426778853,
-0.1728705615,
0.8195651174,
-0.1815425009,
0.0706665069,
0.5562505722,
-0.3345041275,
-0.2653851509,
0.4525248408,
0.7120822668,
0.5491624475,
-0.1712653786,
0.3965468407,
0.2544089258,
-0.4511521161,
0.3585701287,
0.3797848821,
-0.4089395106,
0.1998099834,
0.1801703721,
0.530973196,
-0.041684173,
-0.5775835514,
0.6490689516,
0.0410910398,
-0.2546428144,
-0.1846179962,
-0.0054778261,
0.2813182473,
0.2290372699,
0.5368785262,
0.0834229961,
0.1335365921,
-0.6161659956,
0.5915551186,
0.6933092475,
-0.1416839212,
-0.143192634,
0.4703708291,
0.2548733354,
-0.1743331105,
0.231926322,
-0.1283712834,
-0.7073195577,
0.5027443171,
0.442050904,
0.6941453218,
-0.3041323721,
0.3272393644,
0.4090540409,
0.5756332278,
-0.5555069447,
0.0222123805,
0.4506686628,
-0.8286412954,
-0.9473297596,
-0.336915195,
-0.4416029751,
0.5242033005,
-0.2367422283,
0.3112946451,
-0.3131993711,
-0.1222611517,
0.075264506,
-0.0824034736,
-0.6573877931,
0.251059711,
0.298235774,
0.9428398609,
-1.321521163,
0.7922955751,
0.5530388951,
-0.2695881426,
-0.679097414,
0.3579598665,
0.3943046331,
-0.9590741396,
0.5072225928,
0.0489024706,
-0.3226621449,
0.0354111902,
-0.8599916697,
-0.8570684791,
0.9849993587,
0.8714083433,
-0.6041475534,
0.0874712244,
0.2778406143,
0.2760562599,
-0.2593263388,
-0.0062741498,
0.458486706,
0.6323812604,
0.1676582843,
-1.1781072617,
0.4185674191,
0.2932654321,
-0.4721788168,
-0.0641048774,
-0.5676678419,
0.5907365084,
-0.265047729,
-0.3252975047,
-0.275805831,
0.6231673956,
0.3286770582,
0.3030334711,
0.7975183129,
0.6584149003,
0.8962134123,
0.0707063302,
0.8537939191,
-0.2641430497,
0.6226857901,
1.1394549608,
-0.469201982,
0.4140736163,
0.1316970885,
-0.2677183747,
0.3551163077,
0.7931672335,
-0.1706627905,
0.2729069293,
0.1254341155,
-0.411814183,
-0.4217221439,
-0.3866940439,
-0.4197073877,
0.1382635236,
0.4664006531,
-0.2697147727,
-0.4527581632,
-0.3675819933,
0.1629777104,
0.0476922356,
-0.2355885506,
0.8174821138,
-0.1318944842,
-0.6586710215,
0.3496141434,
-0.132504344,
0.7209435701,
-0.5195406675,
-0.2567053437,
0.1408229619,
-0.0794182047,
-0.3863421977,
-0.8520107865,
0.3813048601,
-0.0231023319,
-0.3410210609,
0.0262480509,
1.2169210911,
-0.7382948995,
-0.5504389405,
0.0723527968,
0.6817258596,
-0.111005567,
-0.4445442259,
-0.7452609539,
-0.0738803148,
-0.1704926193,
0.1125152186,
0.1336840838,
0.402285099,
-0.051825542,
0.6693644524,
0.7350716591,
0.2435625046,
-0.26782161,
0.0599247515,
0.8445450664,
-0.2948931754,
-0.3906570673,
-1.1444905996,
0.1226315051,
-0.4024879336,
0.4535257816,
0.7026088834,
0.8076873422,
0.5780035853,
-0.0300374236,
1.4131343365,
-0.1695158184,
0.9722169042,
-0.4977717698,
0.8728123307,
-0.3147652745,
0.0934810713,
-0.1232075468,
-0.6406074166,
-0.2750688791,
0.4521899223,
-0.4417408705,
-0.1568141729,
0.5198206902,
1.0951262712,
-0.2890398204,
-0.1638841629,
0.1567756087,
0.3731856048,
0.4265330732,
0.2404277772,
0.7612659335,
-0.2582048178,
0.4295464158,
0.1997126043,
-0.3955236077,
-0.4321811795,
-1.3258821964,
-0.7042864561,
-0.346394062,
-0.5739048123,
-0.645113349,
0.1247802153,
1.2838954926,
0.5779876709,
-0.7694682479,
0.2513352931,
0.1408135891,
0.3310970962,
-0.0824269652,
-0.2092175484,
0.4730534256,
0.050566826,
-0.3135433495,
0.3285497427,
0.136435464,
0.1184585616,
-0.1747909188,
0.0199628025,
-0.273893863,
0.3050353229,
0.6406511068,
0.296354264,
-0.70291394,
-0.5888471603,
-0.1974495053,
-0.3087940216,
0.0745072663,
1.0380198956,
-0.6338824034,
0.1360589266,
0.4737948775,
0.9993520975,
0.2635940909,
0.1796567142,
0.4254589081,
-0.6489768028,
-0.2791497111,
-0.0368443653,
0.5175302625,
0.7498076558,
-0.7168758512,
0.590618968,
0.5729075074,
-0.5430440307,
-0.7852395177,
0.3409011066,
-1.0732485056,
-0.0514400974,
1.0586948395,
0.1059719324,
-0.1008462831,
-0.4165418148,
-0.1867854148,
0.4077874422,
-0.3659380376,
1.0912361145,
0.734082222,
0.1213051528,
-0.1406113952,
-0.5753214359,
0.7450430393,
-0.0320626795,
-0.891151011,
0.1479294747,
0.4554712772,
0.7474098802,
0.1861806065,
0.8105274439,
-0.0661028326,
0.2420080006,
-0.3584546745,
0.0415745303,
-0.0339285545,
0.1383644938,
0.1296826452,
-0.0489851311,
-0.082030043,
-0.0532012023
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05889v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05889v2
|
CREMA: Generalizable and Efficient Video-Language Reasoning via Multimodal Modular Fusion
| 2024-02-08T18:27:22 | 2024-06-12T21:03:33 |
Shoubin Yu, Jaehong Yoon, Mohit Bansal
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Despite impressive advancements in recent multimodal reasoning approaches,
they are still limited in flexibility and efficiency, as these models typically
process only a few fixed modality inputs and require updates to numerous
parameters. This paper tackles these critical challenges and proposes CREMA, a
generalizable, highly efficient, and modular modality-fusion framework that can
incorporate any new modality to enhance video reasoning. We first augment
multiple informative modalities (such as optical flow, 3D point cloud, audio,
thermal heatmap, and touch map) from given videos without extra human
annotation by leveraging sensors or existing pre-trained models. Next, we
introduce a query transformer with multiple parameter-efficient modules
associated with each accessible modality. It projects diverse modality features
to the LLM token embedding space, allowing the model to integrate different
data types for response generation. Furthermore, we propose a novel progressive
multimodal fusion design supported by a lightweight fusion module and
modality-sequential training strategy. It helps compress information across
various assisting modalities, maintaining computational efficiency in the LLM
while improving performance. We validate our method on 7 video-language
reasoning tasks assisted by diverse modalities, including conventional VideoQA
and Video-Audio/3D/Touch/Thermal QA, and achieve better/equivalent performance
against strong multimodal LLMs, including OneLLM, BLIP-2, and SeViLA while
reducing over 90% trainable parameters. We provide extensive analyses of CREMA,
including the impact of each modality on reasoning domains, the design of the
fusion module, and example visualizations.
|
[
-0.3979001343,
-0.7500633001,
0.5096298456,
-0.0116995517,
-0.5186679363,
-0.1454500407,
-0.370664686,
-0.0959380865,
0.0419847816,
0.4589110315,
-0.5837011337,
-0.6227526069,
-0.4330379665,
-0.2296635509,
-0.337027967,
0.4445678592,
-0.1139020473,
0.2968206406,
-0.4080227911,
-0.5283240676,
-0.3739914596,
-0.3858202696,
-0.019703703,
-0.231154874,
0.4535500705,
0.4076239467,
0.6482929587,
0.5117444396,
0.5680151582,
0.4335934818,
0.4704222977,
0.5369005203,
-0.1520546973,
0.4264500439,
-0.1144043654,
-0.265544951,
-0.3831458092,
-0.5274789929,
0.560313642,
0.3989963531,
-0.1514024287,
0.1550375074,
-0.4283053577,
0.4804058969,
-0.8922452927,
-0.0754476115,
-0.6272520423,
-0.0913171545,
-0.0244763121,
-0.2656089067,
-0.4057479203,
0.0181694403,
0.0229962468,
-0.5063695908,
0.3454310596,
-0.0542160906,
0.5301074386,
0.7213736773,
-0.5721234679,
0.1553244144,
-0.9073144794,
0.8036544323,
-0.4423153102,
1.0244065523,
0.2584111989,
0.596237421,
0.2359244674,
-0.6023759842,
-0.6533076763,
-0.1462887824,
0.1430077702,
0.0675552636,
0.0345540866,
0.2357514501,
0.1489701122,
0.1847704053,
-0.9763950109,
-0.0914137587,
-0.1066888869,
-0.4409770072,
0.4938306808,
0.4093897641,
0.3329159021,
-0.1445660293,
-0.5335104465,
-0.0383665897,
-0.3086006343,
0.0333752669,
0.1511524022,
-0.0058301184,
-0.1998539418,
0.6891608834,
-0.4411067069,
0.9231558442,
-0.2214828879,
-0.5529334545,
0.2220186293,
-0.6463410258,
-0.6457050443,
-0.3105517626,
0.680077374,
0.3007445633,
-0.2459103018,
0.0670529678,
0.1285301,
0.4166531265,
0.1568197161,
-0.7185499668,
-0.36889413,
0.3185878396,
-0.3846749067,
0.1139009446,
-0.0770815983,
-0.8540735245,
-0.1125592068,
-0.3961046934,
0.3488217592,
-0.6024585962,
-0.2648179531,
0.3873776197,
-0.2054851651,
0.414306134,
0.6752917767,
-0.7882351279,
0.0442183651,
0.4187690616,
0.2586449087,
-0.0162024982,
-0.1892327368,
-0.4103839099,
0.5532897711,
0.2250507921,
0.9868589044,
-0.9622762203,
-0.249853611,
0.1750003844,
-0.1195625365,
-0.267337501,
-0.2761032879,
0.35924685,
-0.3328808546,
0.5295209885,
-0.0254383571,
-0.1690220237,
-0.687784791,
0.5524130464,
-0.583008945,
0.7125139832,
-0.1092066541,
-0.3148599565,
0.4400051832,
-0.5193904638,
-0.4503538013,
-0.0032706754,
-0.4293504953,
-0.2019541115,
-0.2832329869,
0.1873666197,
0.2794590294,
-0.631336689,
0.2284730524,
-0.2689587772,
0.0386802666,
0.1656604856,
-0.5796847939,
0.0824665353,
0.1609928459,
-0.3471035659,
0.3830227554,
-0.557546258,
0.1109748334,
-0.3009693027,
-0.3287917078,
0.1395041049,
-0.118116051,
-0.1902710348,
0.1917384714,
-0.0345657915,
-0.257042259,
0.2751450241,
0.1718046218,
0.3732531667,
0.3702260256,
-0.1190811321,
0.7519083619,
-0.1407739967,
0.5287798047,
0.105902262,
0.4422385395,
-0.4433692694,
-0.412796706,
-0.7311168909,
-0.8397548795,
0.0175890159,
0.61442554,
-1.024205327,
-0.100469999,
-0.1463815123,
-0.5289367437,
-0.3925275803,
0.4204388559,
0.3970797658,
0.543007791,
0.4812884033,
-0.2707087696,
-0.4812702835,
-1.2018042803,
0.0284314156,
-0.2223768383,
-0.0235329978,
0.3608130217,
0.2016949505,
-0.237694934,
0.6835539341,
-0.4816327989,
-0.3510723412,
-0.4454625249,
-0.014577236,
-0.1834727228,
0.404127717,
0.4150795639,
-1.0695894957,
0.0765760839,
0.0369863734,
-0.8691173792,
0.068349652,
-0.3493754268,
-0.1611811221,
0.2971170545,
-0.0161965508,
-0.8645513654,
0.3506937325,
0.4330616891,
-0.2048169971,
0.559168458,
-0.0212964509,
0.8224513531,
-0.7831102014,
-0.0731323957,
0.2020447254,
-0.1504125744,
-0.6558237076,
0.0359461047,
-0.1132822707,
-0.1934186369,
-0.7755550146,
0.4401214719,
-0.2671762407,
0.1527986377,
-0.0232599974,
0.2305606902,
0.2549807131,
0.7646378875,
0.1256457418,
0.4400582016,
0.7080686688,
-0.6890221238,
0.6310271621,
0.2003624588,
-0.0760604814,
0.4888612032,
-0.2727648914,
-0.0857407674,
-0.1448108852,
0.4213050604,
-1.137856245,
-0.5980029106,
0.4012872577,
-0.4066047966,
0.1739464104,
-0.2741430998,
-0.2842307687,
-0.1333302855,
-0.2093437314,
0.9240669012,
0.4501890242,
-0.2586229146,
1.3656231165,
0.2658700049,
0.2227732539,
-0.4709736109,
-0.6519297957,
-0.2049592137,
-0.2748135328,
-1.1716698408,
0.3501210809,
-0.2560871243,
-0.2260005325,
-0.0446498878,
-0.2152406573,
-0.5171445608,
-0.2400140166,
0.2396078557,
0.2783560455,
-0.1038467437,
0.1404870749,
0.0863687918,
-0.0430859998,
-0.2183606774,
-0.1030763313,
0.6572776437,
-0.0753333047,
-0.7510044575,
-0.6912436485,
0.5545548797,
0.646443069,
-0.2327695787,
0.1352074146,
0.9531088471,
-0.3357941508,
0.0194841288,
-0.996522963,
-0.1519446373,
-0.4535982907,
0.3375808299,
-0.3578320742,
-0.9206895232,
0.4632398784,
-0.0222703032,
0.0155548966,
0.1386786848,
1.0955672264,
0.0944798961,
1.1811034679,
0.3151648641,
0.3887366056,
0.4524495304,
-0.3892551661,
0.0426311381,
-0.4632509351,
-0.8063338995,
-0.2755232751,
-0.4033023119,
-0.0501736179,
-1.0014045238,
0.5507872105,
-0.1821379811,
-0.133709535,
0.2923002839,
-0.317216754,
0.331109345,
0.2843624949,
0.2096100897,
0.3063867688,
-0.1684868485,
0.0419835486,
0.0457391478,
-0.8403447866,
-0.2729707062,
0.4616840482,
0.1139119565,
0.818339169,
0.3911119699,
0.2058427483,
0.3805218041,
0.0557200573,
-0.7364625335,
0.8935096264,
0.1319725662,
-0.5438722968,
-0.0935541466,
-0.300345242,
-0.6033754349,
0.5211182237,
-0.3470663726,
-0.4189913571,
0.0656004921,
0.3019167185,
-0.2221975327,
0.3538223505,
-0.783670783,
0.7496717572,
-0.3122881055,
-0.6335459948,
-0.585314393,
-0.7076190114,
0.7959735394,
0.3554883599,
0.3677033484,
-0.2154795527,
-0.2515369058,
0.2926482856,
-0.3127797246,
0.713340342,
-0.168111518,
0.1799303442,
0.427688241,
0.4158994555,
-0.0411259197,
0.2332943529,
0.0942790434,
0.1670362353,
-0.1612811685,
-0.4206704199,
-0.8146989942,
0.5603385568,
-0.3985612094,
-0.7145872712,
-0.0901524201,
-0.6533391476,
-0.2728251517,
-0.048290696,
-0.0134283388,
0.7887923717,
0.1595734656,
0.1923133731,
0.637452662,
-0.0876433551,
0.4289886653,
0.3245697916,
0.0167747922,
-0.9119874835,
0.8937511444,
-0.3191147149,
0.3965060413,
0.5130863786,
-0.0611412078,
-0.2504920065,
-0.453727603,
-0.8495086432,
0.1390508115,
-0.7635273337,
-0.4932345152,
-0.6820995808,
0.2015028149,
-0.4017695189,
-0.2722082138,
-0.2520524263,
-0.5183820128,
-0.0669605061,
-0.0111912498,
0.1088354662,
0.116712302,
0.0165261608,
0.1204066575,
-1.0435574055,
0.5191648602,
0.5706802011,
0.1334138513,
-0.1471367925,
-0.2866840959,
-0.0712157786,
0.0034758889,
-0.3938422501,
-0.8222536445,
0.1771311909,
0.260571748,
0.8024291992,
0.4650627971,
-0.1633668989,
0.8211355805,
-0.269411236,
1.1865234375,
0.6273667216,
-0.8476186991,
0.4681347907,
-0.3139183223,
0.1925048679,
0.5117889047,
0.3255428672,
-0.2491547167,
-0.0464246422,
-0.4707046747,
-0.7400032282,
0.0785788298,
-0.0337890945,
0.0698337108,
-0.0178748704,
-0.047612071,
0.3784524798,
0.1558395326,
-0.3580840826,
-0.0053911288,
-0.5204113722,
-0.1179359183,
0.505910337,
-0.1277240813,
-0.3300562799,
-0.4751770198,
0.5066181421,
-0.3476450145,
0.1691314131,
0.3630414903,
-0.4797285199,
0.0586695708,
0.2505553365,
1.0644452572,
0.5923561454,
0.1409930438,
0.2335419059,
0.3069583178,
-0.1098529547,
0.1568879187,
-0.2609559298,
0.2421370596,
0.0467262417,
0.4538164139,
0.7410318255,
0.4345553219,
-1.0262755156,
0.4560528696,
-0.0932391807,
-0.5107621551,
-0.2208949924,
0.1917149872,
-0.111525923,
0.5106781721,
0.2002007514,
0.2062749416,
0.2531388104,
-0.5579015017,
0.3464361429,
0.5278692842,
-0.2595170736,
-0.5213370919,
0.7086046338,
0.4046127498,
-0.3165897429,
0.3026182652,
0.0916978642,
-0.6237180233,
0.13774544,
0.1058291495,
0.7293304801,
-0.1530766487,
0.4101044834,
0.1511301845,
0.0953263044,
0.0975201577,
0.3783391118,
-0.4185777009,
-0.5917439461,
-0.6383194923,
-0.3246497512,
-0.5138148069,
-0.3432901204,
-0.3206520379,
0.4658646584,
-0.3431384265,
-0.0748924166,
-0.2196278572,
-0.4591394663,
-0.9445108175,
0.2355951667,
0.3552515209,
0.9658870697,
-0.6774549484,
0.6553944945,
0.6516878009,
-0.5459365845,
-0.4215781987,
-0.4799903631,
0.0786843672,
-0.8328592777,
0.5170299411,
-0.0318564363,
-0.2204796225,
-0.4410991669,
-0.3692474067,
-0.5073173046,
1.2404880524,
0.5619410872,
-0.2133058459,
-0.0503043756,
0.3527322114,
0.2345052361,
-0.4694685638,
0.4982466698,
0.4024131894,
0.6698027253,
0.5333204269,
-0.8413584232,
-0.0783504322,
-0.1336570829,
-0.3689146936,
0.3106532991,
-0.7508326173,
0.4993023574,
-0.3216657341,
-0.0075794603,
-0.0695831999,
0.5650957227,
0.1027965546,
0.5021553636,
0.586312294,
0.8367273808,
0.447181046,
-0.0563319065,
0.9005355835,
-0.2202175111,
0.0545684583,
0.7194150686,
-0.3300258815,
0.4441039264,
0.5271529555,
0.2580717802,
0.7713084817,
0.3135023713,
0.1180143878,
0.4463639557,
-0.0553205237,
-0.6558728814,
-1.1197626591,
-0.1959766001,
-0.2359504104,
0.7540006042,
0.3434474766,
-0.1870345026,
-0.5295027494,
0.2365955263,
-0.2534345388,
0.1034934744,
-0.1954573244,
0.8485773206,
-0.1085338369,
-0.4598821402,
0.4873843491,
-0.2604473829,
0.4145337045,
-0.7271922231,
-0.1586764902,
-0.0184799116,
-0.0553026311,
-0.4200059175,
-0.5085725188,
0.2097931355,
-0.2031922191,
-0.3203339279,
-0.1928450614,
0.9027035236,
-0.726297915,
-0.2156923413,
-0.0786407068,
0.7562288046,
0.0183383599,
0.1268306375,
-0.6005926728,
0.5661373138,
-0.0101200705,
-0.1805930287,
0.4654158652,
0.2821643651,
0.0828350484,
1.0026789904,
0.7585996985,
-0.2579371333,
-0.0641910583,
0.2008326501,
1.1400079727,
-0.646351099,
-0.0179368518,
-0.8418064117,
0.9142394662,
-0.0095675141,
-0.1938423663,
0.4142711759,
0.6271368265,
0.587008357,
-0.1134788319,
0.7288593054,
-0.0756647661,
-0.0269335732,
-0.7120825052,
0.025831474,
-0.573708117,
0.1647925973,
0.0587878972,
-0.814586997,
-0.5707780719,
0.349252969,
-0.2105419785,
-0.1604223102,
0.7062745094,
0.8362466693,
-0.1172595546,
0.1444977373,
0.4952764809,
-0.1860552877,
0.6090099216,
0.5973136425,
0.7687953711,
-0.2513737977,
0.7819516659,
-0.2214852422,
-0.165169552,
-0.2624183893,
-0.8959383368,
-0.7054179907,
-0.6583419442,
-0.4512854517,
-0.2362871021,
-0.1625216901,
1.0697407722,
0.9217315912,
-0.3122059107,
-0.0557648167,
0.4745029509,
0.2748642266,
-0.1321427822,
-0.2259946764,
-0.0130535513,
-0.1976535767,
-0.6701964736,
0.5612895489,
0.5069513917,
-0.3596605957,
-0.5842057467,
-0.0687598884,
-0.0601479448,
0.086908102,
0.7895974517,
0.2646056116,
-0.8905395269,
-0.6544868946,
0.0738529339,
0.1611948907,
0.0737858936,
1.206176281,
-0.9216364026,
0.4291768372,
0.8644289374,
0.6604695916,
0.3923206329,
0.0630272701,
0.5921573043,
-0.414545238,
0.2784203589,
0.5128781796,
0.6129496098,
0.296781987,
-0.0576731302,
0.3525674939,
0.5852140784,
-0.5092599988,
-0.9010608196,
0.6876927018,
-1.7173937559,
-0.1051873043,
1.38050735,
0.2059786916,
-0.332832545,
-0.1262684315,
-0.3488164246,
0.0840658396,
-0.427097708,
0.501912117,
0.3694595397,
-0.4937839806,
-0.4855973125,
-0.283990711,
0.2837242186,
0.5426238775,
-0.6299538612,
0.0218109433,
0.8294157386,
0.3294734955,
-0.0036751351,
0.5251615644,
-0.0259844549,
0.5679153204,
-0.0684239194,
0.0882575959,
-0.4612841904,
-0.5482084155,
0.048848439,
0.5424579978,
-0.4015850127,
-0.1380656362
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05880v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05880v2
|
Generative Echo Chamber? Effects of LLM-Powered Search Systems on Diverse Information Seeking
| 2024-02-08T18:14:33 | 2024-02-10T17:03:58 |
Nikhil Sharma, Q. Vera Liao, Ziang Xiao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
Large language models (LLMs) powered conversational search systems have
already been used by hundreds of millions of people, and are believed to bring
many benefits over conventional search. However, while decades of research and
public discourse interrogated the risk of search systems in increasing
selective exposure and creating echo chambers -- limiting exposure to diverse
opinions and leading to opinion polarization, little is known about such a risk
of LLM-powered conversational search. We conduct two experiments to
investigate: 1) whether and how LLM-powered conversational search increases
selective exposure compared to conventional search; 2) whether and how LLMs
with opinion biases that either reinforce or challenge the user's view change
the effect. Overall, we found that participants engaged in more biased
information querying with LLM-powered conversational search, and an opinionated
LLM reinforcing their views exacerbated this bias. These results present
critical implications for the development of LLMs and conversational search
systems, and the policy governing these technologies.
|
[
-0.5107904673,
-0.5991185308,
0.8938861489,
-0.0309482999,
-0.2609362602,
0.1698512882,
-0.1014777869,
-0.5062569976,
0.3990011811,
0.5642726421,
-0.4675320089,
-0.4210002422,
-0.6465812922,
0.1038190275,
-0.6386162043,
0.7449600101,
0.3216578662,
0.1341474205,
-0.0182669759,
0.2514095604,
-0.3652415574,
-0.9292670488,
-0.3010846674,
-0.1473668814,
0.6458455324,
0.2701399624,
1.0309976339,
0.1120695025,
0.5230106115,
0.1898249537,
-0.3526345789,
-0.0753431767,
-0.8020920157,
0.5320388675,
-0.2087426633,
-0.837415576,
-0.182476595,
-0.0389562957,
0.7066754103,
0.5504102111,
-0.3037381172,
-0.1082066298,
0.2595568001,
0.7199035883,
-0.6362698674,
-0.2237390727,
-0.9603132606,
0.1383968294,
-0.3265174329,
-0.6479286551,
-0.4288322926,
-0.2464323938,
0.1822889894,
-0.557130754,
0.3584981263,
0.1951837391,
0.4487018585,
0.1670412719,
-0.5293011069,
-0.488468498,
-0.9931545854,
0.8942012787,
-0.377910465,
0.4213437438,
0.1075295359,
0.0040819175,
-0.1717060655,
-0.6117960215,
-0.5093176961,
0.0039159888,
0.1506263912,
0.1676197201,
-0.4890251756,
0.2313562185,
0.227175951,
0.4122000337,
-0.4223923087,
0.1208957806,
-0.403876394,
0.0308516491,
0.5473150611,
0.2561342716,
0.1616829932,
-0.2124085873,
-0.1222802624,
-0.1093851849,
-0.9062021971,
-0.0580460355,
0.6714032888,
0.3212559223,
0.3122293353,
0.6858789325,
-0.3265488446,
0.4452228844,
0.0714855567,
0.1192486957,
0.0199990738,
-0.3267754018,
-0.0033225056,
0.2620396316,
0.4991388917,
0.4580515027,
0.1048272178,
-0.0614298396,
-0.2151765078,
-0.2469613254,
0.4616080821,
-0.7764846087,
0.3607710302,
0.0997968391,
-0.7168841958,
-0.50805825,
0.4340142608,
-0.837510705,
-0.7206058502,
-0.0149363531,
0.4527455866,
0.1825574785,
-0.2377354801,
0.2551505864,
-0.3394470811,
0.2657279968,
0.2002999336,
-0.7860036492,
0.5432552099,
0.6610456109,
0.8321661353,
-0.2320770919,
0.1820871085,
-0.3073248565,
-0.240959093,
-0.2287334055,
0.7504831553,
-0.8164185882,
-0.9510986209,
0.3386768997,
-0.0661949217,
0.211947307,
-0.9519258142,
0.5170878768,
-0.8583657146,
0.3265738487,
-0.4992012978,
-0.4126642048,
-0.0639120489,
0.0232349373,
-0.458162576,
0.6310476661,
-0.2699149549,
-0.549407959,
0.2133768946,
-0.3267020583,
-0.4210176766,
0.0324765295,
-0.4255358279,
-0.3077759147,
0.3079517186,
0.3432172239,
0.1512598991,
-0.3046406209,
0.0760168657,
-0.4104146659,
-0.5144678354,
0.636387229,
-0.6112231612,
0.5315092206,
0.0372819826,
-0.7477912903,
-0.1126465797,
-0.1232208088,
-0.138480112,
0.2944051921,
-0.3979536593,
-0.206142202,
0.283095032,
-0.0562124886,
0.121974133,
0.19032529,
-0.5750698447,
0.0621041283,
-0.225552395,
0.0785068721,
0.8750088811,
0.0832457319,
0.2679538131,
-0.6031245589,
0.6909254193,
0.0202218704,
0.3002856672,
-0.1665654331,
-0.7188929915,
-0.6827768087,
0.2114618123,
-0.0933374614,
0.3994369209,
-0.3698573411,
0.3603879511,
0.0448449291,
-0.2057932764,
-0.688012898,
0.0653073639,
0.0328594372,
0.1589790732,
0.1359933615,
-0.248264581,
-0.4364629388,
-1.0673781633,
-0.4283580184,
-0.198714599,
-0.3262453675,
1.048140049,
0.0108484821,
-0.2679232955,
0.6434201598,
-0.5198317766,
-0.5205513239,
-0.2155546993,
-0.0859568119,
0.3796993792,
-0.1198723689,
0.2561181188,
-0.9612572789,
-0.2001939565,
-0.2617916465,
-0.614172101,
-0.4395444691,
0.1226459593,
0.165528059,
-0.1457141191,
0.3506039083,
-0.652825892,
0.2960636914,
0.6581751704,
0.2102537602,
0.4596421719,
0.2674299181,
0.3062996268,
-0.8577613831,
0.0190713741,
-0.1278284788,
-0.0176872667,
-0.5683556795,
0.0218265448,
-0.3094314039,
-0.2446717918,
-0.3487274349,
0.2945339978,
-0.428547591,
-0.2231429964,
-0.6327312589,
0.5151626468,
0.0890884399,
-0.0104128718,
0.0318007767,
0.8965299726,
0.5842157006,
-0.62890625,
0.2306933403,
0.0629372597,
-0.4086205661,
0.192230463,
-0.4256905913,
0.4468492568,
-0.1131966785,
0.4501380324,
-0.8088130951,
-0.1395153403,
-0.1868328154,
-0.3021501899,
0.0066871182,
0.1387301385,
-0.3765751719,
-0.2483766079,
-0.46889925,
0.5442383885,
0.4683838487,
-0.7585148215,
0.4394354522,
0.558594346,
-0.5884767175,
-0.5824531913,
-0.4929511845,
0.4817063212,
-0.1754525602,
-0.5373427868,
0.4394262135,
0.0599114113,
-0.6129925847,
-0.14396438,
-0.0571408607,
0.3164226413,
0.1504389942,
0.3410367966,
0.2434661686,
0.0311440732,
0.4604147375,
-0.2240071595,
0.1128162071,
0.1107880101,
-0.1619379073,
0.8479553461,
-0.2807231545,
-0.7279152274,
-0.2498890311,
0.607144773,
0.4221331477,
0.1528254449,
0.6404135823,
0.0706153288,
-0.1693153083,
-0.083407037,
-0.8909674883,
-0.6219889522,
-0.5261240602,
0.4037767053,
0.1083943024,
-1.227930665,
0.3883211911,
-0.062427368,
-0.1714440137,
0.3293733895,
0.9278357625,
-0.3865925968,
1.3247383833,
0.5118910074,
-0.1906486303,
0.7045817971,
0.0703709945,
0.3867909014,
-0.8986648917,
-0.2646819651,
-0.655464232,
-0.4885003269,
-0.9447697401,
-0.0898951292,
0.7005244493,
-0.2524208724,
0.2518201768,
-0.4312782884,
-0.7122306824,
0.2307654768,
0.6682835817,
0.4763195217,
0.5362687111,
0.0517366789,
0.1896144301,
-0.1134354547,
-0.6424244046,
-0.4506542087,
1.4859161377,
0.2183167934,
1.1210095882,
0.2181892395,
0.5632638931,
0.306222856,
0.2352143228,
-0.9346783757,
0.4986379445,
0.0216050614,
-1.0462816954,
-0.1950304806,
-0.3462955058,
-1.1045453548,
0.2319158465,
-0.1156133562,
-0.6458827853,
0.347754389,
-0.0668755397,
-0.0928261057,
0.4988612831,
-0.3367788494,
0.0162080377,
-0.588891685,
-0.3707635403,
-0.5919796824,
-0.3786324561,
0.3685908318,
-0.2188461721,
0.1651067883,
0.1599483192,
0.1491855085,
0.7140072584,
0.0248113554,
0.7787245512,
-0.0306385737,
0.0795633644,
0.2635938823,
0.0337868817,
0.5416781306,
0.0016585905,
-0.1296236068,
0.2378807366,
-0.5004761815,
-0.1836582571,
-0.5361856222,
0.6655848622,
-0.6534808278,
-1.4423065186,
-0.4234006107,
-0.4826836586,
0.0153102446,
0.1850093752,
0.3008706868,
0.0507833473,
-0.3387127519,
0.7244998217,
0.8433247805,
-0.2288305014,
0.0264463276,
0.4445577264,
-0.4685164094,
-0.1227774695,
0.4404677749,
0.2292866558,
0.3678385913,
0.2829693854,
0.2006328106,
-0.1540249437,
-0.522174716,
0.0870618001,
-0.0122226495,
-0.490474999,
0.0529508628,
-0.5764338374,
-0.2985746264,
-0.3297355473,
0.0639478564,
-0.2659430802,
-0.0700715408,
-0.465547502,
-0.1357038468,
-0.0177067574,
0.7701708674,
0.1476667076,
0.2272779197,
-0.3808458447,
0.168318674,
0.6894463301,
0.3644283712,
-0.2304826081,
-0.4682440758,
-0.1195028052,
0.0328997932,
-0.6243211031,
-0.9240692854,
0.1560786515,
-0.103172712,
0.6757577062,
0.5088936687,
0.1026247218,
0.151080355,
-0.1285445988,
0.9413217306,
0.0417303517,
-0.4423918128,
0.4823517203,
-0.4194287658,
0.3209101856,
0.3763115108,
0.2467505634,
-0.6093797684,
-0.4172495306,
-0.6485161781,
-0.7094238997,
0.5027104616,
0.305675,
0.3389377594,
0.0712682828,
0.1274043471,
0.1277582496,
0.5657261014,
-0.7046591043,
-0.1397685856,
-0.1044652686,
0.2525525689,
0.1404081732,
-0.5177937746,
-0.3786195219,
0.1237342283,
0.6462987065,
0.0584538691,
0.2629200518,
0.4895467162,
0.234187007,
-0.2602731287,
0.5771046281,
0.3722488582,
0.2096092999,
-0.4634493291,
0.3029091358,
0.0493259355,
-0.4529868662,
0.2142155468,
0.020119762,
-0.3898560107,
0.0925482512,
0.0016962609,
0.783741951,
-0.0168469958,
-0.7501934767,
0.49719733,
-0.1469796002,
-0.1464273781,
-0.2781232595,
0.0994799659,
0.1212126017,
0.2960557938,
0.709746778,
-0.1373027116,
0.4304432273,
-0.790620923,
-0.0661350563,
0.9538740516,
-0.3627274632,
-0.0664272457,
0.4580044746,
0.2485998571,
-0.6461073756,
0.4321423173,
0.2224297822,
-0.4702081084,
0.3461785316,
0.5316973925,
1.245020628,
-0.2908958495,
-0.0411574058,
-0.1974327862,
0.533439815,
0.0947416872,
0.0248201694,
-0.1195689216,
-0.8746419549,
0.2102194726,
-0.384565264,
-0.8532621264,
0.3093200624,
-0.6611648202,
0.0026076955,
-0.1871579736,
-0.6028660536,
-0.2986286581,
-0.075593546,
-0.7420262694,
-0.1504959315,
0.3153018355,
0.6117497683,
-0.47718817,
0.3176944554,
0.4807134271,
-0.0890418068,
-0.3525600135,
0.4169817567,
0.2869636118,
-0.7824505568,
0.5370835066,
0.1961390674,
-0.5017796159,
-0.1737076491,
-0.6903946996,
-0.9955230355,
1.0924466848,
0.3327079713,
-0.8165253401,
0.0722553656,
0.379119575,
0.4801092446,
-0.5010207891,
0.3370273411,
0.5701876283,
0.3351351619,
-0.162446022,
-1.0100995302,
-0.149922058,
-0.1871890128,
-0.1369330734,
-0.1286598295,
-0.826454699,
0.6582402587,
-0.0272368155,
-0.4028196633,
-0.1059204191,
0.0524944402,
0.5112882257,
0.4155699611,
0.4651398659,
0.3158548176,
0.6653313041,
0.0667593926,
1.25509727,
-0.2727277577,
0.1697171777,
0.6647726893,
-0.6200806499,
0.793299973,
0.6089558601,
-0.1994068176,
0.4071699679,
0.4152988791,
0.214989081,
0.4863197207,
0.1569993496,
-0.7305329442,
-0.1962373257,
-0.5373187661,
-0.3948175907,
0.23598364,
0.4965004325,
-0.6758858562,
0.0082541751,
-0.0718034655,
-0.0773236901,
-0.0110879289,
-0.1323520988,
0.8125382066,
0.3329285681,
-0.572158277,
0.258105427,
-0.256395489,
0.7279013395,
-0.3650946319,
0.3366649151,
-0.1798131168,
-0.1040702313,
-0.2969637513,
-0.9361806512,
-0.1297918409,
0.0256618392,
-0.2096087188,
-0.2068484128,
0.9813147187,
0.0453425311,
-0.4052941501,
0.654920578,
0.7518719435,
0.1991473287,
-0.327978462,
-0.4945340157,
0.1458799541,
0.1169961616,
-0.6576299667,
0.4844837785,
-0.0409114286,
0.2337138951,
0.7321902514,
0.7826479673,
0.2380766571,
0.1365664154,
0.3135870099,
1.2105331421,
-0.7356109023,
-0.2060831636,
-0.6713833213,
-0.0105140973,
-0.1295146495,
0.0318346359,
0.5211585164,
0.6216521859,
0.7734530568,
0.3111412823,
1.2220366001,
0.3090826571,
0.39948681,
-0.5379287601,
0.5487372875,
-0.4681806862,
0.5717204213,
-0.0632448941,
-1.2007682323,
-0.1812709123,
0.2124723196,
-0.4808867574,
0.323717922,
0.5836414695,
1.164483428,
0.1476655006,
0.1266133636,
0.3060638607,
0.4130475521,
0.6014386415,
0.2622680366,
1.1134041548,
-0.1357757151,
0.7239586711,
0.011224228,
-0.3945983052,
-0.5933318734,
-0.4053630233,
-0.5046061277,
-0.300282985,
0.1332982481,
-0.2108430713,
0.2192250043,
0.6882210374,
0.4650900662,
-0.5292565227,
-0.3515357375,
-0.1073702723,
0.2824313641,
0.0620711744,
-0.3021589816,
-0.0268307161,
-0.1160783917,
-0.717244029,
0.6128141284,
0.5410212278,
-0.17778036,
-0.512057364,
0.0736678168,
0.0108132642,
0.274028331,
0.3470365107,
0.1011138484,
-0.8768724799,
-0.4614050686,
0.3518384397,
-0.3306465745,
0.3106150031,
0.8968453407,
-0.8465678096,
0.7265538573,
0.3532712758,
0.4207651317,
0.6977282763,
0.2745018601,
0.5809543729,
-0.4740948081,
-0.0013080612,
0.5160388947,
0.2477022409,
0.2158408463,
-0.5174924731,
0.059055049,
0.1460977644,
-0.880648911,
-0.7631152868,
0.2814053595,
-0.8642596006,
-0.2054344118,
1.3050355911,
0.4565867782,
0.1886265129,
-0.1116312668,
-0.4097152054,
0.0951474756,
-0.5332515836,
1.2982923985,
0.7005950212,
-0.4551478922,
-0.088737607,
-0.543633461,
0.1731500626,
0.6446077228,
-0.6463611722,
-0.0468889959,
0.2275265604,
0.0585155748,
0.3279996812,
0.5052201152,
-0.3082434833,
0.1896618903,
-0.0614589117,
-0.0477169231,
0.2533596158,
-0.177289933,
-0.5664104223,
0.3513938785,
0.1161407903,
0.035570249
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05868v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05868v2
|
EmojiCrypt: Prompt Encryption for Secure Communication with Large Language Models
| 2024-02-08T17:57:11 | 2024-02-12T16:26:14 |
Guo Lin, Wenyue Hua, Yongfeng Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Cloud-based large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT have increasingly
become integral to daily operations, serving as vital tools across various
applications. While these models offer substantial benefits in terms of
accessibility and functionality, they also introduce significant privacy
concerns: the transmission and storage of user data in cloud infrastructures
pose substantial risks of data breaches and unauthorized access to sensitive
information; even if the transmission and storage of data is encrypted, the LLM
service provider itself still knows the real contents of the data, preventing
individuals or entities from confidently using such LLM services. To address
these concerns, this paper proposes a simple yet effective mechanism EmojiCrypt
to protect user privacy. It uses Emoji to encrypt the user inputs before
sending them to LLM, effectively rendering them indecipherable to human or
LLM's examination while retaining the original intent of the prompt, thus
ensuring the model's performance remains unaffected. We conduct experiments on
three tasks, personalized recommendation, sentiment analysis, and tabular data
analysis. Experiment results reveal that EmojiCrypt can encrypt personal
information within prompts in such a manner that not only prevents the
discernment of sensitive data by humans or LLM itself, but also maintains or
even improves the precision without further tuning, achieving comparable or
even better task accuracy than directly prompting the LLM without prompt
encryption. These results highlight the practicality of adopting encryption
measures that safeguard user privacy without compromising the functional
integrity and performance of LLMs. Code and dataset are available at
https://github.com/agiresearch/EmojiCrypt.
|
[
-0.1982896328,
-1.145737052,
0.6570236683,
0.2412301302,
-0.3583462238,
0.3573004901,
-0.3120137155,
-0.3530995846,
0.2795125842,
0.7912088037,
-0.7262215018,
-0.6692094803,
-0.6675283313,
0.2220448256,
-0.3386677504,
0.5519511104,
0.2372393161,
-0.1516226232,
-0.0474257208,
0.3026224077,
-0.3324976265,
-0.7832409739,
-0.7300533056,
-0.0075996597,
0.3501070738,
0.5155866742,
0.9367384911,
0.4582803249,
0.477594167,
0.2403285354,
-0.2671810091,
-0.1223018467,
-0.2215077579,
0.7613169551,
0.1926027387,
-0.5327287912,
0.0749674439,
-0.5453561544,
0.3289461434,
0.1139215752,
-0.3016800582,
-0.1000387818,
0.1093635559,
0.5540627837,
-0.6692792773,
0.2040667534,
-0.8423944116,
0.1208108291,
-0.2292723507,
-0.3089585304,
-0.3521176279,
-0.2700970173,
-0.2301580608,
-0.2595193982,
-0.2818575799,
0.3855086565,
0.4706366956,
0.2839459777,
-0.096576646,
-0.401047945,
-0.292140305,
0.5638644695,
-0.4687941968,
0.6038520932,
0.7586345077,
0.4644478261,
-0.2021364719,
-0.5595753789,
-0.4632399976,
-0.4405755997,
0.1995467693,
0.0120907687,
-0.0818557516,
0.2943487167,
0.3763437867,
0.109209314,
-0.5547080636,
0.345975548,
0.1926735044,
-0.3048239648,
0.2555255592,
0.2078480273,
0.6644918323,
-0.2411421686,
-0.4684861898,
0.1264471859,
-1.1168761253,
0.2400344312,
0.2017025203,
0.4218266904,
-0.2028123438,
0.7814757824,
-0.2548325062,
0.3966614008,
-0.0291111358,
-0.0043779481,
-0.2016165107,
-0.105109632,
-0.0819818377,
0.2457237393,
0.97308743,
0.1297473013,
0.2431469411,
-0.2520917058,
-0.0967900753,
-0.1005829796,
-0.061672274,
-0.9531161189,
0.1298376173,
0.4216541648,
-0.1960480362,
-0.3894349039,
-0.0244041979,
-0.7136377692,
-0.7177547812,
-0.0577867217,
0.0817443803,
-0.3411682248,
0.2200264782,
-0.1418357641,
0.3352161944,
-0.0533922985,
0.3578569293,
-1.3735702038,
0.4925301075,
1.0899809599,
1.0165321827,
0.1310179681,
-0.1916379482,
-0.3558017612,
0.1274277866,
0.0149964401,
0.3131921291,
-0.7283286452,
-0.4010313153,
0.3645502627,
-0.0359066837,
0.0352482125,
-0.0110277571,
0.5053983331,
-0.5802845955,
-0.0319192708,
-0.1175526604,
-0.7581694722,
0.1450107098,
0.2962223291,
-0.5607566237,
0.4479385614,
-0.3675114512,
-0.8005926609,
0.166691944,
-0.4727012515,
-0.4367175996,
0.3784733713,
-0.4750055075,
-0.352030009,
0.0730250105,
0.7746144533,
0.6692358255,
-0.3714645803,
-0.1851372868,
-0.4665264189,
-0.3452909291,
0.9694778323,
-0.4572491348,
0.7997194529,
0.3350153565,
-0.0907034427,
-0.1201733276,
-0.1950395703,
-0.0117418226,
0.1398739815,
-0.1045669243,
-0.125903964,
-0.1948262304,
0.1998178661,
0.0597701073,
0.6364173293,
-0.7900282741,
0.2383976132,
-0.4418264031,
0.8330801129,
0.641321063,
0.0515866205,
0.5539004803,
-0.0887000859,
0.8092214465,
-0.3098792434,
0.4797010124,
-0.5773441195,
-0.7680669427,
-0.1345753074,
-0.5477966666,
0.33591941,
0.7362769842,
-0.8575459719,
0.6425714493,
-0.1999991983,
-0.3131406903,
-0.516159296,
0.1833544672,
0.2657165229,
0.1935155392,
-0.1436514109,
-0.126746878,
-0.2995378673,
-0.7058048844,
-0.4787442982,
-0.1351131201,
-0.1560574174,
0.5794969797,
0.2521604002,
-0.2502849698,
0.65296942,
-0.5444520116,
-0.2745035291,
-0.1963576227,
-0.1471487582,
0.1601104438,
0.4679237306,
0.2675740719,
-0.8081669211,
-0.4259749055,
-0.2136876285,
-0.542748034,
-0.1683487743,
-0.2814106941,
-0.1173254773,
0.2637064457,
0.3379585445,
-0.9619190097,
0.4315482676,
0.7658498287,
-0.6277948618,
-0.0899221674,
-0.1566094309,
0.377861172,
-1.0474563837,
-0.051925797,
-0.4832927883,
-0.5203566551,
-0.6415603161,
0.100455448,
0.197351709,
-0.6375695467,
-0.5213249326,
0.4448588789,
-0.4520253837,
0.1252911836,
-0.1647829264,
0.0357583538,
-0.2992829978,
0.2095984071,
-0.1163517535,
0.6976773739,
0.8140338063,
-0.1095339805,
0.2273736894,
0.727887094,
-0.2155513167,
0.3801255524,
-0.5075579882,
0.6406588554,
0.2393927872,
0.0990749151,
-0.8779932857,
-0.2754543424,
0.5786401033,
-0.8262580633,
0.1996581405,
-0.2804487646,
-0.8295570016,
0.043634627,
-0.4500422478,
-0.0125126,
0.8050336838,
-0.7020338774,
0.6972557902,
0.4111912549,
-0.4075175524,
-0.5400360823,
-1.0456939936,
0.5932956338,
-0.1982064694,
-0.8415765166,
0.1493013352,
-0.2503711581,
0.1173315644,
-0.3405221403,
0.0684647262,
-0.3771927357,
0.5278717875,
0.800052762,
0.2005344182,
0.5264988542,
-0.0528244227,
0.2066898495,
-0.1402674913,
0.1494372934,
0.0139862709,
0.7530094385,
0.0861110985,
-0.4093690217,
-0.7143295407,
0.4923312068,
0.5469695926,
-0.0755414143,
0.9903388619,
0.2562453449,
-0.5093817711,
-0.3025074303,
-0.5216457844,
-0.6068848968,
-0.558591187,
-0.0013282119,
-0.3558005691,
-1.2200497389,
0.6929386854,
0.0821014494,
-0.0080576902,
-0.3079380393,
0.62063694,
-0.1393234581,
1.0375256538,
0.284671694,
-0.1846963167,
0.8185304403,
0.4364264607,
0.3654118478,
-0.6502315998,
-0.2515063882,
-0.4993942678,
0.1285416037,
-0.5958289504,
-0.0862022191,
0.1395941973,
0.0741845667,
-0.2172870636,
0.2246116847,
-0.4341207445,
0.5103794336,
0.3275553286,
0.3807948232,
0.3240686059,
0.3431529403,
0.2838434875,
-0.2231998891,
-0.3634551167,
-0.4524828792,
1.0092954636,
0.4288555682,
1.1658481359,
0.1543873996,
1.1237475872,
0.2527195811,
-0.0486585796,
-0.6861621737,
0.5498633981,
0.0821719691,
-0.359366715,
-0.3056081235,
-0.5154204965,
-1.1411319971,
0.2650692165,
-0.3507355452,
-1.108877182,
-0.1749149412,
0.2437589467,
-0.2408322841,
0.1184795946,
-0.38518852,
0.5008473396,
-0.3564743698,
-0.1346689612,
-0.0547469631,
-0.6826902628,
0.2322034687,
-0.3079377413,
0.2575199008,
-0.1314295679,
-0.3391099274,
0.5752099156,
-0.4663327038,
0.8920007944,
-0.0726598799,
0.2549464405,
0.1153657213,
0.3455186486,
0.936943233,
0.3871087134,
0.3021182418,
0.3283751309,
-0.1542500556,
0.0273990948,
-0.8401024938,
1.0063197613,
-0.4815629423,
-0.7509982586,
-0.3211776018,
-0.3773395121,
-0.0903221369,
0.0374550819,
0.1761674732,
0.2129817009,
0.0786619112,
0.3573007882,
0.4520095289,
-0.2196385115,
0.4473667443,
0.3101572096,
-0.3525506556,
-0.7434685826,
0.5698011518,
-0.0241127387,
0.1419806182,
0.6078556776,
0.2912491262,
-0.64754498,
-0.408293575,
-0.4970116317,
0.0847831815,
-0.9385969043,
-0.1932820082,
-0.6715613604,
0.0452188924,
-0.5121483803,
-0.382101953,
-0.0742227361,
-0.7045860887,
-0.2505064011,
-0.004368729,
0.5746330619,
0.2559070587,
0.2868792415,
0.3783701062,
-0.8500947356,
0.2284310609,
0.0597262122,
0.0236561447,
-0.2274168283,
-0.4051471651,
-0.0043451865,
-0.0585003011,
0.0243896432,
-0.9589276314,
0.4804711342,
0.0293797031,
0.380433619,
0.3966867924,
0.1241704822,
0.3312850296,
-0.468365252,
0.7982506752,
0.4191874862,
-1.2908214331,
0.524356842,
-0.2129645497,
0.3150531352,
0.7064522505,
-0.0240246635,
-0.8219316602,
-0.5018113852,
-0.5452333093,
-0.9373210073,
0.4689479768,
0.6109771132,
0.1476944834,
0.1005821973,
0.2476638258,
0.0061088931,
0.4588125646,
-0.5983777642,
-0.2963641882,
-0.1273177117,
-0.507943809,
0.1604745537,
-0.2818429172,
-0.0085441675,
0.1826592237,
0.2374873012,
0.0466099605,
0.4318135679,
0.0160163771,
-0.1575066,
0.3615912497,
0.6474276781,
0.2457979321,
0.2355320007,
0.0396410301,
0.2284333259,
0.2635166645,
-0.7145491242,
0.1014973596,
0.0757430792,
-0.3849076033,
-0.2631351352,
0.3242678344,
0.4269667268,
0.2460311353,
-0.673130095,
0.7758992314,
-0.377007246,
0.2151782513,
-0.5724592209,
-0.1235320717,
0.0904070958,
0.0381511785,
0.1355730593,
-0.254393667,
0.1860860437,
-0.3542229533,
-0.0283056926,
0.3866361678,
-0.1818757206,
-0.2833967805,
0.620266974,
0.2387197167,
-0.4753079414,
0.662524581,
0.2898640633,
-0.6006571651,
0.5300571918,
0.6387222409,
1.1384949684,
-0.478362143,
0.0779890791,
-0.0944911167,
0.545320034,
-0.0980765074,
0.7009967566,
-0.2388645858,
-0.5080019236,
0.0446927398,
-0.3140798509,
-0.6589415073,
-0.2604819238,
-0.4604498148,
0.0102782212,
-0.9437878132,
-0.1512655318,
-0.2839903831,
-0.5011443496,
-0.7750948668,
0.0904623941,
0.4322847724,
0.7626408339,
-0.7537531257,
0.6413741112,
0.4478131533,
-0.1695747823,
-0.4993124008,
-0.1622081846,
0.1021059379,
-1.0485289097,
0.4220801294,
0.3631121516,
0.0004019671,
-0.3468610942,
-0.658914566,
-0.8565453291,
0.9706885815,
0.510016799,
-1.1179367304,
0.3340366781,
0.5641711354,
0.1939835548,
-0.42568174,
0.2761490643,
0.3719353676,
0.5112038255,
-0.0381361768,
-0.6351275444,
0.6950631738,
0.1853813827,
0.0335823186,
0.1363022476,
-0.3648107946,
0.6448968649,
-0.1054136679,
-0.5953407884,
0.0861127898,
0.320607841,
0.4355452657,
0.1228090823,
0.4687240124,
0.1582382023,
0.9190095663,
-0.1084560826,
1.1813874245,
-0.7356945276,
0.2895486355,
0.7011691928,
-0.2145577371,
0.9338365197,
0.6438477635,
-0.0134399543,
-0.0748773515,
0.5825804472,
-0.0029331837,
0.681419909,
0.2489376813,
-0.467123121,
-0.3895376623,
-0.3246106803,
-0.1980669051,
0.097862117,
0.4487323463,
-0.5722553134,
0.250094533,
0.1495467275,
0.2544164956,
0.0563547686,
-0.3026123047,
0.6870518327,
0.5051684976,
-0.406642288,
0.5554264188,
-0.193834126,
0.6076213717,
-0.4708086252,
0.2227992564,
0.1019474715,
0.0146435285,
-0.3850559294,
-0.9539883137,
0.031482324,
0.0555697307,
0.2578591406,
-0.1353796721,
0.8652192354,
-0.4520733953,
-0.4589695334,
0.1801734269,
0.2513226867,
0.1950291395,
-0.302511394,
-0.9740427136,
0.4716050625,
-0.0258129295,
-0.4836155772,
0.2804280818,
0.0119206151,
0.1153537855,
1.1081968546,
0.7034927607,
0.1449781656,
-0.1422916204,
0.4551532567,
0.7132837772,
-0.8271417618,
-1.0136380196,
-1.3055019379,
0.1541684717,
-0.0857274458,
-0.0664723739,
1.0040271282,
0.1818289459,
0.3767085075,
-0.0334161669,
0.8533214331,
0.1454216391,
0.2159053236,
-0.8082925081,
0.8440619111,
-0.0820984095,
0.3056331575,
-0.0704148561,
-0.7222172022,
-0.4636304975,
0.1916250885,
-0.1890803277,
-0.0132750729,
0.5728309751,
0.8695403337,
0.3328994811,
0.1607667357,
0.5121415257,
0.10633149,
0.4945957363,
0.570941329,
1.076274991,
-0.1311781257,
0.3604255021,
-0.2577707469,
-0.2174199373,
-0.1466554552,
-0.72231704,
-1.4345221519,
-0.3389151394,
-0.1724442542,
-0.1512271613,
0.2607249022,
0.9180347323,
0.4476895034,
-0.5936819911,
0.1294602305,
-0.2272693813,
0.0157594569,
-0.0309141241,
-0.0897583812,
0.4292401969,
-0.0439314097,
-0.4624920487,
0.482291013,
0.1939329207,
0.2952738106,
-0.1705430001,
0.0063394317,
0.4280675948,
0.280009985,
0.250020206,
0.2949133217,
-0.9861702323,
-0.1488247663,
-0.1588646024,
-0.1377713233,
0.0668241903,
0.6756793261,
-0.3260781765,
0.4252614379,
0.7206113935,
0.8386753798,
0.4652128816,
0.2460392118,
0.2690098584,
-0.6389607191,
0.1229731664,
0.1864941567,
0.6510711312,
0.6423636675,
-1.0483666658,
0.096678257,
-0.2454706132,
-0.7875169516,
-0.7412416339,
0.3804368377,
-1.1199587584,
-0.1225983426,
0.987152338,
-0.3314984441,
-0.4815234542,
-0.1293213516,
-0.3889677823,
-0.2596539557,
-1.0745068789,
0.7570232153,
0.412607789,
0.1792202443,
-0.5215615034,
-0.3599362969,
0.6226637363,
0.3895428777,
-0.923275888,
0.4259156287,
0.0740989596,
0.2937203348,
-0.1096336544,
0.5034624338,
-0.1471846402,
0.1924365461,
-0.1669909954,
0.0937680081,
-0.4768468738,
-0.3046227098,
-0.6844383478,
0.316876471,
0.2236506194,
-0.2493265122
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05864v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05864v1
|
Permute-and-Flip: An optimally robust and watermarkable decoder for LLMs
| 2024-02-08T17:54:23 | 2024-02-08T17:54:23 |
Xuandong Zhao, Lei Li, Yu-Xiang Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
In this paper, we propose a new decoding method called Permute-and-Flip (PF)
decoder. It enjoys robustness properties similar to the standard sampling
decoder, but is provably up to 2x better in its quality-robustness tradeoff
than sampling and never worse than any other decoder. We also design a
cryptographic watermarking scheme analogous to Aaronson's Gumbel watermark, but
naturally tailored for PF decoder. The watermarking scheme does not change the
distribution to sample, while allowing arbitrarily low false positive rate and
high recall whenever the generated text has high entropy. Our experiments show
that the PF decoder (and its watermarked counterpart) significantly
outperform(s) naive sampling (and it's Gumbel watermarked counterpart) in terms
of perplexity, while retaining the same robustness (and detectability), hence
making it a promising new approach for LLM decoding. The code is available at
https://github.com/XuandongZhao/pf-decoding
|
[
-0.0207961779,
-0.3813557029,
0.3812067807,
0.3104609549,
-0.7028486133,
0.2063558847,
0.349511981,
-0.2871256769,
0.3201258183,
0.589904964,
-0.4829180837,
-0.6105612516,
-0.6922886372,
0.04388313,
-0.719337523,
0.4910586476,
0.04210978,
0.1463880688,
-0.0166317467,
-0.0843832195,
0.2862932086,
-0.735645175,
-0.4795698822,
-0.6597544551,
0.1351347566,
0.1815792918,
0.8031651378,
0.8703620434,
0.5121023059,
0.1875810772,
-0.341699332,
0.0688617229,
-0.636433363,
0.1773435026,
0.150011465,
-0.5189442039,
-0.6502292752,
-0.0689964145,
0.6045783758,
0.3920201361,
-0.0491111055,
0.0962401554,
0.0414214358,
0.8242285252,
-0.9854655266,
-0.0023983279,
-0.8384113908,
0.1380456388,
-0.4565622211,
-0.7980259061,
-0.402669847,
-0.3323316574,
-0.5270097852,
-0.6381468773,
-0.0753888488,
0.1903446913,
0.6927700043,
0.1551990211,
-0.2782029212,
-0.0877410993,
-0.7109891772,
0.7665219307,
-0.721412003,
0.3515168428,
0.3253058493,
0.3908553421,
-0.2270802855,
-0.7139779329,
-0.5693746209,
0.3169334829,
0.4900695384,
0.414075315,
-0.2884898186,
-0.1767765135,
0.0731562451,
0.7393912673,
-0.3957317472,
-0.1822980344,
0.3820513487,
-0.3263804317,
0.5737361908,
0.5370876193,
0.0927804559,
0.2867444456,
-0.6567792892,
-0.4625818431,
-1.0468283892,
0.1076802164,
0.9499061108,
-0.1771824062,
0.1262958497,
0.4131770134,
-0.0250278544,
0.5038419366,
0.0889523998,
-0.4280813336,
0.2802633047,
-0.2852642238,
-0.2367436737,
-0.0992681235,
0.5545854568,
0.4219133258,
0.1262159497,
-0.3096889257,
-0.5048219562,
-0.1739143431,
0.0759653151,
-0.8193141222,
-0.399024725,
0.1228655577,
-0.733822763,
-0.5885517597,
0.3240727484,
-0.75286901,
-0.3768671751,
0.1241437718,
0.4660469592,
-0.5665975213,
-0.4615763426,
0.6970363855,
-0.1461249143,
0.5790892243,
0.2051612288,
-0.7796143889,
0.4065197706,
0.7646282911,
0.5513337255,
-0.3422096074,
-0.2791955471,
-0.5287906528,
0.3029322326,
-0.1947160661,
0.9687703848,
-0.4116153419,
-0.4707023501,
0.077090092,
-0.222425878,
0.2166173905,
-0.8571754098,
0.4875701964,
-0.7957544923,
-0.311350286,
-0.1710329354,
-0.6203696132,
-0.014711624,
0.0130583309,
-0.9360684752,
0.6379396915,
-0.0571807101,
-1.0166277885,
0.121696122,
-0.2836839557,
-0.5560825467,
-0.0281712189,
0.1298986226,
-0.7065194249,
-0.0104988292,
0.4148102403,
0.2829011679,
-0.2094000876,
-0.330147028,
-0.2883372009,
-0.7121071815,
0.7722196579,
-0.6820062399,
0.9786319137,
0.2413649261,
-0.1920369267,
-0.2176743746,
-0.9154517055,
0.0998684093,
0.4905955791,
-0.8277130127,
-0.0053837956,
0.1139693335,
0.1973839104,
-0.4585421681,
0.2950820327,
-0.3589072227,
0.0045236172,
-0.351667583,
0.4503253698,
0.7343349457,
0.0597789548,
0.6418188214,
-0.4909489155,
0.5632331371,
0.1487540156,
0.1612223238,
-0.2332920879,
-0.3717644513,
-0.4444947243,
-0.6727989912,
0.345346123,
0.882452786,
-0.8949657679,
0.4532765448,
-0.2560101151,
-0.0254455637,
-0.3391456306,
0.4306666255,
0.1747864485,
0.3219079077,
0.4564543366,
-0.3113307059,
-0.4374064207,
-0.5742497444,
-0.4801140726,
-0.0805222914,
-0.1648629308,
0.0124637531,
0.3576594889,
-0.2366000414,
0.7637392282,
-0.3040366173,
0.041726239,
-0.3037742972,
-0.0496185534,
0.3772461116,
0.4387322366,
0.2997594476,
-0.7406308055,
-0.3097692132,
-0.4260870814,
-0.4895373583,
-0.2437278032,
-0.0729011595,
-0.4356721938,
0.0870678872,
0.5773509741,
-0.3056787252,
0.5392608643,
0.5669162869,
-0.3292497993,
0.5902482867,
-0.0884610116,
-0.1852955967,
-0.9909819365,
0.0734575242,
-0.55233109,
-0.4654185474,
-0.4552046657,
0.0233762618,
0.3118158579,
0.1812909395,
-0.4195473194,
0.3603869379,
-0.6469489336,
-0.044929523,
-0.5334174633,
-0.4288784266,
-0.0888358876,
0.0987177417,
-0.0038024234,
0.8586232662,
0.5381626487,
-0.2980229557,
0.4188138545,
0.1804402769,
-0.3605186045,
0.6593803763,
-0.4071628451,
0.4214825332,
-0.1940229833,
0.2513575256,
-0.9931902885,
0.1369055212,
0.4144696593,
-0.4461840093,
0.5461946726,
-0.3336085081,
-0.5765613914,
0.0034673109,
-0.8029008508,
0.5845839977,
0.7305409312,
-0.8560044169,
0.4836449325,
0.2633674443,
0.2824558914,
-0.5287358165,
-0.8540632725,
0.236216709,
-0.1623614877,
-0.4869144559,
0.5957263708,
-0.1248486191,
-0.0394025035,
0.0242603533,
-0.541282773,
0.1230012476,
0.1022952944,
0.296243161,
0.0180770848,
-0.1994279772,
-0.6279841065,
-0.0417800061,
-0.8693550825,
-0.0376720503,
-0.5480622649,
0.6039317846,
-0.15162009,
-0.5913848877,
-0.3558088541,
0.4530840814,
0.4400203228,
-0.1381754577,
0.5095572472,
0.5194077492,
-0.3427137733,
-0.0277277976,
-0.4241910279,
-0.1564390659,
-0.5431928039,
0.0405938886,
-0.3579168022,
-0.7447248101,
0.5367509723,
-0.1423248947,
-0.0189285204,
-0.0883329138,
0.5209817886,
-0.4341424704,
0.7168306708,
0.6442552209,
-0.2430927455,
0.5318710208,
-0.4755093157,
0.3519639969,
-0.8287478685,
-0.061405275,
-0.2813563943,
-0.3926116526,
-0.1859343946,
-0.498934269,
0.2616531253,
0.537191391,
-0.1710544676,
0.2322326899,
-0.4381295145,
0.6109595299,
0.6050627232,
0.1217921078,
0.6102215648,
0.5510374904,
-0.0587464832,
-0.0974015817,
-0.634839952,
-0.7551006079,
1.3998721838,
0.2544198036,
1.2602641582,
0.0410516001,
1.1182845831,
-0.0492921025,
0.2114851326,
-0.5886175036,
0.6679652929,
-0.06558007,
-0.3212264478,
-0.2362861186,
-0.4667496979,
-1.2675305605,
0.3048287332,
-0.2653420269,
-0.5027186871,
0.1358394027,
0.0901757404,
0.0055075716,
0.7332459688,
-0.2131055593,
0.2290245146,
-0.2272119671,
-0.1882973611,
-0.0270166881,
-0.4235192239,
0.1801936179,
0.2425888032,
0.101668112,
-0.1174400598,
-0.3346301615,
0.5953304172,
-0.3179097176,
0.4810579717,
-0.1803645045,
-0.3079253435,
0.1804611981,
0.4146806896,
0.4982626438,
0.4467203319,
-0.1867509186,
0.1061355993,
0.1572407931,
-0.5815091133,
-0.4750283062,
0.3672997057,
-0.7393884063,
-0.4950733483,
-0.4974063635,
-0.416826427,
-0.1161820516,
0.1094858423,
0.592867732,
0.3297694921,
0.1293615401,
0.0856366456,
0.9077723026,
-0.1353335083,
0.4847765565,
0.5594729185,
-0.0472617261,
-0.8316778541,
1.1009360552,
-0.2719329298,
0.0701328143,
0.856495142,
-0.0674353093,
-0.2741380632,
-0.9704415202,
-0.2122002244,
0.1788625568,
-0.9075341225,
-0.5487847924,
-0.3010075092,
-0.3966307342,
-0.2439192832,
-0.1517564356,
-0.4459348917,
-0.1825968474,
-0.4157896042,
0.0371653959,
0.1329106987,
0.2190698683,
-0.2306724638,
0.0633241087,
-0.5566216707,
0.6330744624,
0.4826745391,
0.3327398896,
-0.1434203237,
-0.589515388,
0.0887436494,
-0.1164488941,
-0.3563186228,
-1.1459031105,
0.3054262102,
0.0020226554,
0.7367602587,
0.5665681362,
0.25575158,
0.351305306,
-0.3007492721,
0.5191346407,
0.2667419314,
-1.0194511414,
0.1331031471,
-0.0995941311,
0.3067448139,
0.6000333428,
-0.0540827848,
-0.2331715822,
-0.3251981437,
-0.4520852864,
-1.2992569208,
0.4426831305,
0.3487837911,
0.3078791499,
0.2036302239,
0.3982344866,
0.2492475212,
0.1479634345,
-0.8343179822,
-0.5573081374,
-0.7342259288,
-0.2984320819,
0.169070363,
-0.7830713987,
-0.1377034485,
-0.1366482526,
0.5502121449,
-0.2226415277,
0.9397820234,
0.1873770654,
-0.4441505075,
-0.0843387023,
0.2601277828,
0.4946087897,
0.3603748083,
-0.3140545189,
0.6297538877,
0.1620028019,
-0.8259567618,
0.3831136525,
-0.160298124,
-0.3445291221,
-0.1025273576,
0.6149741411,
0.6336070299,
-0.044161018,
-0.4211111963,
0.6759444475,
-0.0131902425,
-0.5167845488,
-0.0948166549,
0.0319486558,
0.3059962094,
0.4424673319,
0.6814819574,
-0.2307980061,
0.181469515,
-0.265394479,
-0.0164952874,
0.5145349503,
0.3154209554,
-0.3225991726,
0.753397584,
-0.0105676726,
-0.4293870926,
0.3606655002,
-0.3238734901,
-0.6103926897,
0.3233065009,
0.8483828306,
0.8767192364,
0.135384053,
-0.0592000894,
0.0237732772,
0.3852469921,
-0.1729584038,
0.6132716537,
-0.2892613709,
-0.9656381011,
0.0433661379,
-0.6772124171,
-0.63477391,
0.2563084662,
-0.747705698,
-0.110550493,
-0.6203622222,
-0.0566249005,
-0.5747497678,
-0.1945421398,
-0.4353962839,
0.0003617716,
0.2858670056,
1.1510591507,
-0.4376797378,
1.1261188984,
0.7930493355,
0.2926093638,
-0.3571162522,
0.3457328379,
0.0099048764,
-1.1573385,
0.1196458712,
0.037299566,
-0.4940527081,
0.011066475,
-0.7836993337,
-0.9539266825,
1.5256259441,
0.7381793261,
-0.3980975449,
0.4642544985,
0.2826728225,
0.1873793751,
-0.1525641829,
-0.0404893756,
0.7020870447,
0.5020671487,
0.0634639412,
-0.3338946998,
0.1756963879,
-0.434209168,
0.2310703546,
-0.1041923165,
-0.4951113164,
0.5494663119,
0.1252872497,
-0.4423253238,
0.3861768842,
0.5116623044,
0.3535032868,
0.2578339875,
0.5039274096,
0.5710001588,
0.6432592273,
-0.1231153607,
1.0762344599,
-0.5668362975,
0.3414697647,
0.6503604054,
-0.3309182823,
0.946500957,
0.886839211,
-0.4403139651,
0.1431604773,
0.2922536433,
0.0237777364,
0.9368215203,
0.4045228064,
-0.374381572,
-0.614215672,
0.6709998846,
-0.3592574298,
0.0321733169,
0.214658469,
-0.1399638504,
-0.2632808089,
-0.1871942282,
-0.1764445007,
0.1181099042,
-0.1924393922,
0.4959263206,
0.2617956102,
-0.0378978588,
0.7338573933,
0.3257876635,
1.156434536,
-0.4128204286,
0.3379971087,
-0.4936672747,
0.2195681781,
-0.3071998358,
-0.9751944542,
0.2402868867,
-0.3028276265,
-0.0831915066,
-0.6399179101,
0.9805205464,
-0.282092154,
-0.2892092168,
0.3522214293,
0.2982717156,
0.2406954616,
-0.1316961348,
-0.5480076671,
0.3168355227,
-0.1111868918,
-0.4939201474,
0.3081283271,
0.1900029629,
0.3280017078,
0.7843313217,
0.7967820764,
0.0944729,
0.413598448,
-0.0798638612,
0.5675836205,
-0.7700294256,
-0.4463874996,
-0.9628475308,
0.2138455212,
0.2042258978,
-0.0272252914,
0.552084744,
0.6227989793,
0.6829710007,
-0.1811182946,
0.7584764361,
0.4693021774,
0.1862273216,
-0.9146318436,
0.6238797903,
-0.5278893113,
0.4109326303,
-0.1840836853,
-0.9147644043,
-0.4465336204,
0.8902484775,
-0.01841137,
-0.1439699978,
0.570971787,
0.9872535467,
-0.1154388338,
0.069129698,
0.3756504655,
-0.1646295488,
0.3340180516,
0.9707380533,
1.027312398,
-0.6108195186,
0.8585467935,
-0.1303804666,
-0.1476064622,
-0.4782130718,
-1.0586979389,
-0.8616508842,
-0.4004312456,
-0.3254716098,
-0.4652222991,
0.0641878247,
0.457482338,
0.6170502901,
-0.8639702201,
-0.1550989449,
-0.1609764397,
0.4635208249,
-0.5004323721,
-0.1177627593,
0.2115288228,
0.0129503151,
-0.5843390822,
0.372846514,
0.6581554413,
0.5557224154,
0.0202005394,
-0.4629259706,
0.1934267581,
0.2950876057,
0.2600932717,
0.2108628601,
-0.3036673367,
0.1890913695,
-0.0173498522,
-0.2870735526,
0.3958257437,
1.1471716166,
-0.3770361841,
0.0062569724,
0.594506979,
0.8371534944,
0.9626396298,
-0.1778851002,
0.16343759,
-0.2618615627,
0.2612009346,
0.248567149,
0.3778260946,
0.3068962693,
-0.2616646588,
0.2889307141,
0.6061578393,
-0.0955912694,
-0.9751867652,
0.2417836934,
-1.0708507299,
-0.1729377508,
1.2663314342,
-0.1867414564,
-0.3890939653,
-0.1279489249,
-0.1368977129,
0.0285572428,
-0.167218715,
0.6440448761,
0.6989388466,
0.0165204816,
-0.3164204657,
-0.1378304511,
0.3374547064,
0.6694658399,
-0.53451401,
-0.1517972052,
-0.0826804042,
0.752779305,
-0.1223219484,
0.9149886966,
-0.6212749481,
0.4398111701,
0.1688082516,
-0.019270625,
-0.5228136182,
-0.1901398301,
-0.5965024233,
0.3143051863,
0.1623246968,
-0.2967863679
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05863v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05863v1
|
How Well Can LLMs Negotiate? NegotiationArena Platform and Analysis
| 2024-02-08T17:51:48 | 2024-02-08T17:51:48 |
Federico Bianchi, Patrick John Chia, Mert Yuksekgonul, Jacopo Tagliabue, Dan Jurafsky, James Zou
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.GT
|
Negotiation is the basis of social interactions; humans negotiate everything
from the price of cars to how to share common resources. With rapidly growing
interest in using large language models (LLMs) to act as agents on behalf of
human users, such LLM agents would also need to be able to negotiate. In this
paper, we study how well LLMs can negotiate with each other. We develop
NegotiationArena: a flexible framework for evaluating and probing the
negotiation abilities of LLM agents. We implemented three types of scenarios in
NegotiationArena to assess LLM's behaviors in allocating shared resources
(ultimatum games), aggregate resources (trading games) and buy/sell goods
(price negotiations). Each scenario allows for multiple turns of flexible
dialogues between LLM agents to allow for more complex negotiations.
Interestingly, LLM agents can significantly boost their negotiation outcomes by
employing certain behavioral tactics. For example, by pretending to be desolate
and desperate, LLMs can improve their payoffs by 20\% when negotiating against
the standard GPT-4. We also quantify irrational negotiation behaviors exhibited
by the LLM agents, many of which also appear in humans. Together,
\NegotiationArena offers a new environment to investigate LLM interactions,
enabling new insights into LLM's theory of mind, irrationality, and reasoning
abilities.
|
[
-0.64511168,
-0.7184452415,
0.7508749962,
0.1864078343,
-0.2377160788,
0.2857739329,
-0.4211146832,
-0.7753767371,
0.647446394,
0.3218097687,
-0.2890074849,
-0.2920186222,
-0.6126391888,
0.1374077052,
0.0767735094,
0.4485232234,
0.0676300228,
0.1014270335,
0.1439362317,
-0.5794376135,
-0.4762585759,
-0.8752002716,
-1.1958626509,
-0.5591633916,
0.7329850793,
0.3261787295,
0.8509312272,
0.1135976687,
0.3958806992,
0.5081838965,
-0.2873091698,
0.0083414866,
-0.5504456162,
0.5106133819,
-0.4744326174,
-0.5471431017,
-0.6215696335,
0.2130795419,
0.1776778996,
0.3752479553,
-0.42056337,
0.1193223298,
0.0436480045,
0.5057839751,
-0.3134476244,
0.1869055778,
-0.9849379063,
0.1514755636,
-0.1368701011,
-0.1371918768,
-0.3008129597,
-0.3218419552,
-0.0228219274,
-0.6498883963,
-0.3681658506,
0.055837974,
0.8612117767,
0.2173105776,
-0.507810533,
-0.3711435199,
-0.5409098268,
0.4817602038,
-0.4852972031,
-0.0540008396,
0.3285498321,
0.4827370942,
-0.5173811913,
-0.8352048993,
-0.7111611962,
-0.4025425911,
0.1006141603,
0.3118158281,
-0.5120020509,
0.0031115415,
0.2131497711,
0.2290542424,
-0.281286329,
0.2996774614,
-0.3559237123,
-0.0445879996,
0.7648895383,
0.3570802212,
0.3789562285,
-0.1075952426,
-0.5672129989,
-0.0662358031,
-0.4135558903,
0.1531187743,
0.527161181,
0.2780946791,
0.1201544479,
0.6678622365,
0.0701706409,
0.4875017107,
-0.1239845902,
0.3157447577,
-0.3000611067,
-0.1342500597,
-0.4327013195,
-0.2583165467,
0.6995226145,
0.6188138723,
0.4336999953,
-0.2064220309,
-0.2481357306,
0.291341722,
0.3910599649,
-0.3623224199,
0.0939421505,
0.2059433609,
-0.8546923995,
-0.4075931907,
-0.3462908268,
-1.0633960962,
-0.3061410487,
-0.3279576898,
0.5537586212,
0.0277687423,
-0.4980737269,
0.3202741742,
-0.1287766695,
0.5617504716,
0.288795501,
-0.7039136291,
0.8300927281,
0.4248800576,
0.8319179416,
-0.1596810371,
-0.595328033,
-0.3500191569,
-0.0166739635,
-0.2307299227,
0.8883751035,
-0.3970919549,
-0.583878994,
-0.1145742163,
-0.4502499104,
-0.2402297854,
-0.6583987474,
0.4296315312,
-0.7394667864,
-0.3476298153,
-0.4118852317,
-0.4654521644,
-0.0224826187,
0.80058074,
-0.9488092065,
0.3870554268,
-0.164351359,
-0.3027124405,
0.110832572,
-0.8371694088,
-0.2816142738,
0.1066764444,
-0.1908518225,
0.0140025988,
0.0507312007,
-0.2167058438,
0.385078609,
-0.5372006297,
0.1421708018,
-0.3203443289,
-0.2527146041,
1.1372262239,
-0.372005105,
0.4713312685,
0.4228954911,
-0.1670011729,
0.2825962901,
-0.0119867828,
-0.1067126766,
0.3871613145,
-0.4605780244,
-0.003657683,
-0.1046502441,
0.175256148,
0.3197917938,
0.4262634814,
-0.2566735446,
0.6596242785,
-0.2083283663,
0.6564914584,
0.8034287095,
-0.0462681055,
0.4739274085,
-0.6020858288,
0.8595222831,
-0.4946673512,
0.3221492767,
0.6920349598,
-0.4280280173,
-0.8139570951,
0.0469179936,
0.0586634651,
0.3726626039,
-0.6648830175,
-0.1786014289,
-0.0277330205,
-0.4196696579,
-0.3650885522,
-0.0252897721,
0.3723976016,
0.1202549636,
0.2234141678,
-0.1219297647,
-0.4140938222,
-0.754709959,
-0.4190195501,
-0.2194073796,
0.2247523069,
0.1447686851,
0.3427131772,
0.0055961069,
0.6818175912,
-0.2671222389,
-0.4015522301,
-0.6166923046,
0.3909839988,
-0.1144405156,
0.1616525501,
0.6141775846,
-0.8504489064,
-0.3327277005,
0.1897747517,
-0.4913651347,
0.3558038473,
-0.1161470562,
-0.3638897538,
0.3022276461,
0.5449883342,
-0.8127189279,
0.5569499731,
0.5912749171,
-0.430837214,
0.5118119717,
-0.280526191,
0.1596506834,
-1.1118135452,
-0.0124797001,
-0.2863242626,
-0.3238767087,
-0.4758505523,
0.2026475519,
-0.522157371,
-0.191996038,
-0.5575056672,
0.5650553107,
-0.4355224967,
-0.3254814744,
-0.3347556889,
0.3132886887,
-0.2896645963,
0.6201796532,
0.1196525469,
0.968031466,
0.3571543396,
-0.7469808459,
0.2424809784,
0.2235187441,
-0.3183348477,
0.5859188437,
-0.8021779656,
0.2460024655,
0.2270589471,
0.380046308,
-0.652864337,
-0.1856995672,
0.3547900319,
-0.2297135741,
-0.0643291697,
-0.1352128088,
-0.3845330775,
0.0460473523,
-0.2215709686,
0.3967267871,
0.3649020791,
-0.3298358917,
1.0074775219,
0.5420041084,
-0.1566882432,
-0.3463663459,
-0.5403209329,
0.4906179905,
-0.4290526807,
-0.5327891707,
0.3012357354,
-0.3471033275,
-0.613894403,
-0.095528096,
0.1813056767,
-0.1825194359,
0.2051483542,
0.0395377874,
0.1017773524,
0.0257412065,
-0.0426981859,
-0.0655155927,
-0.3777801096,
0.1153760999,
0.1331944317,
0.8227052689,
-0.3746364713,
-0.4012699127,
-0.1439013034,
0.2737437487,
0.8366170526,
-0.2317813784,
0.7969207168,
0.1309647411,
-0.4343188405,
0.2169739902,
-0.5238758326,
-0.0919480845,
-0.4708860219,
0.1949802041,
-0.6474063993,
-0.8630461693,
0.9874606133,
-0.4333101809,
-0.1172252968,
0.2634176016,
0.6221757531,
-0.0222506002,
0.9374207258,
0.329805851,
-0.0019946722,
0.0395591892,
-0.1916732192,
0.0638864487,
-0.8729504943,
-0.4065449536,
-0.4295166731,
-0.7445106506,
-0.4546741843,
-0.4650427699,
0.3208882809,
-0.0000290753,
-0.1498979032,
0.2440163195,
-0.2296342552,
0.9170465469,
0.1857538074,
0.1556777209,
0.3937167227,
-0.3080313802,
0.0193029847,
-0.159349069,
-0.4116620123,
-0.7421515584,
0.6712933183,
0.4886290133,
0.4321686924,
0.7019876838,
0.3418884873,
0.1673043668,
0.3173541725,
-1.137554884,
0.8930894732,
0.1424102485,
-0.462908417,
-0.4588943422,
-0.4993034899,
-1.3491829634,
0.3485043347,
-0.2068324089,
-0.8851021528,
0.3262062967,
-0.1771500409,
-0.1753575951,
0.4837890863,
-0.4119772315,
0.7095106244,
-0.5308247805,
-0.3387179971,
-0.6260330081,
-0.4700812399,
0.1952406466,
0.0743685812,
0.0748662278,
-0.2516444325,
-0.1218700036,
0.6403003335,
-0.0024488815,
0.8580435514,
0.0221377574,
-0.0505565405,
0.0261736047,
0.6358591914,
0.4031168222,
0.0224372335,
-0.3640833199,
0.0953436419,
-0.1430265754,
-0.477863878,
-0.8792846203,
0.5503766537,
-0.747410655,
-0.5872225165,
-0.5991300941,
-0.5320930481,
-0.2478382736,
0.0079455748,
0.3539585471,
0.0639964789,
-0.5791597366,
-0.1250044256,
0.3860070109,
0.0959174931,
0.2189018428,
0.5040270686,
-0.305149287,
-0.316067785,
0.6927838326,
0.0673111379,
0.2327573001,
0.016500866,
0.1982601881,
-0.3241663873,
-0.5770165324,
-0.0128908865,
0.1206642091,
-0.7502913475,
-0.4408428073,
-0.2130952626,
-0.1040763259,
0.1195201427,
-0.3965621889,
-0.3176417351,
-0.479629457,
0.0154041657,
-0.3065518439,
0.3837961257,
1.1599285603,
-0.1648363024,
0.3063005507,
-0.5067525506,
0.021081781,
0.6007555723,
0.1640959531,
0.2350360602,
-0.205491364,
-0.0762247294,
-0.1109337434,
-0.135198608,
-1.0314310789,
0.3734771907,
-0.2615973949,
0.6768028736,
0.1617785394,
0.1545274854,
0.6552143097,
-0.1197993979,
0.8058503866,
0.1367866248,
-1.2045404911,
0.2784236073,
-0.2939307392,
-0.1245722696,
0.5770283341,
0.1284936965,
-0.4250498414,
-0.2316730618,
-0.5341980457,
-0.9754882455,
0.4600489736,
0.3745177984,
0.2365892977,
0.1196023896,
0.3711855114,
-0.0798485577,
0.2470951676,
-0.9110068679,
-0.1977840513,
0.1759446263,
0.0752636492,
0.0564465523,
-0.2705111504,
-0.5784121156,
-0.096827358,
0.3636445105,
-0.000490961,
0.2329636365,
-0.027497353,
-0.1202006787,
0.010220102,
0.4332630038,
0.7166790366,
0.7492141724,
-0.0075337775,
0.1835832149,
0.4087260664,
-0.147770077,
0.2650294602,
0.0741036311,
0.6072360277,
-0.5468440056,
0.1970499009,
0.6162935495,
0.3443246782,
-0.8002716303,
0.3139155209,
-0.769169271,
-0.5853953958,
-0.3458436728,
-0.0403788723,
0.2370225638,
0.8053884506,
0.1260292083,
0.0386454016,
0.1491859406,
-0.5223301649,
0.0058175717,
0.3818921447,
-0.0653091893,
-0.2138916701,
0.4077585638,
0.4480414987,
-0.522328198,
0.5740824342,
-0.2755696476,
-0.8047252297,
0.548797369,
0.3700638711,
0.6876111627,
-0.1206627935,
0.4561595023,
-0.1050065011,
0.3162952363,
0.0120498668,
0.3348524868,
-0.1340131462,
-0.9708111882,
-0.2844952643,
-0.2479120791,
-0.8645619154,
0.0879404619,
-0.7828605175,
-0.1112617925,
-0.3811823428,
-0.4239859283,
-0.2823307812,
0.3053435981,
-0.8137207627,
-0.3674588799,
-0.2097637057,
0.9378653765,
-0.5819274187,
0.6666363478,
0.9122735262,
-0.7989687324,
-1.0019901991,
0.1776026189,
-0.2422552258,
-0.7858680487,
0.6743955612,
-0.0956658944,
-0.5538848042,
-0.0779713616,
-0.7027328014,
-0.4893161654,
1.0485502481,
0.8099548817,
-0.3862305284,
0.143354848,
0.0958708823,
0.4537646174,
-0.3115845025,
0.0840949342,
0.7206078768,
0.8171745539,
0.2650296092,
-0.960613668,
0.1395501643,
-0.2514853776,
-0.1721541137,
-0.085913375,
-1.0173422098,
0.9030657411,
0.078993842,
0.0024967121,
0.4899714589,
0.5324781537,
0.3844749033,
0.5274683833,
0.6330704689,
0.3747140467,
0.9385455847,
0.1298556924,
0.9406033158,
-0.0782000721,
0.2537970245,
0.8173164129,
-0.7991138697,
1.0089640617,
0.5255724192,
-0.061308898,
0.4641029239,
0.6092994213,
0.4777492285,
0.0374758691,
0.5299659967,
-0.4060746729,
-0.5383581519,
-0.2068086863,
-0.0827103853,
0.6382600665,
0.4013655782,
0.217854932,
-0.0231864639,
0.0177234281,
0.2558558285,
0.2802611887,
-0.2049312443,
0.7597632408,
0.2504718304,
-0.4768825471,
0.07986366,
-0.0525158942,
0.5185513496,
-0.5624327064,
0.0014600923,
-0.3254063725,
0.0239036791,
-0.0004713249,
-0.8503658175,
0.304279238,
-0.1360403001,
0.0794566497,
-0.2138133049,
0.8625671864,
-0.2833493948,
-0.1551631689,
0.7170637846,
0.6409314871,
0.3707706034,
0.0587890744,
-0.8150549531,
0.4203904271,
-0.3783132732,
-0.35835132,
0.685076952,
0.5496990681,
0.1473432183,
0.7843321562,
0.5725716949,
0.3338707685,
-0.4871826172,
-0.0185898766,
0.9241431952,
-0.5515534878,
-0.3537466228,
-0.6131345034,
0.4599043131,
-0.2670699358,
-0.202885747,
0.5457402468,
0.1526997387,
0.4385923147,
0.3015644848,
0.4263124168,
0.3578378558,
-0.0426032916,
-1.0422626734,
0.979409039,
-0.5219010711,
0.2129263133,
0.085020788,
-0.8917247057,
0.0096339602,
0.9555135369,
-0.2201742679,
0.1135645583,
0.6556476355,
0.5178837776,
-0.2187612504,
0.1725376844,
0.4273097813,
0.2268411964,
0.3394157887,
0.4703897536,
1.1874438524,
0.0076728067,
0.7907916903,
0.1098528653,
0.0012844785,
-0.0004939283,
-0.7477855682,
-0.7994850874,
-0.5481722951,
-0.0971119776,
-0.3940332234,
0.0866401047,
1.2065725327,
0.6805661917,
-0.1425712556,
-0.7983504534,
0.0525036864,
0.2957917452,
-0.1710356325,
-0.2275087833,
0.0288686454,
-0.1748120785,
-0.7271363735,
0.6396077871,
0.1304755658,
0.1761832386,
-0.4558661878,
-0.4393163919,
-0.0717749074,
0.4460313916,
0.5174128413,
0.4095437825,
-0.456367135,
-0.1333662271,
-0.039998766,
-0.0038951337,
-0.1454413235,
1.1862920523,
-0.6396756172,
0.1526671797,
0.0485653467,
0.5219281316,
0.4227560759,
-0.1753568053,
0.7002447248,
-0.3699376285,
0.3691677153,
0.3571197689,
0.3502159417,
0.0602545254,
-0.2288954556,
0.4685491621,
-0.3333205879,
-0.814103663,
-0.5391798019,
0.5120609403,
-0.8890937567,
-0.4069087207,
0.9319427609,
-0.0426020771,
-0.1049532667,
-0.2340640873,
-0.3582525551,
0.0864780098,
-0.5629150867,
0.7818350196,
0.8581346273,
-0.4281290472,
0.0434459522,
-0.4109992683,
0.3884476423,
0.6306423545,
-0.7004195452,
-0.1753059924,
0.3540970087,
-0.097360298,
0.1043755412,
1.0262016058,
0.2548390627,
0.1432840824,
-0.3591446579,
-0.1286063343,
0.1244042367,
-0.2314649373,
-0.3826307654,
0.0894877911,
0.5548200011,
-0.1281301528
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06690v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06690v1
|
Neural Models for Source Code Synthesis and Completion
| 2024-02-08T17:10:12 | 2024-02-08T17:10:12 |
Mitodru Niyogi
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.PL
|
Natural language (NL) to code suggestion systems assist developers in
Integrated Development Environments (IDEs) by translating NL utterances into
compilable code snippet. The current approaches mainly involve hard-coded,
rule-based systems based on semantic parsing. These systems make heavy use of
hand-crafted rules that map patterns in NL or elements in its syntax parse tree
to various query constructs and can only work on a limited subset of NL with a
restricted NL syntax. These systems are unable to extract semantic information
from the coding intents of the developer, and often fail to infer types, names,
and the context of the source code to get accurate system-level code
suggestions. In this master thesis, we present sequence-to-sequence deep
learning models and training paradigms to map NL to general-purpose programming
languages that can assist users with suggestions of source code snippets, given
a NL intent, and also extend auto-completion functionality of the source code
to users while they are writing source code. The developed architecture
incorporates contextual awareness into neural models which generate source code
tokens directly instead of generating parse trees/abstract meaning
representations from the source code and converting them back to source code.
The proposed pretraining strategy and the data augmentation techniques improve
the performance of the proposed architecture. The proposed architecture has
been found to exceed the performance of a neural semantic parser, TranX, based
on the BLEU-4 metric by 10.82%. Thereafter, a finer analysis for the parsable
code translations from the NL intent for CoNaLA challenge was introduced. The
proposed system is bidirectional as it can be also used to generate NL code
documentation given source code. Lastly, a RoBERTa masked language model for
Python was proposed to extend the developed system for code completion.
|
[
-0.2687611282,
-0.3693193197,
0.4875047803,
0.3497999609,
-0.1162593886,
0.2682509124,
-0.5105482936,
-0.4096627533,
0.1702493131,
0.4979990125,
-0.3939076066,
-0.5812307,
-0.2598442733,
0.3264790773,
-0.5520224571,
0.7403789163,
0.0732476041,
0.0598766319,
-0.0145997619,
0.2125952393,
-0.8609127998,
-0.6060557961,
-0.4800348878,
-0.0847542956,
0.2762426436,
0.3312274516,
0.4262680411,
0.4537862241,
0.3353567719,
0.2905808687,
-0.065617688,
0.109363094,
0.0634969324,
0.2129696608,
-0.0862263069,
-0.3446078897,
-0.4065939188,
-0.2606115341,
0.2773157656,
0.61982584,
0.0538611859,
0.3185409606,
0.1781824976,
0.6200280786,
-0.4738538265,
0.1840402484,
-0.5841131806,
0.0769495368,
0.2806994915,
-0.2907300889,
-0.4993785024,
-0.5057984591,
0.2820317447,
-0.380340308,
0.0543057472,
-0.1812506318,
0.3688930273,
0.5017130971,
0.0282932948,
-0.7666154504,
-0.6344322562,
0.4777098298,
-1.1311631203,
0.2237161696,
0.3534312546,
0.0769946799,
-0.0912043825,
-0.671810329,
-0.3901429474,
-0.5274819136,
-0.1574175656,
-0.2140754014,
-0.0027907563,
0.0975607038,
0.3672094941,
0.2659440637,
-0.7277219892,
-0.1304441541,
-0.4215488434,
-0.1688033342,
0.4924001098,
-0.0799575597,
0.3717355132,
-0.5263440013,
-0.1329785287,
0.2473695129,
-0.6316552758,
0.0022974052,
0.2268242389,
0.435642302,
0.0181666333,
0.4836644828,
-0.3540042639,
1.1796963215,
-0.1111700982,
0.3345508575,
0.1613002568,
-0.6115357876,
-0.4491736293,
0.0015809403,
0.6564904451,
0.1248532236,
0.3393757045,
-0.3327219784,
-0.1480218768,
0.1409986466,
0.4854857326,
-0.3782585561,
-0.0291881617,
0.2700590193,
-0.4933704138,
-0.3348444104,
-0.0370346941,
-0.6035158038,
-0.238828063,
-0.9284840226,
0.1313498616,
-0.4900422394,
-0.307315439,
0.2956444025,
-0.1079000458,
0.0750719085,
0.2181236595,
-0.6467519403,
-0.0559637994,
0.5731485486,
0.6694048047,
0.0553130582,
-0.2540870905,
-0.2266095877,
0.1936650723,
-0.2980521619,
0.3642112315,
-0.6041811109,
-0.1392345876,
0.0831020102,
-0.2163714468,
0.2398483008,
-0.5187225938,
0.115236558,
-0.5963705778,
-0.0969421938,
0.1598882079,
-0.4973137379,
-0.2468893528,
0.1797367036,
-0.4972326159,
0.6450110674,
0.1230120957,
-0.414005816,
0.1010315716,
-0.5594091415,
-0.5187882781,
0.0663183555,
-0.1795442998,
0.0485074669,
0.1655281484,
-0.0457706004,
0.3125733733,
-0.2118803412,
0.7756974101,
0.0928077921,
-0.4918656051,
0.006772961,
-0.0561928563,
0.8265945315,
0.4829128981,
-0.5140246153,
0.4216201603,
-0.8628504276,
0.2120915502,
-0.1812980622,
-0.5696531534,
-0.2958881855,
-0.1211490929,
-0.1085479781,
0.2714067996,
0.2436522245,
-0.0592833236,
0.4115338326,
-0.4485275745,
0.7385500073,
0.529663682,
-0.2214385718,
0.6081283689,
0.140988484,
0.4259721935,
-0.1038582921,
0.0741609186,
-0.3837983906,
-0.4765732288,
-0.8031191826,
0.2306084633,
0.4782274961,
0.6763327718,
-0.9178458452,
0.6434687376,
-0.1677397788,
-0.0870006382,
-0.4446496665,
0.3946883082,
0.536925137,
0.3742154241,
0.3390895724,
-0.357159555,
-1.0529733896,
-0.7979134321,
-0.1317968369,
-0.0517299175,
-0.2015329599,
0.0325630344,
0.2347085178,
-0.302696377,
1.0443102121,
-0.2422055006,
-0.0416292511,
-0.3035341203,
-0.2071223408,
0.5128627419,
0.7725341916,
0.2400668561,
-0.727244854,
-0.3221538067,
-0.0549181662,
-0.710375905,
0.1156575456,
-0.1118331775,
-0.0151114678,
0.148811698,
0.9354931116,
-0.4205309749,
0.518996954,
0.4191414118,
-0.2298189402,
0.4467688203,
-0.2967867255,
-0.3538859487,
-1.2260401249,
0.3747673333,
-0.1837673634,
-0.0170527045,
-0.6068071127,
0.3114530742,
0.2486614436,
-0.3245197535,
-0.3023100495,
0.2352697849,
-0.5396416783,
-0.1715712398,
-0.3205807507,
-0.1875278503,
0.0321386717,
0.7530845404,
0.1272604465,
0.8275635839,
0.580147326,
-0.7592755556,
0.2845012546,
0.1569885761,
-0.3375110924,
-0.0280845687,
-0.7171624303,
0.3621288538,
-0.0158155374,
-0.0076223984,
-0.7144470215,
-0.1335784197,
0.1741505563,
-0.5692796707,
0.2512632012,
-0.4106027186,
-0.3972298801,
-0.3951246142,
0.0101523232,
0.5458897352,
0.5074688196,
-0.2639404237,
0.3408634961,
0.117480576,
-0.1374434829,
-0.5371260643,
-0.7419996262,
0.4099956751,
0.2128491253,
-0.4122225344,
0.3494834006,
-0.1844982952,
0.0378228128,
0.059171062,
0.133373946,
-0.0947888866,
0.0851162523,
0.3155769706,
0.3426996171,
-0.1904343665,
0.04178451,
-0.1330288649,
-0.2401726693,
0.0818445683,
-0.7494193316,
0.5813251734,
-0.2682205737,
-0.2653085887,
-0.09401384,
0.4502431452,
0.351111114,
-0.4500761628,
0.2305087,
0.225812152,
-0.351129204,
-0.347600013,
-0.4596241117,
-0.0392307639,
-0.4449034631,
0.2226617783,
-0.2546291649,
-0.7662581205,
0.4489175975,
-0.1173355654,
-0.0916096345,
0.1779146343,
0.5242677331,
0.2122318596,
0.637822926,
0.6649638414,
-0.1267323196,
0.6175635457,
-0.7459536195,
0.2128359675,
-0.9322136045,
-0.0453982577,
-0.4441688955,
-0.308898896,
-0.2620835602,
-0.3552880287,
0.0641157553,
0.1504890472,
-0.2301062196,
0.7744250298,
-0.972299099,
0.5665000677,
1.0062404871,
0.0663276017,
0.2205820233,
0.041389823,
-0.2815000117,
0.2916812301,
-0.7269999385,
-0.3254413307,
1.0945215225,
0.1188924164,
0.4353076518,
-0.0849726722,
0.7241892219,
0.3410292268,
0.0902282298,
-0.6141528487,
0.5040361881,
-0.0961412117,
-0.4233841598,
-0.141602993,
-0.2422105074,
-0.5990678072,
-0.3025693595,
0.0895494968,
-0.3019569516,
0.4389441609,
-0.0314226486,
-0.7622063756,
0.1008023992,
-0.8724859357,
0.8001846075,
-0.0918028876,
-0.2713080943,
-0.0637563393,
-0.7889618874,
0.2235099524,
0.1482395381,
0.0126479696,
0.1577069759,
0.1774728745,
0.3818981946,
-0.1949652582,
0.9883183837,
-0.1124931127,
-0.1523923129,
0.3952898681,
0.2235109806,
0.2606526911,
0.2567496002,
-0.4360906184,
0.2082623094,
-0.2876370847,
-0.1712394804,
-0.411808759,
0.5951313376,
-0.4514346719,
-0.4604298472,
-0.1061708555,
-0.602250576,
-0.0093733175,
0.4151387215,
0.3170581758,
0.5797206163,
0.1794511527,
-0.0919284746,
0.4412871003,
-0.3625112474,
0.7458668947,
0.3116996884,
-0.1624251306,
-0.5728168488,
0.7917847037,
-0.0982746929,
0.0409752838,
0.1783888936,
-0.3343683481,
-0.0883797705,
-0.8264454007,
-0.6445741057,
-0.0845313892,
-0.6525843143,
-0.6560648084,
-0.2861605585,
-0.5254707336,
-0.4639337957,
-0.2274676263,
-0.0784271359,
-0.3933189511,
-0.2919661105,
-0.0437207855,
0.3097146749,
0.8939422369,
0.1050444841,
0.0354647115,
-0.8012714982,
0.2523612976,
0.2153123319,
0.7146633863,
0.2704872787,
-0.247717768,
-0.4790077507,
0.0995902121,
-0.1530557424,
-0.7941480875,
0.5616639256,
-0.1581984162,
0.362916708,
-0.0968969464,
-0.0762554258,
0.3751062155,
-0.6061290503,
0.6820573211,
0.0901305303,
-1.0787726641,
0.9701991677,
-0.286857307,
0.2805524766,
0.6933745742,
-0.0297680814,
-0.4543275237,
-0.3979226947,
-0.2618153393,
-0.7508539557,
0.6437683702,
0.2023586631,
0.1284290552,
-0.1424924731,
0.6556334496,
0.0554271117,
0.3782130778,
-0.5895580649,
-0.1303314269,
-0.3650718629,
-0.356411159,
0.1239375249,
-0.1928128004,
0.1518468559,
-0.4682284594,
0.2935874462,
-0.3885677159,
0.3440248072,
0.4125112295,
-0.2793660164,
0.106609948,
0.2899287641,
0.9718133807,
0.8722846508,
-0.2562882304,
-0.0446180403,
-0.1680410057,
-0.242127195,
0.0924510136,
0.0343675502,
-0.5752354264,
0.1591606587,
0.1620988101,
0.9359434247,
0.2301521152,
-0.5542610884,
0.3696195781,
-0.0668743849,
0.0362097472,
-0.5663485527,
0.1520861238,
0.2387535125,
0.1982933283,
0.2461476028,
0.610509336,
0.3847376406,
-0.4957677424,
0.2808006406,
0.4475086331,
-0.1912372708,
-0.3530081213,
0.5234633088,
0.362265408,
-0.5937151909,
0.5941303968,
-0.2269939184,
-0.554451704,
0.9752730727,
0.532125473,
1.226367116,
0.0573802888,
0.118509382,
0.5104631186,
0.111140199,
0.047597006,
0.3182148933,
-0.2937789857,
-0.350135237,
-0.7730888724,
-0.7921047211,
-0.0914056748,
-0.1490891427,
-0.4100438654,
0.3419278562,
-0.750375092,
-0.1650870442,
-0.2501969039,
-0.2487740964,
-0.6701476574,
0.0074612363,
0.4010382295,
1.2267341614,
-0.3535039127,
1.1520605087,
0.6520866752,
-0.7240281701,
-0.9333097935,
-0.1526385546,
-0.4073685706,
-0.5587406754,
0.8750653863,
0.0941370204,
0.2128256112,
0.0233983975,
-0.5487875938,
-0.9375237226,
0.8731107116,
0.5236650109,
-0.5573173165,
-0.5949557424,
0.1634445339,
0.5786449909,
-0.5427014232,
0.2735521495,
0.5000864863,
0.360417366,
-0.0141362315,
-1.0221681595,
0.1307739913,
-0.5651461482,
0.4109208584,
0.0637159273,
-0.2723642588,
0.7080075145,
-0.3314332366,
0.0600438863,
0.1766911447,
0.511328578,
0.1477239281,
0.2275556475,
0.1596704572,
0.4449798763,
0.3308935463,
0.1429904252,
1.0943381786,
-0.6826666594,
0.1434018314,
1.1749436855,
-0.0846161023,
0.8925536871,
0.4927935004,
0.0074058576,
0.6622937918,
0.4587397575,
0.0153219914,
0.5515419245,
0.3347527981,
0.1137929633,
0.0552720688,
-0.0559107661,
-0.5425558686,
0.1230851412,
0.3465605676,
-0.5209448338,
-0.1581617743,
-0.0179663245,
-0.4737268984,
0.0815943182,
-0.2604049146,
1.0534832478,
0.1930622905,
-0.902772367,
0.9015011787,
-0.0640559644,
0.8531380892,
-0.6513414979,
-0.2142516822,
-0.4531810284,
0.050599087,
-0.3638018966,
-0.5537757277,
0.6503420472,
-0.0911535248,
-0.4326246977,
-0.2996453047,
0.6392450333,
-0.6132237315,
-0.340211004,
0.4025467634,
0.2643117607,
-0.2815367579,
-0.0270805527,
-0.5708483458,
0.0401069261,
0.2532606721,
0.0996682569,
0.1356620938,
0.2283698618,
0.1425274611,
0.6152694225,
0.7289306521,
0.2376300395,
0.2964675426,
0.1277450323,
0.8506708741,
-0.7815952301,
-0.5109772682,
-0.8137332201,
0.4916712046,
-0.0382586196,
-0.1073463261,
0.6299815774,
0.4377009571,
1.013948679,
-0.454770565,
0.7817434669,
-0.2109595537,
0.1739363223,
-0.6751281619,
0.6234609485,
-0.2485867292,
0.5666898489,
-0.2726819515,
-1.0989086628,
-0.3586096764,
0.3664340973,
-0.1440621018,
-0.075201124,
0.4676807821,
0.748529911,
-0.0465714596,
-0.0133935167,
0.1184541732,
-0.1540407091,
0.201355055,
0.8678982854,
0.7627258301,
-0.4562859237,
0.4764181077,
-0.2479384691,
0.0896247476,
-0.2429718971,
-0.8189495206,
-0.5857918262,
-0.7126867175,
-0.2397217453,
-0.3997510374,
-0.0859561265,
1.14534235,
0.898409903,
-1.0116320848,
-0.4142180681,
-0.535741508,
0.2293589413,
-0.0600107349,
-0.2103031725,
0.3562473953,
-0.7441136837,
-0.5288779736,
0.5764250755,
0.4048725963,
0.0189420693,
-0.3040082753,
-0.2623281181,
-0.2519838214,
-0.2180594206,
0.631853044,
0.373180747,
-0.8805603385,
0.1030125394,
0.1289205551,
-0.2944715917,
0.0412332714,
1.0915882587,
-1.0460116863,
0.3468082249,
0.6864608526,
0.9072013497,
-0.0841144547,
-0.2181932628,
0.8117133379,
-0.9202682972,
0.3928201795,
0.3734462559,
0.3144354522,
0.2805317342,
-0.5425216556,
0.6418958902,
-0.0494716279,
-0.3745144308,
-0.6685317755,
0.2136195004,
-0.7586826682,
-0.4502352476,
1.0803691149,
0.0120749697,
-0.3331647515,
-0.185076341,
-0.3731602132,
0.1792081594,
-0.3478981256,
0.5621948838,
0.4609280229,
0.1213178709,
-0.0390387177,
-0.5633100867,
0.9044630527,
0.4404089749,
-0.5989604592,
0.1568800062,
0.5146012306,
0.2046434581,
0.5854192376,
0.6120741963,
-0.0125850951,
0.4335744977,
-0.3880755007,
0.2949932516,
-0.3523490429,
-0.4041140378,
-0.5853046179,
0.1809986532,
0.1590507776,
0.011034226
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05827v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05827v1
|
Is it Possible to Edit Large Language Models Robustly?
| 2024-02-08T17:06:45 | 2024-02-08T17:06:45 |
Xinbei Ma, Tianjie Ju, Jiyang Qiu, Zhuosheng Zhang, Hai Zhao, Lifeng Liu, Yulong Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have played a pivotal role in building
communicative AI to imitate human behaviors but face the challenge of efficient
customization. To tackle this challenge, recent studies have delved into the
realm of model editing, which manipulates specific memories of language models
and changes the related language generation. However, the robustness of model
editing remains an open question. This work seeks to understand the strengths
and limitations of editing methods, thus facilitating robust, realistic
applications of communicative AI. Concretely, we conduct extensive analysis to
address the three key research questions. Q1: Can edited LLMs behave
consistently resembling communicative AI in realistic situations? Q2: To what
extent does the rephrasing of prompts lead LLMs to deviate from the edited
knowledge memory? Q3: Which knowledge features are correlated with the
performance and robustness of editing? Our experimental results uncover a
substantial disparity between existing editing methods and the practical
application of LLMs. On rephrased prompts that are complex and flexible but
common in realistic applications, the performance of editing experiences a
significant decline. Further analysis shows that more popular knowledge is
memorized better, easier to recall, and more challenging to edit effectively.
|
[
-0.1200868562,
-1.1870408058,
0.6263492107,
0.0013363452,
0.1222670451,
0.1927206963,
-0.6709513664,
-0.6470360756,
-0.1295951754,
0.3144381046,
-0.202610895,
-0.2081873566,
-0.6274498701,
0.2137549073,
-0.3511696756,
0.5546546578,
-0.034542162,
0.1246480867,
-0.224655062,
-0.3934376538,
-0.6380234361,
-0.818238616,
-0.7254367471,
-0.1951576024,
0.3825813234,
0.2570388317,
1.1409380436,
0.9469388127,
0.4018197656,
0.5049279928,
-0.7719128728,
0.1803235412,
-0.6173184514,
0.422393918,
-0.1473291963,
-0.7583450079,
-0.7944383025,
0.0001665372,
0.9432098269,
0.7571281195,
-0.0561463386,
-0.2089738846,
0.3538669646,
0.4454876184,
-0.3729282618,
0.1689164639,
-0.8938624859,
-0.3370579779,
-0.0357207954,
0.0636596084,
-0.4638473988,
-0.0610175654,
0.0832133889,
-0.6337615848,
-0.0458695889,
-0.1182186231,
0.6870573759,
0.4106808007,
-0.0525021106,
-0.4405508041,
-0.8247141242,
0.7280664444,
-0.8904624581,
0.3508175611,
0.345577687,
0.1090836003,
-0.2412722856,
-0.6080905795,
-0.5561938286,
-0.2039462775,
-0.0063305176,
-0.2784039676,
-0.2910554707,
0.2501049638,
0.6246243715,
0.1613510549,
-0.3306421638,
0.4485881925,
-0.1585571915,
-0.191274479,
0.5779323578,
0.3714111447,
0.6302634478,
-0.0920619071,
0.2090138793,
-0.0968140736,
-0.6243282557,
0.1694978327,
0.2742654979,
0.1567104757,
0.01556159,
0.7041943669,
-0.1575419605,
0.8156105876,
0.0052099708,
-0.4530334771,
-0.2105505913,
-0.2406957448,
-0.3531943858,
-0.432595849,
0.6345603466,
0.4719388783,
0.4154323936,
-0.0568121858,
-0.2426777482,
-0.1383536011,
0.1138407141,
-0.5329796076,
-0.1903462559,
0.2393760085,
-0.4841992259,
-0.3249406219,
-0.340151608,
-0.4001750946,
-0.400355041,
-0.3489090502,
0.2036397755,
-0.5986213684,
0.1674079001,
0.1897684783,
-0.0932788104,
-0.0888409093,
0.8006551266,
-0.7665273547,
0.0041905134,
0.8658483624,
0.6817505956,
-0.0588195771,
-0.5692320466,
-0.422991097,
0.0594151169,
-0.2878252864,
0.5367009044,
-0.85611552,
-0.4421533942,
-0.1421514899,
-0.1552511305,
-0.1248674765,
-0.5450307727,
0.3221637011,
-0.7227494121,
-0.0166468173,
-0.3341030777,
-0.8236493468,
-0.0255798306,
0.4009575844,
-0.6604016423,
0.5556414127,
-0.1393886507,
-0.770499289,
0.0895745978,
-0.29610008,
-0.3402360976,
-0.441595763,
0.1178786755,
-0.2708336115,
0.1725562662,
0.3183374703,
0.3480583131,
-0.0453506708,
0.5003504157,
-0.4173485041,
-0.315492481,
0.7218052745,
-0.698343277,
0.7819045186,
0.3006008863,
0.054776147,
0.2820496857,
-0.7179397345,
-0.1616280228,
-0.1346774101,
-0.6163809896,
-0.2339029312,
-0.0894527733,
-0.2251221687,
-0.0529775321,
0.229260534,
-0.2424558252,
0.5541810393,
-0.235386312,
0.5338673592,
0.9187771082,
0.0296729691,
0.4632352293,
-0.6976969242,
0.713647604,
-0.2202939391,
0.0999319181,
-0.3246173561,
-0.455914259,
-0.7220531702,
-0.5509606004,
0.4615567327,
0.6843146086,
-0.6665413976,
0.1305676848,
-0.2053575218,
-0.5339183211,
-0.4096055925,
0.2865660489,
0.2966305614,
0.4450891614,
0.1720739603,
0.0406324714,
-0.4040465355,
-0.7324683666,
-0.7426009774,
-0.2779712379,
0.0472933948,
0.2391295135,
0.2324981838,
-0.0598097444,
0.7040809393,
-0.2587120235,
0.3616491854,
-0.4251939654,
-0.0694173351,
0.1001630276,
0.4774826765,
0.4996553361,
-0.4118702412,
-0.3705168366,
-0.2268802226,
-0.7235786319,
-0.2641066909,
-0.4054539502,
0.2282251269,
0.1740111113,
0.6954751015,
-0.9792729616,
0.4841862023,
0.3375446796,
-0.1359704584,
0.5837084651,
-0.5309357643,
0.2343257368,
-0.96988976,
0.0174014829,
-0.296980828,
-0.1957381517,
-0.8139841557,
0.3795188367,
0.0134586273,
-0.0729639307,
-0.4199642241,
0.5287675858,
-0.4731218219,
0.1539000571,
-0.3448570669,
0.1540443748,
-0.0913026556,
0.245211184,
-0.2405854613,
0.5634151697,
0.5908856988,
-0.6668704748,
0.348118782,
0.4272886515,
-0.6436267495,
0.4764736891,
-0.8720794916,
0.1977929175,
-0.2165001333,
0.2181028426,
-0.783141613,
-0.4088385701,
0.0727786794,
-0.3297359049,
0.3939899206,
0.0354106352,
-0.5987881422,
0.2493132949,
-0.219932735,
0.3182360828,
0.3505575061,
-0.4412584305,
0.5730798841,
0.3059139252,
-0.6045324802,
-0.5271069407,
-0.6288305521,
0.3605891168,
-0.287109226,
-0.8282340169,
-0.0303640459,
-0.2817308605,
-0.7629237175,
-0.1755243838,
0.3194126487,
0.0002762152,
0.5116545558,
0.1232838631,
0.3223633468,
-0.0156223541,
0.0726100579,
0.0658771843,
-0.0036926817,
-0.1488823295,
0.4139407277,
0.3116928637,
0.1911007911,
-0.4198381007,
-0.7680194378,
0.3398823142,
0.9947525859,
-0.2995479107,
0.579431653,
0.1059727371,
-0.3604014516,
-0.1003131866,
-0.4795027375,
-0.0638905764,
-0.4754849076,
0.4506884813,
-0.4707118571,
-1.2195663452,
0.686101675,
0.039244812,
0.1914178878,
0.1907279044,
0.5188153982,
-0.0621631928,
1.0424740314,
0.5268387198,
-0.1698853672,
0.4046545327,
0.050423298,
0.1747326404,
-0.7994615436,
0.1696237922,
-0.8165565133,
-0.4068576097,
-0.716884613,
-0.3961820006,
0.2702276409,
0.1762266308,
0.0566387475,
0.0190298855,
-0.0725328475,
0.410047859,
0.5123810768,
0.0009804891,
0.5014146566,
-0.2999964356,
0.1933936477,
-0.0781662539,
-0.9164334536,
-0.7669799924,
0.9921163321,
0.5517819524,
0.9769311547,
0.222156167,
0.2659602761,
0.1015477628,
0.2169700861,
-0.6544847488,
0.6701709628,
0.0357733369,
-0.6019983888,
-0.4117557704,
-0.2016385347,
-0.6629782319,
0.0539431423,
-0.514370501,
-0.8741719723,
0.2511107028,
0.4259437919,
-0.378999114,
0.6067417264,
-0.7006251216,
0.6236623526,
-0.0789895803,
-0.2770060897,
-0.3262720108,
-0.5681834817,
0.2001932263,
-0.1681937873,
0.3965412974,
0.1962435097,
0.0861742496,
0.3776569068,
-0.4643380046,
0.9888395071,
0.1167595387,
-0.0765849352,
0.2586193085,
0.300411582,
0.7409345508,
0.1995663494,
-0.4488688707,
-0.0343672074,
0.0673579872,
-0.334223181,
-0.9605744481,
0.5621533394,
-0.6637738347,
-0.964695096,
-0.2337997556,
-1.0262446404,
-0.2809491456,
0.0176913049,
0.062233489,
0.5198715329,
-0.2880020142,
0.2137753814,
0.4919265807,
-0.5342305899,
0.5044466257,
0.2479162663,
-0.2716162205,
-0.333706677,
0.7826445699,
0.3156315088,
0.4749349654,
0.2485058606,
0.2735372782,
0.106688723,
-0.8705633283,
-0.3408097327,
0.1102413461,
-0.7861221433,
0.2113664001,
-0.7809571624,
-0.0378091186,
-0.3739009202,
-0.4203901887,
-0.2708564997,
-0.575299561,
-0.4167213738,
-0.0184921417,
0.2256391793,
1.0221891403,
-0.2359240502,
0.3259854615,
-0.8256705403,
0.2864687741,
0.4078165591,
0.1749702096,
0.0710350052,
-0.5449237823,
-0.1317839622,
0.2542111874,
-0.1017749831,
-0.7341539264,
0.2307404727,
0.1779863834,
0.483109802,
0.3037787974,
-0.0189899895,
0.8277401328,
-0.2447577864,
0.875778079,
-0.3770777881,
-1.0651099682,
0.2438578755,
-0.4216401875,
0.3990723193,
0.3220178187,
0.0765320137,
-0.4065217376,
-0.8087980747,
-0.6648726463,
-0.3528731167,
0.5779086947,
0.0422583334,
0.2472263724,
0.1708623171,
0.6843395829,
0.0531958118,
0.0398759507,
-0.29201141,
-0.0992512181,
0.0876226351,
0.0111834733,
-0.186695829,
-0.6191881299,
0.0081713246,
-0.3307056129,
0.5284463763,
0.1957023591,
-0.0639005899,
0.1257597953,
-0.1445976645,
-0.0047085867,
0.5972373486,
0.8866433501,
0.7949406505,
-0.1393687576,
0.0300616715,
0.4602611959,
-0.3007645905,
0.031177735,
-0.2428098768,
-0.4967190027,
-0.1069697812,
0.6934946775,
0.8979042768,
0.1089397296,
-0.7753409147,
0.0955507383,
-0.2385076582,
-0.1317123473,
0.1546900868,
0.3176313341,
0.1173553914,
0.3776926994,
-0.1171725318,
0.3239158988,
-0.156198144,
-0.7085540891,
-0.0501103476,
0.5354440808,
-0.0677981451,
-0.3330619931,
0.6605030298,
-0.0018773479,
-0.556293726,
0.5730713606,
0.0627045631,
-0.4912642837,
0.35039711,
0.4412921667,
0.4953598082,
-0.2717000842,
-0.1303492188,
0.249191314,
0.4785154164,
-0.1356846541,
0.0691164508,
0.227814734,
-0.8438252211,
-0.4991756678,
-0.0943877175,
-0.6731385589,
0.2833257318,
-0.5603845119,
0.2572188675,
-0.5576698184,
-0.2165354788,
0.0291393884,
-0.4120642245,
-0.5383400917,
0.2736824155,
-0.3094012439,
0.981464386,
-0.5510919094,
0.8922274113,
0.8218554854,
0.1062293053,
-1.0187087059,
-0.0443814173,
0.1959656179,
-0.5215964317,
0.17724365,
-0.0908174142,
0.1333971769,
-0.171348393,
-0.7904829979,
-0.7326393127,
0.8336482644,
0.7057505846,
-0.5105229616,
-0.1516375989,
-0.0015265414,
0.6230252385,
-0.1760257632,
0.2177789658,
0.5649269819,
0.56846416,
0.0054226723,
-1.1316211224,
-0.092979081,
-0.2877310216,
-0.0024541523,
-0.2860716283,
-0.6645171642,
0.8341812491,
-0.3342095912,
-0.132167086,
0.4303690791,
0.5187985301,
0.1243321374,
0.0402806662,
0.3870589137,
0.5855312943,
0.9209020734,
0.0521362238,
1.0918588638,
-0.4981148541,
0.1083614826,
1.2305088043,
-0.2114197314,
0.8014268875,
0.4366134703,
0.0804671049,
0.1293792129,
0.4414230287,
0.190080598,
0.0334728658,
0.0806723461,
-0.1924334168,
-0.4234440923,
0.0412797108,
-0.1878651083,
0.7905267477,
0.2898346484,
-0.2543578446,
0.1465750188,
-0.0560416915,
0.3610885143,
0.2095459551,
-0.1238030121,
0.689961195,
-0.0508736484,
-0.8187896609,
0.4570820332,
0.1924328357,
0.5289101601,
-0.3542210162,
-0.0486475155,
-0.0429219939,
0.0285581127,
0.0048064785,
-0.7661093473,
0.4500739574,
0.2251244485,
0.0005726177,
-0.2632563114,
0.841150701,
-0.3043912947,
-0.3617385924,
-0.1350616366,
0.6730446219,
-0.0397115648,
0.0708141476,
-0.5159422159,
0.6171996593,
0.0232690237,
-0.3501684666,
0.2869700789,
0.4523309171,
0.032942757,
1.0382201672,
0.6014062762,
0.3119028211,
-0.0539005138,
-0.3496486843,
0.8038508892,
-0.6080560684,
-0.3253464997,
-0.9301615357,
0.6804273725,
0.0011673784,
-0.2661193013,
0.7514318824,
0.2226423025,
0.7435157299,
-0.0971152782,
1.0068461895,
0.0726306885,
0.4019436836,
-0.6858945489,
0.8619056344,
-0.2674177885,
0.5108861923,
-0.4403032959,
-0.7441781163,
-0.4629192352,
0.5225831866,
-0.2243087441,
0.0683817342,
0.3905676603,
1.0086529255,
0.1453680992,
0.103092894,
0.5588302016,
0.6780117154,
0.4571227133,
0.2736047208,
1.0324442387,
-0.1444444656,
0.2070919573,
-0.3660759926,
-0.1928334534,
-0.1172175109,
-0.971755743,
-1.092220068,
-0.465370059,
-0.3028538823,
-0.2187434733,
0.1897290945,
0.9690951705,
0.4086787701,
-0.5384902358,
-0.1825313419,
0.2762278318,
0.4382089376,
-0.132152155,
-0.1274220198,
0.3155632317,
-0.1049584746,
-0.8596929908,
0.6139604449,
0.2564008236,
0.1044865847,
-0.0481787324,
-0.0798028782,
-0.0301684141,
0.2810229361,
0.5226596594,
0.3217586577,
-0.6729136705,
-0.6460976005,
0.1103778109,
-0.1353563368,
-0.0339263789,
0.6761139035,
-0.3802960813,
0.7116618156,
0.6056562662,
0.7109084129,
-0.1484028846,
0.1155025214,
0.8052270412,
-0.3346289098,
0.0597754158,
-0.0397104993,
0.5093336105,
0.4927885234,
-0.1531768143,
0.0443256386,
0.1430808753,
-0.8340854645,
-0.8528485894,
0.1199377254,
-1.0834565163,
-0.2043379843,
1.3047764301,
-0.317345947,
-0.1445510536,
-0.1877378523,
-0.5158683062,
0.3360222876,
-0.0438781567,
0.8146342635,
1.0155364275,
-0.2084283382,
-0.2722782493,
-0.4688381851,
0.340531081,
0.4542586207,
-0.657975316,
0.1455676109,
0.7412675619,
0.3802543879,
-0.1127040982,
0.4073233008,
0.069221653,
0.4063035846,
-0.1310827136,
-0.2446325123,
-0.18860735,
-0.2145787627,
-0.5563675761,
0.2116324157,
0.7405894399,
0.3285270929
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05819v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05819v1
|
Integrating Self-supervised Speech Model with Pseudo Word-level Targets from Visually-grounded Speech Model
| 2024-02-08T16:55:21 | 2024-02-08T16:55:21 |
Hung-Chieh Fang, Nai-Xuan Ye, Yi-Jen Shih, Puyuan Peng, Hsuan-Fu Wang, Layne Berry, Hung-yi Lee, David Harwath
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recent advances in self-supervised speech models have shown significant
improvement in many downstream tasks. However, these models predominantly
centered on frame-level training objectives, which can fall short in spoken
language understanding tasks that require semantic comprehension. Existing
works often rely on additional speech-text data as intermediate targets, which
is costly in the real-world setting. To address this challenge, we propose
Pseudo-Word HuBERT (PW-HuBERT), a framework that integrates pseudo word-level
targets into the training process, where the targets are derived from a
visually-ground speech model, notably eliminating the need for speech-text
paired data. Our experimental results on four spoken language understanding
(SLU) benchmarks suggest the superiority of our model in capturing semantic
information.
|
[
-0.4171110988,
-0.7320465446,
0.7752902508,
0.092187278,
-0.2296491414,
-0.3305751979,
-0.0424718522,
-0.5685968399,
0.3226925135,
0.4227077663,
-0.5291067362,
-0.5109299421,
-0.486905098,
-0.1815593541,
-0.7054622769,
0.7940959334,
-0.0095730368,
-0.1226100996,
-0.2210015357,
0.1326464564,
-0.4391869009,
-0.5909485221,
-0.1624058187,
-0.227387324,
0.5556887984,
0.4964974523,
0.5098757148,
0.7216822505,
0.213178128,
0.2812022269,
0.2076509446,
-0.1503637284,
-0.6208859086,
-0.2954387665,
-0.2589253783,
-0.3471673429,
-0.4474817514,
0.5072401762,
0.8499943018,
0.8858907819,
-0.2067135572,
0.2422582209,
0.0314478613,
0.295765698,
-0.673550725,
0.2432368994,
-0.6646723747,
0.1546854377,
-0.0525904298,
-0.0705490336,
-0.3638502061,
0.2864834964,
0.4471999407,
-0.7711526155,
0.1089102179,
0.1463153064,
1.013433218,
0.1852421612,
0.0876977742,
-0.0016690138,
-0.381152451,
0.8472502232,
-0.6139584184,
0.5230154991,
0.6560956836,
0.1078472808,
0.0510154292,
-0.9133232832,
-0.5888218284,
-0.3420505226,
-0.3001369536,
0.36442554,
-0.4978772104,
0.2754522264,
0.2151999176,
0.1046365425,
-0.6862468123,
-0.0739098936,
-0.3177123368,
-0.2315489054,
0.4600147307,
-0.0743898004,
0.3462117314,
-0.4290443063,
-0.4196582735,
0.0083525823,
-0.2089880556,
-0.0233166218,
0.1285962611,
0.3894915581,
-0.388207376,
0.6260506511,
-0.4288523793,
1.1150915623,
0.2057663798,
-0.2456106842,
0.1286731958,
-0.2769162357,
-0.214709118,
0.3894356489,
0.5999386311,
0.1755071282,
0.4365287125,
-0.3413919806,
-0.2491175383,
0.1590206474,
0.2956576943,
-0.6236938834,
-0.7345281243,
0.0683988482,
-0.4499423504,
-0.209189117,
0.0295314342,
-0.3225118518,
0.3756500185,
-0.619838953,
0.8458141088,
-0.5112001896,
-0.4883055091,
-0.0955521092,
-0.354600966,
0.310207665,
0.1387243718,
-0.8070470691,
0.1613465697,
0.4941169918,
1.005241394,
-0.115631707,
-0.5306217074,
-0.8918201923,
0.414039135,
-0.6617221236,
0.6655362844,
-0.4418844581,
-0.4546869397,
-0.2635875642,
-0.2997866571,
-0.119127661,
-0.3896003366,
0.1890001744,
-0.2467526495,
0.4898037314,
-0.0896387175,
-0.6372321248,
-0.1884019375,
0.1233829707,
-0.0805664882,
1.2513720989,
0.3512392938,
-0.872119844,
0.422822386,
-0.3413754106,
-0.3439771831,
0.2085028738,
-0.3839403987,
-0.2081691027,
0.274410069,
0.2995158732,
0.6238221526,
0.0423665792,
0.6221809387,
-0.3932206929,
-0.5256963372,
-0.0061324299,
-0.3029629588,
0.4005710483,
0.0650599971,
-0.495513916,
0.2422423512,
-0.9649848938,
0.0994056091,
0.1556628197,
0.183532536,
-0.6139001846,
-0.1322183609,
0.0297891013,
0.3941335082,
0.458319515,
-0.4237886965,
-0.2756474912,
-0.4174014926,
0.2879543304,
0.5564371347,
-0.2211056948,
0.6172428131,
-0.0979074538,
0.3511009514,
-0.0972319692,
0.0599444695,
-0.1740508229,
-0.5150280595,
-0.6836878061,
-0.8335229754,
0.1550751328,
0.6416150331,
-0.7667170167,
0.5263652205,
-0.2620994747,
-0.347956866,
-0.5681142211,
0.1927018166,
0.4946705401,
1.0984957218,
0.7110477686,
-0.0626516715,
-0.3016586006,
-1.0641072989,
-0.2969347835,
-0.5234792829,
-0.0779800341,
0.2359454334,
0.3779351413,
-0.0426333062,
1.4815636873,
-0.4785518944,
-0.5191991925,
-0.5602734089,
0.4221989214,
0.1590586156,
0.4076453745,
0.5044121742,
-0.7983089685,
-0.4634659886,
-0.3272198141,
-0.8642119765,
-0.428150028,
0.0205281582,
-0.1278345883,
-0.5203583837,
0.6084653735,
-0.2940152586,
0.5750593543,
0.7004836798,
-0.0018214218,
0.3762976229,
-0.2789727151,
-0.1262678355,
-0.8679900765,
-0.0796793401,
0.1424453408,
-0.3652045131,
-0.8204218745,
-0.3772410452,
0.1295741051,
-0.4666301012,
-0.5507760644,
0.5017216802,
-0.3957496285,
-0.3195292652,
-0.5627612472,
0.4270553887,
0.0178193264,
0.4097844958,
0.6252804399,
0.8105604649,
0.7228279114,
-0.4963140786,
0.3573836684,
0.1830602735,
-0.3064820468,
0.7737621069,
-0.876932621,
-0.0078307781,
-0.2704272866,
0.2211174518,
-1.103276968,
-0.3623009622,
0.3600869775,
-0.3663267493,
0.4263612628,
-0.2218602002,
-0.2608932257,
-0.1577928066,
-0.1742009819,
0.3097461164,
0.4124551415,
-0.6909556389,
0.5808428526,
0.5373695493,
0.1044297218,
-0.3660588861,
-1.035020113,
0.392231375,
-0.4720498323,
-0.6704797745,
0.7109433413,
0.4541052282,
-0.1344648153,
0.2190639377,
-0.070556432,
0.1388222277,
-0.2400435507,
0.0156023595,
0.1360816509,
-0.2715239823,
0.0119885979,
-0.0370352045,
-0.5080682039,
0.0788087025,
-0.5975525379,
0.1382122636,
0.1335654855,
-0.1236213446,
-1.000351429,
0.6413725019,
0.0652794614,
-0.3391848207,
0.8712847829,
0.6780938506,
-0.4491767287,
-0.3079396784,
-0.4686252475,
-0.3126154542,
-0.4341995418,
0.3362306654,
-0.7770046592,
-0.8008331656,
0.0003406109,
-0.0463294871,
-0.2952379584,
0.2651002109,
0.2200158834,
-0.570006907,
0.9330618382,
0.7567562461,
-0.1795671284,
0.7024222016,
-0.3647459149,
0.3273659348,
-0.6927861571,
0.0163744073,
-0.2045258135,
-0.0602819584,
-0.3111957908,
-0.4654597342,
0.3209965825,
0.3851945102,
0.3014867604,
0.6593498588,
-0.3397584856,
-0.0712743476,
0.7339169383,
0.0920804068,
-0.0254781209,
-0.0461714007,
-0.057414528,
-0.2003805637,
-1.0384424925,
-0.3252325356,
0.7161789536,
0.3859911859,
0.8355843425,
-0.1230903119,
0.9762605429,
0.1797396988,
0.2197465897,
-0.7896083593,
0.5846366882,
-0.0252537206,
-0.5795173645,
-0.4629280269,
-0.5506232381,
-0.5251990557,
0.5597214103,
-0.0618453994,
-0.8239462376,
0.3513976336,
0.5179746747,
-0.0305234008,
-0.0864396542,
-0.8454902768,
1.2591311932,
-0.2447020113,
-0.2448338121,
-0.2506020665,
-0.7274694443,
0.3311110437,
-0.1745581031,
0.4344388843,
-0.3016601801,
0.0317908935,
0.890579164,
-0.4557729363,
0.8532320261,
-0.4822894037,
-0.104997322,
0.3890697658,
-0.2507610619,
0.5173472762,
-0.1100850552,
0.1507411152,
0.3660924137,
-0.0223759655,
-0.4247951508,
-0.4774841964,
0.5545883775,
-0.5162597299,
-0.4639267921,
-0.5745104551,
-0.2933845818,
-0.4427852631,
0.0885142758,
0.4275720716,
0.7470870018,
-0.1050916538,
0.0098866289,
0.5846711397,
-0.1282126456,
0.2172695696,
0.5235672593,
-0.2833228707,
-0.384830147,
1.1492500305,
0.1289165169,
0.4451974034,
0.5198011994,
0.3588999808,
-0.5821454525,
-0.5873904824,
-0.2981576622,
0.2412931174,
-0.7570486665,
0.118623741,
-0.739218533,
-0.0741769895,
-0.4419220984,
-0.1949227303,
-0.3097643554,
-0.0156972203,
-0.5435613394,
-0.1352630705,
0.1788923293,
0.3100097179,
-0.5188906193,
0.6784347892,
-0.5077008009,
1.0141085386,
0.482526809,
-0.0663009807,
-0.2962786555,
-1.0170601606,
-0.134680748,
-0.0004486801,
0.3040085733,
-0.9801485538,
0.3315190971,
0.4802519977,
0.6941429973,
0.3391087055,
-0.0136909289,
1.2676872015,
-0.7020638585,
0.6694982648,
0.5252531767,
-1.1551351547,
0.9793814421,
-0.3212596774,
0.3640649021,
0.6349942684,
0.3130482137,
-0.3700975776,
-0.4565517902,
-0.5234646797,
-0.6189548373,
1.0464770794,
0.1820849478,
0.2719199657,
-0.1674918681,
0.2426911741,
-0.3130528629,
0.0278090034,
-0.7515987158,
-0.1324301809,
-0.4651331306,
-0.4743985534,
-0.1988798827,
-0.3918071985,
0.0727677792,
-0.4295383096,
0.5963905454,
-0.1716857105,
0.0343576968,
0.4011367857,
-0.537337184,
0.1176795438,
-0.0932526812,
0.2442437261,
0.6054311991,
-0.2552799284,
0.2368135005,
0.1868922859,
-0.4286184013,
0.0391403846,
0.1905530244,
-0.1243539229,
0.1004806012,
0.6909124851,
0.8252705336,
0.7364679575,
-0.5289587975,
0.6657143831,
0.1236127689,
-0.2713245451,
-0.1406342089,
-0.0324315578,
0.0248438343,
-0.0548991226,
0.3339110613,
-0.4101559818,
0.3017831445,
-0.5787925124,
0.5832529664,
0.4398141205,
-0.6873694062,
-0.0980336368,
0.7131947279,
0.0703234747,
-0.032698635,
0.3866108358,
-0.118440263,
-0.5000414848,
0.081949465,
0.6606603265,
0.7031903863,
-0.2583196163,
0.3331439495,
0.1354668885,
0.3234658539,
-0.0084109679,
0.3031494319,
-0.5717220902,
-0.578143537,
-0.5917052627,
-0.7039547563,
-0.2715557516,
-0.0091944896,
-0.6708325148,
0.3949601054,
-0.2404361963,
-0.2135976106,
0.0250123795,
-0.4075910449,
-0.2357726544,
0.6482194066,
0.3693701029,
0.5829029083,
-0.6670534015,
1.0495129824,
0.4624362588,
-0.2400106192,
-0.9043825269,
0.0921671763,
-0.0793331489,
-0.7899398208,
0.8270987272,
0.3899986446,
-0.6256572604,
0.3076968789,
-0.3239803016,
-0.9169490933,
0.6304893494,
0.3928643763,
-0.618999958,
-0.0675145835,
0.1400477588,
0.3375724256,
-0.2860647738,
-0.0927437916,
0.4868727028,
0.369186759,
0.1851929277,
-0.882594347,
-0.4724709988,
0.1993742883,
0.1009973213,
0.1288812011,
-0.1541618407,
0.5392529964,
0.1168325916,
-0.17055583,
-0.1168488637,
1.170060873,
0.0439411066,
0.4512283206,
0.7309367061,
0.723387301,
0.3837228417,
-0.016124092,
0.7547248602,
-0.3198530972,
0.285825491,
1.3212165833,
-0.0157623366,
0.9193637967,
0.3562532961,
-0.127238065,
0.2539748549,
0.5644660592,
0.269900471,
0.8715513349,
0.2045016587,
-0.1463220119,
-0.3909538686,
-0.1772089452,
-0.3747399747,
0.8710946441,
0.514490366,
-0.2263672352,
-0.2077051103,
0.1400623918,
-0.2372729182,
0.1546785384,
-0.3010277748,
0.8850027919,
0.3785977364,
-0.4219286144,
0.6145167947,
0.0875442922,
0.6207528114,
-0.8252762556,
0.016439518,
0.1233213097,
-0.0640722662,
-0.1832390875,
-0.6172649264,
0.2910996079,
0.1844440997,
0.0758753866,
-0.5299554467,
0.790795207,
-0.7312240005,
-0.4836646616,
0.529536128,
0.37930879,
0.2722678781,
-0.3682534695,
-0.9390100241,
0.0104633635,
-0.3235759139,
0.0048932261,
0.2342577726,
0.4547708929,
0.1818118095,
0.2310964167,
0.6720786095,
0.0534752421,
0.1200231165,
0.210347876,
0.6155011654,
-0.6604198217,
-0.870744288,
-0.7213291526,
0.3169883192,
-0.1808494776,
-0.2771212757,
0.7876317501,
0.4637677073,
0.7318662405,
0.1931150854,
0.5224563479,
0.1430225372,
0.6338563561,
-0.6793726087,
0.4632282853,
-0.7492497563,
-0.2858752608,
-0.5506668687,
-1.082773447,
-0.0822524056,
1.0594500303,
-0.6174784899,
-0.0012010525,
0.4665099084,
0.4378916323,
-0.2941814363,
-0.0921699926,
0.7498854995,
-0.0581432581,
0.1338608116,
0.2057822645,
0.993811965,
-0.0059387404,
0.3342575133,
-0.5600656271,
-0.5993986726,
-0.1622606665,
-0.7914942503,
-0.9499582052,
-0.5256919861,
-0.3964369893,
0.0084958747,
-0.0395533144,
0.5655204654,
1.1033051014,
-0.692137599,
-0.1678227931,
-0.1491836905,
-0.375475198,
0.0058355257,
-0.2366334051,
0.3882506192,
-0.4513800442,
-0.5477429628,
0.8419060707,
0.7441202998,
0.0547005944,
-0.2303804755,
0.0551992953,
-0.2419655174,
0.0171326753,
0.620208323,
0.2371376008,
-0.9409766793,
-0.2910011709,
-0.1302336752,
-0.0927098691,
-0.1009220555,
0.6735364199,
-0.9714610577,
0.5259242654,
0.1929197758,
0.481559217,
0.7785105705,
0.3203423023,
0.5489637852,
-0.6859403253,
0.5267409682,
0.1607032865,
0.3385965824,
0.4579655528,
-0.1230576709,
0.150282234,
0.4208538234,
0.0802560672,
-0.7845070958,
0.1512051821,
-0.9160716534,
-0.340036422,
0.8896915317,
-0.2463092953,
-0.2439064831,
-0.1750154048,
-0.1931131333,
0.2524732053,
-0.1219979003,
0.4065119028,
0.6666249633,
-0.237178117,
-0.2286587954,
-0.5820448399,
0.4581205249,
0.639382422,
-0.7908414602,
-0.1765156835,
0.4837763309,
0.0188433267,
0.0884636417,
0.7759038806,
0.1384883821,
0.2260296494,
0.0762920082,
-0.2748430073,
0.1523842663,
-0.6386481524,
-0.1704371125,
0.0037948333,
-0.1056347862,
-0.5080946684
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05813v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05813v1
|
Selective Forgetting: Advancing Machine Unlearning Techniques and Evaluation in Language Models
| 2024-02-08T16:50:01 | 2024-02-08T16:50:01 |
Lingzhi Wang, Xingshan Zeng, Jinsong Guo, Kam-Fai Wong, Georg Gottlob
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The aim of this study is to investigate Machine Unlearning (MU), a burgeoning
field focused on addressing concerns related to neural models inadvertently
retaining personal or sensitive data. Here, a novel approach is introduced to
achieve precise and selective forgetting within language models. Unlike
previous methodologies that adopt completely opposing training objectives, this
approach aims to mitigate adverse effects on language model performance,
particularly in generation tasks. Furthermore, two innovative evaluation
metrics are proposed: Sensitive Information Extraction Likelihood (S-EL) and
Sensitive Information Memory Accuracy (S-MA), designed to gauge the
effectiveness of sensitive information elimination. To reinforce the forgetting
framework, an effective method for annotating sensitive scopes is presented,
involving both online and offline strategies. The online selection mechanism
leverages language probability scores to ensure computational efficiency, while
the offline annotation entails a robust two-stage process based on Large
Language Models (LLMs).
|
[
-0.3080299795,
-0.73865062,
0.1833328009,
-0.0424823761,
-0.0921868458,
0.256611228,
-0.5097493529,
-0.0116133112,
-0.2490460873,
0.434032768,
-0.6419921517,
-0.2995269001,
-0.3717080057,
-0.2530345023,
-0.298002243,
1.1466978788,
-0.167506054,
-0.0011039356,
-0.2328618765,
-0.4862881005,
-0.5210348964,
-0.762390554,
-0.4833819568,
-0.3648067117,
0.5908987522,
0.2884220481,
0.1749051958,
0.578802228,
0.5685938001,
0.1753307283,
-0.1778988242,
0.2558041215,
-0.8290875554,
0.2444147319,
-0.4952129722,
-0.3923389912,
-0.2103429735,
-0.0976669118,
0.9327487946,
0.9382932186,
-0.1931769401,
0.5074825287,
0.141875416,
0.7972300053,
-1.3034234047,
-0.2504513264,
-1.1978449821,
0.2591513693,
-0.3088323474,
-0.0128588341,
-0.6458700895,
0.0305078458,
0.0164366029,
-0.4361799955,
0.3791688681,
-0.341806531,
0.7941457629,
0.2556326389,
-0.0712252036,
-0.2361791879,
-0.8342197537,
1.2054973841,
-0.3381118476,
0.3538356423,
1.0845156908,
0.2267465144,
0.2358325571,
-0.5674154758,
0.063343741,
-0.1201518402,
0.3146508336,
0.2973460555,
-0.3411506116,
-0.1827326715,
0.2506872416,
0.2794108093,
-0.291629076,
0.125556618,
-0.5206149817,
-0.4035615027,
0.4661009312,
-0.0216538962,
-0.1083399057,
0.3793563247,
-0.2536974251,
0.3989298344,
-0.7576507926,
-0.2826217711,
0.5091116428,
0.2240979522,
0.0688520893,
0.5397703648,
-0.1777082384,
0.2607966661,
0.0718081966,
0.0737998709,
0.3226034641,
-0.0412838571,
-0.0918352976,
-0.683292985,
0.7192863226,
0.0307920016,
0.4900262058,
-0.4489047229,
-0.4030881822,
0.0768498406,
0.4469122291,
-0.3688818812,
-0.2059764713,
0.0468965322,
-0.6073265076,
-0.1288633645,
-0.2954669297,
-0.6561279297,
-0.3585537076,
0.0235468633,
0.3468827605,
-0.6135585308,
-0.2949267924,
-0.2841803432,
-0.1653932035,
-0.2935296595,
-0.0360798016,
-1.1006054878,
0.257299602,
0.2516533136,
0.4911965728,
-0.2518861294,
-0.4182313681,
-0.447432667,
0.3144952059,
-0.1413261294,
0.3299247026,
-0.6946215034,
-0.3627621233,
-0.0347352773,
-0.2083980292,
-0.3518050611,
-0.8898727298,
0.5020765066,
-0.6054641008,
0.2698131204,
-0.1334438026,
-0.5544592142,
-0.4671438336,
0.2216658592,
-0.6745470762,
1.0792257786,
0.4085786343,
-0.6995539069,
0.3059679568,
-0.5375798941,
-0.2108931988,
-0.1202016547,
0.1169945374,
-0.8193620443,
0.2859944701,
-0.0421014279,
0.4375384152,
-0.0941727161,
0.4599934518,
-0.4256152511,
-0.3048200905,
0.3578129411,
-0.6783647537,
0.7425299883,
0.4242835939,
-0.2307082862,
0.1011499688,
-0.6669892669,
-0.0524186343,
0.3428817689,
-0.5062934756,
-0.3101172745,
-0.0320080407,
-0.2623231411,
0.0341929607,
0.288928926,
-0.3202952445,
-0.1691151708,
-0.1558711827,
0.4917011857,
0.776576221,
0.0625527427,
0.5377510786,
-0.6023238897,
0.4476280808,
0.125774473,
0.3345246315,
-0.3926542699,
-0.4741440415,
-0.9681191444,
-0.188072741,
0.3061428666,
0.5169504881,
-0.3568684161,
0.2397446185,
0.1035786122,
-0.4599891305,
-0.5988320112,
0.5286173224,
0.8874853253,
0.3569114804,
0.3094209731,
-0.3258492649,
-0.7083184719,
-0.8778349757,
-0.4346775711,
-0.2019181848,
-0.0425852314,
0.2064454854,
0.5041553974,
-0.4356491268,
0.6373268366,
-0.1713312119,
-0.3485179245,
-0.2894645631,
0.0344018675,
-0.3330378234,
0.3602738678,
0.3487319946,
-0.60658288,
-0.2273344994,
-0.1565934271,
-0.7842629552,
0.1048740968,
-0.0105784116,
0.0725967661,
0.3182370961,
0.2750187814,
-0.4453187883,
0.3789713085,
0.3143600225,
0.0783717856,
0.4395987689,
-0.1423962414,
-0.0122529827,
-0.6551293731,
0.4720934927,
-0.3120630383,
-0.0057324651,
-0.7438077927,
0.1370160431,
0.3810226917,
0.0218850654,
-0.6990175247,
0.6575908065,
-0.7497917414,
0.3220447898,
-0.2198477089,
-0.0106447088,
-0.0098746317,
0.7003627419,
-0.2600693405,
0.4032752812,
0.4472976923,
-0.7409132719,
-0.2227674127,
-0.0961142033,
-0.1018468142,
0.0082341712,
0.1172915101,
0.4914475977,
-0.3001486957,
-0.4624809623,
-0.6862903833,
0.0289141964,
0.2779926062,
-0.4488108158,
0.4636648297,
-0.1335639805,
-0.1466999501,
-0.2939538062,
-0.2319492549,
0.4985315502,
0.5075290799,
-0.077048406,
0.3412209749,
0.8130494356,
-0.0952167138,
-0.5952695012,
-0.6665322185,
-0.1093538254,
-0.428914547,
0.0631091595,
0.2436341047,
-0.16993922,
-0.2479369789,
-0.0366025493,
0.0047862334,
-0.4931265414,
0.5464978814,
0.1013308838,
0.05773459,
0.0440829657,
0.3120788038,
-0.0983231589,
-0.2354448885,
-0.0769831836,
-0.1204684079,
0.5292331576,
0.1461692601,
-0.5041601062,
-0.3317456543,
0.6320101023,
0.3153423965,
-0.3770335615,
0.5718963742,
0.5900571346,
-0.916382134,
-0.3539322615,
-0.7605912685,
-0.1924429685,
-0.3889323175,
0.651229918,
-0.3059705198,
-0.8811066151,
0.7056305408,
-0.0330376774,
0.1621750593,
0.3860121667,
0.7056086659,
-0.1115486398,
1.0507113934,
0.9368181229,
-0.3072324991,
0.6219030023,
-0.0877573118,
0.0509590469,
-0.806126833,
-0.2046004981,
-0.3412808478,
-0.2135202587,
-0.1327445954,
-0.3157017529,
-0.1274129152,
0.4817359746,
-0.3568364382,
0.0474168807,
-0.3855873942,
0.4354181588,
0.6521220803,
0.0955520868,
0.0924788341,
0.2114079446,
-0.4216144085,
-0.230131492,
-0.7464111447,
-0.5665562749,
1.4525289536,
0.3721937239,
0.4134162068,
-0.1479445398,
0.3741587102,
0.1584139615,
0.5979146361,
-0.5740687251,
0.4035230875,
-0.2071315944,
-0.9811831713,
-0.211869657,
-0.5723504424,
-0.8662583828,
-0.0233037602,
0.0779387429,
-0.9857963324,
-0.3274503052,
0.3050822616,
-0.5536742806,
0.6475008726,
-0.8231326342,
0.5831732154,
-0.1772043407,
-0.3983822167,
-0.2579165399,
-0.3829921484,
0.4579654932,
-0.5777218342,
0.020219028,
-0.3203305006,
-0.0304138437,
0.8652305603,
0.1622132063,
1.0573132038,
-0.2315714806,
0.3733570278,
0.5512269139,
0.2409603596,
0.2989456356,
-0.3452310562,
-0.5844530463,
0.3879424036,
-0.4672335684,
-0.3004087806,
-0.2836943269,
0.5012131333,
-0.5339494348,
-0.4385415018,
-0.1255744994,
-0.7114281654,
-0.3882524371,
0.3948927522,
0.3856642246,
-0.311730504,
-0.3779243827,
0.1096965,
0.8504562974,
-0.2930640876,
0.5939816833,
0.5836430192,
-0.035088066,
-0.5800684094,
1.0379452705,
0.4485171437,
0.3551576138,
0.5100567341,
0.2560913563,
-0.0823578387,
-0.6097359061,
-0.3725400269,
0.2642052472,
-0.7209157944,
-0.1852642894,
-0.728695035,
-0.2946873307,
-0.175406605,
-0.015251019,
-0.5848739743,
-0.3569195271,
-0.5130784512,
-0.1901748627,
0.2139735073,
0.5157746077,
0.0915348604,
0.3658969998,
-0.7640379667,
0.253151983,
-0.0268978756,
0.4735693336,
0.0516366586,
-0.7493877411,
-0.3563073575,
0.1958319396,
-0.7883101106,
-0.6060866117,
0.3370041847,
0.4404156208,
1.0446830988,
0.6786724329,
-0.0908552781,
0.5228541493,
-0.2023916245,
0.3910322785,
0.1664784253,
-0.8639401793,
0.790945828,
-0.4202280045,
0.5373571515,
0.7591637969,
0.3594240844,
-0.4614628553,
-0.4650720358,
-0.6424613595,
-0.9376525283,
0.7549606562,
0.1507319957,
0.1154100522,
0.0852356628,
0.3884887695,
0.4065113664,
0.3074319959,
-0.8260061741,
-0.3198104799,
0.2336329222,
-0.3297293782,
0.0211072881,
-0.6175110936,
-0.0876060128,
0.0826502666,
0.7697312832,
0.1113801673,
0.1151832342,
-0.3018189967,
-0.3845099211,
-0.2362039685,
0.0923598558,
0.4676944911,
0.7247012854,
-0.0361819342,
-0.0007107039,
0.6912549734,
-0.5760330558,
0.0887857303,
-0.4376403391,
-0.6812832355,
-0.1198358983,
0.0981785133,
0.5450767875,
0.3095078766,
-0.7548204064,
0.3307313025,
0.1811301261,
-0.0955722556,
-0.2683784068,
0.0543165803,
0.1518073976,
-0.2979205549,
0.1986927688,
0.3268058002,
-0.0302720424,
-0.4710026383,
0.4508623481,
0.2940865159,
-0.8408104181,
-0.4184323251,
0.6334801912,
-0.0367813036,
-0.2967163622,
0.6780355573,
-0.2900245488,
-0.3936574459,
0.4294219315,
0.5991534591,
1.2060399055,
-0.6763716936,
-0.0587117895,
0.3665502369,
0.428011775,
-0.0645911396,
0.3413977623,
-0.1417677104,
-0.6388204694,
-0.042600397,
-0.4754694402,
-0.1663482189,
0.3436433375,
-0.6653900743,
0.123763226,
-0.8161822557,
-0.4834192395,
-0.2541653812,
-0.1303058416,
-0.4997906387,
0.1897423416,
0.1593530923,
0.6214735508,
-0.7289549708,
0.7328547239,
0.5365956426,
-0.3311992288,
-0.3987364769,
-0.1581674516,
0.3968656957,
-0.7885844111,
0.1900868416,
0.2760621309,
-0.0076818904,
-0.1511569917,
0.0914906114,
-0.8057932258,
0.758559823,
0.6602737308,
-0.5960767269,
0.3237649202,
0.0923437029,
0.2099295706,
-0.1291822493,
0.4205663502,
0.5072149634,
0.2248372436,
-0.2645275593,
-0.7979648113,
-0.2308294028,
-0.443146795,
-0.2713937163,
0.3755334616,
-0.9176122546,
0.850482285,
-0.4229547679,
-0.4338034391,
0.0539563224,
0.3190947771,
0.2469994724,
0.4240381122,
0.3409655392,
0.6053212285,
1.1277735233,
0.0081243962,
0.4954467118,
0.0193217508,
0.1870609969,
1.1094944477,
-0.3336813748,
0.7358136177,
0.4278963208,
0.0387805663,
-0.1800803393,
0.5533174872,
0.058455158,
0.6041691899,
0.2687119842,
-0.3636223674,
-0.170132637,
-0.1893154681,
-0.1501490772,
0.4967917204,
0.365441978,
-0.60039711,
-0.1865100712,
0.2108482718,
0.2279061526,
0.2390210479,
-0.3273822665,
0.8747231364,
0.1943901777,
-0.7023940682,
0.5251281261,
0.2375094593,
0.3944044709,
-0.7699163556,
0.3618099988,
-0.2272349298,
0.6053117514,
0.0069551282,
-0.3887533247,
0.4953929782,
0.3099308014,
-0.6752598882,
-0.427344501,
0.6806753278,
-0.361191541,
-0.5880329609,
0.6882087588,
0.4172365963,
0.1847136468,
-0.2661432326,
-0.8754244447,
0.1519077718,
0.3406793773,
-0.3500294387,
0.4236909449,
0.3606768847,
-0.5623928308,
1.1038274765,
0.5653010607,
0.0087919068,
0.0942397937,
0.4837052822,
0.7020670772,
-0.8131491542,
-0.2458346635,
-0.9578801394,
0.4693108201,
0.1302669495,
-0.7151488066,
0.7218288779,
0.7357470989,
1.0163933039,
-0.0459694229,
1.038544178,
0.4634439945,
0.794162035,
-0.3359002769,
1.0376858711,
-0.1927264184,
0.3452621698,
-0.0795730203,
-0.7154778838,
-0.5889571309,
0.2737847865,
-0.2076765448,
0.3625562489,
0.6517626643,
0.8490796685,
0.0093212565,
-0.2415165901,
0.629512012,
-0.1377688199,
0.00683591,
0.897932291,
1.0673052073,
-0.3962947726,
0.6646139026,
-0.4620991647,
-0.2602180541,
-0.1370596439,
-0.5789940953,
-0.9775288701,
-0.5076319575,
-0.460955441,
0.1534197181,
0.3327843249,
0.4267357588,
0.7382945418,
-1.0264567137,
-0.1851447672,
0.0608686358,
0.1664834321,
-0.2875711918,
-0.1210689545,
0.1620585918,
-0.3936874866,
-0.5555305481,
0.4467576742,
0.5570453405,
0.0267977361,
-0.1902823746,
-0.0387684964,
-0.290237695,
-0.1129286885,
0.2120420337,
0.3237991631,
-0.6076658368,
-0.0386548452,
-0.0032533817,
-0.096357137,
-0.0564761125,
0.8496187329,
-0.6377441287,
0.606634438,
0.3154462874,
0.5533995628,
0.4263804853,
-0.1374850273,
0.57359761,
-0.7109687328,
0.2741298378,
0.5548126101,
0.4488710761,
0.5003572106,
-0.2671890259,
0.2751550078,
0.2510313988,
-0.2678002417,
-0.933134973,
0.2229415923,
-0.3967188001,
-0.3392911255,
1.0109419823,
-0.4522429407,
-0.1880822629,
-0.3848566115,
0.0238891076,
0.4382399321,
-0.0487603359,
0.9905142188,
0.7081360221,
0.3863146603,
-0.1051564068,
-0.56824404,
0.269338429,
0.6519841552,
-0.3570244014,
0.3233544528,
0.1507799327,
0.2917408645,
-0.0728903785,
0.7385334969,
-0.3226467371,
0.2301800847,
0.0826078951,
0.2360908836,
-0.0122272447,
-0.5642855167,
-0.4472843409,
0.3649592996,
-0.00219563,
-0.3514264524
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05812v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05812v3
|
FAQ-Gen: An automated system to generate domain-specific FAQs to aid content comprehension
| 2024-02-08T16:49:41 | 2024-05-09T10:29:16 |
Sahil Kale, Gautam Khaire, Jay Patankar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) refer to the most common inquiries about
specific content. They serve as content comprehension aids by simplifying
topics and enhancing understanding through succinct presentation of
information. In this paper, we address FAQ generation as a well-defined Natural
Language Processing task through the development of an end-to-end system
leveraging text-to-text transformation models. We present a literature review
covering traditional question-answering systems, highlighting their limitations
when applied directly to the FAQ generation task. We propose a system capable
of building FAQs from textual content tailored to specific domains, enhancing
their accuracy and relevance. We utilise self-curated algorithms to obtain an
optimal representation of information to be provided as input and also to rank
the question-answer pairs to maximise human comprehension. Qualitative human
evaluation showcases the generated FAQs as well-constructed and readable while
also utilising domain-specific constructs to highlight domain-based nuances and
jargon in the original content.
|
[
-0.8179155588,
-1.0965247154,
0.3817227483,
-0.2063776106,
-0.3065554202,
-0.0214113891,
0.2062737793,
-0.0591467731,
-0.0067022522,
0.9041805267,
-0.8509732485,
-0.3190936446,
-0.168584615,
0.6389098167,
-0.6803504229,
1.1583782434,
0.0281242728,
-0.4601823986,
-0.6510820389,
-0.0049280715,
-0.233398959,
-0.4725911021,
-0.5015195608,
-0.0630328208,
0.1266271472,
0.4180481434,
0.7710559368,
0.3666443527,
-0.0246863402,
0.2097436488,
0.1853877157,
0.8225559592,
-0.5382620692,
0.5026989579,
-0.2806223333,
-0.0670904219,
-0.1610378325,
-0.1796063036,
-0.0861165896,
0.6912580132,
0.0724264383,
0.3836334944,
0.0964723974,
0.8097721338,
-0.2837982178,
-0.4377696216,
-0.5475039482,
-0.0251931045,
0.0209677815,
-0.520359695,
-0.2688497603,
-0.3782339394,
0.2050095946,
-0.9835974574,
0.5871171355,
0.1625728458,
0.7738592625,
0.426512748,
-0.5436748266,
-0.7237579823,
-0.4931514263,
0.3625875711,
-0.2600590289,
0.4473437667,
0.364884764,
0.1987574697,
-0.3633910418,
-0.5264223218,
-0.6459020376,
0.2607478201,
-0.0331027769,
-0.0006157782,
-0.274700731,
-0.2555763125,
-0.0257418584,
0.5510072708,
-0.8391308188,
-0.6116737127,
-0.3353681564,
-0.1973235458,
0.7048116326,
0.2898178101,
0.5442191362,
-0.3447866738,
-0.0952602252,
0.2692556679,
-0.6313422322,
0.037215203,
0.3480133116,
-0.0453570411,
0.3607496917,
0.4267657399,
-0.5983242989,
0.8793902993,
0.6530211568,
0.0152488146,
0.0357246138,
-0.5477591753,
-0.2146774232,
-0.4861884117,
0.5451606512,
0.3355687559,
0.4207908213,
-0.3943702579,
-0.2305300236,
-0.4353867769,
0.4468950927,
-0.3687128425,
-0.0249101613,
0.4939482212,
-0.177248165,
-0.3901837468,
0.04884433,
-0.6608409286,
-0.2078225911,
-0.4013780057,
0.3731943667,
-0.3177303076,
-0.1009757295,
0.1171146557,
-0.2295205891,
0.4138628542,
0.4077568948,
-0.7958390117,
0.185185343,
0.4229328036,
0.5058780909,
-0.3352994919,
0.0999382734,
-0.2475552708,
0.4601740241,
-0.1050711945,
0.988724947,
-0.066370286,
-0.478677839,
0.3389367163,
0.1132640541,
0.3121522367,
-0.410805583,
0.3321600854,
-0.7336573005,
0.5027087927,
-0.019625511,
-0.4600484967,
0.0914151445,
0.2778642476,
-0.7013537288,
0.9278151989,
0.3442592323,
-0.6056310534,
0.1343261898,
-0.6155383587,
-0.7878158689,
0.3320047259,
-0.1778808385,
-0.0797950104,
-0.1337088346,
0.4549007118,
0.6294313073,
-0.7685750723,
0.2705349624,
0.4311848581,
0.1425866783,
0.3149254322,
-0.2533070147,
0.6012011766,
0.5444057584,
-0.150766924,
-0.1391904801,
-0.3553155661,
0.2309342474,
0.2842827737,
-0.2940996885,
-0.1554121524,
-0.2775346935,
-0.2755550146,
0.178894937,
0.5137985349,
-0.2197894156,
-0.0491840541,
-0.3343321979,
0.3973108232,
0.3090729415,
0.6467614174,
0.6795796752,
-0.7176253796,
0.6484482288,
-0.1661036611,
0.2938475311,
-0.4171472192,
-0.6737561822,
-0.6348406076,
0.2772964537,
-0.0448042788,
0.5878449678,
-1.0713162422,
0.5366587043,
-0.142961815,
-0.4882704318,
-0.356959939,
0.5863496661,
0.0942780226,
0.4789997637,
0.3766132593,
-0.0963339955,
-0.2634936869,
-0.605003953,
0.0699412301,
-0.0549891666,
-0.1827220619,
0.3549301028,
0.2696334422,
-0.0691105723,
1.1703929901,
-0.7120025158,
0.0386229567,
-0.3106507659,
0.3142623901,
-0.0755414665,
0.2559333742,
0.4994049966,
-1.0914607048,
-0.5818381906,
-0.1202991307,
-0.7333045006,
-0.3930445611,
-0.162460804,
-0.5553896427,
0.226274699,
0.352373302,
-0.5428964496,
0.2550770044,
0.1059270874,
-0.3338271677,
0.5986726284,
0.0754822791,
0.3782758713,
-1.1562819481,
0.2829417288,
-0.1840099096,
-0.197998628,
-0.8908792138,
0.0888691843,
-0.2171134651,
-0.4351855814,
-0.2125194371,
0.7189988494,
-0.2996341586,
0.1138621643,
-0.1803707629,
0.11186371,
0.4948380589,
0.4974718094,
0.0169801209,
0.8769325018,
0.1526113749,
-0.9297807217,
0.3162029684,
0.5994403958,
-0.0666272789,
0.5843032598,
-0.6329780817,
0.4463399351,
-0.2549271286,
0.083433494,
-1.083063364,
-0.5112811327,
0.379199475,
-0.7836546302,
-0.1512454003,
-0.0843088552,
-0.4495595396,
-0.3631610274,
-0.0442059189,
0.1746645719,
0.5537737012,
-0.3586921394,
0.2570034564,
0.4330822229,
-0.5032915473,
-0.3947937787,
-0.318947643,
-0.1449901909,
0.3071213365,
-0.968024075,
0.2204989791,
-0.3793258667,
-0.1501819491,
-0.0036298565,
-0.151132524,
-0.4195497632,
0.1885625124,
0.1921637803,
-0.0502737723,
-0.2741086781,
0.3417834044,
0.6767385602,
0.1927844435,
0.074296385,
-0.305624336,
0.6172559261,
0.2286282033,
-0.0579604693,
-0.1128926575,
1.055991888,
0.6587547064,
-0.3642908633,
0.1303262115,
0.2975640893,
-0.2308059484,
-0.472015053,
-0.4944116473,
-0.016764598,
-0.4746373296,
-0.0244312063,
-0.4374684989,
-0.9075131416,
0.2079821378,
-0.0749835297,
0.4293057323,
0.7355543971,
0.5543681979,
-0.228966251,
0.863830626,
0.4282507896,
0.3847965002,
0.0829947218,
0.0768448561,
-0.1050040051,
-0.3040169775,
-0.179075554,
-0.431048125,
0.1849517971,
0.0611692183,
-0.541536808,
0.144287467,
-0.0950210914,
-0.2264858782,
0.1736399978,
-0.6633843184,
0.315058887,
0.3907755911,
-0.0296919998,
0.5332143903,
0.287646085,
-0.0373047628,
0.4052293003,
-0.5989343524,
-0.7854200006,
1.0977134705,
0.0648038909,
0.4529283941,
-0.0041118972,
0.6394234896,
0.7122980356,
0.4330936074,
-0.5038037896,
0.4435195923,
-0.1716354042,
-0.8835987449,
-0.6765583158,
-0.2845816612,
-0.8611337543,
-0.1165505126,
-0.1976504177,
-0.105087474,
0.062341664,
-0.0695295781,
-0.6199291945,
-0.1215879768,
-0.4526219964,
0.5073284507,
-0.3459413648,
-0.2574704587,
0.3162943423,
-0.5397432446,
0.3103363514,
-0.4147500694,
0.1424698234,
0.1179903969,
0.0185249168,
0.7214997411,
-0.4128516018,
0.4742862582,
-0.065371342,
-0.4373348057,
0.8670447469,
0.2231281996,
-0.0616427809,
0.2121006399,
-0.1206899658,
-0.1528649777,
-0.0868906602,
-0.3532263935,
-0.6938323379,
0.3686788678,
-0.8798077703,
-0.8944881558,
0.114889212,
-0.386161238,
-0.3737635612,
0.0840414315,
0.3930268884,
0.2758666873,
-0.380977273,
0.0023294869,
1.0218414068,
-0.3443929851,
-0.0969606563,
0.4534568787,
-0.1717639118,
-0.4747205079,
0.6630318165,
-0.0565772168,
0.2396250963,
0.471680522,
-0.1935718805,
-0.382457912,
-0.4088571966,
-0.9021623135,
0.1106897593,
-0.7256428003,
-0.4966073334,
-0.7742843032,
-0.3544344306,
-0.8644682765,
-0.3794520795,
0.238536641,
-0.3614435494,
-0.5781382918,
0.0848796144,
0.3569016159,
0.7556177974,
0.2224889547,
0.2599053681,
-0.8846274614,
0.6211089492,
0.7345227599,
-0.0405946001,
-0.2102658153,
-0.7012786865,
-0.1606351435,
0.0647029057,
-0.4825614691,
-0.9816143513,
0.3579060733,
0.3233641386,
0.6215926409,
0.261073947,
0.3647782803,
0.285202831,
-0.3321923912,
0.9138269424,
0.1347109675,
-0.8549393415,
0.7590036392,
-0.4690336883,
0.3875630796,
0.7083716393,
0.7031286955,
-0.6300907135,
-0.4438386559,
-0.4636473656,
-0.8558853865,
0.3581474423,
0.1971310824,
0.3708511889,
-0.2425000966,
0.8971756697,
0.7685884833,
0.2531191409,
-0.2440091372,
-0.3468341231,
-0.5963048935,
-0.399717778,
0.3706661165,
0.0419969037,
-0.0766795874,
0.093763046,
0.6082432866,
-0.3293759525,
0.3890263736,
0.545601964,
-0.3442538977,
-0.4460855424,
0.346034497,
0.2939426005,
0.3727521598,
0.131464228,
-0.160029009,
-0.0907327309,
-0.3917690217,
0.2379652262,
-0.1713010073,
-0.3975665569,
0.0180456396,
-0.2582471669,
0.3384578526,
-0.1796261817,
-0.6972863078,
0.4712106586,
-0.2310138494,
-0.6035189629,
-0.2323757708,
0.3530731797,
-0.0406570584,
-0.0962106138,
0.9315420985,
-0.1624766439,
0.0518916734,
-0.3898193836,
0.7261773944,
0.146581769,
0.0412183851,
-0.149689123,
0.6265728474,
0.8340775371,
-0.4249308705,
0.4044825733,
-0.3209567666,
-0.3694519699,
0.449621141,
0.4315690994,
0.771874845,
-0.1124334857,
0.6037466526,
0.2981072068,
0.0110368049,
0.2051184177,
0.4519234002,
-0.5009499788,
-0.8043971658,
-0.3120477796,
-0.5175876617,
-0.5363745093,
0.2390728295,
-0.483846724,
0.1474672109,
-0.5117352009,
-0.1228533685,
0.0235767663,
-0.0374912806,
-0.6949996352,
0.5351228714,
0.1077876315,
0.8764711022,
-0.6682107449,
0.3272103369,
0.9276993275,
-0.6416643262,
-0.3508853614,
0.1995878518,
-0.3729941249,
-0.4983394146,
0.3883372545,
-0.1572876871,
-0.1375920027,
0.2427292317,
-0.8582872748,
-0.7973687649,
1.2579100132,
-0.0640985817,
-0.160101831,
-0.2310726643,
0.6133162975,
0.5143013597,
-0.4922035635,
-0.1412105709,
0.2422068119,
0.2523607612,
0.0529219881,
-0.4992922544,
0.2454376221,
-0.4811436236,
-0.5296894312,
0.2219793797,
-0.3659908772,
0.5496274829,
-0.0751523748,
-0.366851747,
0.3595593572,
0.7441157699,
0.0482725687,
0.3619697988,
0.6102792621,
0.1564193219,
0.8552170992,
0.1465185583,
0.7602059841,
-0.61523211,
-0.0376376249,
0.7103108764,
-0.0467533283,
0.4705183506,
0.3810299635,
0.1790885627,
0.3699404597,
0.4171532393,
0.1813255847,
0.344399631,
0.0975022092,
-0.2829914391,
-0.5165281296,
-0.1246137396,
-0.2416957617,
0.1680167019,
0.6440804005,
-0.4136394858,
-0.2189717442,
-0.1479936987,
-0.2421368361,
0.2031564116,
-0.2376597375,
0.856095314,
-0.1770554632,
-0.9751138687,
0.4937967658,
-0.0996975824,
0.4882671237,
-0.4011600614,
0.1325567812,
-0.5410276055,
-0.6949625015,
-0.1716189981,
-1.0136985779,
0.3155217171,
0.3867582381,
-0.4570426047,
-0.4337464571,
1.0246646404,
-0.352440238,
-0.0559097715,
-0.3153930008,
1.2180796862,
-0.025691973,
-0.127435565,
-0.6836862564,
-0.4467237294,
0.3215003908,
-0.265023917,
0.1445873529,
0.8450863957,
0.1041840911,
0.6247306466,
0.7288924456,
-0.5857158899,
0.0693136156,
-0.1544121355,
0.6849856973,
-0.6005959511,
-0.4425785244,
-0.126684472,
0.4856696725,
-0.074178502,
-0.6902237535,
0.2952518165,
0.3615490496,
0.5633356571,
-0.2468857467,
1.2621701956,
-0.1651973277,
0.5318541527,
-0.1992238909,
0.807956934,
-0.7675551772,
0.0053381687,
-0.0128760999,
-0.5710893273,
-0.1188677847,
0.26923576,
-0.1337898374,
-0.3055528998,
0.3245511353,
0.6992512345,
0.2933333814,
0.1531310678,
0.5685118437,
-0.2703421116,
0.0923708677,
0.3260462284,
0.9054194689,
-0.4453954399,
0.9232566953,
-0.0427298434,
0.0108252494,
-0.1808494627,
-0.1930781454,
-0.7716997862,
-0.9604703784,
-0.2953212559,
-0.1146926135,
0.1823775321,
0.7438061237,
0.4021759927,
-0.5977185369,
0.0117634693,
-0.120733723,
0.1008981392,
0.1030859724,
-0.2632645369,
0.0916977003,
-0.4403738379,
-0.6515233517,
0.0954811424,
0.1284765005,
0.1840035766,
-0.4331983626,
-0.0829081312,
-0.1131792068,
0.4489673078,
0.67155689,
0.440695554,
-0.409229964,
-0.1631289572,
0.56250453,
-0.3091430664,
0.0584485047,
0.9161111712,
-0.8043978214,
0.0714230612,
0.5786325336,
0.9488116503,
0.0976804271,
0.3465456367,
0.8565195203,
-0.8300246596,
-0.6590425968,
0.2091770619,
-0.0312915258,
0.44979918,
-0.7073479891,
0.5484140515,
0.1376838386,
-0.5352650285,
-0.3131918013,
0.3297285438,
-0.9158467054,
-0.3899151981,
1.3928425312,
0.0644734353,
-0.277903676,
-0.9459947944,
-0.3302344382,
0.4129815996,
-0.5719112158,
0.5260214806,
0.4714473784,
-0.2829568982,
-0.0383387357,
-0.3163378239,
0.6225653887,
0.398303479,
-0.9535009265,
0.1399514526,
0.4429965019,
0.4901275039,
0.2381029576,
0.5160630345,
-0.0636307597,
0.6043540239,
-0.3744175136,
-0.024230592,
0.0047573047,
-0.0024407294,
0.0111955423,
0.6244764924,
-0.1457221955,
0.2170841694
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05808v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05808v2
|
Training Large Language Models for Reasoning through Reverse Curriculum Reinforcement Learning
| 2024-02-08T16:46:26 | 2024-03-17T09:02:02 |
Zhiheng Xi, Wenxiang Chen, Boyang Hong, Senjie Jin, Rui Zheng, Wei He, Yiwen Ding, Shichun Liu, Xin Guo, Junzhe Wang, Honglin Guo, Wei Shen, Xiaoran Fan, Yuhao Zhou, Shihan Dou, Xiao Wang, Xinbo Zhang, Peng Sun, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In this paper, we propose R$^3$: Learning Reasoning through Reverse
Curriculum Reinforcement Learning (RL), a novel method that employs only
outcome supervision to achieve the benefits of process supervision for large
language models. The core challenge in applying RL to complex reasoning is to
identify a sequence of actions that result in positive rewards and provide
appropriate supervision for optimization. Outcome supervision provides sparse
rewards for final results without identifying error locations, whereas process
supervision offers step-wise rewards but requires extensive manual annotation.
R$^3$ overcomes these limitations by learning from correct demonstrations.
