id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03620v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03620v1
|
Self-Discover: Large Language Models Self-Compose Reasoning Structures
| 2024-02-06T01:13:53 | 2024-02-06T01:13:53 |
Pei Zhou, Jay Pujara, Xiang Ren, Xinyun Chen, Heng-Tze Cheng, Quoc V. Le, Ed H. Chi, Denny Zhou, Swaroop Mishra, Huaixiu Steven Zheng
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We introduce SELF-DISCOVER, a general framework for LLMs to self-discover the
task-intrinsic reasoning structures to tackle complex reasoning problems that
are challenging for typical prompting methods. Core to the framework is a
self-discovery process where LLMs select multiple atomic reasoning modules such
as critical thinking and step-by-step thinking, and compose them into an
explicit reasoning structure for LLMs to follow during decoding. SELF-DISCOVER
substantially improves GPT-4 and PaLM 2's performance on challenging reasoning
benchmarks such as BigBench-Hard, grounded agent reasoning, and MATH, by as
much as 32% compared to Chain of Thought (CoT). Furthermore, SELF-DISCOVER
outperforms inference-intensive methods such as CoT-Self-Consistency by more
than 20%, while requiring 10-40x fewer inference compute. Finally, we show that
the self-discovered reasoning structures are universally applicable across
model families: from PaLM 2-L to GPT-4, and from GPT-4 to Llama2, and share
commonalities with human reasoning patterns.
|
[
-0.251571238,
-0.7112934589,
1.0288468599,
0.1688987464,
0.2612172961,
0.0249965228,
-0.0225413088,
-0.5053998828,
0.0924988464,
0.4801632464,
-0.6483193636,
-0.4602763355,
-0.2809256911,
0.1010043547,
-0.1798316091,
0.4817944765,
-0.1312329918,
-0.1636861563,
-0.0065471311,
0.1312084198,
-0.2116937786,
-0.7227526903,
-0.3816218674,
-0.4813347459,
0.4505227208,
0.5525956154,
0.3699841201,
0.7590637803,
0.1289250702,
0.3348171115,
-0.011958003,
0.182466045,
-0.237219125,
0.5519484282,
-0.7281756401,
-0.5661728382,
-0.5414227843,
-0.2201082259,
0.4437378943,
0.535507977,
-0.0786575526,
0.1098449156,
-0.1573528349,
0.9420409799,
-0.4513479769,
0.2888466418,
-0.6055848598,
0.0904593468,
-0.2472602427,
-0.1683348119,
-0.4198090732,
0.1019823626,
0.1955892146,
-0.4175184071,
0.5260834694,
0.1781460345,
0.1783243567,
0.1839961857,
-0.6342799664,
-0.4097411036,
-0.685439229,
0.6164529324,
-0.467900902,
0.3214504123,
0.3961492777,
0.4097905755,
-0.3394183218,
-0.5240318179,
-0.4624254704,
-0.3329437375,
0.1293099523,
-0.010699546,
-0.0058691856,
0.1751182228,
0.325740695,
0.5081102252,
-0.7422878742,
0.1184118837,
-0.1871835738,
-0.4792544544,
0.7071550488,
0.1970456541,
0.2025362849,
-0.1473963708,
-0.3104780912,
0.1612769514,
-1.2585171461,
-0.3016959131,
0.1710674316,
0.122558102,
0.1254103035,
0.5111256838,
-0.452036351,
0.4568085968,
0.1402977854,
-0.0596015975,
0.2057765126,
-0.3816627562,
-0.1419412643,
0.0873314515,
0.68465662,
-0.1398794502,
0.1866274923,
0.0639629066,
-0.3711208999,
-0.159180209,
-0.0361696519,
-0.6784203053,
-0.6787876487,
0.1857279092,
-0.463981241,
0.1223095059,
-0.2010228336,
-0.1610538214,
-0.397075206,
-0.3846221268,
0.5452190042,
-0.2947380543,
-0.5019959807,
0.2486280948,
-0.1383396089,
0.2629761994,
0.6918199062,
-1.2190852165,
0.2249091715,
0.5741730928,
0.652559638,
-0.0813491419,
-0.3317485154,
-0.2020592988,
0.4384035468,
-0.5111766458,
1.1509298086,
-0.3137605786,
-0.3405330777,
-0.2361646146,
-0.1535301507,
0.1383033246,
-0.6331354976,
0.4866054058,
-0.3052509427,
0.0284181703,
-0.7822364569,
-0.8344168663,
-0.1777369082,
0.501503706,
-0.6017910242,
1.1022646427,
0.1705268174,
-0.5683217645,
-0.0924101993,
-0.7774046659,
-0.4601102769,
0.202383399,
-0.3200648725,
-0.1300421804,
0.1058092937,
0.3403750062,
0.641607821,
-0.5058105588,
0.1479174495,
-0.4053375125,
-0.1872473359,
0.0506155342,
-0.3618895113,
0.4686583579,
0.3534915447,
-0.786473155,
0.215877831,
-0.5144429207,
0.0651343018,
0.3990935385,
-0.1516105384,
-0.0436924733,
0.0991719514,
-0.5994884968,
0.1987664998,
0.405952692,
-0.4315925539,
0.6134795547,
-0.4016603827,
0.7488906384,
0.870924592,
-0.0141347414,
0.5135624409,
-0.1703223288,
0.4211368561,
0.2121048272,
0.0659412369,
-0.4743187726,
-0.2132478058,
-0.8820337653,
-0.0297845844,
-0.0276085176,
0.3290286958,
-0.4142666459,
0.392224282,
0.0431905128,
-0.4894619584,
-0.3185810149,
0.3177535534,
0.4260482788,
0.4827004373,
0.4474420846,
0.0687916428,
-0.3177112639,
-1.0772526264,
-0.2553846836,
-0.1976683438,
0.170426175,
0.2678447068,
0.6191447973,
-0.5846569538,
0.6575542092,
-0.5346013308,
-0.150341168,
-0.4068779349,
0.0418239869,
0.0767591894,
0.4756243527,
0.2311498523,
-0.5456596613,
-0.4651988447,
-0.1212637648,
-0.8654096723,
0.0160970408,
0.0189677719,
-0.0711062402,
0.2959364653,
0.6217960119,
-0.6660612226,
0.1971470565,
0.1844006628,
-0.3020176589,
0.7995025516,
-0.2690204978,
-0.1132423431,
-0.6890779734,
-0.1537242979,
-0.3189038932,
-0.2693429589,
-0.3341950476,
0.0717212111,
0.1455121189,
0.3226055801,
-0.0963052735,
0.7904565334,
-1.0561888218,
-0.3793435693,
-0.3912271261,
0.1208146513,
-0.0509956442,
0.4239247441,
0.0092945183,
0.918118,
0.8997166157,
-0.7096750736,
0.2408301532,
0.1016242281,
-0.4015723169,
0.31408602,
-0.65769279,
0.3561619818,
-0.1238977239,
0.5019747019,
-0.8684626818,
-0.2537356317,
0.1532607526,
-0.3212355375,
0.1164974198,
-0.0672557205,
-0.570502162,
-0.5337562561,
-0.2147372365,
0.4509939253,
0.132854864,
-0.8620337248,
0.8568407297,
0.3970400095,
-0.1047889069,
-0.5662347078,
-0.4067927599,
-0.0304199103,
0.044293724,
-0.5276111364,
0.2693669498,
-0.4561703205,
-0.0248432532,
-0.2278835624,
-0.4650052488,
0.1286187619,
0.2563597858,
0.4502591491,
-0.0734064877,
-0.2813003659,
0.4753499627,
0.1224611327,
-0.1242737249,
0.2470204979,
-0.5597652197,
0.5814888477,
-0.5678467155,
-0.5939519405,
-0.3098373413,
0.3968916237,
0.3938672841,
-0.3111825883,
0.1803317517,
0.3978722692,
-0.3015057147,
-0.5297264457,
-0.8511485457,
-0.2680887282,
-0.5097442865,
0.0295456648,
-0.9484093785,
-1.2878541946,
0.5623899102,
-0.2439316362,
-0.1796737164,
0.8116217256,
0.8329414129,
-0.0872689933,
1.2500576973,
0.4262732267,
-0.2390327752,
0.1294086277,
-0.2762706876,
0.1392682493,
-0.9057719111,
-0.3346635103,
-0.3098285496,
-0.043474026,
-0.385030061,
-0.4755969346,
0.440149188,
0.1513564736,
-0.5435966849,
0.2451445162,
-0.6689163446,
0.7293891907,
0.7860164046,
0.0668758452,
0.4629558623,
-0.2619017959,
-0.4657122195,
0.3987667263,
-0.696862638,
-0.4248781502,
1.236348629,
0.4009691179,
0.8585624695,
0.3230921626,
1.1131666899,
0.3308244348,
0.3680801988,
-0.6611824632,
0.6094667912,
0.3845695853,
-1.0010451078,
-0.4376854002,
-0.5284765363,
-1.0407207012,
0.2236198187,
0.1122750193,
-0.7031700015,
-0.2302235514,
0.4077588022,
-0.3466876149,
0.1811298281,
-0.6492784619,
0.7608445287,
-0.4595456719,
-0.2311126739,
-0.5835651159,
-0.7118055224,
0.4853368998,
0.1598818153,
0.08058016,
-0.2871448398,
0.1695717722,
0.4953220487,
-0.2271630019,
0.8575297594,
-0.0965870172,
-0.4237574935,
0.7350972891,
0.5801948905,
0.5101593137,
0.0888101384,
0.0130719775,
-0.1452572942,
0.0269730166,
-0.2910151184,
-0.8463215232,
0.8666912317,
-0.7657935023,
-1.0455029011,
-0.5861925483,
-0.4215503037,
-0.1150281504,
0.3807433546,
0.2093745619,
0.4104239345,
-0.1487633288,
-0.0043681259,
0.8507599831,
0.2442992926,
0.2387258261,
0.8106300235,
-0.2471666336,
-0.2078671604,
0.6719233394,
0.1052046716,
0.2183357924,
0.6302796602,
0.420971185,
-0.6589952707,
-0.5330935717,
-0.3566394746,
0.4069201052,
-0.9650194645,
-0.3129075766,
-0.6935825944,
-0.2336103171,
-0.4508694708,
0.0133865289,
-0.5303118229,
-0.5500646234,
-0.1315648854,
-0.4263191223,
-0.0110279815,
1.0738096237,
-0.4124120474,
0.1211145073,
-0.6647294164,
0.356623143,
0.5506411195,
0.2430874556,
0.2155273706,
-0.2615211606,
-0.0444775745,
-0.0891288295,
-0.4833618701,
-0.7916449308,
0.1602845639,
-0.0658011138,
0.7669927478,
0.4440636337,
0.035532482,
0.4886628985,
-0.480479598,
0.6135727167,
0.1352196932,
-1.3061498404,
0.7249810696,
-0.4757022858,
0.2905850112,
0.2505474985,
0.404471755,
-0.2009963393,
0.0204942189,
-0.8590325117,
-0.5526836514,
0.2513239086,
0.0817899182,
-0.2053450197,
-0.1771222949,
0.5601014495,
0.01558387,
0.050832577,
-0.9123085737,
-0.1964823157,
-0.0981817245,
-0.0710582435,
-0.0304521956,
-0.4911362231,
-0.2452762574,
-0.3104654551,
0.5496652722,
-0.5187110305,
0.3675483763,
0.7373565435,
-0.212518543,
-0.1251637191,
0.3627632856,
0.4586803317,
0.6625362635,
0.0141966585,
0.6315668225,
0.1204165146,
0.1455732584,
0.2823266685,
-0.2330844998,
0.1348018795,
-0.4472360909,
0.5102867484,
0.5317998528,
0.2718528807,
-0.7067971826,
0.3414663374,
0.1491731107,
-0.2637185752,
-0.5765558481,
0.4302234054,
0.2609466314,
0.5603747964,
0.3322633505,
-0.2801375687,
0.4631733596,
-0.9168843031,
0.1159804389,
0.5570896864,
-0.0387991406,
-0.4036220908,
0.5304104686,
0.1677260846,
-0.082923308,
0.5665043592,
-0.4509077668,
-0.9313792586,
0.4173849821,
0.8658103943,
0.7819861174,
-0.4653740823,
0.2353356034,
0.3711886704,
0.2614534497,
-0.5071361065,
0.4149764478,
-0.6536145806,
-0.9761016369,
-0.3926507235,
-0.2463026196,
-0.5937328935,
-0.0698312074,
-0.4074702561,
-0.1715806127,
-0.649568975,
0.0776536539,
0.0521556176,
0.201446116,
-0.4960970283,
0.1521669328,
0.211396873,
0.8221855164,
-0.4686560035,
0.8378815651,
0.3300119042,
-0.1100579128,
-1.0848921537,
-0.3396888077,
0.2693262398,
-0.9313464761,
0.7109376192,
0.4565281272,
-0.3966053724,
0.1321232915,
-0.7733285427,
-1.1663345098,
1.2654805183,
0.2469075918,
-0.734872818,
-0.0977598727,
-0.2546690106,
0.4009336829,
-0.4645625949,
0.4018793106,
0.5662325621,
0.4775906801,
0.303925693,
-0.941863358,
0.2423438877,
-0.0726589337,
-0.38064605,
0.3498713374,
-0.6608102918,
0.9770579934,
-0.6093500853,
-0.2648031414,
0.0288379602,
0.8071753383,
0.530612886,
0.2551340163,
0.3927945495,
0.4739551544,
1.0438710451,
0.107840769,
0.8517380953,
-0.2512757778,
0.3466153443,
1.1568932533,
-0.4601503611,
0.7367370725,
-0.0899834484,
-0.1499317884,
0.8206394911,
0.5634579062,
0.0370043144,
0.0994914025,
0.3067457378,
-0.2138921618,
-0.6959924102,
0.3430515826,
-0.4590145051,
0.3755660653,
0.6435682178,
-0.1712344587,
-0.1815323234,
-0.3226473033,
0.0377489999,
-0.028346343,
-0.446069777,
0.6495948434,
0.2296066582,
-0.8873096108,
0.5635123849,
0.0413103811,
0.2723759413,
-0.4916247129,
-0.0050753434,
-0.1721840501,
0.2639902532,
-0.2290805131,
-0.9832348228,
0.0843447372,
-0.5223491788,
-0.2744036615,
-0.2533136606,
0.9376352429,
-0.3334960938,
-0.2029859573,
0.4914104939,
0.8737804294,
0.185959205,
-0.5514684916,
-0.7355974913,
-0.1852746308,
0.062412411,
-0.3305652738,
0.3502512574,
0.644773066,
-0.105474636,
1.2104021311,
0.6754497886,
-0.2377489954,
-0.0706910118,
0.1225181371,
0.9394382238,
-1.1862339973,
-0.4635766745,
-0.8841120601,
0.08565972,
0.0114426874,
-0.0793675259,
0.8973163366,
0.6964322329,
0.5980761051,
-0.0639319941,
0.9008223414,
0.2405908555,
0.6886594892,
-0.6692224741,
0.3177081048,
-0.2743294239,
0.2664065957,
-0.0792827457,
-0.8925353289,
-0.1121703163,
0.753559649,
-0.3013646603,
-0.0308465306,
0.783295393,
0.772246182,
0.1126744151,
0.1106250286,
0.2202225327,
0.4334602356,
0.5915673375,
0.7978557348,
1.0224784613,
-0.0862423778,
0.1652141064,
0.0367223881,
-0.2532524467,
-0.0763241351,
-0.7743057013,
-1.1639175415,
-0.7131028175,
-0.1697403491,
-0.2105830461,
-0.1575673521,
1.0115494728,
0.7764402032,
-0.6946950555,
-0.3194478154,
-0.3734615445,
0.5021823645,
-0.0584152564,
-0.1997196227,
0.356272012,
-0.4111694098,
-0.3776257038,
0.9704438448,
0.5270065069,
0.177621901,
-0.5840911865,
-0.1351117492,
0.0288395714,
-0.0021121805,
0.7781500816,
0.5873888731,
-0.8792933822,
-0.3099476993,
0.0412195064,
0.0633616745,
0.0579147041,
1.0604423285,
-0.8757004738,
0.3272752464,
0.3072724938,
0.4023527503,
0.7938652039,
-0.0281728264,
0.6117771268,
-0.2544561625,
-0.1497879326,
0.3699928522,
0.6013275385,
0.2493076771,
-0.381991297,
0.691452384,
0.2384475023,
-0.8676016331,
-0.5834358335,
0.7778896093,
-1.0343523026,
-0.4880282879,
1.1133158207,
-0.0385500416,
-0.1748028696,
-0.1363027543,
-0.2392380536,
-0.2008933127,
-0.2696154118,
0.7362086773,
0.5121206641,
-0.5245290399,
-0.3401880562,
-0.151551947,
0.6339526176,
0.4208200574,
-0.8870823383,
0.1721220613,
0.5793632269,
0.6289120317,
0.2416239083,
0.995777905,
-0.053040877,
0.1286543161,
-0.1680202782,
0.0021218851,
-0.0635420829,
-0.766882658,
0.0093450649,
0.1978272349,
0.2154202014,
0.3853548765
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03618v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03618v1
|
Comparing Abstraction in Humans and Large Language Models Using Multimodal Serial Reproduction
| 2024-02-06T01:07:56 | 2024-02-06T01:07:56 |
Sreejan Kumar, Raja Marjieh, Byron Zhang, Declan Campbell, Michael Y. Hu, Umang Bhatt, Brenden Lake, Thomas L. Griffiths
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, q-bio.NC
|
Humans extract useful abstractions of the world from noisy sensory data.
Serial reproduction allows us to study how people construe the world through a
paradigm similar to the game of telephone, where one person observes a stimulus
and reproduces it for the next to form a chain of reproductions. Past serial
reproduction experiments typically employ a single sensory modality, but humans
often communicate abstractions of the world to each other through language. To
investigate the effect language on the formation of abstractions, we implement
a novel multimodal serial reproduction framework by asking people who receive a
visual stimulus to reproduce it in a linguistic format, and vice versa. We ran
unimodal and multimodal chains with both humans and GPT-4 and find that adding
language as a modality has a larger effect on human reproductions than GPT-4's.
This suggests human visual and linguistic representations are more dissociable
than those of GPT-4.
|
[
-0.4431697428,
-0.6095248461,
0.5701568127,
0.5043153167,
-0.316698879,
0.305875659,
-0.2081113607,
-0.8852253556,
-0.0185645036,
0.053143125,
-0.0707425997,
-0.0710596293,
-0.4082347453,
0.2300068736,
-0.3760263622,
0.6241174936,
0.2779398263,
0.1873638481,
-0.436938256,
0.0453995727,
-0.1282119453,
-0.8940200806,
-0.6893467307,
-0.4942416549,
0.6051514745,
-0.1395510882,
0.7019367218,
0.6592740417,
0.3496153951,
0.5010070205,
-0.0359640568,
0.0610723943,
-0.2598218322,
0.0592355989,
-0.0927919224,
-0.3720463216,
-0.3184620738,
0.0771335736,
0.6774165034,
0.8615652323,
0.0114532877,
-0.1173809841,
0.115270175,
0.4730829,
-0.4063806534,
0.3530575037,
-0.1359669864,
0.1031051427,
-0.271553576,
-0.312893033,
-0.3556050956,
-0.1538069099,
0.0798346996,
-0.5083855391,
0.0596859194,
-0.1141931638,
0.505941093,
-0.0037825131,
-0.6111806035,
-0.2606946826,
-1.0721242428,
0.5285393,
-0.6642960906,
0.769276619,
0.38105914,
-0.291642189,
-0.1248486042,
-0.6901305914,
-0.8414517045,
-0.5962531567,
-0.2913295329,
0.1978156567,
-0.1019578725,
0.2665748596,
0.520591557,
0.1240252703,
-0.4783053696,
-0.2555716336,
-0.7510101795,
-0.2229883373,
0.362203449,
-0.0111332294,
0.5331582427,
-0.1988220215,
-0.4966225624,
0.0349945873,
-0.2444482595,
-0.0969628543,
0.669780314,
-0.0445032753,
0.0122291939,
0.1648930758,
0.0105073843,
0.7438643575,
0.0569849163,
-0.2278223634,
0.5539035797,
-0.5071766973,
0.0766213834,
-0.2771094441,
0.9253569841,
0.6018105149,
0.1264681518,
-0.3840471804,
-0.2044988424,
0.4744791687,
0.1907049865,
-0.8036596775,
-0.0612343289,
-0.0865856558,
-0.6241265535,
-0.2341480106,
0.064971976,
-0.6891223192,
-0.3866440952,
-0.4354529977,
0.4390793443,
-0.3296769857,
-0.4722633362,
0.2262828499,
-0.440577209,
0.0478463359,
0.1217634678,
-1.1535166502,
0.6868314147,
0.5563587546,
0.9417381883,
-0.1473905891,
-0.6690619588,
-0.0889667273,
-0.1017468125,
-0.5053278804,
0.8343912363,
-0.4323224723,
-0.3419051468,
-0.5373307467,
-0.1982958466,
0.182780236,
-0.843110323,
0.2260035574,
-0.5418094397,
0.3098876774,
-0.2752214074,
-0.2619209886,
-0.1691920608,
0.0748980567,
-0.7990758419,
0.5802301168,
0.189665392,
-0.5156787038,
0.4662447572,
-0.7028160095,
-0.3676513433,
0.0942627117,
-0.4430977106,
-0.2556889653,
0.1527317166,
-0.1647716463,
0.2636185586,
-0.2414408475,
0.009673981,
-0.1751290709,
-0.2998631597,
0.5268682837,
-0.4797878861,
0.5159704089,
0.2157612145,
-0.4223088622,
-0.00583944,
-0.5488186479,
-0.1075566337,
0.0189486239,
-0.5482152104,
-0.4622421265,
0.2389727682,
0.0835808069,
0.6097242832,
0.0410198346,
-0.5611897111,
0.1331169009,
-0.2453897595,
0.7399874926,
0.478928715,
0.2413087934,
0.5683867931,
-0.5072225332,
0.3451425731,
0.6813241243,
0.2011041343,
-0.2283645719,
-0.629983604,
-0.386089921,
-0.2338154912,
0.104888007,
0.2226941437,
-0.5323079228,
-0.1865507662,
-0.2643923163,
-0.1978599131,
-0.1829361916,
0.3206420243,
0.528531909,
0.041373942,
0.0305604897,
-0.7288395762,
-0.5112066269,
-1.0035675764,
0.0813174546,
-0.2368259281,
-0.0365325436,
0.2647268176,
0.3995806873,
-0.269790113,
0.8581157327,
-0.2704393268,
-0.1487928927,
0.0111628128,
0.5070930123,
-0.2223027349,
0.4229625463,
0.7522439957,
-0.8262853026,
-0.1636907756,
0.1310280859,
-1.0231881142,
0.2809167802,
-0.1230134219,
0.0437623449,
0.2549943328,
0.3629654348,
-0.6399732232,
0.4684396386,
0.5460208654,
-0.471580565,
0.5397713184,
-0.388015449,
0.4887127578,
-0.9743345976,
-0.1360028088,
-0.193699941,
-0.29450804,
-0.6100379229,
-0.0700552016,
0.0108655849,
-0.0916745663,
-0.3976210356,
0.2709446549,
-0.8165604472,
-0.5417231917,
-0.1468130201,
0.0738002881,
-0.1102459952,
0.6192147136,
0.0764677376,
0.7773258686,
0.4155431092,
-0.5792202353,
0.4540600777,
0.0877783448,
-0.5010352731,
0.2684462965,
-0.695546031,
0.2990942597,
-0.2962535024,
0.2156215459,
-1.0204683542,
-0.3269156814,
0.1881218255,
-0.383287847,
-0.078353487,
0.1469532996,
-0.4101659358,
-0.3458354771,
-0.3260267079,
0.8443779349,
0.6359871626,
-0.2641506791,
0.4925548136,
0.192174837,
-0.2525897622,
-0.4246757627,
-0.7474365234,
0.1422148943,
-0.1801891327,
-0.5799936056,
0.078702338,
-0.1514719576,
-0.5511268973,
-0.0973020941,
0.0071655931,
-0.2027252316,
0.0183153786,
0.3457870483,
0.1809166223,
-0.0437020846,
0.2265204489,
-0.108207874,
0.0183511004,
0.2344812602,
-0.1174150631,
0.6691508889,
-0.2136863917,
-0.4226802588,
-0.5611642599,
0.6373150349,
0.9207972288,
-0.2185660154,
0.4496412277,
0.2312671393,
-0.258420676,
0.1991447359,
-0.395508498,
-0.3615653813,
-0.4773980677,
0.5993743539,
-0.4824163616,
-0.4131661057,
0.5671975613,
-0.1499315351,
-0.0910453051,
-0.1657293737,
0.6399484873,
0.0526703522,
1.0443631411,
0.3178247213,
0.0839494914,
0.5334177613,
-0.3559624553,
0.0410110615,
-0.707414031,
-0.1823047847,
-0.132346034,
-0.5322033167,
-0.282979548,
-0.5823069811,
0.1441042721,
0.3415717781,
-0.4379273653,
0.0378708579,
-0.3909277618,
0.5679929852,
0.4366996586,
0.3604919016,
0.7770294547,
0.1244710982,
-0.0413731858,
-0.1866404414,
-0.3105630875,
-0.6537073851,
0.9695443511,
0.0726892427,
0.6880069375,
0.4296025932,
0.6674811244,
0.2449538112,
0.3956441283,
-0.7682257891,
0.4389049113,
-0.1278268248,
-0.499291569,
-0.1065542325,
-0.4380249679,
-1.1214766502,
0.2792329788,
-0.0957316607,
-0.7671036124,
0.5446834564,
0.1931182742,
-0.2679313719,
0.1868445128,
-0.7888319492,
0.7315266132,
-0.3930632472,
-0.3896140456,
-0.0996930301,
-0.5613000393,
0.4410533905,
-0.1735527813,
0.5745591521,
0.1681476682,
-0.4517613053,
0.6395949125,
-0.1834557652,
0.8794796467,
-0.0406995229,
-0.324944675,
0.1525491923,
0.1578378677,
-0.00978423,
-0.074347429,
0.1816565841,
0.2052815259,
-0.141361922,
-0.2474488467,
-0.823812604,
0.6260117888,
-1.1679323912,
-0.4591897726,
-0.3966003656,
-0.6332153082,
-0.0568682328,
0.2193094939,
0.3425115347,
0.8467032313,
-0.1838410795,
-0.091312401,
0.1282217801,
-0.0411012545,
0.8006100059,
0.2667486966,
-0.6978957653,
-0.341058284,
0.9335347414,
0.0379493348,
0.8122945428,
0.1171898097,
0.1999577135,
-0.2862778306,
-0.3586702645,
-0.4025237858,
0.31316185,
-0.5254077911,
0.0590943098,
-0.6928727031,
-0.0227289926,
-0.1059092805,
0.2290067822,
-0.2810606658,
-0.1969952881,
-0.0250964779,
0.0302483365,
0.2934927344,
1.2077758312,
-0.4612944722,
0.040555574,
-0.7438554168,
0.4632882476,
0.7122827172,
0.4041198194,
0.1928841472,
-0.31575647,
-0.0476539321,
0.3621826768,
-0.3664342165,
-0.9062162638,
0.2318072319,
0.3452454805,
0.2494585514,
0.4923976064,
-0.3764179051,
0.982753098,
-0.6125926375,
0.8450604677,
0.4389640987,
-1.0343199968,
-0.0755139068,
-0.6135385633,
0.2346220762,
0.012669201,
0.4045672715,
-0.7416163087,
-0.29826051,
-0.508929491,
-0.7463907003,
0.6592324972,
0.0890861452,
0.3588494658,
-0.3488233984,
0.2443634123,
0.0362739302,
0.2929050326,
-0.9078951478,
-0.3989347219,
-0.1887048185,
0.2702488303,
-0.2178582996,
-0.3051938415,
-0.0777392238,
-0.291244328,
-0.0809929296,
0.2400877625,
0.6144478917,
0.1347775459,
0.0056409985,
-0.2024638057,
0.3219920695,
0.7811135054,
0.8603330851,
-0.057560049,
0.3749300838,
-0.278937012,
-0.648018837,
0.5639667511,
-0.2913755774,
-0.1024203673,
0.0335498489,
0.5085972548,
0.705155313,
0.3307062387,
-0.6600770354,
0.6685643792,
-0.1954215169,
-0.5906606317,
-0.2365001142,
-0.2467521131,
0.4959482849,
0.3251128495,
0.3818864226,
0.482206881,
0.284196645,
-0.9152207971,
0.2130395323,
0.2222639769,
-0.0064298739,
-0.5803938508,
0.7090642452,
0.216074869,
-0.5131623745,
0.7218866348,
-0.5211565495,
-0.4514843225,
0.298419714,
0.8555642366,
0.5485586524,
-0.2521319985,
0.2257822156,
0.2665715218,
0.0940613598,
-0.332900852,
0.3916881979,
-0.1011779681,
-0.9727927446,
-0.7777901888,
-0.4736868143,
-0.0601807833,
0.1467795223,
-0.7001178265,
-0.264741689,
-0.3776503205,
-0.2447412908,
0.2335629761,
-0.5537221432,
-0.4756855667,
-0.2598185837,
0.3030158579,
0.1456112564,
-1.0145835876,
0.5031604171,
0.9513915777,
-0.67511338,
-0.7782706022,
-0.0507762842,
-0.1540175527,
-0.2277968973,
1.2606099844,
0.059192393,
-0.2729347944,
0.1997968554,
-0.3440070152,
-0.7817980051,
0.8863133788,
0.6300528049,
-0.5083642602,
-0.0038709389,
0.1327890903,
0.6749789715,
0.0155654754,
0.3430252075,
0.6341940761,
0.4183974564,
0.0762074441,
-1.1950623989,
-0.0233856663,
-0.3016698956,
0.2857039869,
0.3980764151,
-0.5012537837,
1.1606280804,
-0.3054056466,
-0.5575128198,
0.185842067,
0.3779765666,
0.0537452698,
-0.0082367016,
0.6011369228,
0.5001704097,
0.5682412386,
0.0048663276,
0.9764105082,
-0.17944175,
0.2968821228,
0.9610862732,
-0.1554894745,
0.8577244282,
0.5181838274,
-0.4570966065,
0.6893473268,
0.2471399158,
0.4323780239,
0.2983488739,
0.3491829336,
-0.5801541209,
-0.1545472443,
0.1124552041,
-0.295717448,
0.7359904051,
0.1906323731,
-0.2267205566,
-0.1901488602,
0.520249486,
-0.0857822895,
0.2067221552,
-0.1262759268,
0.9704415202,
0.014660418,
-0.4188517928,
0.7103467584,
-0.3258222938,
0.8479637504,
-0.3676132858,
-0.1097325906,
-0.3355139196,
0.3144719303,
-0.355369091,
-0.3862489164,
0.2570686638,
-0.2204733193,
-0.3410462141,
-0.2145229131,
0.269947648,
-0.5754107237,
-0.2512239814,
0.4921961427,
0.7205619812,
0.4635949135,
-0.0515034385,
-0.6194378734,
0.2304100245,
-0.0523333289,
-0.1556337029,
0.3625418544,
0.4635005295,
-0.1284326017,
0.6754875183,
0.7508984804,
0.147025004,
0.2800720036,
0.1799574047,
0.7718172073,
-0.8595139384,
-0.3260850906,
-1.0458834171,
0.4268901944,
-0.0919605494,
-0.2251446843,
0.6321284175,
0.7914047241,
0.7099570632,
-0.3524437249,
0.7468498945,
-0.2054418027,
0.1456413567,
-0.07549344,
0.5214834809,
-0.4357767701,
0.0887549296,
-0.596062243,
-0.9476343393,
-0.2041549981,
0.6856598258,
-0.1106561869,
0.2218928635,
0.9752489328,
0.8206228018,
-0.1704560071,
-0.1024992317,
0.5505412221,
0.4118128121,
0.2327795327,
0.3166828454,
1.2936087847,
-0.1629387289,
0.4187341332,
-0.3109588623,
-0.3998694122,
0.3248602748,
-0.7513822913,
-0.6655489206,
-0.8721322417,
-0.0751354769,
-0.0638360679,
-0.112012282,
0.9786602855,
0.6423304081,
-0.2980138659,
-0.6053236723,
-0.0622258559,
-0.2839955091,
-0.4475472569,
-0.2565137744,
0.1163643077,
-0.2635552585,
-0.9984096885,
0.1450402737,
0.4714783132,
0.263233602,
-0.468141228,
0.0521374792,
-0.1589457244,
-0.2856229246,
0.9709359407,
0.1665903628,
-0.7435389161,
-0.2103283256,
-0.0707884654,
-0.0456605516,
0.1517269909,
0.9778782725,
-0.8912337422,
0.6183255315,
0.4031971395,
0.3218013346,
0.3384252787,
0.0752509758,
0.8385922909,
-0.6485268474,
0.5061467886,
0.1873071939,
0.3156865239,
0.3796622157,
-0.1335698515,
0.2287650108,
0.4940536916,
-0.6282912493,
-0.4714868367,
0.3186526597,
-1.11148417,
-0.285100311,
1.0582194328,
0.0396571197,
-0.0803505629,
-0.5483049154,
-0.4751353562,
0.0752638429,
-0.518689692,
0.6640802026,
0.6828056574,
-0.2852131128,
-0.1412416548,
-0.5411664844,
0.5020879507,
-0.0001734552,
-0.761850059,
0.0685727894,
0.7118974924,
0.3788951635,
0.462476939,
0.8690311909,
-0.2714910805,
0.3594630957,
0.2689849734,
0.2036953866,
-0.1516343057,
0.1898660958,
-0.1444711536,
0.0254636221,
0.2006570399,
-0.257094264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03616v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03616v1
|
Leveraging Large Language Models for Hybrid Workplace Decision Support
| 2024-02-06T01:05:14 | 2024-02-06T01:05:14 |
Yujin Kim, Chin-Chia Hsu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.IR
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) hold the potential to perform a variety of text
processing tasks and provide textual explanations for proposed actions or
decisions. In the era of hybrid work, LLMs can provide intelligent decision
support for workers who are designing their hybrid work plans. In particular,
they can offer suggestions and explanations to workers balancing numerous
decision factors, thereby enhancing their work experience. In this paper, we
present a decision support model for workspaces in hybrid work environments,
leveraging the reasoning skill of LLMs. We first examine LLM's capability of
making suitable workspace suggestions. We find that its reasoning extends
beyond the guidelines in the prompt and the LLM can manage the trade-off among
the available resources in the workspaces. We conduct an extensive user study
to understand workers' decision process for workspace choices and evaluate the
effectiveness of the system. We observe that a worker's decision could be
influenced by the LLM's suggestions and explanations. The participants in our
study find the system to be convenient, regardless of whether reasons are
provided or not. Our results show that employees can benefit from the
LLM-empowered system for their workspace selection in hybrid workplace.
|
[
-0.2835107446,
-0.5720828772,
1.0533055067,
0.3577538729,
-0.2812936306,
0.0980731398,
-0.4293389916,
-0.6960011721,
0.1907687336,
0.6634676456,
-0.6018579602,
-0.3418394327,
-0.1583781838,
0.3184925616,
-0.1622724384,
0.6272881627,
-0.3165153861,
0.0662331283,
-0.580362618,
-0.0620270595,
-0.9106753469,
-0.4331098497,
-0.5792655945,
-0.7060290575,
0.5883783102,
0.4604982734,
0.9684163332,
0.1711736172,
0.0227358919,
0.3657980859,
-0.2263528556,
0.3315192461,
-0.1800531596,
0.0416524895,
-0.4707721174,
-0.5795869231,
-0.4653350115,
-0.348290503,
0.4179253578,
0.8009545207,
-0.2995116711,
-0.1334311813,
-0.0121348416,
0.3907401562,
-0.2597664297,
-0.0147646014,
-0.3910606802,
0.3614403903,
-0.1549807787,
0.0783751756,
-0.5631114841,
-0.0883134305,
-0.0688158646,
-0.4452813566,
-0.2800229788,
0.3093366325,
0.1677266508,
0.1849555969,
-0.4448573589,
0.1694885492,
-1.0663660765,
0.691202879,
-0.7123022676,
0.4917690158,
0.2496383786,
0.1813187301,
-0.2457402796,
-0.3185769618,
-0.7658770084,
-0.2930663228,
-0.3099858165,
0.1004237309,
-0.0290010497,
0.3157975078,
0.328607738,
0.4407496452,
-0.4949439466,
0.6573756337,
-0.2457227707,
-0.1133031622,
0.5068193078,
0.311422646,
0.3922178447,
0.0439725034,
-0.3832154274,
0.1985672712,
-0.4203332067,
-0.2569707036,
-0.000936871,
0.0401905589,
0.1075696126,
0.8855034113,
-0.2124715298,
0.9715524316,
-0.2882651985,
-0.3585448265,
0.0534990095,
-0.268796593,
-0.3402252793,
-0.3173876703,
0.7621337771,
0.0992563665,
-0.0395394042,
-0.4871965349,
-0.2943487167,
0.252522558,
0.1770062298,
-0.2462538183,
0.2114376724,
0.2834183872,
-0.7211512923,
-0.0575094782,
-0.286690563,
-0.4444886446,
-0.7826912403,
-0.7568919659,
0.1746571213,
-0.2559385896,
-0.5975051522,
0.2931582034,
-0.3769371808,
-0.1044099256,
0.8447637558,
-0.5292593837,
0.2325984836,
0.337877363,
0.8554833531,
-0.5220900774,
-0.363512367,
-0.2721937001,
0.2693103254,
-0.2083426863,
0.6788930297,
-0.6990016103,
-0.5949403048,
0.149778977,
-0.2834198475,
-0.2361074537,
-0.7981246114,
0.550647974,
-0.4963709414,
0.3124418259,
-0.216280967,
-0.3950722516,
-0.2031333148,
0.1722066998,
-0.7716386914,
0.9932492971,
0.0058619515,
-0.7746210098,
0.4830440879,
-1.0558422804,
-0.5087870359,
0.5625574589,
-0.3748305142,
-0.1309046894,
0.0841242,
-0.1672947854,
0.5520402789,
0.0320743583,
0.2982272506,
-0.4861998558,
-0.0956886709,
0.2946948409,
0.0677791759,
0.7185642123,
0.2178095728,
-0.1633746028,
0.4042477012,
-0.3639208972,
-0.1934576184,
0.0793891847,
-0.6958109736,
-0.3082249761,
0.2603951395,
0.0512894168,
0.4025550485,
0.4435498416,
-0.5193852186,
0.1691372246,
0.1535034478,
0.14403449,
0.7167140841,
-0.4076737463,
0.4757900834,
-0.5113961697,
0.7361488938,
-0.165783003,
0.0293473508,
0.3719997108,
-0.5456928611,
-0.4486978948,
-0.473000288,
-0.1009946689,
0.7170507312,
-1.1494472027,
0.4937629104,
0.0821851641,
-0.3084840775,
-0.0325259492,
0.2948769927,
0.1909528375,
0.2745608091,
0.1241526827,
0.2654773593,
-0.6932172179,
-0.966779232,
-0.3750351369,
-0.030904416,
-0.0021263219,
0.4016198516,
0.5015442967,
-0.5311263204,
1.1860464811,
-0.3382458687,
-0.0592546612,
-0.7710230947,
-0.200429365,
0.3987650573,
0.1498235315,
0.3262575567,
-1.0522181988,
-0.4170415401,
0.1318022162,
-0.7200468779,
-0.2355505675,
-0.4308263361,
-0.418825686,
0.0576851815,
0.5603394508,
-0.9452671409,
0.3550581336,
0.5992379785,
-0.4130415022,
0.9593213797,
-0.30390504,
-0.4413265884,
-1.1804540157,
0.0918403566,
0.216546163,
-0.6451525092,
-0.4060876966,
-0.2402943671,
-0.1683584899,
-0.1537620723,
-0.1145170331,
0.5480149984,
-0.3108400404,
-0.3222566247,
-0.4317855537,
0.0617743172,
-0.0380463153,
0.4086528718,
0.681065917,
0.6479854584,
0.3440095782,
-0.6006350517,
0.4921613038,
0.470041573,
-0.4835048318,
0.54838413,
-0.5223359466,
0.1365409046,
0.0978340209,
0.9157472849,
-0.8420407772,
-0.0766263604,
-0.1185302511,
0.0539460853,
-0.211264804,
0.0984733552,
-1.15254879,
-0.7081842422,
0.0063471068,
-0.0097180111,
0.0968267396,
-0.8509385586,
1.0821946859,
0.4888445437,
-0.3090410829,
-0.1186540276,
-0.6826886535,
0.2136766016,
-0.3041640222,
-0.7909192443,
0.6669060588,
-0.1392982304,
-0.6328494549,
-0.1204262003,
-0.0329297446,
-0.0371123888,
0.0664383844,
0.4682708979,
0.8022280931,
0.2397251874,
0.00565717,
-0.2136486769,
-0.0982260108,
0.1307640821,
-0.3972821832,
0.2982037961,
-0.0575964041,
-0.260310024,
-0.109714888,
0.5484229922,
0.9314706326,
-0.1312011182,
1.0652412176,
0.5384168625,
-0.6612112522,
-0.5252637863,
-0.7144706249,
-0.0435395427,
-0.5094807744,
0.2441591322,
0.0490814149,
-0.9741560817,
0.515837431,
-0.406906575,
0.3913745582,
0.0562796742,
1.0805571079,
-0.1081627309,
1.1637408733,
0.695217073,
0.0575024895,
0.7094730139,
0.0759435594,
0.3780016005,
-0.7814949751,
-0.5843010545,
-0.3171253204,
-0.3113542795,
-0.1388857663,
-0.5102820992,
0.5420967937,
-0.3242163062,
0.214979291,
0.3571684957,
-0.1692163795,
0.4306064248,
0.5317017436,
0.2611982822,
0.2723938823,
-0.2872725427,
-0.6500774622,
0.0432279743,
-0.7289992571,
-0.5321536064,
0.1085286513,
0.4393736124,
0.7108570933,
0.188969329,
0.376580894,
0.4726828039,
0.073289603,
-0.6067658067,
0.7441552877,
-0.0251159221,
-0.6633659005,
-0.3171380162,
-0.4690900743,
-0.5957202911,
0.7094618678,
-0.5498839021,
-0.9839295745,
-0.0925342813,
-0.0311340857,
-0.4903458953,
0.5620447993,
-0.8661090732,
0.6503295302,
-0.4698771834,
-0.5010903478,
-0.6229692101,
-0.065534845,
0.3281086981,
-0.1060013175,
0.4692423344,
0.0742677823,
0.1261165291,
0.8671319485,
-0.5868947506,
1.2332698107,
-0.0937479436,
-0.1673005223,
0.0251194891,
0.3097796738,
0.5700812936,
-0.0348662622,
-0.5366193652,
-0.1351643801,
-0.1335870177,
-0.0181056298,
-0.3686340451,
0.6922882199,
-0.4825279713,
-0.5318547487,
-0.1087101027,
-0.7573626637,
-0.736563623,
0.3515044749,
0.1513506472,
0.1539271325,
0.1781733632,
0.2231907547,
0.4791840911,
-0.4366653264,
0.4288075566,
0.5624046922,
-0.4901300073,
-0.0387075208,
0.3769676685,
0.1638190001,
-0.0276266523,
0.3148314357,
0.4320965111,
-0.7726309896,
-0.5478690863,
-0.3146467805,
0.2288337946,
-0.7883310914,
-0.1112250984,
-0.4129214287,
0.157902047,
0.1538172215,
-0.503339529,
-0.0578523017,
-0.1638534069,
-0.1054980755,
-0.503110528,
0.2769525051,
0.8307956457,
-0.001642742,
-0.0436705835,
-0.7504681945,
0.2454209179,
0.4330810308,
0.563226223,
0.0856026709,
-0.1826773435,
-0.5856980681,
-0.2673370242,
-0.0549583882,
-0.9028743505,
0.2859588265,
-0.3014614284,
1.0101191998,
0.1389276981,
0.1141543016,
0.1371939331,
-0.3332331181,
0.7074763775,
0.3403694928,
-0.758589983,
0.43745929,
-0.6570211053,
0.1790878475,
0.4846528769,
0.1081350967,
-0.5695077181,
-0.1756927222,
-0.4433763921,
-0.6041379571,
0.7323842049,
0.1263183206,
-0.0625365525,
0.3111473322,
0.0309110153,
0.3164229095,
0.1263659596,
-1.1057218313,
0.0241626687,
0.2697887123,
0.1523426622,
0.2316554934,
-0.0357236452,
-0.3119454682,
-0.2846603096,
0.3954847753,
-0.2116128951,
0.1485835016,
-0.2012830079,
0.0432806313,
-0.4202078283,
0.279453516,
0.231017828,
0.9180101752,
0.1955965459,
-0.0102726948,
0.7841330171,
0.3210340738,
-0.2658390403,
0.0159042533,
0.2214306593,
0.1179638728,
0.2151760906,
0.9926697016,
0.0298010297,
-0.8254994154,
0.4469818175,
-0.0184225217,
-0.3588497043,
-0.3139128387,
0.3856809437,
0.3979493976,
0.4825443029,
0.2149442583,
0.1062656417,
-0.0254348237,
-0.4378691912,
-0.24175708,
0.5636926293,
0.1667220592,
0.0328431465,
0.4268249869,
0.3315474987,
-0.4527652264,
0.4088361561,
0.0329650082,
-0.6952311397,
0.3870064318,
0.8217376471,
0.6705783606,
0.3011718094,
0.4073534012,
-0.0499518663,
-0.0865567625,
-0.0995194167,
0.314725548,
-0.0972508416,
-0.8594401479,
-0.7536787391,
-0.4492927194,
-0.8980901837,
0.1368698478,
-0.2149212956,
0.0753118992,
-0.6357125044,
-0.1822604388,
0.0533321872,
-0.2166343331,
-0.7407318354,
0.2296677232,
0.8321514726,
1.1893882751,
-0.747326076,
0.6716405153,
1.1524993181,
0.0590476654,
-0.760165751,
-0.2347044647,
0.0367540717,
-0.7713056207,
0.4791813493,
-0.1096985787,
-0.3444215059,
-0.5940580964,
-0.4533314407,
-0.5006397963,
1.1209937334,
0.3865831792,
-0.8097566366,
0.0211229417,
0.045761466,
0.6717700958,
-0.3089132309,
0.1706718206,
0.3345137537,
0.7923052907,
-0.0319205113,
-1.1668841839,
0.2091564536,
-0.158059448,
0.2170423716,
-0.0011172281,
-0.6272811294,
0.5974299908,
-0.2127954066,
0.1023272425,
-0.2908209562,
0.3960267901,
0.5554401875,
0.0952556059,
0.9995552301,
0.4102885723,
0.9549149275,
0.2142390162,
1.1383686066,
-0.0989019051,
-0.0742970705,
0.8287414312,
-0.4804050922,
0.8813948631,
0.4275329709,
-0.2123077065,
1.069423914,
0.5741302371,
0.2494544834,
0.2825465798,
-0.1142642722,
-0.4386754036,
-0.6410958767,
-0.4309063852,
-0.1105285808,
0.2093736976,
0.4421027899,
-0.1740046591,
-0.1389458179,
0.0847917199,
-0.0520548262,
0.0254552551,
-0.1608811319,
0.8824141622,
0.2710829675,
-0.8301187158,
0.2501543164,
0.3068191111,
0.6012333632,
-0.5549446344,
0.0636922345,
0.1673312634,
0.2305275053,
-0.805804491,
-1.1056978703,
0.3424478471,
0.0585190617,
-0.2922794819,
-0.6694318652,
0.9326880574,
-0.3219997287,
-0.2411631942,
0.5452477336,
0.6650506258,
-0.4752976894,
-0.1233755648,
-0.684266448,
0.0169152506,
0.03059664,
0.1163396984,
0.3464688659,
0.3735201061,
-0.2165350169,
0.5398417115,
0.8547977805,
0.1358756274,
-0.244184643,
0.1632268578,
0.9672690034,
-0.3434240818,
-0.9515599608,
-0.8227529526,
0.4778556526,
-0.2779670358,
-0.1574937999,
0.5511968732,
0.3674546182,
0.5003762245,
-0.1620972008,
1.2532725334,
-0.1284424961,
0.5307867527,
-0.7279058695,
0.192174688,
-0.4886113703,
0.3119335473,
-0.2690308094,
-0.8599559665,
-0.1125677675,
0.6570452452,
-0.9373990297,
-0.0474744588,
0.5211727619,
0.622182548,
-0.1318183988,
0.3102948666,
0.2192935795,
0.0502604209,
0.3944323063,
0.4579560757,
1.1549847126,
0.633051157,
0.4552904963,
-0.1000456512,
-0.2862530947,
-0.4715075195,
-1.103813529,
-0.8558555245,
-0.3861956,
-0.2394339889,
-0.3643991351,
-0.4359059036,
1.0842194557,
1.050652504,
-0.3898396194,
-0.3131239712,
-0.1139137074,
0.2780134976,
-0.1346342266,
-0.2421460152,
-0.1305660605,
0.0302297473,
-0.1814740896,
0.6447032094,
0.3173859715,
-0.1616646498,
-0.3709459901,
-0.4352010489,
-0.0551400781,
0.0402825885,
0.7005193233,
0.2242115289,
-0.6044175625,
0.0711110309,
-0.1563907266,
-0.1582299173,
-0.1436574012,
0.9236485362,
-0.5740830898,
0.3522324264,
0.6729343534,
0.6793693304,
0.4065235257,
-0.2674428523,
0.9077683091,
-0.5613811016,
-0.0006193127,
0.3727251291,
0.9683353305,
0.5111042857,
-0.4973342121,
0.3705910742,
0.1204315424,
-0.3881978095,
-0.4088411033,
0.121891275,
-0.815023005,
-0.5595698357,
1.5297082663,
0.2543186843,
-0.0646283329,
-0.3088993728,
-0.6659263968,
-0.0771128908,
-0.3186327517,
0.7529454231,
0.7649380565,
-0.4745612741,
-0.1886408925,
-0.4599162042,
0.3031750023,
0.6803266406,
-1.0874353647,
0.1162841395,
0.6538927555,
0.131702289,
0.1741906852,
0.8574814796,
0.2035549432,
0.3755948246,
-0.2548224032,
-0.3853441775,
-0.0373012796,
-0.2027885765,
0.0652445033,
-0.1492216885,
0.3421254158,
-0.1371135861
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03610v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03610v1
|
RAP: Retrieval-Augmented Planning with Contextual Memory for Multimodal LLM Agents
| 2024-02-06T00:53:27 | 2024-02-06T00:53:27 |
Tomoyuki Kagaya, Thong Jing Yuan, Yuxuan Lou, Jayashree Karlekar, Sugiri Pranata, Akira Kinose, Koki Oguri, Felix Wick, Yang You
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Owing to recent advancements, Large Language Models (LLMs) can now be
deployed as agents for increasingly complex decision-making applications in
areas including robotics, gaming, and API integration. However, reflecting past
experiences in current decision-making processes, an innate human behavior,
continues to pose significant challenges. Addressing this, we propose
Retrieval-Augmented Planning (RAP) framework, designed to dynamically leverage
past experiences corresponding to the current situation and context, thereby
enhancing agents' planning capabilities. RAP distinguishes itself by being
versatile: it excels in both text-only and multimodal environments, making it
suitable for a wide range of tasks. Empirical evaluations demonstrate RAP's
effectiveness, where it achieves SOTA performance in textual scenarios and
notably enhances multimodal LLM agents' performance for embodied tasks. These
results highlight RAP's potential in advancing the functionality and
applicability of LLM agents in complex, real-world applications.