Specifically, R$^3$ progressively slides the start state of reasoning from a
demonstration's end to its beginning, facilitating easier model exploration at
all stages. Thus, R$^3$ establishes a step-wise curriculum, allowing outcome
supervision to offer step-level signals and precisely pinpoint errors. Using
Llama2-7B, our method surpasses RL baseline on eight reasoning tasks by $4.1$
points on average. Notebaly, in program-based reasoning on GSM8K, it exceeds
the baseline by $4.2$ points across three backbone models, and without any
extra data, Codellama-7B + R$^3$ performs comparable to larger models or
closed-source models.
|
[
-0.2029662728,
-0.8013173342,
0.8832602501,
0.2464814931,
-0.1437567472,
-0.1178544462,
-0.2656807899,
-0.2156549245,
-0.1671266258,
0.9428840876,
-0.7433854938,
-0.6071053147,
-0.5408302546,
-0.2043012977,
-0.1771619767,
0.9932630658,
-0.270586282,
0.2083300054,
0.1353268474,
0.2364238203,
-0.3729735315,
-0.4280467331,
-0.9055408239,
-0.6757603884,
0.7470154762,
0.7637972236,
0.3928243816,
0.5270271897,
0.1287776232,
0.1600215137,
0.1764829308,
0.4420208037,
-0.6267754436,
0.1504640877,
-0.3680957854,
-0.6731929779,
-0.3257328868,
0.2428647578,
0.3660671711,
0.5599985123,
-0.4306306243,
0.0693660602,
-0.236489594,
0.7532427907,
-0.6747139096,
0.4337100685,
-0.4413597584,
0.1451676339,
0.0737513155,
-0.2728608251,
-0.9626009464,
-0.5724709034,
-0.2603708506,
-0.6086139083,
-0.0960512087,
0.1816491485,
0.6281729341,
0.1853298992,
-0.2974599004,
-0.2221800089,
-0.7443736196,
1.1078691483,
-0.7990301847,
0.3846924007,
0.6425588727,
0.5624340773,
-0.3390235007,
-0.5149686337,
-0.5169996619,
-0.2571599782,
0.1431871802,
0.2760720849,
0.3577286303,
0.0728851631,
0.5384976268,
-0.0039763274,
-0.432844907,
0.2328501791,
-0.4970478117,
0.0062770694,
0.7151345611,
0.247132048,
-0.0578235202,
0.181759581,
-0.1476537585,
-0.2901898026,
-1.0642193556,
0.0111229997,
0.5067891479,
0.3474594653,
0.0202905051,
0.4706638455,
-0.2988428771,
0.634562254,
-0.1579392403,
-0.2751577795,
-0.0656135529,
0.2208124995,
-0.2943816185,
0.1170176268,
0.5352597237,
0.0472770333,
0.319393605,
0.1055434793,
-0.3520276845,
-0.0110437796,
0.4713378251,
-0.5018336177,
-0.2902775109,
0.1684251279,
-0.3731280565,
-0.1803936809,
0.0861837566,
-0.5112300515,
-0.2949078977,
-0.5899088979,
0.4664788246,
-0.3689545691,
-0.2548332512,
0.5077909231,
0.3032946885,
0.4428038299,
0.7659884691,
-0.8949614167,
0.2164418548,
1.0709683895,
0.4974612594,
-0.0891639665,
-0.3954287171,
-0.7988187075,
0.1065615416,
-0.5401062965,
0.6776871681,
-0.5149380565,
-0.2208028436,
-0.0132861575,
-0.0758152977,
-0.1017696336,
-0.5594878793,
0.6758298278,
-0.7628028989,
0.1789889038,
0.1418883651,
-0.4142198861,
-0.5938771367,
0.2357447147,
-0.5055500269,
0.9246321917,
-0.0788818151,
-0.4820683897,
0.3249692917,
-0.4215356708,
-0.4810173213,
-0.3063757122,
-0.2410604656,
-0.6751827002,
-0.2286832482,
0.2541939914,
0.6946300864,
-0.134456858,
0.5265306234,
-0.5574241877,
-0.659101069,
0.0270668343,
-0.3186892271,
0.7133244872,
0.2084886879,
-0.3848704994,
0.3685247302,
-0.828535378,
0.032039836,
0.1651032418,
-0.4641901255,
-0.0584236719,
0.0321370102,
-0.4468853176,
0.2615628839,
-0.1189365014,
-0.3882859647,
0.491333127,
-0.4578283727,
0.1285512894,
0.7265638113,
0.1056382507,
0.2409130186,
-0.2264762521,
0.6053305268,
0.0107605001,
0.2501665354,
-0.1042180136,
-0.5659406185,
-1.0163385868,
-0.1344575286,
-0.0846671164,
0.6647020578,
-0.7748913169,
0.1841236353,
0.1551135182,
-0.3811932206,
-0.3445818126,
-0.0149139119,
0.6727183461,
0.5344734788,
0.6783293486,
0.0486334674,
-0.7076535225,
-0.948120892,
-0.1654027402,
-0.3852081299,
0.0985693857,
0.108746767,
0.616292119,
-0.0248735473,
0.5023373961,
-0.6707806587,
-0.2791317701,
-0.6374713182,
0.4123093784,
0.5341374874,
0.5665498376,
-0.0848615989,
-0.6333798766,
-0.0399756953,
-0.0420404524,
-0.9520629644,
0.0291344468,
-0.3572068512,
-0.1856895089,
0.3346589506,
0.5448666215,
-0.4568003118,
0.4365482628,
0.3253228962,
-0.0125885904,
0.8350065351,
-0.2676717937,
0.0723923594,
-0.6810624599,
-0.2116558552,
0.0526450165,
-0.2312151045,
-0.405400753,
0.1462433934,
0.1595299989,
0.1730129421,
-0.4467361867,
0.3872834444,
-0.2954869568,
-0.2472126782,
-0.2950319052,
0.1421185434,
-0.0084827896,
0.7958162427,
0.4404464066,
0.6442104578,
0.3588812649,
-0.5912524462,
0.5669950843,
0.0197393987,
-0.4673341811,
0.2805282772,
-0.3162378073,
-0.0968497396,
0.0699759573,
0.7294977307,
-0.6876632571,
-0.1992816478,
0.4664641023,
-0.4485180378,
0.2303768396,
-0.0935904309,
-0.2653593123,
-0.4579084814,
-0.1097259149,
0.1851991266,
0.4795384407,
-0.7490236759,
0.6735147238,
-0.0362870358,
0.1712414324,
-0.9026955962,
-0.6790421009,
-0.0898932442,
-0.2466047853,
-0.2773064077,
-0.2548311949,
0.3176068366,
-0.1930381507,
-0.1938311011,
-0.0431999601,
-0.0083023673,
0.2009508461,
0.3603286743,
0.2923403382,
-0.1953912079,
0.0117465528,
0.1196296662,
-0.3106052577,
0.3007349968,
-0.4421654642,
0.14067173,
-0.1087701172,
-0.787420392,
-0.5847241879,
0.2803662717,
0.1431697458,
-0.0902187824,
0.6254953146,
0.3440208733,
-0.2018704265,
-0.5795432329,
-0.5502658486,
-0.1923503131,
-0.3741697073,
0.3494567871,
-0.5329739451,
-0.8510407805,
0.371361047,
-0.1321447343,
0.212019369,
-0.0134411594,
0.5870392919,
0.206204623,
1.2719355822,
0.3190679252,
0.3072221279,
0.2095945776,
-0.3942195177,
0.3941266239,
-0.9102381468,
-0.4410517216,
-0.2423002869,
0.1851690263,
-0.12865372,
-0.5849388838,
0.0914451405,
0.5382924676,
-0.6108760834,
0.3314276636,
-0.2410315126,
0.3661193848,
0.7252753377,
0.3249181509,
0.4441533387,
-0.4505482316,
-0.2223069668,
0.1800338328,
-0.5751965642,
-0.7168530226,
0.9530619979,
0.4728481174,
1.152848959,
0.1944066733,
0.963620007,
0.1107624024,
0.6546126008,
-0.8920831084,
0.7866345048,
0.3587051928,
-0.2401625216,
-0.3039672971,
-0.476793766,
-0.499165535,
0.4293452501,
-0.0759677514,
-0.777991116,
-0.1143206879,
0.3156158328,
-0.2191490084,
0.4134367406,
-0.7641972303,
0.8003565073,
-0.0885362253,
-0.4982896149,
-0.398768425,
-0.7774371505,
0.8848947287,
0.1159858704,
0.4001962245,
0.1226823181,
0.3174493909,
0.5628906488,
-0.2448711246,
1.0011804104,
-0.2754819691,
-0.452129215,
0.3551632762,
0.3923017681,
0.7332080603,
0.3164662719,
0.1018495858,
-0.2915189564,
-0.2488753647,
-0.3675768673,
-0.8937514424,
0.6925489306,
-0.6904944181,
-0.9960374832,
-0.3240998685,
-0.4164206088,
-0.4122861922,
0.0417807698,
-0.3533884585,
0.3255127668,
0.2556108534,
-0.0785428211,
0.9695417285,
-0.4059257805,
0.0433712751,
0.5666900277,
-0.6135013103,
-0.2851499915,
0.9262850881,
-0.2839268148,
0.4602349401,
0.5725851059,
0.2094707638,
-0.3712912798,
-0.5064243078,
-0.4964873493,
0.3159143031,
-1.0943821669,
-0.1959032416,
-0.7744463086,
-0.1272625178,
-0.3127874136,
-0.2373908907,
-0.5523988008,
-0.4344713986,
-0.3263273835,
-0.3383594751,
-0.0241129193,
0.8055205941,
-0.2716220915,
0.1913621426,
-0.576125145,
0.3419202864,
0.4150971472,
0.3103146255,
0.343501091,
-0.6563683152,
-0.294583112,
-0.0903103277,
-0.3820776343,
-0.674334228,
0.2623809874,
-0.1610540748,
0.5625083447,
0.5140959024,
-0.0306561273,
0.5343251228,
-0.4591329992,
0.6948523521,
0.103895016,
-0.8204096556,
0.687928319,
-0.3824193478,
-0.0318469927,
0.1241734847,
0.3375255167,
-0.3891139328,
-0.6852180958,
-0.6000506282,
-0.726444006,
1.0638048649,
-0.2345927358,
-0.2214555442,
-0.1357881576,
0.4183951318,
0.10469044,
-0.1996892095,
-0.8767871261,
-0.0054113176,
-0.3147803843,
-0.136179626,
0.1276013702,
-0.2328227162,
-0.2336958796,
-0.0972445905,
1.2901147604,
-0.3154122531,
-0.0402433164,
0.1329920292,
-0.0373144969,
0.0018034062,
0.4372645319,
1.0242298841,
0.742108047,
-0.3025059402,
0.393153578,
0.2413867414,
-0.1051596254,
0.1740913689,
-0.303591162,
0.1412462443,
-0.6090670228,
0.6857270002,
0.8749748468,
0.3040359616,
-0.8619449735,
0.5513909459,
0.0349323004,
-0.4886825681,
-0.4036264718,
0.2777846754,
0.2461580932,
0.6064510345,
0.3464882374,
-0.3175169528,
0.0032297706,
-0.4171060026,
0.3916905224,
0.0266257972,
-0.4594797492,
-0.0858709216,
0.6556991935,
-0.1416140795,
-0.0763588771,
0.613396585,
-0.2440714687,
-0.5404723287,
0.6420589089,
0.8574442267,
0.5530882478,
-0.0518884286,
0.3657983541,
0.5893557668,
0.1184926927,
-0.8019453287,
0.2136348188,
0.0228434931,
-0.742883265,
-0.994346261,
-0.5109288692,
-0.8333894014,
0.08304324,
-0.8330104947,
0.3565503955,
-0.5514231324,
0.4222151935,
-0.224637419,
-0.2639020085,
-0.0006170645,
0.3762328327,
0.0835534632,
0.8214668632,
-0.969897747,
1.0841468573,
0.6243869066,
-0.5614734292,
-1.2406394482,
-0.3335646093,
-0.0201114528,
-0.9995388985,
1.3410840034,
0.2484679818,
-0.4930274785,
0.0358703062,
-0.7621011734,
-0.4132416546,
0.9064508677,
0.0991131961,
-0.4477058649,
0.0971446037,
-0.3480193913,
0.4163096249,
-0.4575742781,
0.3356224298,
0.4874357283,
0.4342617393,
0.4240559042,
-0.5419584513,
0.1176580191,
0.2514780462,
-0.1198230758,
0.1976179779,
-0.4323268235,
0.8705895543,
-0.6765566468,
-0.2007207721,
0.0375267863,
0.8716564775,
0.7843806148,
0.2573408782,
0.3509798646,
0.7751603127,
0.3445724845,
-0.0830228403,
1.0047758818,
0.3129374683,
0.6144505739,
1.402141571,
-0.4509080648,
0.7974030972,
0.4878130555,
-0.1886647344,
0.6371471882,
0.6011746526,
0.1519887447,
0.4988956451,
0.3686473668,
-0.1424580812,
-0.8505476117,
0.1427089274,
-0.0846113041,
0.2604047358,
0.5452531576,
-0.1484252661,
-0.4144330919,
0.1283852905,
0.1446425766,
0.5171134472,
-0.3037654757,
0.6159142852,
0.2419692278,
-0.8929261565,
0.5612472892,
0.038950406,
0.2802405357,
-0.4724521637,
-0.5678824782,
-0.1524678469,
0.41178146,
-0.2746806443,
-0.9922472239,
0.330658555,
-0.2761608064,
0.0736820698,
-0.2953501344,
0.4312446415,
-0.3486123085,
-0.2409096509,
0.3541334867,
0.2462766916,
0.2006354779,
0.2516304255,
-0.6436961293,
0.007143477,
-0.0142096439,
-0.5422005653,
0.2489917278,
0.5023231506,
-0.3543694019,
1.1094601154,
0.5258131623,
0.2464466542,
-0.1000480801,
0.3330224454,
0.8760959506,
-0.8313351274,
-0.4351710379,
-0.7879322767,
0.148391068,
0.0816886798,
0.0174577441,
0.5479789972,
0.4704438746,
1.0758744478,
-0.1461106092,
0.7392970324,
0.2204929143,
0.7677045465,
-0.9981698394,
0.0617926046,
-0.3346267641,
0.4568748772,
-0.0814468116,
-0.715456605,
-0.7112683058,
1.0571484566,
-0.8148255944,
-0.0544937141,
0.7801845074,
0.9488531947,
-0.1602124572,
0.2899179757,
0.4177369177,
0.0278897379,
0.5933248997,
0.9344755411,
1.2139393091,
-0.1687431335,
0.4209921956,
-0.031515006,
-0.2446634322,
-0.3461345732,
-0.9744117856,
-0.9031789303,
-0.2009280771,
-0.1307707578,
-0.5146330595,
0.1441279948,
1.0486184359,
0.5251775384,
-0.8921177387,
-0.2386341542,
-0.3262999952,
0.4985230267,
-0.491840452,
-0.278070122,
0.2860719562,
-0.4704660177,
-0.430106312,
0.4101957381,
0.359105438,
-0.3863644004,
-0.4827706516,
-0.2807263732,
-0.4419413805,
-0.0372770578,
0.5247305036,
0.4783211648,
-0.9941923618,
-0.6196264029,
-0.5602366328,
-0.1203491539,
-0.0782786757,
1.0085088015,
-0.6680856347,
0.1888543218,
0.2733372748,
0.6443598866,
0.7069150209,
0.0038275959,
0.464138478,
-0.440864712,
0.1065259203,
0.2344562411,
0.2108534425,
0.1931334138,
-0.1676873565,
0.6464161873,
0.1128312722,
-0.7210592031,
-0.7384809852,
0.7494645119,
-0.9830468297,
-0.3285559714,
1.3164490461,
-0.5028120279,
-0.1793112457,
-0.2179253548,
-0.4468778372,
0.3387415409,
-0.3732150197,
0.8224357367,
0.476796478,
-0.5088701844,
-0.5216795206,
-0.8829049468,
0.3100240231,
0.3597233593,
-0.7798852921,
0.3527528346,
0.5552715659,
0.1274199039,
-0.0797693804,
0.559340477,
-0.2195866704,
0.2384507805,
-0.2355665863,
0.2005080581,
-0.2728136778,
-0.4907976985,
-0.1631795466,
0.1673040241,
0.2220951766,
0.1832853258
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05794v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05794v1
|
Phonetically rich corpus construction for a low-resourced language
| 2024-02-08T16:36:11 | 2024-02-08T16:36:11 |
Marcellus Amadeus, William Alberto Cruz Castañeda, Wilmer Lobato, Niasche Aquino
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Speech technologies rely on capturing a speaker's voice variability while
obtaining comprehensive language information. Textual prompts and sentence
selection methods have been proposed in the literature to comprise such
adequate phonetic data, referred to as a phonetically rich \textit{corpus}.
However, they are still insufficient for acoustic modeling, especially critical
for languages with limited resources. Hence, this paper proposes a novel
approach and outlines the methodological aspects required to create a
\textit{corpus} with broad phonetic coverage for a low-resourced language,
Brazilian Portuguese. Our methodology includes text dataset collection up to a
sentence selection algorithm based on triphone distribution. Furthermore, we
propose a new phonemic classification according to acoustic-articulatory speech
features since the absolute number of distinct triphones, or low-probability
triphones, does not guarantee an adequate representation of every possible
combination. Using our algorithm, we achieve a 55.8\% higher percentage of
distinct triphones -- for samples of similar size -- while the currently
available phonetic-rich corpus, CETUC and TTS-Portuguese, 12.6\% and 12.3\% in
comparison to a non-phonetically rich dataset.
|
[
-0.4783916771,
-0.6454174519,
-0.0597749688,
0.341091454,
-0.4631046653,
0.3622766733,
-0.5320691466,
-0.5273613334,
0.7194551229,
0.5200472474,
0.0866538659,
-0.4379175901,
-0.1852661222,
0.0711074173,
-0.2028112262,
0.8084390163,
0.3792025149,
-0.0661535561,
0.5088339448,
-0.1975417733,
-0.4199347496,
-0.3671188653,
-0.3366090357,
0.1711608022,
0.4046573341,
0.5529125333,
0.8938286304,
0.7963443398,
0.1806482822,
0.1755402386,
-0.5735545754,
0.1364562809,
-0.2228644788,
0.0982785374,
0.054139927,
-0.3752866387,
-0.3972671032,
-0.1476602405,
0.7027777433,
1.1976445913,
-0.3225147724,
-0.1061397269,
0.2387754917,
0.0033808372,
-0.5668418407,
-0.0435759649,
-0.5824024081,
0.1505589187,
-0.6590490341,
-0.3425813913,
-0.3024789095,
-0.3500666618,
0.0710945278,
-0.5008397698,
0.1651494056,
-0.236485213,
0.5646824837,
0.1018829271,
-0.0352450013,
-0.3636493385,
-0.9340132475,
0.794819057,
-0.3536423743,
0.5787138939,
0.5174888968,
0.2184228897,
0.2357186824,
-0.2083882391,
-0.3418004215,
-0.3638427556,
0.2257012725,
0.1368959695,
-0.040770933,
-0.0013389274,
0.0018182938,
0.3969713748,
-0.5837078094,
0.1922613084,
-0.5007963777,
-0.403496027,
0.4142516553,
-0.3421611786,
0.2212671787,
-0.5061746836,
-0.250751704,
-0.0536813214,
-0.5886057019,
-0.212596491,
0.7546890974,
0.8935739994,
-0.3198511899,
0.6618846059,
0.0271042604,
0.6798866391,
-0.4312563837,
-0.4362201393,
0.5264448524,
-0.3597359657,
-0.1266501248,
0.3457135856,
0.794338882,
-0.3875497282,
0.4872983098,
-0.1076564118,
-0.3897738755,
-0.0173390377,
-0.0263052303,
-0.5379140973,
-0.063967295,
0.3429124355,
-0.4153263867,
-0.372603178,
-0.2560617626,
-0.6881895661,
-0.1449057311,
-0.0902922899,
-0.2380280942,
-0.7464543581,
-0.4558006227,
-0.1330947131,
-0.0458239354,
-0.1722570211,
-0.0136311762,
-0.7728462219,
0.1243283451,
0.0958517343,
0.9404106736,
-0.103189446,
-0.1237816066,
-0.7618463635,
0.0487554222,
-0.5044256449,
0.8924878836,
-0.7543333769,
-0.9007587433,
0.2451304793,
-0.4119699299,
0.0499610938,
-0.8693420887,
1.0504468679,
-0.1196924523,
0.2120441347,
0.0102451788,
-0.1812007427,
0.1846259534,
-0.0897649676,
-0.7312850952,
1.1223045588,
0.3698192239,
-0.8162326217,
0.3482717276,
-0.4320629537,
-0.8059349656,
0.5894419551,
-0.196275562,
-0.0470328666,
-0.1646972001,
0.1022633389,
0.3391390443,
-0.0978113413,
0.0893001407,
-0.2739760876,
-0.5636942983,
0.3672002554,
-0.4843725264,
1.0979983807,
0.7302849889,
-0.1683855355,
-0.2759364843,
-0.8505383134,
0.1484334618,
-0.0485771522,
-0.7157662511,
-0.4799335003,
-0.3812734783,
0.588512063,
-0.1876603812,
0.0869566575,
-0.3921414614,
0.2789023519,
-0.7583793998,
0.5114017725,
0.3051800728,
-0.0876220539,
0.5796666741,
-0.3513264358,
0.6323464513,
-0.110564433,
-0.1005479842,
0.0402188264,
-0.3693823218,
-0.5837184787,
-0.8668914437,
0.8405386806,
0.9266235828,
-0.6910405755,
0.590302825,
-0.2367615253,
-0.5485519171,
-0.6618335843,
0.1062395722,
0.355638206,
0.1542913914,
0.3116821945,
-0.3434894681,
-0.4934539795,
-0.7692376375,
0.1870512068,
-0.3413673937,
-0.2092994899,
0.4776147306,
0.058515925,
0.0086841891,
0.5275849104,
-0.1778796166,
-0.3602629304,
-0.4779318571,
-0.0639432445,
0.3359182775,
0.4381436408,
0.7295377851,
-0.4433287382,
-0.1250671297,
0.0140628926,
-0.3932096362,
-0.2308029979,
0.0974433199,
-0.0823293552,
0.1526488364,
0.1917762905,
-0.5420645475,
0.0070511447,
0.2756438255,
0.0151189277,
0.2628672123,
-0.1557822376,
-0.1477811933,
-1.0777759552,
0.0964115858,
-0.0799829811,
-0.0036718138,
-0.3195987344,
-0.1909502596,
-0.3167538941,
-0.366494,
-0.5364584923,
0.5588297248,
-0.5505304933,
-0.343408674,
-0.1404387951,
0.2493836135,
-0.3364059329,
0.4611284733,
0.277058959,
0.7033901811,
0.6000355482,
-0.6631004214,
0.3905702829,
0.3339861333,
-0.3540724218,
0.7230358124,
-0.5604726672,
-0.0630299896,
0.1774219722,
0.2494168133,
-0.7431171536,
-0.2147902399,
0.0817437172,
-0.2947109044,
0.1682236791,
-0.388795048,
-0.4867187142,
-0.2651107609,
0.0763854533,
0.5878187418,
0.5068463087,
-0.3968245089,
0.3740463555,
0.8510993123,
-0.6050826311,
-0.3962773383,
-0.823795557,
0.2688155472,
-0.555746913,
-0.6170594096,
0.3795873523,
0.0488617793,
-0.4417819977,
-0.2106799483,
0.3700792491,
-0.2951821983,
0.004139611,
-0.0807341784,
0.2796194255,
-0.207283482,
0.3518153727,
0.0531820953,
0.1405295283,
-0.4261255562,
-0.5322896242,
0.67182827,
-0.0127526801,
0.117595084,
-0.2739340067,
0.5746923089,
0.2199499607,
-0.4508271217,
0.0348438919,
0.634713769,
-0.3188958764,
-0.5439522862,
-0.3928436041,
-0.0788302198,
-0.3277606964,
-0.0272979811,
-0.466558516,
-0.5507600904,
0.5997963548,
0.2680562139,
-0.143723011,
0.1836544275,
0.6320613623,
-0.0427695401,
0.3494703472,
0.2976006567,
-0.1298986673,
0.6774579883,
-0.3887229562,
-0.2458157688,
-0.3836391568,
0.0990845785,
-0.7979907393,
-0.1302259266,
-1.0286076069,
-0.4541752934,
0.3138741553,
-0.0749063417,
0.1822891533,
0.579769969,
-0.695618391,
0.1856594086,
0.9935923815,
0.0556445718,
0.1834148616,
0.2268057913,
-0.4650943577,
0.2973065376,
-0.6841225624,
-0.6863773465,
1.0087579489,
0.012081896,
0.4943868816,
0.1897662282,
0.9697696567,
0.3966379166,
-0.3915269077,
-0.8463009596,
0.6289466619,
-0.0925308689,
-0.4542233944,
-0.5306823254,
-0.4246305823,
-1.293328166,
0.2439631969,
-0.3312766552,
-0.4710023701,
0.385500133,
-0.086565882,
-0.7048301697,
-0.0803911909,
-0.8581416011,
0.6497404575,
-0.246026203,
-0.2568112016,
-0.1018172204,
-0.6263390183,
-0.0624313056,
0.0600749068,
0.3894666135,
0.0436967798,
-0.0002359055,
0.8782687783,
-0.5032077432,
0.6895967126,
-0.2938023508,
-0.219874844,
0.8578622937,
0.2229727358,
0.2717436552,
0.0935408324,
-0.1018172801,
0.2172356993,
0.0113766426,
-0.6713808775,
-0.0669473186,
0.5555329323,
-0.7013348341,
0.0367168523,
-0.3388508558,
-0.3564117849,
-0.5295013189,
0.1683029979,
0.4505182207,
0.339497447,
-0.591152072,
-0.001944655,
0.5007300973,
-0.2634181976,
0.7178800702,
0.2147394121,
0.2866182327,
-0.4908719659,
1.0348802805,
0.4242623448,
-0.1200940385,
0.427238822,
0.272652626,
-0.2607843578,
-0.7491471767,
-0.529774487,
0.3283634186,
-0.3044023216,
0.0386039987,
-0.4563123584,
-0.0244453214,
-0.4226428866,
-0.0037016058,
-0.3227266371,
-0.7114027739,
-0.2533004284,
-0.1555233747,
0.0086291917,
0.3811487556,
-0.3736086488,
0.2278258055,
-0.7786273956,
0.1972601563,
0.0718936399,
0.1399554908,
-0.4330409467,
-0.4297907054,
-0.1730470657,
0.0498203523,
-0.14206177,
-0.9177109003,
0.5474398732,
0.1309022158,
0.5035076141,
0.254465282,
0.1473524421,
0.2972863317,
-0.1899293214,
0.588684082,
-0.0332153514,
-0.7022690177,
0.8122820258,
-0.708956182,
0.1348585933,
0.4569068849,
-0.0643594116,
-0.3675113022,
-0.5540076494,
-0.9930002689,
-0.9442243576,
0.3307470381,
0.5731914043,
0.1282977909,
-0.1690508127,
-0.1364392191,
0.1945302039,
0.1669338644,
-0.3650704622,
0.1918938458,
-0.3312256634,
-0.1183384806,
0.1519138664,
-0.1563621759,
-0.2241607755,
0.1376289278,
0.6128155589,
-0.1689337641,
0.3939158618,
0.1252093464,
0.0169519577,
0.2033981234,
0.7243965864,
0.5044484735,
0.1894635856,
-0.2022205591,
0.2263762355,
0.1988584846,
-0.6381958723,
-0.0631197914,
0.481605202,
-0.223206833,
0.3547854722,
0.5299316049,
0.7026227117,
0.0529981442,
-0.7972079515,
0.4975450337,
0.2999742925,
0.024484342,
-0.3905180693,
-0.116520144,
0.0643946379,
0.1181836426,
0.2739568353,
0.0040741675,
0.2927883863,
-0.5352540612,
-0.0031139252,
0.3429548144,
-0.2430083454,
-0.24168396,
0.308032304,
0.6154568195,
-0.1603002399,
0.5179239511,
-0.4550885558,
-0.0313829556,
0.4891780019,
0.1428505927,
0.7466561794,
-0.4412518144,
0.2872274518,
0.2257581502,
0.1431374848,
-0.0646958053,
0.7249305844,
-0.2666613758,
-0.7393068671,
-0.1890904456,
-0.6350067258,
-0.5230189562,
0.0861669406,
-0.4092390239,
0.4321620762,
-0.2289068252,
-0.1761673391,
0.1360475868,
-0.1164575368,
-0.5393317342,
0.3790382147,
0.2864949703,
0.537040472,
-0.4549399316,
0.8322034478,
0.3699154854,
-0.4648453891,
-0.8892941475,
-0.1155171841,
-0.3719240725,
-1.031463027,
0.5204457641,
-0.2937634587,
-0.0692408085,
-0.3088804483,
-0.1814988703,
-0.5096593499,
0.4967862368,
0.7968028784,
-0.6020812392,
-0.2401153892,
0.2387292981,
0.6364713907,
-0.3289244175,
0.4657826722,
0.3809634149,
0.363984108,
0.2657727599,
-1.3476301432,
-0.2506221831,
-0.2488453984,
0.0001826365,
0.0272248425,
-0.6261053681,
0.5385773778,
-0.4913573265,
-0.4643698633,
0.0411115438,
0.5708669424,
0.1716786772,
-0.0802864656,
0.7298084497,
0.477535516,
1.2341759205,
-0.0417084694,
0.8393551707,
-0.5357743502,
0.0139537659,
0.9498935342,
-0.1849317551,
0.9341463447,
0.2582969666,
-0.1125335097,
0.1517594159,
0.8328523636,
-0.0077882661,
0.3974150717,
0.336473763,
-0.4150480628,
-0.3550875485,
-0.587849021,
-0.5479994416,
1.0893993378,
0.2639531195,
-0.3330289721,
0.0887015387,
0.2086214125,
0.0848806351,
-0.0974686071,
-0.1347585022,
0.4997045398,
0.0580854788,
-0.5631299019,
0.9329276681,
-0.2382431328,
0.5903768539,
-0.1662519276,
0.1925721318,
-0.2560396791,
-0.0336647071,
-0.2001141757,
-0.7962235212,
0.2195388526,
0.0773344859,
0.2302919626,
-0.2263302058,
0.4779552221,
-0.537440896,
-0.3987128139,
0.1890967935,
0.9140504003,
0.438842237,
0.0470690504,
-0.183706373,
0.0299807247,
-0.1502352655,
-0.0413301587,
-0.0846133456,
0.6702814102,
-0.1372543126,
0.353697896,
0.524007678,
0.5789156556,
-0.250841856,
0.456117034,
0.6490306854,
-0.7897537947,
-1.0943943262,
-0.3925049007,
0.1352561265,
-0.0307198409,
-0.5449901819,
0.3188898265,
0.8779206872,
0.7719193101,
0.1500755847,
1.2257525921,
0.081073761,
0.8966943622,
-0.4817209244,
0.3781898022,
-0.1864072829,
0.3748018742,
-0.3530247509,
-1.1022201777,
-0.112667352,
0.7199172378,
0.1139793694,
0.0748346373,
0.559710741,
0.555685401,
-0.1027344614,
0.2832916081,
0.3357977271,
0.220377326,
-0.0396647304,
0.5549077392,
0.8075322509,
-0.0007339412,
1.1437761784,
-0.0763963908,
-0.3422735035,
-0.2425824851,
-0.5725472569,
-0.6878503561,
-0.546521306,
-0.2343321741,
-0.5739924312,
0.0488013178,
0.910954535,
0.727532804,
-0.5902620554,
-0.5341541171,
0.0315907039,
-0.0022905599,
-0.2987904549,
-0.2080420405,
0.3382348418,
-0.0919188708,
-0.9599227905,
0.7171323299,
0.1439075321,
0.3344755471,
-0.1559799016,
0.2021634579,
0.2116343379,
0.1306964457,
0.4417794049,
0.3794519007,
-0.41003564,
-0.2125593275,
0.2302984297,
-0.1923865974,
0.2127235681,
0.7659994364,
-0.8194879293,
0.2162906677,
0.5134059191,
0.3024524748,
0.4125857949,
-0.4391537309,
0.2738432884,
-0.8810198307,
0.5361351967,
0.7130568624,
0.6535486579,
0.5666194558,
-0.1151446104,
0.686286509,
0.5555801392,
-0.1673949808,
-0.835406661,
0.3576657176,
-1.7591485977,
-0.2053622752,
1.5952666998,
0.332059592,
0.0120280189,
-0.2472924739,
-0.5766205788,
0.2858776152,
-0.9438288808,
0.6089789271,
0.5600200891,
-0.0238740724,
0.2008576244,
-0.1958053112,
0.2986263335,
0.2138614655,
-0.7037296891,
0.1181234643,
0.5837587118,
0.0350362882,
0.4780012965,
0.795946002,
0.0385998711,
-0.0234912802,
0.1933474243,
-0.0487431735,
0.204194203,
-0.2488689125,
0.1866424084,
0.6752160788,
0.0170337297,
-0.2757595778
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05785v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05785v3
|
Limits of Transformer Language Models on Learning to Compose Algorithms
| 2024-02-08T16:23:29 | 2024-05-25T11:09:28 |
Jonathan Thomm, Aleksandar Terzic, Giacomo Camposampiero, Michael Hersche, Bernhard Schölkopf, Abbas Rahimi
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We analyze the capabilities of Transformer language models in learning
compositional discrete tasks. To this end, we evaluate training LLaMA models
and prompting GPT-4 and Gemini on four tasks demanding to learn a composition
of several discrete sub-tasks. On both training LLaMA models from scratch and
prompting on GPT-4 and Gemini, we measure how well these models can reuse
primitives observable in the sub-tasks to learn the composition task. Our
results indicate that compositional learning in state-of-the-art Transformer
language models is highly sample inefficient: LLaMA requires more data samples
than relearning all sub-tasks from scratch to learn the compositional task;
in-context prompting with few samples is unreliable and fails at executing the
sub-tasks or correcting the errors in multi-round code generation. Further, by
leveraging complexity theory, we support these findings with a theoretical
analysis focused on the sample inefficiency of gradient descent in memorizing
feedforward models.
|
[
-0.1097497791,
-0.5493947268,
0.6064799428,
0.3084753454,
0.0102871163,
0.2158461064,
-0.2120315433,
-0.3509606123,
-0.2087804675,
0.4442884624,
-0.9119818807,
-0.1395757496,
-0.6917147636,
0.3031014204,
-0.5261352658,
1.1969817877,
-0.1479960829,
-0.0795566291,
-0.3914788067,
0.2545282245,
-0.7928085923,
-0.1639031321,
-0.5205697417,
-0.4229223728,
0.3973718584,
0.5939359665,
0.1645632386,
0.4792799354,
0.3770291209,
0.354755789,
-0.021680871,
-0.0696932375,
-0.6314535737,
0.2331199199,
-0.0350986719,
-0.9101143479,
0.1294572651,
0.1046254113,
0.5109605193,
0.6197099686,
-0.2397441715,
0.0693610609,
-0.2537820637,
0.5119926333,
-0.3745371997,
0.3667037487,
-0.9323952794,
0.0211801268,
-0.0096592028,
0.2821392417,
-0.4274129868,
-0.134449929,
0.2616740167,
-0.5995411277,
0.307207197,
-0.2836260498,
0.3981468081,
0.536036253,
-0.2409549206,
-0.7208964229,
-0.8067803383,
0.9422901869,
-0.4224290848,
0.2433566749,
0.4490819275,
0.4008382559,
0.135526821,
-1.0600320101,
-0.6695191264,
-0.454367727,
-0.0285406504,
0.0999475643,
-0.3697105944,
-0.173303172,
0.5048892498,
0.4032928944,
-0.2328034341,
0.1971305907,
-0.7134343386,
-0.0159394871,
0.3776727617,
0.3239840865,
0.259755373,
0.0602253713,
-0.2306886613,
-0.2315178812,
-0.776679635,
0.1468921155,
0.4740225077,
0.1228734553,
-0.3687033057,
0.357096523,
0.1070089117,
0.5502906442,
0.3547853231,
-0.3893223107,
0.0853401199,
-0.1530506909,
-0.2128852159,
-0.4705398381,
0.6024629474,
-0.1923828125,
0.2529101968,
-0.3396146595,
-0.4531965852,
0.1881662309,
0.7707115412,
-0.5857153535,
-0.4561330378,
0.236262694,
-0.1092175916,
-0.218966499,
-0.038821578,
-0.3157134056,
0.0019815802,
-0.3541365862,
0.6672460437,
-0.414213568,
0.0541231558,
0.0223423541,
-0.0620609522,
0.2650193572,
0.040310055,
-1.2553220987,
0.3716821969,
0.7551196814,
0.5510885715,
-0.2007885873,
-0.6547082663,
-0.1016541198,
-0.2028730363,
-0.1890096962,
0.8312652707,
-0.6315495968,
-0.6672174335,
-0.2064863145,
-0.0180888418,
-0.5826224685,
-0.7285531163,
0.389793843,
-0.4749598503,
0.286547929,
-0.3647562265,
-0.5655121803,
-0.3736253977,
0.0632228181,
-0.987631619,
1.0352417231,
0.5091034174,
-0.4528025091,
0.1152904779,
-0.4648757875,
-0.7071681619,
-0.0284570772,
-0.2453501374,
-0.5813099146,
0.3100332022,
0.2658444941,
0.6401970983,
-0.3128381371,
0.166655153,
0.3451052308,
-0.5099673867,
0.2948194444,
-0.2142007947,
0.50818187,
0.0894776508,
-0.5860668421,
0.0968024433,
-0.6309841275,
-0.4633561075,
0.1517751366,
-0.5767429471,
0.2364256978,
0.1860581487,
-0.2695580125,
0.2064121515,
0.088622652,
-0.3957037032,
0.1931450665,
-0.2749098241,
0.7063952684,
0.7277413011,
-0.1468604505,
0.6362476349,
-0.6345498562,
0.7909710407,
0.0762122124,
0.0729484037,
-0.5675861239,
-0.4248714745,
-0.959626019,
-0.1998473704,
0.0072894963,
0.5651982427,
-0.8051646948,
0.0768561289,
-0.291004926,
-0.7616207004,
-0.334025979,
0.1600745916,
0.452729404,
0.6246384978,
0.327772975,
-0.2079161108,
-0.4005672634,
-0.7802701592,
0.1390705705,
0.0915110707,
-0.0082485629,
0.1115906909,
0.7861730456,
-0.2881920636,
0.7051073909,
-0.1526442319,
0.0234857947,
-0.4053656161,
-0.0848385766,
0.2537661195,
0.4377702475,
0.4139864147,
-0.6796141267,
-0.4988725483,
-0.1441577226,
-0.4961754382,
0.0173826274,
-0.0309670419,
0.3557603657,
0.0488568768,
0.512042284,
-0.6686277986,
-0.0118604964,
0.7481254339,
0.1411315203,
0.5648013949,
-0.070599407,
-0.384275794,
-0.8121877313,
-0.1314559579,
-0.1668320447,
0.1319801211,
-0.8892527819,
0.1572648287,
0.200677231,
-0.0681339279,
-0.4310836792,
0.1717024595,
-0.3163943589,
0.1355181783,
-0.439606607,
-0.3666973412,
-0.2837688327,
0.766780138,
0.0106925527,
0.7336500883,
0.5343925357,
-0.657802403,
0.1425084025,
0.0284728594,
-0.3129237592,
0.4542004466,
-0.8905557394,
0.2301685065,
-0.3419152796,
0.4277745485,
-1.1051638126,
-0.2007776946,
0.1354354322,
-0.0274723526,
0.3219040036,
0.1127105951,
-0.0803899243,
-0.3692377806,
-0.0213084538,
0.3942452371,
0.5135876536,
-0.4285505116,
0.8793507218,
0.1220739558,
0.1584526151,
-0.7064184546,
-0.6634350419,
-0.3898018599,
-0.0926020518,
-0.3309521973,
0.5487409234,
-0.0426588356,
0.0503325053,
-0.1495597959,
-0.2097915113,
0.183325842,
0.0871258005,
0.4557410181,
0.0364072695,
0.052634567,
0.0303110983,
-0.0075379442,
-0.1937867254,
0.207369104,
-0.3751155138,
0.610969305,
-0.076648362,
-0.6280785799,
-0.3057955205,
0.2093591392,
0.6089955568,
-0.2581703663,
0.5732117891,
0.4100126922,
-0.1655034274,
-0.4652509093,
-0.6100821495,
-0.3073514998,
-0.4643267989,
0.336116761,
-0.5266094804,
-1.040168643,
0.7275583744,
0.1479845941,
0.2498898059,
0.6389533877,
0.6311270595,
-0.1072536334,
0.4488854408,
0.7140985727,
-0.3612506092,
0.4913824797,
-0.6990472674,
0.0386722386,
-0.6035549641,
-0.4105948508,
-0.6348249316,
-0.4211453199,
-0.6628041863,
-0.5185332298,
0.4799293578,
-0.4725942314,
-0.4549189806,
0.4047222137,
-0.447444737,
0.7461932898,
0.8357411623,
0.2592818737,
0.2015464753,
0.0185415279,
-0.0091902716,
0.1368549168,
-0.7889805436,
-0.2509430945,
1.2302436829,
0.3294374347,
0.8293322921,
-0.0787007138,
0.6344248056,
-0.0868655294,
0.4348177314,
-0.867677331,
0.2030435354,
-0.1800775677,
-0.5517688394,
-0.1418364942,
-0.2539631128,
-0.8066874146,
0.0911958739,
0.0269177146,
-0.4596046805,
0.062417116,
-0.0272336565,
-0.1588991284,
0.3373389542,
-0.4505507052,
0.5735412836,
0.0392661765,
0.1396717876,
-0.0650965795,
-0.7840062976,
0.4871005118,
-0.2611822784,
0.1567716151,
0.2637355924,
-0.0182465259,
0.5401673317,
-0.1594384015,
1.3463947773,
-0.0833922401,
-0.3601187766,
0.3934421241,
0.0665872023,
0.7278101444,
-0.3499342799,
0.0164337531,
-0.0414071456,
-0.2538357973,
-0.2643022537,
-0.5322595835,
0.2727501094,
-0.9377339482,
-0.4528982341,
-0.1028328091,
-0.5131335855,
-0.0358403586,
-0.2085432261,
0.6569725275,
0.3084429204,
0.0440750867,
0.0550251417,
0.7145854235,
0.0389951169,
0.5575037599,
0.3123162985,
0.3286897242,
-0.3294288814,
0.9434518814,
0.025025012,
0.4220975637,
0.6071000099,
0.2006067038,
-0.2102054507,
-0.6674514413,
-0.4044703245,
0.2885220647,
-0.8612086773,
-0.1140869111,
-0.5832115412,
-0.1067848057,
0.117269814,
-0.0813842416,
-0.4176805317,
-0.2366182506,
-0.4027383029,
-0.2115493864,
-0.0323199555,
1.1500816345,
0.2597397864,
0.7489351034,
-0.6454894543,
0.0642283335,
0.5858824253,
0.0493101887,
0.2694067061,
-0.6250955462,
-0.4361082911,
-0.1808789819,
-0.6625842452,
-0.8498359919,
-0.007646645,
0.0734066665,
0.7635321617,
0.2099174261,
-0.3871673048,
0.3866505325,
-0.5504045486,
0.9339835048,
-0.0581220202,
-1.1885421276,
0.1845114082,
-0.3571929634,
0.3835488856,
0.4739507139,
0.6782416701,
-0.5417797565,
-0.2665337324,
-0.6379582286,
-0.5235245824,
0.6614840627,
-0.0679332912,
0.5277258754,
0.0139798187,
0.6041359901,
0.2995039225,
0.2343692482,
-1.0911337137,
-0.156896174,
-0.2657424212,
-0.372549057,
-0.0756484568,
-0.2807520628,
0.0324318558,
-0.2181113958,
0.5939047933,
-0.2510151565,
0.3729096949,
-0.1300016046,
-0.0609878674,
-0.1229865551,
0.0772042572,
0.8526355028,
0.6184328198,
0.3630420566,
0.0193904582,
0.3341201842,
-0.5437151194,
0.3555076122,
-0.1555230767,
-0.2687635422,
-0.4944289625,
0.6519386172,
0.9662941694,
0.4163659215,
-0.6795421839,
0.4555619657,
-0.0068488731,
-0.4399263561,
-0.2623697519,
0.2424145788,
0.2818908691,
0.3136619031,
0.4248930216,
-0.0838840902,
-0.1447632164,
-0.4309911728,
-0.0305752661,
0.3734180033,
-0.3597460091,
-0.551504612,
0.6893389225,
-0.0429677926,
-0.2148553431,
0.8299011588,
-0.0163523536,
-0.6737828851,
0.6587033272,
0.7681876421,
0.8146882057,
-0.4067279398,
0.2280668467,
0.1939662099,
0.4658371508,
-0.3772227764,
0.1589021832,
-0.3626767695,
-0.6738333106,
-0.7602407932,
-0.5168653727,
-0.7046738267,
0.1099722311,
-0.2331649661,
-0.0911271796,
-0.3939287066,
0.1859389544,
-0.1068529412,
-0.1515064985,
-0.5901794434,
0.2537482083,
-0.123076193,
0.5803610086,
-0.9812200665,
0.4829784334,
0.5053933263,
-0.3577677608,
-1.2860014439,
-0.2263812721,
-0.2115953714,
-0.7197108865,
0.7607755661,
0.2415536046,
-0.0189459883,
0.0159430485,
-0.6224755049,
-0.8153444529,
1.1083310843,
0.4333272576,
-0.4170095026,
-0.2439443469,
0.2652781606,
0.4854727089,
-0.4170206487,
0.3777056336,
0.6802767515,
0.331391573,
0.2680156827,
-0.9785291553,
0.0072958372,
-0.1578525603,
0.0453708731,
0.0555369891,
-0.5967085361,
1.4248400927,
-0.1700323969,
-0.2873942554,
0.0316898488,
0.6165280342,
0.0307401139,
0.0226619262,
0.4862616956,
0.66534549,
0.6223966479,
-0.1169847324,
1.1661639214,
-0.0296202395,
0.2270535678,
0.8993577957,
-0.0508586988,
0.6435596347,
0.4582456648,
-0.4610691369,
0.8478560448,
0.419239819,
-0.1265313178,
0.4397237599,
0.4563670158,
-0.3690293431,
0.0229763687,
0.398816973,
0.0273024477,
0.7304965854,
0.3374398053,
-0.4215053022,
-0.1038430557,
0.2074905634,
-0.0898022503,
0.0012465239,
-0.0464548618,
0.8619394898,
0.0448362976,
-1.0937867165,
0.5456295609,
0.0656138882,
0.7195359468,
-0.5904909372,
0.1944105923,
-0.2300972641,
0.043870829,
-0.1326816827,
-0.3580787778,
0.3936907947,
-0.2173089981,
-0.228728652,
0.0143599315,
0.392989248,
-0.3005611897,
-0.4600054622,
-0.1233107001,
0.6657687426,
-0.0492612198,
-0.244444117,
-0.3720061779,
-0.0156935323,
0.0600068122,
-0.2237873822,
0.0730974525,
0.1239343286,
-0.0585298017,
0.7939232588,
0.6492869258,
-0.2085632235,
0.2912579775,
0.0513982996,
0.966599524,
-0.4889383316,
-0.4040050507,
-1.0174146891,
0.5147945881,
0.5359190106,
-0.0973737091,
0.590254426,
0.2436895519,
1.2140511274,
-0.5107243061,
0.7939009666,
-0.0230284017,
0.2459356636,
-0.6410540938,
0.226016745,
-0.1630664766,
0.3354964256,
-0.1107008606,
-0.996725738,
-0.1028658524,
0.4944903851,
-0.3457010686,
0.3341938257,
0.7198153734,
0.8166384697,
-0.1985056251,
0.4125031531,
0.1475985944,
-0.2584034801,
0.453237623,
0.8884189129,
1.0895820856,
-0.4334207177,
0.3805870414,
-0.5547454953,
0.0421147496,
0.0066629308,
-0.6894987226,
-0.9699383974,
-0.8617860675,
0.069471769,
0.0088131074,
-0.3444288671,
0.8140090704,
0.710670352,
-0.6325336099,
-0.4103469551,
-0.3461814821,
0.1446817219,
-0.3828659356,
-0.1423113495,
0.2421227396,
-0.5296390653,
-1.0134198666,
0.5084414482,
-0.0236322954,
0.2927156389,
-0.450615108,
0.0145256398,
0.2324736416,
-0.0603307448,
0.5387287736,
0.2729106843,
-0.6624130607,
-0.0113197025,
0.2436965108,
0.0165766329,
0.0331726,
1.1949123144,
-0.7664679885,
0.2037941813,
0.3914786279,
0.8192844987,
0.8179408908,
-0.168115288,
0.373034209,
-0.8471208811,
-0.0649650469,
0.1153753474,
0.2117458582,
0.3430716693,
-0.1756442338,
0.3699728251,
0.2727866173,
-0.695340991,
-0.3185497224,
0.4233616292,
-0.7975688577,
-0.1671427637,
0.8565577269,
-0.0172970649,
-0.2543802261,
0.0421681628,
-0.1641140431,
0.0196760185,
-0.0986607149,
0.6837907434,
0.6109814644,
-0.243699044,
-0.2112013847,
-0.4805062413,
0.582019031,
0.3385483325,
-0.7473987937,
-0.1863816231,
0.3348989487,
0.55061692,
0.1730717868,
0.6474813223,
0.0578337871,
0.3356787264,
0.1482053995,
-0.1740319878,
-0.2440164536,
-0.5022802353,
-0.4758666754,
0.2260219008,
-0.1536600143,
0.0509405509
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05783v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05783v2
|
Text-to-Code Generation with Modality-relative Pre-training
| 2024-02-08T16:17:24 | 2024-02-12T10:44:18 |
Fenia Christopoulou, Guchun Zhang, Gerasimos Lampouras
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large pre-trained language models have recently been expanded and applied to
programming language tasks with great success, often through further
pre-training of a strictly-natural language model--where training sequences
typically contain both natural and (linearised) programming language. Such
approaches effectively map both modalities of the sequence into the same
embedding space. However, programming language keywords (e.g. "while") often
have very strictly defined semantics. As such, transfer learning from their
natural language usage may not necessarily be beneficial to their code
application and vise versa. Assuming an already pre-trained language model, in
this work we investigate how sequence tokens can be adapted and represented
differently, depending on which modality they belong to, and to the ultimate
benefit of the downstream task. We experiment with separating embedding spaces
between modalities during further model pre-training with modality-relative
training objectives. We focus on text-to-code generation and observe consistent
improvements across two backbone models and two test sets, measuring pass@$k$
and a novel incremental variation.
|
[
-0.2794430554,
-0.3587810695,
0.4625290632,
0.1193738207,
-0.3997282684,
0.0666349307,
-0.2900155783,
-0.4171696603,
0.0186103173,
0.3009543717,
-0.5122611523,
-0.3009101748,
-0.4886814952,
0.3967473209,
-0.2136129439,
1.1790076494,
-0.1511241198,
0.0592797771,
-0.1479435712,
-0.0608227886,
-0.7411031127,
-0.9203024507,
-0.1249476373,
-0.0202794857,
0.3874312341,
0.2376797646,
0.5045237541,
0.544927001,
0.4303080142,
0.262334615,
0.4284659028,
-0.0443652831,
-0.2376629859,
0.0312708355,
-0.1251005977,
-0.5737899542,
-0.3845046163,
0.0109625096,
0.7572080493,
0.7325347066,
0.2892301679,
0.1641702354,
0.1128155142,
0.4364399016,
-0.6119399667,
-0.0371649824,
-0.6426236629,
0.0334560983,
-0.1363687366,
-0.4046561122,
-0.4576510489,
-0.2182941288,
0.1291391551,
-0.5545434356,
0.102024816,
-0.0982879251,
0.790910244,
0.1350778788,
-0.4817842245,
-0.5617782474,
-0.4511582851,
0.7096908092,
-0.8706977963,
0.4965950251,
0.3768058717,
-0.0317777358,
0.1753522754,
-0.8937213421,
-0.6764950752,
-0.642988801,
-0.1865005344,
-0.1134632155,
0.2135428786,
0.0600225329,
0.3836862445,
0.2977932096,
-0.5032797456,
-0.1200141609,
-0.3188224733,
-0.217618674,
0.3626586199,
-0.0327420793,
0.160525471,
-0.4238601029,
-0.2723404169,
-0.1314863861,
-0.724247396,
0.0790641233,
0.445273608,
0.4613551795,
-0.2889043391,
0.5045633912,
0.0686142147,
0.7872257829,
0.1174624637,
-0.1763952374,
0.421159029,
-0.9705115557,
-0.310934931,
-0.231403023,
0.5475186706,
-0.2244892865,
0.1521975994,
-0.3445186317,
-0.3017633259,
0.195243001,
0.5663046837,
-0.8671905994,
-0.3455623388,
-0.2048039138,
-0.6077687144,
-0.4365859032,
0.2538317442,
-0.1649044305,
0.1056282297,
-0.5568765998,
0.6011365652,
-0.4680746794,
-0.1692585051,
0.0726721659,
-0.005912988,
0.2772496045,
0.0413034558,
-0.6401950121,
0.0400267057,
0.4710448384,
0.675386548,
-0.1474992335,
-0.1462374777,
-0.5956684947,
0.0351434276,
-0.2296642363,
0.5146375895,
-0.8274461627,
-0.6463577151,
0.0748507604,
-0.1697833985,
-0.1803236604,
-0.347566396,
0.172792092,
-0.5336546302,
0.503262639,
-0.3116591275,
-0.5398551822,
0.047867775,
0.272752136,
-0.3607842326,
0.9648371935,
0.2807385027,
-0.736428678,
0.68106848,
-0.7892484069,
-0.6945621371,
-0.3349044323,
-0.5065205097,
-0.2264158726,
0.2987091243,
-0.176593855,
0.3343858421,
-0.283097595,
0.0626100376,
-0.1767306924,
-0.2787724435,
0.4786532223,
-0.3768688142,
0.2498021424,
0.2127726525,
-0.4568924606,
0.1709360778,
-0.9164925814,
0.1844209284,
-0.2022959292,
-0.6649340391,
-0.3808034658,
-0.1106997952,
0.1011202335,
0.41943416,
0.1771895438,
-0.2003600746,
0.4804426134,
-0.3557637036,
0.3603854775,
0.731767714,
-0.0759640038,
0.7017480135,
-0.41918993,
0.721224606,
0.073772639,
-0.2010620981,
-0.5343486071,
-0.0844451711,
-0.7525585294,
-0.277664274,
0.4415562153,
0.4105662405,
-1.0317534208,
0.5488536358,
-0.3724391758,
0.078372106,
-0.0622147396,
0.0725127682,
0.5645073652,
0.4003456533,
0.2317948192,
-0.7524174452,
-0.4804131091,
-0.4996345639,
-0.0744205937,
-0.2043633014,
-0.034197595,
0.3106627762,
0.3794086576,
-0.3120881319,
0.8936089277,
-0.4613008797,
-0.0041933083,
-0.237194553,
0.1783893704,
0.2080252171,
0.754334271,
0.610868454,
-0.772816956,
-0.4693071246,
-0.0960708559,
-0.2370526493,
-0.2146077156,
-0.5646416545,
-0.2294168174,
0.2535485923,
0.7526900172,
-0.1830336452,
0.4620881975,
0.5343689919,
-0.4019018412,
0.7023866177,
-0.2658005953,
0.2397030294,
-1.4761722088,
0.4043809772,
-0.4626503885,
-0.432331413,
-0.4775542021,
-0.0075362078,
0.0194568485,
-0.0562101044,
-0.350589186,
0.260579139,
-0.5410097837,
-0.1353527457,
-0.2984364629,
-0.1116775349,
0.0917712748,
0.4696097374,
0.1001798809,
0.9597713947,
0.5221446753,
-0.7190901041,
-0.0752085522,
0.1342532635,
-0.0492778048,
0.2569195926,
-0.5212017298,
0.4712899029,
0.1668147892,
0.251321435,
-0.9156343937,
-0.1619429588,
0.237606883,
-0.4066427648,
0.6351135373,
-0.0765509084,
-0.4439421892,
-0.1202070564,
-0.3361777365,
0.9105184674,
0.5911244154,
-0.0934933275,
0.3613843322,
-0.0701434687,
0.0016624127,
-0.3684149086,
-0.7728040218,
-0.0997153521,
-0.1769135147,
-0.3648885489,
0.5405587554,
-0.0550566204,
0.1486450285,
-0.0922396332,
-0.2204910517,
-0.2242750973,
0.0432109796,
0.239072457,
0.3233941197,
-0.4206269979,
0.274205029,
-0.0315609351,
-0.1340138167,
-0.0193447471,
-0.6925891042,
0.5658307076,
0.0370299481,
-0.6102067828,
-0.2406214178,
0.3649190366,
0.3320170939,
-0.3247828186,
0.6486347318,
0.3704294264,
-0.1264787912,
-0.1422669291,
-0.2098591328,
-0.1442109793,
-0.5217083097,
0.440341413,
-0.6259188652,
-0.8824378848,
0.309063524,
-0.083860673,
0.2155469656,
0.1143194586,
0.4595338106,
0.0970206708,
0.7265431285,
0.9206382632,
0.1055538133,
0.8597659469,
-0.1861050874,
0.3091204464,
-0.5269829035,
-0.0110064847,
-0.6925516725,
-0.1091181636,
-0.5952382684,
-0.7108647823,
0.1045396626,
0.297778964,
-0.2728737295,
0.6163353324,
-0.3238966465,
0.3112593889,
0.3905979693,
-0.0253944565,
0.1163528338,
0.0405515619,
-0.1437580884,
-0.0684054866,
-0.7168287039,
-0.4866999686,
1.1870297194,
0.1306756884,
0.5483402014,
0.1152244508,
0.8033114076,
0.3448877037,
0.5561490059,
-0.6122036576,
0.3311772048,
-0.3032124341,
-0.352905035,
0.0511518382,
-0.5581749678,
-0.7090122104,
-0.0843841136,
-0.1493764371,
-0.4586852789,
0.0937644914,
0.2446449697,
-0.2602712512,
-0.0360129997,
-0.5741306543,
0.9004523158,
-0.1932279468,
-0.2130961269,
-0.1552102119,
-0.7985944748,
0.0270806793,
-0.4298169315,
0.1450336874,
0.2180463672,
-0.0252714884,
0.3444764018,
-0.5628108382,
0.7287507653,
0.0181114729,
-0.1258151531,
0.2691473961,
0.2000885904,
0.3518251181,
0.1050586626,
0.0135610746,
-0.1540309042,
0.013409609,
-0.4288156331,
-0.4378739297,
0.3049846292,
-0.648082912,
-0.4019672275,
-0.1772996634,
-0.5965892673,
-0.3476613462,
0.2157639861,
0.5705770254,
0.8680426478,
0.1070336923,
0.1187303215,
0.4397329688,
-0.4138104618,
0.4575490355,
0.1928619593,
-0.182746917,
-0.221483022,
0.7891149521,
-0.1563673317,
0.714289844,
0.6438513994,
0.0502948985,
-0.3949343264,
-0.5608291626,
-0.4027120173,
0.0764129385,
-0.7267331481,
-0.1659798175,
-0.3255403936,
-0.1028589979,
-0.5348784924,
-0.5901405215,
-0.2375291437,
-0.368031472,
-0.49300313,
0.1394245923,
0.0847221836,
0.563962996,
0.0054403464,
0.1589392424,
-1.1586619616,
0.2466964722,
0.1973884255,
0.1830264777,
-0.212433666,
-0.7576431036,
-0.2291785479,
0.1259419769,
-0.2691866457,
-0.9416745901,
0.1315589994,
0.4770042896,
0.3192244768,
0.2785563767,
-0.0731718168,
0.8823490739,
-0.5759788752,
0.9111521244,
0.5125508308,
-1.149695158,
0.4762482345,
-0.2372882068,
0.4156830609,
0.7833092213,
0.1813227683,
-0.3711061776,
-0.3615818322,
-0.3299039602,
-0.7344787717,
0.5843334198,
0.2749898434,
0.6495682597,
-0.11795035,
0.4524652958,
0.448502332,
0.2941668332,
-1.1267940998,
-0.0406616181,
-0.4103686512,
-0.1902349442,
0.2089998573,
0.0331645347,
0.1864511222,
-0.1562167108,
0.3827835023,
-0.3765094876,
0.5613750219,
0.1772328913,
-0.4033317566,
0.3121468127,
0.3038335443,
0.6230976582,
0.7569645643,
0.2066063285,
0.1621403396,
0.0379986353,
-0.5639821291,
0.1864178479,
-0.0411915183,
0.0981820002,
0.0971986949,
0.5459651947,
0.7788643837,
0.274086833,
-0.6953693032,
0.7051839232,
0.131886676,
-0.1755717695,
0.0178191476,
0.1150268242,
-0.1600303948,
0.0335541815,
0.1888567805,
0.2658984363,
0.0777897537,
-0.6870440245,
0.4024142027,
0.1996130198,
-0.2743712962,
-0.5428375602,
0.5280568004,
0.317860961,
-0.2937364876,
0.5388634205,
-0.3393038511,
-0.6319589019,
0.5449604988,
0.6993339658,
0.9744644165,
0.2847310603,
0.0442527421,
0.1406648159,
0.0241237897,
0.2191260159,
0.3989605606,
-0.6050786972,
-0.6612349153,
-0.7297267914,
-0.6439848542,
0.118676275,
-0.1542628706,
-0.6232917905,
0.4224527478,
-0.4186702073,
-0.3488833606,
-0.3383822739,
-0.3016328514,
-0.8418290615,
0.0798735321,
0.3343304992,
0.8437129259,
-0.674725771,
1.1446779966,
0.9762477279,
-0.5249846578,
-1.168766737,
0.5087500215,
-0.5211416483,
-0.3856314123,
0.841567874,
0.3750110269,
-0.099732101,
-0.1012787372,
-0.2678197622,
-0.8404801488,
0.7827236056,
0.2964569926,
-0.4537319839,
-0.3042676151,
0.3178267181,
0.3413698673,
-0.4314659238,
0.0635883808,
0.3777186275,
0.1630445868,
0.0267131105,
-1.1473938227,
0.1061096489,
-0.1620294601,
0.2338812351,
0.3388612568,
-0.1990709901,
0.8248197436,
-0.1034125239,
-0.3199573159,
0.1578466296,
0.5641684532,
0.2160727531,
0.0395435691,
0.6115888953,
0.1959943622,
0.4282819033,
0.0956187174,
1.1087834835,
-0.4442915022,
0.2061597705,
1.0210350752,
-0.2111685574,
0.7003005147,
0.5863386393,
-0.2366214991,
0.6825605035,
0.4860233366,
0.3323260248,
0.7581811547,
0.3394479752,
-0.0947476402,
-0.2298686355,
0.1312255561,
-0.6616182327,
0.3074499071,
0.0684903115,
-0.5477272868,
-0.0056488803,
0.1428788453,
0.0201979037,
0.0850502327,
-0.0765783265,
0.6251800656,
0.0920695066,
-0.6754519939,
0.593816936,
0.096385628,
0.9350441098,
-0.8227035999,
-0.0087046595,
-0.1532892287,
-0.0378472507,
-0.101766035,
-0.3747881651,
0.4280739725,
0.0641314015,
-0.3240122199,
-0.4950455725,
0.6193082333,
-0.3901900649,
-0.4305250347,
-0.0649943426,
0.4277757406,
-0.0535521545,
0.1876832396,
-0.6160581708,
-0.0489186719,
0.1838224977,
-0.1935718209,
0.3011796176,
0.417322427,
0.0075460221,
0.13162449,
0.8318962455,
0.0365058593,
0.3235764802,
0.070740819,
0.9865885377,
-0.5167686939,
-0.8176737428,
-0.772130847,
0.5349903107,
0.1406496465,
-0.6574508548,
0.4926381409,
0.4407121539,
0.9890390635,
-0.2510508597,
0.6881069541,
-0.4592586756,
0.0195400827,
-0.823923707,
0.398150146,
-0.5551211834,
0.3928280473,
-0.3460925817,
-1.0499646664,
-0.1624583006,
0.7965505123,
-0.203775987,
0.1517011076,
0.8824965358,
0.7083758116,
-0.0586081296,
-0.2234764993,
0.2019520253,
-0.163540706,
0.4261897802,
0.7219347954,
0.8489188552,
-0.2268348932,
0.3901707232,
0.0219900832,
-0.1092342213,
-0.0975472257,
-1.0879188776,
-0.6733701229,
-0.6491596699,
-0.3230007291,
-0.3977440596,
-0.1296420991,
1.103051424,
0.8550742865,
-0.6755837798,
-0.091264762,
-0.3863141537,
-0.2266459912,
0.0593302101,
-0.1815682948,
0.1894320697,
-0.718830049,
-0.4232163131,
0.2379262745,
0.1271124631,
0.1340040416,
-0.1398584098,
-0.1445091814,
0.088108018,
0.1929760128,
0.5368593931,
0.1900408268,
-0.3468714356,
-0.5509452224,
0.205151394,
-0.3573106527,
0.1324556917,
1.462157011,
-0.9701416492,
0.3402279317,
0.6442549825,
0.8214265108,
0.2467685938,
-0.054760389,
0.8020247817,
-1.1569322348,
0.3970940709,
0.2343807966,
0.1263896972,
0.1489775777,
-0.2071142495,
0.2806401849,
0.3236210942,
-0.2935018837,
-0.8718759418,
0.4483329952,
-0.8068110943,
-0.4467437565,
1.2088466883,
-0.1237456575,
0.2179427594,
-0.1045418382,
-0.2362548113,
0.4006028175,
-0.0541228615,
0.547175169,
0.5351868272,
-0.1023485214,
0.4141772985,
-0.2983619571,
0.5537260175,
0.5894472599,
-0.9405026436,
-0.1975748241,
0.6673590541,
0.3050485849,
0.2070668042,
0.7980819941,
-0.2214083821,
0.39438501,
0.0674582645,
-0.0859071985,
-0.0534010828,
-0.2258754522,
-0.2563738227,
0.1022101119,
0.250082612,
-0.3615498841
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05779v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05779v1
|
Examining Gender and Racial Bias in Large Vision-Language Models Using a Novel Dataset of Parallel Images
| 2024-02-08T16:11:23 | 2024-02-08T16:11:23 |
Kathleen C. Fraser, Svetlana Kiritchenko
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Following on recent advances in large language models (LLMs) and subsequent
chat models, a new wave of large vision-language models (LVLMs) has emerged.
Such models can incorporate images as input in addition to text, and perform
tasks such as visual question answering, image captioning, story generation,
etc. Here, we examine potential gender and racial biases in such systems, based
on the perceived characteristics of the people in the input images. To
accomplish this, we present a new dataset PAIRS (PArallel Images for eveRyday
Scenarios). The PAIRS dataset contains sets of AI-generated images of people,
such that the images are highly similar in terms of background and visual
content, but differ along the dimensions of gender (man, woman) and race
(Black, white). By querying the LVLMs with such images, we observe significant
differences in the responses according to the perceived gender or race of the
person depicted.
|
[
-0.5679528713,
-0.5094468594,
0.5091090202,
0.1050148755,
-0.1247469038,
0.1677667201,
-0.1686748862,
-0.6931772828,
0.2799917459,
0.5814147592,
-0.6596247554,
-0.40974769,
-0.5220786929,
0.1386445314,
-0.506957233,
0.6558942199,
0.0279972199,
0.375482142,
-0.4926082492,
-0.3123437762,
-0.6680835485,
-0.3926191032,
-0.5437523723,
-0.0146263819,
0.4716976583,
0.1584557891,
0.8210903406,
0.3803468943,
0.6772399545,
0.2464595288,
0.124092333,
0.1299716234,
-0.5611136556,
0.1517583579,
-0.1951375157,
-0.5734657049,
0.039567396,
-0.1530409902,
0.7269516587,
0.6442008615,
0.2596226335,
0.5573900342,
0.1038102806,
0.7572097182,
-0.6685899496,
0.3221223652,
-0.6004980803,
0.2482624203,
-0.3581548035,
0.0630584732,
-0.2117083073,
-0.175478518,
0.1018634886,
-0.4037083089,
0.4262586236,
0.3124002516,
0.7093409896,
0.2075977921,
-0.4914855361,
-0.0001074532,
-0.8227289319,
0.6951872706,
-0.3934332728,
0.4842247367,
0.331677407,
0.4671815634,
0.0525895394,
-0.2726885378,
-0.9101549387,
-0.2979053259,
-0.2976962328,
-0.0587397143,
-0.0797820687,
-0.1994677633,
0.4425764084,
0.0820867568,
-0.511762917,
0.2499641776,
-0.4863551259,
-0.1262261122,
0.8158398271,
0.4178678095,
0.5287620425,
-0.1056180149,
-0.1345668435,
-0.1546942741,
-0.6555988193,
0.0038696376,
0.5335842371,
0.2161407173,
-0.4309787154,
0.7974259853,
-0.2694815695,
0.7988167405,
-0.174716413,
-0.1129541546,
0.4301356375,
-0.2195456028,
-0.1308330446,
-0.1718973666,
0.8590490818,
1.0110523701,
0.6243519783,
0.110334076,
-0.0400564335,
0.214730069,
-0.0315824412,
-0.6067355871,
-0.0438574776,
-0.0762602314,
-0.7093022466,
-0.3779945672,
-0.0762387663,
-1.1057405472,
-1.0310133696,
-0.3980651498,
0.0497478358,
0.0739514604,
-0.2781222761,
-0.2765347362,
-0.2976605296,
0.3258702159,
0.3697770834,
-0.8994035125,
0.2193727791,
0.4015005231,
0.6267002225,
-0.4824182689,
-0.3601045012,
-0.2540684342,
0.0323648937,
-0.2441931814,
0.5563797355,
-0.7067949772,
-0.1146668568,
0.0322639197,
-0.1174539253,
0.1221432537,
-0.6271998882,
0.2865456343,
-0.5426832438,
0.1348289251,
-0.5045602322,
-0.1393160224,
0.1611644328,
0.2502405047,
-0.7548944354,
0.6961518526,
-0.2277746946,
-1.1250010729,
0.413130492,
-0.546290338,
-0.181750074,
0.0392036512,
-0.7646495104,
-0.3645261824,
0.0249813329,
0.5975564718,
0.3975148499,
-0.3830737174,
0.1985992789,
-0.575457871,
-0.4318851531,
0.3134120405,
-0.328134805,
0.8240116835,
0.1111195311,
-0.3518487215,
0.0578233786,
-0.5589159131,
-0.5049664974,
0.7047355771,
0.0994688496,
-0.5128465891,
0.3164211214,
0.004566506,
0.1587512493,
0.1942816079,
-0.8548281789,
-0.1063551828,
0.1827238351,
0.2978295982,
0.8452327251,
-0.4494325519,
0.4591559172,
-0.1104496568,
0.4191002548,
0.2341393381,
0.3086126447,
-0.359611392,
-0.626511097,
-0.8632350564,
-0.1288618892,
0.1386096627,
0.5081686378,
-0.9074514508,
-0.0497974642,
-0.2975077331,
-0.0720830113,
-0.3874334097,
-0.0418226123,
0.3272539079,
0.4273453355,
0.0015877783,
-0.3055651784,
-0.5079845786,
-1.3682599068,
-0.2216121107,
-0.1918994635,
-0.1346567571,
0.8508979678,
0.6315039396,
-0.1292363405,
0.9299987555,
-0.6594724655,
-0.1285422891,
0.0050744815,
-0.2161101252,
-0.1522093862,
0.3219143152,
0.7481312156,
-0.9678406119,
-0.3574847579,
-0.1478871852,
-0.9863108993,
-0.0932452977,
0.043414358,
-0.1632379591,
0.2192264497,
0.719828248,
-0.2351389527,
0.6071216464,
0.836564064,
-0.3855217099,
0.6520382166,
0.1741702408,
0.1537362933,
-0.8749921322,
-0.136172682,
0.460814029,
-0.2613945305,
-0.4056946635,
0.1754422039,
-0.0410634242,
-0.2330657244,
-0.4561754167,
0.6910598874,
-0.5259379745,
-0.7174322009,
-0.0322728083,
-0.1252379864,
-0.17268309,
0.5059099793,
0.174586013,
0.7140291929,
0.6592338681,
-0.0727893785,
0.4645287991,
0.2714034319,
-0.6804757714,
0.6214290261,
-0.6708949208,
0.3285856843,
-0.7138445377,
0.4099977314,
-1.0484858751,
-0.3479112983,
0.2562415004,
-0.3028495908,
0.0110385232,
-0.0886167213,
-0.6170250177,
-0.6417988539,
-0.1531754583,
0.8372250795,
0.4874176085,
-0.5050965548,
0.5601832867,
0.5163044333,
-0.261272043,
-0.575656414,
-0.8112288713,
0.1849524379,
-0.0556573868,
-0.6661403775,
0.0369804986,
0.1507611871,
-0.4595425725,
-0.0058770683,
0.369294703,
-0.0917926356,
-0.2435009331,
0.508882165,
0.5795720816,
-0.0512222052,
0.0310890526,
-0.2336890846,
0.4490008354,
0.0595290288,
-0.033523798,
0.7423278093,
-0.0352386273,
-0.6169784665,
-0.4560168982,
0.5269290805,
0.6495326161,
-0.4551389515,
0.7964135408,
0.5093248487,
-0.2268463224,
0.0354364403,
-0.5798027515,
-0.2215052396,
-0.4206590354,
0.5042345524,
-0.1693502814,
-1.192122221,
0.6522664428,
0.5797095895,
0.0818317384,
0.1829355508,
0.7898241282,
-0.4293885231,
1.0101274252,
0.5519248843,
-0.0554959252,
0.7267961502,
-0.0017900891,
-0.0968236327,
-0.672073245,
-0.3781792521,
-0.3610835671,
-0.7916770577,
-0.7338433862,
-0.5018433332,
0.3854462504,
-0.6336525679,
-0.488972187,
-0.2408849448,
-0.2114621848,
0.7018658519,
0.8819662333,
0.3215924203,
0.0780839995,
0.3336981535,
-0.1408359706,
-0.2646044493,
-0.4094133377,
-0.2207391709,
1.3797183037,
0.3625339568,
0.7084649205,
-0.1991489977,
0.3597444892,
0.4726270139,
0.202639997,
-0.397636801,
0.7081905007,
-0.412768364,
-0.8394300938,
-0.1981070042,
-0.492981106,
-0.8780943751,
0.3095582724,
-0.5635489225,
-0.7316055894,
0.3343293965,
0.2718898356,
-0.0415065438,
0.5001718998,
-0.697468102,
0.6508159041,
-0.3419978023,
-0.3620747328,
-0.0276752692,
-0.684371531,
0.7848027945,
-0.0925321132,
0.1831912398,
-0.2582488358,
0.1720609963,
0.6287372708,
-0.1751782,
0.9757784605,
-0.1511478573,
0.0015696565,
0.0159276742,
-0.0040747556,
0.3216819465,
-0.269723326,
0.1198802814,
0.6768445373,
-0.3367237449,
-0.4272724688,
-0.5789138079,
0.5183914304,
-0.9254246354,
-0.5691856146,
-0.1956952512,
-0.878528893,
-0.1535983235,
0.0585382953,
0.0686966106,
0.5534347892,
-0.1490311623,
-0.013118241,
0.2366167605,
-0.7305136919,
0.2168646604,
0.1824666262,
-0.5488097668,
-0.1197546273,
0.6647723317,
-0.092410706,
0.3032966256,
0.227453962,
0.0464926288,
-0.10689082,
-0.481333226,
-0.4489140809,
0.3334858119,
-0.3892045319,
0.1865498573,
-0.5116847157,
-0.2232023925,
-0.2577069402,
0.1324525774,
-0.2418688536,
-0.2512729764,
-0.1266177595,
0.2040753812,
0.0990635529,
0.7184756398,
0.4743092656,
0.2089403868,
-0.5505244732,
0.6968773007,
0.7352275252,
0.3677845299,
0.0375294685,
-0.3405036926,
-0.074742578,
0.1897468418,
-0.0595542453,
-0.8200570345,
0.3489492834,
-0.0370410942,
0.422345072,
0.2002245784,
-0.1356154978,
0.4000025988,
-0.8001766801,
0.8150817752,
0.4126609862,
-0.5154651999,
0.4201846123,
-0.5126293302,
0.180332154,
0.238233909,
0.1953388453,
-0.6340776086,
-0.4436309636,
-0.1323747039,
-0.4218108952,
0.7216176391,
0.4998819828,
0.1934355199,
0.2815923393,
0.3026708066,
0.0247131996,
0.319337368,
-0.7706477642,
-0.6149806976,
-0.0596374162,
-0.3582538962,
0.0135526638,
-0.3340653777,
-0.1980386525,
-0.3458281755,
-0.022547204,
-0.1917297542,
0.5203386545,
-0.0914874598,
-0.1205340847,
0.0574790947,
-0.0009359982,
0.5424395204,
0.5070576072,
-0.1683275104,
0.0762212574,
0.0716443211,
-0.4863801897,
0.0717716739,
-0.0284939259,
-0.5148253441,
-0.0547375046,
0.2824906111,
1.2567743063,
-0.3506098986,
-0.841265738,
0.5612870455,
-0.3834473789,
-0.3542766869,
-0.2321219891,
-0.0878151357,
0.06186755,
0.5530868173,
0.3753119409,
0.1863673776,
0.0582608096,
-0.7099613547,
-0.2539984584,
0.5922932625,
-0.2234939486,
-0.2138117552,
0.6767851114,
0.4405904114,
-0.3364284933,
0.6695390344,
-0.0121779544,
-0.5935300589,
0.8655372858,
0.319039166,
0.7455332875,
0.2003201246,
0.2921251655,
0.2893419266,
0.5217572451,
0.0791905895,
0.1805576384,
0.0410400629,
-1.2483158112,
-0.2427465618,
-0.6041295528,
-0.3662052453,
0.143331781,
-0.4939802587,
0.3042639494,
-0.447964102,
-0.1302599162,
0.1272073835,
-0.5609390736,
-0.9192616343,
0.1688294858,
0.9294056892,
0.5066902041,
-1.0178422928,
0.5935120583,
0.8917420506,
-0.0076939147,
-0.4801257551,
0.145370245,
0.0582163893,
-1.1190888882,
1.0936911106,
0.2653300166,
0.186710611,
-0.4056390822,
-0.6704868674,
-0.8711591363,
0.8182983398,
0.8091427684,
-0.9753393531,
-0.1340682656,
0.5539168119,
0.4655187726,
-0.6076587439,
0.2782149315,
0.5954309702,
0.258828491,
0.013403466,
-1.072838068,
-0.2034766972,
-0.2902676463,
0.3799820542,
0.0546006784,
-0.7857878208,
1.0000588894,
-0.3482125401,
-0.0813343078,
-0.2945953608,
0.5977094173,
0.5652643442,
0.4690767229,
0.9250582457,
0.4450603127,
0.5774401426,
-0.0800066143,
1.2074041367,
0.0965755284,
0.0522360764,
1.343955636,
-0.4135845006,
0.6490140557,
0.3450315893,
-0.324790746,
0.5832173824,
0.3875456452,
-0.1609019488,
0.2439593375,
0.2249061316,
-0.0693483651,
-0.2607164681,
-0.3021349311,
-0.2410714179,
0.6174560785,
0.2185472399,
-0.624678731,
0.026102623,
0.1328165531,
-0.3350735009,
0.0816263855,
-0.4460496306,
0.5067705512,
-0.0464580208,
-0.491361022,
0.2530498207,
-0.1602922231,
0.9822111726,
-0.1095265895,
0.0493139587,
-0.361620903,
-0.0027078046,
-0.1790613979,
-1.0263851881,
0.0571050011,
0.2957715094,
-0.3229149878,
0.0671860278,
0.7617427707,
-0.4628184438,
-0.9962934256,
0.1701915264,
0.3166822493,
0.1503033191,
-0.1262342632,
-0.7616872191,
0.2829940617,
0.1878804564,
0.1765397638,
0.2847691178,
-0.1130336002,
-0.4760465622,
0.6293082833,
0.6099963188,
0.2504869103,
0.3976287246,
0.3738760054,
0.6934383512,
-0.6712398529,
-0.4666181803,
-0.9096792936,
0.1425717175,
-0.3104450405,
-0.0522080548,
0.6738775969,
0.3870489299,
0.8089437485,
0.0110712256,
0.8558183908,
0.186268419,
0.3809550703,
-0.3642466962,
0.572840035,
-0.7625080943,
-0.0025291622,
-0.4782464504,
-1.0063527822,
-0.1495809406,
0.2633060813,
-0.322473675,
0.1062493548,
0.4123755395,
0.8148411512,
-0.0060825916,
0.1593625396,
0.2122760117,
0.141496554,
0.3092466593,
0.4599929154,
1.0837094784,
-0.1525861621,
0.3701453507,
-0.1330155134,
-0.1249753535,
-0.1836984158,
-0.8149898052,
-1.0527982712,
-0.4180471003,
-0.2091805339,
0.0013515347,
0.0644817054,
0.6959053278,
0.6668025255,
-0.6866853237,
-0.3081611693,
0.2651091516,
0.0347094052,
0.2555519044,
-0.1829689443,
0.2019255161,
0.2452855706,
-0.9065566063,
-0.2812016308,
0.1681134403,
0.0839804783,
-0.7004026175,
-0.0388166569,
0.2134495676,
-0.1698670387,
0.6309651136,
0.0881592035,
-0.6414574385,
-0.2154484689,
-0.0856980309,
-0.0705263466,
0.0650769174,
0.820315063,
-0.6817387342,
0.5354096293,
0.5282894969,
0.5967100263,
0.6188271642,
-0.1867709607,
0.7413454056,
-0.733935535,
0.5589191318,
0.0248181913,
0.5652275681,
0.6636176705,
-0.1749313027,
0.2254676819,
0.4810512364,
-0.3539484441,
-0.8491424918,
0.2493773848,
-1.0123540163,
-0.2746983469,
1.3012228012,
0.1438431293,
-0.2995798588,
0.0777852535,
-0.3548510671,
-0.0572807454,
-0.4504524767,
0.5607456565,
0.560089767,
0.1846717745,
-0.4559942484,
-0.7076273561,
0.134746626,
0.3823464513,
-0.7795196176,
-0.0783535317,
0.7632789016,
0.198860839,
0.0401810408,
0.5623494983,
-0.1062145755,
0.2321807444,
-0.1297163367,
0.2271699309,
-0.091701746,
-0.1683684438,
-0.253231436,
0.1346994936,
-0.2395590097,
-0.3803302348
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07939v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07939v5
|
UFO: A UI-Focused Agent for Windows OS Interaction
| 2024-02-08T15:40:35 | 2024-05-23T05:18:58 |
Chaoyun Zhang, Liqun Li, Shilin He, Xu Zhang, Bo Qiao, Si Qin, Minghua Ma, Yu Kang, Qingwei Lin, Saravan Rajmohan, Dongmei Zhang, Qi Zhang
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We introduce UFO, an innovative UI-Focused agent to fulfill user requests
tailored to applications on Windows OS, harnessing the capabilities of
GPT-Vision. UFO employs a dual-agent framework to meticulously observe and
analyze the graphical user interface (GUI) and control information of Windows
applications. This enables the agent to seamlessly navigate and operate within
individual applications and across them to fulfill user requests, even when
spanning multiple applications. The framework incorporates a control
interaction module, facilitating action grounding without human intervention
and enabling fully automated execution. Consequently, UFO transforms arduous
and time-consuming processes into simple tasks achievable solely through
natural language commands. We conducted testing of UFO across 9 popular Windows
applications, encompassing a variety of scenarios reflective of users' daily
usage. The results, derived from both quantitative metrics and real-case
studies, underscore the superior effectiveness of UFO in fulfilling user
requests. To the best of our knowledge, UFO stands as the first UI agent
specifically tailored for task completion within the Windows OS environment.
The open-source code for UFO is available on https://github.com/microsoft/UFO.
|
[
-0.4088023603,
-0.8751173615,
0.7532786727,
0.1298507601,
0.231109187,
0.2043105364,
0.2337816656,
-0.6147862077,
0.3495401144,
0.3636528254,
-0.7370594144,
-0.2318268418,
-0.0063155834,
0.0953705311,
-0.1235826388,
0.8293773532,
0.1456996948,
-0.6807068586,
-0.4370916784,
0.0260937847,
-0.4334840178,
-0.2250903696,
-0.414008677,
-0.1010671929,
0.9091118574,
0.2931746542,
1.1736428738,
0.3541187048,
0.5157643557,
0.3909240961,
0.4936680496,
0.2653476894,
-0.3923544288,
0.1625338346,
-0.2677130401,
-0.2708571553,
-0.7323695421,
0.2046092898,
0.3590569794,
0.633916676,
-0.0348914526,
-0.0394822881,
0.3024271727,
0.6272881627,
-0.7696323395,
-0.1391754746,
-0.2970016003,
0.2702016532,
-0.1664586812,
-0.1904394031,
-0.3376615942,
-0.0175987184,
-0.0572412051,
-1.273011446,
0.0446762852,
-0.0660815164,
0.6176294088,
0.3724963069,
-0.5127874613,
0.2610503137,
-0.8131835461,
0.6865075231,
-0.1307558566,
0.3633261621,
0.1570678651,
0.3651164472,
-0.5386816859,
-0.7273153663,
-0.4588991106,
-0.8697622418,
-0.1441103369,
0.0612003095,
-0.3937855363,
0.402562052,
0.2792210579,
0.265468061,
-0.7165854573,
-0.2312117219,
-0.1345627755,
-0.4361569583,
0.3405936062,
0.367708832,
0.6174429059,
0.3819521666,
-0.6969304085,
0.2215781361,
-0.4275450706,
0.4654016197,
0.1061236709,
0.2489167005,
-0.0532228462,
0.7580057979,
-0.5971444249,
0.9265610576,
0.0125433607,
0.1042867973,
0.2088900805,
-0.0856048614,
-0.5279909968,
-0.6041679978,
0.7267487049,
0.4211981297,
-0.3307025433,
-0.5819564462,
-0.3072755337,
0.1670797467,
0.5934118032,
-0.4408047199,
0.0422025546,
0.382181555,
-0.296369791,
-0.3444489241,
0.4587101936,
-0.3109245002,
-0.5033782721,
-0.5900387764,
0.3882113695,
-0.1499430239,
-0.6775743961,
-0.3233400881,
-0.4334931672,
0.2127919197,
0.699593842,
-0.1685693562,
0.1470167339,
0.7836689353,
0.6957702041,
-0.5665266514,
-0.6529790163,
-1.1474354267,
0.3056696057,
-0.4881074727,
0.8136590719,
-0.5676665306,
-0.3983823657,
-0.3088727891,
0.021429915,
0.0307444837,
-0.2478865534,
-0.2487454861,
-0.3231529891,
0.1543405354,
-0.268586278,
-0.1331598908,
-0.2726118565,
0.46546188,
-0.5577398539,
1.1226391792,
0.5255680084,
-0.3831807673,
0.4833286703,
-1.1090394258,
-0.3889511526,
0.7575181127,
-0.2594152987,
0.102656737,
0.2945283055,
-0.5294520855,
0.3868618309,
0.0257929508,
-0.026001092,
-0.38046363,
-0.5614888668,
-0.0023502877,
-0.2788028419,
0.5483222008,
0.3396821618,
-0.6224591732,
0.4165690839,
-0.4947894812,
0.2176900208,
-0.191511482,
-0.2447957397,
-0.4078847766,
-0.0395338796,
0.563044548,
0.0086847655,
0.5722380877,
-0.8189416528,
0.622833252,
0.0332089327,
-0.0377683565,
0.4975912869,
-0.3305734396,
0.402472645,
-0.0840322599,
0.7169763446,
-0.1916106492,
0.718319416,
0.1522290558,
-0.5796631575,
-0.282990694,
-0.2301409394,
-0.4951508641,
0.6627008915,
-0.981292367,
0.0821663514,
0.0425864384,
-0.3723005652,
-0.0533209778,
0.2137198448,
0.4629368186,
0.3556979895,
0.1166554317,
-0.215464294,
-0.106118001,
-0.8554318547,
-0.3401581645,
-0.3251920938,
-0.2253558636,
0.3421709538,
0.182112366,
-0.744156599,
1.6180808544,
-0.3048118353,
-0.5455443859,
-0.2333670706,
0.0666662604,
0.0204613134,
0.2489342541,
0.8007634878,
-1.2786357403,
-0.9207640886,
0.8178759813,
-1.1204682589,
-0.1424660981,
-0.121248439,
-0.2297551483,
0.3905239403,
0.487670809,
-0.4944503009,
0.8761059642,
0.3732356131,
-0.6495209932,
0.7071790099,
-0.3059956431,
0.2839933038,
-0.669998765,
0.2519029975,
-0.141418308,
-0.4428035021,
-0.8306789398,
0.2164811492,
0.1313647628,
-0.2052039355,
-0.5261434913,
0.4912743866,
-0.5460996032,
-0.0821120217,
-0.7249079943,
-0.2749073207,
0.0365362838,
0.5562956333,
-0.0231987331,
1.1552612782,
0.7623752356,
-0.7100616097,
0.6846982241,
-0.154230535,
0.1730321497,
0.8348188996,
-0.5428498983,
0.4244566858,
0.0261925496,
-0.2269224972,
-0.8757960796,
-0.2129456103,
0.3837051094,
-0.3132105768,
-0.0322596096,
-0.1005816683,
0.0366062336,
-0.4305654168,
-0.366281718,
-0.0878298059,
0.2072985023,
-0.3421994448,
1.1358145475,
0.3386731744,
0.113624543,
-0.7702450156,
-0.5213392377,
0.6869520545,
-0.0939202234,
-0.4234369695,
0.0621243119,
-0.2202153951,
-0.3867921233,
0.2517086565,
-0.08016444,
-0.0250790287,
0.2132141888,
0.7070903182,
0.3221029639,
-0.3481443524,
-0.5050008893,
-0.0899784565,
-0.2214481682,
-0.2918738723,
-0.319874078,
-0.107536681,
-0.4708235264,
-0.3693124652,
-0.8097693324,
0.6844801307,
1.0658472776,
-0.0716126263,
0.2389377505,
0.6735985875,
-0.1924441308,
-0.1255790442,
-0.7245672941,
0.066989854,
-0.630766809,
0.6130344868,
-0.912332356,
-0.5612809062,
0.3455230594,
0.0548746362,
0.3151111007,
0.0831691846,
0.1790566593,
-0.2603293359,
0.9849395752,
1.2299482822,
-0.3627203405,
0.6782987118,
-0.2099857479,
-0.2559889853,
-0.6274759769,
-0.2116108239,
-0.0683976486,
-0.1294088215,
-0.1292295158,
-0.1532183737,
0.5960549116,
-0.2645650804,
0.0269595701,
0.4267427921,
-0.8598943949,
0.4082718492,
0.803057909,
0.0061020171,
0.0909220949,
0.1074521318,
-0.0123205623,
0.1662506163,
-0.3400342464,
-0.4989684224,
0.5856460929,
0.2281704098,
0.7662038207,
-0.0167112853,
0.1945397705,
1.1148405075,
0.6737042069,
-0.712554574,
0.7948881388,
0.1445272863,
-0.3505248427,
-0.6492673755,
-0.2856597304,
-0.972758472,
0.4163246453,
0.2347357422,
-0.764909029,
0.245558694,
0.2552469969,
-0.3482827246,
0.376159966,
-0.7431672215,
0.9977908731,
-0.2383885533,
-0.669116199,
-0.2589539886,
-0.4002608359,
-0.124156937,
0.3759293854,
-0.0992814377,
-0.3159520328,
-0.3754337132,
0.1666081399,
-0.6815166473,
0.8257704377,
-0.735747695,
-0.1839019954,
0.2809566855,
0.4528246522,
0.5371265411,
-0.209990561,
0.080882825,
0.096566394,
-0.0623411015,
-0.1984954178,
-0.4954683781,
0.5856069326,
-0.5615843534,
-0.6384611726,
-0.554620862,
-0.6288622022,
0.0096325576,
0.3538030684,
0.0881287828,
0.4813649654,
-0.670794189,
-0.0362500101,
-0.0122556668,
-0.0182811525,
0.4984944761,
0.9785805941,
-0.4392494261,
-0.1003332213,
1.0670212507,
-0.1808509678,
0.1867778748,
0.6066229939,
0.0023945947,
-0.1388287395,
-0.4832221568,
-0.6473945975,
-0.2061553895,
-0.0925116315,
-0.1165588349,
-0.5155726671,
0.058952231,
-0.2262443304,
-0.3712447882,
-0.4258515537,
0.0876890197,
-0.1335861087,
0.0891572088,
0.2461075783,
1.1015418768,
-0.1372187883,
0.2769917548,
-0.3867000043,
0.847020328,
0.6653660536,
0.4143963456,
-0.4836011529,
0.1888745874,
-0.2762994468,
0.2104720771,
-0.4952186644,
-0.7181230187,
0.2857801318,
0.2773054838,
0.7314628959,
0.9000439644,
0.1401444077,
0.5692506433,
-0.4129383862,
0.961348474,
0.3893598914,
-0.7427424192,
0.7012218237,
-0.4426114559,
0.1192064956,
0.5948317647,
-0.1361595094,
-0.6284170747,
-0.9003936648,
-0.0052734092,
-0.4512044191,
1.0301219225,
0.2388379127,
-0.0011555373,
0.3093408048,
0.2854488194,
0.3781803846,
0.1739753634,
-0.5037900209,
-0.3756068051,
-0.1889662445,
0.2341368198,
-0.0744675472,
-0.0809783489,
-0.0417799056,
-0.0460277796,
0.4598662257,
-0.3892503381,
0.2766614854,
0.4311264157,
-0.2183066905,
-0.2697949409,
0.0534283333,
0.3963887095,
0.8554217219,
-0.3402061462,
0.0491117276,
-0.2753918171,
-1.1754552126,
0.080191046,
0.1577560455,
-0.4415470958,
-0.0541565977,
-0.2079697996,
0.4873337746,
-0.3202280402,
-0.364599824,
0.508015573,
-0.2205999494,
-0.1169940382,
-0.4165330529,
0.4576883018,
-0.5082070231,
0.2554810941,
1.0541212559,
0.329829514,
0.5728731155,
-0.5227173567,
0.0850831121,
0.7019841671,
-0.7319034338,
-0.4241377711,
1.1338806152,
0.4783382714,
-0.4742990732,
0.5299616456,
-0.2746319175,
-0.3070814013,
0.8698804379,
0.1856652647,
1.2020875216,
-0.2053834349,
0.6126125455,
-0.3068552315,
0.4869884253,
0.176307559,
0.3816694319,
-0.5626853108,
-0.4993161559,
-0.2863853574,
-0.3133563697,
-0.8298208117,
-0.0143594248,
-0.6415843964,
-0.1794600785,
-0.1733225286,
-0.4214499593,
-0.0406002104,
0.1431438178,
-0.5873826146,
0.0059412923,
0.1739960164,
0.9561748505,
-0.4448392987,
0.7996153831,
1.2041318417,
-0.2207031846,
-0.3354273438,
-0.002272696,
0.1183441132,
-0.4770231843,
0.2316759676,
0.5371246934,
-0.6558787823,
-0.1449523121,
-0.5000209808,
-0.5460406542,
0.9920973182,
0.4130092859,
-0.4068363607,
0.1708330363,
0.508159399,
0.3830029368,
-0.1567151248,
0.288084209,
0.2761572599,
0.8025602102,
-0.2765932679,
-1.1244161129,
0.0466429032,
-0.7551985383,
0.0597893409,
-0.075284183,
-0.4619503617,
0.3726690412,
-0.4039881527,
-0.1905193478,
0.336582154,
0.8152796626,
-0.0113155451,
0.9676043391,
0.8300304413,
0.1000989601,
0.6383219361,
-0.1101636365,
1.188619256,
-0.0899680331,
-0.0395650789,
0.6593496799,
-0.4424727857,
0.4910770655,
0.5028764606,
-0.4873778522,
0.442786932,
0.3809221387,
0.1649263054,
0.50757581,
-0.416074574,
-0.4224710166,
-0.0745598152,
-0.0752433687,
-0.3966728449,
0.1295006722,
0.2844525576,
0.5117917657,
0.0894652456,
0.7286595106,
-0.2877112925,
0.0028826101,
-0.5188061595,
0.8357525468,
-0.2094281018,
-0.7607291341,
0.2892288864,
-0.1526363343,
0.9099175334,
-0.9516893029,
-0.0872110501,
-0.3300089538,
0.1613551527,
-0.40041852,
-0.7233585119,
0.1932866126,
-0.0664628744,
-0.3105081022,
-0.3011098802,
0.6267828941,
-0.209003821,
-0.1666619182,
0.273765564,
0.25077492,
0.3356158435,
-0.9189046025,
-0.582243979,
0.0532308742,
0.1339803189,
-0.5407602787,
0.3283628225,
0.3773521781,
0.0664738789,
0.8746308684,
0.6751020551,
-0.1120669171,
-0.0956797525,
-0.1974640787,
0.956035912,
-0.7173924446,
-0.8196470141,
-0.4986421168,
0.6754635572,
-0.1013902798,
-0.1201861799,
0.9322089553,
1.0231342316,
0.2978408039,
-0.3012952209,
1.0190845728,
-0.4000602663,
0.3145147264,
0.0587138981,
0.7649935484,
-0.9021728635,
-0.1129347309,
-0.1279753894,
-0.915604949,
0.1184697077,
0.2829318643,
0.062355075,
-0.0577442758,
0.443095088,
0.8760201335,
-0.3491286635,
-0.2185002267,
0.7837659121,
0.0202447735,
0.2385875136,
0.5887041688,
1.1371426582,
-0.0266736466,
0.5872730613,
-0.0913007706,
-0.6948004961,
-0.2675660849,
-0.6432815194,
-0.7457876801,
-0.5768514872,
-0.3987718225,
-0.1640661061,
0.0995669141,
0.5506600142,
0.9061504006,
-0.6571598053,
-0.2356785983,
-0.2405719161,
0.2076027691,
-0.7806510329,
-0.3605225086,
0.0400449149,
-0.3395829797,
-0.7802062035,
0.878842473,
0.6725218296,
-0.0116985328,
-0.2371892035,
-0.3609382808,
0.5404037833,
-0.2761773169,
0.5655381083,
0.9262747765,
-0.6768640876,
-0.0550806224,
0.0680793673,
-0.4511930943,
-0.1513331085,
0.8614633679,
-1.0857287645,
0.405993402,
0.0573352501,
0.2095590234,
0.2133847475,
0.0529785082,
0.7647122145,
-0.7718213797,
0.3739086688,
-0.0093861166,
-0.0847461447,
-0.0373188034,
-1.0278794765,
0.4601487219,
0.2335319966,
-0.2203202546,
-0.855751574,
0.02412799,
-1.3608565331,
-0.4381811917,
1.0386850834,
-0.0140676424,
-0.1608885527,
-0.6641793847,
-0.535838306,
-0.4438204169,
-0.5872852206,
0.5174494982,
-0.0985824615,
-0.3095004857,
0.295386821,
-0.6307347417,
0.5612002611,
0.005339935,
-0.7704244256,
0.1537784487,
0.7268983722,
0.2763162553,
0.2424462736,
0.9472342134,
0.2721885741,
0.6394427419,
-0.0166685097,
0.225764975,
-0.8097171783,
-0.5499585271,
0.0911485627,
0.4407384992,
-0.3197709918,
-0.6871258616
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05755v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05755v1
|
SpiRit-LM: Interleaved Spoken and Written Language Model
| 2024-02-08T15:39:32 | 2024-02-08T15:39:32 |
Tu Anh Nguyen, Benjamin Muller, Bokai Yu, Marta R. Costa-jussa, Maha Elbayad, Sravya Popuri, Paul-Ambroise Duquenne, Robin Algayres, Ruslan Mavlyutov, Itai Gat, Gabriel Synnaeve, Juan Pino, Benoit Sagot, Emmanuel Dupoux
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
We introduce SPIRIT-LM, a foundation multimodal language model that freely
mixes text and speech. Our model is based on a pretrained text language model
that we extend to the speech modality by continuously training it on text and
speech units. Speech and text sequences are concatenated as a single set of
tokens, and trained with a word-level interleaving method using a small
automatically-curated speech-text parallel corpus. SPIRIT-LM comes in two
versions: a BASE version that uses speech semantic units and an EXPRESSIVE
version that models expressivity using pitch and style units in addition to the
semantic units. For both versions, the text is encoded with subword BPE tokens.
The resulting model displays both the semantic abilities of text models and the
expressive abilities of speech models. Additionally, we demonstrate that
SPIRIT-LM is able to learn new tasks in a few-shot fashion across modalities
(i.e. ASR, TTS, Speech Classification).
|
[
-0.1789514422,
-0.6925833225,
0.3680569232,
0.3072634339,
-0.5048530698,
0.1960440874,
-0.4170661569,
-0.5864648223,
0.435779959,
0.6292303801,
-0.5731931329,
-0.2921700478,
-0.546132803,
-0.0479857512,
-0.4995043576,
1.1374698877,
0.1185114086,
0.725071609,
-0.0384811796,
-0.1762588024,
-0.4809348285,
-0.6979508996,
-0.3539710641,
-0.6104527712,
0.4185212255,
0.1043200195,
0.4697567225,
0.2310101986,
0.2830476463,
0.2741733193,
-0.0852102935,
-0.1059264168,
-0.3398367465,
0.2991542518,
-0.1819796711,
-0.6418130994,
-0.5283950567,
0.3016188145,
0.7844821215,
0.7932760119,
-0.0495742932,
-0.0851588398,
0.0556363016,
0.5566142797,
-0.3742319047,
0.3226917386,
-0.9689354897,
-0.0960524231,
-0.0985729843,
-0.1980083287,
-0.3296053708,
-0.1894087791,
0.2192992866,
-0.2393838614,
-0.0738852993,
-0.1443603337,
0.4864501357,
0.3545845747,
-0.520419836,
-0.6415119767,
-0.6819416285,
0.6863673329,
-0.6421174407,
0.6769855618,
0.1981801391,
0.1801047325,
0.0848039389,
-0.8886890411,
-1.0472043753,
-0.3450478315,
0.0540109836,
0.1828795671,
0.1622942835,
0.6373611689,
-0.1183518022,
0.3766585588,
-0.3513710797,
-0.3325275779,
-0.2400303036,
-0.0032035129,
0.5193580985,
0.0708965808,
0.4389971197,
-0.1543557048,
-0.5275930762,
-0.0385948159,
-0.3502963781,
0.0202964954,
0.3319156766,
0.6961988807,
-0.0119278235,
0.7926532626,
0.0508560985,
0.7060836554,
-0.0982266888,
-0.6801763177,
0.1173823997,
-0.3433208168,
-0.5019052029,
0.345577836,
0.6169078946,
0.1512442082,
0.2857037485,
-0.3738867939,
-0.3533183336,
0.2563225925,
0.0789933279,
-0.904726088,
0.1039550677,
0.148294881,
-0.5652288198,
-0.1477898359,
0.0595284849,
-0.3187955916,
-0.3876288235,
-0.4593880475,
0.7467963696,
-0.6793786287,
-0.6539518833,
0.2136763781,
-0.0188881941,
0.1445423514,
0.4378111959,
-0.8409906626,
0.4821617901,
0.7351880074,
0.7547317743,
-0.1617830992,
-0.3065277934,
-0.6621219516,
-0.1070130542,
-0.13846986,
0.2727681696,
-0.614646852,
-0.4583394527,
-0.0109977024,
0.0995402485,
-0.1811184734,
-0.4544963241,
0.6044653058,
-0.4572157562,
0.4522993565,
-0.0615728721,
-0.9322964549,
-0.6301549673,
-0.0597661212,
-0.6044512987,
1.0157496929,
0.1714917868,
-0.5647193789,
0.4002021253,
-0.3860907853,
-0.2467467934,
0.1984221637,
-0.1799666435,
0.0146441879,
0.5086590648,
-0.42599985,
0.7068327665,
-0.2965082228,
0.5827648044,
0.0682361349,
-0.2252662033,
0.0481224544,
-0.5107742548,
0.6318438053,
0.2848673463,
-0.2474584877,
0.4537653923,
-0.8965856433,
0.1446263194,
-0.0080542574,
-0.4280069768,
-0.3827576637,
0.090727292,
0.6148477197,
0.4737324715,
0.2337297201,
-0.4357835948,
0.1331174672,
-0.4893989861,
0.2523680627,
0.3596111536,
-0.4343908131,
0.5556138754,
-0.306483984,
0.5438984036,
0.2116110623,
-0.2687034905,
-0.6660464406,
-0.4459203184,
-0.838880837,
-0.5003455281,
0.0497969724,
0.7978396416,
-0.6374766231,
0.3748264611,
-0.1571215987,
-0.4817142189,
-0.653796792,
0.1477821767,
0.5573676825,
0.5828139782,
0.418667078,
-0.3232061267,
-0.3464024961,
-0.6101633906,
-0.557767868,
-0.4080893695,
0.3238228559,
-0.0601045452,
0.3470115364,
-0.2145520896,
1.2143006325,
0.0856109038,
-0.2630771399,
-0.6270165443,
0.1016321257,
0.1207829714,
0.4999960065,
0.6130264997,
-0.8901438713,
-0.4838142991,
-0.2782729566,
-0.6844154596,
-0.3249337673,
0.0162272435,
0.414672792,
0.1579856277,
0.5454768538,
-0.471675992,
0.4550482333,
0.8230094314,
-0.4891582429,
0.3089491725,
0.019580381,
0.1245532408,
-1.3344693184,
-0.205121085,
-0.226649642,
-0.5172531009,
-1.061401844,
0.1522253901,
0.1450919509,
-0.2402024269,
-0.7816182971,
0.8325577378,
-0.5169758201,
-0.0403352343,
-0.6511052847,
0.0792312324,
-0.0533508584,
0.438375771,
0.2998985946,
0.5707741976,
0.6331067681,
-0.5160252452,
0.4895627201,
-0.3274249136,
-0.309881866,
0.6260975003,
-0.5910902023,
0.1212263405,
-0.627207756,
0.1649263054,
-1.1688113213,
-0.1761459708,
0.1525197923,
-0.118899107,
0.5298258066,
0.1272567213,
-0.4506296515,
0.1277849227,
-0.0228439607,
0.4307001531,
0.2516836822,
-0.3958393037,
1.1341817379,
0.1872782856,
-0.1118745431,
-0.5242969394,
-0.663911581,
0.0940263197,
-0.1245111823,
-0.8431792855,
0.4214348793,
-0.413579613,
-0.5205528736,
0.1445565671,
0.0381688103,
-0.1017844155,
0.0839211121,
0.4648782909,
0.0546679758,
-0.1527258009,
0.3520621061,
0.0310910679,
0.1480624974,
-0.2835999429,
-0.1989388317,
0.7873069048,
-0.4744895101,
-0.4117596745,
-0.5504807234,
0.566198647,
0.5818209052,
-0.1949781775,
0.9531129599,
0.5483567119,
-0.6589460373,
0.0898250267,
-0.5273789763,
-0.1462972164,
-0.3719206154,
0.4815035462,
-0.703884244,
-1.0064171553,
0.4837939441,
-0.1596222967,
0.0583665296,
0.09499567,
0.5246075988,
0.0573616028,
0.7715362906,
0.8591701984,
0.0797539428,
0.6236339808,
0.1603167802,
0.038349282,
-0.4671143591,
-0.3979178667,
-0.2615410089,
-0.1779865175,
-0.2541348934,
-0.5214530826,
0.2715761065,
0.7815506458,
0.1201935709,
0.1225600392,
-0.2828096449,
0.3459512591,
0.3853094876,
-0.1471046358,
0.5217849612,
-0.2538205981,
-0.2451555133,
-0.1208477914,
-0.4883368909,
-0.6135588288,
0.833948195,
0.516528368,
0.8653946519,
0.125986591,
0.6955292225,
-0.0398180857,
0.3694376051,
-1.2584623098,
0.5689774752,
-0.2310838252,
-0.7517519593,
-0.0161669087,
-0.1033526063,
-0.4211331904,
0.6107791066,
-0.4626746178,
-0.4762151241,
-0.2228685766,
0.0739498511,
0.0742753744,
0.3973478973,
-0.7553004026,
0.5267665982,
-0.4609185755,
-0.094370082,
-0.3085005283,
-0.7585540414,
0.5491892099,
-0.1383105069,
0.2026482821,
-0.1563809812,
-0.0935560614,
0.485770613,
-0.5594778061,
0.793540597,
-0.155042991,
-0.3963066339,
0.2471116036,
0.0747300312,
0.3417910337,
-0.0536396541,
-0.0694253668,
0.1554003358,
-0.0205901265,
-0.1684309244,
-0.4336979687,
0.4154072404,
-0.6180730462,
-0.500888586,
-0.6197412014,
-0.4253258109,
-0.2360280305,
0.3403997719,
0.2272724509,
0.4649894834,
-0.3883690834,
0.1915670931,
0.7373533845,
-0.2405499071,
0.6618155241,
0.549936235,
-0.712852478,
-0.545828402,
0.4662357867,
0.0358799808,
0.6164940596,
0.4250419736,
0.1537048072,
-0.3543207347,
-0.1704059243,
-0.2470850796,
0.3190130591,
-0.8591380119,
0.1428246945,
-0.9124327302,
-0.2772297859,
-0.3532496393,
0.0040966612,
-0.4606545269,
-0.4090544581,
-0.4127488732,
-0.060279686,
0.3368362188,
0.6994348168,
0.1313002408,
0.6758205891,
-0.7047399879,
0.4785035849,
0.4327023029,
0.248558715,
-0.2349243164,
-0.3764118552,
-0.1188339442,
0.071909532,
0.0498412251,
-1.1848701239,
0.4339858592,
0.4728856683,
0.4641380608,
0.2394378036,
-0.4802615345,
0.6178119779,
-0.7674248219,
1.0311527252,
0.656427145,
-1.3625463247,
0.4183015525,
-0.1026964635,
0.1190599948,
0.4541561604,
0.2472948879,
-0.8907151818,
-0.349998951,
-0.3129166663,
-0.6009588838,
0.7026695609,
-0.201174885,
0.25177598,
-0.0187898334,
0.4019238949,
0.2701616585,
0.5857436657,
-0.9995093346,
-0.4093354344,
-0.7286628485,
-0.5320758224,
-0.1885381639,
-0.2931404114,
-0.112274088,
-0.4102691114,
0.6458711028,
-0.4058359861,
0.1418080032,
0.1463541389,
-0.3282914162,
-0.0735756233,
0.3026808202,
0.8698823452,
0.406922996,
-0.1630849242,
0.412212193,
-0.0888157934,
-0.7394654155,
0.1903723925,
0.0352901183,
0.0711465105,
0.273080796,
0.4334482253,
1.2346504927,
0.0345481113,
-0.837210536,
0.6442939639,
-0.1715498567,
-0.222066462,
-0.3793936074,
0.1219087094,
0.2061458677,
0.4459697604,
0.5058386922,
0.0371156819,
-0.1645383686,
-0.9345188141,
0.0523804389,
0.6285155416,
-0.7351545691,
-0.5349597335,
1.0335792303,
0.1356740594,
-0.2846643925,
0.0378269106,
-0.0674252957,
-0.653370142,
0.1717349887,
0.7043540478,
1.184920311,
-0.2344967574,
0.0000650656,
-0.0853431672,
0.4419692755,
-0.1357664615,
0.7586895227,
0.0335053615,
-0.9111433625,
-0.3561548591,
-0.828126967,
-0.1751331389,
0.302918762,
-0.3282221258,
0.3971479237,
-0.3999061882,
-0.0989530757,
-0.3555829227,
0.0372451022,
-0.71333915,
0.5167813897,
0.2072698325,
0.9908536077,
-0.8585686684,
1.2826075554,
0.7315059304,
-0.4483814836,
-0.9007310867,
0.0829757378,
0.0483362861,
-0.6900445819,
1.0356450081,
0.1849959791,
-0.4850634634,
0.1417644173,
-0.4626776278,
-0.7541898489,
1.0799254179,
0.4919649959,
-0.5517570972,
-0.1063093469,
0.0434218235,
0.4235717356,
-0.5976914167,
0.3295271993,
0.1614925563,
0.238217622,
0.0221055187,
-1.2834559679,
-0.1751623303,
-0.1349894851,
0.1321044564,
-0.0131150875,
-0.8494549394,
1.2051794529,
0.1533727795,
-0.3827097714,
0.1774683446,
1.0304634571,
0.1381647736,
0.193496421,
0.7935246229,
0.5742740631,
0.8743709326,
-0.1697877944,
0.6209925413,
-0.6237458587,
0.1330492496,
1.0498793125,
-0.5650957823,
0.6279823184,
0.563044548,
0.1983201653,
0.453299433,
0.2917659581,
0.7485276461,
0.5671114326,
0.0591355041,
-0.8094081879,
-0.0848169774,
-0.2409852296,
-0.441344589,
0.7263725996,
0.4433184564,
-0.488309443,
-0.0309494473,
0.4382144213,
0.1266326904,
0.175832808,
-0.3468466103,
0.7951772213,
0.1828430742,
-0.5737156272,
0.5240470171,
0.228934899,
1.1402951479,
-0.9022864699,
0.1311395764,
0.0750213787,
-0.0194941554,
-0.2150982171,
-0.5409490466,
0.196904093,
-0.0929621682,
-0.2071788013,
-0.4221976995,
1.0197007656,
-1.0167753696,
-0.2658982277,
0.4977554977,
0.6463822126,
0.1789411157,
-0.015137692,
-0.5478191376,
0.1670897603,
-0.3786078691,
-0.2774654627,
0.1429201812,
0.5511549115,
0.0293089803,
0.6067480445,
0.4433500767,
0.2280521244,
0.3941627145,
0.327593118,
0.7181378007,
-0.7605187893,
-0.5444425941,
-0.7717028856,
0.4880154133,
0.3539235592,
-0.2596606314,
0.4857811928,
0.5435287356,
0.7126897573,
-0.1841876805,
0.8794133067,
-0.0276802313,
0.5579468012,
-0.7258388996,
0.5365144014,
-0.8117027879,
-0.1034609079,
-0.455932796,
-1.0488356352,
-0.0323848166,
0.5561228991,
0.4649339616,
0.1127508134,
0.6745702028,
0.534539938,
0.0001579643,
0.1731703579,
0.3986082375,
-0.0844820365,
0.2236199677,
0.2750167251,
0.815669477,
-0.3067765832,
0.0561331771,
-0.0904208347,
-0.3253868818,
-0.1350177824,
-1.1118450165,
-0.9981697202,
-0.8921923041,
0.0083359499,
-0.4001902938,
-0.2122046947,
1.4617607594,
0.8427492976,
-0.4988622069,
-0.4557291567,
-0.1030696034,
-0.2066049725,
-0.1362772137,
-0.2944188714,
-0.1289499402,
-0.3811408579,
-1.031132102,
0.7752979994,
0.4578863084,
0.2980803251,
-0.6566096544,
-0.2648354769,
-0.2093343884,
0.3721854389,
0.8400660753,
-0.0694844425,
-1.0020437241,
-0.2496550679,
0.0916590542,
-0.2077916861,
-0.111462757,
0.9542320967,
-0.9221258759,
0.7309948206,
0.658885479,
0.6180859208,
0.4900968373,
-0.229382053,
0.4466090202,
-0.9759238958,
0.5997692347,
0.3131850958,
0.450314194,
0.3266806006,
-0.0667457879,
0.3496023417,
0.5523449183,
-0.1943507791,
-0.7624086142,
0.4690643549,
-1.1826980114,
-0.4989203811,
1.1140921116,
0.1203929335,
0.0325821191,
0.0723204166,
-0.2374877036,
0.58970505,
-0.1370339245,
0.2082804739,
1.0186619759,
-0.0842698067,
-0.2914460897,
-0.5121889114,
0.689540565,
0.4682974815,
-0.655714035,
-0.264351666,
0.4900982976,
0.3923719525,
0.1332162917,
1.0489407778,
-0.0084152548,
-0.1353812218,
-0.2407240719,
0.2499531806,
0.1810038835,
-0.5766724348,
-0.5955088735,
0.2228509039,
-0.1248564348,
0.0500712059
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05733v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05733v1
|
TimeArena: Shaping Efficient Multitasking Language Agents in a Time-Aware Simulation
| 2024-02-08T15:08:57 | 2024-02-08T15:08:57 |
Yikai Zhang, Siyu Yuan, Caiyu Hu, Kyle Richardson, Yanghua Xiao, Jiangjie Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite remarkable advancements in emulating human-like behavior through
Large Language Models (LLMs), current textual simulations do not adequately
address the notion of time. To this end, we introduce TimeArena, a novel
textual simulated environment that incorporates complex temporal dynamics and
constraints that better reflect real-life planning scenarios. In TimeArena,
agents are asked to complete multiple tasks as soon as possible, allowing for
parallel processing to save time. We implement the dependency between actions,
the time duration for each action, and the occupancy of the agent and the
objects in the environment. TimeArena grounds to 30 real-world tasks in
cooking, household activities, and laboratory work. We conduct extensive
experiments with various state-of-the-art LLMs using TimeArena. Our findings
reveal that even the most powerful models, e.g., GPT-4, still lag behind humans
in effective multitasking, underscoring the need for enhanced temporal
awareness in the development of language agents.
|
[
0.0491376258,
-1.0587688684,
0.6916529536,
0.8411563039,
0.1110728383,
0.3320855498,
-0.0792025775,
-0.59375,
0.3964951932,
0.3613415658,
-0.5173593163,
-0.1126306653,
-0.2677384019,
0.0326401778,
-0.1907349974,
0.5137603879,
-0.2249025404,
-0.1776000261,
0.1117084697,
-0.0748266578,
-0.3318709433,
-0.797390461,
-0.6534662247,
-0.6097063422,
0.6499875188,
0.2144015431,
0.6550476551,
0.5062596798,
-0.0618648343,
0.3639819324,
0.1290602982,
0.28507182,
-0.1685593724,
0.4787160158,
-0.0096061286,
-0.5171636343,
-0.6929832101,
-0.0476895235,
0.4548526406,
0.3711589277,
-0.2992165387,
0.1091941074,
-0.0218854267,
0.279653877,
-0.5056081414,
0.4301344454,
-0.2625067532,
0.2745906413,
-0.2775468528,
-0.4059558213,
-0.1611805707,
-0.1053230986,
-0.1096082553,
-0.8503102064,
0.0427333079,
0.0951899663,
0.6388732791,
0.4070436358,
-0.3790363967,
0.0268793907,
-1.3744808435,
0.7816876769,
-0.3934676051,
0.2313990891,
0.2841333747,
0.6309798956,
-0.2215570211,
-0.6260504723,
-0.8558080792,
-0.1106225997,
0.464525193,
0.1608482152,
-0.025325194,
-0.1064311042,
0.2551189959,
-0.2173420489,
-0.4337649941,
-0.0026457596,
-0.1246226877,
0.0763787478,
0.0475008748,
0.6305853724,
0.5695061088,
0.0811549202,
-0.1392431408,
-0.1578093469,
-0.4558051527,
0.1460857838,
0.3515807986,
0.159732908,
0.0405420363,
0.5413716435,
-0.0678645223,
0.5083268285,
-0.4151798487,
-0.0541803874,
-0.0623791851,
-0.3842128515,
-0.232541889,
0.035103336,
0.4622572958,
0.402905941,
0.2546223402,
-0.1693062633,
0.1125712618,
0.6546468139,
0.5065351129,
-0.8401217461,
0.006377324,
0.4197824895,
-0.2164393812,
-0.4067597091,
-0.5933033824,
-1.0372077227,
-0.0663291737,
-0.258777082,
0.2659049928,
-0.3072778583,
-0.3767625391,
0.3109240532,
0.0596340597,
0.0684931874,
0.4404428899,
-0.6984121203,
0.5963686705,
0.5063713789,
0.8923978806,
0.0239039026,
-0.865501225,
-0.5709857941,
0.6409958005,
-0.2925975323,
0.8907109499,
-0.7755035162,
-0.401812464,
-0.1576887518,
-0.0162676945,
-0.2926140726,
-0.205169484,
0.1594718397,
-0.6151390076,
0.0931301713,
-0.1288916469,
-0.2941465676,
-0.0991004407,
0.4922481179,
-0.9784141779,
0.9478076696,
-0.0446610525,
-0.2582113743,
0.392978251,
-1.2218497992,
-0.4866856337,
-0.1343288124,
0.0343736932,
-0.2616965175,
-0.2107248604,
0.3170488477,
0.538285017,
-0.0983124971,
0.2825275958,
-0.2041134983,
-0.1793907136,
0.4547706842,
-0.461299777,
0.5785800219,
0.4634695649,
-0.509256959,
0.2703664601,
-0.326752305,
0.0453856885,
0.2007737011,
-0.3881407678,
-0.2590597272,
0.2027865499,
0.2503106594,
0.3839032054,
0.1827622503,
-0.6989843845,
0.4132811129,
-0.0291764829,
0.7034959793,
0.4640765488,
0.0859898552,
0.3644140661,
-0.8058423996,
0.8486582041,
-0.1651643515,
0.5355588198,
0.0042566746,
-0.3797659278,
-0.6384066939,
-0.016623985,
-0.0086740265,
0.7961758375,
-0.8839552402,
-0.192145586,
-0.3752230108,
-0.505877018,
-0.1693101376,
-0.0296322852,
0.4336339533,
-0.0859870315,
0.2491460443,
0.1051020101,
-0.3649245799,
-0.4783489406,
-0.3595754206,
-0.0482643992,
0.3427454829,
0.0104028024,
0.5037523508,
-0.1771800518,
0.7893131971,
-0.3626554906,
-0.4081348777,
-0.4813960791,
0.1005489752,
-0.2164252698,
0.3345448673,
0.8053326607,
-0.6688888669,
-0.236090064,
-0.1265855581,
-0.800108254,
0.0177131072,
-0.3805839717,
0.0120316502,
0.1286923885,
0.6532582045,
-0.6308732033,
0.3586699665,
0.8180980086,
-0.5555548668,
0.6771858335,
-0.4549847543,
0.3060713112,
-1.3557614088,
0.074792631,
-0.3156211972,
-0.3383588791,
-0.7250275612,
-0.0328850001,
-0.0594250336,
-0.443790406,
-0.5552605391,
1.0424274206,
-0.5893193483,
-0.0089052133,
-0.251937449,
-0.1162202358,
0.1159862503,
0.7842696309,
-0.1130388379,
1.0018732548,
0.0828437358,
-0.8146875501,
0.1195722744,
-0.1609493345,
-0.4066670835,
0.2680826783,
-0.7057101727,
0.0446179323,
-0.0027742195,
0.4518586695,
-0.4486016035,
-0.3555708826,
0.0703616962,
-0.050999783,
-0.0349279307,
0.0677205324,
-0.906270504,
-0.1344136149,
-0.2128609419,
0.7088570595,
0.275475353,
-0.2367709875,
1.2318688631,
0.4933568239,
-0.1033399701,
-0.475349158,
-0.6826236248,
0.2379902303,
-0.2417255342,
-0.2155275792,
0.4071119428,
-0.0710355565,
-0.4806520343,
0.094585292,
0.1512790322,
-0.1631749868,
0.3279526234,
0.4643343091,
-0.0660614148,
0.3279648125,
0.0823711827,
0.1941819638,
0.0019527551,
-0.1138131395,
-0.3171580136,
0.6993344426,
0.0285821483,
-0.3698922992,
-0.4587033987,
0.5296045542,
0.8403499126,
-0.3072985709,
0.6697695851,
0.3935661018,
-0.5912341475,
-0.2992819548,
-0.5494741201,
-0.0187698957,
-0.46120134,
0.2341234684,
-0.445356071,
-0.7494122386,
0.7573561072,
-0.0819211304,
0.4869690537,
0.0435244851,
0.424879998,
0.0547574945,
0.8403394818,
0.4105847776,
0.1698843092,
0.9076020122,
-0.2200139016,
-0.0973716155,
-0.7998532057,
-0.330439806,
-0.5221533179,
-0.4027328193,
-0.0655442998,
-0.9518703222,
0.4363715351,
-0.3898692131,
-0.0913752392,
0.2700480521,
-0.1353319287,
0.6174762249,
0.3946938217,
0.001734172,
0.2489349097,
-0.1200191081,
-0.2207405865,
0.0042986637,
-0.7568171024,
-0.6784493923,
0.8696162701,
0.0754490495,
0.7089851499,
0.1441883445,
0.4033742845,
0.3222033381,
0.1936897933,
-0.4289799035,
0.6036775708,
-0.1193087399,
-0.9084681273,
-0.4854171276,
-0.3447986543,
-1.3783228397,
0.1872957647,
0.0940803215,
-0.600990057,
-0.1157237217,
0.2364291996,
-0.543546319,
0.5387386084,
-0.8176493049,
0.8879123926,
-0.557105422,
-0.5038830638,
-0.5994536877,
-0.3243270814,
-0.1112672985,
0.0929590911,
0.3982568979,
-0.5694772601,
-0.278311193,
0.6372797489,
-0.4554313123,
1.2294118404,
-0.3006617129,
0.0149923712,
0.3387003541,
0.6626883745,
0.5057073832,
-0.1003227383,
-0.1167759672,
-0.1981246471,
0.1600653529,
-0.611030519,
-0.6821039915,
0.8488814235,
-0.6097709537,
-0.2729665041,
-0.5809450746,
-0.5715091228,
-0.2673986256,
0.1530949771,
-0.1193219498,
0.7270932198,
-0.6463809609,
-0.3041802645,
0.3569423556,
-0.162918672,
0.6795400381,
0.5893632174,
-0.5270516872,
0.0472502559,
0.7728894949,
0.4046457708,
0.0402138978,
0.6611785889,
0.0938000008,
-0.3604457676,
-0.099232778,
-0.4189377129,
0.0344477817,
-0.3701960444,
0.158715412,
-1.063655138,
0.1076321751,
-0.1104315296,
-0.2028450817,
-0.6651930213,
-0.626523912,
-0.1082347929,
-0.0532326922,
0.3998954296,
0.8686526418,
0.1905880868,
0.270752728,
-0.8059190512,
0.2587707043,
0.5984959602,
0.3619330227,
0.1902455688,
0.1667419076,
-0.1777241975,
-0.2280447334,
-0.0576433539,
-0.5719445944,
0.3430610597,
0.1779797077,
0.4902206659,
-0.0803394839,
-0.0854522213,
0.6501863599,
-0.5995882154,
0.7763613462,
-0.168593213,
-0.7866054773,
0.3217218816,
-0.4797751307,
0.8060392737,
0.2482051253,
-0.1377647668,
-0.7378183603,
-0.3975532949,
-0.3627094328,
-0.8237404823,
0.4701730013,
0.5144059658,
0.09319143,
0.0522576831,
0.0269703865,
0.0958434567,
0.0953317881,
-0.4384176433,
-0.0329552181,
-0.380970329,
0.0653432608,
-0.2381195426,
-0.3273144662,
0.0136070345,
0.0765230954,
0.4129196107,
0.0094117317,
0.5449323058,
0.1345549226,
-0.1936209202,
0.0800078362,
0.4474413693,
1.032668829,
0.5338125229,
0.0623046607,
0.1445723176,
0.2722444534,
-0.5596923232,
0.428678751,
0.0795186013,
0.0979174972,
-0.1766071171,
0.3238039017,
0.6361644268,
0.5586374998,
-0.5019085407,
-0.0443045497,
-0.6284008622,
0.0626114905,
-0.7644275427,
0.0823411718,
0.2384282798,
0.4105698764,
0.1790061742,
0.0950189903,
-0.0909357294,
-0.5371821523,
-0.1502299607,
-0.1391799152,
-0.1169513613,
-0.5485744476,
0.9913989305,
0.4128518999,
-0.4369507134,
0.2263156772,
-0.3780452907,
-0.557264328,
0.7562412024,
0.4678037763,
1.1154458523,
-0.5000276566,
0.181761235,
0.1233080477,
0.3028790057,
-0.3156725764,
0.8143986464,
0.0433625355,
-0.6886031032,
-0.649230957,
-0.6575342417,
-0.4408082962,
-0.0191067457,
-0.1101559699,
-0.2474887967,
-0.4351645112,
-0.5131332278,
-0.0464244932,
-0.0755585805,
-0.774232924,
-0.2037463337,
-0.4317214489,
0.6671749353,
-0.5414626598,
1.0589854717,
0.9779411554,
-0.0258750785,
-0.9023647904,
0.1646539271,
0.1547900736,
-0.536839962,
0.4180066586,
0.1144936606,
-0.7245955467,
-0.046046894,
-0.1043668464,
-0.6400043368,
1.1426861286,
0.324829936,
-0.5524690747,
-0.4555958807,
-0.1438331753,
0.6912742853,
-0.2461818159,
-0.0873773172,
0.197930783,
0.4699023366,
-0.4662697911,
-1.0072364807,
-0.0578881912,
-0.6049682498,
0.1333689094,
0.366282016,
-0.9813655615,
0.7096498013,
-0.2047650665,
-0.2848159671,
0.0060477289,
0.4361926913,
0.2503654361,
0.3048515618,
0.6214431524,
0.3995665014,
0.5447859764,
0.0127821499,
1.3173151016,
-0.4328627288,
-0.0522711761,
1.1544445753,
-0.6472402811,
0.5281634331,
0.3577331901,
-0.0649034083,
0.3501414359,
0.2993811965,
0.4926374257,
0.2381413281,
-0.031207351,
-0.463581562,
-0.444268316,
-0.4123249948,
-0.1536898166,
0.5947446823,
0.5731709599,
0.2661980391,
-0.1734516025,
0.3470189273,
0.3680459857,
0.2345643044,
-0.0254511777,
0.4148205519,
-0.0058126799,
-0.7837447524,
0.0283353534,
-0.1605086476,
0.3797966242,
-0.6605462432,
-0.2060120702,
-0.1043287292,
0.4264762998,
0.2158263624,
-0.6304872036,
0.2673584521,
0.0647913218,
-0.0879738778,
-0.4825895131,
0.5405960679,
-0.4842000902,
-0.371178925,
0.6614299417,
0.7753236294,
0.1504726559,
-0.1018139124,
-0.5371428132,
0.2436857074,
-0.358832866,
-0.3365557194,
0.2254523784,
0.5997574329,
-0.327742219,
1.065969944,
0.4778117537,
0.133666724,
0.1292117685,
0.172107175,
0.6518293023,
-0.6863990426,
-0.8153320551,
-0.7967914939,
-0.0677144378,
0.0065071317,
-0.2537741661,
0.5156844258,
0.5251375437,
0.6064537764,
-0.1071829572,
0.6957873106,
-0.0313426629,
0.4766609073,
-0.7647710443,
0.9425945878,
-0.541115582,
0.1798474789,
-0.2060885578,
-0.9472734928,
-0.1080034077,
0.2799829543,
-0.1367488801,
0.2623961866,
0.8337618113,
0.6118637323,
0.0053577763,
-0.1535973996,
0.3982910812,
-0.0036737304,
0.6851122379,
0.731529355,
0.9635334611,
0.0296317898,
0.730691731,
-0.4631267488,
-0.0095991986,
-0.2068263292,
-0.8672174811,
-0.951063931,
-0.7644819617,
-0.0097657423,
-0.0715695545,
0.3421528935,
1.1424491405,
0.8453019261,
-0.521738708,
-0.4715218842,
0.1781248599,
-0.3038242459,
-0.5839090943,
-0.1741493493,
0.0754317865,
-0.1292688847,
-0.9187942743,
0.6877191663,
0.2448931187,
0.3281616867,
-0.2514802814,
-0.1017789915,
-0.31589064,
-0.0008569983,
0.7357650995,
0.4580587447,
-0.4907935262,
-0.0981125012,
0.1396432519,
-0.1385864168,
-0.1986311823,
1.1959317923,
-0.7168447971,
0.5030861497,
0.1561692357,
0.3829845488,
0.7019712329,
-0.1663120985,
0.775606811,
-0.6688359976,
0.3441540599,
0.3915809393,
0.1824771464,
0.0611290224,
-0.2129748762,
0.5719618201,
-0.0631088391,
-0.7294319868,
-0.4727621078,
0.3541077971,
-0.8354119658,
-0.5059276223,
0.9730142951,
-0.0025099667,
-0.4579733312,
-0.454188168,
-0.1607259959,
0.5266929269,
-0.8048670888,
0.97126019,
0.7360289693,
-0.3196603656,
0.0760354921,
-0.9829808474,
0.5210259557,
0.5144345164,
-1.1556099653,
0.2230698317,
0.410898,
0.2595922649,
0.2576696873,
0.8733834028,
-0.0394526757,
0.277890116,
0.0398476273,
0.1529703289,
-0.3964214325,
-0.7699143887,
0.0365859531,
0.059167996,
0.062292397,
-0.1451123059
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05706v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05706v1
|
Unified Speech-Text Pretraining for Spoken Dialog Modeling
| 2024-02-08T14:35:09 | 2024-02-08T14:35:09 |
Heeseung Kim, Soonshin Seo, Kyeongseok Jeong, Ohsung Kwon, Jungwhan Kim, Jaehong Lee, Eunwoo Song, Myungwoo Oh, Sungroh Yoon, Kang Min Yoo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
While recent work shows promising results in expanding the capabilities of
large language models (LLM) to directly understand and synthesize speech, an
LLM-based strategy for modeling spoken dialogs remains elusive and calls for
further investigation. This work proposes an extensive speech-text LLM
framework, named the Unified Spoken Dialog Model (USDM), to generate coherent
spoken responses with organic prosodic features relevant to the given input
speech without relying on automatic speech recognition (ASR) or text-to-speech
(TTS) solutions. Our approach employs a multi-step speech-text inference scheme
that leverages chain-of-reasoning capabilities exhibited by the underlying LLM.
We also propose a generalized speech-text pretraining scheme that helps with
capturing cross-modal semantics. Automatic and human evaluations show that the
proposed approach is effective in generating natural-sounding spoken responses,
outperforming both prior and cascaded baselines. Detailed comparative studies
reveal that, despite the cascaded approach being stronger in individual
components, the joint speech-text modeling improves robustness against
recognition errors and speech quality. Demo is available at
https://unifiedsdm.github.io.
|
[
-0.1815231144,
-0.8586377501,
0.6502956748,
-0.0372095332,
-0.6208035946,
0.0834819227,
-0.2493558824,
-0.2653042078,
-0.0585570298,
0.7960627675,
-0.7234332561,
-0.5568862557,
-0.1547790766,
0.3588737547,
-0.288832128,
0.9016646147,
0.2378189564,
0.6596048474,
-0.252104044,
0.1411296129,
-0.3791422248,
-0.7908713818,
-0.4261342585,
-0.6605546474,
0.233896777,
0.1551232189,
0.3927051127,
0.2286701351,
0.1934659481,
0.3590725958,
-0.0270622652,
-0.0886626616,
-0.1374621689,
0.0522439443,
0.0995934978,
-0.2653464377,
-0.5844919086,
0.0767492875,
0.7265372872,
0.8865602612,
-0.349960655,
-0.1315373331,
0.2270286977,
0.2856157124,
-0.2125748694,
0.0639936551,
-0.7515742183,
-0.070043698,
-0.2227604836,
-0.3642438948,
-0.5200823545,
-0.0485338755,
0.4706389904,
-0.6227576137,
0.1647020131,
-0.1136040762,
0.4828675389,
0.0420854986,
-0.5099444985,
-0.2827312946,
-0.8444554806,
0.641849041,
-0.881148994,
0.6271696091,
0.2561950088,
0.0717860982,
-0.207701534,
-0.7195702791,
-0.5279098749,
-0.4569846988,
0.0909496471,
0.3021276295,
-0.0228171051,
0.4705277681,
-0.2429486513,
0.4018421173,
-0.6807296872,
0.0398270115,
0.141974926,
-0.3440437615,
0.3138877451,
0.2066466808,
0.236571312,
-0.1101539433,
-0.6215408444,
-0.0280053336,
-0.689037323,
0.1281178296,
0.1682167798,
0.6177191734,
-0.1816056073,
0.5066927671,
0.0347168148,
0.6967733502,
-0.0463501364,
-0.2451816201,
0.0418124422,
-0.5682116747,
-0.4695904553,
0.0552510582,
1.0549640656,
-0.0007413991,
0.2040427476,
-0.3649009764,
-0.2018194199,
0.0606018715,
0.1652554274,
-0.8134124279,
-0.0461739972,
0.0646853819,
-0.0552242622,
-0.2864542902,
0.1699667275,
-0.6389787197,
-0.0618476644,
-0.6351712346,
0.4549711347,
-0.3136948645,
-0.2543475628,
0.0195507184,
0.0642583519,
-0.0384719744,
0.2821632326,
-0.7155485153,
0.4464224279,
0.5042883754,
0.6225530505,
-0.0738437846,
-0.1274940372,
-0.757663548,
0.1915064007,
-0.2049236745,
0.7174464464,
-0.7142032981,
-0.7100877166,
-0.0770068467,
-0.2174884528,
-0.2096638381,
-0.5700774193,
0.450655967,
-0.4084140658,
0.3233688772,
0.0111778919,
-0.5390228629,
0.0082688853,
0.0039631692,
-0.4865966439,
0.9191794991,
-0.0506996624,
-0.6077558994,
0.0460305251,
-0.4326955378,
-0.4672951996,
0.1097433046,
-0.3971152008,
-0.1756897867,
0.2432981133,
0.1942882985,
0.2909354866,
-0.660356164,
0.7433992624,
-0.2029224038,
-0.1569596827,
0.3634314239,
-0.6670346856,
0.7437397838,
0.1132187396,
-0.2629321218,
0.3984433115,
-0.7881700397,
0.1214689538,
0.0472411029,
-0.5634227991,
-0.0061527248,
-0.1077673584,
0.175271675,
0.00238915,
-0.0193302575,
-0.4723861516,
0.0236210525,
-0.34535411,
0.4235082269,
0.8019296527,
-0.1533146203,
0.604845643,
-0.0631953403,
0.5057559013,
0.0471894033,
-0.1281198412,
-0.4450976849,
-0.4255484343,
-0.5752000809,
-0.3328072131,
0.3612934649,
0.7581605911,
-0.6947323084,
0.7450765967,
-0.0989381671,
-0.2317057252,
-0.18721582,
0.2036040872,
0.7355829477,
0.7285371423,
0.2984896898,
-0.4437071383,
-0.6258680224,
-0.4914185703,
-0.2943575382,
-0.4119715989,
-0.3924677372,
0.146747902,
0.250310123,
-0.2855873406,
1.1987184286,
-0.2890668809,
-0.3454523683,
-0.4451150596,
0.3910805285,
-0.1105181798,
0.2712667286,
0.2254390866,
-0.7267823815,
-0.2327428609,
-0.1010282785,
-0.398653239,
-0.407784909,
0.0214758627,
0.0713777766,
0.0879676118,
0.4941547811,
-0.7481840849,
0.1789626777,
0.6628893614,
-0.1577750444,
0.7945812941,
-0.0719548985,
-0.0984022543,
-1.2535213232,
0.0151252346,
0.0093342615,
-0.4336591661,
-0.9082863927,
-0.352109164,
-0.3815237582,
-0.5517663956,
-0.4014029503,
0.5943328142,
-0.3569962978,
-0.061933782,
-0.2191801518,
0.0211712588,
0.002620148,
0.5763788819,
0.3159902394,
0.869474113,
0.5857813954,
-0.6353251338,
0.1687968075,
0.0716607124,
-0.0641698763,
0.5562019944,
-0.7687576413,
0.4218920469,
0.0471992791,
0.6213935614,
-0.9964104891,
-0.3808333874,
0.1274523139,
-0.3417476714,
0.3560707867,
0.0391352959,
-0.3056634963,
-0.2828612626,
0.0335609317,
0.3071855307,
0.3781317174,
-0.3784030974,
1.0832569599,
0.4593606293,
-0.6842877269,
-0.0667931587,
-0.4118961096,
0.0566432774,
-0.0624061711,
-0.5675253272,
0.439375639,
-0.1904346198,
-0.0557834692,
-0.3299319148,
-0.3613546193,
-0.3048850894,
-0.0531649329,
0.2066836357,
0.1892125309,
-0.1739520282,
0.0738458633,
-0.1585227549,
-0.3427516222,
0.0661528111,
-0.4909631908,
0.7229210734,
-0.2890208662,
-0.3138674498,
-0.7849060893,
0.5065661073,
0.4555962682,
-0.3330383599,
0.1428461522,
0.5526270866,
-0.2208971679,
0.039096389,
-0.3630725443,
-0.3758043051,
-0.4708270431,
0.2609900236,
-0.1682043225,
-0.966614306,
0.230326131,
-0.410638243,
-0.0827246979,
-0.0060290052,
0.4346414208,
-0.2185163349,
1.0978091955,
0.4787688553,
-0.0496329591,
0.6061400175,
0.0202738531,
0.0803319067,
-0.587744236,
-0.2483786643,
-0.6652610898,
0.2916352749,
-0.1092851683,
-0.4930454195,
0.3314379454,
0.1285922378,
-0.158483997,
0.1263989955,
-0.0005478535,
0.3138213158,
0.5208352804,
0.0240927674,
0.3509599268,
0.1822101325,
-0.5656237006,
-0.0789197981,
-0.5562494397,
-0.6822459102,
0.8812390566,
0.0747347996,
0.8336563706,
-0.2425785512,
0.6660660505,
0.0495261252,
0.3310989141,
-0.5626971126,
0.6763249636,
-0.1726260185,
-0.4335221946,
-0.2623414695,
-0.677524507,
-0.8041952848,
0.2997820377,
-0.2315708101,
-0.7900506258,
-0.2730906308,
0.278537035,
-0.3315013945,
0.180177182,
-0.67670542,
0.6767314076,
-0.4307934642,
0.1633038372,
0.0359133668,
-0.7335149646,
0.0941775367,
-0.1876800507,
0.2074359953,
-0.081345655,
0.2654417753,
0.6108153462,
-0.6040937304,
1.1255252361,
-0.2049271911,
-0.2595310211,
0.5010714531,
-0.0947133303,
0.4131573737,
0.0343150571,
0.0114917643,
0.3155284524,
-0.3521321118,
-0.1362700611,
-0.4350982904,
0.2907501459,
-0.5222322345,
-0.6088767648,
-0.2943680882,
-0.4654337168,
-0.5230674744,
0.4076643288,
0.3435835838,
0.8652840257,
-0.6757204533,
0.274597168,
0.5156037211,
0.0521455221,
0.2929300666,
0.6305237412,
-0.2658090591,
-0.7930299044,
0.7411006689,
-0.0794896558,
0.4267650843,
0.4617722332,
0.2662143111,
-0.5594879985,
-0.5040751696,
-0.508421123,
-0.0216374975,
-0.3307119012,
-0.1855833083,
-0.5554602742,
-0.1344830841,
-0.4983518124,
-0.0710303634,
-0.3966136575,
-0.0453904681,
-0.5632904768,
-0.0520690493,
-0.0161294285,
0.7109514475,
0.0738078728,
0.6097092628,
-1.0034122467,
0.7181261778,
0.7306388617,
0.1954591125,
-0.1885806173,
-0.5276502371,
0.018895166,
0.4750881195,
-0.4343661666,
-0.8834558725,
0.3481194675,
0.5139419436,
0.4924084544,
0.485653609,
-0.0188633706,
0.7262383103,
-0.7345662713,
0.7955133319,
0.6045523882,
-1.1421358585,
0.5201797485,
-0.4982937872,
0.465398252,
0.5648633242,
0.1734920144,
-0.2732658386,
-0.5321144462,
-0.3502961397,
-0.7951821685,
0.5647054315,
0.3133232594,
0.1562244743,
-0.0010647201,
0.0573410876,
0.0924674794,
0.2175368965,
-0.7226814032,
0.0062066615,
-0.1757091582,
-0.238404274,
-0.2090710104,
-0.1165396944,
-0.1977992207,
-0.3646324873,
0.5721345544,
-0.3001387715,
0.2365721762,
0.2580737472,
-0.3652819991,
-0.1233621687,
0.5955663919,
0.4355898201,
0.5032737851,
-0.1965301931,
0.1906384975,
0.0950476751,
-0.6238006353,
0.4898471832,
0.337696135,
-0.1030371785,
0.1110258773,
0.3472335637,
0.8927464485,
0.6237435341,
-0.6661127806,
0.4324131906,
-0.1082715541,
-0.277983129,
-0.1373199522,
0.0054642158,
0.2544109821,
0.1828759164,
0.5082818866,
0.0148761757,
-0.0160210114,
-0.5901945829,
0.1541612446,
0.4882131815,
-0.5219162107,
-0.63809973,
0.7438471913,
0.5837581158,
-0.4923986793,
0.5128957033,
0.0739333704,
-0.5272839069,
0.4065442681,
0.8755767345,
1.1395932436,
-0.4726058543,
0.271325469,
-0.0762570873,
-0.0665659532,
0.0769049376,
0.3202207386,
-0.2064567953,
-0.6640594006,
-0.3812715411,
-0.7860639691,
-0.4338918924,
0.2243979126,
-0.6656717658,
0.0463739485,
-0.3288202286,
-0.3661566377,
0.0334353298,
-0.2585574687,
-0.5826365352,
0.3294090629,
0.3081566691,
0.5906375647,
-0.8108286858,
0.8274717331,
0.6878451109,
-0.1516284645,
-0.8188890219,
0.2415693402,
0.2736900449,
-0.5351775289,
0.3069689274,
0.5058870316,
-0.4505413473,
0.2092270255,
-0.4319823384,
-0.5785161257,
1.0630760193,
0.7473065853,
-0.7926114202,
-0.1329799742,
0.4885113835,
0.463855356,
-0.5593990088,
0.0662830845,
0.5039883852,
0.2111070305,
0.2505065501,
-1.1595096588,
-0.2373316139,
-0.1446041167,
0.1670229286,
0.0649637654,
-0.3030495346,
0.7038421631,
-0.177374512,
-0.4684824944,
0.2902344167,
0.6499585509,
0.3116644323,
0.2741851509,
0.6863316894,
0.7560437322,
0.8203282356,
-0.0978395194,
0.8670703173,
-0.1778329015,
0.1015386507,
1.3143533468,
-0.5898115635,
0.8569553494,
0.3130168617,
-0.2072039694,
0.4081286788,
0.4718867242,
0.5999757051,
0.5894814134,
0.0434535742,
-0.650133729,
-0.57309407,
-0.152891174,
-0.4077506363,
0.7185896635,
0.2437180877,
-0.0792846829,
-0.3877589703,
-0.0018717078,
-0.0147108315,
-0.1375931203,
-0.2477231622,
1.146389246,
0.3528855741,
-0.567946732,
0.4304282069,
-0.3559765518,
0.5384375453,
-0.825627923,
-0.022617707,
0.0638621151,
-0.0273183472,
0.1906550825,
-0.4229560792,
0.0406411812,
0.2753422558,
-0.1738052815,
-0.4649537504,
0.7215898037,
-0.6825546026,
-0.4283019602,
0.3352345228,
0.4331207871,
-0.0021058016,
-0.2720667422,
-0.6613300443,
-0.1629589647,
-0.0717949867,
-0.2759067714,
0.3235984743,
0.4015425444,
0.0605461337,
0.4031056762,
1.0438835621,
-0.1374769509,
-0.0459624007,
0.6053647995,
0.936420083,
-0.6091426611,
-0.6936799288,
-0.7130577564,
0.6467201114,
0.1674472243,
-0.1545718759,
0.4457426369,
0.4098830223,
0.6350349188,
-0.035862729,
0.7578146458,
0.3781393468,
0.3774834871,
-0.7584607005,
0.5050565004,
-0.3564931452,
0.079210639,
-0.4215421379,
-0.9444921017,
-0.1782542616,
0.4888063967,
0.0803487301,
0.1765363514,
0.506041944,
0.6430401206,
0.118921563,
0.2860341072,
0.2595127225,
0.1926437914,
0.3449927568,
0.203907147,
0.7460959554,
0.0050440668,
0.5798599124,
0.1022638232,
-0.125288412,
-0.206908375,
-0.8718897104,
-0.8454105854,
-0.4327058792,
-0.0063170376,
-0.0343836546,
-0.0341293663,
0.8914423585,
0.8821024895,
-0.7693727612,
-0.3392548561,
-0.5255087018,
-0.208778441,
0.0637510121,
-0.1844351888,
-0.0451389663,
-0.319424659,
-0.5189865232,
0.726711452,
0.4125496447,
0.3645649254,
-0.1755328327,
-0.3296216726,
-0.0610805638,
0.3599422872,
0.5830719471,
0.1560640335,
-0.829818368,
0.030529011,
0.0872205198,
0.0316256732,
0.0615718476,
1.0482677221,
-0.6862964034,
0.5795000196,
0.302015543,
0.4866586924,
0.2925956249,
0.0800298676,
0.9300468564,
-0.9245206714,
0.2815703154,
0.3761206865,
0.3269795477,
0.3593393564,
-0.0150076766,
0.1463703215,
0.3364501595,
-0.4499772489,
-0.8261340261,
0.430049032,
-1.0713094473,
-0.1599835902,
1.0192935467,
-0.1777281612,
-0.1074809805,
-0.2009219676,
-0.3919196725,
0.3929428458,
-0.4390653074,
0.3375917077,
0.5557386875,
-0.0927123576,
-0.0252283439,
-0.1994888484,
0.4320189655,
0.4413618445,
-1.0128517151,
0.1717642844,
0.6093123555,
0.2360007316,
0.0889915377,
0.9702575207,
0.0027292722,
0.1871509701,
0.0403134748,
-0.0721608251,
-0.0062933317,
-0.6839572191,
-0.3735975623,
-0.0628391877,
-0.1905005425,
0.0264208354
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05699v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05699v3
|
Self-Alignment of Large Language Models via Monopolylogue-based Social Scene Simulation
| 2024-02-08T14:21:03 | 2024-06-08T06:13:55 |
Xianghe Pang, Shuo Tang, Rui Ye, Yuxin Xiong, Bolun Zhang, Yanfeng Wang, Siheng Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
Aligning large language models (LLMs) with human values is imperative to
mitigate potential adverse effects resulting from their misuse. Drawing from
the sociological insight that acknowledging all parties' concerns is a key
factor in shaping human values, this paper proposes a novel direction to align
LLMs by themselves: social scene simulation. To achieve this, we present
MATRIX, a novel social scene simulator that emulates realistic scenes around a
user's input query, enabling the LLM to take social consequences into account
before responding. MATRIX serves as a virtual rehearsal space, akin to a
Monopolylogue, where the LLM performs diverse roles related to the query and
practice by itself. To inject this alignment, we fine-tune the LLM with
MATRIX-simulated data, ensuring adherence to human values without compromising
inference speed. We theoretically show that the LLM with MATRIX outperforms
Constitutional AI under mild assumptions. Finally, extensive experiments
validate that our method outperforms over 10 baselines across 4 benchmarks. As
evidenced by 875 user ratings, our tuned 13B-size LLM exceeds GPT-4 in aligning
with human values. See our project page at
https://shuotang123.github.io/MATRIX.
|
[
-0.2124731094,
-0.4466884732,
0.4951965511,
0.3069758415,
-0.1449658722,
0.3921900988,
-0.1292423159,
-0.2034148276,
0.5382409692,
0.6014370322,
-0.3731684089,
-0.3382882476,
-0.1462161541,
-0.2742004991,
-0.2871728539,
0.7370108366,
0.2083729059,
0.1777492464,
-0.3400872946,
-0.0913906768,
-0.2734233737,
-0.5940282941,
-0.311904043,
-0.347952038,
0.7191026211,
0.4750247002,
0.8821294308,
1.0284721851,
0.2620048523,
0.3921564221,
0.1516308337,
0.2342535704,
-0.7342225313,
-0.0863426104,
-0.3560711741,
-0.0810689405,
-0.6659136415,
0.1351699084,
0.9451451302,
0.4872905016,
-0.4102326632,
0.5020160079,
0.3988426626,
0.6545818448,
-0.5393155813,
-0.0270461123,
-0.5655088425,
0.016397452,
-0.1029484794,
0.0508728027,
-0.3370792866,
-0.5033991337,
-0.1832687706,
-0.4443571866,
-0.2257412523,
0.2503097951,
1.092181921,
0.2389225513,
-0.4985348284,
0.158989653,
-0.7980522513,
0.5606677532,
-0.5736964941,
-0.0429345071,
0.0590114519,
0.5374552011,
-0.3469403088,
-0.3749265373,
-0.6792185903,
0.0387722217,
0.201960817,
0.1915896684,
-0.0815354213,
0.0552827045,
0.0902395248,
0.0219359528,
-0.4453571737,
0.2111161798,
-0.5688577294,
-0.1884180307,
0.6863925457,
0.6477939487,
0.2826541364,
-0.3564712107,
-0.5155826807,
-0.0751215592,
-0.7780308127,
0.3147268891,
0.750457406,
0.3201741874,
0.0021271564,
0.7388524413,
0.1030335501,
0.6386381984,
0.3163167536,
-0.0572096594,
0.0702348873,
-0.1681159437,
-0.1385256052,
0.3560751379,
0.8700011373,
0.7045215368,
0.5842909217,
0.1684702635,
0.0302834325,
0.1686983854,
0.6216053963,
-0.6421161294,
0.1136667728,
0.0379936136,
-0.3052062392,
-0.5221737623,
-0.3481149077,
-0.9007915258,
-0.6461669207,
-0.6652792096,
0.552857101,
-0.1116704941,
-0.2387976646,
0.0399665721,
0.2802017033,
0.512065351,
0.5510845184,
-0.8400146365,
0.4834632277,
0.6958104372,
0.761012733,
-0.1002114341,
-0.4442900419,
-0.3514047265,
0.4201286733,
-0.5991990566,
0.763247788,
-0.4824032784,
-0.1473187655,
-0.1262879521,
-0.2906567454,
0.0219332334,
-0.5215317011,
0.096467413,
-0.2737677991,
-0.1268217266,
-0.3655209243,
-0.4195640087,
0.408741504,
0.3438703418,
-0.6033455729,
0.8395694494,
-0.1616305113,
-0.6530361176,
0.1499355286,
-0.3111903965,
-0.070830971,
-0.2113921642,
-0.5936570764,
-0.3972333074,
-0.0075494172,
-0.0928621963,
0.2821544111,
-0.1289752275,
0.501820147,
-0.7539952993,
-0.5121113062,
0.725662291,
-0.2496628314,
0.6836408377,
0.2227708101,
-0.2205104232,
0.3340291679,
-0.5298386812,
0.0056580715,
-0.0086765932,
-0.1083361432,
0.0669000149,
0.1649460495,
-0.0527300648,
0.5635172725,
0.2628333569,
-0.4426113665,
0.2785741985,
-0.2756696343,
0.3584562838,
1.3119733334,
-0.4423948526,
0.6702101827,
-0.513235271,
0.6947389245,
-0.1697393358,
0.1509609222,
0.3976441026,
-0.2433539778,
-0.546797514,
-0.3797456324,
0.4302511811,
0.5823431015,
-0.1566754878,
0.303329587,
-0.433517158,
-0.3091924787,
-0.9248633385,
0.1968074292,
0.2566617429,
0.2967508733,
0.0442587398,
-0.1545015126,
-0.7359311581,
-1.2752206326,
-0.2690416574,
-0.2083016783,
-0.0111300349,
0.5408495665,
0.1395668089,
0.0335618183,
1.1763265133,
-0.4146558344,
-0.4527895749,
-0.2409365922,
-0.0502195954,
0.0628084242,
0.5077310205,
0.0974126607,
-0.1977085173,
-0.4783504009,
0.0112309484,
-0.6027271748,
-0.2847744524,
-0.0699486732,
-0.3653878868,
0.014746977,
0.599011302,
-0.2556821108,
0.2625022829,
0.7412824035,
-0.139282912,
0.5482057929,
-0.3621630073,
0.0076596411,
-1.5132662058,
0.1258135438,
-0.1013812944,
-0.4706597328,
-0.3794639707,
-0.3479087353,
0.103530474,
-0.2541586459,
-0.3429087102,
0.5508180261,
-0.4948568344,
-0.3946685195,
-0.2420586795,
0.3247024417,
0.0024179139,
0.3484890759,
-0.2896299362,
0.9389535189,
0.2194552124,
-0.1063069478,
0.0895093307,
0.0288737174,
-0.5742209554,
0.5103301406,
-0.4683635533,
0.165037781,
-0.2396436781,
0.4054396451,
-1.1630402803,
-0.3315012455,
0.052657716,
-0.3193535209,
0.2142741084,
-0.3104005754,
-0.6037386656,
-0.0598888695,
-0.1631075144,
0.4809673429,
0.7059599757,
-0.3269413412,
0.7843106985,
0.9924336672,
-0.0486998782,
-0.8299552798,
-0.3949908614,
0.3721647561,
-0.4854051173,
-0.6468060613,
0.192648232,
-0.0159711298,
-0.2196112722,
-0.1383948773,
0.1135618538,
0.0618755035,
-0.0728792697,
0.3956765234,
0.4097835124,
-0.0834167898,
-0.1122412384,
0.0902613848,
0.0247973111,
0.0679593086,
-0.2375537008,
0.4749597311,
-0.3117437661,
-0.1537896991,
-0.3126100898,
0.2281803042,
0.5417053103,
-0.0008500048,
0.4605931938,
0.2656513751,
-0.2292243093,
-0.1324596703,
-0.7330821157,
0.0426301435,
-0.5573660731,
0.1013571993,
-0.1491486728,
-0.9588525295,
0.7597039938,
-0.1047268435,
-0.2362122834,
-0.0990979224,
0.5919747353,
-0.3285744488,
1.1899840832,
0.3998001814,
-0.1661283374,
0.4186112583,
-0.0764876306,
0.2707617581,
-1.0392602682,
-0.0950997174,
-0.4207550287,
-0.6507403851,
-0.4852866828,
-0.6946073771,
0.312654078,
-0.0630965829,
-0.2953638732,
0.3674004078,
-0.2124463022,
0.6953971386,
0.1231989637,
0.061462082,
0.0987113789,
-0.0152650252,
-0.4330270588,
-0.1621735245,
-0.6466786265,
-0.8141109943,
0.7826980352,
0.2771273553,
1.1298117638,
0.2122686207,
0.7648672462,
0.0233104099,
0.5561910272,
-0.4207991958,
0.7475488186,
0.0164609794,
-0.986797452,
-0.3947005272,
-0.4369233847,
-0.9427059293,
0.4257879555,
-0.2147455961,
-1.0057611465,
0.3833141625,
0.5458815694,
-0.5972927809,
0.1379915923,
-0.5010501742,
1.1361790895,
-0.128957361,
-0.8459990025,
-0.360096544,
-0.6218237877,
0.3435700238,
0.046845153,
0.4427625537,
-0.5869103074,
0.0537800193,
0.1967969388,
-0.1444153935,
1.2628685236,
0.1077844426,
-0.0703722611,
0.1159937754,
0.2784309983,
0.326022476,
-0.0738169029,
-0.0114453696,
0.140854612,
-0.0988121256,
-0.4694983661,
-0.5092734694,
0.8700124621,
-0.7973021269,
-0.8806055784,
-0.4299598932,
-0.5974652171,
0.0275670383,
0.0024476747,
-0.0296977367,
0.3494446576,
-0.604881525,
0.0743332654,
0.2644257545,
-0.2307711393,
0.1802976578,
0.4054572284,
-0.5484914184,
-0.6355801821,
0.9469330311,
0.389882654,
0.4866558909,
0.0559131652,
0.3057217002,
-0.3793512285,
-0.0409271084,
-0.69634974,
0.1904864013,
-0.5048539042,
-0.2704316378,
-0.5621638894,
-0.2514533103,
-0.4503924549,
-0.4283045828,
-0.5570684671,
-0.2475893646,
-0.0673949197,
-0.1221350878,
-0.162972033,
0.5794373751,
-0.3336904645,
0.0569006838,
-0.4072978199,
0.0809777528,
0.5138172507,
0.4725969136,
-0.0071510118,
-0.5949983597,
-0.320576787,
0.095919311,
-0.2399231791,
-0.7237081528,
0.3929727972,
-0.0214651451,
0.3662863672,
0.4854313731,
0.1213616282,
1.2097340822,
-0.9935628176,
0.4217896163,
0.086998269,
-1.147785902,
0.2138971984,
-0.5020527244,
0.0955397263,
0.7259501219,
-0.0596755631,
-0.5190512538,
-0.5475950837,
-0.3500069082,
-0.6258129478,
0.6209715009,
0.2074731886,
0.4539598525,
-0.0458181649,
0.3268767297,
-0.3910433948,
0.0543184206,
-0.8977084756,
0.0561433807,
-0.2683191597,
-0.4215041995,
-0.0606026128,
-0.209043175,
-0.2399239838,
-0.3273477554,
0.2883830667,
-0.1974313706,
0.0920963958,
0.1888122112,
-0.0563355125,
-0.4349265397,
0.1995926201,
0.8144826293,
0.867861867,
-0.2815501988,
0.218498826,
0.2335766107,
-0.0939884931,
0.4815877974,
-0.2224425673,
0.2308095247,
-0.4740744233,
-0.1140994504,
0.5170229077,
0.4572738707,
-0.6065593362,
0.6535440683,
-0.1075328067,
-0.1380137354,
-0.6614563465,
0.0831329748,
0.4588904083,
0.4421583116,
-0.0482414588,
-0.1795252413,
0.0981922075,
-0.6491600275,
0.1216721833,
0.6560091972,
-0.4466735721,
-0.2569632232,
0.7296421528,
0.1364698857,
-0.5890617371,
0.4153755605,
-0.1455645114,
-0.3265825808,
0.7219294906,
0.7538380623,
0.7601691484,
-0.5116189122,
0.241588071,
0.3090665936,
0.3822668493,
-0.1864448637,
-0.0206230264,
0.1666194648,
-1.1009380817,
-0.7161512971,
-0.6973099709,
-0.4828062952,
-0.0241219271,
-0.6317185163,
0.2993638217,
-0.566560626,
-0.111759901,
0.0122465258,
-0.0591178052,
-0.1687290519,
-0.3149421811,
0.2950126231,
0.5919826627,
-0.8641805649,
1.3481432199,
0.4276001751,
-0.0576594286,
-0.9785383344,
-0.0857845992,
0.3059217036,
-0.8697769642,
0.5971611738,
0.3714624047,
-0.477650404,
0.1024270579,
-0.5370770693,
-0.9353391528,
1.0723816156,
0.8329277039,
-0.6311240792,
-0.0703341812,
0.3127209842,
0.7079516649,
-0.717994988,
-0.134916231,
0.3285494745,
0.3372614384,
0.1579263508,
-0.8596665859,
0.0468053855,
-0.2671935856,
0.0706645399,
0.1817211211,
-0.6983385086,
0.6289538741,
-0.2139041126,
-0.1877135485,
-0.0194892567,
0.4738616943,
0.3269297779,
0.1866887361,
0.6892166734,
0.5347220302,
0.4752234817,
0.3673222959,
0.7857515216,
-0.3759329915,
0.1953025162,
1.2586497068,
-0.8601167202,
0.6808421016,
0.3308180869,
0.0149453264,
0.5302112699,
0.5216531157,
0.0406540446,
0.2353459448,
0.5718621016,
-0.1049817577,
-0.5825366378,
0.0056871907,
-0.1142482609,
0.7025603652,
0.2681459188,
-0.1352385581,
-0.1128626093,
-0.4858697355,
0.0211751722,
0.3083499968,
-0.17499879,
0.8960751891,
0.1888353676,
-0.6838139296,
0.4296100438,
-0.1779203713,
0.0449261665,
-0.3910529912,
-0.0726559162,
-0.2358101159,
0.3392549455,
0.0197484363,
-0.6465204358,
0.2159999013,
-0.1077871844,
0.0279191267,
-0.3307624459,
0.4484677911,
-0.6541087031,
-0.4495160282,
0.4598988593,
0.146260038,
0.1514416486,
0.1382102966,
-0.6932349205,
0.0061433357,
-0.0811813548,
0.1051775366,
0.7306061387,
0.5108708143,
-0.0759541318,
0.588475883,
0.6005379558,
0.0191142634,
-0.1594877243,
-0.0438369252,
0.9668744802,
-0.7788085341,
-0.5654454827,
-1.0482609272,
0.538018465,
-0.4281025827,
-0.2647688687,
0.5856527686,
0.6691756845,
0.5762905478,
0.2464669943,
0.234872207,
0.4690277874,
0.1786752194,
-0.4238678217,
0.7832484245,
-0.4518938959,
0.2836699486,
-0.5369254947,
-0.8691150546,
-0.090878278,
0.8471820354,
-0.2204797119,
-0.2930917144,
0.3093642294,
1.0924438238,
-0.1032938138,
-0.4699218869,
0.6499396563,
0.2689335644,
0.2064199001,
0.196411863,
1.0877898932,
0.0385481715,
0.6745363474,
-0.0257817116,
-0.1604071558,
-0.338490665,
-1.0202409029,
-0.9314948916,
-0.4631011188,
0.0322301947,
-0.6017252803,
0.1621843576,
1.2738209963,
0.7693636417,
-0.3625552654,
-1.0201698542,
0.2163122296,
0.1190285087,
-0.0031217872,
-0.1742232442,
0.0801880434,
-0.2755065262,
-0.5171034336,
0.2408649176,
0.5668975711,
-0.0516102649,
-0.5432684422,
-0.0273710173,
-0.2296531647,
0.6452295184,
0.3827677965,
0.0639527738,
-0.7495930791,
-0.5079122186,
-0.0282953884,
-0.5618495941,
0.3334710896,
0.9165610671,
-0.5710714459,
0.4251402318,
0.144242838,
0.4761648774,
0.454115808,
0.3173089027,
0.9021144509,
-0.5572053194,
-0.0711464882,
0.1376779228,
0.3269566894,
0.2650373578,
-0.4436268508,
0.154326722,
-0.1316485256,
-0.8247027397,
-0.8670342565,
0.4269459546,
-1.0597529411,
-0.1870949268,
1.027436614,
0.0305848457,
-0.5516534448,
-0.0992297307,
-0.2743700445,
0.1498392075,
-0.4955232143,
1.2578624487,
0.6599705219,
0.175587818,
-0.1136474162,
-0.4996945262,
0.4008610845,
0.3739554286,
-0.6631373167,
0.3115520179,
0.6810104847,
0.331974566,
0.1147429571,
0.7733973861,
-0.1969014257,
0.1324946284,
-0.3053767681,
0.3580312431,
0.1195968315,
-0.1883804798,
-0.5331578255,
0.0942074805,
-0.000900265,
0.0603689402
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05672v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05672v1
|
Multilingual E5 Text Embeddings: A Technical Report
| 2024-02-08T13:47:50 | 2024-02-08T13:47:50 |
Liang Wang, Nan Yang, Xiaolong Huang, Linjun Yang, Rangan Majumder, Furu Wei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
This technical report presents the training methodology and evaluation
results of the open-source multilingual E5 text embedding models, released in
mid-2023. Three embedding models of different sizes (small / base / large) are
provided, offering a balance between the inference efficiency and embedding
quality. The training procedure adheres to the English E5 model recipe,
involving contrastive pre-training on 1 billion multilingual text pairs,
followed by fine-tuning on a combination of labeled datasets. Additionally, we
introduce a new instruction-tuned embedding model, whose performance is on par
with state-of-the-art, English-only models of similar sizes. Information
regarding the model release can be found at
https://github.com/microsoft/unilm/tree/master/e5 .
|
[
-0.3046563566,
-0.3825133145,
0.2827641666,
0.3161304295,
-0.2097516507,
-0.0719465315,
-0.2194148749,
-0.7588777542,
0.0824670717,
0.3887257278,
-0.3019945323,
-0.8805812597,
-0.4970897138,
0.3683662713,
-0.4968078732,
0.7422210574,
-0.2429301441,
0.3822340667,
-0.2610499561,
-0.220302403,
-0.4530490935,
-0.6738145351,
-0.2530857921,
-0.0777071342,
0.7121570706,
0.5492073298,
0.2932093441,
0.8046088815,
0.6234928966,
0.24019894,
0.0383295156,
-0.0554170571,
-0.2611562908,
-0.1124567986,
0.2386206537,
-0.2721513212,
-0.663459599,
0.3242115676,
0.5665778518,
0.5811536908,
-0.2732614279,
0.1172483191,
0.0297466125,
0.1975425929,
-0.696485281,
0.1714718044,
-0.2074405551,
0.2303217351,
0.0478243157,
0.0415302031,
-0.9087940454,
-0.2105671167,
0.1465009451,
-0.598266542,
0.2157071829,
0.1786742508,
0.7760310173,
-0.0060958588,
-0.5658056736,
-0.3713990152,
-0.3882008493,
0.8391901255,
-0.5750704408,
0.8262368441,
0.4066350162,
0.3519120216,
0.4792266488,
-0.9794490337,
-0.1952943206,
-0.159514457,
0.0273619238,
0.1568294913,
0.2719833255,
0.1281603724,
-0.0998161659,
0.2345169485,
-0.5389464498,
0.2586655021,
-0.4203331769,
0.0005950497,
0.5280116796,
-0.1570874304,
0.1989225149,
0.4402195513,
-0.2209253311,
0.0796797648,
-0.7660152316,
-0.5710793734,
0.4082463384,
0.222132355,
-0.4631549716,
0.3504171669,
0.1249779314,
0.7461113334,
-0.2070538998,
-0.1624775082,
0.5856437683,
-0.5283063054,
-0.1701096147,
0.1955713034,
0.3939861655,
0.4079576135,
0.2135657668,
-0.3107483983,
-0.3345487118,
-0.222565338,
0.2453584373,
-1.0101991892,
-0.3670239747,
0.170501411,
-0.6470194459,
-0.4114108682,
0.1604290903,
-0.4174099565,
-0.144124195,
-0.1340163946,
0.4008549452,
-0.5141513944,
-0.3296321332,
0.2333185822,
-0.2239453793,
0.1306429952,
0.3057997525,
-0.9246981144,
0.1120301709,
0.3120251,
0.7595257759,
0.1232850328,
-0.5510059595,
-0.3235771358,
0.3941721022,
-0.1263511032,
0.7346519232,
-0.8794534206,
-0.3238764405,
0.2316599488,
0.2263479978,
0.1106225029,
-0.2045138329,
0.7292832136,
-0.5495226979,
0.3454365432,
-0.1361094564,
-0.5956112742,
-0.344537437,
0.2501634955,
-0.8583036065,
0.8330004811,
-0.1354944259,
-0.7344908118,
0.4637147188,
-0.9125709534,
-0.0451454595,
-0.1700773388,
0.1678389758,
-0.5145215988,
-0.0090876976,
0.1526100039,
0.421795398,
-0.3571636677,
-0.1651064306,
-0.4328123033,
-0.3276377618,
-0.1812925935,
-0.258249104,
0.4707410038,
0.397585243,
0.0538693778,
0.2286622226,
-0.7865650058,
0.1088716909,
0.1558278799,
-0.2389801145,
-0.0972076952,
-0.0165555477,
0.3896751106,
0.2099586576,
0.4500591755,
-0.7737893462,
0.0220434759,
-0.2272767127,
0.6546630859,
0.5070469379,
-0.2781854868,
0.3337206841,
-0.0970115736,
0.4541813731,
0.4602363408,
0.1336106807,
-0.7227184176,
-0.3523325622,
-0.6232681274,
-0.35773471,
0.9956332445,
0.3927904665,
-0.4869806468,
0.2087736428,
-0.1616748124,
-0.3978957832,
-0.8284407258,
-0.1320015788,
0.5054756999,
-0.0466344655,
0.4123029411,
-0.0591087639,
-0.5335608721,
-0.958822608,
-0.3139337599,
0.3919867575,
0.3021283448,
-0.1503985375,
0.7434703708,
-0.1325319558,
0.5475891829,
-0.255390197,
0.0871723965,
-0.2187803537,
0.3569085002,
-0.2127487361,
0.522223413,
0.6893051863,
-0.7092690468,
-0.8277420998,
0.0710561499,
-0.722743988,
0.0666421503,
0.3776682615,
0.288051635,
0.4602757394,
0.6412452459,
-0.0150981424,
0.2138871998,
0.9046501517,
-0.2730884552,
0.2090937495,
-0.5268771648,
0.1301683336,
-1.2542636395,
-0.0520389415,
0.1420417577,
-0.4085428119,
-0.2848190665,
0.283867836,
0.4820202589,
-0.2589558959,
-0.6196081638,
0.28928864,
-1.0287908316,
-0.0743098035,
0.118249096,
0.3142360747,
0.0978021249,
0.075656563,
-0.0784082189,
0.6722923517,
0.2612181008,
-0.529589057,
0.2574100792,
0.0233467892,
-0.2782073617,
0.5181112885,
-0.8339701295,
0.4855027199,
-0.1172002628,
0.1582579315,
-0.6958976984,
-0.1830717623,
-0.0764011443,
-0.4134356081,
0.483899653,
-0.1051952988,
-0.6468952894,
-0.2916720212,
-0.5364690423,
0.2850947678,
0.1738610864,
-0.52743572,
0.3885257542,
0.5065892935,
-0.1350939125,
-0.4188987017,
-0.886080265,
0.014396714,
0.0170544405,
-0.567748785,
0.6428488493,
-0.1819152683,
0.1176513657,
0.2199504972,
0.3831793368,
-0.3501483798,
0.1481183618,
-0.162492469,
-0.1211424023,
-0.25045982,
0.1656738967,
0.0792060941,
-0.2102747858,
-0.1498795748,
-0.308452189,
0.291246593,
-0.2038466334,
-0.4859633446,
-0.3554943204,
0.6201230884,
0.3562118709,
-0.6348496675,
1.1237303019,
0.7329269052,
-0.4523970485,
-0.1156678721,
-0.3022076786,
-0.1151580885,
-0.4383710623,
0.6622845531,
-0.6617826819,
-0.759467721,
0.2143168002,
-0.136566177,
0.4150300622,
0.4517038167,
0.4103914499,
-0.0511545278,
1.5238620043,
0.9603431821,
0.4279462695,
0.330915451,
-0.0543933325,
0.286147058,
-0.4521695971,
-0.5290198326,
-0.8840065002,
-0.1961961538,
-0.7637819052,
-0.2657238245,
0.3258146942,
0.1113590151,
-0.2798835635,
0.0364397801,
-0.3886621296,
0.6577415466,
0.4450074136,
-0.1079397574,
0.2388917655,
0.0702050701,
-0.548334837,
-0.1950397938,
-0.7372028232,
-0.7272545695,
1.2448158264,
0.529714644,
0.438177526,
0.2455039322,
0.7233778834,
0.1934408993,
0.3352974653,
-0.5203142762,
0.1141729504,
-0.319458127,
-0.4315351248,
-0.1179181039,
-0.1343807876,
-0.8715572953,
0.1391232312,
-0.1292896569,
-0.3596696556,
-0.3307410181,
0.1063162088,
0.0127899433,
0.2266642004,
-1.2040675879,
1.0696063042,
-0.1048035622,
-0.0397357456,
-0.4114178419,
-0.5637256503,
0.0176098812,
0.0198543277,
0.2955279052,
0.1653317958,
-0.2479200065,
0.7249871492,
-0.1025026739,
0.8961411119,
-0.3242787421,
-0.0837267339,
0.0073747798,
-0.3028106987,
0.4783867896,
-0.379660964,
-0.1804210395,
0.204881981,
0.3188619912,
-0.635316968,
-0.3633265495,
0.659876585,
-0.9007296562,
-0.1885925233,
-0.3506222963,
-0.2938646376,
-0.1942232102,
0.249046728,
0.2032522559,
0.5480619073,
-0.6633457541,
0.5495331883,
0.5945216417,
-0.4810237288,
0.7394953966,
0.6904445291,
-0.4271992743,
-0.61749506,
1.0704196692,
0.4339993894,
0.1305923611,
0.5103254318,
-0.1026797667,
-0.2715019286,
-0.5878234506,
-0.3993053734,
0.2598771155,
-0.6814197302,
0.0328843296,
-0.5852339268,
-0.2269775867,
-0.5301624537,
-0.071375899,
-0.5062710643,
-0.3014585078,
-0.2411847562,
-0.3284775019,
0.1847859323,
1.4825021029,
0.082726568,
0.3094708622,
-1.0073187351,
-0.1088987812,
-0.200039193,
0.5719627738,
-0.2218686193,
-0.4653933048,
-1.0800324678,
0.1643066555,
-0.6701117754,
-0.8513094783,
0.419223398,
0.3018289804,
0.6154665351,
0.132481128,
-0.2488336861,
0.244624719,
-0.6378221512,
0.8877776861,
0.3416804671,
-0.9860883951,
0.4765669703,
-0.3189385533,
0.357727319,
0.171216473,
0.6283112764,
-0.4344779253,
-0.0037647043,
-0.5598548651,
-0.6785850525,
0.7005442381,
-0.3119240701,
0.0855046138,
-0.0804377422,
-0.0188933555,
0.3641349077,
0.3393989801,
-0.5621168613,
-0.3227785528,
-0.313207984,
-0.4391937256,
-0.1839875579,
-0.6434537768,
0.0966752544,
-0.2566716373,
0.5691739321,
-0.0769968107,
0.6023986936,
-0.0421205685,
-0.441503942,
0.169893235,
0.2207166702,
0.8654212356,
0.7278627753,
-0.1598615199,
0.0664118305,
0.1322567463,
-0.5274932384,
0.0462746434,
0.0352313705,
0.0803335384,
0.0702655986,
0.4321184456,
0.8193026781,
0.474950254,
-0.1558700651,
0.4875555336,
-0.0659317151,
-0.4505933225,
-0.2844205797,
-0.4199994504,
0.2577720284,
-0.0633361414,
0.0328894146,
-0.2805529237,
0.0536561832,
-0.4120646119,
0.1416223198,
-0.0140164914,
-0.4265717566,
-0.6939187646,
0.5577082038,
0.7132220268,
-0.2618971765,
0.6149470806,
-0.0545473956,
-0.4006301463,
0.4593628943,
0.7983523011,
0.8551875353,
-0.4871769547,
0.3436057866,
0.3100355566,
0.6280687451,
0.1577399522,
0.6667755842,
0.4238316417,
-0.5916736722,
-0.4188939035,
-0.3636550903,
-0.4579733312,
-0.1178197041,
-0.6359576583,
0.4851242304,
-0.2155173272,
-0.0883090198,
-0.076451987,
0.0289918017,
-0.8863028288,
0.2342416495,
0.0762746111,
1.2609140873,
-0.7200400233,
0.9857137799,
0.9995394945,
-0.513517797,
-0.6212700605,
-0.1047224849,
-0.081351921,
-0.5870589018,
0.5608818531,
0.3793814182,
-0.1544763893,
0.3674614131,
-0.5945755839,
-0.7747780085,
1.218513608,
0.7329143286,
-0.6610591412,
-0.0069391276,
0.0616444461,
0.263142854,
-0.6298642159,
0.6303305626,
0.3058148623,
0.64270854,
-0.243898347,
-1.1279155016,
-0.3048746288,
-0.342177093,
-0.0811160356,
0.1733931154,
-0.7874215841,
0.6787013412,
-0.1932993382,
-0.007187671,
-0.0710104108,
0.7435244918,
0.0200251043,
0.0391731225,
0.1811417192,
0.7949950695,
0.8803638816,
-0.185730055,
1.3020483255,
-0.8735079765,
0.2944501638,
1.001483202,
-0.2405747026,
1.0423521996,
0.3199488819,
0.034542799,
0.4849006236,
0.7814502716,
0.1534620225,
0.6660767198,
-0.140035674,
-0.1047568098,
-0.0668429509,
-0.321906358,
-0.7404144406,
0.3707127273,
0.1775389612,
-0.7418093085,
-0.1105054766,
-0.0890622362,
0.0609233268,
-0.252294302,
-0.1510428041,
0.7159326077,
0.1198957339,
-0.3842089474,
0.5193953514,
0.6304286122,
0.5082517862,
-0.3755901456,
-0.2327617854,
0.0917905271,
0.201680392,
-0.0804014876,
-0.6315873861,
0.1984727532,
-0.0803870782,
-0.2747037113,
-0.5152132511,
0.309623301,
-0.6347625256,
-0.4699329436,
0.4649341702,
0.441614449,
0.1421067268,
0.2911523879,
-0.6203737259,
0.1842079312,
-0.1445053518,
-0.2821041644,
0.3361753821,
0.6842814088,
0.0943887308,
0.3996069133,
0.2313607931,
-0.1095966324,
0.1175062805,
0.4477199018,
0.5773403049,
-0.7705298662,
-0.5708754659,
-0.5838468671,
0.7611446977,
-0.0849442035,
-0.3989830613,
0.709041357,
0.6434530616,
0.8665969372,
-0.2502893209,
0.870588541,
0.3942121267,
0.4003637731,
-0.6798532009,
0.5932340622,
-0.6056720018,
0.0694494471,
-0.0285213236,
-0.7952789068,
-0.195822686,
0.3839362264,
-0.1707786024,
0.4221623242,
1.1742935181,
0.5912975073,
-0.1256461591,
0.3142287731,
0.5295450687,
0.3633520305,
0.1179137677,
0.3004432917,
0.5572875738,
-0.4501555264,
0.3887351453,
-0.1530893296,
-0.0438267142,
-0.2354583591,
-1.0940591097,
-0.8121522665,
-0.6122225523,
-0.2899414301,
0.0469508879,
0.2527926862,
0.8879377246,
0.8230298162,
-0.8343715072,
-0.1272884607,
0.0112520205,
-0.1409987062,
0.0140039437,
-0.1098753735,
0.0682663247,
-0.4027764201,
-0.820653975,
0.3886359334,
0.2222951055,
0.1296672076,
-0.4950689077,
-0.2334373891,
-0.2998617589,
0.0737838373,
0.7014112473,
-0.289139986,
-0.5120596886,
-0.3645653129,
0.069674015,
-0.178274706,
0.0065381657,
0.6319936514,
-0.2818984687,
0.4097480178,
0.3541693687,
0.3927199543,
0.4715785384,
-0.5770590305,
1.0028343201,
-0.9681499004,
0.2554151118,
-0.0201492589,
0.4125704169,
0.4266879857,
0.0748887882,
0.5151309371,
0.1546367854,
-0.4589403868,
-0.8922184706,
-0.0036460804,
-0.4233274758,
-0.1966298521,
0.7745200992,
-0.4899343848,
-0.0427132435,
-0.0309472755,
0.0080761239,
0.2827297449,
-0.3206052482,
0.2853174806,
1.0277934074,
0.4372087121,
-0.4045115113,
-0.6859694719,
0.2573210299,
0.2520828545,
-0.8296309114,
-0.3623827696,
0.4159117341,
0.1881936938,
-0.0423647389,
0.1884952933,
-0.2112807482,
0.1877744347,
0.2654544115,
0.4797730744,
-0.3152171969,
-0.8200718164,
-0.3113037348,
0.3855954707,
0.3211248815,
-0.2765785456
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05668v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05668v1
|
Comprehensive Assessment of Jailbreak Attacks Against LLMs
| 2024-02-08T13:42:50 | 2024-02-08T13:42:50 |
Junjie Chu, Yugeng Liu, Ziqing Yang, Xinyue Shen, Michael Backes, Yang Zhang
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Misuse of the Large Language Models (LLMs) has raised widespread concern. To
address this issue, safeguards have been taken to ensure that LLMs align with
social ethics. However, recent findings have revealed an unsettling
vulnerability bypassing the safeguards of LLMs, known as jailbreak attacks. By
applying techniques, such as employing role-playing scenarios, adversarial
examples, or subtle subversion of safety objectives as a prompt, LLMs can
produce an inappropriate or even harmful response. While researchers have
studied several categories of jailbreak attacks, they have done so in
isolation. To fill this gap, we present the first large-scale measurement of
various jailbreak attack methods. We concentrate on 13 cutting-edge jailbreak
methods from four categories, 160 questions from 16 violation categories, and
six popular LLMs. Our extensive experimental results demonstrate that the
optimized jailbreak prompts consistently achieve the highest attack success
rates, as well as exhibit robustness across different LLMs. Some jailbreak
prompt datasets, available from the Internet, can also achieve high attack
success rates on many LLMs, such as ChatGLM3, GPT-3.5, and PaLM2. Despite the
claims from many organizations regarding the coverage of violation categories
in their policies, the attack success rates from these categories remain high,
indicating the challenges of effectively aligning LLM policies and the ability
to counter jailbreak attacks. We also discuss the trade-off between the attack
performance and efficiency, as well as show that the transferability of the
jailbreak prompts is still viable, becoming an option for black-box models.