|
[
-0.3739461899,
-0.8086616397,
0.8184302449,
0.5064414144,
0.2329428941,
0.4078333378,
-0.0883437246,
-0.371817857,
0.5617075562,
0.4166589081,
-0.6192064285,
-0.4439907968,
-0.3838053048,
-0.1575452089,
-0.3290017843,
0.6399760246,
-0.297544986,
-0.2049873024,
-0.1951457262,
-0.0125740804,
-0.5909156799,
-0.7143564224,
-0.7031941414,
-0.2776578069,
0.6528995037,
0.4747110009,
0.7158949375,
0.2730348706,
0.373098284,
0.2489930689,
0.0212491807,
0.4642363191,
-0.5640528798,
0.5048592091,
-0.374722451,
-0.2320147753,
-0.6856423616,
-0.1291942149,
0.7867863774,
0.369261682,
-0.0815463513,
-0.2059189975,
-0.5315830112,
0.4259470999,
-0.994422555,
0.017546406,
-0.5338956714,
0.2750318944,
0.2295137942,
-0.7135445476,
-0.5777016878,
0.0878400356,
0.2507442534,
-0.7562047243,
-0.3408210278,
0.1185846627,
0.3544463515,
0.2689817548,
-0.4299857616,
-0.4332369864,
-1.0989793539,
0.7343490124,
-0.2015701383,
0.5879952908,
0.3644970953,
0.3865509629,
-0.4606142044,
-1.0587273836,
-0.6193470955,
-0.2437157929,
0.1330206096,
0.2719919682,
-0.130663991,
-0.0712425262,
0.3024170101,
-0.1190168411,
-0.2160573751,
-0.1907333434,
-0.1481227577,
-0.1940961033,
0.3750264943,
0.1783852428,
0.5970071554,
-0.0039569554,
-0.9233310223,
-0.1168974191,
-0.7719057798,
0.1163700595,
-0.033479657,
0.4804106951,
0.1010314375,
0.6611963511,
-0.0754925013,
0.5023739934,
-0.4146580398,
-0.3981050849,
0.1896204203,
-0.4293797016,
0.0287140291,
0.0981397331,
0.4064086378,
0.3185881376,
0.005154443,
-0.3333476782,
-0.3530140817,
-0.0768319964,
0.494551748,
-0.5720883012,
0.0550812595,
-0.1288876086,
-0.1901094764,
0.225038901,
-0.2284817845,
-0.7246063352,
-0.2868262529,
-0.2194908112,
0.5839508176,
-0.7959685922,
-0.2950665653,
0.1594380438,
-0.3628889024,
0.1078479365,
0.4075635672,
-0.5863838196,
0.3672745228,
0.4263034165,
0.870100975,
-0.2266514003,
-0.7007303238,
-0.8772931695,
0.6120468974,
-0.381441772,
0.9238618016,
-0.8952271938,
-0.6570543647,
-0.0072966237,
-0.3006187677,
0.021143388,
-0.4135180712,
0.6740764976,
-0.8003761768,
-0.3798610866,
-0.3217841983,
-0.0868537948,
-0.0042185597,
0.6182329655,
-0.6809244752,
0.9882923365,
0.06344679,
-0.3668108881,
0.5394150615,
-0.6988030672,
-0.4473406374,
-0.0934600309,
-0.2685943246,
-0.0387022793,
-0.2368882895,
0.127534464,
0.2565208375,
0.1791885644,
0.0903561339,
0.0341383927,
-0.5725274086,
0.2112517357,
-0.2001548856,
0.2691370249,
0.3318796754,
0.0931934863,
0.3523424864,
-0.5107078552,
0.0051816576,
-0.0139586162,
-0.556709826,
-0.4791405201,
0.2702741623,
-0.0784962475,
0.5058764815,
0.2222966701,
-0.3583241999,
0.5161908865,
-0.1983805746,
0.2575044036,
0.4806861579,
-0.1279319078,
0.7645522952,
-0.5270226002,
0.6985824704,
-0.0404975712,
-0.0597690046,
-0.3514291644,
-0.2251755595,
-0.3344120681,
-0.3830648959,
-0.0524339266,
0.445923239,
-1.2176758051,
-0.2724683583,
-0.3297712803,
-0.2210481465,
0.1916227639,
-0.1318541914,
0.2046353072,
0.3531054854,
0.3954488933,
-0.0894901454,
-0.8707560301,
-0.6076622009,
-0.1269370466,
-0.2118929327,
0.3044549227,
0.6111430526,
0.4519283772,
-0.6394383311,
1.2395310402,
-0.3171841502,
-0.4508363307,
-0.613602221,
0.2578814328,
-0.140499264,
0.2574488819,
0.651647687,
-1.1237319708,
-0.1357178986,
-0.3143326938,
-0.4942489564,
0.0379266664,
-0.4236347377,
-0.3763471544,
0.0154276565,
0.5733712912,
-0.7963896394,
0.4979303479,
0.4099363089,
-0.4096697867,
0.7718212605,
-0.5021818876,
0.0819299221,
-0.9500538111,
-0.0058552194,
-0.3192356229,
-0.3301177025,
-0.5905588269,
0.1782754809,
0.0413855501,
0.0294940956,
-0.6463703513,
0.8822496533,
-0.551928997,
-0.5377231836,
-0.2328413129,
0.4598543346,
-0.0851610005,
0.46889624,
0.2314516604,
1.2663966417,
0.2307518721,
-0.8761839271,
0.1428826302,
0.5377909541,
-0.1833051145,
0.4008883238,
-0.1541661918,
0.085029304,
-0.1368400455,
0.4897845089,
-0.6931860447,
-0.109545216,
0.1174623072,
-0.4126484692,
0.3941260278,
-0.109587945,
-0.5102942586,
-0.0632677823,
-0.3258823156,
0.6640409827,
0.0154903643,
-0.4176603854,
1.3374774456,
0.5878965855,
-0.24475196,
-0.7577345371,
-0.573563695,
0.3290338218,
0.1095682532,
-0.2144551277,
0.7467970252,
-0.2291891426,
-0.3401726186,
-0.0314742215,
-0.1335800141,
-0.0410621874,
-0.1457579285,
0.3361115754,
0.2965533137,
0.0520353988,
0.1614635438,
-0.0329021439,
-0.1862567365,
-0.1184877679,
0.0581826195,
0.9107200503,
-0.023614116,
-0.2608402669,
0.1093561053,
0.3655564487,
0.564675808,
-0.34709993,
0.5514246821,
0.3136064112,
-0.2646360397,
-0.2115881294,
-0.3665554225,
0.1341932863,
-0.4251874983,
0.459086448,
-0.6531408429,
-0.7718542218,
0.4706940055,
-0.5868174434,
-0.0611538589,
-0.0903481469,
0.5051990747,
-0.1803479344,
0.9475913048,
0.5627481341,
0.1389808208,
0.7204402685,
-0.4966623485,
0.1119756773,
-1.1078050137,
-0.3584443927,
-0.1094372198,
-0.6528029442,
-0.2792186737,
-0.6558420062,
0.4632823765,
-0.0596483126,
-0.3034364879,
0.0802329928,
-0.0061090016,
0.4862346053,
0.5927247405,
-0.0031051408,
0.3776654005,
-0.192630291,
-0.3713332117,
0.0572361015,
-0.491495043,
-0.6489681005,
0.8917505741,
0.0981778949,
0.7490792274,
0.1795817465,
0.5557355285,
0.3027626574,
0.0631691962,
-0.9653561115,
0.7677459121,
0.0691881999,
-0.510530591,
-0.3186220527,
-0.3662307262,
-1.0292503834,
0.1692184359,
-0.4300759435,
-0.8149524331,
0.238479346,
-0.0589311719,
-0.5467075706,
0.5003453493,
-0.5557069778,
0.5416343808,
-0.4479086101,
-0.3740958571,
-0.3249082565,
-0.5373315811,
0.1055281758,
0.0698512271,
0.1059285402,
-0.1043333188,
-0.4533368349,
0.5454158783,
0.0584505573,
0.3830142319,
-0.2450142056,
0.1812773645,
0.2854941189,
0.4718008339,
0.6303509474,
-0.0743806064,
-0.1285090894,
-0.2885465026,
0.1500919908,
-0.1037301049,
-0.6767026186,
0.8117387295,
-0.7682783008,
-0.3480150104,
-0.4936971664,
-1.0875502825,
-0.442201972,
0.4190148115,
-0.2145647258,
0.5934323072,
-0.372824192,
0.217276901,
0.4005352259,
-0.5708384514,
0.5365978479,
0.6388958693,
-0.7190057039,
-0.1206396371,
0.7190587521,
0.2309911996,
0.1349539012,
0.5837584734,
-0.0917946994,
-0.3684661984,
-0.6903510094,
-0.1044957265,
0.0233566333,
-0.5734625459,
-0.1611514986,
-0.9052267671,
-0.212736249,
-0.1743334234,
-0.2094353139,
-0.4474855661,
-0.4671196342,
-0.0012586822,
-0.2707698047,
0.2242387533,
0.5460549593,
-0.2173447609,
0.2573453784,
-0.51086694,
0.6950595379,
0.2493130267,
0.3479566872,
-0.1780993789,
-0.0530479997,
-0.0136072934,
0.2405425012,
-0.341009587,
-0.691834867,
0.7008852363,
0.1899781525,
0.6623418331,
-0.0307365749,
0.2879258692,
0.8237457871,
-0.5437315702,
0.4924746454,
-0.2213172615,
-0.4719999731,
0.7292744517,
-0.2698532045,
0.235066101,
0.5522331595,
0.3301340938,
-0.4369637966,
-0.0084336596,
-0.3056545854,
-1.1062697172,
0.8904575109,
0.0968502015,
0.3035950661,
-0.1032870412,
0.4359124899,
0.0271645598,
0.1087373719,
-0.4349675477,
-0.1378349513,
-0.0076912814,
0.2709090412,
0.0345796309,
-0.6633845568,
-0.0821422935,
-0.1532349288,
0.3600780666,
-0.0881448239,
0.6385732889,
0.2448953092,
-0.3503625393,
0.0159125607,
0.2932384014,
0.8832497001,
0.9932829142,
-0.4488653243,
0.3901813328,
0.21041435,
-0.4864413738,
0.1092300564,
-0.0618786179,
-0.1791893691,
-0.3217593133,
0.1893307865,
0.4813662767,
0.6644378304,
-1.2214338779,
0.3870224059,
-0.2083136439,
0.0518782325,
-0.6838085651,
0.1276078522,
-0.0936106294,
0.5297712088,
0.6538504958,
0.2799412608,
0.1980086714,
-1.0088728666,
0.4578681886,
0.325207293,
-0.3662182987,
-0.0878518745,
0.4003526568,
-0.1285545975,
-0.5753083825,
0.5111062527,
-0.3158658743,
-0.5444390178,
0.2601331174,
1.0046236515,
0.5181639194,
-0.0542935468,
0.2317529321,
0.1911657304,
-0.0877783373,
-0.0546060465,
0.5949850678,
-0.1244562119,
-1.0643311739,
-0.4613867998,
-0.4988904893,
-0.4422617555,
-0.4380683601,
-0.3502503932,
0.0909961909,
-0.6341370344,
-0.480440855,
-0.628200829,
-0.0106102042,
-0.5068867803,
0.1412782222,
-0.0251285806,
1.0996266603,
-0.2348237783,
0.8124859929,
0.9612695575,
-0.4958460927,
-0.7106866241,
0.0043054176,
-0.0424172208,
-0.9686834216,
1.0629936457,
-0.0666810721,
-0.725858748,
0.0310203917,
-0.4574807584,
-0.9273353219,
1.3941012621,
0.4243963361,
-0.2220454216,
-0.4288606644,
-0.2307778001,
0.4323546588,
-0.4372438788,
0.4111789167,
0.5912826061,
0.3792990446,
0.7459595799,
-0.8444427252,
-0.26718086,
-0.28816697,
-0.041833166,
0.251270622,
-0.5452137589,
0.8848626614,
-0.3259265423,
-0.4411782324,
0.0842239186,
0.6202831864,
0.7618787885,
0.4801902473,
0.4299063087,
0.3914931417,
0.5666868091,
-0.0652352646,
1.1201777458,
-0.2575760186,
-0.180618912,
1.3473242521,
-0.5404093862,
1.2164711952,
0.5152899027,
0.1217021868,
0.6133039594,
0.2254755348,
0.6618281603,
0.751532793,
-0.3699117005,
-0.2438037246,
-0.3026994765,
-0.4538444877,
-0.2268864512,
0.7312978506,
0.4956016839,
-0.1135362983,
-0.202703923,
0.0734424815,
0.0124207241,
0.2222025394,
-0.3622150719,
0.6614983082,
-0.0242394619,
-0.5477129221,
0.0602500811,
-0.1785019189,
0.6231040359,
-0.693821907,
-0.2841132879,
-0.0614506863,
0.1681972444,
0.0102544641,
-0.9815762639,
0.4183766544,
-0.1978004128,
-0.1390077472,
-0.7650147676,
0.8505736589,
-0.1954841614,
-0.1245750561,
0.6349186301,
0.7118120193,
-0.0607810505,
-0.1061374173,
-0.3971306384,
0.264259547,
-0.5410144925,
-0.0480340458,
0.368147403,
0.4752757549,
-0.0782776996,
1.252940774,
0.6068177819,
0.3484873176,
-0.0428156778,
0.06865751,
1.0002017021,
-0.8916307688,
-0.5247905254,
-0.6989579797,
0.3458386958,
0.0736471415,
-0.0175715256,
0.530937016,
0.8116186857,
0.799459517,
0.1719262004,
0.4616790414,
-0.0424493067,
0.5951254368,
-0.6221144199,
0.5340713263,
-0.5466679931,
0.4085904062,
-0.3813195229,
-0.828338623,
-0.3247763813,
0.7766414285,
-0.6046446562,
0.2423357815,
0.4528428912,
0.6153719425,
0.0354132839,
-0.269045949,
0.4628039598,
0.0943883583,
0.5001223087,
0.6910104752,
1.3570687771,
-0.0309032705,
0.5761760473,
0.1116239727,
-0.0961545557,
-0.1975247115,
-0.8396012783,
-0.570340395,
-0.6436198354,
0.2813487053,
0.1448252946,
0.0307421088,
1.3144347668,
0.5937002301,
-0.3434371948,
-0.2405249178,
0.3419307768,
0.1398235708,
-0.1408741027,
-0.1727918535,
0.0856740549,
-0.3080934286,
-0.537211895,
0.8916344047,
0.6790035367,
0.0780006871,
-0.1395366937,
-0.4652256966,
-0.748971045,
-0.0070034782,
1.0384771824,
0.3591287732,
-0.6299991608,
-0.3499099612,
0.2056855857,
-0.143952176,
0.1071491167,
1.0491861105,
-1.2961729765,
0.7370962501,
0.3531358242,
0.5260950923,
0.6761318445,
-0.0218800772,
0.8308634162,
-0.8469343185,
0.3257292211,
0.5187279582,
0.4314555228,
-0.040131025,
-0.0629727989,
0.5745369792,
-0.1937323064,
-0.4453227818,
-0.664429307,
0.2257140279,
-1.1431003809,
-0.2813717127,
1.143671751,
0.0617844425,
0.0201407894,
-0.1582919359,
-0.757350266,
0.2065788656,
-0.4681182802,
0.6265895963,
0.4789629579,
-0.345440954,
-0.4207813442,
-0.5565327406,
0.4193731844,
-0.0176384989,
-0.6020344496,
-0.2197213471,
0.7033669353,
-0.2128180712,
0.373285979,
1.1265749931,
0.0721412525,
0.3609924912,
-0.0753101185,
-0.007243346,
-0.3390751183,
-0.8615708351,
0.3776425421,
0.2469832897,
0.227399841,
0.0900522172
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03607v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03607v1
|
Improving Contextual Congruence Across Modalities for Effective Multimodal Marketing using Knowledge-infused Learning
| 2024-02-06T00:51:27 | 2024-02-06T00:51:27 |
Trilok Padhi, Ugur Kursuncu, Yaman Kumar, Valerie L. Shalin, Lane Peterson Fronczek
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.CY, cs.HC, I.2.7; I.2.10; I.2.4; I.2.1
|
The prevalence of smart devices with the ability to capture moments in
multiple modalities has enabled users to experience multimodal information
online. However, large Language (LLMs) and Vision models (LVMs) are still
limited in capturing holistic meaning with cross-modal semantic relationships.
Without explicit, common sense knowledge (e.g., as a knowledge graph), Visual
Language Models (VLMs) only learn implicit representations by capturing
high-level patterns in vast corpora, missing essential contextual cross-modal
cues. In this work, we design a framework to couple explicit commonsense
knowledge in the form of knowledge graphs with large VLMs to improve the
performance of a downstream task, predicting the effectiveness of multi-modal
marketing campaigns. While the marketing application provides a compelling
metric for assessing our methods, our approach enables the early detection of
likely persuasive multi-modal campaigns and the assessment and augmentation of
marketing theory.
|
[
-0.2414442748,
-0.6859883666,
0.3883675933,
0.1612619907,
-0.3861060441,
-0.0056016208,
-0.4662826955,
-0.5221998096,
0.1187850311,
0.2499131113,
-0.4754133523,
-0.5684946775,
-0.3561525643,
-0.1625378132,
0.2012462616,
0.7045328021,
0.0882886723,
0.2382661253,
-0.4775988758,
-0.2685184777,
-0.6057778001,
-0.2954948843,
-0.308070749,
-0.1621798575,
0.7575817704,
0.4493024051,
0.3211986125,
0.2265364975,
0.211274147,
0.3386964202,
0.1644063294,
0.6526789665,
-0.6436437964,
0.3233166337,
-0.160267055,
-0.1825151742,
-0.3731449544,
-0.0056145503,
0.4264827371,
0.5938210487,
0.105295606,
0.1215387359,
0.0762824118,
0.3192170858,
-0.7986603975,
0.593770504,
-0.7042660713,
-0.174517408,
-0.012096622,
-0.4861584008,
-0.4895729423,
0.075452134,
0.396374166,
-0.9066857696,
-0.0688399896,
0.2115712315,
0.6616490483,
0.1297068745,
-0.8514329195,
-0.2687087357,
-0.549456656,
0.8898120522,
-0.4166698158,
0.8103581667,
0.3040238023,
0.2736700475,
0.0888002887,
-0.7032498717,
-0.4998045862,
-0.2268223614,
-0.1783755869,
0.2636294067,
-0.0133833447,
0.0597044714,
0.1841120273,
0.1266622394,
-0.2833949029,
-0.1582227647,
-0.4149454236,
-0.3565746546,
0.3970704973,
0.1232559904,
0.2140276879,
-0.4314189255,
-0.9184426069,
0.1208601445,
-0.231394887,
0.3168557584,
0.0233609248,
0.3467069864,
-0.2958664298,
0.6582462788,
-0.3971900344,
0.8460275531,
0.1886487752,
-0.4091738164,
0.3296373487,
-0.8752525449,
-0.3556560874,
-0.1225396097,
0.5109907389,
0.569876194,
0.035602469,
-0.0229106508,
-0.2257786095,
-0.0529544801,
0.0315346941,
-0.8136783242,
-0.1234617382,
-0.0199796893,
-0.3328987956,
-0.0529968627,
-0.0448854193,
-0.6256350279,
-0.3889288604,
-0.6825233698,
0.5908457637,
-0.5365693569,
-0.3830290139,
0.0054589054,
-0.3641976416,
0.1629727036,
0.3888272047,
-0.6324499249,
-0.2835383713,
0.5458531976,
0.6074590683,
0.0645645037,
-0.1427128315,
-0.4402570128,
0.6418948174,
0.0374293961,
0.6370204687,
-0.7623675466,
-0.148584649,
-0.0399045832,
0.0182207935,
-0.4500401318,
-0.3109463155,
0.1611088812,
-0.8310331106,
0.313257724,
-0.5270827413,
-0.5168699622,
-0.6333072186,
0.6638998985,
-0.7087632418,
0.727062583,
0.0552994199,
-0.5405027866,
0.8397395611,
-0.6693608165,
-0.555729866,
0.1391658038,
-0.1216807812,
-0.3618212044,
0.1575594991,
0.2328749597,
0.7352178693,
0.1385105848,
0.1812721193,
-0.4224725962,
0.003896185,
0.2628667057,
-0.6576399803,
0.5092473626,
0.2735914886,
-0.3406109512,
0.358507067,
-0.7445419431,
-0.2110612243,
-0.1038922742,
-0.4661478996,
-0.5751824379,
-0.242599085,
0.2430910915,
0.3434920609,
0.3411087692,
-0.2132838219,
0.0591933504,
0.0263109617,
0.2307498604,
0.8077613115,
0.0672266632,
0.4752838612,
-0.2376205772,
0.2668041289,
0.2786248028,
0.2776221633,
-0.3916399181,
-0.5935665369,
-0.5725160241,
-0.5789092779,
-0.0775548145,
0.1308476329,
-1.0207220316,
0.0794121996,
-0.484872669,
-0.3604468703,
0.0508665144,
0.5566059947,
0.1839736551,
0.5610903502,
0.2580900788,
-0.4682547152,
-0.3984266818,
-0.6030691266,
-0.3153831363,
0.0512086824,
0.2523118854,
0.4961853027,
0.3773883879,
-0.2170736194,
0.9021942019,
-0.310013622,
-0.4365177453,
-0.3468477726,
0.1288818121,
-0.2439899594,
0.1541622728,
0.2264737934,
-1.2138631344,
-0.3576336503,
0.2417877913,
-0.6857888103,
0.195833534,
0.0250679627,
0.1920392066,
0.1927603334,
0.3783554733,
-0.4527668953,
0.1845512688,
0.579455018,
-0.6345270872,
0.3938144445,
-0.1233650744,
0.4807569981,
-0.9947195649,
0.0157580394,
0.4590927362,
-0.2497840226,
-0.5216414928,
-0.3231032491,
0.0604681186,
-0.1493897289,
-0.7354769111,
0.4966598451,
-0.4214411378,
-0.1460638195,
0.0493631698,
0.1634490639,
0.4579260349,
0.744972229,
-0.0279959962,
0.7227426767,
0.2890702784,
-0.6921725273,
0.2730436325,
-0.0074228104,
-0.5786825418,
0.9377806187,
-0.3196781576,
-0.3914319873,
-0.2763883471,
0.2000873387,
-1.2411489487,
-0.5742596984,
0.2400930822,
-0.2494156957,
0.0899740756,
-0.0493976846,
-0.3391582966,
-0.0688883737,
-0.1058514863,
0.7613549232,
0.1319280267,
-0.5103750229,
0.9803358316,
0.1377412081,
0.1054306552,
-0.4352113605,
-0.3974128664,
-0.1350980252,
-0.347931385,
-0.926856935,
0.042883765,
0.1500436962,
-0.173071757,
-0.0843070894,
0.0647748858,
-0.0073068812,
-0.0226945076,
0.1894905418,
0.2177719772,
-0.2084927261,
0.4468784332,
-0.2387587577,
-0.0585370287,
-0.041048836,
-0.4647122324,
0.477332592,
-0.164872393,
-0.6413010359,
-0.5619597435,
0.1457721591,
1.0348360538,
-0.5103627443,
0.557349205,
1.0837419033,
-0.1325579584,
-0.0799353048,
-0.6366773844,
-0.2617776096,
-0.4671454132,
0.3868829906,
-0.3440841734,
-0.7548905015,
0.3950856626,
-0.2812003493,
-0.2373170704,
0.1451404095,
0.5967355371,
0.01852463,
1.2492786646,
0.5449126363,
0.3568899632,
0.8277881742,
-0.3713319302,
0.3356814384,
-0.6168606877,
-0.8653655052,
0.2169997096,
-0.3487991989,
-0.1910622269,
-0.7512970567,
0.5717875957,
0.0430441163,
-0.1281026155,
0.0933217108,
-0.1321220994,
0.3469083607,
0.720600605,
0.4619728923,
0.6344888806,
0.2994817495,
0.0360305272,
-0.1020108461,
-0.8139774799,
-0.1899406016,
1.0074084997,
0.2430462688,
0.6780538559,
0.1830617934,
0.0740378201,
0.1937964559,
0.3411392272,
-0.8622229695,
0.4289448261,
0.0564632416,
-0.6611055136,
-0.0586089529,
-0.4525932968,
-0.7271314263,
0.400324285,
-0.50494349,
-0.3522632122,
0.408334285,
0.2046077698,
-0.2500571012,
0.2860997915,
-0.9234830141,
1.0810117722,
-0.6574858427,
-0.7623748779,
-0.3508323729,
-0.380107522,
0.5275646448,
0.0958756208,
0.4010867774,
-0.1395885944,
-0.096175611,
0.6251888871,
-0.2419590354,
1.1361202002,
-0.1091003567,
-0.2082054168,
0.1879144609,
-0.2358022928,
0.4250748456,
-0.1212155372,
0.284702003,
-0.1067509875,
-0.3435524404,
-0.6638271809,
-0.62394315,
0.6614918113,
-0.4087244868,
-0.2302985489,
0.0070957318,
-0.7894695401,
-0.3650083244,
0.3022585213,
-0.052807387,
0.8638450503,
-0.0945552066,
0.3490007818,
0.7365905643,
0.0935410783,
0.3694693148,
0.2482872754,
-0.0112306504,
-0.70273453,
1.1884906292,
0.0010308675,
0.6438705921,
0.1856966168,
0.2531422675,
-0.6772141457,
-0.3409480751,
-0.3047133386,
0.0335026942,
-0.9462003112,
-0.0734940842,
-0.6127696037,
0.4356046915,
-0.5875912905,
-0.1055241302,
-0.0883981511,
-0.1236099154,
-0.2234149575,
0.0181029737,
0.308427304,
0.5882008076,
-0.1468250304,
0.2852579355,
-0.5931435823,
0.2585134804,
0.8355715871,
0.20368357,
0.1588502377,
-0.1356734782,
-0.3860353529,
0.2736701369,
-0.2442287654,
-0.6208381057,
0.2708559632,
0.0245149117,
0.7007938027,
0.8083342314,
-0.1036394387,
0.7724525928,
0.0846392885,
0.6589514017,
0.6931512952,
-0.7863525152,
0.3554787338,
-0.6390323043,
0.164671883,
0.5356974602,
0.5435980558,
-0.3697330952,
0.0669107139,
-0.471485585,
-0.7990989089,
0.1921801865,
-0.2355414182,
0.0962432921,
0.0113273142,
-0.34960109,
0.107276082,
0.5114246011,
-0.921274066,
-0.0142884096,
-0.4525357187,
-0.3734943867,
-0.0778219923,
-0.0823462829,
-0.3649953008,
-0.3791329265,
0.4573770761,
-0.3903677166,
-0.2904399931,
0.1240329742,
-0.3764658272,
0.1580417156,
0.2203763723,
0.8080778718,
0.9362869859,
-0.0746006221,
0.3718494177,
-0.0779628828,
-0.2437598258,
-0.1473574787,
0.0755269825,
0.0710406154,
-0.2031201124,
0.2859636545,
0.7257748246,
0.7099180222,
-0.824601531,
0.7733246684,
0.2388112098,
-0.002866447,
-0.0764133558,
-0.2283931077,
-0.0500160344,
0.5041469932,
0.3651055694,
0.2040133774,
0.0130962273,
-0.7995744348,
0.3036396503,
0.7064178586,
-0.7075598836,
-0.2370096445,
0.593985796,
0.5921413898,
0.0353894234,
0.10423702,
0.0384716466,
-0.6797818542,
0.286069721,
0.3973553777,
0.4725618958,
0.0768326148,
0.1925211102,
0.1377358437,
0.1805860847,
0.0735705122,
-0.0310772546,
-0.3988541067,
-0.6092818379,
-0.5743074417,
-0.3670464456,
-0.1388469487,
-0.0646777526,
-0.3628434539,
0.3917324841,
-0.2539985776,
-0.2443857342,
-0.0091053601,
-0.0231086053,
-0.8407975435,
0.2092450559,
0.3091331422,
0.640186131,
-0.8732787371,
0.4872736633,
0.6520973444,
-0.6673997641,
-0.755666554,
-0.3439720273,
-0.0937761813,
-0.9015343189,
0.8811440468,
0.2939468026,
-0.1830246001,
-0.0127210598,
-0.481633842,
-0.6931906939,
1.2961555719,
0.042156186,
-0.4067898095,
0.1590733975,
0.1372019351,
0.0276617352,
-0.5041180253,
0.1384738535,
0.1024716869,
0.799628377,
0.3408851027,
-0.7124640942,
0.0020740076,
-0.0045917626,
-0.189492926,
0.0575896017,
-0.4309287369,
0.6206625104,
-0.265111953,
-0.3410339653,
-0.3638002872,
0.6820427179,
0.2433822006,
0.9431482553,
0.6497217417,
0.6523252726,
0.7520879507,
0.1752388179,
0.861782968,
-0.2974843085,
0.2284901291,
0.7341623902,
-0.0727340803,
0.7806227207,
0.6107901931,
0.4414782524,
0.7309899926,
0.4196654558,
0.1217777133,
0.5738916397,
-0.0930205137,
-0.5418677926,
-0.8095055819,
-0.4976468086,
-0.3322688043,
0.4953817129,
0.4607927799,
-0.3698163033,
-0.3931776583,
0.4450803697,
-0.1104936972,
0.1446206868,
-0.4240464866,
0.7597982883,
-0.1182960868,
-0.5278169513,
0.4746085703,
-0.3734849989,
0.8201415539,
-0.5647266507,
-0.0865697414,
0.0696842372,
0.2081452757,
-0.2113604248,
-0.546164155,
-0.1248531491,
-0.5885074735,
-0.2524527013,
-0.262645483,
0.8955193162,
-0.7492320538,
-0.4220205247,
0.1584357172,
0.7345220447,
-0.312422365,
-0.0324133523,
-0.6076307297,
0.1863555163,
-0.2006940991,
-0.1246607751,
0.0329362378,
0.5446534157,
0.1099151149,
0.611952424,
1.0041078329,
-0.2574414909,
0.1953447908,
0.0502791479,
0.8622862101,
-0.4534138441,
-0.3793049157,
-0.6439263225,
0.702802062,
-0.4073024094,
-0.2138621658,
1.1279417276,
0.6012428999,
0.9823399782,
-0.0342121609,
0.7154864073,
0.1283115,
-0.123597838,
-0.4818379581,
0.4820002615,
-0.9305719733,
0.2289864272,
-0.1377612054,
-0.8090910912,
-0.1693986207,
0.1779357046,
-0.5001718402,
-0.0432690606,
0.4193042517,
0.7082001567,
-0.3768297434,
-0.0160045754,
0.4796677232,
0.0524684787,
0.2121538222,
0.5914688706,
1.0859475136,
-0.2615483105,
0.6448350549,
-0.2673045695,
-0.3114715517,
-0.3842766583,
-0.8517970443,
-0.9115059376,
-0.6868528724,
-0.2402487248,
-0.424565345,
-0.0575034246,
0.8998054266,
0.8882574439,
-0.3207021058,
-0.1084322035,
0.23178114,
0.3370184004,
-0.4114570916,
-0.2540113032,
0.1926564723,
-0.4341011643,
-0.6884894371,
0.3825170994,
0.395698607,
0.0731251612,
-0.4388402402,
-0.056426093,
-0.2308895439,
-0.01671388,
1.0576410294,
0.1165166423,
-0.6672595143,
-0.2784849405,
0.2248340994,
-0.1343521625,
-0.0812408999,
1.1615242958,
-0.7552230358,
0.5806998014,
0.6890789866,
0.397809118,
0.2904344499,
0.1165848523,
0.5503177643,
-0.5836000443,
0.1137154251,
0.1172461584,
0.3229057193,
0.443711102,
0.0274160951,
0.068625316,
0.7046089768,
-0.1392921656,
-0.4721761942,
0.4965662956,
-1.3948197365,
-0.5250287056,
1.304210186,
0.1960240752,
-0.3569497466,
-0.6182378531,
-0.0813128278,
-0.0564778447,
-0.3483929336,
0.4993456304,
0.2169875205,
0.222566992,
0.0962317362,
-0.310100913,
0.3768343925,
0.3990257978,
-0.5758060217,
-0.0423228256,
0.8124342561,
0.3533116281,
0.2859304845,
0.5654785633,
0.2177774906,
0.1653318703,
-0.0676451176,
-0.2538696826,
-0.5414798856,
-0.399527818,
0.0772910193,
0.5293149352,
-0.261199981,
-0.1591788381
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05969v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05969v2
|
Breaking Symmetry When Training Transformers
| 2024-02-06T00:32:28 | 2024-06-16T22:18:36 |
Chunsheng Zuo, Michael Guerzhoy
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
As we show in this paper, the prediction for output token $n+1$ of
Transformer architectures without one of the mechanisms of positional encodings
and causal attention is invariant to permutations of input tokens $1, 2, ...,
n-1$. Usually, both mechanisms are employed and the symmetry with respect to
the input tokens is broken. Recently, it has been shown that one can train
Transformers without positional encodings. This must be enabled by the causal
attention mechanism. In this paper, we elaborate on the argument that the
causal connection mechanism must be responsible for the fact that Transformers
are able to model input sequences where the order is important. Vertical
"slices" of Transformers are all encouraged to represent the same location $k$
in the input sequence. We hypothesize that residual connections contribute to
this phenomenon, and demonstrate evidence for this.