Overall, our research highlights the necessity of evaluating different
jailbreak methods. We hope our study can provide insights for future research
on jailbreak attacks and serve as a benchmark tool for evaluating them for
practitioners.
|
[
-0.4107341766,
-0.9906551242,
0.5673345923,
0.2659158111,
-0.1621702164,
0.484513998,
-0.1390990466,
-0.5045952201,
0.3878389895,
0.566016674,
-0.3744135499,
-0.3110917509,
-0.6586406827,
0.2210892439,
-0.4874706864,
0.7335198522,
-0.0023929854,
-0.0159733929,
0.1197090745,
-0.0628202036,
-0.6711888313,
-0.6524587274,
-0.3771396279,
0.0796048418,
0.4797897637,
0.2455350906,
0.4681549072,
0.2416068912,
0.7006723285,
0.2387978137,
-0.4001071751,
-0.0507797189,
-0.402785778,
0.0735296607,
-0.1187109426,
-0.3780995011,
-0.4317836165,
0.0717581511,
0.2839864492,
0.2481513172,
-0.1361048669,
0.144542098,
-0.0781565681,
0.7474302053,
-0.8445584178,
-0.5485884547,
-0.873141706,
0.0592614412,
-0.4276098609,
0.1145199686,
-0.582116127,
-0.4626438022,
-0.272539854,
0.1462953836,
-0.2813745737,
-0.0147529012,
0.4161479175,
-0.0652910173,
-0.3423934877,
-0.4224963784,
-0.3147210181,
0.6213517785,
-0.8725539446,
-0.0277436133,
0.4049330056,
0.2764511704,
-0.3730487227,
-0.2642642856,
-0.1934643835,
-0.6259152293,
0.1511484087,
-0.0841725618,
-0.5068648458,
0.0556518584,
0.4802929163,
0.1845706254,
-0.349265337,
0.4719714522,
-0.517929554,
-0.2152545452,
0.7040525079,
0.3430224955,
0.4462204278,
-0.3351044655,
-0.5477669835,
0.111115627,
-1.091219306,
0.1291802227,
0.5715281367,
-0.024399532,
-0.2575913966,
0.6656443477,
0.1392118782,
0.8020591736,
-0.1654295027,
-0.1626856476,
-0.1221624315,
-0.4564279318,
-0.1418485194,
0.0673122779,
0.9791224003,
0.5676465034,
0.3321438432,
-0.3523655832,
-0.1600004733,
-0.1550306529,
0.4808618128,
-0.8276709318,
0.1780043542,
0.3458765745,
-0.1355805844,
-0.7335472107,
0.0602268502,
-0.8094149232,
-1.0081107616,
0.4534877241,
0.0750326365,
-0.1731867194,
-0.0154341981,
0.0087547274,
-0.0353006385,
0.5334264636,
0.1766026616,
-0.6948039532,
0.3417224288,
0.6400101185,
0.9830542803,
-0.2432947159,
-0.0965587124,
-0.553401351,
-0.0278065149,
-0.3502989709,
0.4911367297,
-0.1215489954,
-0.5993952155,
-0.0996469855,
-0.1925697178,
-0.04763069,
-0.4781602025,
0.3560566008,
-0.5372279882,
-0.5599037409,
-0.1713296324,
-0.5539790988,
0.0315628536,
0.6277626753,
-0.6919175386,
0.492683053,
-0.0926694646,
-0.8148100972,
0.082060501,
-0.4605081677,
-0.4238553941,
-0.2311982512,
0.1052004695,
-0.381257534,
0.3043947518,
0.1541352123,
0.4419505,
-0.388039887,
0.3273379803,
-0.5890718102,
-0.4654269814,
0.634272337,
-0.4092134535,
0.8415567279,
0.2745820582,
-0.5836369991,
-0.0597560443,
-0.4889884293,
-0.1351016164,
0.4405393004,
-0.0665890872,
-0.3655592799,
0.1508371979,
-0.191980496,
-0.0244625434,
0.2459104806,
-0.7425835729,
0.3321538866,
-0.2979578078,
0.7777056694,
0.8465210795,
0.1420268714,
0.0787588581,
-0.0419965014,
0.5628228188,
-0.3289690316,
0.4489396513,
-0.0592687018,
-0.1513154507,
-0.0985965803,
-0.189165324,
0.1324055046,
0.8045482635,
-0.0684252605,
0.3957597911,
0.0838726833,
-0.827216506,
-0.2416937053,
0.3028641343,
0.4975577295,
0.2170006782,
0.2846520841,
-0.3534049094,
-0.3027485013,
-0.7154539227,
-0.6668006778,
-0.2210491598,
0.3079029918,
0.2964828908,
0.4098307788,
-0.1950218976,
0.6050817966,
-0.278682977,
0.0569501556,
-0.4081350267,
-0.2570631802,
0.0934197158,
0.3325859904,
0.6682547331,
-0.3055481315,
-0.2137378007,
-0.359787792,
-0.7559829354,
-0.1937872767,
0.032254722,
0.2597168982,
0.0263761617,
0.6700545549,
-0.500377059,
0.3900998533,
0.5059662461,
-0.5154118538,
0.7730829716,
0.0982527882,
0.2116961032,
-0.7752689719,
-0.1343705505,
0.0342523046,
-0.0537664592,
-0.7622899413,
0.3492378592,
0.2238614112,
0.0979957655,
-0.8106245399,
0.4145640433,
-0.3778276145,
-0.3353182673,
-0.2174741775,
0.3120657206,
-0.1395222098,
-0.2001226097,
-0.5834143162,
0.8905005455,
0.298257947,
-0.0650056452,
0.5100725293,
-0.0060295961,
-0.4065012634,
0.3917128742,
-0.91873312,
0.5074807405,
0.1253566295,
0.1632883847,
-1.0890198946,
-0.0745143369,
0.1720093936,
-0.3287445903,
0.1949240565,
-0.2558966577,
-0.5866001248,
-0.2610118985,
-0.7716224194,
0.0526560321,
0.393339783,
-0.4420067668,
0.1891011745,
0.3664900362,
-0.0857193395,
-0.8222646713,
-0.5163491964,
0.615568459,
-0.7175919414,
-0.7426285148,
-0.0455538221,
0.0519932285,
-0.6431357265,
-0.4944915473,
-0.257258743,
0.2342900038,
0.8005738854,
0.2530124187,
0.5349358916,
0.2352779657,
-0.6225453615,
-0.1868249178,
0.2707749307,
0.5137543082,
0.1261796653,
0.6681491733,
-0.1258475184,
-0.3801545203,
-0.2802091241,
0.0555349402,
0.7611441016,
-0.2858885229,
0.7080933452,
0.2427194417,
-0.0830954239,
0.154815957,
-0.7974647284,
-0.0747932866,
-0.4546166062,
0.3496997952,
-0.1916245818,
-1.0429509878,
0.5306999087,
-0.1777185202,
0.2374197096,
-0.1226487458,
0.3359367549,
-0.0639617071,
0.7571533322,
0.3788049221,
-0.5062249899,
0.4647374153,
0.0578856729,
0.2686671317,
-0.8569914103,
-0.1942830086,
-0.6053111553,
-0.1377327144,
-0.5892960429,
-0.188332662,
0.1674588919,
0.4643309414,
-0.324593991,
0.5048307776,
-0.1869214773,
0.500069201,
-0.0393941253,
0.1168712601,
0.2882218361,
-0.186820671,
0.0186803434,
0.1060499698,
-0.2374638617,
-0.5440174937,
1.2831323147,
0.5758277774,
1.0343466997,
0.2256484479,
0.8831962943,
0.430714041,
0.4319132566,
-0.7202308178,
0.6569391489,
-0.0372827426,
-0.5270274282,
-0.0973804966,
-0.3289186954,
-0.8486196399,
0.2271738946,
0.0375528075,
-1.2397259474,
-0.1168173924,
0.0289753936,
-0.3298713863,
0.425096035,
-0.6946746707,
0.7875467539,
-0.5671996474,
-0.4407487512,
-0.1541968882,
-0.7569741607,
0.7241003513,
-0.3733788431,
0.5171012878,
-0.2521072626,
0.1214951351,
0.7454994321,
-0.5017210245,
0.978012979,
-0.386456728,
-0.0979112536,
0.2264760137,
0.2686100006,
0.7416729927,
0.2120157033,
0.1135114506,
0.1124545559,
-0.088381879,
-0.3260757327,
-0.3554232121,
0.6918646693,
-0.6581860185,
-0.8170337081,
-0.301458925,
-0.3652559519,
-0.3727102578,
-0.0059289872,
0.0869375095,
0.1699161083,
-0.2361617833,
0.0288164131,
0.7186732888,
-0.4454089403,
0.4043482542,
0.4756076634,
-0.3140271604,
-0.4997246563,
0.5021603703,
-0.0367287658,
0.5373408794,
-0.0505314171,
0.2046669722,
-0.1517328918,
-0.8181869984,
-0.4162804186,
0.1577432156,
-0.4082885683,
-0.4079589844,
-0.3691724241,
-0.2861573696,
-0.2874665558,
-0.4089492857,
-0.2911986411,
-0.1168263629,
0.2174098641,
-0.4429403543,
0.4790970683,
0.6596389413,
0.0903495252,
0.338460952,
-0.7739133239,
0.2450318038,
0.0691277981,
-0.0779413581,
-0.0457872711,
-0.4033248723,
0.1006768346,
-0.2864789665,
-0.2662543654,
-1.277263999,
0.1257845163,
-0.2418604791,
0.4186758399,
0.3047533333,
0.0710874349,
0.6205914021,
-0.5225136876,
0.7390125394,
0.4537616372,
-0.9918076396,
0.8199427724,
-0.1890308261,
-0.2245658487,
0.7473515272,
0.1504788399,
-0.3805653751,
-0.6283808351,
-0.5255360603,
-0.9578188062,
0.3361981809,
0.0105377883,
0.2991645336,
-0.013696217,
0.4206052423,
-0.1494722366,
0.1485332698,
-0.6916973591,
-0.3890844285,
0.1169843003,
0.1489723027,
0.041098047,
-0.2716315687,
-0.2361789197,
-0.0793474689,
0.1101215705,
0.3685374558,
-0.0848930329,
0.045998387,
-0.3451507986,
0.2140348405,
0.6651391387,
0.5790167451,
0.5806206465,
-0.2626448274,
0.0487231314,
0.2573712766,
-0.899128139,
0.5910176635,
0.0058259806,
-0.2512383759,
-0.3195045888,
0.2929288149,
0.536151588,
0.0630737022,
-0.9647160769,
0.6378929019,
0.001499558,
-0.024888264,
-0.3671605289,
0.1736933142,
-0.0764576718,
0.3126946986,
0.0766031966,
-0.1028035581,
0.0067289779,
-0.563506484,
0.0788667873,
0.7540947795,
-0.3872559965,
-0.1119099334,
0.4833563268,
-0.0031424696,
-0.2284128219,
0.6372343302,
-0.0708316714,
-0.3999070525,
0.797967732,
0.7095289826,
0.8381352425,
-0.2368040979,
0.070851557,
0.0923060849,
0.9719775915,
0.0297318809,
0.126036644,
0.1046295166,
-0.6605712175,
-0.5070755482,
-0.3929411471,
-0.6033056974,
0.2921277285,
-0.7801592946,
0.0082567893,
-0.8629389405,
-0.2868012786,
-0.2219145149,
0.029725777,
-0.1921824068,
-0.2529056072,
0.2275732607,
1.4121729136,
-0.7329115272,
0.6236043572,
0.6315538287,
-0.0393017903,
-0.679451406,
-0.0715490878,
0.3277757168,
-0.8591193557,
0.4088068902,
0.3813250363,
-0.0680274442,
-0.3698282242,
-0.8171815872,
-0.5193247199,
0.9636181593,
0.3328329027,
-0.823587358,
0.084841311,
0.1173752397,
0.0769121647,
-0.0523067005,
0.0581865348,
1.1198288202,
0.5776750445,
-0.257627964,
-0.8112882376,
0.2698830664,
-0.0200982392,
-0.1253192127,
0.5130347013,
-0.5610061884,
0.4100865722,
-0.4892908037,
0.2282586992,
0.1796726733,
0.1811887771,
0.7634871602,
0.4117940664,
0.4582872093,
0.52575773,
0.4856930077,
-0.0972359851,
0.9062469006,
-0.2775257826,
0.1740967184,
0.7828856707,
-0.4719679952,
0.6709947586,
0.6860554218,
-0.2297982574,
0.1160072833,
0.4191981554,
-0.2874700725,
0.4709398448,
0.7795492411,
-0.1390244812,
0.140341714,
0.1934797019,
-0.1425262988,
0.2592615485,
0.5264142752,
-0.1413633078,
-0.2403859198,
0.3822504878,
0.7700207829,
-0.0569015034,
-0.4795886874,
0.7623124123,
0.2582097054,
-0.3828583956,
0.486558795,
0.3120408952,
0.8470848799,
-0.6880531311,
0.3348713219,
-0.4223828912,
-0.1056491807,
-0.2363066375,
-0.8458583355,
0.078757979,
0.6507335305,
0.3051815033,
0.1056327,
0.8060654402,
0.3129844069,
-0.0663516223,
0.5413760543,
0.3700211346,
0.1355257332,
-0.0504934639,
-0.6345674992,
0.5489984751,
-0.0154589312,
-0.3898333013,
0.7244094014,
-0.1824135482,
0.0173462965,
0.5188342333,
0.4898557961,
0.3366144001,
0.2953642309,
-0.0791167542,
0.8403104544,
-0.8716791868,
-0.0970015675,
-1.3313343525,
0.2933096886,
-0.3088555932,
-0.1515752375,
0.8969217539,
0.3033464253,
0.5926042199,
0.3942634761,
0.7565291524,
-0.2344733626,
-0.0149325375,
-0.6643514633,
0.553432703,
-0.1615426689,
0.722420752,
-0.6179788709,
-0.6635335088,
-0.1015253887,
0.368336916,
-0.5281754136,
-0.1963512152,
0.4446169734,
0.6647312641,
0.3418197334,
-0.0034200347,
0.2138135433,
0.180863902,
0.5108669996,
0.4923051298,
1.2177096605,
-0.2355109751,
0.3912516534,
-0.1876746714,
-0.400988847,
-0.0632020384,
-0.7966378927,
-1.1199017763,
0.176663667,
-0.0740201697,
-0.5725314021,
0.4085591435,
0.7283895016,
0.2542870045,
-0.5356557369,
-0.3837991953,
0.1000200063,
0.1212249249,
-0.0875816867,
-0.1826910079,
0.0956853926,
-0.266051203,
-0.1254519969,
0.7503532767,
0.4259069264,
-0.1619705707,
-0.3207424283,
0.1852468848,
0.1054861471,
0.1540815681,
0.6099382043,
0.3177105188,
-0.5683653951,
-0.152580142,
0.1081348434,
-0.2881139517,
-0.0304770153,
0.8493879437,
-0.33956182,
0.052060198,
0.1954580545,
0.8047186732,
0.2064996362,
0.0710736811,
0.2055266201,
-0.5166873336,
0.0491231531,
0.1588482857,
0.5129347444,
0.1599714905,
-0.3009970188,
0.4194574058,
0.0290190969,
-0.5201346874,
-1.1189385653,
0.2674246132,
-0.8008568883,
-0.3541964293,
1.0512635708,
-0.3790674806,
-0.2429177314,
-0.0964671299,
-0.1262618005,
-0.3712243736,
-0.2595833242,
0.7324701548,
0.7036156058,
-0.0187119693,
-0.0311861634,
-0.8653821945,
0.0894607455,
0.1494416595,
-1.0188336372,
0.2644872665,
0.4722231627,
0.4483415782,
0.0567474365,
0.3695787787,
-0.6345422268,
0.2875046134,
-0.3225377798,
-0.2941676974,
-0.0620046519,
-0.2741759121,
-0.5036650896,
0.276571095,
0.3551726937,
0.1218645796
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14579v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14579v1
|
Text Role Classification in Scientific Charts Using Multimodal Transformers
| 2024-02-08T13:21:44 | 2024-02-08T13:21:44 |
Hye Jin Kim, Nicolas Lell, Ansgar Scherp
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Text role classification involves classifying the semantic role of textual
elements within scientific charts. For this task, we propose to finetune two
pretrained multimodal document layout analysis models, LayoutLMv3 and UDOP, on
chart datasets. The transformers utilize the three modalities of text, image,
and layout as input. We further investigate whether data augmentation and
balancing methods help the performance of the models. The models are evaluated
on various chart datasets, and results show that LayoutLMv3 outperforms UDOP in
all experiments. LayoutLMv3 achieves the highest F1-macro score of 82.87 on the
ICPR22 test dataset, beating the best-performing model from the ICPR22
CHART-Infographics challenge. Moreover, the robustness of the models is tested
on a synthetic noisy dataset ICPR22-N. Finally, the generalizability of the
models is evaluated on three chart datasets, CHIME-R, DeGruyter, and EconBiz,
for which we added labels for the text roles. Findings indicate that even in
cases where there is limited training data, transformers can be used with the
help of data augmentation and balancing methods. The source code and datasets
are available on GitHub under
https://github.com/hjkimk/text-role-classification
|
[
-0.1622060686,
-0.1596681625,
0.4178310633,
0.2643393874,
-0.2726274133,
0.1401187479,
-0.0584421046,
-0.6895554066,
-0.1223866045,
0.8220017552,
-0.2817310095,
-0.7334874272,
-0.7154379487,
0.4757961035,
-0.4106814265,
1.1727061272,
-0.17849949,
0.228417173,
-0.5886567235,
-0.124577567,
-0.4974478781,
-0.3801622987,
-0.1512549967,
-0.2004219294,
0.6673436165,
0.4922385514,
0.7179777622,
0.6211019158,
0.5591521859,
0.436549902,
0.2514750957,
0.3929152191,
-0.2243181914,
0.392909497,
0.2425247878,
-0.4164801836,
-0.567291081,
0.3832143247,
0.5601469278,
0.5718083978,
0.3102070093,
-0.1145385131,
-0.0159693621,
0.230966717,
-0.4063495994,
0.946515739,
-0.2303029746,
0.1071079299,
-0.2284583151,
-0.5795968175,
-0.909060359,
-0.0918625966,
0.2749921381,
-1.1053138971,
0.2859082818,
0.2940239906,
0.6465594769,
0.1931737661,
-0.9910649657,
-0.4935815632,
-0.665132761,
0.968501389,
-0.4172811806,
0.5153883696,
0.3694844842,
0.2416797727,
0.2661103308,
-0.978007257,
-0.4035970867,
-0.1192899197,
-0.5992284417,
0.5348379612,
-0.0503560826,
0.2473567873,
0.3000276387,
0.1135211065,
-0.6071360111,
0.3809054494,
-0.7639833093,
-0.299587965,
0.6304862499,
0.1642333567,
0.4316218197,
-0.6239943504,
-0.4027311504,
-0.5422124267,
-0.0370234251,
0.0852674693,
0.3434140682,
0.2611044943,
-0.1646582484,
0.7630195022,
0.3236174285,
0.6685869694,
-0.2177034318,
-0.3514425457,
0.1964248866,
-0.4043803215,
-0.1489609927,
0.1589267105,
0.7525666356,
0.3889293671,
0.1224129349,
0.1778528988,
-0.0410479978,
-0.0770244673,
0.6514303684,
-0.7280956507,
-0.2954154909,
-0.1406785548,
-0.43987602,
-0.4833354652,
0.3135491312,
-0.6991669536,
-0.6118892431,
-0.4810746312,
0.2008463442,
-0.4564309418,
0.1611604095,
-0.1192757264,
-0.2906711996,
-0.193978399,
0.5749253631,
-0.782875061,
0.1626316756,
0.5629959702,
0.8592995405,
-0.1831379831,
-0.2740717232,
-0.3461475968,
0.4300349951,
-0.1632301807,
0.8201473951,
-0.5237013102,
-0.5171300173,
-0.2343239039,
0.1027396619,
-0.5198143125,
-0.1295698583,
0.8167073131,
-0.564012289,
0.7066508532,
0.1418367773,
-0.6103319526,
-0.3201862872,
0.1276407987,
-1.1822246313,
0.7855311036,
0.1568227559,
-1.0815634727,
0.5709533095,
-0.832367897,
-0.450040102,
0.0625095963,
-0.2918518782,
-0.5800340176,
-0.3316731155,
0.2431596518,
0.6092351675,
-0.0069036698,
-0.056093514,
-0.1859933287,
-0.0868964121,
0.3190484047,
-0.3690936565,
0.5242397785,
0.2551044822,
-0.0371981412,
0.3269598782,
-0.7459819317,
-0.103286922,
-0.246829018,
-0.2660029829,
-0.6431379318,
0.1467850655,
0.6604655981,
0.1738813519,
-0.1819120347,
-0.3592566252,
0.5358948708,
-0.1893229634,
0.344173342,
0.5692018867,
-0.1017053276,
0.5015850067,
-0.0857055038,
0.5774060488,
-0.0714030191,
0.1764820367,
-0.1755785197,
-0.6939572692,
-0.3492898643,
-0.6773594022,
0.567789495,
0.5407966375,
-0.7311676145,
0.4598014653,
-0.6134490967,
-0.6429030299,
-0.044577904,
0.0930613801,
0.0938810334,
0.666936934,
0.5796481371,
-0.2534390688,
-0.55685848,
-0.7586991191,
0.2011126578,
-0.1841935217,
-0.0208335426,
-0.0221404992,
0.3108080626,
-0.4267038703,
0.8013595939,
-0.5385688543,
-0.5405936241,
-0.3646198213,
0.5652633905,
-0.0897873193,
0.2866981626,
0.8165986538,
-1.0981395245,
-0.4514094293,
0.1634664685,
-0.7374584675,
-0.3606939614,
-0.1449379623,
0.0678430051,
0.1186510473,
0.6268634796,
-0.7568938732,
0.5491205454,
0.6895953417,
-0.4705725908,
0.3692914248,
-0.1971776783,
0.2193683684,
-0.9924277663,
0.0571504273,
0.1869423985,
-0.2758800983,
-0.8145417571,
-0.2698992193,
0.2368098646,
-0.3036650717,
0.0538540892,
0.470286876,
-0.3582785428,
-0.0248869266,
-0.3178980947,
-0.0023894492,
0.3352477551,
0.0174464267,
0.1451729834,
0.5129441023,
0.2420749664,
-0.421382308,
0.1344249994,
0.4350795746,
-0.3997634053,
0.3580287397,
-0.3199672401,
-0.2764419317,
-0.1551335156,
0.7011271715,
-1.3697232008,
-0.4166411757,
0.0301815812,
-0.3133603632,
0.5904389024,
-0.0401175916,
-0.7646966577,
-0.3202682436,
-0.3460259438,
0.3597153425,
0.015251467,
-0.2307338715,
0.7139596343,
0.1765446365,
-0.2568871379,
-0.5773236156,
-0.4974699914,
-0.3501398265,
-0.2912304699,
-0.797038734,
0.6319952011,
0.1911123395,
0.0275306217,
-0.2108098567,
-0.3622365892,
-0.0899602845,
-0.0729484111,
0.4279232025,
0.5554491878,
0.1643163115,
0.2483456582,
0.102528736,
-0.4276266992,
-0.2170017213,
0.0098640658,
0.3989487886,
0.1095600352,
-0.4077542722,
-0.3913053572,
0.1245093867,
0.9824410081,
-0.1349624991,
0.4835719764,
0.8511123657,
-0.0661302954,
0.2294176221,
-0.2395868152,
-0.0013670763,
-0.4445947707,
0.3608715236,
0.1232578903,
-0.537770927,
0.3246402442,
0.276402235,
0.3393341601,
0.6526412964,
0.1925318241,
-0.4269978106,
1.2770026922,
0.7058200836,
0.1292786151,
0.4915022254,
-0.4284288883,
0.1424716711,
-0.5543453097,
-0.2331870943,
-0.55777812,
-0.4242413938,
-0.6645051837,
-0.5142354965,
0.7430287004,
0.0243819281,
-0.0834385976,
0.2534562051,
-0.5507977009,
0.0723716095,
0.3239841759,
-0.1286664903,
0.4290075898,
0.1401272118,
0.1084158272,
-0.3648538589,
-0.5092044473,
-0.7402925491,
1.0665783882,
0.3154737949,
0.9029160738,
-0.0699838698,
0.351556778,
0.3608327806,
0.5274883509,
-0.7763544321,
0.2417459041,
-0.2772975564,
-0.456677258,
-0.4454960525,
-0.3491897285,
-1.0121661425,
0.4257744551,
-0.3886554837,
-0.3433281481,
0.1727666557,
0.0997985601,
-0.0467090867,
0.1017845869,
-1.0982766151,
0.9314193726,
-0.5175147653,
0.0551718138,
-0.0958755463,
-0.6157646179,
0.0866658837,
-0.1146886721,
0.5442771316,
0.1627045125,
0.0165704358,
0.8249441385,
-0.2413516939,
1.0054302216,
-0.2302349061,
-0.1621571183,
0.022653129,
-0.0841054842,
0.2525803447,
0.1777449399,
-0.0896651968,
-0.0994370654,
0.3966681957,
-0.3250891566,
-0.6479756236,
0.5850337148,
-1.0737556219,
-0.2494644225,
-0.6157755256,
-0.6624820828,
-0.2140085995,
0.4000296295,
0.3182806373,
0.3847746849,
0.1668385118,
0.6996105909,
0.2645103335,
-0.0301012788,
0.2908812761,
0.3395512104,
-0.249033317,
-0.3460424244,
0.6490406394,
0.2538684607,
0.1586586833,
0.4484180808,
0.0989760682,
-0.5316668749,
-0.3815387487,
-0.143125236,
-0.0462605357,
-0.9426252246,
-0.4248951674,
-0.7766085863,
-0.32306391,
-0.5350526571,
-0.0846130922,
-0.0073222225,
-0.5375310183,
-0.5676085949,
-0.2939612567,
0.5096824765,
0.5426880121,
0.1734420955,
0.4930476844,
-0.8187946081,
0.2592589557,
0.3097740114,
0.1811612099,
-0.1318101585,
-0.2111387104,
-0.2634399235,
-0.2208583057,
-0.9235205054,
-0.9284428954,
0.3954975605,
0.0858425424,
0.6591624618,
0.5080881119,
-0.1333466917,
0.520414114,
-0.2595214844,
0.5148360133,
0.2977685332,
-0.8174598813,
0.1403272301,
-0.4323559701,
0.0689052269,
0.388555795,
0.4873299301,
-0.5583667159,
-0.3962079883,
-0.2914324701,
-0.830272615,
0.8889769316,
0.4740476012,
-0.1077171043,
0.3082225621,
0.0210311264,
0.308586508,
0.0962552652,
-1.0880182981,
0.1213520095,
-0.7664419413,
-0.5473374724,
-0.2441366762,
0.0632949397,
-0.1348989308,
-0.6246106625,
0.3266102672,
-0.4517781734,
0.0962473378,
0.2588587701,
-0.3151918352,
-0.1106133163,
0.3540735245,
0.6909270883,
0.7565871477,
-0.101915203,
0.2671789527,
-0.1935792118,
-0.7451479435,
-0.0242459141,
0.4601870775,
0.0437515154,
-0.0868945643,
0.9548014402,
0.815595448,
0.5000768304,
-0.5410030484,
0.3851704001,
-0.0513667092,
-0.1807644069,
-0.1160983071,
0.1583009958,
-0.091154553,
0.0985244215,
0.4754284918,
0.1214469299,
0.2020148635,
-0.3392840028,
0.0710130706,
0.1932484359,
-0.3911874592,
-0.4025896788,
0.5753182173,
0.081652455,
0.1324429363,
0.5776491165,
0.2865467966,
-0.4199889898,
0.673227489,
0.4396183789,
0.378715992,
-0.1753564775,
0.5637207031,
0.0025649935,
0.3054650426,
0.2265252918,
-0.0534119084,
0.2161292434,
-0.5897903442,
-0.5781770945,
-0.3659926653,
-0.4733063877,
0.2054122537,
-0.536290586,
0.5402729511,
-0.207150504,
-0.224146232,
0.5630204678,
0.0123551041,
-0.6735646725,
0.1617279947,
0.1195278764,
0.5172381997,
-0.8679745793,
0.6179495454,
0.9935677648,
-0.2297103256,
-0.33144328,
-0.1188417375,
0.1192496642,
-0.4113953412,
0.7846513391,
0.5294189453,
0.0876950622,
-0.073972255,
-0.6199859977,
-0.7008296847,
1.4339356422,
-0.07830026,
-0.1700078994,
-0.2206814587,
0.1723862737,
0.8592419624,
-0.4145127237,
0.5059440136,
-0.0246750675,
0.8067641258,
-0.0675995126,
-0.9336935282,
-0.2970592082,
-0.2217423469,
-0.1326106191,
-0.0206896551,
-0.4387827516,
0.8904508948,
0.22282435,
-0.2178585976,
-0.1153195128,
0.5883201361,
0.3622535467,
0.4332954586,
0.7571348548,
0.1349768192,
0.7554953694,
-0.1447035372,
1.0963944197,
-0.1218636855,
0.4073459208,
0.6660165787,
-0.4271383584,
0.2659412622,
0.3506600559,
0.145317629,
0.7108553052,
0.5632523894,
-0.2214338928,
0.5529314876,
-0.2211441398,
0.2584299445,
-0.1972811818,
0.2050528228,
-0.3494594097,
0.6269074082,
0.5107972026,
-0.4649101496,
-0.3088762164,
0.3155467212,
-0.2170825899,
-0.0380373597,
-0.0151770599,
0.4811941385,
-0.0546140708,
-0.2920175195,
0.1365634054,
0.2078086287,
0.3602561653,
-0.6496523023,
0.0070834523,
0.0770553797,
0.1882915497,
-0.3470941186,
-0.8659960032,
0.1602786481,
-0.1508281678,
-0.4409528375,
-0.5519160628,
0.7412071228,
-0.2688370347,
-0.6094928384,
0.1659064889,
0.1549414694,
-0.3729191422,
0.2336972058,
-0.4460187256,
-0.0241137408,
-0.2377570271,
-0.1240038723,
0.2604931891,
0.3290880919,
-0.6311366558,
0.6101117134,
0.5512410402,
-0.3587685525,
0.0489685573,
0.1702495366,
0.7119283676,
-0.5291184187,
-0.6732975841,
-0.3763872385,
0.4975417256,
-0.3748743832,
-0.1444950998,
1.002850771,
0.8091566563,
0.6599538922,
-0.3291957378,
0.7498366833,
0.0802164823,
0.3682075441,
-0.5641362667,
0.8722833395,
-0.5151950717,
0.1032234728,
-0.7142888904,
-0.7653722167,
-0.5659866333,
0.4992871583,
-0.483243227,
-0.1166904718,
0.7376499176,
0.2926744819,
-0.5032394528,
0.3927389681,
-0.1396674365,
0.0044549238,
0.683529079,
-0.0671121702,
0.8965712786,
-0.3030532002,
0.6314801574,
-0.3343249261,
-0.1870186627,
-0.3082334995,
-0.695686996,
-0.9271255732,
-0.7560132742,
-0.2597224414,
0.017543193,
-0.7882507443,
0.6914785504,
0.9328365922,
-0.6813501716,
-0.2149576545,
0.1932639033,
0.0907273293,
-0.1878073066,
-0.3163576722,
0.4665846229,
-0.2346153408,
-0.6770545244,
0.3244543672,
0.2432284504,
0.349901408,
-0.0828535631,
0.1142908409,
-0.0297121666,
-0.1959928572,
0.8658704758,
0.0884507746,
-0.5983410478,
-0.2188498974,
0.1219232008,
-0.2064612061,
0.0562519319,
1.1670657396,
-0.3181610703,
0.6502232552,
0.6410693526,
0.2295094728,
0.5878486633,
0.2272796929,
0.3784651756,
-1.0229959488,
0.3527680933,
0.2739706039,
0.3026516736,
0.2468574792,
-0.4194323123,
0.3797565103,
0.1692299545,
-0.5012781024,
-0.9185448289,
-0.1146191806,
-1.3185863495,
-0.2489832342,
0.8810767531,
0.2535537779,
0.1168377399,
-0.2148181796,
-0.4363835156,
0.3737799525,
-0.10800495,
0.7303969264,
0.9101646543,
-0.4297351539,
-0.1593170464,
-0.6900106072,
0.440096736,
0.0601916201,
-1.0403914452,
-0.0399658084,
0.721136272,
0.0627584085,
0.7319168448,
0.3723197877,
-0.265758872,
0.0739429146,
-0.4988029301,
0.0256650113,
-0.1346444637,
-0.5125879049,
0.1912513524,
0.1562464833,
-0.200208649,
0.1717388332
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10943v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10943v1
|
Advances and Limitations in Open Source Arabic-Script OCR: A Case Study
| 2024-02-08T12:51:36 | 2024-02-08T12:51:36 |
Benjamin Kiessling, Gennady Kurin, Matthew Thomas Miller, Kader Smail
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
This work presents an accuracy study of the open source OCR engine, Kraken,
on the leading Arabic scholarly journal, al-Abhath. In contrast with other
commercially available OCR engines, Kraken is shown to be capable of producing
highly accurate Arabic-script OCR. The study also assesses the relative
accuracy of typeface-specific and generalized models on the al-Abhath data and
provides a microanalysis of the ``error instances'' and the contextual features
that may have contributed to OCR misrecognition. Building on this analysis, the
paper argues that Arabic-script OCR can be significantly improved through (1) a
more systematic approach to training data production, and (2) the development
of key technological components, especially multi-language models and improved
line segmentation and layout analysis.
Cet article pr{\'e}sente une {\'e}tude d'exactitude du moteur ROC open
source, Krakan, sur la revue acad{\'e}mique arabe de premier rang, al-Abhath.
Contrairement {\`a} d'autres moteurs ROC disponibles sur le march{\'e}, Kraken
se r{\'e}v{\`e}le {\^e}tre capable de produire de la ROC extr{\^e}mement exacte
de l'{\'e}criture arabe. L'{\'e}tude {\'e}value aussi l'exactitude relative des
mod{\`e}les sp{\'e}cifiquement configur{\'e}s {\`a} des polices et celle des
mod{\`e}les g{\'e}n{\'e}ralis{\'e}s sur les donn{\'e}es d'al-Abhath et fournit
une microanalyse des "occurrences d'erreurs", ainsi qu'une microanalyse des
{\'e}l{\'e}ments contextuels qui pourraient avoir contribu{\'e} {\`a} la
m{\'e}reconnaissance ROC. S'appuyant sur cette analyse, cet article fait valoir
que la ROC de l'{\'e}criture arabe peut {\^e}tre consid{\'e}rablement
am{\'e}lior{\'e}e gr{\^a}ce {\`a} (1) une approche plus syst{\'e}matique
d'entra{\^i}nement de la production de donn{\'e}es et (2) gr{\^a}ce au
d{\'e}veloppement de composants technologiques fondamentaux,
notammentl'am{\'e}lioration des mod{\`e}les multilingues, de la segmentation de
ligne et de l'analyse de la mise en page.
|
[
-0.3746953309,
-0.4843450487,
0.5496076345,
-0.2410755306,
-0.1575532109,
0.2238550186,
-0.2908537686,
-0.8003879189,
0.3513053954,
0.3714767992,
-0.0736109838,
-0.8823920488,
-0.509079814,
0.1226938739,
-0.4600691199,
0.9029265046,
-0.4802120924,
0.1003399193,
0.4832717776,
-0.7806046605,
-0.3139028549,
-0.5063915849,
-0.5033288598,
0.3738549352,
0.5984811783,
0.566511631,
0.7488928437,
0.7618466616,
0.688863337,
0.2724006772,
0.1405631453,
0.176653564,
-0.2057963908,
0.1134869978,
-0.0221406948,
-0.2522366643,
-0.2987653017,
-0.0879559368,
0.6375139356,
0.4347490072,
0.0318545401,
0.1936533749,
-0.0469781794,
0.8697271347,
-0.841717422,
0.0955491364,
-0.214163661,
-0.2205971479,
-0.2329512537,
0.2247089595,
-0.3132231534,
-0.6494457722,
-0.0111475447,
-0.5735225677,
0.3021364212,
-0.0352289453,
1.1001466513,
0.1298125982,
-0.1624399871,
-0.8869571686,
-0.9287517071,
0.9963525534,
-0.592233181,
0.3492266238,
0.3519968987,
0.7218883634,
-0.0362909324,
-0.9483946562,
-0.7123171091,
-0.2826110423,
0.1298208088,
0.2137861699,
-0.1204693615,
-0.2548020184,
0.1133936718,
0.4867060781,
-0.3340989351,
-0.0057464666,
-0.4489079714,
-0.4023534954,
0.4908863306,
0.0184750352,
0.2986218035,
0.2830529213,
-0.071421355,
-0.4345175624,
-0.5280153155,
0.2264820784,
0.4761009812,
0.2065788209,
-0.1654779166,
0.899456203,
-0.1225775629,
0.4599475265,
-0.2785834372,
-0.1267609149,
0.2956646085,
-0.3484928906,
0.0233879201,
0.403323859,
0.7214916348,
0.4646130204,
0.3243415952,
0.2691933215,
-0.1697059274,
0.163807556,
0.4647550881,
-0.903061986,
-0.3040534854,
0.3747190833,
-0.4917130172,
-0.2104006559,
0.489906162,
-0.8470191956,
-0.185051769,
0.0521324575,
0.396199137,
-0.5673443079,
-0.0851177871,
0.1166629791,
-0.2378718257,
0.275282681,
0.6227180958,
-0.5255707502,
-0.0779396594,
0.3160851896,
1.1026991606,
0.2415294945,
-0.2388281226,
-0.3243053257,
0.0387335904,
-0.5882505178,
0.7674997449,
-0.4835647941,
-0.4358194172,
0.2093297839,
-0.021395741,
0.0473146737,
-0.2842290401,
0.820227921,
-0.6926954389,
0.0538620129,
-0.144932732,
-0.3613861501,
-0.6082623601,
-0.0622880496,
-0.7880119681,
0.9893954992,
0.0754466802,
-0.8779867291,
0.386259824,
-0.8345544934,
-0.2548485398,
-0.0304133072,
-0.5696219206,
-0.5302317142,
-0.1350473911,
0.2990735173,
-0.041433651,
-0.1573661864,
-0.3834445179,
-0.284576267,
-0.4378223419,
0.4351679385,
-0.2288024127,
0.8630684614,
0.4290638566,
-0.4971709847,
-0.072831504,
-0.9350953102,
0.1186702773,
0.160889253,
-0.4916658998,
-0.3760997057,
-0.0232414231,
0.1276154667,
-0.0535736829,
0.3912439346,
-1.0699834824,
0.1580545753,
-0.3478218615,
0.3967407644,
0.5728068352,
0.1371675134,
0.3682428002,
-0.5926367044,
0.2891279459,
-0.1848871857,
0.1152084246,
-0.180289641,
-0.5859286189,
-0.6485191584,
-0.5293963552,
0.6062545776,
0.6962653399,
-0.8124072552,
0.4742152691,
-0.3231571019,
-0.8908333778,
-0.7918112278,
-0.1841387898,
0.3955694437,
0.274341315,
0.4408374131,
-0.5429404378,
-0.4416920841,
-0.8851071596,
-0.5332188606,
-0.0795646906,
-0.0006336353,
0.321555078,
0.7026562095,
-0.1547632068,
0.9870877266,
-0.4777801931,
-0.439111352,
-0.0567199364,
0.1239640564,
0.3962139785,
0.676841855,
0.9203386903,
-0.7042184472,
-0.9407280684,
0.3926016986,
-0.6965138912,
-0.027099641,
0.3897250593,
-0.0917386487,
0.5652435422,
0.3482189775,
-0.342163682,
1.0160330534,
0.3263579011,
-0.1449689269,
0.6884302497,
-0.4097489119,
0.5454851389,
-0.9417414069,
0.2705107927,
-0.050491441,
0.0708389357,
-0.6437629461,
0.3654685318,
0.16991207,
0.0500500798,
-0.5136651993,
0.4619867504,
-0.3075759411,
0.1220948324,
-0.1387972534,
0.0117478026,
-0.0818132609,
0.3798307478,
-0.1268171519,
0.8988079429,
0.2546708286,
-0.3595371246,
0.1112969071,
0.3404708803,
-0.9063857198,
0.5467371941,
-0.547826767,
0.1688993424,
-0.2197975218,
0.03392471,
-1.2224190235,
-0.3721903861,
0.7029004097,
-0.6399093866,
0.0443256944,
-0.0765728429,
-0.4680784941,
-0.1799713671,
-0.3423169553,
0.6800068617,
0.571274817,
-0.3595798612,
0.5641387701,
0.2022996396,
-0.2100450695,
-0.8046060205,
-0.8619773984,
-0.0369628333,
0.0813199058,
-0.60874933,
-0.0487305708,
-0.046602305,
-0.445612371,
0.1835250109,
-0.1714325994,
-0.4082277417,
-0.1919594258,
0.1635867208,
0.2515100539,
-0.4019548297,
-0.1596809179,
0.1715951711,
-0.0012549327,
-0.2116642296,
-0.1417037994,
0.4674445987,
0.1012235135,
-0.7274698019,
-0.5414307714,
0.4302760959,
0.8359234929,
-0.3130466342,
0.7435173988,
0.8207541704,
-0.2522772551,
0.0857263505,
-0.7445735931,
0.1473349631,
-0.492736727,
0.2613590062,
-0.3133429289,
-0.8285862803,
0.7494445443,
0.3019970953,
0.3730093241,
1.0448362827,
0.3347536027,
-0.1892312318,
1.1006934643,
0.3747089803,
-0.0787142962,
0.4786507189,
-0.4648192823,
0.238966018,
-0.5073096156,
-0.3400588334,
-1.0925931931,
-0.3282039165,
-0.5473807454,
-0.3641594052,
0.5890610218,
-0.0853718594,
-0.342435807,
0.0665945038,
-0.5006600022,
0.6003082991,
0.6377360821,
0.2478558719,
0.2606879771,
0.3564915955,
-0.2913320363,
-0.1065862924,
-0.7140001059,
-0.6794649363,
1.2311593294,
0.3971062005,
0.7141343355,
0.3577893078,
0.531527102,
0.6354623437,
0.1360468417,
-0.7469807267,
0.3205406368,
-0.1951619983,
-0.6216709614,
-0.4972886443,
-0.2305601686,
-1.0129121542,
0.0645555481,
0.0234048627,
-0.8141414523,
0.5841721296,
-0.1245941222,
-0.4371044338,
0.4759311676,
-0.5193920135,
0.8739823699,
-0.0153898206,
-0.2858181,
-0.3670237362,
-0.6218317747,
-0.0078594219,
-0.1195949763,
0.5346367955,
-0.0243167896,
-0.1239585355,
0.8026576042,
-0.8431581259,
0.7432466149,
-0.3365975022,
-0.166827932,
0.8612191677,
0.3049185872,
0.5824775696,
-0.2942153513,
-0.2038669586,
0.4962635636,
0.1089884266,
-0.6582974792,
-0.3143462539,
0.5662787557,
-0.9947116375,
-0.1869095117,
-0.6638561487,
-0.3994241953,
0.4247663617,
0.4288577735,
0.4096518755,
0.8555386662,
-0.2858717144,
0.1812017858,
0.2310420722,
-0.2980057895,
0.4558808208,
0.5633261204,
-0.2433823049,
-0.7229204774,
0.9831790924,
0.395881176,
0.044630833,
0.2580267787,
-0.0670633465,
-0.4467318356,
-0.7330861092,
-0.9374457598,
0.141089499,
-1.0512865782,
-0.019991124,
-0.5870603323,
-0.2575522065,
-0.2701400816,
-0.3102648854,
-0.2694874704,
-0.4459316134,
-0.1683350652,
0.1473187208,
0.5236233473,
1.1015200615,
-0.1262994111,
0.3386361301,
-0.864782691,
0.0109725362,
0.0028479127,
0.2341228575,
0.0916072503,
-0.5867449641,
-0.7917767167,
0.4220671356,
-0.2692409456,
-0.8315088749,
0.2425452024,
-0.0483886637,
0.3982117474,
0.2829725742,
0.1095197424,
0.3667820096,
-0.3893468082,
0.9799947739,
0.0848693624,
-0.9155775905,
0.3962981999,
-0.3756432533,
0.2762394249,
0.9136456847,
0.6078121662,
-0.4702009559,
-0.4893428385,
-0.472317785,
-0.7625486255,
0.8770509362,
0.5071210265,
-0.4229278266,
0.0332282409,
0.2920538187,
0.3124414384,
0.1600586176,
-0.2024465501,
-0.3628837466,
-0.2915792763,
-0.2760648727,
-0.2561655641,
-0.2552942634,
0.0165768974,
-0.25872311,
0.7624374628,
0.2779623866,
0.2616943717,
0.7338941693,
-0.2979545295,
-0.0895458087,
0.1335255057,
0.8636847734,
0.6580690742,
-0.5019947886,
0.0422972776,
0.2043758333,
-0.9365745187,
0.3256431818,
-0.0812790245,
-0.28608796,
0.253998071,
0.3894227147,
0.4496053457,
-0.0847246721,
-0.6122291684,
0.6416350007,
0.0382246785,
-0.4017024934,
-0.6937167048,
-0.1673585474,
-0.6095628142,
0.3470931351,
0.5752817988,
0.3960138857,
0.1692836583,
-0.4036900103,
-0.0581061691,
0.2278129458,
-0.4233794808,
-0.0635613874,
0.6647434831,
-0.0148116639,
-0.3946768939,
0.5255648494,
-0.3635658026,
-0.4711734951,
0.7144911289,
0.2804300487,
0.7822633386,
-0.5018835664,
0.0868109763,
0.6721999049,
0.519274056,
-0.0192188919,
0.5750306249,
0.0456343293,
-0.7124339342,
-0.5105420947,
-0.545230031,
-0.6269020438,
-0.0231672879,
-0.6678669453,
0.1356179714,
-0.5334974527,
-0.0939000621,
0.0466043241,
-0.1464598626,
-0.6795917749,
0.052546721,
-0.2353388071,
1.0582280159,
-0.6025084853,
0.7043247223,
0.9127189517,
-0.6103067398,
-0.5400602818,
-0.0511229225,
-0.3445792198,
-1.0322099924,
0.4906923473,
0.147570774,
-0.2878569067,
0.0059349411,
-0.4574888051,
-1.0259034634,
0.9797255993,
0.0720876604,
-0.6263952851,
0.2447255254,
0.2920013964,
0.4700041115,
-0.2302488685,
0.3575309217,
0.4367185533,
0.7702068686,
-0.0186143648,
-1.1321940422,
0.2541512847,
-0.2338637114,
-0.1857321858,
0.4889600575,
-0.6505630016,
0.9438455701,
-0.0868946239,
-0.4853072762,
0.399554342,
0.435385704,
-0.3285855353,
0.4395494759,
0.3452317715,
0.6392928362,
0.4888356924,
0.0562605597,
1.034250617,
-0.4493985176,
0.3060125411,
0.7512819767,
-0.1790309995,
0.9408977032,
0.2399621755,
-0.3267459869,
0.9896619916,
0.3121771812,
0.0656917393,
0.5385554433,
-0.078946501,
-0.5070443153,
0.0928335562,
-0.0365131609,
-0.4571871758,
0.524915874,
0.3641844392,
-0.4513067305,
-0.3016492724,
-0.0700236484,
-0.1041966826,
0.1210806072,
-0.5331030488,
0.6105993986,
-0.0921833292,
-0.4112722278,
0.6816270947,
0.2418545485,
0.1680661738,
-0.5833191276,
0.0325129591,
0.0558787286,
0.262324512,
-0.2274538279,
-0.6785027385,
0.3599682748,
0.0029794977,
-0.0007302013,
0.3083561361,
0.8304044604,
-0.2921032608,
-0.5451394916,
0.1522913724,
0.5463647842,
0.4938570857,
-0.1862924695,
-0.4115894437,
0.3962463737,
0.0635836869,
0.0267295782,
0.1333552599,
0.2395792454,
0.0773570314,
0.1349001527,
0.5573067665,
0.0952862799,
-0.0223871227,
-0.2401772738,
0.6854060888,
-0.6840173602,
-0.5337765217,
-0.8999606371,
0.5767616034,
-0.0243331157,
-0.0858077109,
0.7913182974,
0.7916889787,
0.9037446976,
-0.1836257279,
1.1130512953,
-0.0209090896,
0.59926337,
-0.4204845726,
0.7080938816,
-0.5089088678,
-0.1684304923,
-0.1703507453,
-1.0772525072,
-0.3077685833,
0.8239377737,
-0.458045423,
-0.0241053309,
0.8428077102,
0.8249848485,
-0.1411243081,
0.2162622064,
0.1128850803,
0.2542795539,
0.2293560505,
0.3115748167,
1.0119793415,
-0.6028975248,
0.7223709226,
-0.4089432657,
-0.3121374249,
-0.5562397242,
-0.7419437766,
-0.8678926229,
-0.5769077539,
-0.2165616304,
-0.6102249622,
0.04837,
1.075840354,
0.1488387138,
-1.0948264599,
-0.4275225997,
-0.0207679402,
-0.1107187048,
-0.3296824694,
-0.2404814512,
0.5434055328,
-0.0230795201,
-0.651181221,
0.2926030159,
0.2163011879,
0.3509294391,
-0.0561066754,
0.0248463042,
-0.0248634499,
0.1075446606,
0.4627616405,
0.4978919029,
-0.5860049725,
-0.7104594111,
-0.3141682446,
-0.2568406761,
0.193037197,
0.7664321065,
-0.3001146019,
0.4383660555,
0.2823527753,
0.6740778089,
0.6331914067,
-0.2456784993,
0.2692014277,
-0.4947987199,
0.2224729955,
0.2569822669,
0.2826462686,
-0.0678422824,
-0.1310964972,
0.5084862113,
0.1869254112,
-0.9350041151,
-0.7517906427,
0.3270821869,
-0.8828718662,
-0.2758108675,
0.8994145989,
-0.2517704964,
-0.3390515149,
-0.4750320315,
-0.686332643,
0.3879475594,
-0.8054492474,
0.814455986,
0.8060460091,
0.0529798977,
0.3224391043,
-0.6404142976,
0.3461027741,
0.3466573358,
-0.2560263276,
-0.1990144551,
0.5838648081,
0.1449478865,
0.5354414582,
0.6691789031,
-0.0728313848,
0.5640659332,
0.3470938206,
0.4828287065,
-0.0352208912,
-0.3077856302,
-0.4171275496,
0.2113713771,
0.2960705459,
-0.5494742393
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05629v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05629v4
|
Merging Facts, Crafting Fallacies: Evaluating the Contradictory Nature of Aggregated Factual Claims in Long-Form Generations
| 2024-02-08T12:36:29 | 2024-06-07T02:28:40 |
Cheng-Han Chiang, Hung-yi Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Long-form generations from large language models (LLMs) contain a mix of
factual and non-factual claims, making evaluating factuality difficult. Prior
works evaluate the factuality of a long paragraph by decomposing it into
multiple facts, verifying those facts independently, and aggregating the
results. Such methods assume that combining factual claims forms a factual
paragraph. The above assumption can be violated: we show that strong
open-source models like Llama-chat can generate paragraphs that contain
verifiable facts, but the facts are combined into a non-factual paragraph due
to entity ambiguity. We further reveal that existing factuality metrics,
including FActScore and citation recall, cannot properly evaluate these
non-factual paragraphs and overestimate their factuality. To address this, we
introduce an enhanced metric, D-FActScore, specifically designed for content
with ambiguous entities. We evaluate the D-FActScores of people biographies
generated by retrieval-augmented LLMs. We show that D-FActScore can better
assess the factuality of paragraphs with entity ambiguity than FActScore. We
also find that four widely used open-source LLMs tend to mix information of
distinct entities to form non-factual paragraphs, making their D-FActScore much
lower than FActScore by over 10%.
|
[
-0.3876671195,
-0.9334877729,
0.9103577733,
0.2671046853,
-0.2203298956,
0.5479516387,
-0.237205714,
-0.6557549834,
0.0992808715,
0.4066280723,
-0.4504609108,
-0.4328097999,
-0.6630218029,
0.0434761569,
-0.4331947565,
1.0763745308,
0.0748515353,
-0.4042421579,
-0.7287060618,
-0.3049877584,
-0.1929408759,
-0.4108011425,
-0.1557228714,
-0.2915449142,
0.4468157589,
0.4322172403,
0.9306966066,
0.5276159644,
0.3401959836,
0.3462519646,
-0.2814589739,
0.678866148,
-0.722099185,
0.0867381915,
-0.2709237039,
-0.503872335,
-0.4236556292,
0.1822154373,
0.6221714616,
0.7898646593,
-0.1417895108,
0.4078148305,
-0.0287660398,
0.6286594868,
-0.633092165,
0.096175842,
-0.5428608656,
-0.0751756132,
-0.2884075642,
-0.1805373877,
-0.4415179193,
-0.7313885093,
0.1941395402,
-0.1391348541,
0.3007805347,
0.2098625004,
0.71661973,
0.221857205,
-0.4420324564,
-0.4660809934,
-0.8968997598,
0.9734156132,
-0.8210896254,
0.5647327304,
0.0298670232,
-0.0489270687,
-0.3095296323,
-0.5500016212,
-0.8961427212,
-0.4602635801,
-0.2103010863,
0.0478789993,
-0.4417008758,
0.0264087655,
0.4830711782,
0.6443070173,
-0.5361993313,
0.2213664204,
-0.6118061543,
-0.2417228967,
0.7355234623,
0.1596516222,
0.3728828132,
-0.4196789563,
-0.7932087779,
0.0862926543,
-0.8956148624,
-0.2006659359,
0.5982764363,
0.0525614396,
-0.0433049873,
0.91636765,
-0.0811001062,
0.4811371565,
0.1831238866,
-0.6863912344,
0.2878119648,
-0.4255751371,
-0.1581570655,
0.3589300811,
0.7273619175,
0.6330192089,
-0.2985113859,
-0.3614836335,
0.0895195678,
0.2265099734,
0.0563243032,
-0.4612517357,
0.1827940345,
0.4146545827,
-0.3473323584,
-0.1806296706,
-0.0056846836,
-1.0171216726,
-0.4795072377,
-0.4346306324,
0.1088210046,
-0.4238847494,
-0.0795426369,
0.0629175305,
-0.4121214449,
0.0581775159,
0.4016655087,
-0.4901682138,
0.188461259,
0.7359898686,
0.8416617513,
-0.3259863853,
-0.3862076402,
-0.277700454,
0.1749607772,
-0.2671945989,
0.9045937657,
-0.4116326869,
-0.5182392597,
-0.005970004,
-0.2488589287,
0.1046482325,
-0.6483543515,
0.8751043677,
-0.5149701834,
0.5780041814,
-0.3361725509,
-0.6931657791,
-0.1246596202,
0.2793020606,
-0.7207890153,
1.3296769857,
0.2029767632,
-0.8872190714,
0.5910658836,
-0.2346904576,
-0.3755322397,
-0.0034675607,
-0.2641819417,
-0.4708766937,
0.192555517,
-0.1246831417,
0.1929834187,
-0.6061241627,
0.581867516,
-0.3728946149,
-0.2317666709,
0.3175805807,
-0.5611799955,
0.790995717,
0.1990489066,
-0.3910723329,
-0.2706443071,
-0.9063962102,
-0.2513276637,
0.0265597831,
-0.7375222445,
-0.3187795281,
0.267701894,
-0.3711919487,
0.1424083114,
0.3599749207,
-0.6379554272,
0.0915981233,
-0.1840812564,
0.1700530052,
0.560539484,
-0.0106640067,
0.2532144785,
-0.8095300198,
0.1536017805,
0.3464961648,
-0.0234701,
0.0499173664,
-0.3998667896,
-0.8647681475,
-0.1498218328,
0.0694782734,
0.552975893,
-0.7105593085,
0.726328671,
-0.631657362,
-0.709332943,
-0.1969957501,
0.2141871899,
0.1382457316,
0.8718819022,
0.459431231,
-0.0996489972,
-0.8004280925,
-0.8928970695,
-0.3862289786,
-0.7426778078,
0.0876257718,
0.0315383449,
0.4038385749,
-0.0108703235,
1.1165744066,
-0.6385774612,
0.2131258845,
-0.0671616644,
0.3520210981,
0.1357629448,
0.2491867542,
0.5022450089,
-0.6284986138,
-0.172221601,
-0.3620927632,
-0.7802926302,
0.1063964963,
-0.2453007698,
0.2317074388,
0.2828572989,
0.2834039927,
-1.027187109,
0.1382413656,
0.4845514894,
-0.2383028716,
0.7409481406,
-0.0665997118,
0.3280662298,
-0.7958825827,
-0.2046786845,
0.2392697334,
-0.1051195562,
-0.3721350729,
0.0191279743,
-0.0235520601,
0.1584178358,
-0.4663336575,
0.2773534954,
-0.4648528099,
0.071384877,
-0.011248271,
0.3556059897,
0.1867654175,
0.0922153369,
-0.2558534145,
0.7457636595,
0.2326519191,
-0.5856661797,
0.6366595626,
0.1695140749,
-0.6484184861,
0.7815930247,
-0.2898256183,
0.0295331441,
-0.4336794615,
0.5123741031,
-0.8723013997,
-0.1240709648,
0.0214930438,
-0.3095539808,
0.2171768844,
0.022579832,
-0.568993628,
-0.4657374024,
-0.5054275393,
0.1244393438,
0.6387990117,
-0.7021353245,
0.6380627155,
0.3080311418,
-0.3439058661,
-0.7650359869,
-0.7719681263,
0.3784666061,
-0.5138822198,
-0.9005256295,
0.6052867174,
-0.2548988163,
-0.4906234741,
0.2344490439,
-0.13165842,
0.0295272246,
-0.1436457038,
0.0461612828,
0.4906051457,
-0.4097076654,
0.181041792,
-0.0458766669,
0.3529830575,
0.1584955901,
-0.0317586511,
0.2438666821,
0.1247297674,
-0.5316867232,
-0.0755712837,
0.325296998,
0.6555837393,
0.0737888962,
0.9239368439,
0.2233983129,
-0.246838063,
-0.2915141881,
-1.1060006618,
0.3195467889,
-0.4134795368,
0.1795546412,
0.0597801991,
-0.9917368293,
0.4792436063,
-0.2291402519,
0.2469907403,
0.7262986302,
0.5278723836,
-0.0362329222,
0.5961329341,
0.2244358659,
0.0231555104,
0.1222224385,
-0.0055884505,
0.3111017644,
-0.6246993542,
-0.3871054053,
-0.4243592024,
-0.080300197,
-0.698943913,
-0.649723053,
0.2174171656,
-0.0133148283,
-0.0437662154,
0.0761043578,
0.067491293,
0.5352147222,
0.4438953698,
0.2938630879,
0.6328803897,
0.0092652394,
0.2223993689,
0.0015302288,
-0.5309414268,
-0.6557139158,
0.9880301952,
0.4427725375,
0.7269013524,
0.4577696025,
0.6701743007,
0.5958926082,
0.1386576742,
-0.8537194729,
0.5448397398,
-0.2251554281,
-0.6580063701,
-0.0951535627,
-0.6541930437,
-0.5355328321,
0.0566619486,
-0.2834854722,
-0.5899785161,
0.3476145566,
0.0025551526,
-0.476987958,
0.3712757826,
-0.658347249,
0.3058819473,
-0.2837837636,
-0.3887572885,
-0.2547352612,
-0.3974553943,
0.7836452127,
-0.1077295765,
0.4159623384,
-0.1998836398,
0.1246450245,
0.5820490122,
-0.3667430878,
0.8907181621,
0.1404139698,
-0.2956684828,
0.6283450723,
0.0848645493,
0.4471296668,
0.0274005458,
-0.0723804533,
0.1386279762,
-0.0964781493,
-0.3000781834,
-0.7444280982,
0.7066883445,
-0.7603730559,
-0.9633473158,
-0.5088037848,
-0.2332209796,
-0.2966039777,
0.0038454542,
0.0728390515,
0.4068522453,
-0.5913903713,
0.2668039501,
0.7461183071,
-0.0691676661,
0.0557836294,
0.4620696604,
0.1786852181,
-0.3859863877,
0.7997521162,
0.2436675429,
0.3652078807,
0.1349299699,
0.1484699547,
-0.499694407,
-0.5574237108,
-0.4440917075,
0.3476135433,
-0.9901086092,
-0.1764531285,
-0.5604037046,
-0.3618746102,
-0.364862442,
0.2440139651,
-0.2328170985,
-0.4967542291,
-0.2141260803,
-0.4266299009,
0.1019952968,
0.6256283522,
-0.2128152698,
0.0095612956,
-1.0179064274,
0.3293264806,
0.4896465838,
0.2808107138,
-0.0556341857,
-0.4499311447,
-0.0328021348,
0.0478669927,
-0.4446786344,
-1.0064649582,
-0.2452123463,
0.0584721416,
0.7887508273,
0.2906450629,
0.0968046486,
0.7147637606,
-0.6052896976,
1.0894150734,
0.410174787,
-0.8567281365,
0.2595802546,
-0.1147259623,
-0.2354454696,
0.4470107257,
0.4793936312,
-0.5038179755,
-0.413354516,
-0.797429502,
-0.7483400702,
0.5390062332,
0.1118744761,
0.1818838567,
-0.3231107593,
0.1592670828,
0.2029437721,
0.0485219248,
-0.5875213146,
-0.3780501783,
-0.0590136573,
-0.3489964604,
0.0438996181,
-0.7066164613,
-0.5479884744,
-0.1039889529,
0.5680286884,
0.1129025072,
-0.0594402477,
0.2814922929,
-0.274225086,
-0.1359421015,
0.5822126865,
0.6914847493,
0.9344841838,
-0.2196155787,
0.4772197902,
0.2834037244,
-0.1990159005,
0.1971502155,
0.1959852725,
-0.1943221688,
0.1338146925,
0.5954588652,
0.8772993684,
0.1960224807,
-0.642932713,
0.5137163401,
0.116161041,
-0.2136379927,
-0.3277906179,
0.1109075919,
0.1839218736,
0.2905381918,
0.3367244899,
0.0682467073,
0.0067895022,
-0.9117480516,
0.1241093501,
0.2364250273,
0.0329671502,
-0.2716294527,
0.3752581477,
0.2820029259,
0.1141049862,
0.6595115066,
-0.1060231328,
-0.4392088056,
0.3414500058,
0.5690841675,
0.5679309368,
-0.0150650274,
0.482658118,
0.3069584072,
0.3394036889,
-0.3499168158,
-0.0015364388,
0.0221540313,
-0.7746118307,
-0.682226181,
-0.6519200206,
-0.4768538475,
0.1800857335,
-0.3338724971,
0.3199151754,
-0.2840098739,
-0.2614444494,
0.0118273729,
-0.0605780669,
-0.5031427741,
0.2413891405,
0.244894132,
0.9419648647,
-0.9920150042,
0.1773368269,
0.3955840468,
-0.6184175014,
-0.4315822721,
0.080102101,
0.2192351073,
-0.6525016427,
0.6310197711,
-0.2125425041,
-0.2284002006,
-0.3419479132,
-0.4084354043,
-0.9115563631,
1.0582937002,
0.5916928053,
-0.4172440767,
-0.3852628469,
0.3582668006,
0.402379483,
-0.1935744882,
0.1319278628,
0.7079833746,
0.5627387762,
0.4588137269,
-0.8072693348,
0.3415538669,
0.1823908538,
-0.2503634393,
0.1090653762,
-0.8813485503,
0.9352967143,
-0.1806752086,
-0.6070836186,
-0.1786562651,
0.874417603,
0.4454354048,
0.390229702,
0.7348399758,
0.7673523426,
1.0720158815,
0.0312860198,
0.8257750273,
-0.2708010077,
0.3586889505,
1.1586856842,
-0.2669584453,
0.6000296474,
0.4065922201,
-0.611359477,
0.8827248812,
0.5725509524,
-0.1570961773,
-0.0054811547,
0.0041542002,
-0.5177974105,
-0.1865872294,
-0.1099500805,
-0.3552105129,
0.5032947659,
0.3679161072,
-0.3630580008,
-0.5039817095,
-0.6716636419,
0.3995540738,
0.1820066124,
0.0707604215,
0.6435354352,
0.031184379,
-0.9189169407,
0.404461354,
-0.0826919004,
0.5272083282,
-0.3195037246,
-0.0195028391,
-0.2110326588,
-0.1649340838,
-0.5265010595,
-0.9351615906,
0.3819285631,
0.2163503915,
-0.2625909746,
0.033513505,
0.6473326087,
-0.4457435608,
-0.5087503195,
0.0488637872,
0.6843341589,
-0.046866376,
0.3074513078,
-0.5141841173,
0.1001153365,
-0.0163228586,
-0.0908194631,
0.1476344466,
0.4652282894,
0.1378766894,
0.3547351062,
0.7125763893,
0.2464179695,
0.0783424228,
0.0167897921,
1.001011014,
-0.6607125401,
-0.3273089826,
-1.145518899,
0.5353677273,
-0.4793778062,
-0.1088612154,
0.8970423937,
0.7252232432,
0.8035090566,
0.2167887092,
0.9487232566,
-0.097896643,
0.6454492211,
-0.7052013874,
0.3561862707,
-0.5149816275,
0.2538690567,
-0.0107384324,
-1.1485314369,
0.0770666376,
-0.0971629322,
-0.2729102373,
0.0189894866,
0.7718291283,
0.5403355956,
-0.2182545066,
0.1985942274,
0.1332888007,
0.3495123088,
0.3856791854,
0.1888073236,
1.1764894724,
-0.110576719,
0.5083724856,
-0.0369362421,
-0.2007094026,
-0.1688759327,
-1.113365531,
-0.6230939627,
-0.3750561476,
-0.4184162021,
-0.4846196771,
-0.0645811856,
0.758107841,
0.2898776531,
-0.4109680355,
-0.029024614,
0.2802552581,
0.3500737548,
0.288284719,
-0.2647812665,
0.2556340694,
-0.2733303308,
-0.752168119,
0.5642837286,
0.3601220846,
0.1213832945,
-0.5949366093,
0.1603668034,
-0.1134640351,
0.4174382389,
0.6357295513,
0.2338113487,
-0.731292069,
-0.5870001912,
-0.2007132918,
-0.01326699,
0.280849874,
0.7416699529,
-0.5482160449,
0.3282163739,
0.6293299794,
0.5548055172,
0.2604435682,
0.4340082407,
0.4529003501,
-0.7313462496,
-0.0364599824,
0.0650997683,
0.3351005912,
0.6413224339,
-0.4653261006,
0.2460839003,
0.429089427,
-0.4706958234,
-0.927149117,
0.401961267,
-0.9204680324,
-0.1664425582,
1.0176234245,
-0.1848296821,
-0.3335976005,
-0.0216947943,
0.1930794716,
0.2079169154,
-0.2897232473,
0.9834322333,
1.0040338039,
-0.2084109187,
0.1989896894,
-0.3493416607,
0.3802981079,
0.0856504813,
-0.7152853012,
0.0532238185,
0.8638324738,
0.3875285685,
0.5270231366,
0.5676124096,
-0.1406717002,
0.0305808261,
0.2016728967,
-0.3556984365,
-0.0076675778,
-0.142094925,
0.1590396315,
0.1173536405,
0.213687703,
0.2472394109
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05624v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05624v1
|
Efficient Models for the Detection of Hate, Abuse and Profanity
| 2024-02-08T12:28:18 | 2024-02-08T12:28:18 |
Christoph Tillmann, Aashka Trivedi, Bishwaranjan Bhattacharjee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are the cornerstone for many Natural Language
Processing (NLP) tasks like sentiment analysis, document classification, named
entity recognition, question answering, summarization, etc. LLMs are often
trained on data which originates from the web. This data is prone to having
content with Hate, Abuse and Profanity (HAP). For a detailed definition of HAP,
please refer to the Appendix. Due to the LLMs being exposed to HAP content
during training, the models learn it and may then generate hateful or profane
content. For example, when the open-source RoBERTa model (specifically, the
RoBERTA base model) from the HuggingFace (HF) Transformers library is prompted
to replace the mask token in `I do not know that Persian people are that MASK`
it returns the word `stupid` with the highest score. This is unacceptable in
civil discourse.The detection of Hate, Abuse and Profanity in text is a vital
component of creating civil and unbiased LLMs, which is needed not only for
English, but for all languages. In this article, we briefly describe the
creation of HAP detectors and various ways of using them to make models civil
and acceptable in the output they generate.
|
[
-0.3802824616,
-0.7949546576,
0.4522486329,
0.1085534096,
-0.14793396,
0.0154150659,
-0.2326641828,
-0.5678318143,
-0.0896830633,
0.5439869761,
-0.1675002873,
-0.5975714922,
-0.8092428446,
-0.017168697,
-0.7750965953,
1.0297417641,
0.1109004244,
0.0206248853,
0.1150380373,
-0.0801211819,
0.0531725883,
-1.0249222517,
-0.7756498456,
-0.2881776094,
0.4935745299,
0.2353509367,
0.6913733482,
0.5341807008,
0.6795681119,
0.3138805032,
-0.2367440015,
0.078729935,
-0.5116992593,
0.3270648122,
-0.3464490771,
-0.3484291136,
-0.3355779946,
0.0919947401,
0.5440893173,
0.3266381919,
-0.1054890603,
0.0771587864,
-0.1593750566,
0.4340771437,
-0.5294722915,
-0.1751986295,
-0.7999643683,
0.1097380593,
-0.5481735468,
-0.1001432315,
-0.4814560413,
-0.1746043414,
-0.2252109051,
-0.2257955819,
0.1093351319,
0.2185636014,
0.7830535173,
0.0520113632,
-0.3122067451,
-0.5909766555,
-0.8887686133,
0.9211964011,
-0.8467097282,
0.4875974953,
0.325920254,
0.275444448,
-0.4842229784,
-0.4293245673,
-0.865737021,
-0.347461015,
-0.0099446196,
-0.0934204757,
-0.4690018296,
0.1483711302,
0.3239428103,
0.5118718743,
-0.5371710062,
0.4672162533,
-0.1992890686,
-0.2642202675,
0.8190678358,
0.1792863756,
0.5609668493,
-0.4852468073,
-0.4051873982,
0.2801295221,
-0.6371461153,
-0.4118660986,
0.6904135942,
0.2103036642,
-0.1769258678,
0.5687194467,
0.0172850676,
0.6365184188,
-0.2474570274,
-0.6337165833,
0.0467104986,
-0.0035317645,
-0.2442746609,
-0.4533415139,
0.7626578808,
0.1816486716,
0.7667370439,
-0.0533403717,
-0.4129953384,
0.4518634677,
0.3848752081,
-0.7207878828,
-0.1384741664,
0.0503162257,
-0.4668763876,
-0.6006186008,
-0.4190631211,
-0.7978847027,
-0.6753014922,
-0.2223255038,
0.2871121466,
-0.4331267476,
-0.2484761626,
0.1576819122,
-0.191933006,
0.0430006348,
0.3690381348,
-0.6889833212,
0.414621681,
0.5500949025,
0.6871243119,
-0.3994682133,
0.1027127057,
-0.5092920661,
0.1372485459,
-0.1088140234,
0.6964092255,
-0.5313960314,
-0.1446222216,
0.2075750232,
-0.2097785622,
0.1611113697,
-0.6807256937,
0.9744206071,
-0.6814474463,
0.2307649106,
0.3673326373,
-0.6394477487,
-0.4163658321,
0.3364847302,
-0.5002182722,
0.9916261435,
0.2301825136,
-0.8287137151,
0.0785227194,
-0.6711455584,
-0.4085012674,
0.2396710813,
0.0225632992,
-0.7032238245,
0.0774379149,
-0.0240048878,
0.6101666689,
-0.1722132117,
0.1491539329,
-0.4824612439,
-0.2092084438,
0.2282966673,
-0.2212830037,
0.7275276184,
0.4993643463,
-0.2784010768,
0.3208462298,
-0.7531638741,
-0.3761141002,
0.4225286543,
-0.5460956097,
-0.5776535273,
0.3654397428,
0.3300470114,
0.2647453547,
-0.1223399788,
-0.58318156,
-0.3513532281,
-0.4100601673,
0.1811001748,
0.7878896594,
-0.0983063206,
0.0468986928,
-0.4874504805,
0.6736720204,
0.1156010181,
0.1680805832,
0.0535566658,
-0.6041170359,
-0.8305791616,
-0.4697744846,
-0.061894726,
0.6044262052,
-0.4538027048,
0.3765030205,
0.023421118,
-0.5292348266,
-0.1610153317,
0.3719022572,
0.416826427,
0.4137218595,
0.1212480664,
-0.2635096014,
-0.8933375478,
-0.8850509524,
-0.4258949161,
-0.2653891146,
-0.0561616495,
0.0950260907,
0.6237029433,
-0.0685082301,
0.5783487558,
-0.3820145726,
-0.3959330618,
-0.3316668272,
0.0503996946,
0.055593282,
0.2555356324,
0.7769385576,
-0.9200571179,
-0.5240258574,
-0.1720052958,
-0.7585864663,
-0.2930692136,
0.3442296386,
-0.0465073436,
0.2905136049,
0.4977235496,
-0.2686149776,
0.4590711594,
0.5836376548,
-0.3065522909,
0.8264029622,
0.3392146826,
0.1441012472,
-1.0420835018,
-0.0062281783,
0.1642610282,
-0.7079802155,
-0.9405781627,
0.5970731974,
-0.2997675836,
-0.1079919264,
-0.729678154,
0.5320776701,
-0.4215616584,
0.0178882498,
-0.4385346472,
0.2465961576,
-0.2021294683,
0.370225817,
0.0514147244,
0.7210385799,
0.2037341595,
-0.665546298,
0.4941489697,
0.0318625197,
-0.3982999921,
0.7360136509,
-0.3490130305,
0.1107619181,
-0.2286031991,
-0.0371121988,
-0.7601080537,
-0.3761234283,
0.3477602899,
-0.4267451763,
0.1281739622,
-0.3001617193,
-0.7332863212,
-0.6543273926,
-0.3197773993,
0.3166840971,
0.6473203897,
-0.6412974,
0.5367243886,
0.9413002133,
0.0485272631,
-0.5286396742,
-0.4232915044,
0.1095399633,
-0.6051911712,
-0.6385077238,
0.1551121324,
-0.088607572,
-0.5310198069,
-0.2155283242,
0.245062843,
-0.2319176048,
0.4138415158,
0.4458284974,
0.2487710118,
-0.1638136208,
0.213267073,
-0.3677622378,
0.2046236843,
0.2094768584,
0.0404131934,
0.8703785539,
0.0280466918,
-0.2996328175,
-0.3003672063,
0.5253639817,
0.5717204809,
-0.0524135195,
0.8029321432,
0.6026582122,
-0.7978796959,
-0.3451954424,
-0.6546419859,
0.0628797859,
-0.4562891126,
0.3570367694,
-0.110299319,
-1.1699160337,
0.5258849859,
0.1856642216,
-0.0429721996,
0.4011262655,
0.9913939238,
-0.0783201605,
1.0609562397,
0.721886158,
-0.2926784158,
0.5280878544,
0.4051910937,
0.3913462162,
-0.6046946645,
0.0618211664,
-0.7221450806,
-0.1100170761,
-0.4571695328,
-0.4733554125,
0.4641823471,
0.2133590132,
-0.2667755187,
0.166286692,
-0.4902524054,
0.4072082639,
0.295001924,
-0.0173563231,
0.5105237961,
0.3395721316,
0.0275799949,
-0.19286412,
-0.2923742235,
-0.8309574723,
1.1394284964,
0.7573256493,
0.8688464761,
0.3979168236,
0.5518054366,
0.5250178576,
0.6748434901,
-0.9357525706,
0.5902014375,
-0.2919837236,
-0.9042559862,
-0.0230944622,
-0.1870339662,
-0.7416657805,
0.0913133323,
-0.3762794137,
-0.8918001056,
-0.1679158807,
0.2199587077,
-0.2097117007,
0.6701695919,
-0.331292361,
0.4203090668,
0.0577187575,
-0.1140069515,
-0.4232020974,
-0.0860782862,
0.8193054199,
-0.2008381933,
0.3931817412,
-0.259042263,
0.0714957342,
1.0085805655,
-0.1494738162,
0.9587843418,
-0.1078363433,
-0.3201669753,
0.401951462,
0.3411731422,
0.31039083,
-0.276604712,
-0.1868911982,
0.1580366939,
-0.3858755231,
-0.183338657,
-0.190518409,
0.4549216628,
-0.5768790841,
-0.7788723707,
-0.4315567017,
-0.6545644999,
0.1104317978,
0.2019557655,
0.0619420186,
0.1045343354,
-0.2473318726,
-0.0764524639,
0.8235828876,
-0.3859736919,
0.1460941136,
0.6872834563,
-0.7586065531,
-0.0234820191,
0.588511765,
-0.1790897101,
0.2215791792,
0.1689547747,
0.1259118617,
-0.060642194,
-0.8687245846,
-0.267003268,
0.4022807181,
-0.8435514569,
-0.3038648069,
-0.9286670089,
-0.5357163548,
-0.5045085549,
-0.0369071737,
-0.0152997635,
-0.232597664,
-0.2431235015,
0.0831995532,
0.5177082419,
0.9528606534,
-0.2464579791,
0.6645948887,
-0.6740349531,
0.5063970685,
0.1245886385,
0.3044394553,
-0.1304400265,
-0.9738081098,
-0.1418629587,
-0.2584602535,
-0.3614116013,
-1.1570426226,
0.5713997483,
0.0636251196,
0.3477604985,
0.5055956244,
-0.0572695248,
0.2524803877,
-0.3786074221,
0.5717101097,
-0.0132555468,
-0.8545524478,
0.5363223553,
-0.5372769237,
-0.258882314,
0.0393331423,
0.8023898602,
-0.8476732969,
-0.6561978459,
-0.3998850286,
-0.4703383148,
0.5519062877,
0.0223306958,
0.2590145469,
-0.256477356,
0.2575183213,
-0.1362437159,
0.1319624931,
-1.071592927,
-0.2159529924,
0.1574902385,
-0.3047391176,
0.2197656184,
-0.6015233397,
-0.2969923317,
-0.0797856823,
0.806396544,
0.0160303302,
0.229022637,
-0.037387237,
-0.3910427094,
-0.2036720514,
0.3481411934,
0.5682417154,
0.2643948495,
-0.1280203462,
0.2790767252,
0.0960735455,
-0.522918582,
0.2018889785,
-0.2559795082,
-0.1186588109,
0.0130984401,
0.3372278512,
0.5509098768,
0.021261245,
-0.7683548927,
0.7670288086,
0.1224243566,
0.0070105991,
-0.7165802121,
0.2715358138,
0.1919891685,
0.1110979989,
0.0497789569,
-0.1800515056,
0.2071687579,
-0.6255416274,
0.3968080878,
0.7131497264,
-0.1343338639,
-0.1896718591,
0.6369987726,
0.0910711884,
-0.47799173,
0.4716629386,
-0.3628613651,
-1.0583639145,
0.3065916896,
0.7837353349,
0.4166956842,
-0.5411798954,
0.268148154,
0.4525310397,
0.3437882364,
0.3543908298,
0.3285378814,
0.2453629673,
-1.1437445879,
-0.2931171358,
-1.1388660669,
-0.2502688766,
0.5671259761,
-0.4284666479,
0.3624833524,
-0.8083344698,
0.0043067243,
0.2180089504,
-0.2490988523,
-0.5880725384,
0.2836087644,
0.6469517946,
0.9613126516,
-1.0964576006,
0.746663928,
0.4687920213,
-0.2411421239,
-0.5909209251,
-0.3713907599,
0.367105186,
-1.1290159225,
0.7513884902,
0.0823024362,
0.0406289436,
-0.106962882,
-0.6185572147,
-0.7066133022,
0.2003107816,
0.0864067897,
-0.593508482,
-0.0848525092,
0.2598133385,
0.6860117912,
-0.429191798,
0.2049823999,
0.7629609108,
0.5696995258,
-0.3198605776,
-0.6492688656,
0.1219165623,
-0.1812572628,
-0.0740710422,
0.301876545,
-0.2794023752,
0.8941468,
0.0289989561,
-0.4630582333,
0.0915185288,
0.6040028334,
0.2485862672,
0.0714532956,
0.6500202417,
0.6653511524,
0.5579817891,
-0.0337260589,
1.0436691046,
0.0007999183,
0.1158752665,
0.9844809771,
-0.1967983395,
0.8104355931,
0.2162611187,
-0.2217469364,
0.6223796606,
0.4214152396,
-0.231395036,
-0.1038025618,
0.6581770778,
-0.5930228233,
-0.3300037384,
-0.3552141488,
0.0218889602,
0.7268547416,
0.6214475036,
-0.42040959,
-0.4015013576,
0.1153945327,
0.5760244131,
0.543704927,
-0.4344783723,
0.7005400658,
0.1972946823,
-0.3311100304,
0.5358476043,
0.3896679878,
1.1344131231,
-0.4912647009,
0.1119408906,
0.0891577452,
0.1323255002,
-0.4090754092,
-0.8225828409,
0.5427422523,
0.3461475968,
-0.3534402251,
0.0905333757,
0.9772629142,
-0.3925778866,
-0.3447907269,
0.5796179771,
0.447810173,
0.5315881371,
-0.1788633019,
-0.7388192415,
0.1190077513,
-0.1021990702,
-0.2805118561,
0.3031527102,
0.0480433889,
-0.3567721546,
0.7021970749,
0.7970885038,
0.3412746787,
0.2805770934,
0.228993088,
0.7577912807,
-0.6123220325,
-0.2387201786,
-0.8894310594,
0.1705594212,
-0.176537782,
-0.0615439154,
0.7603748441,
0.3770447373,
0.7990739942,
0.0544654466,
0.7701320052,
-0.0013759105,
0.9445095062,
-0.3913565278,
0.8910333514,
-0.534673214,
0.044912383,
-0.3544909954,
-0.8314474821,
-0.5441582799,
0.5521122217,
-0.1650716215,
-0.0193047095,
0.5549218059,
0.9480488896,
0.0237359572,
0.0396963917,
0.6530930996,
0.3248763978,
0.5652886629,
0.3827464879,
0.7946922183,
-0.2842057943,
0.3606981635,
-0.1655575782,
-0.3308309317,
-0.1938176602,
-0.9481512308,
-1.0686323643,
-0.4250559509,
-0.2051831335,
-0.4578740597,
0.0882904604,
0.6856285334,
0.7545870543,
-0.9531149268,
-0.2908008695,
0.2467029095,
0.3497047722,
0.2479898632,
-0.2981382906,
-0.0581473894,
-0.3823106587,
-0.8708385229,
0.3829318583,
0.3753600121,
0.1842164546,
-0.3658306897,
0.0122470679,
-0.472653538,
0.2625132799,
0.8775518537,
0.2589586377,
-0.6089861989,
-0.5353716612,
-0.4626537561,
-0.2398017943,
-0.020731682,
0.6503885388,
-0.5628987551,
-0.0006748903,
0.50223279,
0.5444118381,
0.1300792545,
-0.233007893,
0.5658416748,
-0.6277834177,
0.2462589294,
0.2718008459,
0.4801210165,
0.611403048,
-0.5037206411,
0.5847444534,
0.5041039586,
-0.6189039946,
-1.1182140112,
0.6416203976,
-0.6736539602,
-0.240063414,
1.0802185535,
-0.1950894892,
-0.3829361498,
-0.3677014709,
-0.0288397502,
0.3590636849,
-0.143942073,
0.7227910161,
0.804733336,
0.0953721926,
-0.1342187226,
-0.5902217627,
0.7845060229,
0.4288422763,
-0.9118471742,
0.0303222947,
0.5006447434,
0.4879777133,
0.2899301648,
0.5889056921,
-0.3839645684,
0.2181676477,
-0.2818319201,
0.4204401374,
0.1880986094,
-0.3332664669,
-0.3057505786,
0.2276984304,
0.1291469038,
0.1838029474
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05617v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05617v1
|
Deep Learning-based Computational Job Market Analysis: A Survey on Skill Extraction and Classification from Job Postings
| 2024-02-08T12:20:28 | 2024-02-08T12:20:28 |
Elena Senger, Mike Zhang, Rob van der Goot, Barbara Plank
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent years have brought significant advances to Natural Language Processing
(NLP), which enabled fast progress in the field of computational job market
analysis. Core tasks in this application domain are skill extraction and
classification from job postings. Because of its quick growth and its
interdisciplinary nature, there is no exhaustive assessment of this emerging
field. This survey aims to fill this gap by providing a comprehensive overview
of deep learning methodologies, datasets, and terminologies specific to
NLP-driven skill extraction and classification. Our comprehensive cataloging of
publicly available datasets addresses the lack of consolidated information on
dataset creation and characteristics. Finally, the focus on terminology
addresses the current lack of consistent definitions for important concepts,
such as hard and soft skills, and terms relating to skill extraction and
classification.
|
[
-0.3104072809,
-0.7935565114,
0.0861060768,
0.0395446122,
0.0939462036,
0.4253637493,
-0.3393355608,
-0.7982538342,
0.2061956823,
0.6060029864,
-0.7043935657,
-0.5634973645,
-0.6499642134,
-0.0278916061,
-0.4699013531,
0.9419451356,
0.4851369262,
-0.0496554524,
-0.4057240486,
0.1845910996,
-0.4527131915,
-0.5341659784,
-0.8729814291,
-0.0405242145,
0.4705660939,
0.5863553882,
0.3906099498,
0.6076527238,
0.653131783,
0.2937395275,
0.1398958266,
-0.0319899954,
-0.2221798152,
0.4179732502,
-0.1832217276,
-0.1526465714,
-0.4232820868,
0.3938125968,
0.4976840317,
1.2987372875,
-0.2432175577,
0.436620295,
0.0189806446,
0.6730588078,
-0.7335758805,
0.3862887919,
-0.8226950765,
0.2703976035,
-0.2736207247,
-0.0745855793,
-0.0375180021,
-0.3586775661,
0.4549124837,
-0.3946479261,
0.6543900371,
-0.4477034509,
0.6075117588,
0.1606466323,
-0.4077008963,
-0.4946867526,
-0.8597538471,
0.9264432192,
-0.5256351233,
0.4652332664,
0.3138675094,
0.7300750613,
0.2278972268,
-0.9266637564,
-0.1253201663,
0.0238456931,
0.1875396818,
0.108278431,
0.1711064726,
0.0817228034,
0.1451714039,
0.6112402678,
-0.5685816407,
0.6983735561,
-0.7010422945,
-0.0139189139,
0.9944552183,
0.4068635404,
-0.0339961573,
0.1313768178,
-0.0477334,
-0.2925400436,
-0.4706937373,
0.2527330518,
0.3468747735,
0.3941472471,
0.0969394147,
0.5227040052,
-0.5550954342,
0.7698510885,
-0.1823839992,
-0.2275226712,
0.3026521802,
-0.134120822,
-0.4461461604,
-0.0677632242,
0.8190543652,
0.2202399224,
-0.1515718699,
-0.2699996233,
-0.1839633286,
-0.2148936987,
0.5986367464,
-0.5581355095,
-0.0405769907,
-0.0667381585,
-0.5990145802,
-0.6517846584,
0.166114226,
-0.9709712863,
-0.9458008409,
-0.2730787992,
-0.3831391633,
0.2405670732,
-0.4715351164,
0.0063196453,
-0.2653149068,
0.4243134856,
0.0623923987,
-0.9190439582,
0.4840478301,
1.0320036411,
0.5183085203,
-0.4524662197,
-0.0535615049,
-0.0621694326,
-0.3490183651,
-0.2550285161,
0.6705421209,
-0.6544862986,
-0.0897704512,
0.2641831636,
0.1197751388,
-0.1028965786,
-0.7224340439,
0.5126159191,
-0.9618778229,
0.1409328878,
0.0814949796,
-0.4690208733,
-0.544421196,
0.5906618237,
-0.8689638376,
0.9846944213,
0.4621704221,
-0.4873170257,
0.6416118741,
-0.6606776118,
-0.2896068394,
0.2582661808,
-0.4046425521,
-0.3060208857,
0.0092419777,
0.0391041152,
0.8492687941,
-0.4517239034,
0.2862775326,
-0.3997580707,
-0.3520281613,
0.5141313076,
-0.4897627831,
0.917621851,
0.5092975497,
-0.2263417095,
-0.2520826459,
-0.6878401637,
0.0015847913,
-0.0497474819,
-0.2574832439,
-0.0189366546,
-0.0644349679,
-0.0276578981,
0.4282607734,
0.2731539905,
-0.3996929228,
0.3767003119,
-0.8665909767,
0.2332925498,
0.4994831681,
-0.0683708787,
0.5857089758,
0.2254609317,
0.8933349848,
-0.1817546636,
0.0959528908,
0.4388088882,
-0.4233707786,
-0.2557107508,
-0.0796314552,
0.4902381599,
0.7981973886,
-0.7031343579,
0.5938866138,
-0.2129097134,
-0.9336836338,
-0.4598476291,
0.1789415479,
0.1289240271,
0.4480957091,
0.1483965665,
-0.4162855744,
-0.8660849929,
-0.9325873256,
-0.3194034398,
0.3316034675,
0.0777828842,
0.2216790915,
0.0716852918,
-0.330607444,
0.9463706613,
-0.8394224048,
-0.3792810738,
-0.3235457242,
0.2489743382,
0.7280678153,
0.2515386045,
0.3767808974,
-0.9008587003,
-0.3732358515,
0.1423002034,
-0.8873574138,
0.2170667052,
-0.0739310756,
0.2271286398,
-0.0452497751,
0.5981151462,
-0.6891789436,
0.4171193242,
0.2512530684,
-0.0418830924,
0.5914369226,
0.1532869786,
-0.0979872048,
-0.7409790754,
0.3968081772,
0.1609540135,
0.1663692743,
-0.7134332657,
0.1408241242,
-0.4752773046,
-0.2968941331,
-0.4798262715,
0.557749629,
-0.4670336246,
-0.5475950241,
-0.6013904214,
-0.1784367412,
-0.3099277914,
0.3744065464,
0.1617012471,
0.6284047961,
0.8315973282,
-0.7381404638,
0.7265869379,
0.2302528471,
-0.4205148518,
0.1902977973,
-0.353072077,
0.2609728873,
-0.0257298071,
0.0941743776,
-0.7059800029,
-0.3781197965,
0.3325113058,
-0.4319482446,
0.2563258708,
-0.2318061143,
-0.2501532137,
-0.6791052222,
-0.1759783328,
0.3774657845,
0.4711661041,
-0.0137724811,
0.0958506465,
0.5978720784,
-0.5641536117,
-1.253289938,
-0.777590394,
-0.0531259626,
-0.0902667418,
-0.1125949025,
0.3374058902,
0.3305878043,
-0.2060270011,
-0.2574898601,
-0.047439523,
-0.9426088929,
0.5036134124,
0.1300722808,
0.2012207955,
-0.1919192523,
0.1028241441,
0.0184945278,
-0.2219924927,
0.3801308274,
-0.0862988085,
0.3319207132,
0.1319130063,
-0.1343036741,
-0.2280921936,
0.0975758284,
0.3754057586,
-0.0901686102,
0.6359114647,
1.0117989779,
-0.2973956168,
-0.2170188725,
-0.5472789407,
-0.1482727528,
-0.5054512024,
0.3515010774,
0.1217974126,
-1.0067292452,
0.3042895794,
-0.302391082,
0.0229672603,
0.9427506924,
0.2994374931,
-0.2461790591,
0.8568607569,
0.892152369,
-0.111786522,
0.3064758182,
-0.6399623752,
0.195752725,
-0.4224742353,
-0.3136279285,
-0.5293085575,
-0.5742651224,
-0.6680927873,
-0.0654212609,
0.0006425736,
-0.1466951668,
-0.1424016356,
0.0899177268,
-1.0612300634,
0.3404615223,
0.678488791,
-0.0701503679,
-0.1234748811,
0.0950589254,
0.3921148777,
-0.1397604197,
-0.3787187636,
-0.1935755759,
1.3117375374,
0.2605499029,
0.351044178,
-0.3201886117,
0.5158308744,
0.5280100703,
0.0881596208,
-0.8614532351,
0.5104591846,
-0.526399076,
-0.5004651546,
-0.4331537783,
-0.4504354,
-1.1247606277,
-0.1173232198,
-0.4962183535,
-0.340079844,
0.3611693084,
-0.1667249054,
-0.4372265935,
0.2782186568,
-0.3467457891,
0.9657686353,
-0.3682927787,
0.1396866739,
-0.2869281173,
-0.6185234189,
0.3595918119,
-0.31950441,
0.2599499226,
-0.2190065086,
0.0087519148,
0.93685323,
-0.0713087916,
1.0248043537,
-0.5523638129,
0.1505635083,
0.3389343619,
-0.1339460611,
0.185323447,
-0.0958552286,
-0.4650906026,
0.2579840422,
0.1219102293,
-0.2333064228,
-0.4745098948,
0.427957654,
-0.6860103011,
-0.0029665146,
-0.4407072067,
-0.4193761349,
-0.2683508992,
0.337526381,
0.149239704,
0.0228568465,
-0.3730622232,
0.4146974683,
0.5259921551,
-0.1879564375,
0.2696972787,
0.1668839604,
0.0125651332,
-0.2833604217,
1.2384089231,
0.3352975547,
-0.4956563115,
0.3484417796,
-0.1370581388,
-0.2675729692,
-0.7994553447,
0.1852634698,
-0.0304984525,
-0.4178533852,
-0.2675190866,
-0.4726485908,
-0.5908350945,
-0.7876101136,
-0.2134053707,
-0.2196393162,
-0.4254130125,
-0.4035108387,
-0.2973078191,
0.1858144552,
0.8850905895,
-0.0423570573,
0.3538003862,
-0.7956287265,
0.2953953743,
0.496789664,
0.6338378787,
-0.0291638803,
0.021672057,
-0.6086453795,
0.2100096196,
-0.330506444,
-0.728192091,
0.7007277012,
0.187673986,
0.9176187515,
0.455037564,
-0.1776104271,
0.3076126277,
0.1798990369,
1.0235458612,
0.2564110458,
-0.4333291948,
0.4463809431,
-0.2854624391,
0.001282335,
0.8701967597,
0.7011187673,
-0.6509923935,
0.0329370797,
-0.8542328477,
-0.9792672396,
0.6935949922,
0.0284350757,
0.1385889798,
-0.0465185679,
0.5893089175,
0.5159766674,
0.5546500683,
-0.3021916747,
-0.0706574544,
0.0793568343,
-0.2406411618,
-0.107972227,
-0.3216474056,
0.0791933164,
-0.6174530387,
0.4652584493,
-0.1915124506,
0.346675247,
-0.2548722029,
-0.324313432,
0.2799680531,
0.0885718539,
0.3868073523,
0.8660974503,
-0.194678843,
0.0284682419,
0.2771755755,
-0.6580032706,
-0.1559314281,
0.2241630703,
0.1455127448,
-0.1979552209,
0.2713665068,
0.2820231915,
-0.0576943457,
-0.9193991423,
0.8154484034,
0.1279003322,
-0.5583848357,
-0.716338098,
0.1692818701,
-0.2529295087,
0.3536095321,
0.6611614823,
0.0140905483,
0.5936471224,
-0.3209070861,
0.3017817438,
0.4542661607,
-0.6748347282,
-0.1983346194,
0.2773010135,
0.1663809121,
-0.0827224702,
1.2878652811,
-0.2050307095,
-0.0900860801,
0.9260745645,
0.0793303847,
1.2258810997,
-0.0867562294,
0.2979621589,
0.2136928141,
-0.0497971848,
-0.0064364835,
0.3198825419,
-0.0239676908,
-0.7826521993,
-0.542439878,
-0.4947376251,
-0.5230534077,
0.3883238733,
-0.7595928907,
0.050455153,
-0.7080590129,
-0.199072808,
0.1665937901,
0.1724146158,
-1.0771946907,
0.7473580241,
0.3226218522,
0.7640881538,
-0.8297267556,
0.6415835023,
0.7890406847,
-0.3447322845,
-0.2424466908,
-0.6194630861,
-0.0966544375,
-0.6757480502,
0.8306972384,
0.3018940985,
0.0954955518,
-0.1433049887,
-0.8602494001,
-0.7133974433,
1.1161234379,
0.2337179482,
-0.1296223402,
-0.3892174959,
0.4482702911,
0.5405088067,
-0.4590694308,
0.2152189761,
0.5066582561,
0.3565063477,
-0.19915618,
-0.7909594774,
-0.360268116,
-0.3058255315,
-0.0874252394,
-0.1130024493,
-0.1445855349,
0.637370944,
0.4174399078,
-0.2292391062,
-0.2595511079,
0.663936317,
-0.0931499824,
0.5676867366,
0.5201935172,
0.3942228854,
0.8136659861,
0.0323232189,
0.5664864182,
-0.1815915555,
0.4334640205,
0.9668024182,
-0.1136546135,
0.6769477129,
0.0213629324,
-0.1884424239,
0.6753953695,
0.878867805,
-0.4695580304,
0.3936866224,
0.1463646591,
0.0607477687,
-0.2574163973,
-0.0176890735,
-0.4253426194,
0.8778475523,
0.5245142579,
-0.5194430947,
-0.2343555242,
0.1156227812,
-0.5054852366,
-0.1362085044,
-0.5327762961,
1.0142141581,
0.1148245782,
-0.3629211783,
0.2119296938,
-0.061437089,
0.7937200665,
-0.5042513013,
-0.3972886503,
0.1425896585,
-0.0261841882,
-0.3837674856,
-1.1386494637,
0.8511118889,
-0.2875700891,
-0.2801544964,
-0.591145575,
1.165487051,
-0.2122306973,
-0.4073719084,
0.0728349835,
0.6752170324,
0.4611529708,
-0.219105795,
-1.0753793716,
-0.3834984601,
-0.2901343107,
-0.0337259136,
0.3314557076,
0.1764634103,
0.1099102721,
0.6218802929,
0.6927178502,
0.0233725086,
0.055004552,
-0.1635455191,
0.6354572177,
-1.07452631,
-0.435431391,
-0.4641644061,
0.3573265374,
-0.5242435336,
-0.4898670614,
0.4694777131,
0.6988614202,
0.7954035997,
-0.2742778361,
0.738054812,
0.04012274,
0.7661759257,
-0.1845445335,
0.7919080257,
-0.3588487804,
0.0602782965,
-0.0851874873,
-0.8613513112,
-0.2284318656,
0.211210683,
-0.4639264643,
0.0520521328,
0.2738501132,
0.6230643392,
-0.1641451418,
-0.1298449039,
0.2315924615,
-0.0624785647,
-0.1421937495,
0.0491670221,
0.7837133408,
-0.1443158835,
0.3475210071,
-0.5118669271,
0.0996917784,
-0.5559853315,
-0.6254128814,
-0.4191506803,
-0.4890883565,
-0.5007590055,
-0.0946537852,
-0.2158776373,
0.6212716699,
0.7660684586,
-0.7500129938,
-0.586714685,
-0.0766616315,
0.2670613527,
-1.0626969337,
-0.3448854983,
0.4045490324,
-0.3547031581,
-0.3414733112,
0.7747362852,
-0.0590571128,
-0.3199865222,
-0.3926615119,
0.2583681047,
-0.0792987272,
-0.2938236594,
0.6815360188,
0.7211467028,
-0.3144675195,
0.1610094905,
0.0714766011,
-0.2652333379,
-0.1682546139,
0.9095874429,
-0.8323453665,
0.3149359226,
0.6370773911,
0.9750415087,
0.4156453311,
-0.2638082206,
0.5630987883,
-1.0525220633,
0.0105926916,
0.5079998374,
-0.1561679542,
0.1131252348,
-0.6790198088,
0.8598374128,
0.3908734918,
-0.4246637225,
-0.7503390908,
0.0784949735,
-1.1403650045,
-0.6510882974,
0.8118075132,
0.4178059697,
-0.1127084121,
-0.372400105,
0.1784191281,
0.3393812776,
-0.0384078138,
0.7429657578,
0.4060171545,
-0.1950333118,
-0.2632471025,
-0.8063901067,
0.5008050799,
-0.1431364566,
-0.6794226766,
0.0413719006,
0.4341296554,
0.0498073734,
0.1461029053,
0.6700933576,
0.1532452554,
0.4329216182,
-0.2098056525,
0.3855695426,
-0.0951132774,
-0.2693083882,
-0.5025387406,
0.6747117043,
0.1800937504,
-0.0135908946
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05616v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05616v1
|
Pretrained Generative Language Models as General Learning Frameworks for Sequence-Based Tasks
| 2024-02-08T12:19:32 | 2024-02-08T12:19:32 |
Ben Fauber
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
We propose that small pretrained foundational generative language models with
millions of parameters can be utilized as a general learning framework for
sequence-based tasks. Our proposal overcomes the computational resource, skill
set, and timeline challenges associated with training neural networks and
language models from scratch. Further, our approach focuses on creating small
and highly specialized models that can accurately execute a challenging task of
which the base model is incapable of performing. We demonstrate that 125M,
350M, and 1.3B parameter pretrained foundational language models can be
instruction fine-tuned with 10,000-to-1,000,000 instruction examples to achieve
near state-of-the-art results on challenging cheminformatics tasks. We also
demonstrate the role of successive language model fine-tuning epochs on
improved outcomes, as well as the importance of both data formatting and
pretrained foundational language model selection for instruction fine-tuning
success.
|
[
-0.0433993116,
-0.730328083,
0.5108809471,
0.0590704046,
-0.2211702317,
-0.1356108189,
-0.3215835989,
-0.075852409,
-0.0913869217,
0.4459599853,
-0.5789417624,
-0.4475075006,
-0.435762316,
0.0556127355,
-0.4613541961,
0.9986819029,
0.12709409,
0.2160595655,
0.1109218076,
0.3574861884,
-0.2640812397,
-0.4233566225,
-0.5730772614,
-0.2820479274,
0.4880963862,
0.4662761986,
0.7082720995,
0.8392703533,
0.2180019915,
0.294842124,
0.0721557662,
-0.0528951921,
-0.5417560935,
-0.1929149926,
-0.2400188148,
-0.4355827272,
-0.3403043449,
-0.0010838179,
0.7149523497,
1.3373202085,
-0.2463767529,
-0.0545433052,
0.0030029088,
0.7432935238,
-0.4908656478,
0.1423224062,
-0.4898065329,
0.1623496264,
-0.1379817128,
0.0360844433,
-0.410789609,
-0.3221433461,
0.2233365029,
-0.75835675,
0.5694329739,
-0.1383661628,
0.5747222304,
0.1219622567,
-0.1554828584,
-0.2557341754,
-0.8136025667,
0.7373004556,
-0.7133727074,
0.3053118289,
0.307393074,
0.231916815,
-0.086410597,
-0.9943884015,
-0.3795704842,
-0.3006332517,
-0.0518276952,
-0.2195978016,
0.2153171003,
0.401022017,
0.4629704654,
0.7180384994,
-0.7666376233,
0.2942221761,
-0.3610256314,
-0.0695006251,
0.395172745,
0.3479170203,
0.2678779364,
0.0340419039,
0.0001816498,
-0.1850208789,
-0.9254460931,
-0.1974958926,
0.2442942709,
0.5902997255,
-0.1205199137,
0.2882851064,
-0.6276366711,
0.9538803697,
0.1585627198,
0.3484383821,
0.054276593,
-0.2212201953,
-0.6396002769,
-0.2216043174,
0.7930067778,
-0.3120927215,
0.3119395673,
-0.3885353804,
-0.0605040155,
0.0675255358,
0.3953233361,
-0.9960558414,
-0.5271242261,
0.1165125892,
-0.154702425,
-0.3458772302,
-0.0615426935,
-0.7569079995,
-0.1196568981,
-0.7159099579,
0.523855865,
-0.4064881206,
0.0295913815,
0.3902238011,
0.2397181988,
0.1517711431,
0.3742567599,
-1.4034618139,
0.1993602216,
0.5835444927,
0.701964438,
0.0458307862,
-0.2606853843,
-0.4804305434,
-0.0820730999,
-0.4205949008,
0.3724310696,
-0.6516672969,
-0.6020520329,
-0.0463618189,
0.1511322856,
-0.2172571868,
-0.5394323468,
0.0104256915,
-0.547966063,
0.1483720243,
-0.2365016788,
-0.5546609163,
0.1031525284,
0.0631434247,
-0.7517868876,
0.602060616,
0.4173268974,
-0.2488335818,
-0.0127555979,
-0.4470589757,
-0.7166556716,
0.2193701267,
-0.2499343157,
-0.1918972731,
0.1890726835,
-0.0630559176,
0.6629428864,
-0.5691389441,
0.2426185757,
-0.0865759552,
-0.4258693755,
-0.3427039087,
-0.21524553,
0.7155071497,
0.3956900537,
-0.4820614159,
0.3234605789,
-0.8160214424,
0.4099363387,
-0.0843198672,
-0.5882095098,
0.1959805787,
-0.1340455711,
-0.0748931319,
0.234050855,
0.1342577189,
-0.1205011457,
0.1585604697,
-0.6710698009,
0.6052442789,
0.536463201,
-0.2638320923,
0.7048306465,
-0.2017371356,
0.6196982861,
-0.019928379,
-0.0882099047,
-0.4442991018,
-0.2623298764,
-0.867123425,
-0.0141507732,
0.4790566862,
0.6607174873,
-0.7559180856,
0.4527674317,
-0.2950590849,
-0.5597754717,
-0.3186315,
0.4446940422,
0.6819072962,
0.4466283917,
0.4698753357,
-0.423568517,
-0.5682442188,
-0.6941060424,
-0.0230153762,
0.152974993,
-0.2283176631,
0.0072589987,
0.4353322387,
-0.3201025128,
0.6722051501,
-0.3774218559,
0.0134376027,
-0.1731473356,
0.5218846202,
0.0293451902,
0.8904080987,
0.3340111077,
-0.8072515726,
-0.4243314862,
0.1132674739,
-0.663602829,
0.2134933472,
0.0659885779,
-0.0647807792,
-0.0205825604,
0.8385137916,
-0.5170935988,
0.1289441586,
0.4032953084,
-0.0288678687,
0.625646174,
-0.2585508823,
0.0920694619,
-1.0757707357,
0.1758096665,
-0.1643451452,
-0.1156543493,
-0.9403135777,
0.1783628762,
0.0957805663,
-0.4383091033,
-0.6545213461,
0.4084565043,
-0.3401001096,
0.1096896753,
-0.2926922441,
-0.501616776,
-0.1673413217,
0.5370982885,
0.2977141142,
0.6024439931,
0.594325006,
-0.7720046043,
0.2592924833,
-0.0070474157,
-0.6474065185,
0.0925098583,
-0.8316951394,
0.2451176941,
-0.100860402,
-0.0539556332,
-0.5301753879,
-0.4903214872,
0.0587903969,
-0.013634352,
0.5174044371,
-0.0758050531,
-0.3013552725,
-0.1747516394,
0.2665583789,
0.5318110585,
0.6923618913,
-0.3325113058,
0.4968200922,
-0.1942909062,
-0.2603651285,
-0.4967199862,
-0.4008511603,
-0.361142844,
0.0145715801,
-0.3001061082,
0.5211779475,
-0.2177253962,
0.1503933519,
-0.1663981825,
0.0473426394,
-0.000677719,
0.2079077512,
0.3163787425,
0.0268121809,
-0.4213126004,
0.015953185,
-0.0453840904,
-0.1403956413,
-0.0996458605,
-0.6321994662,
0.7167223096,
-0.3677918315,
-0.3172827959,
-0.219657585,
0.3539528251,
0.3324575126,
-0.2232590765,
0.7170809507,
0.3467613459,
-0.4999506772,
-0.3041864634,
-0.1673693657,
-0.143075645,
-0.5132668614,
0.5685810447,
-0.2935282886,
-1.1229845285,
0.3111597598,
-0.2658092082,
-0.164919883,
0.4667956829,
0.525195539,
-0.0487168916,
0.788554728,
0.7634499073,
-0.2373092324,
0.5635305643,
-0.3293536603,
0.0471230522,
-0.3424410522,
-0.1459344029,
-0.543307364,
-0.1028085276,
-0.218801409,
-0.5412302017,
0.0361974053,
0.5117864609,
-0.6258548498,
0.2179021984,
-0.2844811678,
0.7114602923,
0.5972182155,
0.2011276633,
-0.1075386778,
0.0577473864,
-0.2725470662,
0.3034777641,
-0.7542013526,
-0.4991448522,
1.1002902985,
-0.0313973278,
0.7814384699,
-0.1331094801,
0.5495087504,
0.2847362459,
0.3277344108,
-0.6013090014,
0.4156186879,
-0.4124928117,
-0.6272457242,
-0.5115138888,
-0.4644113183,
-0.8257752657,
-0.1070607752,
-0.0470367782,
-0.6645659208,
0.176909551,
0.4969515502,
-0.6570757031,
0.1749310941,
-0.8371815085,
1.3694025278,
-0.3116415739,
-0.1308887005,
-0.1103226095,
-0.886133194,
0.2690577805,
-0.1162933707,
0.0922360122,
0.1190777197,
0.3668295741,
0.4464114308,
-0.6130801439,
1.1382375956,
-0.0910751671,
-0.0626357123,
0.1744935215,
-0.004830719,
0.4372420311,
-0.214462176,
-0.0768429562,
-0.1713859141,
-0.1190513968,
-0.6233484149,
-0.6105983257,
0.5755543113,
-0.7447617054,
-0.6508793235,
-0.0441688001,
-0.4035682976,
-0.3044735491,
0.3296999633,
0.5430054665,
0.4109695554,
-0.5907274485,
0.2464262694,
0.9218104482,
-0.0859587416,
0.3651777804,
0.3635006547,
0.1313266605,
-0.2395082265,
1.043050766,
-0.2511076927,
0.5981573462,
0.7259255648,
-0.1266140491,
0.0568487197,
-0.5821788311,
-0.5216348767,
-0.0862636566,
-0.7638232708,
-0.0499862172,
-0.4761535525,
-0.2832130194,
-0.4118964076,
-0.3215117455,
-0.4762624204,
-0.2475170493,
-0.6736235023,
-0.0249958858,
0.0474840999,
0.6941906214,
-0.0068262657,
0.6054373384,
-0.8208023906,
0.3709118664,
0.7022250891,
0.3906923234,
0.0333768167,
-0.4854255021,
-0.6112100482,
0.2672008276,
-0.0984355509,
-0.7175291777,
0.2656196356,
0.5493401885,
0.3960590065,
0.4474619627,
-0.2645463347,
0.6171064377,
-0.9156640768,
0.6439574361,
0.1270076036,
-1.0664328337,
0.8102490306,
-0.4403240383,
0.4088078737,
0.4709635377,
0.6923641562,
-0.3011796772,
0.2569427192,
-0.4650184214,
-0.6773854494,
0.8232805729,
-0.0311430749,
0.0708079264,
-0.0827208906,
0.6524178386,
0.0002792756,
0.3162938654,
-0.4199870825,
-0.2011086643,
-0.4835581481,
-0.4725900888,
-0.6052724719,
-0.142240867,
-0.1135248989,
-0.3503338695,
0.5479465723,
-0.3517006338,
0.1486704201,
-0.2220675349,
-0.4719264507,
-0.120939292,
0.4413219988,
0.7901957035,
0.4752854109,
-0.145216316,
-0.0108103799,
0.1333166212,
-0.5719255209,
0.3956072927,
0.3421896696,
-0.0775001049,
-0.362198025,
0.1723738015,
0.9322223663,
0.6137549877,
-0.7438672781,
0.1680530608,
0.2673918903,
-0.1684654206,
-0.0900167525,
0.3703317642,
0.2467320412,
0.049011413,
0.1929302067,
-0.0193490908,
-0.0519009084,
-0.4792751968,
0.2655381858,
0.3954404593,
-0.3619141281,
-0.5228272676,
0.8141656518,
0.1579475105,
-0.1800159663,
0.7641276121,
-0.2912654281,
-0.346083492,
0.7962341309,
0.6066331863,
0.6980599761,
-0.4690000117,
0.2592534721,
0.3454472721,
0.2543022037,
-0.5177478194,
0.3059512079,
-0.0669943243,
-0.7534326315,
-0.3727334738,
-0.9574721456,
-0.366579771,
0.3613276184,
-0.7251517177,
0.0739137754,
-0.8712410927,
0.2081476152,
0.1412205994,
-0.1391851604,
-0.9097956419,
0.7674719095,
0.1065254062,
0.6690688133,
-0.856916666,
1.0620487928,
0.8322979212,
-0.4153697491,
-0.8315243721,
-0.5240928531,
0.0029181771,
-0.5235334039,
0.8275175691,
0.1434021294,
-0.0919941142,
0.4260056317,
-0.5647104383,
-0.8205086589,
1.0461705923,
0.5740196705,
-0.7874243855,
-0.4996524751,
0.3795382679,
0.5210180283,
-0.5374466181,
-0.1229891628,
0.655587256,
-0.0884448588,
0.0926164538,
-0.810824573,
0.0062824315,
-0.4601676464,
0.2500920296,
0.0677675977,
-0.3671992123,
1.1108820438,
-0.2734488249,
-0.2823235393,
0.5303613544,
0.7746819854,
0.1727634221,
-0.0818058252,
0.36123541,
0.781416595,
0.6499843597,
-0.1778046787,
1.0531135798,
-0.1668775827,
0.1204724982,
1.146006465,
-0.1599953771,
0.7397274971,
0.0150274299,
-0.2321753055,
0.5745577216,
0.6915463209,
0.0973643512,
0.6851841807,
0.3645064235,
-0.3973969817,
-0.5171328187,
0.3037716746,
-0.5266751051,
0.0694135875,
0.6405854225,
-0.487444371,
-0.1041271687,
0.1336720437,
-0.2951439619,
-0.0326629095,
-0.4800331593,
0.4602214992,
0.1115922853,
-0.534768343,
0.5866815448,
0.0630706996,
0.5170192719,
-0.6648240089,
-0.0274477229,
-0.0395809487,
0.1099235564,
-0.0218702313,
-0.123072207,
0.0149474917,
-0.1008367613,
-0.5045937896,
-0.2625572085,
0.5516989827,
-0.5027960539,
-0.3936713338,
-0.1900235713,
0.3460646272,
0.0238425247,
-0.1956591606,
-0.5027668476,
-0.200935021,
-0.0875510424,
-0.0982518792,
0.4002340734,
0.3708589077,
0.0414379314,
0.5194029212,
0.5287723541,
-0.0967005044,
0.206937626,
0.1343431622,
0.7833876014,
-0.8987409472,
-0.5893672109,
-0.6080106497,
0.545578301,
0.3713663816,
-0.3032775223,
0.3335133791,
0.4314312637,
1.2209402323,
-0.5878167152,
0.8518236876,
-0.122571364,
0.2743460238,
-0.8108612299,
0.5955364108,
-0.3537921607,
0.1395924091,
-0.1563833207,
-0.7506791353,
-0.2093288451,
0.5859194994,
-0.2231918722,
0.5087133646,
0.5783547759,
0.7811185122,
-0.0639091283,
0.1849837154,
0.4116621614,
-0.0248535331,
0.1129183099,
0.8177539706,
0.7583169341,
-0.2896821201,
0.1617774814,
-0.284840107,
0.0215816051,
-0.2053917646,
-0.8165063858,
-0.9714121222,
-0.6033035517,
-0.311031729,
-0.0128085269,
0.209142372,
0.8836106062,
0.9661281109,
-1.155579567,
-0.2084885985,
-0.5417017341,
-0.1908281893,
-0.1388040632,
-0.1473154575,
0.2263762206,
-0.6966841817,
-0.7444783449,
0.5673675537,
0.0425671339,
0.4231724441,
-0.1218384355,
-0.2554085255,
-0.0366636738,
-0.2574358284,
0.6146495342,
0.9142028689,
-0.6753282547,
-0.1551041901,
0.1064563394,
-0.2672591209,
-0.2045519501,
1.0633877516,
-0.7709340453,
0.4197416902,
0.253610909,
0.8524026871,
0.4292415082,
-0.0429402925,
0.9260268211,
-0.9874654412,
0.2809807062,
0.2355809212,
0.1889081001,
0.368953824,
-0.2578795552,
0.3600662351,
0.2109203935,
-0.3539890051,
-0.5449718833,
0.4275665879,
-0.7677326798,
-0.30961743,
0.8203386068,
-0.2117978036,
0.0443627909,
0.0602963082,
0.2306298912,
0.4215848744,
0.1938627213,
0.5417525768,
0.5129706264,
0.075461179,
-0.1676870435,
-0.3425229788,
0.9946535826,
0.669084549,
-0.8990572691,
-0.1282081902,
0.5538091063,
0.2452389598,
0.092297703,
0.5069244504,
-0.0104735894,
0.4918608963,
-0.0595160089,
0.0588357933,
-0.1108517945,
-0.6558711529,
-0.5591760278,
0.1795480698,
0.1164012551,
0.0084853806
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05602v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05602v2
|
AttnLRP: Attention-Aware Layer-Wise Relevance Propagation for Transformers
| 2024-02-08T12:01:24 | 2024-06-10T09:58:55 |
Reduan Achtibat, Sayed Mohammad Vakilzadeh Hatefi, Maximilian Dreyer, Aakriti Jain, Thomas Wiegand, Sebastian Lapuschkin, Wojciech Samek
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models are prone to biased predictions and hallucinations,
underlining the paramount importance of understanding their model-internal
reasoning process. However, achieving faithful attributions for the entirety of
a black-box transformer model and maintaining computational efficiency is an
unsolved challenge. By extending the Layer-wise Relevance Propagation
attribution method to handle attention layers, we address these challenges
effectively. While partial solutions exist, our method is the first to
faithfully and holistically attribute not only input but also latent
representations of transformer models with the computational efficiency similar
to a single backward pass. Through extensive evaluations against existing
methods on LLaMa 2, Mixtral 8x7b, Flan-T5 and vision transformer architectures,
we demonstrate that our proposed approach surpasses alternative methods in
terms of faithfulness and enables the understanding of latent representations,
opening up the door for concept-based explanations. We provide an LRP library
at https://github.com/rachtibat/LRP-eXplains-Transformers.
|
[
-0.01283227,
-0.5327941775,
0.7842439413,
0.2915054858,
-0.2222201973,
-0.0876215175,
-0.2441082597,
-0.4456263185,
-0.1785536557,
0.6695236564,
-0.3952001631,
0.0495687947,
-0.4179039299,
-0.3963978291,
-0.6000807881,
0.7447410822,
0.0190376174,
-0.3420087397,
-0.1956951171,
0.0918860286,
-0.0958318487,
-0.3857675493,
-0.5187216401,
-0.8373845816,
0.8685360551,
0.2902317643,
0.7835019231,
0.4498199821,
0.7115980387,
0.2321518511,
-0.4465901256,
0.0252428278,
-0.5086286068,
0.2194531858,
-0.449560374,
-0.3899667263,
-0.297752142,
-0.250345856,
0.7220762968,
0.395621419,
-0.3051133156,
0.3870027363,
0.1026239321,
0.4829889834,
-0.6966366172,
-0.0207773801,
-0.9834486246,
0.2209784687,
-0.0535494089,
-0.5249958038,
-0.7751885056,
-0.1659548581,
0.0554607622,
-0.4385820031,
0.3614139259,
-0.0326118432,
0.6046527028,
0.6287979484,
-0.2114717215,
0.293779403,
-1.0966674089,
0.969575882,
-0.3922345042,
0.6550132632,
0.3005975485,
0.7003851533,
0.0569195151,
-0.9658094645,
-0.5530619621,
-0.0405302607,
-0.2523920238,
0.2577671707,
-0.1153217405,
-0.0887436345,
0.1405223012,
0.5768883228,
-0.2075462192,
-0.2399088889,
-0.3473882973,
-0.3572086394,
0.2052330971,
-0.233776927,
-0.3632256389,
-0.1034896076,
-0.3397840261,
-0.3089297116,
-0.5649959445,
-0.150639385,
0.067515716,
0.1721836179,
-0.0337902345,
0.7306014299,
0.2992455065,
0.5926745534,
0.3059775531,
-0.0398748927,
0.1603329778,
-0.414634347,
-0.1051637754,
0.2170545906,
0.5458740592,
-0.0335521102,
0.0362908244,
-0.5991994739,
-0.2678559422,
0.014425165,
0.857631743,
-0.5168052316,
-0.0011825485,
0.2294737697,
-0.5620049834,
-0.4336159527,
-0.2562057078,
-0.756125927,
-0.262178272,
-0.0501230843,
0.5727174282,
-0.0631555691,
-0.2691994607,
0.0763661638,
0.0569303334,
0.5260642767,
0.3265269399,
-0.5580710173,
-0.0515093841,
0.8213297129,
0.6287750602,
-0.0290075522,
0.0039198422,
-0.4651845396,
0.4724200666,
0.0397568233,
0.7453439236,
-0.6070669293,
-0.0001161272,
-0.1688846946,
-0.2588876188,
0.0245292746,
-0.4682256877,
0.99410218,
-0.7803713083,
0.2807559669,
0.0356180854,
-0.2232732177,
-0.0409298427,
0.1781712323,
-0.559263289,
1.0416499376,
0.3263375163,
-0.8274542689,
0.0022465999,
-0.7255985737,
-0.4811308086,
-0.2259367555,
0.0267961528,
-0.6202033162,
0.4759448469,
0.338402003,
0.5036625862,
-0.2637422383,
0.32791695,
-0.0017599129,
-0.3541027606,
0.2621510625,
-0.7444365025,
0.5156441331,
0.198401168,
-0.3438686728,
0.2862751484,
-0.6271935701,
0.0190495215,
0.4047375619,
0.0352794454,
-0.0686680973,
-0.0378444158,
0.0375965759,
0.1697888076,
0.0775846094,
-0.4366376698,
-0.0040328349,
-0.3802583814,
0.5000380278,
0.7270348072,
-0.114359282,
0.6127935648,
-0.1244904771,
0.3616921306,
0.0126855047,
0.3781353533,
-0.1615279168,
-0.574775219,
-0.744528234,
0.1044535041,
-0.1309837252,
0.4685544074,
-0.7543461323,
0.3333067298,
-0.4570468366,
-0.5420533419,
-0.602951169,
-0.1448005289,
0.3997308314,
0.9027550817,
0.70951581,
-0.0321314782,
-0.3558014631,
-1.0105184317,
-0.1927067935,
-0.2312188447,
-0.2247043252,
0.4479067624,
0.2059211284,
-0.2510095239,
0.7525553107,
-0.3496269882,
-0.5309795737,
-0.4079521298,
-0.1671761721,
0.3556919396,
0.3396513164,
0.3877852261,
-0.9373309612,
-0.2897087038,
0.1712623388,
-0.4602451921,
0.0636967421,
-0.0281699132,
-0.2259494066,
-0.1887681037,
0.3529867232,
-0.5789824724,
0.2799676061,
0.5265309811,
-0.1645123661,
0.261592716,
-0.0046741813,
-0.0182860121,
-0.8696574569,
0.2161125392,
-0.1146656945,
-0.4247380197,
-0.6881763935,
0.2622335851,
0.1786790341,
-0.0746742487,
-0.525401473,
0.5947405696,
-0.0996172503,
-0.1482049376,
-0.0650981292,
0.0654965565,
0.2036225498,
0.4982535243,
-0.0220517628,
0.864557445,
0.3963969946,
-0.4522832632,
0.3249955177,
0.2340211421,
-0.2561689019,
0.2694314718,
-0.9007572532,
0.4187800288,
-0.2894537151,
0.3429995179,
-0.7472328544,
-0.1186915189,
0.5287231207,
-0.2675330341,
0.3699736595,
-0.0988637507,
-0.5401966572,
-0.4284934402,
-0.1105674505,
0.7367563248,
0.5846062303,
-0.7776836157,
1.1067156792,
0.0998198166,
0.3507315814,
-0.7720309496,
-0.8704825044,
-0.0992282182,
-0.4170481265,
-0.4696640968,
0.7922105193,
0.0935703516,
-0.1125400886,
-0.0295475181,
-0.3511469066,
-0.1222040579,
-0.0897785202,
-0.1240167469,
-0.1049310863,
-0.3177581429,
-0.0435704216,
-0.2349992096,
-0.2602932155,
0.1833789647,
-0.3450572491,
0.4080451131,
-0.0480047315,
-0.5192648768,
-0.3145747185,
0.133922115,
0.3962474763,
-0.3356660903,
0.7371994853,
0.7614258528,
-0.2785887718,
-0.2421907336,
-0.7857972383,
-0.4502337277,
-0.5200454593,
0.2805488706,
-0.3106075227,
-0.7954328656,
0.7819547653,
0.300603807,
-0.0611961894,
0.587262094,
0.498480618,
0.0716933236,
0.70252949,
0.7603107691,
-0.0736343339,
0.5698441267,
-0.0570738353,
0.4833354056,
-0.941382885,
-0.4222836196,
-0.447040081,
-0.2132599056,
-0.1756039262,
-0.8920198083,
0.3344473839,
-0.0831617266,
-0.071585238,
0.3474667668,
-0.7993878722,
0.6016878486,
0.3434585631,
0.4148770273,
0.3685400486,
0.2759640217,
0.2320702523,
-0.0881616548,
-0.7350705266,
-0.2180064619,
0.8363493681,
0.6667537689,
0.8958961964,
0.13470532,
0.3541179895,
0.1502433866,
0.3575388193,
-0.7616391778,
0.3522128761,
-0.1025797501,
-0.443805635,
-0.1502544582,
-0.4854441583,
-0.5884252191,
0.2084416151,
0.3090698719,
-0.8702111244,
0.2676221132,
0.5252459645,
-0.1949439794,
0.4155248106,
-0.4266676903,
0.8094495535,
-0.1925798357,
-0.6290357113,
-0.4111879766,
-0.7794942856,
0.3330331743,
-0.1413751245,
-0.0747589394,
0.260848701,
-0.0091747241,
0.4517457485,
-0.0971872807,
0.6061500907,
-0.0524755679,
-0.5473409295,
0.3568243086,
-0.1157885492,
0.7196677327,
0.0801050141,
-0.3226606548,
0.1089459807,
-0.7397448421,
-0.1426913738,
-0.8921210766,
0.5735860467,
-0.573697865,
-0.5568856597,
-0.0427419543,
-0.4675477147,
-0.1171293408,
0.094008185,
0.3164854646,
0.2833862603,
0.294460237,
0.4605380297,
0.9605784416,
-0.0781823322,
0.1557161063,
-0.0176163949,
-0.1819981933,
-0.067811206,
0.9118622541,
-0.3348499238,
0.3734309971,
0.7240347862,
0.4059310555,
-0.4436034858,
-0.3385525644,
-0.1867467463,
0.2302436978,
-1.1069500446,
-0.3357020319,
-0.7432630658,
-0.4826157391,
-0.1136720777,
-0.1604037881,
-0.7095854878,
-0.3677354753,
-0.3536852896,
0.195052892,
0.2587024271,
0.4583738148,
0.2203554213,
0.4587253928,
-0.5071977973,
0.6598898172,
0.3331988752,
0.6570475101,
0.3754622638,
-1.0625329018,
-0.1274240464,
-0.004325564,
-0.4505695105,
-0.644323349,
0.0552060716,
0.4044628739,
0.7561236024,
0.3588025272,
0.0616033264,
0.6849470735,
-0.5113962293,
0.6140868068,
-0.0203446317,
-0.9867254496,
0.7085587978,
-0.121334061,
0.3540309668,
0.2892190218,
0.0999227539,
-0.2736194432,
-0.5386958122,
-0.6887913346,
-0.9612872005,
0.6977174282,
0.5269796252,
0.2038687021,
0.3237412274,
0.6017699242,
-0.1196524724,
0.1239723787,
-1.037104845,
-0.4236544371,
-0.6065419316,
-0.1252833605,
-0.1454789639,
-0.4148559272,
-0.0374093652,
-0.2703027129,
0.6543834805,
-0.2452245057,
0.7815128565,
0.2927845418,
-0.229614839,
-0.2874613702,
0.4142551124,
0.6947237849,
0.6905300617,
-0.2290785313,
0.4478586316,
-0.0056785149,
-0.349920541,
0.048312854,
-0.0644526705,
-0.0727377087,
-0.0413567275,
0.4444976151,
0.7357780933,
0.2164667845,
-0.2577801943,
0.5809532404,
-0.0038286794,
0.0404559299,
-0.3053620756,
0.0237697884,
-0.10254886,
0.4809602797,
0.6673635244,
0.1937579364,
0.2109470814,
-0.3363932371,
0.266567111,
0.31137079,
-0.6639682055,
-0.3276498318,
0.8474566936,
-0.1249898523,
-0.105769977,
0.5717120171,
0.1981509626,
-0.852183044,
0.4654223025,
0.7029818296,
0.9754056931,
-0.3488096595,
-0.007551508,
0.2816713154,
0.4398300648,
-0.1774658859,
-0.0946610123,
-0.2799213529,
-0.8000203967,
-0.8132966757,
-0.5263507962,
-0.4415008724,
0.1948962063,
-0.5654283762,
0.1478155702,
-0.122441791,
-0.0284978487,
0.1014171317,
-0.6149456501,
-0.5522817373,
0.0076350085,
0.2544976175,
0.6741637588,
-0.5967866182,
0.8554596901,
0.6193190217,
-0.1115106791,
-0.703751266,
0.2429328859,
-0.4842635691,
-0.9274010062,
0.6460347772,
0.2172756046,
-0.3825443983,
0.0611272752,
-0.4640878141,
-0.9466354251,
0.8303832412,
0.5814889669,
-0.2450636178,
0.0050682859,
0.209606573,
0.6028048396,
-0.1956685483,
0.4798404574,
0.1822527647,
0.602086544,
0.3947630525,
-0.8616749048,
-0.0053925207,
-0.0436425023,
0.0487091057,
0.023324959,
-0.5109130144,
0.3463670909,
-0.3996152878,
-0.0854929537,
-0.296274364,
0.8769086599,
0.0524938144,
0.0442901403,
0.5865377188,
0.3484252393,
0.286385119,
-0.2273693532,
1.112431407,
-0.1530724168,
0.4593695104,
1.1181812286,
-0.0226322655,
0.7280184031,
0.8160533309,
-0.1253671795,
0.3298264742,
0.2401593477,
0.1060351357,
0.8341177106,
-0.0015660962,
0.0111194933,
-0.3481448591,
-0.4674671292,
-0.4141049385,
0.4309408367,
0.2346450984,
-0.6787568927,
-0.138985008,
0.0106391823,
-0.3665466905,
-0.075112693,
-0.3489503264,
0.6645059586,
0.1488528848,
-0.5328919888,
0.5235543847,
-0.2164977044,
0.6102746725,
-0.562928319,
-0.1547870338,
-0.0453427248,
0.5820772648,
-0.2620641291,
-1.0081152916,
0.6513610482,
-0.2737312615,
-0.3627582788,
-0.7022337317,
0.9904173017,
-0.4444135427,
-0.6457434893,
0.3490300179,
0.1670143455,
-0.0892607719,
-0.283962816,
-0.5080387592,
0.1377331614,
0.0452704541,
-0.486379236,
-0.0478027053,
0.3803757429,
-0.0374398939,
0.9158872962,
0.2532510161,
-0.0757386982,
0.0851436928,
0.317482233,
0.9697981477,
-0.3833922446,
-0.2917389572,
-0.698082149,
0.7348858714,
0.032025326,
0.0729509369,
0.5291398764,
0.3739659488,
0.6451234221,
-0.0989719555,
0.3795082569,
0.1986898333,
0.3754615188,
-0.2950970531,
0.5652042627,
-0.8266039491,
0.38068524,
-0.3994808495,
-1.5054740906,
-0.4564221501,
0.9190090895,
-0.0446228907,
0.1534851491,
0.5345211625,
0.5181356072,
-0.6699888706,
-0.1121204272,
0.2171359658,
0.2665069997,
0.377240181,
0.4916984439,
0.8987435699,
-0.6649982929,
0.7057667375,
-0.6263307333,
0.1076385975,
-0.2501053214,
-1.1523580551,
-0.7121626139,
-0.3997210562,
-0.3064054847,
-0.2372270077,
0.0520265624,
0.5322932005,
0.5479158759,
-0.7288833857,
0.2152298838,
-0.1368277967,
0.2054617703,
-0.3119166493,
-0.2506368458,
0.4515418708,
-0.097262457,
-0.3142170012,
0.313690722,
0.1692185402,
-0.0318409689,
-0.5948380828,
0.0766481832,
0.225630179,
-0.150091067,
0.7276816368,
-0.12697047,
-1.0998108387,
-0.562507093,
0.0556501411,
0.0097483648,
0.2714695036,
0.9747589231,
-0.9461113214,
0.2430626154,
0.3599714637,
0.7573558092,
0.5987546444,
0.0033222537,
0.577829361,
-1.0121198893,
0.3403161168,
0.5106529593,
0.2185818553,
0.5228069425,
-0.6395228505,
0.5214754939,
-0.0597101264,
-0.5179088116,
-0.8712480068,
0.297606647,
-1.1562336683,
0.1110859886,
1.063431859,
-0.013413582,
-0.2240196913,
-0.0473055243,
0.0389057696,
0.3813388646,
-0.4466887712,
0.8046948314,
0.2003526092,
0.1408426762,
-0.7622526884,
-0.4036584795,
0.2917767167,
0.5901928544,
-0.5333226919,
0.3845902085,
0.0199089013,
-0.2779528499,
0.5374827981,
0.2928633988,
-0.0988813043,
0.0264571309,
-0.3165925443,
-0.1634664387,
-0.0909247622,
-0.5205524564,
-0.2149736434,
0.1562716961,
-0.0305104982,
0.3339740932
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05591v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05591v1
|
SoftEDA: Rethinking Rule-Based Data Augmentation with Soft Labels
| 2024-02-08T11:44:25 | 2024-02-08T11:44:25 |
Juhwan Choi, Kyohoon Jin, Junho Lee, Sangmin Song, Youngbin Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Rule-based text data augmentation is widely used for NLP tasks due to its
simplicity. However, this method can potentially damage the original meaning of
the text, ultimately hurting the performance of the model. To overcome this
limitation, we propose a straightforward technique for applying soft labels to
augmented data. We conducted experiments across seven different classification
tasks and empirically demonstrated the effectiveness of our proposed approach.
We have publicly opened our source code for reproducibility.
|
[
-0.0543214679,
-0.9579769969,
0.3092830479,
-0.0368030928,
-0.4219552875,
-0.2974870801,
-0.1897345483,
-0.7194164991,
0.3737835884,
0.9911555052,
-0.7751974463,
-0.5357350707,
-0.4423382282,
0.0694513768,
-0.3362340629,
1.5045558214,
-0.0188328736,
-0.3771719933,
-0.1499407291,
-0.4011148512,
-0.6907058358,
-0.6252192855,
-0.162295714,
-0.2225039899,
0.7272341847,
0.6695662737,
1.16527915,
0.7294660211,
0.7043579817,
0.3780864179,
-0.32888183,
0.6134192348,
-0.3473243713,
0.3700171113,
-0.1184719056,
-0.5859801173,
-1.0211800337,
-0.1270745248,
0.587187767,
1.1766322851,
-0.0514077768,
0.0413905866,
0.1290133446,
0.6514159441,
-0.5015469193,
0.0752379745,
-0.4779735506,
0.2000132948,
-0.3621788919,
-0.2143500596,
-0.2834146321,
-0.4947354496,
0.1400855333,
-0.8745746613,
0.4207775891,
-0.0324888602,
0.6213477254,
0.4815120697,
-0.4458538592,
-0.1977988482,
-0.9296229482,
0.7444165945,
-0.780959785,
0.2196227759,
0.1642194092,
-0.0222312994,
-0.1619392782,
-1.0647718906,
-0.6281548738,
0.022313999,
-0.1617421061,
-0.2131638825,
0.1968242079,
0.2351005822,
0.424028933,
0.5781078339,
-0.1815439761,
0.1114308909,
-0.3489376605,
-0.0052614063,
0.747674644,
0.2596426904,
0.3472692072,
-0.1535534859,
-0.3195239007,
-0.1694804579,
-0.6368032694,
-0.2287068069,
0.2760840058,
0.701394558,
0.2165637463,
0.8226040006,
-0.1355913877,
0.5419849157,
0.2055793703,
-0.1127072796,
0.9718145728,
-0.3055953979,
-0.2292306125,
0.1873071492,
0.4746277034,
0.3746906817,
-0.0618951991,
-0.409280479,
-0.2860588431,
0.0049341642,
0.371392101,
-0.7618175745,
0.1898797601,
0.1864462793,
-0.4429187775,
-0.4433618188,
-0.1209462732,
-0.9047503471,
-0.5892280936,
-0.4106014669,
0.7565280199,
-0.2362027615,
-0.2597348988,
0.2047057897,
-0.1032180414,
-0.0571862385,
0.2948627472,
-0.9411329627,
0.503035605,
1.1274507046,
0.6645789742,
0.056568794,
-0.331256777,
-0.3302486837,
0.1229339987,
-0.3906272352,
0.9569634199,
-0.4100188315,
-0.4581101835,
-0.0750862882,
0.2088225335,
0.1391774565,
-0.4682755172,
1.1156328917,
-0.2570303679,
0.2048555464,
-0.1095460728,
-0.7300487161,
-0.3865174651,
-0.123387292,
-1.0005199909,
0.8726618886,
0.0084051043,
-0.5325315595,
0.695544064,
-0.6686943173,
-0.74868536,
0.2782135606,
0.1173840687,
-0.6355531812,
0.0855311304,
0.0216223858,
0.5206766725,
0.0046142638,
0.4808571041,
-0.3580970764,
-0.492708683,
0.3027683794,
-0.574272573,
0.611503005,
0.0750175864,
-0.4189789593,
0.165996626,
-0.799281776,
0.0536896326,
-0.0933805555,
-0.3431242406,
-0.6869996786,
0.1575817019,
0.2284390032,
-0.1142479554,
0.1971603185,
-0.5197328925,
0.6308803558,
-0.8247036338,
-0.0932854861,
0.91578722,
-0.3164105117,
0.6847389936,
-0.4745708406,
0.3096532226,
-0.2847372293,
0.2935637832,
-0.113977544,
-0.6355107427,
-0.5121016502,
-0.2071394771,
0.7228665948,
0.5631793141,
-0.9544317126,
0.3391841948,
-0.2893679142,
-0.632399559,
-0.857693553,
0.655538857,
0.1835898012,
0.7674242854,
0.5647030473,
-0.3027756512,
-0.7113009691,
-0.9265704751,
-0.2573312819,
0.1541373581,
-0.0237317123,
0.3951497078,
0.3621727824,
-0.7236620784,
0.7324978709,
-0.7172576785,
-0.4852125645,
-0.2060818672,
0.2514986992,
0.5753129125,
0.6051883698,
0.465436697,
-1.0475255251,
0.0721981302,
-0.1714603454,
-0.6543534398,
-0.3740124106,
-0.0701347739,
0.131676048,
0.1159868017,
0.3781206012,
-0.4262160659,
0.5507901907,
0.3609131277,
-0.5385147929,
0.5844433904,
-0.3640341163,
0.2620242536,
-0.8400994539,
-0.1076259762,
0.1851672679,
-0.1330286115,
-0.921223104,
0.2684274316,
0.0019210248,
-0.0094044674,
-0.5629841685,
0.457649231,
-0.1819474846,
0.156607151,
-0.6190198064,
-0.2909536362,
0.1547490805,
0.4933680594,
0.167451933,
0.5599988699,
0.3469549119,
-0.741887629,
0.3726859689,
0.336933136,
-0.3647279143,
0.4802695215,
-0.9209090471,
0.1525831521,
-0.3516146243,
0.4003439248,
-0.8747282028,
-0.1477614492,
0.2952035367,
-0.1562432498,
0.3140444458,
-0.2565566599,
-0.61288625,
0.0192693211,
-0.5361712575,
0.6840209961,
0.5055750012,
-0.7200625539,
0.7099900246,
0.6139342189,
-0.144504115,
-0.407561034,
-0.7481575012,
0.2342082113,
-0.517919004,
-0.7621484399,
0.7764791846,
-0.0911715105,
-0.2551861107,
0.0418972448,
0.1424862593,
-0.272941798,
0.1160387471,
0.5871879458,
0.2205509841,
-0.1830245107,
0.1654007435,
0.2735314071,
-0.1784590185,
-0.2491969615,
0.1560636014,
0.1756931245,
-0.071770072,
-0.0034199916,
-0.4436606765,
0.4761627018,
0.3610226214,
0.1762195677,
0.856530726,
0.4985183775,
-0.4990125299,
-0.3311246037,
-0.3165521622,
-0.0813795179,
-0.6355558634,
0.0180335939,
-0.2699202895,
-0.4527525902,
0.2403362095,
-0.2635641396,
0.3409578204,
0.5845342278,
0.3070838749,
-0.3125279248,
1.1930468082,
0.815502286,
0.3316833973,
0.5418911576,
-0.1955575645,
-0.1433530003,
-0.8201355338,
-0.4121451974,
-0.5030130744,
-0.4739455581,
-0.7082444429,
-0.3824262619,
0.2677071691,
-0.2625791728,
0.2320303768,
0.297347635,
-0.6697447896,
0.1892107874,
0.4185034335,
0.5239144564,
0.2170971781,
-0.1083872169,
0.4043284953,
-0.2540899813,
-0.7228655219,
-0.3819592893,
1.1773319244,
0.4066223502,
1.0160161257,
0.1533112973,
0.4532312453,
0.7306415439,
0.3831668496,
-0.7293933034,
0.586841464,
-0.6414683461,
-0.6874314547,
0.0144028943,
-0.5264543295,
-1.2480247021,
0.0878714696,
-0.4951808155,
-0.2688904405,
0.5207031965,
0.3142158389,
-0.2046130896,
0.1351788342,
-1.0515395403,
0.6607838869,
-0.3106188774,
-0.4230662286,
0.0772323981,
-0.3575931191,
0.3244432509,
-0.1708892733,
0.5051797032,
0.0984994397,
-0.3628398478,
1.4307258129,
-0.9776520133,
1.1440856457,
-0.2878921926,
-0.3649422824,
0.3386962116,
-0.2976228893,
0.3264944255,
-0.1986490041,
-0.1181767657,
0.0369647257,
-0.0761765614,
-0.3724703789,
-0.7976450324,
0.7387124896,
-0.4430634677,
-0.370225668,
-0.3724957407,
-0.5893545151,
-0.2473332137,
0.06208786,
-0.2029610425,
0.6890838742,
0.1972006112,
0.3338653147,
0.6666246057,
-0.1732483953,
-0.0462447144,
0.52688694,
-0.147185117,
-0.4768858552,
1.0601462126,
0.3974928558,
-0.0237641893,
-0.0682692155,
0.2686475813,
-0.4253363609,
-0.5508977175,
-0.3734760582,
0.0063608312,
-0.432041347,
-0.2206729501,
-0.3969202638,
0.1373270601,
-0.5886301398,
-0.1794116497,
-0.2591754794,
-0.8445228934,
-0.4104778767,
-0.224750638,
0.7849330902,
0.6946216226,
-0.2154785246,
0.5263796449,
-0.6772147417,
0.7276465297,
0.2418597788,
0.6824535131,
-0.4674458802,
-0.5604697466,
-0.0886102766,
0.3438546956,
0.064732261,
-1.0787389278,
0.3172167242,
0.4025156796,
0.5383060575,
0.2843618095,
-0.068674989,
0.6486626863,
-0.6837467551,
0.4628975987,
-0.0632996336,
-0.8403285146,
0.7581547499,
-0.2206834108,
-0.0529892519,
0.7199962735,
0.0770673081,
-0.3653859198,
0.0135447979,
-0.8835954666,
-1.3361045122,
0.4214017689,
0.0299562477,
0.4049758315,
0.2962333262,
0.8088903427,
0.5462025404,
0.2515876591,
-0.3196022511,
-0.4644262493,
-0.1728508323,
-0.5141506791,
-0.121756278,
-0.3706673682,
0.1966909021,
-0.3300480843,
0.6784178615,
-0.1396449804,
-0.0309238005,
0.1862182617,
-0.1660411358,
0.0029422806,
0.1182828769,
0.2361769378,
0.2964946628,
-0.3318212628,
0.0220492817,
0.3168226779,
-0.6007928848,
-0.0524055436,
0.3473905921,
-0.5865411162,
0.1717964262,
0.3033978343,
0.7097565532,
0.5248452425,
-0.7618732452,
0.1649916172,
-0.0176729746,
-0.348023504,
0.1481220722,
0.3345618844,
-0.5056909323,
-0.0773556903,
0.4094188511,
0.0788090378,
0.5443964601,
-0.8384712338,
0.6418864131,
0.2448827773,
-0.4019348919,
-0.2234791368,
0.6025292277,
0.4302522838,
-0.5952254534,
0.0861760303,
0.1276730448,
-0.6257640123,
0.5400246382,
0.5834563375,
0.5346523523,
-0.2359479666,
0.2384475321,
-0.0254036058,
0.3206214905,
-0.0542291887,
0.3252825737,
0.0961176381,
-0.6704354882,
-0.7855415344,
-0.335043937,
-0.7417101264,
0.0739816055,
-0.5676317215,
0.2189860344,
-0.5751923919,
-0.3279395103,
0.2994675636,
0.1901563853,
-0.5097797513,
0.5815169215,
0.1764512062,
0.8049381971,
-0.9543013573,
0.4376938045,
0.7091605067,
-0.2614038885,
-0.5307258964,
-0.3443760574,
-0.0057022385,
-0.4766016006,
0.1337570995,
0.0520686582,
0.0496526584,
-0.384539336,
-0.818790555,
-0.5102558732,
0.7290391922,
0.0897514001,
-0.2936047912,
0.1375862062,
0.1260069609,
0.7936475873,
-0.0344370641,
0.0491543449,
0.5336889625,
0.6365791559,
-0.0508156717,
-0.7499184012,
0.1366011798,
-0.5722401738,
-0.4736357033,
0.1951694787,
-0.3741383851,
0.5650638342,
-0.1673592478,
-0.1918729842,
0.0101530878,
0.9596708417,
-0.0449582934,
0.7090750933,
0.7604157329,
0.4390046,
0.9637540579,
-0.0763742328,
1.0360519886,
0.2329242229,
0.209700346,
1.1100885868,
-0.319629848,
0.5878241658,
0.3320397437,
-0.0583203174,
0.6702040434,
0.3075097203,
-0.0827130824,
0.4247404933,
-0.1879145354,
-0.1934361905,
0.1462205201,
-0.5730453134,
-0.3652131259,
0.3140535355,
0.6918085217,
-0.1127115339,
0.0306451228,
0.1657385975,
0.1366025656,
0.1449085027,
-0.6131747365,
0.9336465001,
-0.1542267948,
-0.3310000598,
0.4229440391,
0.1057878658,
1.1487079859,
-0.3330416381,
-0.3105672002,
-0.0087400591,
0.3274987638,
-0.5258343816,
-1.1268635988,
0.5805877447,
0.2317371517,
-0.0259717591,
-0.4066717327,
1.2053706646,
-0.3738399148,
-0.7933117151,
-0.0549128316,
0.3897972703,
0.0696787909,
0.2049924582,
-0.7945305705,
-0.0669236928,
-0.0676725134,
-0.2239899933,
0.1811963171,
0.4394337833,
0.0850363821,
0.789465487,
0.8796362281,
0.0210187174,
-0.0018571572,
0.08427836,
0.9172185063,
-0.6064075828,
-0.2823992372,
-0.6117473841,
0.4470383823,
-0.0161844306,
-0.3180269599,
0.8282267451,
0.4805676639,
0.2456152737,
0.203959927,
0.6438132524,
-0.0960764512,
0.6957996488,
-0.546656549,
0.5096415877,
-0.705834806,
0.3907546401,
-0.6052163839,
-0.7037309408,
-0.517475009,
0.2689721286,
-0.2466836721,
-0.0650209337,
0.3088245392,
0.7860769033,
-0.1075696945,
0.1449522674,
-0.0615792461,
0.2966316342,
0.1796305329,
0.3340129256,
0.5611673594,
-0.5382074714,
0.6620458364,
-0.603197217,
-0.3136823475,
-0.2889135182,
-0.7977162004,
-0.5032488108,
-0.6078688502,
-0.5875009894,
-0.5540959835,
0.1284404695,
0.7102789879,
0.6406789422,
-0.6427473426,
0.3609315455,
0.1384891123,
0.5320269465,
-0.3863250911,
-0.2718885839,
0.4751255214,
-0.056638319,
-0.7695496678,
0.624247551,
-0.2089802474,
0.1451357305,
0.027146956,
0.0401155949,
-0.071068652,
0.0096617546,
0.550748229,
0.4172126651,
-0.0158962645,
-0.1678201109,
-0.2806221545,
0.1207121536,
-0.0360731147,
0.7940503359,
-1.1164610386,
0.1548048407,
0.5534486771,
0.5892759562,
0.2070466578,
0.2393386215,
0.5684861541,
-0.8342847228,
0.2288744003,
0.288978368,
0.3061761856,
0.387580663,
-0.5469210744,
0.5156635046,
0.2800393701,
-0.4376481473,
-1.1719762087,
-0.1095068082,
-1.1984652281,
-0.4507887363,
1.3028916121,
0.1900651157,
-0.6016449332,
-0.2439971715,
-0.5490299463,
-0.0254617482,
-0.3207697272,
0.7402356267,
0.0142462924,
0.1332388669,
0.1443386525,
-0.4438994229,
0.5740848184,
0.4730606377,
-0.9824114442,
-0.1078330129,
0.550981462,
0.3103321195,
0.312730372,
0.4859564006,
0.1410356909,
0.3654696345,
-0.0669747666,
-0.1119411364,
-0.1917832196,
-0.4323198497,
-0.2627441287,
0.301024884,
-0.1506623179,
-0.0530964658
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05584v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05584v1
|
AutoAugment Is What You Need: Enhancing Rule-based Augmentation Methods in Low-resource Regimes
| 2024-02-08T11:36:23 | 2024-02-08T11:36:23 |
Juhwan Choi, Kyohoon Jin, Junho Lee, Sangmin Song, Youngbin Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Text data augmentation is a complex problem due to the discrete nature of
sentences. Although rule-based augmentation methods are widely adopted in
real-world applications because of their simplicity, they suffer from potential
semantic damage. Previous researchers have suggested easy data augmentation
with soft labels (softEDA), employing label smoothing to mitigate this problem.
However, finding the best factor for each model and dataset is challenging;
therefore, using softEDA in real-world applications is still difficult. In this
paper, we propose adapting AutoAugment to solve this problem. The experimental
results suggest that the proposed method can boost existing augmentation
methods and that rule-based methods can enhance cutting-edge pre-trained
language models. We offer the source code.
|
[
-0.2194535881,
-0.885566771,
0.3922864199,
0.1700199246,
-0.4340312779,
0.0019069184,
-0.2075377703,
-0.5478962064,
0.0796817765,
0.6473065019,
-0.6560829878,
-0.2592790723,
-0.541161418,
0.2112895548,
-0.3833148479,
1.0389904976,
-0.0744940937,
-0.4466394186,
-0.2194674164,
-0.2668537199,
-0.5496747494,
-0.6082267165,
-0.3008341491,
-0.1611980945,
0.2698084712,
0.6839954853,
0.8755677342,
1.1053082943,
0.5462095141,
0.4914994538,
0.2112948895,
0.6631731391,
-0.4226896465,
0.1806963235,
-0.1907484233,
-0.2924190164,
-0.8381906748,
-0.0532265417,
0.5501197577,
0.6805078387,
-0.0946918875,
-0.0121312076,
0.1648080349,
0.6275422573,
-0.6038547158,
0.2350033522,
-0.424606055,
-0.1711584777,
-0.1321990192,
-0.3166995645,
-0.1407677978,
-0.4558739364,
0.2248838395,
-0.9603644609,
-0.0029666517,
0.2500274479,
1.0077620745,
0.7069176435,
-0.1826625019,
-0.3056746423,
-0.8139116764,
0.686817348,
-0.8400139213,
0.2181797624,
0.4720985889,
-0.0355801955,
-0.2247794867,
-0.7092306614,
-0.6595339179,
-0.0871925279,
-0.4847426713,
-0.1989732832,
-0.1843862534,
0.2004816979,
0.2488756478,
0.4967998266,
-0.4385924041,
0.277915597,
-0.1643077731,
-0.2173891366,
0.725658834,
0.0118021592,
0.4632887542,
-0.2138292789,
-0.1377096176,
-0.3306692243,
-0.2318048775,
-0.172920689,
0.3718694746,
0.3528049886,
-0.1101298183,
0.3669775426,
-0.4649954438,
0.9057497978,
0.3695527911,
0.0171933137,
0.6692544818,
-0.7231560349,
-0.445171386,
-0.0013667275,
0.7010464668,
0.1797954142,
0.3140141964,
-0.1262706369,
-0.2467315644,
-0.2154714018,
0.1444379687,
-0.9955464005,
-0.3228057921,
-0.1060258448,
-0.4279702604,
-0.2719491422,
-0.0999752209,
-0.8748025894,
-0.3192816377,
-0.4395570755,
0.5257835388,
-0.4313863814,
-0.0270880908,
0.1147289202,
0.2295070142,
0.0099846916,
0.3362850547,
-0.9435147047,
0.2704739571,
0.4782195389,
0.8354018927,
0.0001487192,
-0.1006420255,
-0.5511780381,
0.1181444526,
-0.1128851622,
1.0519512892,
-0.6397222877,
-0.3995196819,
-0.1742417365,
0.1427329928,
-0.0087399073,
-0.4012931883,
0.7047845721,
-0.2556579411,
0.4361013174,
0.1516759098,
-0.5463622212,
-0.2016379684,
-0.0614273883,
-0.7246034145,
1.1823424101,
0.2423121631,
-0.3101775348,
0.5822654366,
-1.0005910397,
-0.8748890162,
0.2349156588,
0.1317236722,
-0.5802806616,
-0.0859286711,
0.6387829781,
0.3922007382,
0.0771699175,
0.222007066,
-0.1796698123,
-0.2298433483,
0.1933281124,
-0.4894385338,
0.6967208982,
0.181928128,
-0.3274215162,
0.2127353251,
-0.9119428992,
0.0103218611,
-0.1655660272,
-0.3477539122,
-0.7678415179,
0.2302191108,
0.0113664968,
0.1640394032,
0.3786685467,
-0.3479605019,
0.3851044178,
-0.8059872985,
0.2536301911,
0.8786101341,
0.0002146167,
0.8572183251,
-0.2029045969,
0.3120950162,
-0.0075916424,
0.3659129143,
-0.2388872057,
-0.1379633248,
-1.009088397,
-0.4939165115,
0.7121649384,
0.6817448139,
-1.090054512,
0.7213337421,
-0.3038422465,
-0.3616960347,
-0.951849997,
0.7475582361,
0.1093253866,
0.5192317963,
0.607155323,
-0.5067558289,
-0.604744494,
-1.0203262568,
-0.2401479781,
-0.1228492558,
-0.0215228461,
0.3580929637,
0.1393389702,
-0.5298596621,
1.1622769833,
-0.6541914344,
-0.6262760758,
-0.001467461,
0.3534868658,
0.1608325541,
0.6252636909,
0.638610065,
-0.8301540613,
-0.2932502627,
-0.0284095667,
-0.6033681035,
-0.5450613499,
-0.2216056138,
-0.1188862994,
0.1385558844,
0.6607044935,
-0.125191167,
0.3491630256,
0.5058209896,
-0.4404025078,
-0.0047200597,
-0.6406720281,
0.1540461928,
-0.8382568955,
-0.0802852586,
0.2061212808,
-0.6290608048,
-0.733312428,
-0.1523094177,
0.0772459432,
0.0786779821,
-0.1757854968,
0.5375417471,
-0.4713865221,
0.2032497078,
-0.6241900325,
0.1103411838,
0.0653035715,
0.3773522973,
-0.1254362613,
0.7863603234,
0.4497606456,
-0.8388813138,
0.4021235704,
0.2562777996,
-0.4038236737,
0.5468838811,
-0.5242905617,
-0.0745405927,
-0.4470270574,
0.3381840587,
-0.9289059043,
-0.2867624164,
0.3821131587,
-0.0712456331,
0.2592462301,
-0.0283004828,
-0.6135833859,
-0.1915365607,
-0.2098701894,
0.406652391,
0.6168596745,
-0.6777778268,
0.7884246707,
0.5117968917,
-0.5342006683,
-0.2589554489,
-0.5317667723,
0.2920119166,
-0.2631535232,
-0.3566783369,
0.5247348547,
-0.3030004203,
-0.1324650198,
0.0116427224,
0.2804141045,
-0.2351885289,
0.1732679904,
0.2387609184,
0.4046776593,
-0.0668421611,
0.2137767076,
0.2525857389,
-0.2545056641,
-0.4043525457,
-0.2655105293,
0.184047699,
0.033553753,
0.0950640216,
-0.4613814652,
0.146840319,
0.463504374,
-0.2151729614,
0.4406871796,
0.6695271134,
-0.3164281249,
-0.3432508409,
-0.5474248528,
-0.2678924799,
-0.6577968597,
0.3292779624,
-0.1022428349,
-0.8073928356,
0.0610031486,
-0.2400910407,
0.1254828423,
0.46745947,
0.5595738888,
-0.1782037765,
0.9210351706,
1.0131070614,
-0.1531389058,
0.8065885305,
0.1143423468,
0.2437955141,
-0.5133117437,
-0.0476617813,
-0.4860998392,
-0.263117522,
-0.7799779773,
-0.4011311531,
0.1528950632,
-0.1524119824,
0.262283057,
0.5078693628,
-0.7491247654,
0.3636622429,
0.3537226319,
0.2673506439,
0.3350528181,
0.1378733069,
0.2458264679,
-0.0722227395,
-0.9039424062,
-0.356690377,
0.6866514087,
0.4520009756,
0.9162189364,
0.0040928693,
0.5193434954,
0.6868028045,
0.5176308155,
-0.7805348039,
0.5435674191,
-0.5528412461,
-0.4519069493,
-0.4317033291,
-0.6290338635,
-0.8693566322,
0.1294698268,
-0.4839766026,
-0.4373413622,
0.7214287519,
0.3514530659,
-0.5809129477,
-0.1987523288,
-0.8946342468,
0.5940346122,
-0.3486659229,
-0.3458285034,
0.1063079014,
-0.2832698226,
0.1777718663,
-0.4405752718,
0.7397320271,
-0.1675490439,
-0.1007454172,
1.0117286444,
-0.9114980102,
0.9589439631,
-0.245478034,
-0.3639143109,
0.312834233,
-0.3037779331,
0.5821325779,
-0.2700337768,
0.0263830908,
-0.3279508054,
-0.1490616798,
-0.3779552579,
-0.7502337694,
0.7110753655,
-0.5703420639,
-0.3530926704,
-0.3297649026,
-0.6900337338,
-0.2994848788,
0.2296546251,
-0.0458942764,
0.4231230617,
-0.0439056158,
0.0117278155,
0.4952482879,
-0.072336264,
0.8205609322,
0.7414471507,
-0.053182181,
-0.4060056806,
1.1378688812,
0.2327151597,
-0.0230963249,
0.0310599785,
0.1181089729,
-0.449624002,
-0.5395168662,
-0.7189672589,
0.0917379707,
-0.4786140919,
-0.3627824783,
-0.5961712599,
0.078205578,
-0.4436168671,
-0.1778353006,
-0.1405788064,
-0.7601485252,
-0.4935486019,
-0.0645924211,
0.8638711572,
0.4984054267,
-0.2900795639,
0.7452252507,
-0.6429290771,
0.6918829083,
0.4648788571,
0.5156596303,
-0.3097752035,
-0.806640625,
-0.4127336144,
-0.0015085769,
0.0948455036,
-0.6604701281,
0.4337231517,
0.7123730779,
0.370533824,
0.2286380976,
0.1368996799,
0.9639306068,
-0.5917302966,
0.2889112234,
-0.0464393198,
-0.9719683528,
0.5831685662,
-0.1441408992,
0.2604906559,
0.9155495167,
0.0972624719,
-0.2147191614,
-0.3938140869,
-0.5685560107,
-1.1865340471,
0.6464149952,
0.246197626,
0.3865825236,
0.3543319404,
0.6987934709,
0.047745578,
-0.0016836161,
-0.6399379373,
-0.2829074562,
-0.339292556,
-0.6788752079,
-0.1288928092,
-0.0596456379,
0.3470613062,
-0.3468372226,
1.0329376459,
-0.2887457013,
-0.1625472307,
0.2561124265,
-0.504439652,
-0.1253526807,
0.314301163,
0.2933656573,
0.3467816114,
-0.1172969937,
-0.1453647465,
0.2958311737,
-0.5242028832,
0.3125038445,
0.6528134346,
-0.5787573457,
0.016470328,
0.2319272161,
0.8120403886,
0.4206244648,
-0.5073078275,
0.3288898468,
-0.0482886583,
-0.1253857762,
0.2042001337,
0.4001903832,
-0.5208432674,
-0.0280219465,
0.5602463484,
-0.1046650186,
0.3436249793,
-0.6443912983,
0.5898166299,
0.1919442713,
-0.3742023706,
0.0891798362,
0.4809443355,
0.4953067303,
-0.3576684892,
0.2464756668,
-0.1871567667,
-0.5190657973,
0.2854640186,
0.412116915,
0.6260590553,
-0.5391604304,
0.180364877,
0.2554454207,
0.5367099643,
0.0209799521,
0.1410925388,
-0.0014418004,
-0.5386878252,
-0.8768479228,
-0.7698122859,
-0.2902243435,
0.0808342844,
-0.4356585443,
0.0775261596,
-0.5025168657,
-0.2754500508,
0.1494670957,
0.0391651727,
-0.5640761852,
0.5467174649,
0.1014206409,
0.7179442048,
-0.7689499855,
0.9043700099,
0.6399145126,
-0.1865285486,
-0.4078440666,
-0.1375265121,
-0.2915676832,
-0.5853610039,
0.3004187942,
-0.1143111661,
-0.1712153852,
0.1916884035,
-0.5633140206,
-0.6883069873,
0.8109307289,
0.013895453,
-0.6101116538,
-0.0719404146,
0.134465903,
0.5867034197,
-0.4173234403,
0.0699627772,
0.7041461468,
0.8407982588,
-0.1993829757,
-0.9191079736,
0.0932104439,
-0.3381448984,
-0.0327416621,
0.1566517502,
-0.4595730007,
0.3646408916,
0.1592343152,
-0.2600109875,
-0.0408990309,
0.9451143742,
-0.379111737,
0.1205258369,
0.8679554462,
0.3496452272,
0.815731883,
-0.0516044423,
0.8518593311,
-0.1712318957,
0.2781549394,
1.1967947483,
-0.2589202225,
0.4757667482,
0.1849748641,
0.1451629698,
0.9297524691,
0.53427881,
-0.2283818275,
0.6015078425,
-0.0606709123,
-0.1864602715,
-0.2058082819,
-0.4111109078,
-0.01942279,
0.5960848331,
0.6444233656,
-0.1888818741,
-0.1123285368,
0.2990174294,
0.0804000273,
0.2190291286,
-0.4419696033,
1.1026651859,
-0.1176088825,
-0.4938437939,
0.4909214973,
0.3073273003,
0.8999055624,
-0.4248728454,
-0.0687372535,
-0.1307102144,
0.133290574,
-0.327783972,
-0.5098116994,
0.1535752118,
0.1463936418,
-0.1218180507,
-0.4092190564,
1.1911283731,
-0.7078256607,
-0.7404369116,
0.1817631274,
0.6387045979,
-0.220063284,
0.2747795582,
-0.8477618098,
-0.0945642143,
-0.0642322227,
0.0361476168,
0.1652037501,
0.4560190141,
0.0658439547,
0.5891009569,
0.766676724,
-0.0266046524,
-0.0415880345,
-0.0720253289,
0.9995118976,
-0.5607055426,
-0.6711630225,
-0.9381177425,
0.3158868849,
-0.2903799415,
0.032764364,
0.8044084311,
0.4595090449,
0.4803336859,
0.1986954063,
0.9284937382,
-0.0118262637,
0.5366919637,
-0.5363818407,
0.8127995729,
-0.5500510335,
0.1023153365,
-0.4403429627,
-0.9166570306,
-0.399068445,
0.7499089837,
-0.4346576035,
0.0149638839,
0.3617958128,
0.8393250108,
-0.3236810565,
-0.3043869734,
0.1533407718,
0.4031433761,
0.0179269724,
0.299990952,
0.4460088611,
-0.4548220634,
0.6326331496,
-0.3022552431,
-0.6306792498,
-0.358315289,
-1.083706975,
-0.7481184602,
-0.53997612,
-0.7030508518,
-0.214267388,
0.209593147,
0.7645260096,
0.9324538708,
-0.7449471951,
0.0699092075,
0.1229727119,
0.0707030371,
-0.0024490689,
-0.2875650525,
0.449044764,
-0.4137127399,
-0.8025403619,
0.7114683986,
0.2878704965,
0.3789010942,
-0.0434944928,
0.0102807907,
-0.2741750777,
0.374573946,
0.6839162111,
0.4832389355,
-0.148160398,
-0.203141436,
-0.3665829897,
-0.0703429058,
0.1562562287,
0.8283855319,
-1.1066279411,
0.4669732153,
0.3081572056,
0.6043711305,
0.2797781825,
0.4806639254,
0.620600462,
-0.8561125398,
0.2905448973,
-0.0169262029,
0.1997988373,
0.551107049,
-0.3993752301,
0.398049593,
0.102220282,
-0.4322567284,
-0.7790951729,
0.0825424492,
-0.7721329331,
-0.2865667939,
0.9135048985,
0.0315956995,
-0.3902484775,
-0.4333424568,
-0.3129504621,
0.2018440515,
-0.4458349347,
0.7636245489,
0.5494711399,
0.0614140481,
-0.2083614469,
-0.5037295818,
0.8008703589,
0.4776568413,
-1.3085294962,
0.174501881,
0.7206616998,
0.0933474526,
0.1405442953,
0.6416414976,
0.0297752004,
0.168654412,
-0.428452462,
-0.1818834841,
-0.2385527939,
-0.1741798967,
-0.4374475777,
-0.0945488364,
-0.021054009,
-0.0095747141
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05581v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05581v1
|
Establishing degrees of closeness between audio recordings along different dimensions using large-scale cross-lingual models
| 2024-02-08T11:31:23 | 2024-02-08T11:31:23 |
Maxime Fily, Guillaume Wisniewski, Severine Guillaume, Gilles Adda, Alexis Michaud
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
In the highly constrained context of low-resource language studies, we
explore vector representations of speech from a pretrained model to determine
their level of abstraction with regard to the audio signal. We propose a new
unsupervised method using ABX tests on audio recordings with carefully curated
metadata to shed light on the type of information present in the
representations. ABX tests determine whether the representations computed by a
multilingual speech model encode a given characteristic. Three experiments are
devised: one on room acoustics aspects, one on linguistic genre, and one on
phonetic aspects. The results confirm that the representations extracted from
recordings with different linguistic/extra-linguistic characteristics differ
along the same lines. Embedding more audio signal in one vector better
discriminates extra-linguistic characteristics, whereas shorter snippets are
better to distinguish segmental information. The method is fully unsupervised,
potentially opening new research avenues for comparative work on
under-documented languages.
|
[
-0.8453620672,
-0.4526773691,
0.3087394238,
0.136054486,
-0.1440809518,
0.0048925136,
-0.6063033342,
-0.5017949343,
0.4657719135,
0.337133348,
-0.3258520365,
-0.6666005254,
-0.5721225739,
0.0796641409,
-0.5702335238,
0.3863209188,
0.1169594601,
0.248783052,
-0.4025483429,
-0.5617700815,
-0.1689794213,
-0.8610031605,
-0.2409323305,
-0.4401585162,
0.2344009727,
0.0376109518,
0.5438038707,
0.5923786163,
0.3541325331,
0.2444373071,
-0.303748101,
-0.2002218813,
-0.0519952141,
-0.1782565266,
-0.1482344866,
-0.5998345613,
-0.0940699205,
0.1218829527,
0.9216400385,
1.1945518255,
0.0173161831,
0.4055621326,
0.1453407407,
0.1167720184,
-0.4918219745,
0.0650662556,
-0.3833294511,
0.2764927149,
-0.1933787912,
-0.29738307,
-0.4142034352,
0.1198050901,
-0.0533238351,
-0.3406853378,
0.3159333766,
-0.0620000921,
0.7629953027,
0.2424123883,
-0.4470413625,
-0.0629066974,
-1.0843701363,
1.0036358833,
-0.6424599886,
1.0355966091,
0.5134398341,
0.1804997176,
0.271022439,
-0.3244229555,
-0.4213053286,
-0.0817175582,
-0.3128779829,
-0.1822419465,
-0.3102865517,
-0.0657106712,
0.4165706635,
0.3725005984,
-0.4239629805,
0.1941513866,
-0.3383107483,
-0.4474911094,
0.6017429233,
-0.3185255826,
0.3833271265,
-0.1750947237,
-0.1502155066,
-0.3821407259,
-0.677688539,
0.1221338809,
0.450979501,
0.4043588936,
-0.3044525385,
0.777115643,
-0.0751823708,
0.2524989843,
-0.1115883365,
-0.2387239486,
0.7086222172,
-0.3676435649,
0.1648714244,
0.5394548774,
0.8125927448,
0.0695486516,
0.0781541243,
-0.058229357,
-0.3633720577,
0.0548042096,
-0.3047329485,
-0.4992054701,
-0.0380438343,
0.0673079491,
-0.7404761314,
0.3427406251,
0.0060478812,
-0.4030292928,
-0.2011843026,
-0.7880917192,
0.4090229273,
-0.3829545379,
-0.5306429863,
-0.1152692661,
-0.1711718589,
0.147892341,
-0.2499367446,
-0.7651566267,
0.2878990173,
0.5764496922,
0.8620752692,
-0.1427848488,
-0.304676652,
-0.6384617686,
0.0881259516,
-0.3755490482,
0.656555295,
-0.8431400657,
-0.6306274533,
0.063305147,
-0.1589839309,
0.4488531351,
-0.6503363252,
0.3413469493,
-0.1921163499,
0.0502614006,
-0.3056546748,
-0.4911282957,
-0.1876540035,
-0.1127696037,
-0.7825115919,
1.0311285257,
0.2755615115,
-0.8329682946,
0.3758856058,
-0.3422127366,
-0.2127246857,
-0.3770670593,
-0.61480546,
-0.2281851918,
0.3199267089,
0.3129868209,
0.4568927288,
-0.0444797128,
-0.0356775448,
-0.2253010422,
-0.3596131504,
0.3761851788,
-0.5028192997,
0.7202472687,
-0.0273399279,
-0.0385363959,
-0.0094032465,
-1.0007573366,
-0.1886168867,
-0.1505220532,
-0.4062570632,
-0.8839597106,
-0.3255947232,
0.0108477585,
0.0225105546,
0.251725316,
-0.9496344924,
-0.0403430983,
-0.4264114499,
0.204094708,
0.2564890683,
0.0501687936,
0.5116480589,
-0.2257182747,
0.6053292751,
0.1555977166,
-0.1702136397,
-0.2888509929,
-0.080690302,
-0.5419358015,
-0.3496753871,
0.6995462775,
0.2619847953,
-0.3888776302,
0.4353792369,
-0.3128455877,
-0.2909115553,
-0.8924046755,
0.1304441094,
0.5170177221,
0.0378726944,
0.4581092596,
-0.6243972778,
-0.5284861326,
-0.9682427645,
-0.0043286541,
-0.0633550733,
-0.5565927625,
0.4227174222,
0.2825122178,
-0.4385212362,
0.8258182406,
-0.235518828,
-0.3095889688,
-0.1204136014,
0.4170749187,
0.2480111718,
0.2847154438,
0.8810104132,
-0.5008185506,
-0.2033723593,
0.1038616151,
-0.5284184217,
-0.2133034021,
0.229559049,
0.1943474114,
0.0579077713,
0.8022383451,
-0.3164631426,
0.3326165378,
0.5389458537,
-0.14475815,
0.3748935759,
-0.2804252505,
0.0771477818,
-0.6464234591,
-0.0237591062,
-0.171138972,
-0.1284275204,
-0.4710205793,
-0.2493007779,
-0.164209649,
-0.1057454944,
-0.5482443571,
0.4519203305,
-0.6526429057,
-0.600332737,
-0.0916314572,
0.2492118031,
-0.1191668957,
0.6013085842,
0.3646273017,
0.5916746259,
0.7090782523,
-0.4659788609,
0.3860776722,
0.3707268536,
-0.5273947716,
0.4664562643,
-0.5897000432,
0.312299937,
-0.2707917392,
-0.0269501973,
-1.0142098665,
-0.047452841,
-0.4934328496,
-0.6996964216,
0.3034978211,
-0.1658292413,
-0.427138567,
0.0960289314,
-0.1093645915,
0.9829075933,
0.5437219143,
-0.5105242729,
0.7027134299,
0.7047370672,
-0.378430903,
-0.4778393507,
-0.6496012807,
-0.3129602969,
-0.4608109891,
-0.2974651456,
0.1337624192,
0.2278664857,
-0.5812173486,
-0.0996603295,
-0.0495226681,
-0.1538613141,
-0.281252116,
0.3608281314,
-0.0329141654,
-0.5868954062,
0.1315580606,
-0.0353400856,
0.1436239481,
0.3389395177,
-0.1295430958,
0.592232585,
0.1741643697,
-0.4966593981,
-0.2151275873,
0.8604488969,
0.4421392977,
-0.5505185723,
0.2550733685,
0.724971354,
-0.2179221064,
-0.3994500935,
-0.3356487155,
-0.2718779147,
-0.3891706765,
0.2092078179,
-0.332355231,
-0.7478787303,
0.8416790366,
-0.1071218625,
-0.0654901639,
0.1395684928,
0.3343041241,
0.0564208999,
0.9642241001,
0.764552176,
-0.1635322571,
0.2839816511,
-0.4704894423,
0.0941534713,
-0.9529597759,
-0.3627689779,
-0.7752715349,
-0.2156409472,
-0.4193767309,
-0.5308052301,
0.4876847565,
-0.1506515294,
-0.0887463093,
0.2624187768,
-0.1853884757,
0.5334612727,
0.6643494368,
-0.1496708542,
0.2680452764,
0.0882972106,
-0.4617353678,
-0.1652456969,
-0.5413902998,
-0.16092664,
1.1274938583,
0.5120911002,
0.5239465237,
0.2520246804,
0.7070780396,
0.2343741059,
-0.1040493771,
-0.9500389695,
0.3116881847,
-0.1413790733,
-0.3725163639,
-0.6190384626,
-0.3394022584,
-0.9121592641,
0.4150497615,
-0.3196582794,
-0.6580955982,
0.4501551092,
-0.1242173165,
-0.4440422654,
0.1370468438,
-0.474298507,
0.440946728,
-0.0998158604,
-0.1525277942,
-0.0875551403,
-0.3714809716,
0.0209071282,
-0.3059124053,
0.5600004196,
-0.0602828674,
0.2201582342,
0.9480034113,
-0.2554969192,
0.6448304653,
-0.1320885867,
-0.427595824,
0.26760602,
0.320704639,
-0.0394255221,
-0.0225435663,
0.0877872184,
0.621403873,
0.2666463256,
-0.2259218246,
-0.6263406277,
0.5805102587,
-0.9917010665,
-0.402841568,
-0.0734807923,
-0.47202003,
-0.502684772,
0.3081822097,
0.3587562442,
0.8427978754,
-0.2908298373,
0.4111016691,
0.6734613776,
-0.4460996091,
0.5512741804,
0.5093083382,
-0.3733473122,
0.0687719434,
0.7565575838,
0.1234113872,
0.0960191265,
0.6896516085,
0.2745045424,
-0.6732522249,
-0.5848202705,
-0.0258227978,
0.4595045149,
-0.8528991938,
0.1982467026,
-0.3502392173,
-0.1474379599,
-0.5536190271,
0.2025211155,
-0.7279443145,
-0.4069725275,
-0.1619872749,
-0.2054466307,
0.1380657852,
0.6659726501,
-0.5216803551,
0.208314836,
-0.7788689137,
0.4677405953,
0.2273682505,
0.2464547157,
-0.0239515305,
-0.6703155637,
-0.27382043,
0.0835012123,
0.310223043,
-0.6946347356,
0.4350990355,
0.2805815935,
0.626863122,
0.6865271926,
0.2586925328,
0.3456104398,
-0.5242350698,
0.7319148779,
0.2189380676,
-1.1083874702,
0.4663170576,
-0.4512660503,
0.3088464439,
0.3736397326,
0.4984515905,
-0.3438198566,
-0.4829550087,
-0.5562291741,
-0.7832409739,
0.3309083879,
0.0316223092,
0.1036420763,
0.269928813,
-0.0057401811,
0.1725527942,
0.0297707748,
-0.4119943678,
-0.2747659683,
-0.3358282149,
0.2229088992,
-0.363752991,
-0.0883370861,
-0.2840835154,
-0.3744432032,
0.2130853087,
0.1636600345,
0.4029185772,
0.1857263446,
0.0125715509,
0.1435282379,
0.3363086283,
0.293117255,
0.6878159046,
-0.2577928305,
0.643543303,
0.1742198318,
-0.4618090987,
0.3407467604,
-0.108894743,
0.246026814,
0.4999985099,
0.9486156106,
0.6942256689,
0.1578843892,
-0.5563813448,
0.7232851386,
-0.0459162742,
-0.1123879775,
-0.5949161649,
-0.0838616416,
-0.0449980982,
0.0838489532,
0.027876528,
-0.3436647356,
0.2876140773,
-0.730346024,
0.3900258541,
0.2842910886,
-0.5572239161,
-0.3900583982,
0.6064998507,
0.168467775,
-0.1808464825,
0.5545527339,
-0.1221868545,
-0.1910041124,
0.4208386838,
0.2716628313,
0.5774414539,
-0.4821958244,
-0.0255184993,
0.4151422083,
0.1220364198,
0.049365893,
0.1839484125,
-0.4096771479,
-0.7725880742,
-0.5770221353,
-0.8011745811,
-0.3192649484,
0.3858449161,
-1.0021203756,
0.2336409241,
-0.0761425793,
-0.1389283091,
0.2992005944,
-0.3053508997,
-0.6851710677,
-0.0788873136,
0.3976112604,
0.742174089,
-1.1837699413,
0.8222349882,
0.5605454445,
-0.1427689344,
-0.9615131021,
-0.0610310063,
0.0053631193,
-0.5190742016,
0.7103927135,
-0.0603320561,
-0.3886530101,
-0.3439561129,
-0.2742089331,
-0.9352659583,
0.5972550511,
0.5051354766,
-0.7384280562,
0.0591459759,
0.515442431,
0.5357216001,
-0.3126707375,
0.2702836096,
0.7512280345,
0.341148138,
0.0619330183,
-1.3262776136,
-0.1827275604,
-0.1913556308,
-0.1299482733,
0.1328872889,
-0.2784918249,
0.8933662176,
-0.0772427991,
-0.2764248252,
-0.331569612,
0.66636765,
-0.0049250624,
0.2035744488,
0.6146599054,
0.3487829268,
0.7264312506,
0.033469487,
0.8112686872,
-0.2678444088,
0.134811759,
1.0384494066,
-0.0426361114,
0.8596023917,
0.524546206,
-0.1526666284,
0.2086120248,
0.4284871519,
-0.0708407611,
0.4641611278,
0.3882322013,
-0.4526529014,
-0.3302995265,
-0.5922424793,
-0.4991789162,
0.9425753951,
0.297154814,
-0.3348180056,
0.0395324789,
0.3751332462,
-0.0269170292,
0.2644739747,
-0.4518702328,
0.700324595,
0.2221595198,
-0.4567370117,
0.7759847045,
-0.1517540216,
0.54948318,
-0.4736625552,
-0.1561861038,
-0.2276603132,
0.0092584016,
-0.2433731258,
-0.6126334071,
0.3937805295,
-0.1750713289,
-0.0675882548,
-0.0816272125,
0.378272295,
-0.6561748981,
-0.2685314119,
0.6478073597,
0.4429008365,
0.5067011118,
0.0439541303,
0.0571545288,
0.2289847583,
-0.0394750871,
0.0652026236,
0.1246578768,
0.7231654525,
-0.0747002885,
0.2737817466,
0.5351834893,
0.4767675102,
0.1157794371,
0.3797882795,
0.578864336,
-0.5966715217,
-0.7005489469,
-0.5179421902,
0.0171351898,
0.1341370791,
-0.0481322519,
0.7895559669,
0.7216438055,
1.3269305229,
-0.068730019,
0.931135118,
0.4128801227,
0.7585997581,
-0.6591544151,
0.5191588402,
-0.4937543869,
0.3431695402,
-0.2010298818,
-0.9150465727,
-0.1265144497,
0.6652293801,
-0.0273257848,
-0.2052179575,
0.6920979619,
0.6530436873,
-0.4987648427,
-0.1661291867,
0.4337820113,
0.187741369,
0.0359661058,
0.377574861,
0.9864955544,
0.118375577,
0.4456010461,
-0.4697743952,
-0.2043493986,
0.0856371373,
-0.5274887681,
-1.2959976196,
-0.9057639241,
-0.3500875533,
-0.1000844017,
-0.4815272689,
0.8440295458,
0.7544026971,
-0.7172225118,
-0.354531914,
0.7304139137,
-0.0423569195,
-0.1996866912,
-0.1156379208,
0.6344845295,
0.3568327725,
-0.718031168,
0.5389926434,
-0.0403119363,
0.2115134895,
-0.6337596178,
0.0613495782,
0.1584484875,
0.339335829,
0.5912647843,
0.3337342441,
-0.4166803062,
-0.4320907891,
-0.1829483956,
0.3312653005,
0.2682528496,
0.9007228017,
-0.5503997207,
0.3852381408,
0.7155441046,
0.3636488616,
0.3694675863,
-0.0945620686,
0.4764558375,
-1.3256909847,
0.5528056026,
0.2656867802,
0.5996721983,
0.5369449854,
-0.0640607178,
0.1636614054,
-0.0782785863,
-0.1490115076,
-1.0145939589,
0.3557411134,
-1.122377634,
-0.3169190586,
1.4907301664,
-0.2134028524,
-0.1989712715,
-0.3055961132,
-0.0918907225,
0.3788018525,
-0.3406692147,
0.6285577416,
0.7690022588,
-0.282656163,
-0.1342405081,
-0.453133136,
0.5215169787,
0.1138463914,
-0.2055943161,
0.0662402585,
0.2974229753,
0.2297613025,
0.6809664965,
0.468113929,
-0.4006972909,
0.0390359163,
0.1462381929,
0.0962165967,
-0.1352247447,
-0.4764219224,
-0.5352116823,
0.2583267689,
0.1434601396,
-0.3369788527
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05571v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05571v1
|
Traditional Machine Learning Models and Bidirectional Encoder Representations From Transformer (BERT)-Based Automatic Classification of Tweets About Eating Disorders: Algorithm Development and Validation Study
| 2024-02-08T11:16:13 | 2024-02-08T11:16:13 |
José Alberto Benítez-Andrades, José-Manuel Alija-Pérez, Maria-Esther Vidal, Rafael Pastor-Vargas, María Teresa García-Ordás
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Background: Eating disorders are increasingly prevalent, and social networks
offer valuable information.