|
[
-0.3638234138,
-0.1670958847,
0.6493487358,
0.1548518836,
-0.2997300327,
-0.2242893875,
0.4932665527,
-0.2426912785,
0.2229759246,
0.34769243,
-0.992444396,
0.0078192316,
-0.8817868233,
0.184952572,
-0.8022870421,
0.948808074,
-0.058856044,
0.4430344701,
-0.2760482132,
-0.3154908717,
-0.8860011697,
-0.5561274886,
-0.6706755161,
-0.5209822655,
0.9420480132,
0.140738517,
0.7416841984,
0.9878486991,
0.5919753909,
0.3888171911,
0.1018646955,
-0.399769038,
-0.697658658,
0.2528583109,
-0.2200426161,
-0.9478930235,
-0.1100904569,
0.0676071942,
0.74846977,
0.7556874156,
0.0013742624,
0.1789528131,
0.1313195825,
0.4849162102,
-0.4207695127,
0.066997461,
-0.6410010457,
0.3624856174,
-0.0702576712,
-0.3069937825,
-0.4947478175,
-0.1037490293,
-0.179147765,
-0.4954396486,
0.50517416,
-0.3048283756,
1.243311882,
0.5658128262,
-0.3646735251,
0.4553815126,
-1.0761104822,
0.4691848755,
-0.2511161864,
0.7715836763,
0.3711184263,
0.5473138094,
-0.0294526313,
-0.6815368533,
-0.4130803645,
0.288694948,
-0.3393237293,
0.4579638243,
0.0237692054,
-0.0160109196,
0.6255006194,
0.1732695103,
-0.2740037739,
0.1744776368,
-0.6042961478,
0.184907034,
0.1367584467,
0.3773885369,
0.213180095,
-0.0739615038,
-0.5720565915,
-0.2310349941,
-0.6360388994,
0.1852284819,
0.4038043916,
-0.0791707933,
-0.3627847433,
0.5523214936,
0.2176000625,
0.6132514477,
0.6621205807,
-0.0151008284,
0.055562105,
-0.1453922242,
-0.2642223537,
0.2736911774,
0.7617332935,
0.0545497201,
0.0956076458,
-0.4166210592,
-0.0214097556,
0.2463806421,
0.6909623146,
-0.4459144473,
0.0600526407,
0.0205563158,
-0.4805502594,
-0.4336590767,
0.59016186,
-0.5909519792,
-0.1032570228,
-0.5640026331,
0.3856984973,
-0.3415569365,
0.0204260461,
-0.0251110718,
-0.3717312217,
0.5252443552,
-0.0350603983,
-1.3327100277,
0.2107596397,
0.8000631928,
0.5267359018,
0.0517894588,
-0.7322040796,
-0.4735079706,
0.2680150867,
-0.1683927923,
0.7917150259,
-0.3819413781,
-0.0676018968,
0.0564921685,
0.3309913874,
-0.2423930466,
-0.4138207436,
0.3948876858,
-0.6382468343,
0.3713001609,
-0.4440153837,
-0.3006435633,
0.0684587359,
-0.1123271435,
-0.7819879055,
0.4533652961,
0.1312011182,
-0.7939625382,
0.684083581,
-0.199833259,
-0.588920176,
-0.2861877084,
-0.3972038031,
-0.5440732241,
0.29814744,
0.1460361928,
0.0254050717,
-0.1193540022,
0.3606725633,
-0.7132923007,
-0.6074573398,
0.3769453466,
-0.7100400329,
1.0671825409,
-0.0928588361,
-0.527241528,
0.1467171907,
-0.7268849611,
-0.643337965,
0.3951118886,
-0.0212204363,
0.0464232825,
0.2134221345,
-0.2991163731,
0.5179896951,
-0.0947504938,
-0.5655859709,
0.0955355838,
-0.5797176361,
0.3159944713,
1.1137043238,
-0.0205278173,
0.6979197264,
-0.1296800077,
0.3933945894,
0.3835223913,
0.4186228514,
-0.124961026,
-0.3021326661,
-1.0364761353,
-0.1389679611,
0.1964214742,
0.2987801433,
-0.5365901589,
0.4706963003,
-0.2170905471,
-0.3630829751,
-0.1849815995,
-0.254077822,
0.1621133089,
0.6530456543,
0.2153185904,
-0.1717936546,
-0.6836594939,
-0.8133727312,
-0.4467966259,
-0.2523373365,
-0.1408713162,
-0.0301336404,
0.2367855906,
0.0274424851,
0.973511219,
-0.4383722544,
-0.2156059593,
-0.1637091488,
-0.0010204075,
0.5941002369,
0.5043692589,
0.5490070581,
-0.5914497375,
-0.1940641701,
-0.2305528969,
-1.0451219082,
0.2131891847,
-0.2591376007,
-0.3477581441,
-0.0575010404,
0.6731647849,
-0.8869869709,
0.5848739147,
0.3809711039,
-0.3322694898,
0.2756052911,
0.325494349,
-0.224040851,
-1.0144724846,
-0.0133405589,
0.0469131358,
0.0751005709,
-0.6659208536,
-0.2228684574,
-0.0045640804,
-0.4462431371,
-0.4413249791,
0.3169941604,
-0.1632305831,
-0.1703071147,
-0.083473675,
-0.2747651637,
-0.1002709791,
0.7447986007,
-0.1430451274,
0.1725941747,
0.5080848336,
-0.4059163332,
0.2048472613,
0.4928462803,
0.1600634158,
0.4916478693,
-0.9102318287,
-0.1333981007,
-0.2430143952,
0.2350074798,
-1.048832655,
-0.157255128,
0.4881046116,
-0.4438378811,
0.4798567891,
-0.1067999974,
-0.3477524817,
-0.3104531169,
-0.0431739613,
0.7040145993,
0.5771518946,
-0.9214040637,
0.6092370749,
-0.0099540316,
0.5735230446,
-0.8088531494,
-0.5582131743,
-0.3959692419,
-0.2773767412,
-0.6111750007,
0.1049109548,
0.5746250749,
0.0405405276,
0.0583721548,
-0.7200103998,
0.0146709615,
0.2248362005,
0.4924275279,
0.2916654646,
-0.2774116099,
-0.1286173165,
0.2565467358,
-0.493801862,
0.4626895189,
-0.2505983114,
0.6822639704,
0.4668429792,
-0.6773527265,
-0.7608728409,
0.2285495698,
1.0538514853,
-0.2578107119,
0.9654582739,
0.677905798,
-0.3871670365,
0.0998289809,
-0.3684712946,
-0.5488968492,
-0.5855758786,
0.2253938317,
-0.3807968199,
-0.5958432555,
0.5579138994,
0.17270872,
-0.1150664464,
0.5486719608,
0.1770811528,
-0.3385738432,
1.3008219004,
0.683845818,
-0.1723751128,
0.8446928263,
-0.0684225932,
0.5313945413,
-0.5474976301,
-0.147029534,
-0.6317434311,
-0.6547419429,
-0.5894194841,
0.2309813946,
0.2171230465,
0.1879855096,
-0.6376110315,
0.4055097103,
-0.4063393772,
0.5381945968,
0.5727985501,
0.1706939042,
-0.0084749721,
0.3839716911,
-0.0713936016,
-0.099055782,
-0.9265955091,
0.0834095329,
0.7309244275,
0.4408317804,
0.7997318506,
-0.1485371888,
0.7579577565,
-0.3617979288,
0.249091208,
-0.705673933,
0.3861623406,
-0.1348095387,
-0.4125748575,
-0.2189246714,
-0.2929528952,
-1.2107087374,
0.1016448885,
0.0348840393,
-0.7604948282,
0.6134593487,
0.1037248895,
0.1825201064,
0.3093039393,
-0.4855246544,
1.0564391613,
-0.1492122114,
-0.2390523851,
0.0312742591,
-0.8666104674,
0.5125725865,
0.2157109529,
-0.38173455,
0.3729073405,
0.6509602666,
0.6150960922,
-0.6357424855,
0.9036640525,
-0.1824003011,
0.0550436787,
-0.0661120191,
0.0145315062,
0.482929945,
0.1544459909,
0.4572519362,
0.5380109549,
-0.3939560056,
-0.4193162024,
-0.8077864051,
0.3107919097,
-1.1751331091,
-0.8780480623,
-0.4946784079,
-0.4508604109,
-0.2500165403,
0.165964365,
0.8522903323,
0.547190845,
0.1964927763,
0.1250255555,
0.4467720091,
0.0962175578,
0.443985343,
-0.0794924125,
-0.0408318266,
-0.295170933,
0.7167482972,
0.1453465521,
0.3850019872,
0.3611581922,
0.010382561,
-0.1486126781,
0.0062299543,
-0.2217721641,
0.4995382726,
-0.6849044561,
-0.1669054776,
-0.507073164,
-0.3994552791,
-0.2559415698,
-0.2181800157,
-0.3551379144,
-0.4000822604,
-0.4274195135,
-0.2977788746,
-0.1845522672,
0.6784952879,
0.0998685509,
0.2152938843,
-0.8734433055,
0.5548486114,
0.5139584541,
0.5210388303,
0.2363551706,
-0.6435934305,
-0.3829403818,
-0.0381700248,
-0.4952589273,
-0.8401717544,
0.1554868221,
-0.3188109398,
0.5780411363,
0.9327781796,
-0.3716417849,
0.8807705641,
-0.9765406251,
0.5794445276,
0.6365277767,
-0.9451098442,
0.2755971849,
-0.4869541824,
0.4482088089,
0.2701472044,
0.339938283,
-0.5794034004,
-0.7468589544,
-0.6511216164,
-0.6530693173,
1.1691282988,
0.0391009487,
0.0494503863,
-0.0959618911,
0.2731611729,
0.2449142188,
-0.1078238934,
-0.6675759554,
-0.601639688,
-0.6988146901,
-0.258664012,
-0.0323084444,
-0.2550653517,
-0.4201845825,
-0.4291519821,
0.2667565644,
0.3245197237,
0.8194934726,
0.0087132277,
0.0450556614,
-0.350207448,
-0.3529250026,
0.7399366498,
0.7553337812,
0.1318061501,
0.12882559,
-0.1816054583,
-0.4907139242,
0.5602449179,
-0.1839628667,
-0.226980567,
0.1394543499,
0.2501153648,
1.002176404,
0.3354633152,
0.1075279564,
0.2430898249,
-0.3584744036,
-0.3412066698,
-0.1746608317,
0.0834104717,
0.0063861641,
0.2667112947,
0.2955380082,
0.597707212,
-0.1246601865,
-0.2294894755,
0.3385491073,
0.3018997908,
-0.7832172513,
-0.5408662558,
1.0129051208,
-0.1098549441,
-0.5151850581,
0.8554320931,
0.3459529281,
-0.4361235499,
0.7801948786,
0.8978890181,
1.2577832937,
-0.3383826315,
0.0880168527,
0.4482245147,
0.4570137262,
-0.1782631427,
-0.2390398234,
0.1116141751,
-0.8325845003,
-0.4127605259,
-0.4197695255,
-0.0676902905,
-0.0839704201,
-0.9445598125,
0.640668273,
-0.5287876725,
-0.0352914073,
-0.2114864886,
-1.119651556,
-0.7106924653,
-0.0177588444,
0.2113993019,
0.4490013719,
-1.0762387514,
0.6516155005,
0.5612918139,
-0.4656988978,
-0.9215896726,
0.1871161908,
-0.1602002531,
-0.6984742284,
0.974313736,
0.2639217675,
-0.049580019,
-0.2706335485,
-0.5765716434,
-1.2603268623,
1.0307866335,
0.7933238745,
-0.3350923657,
-0.0855873227,
0.5006062984,
0.3983548582,
0.0682870001,
-0.0180993229,
0.3079834282,
0.2949247956,
-0.0916089267,
-0.4721698165,
0.01001391,
-0.1617024094,
-0.0274750702,
0.5797244906,
-0.79167068,
0.9857717752,
0.2645894587,
-0.5557230711,
-0.0986101478,
0.5996718407,
0.2159435302,
0.0299196858,
0.3515281975,
0.8828186989,
0.1464361995,
-0.299585253,
1.0367168188,
-0.2582469583,
0.5805639625,
1.0198270082,
-0.1860041916,
0.2597698569,
0.7834009528,
-0.2035846263,
0.5570352674,
0.4026714563,
-0.3697453141,
0.6542127728,
-0.2455043942,
0.2408444881,
-0.1821129173,
0.2107531875,
-0.4047434926,
0.5492683053,
0.0396676324,
-0.561668694,
-0.3664568663,
-0.0768899322,
-0.0874563977,
-0.2642351687,
-0.1811181903,
0.6025520563,
0.0827766508,
-0.616230607,
0.6808853745,
-0.1902055144,
0.0614928529,
-0.5656975508,
-0.1446093023,
-0.4571048319,
0.2622928023,
-0.2806132138,
-0.2883619368,
0.3613494337,
-0.3671379983,
-0.4511710703,
-0.3183809519,
0.630297482,
-0.0778486952,
-0.5793093443,
0.3045638502,
0.0503728949,
-0.3486675322,
0.3328139782,
-0.4232886434,
-0.1672710627,
-0.1102034152,
-0.3239783943,
0.6010257602,
0.5417386889,
0.1555443555,
0.3575620353,
0.5343388319,
-0.3402906954,
0.3850321174,
0.1271910071,
0.7974202633,
-0.6531069279,
-0.4741490185,
-1.0935376883,
0.7453469038,
0.1195278242,
-0.3017764986,
0.6857643723,
0.2025123835,
1.0085763931,
-0.3318820596,
0.3783726692,
0.4367110729,
-0.2173694968,
-0.4143187106,
0.7030994892,
-0.3109425008,
0.0686322674,
-0.231249854,
-1.3753407001,
-0.4100981653,
0.5179721117,
-0.2692158222,
-0.1284882575,
1.270050168,
0.2326894701,
-0.4012844265,
0.1680721194,
0.3576162159,
0.223875463,
0.2999009192,
0.311052829,
0.8657098413,
-0.7057145834,
0.438906461,
-0.2841217816,
0.1575532407,
0.0772656873,
-0.3795298934,
-0.8307087421,
-0.4152407646,
-0.0181646012,
-0.5000853539,
-0.2278898358,
0.2515504956,
0.4249641001,
-0.6267752051,
-0.3520770073,
-0.6067156196,
0.4115267992,
-0.6056637168,
-0.2196074575,
0.2783140242,
-0.609705925,
-0.5690889359,
0.0280348286,
0.5727748871,
-0.1550805569,
-0.2454957515,
0.2306957394,
-0.0722621307,
-0.18444933,
0.4384046197,
0.3361844122,
-0.6719275713,
-0.5434279442,
0.2376279235,
-0.0426720716,
0.4714518189,
0.8905724287,
-0.7996231914,
0.1106310412,
0.4783650041,
0.7052994967,
0.5306148529,
0.0709203705,
0.7871387601,
-0.6304810643,
0.3741555214,
-0.0135219386,
0.6814604402,
-0.1508758515,
-0.4125047624,
0.26952371,
0.540540874,
-0.4328567386,
-0.8331416845,
0.5083510876,
-0.9057751298,
-0.0051809167,
0.8775266409,
-0.0189685374,
-0.4591915309,
0.0010281448,
0.0609323718,
0.5624181628,
-0.0858212933,
0.9255897403,
0.564791739,
-0.0766159445,
-0.1300157011,
-0.1058747247,
0.0921835303,
0.7091187239,
-0.260443598,
-0.2264757901,
0.1828179061,
0.1361482441,
0.3263707757,
-0.1488240808,
-0.4064278603,
0.5076500773,
0.2104585618,
-0.0526612177,
0.1449332237,
-0.478142947,
-0.6977168322,
0.2986268103,
-0.0766081363,
-0.4209409058
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03597v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03597v1
|
Identifying Reasons for Contraceptive Switching from Real-World Data Using Large Language Models
| 2024-02-06T00:14:53 | 2024-02-06T00:14:53 |
Brenda Y. Miao, Christopher YK Williams, Ebenezer Chinedu-Eneh, Travis Zack, Emily Alsentzer, Atul J. Butte, Irene Y. Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Prescription contraceptives play a critical role in supporting women's
reproductive health. With nearly 50 million women in the United States using
contraceptives, understanding the factors that drive contraceptives selection
and switching is of significant interest. However, many factors related to
medication switching are often only captured in unstructured clinical notes and
can be difficult to extract. Here, we evaluate the zero-shot abilities of a
recently developed large language model, GPT-4 (via HIPAA-compliant Microsoft
Azure API), to identify reasons for switching between classes of contraceptives
from the UCSF Information Commons clinical notes dataset. We demonstrate that
GPT-4 can accurately extract reasons for contraceptive switching, outperforming
baseline BERT-based models with microF1 scores of 0.849 and 0.881 for
contraceptive start and stop extraction, respectively. Human evaluation of
GPT-4-extracted reasons for switching showed 91.4% accuracy, with minimal
hallucinations. Using extracted reasons, we identified patient preference,
adverse events, and insurance as key reasons for switching using unsupervised
topic modeling approaches. Notably, we also showed using our approach that
"weight gain/mood change" and "insurance coverage" are disproportionately found
as reasons for contraceptive switching in specific demographic populations. Our
code and supplemental data are available at
https://github.com/BMiao10/contraceptive-switching.
|
[
-0.1270952523,
-0.7327817678,
0.8551618457,
0.216796875,
-0.1826704443,
-0.4083798826,
0.0454860106,
-0.4911445677,
-0.2595085502,
0.628303051,
-0.6315367818,
-0.5069010258,
-0.5327031612,
-0.1049339771,
-0.5681939125,
1.2120989561,
-0.1776627153,
0.1535681635,
-0.05862692,
0.3049467802,
-0.5576946139,
-0.5227137208,
-0.2498976886,
-0.5330755711,
0.8998051882,
0.4912290573,
0.5031860471,
0.2644909024,
0.5039406419,
0.0377731733,
0.0825019702,
-0.2998075485,
-0.200074181,
-0.0689551011,
-0.1477048099,
-0.6937378645,
-0.5146027803,
0.1779128313,
0.23819381,
0.6982522607,
-0.3362276256,
0.4324027896,
-0.0846158564,
0.5592832565,
-0.6696420312,
0.1992924958,
-0.6297979951,
0.1532942206,
-0.6035851836,
0.0658484474,
-0.3979755342,
0.0551249199,
0.4722660184,
-0.3493784666,
0.3869650066,
-0.3824214339,
1.0894207954,
0.0057691834,
-0.8127077818,
-0.1562090367,
-1.0135217905,
0.6515248418,
-0.6596670747,
0.7773228288,
0.3916842043,
-0.0006432314,
-0.1133284792,
-0.4365243018,
-0.5186647177,
-0.2474303246,
0.1133835092,
0.1162384748,
-0.4454264343,
-0.070303984,
0.413654983,
-0.0360158049,
-0.5392209888,
0.0346088521,
-0.5005064011,
-0.1509330124,
0.3800914586,
0.0712208077,
0.475931555,
0.0271916259,
-0.1469650716,
-0.0672080293,
-0.7807139754,
0.1006241664,
0.4274172783,
0.3409914076,
-0.3349183202,
0.6999061704,
0.3628242016,
0.5582008958,
0.0546799451,
0.169005394,
0.0883295909,
-0.1108587459,
-0.2798714638,
-0.0075993175,
0.5750884414,
0.3127078712,
-0.1442327499,
-0.1244664863,
0.250990957,
-0.0779731274,
0.3588435352,
-0.8729054332,
-0.2384090573,
0.3716528416,
-0.7430097461,
-0.0691885054,
-0.0969128832,
-0.8572385907,
-0.1984933466,
-0.4734357595,
0.1668453366,
-0.5386270881,
-0.1650646925,
0.166417405,
-0.2463979572,
0.3337308466,
0.4449721575,
-1.0077021122,
0.3481319249,
0.7277220488,
1.0007811785,
-0.5667905211,
-0.156429261,
-0.206933111,
-0.1229342297,
-0.3791530132,
0.8564918041,
-0.1410611868,
-0.4132788181,
0.2288816422,
-0.0008988335,
-0.3670673668,
-0.5819595456,
0.5084289312,
-0.2552238405,
0.6416575313,
-0.6597133279,
-0.5749843717,
-0.0720548928,
0.2151499987,
-0.6583147049,
0.3648708165,
-0.0342337787,
-0.568695426,
0.5598301888,
-0.4803605378,
-0.4687842131,
0.048349794,
-0.1263154596,
-0.6133608818,
0.1313038468,
-0.1960226446,
0.1678542495,
-0.3787845075,
0.2929208279,
-0.2879843712,
-0.1437481046,
0.5893306732,
-0.6542263031,
0.7531827688,
0.0853756815,
-0.110437423,
0.0981394947,
-0.5013909936,
-0.4192835689,
0.1132222041,
-0.2551157773,
-0.449262917,
0.0153850028,
0.3938007653,
0.2737132609,
0.1068795845,
-0.7086682916,
0.3037893772,
0.0528041795,
0.3210144937,
0.5433516502,
0.4068487287,
0.1691773236,
-0.2417983264,
0.6384198666,
0.0690704733,
0.4062456787,
0.1644048989,
-0.9585556984,
-0.218092829,
-0.1680126786,
0.4459308088,
0.4631877542,
-0.4138985872,
-0.0833950341,
0.0299575403,
-0.1395679861,
-0.2171250582,
0.1014495268,
0.2731088996,
0.6534329653,
0.4638434649,
0.0269667394,
-0.1818966568,
-0.7158579826,
-0.3418252468,
-0.3054890931,
0.046159517,
0.1347480416,
0.5525947809,
-0.3142035007,
1.0643769503,
-0.84799546,
-0.0885515362,
-0.410201937,
0.2263884842,
0.4093257487,
0.3180821836,
0.3472596705,
-0.7700812221,
-0.2168937624,
-0.1591102332,
-0.2535154521,
-0.3588687181,
-0.6424745321,
-0.4102582633,
-0.1429361701,
0.3800050914,
-0.7719480395,
0.5232656598,
0.3658319712,
-0.3406094015,
0.8231092691,
-0.3984639645,
-0.2515958846,
-0.789291501,
0.2282565832,
0.1913990527,
0.2060606927,
-0.7613590956,
-0.1685473919,
0.3736253381,
-0.0830187201,
-0.5681827664,
0.4727090001,
-0.287132442,
0.1168578118,
0.1613291204,
-0.3531250656,
-0.2522811592,
0.1342545003,
-0.17874071,
0.3627236485,
-0.106757842,
-0.5280681252,
0.1551726758,
0.5596256852,
0.0636039972,
0.4384228289,
-0.473644346,
-0.1553422064,
0.1226733848,
0.1903966963,
-0.9805755019,
-0.1973049045,
0.3546917737,
-0.1388562471,
0.2918441892,
-0.6149854064,
-0.0564367883,
-0.409108758,
0.0049254796,
-0.0148257539,
0.3467585444,
-0.3147257566,
0.4232081771,
0.2362677753,
-0.2980164587,
-0.2956467271,
-0.8031327724,
0.3939743638,
-0.1645820737,
0.108124733,
0.5099312663,
0.1313289404,
-0.1729058623,
0.1305268109,
-0.2731023729,
-0.0559408702,
-0.3960519433,
0.3085661829,
0.7114761472,
0.2226284891,
0.4430420995,
0.3312737942,
-0.2534728646,
0.3196901977,
-0.4212015271,
0.554872334,
0.3060024083,
-0.2343549877,
-0.3284582794,
0.4990107119,
0.4466173351,
-0.2188994884,
0.5054839849,
0.2428708971,
-0.3543821275,
-0.2023775131,
-0.4103495181,
-0.0383410938,
-0.3007630706,
0.2401620001,
0.0132797798,
-0.36479491,
0.6137388349,
0.0738490224,
0.0777103603,
0.3609215617,
0.6308066845,
0.0006020796,
0.7133901119,
0.322684139,
0.1666931063,
0.7620568871,
-0.1320911795,
0.2282275259,
-0.5601520538,
-0.2591362298,
-0.2052213103,
-0.188018769,
-0.4540271461,
-0.3385462761,
0.2849901617,
-0.292034328,
-0.2130034417,
0.2332548052,
-0.3687306345,
0.0356435217,
0.0665315837,
0.2483402789,
0.2319134474,
-0.0168359913,
-0.1679399461,
-0.1103009433,
-0.3860373497,
-0.0658888146,
1.3748556376,
0.3026260734,
0.7959521413,
0.2878054976,
0.4554655552,
0.3573037982,
0.4493578672,
-0.5732742548,
0.6455125809,
-0.686532855,
-0.7522431612,
-0.1581407338,
-0.7575158477,
-1.1709860563,
0.3958011568,
-0.3716440499,
-0.5896369219,
0.325217098,
0.1913669258,
-0.4335478842,
0.2007095516,
-0.9336881042,
1.120392561,
-0.5792149305,
-0.4976304173,
0.0853834152,
-0.4663493931,
0.428144753,
-0.0257996209,
-0.1168804839,
-0.3587604463,
0.0972481295,
0.3995510638,
-0.4872013032,
0.8069008589,
-0.188428551,
-0.3274611831,
-0.0943640918,
-0.0585632436,
-0.1083664894,
-0.04070355,
0.2579235733,
0.5976881385,
0.0455136821,
0.0191374347,
-0.460208863,
0.7450829744,
-0.6462470293,
-0.3889770508,
-0.5894591212,
-0.4905083477,
-0.2520287037,
0.298086524,
0.33601439,
0.3096911311,
-0.1696033478,
-0.2026793659,
0.3751408756,
-0.4422802031,
0.34278512,
0.802547276,
-0.4167561829,
-0.0821022317,
0.4624764621,
0.6730447412,
0.2671793699,
0.5035175681,
0.5584683418,
-0.6319429874,
-0.305334121,
-0.5473154187,
0.3628752828,
-0.2001942843,
0.0994313136,
-0.6667593122,
-0.0521037802,
-0.5139065385,
0.1891432256,
-0.2327739894,
-0.1337480396,
-0.4386668801,
-0.2058930397,
0.2987867594,
0.4048244357,
0.1939334869,
-0.0011354098,
-0.9002036452,
0.3478516936,
0.5111454725,
0.3351967931,
-0.1276579648,
-0.2581984401,
0.1718497872,
-0.3612819612,
-0.3253072202,
-1.5345396996,
0.373416543,
-0.1062665433,
0.5543487668,
0.5674025416,
0.0405533612,
0.8492259383,
-0.3737590313,
0.5794430971,
0.1346257776,
-0.9251770973,
0.3139739931,
-0.6952041388,
0.5868950486,
0.4221899211,
0.3754142523,
-0.8209125996,
0.169328168,
-0.4289493561,
-0.9110546112,
0.5311377048,
0.3715670109,
-0.1273504645,
0.0208064783,
0.5983088613,
0.0905077085,
0.3047957718,
-0.6764646769,
-0.1610382795,
0.0226691086,
-0.0097615048,
0.162960723,
0.0174438637,
-0.1076301709,
-0.1206742898,
0.3584420681,
-0.0758553073,
0.3269373775,
0.2439452857,
0.0700739399,
-0.0820944011,
0.6808248162,
0.6808293462,
0.7305755615,
-0.481931895,
0.1856745332,
0.0313393064,
-0.8477135301,
0.1094124168,
0.7523150444,
-0.714045763,
0.0674975961,
0.526678741,
0.7272542119,
0.3648311496,
-0.5929657221,
0.462693423,
0.0265007988,
-0.2199430913,
-0.3481507897,
-0.0745318979,
0.0054674679,
-0.2002402395,
0.2034329176,
-0.0054429802,
0.2065381259,
-0.7935877442,
-0.0017383042,
0.3228130639,
-0.4346925914,
-0.3166857958,
0.6014428735,
0.0717381462,
-0.1191138253,
0.5698847175,
-0.0743849725,
-0.2478295267,
0.6027770042,
0.8655155301,
0.7690077424,
-0.4066675603,
0.5556698442,
0.1971837133,
0.1561306715,
-0.167627871,
0.1261600554,
0.3509769142,
-0.7385743856,
-0.1116317734,
-0.0550493933,
-0.6544694901,
0.1652543098,
-0.9379760027,
0.3337263465,
-0.3353560567,
-0.4330980182,
0.0904926062,
-0.3486458063,
-0.727134645,
0.021019483,
0.4813848734,
0.7075991631,
-0.9775158167,
0.6144401431,
0.7608931065,
-0.5748152733,
-0.6092879176,
0.2886640728,
0.2454714328,
-0.4174069464,
0.1402652264,
-0.0528975911,
0.1746799052,
-0.496673882,
-0.4472430646,
-0.5222262144,
0.9547111392,
0.3953692615,
-0.9116919041,
-0.2852966189,
0.4260996878,
0.5021620989,
-0.3442198336,
0.3673803508,
0.6472365856,
0.234491989,
0.1493869573,
-0.6042291522,
-0.0689151585,
-0.0579800457,
-0.0719361752,
0.5872660279,
-0.3538452983,
1.3798691034,
-0.3676321805,
0.0122854644,
-0.2085894197,
-0.1930323839,
0.278875351,
0.5506564975,
0.5950811505,
0.4902638197,
0.6197810769,
0.0413817726,
0.8714334965,
-0.0172227807,
0.4512397051,
1.1657243967,
-0.8170561194,
1.2337104082,
0.4528759122,
-0.325194329,
0.7005259395,
0.20778431,
-0.1041677818,
0.2253280878,
-0.1157118455,
-0.1715679616,
-0.3246307671,
0.3879457116,
-0.4423082769,
0.5972992182,
0.3599991202,
-0.3581797779,
-0.4696010053,
0.1015023738,
0.3338694274,
-0.5681775212,
-0.0675237998,
0.5958291888,
0.0457300507,
-0.7244213223,
0.1155990511,
-0.1420393437,
0.0216280129,
-1.107606411,
-0.3859270513,
-0.1716155261,
0.4088230729,
-0.2496127188,
-0.6570287943,
-0.0351175591,
0.2815247774,
-0.138589859,
-0.5753355026,
0.7749729753,
-0.4276165068,
-0.4933878481,
0.2792359591,
0.5646408796,
-0.0499252193,
-0.0571778007,
-0.9082740545,
-0.2474904358,
0.1023295671,
-0.0481454805,
0.5827216506,
0.4104467034,
-0.4227027893,
0.3482365012,
1.3310334682,
0.3837178946,
-0.3037454784,
0.2797021866,
0.6601355672,
-0.8351012468,
-0.6120731235,
-0.959226191,
0.4454963207,
-0.1726174951,
-0.7224066854,
0.9750757813,
0.5787016153,
0.2265393436,
-0.2970540226,
0.6341747642,
0.1957715303,
0.707064271,
-0.4759358764,
1.0636532307,
-0.2778181434,
0.417870909,
-0.2845965326,
-0.6738618612,
-0.4942340255,
0.3430591226,
-0.6381250024,
-0.1779165566,
0.5968897939,
0.258477509,
-0.0604142584,
0.0307629686,
0.214199543,
0.5075027347,
0.8370677233,
0.2521832585,
0.5885941982,
-0.2276837975,
0.6621479392,
0.2349824905,
-0.3224304318,
-0.2164926231,
-1.0702525377,
-0.5119947195,
-0.3147176206,
-0.4591569602,
-0.3947310746,
0.0566281229,
0.7829220891,
0.5521435738,
-0.6819438338,
-0.1739698648,
-0.2332354784,
0.1040349603,
-0.4117789268,
-0.1807952821,
0.045310799,
-0.113640368,
-0.0476654358,
-0.055760745,
0.2422960252,
-0.0516536757,
-0.1387014687,
0.5786773562,
-0.4113904238,
0.1347230226,
0.3792822063,
0.6447427273,
-0.6396946311,
0.1302842349,
0.1249720827,
-0.1995148212,
-0.3656086624,
1.0587025881,
-0.4819382429,
0.5079056025,
0.519977808,
0.2294497341,
0.5973318219,
-0.0023454644,
0.6220648885,
-0.1222109497,
-0.0990162715,
-0.0916540027,
0.4498578608,
0.1576509923,
-0.3984754384,
0.1850421131,
0.3952661455,
-0.6797528863,
-0.5455362797,
0.0600779355,
-1.0111703873,
-0.2285480797,
1.3419454098,
-0.2469735742,
-0.1285380721,
-0.4648959339,
-0.3390071988,
0.0215460211,
-0.4970583916,
0.9224825501,
0.858006835,
-0.5484842658,
-0.4611292183,
-0.9618487358,
0.360473603,
0.2927514315,
-1.1906570196,
0.1238353774,
0.4555075169,
0.4838988781,
0.1413446367,
0.7545487881,
-0.3215349317,
0.2107344866,
-0.2200454473,
0.1763715297,
0.2896065414,
-0.1366862208,
-0.274586767,
0.0363189206,
-0.4064941406,
-0.4035278261
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05132v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05132v2
|
TexShape: Information Theoretic Sentence Embedding for Language Models
| 2024-02-05T22:48:28 | 2024-05-11T20:03:26 |
Kaan Kale, Homa Esfahanizadeh, Noel Elias, Oguzhan Baser, Muriel Medard, Sriram Vishwanath
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IT, math.IT
|
With the exponential growth in data volume and the emergence of
data-intensive applications, particularly in the field of machine learning,
concerns related to resource utilization, privacy, and fairness have become
paramount. This paper focuses on the textual domain of data and addresses
challenges regarding encoding sentences to their optimized representations
through the lens of information-theory. In particular, we use empirical
estimates of mutual information, using the Donsker-Varadhan definition of
Kullback-Leibler divergence. Our approach leverages this estimation to train an
information-theoretic sentence embedding, called TexShape, for (task-based)
data compression or for filtering out sensitive information, enhancing privacy
and fairness. In this study, we employ a benchmark language model for initial
text representation, complemented by neural networks for information-theoretic
compression and mutual information estimations. Our experiments demonstrate
significant advancements in preserving maximal targeted information and minimal
sensitive information over adverse compression ratios, in terms of predictive
accuracy of downstream models that are trained using the compressed data.
|
[
-0.1878683567,
-0.8297632933,
0.6448432803,
0.1069250554,
-0.0517416447,
-0.0835878104,
-0.2480781525,
-0.3000279963,
-0.136660561,
0.3896558881,
-0.2905845344,
-0.4879077375,
-0.952536881,
-0.1556633264,
-0.4808383286,
0.7836225033,
0.0039635571,
-0.0305215977,
-0.2527502775,
-0.1659336537,
-0.422150135,
-0.7533708215,
-0.2631865144,
-0.0378766544,
0.4297488928,
0.1579950303,
0.7045735121,
0.7948642969,
0.1980779022,
0.2367067933,
0.1274033189,
0.0042204447,
-0.3946009278,
0.3890365064,
0.0881905928,
-0.553653121,
0.0611227527,
0.0364631601,
0.6170930266,
0.8373289704,
-0.4262439609,
-0.1814726591,
0.1673016399,
0.4736887217,
-0.8831412196,
0.4084095359,
-0.4363020062,
0.4805624783,
0.0166164096,
-0.255530864,
-0.5814011097,
-0.7116619349,
0.0382614285,
-0.4267807007,
0.0275799613,
0.3151460886,
0.7993229032,
0.3018889427,
-0.4719712436,
-0.0698234439,
-0.5620649457,
1.0085171461,
-0.4133983552,
0.6153410077,
0.8036198616,
0.1615352482,
-0.0190724973,
-0.639575541,
-0.5142455101,
-0.1071206182,
-0.1714467406,
-0.0398685187,
-0.6246162057,
0.2430200875,
0.3020911217,
0.1303965598,
-0.4044786692,
0.0889088511,
-0.0588854328,
-0.240121454,
0.5777016878,
0.1682872921,
0.1101929992,
-0.0381446742,
-0.2810491621,
-0.3842550218,
-0.3553228974,
0.0097492654,
0.4783461988,
0.2568612397,
-0.1605064124,
0.4956758618,
-0.1243717223,
0.5324012041,
-0.1790469885,
0.3997601271,
0.1707033366,
-0.3459120393,
-0.4405139089,
0.0141813867,
0.8866496086,
0.0766734481,
0.2153260708,
-0.3335618079,
-0.0736005381,
0.1651821434,
0.2878680229,
-0.9656995535,
0.1470499784,
0.2782194018,
-0.5499632955,
-0.5622295141,
0.317505151,
-0.6652129292,
-0.3632619679,
-0.2425682694,
0.1931243688,
-0.5060073137,
-0.1100686938,
0.3745000958,
-0.1590701342,
-0.0830005184,
-0.0254317354,
-0.9045552611,
0.6348761916,
0.6181925535,
0.7330781221,
0.3216716647,
-0.1014910638,
-0.6582862139,
0.1645299345,
-0.1437080801,
0.4778937697,
-0.8059624434,
-0.1707387716,
0.2722137272,
-0.2004173696,
0.0565024242,
-0.0993540511,
0.8868450522,
-0.3150241077,
0.3980402946,
-0.0541472323,
-0.9718082547,
-0.2494497746,
-0.035820879,
-0.6893912554,
0.7968686819,
0.1985195577,
-1.0177894831,
0.2249209583,
-0.583992362,
-0.156272769,
-0.0421046168,
-0.3977240324,
-0.405258894,
0.2609186172,
0.0560384318,
0.8169700503,
-0.424911201,
0.413238585,
-0.3851953447,
-0.2799139917,
0.3836647272,
-0.3501861989,
0.6287763119,
0.2704613507,
0.0423640385,
-0.3761995137,
-0.374369204,
0.3366883397,
0.1232803389,
-0.1980816871,
-0.6055645347,
-0.0653708801,
0.4809371531,
-0.2081281841,
0.0603228472,
-0.758610189,
0.1252769679,
-0.1347452253,
0.4457915425,
0.899425149,
-0.3328122199,
0.4791751504,
-0.3543702364,
0.4418957531,
0.1805485189,
0.1932099015,
-0.1327651739,
-0.2656100988,
-0.3566335738,
0.1736830175,
0.6367030144,
0.4305853248,
-0.3797996342,
0.4471375048,
-0.4045982659,
-0.179868266,
-0.3485721052,
-0.2128072232,
0.2443429679,
0.2808431983,
0.2247434407,
-0.1413911283,
-0.5736826658,
-0.9698709846,
-0.3994707465,
-0.044007197,
0.0730805323,
0.4123784602,
0.1106581613,
-0.2193186432,
1.0318933725,
-0.6001645923,
-0.1050108075,
-0.1487474591,
0.2260153145,
0.1203403547,
0.4371493161,
0.6326066852,
-1.051166296,
-0.5169146657,
-0.1471220702,
-0.7660870552,
-0.2051483691,
0.2817617655,
-0.0801932439,
-0.0150037324,
0.2138409019,
-0.5080153942,
0.4764455855,
0.7764740586,
-0.7064426541,
0.1098206639,
-0.252684921,
0.1843792796,
-1.2852787971,
-0.072871469,
0.0926566496,
-0.6071478128,
-0.6815917492,
-0.1264945567,
0.1977060139,
-0.0556839295,
-0.0077681402,
0.4343364537,
-0.3467240632,
0.1985358149,
-0.2720853686,
-0.0255491473,
0.0235302038,
0.4607692957,
-0.0734614283,
0.5134619474,
0.4618412554,
-0.6370125413,
0.0201221891,
0.4000674784,
-0.3298162222,
0.4698739946,
-0.4849340618,
0.2207282633,
-0.4469463825,
0.2327508032,
-0.0912702158,
-0.1670573503,
0.0707921162,
-0.406852901,
0.2633455098,
-0.1136448979,
-0.6102737784,
0.1016977429,
-0.5165754557,
0.4911078811,
0.7291314602,
-0.2955114543,
0.5357972383,
0.6084607244,
-0.1286697239,
-1.0274302959,
-0.9963583946,
0.0452897176,
-0.1695290506,
-0.5261138082,
0.6554124355,
0.0172008947,
-0.3006123006,
0.3262717426,
-0.0654874966,
-0.5527254939,
-0.0325283594,
0.4108508825,
-0.0473397188,
-0.0401094295,
0.4705228508,
0.3079075217,
-0.1672463119,
-0.0751293451,
-0.4635369778,
0.5913204551,
0.0405003987,
0.0424053222,
-0.3050449789,
0.7474559546,
-0.1118669063,
0.2190449536,
0.855517745,
0.4191242754,
-0.4710372984,
-0.4228652716,
-0.4029895663,
-0.1935215592,
-0.4176445305,
0.3809983134,
-0.0816734582,
-1.0763509274,
0.0774438754,
-0.0246056803,
-0.1573410332,
0.158924669,
-0.0086687198,
-0.1483495086,
0.7625896931,
1.2197347879,
-0.1412085295,
0.6029363275,
-0.2449422032,
0.1205371395,
-0.4384515882,
-0.1027445272,
-0.7023432851,
-0.0766477808,
-0.5724387169,
-0.364082247,
0.1750899404,
0.1087179333,
-0.3186094463,
0.3827987015,
-0.2077029049,
0.591561377,
0.6419817805,
0.2466678172,
0.1268008351,
0.2070341259,
-0.1124837771,
-0.1425751746,
-0.865681231,
-0.48332569,
1.1586668491,
0.2176642418,
0.8239723444,
0.1295096129,
0.5964052677,
0.7338104844,
-0.3459115922,
-0.5892233849,
0.2949146628,
-0.4063595235,
-0.0485225245,
0.0198147744,
-0.6689271927,
-1.0797730684,
-0.1219281107,
-0.4017904103,
-0.8180031776,
0.3295960724,
-0.0501392148,
-0.0425463803,
0.196794644,
-0.6630744338,
0.7021366358,
0.1250011027,
-0.4673824012,
-0.419141978,
-0.4351898432,
-0.0055948985,
-0.1658962369,
0.1551659852,
-0.072721079,
-0.2639382184,
0.7378447056,
-0.5864157677,
0.657507956,
-0.245916754,
0.2407106012,
-0.1058812961,
0.0140799368,
0.4821498692,
-0.0084216101,
-0.1387468278,
0.2591620088,
0.1606530249,
-0.5366895199,
-0.8425238132,
0.3920704424,
-0.6323217154,
-0.3089915216,
-0.4700651765,
-0.6343474388,
-0.320509702,
-0.050706666,
0.0925646871,
0.4946976006,
-0.2748779058,
0.4628255069,
0.6345523596,
-0.2996433377,
0.7060748339,
0.251668483,
0.0476888493,
-0.2453946322,
0.4042255282,
-0.0817247704,
-0.0239143204,
0.7294825315,
0.3435932696,
-0.3484660089,
-0.3390376866,
0.0765229762,
-0.0456236899,
-0.7826147079,
-0.3786078095,
-0.8874680996,
-0.3380212188,
-0.1439230889,
0.0115029244,
-0.1118184701,
-0.6043422222,
0.1667109579,
-0.0702977255,
0.5797327757,
0.8776897788,
-0.2010679841,
0.2664213181,
-0.8393682837,
-0.0808427483,
-0.0925646797,
0.3924154341,
-0.1630514562,
-0.1179739833,
-0.5020759702,
0.1517843604,
-0.0499802381,
-0.8021060824,
0.2410236001,
0.2006344348,
0.4943449795,
0.0592039414,
0.2449814826,
0.2208842337,
-0.3617938161,
0.5513576269,
0.0781229064,
-0.9906156659,
0.5860215425,
-0.1144814417,
0.1198798195,
0.435302794,
0.4295288324,
-0.755671382,
-0.320853442,
-0.5706299543,
-0.5019030571,
0.7578320503,
0.4869173169,
0.591231823,
0.2134828418,
0.2790957391,
0.4563238919,
0.4215291142,
-0.8428593278,
-0.1357107162,
-0.0418406278,
-0.7358204126,
0.2619944215,
-0.4250477254,
0.0515907072,
0.1088628694,
0.4034514725,
-0.0031929079,
0.6099110842,
0.0605169199,
-0.2272962034,
0.4249737859,
0.4736599028,
0.1319473535,
0.2328378856,
-0.1211771071,
0.1233890504,
-0.1929925084,
-0.8413779736,
0.3527860045,
0.3464449346,
-0.3190963268,
0.0717114061,
0.390003562,
0.8628462553,
0.0126889814,
-0.5480981469,
0.8847846389,
-0.3553411961,
0.0131941028,
-0.1363235861,
0.1114498377,
-0.3910114169,
0.3010905981,
0.3444107473,
0.0949832574,
0.1936751455,
-0.3337474465,
0.3027408719,
0.3028002977,
-0.4741402566,
-0.0820114985,
0.7260530591,
-0.0034439573,
-0.1048109978,
0.3951200545,
0.177981481,
-0.3615982234,
0.5295378566,
0.16197142,
1.1046723127,
-0.2892038226,
0.2998472154,
0.2740218937,
0.1362262368,
-0.0648659319,
0.260404259,
-0.4685162306,
-0.8032484651,
-0.267331481,
-0.5345190763,
-0.3329956532,
-0.2130358368,
-0.4835484028,
0.2721136808,
-0.4537119567,
-0.2683292627,
-0.1148205101,
-0.1098281592,
-0.7903110385,
0.0838320032,
-0.0570991561,
0.714084506,
-0.6007400155,
0.944691062,
0.1359369159,
-0.5208142996,
-0.7379935384,
0.2428950816,
-0.3314635158,
-0.5221110582,
0.7458302975,
0.2976494133,
-0.0026842805,
-0.125029847,
-0.5708904266,
-0.6485978365,
1.1009258032,
0.8273383975,
-0.6512525678,
0.0058560665,
0.3475363255,
0.160803169,
-0.419701755,
0.3795228004,
0.1374037415,
0.3509726524,
-0.4996701777,
-0.7327994704,
0.2018565387,
-0.3633963764,
0.1708220094,
0.1196171865,
-0.4347204864,
0.8222791553,
0.1033771858,
-0.3655878305,
-0.2222173065,
0.2435796857,
-0.1644404083,
-0.0007903081,
0.4739480913,
0.4392735958,
0.9043849111,
-0.147841841,
1.4240256548,
-0.3669864535,
0.2914376259,
0.9717795849,
0.1068435609,
0.804913342,
0.2975148559,
-0.2425839603,
0.6726722717,
0.487822026,
0.0738745183,
0.6463761926,
0.090554148,
-0.4207318127,
0.1440686882,
-0.5074082017,
-0.4195683897,
0.4747970402,
0.0346617065,
-0.731127739,
-0.0426361598,
0.1506497562,
0.2118528932,
0.2386542708,
-0.0460578837,
0.6233441234,
0.1149179861,
-0.2074442506,
0.3240328729,
0.3208731115,
0.7243053317,
-0.676340282,
-0.032499902,
-0.3308780193,
0.0038891835,
-0.1213599294,
-0.7511076331,
0.2782899141,
0.1270596683,
-0.2285086215,
-0.4013772905,
0.6768221259,
-0.5913823843,
-0.2964657247,
0.4233365655,
0.3927980661,
-0.0401579626,
-0.0658442006,
-0.5268495083,
0.1168045774,
-0.2027585506,
-0.1331700236,
0.1325969398,
0.3812992275,
0.1898262352,
0.5621589422,
0.2124135196,
0.0222327784,
-0.1116682738,
0.1748749167,
0.7135972977,
-0.883476615,
-0.8374931812,
-0.9686330557,
0.3338290155,
-0.48115924,
0.1319686323,
0.4677962363,
0.5748338699,
0.6218928695,
0.1104438603,
1.1982866526,
-0.1651483327,
0.1757835597,
-0.9057866931,
0.8503576517,
-0.2966404259,
0.0806975663,
-0.183909446,
-1.0770978928,
-0.0976035371,
0.5894252658,
0.0754316077,
0.1637189984,
0.9783853889,
0.5618113279,
-0.4153626263,
0.3465102315,
0.2916198373,
0.2803834975,
-0.0042671766,
0.93967098,
0.5839592218,
-0.6646468043,
0.4702532887,
-0.458280772,
-0.0628216341,
0.0190009456,
-0.9926292896,
-0.6752555966,
-0.9663882852,
-0.2678329647,
-0.2344362289,
0.0396670997,
0.853049159,
0.9389786124,
-0.5245333314,
-0.2379539758,
-0.498452425,
-0.0142802652,
0.0982814059,
-0.2002705634,
0.4322034717,
-0.2051066309,
-0.7824311256,
0.2702312171,
0.3048733473,
0.3002541363,
-0.1798214614,
-0.1554359198,
-0.0083133318,
0.2728744745,
0.5268750191,
-0.1269454956,
-0.3576133251,
-0.3412656486,
-0.2473435849,
-0.218637675,
0.0591811538,
0.8863096833,
-0.8858832717,
0.4321700633,
0.3334650397,
0.9098265767,
0.5844241977,
-0.1165320128,
0.9625943303,
-0.978126049,
0.4865961373,
0.340656966,
0.4656927586,
0.4451602995,
-0.4647769034,
0.7876631618,
0.0204333179,
-0.3243292272,
-0.9426177144,
0.2562616467,
-0.7807539105,
-0.2539293468,
0.8687919974,
-0.2397741079,
-0.2147360146,
-0.0306933373,
-0.0580027141,
0.2697917223,
-0.4913054705,
0.6628145576,
0.8881278634,
0.1294230074,
-0.4351822436,
-0.540702939,
0.6462162137,
0.4178982079,
-0.9494216442,
0.2181149572,
0.5444405675,
-0.0857457221,
-0.2162508667,
0.5725951195,
0.1604180634,
0.0763101652,
0.3504177332,
-0.1512449086,
-0.2263336778,
0.092000246,
-0.3639317155,
0.3712868392,
-0.3030029833,
-0.1782680303
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05131v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05131v3
|
Financial Report Chunking for Effective Retrieval Augmented Generation
| 2024-02-05T22:35:42 | 2024-03-16T09:08:26 |
Antonio Jimeno Yepes, Yao You, Jan Milczek, Sebastian Laverde, Renyu Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Chunking information is a key step in Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG).