Objective: Our goal was to identify efficient machine learning models for
categorizing tweets related to eating disorders.
Methods: Over three months, we collected tweets about eating disorders. A
2,000-tweet subset was labeled for: (1) being written by individuals with
eating disorders, (2) promoting eating disorders, (3) informativeness, and (4)
scientific content. Both traditional machine learning and deep learning models
were employed for classification, assessing accuracy, F1 score, and
computational time.
Results: From 1,058,957 collected tweets, transformer-based bidirectional
encoder representations achieved the highest F1 scores (71.1%-86.4%) across all
four categories.
Conclusions: Transformer-based models outperform traditional techniques in
classifying eating disorder-related tweets, though they require more
computational resources.
|
[
0.0532291271,
-0.7615458369,
0.2620022893,
0.1630606502,
-0.1077319458,
0.3825441301,
0.008921206,
-0.644690454,
0.5714532733,
0.4038037062,
-0.2737540901,
-0.4488562644,
-1.0533400774,
0.2471005023,
-0.6494867802,
0.7424082756,
-0.3320407569,
0.4189414084,
0.0915604457,
-0.0867419392,
-0.1659165025,
-0.3041810095,
-0.6051369905,
-0.253526628,
0.4741503298,
0.316147238,
0.647172451,
0.3666463792,
0.7746585011,
0.2290527523,
0.1509852856,
0.1030914858,
-0.5595873594,
0.0173868909,
-0.0507281609,
-0.0447330065,
-0.190457359,
-0.0089049358,
0.1711149365,
0.7411524653,
-0.2671948075,
0.3403496444,
0.205934599,
0.6443921924,
-0.0869310275,
0.0542381331,
-0.2196879685,
0.4000795782,
-0.0452582166,
-0.0440707169,
-0.3341365159,
-0.7636728883,
0.1225422472,
-0.3127595186,
0.118391782,
0.0663647205,
0.9651429057,
0.1289189607,
-0.7741194963,
-0.4848926067,
-0.5786579847,
0.4762018621,
-0.5895881653,
0.4654890895,
0.4401842058,
0.5267981887,
0.1800527126,
-0.6612047553,
-0.4194060862,
0.0625884235,
-0.2035531104,
-0.2060918361,
-0.2035013735,
-0.0533839799,
0.0433390662,
0.0137242712,
-0.7679092288,
0.2693087459,
-0.5005996823,
0.1441058517,
0.8750098348,
0.0883968174,
0.4323492944,
-0.4318541884,
-0.0517560095,
0.0770142078,
-0.1561212838,
-0.058257103,
-0.2551524639,
-0.0086542014,
-0.0297957007,
0.8116725087,
0.1076162159,
0.2848922014,
0.3233077526,
0.0759811103,
0.4376588464,
0.0938119143,
-0.4222946465,
0.1299251914,
0.8507692814,
0.7940295339,
0.2248564065,
-0.2916846871,
-0.3347578347,
-0.0916583464,
0.5080127716,
-0.9535670877,
-0.3188278675,
0.1835146248,
-0.7504121661,
-0.3719395697,
0.1350204945,
-0.6470074654,
-0.7776985765,
-0.0424894243,
0.3720217347,
-0.5837255716,
-0.1835913509,
-0.1127301306,
-0.2921625972,
0.3897138238,
0.4527398944,
-0.7029226422,
0.3761917055,
0.5967406631,
0.7555461526,
-0.1723069549,
0.3622623682,
-0.0186270867,
0.2716556191,
-0.4456638992,
0.6390478611,
-0.6947542429,
-0.04384524,
0.0834915563,
0.3396477401,
-0.4672326744,
-0.4638681412,
0.7852256894,
-0.6497937441,
-0.0980980024,
-0.3608072698,
-0.8594205976,
-0.6958401799,
0.1730613858,
-0.8571605682,
0.6702819467,
0.1725520492,
-0.5682772994,
0.3727647364,
-0.67711097,
-0.8523913622,
0.2544882894,
0.098707132,
-0.3916317821,
0.1523270607,
0.4569203258,
0.9811306,
-0.320936352,
0.582384944,
-0.2992227077,
-0.2402597219,
0.350749135,
-0.2597279549,
0.5625537634,
0.3775005043,
-0.2449033856,
0.1668497622,
-0.3021899164,
-0.1888413429,
0.5438399911,
-0.1394420862,
-0.2175135911,
0.1477066725,
0.3429338634,
-0.0443259738,
-0.0370760895,
-0.685112834,
0.1415241212,
-0.1888404489,
0.7071327567,
0.5684937239,
0.083861649,
0.2436230332,
-0.7470170856,
0.256791085,
0.0969909951,
0.0091876127,
-0.0023479762,
-0.7481351495,
-0.3802060485,
0.0053148787,
0.2411456853,
0.6185321212,
-0.7342615128,
0.7167270184,
-0.5034046173,
-0.4819121957,
-0.6778241396,
-0.2448803931,
-0.0733265877,
0.6213443875,
0.4406404495,
0.1384504884,
-0.5703750849,
-0.6207429171,
-0.1103359684,
0.3103884757,
-0.0999274403,
0.3153908253,
0.5272340178,
-0.4072041512,
0.4461392164,
-0.3219633996,
0.0023661647,
-0.3999412954,
0.3115591407,
-0.1062924713,
0.3734888434,
0.7752273679,
-1.1052744389,
-1.0032662153,
0.2030148059,
-0.7227827311,
0.0523901917,
0.3179536164,
0.2320307344,
0.3235692084,
0.1099156067,
-0.2769334912,
0.5827880502,
0.5166582465,
-0.2599023283,
0.4332513213,
0.5041434169,
0.3356829286,
-1.0295737982,
-0.1498671621,
0.3966188729,
-0.3903095126,
-0.5424744487,
-0.4270269275,
0.2390949726,
-0.1558923274,
-0.0366872698,
0.2053643018,
0.0102420868,
0.311232239,
0.0290232953,
-0.4546353519,
-0.1152345911,
0.2317334116,
-0.0254371632,
0.2323182076,
0.6478334069,
-0.3412868679,
0.4768973589,
-0.2661338449,
-0.3378555477,
0.264521271,
-0.6695771813,
0.0109073035,
-0.3684209585,
0.1522056162,
-1.4865034819,
-0.4557312429,
0.4409304857,
-0.5886143446,
0.347173959,
0.1344911754,
-0.5980993509,
-0.877392292,
-0.4441890419,
0.1957696825,
0.5037795305,
-0.5754714608,
0.5852780938,
0.3779171705,
0.1254902184,
0.0362001918,
-0.7732430696,
-0.0571777709,
-0.1559779346,
-0.6146000624,
0.2566129565,
0.1239060685,
0.1258243918,
0.4160425663,
-0.115012303,
-0.1899178475,
-0.0574986115,
0.1456569135,
-0.1604954898,
-0.0265452918,
0.1170358434,
0.1088941917,
0.3029218912,
-0.0602536388,
0.0164290275,
0.5850747228,
0.0373596363,
-0.1571029425,
-0.7458107471,
0.6198664308,
0.610966742,
-0.0160323437,
0.8088029027,
0.8014851809,
-0.6430698037,
-0.2142996937,
-0.5201110244,
-0.1935185045,
-0.4607659578,
0.2727948129,
-0.1119293049,
-0.6873601675,
0.5123511553,
0.1180372536,
-0.123682633,
0.3821446896,
0.2690967023,
-0.5889924765,
1.1115187407,
0.4268374443,
-0.0987215862,
0.4680508971,
-0.4149834812,
0.1591484398,
-0.5125986338,
-0.3095780909,
-0.3734329939,
-0.6108316183,
-0.6786937714,
-0.4409179986,
0.2751888037,
-0.6384937763,
-0.4397549033,
0.2661709785,
-0.6936770082,
0.230759114,
0.2123452723,
0.3858289421,
-0.2155936658,
0.0027431725,
-0.1682534367,
-0.1918097436,
-0.3974987864,
-0.4930438995,
1.1885368824,
0.6261426806,
0.8718782663,
0.0953183547,
0.7745909095,
0.731515646,
0.8392141461,
-0.9236713648,
0.2798402011,
-0.4823122323,
-0.5936157703,
-0.1705076098,
-0.6966958642,
-0.8106717467,
-0.0519754104,
0.1877860427,
-0.805703938,
0.0544457659,
-0.3688372672,
-0.1506014019,
0.5955471396,
-1.0509119034,
0.7608038783,
-0.5233511329,
-0.0365532525,
0.0222581849,
-0.7460289598,
0.1471679509,
-0.0976840928,
0.1095216051,
-0.1677557379,
0.1168221533,
1.4548773766,
-0.24917835,
0.9926719666,
-0.2715238035,
0.0995128751,
-0.0510542803,
0.1824294478,
0.1875176281,
-0.132338047,
-0.2829570174,
0.1002510265,
0.0224820822,
-0.1950082481,
-0.4643109143,
0.486959219,
-0.802297771,
-0.2042379826,
-0.509949863,
-0.1064893156,
-0.2861951888,
0.4043619037,
-0.0569020994,
0.1318190694,
-0.1430564523,
0.3392369151,
0.5916413665,
0.0768040121,
0.5275875926,
0.3596065044,
-0.0834157765,
-0.5136184096,
0.7886925936,
0.3087036312,
-0.3290311992,
0.7090401649,
0.2319685668,
-0.0790246949,
-0.3933876455,
-0.1473105252,
0.4045730531,
-0.35837394,
-0.4870541394,
-0.5500428081,
-0.4697934985,
-0.7685187459,
-0.4325304925,
-0.3296218216,
-0.1823561937,
-0.69343853,
-0.4322938919,
0.0197547395,
1.0941931009,
0.1086656302,
0.2323944569,
-0.7867090106,
0.4463414252,
0.0827331468,
0.524273932,
0.5372542739,
-0.270999372,
-0.16794011,
0.1299494803,
-0.7285018563,
-1.3931897879,
0.673596859,
0.2299305052,
0.4608301818,
0.9353432059,
0.1430253386,
0.512989521,
-0.147598505,
0.6396523714,
0.339436084,
-0.5927971005,
0.4897970557,
-0.0206042342,
0.0356226116,
0.2186377347,
1.1843641996,
-0.8897582293,
-0.0506582744,
-0.2130739242,
-0.4945120215,
0.7662084103,
-0.007054694,
0.1141940355,
-0.1255143732,
0.1903603971,
0.360122174,
0.2282191962,
-0.8249223232,
-0.2974509597,
-0.4499996901,
-0.6049638987,
-0.0799773261,
-0.4783261418,
0.1155011654,
-0.7903063893,
0.45440045,
0.0625746325,
0.4267136753,
0.12099915,
-0.1459885538,
-0.4695602357,
-0.0368733332,
0.1848700643,
0.4839431047,
-0.5681025982,
-0.0412113741,
-0.3061174154,
-0.6007139087,
-0.0005949511,
0.4470528364,
-0.1745446473,
0.0330957621,
0.5018643737,
0.7177824974,
0.0961024985,
-0.5403212309,
0.4844864607,
-0.198843345,
-0.4599581361,
-0.1186883226,
-0.1163719743,
0.1473957002,
0.0268546995,
0.6529049277,
0.0120801497,
0.3351679146,
-0.3673611879,
0.2846431732,
0.1600183994,
-0.5108278394,
-0.5876834989,
0.5040740371,
0.255574882,
-0.2787222862,
0.88848418,
-0.4013572335,
-0.6746063232,
0.6766555309,
0.4693318903,
1.0921792984,
-0.6855279803,
0.4853451252,
0.3534317315,
0.3887670338,
0.1827438772,
0.2720605135,
-0.1904776096,
-0.9573712945,
-0.0533150695,
-0.8322343826,
-0.1178569943,
0.0579583719,
-0.7717664242,
0.1788831353,
-0.2468679547,
-0.3348157704,
0.469117552,
-0.1432258487,
-0.7818512917,
0.1077859178,
0.389439553,
0.7270435691,
-1.0434855223,
0.6970852613,
1.1916577816,
-0.213904351,
-0.6196734905,
0.3775361478,
-0.0845251977,
-0.7690825462,
0.3920042217,
0.5398976207,
0.4182903469,
-0.1156217456,
-0.7170135379,
-0.8267190456,
0.8148346543,
-0.0664809495,
-0.5373687744,
-0.2885206342,
0.3858044744,
0.5843459368,
-0.3107103705,
0.140639931,
0.5090492368,
0.5701834559,
0.5924230814,
-1.1735916138,
-0.0067255776,
-0.2228720784,
0.1035940945,
0.0444932021,
-0.3648152351,
0.4788601696,
-0.3740089536,
-0.443918705,
-0.3750516474,
0.4582712352,
-0.3256166279,
0.5964086652,
0.1795010716,
0.6699300408,
0.8231095672,
-0.105470866,
0.8439359665,
0.0932900757,
0.4036604464,
0.658005476,
-0.2915617526,
0.5159636736,
0.1506877244,
-0.2354909629,
0.3694777191,
0.8611136079,
-0.150520131,
0.7580664754,
-0.0541616119,
0.2682118714,
0.0336910374,
-0.0027006082,
-0.0360084996,
0.236865446,
0.6793804169,
-0.7271813154,
-0.3656997979,
0.7049711347,
0.1854754686,
-0.168040514,
-0.2809547484,
1.0308992863,
-0.0310923606,
-0.1453879625,
0.6274451017,
0.2285927981,
0.7001883984,
-0.1772557944,
-0.0103889313,
0.0573143698,
0.0531038083,
-0.217385307,
-1.0264691114,
0.6303883791,
-0.1634873301,
0.0226338208,
-0.3983426392,
0.8260853291,
-0.2898062766,
-0.9222127795,
0.2431358397,
0.2242785394,
-0.0386380777,
0.0458341055,
-0.810934782,
0.204687804,
-0.0577061623,
-0.3809667826,
-0.1918701977,
0.4746963978,
-0.0347619131,
0.751855433,
0.2152227759,
-0.1617832631,
0.1230238974,
-0.0120991459,
0.8805397749,
-0.7154534459,
-0.5225133896,
-0.7206779718,
0.1194121167,
0.0004790772,
0.3196932673,
0.7493091226,
0.4612565935,
0.5708386898,
-0.1261039227,
0.7484039068,
-0.4780483842,
0.8083801866,
-0.0041567092,
0.9610418677,
-0.822468996,
0.0305351149,
-0.0886917114,
-0.1646572053,
-0.4732894003,
0.6205496192,
-0.6432510614,
0.3559238315,
0.7599204183,
0.4389725626,
-0.0829161555,
0.3778218031,
0.0227335412,
0.427708894,
0.4999897778,
0.4790106714,
0.3848461211,
-0.4232017398,
-0.061951194,
-0.5271320343,
-0.3127095699,
-0.8000008464,
-0.3954606354,
-0.8296326399,
-0.8806131482,
-0.2535820901,
-0.092396602,
0.2778413594,
0.8768540621,
0.8913408518,
-1.0501242876,
-0.1608641595,
0.2561137676,
0.404663682,
-0.5139706731,
-0.3382506073,
0.4896612763,
-0.0565968752,
-0.4228308201,
-0.0940514877,
-0.2899381816,
0.1099968627,
0.108075805,
0.0311786421,
-0.2763603032,
0.1066456512,
0.6569312215,
-0.0769045502,
-0.3341362476,
-0.0794115141,
-0.0988041386,
-0.1949672401,
0.2577301264,
0.4152440727,
-0.392860055,
0.3937579691,
0.267539382,
0.4840600491,
0.4553186893,
0.3003806472,
0.2492435575,
-0.4637310803,
-0.5261211991,
0.7327485681,
0.3712405264,
0.4408035576,
-0.468321681,
0.2136857361,
0.3009397686,
-0.5383216739,
-0.8416220546,
-0.3623922765,
-1.0999418497,
-0.4111973047,
1.1926966906,
0.25486058,
-0.6777297854,
-0.0015075126,
-0.1046242416,
0.3109056652,
-0.6229304671,
0.8411031365,
0.390999645,
-0.3704060316,
-0.1709503531,
-0.3855743706,
0.4592534006,
-0.1322706491,
-0.546500206,
-0.2275379747,
0.2973234951,
0.5880799294,
-0.1470691562,
0.3351145983,
-0.0038820819,
0.1149096116,
-0.4067208171,
0.0672374666,
0.0094742868,
-0.2782153189,
0.0611636266,
0.3572134674,
-0.577442348,
-0.3202126622
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05547v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05547v2
|
Benchmarking Large Language Models on Communicative Medical Coaching: a Novel System and Dataset
| 2024-02-08T10:32:06 | 2024-06-08T16:36:56 |
Hengguan Huang, Songtao Wang, Hongfu Liu, Hao Wang, Ye Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Traditional applications of natural language processing (NLP) in healthcare
have predominantly focused on patient-centered services, enhancing patient
interactions and care delivery, such as through medical dialogue systems.
However, the potential of NLP to benefit inexperienced doctors, particularly in
areas such as communicative medical coaching, remains largely unexplored. We
introduce "ChatCoach", a human-AI cooperative framework designed to assist
medical learners in practicing their communication skills during patient
consultations. ChatCoach (Our data and code are available online:
https://github.com/zerowst/Chatcoach)differentiates itself from conventional
dialogue systems by offering a simulated environment where medical learners can
practice dialogues with a patient agent, while a coach agent provides
immediate, structured feedback. This is facilitated by our proposed Generalized
Chain-of-Thought (GCoT) approach, which fosters the generation of structured
feedback and enhances the utilization of external knowledge sources.
Additionally, we have developed a dataset specifically for evaluating Large
Language Models (LLMs) within the ChatCoach framework on communicative medical
coaching tasks. Our empirical results validate the effectiveness of ChatCoach.
|
[
-0.1541761905,
-0.6922697425,
0.3067270517,
0.1561718732,
-0.0988523141,
0.4070441127,
-0.4906482995,
-0.705597043,
0.3328193426,
0.3507380486,
-0.4542709291,
-0.5764824748,
-0.6228969693,
0.0855988488,
-0.2620114088,
0.631229341,
0.2031178474,
0.7637214065,
-0.3974405527,
-0.2894661725,
-0.5032775402,
-0.752322793,
-1.2196935415,
-0.6006565094,
0.304661423,
0.5081628561,
0.5842259526,
0.2215661854,
0.6430308819,
0.3600000143,
0.0677869469,
0.4021927118,
-0.2782138586,
0.5381020904,
-0.1057645977,
-0.5948560834,
-0.4675683677,
-0.0147159547,
0.4270358384,
1.1882638931,
-0.6753854752,
-0.2149832249,
0.0331188962,
0.3858122826,
-0.3526492715,
0.4045545757,
-0.7023133039,
0.2012901455,
0.3363241255,
-0.2515308857,
-0.4730697274,
-0.4584712982,
0.2633054256,
-0.5511713624,
0.1469654441,
0.2114522159,
0.590598464,
0.2638991177,
-0.2334979475,
-0.5159000158,
-0.5632351041,
0.7009301186,
-0.8057925701,
0.2848169804,
0.4469284415,
0.6207567453,
-0.3981074095,
-0.6366553903,
-0.3964785039,
-0.4527914822,
0.1065308824,
0.3978211582,
-0.2342328876,
0.295288831,
0.1653667539,
0.2457375973,
-0.411018014,
0.4848766625,
-0.0613502823,
0.0606921166,
0.6189288497,
0.2945849001,
0.5967103243,
0.274826467,
-0.0152516905,
-0.0819713697,
-0.5086680055,
-0.024716448,
-0.2842350006,
0.1556590348,
-0.4312281907,
0.4805492759,
-0.2089407891,
0.5596629381,
-0.2588247955,
-0.0991930813,
0.1543819457,
-0.1815519631,
-0.3334074914,
-0.0437063798,
1.0539221764,
0.5889829993,
0.570438683,
-0.4695011079,
0.1847178936,
0.2202538997,
0.3748446107,
-0.8104307652,
-0.2448327243,
0.2148995101,
-0.350384593,
-0.4353264868,
-0.3230347037,
-0.7720360756,
-0.4465403855,
-0.1481432766,
-0.195802927,
-0.2738874853,
-0.0655120239,
0.1942709237,
0.0771164149,
0.2491945177,
0.4047625661,
-0.949937582,
0.8903983235,
0.7212554216,
0.8840742111,
-0.303793788,
-0.0503851809,
-0.7103934884,
-0.0865950659,
-0.5179858208,
0.8631876111,
-0.6007814407,
-0.6168943644,
0.2616380453,
-0.0792437196,
-0.1254978925,
-1.1015689373,
0.6100648642,
-0.0241233148,
0.2064504027,
0.2155987024,
-0.8035236001,
0.3314895332,
0.3296001256,
-0.5365636945,
0.6283851266,
0.0308309812,
-0.4801020324,
0.2461749315,
-0.5680474639,
-0.5229277611,
0.2749940753,
-0.6762273312,
-0.530739069,
0.1381739676,
0.2931016386,
0.3906959891,
-0.7250560522,
0.4424982965,
-0.4006509185,
-0.316219002,
0.2992451191,
-0.244952485,
0.76187253,
0.0033345546,
-0.2391353101,
0.1179365292,
-0.609228313,
0.2959148884,
-0.092580311,
-0.226629898,
-0.2100888938,
0.0978444293,
-0.1975697875,
0.2392731011,
-0.5091077685,
-0.3967319131,
0.4550107718,
-0.5051246285,
0.3941153884,
0.1626435071,
0.1828137338,
0.1100950465,
-0.4609812498,
0.7521871328,
-0.043906074,
0.2914684713,
-0.0512138233,
-0.7089231014,
-0.4943061769,
-0.406973809,
0.227418229,
0.4110409021,
-0.987716496,
0.3374645114,
-0.2252936661,
-0.51044029,
-0.8499929309,
-0.0959999338,
0.3819973767,
0.6922649741,
0.3770042062,
-0.7540398836,
-0.4424459934,
-0.6722737551,
-0.1221892461,
-0.2271634787,
-0.2209224105,
0.60094136,
0.4056756198,
-0.1934240758,
0.5426517725,
-0.3947776854,
-0.4718899429,
-0.2502001524,
0.1066162661,
0.1062409878,
0.50426507,
0.3398727775,
-0.4698021114,
-0.5179738998,
0.1024743542,
-0.789986372,
-0.1659544259,
-0.0210988838,
0.0326896198,
0.0884581506,
0.5300406218,
-0.5047748089,
0.2885549068,
0.8859167099,
-0.1914283186,
0.6648003459,
-0.5660888553,
0.2334385365,
-1.1732029915,
0.3416377902,
-0.1630480587,
-0.3345094919,
-0.6175408363,
-0.1955846697,
-0.2641650736,
-0.1911868006,
-0.1499249339,
0.4834051132,
-0.3092294931,
0.0340340286,
-0.3841737211,
0.1677952409,
-0.2951944172,
0.4485840797,
0.1796280444,
0.6484107971,
0.5739575624,
-0.3735044897,
0.4326698482,
0.3936373889,
-0.670091331,
0.9894439578,
-0.9559883475,
0.172771588,
0.3386763036,
0.5008975267,
-0.7258462906,
-0.2620394826,
0.1722358167,
-0.5553485155,
0.1141891629,
-0.2501529455,
-0.4777844548,
-0.3733767867,
0.0738775581,
0.2240950912,
0.4012596011,
-0.2377322614,
0.3629864156,
0.7218660116,
-0.4927217364,
-0.3104261458,
-0.5140873194,
0.3659401536,
0.2512409091,
-0.3187000155,
0.3160769641,
-0.1437193602,
-0.1789461225,
-0.1154920682,
0.0164875798,
-0.5145323873,
0.2750300169,
0.4222689271,
0.4479883909,
0.0433360152,
0.3269662261,
0.0282047782,
-0.0237909928,
0.1789741963,
-0.266582787,
0.6929778457,
0.1044020504,
-0.389233619,
-0.5316375494,
0.5797884464,
0.4014291465,
-0.2614895403,
0.7505783439,
0.1612135768,
-0.2704148889,
-0.222371459,
-0.4185494184,
-0.2748629153,
-0.3583392799,
0.4366650581,
0.131258592,
-0.8244611621,
0.3215900958,
-0.2566551864,
-0.0187552478,
0.0438626185,
0.7733077407,
-0.1974460632,
1.1018440723,
0.3776990473,
-0.1449120939,
0.2229585946,
-0.3092169464,
-0.044590354,
-0.6491099,
-0.257197082,
-0.708810389,
-0.202246055,
-0.7496407628,
-0.6721100807,
0.4184296429,
-0.2936722934,
0.0622556396,
-0.1071609184,
-0.3653477132,
0.3996143043,
0.5628449917,
0.0668623969,
0.3516477346,
-0.2435843796,
-0.5410394073,
0.0523816273,
-0.8779512644,
-0.1825761795,
0.9760290384,
0.1230986342,
0.784858346,
-0.0609343164,
0.6546421051,
0.0433327109,
0.5752202868,
-0.9226642847,
0.4818761945,
-0.0624118932,
-0.4084195793,
-0.0627489239,
-0.7271580696,
-1.2154774666,
0.2691025436,
-0.4943970144,
-0.5818542838,
-0.2576993704,
0.0250668097,
-0.3697833121,
0.1310324669,
-0.7713702917,
0.6504835486,
-0.0467660353,
-0.3560828269,
-0.3451519907,
-0.663184762,
-0.0887413844,
0.0213028342,
0.1714372486,
-0.0145026846,
0.1195789129,
0.3924174607,
-0.4208775461,
0.9176629782,
-0.1966965944,
-0.0420464277,
0.0651135966,
-0.1995896697,
0.2366101742,
0.0141351726,
0.0078358212,
0.0376343951,
0.0899003744,
-0.4861549735,
-0.8268848658,
0.6204943657,
-0.6362081766,
-0.3261333406,
-0.3741826415,
-0.5989402533,
-0.8667958975,
0.0431191958,
-0.0488653891,
0.442763567,
-0.5161478519,
0.4129615724,
0.2118104845,
-0.4268783629,
0.1711299568,
0.664658308,
-0.1914442182,
-0.3774442673,
0.5402035713,
0.0668873712,
0.350821346,
0.1737938523,
0.1442506611,
-0.0922329277,
-0.5517346859,
-0.0188970193,
0.2687239349,
-0.4805444479,
-0.0806572959,
-0.5329709649,
-0.3352755606,
-0.2384260893,
0.0266421735,
-0.2450157106,
-0.1878086329,
0.3047688007,
0.1448810846,
-0.1897925735,
0.6789788008,
0.2144426256,
0.2066508681,
-0.6513307095,
0.155283317,
0.2758584023,
0.5741351247,
0.105811514,
-0.0968932062,
-0.4720597565,
0.077353619,
-0.2735317051,
-0.5718325973,
0.4462411106,
0.1315368861,
0.6954574585,
0.1880316138,
-0.0052733659,
0.4562285244,
-0.7058519125,
0.65392524,
0.4050952196,
-0.5686377883,
0.2401923686,
-0.0975811332,
0.4404707253,
0.721419096,
0.416238755,
-0.9341675639,
-0.785933733,
-0.6561352611,
-0.7656587958,
0.3794249594,
0.146111384,
-0.0257847626,
-0.3207903504,
-0.0231694654,
-0.0096735219,
0.3946608603,
-0.1298762262,
0.0101028997,
0.3893842697,
-0.3863251805,
-0.1866916716,
0.1432855725,
-0.3466988206,
-0.2706261575,
0.5014684796,
-0.308671236,
0.5015456676,
0.3382168114,
0.0122516621,
0.0515341684,
0.2456404865,
0.6126113534,
0.4049679041,
-0.0615068153,
0.0670646951,
0.1562601924,
-0.6408885717,
0.0649751946,
0.0483543091,
0.2872714996,
0.2200060785,
0.6006171703,
0.508279264,
0.6276592612,
-0.9162584543,
0.5269011855,
-0.3922483027,
-0.2877358496,
-0.0920480415,
0.2386514693,
0.2446481735,
0.1709194481,
-0.0141272489,
0.06486772,
0.0890655443,
-0.551592648,
0.3645831645,
0.4882526696,
-0.6307014823,
-0.2069238126,
0.5897394419,
0.5456704497,
-0.5702799559,
0.5080525279,
0.2566248477,
-0.2240776271,
0.5216397643,
0.3726553917,
0.7475336194,
-0.2082571685,
0.3529125452,
0.1943086535,
-0.1790224612,
-0.0746676624,
0.0738549903,
-0.130574435,
-0.6207288504,
-0.5367615223,
-0.0396283306,
-1.1424665451,
-0.0889649689,
-0.771371007,
0.0761493519,
-0.2884787321,
-0.2742136419,
0.4786314964,
0.265103668,
-0.8755412698,
0.2491155565,
0.0398571193,
0.9017137885,
-0.4168947935,
1.2237473726,
0.4960481524,
-0.2972994745,
-0.9027481675,
0.1014380604,
0.0028077194,
-1.0130726099,
0.4307617247,
0.0877811238,
-0.2634697556,
0.0083567612,
-0.5679458976,
0.0650609061,
0.9136565924,
0.3579001725,
-0.780087173,
-0.2643501163,
0.2172490209,
0.9506569505,
-0.6143566966,
0.608979702,
0.3046313226,
-0.1506646574,
0.146217227,
-1.1117430925,
-0.2977021635,
-0.3753119707,
-0.2841916978,
-0.0871912092,
-0.5466843247,
0.2227536142,
-0.1900713295,
0.070818007,
0.2363081127,
0.0707118064,
0.1153966263,
0.1328071356,
0.4791501164,
0.4110938013,
1.2054486275,
-0.058785826,
1.3089512587,
-0.396266222,
0.3577390015,
1.5164132118,
-0.5818821788,
0.8679084778,
0.4824948013,
-0.0758466646,
0.4730663598,
0.0597674213,
0.0328321978,
0.2713878155,
0.3937589824,
-0.3489035368,
-0.0841581002,
-0.4869783819,
-0.225442335,
0.5810120106,
0.1956817359,
-0.4379140437,
0.0243216585,
-0.1087434664,
0.1999652684,
0.1570439041,
-0.1451234818,
1.0237777233,
0.3380849361,
-0.9987403154,
0.7532637119,
-0.4186944366,
0.3794117272,
-0.6073800325,
-0.148413226,
-0.2472449392,
0.3485994041,
0.0445576161,
-0.6167188883,
0.0725984573,
0.026259426,
0.2445881963,
-0.0525830649,
0.4308629632,
-0.6613068581,
-0.3302694261,
0.4441866279,
0.5766842961,
0.0343700387,
0.1520280093,
-0.7218251228,
-0.0685549527,
-0.3412529826,
0.162728861,
0.2363806814,
0.3564225733,
0.1902508885,
0.9165777564,
0.5730427504,
0.4552755356,
-0.2840656042,
0.5695900321,
0.8213080168,
-0.6180207729,
-0.4367049634,
-0.6630989313,
0.2330784798,
-0.5112964511,
-0.3021956384,
0.4834553003,
0.614135921,
0.6439430118,
0.1323370636,
0.7242543101,
0.2559595406,
0.678301096,
-0.3516588509,
0.84163028,
-0.3173236847,
-0.0025893124,
-0.2946422696,
-0.3101351261,
-0.6242108345,
0.641326189,
-0.3120405376,
-0.085366033,
0.7461829782,
0.5416982174,
0.1690286994,
0.1797818691,
0.658868134,
0.2430776954,
0.6908531785,
0.7183864117,
0.6943898797,
-0.0600028783,
0.2488409728,
0.0069885068,
-0.2957207263,
-0.348199755,
-0.5333366394,
-1.0786840916,
-0.3725103438,
-0.2705612481,
-0.2873140574,
0.334022969,
1.3707014322,
0.9891837239,
-0.7222642303,
-0.4899449348,
-0.0827131346,
-0.2616136074,
-0.4363201857,
-0.1088229194,
0.1779384464,
-0.5472596288,
-0.7695093751,
0.3621479869,
0.3486713469,
-0.0253860503,
-0.0600560196,
-0.1621222496,
-0.2040085495,
0.1519806087,
0.4475469589,
0.1794567108,
-0.3331408501,
-0.1398668885,
0.0948892534,
-0.4397820234,
0.3722527027,
0.9285671711,
-0.6760463715,
0.7008011341,
-0.1229307801,
0.8631895781,
0.2983079553,
-0.1618921906,
0.8698501587,
-0.5104981661,
0.2062486261,
0.5804648399,
0.2441031188,
0.2991626263,
0.16387178,
0.6988223791,
0.1707092524,
-0.7231940627,
-0.7784042358,
-0.003753952,
-0.9661791325,
-0.0627786294,
0.8992958665,
-0.3816891015,
-0.0387157127,
-0.2638909817,
-0.5582857728,
0.3184768558,
-0.2930336297,
1.0197240114,
0.7415795326,
-0.0892476141,
0.0007576091,
-0.849200666,
0.5280067921,
0.6495234966,
-1.2223684788,
-0.0872610286,
0.1569794416,
0.182815671,
-0.2225605398,
0.9022958875,
-0.0008034817,
0.3072175086,
-0.1215903834,
0.1371213347,
0.1978882402,
-0.1362175047,
-0.1274089813,
-0.0890527591,
0.0229736269,
-0.2292380184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05545v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05545v1
|
Named Entity Recognition for Address Extraction in Speech-to-Text Transcriptions Using Synthetic Data
| 2024-02-08T10:29:11 | 2024-02-08T10:29:11 |
Bibiána Lajčinová, Patrik Valábek, Michal Spišiak
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
This paper introduces an approach for building a Named Entity Recognition
(NER) model built upon a Bidirectional Encoder Representations from
Transformers (BERT) architecture, specifically utilizing the SlovakBERT model.
This NER model extracts address parts from data acquired from speech-to-text
transcriptions. Due to scarcity of real data, a synthetic dataset using GPT API
was generated. The importance of mimicking spoken language variability in this
artificial data is emphasized. The performance of our NER model, trained solely
on synthetic data, is evaluated using small real test dataset.
|
[
-0.3700855076,
-0.7761238217,
0.6368625164,
-0.1466625482,
-0.0564980619,
0.0472524799,
-0.2541079819,
-0.8152804375,
0.3959857225,
0.7636358738,
-0.5223510265,
-0.3810079098,
-0.5073292255,
0.4889074266,
-0.6755482554,
1.0881112814,
0.0958250985,
0.1477038264,
0.2031606585,
0.1712379903,
-0.3698934317,
-0.7799766064,
-0.6015791893,
-0.065798156,
0.2973721921,
0.3101160526,
0.3951586187,
0.4577172697,
0.4471947849,
0.2960363328,
0.0120903319,
0.0366775692,
-0.0713359341,
0.1934861988,
-0.1247536168,
-0.2822670937,
-0.3151320815,
-0.1777801514,
0.9507933855,
0.3624303341,
0.0106187724,
0.1675053239,
-0.3821061552,
0.3313975036,
-0.1094016358,
0.1685361713,
-0.8498510718,
-0.0750392452,
-0.3281398118,
0.0570834726,
-0.5936838388,
-0.4580518603,
0.6701840758,
-0.3065047264,
0.5270616412,
0.0129551431,
1.0630151033,
0.044181183,
-0.279936254,
-0.5327911973,
-1.2119714022,
0.4178700745,
-0.5547809601,
0.6773861647,
-0.0262111668,
0.56012398,
-0.2553738356,
-0.8614913225,
-0.8140332103,
-0.1575697809,
-0.0965938345,
0.0131494151,
-0.1807462871,
-0.028209094,
0.3786540627,
0.1981651634,
-0.3816398084,
-0.2448566705,
-0.5900399685,
-0.1833742857,
0.4537374675,
-0.1410627067,
0.5223335028,
-0.2916742563,
-0.5255249739,
-0.014679526,
-0.6309912205,
-0.1337855607,
0.6256426573,
0.6757931709,
0.0742350966,
0.6672859788,
-0.0525141023,
0.4638104439,
0.4449336827,
0.0701079592,
0.3393336535,
0.1976533085,
-0.3417747915,
0.7543529868,
0.6063304543,
-0.3554850221,
0.3502812088,
-0.6301829219,
-0.4945895374,
-0.2036091387,
0.4032205641,
-0.6296996474,
-0.5572642684,
0.1595649123,
-0.2910440266,
-0.0742992312,
0.4118285477,
-0.9106271267,
0.0447101183,
-0.6358367205,
0.3987049758,
-0.5258949399,
-0.246580869,
-0.3137353063,
-0.2308321595,
0.3986602426,
0.2925272882,
-0.8572249413,
0.5673915744,
0.6073891521,
0.5308268666,
-0.2653526366,
0.1093583107,
-0.3843811154,
0.279056102,
0.0693447888,
0.8149511814,
-0.5739355683,
-0.3343484402,
-0.2082541734,
0.1513514221,
-0.0588172562,
-0.7596131563,
0.3239841759,
-0.7978901267,
0.1541820467,
0.0576085076,
-0.5724555254,
-0.0440833308,
0.1305303127,
-1.056625247,
1.0331281424,
0.2671287656,
-0.7317761779,
0.1181657612,
-0.8173140883,
-0.3482911587,
0.2132676393,
-0.1329061538,
-0.3877104819,
0.1281100661,
0.1837812066,
0.0261344854,
-0.3094058633,
0.39553532,
0.179286465,
-0.0594322681,
0.4115211368,
-0.644764483,
0.6747985482,
0.119560495,
-0.2946288288,
-0.2449421585,
-1.1806069613,
0.0046794736,
0.1741378158,
-0.4772172868,
-0.465932548,
0.1460786164,
0.3636363149,
0.1181562915,
0.2839558721,
-0.822598815,
0.1570319533,
-0.5575128198,
0.2800383866,
0.5713278055,
0.1350855082,
0.4923627675,
0.1028290614,
0.349757731,
0.0693998858,
-0.2827380002,
0.2788456976,
-0.3919493854,
-0.8754168153,
-0.3906804025,
0.9417983294,
0.7307903767,
-0.6987102032,
0.2229026407,
-0.6381916404,
-0.4706889689,
-0.6628939509,
-0.3496944606,
0.1732947975,
0.5719811916,
0.4990700483,
-0.1040215492,
-0.998313725,
-1.1348603964,
-0.0603880361,
-0.1014292389,
-0.1750261337,
0.4380654693,
0.4638684094,
-0.4337092638,
1.2295091152,
-0.3396914303,
0.1157391518,
-0.3903310597,
0.2505145669,
0.2751943469,
0.5183104873,
0.2125284523,
-0.9549409151,
-0.4843382537,
-0.0947749987,
-0.3839106262,
-0.0391871035,
-0.0293129273,
-0.1994892806,
-0.0175548401,
0.1467550099,
-0.8761399388,
0.3808264732,
0.3401260376,
0.0052868547,
0.7428400517,
-0.1541183144,
-0.2046300322,
-1.2098209858,
-0.0287625734,
-0.0072467285,
-0.3856660724,
-0.9670240879,
-0.3729079962,
0.1097893938,
-0.3397431374,
-0.4874560535,
0.4093494415,
-0.6910297275,
-0.3360405862,
-0.0222482458,
0.0156174367,
-0.4052999318,
0.3059635162,
0.5103775263,
1.0443912745,
0.2902005017,
-0.584485352,
0.6232249737,
0.4512781203,
-0.2010570616,
0.4524196386,
-0.6612312198,
0.5192814469,
-0.243375212,
0.0720393583,
-0.8521329761,
-0.2858066857,
0.2978906035,
-0.6126018167,
0.5400936604,
-0.4070052505,
-0.66653198,
-0.327124089,
0.467539221,
0.3216493726,
0.6674795747,
-0.8193002343,
0.8871943951,
0.7063356042,
-0.4341595471,
-0.1263788491,
-0.6116948128,
0.2165893316,
-0.2204286009,
-0.2469241321,
0.7308399677,
0.3256545365,
-0.0625633895,
-0.1238718256,
0.0114980889,
-0.5745353699,
-0.3212227225,
0.2232217193,
0.5832667947,
-0.2653777003,
0.2704470456,
-0.1581441164,
-0.2280335873,
0.3549454808,
-0.3210346699,
0.5378324389,
0.0990664214,
-0.0072650858,
-0.5589596033,
0.4091552496,
0.4979591072,
-0.196860984,
0.5211088061,
0.1784988642,
-0.7349927425,
-0.1137984768,
-0.5404440165,
-0.0740496889,
-0.44182235,
0.1700510681,
-0.5308707952,
-0.3071719408,
0.4864408374,
-0.2524873018,
-0.2847553492,
0.5437777042,
0.401996851,
-0.0272168014,
0.7084083557,
0.5995886922,
-0.1700015366,
0.4198548198,
-0.0836312473,
0.5380612016,
-0.8952191472,
-0.2989761233,
-0.7166408896,
-0.1960251033,
-0.8787812591,
-0.1108818427,
0.0648191571,
-0.4844502807,
-0.0676905811,
1.1125252247,
-0.6574614644,
0.2984460592,
0.7308542132,
0.1568214297,
-0.0595394745,
0.0294487663,
-0.2584940791,
-0.2027456164,
-0.2550683618,
-0.7308626771,
0.8271214962,
0.2920571864,
0.5784258246,
0.1873931587,
1.0232172012,
0.2318717092,
0.3202743232,
-0.5620804429,
0.5168727636,
0.0369497575,
-0.7342936993,
-0.2769917846,
-0.2882891893,
-0.7897365689,
-0.1789106727,
-0.0299524814,
-0.944814086,
0.5131395459,
-0.0983749405,
-0.2366494536,
0.3240324855,
-0.6167382002,
0.5104764104,
-0.2409744859,
0.1269053072,
0.4139777422,
-0.6606634259,
0.024986688,
-0.160022229,
-0.0838264525,
0.153347984,
0.3913864493,
0.8151592612,
-0.2430976182,
0.617865026,
-0.2940968275,
-0.078833811,
0.3515724242,
-0.1538417786,
0.8739281893,
0.0483478941,
-0.187747851,
0.379786253,
-0.107393451,
0.0491816774,
-0.4403092861,
0.5467458963,
-0.7155024409,
-0.3085317016,
-0.3695913255,
-0.433311671,
-0.1856509447,
0.1364646554,
0.2869982123,
0.4476862848,
-0.3479765058,
0.0006199562,
0.7003131509,
-0.2133440673,
0.3241795003,
0.3890440166,
0.2341607362,
-0.6145219803,
0.748154819,
0.1972917765,
0.0870367065,
0.6174297333,
-0.3823980689,
-0.4814663529,
-0.3183321357,
-0.556776464,
0.0695494041,
-0.3858382404,
-0.3211400509,
-0.7964507341,
-0.7927024364,
-0.4715071619,
0.2426256388,
-0.5571376085,
-0.4578688443,
-0.4605392814,
0.0298055205,
0.2383786738,
0.6449008584,
0.0876323804,
0.2888589203,
-0.8052984476,
0.512162149,
0.1494847387,
0.1675031185,
-0.2170291841,
-0.4304936528,
-0.048752699,
0.2955689132,
-0.0466648564,
-1.3760942221,
0.8090440631,
0.1093116477,
0.6150212288,
0.1620550007,
0.0290503018,
0.7436824441,
-1.0242481232,
0.5536138415,
0.0041962201,
-0.8629236221,
0.7606968284,
-0.0699534342,
-0.1484631151,
0.4206170738,
0.267190963,
-0.2332537472,
-0.1482660025,
-0.889267087,
-0.8657725453,
0.6921592951,
0.2840736806,
0.2464769483,
-0.2896891832,
0.4843446612,
0.1581505239,
0.179977566,
-0.7431001067,
-0.3107093275,
0.1082888022,
-0.4665097892,
0.2191412747,
-0.4484407604,
0.2928321064,
-0.1710197031,
0.6302483678,
0.3962056041,
0.9479627609,
0.4615827203,
-0.3011687696,
0.2136697024,
0.4894840121,
0.2831220627,
0.0886006355,
-0.3744240105,
0.124456808,
0.3214088976,
-0.6038293839,
0.1498553753,
0.5114078522,
-0.5491107106,
0.595919311,
-0.1439178884,
0.6695306897,
0.1729934514,
-0.5764555335,
0.3206232488,
0.0842572078,
-0.0689469054,
-0.823310256,
-0.0114566619,
-0.1381765753,
0.3020924032,
0.3607211709,
-0.0548616312,
0.3667102158,
-0.4439448714,
0.3283406794,
0.3845721483,
-0.4987748563,
-0.494933635,
0.6980136037,
-0.0509311855,
-0.7935890555,
1.0009826422,
0.0753601044,
-0.7154884934,
0.8487730622,
0.9169833064,
1.1560404301,
-0.3196761012,
0.0386291184,
0.4625891149,
0.1483629048,
-0.0074818865,
0.1651543975,
-0.1103660017,
-0.5879583359,
-0.0423673168,
-0.5748083591,
-0.477769345,
0.1636843383,
-0.8224933743,
0.4299151003,
-0.3337320983,
-0.2384906709,
0.3296345472,
-0.2876543403,
-0.9251936078,
0.321708411,
0.3105221391,
0.7621807456,
-0.5174879432,
1.0673966408,
0.6604903936,
-0.3931392133,
-0.7805584669,
0.1538325697,
-0.3434213698,
-0.5369150043,
1.2628488541,
0.1523784399,
0.0851894692,
0.2198816389,
-0.5435490608,
-1.1229567528,
0.8886142969,
0.2001906633,
-0.7322303057,
-0.3615191579,
0.3609858155,
0.566639483,
-0.4828260541,
0.1560377181,
0.5036591291,
0.3313194215,
0.0437822901,
-0.8642914295,
-0.1604941189,
-0.1878205389,
0.0848185271,
0.3924079537,
-0.1503589451,
0.8920894861,
-0.1765500605,
-0.4542241395,
0.1402685046,
0.7359858751,
0.0497696921,
0.0188905057,
0.2100726664,
0.4713094234,
0.6782281399,
-0.2813797891,
0.664319694,
-0.2753751576,
0.3839215338,
1.3159021139,
-0.427957356,
1.0881018639,
0.6188368797,
-0.2181202918,
0.5988792777,
0.3504081368,
-0.2838833034,
0.9195347428,
0.3466273248,
-0.3927183449,
0.2307883501,
0.2720410526,
-0.2072811276,
0.5482826233,
0.3716052473,
-0.6364203095,
-0.2086020112,
-0.02861722,
-0.2845718265,
-0.3259972036,
0.1008569673,
1.0827527046,
-0.2511830032,
-0.3974611163,
0.2673689425,
0.1327218711,
0.3843134642,
-0.2968579233,
-0.3480342031,
0.2471824437,
0.0103072403,
0.2209423631,
-0.3831699789,
0.3248128891,
0.2805531621,
-0.5249769688,
-0.0874119774,
0.8750476837,
-0.6775772572,
-0.5844559669,
0.0582320914,
0.2052087188,
0.3661754727,
-0.0390209705,
-0.3135461807,
-0.4098970294,
-0.1111596078,
-0.0198808815,
0.1453263313,
0.6305506825,
0.2552966475,
0.3509055078,
0.8617392778,
0.4358985126,
0.1717348844,
-0.0592841543,
0.6849702597,
-0.8730540872,
-0.4940401614,
-0.795558095,
0.2982938588,
-0.2353998423,
-0.069744572,
0.4750220776,
0.7890589237,
0.691428721,
-0.3480767906,
0.8706629276,
-0.044641953,
0.870072484,
-0.3504300714,
0.4302582443,
0.051100269,
0.2440260798,
-0.2838830948,
-1.033809185,
0.0002038966,
0.6839804649,
-0.4613240957,
-0.2187149674,
0.3494296968,
0.7171762586,
-0.221489802,
0.0120559158,
0.1167213842,
0.0956322029,
0.2504609525,
0.5752381682,
0.757083416,
-0.8448563218,
0.2755051255,
-0.2208437622,
0.2388667315,
-0.2596090138,
-0.6427082419,
-0.5896906257,
-0.6038167477,
-0.2205052078,
-0.3774939477,
0.2261979133,
0.9901203513,
0.6005613208,
-1.1065922976,
0.2035699487,
-0.2734715939,
-0.1414206624,
0.1845614314,
-0.2818620205,
0.5632494688,
-0.0546907932,
-1.0204726458,
0.3488114178,
0.2240320444,
0.6106086373,
0.0553405508,
0.067428045,
-0.143089816,
0.1725421101,
0.2892463803,
0.4369573593,
-0.8066825271,
-0.4174529016,
0.0595518798,
-0.2813515663,
0.2513537407,
0.5429589748,
-0.8792782426,
0.3717882037,
0.3853829503,
0.7949820161,
0.297462672,
0.253198266,
0.5132511854,
-0.6718656421,
0.0034524412,
0.2781888247,
0.3989186883,
0.2817632258,
-0.7209390402,
0.2085602582,
0.1326589286,
-0.3978749216,
-0.7428601384,
-0.0049083927,
-1.0105663538,
0.3110376,
1.1658327579,
0.0827291459,
-0.3265045285,
-0.2436853349,
-0.4043834805,
0.4567311108,
-0.4516195059,
0.7476920485,
0.6786614656,
-0.1259026974,
-0.2232967019,
-0.7778589725,
0.2887791991,
-0.1675260216,
-0.8394785523,
-0.0070160357,
0.4444726408,
0.5173795223,
0.2365654707,
0.3783209026,
-0.2987481654,
0.1145499051,
0.0654292852,
0.3063384593,
0.2247668356,
-0.5275917649,
0.0458833873,
0.0911371931,
-0.2779780626,
-0.3556950688
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05536v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05536v1
|
Empowering machine learning models with contextual knowledge for enhancing the detection of eating disorders in social media posts
| 2024-02-08T10:15:41 | 2024-02-08T10:15:41 |
José Alberto Benítez-Andrades, María Teresa García-Ordás, Mayra Russo, Ahmad Sakor, Luis Daniel Fernandes Rotger, Maria-Esther Vidal
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Social networks are vital for information sharing, especially in the health
sector for discussing diseases and treatments. These platforms, however, often
feature posts as brief texts, posing challenges for Artificial Intelligence
(AI) in understanding context. We introduce a novel hybrid approach combining
community-maintained knowledge graphs (like Wikidata) with deep learning to
enhance the categorization of social media posts. This method uses advanced
entity recognizers and linkers (like Falcon 2.0) to connect short post entities
to knowledge graphs. Knowledge graph embeddings (KGEs) and contextualized word
embeddings (like BERT) are then employed to create rich, context-based
representations of these posts.
Our focus is on the health domain, particularly in identifying posts related
to eating disorders (e.g., anorexia, bulimia) to aid healthcare providers in
early diagnosis. We tested our approach on a dataset of 2,000 tweets about
eating disorders, finding that merging word embeddings with knowledge graph
information enhances the predictive models' reliability. This methodology aims
to assist health experts in spotting patterns indicative of mental disorders,
thereby improving early detection and accurate diagnosis for personalized
medicine.
|
[
-0.0888299122,
-1.0821566582,
0.5374075174,
-0.0958167538,
-0.3711193204,
0.3861211538,
-0.0569863021,
-0.5984632373,
0.8954284191,
0.4489366412,
-0.1840987056,
-0.6212533116,
-0.8454321027,
-0.1650566608,
-0.4544279873,
0.7119262218,
-0.2232400626,
0.2858797908,
-0.4367063642,
-0.3166547716,
-0.3085203171,
-0.3582391739,
-0.919408977,
-0.3032338619,
0.6966251135,
0.1429389268,
0.518914938,
0.4600796402,
0.2689450383,
0.2069256902,
0.1913845539,
0.7296645045,
-0.3996546268,
0.0499060787,
-0.2080908269,
-0.0433017835,
-0.3001798391,
-0.3545539677,
0.1895428002,
0.9721699953,
0.0506012179,
0.1105876788,
0.2552403808,
0.5088592172,
-0.3416581154,
0.1244521663,
-0.2537073791,
0.3385182917,
-0.1071285084,
-0.243570298,
0.0164211355,
-0.1461090297,
0.0800051093,
-0.73430866,
-0.0987311229,
-0.0417389087,
0.6601862907,
0.3887416124,
-0.878921628,
-0.3536997736,
-0.6817567348,
0.2822620869,
-0.5170140862,
0.4421355426,
0.4378151298,
0.3332670629,
-0.0852316394,
-0.7720758319,
-0.5597063899,
0.2264545709,
-0.3651940525,
-0.3087770939,
-0.2412817627,
-0.1041972786,
0.0558883883,
0.1555300802,
-0.8027348518,
0.1649032682,
-0.4558151662,
-0.2171050161,
0.6513777375,
0.1266283542,
0.6640163064,
-0.2818757594,
0.0232120659,
0.203840822,
-0.3077229261,
0.0983701721,
-0.1974625587,
0.1410966516,
-0.0718634054,
0.6159135103,
-0.2068628371,
0.5632607937,
0.2636047602,
0.036410898,
0.377407819,
-0.227437973,
-0.1562501639,
0.1053133979,
0.6166889071,
0.782433331,
0.0206845943,
-0.1900310516,
-0.059932936,
0.1883657426,
0.3921497464,
-0.7242266536,
-0.519405961,
0.2052247077,
-0.6395802498,
-0.2024173141,
-0.1026872918,
-0.5541613102,
-1.0594055653,
-0.2819350958,
0.3084124625,
-0.6011037827,
-0.3597639799,
-0.1461303234,
-0.1563812047,
-0.0452455916,
0.2611985207,
-0.6538028121,
0.3516362309,
0.6300898194,
0.605266273,
0.0129272481,
0.1221044138,
-0.3565208912,
0.6313411593,
-0.2687647939,
0.7000854611,
-0.6023026705,
-0.117438443,
-0.0013063541,
0.2155411839,
-0.1981320679,
-0.6593818069,
0.4615657628,
-0.5206474066,
-0.2389646471,
-0.5096811056,
-0.989228189,
-0.4277044535,
0.2703438103,
-0.7031230927,
0.8029623628,
0.305952251,
-0.7056522369,
0.6862227321,
-0.4386493564,
-0.9490676522,
0.3906831443,
-0.2198297828,
-0.3575611711,
0.0730127171,
0.564278245,
0.8598352671,
0.0990048423,
0.4709929228,
-0.8268865943,
-0.1702996939,
0.0077280393,
0.1824150681,
0.3490360975,
0.2416542321,
-0.0151679125,
0.3412443697,
-0.3989439905,
-0.0294384509,
0.3136079907,
0.0040641739,
-0.8439570069,
0.3106125891,
-0.0402729101,
-0.0562165119,
0.0654793233,
-0.2072748393,
0.0021887035,
-0.2340621799,
0.7064761519,
0.4311009347,
0.3150138855,
0.2805142701,
-0.4624347091,
0.1616084725,
0.2938264906,
0.0404864512,
0.0073201051,
-0.6119957566,
-0.2266336977,
-0.1988865882,
0.2091278434,
0.5747550726,
-1.0530833006,
0.8906764984,
-0.2685825825,
-0.3366275132,
-0.5061784983,
0.3087338805,
-0.0302528553,
0.7358118892,
0.5625677109,
-0.0627546757,
-0.7127181292,
-0.5823637843,
-0.2560832202,
0.4205396175,
-0.1775573492,
0.4302687645,
0.5448453426,
-0.6552983522,
0.6111804843,
-0.305708468,
-0.2394051105,
-0.3935305476,
-0.047975447,
-0.2005112767,
0.4323276579,
0.7310888767,
-1.1288108826,
-0.7172126174,
0.3151577115,
-1.0098104477,
0.25246647,
0.4843775034,
0.1563184708,
-0.0951926485,
0.3238791525,
-0.3201287091,
0.4085575044,
0.3022023737,
-0.4878647029,
0.0208875034,
0.1771485358,
0.1875905842,
-1.3447378874,
-0.0427218042,
0.3370431364,
-0.4422535002,
-0.5469136238,
-0.2788062096,
0.0557572395,
-0.2952460647,
-0.0694776922,
0.5613611937,
0.0378118567,
0.0535403453,
-0.1352510601,
-0.2968193293,
0.0662067905,
0.0536681674,
-0.0639102533,
0.1163813621,
0.5606392622,
-0.594217658,
0.3910410404,
-0.1897475123,
-0.3898274004,
0.4853072762,
-0.4660607874,
-0.0869421139,
-0.2957850695,
0.4239049852,
-0.9558870792,
-0.6019258499,
0.5479226112,
-0.6223480105,
0.1690007597,
0.2606492341,
-0.6559211612,
-0.681194663,
-0.1128975973,
0.5116192698,
0.1870818734,
-0.5353159904,
0.5485123396,
0.6352434158,
0.0628587753,
-0.0636701509,
-0.6700266004,
-0.0720953494,
-0.1823215485,
-0.6339156628,
0.3802904785,
0.2469881475,
-0.0101895761,
0.7674286962,
-0.0530505255,
-0.2199708968,
0.2574456036,
-0.0503740162,
-0.0923206955,
-0.1605873108,
0.3066819608,
0.5788004398,
0.2999918461,
-0.1345792711,
-0.4429717064,
0.6528210044,
0.1095879078,
-0.0547630526,
-0.6447657943,
0.6505764723,
0.4164186716,
-0.2558929026,
0.8121458888,
0.7723261714,
-1.0345253944,
-0.288898021,
-0.3196683228,
-0.3992228806,
-0.423830688,
0.2263830602,
0.0547121391,
-1.0170460939,
0.5362210274,
-0.1186028346,
-0.4151870608,
0.2788896561,
0.2118808478,
-0.4492390156,
1.1238569021,
0.6081861854,
-0.230423376,
0.4222939312,
-0.2296425849,
0.3364829719,
-0.6433208585,
-0.3026492596,
0.1452153772,
-0.5754590034,
-0.4088927805,
-0.5082992315,
0.4482316077,
-0.1400566697,
-0.1863731742,
0.0240287781,
-0.545443058,
0.3283871412,
0.1981621981,
0.6869961619,
-0.0071780942,
-0.016742846,
-0.251221031,
-0.0909948796,
-0.737459898,
-0.3922042251,
1.1226377487,
0.2328906506,
0.4566911757,
-0.1820945293,
0.8000240326,
0.7702059746,
0.5594996214,
-0.8027892709,
0.1213984713,
-0.3480541706,
-0.4838711321,
-0.0413660891,
-0.6883946657,
-0.8321509361,
-0.0402649119,
-0.332239002,
-0.7672371864,
0.0586392209,
0.2177954167,
-0.5930451751,
0.5255329609,
-0.7680860162,
1.0503015518,
-0.4259968102,
-0.0942069218,
-0.191225335,
-0.5449278355,
0.3957033157,
0.0367931128,
0.300334543,
-0.0027040492,
0.0169083178,
0.9911950231,
-0.2303909361,
0.9151960015,
-0.1512029022,
0.2907356918,
0.0168555453,
-0.1522695273,
0.0524563417,
0.0630173162,
0.1455641687,
-0.0657099634,
-0.0221830644,
-0.4239536524,
-0.6764320731,
0.672516048,
-0.732435286,
-0.0774226487,
-0.1526025087,
-0.3146961629,
-0.4228444397,
0.4598143399,
-0.0804096758,
0.2372058481,
-0.0025607792,
0.2682849765,
0.7287750244,
-0.1912547946,
-0.0310679972,
0.2538582087,
-0.1994482875,
-0.5460835695,
1.0636307001,
0.2453786433,
-0.3750723004,
0.3919405043,
0.2562779188,
-0.0902162716,
-0.3509705365,
-0.0066023986,
0.2788766325,
-0.608533144,
-0.0933487862,
-0.7513519526,
-0.2778116465,
-0.8799139261,
-0.3095433116,
-0.2235146761,
0.0564591251,
-0.5488357544,
-0.4629429877,
0.1851992011,
0.873455584,
-0.0700148493,
0.1642744988,
-0.7593203783,
0.5016158819,
0.1894370019,
0.3558230698,
0.5632990599,
0.048963692,
-0.2622638643,
0.1144348979,
-0.2884311378,
-1.027230382,
0.4398826361,
0.1074111164,
0.5939509869,
0.8537002206,
0.2019380182,
0.514408946,
-0.1015533507,
0.3997302353,
0.2243400067,
-0.5242356062,
0.7277914882,
-0.2359194756,
-0.0561523251,
0.5192181468,
1.1263035536,
-0.7985909581,
-0.1704609096,
-0.3620023131,
-0.7530930638,
0.1885607392,
-0.1482207924,
0.0494642593,
-0.1418444216,
0.4935891926,
0.0605029762,
0.24055475,
-0.4887565374,
-0.2755111158,
-0.3612390459,
-0.4693811238,
-0.0831135139,
-0.1188753173,
-0.2508833408,
-0.8653890491,
0.4111403227,
-0.1745360941,
0.131564945,
0.1449495256,
-0.2441546917,
-0.1696208864,
-0.225930199,
0.1777525693,
0.7017641068,
-0.0964994058,
0.1957885027,
-0.1529844254,
-0.1177746728,
-0.2093739063,
0.3966896832,
-0.1578223705,
-0.0884314254,
0.5243335366,
0.6453442574,
0.4165832698,
-0.6096265316,
0.4645840526,
-0.0940764397,
-0.1833499223,
-0.1792312413,
-0.0619636141,
0.2356821597,
0.3298244774,
0.427131325,
-0.0794708207,
0.3464818597,
-0.6112726331,
0.497970283,
0.3200983405,
-0.376866132,
-0.4141762257,
0.5900027156,
0.3760602176,
-0.2079118192,
0.5451855659,
-0.3991398811,
-0.5680820942,
0.6349777579,
0.2729306519,
0.4259726703,
-0.3185929954,
0.3449141979,
0.2073891312,
0.2088094354,
0.222898066,
0.2812863588,
-0.2294487506,
-0.9253987074,
-0.1581231058,
-0.6476941705,
-0.0959312543,
0.3491995037,
-0.6725072265,
0.1200175658,
-0.49825719,
-0.1670864671,
0.4424682856,
0.0566921793,
-0.7533428073,
0.2203767151,
0.5269016027,
0.6067593694,
-1.1877251863,
0.8584519625,
0.8894074559,
-0.2766997516,
-0.6719786525,
0.2043760568,
-0.002284389,
-0.7166379094,
0.0522861555,
0.5254087448,
0.5370059013,
-0.1328401119,
-0.5567489862,
-0.7696140409,
0.9846711755,
0.0405281782,
-0.2849446237,
-0.172351867,
0.1225735247,
0.6495189667,
-0.4446843565,
-0.2201719433,
0.4222323895,
0.6009949446,
0.2563380599,
-0.6926574111,
0.1987210512,
-0.1399283856,
-0.0207200814,
-0.0161624011,
-0.3244600296,
0.479434222,
-0.3128890395,
-0.3428530395,
-0.2046031952,
0.6826794147,
0.0783028379,
0.8003938794,
0.4086364806,
0.8946608305,
1.2562637329,
0.1799519956,
0.9703007936,
-0.2540543973,
0.2442610711,
0.9265956879,
-0.4549643099,
0.5534321666,
0.1833095998,
0.043317847,
0.5370523334,
1.1478054523,
0.0126648862,
0.6450560093,
-0.0248492006,
-0.1725297719,
-0.2610168755,
-0.3659650981,
-0.3519895673,
0.0842011869,
0.8394352198,
-0.6938878298,
-0.2554555237,
0.5074349046,
0.148315832,
0.1515891552,
-0.4628814161,
0.8906039596,
0.1044194773,
-0.133074522,
0.2691283226,
-0.0350781567,
0.5968840122,
-0.2682409286,
-0.019015912,
0.0395803452,
0.0053399792,
-0.335344106,
-0.692328155,
0.6996368766,
-0.4520412982,
-0.2831220627,
-0.1333276331,
1.0805659294,
-0.4374417663,
-0.8493954539,
0.6133232117,
0.4914455116,
-0.1532587409,
-0.0358378589,
-0.7235243917,
-0.0332765952,
-0.3839026988,
0.0487375893,
0.1586803347,
0.5252270103,
-0.1275490671,
0.4895336628,
0.5318290591,
-0.1063815132,
-0.154808417,
-0.2466836572,
1.1128191948,
-0.3712424934,
-0.5103969574,
-0.7669359446,
0.1510136127,
-0.2580637336,
0.1036103219,
0.5362066627,
0.4325129688,
0.853713572,
0.1071482748,
0.8794962168,
-0.462849617,
0.5629649758,
-0.1315830797,
1.0758539438,
-1.0798422098,
-0.1968984604,
-0.0365334004,
-0.1044497415,
-0.3034807146,
0.4166124463,
-0.5691461563,
0.1279218942,
0.5986559391,
0.5279709697,
-0.1939816922,
-0.1040375158,
0.1631788611,
0.3171811402,
0.135118112,
0.5981935263,
0.5042939186,
-0.0309510622,
0.0013069982,
-0.4470714629,
-0.2627340853,
-0.4499299228,
-0.3383316696,
-0.9313782454,
-0.6815129519,
-0.205653578,
-0.1812252551,
0.3067611456,
0.7594120502,
0.9956226349,
-0.7723463774,
0.1949494034,
0.2103403807,
0.6242936254,
-0.4940278828,
-0.3017484248,
0.3027496338,
0.0778026581,
-0.2465815544,
0.3739100695,
-0.0510635786,
-0.1562061906,
-0.1220060065,
0.0343742631,
-0.3103480637,
-0.2229231745,
0.6123922467,
0.1557328701,
-0.4635806382,
-0.082944788,
-0.3395116925,
-0.0601573288,
-0.0366405882,
0.5811895132,
-0.575753212,
0.3312394321,
0.225622803,
0.9141538143,
0.2588357925,
0.0684647858,
0.3243587911,
-0.5390661359,
-0.1410063803,
0.5094891191,
0.4462429881,
0.4149526656,
-0.8115599155,
0.1730886698,
0.624260664,
-0.137196362,
-0.6235269904,
-0.1666022688,
-0.9402597547,
-0.5798364878,
1.0248173475,
-0.0380073003,
-0.6008505821,
-0.0334030986,
0.1975636482,
0.3737185001,
-0.3955507874,
0.8452369571,
0.4086447656,
-0.3139903545,
-0.0752210617,
-0.4887303114,
0.3810706735,
0.1095569655,
-0.7418647408,
-0.4645406604,
0.2341373414,
0.573843956,
-0.1511921883,
0.5692566633,
0.2937209904,
0.2571372688,
-0.3944839239,
-0.1748912334,
-0.0623671971,
-0.1694887877,
0.0732532442,
0.123574242,
-0.5782106519,
-0.1048850119
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05515v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05515v2
|
NoisyICL: A Little Noise in Model Parameters Calibrates In-context Learning
| 2024-02-08T09:48:02 | 2024-02-15T15:25:47 |
Yufeng Zhao, Yoshihiro Sakai, Naoya Inoue
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In-Context Learning (ICL) is suffering from unsatisfactory performance and
under-calibration due to high prior bias and unfaithful confidence. Some
previous works fine-tuned language models for better ICL performance with
enormous datasets and computing costs. In this paper, we propose NoisyICL,
simply perturbing the model parameters by random noises to strive for better
performance and calibration. Our experiments on two models and 12 downstream
datasets show that NoisyICL can help ICL produce more accurate predictions. Our
further analysis indicates that NoisyICL enables the model to provide more fair
predictions, and also with more faithful confidence. Therefore, we believe that
NoisyICL is an effective calibration of ICL. Our experimental code is uploaded
to Github.
|
[
-0.3411613405,
-0.6835036874,
0.435759902,
0.0065422608,
-0.2794746161,
0.0288796294,
-0.403303206,
-0.7866106629,
-0.4702233076,
0.1727360338,
-0.5268226266,
-0.555388391,
-0.2123757899,
-0.1926357299,
-0.3755200803,
1.2654393911,
0.3622457087,
0.5235661864,
0.0501221307,
0.0216177776,
-0.2211904228,
-0.2122459561,
-0.82046628,
-0.5856471062,
0.5905857682,
0.5090984106,
0.7612143159,
0.3706146777,
0.2121638507,
0.1320836991,
-0.1968972683,
0.2011103034,
-0.7078721523,
0.1926627457,
0.1160521135,
-0.3856032789,
-0.1333896518,
-0.0955777317,
0.7473951578,
0.9819918871,
-0.258374393,
0.3495606184,
0.5388338566,
0.6256437302,
-0.8024086952,
0.1944634914,
-0.7204271555,
-0.03977203,
-0.164236322,
0.0760232508,
-0.5859943032,
-0.2836534381,
0.1389175951,
-0.6232584119,
-0.0848696083,
0.2594534159,
0.8024831414,
0.7299820781,
-0.0584909506,
-0.2427342981,
-1.0640873909,
1.0083676577,
-1.050118804,
0.5728264451,
0.5078452826,
0.2292552441,
-0.1064911112,
-0.8536980748,
-0.1886509806,
-0.3369826376,
0.1595310718,
-0.0292691924,
0.1643708497,
0.1005166695,
0.4075909257,
0.0629156008,
-0.1285274178,
0.1171079129,
-0.3030266166,
-0.1682777852,
0.4941176176,
0.0551541224,
0.0968201458,
0.6407779455,
-0.2101631016,
0.0007058271,
-0.9431210756,
0.3459436297,
0.7705276608,
0.5895835757,
-0.2614814937,
-0.1225860044,
-0.1092112586,
0.8436895609,
0.3812868297,
-0.2486073226,
0.1514682323,
0.1330818385,
-0.1041813716,
0.4542126954,
0.390216589,
-0.0179129019,
0.2794314325,
-0.2363088578,
-0.4966911376,
-0.3014714122,
0.0297792535,
-1.0606518984,
-0.7151374221,
0.1994571239,
-0.422911644,
-0.46665591,
0.0619713925,
-0.3444852233,
-0.1916278154,
-0.6462258697,
0.448779583,
-0.3539967239,
-0.0981158167,
-0.0044915187,
0.2976509035,
-0.1804226935,
0.6269967556,
-0.8660745025,
0.4415528774,
0.4579169154,
0.3937225342,
-0.0840708241,
-0.2944690585,
-0.6748007536,
-0.0075993706,
-0.6231582761,
0.6707881093,
-0.4557002187,
-0.1088811085,
-0.1747793406,
-0.5889210105,
0.0148595972,
-0.7282969952,
0.3489231467,
-0.5087989569,
-0.1464071274,
-0.2696801722,
-0.4824090302,
-0.0779277235,
0.0202000458,
-0.602238059,
1.1331775188,
0.1025782824,
-0.6336247921,
0.8619606495,
-0.6218416691,
-0.2485827208,
0.2300369143,
-0.3594336212,
-0.397957176,
-0.0038335656,
0.058499705,
0.1143664569,
-0.1443270296,
0.2395182401,
-0.4904440939,
-0.9257807732,
0.4786737561,
-0.8133770227,
0.9346545339,
0.5926111341,
-0.3436844945,
0.0317119919,
-0.7790505886,
0.2799252272,
-0.4315921664,
-0.465318948,
-0.3777808249,
0.2573110461,
0.3242149055,
0.0937508121,
0.1315607727,
-0.497605294,
-0.1498666555,
-0.7743443847,
0.168255955,
0.6150652766,
-0.134157598,
0.4171840549,
-0.4755942822,
0.2166542262,
0.0376353152,
0.2277362943,
0.1948643178,
-0.4080552459,
-0.3163274229,
-0.3751578331,
0.4118095636,
0.0121504599,
-0.2396421582,
-0.1727996022,
0.0912280232,
-0.4013686776,
-0.6765693426,
0.5139206648,
0.492647469,
0.7655417919,
0.2883490026,
-0.1158466935,
-0.5270929933,
-0.4810424447,
-0.356223613,
-0.3779452443,
-0.0633161664,
0.4515708089,
0.1267921478,
0.1218335852,
0.8080301881,
-0.0482410267,
-0.2729851902,
-0.0288421139,
0.1815306097,
0.1072987244,
0.3642100692,
0.7061964273,
-0.9372566938,
-0.9416593909,
-0.2423289567,
-0.3399344385,
-0.1994375437,
0.2665414512,
0.2291871011,
0.1472556889,
0.7674000263,
-0.0286764503,
0.4146529138,
0.4971973002,
-0.0123744216,
0.4510727823,
-0.1330793351,
-0.2143752128,
-0.6891397238,
-0.0236125197,
-0.2569396794,
-0.2554037273,
-0.3954028487,
0.1850545108,
0.0483977199,
0.0550220273,
-0.7416009903,
0.5027186275,
-0.3445705771,
0.22958754,
-0.3007614613,
-0.0406465568,
-0.3128606379,
0.2420655489,
-0.1740419418,
0.9542503357,
0.740578413,
-0.6439704895,
-0.2169819772,
-0.1725855321,
-0.4366428256,
0.240191564,
-0.3034363687,
0.0856963322,
-0.114524506,
0.2884773016,
-1.0502458811,
-0.2999688685,
0.2340734899,
-0.1120835841,
0.4146697521,
-0.2723971009,
-0.3859446049,
0.1647551954,
-0.1451489627,
0.862511456,
0.4295681119,
-0.8335811496,
0.3495820761,
0.5121520162,
0.3919916153,
-0.5300305486,
-0.7896901965,
-0.2081308067,
-0.0928235948,
-0.1627044827,
0.3972521424,
-0.7375926971,
-0.545407176,
-0.11402639,
-0.0007999741,
-0.2874643207,
0.1263052523,
0.5247246623,
0.0758106858,
-0.45808056,
0.1626223624,
-0.2203984112,
-0.066842854,
0.0764428303,
-0.3396263421,
0.4277967811,
-0.3191527724,
-0.3127592504,
-0.6055390835,
-0.0968289748,
0.564463675,
0.1978079379,
0.4164747298,
0.5049022436,
-0.5127002597,
-0.6425181031,
-0.3378508985,
-0.4699813724,
-0.5152730942,
0.2269276083,
-0.2252340466,
-0.5661336184,
0.5570754409,
-0.1251743436,
0.079132624,
0.1266574711,
0.5069202781,
-0.2044991255,
1.411129117,
0.6711147428,
-0.3303215504,
0.5635376573,
0.0286894571,
0.3849031925,
-0.6110306382,
-0.0390054919,
-0.5931708217,
-0.5211575031,
-0.5659891963,
0.0294211097,
0.2275539488,
0.0270906296,
-0.6136314273,
-0.1390750855,
-0.4706014395,
0.76477319,
0.5479958653,
0.2354477197,
0.2815368176,
0.0732305944,
-0.2398812175,
-0.3680121899,
-0.6760703325,
-0.4564355016,
0.9241861701,
0.1565798968,
1.3388762474,
-0.0475711003,
0.6522218585,
-0.001656247,
0.5688554049,
-0.5186700821,
0.2100373954,
-0.2898912132,
-0.7380966544,
-0.3332547247,
-0.1601511389,
-0.5908785462,
-0.2279361635,
-0.1052717641,
-1.2702476978,
0.178122595,
0.4682748914,
-0.7949133515,
0.4431524575,
-0.3824218512,
0.4877236784,
-0.0972471386,
-0.4312053025,
-0.1865526587,
-0.6386188269,
0.286860019,
-0.1549251676,
0.2179461867,
-0.0902783573,
0.1386936754,
0.4588282704,
-0.3882113099,
1.1127289534,
-0.1341765672,
0.0280357506,
0.4807864428,
0.2741054296,
0.5263627768,
0.2613096833,
-0.4116596282,
0.1959084719,
0.1141845807,
-0.0607959516,
-0.4505571127,
1.0550500154,
-0.8948407769,
-0.107134752,
-0.211623162,
-0.8615810871,
-0.1597279012,
0.0497456416,
0.4079441428,
0.4431038499,
0.0788042545,
0.4398888052,
0.8253163695,
0.1216207221,
0.615396142,
0.6787199378,
-0.3430375159,
-0.019694021,
0.8496150374,
0.3029825091,
0.2080936581,
0.2544624209,
0.1764917225,
-0.0485427193,
-0.573532939,
-0.360272795,
-0.315689683,
-0.6449589729,
-0.2065276206,
-0.4072180688,
-0.5675465465,
-0.055405464,
-0.1459319592,
-0.6830955744,
-0.228401795,
-0.4468222857,
0.1098519936,
-0.0409804806,
0.7594748139,
0.0229042992,
0.354188025,
-0.2156071067,
0.0156425405,
0.0299669802,
0.5069670677,
0.1348578632,
-0.6341198087,
-0.4335223734,
0.259483248,
-0.2024941146,
-0.4447315931,
0.3285169899,
0.4839619994,
0.4029208422,
0.5960299969,
0.2460965067,
1.0008738041,
-0.3812967837,
0.7091064453,
-0.1515532583,
-0.810361743,
0.2742621899,
-0.030617686,
0.4943101406,
0.9115308523,
0.0016824945,
0.0091145718,
-0.8387976289,
-0.7779738903,
-0.8091744184,
0.6081230044,
-0.1722290665,
0.2416904569,
0.3016930521,
0.5299159884,
0.1325220764,
0.1261481792,
-0.7496371269,
-0.3598017395,
0.1641025096,
-0.4492354393,
0.1469307542,
-0.2706978917,
0.0193622429,
-0.4199108779,
0.846991539,
-0.1650869697,
-0.1780503094,
0.0268100407,
-0.1442061067,
-0.8730962276,
-0.187546283,
0.4596261084,
0.7777072787,
-0.5111877322,
0.0919492543,
0.3937108517,
-0.6801580191,
-0.1820047945,
-0.056576509,
-0.7296393514,
-0.0807936713,
0.1080948561,
0.4724158645,
0.6452490687,
-0.7747020721,
0.5536445975,
-0.3312802613,
-0.0672873259,
-0.6060205698,
0.4519286454,
-0.2041659057,
0.3699100614,
0.5907956362,
0.6510697007,
0.3062169254,
-0.2303355485,
0.4442030787,
0.5096498728,
-0.932374239,
-0.3930687308,
1.1016610861,
-0.1304236501,
-0.3340467513,
0.6131625772,
-0.0886942968,
-0.1919511408,
0.5266520977,
0.7820936441,
0.6735587716,
-0.1259602755,
-0.0957893655,
0.3645667732,
0.2011235207,
-0.0407655239,
0.3405196965,
-0.1229699999,
-0.782351315,
-0.5705005527,
-0.7030426264,
-0.6118990183,
0.2844294012,
-0.5503837466,
0.4136219919,
-0.7220577598,
0.0199929774,
-0.0843138546,
0.2558499575,
-0.6941398978,
0.3722720146,
0.202066347,
0.8471976519,
-0.6531096101,
1.2523627281,
0.6989976764,
-0.3955995739,
-1.2737572193,
0.2770668566,
0.2479176819,
-0.468878746,
0.8685290217,
0.1015112028,
-0.3578692079,
0.2746911943,
-1.0848371983,
-0.9763586521,
0.9038829803,
0.8639724255,
-0.6728437543,
0.2747138143,
0.0986956432,
0.5372332335,
-0.6106469631,
0.3108969927,
0.0826997161,
0.3931711018,
-0.0392700955,
-0.6725389361,
-0.1232121438,
0.0027004448,
-0.2773487866,
-0.0522740744,
-0.6310843229,
1.0289144516,
-0.3738372326,
-0.0956252292,
0.2265851796,
0.5769042373,
0.1760011017,
0.499058485,
0.5565353632,
0.2162285447,
0.9584025145,
0.0502102748,
0.8801457882,
-0.8729268312,
0.3328496218,
1.4971237183,
-0.3366288841,
0.8852000237,
0.6409067512,
0.0384591669,
0.3534875214,
0.7759744525,
0.1740478426,
0.6687888503,
0.073347047,
-0.4202276468,
-0.396648705,
-0.1540129334,
-0.0897842869,
0.1850876361,
0.3340304792,
-0.1441252381,
-0.3988859951,
0.0134420646,
-0.1270614862,
0.0860529616,
-0.2154484093,
0.6132078171,
0.1663958281,
-0.4098339081,
0.3301878273,
-0.2192323357,
0.4109910727,
-0.4706777036,
-0.215970397,
-0.0641125962,
0.5291032195,
-0.1457299888,
-0.3844468892,
0.1281535625,
-0.3873579502,
-0.2198456079,
-0.1136488169,
0.8356819153,
-0.6563748121,
-0.314116478,
0.3771699667,
0.2160527557,
0.2677225471,
-0.1536947936,
-0.7917852402,
0.0222963039,
0.0614981353,
-0.1181008816,
0.5190380216,
0.366412729,
0.0487917922,
0.8145985603,
0.8309316039,
0.2370961457,
0.0229874626,
0.3212139308,
0.7316697836,
-0.1255126446,
-0.403911829,
-0.765460968,
0.5091795325,
0.2071762681,
-0.6212628484,
0.6128302217,
0.6837425828,
1.2185759544,
0.1170162857,
0.4856677949,
0.1583031863,
0.4290654063,
-0.3762588799,
1.0312005281,
-0.5796420574,
0.7304528952,
-0.2527809441,
-0.7861152887,
-0.6900396347,
0.7053756118,
-0.1128066853,
0.1638380587,
0.4851697087,
1.1179530621,
-0.3962639272,
0.0699473172,
0.7167385221,
0.4489068091,
0.0410839505,
0.2455870211,
0.7746506929,
-0.5815054178,
0.4356351793,
-0.7498846054,
0.0121599287,
-0.3399583399,
-0.8590738177,
-0.6821346879,
-0.5235770941,
-0.5254514217,
-0.425774157,
0.4056254327,
1.1298080683,
1.0736296177,
-1.1215771437,
-0.4686712027,
-0.0669431612,
0.0204785522,
-0.4895116389,
-0.2238982916,
0.1769904494,
-0.6961429119,
-0.9177643657,
0.4999558926,
0.164809525,
-0.0991773456,
-0.151897952,
-0.4884503484,
-0.0164742433,
0.0467867404,
0.1774963439,
0.2410142571,
-0.5907205939,
-0.2535220981,
-0.4694908559,
-0.3475371599,
0.1433260143,
0.5806553364,
-0.7943157554,
0.4628918767,
0.0926546901,
0.2605693638,
0.5815909505,
-0.0740076527,
0.4929810762,
-0.748961091,
0.4773412943,
0.3519935012,
0.217786938,
0.1390987486,
-0.6065567136,
0.435726732,
-0.2192281336,
-0.7271414399,
-0.9443829656,
-0.0225006174,
-0.567709446,
-0.3661608398,
0.9494261146,
0.1222962588,
-0.2698481083,
-0.2320363224,
-0.2844088674,
0.1346581727,
-0.6454743147,
0.9003485441,
0.6221759319,
-0.0437819697,
-0.0257812832,
-0.8977105618,
0.9164454341,
0.4395146668,
-0.1018520594,
-0.1140133366,
0.3413716853,
0.4217923284,
-0.1003590599,
0.3314432502,
-0.1278202981,
0.3052633405,
-0.0568733513,
-0.1586333215,
0.1667550057,
-0.4400783479,
-0.2389963865,
0.1772440672,
0.6365361214,
0.1654562354
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05512v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05512v1
|
GPTs Are Multilingual Annotators for Sequence Generation Tasks
| 2024-02-08T09:44:02 | 2024-02-08T09:44:02 |
Juhwan Choi, Eunju Lee, Kyohoon Jin, YoungBin Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Data annotation is an essential step for constructing new datasets. However,
the conventional approach of data annotation through crowdsourcing is both
time-consuming and expensive. In addition, the complexity of this process
increases when dealing with low-resource languages owing to the difference in
the language pool of crowdworkers. To address these issues, this study proposes
an autonomous annotation method by utilizing large language models, which have
been recently demonstrated to exhibit remarkable performance. Through our
experiments, we demonstrate that the proposed method is not just cost-efficient
but also applicable for low-resource language annotation. Additionally, we
constructed an image captioning dataset using our approach and are committed to
open this dataset for future study. We have opened our source code for further
study and reproducibility.
|
[
-0.3797615767,
-0.4230703712,
0.4619828463,
0.1586550027,
-0.6090514064,
0.098082386,
-0.3640777469,
-0.4677563608,
0.0582398064,
0.5044995546,
-0.5175653696,
-0.2842566073,
-0.6142708659,
0.3975492418,
-0.3081756234,
0.9726102948,
-0.1733154804,
-0.1929475516,
0.2529506683,
-0.2562687993,
-0.2081988454,
-0.4705146253,
-0.6956045032,
0.1209672764,
0.4017302692,
0.2912986279,
0.9107404947,
1.0782854557,
0.384036988,
0.4023730755,
0.380182296,
0.3865775764,
-0.0539491437,
0.0930178761,
-0.0258940235,
0.0534809157,
-0.0558729954,
0.1333567947,
0.7428908944,
0.4400680363,
0.166952014,
0.291608423,
-0.2005235404,
0.5967634916,
-0.2245193422,
0.6114270091,
-0.7613744736,
0.0333075821,
-0.4159009755,
-0.0612226017,
-0.3330367506,
-0.5426025987,
0.001683276,
-0.728261292,
0.4148469269,
-0.1356189847,
0.6880285144,
0.3347356319,
0.0090848068,
-0.225453496,
-0.5665141344,
0.5344979763,
-0.6704461575,
0.0557629801,
0.2960056067,
0.435095042,
0.1159740165,
-0.6034058332,
-0.8683611751,
-0.3191726506,
-0.4594479501,
-0.2392843217,
0.3570074141,
-0.2391267866,
0.4260217249,
0.4336799979,
-0.6289604306,
0.0671501905,
-0.3557092249,
-0.1929037422,
0.9773349762,
0.043419078,
0.371199131,
-0.4961403608,
-0.2066971958,
-0.0442288741,
-0.6543735266,
-0.3557189703,
0.4125060141,
0.8435490131,
-0.2903700173,
0.7641633749,
-0.3281291723,
0.7136127353,
-0.1337972432,
0.0261191744,
0.3312118351,
-0.2005953491,
-0.2730374634,
-0.2483496964,
1.2151095867,
-0.0569125526,
0.6817987561,
-0.3508060873,
-0.1902184486,
-0.268814683,
-0.1979199797,
-0.8113379478,
-0.5470176339,
0.1053072661,
-0.140490815,
-0.196183607,
0.2306190133,
-0.8095741868,
-0.5632597208,
-0.4063284099,
0.2191472352,
-0.3080351055,
-0.2778391242,
-0.3120958805,
0.2548880279,
0.0649253279,
0.4351226985,
-0.8987461925,
-0.0699604079,
0.386007309,
1.3014423847,
0.1209222749,
-0.4220999479,
-0.7596830726,
0.2155288756,
-0.2105766833,
0.7066420317,
-0.543697834,
-0.429959029,
-0.0718683898,
0.2672283053,
-0.0447893664,
-0.1384371966,
0.0471440218,
-0.5882774591,
0.1649894714,
-0.229649052,
-0.4570703208,
-0.1424482167,
-0.2197463363,
-1.0584805012,
0.8909806013,
0.0972307548,
-0.6696149111,
0.4938819706,
-1.0057851076,
-0.5493907332,
0.815715909,
-0.5497626066,
-0.434425652,
-0.1993420273,
0.6433615685,
0.8408074379,
-0.1006285623,
0.4023115933,
0.0560677871,
-0.1591038406,
0.2289481014,
-0.3036330938,
0.4824087322,
0.2388858944,
-0.6530542374,
0.1168156639,
-0.4693762362,
0.0664636046,
0.3385003507,
-0.3189868629,
-0.0258816928,
0.0256722327,
0.2636248767,
0.3312707841,
-0.0485909395,
-0.4310758114,
0.7005214095,
-0.1115356982,
0.6666266322,
0.818600297,
0.062421076,
0.2932520509,
0.0305566788,
0.4942988753,
-0.2168815434,
-0.0206036642,
-0.4855234623,
-0.7345908284,
-0.3088588417,
-0.6565688252,
0.3989765346,
0.5433089733,
-1.2509263754,
0.2987566888,
-0.436769098,
-0.4950287938,
-0.7173213959,
0.3173817098,
0.4453152716,
0.308681339,
0.3343058527,
-0.3693144917,
-0.4486784935,
-0.8487579823,
0.189956978,
-0.1387408376,
0.0223145485,
0.1895999014,
0.4968426228,
0.045537211,
0.924805522,
-0.3827877939,
-0.1710959673,
-0.07452631,
0.4821193218,
0.0506738387,
0.6728159785,
0.4567377865,
-0.7605105042,
-0.5307574272,
0.1914380342,
-0.6750618815,
-0.0348799787,
-0.3351044953,
-0.0874258503,
0.5517423153,
0.4264683723,
-0.5861356258,
0.3099420071,
0.6570588946,
-0.100961782,
0.4038722813,
-0.0665321648,
0.3774020076,
-0.9714729786,
0.2580713034,
0.1597765982,
-0.371620357,
-0.3102579415,
-0.0733833984,
-0.0413557477,
-0.3473806977,
-0.4125058651,
0.6278063655,
-0.7997738123,
-0.136226967,
-0.236479044,
0.162923187,
-0.3103192449,
0.3833977282,
0.4838111699,
1.0779511929,
0.5782452822,
-0.216116637,
0.6202979088,
0.2693833113,
-0.474581182,
0.1312488616,
-0.569549799,
0.3489130437,
-0.0587712079,
0.2013632357,
-1.1160931587,
-0.6117045283,
0.3529882133,
-0.3527873456,
0.1524084806,
-0.5839090943,
-0.9788340926,
-0.649503231,
0.0613576025,
0.3882810175,
0.4312583208,
-0.7334920168,
0.1373552978,
0.3506010473,
-0.5241532326,
-0.2697586119,
-0.8406427503,
0.2286355495,
-0.2292110324,
-0.5031481981,
-0.2048920095,
0.2273316383,
-0.0069054333,
-0.2243086696,
0.5844019651,
-0.1014327481,
-0.2386006117,
0.341290921,
0.2531813085,
-0.1166479439,
0.4550389349,
-0.2646504641,
-0.3146728277,
-0.3800968528,
-0.5009607077,
0.4803116024,
-0.1945863813,
-0.5077453852,
-0.5276283026,
0.6505502462,
0.3970167339,
-0.6916312575,
0.547278583,
0.6789419055,
-0.4293340147,
-0.0188696478,
-0.7503307462,
0.0416111648,
-0.5031260252,
0.4332720637,
-0.2886765897,
-1.0173430443,
0.5454121232,
0.2066002339,
-0.0391494147,
0.4578994811,
0.7236070037,
0.3814549446,
0.7613681555,
0.3111016452,
-0.4918174148,
0.309733808,
-0.0396020412,
0.1531088352,
-0.3483211696,
0.2761527598,
-0.3707696795,
-0.1001678035,
-0.7994054556,
-0.8160511851,
0.2138952762,
-0.1003222466,
-0.2867065668,
0.3535322249,
-0.8795833588,
0.598600328,
0.7114115953,
-0.108358413,
0.3798092306,
0.1453682482,
0.2821726203,
-0.0338174067,
-0.4662593305,
-0.8288099766,
1.086443305,
0.0929622948,
0.5138401389,
0.0995227545,
0.6648245454,
0.3001177311,
0.6993426085,
-0.437838465,
0.5866312981,
-0.1314569265,
-0.5448578,
-0.8382385969,
-0.3976156414,
-0.8072756529,
0.0692911521,
-0.0484337024,
-0.8801804185,
-0.1335857213,
0.2134049386,
-0.5295990109,
0.5051542521,
-0.928945303,
0.8399096727,
-0.2038024217,
-0.3806441426,
0.359428823,
-0.7000595927,
0.2206924558,
-0.2142113596,
0.3381952941,
-0.1467842609,
0.1169614643,
0.6864215732,
-0.5833734274,
0.8983379602,
-0.6395727992,
-0.0947555825,
0.7560229897,
-0.0227503795,
0.8666856289,
0.2520858049,
0.0500783063,
0.0418380015,
-0.4775547385,
-0.3556323946,
-0.1986708045,
0.6946982145,
-0.4727551937,
-0.4374517798,
-0.212399587,
-0.7226430774,
-0.0461162664,
0.1324599534,
-0.0255627558,
0.3056866825,
0.283947736,
-0.3625426888,
0.111638777,
-0.1934655905,
0.9829618931,
0.3195905685,
-0.1154722422,
-0.6482518911,
0.8244736195,
0.2665472329,
0.1321779341,
0.0547943227,
0.0236807484,
-0.3309777677,
-0.5649747849,
-1.1842119694,
0.2575573027,
-0.4474671781,
-0.3171141744,
-0.5011171103,
0.1351935863,
-0.4843173325,
-0.2338405252,
-0.3449924588,
-0.4627788067,
0.1485448033,
-0.3247583807,
0.9278475642,
0.8304419518,
-0.1393301785,
0.3614885509,
-0.8904936314,
0.263981998,
0.5826845169,
0.4739036262,
0.0484059751,
-0.0301183891,
-0.3282762766,
-0.0958518982,
0.019516781,
-0.9036553502,
0.4800342619,
0.1319270879,
0.3582201898,
0.2005980313,
-0.1920018047,
0.8005747795,
-0.620077908,
0.9417591691,
-0.0018255408,
-1.1552764177,
0.5943621397,
-0.7347590923,
0.2037879825,
0.5004581213,
0.2185509801,
-0.4629192948,
-0.4236907959,
-0.4918344319,
-1.0370295048,
0.5851528049,
0.2734422982,
0.1631085575,
-0.3007034063,
0.4758173525,
0.3689776957,
0.2832955122,
-0.9162385464,
-0.0488841869,
-0.1614207476,
-0.1158416271,
-0.2962229848,
0.0276597645,
-0.0268081073,
-0.1779419929,
0.6841232777,
-0.5078456402,
0.2135433853,
0.30944857,
-0.0468799621,
-0.3356974125,
0.1074577048,
0.483862102,
0.4370380342,
0.1724935025,
-0.1407653689,
-0.0611814968,
-0.4657176435,
0.1590021402,
0.6662399769,
-0.2018537819,
0.2018850595,
0.3668008149,
0.7335718274,
-0.3093701005,
-0.6313134432,
0.5558614731,
0.3552472889,
0.0356861278,
-0.2973779142,
-0.4603328705,
0.1499611586,
0.3475674391,
0.6090952754,
-0.3706378341,
-0.0876573771,
-0.1904072464,
0.3375263512,
0.3714832664,
-0.0441921651,
-0.1673736721,
0.6818271279,
0.3434747159,
-0.0600243621,
0.7499345541,
-0.5820786953,
-0.3575614691,
0.5243450403,
0.1209036335,
0.9721885324,
-0.3645540476,
0.3515790999,
0.4264875054,
0.4695788622,
-0.2525577843,
0.1741956919,
-0.0199926682,
-0.3178643286,
-1.0201935768,
-0.4611078799,
-0.2611433864,
0.1391249001,
-0.4489561021,
0.1105179042,
-0.1894809306,
0.0747863725,
0.0207876079,
-0.1138931811,
-0.895629108,
0.4535000324,
0.469466418,
0.4846904278,
-1.0737999678,
0.9496777654,
0.788069725,
-0.6456114054,
-0.9532135129,
-0.1765236855,
-0.1137240678,
-0.9136014581,
0.7182952166,
0.2695198357,
0.1699154824,
-0.0526594073,
-0.5947176814,
-0.8527336121,
1.1482995749,
0.2595425546,
-0.7657099962,
0.0141371544,
0.418425262,
0.4962943792,
-0.4319446087,
0.094690226,
0.2509029806,
0.748290658,
0.0489105359,
-1.1859101057,
0.3176719844,
-0.343462199,
0.0197904948,
0.2706634402,
-0.5959391594,
0.8846387267,
-0.4059790373,
-0.3043586016,
0.2459134758,
0.7007220387,
0.1693483889,
-0.0188058335,
0.4800174832,
0.3524332345,
0.7550857067,
-0.250505656,
1.0734392405,
-0.1706620157,
0.531455636,
1.2634395361,
-0.2860171497,
0.674603641,
0.5298020244,
-0.3676435649,
0.243548736,
0.5135375857,
-0.3585859239,
0.4803810716,
0.6750998497,
-0.2812642455,
-0.2385768145,
0.1698916405,
-0.2514402568,
0.2445746958,
0.1378368288,
-0.6592743397,
-0.1923386008,
0.1444475055,
0.1773848832,
0.1188372374,
-0.4126132429,
0.7599922419,
-0.2424090654,
-0.5836414099,
0.3676612079,
-0.1361542642,
0.614952147,
-0.3819403946,
-0.0111756315,
-0.043355979,
-0.1233647391,
-0.1692684591,
-0.7679152489,
0.3099585772,
0.3035346568,
0.0033297196,
-0.0505694039,
0.3593988717,
-0.4860943556,
-0.7566767931,
-0.0946668461,
0.7225256562,
0.2087127864,
-0.2922008038,
-0.4802258015,
-0.1486525685,
-0.015679175,
-0.3679223359,
-0.0505634956,
0.6572470665,
-0.3352743983,
0.5128705502,
0.59561342,
0.1311861277,
0.2458733767,
0.1791178733,
0.7777037024,
-0.6544237137,
-0.51227808,
-0.9812874794,
0.8209529519,
-0.1206220314,
-0.2168465257,
0.6422905922,
0.573675096,
0.9265618324,
-0.4561259747,
1.4837117195,
-0.3497689962,
0.4873109758,
-0.4849346876,
0.759537816,
-0.0400962047,
-0.0933569148,
-0.5502765775,
-0.6514958143,
-0.5063359141,
0.568010509,
-0.5540409088,
0.2052502334,
0.3514880538,
0.7406634688,
0.1873545796,
0.112037167,
-0.0109561142,
-0.0052648326,
0.4396361113,
0.5653418303,
0.5806180239,
-0.2822521925,
0.3902699053,
-0.4890803695,
-0.160902828,
0.2910924256,
-1.0945994854,
-0.9462422729,
-0.8088686466,
-0.6779652238,
-0.0892946646,
0.1269186288,
1.0447993279,
0.8861417174,
-0.9064099789,
-0.0488479212,
-0.1159734577,
-0.3739194572,
-0.0576846153,
-0.2237266004,
0.7248774767,
-0.2706574798,
-0.9097688198,
0.0919819847,
0.1295099854,
0.3292875886,
-0.41856426,
0.1083707511,
-0.1904405653,
-0.2870049477,
0.3916551471,
0.4034746587,
-0.686701417,
-0.615028441,
-0.5111196041,
-0.054147251,
0.0141758993,
0.7797557116,
-0.7396163344,
0.4654729962,
0.140223816,
0.5607679486,
0.3483250141,
0.2977845967,
0.4681074321,
-1.0210183859,
0.4603956938,
0.1214180812,
0.3478420675,
0.8155418038,
-0.4118346274,
0.7107869387,
0.1905597299,
-0.6341543794,
-0.6790451407,
0.1385463327,
-0.8663791418,
0.2275194973,
1.1865596771,
-0.3580558598,
-0.0130305355,
0.015817361,
-0.3243571222,
0.2868411541,
-0.5184772015,
0.8500480652,
0.5913537145,
0.0722269267,
-0.271181047,
-0.6065356731,
0.570650816,
-0.084395051,
-0.9165150523,
0.3482477069,
0.6097593307,
0.0825455785,
0.3175332546,
0.7232201695,
-0.2740598917,
0.0439504869,
-0.2307339609,
0.4776265323,
-0.3225881159,
0.1097802147,
-0.1672649086,
0.2333306521,
0.1133798808,
-0.4157569706
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05467v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05467v1
|
Rapid Optimization for Jailbreaking LLMs via Subconscious Exploitation and Echopraxia
| 2024-02-08T07:56:49 | 2024-02-08T07:56:49 |
Guangyu Shen, Siyuan Cheng, Kaiyuan Zhang, Guanhong Tao, Shengwei An, Lu Yan, Zhuo Zhang, Shiqing Ma, Xiangyu Zhang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have become prevalent across diverse sectors,
transforming human life with their extraordinary reasoning and comprehension
abilities. As they find increased use in sensitive tasks, safety concerns have
gained widespread attention. Extensive efforts have been dedicated to aligning
LLMs with human moral principles to ensure their safe deployment. Despite their
potential, recent research indicates aligned LLMs are prone to specialized
jailbreaking prompts that bypass safety measures to elicit violent and harmful
content. The intrinsic discrete nature and substantial scale of contemporary
LLMs pose significant challenges in automatically generating diverse,
efficient, and potent jailbreaking prompts, representing a continuous obstacle.
In this paper, we introduce RIPPLE (Rapid Optimization via Subconscious
Exploitation and Echopraxia), a novel optimization-based method inspired by two
psychological concepts: subconsciousness and echopraxia, which describe the
processes of the mind that occur without conscious awareness and the
involuntary mimicry of actions, respectively. Evaluations across 6 open-source
LLMs and 4 commercial LLM APIs show RIPPLE achieves an average Attack Success
Rate of 91.5\%, outperforming five current methods by up to 47.0\% with an 8x
reduction in overhead. Furthermore, it displays significant transferability and
stealth, successfully evading established detection mechanisms. The code of our
work is available at
\url{https://github.com/SolidShen/RIPPLE_official/tree/official}
|
[
-0.6693759561,
-1.0429791212,
0.6580960155,
0.5096039176,
-0.3618107736,
0.2553201616,
-0.2724882662,
-0.4445059299,
0.1186630055,
0.6636599302,
-0.7927897573,
-0.3415363133,
-0.6290287375,
0.0364189707,
-0.2795199752,
0.6977446079,
-0.0988164544,
-0.166942209,
0.2980596125,
-0.0602200776,
-0.6128925681,
-0.481726706,
-0.4167212546,
-0.052914571,
0.3281744421,
0.4136859775,
0.4439193904,
0.5862611532,
0.5141496062,
0.2716009915,
-0.0108396979,
0.274333328,
-0.7969748378,
0.1508286744,
-0.0605073348,
-0.2006565183,
0.0774969235,
-0.1418482959,
0.4400744736,
0.4326191843,
-0.2608793676,
-0.0172401797,
0.1587208211,
0.6746243834,
-0.8597677946,
-0.1914856136,
-0.7935222983,
0.2020950317,
-0.1230091825,
-0.1082831994,
-0.327911377,
-0.4957789481,
-0.2614715397,
-0.4459660947,
-0.1925355196,
0.3333672881,
0.5574886203,
0.2624101937,
-0.0607897639,
-0.4107930958,
-0.5962599516,
0.8399381638,
-0.3397683501,
0.3995629251,
0.2065867335,
0.0757492781,
-0.3834770024,
-0.4728290439,
-0.5475013852,
-0.4150286019,
0.2486465126,
-0.165337041,
-0.4249880016,
0.2728368044,
0.2860781848,
0.1324801743,
-0.3279823363,
0.3439200521,
-0.0047703316,
-0.315285176,
0.4281814396,
0.4084944129,
0.2702921331,
-0.1005184129,
-0.5504178405,
-0.1900944412,
-0.4298765659,
0.2521045506,
0.4326682389,
0.4454521835,
-0.3003978133,
0.6324954629,
0.1216363385,
0.5947054625,
0.1720573902,
-0.2501598895,
0.0995816961,
0.0329337418,
0.0602973104,
0.0159193985,
0.9076129198,
0.38362661,
0.1677249223,
-0.1279441565,
-0.6091824174,
0.0095290802,
0.4703706503,
-0.6759919524,
0.4901606143,
0.5403036475,
-0.5433446169,
-0.5582678318,
-0.1139544919,
-0.8210791349,
-0.7983542085,
-0.1161869764,
0.2796861827,
-0.6166293025,
-0.134288013,
0.1815438718,
-0.0972492248,
0.329875946,
-0.0776181743,
-0.9237862825,
0.33654055,
1.0357717276,
1.0578180552,
-0.0578420721,
-0.2225475609,
-0.5239276886,
-0.110808149,
-0.3822987974,
0.6268174648,
-0.3473761678,
-0.9314697385,
-0.0096442597,
-0.4869104922,
0.0637661368,
-0.4922551811,
0.73223418,
-0.4169796705,
-0.4146784842,
-0.0836574882,
-0.4622205496,
0.1059663743,
0.3508531749,
-0.4816038609,
0.5886369348,
0.0643423051,
-0.6024442315,
0.0628324747,
-0.5192738771,
-0.450209558,
-0.114470385,
-0.0082605649,
-0.411837697,
0.3226605058,
0.2174492329,
0.1321369857,
-0.2876228094,
0.2854361534,
-0.4654667675,
-0.4899211824,
0.4670362771,
-0.2932182848,
0.736997962,
0.5909113884,
-0.4614414275,
0.0392363705,
-0.5277833343,
-0.0490856357,
0.0776196346,
-0.115007095,
-0.4012593627,
0.00349755,
0.0376356989,
-0.0274148025,
0.3363012671,
-0.6369059682,
0.2673018873,
-0.3739275932,
0.2544538379,
1.1829400063,
0.2793370187,
0.3177941442,
-0.1650380343,
0.5186097622,
-0.393353194,
0.6726487279,
-0.0272809416,
-0.1790438741,
-0.4391785264,
-0.6351376176,
-0.2880199254,
0.8146777153,
-0.2460971177,
0.6844046116,
0.1409611553,
-0.5291168094,
-0.3669190407,
0.4223528206,
0.6217470169,
0.6451174617,
0.2168640196,
-0.3050223589,
-0.9005204439,
-0.8949166536,
-0.7122616172,
-0.0781108886,
-0.0131800836,
0.4237567782,
0.1208519787,
-0.6626452208,
0.9148789644,
-0.5353807807,
-0.4135440886,
-0.3967091143,
0.05579485,
0.5871553421,
0.4990579188,
0.2765472531,
-0.4701503813,
-0.2175452411,
-0.2035316974,
-0.9134269953,
-0.3207467198,
-0.4767904878,
-0.265535295,
-0.0834754333,
0.5299188495,
-0.7873815894,
0.1340952963,
0.290532589,
-0.1848116666,
0.8285266161,
-0.0371241085,
-0.2062266469,
-0.7869102359,
-0.0078484342,
0.0876965746,
0.0909666419,
-0.5929965377,
0.3288445175,
0.1401760727,
-0.3160666525,
-0.5373056531,
0.6585657597,
-0.5078049898,
0.1791345924,
-0.3464592099,
0.1469021291,
-0.5160226822,
0.5406134129,
-0.2261153907,
0.6343034506,
0.6075922251,
-0.3492843509,
0.124228932,
0.1741379648,
-0.3543485999,
0.2668500841,
-0.5187109709,
0.295663029,
0.0034181934,
0.1275445372,
-0.4744248986,
-0.051993493,
0.2940663099,
-0.2394713163,
0.0652737841,
-0.0177864637,
-0.3247376084,
-0.4612375498,
-0.6654024124,
0.2424912155,
0.8486078978,
-0.5774230957,
0.7489473224,
0.5241754055,
-0.0067028329,
-0.8597869873,
-0.3731517196,
0.3546628654,
-0.3461498618,
-0.4450493753,
0.0600415133,
0.0016183463,
-0.7087831497,
-0.4253719449,
-0.2532271743,
0.2711277008,
0.1501012892,
0.4870621264,
0.4850282371,
0.2582135201,
-0.3544330001,
0.0446339212,
-0.2156648338,
0.1598085612,
-0.3745507896,
0.6456065774,
-0.3399812877,
-0.2507164478,
-0.4948362708,
0.3696954548,
0.5271107554,
-0.0145012829,
0.5952289104,
0.4394459724,
-0.1272441894,
-0.4341275692,
-0.8152377009,
-0.3301106393,
-0.6283311844,
0.2607572377,
-0.3848569095,
-1.0184099674,
0.5623327494,
-0.2247806191,
0.0460444279,
-0.3806075156,
0.64262712,
-0.0318998359,
1.0058835745,
0.7493780851,
-0.4648845792,
0.6779671907,
-0.1912349164,
0.5610775948,
-0.8699041605,
-0.1842704564,
-0.4242162406,
-0.1966400445,
-0.5718249679,
-0.5301216245,
0.4782025814,
0.2709699571,
-0.4342255592,
0.1803025752,
-0.5140333772,
0.5131621957,
0.3610982597,
0.1092339754,
0.0859808475,
0.0005714099,
-0.3621213734,
0.1500299126,
-0.2686965764,
-0.4302386642,
1.1443139315,
0.3982847333,
1.1274101734,
-0.0721802637,
1.0275082588,
0.3958770037,
0.4415796101,
-0.7782749534,
0.7607275844,
0.0397636406,
-0.2954538763,
-0.156084612,
-0.3160476089,
-1.0695188046,
0.3475399017,
-0.2283839136,
-1.0951843262,
0.1898410022,
0.1430334151,
-0.2483654469,
0.3684502244,
-0.6709819436,
0.366464138,
-0.4986775219,
-0.5487327576,
-0.3138153553,
-0.6727441549,
0.7018891573,
-0.3700980842,
0.6873157024,
-0.2664352357,
-0.3084886968,
0.4556373656,
-0.7619906664,
0.9510801435,
-0.4665039182,
-0.1142904311,
0.4393850565,
0.2927601039,
0.818629384,
0.2181660384,
0.0749171078,
0.2551943064,
-0.6719363332,
-0.3262426555,
-0.5061709285,
0.688523829,
-0.8875054717,
-0.792278707,
-0.1348753273,
-0.5344777107,
-0.4421848357,
0.4251683652,
0.268735975,
0.0874451324,
-0.1691608429,
-0.2647351921,
0.7237573266,
-0.23855488,
0.5299006104,
0.5147371292,
-0.2645197511,
-0.545161128,
0.8853949308,
-0.3815520406,
-0.0994860604,
0.1862079203,
0.32202214,
-0.3774717152,
-0.7648228407,
0.0386996157,
0.3408640921,
-0.4969973862,
-0.1528767049,
-0.6365109682,
-0.0326592848,
-0.3220785558,
-0.6052539945,
-0.4999895692,
-0.1843114048,
0.0120853083,
-0.2250775546,
0.1644266248,
0.2805954814,
-0.5342940688,
0.0544707775,
-0.9122325182,
0.735004425,
0.2622615993,
0.4350760877,
0.0274584107,
-0.2616491616,
-0.1201337427,
-0.1573586762,
-0.3290177584,
-0.7345257998,
0.4466242194,
-0.0712028146,
0.6456782818,
0.6945804358,
0.268113941,
0.8094285727,
-0.3732699454,
0.4725711048,
0.5350011587,
-1.1558215618,
0.7176007628,
-0.3956929147,
-0.0601796359,
0.6718658209,
0.1622376144,
-0.6888543367,
-0.7575015426,
-0.3068957627,
-1.1284798384,
0.2926471829,
0.1570799202,
0.3990067542,
-0.1568754613,
0.3549337983,
0.1511543989,
0.0621528737,
-0.6341768503,
-0.0937770084,
-0.0471391007,
-0.0298715122,
0.0596068464,
-0.2045640796,
-0.4049578905,
-0.0154123995,
0.4534188807,
0.0042257225,
0.2738999128,
0.1296789646,
-0.2735969424,
-0.0408862755,
0.0652009547,
0.58526057,
0.2359470725,
-0.2227225602,
-0.0666312948,
0.1139399111,
-0.8114094734,
0.4382002056,
-0.1119956002,
-0.0925729796,
-0.3090205491,
0.4827487767,
0.748650074,
0.1167798638,
-1.2519652843,
0.4075326324,
-0.0970919058,
-0.0378565826,
-0.5186753273,
0.2028559595,
-0.4026347697,
0.3356108665,
0.5740278959,
0.2103921473,
0.0565880276,
-0.3274255991,
0.1288211495,
0.5695829988,
-0.2725383341,
0.0057945503,
0.6372359395,
0.2558731735,
-0.5882602334,
0.8492760062,
-0.0062009576,
-0.3687136471,
0.4598829448,
0.5388790369,
1.336982131,
-0.0011027601,
-0.1730323881,
0.2961937785,
0.4744120836,
-0.1358696371,
0.2351872623,
-0.25745821,
-1.0588965416,
-0.1897058189,
-0.6229878664,
-0.5231433511,
-0.0947959349,
-0.7272268534,
0.3456088305,
-0.8339779377,
-0.2959581614,
-0.5901728272,
-0.2472465932,
-0.2691677213,
-0.1355221868,
0.4027643502,
1.2022601366,
-0.4581065476,
0.6638664603,
0.1590666473,
0.0034497471,
-0.8833436966,
-0.0592118539,
0.2646002173,
-1.2375022173,
0.2757982612,
0.2676805258,
-0.3605390787,
-0.1491194069,
-0.627607882,
-0.7319779992,
0.7151466012,
0.3846275508,
-0.9553599954,
0.0881119296,
0.0633296743,
0.3117009401,
-0.2212917656,
-0.06354931,
0.9210998416,
0.6831662059,
-0.2010032386,
-0.602525413,
0.1569620073,
-0.3833627403,
0.0877929479,
0.2292758673,
-0.7189105153,
0.5173799992,
-0.7252988815,
-0.055142805,
0.1646687835,
0.2857401073,
0.9061337113,
0.1742830426,
0.7006422281,
0.8059353828,
0.6994454265,
0.1074711755,
1.3471933603,
-0.6526601911,
0.2926875353,
0.8047207594,
-0.3868430555,
0.6430328488,
0.9279849529,
0.0371510908,
0.4417370558,
0.5807629228,
-0.0534006096,
0.6568868756,
0.3837544918,
-0.395052433,
-0.1133877933,
0.0489824675,
-0.1737218946,
0.3657695055,
0.4002900124,
-0.1880527884,
0.0944644734,
0.4627617002,
0.3777998388,
-0.0302789081,
-0.3937461674,
0.7439881563,
0.2484260499,
-0.6218737364,
0.9331535697,
-0.0028604751,
0.8376136422,
-0.7444455624,
0.3930997252,
-0.5788999796,
0.2488819808,
-0.0611606762,
-0.5274467468,
0.1066474766,
0.3982483745,
0.3061209023,
-0.5774503946,
0.7500206828,
0.2777760029,
-0.44476372,
0.5670459867,
0.2274353802,
-0.0927887708,
0.0228119884,
-0.7293871641,
0.6273638606,
0.0489220694,
-0.5473191738,
0.3865228295,
0.0648752078,
0.0283589121,
1.0759145021,
0.8545336723,
0.2231344581,
-0.0244867839,
0.0439335629,
1.1093417406,
-0.8986360431,
-0.7144762874,
-1.0833741426,
0.364291966,
-0.0766230151,
-0.2356443852,
0.8236256242,
0.6109337211,
0.4440507293,
-0.0130867129,
0.8823801875,
0.0174531359,
0.1939808726,
-0.5067208409,
0.4898446798,
-0.1880788058,
0.6798135638,
-0.4157437086,
-0.9765554667,
-0.2737288475,
0.5345904231,
-0.2414530665,
-0.3230641782,
0.5081650019,
1.0276527405,
0.3740811348,
-0.0847323388,
0.1544190496,
0.3657231927,
0.3715326488,
0.6610758901,
1.019397974,
0.1454837024,
0.4916325212,
-0.4192850292,
-0.5428980589,
-0.2944692075,
-0.7168678641,
-0.6195027232,
-0.1635462344,
0.0702064186,
-0.4499858916,
0.13077344,
1.066237092,
0.6436561942,
-0.5405504704,
-0.5930591226,
-0.3802843392,
0.3021330535,
-0.3343679607,
-0.2355159074,
-0.0117208231,
-0.62371701,
-0.4717889428,
0.6260052919,
0.5166835189,
0.0405710265,
-0.1964700669,
-0.2415193915,
0.3407823741,
0.5030865669,
0.4938197434,
0.5490354896,
-0.6556718349,
-0.1907181442,
-0.0759483203,
-0.1156617403,
-0.1074163765,
1.2459540367,
-0.7156921029,
0.4362999499,
0.1518035978,
0.4923609793,
0.4879209101,
0.0789504945,
0.4491310716,
-0.6003026962,
0.6013249159,
0.5460923314,
0.3571513593,
-0.0366049334,
-0.4920465648,
0.267609328,
0.0958224237,
-0.2936496735,
-1.1755737066,
0.2804104984,
-1.0709835291,
-0.5265371799,
0.9143567085,
0.069651328,
-0.401828438,
-0.0738504604,
-0.3267146349,
-0.0516472608,
-0.4987710714,
1.1760715246,
0.2419202775,
-0.4734249115,
-0.1324670464,
-0.0588252284,
0.2683728337,
0.2423024029,
-0.4932039678,
0.1614468992,
0.298328191,
0.1243746802,
0.0389549807,
0.7083208561,
-0.1777895242,
0.2182380408,
0.2862311006,
0.2165160477,
-0.1951065809,
0.0981980562,
-0.4236476719,
0.4363471866,
0.111973092,
-0.0760712251
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05457v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05457v1
|
It's Never Too Late: Fusing Acoustic Information into Large Language Models for Automatic Speech Recognition
| 2024-02-08T07:21:45 | 2024-02-08T07:21:45 |
Chen Chen, Ruizhe Li, Yuchen Hu, Sabato Marco Siniscalchi, Pin-Yu Chen, Ensiong Chng, Chao-Han Huck Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.MM, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Recent studies have successfully shown that large language models (LLMs) can
be successfully used for generative error correction (GER) on top of the
automatic speech recognition (ASR) output. Specifically, an LLM is utilized to
carry out a direct mapping from the N-best hypotheses list generated by an ASR
system to the predicted output transcription. However, despite its
effectiveness, GER introduces extra data uncertainty since the LLM is trained
without taking into account acoustic information available in the speech
signal. In this work, we aim to overcome such a limitation by infusing acoustic
information before generating the predicted transcription through a novel late
fusion solution termed Uncertainty-Aware Dynamic Fusion (UADF). UADF is a
multimodal fusion approach implemented into an auto-regressive decoding process
and works in two stages: (i) It first analyzes and calibrates the token-level
LLM decision, and (ii) it then dynamically assimilates the information from the
acoustic modality. Experimental evidence collected from various ASR tasks shows
that UADF surpasses existing fusion mechanisms in several ways. It yields
significant improvements in word error rate (WER) while mitigating data
uncertainty issues in LLM and addressing the poor generalization relied with
sole modality during fusion. We also demonstrate that UADF seamlessly adapts to
audio-visual speech recognition.
|
[
-0.2814658284,
-0.7712567449,
0.4455809295,
0.12938039,
-0.1848839223,
0.3291869462,
-0.1449307203,
-0.5380023122,
-0.1914672405,
0.2370209992,
-0.3704859018,
-0.2633790076,
-0.3917173743,
-0.0244365111,
-0.492395103,
0.5252346396,
-0.0342444815,
0.0945168585,
-0.1959271878,
-0.0644343868,
-0.1960253716,
-0.3265203536,
-0.6964641809,
-0.4826047719,
0.3864814639,
0.1666252464,
0.6425272226,
0.8732804656,
0.3873177767,
0.3748659194,
-0.0503376424,
0.1491106749,
-0.2760835886,
0.0803040117,
0.1657812446,
-0.406000942,
-0.5688322783,
-0.2588128448,
1.0680553913,
0.8744368553,
-0.4283970296,
-0.1391447186,
0.0665720478,
0.3537767231,
-0.5399622917,
0.1935282499,
-0.6098509431,
0.1258926392,
-0.3765069544,
-0.2427740544,
-0.2452282459,
-0.1840737909,
-0.0244482979,
-0.4928303659,
0.1215653569,
-0.1280210167,
0.5519522429,
0.7021692991,
-0.3801019192,
-0.1035054103,
-1.330518961,
0.8710385561,
-0.7556995153,
0.7888336182,
0.3775389791,
0.4961530864,
-0.5089847445,
-0.4743868113,
-0.9362170696,
0.1851616204,
0.263097167,
0.116469495,
-0.4309726655,
0.2703936398,
0.1526718587,
0.3823128343,
-0.4937568605,
0.2339202017,
-0.1280774325,
-0.5731378794,
0.580653429,
-0.0530857295,
0.228978157,
0.0258929525,
-0.1636420786,
-0.4176949859,
-0.4647020996,
-0.0609609596,
0.2920945585,
0.2587768137,
-0.3606872559,
0.5106298923,
-0.0217038523,
0.9346708059,
0.2981903553,
-0.4434028566,
0.2953831851,
-0.3911302388,
-0.184498027,
0.5158376098,
0.902607739,
0.0615182482,
-0.2990660369,
0.0074638664,
-0.4435520768,
0.3306767344,
-0.1897592098,
-0.3083554208,
-0.1383776963,
0.4300262928,
-0.1434212923,
-0.1155496389,
-0.1003005132,
-0.7153562307,
-0.3358517587,
-0.12962991,
0.6647998691,
-0.2748434246,
-0.2740333974,
0.186609149,
0.0978390574,
0.1881964952,
0.3249539733,
-0.6387645602,
-0.047540389,
0.3197823465,
0.6778762341,
0.0765129924,
-0.23932302,
-0.9590752125,
0.5149025917,
-0.3768177927,
0.8428861499,
-0.4212347865,
-0.5534933209,
-0.1819097102,
-0.3651921749,
-0.0131655792,
-0.3865743876,
0.5244140029,
-0.4248034954,
0.1033840179,
0.0686917827,
-0.5168455839,
-0.0196583048,
-0.1559990346,
-0.8527242541,
0.6633607149,
0.090582259,
-0.517635107,
0.3671516478,
-0.4416896403,
-0.5259839892,
-0.0179281235,
-0.3974715173,
-0.6114911437,
0.0050672558,
0.3069090843,
0.3436426222,
-0.1015676633,
0.2394564301,
-0.3297475576,
-0.3379482329,
0.2583039999,
-0.738697648,
0.4492952526,
0.2556634247,
-0.310949564,
-0.0544809178,
-0.9834273458,
-0.0012604328,
-0.1063344851,
-0.6748614907,
-0.0199163463,
-0.151593402,
-0.0403055251,
0.1458680481,
0.1695388258,
-0.5356500745,
-0.0180024132,
-0.5613831878,
0.3979110122,
0.6617659926,
-0.2130016834,
0.6367538571,
-0.3892810643,
0.4767940044,
-0.2456943095,
0.0267613251,
-0.1280625015,
-0.2338357717,
-0.7938437462,
-0.1841818243,
0.3282361925,
0.6105293632,
-0.9361625314,
0.6997663379,
-0.1488507241,
-0.7377721667,
-0.6342785358,
0.1726000011,
0.4360210896,
0.560982883,
0.2089877576,
-0.3115536869,
-0.6839011312,
-0.484790355,
-0.0399114154,
-0.523414135,
0.0384514593,
0.325186342,
-0.1742191315,
-0.4630004466,
0.8860316277,
-0.2586909235,
-0.6817216873,
-0.3457623124,
0.3982363343,
0.2774032354,
0.5858187675,
0.1942633092,
-0.824131012,
-0.1965164393,
0.0674759373,
-0.6878512502,
-0.1500425935,
-0.3304975331,
0.1983420402,
0.2787799537,
0.4945619404,
-0.5541826487,
0.1855832189,
0.9283803701,
-0.0791325644,
0.2203737348,
-0.4013334513,
0.0812591389,
-0.8755127788,
-0.1114713997,
-0.2404655665,
-0.0885526389,
-0.5191595554,
-0.4857380092,
-0.080409497,
-0.1640994847,
-0.4340541363,
0.5017317533,
-0.5939978361,
-0.2265322804,
-0.3675933778,
-0.1106043383,
-0.1041729823,
0.1197734103,
-0.0933112204,
0.7443686128,
0.6215680838,
-0.565148294,
0.6975794435,
0.193535462,
-0.2567263246,
0.3080945313,
-0.5262063742,
0.2019263059,
-0.1624596268,
0.5568699837,
-1.0164041519,
-0.5477086306,
0.0780549422,
-0.5440707207,
0.647539854,
-0.0489523672,
-0.3816452622,
-0.4823577404,
0.1185689494,
0.7767367363,
0.4231370986,
-0.4189163446,
1.2271168232,
0.5876826048,
-0.3560254276,
-0.4651433527,
-0.8012340665,
0.0983547047,
-0.1200143918,
-0.7101155519,
0.4557726085,
-0.2183733284,
-0.1702172905,
-0.0560834147,
-0.1032560766,
-0.0807231814,
-0.1585789174,
0.1781385839,
0.1649243385,
-0.0499319285,
0.1427296847,
0.0526728518,
-0.3131361604,
-0.2601723969,
-0.1642421335,
0.7330422997,
-0.1423205286,
-0.6332976222,
-0.5512506962,
0.3018327057,
0.6841122508,
-0.2942941785,
0.3424638212,
0.9714191556,
-0.6098982692,
-0.0449318849,
-0.8529513478,
-0.1193941236,
-0.490745157,
0.2096008956,
-0.0566296577,
-0.6660260558,
0.4936695993,
0.1253847778,
-0.072809644,
0.4627785981,
0.4694094956,
-0.3473151326,
1.0636823177,
0.740735054,
-0.1732510924,
0.5960782766,
-0.3103104234,
0.1949772388,
-0.538959384,
-0.2970392406,
-0.3057232797,
-0.1302445531,
-0.3422080874,
-0.660710156,
0.6974993348,
-0.2683953643,
0.2174220383,
0.0317579508,
-0.1000884101,
0.2761995792,
0.4980478883,
0.0110432319,
0.1639996469,
0.0267409962,
0.0182117634,
0.0361138284,
-0.9201737642,
-0.0552616231,
0.9878497124,
0.2740861177,
1.1302423477,
-0.0717931911,
0.7249999046,
0.3324024677,
-0.3010319173,
-0.6254040599,
0.3716942072,
-0.1529733539,
-0.1215569079,
-0.6708152294,
-0.5557017326,
-0.7931930423,
-0.015475546,
-0.459572345,
-0.1455916613,
0.3183091283,
0.5551953316,
-0.9345609546,
0.359456867,
-0.5868154764,
0.4107620418,
-0.4778322279,
-0.207670331,
-0.1320190132,
-0.7615083456,
0.1007942334,
-0.5432617068,
0.5093845725,
-0.0018331718,
0.0192128047,
0.9394317269,
-0.2141597718,
0.7063326836,
-0.1840560585,
-0.3527851701,
0.2111416906,
-0.1354788542,
0.6806339025,
-0.251750201,
-0.0899534449,
0.1152111888,
-0.268198669,
-0.0540677495,
-0.5400348902,
0.7534784079,
-0.6407616138,
-0.3977752924,
-0.6215295196,
-0.7515050173,
-0.3221870065,
0.2057420611,
0.3017493784,
0.6335755587,
0.0002695632,
0.1255395263,
0.8106503487,
-0.1098307818,
0.5919818878,
0.4164921939,
0.1505607367,
-0.548586905,
1.0600633621,
0.2175278664,
0.2739846706,
0.3995960951,
0.3057207167,
-0.4725509584,
-0.7120814919,
-0.4700617492,
0.3938856125,
-0.5491919518,
-0.228355214,
-0.8431735039,
-0.2561447322,
-0.4699126184,
-0.1533005685,
-0.5921134353,
-0.2395433187,
-0.5266594887,
0.1050817296,
0.3137597144,
0.47078529,
-0.5889969468,
0.4102630615,
-1.119053483,
0.4266572893,
0.4077866077,
0.2679328024,
-0.2490151823,
-0.4257780015,
-0.1950226128,
0.2308568954,
0.033445131,
-0.5846564174,
0.3145921826,
0.6452522278,
0.6894895434,
0.4043455124,
0.1745271981,
0.7657535672,
-0.3699295521,
0.6518918872,
0.3642716706,
-0.944776237,
0.6315882206,
-0.4031784534,
0.5505943298,
0.1814019233,
-0.0028432671,
-0.4471672475,
-0.5109836459,
-0.5612043738,
-0.9822931886,
0.4501830637,
0.0387617983,
-0.0441410318,
0.4607619345,
-0.0745365843,
-0.0507901013,
0.0973085091,
-0.2439477295,
-0.0491753891,
-0.0675417632,
-0.287777245,
-0.3592736721,
-0.2367594838,
-0.1550542414,
-0.2103189975,
0.5972875953,
-0.1349927187,
0.3801970184,
-0.0046571931,
-0.0498462655,
-0.6508542299,
0.2994270921,
0.5200486183,
0.4789672792,
-0.1522416025,
0.096363917,
0.2441278249,
-0.4146439135,
0.3905202448,
0.5312130451,
0.1765765101,
0.0432001278,
0.6035590768,
0.7281610966,
0.3872659802,
-0.7790244222,
0.5002164245,
-0.1193342432,
0.1284550577,
-0.5526219606,
0.0660883784,
-0.0590305328,
0.4813222289,
0.5493894815,
0.2287015915,
0.0784093812,
-0.4148073792,
0.4867391586,
0.3997364044,
-0.2921282053,
-0.220183,
0.7612019181,
0.1844608784,
-0.0948181674,
0.3961586952,
0.1157531589,
-0.4644988179,
0.2368854284,
0.4639864564,
0.7179448009,
-0.85181427,
-0.1405904591,
-0.0118758455,
-0.0490785651,
0.0049226927,
0.3505678773,
-0.0967101529,
-0.6854432821,
-0.6211031675,
-0.7580153942,
-0.2928469777,
0.0587225072,
-0.5188062787,
0.2810916007,
-0.3388620615,
-0.2574923038,
-0.0579175837,
-0.3267799616,
-0.5913232565,
0.4524781108,
0.2676394582,
0.4520461559,
-0.9138615131,
0.8091983795,
0.4503622651,
-0.1666838676,
-0.916952014,
0.0389993191,
0.1907870471,
-0.7386631966,
0.2790865004,
-0.2827824056,
-0.4187155664,
0.1070845723,
-0.248829037,
-1.1022721529,
1.1147648096,
0.5886951089,
-0.8566234112,
-0.2691156566,
0.118855536,
0.3058435619,
-0.072197102,
-0.1949555725,
0.5869910717,
0.4412856996,
0.712485075,
-1.2680658102,
-0.4146696031,
-0.1280216426,
-0.2436215729,
0.2858895957,
-0.3917746246,
0.8791740537,
-0.5315875411,
-0.3323728144,
-0.1169239357,
0.8050263524,
0.159168601,
0.2361858338,
0.8268438578,
0.5444096923,
0.8712900877,
-0.1385205984,
0.8843536377,
-0.0887071118,
-0.0308495536,
1.0006843805,
-0.1369176209,
0.8613341451,
0.5270788074,
-0.1158163399,
-0.0121933864,
0.5797826648,
0.0103690531,
0.6008709073,
-0.0800745487,
-0.4756597281,
-0.4369236827,
-0.3537220061,
-0.6200601459,
0.8796874881,
0.4461070597,
-0.1450546235,
-0.1865610331,
0.363948971,
-0.1337948591,
-0.0200221185,
-0.2528269291,
0.9453995228,
0.1311054528,
-0.1527612358,
0.7200401425,
-0.2750486434,
0.7155320048,
-0.6556473374,
-0.182002157,
0.0304865874,
0.3440621495,
-0.2295140177,
-0.6687932611,
0.2604315877,
-0.17839849,
-0.1883148551,
-0.1700318903,
0.7013317347,
-0.9339392781,
-0.713675499,
0.236827001,
0.3522996008,
-0.01067123,
0.0645969287,
-0.3367216587,
0.6731094718,
-0.0043943292,
0.2856420875,
0.0864169896,
0.1203510389,
0.2280899137,
0.8374145627,
0.8258945346,
0.5457576513,
0.0454117805,
0.0342127383,
0.927870512,
-0.3625740111,
-0.6622698307,
-0.6145815849,
0.4583826661,
0.2998220623,
0.1296980828,
0.5476697683,
0.4109765291,
0.803476274,
0.1614583433,
0.9594009519,
0.2831158042,
0.5180633664,
-0.7384811044,
0.9537758827,
-0.7043194771,
0.252291292,
-0.5049316287,
-0.8331167102,
-0.5319566131,
0.6286836863,
-0.0477831364,
0.0905537233,
0.2900437415,
0.7623590827,
0.0515311845,
-0.1424123198,
0.5228859782,
0.2684480846,
0.5280936956,
0.6120432615,
0.6865971684,
-0.4573709667,
0.7985653877,
-0.2880239487,
-0.2664726377,
-0.3092536032,
-0.8596392274,
-0.3089336455,
-0.7652768493,
-0.3311807811,
-0.3909442723,
0.0299499389,
0.9100730419,
0.5898477435,
-0.6447545886,
-0.2187597603,
0.2452251762,
-0.0657139271,
-0.142274648,
-0.0779699162,
0.4126628935,
0.0929703191,
-0.730750978,
0.8486118317,
0.2918827236,
0.7263768315,
-0.2821011543,
-0.2451889366,
0.0235297829,
0.0065590953,
0.3342380524,
0.4174663126,
-0.7438489795,
-0.2470704913,
-0.189705506,
0.0405396223,
-0.0611307509,
0.5857827663,
-0.7837982178,
0.9454731345,
0.3567221761,
0.7343271971,
0.2650259435,
-0.2811944485,
1.0786212683,
-0.4870929718,
0.1774279922,
0.4742769301,
0.4729114473,
0.7231041789,
-0.3968083858,
0.1032516286,
0.2882751226,
-0.4370098114,
-1.0020091534,
0.1646402627,
-1.1090928316,
0.2232334018,
1.1464468241,
0.1392248273,
-0.2430562973,
-0.2324514836,
-0.1789586991,
0.6251888871,
-0.5175706744,
0.7478045225,
0.5088188648,
-0.090576157,
-0.2597601414,
0.0709033683,
0.6432468295,
0.1238320023,
-0.6149891615,
0.0119112842,
0.6423502564,
-0.1783280075,
0.3087466359,
0.5591725707,
0.0194049329,
0.6224112511,
0.0812443346,
-0.1062518656,
-0.1710919589,
-0.4544008076,
-0.5755118728,
0.0222008377,
0.1836731881,
-0.2034441233
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05455v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05455v1
|
Large Language Models for Psycholinguistic Plausibility Pretesting
| 2024-02-08T07:20:02 | 2024-02-08T07:20:02 |
Samuel Joseph Amouyal, Aya Meltzer-Asscher, Jonathan Berant
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In psycholinguistics, the creation of controlled materials is crucial to
ensure that research outcomes are solely attributed to the intended
manipulations and not influenced by extraneous factors. To achieve this,
psycholinguists typically pretest linguistic materials, where a common pretest
is to solicit plausibility judgments from human evaluators on specific
sentences. In this work, we investigate whether Language Models (LMs) can be
used to generate these plausibility judgements. We investigate a wide range of
LMs across multiple linguistic structures and evaluate whether their
plausibility judgements correlate with human judgements. We find that GPT-4
plausibility judgements highly correlate with human judgements across the
structures we examine, whereas other LMs correlate well with humans on commonly
used syntactic structures. We then test whether this correlation implies that
LMs can be used instead of humans for pretesting. We find that when
coarse-grained plausibility judgements are needed, this works well, but when
fine-grained judgements are necessary, even GPT-4 does not provide satisfactory
discriminative power.
|
[
-0.2370166928,
-0.9228544235,
0.8766567111,
0.4006093144,
-0.1388021708,
-0.1731363684,
-0.5292447805,
-0.6033928394,
-0.1034931466,
0.3079231679,
-0.1766010225,
-0.2697141767,
-0.3039776683,
0.2404644042,
-0.4606916904,
1.1586842537,
-0.1325831115,
0.02617478,
-0.0946846828,
0.1494508386,
-0.2866501808,
-0.9876986742,
-0.2272752225,
-0.4797371626,
0.6113394499,
-0.1001623943,
0.9230632186,
0.0501918495,
0.5703685284,
0.3114114702,
0.1166407093,
-0.4499234855,
-0.2908568978,
-0.0870522037,
-0.3751663864,
-0.5555779338,
-0.8947533965,
0.250228107,
0.4389721155,
0.9239223003,
-0.2993112206,
-0.000520096,
0.2954469919,
0.0208644569,
-0.4722353518,
0.1826717705,
-0.4806724489,
0.0614948869,
-0.2977528572,
-0.2037767619,
-0.5557001829,
-0.5289918184,
0.3230137825,
-0.4797935784,
0.3531908691,
0.1096164957,
0.900965631,
-0.0453839339,
-0.335746944,
-0.5022932887,
-0.8559475541,
0.5991598964,
-0.9666250944,
0.536136806,
0.8970211148,
0.2157844156,
-0.1303816736,
-0.8509694338,
-0.685033977,
-0.9367793798,
-0.2912683785,
0.0074102688,
0.0368190184,
0.2563722134,
0.333242476,
0.4190270305,
-0.6967206597,
0.1446139365,
-0.2532070875,
-0.4583823085,
0.5332013965,
0.0523560755,
0.28317222,
-0.0579012185,
-0.2061390281,
-0.1520391554,
-0.6226376891,
-0.0668042675,
0.6858291626,
0.3186773956,
-0.0836904198,
0.562782228,
0.2568960786,
0.6146401763,
-0.107474342,
-0.3106052577,
0.2938239872,
-0.6637690067,
-0.1906973422,
-0.1815284193,
0.8681615591,
0.2623073757,
0.5506869555,
-0.2169940174,
-0.3066155612,
0.2218282521,
0.2151989639,
-0.7927909493,
-0.5064172149,
0.0609059446,
-0.4453658462,
-0.147934854,
-0.109168835,
-0.6076732278,
-0.3150376379,
-0.2764484584,
0.6018874049,
-0.4826672971,
-0.540638864,
0.3122291267,
0.0766213164,
0.1801481098,
0.0115646655,
-0.6669622064,
0.4868195653,
0.4092711806,
0.6611250639,
-0.0508604497,
-0.6067474484,
-0.2362197787,
-0.188800171,
-0.4332253039,
0.7772179246,
-0.5519508719,
-0.2845428288,
-0.2393425107,
0.085151732,
-0.0404035449,
-0.5413028002,
0.8055079579,
-0.3407304883,
0.4514602423,
-0.167450875,
-0.6493032575,
-0.0788228214,
0.117146723,
-0.6380194426,
0.5972304344,
0.1962254494,
-0.5678800941,
0.3468452692,
-0.6244978309,
-0.5750555396,
0.2046537548,
-0.2814177275,
-0.4837821424,
0.2045871764,
-0.337816,
0.4224348366,
-0.3502120078,
0.7293779254,
-0.5446252823,
-0.3143835068,
0.4920004308,
-0.552834332,
0.5949572325,
0.1334965527,
-0.4309175014,
0.1181352735,
-0.4351961017,
0.0425936542,
0.2379044741,
-0.426260829,
-0.3208171725,
0.1351615787,
0.1998559684,
0.297453016,
0.1515770108,
-0.2803943753,
-0.1516419351,
-0.3953610659,
0.278690815,
0.6246026754,
-0.2614921331,
0.2100745291,
-0.3716295063,
0.7247202396,
-0.1914252639,
-0.0640837178,
0.050656952,
-0.3626230955,
-0.2928648293,
-0.389098227,
0.2463315278,
0.3458410501,
-0.4737437665,
0.5435010791,
0.0174042899,
-0.4220400453,
-0.0754310489,
0.1511247307,
0.5639736056,
0.3135901392,
-0.0364749804,
-0.3586806655,
-0.6093600988,
-1.0022774935,
-0.5572875142,
-0.227637127,
-0.3052595556,
0.1231927499,
0.5905843377,
0.0616273917,
0.9515346885,
-0.4651077092,
-0.1515155435,
-0.3010779023,
0.1650486141,
0.1584144533,
0.1058276147,
0.84866184,
-0.7875848413,
-0.1063395217,
-0.3469181955,
-0.7203342915,
-0.3176505566,
0.1336304694,
0.3134854436,
0.1268956363,
0.347568661,
-0.5559143424,
0.3867203593,
0.6584533453,
-0.5923910737,
1.0659943819,
-0.4152525067,
-0.0392109342,
-0.7420919538,
0.1426301003,
0.0326603577,
-0.2877208591,
-0.6168734431,
0.1667895317,
-0.0377131216,
-0.0566676594,
-0.2586142421,
0.5532769561,
-0.3640969992,
-0.1804113984,
-0.0561063215,
0.1376526654,
-0.0071379724,
0.2994571328,
0.1773596257,
0.5713639855,
0.3415079713,
-0.5839480758,
0.039368663,
-0.0304773059,
-0.7157438993,
0.3695475161,
-0.7483475804,
0.1499388516,
-0.0081624873,
0.485085696,
-0.9063957334,
-0.3921455145,
-0.1010744274,
-0.0997127891,
-0.0771144331,
0.2341189682,
-0.6981449127,
-0.3779365122,
-0.0752435848,
0.4592557847,
0.4735212326,
-0.0617194399,
0.4519179165,
0.2452774346,
-0.6031807661,
-0.0445050374,
-0.5420069695,
0.0152997915,
-0.4741857946,
-0.3280467093,
-0.0260581672,
-0.5484442711,
-0.5361944437,
-0.2777236402,
0.1894774139,
-0.147920996,
0.2933521569,
0.2890101969,
0.3375381827,
-0.4374061823,
0.0955752209,
-0.427698493,
0.0268862862,
0.1548231244,
0.0850218534,
0.7559970021,
-0.3374679089,
-0.5923181772,
-0.2973864377,
0.2700787485,
0.5225840807,
-0.312356472,
0.4453908503,
0.4157537222,
-0.4134121537,
0.0628355891,
-0.5788472891,
-0.4079859555,
-0.4393801689,
0.6256110668,
-0.6632201672,
-0.6948294044,
0.4902758598,
0.0261752121,
-0.1915598065,
0.1437219083,
0.9069452286,
0.0171857066,
0.9168500304,
0.4056874812,
0.2308982164,
0.4389917552,
0.154734388,
0.6658930779,
-0.3145368397,
0.1965532005,
-0.4680066407,
-0.1207607985,
-0.5559569597,
-0.282664448,
0.1809427142,
0.1659946591,
-0.1474069506,
0.1775254607,
-0.0487325415,
0.6188287139,
0.2375942916,
0.0817719549,
0.3790647388,
-0.1315854043,
-0.1747883707,
-0.0956281349,
-0.2695597708,
-0.7381293178,
1.042495966,
0.4269451201,
0.5918033719,
0.2457989156,
0.2626499534,
0.0019588964,
0.6294804811,
-0.6601803899,
0.5640587807,
-0.2119053751,
-0.8823506236,
-0.3183121383,
-0.3218816221,
-0.9532470107,
0.1426104754,
-0.1546783447,
-0.8371981978,
0.0210793894,
0.162123099,
-0.4915593565,
0.1215749905,
-1.0512154102,
0.8018651009,
-0.4092915654,
-0.1633483768,
-0.1265147328,
-0.4688744843,
0.5372136235,
-0.5801644325,
0.3991642594,
-0.1334736794,
0.3587636352,
0.8070444465,
-0.2319407761,
0.8905493617,
-0.0819263458,
-0.4295380116,
0.1097920239,
0.310980618,
0.2456094027,
-0.2642429769,
-0.2972924113,
0.0307820868,
0.2288626432,
-0.3119044304,
-0.5040884018,
0.5077309012,
-0.6608738303,
-0.6510798931,
-0.2667809427,
-0.7435980439,
-0.2680962086,
0.3558264971,
0.1942481995,
0.4087001681,
-0.3825794756,
0.2249998897,
0.0849747509,
-0.2933714986,
0.2149534523,
0.789740026,
-0.4601981044,
0.0509900488,
0.8351247907,
0.1003513038,
0.4021517336,
-0.1037724689,
0.6320734024,
-0.4115145802,
-0.7421937585,
0.2429289818,
0.2614539862,
-0.4879580438,
0.1411545575,
-0.199023515,
-0.1772036552,
-0.4953043759,
-0.0239277557,
-0.159400478,
-0.0037152851,
0.2436037809,
-0.2756869793,
0.0219628979,
0.9051576257,
0.0338788815,
0.24759911,
-0.5035324693,
0.4814918041,
0.1511875093,
0.4209032655,
-0.0357574709,
-0.493296206,
0.0487557054,
0.1255533099,
-0.3035799861,
-0.8713176847,
0.3587000072,
0.2274273485,
0.5001741052,
0.3639024198,
0.068439424,
0.5588464141,
-0.5966410041,
0.7145559788,
0.2267550677,
-0.9565318823,
0.3080336452,
-0.5867907405,
-0.1060670167,
0.3844221234,
0.4664469957,
-0.0657531619,
-0.5837013125,
-0.5806168318,
-0.8087494969,
0.4368176758,
0.1681655943,
0.0408268049,
0.0537864193,
0.2681623399,
0.3270656466,
0.0936316848,
-0.7952017188,
0.2399327755,
-0.1086968705,
-0.2868923843,
-0.6818665266,
-0.2021012455,
-0.1144254282,
-0.1703084707,
0.0935317576,
-0.036368981,
-0.0807387531,
0.1608603746,
-0.1995410174,
0.0582208335,
0.5176099539,
0.7873659134,
1.025403738,
-0.5024307966,
0.2741934061,
0.0950314105,
-0.5931951404,
0.2591067255,
0.1814407557,
0.1476363242,
-0.2177857906,
0.5496310592,
0.7859331369,
0.312107265,
-0.6776221395,
0.6894394159,
-0.2778041661,
-0.2794871926,
-0.4771744311,
-0.1432810277,
0.2129409909,
0.2259754539,
0.1844680309,
-0.1570302695,
0.0488407649,
-0.9375150204,
0.272133112,
0.2686536908,
0.2619767189,
-0.8353985548,
0.5216059089,
0.0771760419,
-0.6464468837,
0.4282330275,
-0.3168347478,
-0.563113153,
0.3102030754,
0.8048151135,
0.6496089101,
-0.4976276457,
0.1138264686,
0.0252246056,
0.0998982415,
-0.3036543131,
0.1774487495,
0.1412563175,
-0.9357176423,
-0.568114996,
-0.8130292296,
-0.4845302105,
0.4520019293,
-0.6374500394,
0.217560783,
-0.3062844872,
-0.3126869202,
0.1339231133,
-0.0334657989,
-0.8914045691,
0.1702801287,
0.2663983405,
0.6343809366,
-1.2305077314,
0.8171098232,
0.594836235,
-0.4301689267,
-1.0610655546,
0.1624480635,
-0.1516962498,
-0.5812398195,
0.6892725229,
-0.0720605105,
0.0158237629,
-0.133626923,
-0.3868924677,
-0.5415023565,
0.9594624043,
0.8912388086,
-0.5666058064,
-0.4741640389,
0.1224965528,
0.7247487903,
-0.1357909441,
0.5011302233,
0.7610807419,
0.6096825004,
-0.0962179005,
-1.4983311892,
0.1896805614,
-0.0890133902,
-0.3036885262,
-0.0814340636,
-0.2656466365,
1.0869531631,
-0.1886101961,
-0.0623773597,
0.0919447541,
0.3011655509,
0.6723097563,
0.3040262759,
0.7939351201,
0.3369298279,
0.9305068851,
0.1326688975,
1.37591362,
-0.2386413217,
0.3403471112,
1.4539052248,
-0.7254055738,
1.0154230595,
0.4334319532,
-0.3881486654,
0.5657548904,
0.5860651135,
0.2307638377,
0.3201820254,
0.3965276778,
-0.0677870885,
-0.3146306574,
-0.0641010925,
-0.2584779859,
0.6880870461,
0.3279352784,
-0.3317543566,
-0.354978919,
0.0525727533,
0.0377551988,
-0.0362282507,
0.0569137074,
0.4723641574,
0.3444945514,
-0.7176789641,
0.5640388727,
-0.2352743745,
0.596165061,
-0.8424050808,
0.184704572,
-0.076261729,
0.5026057363,
-0.2494927496,
-0.7552881837,
0.3803799748,
0.0777226537,
0.0569048561,
-0.2249346524,
0.7374333739,
-0.3747109473,
-0.4235863388,
0.5186835527,
0.7270201445,
0.5389506817,
-0.2453413904,
-0.3308339715,
-0.1155864745,
-0.277754426,
-0.5661640167,
0.6592695713,
0.3219997287,
-0.2902852893,
0.4570877254,
0.8026738167,
0.3782689571,
-0.1578275114,
0.3620812595,
0.6320312619,
-0.6279674172,
-0.5739793181,
-0.9831008315,
0.1914582998,
0.2242311239,
-0.1282495856,
0.8645207882,
0.4194514155,
0.6006915569,
-0.0955779478,
0.7966655493,
0.1045761406,
0.2933583558,
-0.4905886054,
0.8693692088,
-0.2488792986,
0.0711503401,
-0.4289235473,
-0.9418100715,
-0.2084736526,
0.7489349842,
-0.6441297531,
0.3124587238,
0.9941491485,
0.7858401537,
-0.1418953538,
0.0533993579,
0.6685242057,
0.6441972852,
0.3323169053,
0.6386402249,
0.9225971103,
0.0479058996,
0.4068464637,
0.147571072,
-0.2064060867,
-0.0173666868,
-0.9956147671,
-0.9575612545,
-0.6237629652,
-0.1550982594,
-0.2828647196,
-0.0978090763,
0.7709521055,
0.6281151772,
-0.7093404531,
-0.3093350828,
0.0047828425,
-0.1843809187,
0.131172657,
-0.2737921178,
0.3934243023,
0.0081247445,
-0.4485088587,
0.3796516955,
-0.0498411357,
0.2560501695,
-0.3406970501,
-0.1702274084,
0.0045750556,
0.1220247224,
0.5888627172,
0.0258345213,
-0.960536778,
-0.5044697523,
-0.1231649518,
0.0611440465,
-0.1465563774,
0.9932219386,
-0.7412118912,
0.0623205118,
0.5138428211,
0.2435571849,
0.1600555629,
-0.0283332467,
0.9349546432,
-0.7066118121,
0.3024850786,
0.3518810868,
0.5906836987,
0.2935450077,
0.0041726301,
0.3391078711,
0.0597388968,
-0.6311022043,
-1.1086007357,
0.3361871839,
-0.7803140283,
-0.2176648527,
1.0929344893,
-0.5002782345,
-0.0281664897,
-0.3077219129,
-0.198043406,
0.0620572679,
0.0693171024,
0.5856019258,
1.0402308702,
-0.1206375211,
-0.0933023691,
-0.7162697911,
0.5222142339,
0.5624650121,
-0.8484576344,
0.1436171383,
0.2134760469,
0.6559557319,
0.4011103213,
0.9149979949,
-0.0315784961,
0.0904392973,
-0.0809429809,
-0.005785598,
0.1829863787,
-0.0507245734,
-0.3096801639,
0.2574605942,
0.3754145801,
0.2844914198
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05445v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05445v2
|
Accurate LoRA-Finetuning Quantization of LLMs via Information Retention
| 2024-02-08T06:53:31 | 2024-05-27T09:20:35 |
Haotong Qin, Xudong Ma, Xingyu Zheng, Xiaoyang Li, Yang Zhang, Shouda Liu, Jie Luo, Xianglong Liu, Michele Magno
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
The LoRA-finetuning quantization of LLMs has been extensively studied to
obtain accurate yet compact LLMs for deployment on resource-constrained
hardware. However, existing methods cause the quantized LLM to severely degrade
and even fail to benefit from the finetuning of LoRA. This paper proposes a
novel IR-QLoRA for pushing quantized LLMs with LoRA to be highly accurate
through information retention. The proposed IR-QLoRA mainly relies on two
technologies derived from the perspective of unified information: (1)
statistics-based Information Calibration Quantization allows the quantized
parameters of LLM to retain original information accurately; (2)
finetuning-based Information Elastic Connection makes LoRA utilizes elastic
representation transformation with diverse information. Comprehensive
experiments show that IR-QLoRA can significantly improve accuracy across LLaMA
and LLaMA2 families under 2-4 bit-widths, e.g., 4- bit LLaMA-7B achieves 1.4%
improvement on MMLU compared with the state-of-the-art methods. The significant
performance gain requires only a tiny 0.31% additional time consumption,
revealing the satisfactory efficiency of our IR-QLoRA. We highlight that
IR-QLoRA enjoys excellent versatility, compatible with various frameworks
(e.g., NormalFloat and Integer quantization) and brings general accuracy gains.