Current research primarily centers on paragraph-level chunking. This approach
treats all texts as equal and neglects the information contained in the
structure of documents. We propose an expanded approach to chunk documents by
moving beyond mere paragraph-level chunking to chunk primary by structural
element components of documents. Dissecting documents into these constituent
elements creates a new way to chunk documents that yields the best chunk size
without tuning. We introduce a novel framework that evaluates how chunking
based on element types annotated by document understanding models contributes
to the overall context and accuracy of the information retrieved. We also
demonstrate how this approach impacts RAG assisted Question & Answer task
performance. Our research includes a comprehensive analysis of various element
types, their role in effective information retrieval, and the impact they have
on the quality of RAG outputs. Findings support that element type based
chunking largely improve RAG results on financial reporting. Through this
research, we are also able to answer how to uncover highly accurate RAG.
|
[
-0.2274424583,
-0.7977692485,
0.3037537336,
0.3750415146,
-0.3879841864,
0.6471187472,
0.2610778213,
-0.8558781743,
0.4978122413,
0.5235696435,
0.0079280427,
0.0527249388,
-0.6643965244,
-0.0258595664,
-0.7172986269,
1.1733119488,
0.158044219,
-0.0448293164,
-0.3649066091,
0.1258509606,
-0.3602062166,
-0.108585842,
-0.9600160122,
-0.3983401656,
0.502515316,
0.4905306995,
0.5693330169,
0.959181726,
0.7973381281,
0.3366790116,
-0.1989804059,
0.3855531812,
-0.3426308632,
0.0695929974,
-0.1973131895,
-0.4283109605,
-0.6545497775,
0.0763218477,
0.5833855271,
0.5620090961,
-0.1326876879,
0.372926414,
0.0232009757,
0.9875382185,
-0.8334029317,
0.1034403369,
-0.5518479943,
-0.0972165018,
-0.4159404039,
-0.6658710837,
-0.5770616531,
-0.2922002673,
0.284543246,
-0.7132294178,
0.4546386003,
0.4978841543,
0.8501433134,
0.1272209585,
-0.5408186913,
-0.7857798934,
-0.7037637234,
0.4950074255,
-0.454785794,
0.1698606312,
0.7177992463,
0.0305874851,
0.2279217839,
-0.7275575399,
-0.1796772033,
0.0382819101,
-0.2396848202,
0.1554752737,
-0.0071647344,
-0.0079954006,
0.0164079238,
0.9705764055,
-0.3789054155,
-0.1934525818,
-0.4960238636,
-0.181975767,
0.6094668508,
0.0543892831,
0.1616144478,
-0.3290706873,
-0.5490753651,
-0.4139472246,
-0.4261043072,
-0.0786366239,
0.5057149529,
0.3550701439,
0.0962128192,
0.7517911196,
0.1667497158,
0.6438203454,
0.5480061173,
-0.4631708264,
0.0299831685,
-0.5323576927,
-0.1597462893,
0.3369461,
-0.0987184122,
0.2715594172,
-0.215794161,
-0.1742869467,
-0.3160129189,
-0.516033709,
0.6300349236,
-0.6186821461,
-0.0435968004,
0.2879554629,
-0.5560064316,
-0.4370086789,
0.4248649478,
-0.7794824839,
-0.6291851997,
-0.2913026512,
0.3503671587,
-0.7162522078,
-0.2100088298,
-0.1660574824,
-0.730924964,
0.4461567402,
0.3635590374,
-1.0014425516,
0.4382048845,
1.0039323568,
0.6217269897,
-0.012362076,
0.0360032208,
-0.9838781357,
0.3863283694,
-0.3989054561,
1.1293048859,
-0.5851572156,
-0.5537706614,
-0.1857500225,
-0.4936820865,
0.0634455979,
-0.9135406613,
0.2618792653,
-0.7396252751,
0.0539124906,
-0.3670655787,
-0.7306165695,
-0.2523315251,
0.1803572923,
-0.7669356465,
1.0412253141,
0.6079888344,
-0.9652779102,
0.6988664269,
-0.3986102045,
-0.6894620061,
0.1879591793,
-0.0449158065,
-0.1993758082,
0.3106272519,
0.1335946918,
0.0346447043,
-0.3506124318,
-0.1086345837,
0.0734755546,
-0.1740603,
0.3256825507,
-0.1475544721,
0.077857241,
0.297378391,
-0.1281496435,
0.0665165558,
-0.9644280076,
-0.0687564462,
0.1368451416,
-0.4736985564,
-0.8909074664,
-0.0145537592,
0.2271021008,
-0.2398068905,
0.4653659165,
-0.50562042,
-0.0551513731,
-0.4783380032,
-0.056982249,
0.83570683,
0.1778377146,
0.7156595588,
-0.6070911884,
0.4360910654,
0.1164978221,
-0.1476122737,
-0.3776288331,
0.0276435763,
-0.6324936152,
-0.4061854184,
0.7687590122,
0.465929389,
-0.7646382451,
0.1797516495,
0.0601465702,
-0.3995297551,
-0.5111051202,
-0.1072124019,
0.4141792357,
0.6897298098,
0.3342053294,
-0.424807936,
-0.6668989062,
-0.8609483838,
-0.3469939232,
-0.1721475422,
-0.1225457564,
0.1016070992,
0.2999969125,
0.3136977255,
0.8693804145,
-0.7744736671,
0.0261032805,
-0.4017317891,
0.6687749624,
-0.1076757237,
0.5325846672,
0.45961079,
-1.1911873817,
-0.4285300076,
0.0237661283,
-0.1381493807,
0.2202414721,
-0.4238251448,
-0.0267716795,
0.1790361553,
0.1844114512,
-0.2016575933,
0.5825916529,
0.0802736133,
-0.787340343,
0.3366375566,
-0.2696434557,
0.1180450022,
-1.0115857124,
0.1187285855,
0.0842841268,
-0.5070628524,
-0.5035654902,
0.1019345522,
0.2013072073,
0.1856978983,
0.0502876416,
0.5741173625,
-0.4816602468,
-0.5984141827,
-0.6241044402,
0.0765152648,
0.3606348932,
0.0115353689,
-0.2863354385,
0.8352570534,
-0.06059625,
-0.5011222363,
-0.0916148424,
0.2807709575,
-0.374029547,
0.8827155828,
-0.5058131814,
0.0113263885,
-0.414570868,
0.1265935749,
-0.9229735732,
-0.2069844007,
-0.0296573024,
-0.4714764953,
0.8897542953,
0.1487756222,
-0.3738466799,
-0.0536093637,
-0.5180207491,
0.3051838577,
0.1945776194,
-0.3635287881,
0.8622641563,
0.4680743814,
-0.504016459,
-0.6597344279,
-0.4871372879,
-0.0924597457,
-0.2424815595,
-0.6624186635,
0.6654222012,
-0.0833005533,
-0.4784912765,
0.2141622752,
-0.802256763,
-0.3410463035,
0.0758493617,
-0.0487808138,
0.5963184834,
-0.1575684696,
-0.1386478543,
-0.0645344034,
-0.1559541523,
-0.2921471298,
0.0687978119,
0.5501835942,
0.0726279616,
-0.1097507626,
0.1557230502,
0.5454185605,
0.3593253195,
-0.5889145136,
0.6901358962,
0.6008477211,
-0.099076584,
-0.1671468765,
-0.8074569702,
0.086655654,
-0.5095337033,
0.1515210569,
-0.2336073965,
-0.9616162181,
0.6351954937,
0.1046594679,
0.238104865,
0.7968446612,
0.1483671069,
-0.1489024311,
0.5443891287,
0.8632372022,
-0.0163421277,
0.4819368422,
-0.152314648,
0.1033481956,
-1.0154876709,
-0.3500039577,
-0.6763135195,
-0.2322100252,
-0.0937509388,
-0.6575054526,
0.34550789,
0.2526662946,
0.0134659465,
0.0882145464,
-0.4937815666,
0.5154600143,
0.4111457169,
-0.111430414,
0.4238227904,
-0.0173634812,
0.0525561273,
0.2398631424,
-0.4136057198,
-0.0889762864,
0.8821870685,
0.3531038165,
0.66071105,
-0.2303253859,
0.7412486672,
0.4886527658,
0.2703922391,
-0.6942030191,
0.2036473006,
-0.1813109666,
-0.7103123665,
-0.4016066194,
-0.7344754338,
-0.804159224,
0.3080546856,
-0.0327693298,
-0.4379866421,
0.2069434077,
-0.1030268595,
-0.4267983735,
0.2299930155,
-0.5322310925,
0.3090827167,
-0.0769885704,
0.0322763696,
-0.2277924269,
-0.4529874027,
0.3799430132,
-0.286326319,
0.4587497413,
0.0910746232,
-0.1946557164,
0.7462078929,
-0.36016047,
0.5663755536,
0.003663335,
-0.181304574,
0.593327105,
0.0700433403,
0.5334352851,
0.0175463464,
-0.0994830653,
-0.4480060935,
0.1537190676,
-0.4897024632,
-0.656545043,
0.2519561648,
-0.3138182759,
-0.3488567472,
-0.6399148703,
-0.9541647434,
0.0292955954,
0.1128662303,
0.0276747551,
0.649964571,
0.0043777358,
0.2851463556,
0.6451717615,
-0.0109105138,
0.3690603077,
0.6282029748,
-0.210828647,
-0.572560668,
1.1563055515,
0.2972840071,
0.1286206394,
0.6271260977,
0.1308609694,
-0.3413927555,
-0.6222299337,
-0.1983064115,
0.2851168215,
-0.5369164348,
-0.3887709081,
-0.3973086476,
-0.2835620642,
-0.5556550622,
-0.3240045607,
-0.4721896052,
-0.619787097,
-0.2405206859,
-0.4236676693,
0.209781155,
0.9487318397,
-0.230232805,
0.064818427,
-1.087697506,
0.4548913538,
0.2514262199,
0.3809950352,
0.3081156313,
-0.2999332845,
-0.4953908622,
-0.2941635847,
-0.3950244188,
-0.5885989666,
0.2137148231,
-0.0606758371,
0.3960479796,
0.4680922329,
0.1191565543,
1.025462985,
-0.317971319,
0.6735816002,
0.1492357254,
-0.9268895984,
0.2473821491,
-0.2725919783,
0.1602798849,
0.7464637756,
0.2026905119,
-0.4940935969,
-0.4429496825,
-0.7450856566,
-1.3574745655,
0.6320169568,
0.1506481022,
-0.3277337849,
-0.1525841057,
0.4441390038,
0.1936391592,
0.2196507752,
-0.1657245755,
-0.226853326,
0.0556019247,
0.05702167,
0.0623598807,
-0.5174574852,
-0.0370099731,
-0.0880879313,
0.5853864551,
0.0622045211,
-0.0710083321,
0.4975111783,
0.1417410523,
-0.30585289,
0.1400928199,
0.4809637666,
0.9971642494,
-0.411903739,
-0.0060823071,
-0.1022869647,
-0.6072150469,
-0.0936704874,
0.2357102782,
-0.1468047947,
0.0505704172,
0.4094474018,
0.4075354636,
0.4437544346,
-0.594163835,
0.1778147072,
0.0446271114,
-0.1764229834,
-0.3896237016,
-0.1872674376,
0.0257857405,
0.2858982384,
0.8891325593,
0.0020469087,
0.3059715331,
-0.7330682874,
0.4454283416,
0.2501069903,
-0.148527652,
-0.0351032503,
0.5453315973,
0.1010872722,
-0.0109922448,
0.6126964688,
-0.1862948835,
-0.1336828321,
0.826008141,
0.6851900816,
0.759164989,
-0.2573899925,
0.4525580108,
0.1183011681,
0.3184079528,
-0.2014010698,
0.2867669165,
-0.1348419935,
-0.3822430074,
-0.7895689011,
-0.8923071027,
-0.6089405417,
-0.1594756395,
-0.9717695713,
-0.3160634041,
-0.4136779308,
0.0283482987,
0.1115353405,
0.0432068259,
-0.1702362299,
0.3785579205,
0.1549914777,
1.2062093019,
-0.2859065533,
0.3333226144,
0.6544655561,
-0.4968629777,
-0.9059590697,
-0.0535082482,
-0.0295487419,
-0.5976202488,
0.5380988121,
-0.0982765183,
0.0566975735,
-0.2694683969,
-0.2307655215,
-1.2381168604,
1.0869147778,
-0.1512871087,
0.0231667515,
-0.4218792915,
0.1402760148,
0.1262617558,
-0.3453514576,
0.0924630687,
0.5892236829,
0.6573629379,
0.6742166877,
-0.788069129,
-0.034386795,
-0.2375059128,
0.0351942144,
0.5399798155,
-0.6399133801,
0.9563931823,
0.1723055094,
-0.1145344377,
0.0138803916,
0.9084098935,
0.2355877608,
0.7916641235,
0.6077604294,
0.6710699201,
0.9418562651,
0.1397091746,
1.2768602371,
-0.2194702774,
-0.0039641061,
1.3637332916,
-0.3502644002,
0.7942970395,
0.3948786557,
-0.0846056864,
0.4332364202,
0.4324164093,
0.0182522144,
0.3538648486,
0.2174238414,
-0.0660305694,
0.1475913972,
-0.2387332618,
-0.333758086,
0.5383588076,
0.3511685431,
-0.3331262469,
-0.2458494008,
-0.2094348967,
0.0059834924,
0.0388417877,
-0.5502710342,
0.9330663085,
0.1107065752,
-0.5352272987,
-0.023858605,
0.2067243159,
0.5550836921,
-0.7984751463,
-0.0975847989,
-0.1664306819,
-0.2347238064,
-0.3135515451,
-0.4591157436,
0.8171967864,
0.2233846337,
-0.4491584897,
-0.3224511445,
1.0607377291,
-0.2537952363,
-0.4766636491,
-0.1724021882,
0.3781526685,
-0.1009244546,
-0.1701313555,
-0.1848076284,
-0.1675965041,
-0.0078394488,
-0.3589880764,
0.7545924783,
0.4586056173,
0.3204935193,
0.3683744669,
0.6945098639,
-0.0065683471,
-0.1421968192,
-0.3364320993,
1.0350264311,
-0.8652733564,
-0.6826854348,
-0.548178494,
0.7704282999,
-0.3620870411,
-0.2038464993,
0.8753675818,
1.122143507,
0.6955866218,
0.1870951504,
0.5413282514,
-0.1600280106,
0.8369114995,
-0.4270514846,
0.6567716002,
-0.6672478318,
0.1676003784,
-0.4466210902,
-0.9232230186,
0.0345295034,
0.3000021875,
-0.207559973,
-0.3128172457,
0.7849828005,
0.115964748,
0.0162007269,
0.2803573012,
0.0852900669,
0.1430400014,
0.1960967332,
-0.2930410206,
0.502592802,
-0.2069144994,
0.6596699357,
-0.2915243804,
-0.1553353071,
-0.1368660033,
-0.6149423122,
-0.4636794627,
-0.5641207099,
-0.3011029959,
-0.3377316296,
-0.3187151551,
0.5068962574,
0.3196844757,
-0.4315437078,
-0.2708264291,
0.22682859,
0.258382082,
-0.1119311675,
-0.3353098929,
0.3496560454,
-0.6029503345,
-0.4570861161,
0.6139769554,
0.6385151148,
0.0881769955,
0.0261172429,
0.4165718853,
-0.2351943552,
0.5072191954,
0.7134129405,
0.2183752209,
-0.1570610255,
-0.2901419699,
-0.0891848132,
0.0272013713,
0.2013216466,
0.99175179,
-0.3480181694,
0.161608994,
0.5385277867,
0.9141236544,
0.7753669024,
0.583977282,
0.5162783265,
-0.8131400943,
0.1024266705,
0.3888271749,
0.0463286079,
0.2022452652,
-0.5747405291,
0.7061911821,
-0.1121936589,
-0.6232885122,
-0.6484234929,
-0.0051599992,
-1.0989695787,
-0.5527098775,
0.7151460052,
0.0432012528,
-0.5584260225,
-0.0629138499,
-0.2344549745,
0.1825164407,
-0.6260294318,
0.7083590627,
0.7585546374,
-0.1362500638,
0.0438254513,
-0.2866691351,
0.3180517256,
0.3666342795,
-0.6710267663,
-0.0125880018,
0.5914754272,
0.1226587966,
0.5185442567,
0.876136899,
-0.3119181097,
0.1545883566,
0.3090245426,
-0.2688685954,
-0.0731991678,
-0.3140871823,
-0.0143087693,
0.5209310651,
-0.0201499611,
0.0333897024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03563v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03563v2
|
Distinguishing the Knowable from the Unknowable with Language Models
| 2024-02-05T22:22:49 | 2024-02-27T07:37:08 |
Gustaf Ahdritz, Tian Qin, Nikhil Vyas, Boaz Barak, Benjamin L. Edelman
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We study the feasibility of identifying epistemic uncertainty (reflecting a
lack of knowledge), as opposed to aleatoric uncertainty (reflecting entropy in
the underlying distribution), in the outputs of large language models (LLMs)
over free-form text. In the absence of ground-truth probabilities, we explore a
setting where, in order to (approximately) disentangle a given LLM's
uncertainty, a significantly larger model stands in as a proxy for the ground
truth. We show that small linear probes trained on the embeddings of frozen,
pretrained models accurately predict when larger models will be more confident
at the token level and that probes trained on one text domain generalize to
others. Going further, we propose a fully unsupervised method that achieves
non-trivial accuracy on the same task. Taken together, we interpret these
results as evidence that LLMs naturally contain internal representations of
different types of uncertainty that could potentially be leveraged to devise
more informative indicators of model confidence in diverse practical settings.
|
[
-0.0090722702,
-0.5865314603,
1.1370583773,
-0.1234404594,
-0.0198578537,
0.1373528093,
-0.4992547929,
-0.3034076989,
0.1145681143,
0.1460437179,
-0.1872458309,
-0.4540963173,
-0.9726213813,
-0.2750196457,
-0.6384348273,
0.467620492,
-0.1364554763,
-0.0438673757,
-0.4393589199,
-0.0171754174,
0.0470840223,
-0.516841948,
-0.2682460546,
-0.5714910626,
0.3492633998,
0.0882215351,
0.7263898849,
0.670396626,
0.1707574278,
0.2152604461,
-0.2228656262,
0.0069023236,
-0.2077755034,
0.1252804399,
-0.2517486811,
-0.8537943959,
0.1060446054,
0.1601798683,
0.7377096415,
0.9192364812,
-0.0787713826,
0.0338567495,
0.102505669,
0.4606234729,
-0.8348901868,
0.2565547526,
-0.8404117823,
0.0360340402,
-0.2183471322,
0.0019591819,
-0.5389514565,
-0.075412482,
0.1296843588,
-0.587223351,
0.0624921136,
0.0576415882,
1.0264471769,
0.4321662486,
-0.4913150072,
-0.4217852652,
-1.1115888357,
0.820209384,
-0.7180572748,
0.7001091838,
0.6967847943,
0.1328774542,
-0.0492697023,
-0.4768775702,
-0.6692121029,
-0.046451211,
0.0359918997,
0.0566086695,
-0.3453569412,
-0.0094933202,
-0.0556595474,
0.3590565026,
-0.1412426978,
0.2503938079,
-0.0146831824,
-0.3177787364,
0.216241926,
-0.2226847708,
0.2907049656,
0.2478331625,
-0.1016509831,
0.0663051829,
-0.8065400124,
0.1229419187,
0.2752283216,
0.2574507594,
-0.1591960043,
0.8045907021,
-0.0928179175,
0.5782114863,
-0.0028706219,
-0.1794214994,
-0.001605534,
0.3076894283,
-0.2775375247,
-0.1354966164,
0.6485395432,
-0.0842642486,
0.2092745453,
-0.3950268924,
-0.2945399284,
-0.0904229805,
-0.1078743637,
-0.3598199487,
-0.2979228199,
0.3085352778,
-0.1528244615,
-0.2175388932,
0.2515403628,
-0.3403608203,
-0.6649178267,
-0.186667949,
0.5930188894,
-0.3137119114,
-0.4972284734,
0.0719221309,
-0.1539674252,
0.114227064,
0.4765191674,
-0.7827426791,
0.3124877214,
0.6395753026,
0.8301277757,
0.1342658103,
-0.2230057269,
-0.1815169305,
0.2589548528,
-0.826040864,
0.618802011,
-0.6189952493,
0.0508200675,
-0.0121373953,
-0.0963946953,
0.0345535316,
-0.3285160959,
0.1974188089,
-0.5717824101,
0.1630764455,
-0.1021735594,
-0.8968342543,
-0.2284626365,
0.2542690039,
-0.7509009242,
0.8420292735,
0.0771047324,
-0.9492684603,
0.3317696154,
0.0047900449,
0.0733760893,
-0.1838719547,
-0.4295337796,
-0.1424856335,
0.6250048876,
0.0219241232,
0.5716332197,
-0.4852740169,
0.2911893129,
-0.4532035589,
-0.1185880899,
0.7034419775,
-0.7388211489,
0.4840992093,
-0.0021340095,
-0.2162108421,
-0.2011658251,
-0.7811096311,
0.1716036946,
0.1331592202,
-0.5188784599,
-0.692278266,
0.1089981943,
-0.4439596832,
-0.0334338173,
0.3214794695,
-0.6023283601,
-0.0932630822,
-0.4694692194,
0.2654807568,
0.6965579987,
-0.2605579793,
0.6628318429,
-0.139640063,
0.246221751,
0.2586134076,
-0.266274035,
0.1719489694,
-0.6461712122,
-0.9707249999,
-0.3067577779,
0.6059266329,
0.5166011453,
-0.5884606838,
0.3129968345,
-0.1321549118,
-0.6667050719,
-0.5830417275,
0.2006850839,
0.3854285777,
0.2689104378,
0.0034310746,
0.0098669222,
-0.3352426887,
-0.6843339205,
-0.4562647045,
-0.446384728,
-0.3019017875,
0.0373201519,
0.4769126773,
-0.1335949004,
0.9584186673,
-0.4460837245,
0.1164359972,
-0.0514808893,
0.3038835824,
0.2019390762,
0.2427780181,
0.1845278889,
-0.6616905928,
-0.2804345787,
0.213242799,
-0.8938068151,
0.154430151,
-0.0431692787,
0.2474034131,
0.1277031898,
0.5443831682,
-0.70305264,
0.5657747388,
0.5803952813,
-0.2714888752,
0.2794261873,
-0.5159720182,
-0.1520467997,
-0.8776315451,
-0.1074932441,
-0.001068787,
-0.1370967925,
-0.7756536007,
-0.0620111041,
0.3016240001,
0.280914098,
-0.1285707653,
0.6858699918,
-0.6687498689,
0.019084787,
-0.0451258235,
0.0095162829,
-0.038504038,
0.1685141921,
0.2718005478,
0.4841313958,
0.6846140027,
-0.6423760653,
-0.0020219544,
-0.2071743906,
-0.6611744761,
0.0858598351,
-0.5460246205,
0.037708018,
-0.3738599122,
-0.0972764194,
-1.1829009056,
-0.4955028892,
0.0195381083,
-0.7217978835,
0.344697386,
-0.2651559711,
-0.3255274892,
-0.1207397059,
0.0963921845,
0.2982587516,
0.5194108486,
-0.3927966058,
0.4716521502,
0.4329100251,
-0.1123638898,
-0.6182827353,
-0.8899075985,
-0.1073653772,
-0.2707956731,
-0.2414999306,
0.0261619538,
0.1346893758,
-0.8056012988,
-0.0164061859,
-0.1903028041,
-0.6472079158,
0.4156455398,
0.4542890787,
0.0564387068,
-0.2492334545,
0.5251381397,
0.0355100296,
0.0450375341,
0.0289959926,
-0.5104568005,
0.2952472866,
-0.1682647169,
-0.7383363247,
-0.2056216747,
0.1573313773,
0.6363196969,
0.0168233197,
1.0146900415,
0.2290614545,
-0.927977562,
-0.2925388217,
-0.4863265753,
0.0099103162,
-0.4060575962,
0.1352895498,
-0.2652854323,
-0.8958675265,
0.7016391754,
0.0006041775,
-0.2731881738,
0.5536882281,
0.4422848225,
-0.0725243092,
0.8207470179,
0.8689621091,
0.090522714,
0.1020450816,
0.1298583746,
0.3595057726,
-0.4046926796,
-0.272018224,
-0.6811082959,
0.1503683627,
-0.4853030145,
-0.7613184452,
0.2458267808,
0.429623425,
-0.3928762376,
-0.1194564849,
-0.1556920707,
0.6956878901,
0.6476128101,
0.1028902158,
0.3692250252,
-0.1150301546,
-0.3096639216,
-0.1099797115,
-0.5434845686,
-0.7184842229,
1.1902391911,
0.7050638199,
0.7951570749,
0.2863134742,
0.5681652427,
0.0122191096,
0.2737936676,
-0.735296905,
0.069992058,
0.1164290085,
-0.7489278913,
-0.5641820431,
-0.5212101936,
-0.7406110764,
0.164436087,
-0.342359364,
-0.9773414731,
0.2744061947,
0.0780454054,
-0.42048195,
0.7354943156,
-0.594096303,
0.4251305759,
-0.1383583695,
-0.036548648,
0.2982831299,
-0.5266543031,
0.3888306916,
-0.4044222236,
0.4628867209,
-0.0824280009,
-0.158248499,
0.6275260448,
-0.362475425,
1.0566477776,
-0.0560954884,
-0.4087174535,
0.3858428299,
0.3404012918,
0.4897508025,
-0.0542759411,
-0.0646379367,
0.2472093701,
-0.0442680977,
-0.2614966631,
-0.6019608378,
0.3311330378,
-0.8296029568,
-0.4852401018,
-0.3521079123,
-0.3805158138,
-0.4281273484,
0.2475372255,
0.5379924178,
0.2028098404,
-0.2393684685,
0.2029631883,
1.0645551682,
-0.2954274118,
0.2412577122,
0.5816652179,
-0.1882226467,
-0.080291234,
0.7121348977,
0.2511630654,
0.3729101419,
0.7600830197,
0.3718852401,
-0.4353826642,
-0.6949790716,
-0.0554803684,
0.1417283863,
-0.8597063422,
-0.1077610105,
-0.4328267276,
-0.3199231327,
-0.3947847784,
0.0112135326,
-0.6373679042,
-0.5813946724,
-0.4943573475,
-0.3648523986,
0.260187,
1.1248720884,
-0.3014814854,
0.4470772743,
-0.6231133342,
-0.1372543573,
0.4648563266,
0.4413683414,
-0.016846979,
-0.7262489796,
-0.231173113,
0.3423936367,
0.0678383335,
-0.9487612247,
0.4219726026,
0.2332575321,
0.7259243131,
0.743158102,
0.204743728,
0.2625923753,
-0.3224224448,
0.6714487076,
0.2967380583,
-1.191534996,
0.4016600549,
-0.3605977297,
-0.0139031447,
0.3210893571,
0.6500142217,
-0.3434117436,
-0.7002305388,
-0.7048073411,
-0.7170276642,
0.254599601,
0.0266768988,
0.0134274764,
-0.1292742044,
0.3682278693,
0.094544895,
0.2871811688,
-0.7713843584,
-0.1546808779,
-0.0116130477,
-0.2689962685,
-0.2319734544,
-0.3591247201,
-0.2598536909,
-0.0155417342,
0.4427141249,
-0.1210036054,
0.516366303,
0.1843626648,
-0.2164245844,
-0.1079520136,
0.4519493878,
0.5723522305,
0.6935412884,
-0.2602309883,
0.7894725204,
0.1051366031,
-0.2427532673,
0.2841667831,
-0.3127554059,
-0.0632473379,
0.0823497102,
0.8018683195,
0.6269305944,
0.0810559317,
-0.6008600593,
0.7030937076,
-0.0199523848,
-0.1138431206,
-0.5131827593,
-0.2590254843,
0.3696215749,
0.3076389432,
0.4208361208,
0.0207748339,
-0.2245841026,
-0.6009458899,
0.1551000327,
0.3317804635,
-0.6282150745,
-0.5221228004,
0.5153605342,
-0.205505833,
-0.137493521,
0.4284750819,
-0.270852387,
-0.4234096408,
0.462240696,
0.5611107945,
0.6532799006,
-0.3073807955,
0.2875680327,
0.1052472144,
0.5001580119,
-0.4996754229,
0.0712964088,
0.4036735594,
-1.2040119171,
-0.345772028,
-0.6582942009,
-0.4308228195,
0.1924714446,
-0.8273107409,
-0.2312172055,
-0.6608486176,
0.0246230159,
-0.0872942433,
-0.3907921612,
-0.6915215254,
0.3393179178,
0.208623454,
0.7842490673,
-1.158645153,
0.8488805294,
0.6487304568,
-0.1949429065,
-0.9823315144,
0.2483121008,
0.2324640304,
-0.934642911,
0.5640195012,
-0.0012245707,
-0.0776155591,
-0.2496383637,
-0.644072473,
-1.0338162184,
0.9220917225,
0.5746389627,
-0.4283008873,
-0.0569972619,
0.2128081471,
0.5251743197,
-0.3562117219,
0.2742647231,
0.4607918262,
0.3887156248,
0.0340466276,
-0.9106867313,
0.0522060879,
0.0318335183,
-0.1799691021,
0.2226293832,
-0.3263041079,
1.2279503345,
-0.3050285876,
-0.4956388474,
-0.0105389608,
0.6372725964,
-0.0402135476,
0.2423806936,
0.4214728177,
0.5836750865,
1.3779089451,
-0.2557201087,
0.8876914382,
-0.2210523635,
0.4430297315,
1.1785740852,
-0.0750792846,
1.0031571388,
0.6137627363,
-0.1295258701,
0.3074667752,
0.60201478,
0.537982285,
0.6024145484,
0.2541020513,
-0.2891591489,
-0.6941500902,
-0.0934809968,
-0.1851507276,
0.4864952862,
0.7206930518,
-0.3773549497,
-0.1886071712,
-0.1047770232,
0.1348474473,
0.173016727,
-0.3030189574,
0.6778239608,
0.1608641297,
-0.4326038659,
0.48763147,
0.0062155561,
0.5305312276,
-0.4768065214,
0.1906778812,
-0.0097679794,
0.3341845274,
0.0268118195,
-1.0182478428,
0.2633391023,
-0.1740929782,
-0.1799959391,
0.0132680396,
0.8141747713,
-0.4824327528,
-0.5743462443,
0.2978802919,
0.9828545451,
0.3202298284,
-0.3358851969,
-0.2344970703,
0.0004547,
0.1052135974,
-0.3076326251,
0.2862437367,
0.9509266615,
0.0583618395,
0.8967306614,
0.2310762256,
0.2690205574,
0.1239964217,
-0.3144132495,
0.5762648582,
-0.5908129215,
-0.0914506316,
-0.78397578,
0.3857894838,
0.0794892684,
-0.3297307789,
0.736102283,
0.1799758673,
0.9130706787,
-0.1574020982,
1.0902243853,
0.1026052088,
0.6391098499,
-0.7131995559,
0.7258966565,
-0.5436475277,
0.3516058922,
-0.1245514899,
-0.4276917577,
-0.3911675513,
0.8482788801,
-0.2565615475,
-0.1877254248,
0.6500764489,
0.6020910144,
-0.0626390949,
-0.1698324233,
0.700596571,
0.2570911944,
0.035782557,
0.5510191321,
1.0758776665,
-0.2227401882,
0.2614290416,
-0.1415709853,
-0.3490491807,
0.0528981797,
-0.891584456,
-1.0003054142,
-0.8653926849,
-0.1467757523,
-0.3426166773,
-0.1494381726,
0.7388375998,
0.5422990322,
-0.7177631259,
0.0215586741,
-0.0270670503,
0.3097422719,
0.0007549918,
-0.105755128,
0.1916094869,
-0.0875243843,
-0.4879538119,
0.4499449432,
0.0778617561,
0.5908052325,
-0.1959029138,
-0.1390820593,
-0.0078419531,
0.5787220597,
0.2715834975,
0.237122044,
-0.8095177412,
-0.6450663209,
-0.1660835445,
-0.0469497256,
-0.1909767538,
0.5527892709,
-0.3722320795,
0.3092361391,
0.3181586266,
0.6079674363,
0.1831817776,
-0.3082188368,
0.6882776618,
-1.0063766241,
0.1404711157,
0.0884280503,
0.5222566724,
0.3575960994,
-0.363324374,
0.3984327614,
0.0401897542,
-0.3341386318,
-0.9776035547,
0.3884947598,
-0.5663674474,
-0.5466327071,
1.197278142,
-0.5352382064,
-0.1963629574,
-0.2430848777,
0.4245042801,
0.2790471613,
-0.0624447316,
0.700917542,
1.1824831963,
0.3402200639,
-0.095181033,
-0.6107707024,
0.4349712133,
0.1866490096,
-0.6829787493,
0.3211323917,
0.3266721368,
0.4576585889,
0.4616390765,
0.5451809168,
0.0188082308,
-0.212024048,
0.3104808033,
0.0041284799,
0.1405262202,
-0.5714685917,
-0.3033655584,
0.2765336633,
0.5266953111,
0.0935776904
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03561v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03561v2
|
VLN-Video: Utilizing Driving Videos for Outdoor Vision-and-Language Navigation
| 2024-02-05T22:20:19 | 2024-02-07T18:02:51 |
Jialu Li, Aishwarya Padmakumar, Gaurav Sukhatme, Mohit Bansal
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Outdoor Vision-and-Language Navigation (VLN) requires an agent to navigate
through realistic 3D outdoor environments based on natural language
instructions. The performance of existing VLN methods is limited by
insufficient diversity in navigation environments and limited training data. To
address these issues, we propose VLN-Video, which utilizes the diverse outdoor
environments present in driving videos in multiple cities in the U.S. augmented
with automatically generated navigation instructions and actions to improve
outdoor VLN performance. VLN-Video combines the best of intuitive classical
approaches and modern deep learning techniques, using template infilling to
generate grounded navigation instructions, combined with an image rotation
similarity-based navigation action predictor to obtain VLN style data from
driving videos for pretraining deep learning VLN models. We pre-train the model
on the Touchdown dataset and our video-augmented dataset created from driving
videos with three proxy tasks: Masked Language Modeling, Instruction and
Trajectory Matching, and Next Action Prediction, so as to learn
temporally-aware and visually-aligned instruction representations. The learned
instruction representation is adapted to the state-of-the-art navigator when
fine-tuning on the Touchdown dataset. Empirical results demonstrate that
VLN-Video significantly outperforms previous state-of-the-art models by 2.1% in
task completion rate, achieving a new state-of-the-art on the Touchdown
dataset.
|
[
-0.3411936462,
-0.5380857587,
0.6162236929,
0.1069651544,
-0.4097253978,
0.0458875969,
-0.1989683807,
-0.498967886,
0.0129918912,
0.456989646,
-0.6993175745,
-0.6090812683,
-0.2487957329,
-0.2808193862,
-0.2079861462,
0.546458602,
0.021792978,
0.2240231335,
-0.191913873,
-0.1963561028,
-0.4222831726,
-0.3608807921,
-0.4173629582,
-0.2415636629,
0.2251418531,
0.2233151048,
0.8141397834,
0.5914094448,
0.4797626138,
0.3336245716,
0.25126791,
0.4176807702,
-0.4524201453,
-0.2249546796,
-0.2088461369,
0.0868652761,
-0.0899396688,
-0.4116152525,
0.5974243879,
0.2451981604,
0.0208955016,
-0.1243573651,
-0.1962909251,
0.7518270016,
-0.8995954394,
0.3813206851,
-0.2398603559,
0.0830594599,
-0.1296223998,
-0.3181453347,
-0.0252097864,
-0.3071903586,
0.3649648428,
-0.8973861933,
0.2068963945,
0.0866430849,
0.7357991338,
0.4111382067,
-0.6355544925,
0.0202775598,
-0.9961036444,
0.4290711582,
-0.5474073291,
0.9614328146,
0.4303817749,
0.5746886134,
0.1344911754,
-0.3607435524,
-0.6237729788,
-0.3068944216,
0.1420643479,
0.3692006469,
0.2569514215,
0.2571896613,
0.0775574222,
0.3278428018,
-0.7506306171,
0.2700130641,
-0.5407739878,
0.0349399634,
0.6933435202,
0.3474674821,
0.003590781,
0.0786712989,
-0.4728266895,
-0.474624902,
-0.7671524882,
0.641420424,
0.0467549227,
0.3927699924,
-0.2353088409,
0.5243142247,
-0.6378987432,
0.851320982,
-0.2811317742,
-0.2303340137,
0.3866162598,
-0.4461512268,
-0.5283147097,
0.170389384,
0.6563928127,
0.8921214938,
0.1459742785,
-0.0332000181,
-0.3584490418,
-0.2984661758,
0.4295294285,
-0.4876587391,
-0.4296757877,
-0.2281133235,
-0.0224146117,
-0.0222141203,
0.2056440562,
-0.6933687925,
-0.5318449736,
-0.7262270451,
0.5848497748,
-0.4689749181,
-0.3685003519,
0.259986043,
-0.1893334836,
0.5994403362,
0.4924164414,
-0.7494288087,
0.1163139343,
0.4063415527,
0.7326321602,
0.0217589028,
-0.3669607937,
-0.7691138983,
0.3493433297,
-0.2933340073,
0.3573075831,
-0.3191967905,
-0.3576099277,
0.358384043,
0.1361774653,
0.076784879,
-0.3101502955,
-0.0952664241,
-0.5571225882,
-0.0113469018,
-0.2260539234,
-0.1519782394,
-0.677644074,
0.4733184278,
-0.6794920564,
1.163433671,
0.0847734213,
0.0397038311,
0.5860003829,
-0.6232824922,
-0.7667155862,
0.3301710486,
-0.165129438,
-0.3508010805,
0.1383173913,
0.4055332839,
0.2009298205,
-0.0543642752,
0.0075157355,
0.227428332,
-0.5001853704,
-0.1292956918,
-0.4931744337,
0.4665409327,
-0.2999058664,
-0.8289343119,
-0.0220189951,
-0.5902950764,
-0.0482550487,
-0.0724322125,
-0.349201858,
-0.2795356214,
0.1067237109,
-0.1069884598,
0.0452381037,
0.1219622195,
-0.4679133594,
-0.0224308539,
-0.6105908155,
-0.2150868177,
0.8160347342,
-0.1569022089,
0.5974642634,
0.0763561875,
0.4846936166,
-0.008416594,
0.3141614497,
-0.1158365384,
-0.7139188647,
-0.8233454823,
0.2136194855,
-0.4881660938,
0.6152428389,
-1.1167691946,
-0.1496150494,
-0.6052540541,
-0.5197811127,
-0.5105856061,
0.2637175024,
0.7631522417,
0.472797662,
0.7488353252,
-0.2657405138,
-0.5016027093,
-0.3719917238,
0.2175279558,
-0.2337003797,
0.1963521987,
0.5979627967,
0.4049967825,
-0.3188080788,
0.9783608913,
-0.3450449407,
-0.4924985766,
-0.1293110102,
-0.0954947025,
-0.0716534853,
0.2278019488,
0.5334582329,
-1.0500669479,
-0.5227486491,
0.3978390098,
-0.8864133954,
0.3557398617,
-0.0708386749,
0.1293368042,
0.1116429642,
0.6186864972,
-0.3202943504,
0.8021905422,
0.4716976881,
-0.037264362,
0.4565431178,
-0.3912655115,
0.3069921136,
-0.4208111167,
-0.557226181,
0.1510507464,
-0.3758053482,
-0.6105313897,
0.1777814478,
-0.2669800222,
0.0031026136,
-0.8821483254,
0.4374067187,
-0.4580689967,
-0.2489046752,
-0.2699435055,
0.0797785521,
-0.0510968454,
0.5052864552,
0.4436305165,
0.7611697316,
0.9054504633,
-1.0932639837,
0.7822519541,
0.2049545348,
-0.4981584251,
0.1982474476,
-0.2658497989,
-0.0665212572,
-0.6506692171,
-0.0551052727,
-0.7619367242,
-0.3019795716,
0.0580893718,
-0.0775759369,
-0.0717686787,
-0.3698140979,
-0.3104010522,
-0.1194681898,
0.0324204899,
0.3165233731,
0.6678897142,
-0.7588596344,
0.838062346,
0.0341307782,
0.4515791237,
-0.2722572386,
-0.6737601757,
0.1015649438,
-0.1966691315,
-0.5374888778,
0.5581575632,
0.0667166039,
-0.1341708899,
-0.1467614472,
0.0481441766,
-0.0949168876,
-0.0846929029,
0.6691830754,
0.216265589,
-0.3983098865,
-0.0285975263,
-0.3330691159,
0.0144662429,
0.0993593857,
-0.246312812,
0.3495159447,
-0.1788523793,
-0.3529464304,
-0.439647615,
0.231571272,
0.3575074375,
-0.3066928089,
0.6161090136,
0.7004957795,
-0.1157759577,
0.1320096105,
-0.3538467288,
-0.2270307392,
-0.6342611313,
0.380250901,
-0.3771485388,
-0.6591386199,
-0.2989242673,
-0.078920491,
0.1788413227,
-0.0027132996,
0.2547147572,
-0.6299412251,
0.6930649281,
0.6891594529,
0.1605365723,
0.7732892632,
-0.5123841166,
0.2674497068,
-0.4674967825,
-0.6789284945,
0.2162421346,
-0.2079535127,
-0.481282562,
-0.7138800621,
0.652972579,
-0.2556325793,
-0.5279557109,
0.4738254845,
-0.1566280425,
0.5931919813,
0.8532958031,
0.2505316436,
0.1510103047,
0.0940428376,
0.0575911961,
-0.3103874326,
-0.5951128006,
-0.191978246,
0.8197339773,
0.1132554859,
0.5760915279,
0.4920317531,
0.5369586945,
0.2936235666,
0.0913919434,
-0.5573613644,
0.8532207012,
-0.1946674287,
-0.364890784,
-0.2623080313,
-0.3158918619,
-0.6625728607,
-0.0388687849,
-0.2364548296,
-0.6008955836,
-0.2197046876,
0.3492332399,
-0.4493149817,
0.2192445397,
-0.5248339772,
0.9089280367,
-0.8524668217,
-0.4729599059,
-0.0656926036,
-0.7824777961,
0.2456126958,
0.414640069,
0.2306133509,
0.1200160459,
0.1671849042,
0.2723048329,
-0.3183603883,
0.8618273139,
-0.5488128662,
0.0785924345,
0.2454672754,
0.0486191958,
0.4346517026,
0.0585051551,
0.3915322423,
-0.1161718518,
-0.5706725717,
-0.0241101403,
-0.7450848222,
0.4939796031,
-0.7023909688,
-0.5901237726,
-0.3300027251,
-0.0153985946,
-0.1473966986,
0.0039523775,
0.2922177017,
0.6168925762,
-0.1728459895,
0.2037872821,
0.5862474442,
-0.2743399143,
0.7983395457,
0.5673508048,
-0.406330049,
-0.4232027233,
1.4196224213,
-0.0331747867,
0.2186292261,
0.6210514307,
0.0011220884,
-0.5489202738,
-0.6653971076,
-0.6304450631,
-0.2185298651,
-0.6392396092,
0.0069186972,
-0.3086486459,
-0.4194304943,
-0.3396780789,
-0.422333777,
-0.6298142672,
0.1469735503,
-0.2933680415,
-0.4639880955,
0.4715568125,
0.7405536771,
-0.0456506237,
0.7235404253,
-0.6243575215,
0.4509353638,
0.666782558,
0.0692422688,
-0.3205966949,
-0.2616624832,
-0.4848602414,
0.2065977752,
-0.1650154293,
-0.6681973338,
0.3646507263,
0.4306097925,
0.4855423868,
0.3339472413,
-0.117293857,
1.0971673727,
-0.5295844078,
1.0072849989,
0.2743940353,
-0.5756953359,
0.6549940109,
-0.2013932019,
0.56013304,
0.7125604153,
0.4043619931,
-0.1004699543,
-0.11485634,
-0.2558565736,
-1.0561434031,
0.2535188198,
0.3157084584,
0.1320120692,
0.4249831736,
-0.03950027,
-0.2198348492,
0.1585282087,
-0.9225379229,
-0.1462388933,
-0.7961309552,
0.0112785567,
-0.5344488621,
0.1933787316,
0.0746738464,
-0.4964652061,
0.6679120064,
-0.3071292341,
-0.0075045745,
0.3336162865,
-0.3859226704,
0.3584129214,
-0.1553982347,
0.7024450302,
0.208207041,
-0.2779573202,
0.198028177,
0.2434797883,
-0.4796524644,
0.3210474551,
-0.008215257,
-0.3769485056,
0.215692088,
0.2339370251,
1.057338357,
0.284055531,
-0.9509778023,
0.7009046674,
0.2871393263,
0.0114660515,
-0.7556397319,
0.273958832,
-0.3472844958,
0.4319348037,
0.2290195227,
-0.064362973,
0.3390497267,
-0.509072423,
0.0693948492,
0.3887459338,
-0.8369780183,
-0.25992167,
0.7457701564,
0.3960539103,
-0.502073288,
0.7165421844,
-0.4991277158,
-0.5132568479,
0.446531266,
0.2064397335,
0.8305734396,
-0.0955288708,
0.4362564981,
0.567681551,
0.4978100657,
-0.1819773316,
0.3275988996,
-0.1560411006,
-0.5035586357,
-0.4068350196,
-0.4996078014,
-0.2627000511,
0.164644137,
-0.4846763611,
0.1709258556,
-0.5230306983,
-0.0945692584,
-0.5972402692,
-0.4112886786,
-0.9929398894,
0.8293629885,
0.4327977002,
0.6158097386,
-0.6618660092,
0.6568539143,
0.6425735354,
-0.2750656009,
-0.463399142,
-0.099506475,
0.2705233395,
-0.5667485595,
0.7641883492,
0.5914393663,
-0.5515881181,
-0.1305298507,
-0.2811867595,
-0.7877659202,
1.2093884945,
0.1432284862,
-0.5616008639,
-0.2494433075,
0.46416381,
0.2577049732,
-0.3317952156,
0.1453576833,
0.4280833006,
0.3618047535,
0.1144585386,
-0.8308354616,
-0.3390767276,
-0.1868618727,
0.0423810184,
0.0235151574,
-0.6455435157,
0.339746505,
-0.1833572388,
0.0891553834,
-0.1387234777,
0.8382208943,
0.3045552075,
0.5172989964,
0.6469973922,
0.5787932277,
0.3260090947,
-0.1269215643,
0.7896018624,
0.1390323937,
-0.168798238,
1.5193279982,
-0.2792827487,
0.74922508,
0.4965384901,
0.2413737178,
0.6810846925,
0.2647057772,
0.0142836925,
1.1476498842,
-0.1147776768,
-0.5796967745,
-0.4908180833,
-0.2140984535,
-0.207206592,
0.8237906098,
0.1176497936,
-0.2670127451,
-0.1103021204,
0.4741400182,
-0.3908195794,
0.0883073434,
-0.4842467308,
0.8920715451,
-0.276938796,
-0.6261804104,
0.2151677012,
-0.069196254,
0.4424198866,
-0.6572884917,
-0.2581967115,
-0.1509197205,
0.0967269465,
-0.0563807487,
-0.9240724444,
0.0666921511,
0.0612869151,
0.2065711319,
-0.5370963812,
0.1636844128,
-0.3403969407,
-0.4251712263,
0.3003296554,
0.1460853666,
0.1144155636,
-0.1443573385,
-0.2078533322,
0.0231692232,
0.2223863155,
-0.0363980681,
0.09012454,
0.1739666015,
0.1168533564,
0.8548073173,
0.5608682632,
-0.1963701099,
0.5104480386,
0.08078105,
0.9510819316,
-0.9068021774,
-0.479918927,
-0.8889120221,
1.0615365505,
-0.2695160806,
-0.4940110147,
0.8280908465,
0.9421093464,
1.0041687489,
-0.1885621548,
0.6955674291,
0.1108112335,
-0.2213646919,
-1.1076639891,
0.111867778,
-0.6663104296,
-0.0824508443,
-0.1295337975,
-0.7670920491,
0.0896161571,
0.6621772647,
-0.2077119946,
0.0461225621,
0.3594491184,
1.0263177156,
-0.5127159357,
-0.1447500587,
0.3685980737,
-0.214077577,
0.5240124464,
0.7620285153,
0.8414704204,
-0.643168807,
0.6303901076,
-0.4933715761,
-0.0016412878,
-0.4303207397,
-0.9517002106,
-0.8840309381,
-0.6256240606,
-0.5311588645,
-0.144234091,
0.2669375539,
0.737452507,
1.0560604334,
-0.1788608581,
-0.3123315573,
-0.4479404688,
-0.1808167994,
-0.4451466799,
-0.2540667355,
-0.1532124132,
0.0668135956,
-0.5074653029,
1.2104245424,
0.5004987717,
0.5418064594,
-0.4642352164,
-0.4766766727,
0.0006326898,
-0.2203359753,
0.5967356563,
0.4597538114,
-0.6874113083,
-0.2746838033,
0.1694130152,
-0.0180857293,
0.2400580347,
0.7503095269,
-1.0477689505,
0.7601518631,
0.1855139434,
0.4855616689,
1.0408756733,
0.03667273,
0.7377105355,
-0.7775258422,
0.2608244717,
0.1757814139,
0.2074739635,
0.6376671791,
0.0084172292,
0.5387253165,
0.1334244311,
-0.2048481554,
-0.5210596919,
0.3927169144,
-0.9565666914,
0.0312445033,
1.229593873,
-0.007812948,
-0.298384577,
-0.0981002972,
-0.2495894879,
-0.0373730659,
-0.2417345941,
0.5296843648,
0.1486925185,
0.1726633161,
-0.6999605298,
-0.8927062154,
0.6590675116,
0.1496810168,
-0.6360555887,
-0.2188786864,
0.5677481294,
-0.0675717816,
0.0716924444,
0.4790036082,
0.4866761267,
0.6414130926,
-0.1125547662,
-0.2901243567,
-0.3437337875,
-0.6792905927,
-0.1945344061,
0.1415862739,
-0.3299608231,
-0.4370907545
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03519v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03519v1
|
Resolving Transcription Ambiguity in Spanish: A Hybrid Acoustic-Lexical System for Punctuation Restoration
| 2024-02-05T21:05:35 | 2024-02-05T21:05:35 |
Xiliang Zhu, Chia-Tien Chang, Shayna Gardiner, David Rossouw, Jonas Robertson
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Punctuation restoration is a crucial step after Automatic Speech Recognition
(ASR) systems to enhance transcript readability and facilitate subsequent NLP
tasks. Nevertheless, conventional lexical-based approaches are inadequate for
solving the punctuation restoration task in Spanish, where ambiguity can be
often found between unpunctuated declaratives and questions. In this study, we
propose a novel hybrid acoustic-lexical punctuation restoration system for
Spanish transcription, which consolidates acoustic and lexical signals through
a modular process. Our experiment results show that the proposed system can
effectively improve F1 score of question marks and overall punctuation
restoration on both public and internal Spanish conversational datasets.
Additionally, benchmark comparison against LLMs (Large Language Model)
indicates the superiority of our approach in accuracy, reliability and latency.
Furthermore, we demonstrate that the Word Error Rate (WER) of the ASR module
also benefits from our proposed system.
|
[
-0.1710852683,
-0.7696367502,
0.4398452342,
0.6317861676,
-0.4870823026,
0.7377872467,
-0.3672805727,
-0.5962311625,
0.6828402281,
0.2902539074,
-0.434278518,
-0.3691269159,
-0.3886328936,
0.6867024302,
-0.4692811072,
0.6130475402,
0.1442822516,
0.3128317595,
-0.1028412282,
-0.0494904816,
-0.4239987433,
-0.3476779163,
-0.6276946068,
-0.3410106003,
0.3541029096,
0.0208390113,
0.7881479859,
0.5135909319,
0.6438314319,
0.3543342352,
-0.4751534164,
0.4183969796,
-0.0879139453,
-0.1595099866,
-0.247032702,
-0.2876123786,
-0.3001048267,
-0.5927274227,
0.7537201047,
1.0197901726,
-0.3015374243,
-0.3167151809,
0.1361401081,
0.4497477412,
-0.4256377816,
0.0023837332,
-0.4433614612,
0.0898728594,
-0.0724364221,
-0.4124260843,
-0.1458841711,
-0.7115114927,
-0.0847589821,
-0.5028268695,
-0.0617817156,
-0.0584706329,
0.396809727,
0.5477210879,
-0.318796128,
-0.0758360177,
-1.0025873184,
0.4952165484,
-0.6135191917,
0.4784616828,
0.197545886,
-0.0323920883,
-0.2439279109,
-0.5217969418,
-0.5526351333,
0.1737718433,
-0.1880380958,
0.3738642633,
-0.160552159,
0.2664440572,
-0.1296165735,
0.8523394465,
-0.4009591639,
0.1516605467,
-0.432292819,
-0.6951798797,
0.1322727501,
0.009499467,
0.2797597647,
-0.1486363113,
-0.5313494205,
-0.024003461,
-0.697475493,
0.1969640404,
0.6658142805,
0.4460348785,
0.1877362877,
0.3110599518,
-0.1310382038,
0.7027307153,
-0.3006394804,
-0.3324535787,
0.4578896165,
-0.384521991,
-0.1207917407,
0.4161984324,
0.8845317364,
0.0714996904,
0.0198654216,
-0.3348298371,
-0.2753418386,
0.1891401261,
-0.0914152488,
-0.0953605622,
0.1822448075,
0.1885749102,
0.1824572235,
-0.0853136107,
0.564910233,
-0.4001256824,
-0.3132570088,
-0.3151650131,
0.5866527557,
-0.3633526862,
-0.3124038875,
0.8690886497,
-0.1449519694,
0.1340353936,
0.4392180145,
-0.4697917998,
0.5580337644,
0.6181183457,
0.8065819144,
-0.1455500573,
0.0015968209,
-0.1961955279,
0.0844897032,
-0.142599225,
0.8026015162,
-0.3434761465,
-0.8762131929,
0.0250648614,
-0.0575561523,
-0.5352993608,
-0.9991103411,
0.815605402,
-0.4048148096,
0.5441183448,
-0.3025994003,
-0.348539263,
-0.210177049,
0.1159359887,
-0.8036194444,
1.250803113,
-0.2460495234,
-0.5761627555,
-0.1828633845,
-0.3948741853,
-0.6534338593,
0.0418161862,
-0.0656660348,
-0.4232712984,
-0.1620600224,
0.2357610166,
-0.1541801542,
-0.2209544629,
0.3332684636,
-0.0042697322,
-0.5629032254,
0.2814801037,
-0.2271896601,
0.8298910856,
-0.1867426336,
-0.3222161531,
-0.1128925458,
-0.6657879949,
-0.0462078117,
-0.3409626186,
-0.7321600318,
-0.321451813,
-0.3053900599,
-0.0194389056,
0.2463577837,
0.5432641506,
-0.9416069984,
-0.1870346069,
-0.6792331934,
0.353507638,
0.4832686186,
0.2628538013,
0.2477793396,
-0.6424635649,
0.6416199207,
-0.1653690189,
0.0487156622,
-0.1835860908,
-0.5811008811,
-0.8079679012,
-0.4635280967,
0.4030237496,
0.9858644605,
-0.6461764574,
0.8758999109,
-0.273075819,
-0.1412814409,
-0.6411848664,
-0.1555384845,
0.8079538941,
0.7921600938,
0.5626443624,
-0.3653831184,
-0.9520949721,
-0.7905235887,
-0.1181111485,
-0.2960543036,
-0.1362273842,
0.2685849667,
0.2439456582,
0.1360457391,
1.0939651728,
-0.0663698912,
-0.4489118457,
0.0577942729,
0.0796284825,
0.365344733,
0.5360076427,
-0.1283678114,
-0.6577371359,
-0.2334668487,
0.1830764264,
-0.3082407117,
-0.5090147257,
0.0894117877,
0.104737632,
-0.1215483472,
0.7062273622,
-0.2364335656,
0.2632035017,
0.4252444804,
-0.3625168204,
0.6979886293,
-0.1849172264,
0.3823906779,
-0.8840136528,
0.2765952349,
-0.4484085441,
-0.5511346459,
-0.5652264953,
-0.1755138785,
0.1367023587,
0.0483623073,
-0.6666076183,
0.2343375534,
-0.2753490508,
-0.0781272799,
-0.0499898009,
-0.0557939075,
0.2592576742,
0.3288939297,
0.1004645377,
1.0544532537,
0.2803431749,
-0.3669041693,
0.0719549432,
0.6117925644,
-0.0951260403,
0.4626390934,
-0.7643998265,
0.274291873,
0.0071236487,
0.3087893724,
-0.9327762723,
0.1526855528,
0.1435068548,
-0.2712347507,
-0.0029861103,
0.1472164392,
-0.7477310896,
-0.4834486544,
-0.3242145479,
0.4477211237,
0.2998225987,
-0.4473874867,
0.4570967257,
0.1646021605,
-0.4518754184,
-0.3983386457,
-0.523437798,
0.1452756077,
0.0359633751,
-0.7509328723,
0.5776071548,
-0.0850119963,
-0.2635172904,
-0.24303554,
-0.4421070814,
0.0686717108,
-0.0822270364,
0.0185126327,
0.2259055823,
-0.353851974,
0.1501782537,
0.274045974,
0.1136571094,
-0.0792497024,
-0.3262284696,
0.7724626064,
-0.1430781633,
-0.4473547041,
-0.6443378925,
0.3641241789,
0.5955787301,
-0.4403553903,
0.4070984125,
0.1493104696,
-0.4110417366,
0.0684334263,
-0.9453532696,
-0.1197283939,
-0.46728459,
-0.0629323199,
-0.3065541387,
-0.7938950658,
0.9747574925,
-0.1590041518,
-0.4350344837,
0.362621665,
0.5715758204,
-0.1842894703,
0.4111979604,
0.4838647842,
-0.0616910681,
0.5553405285,
-0.0783005133,
0.1124425381,
-0.6847676039,
-0.6815401316,
-0.6405323744,
-0.0988663882,
0.1552022845,
-0.4699079096,
0.5373911858,
-0.1362869591,
0.3186167181,
0.4632681608,
-0.2278790921,
0.6159595847,
0.6431242824,
0.5151796341,
0.9597924948,
-0.1523085982,
-0.4271441996,
0.0061792512,
-0.4078016877,
-0.5332491398,
0.4956633151,
0.0137578612,
0.3023549914,
0.1034802422,
0.7674869895,
0.3081153333,
-0.3860709965,
-0.5984158516,
0.397672981,
-0.1703993082,
-0.3604203463,
-0.3153756559,
-0.3104332685,
-0.7193107605,
0.5183362365,
-0.3129321039,
-0.5740098953,
0.4739502072,
0.0646188334,
-0.950324893,
0.2513716519,
-0.5945928693,
0.525192678,
0.1443411708,
-0.2194633633,
-0.0481596291,
-0.7171865106,
0.0537451617,
-0.2590447664,
0.3516757488,
0.0661202371,
-0.2505740523,
0.8058553338,
-0.8130737543,
0.6820579171,
0.0074112196,
-0.1852872968,
0.0643867105,
0.04846761,
0.4924437404,
-0.1575263888,
-0.1492921114,
-0.003676723,
-0.0670811981,
0.0357873961,
-0.646676898,
0.3185337782,
-0.5141416192,
-0.4193474054,
-0.1121585295,
-0.6503660083,
-0.4487584829,
0.074867487,
0.1756110936,
0.3721948564,
-0.3933770061,
0.0727689266,
0.8191799521,
-0.1116799638,
0.5868083835,
0.6632348299,
0.0137556605,
-0.6875054836,
0.6968208551,
-0.3258870244,
0.2026306689,
0.44547984,
0.0644945502,
-0.3917411268,
-0.5859391093,
-0.3347990811,
0.4971069694,
-0.3730029166,
-0.3189515769,
-0.717473805,
0.0284683667,
-0.3079350889,
-0.1795004904,
-0.3579813838,
-0.782273829,
-0.6564612985,
-0.070642218,
0.3150481582,
0.3965710104,
0.035884466,
0.4573632479,
-0.6890838742,
0.13051112,
0.0669040233,
0.1043228135,
-0.4787474573,
-0.916008234,
0.032879211,
-0.134856388,
0.020624375,
-0.8387168646,
0.3123582602,
0.4300951362,
0.1914788932,
0.4014008939,
-0.0493654311,
0.9483353496,
-0.7085184455,
0.3239899278,
0.3208216429,
-1.0550093651,
0.4100009203,
-0.5536773205,
0.3222345412,
0.7947309017,
-0.0792526752,
-0.8810557127,
-0.9061364532,
-0.5333746076,
-0.9730827808,
0.488776654,
0.2859839201,
-0.2364769578,
0.0329389982,
0.1898352504,
0.1911876202,
0.3322958648,
-0.4679945111,
0.0356769115,
-0.0025688261,
-0.3042764068,
0.0515033863,
-0.0217390377,
-0.2953554392,
-0.4091225564,
0.7307309508,
0.2106925398,
0.0766298547,
0.3962151408,
-0.475620389,
-0.1006830856,
0.3735069633,
0.6315246224,
0.356546551,
-0.0545304269,
0.1021901369,
0.1677110493,
-0.5407473445,
0.2234694511,
0.4246795177,
-0.1481649727,
0.179615289,
0.2839798927,
0.4120140374,
0.7774706483,
-0.5944626331,
0.6693576574,
0.2749259174,
-0.0708889812,
-0.4229151309,
-0.2266861647,
0.1262726635,
0.2340205014,
0.4608899951,
0.4092942476,
0.3640310764,
-0.4487035573,
0.1686029285,
0.2741453052,
-0.1930747479,
-0.2901908159,
0.6273193955,
0.4195088148,
-0.5698733926,
0.1428291649,
-0.0106352633,
-0.7257909775,
0.6168328524,
0.6848887801,
0.481141001,
-0.3835617602,
0.1904162765,
0.1867894679,
0.2565094233,
-0.4054220617,
0.663176775,
-0.133505255,
-0.6287380457,
-0.3649697602,
-0.7076218128,
-0.630182147,
-0.34438169,
-0.8129987121,
0.0891565457,
-0.4808162451,
-0.0194697808,
-0.2453784645,
-0.2566075921,
-0.2888355851,
0.0706401393,
0.1951893866,
0.8961786032,
-1.0059418678,
0.7948403955,
0.5652190447,
-0.360093385,
-0.6280504465,
-0.410249263,
-0.065563865,
-0.8112699389,
0.0850941464,
-0.1469859779,
-0.6588635445,
0.0533852428,
0.1322451979,
-0.9693706632,
0.9475172758,
0.7104962468,
-0.7666028738,
-0.0386264659,
0.5002567768,
0.7893974185,
0.1547285318,
0.0101769855,
0.7714335918,
0.6034260392,
0.1163557172,
-1.5840444565,
0.0198930521,
-0.2600985467,
-0.0992154852,
0.4279429317,
-0.4284579754,
0.5398866534,
0.0403574258,
-0.4571562111,
0.3373378515,
0.4743254483,
-0.1913981438,
-0.0914430693,
0.5613164306,
0.6429337859,
1.0271383524,
-0.3825640082,
0.7568334937,
-0.189080894,
0.2618597448,
0.9837542176,
-0.0046994393,
0.7728909254,
0.9883361459,
-0.3635830581,
0.6739740372,
0.4733001888,
0.2108996063,
0.3794006109,
0.007766237,
-0.6307541728,
-0.2202847898,
-0.292239666,
-0.3919614553,
0.4372747838,
0.3160300851,
-0.2627923489,
-0.0454381704,
0.0859098062,
0.0371043049,
0.4660116732,
-0.27104792,
0.8870799541,
-0.0352524258,
-0.5638799667,
0.3309266269,
-0.127616182,
0.685756743,
-0.4947046638,
0.2862363458,
-0.3854630888,
0.0972630084,
-0.4188577831,
-0.1915454268,
0.4177607,
-0.3899796903,
-0.1790556312,
-0.3580354154,
0.3049014807,
-0.7051953673,
-0.4514223933,
0.1980963945,
0.6576246619,
0.0904540867,
-0.1753053367,
-0.4001483619,
0.2190472931,
-0.0280344989,
0.2320943922,
-0.3145100474,
0.0975669548,
0.1479199082,
0.3352979422,
0.6601893902,
0.2853549719,
0.4110899866,
0.4627222717,
0.8241898417,
-0.6060711741,
-0.7728116512,
-0.7279222012,
0.5761120319,
-0.0042530256,
-0.2885330021,
0.5919578671,
0.7882803679,
0.5848848224,
-0.0977792591,
0.4819987416,
0.2135983258,
0.8270534873,
-0.6262291074,
0.2672027051,
-0.1756922305,
0.5181775689,
-0.4908075631,
-0.8043321967,
-0.8956514597,
0.4574147463,
-0.2361729741,
-0.3407228887,
1.0978960991,
1.0951250792,
-0.1551530957,
0.2194447517,
0.4487434924,
0.0575643778,
-0.088624388,
0.3137799799,
0.8823090196,
-0.3922763467,
0.846208334,
-0.2767040133,
-0.2221193016,
-0.0771967694,
-0.4257713556,
-0.2824789286,
-0.5029855371,
-0.3113407195,
-0.1471194625,
0.4239605665,
0.9608903527,
0.22744748,
-0.8588777781,
-0.3497220874,
-0.1094086841,
0.0520051718,
-0.2000128031,
-0.1799435765,
0.3826512396,
-0.1759169102,
-0.7618606091,
0.8865625262,
0.5245854259,
0.0795102045,
-0.1520645022,
0.0385741517,
-0.1564714015,
-0.065710336,
0.2148169577,
0.6798554063,
-0.8170529008,
-0.3596345484,
0.2948357761,
0.0548932217,
0.4301300347,
1.1212213039,
-1.0515863895,
0.5735964775,
0.2795627117,
0.5610421896,
0.2993455529,
-0.0245957896,
0.7435011268,
-0.8080099821,
0.3185299933,
0.5186963081,
0.8464481831,
0.5961269736,
-0.3237088025,
0.2843016088,
0.5686910748,
-0.2015943825,
-0.7063903213,
0.2264264226,
-1.147597909,
0.0680047721,
1.0725973845,
0.0267470144,
0.0091858283,
-0.461928457,
-0.5094641447,
0.2385053635,
-0.5612620115,
0.8178297281,
0.5250813365,
0.0838987529,
0.1963136345,
0.2266238928,
0.3439414203,
0.6220960617,
-0.5744740963,
-0.2161656171,
0.5073004961,
0.2126791328,
0.3939478993,
0.594342947,
-0.4548920989,
0.5524749756,
-0.3230046928,
0.2618608773,
-0.0242760163,
-0.2986456752,
-0.7269492745,
0.1211063862,
-0.1333489269,
-0.3283238411
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03509v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03509v1
|
Evaluating the Factuality of Zero-shot Summarizers Across Varied Domains
| 2024-02-05T20:51:11 | 2024-02-05T20:51:11 |
Sanjana Ramprasad, Kundan Krishna, Zachary C Lipton, Byron C Wallace
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Recent work has shown that large language models (LLMs) are capable of
generating summaries zero-shot (i.e., without explicit supervision) that, under
human assessment, are often comparable or even preferred to manually composed
reference summaries. However, this prior work has focussed almost exclusively
on evaluating news article summarization. How do zero-shot summarizers perform
in other (potentially more specialized) domains? In this work we evaluate
zero-shot generated summaries across specialized domains including biomedical
articles, and legal bills (in addition to standard news benchmarks for
reference). We focus especially on the factuality of outputs. We acquire
annotations from domain experts to identify inconsistencies in summaries and
systematically categorize these errors. We analyze whether the prevalence of a
given domain in the pretraining corpus affects extractiveness and faithfulness
of generated summaries of articles in this domain. We release all collected
annotations to facilitate additional research toward measuring and realizing
factually accurate summarization, beyond news articles. The dataset can be
downloaded from https://github.com/sanjanaramprasad/zero_shot_faceval_domains
|
[
-0.0473308526,
-0.8309325576,
0.7560139894,
0.1515041739,
-0.3312198818,
0.1476871669,
-0.1752141714,
-0.531355679,
0.3317550421,
0.340200901,
-0.2459707409,
-0.6929292083,
-0.7952409983,
0.400579989,
-0.3687699735,
1.454028964,
-0.0432019085,
-0.2167795151,
-0.6113206148,
-0.3823717535,
-0.3046656847,
-0.5306452513,
0.0691193268,
-0.2853936255,
0.6560229659,
0.2739623189,
0.4073870778,
0.4460350573,
0.6095976233,
0.1749376208,
-0.001655817,
0.1274420768,
-0.6457523108,
-0.0027693138,
-0.2683161199,
-0.2116493285,
-0.5582678318,
0.2066308558,
0.6026533842,
0.6946774721,
0.0833213925,
0.4287319481,
-0.20963341,
0.5517998338,
-0.8751934171,
0.0065876599,
-0.6675739288,
0.1204163134,
-0.2082738727,
-0.3938254118,
-0.3517097831,
-0.5043292046,
0.250898242,
-0.3363461196,
0.4957020283,
-0.1922920495,
1.1237180233,
0.170717299,
-0.6534097195,
-0.1918979436,
-0.781095922,
0.6640095711,
-0.7907218337,
0.1113421172,
0.0118712252,
0.2399987131,
0.2273619622,
-0.5706909895,
-0.4274093211,
-0.1883015782,
-0.1398688555,
0.4683279395,
-0.3146438897,
-0.1560012698,
0.221890077,
0.3685257733,
-0.7004866004,
-0.1552373767,
-0.4707786441,
-0.1634174287,
0.767991662,
0.1190472394,
0.3869466782,
-0.0282633733,
-0.0958452672,
0.4779411554,
-0.9305108786,
-0.2762337327,
0.3865798414,
0.1863479465,
-0.2249450982,
0.8257442713,
-0.5226349235,
0.686311841,
0.0339499861,
-0.2728975415,
0.2383145243,
-0.5589988828,
-0.2367831916,
0.184000358,
0.6005380154,
0.5789292455,
0.2501928508,
-0.3282713294,
0.0041182186,
-0.1348119378,
0.4989729226,
-0.8546692729,
-0.0538365953,
0.4041028917,
-0.1571065187,
-0.4085314274,
-0.0134693831,
-0.2633479536,
-0.1820168346,
-0.2457907349,
0.563057065,
-0.2345548868,
-0.1876450777,
0.1306687146,
-0.2904279232,
0.0981015414,
0.4791916311,
-0.5912585258,
0.1489020437,
0.5420427322,
0.827298522,
-0.4002466798,
-0.2109277397,
-0.3350788355,
0.1446316838,
-0.3283409476,
1.0934542418,
-0.0282800309,
-0.2362916023,
0.0765426531,
-0.2231539488,
-0.2412268817,
-0.5549066663,
0.4372259974,
-0.6202526093,
-0.0100605199,
-0.3274538219,
-0.7637456059,
-0.1087843701,
0.4058141708,
-0.4088770151,
0.3623247147,
0.0865955204,
-0.8305339813,
0.5305503011,
-0.449275285,
-0.7244938612,
0.0261436477,
-0.2494002432,
-0.5123226047,
0.260840863,
-0.0343234502,
0.5114773512,
0.1659559906,
0.423871845,
-0.1691252291,
-0.3284672499,
0.3630259037,
-0.3726046979,
0.7431672812,
-0.0837385431,
-0.1993805915,
-0.0102389231,
-0.7321364284,
-0.3640120327,
0.2032127231,
-0.2163876146,
-0.3362498581,
-0.1925704479,
-0.1570890993,
0.0531875417,
0.0762856528,
-0.7201551199,
0.0713019371,
-0.3277102113,
-0.056058269,
0.1391466409,
0.5345008969,
0.1421433836,
-0.4444221854,
0.313963145,
0.1335891038,
-0.1499459743,
-0.4894099534,
-0.3757621348,
-0.5083604455,
-0.4602208436,
0.553796947,
0.4597825408,
-0.6406307817,
0.3224615455,
-0.4518265426,
-0.5264843106,
-0.2620820701,
-0.0969894007,
0.5326006413,
0.8039051294,
0.2586920559,
-0.4251333177,
-0.3953193426,
-0.8542221785,
-0.5616872907,
-0.0335881263,
0.0586130284,
0.1725112498,
0.7932440042,
-0.0946528018,
1.1246539354,
-0.5366818905,
-0.0973629057,
-0.2351676077,
0.5695972443,
0.1606646925,
0.1709128916,
0.7530921698,
-0.3598189652,
-0.4190281034,
-0.0725502595,
-1.1623706818,
-0.3272900879,
-0.3671663702,
0.1317750514,
0.2569874227,
0.0119360611,
-0.9648337364,
0.6704381704,
0.1754249185,
-0.1241447926,
1.0311204195,
-0.1056040078,
0.2380751967,
-0.6163123846,
0.3514214158,
0.0868245289,
-0.4757949412,
-0.6443451643,
0.0658196807,
-0.0497091264,
0.0087820878,
-0.5908968449,
0.4265478849,
-0.4405023456,
-0.3128092289,
-0.3111486733,
0.4045144916,
0.2242925465,
0.2945306301,
0.1103673875,
0.7715917826,
0.3275571465,
-0.6183981895,
0.1431532949,
0.2954870462,
-0.2853794396,
0.6043853164,
-0.9150060415,
-0.1434486657,
-0.2396267503,
0.3711341619,
-0.678966403,
-0.4108958244,
0.1503451914,
-0.600487113,
0.2226416022,
-0.0097396588,
-0.3557006121,
-0.0024093469,
-0.5420360565,
0.1737575084,
0.3329346776,
-0.0641755164,
0.2461224198,
0.4369096756,
-0.2470254749,
-0.760345161,
-0.5434967875,
0.3555878103,
0.1434066892,
-0.2038320005,
0.2026432306,
-0.024331348,
-0.4606293738,
0.3090738058,
-0.3790829182,
-0.1027932093,
0.1103062034,
0.2160424888,
0.3356908858,
-0.3182437718,
-0.1671854109,
0.2814516127,
0.0836661384,
0.0952731147,
0.0142818922,
-0.0172637198,
0.0863311216,
-0.441578418,
-0.3634600937,
0.2419206351,
0.4939364493,
-0.1597881019,
0.6572175026,
0.3590044975,
-0.2930404842,
-0.0297700893,
-0.6016154289,
0.0454795659,
-0.2898627818,
0.2750936449,
-0.0830927864,
-0.7882900238,
0.4955177903,
0.1693301648,
0.3687932789,
0.6925703883,
0.7396096587,
-0.0941084772,
0.37445274,
0.5473998189,
0.2347570807,
-0.1236517876,
-0.1930112541,
0.2458751202,
-0.6129145622,
-0.0615446456,
-0.3086747825,
0.1438546181,
-0.2750226557,
-0.1944044083,
0.4818948209,
-0.1109356433,
0.1566921771,
0.3736972511,
-0.0653181374,
0.704262197,
0.2938930392,
-0.0847078562,
0.4753459394,
0.1336411834,
0.0214475151,
0.1082334965,
-0.6331611872,
-0.7338628173,
1.1785290241,
0.2150210887,
0.2515996099,
0.0423936322,
0.7098661661,
0.5965045691,
0.6780409217,
-0.9558903575,
0.2894513011,
-0.0852143839,
-0.7324098945,
-0.0180551,
-0.4107398987,
-0.7082416415,
0.2634619474,
-0.3264799118,
-0.4241293669,
0.2191259712,
0.0048605087,
-0.7870320082,
0.1225868315,
-0.3639251888,
0.7119441032,
0.0060601891,
-0.2291061133,
-0.1862211376,
-0.7107647657,
0.6998466253,
-0.3854807913,
0.0861678272,
-0.337348491,
0.0298679229,
0.5119826794,
-0.2567091882,
0.8949112892,
0.0332273096,
-0.205745548,
0.4207748175,
0.0426526703,
-0.2718403339,
0.1465784907,
0.0912955105,
0.7089796066,
0.0654800981,
-0.4870763719,
-0.3383511603,
0.3950058818,
-0.7663968801,
-0.5763754845,
-0.6778977513,
-0.5430462956,
-0.398994267,
0.3589052856,
0.3372991383,
0.652825892,
-0.5034691095,
0.1822500676,
0.6186149716,
-0.3478520513,
0.2275814861,
1.0405708551,
-0.0106279701,
-0.3216068745,
0.8768420815,
0.5296479464,
0.0167184956,
0.3790290952,
-0.1610261053,
-0.0672914535,
-0.6471845508,
-0.6500900388,
0.4216378927,
-0.5957336426,
-0.4246899188,
-0.8485637307,
-0.4296455979,
-0.6353421807,
-0.071290575,
-0.2393479943,
-0.6341770291,
-0.1571502239,
-0.4009056687,
0.0022155126,
0.7327104807,
-0.116709657,
0.2080795467,
-1.148643136,
0.4177725017,
0.2161791325,
0.0909579769,
-0.2930814326,
-0.6666405201,
-0.4707197547,
-0.0952159092,
-0.2851141989,
-0.7777184248,
0.1986770779,
0.1435073763,
0.5449187756,
0.2444377691,
0.0930059999,
0.4875750244,
-0.770210743,
1.0068104267,
0.2335594445,
-0.9207134843,
0.413199693,
-0.4637350738,
0.3329231441,
0.6904532313,
0.4711490273,
-0.3209517002,
-0.5735986233,
-0.5755769014,
-0.8439873457,
0.4733160138,
0.4545000792,
0.2571846545,
-0.0918702856,
0.601752162,
0.3433951735,
0.4282397032,
-0.3105672896,
-0.3828808665,
-0.115355514,
-0.0736389905,
0.0292353127,
-0.4488566518,
-0.3048732877,
0.0676043555,
0.7061058283,
0.0314734504,
0.1679341793,
0.4349831045,
-0.4871300161,
-0.2229561061,
0.1542529017,
1.0257650614,
1.0344232321,
-0.3128989041,
0.2515580356,
0.0145191634,
-0.5379440784,
0.0558510944,
-0.0542838909,
-0.5283427238,
0.5878750682,
0.8826398849,
0.6873922944,
0.1708431244,
-0.7687860727,
0.8504819274,
-0.1300376207,
-0.3316509724,
-0.0967992172,
-0.0054744189,
-0.242067337,
-0.0150251761,
0.4180573523,
0.2896928489,
0.3236189783,
-0.4707604647,
0.4015734792,
0.3020720482,
-0.1098120362,
-0.8094539642,
0.697881043,
0.2704239786,
0.1549568474,
0.1526858807,
-0.1631684303,
-0.1956645101,
0.6444430351,
0.4631763399,
0.9950430393,
0.1491401196,
0.4100228846,
0.3561799824,
0.331548959,
0.1467392743,
-0.0633920431,
-0.0009535836,
-0.8286142349,
-0.8629370332,
-0.5502090454,
-0.7278710008,
-0.0059130872,
-0.5707994103,
-0.0369007699,
-0.2025907338,
-0.2732028067,
0.2976709008,
-0.0835099146,
-0.2902228534,
0.3631542921,
0.240092352,
0.7690452337,
-1.1023525,
0.5437272191,
0.7609862089,
-0.6887254715,
-0.3186158836,
0.2984579802,
0.0600146241,
-0.6513788104,
0.5980368853,
0.0271790605,
-0.2737336457,
-0.2645484507,
-0.6530636549,
-0.5209349394,
0.9454166889,
0.6411758065,
-0.3574354351,
0.2016732544,
0.3767377436,
0.6159479022,
-0.2829171717,
0.2415795326,
0.4664032757,
0.1957551688,
0.0220189299,
-0.9328258038,
-0.1858903915,
-0.1573268324,
-0.3162524402,
-0.2970553935,
-0.5412604213,
0.6143373251,
-0.2276183963,
-0.2284486145,
-0.2709689736,
0.7010272741,
0.3212592006,
0.6648516655,
-0.0536854863,
0.5178438425,
0.4484830797,
0.1201933697,
1.1151460409,
-0.4110492766,
0.4122726619,
1.2127873898,
-0.6627947092,
0.553504765,
0.2643708289,
-0.0536907837,
0.4110503793,
0.3193774819,
0.0079274001,
0.394185245,
-0.1537607461,
-0.3936095536,
-0.0109685864,
-0.3273937702,
-0.1569402665,
0.3878630698,
0.0749291554,
-0.0991360098,
-0.5664773583,
-0.2408442646,
0.2516168058,
0.0138472794,
-0.1733500808,
0.8126430511,
0.181182459,
-0.488147229,
0.4184121192,
0.1572458893,
0.3565982282,
-0.4674618244,
-0.0397984087,
-0.3780784011,
-0.1290024966,
-0.4081658423,
-0.6370311379,
0.7463395,
0.5671029091,
-0.1523930579,
-0.0538938046,
0.9751915932,
-0.3313111961,
-0.2573050261,
-0.1774733812,
0.9535048008,
0.3351869285,
-0.0498937853,
-0.407576412,
0.0456076935,
-0.2918691337,
-0.2724808753,
0.3280927241,
0.4401511848,
0.1359495074,
0.1436386704,
0.478412807,
0.3220707476,
-0.1053864807,
0.0225676913,
0.6068018675,
-0.4717801511,
-0.0148937842,
-1.0191313028,
0.5108400583,
-0.2078224421,
-0.3683069348,
1.1117959023,
0.7636707425,
0.6667993069,
-0.3685426712,
0.8969063163,
0.024221791,
0.4660982788,
-0.324978292,
0.8366079926,
-0.385114342,
0.0215543807,
-0.0510432459,
-0.8596062064,
-0.7303516269,
0.2993463576,
-0.3935557604,
-0.1922212392,
0.5697382092,
0.3425930142,
-0.1008369103,
-0.2167569399,
0.5243877769,
0.2386823595,
0.0475460328,
-0.0437356234,
0.6533948183,
-0.3796413839,
0.157864958,
-0.1964543164,
-0.0943623111,
-0.3725093305,
-1.1000359058,
-0.8423420787,
-0.0544935986,
-0.7382802367,
-0.1062504053,
0.2551220357,
0.7092108727,
0.5272887945,
-0.9594552517,
-0.094597131,
0.2524234951,
0.1376576275,
-0.1164368764,
-0.2386988699,
0.3752353787,
-0.3595124483,
-0.5154231191,
0.2333749384,
0.6783676147,
-0.1045586765,
-0.1667045206,
0.3393307626,
-0.01822244,
0.5133330226,
0.8952507377,
0.3116384447,
-0.4897359014,
-0.3309164047,
-0.0473752953,
-0.3216512203,
0.1096580029,
0.692481339,
-0.6240791082,
0.1919760853,
0.3562863469,
0.7306657434,
0.30592224,
0.2132688463,
0.3664605916,
-1.0251772404,
-0.1798110306,
0.0681077763,
0.2736121714,
0.3782334328,
-0.3352760077,
0.5517735481,
0.6567739248,
-0.4921491146,
-0.8113734126,
-0.0466381572,
-0.9753732085,
-0.203992337,
1.1754876375,
-0.4971631169,
-0.3938562572,
-0.1992631555,
0.028896559,
0.4072575271,
-0.1232380345,
0.882003665,
0.5462729335,
-0.2342800498,
0.15535523,
-0.6916457415,
0.3074406385,
0.1084549204,
-0.910769105,
0.0834710225,
0.7440623045,
0.5959079266,
0.3062364459,
0.8482257128,
-0.2159759253,
0.3476523757,
-0.1277533919,
0.1581897289,
-0.1016467661,
-0.2545340359,
-0.4291528165,
0.2222914845,
-0.2599358857,
0.0583928674
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03507v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03507v1
|
Neural networks for abstraction and reasoning: Towards broad generalization in machines
| 2024-02-05T20:48:57 | 2024-02-05T20:48:57 |
Mikel Bober-Irizar, Soumya Banerjee
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
For half a century, artificial intelligence research has attempted to
reproduce the human qualities of abstraction and reasoning - creating computer
systems that can learn new concepts from a minimal set of examples, in settings
where humans find this easy. While specific neural networks are able to solve
an impressive range of problems, broad generalisation to situations outside
their training data has proved elusive.In this work, we look at several novel
approaches for solving the Abstraction & Reasoning Corpus (ARC), a dataset of
abstract visual reasoning tasks introduced to test algorithms on broad
generalization. Despite three international competitions with $100,000 in
prizes, the best algorithms still fail to solve a majority of ARC tasks and
rely on complex hand-crafted rules, without using machine learning at all. We
revisit whether recent advances in neural networks allow progress on this task.
First, we adapt the DreamCoder neurosymbolic reasoning solver to ARC.