The code is available at https://github.com/htqin/ir-qlora.
|
[
-0.3887984455,
-0.6248983741,
0.3881503344,
0.0692142099,
-0.5673502684,
0.2072229236,
-0.1910077035,
-0.3838378489,
0.1750857979,
0.1186548173,
-0.2100717425,
-0.5533648729,
-0.0575654469,
-0.1170768589,
-0.1684692651,
0.7784263492,
-0.0802546144,
-0.0089951567,
0.2417649776,
-0.6835569143,
-0.4325114191,
-0.2698483467,
-0.1306883246,
-0.5110654235,
0.858178556,
0.554474175,
0.7651155591,
0.6528756022,
0.6614348888,
0.1938811541,
-0.1136410013,
0.4001936316,
-0.5403680205,
-0.0040716468,
0.1255328804,
-0.7308558822,
-0.5412655473,
-0.3232473135,
0.8866089582,
0.247662887,
-0.4499779642,
0.5807504654,
0.0478749163,
1.2571640015,
-0.8699817657,
-0.1169434935,
-0.6783567667,
0.1094418764,
-0.4060514867,
-0.5958881974,
-0.330868572,
-0.5897424817,
-0.1365094483,
-0.7931857705,
-0.1597617567,
0.093130894,
0.8600722551,
0.4569942355,
-0.6022414565,
0.1625304222,
-1.0584275723,
0.7097132206,
-0.6168316603,
0.5205665827,
0.2357289493,
0.5105671883,
0.0682060346,
-0.6150832772,
-0.2493895143,
0.0742795989,
0.3203265965,
0.1966325194,
-0.1717254519,
0.1936284453,
0.0477550738,
0.3416859806,
-0.4320727885,
0.2687297463,
-0.4280426204,
0.0558823198,
0.1807577163,
-0.0531581566,
-0.3012493849,
0.2112118155,
-0.7986017466,
-0.1738726944,
-1.1272394657,
-0.0701696053,
0.3878050148,
0.1065989807,
-0.1047290415,
0.4758863449,
-0.11081478,
0.4088690579,
0.1398016959,
-0.3125692308,
0.1240495592,
0.0206059944,
-0.2298570275,
0.1749314964,
0.5537564158,
0.3535658419,
-0.0519446768,
0.1364765167,
-0.2958058715,
-0.0137742674,
-0.1639051288,
-0.9456548095,
0.0226765778,
0.2962896824,
-0.4002741575,
-0.036520347,
0.1644134223,
-0.6169840693,
-0.1458716244,
-0.2722120285,
0.5973858237,
-0.3931503594,
0.0316286758,
0.1167847216,
0.174054414,
0.1937355101,
0.4517782032,
-0.7163596153,
-0.0201455746,
0.6100205183,
0.7480980158,
0.0269654784,
0.2388643324,
-0.4682736397,
0.3070742786,
-0.2287508994,
0.8020387888,
0.138348788,
0.2383062243,
-0.1331551969,
-0.4615080655,
0.4105452001,
-0.6492774487,
0.2411905676,
-0.9078099728,
-0.1350888759,
0.0762904584,
-0.332248807,
-0.2068212628,
0.2199267596,
-0.8067258596,
0.7684200406,
0.2555912435,
-0.4733017087,
0.0921993256,
-0.2825017869,
0.2840755284,
0.0312895291,
-0.3014741838,
-0.5926927924,
0.0903765112,
-0.1321684867,
-0.0669701397,
-0.6343463659,
0.3308060467,
-0.321496278,
-0.8472024202,
0.5200440288,
-0.8841642737,
0.4624690115,
0.5323121548,
-0.3083706796,
-0.1755821258,
-0.8810017109,
0.4274321198,
-0.2123867869,
-0.6409294605,
-0.3044132888,
-0.3796410561,
-0.0387374759,
-0.1896847486,
0.5176462531,
-0.5351871848,
0.2067087591,
-0.1605665833,
0.3846607804,
0.8571394086,
-0.2021485567,
0.4145465195,
-0.5179440379,
0.5078699589,
-0.1390415281,
0.3585934639,
0.0142343864,
-0.1016515419,
-0.6417781711,
-0.300999999,
0.6759281754,
0.6028633118,
-0.6889093518,
0.4384708703,
-0.4157111943,
-0.5454273224,
-0.3246512115,
0.1922053695,
0.3583303094,
0.2589541078,
0.2682794034,
-0.1662192643,
-0.4418160021,
-0.5550926328,
0.0013727242,
-0.1865932047,
-0.1077444181,
-0.0788685381,
0.0338266343,
-0.4218542874,
1.0206260681,
-0.2956572175,
-0.8065276146,
0.1992500722,
0.1603690684,
0.4187040627,
0.7039341331,
0.3910108209,
-0.7636892796,
-0.2690111995,
0.2240781188,
-0.671996057,
-0.0546652749,
-0.0421422236,
-0.2446212023,
0.1705813706,
-0.030496832,
-0.3603802323,
0.5525687933,
0.7021083832,
-0.3293102086,
0.3310374916,
-0.3480730057,
0.2156906873,
-0.8985687494,
0.0986440927,
0.1629568934,
-0.3622848988,
-0.4282399714,
0.1213195696,
0.324945271,
0.2300937474,
-0.6989142895,
0.3571533859,
-0.4184134007,
-0.0831771791,
-0.0978874937,
0.0978391692,
0.1772334278,
0.5635192394,
-0.5567144752,
0.866962254,
-0.1710925251,
-0.4436948001,
0.3118022084,
-0.0284041464,
-0.1334356219,
0.8109299541,
-0.4875555038,
0.0722467229,
-0.1863598824,
0.1610481143,
-0.5767822266,
0.1052853689,
0.0210396089,
-0.1208025366,
0.1116372049,
-0.3243333995,
-0.5744799972,
-0.0199765079,
-0.6508271694,
0.8017498255,
0.8398380876,
-0.6104894876,
0.6367301941,
0.1058911383,
0.1773270071,
-0.5017215014,
-0.9297698736,
-0.2619856298,
-0.5174671412,
-0.4854851663,
0.4542758167,
-0.2679841518,
-0.2968819141,
-0.174992159,
-0.3403825462,
-0.3279326856,
-0.0123526314,
0.0682660565,
0.35625723,
-0.4219392836,
0.4179761708,
-0.0847920477,
-0.1921128333,
-0.3259108365,
-0.3000795245,
0.485635072,
-0.4602362514,
-0.3620802462,
-0.8544360995,
0.1103111133,
0.4486395717,
0.0525739156,
0.5448387265,
0.7523258328,
-0.3295920491,
-0.0560654402,
-0.8480686545,
-0.1860456616,
-0.5532531738,
0.2164430171,
-0.3236970305,
-0.8384107351,
0.7153664827,
-0.1541342288,
-0.079355225,
0.3390085399,
-0.10030853,
-0.539355278,
0.8279743195,
0.5088076591,
-0.0529210195,
0.7869182229,
-0.5863281488,
-0.0603862554,
-0.7832493186,
0.1031256318,
-0.3465402424,
-0.4084131718,
-0.4744495451,
-0.3038436174,
0.7995200157,
0.3432572186,
-0.7032051682,
-0.029616233,
-0.5202789903,
0.3995409906,
0.6143262982,
0.3790282607,
0.5900557041,
0.503040731,
0.4244755805,
-0.112620987,
-0.7661720514,
-0.571998179,
0.968244791,
0.37152946,
1.3782730103,
0.2266383618,
0.6606459022,
0.4743576348,
0.1367195845,
-0.4303609133,
0.2957029641,
-0.2274000794,
-0.0421001576,
-0.3143864572,
-0.6912605166,
-0.8261474967,
0.1884974092,
-0.0204264745,
-0.523817718,
0.3288228214,
0.537358284,
-0.6054730415,
0.6382050514,
-0.5688861609,
0.2306981534,
-0.2640504241,
-0.3817203641,
-0.2283220738,
-0.5420634151,
0.2137247026,
-0.1778291613,
0.0399383903,
-0.3247967958,
-0.1719947159,
0.7756707072,
-0.7269558907,
0.5653069019,
-0.176532492,
-0.6369555593,
0.5291642547,
-0.0004041818,
0.6225154996,
0.059614554,
-0.213198185,
0.1292116195,
0.1625716239,
-0.3918942809,
-0.8792377114,
0.6389356256,
-0.6063095927,
-0.2741851211,
-0.2754160464,
-0.4721428454,
0.081635721,
0.1332175434,
0.0821232647,
0.5747824311,
0.0973394141,
0.4183591604,
0.8248696327,
0.1971630752,
0.0765036047,
0.5681275129,
0.0828752294,
-0.8613221049,
1.2606924772,
0.3177771866,
0.414362371,
0.4723387957,
0.2761366665,
-0.1740175933,
-0.5095081329,
-0.460478276,
0.3608075976,
-0.5921969414,
-0.8390837312,
0.006820708,
-0.0714325681,
0.0502324328,
-0.1920238882,
-0.6578599215,
-0.5636479259,
-0.567912817,
0.2137804031,
0.7719247937,
0.5289743543,
-0.2834039629,
0.7113947272,
-0.8720921874,
0.3387404084,
0.278203845,
0.4745019674,
-0.1298827827,
-0.5112860203,
-0.2674736977,
0.4885119796,
-0.2949808836,
-0.5594551563,
0.2267375439,
0.3787383437,
-0.081054166,
0.5545110703,
0.3135288954,
0.9805785418,
-0.011873194,
0.3137585521,
0.3172641098,
-0.7633436918,
0.6244062185,
-0.2865919769,
0.51634413,
0.8014358878,
-0.0748130381,
-0.3080948293,
-0.3048425317,
-0.3233714998,
-0.8494645953,
0.4666136801,
-0.0436048135,
-0.2182536572,
0.5247201324,
0.4117428362,
0.0624955446,
0.1731017679,
-0.7239457965,
-0.5516411662,
0.1385691017,
-0.5216950178,
0.4270859957,
-0.4733019173,
-0.2241477221,
0.1492593437,
0.6792756319,
-0.5406938791,
0.5505304337,
0.2541556358,
-0.1021845564,
-0.1614576429,
0.3210844994,
0.5332562923,
0.6603998542,
-0.5192917585,
0.3611968458,
0.2265547514,
-0.5544635057,
0.7107174397,
0.0769088492,
-0.434273988,
-0.1768803596,
-0.1081246585,
0.5414850712,
0.1629794091,
-0.5923990607,
0.3656852245,
-0.0485488214,
0.0216150321,
-0.586789608,
0.0199852418,
-0.3169418573,
0.5783260465,
0.8079997301,
0.0962188095,
-0.047480993,
-0.4569703043,
0.0400994495,
0.3015702069,
-0.3008265197,
-0.2472682595,
0.6111339927,
0.0625232384,
0.02518088,
0.2762761712,
-0.1626197696,
-0.1291310042,
0.6025460958,
0.4840885103,
0.5335180163,
-0.0376131721,
0.0501083285,
0.1468721032,
0.0095092272,
-0.2199547589,
0.5656935573,
-0.2485477626,
-0.5083550811,
-0.1776722819,
-0.3331694901,
-0.4132487774,
-0.2925830781,
-0.8006862402,
-0.0020774377,
-0.5135992169,
-0.4511114359,
-0.71554178,
0.0897505805,
-0.4971799254,
0.0361186564,
0.020290643,
0.7945311069,
-0.2228522301,
0.7787441611,
0.1837846041,
-0.1936991066,
-0.7567124963,
-0.4229289889,
-0.1461988539,
-0.6768241525,
0.6008185744,
0.0258871,
-0.3349351287,
0.1879244,
-0.4739091694,
-1.1783950329,
1.8514775038,
0.7013642788,
-0.9286715984,
0.1314483583,
0.1992247701,
0.3534452617,
0.0300527215,
0.2802068889,
0.502166748,
0.4862428606,
0.0649013817,
-0.7370234132,
-0.0538308434,
-0.0312235747,
0.0943872184,
0.2065162957,
-1.071234107,
0.5833240151,
-0.3383511007,
-0.5058400631,
0.5764698982,
0.9809295535,
0.648669064,
0.2645855546,
0.4814915061,
0.5008742809,
1.0007766485,
-0.2334203124,
0.5639865398,
-0.2593899667,
0.5103870034,
0.8553340435,
-0.2215422392,
0.7942729592,
0.6688462496,
-0.1536046863,
0.4060023427,
0.3066549301,
0.1756933928,
0.4718818665,
0.2638845444,
-0.600579083,
0.1958325803,
-0.3164559901,
-0.4580335617,
0.1981872916,
0.2464505732,
-0.0496535487,
-0.0192172825,
0.2418544441,
-0.0824524611,
-0.23727566,
-0.4108806551,
0.4221043885,
0.0248349681,
-0.463588208,
1.0347598791,
-0.1789133102,
1.026638031,
-0.5963145494,
-0.2442378849,
-0.3721292019,
0.2460377514,
-0.3248637319,
-0.4817487001,
-0.2042654753,
-0.0982612744,
-0.0033533133,
-0.073699072,
0.6403797269,
-0.6203073263,
-0.2757650018,
0.0308306813,
0.3214742243,
-0.0248823017,
0.1297686547,
-0.1772485971,
0.3871705532,
0.1332185715,
-0.1269503683,
0.3724289238,
0.4525630474,
0.0606789291,
0.8673671484,
0.4418039024,
0.2853728831,
0.2790334523,
0.1604292095,
0.718667984,
-0.8023244739,
-0.3824414909,
-0.4895008206,
0.2328353226,
0.3780780733,
-0.2719556093,
0.3709507287,
0.3762025237,
0.5084593892,
0.1593309492,
0.2957146466,
0.1576226652,
0.1354868412,
-0.921679318,
0.5219080448,
-0.4445335269,
0.461920023,
0.0791748688,
-1.0814458132,
-0.407361269,
0.6006707549,
0.2903286219,
0.0751952529,
0.5597336888,
0.7841669321,
0.0721698776,
-0.1735703498,
0.4144127667,
0.149870947,
0.3955648243,
0.7393488884,
0.7632265091,
-0.864580512,
0.6429392099,
-0.4150291085,
-0.2010359913,
-0.3721189797,
-0.7103475928,
-0.1376176029,
-0.3197162747,
-0.5387222171,
-0.0830702558,
0.2490751296,
0.8799948096,
0.8177921176,
-0.4754284024,
-0.1926584393,
0.0146924425,
0.101936616,
-0.0159958284,
-0.2801747024,
0.3268094361,
-0.0772175416,
-0.4327668548,
0.2163015902,
0.2342108637,
0.6189017296,
-0.4179432392,
-0.2503542602,
0.0415488519,
-0.1786753237,
0.4213052392,
0.5830760002,
-0.5973159671,
-0.3294578195,
-0.2237052172,
-0.3102384508,
0.4042304754,
0.4614261389,
-1.0290015936,
0.1409390718,
0.3015544415,
0.4729005694,
0.3958611488,
0.2036302984,
0.4027697146,
-0.635573864,
0.2280298471,
0.1882414371,
0.3046009839,
0.1264213622,
-0.4556518197,
0.7264047861,
-0.0791641548,
-0.797399044,
-0.8653932214,
-0.0849718302,
-1.1732540131,
0.3376864791,
1.0329333544,
-0.139658466,
-0.5025343299,
0.2966821194,
-0.3428654075,
0.199241668,
-0.6165558696,
0.6601260304,
-0.2329420894,
0.0253043137,
-0.1086300537,
-0.2188610435,
0.1811666638,
0.5267097354,
-0.5803422928,
-0.1471889317,
0.3837343752,
-0.0046642376,
0.2671678364,
0.5632384419,
-0.0121454494,
0.6297699809,
-0.4094907343,
0.3163816035,
-0.0710186437,
-0.2252599746,
-0.6193907857,
0.2487692386,
0.3412011862,
-0.2915250361
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05440v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05440v1
|
Improving Agent Interactions in Virtual Environments with Language Models
| 2024-02-08T06:34:11 | 2024-02-08T06:34:11 |
Jack Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Enhancing AI systems with efficient communication skills for effective human
assistance necessitates proactive initiatives from the system side to discern
specific circumstances and interact aptly. This research focuses on a
collective building assignment in the Minecraft dataset, employing language
modeling to enhance task understanding through state-of-the-art methods. These
models focus on grounding multi-modal understanding and task-oriented dialogue
comprehension tasks, providing insights into their interpretative and
responsive capabilities. Our experimental results showcase a substantial
improvement over existing methods, indicating a promising direction for future
research in this domain.
|
[
-0.3942745626,
-1.1847300529,
0.5441967845,
0.0631688535,
0.2078592628,
0.3469194472,
-0.2258992046,
-0.644305706,
-0.2549146414,
0.3306097686,
-0.5996435881,
-0.2889695168,
-0.4674127996,
0.0044402205,
-0.0194316991,
0.5926275849,
0.0394773334,
-0.1562746018,
-0.6778036952,
-0.1528756469,
-0.8103721738,
-0.6093925238,
-0.7163495421,
-0.4545185864,
0.2662581205,
0.274058193,
1.0772355795,
0.8265331984,
0.3750260472,
0.5810651779,
0.0640217662,
0.2530984879,
-0.5348221064,
0.2350285798,
-0.3686801791,
-0.3599582016,
-0.5850301385,
-0.1672156751,
0.1945139021,
0.6404632926,
-0.1236394718,
0.1330619305,
-0.0796454996,
0.1010021493,
-0.2955814898,
0.8461289406,
-0.5573116541,
-0.2585194111,
0.2512938976,
0.0553154238,
-0.344281882,
0.3173337579,
0.2843915224,
-0.9079337716,
0.2390601635,
0.1401141584,
0.5527985096,
0.3127369583,
-0.2414025217,
-0.1555179805,
-0.4957411289,
0.7561483383,
-0.6967599392,
0.366325587,
0.5791631937,
0.1623769999,
-0.3287860453,
-0.3960180581,
-0.6583744287,
-0.4083276093,
-0.0154443393,
0.1075559035,
-0.2360004783,
0.3995858133,
0.1736710966,
-0.065977186,
-0.3164241016,
0.0228899028,
-0.3940375149,
-0.2277948707,
0.6604412198,
0.411036998,
0.7327066064,
-0.2154024243,
-0.022503512,
0.012473966,
-0.0945421085,
0.2742200792,
0.1270285398,
0.6491405964,
-0.2110747397,
0.6181149483,
-0.1692357957,
0.9538567066,
-0.0878709331,
-0.044795543,
0.0600581653,
-0.6979371309,
-0.4464093745,
-0.2869315743,
0.0971934274,
0.4989768267,
0.2078153342,
-0.4028215706,
-0.0289133135,
0.4488256276,
0.7422155142,
-0.3681395948,
-0.0670958459,
0.4428777993,
-0.578268826,
-0.4757407308,
-0.0719858855,
-0.3177894056,
-0.6195411086,
-0.7938848734,
0.3936507106,
-0.2243087292,
-0.8997753263,
0.0808720142,
-0.4866439998,
0.0387379937,
0.5673496723,
-0.5548258424,
0.6296003461,
0.7476452589,
0.7701491714,
0.0479812473,
-0.4504111707,
-0.5418736935,
0.2878046036,
-0.086392276,
0.6722112298,
-0.8177261949,
-0.5520871282,
-0.19779405,
0.0012678227,
-0.0673289523,
-0.5644083619,
0.115349181,
-0.1803135425,
0.2740480304,
-0.0408785269,
-0.1597437412,
-0.2337296307,
0.4865182042,
-0.6399064064,
0.7903079391,
0.4414213896,
-0.3432637155,
-0.1372196227,
-0.9534671903,
-0.1482227594,
0.1143493205,
-0.0074705947,
0.065681614,
0.3992140889,
0.1837480813,
0.3396589756,
-0.2131197751,
0.1363366544,
-0.1522040218,
-0.369405508,
0.222957164,
-0.0943855643,
0.6202067733,
0.2434680462,
-0.3409219384,
0.5202850699,
-0.4744178057,
0.1176083609,
0.0396859087,
0.0084681464,
-0.4698089063,
0.1306965798,
0.1191937923,
0.320717454,
0.1351809204,
-0.1887559444,
0.4862178266,
-0.4365855157,
0.1171008795,
0.8709208369,
-0.2538328171,
0.5720916986,
-0.4044100046,
0.7610625625,
-0.0061286697,
0.058929272,
-0.0898765624,
-0.3393449187,
-0.4023778141,
-0.3300378025,
-0.0822006464,
0.7243754864,
-1.0975122452,
-0.0575195216,
-0.2722488344,
-0.3159891963,
-0.635640204,
0.241831407,
0.6836003661,
0.4483993948,
0.2527946532,
-0.4615882337,
-0.5951138139,
-0.538515687,
-0.0472151376,
-0.543863833,
0.0247988664,
0.5872451663,
0.0369236581,
-0.3054772019,
1.00761199,
-0.0833983198,
0.029828934,
-0.626226306,
0.1693844497,
0.0868979096,
0.3302278221,
0.4071351588,
-0.9511324167,
-0.4920706749,
0.2791160941,
-0.9052981138,
-0.1977842003,
-0.2281771898,
-0.185566321,
-0.0262521133,
0.499738425,
-0.6220103502,
0.4008132517,
0.5665796399,
-0.6448125243,
0.4228410423,
-0.2147466391,
0.2667732239,
-1.1181571484,
-0.373647064,
0.1102032736,
-0.378279388,
-0.9960591197,
0.255029887,
-0.266811341,
-0.1285466105,
-0.5340445042,
0.7268317342,
-0.8907283545,
0.0796841457,
-0.6428819895,
0.3554017246,
-0.1923885494,
0.5707080364,
0.1499829292,
0.8853994608,
0.7755230069,
-0.4461406469,
0.6681272388,
0.252908349,
-0.1373324245,
0.76368922,
-0.8489006162,
0.2746055126,
-0.3997129798,
0.0318103209,
-0.9174003005,
-0.2293654978,
0.2633900344,
-0.5063029528,
-0.1407980025,
-0.2762658894,
-0.4635304213,
-0.4053811431,
-0.0329064503,
0.2733541727,
0.2266869396,
-0.1669804901,
0.9317551255,
0.545220077,
-0.1953585148,
-0.4972673953,
-0.3832236528,
0.057579495,
-0.0989991203,
-0.6974701881,
0.1746355444,
-0.0713032335,
-0.9732303619,
0.1378333867,
-0.0742288455,
-0.408605516,
0.3506864905,
0.7128533721,
0.2787470222,
-0.1633237451,
0.3657754362,
-0.2909199893,
-0.0276143067,
0.0998402908,
-0.0942260027,
0.4742304981,
-0.1504642516,
-0.299492687,
-0.5721088052,
0.4930362105,
0.7231174707,
-0.4418829978,
1.1034394503,
0.4234023988,
-0.4386309683,
-0.2112342864,
-0.5314869285,
-0.1357788295,
-0.5263577104,
0.5314279199,
-0.7666264176,
-0.7189285159,
0.6383990049,
-0.2290690541,
0.0731385127,
0.1325636655,
0.5596297383,
-0.1329336017,
1.1261171103,
0.8087314963,
-0.2914524376,
0.6758722067,
-0.1400221586,
0.1717835367,
-0.6570478082,
-0.2385089695,
-0.3376618624,
-0.1576699764,
-0.2126914412,
-0.7548078299,
0.1878581643,
-0.0630580559,
0.1443275511,
0.5119290948,
-0.4455664456,
0.4098461568,
0.2610217035,
0.2605505288,
0.1410043091,
-0.0400898419,
0.2167772353,
0.2936302125,
-0.5485856533,
-0.5245863795,
0.7271526456,
0.1917386651,
0.5201321244,
0.4426151216,
0.3120427132,
0.5424950719,
0.4082151949,
-0.5585180521,
0.4434166253,
0.5796202421,
-0.6524947882,
-0.6231902242,
-0.2763178647,
-1.1968624592,
0.6720340252,
-0.2895281315,
-0.8437721133,
-0.0818455145,
0.0736935437,
-0.2321811467,
-0.0347691178,
-1.0479136705,
1.10384655,
-0.0398382954,
-0.429118067,
-0.6400393844,
-0.4620083869,
-0.0582237244,
0.3841755092,
0.6150170565,
-0.232602194,
0.1242191121,
-0.086462453,
-0.3179342151,
1.0124306679,
-0.4054283202,
-0.0440657772,
0.480679065,
0.1675567925,
0.7289370298,
0.002647734,
-0.4558729231,
-0.2921828926,
0.0084147081,
-0.7370123863,
-0.836709857,
0.616414845,
-0.9814355969,
-0.8022359014,
0.0143789724,
-1.0792738199,
-0.2300992608,
-0.1239576489,
-0.530613482,
0.6938044429,
-0.4338804185,
0.0081292065,
0.4103932381,
-0.0212768335,
0.4172956049,
0.5270402431,
-0.0105136177,
0.0970155373,
0.9301103354,
-0.1143825799,
0.4192024171,
-0.0436933972,
-0.1609020978,
-0.1697712094,
-0.410969615,
-0.4069210589,
-0.0483818538,
-0.5173394084,
0.030396603,
-0.8511462808,
0.0490738489,
-0.7273845673,
-0.3078032434,
-0.0749998316,
-0.2932694256,
-0.2128797621,
-0.4299467504,
0.1737222522,
0.9873698354,
0.0402195714,
0.4575793147,
-0.8622760773,
0.5034159422,
0.3127995431,
0.098643966,
0.1668451577,
-0.2179650366,
-0.5067452192,
0.1247398183,
-0.0871358588,
-1.0888299942,
0.3390448093,
-0.0913968012,
1.2282599211,
-0.0750336349,
-0.0299436338,
0.757689476,
-0.3054741621,
0.8824371696,
-0.1491058171,
-1.1621545553,
0.6134752631,
-0.6089197397,
0.6093062758,
0.3918602169,
-0.0532920398,
-0.6663081646,
-0.5442473292,
-0.7753435373,
-0.6494563818,
0.7510929108,
0.3029454947,
0.3971901238,
0.1475043446,
0.294882983,
-0.1421029419,
0.3512708545,
-0.6157191992,
-0.1620215774,
-0.1240333989,
-0.3452447057,
-0.0057534543,
0.0064670588,
-0.2262366563,
-0.3193414509,
0.4580521584,
-0.1737653464,
0.3426459432,
0.0142645435,
-0.4989043176,
-0.1003300622,
0.1977876872,
0.5609585047,
1.0945829153,
0.2773630917,
0.231473878,
0.4819938838,
-0.1723691374,
0.1861462295,
0.0597416349,
0.4276326001,
-0.3055196702,
0.5161747932,
0.7712609768,
-0.295116365,
-0.8794152141,
0.4051587284,
-0.1379295141,
0.120641917,
-0.0370224752,
0.3923526108,
0.1238576919,
0.5702784657,
0.1616192609,
-0.0331223384,
0.1187113747,
-0.8338101506,
0.0864678472,
0.437215358,
-0.4282931089,
-0.4465370774,
0.4034045041,
0.506717205,
-0.610249877,
0.7929007411,
-0.0919172615,
-0.4457954466,
0.9925708771,
0.6150150895,
0.6448533535,
-0.337951988,
0.4449002445,
0.036869958,
0.3873978853,
0.0775345862,
0.4498768449,
-0.2292232066,
-0.9051308036,
-0.5676797032,
-0.1294059753,
-0.5181761384,
-0.2633838952,
-0.34842062,
-0.1428274959,
-0.2490972131,
-0.2091700733,
-0.207642287,
0.0027867241,
-0.9843894243,
0.1626907438,
0.2773523629,
0.4383349121,
-0.8823800683,
0.8998123407,
1.0526846647,
-0.3419581652,
-0.7431976795,
-0.1968993843,
0.2851754725,
-0.4762603641,
0.5422791839,
0.0425401889,
-0.2988957763,
-0.008664161,
-0.7317616343,
-0.7320867777,
0.8983371258,
0.1751908064,
-0.1313993037,
-0.0192104783,
-0.0214866232,
0.9037125707,
-0.3620607257,
0.5464945436,
0.2734477222,
0.6595445871,
-0.4700710177,
-1.3669885397,
0.0748263299,
-0.7001555562,
0.1377645135,
-0.0502473488,
-0.6696978211,
0.4054534137,
-0.1097304747,
-0.0885483623,
-0.0606407039,
0.9110863209,
0.1350210309,
0.4076740146,
0.8589619398,
0.1248243526,
0.7819250226,
0.0382211767,
1.238841176,
-0.1958328933,
0.0380605161,
1.1837756634,
-0.0426137522,
0.4839282334,
0.5050438046,
-0.0154477945,
0.536359787,
0.4643928409,
0.3338034451,
0.3772206903,
0.493157208,
-0.4767899513,
-0.4224793911,
-0.7335264683,
-0.1757081449,
0.4937871397,
0.4914149344,
0.0560546927,
0.0949280187,
0.4473712444,
-0.1384617984,
0.3430608511,
-0.2329429984,
0.9925608039,
-0.2211723626,
-0.6447826028,
0.1129589304,
-0.1190621853,
0.410676688,
-0.2387633771,
-0.2767707705,
0.0370661579,
0.004197605,
-0.1452103108,
-0.4217386842,
0.3513557613,
-0.154603973,
-0.4114277065,
-0.5116442442,
0.7046835423,
-0.5649733543,
-0.3447733223,
0.2871844172,
0.8891584277,
0.0751783103,
-0.2631577849,
-0.7086231709,
0.3400568962,
-0.1700481325,
-0.17931436,
0.0610898398,
0.5284910202,
-0.2569117844,
0.7502804995,
0.6528244615,
-0.0852340385,
0.0874794871,
0.1519144028,
1.02412498,
-0.4281196892,
-0.3095264137,
-0.6278681755,
0.9113084078,
-0.3320772052,
0.0686302856,
0.7916556001,
0.2476214767,
0.9077684283,
-0.147375688,
0.9221283197,
-0.2643612325,
0.3075206876,
-0.1628094465,
0.3049245179,
-0.4791609943,
0.0222115144,
-0.2061722577,
-0.8533063531,
-0.0985040441,
0.7099183202,
-0.0775921494,
-0.1573738307,
0.319316119,
0.8685762882,
-0.1486196071,
-0.2189721167,
0.5031093955,
0.1950774789,
0.5666192174,
0.2506776452,
1.0462468863,
-0.0691134781,
0.3523430824,
-0.1313200891,
-0.1574256271,
0.0713615268,
-0.520108223,
-1.154201746,
-0.6307774186,
-0.2537149191,
-0.2196907848,
0.3828135729,
1.2668944597,
1.0228918791,
-0.6674565673,
-0.4983213246,
0.0152055193,
0.2266275287,
-0.7061405778,
-0.2157129794,
-0.1415320337,
-0.470512569,
-1.0385005474,
0.8941635489,
0.1402016878,
-0.0717764869,
-0.2644763887,
-0.2457554191,
-0.1454105228,
0.2024215311,
0.6882701516,
0.087052308,
-0.9664991498,
-0.4401434958,
0.1723411679,
-0.2560088634,
-0.1110248864,
0.8616076708,
-0.8765993118,
0.8722985983,
0.7432230711,
0.7678037882,
0.1894219071,
0.5594847798,
1.0069330931,
-0.7077870369,
0.3982748091,
-0.074571833,
0.0375481471,
0.2242850065,
-0.6811489463,
0.6670383215,
0.1907155216,
-0.4223122895,
-0.6718208194,
-0.1054080427,
-0.9065838456,
-0.437823683,
0.9454544187,
-0.0573476031,
-0.1824175417,
-0.5745384693,
-0.762678206,
0.3988488317,
-0.3139169812,
0.8258383274,
0.9982041717,
-0.1699946076,
-0.6381549835,
-0.7734318972,
0.2895674109,
0.5750710964,
-1.1858856678,
0.1195566729,
0.9792916775,
-0.1551878303,
0.1149811223,
0.7692102194,
0.4198865891,
0.2315218151,
-0.0416369401,
0.1677488536,
-0.4452036917,
-0.3933404386,
-0.1034306288,
0.1589272916,
0.0878405795,
-0.22337614
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05435v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05435v1
|
GPT-4 Generated Narratives of Life Events using a Structured Narrative Prompt: A Validation Study
| 2024-02-08T06:20:01 | 2024-02-08T06:20:01 |
Christopher J. Lynch, Erik Jensen, Madison H. Munro, Virginia Zamponi, Joseph Martinez, Kevin O'Brien, Brandon Feldhaus, Katherine Smith, Ann Marie Reinhold, Ross Gore
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7; I.6.4
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) play a pivotal role in generating vast arrays of
narratives, facilitating a systematic exploration of their effectiveness for
communicating life events in narrative form. In this study, we employ a
zero-shot structured narrative prompt to generate 24,000 narratives using
OpenAI's GPT-4. From this dataset, we manually classify 2,880 narratives and
evaluate their validity in conveying birth, death, hiring, and firing events.
Remarkably, 87.43% of the narratives sufficiently convey the intention of the
structured prompt. To automate the identification of valid and invalid
narratives, we train and validate nine Machine Learning models on the
classified datasets. Leveraging these models, we extend our analysis to predict
the classifications of the remaining 21,120 narratives. All the ML models
excelled at classifying valid narratives as valid, but experienced challenges
at simultaneously classifying invalid narratives as invalid. Our findings not
only advance the study of LLM capabilities, limitations, and validity but also
offer practical insights for narrative generation and natural language
processing applications.
|
[
0.1424827278,
-0.7523723245,
1.1599112749,
0.1692744792,
-0.1681096107,
-0.0897885263,
0.131800741,
-0.3550460935,
-0.2129478902,
0.2944329381,
-0.6787349582,
-0.6697285771,
-0.2760863602,
0.3932905197,
-0.283128351,
1.2055999041,
-0.3149034977,
-0.218114242,
-0.1533657908,
-0.022579791,
-0.5930056572,
-0.5266646147,
-0.4274964333,
-0.2401320189,
0.6794540882,
0.1225345582,
0.521361351,
0.6254428029,
0.1663582325,
0.1732936352,
0.1895717233,
0.2851301134,
-0.4098888338,
0.3820698559,
0.1988916397,
-0.3367381096,
-0.3372705877,
0.356703788,
0.546843946,
0.6182132363,
-0.0974156931,
0.2554911077,
0.0492835715,
0.2613225281,
-0.3863254786,
0.1064345166,
-0.3512917757,
0.3539320529,
-0.123228766,
-0.2217781693,
-0.5434682369,
-0.817473948,
0.0149418069,
-0.4389123917,
0.3201774955,
-0.0780178085,
0.9102793932,
0.0707827955,
-0.418969065,
-0.4890805483,
-0.9098357558,
0.578504324,
-0.7483597398,
-0.0536010824,
0.1829340905,
0.3161532283,
-0.2311832309,
-0.7973860502,
-0.6070863008,
-0.3048575222,
-0.0443223305,
0.1257828027,
-0.0892223418,
0.1173928678,
0.3658045828,
0.4238291681,
-1.054005146,
0.2760742009,
-0.3496131003,
-0.2629068494,
0.425871551,
0.6384337544,
0.5436899662,
-0.4491720498,
-0.2696792185,
0.2072840184,
-0.8265155554,
0.0296972618,
0.7228360772,
0.12881805,
-0.1761762202,
0.7306281924,
-0.2089665234,
0.6539170146,
-0.1195204556,
-0.5817485452,
0.2248921245,
-0.4200884104,
-0.1858988553,
0.1851658374,
0.9099192023,
0.6388289332,
0.4823436737,
-0.1359396726,
-0.1469655782,
0.1612249911,
0.2605966926,
-0.8693189025,
0.1873196065,
0.4137863815,
-0.4851538539,
-0.5335181952,
-0.2430617064,
-0.5241094828,
-0.5186488032,
-0.0292332396,
0.1308593154,
-0.3754143119,
0.2228444964,
0.1855642349,
-0.227035448,
0.3847411871,
0.5491471887,
-0.733697474,
-0.1939223111,
0.5471475124,
0.824539125,
-0.2587968111,
-0.1286109239,
-0.5510101914,
0.2049035728,
-0.3855140209,
0.7163054347,
-0.3836993575,
-0.2085842937,
0.1432188749,
-0.1150993332,
-0.0568987951,
-0.3962410092,
0.9868044853,
-0.4057582021,
0.4643343687,
0.0020962565,
-0.5650303364,
-0.0776323825,
0.5941887498,
-0.4562587738,
0.650676012,
0.0840854719,
-0.427549839,
0.5582394004,
-0.4633607864,
-0.3282875419,
0.3380648196,
-0.5243965387,
-0.4500562847,
0.0768745169,
0.1841706038,
0.5739905834,
-0.1369036734,
0.8756957054,
-0.0941294208,
-0.3399619162,
0.0386679769,
-0.6335501671,
0.5737751126,
0.3020184934,
-0.2911968827,
0.0744405463,
-0.7994045615,
-0.2319828123,
0.4173214734,
-0.5555209517,
0.2254808247,
-0.1628631502,
-0.1494716853,
0.0630078986,
-0.0773923323,
-0.8093068004,
0.4914261401,
-0.4124481678,
0.4059886336,
0.4153707623,
0.453967154,
0.1784684062,
-0.4802985489,
0.9376788735,
-0.0016524638,
0.0903080478,
-0.949637115,
-0.8641217351,
-0.2037369907,
0.1624368131,
0.0107201198,
0.6786745787,
-0.8475586772,
0.2778903544,
-0.151074633,
-0.3769325912,
-0.1027379036,
-0.2476399243,
0.0793901309,
0.9508553743,
0.1973982751,
0.112944074,
-0.6636311412,
-0.6796104312,
-0.288720727,
-0.3897204101,
-0.2727009356,
0.060804978,
0.3384066224,
-0.2579133809,
1.1212713718,
-0.3880769014,
0.0147474185,
-0.4498608708,
0.3907046914,
0.4162319303,
0.2823642194,
0.6706682444,
-0.7036213875,
-0.2323070765,
-0.2589919567,
-1.1658447981,
-0.1338510513,
-0.5465114713,
0.3460826874,
0.3222454488,
0.0479408391,
-0.6389638186,
0.7734616399,
0.4177547395,
-0.4208509624,
0.9648211598,
-0.2639162242,
0.1883175373,
-0.7902984023,
-0.0586758517,
-0.0156964455,
-0.321387291,
-0.5907853246,
-0.3225424588,
0.0319316387,
-0.2990216315,
-0.4117455781,
0.7223175168,
-0.2836904824,
0.0621410571,
-0.0915672779,
0.2126334757,
0.0260208473,
0.4264788032,
-0.0127971917,
0.5421421528,
0.116032809,
-0.4345806539,
0.5457988381,
0.5491218567,
-0.4699768722,
0.4230174124,
-0.5384829044,
0.0028633217,
-0.2184475064,
0.6967845559,
-1.0202089548,
-0.625677824,
0.3702293634,
-0.442909658,
-0.0103793954,
-0.0894546658,
-0.7193953395,
-0.3578546941,
-0.2313456088,
0.2343758047,
0.5628447533,
-0.3194869459,
0.7054010034,
0.0002418301,
-0.3666560054,
-0.1799762398,
-0.7253363132,
0.3970387578,
-0.4122032821,
-0.6464582682,
0.1264017969,
-0.2698452771,
-0.0580043793,
-0.1597049981,
0.0708269775,
0.0055757514,
-0.1035707965,
0.5106938481,
0.4425537586,
-0.3352117538,
-0.1427239776,
0.0205611903,
-0.2870740891,
-0.0367302559,
-0.2620973289,
0.3822740912,
0.2329297364,
-0.4825062156,
-0.3634598255,
0.2431031913,
0.4329076707,
0.191623643,
0.7967244387,
0.5491948724,
-0.4796874225,
0.109555915,
-0.5069637895,
0.3014988005,
-0.3930194974,
-0.1198388115,
-0.1284722537,
-1.0320181847,
0.5037865639,
0.122106947,
0.2458709627,
0.4477683902,
0.6425846815,
0.1190063432,
0.9826207161,
0.2579019368,
0.1083541289,
0.1362786591,
0.2355599701,
0.3261642158,
-0.4819974303,
-0.1267929822,
-0.3059931695,
-0.0450623967,
-0.4052481651,
-0.0943808705,
0.6128047705,
0.0442093089,
-0.3614426851,
-0.0435070768,
-0.3061933815,
0.6274625659,
0.3610837162,
-0.1752821654,
0.6426371932,
-0.1814136952,
-0.3053829074,
-0.0209895372,
-0.5065544248,
-1.0941220522,
0.9559092522,
0.4518130124,
0.4524743855,
0.0100756148,
0.7011983395,
0.2870253325,
0.4379597306,
-0.3269485235,
0.3747147322,
0.1184228808,
-0.601123929,
-0.2895612717,
-0.389514327,
-0.9933965206,
-0.1574525982,
0.0475417934,
-0.8489687443,
-0.0324301012,
-0.0645006299,
-1.0343410969,
0.0926021114,
-0.7080497146,
0.9120729566,
-0.4325740039,
0.032779105,
0.4057657421,
-0.7258891463,
0.5358514786,
-0.3378144503,
0.1635059863,
-0.0910289958,
0.0758762881,
0.4566097856,
-0.3964784443,
0.9811682701,
-0.1388666183,
-0.1429679394,
0.5618474483,
0.123188071,
0.6064360142,
0.09503223,
-0.2452100217,
0.0075331577,
-0.0998936072,
-0.1600743234,
-0.3500550091,
0.4316475093,
-0.5178664327,
-0.3978290558,
-0.2857705355,
-0.4772758782,
-0.2347377539,
0.130835101,
0.3128720522,
0.6875865459,
-0.3438281715,
-0.0040346459,
0.328561604,
-0.7616559863,
0.6564108133,
0.432340771,
-0.4018752277,
-0.3817850947,
0.5812382102,
0.2008296847,
0.1999381334,
0.0829792544,
0.1815610528,
-0.1986884922,
-0.8808008432,
-0.8088764548,
0.2219488472,
-0.702342689,
-0.3474017084,
-0.8165907264,
-0.2950116694,
-0.4269801676,
-0.2620217502,
0.0998855233,
-0.1377136558,
-0.3834286928,
-0.7411987185,
0.0428432524,
0.9660927653,
0.0086079752,
0.1364617348,
-1.1875269413,
0.4636503458,
0.0932063311,
0.1912784129,
-0.2829916775,
-0.4493189454,
0.0886237696,
-0.0924959555,
-0.4923045337,
-0.9850601554,
0.5540403724,
0.0869689584,
0.5272216797,
0.394829005,
0.1829627007,
0.4712353945,
-0.8648962975,
1.2963380814,
0.053141091,
-0.6292824149,
0.779697299,
-1.0339539051,
0.4194678366,
0.2790213227,
0.6354396939,
-0.4537001848,
-0.378433764,
-0.7609864473,
-0.7377988696,
0.6710990667,
0.4516319036,
0.2559146583,
-0.1588506103,
0.7222496867,
0.3189354539,
0.1311879605,
-0.8886144161,
-0.2370132506,
0.0085917581,
-0.4126676321,
-0.0058081602,
-0.4969443083,
0.1577148438,
0.0908156335,
0.3652268946,
-0.1749424785,
0.087741673,
0.1611344516,
0.0143953916,
-0.2721106708,
0.1617238522,
0.7741088271,
0.6272150278,
-0.1196181625,
-0.0658866763,
0.167326346,
-0.3928912282,
0.2537021041,
0.070513241,
-0.3400564492,
0.0289946813,
0.6291543245,
0.9113310575,
0.1020991802,
-0.8393618464,
0.6629617214,
-0.3854041398,
-0.3159600496,
-0.3389975131,
0.2041961551,
0.0499590524,
0.2717468739,
0.3986715078,
-0.2543030083,
-0.0241215508,
-0.6404178143,
0.0426693447,
-0.0007637059,
-0.0988015458,
-0.4616619349,
0.7023831606,
0.0777508914,
-0.2409770638,
0.7848243117,
-0.3721265793,
-0.3408162296,
0.5306938291,
0.4749755263,
0.8959021568,
-0.1338293999,
0.4788696766,
0.4582290649,
0.3048292696,
-0.008462213,
-0.0537213981,
0.108068727,
-0.9298112988,
-0.6607034802,
-1.0734423399,
-0.6030503511,
0.5582748055,
-0.3792948723,
0.2029340714,
-0.1453056335,
0.1521889865,
-0.1777818799,
-0.2899618447,
-0.5999663472,
0.2149114013,
0.6475765109,
0.7355511785,
-1.022387743,
0.5311686397,
0.394290328,
-0.7085232139,
-0.9425980449,
0.0460878387,
0.1580068618,
-0.5792079568,
0.5130891204,
0.4025826454,
0.2906225324,
0.0218041744,
-0.5966008902,
-0.4931381345,
1.2205181122,
0.4834180176,
-0.4487796128,
-0.4224330187,
0.4588020444,
0.7236410379,
-0.5658909678,
0.3175450265,
0.3826345205,
0.574847281,
0.3780766726,
-0.9285761714,
-0.0587777719,
0.025562698,
-0.0566109754,
-0.1322809458,
-0.1686362475,
0.6211567521,
-0.2995916009,
-0.5482265353,
0.2805404961,
0.6447652578,
0.6741932631,
0.6645298004,
0.282789737,
0.3635210097,
0.8390377164,
-0.15307495,
1.3543101549,
0.0612838119,
0.1436989903,
0.9609136581,
-0.5724654794,
0.3129405379,
-0.1077391431,
-0.033316344,
0.7003591061,
0.8450616002,
0.1157315597,
0.1293763816,
0.029966088,
-0.3440652192,
-0.2391554713,
0.0136253452,
-0.0762577802,
0.2974063754,
0.1619867086,
-0.3550799191,
-0.4504432082,
0.3666942418,
-0.0180741455,
-0.1493427306,
-0.2234324515,
0.7781858444,
0.0971826389,
-0.8094052076,
0.2262931913,
-0.0460461229,
0.3194355965,
-0.5366744399,
-0.2453477085,
-0.2013153583,
-0.112875551,
-0.1547814608,
-0.8113968372,
0.3633823693,
0.467553407,
-0.2013263404,
-0.6311026216,
0.9221766591,
-0.2144839913,
-0.3160698414,
-0.2621830702,
0.5881279707,
0.3373849988,
-0.2765604854,
-0.3121004701,
0.1444514543,
0.1157889813,
-0.437961936,
0.2385674268,
0.747361362,
-0.1724111736,
0.3871070445,
0.6227630377,
-0.0165816508,
0.0271647442,
0.1106866822,
0.6225891113,
-0.9750965834,
-0.6543912888,
-1.0594110489,
0.7919929624,
0.1720424145,
-0.293437928,
0.6904885173,
0.5883745551,
0.4019281566,
-0.0319260918,
0.9656218886,
0.2589216232,
0.7109322548,
-0.6020410657,
0.4260246754,
-0.0123864403,
0.1857022792,
-0.1027791128,
-0.7047683597,
-0.4320864081,
0.3468709886,
-0.5179945827,
0.2875936329,
0.651859045,
0.4208607376,
0.3434430659,
0.217298612,
0.4384242892,
0.1210646555,
0.5211071372,
0.4703992009,
1.1773309708,
-0.3124823868,
0.5278052092,
0.4105994105,
-0.1350346506,
-0.1362193823,
-1.2358769178,
-0.7497653961,
-0.4301679134,
-0.3246943653,
-0.1204896495,
-0.0146838753,
0.5673909187,
0.368868649,
-0.5122044683,
0.2794116735,
-0.0970052853,
-0.1647272855,
0.4544929862,
-0.2887051702,
-0.0080002081,
-0.3785323203,
-0.4487429857,
0.6745954156,
0.6424898505,
0.1226790845,
-0.2300285548,
-0.1783206314,
0.074234359,
0.0851005912,
0.5195178986,
0.1112771928,
-0.6611943841,
-0.4831668139,
-0.2514970005,
-0.2105562985,
0.1164597124,
0.9000046253,
-1.0898592472,
0.0804569572,
0.3223252892,
0.6309335828,
0.3818220794,
0.2119104862,
0.7642176747,
-0.9112783074,
-0.2726963758,
0.3361082971,
0.4414767623,
0.2901621163,
-0.636700809,
0.6338374615,
0.3105515838,
-0.8423596621,
-0.9134348035,
0.2863036096,
-0.9218531251,
-0.1353844702,
1.3754047155,
-0.2609780729,
-0.1347353756,
-0.2655728459,
-0.3311672509,
0.1603441536,
-0.1541661769,
0.4052135348,
0.8381745815,
-0.4588252008,
-0.221866399,
-0.8741473556,
0.3620017469,
-0.0983190909,
-1.070306778,
-0.0609434396,
0.876652956,
0.2062042952,
0.1102505848,
0.7860859036,
-0.0628188923,
0.1947888583,
-0.202851668,
-0.0703707039,
-0.3285508752,
-0.2556385398,
-0.4215397537,
0.4443185031,
-0.1148731261,
0.2017154843
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05406v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05406v2
|
Everybody Prune Now: Structured Pruning of LLMs with only Forward Passes
| 2024-02-08T04:48:26 | 2024-02-09T19:53:56 |
Lucio Dery, Steven Kolawole, Jean-François Kagy, Virginia Smith, Graham Neubig, Ameet Talwalkar
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Given the generational gap in available hardware between lay practitioners
and the most endowed institutions, LLMs are becoming increasingly inaccessible
as they grow in size. Whilst many approaches have been proposed to compress
LLMs to make their resource consumption manageable, these methods themselves
tend to be resource intensive, putting them out of the reach of the very user
groups they target. In this work, we explore the problem of structured pruning
of LLMs using only forward passes. We seek to empower practitioners to prune
models so large that their available hardware has just enough memory to run
inference. We develop Bonsai, a gradient-free, perturbative pruning method
capable of delivering small, fast, and accurate pruned models.
We observe that Bonsai outputs pruned models that (i) outperform those
generated by more expensive gradient-based structured pruning methods, and (ii)
are twice as fast (with comparable accuracy) as those generated by
semi-structured pruning methods requiring comparable resources as Bonsai. We
also leverage Bonsai to produce a new sub-2B model using a single A6000 that
yields state-of-the-art performance on 4/6 tasks on the Huggingface Open LLM
leaderboard.
|
[
-0.2630107999,
-0.779170692,
0.5549641848,
0.6224454045,
-0.5736700892,
-0.1985951215,
-0.1677749455,
-0.4791041017,
0.1981199533,
0.5727797747,
-0.9847855568,
-0.4427886307,
-0.1722687781,
-0.081087254,
-0.4707207084,
0.8667060137,
0.140418753,
-0.0303522926,
-0.3298868835,
-0.0941196084,
-0.3563966155,
-0.5462026,
-0.4659268856,
-0.4865118861,
0.6192827821,
0.3979209363,
0.5390255451,
0.5550082922,
0.3107447922,
0.2247041017,
-0.3751725852,
0.1622813195,
-0.5459957719,
0.0983217284,
-0.0524434708,
-0.6375979185,
-0.713490963,
-0.0460779071,
0.6867627501,
0.7112277746,
-0.3272967339,
0.3174310923,
0.1317309737,
0.6623625159,
-0.5474467874,
-0.207342416,
-0.7498819828,
0.137985006,
-0.372173667,
-0.3931301832,
-0.4348791838,
-0.4591931999,
-0.4304992259,
-0.6828783751,
0.3656055033,
-0.0959791169,
0.7803023458,
0.4401781261,
-0.1413113326,
0.3821052909,
-0.7821070552,
0.7719889283,
-0.371299535,
0.230300203,
0.0037056813,
0.301314652,
-0.2006000578,
-0.7546181679,
0.021863075,
-0.1033678651,
0.0390275456,
0.0417542383,
0.069675222,
0.2869177461,
0.1369662583,
0.3002550304,
-0.1996554434,
0.2894723713,
-0.4657980502,
-0.0925455242,
0.8425358534,
0.0946504474,
-0.1403696388,
0.0160720777,
-0.785212934,
-0.0101246471,
-1.0675222874,
-0.1699320078,
0.2315765768,
-0.1769208759,
0.3680499792,
0.4748544693,
0.2149713188,
0.824772656,
-0.2996506095,
-0.2843281627,
-0.4041278958,
-0.1735734195,
-0.6223466396,
-0.1755706072,
0.4944600463,
0.420298785,
0.4994853735,
-0.0629101098,
-0.2165220529,
0.023508532,
0.1026495472,
-1.0099278688,
-0.7925763726,
0.2684009373,
-0.4390720725,
-0.217793867,
-0.2104680985,
-0.6620742083,
-0.198972851,
-0.1094535813,
0.0515397191,
-0.0480710231,
-0.2922810018,
-0.0623501539,
-0.0974580422,
0.138205424,
0.8794127107,
-0.5348139405,
0.5746661425,
0.8890417814,
1.0655044317,
0.1082120538,
-0.0178407189,
-0.3273571134,
0.2652346194,
-0.4423552454,
0.5829234123,
-0.4014077485,
-0.9715894461,
-0.5561899543,
-0.0115619395,
0.0337803029,
-0.7166317105,
0.4715837836,
-0.4436757863,
-0.2975497842,
-0.1092425734,
-0.3913217783,
-0.276370585,
0.2419417202,
-0.5307422876,
0.6477112174,
-0.0415911637,
-0.4975844324,
0.043256823,
-0.401584208,
-0.4483554065,
0.1409263909,
-0.3420457542,
-0.6549288034,
0.3251674175,
-0.0024929126,
0.5189805031,
-0.2961132526,
0.5524682999,
-0.5252842903,
-0.6066120863,
-0.1790627986,
-0.5401538014,
0.9392272234,
0.092316553,
0.116102092,
0.2434371561,
-0.411952734,
0.1287204772,
0.2792045772,
-0.3776207268,
-0.1367837936,
-0.1400550306,
0.0459818952,
0.1638307422,
0.2158399969,
-0.5931959152,
0.4393420815,
-0.2254247218,
0.6331937313,
1.1290217638,
0.2209484577,
0.3706353605,
-0.556458354,
0.6376956701,
-0.0304698944,
0.3953488469,
-0.1561796963,
-0.6493917704,
-0.5400835872,
-0.4365985394,
0.395476222,
0.376270771,
-0.0742544681,
0.3030802608,
-0.1628062278,
-0.5935268402,
-0.4087189734,
0.2620798945,
0.3194070458,
0.4631542563,
0.2479193956,
-0.541302979,
-0.4058776498,
-1.0587512255,
-0.247857064,
-0.0883678421,
-0.3889839649,
0.536709547,
0.3963192403,
0.2428735942,
0.7877462506,
-0.5848093033,
-0.4834347367,
0.0940962881,
-0.1188927218,
0.1193010062,
0.8116466403,
0.1642493159,
-0.8717429638,
0.0181202721,
-0.2138573527,
-0.5624182224,
0.1779700965,
-0.323240906,
-0.0959266797,
-0.0021290819,
0.367506057,
-0.8135476112,
0.5885643363,
0.4782230854,
-0.1563437283,
0.639539063,
-0.420121938,
-0.4850606322,
-0.5786550641,
0.2409138381,
0.1644067466,
-0.4132785499,
-0.1435010284,
0.1011187732,
0.0931969583,
-0.1981344521,
-0.5181516409,
0.5664426684,
-0.7446588874,
-0.5486192703,
0.0542922132,
-0.0088003185,
0.2678790689,
0.6875402927,
0.0974242613,
0.5129597783,
0.3309091926,
-0.8285571933,
0.1721275151,
0.1557939649,
-0.3125351965,
0.4245774746,
-0.8330494761,
0.0793058723,
-0.1859951168,
0.803725481,
-0.5976437926,
-0.1251322627,
0.3908087611,
-0.1009054855,
0.5509712696,
-0.2321018577,
-0.21089378,
-0.2414764613,
-0.2275057584,
0.2268755883,
0.6657270193,
-0.4410326779,
0.5787189603,
0.1856943071,
-0.1276502162,
-0.288441956,
-0.8597009182,
0.0633990839,
-0.241499573,
-0.7073252797,
0.624237299,
-0.2175876051,
-0.2872995436,
0.0228263997,
-0.5926920176,
-0.0193471778,
0.6723157167,
0.3763706088,
0.2474864721,
0.0059317052,
-0.0912124664,
-0.045576416,
-0.0462188646,
0.0509888418,
-0.5635862947,
0.1990311444,
0.0629865006,
-0.5941433311,
-0.6135331988,
0.33217296,
0.4550978839,
-0.3435896635,
0.4765870571,
0.251383543,
-0.2417707741,
-0.442135781,
-0.3444038928,
-0.4508804679,
-0.4391043484,
0.4008282125,
-0.5381082892,
-0.7199829817,
0.0440934598,
-0.4883152246,
0.7924588323,
0.1069900915,
0.2959367633,
-0.1013022214,
0.7488113046,
0.5770530701,
0.1929747909,
0.3042056262,
-0.4860799611,
0.0938676745,
-0.901681602,
-0.5173415542,
-0.4701448977,
-0.723064959,
-0.2886165082,
-0.6768519878,
0.4036847949,
0.4870601594,
-0.1782986075,
-0.0364952795,
-0.7635500431,
0.5720124841,
0.5467393398,
0.4421385527,
0.4743955731,
-0.0128367431,
0.3455430269,
0.2008975744,
-1.027354002,
-0.4472408891,
0.7842955589,
0.4627427757,
0.6465734839,
-0.2056211233,
0.7215695381,
0.0566494092,
0.9508416653,
-0.7799493074,
0.8888221979,
-0.0090635279,
-0.7708708048,
-0.1985896379,
-0.4779451489,
-0.7568272352,
0.4906055927,
0.3186300993,
-0.586520493,
0.3168634772,
0.3902955055,
-0.4824109674,
0.6815850735,
-0.4352979958,
0.4872814119,
-0.3030954599,
-0.5629836917,
-0.2979738414,
-0.7476375699,
0.8598265648,
-0.0972059518,
0.1726430655,
-0.4018139243,
-0.3945883811,
0.8175793886,
-0.6825507283,
0.9457119107,
-0.4917098582,
0.0066767423,
0.301597178,
0.389002949,
0.5437753201,
0.0442177095,
-0.0067107249,
0.2776347399,
-0.1524410397,
-0.7034805417,
-0.5961768031,
0.6965296268,
-0.4809884429,
-1.0071377754,
-0.166359365,
-0.3687461019,
-0.0569613315,
-0.097506471,
0.0650263876,
0.328500092,
-0.1407809556,
0.2238003016,
0.5946977139,
0.1677712351,
0.4513637125,
0.3851128519,
-0.08020401,
-0.1873536259,
0.8570918441,
0.3010860682,
0.0102430815,
0.125083372,
0.1142853126,
-0.100166142,
-0.6452991366,
-0.4548121989,
0.2741884589,
-0.5179265738,
-0.3616125286,
-0.5748456717,
-0.1519432068,
0.0846695378,
-0.2832101285,
-0.2927004695,
-0.7218202353,
-0.3754129112,
-0.0545924455,
0.3480605781,
0.7167381644,
-0.163315773,
0.4029394388,
-0.8140530586,
0.0715408772,
0.0647640079,
0.1308176666,
0.2310311347,
-0.2719085217,
0.0974469781,
-0.1121850833,
-0.5306705832,
-0.7370396256,
0.4196462035,
0.4498882294,
0.2659236491,
0.4137940109,
0.0721526295,
0.778398931,
-0.4541336894,
0.5166143775,
0.2831217647,
-0.5460879207,
0.4086810052,
-0.0687706918,
-0.001646513,
0.4125026762,
0.462964952,
-0.1905412078,
-0.0057809181,
-0.9359449148,
-0.8968731165,
0.5265068412,
0.0247808285,
-0.2695633769,
0.3778046072,
0.4659094512,
-0.0376206972,
0.3829858005,
-0.5121576786,
0.0137562575,
-0.029053418,
0.1166014224,
-0.1870621443,
-0.1359620541,
-0.3741941154,
-0.2555915713,
0.7449451685,
0.0020613014,
0.1362293214,
0.4033958912,
0.1418416649,
-0.1225890964,
0.1119798198,
0.1554217041,
0.7241860628,
-0.1967976689,
-0.1158113927,
-0.0494709015,
-0.0911966339,
0.4420873821,
0.0178189408,
-0.4685479701,
-0.0093521811,
0.1748398095,
0.5545895696,
0.556402266,
-0.4437691867,
0.3900071979,
-0.0483727865,
-0.4263793528,
-0.169105947,
0.194861725,
0.2451624125,
0.2335336357,
0.0359028503,
0.5288062692,
-0.1739404947,
-0.3022112846,
0.2059245706,
0.4393639266,
-0.1570487171,
-0.3446309865,
0.7601698041,
0.5235472322,
-0.5651253462,
0.8552480936,
0.2478672266,
-0.3584604263,
0.6297820807,
0.3843788505,
0.7595253587,
-0.0863366649,
0.0809043646,
0.1376464814,
0.2809126973,
-0.2578314841,
0.1786714196,
-0.8014076352,
-0.1809225678,
-0.6172842979,
-0.9040054679,
-0.6540004015,
-0.1440517604,
-0.6130517125,
-0.0088245748,
-0.9733780026,
0.0176873766,
-0.332826376,
0.2873632014,
-0.4822681248,
0.2819870412,
-0.1766091287,
1.4313993454,
-0.773948729,
1.0035339594,
0.6068109274,
0.0102372207,
-0.6913343072,
-0.2364770919,
-0.0330119915,
-0.6671431065,
0.3399404883,
0.2995298207,
-0.0073768753,
0.2504820526,
-0.7023809552,
-0.4860502481,
1.2105077505,
0.4713804126,
-1.0820100307,
-0.5491800308,
-0.5651580095,
0.0127707478,
0.1557316184,
0.0931050479,
0.5821874738,
0.6992737651,
0.4042938054,
-0.3415408134,
-0.0460985489,
-0.1620230824,
0.0063379346,
0.389354825,
-0.9996227622,
0.9033734202,
-0.2151240259,
-0.3149905503,
0.2981771529,
0.776096344,
0.7831587791,
0.2989564836,
0.6302911043,
0.5443589687,
1.1187531948,
-0.0857850015,
1.0820330381,
-0.2773402631,
0.0404779278,
1.0194425583,
-0.3538998365,
0.5689733624,
0.5365465283,
-0.2150275856,
0.2855735421,
0.9839821458,
0.1899664253,
0.1390790194,
0.4875248373,
-0.3852616549,
-0.5233176351,
-0.2004494071,
-0.2279313654,
0.1226079315,
0.4432201684,
0.0087305764,
-0.2565194368,
-0.1462525278,
0.1871065497,
-0.0242832452,
-0.5284616351,
0.5478281975,
0.6168564558,
-0.8366555572,
0.5116314888,
0.1540721953,
0.7775274515,
-0.8245968819,
0.0582143925,
-0.3040342629,
0.2534132898,
-0.4788876772,
-0.5540685654,
0.4131815135,
-0.1276106387,
0.2194187194,
-0.7388093472,
0.9155769348,
-0.242231518,
-0.4556459785,
0.2798995972,
0.3883913457,
0.4999033809,
-0.2020282894,
-0.5897840261,
0.1182686165,
0.0899664909,
-0.5109272003,
0.4497309625,
0.2934171855,
-0.2876138687,
0.7780486345,
0.5833986402,
0.4781896174,
-0.1312488019,
-0.2132580876,
1.067496419,
-0.6123347282,
-0.4081800282,
-0.8085051179,
0.3400198519,
-0.0548602678,
-0.3351536691,
0.7479221225,
0.3582229912,
0.7910324335,
0.3404572904,
0.3448448479,
0.2472300828,
0.1065457389,
-0.407325685,
0.4619888663,
-0.7817860842,
0.3369244337,
0.1881657839,
-0.9051855803,
-0.1899898201,
0.4956921339,
-0.1646960676,
0.0637054741,
0.1072611958,
0.6834192276,
-0.0899514779,
0.2940514982,
0.3620370328,
0.232667774,
0.3213199675,
0.7183819413,
0.6643388271,
0.042676948,
0.3907170296,
-0.4486183226,
-0.3637382984,
-0.3242968619,
-0.8954796791,
-0.43106547,
-0.0953732803,
-0.2842013836,
-0.1551722735,
0.1813727915,
0.5759376884,
1.0391631126,
-0.3113004565,
-0.2722085118,
-0.5114617944,
0.2330416441,
-0.1945948303,
-0.1668628156,
0.2842403948,
0.1778903604,
-0.3665113747,
0.6820383668,
0.3091334999,
-0.0293057151,
-0.6940844059,
-0.0297065713,
-0.1594750136,
-0.052456446,
0.2673349977,
0.3856508136,
-0.5013016462,
0.2757895291,
-0.3107486963,
0.2532736063,
0.1290400475,
1.0251033306,
-1.0360844135,
0.027967317,
0.1905064285,
0.5404155254,
0.8254817128,
0.4338944256,
0.5784131289,
-0.9122244716,
0.3756859303,
0.7472795844,
0.2579280138,
0.3668861687,
-0.2405087054,
0.4864060879,
0.3697273731,
-0.6564253569,
-0.9118521214,
0.4135338962,
-0.5149020553,
-0.6499630213,
0.6271520257,
-0.472268641,
-0.8409845829,
0.1664938331,
-0.0892370269,
0.1555133462,
-0.1986582726,
0.2972271144,
0.1379168481,
-0.1466863602,
-0.1682366133,
-0.2973930836,
0.347350806,
0.6478691101,
-0.6418082714,
0.1762992144,
0.5554593205,
0.1733459383,
-0.176035583,
0.8851436377,
-0.0677768737,
0.1600276977,
-0.0897259414,
-0.0911854804,
-0.4311719239,
-0.9596713781,
-0.4950197935,
0.5490194559,
0.1340744197,
-0.1697764099
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05403v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05403v2
|
In-Context Principle Learning from Mistakes
| 2024-02-08T04:42:29 | 2024-02-09T19:09:52 |
Tianjun Zhang, Aman Madaan, Luyu Gao, Steven Zheng, Swaroop Mishra, Yiming Yang, Niket Tandon, Uri Alon
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In-context learning (ICL, also known as few-shot prompting) has been the
standard method of adapting LLMs to downstream tasks, by learning from a few
input-output examples. Nonetheless, all ICL-based approaches only learn from
correct input-output pairs. In this paper, we revisit this paradigm, by
learning more from the few given input-output examples. We introduce Learning
Principles (LEAP): First, we intentionally induce the model to make mistakes on
these few examples; then we reflect on these mistakes, and learn explicit
task-specific "principles" from them, which help solve similar problems and
avoid common mistakes; finally, we prompt the model to answer unseen test
questions using the original few-shot examples and these learned general
principles. We evaluate LEAP on a wide range of benchmarks, including multi-hop
question answering (Hotpot QA), textual QA (DROP), Big-Bench Hard reasoning,
and math problems (GSM8K and MATH); in all these benchmarks, LEAP improves the
strongest available LLMs such as GPT-3.5-turbo, GPT-4, GPT-4 turbo and
Claude-2.1. For example, LEAP improves over the standard few-shot prompting
using GPT-4 by 7.5% in DROP, and by 3.3% in HotpotQA. Importantly, LEAP does
not require any more input or examples than the standard few-shot prompting
settings.
|
[
-0.2993250191,
-0.6419741511,
0.6503175497,
0.0420622304,
-0.1116413474,
-0.037444111,
0.0104854424,
-0.1808998138,
-0.5714033842,
0.2823924124,
-0.6829150319,
-0.3499571085,
-0.4666883349,
0.0286871307,
-0.1411796659,
1.239110589,
-0.0972410142,
0.2302378267,
-0.0959730148,
0.0616314523,
-0.5775479674,
-0.3001728654,
-0.6625378728,
-0.3666549027,
0.3938215971,
0.941595912,
0.0143081136,
0.2453438789,
0.5244627595,
0.0746838152,
-0.1551837921,
0.3930278718,
-0.7178243399,
-0.4198508859,
0.0626297891,
-0.656920135,
0.0567755699,
0.0158952661,
0.5821629167,
0.5896776915,
-0.1294523031,
-0.0324369408,
0.695293963,
0.7697940469,
-0.7665173411,
0.2040343881,
-0.6638895273,
0.189446643,
-0.0143589806,
-0.3157227933,
-0.6800161004,
-0.3317068815,
-0.0534031168,
-0.6635299921,
0.1237009317,
-0.253271848,
0.6971212029,
0.2703651786,
-0.4851892591,
-0.346698463,
-0.7474367023,
0.8737257123,
-0.7629060745,
0.4334653914,
0.3788497746,
0.3588021696,
-0.2787896097,
-0.6546114683,
-0.3474647403,
-0.0075893034,
0.0278031882,
0.2235243022,
0.152804479,
0.0146032823,
0.4348789155,
-0.1322872788,
-0.0890915468,
-0.0915594473,
-0.4439966977,
0.0399976186,
0.5078414679,
0.2004719526,
-0.1060050428,
0.0771852061,
-0.577991128,
-0.2914829552,
-1.3194646835,
0.6011888385,
-0.1244743913,
0.6060554385,
-0.1754183471,
0.0829233676,
0.0090525867,
0.699645102,
0.414211154,
-0.4243911803,
0.0486210994,
-0.3707452118,
-0.2862889767,
-0.1448555142,
0.1668103337,
0.1537898481,
0.0854370072,
0.0833897367,
-0.0857821181,
-0.4962666631,
0.2293337882,
-0.5785241723,
-0.201269567,
-0.1326528937,
-0.2183553278,
0.0529707745,
0.1059753299,
-0.4732030034,
-0.3044668734,
-0.2156479508,
0.6064474583,
-0.7658948302,
0.1461783946,
0.0237415228,
-0.0591498613,
0.7291361094,
0.7361454964,
-0.810049355,
0.5018962622,
0.8843450546,
0.8197805285,
-0.1842670143,
-0.5373861194,
-0.8604417443,
0.0436486751,
-0.6412587166,
0.7266810536,
-0.1341002434,
-0.5701056719,
0.0013425335,
-0.3656802177,
-0.3498846292,
-0.6282126904,
0.3828071654,
-0.4657144845,
0.0382857174,
-0.5099636316,
-0.8220959306,
-0.4076721072,
0.4105372429,
-0.2005913854,
0.7887195945,
-0.0823784471,
-0.5432785153,
0.8097377419,
-0.9530958533,
-0.2784883678,
-0.1816989183,
-0.1836043894,
-0.1321953833,
0.1289027333,
0.0944385603,
0.444617331,
-0.09125413,
-0.2037639469,
-0.1746546477,
-0.5158536434,
-0.0125268642,
-0.3548199832,
0.8176204562,
0.0645264909,
-0.3568772674,
-0.2361360639,
-0.7202242613,
0.1907058954,
-0.0068759704,
-0.6661435962,
-0.3373064101,
0.0812865347,
-0.2622704208,
0.386122793,
-0.3919942081,
-0.2698821127,
0.1562125683,
-0.4755023718,
0.2446935177,
0.7596483827,
0.4055436552,
0.4356358647,
-0.4238899052,
0.2865640819,
0.4365134239,
0.1733285785,
-0.4539206028,
-0.3760511875,
-0.7138559818,
-0.1693640798,
-0.1079541445,
0.6547842026,
-0.6075353622,
-0.0367674232,
0.1678162664,
-0.2847653329,
-0.1047950834,
0.6724168658,
0.5584293008,
0.8925559521,
0.4778575897,
-0.1235024408,
-0.2411863804,
-0.4505858719,
-0.4698259532,
-0.5125694871,
0.146018073,
0.2430110276,
0.4104686081,
0.127752468,
0.932456255,
-0.4121854305,
-0.195454061,
-0.2299549133,
0.1339982003,
0.2344955206,
0.393321991,
0.3630928695,
-0.8082085252,
-0.5546337962,
-0.155259639,
-0.7002468109,
0.269174546,
-0.071069099,
0.0865033418,
0.0648877174,
0.4960295856,
-0.5272287726,
0.4627366662,
0.1765679121,
-0.1816043705,
0.3443019092,
-0.0351882502,
-0.0088025304,
-1.1611047983,
-0.5727795362,
0.1526005268,
-0.028466301,
-0.6997920871,
0.2389953732,
0.397051096,
0.2055469453,
-1.0532220602,
0.6065787673,
-0.2706020772,
0.0456270613,
-0.1476104707,
-0.235066399,
0.05325583,
0.4471398294,
-0.1195519492,
0.720641017,
0.4526124895,
-1.0046371222,
-0.059742894,
0.2124643624,
-0.2013727576,
0.4022729695,
-0.479072094,
0.4291715026,
-0.0873857811,
0.1675370336,
-1.2336007357,
-0.0193510167,
0.2098563761,
-0.2536099553,
0.5191485286,
-0.2840465605,
-0.3355739415,
-0.1280783266,
-0.3918587267,
0.2212379873,
0.6269740462,
-0.9123553038,
0.2940436602,
-0.2118659616,
0.1006539986,
-0.7995418906,
-0.6773860455,
-0.1725753397,
-0.2441495061,
-0.2653108835,
0.0891366974,
-0.282802999,
-0.3641645908,
-0.1829249263,
-0.0942271948,
-0.1585318297,
0.2405697256,
0.1706368029,
0.1377345622,
-0.2870821953,
0.2161293179,
-0.1874928027,
0.0458483584,
-0.1143608615,
-0.2676043212,
0.1316961646,
-0.3168449402,
-0.5252187252,
-0.3066275716,
0.067079708,
0.3761115074,
0.227726832,
0.2460263073,
0.2071734369,
-0.436522454,
-0.3142067492,
-0.2704848051,
-0.5828375816,
-0.4363258481,
0.3227104843,
-0.4858374894,
-0.6892876029,
0.1160017774,
-0.2791414559,
0.5266088843,
0.1812283099,
0.1758149266,
-0.6634916663,
0.7264120579,
1.0460640192,
-0.1877703518,
0.3463931978,
-0.4964819551,
0.2163497508,
-0.855409503,
0.0846156627,
-0.210380435,
-0.3132174015,
-0.4182515144,
-0.493303895,
0.6078965068,
0.5125043392,
-0.4758316576,
0.1735729724,
0.0044703283,
0.5041363835,
0.7545278668,
0.2257098705,
0.2590205669,
-0.0349789262,
-0.4006382525,
-0.2379348576,
-0.9231019616,
-0.4691272974,
1.2029515505,
0.2105645239,
0.9402537346,
0.160703361,
1.1877789497,
0.0415999293,
0.3670318723,
-0.908003211,
0.4623724222,
0.108618021,
-0.5981156826,
-0.2785659134,
-0.1239735857,
-0.6931817532,
0.1913221031,
-0.0522800721,
-0.7113247514,
0.293335557,
0.542951405,
-0.6972080469,
0.4172329307,
-0.7111579776,
0.5189276934,
-0.2284237295,
-0.4878210723,
-0.1680922359,
-0.6984542608,
0.6865937114,
-0.1345856041,
0.0484659299,
0.1846199334,
-0.1150053442,
0.4041451216,
-0.2879346311,
1.2594803572,
-0.2765921056,
0.0861708373,
0.5521970987,
0.1504064202,
0.652623117,
0.0132991709,
0.0923787355,
-0.0081639504,
-0.1969937831,
-0.3690666258,
-0.7799808383,
0.4363669753,
-0.7871306539,
-0.5535444021,
-0.4055575728,
-0.4791854322,
-0.5094012618,
0.0221398398,
0.4685724974,
0.3745696247,
-0.2351119816,
0.2442650199,
0.7250589728,
0.0794822127,
0.8394749761,
0.5395805836,
0.0054734545,
-0.3013528883,
0.4925610125,
0.0616085492,
0.4297662973,
0.5020938516,
0.3326386511,
-0.3561169803,
-0.4988970459,
-0.4709329903,
0.0911086872,
-1.0590517521,
-0.3390959203,
-0.541364789,
-0.2214263231,
-0.2650631666,
-0.3480420411,
-0.3290489018,
-0.1137818098,
-0.3259126842,
-0.1305188686,
0.2454783469,
0.6986857057,
-0.2187469155,
0.2912181318,
-0.942011416,
0.2161422223,
0.7379363179,
-0.1393616647,
-0.1514585763,
-0.7744669318,
-0.2261228412,
-0.0024882881,
-0.7227424979,
-0.7194676995,
0.1806177199,
0.3903403282,
0.5846123695,
0.6600081921,
-0.0225481074,
0.8960441947,
-0.6627439857,
0.861910522,
0.2852315009,
-0.8226009011,
0.6075341105,
-0.0211734977,
0.2931157053,
0.6704908013,
0.5092752576,
-0.4621027112,
-0.081661962,
-0.7469086647,
-0.4753454328,
0.6727656722,
-0.0586668849,
0.1746672988,
0.1549854279,
0.5292016864,
0.1708602607,
0.1556595266,
-0.7277511358,
-0.1693460196,
-0.027950719,
-0.1038919911,
-0.1956786215,
-0.0040777973,
-0.3057180643,
-0.2640002966,
0.6530123949,
-0.5404379368,
0.208918035,
0.158433497,
-0.3075808287,
-0.1042617857,
0.275852561,
0.8009693027,
0.9786234498,
-0.0592589416,
0.224024415,
0.5213149786,
-0.2857404649,
0.4290006161,
-0.1954491735,
-0.5377194881,
-0.2503601313,
0.4317803085,
0.7106907368,
0.4727389216,
-0.4176479578,
0.3778153658,
0.1698653996,
-0.1975280941,
0.0030119205,
0.3898006976,
-0.0129936198,
0.3694993258,
0.6442760229,
0.2249596864,
0.1267492473,
-0.6298912168,
0.5209213495,
0.3031279445,
-0.5006092787,
-0.3422637284,
0.427682668,
-0.0358138606,
-0.2941710651,
0.4733465314,
-0.1464136243,
-0.2517279983,
0.6109780073,
0.8842145205,
0.8681789637,
-0.0843459219,
0.3043807149,
0.4371044934,
0.3360468745,
-0.2188711911,
0.229224667,
-0.2105356753,
-0.9374032617,
-0.361320287,
-0.1730042994,
-0.7637120485,
0.1379751414,
-0.5666640997,
0.4779800475,
-0.8507271409,
0.2656746805,
-0.2880802155,
0.0481016934,
-0.6886022091,
0.2990354002,
0.0573839433,
0.9657781124,
-0.8495194912,
0.7446849346,
0.8239664435,
-0.4185532033,
-1.0501623154,
0.3900848627,
0.4412516057,
-1.09651649,
0.9272481799,
-0.0935748219,
-0.0377192497,
0.0658235922,
-0.8762010932,
-0.8535820842,
0.9546625614,
0.236638397,
-0.4975531101,
0.0424467362,
-0.1894965917,
0.1256211996,
-0.498542726,
0.1894777119,
0.3301460147,
0.1900374293,
0.2320796251,
-0.6621930003,
-0.2411162406,
0.0419588238,
-0.175139308,
0.061991334,
-0.8062246442,
0.8990398049,
-0.7589181066,
0.0421872474,
-0.1840045303,
0.475599587,
0.7960485816,
0.7148500085,
0.5309853554,
0.3816278577,
0.7521027923,
0.0263560321,
0.9389542341,
-0.0157228857,
0.3504606783,
1.3137953281,
-0.4542749524,
1.1187292337,
0.7066624165,
-0.2372618616,
0.4176729918,
0.8626016378,
0.4128813446,
0.7850822806,
-0.0314059593,
-0.1306868792,
-0.0956975073,
0.4149046242,
-0.1245061979,
0.4227065444,
0.4207927585,
-0.0491743162,
-0.5087419748,
0.1329360604,
-0.0094023012,
-0.0519955866,
-0.4002600312,
0.9874369502,
0.376065284,
-0.5649681687,
0.7111532092,
-0.3225926459,
0.5974763632,
-0.5811591148,
-0.4368655086,
-0.4684553742,
0.3285061121,
0.0072781527,
-0.6643276215,
0.0167270936,
-0.0365362912,
-0.2741409242,
-0.1662795395,
0.8254188299,
-0.1347578764,
-0.4720849097,
0.0615540296,
0.6371570826,
0.2658049762,
0.1539678723,
-0.7775577307,
-0.3928276002,
-0.0810569301,
-0.0839356706,
0.3359102309,
0.329672277,
0.0234653167,
0.649099648,
0.4434279203,
0.1008614674,
0.2792259753,
-0.2453313023,
0.6839871407,
-0.925183475,
-0.5555300117,
-0.7883332968,
0.5687378645,
0.0989461914,
-0.5189896822,
0.7410511971,
0.2899205387,
1.1730048656,
-0.0130215995,
0.9011102915,
0.2124910951,
0.484898299,
-0.7913021445,
0.2637675405,
-0.5494688749,
0.1898100674,
-0.3618262708,
-0.8372365236,
-0.3815076053,
0.5436202288,
-0.1839349568,
0.0557592101,
0.8419163823,
0.6630376577,
-0.138528198,
-0.1876754463,
0.6786990762,
0.0210027043,
0.3549274206,
0.865406394,
1.0082837343,
-0.7132148147,
0.4691501558,
-0.3538737893,
-0.0398560874,
-0.4326266944,
-0.9589955807,
-0.6228263378,
-0.5178239346,
-0.417442888,
-0.4116123617,
0.1438604295,
1.1470764875,
0.9411344528,
-0.7386514544,
-0.283706218,
-0.3197495341,
0.3975409567,
-0.6662749052,
-0.2041798383,
0.1376633495,
-0.7751379609,
-0.575050354,
0.6702086926,
0.3972952366,
0.2178888321,
0.1146610901,
-0.5352295637,
-0.1552202553,
0.058002159,
0.7197086215,
0.6488207579,
-0.6819614768,
-0.345526576,
0.1535624266,
-0.0485249497,
0.4042761624,
1.0131499767,
-0.6728002429,
0.285451889,
0.4212502837,
0.912940681,
0.3891229033,
-0.0653784871,
0.3343955278,
-0.7332028747,
0.0872869045,
0.2818048894,
0.3012515306,
0.2271509171,
-0.3736044466,
0.5249295235,
0.3050304651,
-0.3361191154,
-0.6502610445,
0.2427108586,
-0.5396538377,
-0.1370090842,
1.3078039885,
-0.2892689705,
-0.2130676508,
-0.1368853152,
-0.1256876439,
-0.0034479396,
-0.2425707877,
0.7615998983,
0.6803911924,
-0.6568672657,
-0.4741000831,
-0.4809882939,
0.64037323,
0.6079984903,
-0.8123998046,
-0.2088303119,
0.4448885918,
0.4343607128,
-0.0319576636,
0.7444119453,
-0.0636714399,
0.5659339428,
-0.233597219,
-0.053970553,
0.2390766889,
-0.6141913533,
-0.6201997399,
0.1246210113,
0.4291238487,
-0.530872941
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10941v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10941v1
|
Text2Data: Low-Resource Data Generation with Textual Control
| 2024-02-08T03:41:39 | 2024-02-08T03:41:39 |
Shiyu Wang, Yihao Feng, Tian Lan, Ning Yu, Yu Bai, Ran Xu, Huan Wang, Caiming Xiong, Silvio Savarese
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Natural language serves as a common and straightforward control signal for
humans to interact seamlessly with machines. Recognizing the importance of this
interface, the machine learning community is investing considerable effort in
generating data that is semantically coherent with textual instructions. While
strides have been made in text-to-data generation spanning image editing, audio
synthesis, video creation, and beyond, low-resource areas characterized by
expensive annotations or complex data structures, such as molecules, motion
dynamics, and time series, often lack textual labels. This deficiency impedes
supervised learning, thereby constraining the application of advanced
generative models for text-to-data tasks. In response to these challenges in
the low-resource scenario, we propose Text2Data, a novel approach that utilizes
unlabeled data to understand the underlying data distribution through an
unsupervised diffusion model. Subsequently, it undergoes controllable
finetuning via a novel constraint optimization-based learning objective that
ensures controllability and effectively counteracts catastrophic forgetting.
Comprehensive experiments demonstrate that Text2Data is able to achieve
enhanced performance regarding controllability across various modalities,
including molecules, motions and time series, when compared to existing
baselines.
|
[
-0.0059054275,
-1.0253460407,
0.4816377759,
0.1154038534,
-0.119074069,
0.1458075345,
-0.3889507949,
-0.1693235487,
-0.0783824176,
0.6188211441,
-0.6122559905,
-0.5571326613,
-0.5938119888,
-0.1188969687,
-0.375399828,
1.3400011063,
-0.358084172,
-0.2518206239,
-0.4415992796,
-0.1114775091,
-0.3997571468,
-0.266741097,
-0.5692195296,
-0.515062809,
0.3108962774,
0.6185020208,
0.693208158,
0.7361122966,
0.306830883,
0.1731441468,
0.0148982108,
0.5136111975,
-0.6928700209,
0.0881692618,
-0.2744330764,
-0.4038516283,
-0.0618718751,
0.021321794,
0.3794074655,
0.751578927,
-0.1042382345,
0.1238935292,
0.4252981842,
0.9070237279,
-0.5357013941,
0.1371431649,
-0.5195691586,
0.1967843622,
-0.2827723324,
-0.2391642034,
-0.380114913,
-0.2545206547,
0.0785420612,
-0.9348556995,
0.3010934591,
-0.1957564652,
0.5780798197,
0.7865228653,
-0.4415305257,
-0.6873244047,
-0.8942511678,
0.8116660714,
-0.0685205162,
0.0802409798,
0.7858651876,
0.0553521588,
-0.1274473816,
-0.8170223236,
-0.4955914915,
0.3242293596,
-0.151883781,
0.2176020443,
-0.3181357086,
-0.2312831879,
0.0086364849,
-0.1563325077,
-0.5408393145,
0.2385532409,
-0.346198678,
-0.1870934367,
0.4278052151,
0.1806046218,
0.1923323125,
-0.360050261,
-0.3974742293,
-0.0185322203,
-0.2505359948,
-0.1298433542,
0.3193308115,
0.3149672747,
-0.3900598288,
0.8191118836,
-0.1353946775,
0.2962340713,
-0.0759895742,
0.0875008181,
0.05555382,
-0.4439596832,
-0.2115450203,
0.1676597446,
0.9620838165,
0.4617418051,
0.0996105522,
-0.3304314911,
-0.0797078088,
0.1129580215,
0.2079254538,
-0.975320816,
-0.5295687318,
0.1960763037,
-0.4684614539,
-0.4097294807,
-0.2044368684,
-1.1879749298,
-0.5142251849,
-0.5218582153,
0.2389771938,
-0.5119558573,
-0.0393884592,
-0.0276986565,
-0.0923505798,
-0.2663936317,
0.2621333301,
-1.1588730812,
0.4152704179,
0.4088581204,
1.0752655268,
-0.5035685897,
0.2286062986,
-0.2856272161,
0.4843826294,
-0.4912996292,
0.5846212506,
-0.4428122938,
-0.5640097857,
-0.2255422324,
-0.2410097867,
0.1618245989,
-0.5922372937,
0.3227027953,
-0.27018255,
0.3046858907,
0.0529768355,
-0.5364884734,
0.0213781893,
-0.2079719007,
-0.7569076419,
1.2294561863,
0.2654133737,
-0.8216384649,
0.3110810518,
-0.7439119816,
-0.5494921207,
-0.0975496769,
-0.3326816261,
-0.8014245629,
-0.1394632012,
-0.0999706537,
0.378110379,
-0.4656048715,
0.4719449878,
0.0903563574,
-0.0874539763,
0.200012207,
-0.8152167201,
0.4162477553,
0.2827650905,
-0.3278649747,
-0.2714999914,
-0.9251900315,
0.1017127335,
0.1505334377,
-0.658970654,
-0.4825574756,
0.2828625143,
0.5838366747,
-0.0649367869,
0.252833426,
-0.3486184478,
0.1919442415,
-0.205161348,
0.4724540114,
0.57417804,
0.197938785,
0.776606977,
-0.089715071,
0.2898695767,
-0.0210568011,
-0.2433716655,
-0.034370359,
-0.3282139003,
-0.6023032665,
-0.0055819494,
0.2951368093,
0.7301350832,
-1.0621051788,
0.2301037461,
-0.0823397115,
-0.2930410504,
-0.4602024257,
0.5315788388,
0.4027303159,
0.6577576399,
0.7250188589,
0.0874008536,
-0.5398342013,
-0.754922986,
0.1644537449,
0.1618659496,
-0.4005931914,
0.2954964638,
0.457220912,
-0.6308247447,
1.1422919035,
-0.7100455761,
-0.4825854599,
-0.1283259392,
0.5890719295,
-0.2879844606,
0.7818425298,
0.4842431247,
-0.9006146789,
-0.1432521492,
0.0900285691,
-0.8411743045,
-0.2234565914,
-0.4330061674,
-0.4252498448,
0.5534049273,
0.543376863,
-0.4066362381,
0.3219011128,
0.581806004,
-0.4353622496,
-0.0625831261,
-0.4649263322,
-0.2537728548,
-1.24264884,
0.257345438,
0.0610303693,
-0.0533525459,
-0.4349244237,
-0.6530359387,
0.0461552553,
-0.0876962766,
-0.170440197,
0.4585908055,
-0.2348388433,
0.1558234841,
-0.14829579,
-0.0652768537,
-0.0699825436,
0.4810538888,
0.1957517117,
0.7145810723,
0.1746790111,
-0.6857218742,
0.1668243557,
0.5085223317,
-0.2989042401,
0.5006257296,
-0.5032795668,
0.0130346445,
-0.4389382899,
-0.0581626669,
-0.8309531212,
-0.5450386405,
0.17866759,
-0.4682915807,
0.3325247467,
0.0192101449,
-0.5720143318,
-0.0572251789,
-0.1054826453,
0.3835496306,
0.6928526759,
-0.449927628,
0.2795459032,
0.5154665112,
-0.196057573,
-0.0801423714,
-1.0616083145,
0.0053819814,
-0.0570324622,
-0.0218534544,
0.3305360079,
-0.0954004377,
-0.1426720619,
0.1809921116,
0.0800193623,
-0.4673910737,
0.0526809618,
0.3942635953,
0.1604029536,
0.3079832196,
0.4319206178,
0.6937604547,
-0.3583320677,
-0.001557594,
-0.4759278595,
0.3425925672,
0.6507849097,
0.0980902612,
-0.7131379247,
0.4446534216,
0.1819689572,
0.0688408315,
0.4957707226,
0.5271565914,
-0.4456776381,
-0.5363382101,
0.2843651474,
0.0408486873,
-0.4892601371,
0.428039521,
-0.0181055684,
-0.6641884446,
-0.0532760285,
-0.3159009516,
0.005274171,
0.4388783872,
0.6301804781,
-0.5860521793,
0.685041666,
0.6749975681,
0.2382998019,
0.3258737922,
-0.4707969129,
-0.2616892755,
-0.4148724377,
-0.6102275848,
-0.43907547,
-0.5789557695,
-0.7116773129,
-0.6585915685,
0.2133561671,
0.3202748895,
-0.338040024,
0.0983695686,
-0.7112674713,
0.4294787943,
0.4760533869,
0.2053486407,
0.2398579717,
0.1893005669,
-0.0180130154,
-0.3318185508,
-0.5934523344,
-0.7250791192,
1.2374734879,
0.1205440536,
0.941486001,
0.1721412987,
0.4461978674,
0.6076015234,
0.0001166931,
-0.702262044,
0.2454679608,
-0.4754746854,
-0.1876434684,
-0.2849212587,
-0.6576138735,
-1.0030919313,
-0.2226994932,
-0.4079099894,
-0.4953995943,
-0.0404050462,
0.3253912032,
-0.1738924235,
0.2043931633,
-0.9370345473,
0.6831365228,
-0.120600991,
-0.5531184673,
0.0971404612,
-0.5506907701,
0.1770341992,
-0.4176297486,
0.1738982201,
-0.0625049397,
-0.3580028713,
1.0825712681,
-0.4861973524,
1.0211932659,
-0.2110405564,
-0.1664911658,
0.5308627486,
0.2009476423,
0.5535109043,
0.1634436697,
0.0781709924,
-0.0448523089,
-0.2865860462,
-0.4016658962,
-0.3251783848,
0.6324243546,
-0.7192900181,
0.294623673,
-0.0246798005,
-0.5909194946,
-0.1826175302,
0.2172391117,
0.6012809277,
0.3549838662,
-0.1730275154,
0.2615713775,
0.8634076715,
-0.3277884722,
0.7378123403,
0.2196121663,
0.1620985866,
-0.4448308647,
1.1127202511,
0.2992798388,
0.2603141963,
0.6625034213,
-0.0853008181,
-0.332868576,
-0.4531583786,
-0.6151232123,
-0.1138843,
-0.2317428589,
-0.3541888297,
-0.7450333834,
0.0208788458,
-0.0161807016,
-0.268402338,
-0.5106822252,
-0.5489399433,
-0.8416448832,
-0.3080219626,
0.6404179335,
0.7358358502,
-0.0504481159,
0.4782994092,
-0.5407995582,
0.6321194172,
0.1634504795,
0.4348037839,
-0.2038241923,
-0.0816617385,
-0.303016603,
0.1462379992,
-0.4651933014,
-0.60568887,
0.2403960973,
0.2187360674,
-0.0572522841,
0.2351698875,
0.2494765073,
0.1888578534,
-0.6019729972,
0.5755851269,
0.3139454424,
-0.8181931973,
0.7961518764,
-0.3264818788,
0.2917335629,
0.4868090451,
0.3823289275,
-0.2967653275,
-0.3171673417,
-0.298689276,
-0.961594224,
0.705570519,
0.4989055991,
0.2363255769,
0.2302371114,
0.3617174923,
0.2715167701,
0.2228168845,
-0.3829281032,
-0.1594453007,
-0.3991588354,
-0.7750324011,
-0.0699291378,
-0.3157590926,
-0.0885933191,
0.068129912,
0.3181132078,
-0.2638167143,
0.2270504236,
0.1131787971,
0.0283805709,
-0.1264151484,
0.1610614657,
0.4525488019,
0.0912714303,
0.0699869916,
0.2821604311,
-0.1087380648,
-0.778598249,
0.2712439001,
0.1527315527,
-0.6448557377,
0.0369622074,
0.341160059,
0.8916749358,
0.1556248814,
-0.7737372518,
0.2061205506,
0.135361895,
-0.5384495854,
-0.0106377788,
0.0670756474,
0.0017196655,
0.0569072701,
0.2679658234,
0.2430484146,
0.0494568832,
-0.1533611864,
0.4740225673,
0.1222076043,
-0.4917092621,
-0.3158613443,
1.2261086702,
0.3377535939,
0.1120354384,
0.4967452288,
-0.2528522313,
0.047805883,
0.5910809636,
0.4560608566,
0.4841367304,
0.018120043,
0.5302813053,
0.2565762997,
0.3016526997,
-0.055326432,
0.3520604074,
-0.1736724824,
-0.5602846742,
-0.1018574759,
-0.6478487253,
-0.166148603,
0.0091392063,
-0.662364006,
0.0781028345,
-0.6649103165,
-0.1812673807,
0.1186728105,
-0.0296307039,
-0.4254671335,
0.3326289058,
-0.1703229547,
0.7065951824,
-0.7390323281,
0.8620084524,
0.3143886924,
-0.3331047595,
-0.4515752792,
-0.0042148572,
0.1966632307,
-0.451243192,
0.5828925967,
0.1120657474,
0.0371814296,
0.1867101789,
-0.5962093472,
-0.4714886844,
1.2113940716,
0.2578136027,
-0.5600748062,
-0.0592029281,
0.3065913022,
0.4978834987,
0.1076110378,
-0.2947508693,
0.7041969299,
0.5966659188,
0.2215398103,
-0.451787442,
-0.1554154605,
-0.1389537752,
0.1138773486,
0.4815019071,
-0.4722511172,
0.6560714841,
-0.3577666283,
-0.4266999364,
0.0575796962,
0.6135337353,
-0.1037265509,
0.4770605266,
0.0145268161,
0.6484952569,
0.926573813,
-0.2951555848,
0.8715099692,
0.1045879722,
0.4416409433,
1.2608525753,
-0.0968351513,
0.7703954577,
0.5115541816,
-0.1311833709,
0.2089213431,
0.5284199119,
-0.0837991685,
0.8532461524,
0.0302757286,
-0.2606363595,
0.1439626068,
-0.3595955372,
0.0341226198,
0.4256352484,
0.4119408727,
-0.2715703547,
-0.2143951952,
0.3404553831,
0.2494119257,
0.5493015051,
-0.2923718095,
0.9951343536,
-0.2699804008,
-0.198478967,
0.4783915579,
0.1711423397,
0.7972887754,
-0.4819529057,
-0.0992185771,
-0.2392736524,
0.1876955032,
-0.2849809527,
-0.9593293667,
0.5225296021,
0.4513984025,
-0.5807976127,
-0.5012630224,
0.3491683006,
-0.7976347804,
-0.5146983862,
0.2342359573,
0.1742211878,
-0.0314535201,
0.3662467599,
-0.413902998,
-0.0786491856,
0.149981454,
-0.1959726363,
0.1203342453,
0.6477479339,
-0.184812218,
0.5992546082,
0.5296326876,
0.0676194951,
-0.1611087471,
-0.2695243359,
0.7013985515,
-0.6124031544,
-0.429643929,
-0.6021651626,
0.3314548135,
0.0053610308,
-0.3119950891,
0.2762152553,
0.9107361436,
0.7798178196,
0.1287661046,
1.182074666,
-0.1994374543,
0.5875205994,
-1.0323597193,
1.0378929377,
-0.4363265932,
0.0050126771,
0.0447409824,
-0.4883479476,
-0.13386783,
0.2159622014,
0.0685169548,
-0.2156963944,
0.5359630585,
0.6568613052,
0.0630490258,
-0.160771668,
0.007612329,
0.1486623585,
0.2966310978,
0.8360228539,
0.3021349013,
-0.3660265505,
0.7061659694,
-0.1066480353,
-0.1831929088,
0.0870017111,
-0.6102361679,
-0.8198618293,
-0.7546194196,
-0.1793902069,
-0.2576238215,
-0.1799746007,
0.7733576894,
0.4682728648,
-0.7178543806,
0.0675103143,
-0.638278842,
-0.0097313533,
0.2155907303,
-0.2319189757,
0.5458136201,
-0.1963287294,
-0.9356200099,
0.2627918124,
0.2106041908,
0.804304719,
-0.0154262763,
-0.2798483074,
0.0778557882,
0.0345550478,
0.5602377653,
0.3061995804,
-0.226819545,
0.1692630202,
-0.3417018652,
-0.531229198,
-0.1770366877,
0.9131937027,
-0.9116766453,
0.4260402918,
0.2105289102,
0.9940098524,
0.4762214422,
0.1117536724,
0.4379389882,
-1.0134660006,
0.4497818053,
0.1271770447,
-0.2828364372,
0.2913507223,
-0.4656071663,
0.5677865148,
0.2944340408,
-0.2894429564,
-0.5404298902,
0.0155410403,
-1.0172725916,
-0.5656807423,
1.0556879044,
0.3553077579,
-0.0205659941,
-0.0260138791,
-0.4559198916,
0.3979387283,
-0.5848569274,
0.7068448663,
0.3374387026,
-0.1609178483,
-0.0573718697,
-0.8325484991,
0.9833629131,
0.1985187531,
-1.183844924,
0.3614446521,
0.7631636262,
0.0226225629,
-0.159461081,
0.6808073521,
0.0851183087,
-0.0472221039,
-0.091661483,
-0.084201619,
-0.0943013281,
-0.4395003319,
-0.0693367198,
0.2189401984,
-0.5559552312,
-0.3527428806
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05376v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05376v1
|
Zero-Shot Chain-of-Thought Reasoning Guided by Evolutionary Algorithms in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-08T03:17:38 | 2024-02-08T03:17:38 |
Feihu Jin, Yifan Liu, Ying Tan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable performance across
diverse tasks and exhibited impressive reasoning abilities by applying
zero-shot Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting. However, due to the evolving nature
of sentence prefixes during the pre-training phase, existing zero-shot CoT
prompting methods that employ identical CoT prompting across all task instances
may not be optimal. In this paper, we introduce a novel zero-shot prompting
method that leverages evolutionary algorithms to generate diverse promptings
for LLMs dynamically. Our approach involves initializing two CoT promptings,
performing evolutionary operations based on LLMs to create a varied set, and
utilizing the LLMs to select a suitable CoT prompting for a given problem.
Additionally, a rewriting operation, guided by the selected CoT prompting,
enhances the understanding of the LLMs about the problem. Extensive experiments
conducted across ten reasoning datasets demonstrate the superior performance of
our proposed method compared to current zero-shot CoT prompting methods on
GPT-3.5-turbo and GPT-4. Moreover, in-depth analytical experiments underscore
the adaptability and effectiveness of our method in various reasoning tasks.
|
[
-0.3750679195,
-1.1918361187,
0.9875662923,
0.052870959,
-0.6201059222,
0.3155021369,
-0.4133206308,
-0.2125136554,
0.3581906855,
0.2761188447,
-1.1340799332,
-0.5225848556,
-0.2927416861,
0.4376716018,
-0.1706793606,
0.8095863461,
-0.2187774479,
-0.2765442133,
0.080352053,
0.1064349413,
-0.7474064827,
-0.1493625045,
-0.5143876672,
-0.2998046279,
0.9667211175,
0.5075325966,
0.4220618308,
0.4084843397,
-0.1067263633,
0.1946705431,
-0.1791380644,
0.4145745635,
-0.4562711716,
0.5759757757,
-0.3637940884,
-0.5405162573,
-0.0787741989,
-0.2784669399,
0.4611323476,
0.4783007801,
-0.0190047268,
0.1109504998,
-0.3158195317,
0.3258190453,
-1.0361795425,
-0.3034267128,
-1.2307816744,
0.2582234442,
0.0702987909,
-0.7200784087,
-0.5327994823,
-0.2769666314,
-0.0070469636,
-0.5505799055,
0.0946581364,
-0.1291272342,
0.5111835599,
0.1413200647,
-0.181571722,
-0.4005533457,
-0.6579556465,
0.733040154,
-0.5759362578,
0.2719541192,
-0.0995741487,
0.110345602,
-0.3613201976,
-0.4109177887,
-0.8589978814,
-0.2661484182,
0.398341924,
0.0769752935,
-0.1654027551,
-0.1165413633,
0.1075332537,
-0.0128325429,
-0.5512972474,
0.1764178276,
-0.2748369873,
0.2039633691,
0.3739026487,
0.0187754463,
0.1222887412,
0.1966599524,
-0.4056500494,
0.0154333077,
-0.9869265556,
-0.1310760528,
0.1781616062,
0.4018276036,
0.0726396963,
0.3879030347,
-0.3797189891,
0.8716052771,
0.1991884559,
0.2028649151,
0.1776207536,
-0.0541591644,
-0.3167335987,
0.3269212544,
0.8028715849,
0.1851970106,
0.5277011991,
-0.1902554333,
-0.0759804994,
0.0547527373,
0.2692801654,
-0.4348726869,
-0.0045156083,
0.2228491008,
0.0606046431,
-0.6261136532,
-0.3331768811,
-0.971767962,
-0.2111315727,
-0.1889195591,
0.6151069403,
-0.4854371548,
0.0050326185,
0.3373527825,
-0.1259153932,
0.3987673521,
0.3785172105,
-1.0200493336,
-0.2279926986,
0.4918608665,
0.9148749113,
0.1646036059,
-0.4974059463,
-0.6743537784,
0.2710770667,
-0.4810240567,
1.0684672594,
-0.7524783611,
-0.3563527465,
-0.0248991642,
-0.3317851722,
-0.0642094687,
-0.1425186098,
0.2707862556,
-0.4210755229,
0.1931513995,
-0.3082478344,
-0.3348810971,
-0.0993314907,
0.6113269925,
-0.1118936911,
0.8348699808,
-0.0887057707,
-0.3816580176,
0.5540087223,
-0.6711378098,
-0.3770726919,
0.3219969869,
-0.5107277036,
-0.1973582804,
0.3055018485,
0.7067913413,
0.2700163126,
-0.2435630709,
0.2114095241,
-0.4170591831,
-0.4355778098,
0.0252664369,
-0.5160797834,
0.7605468035,
0.1277307421,
-0.5714930892,
0.2036585361,
-0.3904926777,
0.3391978443,
0.4197898209,
0.1290555447,
-0.1130846292,
-0.0825775862,
-0.9295012355,
0.1469199806,
0.0738186911,
-0.5193414092,
0.6631787419,
-0.3231650889,
0.5575858355,
0.8669225574,
0.375297457,
0.1099708155,
-0.2598757148,
0.6871033311,
-0.1162078232,
0.1931373179,
-0.4825542569,
-0.6222252846,
-0.7016612291,
-0.0386140421,
-0.0384974964,
0.5654924512,
-1.0160793066,
0.5737022758,
-0.1576377898,
-0.4743866324,
-0.3105748594,
0.0609259903,
0.2813765705,
0.379306823,
0.4293515086,
-0.0440838076,
-0.3634977043,
-0.3929169178,
-0.2802172005,
-0.2005137056,
0.0823120773,
0.230949387,
0.4255622327,
-0.0642185956,
0.9031838179,
-0.705119729,
0.4212887883,
-0.4237430096,
0.4276241362,
0.2231715173,
0.1318911165,
0.5642362237,
-0.1236558631,
-0.1677633971,
-0.1170340776,
-0.7356073856,
-0.4124805033,
-0.6578552127,
-0.4585161209,
-0.1250498146,
0.5006933808,
-0.6988745332,
0.3121041656,
0.2486542761,
-0.1907574683,
0.8583325148,
-0.2347731143,
0.0094229868,
-0.8122114539,
-0.0785797462,
-0.3045427501,
-0.0034481729,
-0.6300349236,
0.2422769666,
-0.0992107466,
0.0315410122,
-0.5023107529,
0.5607156157,
-0.6169354916,
0.1736042202,
-0.255949229,
0.294200629,
-0.0552782342,
0.5690581799,
0.0241244957,
0.7205151916,
0.8184458017,
-0.6947050691,
0.5510146022,
0.3554399908,
-0.0857476145,
0.417699635,
-0.443139255,
0.5018819571,
-0.3186753094,
0.4839588106,
-0.6441419125,
0.0995956659,
0.2806675434,
-0.2870809734,
0.006564056,
-0.0214408413,
-0.2408257276,
-0.6439041495,
-0.568692863,
0.5729718804,
0.4940163493,
-0.7338462472,
0.4007274806,
-0.4411088824,
-0.2520733476,
-0.4097091258,
-0.4796312153,
0.3934625387,
-0.1027893722,
-0.3505680561,
0.1825681031,
-0.135864988,
0.1414889693,
-0.1881325394,
-0.243419826,
0.1941693872,
-0.1078626513,
-0.140414387,
0.5018472672,
-0.2373207361,
0.0930278674,
0.3038161397,
0.0331332423,
-0.062097352,
-0.6362455487,
0.901037991,
0.0837737173,
-0.324528724,
-0.3708364666,
0.13751553,
0.5472869873,
-0.3398464918,
0.5775960684,
0.1850282252,
0.0046474724,
-0.6888815761,
-0.5536592603,
-0.3177502453,
-0.5096508861,
-0.1152534634,
-0.428296864,
-0.8928200603,
0.3115399182,
-0.2304036468,
0.1081447527,
0.0272946134,
0.9161484241,
0.1042675152,
0.7684975863,
0.1076658741,
0.1681236178,
0.5897750258,
-0.2473127246,
0.5587514639,
-0.8693345785,
-0.2557718754,
-0.250382185,
-0.3556248546,
-0.3390795588,
-0.4266376793,
0.3032864928,
0.2382685393,
-0.4947154224,
0.2452711463,
-0.7903160453,
0.8891454339,
0.4791338742,
0.1699903905,
0.1777504236,
0.0584165566,
-0.5661455393,
0.6503041983,
-0.7202399373,
-0.3380975127,
0.9743475914,
-0.0528943874,
0.6285431981,
-0.0750959963,
1.0363599062,
0.0241201967,
-0.0023277614,
-0.8225993514,
0.7805400491,
0.1917078346,
-0.3987663984,
-0.3012550771,
-0.407465905,
-1.1336653233,
0.1837872863,
-0.366011858,
-1.0859205723,
0.2010944933,
0.1811341047,
-0.8564614654,
0.4437529445,
-0.5040961504,
0.4512797296,
-0.4698880315,
-0.2584920824,
-0.0880772397,
-0.564568162,
0.3999359012,
-0.1544259638,
-0.1248946264,
-0.1735173017,
-0.0633694977,
0.2096597403,
-0.4544581771,
0.5970060825,
-0.083245337,
-0.1098684818,
0.5716771483,
0.3887646496,
0.6413726211,
-0.1052207723,
-0.179067418,
-0.0504227765,
-0.190724507,
-0.371650666,
-0.7763043046,
0.7057849169,
-0.5296418667,
-0.7637447119,
-0.3789083064,
-0.5317378044,
-0.4926882088,
0.2725820243,
0.3815145791,
0.244505465,
0.1186717823,
-0.0716201514,
0.4237350821,
-0.3785623014,
0.5364460349,
0.3931316435,
-0.1495580077,
-0.2888749242,
0.6746198535,
-0.1072568223,
0.5093784928,
0.1998631805,
0.3670477271,
-0.2507429421,
-0.675909698,
-0.6954907179,
0.1792814881,
-0.5389387012,
-0.3317700922,
-0.5253939033,
-0.1027066559,
-0.2080479115,
-0.7618489861,
0.0411453433,
-0.2238896042,
-0.1236818135,
-0.181547761,
0.5307097435,
0.6573204398,
0.2142001987,
0.216163069,
-0.7389790416,
0.3898823559,
0.542996347,
0.4387231469,
0.31151703,
-0.2739409506,
0.3437328637,
0.2419958264,
-0.5525583029,
-1.0491452217,
0.147599116,
0.0785599053,
0.5139616728,
0.4207022488,
0.1516968608,
0.8762475252,
-0.7060984373,
1.0315872431,
0.473220408,
-1.0470333099,
0.8876414895,
-0.5779621005,
0.6431539655,
0.6170393825,
0.1349848062,
-0.4749378562,
-0.5773606896,
-0.5635758638,
-0.8652820587,
0.5553530455,
0.2749510109,
0.2472425252,
-0.417911917,
0.6013368368,
0.1311647147,
0.1786420941,
-0.5132191777,
0.0697708055,
-0.1412301809,
-0.0129665677,
0.3133452535,
0.0560324192,
0.0491260961,
-0.2804507315,
0.5559999943,
-0.3296751976,
0.3445772827,
0.2958989143,
-0.0601702593,
-0.2806374431,
0.5829370022,
0.8083465099,
0.6161177754,
-0.0938480422,
0.1340332478,
0.7348341942,
-0.1500122547,
0.3571543992,
-0.4459042847,
-0.3424012661,
-0.0629499927,
0.3922556341,
1.0503971577,
0.0921030268,
-0.5896405578,
0.3146114945,
0.1028819755,
-0.4781785607,
-0.0025786043,
0.3805257976,
-0.0540571362,
0.1443042904,
0.2779029608,
-0.2530302703,
-0.330165416,
-0.8063118458,
0.0099481065,
0.4775527716,
-0.0902445093,
-0.1425936967,
0.4607824385,
0.2127895057,
-0.4224461913,
0.5980657339,
-0.4584939778,
-0.560102284,
0.4046139717,
0.7091561556,
1.1458052397,
-0.2079414576,
0.4319481552,
0.1940984428,
0.1277779341,
-0.0885113999,
0.4814041555,
-0.3209657073,
-0.8171347976,
-0.6556631327,
-0.5623579025,
-0.5528271794,
0.1467941999,
-0.347114116,
0.4914307892,
-0.7495428324,
0.1017152369,
0.1210626066,
-0.4430346787,
-0.4545311928,
0.1410567462,
0.5293066502,
0.9854730368,
-0.5460166931,
0.7309275866,
0.4749663472,
-0.4043759704,
-0.8718705177,
0.2952420115,
0.1650352925,
-1.1807496548,
0.3380600512,
0.0487838723,
-0.5508136153,
0.1073189303,
-0.7560068965,
-0.5211907625,
1.1689100266,
0.3540923893,
-0.8731572032,
-0.076674208,
0.0776476935,
0.3895926774,
-0.5737456679,
0.4162780046,
0.5755594373,
0.336709857,
0.6582561135,
-0.7240959406,
0.1745058894,
-0.0820734277,
-0.0010583011,
0.4908386469,
-0.4523302913,
0.7755839229,
-0.4884231389,
-0.0758779943,
0.0844270289,
0.2581469715,
0.7551691532,
0.1501392573,
0.6438248754,
0.4148247838,
0.8325887322,
0.0582315736,
0.8044264913,
-0.3278654814,
0.2844863534,
1.1494123936,
-0.6845787168,
0.8472515345,
0.4835562408,
0.1010696143,
0.9591390491,
0.4227352738,
-0.2116779834,
0.4209856093,
0.4190388918,
-0.6227940321,
-0.3796747923,
0.0000382268,
-0.2518966198,
0.39755252,
0.1265549064,
-0.1821929514,
-0.5211004019,
-0.1304742396,
0.1193845123,
-0.2344461083,
-0.4064984024,
0.8801320791,
-0.0812567323,
-0.9623324275,
0.963065207,
-0.3172716796,
0.7029796839,
-0.6095210314,
0.0467811003,
-0.1054590121,
-0.1110576317,
-0.0563790686,
-0.9723357558,
0.045921918,
0.3647799194,
0.091811277,
-0.3156920969,
0.4407471418,
-0.394254148,
-0.5068215132,
0.2514720559,
0.5997872949,
0.0803702176,
-0.0057905479,
-0.5855858922,
0.0986111015,
0.0982012898,
-0.1443444043,
0.0467885695,
0.6388159394,
-0.2209170759,
0.678082943,
0.919737339,
0.273907423,
0.0456060357,
0.3455352187,
1.0519522429,
-0.8685119152,
-0.5589126945,
-1.1409934759,
0.3533605933,
-0.059645731,
-0.4112132788,
0.3283337653,
0.1338912249,
0.5901400447,
-0.019484479,
0.8182701468,
0.0660414398,
0.0343434401,
-0.5725702047,
0.3847769201,
-0.3380655646,
0.2392932326,
-0.2291548401,
-1.0393697023,
-0.4343576729,
0.6766082048,
-0.5750637054,
0.1047067866,
0.9406080246,
0.8024539351,
0.1052893698,
0.4095667005,
0.2612026036,
0.2132265866,
0.4276216626,
0.8504238725,
0.9246688485,
0.1534496695,
0.5231233239,
0.2264325619,
-0.3104095459,
-0.1065321565,
-1.2352073193,
-0.9419544935,
-0.0813179314,
-0.2622511089,
-0.0391707942,
0.3913574815,
1.2755968571,
0.4800605476,
-0.7503022552,
0.0993072391,
-0.6733264923,
-0.0343234725,
-0.1853291243,
-0.1684536189,
0.0688366666,
-0.6528534889,
-0.2835572958,
0.6039125919,
0.5633833408,
-0.060471978,
-0.1762119979,
-0.0043661958,
-0.4726656377,
0.5681192875,
0.6351496577,
0.3443649709,
-0.8413303494,
-0.5228231549,
-0.0215453673,
0.4218320847,
-0.0281436816,
0.935913682,
-1.0910625458,
0.6505743265,
0.5251366496,
0.355140388,
0.5071752071,
-0.1827692837,
0.7036368847,
-0.7877706289,
0.1622458547,
0.4315135181,
0.3186033666,
0.0342393406,
-0.374620229,
0.2446980178,
0.131510362,
-0.4697521329,
-0.7912271619,
0.4759913385,
-0.9043012261,
-0.5200825334,
1.2438184023,
0.0060345577,
-0.1845402867,
0.0408389941,
-0.3457198441,
0.1875934303,
-0.3884228766,
0.9056251049,
0.7045431733,
-0.3755888343,
-0.5166284442,
-0.2293480337,
0.1473099291,
0.5593938231,
-0.8424599767,
0.1470757574,
0.2361983508,
0.2522299588,
0.0443404801,
0.4102594256,
0.1453385055,
0.3876207471,
-0.047233887,
-0.0477769822,
-0.1944924444,
-0.3456335366,
-0.3523160517,
-0.0271892324,
-0.0070462865,
-0.0929500759
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05374v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05374v2
|
CIC: A framework for Culturally-aware Image Captioning
| 2024-02-08T03:12:25 | 2024-05-02T02:41:50 |
Youngsik Yun, Jihie Kim
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Image Captioning generates descriptive sentences from images using
Vision-Language Pre-trained models (VLPs) such as BLIP, which has improved
greatly. However, current methods lack the generation of detailed descriptive
captions for the cultural elements depicted in the images, such as the
traditional clothing worn by people from Asian cultural groups. In this paper,
we propose a new framework, \textbf{Culturally-aware Image Captioning (CIC)},
that generates captions and describes cultural elements extracted from cultural
visual elements in images representing cultures. Inspired by methods combining
visual modality and Large Language Models (LLMs) through appropriate prompts,
our framework (1) generates questions based on cultural categories from images,
(2) extracts cultural visual elements from Visual Question Answering (VQA)
using generated questions, and (3) generates culturally-aware captions using
LLMs with the prompts. Our human evaluation conducted on 45 participants from 4
different cultural groups with a high understanding of the corresponding
culture shows that our proposed framework generates more culturally descriptive
captions when compared to the image captioning baseline based on VLPs. Our code
and dataset will be made publicly available upon acceptance.
|
[
-0.5313779712,
-0.2868075371,
0.1137837544,
0.4400894046,
-0.4776964784,
0.245423615,
-0.2985255718,
-0.6494725347,
0.3152346611,
0.6350431442,
-0.5413312316,
-0.648680985,
-0.0743241683,
0.4516828358,
-0.1608889252,
0.6118952632,
-0.1239995882,
0.1545483172,
-0.3743737936,
-0.1982179731,
-0.2417060435,
-0.3070366085,
-0.2663222551,
0.3472957313,
0.3337073922,
0.8074259162,
0.5109391212,
0.6885119677,
0.7319637537,
0.266784668,
0.1567196697,
0.4005427659,
-0.1999025941,
-0.085663259,
-0.2501772344,
-0.5492215157,
-0.0946917385,
-0.088197805,
0.2005082369,
0.4019375145,
0.1280228198,
0.4522049129,
-0.2089596391,
0.4908942878,
-0.827500999,
0.1801440567,
-0.5076873899,
0.2712055743,
-0.0363370292,
-0.5123121142,
-0.3221898377,
-0.1539640576,
0.0920657143,
-0.6923248768,
0.2937042415,
0.3318293095,
0.7650111318,
0.1251023561,
-0.4987488985,
-0.3842378557,
-0.5727902651,
0.5074121952,
-0.3175862134,
0.150243029,
0.4311256409,
0.518445015,
0.336461097,
-0.7251017094,
-0.7654066086,
-0.0188451502,
-0.120471403,
0.4567941129,
0.2199237049,
-0.3538473547,
0.1942510009,
0.494130671,
-0.6165904403,
0.0789752007,
-0.593351841,
-0.3084767759,
0.5961765647,
0.2254534662,
0.7208203673,
-0.3455971479,
-0.7545145154,
0.120411694,
-0.8196741939,
0.1353937089,
-0.1364599466,
0.0781535953,
-0.5139136314,
0.4916840196,
-0.6186612248,
0.3715638518,
-0.0222982671,
-0.1745465994,
0.0835126415,
-0.2898231745,
0.0856641456,
0.1371596456,
0.5330967903,
1.1683546305,
0.6773857474,
0.0038119152,
0.0626738593,
0.1137165204,
-0.2043418288,
-0.7832503319,
-0.1124310046,
-0.004368396,
-0.7628353238,
-0.3600047827,
0.3659642935,
-0.6604896784,
-0.6348043084,
-0.4264011085,
-0.3598091304,
-0.1036646515,
-0.2509537935,
-0.157317102,
-0.0597768314,
0.8488950133,
0.2744078934,
-0.7171535492,
-0.0260307342,
0.1209500208,
0.6731309891,
-0.2708173096,
-0.0061188559,
-0.2863226831,
0.355047375,
-0.3146939278,
0.6071953773,
-0.3626390398,
-0.3690865636,
0.246773079,
0.2695828974,
0.4993000627,
-0.3314330578,
0.3689878285,
-0.5884792805,
0.1450838894,
-0.6710144281,
-0.0511273332,
-0.1831965595,
0.3234995008,
-0.7403727174,
0.3313530087,
-0.0921996608,
-0.8958166838,
0.5084834099,
-0.6413040161,
-0.5550578833,
0.7044504285,
-0.3222388029,
-0.1604961306,
-0.1455268413,
0.7621177435,
0.4670084715,
-0.3618327081,
-0.0083702104,
-0.2526974678,
-0.6743878722,
0.45609653,
-0.0894376636,
0.8788398504,
0.7101642489,
-0.5597407818,
-0.0401138589,
-0.5121169686,
0.0419769064,
0.2127602398,
-0.0748326033,
-0.276745379,
-0.0493922904,
0.0772689804,
0.1260278672,
0.4011629522,
-0.4043698013,
-0.1588939875,
0.042966608,
0.4628776312,
0.6874504685,
0.1202666685,
0.5885712504,
-0.2200976312,
0.7342022061,
-0.007023559,
0.2395677418,
-0.6971417665,
-0.0424329042,
-0.6803216338,
-0.5657542348,
-0.0750117302,
0.6950935125,
-1.3662952185,
0.3143853545,
-0.3743260503,
-0.5471145511,
-0.261769563,
0.0074592424,
0.3635522127,
0.4493037164,
0.0198885333,
-0.5529071689,
-0.5917810798,
-0.925742209,
0.3138626814,
-0.2947795689,
-0.1407840252,
0.3357723951,
0.3865954876,
0.0029593089,
0.6934068799,
-0.3892869353,
-0.3280642033,
-0.151986599,
0.0690162182,
-0.1959701926,
0.3659432828,
0.592553854,
-1.0618854761,
-0.5682719946,
0.0981573686,
-0.923992455,
-0.1519973725,
-0.2433405221,
-0.3526865542,
0.4388635159,
0.7313297391,
-0.1095129102,
0.4182862043,
0.371801585,
-0.1443596035,
0.743072331,
0.1136762425,
0.5287930369,
-1.1120994091,
0.2416497022,
-0.0484260768,
-0.1130094379,
-0.0138065964,
0.4054887891,
0.0806935206,
-0.307081759,
-0.6401358843,
0.4902498722,
-0.619022429,
0.0385095626,
-0.0401126035,
-0.1078051999,
-0.0002250728,
0.6323312521,
0.6980827451,
0.5478835702,
0.7843353748,
-0.4092012346,
0.4335868061,
0.2661553621,
-0.6885916591,
1.1565549374,
-0.4638220966,
0.0817701146,
-0.4640675783,
0.2515815198,
-0.8858363032,
-0.4256888032,
0.3068208694,
-0.3945300281,
-0.0268853325,
-0.0933062881,
-0.5890188217,
-0.5885566473,
-0.1649507582,
0.5717009306,
0.4635221064,
-0.6082104445,
0.4319399595,
-0.0174644589,
-0.2000124156,
-0.4640292525,
-0.8198820353,
0.0545941144,
-0.4989695251,
-0.6577435732,
-0.0674209073,
-0.2754983604,
0.0306439195,
-0.2593431771,
0.0652508289,
-0.1012358516,
0.0699527934,
0.1969475448,
0.3199870288,
-0.2133427858,
0.0420937799,
-0.2183305025,
0.3017567396,
0.0654971376,
-0.3110087812,
0.4264911711,
-0.3568896949,
-0.282088697,
-0.6122999787,
0.7656570673,
0.5911412835,
-0.9687252641,
0.2994630635,
0.7649793625,
-0.2725580633,
0.1925349534,
-0.345900327,
-0.0632854253,
-0.4487343132,
0.2957350314,
-0.321438849,
-0.8508268595,
0.6499769092,
0.0257905889,
-0.1076617762,
0.0549666397,
0.5737296343,
-0.4896806777,
0.9265498519,
0.5885906219,
0.0778610334,
0.4518040717,
-0.155434072,
0.0804449394,
-0.3583189845,
-0.1342534274,
-0.3707220852,
-0.3124473393,
-0.8342051506,
-0.4421336651,
0.4596270919,
-0.1132285148,
-0.5229606628,
-0.026894588,
-0.4906928241,
0.6998838782,
0.5985494256,
0.141427502,
0.2744064927,
0.3600925207,
0.0150852595,
-0.1004471108,
-0.4988449514,
-0.633761704,
0.8231608868,
0.1651314199,
0.7682939768,
0.1449593604,
0.4395240843,
0.4102988243,
0.5293633938,
-0.5373736024,
0.606413126,
-0.2984363735,
-0.6229171753,
0.1183370426,
-0.2421416938,
-0.4509444237,
-0.1539908946,
-0.3579342663,
-0.5567703843,
0.2049709558,
0.3156742156,
-0.2773914337,
0.1550804228,
-0.4614054859,
0.4448693395,
-0.5217060447,
-0.2043275386,
0.2567121983,
-1.0143108368,
0.4876978993,
0.2693251073,
0.2619361579,
0.0529340804,
0.1193049923,
0.3941120803,
0.001765433,
1.024373889,
-0.2006174177,
0.1530276239,
0.6321307421,
0.223318547,
-0.0256079752,
0.0016849235,
0.275690794,
0.1084492579,
0.1241153479,
-0.5104218721,
-0.4202111959,
0.402215749,
-0.5074211359,
-0.4103569388,
-0.0797739029,
-0.4311522245,
0.0514193401,
0.1160418689,
0.4379292428,
0.3738709092,
-0.0301289726,
0.4007680714,
0.5008827448,
-0.4806698859,
0.3472977281,
0.4258707464,
-0.184305951,
-0.5975119472,
0.7052468657,
-0.1680024862,
0.1297494322,
0.4740664661,
-0.0511166528,
-0.1050119549,
-0.2968678772,
-0.5193001032,
0.1463433057,
-0.8538436294,
-0.3335965574,
-0.1012919247,
-0.0400670022,
-0.312992245,
-0.5318786502,
0.1679689139,
-0.1028017998,
-0.1339687854,
-0.0898590237,
0.1384592056,
0.1585711092,
0.0511161089,
0.5669781566,
-0.6140124202,
0.2998508811,
0.3394208848,
0.3140081763,
-0.0665656477,
-0.0404386707,
-0.1830525696,
0.1433624029,
-0.1462454647,
-0.6666534543,
0.2659281492,
0.0863455832,
0.2898235619,
0.7326127291,
0.4053848386,
0.5994828939,
-0.2255369425,
1.0068637133,
0.5009920001,
-0.6815092564,
0.5348221064,
-0.2570025921,
0.6502728462,
0.3419784307,
0.4253666401,
-0.7188448906,
-0.4578225613,
-0.2067021579,
-0.8094987273,
0.1462517083,
-0.0567247681,
0.3476547003,
-0.3199765086,
0.1703895777,
-0.0270786807,
0.0940756127,
-0.9222239852,
0.170680657,
-0.4522953033,
-0.2794723511,
0.1799040884,
-0.2345977128,
-0.1549042761,
-0.1049974486,
0.3782145679,
-0.5376150012,
0.117475681,
0.5053017735,
-0.3479139805,
-0.1245235056,
0.0727424026,
0.4368022978,
0.6088914275,
0.0614282973,
0.0368452631,
-0.0199095272,
-0.0904010832,
-0.214744091,
-0.1859693676,
-0.3939914405,
-0.4222016633,
0.4618824124,
0.542902112,
-0.4184880555,
-0.8820723891,
0.4202254415,
-0.2784193456,
-0.1448217332,
-0.7399493456,
-0.291297406,
0.0050698328,
0.1542516947,
0.3278006911,
-0.0741245523,
0.2109673619,
-0.5591152906,
0.1419845074,
0.292088598,
-0.4382841587,
-0.028352933,
0.7356160283,
0.5619804859,
0.0912386775,
0.7499790788,
-0.0776562989,
-0.656003654,
0.6136692762,
0.3614587188,
0.3757828176,
-0.0225631204,
0.5999317169,
0.5196875334,
0.3826793134,
0.3248419762,
0.5418086052,
-0.3086717129,
-0.6771253347,
-0.507573247,
-0.5221021175,
-0.1145766824,
-0.2546088398,
-0.6725720167,
0.3434189856,
-0.5106526017,
0.1892871708,
-0.3767969012,
-0.166216284,
-0.869122088,
0.4724611044,
0.6303642988,
0.9104946852,
-0.9570989609,
0.2955065668,
0.8423754573,
-0.6361612678,
-0.7414066792,
-0.1603257954,
-0.0559221879,
-0.6281806231,
0.5257585049,
0.3467929065,
-0.0645061135,
-0.3250508606,
-1.2150173187,
-0.6677643657,
1.1824580431,
0.1091767401,
-0.3370381594,
0.1509736627,
0.2969985306,
0.5802605152,
-0.905305624,
-0.0321000665,
0.1708174646,
0.3757443428,
0.5391725898,
-0.55209589,
0.0318026654,
-0.4526837468,
0.1672123224,
-0.4921446443,
-0.5284822583,
0.3812374175,
-0.4450606406,
-0.340677321,
0.6758246422,
0.9690777659,
0.4223878086,
0.4456016421,
0.6628311276,
0.0150294043,
0.5914617181,
-0.2225234509,
1.113812089,
-0.08717639,
-0.1359485984,
1.181101799,
-0.2624716759,
0.4745302796,
0.390869379,
0.3066568375,
0.5436010361,
0.7664120793,
-0.1769918948,
0.4718139172,
0.5133148432,
-0.200889796,
-0.3717362881,
-0.6666833162,
-0.1221273988,
0.8810645938,
0.0284257904,
-0.5988403559,
0.1913170218,
0.039496351,
-0.0120194349,
0.5815392733,
-0.5074332356,
0.8241128325,
-0.0780066773,
-0.6313974261,
0.5155243278,
-0.2166020721,
0.558226347,
-0.4459914863,
-0.100089401,
-0.3703185618,
-0.3718910515,
-0.2226596922,
-0.6142397523,
0.015790876,
0.1417865455,
-0.3096804619,
-0.0158066917,
0.4023085237,
-0.6944907904,
-0.6445394158,
-0.2732037902,
0.2886806726,
0.2408103198,
0.1274373084,
-0.256411463,
-0.1399320811,
0.1477713138,
0.3896820545,
-0.3563525677,
0.3648289144,
-0.7420176864,
0.491269052,
0.609692812,
0.0002872016,
-0.0466716699,
0.2279244512,
0.3316571414,
-0.4532746077,
-0.7830748558,
-0.285212785,
0.7407286167,
-0.348588109,
0.0894725248,
0.135620892,
0.3112170398,
0.960057497,
-0.4600694478,
0.9754937887,
-0.4673290253,
0.0722089112,
-0.4747729301,
0.8047359586,
-0.6143864393,
0.0341995545,
-0.1041983366,
-0.8782988787,
-0.3520965278,
0.4069144428,
0.0190150458,
-0.1441484094,
0.5526405573,
0.9596914053,
0.1868017763,
0.2027769089,
0.1469026059,
-0.0242963303,
0.2562426627,
0.2997285724,
1.0387313366,
0.125403598,
0.6240206957,
-0.5164356232,
-0.3399511278,
0.2171513438,
-1.085970521,
-0.6657142639,
-0.8752579093,
-0.4692781568,
0.1074365079,
-0.2005860507,
0.8318781257,
0.7311327457,
-0.7076044083,
-0.2144958824,
0.4486240447,
-0.1071042269,
-0.2808212042,
-0.2355662882,
0.4004594386,
0.0686832815,
-0.7083550096,
-0.3170515001,
0.0722421855,
0.0983784869,
-0.3259164393,
-0.1069982052,
0.0449221767,
-0.1598382145,
0.6250953674,
0.1994711161,
-0.6281709671,
-0.4583120346,
0.1277876645,
-0.0105375471,
-0.1823310107,
0.8464882374,
-0.3651028574,
0.6551554799,
0.3627839684,
0.3358864486,
0.1211730167,
0.076799795,
0.6601246595,
-0.7400413156,
0.1151421666,
0.1031589732,
0.5175119638,
0.7455981374,
-0.3748726547,
0.524615705,
0.1309351623,
-0.2038169205,
-0.2593730986,
0.4375136495,
-1.2690855265,
-0.143632561,
1.0024666786,
-0.4113724828,
-0.3726220727,
0.2620221376,
-0.5614888668,
0.1163884252,
0.0108885635,
0.7172150016,
0.4823384583,
0.5011350513,
-0.4582754672,
0.0312674157,
0.0723734722,
0.225077942,
-0.7254759073,
0.0445554703,
0.7503097653,
0.3474389017,
0.1118087843,
0.4469663799,
-0.4564234614,
0.66705513,
-0.6422082782,
0.6181441545,
-0.0892450958,
-0.2030962855,
0.1585169286,
0.117878519,
-0.0692306757,
-0.2595903575
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05369v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05369v2
|
Noise Contrastive Alignment of Language Models with Explicit Rewards
| 2024-02-08T02:58:47 | 2024-07-03T13:53:06 |
Huayu Chen, Guande He, Lifan Yuan, Ganqu Cui, Hang Su, Jun Zhu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
User intentions are typically formalized as evaluation rewards to be
maximized when fine-tuning language models (LMs). Existing alignment methods,
such as Direct Preference Optimization (DPO), are mainly tailored for pairwise
preference data where rewards are implicitly defined rather than explicitly
given. In this paper, we introduce a general framework for LM alignment,
leveraging Noise Contrastive Estimation (NCE) to bridge the gap in handling
reward datasets explicitly annotated with scalar evaluations. Our framework
comprises two parallel algorithms, NCA and InfoNCA, both enabling the direct
extraction of an LM policy from reward data as well as preference data.
Notably, we show that the DPO loss is a special case of our proposed InfoNCA
objective under pairwise preference settings, thereby integrating and extending
current alignment theories. By comparing NCA and InfoNCA, we demonstrate that
the well-observed decreasing-likelihood trend of DPO/InfoNCA is caused by their
focus on adjusting relative likelihood across different responses. In contrast,
NCA optimizes the absolute likelihood for each response, thereby effectively
preventing the chosen likelihood from decreasing. We evaluate our methods in
both reward and preference settings with Mistral-8*7B and 7B models.
Experiments suggest that InfoNCA/NCA surpasses various preference baselines
when reward datasets are available. We also find NCA significantly outperforms
DPO in complex reasoning tasks like math and coding.
|
[
-0.3151398897,
-0.3287144303,
0.6173818111,
0.0936867669,
-0.1330751777,
-0.1802457571,
-0.4559791386,
-0.1760774553,
0.2009955496,
0.3944980502,
-0.6708419919,
-0.4061906934,
-0.5707524419,
-0.0674051195,
-0.0641659796,
0.9845392108,
-0.0224044975,
-0.0695392117,
-0.2762733996,
-0.119182609,
-0.5764356256,
-0.2313046604,
-0.6805225611,
-0.1379409432,
0.8699022532,
0.47178635,
0.7624340653,
0.972830236,
0.6734657884,
0.228705436,
-0.1277377009,
0.2545224428,
-0.6764678955,
0.0040226248,
-0.1477980763,
-0.2695710957,
-0.1229172722,
-0.1138551906,
0.403491199,
0.4688587487,
-0.1327557117,
-0.1147913486,
0.2496955693,
0.8929738402,
-0.974937439,
0.0979995504,
-0.4878286421,
-0.0983364433,
-0.2066895664,
-0.3281137347,
-0.1939335614,
-0.5562970042,
0.1854958832,
-0.7713037729,
-0.3063625693,
-0.062676765,
1.1154108047,
0.5762578845,
-0.1278315783,
-0.3492451608,
-0.6420244575,
1.1124798059,
-0.564101994,
0.3844136894,
0.3313008547,
0.1789248735,
-0.1429216713,
-0.1342771202,
-0.5348294973,
-0.0539384894,
-0.1893935651,
0.222662285,
-0.3035477996,
0.1937014312,
0.0884821266,
0.5417837501,
-0.5076127648,
0.5033558011,
-0.2046758533,
-0.1146080941,
0.3400250375,
0.2061516941,
0.0490427986,
0.2804338932,
-0.3239239752,
-0.2759436667,
-0.6262463331,
0.2861374021,
0.6180438995,
0.5270396471,
-0.388201952,
0.4574912488,
-0.1935200095,
1.0039894581,
0.5059483647,
-0.0296508968,
0.1812459528,
-0.4671109915,
-0.0136049381,
0.2051561028,
0.8326182961,
0.4732881188,
0.0753292963,
-0.2545947433,
-0.1291703582,
0.1674782336,
0.0782642439,
-0.680539608,
-0.0944879502,
0.3532550335,
-0.3292393386,
-0.6171937585,
-0.0193826724,
-0.6545645595,
-0.6341947317,
-0.8808341026,
0.2348262966,
-0.0478671566,
-0.2977842093,
0.2957177758,
0.1663274169,
0.3539306819,
0.1106392294,
-1.2253701687,
0.3371022344,
0.9394322634,
0.6292092204,
-0.4148305058,
-0.1432274878,
-0.7265719175,
-0.1139151007,
-0.318059206,
0.6970679164,
-0.6559163928,
0.1536884308,
0.0950006843,
-0.2621783912,
-0.0744473338,
-0.5375900865,
0.8195610642,
-0.496750921,
0.4109744728,
-0.5410056114,
-0.6207700372,
0.0053842301,
0.1872068346,
-0.7900616527,
0.8464227319,
0.0646978766,
-1.1013233662,
0.5390683413,
-0.5398035645,
-0.0620807074,
-0.4184058011,
-0.2891848981,
-0.4023945332,
0.0739544183,
0.2498038262,
0.256075561,
-0.4570766389,
0.4922302067,
-0.446888715,
-0.6196682453,
0.1550604403,
-0.1333791614,
0.6781284213,
0.2671654522,
-0.4142714143,
0.439162761,
-0.5337182283,
-0.2623098195,
-0.0012495596,
-0.2063505203,
-0.5538359284,
0.0725091994,
-0.2525808811,
0.3054305017,
0.4781316221,
-0.4643872678,
0.1708244085,
-0.4493490756,
0.0332930498,
1.1379822493,
-0.4338504076,
0.5424374938,
-0.3115941584,
0.3829093575,
0.155799821,
0.251046747,
0.3309106827,
-0.0348032117,
-0.682531774,
-0.4201231599,
0.4704263806,
0.3430787027,
-0.1237001196,
0.6555093527,
-0.4153722823,
0.0267704707,
-0.9070100784,
0.1406058073,
0.4788860083,
0.6918921471,
0.3005365431,
-0.0376636684,
-0.5515109897,
-1.1392424107,
-0.1954439878,
-0.0358786508,
0.0976381674,
0.2916289866,
-0.395054996,
0.1024469212,
0.8331512809,
-0.4305435717,
-0.2078171074,
0.0825995654,
0.0396119952,
0.5494143367,
0.4354664683,
0.3560453057,
-0.8378019333,
-0.4740992188,
0.1290056556,
-0.5273709297,
-0.3534499407,
-0.0753150061,
-0.3610813618,
-0.0019445167,
0.2058327496,
-0.0323634557,
0.2142127752,
0.8336464167,
-0.1940668672,
0.4188849628,
0.1544523537,
0.2683885992,
-0.9775798321,
0.0856003165,
0.0338463224,
-0.012209055,
-0.577702105,
-0.2960282266,
-0.0638155863,
0.2139983475,
-0.0437326916,
0.7058891654,
-0.3364629447,
-0.0761635602,
-0.4368904531,
0.1186269969,
-0.1006478518,
0.6666371226,
0.4042622447,
0.6185498834,
0.5842265487,
-0.7464368343,
-0.1136422902,
0.0978286192,
-0.3236961365,
0.7323450446,
-0.4720568359,
0.1628128439,
-0.1351883411,
-0.3257415295,
-0.852319479,
0.0040176674,
0.4162982404,
-0.0328031667,
0.3764638901,
0.0205746051,
-0.0986558944,
0.0245762095,
-0.3567604423,
0.5753179193,
0.3125688732,
-0.8859967589,
0.1374051422,
0.3949088454,
-0.1775170416,
-1.0389614105,
-0.3306960762,
-0.1698303223,
-0.4586480856,
-0.4170411825,
0.5429512262,
-0.1570021361,
-0.4663515389,
0.0033120627,
-0.2866688669,
-0.1174494997,
-0.0264014732,
0.2032880485,
0.3996359408,
-0.2246436626,
0.1843914688,
0.1409897804,
-0.2317764312,
-0.2550992072,
-0.1070300639,
0.4916748703,
-0.1640627831,
-0.2139399797,
-0.4132812917,
0.1573757529,
0.0662337467,
-0.0665747672,
0.4739038944,
0.4732640088,
-0.0279719662,
0.2321716696,
-0.774627924,
-0.3272209466,
-0.4806631804,
0.195675835,
-0.3991050422,
-0.9387013912,
0.229571864,
0.0832167119,
0.324916333,
0.2738078237,
0.4219193459,
-0.0302484371,
0.9779271483,
0.6307817101,
-0.3087346554,
0.7571296096,
0.2185283452,
0.1297544092,
-0.761869669,
-0.0170680173,
-0.538850069,
-0.5066171288,
-0.5453947186,
-0.1493942142,
0.0714419335,
0.2830024958,
-0.3364979625,
0.2432118058,
-0.6828281879,
0.5179884434,
0.6323763728,
0.1093340218,
0.2621192932,
0.2449267507,
-0.0316705182,
-0.3085340559,
-0.6587737799,
-0.2632553279,
0.9963142276,
0.0834098309,
0.6341222525,
-0.0127909761,
0.8192350268,
0.0344581455,
0.1161418036,
-0.6966837645,
0.1800502837,
-0.2621025443,
-0.0691285878,
-0.340832293,
-0.5715913773,
-1.1088607311,
0.0673308969,
-0.2363035977,
-0.7795629501,
0.6750247478,
0.3902745843,
-0.254481107,
0.0230693966,
-0.3241279125,
0.939586997,
-0.2942448854,
-0.5349362493,
-0.172881186,
-0.5826708078,
0.4677270651,
0.0274926852,
0.2099869549,
-0.2342844158,
0.0490737744,
0.583032608,
-0.2975783348,
0.5465406179,
-0.0553705804,
-0.1873063147,
-0.1357610971,
0.004895288,
0.6750943065,
-0.3943375945,
-0.3308730125,
0.081963174,
-0.2094763368,
-0.3859807551,
-0.7128602266,
1.0148444176,
-0.6705064178,
-0.4323454499,
-0.2971667349,
-0.7714042664,
-0.311562717,
0.0300320927,
0.0843001083,
0.2227590829,
-0.1749426425,
-0.0809781179,
0.5609882474,
-0.040125981,
0.1788017005,
0.5257149935,
-0.0397417098,
-0.3374454379,
1.0879238844,
-0.345113188,
0.3061839938,
0.6734063625,
0.6020103097,
-0.5495779514,
-0.5957816243,
-0.1714249104,
0.322645843,
-0.5294169784,
0.0001893607,
-0.3835372925,
0.2520831525,
-0.3191785514,
-0.3033154011,
-0.2809426486,
-0.3980665803,
-0.0555951074,
-0.0984893516,
0.3298152685,
0.4271465838,
-0.3008407652,
0.1676557511,
-0.2556477785,
0.2484260648,
0.3036727309,
0.3596196473,
-0.4700059891,
-0.5716381669,
-0.165722698,
0.1142015979,
0.0222246833,
-0.5020520091,
0.0568148717,
-0.145813182,
0.4356164634,
0.5890955925,
0.176123932,
0.9385721684,
0.0197507665,
0.2891267538,
0.4321362972,
-0.6844305396,
0.3252572417,
-0.2253128886,
0.4016925395,
1.0113946199,
0.2835157514,
-0.5146840215,
-0.1953360587,
-0.3051224649,
-0.6582430005,
0.8192276359,
0.1836813837,
-0.2271152139,
0.1146968529,
0.2801705003,
0.1038175672,
0.1632585377,
-0.7625454068,
-0.2169135213,
0.0068376237,
-0.5985034108,
0.0463346802,
-0.2340008318,
-0.3973657489,
0.0338576064,
0.7397143841,
-0.1346773207,
-0.0874209926,
-0.1162440926,
0.0729540214,
-0.06272991,
0.2993436456,
0.6316584945,
0.5473673344,
-0.347958982,
0.0051961443,
-0.3369163573,
-0.0626892745,
0.1238651723,
0.1678286642,
-0.31537655,
-0.2145658433,
-0.0848641321,
1.098143816,
0.4838858843,
-0.5745555162,
0.6755592823,
-0.1333701909,
-0.0995901674,
0.0803294256,
-0.1149632484,
0.0894222409,
-0.038228292,
-0.336497277,
-0.0879832357,
0.3202254772,
-0.1879915297,
0.0335591361,
0.5141683817,
-0.8931087255,
-0.2275121212,
0.4320462048,
-0.0181463491,
0.0014146686,
0.4374658167,
-0.003472381,
0.0710086301,
0.4563668072,
0.3717720211,
0.952329576,
-0.2983481884,
0.1505715251,
0.5536037087,
0.1069078967,
-0.0842909738,
0.2451570928,
-0.2190232724,
-0.8840733767,
-0.3761331141,
-0.6708605289,
-0.3002449572,
0.2408651263,
-0.82546103,
0.4912371337,
-0.2064558119,
0.2193130851,
0.2013651133,
-0.2573492229,
-0.7183641195,
0.0550559834,
0.0325357877,
0.2743202746,
-0.6717767715,
0.7309415936,
0.4558531344,
-0.3547771275,
-0.8282089829,
-0.0828996301,
0.207557112,
-0.8447709084,
0.6033580899,
0.038484361,
-0.3370480537,
-0.1407189369,
-0.2399356663,
-0.9241073728,
0.7736853361,
0.6749866009,
-0.9324276447,
0.1082120538,
0.1075454354,
0.2564354241,
-0.478615582,
0.1767595559,
0.6136760116,
0.7124580145,
0.1722528189,
-0.8172851801,
0.1429060847,
-0.0883460864,
-0.2430410236,
0.4494511485,
-0.4456628561,
0.5039008856,
-0.0479759313,
-0.2012609243,
-0.0537556559,
0.3696655333,
0.4310365319,
0.1102370322,
0.7873122692,
0.5810335875,
0.8130275607,
-0.104662247,
1.0179213285,
-0.3191882074,
0.0327125564,
1.3818430901,
-0.1961226016,
0.4774242938,
0.8026788831,
-0.1434692144,
0.4168887138,
0.7050307989,
0.2506554723,
0.736979723,
0.363515079,
-0.2168076336,
-0.2533014715,
-0.3920761347,
-0.2804955244,
0.3191397488,
0.0983912647,
-0.3419286013,
-0.0718990266,
-0.3901800215,
-0.0232188832,
0.3180070817,
-0.3055585325,
1.0574471951,
-0.1061948091,
-0.9947628975,
0.676548183,
-0.2821036279,
0.7193213701,
-0.6082502007,
-0.014666236,
-0.2853365541,
0.2227662355,
-0.2479399145,
-0.4798741043,
0.19933258,
-0.1795210987,
-0.3146713078,
0.068136692,
0.490262568,
-0.7817357183,
-0.2096711248,
0.3108490705,
0.0253546759,
0.1997026503,
-0.120081678,
-0.889349401,
0.2614426613,
0.0780930817,
-0.0146480538,
0.6542232037,
0.026892662,
-0.0796192959,
0.2378510684,
0.5932191014,
0.0871758312,
-0.1702680141,
0.2290471196,
0.8150507212,
-0.5201519132,
-0.503567934,
-0.8385411501,
0.3765491247,
-0.2782012224,
-0.2446795106,
0.5237383246,
0.7904655933,
0.6534731984,
0.162149936,
0.6445592046,
0.218720153,
0.490862608,
-0.6877412796,
-0.0022353164,
-0.5437882543,
0.3907800615,
-0.3743171096,
-1.0293961763,
-0.2348083109,
0.48843503,
-0.3696635962,
-0.3127958775,
0.5580749512,
1.046195507,
-0.2857614756,
-0.1087370366,
0.2699832916,
-0.088128157,
0.0262522064,
0.5634403825,
0.7141680121,
-0.1004865468,
0.4829968512,
-0.5597821474,
-0.3286056817,
-0.0754124671,
-1.0319362879,
-0.5808284283,
-0.4607386291,
-0.5970174074,
-0.3452430367,
0.2086922675,
0.8606869578,
0.6305452585,
-0.9695310593,
-0.5950123668,
-0.3101878166,
0.328482151,
-0.6550807953,
-0.2299634218,
0.6103969216,
-0.5437681079,
-0.9894657731,
0.4482652545,
0.4845039248,
-0.1517266631,
0.0513116457,
-0.4413113296,
-0.1652202606,
0.0798057765,
0.0656916499,
0.5911992788,
-0.8380445242,
-0.1243971288,
-0.0202163178,
-0.1968565434,
0.310808301,
0.8683260679,
-0.4386858046,
0.7234632969,
0.5092749596,
0.6984026432,
0.4968990386,
0.1852295697,
0.8693134189,
-0.5731679797,
0.2029014975,
0.1489784122,
0.2835862339,
0.2653647363,
-0.3620069921,
0.5651581883,
-0.201985091,
-0.5819294453,
-0.8503967524,
0.2241167724,
-1.1640491486,
-0.1263632327,
1.0891480446,
-0.0480454378,
-0.1443644762,
-0.0926140249,
-0.2528761923,
0.0351110399,
-0.4716338515,
0.9293890595,
0.6322208643,
-0.1072804481,
-0.095667392,
0.0478356406,
0.9436064959,
0.7267204523,
-0.8066222072,
0.2178054452,
0.6180020571,
0.0421866141,
0.0939759389,
0.7680229545,
-0.2207834423,
0.4089697301,
-0.3273531199,
0.2975059748,
-0.1018112004,
-0.0697966516,
-0.7719322443,
-0.023236597,
0.1580546647,
-0.3421832323
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05359v6
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05359v6
|
An Examination on the Effectiveness of Divide-and-Conquer Prompting in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-08T02:37:30 | 2024-07-02T18:18:18 |
Yizhou Zhang, Lun Du, Defu Cao, Qiang Fu, Yan Liu
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Foundation models, such as Large language Models (LLMs), have attracted
significant amount of interest due to their large number of applications.
However, when handling tasks involving repetitive sub-tasks and/or deceptive
contents, such as arithmetic calculation and article-level fake news detection,
simple instructional prompts suffer from inaccurate responses. Existing works
show that more complicated prompting strategies, such as Chain-of-Thoughts and
Least-to-Most, can unlock LLM's powerful capacity in diverse areas. Recent
researches reveal that simple divide-and-conquer prompting strategy, i.e.
simply dividing the input sequence to multiple sub-inputs, can also
substantially improve LLM's performance in some specific tasks such as
misinformation detection. In this paper, we aim at examining the utility of
divide-and-conquer prompting strategy and answer on which kind of tasks this
strategy gets advantages. Specifically, we provide a theoretic analysis to
divide-and-conquer prompting strategy and help us identify the specific tasks
where DaC prompting can bring performance boost with theoretic guarantee. We
then present two cases (large integer arithmetic and fact verification) where
experimental results aligns with our theoretic analysis.
|
[
-0.7972677946,
-1.24033916,
0.6275473237,
0.4774137735,
-0.0480155423,
-0.0377835967,
-0.2125172168,
-0.2522091866,
-0.070695594,
-0.0832464397,
-0.7097945809,
-0.0592784397,
-0.7878988981,
0.3268973827,
-0.5002898574,
0.7022487521,
-0.0183022395,
0.1180931255,
-0.3893324435,
0.151163131,
-0.7369095087,
-0.5007309914,
-0.8122239113,
-0.3225620389,
0.6056214571,
0.5916421413,
0.4455181956,
0.6671683788,
0.2869981825,
0.3025688827,
-0.3411004245,
0.3361490965,
-0.2911882699,
0.1849028766,
-0.0124041401,
-0.5836825967,
-0.2074026912,
0.0397822075,
0.6338870525,
0.6980335116,
-0.3830244243,
-0.1900906712,
0.0153313819,
0.8087726235,
-0.7138953805,
-0.1079206243,
-0.4087239206,
-0.188707903,
-0.1268892884,
-0.2380441278,
-0.6147329807,
-0.3608008623,
0.0909605324,
-0.3979337215,
0.046207983,
-0.0018260977,
0.453045398,
0.1593903899,
-0.6205419898,
-0.7760876417,
-0.4809720218,
0.721011281,
-0.4480179846,
0.3259476721,
0.513356626,
0.1801742911,
-0.2073324025,
-0.4035712481,
-0.7211948633,
-0.207333684,
0.0654138699,
-0.0261704493,
-0.4408113956,
0.1107346639,
0.5253485441,
0.5035758615,
-0.3670170009,
0.4130687416,
-0.2850809693,
-0.1591503173,
0.2987538874,
0.1822813451,
0.5556067824,
-0.0092679914,
-0.3605846465,
-0.2861162126,
-0.9204686284,
0.2644135058,
0.3679486513,
0.1085406095,
-0.1161224246,
0.5394993424,
-0.2451152653,
0.9323065281,
0.5230594873,
-0.4361878633,
-0.2013594806,
-0.3654923439,
-0.2302342504,
0.0663629249,
0.439414531,
0.1274983138,
0.2537426651,
0.0966221839,
-0.1824581772,
0.1669101417,
0.1886085719,
-0.9607705474,
0.0877035409,
0.2623816729,
-0.1443981379,
-0.3923642337,
-0.1935736686,
-0.6916744113,
-0.3618164659,
-0.3719380796,
0.3596672714,
-0.6697314978,
-0.0611323602,
0.3212394714,
0.085621044,
-0.056556277,
0.5419618487,
-1.0233209133,
0.1723517925,
0.8727083206,
0.699823916,
-0.4749478698,
-0.2634118795,
-0.9015467763,
-0.3790082633,
-0.4542163312,
0.6085602641,
-0.3222580254,
-0.363535285,
0.043502681,
-0.3965102732,
-0.2844433486,
-0.6265841126,
0.6062125564,
-0.7998353839,
0.297919333,
-0.9108560681,
-0.6713961959,
-0.2219693363,
0.5669543743,
-0.9462771416,
0.7713161707,
-0.2687556744,
-0.9091056585,
0.2198993713,
-0.62926054,
-0.6994978786,
-0.0676552728,
-0.179682821,
0.0446442999,
0.0498059168,
0.59265697,
0.2963980138,
-0.332810849,
0.2993760109,
0.0427107885,
-0.1505242437,
0.5684350133,
-0.8741726875,
0.8137291074,
0.0659540445,
-0.4481655955,
-0.1710393876,
-0.2693042457,
-0.1660608202,
0.0116716921,
-0.6020492315,
-0.361289531,
-0.2570846975,
-0.6755799651,
0.1065139771,
0.0604181811,
-0.41110304,
0.3720703721,
-0.4355114996,
0.0731750876,
0.7892173529,
0.1560693681,
0.3899892271,
-0.4718064964,
0.7817748785,
0.1527899653,
0.0120050795,
-0.3280027807,
-0.4004231989,
-0.7410342097,
-0.599430263,
0.4779052138,
0.4502507448,
-0.9329907894,
0.0870809034,
0.0618024357,
-0.0715896636,
-0.331543982,
-0.0254082922,
0.3899326324,
0.4427841604,
0.165967077,
0.0546092428,
-0.3940605819,
-0.6222545505,
-0.0627191961,
-0.090686962,
0.2035561204,
0.1515132189,
0.3685035706,
0.1437732726,
0.8701213002,
-0.0995326713,
0.2157190442,
-0.3467297256,
0.1596436799,
0.1137058511,
0.0299999882,
0.4206545651,
-1.1726878881,
-0.6145542264,
-0.3562104404,
-0.3928204477,
-0.2394673079,
0.0007222649,
0.1199693084,
0.3212904036,
0.1547857076,
-0.8562610745,
0.4471775889,
0.7113888264,
-0.293815136,
0.8868133426,
0.0127769401,
0.5312616825,
-0.6760231853,
-0.0937352702,
-0.0528265983,
-0.1123280376,
-0.7695351243,
0.1171550974,
-0.0647970214,
0.3463521302,
-0.3187070191,
0.2766480446,
-0.4410338998,
0.193399176,
-0.5489917994,
0.1248702556,
-0.1827156991,
0.1856402457,
-0.1191745177,
1.0599837303,
0.5593214035,
-0.9611434937,
0.4538338482,
-0.0035197951,
-0.3675769866,
0.825355649,
-0.5675034523,
0.0455015264,
-0.1169998348,
0.3348929584,
-1.0753722191,
-0.1624562591,
-0.0223871171,
-0.3590718806,
0.1891443133,
0.0507181846,
-0.6574020386,
-0.4142037928,
-0.2286316752,
0.5196421742,
0.5207002163,
-1.1259739399,
0.4804584682,
-0.1365671456,
-0.2076873034,
-0.7730180621,
-0.3566099703,
-0.0502392389,
-0.3069936335,
-0.7062059641,
0.3036033511,
-0.3554914892,
-0.4971589446,
-0.2719215155,
-0.2939916849,
0.3288558424,
0.115008533,
0.3958116174,
0.3672499657,
-0.1185468659,
-0.0777098387,
0.091380246,
0.0096454322,
0.1988529265,
-0.2224345505,
0.691031754,
-0.0588787608,
-0.6483197808,
-0.4119116664,
0.1733420938,
0.5752106309,
-0.1101690531,
0.6332994699,
0.0550918803,
-0.1582276672,
-0.2864862084,
-0.8697965145,
-0.3052425981,
-0.4860692918,
-0.0266244411,
-0.4293961823,
-1.0093169212,
0.1884174794,
-0.2458411306,
0.0265007038,
0.3830906749,
0.8384760618,
0.1448088437,
1.10493958,
0.3679076433,
-0.2079243511,
0.1724782139,
-0.1714458466,
0.1652115285,
-0.5101873279,
-0.3118335307,
-0.5960349441,
-0.2420318574,
-0.0906900316,
-0.5342566371,
0.3850501776,
0.3219441473,
0.0839920789,
0.013284564,
-0.2824546397,
0.6886562705,
0.4993632138,
-0.213840723,
0.5291751623,
0.3801417351,
-0.3840524256,
-0.0048713232,
-0.8923371434,
-0.1010938138,
0.6859093308,
0.3052642941,
0.572863102,
0.1283672601,
0.623018384,
0.5121359229,
0.1502942443,
-0.9590315819,
0.4759036899,
0.0734102353,
-0.5828319788,
-0.3492429852,
-0.4872309268,
-0.8014032245,
0.2830042243,
0.0495852903,
-0.5754686594,
0.5110471845,
0.0702701136,
-0.4330711365,
0.3805186749,
-0.4750034213,
0.4772721231,
-0.2822728157,
0.0485028364,
-0.417348057,
-0.2162529677,
0.4416162372,
-0.1464411169,
0.3084515035,
0.4230804741,
0.0417860039,
0.6829891801,
-0.3741972148,
0.8475269079,
-0.109169066,
-0.274148941,
0.3466139138,
0.3331491351,
0.8170521855,
-0.2149872184,
0.023629237,
-0.2392388731,
-0.1939468384,
-0.2157883793,
-0.6165846586,
0.6456395984,
-0.4619363844,
-0.7185838819,
-0.4118458927,
-0.6316316724,
-0.2657620013,
0.0362137705,
0.5393815637,
0.4213444293,
-0.2186181396,
0.3689931333,
1.051766634,
0.1252292246,
0.619519949,
0.5396162868,
-0.1554022282,
-0.3907266259,
0.6086372137,
0.0295840222,
0.4912094176,
0.2980844975,
0.2104271501,
-0.3823538721,
-0.5323201418,
-0.6604945064,
0.2051418871,
-0.6913277507,
-0.2324384153,
-0.5199107528,
-0.0586995631,
-0.1936789602,
-0.0767687038,
-0.0089952312,
-0.3506911695,
-0.0452571362,
-0.342929244,
0.2306104004,
0.8387254477,
-0.1414365172,
0.3200407624,
-0.3847470284,
0.2377780676,
0.7407758236,
-0.2392765582,
0.4472113848,
-0.5695026517,
-0.2059797794,
0.2142858207,
-0.2586039007,
-0.9309596419,
0.1572361737,
-0.2724058032,
0.5478616953,
0.52468431,
0.0474569462,
0.4522772431,
-0.2917871475,
0.6608333588,
0.3274452984,
-0.8522340655,
0.0515036881,
-0.1561907232,
0.2179267704,
0.2923538089,
0.6377165914,
-0.5919696689,
-0.1077462509,
-0.7087869048,
-0.4292574525,
0.7275393605,
0.1406911761,
-0.1302750409,
0.0434372351,
0.2379370779,
0.037828885,
0.3152537644,
-0.4761890471,
-0.3285700679,
0.1907650828,
0.0086190505,
0.3771492839,
-0.6914697886,
-0.3950626552,
0.1543114185,
0.7553303838,
0.029594874,
-0.0640778467,
0.109388046,
-0.1049524993,
-0.2213228494,
0.5670824647,
0.6894190907,
0.7425872087,
0.3706300557,
0.2423761338,
0.3145271242,
-0.3798595965,
0.3775064945,
0.0701629519,
-0.3900101483,
-0.1729106903,
0.5009552836,
0.8232511878,
-0.3253887594,
-0.4484685063,
0.5896344185,
0.1728699505,
-0.3477668166,
0.2396960855,
0.1356301755,
0.1930256933,
0.2284447998,
0.7236974835,
-0.1691532135,
0.1062145755,
-0.4844660759,
-0.0592715181,
0.3650331199,
-0.008962105,
-0.128476873,
0.1382813752,
-0.0006760044,
-0.3970303833,
0.5720805526,
-0.4349906743,
-1.013908267,
0.7514004111,
0.6441527605,
0.4671808779,
-0.4808472395,
0.4109679461,
0.1677650958,
0.2965150476,
-0.3413713872,
-0.0253244173,
-0.237049669,
-0.685726881,
-0.9958856106,
-0.5056712031,
-0.2913807034,
0.1393073648,
-0.5511894822,
0.0192218348,
-0.2624785006,
-0.0589812547,
0.1873047054,
0.0209284965,
-0.3862609267,
0.399466306,
0.2880278528,
1.1565762758,
-0.6771402359,
0.6416301727,
0.4884211421,
-0.0615724139,
-1.1996155977,
-0.0025073243,
0.2408237606,
-0.7575370073,
0.8856237531,
0.122587353,
-0.1830930412,
-0.234130621,
-0.5997719765,
-0.5456402302,
0.7988339663,
0.2473663688,
-0.6862773299,
-0.2403600514,
0.2542484403,
0.375472784,
-0.4949532449,
0.1102011874,
0.6876295805,
0.5852169991,
0.5824221373,
-0.9032082558,
0.2859954834,
-0.0457327329,
-0.0881483331,
0.1386527568,
-0.370882988,
0.9441745281,
-0.4036218524,
-0.1431745291,
-0.0685912296,
0.5720399618,
0.6171301007,
0.3721657395,
0.9856003523,
0.4654835761,
0.8568775654,
-0.1085747927,
1.0066232681,
-0.1276895702,
0.1246000826,
0.6370587349,
-0.0662338883,
0.4926875234,
0.3928565681,
-0.2624937296,
0.7161350846,
0.5772797465,
0.1580918133,
0.3866681159,
0.074719131,
-0.3828597665,
-0.437374562,
-0.180379048,
-0.3843000233,
0.1187064201,
0.4239888489,
-0.0530354716,
-0.1280467659,
0.1342502683,
0.1619165689,
-0.0957682207,
-0.1953551769,
0.703846693,
0.1382155418,
-1.0740537643,
0.6550332904,
0.1237436607,
0.6931304336,
-0.555318892,
-0.0089431936,
-0.3388389051,
-0.1047032997,
-0.1625041664,
-0.5681677461,
-0.0804388747,
0.028442068,
-0.4633140266,
-0.1359541863,
0.678809166,
-0.5544105172,
-0.0690281764,
0.0935112983,
0.2989897132,
-0.190900594,
-0.3493310213,
-0.5757423639,
0.1128900498,
0.2570585012,
-0.2171028405,
0.3298600018,
0.6161549091,
-0.1451530606,
0.7451355457,
0.8731876612,
0.180362463,
0.0213657971,
0.0559256487,
0.7530729771,
-0.2102537304,
-0.6863389611,
-1.1146006584,
0.3147727847,
-0.07124497,
0.2898363769,
1.0344535112,
0.5320605636,
0.5504462123,
0.1327845603,
0.668168664,
-0.165662244,
0.4081098139,
-0.6507528424,
0.2112641037,
-0.4506908953,
0.3005014956,
0.0364873223,
-0.699424684,
0.1123512983,
0.2788049579,
-0.4257793128,
0.121600993,
0.8565918207,
0.6140738726,
0.0383958817,
0.372081995,
0.2438199818,
0.1906111985,
0.2121139169,
0.5352583528,
1.0042479038,
0.0410654619,
0.5005461574,
-0.1646149158,
-0.3289943933,
-0.4009658992,
-0.6951904297,
-0.995339334,
-0.3370367289,
-0.2031501979,
-0.7043449879,
0.0635950565,
0.865874052,
0.7240096331,
-0.8171799183,
-0.1889143884,
-0.1448363215,
0.3632305264,
-0.2524743378,
-0.124846153,
0.3548377156,
-0.0635937899,
-0.8197045326,
0.6384893656,
0.2066524923,
0.1814479381,
-0.3318478465,
-0.2148252726,
-0.2040801346,
0.3211978674,
0.5362874269,
0.3531826437,
-0.6543168426,
0.2776524723,
0.311756134,
-0.1734697223,
-0.111375846,
1.0643341541,
-0.5540653467,
0.4052506685,
0.6310526729,
0.7082204819,
0.484248817,
0.4327492714,
0.5176782012,
-0.6258332133,
-0.0470328331,
0.0382763408,
0.1574930996,
0.4565275908,
-0.4440218806,
0.2134347409,
0.3091908991,
-0.4270172119,
-0.7327009439,
0.1552579999,
-0.6908532977,
-0.2255970836,
1.2807945013,
-0.0081411069,
-0.2696743608,
0.2349773198,
-0.3352880478,
-0.089402698,
-0.4150006473,
0.6793531179,
1.0233371258,
0.0119426511,
-0.0056001069,
-0.2391681969,
0.5080937743,
0.7070296407,
-0.6798815131,
0.0855955482,
0.6430558562,
0.2551450133,
0.4029552042,
0.5683627129,
0.0933695659,
0.5303190947,
-0.2454296649,
-0.4123252034,
-0.3212097585,
-0.6691489816,
-0.4910320342,
0.1585695446,
0.138088122,
-0.0011220727
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14590v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14590v1
|
Scaling Up LLM Reviews for Google Ads Content Moderation
| 2024-02-07T23:47:02 | 2024-02-07T23:47:02 |
Wei Qiao, Tushar Dogra, Otilia Stretcu, Yu-Han Lyu, Tiantian Fang, Dongjin Kwon, Chun-Ta Lu, Enming Luo, Yuan Wang, Chih-Chun Chia, Ariel Fuxman, Fangzhou Wang, Ranjay Krishna, Mehmet Tek
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) are powerful tools for content moderation, but
their inference costs and latency make them prohibitive for casual use on large
datasets, such as the Google Ads repository. This study proposes a method for
scaling up LLM reviews for content moderation in Google Ads. First, we use
heuristics to select candidates via filtering and duplicate removal, and create
clusters of ads for which we select one representative ad per cluster. We then
use LLMs to review only the representative ads. Finally, we propagate the LLM
decisions for the representative ads back to their clusters. This method
reduces the number of reviews by more than 3 orders of magnitude while
achieving a 2x recall compared to a baseline non-LLM model. The success of this
approach is a strong function of the representations used in clustering and
label propagation; we found that cross-modal similarity representations yield
better results than uni-modal representations.
|
[
-0.5191907287,
-0.572142005,
0.5794288516,
0.320684731,
-0.5290182829,
0.0366260596,
-0.5612391829,
-0.2936213315,
0.4659878612,
0.6787358522,
-0.2394335121,
-0.6870214939,
-0.765119493,
0.1281182766,
-0.5309419632,
1.2871544361,
0.0924788341,
0.1145573854,
-0.2940634191,
-0.1706779897,
-0.1236056462,
-0.0915239975,
-0.9164854884,
-0.2441338748,
0.5353170037,
0.2228442281,
0.6972261667,
0.6198700666,
0.4277075529,
0.2520830333,
-0.5083544254,
0.2469358295,
-0.9185418487,
-0.0853391588,
-0.179807201,
-0.3881910145,
-0.7713454962,
0.2493385673,
0.7671839595,
0.7152325511,
-0.2645932734,
0.0881372318,
0.039893087,
0.7179261446,
-0.3464695513,
0.0249546375,
-0.8234204054,
-0.2445738167,
0.3671099544,
-0.1146940365,
-0.4252597094,
-0.4855776429,
0.2395254821,
-0.6687809825,
0.2841730416,
0.0790993497,
0.5469692945,
-0.0916377008,
-0.7902622819,
-0.4695517123,
-0.9104830623,
0.9355295897,
-0.6430926919,
0.1637987047,
0.3030809462,
0.2067752182,
0.0359271355,
-0.5605698228,
-0.2727091908,
-0.4440698028,
-0.0713797435,
-0.0308032148,
-0.1803843081,
-0.2342379987,
0.0815537646,
0.6843613982,
-0.2453100979,
0.0548107848,
-0.542973578,
-0.2128896564,
0.8251924515,
0.1889490038,
0.0395909473,
-0.0379693545,
-0.6374717355,
-0.158965379,
-0.9426816702,
-0.0025274856,
0.4498495758,
0.1386147439,
0.2001841217,
0.4610573649,
-0.288305372,
0.43246907,
0.3157353103,
-0.1143447012,
0.0024676977,
-0.6927955151,
-0.2026940435,
-0.0269219112,
0.6229149699,
0.8405129313,
-0.0786707252,
0.0956477076,
-0.4835985899,
0.1311425865,
0.7744596004,
-0.8416400552,
-0.0669110566,
-0.0550981313,
-0.7086169124,
-0.2160118669,
0.0620731562,
-0.6599634886,
-0.5564889312,
-0.2306039035,
0.5032733083,
0.0349583328,
0.0571685247,
0.2114762217,
0.3480581939,
-0.2346490026,
0.4771283269,
-0.6685646772,
0.4173422456,
0.6225531697,
0.6219685078,
-0.3540367484,
0.1761320978,
-0.4719188511,
0.1349278539,
-0.3656518757,
0.9277566671,
-0.5504938364,
-0.6713332534,
-0.0094679985,
0.0877466574,
0.0739332587,
-0.6742635369,
0.5780344605,
-1.1068553925,
0.2568783164,
-0.3536021113,
-0.7014995813,
-0.5245897174,
0.3852165639,
-0.9763448238,
0.528424561,
0.2833303809,
-0.2554691136,
0.5640704036,
-0.2790041566,
-0.6001077294,
0.0190701466,
0.1023908854,
-0.67692554,
0.1403380483,
0.7138108611,
0.3764069676,
-0.281855762,
0.2335678041,
-0.2469085306,
-0.3348661661,
-0.0497049354,
-0.3172218502,
0.3373053372,
0.3496179581,
-0.1558067054,
0.5186787248,
-0.4556789994,
-0.2479626089,
-0.0253995564,
-0.6444689035,
-0.2917745411,
0.0658093244,
0.0425538942,
-0.1027393863,
0.0970804542,
-0.3788701296,
0.3452968001,
-0.0850892588,
0.3792015314,
0.7843563557,
0.2406405061,
0.8935504556,
-0.4286524057,
0.5642481446,
-0.1240180209,
0.1931377947,
-0.0505701229,
-0.4363837242,
-0.6519541144,
-0.2170625776,
0.2274444997,
-0.0624423958,
-0.5056536794,
0.552546382,
-0.4750676155,
-0.4343423247,
-0.5805925727,
0.6884170175,
0.29538095,
0.1498542875,
0.1508038789,
-0.5764973164,
-0.0672301129,
-0.6481243968,
-0.0119085573,
-0.0821328685,
-0.3478911519,
0.4833404124,
0.301769495,
-0.5181300044,
0.555367589,
-0.4479842186,
-0.6868127584,
-0.2579905689,
0.0781284943,
0.0965275466,
-0.0208470728,
0.3648684621,
-0.8298771381,
-0.5803669691,
-0.1395370513,
-0.0342565104,
-0.184117943,
-0.1664554477,
0.3148874044,
0.2166685015,
0.348862648,
-0.2221446335,
0.1469691694,
0.9173334837,
-0.3332130611,
0.2195468992,
-0.1781864464,
0.4316153228,
-1.0224299431,
-0.2086415142,
0.2767242491,
-0.4622147679,
-0.1332522333,
-0.0203857645,
0.0847855657,
0.1250586063,
-0.2632469833,
0.3820303679,
-0.3989682496,
-0.0133717768,
-0.4140499234,
0.4495655298,
0.2607147396,
0.1620789319,
-0.2124719322,
0.8666421175,
0.3085735142,
-0.7660014629,
0.608473897,
-0.0766206682,
-0.6909378767,
0.618260324,
-0.7735500336,
0.0048659965,
-0.1406887919,
0.756680131,
-1.5450179577,
-0.0348329246,
-0.0884569138,
-0.1542561203,
-0.0058898209,
-0.0460627265,
-0.5208335519,
-0.2570771575,
-0.6191407442,
0.2390168309,
0.3331438303,
-0.7684678435,
0.3871144652,
0.6171680093,
-0.2921918929,
0.0322068259,
-0.0571646132,
0.0359158739,
-0.1858997643,
-0.5236352086,
0.392442733,
-0.1961991936,
-0.1336604208,
0.2926961482,
-0.1991950721,
0.29522717,
-0.182049036,
-0.0481583513,
0.0967649668,
-0.1104339659,
0.1154732704,
-0.0914801434,
-0.0285997111,
-0.0884018838,
-0.2061739117,
0.4221622348,
-0.1525806636,
-0.2434085757,
-0.1781022251,
0.3155747056,
0.6904436946,
-0.0083416728,
0.2538993955,
0.7813726664,
0.041380439,
-0.364153564,
-0.6008277535,
-0.3333461583,
-0.4047290087,
0.3567824662,
0.1283391565,
-1.3157365322,
0.4995422363,
-0.0895346105,
0.1961856037,
0.4172384441,
0.8342823386,
0.0725125223,
1.489151597,
0.6047435999,
-0.4350142777,
0.536269486,
-0.3430018425,
0.2479033768,
-0.9329625368,
-0.1162399799,
-0.1264151931,
-0.571149528,
-0.465324074,
-0.6611231565,
0.6383664608,
-0.1198140383,
0.2055878639,
0.299256295,
-0.2861778438,
0.5468063951,
0.4643023312,
0.2476407737,
0.5304566026,
0.4577359855,
0.2502523661,
0.1156138256,
-0.4956686795,
-0.5374937057,
1.1418063641,
0.390450418,
1.2243107557,
0.257938683,
0.0514408909,
0.388419807,
0.7615217566,
-0.8558202982,
0.6525573134,
-0.5022640824,
-0.6699352264,
-0.3582699895,
-0.5832077861,
-0.8615653515,
0.3081090748,
-0.1951298416,
-0.2274935842,
-0.3158403635,
-0.0434945896,
-0.5158497691,
0.5995970964,
-0.462105006,
0.1114823073,
-0.0516031533,
-0.2325957119,
-0.777933836,
-0.2693904042,
0.2934198081,
-0.1686327457,
0.2338563055,
0.1076982319,
-0.1140147522,
0.701767385,
-0.327503264,
0.86353302,
0.2034825236,
-0.5764507055,
0.5891498923,
0.2289782614,
0.6264982224,
0.4107062221,
0.1631019264,
-0.1028598398,
-0.3905983269,
-0.224376902,
-0.6147336364,
1.1690206528,
-0.6592609882,
-0.7469565272,
0.0501731597,
-0.6005310416,
-0.0718513876,
0.0670505166,
-0.0552823916,
0.1747540534,
-0.0587491728,
0.731048286,
0.6724398136,
0.1067204475,
0.2396623194,
0.5035964251,
-0.3159295619,
-0.7994365692,
0.6347134113,
0.0497848354,
0.544677496,
0.0318001658,
0.3019515276,
-0.6457916498,
-0.4679798782,
-0.494641304,
0.3154197931,
-0.5731462836,
-0.0366784148,
-0.6763725877,
0.0501044616,
-0.6455579996,
-0.1792606413,
-0.4016777873,
-0.2476601601,
-0.2968952954,
-0.0381484143,
0.2777536213,
0.9105570912,
0.0883440822,
0.664890945,
-0.5911585689,
0.4447891414,
0.7340924144,
0.6801671386,
0.0232609101,
-0.7895032167,
-0.3465082049,
-0.1057053804,
-0.3053393364,
-0.4687604308,
0.2891447842,
-0.1229607537,
0.3440472484,
0.76080966,
-0.1548902988,
0.5113660097,
-0.2594955564,
0.9621958137,
0.1520762742,
-0.5543726683,
0.1976024359,
-0.4124463797,
0.2933269143,
0.4906665683,
0.4872676134,
-0.4665831327,
-0.2055107802,
-0.2950489223,
-0.8791268468,
0.3517506719,
0.035193447,
0.5406181812,
0.0516665988,
0.2208013535,
0.0488470159,
0.2748985589,
-0.6901350617,
-0.0101171387,
0.3129905462,
0.3883506358,
-0.4712189138,
-0.7131993771,
-0.4017745852,
-0.1978858858,
0.7911513448,
-0.1172562167,
-0.1363033652,
0.0329479054,
-0.0112703722,
-0.4846038222,
0.3257414103,
0.4784001708,
0.7279547453,
-0.2503378987,
0.1390906423,
0.1073320433,
-0.4533208013,
0.1435685158,
-0.299695015,
-0.3387295008,
-0.1287970692,
0.0961920172,
0.7049381733,
0.2029573917,
-0.5410491228,
0.5342624187,
-0.1968655735,
-0.1803438067,
0.0751626492,
-0.1274077445,
0.0445097946,
0.2135938257,
0.1108410805,
-0.2275623381,
0.136960268,
-0.5780745745,
0.3227054775,
0.4972782433,
-0.5198742747,
-0.2690519989,
0.7883812785,
0.4706023932,
-0.06102027,
0.5611613393,
-0.0735218972,
-0.4958133101,
0.5163291097,
0.6551026106,
0.9099120498,
-0.1944660842,
0.3180424571,
0.3827686906,
0.3978472054,
-0.2136117816,
-0.0840365738,
-0.0568950437,
-0.5946601033,
-0.623241961,
-0.4854017794,
-0.6915128231,
0.3421108425,
-0.5518904328,
0.22990641,
-0.5677799582,
-0.3198032379,
-0.139026463,
0.365958631,
-0.2892392874,
0.3685501516,
0.2963404059,
0.6724044085,
-0.9648622274,
0.5261185169,
0.7768841982,
-0.1213772595,
-0.6034139395,
-0.0809224397,
0.199803561,
-0.5278576612,
0.1401400566,
0.1533908695,
-0.3301774263,
-0.1589307785,
-0.6468334198,
-0.7622461915,
1.0259757042,
-0.0494018942,
-0.6194438934,
0.2549096942,
-0.2974864841,
0.7708391547,
-0.7557091117,
-0.0130304713,
0.3195045292,
0.2437571138,
0.2149135023,
-0.7189217806,
0.1437928826,
0.095641084,
0.1599036306,
-0.0609082952,
-0.5802269578,
0.93114537,
-0.4169505537,
-0.3047580123,
-0.0651572272,
0.5430803299,
0.3300885856,
0.2699623704,
0.9211043715,
0.5819152594,
0.415266782,
0.3708417714,
1.2253928185,
-0.1210041568,
0.588064611,
1.0182231665,
-0.3066094816,
0.641336441,
0.5687099695,
-0.1877033412,
0.4637100399,
0.6347322464,
-0.1824362129,
0.3954497874,
0.2757206261,
-0.4811972976,
-0.3618860841,
-0.4464164078,
-0.1384447962,
-0.0014759875,
0.2284960747,
-0.6959070563,
-0.4709207714,
-0.046092473,
0.2418731749,
0.2992344797,
-0.5307325721,
0.8669734597,
0.0322871916,
-0.6297029257,
0.3848769963,
0.1640817225,
0.6101419926,
-0.4827853739,
0.0332459882,
-0.262827754,
0.1592774093,
-0.0557765923,
-0.9647247791,
0.1491642594,
-0.1040506661,
-0.3984323144,
-0.6607503295,
0.610071063,
-0.6833506227,
-0.656873107,
0.5028311014,
0.217294395,
-0.0676315203,
-0.2351350784,
-0.3461763561,
0.1658887118,
-0.0326659605,
-0.4934692979,
0.2693641782,
0.0395205431,
-0.4486015141,
0.5781341195,
0.8436661363,
0.3981310129,
-0.0175143909,
0.3792419136,
1.0797100067,
-0.3450800776,
-0.6159781218,
-0.6198428869,
0.014731776,
-0.0931354463,
0.0725505054,
0.8059268594,
0.5041684508,
1.1614857912,
-0.0507230163,
0.540851593,
0.2027754784,
0.3199286163,
-0.3843678236,
0.7660396099,
-0.6710586548,
0.6281638741,
-0.0695032328,
-1.1599128246,
-0.5374239683,
0.3436826468,
-0.4216009378,
0.0140044531,
0.4968710542,
1.0098859072,
0.0268766694,
-0.1876638532,
0.3802134693,
0.2332446426,
0.5261274576,
0.4865196049,
0.7081542611,
-0.3453046083,
0.8262759447,
-0.2569796443,
-0.1350502968,
-0.4001941085,
-0.7710191011,
-0.9617240429,
-0.3205857575,
-0.3237015605,
-0.6538904905,
-0.3191360831,
0.7638491392,
0.9108166099,
-0.8000636697,
-0.3694338202,
0.3839393854,
0.3380922675,
-0.419829309,
-0.1746852547,
0.3391206563,
-0.1666925848,
-1.0238131285,
0.3967072666,
0.3339357376,
-0.286667347,
-0.6202062368,
0.0038059275,
0.0603107587,
0.184321627,
0.9186577201,
-0.2074568123,
-0.6402231455,
-0.3217440248,
-0.0842261016,
-0.3340491652,
0.0345142297,
1.0568765402,
-0.4245580137,
0.8914942145,
0.6700853109,
0.4613075256,
0.3696804047,
0.3152704537,
0.3964144886,
-0.5500171781,
-0.279642731,
0.0622590519,
0.1112415418,
0.2651036084,
-0.3019284606,
0.3345394135,
0.1202082783,
-0.6739906669,
-0.4470559359,
0.2881360352,
-1.0650495291,
-0.0983279496,
1.5008380413,
-0.0339175723,
-0.153419897,
0.3262794614,
-0.3556222916,
-0.1286823601,
-0.462411195,
1.2158075571,
0.6102780104,
0.1425802261,
-0.032437671,
-0.292481482,
0.318497777,
0.3623173833,
-0.4867210984,
-0.0357764885,
0.645745635,
0.5641907454,
0.1274595559,
0.6160574555,
-0.4720024765,
0.0254777875,
-0.3663730025,
-0.2799963355,
0.1291324794,
-0.5032579899,
-0.6851345897,
0.3000888526,
-0.1348161846,
0.0353722386
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05318v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05318v1
|
Navigating the Knowledge Sea: Planet-scale answer retrieval using LLMs
| 2024-02-07T23:39:40 | 2024-02-07T23:39:40 |
Dipankar Sarkar
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Information retrieval is a rapidly evolving field of information retrieval,
which is characterized by a continuous refinement of techniques and
technologies, from basic hyperlink-based navigation to sophisticated
algorithm-driven search engines. This paper aims to provide a comprehensive
overview of the evolution of Information Retrieval Technology, with a
particular focus on the role of Large Language Models (LLMs) in bridging the
gap between traditional search methods and the emerging paradigm of answer
retrieval. The integration of LLMs in the realms of response retrieval and
indexing signifies a paradigm shift in how users interact with information
systems. This paradigm shift is driven by the integration of large language
models (LLMs) like GPT-4, which are capable of understanding and generating
human-like text, thus enabling them to provide more direct and contextually
relevant answers to user queries. Through this exploration, we seek to
illuminate the technological milestones that have shaped this journey and the
potential future directions in this rapidly changing field.
|
[
-0.6049958467,
-0.8000571728,
1.141023159,
-0.2138794214,
-0.0934090838,
0.4433979094,
0.0469753183,
-0.4480186403,
0.079621464,
0.5860397816,
-0.5478785038,
-0.2940531671,
-0.4101791382,
0.0404057503,
-0.3844124973,
0.8384878635,
0.1816282868,
-0.1000651568,
-0.3385776579,
0.0790419281,
-0.2092106491,
-0.6625477672,
-0.3932309151,
-0.3979477584,
0.6280784011,
0.2987703085,
0.8434351087,
0.7212541699,
0.9091056585,
0.2589374781,
-0.2864098549,
0.1107420549,
-0.4404624999,
0.3518604338,
-0.3538852632,
-0.7675324082,
-0.3492401838,
-0.0120025706,
0.5719213486,
0.8513206244,
-0.1931625456,
0.2390336543,
0.0706852004,
0.7944303155,
-0.3932723701,
0.1101761758,
-0.6026628613,
-0.0275641363,
-0.3342725039,
-0.7107492685,
-0.1763668805,
-0.4820031524,
0.2906806767,
-0.8415749073,
0.0454993621,
0.425604552,
0.4592383802,
0.1680078655,
-0.6735390425,
-0.7021451592,
-0.8640838265,
0.7753348947,
-0.4500315189,
0.5491688251,
0.0355956927,
0.6071253419,
-0.3985610604,
-1.0423295498,
-0.5331884623,
-0.0283555612,
0.2797228098,
0.0767641068,
0.0268784557,
-0.0567718074,
0.0437581129,
0.4332864583,
-0.57984519,
0.0398170687,
-0.5713291168,
0.0549163297,
0.3619036674,
0.2388899326,
0.2079745978,
-0.2650114596,
-0.4249008298,
0.11084719,
-1.044782877,
-0.205337733,
0.0545935147,
0.4592984915,
0.2397647798,
0.6653813124,
-0.1553771496,
0.8776701689,
-0.1695767641,
-0.3413996398,
0.012473573,
-0.3391503394,
-0.082015723,
-0.0688355342,
0.4710960686,
0.3223258257,
-0.0287311412,
-0.1281373799,
-0.1548916698,
-0.3685958087,
0.309251368,
-0.6914735436,
0.0730667487,
-0.0376645178,
-0.5504177213,
-0.3192378879,
0.0052276105,
-1.0077764988,
-0.8042209744,
-0.3747692704,
0.5037166476,
-0.0808366686,
-0.3419059813,
0.1817228198,
-0.0939802602,
0.4724270105,
0.3920719326,
-0.6756783128,
0.3140332699,
0.8968594074,
0.9249876738,
-0.1013370529,
0.2707555294,
-0.2007560432,
0.2650689483,
-0.3056785464,
0.7568854094,
-0.5692831278,
-0.7247934937,
0.1816268265,
-0.1568921506,
0.3328731954,
-0.6369723082,
0.4469848275,
-1.3539830446,
0.2263890952,
-0.6620761752,
-0.593380928,
-0.4402893186,
0.6102112532,
-0.6028890014,
1.003534317,
0.0224086065,
-0.7013271451,
0.0208156109,
-0.9192199707,
-0.0044217198,
0.521795094,
-0.2196484357,
0.186522007,
-0.091523461,
0.0131635629,
0.203915745,
-0.996294558,
0.034863919,
-0.2616295218,
-0.4790529609,
0.0728593469,
-0.0268911738,
0.3876418471,
0.3545402884,
-0.1265064627,
-0.1386413425,
-0.4909397662,
0.0990510583,
0.1272681952,
-0.6216677427,
-0.5035060048,
0.1176754236,
-0.1754551828,
0.5128595829,
0.7724329829,
-0.4448493421,
0.432325989,
-0.0112446398,
0.717880547,
0.6304669976,
0.2594729364,
0.5169265866,
-0.2448608577,
0.6498154998,
0.0477492623,
0.2502034009,
-0.2743290961,
-0.6157260537,
-0.4032013714,
0.3459305167,
0.134447515,
0.5942612886,
-0.9618073702,
0.0726194531,
-0.7180399895,
-0.6455501914,
-0.7097061276,
0.1891195774,
-0.0554202236,
0.5512375832,
0.4703102708,
0.022454761,
-0.3216220438,
-0.7463067174,
-0.2126372457,
-0.3631686866,
-0.2372771651,
0.4992805123,
0.2408171892,
-0.2773085833,
0.8042455912,
-0.5802335143,
-0.0556300692,
-0.196210131,
-0.1550422311,
0.438493818,
0.1082784683,
0.0769514292,
-1.3955465555,
-0.161210224,
0.2039174885,
-0.9257876873,
-0.0850440338,
0.2108087689,
-0.0414069071,
-0.2574882209,
0.9370171428,
-0.4975630045,
0.044730179,
0.3272639811,
-0.1289687157,
0.4385231733,
-0.18400684,
0.3865623772,
-1.0941970348,
0.2196819037,
-0.0365907885,
-0.0594929494,
-0.5204820037,
0.3162248433,
0.1667028368,
0.0805724934,
-0.0736269876,
0.4560551047,
-0.6725051999,
-0.5632301569,
-0.2853336334,
0.6929320097,
-0.1345353425,
0.0063117486,
-0.2251992673,
1.0538778305,
0.2028289139,
-0.8806151152,
0.5505943894,
0.2724449039,
-0.2329310179,
0.6824487448,
-0.3675630391,
0.3130015433,
-0.2132081389,
0.1089336872,
-1.0914860964,
-0.0817293897,
-0.2317808867,
-0.2431931496,
0.0391639434,
-0.1683348715,
-0.8175022006,
-0.6475225687,
-0.2753103971,
0.4463503361,
0.4322214127,
-0.608240664,
0.5816829801,
0.5736920238,
-0.6627063751,
-0.4358919561,
-0.4492994249,
0.3991856575,
-0.3659257293,
-0.6083425283,
0.345087111,
-0.3994188011,
-0.431760937,
-0.2518828511,
-0.1607948691,
0.0629530698,
0.022499837,
-0.0675842538,
0.623136878,
-0.3556486964,
0.3470624983,
-0.165448606,
0.1647135615,
0.1077616289,
-0.546705842,
0.6862681508,
-0.2337248027,
-0.2335298061,
0.0010065498,
0.1555463076,
0.7840148211,
-0.2683710158,
0.5644232035,
0.2703537345,
-0.1173514947,
0.3102214932,
-0.8237688541,
-0.2328812927,
-0.5573593378,
0.4430579841,
-0.4400289059,
-1.2186723948,
0.5319183469,
-0.589127183,
-0.0984469652,
0.2987105846,
0.2485113442,
-0.0888732374,
0.8313438892,
0.901263535,
-0.1121278182,
0.3660795689,
0.1341330409,
0.3208518326,
-1.1491211653,
-0.4773662984,
-0.5115674734,
-0.2534532547,
-1.0873376131,
-0.5064259171,
0.8998169899,
-0.0899408087,
-0.5027007461,
-0.0950413793,
-0.4210973084,
0.3543255627,
0.4268175066,
0.0847375095,
0.5959636569,
-0.1226838529,
-0.1237981915,
-0.112732932,
-0.6808007956,
-0.5379137397,
1.2982574701,
0.2868078053,
0.8591141701,
0.3609910011,
0.4811843336,
0.2878872752,
0.2312917262,
-0.6538055539,
0.8660553098,
0.1136073694,
-0.6299224496,
-0.3515816033,
-0.4771809578,
-0.7680621147,
0.3400435448,
0.0302716363,
-0.5264204741,
-0.0221123807,
-0.3503417373,
-0.2290148139,
0.4569225907,
-0.3016301095,
0.3550803065,
-0.2375239432,
-0.4662097991,
-0.2071820945,
-0.9411574006,
0.2093081772,
-0.1790840775,
0.498809278,
0.2591624856,
-0.4860887527,
0.7148708701,
0.1283124089,
0.3975148499,
-0.141575411,
-0.3087828159,
0.212704733,
0.2593600452,
0.3092199564,
-0.2547307014,
-0.2305920124,
-0.2685429156,
-0.0105090719,
-0.3397243619,
-0.5009073019,
0.9476523995,
-0.5938735604,
-0.8353247046,
-0.2497584671,
-0.5303940773,
-0.3401543498,
0.4775642753,
-0.0312169585,
0.1873863041,
-0.056724418,
0.203118369,
1.2387382984,
-0.25137344,
0.3232697845,
0.673982501,
-0.6347987056,
-0.1312446743,
0.6726087332,
0.1980852485,
0.1962017119,
0.6199788451,
0.00667952,
-0.5458085537,
-0.5570388436,
-0.174792856,
0.487595886,
-0.9339305758,
-0.266441375,
-0.405921638,
-0.1875342727,
-0.2178589702,
-0.0158011913,
0.0153640946,
-0.2437973619,
-0.1007122695,
-0.2044059783,
0.2069163918,
1.3101581335,
0.1423268318,
0.2329796255,
-0.753724575,
0.1462848186,
0.3417690098,
0.2568085194,
-0.1516668051,
-0.5873420835,
-0.128472954,
-0.1606607139,
-0.4090132415,
-0.9669653177,
0.2071765065,
-0.0930190757,
0.4297369719,
0.1502714753,
-0.1704560369,
0.5319057703,
-0.4615316987,
0.9725498557,
-0.0008260045,
-0.51088202,
0.5285245776,
-0.665337801,
0.5219781399,
0.3322602808,
0.6076884866,
-0.9990816116,
0.0963646844,
-0.2806007564,
-1.0754622221,
0.3845385909,
-0.3689084053,
-0.0150415096,
0.1423319578,
0.8069798946,
0.0071293032,
0.5792322755,
-0.5816115141,
-0.1352487952,
0.219512403,
-0.007661073,
-0.0467151031,
-0.233647123,
0.0189328957,
0.0718298554,
0.8399335742,
-0.2341410965,
0.3685017228,
0.1993266344,
-0.056034483,
-0.1063283607,
0.4782923758,
0.3031834364,
0.7368917465,
-0.1364199966,
0.1673520505,
-0.0562654994,
-0.5455650091,
0.0568843037,
0.1761741936,
-0.1850441545,
-0.252137363,
-0.0250430033,
0.4745028615,
0.1791674048,
-0.5708250999,
0.3539293706,
0.1075615734,
-0.0353215598,
-0.3907872438,
-0.05186335,
0.3516608477,
0.453646332,
1.0824213028,
-0.3685798347,
0.3821042478,
-0.6284613013,
-0.0272578653,
0.4458957613,
-0.3903062642,
-0.1783936471,
0.7098886967,
0.0420347638,
-0.1619886011,
0.651081264,
0.0744287893,
-0.3566925824,
0.2312598228,
0.3896701932,
0.508731246,
-0.4227111936,
0.0627295449,
0.1633450091,
0.4401569664,
-0.0426807478,
0.3409160078,
-0.1627332568,
-0.4567724466,
-0.1853251606,
-0.6708391309,
-0.4788713455,
0.220203653,
-0.6834452748,
-0.0114388624,
-0.3861200213,
-0.2587874234,
-0.0080124578,
0.0808529705,
-0.7082338333,
0.2147897929,
0.3040626645,
1.2316939831,
-0.4439234734,
0.5179219246,
1.0400929451,
-0.3792383373,
-0.3415768445,
0.1589722633,
0.2450138032,
-0.7681216598,
0.8944503069,
0.0426167101,
-0.2464827001,
0.3222900033,
-0.766821444,
-1.1547861099,
1.5718755722,
0.0176794436,
-0.4306434095,
-0.4659594297,
0.3396838307,
0.5710125566,
-0.3416762352,
0.2996021211,
0.6941766739,
0.4572006762,
0.0176649056,
-1.0226213932,
0.0767186955,
-0.0597318411,
0.4028432965,
0.3100683689,
-0.6432988644,
0.7361991405,
-0.0726498514,
0.0009169467,
0.2137035877,
0.6296064258,
0.2659862339,
0.0881817341,
0.2723034918,
0.2094810754,
0.8609415293,
-0.190759927,
0.9367001057,
-0.2825025618,
0.1349385381,
0.5221819282,
-0.3917426467,
1.0204979181,
0.7542681694,
-0.3779696226,
0.6956089735,
0.5976225138,
0.3344391584,
0.4088131785,
0.2194187194,
-0.6366596818,
-0.2352921367,
-0.1477679163,
-0.2769926488,
0.2377888709,
0.7913709879,
-0.3000859022,
-0.419626981,
-0.0016516665,
-0.0323627703,
0.070449613,
-0.6667862535,
0.8878269196,
0.0943175778,
-0.75298208,
0.324208945,
-0.0760435462,
0.7156999707,
-0.753046751,
-0.0222063679,
-0.1784816235,
0.0048869527,
-0.0746067315,
-1.1248818636,
-0.2469163388,
-0.2396972477,
-0.2242430151,
-0.0837233141,
0.7655175924,
-0.2138156742,
-0.037232291,
0.4598821104,
0.7418546677,
0.1549338549,
-0.0695262998,
-0.6971021891,
0.0170772336,
0.0087541118,
-0.4153701961,
0.4947163165,
0.5653498769,
-0.1123496965,
1.0954101086,
0.5978637338,
-0.1562211215,
0.2875362635,
-0.3044728935,
0.9935905933,
-0.9518715143,
-0.5710032582,
-0.6083493233,
0.075929068,
-0.0437576436,
0.0825428292,
0.7123658657,
0.6309353709,
0.4112162292,
0.1173995435,
1.0877922773,
-0.0583454557,
0.7841092944,
-0.3798907995,
0.5083302855,
-0.5142298341,
0.5551738143,
-0.1787759364,
-1.04248631,
-0.0792199075,
0.1175757051,
-0.5750978589,
0.2583835721,
0.4268480241,
0.7878064513,
-0.0238362905,
0.153061524,
0.2561506629,
0.2910321057,
0.4670854509,
0.3176883161,
0.8185302615,
-0.3174485564,
0.7390953302,
0.3396920562,
-0.37001279,
-0.3916077912,
-0.7519586682,
-0.2304396927,
-0.7403774261,
0.0541916303,
-0.1700073332,
0.2468896061,
0.6747248769,
0.3766049147,
-0.3896813691,
-0.5195173025,
-0.0446496233,
-0.1637016684,
0.1881762147,
-0.2473568022,
0.0867333114,
-0.3849116266,
-0.4692008197,
0.5268741846,
0.512278676,
0.0463747717,
-0.4929821789,
0.0441681854,
-0.3814657331,
0.1030669883,
0.6027951837,
0.4149803519,
-0.4538356662,
0.0052283881,
0.3919217587,
-0.2162454575,
0.1222238988,
0.6492334008,
-0.9126092196,
0.4531035423,
0.2472726107,
0.7931622863,
0.6096606255,
0.0420917086,
0.6322137117,
-0.402789861,
-0.2707278132,
0.1826158017,
0.1332429498,
0.7602256536,
-0.3409960866,
0.6608898044,
0.1972703636,
-1.0000190735,
-0.6942577958,
0.2590641379,
-0.8366692066,
-0.2426018864,
1.1376581192,
0.2013367862,
-0.2521459758,
-0.2063348293,
-0.200237453,
-0.0616465323,
-0.1792923808,
0.7719871998,
0.7842783928,
-0.1961457729,
-0.1904156357,
-1.0792540312,
0.4114735723,
0.1536867321,
-0.8730044365,
-0.0371201746,
0.4841733575,
0.4295467734,
0.575394392,
0.5184143186,
-0.359607935,
0.1093217731,
-0.4518738985,
-0.0748114511,
0.335612148,
-0.156025961,
-0.1864329576,
0.3472483754,
0.412178874,
0.0977611169
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05294v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05294v1
|
Examining Modality Incongruity in Multimodal Federated Learning for Medical Vision and Language-based Disease Detection
| 2024-02-07T22:16:53 | 2024-02-07T22:16:53 |
Pramit Saha, Divyanshu Mishra, Felix Wagner, Konstantinos Kamnitsas, J. Alison Noble
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Multimodal Federated Learning (MMFL) utilizes multiple modalities in each
client to build a more powerful Federated Learning (FL) model than its unimodal
counterpart. However, the impact of missing modality in different clients, also
called modality incongruity, has been greatly overlooked. This paper, for the
first time, analyses the impact of modality incongruity and reveals its
connection with data heterogeneity across participating clients. We
particularly inspect whether incongruent MMFL with unimodal and multimodal
clients is more beneficial than unimodal FL. Furthermore, we examine three
potential routes of addressing this issue. Firstly, we study the effectiveness
of various self-attention mechanisms towards incongruity-agnostic information
fusion in MMFL. Secondly, we introduce a modality imputation network (MIN)
pre-trained in a multimodal client for modality translation in unimodal clients
and investigate its potential towards mitigating the missing modality problem.