DreamCoder automatically writes programs in a bespoke domain-specific language
to perform reasoning, using a neural network to mimic human intuition. We
present the Perceptual Abstraction and Reasoning Language (PeARL) language,
which allows DreamCoder to solve ARC tasks, and propose a new recognition model
that allows us to significantly improve on the previous best implementation.We
also propose a new encoding and augmentation scheme that allows large language
models (LLMs) to solve ARC tasks, and find that the largest models can solve
some ARC tasks. LLMs are able to solve a different group of problems to
state-of-the-art solvers, and provide an interesting way to complement other
approaches. We perform an ensemble analysis, combining models to achieve better
results than any system alone. Finally, we publish the arckit Python library to
make future research on ARC easier.
|
[
-0.2763974071,
-0.6625387669,
0.6172575355,
0.194093436,
0.1704740971,
0.2325942963,
-0.3360819221,
-0.6091005802,
0.1839771718,
0.4347940683,
-0.3273657858,
-0.46773085,
-0.619769752,
0.0847173482,
-0.6238784194,
0.3062128425,
-0.2661502063,
-0.0242875442,
-0.296494931,
-0.1517745107,
-0.2670944035,
-0.6505936384,
-0.7830221653,
-0.5499088764,
0.3836896718,
0.2383564413,
0.5228527784,
0.4017736316,
0.6218759418,
0.3436741233,
-0.1445435137,
0.2852869034,
0.0063295048,
0.0511550754,
-0.2320625037,
-0.6515463591,
-0.2960269451,
-0.5880540013,
0.2355937809,
1.1625512838,
0.2102599144,
-0.0653700978,
-0.1127395257,
0.8448873162,
-0.8514878154,
0.3560817242,
-0.456695646,
0.3631601036,
0.159234345,
0.258300215,
-0.3714292049,
-0.2187184691,
0.0813646019,
-0.6488288641,
0.0768377557,
-0.0000891791,
0.6748328209,
0.2144149095,
-0.0759220198,
-0.246917665,
-1.0821131468,
0.8314221501,
-0.3663054407,
0.0569604672,
0.186722815,
0.2760736942,
-0.026282208,
-0.9280143976,
-0.4186900258,
-0.076694563,
0.163613081,
-0.0733829662,
-0.7488793135,
0.3320838809,
0.2133081406,
0.233613506,
-0.4854965508,
0.083755374,
-0.2874756157,
-0.2671440244,
0.8082556129,
0.3387773633,
0.5142483115,
0.2589004934,
0.1253323853,
0.1213066354,
-0.5045152903,
0.1208972037,
0.1987160593,
-0.0221455079,
0.1523131579,
0.4725774229,
-0.4734537005,
0.7156761885,
-0.1632831842,
0.5166410804,
0.1579228342,
-0.1466426998,
-0.2026979923,
-0.0238884855,
0.7025798559,
0.0711298063,
0.7893635035,
-0.3726806641,
-0.2996246517,
0.509262085,
0.0614609346,
-0.3080303371,
-0.4501410425,
0.3837794662,
-0.6395968795,
-0.1241812408,
-0.3025473058,
-0.2470366359,
-0.2901011407,
-0.8579537272,
0.3176892996,
-0.489559412,
-0.4882876873,
0.4559465647,
-0.2450370044,
0.1723755598,
0.4198819697,
-0.9156348705,
0.4072302282,
0.725086987,
0.6672789454,
-0.275028497,
-0.3113374412,
0.2307654619,
-0.0807202607,
-0.711281836,
0.7313937545,
-0.6656736135,
0.0776472017,
-0.2005933225,
-0.46542117,
-0.0932504982,
-0.6939170361,
0.2852115631,
-0.3992134035,
-0.2142551839,
0.0502884127,
-0.4937099218,
-0.3531552553,
0.2906242907,
-0.580237031,
0.363386929,
-0.2034202218,
-0.5039283633,
-0.1744788736,
-0.9491035938,
-0.5130071044,
-0.2459289581,
-0.1894028783,
-0.0659279302,
0.2640526891,
0.3832610846,
0.401841104,
-0.1448209286,
0.2812424004,
-0.1694105864,
-0.5686507821,
0.1261778176,
-0.3399771452,
0.7607224584,
0.3621226549,
-0.336981982,
0.2528008223,
-0.460840553,
0.2078539133,
0.2337068766,
0.0464983992,
-0.159624964,
-0.0484506227,
-0.2744329572,
-0.0976620838,
0.1427851617,
-0.392267406,
0.1316772848,
-0.4330815971,
0.7983615398,
0.607814014,
-0.1971458197,
0.593067944,
-0.0888640359,
0.2213108391,
0.1623708606,
0.061375387,
-0.169819057,
-0.6621184349,
-1.0228159428,
0.1625388712,
0.3938954771,
0.5125325322,
-0.618181169,
0.3967728913,
-0.163567543,
-0.1029950529,
-0.3070890903,
-0.1486535072,
0.1788226068,
0.2788639665,
0.4064662457,
-0.1914405972,
-0.8310219049,
-1.0022240877,
-0.2985670567,
-0.146840483,
-0.1715521961,
0.3454362452,
0.5195985436,
-0.2413982004,
1.0816340446,
-0.3538450301,
-0.0460890085,
-0.437428385,
0.1575577855,
0.348017633,
0.4953680634,
0.0449897796,
-0.9446920156,
-0.0167023167,
0.2510296404,
-1.3442187309,
0.2898077071,
-0.0701534003,
0.0754307806,
-0.0866207704,
0.5190131664,
-0.4993952513,
0.5857585669,
0.2988486588,
-0.1042691395,
0.7645193338,
-0.1153934523,
-0.181917876,
-0.4710657895,
0.067724295,
0.0273937695,
0.0384357572,
-0.6772664189,
0.0945181996,
-0.1912558228,
-0.2353366911,
-0.3159769177,
0.5015519857,
-0.4492130876,
-0.1358625293,
-0.4343184531,
-0.1859561354,
-0.0498910286,
0.7422026992,
0.329780668,
0.3630540669,
1.0597100258,
-0.7594555616,
0.7638662457,
0.0908330083,
-0.1628559828,
0.1429647505,
-0.7831823826,
0.1904024333,
-0.468228966,
0.2452828735,
-0.7805436254,
-0.1447316706,
0.3031639755,
-0.4421239793,
0.0081862239,
-0.0971785933,
-0.0169106033,
-0.5682868958,
0.182400018,
0.6492180824,
0.5649338961,
-0.3813229203,
1.012802124,
0.1080500185,
-0.0210688189,
-0.8126282692,
-0.9391773939,
0.5268426538,
0.0974621698,
-0.7231000066,
0.2483624965,
0.0965882391,
-0.6611889601,
0.1480918378,
-0.1776049584,
-0.4027109444,
0.0937283784,
0.0735669956,
0.0475530662,
-0.5016986132,
0.086915113,
0.1936581433,
-0.18373999,
0.2541542947,
-0.700663507,
0.5077772737,
-0.6309312582,
-0.5716871023,
-0.5620344281,
0.3717738688,
0.2347629368,
-0.3526058197,
0.3202368021,
0.2402400821,
-0.5037094951,
-0.3317585588,
-0.4393158853,
-0.2596014142,
-0.4011740983,
0.4591807723,
-0.6642332673,
-0.5302889347,
0.4387981892,
-0.4689817429,
-0.0752448291,
0.3761481643,
0.4928792715,
-0.267175287,
0.9674656391,
0.5135163665,
-0.0708596557,
0.2194388956,
-0.8690306544,
0.101637274,
-0.7324389219,
-0.3396146595,
-0.187684536,
-0.9962827563,
0.1446325332,
-0.2153181136,
0.0108331535,
0.339381814,
-0.3383846581,
0.2434513718,
-0.8074090481,
0.9035396576,
0.5854430199,
0.2065306902,
0.476033628,
-0.0391833782,
-0.2793168724,
0.4989746511,
-0.6942963004,
-0.3829646707,
1.3021228313,
0.1028958783,
0.6529211998,
-0.3072481453,
0.6225867271,
0.3138305843,
0.1355996579,
-0.6461002827,
0.6864655614,
-0.1637212783,
-0.4149802327,
-0.2700519562,
-0.3615483046,
-1.1322753429,
0.2582491636,
0.0253909491,
-0.8823571801,
0.4245667756,
0.0285704602,
-0.2221473306,
0.664419353,
-0.8780869842,
0.6438243389,
-0.2433374226,
-0.1195006743,
-0.2545409203,
-0.7326830626,
0.4571901262,
0.3354022801,
0.0387615226,
-0.1733347774,
-0.0586976409,
0.4136784077,
-0.1612223387,
0.9237078428,
-0.1080364659,
0.347312808,
0.5051504374,
0.0566712953,
0.2056545317,
-0.220886305,
-0.1574907005,
0.3955021799,
-0.4500166178,
-0.4913506806,
-0.6671536565,
0.4991661012,
-0.7487308979,
-0.5385028124,
-0.1938483864,
-0.7129775882,
-0.1756058782,
0.1386247128,
0.2884457707,
0.4094212651,
-0.1230274141,
-0.1178890541,
0.8989623189,
0.1445240825,
0.6950486302,
-0.2497595102,
-0.2460012138,
-0.0437581167,
0.9918813705,
-0.2602644861,
0.0278028939,
0.3127729595,
0.1356188357,
-0.1668016613,
-0.8548298478,
-0.518533051,
0.0422132649,
-0.7804461122,
-0.0539769419,
-0.55646348,
-0.5761539936,
-0.0042239283,
-0.1396519095,
-0.2367576808,
-0.825316906,
-0.2109602094,
0.1012603194,
0.0072799046,
0.8160000443,
-0.0718216449,
-0.126179859,
-0.3130124807,
0.4484624565,
0.325882107,
0.1845701039,
0.3636263311,
-0.0811353698,
-0.0148912035,
0.1801148057,
-0.2404225171,
-0.3321864009,
0.0597395673,
0.0268134251,
0.6012212038,
0.3369588256,
-0.2191901207,
0.3225360513,
-0.418160826,
0.6757269502,
0.3765199184,
-0.8851389885,
0.5969045162,
0.0196241736,
0.1478297412,
0.2138523012,
0.4276945591,
-0.4990532696,
-0.25872913,
-0.5463190675,
-0.6561304331,
0.3673408628,
0.4311546981,
0.1794379056,
0.3034631908,
0.5117226839,
-0.1017233506,
-0.0086188558,
-0.4392271042,
-0.3349159658,
-0.3118569851,
-0.4569320381,
0.2185550183,
0.4449938238,
-0.0597630106,
-0.4459347129,
0.2660607994,
-0.2552715838,
0.4253319204,
0.2639126182,
-0.1758991182,
0.2478306442,
0.2332041562,
0.3375368714,
0.7193629742,
0.3116427064,
0.0711268485,
0.1816708595,
-0.2404069304,
0.30203107,
-0.1257896572,
-0.2395969778,
-0.0349625126,
0.4618091285,
0.8089325428,
-0.2291265428,
-0.814609468,
0.404432565,
-0.1127641052,
-0.5270181894,
-0.3983857334,
0.3477146626,
0.271286279,
0.317992121,
0.3643736541,
0.8177903295,
0.2718381882,
-0.3557154238,
-0.0837573186,
0.4815571308,
-0.3017627299,
-0.2677748501,
0.6955230236,
0.1994970441,
-0.4337627292,
0.8148460984,
0.023051599,
-0.357144773,
1.0822259188,
0.4088101983,
0.9246673584,
0.1557554156,
-0.0072449441,
0.1643431932,
0.180207774,
-0.2619285882,
0.3218191564,
-0.0576453581,
-1.099394083,
-0.6360679865,
-0.4393461943,
-0.586773932,
-0.0399091244,
-0.1499888301,
-0.0722954422,
-0.6928940415,
-0.022721244,
0.0662455037,
-0.486346066,
-0.6283255816,
0.2376977801,
0.6302374601,
0.9126732945,
-0.608091414,
0.6197814345,
0.731105566,
-0.5168655515,
-0.8403731585,
-0.3466710746,
-0.2881786525,
-0.8160270452,
0.7390289307,
0.1180458441,
-0.0484399647,
-0.0526119918,
-0.7729410529,
-0.7297719121,
0.8175471425,
0.6174635291,
-0.5820927024,
-0.5071470141,
0.1884622425,
0.506190896,
-0.4588809013,
0.3939826787,
0.7817710042,
0.4858620763,
0.2187945098,
-0.7728152275,
-0.3264807761,
-0.4745806158,
0.0900576264,
0.029723458,
-0.3693094552,
0.8597531319,
-0.4577631354,
0.1226515025,
0.4231293201,
0.8199980855,
0.1477119774,
0.4369931519,
0.2648723125,
0.7453106642,
0.8550819755,
-0.3892759383,
1.1602493525,
0.0468174741,
0.0321501493,
0.7279015779,
-0.0838340819,
0.6204426289,
0.3020812273,
-0.2335260808,
0.9202242494,
0.3184685409,
0.0590867698,
0.0779653639,
0.648661077,
-0.3943601251,
-0.467636317,
0.1228025481,
-0.2142609358,
0.4065541923,
0.5566439033,
-0.3699316382,
-0.0680123866,
0.4774803817,
-0.4844716787,
0.1219455004,
-0.9219145179,
0.7503896356,
0.3490866721,
-0.4810940623,
0.6066629887,
-0.1930938363,
0.7489738464,
-0.5553608537,
-0.0323981941,
-0.2342132181,
0.5103604794,
-0.5542925,
-0.7787377834,
0.5049897432,
-0.2102313489,
-0.1435778588,
-0.0685456395,
0.9356331825,
-0.0789281726,
-0.6278375983,
0.0421024375,
0.6227356791,
0.3155832887,
-0.3044873476,
-0.6670328379,
0.0255291481,
-0.1578404158,
0.0006010564,
0.1246482283,
0.3839513063,
-0.2196428031,
1.0687242746,
0.5647290349,
0.2258473635,
0.0717870072,
0.1280600578,
0.9008534551,
-0.7386180162,
-0.3163333237,
-0.7576701045,
0.3435561657,
-0.0967850983,
-0.1895844936,
0.2836014926,
0.4855660796,
0.7140770555,
-0.0779554993,
0.9857264161,
0.0493171215,
0.0796385631,
-0.4477402866,
0.5581446886,
-0.3451423943,
0.2044377923,
-0.1910783947,
-0.7976253629,
-0.8467108011,
0.6639981866,
-0.4576204717,
-0.0580634698,
0.6570562124,
0.5485656857,
-0.3007948399,
0.5151812434,
0.2250543088,
0.0526735783,
0.104527384,
1.0910800695,
1.2194931507,
-0.261578083,
0.7745693326,
-0.1834529936,
-0.084042944,
0.0889054239,
-0.5569652915,
-0.6922464371,
-0.3584333062,
-0.2788684666,
-0.1409986019,
0.3536394536,
0.7144138813,
0.8438228965,
-0.9663954973,
-0.4014660716,
-0.6920177341,
0.4086267948,
-0.6452835202,
-0.177764222,
0.3894454241,
-0.5753108263,
-0.6577371955,
0.4649603665,
0.3248730898,
-0.2081372738,
-0.1465431005,
-0.1945991516,
0.1160187349,
-0.1030529663,
0.4861948788,
0.5972582698,
-0.8379994035,
-0.0575104877,
0.0910620242,
0.1127295643,
0.3027472198,
0.9191679955,
-1.0900937319,
0.2825439572,
0.4116670787,
0.941044867,
0.627954185,
-0.2278367728,
0.486900121,
-0.4543579519,
0.1273752451,
0.8504577279,
0.6249431372,
0.1050321236,
-0.1383168995,
0.5025731325,
0.2931128442,
-0.262899667,
-0.3304950595,
0.3908956647,
-0.6847370267,
-0.6187487245,
0.8804338574,
-0.0112144509,
-0.4540725052,
-0.4324323237,
-0.1694106907,
-0.1354687065,
-0.2438895702,
0.5356188416,
0.5596539378,
-0.8892233372,
-0.3039713502,
0.0528933592,
0.1528414339,
0.5802134871,
-0.8286665082,
-0.1222002059,
0.2555192709,
0.1605099291,
0.4795348346,
0.4870221913,
0.0214082189,
0.5345569253,
0.0685980394,
0.1479241699,
-0.4142879546,
-0.5708506703,
-0.4705465734,
0.431281805,
-0.051943887,
-0.2258203477
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03501v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03501v1
|
An Inpainting-Infused Pipeline for Attire and Background Replacement
| 2024-02-05T20:34:32 | 2024-02-05T20:34:32 |
Felipe Rodrigues Perche-Mahlow, André Felipe-Zanella, William Alberto Cruz-Castañeda, Marcellus Amadeus
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In recent years, groundbreaking advancements in Generative Artificial
Intelligence (GenAI) have triggered a transformative paradigm shift,
significantly influencing various domains. In this work, we specifically
explore an integrated approach, leveraging advanced techniques in GenAI and
computer vision emphasizing image manipulation. The methodology unfolds through
several stages, including depth estimation, the creation of inpaint masks based
on depth information, the generation and replacement of backgrounds utilizing
Stable Diffusion in conjunction with Latent Consistency Models (LCMs), and the
subsequent replacement of clothes and application of aesthetic changes through
an inpainting pipeline. Experiments conducted in this study underscore the
methodology's efficacy, highlighting its potential to produce visually
captivating content. The convergence of these advanced techniques allows users
to input photographs of individuals and manipulate them to modify clothing and
background based on specific prompts without manually input inpainting masks,
effectively placing the subjects within the vast landscape of creative
imagination.
|
[
-0.3288191259,
-0.4857223332,
0.585011363,
0.0591572151,
-0.4014645219,
0.7344338298,
0.0011727475,
-0.6979853511,
0.2852418125,
0.6378231645,
-0.8903405666,
-0.3459202945,
-0.4947065711,
-0.1688188314,
-0.4682762027,
0.5917203426,
-0.1322949231,
-0.3049886823,
-0.2535142004,
-0.1523700804,
-0.7719951868,
-0.1887776405,
-0.3705791831,
-0.4369139075,
0.1869942248,
0.5201455355,
0.7651748061,
0.2318575084,
0.4421210289,
0.299343884,
0.1145531163,
0.499368608,
-0.407033354,
0.3448300362,
-0.3200164437,
-0.3849773109,
0.0365245566,
0.2283691168,
0.2906717062,
0.4455369413,
0.0586647019,
0.0763889849,
0.4464802444,
0.9035089612,
-0.9899072647,
-0.2577846944,
-0.396394968,
0.2810582519,
-0.4912009835,
-0.5463406444,
0.0725923777,
0.2414005548,
-0.2428774834,
-0.7817904353,
0.3532986641,
-0.3135904074,
0.5810964108,
0.5663372874,
0.0704091489,
-0.1136246398,
-1.0682121515,
0.4335735738,
-0.4817233384,
0.4411844313,
0.3402308822,
0.3895564377,
0.153488934,
-0.9700936675,
-0.5376473665,
0.2578569949,
-0.2866290212,
0.4558585882,
0.1720073968,
-0.1228314266,
0.3486642838,
0.6339159608,
-0.4838742614,
0.0009334654,
-0.2442101836,
0.1701497585,
0.62313205,
0.2028821409,
0.8562232256,
0.0541538745,
-0.4273473024,
-0.1089693457,
-0.4915139973,
-0.1141272411,
0.3812608421,
-0.2155699134,
-0.0398188084,
0.5560189486,
-0.4529545605,
0.8000537753,
0.1726733446,
-0.2610251307,
-0.015464549,
-0.2960585356,
-0.6189131141,
-0.1049225181,
0.36383605,
0.6730208397,
-0.1871421635,
-0.4578180015,
-0.1065129489,
0.1107059047,
0.3560783863,
-0.6234816909,
-0.3060697913,
0.3494190574,
-0.4001483321,
-0.3320338726,
0.4193461835,
-0.8737075925,
-0.6116486192,
-0.777104795,
0.3525749147,
-0.3334083259,
-0.0688209459,
-0.1744448841,
-0.6727202535,
0.5908181667,
0.6761412621,
-0.7761039138,
-0.221956417,
0.5991708636,
1.0016893148,
-0.1033926755,
0.1063354239,
-0.1443319023,
0.4778135121,
-0.7056975365,
0.5031261444,
-0.6666485071,
-0.3426338732,
-0.0916878656,
0.0011160721,
0.3611921966,
-0.6065334678,
0.149025023,
-0.6776788235,
0.1557037234,
0.071395576,
-0.2528195679,
-0.0955701545,
0.0960782766,
-0.7082561255,
0.6468814015,
0.2793630958,
-0.4553590715,
0.3914079666,
-0.791007936,
-0.3418035507,
0.5961016417,
0.0000472457,
-0.5708302259,
-0.0801467523,
0.3591445982,
0.1113285124,
0.2026688457,
-0.0404687151,
-0.0895149112,
-0.8806218505,
0.1784275025,
-0.0294763092,
0.9048149586,
0.2324706763,
-0.3447408676,
0.1264093965,
-0.6217982173,
-0.3611344397,
-0.1676860154,
0.060984686,
-0.2105200738,
-0.3350729644,
0.2690352798,
0.1161608994,
0.4315128028,
-0.6137078404,
0.1103261039,
-0.2556683123,
0.451018095,
0.8318967223,
0.1885293722,
1.0632417202,
-0.5791226029,
0.5697017908,
-0.4041723609,
0.3246284425,
-0.4324572384,
-0.7008080482,
-0.7079866529,
-0.490105629,
-0.1947071254,
0.6503167748,
-1.1619511843,
0.0956450701,
0.2106562108,
-0.59911412,
-0.1870565712,
0.066466704,
0.0819249973,
0.4707486928,
0.3541052341,
-0.4801443219,
-0.7181707621,
-0.484505415,
-0.2981691062,
0.2229112089,
-0.5936092138,
-0.0189908631,
0.1458801478,
-0.5224564672,
0.9056161046,
-0.2108581662,
-0.452770412,
0.229997322,
0.1318979412,
0.4076823294,
1.0703368187,
0.4494853318,
-0.8549460769,
-0.6127225161,
0.1148457602,
-1.0308699608,
0.0461786687,
-0.4354855418,
-0.3611539304,
-0.0428515039,
0.7311112285,
-0.225666061,
0.9028055072,
0.3056194782,
-0.0108164633,
0.4753563404,
-0.1319942176,
0.5888602138,
-0.7686089277,
-0.0384758897,
0.0986517593,
-0.2463693917,
-0.8867925406,
0.7584597468,
-0.1038318276,
-0.6781401634,
-0.3919488192,
0.5698260069,
-0.6305188537,
0.0339767449,
-0.3781251013,
-0.5421487689,
0.3159886301,
0.6037532687,
-0.2792187929,
0.7546290159,
0.5621520281,
-0.547739923,
0.7155886292,
0.4059721529,
-0.624992311,
0.8341422677,
-0.557934463,
0.9370339513,
-0.3501153588,
0.2885750234,
-1.1590605974,
-0.6869730353,
0.9987043142,
-0.0812496841,
0.4229821265,
-0.5883944035,
-0.6807744503,
-0.0353105366,
-0.3148387372,
0.7617907524,
0.8073495626,
-0.8177318573,
1.0422208309,
0.2361892015,
-0.1585146338,
-0.2240026891,
-0.9497659802,
0.6050395966,
-0.7799707055,
-0.6335370541,
1.0484417677,
-0.1528753638,
-0.3403472602,
-0.2920868397,
0.147668615,
-0.1245442852,
-0.0304598715,
0.0704317614,
0.6450366378,
0.2310716212,
-0.2277164608,
0.0913768336,
0.2390529364,
-0.2871161997,
-0.3057928383,
0.4273211956,
0.4246425331,
-0.5041546822,
-0.6461666226,
0.5663796067,
0.6513181329,
-0.2244533002,
0.3442882895,
0.5191748142,
-0.4781678617,
0.1947654784,
-0.5594225526,
-0.0224593449,
-0.4930490553,
0.0030414131,
-0.172755897,
-0.4421322942,
0.6400676966,
-0.1279371381,
0.1529269218,
0.2752556205,
0.314250499,
-0.6076164842,
0.832865715,
0.5587816834,
0.3498775661,
1.0124123096,
-0.645891726,
-0.0229640771,
-1.1893699169,
-0.3818867803,
-0.0081863897,
-0.9399268627,
-0.5765586495,
-0.753544271,
1.0054969788,
-0.0247166734,
-0.2903331816,
0.2456644326,
-0.6071591973,
0.7421839237,
0.6658928394,
1.1111905575,
0.3162373006,
0.1403121054,
0.7184197903,
-0.0119166952,
-0.2854876518,
-0.1996825188,
1.0596795082,
-0.0338330157,
0.815877676,
0.0922932103,
0.4731663764,
0.3417531848,
0.4147424698,
-0.6131258607,
0.325011313,
-0.4501508176,
-0.047012005,
-0.4861657917,
0.19642061,
-0.5351307988,
-0.0134293064,
-0.333629638,
-0.5193973184,
0.774076879,
0.2193934172,
-0.1622682661,
0.5453252196,
-0.3780271709,
0.1548652202,
0.0192051474,
-0.6862915754,
-0.3933542967,
-0.7359650135,
0.4324900806,
-0.0308780707,
-0.0763388723,
0.1649165452,
-0.093784757,
0.5205596089,
-0.4168327153,
0.7998431921,
-0.0034155382,
-0.0751375929,
0.0572788566,
-0.1114243418,
0.4191741943,
-0.1267308444,
-0.0716014579,
0.422254771,
-0.65461725,
-0.4756510556,
-0.8883782625,
0.4209218323,
-0.371558547,
-0.5627518892,
-0.0770071372,
-0.7184551358,
-0.2746463418,
-0.142924428,
0.4310424328,
0.6563831568,
-0.2430638373,
0.0919593945,
0.5437197089,
-0.3130766451,
0.5486660004,
-0.3044392169,
0.0171156731,
-0.3495431542,
0.7733935118,
0.1612879485,
0.1589276195,
0.3234488368,
0.1419002861,
-0.1377262026,
-0.1160760373,
-1.0881302357,
-0.2117553651,
-0.8238002658,
-0.0901922584,
-0.3094152808,
-0.2757118046,
-0.2461957783,
-0.6265936494,
0.2431853563,
-0.1876628846,
-0.5973411202,
0.4285733104,
0.1743566245,
0.6791174412,
0.093296282,
0.1454887241,
-0.3045966923,
0.3414497375,
1.1239441633,
0.1957630813,
-0.1623116881,
-0.5455875397,
-0.4056589901,
0.1080125794,
-0.3102495372,
-0.7888107896,
0.3708517551,
0.2944287062,
0.4412743151,
0.1758094728,
-0.343485266,
0.8570336699,
-0.1890512556,
0.7294480205,
0.1909152418,
-0.700319469,
0.633257091,
-0.4292525053,
0.422412008,
0.187524125,
-0.0330445357,
-0.5747516751,
-0.4485805333,
-0.742631495,
-0.7208740711,
0.1812234968,
0.0755243525,
0.2678329349,
0.5450680852,
0.3257707655,
0.0458048768,
0.3864155114,
0.1437664777,
0.0989667848,
-0.6125299931,
0.085632056,
0.0463735983,
0.174816981,
-0.2835241556,
-0.2977996469,
0.5565165281,
-0.2266972065,
0.177810967,
0.0689224154,
-0.0965664163,
-0.0820279792,
-0.0175156891,
0.3806034625,
0.9927831292,
0.0069083604,
-0.3265497983,
-0.0091397641,
-0.1241297275,
0.0935923681,
0.0131600713,
-0.3415367007,
-0.0355195291,
0.2235553265,
0.8068685532,
-0.0547997244,
-0.4700736701,
0.2756594419,
0.3589630723,
0.1948050708,
-0.3745412827,
0.067663908,
-0.3517258763,
0.2250370234,
0.6269777417,
0.6901944876,
0.5497221947,
-1.1300635338,
0.1256202161,
0.5302075744,
-0.2402506024,
-0.107280843,
0.7746765614,
0.0745812356,
-0.4709311128,
0.648912251,
0.2611144781,
-0.2518230975,
0.7041090727,
0.1872957498,
0.9943611622,
-0.198431626,
0.3222275972,
0.3020555377,
-0.16803734,
0.1144880578,
-0.1656911969,
-0.1298071146,
-0.8712525368,
-0.4472998381,
-0.3085234463,
-0.6585479975,
0.0919679329,
-0.2600058317,
0.2981620729,
-0.6225482821,
0.4202554524,
-0.3108507991,
-0.6809881926,
-0.6865684986,
0.4197164774,
0.2753517628,
0.4326605797,
-0.8955036402,
0.2806269825,
0.8012640476,
-0.5987770557,
-0.4006347656,
0.4499378502,
-0.1147022247,
-0.7707512975,
0.4516510367,
0.0820014179,
-0.1235251725,
-0.0640580431,
-1.042514205,
-0.5502305031,
1.0219074488,
0.3774252534,
-0.4274821281,
-0.1294098049,
-0.1623147726,
0.4132643342,
-0.3696833849,
-0.0376195759,
0.7022145391,
0.4557899833,
0.5680471063,
-0.3833042383,
-0.3781885207,
-0.4805165231,
0.398735553,
0.0190382507,
-0.5274876952,
0.8078988194,
0.0995960534,
-0.5380432606,
0.4874004126,
0.5181365013,
0.3675048649,
0.5141115189,
0.8425130248,
0.834040463,
0.5352040529,
-0.1535173953,
0.8420446515,
-0.1039488986,
0.069120802,
0.8293802738,
0.2655079365,
0.2800865173,
0.2906072736,
-0.0673923641,
1.0551599264,
0.5066046119,
0.0376273878,
0.766366899,
0.0516702235,
-0.6963399053,
0.0002385424,
-0.1758793592,
-0.1788814664,
0.6807203293,
0.2252753973,
-0.18118909,
0.1019669846,
0.3770855963,
-0.1178107411,
0.1870437562,
-0.5159240961,
1.0274534225,
-0.4446296394,
-0.5458152294,
0.4272709191,
-0.2091071457,
0.7760042548,
-0.4077861607,
-0.777736187,
-0.3635925651,
-0.3049583435,
-0.3607993126,
-1.0799787045,
0.5036330223,
-0.1303044111,
0.0787154287,
-0.6653292775,
1.0759913921,
-0.395858705,
-0.5461279154,
-0.2782099247,
0.1788731217,
0.0663758516,
-0.435095042,
-0.3435597122,
0.0451269411,
-0.2464193851,
0.3925658166,
0.2003434151,
0.2005825043,
-0.0208696835,
0.3062526882,
0.8917295337,
-0.1811677665,
-0.3841686845,
0.2217347175,
0.937289238,
-0.1871362925,
-0.8229025006,
-0.6628100276,
0.7977313399,
-0.2742544711,
0.013595324,
0.3204872012,
0.3736545742,
0.8544893861,
-0.4203724265,
0.8491060734,
-0.0858993381,
-0.0244227909,
-0.7320739031,
0.6569586992,
-0.5936688781,
0.1254083514,
-0.7383282185,
-0.9174712896,
-0.2343850583,
0.5451171398,
0.2064817101,
-0.0559373051,
0.0787427127,
0.9053136706,
-0.2909348905,
-0.2292166799,
0.4386278987,
-0.3674496412,
0.2608686686,
0.1442429274,
0.9571458101,
-0.3309173584,
-0.0600530319,
-0.6255158186,
-0.7074978948,
-0.0626368448,
-0.8431125283,
-0.2650544941,
-0.6762421131,
-0.3499296308,
-0.1881732643,
0.1571552306,
0.357550621,
0.9831861258,
-0.5474441051,
-0.1451866031,
-0.1936523616,
-0.1684761047,
-0.5897937417,
-0.2845864594,
-0.0450423695,
-0.1746263057,
-1.0508738756,
0.8269295096,
0.891661644,
0.0077442685,
-0.7664684057,
0.2086826116,
0.021246694,
-0.1789916754,
0.7184048891,
0.2922469974,
-0.6982840896,
-0.3041537106,
-0.3614764214,
0.2500618398,
0.3057776093,
0.9467303157,
-1.0863931179,
0.8051865697,
0.7816839218,
0.7469470501,
0.6038737893,
0.3480902314,
0.636661768,
-1.0094453096,
0.2912344635,
0.0700396821,
0.3543490171,
0.8028206229,
-0.7420071959,
0.8096280694,
0.4944743514,
-0.4076370597,
-0.3409411609,
0.4378567934,
-0.8655072451,
-0.1813240796,
0.5467086434,
0.084031187,
0.1127417833,
-0.2577688396,
-0.346170038,
0.2290025502,
0.1277793944,
0.8114257455,
0.4120519757,
-0.2428282052,
-0.4917185009,
-0.0454832651,
0.2300738394,
-0.013749484,
-0.8654695749,
-0.4720521271,
0.394505769,
0.198996976,
0.3420844078,
0.5344359279,
-0.1051065326,
0.4016811848,
-0.4417661726,
-0.0474363677,
0.0517425723,
-0.3807040453,
-0.0825911462,
0.0699259415,
-0.5647944808,
-0.4872812033
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03485v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03485v2
|
Attention Meets Post-hoc Interpretability: A Mathematical Perspective
| 2024-02-05T19:56:56 | 2024-06-17T13:18:30 |
Gianluigi Lopardo, Frederic Precioso, Damien Garreau
|
stat.ML
|
stat.ML, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Attention-based architectures, in particular transformers, are at the heart
of a technological revolution. Interestingly, in addition to helping obtain
state-of-the-art results on a wide range of applications, the attention
mechanism intrinsically provides meaningful insights on the internal behavior
of the model. Can these insights be used as explanations? Debate rages on. In
this paper, we mathematically study a simple attention-based architecture and
pinpoint the differences between post-hoc and attention-based explanations. We
show that they provide quite different results, and that, despite their
limitations, post-hoc methods are capable of capturing more useful insights
than merely examining the attention weights.
|
[
-0.6142030954,
-0.7789575458,
0.8421660662,
0.3237010539,
-0.1151125655,
-0.3962988853,
0.0653853863,
-0.5511689782,
-0.0973298773,
0.1894370615,
-0.7926573753,
0.1491639167,
-0.6100484133,
0.0063071493,
-0.5751643777,
0.9541934133,
-0.1947237998,
-0.1832587421,
-0.58376652,
-0.1275305599,
-0.4572288394,
-0.1820328832,
-0.4109015465,
-0.5098931789,
0.6697583795,
0.1768156737,
0.8582725525,
0.813583374,
0.8444418907,
0.3167340159,
-0.0531839132,
-0.0660016164,
-0.410448432,
-0.2947267592,
-0.2927117348,
-0.5275643468,
-0.3438652456,
0.022507865,
0.2626566887,
1.0001883507,
0.122304529,
0.5390676856,
0.2796384096,
0.782507658,
-0.521553576,
0.3183072209,
-0.3180279732,
0.1245861202,
-0.1049325764,
-0.5681878328,
-0.4684069753,
-0.2329336405,
0.4831116199,
-0.7397723794,
0.3582786918,
0.0364314914,
0.7015343308,
0.7011725903,
-0.2322508395,
-0.2396878749,
-1.1262274981,
1.0257483721,
-0.1227215454,
0.6588125229,
0.2125218958,
0.6540358067,
0.3906843364,
-0.8554201126,
-0.1452032924,
0.2159938514,
-0.2933820784,
0.2361019999,
-0.2479618937,
-0.1638079733,
0.6150900126,
0.5452887416,
-0.5290555954,
-0.3595612943,
-0.4320865273,
-0.1932308674,
0.3184872568,
0.0798382387,
0.0020631491,
-0.0026242652,
-0.5108624101,
0.2078478485,
-0.6960763335,
0.342917949,
0.0070630712,
-0.2094926685,
-0.3284592628,
0.5171718001,
-0.1618452668,
0.6216108203,
0.2999232709,
0.6031839252,
-0.2657433152,
0.0223287717,
-0.359906733,
0.1515555233,
0.3200918138,
0.1805009991,
0.3748840094,
-0.2706698477,
0.004400718,
0.459877491,
0.8542488813,
-0.5275380015,
-0.3521386683,
0.2681331933,
-0.8341981769,
-0.2464698851,
0.0736005753,
-0.9869041443,
-0.0539571829,
-0.5775637627,
0.4814938605,
-0.0267394464,
-0.2548649907,
0.2831355035,
-0.10555619,
0.6591022015,
0.4075056016,
-1.0130901337,
0.2116448432,
1.0146216154,
0.8996673822,
0.1700943559,
-0.0362913981,
-0.6562798023,
-0.127489686,
-0.2937756479,
1.2069228888,
-0.4523646235,
-0.315784514,
-0.0130285583,
-0.2523135245,
0.0723558441,
-0.4832950234,
0.5646805763,
-0.9387865067,
0.3316037059,
-0.4381232262,
-0.1626690626,
-0.3150585294,
-0.0400846116,
-0.5946491361,
1.0390043259,
0.1657399833,
-1.0321793556,
0.267731607,
-1.0996955633,
-0.6247388721,
0.0582705587,
-0.0560533665,
-0.2048583478,
0.7620909214,
0.1166751087,
-0.0398290753,
-0.3736690581,
-0.0126706762,
-0.351674974,
-0.4452706277,
0.478179425,
-0.35252738,
0.7292795181,
0.2984693646,
-0.4757849276,
0.2176741213,
-0.6531075239,
-0.3812760115,
0.2037237287,
0.2297543734,
-0.0485006459,
0.3366873562,
-0.4194429219,
0.3519756794,
0.2835120559,
-0.3816201091,
-0.3480292261,
-0.6851328015,
0.7053656578,
0.8081424236,
-0.2632778883,
0.8162598014,
-0.6010862589,
0.5755627751,
-0.2213160545,
0.4429527521,
-0.467964828,
-0.5179866552,
-0.5796712637,
-0.0102585219,
-0.1855404377,
0.2247501016,
-0.7542950511,
-0.155567795,
-0.2623686194,
-0.4584925771,
-0.7443915606,
-0.3963280618,
0.2008108944,
0.9083301425,
0.4151315689,
-0.1670587361,
-0.533767581,
-0.8282576799,
-0.8207330704,
0.0177835282,
-0.4046551883,
0.6271877885,
0.0927866176,
-0.0272937622,
0.8834832907,
-0.5240527391,
0.2280478626,
-0.0753617138,
0.1110925823,
0.3479444087,
0.0245613959,
0.2445494682,
-0.7731357813,
-0.2872438133,
0.2801533937,
-0.9581790566,
-0.176804468,
-0.3163872659,
-0.2866687477,
-0.3609015346,
0.5972445011,
-0.8163641095,
0.6054519415,
0.0888160616,
-0.0380820855,
0.7990788817,
0.123592183,
0.0716234893,
-0.4676673412,
0.2088188231,
0.0753013492,
-0.1239694655,
-0.6611158848,
-0.0225407984,
-0.0377479941,
-0.2420923114,
-0.7587255239,
0.6580243707,
-0.4353370667,
-0.6001617908,
-0.3723478019,
0.2716597915,
0.1636556685,
0.5461992025,
-0.0284563266,
0.3253255486,
0.7390568256,
-0.8556455374,
0.4885722399,
0.5604383945,
-0.3779752254,
0.6163260341,
-1.1932281256,
0.195070982,
-0.360340029,
0.0101224426,
-1.3728688955,
-0.3992483616,
0.298363924,
-0.7718178034,
-0.0759728774,
0.0657690465,
-0.0925420672,
-0.5431550145,
-0.3658406138,
0.6127535701,
0.5501821637,
-0.6932920218,
0.8809731007,
-0.0169574544,
-0.1313130558,
-0.3839924335,
-0.7043612599,
-0.4304763675,
-0.3340961933,
-0.8742313981,
0.1278646439,
-0.0282959845,
-0.7793980241,
0.1349627972,
-0.3807366192,
0.0298176203,
0.3735052943,
0.3090455532,
0.3538097441,
-0.622161448,
0.2659099698,
-0.1314716041,
-0.7016163468,
0.4907021523,
-0.4202905893,
0.5150354505,
0.0016387757,
-0.3960379958,
-1.1311022043,
0.3997524977,
0.8531259298,
-0.4046916366,
0.5416570306,
0.2864285111,
-0.3173930049,
-0.1093591228,
-0.2223121077,
-0.5707107782,
-0.5572552085,
-0.1098562479,
-0.4905706346,
-0.6514632702,
0.4696668684,
-0.2022154033,
0.3633917868,
0.8741737604,
0.6662589312,
-0.3532918394,
1.3189108372,
0.6251819134,
0.4428583086,
0.768552959,
0.2263740301,
0.3803528547,
-0.9414479136,
-0.1054585502,
-0.809440434,
-0.5933238864,
-0.3759191632,
0.0016928877,
0.2469429374,
-0.3552431166,
-0.2365413308,
0.3301086426,
-0.8556582332,
0.3323851526,
0.4120564461,
-0.0508532412,
0.2007894814,
-0.0635133758,
0.6247740388,
-0.1407760084,
-0.7632939219,
-0.5329209566,
0.8501001596,
0.3675500154,
0.6093981862,
-0.1984818876,
0.1135217026,
0.1077898741,
0.8781591654,
-1.1441341639,
0.2198047191,
0.2427690029,
-0.6305632591,
-0.2632394731,
-0.5302217603,
-0.9685743451,
0.2679279447,
0.2313304096,
-0.627279222,
0.2557830513,
0.4542094469,
-0.4573479295,
-0.0457260422,
-0.9308333397,
1.2277027369,
-0.2920378149,
-0.29289487,
-0.4277593791,
-0.7488569021,
0.430177331,
-0.0064474656,
0.690766871,
0.2192112207,
0.1698824763,
0.5856394172,
-0.2186844796,
0.5364874005,
0.0300462823,
-0.1511170864,
0.2721694112,
0.1068333313,
0.3807375133,
-0.0843100771,
-0.126923129,
0.2430654466,
-0.2543672621,
-0.5000157356,
-0.7982587814,
0.5106585622,
-0.6556116343,
-0.8531182408,
-0.0833982676,
-0.6129724383,
-0.0663964674,
0.1240679249,
0.562086463,
0.9309141636,
-0.0290936772,
0.2330355197,
0.7991535068,
-0.1576819867,
0.4503682256,
0.245504871,
-0.0760657042,
0.1697419137,
0.7546781301,
-0.1615189761,
0.089157708,
0.6733469963,
0.4079883695,
-0.6294389963,
-0.2108771652,
-0.4573783875,
0.3206988871,
-0.624366641,
0.2952794433,
-0.6946306229,
0.1372123659,
-0.1408765167,
-0.5102454424,
-0.3042087555,
-0.3356110454,
-0.4061655998,
0.0137696555,
0.0402876958,
0.9287462831,
0.0941970646,
0.5257269144,
-0.8161387444,
0.5474637151,
0.4020031095,
0.5640310645,
0.3830386996,
-0.7344297171,
-0.5243896246,
0.0509422421,
-0.2662233412,
-0.8864293694,
-0.0867114291,
-0.0794664845,
0.4782387912,
0.8415418863,
-0.0014865194,
0.4928040504,
-0.4856704473,
0.635137856,
0.0920267105,
-1.172391057,
0.6181433201,
-0.2916980386,
0.5845249295,
0.0185718071,
0.3526158631,
-0.4803290367,
-0.1386465877,
-0.8464093208,
-0.4358389676,
1.1145335436,
0.1074677706,
0.0666085035,
0.2730799913,
0.4999313951,
0.2534366846,
0.1604322195,
-0.4120469093,
-0.1411577165,
-0.3557381928,
-0.1743574589,
0.0050235689,
-0.2221006453,
-0.2644011378,
0.1203539595,
0.3251381516,
0.2352138758,
0.5481978655,
0.33035779,
-0.4265837371,
-0.4469109476,
0.0030080825,
0.6836975813,
0.9046150446,
0.2553469241,
0.52000314,
-0.1131476685,
-0.1802850217,
-0.1756203324,
0.0272061732,
0.0217621028,
-0.014040607,
0.6567854881,
0.8331649303,
0.3091409802,
-0.4187787771,
0.2639366984,
-0.1268296391,
-0.2923893631,
0.2281209379,
-0.2247311324,
-0.0498348176,
0.3527172804,
0.3107995093,
0.3712639809,
0.3208115101,
-0.6573067307,
0.3911118507,
0.3322734833,
-0.7582296133,
-0.8558186889,
1.1895717382,
0.1356175095,
-0.7494056225,
0.1829762906,
0.3868385255,
-0.323299557,
0.878308475,
0.0668333322,
1.0203492641,
-0.4983457625,
0.2242920399,
0.077802971,
0.3542688191,
0.1620841771,
0.0807354525,
-0.7120314837,
-0.4248641133,
-0.6794120073,
-0.4394696355,
-0.3854677677,
-0.237251699,
-0.987031281,
0.0434822217,
-0.4169597328,
0.034616936,
0.7113252878,
-0.6021522284,
-0.8669645786,
0.1367090642,
-0.1709426641,
0.5787382722,
-0.5538670421,
0.1432230473,
1.0173681974,
0.069407776,
-0.383846432,
0.1607819051,
-0.0127458945,
-1.0016648769,
0.3898756206,
0.4709465504,
-0.334059298,
0.0072335922,
-0.2903779447,
-0.9280762672,
0.5272469521,
0.2687496543,
-0.4256541431,
0.1971272975,
0.0240481962,
0.7440398335,
0.1847403049,
0.3124083877,
0.5168324709,
0.4917292595,
0.0684524775,
-0.6084110141,
-0.207507357,
-0.0946855694,
-0.2811927795,
0.4574043155,
-0.5427680016,
0.7101160288,
-0.1507878453,
-0.5712623596,
-0.4137058556,
0.7114572525,
-0.2388661355,
0.8893888593,
0.4276172817,
0.2022483945,
0.214705795,
-0.2760614455,
1.4119098186,
-0.4183325171,
0.5735505223,
0.7583346367,
-0.0265266802,
0.3547099829,
0.441315949,
-0.435501188,
0.4262808263,
0.8426473737,
0.4525341392,
0.5250706077,
-0.1517486572,
0.0147748794,
-0.2284896225,
-0.1313149631,
-0.4520882368,
0.3087189794,
0.2980179787,
-0.2663594484,
-0.402341336,
-0.0077512758,
-0.4064105153,
-0.1144647375,
-0.5536339283,
0.9203191996,
0.3887215555,
-0.7893763185,
0.2642543316,
-0.4882318676,
-0.0850185156,
-0.2291882038,
0.1688810289,
-0.053121347,
0.4969730377,
-0.2735677063,
-0.6854530573,
0.9173668623,
-0.0651137233,
-0.4280662835,
-0.5921693444,
0.6031436324,
0.1439959854,
-0.2477102578,
0.1091415286,
0.5746872425,
0.131085977,
-0.3744694293,
-0.3310675919,
0.2619374394,
-0.198452577,
-0.2592703998,
-0.0155182462,
0.7297045588,
0.035268236,
0.5231526494,
0.5715967417,
-0.5530692935,
-0.1008413807,
-0.2049568743,
0.6509617567,
-0.5180065036,
-0.7010615468,
-1.0797730684,
0.6719099283,
0.2503819764,
-0.3435521126,
0.8029795289,
0.2709898353,
0.6066634655,
-0.205594942,
0.6286387444,
0.3069794774,
0.486623615,
-0.2861092389,
0.2966007292,
-0.8161323071,
0.1450493932,
-0.0639121979,
-1.189239502,
-0.3820416331,
0.6817852855,
-0.7944310308,
-0.0950391516,
0.859026134,
0.2852813005,
-0.2229286879,
0.4243229628,
0.2224075794,
0.4352236688,
0.1778832823,
0.4874716103,
1.3240054846,
-0.0851101801,
0.6974952221,
0.0644575134,
-0.4324502647,
-0.6153783798,
-0.462886095,
-0.5974286795,
-0.3195546567,
-0.1859052181,
-0.1412594765,
-0.473721385,
0.1559293866,
0.5498995185,
-0.6554206014,
0.1808111519,
-0.3441725671,
0.4050126374,
-0.5037212968,
-0.2187484801,
0.5106391907,
-0.2492966801,
-0.5722662807,
0.126783669,
0.7550837994,
-0.2638255358,
-0.16929169,
0.3242969811,
0.5080068707,
0.4591616988,
0.9845777154,
0.2959926724,
-0.7031837702,
-0.4616462588,
0.3982484043,
0.1160338148,
0.357393086,
1.2329865694,
-0.6580051184,
0.6632025838,
0.6703560352,
0.7632827759,
0.5979524851,
0.3173052669,
0.5609608293,
-0.311306417,
0.2447759807,
0.1625658572,
0.3685410619,
0.2446982712,
-0.4631067216,
0.2062658221,
0.2688281536,
-0.6317432523,
-0.7392881513,
0.6371539235,
-0.9871531129,
-0.048753757,
0.697637856,
0.0584478006,
-0.4250760078,
-0.4445488453,
-0.237276569,
0.4554840326,
-0.1195471734,
1.1692409515,
0.898240149,
-0.2884842753,
-0.4475200772,
-0.7013034821,
0.6044235826,
0.7566457987,
-0.957500577,
0.1256233752,
0.1957294047,
-0.1504713744,
0.3292338848,
0.3580823243,
-0.2722886205,
0.6732110977,
0.0291653331,
-0.475183785,
0.2713082433,
-0.5194725394,
-0.5196241736,
0.1657126397,
-0.233479172,
-0.4703837335
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03484v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03484v1
|
Harnessing PubMed User Query Logs for Post Hoc Explanations of Recommended Similar Articles
| 2024-02-05T19:56:27 | 2024-02-05T19:56:27 |
Ashley Shin, Qiao Jin, James Anibal, Zhiyong Lu
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Searching for a related article based on a reference article is an integral
part of scientific research. PubMed, like many academic search engines, has a
"similar articles" feature that recommends articles relevant to the current
article viewed by a user. Explaining recommended items can be of great utility
to users, particularly in the literature search process. With more than a
million biomedical papers being published each year, explaining the recommended
similar articles would facilitate researchers and clinicians in searching for
related articles. Nonetheless, the majority of current literature
recommendation systems lack explanations for their suggestions. We employ a
post hoc approach to explaining recommendations by identifying relevant tokens
in the titles of similar articles. Our major contribution is building PubCLogs
by repurposing 5.6 million pairs of coclicked articles from PubMed's user query
logs. Using our PubCLogs dataset, we train the Highlight Similar Article Title
(HSAT), a transformer-based model designed to select the most relevant parts of
the title of a similar article, based on the title and abstract of a seed
article. HSAT demonstrates strong performance in our empirical evaluations,
achieving an F1 score of 91.72 percent on the PubCLogs test set, considerably
outperforming several baselines including BM25 (70.62), MPNet (67.11), MedCPT
(62.22), GPT-3.5 (46.00), and GPT-4 (64.89). Additional evaluations on a
separate, manually annotated test set further verifies HSAT's performance.