Thirdly, we assess the capability of client-level and server-level
regularization techniques towards mitigating modality incongruity effects.
Experiments are conducted under several MMFL settings on two publicly available
real-world datasets, MIMIC-CXR and Open-I, with Chest X-Ray and radiology
reports.
|
[
-0.0967648774,
-0.7579455972,
0.2432020605,
0.1208097711,
-0.1167147905,
-0.1966883689,
0.0113570392,
-0.7381778955,
0.3281946182,
0.1435379088,
-0.6467731595,
-0.1107483655,
-0.3561199903,
0.2815787196,
0.1802929938,
0.9414444566,
0.0994295925,
0.4142623246,
-0.4143903255,
-0.5403049588,
-0.4149935544,
-0.4683833718,
-0.3663482964,
-0.3961060643,
0.5140999556,
0.4592772722,
1.0367017984,
0.7475995421,
0.728942275,
0.2262056321,
0.4132535756,
0.2255117893,
-0.3770886362,
0.0691039711,
0.0536077879,
-0.4227308929,
-0.5073429346,
0.1867981106,
0.6469402909,
1.0086889267,
0.0892026722,
-0.006233633,
-0.2390254438,
0.5438066721,
-0.5046996474,
0.2381447554,
-0.2063242346,
0.6585866809,
-0.389960587,
-0.4559786916,
-0.2170096934,
0.2967403531,
0.2826581597,
-0.481993556,
0.2841528952,
0.0448038951,
0.587182045,
0.3738994598,
-0.7273441553,
-0.3113788962,
-0.4305711389,
0.436032474,
-0.5113865137,
0.7004229426,
0.5243750811,
0.228339687,
-0.1203828752,
-0.5911664367,
-0.3629606962,
-0.3759405315,
-0.4043618739,
0.3312060535,
-0.0469740406,
0.2246761769,
0.1201657057,
0.5059328675,
-0.7777372599,
0.1263322532,
-0.2589136064,
-0.5325097442,
0.419110626,
0.1907028407,
0.3226425648,
-0.31680125,
-0.7087826729,
0.0847718939,
-0.4738683701,
0.0957695618,
0.2963633835,
0.2347734272,
-0.4122680128,
0.3884465396,
-0.1694255024,
0.5622255206,
0.1274347603,
-0.6744453311,
0.5285786986,
-0.708851397,
-0.482301414,
-0.1147675514,
0.6874759197,
-0.1189205125,
-0.4942926168,
-0.2451952994,
-0.1771939546,
-0.2346634269,
-0.0820616558,
-0.4508055151,
-0.311432749,
0.1743512005,
-0.9293336272,
-0.3103701174,
-0.0641098246,
-0.3833174706,
-0.2118244469,
-0.2470987588,
0.5765485168,
-0.6189220548,
-0.5283344984,
-0.1151480526,
0.0600356236,
-0.1288946271,
0.4229733348,
-0.6852912307,
-0.0874026269,
0.3401637673,
0.6339175701,
0.0267090332,
-0.4951861501,
-0.7503839135,
0.097802192,
0.0832708478,
0.5101328492,
-0.6174653172,
-0.190679118,
-0.2918741107,
0.097387515,
-0.5835828781,
-0.4846286774,
0.289478749,
-0.1229838207,
0.4866183996,
-0.1377004087,
-0.3615667224,
-0.291349858,
0.3747269213,
-0.8013171554,
0.4961663187,
0.2485427111,
-0.5072159171,
0.4596455693,
-0.5079151392,
-0.5452409387,
0.1187869459,
-0.5013452768,
-0.517726481,
0.1927507222,
-0.1658918411,
0.57355088,
-0.2135427147,
0.1789248139,
-0.4626092017,
-0.2925661504,
0.4755812883,
-0.769359827,
0.7418797016,
0.2398763448,
-0.369225055,
-0.0487845913,
-0.851968348,
-0.1719097644,
0.0102166627,
-0.411370635,
-0.2561508119,
-0.1632116139,
0.2933672667,
0.4507420063,
-0.0388471968,
-0.3530773818,
-0.0229610745,
-0.3738229871,
0.2883256376,
0.5953277946,
-0.1437263638,
0.0160540603,
-0.7478548884,
0.514125824,
0.4337813556,
0.7108286619,
-0.3714981675,
-0.3062062562,
-0.2976144552,
-0.8397099376,
-0.1127023101,
0.0898473784,
-1.0383262634,
-0.2175751925,
-0.0836190358,
-0.0383227915,
-0.595977366,
0.0211108923,
0.7958397269,
0.6115068793,
0.3200546801,
-0.5176224709,
-0.2167909592,
-0.9403359294,
0.0270539839,
-0.0601338632,
0.3335112929,
0.4217110872,
0.2003827691,
-0.5575805902,
0.5023804903,
0.0465569571,
-0.8224179149,
0.097765699,
0.1049532145,
-0.0886590555,
0.4238620698,
0.7156566978,
-1.0229568481,
-0.352905184,
0.1646079421,
-0.7538856268,
0.0629915893,
-0.2508401871,
0.437422961,
0.4147573411,
0.2576552629,
-0.1191605181,
0.3821426928,
0.7249171138,
-0.547262013,
0.600174129,
-0.303807646,
0.4015163779,
-0.7012791634,
0.1577572078,
-0.0809311345,
-0.3642841876,
-0.7271802425,
0.1749252975,
0.052939143,
-0.165054068,
-0.1939019114,
0.2389806807,
-0.5928139091,
-0.1540437341,
-0.0094556576,
-0.3343081772,
0.1486688554,
0.507327199,
-0.3891341388,
0.7073810101,
0.4587316811,
-0.2193487287,
0.0697201118,
0.0425468944,
0.1046330407,
0.7384907603,
-0.2545155287,
-0.1413511485,
-0.2761662602,
0.1037103608,
-1.0997463465,
-0.462071389,
0.4766450524,
-0.3097251952,
0.4780620039,
0.0010393751,
-0.6157274246,
-0.1418950856,
-0.3285140097,
0.8057742119,
-0.2350606322,
-0.3474480808,
0.5993139744,
0.2284508497,
0.3890219033,
-0.4510733485,
-0.8736295104,
-0.1638726145,
0.0688863546,
-0.7810035348,
-0.0354024097,
-0.5015217662,
0.0099692801,
-0.0186749902,
-0.216263026,
-0.2214527726,
0.2708658874,
0.4717107117,
0.1664459556,
-0.3949151039,
0.5886816382,
-0.0821791887,
0.0762909949,
-0.1689671874,
0.0476034768,
0.3847727478,
-0.2390328199,
-0.9762054086,
-0.5210168362,
0.6195385456,
0.8137644529,
-0.2640218139,
0.3868886232,
0.8022050858,
-0.1820922047,
0.1334539205,
-0.6901320815,
-0.1514231414,
-0.4062831104,
0.2103420496,
-0.558618784,
-1.0189204216,
0.3906796277,
0.2714186311,
-0.2983483076,
0.1805635095,
0.5137856603,
0.0234538224,
0.8558580279,
0.8700292706,
0.1488883793,
0.5545538068,
0.0073213149,
0.1030498669,
-0.5718083382,
-0.3934614062,
0.067563571,
-0.3529938161,
-0.3977592289,
-0.4640473127,
0.7613414526,
-0.2773780525,
0.2718860209,
-0.2742463946,
-0.3224366009,
0.1947632283,
0.2479054779,
0.5364995003,
0.6889182925,
0.0552054979,
-0.2928658426,
-0.1652325243,
-0.8561641574,
0.3033455908,
1.1458030939,
0.3246546984,
0.5305173397,
0.3332616389,
0.3490054905,
0.5681946874,
0.4811016321,
-0.8082864285,
0.0703368634,
-0.1539383531,
-0.5592710972,
-0.1117116436,
-0.6237900853,
-0.8499077559,
0.5235160589,
-0.4114866853,
-0.2315847576,
0.6800031662,
0.2350308448,
-0.2514670789,
0.0611048825,
-0.722452879,
0.8773261309,
-0.2269054949,
-0.3111230135,
-0.2369606644,
-0.9185205698,
0.5577517152,
-0.1564518213,
0.3595734537,
-0.1650336385,
0.0484498329,
0.0688729212,
-0.3652872145,
0.9342418909,
0.0624442585,
-0.0114252046,
-0.4083512425,
0.0126117896,
0.1004869565,
0.2428812981,
0.1555627435,
0.2877586782,
0.0024680775,
-0.4638950825,
-0.1626358032,
0.7129753828,
-0.70714885,
-0.3479931056,
-0.5148285627,
-0.9497029781,
-0.3163413703,
0.2080253512,
0.2902625501,
1.0292122364,
0.07121104,
0.0697544515,
0.8182688355,
0.1060094237,
0.4952560365,
0.7958119512,
0.1141933128,
-0.4593538344,
0.903319478,
0.2987238765,
0.5745269656,
0.4367485344,
0.1710851341,
0.2161921263,
-0.4338666797,
-0.433295846,
0.5244526267,
-0.6889945269,
-0.2508497834,
-0.7916178107,
-0.0191353206,
-0.4535387158,
0.0183225255,
-0.2144839317,
-0.1454160064,
-0.4275405705,
0.3976215124,
0.0471899733,
0.2783857882,
-0.3634475768,
0.0016489531,
-0.6664587259,
-0.0167848803,
0.2353014201,
0.3854355514,
-0.002977293,
-0.2009376436,
-0.3882846832,
0.1655950546,
0.0059692482,
-0.6779965758,
0.0256030932,
0.5295560956,
0.64855057,
0.8211342692,
-0.1812114865,
0.7555692792,
-0.0870408788,
0.249341622,
0.6084427834,
-0.6217634082,
0.2352524847,
-0.324637711,
0.2857182026,
0.458084017,
0.3218075335,
-0.5399148464,
-0.33049649,
-0.5708674788,
-0.3725362122,
0.6004869342,
-0.0482632481,
-0.147545144,
-0.1138164923,
0.1360960901,
0.534506917,
0.19474186,
-0.8101755977,
-0.5367967486,
-0.3229258358,
-0.0736303106,
0.0274724271,
-0.2029114664,
-0.5084143877,
-0.2156729847,
0.2564485669,
-0.4451909363,
0.4048885405,
0.65303123,
-0.3471811414,
-0.4832035005,
-0.0063202679,
0.8074130416,
0.6428408623,
0.0407331884,
0.1675683856,
-0.4041471481,
-0.636767149,
-0.0563206561,
0.3247362971,
0.019606391,
0.1148199365,
0.6313098073,
0.6814959645,
0.3623833358,
-0.8077476025,
0.8698554635,
0.0158447959,
-0.2187611908,
-0.0313850231,
-0.0800646991,
-0.4169722795,
0.5736910701,
0.4278558493,
0.4027417302,
0.3976502419,
-0.8830371499,
0.3728617132,
0.731311202,
-0.6688613296,
-0.467218101,
0.6410129666,
-0.0314755477,
0.165875718,
0.1568841785,
0.1046595946,
-0.0968120173,
0.4845893383,
0.5714671016,
0.4086631238,
-0.2492067218,
0.4527354836,
-0.2508772314,
0.4580299556,
0.1993378103,
0.1322093457,
-0.3450012803,
-0.5929131508,
-0.3016724885,
-0.1954359859,
-0.2446896881,
0.0386379175,
-0.4625704885,
-0.0298425667,
-0.4516767263,
-0.1042298824,
0.1222209781,
-0.0348075703,
-0.679181397,
0.1739535034,
0.1382394731,
0.5050961375,
-0.9375422597,
0.8528562784,
0.8389400244,
-0.7913070321,
-0.8120825291,
0.2005687803,
0.3294514418,
-0.9012969732,
0.5189207196,
0.2691969872,
0.0324817598,
-0.1098148152,
-0.2605911791,
-0.9539800882,
1.3069504499,
0.2937809527,
-0.1077478006,
0.1621810645,
0.3393277824,
0.4849038422,
-0.3705567718,
0.2000669986,
0.1307125241,
0.2980796993,
0.1124008149,
-1.2076038122,
0.2301228046,
-0.2360805422,
-0.1447826475,
0.249176681,
-0.9350270629,
1.1130838394,
-0.1206720471,
-0.3426746726,
-0.284484297,
0.1683543175,
-0.2736986279,
0.6334536672,
0.3096900582,
0.5538058877,
0.7295472622,
0.137469396,
0.8279651403,
-0.0164224431,
0.2904575467,
0.8419328332,
-0.0756826326,
0.1392575204,
0.5539333224,
0.0527717732,
0.2596282959,
0.2957260311,
0.1471158415,
0.4430477321,
-0.3770204782,
-0.3082770407,
-0.1410269439,
-0.2177658081,
-0.6666477323,
0.6159704328,
0.2593781948,
-0.4021581411,
-0.4398477376,
0.8430488706,
0.1015119255,
-0.2642525733,
-0.1534750909,
0.6805305481,
-0.19006899,
-0.1358582675,
0.6295685172,
-0.2271026969,
0.6532347202,
-0.6798893213,
0.0341048166,
-0.6224702001,
0.1487584859,
-0.3760493696,
-0.0920825079,
0.205365181,
-0.8386439085,
-0.5326039791,
0.015054008,
0.6744406819,
-0.6041990519,
-0.1939935237,
0.2406980544,
0.7391918302,
-0.0291293953,
0.113350153,
-0.5862388611,
0.1840460002,
-0.0719510987,
0.0330701172,
0.729580164,
0.7084777951,
-0.0002569505,
0.6928818822,
0.7869940996,
-0.0965095609,
-0.0306618288,
-0.1487269849,
0.9186118245,
-0.207482338,
-0.2810247242,
-0.5623924136,
0.2427408546,
0.1494122744,
-0.3588319123,
0.7381568551,
0.3833607435,
0.8922784925,
-0.0124021899,
0.3321099579,
-0.066620186,
0.0020508522,
-0.4019165933,
0.7476735115,
-1.0835921764,
0.2313729376,
-0.0234515872,
-0.2201602012,
-0.5820691586,
0.3056022823,
-0.0067659798,
-0.4030697048,
0.8615508676,
0.74981004,
-0.3240974247,
-0.001291095,
0.7537216544,
0.1882404387,
0.0989916399,
0.4897676706,
0.283929646,
-0.3120391667,
0.4300673604,
-0.4518427551,
-0.4878756404,
-0.6745439768,
-0.516936779,
-0.8131309748,
-0.6060265303,
-0.3495096862,
-0.131394431,
-0.0441475958,
1.0188838243,
0.6797994375,
-0.4939397275,
0.0137017686,
0.2529279888,
0.0911494344,
-0.4283700883,
-0.2531342804,
0.2645139992,
-0.3845820725,
-0.2809771597,
0.5491356254,
0.7703068256,
0.1427810341,
-0.4569012523,
0.2202833593,
-0.3769976795,
-0.254586339,
0.6807842851,
0.2923888564,
-0.626067102,
-0.3146398067,
-0.123797968,
-0.3750654757,
0.336648345,
0.8949949741,
-0.7166570425,
0.9340439439,
0.1861571521,
0.573335588,
-0.0933648422,
-0.340598613,
0.2762813568,
-0.7959511876,
0.3850213885,
0.3428031504,
0.4575977325,
0.1730676442,
-0.698163867,
0.5252264738,
0.8783149123,
-0.3802199066,
-0.8423152566,
0.4278851449,
-0.9759042263,
-0.3720732331,
0.80835706,
-0.1032072231,
0.0492489971,
-0.3875302672,
0.0411102846,
0.0277724806,
-0.1097788364,
0.8169255853,
0.4266211987,
-0.3903699815,
-0.2065769583,
-0.472543776,
0.4256002307,
0.5455231667,
-0.5962196589,
-0.3619500995,
0.9164803624,
0.4264846146,
0.1171151996,
0.9349307418,
-0.1819191724,
0.5547941327,
-0.1528368443,
-0.2032274455,
-0.5580435991,
-0.3014642298,
-0.3773925006,
0.4276933372,
-0.3646874726,
-0.0058914414
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05282v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05282v1
|
TreeForm: End-to-end Annotation and Evaluation for Form Document Parsing
| 2024-02-07T21:54:53 | 2024-02-07T21:54:53 |
Ran Zmigrod, Zhiqiang Ma, Armineh Nourbakhsh, Sameena Shah
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Visually Rich Form Understanding (VRFU) poses a complex research problem due
to the documents' highly structured nature and yet highly variable style and
content. Current annotation schemes decompose form understanding and omit key
hierarchical structure, making development and evaluation of end-to-end models
difficult. In this paper, we propose a novel F1 metric to evaluate form parsers
and describe a new content-agnostic, tree-based annotation scheme for VRFU:
TreeForm. We provide methods to convert previous annotation schemes into
TreeForm structures and evaluate TreeForm predictions using a modified version
of the normalized tree-edit distance. We present initial baselines for our
end-to-end performance metric and the TreeForm edit distance, averaged over the
FUNSD and XFUND datasets, of 61.5 and 26.4 respectively. We hope that TreeForm
encourages deeper research in annotating, modeling, and evaluating the
complexities of form-like documents.
|
[
-0.1468226016,
-0.973067224,
0.2789347172,
0.2257081121,
-0.328528434,
0.3048119247,
-0.1685940027,
-0.6464081407,
-0.001241999,
-0.064040795,
-0.5985918045,
-0.5450574756,
-0.4880773723,
0.1403083652,
-0.3249160349,
0.645876646,
-0.2879691422,
-0.1625900567,
-0.8212566972,
-0.0674394965,
-0.101084888,
-0.4934414029,
-0.4734177291,
0.1490686238,
0.4399141073,
0.1902534217,
0.8645018339,
0.708732903,
0.6078082323,
0.2395270467,
-0.5383505821,
0.0509453267,
-0.4925836027,
0.3098807931,
0.0958030671,
-0.4575367272,
-0.5433829427,
-0.0397051163,
0.8204925656,
0.6968005896,
0.1424597204,
0.3247021735,
-0.2321742177,
0.4819064736,
-0.7053393126,
0.5191442966,
-0.3382963836,
0.3444166183,
-0.4082621634,
-0.2436489016,
-0.4746029079,
-0.0969435945,
-0.0021707762,
-1.2011547089,
0.3386061192,
0.0827287287,
1.0821486712,
0.1458618492,
0.1234701276,
0.2303972095,
-0.4990321994,
0.1562059522,
-0.3460919857,
0.8097955585,
0.4782848656,
0.8320406675,
-0.0111702057,
-0.7200775743,
-0.5954620242,
-0.1675381511,
-0.2153844386,
0.1897653788,
-0.4333694875,
0.3952445388,
0.2688310444,
0.6216409802,
-0.5291729569,
0.0702619255,
-0.318323791,
-0.2877236009,
0.5410583615,
-0.1029319391,
0.322145462,
-0.4713012576,
-0.2039728165,
-0.3258489966,
-0.418105334,
0.7405869365,
0.2740507722,
0.0723694339,
-0.1973633617,
0.5118814707,
-0.3523661196,
0.7318931222,
-0.2453148812,
-0.0144040603,
0.3055639565,
-0.2143068314,
-0.8765863776,
0.0257250406,
0.6039101481,
0.3032538891,
0.1638329178,
-0.3352248967,
-0.195065245,
-0.1119336411,
-0.0631268099,
-0.8574889898,
-0.0494646803,
-0.2080035359,
-0.5346521139,
-0.5529870987,
0.2193666548,
-0.4133083522,
-0.345323205,
-0.2726504505,
0.3031082451,
-0.4603979886,
-0.248056069,
0.0280959792,
-0.2759007215,
0.2687276304,
1.0586010218,
-0.5436040163,
0.4919634461,
0.7868536115,
1.0015405416,
0.0615318865,
-0.203358233,
-0.8929781914,
0.0056278459,
-0.2476984262,
1.0817843676,
-0.8195582032,
-0.4526304901,
-0.3879936039,
0.0689880773,
0.0108158337,
-0.3227443695,
0.8066159487,
-0.1217277125,
0.4423758388,
-0.0019977579,
-0.2499627173,
-0.6081531644,
0.1810468435,
-0.828458488,
1.267790556,
0.9081448317,
-0.606207788,
0.754322052,
-0.5994628668,
-0.4414021671,
0.414277643,
-0.310605824,
-0.5199338794,
0.3831014037,
0.0862408802,
0.4244878888,
-0.2451539487,
0.2989317477,
-0.5314908028,
-0.3123799264,
-0.1127482057,
-0.6297382116,
0.5436240435,
0.0904626474,
-0.3148437142,
0.67297405,
-0.9532484412,
-0.0630053878,
-0.0738396794,
-0.1490294337,
-0.3354113102,
-0.3133808076,
0.4033596814,
0.2148632258,
-0.1461535543,
-0.5992113948,
0.289866209,
-0.288903594,
0.5729006529,
0.6067903042,
-0.2033076435,
0.073890537,
-0.1879284829,
0.8365854025,
-0.1581979245,
0.3731784821,
-0.4082451165,
-0.4760551751,
-0.3691650927,
-0.4380442202,
0.168141976,
0.1301336288,
-0.0451535955,
0.1667706072,
-0.389721632,
-0.5840890408,
-0.5365642905,
-0.0077811861,
0.2599987686,
0.6567212939,
0.1915472448,
-0.3257825375,
-0.4781287313,
-0.8005964756,
0.0822092146,
-0.4607487619,
0.2935281694,
0.234625116,
0.1938857287,
-0.2210374922,
1.0226136446,
-0.2143214643,
-0.3207240701,
0.0516739897,
0.0402181335,
-0.273688972,
0.2351229638,
0.7627939582,
-0.6962807178,
-0.2392807156,
0.2228082567,
-0.3330392838,
-0.1334890127,
-0.1521818042,
-0.1909498274,
0.0327343605,
0.3816571534,
-0.7273887992,
0.7738132477,
0.2588884532,
-0.8489174843,
0.5019739866,
-0.035178192,
0.2666583061,
-0.4458666742,
0.3006275594,
0.0528455786,
-0.5161290169,
-0.0528922454,
-0.0621643923,
0.1050715521,
-0.0402871557,
-0.3458070755,
0.4818964601,
-0.4615167081,
-0.2755188644,
0.2357847095,
-0.0683785528,
0.4646848142,
0.2054637223,
0.0825881958,
0.7226229906,
0.4407241046,
0.1695177108,
0.1305456012,
0.226865232,
-0.1742205769,
0.5528733134,
-0.521810174,
-0.2262596339,
-0.453545332,
0.3160023987,
-1.3721957207,
-0.1407640278,
0.0435266793,
-0.5839323997,
0.2027451992,
0.1215228587,
-0.4586054385,
-0.1214745119,
-0.6873906255,
0.4249418676,
0.160071969,
-0.3313067555,
0.555093646,
-0.0461880006,
-0.0896521881,
-0.1458355784,
-0.421168685,
0.0778753906,
-0.0720018521,
-1.0112090111,
0.6434557438,
0.01407927,
-0.1300651878,
0.105561927,
-0.3981109858,
-0.1692959219,
0.4818581343,
0.7303986549,
-0.1567908525,
-0.6499737501,
0.0092423446,
0.4315465987,
0.0079928692,
0.1199600771,
0.1774525344,
0.0246641245,
-0.2617898583,
-0.2568944097,
-0.3686880171,
0.176847741,
0.8305174708,
-0.6106114388,
0.2805536389,
0.4863196313,
-0.8170311451,
-0.1078171656,
-0.3312805593,
0.3786320984,
-0.3352461457,
0.2467538416,
-0.7332226634,
-1.0394819975,
0.262509346,
-0.0087325051,
0.2453482449,
0.8672955632,
0.1677227467,
0.0075409049,
0.6765206456,
0.8163978457,
0.5211833715,
0.4583970904,
-0.3317910135,
-0.0913807899,
-0.576533556,
-0.7618093491,
-0.5629867911,
-0.2185330987,
0.0880628899,
-0.6306270361,
-0.0035924276,
0.8786494136,
-0.0094993105,
0.2424290925,
-0.4866192937,
0.1993446499,
0.3250891864,
-0.2725533247,
0.506755352,
0.2030405551,
-0.1391956061,
-0.0060428665,
-0.3996982276,
-0.5342969894,
0.7214720249,
0.6994398832,
0.3455525637,
0.128869772,
0.4439674616,
0.4092999697,
0.7343349457,
-0.8288080692,
0.0902219415,
-0.0226745196,
-0.0398414433,
-0.5947270393,
-0.0751782209,
-0.5973170996,
0.2877891064,
-0.2296967208,
-0.6938018799,
0.094855547,
-0.0579825267,
-0.4958387613,
0.0501693822,
-0.8503732681,
1.2925745249,
-0.2888615429,
-0.2390829176,
0.1228330657,
-0.3916685283,
0.2845691442,
0.1032205671,
0.349370122,
-0.2004539222,
0.0149710812,
0.8723531365,
-0.5876089334,
0.4921394587,
-0.2626763582,
-0.0418406874,
0.2561855614,
0.1879520863,
-0.0268538613,
0.3837409616,
-0.1049604639,
-0.0143439882,
0.298083663,
-0.024802912,
-0.8964971304,
0.3251969814,
-0.690089643,
-0.3553066254,
-0.4032538235,
-0.2083641142,
-0.0756569654,
0.2672810256,
-0.0448325835,
0.2765020132,
-0.4321199954,
0.4177586734,
0.2534433007,
0.0664185286,
0.4029828906,
0.2747524083,
-0.4052570164,
-0.6185792685,
0.4868083,
-0.0755912811,
-0.0455450788,
0.70844239,
0.3542403281,
-0.6085253358,
-0.4456983209,
-0.8218203187,
-0.1132265255,
-0.6195335984,
-0.5127409697,
-0.8011953831,
-0.2348899543,
-0.4874627292,
-0.2545956671,
-0.0402057655,
-0.762556076,
-0.2637676597,
-0.5829315782,
0.6756531,
0.7060289979,
0.0418033265,
0.4535982311,
-0.425303787,
0.3960878551,
-0.1137115657,
0.8741163611,
0.0107314922,
-0.3418160975,
0.0946823135,
-0.2732062042,
-0.3105104268,
-0.8228311539,
-0.1582286656,
0.5628402829,
0.7851576209,
0.4274775088,
-0.3803920448,
1.0389555693,
-0.2559419572,
0.6271908879,
0.3298528194,
-0.9511644244,
0.7226833105,
-0.0440037474,
-0.0353225693,
0.7398506403,
0.0999902412,
-0.5522639751,
-0.0915250853,
-0.7612392306,
-0.6327201724,
0.5831477642,
0.2664355338,
-0.2659063637,
0.3213365376,
0.3377353847,
0.5054299235,
0.0053184754,
-0.6393769383,
0.0741294846,
-0.4996778369,
-0.140168637,
-0.0091638779,
-0.1325152367,
0.2495764792,
-0.7200037241,
0.3035813272,
-0.0931631774,
-0.0794920102,
0.4212081134,
-0.251074791,
-0.5675116777,
0.1655040979,
0.6174288392,
0.7025552392,
-0.3478755057,
0.1591454297,
-0.2327095121,
-0.6066111326,
0.1583369523,
0.5871768594,
-0.2994058132,
0.2707939446,
0.7054628134,
0.9623951912,
0.1716438979,
-0.6535491943,
0.7862579226,
-0.251945734,
-0.3492744267,
-0.0791654289,
0.1171864048,
-0.1331744641,
-0.2351859659,
0.1610112041,
0.0576413274,
0.2180402875,
-0.4041208029,
0.3628080189,
0.2863673866,
-0.7882164717,
-0.432433188,
0.831232667,
0.3279383779,
-0.3890503347,
0.1065613776,
-0.1772117168,
-0.2740700841,
0.5082656145,
0.3571778834,
1.170257926,
-0.1685780287,
0.5535356998,
0.2207504511,
0.3057893813,
0.4176675081,
0.2873550951,
-0.7023599744,
0.1083509177,
-0.5667073727,
-1.1666189432,
-0.1451732218,
0.3120046556,
-0.3475159109,
0.5002290606,
-0.6956630945,
0.1956128776,
0.303974539,
0.0553818792,
-0.6610721946,
0.6369842887,
0.1994320005,
1.2706828117,
-0.6963267326,
0.3830559552,
0.9947286248,
-0.5865722895,
-0.7601881623,
-0.2759007514,
-0.0176945832,
-0.5677701235,
0.7250056863,
0.5951147079,
-0.1306199282,
-0.3228788376,
0.0237256996,
-0.6357361078,
1.1817641258,
0.4440832138,
-0.5762887597,
-0.4308519959,
0.2680729926,
0.5292816758,
-0.2983788848,
0.8122889996,
0.372674793,
0.5293439031,
0.0118163228,
-0.9181681275,
0.1892650425,
-0.6684148312,
0.0848682374,
0.0898597911,
-0.4627733231,
0.4730246365,
-0.0085863378,
-0.4372846186,
-0.1429366767,
0.8350135088,
0.0575986877,
0.4025138617,
0.7084017992,
0.746479094,
0.6411345005,
-0.0373735353,
0.7467272878,
-0.0963593721,
0.2845621705,
0.8318584561,
0.0745761842,
0.6475938559,
0.3833729327,
-0.1786077172,
0.3821533024,
0.7409502268,
0.2034272105,
0.1603283584,
0.6105804443,
0.0002161979,
-0.219286114,
-0.1556874514,
-0.4437875748,
0.5039551854,
0.2930069566,
-0.4196320176,
-0.7075068355,
-0.0575427748,
0.1392557174,
0.3649795949,
-0.039760299,
0.6926124096,
-0.0535075068,
-0.4036467969,
0.4683746099,
0.2539254725,
0.3854049742,
-0.548491478,
-0.3934287429,
-0.0869836211,
-0.3299531937,
-0.4945274591,
-0.9866067171,
0.335658133,
0.1539183408,
-0.2500921786,
-0.3991882205,
0.5881775618,
-0.0762544349,
-0.6004498005,
0.2886324823,
0.3762682676,
-0.0805159956,
-0.4153168499,
-0.5609093308,
0.3692352176,
-0.2096698284,
-0.3256407082,
-0.1797288358,
0.836032927,
-0.5459306836,
0.2705601752,
0.7636076808,
-0.0391953401,
-0.000036683,
0.3987529576,
0.7580356002,
-0.6033046246,
-0.7879325151,
-0.8022674918,
0.5821254253,
-0.0799041018,
-0.7717273831,
0.3505350649,
1.0461086035,
1.0353763103,
0.2872071564,
0.8089381456,
-0.15747118,
0.0922899023,
-0.2308959961,
0.8026015162,
-0.7386739254,
-0.2202778459,
-0.6624523997,
-1.104993701,
-0.4761758447,
0.5818882585,
-0.160585314,
-0.1533813775,
0.4608533978,
0.3338938653,
-0.3183377385,
0.243500337,
0.3328818679,
-0.006876091,
0.7099096775,
0.5326427817,
0.6617084742,
-0.1498876363,
0.4206993282,
-0.5139152408,
-0.573263526,
-0.1653283238,
-0.9451879859,
-0.7086006403,
-0.6974750757,
-0.3274562955,
-0.0167890433,
0.0292485468,
0.4821281135,
0.7627620101,
-0.4427012503,
0.0075961747,
-0.3326962292,
-0.1457570344,
-0.1424732506,
-0.3073101342,
0.6458756924,
-0.0379103571,
-0.0845269933,
-0.0100443885,
0.7074297071,
0.1823716611,
-0.3156072795,
-0.1004247218,
0.1899642944,
-0.4408928454,
0.930490613,
0.131828323,
-1.0138901472,
-0.274006784,
0.1182008311,
0.022312073,
0.3684317172,
0.6111027002,
-0.9554074407,
0.6064767838,
0.5783034563,
0.8214969039,
0.4201724231,
0.2972936034,
0.3646654487,
-0.3955488205,
-0.0137647176,
0.2515934408,
0.3555346727,
0.4812316298,
-0.6570634842,
0.4608765244,
0.5267546177,
0.1742710471,
-0.9042247534,
-0.0995934457,
-1.3865066767,
-0.0154470894,
0.7626745701,
-0.2174555361,
-0.4765891731,
0.4422027767,
-0.7251179814,
0.3155269623,
-0.3568515778,
0.3523916304,
0.6351677179,
-0.3506037593,
-0.5342399478,
-0.4327954948,
0.7392020822,
0.3583755791,
-1.2168540955,
0.3109647334,
0.6469407678,
0.0136906691,
0.139764756,
0.7442202568,
-0.1979586184,
0.6706961989,
-0.1177664176,
-0.2101852149,
-0.6656022072,
-0.5173521638,
-0.1907219142,
0.3027483225,
0.1714733392,
0.051502727
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07938v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07938v2
|
Large Language User Interfaces: Voice Interactive User Interfaces powered by LLMs
| 2024-02-07T21:08:49 | 2024-04-16T07:39:05 |
Syed Mekael Wasti, Ken Q. Pu, Ali Neshati
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7; I.2.1
|
The evolution of Large Language Models (LLMs) has showcased remarkable
capacities for logical reasoning and natural language comprehension. These
capabilities can be leveraged in solutions that semantically and textually
model complex problems. In this paper, we present our efforts toward
constructing a framework that can serve as an intermediary between a user and
their user interface (UI), enabling dynamic and real-time interactions. We
employ a system that stands upon textual semantic mappings of UI components, in
the form of annotations. These mappings are stored, parsed, and scaled in a
custom data structure, supplementary to an agent-based prompting backend
engine. Employing textual semantic mappings allows each component to not only
explain its role to the engine but also provide expectations. By comprehending
the needs of both the user and the components, our LLM engine can classify the
most appropriate application, extract relevant parameters, and subsequently
execute precise predictions of the user's expected actions. Such an integration
evolves static user interfaces into highly dynamic and adaptable solutions,
introducing a new frontier of intelligent and responsive user experiences.
|
[
-0.537558198,
-0.9968314171,
0.9334617853,
0.4384539425,
0.1754083186,
0.4259046912,
-0.4274692237,
-0.6294432878,
0.3981848359,
0.568310082,
-0.8275465965,
-0.3914375007,
-0.081236586,
-0.0324575305,
-0.413094759,
0.4257595539,
0.0832401887,
-0.2986622751,
-0.3624023497,
-0.0444943383,
-0.3653244972,
-0.5724653602,
-0.5927765369,
-0.520106554,
0.7786619067,
0.5195893049,
1.0270811319,
0.3576728702,
-0.004934133,
0.4314326942,
0.1105289981,
0.2029574513,
-0.2930312753,
0.6715660691,
-0.2791158259,
-0.5023444891,
-0.4780597687,
-0.1332020164,
0.5392195582,
0.5239400864,
-0.1622083187,
0.0736580938,
-0.1569245607,
0.171890229,
-0.22430785,
0.1727525145,
-0.5551730394,
-0.0084410384,
-0.0038921691,
-0.4765343666,
-0.3603981137,
-0.0557833537,
0.0750940964,
-0.9747871757,
-0.48844558,
0.1083030701,
0.7260628343,
0.4585190415,
-0.3330167234,
-0.3394165039,
-0.8122496605,
0.7297116518,
-0.753747046,
0.3420579731,
0.0453423299,
0.5543112159,
-0.4953053296,
-0.8629193306,
-1.0160707235,
-0.5597974658,
0.0271067861,
-0.0182054192,
0.0349187702,
0.1263227463,
0.3316810131,
0.0141838454,
-0.2433429062,
0.6262162924,
0.2775720358,
-0.0974202156,
0.5873284936,
0.480225414,
0.824595511,
0.1277583838,
-0.2737448215,
0.1347563565,
-0.7855302691,
-0.1607615799,
0.4293669462,
0.4951160252,
-0.3551838398,
0.6574781537,
-0.2873386145,
0.7860370278,
-0.0545600094,
-0.1593620479,
0.0734789744,
-0.0563691445,
-0.1779991686,
0.1227704212,
0.8350222111,
0.080026798,
0.5176561475,
-0.1093553007,
-0.1661790758,
-0.2244596928,
0.1281726211,
-0.7375760674,
0.2110667527,
0.40958637,
-0.3199037313,
-0.2561200261,
-0.1305542141,
-0.614405632,
-0.6744303107,
-0.8117391467,
0.3143333197,
-0.1146618798,
-0.4371421933,
0.0097306026,
0.1749004722,
0.2065194696,
0.6917205453,
-1.0092865229,
0.3008278012,
0.7431910038,
0.6554057002,
-0.1085579768,
-0.2208934128,
-0.7470827103,
0.3983515203,
0.0762149692,
0.6138603687,
-0.7709599137,
-0.4281088114,
0.1850122809,
0.0096493866,
0.0636190251,
-0.5577175617,
0.2674830854,
-0.5709364414,
0.2138290703,
-0.1007502601,
-0.5091106892,
-0.1742468327,
0.122484751,
-0.5573590994,
0.9072602987,
0.0450999103,
-0.4435512125,
-0.093611829,
-0.9201931357,
-0.4150440991,
0.418253094,
-0.3216862977,
0.0487110801,
-0.0189619623,
0.0385973267,
0.6059736013,
-0.3925721645,
0.30291152,
-0.4210084081,
-0.3634243906,
0.5170410872,
-0.3531840146,
0.6594004035,
0.2964978218,
-0.3731104434,
0.4184089303,
-0.8885397911,
0.18025814,
-0.0030258368,
-0.5048828125,
-0.1384185702,
0.4023904204,
0.3801135123,
0.3349376619,
0.4836393595,
-0.4557498991,
0.2373085618,
-0.2996032238,
0.5995947123,
0.4340363145,
-0.1329254061,
0.2770165503,
0.0364171714,
0.5543771386,
-0.17379269,
-0.1377096027,
-0.3843615949,
-0.3143513203,
-0.6998476982,
-0.3461520374,
0.097701475,
0.8221840262,
-0.809322238,
0.5451596379,
-0.4315598011,
-0.3486361504,
-0.3452583253,
0.1138611585,
0.0337867811,
0.4424915314,
0.150757283,
0.1767709106,
-0.2410765439,
-0.7977241874,
-0.1521223634,
-0.5819920897,
-0.5265834332,
0.4112658501,
0.0301938988,
-0.5825535655,
1.2433178425,
-0.1706363857,
-0.1026565284,
-0.3224462867,
0.207260102,
0.0037885308,
0.2945961356,
0.421970278,
-0.8837412,
-0.4051629603,
0.3989787996,
-0.9239808321,
-0.7484053373,
-0.3853192925,
-0.0747847334,
0.1351144761,
0.676215589,
-0.6016332507,
0.1684848964,
0.5281333923,
-0.2677971423,
0.3657442629,
-0.1588444859,
0.0552354977,
-1.0838975906,
0.0522787459,
-0.0943754837,
-0.4143691957,
-0.6174607277,
-0.0467953607,
-0.1634432077,
-0.2907954156,
-0.488959223,
0.9464928508,
-0.3975103199,
-0.2161208987,
-0.3510096669,
0.4877718985,
0.0146127734,
0.3931019604,
0.0660673007,
0.924808979,
0.173234418,
-0.3556709886,
0.7800393701,
0.1852838397,
-0.2004212588,
0.7525737286,
-0.7789993286,
-0.0336035602,
0.1539669484,
0.1060120612,
-0.8845466971,
-0.5544244647,
0.0107503925,
-0.3143035471,
0.1458018422,
0.0822877586,
-0.8703349233,
-0.112401545,
-0.0047516944,
-0.0352849811,
0.2502935529,
-0.5992408395,
1.1548081636,
0.4167460501,
-0.6137877703,
-0.0996587723,
-0.6274988055,
0.5410829782,
-0.1584056318,
-0.8265991807,
0.1222105026,
-0.029089015,
-0.4531275928,
-0.0061221626,
0.4513744414,
-0.0637326986,
0.262403816,
0.5217475891,
0.2093475312,
-0.2431246638,
0.3358754516,
0.3205732107,
-0.1745162159,
0.0328515954,
-0.1683006883,
0.3837805688,
-0.0506447777,
-0.5945196748,
-0.7484378219,
0.6171952486,
1.0304917097,
-0.3016759157,
0.5231012702,
0.5692717433,
-0.3479025662,
-0.0299327001,
-0.7017382979,
0.0877295807,
-0.5235724449,
0.3941653073,
-0.6075423956,
-1.1199849844,
0.758874476,
-0.3979494274,
0.2543302178,
0.1148627251,
0.9372665882,
-0.1578950733,
1.0704016685,
0.5136124492,
0.0360714383,
0.5907884836,
0.3564004004,
0.1885539442,
-0.7095594406,
-0.3235701621,
-0.4560574591,
-0.3721261024,
-0.4616890848,
-0.1713285893,
0.4554424882,
-0.2872022986,
-0.3007098138,
0.0026299241,
-0.1864346117,
0.0947438404,
0.4690605998,
-0.2540401816,
0.1653682292,
-0.0346257538,
-0.0861579105,
-0.1350988895,
-0.4183550775,
-0.7669138312,
0.3054126501,
0.5992718935,
1.2075508833,
0.3832806051,
0.2243981063,
0.2590893805,
0.3052215576,
-0.9438057542,
0.8382183909,
0.1709323227,
-0.4034306705,
-0.4826947153,
-0.2799097598,
-0.7600933909,
0.3179059327,
-0.595700562,
-1.0015856028,
0.0594441034,
0.0738526434,
-0.3896044195,
0.0989999473,
-1.0033813715,
0.5537669659,
-0.506667912,
-0.6686983109,
-0.1606956124,
-0.6255740523,
0.0093218535,
-0.0490638278,
0.1378136724,
-0.3055539429,
-0.2907244265,
0.3747332096,
-0.4314460456,
0.9837446213,
-0.3654626608,
-0.3280892372,
0.2210259587,
0.0908309147,
0.4268471301,
0.0751734897,
-0.3204342425,
-0.1323998123,
0.0622553229,
-0.0893310606,
-0.9617220163,
0.9775569439,
-0.5815419555,
-0.6356895566,
-0.129518345,
-0.553809464,
-0.4581687748,
0.264587909,
-0.5130723715,
0.612095356,
-0.1615952253,
0.2074977309,
0.7207548618,
-0.5693352222,
0.4234562218,
0.7233194709,
-0.5473214984,
-0.0437033325,
0.772949338,
0.0509209111,
0.2251692265,
0.606682241,
0.171239987,
-0.4851639867,
-0.2301704288,
-0.6460341811,
0.2252005935,
-0.4767400026,
0.0863451213,
-0.6166360378,
-0.1675686538,
-0.0860667452,
-0.3335217535,
-0.0733560845,
-0.2669864893,
-0.5586106777,
0.0687566698,
0.3324551284,
0.7822813988,
0.3488369584,
0.5397237539,
-0.8243709207,
0.2438215613,
0.4618641436,
0.3026402891,
0.0513839424,
-0.1537270993,
-0.2899968326,
-0.1183405593,
-0.0099582402,
-0.6357277036,
0.1971209198,
0.1298807859,
0.7282471061,
0.3404967487,
0.0187542811,
0.5193616152,
-0.6879099011,
0.9429385662,
0.1053828523,
-0.9172033668,
0.3382451236,
-0.5268847346,
0.5927245617,
0.4136225879,
0.0873849615,
-0.7159464955,
-0.3509650826,
-0.2394703478,
-0.8280476928,
0.5086748004,
-0.1904387176,
0.2771633565,
0.2346648872,
0.5001536012,
-0.0661269128,
0.1895356774,
-0.3672720492,
0.0467764549,
0.0379128382,
-0.6515260935,
0.1904829293,
-0.2833850682,
0.0042870734,
-0.0681494698,
0.5704962611,
-0.4607451558,
0.1165886596,
-0.039673727,
-0.1250488162,
-0.0080249598,
0.3805429935,
0.6515693069,
0.76530689,
0.1638240069,
0.1182903871,
0.0484299138,
-0.315109849,
0.1449127942,
0.2082220465,
0.0513335913,
-0.1539905369,
0.3884562254,
0.9357468486,
0.4782901108,
-1.1549651623,
0.3509482741,
-0.2825919986,
0.0840869844,
-0.5227464437,
0.2651755214,
0.508156836,
0.4133856595,
0.3753022254,
-0.6108498573,
0.002894145,
-0.5248003006,
-0.0421065316,
0.4102980196,
-0.3552320302,
-0.2886500955,
0.8855936527,
0.6090651751,
-0.6445456743,
0.2875225246,
0.3156456947,
-0.3994106352,
0.202033177,
0.349049598,
0.8644048572,
-0.3202034235,
-0.0327701904,
-0.155087322,
0.0820683613,
0.3149078488,
0.2349636853,
-0.1943405271,
-0.3908474147,
-0.6292660236,
-0.5503327847,
-0.5660364032,
0.0400345623,
-0.2873792052,
0.2885987163,
-0.3864672482,
-0.1511727124,
0.1237786636,
-0.0624370836,
-0.4346557856,
0.2684725821,
0.1932644248,
1.0687321424,
-0.5483026505,
0.7866533995,
0.8011656404,
-0.1843749732,
-0.6748028398,
-0.0430857167,
0.1140827164,
-0.7285176516,
0.7449839711,
-0.1088048518,
-0.51210922,
0.0101310099,
-0.4477391541,
-0.5079865456,
0.9183803201,
0.5941232443,
-0.7074522972,
0.0783549473,
0.238578096,
0.6482075453,
-0.4483148754,
0.3597195446,
0.3239176571,
0.5996960402,
0.0767502859,
-0.8688477278,
0.0559695512,
-0.282532841,
0.2007468343,
0.0594445914,
-0.5446760654,
0.3734204769,
0.1696018875,
-0.1700722575,
0.1639835536,
0.76571244,
-0.0332393758,
0.2040192783,
0.7049582005,
0.253785938,
0.6369863153,
-0.0959404632,
0.8539438844,
-0.1954859346,
-0.1479973942,
1.1516708136,
-0.6895495653,
1.0438002348,
0.6586354375,
-0.0947605222,
0.7358559966,
0.5233516097,
0.5315033197,
0.1285503656,
0.3757456243,
-0.7457762957,
-0.3192773461,
-0.3117358387,
-0.1762765795,
0.3348345459,
0.8078324795,
0.0262343921,
-0.1018257812,
0.1684589982,
0.0619639494,
0.387871623,
0.0113007762,
0.9430832863,
0.0799266174,
-0.4819608033,
0.2073763758,
-0.0848696008,
0.5092952251,
-0.7509914041,
-0.1677265465,
0.1794542819,
-0.1509095281,
-0.3066966832,
-0.9692575336,
0.096993506,
-0.0955104455,
-0.2276700884,
-0.4136984348,
0.8006585836,
-0.504689157,
-0.2866929173,
0.4102888405,
0.4886959791,
0.0736390725,
0.179315716,
-0.5883364677,
0.5926885605,
-0.2421537638,
-0.5266469121,
0.2447887212,
0.7082096934,
-0.1972889751,
1.0047347546,
0.5949311256,
0.0075718896,
0.0794138238,
0.2859823704,
0.8357629776,
-0.4932288527,
-0.7054967284,
-0.5813454986,
0.5926318169,
-0.2771896124,
0.0785012096,
0.4889359474,
0.4109142721,
0.2744839489,
0.2447755039,
0.9976621866,
-0.0014574083,
0.706716001,
-0.4966450632,
0.7816332579,
-0.6773492098,
0.3952451944,
0.0098878406,
-0.7512611747,
-0.2690580785,
0.4220747352,
-0.1131188348,
0.0004721634,
0.1942074448,
0.6906365156,
-0.1458647251,
-0.013462265,
0.4043125808,
0.3154557347,
0.7323057652,
0.2205296606,
0.9287762642,
0.3118067682,
0.1090745404,
0.3842327297,
-0.4268299937,
-0.4957952797,
-0.987010181,
-0.7809051275,
-0.6923595071,
-0.0517688207,
-0.1721435785,
0.0098764785,
1.1024377346,
0.750208199,
-0.463840276,
-0.3891642988,
0.2249703258,
0.0877816156,
0.2653652728,
-0.2462180853,
-0.1146471724,
-0.4052045345,
-0.9759252071,
0.5639836192,
0.6323188543,
0.1032505184,
-0.8066672683,
-0.1622947752,
-0.0662683323,
0.2508805394,
0.8791657686,
0.5596598983,
-0.9601299763,
-0.514537394,
-0.1644132435,
-0.1599438488,
-0.2906509042,
0.7681537271,
-0.9859643579,
0.5975275636,
0.4221377969,
1.1404652596,
0.3507575691,
-0.1170386374,
0.7455506921,
-0.4958481193,
0.3223900795,
0.0206144713,
0.0948709697,
0.4201663136,
-0.4666736722,
0.2566637695,
-0.135627687,
-0.4116105437,
-0.6981112957,
0.4213564992,
-1.2278321981,
-0.1349395812,
1.1517212391,
-0.1055737808,
-0.2543489635,
-0.3136845231,
-0.4983761013,
0.0297207143,
-0.4023666978,
0.4213600159,
0.7382199764,
-0.2903333902,
-0.0954152122,
-0.7525880337,
0.1607198268,
0.239710182,
-1.189915061,
0.1869600564,
0.6118175983,
0.0409740955,
0.131532535,
0.609085083,
0.0185276233,
-0.049791079,
-0.3528596163,
-0.0184925608,
-0.1516537368,
-0.1485756487,
-0.1649165899,
0.0460796282,
0.1590872258,
-0.0096008638
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10940v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10940v1
|
Neural machine translation of clinical procedure codes for medical diagnosis and uncertainty quantification
| 2024-02-07T20:11:56 | 2024-02-07T20:11:56 |
Pei-Hung Chung, Shuhan He, Norawit Kijpaisalratana, Abdel-badih el Ariss, Byung-Jun Yoon
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
A Clinical Decision Support System (CDSS) is designed to enhance clinician
decision-making by combining system-generated recommendations with medical
expertise. Given the high costs, intensive labor, and time-sensitive nature of
medical treatments, there is a pressing need for efficient decision support,
especially in complex emergency scenarios. In these scenarios, where
information can be limited, an advanced CDSS framework that leverages AI
(artificial intelligence) models to effectively reduce diagnostic uncertainty
has utility. Such an AI-enabled CDSS framework with quantified uncertainty
promises to be practical and beneficial in the demanding context of real-world
medical care. In this study, we introduce the concept of Medical Entropy,
quantifying uncertainties in patient outcomes predicted by neural machine
translation based on the ICD-9 code of procedures. Our experimental results not
only show strong correlations between procedure and diagnosis sequences based
on the simple ICD-9 code but also demonstrate the promising capacity to model
trends of uncertainties during hospitalizations through a data-driven approach.
|
[
0.0721361861,
-0.4554127753,
0.9516766667,
0.5317090154,
-0.5073043704,
-0.0639376715,
-0.1422506124,
-0.1743583381,
0.10001605,
-0.061237637,
-0.3562323749,
-0.5936695933,
-0.9527921677,
0.1480527818,
-0.3266007602,
0.8610399961,
-0.1555891335,
0.7436594963,
-0.1791148782,
0.2312907428,
-0.4344267249,
-0.3108862936,
-0.7705549598,
-0.2126738429,
0.4399483204,
-0.0852720216,
1.1001722813,
0.6057421565,
1.0663611889,
0.2658472955,
0.0652664155,
0.0335904323,
0.4665328562,
0.3107572198,
0.3557244241,
-0.6641482711,
-0.3914211988,
-0.5237618685,
0.2963864207,
0.6340395212,
-0.517762959,
-0.0854250938,
-0.1492377371,
0.5705422759,
-0.5928304791,
0.0989210382,
-0.199613139,
0.6174943447,
0.1981655508,
-0.4226901531,
-0.2526922524,
-0.4390735328,
0.1522485614,
-0.7632491589,
-0.0669626445,
-0.1316056997,
0.3636750579,
1.023712039,
-0.1726878434,
-0.3915062249,
-0.8093378544,
0.4756956995,
-0.7279287577,
0.4015902877,
0.6378543377,
0.4456542432,
-0.0320892818,
-0.8055506349,
-0.3317113221,
0.1376036406,
-0.0566472225,
0.0809716582,
-0.1770192385,
0.2166701406,
-0.1619830132,
0.1360151023,
-0.6267683506,
0.1879639179,
-0.4521526396,
-0.3481607139,
0.7067266107,
0.6372337937,
0.4099422097,
-0.0194465127,
-0.352509588,
0.0015222597,
-0.1876583546,
-0.1932621449,
-0.2742152512,
-0.1244394109,
-0.4699267745,
0.2548626959,
-0.1428215057,
0.7058022022,
0.0754836053,
-0.3936493397,
0.4623748958,
0.0552755184,
-0.5886531472,
0.3147280514,
0.8867415786,
0.4110874534,
-0.2965800166,
-0.3219304681,
-0.1873553544,
0.0264161844,
0.5064470172,
-0.5341338515,
-0.0942568034,
0.6321892738,
-0.8698177934,
-0.7267385721,
-0.1639101207,
-0.6049924493,
-0.7069119811,
-0.3858354986,
-0.0129875876,
-0.8022174835,
-0.1197765768,
0.5455633402,
-0.0645894259,
-0.2196886241,
0.5842707157,
-0.3305050135,
0.1503384858,
0.4213294983,
0.8135883808,
-0.2095860392,
0.1379705369,
0.1225607395,
-0.1505990922,
-0.7592438459,
0.3679538369,
-0.4090101123,
-0.2768289745,
-0.1048841923,
-0.3908576369,
-0.0713891014,
-0.635186851,
0.5885695815,
-0.5298629403,
-0.2884407043,
0.1522611678,
-0.3586999774,
-0.004058897,
0.1502987593,
-0.3682615459,
0.4855144024,
0.220624283,
-0.3667923808,
0.5199125409,
-0.3112149239,
-0.4642527699,
0.1742516309,
-0.3279527426,
-0.4226490259,
0.3634196818,
-0.0079618711,
0.4305695295,
-0.6961635351,
0.7306379676,
-0.307756573,
-0.0098311966,
0.4661652148,
-0.639490068,
0.7113417387,
0.870246172,
-0.0910833478,
-0.0004727024,
-0.9829273224,
0.2677594423,
-0.1881926805,
-0.4919714928,
-0.3308875859,
0.1110380441,
-0.1085790172,
0.3063479662,
0.205602318,
-0.1176787913,
0.089086704,
-0.1505510658,
0.4499359131,
0.5086097121,
0.1491192728,
0.4882448912,
-0.3012576401,
0.7390826941,
0.5483675599,
0.3977152407,
0.1135402024,
-0.7127196193,
-0.3538395762,
-0.070372574,
0.483572036,
0.9866422415,
-0.8062739372,
0.6254227757,
-0.0388288312,
-0.5005902648,
-0.948118329,
-0.2795894742,
0.3163617551,
0.3915028274,
0.3264669478,
-0.1236580014,
-0.5468379259,
-0.7347351909,
0.2420736104,
-0.3935127258,
-0.342967391,
0.0335742757,
0.1496143043,
-0.3856257498,
0.4179022014,
-0.4999405444,
-0.3006327152,
0.3764923513,
0.171668902,
0.1905315518,
0.8707236052,
0.2244411707,
-0.7744638324,
-0.2034326792,
0.3018354177,
-1.1913284063,
0.1055841893,
-0.570132792,
-0.0474828444,
0.1653402299,
0.5885457993,
-0.6613259315,
0.9580819607,
0.2586352229,
-0.2660455108,
0.2855886221,
-0.7352491021,
0.212541908,
-0.9902595878,
-0.0797084421,
-0.1748997867,
0.1552272439,
-0.5208151937,
0.1151012555,
0.3021062315,
0.0443746112,
-0.2147811651,
0.0620822906,
-0.1299303621,
0.1417971551,
0.0675408095,
-0.4810453653,
0.0038329046,
0.0862540305,
0.0383189395,
0.5115658045,
0.94658041,
-0.6841183305,
0.3466497958,
0.0397301093,
-0.4477343857,
0.621506989,
-0.6422851682,
-0.1503442228,
-0.1322734654,
0.1200657934,
-0.4395256042,
-0.1787714213,
0.1933370084,
-0.6030591726,
0.4012361765,
0.1699293703,
-0.4851089418,
-0.3969319761,
0.3194129765,
0.63473773,
0.4430238903,
0.1254386455,
0.4214737117,
0.1411887556,
-0.2499654144,
-0.5779519081,
-1.0363346338,
0.2671887577,
-0.2687874436,
-0.546992898,
0.5279539824,
-0.1507208049,
-0.5755254626,
-0.1861704886,
0.0391717963,
-0.3172566891,
0.3823418915,
0.2619642913,
0.2065327764,
-0.4135459661,
0.4706692696,
0.5830819011,
-0.1394560188,
0.3311491311,
-0.5858441591,
0.4484571218,
0.0254583061,
-0.4628457427,
-0.7631621361,
0.4535190761,
0.6974479556,
0.0033521471,
0.7497361898,
0.6129528284,
-0.9061995745,
0.1356208026,
-0.254670918,
-0.0278300643,
-0.35893929,
0.2603247464,
-0.1835066378,
-0.2879911363,
0.8975991011,
0.1220621914,
-0.6531501412,
0.399697721,
0.723938942,
-0.2739584446,
1.4568645954,
0.1679466814,
0.0443890579,
-0.1735778451,
-0.0101077389,
0.2293947786,
-0.4420209229,
-0.3749819696,
-0.5424437523,
-0.3425475061,
-0.4663002193,
-0.577716887,
0.9191504121,
0.2543283701,
-0.2389815003,
-0.2718700767,
-0.8643472195,
0.0751522407,
0.5039932728,
0.6902063489,
0.0486391038,
-0.2797148824,
-0.223226428,
0.146473676,
-0.7011612654,
-0.1855841577,
1.0686182976,
0.1613204181,
0.8145218492,
0.0405185968,
0.7313098907,
0.5286939144,
-0.1923327893,
-0.6552067399,
-0.0246950146,
0.1042177007,
-0.2984628975,
-0.3146830499,
-0.3672890663,
-0.8940830827,
-0.1984291971,
-0.2002630085,
-0.3787153661,
0.7382977605,
-0.0856712684,
-1.0823938847,
0.1597879231,
-0.6732110977,
0.5306969881,
-0.2940143347,
0.1903582662,
-0.2543753982,
-1.1718398333,
0.0419447348,
-0.3626563847,
0.227481544,
0.2599821985,
-0.3059446216,
0.3792079091,
-0.6276969314,
0.8128902912,
0.0680009425,
-0.2615866661,
0.1183142439,
0.3489662409,
0.3111596406,
0.340893507,
-0.2683478892,
0.3471299708,
0.0651884228,
-0.321667403,
-0.7422930002,
0.3396921158,
-0.7629750371,
-0.3109388649,
-0.420058459,
-0.7969963551,
-0.1019054353,
0.2346712947,
0.6589787602,
0.3361999989,
0.2014188319,
-0.0864319503,
0.6370228529,
-0.5769386888,
0.2798137069,
0.1816002727,
0.4093444347,
-0.4291902781,
0.7870509624,
0.1749624312,
0.0114534115,
0.5391837358,
0.1363779902,
0.132157445,
-1.0180027485,
-0.4977199435,
-0.3397435844,
-0.5739121437,
-0.8208082318,
-0.4709283412,
-0.1778675318,
-0.510697484,
-0.4945665002,
-0.0440470986,
-0.5296174288,
-0.6390451789,
-0.1848962605,
0.2516127825,
0.5646473169,
-0.3636971414,
0.2498933673,
-0.8743371367,
0.16474922,
-0.1242171004,
0.3458930552,
-0.155233711,
-0.173770383,
-0.4703174531,
0.1599630415,
-0.2729105949,
-0.9206780791,
0.723959446,
-0.0045699226,
0.286421746,
0.8158563972,
0.4633460045,
0.7091158628,
-0.4311353564,
0.6955509782,
0.4303361773,
-0.7571126819,
0.6792494059,
-0.200252533,
0.0164604317,
0.3376669884,
0.2789791822,
-0.3676763177,
-0.3712885976,
-0.8707510233,
-0.7847118378,
0.5102387071,
0.1690877229,
-0.3095337152,
-0.1737481952,
0.4551873803,
-0.0609139726,
0.2896871567,
0.0999686494,
-0.4259313941,
0.100849174,
-0.6870372891,
0.0507115498,
0.182804063,
-0.2200439274,
-0.2993361652,
0.3485969305,
0.0071619726,
0.6331613064,
0.5308899879,
0.1487452984,
-0.4616347253,
0.05381044,
0.9271831512,
0.3863482177,
-0.1758453101,
0.090453662,
0.0050912807,
-0.6301288605,
0.1856474727,
0.1637009829,
-0.1573954076,
-0.0608815923,
0.2006009221,
0.6743539572,
-0.4320453405,
-0.5352138877,
0.2733585835,
-0.1771049798,
-0.0439946614,
-0.4986363351,
-0.0953502879,
-0.1145368665,
0.3265325725,
0.2577883601,
0.9360486865,
0.5124611259,
0.0066958871,
0.4542135894,
0.1201098338,
-0.5196406841,
-0.2356020212,
0.715544939,
0.0759114772,
-0.4877443016,
0.7390397191,
-0.1715991199,
-0.1036531404,
1.2307069302,
0.4645830393,
0.7947158217,
-0.3869682848,
0.2103051245,
0.1675307006,
0.3057570457,
-0.0840518698,
0.4041655362,
0.0196641516,
-0.6164303422,
-0.2283707559,
-0.3603187799,
-0.0933797285,
-0.1533645988,
-1.2446420193,
0.2274131775,
-0.6748280525,
-0.4253046215,
-0.1488856226,
-0.5401591659,
-0.635920465,
0.6104538441,
0.386384815,
0.9197452068,
-0.3811921179,
0.7238109112,
0.5893656015,
-0.3552205563,
-0.6870803237,
-0.2022995651,
0.196249783,
-1.1244757175,
0.5053135753,
-0.4166891873,
0.4153117836,
-0.3314856887,
-0.4601612985,
-0.8957796097,
1.0408729315,
0.4361303151,
-0.3265668154,
-0.2954342067,
0.2193330526,
0.7838782072,
-0.3862459064,
0.1688670218,
0.5414078236,
0.3865980804,
-0.1922867298,
-0.9826633334,
0.1590341479,
-0.3749713302,
-0.0886971727,
0.3049092591,
-0.2849453092,
0.7776305676,
-0.6321903467,
0.1100695133,
0.1567696631,
0.280387044,
0.0753938407,
0.6836256981,
0.1161679104,
0.8313298821,
0.9727403522,
-0.113792941,
1.2932522297,
-0.7028416991,
0.0997618958,
0.704390049,
-0.1258779764,
0.4912774861,
0.5044142008,
-0.4429620206,
0.4087044001,
0.8979396224,
0.3596208394,
0.5925822854,
0.3310852647,
-0.4400275946,
-0.4901816249,
-0.1019000858,
-0.7458620667,
0.130555734,
1.0028281212,
-0.934861064,
0.1465667486,
0.2388443798,
-0.1119967476,
-0.3637799025,
-0.21887815,
0.9688696861,
0.2368656546,
-0.7608497143,
0.748251617,
-0.0006437731,
0.1641710699,
-0.4438129365,
-0.0770580545,
-0.0265890248,
0.1739758104,
-0.3634019792,
-0.4661597908,
0.3421493769,
-0.419870764,
-0.4283086956,
-0.1481757611,
0.2960512936,
-0.08031746,
-0.7981613874,
-0.0891053677,
0.3132239282,
0.1377106458,
0.0193169955,
-0.8803389072,
0.1133192256,
0.0376193896,
0.1717511266,
0.4030226171,
0.9852156639,
0.0183260199,
0.8611529469,
0.2768444717,
0.4361203611,
0.0788097009,
-0.1042540967,
0.66437608,
-0.2496722043,
-0.5084916949,
-0.6514797211,
0.4590980709,
0.3524315059,
-0.5769509077,
-0.0309862923,
0.209766522,
0.4839659631,
-0.0848795399,
0.915486455,
-0.0903852209,
0.1003688797,
-0.6033723354,
0.8892442584,
-0.5050545335,
0.4867680073,
-0.0681432784,
-0.0297141857,
-0.7952554226,
0.6855580211,
0.1012660787,
-0.1828866899,
0.7483882308,
0.5777283311,
0.3737561405,
0.0253458843,
0.3786521852,
0.2695690393,
-0.100769721,
0.5649811625,
0.3993071914,
-0.5571891665,
0.3461517394,
-0.5303365588,
-0.0880270749,
-0.0445382558,
-0.5326673388,
-0.042736195,
-0.6462084651,
-0.5605559349,
-0.6433696747,
0.0725075006,
0.9901317954,
0.8408019543,
-0.9151592255,
0.0864104033,
-0.289481014,
0.2188583463,
-0.7111421824,
-0.1201209575,
0.7255709767,
-0.5645991564,
-0.3114670515,
0.1896425784,
0.3147595823,
0.2538136542,
0.1139078364,
-0.3366923332,
0.307587415,
-0.1302844882,
0.2907837927,
-0.2014841288,
-0.730837822,
0.1516608894,
0.0530875362,
-0.1737834662,
0.1093062833,
0.7550213933,
-0.7344194055,
0.5771718025,
0.3953116238,
0.783301115,
-0.1517663896,
-0.2451619357,
0.8565548062,
-0.4211433232,
0.1019457057,
0.593732357,
0.4833388329,
-0.0311474148,
-0.8787740469,
0.4930077493,
0.2224280834,
-0.5534713864,
-0.8499689698,
-0.0674972981,
-0.6458801627,
-0.2912972271,
0.942553699,
-0.2167032957,
0.1049050689,
-0.4593071342,
0.0904179588,
0.2203079313,
-0.4083516598,
0.9590989947,
0.4132013619,
-0.245914191,
0.0415202826,
-0.41358006,
0.6576088667,
0.4258768857,
-0.5557123423,
-0.4328067899,
0.1803092659,
-0.248241663,
0.4804624617,
0.463434577,
-0.1681821346,
0.5042564273,
-0.0167468451,
0.1335898936,
0.2934010923,
-0.1915326864,
-0.5324647427,
0.1163877994,
-0.1727973372,
-0.2878177166
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05224v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05224v2
|
VerAs: Verify then Assess STEM Lab Reports
| 2024-02-07T20:02:09 | 2024-04-25T16:16:36 |
Berk Atil, Mahsa Sheikhi Karizaki, Rebecca J. Passonneau
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
With an increasing focus in STEM education on critical thinking skills,
science writing plays an ever more important role in curricula that stress
inquiry skills. A recently published dataset of two sets of college level lab
reports from an inquiry-based physics curriculum relies on analytic assessment
rubrics that utilize multiple dimensions, specifying subject matter knowledge
and general components of good explanations. Each analytic dimension is
assessed on a 6-point scale, to provide detailed feedback to students that can
help them improve their science writing skills. Manual assessment can be slow,
and difficult to calibrate for consistency across all students in large
classes. While much work exists on automated assessment of open-ended questions
in STEM subjects, there has been far less work on long-form writing such as lab
reports. We present an end-to-end neural architecture that has separate
verifier and assessment modules, inspired by approaches to Open Domain Question
Answering (OpenQA). VerAs first verifies whether a report contains any content
relevant to a given rubric dimension, and if so, assesses the relevant
sentences. On the lab reports, VerAs outperforms multiple baselines based on
OpenQA systems or Automated Essay Scoring (AES). VerAs also performs well on an
analytic rubric for middle school physics essays.
|
[
0.0239326041,
-0.8913303614,
0.7621501088,
0.2103959769,
0.2550899386,
0.5404070616,
0.0020031745,
-0.3664382398,
0.1675784141,
0.254204303,
-0.5134568214,
-0.5852102041,
-0.1587526649,
0.2157174647,
-0.5844735503,
1.0396857262,
-0.3201218545,
0.1782290041,
-0.6721662283,
0.149981454,
-0.3546257615,
0.0286735296,
-0.5173563361,
-0.2787662446,
0.5199795365,
0.5282949209,
0.2281480879,
0.2977034748,
0.7559079528,
0.3922695816,
0.0084683988,
0.5277697444,
-0.4226175845,
0.2549900115,
-0.3198199868,
-0.3279209435,
-0.3112291694,
-0.0979327038,
0.893150568,
0.6130797863,
0.1429705471,
0.5269995332,
-0.2459910214,
0.7249879837,
-0.8669585586,
-0.1544780582,
-0.3693515658,
0.0119275497,
-0.0117692044,
-0.2363575846,
-0.8343673348,
-0.6948869228,
0.3215379119,
-0.5808722377,
0.2608113885,
0.1768420488,
1.0254286528,
0.0854213685,
-0.3887479007,
-0.0395167433,
-0.8841375709,
0.67706424,
0.1313550919,
0.203821823,
0.315849781,
0.4343096912,
-0.1024242267,
-0.8017725348,
-0.5316574574,
-0.4003083706,
0.1124803722,
0.4467360973,
-0.0784855485,
-0.0766268894,
-0.0260318816,
0.2730652988,
-0.5219268203,
0.031142503,
-0.924326539,
-0.5140761137,
0.5572215319,
0.2914871573,
0.0085851019,
0.0204411168,
-0.4942180812,
-0.1416384578,
-0.7003926039,
0.3441053331,
0.3555096686,
0.1696474701,
0.2698636651,
0.8100644946,
-0.4048284888,
0.5798100829,
-0.0088343816,
0.146831125,
0.2148181796,
-0.4489015043,
-0.1716121584,
0.1109679192,
0.800162375,
0.3741428852,
-0.1129597798,
0.0162849557,
0.0437060222,
0.05734317,
0.5475400686,
-0.6791908741,
-0.0652501583,
0.4877256751,
0.0558793955,
-0.1784887314,
-0.1300850809,
-0.7729018927,
-0.4596216679,
-0.4466115236,
0.8844450116,
-0.5696053505,
0.2235814333,
0.1743952185,
-0.1195451543,
0.2154425234,
0.768381834,
-0.551471293,
0.6698658466,
0.4244022369,
0.9087003469,
-0.0561976992,
-0.6233522892,
-0.7095192075,
-0.0627600178,
-0.6386763453,
1.0936030149,
-0.2795161009,
-0.2637342811,
-0.1016687527,
-0.2229869068,
0.0671636388,
-0.1235895678,
0.4872074425,
-0.506469965,
0.2974441051,
-0.3397084475,
-0.4411100447,
0.0105251279,
0.2222096324,
-0.201854676,
1.3271530867,
0.4524978101,
-0.5706186891,
0.3934561908,
-0.7281440496,
-0.2962747216,
0.0876728892,
-0.0937767997,
-0.3019044399,
0.0292539746,
-0.124423489,
0.3936388195,
-0.3685318828,
-0.0694833994,
0.2087269574,
-0.0872851536,
0.5398218632,
-0.1482350528,
0.3931269944,
-0.1539963037,
0.0032228555,
0.632245779,
-0.982557714,
0.382319659,
-0.2743798494,
-0.0943517163,
-0.0381556675,
-0.0086073242,
-0.3228949904,
-0.2902456522,
0.1303454638,
-1.1612976789,
-0.2480298579,
-0.2066171169,
0.0413225554,
0.7236912251,
-0.0482229441,
0.3336116672,
-0.5205447674,
0.3722007573,
-0.1728770286,
0.131559521,
-0.1053135246,
-0.3698392212,
-0.6814606786,
-0.4423718154,
0.1138675809,
0.6894401908,
-0.5090481639,
0.6417446136,
-0.134497121,
-1.1869344711,
-0.7008581758,
-0.1133243591,
0.5488637686,
0.979203999,
0.7697939277,
-0.3437719941,
-0.1288513988,
-0.7796126008,
0.0326747596,
-0.2221178561,
-0.1462405324,
-0.0644657686,
0.6957963705,
0.3650654554,
1.1764942408,
-0.7675090432,
-0.2456843853,
-0.0028448454,
0.3715069592,
-0.0086141676,
0.4730440378,
0.2895299196,
-0.3992302418,
-0.4868572652,
0.1533475369,
-0.4464601278,
-0.087921083,
-0.0819448382,
-0.3322887421,
0.004034542,
0.2907489538,
-0.6549313664,
0.6654184461,
0.0985993221,
-0.6806216836,
0.9768276811,
-0.5328840613,
0.4377352595,
-0.490726918,
0.0371828936,
0.0417411178,
-0.1496818811,
-0.4653511047,
-0.2330928892,
0.2378877103,
0.233090356,
-0.5305774808,
0.3428552151,
-0.4106313288,
-0.0475237556,
-0.1372528672,
0.1608854234,
0.4230619371,
-0.1145326644,
-0.0928598046,
0.48901847,
0.8670890331,
-0.5670807958,
0.6802175641,
0.0948812515,
-0.4941538274,
0.8281299472,
-0.7573324442,
0.046751406,
-0.3945353031,
0.3231259286,
-0.971603334,
-0.2269947231,
-0.2740453482,
-0.7889559269,
0.3378959,
0.2551258206,
-0.4451817274,
-0.5380391479,
-0.6565769911,
-0.1436039209,
0.4214713275,
-0.3447420001,
0.9894897938,
-0.0642173216,
0.0025836832,
-0.9327683449,
-0.4982661009,
-0.3007743657,
0.1287849247,
-0.6279844642,
0.1261952668,
-0.2195055783,
-0.2480446994,
0.082529746,
-0.0895019621,
-0.2971602678,
0.1876483709,
0.3282976449,
0.7361641526,
-0.3074609041,
0.2654334605,
0.5289888382,
-0.0653440207,
0.3138328493,
-0.0296975616,
0.2252987027,
-0.4625501931,
-0.4425400198,
-0.3653463423,
0.3402382433,
0.9690514803,
-0.3142884076,
0.6964645386,
0.4088200033,
-0.4118013084,
-0.3946049511,
-0.5519809723,
-0.2087363899,
-0.476152122,
0.505028069,
-0.3600279391,
-0.7750835419,
0.5362309813,
0.1609658897,
0.2516037226,
0.7436949611,
0.6491510868,
-0.1588431895,
0.3131556511,
0.580958128,
0.4731316864,
-0.1367574781,
-0.1626506001,
0.3207035363,
-0.7478837371,
-0.7249501944,
-0.9160662293,
0.0150213102,
0.1100663692,
-0.5158917904,
0.3799565732,
-0.2438109368,
-0.3045269847,
0.0150091555,
-0.8765388727,
0.9796524048,
0.3935328424,
0.0871777236,
0.2213196456,
-0.0936367139,
-0.1376706362,
0.0043313983,
-0.188536644,
-0.4743492603,
0.9292238951,
0.4289324582,
0.5842152238,
0.0952956453,
0.4450483322,
0.1322748065,
0.587908268,
-0.9789681435,
0.6947492957,
0.142851159,
-0.7078216672,
-0.6273269653,
-0.2843598723,
-0.6641024351,
0.3141443729,
-0.3554285169,
-0.9218314886,
-0.0959670693,
-0.1935129017,
-0.8096508384,
0.1435551941,
-0.8492763042,
0.5401066542,
-0.0339667574,
-0.8080965281,
-0.3131509721,
-0.7343023419,
0.1375598907,
-0.2266857177,
0.0048192623,
-0.1360632777,
0.0615838431,
0.919670105,
-0.371191442,
0.767575562,
0.1076257676,
0.2072107494,
0.7845474482,
0.2812738419,
-0.2098310739,
0.1493437141,
-0.0344679356,
-0.2669204772,
0.3854152858,
-0.1810829043,
-0.4839785993,
0.6263601184,
-1.0097106695,
-0.4835362136,
-0.805349052,
-0.641687274,
-0.1772579104,
0.2161547989,
0.1698921472,
0.4865283966,
-0.2260146141,
0.1184363142,
0.9615454078,
0.1142067388,
0.1888922155,
0.7619441152,
-0.2961652279,
-0.3487164974,
0.9057864547,
0.2173699439,
0.4392077029,
0.4262815714,
0.4643882215,
-0.2729508281,
-0.572416544,
-0.5383008718,
0.20924218,
-0.9398223758,
-0.5025821328,
-0.648142755,
-0.4993102252,
-0.5238050818,
-0.5329412818,
-0.6080700159,
-0.4232123494,
-0.3141971827,
-0.4471051991,
0.6293322444,
0.961420536,
-0.2489845306,
0.0930856243,
-0.8256937265,
0.1929036975,
0.1312975734,
0.1113590002,
-0.2033391893,
-0.5571009517,
-0.1882393211,
-0.2765598893,
-0.4716836512,
-0.7876372337,
0.0481444709,
0.0314317718,
0.3325780034,
0.0764431804,
-0.1738698184,
0.2874237895,
-0.5605251193,
0.9463051558,
0.3906906545,
-1.1958035231,
0.7093140483,
-0.123433277,
-0.008667252,
0.7549265623,
0.6390808821,
-0.0805033445,
-0.4424245656,
-0.3108362854,
-0.5890809894,
0.4725195467,
0.0787662938,
0.033310093,
0.1100889817,
0.434068352,
0.2510908842,
-0.1161142811,
-0.4393748641,
-0.081306912,
-0.2121482491,
-0.363435626,
0.2351113409,
-0.0353269242,
-0.3635930121,
-0.4549614787,
0.5314477086,
-0.298509717,
-0.0184297673,
0.7133123875,
0.4070513248,
-0.2376691103,
0.3688718379,
0.4930703938,
0.8311445713,
-0.2307779193,
0.1810822487,
0.241569832,
-0.7962275147,
0.1789766699,
-0.0665210858,
-0.2054941058,
-0.061018087,
0.2784264684,
0.1817720383,
-0.4198668897,
-0.6697188616,
0.5431441665,
-0.273319602,
-0.4628999531,
-0.1920442581,
0.2361347079,
-0.1534584314,
-0.1148809865,
0.3573352695,
0.2525448203,
0.1252707839,
-0.5677090883,
-0.0159475692,
0.0792173818,
-0.4445364773,
-0.2776742876,
0.2414351255,
0.0505426042,
-0.1324894577,
0.420745492,
0.0472250506,
-0.4165738523,
0.7726765871,
0.4201280475,
0.8013147712,
-0.5289553404,
0.5373311639,
0.6322422624,
0.5421020985,
0.0186988749,
0.7804594636,
-0.0789322928,
-0.4450249374,
-0.5296775103,
-0.6067388654,
-0.9773128033,
-0.4406350255,
-0.5776569843,
0.3913018703,
-0.9003711343,
-0.0761175305,
0.1244389191,
0.0272920299,
-0.3978874981,
0.5575045943,
-0.3062072694,
0.9397234321,
-1.0546150208,
0.3820511997,
0.6819565296,
-0.3113432825,
-0.617564559,
-0.7021600008,
0.0789033473,
-0.3981928229,
0.834246397,
0.2084849626,
-0.6792080402,
-0.2895200253,
-0.6392660141,
-1.1803088188,
1.1127676964,
-0.2101915032,
-0.0697156712,
0.3715297282,
-0.1295651495,
0.867395699,
-0.3225595057,
0.5417824984,
0.3484296501,
0.3018747866,
0.2333308607,
-0.8327524066,
0.1424304098,
-0.1519150436,
-0.6982877254,
0.1265304089,
-0.5689057708,
0.7736991048,
-0.5021528006,
0.0140645523,
0.0762431771,
1.1167961359,
0.2040394992,
0.6720240712,
0.1060756296,
0.2790782154,
1.1963094473,
-0.2092241049,
0.8155659437,
0.1513436288,
-0.0119135175,
1.1849570274,
-0.6242409945,
1.0449819565,
0.4786261916,
-0.2397028059,
0.8090464473,
0.3609595597,
-0.1120391414,
0.3086007833,
0.8003112078,
-0.3644179404,
0.028098084,
-0.4798253179,
-0.2054873407,
0.4640412927,
0.6697477698,
0.1085826904,
-0.0255790185,
-0.1932076663,
-0.0909382328,
0.3434817195,
-0.2608788908,
0.2196172625,
-0.3027768731,
-0.874658823,
-0.125921011,
-0.107298404,
0.0476264805,
-0.8407584429,
0.0572654232,
0.1036919951,
0.2457884103,
-0.466681838,
-1.2998262644,
0.4492277205,
0.1364402026,
-0.1763325185,
-0.1429855078,
0.7192353606,
-0.0991036147,
-0.4711188674,
0.046827089,
0.5284904242,
0.0403656028,
0.5705112219,
-0.0034638788,
0.0023764742,
-0.3850908279,
-0.277533561,
0.0006552908,
0.4664166868,
0.1555900872,
0.8115104437,
0.651805222,
0.1378337592,
0.0779270306,
0.0799137279,
0.8495191932,
-0.3359601498,
-0.338509351,
-0.5206941366,
0.8305081725,
-0.3877559602,
-0.6345997453,
0.6846097708,
0.7004473805,
0.4596470892,
0.0869380459,
0.6266502142,
0.1500178725,
0.8203744888,
-0.6741991639,
0.6801814437,
-0.1734613031,
-0.0588592961,
-0.0501837544,
-0.6553013921,
-0.5331439972,
0.533844471,
-0.2966498733,
-0.1032869518,
1.4393678904,
0.5164395571,
0.3928867877,
0.2891354561,
0.1643627584,
0.2945893705,
0.5431349874,
0.4938451648,
1.170853138,
-0.2840756178,
0.2135736644,
-0.4018263221,
-0.6135722995,
0.1916109174,
-0.7095137239,
-1.1931517124,
-0.5180260539,
-0.7529363632,
-0.7076330185,
-0.2672917247,
0.4767606258,
0.2599650621,
-0.3909439147,
-0.0867397785,
0.157421872,
0.1730463505,
0.0292288139,
-0.2594898343,
0.5709747672,
-0.2605439425,
-0.1843514144,
0.5864434242,
0.6249138713,
0.1527578384,
-0.4014694691,
0.395109266,
-0.0262218863,
0.4540840387,
0.5244289041,
0.2416400909,
-0.435120374,
-0.5019577742,
0.4655287862,
-0.2504517138,
-0.0161521882,
0.5136734247,
-0.8897697926,
0.536722064,
0.7431289554,
0.5302339196,
0.424256444,
-0.3832386136,
0.2131224722,
-0.3511363268,
-0.4535349607,
0.5325165391,
0.3021930456,
0.5301752687,
-0.4828076363,
0.3647009432,
0.0555367395,
-0.7462893724,
-0.810814023,
-0.0991653651,
-1.3497130871,
-0.1011966839,
0.642529726,
-0.3051357567,
-0.5538294315,
-0.1671505421,
-0.3620973229,
-0.0147618726,
-0.2180014998,
0.7753409743,
0.8418121338,
-0.2145158201,
0.3608207703,
-0.2217800766,
0.1010078713,
0.5277327895,
-1.1258510351,
0.0956538096,
0.6544606686,
0.1081341058,
0.7454723716,
0.6764710546,
-0.1023348421,
0.6694951653,
0.1530131251,
-0.0547121614,
-0.1271054,
-0.9089779854,
0.0619449131,
0.4683752358,
-0.2066941112,
-0.223395884
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05201v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05201v2
|
The Effect of Sampling Temperature on Problem Solving in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-07T19:11:23 | 2024-06-14T18:41:51 |
Matthew Renze, Erhan Guven
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this research study, we empirically investigate the effect of sampling
temperature on the performance of Large Language Models (LLMs) on various
problem-solving tasks. We created a multiple-choice question-and-answer (MCQA)
exam by randomly sampling problems from standard LLM benchmarks. Then, we used
nine popular LLMs with five prompt-engineering techniques to solve the MCQA
problems while increasing the sampling temperature from 0.0 to 1.6. Despite
anecdotal reports to the contrary, our empirical results indicate that changes
in temperature from 0.0 to 1.0 do not have a statistically significant impact
on LLM performance for problem-solving tasks. In addition, these results appear
to generalize across LLMs, prompt-engineering techniques, and problem domains.
All code, data, and supplemental materials are available on GitHub at:
https://github.com/matthewrenze/jhu-llm-temperature
|
[
-0.4911494255,
-0.9114167094,
0.8112967014,
0.2694296539,
-0.0989854038,
-0.0240267664,
-0.3957621157,
-0.3648957312,
0.1872105896,
0.383155942,
-0.2791228592,
-0.3513401747,
-0.3304806352,
0.0912975371,
-0.312933892,
0.4867653549,
-0.1237721592,
0.021945646,
-0.4448443949,
0.2924503386,
-0.2487329841,
-0.8059945703,
-0.7958801389,
-0.2070990652,
0.7032907605,
0.6799513102,
0.3667972684,
0.3926454186,
0.4166463614,
0.3071595728,
-0.2519970834,
-0.2278482467,
-0.4332674146,
0.560012877,
0.0879946649,
-0.527579844,
-0.0146922767,
0.0686529055,
0.689794302,
0.6441283226,
-0.3665515184,
0.3155252934,
-0.0254849214,
0.6903303862,
-0.6908633113,
0.2440377027,
-0.7780478001,
-0.3429607749,
-0.3987280726,
-0.2977259159,
-0.4586847723,
-0.0860976651,
-0.0399203226,
-0.4865528047,
0.3903978169,
0.2940391004,
0.3480201364,
0.2512577474,
-0.4061262608,
-0.2336591184,
-0.7276624441,
1.0676225424,
-0.831827879,
0.1781384051,
0.133215338,
0.168200314,
-0.3694913983,
-0.2550789714,
-0.7968318462,
-0.2358561158,
0.534019649,
0.1058532298,
0.0525761135,
-0.1454693526,
0.5831688643,
0.1875510216,
-0.5268087387,
0.2215373367,
-0.5865143538,
-0.0274758004,
0.6724220514,
0.431090802,
0.2828238308,
-0.0606362857,
-0.1041513085,
-0.2811667621,
-0.4571049511,
0.3307549059,
0.3503694832,
0.504375875,
0.1152628288,
0.3768158555,
-0.2092456073,
0.6899965405,
-0.3769138455,
0.0549327172,
0.2981346548,
-0.0522678085,
-0.257737875,
-0.1961784214,
0.544003427,
0.1704957485,
0.3469314277,
-0.0096700732,
-0.0955872685,
-0.4997046292,
0.0350154229,
-0.7656496167,
-0.4566226006,
0.4088761806,
0.0182275064,
-0.1257133484,
-0.0297358967,
-0.7012050748,
-0.4741970897,
-0.3864540458,
0.1792128384,
0.1251632124,
-0.5026900172,
0.107366845,
-0.4408296943,
0.2878941894,
0.2554666698,
-0.6322324276,
0.2159174383,
0.4845161736,
0.5727297664,
-0.2233410627,
-0.3215489984,
-0.0853671953,
-0.0854006484,
-0.4357641637,
0.8988076448,
-0.6882476211,
-0.659106791,
-0.154258877,
-0.0949224308,
-0.2591030598,
-0.8152958155,
0.2609565258,
-0.8140458465,
-0.0389086902,
-0.7601558566,
-0.3048499227,
0.238594532,
0.3490192592,
-0.900036633,
1.2506980896,
-0.3465259373,
-0.6016275883,
0.1074983478,
-0.4546725154,
-0.0901218802,
-0.2323355824,
0.0510164499,
-0.2075529099,
0.1581941396,
0.1629854888,
0.4027069211,
-0.4410871863,
-0.1186775044,
-0.5225800276,
-0.3430230618,
0.7777095437,
-0.2784681022,
0.6841804981,
0.2739549875,
-0.0192882121,
-0.0871710181,
-0.6264952421,
0.2258275896,
0.412311852,
-0.3651952446,
-0.37794137,
-0.200630784,
-0.1666522622,
0.1316645294,
0.1288270652,
-0.6359201074,
0.3983808458,
-0.2015109062,
0.0771173164,
0.7252922058,
0.3344099522,
0.4559173584,
-0.4942078292,
0.7697321177,
0.1415119618,
-0.3532190621,
-0.0113231596,
-0.7274201512,
-0.5922840834,
-0.1428762525,
0.239838928,
0.7670372725,
-0.8523335457,
-0.427041471,
0.2468248308,
-0.7025817633,
-0.1073698327,
0.3419086337,
0.1696467698,
0.3727224767,
0.2887306511,
0.1548313349,
-0.3688747585,
-0.7500662208,
-0.27896294,
0.0100416932,
-0.1881267875,
0.3601494431,
0.5081543326,
0.4014576077,
1.0268667936,
-0.7271119356,
0.2807264924,
-0.1398689002,
0.2050468475,
0.5040177107,
0.5514379144,
0.593306601,
-0.5777741075,
-0.3722862601,
-0.4346752763,
-0.5605486035,
-0.3780647814,
0.1920440793,
-0.0814630166,
0.4412131011,
0.771084547,
-0.8677913547,
0.1300771683,
0.6434252858,
0.004177901,
0.9342743754,
-0.0561828762,
0.3488491476,
-1.0127700567,
0.1329326034,
0.3592576981,
0.2697057426,
-0.7507032156,
0.3640353084,
0.1064060777,
-0.2342454195,
-0.7731258869,
0.9002091289,
-0.571361661,
0.2283429503,
-0.3708564937,
-0.0125591084,
-0.0629052371,
0.2243957818,
-0.1450177282,
0.9565646648,
0.4708856642,
-0.8578885794,
0.5670009255,
-0.2862678766,
-0.3548074067,
0.0857923552,
-0.6524532437,
0.4400507212,
-0.2308718711,
0.2903663218,
-1.0888297558,
-0.1970334649,
0.0653941631,
-0.5076626539,
0.2689146101,
0.0912845135,
-0.8615163565,
-0.3614807129,
-0.2021718472,
0.6846860647,
0.3944800496,
-0.2644133866,
0.28519243,
0.0411240533,
-0.5191636682,
-0.3098877966,
-0.5495993495,
-0.232283175,
-0.3161202967,
-0.413982749,
0.0588520467,
-0.4844431877,
-0.7336471081,
-0.3113517463,
-0.1371876001,
-0.2626044452,
0.2262340039,
-0.0469519123,
0.0945985839,
-0.038694635,
0.3698585927,
-0.1510933191,
0.0133244824,
0.5691940188,
0.0724234506,
0.7447588444,
0.1269036531,
-0.4074354768,
-0.1133210063,
0.5694615245,
0.3770098686,
-0.0523367003,
0.8664990664,
0.1343484372,
-0.348341018,
-0.2633794546,
-0.715318501,
-0.3199258149,
-0.5306072831,
0.2612397969,
-0.6382454038,
-0.7572706938,
0.848171711,
0.2244048417,
0.1734531224,
0.3935171664,
0.657669723,
-0.4727218747,
0.8511580825,
0.339191556,
0.0249948315,
0.4630461037,
0.0388189703,
-0.0367172621,
-0.7807043791,
-0.2040790319,
-1.0453983545,
-0.3896249235,
-0.5144427419,
-0.5544754863,
0.5709027648,
0.0271342937,
-0.3288112581,
-0.1474585682,
-0.1055872217,
0.7245302796,
0.8594784737,
0.1411263496,
0.1020596772,
-0.1604558229,
-0.0533002988,
-0.1014062092,
-0.6961510777,
-0.0993695036,
1.134940505,
0.2512637079,
0.7513332367,
0.1596036106,
0.8693125844,
-0.2178796679,
0.1909992695,
-0.5131214261,
0.6925758719,
0.2133813947,
-0.9702980518,
-0.5743501186,
-0.654599309,
-1.020657897,
0.1633209735,
0.1362839937,
-0.7910688519,
-0.1834252477,
0.0599167272,
-0.2169428319,
0.35889709,
-0.7462792397,
0.6104169488,
-0.0384652428,
-0.2041146457,
-0.1607049108,
-0.1765832454,
0.3798522651,
-0.1190818474,
0.5423753858,
-0.2610662282,
0.1451421231,
0.9561886787,
-0.0430912264,
0.9087898731,
-0.3350721896,
-0.296150744,
0.3781512678,
0.18611148,
0.450587064,
0.0542071089,
-0.5570394993,
-0.0666407198,
0.3712332547,
-0.9993310571,
-0.6840905547,
0.7734116316,
-0.7038196921,
-1.1204899549,
-0.6888716817,
-1.010568738,
-0.4571195841,
-0.0812430754,
0.0072472366,
0.352984041,
0.056431774,
0.2144435495,
0.9577797055,
-0.4967925549,
0.5084950924,
0.6517859101,
-0.4198449552,
0.0849400312,
0.7481458187,
0.4380349219,
0.5870271921,
0.1227810904,
0.2603861988,
0.0465377644,
-0.549338758,
-0.4081846178,
0.2003368288,
-0.8139856458,
-0.0779301599,
-0.3741341531,
-0.3381691873,
-0.6065140963,
0.0212271474,
-0.1130826175,
-0.2247605175,
-0.4780212045,
0.1447675973,
0.4829421341,
0.2810180187,
0.0803440511,
0.1475916505,
-0.8634693027,
0.0743712634,
0.2951099277,
0.1176483035,
0.0870220661,
-0.6721730828,
-0.1971397549,
0.0687788501,
-0.0549025498,
-0.8993926048,
0.2725519836,
-0.1202610061,
0.8115873933,
0.0400648899,
0.330262363,
0.5436775684,
-0.15814735,
0.9638207555,
-0.0105099427,
-0.7443704605,
0.2929302156,
-0.4046487212,
1.1627113819,
0.4002529383,
0.4868689775,
-0.4485400319,
-0.6745167971,
-0.4687284231,
-0.844369173,
0.2205507159,
-0.1005263031,
0.51580441,
0.0114303073,
0.5163064599,
-0.1091453582,
0.043387413,
-0.4855090082,
-0.3533348739,
0.3904879689,
0.1968333572,
-0.2550599873,
-0.4649659693,
-0.0148146078,
-0.4720260799,
0.6723965406,
0.0158380531,
0.3026994765,
0.0579884499,
0.1313674003,
-0.1083799154,
0.5769731402,
0.7962233424,
0.6885718703,
-0.4723617733,
0.0847008526,
0.4780948162,
-0.3410098553,
-0.1472581923,
0.1184649169,
-0.0581408851,
-0.0828218162,
0.2383214533,
0.1524175555,
0.0589450411,
-0.6128535867,
-0.0620971844,
-0.0900288224,
-0.4090367556,
-0.3251822889,
0.3273120224,
0.1730153114,
0.2005384117,
0.7162259817,
-0.0858577862,
0.0461826883,
-0.7486972809,
-0.0836160332,
0.4829258621,
0.0778024122,
-0.0440033302,
0.2779526412,
0.0575081669,
-0.1821871549,
0.844635129,
-0.1566258967,
-0.5597033501,
1.0983946323,
0.8423175812,
0.1864740849,
-0.3074592054,
-0.0565672219,
0.4321583807,
0.3488374054,
0.0979650393,
0.7076907754,
0.1418601424,
-0.7964545488,
-0.4832043648,
-0.5306887627,
-0.8880153894,
0.162301451,
-0.6276652813,
-0.07537736,
-0.4942569137,
-0.0881633162,
-0.263651371,
0.0817033648,
-0.889586091,
0.3644453883,
0.2218086869,
1.0851018429,
-0.7707189918,
0.7468503118,
0.6617288589,
-0.1502084285,
-1.1166946888,
0.1173087358,
0.1938244849,
-0.6441107988,
0.5019267201,
-0.0553881116,
-0.0198752079,
0.1149755269,
-0.7263489962,
-1.2234075069,
0.9741466641,
0.3150782883,
-0.6441600919,
0.0374132358,
0.2226858288,
0.557590425,
0.0748359412,
0.3054460883,
0.6786516905,
0.4771037996,
0.3024326563,
-1.2044935226,
0.0080289794,
-0.4869920611,
-0.1354044378,
0.2135522813,
-0.6586004496,
0.8497530222,
-0.2682268322,
-0.113539204,
-0.0310254879,
0.6633563042,
0.7308628559,
0.6615254879,
0.3721345663,
0.60774225,
0.8830257058,
-0.0708761215,
1.1451816559,
-0.2668879628,
0.1684966385,
0.8702540398,
-0.5046015978,
1.0351066589,
0.7886354923,
-0.2008311599,
0.1586632282,
0.6591662169,
0.2521287203,
0.2963929474,
0.7729684711,
-0.3646303117,
-0.2081965953,
-0.0831580162,
-0.7369982004,
0.234210223,
0.3039948642,
-0.0305901524,
-0.0809037611,
0.1713504642,
0.1643082649,
-0.0901671126,
-0.3906284273,
0.3909920752,
0.3271043301,
-0.5322758555,
0.4806102812,
0.0356831811,
0.4942247272,
-0.2155004591,
0.2587857842,
-0.2440722138,
-0.1713582277,
-0.0419347212,
-1.0009921789,
0.3993748724,
0.0454010218,
-0.311552763,
-0.3863510191,
0.489418149,
-0.1387969404,
-0.6682159901,
-0.0983083993,
0.7292538285,
0.2847007513,
-0.2932211757,
-0.3612554371,
0.3131752312,
-0.3692981899,
-0.7421993017,
0.4784690142,
0.4202768803,
0.1662486643,
0.7280637622,
0.8179844618,
-0.0284914896,
0.1488673091,
0.1376472861,
0.9344388247,
-0.8305375576,
-0.2503342032,
-0.7369299531,
0.2740228176,
0.0419365093,
-0.3119182885,
0.6723498106,
0.6212251782,
0.8456835151,
-0.1326068342,
0.7270405293,
0.1008875892,
0.6925244331,
-1.0113286972,
0.4478902817,
-0.4429953098,
0.4108729661,
-0.3268502653,
-1.1908963919,
-0.2561088204,
-0.059561871,
-0.7712222934,
0.2621966302,
0.8211221695,
0.8962330222,
0.2728549838,
-0.1627345532,
0.3167538345,
0.2236769199,
0.4602983594,
0.3916683793,
0.9150561094,
-0.0499963798,
0.4958517849,
-0.4037380517,
-0.151876688,
0.0151508814,
-0.8053708673,
-0.8079026937,
-0.6409623623,
-0.3038544059,
-0.4721373022,
-0.0279011,
1.0399521589,
0.3738648593,
-0.7809320688,
-0.2436690181,
0.3948711455,
-0.0359905511,
-0.1242502257,
-0.2717813253,
0.0698947385,
-0.3574002981,
-0.7729483247,
0.359118849,
-0.1990270168,
-0.1655576676,
-0.2515088022,
0.2679347396,
-0.0568762757,
0.4771026969,
0.3171908557,
0.3266143799,
-0.5593889952,
-0.160111472,
0.2869012356,
-0.3336142302,
0.0444910824,
0.8589583635,
-0.6369941831,
0.1929498464,
0.6419177055,
0.6311964989,
0.6084933281,
-0.0091851056,
0.3664152324,
-0.8278018832,
0.028098328,
0.1549722403,
0.3359909356,
0.0254051425,
-0.3205589652,
-0.0471225753,
0.1197766885,
-0.7130449414,
-0.7620048523,
0.3005809188,
-1.0294975042,
-0.526550591,
1.4583775997,
0.2762167454,
-0.3595321476,
0.0452785492,
-0.1710790992,
0.0620214827,
-0.5449960828,
1.1516854763,
1.1283103228,
-0.0997984931,
-0.6507076621,
-1.0870701075,
0.0255870949,
0.6029569507,
-0.7464207411,
-0.0482193604,
0.3807886541,
0.5610942841,
-0.1288943589,
0.707909584,
0.3695424497,
0.2865368128,
-0.0538281687,
0.0496657602,
-0.2307249308,
-0.1757603437,
-0.2010045052,
0.2906984985,
0.2691053748,
0.2082260102
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05200v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05200v1
|
Are LLMs Ready for Real-World Materials Discovery?
| 2024-02-07T19:10:36 | 2024-02-07T19:10:36 |
Santiago Miret, N M Anoop Krishnan
|
cond-mat.mtrl-sci
|
cond-mat.mtrl-sci, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) create exciting possibilities for powerful
language processing tools to accelerate research in materials science. While
LLMs have great potential to accelerate materials understanding and discovery,
they currently fall short in being practical materials science tools. In this
position paper, we show relevant failure cases of LLMs in materials science
that reveal current limitations of LLMs related to comprehending and reasoning
over complex, interconnected materials science knowledge. Given those
shortcomings, we outline a framework for developing Materials Science LLMs
(MatSci-LLMs) that are grounded in materials science knowledge and hypothesis
generation followed by hypothesis testing. The path to attaining performant
MatSci-LLMs rests in large part on building high-quality, multi-modal datasets
sourced from scientific literature where various information extraction
challenges persist. As such, we describe key materials science information
extraction challenges which need to be overcome in order to build large-scale,
multi-modal datasets that capture valuable materials science knowledge.
Finally, we outline a roadmap for applying future MatSci-LLMs for real-world
materials discovery via: 1. Automated Knowledge Base Generation; 2. Automated
In-Silico Material Design; and 3. MatSci-LLM Integrated Self-Driving Materials
Laboratories.
|
[
-0.1762845516,
-0.6291370392,
1.1272563934,
-0.0516857728,
0.081080839,
0.5020350814,
-0.0684504732,
-0.371747911,
-0.1599562168,
0.178090468,
-0.6854093075,
-0.361030072,
-0.3474633098,
0.1965902597,
-0.2105270922,
0.4730410278,
-0.4103414416,
0.1089010164,
-0.6069537401,
0.4038999379,
-0.2244350314,
-0.4004743695,
-0.2946308851,
-0.3659848869,
0.3244898021,
0.6559482813,
0.3261901438,
0.6503394842,
0.4915205836,
0.200906232,
-0.0840609372,
0.6377173662,
-0.0342298448,
0.2478463948,
-0.1625820547,
-0.6664523482,
-0.4172553718,
0.2972699404,
0.6547626257,
0.8695808649,
-0.0355313048,
0.110924527,
-0.1152366251,
0.3360902667,
-0.2486709654,
0.0684955642,
-0.4986949861,
0.4977374673,
-0.3182859123,
-0.5301135778,
-0.4398357868,
0.0399925187,
0.0882310197,
-0.6957208514,
0.4242382348,
0.4358963072,
0.7551713586,
0.0046010902,
-0.4507324696,
-0.4581900835,
-0.7855935693,
0.9465938807,
-0.617869556,
0.6340282559,
0.345117867,
0.4168960154,
-0.4922149777,
-0.7131328583,
-0.4991378784,
-0.4217163026,
0.1755717844,
0.0728693902,
0.8247391582,
-0.1691717356,
0.2091226131,
0.390783757,
-0.3497773707,
0.1075998023,
-0.4278026521,
-0.3738279939,
0.2351127416,
0.4619413614,
0.1968719661,
0.0768424347,
-0.4104411602,
-0.0442766286,
-1.028124094,
-0.4326196313,
0.2725792825,
0.3822341263,
-0.0455099382,
0.7319030762,
0.0304715801,
0.2097238302,
-0.482910037,
-0.2989667058,
0.1929752976,
-0.6823586226,
0.0574630499,
-0.0857912004,
0.4847401977,
-0.0928669199,
0.172090143,
-0.3390353024,
-0.3050911129,
-0.1857227534,
-0.0389568396,
-0.9118914604,
-0.0004754137,
0.3667028248,
-0.334428668,
-0.2036520243,
0.0893846899,
-0.5486533046,
-0.7279786468,
-0.4961899221,
0.191246435,
-0.0865060613,
-0.5890375972,
0.1970422119,
-0.4235049188,
0.0672565028,
0.5688998103,
-0.7782271504,
0.3301484883,
0.6013061404,
1.0493600368,
-0.2650925815,
-0.4389900863,
-0.2291807383,
0.2448875457,
-0.4275160134,
0.947640717,
-0.2495197952,
-0.5771206617,
-0.3032151759,
0.1150088981,
0.2744279206,
-0.7106529474,
0.3895054162,
-0.1145268157,
0.0560432412,
-0.5625225902,
-0.3124980927,
0.252337873,
0.3178559542,
-0.4855861068,
0.7602319717,
-0.0038859094,
-0.6734696627,
0.3123336434,
-0.4372270405,
-0.4177784622,
-0.1070561409,
-0.3894999623,
-0.381059438,
0.1534275115,
-0.3967000842,
0.6792080998,
-0.8651906848,
0.5518205166,
-0.4838557541,
-0.2225332558,
0.5944043398,
-0.496565938,
0.1596566886,
0.3166164458,
-0.2237236053,
-0.3205086887,
-0.8308846951,
-0.3323869407,
0.295136869,
-0.3804225922,
0.1001325473,
0.478233397,
0.0925411582,
0.3562246263,
0.3156681061,
-0.8070016503,
0.0348061174,
-0.0864735395,
0.5231698751,
1.0697489977,
-0.2136606276,
0.4821262956,
-0.259331882,
0.4040564001,
0.0947896317,
-0.1449330449,
-0.3004294336,
-0.0319114737,
-0.8156222701,
0.0875681266,
0.2423487008,
0.3772161901,
-0.4660537839,
0.0763407126,
-0.1725083292,
-0.6953253746,
-0.0432905331,
0.095937252,
0.1149176508,
0.5917124748,
0.0736585632,
-0.0796310902,
-0.611276567,
-0.7213242054,
-0.1238500252,
0.1090738997,
0.0668266863,
0.3191259801,
0.3844636977,
-0.0957707688,
1.1035398245,
-0.6572849751,
-0.3215847015,
-0.0996851325,
0.0225714594,
0.2997199297,
0.368204385,
-0.1384619772,
-0.9501392245,
-0.0826766193,
0.0750619173,
-1.1435015202,
0.1587325335,
0.0532122403,
0.2705451548,
-0.0710104033,
0.8586493731,
-0.488623172,
-0.0526719131,
0.1301921755,
-0.145425275,
0.6187084913,
-0.238632828,
-0.0693166479,
-0.9753699303,
0.0436415374,
0.1975061148,
-0.0333000831,
-0.5565957427,
-0.2997973859,
-0.0352462679,
-0.3892801106,
-0.6151023507,
0.7819344997,
-0.7654449344,
-0.4652914107,
-0.0946187451,
0.0459843092,
0.1540779173,
0.1606089324,
0.165779233,
0.8603130579,
0.4534417987,
-0.78977108,
0.3240740299,
-0.1107056141,
-0.5128632784,
0.4489939511,
-0.4424643815,
-0.2164725661,
-0.0650014281,
0.3185680211,
-0.6140130758,
-0.386924684,
0.0455380976,
-0.0707301423,
0.350518465,
0.1719329655,
-0.7831044793,
-0.3361451924,
-0.2183049321,
0.2111807019,
0.0665177554,
-0.6145122647,
0.8075251579,
0.3568071127,
-0.3452116251,
-0.4024754763,
-0.7189204693,
0.0680040643,
-0.1497419924,
-0.5882486701,
0.2441617399,
-0.6821411252,
-0.3737680912,
-0.2551500201,
-0.439397186,
0.1560531259,
0.5766544938,
0.2403037697,
0.1546190828,
-0.1639878154,
0.4079338014,
-0.206843853,
-0.2446213365,
0.144418478,
-0.0285557006,
0.6763369441,
-0.1927995384,
-0.5377095342,
-0.1041239575,
0.068265602,
0.5036995411,
-0.0353167839,
0.1374273449,
0.3531860709,
-0.6145637631,
-0.440233171,
-0.4826118648,
-0.3532245159,
-0.540591538,
0.5186974406,
-0.6722820401,
-0.6718118191,
0.4940998852,
-0.5388213992,
0.1031746939,
0.2135808617,
0.3345970511,
-0.231394127,
0.8597068787,
0.5970810652,
0.4536192715,
0.195260793,
-0.1391390413,
0.4373042881,
-0.7837056518,
-0.5477669239,
-0.3237345815,
0.1348129064,
-0.1576926261,
-0.3320800662,
0.5015841126,
-0.3124034703,
-0.1047091931,
0.0581592433,
-0.4504735172,
0.4668267667,
0.126420036,
0.0255928654,
0.4957931638,
0.1434739083,
0.0007880692,
-0.0198088735,
-0.6213102937,
-0.586081028,
0.9424525499,
0.5363029242,
0.9906628728,
-0.2192918211,
0.2569757104,
0.4792143703,
0.0214965306,
-0.670978725,
0.7280891538,
0.180986926,
-0.6447959542,
-0.0407062545,
-0.4585745931,
-0.5945911407,
0.2211928219,
-0.1507222503,
-0.0147803482,
0.2947887182,
-0.0878532529,
-0.2509976327,
0.3754929304,
-0.6264894009,
0.6110923886,
-0.6693776846,
-0.3070577681,
-0.0412542149,
-0.4984315038,
0.2030518055,
-0.2692488432,
0.8021280766,
-0.6189383268,
-0.1125427708,
0.7486602068,
-0.2577354014,
0.8336902857,
-0.087399818,
-0.5163981318,
0.3888727725,
0.2772637308,
0.2679112852,
0.1157903373,
-0.3467758596,
-0.1009423733,
-0.0751241222,
-0.1988020986,
-0.207332164,
0.7700073123,
-0.3255914152,
-0.522495389,
-0.6185947061,
-0.5522587299,
-0.2203814983,
0.1459259838,
0.1496410966,
0.5113378167,
-0.2739630342,
-0.0568156503,
0.8181462884,
0.0407385007,
0.3222486079,
0.5271395445,
0.1830697656,
-0.0100753205,
1.7033691406,
0.4256635606,
0.1809772104,
0.0985988081,
0.2086655498,
-0.0229869559,
-0.7072326541,
-0.3296310306,
0.2705752254,
-0.7531220317,
-0.2648879588,
-0.5005273223,
-0.3099123538,
-0.318973273,
-0.3352759778,
-0.4442031384,
-0.3020953834,
-0.5564821362,
-0.2323161662,
0.047403723,
0.9335792661,
-0.1667598635,
0.037829306,
-0.7035948634,
0.3711318374,
0.0443371534,
0.4534710944,
-0.1219849512,
-0.2912654877,
-0.4943030477,
-0.0381602272,
-0.046956189,
-0.4562491477,
0.2375557274,
-0.0419047289,
0.635830462,
0.1160452515,
-0.2160625756,
0.2797826529,
-0.5205559134,
0.6304805279,
-0.0217281785,
-0.5116199851,
0.4383508563,
-0.4187911153,
-0.198489815,
0.2554043829,
0.4883781075,
-0.3197411895,
0.1481209993,
-0.6058604121,
-0.7081054449,
0.7365401387,
-0.2304330915,
-0.1949588656,
0.0839219093,
0.197241053,
0.2829360664,
0.1507245153,
-0.7981675863,
-0.0562709756,
0.0688648894,
-0.227045238,
0.0522346608,
-0.2022997737,
-0.2831450105,
0.3037613332,
0.8303445578,
-0.3620012105,
0.1559887528,
0.301528424,
-0.2136941105,
-0.0765600577,
0.2524753511,
0.5234831572,
0.6437389255,
-0.5122911334,
0.3316315114,
0.153965652,
-0.2694023848,
0.2815156281,
-0.0443900488,
0.0536355786,
-0.3074605763,
0.0407008491,
0.5321777463,
0.0121784927,
-1.0740249157,
0.3055788875,
0.0407348499,
-0.1584085524,
-0.6230317354,
-0.104958266,
0.0612258688,
0.2275432199,
0.538420558,
-0.104155682,
0.0094960844,
-0.854001224,
0.0748392865,
0.5081600547,
-0.1460140646,
-0.2416293621,
0.3844368756,
0.2047428042,
-0.0558915883,
0.3030601144,
-0.2670476139,
-0.4122342765,
0.9150652885,
0.6381562352,
0.2995938063,
0.0752575472,
0.0796033964,
0.1938903034,
0.2553704679,
-0.3884417415,
0.0515458062,
-0.1578438878,
-0.6852177978,
-0.0760864243,
-0.4534805417,
-0.8749088049,
-0.126209572,
0.011493504,
0.4945806563,
-0.7007382512,
0.2664289176,
-0.2538995147,
0.2499028742,
-0.1521710306,
0.5755758286,
0.1473294795,
0.8262891173,
-0.9549042583,
0.3835244775,
0.1935613453,
-0.2720270753,
-0.3211962283,
-0.5090421438,
0.1714116931,
-0.6681102514,
0.7027157545,
0.1428194642,
-0.1514206678,
-0.1700061113,
-0.8096154332,
-1.1495162249,
1.4060120583,
0.2714824975,
-0.1882427484,
-0.2759879231,
0.1781804413,
0.1160634831,
-0.2664343119,
0.2513197064,
0.3409326077,
0.5890501738,
-0.0050483253,
-0.4885044098,
0.1327639967,
-0.1471950114,
-0.5047089458,
0.149389565,
-0.7386348248,
0.9247719646,
-0.151627779,
-0.412261337,
0.0924323648,
0.8576392531,
0.5020990372,
0.4487433434,
0.3928731382,
0.4898920059,
0.7131367922,
-0.1772061884,
0.8774234056,
0.0850175172,
0.0836023539,
0.829867661,
-0.581165731,
0.5263139606,
0.4005366862,
-0.1644450426,
0.349165231,
0.9386414886,
-0.2028196603,
0.1441984922,
0.3325657547,
-0.3401570022,
-0.5258756876,
-0.4456602931,
-0.4514421821,
-0.0159283057,
0.881238699,
0.0628459379,
-0.167513296,
0.0913285017,
-0.0774423778,
-0.0885322541,
-0.0048880582,
0.244513765,
0.2472908795,
-0.3694389164,
0.1544655412,
0.0734261498,
0.7637967467,
-0.5738946795,
-0.176651001,
-0.1643729657,
-0.044253666,
-0.2655120492,
-0.8966091871,
0.0259301011,
-0.3072424531,
-0.2684181929,
-0.435269177,
0.9439823627,
-0.1484887004,
-0.2640752792,
0.033854723,
0.674398005,
0.2665593922,
0.1737696826,
-0.2005299926,
0.0701251402,
-0.0995616391,
-0.3146806359,
0.5532101989,
0.3982465267,
-0.0381243937,
0.97262007,
0.888923645,
0.0882654414,
-0.0013305964,
-0.1570981294,
0.7661554217,
-0.7747468352,
0.0741189867,
-0.5324052572,
0.2554122508,
-0.121553719,
0.008354675,
0.6182645559,
0.8433759212,
0.5819969177,
0.0023885705,
0.8774113655,
0.0609754547,
0.7604833245,
-0.5739527941,
0.4198459685,
-0.6097038984,
0.4598631859,
0.1315287054,
-0.8107028008,
-0.2654365301,
0.3894777596,
0.2001006752,
0.0012140656,
0.7808853984,
0.7324616313,
-0.2637502849,
-0.1290662438,
0.1641537398,
0.3585524559,
0.6030495167,
0.1270308942,
0.963348031,
-0.2943843305,
0.5706933737,
-0.2060747743,
0.0586793348,
-0.0334311016,
-1.0476108789,
-0.5481274724,
-0.630161643,
-0.0772535577,
-0.3927395642,
-0.2635572553,
0.6869376302,
0.6504621506,
-0.3633974195,
-0.4193459451,
-0.5150785446,
0.2674853206,
0.5325086117,
-0.2233538628,
0.2603798509,
-0.5015115738,
-0.7289569974,
0.9191505909,
0.3597883284,
0.3125252128,
-0.3651032746,
-0.1319131404,
-0.1467193812,
0.1724497229,
0.4442059696,
0.5727573633,
-0.2960163355,
-0.0025384913,
0.3447073996,
-0.2086933553,
0.1317885816,
0.8137248755,
-0.713488698,
0.1879664361,
0.5631032586,
0.6812120676,
0.549939692,
-0.4653604925,
0.6139685512,
-0.511893034,
0.0705306903,
0.2266775966,
0.6243215203,
0.592638433,
-0.2107783407,
0.794424355,
0.5150145888,
-0.572316885,
-1.0348848104,
0.4830850065,
-1.0950829983,
-0.4944660962,
1.1831561327,
0.2587932646,
-0.263074249,
-0.1525699049,
-0.2682332993,
0.1620659828,
-0.0192557964,
0.3410610855,
0.6601982117,
0.047910884,
0.0621266961,
-0.6634929776,
0.3691039681,
0.5871332884,
-1.0552994013,
0.2806568146,
0.2868441045,
0.344556272,
0.3695784509,
0.572809279,
-0.2436072975,
0.1062509418,
-0.0019289741,
0.0766258985,
-0.2138783783,
-0.6576935053,
0.0963093117,
0.0766416863,
0.3153354824,
0.4545998573
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05195v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05195v2
|
$λ$-ECLIPSE: Multi-Concept Personalized Text-to-Image Diffusion Models by Leveraging CLIP Latent Space
| 2024-02-07T19:07:10 | 2024-04-09T22:14:37 |
Maitreya Patel, Sangmin Jung, Chitta Baral, Yezhou Yang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Despite the recent advances in personalized text-to-image (P-T2I) generative
models, it remains challenging to perform finetuning-free multi-subject-driven
T2I in a resource-efficient manner. Predominantly, contemporary approaches,
involving the training of Hypernetworks and Multimodal Large Language Models
(MLLMs), require heavy computing resources that range from 600 to 12300 GPU
hours of training. These subject-driven T2I methods hinge on Latent Diffusion
Models (LDMs), which facilitate T2I mapping through cross-attention layers.
While LDMs offer distinct advantages, P-T2I methods' reliance on the latent
space of these diffusion models significantly escalates resource demands,
leading to inconsistent results and necessitating numerous iterations for a
single desired image. In this paper, we present $\lambda$-ECLIPSE, an
alternative prior-training strategy that works in the latent space of a
pre-trained CLIP model without relying on the diffusion UNet models.
$\lambda$-ECLIPSE leverages the image-text interleaved pre-training for fast
and effective multi-subject-driven P-T2I. Through extensive experiments, we
establish that $\lambda$-ECLIPSE surpasses existing baselines in composition
alignment while preserving concept alignment performance, even with
significantly lower resource utilization. $\lambda$-ECLIPSE performs
multi-subject driven P-T2I with just 34M parameters and is trained on a mere 74
GPU hours. Additionally, $\lambda$-ECLIPSE demonstrates the unique ability to
perform multi-concept interpolations.
|
[
-0.4908681512,
-0.5561052561,
0.7492505908,
0.4271927476,
-0.5148711801,
0.2371646911,
-0.1176271588,
-0.1599140912,
0.3699838817,
0.5077716708,
-0.4241153896,
-0.5512393117,
-0.5501565933,
-0.2069571167,
-0.3049245477,
0.8294652104,
-0.0664729252,
-0.0182316173,
0.0164630786,
-0.0693368465,
0.0775139332,
-0.1558599025,
-0.6455934644,
0.2675055563,
0.5797757506,
0.3637857735,
0.3166332841,
0.3345879912,
0.2911417782,
0.1203892753,
-0.2542435825,
0.1688033193,
-0.2271203548,
-0.0923377201,
-0.147579819,
-0.2874797881,
-0.3717207015,
0.0285314098,
0.4314947128,
0.5745876431,
0.1762564778,
0.0708307922,
0.2152712494,
0.4879578054,
-1.092492938,
-0.3491507173,
-0.3760117292,
0.2365410328,
-0.3447101414,
-0.1934059262,
-0.2724768519,
-0.2294822931,
0.4245025516,
-1.156242013,
0.372146219,
-0.1022437811,
0.6028636098,
0.3212495148,
-0.4653878212,
-0.022737572,
-0.7951460481,
0.8041414618,
-0.4351884425,
0.2616579235,
0.1111559048,
0.1545752585,
0.3427885175,
-0.740413785,
-0.5557843447,
0.2605499029,
0.3270295262,
0.6085159183,
0.3087635338,
0.0447931699,
-0.0523107424,
0.2838398218,
-0.3811860085,
0.156147778,
-0.2805301845,
0.0387723595,
0.187245205,
0.0244448707,
-0.0104738986,
-0.1423712373,
-0.5318484902,
0.0853337124,
-0.7214756012,
-0.1119503304,
0.1944163293,
-0.2255281508,
-0.1945799291,
0.6358865499,
0.2729156315,
0.2554804087,
0.2211746275,
-0.103900753,
0.0251959674,
-0.5842584968,
-0.0688159466,
-0.1597051919,
0.7937424183,
0.4264174402,
-0.1881297529,
-0.349989146,
0.1369864196,
-0.0541461408,
0.1013747454,
-1.2052459717,
-0.3341743648,
0.2973428369,
-0.3276809156,
-0.0751837343,
-0.1244011596,
-0.9164410233,
-0.3554518819,
-0.0542463586,
0.1895508468,
-0.5809478164,
-0.39039886,
-0.1181255877,
-0.3872248828,
-0.0296824295,
0.6349433064,
-0.7068172097,
0.1852730215,
0.5304214358,
1.3397722244,
-0.3399662077,
-0.2099359781,
-0.3008871675,
0.5119000673,
-0.5514680147,
0.6655244827,
-0.5320537686,
-0.6610816717,
-0.1566669792,
-0.0073974892,
0.0732279643,
-0.391135186,
0.507815361,
-0.5573210716,
0.4944942892,
-0.2021219283,
-0.8577307463,
-0.0666490197,
-0.1061599702,
-0.5410234928,
0.8610741496,
0.0871103927,
-0.9530776739,
0.425660491,
-0.8634156585,
-0.0739058107,
0.0030456726,
-0.1194934547,
-0.6296660304,
0.042188514,
0.2740483284,
0.6725330353,
-0.3269807696,
0.0524638109,
-0.7533874512,
-0.303234607,
-0.0464255884,
-0.2300908267,
0.4808524251,
0.0553266555,
-0.4157500267,
0.2411012501,
-0.7346975803,
-0.2856586874,
-0.0556347333,
-0.0199614838,
-0.8757050037,
-0.2176190764,
0.3761874735,
0.4225577116,
0.1428680271,
-0.6608888507,
0.1457574069,
-0.5594838262,
0.2369243205,
0.8073999882,
0.1287818551,
0.9207607508,
-0.0997195914,
0.5746504664,
0.4088824987,
-0.1553999931,
-0.6064847112,
-0.4749236107,
-0.5904667974,
-0.5601245165,
0.1538345218,
0.4290351272,
-0.9141696692,
0.440975368,
-0.1462413818,
-0.4751363397,
-0.4715472162,
-0.0058247996,
0.4206652939,
0.7308933139,
0.4249746501,
-0.5494935513,
-0.2003203034,
-0.8292930126,
0.264985919,
0.4551784694,
-0.231870234,
0.6060917974,
0.5160220861,
-0.1871090978,
0.9527571797,
-0.6452146173,
-0.4063137472,
0.2597294748,
0.2148533612,
-0.262713939,
0.4902190864,
0.8515325785,
-0.7336953282,
-0.5969573855,
-0.2374139875,
-0.5548562407,
0.110071443,
-0.2380413115,
-0.2946337461,
0.1323054731,
0.4456261694,
-0.3348446786,
0.4669712782,
0.7232569456,
-0.4234125018,
0.4927363992,
-0.4688994288,
0.1781982034,
-1.5220676661,
0.2214062363,
0.4660159647,
-0.1846740842,
-0.2307632715,
-0.1300293803,
0.3002756834,
-0.1188995242,
-0.701089561,
0.8234032989,
-0.5427363515,
-0.2935377657,
-0.4243639112,
0.1545274705,
0.1556286961,
0.5589129329,
0.4004633129,
1.1483917236,
0.8125931621,
-1.0450838804,
-0.0848759413,
0.175346911,
-0.313824147,
0.6689206958,
-0.6449670196,
0.2737141848,
-0.1340032071,
0.4430969656,
-0.9618384242,
0.0611359887,
0.302588582,
0.1348307431,
0.0008467604,
0.1507871151,
-0.3214461803,
-0.1987131387,
-0.7697589993,
0.753190577,
0.3285800517,
-0.6742871404,
0.6348401308,
0.2511103749,
-0.0710142255,
-0.5859103799,
-0.507519722,
0.0165365599,
-0.4691586494,
-0.6104381084,
1.0662256479,
-0.1267686635,
0.2764974236,
0.3727695048,
0.1105437428,
-0.2782874107,
0.1536408514,
0.2952083647,
0.113569051,
-0.2636473477,
0.1234790906,
0.3653807938,
-0.1515391916,
-0.446667105,
-0.7023655176,
0.3490442038,
0.4469386339,
-0.2208678424,
-0.6688395739,
0.3573337793,
0.4639951885,
-0.2845963836,
0.8850438595,
0.7698073387,
-0.2370430529,
0.0330201313,
-0.3564213812,
-0.0873806328,
-0.4039806724,
0.5870066285,
-0.4868704975,
-0.8241189718,
0.2935268283,
-0.6053467989,
0.3557806909,
0.2447445989,
0.4998806417,
-0.3538436592,
0.5497276187,
0.8416499496,
0.1595243365,
0.8753959537,
-0.604559958,
-0.2439132482,
-1.6281248331,
-0.0201212019,
-0.1364877969,
-0.1726595312,
-0.1216836646,
-0.9271460176,
0.5128290653,
0.0614902154,
-0.3349873424,
0.1479075253,
-0.551676333,
0.4338296056,
0.4798571169,
0.2251114845,
0.1135918573,
-0.1031023934,
-0.0882085711,
-0.3364619315,
-0.3849495053,
-0.515869081,
1.569886446,
0.1704691797,
0.677618742,
0.3466592431,
0.5227867961,
0.0162163507,
0.4109836817,
-0.5847941637,
0.4188989997,
-0.5340328813,
-0.3210200667,
-0.3301568925,
-0.036593996,
-0.9768543243,
0.4744482636,
-0.1455647647,
-0.4742504656,
0.1659997255,
0.19392775,
-0.5325494409,
0.3824429214,
-0.8623655438,
0.8072609305,
-0.1906986386,
-0.6160261631,
-0.380219847,
-0.3126468062,
0.5395382047,
-0.3768066168,
0.0015895513,
-0.1067424864,
-0.7262080312,
0.7726646662,
-0.4582714736,
0.7208219171,
-0.269877851,
-0.1855954826,
0.0357657894,
-0.1420470178,
0.259855479,
0.2503360212,
0.0832549259,
-0.124355346,
-0.3139133751,
-0.4291167855,
-0.6213648319,
0.639603138,
-0.8161813021,
-0.4552467465,
-0.2380150855,
0.1260739416,
-0.0687068105,
0.0179285333,
0.7447462678,
0.2052085251,
-0.4628174901,
0.0419584736,
0.7304095626,
-0.4829477668,
0.6588605642,
0.3658575714,
-0.1273361593,
-0.590026319,
0.8394734859,
-0.1470972747,
0.1621808857,
0.5175775886,
0.0160969552,
-0.4405642748,
-0.3519627452,
-0.5464324355,
0.3580498397,
-0.3094580472,
0.1372846365,
-0.8609251976,
0.1864858866,
-0.2628710568,
-0.2856971025,
-0.7593234777,
-0.4765900075,
-0.8604111671,
0.3081371486,
0.0166711528,
0.2124660611,
0.3529557884,
0.4666239917,
-0.6692704558,
0.3958176374,
0.2109010071,
0.3533629179,
0.0885064006,
-0.4728090465,
-0.2598988116,
-0.3562426865,
-0.6764786243,
-1.0266497135,
0.1957893968,
0.3601079285,
0.0599324666,
0.4291556776,
-0.217966184,
0.7009686828,
-0.6147691011,
0.7897130847,
0.5778396726,
-1.0142700672,
0.4708478451,
-0.003079314,
0.3105802834,
0.1592683941,
0.3876584172,
-0.5137742162,
-0.5261210799,
-0.5949127674,
-1.1152344942,
0.7921429873,
0.1518150419,
0.1126342937,
0.4363500178,
0.5118581653,
0.1653366387,
0.2455544919,
-0.5206933618,
-0.2758837938,
-0.4605569541,
-0.2146544158,
-0.282191962,
-0.2926842868,
0.0619940236,
-0.1472041607,
0.7053108215,
-0.2467264235,
0.2009183317,
0.3511555493,
-0.0565654635,
0.2305105478,
0.1693982184,
0.6364130378,
0.257761538,
0.0340173319,
-0.0194878168,
-0.1709884405,
-0.3998689651,
0.4366580248,
0.2697138488,
-0.2909903526,
0.0873184279,
0.0534592308,
1.0756802559,
0.2881567478,
-0.3076858222,
0.7638341784,
-0.1775179058,
-0.1789814681,
-0.4597680271,
-0.0495932214,
0.260912627,
0.1812208444,
0.2261086255,
0.2860883176,
0.2154839486,
-0.0592777133,
0.1442272812,
0.2326605171,
-0.0342833437,
-0.5586933494,
1.0957818031,
0.5417413116,
0.0515302531,
0.1169694588,
-0.2715667486,
-0.1293874532,
0.6104886532,
0.2341667414,
1.1148401499,
-0.1587151885,
0.4137011468,
0.2841289937,
-0.1113363057,
-0.0490203165,
-0.1068590134,
-0.298265934,
-0.6832311153,
-0.4958271086,
-0.2221449763,
-0.5376325846,
0.2855242789,
-0.0868907273,
0.3208020926,
-0.7375900149,
-0.1925335228,
0.3794474602,
-0.244611159,
-0.5248789191,
0.1678952724,
0.0630614758,
0.7496038675,
-0.6016044021,
0.9468714595,
0.8125343919,
-0.2954199612,
-0.6343511343,
0.4248091578,
-0.1285278499,
-0.0637284517,
0.5921316147,
0.1294908077,
-0.0439371802,
-0.0748262033,
-0.1905026585,
-0.7644897699,
1.1518769264,
0.4447685182,
-0.6751642227,
-0.2197547108,
-0.4421726465,
0.4478207827,
-0.4519215822,
0.4790505767,
0.2179125845,
0.0899402723,
0.2798198462,
-0.5617397428,
-0.2048770189,
-0.0146654584,
0.4166324437,
0.0535856113,
-0.8959410787,
0.9762521386,
-0.2253549844,
-0.2962957919,
0.276296556,
0.8231287599,
0.2806816697,
0.4089770019,
0.5348239541,
0.5787438154,
0.8121064901,
0.0971922278,
0.9675340056,
-0.4755742252,
0.3136734366,
0.9315707684,
-0.3983221948,
0.5784245729,
0.3536360562,
0.0145380097,
0.3395548761,
0.8792389631,
0.1448517442,
0.9200973511,
-0.1562338918,
-0.4710222483,
0.0740768313,
0.0389268883,
-0.2827149034,
0.0010410808,
0.3238102198,
-0.323158443,
-0.114883624,
0.4688701332,
-0.2121490687,
-0.0498209186,
-0.07767988,
0.7546949983,
0.0142734572,
-0.602468133,
0.2157325447,
0.2640901506,
1.3359839916,
-0.3511018753,
0.2436603755,
-0.1989793926,
0.2008238435,
-0.0761945248,
-0.7470400333,
0.3359878063,
0.0426036939,
-0.0587516315,
-0.1978855282,
0.3390187621,
-0.5137529373,
-0.2827349603,
0.2375857681,
0.3515678644,
0.0175857153,
-0.1539057195,
-0.7627401352,
-0.3406658769,
-0.2152609825,
-0.3552959263,
0.1418834776,
0.5592852831,
0.0420953967,
0.410777241,
0.2869584262,
0.1018189266,
-0.0113981003,
-0.0212790873,
0.7208852768,
-0.6920345426,
-0.8293355703,
-0.7556481957,
0.3196960092,
-0.0476030521,
-0.6941159964,
0.5439360738,
0.9451701641,
0.5744546652,
-0.2173702866,
0.7887441516,
0.252158314,
0.5959765315,
-0.7739914656,
0.3014800251,
-0.9745616913,
0.1951608807,
-0.6425150633,
-0.9625611305,
0.0547732301,
0.3261093199,
-0.1833399087,
-0.0259795487,
0.7837321758,
0.5077905059,
-0.2616451979,
-0.1411365122,
0.115187116,
-0.1788806021,
0.6619055867,
0.7556203008,
0.7146075368,
-0.2227146626,
0.310072124,
-0.3486477733,
-0.326203227,
-0.1538785398,
-0.6989272833,
-0.7814615965,
-0.8865499496,
-0.6709582806,
-0.1437022686,
-0.3010984361,
0.6317554712,
1.0935924053,
-0.4284203351,
0.1272904277,
-0.3596076965,
-0.0412227772,
0.0207402632,
-0.170213297,
0.7798067927,
-0.0530280024,
-1.0966485739,
0.0579660013,
0.6818000078,
0.4595464468,
-0.4408905506,
-0.1221153289,
0.1306049675,
0.0420291796,
0.5787121058,
0.1860002875,
-0.7011941671,
0.1242534593,
0.0170458406,
-0.3698458374,
0.2326117903,
0.9779151678,
-0.77140522,
0.3421730995,
0.0386417471,
0.9142566919,
0.9853639007,
-0.0143243112,
0.3293697536,
-0.9498243928,
0.7738307714,
0.2449109256,
0.26269418,
0.3268631697,
-0.3376302123,
0.4306892455,
0.4194417,
-0.2273806185,
-0.3597531617,
0.1656067967,
-0.911098659,
-0.6174111962,
0.9738169312,
-0.3085387945,
-0.1796646267,
0.0289245304,
-0.4593697786,
0.1094284058,
-0.572891295,
0.7778377533,
0.6981465816,
-0.0807374194,
-0.4772323668,
-0.1119910255,
0.603813231,
0.6744149923,
-1.0172897577,
-0.3729859591,
0.3644505143,
0.2219927013,
0.2710475624,
1.0673779249,
0.0770334229,
0.2830286324,
-0.306784451,
-0.0017029681,
0.169334501,
-0.3473459482,
-0.1877650172,
0.3463456929,
-0.1594755948,
-0.5823125243
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05188v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05188v1
|
InCoRo: In-Context Learning for Robotics Control with Feedback Loops
| 2024-02-07T19:01:11 | 2024-02-07T19:01:11 |
Jiaqiang Ye Zhu, Carla Gomez Cano, David Vazquez Bermudez, Michal Drozdzal
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
One of the challenges in robotics is to enable robotic units with the
reasoning capability that would be robust enough to execute complex tasks in
dynamic environments. Recent advances in LLMs have positioned them as go-to
tools for simple reasoning tasks, motivating the pioneering work of Liang et
al. [35] that uses an LLM to translate natural language commands into low-level
static execution plans for robotic units. Using LLMs inside robotics systems
brings their generalization to a new level, enabling zero-shot generalization
to new tasks. This paper extends this prior work to dynamic environments. We
propose InCoRo, a system that uses a classical robotic feedback loop composed
of an LLM controller, a scene understanding unit, and a robot. Our system
continuously analyzes the state of the environment and provides adapted
execution commands, enabling the robot to adjust to changing environmental
conditions and correcting for controller errors. Our system does not require
any iterative optimization to learn to accomplish a task as it leverages
in-context learning with an off-the-shelf LLM model. Through an extensive
validation process involving two standardized industrial robotic units -- SCARA
and DELTA types -- we contribute knowledge about these robots, not popular in
the community, thereby enriching it. We highlight the generalization
capabilities of our system and show that (1) in-context learning in combination
with the current state-of-the-art LLMs is an effective way to implement a
robotic controller; (2) in static environments, InCoRo surpasses the prior art
in terms of the success rate; (3) in dynamic environments, we establish new
state-of-the-art for the SCARA and DELTA units, respectively. This research
paves the way towards building reliable, efficient, intelligent autonomous
systems that adapt to dynamic environments.
|
[
-0.0548756756,
-0.742797792,
0.6842942238,
-0.0899811164,
-0.2023354024,
0.1565948129,
-0.1282341182,
-0.4686878324,
0.0192112681,
0.332164675,
-0.6784669757,
-0.5316333175,
-0.265104115,
0.1746608168,
-0.0536732711,
0.9097755551,
-0.278511405,
-0.1210868508,
0.0488709398,
-0.3530435264,
-0.4343540668,
-0.4295759201,
-0.5114786625,
-0.595089972,
0.4429183602,
0.5794821978,
0.3063509166,
0.530389607,
0.3474264741,
0.277173847,
-0.0725525692,
0.3769009709,
-0.4924825132,
0.2630508542,
-0.3196541369,
-0.4314430654,
-0.2021085471,
-0.3988341391,
0.4810158312,
0.5233251452,
-0.2433183342,
-0.0937185511,
0.0912986547,
0.410171032,
-0.7183324695,
0.0521587357,
-0.5788702965,
0.506452024,
0.3637968004,
-0.4599612653,
-0.1992038935,
-0.2867042422,
0.028093243,
-0.860081017,
-0.2727605999,
-0.2173441499,
0.7405948043,
0.5059236884,
-0.5774091482,
-0.6764170527,
-0.9888379574,
0.7198055983,
-0.4929894209,
0.2066077441,
-0.2312355489,
0.4216564,
-0.4725891054,
-0.6040512323,
-0.5073117018,
-0.4319458306,
0.0687261596,
0.4674228728,
-0.001900639,
0.1969331056,
0.2028309107,
0.0675353706,
-0.2285491079,
0.2667760253,
-0.2718152404,
0.1118347645,
0.3445641696,
0.2670942843,
0.145724833,
-0.0869701803,
-0.9322408438,
-0.1615578681,
-0.7647866607,
0.4507941306,
0.2618727088,
0.3261883259,
-0.2574441433,
0.251386106,
-0.453635931,
0.7290584445,
0.1521604657,
-0.5385504365,
0.0424015336,
-0.2128291428,
-0.5173520446,
-0.0427523851,
0.4985595345,
0.0883990228,
0.019868793,
-0.0540962815,
-0.2932709157,
-0.1738612503,
0.4255150557,
-0.219350338,
-0.0638563782,
0.0841164514,
-0.2486726046,
-0.0877604038,
0.1508974135,
-0.7170144916,
-0.32608518,
-0.567879498,
0.4941777289,
-0.3254327476,
0.1689315438,
-0.1981808692,
-0.0616447963,
0.3226297796,
0.8015835285,
-0.5913469791,
0.0483126603,
0.3537600935,
0.885917604,
-0.0655911565,
-0.2885207236,
-0.6806883216,
0.5927304029,
-0.6442191005,
0.7595009208,
-0.4194837213,
-0.3313502371,
0.213058874,
-0.0200827233,
0.0921021402,
-0.8599829674,
0.0316741355,
-0.4780031741,
-0.0207180306,
0.2424622327,
-0.2392508686,
-0.5339760184,
0.3620012105,
-0.0509389378,
0.8230028749,
0.3514923751,
0.1042684838,
0.4558850825,
-0.7127767205,
-0.5229861736,
0.040394105,
-0.1245166808,
-0.0798776224,
-0.1280095577,
-0.2163048238,
0.3286290765,
0.1469416916,
0.1916222572,
-0.5756041408,
-0.6019089222,
0.1751152277,
-0.0385953113,
0.5021609664,
0.3169521093,
-0.4521439373,
0.6104259491,
-0.5607328415,
-0.0273152534,
-0.3159927726,
-0.4861038327,
-0.041921109,
-0.0252664741,
-0.5293463469,
0.2003635466,
0.2917848825,
-0.2072277218,
0.2712097168,
-0.2426566929,
0.4383260608,
0.8463176489,
0.0215428378,
0.6250084043,
-0.1660586447,
0.8371785879,
-0.3858819604,
0.148678109,
-0.4968473613,
-0.1261081845,
-0.8662400246,
-0.358496964,
-0.1942600012,
0.7518999577,
-0.9122251868,
0.5084761977,
0.2906259596,
-0.2269366086,
0.164716363,
0.5100400448,
0.4305352569,
0.6370111108,
0.3874563873,
-0.1742071658,
-0.4491141438,
-0.5215147138,
0.193638891,
-0.0017089405,
-0.5762222409,
0.4839683175,
0.4178471565,
-0.2983204126,
0.6733167171,
-0.1214244068,
-0.5240339041,
-0.2370091081,
-0.1998120546,
0.4288907647,
0.3686183691,
0.3658205867,
-0.4647480249,
-0.2175245583,
0.3284022808,
-1.2037798166,
0.0709299818,
-0.2737469673,
-0.1914237142,
0.160047546,
0.630553782,
-0.213846311,
0.3600215614,
0.4002425373,
0.0269819964,
0.1692247689,
-0.5597749949,
-0.2099207491,
-0.4644383788,
0.0547870919,
0.0790373534,
-0.2274745107,
-0.372495383,
0.5234336853,
-0.1137006059,
0.0166456699,
-0.542644918,
0.3337527514,
-0.2082509696,
-0.1496877372,
-0.3848025799,
0.208344236,
-0.1838010252,
0.8228120208,
0.0420372561,
0.410913378,
0.3617481291,
-1.2048667669,
0.7214577198,
-0.0843403935,
-0.4483057559,
0.614515245,
-0.5801686049,
0.3209932446,
0.1121701673,
0.5994209647,
-0.7176344991,
-0.5273615718,
0.7364397645,
-0.1688067317,
0.1732786447,
0.0233566258,
-0.4881056547,
-0.1735582799,
-0.2522974908,
-0.059046004,
0.3956641257,
-0.7703940868,
0.5449047685,
0.3435094655,
0.3158724308,
-0.4242316782,
-0.5979579091,
-0.2097155154,
-0.3944474757,
-0.1417974681,
0.0429754145,
-0.1809499711,
-0.2891497016,
-0.166863054,
-0.1956072897,
-0.1844587773,
0.3711789846,
0.1112000495,
0.1957971305,
0.0502158627,
0.2938346863,
0.3561908901,
-0.0852753669,
-0.0807993114,
-0.2365861386,
0.4242613912,
-0.1021419093,
-0.1630048156,
-0.6428572536,
-0.1040084809,
0.3269414306,
0.3942254186,
0.2789719105,
0.1314770132,
-0.3241783977,
-0.6621133685,
0.1533435732,
-0.2022080272,
-0.5364845395,
0.1826500148,
-0.4118776023,
-0.8389217854,
0.3902249038,
-0.4870743155,
-0.0622157715,
0.1234021634,
0.4943329692,
-0.5699616075,
0.4139114022,
0.9230104089,
0.1896201223,
0.591527462,
-0.4311531186,
0.110367395,
-0.9015103579,
-0.5271655321,
-0.087911047,
-0.7226027846,
-0.4053730667,
-0.4530635178,
0.7937546372,
0.3257330656,
-0.7182933688,
0.3322443962,
-0.7038484216,
0.2321574539,
0.689580977,
0.3284653425,
0.3041886985,
-0.1203850582,
-0.1379298717,
0.468719393,
-0.9718937874,
-0.6662001014,
0.7361255288,
0.1306554228,
0.7883008718,
0.071059294,
0.3430715799,
0.3469462395,
0.3427200019,
-0.8551524878,
0.4235028028,
0.0322604328,
-0.3257588744,
-0.2955661714,
-0.3174125254,
-0.9603740573,
0.2420482039,
0.1275308579,
-0.7667697072,
0.2976763248,
0.3100322187,
-0.6637438536,
0.4118802249,
-0.5566747785,
0.5221703649,
-0.3898346722,
-0.2781171799,
-0.35322088,
-0.8203189373,
0.4235361218,
0.0884054676,
0.1459224969,
-0.2049925923,
-0.4067459106,
0.0697931573,
-0.2967164814,
0.9506301284,
-0.1865988225,
-0.4394851625,
0.6260910034,
0.1427366287,
0.293769598,
0.332493782,
-0.1310185045,
0.156493336,
-0.3128519058,
0.0047955918,
-0.7333780527,
0.6736910939,
-0.655174017,
-0.36013484,
-0.4806010723,
-0.6748146415,
0.108422108,
-0.066613622,
0.11102245,
0.2456815243,
0.204624936,
0.3772202432,
0.594779253,
-0.4203287661,
0.4717852175,
0.6798112392,
-0.1547807902,
-0.3153988421,
0.6118321419,
0.1574143469,
0.2424960434,
0.7754077315,
0.0317742564,
0.0601506233,
-0.1429132819,
-0.6624231339,
-0.2801494896,
-0.7806904316,
-0.5764333606,
-0.1819649935,
-0.0007143097,
0.0068754097,
-0.7831431627,
-0.1137426049,
0.0126952734,
-0.4244841039,
-0.0159724932,
0.3166584373,
1.0526447296,
-0.2986489534,
0.309342593,
-0.466870755,
0.2304165661,
0.4254499674,
0.2712894976,
-0.0466749407,
-0.5462993383,
-0.1304428428,
0.0889988169,
-0.6464374661,
-0.6265889406,
0.3221025169,
0.1448248327,
0.5795863271,
0.5971582532,
0.119420968,
0.5638362169,
-0.2183891535,
0.6635963917,
-0.0595128126,
-1.1199295521,
0.8526929617,
-0.4830982387,
0.3699668348,
0.3090195358,
0.311054498,
-0.4621156454,
-0.3698269427,
-0.3691660762,
-0.7658074498,
0.7225541472,
-0.3185503185,
0.3049826324,
0.2459445149,
0.7976414561,
0.3681306541,
0.260025382,
-0.64738518,
-0.0604246557,
0.0230085272,
0.0400891341,
0.1092007086,
0.0475820526,
-0.2977383733,
-0.2431784719,
0.3909792304,
-0.5874519944,
0.3497861326,
0.2935875654,
-0.0388736948,
-0.3864144981,
-0.0527356192,
0.7330234647,
0.8186620474,
-0.1843166947,
0.0661190003,
0.7279223204,
0.1739857346,
0.345015198,
-0.5212281942,
-0.3548265994,
-0.2324371934,
0.3783816695,
0.615917027,
0.61412251,
-0.8716028333,
0.0355019979,
0.5191384554,
0.0550836213,
-0.5219715238,
0.6448059678,
-0.2993201017,
0.412106812,
0.333927542,
0.2242909521,
0.0572943948,
-0.8500449657,
0.1989320666,
0.3153236806,
-0.5059882998,
-0.4909186661,
0.4823928177,
0.2206139565,
-0.3119865358,
0.3011304736,
-0.2718853951,
-0.3994111717,
1.0989186764,
0.4413824677,
0.5967715383,
-0.1293581128,
0.2331146598,
0.5126105547,
0.397759527,
0.150243327,
0.1756099164,
-0.4803829789,
-0.8189613223,
-0.1711341888,
-0.329223454,
-1.0526047945,
0.0532048158,
-0.396753639,
0.2632722855,
-1.1832172871,
0.3265603483,
-0.8181425333,
-0.1459914148,
-0.5065666437,
0.3347256482,
0.217565313,
0.5497499704,
-0.3032368422,
0.9528813362,
0.8665721416,
-0.240168035,
-0.567653954,
0.1187479347,
0.0703337267,
-0.6977375746,
0.7810513377,
0.1510085315,
-0.6959562898,
-0.4296966195,
-0.871142745,
-1.1050614119,
1.2567938566,
0.550393939,
-0.3876905739,
0.3821597993,
-0.5037515163,
0.785733521,
-0.5869889259,
0.1700357497,
0.2128903568,
0.4346375763,
-0.0012671622,
-0.7486882806,
-0.1675082892,
-0.0848729387,
0.0727060512,
-0.0986960977,
-1.1406898499,
0.7601944804,
-0.317961067,
-0.3187353313,
0.252453059,
0.7855458856,
0.5801352859,
0.5850060582,
0.3680576384,
0.3228305876,
0.8236173987,
0.0048831468,
1.2668315172,
-0.1664171368,
0.2499127239,
1.1840127707,
-0.4983969331,
0.7549183369,
0.1403978765,
-0.1708049029,
1.1353939772,
0.6221439838,
0.1419693828,
0.7278332114,
0.30597049,
-0.3290855885,
-0.0885113329,
-0.086433351,
-0.178886652,
0.5561079979,
0.547973156,
0.0463856161,
-0.1255881488,
0.2558642626,
-0.0693291202,
0.2721931338,
-0.3157723248,
0.7340777516,
0.0486773886,
-0.4634844363,
0.366815418,
-0.0564832278,
0.8975894451,
-0.9066445827,
-0.1408043355,
-0.3246138394,
0.5598521829,
-0.1451552361,
-0.7229466438,
0.4132952988,
-0.0211343672,
0.1294939518,
-0.3651329577,
0.6656901836,
-0.2996000648,
-0.085103184,
0.6969349384,
0.0667653307,
0.1472257227,
0.4003127217,
-0.3534216285,
0.0400361195,
-0.0704042166,
-0.1157593802,
0.3006441891,
0.5629796982,
0.1606581956,
1.1061441898,
0.3340952694,
-0.3438933194,
-0.0588764288,
-0.5032973886,
0.6995970607,
-0.6092765331,
-0.2567046583,
-0.4676320255,
0.2849365771,
0.2801305652,
-0.650588274,
0.8446276188,
0.2571371198,
1.266130805,
-0.0190513581,
0.7560645938,
0.0037183184,
0.350679934,
-0.6658989191,
0.3740182221,
-0.7785664797,
0.1520463228,
0.0755381361,
-0.7337459922,
-0.4160830975,
0.8907421827,
-0.055812072,
0.1567533612,
0.5335099101,
0.4430481791,
0.0977665633,
-0.3569976091,
0.4597982764,
0.203627497,
0.1902133524,
0.7800300121,
0.987693131,
-0.2052348852,
0.5220914483,
-0.4520466328,
-0.2620768845,
-0.2600800395,
-0.8677180409,
-0.3734073043,
-0.0984380916,
-0.2074334025,
-0.0315470733,
0.1711732745,
1.0573276281,
0.749997735,
-0.8302890062,
-0.7325638533,
-0.2760339975,
0.5583889484,
-0.4287959039,
-0.2323596776,
-0.1295567155,
-0.7782165408,
-0.8835104108,
1.1417577267,
0.6544885039,
-0.4052711427,
-0.3494592011,
-0.3529868424,
-0.149851501,
-0.0406472571,
0.6762791872,
0.6087669134,
-0.6878226995,
-0.5145132542,
-0.1278482676,
-0.0408608802,
0.28720209,
0.7208818793,
-1.2404429913,
0.5941357017,
0.397721231,
0.2305385619,
0.3093519807,
-0.2514730394,
0.693849504,
-0.6193324327,
0.3657052219,
0.0605239905,
0.3448559344,
0.2109553516,
-0.5132235885,
0.8408156633,
0.2771726251,
-0.5221379995,
-0.591011107,
0.2579956055,
-0.88393718,
-0.3741983473,
0.9184949994,
-0.3583117723,
-0.0363433398,
-0.0277769808,
-0.1058136597,
0.3358492851,
-0.5636011362,
0.9535348415,
0.3215636015,
-0.5207405686,
-0.1025571749,
-0.4448671937,
0.1436933428,
0.2358522862,
-1.0775965452,
-0.4737416804,
0.3593151271,
0.1674008667,
0.2125018239,
0.3066584468,
0.2436554134,
0.3364396393,
-0.2093976438,
0.2262968123,
0.1538119316,
-0.6656466722,
-0.6606791019,
0.4203537107,
-0.430914104,
-0.2474330515
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05111v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05111v1
|
Edu-ConvoKit: An Open-Source Library for Education Conversation Data
| 2024-02-07T18:59:31 | 2024-02-07T18:59:31 |
Rose E. Wang, Dorottya Demszky
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We introduce Edu-ConvoKit, an open-source library designed to handle
pre-processing, annotation and analysis of conversation data in education.
Resources for analyzing education conversation data are scarce, making the
research challenging to perform and therefore hard to access. We address these
challenges with Edu-ConvoKit. Edu-ConvoKit is open-source
(https://github.com/stanfordnlp/edu-convokit ), pip-installable
(https://pypi.org/project/edu-convokit/ ), with comprehensive documentation
(https://edu-convokit.readthedocs.io/en/latest/ ). Our demo video is available
at: https://youtu.be/zdcI839vAko?si=h9qlnl76ucSuXb8- . We include additional
resources, such as Colab applications of Edu-ConvoKit to three diverse
education datasets and a repository of Edu-ConvoKit related papers, that can be
found in our GitHub repository.
|
[
-0.5046949387,
-0.9859583974,
0.1148137748,
0.0418811254,
0.003644644,
0.3833838999,
-0.3373463452,
-0.3226901293,
0.1908675283,
0.3283790946,
-0.6413036585,
-0.5893783569,
-0.5248072743,
-0.4481802583,
-0.4169076383,
0.8073182702,
0.1951509267,
0.1813741624,
-0.7886698842,
0.0690224692,
-0.4698901772,
-0.5152910948,
-0.6746572852,
-0.3972838521,
0.1689293236,
1.0887809992,
0.498280406,
0.0610371232,
0.5775353909,
0.2345960736,
0.0936341584,
-0.1283576339,
-0.7442236543,
0.3938806951,
-0.122677736,
-0.1368401349,
-0.4420692027,
0.221825853,
0.6039300561,
0.8374046683,
-0.5025590062,
0.2536264956,
0.5026273131,
0.8672875166,
-0.7812097073,
0.3012338281,
-0.4101783335,
-0.1866697818,
-0.3311733305,
-0.0692339838,
-0.4955274761,
-0.5555105209,
0.4726437628,
-0.8269542456,
0.1233198047,
-0.3617314696,
0.5511667728,
0.2841224372,
-0.0438716076,
-0.4152248204,
-0.6439803243,
0.5525320768,
-0.1885781884,
0.5755568147,
0.5969807506,
0.6125347018,
-0.466850698,
-1.0829170942,
-0.4084329605,
0.3365403116,
-0.0050039934,
0.2969399691,
-0.2479777634,
0.3229942322,
0.1269501448,
0.3319578469,
-0.6096151471,
-0.0150702437,
-0.6759119034,
-0.0069841691,
0.2410370559,
0.0895769745,
0.2153532207,
0.1139042228,
-0.0879321471,
-0.1813390702,
-0.3848964572,
0.3660901785,
0.6047266722,
0.2198647112,
-0.2977800071,
0.5090042353,
-0.2334721684,
0.5511761904,
-0.3991494179,
0.2244102806,
0.2503373921,
-0.3003164828,
-0.2891552448,
0.3741499782,
1.0159907341,
0.2174199969,
0.0860691071,
0.3261851668,
0.4888839722,
0.1949637532,
0.1234331429,
-1.114972353,
-0.8356232643,
0.429404825,
-0.2393787354,
-0.1498000026,
-0.0592819415,
-1.1418848038,
-0.3675175607,
-0.1225512326,
0.0897580683,
-0.3932597637,
-0.4230694771,
0.0234897416,
-0.1070061326,
0.0151034817,
0.453835845,
-0.6733807325,
0.301178962,
0.8705078959,
0.9200358391,
-0.1407130212,
-0.0340915918,
-0.3195389509,
-0.3495555222,
-0.0225507785,
0.6008602977,
-0.9897913337,
-0.7865327597,
0.3402554989,
-0.0612678938,
0.0388053395,
-0.5030787587,
0.7332808375,
0.0292475224,
0.5160438418,
0.1347332001,
-0.6839036942,
0.1106292978,
0.2130074948,
-0.6333891153,
1.1574523449,
-0.0038304848,
-0.664046526,
0.0729782805,
-1.1366612911,
-0.2067533582,
0.5238274932,
-0.3796492815,
-0.2882018089,
-0.4999851584,
0.289511472,
0.3298692703,
-0.4453755319,
0.9130186439,
-0.3358131647,
-0.3908829987,
0.1932069063,
-0.6516913772,
1.2802906036,
0.3475615978,
0.111753799,
0.0645805448,
-0.8932572603,
-0.0937680155,
-0.0993191078,
-0.2782309055,
-0.5266259313,
0.0525027066,
-0.0992821679,
-0.2702946365,
0.2709053159,
-0.7079670429,
0.4209346175,
-0.1637954265,
0.354159981,
0.6174898148,
-0.4012553394,
0.565941453,
0.1177139431,
0.4685342908,
0.0202594046,
0.5813169479,
-0.450820148,
-0.726020813,
-0.4748559892,
-0.1772085875,
0.0500989147,
0.3529836833,
-1.002656579,
0.1045724452,
-0.2716832757,
-0.8058540821,
-1.0265916586,
-0.2308935523,
-0.0168148335,
0.7022503614,
0.3274505436,
-0.2064810246,
-0.680129528,
-0.5535593033,
0.18733266,
-0.5850416422,
-0.0384762846,
0.3517944515,
0.3360573351,
-0.1187919527,
1.2722129822,
-0.6265001893,
-0.2670424879,
0.04947998,
0.1567106694,
0.1603705734,
0.6736568213,
0.5181265473,
-0.7560023665,
-0.4482162595,
-0.2645423114,
-0.6406499743,
-0.2137200385,
0.173675105,
-0.2713019848,
-0.1532065272,
0.3407391012,
-0.4225905836,
0.4526033103,
0.7728486061,
-0.3855846524,
0.3885131478,
0.220151335,
0.1995437145,
-1.1338824034,
0.0712916702,
-0.2037159055,
0.0139421131,
-0.5616006255,
-0.3477590382,
-0.0196689107,
-0.4615626931,
-0.718958199,
0.4135623276,
-0.0330672674,
0.314153105,
0.1559655815,
0.342030108,
-0.0084505575,
0.2767644823,
-0.0500898771,
1.018930316,
0.8641942143,
-0.3812731504,
0.7718643546,
0.7092475891,
-0.5369489789,
0.8418362737,
-0.5948124528,
0.1208142266,
0.2913702726,
0.4010514021,
-0.7246999741,
-0.4000840485,
0.8298014998,
-0.5852732062,
0.0896595865,
-0.4421058595,
-0.1945385784,
-0.4159710705,
-0.5541293025,
0.3517261744,
0.1957339793,
-0.9422180653,
0.3339964449,
0.835906744,
-0.2625856102,
-0.875751555,
-0.2434851378,
0.0885658115,
0.3149128258,
-0.4782580435,
-0.0291856173,
-0.5696955919,
-0.1194009632,
0.4260213971,
0.1552253366,
-0.4622653127,
0.1111208871,
0.743709147,
0.5780986547,
-0.1104493588,
0.0975093022,
0.099149622,
0.1441634446,
0.2435046434,
-0.0996574163,
0.4338332117,
0.0447578058,
-0.3551623821,
-0.3923222125,
0.4113461077,
0.594203651,
-0.0005369568,
0.5335334539,
0.1979082674,
-0.42690593,
-0.2784782052,
-0.2867834568,
-0.2569339573,
-0.5221781731,
0.1155563518,
-0.1135461703,
-0.8466714621,
0.1656282842,
-0.261824429,
0.2530822754,
-0.1257057935,
0.1928033084,
-0.4575836957,
0.4664800167,
0.6259357333,
-0.0301939864,
0.927988112,
-0.6122114658,
0.0467475019,
-0.6986883283,
-0.5678530931,
-0.7132892609,
-0.4477903545,
-0.3491987288,
0.0555486716,
-0.0653107688,
-0.1765185297,
-0.0444458574,
0.1448005438,
-0.8895043135,
0.6906051636,
0.8263357878,
-0.251608938,
0.1091289371,
-0.0967670456,
0.3614252806,
0.0602306984,
-0.7957818508,
-0.3416669965,
1.0011554956,
0.3285705149,
0.9313459396,
-0.0913996175,
0.6149493456,
0.064213872,
0.3983917236,
-1.0278333426,
0.886138916,
-0.04229635,
-0.6372339129,
-0.2469170392,
-0.3719970584,
-1.2370203733,
0.136585921,
-0.3249444664,
-0.750465095,
0.3533096313,
0.069352895,
-0.0866041183,
0.4826641977,
-0.8240053654,
1.2072894573,
0.1254807711,
-0.2104630619,
-0.0739977509,
-0.4771109521,
0.1923977137,
0.0314216763,
0.2000672668,
-0.0691042989,
0.656966269,
1.1667838097,
-0.3617667854,
0.9748879671,
-0.2313468009,
0.1282495856,
0.9184200168,
-0.2132061571,
0.2091299593,
-0.0765111819,
0.0285533573,
0.5468085408,
0.1000382006,
-0.1234814227,
-0.5405917764,
0.8592048883,
-1.071359992,
-0.474555105,
-0.5624213219,
-0.3966852725,
0.1262481958,
-0.0635741279,
0.118523784,
0.4939986765,
-0.5110604167,
0.7189924717,
0.3994092345,
-0.1564203799,
0.4224440455,
0.5087018609,
-0.2706986964,
-0.2899727225,
1.0021617413,
0.5436236262,
-0.0359454565,
-0.1396580338,
0.1010251716,
0.0256142747,
-0.3774960339,
-0.2491639256,
0.0415104143,
-0.8604263663,
-0.1551253349,
-0.6884693503,
-0.3512248099,
-0.6833488941,
-0.2127972245,
-0.5498425364,
-0.4356935024,
-0.6169875264,
-0.2710578442,
0.3259124756,
0.6309345961,
-0.0671539456,
0.6646427512,
-0.6357738972,
-0.0645500049,
0.2964665592,
0.4810145497,
-0.4900942147,
-0.2841397524,
-0.3256736994,
0.1050173789,
-0.6816526651,
-0.7464741468,
0.1462639123,
0.365588069,
0.2976047695,
0.3323247433,
0.6302886009,
0.4815911651,
-0.2521647215,
1.2335933447,
0.2208196223,
-0.6294471622,
0.7872105837,
0.1745852083,
0.0243665744,
0.6105883718,
0.4568181932,
-0.4978246987,
-0.6293616295,
-0.8902111053,
-1.118240118,
0.9695144892,
0.2178797424,
0.1875809729,
0.1147278547,
-0.1467427462,
0.2831355035,
0.2251987457,
-0.0654138178,
-0.6987380981,
-0.5187190771,
-0.3664530814,
0.0196124706,
-0.4093799293,
-0.3439897299,
-0.229064256,
0.7987878323,
0.1816632748,
-0.1578060836,
0.0005909612,
0.1677647531,
-0.2162661999,
0.5744109154,
0.0645603612,
0.6338780522,
-0.5624197721,
0.0392023735,
-0.1621987075,
-1.2467849255,
-0.1212881953,
0.3074208796,
-0.140253827,
0.3826391101,
-0.01128818,
0.6767739654,
0.3675090075,
-0.6075467467,
0.6556172371,
-0.5431583524,
-0.0444710106,
-0.5684639215,
0.1292293072,
-0.0672200248,
0.2778095305,
0.3707567751,
-0.324279964,
0.1574061513,
-0.4883338809,
0.226257816,
0.1763240695,
-0.4196647108,
-0.2673579752,
0.6656334996,
0.815500617,
-0.6462868452,
0.9420905709,
0.1660934985,
-0.1616886258,
0.5275480151,
0.526919961,
0.877309978,
-0.3185590804,
0.6976651549,
0.5518566966,
0.0100129265,
-0.0140513964,
0.1615683585,
-0.1889878958,
-0.7131054401,
-0.1669047177,
-0.2565229535,
-1.1852812767,
0.3168621957,
-0.7374847531,
0.3881274462,
-0.1960835159,
-0.2092087865,
0.195531413,
-0.1224040017,
-0.7217079401,
0.1239675432,
-0.0817233101,
0.9037408233,
-0.7561594844,
1.1553372145,
0.8308101296,
-0.0210672878,
-0.7178223729,
-0.6044102907,
0.1030960977,
-0.2155775428,
0.565115571,
0.1084871739,
-0.0698445216,
0.2451914251,
-1.0044519901,
-0.2357905358,
1.0209553242,
0.5809537172,
-0.9172275066,
0.0665105432,
0.0387529097,
0.2466899306,
-0.1839435399,
0.3635753989,
0.6261364818,
0.2821160257,
0.1855567396,
-0.7427057624,
-0.6390166283,
-0.4633730948,
-0.8426147103,
0.1514968425,
-0.2034887969,
0.6108959317,
0.0436731428,
-0.4654526711,
-0.375743717,
0.7028596401,
-0.0812184513,
0.9898991585,
0.0722622797,
0.5486068726,
0.9621614814,
-0.5333184004,
0.6914486289,
-0.316067487,
0.5459772944,
1.6530952454,
0.2435343266,
0.7619152665,
0.481947273,
-0.308467865,
0.3337541521,
0.6266184449,
0.0790195763,
0.3174102604,
-0.2800856233,
-0.5460583568,
0.073925674,
-0.3321148455,
-0.4631165266,
0.2117892802,
0.6617814302,
0.2456843406,
0.011509371,
0.2078637183,
0.0338739902,
-0.0781653672,
-0.2858421206,
0.7171391845,
0.0678087324,
-0.4357973635,
0.3486952484,
-0.9130023122,
0.6361032724,
-0.53396523,
-0.4252693951,
-0.1143689603,
-0.0981022567,
-0.3069880307,
-1.4138797522,
0.1627962291,
-0.0023081731,
0.2335848957,
0.0042145103,
0.7817912102,
-0.8449701667,
0.04625028,
0.4992188513,
0.3263655305,
0.4478847682,
0.1043122858,
-0.6818655729,
0.3324601948,
-0.2739363909,
-0.2372072339,
0.1216882467,
0.3767534494,
0.2504466176,
0.7570015788,
0.8328425884,
0.0951995403,
-0.1052879691,
0.2013003081,
0.9324228168,
-0.0019659176,
-0.4348727763,
-0.65874964,
0.7211369872,
-0.1752423793,
-0.3259660304,
0.5127376914,
0.6667295694,
1.4722374678,
0.0913103297,
1.0182601213,
-0.221250847,
0.1936868429,
0.1642657816,
0.843731761,
-0.2887435257,
0.1401023716,
-0.2400681525,
-0.9450410604,
-0.1507158577,
0.4380390346,
-0.2028418779,
-0.5856438279,
0.4902747273,
0.6330308318,
-0.0920793116,
0.4415578246,
0.3458263278,
0.2089483589,
0.8166172504,
0.3406409025,
0.8674550653,
-0.4211457968,
0.9968921542,
-0.3839636445,
-0.3355464339,
-0.3855621517,
-0.5026394725,
-0.8884758353,
-0.8487570882,
-0.6499598026,
-0.3739575744,
0.1476221979,
1.1484830379,
0.514775753,
-0.8981390595,
-0.2124856263,
0.2178265005,
0.3571256101,
0.0794282407,
-0.2588305175,
0.3134383857,
-0.1700236499,
-1.1259176731,
0.5845716596,
-0.1075135469,
0.011158553,
-0.1326037645,
0.0271791648,
-0.1414066851,
0.014464247,
0.4567020833,
0.5355426073,
-0.2016292512,
-0.4282562733,
-0.3216119111,
-0.1552184224,
0.1610085368,
0.925881505,
-0.7385840416,
1.1643314362,
0.5562145114,
0.7708200812,
0.1338371933,
-0.1514753699,
0.2475655228,
-0.8548772335,
0.2930138707,
0.2439203113,
0.3054645658,
0.3844115436,
-0.2001211345,
0.8728904128,
0.2413950413,
-0.8339805007,
-1.1318089962,
0.0032106431,
-1.1401352882,
-0.1066535488,
0.7055293322,
-0.3121858239,
-0.0857605338,
-0.3421262205,
-0.664021492,
0.4455782473,
-0.8554451466,
0.5758735538,
0.6896739006,
0.2685658336,
-0.26677984,
-0.6666130424,
0.4299548864,
-0.2591086626,
-0.7944603562,
0.2132645547,
0.4792131782,
-0.0306516457,
0.3152481019,
0.7183741331,
0.0748132169,
0.0387652926,
-0.0589040071,
0.344781369,
-0.3486803472,
-0.6519708037,
-0.0935338736,
0.3591423333,
-0.4602973461,
-0.8351157904
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05106v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05106v1
|
Image captioning for Brazilian Portuguese using GRIT model
| 2024-02-07T18:57:37 | 2024-02-07T18:57:37 |
Rafael Silva de Alencar, William Alberto Cruz Castañeda, Marcellus Amadeus
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This work presents the early development of a model of image captioning for
the Brazilian Portuguese language. We used the GRIT (Grid - and Region-based
Image captioning Transformer) model to accomplish this work. GRIT is a
Transformer-only neural architecture that effectively utilizes two visual
features to generate better captions. The GRIT method emerged as a proposal to
be a more efficient way to generate image captioning. In this work, we adapt
the GRIT model to be trained in a Brazilian Portuguese dataset to have an image
captioning method for the Brazilian Portuguese Language.
|
[
-0.3721578121,
-0.6125404835,
0.3523504436,
0.4023415744,
-0.7646166086,
0.1425110102,
-0.0299287569,
-0.3553864062,
0.2769577205,
0.5961292982,
-0.2669941783,
-0.2643527091,
-0.6670493484,
-0.1499843597,
-0.3404383063,
1.3763391972,
-0.1654573083,
0.6237872243,
-0.3819675744,
-0.1017357334,
-0.5862628222,
0.1540487707,
-0.9096931219,
-0.4195503294,
0.3210811317,
0.2616898119,
0.9933469296,
0.9664757252,
0.970389843,
0.3998256326,
0.1638575643,
-0.0882154033,
-0.5381780267,
-0.2880806327,
-0.1944558769,
-0.675621748,
-0.1247836649,
-0.1036592349,
0.5552332401,
0.3315864801,
0.0947187543,
-0.0478850454,
-0.1312478632,
0.3846991658,
-0.3374153674,
0.6482082605,
-0.6302842498,
0.0676122531,
-0.0038827786,
-0.531875968,
-0.1119861528,
-0.3192963898,
-0.0038917765,
-0.4224192202,
0.7328144312,
0.0334981121,
1.4798713923,
0.1822731793,
-0.0062648426,
-0.1693714559,
-0.9024373889,
0.5937084556,
-0.0816150084,
0.1408444792,
0.0652897879,
0.959130168,
0.4429969192,
-0.9078043699,
-0.270424217,
-0.1273388267,
-0.2203986049,
0.0970405638,
-0.0275126733,
-0.010281113,
-0.124159947,
0.6582538486,
-0.3348014355,
0.0731024593,
-0.8423591852,
-0.4397765398,
0.7777146697,
0.1125003546,
-0.0312152393,
0.0417706408,
-1.0418914557,
-0.3436029255,
-0.8413245678,
-0.0398870595,
0.2071527392,
0.3323894143,
-0.2181649059,
0.264526248,
-0.0133814327,
0.6079768538,
-0.4525932968,
-0.539477706,
0.0972831398,
0.1110243499,
-0.185531944,
-0.0124788545,
0.6605322957,
0.6209850311,
0.4707022309,
-0.4604121745,
-1.0091586113,
0.0606042929,
0.5814094543,
-0.6653868556,
-0.3093042374,
-0.0064768349,
-0.2939534783,
-0.4942760766,
0.1716516465,
-1.043420434,
-0.6454432607,
-0.1776878238,
0.5244546533,
-0.3216786385,
0.2546375096,
-0.1459306628,
-0.3147007227,
0.5748335719,
0.3399996161,
-0.5259582996,
0.6429587603,
0.3718001544,
1.0058943033,
-0.1696232855,
-0.5470532775,
-0.4303668737,
-0.0116014639,
-0.222641781,
1.3306677341,
-0.2682818174,
-0.3575935662,
0.2654826641,
0.3037814796,
0.2381272316,
-0.262886852,
0.451857239,
-0.6956661344,
-0.0981733128,
-0.1908245385,
-0.015598312,
-0.4883417189,
0.1179545,
-0.796043992,
0.8425778747,
0.5178588629,
-0.477757901,
0.2593801618,
-0.7774799466,
-0.4978192747,
0.5647879839,
-0.3173267543,
-0.5268880725,
0.1097848192,
0.2698431015,
0.2669204473,
-0.5409557819,
0.4317381978,
0.0659496039,
-0.6365380883,
0.2141498923,
-0.4687719345,
0.4012148976,
0.3358309567,
-0.3418675363,
0.1516461819,
-0.2936556339,
-0.3523418009,
0.692430675,
-0.1140323356,
0.1797894388,
-0.1546399593,
0.6128744483,
0.2972812653,
0.4766477048,
-0.6277402043,
0.0518225059,
0.0248782691,
0.4799845219,
0.4714151025,
-0.0600988381,
0.654558897,
-0.5833644867,
0.7115421891,
0.1485509574,
0.2082927078,
-0.5788906217,
-0.5771811604,
-1.0505375862,
-0.1828227639,
0.5188678503,
0.767444253,
-1.1647411585,
-0.2460612655,
-0.8358912468,
-0.577239275,
-0.8535295725,
0.0362405293,
0.7944954634,
0.4686056972,
0.4384335577,
-0.5820631981,
-0.2453736961,
-1.2501661777,
0.2908282876,
0.29399544,
0.1229794323,
0.5369601846,
0.4978779852,
0.2568332255,
0.7438599467,
-0.6599806547,
-0.614392817,
-0.1504213363,
0.1570615023,
0.0678093955,
0.4590925872,
0.7451495528,
-0.9533474445,
-0.3668454885,
0.0494414568,
-0.5155374408,
0.0868205279,
-0.2832415104,
0.0115919681,
0.2641113997,
0.5534952879,
-0.19470945,
0.6003056169,
0.3098636866,
0.0238077063,
0.3579877913,
-0.3988870382,
0.23271586,
-0.7295644879,
-0.0350596048,
0.165465951,
-0.4926576018,
-0.2823036909,
0.4517925084,
0.0136736287,
-0.1940828562,
-0.7656841278,
0.5808820128,
-0.5104296207,
-0.380959034,
-0.5404964685,
-0.0881568193,
0.1737495363,
0.7581333518,
0.5078173876,
0.9584849477,
0.8498746157,
-0.2777563334,
0.3664283752,
0.0690400526,
-0.3215053082,
0.7356669307,
-0.9411413074,
0.0889109373,
-0.4644294679,
-0.131213814,
-1.218421936,
-0.1031704843,
-0.1305800676,
-0.2767551243,
0.6209264398,
-0.5818013549,
-0.19374457,
-0.7301236391,
-0.2889883816,
-0.0535505526,
0.5139858723,
-0.5425595045,
0.4606643021,
0.4410902858,
-0.3540845811,
-0.3242051005,
-0.8279180527,
0.1823181212,
-0.3333524168,
-0.5011230707,
0.6370595098,
0.3790284097,
-0.071434103,
-0.2576251626,
0.3044519722,
-0.5276309848,
-0.1418490857,
0.280669868,
0.3969068825,
-0.3303829134,
0.1074348763,
0.1716368794,
-0.1940736771,
-0.0815259367,
0.0490334593,
0.8904775977,
-0.7060976624,
0.1798069924,
-0.1369773149,
0.4288384616,
0.4508205652,
-0.4869374335,
0.5273451805,
0.7471780181,
-0.136497736,
0.0529077984,
-0.4775602818,
-0.366510421,
-0.4866805375,
0.3965381682,
-0.4172668457,
-0.5496720076,
0.8461130261,
-0.0307966303,
-0.0759929344,
0.2835713029,
0.4477518201,
-0.281747669,
0.4105792344,
0.7303805947,
0.0231446102,
0.4941206574,
-0.5317028761,
-0.0921660364,
-0.5914974213,
-0.1791353971,
-0.5997388363,
-0.4463977814,
-0.6557820439,
-0.4190529883,
0.2908187211,
-0.1465489268,
-0.2006380409,
0.3949488997,
-0.5336790681,
0.7401760221,
0.7855162621,
0.4572575092,
-0.0096061509,
0.2272169441,
0.1488036215,
0.0354052857,
-0.7692759037,
-0.7227124572,
0.8125903606,
0.4290575385,
0.7439450026,
-0.1943464726,
0.595965445,
0.4788025022,
0.3740826547,
-0.9415069818,
0.3449882269,
-0.1105972007,
-0.3317076564,
-0.1820702553,
0.1513175368,
-1.3244621754,
0.0986473635,
-0.3374357224,
-0.3409704864,
-0.0373301655,
-0.0237271562,
-0.2536000013,
0.2042252272,
-0.560166955,
0.7723945975,
-0.2224848568,
-0.2856725752,
0.2661528885,
-0.8341960907,
-0.0016942015,
0.2432132363,
0.3727268577,
0.2374207377,
-0.069156535,
0.7862837315,
-0.2165607661,
0.6016294956,
-0.3097293973,
0.097573176,
0.7395782471,
0.3121432364,
0.4476243556,
0.0807946995,
0.3607219458,
0.5011692643,
-0.312500447,
-0.588465035,
-0.4042994082,
0.5648988485,
-0.7716370821,
-0.4571211636,
-0.3254965842,
-0.8428509235,
0.1191784889,
0.3211667538,
0.3268747628,
0.4090806246,
-0.1384124756,
-0.0405353121,
0.4657274187,
0.1112241447,
1.0730905533,
0.5323697329,
-0.2601787746,
-0.6985751987,
0.9990490079,
0.0096950941,
-0.0219557341,
0.3678315282,
0.119450748,
-0.1770081222,
-0.8353972435,
-0.7157202959,
0.3183396757,
-0.7000669241,
-0.5819060206,
-0.2414044142,
-0.2150385976,
-0.3239379823,
-0.5695989728,
-0.5058557987,
-0.1486228555,
-0.0211883504,
0.103596054,
0.4629949629,
0.7445007563,
0.4679868221,
0.9749869704,
-1.0019072294,
0.0243610237,
0.4017008841,
0.5413108468,
-0.3516319394,
-0.4971325099,
-0.2736181915,
0.0782254934,
-0.55678159,
-0.9794943929,
0.7524309754,
0.1254226863,
0.4170387387,
0.4725032449,
-0.4060108364,
0.4364226758,
-0.659963727,
0.856731832,
-0.0596108958,
-0.7025849223,
0.5413967371,
-0.5971152782,
0.2284723669,
0.575407505,
0.4792267382,
-0.0993180051,
-0.1122679934,
-0.7974191308,
-0.5550996065,
0.500848949,
0.1970845163,
0.3702643216,
0.086154528,
0.2560000122,
0.2873301506,
0.2592639327,
-0.8996754289,
-0.1021399125,
-0.3778120875,
0.1160230637,
-0.11945308,
-0.0736164376,
-0.3802249134,
-0.1286145747,
0.5129913092,
-0.4758570194,
0.787768364,
0.0549212955,
-0.2927253842,
-0.0904552639,
-0.0224860739,
0.7769844532,
0.4069358706,
-0.0274604037,
0.0111287115,
0.0697141662,
-0.5469112396,
-0.1844641864,
0.1139573082,
-0.2928711474,
0.2191562355,
0.2862217128,
1.1253548861,
0.2860429883,
-0.4082918465,
0.7340114713,
0.1980281919,
-0.0662442893,
-0.1722189337,
-0.0163698271,
0.0035485649,
0.1085904837,
0.1698329598,
0.0855972916,
0.2128169388,
-0.2226873189,
0.0130800661,
0.3487125337,
-0.9070785642,
0.0520989709,
0.3991067708,
0.2310528308,
-0.5523381829,
0.6850467324,
-0.2343423963,
-0.5187979937,
0.9236301184,
0.72637254,
0.6275476217,
-0.2675611377,
0.493475467,
0.1878437996,
0.5039413571,
0.0182425361,
0.716209352,
0.0696465075,
-0.5696613789,
-0.1628946811,
-0.7484368086,
-0.3072782755,
-0.0299598649,
-0.8860512376,
0.6889545321,
-0.2653142512,
0.0331791863,
-0.0281658694,
-0.1869350076,
-0.903398931,
0.5197408199,
0.2582288384,
0.8020712137,
-1.2204927206,
0.8390558362,
1.0853928328,
-0.6103785634,
-0.3302372396,
-0.7817548513,
-0.5099979043,
-1.2068549395,
0.1408557445,
0.2922896743,
0.1644659191,
-0.0929223448,
-0.9653121829,
-0.8365218639,
1.38104105,
0.3199290931,
-0.3012623191,
0.397795409,
0.4105029106,
0.63543576,
-0.7434279919,
0.2689664364,
0.5274786353,
0.4007557929,
0.5515714288,
-0.8682120442,
-0.2933779657,
-0.2061898112,
0.3897916973,
0.343585223,
-0.7512257695,
1.0072786808,
-0.3849987388,
0.0485561378,
0.0123685785,
0.93444556,
-0.0505724922,
0.2824184895,
0.2384618819,
0.458946079,
0.4964981079,
-0.4905578494,
1.4168651104,
-0.2956256568,
0.5611348152,
1.2395040989,
0.1456568092,
0.5386559963,
0.4997424781,
-0.3069368899,
0.6689832211,
0.5557793379,
-0.4419021904,
0.5461101532,
0.0842952132,
0.0028907445,
-0.0956383646,
-0.3885316849,
-0.1132244691,
1.0040699244,
0.2416938543,
-0.8188297153,
-0.5461863279,
0.1116372347,
0.3668845892,
0.1231449693,
-0.6999406219,
0.7815858722,
-0.3048150837,
-0.7424278259,
0.4990977347,
0.1858777255,
0.538072288,
-0.3660485446,
-0.1932231933,
-0.2850815654,
-0.2687724531,
0.098013334,
-1.1589127779,
0.4241240919,
-0.1165973544,
-0.1304403543,
-0.2275557965,
0.6969747543,
-0.4452509284,
-0.6990203857,
-0.2545479536,
0.413926065,
0.626688242,
-0.1160401255,
-0.6725369692,
-0.0422993451,
-0.173892647,
0.1673336327,
0.2075474411,
-0.0004660795,
-0.4268853068,
0.5307597518,
0.2822766304,
-0.0178563204,
-0.0313427486,
0.0343488827,
0.9142093658,
-0.5396255255,
-0.627638638,
-0.5890858769,
0.4028644264,
-0.0803635046,
-0.3013424873,
0.4137979448,
0.7029080987,
0.4769822359,
-0.591596961,
0.6688099504,
-0.1067693308,
-0.2790027857,
-0.3779858649,
0.9358445406,
-0.1149285212,
-0.3160676062,
-0.0353620499,
-1.1436957121,
-0.3091918528,
0.651894331,
-0.2714623213,
0.1871339381,
0.7659661174,
1.0058921576,
0.1686367244,
0.1416009963,
0.3113140464,
0.0214578584,
0.0871268809,
0.5207138062,
0.2060701847,
-0.7052429318,
0.5030443668,
-0.7917520404,
-0.2100351751,
0.0959532484,
-1.2281494141,
-0.7614097595,
-0.603828311,
-0.402995646,
-0.6019479036,
-0.0416309871,
0.4471568167,
0.5528398752,
-0.8935879469,
-0.2870557904,
-0.067437537,
0.1318901032,
-0.2473423332,
-0.2879680991,
0.4541221559,
-0.3726195097,
-0.9262648821,
-0.0925450101,
0.2570613027,
0.3392439783,
-0.5477357507,
-0.0033605772,
-0.0463360138,
0.1271554828,
0.3196620047,
0.1408596933,
-0.352863878,
-0.1262138635,
-0.2102933079,
-0.1565459967,
0.5403926969,
0.7369466424,
-1.0017464161,
0.4795033336,
0.312105298,
0.212058574,
0.6181465983,
-0.2475801855,
0.295411557,
-0.5625290871,
0.3816226423,
0.2863376439,
0.6052685976,
0.6860188246,
-0.321480304,
0.5274044275,
0.2183762789,
-0.309325546,
-0.3731611073,
-0.1813220084,
-1.3292375803,
0.1219923571,
1.2541074753,
-0.406619221,
-0.7260965705,
0.0102261538,
-0.5500861406,
0.0997854099,
-0.4137193561,
0.9881781936,
0.5491800904,
0.3220778704,
-0.2909823954,
-0.1383537948,
0.1521974057,
-0.1998332143,
-0.8244350553,
-0.518030107,
0.3326097727,
0.1877643764,
0.4265235066,
0.1636822671,
-0.4982916117,
0.6764687896,
0.3800786436,
0.5625317097,
-0.407465905,
-0.7140309811,
-0.4903954268,
0.3446038663,
-0.2528130412,
-0.2417043
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05162v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05162v3
|
Assessing the Brittleness of Safety Alignment via Pruning and Low-Rank Modifications
| 2024-02-07T18:34:38 | 2024-07-01T07:11:17 |
Boyi Wei, Kaixuan Huang, Yangsibo Huang, Tinghao Xie, Xiangyu Qi, Mengzhou Xia, Prateek Mittal, Mengdi Wang, Peter Henderson
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) show inherent brittleness in their safety
mechanisms, as evidenced by their susceptibility to jailbreaking and even
non-malicious fine-tuning. This study explores this brittleness of safety
alignment by leveraging pruning and low-rank modifications. We develop methods
to identify critical regions that are vital for safety guardrails, and that are
disentangled from utility-relevant regions at both the neuron and rank levels.
Surprisingly, the isolated regions we find are sparse, comprising about $3\%$
at the parameter level and $2.5\%$ at the rank level. Removing these regions
compromises safety without significantly impacting utility, corroborating the
inherent brittleness of the model's safety mechanisms. Moreover, we show that
LLMs remain vulnerable to low-cost fine-tuning attacks even when modifications
to the safety-critical regions are restricted. These findings underscore the
urgent need for more robust safety strategies in LLMs.
|
[
-0.1853616536,
-0.8509534001,
0.5852280259,
-0.1057263166,
-0.3417530954,
0.2078224421,
-0.2253887802,
-0.2386340946,
-0.0330567323,
0.3015313447,
-0.477389276,
-0.3960015476,
-0.8765223622,
-0.1709962934,
-0.2855598927,
1.1151936054,
-0.1331194043,
-0.2075196803,
0.2247980684,
-0.1138501912,
-0.4127110839,
-0.6021145582,
-0.5893653631,
-0.2318535149,
0.7517302632,
0.4328288138,
1.0283170938,
0.9230820537,
0.750004828,
0.3156832755,
-0.6648837328,
-0.3409512341,
-0.5119754672,
-0.0057448228,
-0.1923315972,
-0.4844788909,
-0.9063197374,
-0.1812783182,
0.5326673388,
0.7945606112,
-0.1871955842,
-0.2258165479,
0.4339957833,
0.5949627161,
-0.6378002167,
-0.181001544,
-1.0364407301,
-0.1538185179,
-0.5366792083,
-0.1052109897,
-0.366848737,
-0.3855776787,
0.0024294648,
-0.1710303426,
0.079937622,
0.1271585524,
1.1998274326,
0.3758247197,
-0.5502231121,
0.1305881292,
-0.6556531191,
0.9065799117,
-0.6162663102,
0.1114463732,
0.4358112216,
0.1033881828,
-0.5846956968,
-0.23287341,
-0.2255090624,
-0.1632196456,
-0.0350556709,
-0.235366568,
-0.0558976494,
0.494128406,
0.2131390423,
0.1986677796,
-0.5386033654,
0.554469645,
-0.3121248782,
-0.3230818808,
0.5753424168,
0.2630542517,
0.5282325149,
-0.2807382047,
-0.3339706361,
-0.3561284542,
-1.2072899342,
0.106201984,
0.6882594824,
0.4187524617,
-0.0798721164,
0.5173252225,
0.231284216,
0.6436445117,
-0.1546659917,
-0.3616366982,
-0.0590954833,
-0.2599841058,
-0.1945049614,
0.2144433111,
0.8734594584,
0.5552043915,
0.1829590201,
-0.2294465452,
-0.2565540671,
0.0720017254,
0.252460897,
-0.3711465001,
-0.296210438,
0.3898470402,
-0.4580901265,
-0.5407602191,
-0.3384085596,
-0.5503949523,
-0.6354270577,
-0.0911594555,
0.2640766501,
-0.6227381229,
-0.2871134579,
0.1274649799,
0.0684269816,
0.2438227832,
0.1001673415,
-1.2005140781,
0.0899970084,
0.9061578512,
0.9361235499,
-0.0639801547,
-0.522280097,
-0.3780928254,
0.212180227,
-0.3925258517,
0.5767228007,
-0.2073636502,
-0.1913533807,
-0.2061060965,
0.2730585635,
-0.11602889,
-0.4590079784,
0.9199323654,
-0.3419644833,
-0.5515033007,
-0.0752984583,
0.0654743388,
0.0468034148,
0.2666939497,
-0.7094556689,
0.601010263,
-0.1251823753,
-0.7972223163,
0.5107309818,
-0.1010468453,
-0.6331729293,
-0.4547664523,
-0.0503133424,
-0.6908487678,
0.2655591965,
0.0231512897,
0.2346165925,
-0.0859549195,
0.4491713941,
-0.6715078354,
-0.2189386934,
0.3726573884,
-0.6730766296,
0.5785079002,
0.0861416757,
-0.3334006667,
0.2466622591,
-0.6581846476,
-0.0172026716,
0.0438642874,
-0.4878969789,
-0.5778829455,
0.4003659785,
0.0416728109,
0.283185035,
0.4489605129,
-0.3407680392,
0.1707428098,
-0.6984214783,
0.6542899609,
1.242657423,
0.0124500496,
0.5893333554,
-0.2944948375,
0.2117102593,
0.2531728148,
0.4809382558,
0.5221480727,
-0.0749152824,
-0.7789613008,
-0.1058848426,
0.4864982963,
0.4248354435,
-0.4191346467,
0.5719348192,
-0.4175780416,
-0.552020371,
-0.5136795044,
0.2191393375,
0.5561307073,
0.1410019696,
0.2369573265,
-0.3492518365,
-0.3023789227,
-1.0964238644,
-0.2805545926,
-0.3242222071,
0.041308403,
-0.2265441269,
0.5170145631,
-0.0387247428,
0.8239603639,
-0.2926225066,
-0.0578693859,
-0.240527764,
-0.0798423216,
0.1613257676,
0.8642998338,
0.4931341708,
-0.5652691722,
-0.1368986964,
0.0540960208,
-0.6142565608,
0.192338407,
-0.0945602357,
-0.1400781125,
0.034340106,
0.6060189605,
-0.5332117677,
0.3928042352,
0.4858156741,
-0.2341226786,
0.3703587055,
-0.1417246908,
-0.1287384331,
-0.8553695083,
-0.0093919607,
0.0212890785,
0.0379410051,
-0.7107060552,
0.0208116584,
0.138833791,
0.0228698179,
-0.4285532534,
0.0103047583,
-0.599388957,
0.02354558,
-0.1899567991,
0.1919861585,
-0.1780116558,
0.3786374032,
-0.2276646644,
0.5609484911,
0.5983073115,
-0.4849598408,
-0.3075548708,
0.1114469841,
-0.45000723,
0.2262050062,
-0.7462337613,
0.0936076045,
-0.2326536179,
-0.10516233,
-0.6574010849,
-0.4461908937,
-0.0885958001,
0.0501373447,
0.4209765196,
-0.7910374403,
-0.4711068273,
0.16971457,
-0.4283855557,
0.2270231992,
0.5591565371,
-0.2074568421,
0.2719255388,
0.7896382809,
-0.5864788294,
-0.6950013638,
-0.5491764545,
0.0954209864,
-0.6688570976,
-0.8066583872,
0.4322052598,
0.1139430404,
-0.4792300463,
-0.3191916347,
-0.4074665308,
0.043393787,
0.8196822405,
0.5060943365,
0.343416661,
-0.0133280521,
-0.122652255,
0.3093082905,
-0.2205829173,
0.0379556865,
0.2698616683,
0.4939849675,
-0.2230909914,
-0.5289269686,
-0.2562286556,
0.1923787743,
0.9276061058,
-0.1899555624,
0.8649024367,
-0.0050565409,
-0.4489849806,
-0.1521810889,
-0.1430889517,
-0.279684186,
-0.5691295862,
0.4439458251,
-0.2113742679,
-1.0691047907,
0.4516011178,
-0.3056054413,
0.3453628123,
0.1712708622,
0.2463233918,
-0.1027668342,
1.2762172222,
0.7353242636,
-0.1842670292,
0.4368405342,
0.2929339409,
0.5674292445,
-0.8704131842,
-0.0363699347,
-0.6985414028,
-0.5260578394,
-0.6169176698,
-0.044070676,
0.5880048275,
0.5816332698,
-0.2545243204,
0.6040838361,
-0.5150083899,
0.5708352327,
0.0661227033,
0.0847117454,
0.1290256381,
-0.0254528672,
-0.120083414,
-0.2878265381,
-0.535505712,
-0.8067613244,
0.7830786109,
0.7593031526,
1.0483816862,
0.534389317,
0.6368495822,
-0.162695393,
0.1238475293,
-0.7111496925,
0.6967770457,
-0.2941364944,
-0.4625496864,
-0.2989879847,
-0.3756244779,
-1.0377153158,
0.3205297887,
-0.4075101614,
-0.9626060724,
0.2670292854,
0.241218105,
-0.5390582681,
0.2622835636,
-0.9401174784,
0.9443692565,
-0.6420152783,
-0.4056052268,
-0.1768746376,
-0.6863583922,
0.5273080468,
0.0054740869,
0.2374585122,
-0.2517921925,
0.2614108026,
0.7471401691,
-0.4817266762,
0.9850369692,
0.0858946666,
-0.1591302305,
-0.149175331,
0.3502070606,
0.7248686552,
-0.1201792955,
-0.0168818925,
-0.0380394831,
-0.0567811318,
-0.2939496636,
-0.3018958271,
0.9270584583,
-0.7099013925,
-0.7536272407,
-0.6075446606,
-0.4431398213,
-0.3875255585,
0.1659148932,
0.0432258099,
0.2484468818,
-0.1075024009,
0.3295536637,
0.8285565972,
-0.1702561527,
0.6593762636,
0.4095318019,
0.3274143338,
-0.2564819455,
0.7655780911,
0.2991274297,
0.3531907797,
-0.0437022708,
-0.0860032067,
-0.1288396716,
-1.2450493574,
-0.0991611853,
0.1347122937,
-0.7224065661,
-0.0327654928,
-0.3281387985,
-0.3706370294,
-0.2233618498,
-0.3652421832,
-0.4169270396,
-0.4280141294,
-0.1230519488,
-0.4377946854,
0.330532223,
0.5105751753,
0.0008804701,
0.5273784995,
-0.9226258397,
-0.1127151921,
0.1556728631,
0.3667576313,
-0.0574007407,
-0.4543593824,
-0.1257565469,
-0.3207740486,
-0.2627491355,
-0.7515578866,
0.3053730428,
-0.0861322284,
0.4349014461,
0.3739969134,
0.2098450065,
0.8385058641,
-0.6910738945,
0.5925524831,
0.3552930951,
-0.7977259755,
0.5270127058,
-0.4179781675,
-0.1396601349,
0.8312345743,
0.186201334,
-0.1838119775,
-0.434938103,
-0.4881406724,
-1.347555995,
0.6005296707,
0.1167833209,
-0.1251999885,
-0.0044337865,
0.19938308,
-0.1717984676,
-0.065310441,
-0.9221659303,
0.0101256957,
0.2500787377,
-0.2248288393,
0.1486848891,
-0.3612528741,
-0.6626955867,
0.0648726821,
0.5210348964,
-0.0415782072,
-0.2440458238,
-0.1433800459,
-0.2106866986,
-0.1024968773,
0.8037362099,
0.6749086976,
0.4765123725,
-0.3459269702,
0.4821705222,
0.2733288109,
-0.5264174342,
0.2908926606,
-0.1785561293,
-0.1801691502,
-0.3173280358,
0.3163627386,
0.7813183665,
0.3054347038,
-0.5126677155,
0.364138633,
-0.1080379263,
-0.0200985353,
-0.1374454349,
0.3261323273,
-0.0408939011,
-0.0652360022,
0.042651277,
0.3368450999,
-0.3028172851,
-0.5013234615,
0.0778136253,
0.5870240927,
-0.5241912007,
-0.4528854787,
0.5262490511,
0.1906202137,
-0.2542239428,
0.2987852395,
0.2293328643,
-0.3715773225,
0.5884557962,
0.2372981906,
0.9043191075,
0.018392304,
-0.0559929982,
0.2900630236,
1.0608437061,
-0.314447701,
-0.1153763905,
0.4332404733,
-0.4397179186,
-0.4263760746,
-0.7964801788,
-0.2917803526,
0.2090612948,
-0.5286751986,
0.2427131236,
-0.8278685808,
-0.4708551168,
-0.1652034968,
-0.5038951635,
0.0736474767,
0.1265079975,
-0.2331424952,
0.6862257123,
-1.1527148485,
0.7621323466,
0.5063755512,
-0.2407593876,
-0.9509487152,
0.3998831511,
0.1202130988,
-0.2785542607,
0.2709908187,
-0.0635038838,
-0.1103215963,
-0.2858466208,
-0.5837123394,
-0.9368101954,
1.0615538359,
0.6371810436,
-0.8201196194,
-0.2585720122,
0.0721235722,
0.3994743526,
0.4595142901,
-0.0594467819,
0.8319066763,
0.4150187075,
-0.3972285688,
-1.1841363907,
0.3243793845,
-0.0135915056,
-0.0727058724,
0.6108214259,
-0.8551037908,
1.0035722256,
0.0994387344,
-0.4389321804,
-0.0668170005,
0.2703545392,
0.5511199236,
-0.0096249636,
0.6570909023,
0.7126877904,
0.5827005506,
-0.4179596305,
0.6570456028,
-0.2617929578,
0.2196226269,
0.8997898102,
-0.4308748245,
0.9923457503,
0.9370273948,
-0.0361680239,
0.3531284928,
0.4876401722,
0.3781301677,
0.7675995827,
0.0626692623,
-0.2841135263,
-0.4439660013,
0.0852842256,
-0.165654555,
0.2560859025,
0.4657824039,
-0.180901885,
-0.3274985552,
-0.2719826698,
0.4548200369,
-0.153437376,
-0.1968751401,
0.81517452,
0.3426228464,
-0.8873721957,
0.7546508312,
0.1895912886,
0.6190657616,
-0.7441358566,
0.1183448881,
-0.1413434893,
0.3769359291,
-0.291271925,
-0.9349355102,
0.5000565052,
0.1680268645,
0.0098917605,
-0.2755250633,
0.6817290783,
-0.0778725743,
0.06201322,
0.4221513867,
0.0360050127,
-0.162277773,
0.3184428513,
-0.6024945974,
0.3026408255,
-0.1014545634,
-0.2287229449,
1.0972446203,
0.2773571014,
-0.3394155502,
0.6773535013,
0.6753968,
0.1360592544,
-0.0015820208,
-0.1980618238,
0.9687180519,
-0.6243442297,
-0.3401342332,
-1.0736939907,
0.8914657235,
-0.0863143355,
-0.3823263645,
0.7626076341,
0.1863473207,
0.5029219985,
0.0433988087,
0.7506329417,
-0.2698517442,
0.0186762903,
-0.835381031,
1.2006260157,
-0.5273154378,
0.5641607642,
-0.3148024976,
-0.5874484777,
-0.2776566744,
0.4782682061,
-0.5101578236,
-0.3441112339,
0.7710520029,
1.1986207962,
-0.1872405857,
-0.5065978169,
0.3371551931,
0.3795264363,
0.2456471175,
0.6706826091,
0.8514596224,
-0.3775705993,
0.8123005033,
-0.2027842999,
-0.1903706491,
-0.1314130425,
-0.9791531563,
-0.8916279078,
-0.3890419602,
-0.3898119926,
-0.6137132645,
0.0954120159,
0.6084519029,
0.5716003776,
-0.7309683561,
-0.0538088493,
-0.230302304,
0.3482551277,
-0.0802247599,
-0.18197155,
0.4595379829,
0.0553543381,
-0.4677192867,
0.8096116781,
0.4852501452,
0.2324916571,
-0.0646941438,
0.1074736863,
-0.05361671,
-0.0050541912,
0.1675721258,
0.4800630212,
-0.5797327757,
-0.6835395694,
-0.1984536648,
-0.3414676785,
-0.0950955153,
0.3918392956,
0.0415368751,
-0.0221228953,
0.6007851362,
0.4317014515,
-0.0546071641,
0.0720897168,
0.5905540586,
-0.9674910903,
0.3659285605,
0.1991440207,
0.6951400042,
0.3730372787,
-0.0708026588,
0.2008788437,
-0.0301263034,
-0.8244720101,
-1.2929208279,
0.479031533,
-1.1411473751,
-0.1248543859,
1.0197213888,
-0.1064962,
-0.7016153932,
-0.3927688301,
-0.1012535468,
0.0238525756,
-0.0279118419,
0.9241080284,
0.7886890173,
0.2411625385,
-0.1340951771,
-0.3904854655,
0.7687379122,
0.7343108058,
-0.6678227186,
0.2025899589,
0.4152460992,
0.5884338021,
0.3264518976,
0.335065335,
-0.4334856272,
0.2303721905,
-0.0928340927,
-0.0927076414,
0.4437373281,
-0.396450758,
-0.6659109592,
0.3949428797,
0.7762084007,
0.0387657918
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05070v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05070v1
|
A Roadmap to Pluralistic Alignment
| 2024-02-07T18:21:17 | 2024-02-07T18:21:17 |
Taylor Sorensen, Jared Moore, Jillian Fisher, Mitchell Gordon, Niloofar Mireshghallah, Christopher Michael Rytting, Andre Ye, Liwei Jiang, Ximing Lu, Nouha Dziri, Tim Althoff, Yejin Choi
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR
|
With increased power and prevalence of AI systems, it is ever more critical
that AI systems are designed to serve all, i.e., people with diverse values and
perspectives. However, aligning models to serve pluralistic human values
remains an open research question. In this piece, we propose a roadmap to
pluralistic alignment, specifically using language models as a test bed. We
identify and formalize three possible ways to define and operationalize
pluralism in AI systems: 1) Overton pluralistic models that present a spectrum
of reasonable responses; 2) Steerably pluralistic models that can steer to
reflect certain perspectives; and 3) Distributionally pluralistic models that
are well-calibrated to a given population in distribution. We also propose and
formalize three possible classes of pluralistic benchmarks: 1) Multi-objective
benchmarks, 2) Trade-off steerable benchmarks, which incentivize models to
steer to arbitrary trade-offs, and 3) Jury-pluralistic benchmarks which
explicitly model diverse human ratings. We use this framework to argue that
current alignment techniques may be fundamentally limited for pluralistic AI;
indeed, we highlight empirical evidence, both from our own experiments and from
other work, that standard alignment procedures might reduce distributional
pluralism in models, motivating the need for further research on pluralistic
alignment.
|
[
-0.5762484074,
-0.0994144231,
0.4879135191,
0.1259028316,
-0.0439417809,
0.0278929211,
-0.0610302687,
-0.4678063393,
-0.0085216239,
0.593824923,
-0.495531559,
-0.3022236228,
-0.6918546557,
-0.1604259461,
-0.4371497333,
1.199418664,
0.0847275406,
0.0032165346,
-0.2609580755,
-0.6302905083,
-0.7052137852,
-0.4061561227,
0.1248957738,
-0.1646375954,
0.6532922387,
0.4172552824,
1.2520575523,
0.7575407624,
0.7475066185,
0.2785009444,
0.2997354269,
-0.2207520604,
-0.2946575284,
-0.0377077162,
-0.322778821,
-0.2057412714,
-0.3647004664,
0.3712299466,
0.7055314779,
0.922612071,
-0.1894515455,
0.1843522936,
-0.2845550776,
0.5141186118,
-0.8311945796,
-0.3021357954,
-0.5220537782,
-0.1207303703,
-0.1733583361,
0.5468360782,
-0.1404750496,
-0.6877821088,
0.2965476215,
-0.4474214613,
-0.174597472,
-0.0320962444,
0.7244371772,
0.4130420089,
-0.6937326789,
-0.114792034,
-0.7950946093,
1.1237283945,
-0.8584015369,
0.34166646,
-0.0041879076,
0.548007071,
0.3121248782,
-0.1859750301,
-0.6535295248,
-0.0957390293,
0.0339811482,
0.3036955893,
0.0257513635,
0.0526109859,
-0.0913960487,
0.0871185362,
-0.5029853582,
0.3272053003,
-0.5223841667,
0.2177824974,
1.0257403851,
0.2081027478,
0.4260523617,
0.2646700442,
-0.6397356987,
0.0623284467,
-0.3358894587,
-0.1297075748,
0.6202033162,
0.5875119567,
0.0386458896,
0.7601691484,
0.1306883991,
0.7122263312,
-0.0845467374,
0.0900562927,
0.1376595944,
-0.572596848,
0.083651565,
0.0312846489,
0.4937547743,
0.507176578,
0.3364978731,
-0.2402752489,
-0.3273232877,
0.4056822956,
0.8007853627,
-0.3930278718,
0.244172141,
0.2294541746,
-0.3521769345,
-0.2564066052,
0.1070565656,
-0.4685757458,
-0.5376527905,
-0.6862940788,
0.3090102673,
-0.2185853571,
-0.4063465893,
0.0997787118,
-0.411269933,
0.3325606585,
0.3709807992,
-1.244148016,
0.5243589878,
1.0996290445,
0.7557910085,
-0.3710094988,
-0.4813146293,
0.1203585342,
0.2977179885,
-0.4194495976,
0.8307793736,
-0.651153326,
-0.330486387,
0.0514050387,
-0.5734472871,
-0.1542254686,
-0.6043350697,
0.341155529,
-0.1958748847,
0.3940541446,
-0.4460348487,
-0.6760196686,
-0.2310351878,
0.5033120513,
-0.6525890827,
0.4588245153,
0.0101182768,
-0.452927053,
0.4774360657,
-0.8675051332,
-0.2981452942,
0.0629248321,
-0.4304533899,
-0.2453045547,
0.0177080985,
-0.1455385834,
0.0452830233,
-0.3274684548,
0.621111095,
-0.4905999899,
-0.2772909105,
-0.0295434259,
-0.3292315602,
0.9575419426,
0.1213266253,
-0.4598099589,
0.3930422962,
-0.2719498277,
-0.0311774258,
-0.2727802396,
-0.2218161225,
-0.1734953225,
0.266184628,
0.1492444128,
0.1748935431,
0.2837301791,
-0.2329690605,
0.6717722416,
-0.4917212129,
0.2626032829,
1.0743249655,
-0.5892063379,
0.8011828065,
-0.6264113188,
0.5792869329,
0.1041887328,
0.3525761962,
0.5252669454,
-0.6278018355,
-0.3924843073,
-0.3026227653,
0.1811083704,
0.5898902416,
0.2299063802,
0.7800760269,
-0.3749679923,
-0.4828885794,
-0.9330133796,
0.0495703407,
0.1022279635,
0.2558595538,
0.3914490342,
-0.3515999317,
-0.5498309731,
-1.1622161865,
-0.4317718744,
-0.5926659107,
0.1875230521,
0.2519676685,
0.4224906862,
-0.4807187021,
1.1621586084,
-0.1458654255,
-0.1512557119,
-0.1799270064,
0.1691983193,
-0.002047708,
0.4729361236,
0.3393485248,
-1.092510581,
-0.0798965991,
0.1296580434,
-0.6361913085,
-0.0095123099,
0.0827828273,
-0.2604212463,
-0.2419624478,
0.1394250244,
-0.5171698332,
0.2719121873,
0.5649966598,
-0.2360902727,
0.4874538779,
0.3265072405,
0.046351254,
-1.1431117058,
0.2079361379,
-0.0406551845,
0.1051874161,
-0.5924605727,
0.1481027007,
-0.1853193045,
0.0024394474,
-0.1573166847,
0.7743691206,
-0.1857901663,
-0.285594523,
-0.0945334285,
0.2596784234,
-0.0794364214,
-0.0199304894,
-0.1684907228,
0.6223048568,
0.2169902921,
-0.2396153957,
0.3625103533,
0.3400716782,
0.0016285101,
0.7706641555,
-0.6327179074,
-0.3058137,
-0.3404881656,
0.2728572786,
-0.9765277505,
0.0684493631,
0.2034982443,
-0.231438309,
-0.3272255361,
-0.0753480792,
0.0058524809,
-0.1516822577,
-0.1418172568,
0.8866689205,
0.4329880774,
-0.4276093245,
0.8099458814,
0.6442347765,
-0.1648516208,
-0.7248787284,
-0.2974308431,
0.0713469982,
-0.4766435325,
-0.8770862222,
0.6416860819,
-0.2392891943,
-0.7378213406,
-0.1452492774,
0.2197967619,
0.0443860181,
0.1512580514,
0.2970977128,
0.3656278253,
-0.3987908661,
0.275909096,
-0.2586543262,
-0.1458858848,
-0.2885369658,
-0.5387930274,
0.2358641028,
-0.4888992608,
-0.6771180034,
-0.1433233023,
0.6960033774,
0.7051736116,
-0.2867558897,
0.5700234175,
0.4505447149,
-0.4223905504,
0.2377938628,
-0.6633970737,
0.0167506505,
-0.3993743658,
0.1596135348,
-0.0031134046,
-0.624405086,
0.4305449724,
-0.0643777773,
0.6930535436,
0.4909765124,
0.6094192266,
-0.1012609527,
1.4844483137,
0.7231140733,
-0.2979068458,
0.2817744613,
0.0280518476,
0.4467732012,
-0.6496506333,
-0.1003969535,
-0.5512492657,
-0.7688865066,
-0.4037391543,
-0.1454984844,
0.1872486323,
0.06273669,
-0.4071117043,
0.1586525738,
-0.6358832121,
0.3865970671,
0.684995532,
-0.6851380467,
-0.0240665097,
-0.5223383904,
0.1375616491,
-0.065679431,
-0.4432117641,
-0.766279459,
0.950704515,
0.1988045275,
0.714523375,
0.5090708137,
0.7511678338,
0.3413502872,
0.6221237183,
-0.6290599108,
0.3781895638,
-0.2711290717,
-0.9059919715,
-0.5273205638,
-0.0094908224,
-0.8893833756,
0.4371073246,
-0.0591382533,
-0.568374455,
0.3244887888,
-0.0187412594,
-0.4156962037,
0.1623993963,
-0.7400852442,
1.2683295012,
-0.451512605,
0.1711238474,
-0.0313417353,
-0.8062877059,
0.5117480159,
0.2971227169,
0.2832964957,
-0.4970489144,
-0.128714025,
0.6236124039,
-0.2470539808,
0.9208919406,
-0.183417201,
-0.1230733618,
-0.1211822033,
-0.4355879724,
0.2587292492,
-0.172825709,
-0.1928200871,
0.2392902374,
0.068075642,
-0.6898338795,
-0.3570131958,
0.5291976929,
-1.2849539518,
-0.6268103719,
-0.3388773203,
-0.7129800916,
-0.1012818292,
0.2330974191,
0.0362252221,
-0.0450284109,
-0.5889673829,
-0.2076644897,
0.3760378957,
0.4228983521,
0.2296096236,
0.2312094718,
-0.0934815034,
-0.2622964382,
0.8764750361,
0.2667048573,
0.2795983851,
0.093491964,
0.1783155501,
-0.5625444055,
-0.5078735352,
-0.6137715578,
0.0125031639,
-0.6133165956,
0.0350396335,
-0.4547508955,
-0.1824773699,
-0.9055249095,
-0.5991631746,
-0.497033447,
-0.3956362903,
-0.3062575459,
-0.0172106866,
-0.1648218483,
0.8015059233,
0.0638550818,
0.1410693824,
-0.5021766424,
0.3088536263,
0.4601472914,
0.1891284883,
-0.2447050959,
-0.3658162951,
-0.0059379083,
0.1846250594,
-0.3197523057,
-0.7307789922,
0.0495627858,
-0.0003300606,
0.8011234403,
0.6515735984,
0.0604474247,
0.8452596068,
-0.4327484071,
0.7380030155,
0.3749532402,
-0.9468640685,
0.5078715682,
-0.2669403851,
0.2115567625,
0.8039610982,
0.4194357991,
-0.9841448665,
-0.4151636958,
-0.6042236686,
-0.8308849335,
0.2416885942,
-0.1399150044,
0.2316289544,
0.060227856,
-0.0413453653,
0.3596985638,
0.3167796731,
-0.7919555902,
0.1492869854,
-0.2978028059,
-0.7167395949,
-0.1261995584,
0.3441676199,
-0.6820537448,
-0.0227897558,
0.575722754,
-0.3226020336,
-0.1675516367,
-0.3097308874,
-0.0294588841,
-0.0017895319,
0.3185122907,
0.7495639324,
0.8995347023,
0.1053633168,
0.1601552516,
-0.3150387406,
-0.0162327699,
0.4203495979,
0.3650117815,
-0.4254308641,
-0.3416704237,
0.1980081499,
0.5397509336,
-0.0666124895,
-0.7769623399,
0.6998035908,
0.0067777517,
-0.0510892347,
-0.2874267399,
0.1668683887,
0.0913187265,
0.4741173089,
0.1324986666,
0.3635104001,
0.0912050456,
-0.4837557077,
-0.0145274587,
0.8967220187,
-0.5043192506,
-0.3267876208,
0.5628471375,
0.2858324349,
-0.5921666622,
0.7130016088,
-0.0083191944,
-0.2914705575,
0.5486721396,
0.4018119574,
0.9180227518,
-0.2418824285,
0.3218130469,
-0.0384764522,
0.404176563,
-0.2581237555,
0.0502965003,
0.1580604911,
-1.1661065817,
0.0087105557,
-0.3897378147,
-0.4343956411,
-0.4993495345,
-0.6911244988,
0.1989414096,
-0.4084286988,
-0.2097937912,
0.4317823648,
-0.1880100816,
-0.3907971084,
0.158649236,
0.3924033642,
0.4036445618,
-1.1743658781,
0.3931969702,
0.6626261473,
-0.6077380776,
-0.5111984015,
-0.0280888844,
0.2146651149,
-0.9292824864,
0.2166226208,
0.1848973483,
0.0096626198,
-0.0910543948,
-0.5605451465,
-0.9198063612,
0.9000752568,
0.3104993701,
-0.3776715398,
-0.1476642042,
0.1359796226,
0.3294113874,
-0.6706885099,
0.2026560456,
0.4692315459,
0.8737950325,
-0.1334312558,
-0.7143568397,
-0.0654332042,
-0.3903352022,
0.1183626428,
0.4190336764,
-0.6194918752,
0.8086770773,
-0.3305245638,
-0.2243357599,
0.0744312406,
0.531098187,
0.3718692064,
0.2628303766,
0.5891266465,
0.7452141643,
0.7114923,
0.0412254594,
0.5969280601,
-0.0203067958,
-0.0695682541,
0.8024837375,
-0.6420167685,
0.7200294733,
0.7132479548,
-0.2384305,
0.5799343586,
0.5686790943,
-0.2031498849,
0.3517353833,
0.1883923113,
-0.3249127865,
-0.2455371618,
-0.3564580977,
-0.5314308405,
0.3127353489,
0.1239729151,
-0.0373240113,
-0.119879514,
-0.0776610598,
-0.5261528492,
0.1559327245,
0.0183427744,
0.9413432479,
-0.2719400525,
-1.083922267,
0.4058644474,
0.1233998239,
0.6195096374,
-0.3762216568,
0.0773590803,
-0.1082697585,
0.1326191127,
-0.0424555875,
-0.6351035237,
0.2460263819,
-0.356572032,
-0.5645449162,
-0.3407473564,
0.295384407,
-0.4501112103,
-0.5964844823,
0.2254683226,
0.4347993135,
0.1170487702,
0.1661014408,
-0.8562575579,
-0.0454524942,
-0.142584756,
0.2033433765,
0.2492256314,
0.036793299,
-0.3309334219,
0.5477523804,
0.5177570581,
0.0397065952,
0.179522559,
0.4220286012,
0.5843400359,
-0.7007228732,
-0.5770226717,
-0.8272095919,
0.7937126756,
-0.0998672917,
-0.7360252142,
0.4526160061,
0.5390443802,
0.7891030312,
0.3786832988,
1.0918387175,
0.040850237,
0.1069685742,
0.0025425807,
0.2504373789,
-0.5710553527,
0.1046372801,
-0.0946083665,
-0.8180723786,
-0.3526212871,
0.4436761439,
-0.4037321806,
0.2307392061,
-0.0582484379,
0.6239336729,
-0.1001774669,
0.15861094,
0.2523165643,
-0.0664782673,
0.4327820539,
0.1377699077,
1.1675513983,
-0.2504844069,
0.4016852379,
0.1780519783,
-0.2226698548,
-0.3647149801,
-0.5099310279,
-0.3340761065,
-0.511049211,
-0.3089083731,
0.0426143594,
0.2773144245,
0.7497165203,
0.9964290261,
-0.7596008182,
-0.4863444567,
-0.2054313272,
0.3724564612,
-0.4490240812,
-0.2014761269,
-0.1905590892,
-0.2974497974,
-0.6106907129,
0.0901770964,
0.5895968676,
0.1587818861,
-0.5997848511,
-0.2079447359,
-0.4165936112,
0.3040220141,
0.0660057962,
0.3589037657,
-1.1260176897,
-0.384724021,
-0.0712519437,
-0.3669677377,
0.1943073869,
0.7354090214,
-0.303596735,
0.284840256,
0.28076756,
0.5889790058,
-0.079511255,
0.5366064906,
0.8395136595,
-0.5411165357,
-0.0622228161,
0.9121901393,
0.089538075,
0.2156609446,
-0.1304046065,
0.244613573,
0.0007351805,
-0.6701860428,
-0.7986366749,
0.6308935285,
-0.762028873,
-0.3166517913,
0.6994251609,
0.1541135162,
0.0979633778,
-0.1794189066,
-0.0628854334,
-0.011864217,
-0.1139722392,
1.0011718273,
0.7235613465,
-0.1581892371,
0.2010783553,
-0.1275610477,
0.159703359,
0.6763045192,
-0.9183418751,
0.0664680153,
0.5796126127,
-0.020687677,
0.4463594854,
0.7270466685,
-0.046011351,
0.1853000224,
-0.1139521748,
0.2263518423,
0.7938633561,
-0.3920621276,
-0.2697586119,
0.0548572727,
0.0523152612,
-0.0904295817
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05044v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05044v4
|
SALAD-Bench: A Hierarchical and Comprehensive Safety Benchmark for Large Language Models
| 2024-02-07T17:33:54 | 2024-06-07T12:05:46 |
Lijun Li, Bowen Dong, Ruohui Wang, Xuhao Hu, Wangmeng Zuo, Dahua Lin, Yu Qiao, Jing Shao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
In the rapidly evolving landscape of Large Language Models (LLMs), ensuring
robust safety measures is paramount. To meet this crucial need, we propose
\emph{SALAD-Bench}, a safety benchmark specifically designed for evaluating
LLMs, attack, and defense methods. Distinguished by its breadth, SALAD-Bench
transcends conventional benchmarks through its large scale, rich diversity,
intricate taxonomy spanning three levels, and versatile
functionalities.SALAD-Bench is crafted with a meticulous array of questions,
from standard queries to complex ones enriched with attack, defense
modifications and multiple-choice. To effectively manage the inherent
complexity, we introduce an innovative evaluators: the LLM-based MD-Judge for
QA pairs with a particular focus on attack-enhanced queries, ensuring a
seamless, and reliable evaluation. Above components extend SALAD-Bench from
standard LLM safety evaluation to both LLM attack and defense methods
evaluation, ensuring the joint-purpose utility. Our extensive experiments shed
light on the resilience of LLMs against emerging threats and the efficacy of
contemporary defense tactics. Data and evaluator are released under
https://github.com/OpenSafetyLab/SALAD-BENCH.
|
[
-0.3357425332,
-0.8563673496,
0.5245764256,
0.1699572057,
0.0441653617,
0.4879577756,
-0.1536281407,
-0.2854106724,
0.1294573396,
0.1488573998,
-0.3282540143,
-0.5792462826,
-0.513148725,
0.0357076116,
-0.7471073866,
1.0121552944,
-0.0101130707,
0.2595279217,
-0.2760137618,
-0.1858478487,
-0.3340094686,
-0.4140208066,
-0.6067898273,
0.0332634635,
0.6213464737,
0.1113228723,
0.7429651618,
0.6029223204,
0.7401216626,
0.3172043264,
-0.1508672535,
-0.0644821078,
-0.5155685544,
0.5412698984,
-0.5769037008,
-0.4467257559,
-0.6045458317,
-0.008750529,
0.6538498402,
0.7609722018,
-0.4566605985,
-0.0379489213,
0.0361070074,
0.8403458595,
-1.2044513226,
-0.2368330508,
-0.7450067997,
0.0232254136,
-0.4324543476,
0.0973663628,
-0.2134360373,
-0.603902936,
-0.1649903059,
-0.2624652982,
-0.3361616731,
-0.0785729438,
0.6630234718,
0.203451395,
-0.6852810979,
0.2784622014,
-0.4121144414,
0.6814439893,
-0.3362754583,
0.4400440156,
0.3733831346,
0.8529950976,
-0.4957320988,
-0.7714897394,
-0.4075548053,
-0.2602628171,
0.451505959,
0.199044764,
-0.1236282513,
0.1114632338,
-0.0281530172,
0.6987609267,
-0.5079709291,
0.1301115453,
0.2316830605,
0.1701866835,
0.6827357411,
0.3673775792,
0.4357346892,
-0.0402032435,
-0.5622504354,
-0.3417734504,
-0.7852963805,
-0.0260357969,
-0.1229812875,
-0.0623259842,
-0.3564691842,
0.3515496552,
-0.5212930441,
0.3505634069,
-0.1527596116,
-0.1609027535,
0.2315635085,
-0.2927047312,
-0.2181986421,
-0.3947457969,
1.093534112,
0.6439294219,
0.1242207512,
-0.3658431768,
-0.4398640692,
0.221590519,
0.5683794618,
-0.7051693201,
-0.2954443097,
0.1870704144,
-0.3182553053,
-0.6159838438,
-0.1737832576,
-1.1264044046,
-0.9613281488,
0.2001639009,
0.2857898176,
-0.2691180408,
-0.3219432235,
-0.1309583485,
-0.1577135324,
0.2922079861,
0.0058998289,
-0.7218698859,
0.7023082972,
0.9638788104,
0.6996446848,
-0.4242866337,
-0.1989020556,
-0.7762640119,
0.2555360496,
-0.7134655118,
0.7559504509,
-0.3769381642,
-0.4360457957,
0.1439635605,
-0.0759424418,
0.0248935763,
-0.6088610291,
0.8126949668,
-0.4995206892,
-0.2699042261,
-0.4777005315,
-0.3028885126,
-0.0352893323,
0.6647930741,
-0.7477335334,
0.8288400173,
0.2187953144,
-0.7937695384,
0.3461618721,
-0.3279337883,
-0.7094610333,
0.1726463586,
-0.57684201,
-0.2957017422,
0.0295931417,
0.0689010769,
0.2698410749,
-0.9359398484,
0.266628772,
-0.7206397057,
-0.0745252967,
0.4404387474,
-0.4652042687,
0.5698450804,
0.12907736,
-0.1823959053,
0.3993862569,
-0.8798179626,
0.2963011861,
0.2699194252,
-0.6716361642,
-0.2890493572,
0.1578951925,
0.0478589721,
-0.0286872722,
0.3103682995,
-0.3605549335,
-0.2412540466,
-0.3912726641,
0.4158967733,
0.8839794993,
-0.0832302868,
0.3677251935,
-0.53125453,
0.6330868006,
-0.2486512959,
0.2583762109,
0.1311566681,
-0.0024325475,
-0.4847195745,
-0.682978332,
0.6404781938,
0.6577823162,
-0.6758470535,
0.5680286884,
-0.26941818,
-0.7260884047,
-0.2414964437,
-0.0884569064,
0.6044430137,
0.164893508,
0.212469399,
-0.5477973223,
-0.4563406706,
-0.9367806911,
-0.6209884882,
0.0177178122,
0.035725791,
0.0486755222,
0.3264988661,
-0.3600575626,
0.7598850727,
-0.2107141167,
0.2304788083,
-0.1569450796,
-0.3081021309,
0.3041155934,
0.5069739819,
0.7132492661,
-0.5923842788,
-0.6105156541,
-0.0279656556,
-0.8031132817,
-0.0231305566,
0.1863042116,
-0.3217984438,
0.18842116,
0.3646405935,
-0.9129543304,
0.0999577194,
0.5527613759,
-0.2174811065,
0.6637656093,
0.2561627328,
0.2735323608,
-1.130466938,
0.1708518863,
-0.0325253606,
-0.2956267595,
-0.6509358883,
0.6919890642,
0.2832847238,
0.2112925351,
-0.1875427216,
0.3654183447,
0.0072072735,
-0.091511935,
-0.0412008315,
-0.1217789575,
-0.1017714739,
0.0059815426,
-0.5018082261,
0.6658123732,
0.7299522758,
-0.4513866305,
0.3953953683,
-0.0026955486,
-0.6126639843,
0.8602452278,
-0.6711120605,
0.0689848959,
0.2029473484,
0.3717503548,
-1.1487113237,
-0.3398462534,
0.3261027932,
-0.0295472704,
0.4164780676,
-0.0627383664,
-0.548895359,
-0.1752024442,
-0.7221644521,
0.4065297246,
0.4227782488,
-0.6900462508,
0.7554613352,
0.7509431839,
-0.2202279419,
-0.797492981,
-0.4409621358,
0.3002457321,
-0.4047698379,
-0.5523653626,
0.3332559168,
-0.3199947178,
-0.5704430938,
-0.298342824,
-0.5809980035,
-0.2640943527,
0.6320957541,
0.3224091828,
0.2034571618,
0.0255810283,
-0.1274205148,
0.0842002481,
-0.003394179,
0.4317670166,
0.19509767,
0.6563384533,
-0.071790196,
-0.2215119451,
-0.2231998593,
0.3265803456,
0.7723498344,
-0.3391961455,
0.6330801845,
0.2160611451,
-0.2173131406,
-0.2327201962,
-0.5473737121,
0.0749161318,
-0.5102783442,
0.4967845976,
-0.5748894215,
-0.4880973399,
0.2358047068,
-0.2336279452,
0.2009030282,
0.3115588427,
0.4201074839,
-0.1860997975,
0.8266457915,
0.0688702017,
-0.3607863486,
0.3217733502,
0.1091171429,
-0.0598400831,
-0.6428650022,
-0.1412029564,
-0.5650730133,
-0.1686562002,
-0.5691438317,
-0.2961727679,
0.5506389141,
0.1249166653,
-0.5949712396,
0.138574034,
-0.0590261519,
0.5211664438,
0.407022506,
-0.0383855775,
0.077760227,
-0.248905912,
-0.3109101355,
0.2246166617,
-0.3804977834,
-0.2648568451,
1.2661856413,
0.6133638024,
0.9338664412,
0.3842298388,
0.8237788677,
0.2152258903,
0.0751058012,
-0.742701292,
0.8348681331,
-0.175391376,
-0.5438765883,
-0.0842427835,
-0.6921872497,
-0.8399761915,
0.6255914569,
-0.3272406161,
-0.5601598024,
-0.1944518238,
-0.097645618,
-0.3842378557,
0.0543369465,
-0.4987217188,
0.9379333854,
-0.4849238098,
-0.5418159962,
-0.386194706,
-0.5098926425,
0.49470222,
-0.1655756086,
0.4823393226,
-0.1247932464,
-0.133223474,
0.5848852992,
-0.2978002727,
0.5564731956,
0.0811046511,
-0.256120801,
-0.1663693041,
0.5542010665,
0.5384651423,
0.0510912277,
-0.0077510187,
0.1389429867,
0.1967785507,
-0.1070153341,
-0.2703779638,
0.9987258911,
-0.5443188548,
-0.791079998,
-0.6207715869,
-0.6260018349,
-0.5251287222,
0.4502381384,
-0.2789151669,
0.0242276173,
-0.5352547169,
0.481149286,
0.6967731118,
-0.1755886078,
0.4448311925,
0.5531727672,
-0.2279933244,
-0.6988303661,
0.6289522052,
-0.0733594075,
0.2507155538,
0.4447528124,
0.1174982563,
-0.2090999037,
-0.7011085153,
-0.2491081655,
-0.2094570398,
-0.8193299174,
-0.4789625108,
-0.5112332702,
-0.2158485204,
-0.182889685,
0.0861391872,
-0.5220876932,
-0.4948522747,
0.284299463,
-0.0629447699,
0.1490021646,
0.5375944972,
-0.0858566463,
-0.032479234,
-0.5743764043,
0.652831316,
0.4290906787,
0.5697463751,
-0.1330461949,
-0.1212918833,
-0.0306272693,
-0.1802707613,
-0.5127735138,
-0.8399834633,
0.0553989112,
0.0616430454,
0.590046227,
0.4389466941,
0.2004299462,
0.1821122617,
-0.7402053475,
0.5916905403,
0.4208777845,
-0.8034566641,
0.2692270577,
-0.447857976,
0.1744303405,
0.6348228455,
0.3228779733,
-0.3144967854,
-0.1876229644,
-0.0919774398,
-0.9862688184,
0.3119080067,
-0.1345800012,
-0.2233617306,
-0.28088817,
-0.1330030859,
0.0265617855,
0.1714551598,
-0.5302469134,
-0.149677068,
0.0270381607,
-0.2815084159,
0.075885646,
-0.3681604862,
-0.645026803,
-0.150749743,
0.4951926768,
0.0223784707,
-0.2943001091,
-0.4167474508,
0.1499119401,
-0.2450685352,
0.5867299438,
0.0317800157,
0.5894088745,
-0.1249848455,
0.2100708187,
0.4169451296,
-0.347440511,
0.1226991192,
0.3640504181,
0.1094738245,
-0.3736733496,
0.2220707983,
0.1314650327,
0.4949639738,
-0.9348761439,
0.5404525399,
-0.2360468209,
-0.0386694558,
-0.2164742053,
0.3762873113,
0.1945641637,
0.2620231211,
0.2072989494,
-0.0011552721,
0.3675013185,
-0.6229987144,
0.0935397297,
0.8062130213,
-0.0472737588,
0.1602410674,
0.5066406131,
0.2707727253,
-0.01517398,
0.1707322896,
0.1348370463,
-0.3861204088,
0.4585658312,
0.2950093448,
0.8731628656,
-0.4748461246,
-0.0052831876,
0.1540876925,
0.2856076956,
-0.0491456948,
0.4975429177,
0.0020246343,
-0.424696207,
0.0672760978,
-0.7754349709,
-0.2570408881,
0.2892430723,
-0.6001698375,
-0.1120012775,
-0.853603065,
-0.2056202292,
0.0893259868,
-0.1189222634,
-0.3257057667,
0.1482278854,
0.0452750213,
1.2993942499,
-0.4641236961,
0.5737774372,
0.7072282434,
-0.2326973081,
-0.2337837666,
0.148769334,
0.2200715244,
-0.5338661671,
0.2709272802,
0.0594729111,
-0.2706975937,
-0.6162783504,
-0.3112432659,
-0.8865407109,
1.0259999037,
0.4265468121,
-1.0308754444,
0.1110135317,
0.2223709226,
0.3836777508,
0.0260965526,
0.0693134665,
0.9365925193,
0.3717828989,
-0.1189208552,
-1.1222041845,
0.3143059909,
-0.236644268,
0.2498585284,
0.3000001311,
-0.6853204966,
0.9605690837,
0.1412703246,
-0.3148504198,
0.5878132582,
0.3879445195,
0.4386997819,
0.1536996216,
0.6047742963,
0.9050884843,
0.6292818189,
-0.1720311046,
1.4572478533,
-0.3242239654,
-0.0456687175,
1.2167123556,
-0.4462726116,
1.0735542774,
0.4455049336,
-0.353351891,
0.3865619004,
0.5053227544,
0.1862086803,
0.8857157826,
0.5070510507,
-0.343637377,
-0.3021463454,
-0.0950704068,
-0.5240150094,
0.4329813123,
0.289175868,
-0.3631770909,
-0.1683868915,
-0.4122165442,
0.115580298,
0.2263344824,
-0.3206154704,
0.8357216716,
0.2352075726,
-0.5889666677,
0.7961251736,
0.0645355806,
0.4432223439,
-0.5653333664,
0.0389931239,
-0.1632736772,
0.4500892162,
-0.1023145691,
-0.9120989442,
-0.1923755556,
-0.0610984229,
-0.0623152666,
0.2352014184,
0.4321887791,
-0.2067620158,
-0.0653269663,
0.4098309278,
0.3001661897,
-0.1949497908,
0.0211660061,
-0.6539009809,
0.4689860344,
-0.5629962683,
-0.0832467973,
0.607376039,
0.2097777277,
0.075552389,
0.6840316057,
0.4317607582,
-0.2068064809,
-0.10021393,
0.1902137697,
1.1363075972,
-0.5492730141,
-0.6090980172,
-0.8953362703,
0.4291521609,
-0.2191441953,
-0.1835977286,
0.7060669065,
0.5811428428,
0.7332438231,
-0.0578003228,
0.8353821039,
-0.1610209346,
0.6118821502,
-0.4902931154,
1.1894563437,
-0.5011520386,
0.2132470161,
-0.3043808341,
-0.8266131878,
0.0004219604,
0.4168611467,
-0.1572031528,
0.2019705474,
0.759730041,
0.6745089293,
-0.0034940108,
0.0713681504,
0.2052820772,
0.3647542596,
0.3327658474,
0.6835330725,
1.1056314707,
-0.3323599994,
0.4331865907,
-0.1924783885,
-0.5332214832,
-0.0863295496,
-0.6869156957,
-1.18574965,
-0.3152738214,
-0.2252590358,
-0.4340331554,
0.5008003712,
0.9047948122,
0.6623079181,
-0.8754514456,
-0.387213558,
-0.199055016,
0.037437655,
-0.3615582883,
-0.1856182516,
0.1689569503,
-0.5111467242,
-0.477558136,
0.9832632542,
0.111974135,
-0.2717363238,
-0.152943939,
-0.0743453279,
-0.2424807549,
0.1039876416,
0.5536896586,
0.2559820712,
-0.55750525,
-0.0906383544,
-0.6092953086,
-0.2298562676,
-0.2275743335,
0.3180134594,
-0.452658534,
0.3430315554,
0.4601066113,
1.1860209703,
0.0199718755,
-0.279166162,
0.812359333,
-0.5754961967,
-0.3543531001,
0.1260549128,
0.5944849253,
0.2909692228,
-0.1538199037,
0.7710580826,
-0.0615423881,
-0.4000710547,
-1.1091011763,
0.3215999901,
-0.9349963069,
-0.3592883945,
1.1801464558,
-0.1933547258,
-0.2644011378,
0.2133751512,
0.0668374598,
0.0333694369,
-0.3683714569,
1.0797743797,
0.4615194201,
0.4842179716,
-0.1194696277,
-0.3812877238,
0.7017021775,
0.5670735836,
-1.2297101021,
0.1629480273,
0.4622935057,
0.4435859025,
0.0298961848,
0.2343505025,
-0.3016792834,
0.6952385306,
-0.0397430547,
-0.2834853232,
0.297418505,
-0.6356455684,
-0.2828760743,
0.4047191143,
0.1317386627,
-0.4026443064
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05034v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05034v1
|
How BERT Speaks Shakespearean English? Evaluating Historical Bias in Contextual Language Models
| 2024-02-07T17:07:53 | 2024-02-07T17:07:53 |
Miriam Cuscito, Alfio Ferrara, Martin Ruskov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, I.2.7; J.5
|
In this paper, we explore the idea of analysing the historical bias of
contextual language models based on BERT by measuring their adequacy with
respect to Early Modern (EME) and Modern (ME) English. In our preliminary
experiments, we perform fill-in-the-blank tests with 60 masked sentences (20
EME-specific, 20 ME-specific and 20 generic) and three different models (i.e.,
BERT Base, MacBERTh, English HLM). We then rate the model predictions according
to a 5-point bipolar scale between the two language varieties and derive a
weighted score to measure the adequacy of each model to EME and ME varieties of
English.
|
[
-0.6115959883,
-0.9375206232,
0.4152763784,
0.1973386854,
0.0945634469,
-0.4104370773,
-0.3783276379,
-0.4977217615,
0.4575234652,
0.3289688528,
-0.4246342778,
-0.1868060082,
-0.3037760556,
0.0109549742,
-0.2011460811,
0.706781745,
-0.0061592581,
0.6713021994,
0.0463042744,
-0.1736900061,
-0.6018746495,
-0.4871059358,
-0.445476979,
-0.3786484599,
0.4467731416,
0.1140990257,
0.8210524321,
0.2522011101,
-0.0328337662,
0.2670482397,
-0.3535508811,
-0.3024543226,
-0.3599909246,
0.470879674,
-0.2327255458,
-0.4783338308,
-0.1659185737,
0.0907450467,
0.3624627292,
0.8742597103,
0.1353922188,
0.0587133393,
0.0743299499,
0.438146472,
-0.5567446947,
-0.1176422238,
-0.7639118433,
0.031672284,
-0.0793265104,
-0.0401976742,
-0.6781207919,
-0.2665227056,
0.4783416092,
-0.2504629493,
0.1516512632,
0.0213163029,
0.7990355492,
-0.3547708094,
-0.6591786742,
-0.2135034353,
-0.5835340023,
1.1657576561,
-1.0931369066,
0.3574118912,
0.4058105946,
0.2947615981,
-0.0675829425,
-0.4979341328,
-0.5541409254,
-0.6537154317,
-0.1220552027,
0.1591427326,
-0.1627835035,
-0.0978857353,
0.0605219379,
0.1735724658,
-0.5308473706,
0.0510944054,
-0.3455725014,
-0.1550673693,
0.4924250543,
-0.2523437142,
0.2062336504,
-0.3343494833,
-0.4552588463,
-0.0581338815,
-0.4752906859,
0.3025056422,
0.5659127831,
0.2706452012,
0.1748337448,
0.3967894614,
0.1589758694,
0.9141677022,
0.2512788475,
-0.0264121089,
-0.0366226397,
-0.042585101,
-0.1860868335,
-0.0570468083,
0.3632596433,
0.2932297885,
0.6275328398,
-0.1396941841,
0.0128482645,
-0.3120609522,
0.2054644674,
-0.3998930156,
0.0480948947,
0.0472820476,
-0.5428281426,
-0.0670004413,
-0.0457140841,
-0.3764727414,
-0.1420577765,
-0.1465746015,
0.7209544778,
-0.545181036,
-0.0017672463,
-0.2326270789,
-0.2486752421,
0.2579360902,
0.3054590821,
-0.9815887213,
0.1625621319,
0.4908429384,
0.3806114197,
0.030641906,
-0.3532001376,
0.0326193161,
0.144343853,
-0.3810503185,
0.5740663409,
-0.5565776229,
-0.172258094,
0.2754407525,
0.1148676053,
-0.0114065232,
-0.2074136287,
0.6542406082,
-0.3091831207,
0.6744137406,
-0.3178378642,
-0.6295646429,
-0.4765554667,
0.2624381483,
-0.6360798478,
0.7699030638,
0.0011890403,
-0.6980157495,
0.5659015179,
-0.2710874677,
-0.4922284484,
-0.1843684912,
-0.346796602,
0.0096770721,
0.237044543,
0.2886768579,
0.4105185866,
0.0403708667,
0.5418329835,
-0.2306193709,
-0.3047252595,
0.2499278784,
-0.569845736,
1.1629196405,
0.1325436085,
-0.6567143202,
-0.3967484534,
-0.5288117528,
-0.0315058827,
-0.2078031301,
-0.2865403891,
-0.7199218869,
0.2456505895,
0.1827715784,
0.1599448472,
0.2521528602,
-0.7565764785,
0.0241530873,
-0.5227196813,
0.2796048224,
0.6809414029,
-0.1800843626,
0.1689768732,
-0.6310428381,
0.1958065927,
-0.1100314409,
0.1134521738,
-0.2802233994,
-0.7298362851,
-0.7248697877,
-0.103063643,
0.4263971746,
0.2962642312,
-0.2356883287,
0.5903571844,
-0.1184373051,
-0.3625132442,
-0.4942146242,
-0.216464743,
0.1016559228,
0.4815682173,
0.2065793425,
-0.3821558952,
-0.455095917,
-1.3718707561,
-0.4082912207,
-0.2867803872,
-0.3495090604,
0.6688554287,
0.4267750382,
-0.0148314526,
1.1555165052,
0.0767122954,
0.0530227348,
-0.0334833078,
0.2700724304,
0.2099829763,
0.5542621017,
0.9938423634,
-0.4187649786,
-0.5693042278,
-0.0468012094,
-0.2482642382,
-0.3307015896,
0.0370638557,
0.0710708722,
0.398347497,
0.2471684664,
-0.0633946508,
0.3285396099,
0.8620188236,
-0.5381812453,
0.3543861806,
-0.0732554793,
0.4401504397,
-1.1474155188,
0.0093694841,
-0.1824303716,
-0.211745441,
-0.6871932149,
-0.3561981618,
-0.0256712772,
-0.0568703152,
-0.531278491,
0.6224004626,
-0.5709181428,
-0.0011159979,
0.0885589793,
0.3849846721,
0.1381398439,
0.425278604,
-0.0342063308,
0.284124136,
0.3703681827,
-0.4440812171,
0.0821481943,
0.0360129438,
-0.2684194148,
0.4920044839,
-0.5027597547,
0.0005167657,
-0.2064334452,
0.2093591541,
-1.4221910238,
0.0276656393,
-0.4646676183,
-0.5828111172,
0.358484745,
0.0259133615,
-0.0200264268,
-0.1299322695,
-0.3642300367,
0.3258969486,
0.4633123577,
-0.4389086664,
0.631113708,
0.249644652,
-0.366540432,
-0.7938508391,
-0.9770296216,
0.0325928219,
0.0750675425,
-1.0061314106,
0.2561003566,
0.0314590111,
-0.723338306,
-0.0853342637,
-0.1037024185,
-0.3565228879,
0.0249360558,
-0.0716127902,
0.003224005,
-0.3882793486,
0.0241297912,
0.3206550181,
0.4492572248,
-0.1503789872,
-0.0795244277,
0.5030512214,
0.2449008077,
-0.3558731079,
-0.094900474,
0.4243136942,
0.6864982247,
0.3532535732,
0.763186276,
0.3092336357,
-0.3587768674,
-0.0329762921,
-0.9713482261,
-0.454189688,
-0.3496497273,
0.2744342387,
-0.2370626926,
-0.9344860911,
0.8557260036,
0.444404453,
0.321976155,
0.7996141911,
0.7470881939,
-0.1214511618,
0.9986516237,
0.3026961982,
-0.1068659499,
0.6567232609,
0.1643404812,
0.0616368502,
-0.5796908736,
0.0688956529,
-0.5148296952,
-0.6179273725,
-0.8453193903,
0.0270157922,
0.4800798297,
-0.0617200248,
-0.2967254519,
0.3416542709,
0.0439325757,
0.3316694498,
0.6751489639,
0.113659136,
0.0533860549,
-0.1730266511,
-0.4573336542,
-0.2931590974,
-0.4843299687,
-0.8319818974,
1.1790440083,
0.5173469186,
0.5482206345,
0.396304369,
0.3711121082,
0.4523803294,
0.3106262684,
-0.5885131359,
0.3309099078,
-0.1657296121,
-1.3414071798,
-0.4014777541,
0.0639605671,
-1.0215909481,
0.4890111387,
-0.1611605585,
-0.7064930201,
0.4871659577,
0.1921557784,
-0.163846001,
0.1314892471,
-0.7921080589,
0.7549301386,
-0.2601561546,
-0.4400310516,
-0.3242172301,
-0.7025721669,
0.5181669593,
0.1755775064,
0.3841524124,
0.0380662791,
0.0749833137,
0.8068985939,
-0.2833453119,
0.8907034397,
-0.1037658602,
-0.1436003447,
0.1330447346,
0.2044971883,
0.2968723178,
-0.0882591084,
-0.2380020916,
0.1431978345,
0.2251351923,
-0.7926928997,
-0.3335854113,
0.6865392327,
-0.6562045217,
-0.4820889533,
-0.4918809235,
-0.5061703324,
-0.3370028734,
0.0850293338,
0.1413531452,
0.6199499965,
-0.7361260056,
0.3514085114,
0.3078126609,
-0.3491021991,
0.7530789971,
0.9188972116,
-0.1394249201,
-0.2323760539,
0.0380725227,
0.2144916952,
0.4663418829,
0.3522615433,
0.2963563502,
-0.0646109283,
-0.2227181345,
-0.2459713966,
0.0193317067,
-0.5359498262,
0.2358993292,
-0.3394384086,
0.0010591168,
-0.6010261178,
-0.4076762795,
-0.1379884928,
-0.4803970456,
0.0308678579,
0.0774687007,
0.0269056354,
0.9194098115,
-0.102104187,
0.3561760187,
-0.3896068633,
-0.2619062066,
0.5616849661,
0.0023635849,
0.0632772446,
-0.647177875,
-0.2270698845,
0.288480252,
-0.4989901185,
-1.2521665096,
0.3616163433,
0.1211740449,
0.8110083938,
0.5010126233,
-0.2522725463,
0.2835822999,
-0.7617992759,
1.3247667551,
0.0139062712,
-1.1044954062,
0.4792154729,
-0.3299619555,
0.0628311634,
0.3178570271,
0.2786750495,
-0.6001634598,
-0.7411907911,
-0.792576313,
-0.8439196944,
0.5020381808,
0.1350394338,
0.2625646889,
-0.1885000169,
0.1731721312,
0.4050090909,
0.1396684498,
-1.0425788164,
-0.4795193672,
-0.0582769737,
-0.1240613982,
-0.1609626263,
-0.5844604969,
-0.0773268119,
-0.2864260077,
0.6048688889,
0.2549250126,
0.1629425883,
0.3387304544,
-0.4477902353,
-0.1026623473,
0.7041991353,
0.9088201523,
1.1247650385,
-0.6147282124,
0.2759645283,
0.3748448491,
-0.6538884044,
-0.0962786525,
-0.0121723115,
-0.3315657675,
0.579400003,
0.7276176214,
0.7405782342,
0.3626083136,
-0.5448058844,
0.6170293093,
0.1652325839,
-0.0919190124,
-0.3620061874,
-0.3759048581,
-0.1939628273,
0.2262877971,
0.5982193351,
-0.0430637375,
0.0464322567,
-0.8454582095,
0.2725009918,
0.5704951286,
-0.5312474966,
-0.3113542497,
0.4945696592,
0.3683665097,
-0.0637150034,
0.0104174456,
0.2069224268,
-0.7184947133,
0.4575329721,
0.6218698025,
0.9336060286,
-0.5156748891,
-0.0429821648,
0.3641335666,
0.6725596189,
0.2920989394,
0.2733757794,
0.0225539301,
-0.7552872896,
-0.5447704792,
-0.5082066059,
-0.5094355345,
0.2735037804,
-0.7377126217,
0.0805513933,
0.1181214675,
-0.2789342403,
0.1035124213,
-0.0350526758,
-0.4850760996,
0.2661960423,
0.1709069163,
0.8963564038,
-1.1497703791,
0.7305056453,
0.6195522547,
-0.2252032459,
-0.4695064723,
0.1405335069,
-0.0988858938,
-0.9115508199,
0.9522354007,
-0.1344485432,
0.0857967734,
-0.0940950736,
-0.4800648689,
-0.7876214385,
0.8416261077,
0.2848816514,
-0.5818465352,
0.211626187,
-0.4831178486,
0.5637039542,
-0.4606127143,
0.7302193642,
0.5194840431,
0.6839394569,
-0.3029444516,
-1.2253614664,
-0.3833992481,
0.0575637333,
0.0441161506,
-0.038334664,
-0.2798549831,
1.1627215147,
0.1197440475,
-0.0593964644,
-0.0555089004,
0.4655238986,
-0.2642238438,
0.1411834508,
0.4867210984,
0.3121515214,
0.5222248435,
-0.2245898098,
0.8840824366,
-0.4761422873,
0.4515549242,
0.7581545711,
-0.186837852,
1.0469111204,
0.5480654836,
-0.2773196101,
0.7045486569,
0.5856969953,
0.2111610472,
0.4026145339,
0.2914642096,
-0.3334600627,
0.1005244553,
-0.0198565852,
-0.353499651,
0.2985123098,
-0.024779601,
-0.6617053151,
-0.1571377218,
0.1050757915,
0.3636224568,
0.1755377948,
-0.4157428741,
0.6046134233,
-0.213934049,
-0.8580148816,
0.5790780187,
-0.0073052403,
0.7597387433,
-0.5720876455,
0.3523114324,
-0.3645113111,
0.0726714656,
0.098465994,
-0.6090721488,
0.2575397789,
-0.0100919371,
-0.2980546653,
-0.1329069287,
0.2614654899,
-0.7654788494,
-0.2928457856,
0.1615553945,
0.5428085923,
0.2782490849,
0.3724558651,
-0.3843429387,
-0.1290690154,
0.1574501693,
-0.3661906719,
0.0056231865,
0.2883789539,
0.0573971234,
0.31425336,
0.1386035085,
0.2735385001,
0.3004162312,
0.2300397754,
0.3032951951,
-0.8436037898,
-0.39184618,
-0.9333425164,
0.5250602961,
0.0344606936,
-0.3546175957,
0.8726524711,
0.5934643745,
0.7150244713,
-0.2568345368,
0.8369583488,
-0.2072031647,
0.7744788527,
-0.3764131367,
0.6977915168,
-0.4933825433,
-0.1325335652,
-0.2964219749,
-0.892020762,
0.0529854447,
0.8256076574,
-0.4191409945,
0.2643457949,
0.9985248446,
0.4517125785,
0.103682138,
-0.0295658372,
0.5507819653,
0.6243178248,
0.1381255239,
0.3325667083,
0.7950741649,
-0.4340749085,
0.0807536691,
0.0161077529,
-0.4385950863,
-0.2913617194,
-0.9986852407,
-0.9281997085,
-0.6705706716,
0.0315026902,
-0.4273347557,
0.0247155875,
0.8380540609,
0.538459301,
-1.2027767897,
-0.5381937623,
0.3860628605,
0.0819297656,
-0.2590681612,
-0.2189032435,
0.3682551086,
-0.4091917276,
-1.0420780182,
0.3291158676,
0.0514151342,
0.1963366121,
-0.543938756,
0.1285464317,
-0.4441512823,
0.5801356435,
0.6652428508,
0.0408597514,
-1.2234675884,
-0.5896247625,
0.0328555629,
-0.1846227348,
-0.1271310598,
0.755135417,
-0.3836506903,
0.7870879173,
0.6349874735,
0.1046263576,
0.360780865,
0.0421726033,
0.9760830402,
-0.8488870859,
0.2623205483,
0.2978789508,
0.6594981551,
0.3288789988,
0.0937677845,
0.1277643144,
0.0848655924,
-0.5436244011,
-0.6835346818,
0.2602463663,
-1.0395249128,
-0.4164609313,
1.0236313343,
-0.0838695914,
-0.0319374017,
-0.2504531443,
-0.3678869903,
0.1113819554,
-0.1249926314,
0.7323788404,
1.2066318989,
-0.0160962436,
0.1813823432,
-0.7416559458,
0.3136756122,
0.6128186584,
-0.0750166252,
-0.3046071827,
0.598705709,
0.2552194595,
0.269777745,
0.200840354,
0.1098717526,
0.0484823398,
-0.1397376508,
0.3582285345,
0.2952466309,
0.1048866436,
-0.2461203635,
0.0939424112,
0.0606329851,
-0.1991753578
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05000v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05000v1
|
Pedagogical Alignment of Large Language Models
| 2024-02-07T16:15:59 | 2024-02-07T16:15:59 |
Shashank Sonkar, Kangqi Ni, Sapana Chaudhary, Richard G. Baraniuk
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we introduce the novel concept of pedagogically aligned Large
Language Models (LLMs) that signifies a transformative shift in the application
of LLMs within educational contexts. Rather than providing direct responses to
user queries, pedagogically-aligned LLMs function as scaffolding tools,
breaking complex problems into manageable subproblems and guiding students
towards the final answer through constructive feedback and hints. The objective
is to equip learners with problem-solving strategies that deepen their
understanding and internalization of the subject matter. Previous research in
this field has primarily applied the supervised finetuning approach without
framing the objective as an alignment problem, hence not employing
reinforcement learning through human feedback (RLHF) methods. This study
reinterprets the narrative by viewing the task through the lens of alignment
and demonstrates how RLHF methods emerge naturally as a superior alternative
for aligning LLM behaviour. Building on this perspective, we propose a novel
approach for constructing a reward dataset specifically designed for the
pedagogical alignment of LLMs. We apply three state-of-the-art RLHF algorithms
and find that they outperform SFT significantly. Our qualitative analyses
across model differences and hyperparameter sensitivity further validate the
superiority of RLHF over SFT. Also, our study sheds light on the potential of
online feedback for enhancing the performance of pedagogically-aligned LLMs,
thus providing valuable insights for the advancement of these models in
educational settings.
|
[
-0.0974128321,
-0.8883289695,
0.5085439682,
-0.1129503772,
-0.0653467923,
0.3860671818,
-0.5661045313,
-0.1832502186,
0.1472354084,
0.2689467967,
-0.7960021496,
-0.3810273111,
-0.420617789,
-0.112707451,
-0.2365555316,
1.0514820814,
-0.2400498241,
0.2175304741,
-0.3035483658,
0.0257112551,
-0.5429198146,
-0.5097939968,
-0.2853706479,
-0.6413711309,
0.7164188027,
0.4115035236,
0.6038330793,
0.9806072712,
0.678704381,
0.2430548221,
0.1198953614,
0.1761704087,
-0.609371841,
0.137082532,
-0.3976296782,
-0.3420917392,
-0.2028618157,
-0.0121194888,
0.5579907298,
0.8916925788,
-0.5871248841,
0.1675798893,
0.4759114385,
0.758390069,
-0.5155500174,
0.1132846177,
-0.1612518579,
0.1146136448,
-0.2775114775,
-0.1280292571,
-0.4729005396,
-0.5239984989,
0.0429680906,
-0.6288303733,
-0.2992756963,
-0.2328491658,
0.7358393073,
0.3430199623,
-0.1874840558,
-0.1595205814,
-0.5461289883,
0.919849515,
-0.6122922301,
0.3722399771,
0.04602075,
0.3228247166,
-0.1771299243,
-0.3076791763,
-0.3468855023,
0.0190076008,
0.0281408932,
-0.0345617533,
0.4335041046,
-0.0993138626,
-0.0280366261,
0.2482269853,
-0.5071079731,
0.5840640664,
-0.1580429524,
-0.160050258,
0.6321511269,
0.3328739107,
-0.0331060216,
0.0433642939,
-0.6862460971,
-0.2131182402,
-0.8125427961,
0.3659650087,
0.554504931,
0.5908746719,
-0.1642780602,
0.5675034523,
0.0731724352,
0.9263105989,
0.4000098109,
-0.5232464671,
0.1082472503,
-0.1527854949,
0.0560319833,
0.2969830036,
0.6820541024,
0.3456875384,
0.4493523836,
-0.0285693333,
-0.3430368602,
0.0907851085,
0.2729189992,
-0.5473207831,
-0.09400592,
0.0083199469,
-0.2542356849,
-0.550000608,
0.0478053279,
-0.5932258964,
-0.3977009952,
-0.6840214729,
0.5162124634,
-0.177284807,
-0.2060400397,
0.0652106181,
0.5118284822,
0.4806266129,
0.4404169619,
-1.138255477,
0.2316193879,
1.1727737188,
0.5561861396,
-0.5483930111,
-0.4709096253,
-0.4636718333,
0.3363271952,
-0.3012906611,
0.456097424,
-0.6006023288,
-0.0449790023,
0.2170908153,
0.1048824117,
0.032744851,
-0.4779567719,
0.3503282368,
-0.2980154753,
0.393224895,
-0.055461783,
-0.780580759,
-0.1185196638,
0.4796124697,
-0.4090670645,
1.0694503784,
-0.064722769,
-0.5300299525,
0.0211343151,
-0.26659289,
-0.2070009857,
-0.0008396693,
-0.3943797946,
-0.3828927279,
-0.1114307716,
0.1338030845,
0.4936894178,
-0.1680377871,
0.8858633041,
-0.1061451808,
-0.5855020881,
0.4217906892,
-0.4167692065,
0.5883911848,
0.0159388855,
-0.5001246929,
0.3769446015,
-0.3532914519,
0.0350962989,
0.2610129118,
-0.5569173098,
-0.1457898617,
0.0263641104,
-0.0798015743,
0.1647787243,
0.4160488248,
-0.3786084354,
0.3811407387,
-0.4794690609,
0.4787222743,
0.9915118217,
-0.3350451589,
0.4765501022,
-0.4399363399,
0.5739503503,
-0.3272936642,
0.1215983182,
-0.1129745543,
-0.0554072075,
-0.2848863602,
-0.0805091485,
0.4837993681,
0.4483242929,
-0.3148756027,
0.3136657476,
-0.2800953686,
-0.3237227499,
-0.7513744235,
0.356379658,
0.5227513909,
0.5581271648,
0.0614275038,
-0.1617906094,
-0.3951523304,
-0.856842339,
-0.3591881096,
0.0275395866,
0.1140189692,
-0.0037716532,
0.2072209567,
0.0448266417,
0.7521167397,
-0.3494917154,
-0.1388055533,
-0.0421630256,
-0.165144369,
0.2598093748,
0.5893260837,
0.0082399491,
-0.6553333402,
-0.4705794752,
-0.0151497833,
-0.6762915254,
-0.1681688279,
-0.0035229372,
-0.0681802258,
0.2535320222,
0.4263710976,
-0.3969991505,
-0.1136087775,
0.5516467094,
-0.1549079567,
0.4019600749,
0.1022705734,
0.0104288086,
-0.7640837431,
-0.0612555034,
-0.0718851164,
-0.3696361184,
-0.268779248,
0.1962393373,
0.2260757238,
0.0329645909,
-0.4910231531,
0.5567183495,
-0.3460398316,
-0.0624268875,
-0.3248612285,
0.4043067992,
-0.0546905659,
0.7095823288,
0.2155944258,
0.4818506539,
0.2295259535,
-0.2052718997,
0.5055857301,
0.097918354,
-0.3750011325,
0.8707080483,
-0.4279792309,
0.043807622,
-0.0086185895,
0.260833025,
-0.8791735768,
-0.1984743923,
0.2711748481,
-0.2611186504,
0.544842124,
-0.0372796655,
-0.2843146622,
-0.0718792528,
-0.3074423075,
0.465488553,
0.379557848,
-0.7013049722,
0.3841505945,
0.4266501665,
-0.2040431648,
-0.7657214403,
-0.4083867967,
-0.1661484987,
-0.4110146165,
-0.3830287755,
0.4881725609,
0.0117502678,
-0.26525563,
-0.0331368148,
-0.2345390022,
0.2114361227,
0.1917050034,
0.2726567686,
0.6271239519,
-0.2132851481,
0.2092911005,
-0.2124282718,
-0.1253384352,
0.0332760885,
-0.2387495935,
0.4836788177,
-0.0311646778,
-0.530297935,
-0.4496763349,
0.2401226759,
0.316390872,
-0.3009248078,
0.6336326003,
0.4123061001,
-0.3115507364,
-0.0308202673,
-0.5390983224,
-0.2999132574,
-0.4602859616,
0.3140605688,
-0.0745058805,
-1.0769484043,
0.2033221424,
-0.1180330291,
0.1553017646,
0.1204807088,
0.6552491784,
-0.2782201469,
1.0224963427,
0.5798946619,
0.1555054188,
0.5087841749,
0.0425613113,
0.2792043984,
-0.8741469979,
-0.649983108,
-0.2183680087,
-0.5452204943,
-0.4260888696,
-0.194115445,
0.0238438267,
0.3381862044,
-0.629072845,
0.1208584309,
-0.656270802,
0.4426534474,
0.259021908,
0.0693980604,
0.1396214664,
-0.0753398985,
-0.1472086608,
-0.2010905296,
-0.7081975937,
-0.6165946722,
1.0361289978,
0.4423303902,
0.9261505604,
0.2438372821,
0.8782138228,
-0.0231266394,
0.4344570339,
-0.7916553617,
0.4340053201,
0.1363596022,
-0.3224311471,
-0.5680339932,
-0.1486685574,
-0.9146752954,
0.1852982491,
-0.2192048132,
-0.7575644255,
-0.1405703723,
-0.0501628108,
-0.3573385179,
0.1488590389,
-0.604659915,
0.9777002335,
-0.5968091488,
-0.9826815724,
-0.0305949021,
-0.6356033087,
0.1871473938,
-0.1470994502,
0.4950989783,
-0.038648203,
-0.0094788149,
0.8997867107,
-0.4425238073,
1.0214104652,
-0.142768085,
-0.5177007318,
0.2083474547,
0.0965830237,
0.7358961701,
-0.3326514363,
0.170455724,
-0.1730774641,
0.0866437331,
-0.3979548812,
-0.4728554487,
1.1241976023,
-0.6821779609,
-0.9025285244,
-0.4466661811,
-0.8480373621,
-0.2977986634,
0.0569336899,
-0.2657499313,
0.1840269566,
-0.0471964218,
0.0362035967,
0.7303499579,
-0.0814757273,
0.3576024473,
0.5678806305,
-0.408354789,
-0.2346117496,
0.9981694221,
0.1101981103,
0.3761105239,
0.6468916535,
0.2385898381,
-0.5602993369,
-0.2635279894,
-0.3717890382,
0.3143847287,
-0.6890286803,
-0.2553140819,
-0.1835010499,
0.0094824657,
-0.3545157611,
-0.497049123,
-0.3030789495,
-0.2853203416,
-0.1235810146,
-0.1994089037,
0.0434207916,
0.847474277,
0.0519430004,
0.2842533588,
-0.5890968442,
-0.1505387723,
0.3529086709,
0.3899218738,
0.061895486,
-0.4756680429,
-0.2698838115,
0.0649464652,
-0.5095989704,
-0.8254793286,
0.2101251781,
-0.1047485918,
0.5900429487,
0.2191500515,
-0.1189988479,
0.6653268337,
-0.3914677799,
0.6658201814,
0.3535854816,
-0.8422622085,
0.367608279,
-0.4426870942,
0.2421348691,
0.3369499743,
0.2975727618,
-0.5053064823,
-0.0129968217,
-0.4070558548,
-0.8159239888,
0.6567835212,
-0.4122005105,
-0.0359063596,
0.2150573283,
0.4139216244,
0.290866971,
0.257014066,
-0.7873413563,
-0.0500990227,
-0.0551345348,
-0.6321699619,
-0.1182047352,
-0.1450686604,
-0.3599236608,
-0.1545006484,
0.7219470739,
-0.2464511096,
-0.1031552628,
-0.216104269,
-0.1576504558,
-0.3410952091,
0.3826268315,
0.4972462952,
0.7781521082,
-0.0413434133,
0.133195132,
-0.2077702284,
-0.0847360566,
0.4175231159,
-0.0516026728,
-0.0260121319,
-0.5274561048,
0.422300756,
0.562804997,
0.6929734945,
-0.8881115317,
0.6147522926,
0.2789513469,
-0.1343139261,
-0.2073928714,
0.1144450232,
0.4024054408,
0.4937125742,
0.2592028379,
-0.5455728769,
-0.3113259673,
-0.5733149648,
0.0383374803,
0.5337246656,
-0.451359421,
-0.0544974208,
0.5402677059,
0.1233845353,
-0.714538455,
0.5562215447,
0.2982280254,
-0.4197931588,
0.5692015886,
0.7570230961,
0.5134833455,
-0.2476905882,
0.2629199326,
0.3101892173,
0.0670388788,
-0.3480772674,
0.0483112969,
-0.1991458535,
-0.6321036816,
-0.7806084752,
-0.704354167,
-0.4339068234,
0.0080815898,
-0.8343205452,
0.3232170641,
-0.337733835,
0.1497891843,
-0.0920839831,
-0.0623746887,
-0.2703980505,
-0.0018673859,
0.2392225415,
0.481639266,
-0.7908123732,
0.9021039009,
0.7974776626,
-0.1693272442,
-1.1543573141,
-0.0848733187,
0.21980533,
-0.8745521307,
0.7184897661,
0.0865558535,
0.1055950895,
0.062505655,
-0.4774831831,
-0.9510739446,
1.1230925322,
0.5522609353,
-0.9994465709,
-0.141729489,
0.0397981517,
0.3845016658,
-0.4243565202,
-0.0985951573,
0.439751327,
0.562802732,
-0.0595932119,
-0.9459967017,
0.0211599302,
0.0442695245,
-0.174431473,
0.5992149711,
-0.5996755362,
0.6176227927,
-0.2135832608,
-0.0541736409,
-0.0627788231,
0.3753299713,
0.432420224,
0.1076798961,
0.2315621823,
0.7180867195,
0.646071732,
-0.330747962,
0.7494609952,
-0.0890202969,
0.4921098351,
1.1588916779,
-0.2886669338,
0.7785888314,
1.0259606838,
-0.3371664286,
0.4814123213,
0.78118819,
0.0404102169,
0.5174474716,
0.4621030688,
0.0610928722,
-0.4166658521,
-0.252332449,
-0.3157036304,
0.3433744311,
0.2000613511,
-0.083304517,
-0.2515827417,
0.0422128476,
-0.2277463675,
0.6637197733,
-0.5769943595,
0.6633783579,
-0.06940265,
-0.9466249347,
0.6245877147,
-0.0237059109,
0.8282524943,
-0.5197870731,
-0.1578826159,
-0.0065482892,
0.3170251548,
-0.47730425,
-1.0254174471,
0.1050495803,
-0.1690826714,
-0.1418835521,
-0.4572059214,
0.2834785879,
-0.820548594,
-0.2347538769,
0.1889558285,
0.3057103753,
-0.0778672993,
0.4513211846,
-0.636402607,
0.3062828481,
0.032953158,
-0.0531448647,
0.7527658939,
0.2244871706,
-0.2079407424,
0.5770149231,
0.4568384588,
-0.0251470469,
-0.1348348111,
-0.0272949021,
0.4777225554,
-0.532333374,
-0.4703199565,
-0.8674097061,
0.3954517245,
0.2929890752,
-0.172173366,
0.6260936856,
0.4158866405,
1.1891442537,
0.0702051818,
0.3830031455,
0.254455179,
0.5297847986,
-0.5788301826,
0.1495337635,
-0.3042574823,
0.4822360873,
-0.2030838132,
-0.9097962379,
-0.1767490655,
0.6954711676,
-0.4861256778,
-0.0398227572,
0.4334972501,
0.5788635612,
0.1779658943,
-0.0582963452,
0.1811127216,
-0.018065257,
0.0766800046,
0.7072585225,
1.0934054852,
-0.154764697,
0.2853177786,
-0.3828802407,
-0.1240293384,
-0.2842852473,
-0.8780658841,
-0.6571757197,
-0.48597157,
-0.423204571,
-0.207437858,
0.2990406156,
1.1834224463,
0.3367009759,
-0.597951591,
-0.4822425544,
-0.0590487681,
0.2932320237,
-0.4435527325,
-0.2845727205,
0.5242573023,
-0.2187610418,
-0.7266970873,
0.2507162392,
0.2469248176,
-0.0427309796,
-0.5123390555,
-0.3802421987,
-0.3958439827,
-0.1438509375,
0.2217949927,
0.2326266468,
-0.9377881289,
-0.3907716572,
0.1066737249,
-0.2996844053,
0.0181985609,
0.7623315454,
-0.8044643402,
0.1912629604,
0.2882336974,
0.9540676475,
0.2937059104,
0.0866162479,
0.4605398476,
-0.4907003641,
-0.0126707172,
0.2166358083,
0.2326633185,
0.4454922378,
-0.388753891,
0.4089746773,
0.0048692264,
-0.6251494288,
-1.0380256176,
0.1881844252,
-0.7207260728,
-0.3521421552,
0.8692427278,
-0.1455233991,
-0.2035615444,
0.2936827242,
-0.2061865926,
0.2687047124,
-0.1902360022,
0.945499897,
0.8821878433,
-0.1875087917,
-0.1839062572,
-0.1949947625,
0.2412206978,
0.7513518333,
-0.5729376674,
0.1556527317,
0.430498898,
0.4006560147,
-0.0381153114,
0.2828983366,
-0.3067672849,
0.1841287166,
-0.5434826612,
0.0700945407,
-0.2335653007,
-0.2942924201,
-0.6749610901,
0.3814628422,
0.2148960978,
-0.0648706555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04978v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04978v2
|
An Enhanced Prompt-Based LLM Reasoning Scheme via Knowledge Graph-Integrated Collaboration
| 2024-02-07T15:56:17 | 2024-06-12T16:03:31 |
Yihao Li, Ru Zhang, Jianyi Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
While Large Language Models (LLMs) demonstrate exceptional performance in a
multitude of Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks, they encounter challenges
in practical applications, including issues with hallucinations, inadequate
knowledge updating, and limited transparency in the reasoning process. To
overcome these limitations, this study innovatively proposes a collaborative
training-free reasoning scheme involving tight cooperation between Knowledge
Graph (KG) and LLMs. This scheme first involves using LLMs to iteratively
explore KG, selectively retrieving a task-relevant knowledge subgraph to
support reasoning. The LLMs are then guided to further combine inherent
implicit knowledge to reason on the subgraph while explicitly elucidating the
reasoning process. Through such a cooperative approach, our scheme achieves
more reliable knowledge-based reasoning and facilitates the tracing of the
reasoning results. Experimental results show that our scheme significantly
progressed across multiple datasets, notably achieving over a 10% improvement
on the QALD10 dataset compared to the best baseline and the fine-tuned
state-of-the-art (SOTA) work. Building on this success, this study hopes to
offer a valuable reference for future research in the fusion of KG and LLMs,
thereby enhancing LLMs' proficiency in solving complex issues.
|
[
-0.355551213,
-0.6244153976,
0.9024273753,
0.225537017,
-0.2148750275,
0.390779227,
-0.3424211442,
-0.3813850582,
0.2187857628,
0.5015021563,
-0.7470883131,
-0.7185790539,
-0.5394199491,
0.3581413031,
0.0918967277,
0.4001255929,
-0.2224084288,
0.0955098942,
-0.6351987123,
-0.2629841566,
-0.652761817,
-0.3941274285,
-0.6560515761,
-0.6198543906,
0.6538626552,
0.5864586234,
0.5923349857,
0.2458698601,
0.3480584919,
0.2832820714,
-0.1951429695,
0.8980934024,
-0.3168890178,
0.5518064499,
-0.3329246044,
-0.4315710366,
-0.4335213006,
-0.0976996571,
0.2883654833,
0.8479804993,
-0.0299808085,
-0.2071584314,
0.307356894,
0.6860963106,
-0.3840690255,
0.3755550385,
-0.600746274,
-0.0769855529,
0.0666980222,
-0.2250837535,
-0.5355190635,
-0.3799524903,
-0.0326086842,
-0.8975708485,
-0.1900618672,
0.3890296817,
0.4114862978,
0.3915831745,
-0.1417269856,
-0.3933010995,
-0.2307831049,
0.6243545413,
-0.4905288219,
0.3626036644,
0.2612330317,
0.4232777655,
-0.5181016922,
-0.7551201582,
-0.7177183628,
-0.2477955818,
-0.1747480631,
0.1303816736,
-0.0645428076,
0.2227723449,
0.3157099187,
0.1218362153,
-0.5460160971,
0.1550127566,
0.1651962996,
-0.4288637042,
0.50454849,
0.2176803946,
0.2532446384,
-0.1276063472,
-0.3736193478,
0.1779495478,
-0.5257588625,
-0.0625555366,
0.0074882065,
0.4701558053,
-0.149707213,
0.6989036202,
-0.5226665139,
0.631129384,
-0.1695979834,
-0.0608557239,
0.1107704416,
-0.3861114085,
-0.205147177,
0.0782094896,
0.8954648376,
0.4441125095,
0.2986212373,
-0.4359581172,
-0.0214733835,
0.1942053586,
-0.3968864083,
-0.3689348996,
-0.1477352828,
0.2727456093,
-0.0283340421,
0.0184797533,
-0.369432658,
-0.3355276585,
-0.5174083114,
-0.4650548995,
0.3657590151,
-0.5894570947,
-0.1154158339,
0.2621979415,
-0.188397184,
0.0282281563,
0.6938564181,
-0.6476820707,
0.1371001899,
0.817065835,
0.7046452761,
-0.1436329186,
-0.2321799994,
-0.6603025794,
0.4549878836,
-0.1370544136,
0.9632314444,
-0.4696327448,
-0.1939107478,
-0.2468193024,
-0.2228354663,
-0.1367655247,
-0.5791644454,
0.465058744,
-0.6238273978,
0.2037236392,
-0.4402937889,
-0.7622510195,
-0.1145786867,
0.7448154092,
-0.4958079755,
0.9981188178,
0.0836734623,
-0.9075447917,
0.2060291022,
-0.513541162,
-0.0645525604,
0.4820776582,
-0.5088785887,
-0.026061736,
-0.6278607249,
0.5312253833,
0.4339430034,
-0.4284048676,
0.5195124149,
-0.5074594617,
-0.3277846575,
0.0387192033,
-0.0777400434,
0.9136951566,
-0.0187199879,
-0.1487282813,
0.336809665,
-0.6029667854,
0.1994896233,
0.1436570138,
-0.1647206396,
-0.2633089721,
-0.5368496776,
-0.6992800832,
-0.003488214,
0.4982859194,
-0.3574832082,
0.5020891428,
-0.2277246565,
0.146963492,
0.6525622606,
0.1486820877,
0.5181697607,
-0.3519350588,
0.3830689192,
-0.2303165644,
0.2227450162,
-0.0721850917,
-0.6854897738,
-0.7204824686,
-0.3598205745,
0.0822203159,
0.6065769792,
-1.1845448017,
0.5046115518,
-0.065144524,
-0.1304322034,
-0.3450537026,
0.1645744294,
0.3243243098,
0.8102728128,
0.536750555,
-0.0242139194,
-0.5755963326,
-0.6327174902,
-0.1880302578,
-0.1644937992,
-0.0648553073,
0.4377360642,
0.2534829378,
-0.185586378,
1.1266798973,
-0.3747343719,
-0.246278584,
-0.6576952934,
0.0633223876,
0.2637853324,
0.367919594,
0.1273177564,
-0.3919640481,
-0.6024461985,
-0.1750251055,
-1.0697091818,
-0.3592272997,
0.0987720639,
-0.5495666862,
-0.0044679637,
0.5504155159,
-0.6730427146,
0.0195618588,
0.437087059,
-0.4248762727,
0.5469241738,
-0.1901946962,
0.0411896147,
-1.0541753769,
-0.2111553848,
-0.2988980412,
-0.2875335515,
-0.2025722563,
0.0306725334,
-0.2320771962,
0.0549488179,
-0.0665464029,
0.5604490042,
-0.3151698411,
-0.007497034,
-0.1097211838,
0.5857514739,
0.1650648117,
0.574408114,
-0.0148554137,
0.7386805415,
0.6499944329,
-0.4939345419,
0.6981276274,
0.4384776056,
-0.1088625491,
0.6184671521,
-0.347063303,
0.3709828556,
-0.0297986716,
0.435541898,
-0.8691428304,
-0.2456616759,
0.5969979167,
-0.5286561251,
0.0973989218,
0.0342457369,
-0.8552531004,
-0.3247789741,
-0.0689201728,
0.0626435354,
0.2312555164,
-0.6843013167,
0.7825389504,
0.0936365873,
-0.0857857615,
-0.5825096369,
-0.3617762923,
0.2407423705,
0.0425249673,
-1.1183072329,
0.3842312098,
-0.048114486,
-0.4164663255,
0.1563518792,
0.0211629309,
0.038061101,
0.0562853999,
0.0753318369,
0.181705147,
0.0743121207,
0.2189368457,
0.2117621899,
-0.4381334186,
-0.0650815219,
-0.3343818486,
0.567006886,
-0.0892177448,
-0.5115559697,
-0.4581908584,
0.3662540615,
0.2907452285,
-0.0900122747,
0.8635100722,
0.3917833865,
-0.2588112354,
-0.390494585,
-0.5268075466,
-0.3394526243,
-0.4788020849,
-0.1150464341,
-0.2445867658,
-1.244510293,
0.471944809,
-0.6312841773,
-0.1984022558,
0.101118885,
0.4007819891,
-0.1889666766,
0.7948601842,
0.4740864038,
0.0949074849,
0.080596596,
-0.2092039734,
0.0937124044,
-0.8519058228,
-0.7595258951,
-0.3708377182,
-0.1119235158,
-0.0208700132,
-0.5957103372,
0.5996631384,
0.4722608328,
-0.2015007585,
0.0025879636,
-0.4482328296,
0.5245879889,
0.6404371262,
0.2962058187,
0.6387968063,
-0.1007018536,
-0.8158342242,
0.00221389,
-0.9043377042,
-0.4103629291,
0.6436218619,
-0.0674593747,
0.4430832863,
-0.009420095,
0.8070206642,
0.2300802916,
0.1953222156,
-0.677949667,
0.9891600013,
0.2156678736,
-0.0343361497,
-0.4636646211,
-0.5124559402,
-0.7418559194,
0.2125341892,
-0.2891193926,
-0.7578226924,
-0.3886372447,
0.1188503504,
-0.1775398105,
0.206909582,
-0.5707356334,
0.5779210329,
-0.0940870866,
-0.5094531775,
-0.3152469993,
-0.7083738446,
0.3206433058,
0.2503421009,
0.2853286862,
-0.324511826,
0.1619835049,
0.6131078601,
-0.5481695533,
0.7946482301,
-0.3388261795,
-0.0903344974,
0.4688337147,
0.1217164844,
0.8745779991,
0.0836064368,
-0.1267358363,
-0.0288624316,
-0.5882976651,
-0.2460430413,
-0.8908718824,
0.5115129948,
-0.4801571667,
-0.75247401,
-0.0789434537,
-1.0211488008,
-0.6350661516,
0.2224779874,
-0.0121979062,
0.2430053502,
0.3174255192,
0.1574887931,
0.6408772469,
-0.1174963638,
0.256033808,
0.4626893699,
-0.2501120567,
-0.6247828603,
0.5092863441,
-0.0100085493,
0.2268572152,
0.4100969732,
0.3808733821,
-0.4271740019,
-0.5831301212,
-0.4942498207,
0.3580762446,
-0.9669906497,
-0.186554268,
-0.7268562913,
-0.0584852286,
-0.4337254763,
-0.2578831315,
-0.0574456677,
-0.4013335407,
-0.0600408241,
-0.0222726557,
0.6159133315,
0.3418990374,
0.022594586,
0.0894993916,
-0.932834506,
0.2064577341,
0.5069482327,
0.257203728,
0.0538156852,
-0.3702568412,
-0.099475719,
-0.2355142683,
-0.0505290627,
-0.7251397371,
0.0909752399,
-0.318906337,
0.905628264,
-0.0167573895,
0.3874279857,
0.4570357203,
-0.0913653001,
0.7424375415,
0.2623792887,
-0.9119026661,
0.483032912,
-0.5184053779,
0.2357666939,
0.6205298901,
0.3243330419,
-0.4793335795,
-0.5460320711,
-0.4906311035,
-0.797008872,
0.5303558707,
0.3056985736,
-0.3795422018,
0.1674550325,
0.3817304969,
0.0400428697,
0.1086083055,
-0.5843248963,
-0.1602727622,
0.209580496,
-0.38048926,
0.4788327813,
-0.0045739375,
-0.3328400254,
-0.3791850507,
0.7096986175,
-0.5049413443,
0.0088553149,
0.162380144,
-0.0423047356,
0.0637697577,
0.2698861659,
0.1562975198,
0.3382969201,
0.0567242056,
0.2388898432,
0.4187638164,
-0.0521175861,
0.0559327789,
0.1045012325,
-0.0475874543,
-0.1583282799,
0.5574160218,
0.6444454789,
0.08872623,
-0.7079803348,
0.6027835608,
-0.1531770974,
-0.3223064244,
0.0300230142,
0.207055375,
0.579180479,
0.8034616709,
0.2379276901,
-0.0432589091,
-0.1521023661,
-0.1044929847,
0.1940766126,
0.5548678637,
-0.2031487525,
0.0761905611,
0.4648137093,
0.2932563126,
-0.2606575787,
0.6278787255,
-0.6404600739,
-0.5302022696,
0.5216983557,
0.5328819156,
0.59963727,
0.1021888852,
0.3128165305,
0.2786478996,
0.1481907219,
-0.2041439712,
0.3784816563,
-0.4145896435,
-1.0007025003,
-0.6557155252,
-0.240637064,
-0.8838062882,
-0.0198985711,
-0.3091565669,
0.2772223651,
-0.354718864,
0.2415767461,
-0.5043809414,
-0.0235637277,
-0.2465740889,
-0.0033218551,
0.2602628469,
0.9813094139,
-0.6516718268,
0.7906038165,
0.5146542192,
-0.2743917108,
-1.226575613,
-0.0693390444,
-0.1763214916,
-0.9915921092,
0.6045428514,
0.4099203348,
-0.3125921488,
0.1429933161,
-0.7385401726,
-0.648244381,
1.4715852737,
0.6885142326,
-0.7654246688,
-0.0524472743,
0.1158204228,
0.3035592437,
-0.262660861,
0.0879573077,
0.3382776976,
0.4532516003,
0.6473167539,
-0.8709760904,
0.3562392592,
0.0064699748,
-0.4437330663,
-0.0095356526,
-0.7878310084,
0.6373927593,
-0.4167810977,
-0.1640294641,
-0.0844481736,
0.6678711772,
0.8870500922,
0.5917547941,
0.6423275471,
0.6902994514,
1.364548564,
0.1029160395,
0.72172755,
-0.4362772703,
0.1824946404,
1.1389001608,
-0.4971893132,
0.4180882573,
0.4835713804,
-0.0574787185,
0.7187541127,
0.3307044208,
0.1968148351,
0.4153115451,
0.0674711764,
-0.6699448824,
-0.7042691708,
-0.5927000642,
-0.317689687,
0.0780751407,
0.4122422636,
-0.19464688,
-0.4950094223,
-0.0201717503,
0.0791533962,
0.2403989881,
-0.3886427283,
0.7354994416,
0.2887038887,
-0.716689527,
0.3774403334,
-0.2088900208,
0.6255495548,
-0.5977021456,
-0.1434422284,
-0.1737706661,
-0.1036493555,
-0.272665143,
-0.8966434598,
0.1212639809,
-0.0418074206,
0.0319071077,
-0.389169842,
1.0033890009,
-0.4017479718,
0.026496511,
0.5557554364,
0.8940293789,
0.0007646332,
-0.0804799944,
-0.5270545483,
-0.0016822425,
-0.0432264134,
0.0398681611,
0.2896246314,
0.7012013197,
-0.0364887714,
0.8231121302,
0.6114971042,
-0.0226423983,
-0.2363744974,
0.4801955521,
1.1650207043,
-0.4836550057,
-0.5867131352,
-0.8631765246,
0.3128071129,
-0.2534530759,
0.2103709579,
0.711389482,
0.3909361362,
0.6413431168,
0.2871244848,
0.9078091383,
0.2058836967,
0.5648809671,
-0.8047727942,
0.4525653124,
-0.1358078718,
0.4107294083,
-0.0298813041,
-0.6534766555,
-0.5355668068,
0.5543932319,
-0.2328768075,
-0.2278442979,
0.7719424963,
0.7145149708,
0.3228599429,
0.1893222928,
0.1617533118,
0.0153799821,
0.3622117639,
0.7464036942,
0.9675343037,
0.1927648783,
0.7079019547,
-0.1983290613,
-0.2797587812,
0.0152882887,
-1.0738284588,
-0.927486062,
-0.1830073148,
-0.2002495825,
-0.4502708018,
0.0650257915,
1.2100986242,
0.2873300016,
-0.3866089582,
0.2145169079,
-0.5405011177,
0.3858319521,
-0.1309773624,
-0.2325177938,
0.2766960859,
-0.4851862192,
-0.4377730787,
0.6372689009,
0.4389964342,
-0.0630309135,
-0.2816895843,
-0.4028602242,
-0.0043601128,
-0.074374713,
0.4727435112,
-0.0773207545,
-0.5400747061,
-0.2995735407,
0.1356590986,
-0.1118415967,
0.0360015258,
0.7883697748,
-1.0667165518,
0.4813963175,
0.6247742772,
0.739251256,
0.302323848,
-0.1287551671,
0.41419366,
-0.8442065716,
0.094351463,
0.3057474792,
0.4007883966,
0.4868901968,
-0.4988667667,
0.4617104232,
0.6654240489,
-0.481417805,
-0.7245990634,
0.3364513218,
-1.1004831791,
-0.2384764403,
1.2402384281,
-0.3225548565,
-0.027275227,
-0.3900254965,
-0.3657708168,
0.5659305453,
-0.5457569361,
0.605948627,
0.7400205135,
-0.634881258,
-0.241517812,
0.0107202241,
0.2557578981,
0.3880506754,
-1.0059964657,
0.1298890263,
0.4191649854,
0.0283679571,
0.107511282,
0.9346652627,
0.1385833621,
-0.0685173944,
0.0669228658,
-0.1448391378,
-0.5603351593,
-0.4106015861,
-0.0051792846,
0.4496680498,
0.1662588567,
0.025468098
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04967v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04967v1
|
Text or Image? What is More Important in Cross-Domain Generalization Capabilities of Hate Meme Detection Models?
| 2024-02-07T15:44:55 | 2024-02-07T15:44:55 |
Piush Aggarwal, Jawar Mehrabanian, Weigang Huang, Özge Alacam, Torsten Zesch
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV
|
This paper delves into the formidable challenge of cross-domain
generalization in multimodal hate meme detection, presenting compelling
findings. We provide enough pieces of evidence supporting the hypothesis that
only the textual component of hateful memes enables the existing multimodal
classifier to generalize across different domains, while the image component
proves highly sensitive to a specific training dataset. The evidence includes
demonstrations showing that hate-text classifiers perform similarly to
hate-meme classifiers in a zero-shot setting. Simultaneously, the introduction
of captions generated from images of memes to the hate-meme classifier worsens
performance by an average F1 of 0.02. Through blackbox explanations, we
identify a substantial contribution of the text modality (average of 83%),
which diminishes with the introduction of meme's image captions (52%).
Additionally, our evaluation on a newly created confounder dataset reveals
higher performance on text confounders as compared to image confounders with an
average $\Delta$F1 of 0.18.
|
[
-0.6548507214,
-0.6895422935,
0.2998510301,
-0.1214290559,
-0.357201308,
0.1112365574,
-0.0929136202,
-0.6625011563,
0.0442161709,
0.178739965,
-0.6325349808,
-0.258626163,
-1.118937254,
0.1583127826,
-0.3838523328,
1.0436724424,
0.155154556,
-0.1929965317,
-0.2375679016,
-0.3389706612,
-0.3832196593,
-0.6756900549,
-0.6793682575,
-0.2035184652,
0.9549264312,
0.2335596532,
0.8267524242,
0.2730051279,
0.4519785941,
0.2209162563,
0.5215842128,
-0.1063355953,
-0.3368834257,
0.1910378039,
-0.2703108191,
-0.4776492715,
-0.1347881109,
0.2475645691,
0.0935694873,
0.0817641988,
0.4551794231,
-0.1318716854,
-0.2343166918,
0.417963326,
-0.7076762915,
-0.2682061493,
-0.9776646495,
0.1659956872,
-0.2184000164,
-0.3849979043,
-0.4988063276,
0.1156641915,
0.3306159675,
-0.5324403048,
0.6145855784,
0.2185560763,
0.7787135243,
0.1162913218,
-0.728587985,
-0.5262235403,
-0.7635958791,
1.2662256956,
-0.2678076327,
0.4780453444,
0.0070741158,
0.2413202822,
0.2182252109,
-0.3371865749,
-0.848231554,
0.1243769601,
0.0275262669,
-0.0198699292,
-0.7629538178,
-0.0818211734,
0.2420786917,
0.5020760894,
-0.8235551715,
0.1690611392,
-0.385859549,
-0.4163100719,
0.46043998,
-0.0232778415,
0.6922248006,
-0.0348288193,
-0.5870267749,
-0.2049496621,
-0.5952433944,
-0.1660961509,
0.4348472953,
0.0001312155,
-0.0702396408,
0.584161818,
0.1633030623,
0.5165078044,
0.0238172095,
-0.0785780996,
0.2005927563,
-0.2160362899,
-0.1430381984,
-0.2803898156,
0.8479160666,
0.7816208005,
0.6407133341,
-0.2431027442,
-0.0158851054,
0.6655169129,
0.480892837,
-0.9732450247,
-0.1178651005,
-0.0566964522,
-0.5171322227,
-0.2930392027,
-0.4374518991,
-0.8860478401,
-0.4283524454,
-0.1320726573,
0.2229859084,
-0.4249498248,
-0.1382704377,
-0.1961545795,
-0.5948119164,
0.0855992734,
0.4851141274,
-0.8500512838,
0.1581100225,
0.280080229,
0.5388804674,
-0.3837139904,
-0.1653522998,
-0.3131350279,
0.0231711213,
-0.2110971212,
1.0730175972,
-0.9079232812,
-0.0401976556,
-0.0541890822,
0.1181173548,
-0.3050467074,
-0.6213246584,
0.4647637904,
-0.5502032042,
0.2566235065,
0.050793726,
-0.4742851257,
-0.3250187337,
0.2906041741,
-0.6018239856,
0.3782570958,
0.1470019817,
-0.7590728402,
0.7101178765,
-0.5595453382,
-0.4074738324,
-0.1775435209,
-0.2064740658,
-0.7331191301,
0.1405751556,
-0.0692091137,
0.705013752,
-0.2055376768,
-0.0261947773,
-0.6676570177,
-0.0938821211,
0.3884893954,
-0.4446389675,
0.3691308498,
0.2332736403,
-0.6245028973,
-0.2713324726,
-0.6619529128,
-0.3574899137,
0.4043417871,
-0.1244317219,
-1.0488170385,
-0.0402358621,
0.1805419326,
0.3725527525,
-0.182781443,
-0.8249159455,
-0.1270986199,
0.2199635059,
0.0799551085,
0.7570832968,
-0.2003206462,
0.4472992718,
-0.4561104476,
0.5719610453,
0.3895438015,
0.1710898876,
-0.0874036625,
-0.7337102294,
-0.2951582074,
-0.3495342433,
0.0222306885,
0.400760293,
-0.8260324597,
-0.2185165584,
0.0974304825,
-0.239500314,
-0.1296354681,
0.0867347866,
0.56524086,
0.2686208189,
0.5791635513,
-0.2436228245,
-0.6468562484,
-1.2602069378,
-0.5026769638,
0.0690148547,
0.0581644922,
0.4316910803,
0.6820489764,
-0.5171416998,
0.4095681012,
-0.4498548508,
-0.393966049,
0.0922235101,
0.2575129867,
-0.2721118331,
0.3977257311,
1.1654862165,
-1.2401416302,
-0.6141574383,
-0.1652959138,
-0.7137108445,
-0.1332289428,
-0.0973773077,
0.149474293,
0.2676778436,
0.3135359585,
-0.180776462,
0.5174159408,
0.7906486988,
-0.5541654825,
0.5619547963,
0.4027724266,
0.7364042997,
-0.804207027,
-0.3056433201,
0.4470305443,
-0.0932061076,
-0.7663269639,
-0.0971908346,
0.0430597253,
0.0317874625,
-0.4544934928,
0.2827816904,
-0.3300263584,
0.3607438207,
-0.268260777,
-0.0764318034,
0.0202656835,
0.4886321425,
-0.1470172107,
0.7442724705,
0.3371182978,
-0.5405574441,
0.3251613081,
0.1707695425,
-0.126237303,
1.0248626471,
-0.419975996,
-0.0282533206,
-0.2734464407,
0.1414095908,
-1.219233036,
0.0698549822,
0.610719502,
-0.5759907365,
0.3467957377,
-0.1490381062,
-0.2261191308,
-0.2571771443,
-0.4436509907,
0.8737207055,
0.2301021516,
-0.4866444468,
0.5854999423,
0.2857055962,
0.0965918228,
-0.7493088245,
-0.7782335281,
0.1589889228,
-0.3195935488,
-0.4990867972,
0.4838216305,
-0.3507398963,
-0.1955531538,
0.021911893,
-0.1414490491,
-0.3167580068,
0.0807782486,
0.4587439001,
-0.068626754,
-0.1682627946,
0.2870374322,
0.2135943621,
-0.0616890676,
0.0465150401,
-0.122737512,
0.3605393171,
0.1829822063,
-0.1299604326,
-0.2144121975,
0.5789298415,
0.6108884811,
0.2264331132,
0.6335046291,
0.4811341166,
-0.3662509024,
-0.4077470303,
-0.5396909118,
0.1034351885,
-0.4070437849,
0.2990592718,
-0.4267310798,
-1.0204524994,
0.3893735409,
0.2177897394,
-0.0769070238,
0.6336515546,
0.3736938536,
-0.0902851075,
0.8444601893,
0.6798674464,
-0.066917628,
0.469124943,
-0.113510564,
0.2789151371,
-0.4635870457,
-0.2741214037,
-0.6407031417,
-0.3769748509,
-0.4340477884,
-0.5048782229,
0.058935672,
-0.5926867127,
0.1154543087,
0.3563939333,
-0.6058465242,
0.33390522,
0.3275323808,
0.1483438015,
0.1867353618,
0.5252033472,
0.0560803227,
-0.4815711081,
-0.4681125283,
-0.2942703366,
1.3899873495,
0.3575253189,
0.892784059,
0.2362617552,
0.1942991912,
0.8947175741,
0.4413808286,
-0.6810488701,
0.3113965094,
-0.6224014163,
-0.8527322412,
0.0444324128,
-0.2973907292,
-0.9446120858,
0.3005276322,
-0.361207664,
-0.166842863,
0.0587244332,
0.3060728908,
0.2949877977,
0.646458149,
-0.7910103202,
0.9925983548,
-0.0380744934,
-0.1774819195,
-0.5921044946,
-0.2689750791,
0.3132245541,
-0.1969355792,
0.488571614,
-0.1873919517,
-0.1648003012,
0.8115280271,
0.0428083651,
1.026129365,
-0.2899929881,
-0.1173515618,
0.1302310079,
0.1611321419,
-0.1381072849,
-0.5937770605,
0.247883305,
0.2458813637,
-0.2999117672,
-0.6047683358,
-0.592582047,
0.5898640752,
-0.6484799385,
-0.3680920005,
-0.2863768339,
-0.6305626631,
-0.0448107161,
-0.0145610962,
0.3100722432,
0.5874657631,
-0.318929106,
0.152595669,
0.9040704966,
-0.5802173018,
0.263684541,
0.3875570595,
-0.005807518,
-0.4116915762,
1.1224803925,
0.154165417,
0.4756790102,
0.5817103982,
0.0062116189,
-0.1659122556,
-0.5997860432,
-0.6536474228,
0.1076037586,
-0.7454249263,
-0.232438311,
-0.9743645191,
0.121495761,
-0.2505550086,
-0.2717373371,
0.0013269215,
-0.4653327763,
-0.2214637101,
0.249153167,
0.1762978733,
0.7247951031,
0.0860529542,
0.4370316863,
-0.4514013231,
0.5159079432,
0.5628590584,
0.4286707342,
0.1216956601,
-0.6916090846,
-0.2497479916,
0.0312551372,
-0.6639027596,
-0.8908187151,
0.0971558616,
0.1038515046,
0.4447178543,
0.5709265471,
-0.0680986047,
0.4326656163,
-0.382888943,
0.6208129525,
0.4269353151,
-0.674464047,
0.3225546479,
-0.2606575489,
-0.0137970271,
0.0972415656,
0.9688436985,
-0.4780651927,
-0.8859350681,
-0.6290692687,
-0.2107503563,
0.4077093303,
0.2430398166,
0.3653687239,
-0.1008048877,
0.1266475022,
0.420136869,
0.2147307247,
-1.0674904585,
-0.7078793645,
-0.3454695344,
-0.1086378917,
-0.0852852464,
-0.6255787611,
0.0157230776,
-0.1840509772,
0.7003652453,
-0.1525244415,
0.4192464054,
0.148738116,
-0.3902396262,
-0.1571161151,
0.2787089348,
0.806168437,
0.4213263392,
-0.042806346,
0.4520230889,
-0.2019042969,
-0.4330752492,
0.3473787606,
-0.1223624274,
-0.1429470628,
0.2519553602,
0.4078067541,
0.5914384127,
0.1180564463,
-0.5005387068,
0.9095018506,
-0.1579966545,
-0.5571483374,
-0.060616564,
-0.1279015839,
-0.3779169023,
0.2521391213,
0.6416861415,
0.4226241112,
0.3168988228,
-0.4040078223,
0.4617827535,
0.732619226,
-0.3870495558,
-0.6118053794,
0.8346922994,
0.0803714916,
0.0968968272,
-0.1717499793,
0.0046570865,
-0.8614177108,
0.804466486,
0.6478719115,
0.737191081,
-0.3073890507,
0.4909396172,
0.1953518689,
0.5297675133,
0.6741858721,
-0.1065598279,
-0.0055527659,
-0.9501546025,
-0.0373316519,
-0.405605644,
-0.4449188411,
0.3372246325,
-0.0540091135,
0.1144272014,
-0.5076568127,
0.0375009105,
0.7756809592,
-0.2755304277,
-0.5908812284,
0.6044248939,
0.4091085494,
0.6203901172,
-1.0634393692,
0.2550151646,
0.8524625301,
-0.3935446441,
-0.1983894408,
-0.0672182366,
0.1131914109,
-0.8446685076,
0.5961999297,
0.2779448926,
-0.0793642178,
-0.3474045694,
-0.909247458,
-0.2763287425,
0.4472024441,
0.0922176391,
-0.3139178157,
0.2965861261,
0.1981693953,
0.5435382724,
-0.7409656644,
0.2420667261,
0.1392559856,
0.283198297,
-0.1128899306,
-0.4792637527,
0.2677412033,
-0.2221702337,
-0.073837541,
0.2640450001,
-0.5234156847,
0.9690048099,
-0.0373338647,
-0.2249577641,
-0.4417807758,
0.3274382949,
-0.3678505123,
0.8132275939,
0.7305358052,
0.6024221778,
0.0708702356,
0.124597162,
0.9798415303,
0.2397838384,
0.1498335153,
0.689740181,
0.2412586957,
0.2390265316,
0.4584228098,
-0.1986973286,
0.8074946404,
0.4147357345,
-0.369594276,
0.4449205697,
0.128461048,
-0.5408802629,
-0.3117242455,
-0.2329666317,
-0.2715269923,
0.2155994326,
0.2499913424,
-0.6729974747,
-0.5028173923,
0.4234933853,
0.2433804125,
0.3821356595,
-0.1748433262,
0.5812630057,
-0.0614845455,
-0.28867203,
0.7496017814,
0.0501392148,
1.0302923918,
-0.4046467841,
0.0526555888,
0.1470469683,
0.2362472266,
-0.3973895311,
-0.5988957286,
0.5210608244,
0.0525627881,
-0.8582747579,
-0.1209039092,
0.8896727562,
-0.4862085581,
-0.0058900677,
0.6788883209,
0.3778908551,
0.2160955518,
-0.4359279275,
-0.8887981176,
0.12192031,
0.1641741991,
0.0063777482,
0.5705917478,
0.5338236094,
-0.2016540319,
0.5461621881,
0.5805826783,
-0.4628559649,
0.3650481701,
0.0707956851,
0.8711133599,
-0.6133832335,
0.0884285718,
-1.0057122707,
0.3157798648,
-0.0571705811,
-0.2147601247,
0.6250920892,
0.7144034505,
1.0340824127,
-0.4585474432,
1.189260006,
-0.3290611804,
0.57282722,
-0.0826339871,
0.4538985491,
-1.0336036682,
-0.2270347476,
-0.5642213821,
-0.5221480727,
-0.4950796664,
0.1823754311,
-0.3594775498,
-0.0402433835,
0.7921757698,
0.7437879443,
-0.3260776103,
-0.0310235359,
0.6906429529,
0.12554878,
0.48429057,
0.6219336987,
0.9252135158,
-0.8530151844,
0.8583248854,
-0.3898686469,
-0.4401129782,
-0.1168248728,
-0.6614298224,
-1.2113194466,
-0.5951928496,
-0.6481004357,
-0.4409997463,
-0.1291199327,
0.4928381443,
0.4085291326,
-0.9975824952,
0.0703033507,
0.3568444252,
0.4744345844,
0.0978225246,
-0.2727547884,
-0.1762345731,
-0.3608071506,
-0.8023466468,
-0.0540920235,
0.3844146729,
0.2720212936,
0.1808834523,
-0.0433856845,
-0.4547384679,
0.2060768157,
0.9050358534,
0.1673071384,
-0.618590951,
-0.5228483677,
-0.1692255586,
-0.2305470854,
0.1438884139,
0.957269907,
-0.4359691441,
0.3871671557,
0.0457632169,
0.6970294118,
0.253310591,
-0.0476727635,
0.3777257204,
-0.6254899502,
0.1925161481,
-0.0604531914,
0.1740042269,
0.3140315115,
-0.2814120352,
0.4695776403,
0.948253572,
-0.395825237,
-0.651720643,
0.260340184,
-0.8800862432,
-0.4057176709,
0.8550128937,
0.0389333665,
-0.2190494686,
-0.362246573,
-0.2081662267,
-0.0119771566,
-0.56585145,
0.6670008898,
0.7029043436,
0.2158478647,
-0.2891893983,
-0.3350616097,
0.3968902826,
0.5503246188,
-0.5675785542,
-0.1582253575,
0.8200249672,
0.5284787416,
0.3565815389,
0.4867624342,
-0.0380110554,
0.5570254922,
0.0110712163,
0.4230948389,
0.1627119929,
-0.3075815737,
-0.1656243801,
0.3349698186,
-0.4564849436,
-0.3777921498
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04957v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04957v2
|
Reconfidencing LLMs from the Grouping Loss Perspective
| 2024-02-07T15:40:22 | 2024-06-18T20:31:56 |
Lihu Chen, Alexandre Perez-Lebel, Fabian M. Suchanek, Gaël Varoquaux
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs), including ChatGPT and LLaMA, are susceptible to
generating hallucinated answers in a confident tone. While efforts to elicit
and calibrate confidence scores have proven useful, recent findings show that
controlling uncertainty must go beyond calibration: predicted scores may
deviate significantly from the actual posterior probabilities due to the impact
of grouping loss. In this work, we construct a new evaluation dataset derived
from a knowledge base to assess confidence scores given to answers of Mistral
and LLaMA. Experiments show that they tend to be overconfident. Further, we
show that they are more overconfident on some answers than others, \emph{eg}
depending on the nationality of the person in the query. In
uncertainty-quantification theory, this is grouping loss. To address this, we
propose a solution to reconfidence LLMs, canceling not only calibration but
also grouping loss. The LLMs, after the reconfidencing process, indicate
improved confidence alignment with the accuracy of their responses.
|
[
-0.3129886091,
-0.6469548345,
0.6232451797,
0.1786448658,
-0.1801532507,
0.3929428756,
-0.2615848482,
-0.0722537115,
0.2234399766,
0.4341194034,
-0.5115886927,
-0.5755487084,
-0.772670567,
-0.0540677346,
-0.59789747,
0.9727879167,
-0.2262305617,
-0.1399295926,
-0.1528338343,
-0.1300529093,
-0.5199893117,
-0.7120429873,
-0.7036018968,
-0.5247158408,
0.6432099938,
0.4308954775,
0.7533670664,
0.3572283685,
0.3543496728,
0.233761996,
-0.0933272764,
0.1549430788,
-0.9621271491,
0.1911738813,
-0.1466764361,
-1.0539749861,
-0.1825450957,
0.1425630003,
0.5886850953,
0.8195273876,
-0.9642378092,
0.0910385102,
0.0499626175,
0.6708914638,
-0.6692205667,
0.0844606459,
-0.9210287333,
0.0951702297,
0.1814427227,
-0.4001681805,
-0.5224804282,
-0.7439482808,
0.1231105104,
-0.5406184793,
0.2907317281,
0.1527065337,
0.6771383882,
0.6484286785,
-0.3577060997,
-0.2269591987,
-0.7270622849,
0.8873873949,
-0.5269579291,
0.1693434268,
0.5847558975,
0.1285221726,
-0.4725674987,
-0.3457227945,
-0.3895718753,
0.0920908004,
0.070530206,
0.2889000177,
-0.1365791112,
-0.0507955924,
-0.2589583993,
0.6295239329,
-0.5535677671,
0.0895262584,
-0.2179836929,
-0.3561374843,
0.7800700665,
0.2588137686,
-0.2968583107,
0.3050623238,
-0.2619015872,
-0.0731662512,
-0.8373916745,
-0.1792681068,
0.1502839476,
0.1172531098,
0.2642273903,
0.6738737226,
-0.1036756933,
0.3357392251,
0.3934210539,
-0.3488780856,
0.1142632738,
0.0879310369,
-0.3351150155,
0.265651077,
0.5017426014,
0.8119162917,
0.5094462633,
-0.1408694983,
-0.1147882044,
0.0780485496,
0.1484034359,
-0.5693415999,
-0.1849221736,
0.3186136782,
-0.4650529623,
-0.2709681988,
-0.0921944752,
-0.4599958062,
-0.6372355819,
-0.1987602562,
0.5155248642,
-0.2416669279,
-0.2059729993,
0.3590913117,
-0.1559527963,
0.4594741464,
0.6169319153,
-0.6107674837,
0.4729213715,
0.6847921014,
0.7949358225,
-0.3087496459,
-0.1424655467,
-0.179390505,
-0.0010680207,
-0.6723968983,
0.6007023454,
-0.3036010563,
-0.9319061041,
-0.0725325048,
-0.0378689319,
-0.1451131552,
-0.6554613113,
0.2178721577,
-0.6477627754,
0.519639492,
-0.3146761358,
-0.8037996292,
-0.5835440755,
0.5654057264,
-0.4913876951,
0.9799604416,
0.1850296855,
-0.6027036309,
0.2472235113,
0.2157192379,
-0.149739787,
-0.2465168536,
-0.2595255971,
-0.1478319317,
0.285001874,
0.1583982855,
0.4534952939,
-0.3838748932,
0.0996553004,
-0.218558386,
-0.6014808416,
0.5216285586,
-0.4652826488,
0.4037681222,
-0.0185543038,
-0.0740147308,
-0.1609523892,
-0.5586152077,
0.2803100348,
-0.1221160889,
-0.4471011162,
-0.356893301,
0.0688795447,
-0.4543122053,
-0.0346873663,
0.1068933606,
-0.4259821475,
0.2888734639,
-0.1848133951,
0.2479269356,
1.0757625103,
0.3693646491,
0.3210754693,
-0.6394845247,
0.6726692319,
-0.1370736957,
0.1545169055,
0.2850165367,
-0.6558977365,
-0.9590432048,
0.0176754668,
0.0151496306,
0.751717031,
-0.6682198644,
0.3433093131,
-0.2658598125,
-0.6905018687,
-0.5838341117,
-0.0390753932,
0.2544585764,
0.5473824739,
0.1751241237,
-0.4772298038,
-0.4638940096,
-0.8048892021,
-0.0541628376,
-0.4722496867,
-0.1680210084,
0.0599668398,
0.2816138864,
-0.2801435292,
0.8086702228,
-0.7022000551,
-0.239817217,
-0.0288439468,
0.1109556109,
0.2895134091,
0.3620917797,
0.0364716239,
-0.7739067674,
-0.1338312328,
0.00663696,
-0.4201330543,
0.1147182584,
-0.0865076706,
0.019740466,
0.3861801028,
0.4611393213,
-0.6184925437,
0.5330596566,
0.7705410719,
0.022518158,
0.6519477963,
0.2470970005,
0.3958526552,
-1.1250977516,
-0.2732647061,
-0.2068621814,
-0.212973088,
-0.2471728921,
-0.2221110761,
-0.380271405,
0.4580835998,
-0.1433088779,
0.0652835965,
-0.1998966634,
0.0266883429,
-0.1183243617,
0.3131233454,
0.2266742289,
0.4794459343,
0.0263243094,
0.7538970709,
0.4174982607,
-0.5708081722,
0.4366427958,
0.2058931142,
-0.4418694973,
0.5569242239,
-0.7167442441,
0.0452546589,
-0.3870875239,
0.4507947266,
-1.3610367775,
-0.3360975683,
0.2888796628,
-0.6967666745,
0.3011898696,
-0.0412786193,
-0.0633068755,
-0.0714354292,
-0.5137865543,
0.4949089289,
0.4404965043,
-0.2925898433,
0.359292686,
0.3691105545,
-0.1702896357,
-0.9749361277,
-1.1629787683,
0.0196876097,
-0.5114750266,
-0.4199075103,
0.4850862026,
-0.1121022627,
-0.4280989468,
-0.0220632218,
-0.2860826254,
-0.188025713,
-0.0950100645,
0.3532202244,
0.1824667156,
-0.127116859,
0.6787718534,
-0.2782492936,
-0.0747303367,
0.1324177384,
-0.0338827036,
0.7425542474,
-0.2919592261,
-0.524889946,
-0.2397387177,
0.3976105154,
0.2996098399,
-0.1803199947,
1.0445291996,
0.4080693424,
-0.295697093,
-0.0166019518,
-0.91993016,
-0.0588530488,
-0.4543984234,
0.4945879579,
-0.2136591822,
-1.390779376,
1.0073703527,
-0.0317573212,
-0.0994200334,
0.5302823782,
0.8424463868,
-0.028506035,
0.7299981713,
0.7592907548,
-0.3416203856,
0.1705273837,
-0.1728346199,
0.1614484638,
-0.7612109184,
-0.419960171,
-0.370047003,
-0.2164335996,
-0.8220377564,
-0.5081056356,
0.2421319634,
0.0125800185,
-0.3682088256,
-0.0545911826,
-0.5875532627,
0.5932715535,
0.4676702023,
0.2291988432,
0.3635520041,
-0.2026846111,
0.3886933327,
0.0345407315,
-0.6593163013,
-0.4889394045,
1.1605131626,
0.3574910462,
1.4209702015,
0.2781278789,
0.9754232764,
0.1246367171,
0.5603639483,
-1.2067582607,
0.3184971213,
0.3355378509,
-0.5294425488,
-0.4784971476,
-0.7153289318,
-0.8438859582,
0.3072226346,
0.0659787729,
-0.9303845167,
0.3828193843,
-0.0144592002,
-0.6106591821,
0.1546361595,
-0.5229968429,
0.4322839081,
0.1449956447,
0.0659649596,
-0.0961068496,
-0.7451685667,
0.8108099103,
-0.3130347729,
0.0427711084,
-0.1440689862,
-0.2330887169,
0.6717275977,
-0.3785389364,
0.9195411801,
0.2007392347,
-0.6256898642,
0.5156419277,
0.2333702147,
0.3125252724,
0.1448388696,
-0.407869637,
0.0165716894,
0.1006897613,
-0.075561747,
-0.836458683,
0.7610169649,
-0.6904321313,
-0.8336193562,
-0.2867606878,
-0.3947027028,
-0.0635154918,
-0.1546188891,
0.6618391871,
0.0547326207,
-0.238342315,
0.0346598625,
0.8890395164,
-0.2410124093,
0.1299323738,
0.2709533572,
-0.2933365703,
-0.5407495499,
0.4350720644,
0.1730509251,
0.5699806213,
0.2060804367,
0.0475418866,
-0.4267789125,
-0.3380714953,
0.0705884919,
0.2155924886,
-0.8267384171,
-0.4104469419,
0.0449670628,
-0.2320143431,
-0.449311316,
-0.1079874188,
-0.3670434356,
-0.5592060685,
-0.1680363864,
-0.2814105451,
0.3753134608,
0.6408929229,
-0.0192408934,
0.6949687004,
-0.7139261961,
-0.0134232044,
0.3260531723,
0.3231831491,
-0.0546010695,
-0.8802230358,
-0.0473990515,
0.0374059528,
-0.0892507583,
-1.1242269278,
0.2998957634,
0.3946072161,
0.6103566289,
0.5015029907,
0.2062294632,
0.9007237554,
-0.2685289085,
0.6583479643,
-0.0168884676,
-0.8897647262,
0.3959133923,
0.0143225361,
0.1480621248,
0.644454062,
0.4343755543,
-0.9586832523,
-0.3885155618,
-0.522382021,
-0.6894231439,
0.3139220476,
0.0609475523,
0.0514151156,
-0.0703906342,
0.6792964339,
-0.1517892331,
0.366761148,
-0.7437926531,
-0.336835593,
-0.0096182339,
-0.0970159471,
-0.2609348595,
-0.4341578782,
-0.4989121556,
-0.0885175988,
0.7399870157,
0.1023571268,
0.2044320554,
0.431922704,
0.1344989091,
-0.3375517726,
0.2469764352,
0.4993685186,
0.4736233354,
-0.2445659041,
0.1676280499,
0.3432913125,
-0.4031685293,
0.5691709518,
-0.2054874599,
0.1736685485,
-0.1318901479,
0.6572957635,
0.3562527895,
-0.1037918329,
-0.4785260856,
0.6486390233,
-0.1891125292,
-0.233187601,
-0.5183330774,
-0.0085086357,
0.0468256548,
0.1223843023,
0.4286462963,
0.1104708388,
0.1170862168,
-0.5689219236,
0.3399909139,
0.2499469519,
-0.4133746922,
0.1081955135,
0.2170772254,
-0.1436255723,
-0.1088873744,
0.7651719451,
-0.2079034001,
-0.817827642,
0.5625320077,
0.4713637233,
0.7031583786,
-0.815256536,
0.2526041269,
0.2473057508,
0.7250335813,
-0.350613296,
0.1238008291,
0.2686099112,
-1.0957406759,
-0.8040174842,
-0.4364762008,
-0.4237080812,
-0.0911299363,
-1.0402001143,
-0.1868185848,
-0.4303325713,
-0.3686558008,
-0.5739325285,
-0.1196327507,
-0.2152145058,
0.3333692849,
0.045173943,
0.6583253145,
-0.7713885307,
0.6352025867,
0.3899895549,
-0.1728915572,
-0.9390572309,
0.0518351234,
0.2602897882,
-1.1071228981,
0.3921276629,
0.2829577625,
-0.3958826959,
-0.106760785,
-0.6537902951,
-1.0845537186,
1.1289499998,
0.2757641673,
-0.4808087349,
0.1329492778,
0.1983627379,
0.5052458048,
-0.2145359069,
-0.0247877203,
0.786971271,
0.331161797,
0.4670350552,
-0.9170129895,
0.1170764565,
0.1830850393,
-0.1299781054,
0.2455412596,
-0.7767879963,
1.1334606409,
-0.2681468129,
-0.4214491248,
0.1421602815,
0.5596150756,
0.3136535883,
0.0649110079,
0.5140993595,
0.6655625105,
1.0716136694,
-0.2088996619,
0.8856531978,
0.0974004418,
0.4118991196,
1.3665342331,
-0.1881283224,
1.051169157,
0.6393141747,
-0.3583411872,
0.447532326,
0.9984409809,
0.2497773468,
0.4550172985,
0.6523222923,
-0.4331385195,
-0.5385061502,
-0.0475654639,
-0.384267956,
0.640126884,
0.7692260742,
-0.2728107274,
-0.1111693978,
-0.2465173751,
0.1749372035,
0.0416265018,
-0.4498786628,
0.4552127123,
0.3138137162,
-0.6154786348,
0.8535334468,
-0.0555261001,
0.5670473576,
-0.4094577432,
0.0660961792,
-0.5526822805,
0.2429560125,
-0.3609398901,
-0.8468422294,
0.3758075833,
-0.4060249627,
-0.0598634407,
0.2725805938,
0.3864229918,
-0.708396852,
-0.5055603385,
0.0438831709,
0.5271248817,
0.3719142675,
-0.371142447,
-0.4459584653,
-0.0142673086,
0.2319970578,
-0.3609337211,
-0.1224007756,
0.5396201611,
-0.1155596375,
1.1596906185,
0.2365561277,
-0.1085471436,
0.0847345442,
0.0720304102,
0.9197204709,
-0.5221876502,
0.0932415426,
-0.9978029132,
0.1510483474,
0.1068070382,
-0.4030264616,
0.9009568095,
0.4022985101,
0.6976107955,
0.2174628973,
0.582559526,
0.1417236328,
0.5347495675,
-0.5008160472,
0.6949998736,
-0.4633780718,
0.4148168862,
-0.369582355,
-0.9205787778,
-0.6011937261,
0.7124409676,
-0.0823750719,
-0.0056575425,
0.5138891935,
1.1158427,
0.4686125219,
-0.1515751034,
0.3214126527,
0.1913682669,
0.3137086034,
0.8062646389,
1.1515291929,
-0.5056547523,
0.6590275764,
-0.1456953734,
-0.3571308851,
-0.1190464869,
-0.8123402596,
-0.6511963606,
-0.3968425691,
-0.3494173586,
-0.2065348476,
0.0004569727,
0.609313786,
0.4017192423,
-0.7253947258,
-0.2356763631,
0.1179619506,
0.1659041494,
-0.1052569821,
-0.2110623121,
0.475803256,
-0.157646209,
-0.4156472981,
0.2191803455,
0.0253615454,
0.3175421655,
-0.3732880056,
-0.1021535173,
0.0301487893,
0.1284118742,
0.5666720271,
-0.0064771227,
-0.9212012887,
-0.6024127603,
-0.0910360292,
-0.0916734487,
-0.0750022009,
0.427650243,
-0.7102895379,
0.1169763356,
0.1358152479,
0.5425131321,
0.2545703053,
0.3936325908,
0.8485664725,
-0.9758929014,
0.0783493593,
0.2895736098,
0.301733315,
0.3774609268,
-0.3514400721,
0.6753683686,
0.0418798439,
-0.8552146554,
-0.601136744,
0.1834682822,
-1.0351983309,
-0.0708949342,
1.0196003914,
-0.3110346496,
-0.0816824138,
0.0265947338,
-0.4467038512,
0.2710638642,
-0.3594390452,
1.0343677998,
1.0456858873,
-0.1670131385,
-0.2351351529,
-0.121380724,
0.5173218846,
0.5807806849,
-0.6562037468,
0.2534440458,
0.5970177054,
0.0801225603,
0.2366630584,
0.6829138398,
0.0046459031,
0.0414775014,
0.000691323,
0.265701592,
0.4602983892,
-0.0513185486,
-0.4400259852,
0.0453937575,
0.2945622504,
-0.4343436956
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04918v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04918v1
|
Prompting Implicit Discourse Relation Annotation
| 2024-02-07T14:44:42 | 2024-02-07T14:44:42 |
Frances Yung, Mansoor Ahmad, Merel Scholman, Vera Demberg
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Pre-trained large language models, such as ChatGPT, archive outstanding
performance in various reasoning tasks without supervised training and were
found to have outperformed crowdsourcing workers. Nonetheless, ChatGPT's
performance in the task of implicit discourse relation classification, prompted
by a standard multiple-choice question, is still far from satisfactory and
considerably inferior to state-of-the-art supervised approaches. This work
investigates several proven prompting techniques to improve ChatGPT's
recognition of discourse relations. In particular, we experimented with
breaking down the classification task that involves numerous abstract labels
into smaller subtasks. Nonetheless, experiment results show that the inference
accuracy hardly changes even with sophisticated prompt engineering, suggesting
that implicit discourse relation classification is not yet resolvable under
zero-shot or few-shot settings.
|
[
-0.5972313881,
-0.7720047832,
0.8195902705,
0.2396586239,
-0.1215575933,
-0.0584396347,
-0.1164112836,
-0.4505211115,
-0.2124078274,
0.1107202396,
-0.7609699368,
-0.2417627722,
-0.548542738,
0.217114225,
-0.1388303787,
1.1577465534,
0.1145413741,
0.1383791119,
-0.252745837,
-0.0235750191,
-0.4283836186,
-0.5897123814,
-1.1061381102,
-0.2888547182,
0.8058100343,
0.3413310051,
0.4902843833,
0.1681401283,
-0.0355974026,
0.2893134356,
-0.3631754518,
0.4326776862,
-0.3625231087,
0.2699557245,
-0.020858964,
-0.3674610555,
-0.1151846871,
0.3349269032,
0.4706213772,
0.7095505595,
0.3344573081,
0.184157908,
0.1951759011,
0.3972703218,
-0.6695502996,
0.6053194404,
-0.5152340531,
-0.0549662746,
-0.1466757357,
-0.163091898,
-0.8559259772,
-0.4864426851,
0.4153776169,
-0.6510522962,
0.2174132466,
0.2904049158,
0.8774498105,
0.3271442056,
-0.4951792061,
-0.2594429553,
-0.5408033133,
0.4049886465,
-0.3329519629,
0.2201537639,
0.6343930364,
0.1789257824,
-0.2075459659,
-0.6767228246,
-0.4812392294,
-0.5032222867,
-0.5209679604,
0.2263281941,
-0.1082456931,
0.4616641104,
0.7615995407,
-0.1030275077,
-0.4131130278,
0.0697409213,
-0.3604890108,
-0.142205283,
0.2844775617,
-0.0962603167,
0.1116927937,
-0.3963224292,
-0.2317208201,
0.1254363209,
-0.778445065,
0.1020085961,
0.2032883018,
0.2410162985,
0.2064017653,
0.4339144528,
-0.0718144327,
0.5652112365,
0.2235950232,
0.1615907699,
0.0409794077,
-0.116199702,
-0.0415712483,
0.0725073814,
0.7707503438,
0.0241883341,
0.580129087,
0.3087705672,
0.2170356661,
0.0435286537,
-0.0164779201,
-0.6557466984,
-0.4787811041,
0.1732584834,
-0.0874616131,
0.1225587353,
-0.1472333074,
-0.412945658,
-0.3742155433,
-0.4081070721,
0.1655863672,
-0.5798113942,
-0.0778687149,
-0.2787845433,
-0.2285026461,
0.3559034467,
0.7281172276,
-0.8457025886,
0.1714157015,
0.6686532497,
0.8432784081,
0.096382685,
-0.2181691676,
-0.6656012535,
0.0183144398,
-0.2811808586,
1.2426589727,
-0.619528532,
-0.4661183357,
0.0370518416,
-0.0587516464,
-0.2838451862,
-0.1603141874,
0.4713175297,
-0.4284559488,
0.5569276214,
-0.4839330614,
-0.5230355263,
-0.1523318142,
0.377710849,
-0.3980166912,
0.9988713861,
-0.0976056755,
-1.022881031,
0.3645147383,
-0.7459388375,
-0.2504480481,
0.0944522172,
-0.2774347365,
-0.2268016934,
-0.113617368,
0.7016492486,
0.5532913208,
0.090336062,
0.1420594752,
-0.2113389969,
-0.3883161545,
0.1857738197,
-0.4249212146,
0.7940554023,
-0.0461890213,
-0.0718189403,
0.0393858254,
-0.5365673304,
-0.0828466639,
-0.1590132415,
-0.0425440408,
-0.3890424669,
-0.2005110681,
-0.3999087811,
0.2733525336,
-0.127760306,
-0.4481169879,
0.3909542561,
-0.4559545815,
0.2743533254,
0.8594745994,
0.2687813044,
0.377155453,
-0.1415776759,
0.5249063373,
-0.043528311,
-0.1387173235,
-0.5069403648,
-0.8235618472,
-1.0638059378,
-0.157140255,
0.6460687518,
0.5884341598,
-1.0486526489,
-0.205096826,
-0.2365399152,
-0.3613578975,
-0.4352933168,
-0.3349780738,
0.5510848761,
0.7094583511,
0.4045110345,
0.0420640521,
-0.4685046673,
-0.8454703093,
-0.0944776684,
-0.6116669774,
-0.0485597737,
0.4895952046,
0.4583831728,
0.270275414,
0.8900766373,
-0.7036486268,
-0.071062699,
0.099840343,
0.8248750567,
-0.1124270484,
0.3901917636,
0.4446744919,
-0.4613599777,
-0.5561428666,
-0.0631772354,
-0.4442875683,
-0.2452744097,
0.0182921458,
-0.0668023303,
0.2121472508,
0.6391456127,
-0.7985116839,
0.3806690276,
0.2837279439,
0.005394842,
0.7586638927,
0.0941775814,
0.2149090022,
-0.6530604959,
-0.12743406,
-0.0460988544,
-0.2692636549,
-0.6129774451,
-0.4363944829,
-0.0803483203,
-0.1587518901,
-0.6675705314,
0.5413425565,
-0.7408604026,
0.0766385719,
-0.1731231511,
0.1133653596,
-0.1260063499,
0.7736669779,
0.4421301484,
0.8997795582,
0.559735477,
-0.7420399785,
0.1813150346,
0.5017977953,
0.0660862476,
0.6782929897,
-0.6475410461,
0.5456769466,
-0.4514020383,
0.5428084731,
-1.3834985495,
-0.3364422321,
0.5566089749,
-0.5619415641,
0.3388239741,
-0.7869668007,
-0.4051635563,
-0.193623811,
-0.2277397066,
0.3943350613,
0.5444466472,
-0.6388657093,
0.3639732897,
0.0145409955,
-0.4810655415,
-0.6246361732,
-0.5176380873,
-0.0818944573,
-0.0254554134,
-0.4043807089,
-0.0058111446,
0.1980718374,
-0.1607775539,
-0.0888410509,
0.0043900893,
-0.2950301468,
-0.3629390001,
0.4673282206,
0.2831694484,
-0.1345412731,
0.5119078159,
0.2940406203,
-0.3319686949,
0.1553462893,
-0.0298937634,
0.2412381321,
-0.0466278382,
-0.3523672521,
-0.5041347146,
0.3252418339,
0.2228584439,
-0.1301973313,
0.6683655381,
0.3606035113,
-0.1207927018,
0.0024265631,
-0.6927418113,
-0.3173511028,
-0.45478037,
-0.0698863789,
-0.4301418662,
-1.232068181,
0.1637548208,
-0.3819103539,
0.2424584478,
0.2188738585,
0.0664607286,
-0.1389819086,
1.1691991091,
0.1140476465,
0.1109207794,
0.3125955462,
0.1542668492,
0.0567878373,
-0.709536612,
-0.0532370545,
-0.7934687138,
0.0309043285,
-0.6745628119,
-0.2611336112,
0.4276419878,
-0.4296929836,
-0.1117509305,
0.113966994,
-0.5714582205,
0.4590108693,
0.3165833354,
0.0210271776,
0.3808342516,
-0.1408838034,
-0.0060211178,
-0.2322591096,
-0.7136793733,
-0.4291991293,
0.4562589526,
0.1519272178,
0.4627175927,
-0.2275761366,
0.6269436479,
-0.0862792358,
0.6227451563,
-0.8669579029,
0.6847422123,
0.2171701342,
-0.5633864403,
-0.3323679268,
-0.4245394766,
-1.1874605417,
0.395318538,
-0.0984393805,
-0.7878454328,
0.2061621398,
0.3931232393,
-0.5167543888,
-0.2204115093,
-0.9534829259,
0.5067746043,
0.1535238028,
-0.1550821513,
0.2405492514,
-0.5833989978,
0.5534691215,
0.2260684222,
0.2167749852,
-0.2356747687,
-0.0051837699,
0.5765380263,
-0.4358431399,
0.93645823,
-0.2900984883,
-0.0422438495,
0.3716677427,
0.082604602,
0.5661349297,
0.1414238214,
0.1046768874,
-0.2398003489,
-0.2010602653,
-0.314242363,
-0.8848167658,
0.4739130437,
-0.3814418912,
-0.8456587791,
-0.4694072008,
-0.3489402235,
-0.6223512888,
0.0544309728,
0.4236035347,
0.2135808915,
-0.1279761344,
-0.1513339728,
0.6957678795,
-0.005644233,
0.4261897504,
0.2504989803,
-0.2408074737,
-0.0363703556,
0.5676788092,
0.3767697215,
0.1701932847,
0.0841180533,
0.0394780412,
-0.5080754757,
-0.3514840603,
-0.3470493853,
0.2786398232,
-0.598952651,
-0.1376202703,
-0.8308985233,
-0.2517233491,
-0.4629524648,
0.0094758971,
-0.2586331367,
-0.5917671919,
-0.2501781583,
-0.3495365679,
0.492769748,
0.6299495697,
0.1308337599,
0.3543994427,
-0.6599911451,
0.1532426625,
0.6816424727,
0.0409066156,
-0.0290123262,
-0.3659193814,
0.2918153405,
-0.127104491,
-0.1130847409,
-1.023099184,
-0.0080324402,
0.1763772815,
0.2441192567,
0.3649509251,
0.1679562479,
0.930564642,
-0.7067171931,
0.8838738203,
0.0287020802,
-0.88797158,
0.8942202926,
-0.3880047798,
0.4810651839,
0.4637765288,
0.7786703706,
-0.3624174893,
-0.507568717,
-0.7452677488,
-0.7681362033,
0.9013591409,
0.4147523046,
0.3117346168,
-0.1433626413,
0.2948551178,
0.0630736127,
0.0929885358,
-0.8148719668,
-0.3441702425,
-0.1576918066,
0.2782946527,
0.2834629118,
-0.3722397685,
0.1099835187,
-0.4020672739,
0.8323200345,
-0.1862143874,
0.2720035315,
0.2946566343,
-0.0221044607,
0.247662887,
0.4807740152,
0.491063714,
0.6617969871,
0.1624006331,
0.2609260082,
0.4576581419,
-0.2142913491,
0.4251758158,
0.3678450882,
-0.3079658747,
0.3451069593,
0.2239046544,
0.7735588551,
0.3823021352,
-0.2655973732,
0.463031292,
-0.2251195163,
-0.4017140269,
-0.1735668331,
0.100519672,
0.25529778,
-0.0406126156,
0.296657443,
-0.1993417144,
0.1844530106,
-0.2890051305,
0.0130648464,
0.3331750333,
-0.5549407601,
-0.059687186,
0.3235955238,
0.2025766224,
-0.1671532542,
0.760835886,
-0.480011344,
-0.4649567306,
0.1310521364,
0.148248747,
0.6409799457,
-0.4310147464,
0.5109305382,
0.5134019852,
0.2895568609,
-0.2572092414,
-0.0238642972,
-0.2995253503,
-0.6253996491,
-0.906686902,
-0.0087448508,
-0.7091758847,
0.2180290669,
-0.5012588501,
0.2531833649,
-0.5436972976,
-0.2578469515,
0.2241662443,
-0.3341713548,
-0.4622055888,
0.092362009,
0.103310369,
0.6238577366,
-0.6696032882,
0.4730183482,
0.724401474,
-0.3975093961,
-1.0542964935,
-0.0533193722,
0.0975460336,
-0.4040786624,
0.7412078381,
0.3502939343,
-0.1643103659,
0.1308220029,
-0.8696405292,
-0.5126373768,
0.4640709162,
0.5539721251,
-0.325006038,
-0.0984547734,
-0.0492831543,
0.5060091019,
-0.0032224627,
0.5712786913,
0.4161729515,
0.7111992836,
0.3376424313,
-1.0275430679,
0.1772537082,
-0.1699970365,
-0.0668777078,
0.1907364726,
-0.5121085644,
0.5858108997,
0.0019119518,
-0.4109145999,
-0.1004593298,
0.847699821,
0.3498936594,
0.4176872969,
0.6216303706,
0.1200953349,
0.8395671248,
-0.4614282846,
0.7870601416,
0.2811834216,
0.1324036568,
1.2776693106,
-0.3135843873,
0.5803978443,
0.3339309394,
-0.1745215356,
0.5714861155,
0.7297896743,
-0.0010540192,
0.1342123002,
0.0389987156,
-0.3808072209,
-0.3050415814,
-0.3849051893,
-0.414170742,
0.4335612655,
0.5590659976,
-0.1208366454,
-0.2533905804,
0.0016839912,
0.2762698233,
-0.1834675819,
-0.3564353883,
0.9212348461,
0.3246481121,
-1.203056097,
0.5417706966,
-0.5533847213,
0.5039636493,
-0.3440187573,
-0.2501018643,
-0.0759398937,
-0.6019080281,
-0.3124378026,
-0.7006853819,
0.101344794,
-0.0870411173,
0.199103862,
-0.3261262178,
1.0357187986,
-0.3410800993,
-0.177377969,
-0.0554264486,
0.7468033433,
0.318970114,
-0.1995055377,
-0.5438862443,
-0.3597571254,
-0.1950904876,
-0.4419338703,
0.2040190846,
0.7043607831,
-0.0401438512,
0.5066880584,
0.7542331815,
-0.2838187516,
-0.1140152887,
0.1389913261,
0.8511553407,
-0.4313423634,
-0.4731216729,
-0.8274289966,
0.5179501176,
-0.2822053134,
-0.2539267242,
0.8577947021,
0.1650513262,
0.5738039613,
-0.1265972108,
0.8186526895,
0.1452868879,
0.6003177762,
-0.6098530293,
0.2446485311,
0.0430799276,
0.0520765968,
-0.4712409377,
-0.7981831431,
-0.2181769311,
0.5235085487,
-0.6152412295,
0.2503008842,
0.9270740747,
0.6596368551,
0.0782029405,
0.3128983676,
0.2909543812,
0.1203877553,
0.1523170918,
0.4363217652,
1.3608121872,
0.0639290139,
0.8080540895,
-0.0496000312,
-0.1364400685,
0.0579407774,
-0.9944420457,
-1.1215808392,
-0.5399036407,
-0.5460885763,
-0.2531474531,
0.2036020756,
0.9569458365,
0.8377920985,
-0.5484556556,
0.2913841903,
-0.1543565392,
0.1647284925,
-0.1044321656,
-0.2484003752,
0.3536555767,
-0.4727939367,
-0.895730257,
0.1800315678,
0.2586423755,
0.2124839723,
-0.124432303,
0.2675403655,
-0.2939068079,
-0.0472313724,
0.721453011,
0.4281165898,
-0.5832777619,
-0.5132586956,
-0.2528748512,
0.185358882,
0.1645271331,
0.9549078941,
-0.8750098348,
0.0911472589,
0.4973298907,
0.4656758904,
0.6785497069,
0.2248533368,
0.4794414639,
-1.1516942978,
0.2136286199,
0.359624505,
0.2307975292,
0.2640956938,
-0.4993652105,
0.6102510095,
0.0149872815,
-0.6687157154,
-0.5749515891,
0.3836462498,
-0.8095828891,
-0.2217593342,
1.1865919828,
-0.3965324759,
-0.142456457,
-0.6646931171,
-0.8367625475,
0.1415165514,
-0.6887039542,
0.5276446939,
0.9689670801,
-0.6531702876,
-0.5781340599,
-0.5805926323,
0.8241148591,
0.513850987,
-0.7914810777,
0.1243585423,
0.721758604,
-0.0862036571,
0.3438428938,
0.9226195812,
0.1338062137,
0.4799904525,
-0.0731104612,
-0.3700919449,
-0.1204472929,
-0.1669356078,
-0.0040899981,
0.3984811008,
0.2707391381,
-0.0818598792
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04914v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04914v1
|
Personalized Text Generation with Fine-Grained Linguistic Control
| 2024-02-07T14:41:08 | 2024-02-07T14:41:08 |
Bashar Alhafni, Vivek Kulkarni, Dhruv Kumar, Vipul Raheja
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As the text generation capabilities of large language models become
increasingly prominent, recent studies have focused on controlling particular
aspects of the generated text to make it more personalized. However, most
research on controllable text generation focuses on controlling the content or
modeling specific high-level/coarse-grained attributes that reflect authors'
writing styles, such as formality, domain, or sentiment. In this paper, we
focus on controlling fine-grained attributes spanning multiple linguistic
dimensions, such as lexical and syntactic attributes. We introduce a novel
benchmark to train generative models and evaluate their ability to generate
personalized text based on multiple fine-grained linguistic attributes. We
systematically investigate the performance of various large language models on
our benchmark and draw insights from the factors that impact their performance.