Moreover, participants of our user study indicate a preference for HSAT, due to
its superior balance between conciseness and comprehensiveness. Our study
suggests that repurposing user query logs of academic search engines can be a
promising way to train state-of-the-art models for explaining literature
recommendation.
|
[
-0.3092618883,
-0.2498343587,
0.90958637,
-0.1733270735,
-0.7555567622,
-0.1940809637,
0.0201960057,
-0.5348992348,
0.4288338423,
0.7108533978,
-0.5356869698,
-0.555701375,
-0.2221355438,
0.2904787958,
-0.2016048133,
1.4116973877,
0.1090061143,
0.0765319392,
-0.3733908534,
-0.2207555026,
-0.4532474577,
-0.2016857266,
-0.4741879404,
-0.6628987789,
0.7455669045,
0.1037120223,
0.3921073079,
0.2965937257,
0.7422037721,
0.1356643587,
-0.2758174241,
0.1706115007,
-0.6656827927,
0.2018120736,
-0.5099713206,
-0.4944737256,
-0.303011775,
-0.1602239162,
0.2299689949,
0.7302653193,
0.0152161838,
0.2383389473,
0.2863490582,
0.8157282472,
-0.171776399,
-0.2224043161,
-0.6008504629,
-0.0178973339,
-0.2564496994,
-0.5912342668,
-0.3451984525,
-0.5054880977,
0.5437437296,
-0.7416934967,
0.4476612806,
0.445466727,
1.0143451691,
-0.1027067974,
-0.2494096756,
-0.1815869808,
-0.6076387763,
0.7035167217,
-0.6869051456,
0.4773133695,
0.4905814528,
0.2757342756,
0.0338585787,
-0.9289628267,
0.0786897242,
-0.0874137804,
-0.6146755815,
0.1167783365,
-0.1211696342,
0.0249114912,
0.333445102,
0.2565734982,
-1.066187501,
-0.2210078388,
-0.564140439,
-0.1763110161,
0.562667191,
0.257866323,
-0.1303988993,
-0.2640479505,
-0.5045362711,
0.1045761555,
-0.9995964766,
0.1068821996,
0.0565930679,
0.1310667396,
0.4129842222,
0.4200686216,
-0.4864115715,
0.7591275573,
0.2444269657,
-0.0171329975,
0.3428193331,
-0.6913051605,
0.0253354628,
0.2758375406,
0.7160941958,
0.7407814264,
0.0353533924,
-0.1755266637,
0.1130139008,
-0.3253077865,
0.4181391895,
-0.9219252467,
-0.3585700095,
0.2403885871,
-0.8920137882,
-0.0961684063,
0.1266160756,
-0.7539469004,
-0.5208061934,
-0.0094503118,
0.4152579308,
-0.301225543,
-0.0260470677,
0.2612150609,
-0.1873978674,
-0.0295066033,
0.2058548629,
-0.5750666261,
-0.0157240704,
0.6198707819,
0.646173358,
-0.2502695322,
-0.2554920018,
-0.3344659805,
0.254272759,
-0.0666254759,
1.1496678591,
-0.5599701405,
-0.4901313484,
-0.0821548924,
0.2821796238,
-0.0614299066,
-0.4638891518,
0.5060790777,
-0.6519847512,
0.3492880464,
-0.52568537,
-0.6243416667,
-0.2634462416,
0.2184047848,
-0.5020112395,
0.8481647968,
-0.3397822678,
-1.099034667,
0.3916157484,
-0.4686907232,
-0.2942299545,
-0.0253120773,
-0.0090399534,
-0.618973732,
0.1892291605,
0.2338881493,
0.2813167274,
-0.3562999964,
0.3037493229,
-0.237602964,
-0.523557961,
0.11049968,
0.1971399784,
0.7388732433,
0.224762693,
-0.0383904465,
0.2285350412,
-0.160486117,
-0.1923080385,
0.0760619268,
0.1472732276,
-0.840410471,
-0.0966674313,
-0.3166744709,
-0.1399998516,
0.3227062821,
-0.4755659997,
0.0166971646,
-0.4488723278,
0.2690521777,
0.2258205414,
0.584661901,
0.2271001637,
-0.7066005468,
0.5304903388,
-0.3378265202,
0.1168234646,
-0.5043221116,
-0.7212558985,
-0.0589558072,
-0.0173829962,
0.2575885653,
0.1900220513,
-0.4483923614,
0.1107050255,
-0.1940655112,
-0.6744687557,
-0.6914083958,
-0.0565310195,
0.3739262521,
0.6167038083,
0.363079071,
-0.315054208,
-0.7341939807,
-0.9255818129,
-0.7097818255,
-0.4346876442,
-0.1623989195,
0.717140913,
0.1449721307,
-0.3247163296,
0.8789553642,
-0.7890604138,
-0.3021825552,
0.0969576091,
0.3398171365,
0.471056819,
0.1065024883,
0.3484050035,
-0.7945452929,
-0.3740888536,
0.1596293598,
-0.6565407515,
-0.4877394438,
-0.1536572129,
-0.1466119736,
-0.3110476434,
0.6424333453,
-0.3465721011,
0.3169316351,
0.2535383403,
-0.4837287962,
0.8151742816,
-0.2306933552,
0.516161561,
-0.8317098618,
0.3791551888,
-0.0717689097,
-0.2711006999,
-0.1986411214,
-0.0202133451,
-0.2472992092,
-0.0893439874,
-0.1898192167,
0.4028333724,
-0.2322578579,
-0.0285977349,
-0.1410979033,
-0.0541649424,
0.1908221394,
0.1626725942,
-0.0535074361,
0.6509695053,
0.2813200355,
-0.2503883243,
0.0925490707,
0.2039181143,
-0.2166814804,
0.5519858599,
-0.87058568,
-0.162214011,
-0.0704604164,
0.1261552423,
-1.3983699083,
0.1062048301,
-0.099192448,
-0.3408049345,
-0.121337235,
-0.1524785161,
-0.317722708,
-0.4942161441,
-0.5153880715,
0.3488829434,
0.526352644,
-0.3664393723,
0.2259164751,
0.1801791191,
-0.4770988524,
-0.2468434572,
-0.1154542863,
-0.1940484196,
-0.4311667085,
-0.1756126583,
0.5644862056,
-0.1699249446,
0.0021208182,
0.3976822197,
-0.2455800176,
0.0083518885,
-0.0218712334,
0.3913990259,
0.1599134207,
-0.2349753827,
0.3877269924,
-0.0015466067,
-0.2656031549,
0.0764463022,
-0.2496039867,
0.4813206494,
-0.2369341999,
-0.4524303079,
-0.510263741,
0.2366517782,
0.4618220329,
-0.3604077995,
0.4044994414,
0.8232113123,
-0.0849923044,
0.3397093117,
-0.4457416236,
-0.8220946789,
-0.3816530704,
0.1475709826,
-0.1485905349,
-1.0104278326,
0.5729533434,
-0.2584676743,
0.0785150528,
0.6338415742,
0.4294351935,
-0.6182235479,
0.8637546301,
0.3094183207,
0.2136766911,
0.4928468466,
-0.0465600938,
0.3171549439,
-0.7120787501,
-0.3849564791,
-0.610337913,
-0.2462726384,
-0.5961219072,
-0.263320595,
0.4250090122,
-0.0360307954,
0.1086192578,
0.5352315903,
-0.702563405,
0.3849900365,
0.6756031513,
0.2698266506,
0.6546881795,
0.3387291133,
-0.1814109236,
-0.2344468534,
-0.4948326945,
-0.2420618683,
1.3483431339,
0.1045776457,
0.7676166892,
-0.2916349173,
0.9624894261,
0.3336757421,
0.3789617121,
-0.6738266349,
0.2780952454,
-0.0636770353,
-0.7719946504,
-0.2806226611,
-0.1586387008,
-1.3888818026,
0.2096529454,
-0.3566288054,
-0.6183473468,
0.0960231498,
0.1291620582,
-0.5405885577,
0.088942349,
-0.3444191515,
0.7752429247,
-0.0383113921,
-0.5069118738,
-0.3882147968,
-0.5590656996,
0.2220980078,
-0.2628502846,
0.1223540455,
0.044517573,
0.08325243,
1.0136283636,
-0.3081750572,
0.5083556771,
-0.0661796927,
0.2501837909,
0.2759361863,
-0.1414439827,
0.317168057,
0.1848279685,
-0.2276364565,
0.1568730772,
0.3361106813,
-0.2493935823,
-0.5373736024,
0.7828826308,
-0.3143420517,
-0.8269674778,
-0.309578687,
-0.2227900177,
-0.0175212193,
0.384850949,
0.4535619915,
0.3742732704,
-0.1000175178,
0.4825814366,
0.7939520478,
0.0132900365,
0.1043897793,
0.555631578,
-0.4614952207,
-0.3884147108,
0.6353946924,
0.0022088827,
-0.4599996507,
0.3064645827,
0.3939222991,
-0.4825556278,
-0.8048286438,
-0.1679992676,
0.6506237388,
-0.079951793,
-0.4010118246,
-0.7117687464,
0.1201348007,
-0.1501320153,
-0.2403092086,
-0.0741936713,
-0.0675540268,
-0.2505603135,
-0.0785121471,
0.5230736732,
0.6844741106,
0.1823333055,
0.3878633976,
-0.7619444728,
0.2390374094,
0.5102455616,
0.602052331,
-0.0542061552,
-0.6221269369,
-0.5676637888,
-0.2702400684,
-0.2362602651,
-1.1320736408,
0.2639135122,
0.1620499194,
0.6846338511,
0.631372869,
0.2600755692,
0.6773862839,
-0.7232444286,
0.6936928034,
0.2292405814,
-0.322897017,
0.6676667929,
-0.5423708558,
0.3423761725,
0.8926846981,
0.6671535969,
-0.3762982488,
-0.3270461857,
-0.73717314,
-0.7287479043,
0.527402997,
0.2859256864,
-0.2673703134,
0.2279053181,
0.4280804992,
0.3752717674,
0.2212622315,
-0.3854951262,
-0.2356125861,
0.1311647892,
0.0052468441,
-0.1792370528,
-0.5072686672,
-0.3784086108,
-0.2392693907,
0.6365968585,
-0.0031575006,
0.3029822707,
0.5569188595,
-0.015080275,
-0.2042814046,
0.0700845495,
0.33191517,
0.8273478746,
-0.7211315632,
0.2420356125,
-0.0362911224,
-0.4377529919,
-0.1089485958,
0.4373333156,
0.022632299,
0.4450135827,
0.503826797,
0.4907083809,
0.415053457,
-0.7604691982,
0.4089217484,
-0.072367318,
-0.0452210903,
0.0597055778,
-0.2255113423,
0.3574439287,
0.3386626244,
0.5931158066,
0.0523778088,
0.7061840892,
-0.3256498575,
0.6339061856,
0.2573359311,
-0.6658130288,
-0.5383191109,
0.5565975904,
0.1360313892,
-0.2747066021,
0.0594870225,
0.0037675141,
-0.2895095944,
0.4123773575,
0.5741265416,
0.7290830016,
-0.2627854049,
0.2983475029,
0.5568386912,
0.291893065,
-0.2140270174,
0.1800450385,
0.0380047522,
-0.2192575186,
-0.346074909,
-0.6668404937,
-0.2912980914,
0.0417676829,
-0.8845697045,
0.1248902231,
-0.0733347982,
-0.3554540575,
0.3748059869,
0.0844957605,
-0.7486010194,
-0.0268743541,
-0.1713968962,
0.6641612053,
-1.1280761957,
0.6197088957,
1.3095966578,
-0.2250222862,
-0.4144407809,
-0.0291091353,
-0.0307897441,
-0.6719903946,
0.1345520616,
0.1144207865,
0.1605457813,
-0.2390687019,
-0.2840845585,
-0.547429502,
1.1935124397,
0.074964717,
-0.5739141703,
-0.0244085193,
-0.3199965954,
1.0265653133,
-0.5284529328,
0.3189967871,
0.4213215709,
0.2168505639,
0.1409802139,
-1.0788290501,
0.2135492712,
-0.0084722117,
-0.0973611474,
0.0844821036,
-0.2854606509,
0.6107702851,
-0.2410245687,
0.2318119407,
-0.0084549375,
0.311411649,
0.6426920891,
1.0607607365,
0.4986732006,
0.4885137677,
0.742667377,
0.2081675678,
0.9180387855,
-0.1347318739,
0.5716913342,
0.984967351,
-0.0722191855,
0.8390746117,
0.6866734028,
-0.3468492329,
0.7572468519,
0.9176630974,
0.1070309877,
0.8086442351,
-0.1539809853,
0.0836469457,
-0.4428285062,
-0.4050813615,
-0.7408795357,
0.2395584732,
0.3155575395,
-0.8322919607,
-0.4043371081,
0.1132369936,
-0.0340383798,
0.0186127219,
-0.1495616436,
1.1743739843,
0.1585586667,
-0.6684934497,
0.6735052466,
-0.5600324869,
0.3132948577,
-0.5672191381,
-0.060398411,
-0.4137009382,
-0.1582744867,
-0.3565656245,
-0.7895794511,
0.4361074865,
-0.0818986669,
-0.4168210328,
-0.1562372297,
0.7653919458,
-0.5177623034,
-0.2601384819,
0.1638320833,
0.5850864053,
0.5018653274,
-0.0835577697,
-0.746635139,
0.067750074,
0.3615702689,
-0.1000874192,
0.2232999057,
0.3935687542,
-0.0537593886,
0.3433493078,
0.5505338311,
0.1957204789,
-0.5025107861,
-0.3172418773,
0.8053562641,
-0.6290282607,
-0.5674138665,
-0.6191350222,
0.2756511569,
-0.17765221,
-0.1383383423,
0.8653332591,
0.6628905535,
0.5532140732,
-0.1419857293,
0.3868169785,
0.4885455966,
0.6806166768,
-0.2544028461,
0.8135401607,
-0.9180628657,
0.4219652414,
-0.2461671531,
-1.0113968849,
-0.3268027604,
0.3804198205,
-0.5576546788,
-0.2692228854,
0.861587882,
0.727245152,
-0.2227633297,
0.0573065467,
0.1703815162,
0.2810998261,
0.0159792956,
0.2031682581,
0.4443056583,
-0.2518145144,
0.6546375155,
0.0496794917,
-0.2134271264,
-1.0051759481,
-0.7904640436,
-0.987095654,
-0.5573270917,
-0.4053934216,
-0.3794505,
0.4258835018,
0.6136875749,
0.8115532994,
-1.0022293329,
-0.1864178777,
0.2725998759,
0.3920128047,
-0.5212259889,
-0.181217283,
0.6085178256,
-0.1282042116,
-0.289927125,
0.1263126582,
0.202637732,
-0.3880268335,
0.1087059528,
0.0457868874,
-0.2861851752,
-0.1332703829,
0.5508080125,
0.3411144018,
-0.7955818176,
-0.0942399651,
0.0826762021,
-0.1194087863,
0.0194612518,
1.0523337126,
-1.04055655,
0.9684199095,
0.8258885741,
0.5984740853,
0.865657866,
0.1714103073,
0.4201429188,
-0.4768278599,
-0.1822032481,
0.164751038,
0.2660427988,
0.2722230852,
-0.4251320064,
0.5116447806,
0.40629071,
-0.6494942904,
-0.921977222,
-0.0665504113,
-1.0239239931,
-0.3466098011,
1.037740469,
-0.2385552675,
-0.1517932564,
-0.2853604853,
-0.5104589462,
0.1443480998,
-0.6841009259,
0.8595673442,
0.3798229098,
-0.4079005718,
-0.2207588404,
-0.377971828,
0.6860830188,
0.6055490375,
-0.5797317624,
-0.0283734743,
0.2509336472,
0.3030738831,
0.2573001981,
0.5514552593,
-0.1393610686,
0.3514339924,
-0.3312347233,
-0.1982848942,
-0.1472827792,
-0.1664273441,
-0.4275797606,
0.2984992564,
0.0910317153,
-0.0995510221
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03483v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03483v1
|
SWAG: Storytelling With Action Guidance
| 2024-02-05T19:55:06 | 2024-02-05T19:55:06 |
Zeeshan Patel, Karim El-Refai, Jonathan Pei, Tianle Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Automated long-form story generation typically employs long-context large
language models (LLMs) for one-shot creation, which can produce cohesive but
not necessarily engaging content. We introduce Storytelling With Action
Guidance (SWAG), a novel approach to storytelling with LLMs. Our approach
reduces story writing to a search problem through a two-model feedback loop:
one LLM generates story content, and another auxiliary LLM is used to choose
the next best "action" to steer the story's future direction. Our results show
that SWAG can substantially outperform previous end-to-end story generation
techniques when evaluated by GPT-4 and through human evaluation, and our SWAG
pipeline using only open-source models surpasses GPT-3.5-Turbo.
|
[
-0.1213093027,
-0.8516116142,
0.4926002622,
0.353779912,
-0.4414003491,
0.273722738,
-0.0825621933,
-0.4904488623,
0.2844924927,
0.4573272467,
-1.0331642628,
-0.7015988827,
-0.2657979727,
-0.1172622517,
-0.3920573294,
1.377814889,
-0.2023741901,
0.0602440275,
-0.2144503891,
-0.1037411019,
-0.6123042703,
-0.3787322342,
-0.5684447885,
-0.3593637943,
0.8887391686,
0.2637066245,
0.6991338134,
0.3660774529,
0.4658893049,
0.1524833292,
-0.0538633764,
0.1781632453,
-0.5904988647,
0.4394774139,
-0.2526937127,
-0.2368233502,
-0.487403065,
-0.1708083451,
0.2414551079,
0.3798323572,
-0.3499533534,
0.4558552206,
-0.1569981575,
0.5622552037,
-0.3786040843,
-0.59297508,
-0.1623624265,
-0.0544946268,
-0.027706081,
-0.3162677884,
-0.2620282769,
-0.4127752185,
0.2416366786,
-0.3699831367,
0.4212780893,
0.4293502569,
0.6222577691,
-0.0858566463,
-0.3827161789,
-0.7753101587,
-0.9414345026,
0.6780674458,
-0.626996398,
-0.1935551316,
0.2410271764,
0.3074476123,
-0.3922926486,
-0.8483422399,
-0.4774440229,
0.0726629496,
0.1498531848,
0.0711943507,
0.0134678232,
0.0334544107,
-0.0663708821,
0.1621049643,
-0.7559143305,
0.2682324052,
-0.6490185857,
0.2123655826,
1.0031613111,
0.355748415,
0.0786162913,
-0.1339219958,
-0.9079281092,
-0.0054004262,
-0.8716312647,
0.1652417481,
0.5025788546,
0.1407371163,
0.0449884832,
0.5937827229,
0.2535668015,
0.4428531229,
0.0045534302,
-0.4016449749,
-0.1977184862,
-0.3570394516,
-0.243470192,
0.1846053898,
0.6053944826,
0.6559815407,
0.0578492545,
0.0806752294,
-0.3352002203,
-0.2273588628,
0.3964685798,
-0.7754990458,
0.152051568,
0.3018636107,
-0.5343381166,
-0.6294366717,
-0.0888132229,
-0.4755571783,
-0.690987885,
-0.3077721894,
0.4481159449,
-0.4439361095,
-0.174719736,
-0.0549247488,
-0.6603043675,
0.5965836048,
0.4679497182,
-0.8354180455,
-0.1843129396,
0.7557331324,
1.0588468313,
-0.5111124516,
-0.3743613064,
-0.4186755717,
0.5932457447,
-0.6392983198,
1.0582082272,
-0.514559865,
-0.6467499137,
0.1787390411,
-0.4281808734,
0.5233752728,
-0.110783942,
0.4755439162,
-0.199975878,
0.3065603077,
-0.2325028032,
-0.5682247877,
-0.224932164,
0.0899450034,
-0.2537870407,
0.9180060029,
0.2162593007,
-0.3218846619,
0.9110329747,
-0.7442079782,
-0.7410348654,
0.422950983,
-0.2733371854,
-0.2264886647,
0.3681294918,
0.1611639261,
0.3279513121,
-0.2940819263,
0.727730155,
-0.1342867166,
-0.5422770381,
-0.1431351155,
-0.304548651,
0.479376018,
0.1047671884,
-0.2865427136,
0.429982543,
-0.6045414209,
-0.1673661917,
0.3578365445,
-0.4247936606,
-0.1118236706,
0.057474114,
0.0022733693,
0.2271327972,
0.0263895784,
-0.2841210961,
0.5607312322,
-0.1856110841,
0.2771025598,
0.8546987176,
0.111196734,
0.4630126953,
-0.419772476,
0.997943759,
-0.1893504858,
0.0773313567,
-0.6852383614,
-0.5734627843,
-0.6973835826,
0.0365258753,
-0.006123201,
0.1830212474,
-0.6390601993,
0.3304727077,
0.0402787291,
-0.6034334302,
-0.378623873,
0.2295983583,
0.2502112687,
0.35169819,
0.1187614575,
-0.2136146873,
-0.550948143,
-0.4756038785,
-0.2003561258,
-0.252807349,
-0.0538728796,
0.0746884197,
0.3870793283,
-0.1452219784,
0.9278296232,
-0.5248688459,
-0.2657518983,
-0.8503662348,
0.7427010536,
0.2059613615,
0.1923968047,
0.6078380942,
-0.5340441465,
-0.3235218823,
-0.0984853208,
-0.6102845073,
-0.0701864064,
-0.3188935816,
-0.0605095737,
0.5215342641,
0.27508232,
-0.6264491677,
0.8987070918,
0.5041524768,
-0.7318574786,
0.69010216,
-0.1720948517,
0.0982812271,
-0.8695598841,
0.1336325854,
-0.1469509006,
-0.1300834268,
-0.7257772088,
-0.0170182735,
-0.2628640532,
-0.4020965099,
-0.5526964068,
0.9269404411,
-0.4188067913,
-0.2235437781,
-0.4286811352,
0.1905792952,
0.1650988311,
0.6084273458,
0.1459013671,
0.5323585272,
0.4544396102,
-0.7095754743,
0.5333484411,
0.3642003536,
-0.2167555094,
0.6772449017,
-0.5177555084,
0.0760488138,
-0.3616526127,
0.6488531828,
-0.9940559864,
-0.3782246113,
-0.2003973275,
-0.4103495777,
0.2026637644,
-0.0971177742,
-0.4855933487,
-0.6950475574,
-0.4779548049,
0.0027492656,
0.6477886438,
-0.8300173879,
0.590531528,
-0.0378195792,
-0.4684034586,
-0.3550599813,
-0.6917296648,
0.0874323025,
-0.4150969982,
-0.7830501795,
0.1734292656,
-0.2244025618,
-0.0980017409,
-0.4358725846,
-0.1633538157,
-0.0278401598,
-0.1834666282,
0.2731719315,
0.3185083866,
-0.2335274965,
0.3150063455,
0.2493918538,
0.1353415251,
-0.1000764966,
0.1834488362,
0.4843135476,
0.0441809744,
-0.3613055944,
-0.0219014771,
0.8067151308,
0.3777868748,
-0.0010438029,
0.3885334134,
0.8949812055,
0.0937684253,
-0.5609537959,
-0.2941412628,
0.0805282816,
-0.5507627726,
0.1352178454,
0.0424212739,
-0.5938741565,
0.2361592501,
-0.1527530849,
0.5918647647,
0.1489374042,
0.5080701113,
-0.3052269518,
1.268184185,
0.8171246052,
0.3418639004,
0.5659267902,
-0.0178389698,
0.3887444139,
-0.4335550666,
-0.3747364581,
-0.1180993244,
-0.7140343785,
-0.0020569633,
-0.3535652161,
0.2783684134,
0.7808876038,
-0.1904404312,
0.2854954898,
-0.6309857965,
0.620285213,
0.678090632,
-0.3667229116,
0.438213706,
-0.1845746189,
0.0419663899,
0.1941555738,
-0.8172076941,
-0.6147750616,
0.9546841979,
0.4608255029,
0.974273026,
0.2618781626,
0.8802422881,
0.2749796212,
0.3060521483,
-0.8783842921,
0.6466110945,
-0.0207020584,
-0.5131810308,
-0.3057944477,
0.2966561615,
-0.9127138257,
0.1198840588,
-0.2199682891,
-0.4970169067,
-0.0400643498,
0.1533554047,
-0.3997076154,
0.096431233,
-0.8764660358,
0.274966538,
-0.6624253392,
-0.2391303778,
-0.1295581013,
-0.6515125036,
0.2603715658,
0.1709078103,
0.0120775085,
-0.1300002038,
-0.0775386915,
0.6192366481,
-0.3926084936,
0.843398869,
-0.2944812477,
-0.2779800594,
0.7752359509,
0.1949149966,
0.7568743825,
-0.0076408917,
0.1054119021,
0.0066149151,
-0.3960992694,
-0.1758188456,
-0.498174578,
0.5852560997,
-0.1443981826,
-0.7615668178,
-0.3786114752,
-0.6064740419,
0.0492912866,
0.2817017138,
0.4333788157,
0.4424668252,
-0.4981173575,
-0.0551823676,
0.2271415591,
-0.3150528967,
1.1185694933,
0.4914524555,
-0.5602490306,
-0.3647437692,
0.5704709888,
-0.0546909235,
0.1281841546,
-0.2305478603,
0.3491132557,
-0.1953642964,
-0.7317243218,
-0.789262116,
0.1797933728,
-0.7629534602,
-0.4532046616,
-0.3132835925,
-0.1206766218,
-0.4023834765,
-0.9584708214,
-0.0393348373,
-0.2686727047,
-0.238282159,
-0.408587724,
0.464089632,
1.2557213306,
0.1381144524,
0.2619251013,
-0.7180773616,
0.183418721,
0.254190594,
0.25670439,
-0.2291623354,
-0.1659981906,
-0.0333307646,
-0.2832183242,
-0.7182461023,
-0.6341897845,
0.4707228839,
0.2231481373,
0.3983249068,
0.3758838773,
-0.0901058391,
0.9989911318,
-0.6121196747,
1.3297470808,
0.6773888469,
-0.7738489509,
0.9429317713,
-0.6962496042,
0.6703764796,
0.1860465258,
0.3322100043,
-0.3258346915,
-0.4064620733,
-0.7339608669,
-1.0281683207,
0.653362155,
0.0104306536,
0.1360576153,
-0.1549060047,
0.1063303724,
0.3857680857,
0.4855481982,
-0.5252929926,
0.0667843297,
-0.2018264383,
-0.0158493668,
-0.0065984414,
-0.1103812382,
-0.3561880291,
-0.1088694185,
0.378688097,
-0.2580724359,
0.2861873209,
0.1663836241,
0.023272017,
-0.4606413245,
0.2438911498,
0.991861999,
0.9906663299,
-0.0094111525,
-0.2391165793,
0.1972146332,
-0.3099476993,
-0.0875429437,
-0.4722194672,
0.0340905711,
0.308273375,
0.5422566533,
1.053263545,
0.1555419266,
-0.9082576036,
0.8640995026,
0.145298779,
-0.5599745512,
-0.3004811704,
0.2580407858,
0.1181915924,
0.4651372433,
0.5947852135,
-0.1179723293,
-0.0720551535,
-0.6543666124,
0.101730302,
0.33729738,
-0.2019631565,
-0.2942516208,
0.475025177,
0.6277450323,
-0.6146360636,
0.117514953,
-0.1103603169,
-0.1532900184,
0.5305657387,
0.9882899523,
0.9728058577,
-0.186841324,
0.5243317485,
0.2567520738,
-0.0003090813,
-0.2241318822,
0.1508596838,
-0.0624564141,
-0.0772227943,
-0.5316807628,
-0.8408135772,
-0.5248941779,
0.1372128874,
-0.6442332864,
0.8265935183,
-0.3849138021,
0.1513078809,
-0.2945844531,
-0.241197139,
-0.4342745841,
0.175074771,
0.244633168,
0.8884500861,
-0.4791171551,
0.5728417039,
0.6200731993,
-0.2992478907,
-0.6686789393,
-0.0856201872,
0.0336073488,
-0.7148203254,
0.4366055429,
0.2522911429,
-0.3122820556,
-0.2624124289,
-0.815312624,
-0.7095829248,
1.6301894188,
0.0896127373,
-0.6531845927,
-0.6096402407,
-0.2925302088,
0.7436714172,
-0.7123783827,
-0.1826152056,
0.4957566857,
0.3033033907,
0.7199876308,
-0.6296054125,
-0.1491588205,
0.049421493,
0.095686473,
0.3415729105,
-0.5194827318,
0.5432895422,
-0.6337263584,
-0.407379061,
0.1162393689,
0.6639783978,
0.6326958537,
0.6588953137,
0.1778504997,
0.1763726175,
0.6903601289,
0.2154804021,
1.0892226696,
0.0868890584,
0.0772268772,
1.1736952066,
-0.3257522583,
0.8572805524,
0.4518078268,
0.2505017817,
0.7907642126,
0.3897515237,
-0.0266272686,
0.5585797429,
0.1927596331,
-0.1752961129,
-0.0278775059,
0.0326783136,
-0.1656152755,
0.4668716192,
0.178831026,
-0.4823343158,
-0.2930686474,
0.1257106215,
0.1427580267,
-0.0092541408,
-0.6266144514,
0.9361367226,
0.0243845154,
-0.9859913588,
0.5138731003,
-0.225854516,
0.8178427815,
-0.8448992968,
-0.2236420512,
-0.2022257596,
-0.3536419272,
-0.1953805983,
-0.9091439247,
0.2124877423,
0.3141356409,
-0.006685555,
-0.5103993416,
1.0008797646,
-0.6126164198,
-0.4352242649,
0.0846589953,
0.3303349912,
-0.0934540853,
0.4331060648,
-0.6117324829,
-0.1362498999,
-0.1491963118,
-0.5714941025,
0.2649078369,
0.3845511079,
-0.1614107788,
0.6900188327,
0.5771898031,
0.0710819215,
-0.0950270519,
0.1452732086,
0.732534945,
-1.027638793,
-0.7616416216,
-0.6208693385,
0.846734643,
-0.1297995001,
-0.6958666444,
0.5718940496,
0.1754950583,
0.3720208108,
0.0255028456,
0.9041196108,
-0.2226152122,
0.3301340342,
-0.4375215769,
0.5609478951,
-0.2814797759,
0.1505157799,
-0.1940329373,
-0.923519671,
-0.3200538754,
0.3581604064,
0.0697266012,
0.0504551157,
0.8461844921,
0.5861580372,
0.2577540874,
0.1102889404,
0.3476469815,
-0.3057780564,
0.4594998062,
0.2208231539,
0.8627017736,
-0.0719362348,
0.7992730737,
0.2940541506,
-0.1563972533,
-0.2721421421,
-1.1267206669,
-1.2427235842,
-0.4818349183,
-0.1049546823,
-0.1642614156,
-0.0245923717,
0.7056435347,
0.725725472,
-0.2821772993,
-0.182082057,
-0.3075889349,
0.0611540861,
-0.2384787947,
-0.2236977518,
-0.0726856962,
-0.3995107412,
-0.4647709429,
0.795724988,
0.5099096894,
0.1263740659,
-0.5816229582,
-0.2947358191,
-0.0687552989,
0.4760971069,
0.8648286462,
0.0984468237,
-0.7825673223,
-0.2955240607,
-0.3440111578,
0.0797417834,
0.0350009874,
1.2612802982,
-0.6410787106,
0.1705071628,
0.5215545893,
0.2076105773,
0.5432391167,
0.3184426725,
1.0760643482,
-1.0747849941,
-0.0179564767,
0.4000298083,
0.0202188045,
0.1286514997,
-0.5361528993,
0.6552987099,
-0.1377927661,
-0.7485400438,
-0.8309540749,
0.5000882745,
-0.967985034,
-0.4816161692,
1.6772021055,
0.1106370091,
-0.333945334,
-0.0287422501,
-0.5663452148,
-0.0374667533,
-0.5253117085,
0.3357248902,
0.7864921093,
-0.5408326983,
-0.1060973704,
-0.3207122087,
0.5595587492,
0.1419201642,
-0.7627974153,
0.135413602,
0.6757906079,
0.1488026679,
0.0768280029,
0.5961357951,
0.0879500583,
0.4384052753,
0.0908067301,
0.1132639721,
-0.3077512085,
-0.5801155567,
-0.4229322076,
0.1973148584,
0.0747211203,
0.2682269514
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.07927v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.07927v1
|
A Systematic Survey of Prompt Engineering in Large Language Models: Techniques and Applications
| 2024-02-05T19:49:13 | 2024-02-05T19:49:13 |
Pranab Sahoo, Ayush Kumar Singh, Sriparna Saha, Vinija Jain, Samrat Mondal, Aman Chadha
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Prompt engineering has emerged as an indispensable technique for extending
the capabilities of large language models (LLMs) and vision-language models
(VLMs). This approach leverages task-specific instructions, known as prompts,
to enhance model efficacy without modifying the core model parameters. Rather
than updating the model parameters, prompts allow seamless integration of
pre-trained models into downstream tasks by eliciting desired model behaviors
solely based on the given prompt. Prompts can be natural language instructions
that provide context to guide the model or learned vector representations that
activate relevant knowledge. This burgeoning field has enabled success across
various applications, from question-answering to commonsense reasoning.