We make our code, data, and pretrained models publicly available.
|
[
-0.4692322016,
-0.9220731854,
0.4426913857,
0.3579667211,
0.1326237917,
0.0494803078,
-0.4601096213,
-0.3233518898,
-0.0798559934,
0.5765182376,
-0.5365470052,
-0.6597079635,
-0.482629329,
0.1686814278,
-0.3132208586,
1.3003051281,
0.0465460829,
-0.2231347859,
-0.2567942739,
-0.0942410901,
-0.2791386247,
-0.7407230735,
-0.5353719592,
-0.423502177,
0.7350026965,
0.1768953651,
0.8704192042,
0.478000313,
0.5902712941,
0.3047499061,
-0.2248793691,
0.07020206,
-0.3630815744,
0.1473746002,
-0.4095573127,
-0.2857708931,
-0.4836810827,
-0.07987459,
0.6417613029,
0.5509030819,
-0.1443760395,
0.2836497128,
0.1793448329,
0.3895153403,
-0.7008665204,
0.0257735197,
-0.6925266981,
0.0660958216,
-0.4350964129,
-0.1788971126,
-0.550698936,
-0.6338402629,
-0.0404524542,
-0.4930822551,
0.4233190715,
-0.0344118029,
0.9202132821,
-0.0344220139,
-0.2303762287,
-0.2905185819,
-1.0796903372,
0.8588324785,
-0.8206140995,
0.1322334111,
0.5873693228,
0.2679616511,
0.0787989199,
-0.7980812788,
-0.5024108291,
-0.3718969524,
-0.1308791935,
0.008747587,
-0.0570621938,
-0.0132936928,
0.165577963,
0.4368897974,
-0.3053122163,
0.3467701375,
0.0390558392,
-0.1797742248,
0.6021428704,
0.3991640508,
0.2482188195,
-0.1740754247,
-0.2368891686,
-0.2588400841,
-0.3185299933,
0.1480322778,
0.6181501746,
0.391174078,
-0.1382052004,
0.6508812904,
-0.6118640304,
0.5520966053,
0.0623215102,
-0.1866562068,
0.2321572155,
-0.5037552714,
-0.0588550977,
-0.0223359764,
1.0986785889,
0.1999501437,
0.3976812959,
-0.3438964188,
-0.369523406,
-0.1133000106,
0.330250442,
-0.9592945576,
-0.2328000218,
0.1393627226,
-0.5165839791,
-0.6875480413,
-0.1606337577,
-0.654713273,
-0.4601299167,
-0.2779971361,
0.1976996213,
-0.6427372694,
0.0354612805,
-0.0404870063,
0.0659363344,
-0.0269809701,
0.0865669996,
-1.3428487778,
0.2979360223,
0.5298762918,
0.7640911937,
-0.2211351246,
-0.3958463967,
-0.4948579967,
0.2405156642,
-0.3008231223,
0.6721355915,
-0.8312034607,
-0.1180488095,
0.2809503376,
-0.5010825396,
0.213567242,
-0.380405426,
0.2739140093,
-0.4546231329,
0.1052591056,
-0.0931524858,
-0.4700961709,
0.2623883188,
0.1718898267,
-0.5038761497,
0.8908493519,
0.1330828518,
-0.6909092665,
0.5927166939,
-0.2419595122,
-0.5075993538,
0.1429775059,
-0.4121497273,
-0.7796804309,
0.3920968175,
0.0225102063,
0.8299776316,
-0.3932012618,
0.5201465487,
-0.3342563808,
0.275431931,
0.4807330966,
-0.3354910314,
0.0952656344,
0.2770152986,
-0.2697529197,
0.2649710774,
-1.1549001932,
0.4020153582,
0.1441753805,
-0.5046909451,
-0.4280345142,
0.0174250342,
0.4679171443,
0.1553826779,
0.4708971083,
-0.4848380387,
0.0633163452,
-0.2433706373,
0.3268384337,
0.678243041,
-0.0296792891,
0.5118727088,
-0.2959608436,
0.4703476131,
-0.0042439802,
-0.1667090207,
-0.2407297939,
-0.1595540941,
-0.5589727163,
-0.0057038045,
0.3624726236,
0.2034161985,
-0.5349696875,
0.586625874,
-0.0131162973,
-0.5840458274,
-0.3102438152,
0.3620918393,
0.8598663807,
0.0288878605,
0.2914293706,
-0.3860221207,
0.0454659313,
-1.0138144493,
-0.5196983814,
0.2169776708,
-0.218982175,
0.5082908273,
0.2941870987,
-0.0660001785,
0.8929789066,
-0.8160705566,
-0.2726303935,
-0.4306262732,
0.5971643329,
-0.4174619615,
0.6246742606,
0.6733507514,
-0.6924165487,
-0.5184526443,
0.295556277,
-0.4894935787,
-0.4006485343,
-0.4250335693,
-0.1929443479,
-0.0078575257,
0.4386541545,
-0.4166412354,
0.2995863557,
0.6912816763,
-0.5809662342,
0.62953794,
-0.4181980789,
-0.0810336471,
-1.2534228563,
0.2930188179,
0.2973753214,
-0.3098705113,
-0.6557343006,
0.2674199939,
0.1043036059,
-0.1106342375,
-0.2679081857,
0.4446876943,
-0.2118777484,
0.091967918,
-0.1489098966,
-0.1385838091,
0.0334947109,
0.5744304657,
0.049722787,
0.7066693306,
0.2454671711,
-0.5909610987,
0.0884825289,
0.3372242153,
-0.4419511855,
0.5720363855,
-0.7279835343,
0.0987075046,
-0.10351827,
-0.0561244488,
-0.6522606015,
-0.5524088144,
-0.3575391471,
-0.1592892855,
0.2654030621,
0.4754547477,
-0.6684274077,
0.0487003028,
-0.056421157,
0.1225077361,
0.3353660405,
-0.2765621543,
0.6038036942,
0.0978319272,
-0.4123239219,
0.0906523019,
-0.6605488062,
-0.0383412912,
-0.0642160252,
-0.2809122801,
0.548963666,
-0.1684206426,
-0.1023081914,
-0.1560034305,
0.2448493689,
-0.1143816262,
0.1447513252,
0.1826492846,
-0.2715578675,
-0.119575724,
0.1156638935,
0.3908755481,
-0.106167905,
-0.0484134592,
0.0419925414,
0.9062872529,
0.0219883621,
0.0184025299,
-0.6424167156,
0.3604381979,
0.2811015546,
-0.7570884228,
0.9348682761,
0.74911654,
-0.1129198894,
-0.492412895,
-0.5179175735,
-0.0425421223,
-0.4958671331,
0.5108882189,
-0.5610052347,
-0.8509463668,
0.5795130134,
-0.0088094585,
0.0145103978,
0.3498337865,
0.8203670382,
0.236438185,
1.213593483,
0.8995210528,
-0.0518955775,
0.5535486937,
0.0060750805,
-0.0605143495,
-0.6437469125,
-0.2803844213,
-0.7097130418,
-0.385569483,
-0.9168809652,
-0.0524517111,
-0.068108134,
0.0937168151,
-0.4469853938,
0.2452461123,
-0.5779947639,
0.4067050517,
0.7938494682,
0.0769133866,
0.2642707825,
-0.1129553691,
-0.2485740781,
0.0341974385,
-0.4115575552,
-0.7225233316,
0.7909148335,
0.297260344,
1.0952553749,
0.0659096688,
0.6754699945,
0.1625652015,
0.0811509788,
-0.3815549612,
0.4205379188,
-0.7072103024,
-0.4953430295,
-0.1408375353,
-0.6025694013,
-0.6229869127,
0.0141232722,
-0.4633754194,
-0.8753896952,
-0.0494741537,
0.4214885831,
-0.5021505952,
0.2106958777,
-0.8181684017,
0.9249733686,
-0.2181413919,
-0.4878526926,
-0.1001353785,
-0.449560523,
0.2292885482,
-0.3816044033,
-0.2237372696,
-0.2745946348,
0.0308582485,
0.4506191015,
-0.2555785775,
0.9380082488,
0.1244288012,
-0.0348069146,
-0.0644809306,
0.3130034506,
0.4978165329,
0.1167849451,
-0.0150955664,
0.1519765705,
-0.1168858558,
-0.2414631546,
-0.2624891698,
1.0252525806,
-0.7650828362,
-0.2926521003,
-0.0739497915,
-0.5107993484,
-0.362562269,
0.4994345307,
0.5951138735,
0.6521937847,
-0.4199538529,
0.4080102444,
0.5399301648,
-0.6228779554,
0.4988917112,
0.1772931963,
-0.2011261582,
-0.4404989481,
0.9863164425,
-0.0608836636,
0.5542013049,
0.6702276468,
0.5357955694,
0.0148645537,
-0.5800904036,
-0.3281703591,
-0.1476412863,
-0.3997718394,
-0.322106719,
-0.7816229463,
-0.2635943294,
-0.451123178,
-0.3371404707,
-0.4357334375,
-0.1707346886,
-0.4636743367,
0.2465675175,
0.2528156638,
0.9523912072,
0.6587952375,
0.764688313,
-0.7602298856,
0.4755946696,
0.1923844963,
0.6314877868,
0.0250798725,
-0.1288087517,
-0.1837374717,
-0.1626841575,
-0.7338335514,
-0.5699791312,
0.3891575038,
0.4413805902,
0.2694946826,
0.4018749595,
-0.1135070398,
0.2404420525,
-0.8068516254,
0.8625326753,
0.2897157371,
-1.0629738569,
0.6981548667,
-0.3805448711,
0.8554911613,
0.5296390653,
0.1907119602,
-0.2943652272,
-0.919731617,
-0.5315881968,
-0.6603218913,
0.7059563398,
0.524826467,
0.5163857341,
0.0941974372,
0.3856528699,
0.2877739072,
0.4257121086,
-0.7691111565,
0.0024307484,
-0.1318935305,
-0.4319678843,
-0.3431995511,
-0.4560400844,
0.0900046974,
0.0548538193,
0.4018001556,
-0.1957463622,
-0.163374126,
-0.1016500369,
0.2541270852,
0.0219015665,
0.4073793888,
0.7004033923,
0.4707266092,
0.0092767235,
0.1780719012,
-0.0652465299,
-0.4373672605,
-0.1082808599,
0.1210380644,
-0.4181366861,
-0.1377435476,
0.3491179347,
1.1178718805,
0.1361888349,
-0.3580673635,
0.4106943309,
-0.0323194936,
-0.194820255,
-0.0351113416,
0.3420864642,
-0.0110033536,
0.1155859232,
-0.1493553817,
0.2474972308,
-0.047979448,
-0.3128192127,
-0.072285898,
0.3659353554,
-0.2015188634,
-0.6337237954,
1.1324621439,
0.3290448487,
-0.2396463901,
0.2435846925,
-0.1964680552,
-0.2216748446,
0.3155550361,
0.7006825209,
1.0769048929,
-0.216825977,
0.3599782586,
0.3106781542,
0.0737113431,
0.0705915913,
0.1107091606,
-0.1321219951,
-0.8232750297,
-0.2009385079,
-1.0824853182,
-0.1926842183,
0.3772032261,
-0.6666688323,
0.1287192255,
-0.7021927238,
-0.4684073329,
0.5631135702,
-0.0807877928,
-0.7987792492,
0.4129949212,
0.1375778615,
0.7849036455,
-0.7984776497,
0.777086854,
0.7042658329,
-0.4073086977,
-0.6448205709,
0.0860336497,
-0.1775405109,
-0.3705174327,
0.6225007772,
0.1615379006,
-0.1286111623,
0.0477321409,
-0.4780421257,
-0.6182978749,
0.7837198377,
0.1620604396,
-0.6132348776,
-0.1196590886,
0.3795743883,
0.7543760538,
-0.323423028,
-0.032698378,
0.7598400712,
0.2296629548,
-0.0645375475,
-0.9086007476,
-0.1513372362,
-0.2094265819,
0.6462604403,
0.3577498496,
-0.6839157939,
0.8286297321,
-0.0157332197,
0.0410449691,
0.3114759922,
0.7921254635,
0.0808161125,
0.1706527919,
0.19028081,
0.5564346313,
0.6106582284,
-0.0773304179,
1.3265951872,
-0.5590186715,
0.2426421344,
1.3081803322,
-0.2783397138,
0.8482165933,
0.1906832904,
0.0627414361,
0.4346759617,
0.2147003263,
-0.0176428333,
0.5835031867,
0.1513099521,
-0.3868568838,
-0.1608783901,
-0.2796810269,
-0.2066819668,
0.6602627635,
0.0934949443,
-0.7508364916,
-0.034462031,
0.2090060413,
0.0722505376,
0.5956696868,
-0.2307604998,
1.0631295443,
-0.208486557,
-0.6001070142,
0.1639907956,
0.3201602101,
0.7329280376,
-0.8386603594,
0.3098269403,
-0.2277408689,
0.4551126659,
-0.1499020457,
-0.8721712828,
0.0557107739,
0.3140184283,
-0.282253027,
-0.5514084697,
0.6818547249,
-0.5698315501,
-0.611448586,
-0.1001306698,
0.1314979345,
-0.2945970893,
-0.0044152234,
-0.3682767153,
0.1092413813,
-0.0898027122,
-0.5333049297,
0.3919745386,
0.5664716959,
-0.0929460526,
0.6261322498,
0.5881756544,
0.4913620651,
0.1146864817,
0.344004333,
0.8465141058,
-0.7431402802,
-0.627794683,
-0.7661641836,
0.2480240315,
-0.1529030502,
-1.0197780132,
0.7469829917,
0.6982805133,
1.0609942675,
-0.3153094649,
0.819301188,
-0.2279779613,
0.3341161907,
-0.6833059192,
0.9643058181,
-0.394731313,
-0.1484161466,
-0.3309751451,
-0.8906811476,
-0.3243571818,
0.3460408747,
-0.2532809973,
0.3323759437,
0.4647555649,
0.6578406692,
0.0155842341,
-0.1794061512,
0.435721904,
0.1291997135,
0.5492522717,
0.2951845229,
0.7438051701,
0.0019709328,
0.1123081371,
-0.6972421408,
-0.1225447357,
0.0534590669,
-1.0155094862,
-1.0238593817,
-0.6944833398,
-0.3074113429,
-0.2493179739,
-0.2500633597,
0.688716948,
0.6430414319,
-0.880812943,
-0.1124992073,
-0.4410422444,
-0.3290970325,
-0.0537114963,
-0.2543726563,
0.2256771475,
-0.6904851198,
-0.8427247405,
-0.1431353539,
0.1825736016,
0.102948688,
-0.5096399188,
0.1085798964,
0.093283169,
0.1822536141,
0.7338094711,
0.0019208513,
-0.5985136628,
-0.1918166578,
-0.2474857122,
-0.5677009225,
-0.0917993337,
1.1585376263,
-0.4256874919,
0.5691704154,
0.6437527537,
0.4858319759,
0.2803022563,
0.2028966397,
0.6616090536,
-1.2311598063,
0.080403924,
0.1563725919,
-0.0202078372,
0.3507404625,
-0.4757307768,
-0.0061682845,
-0.1489982456,
-0.7686444521,
-0.4693945646,
0.1668058783,
-0.8699291348,
-0.2245815694,
1.2658178806,
-0.0283714347,
0.0160905719,
0.457541734,
-0.1916629672,
0.064375706,
-0.318066299,
0.7588482499,
0.5789639354,
-0.0154343462,
0.026321467,
-0.5528995991,
0.7799422145,
0.324858129,
-1.0745565891,
0.3109256923,
0.4996011257,
0.0948822424,
0.1477523893,
0.5450966358,
0.0285500716,
-0.0240417905,
-0.0511240363,
0.3250409663,
-0.024789907,
-0.4494693875,
-0.2851133049,
0.3093327582,
0.1571690589,
0.1499093026
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04902v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04902v3
|
L4Q: Parameter Efficient Quantization-Aware Fine-Tuning on Large Language Models
| 2024-02-07T14:35:05 | 2024-05-22T20:23:54 |
Hyesung Jeon, Yulhwa Kim, Jae-joon Kim
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Due to the high memory and computational costs associated with Large Language
Models, model compression via quantization and parameter-efficient fine-tuning
(PEFT) methods, such as low-rank adaptation (LoRA), are gaining popularity.
This has led to active research on quantization-aware PEFT techniques, which
aim to create models with high accuracy and low memory overhead. Among
quantization methods, post-training quantization (PTQ) is more commonly used in
previous works than quantization-aware training (QAT), despite QAT's potential
for higher accuracy. This preference is due to PTQ's low training overhead.
However, PTQ-based PEFT methods often utilize high-precision parameters, making
it difficult to fully exploit the efficiency of quantization. Additionally,
they have limited adaptation ability due to a reduced and constrained LoRA
parameter structure. To overcome these challenges, we propose L4Q, which
leverages joint quantization and fine-tuning to reduce QAT's memory overhead
and produce models that consist entirely of quantized weights while achieving
effective adaptation to downstream tasks. By design, L4Q allows quantization
parameters to reflect weight updates, while weight updates reduce quantization
errors. Our experiments demonstrate that this coupled quantization and
fine-tuning approach yields superior accuracy compared to decoupled fine-tuning
schemes in sub-4-bit quantization. Using the LLaMA model families and
instructional datasets, we showcase L4Q's capabilities in language tasks and
few-shot in-context learning.
|
[
-0.2016812414,
-0.6438500881,
0.5861653686,
-0.0564315058,
-0.401027143,
0.1694227457,
-0.2976133227,
-0.2016664147,
-0.3071537316,
0.4919881523,
-0.2051585019,
-0.4663976133,
-0.3139584363,
0.0578094423,
-0.2204492092,
0.998873353,
-0.0898298547,
-0.1747897416,
0.0369946621,
-0.3139296174,
-0.2232332081,
-0.6645128727,
-0.8822462559,
-0.1220728159,
0.551094234,
0.3499925435,
0.7164903879,
0.5688400865,
0.289483279,
0.2195172012,
0.0198490918,
0.1150854006,
-0.6923357248,
-0.08028467,
0.072506398,
-0.7142442465,
-0.7548918724,
-0.1675569266,
0.9517602921,
0.594199717,
-0.0731032491,
0.3189070523,
0.1138608605,
0.8623772264,
-0.9055043459,
0.0958705693,
-0.7266486287,
-0.0678727254,
-0.2578395903,
-0.2738058269,
-0.0707783401,
-0.3933381438,
-0.2579041719,
-0.8867921829,
-0.0173386578,
-0.0400450565,
0.7748670578,
0.4984922111,
-0.524009943,
0.2729073465,
-0.6456407309,
0.9278734922,
-0.8924171925,
0.6555473208,
0.6862410307,
0.10102088,
0.063422218,
-0.7121939659,
-0.3591305017,
0.1718875617,
0.3466006517,
0.0250182599,
-0.1332412064,
0.3334769309,
0.3732723296,
0.3667517006,
-0.3954997361,
0.1676992327,
-0.2382094413,
-0.1402540058,
0.3410664797,
-0.0589579977,
-0.1207405776,
0.2603900731,
-0.0691558346,
0.0000547406,
-0.9646987319,
0.2370405644,
0.4164756835,
0.2369218171,
-0.0398144759,
0.181287393,
-0.6354974508,
0.8644762039,
0.333542347,
-0.312283814,
0.0745074674,
-0.5389832854,
-0.1781808287,
-0.0361465588,
0.6219493151,
0.1819623262,
0.0123273022,
-0.0351175331,
-0.3076380193,
-0.2180941999,
-0.0467415452,
-1.049895525,
-0.4052527249,
0.1816857904,
-0.3656173646,
-0.1624986976,
-0.5452450514,
-0.4086094201,
-0.1282780766,
-0.2501921654,
0.9182506204,
-0.4926309884,
0.0689823776,
0.2046685815,
0.209547624,
0.4162310362,
0.4128881991,
-1.0536563396,
0.4695836306,
0.6838684082,
0.5910833478,
0.0799556524,
-0.1852322668,
-1.01719594,
0.3131415248,
-0.3298149407,
0.6024784446,
-0.3676993251,
0.0917646438,
-0.3318010271,
-0.2053997964,
0.1303288639,
-0.4324471653,
0.5751691461,
-0.5981968641,
0.0594802275,
-0.2569145262,
-0.4233736098,
-0.2539327741,
0.2326325774,
-0.7047638893,
1.1249152422,
0.3370590508,
-0.6240605712,
0.3121680915,
-0.4143796861,
-0.1217485443,
0.0909105986,
-0.0201610271,
-0.608953774,
0.2137729228,
0.4108597934,
0.4575843811,
-0.4270136952,
0.0717232674,
-0.3045487404,
-0.728979528,
0.0449706838,
-0.3280818164,
0.3723991811,
0.074700132,
-0.1705265194,
0.2732726336,
-0.7227707505,
0.1987342685,
0.0356126837,
-0.6610151529,
-0.4729478955,
-0.0833910406,
-0.3794177771,
-0.1039627418,
0.4478238523,
-0.07710094,
0.2665023506,
-0.6166387796,
0.6227836013,
0.5960928202,
-0.0582498126,
0.6456468105,
-0.1997206956,
0.5069510341,
-0.1728075594,
0.2542489469,
-0.0533600636,
-0.190280363,
-0.728976965,
-0.329882592,
0.7671006918,
0.3076292276,
-0.9067399502,
0.2046834826,
-0.277094394,
-0.2453230917,
-0.4489200413,
0.3012649119,
0.3979607522,
0.3040660024,
0.2714360654,
-0.1707890034,
-0.3828493059,
-0.7364004254,
-0.3691743016,
-0.0470693149,
-0.0173719879,
-0.0305112731,
0.2612214684,
0.1804416031,
0.5747203827,
-0.257340759,
-0.0807830766,
-0.1339890212,
-0.0070329057,
0.3502306342,
0.4519040287,
0.570741415,
-0.5328069329,
-0.4729551375,
-0.0159698073,
-0.2589566112,
-0.0397300944,
-0.0450216793,
-0.3465998769,
0.1411240399,
0.3617098033,
-0.4184055328,
0.0993698239,
0.7690061331,
-0.2304230183,
0.238734737,
-0.279445678,
0.1657649428,
-0.9728555679,
-0.0175088346,
-0.2196299732,
-0.6393564939,
-0.5736954212,
0.1729108691,
0.3627384603,
-0.1117533073,
-0.3615582883,
0.3715747893,
-0.4605078697,
-0.2768362164,
-0.2152718455,
-0.1159348488,
0.2624719143,
0.7223178148,
-0.1524030119,
0.784832716,
0.5574988723,
-0.5333452225,
0.1239007488,
-0.0482641049,
-0.1707922667,
0.4461938739,
-0.6247556806,
0.1850511432,
0.214589268,
0.1550002098,
-0.5686026216,
-0.109592557,
0.2635568976,
-0.1161447242,
0.1222452819,
-0.362624824,
-0.7016018629,
0.0811583251,
-0.5640746951,
0.8091514707,
0.6871006489,
-0.4825085402,
0.6160142422,
0.1509688646,
-0.0942224041,
-0.4259904325,
-0.3088200092,
-0.2093774825,
-0.5014113784,
-0.1377598792,
0.5937222242,
-0.2217152864,
0.1179911792,
-0.2093097568,
-0.3374496698,
-0.2956078649,
0.2503266037,
-0.1055713445,
-0.2190157175,
-0.1592332125,
0.1378428936,
0.422888279,
0.0219588019,
-0.2317439169,
-0.2589659691,
0.4030205011,
-0.3144340515,
-0.0365589932,
-0.5812422633,
0.192471087,
0.4004113078,
-0.4992440343,
0.6795341372,
0.7686007023,
-0.4788903594,
-0.1695305109,
-0.3196508288,
-0.247865662,
-0.4938462675,
0.3966297805,
-0.6848577261,
-1.1462090015,
0.3528036773,
-0.3339253664,
0.0001291154,
0.120471634,
0.5500349998,
-0.0800090134,
1.0656273365,
0.5787146091,
0.0625949502,
0.6268646717,
-0.1444922239,
0.2170145512,
-0.7945082188,
0.3110597432,
-0.4009841681,
-0.4619283378,
-0.4440182447,
-0.6485951543,
0.5433881879,
0.6713190079,
-0.5622891188,
0.2493180335,
-0.3871831298,
0.5754190087,
0.7444396019,
0.2347388566,
0.4275763631,
-0.0510573536,
0.2701760232,
0.0130296955,
-0.8030537367,
-0.080228202,
1.1010376215,
0.3081206083,
0.6721298695,
0.2590820491,
0.7472083569,
0.0282232258,
-0.2348773032,
-0.9306473136,
0.4466282129,
-0.1723028719,
-0.071677275,
-0.4648757875,
-0.5113463402,
-0.8983550668,
0.237617895,
-0.3267149031,
-0.4808305204,
0.1279846132,
0.4501419365,
-0.8295776248,
0.1466549784,
-0.5583672523,
0.8800542355,
-0.3860420287,
-0.4981182814,
-0.3841049671,
-0.4346652329,
0.4091434777,
-0.5838201046,
0.2126235068,
-0.2919299006,
-0.3710511029,
0.7786458731,
-0.335740298,
0.8319849372,
-0.1185834333,
-0.3694983125,
0.0091899186,
0.1376466751,
0.6473159194,
0.1193500757,
-0.1362893879,
0.2070414722,
0.5429128408,
-0.5833436847,
-0.7567279935,
0.7623443007,
-0.8759334683,
-0.4824141264,
-0.0988375992,
-0.6425772309,
-0.4318268001,
0.2099917382,
-0.0590897053,
0.3667969108,
0.2681467831,
0.2798926234,
0.6075344682,
-0.3830789924,
0.3032377064,
0.3993745744,
-0.1250019073,
-0.5123309493,
0.9065940976,
0.0126458807,
0.27918455,
0.6041452885,
0.323246479,
-0.1636562496,
-0.8367311954,
-0.2689749897,
0.3251990974,
-0.497500807,
-0.6141455173,
-0.2275525928,
-0.0183940511,
-0.2029248625,
-0.0186885428,
-0.6429014206,
-0.6003196836,
-0.311137408,
0.2479630113,
0.6215635538,
0.1546662152,
0.1370770186,
0.6274681687,
-0.9217249751,
0.5587611198,
0.5194023252,
0.4165417552,
-0.3049600422,
-0.7786781788,
-0.6359741092,
-0.0115850195,
-0.3043916821,
-0.6013839841,
0.2947917879,
0.6797405481,
0.2608439624,
0.228800416,
0.2849372029,
0.8951912522,
-0.4865740538,
0.5969928503,
-0.0144996867,
-1.3207038641,
0.4696370959,
-0.4008828104,
0.4938395321,
0.5226549506,
0.3464950025,
-0.0785172135,
-0.0529442504,
-0.2819268107,
-0.7953961492,
0.6370810866,
0.1547499746,
0.0462530591,
0.4708123803,
0.7583642006,
0.1007467061,
0.2057413459,
-0.8850155473,
0.2607492507,
-0.1193651035,
-0.3288635015,
0.1576333344,
-0.2649801373,
-0.1236765236,
-0.4436425567,
0.5605382919,
-0.5801793337,
0.2071991414,
-0.2596699595,
0.0131258108,
-0.2177175432,
0.2321074754,
0.3787875175,
0.5425295234,
-0.1628478765,
0.1815080941,
0.4587237835,
-0.0935650319,
0.0228638723,
0.0715583414,
-0.0017996971,
-0.3974557519,
0.139412418,
1.073230505,
0.6477233768,
-0.7210586667,
0.5137135386,
-0.1037434638,
-0.4377560318,
-0.2026033551,
0.214791432,
0.091211766,
0.5641835928,
0.2026740611,
-0.2076187581,
0.2438714206,
-0.4209991693,
-0.0940849185,
0.4306121171,
0.0684929416,
-0.589832902,
0.764256835,
0.2234202027,
-0.080184117,
0.2171091884,
-0.113484852,
-0.2899973989,
0.1475625038,
0.3934536278,
0.445985347,
-0.2256930172,
-0.0953532457,
0.45624578,
-0.005706077,
-0.2707392275,
0.4717567861,
-0.3506471515,
-0.6553153396,
-0.8144284487,
-0.9005304575,
-0.4081185758,
0.2171791047,
-0.6214937568,
0.3354854286,
-0.5723359585,
-0.1672842652,
-0.2678972185,
0.067671515,
-0.4570152462,
0.0417240933,
0.1269629002,
0.4914813042,
-0.5670651197,
1.2376945019,
0.5744974613,
-0.1306121349,
-0.9357447028,
0.0670898631,
-0.4307231605,
-0.6358043551,
0.5083522201,
-0.1267251372,
0.0414001793,
0.5560991764,
-0.463075757,
-1.2298523188,
1.1824239492,
0.7265325189,
-0.796544373,
-0.1677757353,
0.0598400682,
0.3443537354,
0.1584441811,
-0.0175715555,
0.7169823647,
0.2973270118,
-0.0963127315,
-1.051400423,
0.1334355772,
0.1395170093,
0.0778225288,
0.5186050534,
-0.8392993808,
0.8595760465,
0.1020958498,
0.0590570122,
0.2679239213,
0.6101150513,
0.4899980724,
0.0111053055,
0.5242293477,
0.5139068961,
0.6733367443,
-0.0071683596,
0.7692968845,
-0.4503538013,
0.3515696526,
1.0918837786,
-0.2475797087,
1.074895978,
0.5213519931,
-0.3262373507,
0.3046254814,
0.6382908225,
0.2905429602,
0.6328232884,
0.1561868787,
-0.3988230824,
-0.4753300548,
0.0909667537,
-0.17502141,
0.6125276089,
0.4599711895,
-0.0456339046,
-0.0839541554,
0.0028752976,
-0.1387936175,
-0.123715803,
-0.5869843364,
0.6745104194,
0.1712997407,
-0.4397605062,
1.1830137968,
0.1265812367,
0.6190927029,
-0.5851707458,
-0.0803447515,
-0.2329316437,
0.1308850497,
-0.0556352176,
-0.3736786842,
0.1276489049,
-0.0164390448,
-0.0118121104,
-0.2805455625,
0.5250654817,
-0.4380092621,
-0.3482481539,
-0.0775778219,
0.5130195022,
0.1154609248,
-0.3310771883,
-0.7631976008,
0.3656623363,
-0.0573681891,
-0.2401473522,
0.6730342507,
0.5366165638,
-0.1994972676,
0.4846634567,
0.559710443,
0.1509475112,
-0.0575694256,
0.1260795146,
0.8182156682,
-0.7525740266,
-0.3995669484,
-0.6485697031,
0.2494915873,
0.3178218901,
-0.1098603085,
0.5150705576,
0.3581039906,
0.8206475973,
0.0938346982,
0.5682414174,
0.2797601819,
0.5179659128,
-0.8645023108,
0.4570819139,
-0.7810204029,
0.2444580048,
-0.0969747975,
-0.9568548799,
-0.4965538085,
0.6342816949,
-0.2534847558,
0.1495889127,
0.6024851203,
0.5860626101,
-0.1123303622,
-0.4772918522,
0.6558155417,
0.2244252563,
0.0569192097,
0.9465582371,
0.6645276546,
-0.6419165134,
0.6226934195,
-0.3022984266,
-0.1028897837,
-0.2142471671,
-0.8618893027,
-0.8745588064,
-0.5216363668,
-0.4572345912,
0.056047678,
0.2015653253,
0.7236207724,
0.9105266333,
-0.6478818059,
-0.0534940884,
-0.1376610845,
-0.1648111641,
-0.277564168,
-0.1738260835,
0.5110639334,
-0.1246872842,
-0.9463519454,
0.4223048687,
0.2293126136,
0.0235098992,
-0.0331688076,
-0.2556076944,
0.1043046266,
-0.0690317005,
0.7512483001,
0.3176442683,
-0.7263227701,
-0.345250845,
-0.2456725985,
0.185405165,
0.1055770665,
0.6000285745,
-1.0350425243,
0.1683276147,
0.3734147847,
0.7876998782,
0.593136847,
0.141366303,
0.6535797715,
-0.7873433828,
0.2102697045,
0.2233043462,
0.2286257148,
0.2481414378,
-0.3621696234,
0.4356313646,
0.0214537829,
-0.7704102397,
-0.8939774036,
0.2120984495,
-1.1067200899,
-0.2518070936,
0.9363150597,
-0.0528610423,
-0.2615768015,
0.1470266879,
-0.2850664854,
0.4181456566,
-0.4205980599,
0.5336281657,
0.256495595,
-0.3179723024,
-0.8068103194,
-0.617410779,
0.6760288477,
0.5815111995,
-0.8852059841,
-0.0666882098,
0.351369679,
0.3040494621,
-0.4567388594,
0.6403630972,
0.1938078701,
0.310896188,
-0.3125927448,
0.1454108059,
0.0207623336,
0.0568261035,
-0.4057342112,
0.0875655189,
0.6744666696,
-0.0867334083
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04889v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04889v2
|
Detecting Generated Native Ads in Conversational Search
| 2024-02-07T14:22:51 | 2024-04-30T09:15:42 |
Sebastian Schmidt, Ines Zelch, Janek Bevendorff, Benno Stein, Matthias Hagen, Martin Potthast
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Conversational search engines such as YouChat and Microsoft Copilot use large
language models (LLMs) to generate responses to queries. It is only a small
step to also let the same technology insert ads within the generated responses
- instead of separately placing ads next to a response. Inserted ads would be
reminiscent of native advertising and product placement, both of which are very
effective forms of subtle and manipulative advertising. Considering the high
computational costs associated with LLMs, for which providers need to develop
sustainable business models, users of conversational search engines may very
well be confronted with generated native ads in the near future. In this paper,
we thus take a first step to investigate whether LLMs can also be used as a
countermeasure, i.e., to block generated native ads. We compile the Webis
Generated Native Ads 2024 dataset of queries and generated responses with
automatically inserted ads, and evaluate whether LLMs or fine-tuned sentence
transformers can detect the ads. In our experiments, the investigated LLMs
struggle with the task but sentence transformers achieve precision and recall
values above 0.9.
|
[
-0.3653788865,
-1.0192723274,
0.4198863506,
0.1325659156,
-0.2806954682,
0.33019045,
-0.1254001558,
-0.7151562572,
0.6308967471,
0.7698579431,
-0.5540988445,
-0.4282060862,
-0.1099882498,
-0.0033809317,
-0.5190208554,
0.7272196412,
0.4958212078,
-0.3049416542,
-0.4811460674,
0.1744485646,
-0.6446788311,
-0.6941612959,
-0.5865083337,
-0.0889243484,
0.1434101462,
0.2976466715,
0.6487678289,
0.2554669082,
0.3056328893,
0.352891326,
-0.0575111695,
0.3428707719,
-0.4238482416,
0.2915415764,
0.0345110819,
-0.5644259453,
-0.4340732694,
-0.0830933899,
0.3653334081,
0.4091163576,
-0.2675192356,
-0.2815100849,
-0.0251742657,
0.3112588525,
-0.4933351874,
-0.1393674463,
-1.2664637566,
-0.0100188032,
-0.2844773233,
-0.2486058772,
-0.5185666084,
-0.4350045323,
0.2566353381,
-0.4392310977,
0.4723257422,
-0.0303565748,
1.0587537289,
0.0403281078,
-0.594256103,
-0.5614161491,
-0.7990078926,
0.7380678654,
-1.0155413151,
0.2330712974,
0.2793038487,
0.2873247266,
-0.5226054192,
-0.8168528676,
-0.5109263062,
-0.1628783941,
-0.2632955611,
0.0368445031,
-0.6358059049,
0.021258533,
0.2234301269,
0.3213936388,
-0.8573890328,
0.3966033161,
-0.5400327444,
-0.4314671755,
0.8011032343,
0.1583073437,
0.4005121589,
-0.2206327319,
-0.5551970601,
0.2267750502,
-0.8193975091,
0.0267017875,
0.4516765177,
0.443497926,
0.1235997602,
0.5694740415,
-0.3235444725,
0.7597867846,
0.0516244918,
-0.0267113242,
-0.1520923674,
-0.3845641315,
-0.0196448937,
0.3741925657,
1.0025351048,
0.4107378125,
0.6998978853,
0.078920804,
-0.4233396053,
0.5317443013,
0.4576756954,
-0.5993376374,
-0.0407581441,
-0.0022794825,
-0.147380054,
-0.3167831302,
-0.1640616953,
-0.4901987612,
-0.318187952,
0.0743508786,
0.1504704505,
0.0155698536,
-0.0497602262,
0.3153803945,
0.2998788059,
0.1299161762,
-0.3598781526,
-0.8226456642,
0.6679083109,
0.5748890042,
0.6476489902,
-0.2094259411,
0.2028512657,
-0.7459277511,
-0.040991772,
-0.2559015155,
1.0408850908,
-0.4066052437,
-0.8277273178,
0.21480079,
-0.0133504085,
-0.2164631039,
-0.8374088407,
0.4351501167,
-0.842541039,
0.3677375317,
0.0567596406,
-0.4844380915,
-0.1663165689,
0.3574068546,
-0.630235672,
0.9518155456,
-0.3026228249,
-0.2200394124,
0.2016077787,
-0.7278478146,
-0.8598646522,
0.2532258034,
-0.0536477417,
-0.606677413,
0.0405338146,
0.560264647,
0.3613004386,
-0.0718313828,
0.3738925457,
-0.1960670948,
-0.3374764025,
0.5999705791,
-0.6413456202,
0.6002409458,
0.4068605304,
-0.315145731,
-0.0170512181,
-0.4144390225,
-0.3210556805,
0.4732678533,
-0.3598772585,
-0.3872671723,
0.323859185,
-0.11231222,
0.0642592907,
0.4806259573,
-0.7231822014,
0.106752269,
-0.5469173193,
0.4002938867,
0.6517195702,
0.1575497091,
0.1205893308,
-0.0423283875,
0.8498214483,
-0.1444022506,
-0.0439877138,
-0.3479628265,
-0.7472471595,
-0.5557048917,
-0.0417268015,
0.0654897615,
0.2367138267,
-0.4702146649,
0.311080426,
-0.3323577642,
-0.3876681328,
-0.3306799233,
0.3556561172,
0.2353056967,
0.5472328663,
0.0137833767,
-0.3080925941,
-0.5267208815,
-0.9417529702,
-0.3249296844,
0.0453845784,
-0.1533419788,
0.4996381402,
0.0968912765,
-0.0620818324,
1.1564400196,
-0.7161035538,
-0.3527058065,
-0.1511618942,
0.1306909323,
0.0901328325,
0.1404922605,
0.666482389,
-0.9843074679,
-0.5283116102,
-0.263571173,
-0.3933783174,
-0.4244947433,
-0.375954777,
0.3240233064,
0.4262548387,
0.7123647332,
-0.7276737094,
0.3059936464,
0.7318716645,
-0.304248631,
0.486595422,
-0.1557713747,
-0.2289705724,
-1.149877429,
-0.0075408691,
0.254470557,
-0.5392463803,
-0.4310037196,
-0.2141393125,
-0.1237938479,
-0.3786872029,
-0.5136668086,
0.3942815959,
-0.3052502871,
-0.2834762335,
-0.3287190795,
0.5458260179,
0.2795593441,
0.3871963024,
0.1375727654,
1.1589590311,
0.2040511072,
-0.8675664663,
0.11911235,
0.2482518852,
-0.5476101041,
0.543582499,
-1.0581357479,
0.2903865576,
0.2292781174,
0.4496487081,
-1.3430659771,
-0.0479064099,
-0.1532041132,
-0.5644335151,
-0.1568790376,
-0.015735181,
-0.6272267103,
-0.576358974,
-0.2390257567,
0.1753112525,
0.3280796409,
-0.5815779567,
0.4822755456,
0.3811981082,
-0.3662321568,
-0.1672738642,
-0.5627518296,
0.3057959378,
-0.2791319489,
-0.6598457098,
0.4894348383,
-0.0669675097,
-0.1030668616,
-0.0566800535,
0.2187762856,
0.2508319914,
0.3210338354,
-0.0195455533,
0.2807042003,
-0.3486639857,
-0.1157584488,
0.0063657966,
0.0235642344,
0.1253395975,
-0.132295385,
0.7631902695,
0.0471282825,
-0.5414681435,
-0.4884285033,
0.1469151825,
0.9193775654,
-0.6294734478,
0.2965648174,
0.4276948869,
-0.3415799141,
0.2086084783,
-0.6095281243,
-0.2505528629,
-0.6328415871,
0.2197500914,
-0.0758001506,
-0.7253756523,
0.5126224756,
0.0663110316,
0.0552047603,
0.3062613308,
0.5311284065,
0.0094009629,
1.7694399357,
0.2986931801,
-0.0708979219,
0.4615398347,
-0.1479999125,
0.45400545,
-0.7597504258,
-0.295234412,
-0.4416843951,
-0.5815597773,
-0.9940803051,
0.1511684954,
0.4736994505,
-0.1790451854,
0.168650642,
0.5144595504,
-0.4369239807,
0.337313652,
0.8635998964,
-0.0119047556,
0.2274750173,
0.2041246444,
-0.1146047488,
-0.1810217798,
-0.4580841362,
-0.4270896018,
0.9215862751,
0.0493149906,
0.7206766009,
0.1683500707,
0.3971886635,
0.4372026324,
0.0335393026,
-0.9998008013,
0.7432156205,
-0.2837981284,
-0.7423654795,
0.2386425883,
-0.084737584,
-1.4088187218,
0.0848800689,
-0.2282352895,
-0.9523825049,
-0.0414443873,
0.0630859733,
-0.5750430822,
0.3846695423,
-0.7500616908,
0.541801393,
-0.512242496,
-0.3358716369,
-0.2946216464,
-0.2074309886,
0.2369348556,
0.0459277928,
0.1004734784,
0.0743765458,
0.1664536148,
0.6423411369,
-0.1234715581,
1.056624651,
0.0189904477,
-0.2195249051,
0.6329731941,
0.3701789975,
0.7048383355,
-0.2089264542,
0.3220303357,
-0.1690137535,
-0.2380793393,
-0.5769942999,
-0.3951389492,
0.923517704,
-0.2054825574,
-0.798158586,
-0.1608910263,
-0.6701407433,
-0.1147807613,
0.3302147985,
0.3064405024,
0.3915213048,
-0.3970067501,
0.3066290617,
0.6341961622,
-0.4072504342,
0.4930239618,
0.7973791957,
-0.1937605441,
-0.2787979543,
1.0488278866,
-0.170253247,
0.236990124,
0.1052565426,
0.4184808135,
-0.6346680522,
-0.4866330028,
-0.2074913383,
0.2666224241,
-0.194410488,
-0.2566059232,
-0.594450593,
-0.1487738639,
-0.623301208,
-0.1881557703,
-0.3800288737,
-0.1940503865,
-0.2739374936,
0.0300845951,
0.281013459,
0.9463362694,
0.1266557127,
0.5502672195,
-0.797228694,
0.3189634383,
0.5173390508,
0.193910107,
-0.0211808104,
-0.1440421492,
-0.1787731946,
0.3574937582,
-0.7076381445,
-0.4771098793,
0.5387929678,
0.1108287796,
0.3817400336,
0.8126173019,
0.076086238,
0.3661347926,
-0.2428017855,
1.0746706724,
-0.0343821086,
-0.4785676897,
0.5777137876,
-0.5165048242,
0.3508189917,
0.0525955409,
0.2864120305,
-0.6121801734,
-0.249223426,
-0.5081012845,
-0.7546012998,
0.4680675864,
0.1509687752,
0.6407232285,
-0.2634339035,
-0.0345658623,
-0.220405966,
0.156792894,
-0.5970835686,
0.0177729968,
0.2509107292,
0.0284719504,
-0.037130937,
-0.346549809,
0.3408550024,
0.1654610634,
0.4374460876,
0.0208328255,
-0.05293734,
-0.0607826412,
-0.1990236938,
0.0320406109,
0.134000212,
0.8361509442,
0.0908027813,
-0.2706531882,
-0.0692009777,
-0.281237781,
-0.3396980762,
-0.2177691013,
0.0918916464,
-0.2806147635,
0.0180278979,
-0.0628336817,
0.4150830507,
0.2057203501,
-0.9741547108,
0.5456572175,
-0.1902769804,
-0.0381238833,
-0.3327327073,
-0.1735064536,
0.2151665539,
-0.065317601,
0.3138211668,
-0.0752483681,
0.235817343,
-0.4700020552,
0.1837685257,
0.9282392263,
-0.4157239795,
-0.5041692853,
0.861353755,
0.4876921773,
-0.7820442319,
0.7717660069,
-0.0445257649,
-0.9955374002,
0.6086940765,
0.917762816,
0.9360132813,
-0.266190052,
0.0016208387,
0.144064337,
0.2094861418,
0.2640475631,
0.0688714832,
-0.1126790121,
-0.8668996096,
-0.473218888,
-0.2195082903,
-0.3497703671,
0.5389385223,
-0.6240430474,
0.4162046909,
-0.2140896618,
-0.1093662307,
0.1412198693,
-0.0953962654,
-0.6434559822,
0.0379865617,
0.5720683336,
0.4786811769,
-0.755030036,
0.5089663863,
0.5971672535,
-0.1976377666,
-0.2306690067,
-0.0957317576,
0.2099200934,
-0.8301618695,
0.2437284589,
0.3404027522,
-0.5704587698,
-0.0027838605,
-0.7057805657,
-0.5681916475,
0.7519066334,
0.1660063267,
-0.5053392053,
0.0457279459,
0.3374965787,
0.5697327852,
-0.2620358169,
-0.101598762,
0.4903447032,
0.0131116873,
-0.1027887464,
-0.9572004676,
-0.0251124762,
-0.1662683636,
-0.0646418631,
0.0631014183,
-0.4739915431,
0.6304464936,
-0.02275878,
-0.4165208936,
0.2405924052,
0.2108739614,
0.239851132,
0.4357442856,
0.4766232371,
0.478976965,
0.3908123374,
0.1965605766,
1.1411662102,
-0.2237828672,
0.019795401,
0.8902417421,
-0.4650810361,
0.827960372,
0.3382112384,
-0.144961223,
0.7310515046,
0.5697099566,
0.0305349119,
0.2981185317,
0.1485202014,
-0.2905870974,
-0.3280959427,
-0.6771873832,
0.0876574218,
0.8012816906,
0.7564647198,
-0.2943661511,
-0.2714323699,
-0.0644821525,
0.1541569084,
0.6650189757,
0.0992287993,
0.8924248815,
-0.0642535463,
-0.8165758848,
0.7669157386,
-0.0861698538,
1.0515440702,
-0.6748464704,
0.0300989617,
-0.4995840788,
0.1727196574,
-0.0497418046,
-0.5042674541,
0.2359520942,
0.0727377832,
0.1439571232,
-0.0341235325,
0.8651713133,
-0.3096257448,
-0.5267509222,
0.1709404886,
0.3521936834,
0.1148029193,
-0.2385983318,
-0.6755704284,
-0.1810887605,
0.0951242,
-0.2412208617,
0.2134682238,
-0.0766271949,
-0.2608467937,
0.7574726939,
0.9805240631,
0.0871355683,
0.0650102645,
-0.0281161834,
0.6653160453,
-0.4345369041,
-0.6748508215,
-0.7305826545,
0.1496791691,
-0.1150050461,
0.0334086567,
0.6451147199,
0.7572993636,
0.9113368988,
0.2149012685,
0.7243560553,
0.3075487018,
0.3549685776,
-0.4400706291,
0.654687047,
-0.673386097,
0.6029244065,
-0.2059671134,
-0.853482604,
-0.1591684371,
0.1488123983,
-0.3968915343,
-0.1127514765,
0.2271871418,
1.0469747782,
-0.4007683098,
-0.1605307013,
0.3259458542,
-0.1052704006,
0.7391739488,
0.4728562832,
0.8566298485,
-0.3318360448,
1.0976022482,
-0.2523834109,
0.268710047,
-0.3916647732,
-0.6381266713,
-0.8207849264,
-0.3013888299,
-0.2564086616,
-0.267519176,
-0.3763373196,
0.6697836518,
0.5732522607,
-0.8950375319,
-0.4469353259,
-0.1649403274,
0.1376122534,
-0.1787126958,
-0.3331963718,
0.2482066154,
-0.1210276634,
-1.0855337381,
0.7550910711,
0.0170559082,
0.3707419634,
-0.4705811143,
0.1412474215,
-0.581879437,
0.3194370568,
0.5833960176,
0.3332620263,
-0.7460952401,
-0.0935169756,
0.5195644498,
-0.1652055234,
0.0979232565,
1.0286960602,
-1.0756599903,
0.8874887228,
0.2967067659,
0.5017561913,
0.5267691016,
0.1627512127,
0.8339300752,
-0.9271138906,
0.1498754472,
0.2874331176,
0.3103870749,
0.5960006118,
-0.4097769856,
0.2416538596,
0.1207289845,
-0.3231092095,
-0.7910174727,
0.4408916831,
-0.6416127086,
-0.199396506,
0.931163609,
0.1290248334,
0.0613210425,
-0.1203852594,
-0.2593009174,
-0.0945581943,
-0.4365547895,
0.880445838,
0.3020527959,
-0.0612438135,
0.3652842939,
-0.4478509724,
0.1863704771,
0.5917729139,
-0.4024173617,
-0.1266552806,
0.3683380783,
0.2584596276,
0.4089887142,
0.3990392685,
-0.1060463414,
0.2867644429,
-0.2071920782,
-0.0932841152,
-0.0248395689,
0.0799264088,
-0.2274996042,
-0.284486711,
0.1705232561,
-0.6043173075
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04875v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04875v3
|
On Provable Length and Compositional Generalization
| 2024-02-07T14:16:28 | 2024-06-07T20:25:05 |
Kartik Ahuja, Amin Mansouri
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
Out-of-distribution generalization capabilities of sequence-to-sequence
models can be studied from the lens of two crucial forms of generalization:
length generalization -- the ability to generalize to longer sequences than
ones seen during training, and compositional generalization: the ability to
generalize to token combinations not seen during training. In this work, we
provide first provable guarantees on length and compositional generalization
for common sequence-to-sequence models -- deep sets, transformers, state space
models, and recurrent neural nets -- trained to minimize the prediction error.
Taking a first principles perspective, we study the realizable case, i.e., the
labeling function is realizable on the architecture. We show that limited
capacity versions of these different architectures achieve both length and
compositional generalization. Across different architectures, we also find that
a linear relationship between the learned representation and the representation
in the labeling function is necessary for length and compositional
generalization.
|
[
-0.3492197692,
-0.3965278268,
0.7345143557,
0.1391475946,
-0.3681004643,
-0.102138862,
-0.2699069679,
-0.4714471102,
0.2246647179,
0.5500691533,
-0.5824751854,
-0.0867728367,
-0.5671229362,
-0.178900227,
-0.5761396289,
0.9584700465,
0.132445544,
-0.0803391188,
-0.3518424034,
-0.3804222047,
-0.455758512,
-0.6039125919,
-0.0657121092,
-0.2869005799,
0.6573147774,
0.0979847834,
1.0228130817,
0.7129946947,
0.6595150828,
0.2297949642,
-0.0070322687,
0.0852730498,
-0.3228556216,
0.0271495916,
-0.0322496705,
-0.700122118,
-0.2735311687,
-0.1567119062,
0.9662140012,
0.9107256532,
0.0138398092,
0.1274795532,
-0.1518523246,
0.8805795312,
-0.5864130259,
-0.0965296179,
-0.1821907014,
0.465657115,
0.1376051754,
0.1508139521,
-0.5418813229,
-0.2792997062,
0.5166670084,
-0.8556197286,
0.2131488174,
-0.1392847449,
0.5092284679,
0.2256079614,
-0.3171637058,
-0.1021408215,
-1.136097312,
0.9211685061,
-0.5085023046,
0.5419850349,
0.138767004,
0.6211946607,
0.0319795199,
-0.9500755668,
-0.4189825356,
-0.4475340545,
-0.5138169527,
0.0303095654,
-0.0519309938,
0.3153224587,
0.2202579528,
0.6185584664,
-0.7251554728,
0.1392922997,
-0.3830666542,
-0.1341156363,
0.5528561473,
0.086231485,
0.1230537295,
0.3282855153,
-0.315549314,
-0.1519947052,
-0.7480818629,
-0.1350826025,
0.3741509914,
-0.2138604373,
-0.0965006277,
0.6600646377,
0.0312533118,
0.7365688682,
-0.0930797979,
0.2821280658,
-0.0864264369,
-0.3267534971,
-0.3582367897,
-0.1728253067,
0.4605223238,
-0.2704453766,
0.2651436627,
-0.561365366,
-0.1269098371,
-0.044360619,
0.3739242256,
-0.6668698192,
0.0128470995,
0.1485881805,
-0.681321919,
0.0446118154,
0.4549786448,
-0.2094969302,
-0.1562449932,
-0.5563282371,
0.58320719,
-0.2934228182,
-0.1450048089,
0.315859884,
-0.1577814817,
0.0026260985,
-0.3944480419,
-1.1717588902,
0.4519165456,
0.9095560908,
0.8853700757,
0.1066138372,
-0.1113096625,
-0.1425391734,
0.1301508993,
-0.4158553481,
0.2449258417,
-0.3644427061,
-0.3517035842,
0.0010918255,
-0.2216498703,
0.0055466718,
-0.5385046005,
0.0761961117,
-0.7391436696,
-0.2004120648,
-0.2152298242,
-0.9720805883,
-0.1754124165,
-0.1040284932,
-0.7875342965,
0.2046133578,
0.3339694738,
-0.6596013308,
0.3685828745,
-0.5286120176,
-0.7088041306,
-0.1811831295,
-0.1169514135,
-0.5664104819,
0.5409681797,
-0.3240999281,
0.4000426233,
0.0253694914,
0.4898222685,
-0.2799779773,
-0.4712767303,
0.4979158342,
-0.4142655432,
0.2830384374,
0.4676727355,
-0.0218543112,
0.119442068,
-0.9680351615,
-0.0658405349,
0.0306565687,
-0.7612633109,
0.0351345949,
0.2982062399,
-0.3853518367,
-0.2001254857,
0.3579242527,
-0.4499761462,
0.234523952,
-0.743139565,
0.6087580919,
0.4989884496,
0.0284955278,
1.0003755093,
-0.308193773,
0.4902660847,
0.1523473859,
0.3496804237,
-0.3728852272,
-0.3114649355,
-0.7110055089,
-0.2348959446,
0.4890170991,
0.6106241941,
-0.5169429183,
0.5709765553,
-0.3905348778,
-0.4940959215,
0.0418986566,
-0.1210276932,
0.6036770344,
0.2993750274,
0.3612131774,
-0.2575052083,
-0.7441325784,
-1.1434810162,
-0.1698773652,
-0.041290231,
-0.2738214433,
-0.0648176,
0.2940217257,
-0.2297591865,
1.2989919186,
-0.7466933727,
-0.0103255659,
-0.3356570005,
-0.1350878179,
0.4927087426,
0.5886255503,
0.4529710412,
-0.6462842822,
-0.2066892982,
-0.0763251558,
-0.6786429882,
0.4261471033,
-0.1222118884,
-0.047861468,
-0.1518972218,
0.1705166847,
-0.4680518508,
0.5701372623,
0.4781783521,
-0.0602730885,
0.227051571,
-0.6329742074,
-0.4743060768,
-0.9628733397,
-0.1925286055,
0.1564818472,
-0.1646724939,
-0.9653834105,
-0.0719340071,
-0.1540339738,
-0.1001528949,
-0.3733606935,
0.4103856981,
-0.1365988553,
-0.5762219429,
0.0187977403,
-0.4453518093,
0.1056452543,
0.3506835401,
0.2736341357,
0.5696386099,
0.5856025219,
-0.9496370554,
0.1246303916,
0.2564275265,
-0.5294627547,
0.1735392511,
-0.87127918,
-0.2280407697,
-0.2613574564,
0.4334085286,
-0.7769581079,
-0.1648890078,
0.2919270396,
-0.2355758548,
0.3565368652,
-0.1137770861,
-0.2199220061,
-0.3258510232,
0.1305626035,
0.6791136861,
0.6293339133,
-0.4175059199,
0.5516617894,
-0.0143444613,
0.4220958948,
-0.7816879749,
-0.9576802254,
-0.4661360681,
-0.1210280508,
-0.7631406784,
0.5626449585,
-0.2103876621,
-0.1356151104,
-0.3333066404,
-0.048072163,
-0.2319431603,
0.0291804541,
0.2016011328,
0.0157556925,
-0.2742086351,
0.3596332073,
0.0134222396,
-0.1289778799,
-0.1368719637,
-0.6618483067,
0.5006638169,
-0.0507616773,
-0.4582325816,
-0.1952679902,
0.4249844849,
0.1809494048,
-0.1649174541,
0.7949722409,
0.4837517142,
-0.2865413725,
-0.1760426164,
-0.1418168843,
-0.4070545435,
-0.4632378817,
0.4515446424,
-0.2503446043,
-0.885240972,
0.770930171,
0.2203678936,
0.0137472693,
0.2437908649,
0.0272361711,
-0.0931895748,
0.7706090808,
0.439907372,
-0.0974669904,
0.5399987698,
-0.7722782493,
0.4583984911,
-0.6223429441,
-0.1841927767,
-0.0304449406,
-0.6869292259,
-0.5546889305,
-0.261457175,
0.3557047546,
0.0147308065,
-0.367426753,
0.4677169621,
-0.5635475516,
0.7337719798,
0.8405176401,
0.3158682287,
-0.1894335449,
0.0784140527,
0.0368189327,
0.0596170425,
-0.6460385323,
-0.1048045754,
1.1223523617,
0.5269616246,
0.4218283892,
0.2272324413,
0.8805147409,
0.4436536729,
0.0515521616,
-0.9037796855,
0.5475819707,
-0.6498737931,
-0.637558341,
-0.3929199278,
-0.1987163723,
-0.9404663444,
0.0883421525,
-0.0987679139,
-0.3563401699,
0.6190524101,
0.3431533277,
-0.4261865914,
0.2842817605,
-0.4919452965,
0.566632688,
-0.1534279585,
0.1084709689,
-0.2522259057,
-0.8704134226,
0.4292514026,
0.1959282309,
-0.0312146489,
0.2080813497,
0.1339828074,
0.5394220352,
-0.641459167,
0.9056868553,
-0.1042150408,
0.0775933862,
0.6100133061,
0.184852615,
0.2964586318,
0.1514513642,
0.3112483919,
0.1608788818,
-0.1392715126,
-0.3935685754,
-0.5216571689,
0.2592129111,
-0.8037893772,
-0.4822281301,
0.018127948,
-0.2621634901,
-0.1938210428,
-0.0458662435,
0.7344634533,
0.6261687279,
-0.2972554862,
0.2299932837,
0.964700222,
-0.1113280877,
0.6507205367,
-0.019155845,
0.0051604914,
-0.5580545664,
0.9311825633,
0.2949531078,
0.4610546529,
0.7390698195,
0.370754391,
-0.571888268,
-0.4965631664,
-0.0270462614,
0.0583137423,
-0.9914106131,
-0.0635462999,
-0.3291679323,
-0.4645766616,
-0.1905411482,
-0.2349914312,
-0.3643655479,
-0.7741392851,
-0.6621849537,
-0.3559286296,
-0.0692329109,
0.9295547605,
-0.3395862579,
0.5807974339,
-0.8274275661,
0.3384954333,
0.6351807714,
0.3062583506,
0.0291535947,
-0.690405786,
-0.4637480676,
-0.0019250039,
-0.3828578591,
-0.7711833715,
0.0750482902,
0.4735789895,
0.4300862849,
0.6509570479,
-0.2502456307,
0.306861639,
-0.3853860199,
0.7084576488,
0.4776328802,
-0.8207674026,
0.381782949,
-0.2091106921,
0.0238645393,
0.1942953467,
0.330334872,
-0.4713709056,
0.106407918,
-0.5602473021,
-0.6928988695,
0.2999506295,
0.0748102739,
0.4472477734,
-0.1930435151,
0.5493488312,
0.1446925253,
0.2026233673,
-0.6052894592,
-0.3201601207,
-0.4866112173,
-0.2368866205,
-0.2361283749,
-0.4815402031,
-0.0454097502,
-0.0532104596,
0.4141622186,
-0.0260030255,
0.4127783477,
0.2352516949,
-0.0928866118,
0.3374551833,
0.4446292818,
1.0529509783,
1.0070639849,
-0.1475796551,
0.0683121309,
-0.1607394814,
-0.2787408531,
0.5691533685,
-0.1511166394,
-0.150272131,
-0.0412706286,
0.5585250258,
1.0013881922,
0.2681978047,
-0.4096955955,
0.4885818064,
0.4037361443,
-0.2763706744,
-0.3760505915,
0.1521367878,
0.1899401844,
0.3047380149,
0.1078163385,
0.0973497406,
0.3314169645,
-0.3464348614,
0.2342739403,
0.1897564232,
-0.270372957,
-0.5952020884,
0.5274071693,
-0.1226327494,
-0.142620787,
0.6309679151,
-0.1078528836,
-0.2518263459,
0.9057916403,
0.5443925858,
0.8922235966,
0.0737793893,
0.4613342285,
0.3498696983,
-0.1264831573,
-0.3396691382,
0.0226655882,
-0.2268678844,
-0.8662452698,
-0.2474987805,
-0.5770856142,
-0.2848599255,
-0.1047575399,
-0.6564257145,
-0.0733525604,
-0.8067131042,
-0.4335002601,
-0.1023611724,
-0.4001474977,
-0.5404025912,
0.3157068789,
0.126359418,
0.7000250816,
-0.6893892884,
0.5654456019,
0.4037100673,
-0.3935340941,
-0.7113457322,
-0.4216997325,
-0.5178964138,
-0.6805817485,
0.9436353445,
0.1286753863,
0.3561784923,
-0.0927091464,
-0.3897816241,
-0.813087225,
1.2616813183,
0.4604465663,
-0.9267368913,
-0.040896561,
0.6448833346,
0.5133280754,
-0.5469296575,
-0.1270870864,
0.7716926932,
0.434730351,
0.3276552558,
-0.4972665906,
-0.3729904592,
0.3937859833,
0.3966048658,
0.1483717412,
-0.5426981449,
0.8115447164,
-0.3068006039,
-0.1733159125,
0.2414676696,
0.77429533,
0.2892223001,
0.3807480931,
0.2337596714,
0.9585401416,
0.4549950063,
-0.1576768458,
1.1516081095,
-0.0832778811,
0.1585151553,
1.1239752769,
0.0617641583,
0.6493343711,
0.2905276716,
-0.4909251332,
0.3126629591,
0.6813898087,
-0.071018666,
0.8322868943,
0.6592047215,
-0.4843954444,
-0.1420453489,
0.1371555626,
-0.3376314342,
0.1504148692,
0.1876873225,
-0.848061204,
0.2651879787,
0.0306484606,
-0.2116103917,
0.073899731,
-0.3254925609,
0.8534122705,
0.1410732865,
-0.7332434058,
0.4700489342,
-0.0804678723,
0.5382980704,
-0.6132007837,
0.1929451525,
-0.2833122313,
0.2482970953,
-0.0203538295,
-0.7644716501,
0.3905497193,
-0.7574185729,
-0.6540263891,
0.1954293102,
0.6824839711,
-0.2878500223,
-0.3829336762,
0.0345892943,
-0.0343449414,
-0.2710965574,
-0.0344824605,
-0.2060692012,
-0.2551548183,
-0.275728792,
-0.2372364551,
0.3924980164,
-0.1609693617,
-0.0327695869,
0.6688076258,
0.4081665277,
-0.0108456491,
0.6848521829,
0.018076444,
0.729562819,
-0.3211466372,
-0.5768131614,
-0.9257490039,
0.6123456359,
0.1782419831,
-0.0388706774,
-0.2460038662,
0.482996285,
0.7926941514,
-0.7453950644,
0.8421484232,
0.1528478861,
0.0496147759,
-0.5386590958,
0.3257281482,
-0.3290979564,
0.0975208879,
0.4981780946,
-1.236695528,
-0.412294209,
0.4626761377,
-0.1813636273,
-0.0805963576,
0.4615039527,
0.5284035802,
-0.0935557932,
-0.1702324897,
0.5397729278,
-0.2620441318,
0.3432098031,
0.6765910983,
0.6997669339,
-0.3856840432,
0.3419991136,
-0.2069821656,
0.1077670678,
-0.1050891802,
-0.7434068918,
-0.6747735739,
-0.7087260485,
-0.0807081088,
-0.1471279562,
-0.04526788,
0.336486429,
1.0313045979,
-0.7126877904,
0.0165729169,
-0.4724753499,
0.0620224252,
-0.1260538399,
-0.1727995574,
0.1546445191,
-0.2399349958,
-0.280081898,
0.3355222046,
0.3230285645,
0.4858606756,
-0.3571593165,
-0.4324657917,
0.2323341072,
0.4568346143,
0.5350272059,
0.6306444407,
-0.677577734,
-0.3428969979,
-0.142222777,
0.3656239808,
0.1464885026,
1.0838750601,
-0.5039211512,
0.3018108606,
0.7660298347,
0.6949613094,
0.2580849528,
-0.1043962613,
0.5353139639,
-1.1757534742,
0.2004005462,
0.1588852555,
0.5410811901,
0.051160112,
-0.4090149999,
0.6514800191,
0.1749740839,
-0.5880377889,
-0.3819319606,
0.9615395665,
-0.8134256005,
-0.2939540446,
0.7713209987,
-0.5237968564,
0.0595667325,
0.4109911323,
0.1750909835,
0.4287559688,
0.1008365899,
0.3766852915,
0.7095354199,
-0.0372044742,
-0.0225252043,
-0.0256194603,
0.4314530492,
0.2388495356,
-0.611700356,
-0.1526243836,
0.4171000719,
0.279861331,
0.3506523073,
0.4233230054,
0.1847547293,
0.2216107845,
-0.2543373704,
-0.4154980779,
-0.2198003083,
-0.5968544483,
-0.3087219298,
0.067394115,
0.0161728598,
-0.3562132418
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04858v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04858v2
|
CodeIt: Self-Improving Language Models with Prioritized Hindsight Replay
| 2024-02-07T13:55:27 | 2024-07-01T10:03:33 |
Natasha Butt, Blazej Manczak, Auke Wiggers, Corrado Rainone, David W. Zhang, Michaël Defferrard, Taco Cohen
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models are increasingly solving tasks that are commonly
believed to require human-level reasoning ability. However, these models still
perform very poorly on benchmarks of general intelligence such as the
Abstraction and Reasoning Corpus (ARC). In this paper, we approach ARC as a
programming-by-examples problem, and introduce a novel and scalable method for
language model self-improvement called Code Iteration (CodeIt). Our method
iterates between 1) program sampling and hindsight relabeling, and 2) learning
from prioritized experience replay. By relabeling the goal of an episode (i.e.,
the target program output given input) to the realized output produced by the
sampled program, our method effectively deals with the extreme sparsity of
rewards in program synthesis. Applying CodeIt to the ARC dataset, we
demonstrate that prioritized hindsight replay, along with pre-training and
data-augmentation, leads to successful inter-task generalization. CodeIt is the
first neuro-symbolic approach that scales to the full ARC evaluation dataset.
Our method solves 15% of ARC evaluation tasks, achieving state-of-the-art
performance and outperforming existing neural and symbolic baselines. Our code
is available at https://github.com/Qualcomm-AI-research/codeit .
|
[
-0.2116191834,
-0.5849454999,
0.4888707399,
0.4213738739,
0.1080939025,
0.3936977684,
-0.4302217364,
-0.0335728489,
0.2820994854,
0.4536547959,
-0.4347843528,
-0.5228860378,
-0.5066819191,
-0.0995659381,
-0.4607224464,
0.964989841,
-0.0321354903,
-0.1362882107,
-0.1245635226,
-0.2064456642,
-0.8364582062,
-0.7551622987,
-0.5595569611,
-0.3137043715,
0.3742484152,
0.8022537231,
0.4459836185,
0.4105438292,
0.4964453578,
0.2962200046,
0.5185970664,
-0.1464552134,
-0.6038244963,
0.0717990324,
-0.1065985784,
-0.427058816,
-0.3702560961,
-0.0185003765,
0.5515863299,
0.5990403295,
-0.1675612628,
0.1063266695,
-0.079349868,
0.5900514126,
-0.6689460874,
0.1331012845,
-0.4459420741,
-0.1678759456,
0.2832022905,
-0.2374181449,
-0.4143884778,
-0.4648604989,
-0.0970525518,
-0.5551895499,
0.0596276745,
0.1167422235,
0.6144832373,
0.4114508927,
0.1455992311,
-0.019333275,
-0.7916216254,
0.857413888,
-0.7717084885,
0.1649350226,
0.3880783319,
0.267531991,
0.0222474132,
-0.9452175498,
-0.4276528656,
-0.3734770417,
0.0376166701,
-0.055288706,
-0.5131398439,
0.0863502473,
0.2820321023,
0.4047547579,
-0.5930390954,
-0.1048131511,
-0.4360407591,
-0.2936231494,
0.5736464262,
0.1162134036,
0.3076533079,
0.2932455242,
-0.016308289,
-0.3500200808,
-0.6221554875,
-0.1006849781,
0.165536806,
-0.0163261425,
0.2287106961,
0.4000258446,
-0.4544516802,
0.4381411672,
0.1049279273,
0.4523076415,
0.5851017237,
-0.3889901042,
-0.122799933,
-0.0689760819,
0.4544735253,
0.1885290891,
0.3916982412,
-0.4129024148,
-0.2955769002,
0.3912867606,
0.6375052333,
-0.6582715511,
-0.574895978,
0.3219325542,
-0.2901970446,
-0.1905906945,
-0.4214634299,
-0.5752440691,
-0.0535046048,
-0.4441428781,
0.485075891,
-0.5699096322,
-0.4538005888,
0.1634496897,
0.1030670702,
0.0385800414,
0.1743279397,
-0.7601763606,
0.3287100494,
0.8184053898,
0.5883472562,
-0.2348984927,
-0.7509788275,
-0.5728068352,
-0.2309776396,
-0.6447437406,
0.8508743644,
-0.6547877789,
-0.1351206601,
-0.3158963323,
-0.3875587583,
-0.0614615791,
-0.6864590049,
0.2514593601,
-0.2533144355,
-0.1162762344,
0.132807076,
-0.5051805377,
-0.1497271657,
0.2621841729,
-0.3714787662,
1.1617970467,
0.0307604689,
-0.4841941595,
0.3342513144,
-0.7545407414,
-0.374312073,
-0.1188980266,
-0.3144983351,
-0.3283000886,
0.3934082091,
0.3853485286,
0.4090035856,
-0.1173283085,
0.736946106,
-0.137898013,
-0.601832211,
-0.1971991807,
-0.3388780653,
-0.0154862851,
0.1534051895,
-0.6641641259,
0.5574912429,
-0.7536225319,
0.4182687402,
0.0427888893,
-0.1191669926,
-0.3741006851,
-0.0053612585,
-0.2175220847,
0.192719385,
0.0406825542,
-0.2577702105,
0.3158093095,
-0.7635297775,
0.563244462,
0.7604904771,
-0.0228911415,
0.6536494493,
-0.3377445042,
0.5775468946,
-0.1159748882,
0.0896093473,
-0.3491456509,
-0.3528491855,
-0.9257691503,
0.0196952783,
0.246715501,
0.4146827757,
-0.6881673336,
0.1993605047,
-0.389534086,
-0.4584782124,
-0.4159985185,
-0.0641339347,
0.6693776846,
0.291344285,
0.5878462791,
-0.462970674,
-0.4556377232,
-0.9848288298,
-0.286664784,
-0.3176307082,
-0.0849739835,
0.2551715374,
0.420163691,
-0.3027415276,
0.993830204,
-0.41426301,
0.0095402086,
-0.3651816547,
0.5965787768,
0.3889194131,
0.7573280931,
0.1735772491,
-0.5406461358,
0.0434961431,
-0.2306679934,
-0.6618495584,
-0.0406215005,
-0.3291695714,
-0.12667723,
-0.0603527948,
0.6460532546,
0.00867448,
0.5305873752,
0.4594449103,
-0.3915400803,
0.6692456007,
-0.3981525004,
0.3704384863,
-0.6382037997,
0.1739973873,
-0.3748823404,
-0.0268038232,
-0.4917781353,
0.1950270981,
0.0418877155,
-0.183910355,
-0.2154482603,
0.5914281607,
-0.4068702459,
-0.2046009004,
-0.4356411099,
-0.2193367183,
-0.3107307255,
1.0577731133,
0.1657377034,
0.9023332596,
0.5851182342,
-0.5965027213,
0.0776468366,
-0.1777310669,
-0.2741943896,
0.1414215416,
-0.7348121405,
0.3480273783,
0.0259783864,
-0.1373898089,
-1.1191563606,
0.2219382375,
0.1612330675,
-0.4795269072,
0.1695705056,
0.0577982366,
-0.1118164808,
-0.3678411841,
-0.0095492946,
0.7563175559,
0.565964818,
-0.4640004635,
0.8253073692,
0.2273222357,
-0.1967492402,
-0.7991630435,
-0.4682831466,
0.2799327374,
-0.0917595476,
-0.3377663493,
0.1521369815,
-0.2935317457,
-0.1744662374,
-0.0889600888,
-0.3671344221,
-0.1159131974,
-0.021348983,
0.4119175375,
-0.0140996426,
-0.2252227515,
0.2846289873,
0.1364643276,
-0.3738504648,
0.1475844532,
-0.4388182163,
0.6302843094,
-0.5161953568,
-0.3065685034,
-0.2225915194,
0.3398734927,
0.2519025803,
-0.3248961568,
0.0492821336,
0.2666492462,
-0.2667112052,
-0.3027666509,
-0.7991557121,
-0.4635108411,
-0.4348247945,
0.5825990438,
-0.5799179077,
-0.9090559483,
0.2254636586,
-0.407617867,
0.2146915197,
0.1961165965,
0.4089030921,
0.0825208649,
0.8597784042,
0.784268558,
-0.4766174257,
0.4239648879,
-0.577585578,
0.1812586933,
-0.4573793113,
0.1286049634,
-0.3433195651,
-0.3585879207,
0.0106503461,
-0.5580522418,
0.0233642217,
0.2432337999,
-0.4815250635,
0.4386190772,
-0.7000297904,
0.5579336882,
0.8702147007,
0.0925230384,
0.4111587703,
-0.055416096,
-0.2250103205,
-0.0639924705,
-0.9685500264,
-0.3492713571,
1.1958925724,
0.1790933758,
0.7745932937,
-0.3836535513,
1.0672608614,
0.5199367404,
0.6161821485,
-0.4406384826,
0.5737397671,
0.1607412249,
-0.2250936031,
-0.4615251422,
-0.3792491257,
-0.7635160089,
0.024277892,
0.0481759124,
-0.6220645905,
0.3275476992,
0.4394871294,
-0.3325744867,
-0.0115578994,
-0.8748505712,
1.1464825869,
-0.1783342212,
-0.2992694378,
-0.8247582316,
-0.5000086427,
0.2038186491,
0.0094515458,
0.1937749833,
-0.0939581543,
0.1697125733,
0.5539360642,
-0.3863282502,
0.8123778701,
-0.0206375103,
0.2569585145,
0.2710611522,
0.3218821883,
0.3782311678,
0.1427800059,
0.168674469,
0.4180191159,
-0.2439087629,
-0.4271234572,
-0.8421831131,
0.6516151428,
-0.6387434006,
-0.7877111435,
-0.3679226339,
-0.5092079639,
-0.2048763782,
0.1002163514,
0.0384256765,
0.6465173364,
-0.2498434633,
-0.0432543643,
0.3565193415,
-0.3992301822,
0.5253706574,
0.1441705674,
-0.2613304555,
-0.4136086404,
1.0816627741,
-0.2374375015,
0.2427141815,
0.2741322517,
0.0682434738,
-0.083768867,
-0.5866869092,
-0.2971430719,
0.1387965381,
-0.6977299452,
-0.2459947169,
-0.5924906135,
-0.0958842039,
-0.2265197486,
-0.3184600472,
-0.6382805705,
-0.399281472,
0.2093368918,
-0.0611734092,
0.1852560043,
0.602801919,
-0.217360422,
0.1392106712,
-0.3556602895,
0.3221684396,
0.2664644122,
0.466252476,
0.1223653182,
-0.2886807323,
-0.2638638914,
-0.01550081,
-0.0711206347,
-0.466378659,
0.3581902981,
0.1047152802,
0.5585954189,
-0.1198778749,
0.0543626994,
0.7489655018,
-0.6029515862,
0.4137689173,
0.2076966316,
-1.0710227489,
0.6970564723,
-0.0339382887,
0.4472743571,
0.7768871188,
-0.001532895,
-0.5214692354,
-0.699727118,
-0.6571489573,
-0.9990349412,
0.5461547971,
0.3032528758,
0.1350401789,
-0.127294302,
0.3584192991,
-0.1533390135,
0.1389538348,
-0.5660228729,
-0.1591581106,
-0.4360679388,
-0.1784454435,
-0.2212099731,
-0.1098793373,
0.0267141201,
-0.3347405195,
0.5466272235,
-0.3894875646,
0.5352779031,
0.33253479,
-0.2646720707,
0.3284356296,
0.2394007444,
0.5650761127,
0.9153513312,
0.094651401,
-0.0825390294,
0.1469797343,
-0.419368118,
0.2572822869,
-0.1480277032,
0.1251055002,
-0.1540064365,
0.3006603718,
0.6242260933,
0.6369969249,
-0.9527037144,
0.5552578568,
-0.2618921399,
-0.0967469439,
-0.3707786202,
0.183739692,
-0.0395846888,
0.4308757484,
0.4411589205,
0.2516686618,
0.2935582995,
-0.4520143569,
0.5845894814,
-0.0131923147,
-0.1807291657,
-0.0872980356,
0.8241761327,
0.0252336953,
-0.3509676754,
0.739146769,
-0.1239189878,
-0.3236540854,
0.8331628442,
0.4128190279,
1.0135873556,
-0.1648714542,
0.2095730007,
0.6754543781,
0.1539179683,
-0.2431726903,
0.3845128417,
-0.21916987,
-0.764082551,
-0.6919885278,
-0.3816708624,
-0.3006640673,
-0.2281596363,
-0.3927024603,
0.0804577544,
-0.5043127537,
0.025462877,
-0.2234043479,
-0.2656448781,
-0.5407222509,
0.2995976508,
-0.1923532784,
0.8253234625,
-0.5728614926,
1.1453715563,
0.3814347982,
-0.6329727173,
-1.0917434692,
0.0260254554,
-0.5211752653,
-0.9517349601,
0.7243173122,
0.0720108226,
-0.0896242037,
0.2694836855,
-0.4889058769,
-0.9592248201,
0.7297545075,
0.3691209853,
-0.7350841761,
-0.2312442213,
-0.1762428731,
0.6141353846,
-0.5123156309,
0.5073644519,
0.6137187481,
0.3969522417,
-0.024838483,
-0.7333755493,
-0.074811399,
-0.5069209933,
0.0555647276,
0.2247549742,
-0.3387946486,
0.4551229775,
-0.4444690645,
-0.0390717871,
0.1786639988,
0.7570459843,
0.2544510663,
0.3893062472,
0.4465569854,
0.5713602901,
0.4065769613,
-0.2139965594,
1.0581495762,
-0.4654299915,
0.2634827793,
1.4532546997,
0.0303593352,
0.7876916528,
0.4046668112,
0.0619249195,
0.5008636117,
0.3727432787,
0.0143755497,
0.5034818053,
0.4345404208,
0.174560219,
-0.3622887135,
0.3652115762,
-0.3967795372,
0.4286029935,
0.1549115777,
-0.2671539485,
-0.1593163162,
0.246941492,
-0.1151961237,
0.3487859368,
-0.3600118458,
0.7534780502,
-0.1672772169,
-0.853254199,
0.8455525041,
-0.2148515284,
0.7212895155,
-0.5404101014,
-0.4196108282,
-0.5277762413,
0.3939109445,
0.0627291352,
-0.4960452616,
0.5207569599,
-0.2150398344,
-0.0757049248,
-0.2600314319,
0.4587422907,
-0.3330095708,
-0.4570775032,
0.4044722319,
0.4203214943,
0.2651318312,
-0.2600823045,
-0.6489456892,
0.0569024123,
-0.0743008852,
-0.2170311809,
0.194104284,
0.0793840587,
-0.2300112396,
0.8963699937,
0.4369499683,
-0.005550677,
0.1708862931,
0.1785179377,
0.9639245272,
-0.8228748441,
-0.575678885,
-0.6445762515,
0.4359422028,
-0.0987563059,
-0.5610870719,
0.5160303712,
0.7183533311,
1.041904211,
-0.0645645112,
0.6670485139,
0.0143769355,
0.3971085846,
-0.307064414,
0.517247498,
-0.4055785537,
0.2290182859,
-0.5297704339,
-0.775724411,
-0.3722987175,
0.6711444259,
-0.5202829838,
0.0035083217,
0.7577652335,
0.8914170265,
0.0789233521,
-0.0467839614,
0.4888944924,
0.2304097116,
0.1330590993,
0.9770295024,
0.8402779698,
-0.3877855241,
0.5654439926,
-0.2750575244,
-0.3304083645,
0.1293313801,
-0.6818290949,
-0.6262269616,
-0.6331832409,
-0.4290441573,
-0.1681250185,
0.4384889007,
0.8125095367,
0.8743598461,
-0.9477465153,
-0.4082668722,
-0.4722794592,
0.1641977429,
-0.7043411136,
-0.1944520772,
0.2978629768,
-0.6916434765,
-0.6821935177,
0.5105353594,
0.4872530401,
-0.5503784418,
-0.0251619127,
-0.2732235491,
-0.0974428132,
-0.1335689723,
0.3728323877,
0.6000948548,
-0.724123776,
-0.4131567776,
-0.0095618023,
0.1551163495,
0.3415502608,
1.2488723993,
-1.2518966198,
0.4634976983,
0.2127726078,
1.0093433857,
0.58398211,
-0.0630109608,
0.9235737324,
-0.5337609053,
0.0485856161,
0.5226821899,
0.3056427538,
-0.1328442693,
-0.2664821744,
0.8190950751,
0.1537903696,
-0.6517674327,
-0.6467434764,
0.1575786471,
-0.5500520468,
-0.4011824131,
0.8552433848,
-0.1737284064,
0.0368986465,
-0.1348702908,
-0.2653193176,
-0.0389040336,
-0.4695499837,
0.8455031514,
0.5095006227,
-0.1727983952,
-0.3713377714,
-0.2670826912,
0.3644076884,
0.7351132631,
-0.7288805246,
0.1933748424,
0.6769221425,
0.327745527,
0.0682415962,
0.9883031249,
0.0088647557,
0.5343116522,
0.0623589717,
0.408387512,
-0.0859781802,
-0.7470131516,
-0.4701683521,
0.1495314837,
0.1242802441,
-0.1042131856
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04854v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04854v4
|
Hierarchical Tree-structured Knowledge Graph For Academic Insight Survey
| 2024-02-07T13:54:06 | 2024-07-03T01:34:52 |
Jinghong Li, Huy Phan, Wen Gu, Koichi Ota, Shinobu Hasegawa
|
cs.DL
|
cs.DL, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Research surveys have always posed a challenge for beginner researchers who
lack of research training. These researchers struggle to understand the
directions within their research topic, and the discovery of new research
findings within a short time. One way to provide intuitive assistance to
beginner researchers is by offering relevant knowledge graphs(KG) and
recommending related academic papers. However, existing navigation knowledge
graphs primarily rely on keywords in the research field and often fail to
present the logical hierarchy among multiple related papers clearly. Moreover,
most recommendation systems for academic papers simply rely on high text
similarity, which can leave researchers confused as to why a particular article
is being recommended. They may lack of grasp important information about the
insight connection between "Issue resolved" and "Issue finding" that they hope
to obtain. To address these issues, this study aims to support research insight
surveys for beginner researchers by establishing a hierarchical tree-structured
knowledge graph that reflects the inheritance insight of research topics and
the relevance insight among the academic papers.
|
[
-0.3202967942,
-0.5504339933,
0.7021387815,
0.0672087297,
-0.1647776961,
0.5148803592,
0.3633855879,
-0.3656216264,
0.4294563532,
-0.0495786257,
-0.6413097978,
-0.7272356153,
-0.5250263214,
-0.0446616709,
-0.1296199858,
1.3568918705,
0.0234682206,
-0.2865445018,
-0.718554914,
-0.1344168335,
-0.0830770805,
-0.1908497065,
-0.9740871191,
-0.403942138,
0.9337047338,
0.5195487738,
0.4968276918,
0.5042204261,
0.5778074265,
0.2049670219,
-0.401049614,
0.1811625659,
-0.7614527345,
0.1372357607,
-0.0586916767,
-0.3744812012,
-0.5874074697,
-0.1599136442,
0.4325118363,
1.1909110546,
0.2230895907,
0.2888458371,
0.4593366385,
0.9048179984,
-0.6167744994,
0.5147369504,
-0.443867594,
0.2099620998,
-0.3399808705,
-0.6870145798,
-0.2103285193,
-0.508820951,
0.3817668855,
-1.1486700773,
0.2717279196,
0.2166431397,
0.6604055762,
-0.1416766047,
-0.6135714054,
-0.2292202562,
-0.5599498749,
0.3640237451,
-0.3864340484,
0.0583088696,
0.4291493595,
0.3131429255,
0.0124816084,
-0.7717428207,
0.0186960474,
0.1183061749,
-0.5480095744,
0.2704140246,
-0.2047789842,
0.0583184063,
0.0240848344,
0.1262290329,
-0.5281615853,
-0.2966641486,
-0.2953064144,
0.0633549094,
0.323205322,
0.4779748619,
0.004316329,
-0.4197036624,
-0.0995822921,
0.0147083886,
-0.4811218381,
0.3893597126,
0.3573303819,
0.382291913,
0.0667275935,
0.2047992349,
-0.4660121799,
0.5789989233,
0.2789299786,
-0.3731473684,
0.4232060313,
-0.5093587637,
0.0553032681,
0.1162964851,
0.5325469375,
0.3652843833,
0.0718737021,
-0.3650984466,
0.2152975649,
-0.3745830953,
0.2939872146,
-0.8076671362,
-0.535817802,
-0.1392905861,
-0.7338964939,
-0.5194808245,
-0.0881583691,
-0.6981247663,
-0.4535204172,
-0.0624391735,
0.0916754529,
-0.5354093909,
-0.5009782314,
-0.479550153,
-0.2552799881,
0.0342399664,
0.4273999929,
-0.6461552382,
0.3915526569,
0.5210005641,
0.8714606762,
-0.1549545527,
0.0142320693,
0.2239659131,
0.3329783678,
-0.1138131246,
0.8200312853,
-0.7303120494,
-0.8077378273,
-0.0512124747,
-0.0221276041,
-0.0853475705,
-0.2016285062,
0.8356518745,
-0.5895107388,
0.3341833949,
-0.3943560421,
-0.3771297932,
-0.3552723825,
0.7016699314,
-0.3061595261,
0.8800286055,
0.41738832,
-1.4545972347,
0.5179901719,
-0.851123929,
-0.3707982898,
0.4414944351,
-0.3798493147,
-0.3504054844,
-0.3469866812,
0.2588875294,
0.1731503159,
-0.1053458005,
0.0968703106,
-0.3317254782,
0.0886730999,
-0.4246657491,
0.1369946748,
0.8995870948,
0.1555108577,
-0.1203972921,
0.0794584081,
-0.6940704584,
0.114397496,
0.1247273982,
-0.246201694,
-1.1180204153,
0.2142130136,
-0.1337240636,
-0.4062007666,
0.3451403081,
-0.4512212276,
0.3570874333,
-0.1685741395,
0.1059088185,
0.4298279583,
0.3684692085,
0.3364382684,
-0.3281520009,
0.8318650126,
0.2269608676,
-0.0578553416,
0.0158032272,
-0.6053537726,
-0.4705324173,
0.3694275916,
0.4118818045,
0.4061546028,
-0.5544926524,
0.271247983,
-0.4531214535,
-0.4328871965,
-0.2154472023,
-0.1195389926,
0.3492805362,
1.0678684711,
0.2230087519,
-0.1106382683,
-0.6872087121,
-0.9257013798,
-0.0213492811,
-0.3727927804,
0.0521089099,
0.6081150174,
0.5881294608,
-0.0289147794,
1.2210476398,
-0.8289670944,
-0.4927820861,
-0.0056374227,
0.5245292783,
0.1302886903,
0.3662240803,
0.6897304058,
-0.811326921,
-0.63613379,
0.2242210358,
-0.5114073157,
0.0304262489,
0.2969346941,
-0.2602658868,
-0.4760488868,
0.3244128823,
-0.3151329458,
0.1376105696,
0.1927581429,
-0.5660265088,
0.3729802966,
0.0813399851,
0.2454990894,
-1.2652016878,
0.3830213547,
0.1016686931,
0.0361961909,
-0.3553835452,
-0.1875241548,
-0.1307303756,
0.0631607249,
0.2844296396,
0.1875363588,
-0.3598750234,
0.2919514179,
-0.0187439229,
0.1642640829,
-0.0444993563,
0.2468025833,
-0.143071875,
0.5684978366,
0.483219862,
-0.3141659796,
-0.3328384459,
0.4247496426,
-0.3417282701,
0.7469611764,
-0.6311240196,
0.0511770174,
-0.3371918201,
0.2036186457,
-1.0063010454,
-0.0918358415,
0.1919101179,
-0.7558018565,
0.1610545516,
-0.3804530799,
-0.1223207861,
-0.2729917765,
-0.3486974239,
0.6593104005,
0.271484673,
-0.167427361,
0.4370821118,
0.4335127175,
-0.525567472,
-0.7407490611,
-0.1091821641,
-0.0443705283,
-0.3844866157,
-0.7163299918,
0.702296555,
0.1791808903,
-0.2270721793,
0.5446206927,
-0.1576332748,
-0.1905768365,
0.1292880625,
0.4438825548,
0.0200381,
-0.4064769149,
-0.03144769,
0.0103458557,
0.0318074673,
0.4785083532,
-0.2099864781,
0.0564931482,
-0.0954827145,
-0.1186617091,
0.0041687936,
0.1938322484,
0.6362831593,
-0.0585004166,
0.3901585042,
0.3214185834,
-0.3230778873,
-0.0524046607,
-0.1032462493,
-0.01488047,
-0.3999835551,
0.2644889653,
-0.4906274974,
-0.9266331792,
0.4954028428,
-0.3788357377,
0.2267800868,
0.5433616638,
0.0522298664,
-0.3518124223,
1.2394618988,
0.602688849,
-0.234540984,
0.3404723406,
-0.4605722427,
0.2974135876,
-0.9045597911,
-0.7795326114,
-1.0998190641,
-0.5252486467,
-0.3443363309,
-0.0039045229,
0.6861348152,
-0.0009023288,
-0.1900278181,
-0.0692265853,
-0.614176333,
0.418277353,
0.6454920173,
0.117986083,
0.4245998561,
0.2352672368,
-0.4090470076,
-0.072616972,
-0.8865582943,
-0.3031075597,
0.8930799961,
0.1526084095,
0.6935015321,
-0.1258526742,
0.7268272042,
0.1206922606,
0.2041145563,
-0.8021336794,
0.2944039404,
0.1301737577,
-0.5308551192,
-0.3748472631,
-0.577196002,
-1.4520807266,
0.1517510414,
-0.1707830727,
-0.6299325228,
0.361014545,
0.0702854842,
-0.3206535876,
0.2700420618,
-0.1688931137,
0.7348738909,
-0.0036115213,
-0.1875240505,
-0.0137238605,
-0.5394018292,
0.4527620077,
0.1972758025,
0.4165340662,
0.1344638616,
0.2671654224,
1.2003111839,
-0.3709809482,
0.7143217325,
-0.4886580408,
0.288195461,
0.205453366,
0.1996885985,
0.3746938705,
-0.0012795435,
0.1092623174,
-0.4919739366,
0.1860638857,
-0.2167652845,
-0.6442904472,
0.5195462704,
-0.9203011394,
-0.725672543,
-0.3095949292,
-0.6511153579,
-0.5262245536,
0.2921720445,
0.0366024747,
0.1878782213,
-0.217094928,
0.6195287108,
0.6233173609,
0.374042064,
-0.0360923037,
0.3603728712,
-0.2113685608,
-0.2563635111,
0.5447419286,
0.2174240947,
-0.3966894448,
0.451497376,
0.5190261602,
-0.3016175032,
-1.0569447279,
-0.1462313384,
-0.1136317253,
-0.5138412714,
-0.2816902101,
-0.729244411,
-0.292840302,
-0.4424184859,
-0.140816763,
0.2351765037,
-0.5592140555,
-0.2134164721,
-0.2326135188,
0.6180563569,
0.7961726785,
0.0956960768,
0.3134207129,
-0.4460569024,
0.249157086,
0.3807927966,
0.2890785933,
0.4376752079,
-0.4563399255,
-0.442551285,
-0.2136910111,
-0.4826298654,
-0.7930265665,
0.094491668,
0.0507674329,
0.6758421659,
0.8177976608,
0.1978587806,
0.8196401596,
-0.2536797822,
0.443662703,
0.1863697022,
-0.2983768582,
0.8204936385,
-0.7814062238,
0.3030184507,
1.0871995687,
0.9614866972,
-0.1717851013,
-0.3332612514,
-0.7282793522,
-0.9060274959,
0.4985288084,
0.1773421764,
-0.3284705877,
0.3680951297,
0.2508205473,
-0.0178407878,
0.1225762516,
-0.7019568086,
-0.3141902089,
-0.0929271728,
-0.1455987394,
0.2718831599,
-0.1882849485,
-0.4535499513,
-0.6396498084,
0.5378986597,
-0.1151600331,
-0.2081193924,
0.2602506578,
0.4312395155,
-0.406562537,
0.2058990747,
-0.1966421306,
0.8838512897,
-0.516528964,
0.3838609457,
-0.1883588731,
-0.5319685936,
0.0481204204,
0.0488739572,
-0.6570441723,
-0.0365849882,
0.3468026221,
0.4419212043,
0.2579563558,
0.0444907136,
0.2377923876,
0.1086052954,
-0.6062533855,
-0.074558273,
-0.0650431588,
0.5039299726,
-0.0587762222,
0.5261100531,
0.1212053001,
0.4219507873,
-0.6855563521,
-0.0184982084,
0.6371703744,
-0.3404659331,
0.0516471229,
0.5061565042,
0.3855009675,
-0.345643878,
0.6812130809,
-0.076397866,
-0.467369616,
0.6528761983,
0.4208737016,
0.7153232098,
0.1046387255,
0.2942103744,
0.4807962775,
0.2349300086,
0.3529874086,
0.157259196,
-0.2717285454,
-0.5279216766,
-0.0906441435,
-0.6867113709,
-0.5123800039,
0.2041841298,
-0.7399669886,
-0.1205086559,
-0.3621389866,
-0.2061719,
0.1707508266,
0.1695272475,
-0.4410482645,
0.1950029731,
-0.3328558207,
0.9833483696,
-0.6692835093,
0.7297914028,
0.9527776241,
-0.1374925971,
-0.8684386015,
-0.1058054641,
-0.0303864274,
-0.5057057738,
0.7069033384,
-0.1090278774,
-0.4493890703,
0.0504796095,
-0.3402047753,
-0.8925759196,
1.2293112278,
-0.1464508325,
-0.3293887079,
-0.3816203773,
-0.0173760969,
0.5595407486,
-0.5623914599,
0.2113449574,
0.3910158277,
0.6606092453,
0.295704484,
-0.4737176597,
-0.0282455925,
-0.554776907,
-0.2318641245,
0.2575462759,
-0.2308564186,
0.7027484179,
-0.0762221366,
-0.1628073007,
-0.2980828285,
0.4736745656,
0.425437212,
0.8180140257,
0.7675352097,
0.6777217388,
0.7790833712,
0.0544632375,
0.7053465843,
-0.4808629453,
0.2242677659,
1.1220936775,
0.0884083137,
0.5606742501,
0.4881020188,
-0.3944965005,
0.9890704155,
0.974350214,
0.0637964085,
0.5921300054,
0.1139396876,
-0.1506909877,
0.0405352563,
-0.2967627048,
-0.8147507906,
0.00163182,
0.649785161,
-0.4286634922,
-0.405190289,
-0.5102366805,
0.0161281731,
-0.0349712782,
-0.4988351464,
0.6754338145,
-0.0654330105,
-0.6230083704,
0.2363187373,
-0.2215848863,
0.549066186,
-0.8335958123,
-0.0246013384,
-0.2827193141,
-0.3567992449,
-0.6835512519,
-0.9094980955,
0.199552685,
-0.1059304774,
-0.2886271775,
-0.306712091,
0.7497971654,
0.0033127007,
-0.5268169641,
0.2288175523,
0.8546561003,
0.13203758,
0.1739541143,
-0.6310065389,
-0.4438126981,
-0.0467625856,
-0.2481332868,
0.2933987081,
0.5919805765,
0.0999148786,
0.5592141747,
0.3565405011,
0.1223789379,
-0.0825830698,
-0.009007684,
0.8569746017,
-0.3967085183,
-0.6513814926,
-0.4961383939,
0.3568617404,
-0.2765677273,
-0.4501783848,
0.9066217542,
0.7833560109,
0.682176888,
0.0516108274,
0.984645009,
-0.3420456052,
0.62127918,
-0.0870525986,
0.7160971761,
-0.7256243229,
-0.1226205751,
-0.4752240479,
-0.7527369261,
-0.2216030955,
0.5265515447,
-0.4255862534,
0.0796313137,
0.8395144939,
0.4969110191,
-0.2848894298,
0.0951508358,
-0.1110494733,
0.1035095453,
-0.0938245207,
0.5275309682,
0.881393075,
0.229083702,
0.8596705198,
-0.3208892643,
-0.3546322882,
-0.2110670209,
-0.7464067936,
-0.8085465431,
-0.6030367613,
-0.4606967866,
-0.2247537673,
0.1737731844,
0.3027432859,
0.8685682416,
-0.7572615743,
-0.2608544528,
-0.3822045326,
0.37719208,
-0.1191748455,
-0.3381865025,
0.6882727146,
-0.2938233912,
-0.2812053561,
0.3696058989,
0.1373393089,
-0.0979451463,
-0.2831779122,
0.0179135501,
-0.1453166157,
-0.2937570214,
0.4378508329,
0.337495029,
-0.3149220645,
-0.1531179994,
-0.1299462765,
0.0716134384,
0.3626946211,
1.285479784,
-0.9832133055,
0.2278988063,
0.7245873213,
0.738244772,
0.6685352921,
0.264036119,
0.2193257213,
-0.7278578281,
-0.1918711513,
0.4699010253,
0.2874605358,
0.0646684766,
-0.4593168497,
0.7800961733,
0.3473184705,
-0.6863616705,
-0.5823982358,
-0.0071510016,
-1.1071830988,
-0.3101494312,
0.6084926724,
-0.2341392338,
-0.0735270828,
-0.4177161455,
-0.2972683311,
0.0915915444,
-0.4410323799,
1.0400271416,
0.6187342405,
-0.5958403349,
-0.1816493273,
-0.315823853,
0.5630730987,
0.4545283616,
-0.9451242089,
-0.1049445868,
0.36504215,
0.1013027355,
0.4270876646,
0.7026993632,
-0.0602209456,
-0.0433192477,
0.2052673101,
-0.3505104482,
-0.0005692569,
-0.3792304695,
0.2513249516,
0.9810020328,
0.5018801689,
-0.0820474774
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.15391v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.15391v1
|
CapsF: Capsule Fusion for Extracting psychiatric stressors for suicide from twitter
| 2024-02-07T13:41:22 | 2024-02-07T13:41:22 |
Mohammad Ali Dadgostarnia, Ramin Mousa, Saba Hesaraki
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SI
|
Along with factors such as cancer, blood pressure, street accidents and
stroke, suicide has been one of Iran main causes of death. One of the main
reasons for suicide is psychological stressors. Identifying psychological
stressors in an at risk population can help in the early prevention of suicidal
and suicidal behaviours. In recent years, the widespread popularity and flow of
real time information sharing of social media have allowed for potential early
intervention in large scale and even small scale populations. However, some
automated approaches to extract psychiatric stressors from Twitter have been
presented, but most of this research has been for non Persian languages. This
study aims to investigate the techniques of detecting psychological stress
related to suicide from Persian tweets using learning based methods. The
proposed capsule based approach achieved a binary classification accuracy of
0.83.
|
[
-0.219752118,
-0.9907021523,
0.6597826481,
0.4086006284,
-0.115739949,
0.4975032508,
-0.3917528689,
-0.294462949,
0.3232702911,
0.047122404,
-0.9734517932,
-0.7230514288,
-0.7174118757,
0.4144282043,
-0.1470213681,
0.7214301229,
-0.1744338274,
0.071530588,
0.1106844991,
0.2397736758,
-0.3486474752,
-0.2669388056,
-1.1150155067,
0.2412038743,
0.6251080036,
0.6969277263,
0.3695465922,
-0.230472967,
0.7145476937,
0.3425221741,
0.2253883332,
0.2741964757,
-0.2769367695,
0.0838569477,
-0.1130470559,
-0.0161222555,
0.101184234,
-0.1523108333,
0.3549014926,
0.2204616517,
-0.2074057758,
0.3285158277,
0.0588069223,
0.4250966012,
-0.6570116282,
0.0326596163,
-0.19583565,
0.4712537229,
-0.3616675138,
0.1106057242,
-0.1348480433,
-0.7402253151,
-0.3194154203,
-0.7003440857,
0.0795565546,
0.2532280982,
0.7405275106,
0.2338460684,
-0.3089681566,
-0.2230041027,
-0.8739504218,
1.0619579554,
-0.3390558958,
0.0403419584,
0.1150581017,
0.6408747435,
-0.069814235,
-0.1512980759,
-0.810721159,
0.2096391618,
-0.2225405574,
0.0042415923,
-0.1254313141,
0.0680914074,
0.2638143301,
0.4911080003,
-0.5844606757,
-0.1182813048,
-0.6340646744,
-0.3505879641,
0.5026761293,
0.1479796022,
1.0460004807,
-0.4735148847,
-0.2389104217,
0.0223072618,
0.1238522753,
-0.0155119719,
-0.0111055002,
0.2816464603,
-0.3314034939,
0.5039587617,
0.0017927333,
0.2401962876,
0.2781868577,
-0.2209416032,
0.3423273861,
0.0320678279,
-0.1661343724,
-0.0738064498,
1.2801834345,
0.237769872,
0.2868550718,
-0.1082907617,
0.2485543787,
-0.1630088985,
0.371394515,
-0.5607331991,
-0.0858701095,
0.4919081926,
-0.6974522471,
-0.4212939739,
-0.1492043287,
-0.8816173077,
-0.4024370611,
0.2683820128,
0.3138341904,
-0.9307040572,
-0.382424593,
-0.054595679,
-0.4486287534,
0.311083287,
0.2840237319,
-0.4902460277,
0.3819030821,
0.5135856271,
1.1284816265,
-0.6117254496,
0.1346782148,
-0.1837956905,
-0.1389410645,
-0.3096727729,
1.0029536486,
-0.3196820915,
-0.2726020813,
0.2661910951,
-0.0282986872,
-0.1641838849,
-0.2397089154,
0.9305437803,
-0.1910415739,
0.3589293957,
-0.8427526355,
-0.4202936888,
-0.1019155458,
0.2286342084,
-0.6433132291,
1.0908955336,
0.3437452018,
-1.0060557127,
0.5316021442,
-0.7812706232,
-0.5752546191,
0.3039624393,
0.048629757,
-0.5825839639,
-0.1470591277,
0.4640770257,
0.7305455804,
-0.3340381086,
0.1988472342,
-0.3291279376,
-0.2176463455,
0.3294773996,
0.1464999318,
0.9143850803,
0.5498797297,
0.0047022528,
0.1166326478,
-0.4980209172,
-0.0467424355,
0.0225472711,
0.0200793725,
-0.323297143,
0.0801253319,
0.4456662238,
0.478471756,
-0.1137251258,
-1.0694214106,
0.0482503064,
-0.033702895,
0.1214558631,
0.4511297941,
0.9981973767,
-0.0460033417,
-0.3546897769,
0.7630485296,
0.2394882888,
0.5303298831,
0.6103078723,
-0.5239518881,
-0.2315269113,
-0.8057345748,
-0.3800329864,
0.8303921223,
-0.7283188701,
0.5184509158,
0.1763768345,
-0.8173061013,
-0.2142774463,
0.0594408177,
0.5221472979,
0.5652238131,
0.4784163535,
0.0429978706,
-0.8618295193,
-0.9673894644,
-0.5055293441,
0.0249593761,
0.0303929076,
0.2208572179,
0.3569174707,
0.0278826542,
0.6537017822,
-0.8970866203,
-0.4693297446,
-0.5898228884,
0.3063653708,
0.1837877631,
0.4909898639,
0.4497784078,
-0.7889925241,
-0.7076561451,
-0.2815781534,
-0.9931088686,
-0.2307300717,
-0.4148994982,
-0.3168953061,
-0.1046644002,
0.4150481522,
-0.7252079844,
0.4050018787,
-0.1450971365,
-0.015094256,
0.618044436,
0.2314039767,
0.391364187,
-1.3960038424,
0.2401131243,
0.2454434782,
-0.2162310481,
-0.7696697116,
-0.4155510366,
0.0666817874,
-0.394045949,
-0.6232292652,
0.1899423152,
-0.4515283406,
0.3239400685,
-0.1314101815,
-0.0667788386,
-0.2823415101,
0.3317001462,
-0.0385523587,
0.7053071856,
0.4055043757,
-0.2322338074,
0.193453908,
0.5583992004,
-0.2820268273,
0.6088714004,
-0.309142828,
-0.2597544193,
-0.2934329808,
0.2435958833,
-1.2138544321,
-0.3620745242,
0.5909762383,
-0.5418373346,
0.1851038486,
0.2917013764,
-0.5437054634,
-0.8360877037,
-0.4644399583,
0.3415610492,
0.5231018662,
0.1248794496,
0.4771889746,
0.5157871842,
-0.1253254414,
-0.4082130492,
-0.5647101402,
0.0436564162,
-0.4152486324,
-0.1264010966,
0.20212771,
0.0345164835,
-0.3072951436,
-0.0527453832,
0.1267810762,
-0.1041172594,
0.0415736549,
0.696223557,
0.1768670678,
0.0775458366,
0.337138325,
0.358977139,
0.0698034167,
-0.0002720302,
-0.0769050419,
0.5445434451,
0.0910690576,
-0.0112996278,
-0.8813624978,
0.7447972894,
0.3732315004,
0.014146491,
1.3616069555,
0.9640785456,
-0.7450147867,
-0.2057150751,
-0.8675653338,
0.0641599521,
-0.4564265013,
-0.1349669695,
0.0947064981,
-0.7038332224,
0.6011858582,
-0.1776581556,
-0.4527824819,
0.5548389554,
0.5373684168,
-0.0932284743,
0.7032448649,
0.6751366854,
-0.4636628032,
0.5132133961,
0.0422891416,
0.4697159529,
-0.5346909165,
-0.2299928367,
-0.2921729088,
-0.3228183985,
-0.4402675331,
-0.3336187601,
0.7324852943,
-0.1490607113,
-0.3130525351,
0.3434431851,
-0.6587958336,
0.4352629185,
0.4206079245,
0.3541882038,
-0.2056600749,
0.0175438598,
-0.1732174754,
-0.0311125703,
-0.1427087337,
-0.2057451159,
0.6451845169,
-0.0633765459,
0.3721273243,
-0.0917808637,
0.7466273904,
0.6365107894,
0.277656287,
-0.5338697433,
0.4948765337,
0.0999183208,
-0.7295549512,
-0.3091926575,
-0.3147988617,
-0.4302291572,
-0.4641152918,
-0.2693679631,
-1.1059635878,
0.2043809146,
-0.2654559612,
-0.8840843439,
0.3621124923,
-0.4544307888,
0.6109381914,
-0.010891458,
-0.058134973,
-0.165750742,
-0.7557755113,
0.5980889201,
-0.1491333246,
0.3145131767,
-0.313259393,
0.1012936532,
1.1103727818,
-0.6456911564,
0.8316915631,
-0.2673488855,
0.3142278194,
0.3791210353,
0.0916271731,
0.0356488414,
-0.1031294167,
-0.0041573304,
0.0653714612,
0.0145685887,
-0.5110333562,
-0.3772960901,
0.5427014828,
-1.0676392317,
-0.384513557,
-0.5259436369,
-0.5188412666,
-0.350045681,
0.2399504334,
0.3256855011,
-0.1521432698,
-0.111604467,
-0.3627527058,
0.3857167959,
-0.6782381535,
0.6194622517,
0.106672287,
0.0347714946,
-0.692070663,
0.6213835478,
-0.0889987648,
-0.0958307758,
0.543725729,
0.2649767697,
0.1546957195,
-0.0420027412,
0.0416051,
0.5296645761,
-0.3349751234,
-0.5270949602,
-0.7153608203,
-0.2720816433,
-0.7429323196,
-0.256344229,
-0.2590439916,
-0.3707898557,
-0.538307786,
-0.5367261171,
0.6054688096,
0.5586402416,
-0.5606906414,
0.3441412151,
-0.9363119602,
0.5085381269,
-0.07393042,
-0.0369318761,
-0.0566344596,
0.1692538261,
-0.2532884479,
-0.3420110643,
-0.5079267025,
-1.3676472902,
0.5228250623,
0.4496003091,
0.1687330157,
0.9894812703,
0.361125052,
0.789276123,
-0.129338026,
0.8629156351,
0.1396744698,
-0.8820919991,
0.8077732921,
-0.5813132524,
-0.0727259517,
0.7370800376,
1.2032262087,
-1.1678465605,
-0.3596104681,
-0.4977629185,
-0.3668692112,
0.8280336261,
0.4545165598,
-0.2395051867,
-0.3607120812,
0.7456325293,
0.0919576958,
0.0641119927,
-0.2652323246,
-0.3312957287,
0.2214258015,
-0.3992691338,
0.0806738138,
-0.390948534,
0.2213466167,
-0.3422206342,
0.6378520131,
0.3335184753,
0.5830942988,
0.4264383316,
-0.0077899811,
-0.6928359866,
-0.0542811491,
0.3459717631,
0.1687291265,
-0.508990109,
-0.1563622952,
0.171228677,
-0.5123941302,
0.1053908467,
-0.0588780306,
-0.191859439,
-0.1814811677,
0.2863455415,
0.2962621748,
0.0199615303,
-0.7053271532,
0.6484587789,
-0.1712656021,
-0.0725757107,
-0.846452415,
-0.0381241478,
-0.0976142213,
0.2599165738,
0.5512811542,
-0.0514338017,
0.3297762573,
-0.4937720895,
0.3606699407,
0.4123807549,
-0.3690122664,
-0.5422863364,
0.3566412628,
-0.1361061633,
-0.3312861919,
0.6146965027,
-0.3423737884,
-0.9876810908,
0.2732888162,
0.331723839,
0.9708531499,
-0.6172338724,
0.696208179,
0.6643503308,
0.1033691168,
0.0637265667,
0.7249001265,
-0.3076337874,
-0.6463527083,
-0.1329539865,
-0.7299957871,
-0.4215715826,
0.1323448271,
-0.77610147,
0.3564609885,
-0.7000483274,
-0.2522476912,
-0.1752621233,
0.3262866735,
-0.4282731712,
0.3953328431,
0.6068335772,
0.7786974907,
-1.3894171715,
0.3202370703,
0.4035806656,
-0.7251387835,
-0.7848800421,
0.2300658077,
0.2179883271,
-0.6416673064,
0.5015699267,
0.2729324102,
0.2824791372,
-0.3540008962,
-0.6179131269,
-0.9570953846,
0.8502614498,
0.0136636868,
-0.153706193,
-0.1717797369,
0.5586477518,
0.6365206242,
-0.1369408816,
0.3419617116,
0.2667331994,
0.4313948154,
0.0640298575,
-0.6655156612,
0.4604125321,
-0.3276720941,
-0.0868350118,
0.3280946612,
-0.7955448031,
0.7711309195,
-0.0076412833,
-0.6315603852,
-0.2073597908,
0.5629291534,
-0.0291657913,
0.1972994655,
0.4040465653,
0.7029676437,
0.7148956656,
0.429363668,
0.9157620072,
-0.1246836185,
0.4186366796,
0.5024320483,
-0.1832845658,
0.8570554852,
0.4824298024,
-0.1481280625,
0.7446534038,
0.6737992167,
-0.001761943,
0.5190142393,
0.1860281527,
-0.3583660722,
-0.417242974,
-0.0770246759,
0.1179877669,
0.0699660927,
0.8190917969,
-0.3099993169,
-0.3618234694,
0.823515296,
0.371994406,
-0.080148086,
-0.0020606988,
0.8145217299,
0.1358085424,
-0.6164349318,
0.3545186222,
-0.151814729,
0.3470164835,
-0.1401300132,
0.1683455408,
0.1420623362,
0.2487185001,
-0.1831786186,
-0.5264932513,
0.8469730616,
0.0864057988,
0.0348329879,
-0.2528139055,
1.2537400723,
0.0118506234,
-0.9785956144,
0.2333485633,
0.6859820485,
0.1278267503,
-0.5257595778,
-0.6522958279,
-0.2197952867,
-0.2838377953,
-0.206477344,
-0.0356217362,
0.3299356997,
0.0640776157,
0.6520465016,
0.5112838149,
0.201711297,
-0.2227379382,
-0.4033660889,
0.7696319222,
-0.7446698546,
-0.1319786608,
-0.9191522002,
0.2584840655,
-0.3491224647,
-0.2932735384,
0.8038388491,
0.4759495258,
0.1460150629,
-0.3662027419,
0.8140019774,
-0.4055411518,
1.0516862869,
-0.0428864881,
1.1876608133,
-0.4254495203,
-0.2541604638,
-0.4014747739,
-0.3894149959,
-0.5913630724,
0.3318068981,
-0.6908739805,
-0.2074047178,
1.0067845583,
0.6700155735,
-0.005305856,
-0.0510889105,
0.1421104521,
0.2796381414,
0.2622626424,
0.6441841722,
0.592938602,
-0.5886636972,
0.351328373,
-0.4863910973,
-0.2666016817,
-0.1676755399,
-0.5351181626,
-1.3004046679,
-0.9194339514,
-0.5186909437,
-0.2570193112,
0.1576393545,
1.1754332781,
0.3133194745,
-1.0593241453,
0.0971337408,
-0.1375421882,
0.1418151557,
-0.3083252609,
-0.2657185495,
0.5810153484,
-0.4045904875,
-0.1506394595,
-0.0515061058,
0.1753145456,
-0.3231714964,
0.1573399007,
0.5672413707,
-0.5058011413,
0.3073372841,
0.1536327899,
0.4119328558,
-0.3826468885,
-0.3270439506,
-0.1207194552,
-0.0875542015,
-0.0162467733,
0.7368300557,
-0.8533640504,
-0.2555177808,
0.5480015874,
0.2174086422,
0.1476911306,
0.1192709282,
0.3321842849,
-0.8396683931,
-0.178256616,
0.1395536512,
0.2363154143,
0.3484473228,
-0.870706439,
-0.0249857008,
0.4442193508,
-0.4276170433,
-0.6588520408,
-0.1807643771,
-1.1714370251,
-0.101835303,
1.0269998312,
-0.1591738313,
-0.8012878299,
-0.1461602896,
-0.351913482,
0.8254520297,
-0.5442304611,
1.1716462374,
0.5250715613,
-0.0752476007,
-0.1426200867,
-0.1419615149,
0.8195634484,
0.0287834667,
-0.9291726947,
-0.2141074985,
0.0272296965,
0.3019247055,
0.2643760145,
0.5767835379,
0.063230969,
0.3482667208,
-0.2313224375,
0.0903642103,
0.1690863073,
0.0938816145,
0.151309222,
0.281326592,
-0.6077635884,
-0.2319446355
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04838v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04838v4
|
PaDeLLM-NER: Parallel Decoding in Large Language Models for Named Entity Recognition
| 2024-02-07T13:39:38 | 2024-02-15T01:52:16 |
Jinghui Lu, Ziwei Yang, Yanjie Wang, Xuejing Liu, Brian Mac Namee, Can Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this study, we aim to reduce generation latency for Named Entity
Recognition (NER) with Large Language Models (LLMs). The main cause of high
latency in LLMs is the sequential decoding process, which autoregressively
generates all labels and mentions for NER, significantly increase the sequence
length. To this end, we introduce Parallel Decoding in LLM for NE}
(PaDeLLM-NER), a approach that integrates seamlessly into existing generative
model frameworks without necessitating additional modules or architectural
modifications. PaDeLLM-NER allows for the simultaneous decoding of all
mentions, thereby reducing generation latency. Experiments reveal that
PaDeLLM-NER significantly increases inference speed that is 1.76 to 10.22 times
faster than the autoregressive approach for both English and Chinese.
Simultaneously it maintains the quality of predictions as evidenced by the
performance that is on par with the state-of-the-art across various datasets.
|
[
-0.5479653478,
-0.8087835312,
0.3613570333,
0.5839750767,
-0.3055965304,
0.1934740841,
-0.3117310107,
-0.5200386643,
0.3685309589,
0.8109611869,
-0.1399085969,
-0.6883612275,
-0.662691772,
0.4140937626,
-0.3769342005,
0.8569877744,
-0.1633154601,
0.1246937513,
-0.1434470564,
-0.0646770969,
-0.1779802591,
-0.6879758239,
-1.032227397,
-0.3600182533,
0.7857502699,
0.425075978,
0.413479656,
0.9078906775,
0.7579875588,
0.2471693903,
-0.1043849587,
0.2632500231,
-0.4018529356,
0.4227592647,
0.090005748,
-0.5136141181,
-0.9088557959,
-0.3412046731,
0.9378025532,
0.903570354,
-0.0467584282,
-0.0701598078,
0.0127941482,
0.7352324724,
-0.6069461703,
0.2687703669,
-0.3952063322,
0.0490809716,
-0.2853505909,
-0.3417064846,
-0.5432101488,
-0.3441012204,
-0.1045706049,
-0.437259078,
0.4814096093,
0.3701244593,
0.6466737986,
0.0223060101,
-0.3036683798,
-0.1326177269,
-0.7013586164,
0.6715731621,
-0.5935153365,
0.2850833833,
0.3987227082,
0.1829691529,
-0.3971501887,
-0.7215237617,
-0.769372344,
-0.1620564461,
-0.0879119858,
0.0338890478,
-0.1387148499,
0.3582071364,
0.4381116927,
0.5426029563,
-0.7359629869,
0.4844810665,
0.0462218337,
-0.1539945602,
0.6753566861,
0.4064007103,
0.2860820591,
-0.1040684357,
-0.5263754129,
-0.0930156931,
-0.9740509391,
-0.2109686881,
0.3941225111,
0.1681813598,
-0.1228783429,
0.3712416887,
-0.2306877673,
0.6848516464,
0.0475551076,
-0.0938322991,
0.2219081223,
-0.0280800797,
-0.1839835942,
0.308791697,
0.7971031666,
0.295648098,
0.0048571811,
-0.313989073,
-0.2849773765,
0.1182466447,
-0.3599956632,
-1.2109907866,
-0.4114082158,
0.1957062483,
-0.8221719265,
-0.0539362468,
0.0640635937,
-0.9550130963,
-0.2731876075,
-0.271048367,
0.1613766104,
-0.2099079043,
-0.3429656923,
0.230588004,
0.0851323605,
0.3053724766,
0.3848569095,
-0.7794981003,
0.6928371191,
0.8124225736,
0.8133758903,
-0.3423280418,
-0.436201781,
-1.0507416725,
0.1663378477,
-0.3989000916,
0.9465134144,
-0.574437499,
-0.4915655851,
-0.317245692,
0.1738590747,
-0.18048729,
-0.8197954297,
0.3350440264,
-0.8171758652,
-0.1463940591,
-0.1755795777,
-0.8975883722,
-0.1395553797,
-0.0017948697,
-0.7779590487,
0.6645247936,
-0.4185093641,
-0.842017293,
0.1952945143,
-0.4178848267,
-0.6242759228,
0.1876807958,
-0.2142688781,
-0.4297679067,
0.20678927,
0.4747778177,
0.7406579852,
-0.6342941523,
0.3345254958,
-0.317257762,
-0.3901931047,
0.1888154447,
-0.3882737458,
0.5753152966,
0.1467681378,
-0.2442914248,
-0.0522500016,
-0.8948228359,
-0.1889082044,
0.0153741371,
-0.3775370717,
-0.3298076689,
-0.0674362034,
0.244825393,
-0.0889406502,
0.0064738248,
-0.5141629577,
0.1015000567,
-0.3198290467,
0.2291220427,
0.4830811918,
0.0262421668,
0.5750069618,
-0.2395852655,
0.5833359957,
0.1613032371,
-0.4056096673,
-0.5395661592,
-0.4028070867,
-1.0222280025,
-0.418263495,
0.6222721338,
0.5481144786,
-0.6456935406,
0.3949219286,
-0.3468146026,
-0.3019579947,
-0.3471421599,
-0.0615643263,
0.5431724191,
0.4884144068,
0.4030571282,
-0.3874647617,
-0.6621069312,
-0.7241951227,
-0.1026765034,
-0.0119649097,
-0.0511493012,
0.4309226573,
0.4872093797,
-0.2931787372,
0.584687233,
-0.3020389378,
-0.0405298062,
-0.3603856862,
0.4490582645,
0.3029998243,
0.5981439948,
0.2417608649,
-0.7137777805,
-0.6563109159,
-0.0147004491,
-0.8093599677,
-0.2633050978,
-0.0063427472,
0.0106688011,
0.2427412122,
0.7314328551,
-0.6902886033,
0.3689180017,
0.5737231374,
-0.0860485137,
0.466372937,
-0.4353665113,
0.0810699686,
-1.1707599163,
-0.0424244963,
-0.1792689115,
-0.1576379687,
-0.4794976711,
-0.0378172733,
0.1381104887,
-0.1440162808,
-0.066937454,
0.8126384616,
-1.1347140074,
-0.3538087606,
-0.5359002948,
0.1363554448,
0.0997064933,
0.066709511,
0.2017897516,
1.0306478739,
0.6540016532,
-0.8389213085,
0.4014757574,
0.1762948781,
-0.3834401965,
0.5113435984,
-0.7064484358,
0.1328582019,
-0.2555891573,
0.4936336577,
-0.49112463,
-0.2641304731,
0.0108084958,
-0.3177965581,
0.6842027307,
-0.1061655656,
-0.6569736004,
-0.3347256482,
0.0039263815,
0.7916184664,
0.5557972789,
-0.9660433531,
0.5611253977,
0.5140061975,
-0.3731221855,
-0.5705238581,
-0.7790692449,
0.4129902422,
-0.261161387,
-0.5724958777,
0.7621713281,
0.0921465605,
-0.1411979795,
0.0562003106,
0.0923583731,
-0.0842146277,
-0.2154082507,
0.1567899436,
0.1707939506,
-0.4769589007,
0.1759050339,
-0.0599777512,
-0.6462695599,
-0.0789490119,
-0.279102385,
0.6331755519,
-0.0769788697,
-0.0731551647,
-0.6514559388,
0.5919933319,
0.3652501106,
-0.4017454386,
0.9354829788,
0.4472282231,
-0.3794929385,
-0.430267483,
-0.7237647176,
-0.271940738,
-0.4207740128,
0.2704699934,
-0.555393219,
-0.9995260835,
0.8595549464,
-0.2644748986,
-0.6897341013,
0.2338276058,
0.4978998899,
-0.0173031595,
0.6995588541,
0.5605996847,
-0.2160692066,
0.2539713383,
-0.3090533912,
0.3956721723,
-0.9553221464,
-0.3216529191,
-0.5260981917,
-0.2163389027,
-0.7209708095,
-0.7633082271,
-0.0628170893,
0.3953256905,
-0.1427797675,
0.3894259334,
-0.2950492501,
0.5366124511,
0.4662755132,
-0.056529101,
0.4586374462,
0.196311146,
-0.1968711317,
-0.055507835,
-0.7683029771,
-0.4739534855,
1.0340942144,
0.1974218786,
0.912183702,
-0.0718331411,
0.9681356549,
0.0994089469,
0.2480176687,
-0.5756920576,
0.7296316624,
-0.3590509892,
-0.2062687427,
-0.0154356556,
-0.6200757623,
-1.2302371264,
0.1613684595,
-0.0241592545,
-0.6373766661,
0.3230566382,
0.1029778346,
-0.2198952436,
0.5639669895,
-0.2538052201,
0.6493516564,
-0.0663098544,
-0.1766978502,
-0.2476663589,
-0.4426116049,
0.3092817366,
0.1084131449,
-0.0435238108,
-0.3266333342,
-0.1467090547,
0.7418413162,
-0.5069137216,
0.4551909268,
-0.1675098091,
0.1118535772,
0.1205067039,
-0.1305456609,
0.7944569588,
0.2625235915,
-0.1044697315,
0.477550149,
-0.4833325744,
-0.4571484029,
-0.4697425067,
0.9992237687,
-0.6160641313,
-0.4826871753,
-0.3637486994,
-0.5166876912,
0.0996470526,
0.0982861146,
0.4355025291,
0.4736593366,
-0.1810267717,
0.236989826,
0.9269087911,
-0.4503284097,
0.631467998,
0.4991554022,
-0.343837589,
-0.7036395073,
0.8057149649,
0.1667258441,
-0.0455149934,
0.8076683879,
-0.3520159721,
-0.235333845,
-0.9544306397,
-0.1643574238,
0.4619151056,
-0.426620543,
-0.4017213285,
-1.0745761395,
-0.3114483654,
-0.1399196237,
0.0496586524,
-0.322791487,
-0.314858526,
-0.3863683343,
-0.0876206383,
0.4204519689,
0.586001277,
-0.1634771526,
0.4199601114,
-0.9071065187,
0.541338563,
0.1110781804,
0.3111103177,
0.0610105619,
-0.2830370963,
-0.1361227483,
-0.3553590775,
0.2798145115,
-0.7957923412,
0.5167531967,
0.0658297539,
0.5229492784,
0.2976045907,
0.1455095559,
0.6963271499,
-0.660656631,
0.3219978213,
0.1955638677,
-0.7917690277,
0.3018582761,
-0.2752449512,
0.0157450177,
0.2323963046,
0.1824555993,
-0.5089635849,
-0.0173971877,
-0.3501540422,
-1.0387517214,
0.6088451743,
0.1105588153,
0.0665714294,
-0.3590022922,
0.2793885767,
0.2949852049,
0.1801184714,
-0.3870278895,
-0.3336469531,
0.3331431448,
0.0940893963,
-0.2207529396,
-0.7594253421,
0.2164766937,
-0.1026385054,
0.5671900511,
0.1181135476,
0.5728435516,
0.1783474833,
-0.2545439303,
0.1465225369,
0.2159148902,
0.2881481051,
0.2924628258,
-0.0910431817,
0.16217044,
0.1493974775,
-0.3210074902,
0.1835451871,
0.5485190153,
-0.1451671571,
0.2569245696,
0.3408239782,
1.1041920185,
0.2602203488,
-0.3208927512,
0.4365799725,
-0.1452928185,
-0.0484843031,
-0.3601381481,
-0.1040990353,
0.1512302905,
0.3336643577,
0.3261542022,
-0.0511921197,
0.1094594598,
0.0031466396,
0.1504961252,
0.1709896475,
0.2184937596,
-0.2291845232,
0.7741314769,
0.3021606505,
-0.3945025504,
0.7993565798,
-0.2862249017,
-0.1971361488,
0.9908198714,
0.6434908509,
1.1128547192,
-0.2840715349,
0.123057425,
0.4483995736,
0.0342070051,
-0.3019975126,
0.3549906909,
-0.1399665326,
-0.7906999588,
-0.54759866,
-0.9158246517,
-0.4162680209,
0.2955687344,
-0.8044589758,
0.1101742983,
-0.4304180443,
-0.1829646677,
-0.0518797301,
-0.1841323823,
-0.669208765,
-0.0337295011,
0.1301212609,
0.8736023903,
-0.3529927135,
0.9375252724,
0.5901021361,
-0.2879447639,
-0.7786319852,
0.244067058,
-0.3638605177,
-0.5587283373,
0.969858706,
0.4813216925,
-0.1716831774,
0.2994582653,
0.0022771275,
-0.9635632038,
1.0727467537,
0.4638983011,
-0.8871077299,
-0.0822609589,
0.0663698316,
0.3798201084,
-0.6422320604,
0.1174871475,
0.348779887,
0.3490388989,
-0.2490501851,
-0.8883212209,
-0.0486013256,
-0.2255851179,
0.5105767846,
0.3609263599,
-0.5470231771,
1.1065433025,
-0.3495315313,
-0.3898111284,
0.4468535483,
0.6931029558,
0.4239000976,
0.5494309068,
0.0379367732,
0.7950981855,
0.8434073925,
-0.1230000407,
1.0109343529,
-0.6742893457,
0.4207392931,
1.2323946953,
-0.3424935937,
1.0809967518,
0.3961431086,
-0.2984950542,
0.4555118382,
0.5709454417,
-0.0801176354,
0.4313944578,
0.2673726678,
-0.6039658189,
-0.2157830447,
0.0328758992,
-0.7189438343,
0.3677495122,
0.5029063821,
-0.4260987937,
-0.2100406587,
0.2059708983,
0.0901847333,
0.211335659,
-0.4465118051,
0.5791658163,
0.3404917419,
-0.4333588779,
0.5896318555,
0.1325233281,
0.8633857369,
-0.185588941,
-0.0834768265,
-0.4331309199,
0.3722787797,
-0.1297374368,
-0.3638561368,
0.0462190509,
-0.0860579386,
-0.5558969378,
-0.2280008942,
0.758567512,
-0.6198508739,
-0.5141865015,
0.8058181405,
0.6135517955,
0.3477120101,
-0.062900506,
-0.4677746892,
0.0966560245,
-0.4533678591,
-0.253519237,
0.3824262023,
0.3501833081,
0.0267623197,
0.61220783,
0.6851084828,
0.1376353055,
0.2010532469,
0.1462989151,
0.684964478,
-0.8781349063,
-0.4611447155,
-0.7543450594,
0.1205492392,
-0.052007433,
0.1143408567,
0.7749198079,
0.7149204612,
0.9456129074,
-0.1809621751,
0.6978984475,
0.2215466499,
0.5535148382,
-0.7179043293,
0.7781660557,
-0.2386551946,
0.5082150102,
-0.0663776845,
-1.150968194,
-0.4614259601,
0.4887647033,
-0.3930606544,
0.05954469,
0.727019906,
1.0212599039,
0.0455291681,
-0.053659182,
0.3750307858,
0.3760866821,
0.0275397431,
0.5537854433,
0.7774966359,
-0.4700977802,
0.3143365383,
-0.2592769265,
-0.0693279654,
-0.3251591623,
-0.9149074554,
-0.9569254518,
-0.2093518972,
-0.3867764771,
-0.1873127222,
0.3425572813,
0.628487885,
0.5830004215,
-1.0969957113,
-0.3991623223,
-0.5696840882,
-0.0083227623,
0.0258525331,
-0.2435038239,
0.5416069627,
-0.4470281303,
-0.895601511,
0.4966199696,
0.5365388989,
-0.0395951048,
0.0983118266,
-0.4023166597,
0.0443999767,
-0.2176798582,
0.4741008878,
0.3646089733,
-0.8346010447,
0.2169612199,
-0.110084489,
-0.1825419366,
0.1747641265,
0.9985972047,
-0.8160142303,
0.4740925133,
0.5781978369,
0.8776469827,
0.7945821285,
-0.1337931007,
0.5955052376,
-0.1718230247,
0.3468625844,
0.3112605512,
0.5422638059,
0.4216506779,
-0.27754879,
0.2219020426,
0.3851273358,
-0.6540020704,
-0.8074805737,
0.1816198528,
-0.840477407,
-0.029917974,
0.9503729343,
-0.44053635,
-0.1191374287,
-0.0698358491,
0.0385532454,
0.2136625946,
-0.3909285665,
0.457731396,
0.4643495083,
-0.2888709903,
-0.460922718,
-0.4126769602,
0.3487394452,
0.3934884071,
-0.7428253889,
0.0559659861,
0.4408101737,
0.2237141877,
-0.1456935257,
0.7933592796,
-0.0254996885,
0.3384527862,
0.3296819627,
0.121847488,
-0.1235962957,
-0.4606280327,
-0.4213773012,
0.3122251928,
0.0592289381,
-0.3085236847
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10938v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10938v1
|
News Source Credibility Assessment: A Reddit Case Study
| 2024-02-07T13:39:24 | 2024-02-07T13:39:24 |
Arash Amini, Yigit Ege Bayiz, Ashwin Ram, Radu Marculescu, Ufuk Topcu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SI
|
In the era of social media platforms, identifying the credibility of online
content is crucial to combat misinformation. We present the CREDiBERT
(CREDibility assessment using Bi-directional Encoder Representations from
Transformers), a source credibility assessment model fine-tuned for Reddit
submissions focusing on political discourse as the main contribution. We adopt
a semi-supervised training approach for CREDiBERT, leveraging Reddit's
community-based structure. By encoding submission content using CREDiBERT and
integrating it into a Siamese neural network, we significantly improve the
binary classification of submission credibility, achieving a 9% increase in F1
score compared to existing methods. Additionally, we introduce a new version of
the post-to-post network in Reddit that efficiently encodes user interactions
to enhance the binary classification task by nearly 8% in F1 score. Finally, we
employ CREDiBERT to evaluate the susceptibility of subreddits with respect to
different topics.
|
[
-0.2884410024,
-0.8200901747,
0.4305661917,
0.4441792369,
-0.480848074,
0.3728462458,
-0.5389161706,
-0.3422124982,
0.2077197433,
0.0815484002,
-0.1542311311,
-0.6316797137,
-0.9260088205,
0.2493558377,
-0.7500643134,
0.8371873498,
0.1678624153,
0.1519461721,
-0.4739581048,
-0.1629738808,
-0.2748260498,
-0.5387459993,
-0.3963032961,
-0.1139517725,
0.7149196267,
0.3156899214,
0.722986877,
0.3150643706,
0.8672217727,
0.2587667704,
-0.0648586154,
0.0804546252,
-0.4663716853,
-0.1552482247,
-0.7234521508,
-0.3098907173,
-0.0601778217,
0.1150091514,
0.269375056,
0.2372326404,
-0.3276982009,
0.6642612219,
0.1309669614,
0.5177624226,
-0.576990962,
0.1819236726,
-0.7632725239,
-0.1317349076,
-0.18786183,
-0.5189683437,
-0.5405141115,
-0.7747019529,
0.0958352983,
-0.3578348458,
0.2837124467,
-0.2891350389,
1.0594171286,
0.1622746438,
-0.4726890326,
-0.3554380238,
-0.8480499387,
0.5987110138,
-0.4080475867,
0.6743398309,
0.1005292833,
0.4518966079,
0.1266646683,
-1.1017677784,
-0.6224961877,
0.1085824296,
-0.1696195304,
0.1983744651,
-0.0466179661,
-0.2110437602,
-0.1559036821,
0.1076661944,
-0.4298791289,
-0.4567206204,
-0.6964993477,
-0.4895117581,
0.6602172852,
-0.4696986973,
0.1303071231,
-0.4758450389,
-0.4242391288,
-0.2953070402,
-0.3439619839,
-0.0924974158,
0.5158777833,
0.3793890774,
-0.0495762043,
0.6706968546,
-0.033772368,
0.543686986,
0.2644574046,
-0.2889029682,
0.1325949878,
-0.5496034026,
0.121041365,
0.2566346228,
0.7274594307,
0.8359399438,
0.2760434449,
0.2515090108,
0.0393753871,
0.4209314287,
0.4644863904,
-0.6439156532,
-0.2036303878,
0.0435991623,
-0.5780989528,
-0.5621765852,
0.5712857842,
-1.0535333157,
-0.3276148438,
-0.2145181149,
0.2414710075,
-0.1168714464,
-0.1793305129,
0.001237217,
-0.2779307961,
-0.0356957987,
0.477404654,
-0.0973862931,
0.0073930756,
0.6535363197,
0.8446916938,
-0.2040174603,
-0.0741404369,
-0.3158348501,
-0.2494033128,
-0.0946771875,
1.1237061024,
-0.7730396986,
0.1959968507,
0.3163180351,
0.0876257494,
0.099866502,
-0.2654820383,
0.9248568416,
-1.0281473398,
0.3316581249,
0.1047793552,
-0.4487452805,
-0.320363909,
0.5654572845,
-0.7460616827,
0.8732872605,
0.3390673399,
-1.0044163465,
0.3037381768,
-0.4571411908,
-0.5691725612,
-0.1308821589,
-0.0530806258,
-0.2527859807,
-0.0617554262,
0.157934621,
0.122697778,
0.1399797648,
0.3436654508,
-0.1841810346,
-0.1688762456,
0.5657254457,
-0.6125899553,
0.7766594887,
0.0095663127,
-0.0129307862,
-0.2562954724,
-0.8066320419,
0.1352595538,
-0.1815911978,
-0.7258489132,
-0.2861111462,
-0.2303910702,
-0.0205405559,
0.252602011,
0.3363598883,
-0.7792779207,
-0.2708705962,
-0.0506693609,
0.881246686,
0.3638831973,
0.4574709833,
0.2758418918,
-0.1796489209,
0.2585633099,
0.0740181506,
0.2667784989,
0.1872572899,
-0.4234381616,
-0.6579502821,
0.1753001064,
1.0344455242,
0.6306477189,
-0.763720572,
0.3733450472,
-0.4053207636,
-0.6969530582,
-0.419408828,
0.0726548433,
-0.1008520052,
0.4505885541,
0.4512673616,
-0.2591904402,
-0.6594616771,
-0.9538438916,
-0.8528710008,
-0.4736936986,
-0.143567279,
-0.073815316,
0.4125591516,
-0.2078011334,
0.8701869249,
-0.0330700055,
-0.1537368745,
-0.0582672469,
0.4268907011,
0.0057347114,
0.1797099859,
0.3628278375,
-1.0015070438,
-0.5713536739,
-0.2114156932,
-0.6444985271,
0.0856933594,
-0.1670435965,
0.006200124,
0.0207267404,
0.2250641584,
-0.6957651973,
0.4459698498,
0.8146064281,
-0.3413097858,
0.3089901805,
0.1389171928,
0.8242138028,
-0.6250425577,
-0.3117794991,
0.3792205155,
-0.6155359745,
-0.3657723963,
-0.0525086448,
0.3408524692,
-0.1044551134,
-0.7568132877,
-0.0166550782,
-0.1505099386,
0.046209611,
-0.119815439,
0.5584083796,
0.3862469494,
0.3160182536,
0.0191404819,
0.522300303,
0.1954443306,
-0.5129950047,
0.3815856576,
0.1803591102,
-0.4556701779,
0.7237758636,
-0.693718195,
0.2536121309,
-0.0329597034,
0.2736139596,
-0.8584710956,
-0.2916199863,
0.0949139446,
-1.0532950163,
0.175569728,
-0.1663034707,
-0.617105782,
-0.3462010026,
-0.1055319831,
0.3853181303,
0.2630085051,
-0.5208258033,
0.5576355457,
0.2721952498,
-0.1940331608,
-0.3040739298,
-0.7868902087,
0.2598466873,
0.08575169,
-0.6310047507,
0.3069852293,
0.143151179,
-0.3693065345,
0.1990251094,
0.02722173,
-0.4006461799,
-0.1713610739,
0.0740918741,
-0.0196147375,
-0.1976649463,
0.006980998,
-0.0169379003,
0.0136866402,
0.148861289,
0.2267085165,
0.2526229918,
-0.0780157298,
-0.5372470617,
-0.8044842482,
0.0365106203,
0.7507767677,
-0.262355417,
0.7455183268,
0.2406190485,
-0.3431679904,
-0.1023377553,
-0.5199894309,
-0.479698956,
-0.4005007148,
0.3013562858,
0.5258650184,
-0.7559508681,
0.1744466871,
-0.0578745976,
0.1616665572,
0.5243700743,
0.5839776397,
-0.1260782033,
0.7385684252,
0.4112293124,
0.2181922942,
0.253575325,
0.3786309958,
0.4922532141,
0.0194080938,
-0.3665295541,
-0.6497840285,
-0.3435864449,
-0.3535814881,
-0.6587329507,
0.0550060533,
-0.0698843449,
-0.0110721905,
0.6927857995,
-0.7027519345,
0.5350256562,
0.6603808999,
0.3142806292,
0.7524502873,
0.2761049569,
0.3618965149,
-0.3185299337,
-0.6180803776,
-0.6529330015,
0.8624997139,
0.7414776087,
0.8231775165,
-0.0583634786,
0.2076845765,
1.0547374487,
0.5476490855,
-0.48487854,
0.5112315416,
0.2665849328,
-0.7124334574,
0.0296656583,
-0.3641715646,
-0.2975284159,
-0.0829117298,
-0.4015810192,
-0.1711336374,
0.3347047269,
-0.1370918155,
-0.3723869026,
0.2368447781,
-0.5762444139,
0.3801003695,
-0.3107150197,
-0.4216367304,
-0.4039175212,
-0.4904325902,
0.247040689,
0.0436888784,
0.2943267524,
0.2153844088,
0.0426370203,
0.8215909004,
0.0581377409,
0.9293171763,
-0.0870655254,
0.2391723245,
0.6768967509,
0.0074735098,
0.3513538837,
0.4654592574,
-0.1223910749,
0.9100534916,
0.0686013028,
-0.1889927834,
-0.7160770297,
0.6168896556,
-0.6909214854,
-0.3737020493,
-0.532111764,
-0.034135446,
-0.0523601472,
0.2144664973,
0.2735714614,
0.3872637451,
-0.3418930769,
0.7470993996,
0.5222143531,
-0.0016202575,
0.1569329947,
0.4446806312,
0.1283139884,
-0.8438556194,
0.4459138811,
0.1206060797,
-0.0056301695,
0.2914078832,
0.0268665217,
-0.4631632268,
-0.3444686234,
-0.343468219,
0.0786807388,
-0.8844935894,
-0.6541196704,
-0.3802022338,
-0.6840392947,
-0.3035796881,
-0.0474073105,
-0.7933356762,
-0.6626605988,
-0.1693491936,
-0.3731021285,
0.1790952384,
0.6231172085,
0.1115828678,
0.0672304034,
-0.9574999809,
0.0499842763,
0.2008123845,
0.4233181477,
-0.4469417632,
-0.6656793952,
-0.141854465,
0.4234627783,
-0.4119609892,
-0.9726498127,
-0.1025673971,
-0.0119267618,
0.5060981512,
0.5292836428,
0.502876699,
0.4605652988,
-0.2993878722,
0.8923254013,
0.2103414237,
-0.6183772683,
0.6070625186,
-0.1672532558,
-0.397213608,
0.8535711169,
0.490373224,
-0.2464508563,
-0.6214881539,
-0.8150565028,
-0.3359751701,
-0.1417092234,
0.5403593183,
0.1650557816,
-0.2937859297,
0.4042401314,
-0.0631641224,
0.3334571421,
-0.8845109344,
-0.0344721302,
-0.7755451202,
-0.2608055174,
0.2456546277,
-0.478787899,
-0.407790333,
-0.3139685988,
0.5475516915,
0.1784308702,
0.3377217948,
0.7332444191,
-0.2554769814,
-0.2020572126,
0.3398455083,
0.777979672,
1.0612508059,
0.0329266563,
0.3195068836,
-0.0836957395,
-0.2495452166,
-0.0183988642,
-0.1172058284,
-0.3023260534,
0.4337988794,
0.7375378013,
0.0115149003,
0.3005609512,
-0.5120642781,
0.8650948405,
-0.5106377602,
-0.5360677242,
-0.4476421475,
-0.1073334888,
0.2228977233,
0.4015559256,
0.307885319,
0.5074773431,
-0.2577906251,
-0.494007796,
0.5309211612,
0.0226354785,
-0.601000607,
-0.4298509359,
0.5093075037,
0.6223147511,
-0.6788157821,
0.5093460679,
0.137384817,
-0.8282709718,
0.3875909746,
0.2093455046,
0.3489994705,
-0.1102390438,
0.3767561316,
0.8894590735,
0.6169940233,
-0.2206971347,
-0.2152366638,
0.1849846542,
-0.7697352767,
-0.1687516719,
-0.6040427089,
-0.4131970704,
0.0114713581,
-0.6072579026,
0.2584913671,
-0.613269031,
-0.5154197216,
-0.3051013649,
0.1358024776,
-0.3888761699,
-0.0667935088,
-0.1400387287,
1.3320370913,
-0.9495128989,
0.3746047616,
0.629725039,
-0.1491354555,
-0.4844085574,
0.1802090555,
-0.0133296894,
-0.3671238124,
0.4183264673,
-0.0111382371,
0.0038633556,
-0.2109539211,
-0.6889107227,
-0.529499352,
0.9938828945,
0.4486080408,
-0.5994639993,
0.2608799934,
0.2401643246,
0.5009657145,
-0.3112430274,
0.1336623132,
0.2515074909,
0.7095697522,
-0.0993275493,
-0.7450190783,
-0.0336386822,
-0.1910306364,
-0.1540318877,
-0.2433929145,
-0.7359223962,
0.6101633906,
0.0647894517,
-0.5573847294,
-0.3479026556,
0.9721505046,
0.1997484863,
0.3659622967,
0.6262304187,
0.3337245286,
0.6639168859,
-0.1287030131,
0.6437970996,
-0.6096391082,
0.6978963017,
0.9832865596,
-0.0729411468,
1.074243784,
0.4880852103,
0.0195107833,
1.087916255,
0.7443070412,
-0.1890452057,
0.5274911523,
-0.2283921242,
0.0212295037,
-0.418163836,
-0.1611881852,
-0.2844908237,
0.4580646455,
0.2579070032,
-0.6888338923,
-0.6078428626,
0.1359410733,
-0.0583367944,
0.6721664667,
-0.1761825532,
0.4376544058,
-0.034420643,
-0.8301730156,
0.1105551198,
0.0002784104,
0.3744938076,
-0.2619809508,
-0.3714607954,
-0.0573292784,
0.3315912485,
-0.3568216562,
-1.1018048525,
0.4389986992,
0.0270120539,
-0.0252807867,
-0.1096102223,
1.2688099146,
-0.4865325987,
-0.7596620321,
0.3814101815,
0.4317776859,
-0.2378109545,
-0.1221106276,
-0.7009218931,
0.2040204257,
-0.146440655,
-0.429538846,
0.0974492729,
0.4933747351,
0.2164569199,
0.5730784535,
0.7853142619,
-0.0516892374,
-0.2401635349,
-0.0481902994,
0.9462944269,
-0.4484637976,
-0.4508096278,
-0.728930831,
0.2873859107,
-0.479952544,
-0.0065542981,
1.0693609715,
0.5208299756,
0.861988008,
0.1820114851,
0.7418375611,
-0.1473892629,
0.8508621454,
-0.1948047131,
0.9087724686,
-0.3124104142,
0.2033614516,
0.0015944442,
-0.7335003614,
-0.4659640789,
0.7586166859,
-0.0847030059,
-0.0045956639,
0.8426679373,
0.9465216994,
-0.2082609087,
0.2821475863,
0.1434379518,
0.2108040899,
0.0183601566,
0.1305811554,
1.0330334902,
-0.3464808166,
0.8510195017,
-0.6201796532,
-0.1711243093,
-0.297412008,
-0.9535734653,
-1.2159430981,
-0.3000313044,
-0.6726214886,
-0.8729678392,
0.1803101301,
0.5249468684,
0.6841501594,
-0.6512662172,
0.2910839915,
0.0544108525,
0.2524616718,
-0.2633123994,
-0.3626942337,
0.1252529323,
0.2561094463,
-0.3994208574,
0.0370148979,
0.2563391626,
-0.3898627162,
-0.4493637681,
0.174314186,
-0.3678666949,
0.1967592984,
0.6311767697,
0.1699537933,
-0.4628574252,
-0.9048729539,
0.0602085479,
-0.184561342,
0.2367547601,
0.8048304319,
-0.5507333875,
-0.0083757993,
0.6391691566,
0.5457471013,
0.1590077281,
0.8365751505,
0.3327713013,
-0.6730113626,
-0.1105177924,
0.3863749802,
0.1042063683,
0.5527279377,
-0.5688075423,
0.2591684759,
0.4360432327,
-0.6351294518,
-0.619851768,
-0.0823523104,
-1.0094618797,
-0.1937886626,
1.2466061115,
-0.1096477136,
-0.5729945898,
-0.3382395506,
0.1525213122,
0.1937128752,
-0.5299597383,
0.8789603114,
0.7911533117,
0.2742327154,
-0.3990861773,
-0.7109895349,
0.1413788646,
-0.2728417814,
-0.5381923318,
0.0515692495,
0.2402305305,
0.6188425422,
0.5615559816,
0.454079181,
-0.3228519261,
0.4004407525,
-0.0308933333,
-0.0948322266,
0.093688935,
-0.5469399691,
0.1351328939,
0.6095089912,
-0.1762713343,
-0.1216978356
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.06988v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.06988v1
|
Guiding LLMs The Right Way: Fast, Non-Invasive Constrained Generation
| 2024-02-07T13:36:02 | 2024-02-07T13:36:02 |
Luca Beurer-Kellner, Marc Fischer, Martin Vechev
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
To ensure that text generated by large language models (LLMs) is in an
expected format, constrained decoding proposes to enforce strict formal
language constraints during generation. However, as we show in this work, not
only do such methods incur performance overhead during generation, but many of
them also significantly impair task accuracy, if they do not correctly align
the underlying LLM sub-word vocabularies with external constraints. To address
this, we present a novel decoding algorithm, DOMINO, that can enforce
constraints in a fully subword-aligned fashion, while leveraging
pre-computation and speculative decoding to achieve virtually no overhead and
in some cases even almost 2$\times$ speedup over unconstrained decoding --
thereby outperforming existing approaches by a wide margin.
|
[
0.0168641992,
-0.5553384423,
0.5661278963,
0.2869747579,
-0.5983563662,
0.1536283195,
-0.1016578674,
-0.0931917801,
0.1983604878,
1.0242515802,
-0.9813972116,
-0.8679457307,
-0.5576251745,
0.2786623538,
-0.2360993028,
0.983014226,
-0.0854016021,
-0.0902203619,
-0.3674711585,
0.1156114489,
-0.1916738302,
-0.2208619863,
-0.1625658274,
-0.2742137313,
0.2677735686,
0.4998154938,
0.8559951186,
1.3689148426,
0.3020422459,
0.2806814313,
-0.0814994946,
0.7648833394,
-0.5630415082,
0.013218483,
-0.1374155134,
-0.5417222381,
-0.3237114251,
-0.3545230329,
0.61821419,
0.5189110041,
-0.301679492,
0.0886671767,
0.0690181851,
0.7203220725,
-0.8123640418,
0.0143896639,
-0.75502038,
0.1139357686,
-0.5767051578,
-0.621665895,
-0.6598019004,
-0.5482574105,
-0.2965024412,
-0.9622498155,
0.2181518674,
0.1395644993,
0.8283614516,
0.5317275524,
-0.6010128856,
-0.594530344,
-0.6298061609,
0.7320453525,
-0.5161604881,
0.4559445679,
0.3366149366,
-0.1557795256,
-0.5233559608,
-0.4953188598,
-0.5495757461,
0.0615853667,
0.1289446801,
0.0863815248,
-0.0049715685,
0.29666394,
0.3361667395,
0.1872817427,
-0.5318459868,
0.2491880953,
-0.1600137502,
-0.4351037741,
0.4848018289,
0.4646812081,
0.1904044002,
-0.4321142435,
-0.1866705418,
0.1264214218,
-1.009180069,
-0.1255113482,
0.417252928,
0.3178346455,
-0.1113227233,
0.7020323873,
-0.0275304019,
0.6705361605,
0.1539798975,
-0.1529168487,
-0.1937223971,
-0.4854477048,
-0.2538880408,
0.1314085126,
0.7506553531,
0.450942874,
0.0997304171,
-0.1251418144,
-0.102397792,
0.4022430182,
0.1572104394,
-0.5379062891,
-0.3407151401,
0.0720738918,
-0.042907469,
-0.1602904648,
-0.2962712348,
-0.7581999898,
-0.5483959317,
-0.0482636467,
-0.104526639,
-0.4979334772,
-0.0125879729,
0.0946445465,
-0.0005877212,
0.3818508983,
0.0755955428,
-1.0669637918,
0.1617302448,
0.8502551317,
0.6831458211,
0.4224235415,
0.1055819467,
-0.8003976941,
0.681545496,
-0.9301276207,
0.5826119781,
-0.4798777699,
-0.6676706672,
0.2956179976,
-0.2771730423,
0.2194944471,
-0.5615916848,
0.6956671476,
-0.5672749281,
-0.0163574759,
-0.3429211378,
-0.7099487782,
0.2745316625,
0.3185768127,
-0.5006982684,
0.9622615576,
0.0815674663,
-0.572209239,
0.5713918209,
-0.2809083164,
-0.7289044857,
0.2486350089,
-0.4422307909,
-0.5667568445,
0.3069429696,
0.7487136126,
0.3324535191,
-0.3439506888,
0.283638984,
-0.0303272344,
-0.2437551469,
0.002690326,
-0.2074203938,
0.6991511583,
0.171175018,
-0.3285078704,
0.16421552,
-0.8559515476,
0.1818635315,
0.0190588981,
-0.4737517238,
-0.0649412572,
0.2229658812,
-0.3871311247,
-0.1804844737,
0.5097147822,
-0.5652186871,
0.5538967848,
-0.4130138755,
0.428954035,
0.923365891,
-0.0167911649,
0.5783362985,
-0.1813940555,
0.6092107296,
-0.0788583085,
0.2554547489,
-0.0056562745,
-0.1391785145,
-0.8508161902,
-0.2047647238,
0.3292087913,
0.6506265402,
-1.1967288256,
0.4899950027,
-0.4763784409,
-0.3900316358,
-0.6826877594,
0.6462721229,
0.7919437289,
0.3541610241,
0.3232444227,
-0.1408995688,
-0.7091737986,
-1.0048838854,
-0.2349427193,
-0.0079068858,
0.1299161166,
0.31506446,
0.0146632157,
-0.341307193,
0.5557307601,
-0.4613927901,
-0.1529701501,
-0.4267726839,
0.0912651196,
0.2803126872,
0.6098250747,
0.0057883831,
-0.6355705261,
-0.6458134055,
0.0348943658,
-0.6505631208,
-0.3003810942,
-0.3179709613,
-0.2377218604,
0.4784639478,
0.7627577782,
-0.787460506,
0.3423117399,
0.6587580442,
-0.0968463868,
0.2200148702,
-0.4625634253,
-0.4148393273,
-1.0172355175,
-0.2963129282,
-0.2079989761,
-0.3582006693,
-0.5438473821,
0.0819667727,
0.446587503,
-0.0152688241,
-0.2036916763,
0.0444438793,
-1.0544942617,
0.1429178119,
-0.1764464676,
0.2031625956,
0.1883813292,
0.2495303154,
0.0978168398,
0.727325201,
0.4478422999,
-0.7864095569,
0.2657433748,
0.1499744356,
-0.6276237965,
0.3481513262,
-0.2111914605,
0.2944402993,
-0.3215990961,
0.3779744208,
-0.5823690295,
0.0206425618,
0.3488385081,
-0.1682761461,
0.4460203052,
-0.190552786,
-0.6797615886,
-0.2580919564,
-0.0874530524,
0.4966593981,
0.6561940312,
-0.5961725712,
0.7539772391,
0.2180616409,
0.4378949404,
-0.7392724752,
-0.6279428601,
0.2275811136,
0.043035116,
-0.5364168882,
0.495157063,
-0.0282798838,
0.0119208749,
0.1216369569,
-0.159446016,
0.1138468832,
-0.2221857607,
0.1249114275,
0.1454688609,
-0.0712329745,
-0.3365255594,
0.2371800393,
-0.1720932424,
-0.1448238194,
-0.5214435458,
0.4788656235,
0.5038135052,
-0.2172755599,
-0.675108254,
0.330204308,
0.6100596786,
-0.2116222531,
0.5783671737,
0.3894162178,
-0.134381637,
-0.738509953,
-0.3796351552,
0.174747318,
-0.6048175693,
0.3622242808,
-0.6242711544,
-0.6020899415,
0.2932513654,
-0.1664355248,
0.1521610022,
0.1179858223,
0.4025254846,
0.143020153,
1.0401016474,
0.9223251939,
0.0845900625,
0.3740667403,
-0.0484575108,
0.3200113177,
-0.9204393029,
-0.3502000272,
-0.4069932997,
-0.0336620584,
-0.6197162271,
-0.6541545987,
0.1742977649,
0.3329950273,
0.302706331,
0.4324412942,
-0.6839942336,
0.6993858218,
0.5817163587,
0.0523496494,
-0.0047655804,
-0.331869781,
-0.4434223473,
-0.1768772751,
-1.003537178,
-0.4414743483,
1.1566400528,
0.0684555322,
0.7733858824,
0.3628195524,
0.9043983817,
0.092214264,
0.4657524228,
-0.4352648854,
0.8776297569,
-0.4311151803,
-0.7045180202,
-0.1323264986,
-0.5810797215,
-0.9441823363,
-0.0875810906,
-0.2417263538,
-0.5877036452,
-0.0453973301,
0.3685109913,
-0.4215257764,
0.3503006399,
-0.4026694894,
0.4452200532,
-0.2683165967,
-0.5985671282,
0.0684990212,
-0.4160289168,
0.4261441529,
0.1335079819,
0.3054111898,
-0.1296313703,
-0.2388538867,
0.4473197162,
-0.6254569292,
0.8678544164,
-0.3198886216,
-0.3769901693,
0.373988539,
0.439979136,
0.858189106,
0.0304178167,
-0.0991320685,
-0.2073933482,
0.0135270627,
-0.5832896829,
-0.7260829806,
0.6462633014,
-0.6427258849,
-0.9267137647,
-0.331517607,
-0.7641836405,
-0.2205156088,
0.3045203686,
0.7818008661,
0.5326162577,
-0.1967873573,
-0.0421181954,
0.9179831743,
-0.1451635063,
0.1628166586,
0.4631311595,
-0.0871090293,
-0.6106718183,
1.0421745777,
0.2904338241,
0.1091714278,
0.961320281,
0.1314812154,
-0.6416064501,
-0.9799288511,
-0.8529886007,
0.1780633032,
-0.6085903645,
-0.1838806421,
-0.0803842247,
0.0153065715,
-0.8140546679,
-0.4261486232,
-0.3801234961,
-0.1540774256,
-0.4333381355,
-0.0909769759,
-0.1183804274,
0.8890189528,
-0.1920424402,
0.2948796153,
-1.0858845711,
0.2368174195,
-0.0414687172,
0.2134406716,
-0.497079879,
-0.1880128831,
-0.2987540364,
-0.2987281084,
-0.2474002987,
-0.9577626586,
0.2454657853,
-0.0139130438,
0.4265319407,
0.6059422493,
0.4175617397,
0.8274318576,
-0.7004988194,
0.7288799286,
0.1310528368,
-1.3172316551,
0.3705062568,
-0.4810968935,
0.4587990344,
0.4818399549,
0.1110336408,
-0.3503214717,
-0.2894951999,
-0.348852694,
-0.8785207272,
0.4275049865,
0.2392407805,
0.0708114803,
-0.081975691,
0.704673171,
-0.0989224315,
0.143469587,
-0.8303847313,
0.0017446374,
-0.1358945966,
-0.5426796079,
-0.2973797321,
-0.4804406762,
-0.4545000196,
0.1393595934,
0.7508755922,
-0.1145837754,
0.1312287748,
0.3519615829,
-0.153695479,
-0.1581422389,
0.307641834,
0.9323512912,
0.408980459,
0.0501747355,
0.1819581389,
0.1304089278,
-0.2691086531,
0.1549285799,
-0.1333950758,
-0.4636430144,
-0.1026054546,
0.5307830572,
0.6584615707,
0.072118856,
-0.5731253624,
0.3478101492,
-0.0548209064,
-0.4639832079,
-0.3126623929,
0.1338272691,
-0.0624202192,
0.158584699,
-0.0060231904,
-0.3202017546,
-0.3492117226,
-0.2404479384,
0.1142035201,
0.6852370501,
-0.2392938137,
-0.1812872738,
0.5549072027,
0.4677575827,
-0.4765809178,
0.8162360191,
-0.3809786141,
-0.5606784821,
0.4399114847,
0.7704834938,
0.7923954129,
-0.009801005,
0.0341331474,
0.1241141781,
0.8036338091,
0.1588174999,
0.5283403397,
-0.3648056686,
-0.8634296656,
-0.5101830959,
-0.5581852198,
-0.4099060297,
-0.0286865067,
-0.6404451728,
0.0110452613,
-1.1277492046,
-0.0714197159,
-0.41781497,
0.0776158795,
-0.4094976485,
0.2833071649,
0.1135970131,
0.9875441194,
-0.3641864955,
1.1120434999,
0.4338793457,
0.1551622897,
-0.9316762686,
0.0487941727,
0.2349393368,
-0.9015988111,
0.3722306192,
0.1056816876,
-0.4457702637,
0.113897562,
-0.3517256379,
-0.7661850452,
0.9596120715,
0.3880403638,
-0.9441121817,
-0.0949828103,
0.4818179905,
0.2385545522,
-0.1398160756,
-0.1507053375,
0.3037189245,
0.496574223,
0.0242266152,
-0.6761730909,
0.2856498361,
-0.3295983672,
-0.0384563096,
0.8152139783,
-0.6643791795,
0.6104906201,
-0.1312575787,
-0.7242491841,
0.3998600245,
0.6895358562,
0.0798885226,
0.2113628238,
0.4025535583,
0.8840171099,
0.9472423792,
-0.0852512419,
1.0265203714,
-0.599262476,
-0.0386830792,
0.849930644,
-0.2148961127,
0.5709966421,
0.5920291543,
0.10055089,
0.6713027954,
0.6557646394,
0.1686628908,
0.5796113014,
0.4279577732,
-0.3268369436,
-0.4693754315,
-0.2802044749,
-0.1898237765,
0.2731824219,
0.6254402995,
-0.2384656221,
0.0158880539,
-0.4416113794,
0.1341232359,
0.5361202359,
-0.3899350166,
0.6231190562,
-0.0488055646,
-0.9787541032,
0.6921240687,
0.2274889946,
0.6560308337,
-0.8220040202,
0.2627830207,
-0.1062330604,
0.3691493571,
-0.2642315626,
-0.4444500208,
0.2213639319,
-0.1738643497,
-0.1226296052,
-0.2890952229,
0.4024660289,
-0.4206587672,
-0.5580704808,
0.2237449437,
0.2330629975,
-0.1613391042,
0.4524294436,
-0.5657600164,
0.3019346297,
0.2851419449,
0.0026287069,
-0.0052508861,
0.6674826741,
0.1532259583,
0.6754787564,
0.7677404881,
0.1873612106,
0.427216053,
-0.1700852364,
0.7930391431,
-0.8172392845,
-0.7426620722,
-0.9648026228,
0.2886851132,
0.1112978235,
-0.4220522046,
0.9781960249,
0.6211262941,
0.7065787315,
0.3567272127,
0.5701479912,
0.3147569597,
0.231801793,
-1.1033316851,
0.2031515688,
-0.5603433847,
0.3597263396,
-0.1751112491,
-0.7801772356,
-0.5073662996,
0.3569585681,
-0.3757131398,
-0.3815920055,
0.5462322235,
1.0761927366,
0.1944365799,
-0.0659152046,
0.2866735756,
0.0032729011,
0.526668787,
1.0124144554,
0.8218162656,
-0.1015448645,
0.8136005998,
-0.3854018748,
-0.2680989802,
0.1268345118,
-1.0386143923,
-0.9448605776,
-0.2481907606,
-0.2192980498,
-0.5120565891,
0.1433665603,
0.6544211507,
0.9217649102,
-0.3527545631,
-0.3421895802,
-0.5861377716,
0.2765919864,
-0.1177477017,
-0.1064746603,
0.2558219731,
-0.1133519188,
-0.9766122103,
0.6794997454,
0.3472815156,
0.1216090694,
-0.3736124933,
-0.3604975939,
-0.0103309546,
0.4579415619,
0.2094031274,
0.4263551831,
-0.6245555878,
-0.0737589598,
-0.0438071676,
-0.2459210753,
0.0153396158,
1.2007529736,
-0.4997901022,
0.3033024967,
0.358779341,
0.7499492764,
0.4811161458,
0.1147249639,
0.7705435753,
-0.9172170162,
0.101201281,
0.3863249719,
0.1913609505,
0.3219952881,
-0.6804752946,
0.0541033894,
0.2347221375,
-0.5086438656,
-0.9115456343,
0.8037132621,
-0.698792696,
-0.4081811011,
1.0034474134,
0.0658914074,
-0.5232083797,
-0.1888300627,
0.0799656734,
0.3017421663,
-0.3273341656,
0.5202639103,
0.5282743573,
-0.3407761753,
-0.3634741604,
0.0446254127,
0.7265654206,
0.8118447065,
-0.4508608282,
0.2021750361,
0.5321934819,
0.1407891214,
0.2617094219,
0.7867310047,
0.0057788659,
0.0024712214,
0.2457872033,
-0.2408489287,
-0.299169004,
-0.5463367701,
-0.0854663402,
0.316767931,
0.0763292611,
-0.236430943
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04833v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.04833v2
|
Long Is More for Alignment: A Simple but Tough-to-Beat Baseline for Instruction Fine-Tuning
| 2024-02-07T13:32:11 | 2024-06-04T17:20:01 |
Hao Zhao, Maksym Andriushchenko, Francesco Croce, Nicolas Flammarion
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
There is a consensus that instruction fine-tuning of LLMs requires
high-quality data, but what are they? LIMA (NeurIPS 2023) and AlpaGasus (ICLR
2024) are state-of-the-art methods for selecting such high-quality examples,
either via manual curation or using GPT-3.5-Turbo as a quality scorer. We show
that the extremely simple baseline of selecting the 1,000 instructions with
longest responses -- that intuitively contain more learnable information and
are harder to overfit -- from standard datasets can consistently outperform
these sophisticated methods according to GPT-4 and PaLM-2 as judges, while
remaining competitive on the Open LLM benchmarks that test factual knowledge.
We demonstrate this for several LLMs (Llama-2-7B, Llama-2-13B, Mistral-7B-v0.1)
and datasets (Alpaca-52k, Evol-Instruct-70k). In addition, a lightweight
refinement of such long instructions can further improve the abilities of the
fine-tuned LLMs, and allows us to obtain competitive results on MT-Bench and
the 2nd highest-ranked Llama-2-7B-based model on AlpacaEval 2.0, while training
on only 1,000 examples and no extra preference data. We also conduct a thorough
analysis of our models to ensure that their enhanced performance is not simply
due to GPT-4's preference for longer responses. Overall, our findings suggest
that fine-tuning on the longest responses should be the default baseline for
any work on instruction fine-tuning. We provide our code at
https://github.com/tml-epfl/long-is-more-for-alignment.
|
[
-0.5543283224,
-0.6286752224,
0.5584993958,
-0.1016631201,
-0.416793257,
0.049052868,
-0.4564683437,
-0.722858429,
-0.0619701371,
0.4005866349,
-0.583201468,
-0.7550327778,
-0.7603367567,
0.0486266315,
-0.4658141434,
1.2948739529,
-0.2240225673,
-0.1863568872,
-0.2299820483,
-0.420306623,
-0.5420233011,
-0.2245093882,
-0.4905817509,
-0.3808039129,
0.6247528791,
0.7544025183,
0.8612027168,
1.1221880913,
0.6828737855,
0.2112486213,
-0.2263175994,
0.4123435915,
-0.5502520204,
-0.1647132933,
0.0766759142,
-0.5629607439,
-0.7516114712,
0.2103850543,
0.4738789499,
0.6827208996,
-0.1517782062,
0.4898083806,
0.1815148592,
1.0312685966,
-0.4829066992,
0.0599317923,
-0.1962407231,
0.0424910411,
-0.3161486685,
-0.3201333582,
-0.3322437406,
-0.7423610687,
0.1396506131,
-0.797857821,
-0.1250452399,
0.1348861158,
1.0204025507,
0.5664427876,
-0.4435759783,
-0.5953740478,
-0.656059444,
0.9665989876,
-0.5887085795,
0.5360333323,
0.3965767622,
0.4005974531,
-0.2676863074,
-0.5857669115,
-0.3344705701,
-0.3662700653,
0.1306705028,
0.2157158405,
0.1280730516,
0.0487456359,
0.4540421367,
0.3075720072,
-0.4353803396,
0.7146008015,
-0.4663503766,
0.0874275863,
0.4254610538,
0.2035216689,
-0.2151668221,
0.2592035532,
-0.5420851707,
-0.0185136553,
-1.2032477856,
0.2504722774,
0.5036206841,
0.0100567481,
-0.2129654884,
0.6372237802,
-0.335607022,
0.9904782176,
0.2917124629,
-0.4299981594,
0.0799443722,
-0.0849802941,
-0.1803233325,
0.1192113459,
0.4742693007,
0.6469579935,
0.1274496466,
0.0284733716,
-0.2972680628,
-0.1538771689,
0.0144483261,
-0.8319664598,
0.0185462721,
-0.0380270407,
-0.3794355392,
0.1593327075,
0.0163209215,
-0.6248419881,
-0.1453737319,
-1.0371125937,
0.3350939155,
-0.3809773326,
0.5943486691,
0.269405216,
0.1353242099,
0.8233027458,
0.404366076,
-0.8066213727,
0.4517017007,
1.170361042,
0.6685586572,
-0.4006149173,
-0.3777109385,
-0.6363588572,
0.0735438615,
-0.5875723362,
0.70116961,
-0.5457867384,
-0.2013774365,
-0.1723230332,
-0.0078688674,
0.2985477149,
-0.4908569753,
0.682700336,
-0.620649755,
0.5338094234,
-0.6561001539,
-0.8782298565,
0.0278988648,
0.0950159803,
-0.4688062966,
1.0333855152,
0.0467156693,
-0.2620503902,
0.6202899814,
-0.4861349463,
-0.4283232391,
-0.1859908849,
-0.1226540506,
-0.5211841464,
-0.0032973585,
0.2383717,
0.3760097921,
-0.5817784667,
0.0569856539,
-0.2502892911,
-0.7541761994,
-0.0031642539,
-0.4367090464,
0.4931709766,
0.16522865,
-0.5514070988,
-0.0198298357,
-0.7687225342,
0.1647958755,
-0.2405024916,
-0.6640619636,
0.1247800291,
-0.0015109623,
-0.6779141426,
0.0423029959,
0.4128701687,
-0.4414524436,
0.2312776595,
-0.2591529191,
0.3275357485,
1.0391997099,
-0.3101109862,
0.3490711153,
-0.5264852643,
0.3808449507,
-0.2827831209,
0.4518259168,
0.1049768031,
-0.4378709793,
-1.0540827513,
-0.074441053,
0.2269913703,
0.4899238646,
-0.2510329783,
0.7829379439,
-0.4880506098,
-0.4618119895,
-0.6267811656,
0.5266636014,
0.6340448856,
0.6216575503,
0.5936535001,
-0.3607627451,
-0.4118045866,
-0.7800194025,
0.1467909813,
0.164163664,
0.085208267,
0.1085188389,
0.416667521,
0.0477044284,
0.6215298176,
-0.5235151649,
-0.0888529196,
0.1551193595,
-0.0418310165,
0.4028552771,
0.2870593667,
0.4559117854,
-0.260397464,
-0.472815007,
0.0568337142,
-0.6615178585,
0.0237599351,
0.0471775681,
-0.4099923074,
0.1284447461,
0.477296561,
-0.6487699747,
0.2348038554,
0.4036133587,
0.0750683397,
0.3921609521,
-0.1571134329,
0.0843022317,
-0.7808132768,
-0.0921357125,
-0.0884932205,
-0.1432602555,
-0.2453943193,
0.2476362288,
0.1920478791,
0.2073646486,
-0.2933233976,
0.2951887846,
-0.6055647135,
-0.2016851008,
-0.4270982444,
-0.0181030035,
0.1674876064,
0.4360190928,
-0.1255271286,
0.9332577586,
0.2042390853,
-0.6230741739,
0.6519091725,
0.159116745,
-0.7188096046,
0.6136848927,
-0.7474368215,
0.3930934966,
-0.099530451,
0.3457019031,
-0.70248276,
-0.3085979819,
-0.04194602,
-0.1685064733,
0.5541997552,
-0.1721622497,
-0.3308408856,
-0.4813961089,
-0.5059263706,
0.1746901274,
0.8583235145,
-0.8676400185,
-0.0281158797,
0.0104276277,
-0.0506638736,
-0.9307793379,
-0.4612870812,
-0.102918759,
-0.3369961679,
-0.2775574923,
0.2373937666,
-0.1938234568,
0.1275031418,
-0.4193399847,
-0.4820875823,
0.1064965278,
0.1483452469,
0.2733877897,
0.2547428906,
-0.5159980655,
0.0135797933,
0.1380913407,
-0.2819902003,
-0.011410078,
-0.234358117,
0.4666140079,
-0.1236099154,
-0.7038223147,
-0.7765313983,
0.1321111172,
0.5815093517,
-0.1950356066,
0.5085334778,
0.526923418,
-0.0935730934,
0.080524005,
-0.632989943,
0.0347740576,
-0.4782168567,
0.1352657974,
-0.1340521872,
-0.7796162963,
0.26274243,
-0.0956049263,
0.3465987444,
0.2754428089,
0.3660291433,
-0.3453969657,
0.9008454084,
0.5793099999,
-0.2680243254,
0.4701380432,
-0.3239522576,
-0.1057798937,
-0.9013769627,
-0.3352166712,
-0.4855105579,
-0.6588375568,
-0.5736913085,
-0.4022637904,
0.2584888935,
0.0909863636,
-0.6235419512,
0.2735325396,
-0.7151480317,
0.9375244379,
0.6628298759,
0.2438814938,
0.1599299759,
-0.0799318105,
0.1478809267,
-0.0199221987,
-0.2904754877,
-0.7002686858,
1.1728477478,
0.3732943237,
1.0078982115,
0.173101142,
0.895930171,
-0.140022561,
0.1814982295,
-0.8485700488,
0.4423324466,
-0.272613138,
-0.277344048,
-0.3078995049,
-0.1828411669,
-0.9885735512,
-0.4056505561,
0.1299841702,
-0.3052322865,
0.036602091,
0.1687233001,
-0.7779160142,
0.0391021371,
-0.6899621487,
0.4536620975,
-0.5825299621,
-0.4046085775,
-0.0205361303,
-0.8498289585,
0.1650539339,
0.1084660739,
-0.0928834379,
-0.3119701445,
-0.4014784992,
0.816659987,
-0.3825163245,
0.7493197918,
-0.061988391,
-0.2160383165,
0.2835519314,
-0.2362096459,
0.5706233978,
-0.0341286212,
-0.1899673641,
-0.1504554898,
-0.1883145124,
-0.5705644488,
-0.6013807654,
0.8658081293,
-1.0198922157,
-0.7359883189,
-0.1330733299,
-0.1963996142,
-0.1292127371,
0.1257583797,
0.412053287,
0.3587813675,
0.1257591993,
0.4380974472,
0.8586369157,
-0.1282058209,
0.2288537621,
0.3071208298,
0.239274323,
-0.3432990909,
0.8727730513,
0.287050426,
0.3721628487,
0.566270113,
0.1854848117,
-0.2673023045,
-0.736731708,
-0.6012957692,
0.0178700369,
-0.7769892216,
-0.5398691297,
-0.2020893544,
-0.160680443,
-0.1259823591,
-0.2220301628,
-0.336060524,
-0.4637689292,
-0.484135747,
-0.3317265213,
0.3608704507,
0.7510899901,
0.2045771778,
0.5521687865,
-0.5893779993,
0.3784156144,
0.4973159134,
0.4684945643,
-0.2114754468,
-0.7313681841,
-0.2419475764,
0.0772032067,
-0.5550101995,
-0.5878639817,
-0.0236526784,
0.3810479343,
0.4285143018,
0.4139975309,
-0.2859038413,
1.2228519917,
-0.4691167474,
0.6354002953,
0.026134422,
-0.6849075556,
0.4375727773,
-0.0491637625,
0.2487229407,
0.6643925309,
0.572471261,
-0.2104072422,
-0.1472413391,
-0.2533088923,
-0.775277555,
0.506596446,
-0.144242689,
0.1102881357,
0.034707576,
0.6705752611,
0.5920313597,
0.1939539313,
-0.4914202392,
-0.1003349274,
-0.0565464534,
-0.2849856913,
-0.0420129411,
-0.2632018328,
-0.3555513024,
-0.431655854,
0.515334487,
-0.1953774691,
0.2400675714,
-0.1787553579,
-0.1309282333,
-0.1754954755,
0.3023462296,
0.7736976743,
0.8846437335,
-0.1092450172,
-0.0715852082,
0.4515124559,
-0.22619313,
0.1013047025,
0.0563700199,
-0.0833494663,
-0.3364573717,
0.6096081138,
0.8972975016,
0.13772659,
-0.260166347,
0.4542632401,
0.2401854396,
-0.0316909663,
-0.2021142542,
0.2862421274,
0.0070182104,
0.1719977409,
0.0837945193,
-0.1742564589,
0.0045815348,
-0.4792168438,
0.1357869953,
0.3294511437,
-0.2631973326,
-0.2450310588,
0.3639364541,
0.1046638042,
-0.0705961436,
0.6055721641,
-0.1424752027,
-0.2104825526,
0.7468716502,
0.3877722025,
0.1908299625,
-0.0198663007,
-0.0552607141,
0.3639489114,
0.1505179554,
-0.3318825066,
0.3134878278,
-0.1885203868,
-0.1874632686,
-0.5638195872,
-0.6795439124,
-0.5415856242,
0.1140274033,
-0.9266235828,
0.5285791159,
-0.8986846805,
-0.1525795758,
-0.0749000162,
0.236573264,
-0.7559169531,
0.1747594476,
0.1747071594,
0.8191127777,
-0.5547996759,
0.6795630455,
0.4545865953,
-0.0673293844,
-0.804233253,
-0.3174376786,
0.0591349415,
-1.2018305063,
0.4915591478,
0.3600803316,
-0.0039016628,
-0.2215041369,
-0.749204576,
-1.0216283798,
1.3925286531,
0.5764210224,
-0.9130160809,
-0.3235281706,
0.1416721344,
0.6914005876,
-0.1041448191,
0.3680637777,
0.8342612982,
0.370372653,
0.1956582665,
-0.9187686443,
-0.1419195682,
0.1831891984,
-0.3063739836,
0.5257165432,
-1.0064263344,
0.7782409191,
-0.3468615413,
0.0243756752,
0.4616283476,
0.7914347053,
0.2974055111,
0.2982589304,
0.0526037067,
0.8358489275,
0.8714801073,
-0.2069476843,
0.8525872827,
-0.3164799511,
0.1304932088,
1.4594781399,
-0.2087475955,
0.8099914789,
0.4808513224,
-0.1661325246,
0.4989005923,
0.7766202688,
-0.0766182989,
0.3550307155,
0.3046815693,
0.1009256542,
-0.2317391187,
0.0688701421,
-0.5041455626,
0.4979685545,
0.3559387922,
-0.211055398,
-0.2003512383,
-0.2319244593,
0.0754572898,
0.010020325,
-0.1681777537,
0.8336539268,
0.1659275591,
-0.8421960473,
0.8854430914,
-0.0730182081,
0.6940808296,
-0.3314123452,
-0.1466666609,
-0.3887723088,
0.0327802934,
-0.2985159755,
-1.0216591358,
-0.0611420907,
0.2047704756,
0.0296131559,
-0.1412181109,
0.1301056296,
-0.1008853167,
-0.1930230856,
0.1147781536,
0.3077455759,
0.1334671527,
0.4791563153,
-0.6857711077,
-0.0439404026,
-0.1392934471,
-0.2489241064,
0.3759465814,
0.3831114471,
-0.1850448251,
0.7032541037,
0.6480067372,
0.0391606204,
0.2892386317,
-0.0385784023,
0.7734854817,
-0.6461794376,
-0.0493471399,
-0.925978601,
0.0980663076,
-0.0959745795,
-0.6535181999,
0.4470051825,
0.7319962978,
0.9503605366,
0.2992488146,
0.1428754032,
0.298168093,
0.4224373698,
-0.8819959164,
0.2423194945,
-0.4156608582,
0.3679271638,
0.2070202827,
-1.0375387669,
-0.0893051922,
0.4302282631,
-0.30759269,
0.0581271164,
0.5418477654,
0.587529242,
-0.1945674717,
0.0335671827,
0.1915521771,
-0.0770769194,
0.3744509816,
1.0219191313,
1.0361847878,
-0.3004152179,
0.5500962734,
-0.4161230028,
-0.1250237823,
-0.2391330153,
-0.7837486267,
-0.7911401391,
-0.1527663767,
-0.1174405962,
-0.0758523569,
0.2823858261,
1.1915112734,
0.6015346646,
-0.65141958,
-0.3242464066,
0.2343572229,
0.1235828027,
-0.1085206196,
-0.0791010782,
0.4923675656,
-0.3036185205,
-0.6550662518,
0.3848653138,
0.1929756105,
0.3634172678,
0.2833322585,
-0.2778069675,
0.2007535547,
-0.1326782256,
0.6076878905,
0.4322113097,
-0.6755698919,
-0.4920566678,
0.1325865239,
-0.3682278693,
0.4400810897,
0.4134283364,
-0.5098230839,
0.105095312,
0.2525600195,
0.6818714142,
0.3667023182,
0.0609499328,
0.3503804803,
-0.6406086087,
-0.0214602109,
0.2759796381,
0.3613506258,
0.2495508939,
-0.3716411293,
0.4739892483,
-0.2609629333,
-0.8119869828,
-0.7730372548,
0.2243981212,
-1.0453323126,
0.128176704,
1.1002099514,
-0.2571650743,
-0.3293962777,
0.2320557237,
-0.2200191915,
0.4092448354,
-0.4162168205,
0.8728095293,
0.7705293298,
-0.4004704654,
0.0860194713,
-0.6085733175,
0.5242230892,
0.6442459226,
-0.9309985638,
-0.0928026885,
0.4979340434,
0.3035405576,
-0.0144473314,
0.1956556886,
-0.1578323543,
0.6354737282,
-0.5542439818,
-0.377315253,
-0.2073314637,
-0.5745966434,
-0.2478967309,
-0.0615977943,
0.4122910202,
-0.1096209139
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.