However, there remains a lack of systematic organization and understanding of
the diverse prompt engineering methods and techniques. This survey paper
addresses the gap by providing a structured overview of recent advancements in
prompt engineering, categorized by application area. For each prompting
approach, we provide a summary detailing the prompting methodology, its
applications, the models involved, and the datasets utilized. We also delve
into the strengths and limitations of each approach and include a taxonomy
diagram and table summarizing datasets, models, and critical points of each
prompting technique. This systematic analysis enables a better understanding of
this rapidly developing field and facilitates future research by illuminating
open challenges and opportunities for prompt engineering.
|
[
-0.496465534,
-0.9991860986,
0.9488068819,
0.5573419929,
0.2001686096,
0.0137306629,
-0.1640879661,
-0.1591489762,
-0.1866793931,
0.256741643,
-1.0196510553,
-0.4080638587,
-0.066110678,
0.3319304883,
-0.1616585404,
0.4952329397,
-0.2052706331,
0.2363020778,
-0.096154131,
0.2966306508,
-1.0791021585,
-0.4308183491,
-0.5593178272,
0.134342581,
0.794075191,
0.4390386343,
0.1872302145,
0.3315232992,
0.2490445673,
0.2996791303,
-0.4165251553,
0.0810944363,
-0.0439388193,
0.3965284824,
-0.0897756666,
-0.2021569163,
-0.1853176355,
0.1420049667,
0.6089708805,
0.9894455671,
0.1805449873,
0.3257496655,
0.2656361461,
0.4205247462,
-0.8195466995,
0.1948294789,
-0.3636807501,
-0.0307110194,
-0.1913572401,
-0.4180054665,
-0.70226717,
-0.4952791333,
0.1714298129,
-0.3826680481,
0.038948644,
0.3395472765,
0.4461814165,
0.0676742941,
-0.3315371275,
-0.4904281497,
-0.491992563,
1.1046646833,
-0.5743732452,
0.1918565929,
-0.0003623502,
0.5645794868,
-0.3863128722,
-0.5835970044,
-0.2603360415,
-0.5266020894,
-0.1185916662,
-0.0004752759,
-0.0522684902,
0.424179852,
0.566821754,
0.0301150233,
-0.78896451,
0.5885942578,
-0.1534899771,
-0.2907426655,
0.3867031634,
0.3333494067,
0.6578021646,
-0.294370234,
-0.4766293168,
0.0641773716,
-0.7273703218,
0.4252046347,
0.0726562738,
0.5455025434,
-0.0337174684,
0.530618608,
-0.465743959,
1.000222683,
-0.1915675998,
0.0508636273,
-0.0602527075,
-0.5456500053,
-0.1284948587,
0.0782876387,
0.7844489813,
0.3319501579,
0.1252288222,
0.173858434,
-0.5027242899,
-0.2386054695,
0.0044916845,
-0.4793303907,
0.208755061,
0.1913393289,
-0.51478374,
-0.2417447269,
-0.3419865072,
-0.6805061698,
-0.6516201496,
-0.5664422512,
0.1328177601,
-0.1096243337,
-0.1126450002,
0.0211336054,
-0.2114025056,
0.57064569,
0.5023955107,
-0.8300619721,
-0.171472922,
0.8172832727,
0.9293305278,
-0.0932131112,
-0.302931428,
-0.6612411141,
-0.3417857885,
-0.4749834836,
0.8000274301,
-0.5896776319,
-0.6139727235,
0.3269225657,
-0.0883098468,
-0.0355470777,
-0.2652374506,
0.7500553727,
-0.6888387799,
0.1923392713,
-0.5641143918,
-0.3777477741,
-0.2668959498,
0.2718827724,
-0.4837966263,
0.8281781673,
-0.1339177638,
-0.5176135302,
0.0830131546,
-0.8175779581,
-0.1115420908,
0.108012937,
-0.1343538612,
0.2488014996,
0.2984697521,
0.4558833539,
0.6797301769,
-0.6027470827,
0.399885416,
-0.083367236,
-0.1480065733,
0.2040940821,
-0.4161556959,
1.0383741856,
0.287763834,
0.0513099618,
0.4804284573,
-0.4916063547,
-0.0821981356,
-0.0193035062,
0.2005329877,
-0.326107651,
-0.2722839415,
-0.0125538493,
0.1698812097,
0.377168119,
-0.2466420084,
0.4755873084,
-0.2990766466,
0.4440112412,
0.881106317,
0.268047452,
0.6370389462,
-0.1999245882,
0.8418982029,
-0.4272049069,
0.3470681906,
-0.8805206418,
-0.6316910982,
-0.4071113467,
-0.2682495713,
-0.0178991016,
0.6948191524,
-0.802447319,
0.1424667686,
0.0962705165,
-0.5219949484,
-0.3353472054,
-0.0471607894,
0.0997799262,
0.798800528,
0.2905183136,
0.2546123564,
-0.4786749482,
-0.9118052721,
-0.2091318518,
-0.2231317759,
-0.1145688668,
0.1319505423,
0.0289072897,
0.0008084856,
1.1878299713,
-0.3821145892,
0.2689957619,
-0.4324128628,
0.2249985039,
0.567224443,
0.3958720863,
0.7326661348,
-0.5934019685,
-0.4259333611,
-0.114159368,
-0.8790893555,
-0.6115742922,
-0.3623119891,
-0.1012254879,
-0.1348778456,
0.6800864339,
-0.7431288362,
0.0446753278,
0.3904660344,
-0.1870842278,
0.9360134602,
0.2106956542,
0.4473855793,
-0.8516082764,
0.0817685723,
0.1321296841,
0.1233945787,
-0.9046205878,
0.2810356021,
0.1157069653,
-0.341658026,
-0.5916356444,
0.94683218,
-0.9089273214,
0.2059615552,
-0.5009703636,
0.0570704155,
-0.1287305653,
0.2354034185,
-0.0626550466,
0.972723186,
1.0515303612,
-0.8854551315,
0.6150929928,
0.2521220744,
-0.2439285815,
0.4984966516,
-0.8508046865,
0.0308512263,
-0.2633259594,
-0.05048104,
-1.206972599,
-0.1907196641,
0.440900445,
-0.3792863488,
0.2653048635,
-0.1501797438,
-0.3642882109,
-0.5098579526,
-0.3246293962,
0.2849487364,
0.795524776,
-0.5265398622,
0.5522717237,
-0.0607100725,
-0.8120618463,
-0.4078285992,
-0.2825306654,
0.289103657,
-0.1814936996,
-0.8038902283,
-0.0243497584,
-0.204893887,
-0.4468015432,
-0.3864583075,
-0.0130993864,
-0.0603052787,
0.2705820501,
0.0150446724,
0.6106801033,
-0.3123154342,
0.0664196014,
0.1316853315,
-0.2596531212,
0.3059279025,
-0.0495980307,
0.5056436062,
0.2033623606,
-0.4130674601,
-0.5697153807,
0.4650877714,
0.3665278256,
-0.4311314523,
0.4234997034,
0.1680058986,
-0.1971443444,
-0.2938309312,
-0.5871166587,
-0.4218120277,
-0.5673536658,
0.1835323274,
-0.3933877051,
-0.8940341473,
0.4238454103,
-0.366951555,
0.533728838,
0.1559571624,
0.3506547809,
-0.1230519786,
1.0049169064,
0.7657966614,
0.0421091989,
0.7081412673,
0.2366486639,
0.1776473671,
-0.6177611351,
-0.1545882076,
-0.9063735604,
-0.1308215261,
-0.2184499055,
-0.3738792539,
0.348969698,
0.1513139904,
-0.013077667,
0.0420105234,
-0.4793697,
0.3125040829,
0.3672643602,
-0.3720936179,
0.0511915758,
-0.1034866944,
0.000332885,
-0.0024759721,
-0.7352889776,
-0.6811951399,
0.5290546417,
0.3827630579,
0.7643821239,
-0.2915052772,
0.5327478051,
0.3077313006,
0.1759510636,
-1.0706892014,
0.8794674873,
0.4983710051,
-0.3113866746,
-0.4737759233,
-0.3528611362,
-0.8916358948,
-0.0467777103,
0.0851970911,
-0.6876373291,
0.2846594453,
0.2144841105,
-0.4853489399,
-0.1657660156,
-0.8328190446,
0.8720633984,
-0.2378674448,
-0.0247262996,
0.096335873,
-0.6022144556,
0.4900132716,
-0.0073977611,
0.2820750177,
0.0287342854,
-0.1626188904,
0.4967801273,
-0.3918633759,
0.9266111255,
-0.3843582273,
-0.5080922842,
0.5530995727,
0.0372282602,
0.8022258878,
-0.2148076594,
-0.1093597114,
-0.1485758275,
-0.3319300115,
-0.2841152847,
-0.7854468226,
0.640876174,
-0.1389952302,
-0.7807866335,
-0.2100877762,
-0.4436453879,
-0.5198197961,
0.2082155645,
0.0714887157,
0.4554564357,
-0.0279693604,
-0.235544458,
0.8654063344,
-0.5228424668,
0.799343586,
0.3762953281,
-0.2862254679,
-0.1568765044,
0.7268131375,
-0.0010799671,
0.2663004994,
0.3705876768,
0.0964375883,
-0.3479703069,
-0.7184000015,
-0.552092433,
0.1851067692,
-0.6984776855,
-0.0169718862,
-0.6931982636,
-0.1437679976,
-0.5635261536,
-0.4993045032,
-0.023035882,
-0.1348169297,
-0.2153202742,
-0.1306795776,
0.4181117117,
0.7477412224,
0.4006945491,
0.3677105606,
-1.0031871796,
0.1767394692,
0.3518702388,
0.0693709478,
0.2104798853,
-0.3513332009,
0.1057702601,
-0.0183749273,
0.109141916,
-1.1769958735,
0.1361164749,
-0.2443184704,
0.9266428947,
0.2187094539,
0.213104099,
0.5066085458,
-0.6745877862,
1.0998468399,
0.279037416,
-0.902967155,
0.78667593,
-0.3633816838,
0.4021092355,
0.3051840067,
0.5148158669,
-0.8102522492,
-0.066462107,
-0.036919158,
-0.9061869383,
0.5654357672,
-0.2248957604,
0.2224241644,
0.1689029634,
0.3493463993,
0.1005974635,
0.0962369889,
-0.1344308257,
-0.1495525688,
0.1789399534,
-0.2772633135,
0.1568157077,
-0.3386823237,
0.079917714,
0.2092831135,
0.6325881481,
-0.1877965033,
-0.0004741184,
0.0937106535,
-0.1933192462,
0.346642226,
0.5031017065,
0.6396932006,
0.5875899196,
0.2494756281,
-0.2564754486,
0.2248191237,
-0.3262966275,
0.2605168223,
0.0917023793,
-0.6126499772,
0.1425393224,
0.3318990171,
0.7906727791,
0.0459418781,
-0.6891670227,
0.440190345,
-0.0261895675,
0.1255806983,
0.0571838915,
-0.0361952558,
-0.1474262923,
0.1529276818,
0.5302348137,
0.0017847588,
0.4218456447,
-0.3146166205,
-0.19854711,
0.437304467,
-0.5950554013,
-0.3718621135,
0.4604717493,
0.4165441692,
-0.2127025276,
0.4608845711,
-0.0018765433,
-0.0152267599,
0.5142410398,
0.2347630709,
1.1423950195,
-0.2924694121,
0.3082811832,
0.4118941724,
0.4221226871,
-0.1573809981,
0.3232637048,
-0.1089444458,
-0.284285605,
-0.8281646371,
-0.5505837202,
-0.4646432698,
-0.0822775811,
-0.336746186,
0.4225135148,
-0.4206205308,
-0.1256119609,
-0.188284412,
-0.5091680884,
-0.5082629919,
-0.1450361311,
0.2764984667,
1.3914263248,
-0.775688231,
0.0932438299,
1.031406641,
-0.2460531294,
-0.9688550234,
-0.0968726724,
0.2915751934,
-0.6344940066,
0.6546273828,
0.3565785885,
0.0562008619,
0.1299933791,
-0.8170834184,
-0.6790512204,
0.7720650434,
0.1776760221,
-0.7232738733,
-0.3138344586,
-0.1360063702,
0.1887920797,
-0.1464153826,
0.4336969852,
0.2398521453,
0.5863346457,
0.0538795926,
-0.9018619657,
0.2667446434,
-0.2699538171,
0.2908700705,
0.0387349874,
-0.344778806,
0.5126253963,
-0.2373471558,
-0.5212835073,
0.4537063539,
0.7206860781,
0.6209913492,
0.3746233582,
0.4546135664,
-0.2874193788,
0.7264970541,
-0.1233732849,
0.9443032146,
-0.3336648941,
-0.0376763567,
0.7229859233,
-0.4683818519,
0.3455441296,
0.5635765195,
0.014281095,
0.1242431104,
0.8495436311,
0.1522944421,
0.2159845084,
0.1866364628,
-0.27091524,
-0.3140458465,
-0.6291183233,
-0.4169890583,
-0.034978997,
0.2671514452,
-0.255934298,
-0.3755660057,
0.4287065268,
-0.2377986014,
-0.1247853115,
-0.6714363098,
0.6931478381,
0.2412293553,
-0.6369813681,
0.3282785416,
-0.190697372,
0.709767282,
-0.7661398053,
-0.0885524452,
-0.1683507413,
-0.5956627131,
0.0639089197,
-0.8658795357,
-0.090595603,
0.196326375,
-0.1980062872,
-0.8487464786,
0.7508320808,
0.038572561,
-0.1868869662,
-0.1346441656,
0.5978372693,
0.0107906479,
-0.117402412,
-0.548258543,
0.1387423873,
-0.1964979172,
-0.4385888577,
-0.1766954064,
0.7022804618,
-0.2581943572,
0.7974577546,
0.7845605016,
0.0984635949,
0.1982988864,
0.2925378978,
0.8728693128,
-0.8342030644,
-0.4635394514,
-0.9205364585,
0.8264547586,
-0.0008088095,
-0.255600512,
1.0237976313,
0.3092779815,
0.3630085588,
-0.3260010183,
0.9633172154,
-0.0280262511,
0.5175309777,
-0.7910798788,
0.3859660625,
-0.2833585143,
0.2191959769,
-0.3013625443,
-0.9835830331,
-0.3346098959,
0.0677997768,
-0.3651650846,
0.005900166,
0.3924220502,
0.9780912995,
0.2537561655,
0.0047334661,
0.255885601,
0.2275249064,
0.3381162882,
0.2667602897,
1.4200142622,
0.1270716935,
0.2771188319,
0.1699700207,
-0.5244879127,
-0.2070765793,
-0.7465487719,
-0.9319556952,
-0.476881355,
-0.2428014874,
0.0424889475,
-0.0164670348,
1.0283290148,
0.5126780272,
-0.664087832,
-0.0598976538,
-0.1582951397,
0.2443045229,
-0.239278838,
-0.2260847986,
0.0057838266,
-0.8328334093,
-0.7349473834,
0.7322442532,
0.3959392011,
0.1522571743,
-0.4471439719,
0.1494981945,
0.0311444849,
0.0389112309,
0.6670466661,
0.4828672111,
-0.5797922015,
0.0540730394,
0.6799548864,
-0.1822709739,
-0.3547959328,
1.1097477674,
-0.6637856364,
0.3363543153,
0.9877169728,
0.8292814493,
-0.3482133448,
-0.1338270903,
0.7908489108,
-0.5887008905,
-0.039995674,
0.3022127151,
0.4141034782,
0.3013748825,
-0.2985006273,
0.1286575347,
0.0971546993,
-0.5012856722,
-0.9333662391,
0.5087736845,
-1.0639953613,
-0.3260453343,
1.2011104822,
0.1565766484,
-0.2891676724,
-0.2116398215,
-0.7479804158,
-0.0535536632,
-0.4187011719,
0.4217905402,
0.6805642843,
0.0086667081,
-0.4650291204,
-0.8043746352,
0.3451196849,
0.405370146,
-0.8108774424,
0.1901217401,
0.8142433763,
-0.0824249387,
0.1148389876,
0.4319337904,
0.185530588,
0.3026864827,
-0.31153211,
0.1299494505,
0.000459641,
-0.3716605902,
-0.5617215633,
0.3407777846,
0.2370391339,
-0.0111588873
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03477v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03477v1
|
Arabic Synonym BERT-based Adversarial Examples for Text Classification
| 2024-02-05T19:39:07 | 2024-02-05T19:39:07 |
Norah Alshahrani, Saied Alshahrani, Esma Wali, Jeanna Matthews
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Text classification systems have been proven vulnerable to adversarial text
examples, modified versions of the original text examples that are often
unnoticed by human eyes, yet can force text classification models to alter
their classification. Often, research works quantifying the impact of
adversarial text attacks have been applied only to models trained in English.
In this paper, we introduce the first word-level study of adversarial attacks
in Arabic. Specifically, we use a synonym (word-level) attack using a Masked
Language Modeling (MLM) task with a BERT model in a black-box setting to assess
the robustness of the state-of-the-art text classification models to
adversarial attacks in Arabic. To evaluate the grammatical and semantic
similarities of the newly produced adversarial examples using our synonym
BERT-based attack, we invite four human evaluators to assess and compare the
produced adversarial examples with their original examples. We also study the
transferability of these newly produced Arabic adversarial examples to various
models and investigate the effectiveness of defense mechanisms against these
adversarial examples on the BERT models. We find that fine-tuned BERT models
were more susceptible to our synonym attacks than the other Deep Neural
Networks (DNN) models like WordCNN and WordLSTM we trained. We also find that
fine-tuned BERT models were more susceptible to transferred attacks. We,
lastly, find that fine-tuned BERT models successfully regain at least 2% in
accuracy after applying adversarial training as an initial defense mechanism.
|
[
-0.3644883633,
-1.0495311022,
0.09914653,
-0.1297264099,
-0.2603238225,
0.0110534942,
0.1010458693,
-0.4915473163,
-0.0847207978,
0.4975151122,
-0.4022005498,
-0.425516665,
-1.0390509367,
-0.0365987644,
-0.8680584431,
1.1818284988,
-0.0473869257,
0.1851801276,
0.2512418926,
-0.1349580139,
-0.4093821943,
-0.8472825289,
-0.6589641571,
-0.1283347309,
0.5874171257,
-0.1495405436,
1.0845820904,
0.1932424456,
0.6124827266,
0.3814685345,
-0.1441239417,
-0.2060819864,
-0.3933811486,
0.0102171954,
-0.0679116473,
-0.3304436803,
-0.0850199461,
0.0561427884,
0.4736397862,
0.535515368,
0.0148170181,
-0.0407053232,
0.0367737785,
0.702981174,
-0.5632824898,
-0.316860795,
-1.2680449486,
0.0691011846,
-0.061103493,
0.2311173677,
-0.2591472566,
-0.4080299139,
0.2687873542,
-0.0449186936,
0.1752424389,
-0.1105263457,
1.0808421373,
0.167317912,
-0.429572016,
-0.7366803288,
-0.4652434289,
0.723590374,
-0.8618249297,
-0.0028088314,
0.140713498,
0.5289677382,
-0.4802319705,
-0.7558426261,
-0.9097642899,
-0.5168060064,
0.0842039213,
-0.0735757276,
-0.6998926401,
0.0563122779,
-0.0508343726,
0.1666502953,
-0.4916019738,
0.0740527809,
-0.0597474426,
-0.3826982975,
0.564050734,
-0.0389650352,
0.5756031871,
0.0059359632,
-0.7251644135,
-0.2766930163,
-0.7358770967,
-0.0831907094,
0.5653265119,
0.1935359985,
0.1580701917,
0.4155686498,
0.0794483125,
0.7624896765,
-0.3269073665,
-0.0250722561,
-0.3560933471,
-0.1129306108,
-0.1356324255,
0.2370281219,
0.5636820197,
0.3160772622,
0.2585104108,
-0.4155804813,
-0.3719308674,
0.3167571723,
0.6768890619,
-0.853695631,
-0.3443729579,
-0.0542531759,
-0.5721465945,
-0.6126672029,
0.1648649424,
-0.4251179397,
-0.4875689149,
0.1560521126,
1.0248893499,
-0.6284174919,
0.1598979533,
-0.0034873334,
-0.2417183816,
0.2374590188,
0.2969953716,
-0.4986732304,
0.4894985855,
0.8285625577,
0.6552385092,
-0.0892166942,
-0.3513939679,
-0.1345169097,
-0.1993022561,
-0.4734679461,
0.3328957856,
0.0247020982,
-0.4154227376,
0.3072420955,
-0.2878538072,
0.1565989256,
-0.501938343,
0.7299519777,
-0.8722797036,
0.279595226,
0.0027851397,
-0.7828299403,
-0.6416586637,
0.497115761,
-0.5789148808,
0.7208728194,
0.007854348,
-0.8702687621,
0.0958949849,
-0.4865309,
-0.6525194049,
0.0997766852,
0.0333081409,
-0.5832329392,
0.0521111712,
-0.0640201345,
0.4939191043,
-0.011319451,
-0.19730407,
-0.3022440374,
-0.3766357303,
0.6641075611,
-0.6319152713,
0.9773952961,
0.2179067731,
-0.604249239,
0.0489234738,
-0.4972840846,
0.1374838203,
0.2697968483,
-0.0257063266,
-0.5197396874,
0.0244643856,
0.1328597069,
0.2972384393,
0.3909943402,
-0.6652243733,
0.220163852,
-0.6474120021,
0.2629529238,
0.7679160833,
0.026634533,
-0.1118848324,
-0.5948489904,
0.3875858784,
-0.0325284749,
0.0266649406,
0.1990081668,
-0.4016592503,
-0.7475693226,
-0.3037452102,
0.4944236577,
0.5389714837,
-0.9010691643,
0.5687040687,
-0.171549961,
-0.7502513528,
-0.6029800773,
0.0847234502,
0.4593396485,
0.2958158553,
0.2950737774,
-0.1927405298,
-0.3374507427,
-1.0538631678,
-0.5159859061,
-0.2243551165,
0.0433197767,
0.2916890979,
0.7985405922,
-0.307693243,
0.7619171143,
-0.3292581141,
-0.2417336851,
-0.344435066,
0.3751915097,
-0.0319204964,
0.2505680025,
0.9037553072,
-0.8668707609,
-0.5261279345,
-0.2118526548,
-0.4668533504,
0.1087414846,
-0.110615924,
-0.2244275957,
0.2218065411,
0.2177944928,
-0.342333883,
0.6324155927,
0.5886821747,
-0.49473086,
0.5638197064,
-0.120762758,
0.04128078,
-1.168125391,
-0.1270060986,
-0.3400848508,
-0.2020132691,
-0.9904240966,
0.5397875309,
-0.0108467173,
-0.1724005938,
-0.6194901466,
0.6469075084,
0.0630791187,
0.1432959139,
-0.5352743864,
-0.1504300088,
-0.1281796396,
0.2463924289,
-0.3752602339,
0.8717848063,
0.5483490229,
-0.5234827995,
0.5125488639,
0.2931487858,
-0.5699439049,
0.2033660114,
-0.8190968633,
0.1519269645,
0.0862820894,
0.1026489288,
-1.0632373095,
0.3063934445,
0.3802906573,
-0.5191480517,
0.586895287,
0.1792132258,
-0.5337662101,
-0.1751083732,
-0.482100606,
0.0515196696,
0.6493137479,
-0.7650510669,
0.3146113157,
0.0692164749,
-0.2405102253,
-0.6877438426,
-0.5748228431,
0.5123981237,
-0.2777493298,
-0.3833181858,
0.5281319022,
0.1257847548,
-0.1730310619,
-0.0183026046,
-0.1005924046,
-0.2194408327,
0.6396152377,
0.3076021671,
0.2327752113,
-0.0079931151,
-0.1988067627,
-0.1081584767,
0.388127327,
0.2846187055,
-0.088755317,
0.5111478567,
-0.1027209982,
-0.3849892318,
-0.548631072,
0.4553974569,
0.5497214794,
0.0117007941,
1.2262890339,
0.7231045365,
-0.6648301482,
-0.1036197245,
-0.415535897,
-0.255284816,
-0.4703963995,
0.744887054,
-0.3042068183,
-0.6443657279,
0.3621237278,
0.1576642841,
0.0014204591,
0.5184118152,
0.5601146817,
-0.1216628402,
1.0495436192,
0.4985554218,
-0.6085557342,
0.2474715859,
-0.1625373513,
0.14275904,
-0.3715444803,
0.0709459707,
-0.5262074471,
-0.3923775554,
-0.6276541352,
-0.0106053008,
0.2438451201,
0.2178154737,
-0.2650612593,
0.467042774,
-0.165065974,
0.0444936454,
0.556394279,
0.2036594003,
-0.2093382627,
0.3520008922,
-0.1934802085,
-0.0454588346,
-0.6986315846,
-0.6405010223,
0.9691692591,
0.4456268549,
0.6590663195,
0.5536941886,
0.7668395638,
0.8571203947,
0.5996400118,
-0.7440091372,
0.6765755415,
-0.4249220788,
-0.6165715456,
-0.0381225049,
-0.355754137,
-1.0651336908,
0.0883764178,
-0.3258683681,
-0.6499257684,
-0.2236863077,
-0.1311602294,
-0.0494157486,
0.4623379111,
-0.4862573147,
0.8761723638,
-0.4223148525,
0.058725439,
-0.2378380299,
-0.5282533169,
0.1844926476,
-0.2470600158,
0.0762539729,
0.2978437543,
-0.0139988111,
0.8253353834,
-0.5142562389,
0.7165507078,
-0.1214949489,
-0.2288853228,
0.2096774727,
0.2693137228,
0.4302794635,
-0.3822107613,
0.0173951238,
0.5601145625,
-0.0906746313,
-0.6848227978,
-0.6537210941,
0.7060168386,
-0.9197487831,
-0.6544083953,
-0.670327127,
-0.4768359959,
0.1083440781,
0.1383652091,
0.2344953865,
0.3838925064,
-0.4782840908,
0.0297798757,
0.2489680499,
-0.3978069723,
0.4116513431,
0.6244949698,
0.0075726458,
-0.3925567567,
1.1086497307,
-0.1647251099,
0.2314292938,
0.4550953209,
-0.0416430682,
-0.3587725759,
-0.8048772216,
-0.5735936165,
-0.1970850527,
-0.6017957926,
-0.3372581303,
-0.3301007748,
-0.4414991736,
-0.3749377131,
-0.2096877098,
-0.08094614,
-0.3734023869,
0.0035716654,
0.3769334853,
0.3181777894,
0.8417406082,
0.3537140787,
0.4346647263,
-0.6910244823,
0.1363935322,
0.5927271843,
-0.1086828932,
0.1235750169,
-0.6223089695,
-0.2992916107,
0.3449900448,
-0.6327094436,
-1.2505452633,
0.4435019791,
0.2523795962,
0.4127173722,
0.5440688133,
0.1971907616,
0.3266227543,
-0.6271185875,
0.9096157551,
0.1208972484,
-0.9426385164,
0.3819669783,
-0.004890372,
0.1057818532,
0.392813623,
0.4780291021,
-0.3229175806,
-0.3929159343,
-0.6158029437,
-0.5760360956,
0.4499599636,
0.6082206368,
0.2062208503,
-0.0547992513,
0.3288772106,
0.0627319366,
0.4305370748,
-0.6617571115,
-0.669878006,
-0.3308908343,
-0.2071811259,
-0.0627300218,
-0.3100685179,
-0.1850121468,
-0.0840407237,
0.8478448987,
0.3219221234,
0.3100247383,
0.0575213134,
-0.2924210131,
0.3996725082,
0.4391690493,
0.5797672868,
0.1461979002,
-0.1225628704,
0.1797870398,
0.375126332,
-0.6220631599,
0.3725492656,
0.5568644404,
-0.359189868,
0.1669601947,
0.5569381118,
0.5425038934,
0.1513166726,
-0.686488986,
0.5596069098,
-0.1832110435,
-0.2147227377,
-0.2643673122,
-0.0844522268,
-0.223418355,
0.0857874006,
0.3361376524,
0.0195732899,
0.243410036,
-0.6218397617,
0.2721331418,
1.077129364,
-0.4532905519,
0.1339643151,
0.3269472122,
-0.0239400417,
-0.5107344389,
0.4009455442,
-0.2589175105,
-1.3671536446,
0.6831700206,
0.4641341567,
0.7191201448,
-0.3558016419,
0.0067874985,
-0.1370080113,
0.4338054359,
0.3140813112,
0.1791987866,
-0.023899572,
-0.7328913808,
0.2036052197,
-0.6488710642,
-0.3496665955,
0.3260880411,
-0.7238829136,
-0.1166571155,
-0.5426825285,
-0.1846942604,
0.1090970114,
0.2432284057,
-0.4917748272,
0.2220227122,
0.1889366508,
0.9462046623,
-0.5677011609,
0.895350337,
0.9320559502,
-0.054624971,
-0.4419169724,
0.2166754007,
-0.2022634298,
-0.7700645924,
0.7957112789,
0.2439620495,
-0.2354038209,
-0.1087687165,
-0.3080342412,
-0.4784739912,
0.7230079174,
0.1162080616,
-0.183939144,
0.2764372826,
0.2721621394,
0.5569132566,
-0.1284640878,
0.068165943,
0.3168205321,
0.1615848243,
-0.283904165,
-0.5851560831,
0.0816916004,
-0.1604363322,
0.057056427,
0.3724428117,
-0.2729563415,
0.78033638,
-0.0098021682,
-0.2010025084,
0.6949919462,
0.7217915654,
-0.2631779909,
0.1829264015,
0.6004838347,
0.8495681882,
0.1884602308,
-0.0045325076,
1.0438836813,
-0.5491248369,
0.2116275728,
0.8457461596,
-0.1947395205,
0.9578116536,
0.1742214561,
-0.3371678591,
0.6023883224,
0.3602286577,
-0.1599424183,
0.7151386738,
0.531080246,
-0.6011108756,
0.1506290436,
-0.1093310416,
-0.626770854,
0.4664256573,
0.3055789769,
-0.3941422105,
-0.4078187048,
0.2307629138,
0.2098272443,
0.3044203222,
-0.4164138734,
0.8665177822,
-0.1613090485,
-0.384934932,
0.8424226642,
0.4867300093,
0.7504575849,
-0.7882267833,
0.0348964743,
0.0430009402,
0.3574364483,
0.2957643569,
-0.4135136008,
0.1243654862,
0.213343218,
-0.0004382162,
0.0533320829,
0.7195931673,
-0.3806360662,
-0.6974030733,
0.1515144855,
0.2097286135,
0.136585772,
-0.2226641029,
-1.0169233084,
-0.2358181477,
-0.0938065276,
0.1258160621,
0.616353035,
0.1308203787,
0.1941868365,
0.6200279593,
0.472224772,
0.3428619504,
-0.0299910177,
-0.1377757043,
0.820723176,
-0.5567384958,
-0.375939846,
-1.1467506886,
-0.1494826525,
-0.0955367684,
-0.0421803184,
1.0164881945,
0.3985005617,
0.7343921661,
-0.104802765,
0.6968173981,
0.1467394382,
0.5058611035,
-0.3683350384,
1.1695559025,
-0.5964369178,
0.1507306546,
-0.3813200891,
-0.5855928063,
-0.0094508501,
0.5791621208,
-0.0290243346,
0.0103199454,
0.4804515243,
0.7367534041,
0.2526368201,
0.005804969,
0.3659701049,
0.3520192206,
0.2633818686,
0.5472711921,
0.9039866328,
-0.7684525847,
0.6317389011,
-0.3336410522,
-0.1618939638,
-0.2923652828,
-0.8080037832,
-1.2005667686,
-0.4213227332,
-0.2712884545,
-0.5631052256,
0.6539775729,
0.824688375,
0.4453567266,
-0.9843475819,
-0.0107829152,
-0.0444558375,
0.2057792544,
-0.1632088572,
-0.253079623,
0.6348980665,
-0.0847854987,
-0.3802818358,
0.2095915526,
-0.2398110777,
0.4590043724,
-0.2810737789,
0.1385932565,
-0.2553505599,
0.1959780008,
0.5231434703,
0.118018195,
-0.953191638,
-0.4371785522,
-0.3103512228,
-0.3268667459,
-0.6036831141,
0.4853131473,
-0.8127972484,
0.3451288342,
0.0027897307,
1.0505722761,
-0.268546313,
-0.0528621674,
0.4032928646,
-0.7506167889,
0.2527781427,
0.2637659609,
0.3854104578,
0.3088074625,
-0.1829839945,
-0.0100474097,
0.0050509879,
-0.292330265,
-0.7780693769,
0.5159110427,
-0.7110178471,
-0.5739482045,
0.8405015469,
-0.549125433,
0.0725460425,
-0.014831569,
-0.4607667923,
0.2907084823,
-0.1439598799,
1.3768442869,
0.9519967437,
0.4765940309,
0.3739394546,
-0.3391672373,
0.5011255145,
0.7920883298,
-0.5614962578,
-0.3492988646,
0.0025383837,
-0.0411485136,
0.023386104,
-0.2776245177,
0.2562150955,
0.3345739245,
-0.0009758135,
-0.078526929,
-0.1660376787,
-0.1174940318,
-0.5567301512,
0.2027671337,
0.1292077303,
-0.476898104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03435v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03435v1
|
Psychological Assessments with Large Language Models: A Privacy-Focused and Cost-Effective Approach
| 2024-02-05T19:00:02 | 2024-02-05T19:00:02 |
Sergi Blanco-Cuaresma
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
This study explores the use of Large Language Models (LLMs) to analyze text
comments from Reddit users, aiming to achieve two primary objectives: firstly,
to pinpoint critical excerpts that support a predefined psychological
assessment of suicidal risk; and secondly, to summarize the material to
substantiate the preassigned suicidal risk level. The work is circumscribed to
the use of "open-source" LLMs that can be run locally, thereby enhancing data
privacy. Furthermore, it prioritizes models with low computational
requirements, making it accessible to both individuals and institutions
operating on limited computing budgets. The implemented strategy only relies on
a carefully crafted prompt and a grammar to guide the LLM's text completion.
Despite its simplicity, the evaluation metrics show outstanding results, making
it a valuable privacy-focused and cost-effective approach. This work is part of
the Computational Linguistics and Clinical Psychology (CLPsych) 2024 shared
task.
|
[
-0.3145986795,
-0.6773399115,
0.9692511559,
0.7257022262,
-0.1012242436,
-0.2109055817,
-0.5927770138,
-0.5432187915,
0.0843249932,
0.4613621533,
-0.7448778749,
-0.6305548549,
-0.7591705918,
0.3906641603,
-0.3987176716,
0.9235467315,
-0.1454687715,
0.1042349115,
-0.0729578435,
0.2972760201,
-0.0629148036,
-0.5924438834,
-0.7232105136,
0.013149336,
0.9872495532,
0.1347201765,
0.6289997697,
0.3262152672,
0.821436882,
0.2550326288,
-0.0953531638,
-0.316591531,
-0.5617480278,
0.1951624155,
-0.17981942,
-0.1595820487,
-0.4949397147,
0.1199637726,
0.4310929477,
0.5849887133,
-0.1990455538,
0.505081892,
0.1334395111,
0.7401994467,
-0.9728910327,
0.1760052145,
-0.216962114,
0.1352101564,
-0.0125175333,
0.1394646317,
-0.5340265632,
-0.7986957431,
0.1988982409,
-0.2341856211,
-0.2611049116,
-0.4732222557,
0.3292112648,
0.2264945805,
-0.3041561842,
-0.2409076095,
-0.5786799192,
0.8863219023,
-0.7240112424,
0.40667817,
0.5467293262,
-0.0122261299,
-0.0811065286,
-0.5493534207,
-0.2273392975,
-0.2018939108,
-0.3146345913,
0.1000844091,
-0.4283540547,
0.2197994143,
0.3452038169,
0.3075076938,
-0.5364770889,
0.1228142679,
-0.3241991699,
-0.2814711034,
1.0207544565,
0.3383474648,
0.2280289978,
-0.1492315531,
-0.1388731748,
0.2393742353,
-0.4467141926,
-0.1046373472,
0.4835279584,
0.2933999598,
-0.2990703285,
0.7406432033,
-0.2324591726,
0.4566800296,
-0.2607200742,
-0.2200226635,
0.1807998121,
-0.2846880853,
-0.0908922851,
-0.2411055714,
1.2649228573,
0.7163617015,
0.5233358145,
-0.1293779612,
0.0920552909,
0.0641116947,
0.3686088324,
-0.877361238,
-0.1531196982,
0.5827946663,
-0.662574172,
-0.2915388048,
-0.3430236876,
-1.2759484053,
-0.7039686441,
-0.2557370365,
0.2404786199,
-0.1115146205,
-0.2387004048,
0.1370563507,
0.166009292,
-0.2524823248,
0.2044986039,
-0.6544507742,
0.4864270985,
0.6505672336,
1.1017984152,
-0.323349148,
-0.1626999825,
-0.1939642876,
-0.0162347537,
-0.1587701291,
0.5144853592,
-0.3830686212,
-0.4678493142,
0.3384738266,
0.01621872,
0.1123924777,
-0.0972840637,
0.7270287275,
-0.3292690516,
0.5325455666,
-0.186037764,
-0.4162767529,
-0.1376580596,
0.2377543002,
-0.6599521041,
0.8627494574,
-0.089449428,
-1.0477931499,
-0.1412667781,
-0.8541727662,
-0.3116417527,
0.0515026338,
-0.1304849386,
-0.3576008976,
0.2264864743,
-0.0473995879,
0.760358274,
-0.2286640108,
0.2855392992,
-0.4484465718,
-0.1166265607,
0.7184066176,
-0.3279914558,
0.7495133281,
0.2189477682,
-0.2863987684,
0.0260919798,
-0.6675658822,
0.1580363661,
0.0450596437,
-0.4819192886,
-0.4176817834,
0.0969643071,
0.1864271313,
0.0562395491,
0.8139849305,
-0.7365791798,
-0.2417075187,
-0.4219209552,
0.4132908881,
0.6177870035,
0.1819152981,
0.3093502223,
-0.1122177392,
0.7030186653,
-0.5991590023,
0.6575211287,
0.1717534065,
-0.3358907998,
-0.0675121993,
-0.7600879669,
-0.0011155749,
0.5118462443,
0.1766435802,
0.4339969754,
0.1360525936,
-0.6560556293,
-0.2355976999,
0.0991204977,
0.4171820581,
0.1905350685,
0.0612475798,
-0.1404799521,
-0.6613406539,
-0.9936292768,
-0.5012685657,
-0.1137263402,
-0.1431437433,
0.3256626427,
0.3973985016,
-0.3775678575,
0.7294185162,
-0.870634675,
-0.4022024274,
-0.1121479124,
0.0458496809,
0.1462748796,
0.1745183915,
0.2680194378,
-0.7174468637,
-0.7674772739,
-0.1616869569,
-0.8096524477,
-0.3516578078,
0.1167002022,
-0.1301115453,
-0.0898425207,
0.4141693413,
-0.7245895267,
0.5390962958,
0.7515736818,
-0.081649214,
0.545357585,
-0.1515317857,
-0.0519618541,
-0.8983166218,
0.2031589597,
0.1651641577,
-0.156637162,
-0.6183999777,
0.0660015345,
-0.1197525561,
-0.2343613952,
-0.3114641011,
0.3221558034,
-0.3967143893,
0.2533785999,
-0.3421785533,
0.3129192293,
-0.4250783026,
0.3389095962,
0.020080639,
0.717523694,
0.3493417501,
-0.1997032762,
-0.0762095377,
0.1656087041,
-0.2643398643,
0.2746703327,
-0.5558517575,
0.1464129984,
-0.1241476014,
0.0256262664,
-0.9977418184,
-0.5143197179,
0.1177960336,
-0.5749229789,
-0.2244551033,
0.3599354923,
-0.3819342554,
-0.1029105633,
-0.6736857891,
0.3075379133,
0.467902869,
-0.0088637611,
0.7317345142,
0.868127048,
-0.6535612941,
-0.4644286036,
-0.6891421676,
0.276309818,
-0.3934786618,
-0.2813418806,
0.0034522593,
-0.3526887298,
-0.5645052195,
-0.1234436184,
0.3104858398,
-0.2833614051,
0.3764005601,
0.6096538901,
0.1151617393,
0.1201636344,
0.0981749073,
-0.1514802575,
-0.0449182466,
0.5459355712,
0.1831082851,
0.6496759653,
-0.0807144791,
0.1211615726,
-0.7764083743,
0.8000137806,
0.5346226692,
-0.1197764277,
0.9278314114,
0.1397759467,
-0.5386821032,
-0.2636883259,
-0.5081555247,
-0.0618344136,
-0.4545399249,
0.372649312,
0.2074338645,
-1.1982114315,
0.4582200944,
-0.1726696938,
0.1636690646,
0.0898600444,
0.9804292917,
-0.2547822893,
1.0011297464,
0.830055356,
0.0185272861,
0.4935751259,
0.2730622292,
0.5755412579,
-0.6322440505,
-0.024578169,
-0.600122273,
-0.1038804799,
-0.6067044735,
-0.1467579007,
0.5031549335,
-0.2363904566,
-0.5030093789,
0.2107616663,
-0.5298451185,
0.5887107253,
0.2619814277,
0.3337347507,
0.3808811605,
0.0476743728,
0.3546598256,
-0.468505621,
-0.0095228432,
-0.7972409129,
1.2922673225,
0.6504251361,
0.7398064733,
0.2446308285,
0.7355325818,
0.3139784932,
0.6989428997,
-0.709797442,
0.7373851538,
-0.1520270109,
-0.7382232547,
-0.4190611243,
-0.4601515532,
-0.7046720982,
0.1220516264,
-0.0592820384,
-1.3417751789,
-0.0239653941,
-0.0585572831,
-0.3910750151,
-0.1637217551,
-0.6481779814,
0.7620130777,
-0.2829642892,
-0.2899782062,
-0.2734999657,
-0.6162119508,
0.6305819154,
-0.7126632333,
0.4176759422,
-0.1668622047,
-0.245303452,
1.1242040396,
-0.1733435839,
1.0461990833,
-0.1411833018,
-0.2304233611,
0.0426129475,
0.0791285485,
0.3570386767,
-0.0057718651,
-0.1890217066,
0.1833185405,
0.1066360474,
-0.0228992589,
-0.5274232626,
0.7674559355,
-0.8214654922,
-0.5764370561,
-0.3465206027,
-0.6430485249,
-0.3627262712,
0.3893218935,
0.0074492916,
-0.0804450065,
-0.295712024,
0.2146926373,
0.5328186154,
-0.3188370168,
0.1866610497,
0.7786408067,
-0.3534107804,
-0.7778884172,
0.4003525078,
-0.0141384071,
0.2806013823,
0.1338926852,
0.6034963727,
-0.3366734982,
-0.4834472835,
0.3950077891,
0.7422471046,
-0.8016931415,
0.017073229,
-0.7348416448,
-0.1908447444,
-0.3776829541,
-0.1774402112,
-0.3505140841,
-0.1093997136,
-0.2240058482,
-0.3609644175,
0.4547276795,
0.7054561377,
-0.2058502436,
0.5463193655,
-0.7102254629,
0.0348776802,
0.022782648,
0.42438519,
0.1342317462,
-0.1250044852,
-0.1571020335,
-0.2258965969,
-0.1879387647,
-1.1369755268,
0.2984922528,
-0.0947764888,
0.1722791046,
0.3389221132,
0.2667939663,
0.4700094461,
-0.4696027339,
0.8398550153,
0.4813001156,
-0.9713640213,
0.3321491778,
-0.5963665247,
-0.086490497,
1.0354939699,
0.8672625422,
-0.639547348,
-0.5030174851,
-0.2442022562,
-0.6227427125,
0.4884974957,
0.1968564838,
0.3605986536,
-0.0718410984,
0.4109112322,
-0.105064407,
0.2556541264,
-1.0588533878,
0.001567801,
0.4267146587,
-0.7336403728,
-0.1305862218,
-0.5308791399,
-0.5112591386,
-0.1636706889,
0.5208640099,
0.0403994694,
0.4000476599,
0.2100825012,
0.3108637333,
-0.2808538377,
0.2103591114,
0.4871505499,
0.7329269052,
-0.2449929416,
0.0732572675,
0.0591606162,
-0.7559517026,
0.1789842993,
0.0043355851,
-0.2590203285,
-0.1455793977,
0.307862848,
0.2238040715,
0.2033731341,
-1.0531849861,
0.8727104664,
-0.3327970803,
-0.3544507623,
-0.6256104708,
-0.1746690273,
0.4480550289,
0.4009771645,
-0.0702062696,
-0.3747954965,
0.0861253962,
-0.3133707941,
0.0901137516,
0.3318555355,
-0.4298294485,
-0.3542562425,
0.4427774251,
0.0247701276,
-0.6165497303,
0.206415087,
0.2320850492,
-0.4369791746,
0.1477704793,
0.2940146029,
1.1784158945,
-0.2041896731,
0.4856000245,
0.3293881118,
0.3320170045,
-0.2439523935,
0.5865225792,
-0.0039635259,
-0.3326098919,
-0.3803013265,
-0.7722242475,
-0.5394219756,
0.2469620556,
-0.698661983,
0.2399054915,
-0.7496657372,
-0.367128104,
-0.2443224937,
-0.081161879,
-0.2565638423,
0.1747056097,
0.1552829295,
0.8826189637,
-0.7543427944,
0.3987720609,
0.4037880898,
-0.3407976627,
-0.7911908031,
0.1126482412,
0.0837735832,
-0.5620760918,
0.5845989585,
0.1447336376,
-0.1585945487,
-0.3961032331,
-0.616902709,
-0.9214649796,
0.6349095702,
0.5338705182,
-0.688575685,
-0.154047668,
0.4698960185,
0.8636978865,
-0.1615407765,
0.1188808754,
0.5379925966,
0.6110838652,
-0.4219617844,
-0.8756396174,
0.1708698124,
-0.0247315522,
-0.3587806225,
0.3396490812,
-0.655955255,
0.8708504438,
0.1033627093,
-0.366554141,
0.1546206921,
0.4424056709,
0.1148601994,
0.1409915686,
0.3441419601,
0.3647326529,
0.8359094858,
0.4551976025,
0.8788402677,
-0.4542630315,
0.7409076095,
1.1651374102,
-0.4872203171,
1.1616734266,
0.4216288626,
-0.341814667,
0.3273603618,
0.4109896421,
0.1564545333,
0.5424553156,
0.3012781143,
-0.5218071938,
-0.109348014,
-0.2021980882,
0.037528526,
0.2253807485,
0.3349206448,
-0.7036058307,
-0.3018523753,
0.0960982889,
0.3637161553,
0.4236180186,
-0.0887848809,
0.8597890139,
0.381958425,
-0.5978910923,
0.1504283547,
-0.0340445675,
0.5157362223,
-0.7810761333,
0.3681180775,
-0.0548000671,
0.4895973802,
-0.3235911131,
-0.8064982891,
0.5228194594,
0.6954730153,
-0.0753925815,
-0.2746694684,
0.613419652,
-0.3344572186,
-0.7058789134,
0.6010639668,
0.3019899428,
0.2627670467,
-0.2826966941,
-0.6843591928,
0.224690944,
-0.043389719,
-0.5082036853,
0.4988071322,
0.1390822232,
0.065958187,
0.5127059817,
0.4726159573,
0.3945479095,
-0.1589540094,
-0.0691290721,
0.6945345402,
-0.7157881856,
-0.571505487,
-1.1405024529,
0.305516541,
-0.0660416558,
-0.4322530031,
0.9375301003,
0.4285759926,
0.5659853816,
0.0588059127,
0.8981842995,
0.1441696286,
0.766759336,
-0.2519466877,
0.9567894936,
-0.4325100183,
-0.1297507882,
-0.4716848433,
-0.7131147981,
-0.6566356421,
0.6449568868,
-0.6996157765,
-0.2693702281,
0.8520585895,
0.7958871722,
0.3767644763,
0.1699190289,
0.2481917739,
0.2894482911,
0.41902861,
0.665397346,
0.9817380905,
-0.179814145,
0.1830053777,
-0.3408582807,
-0.4187063277,
0.1818466485,
-0.9320625067,
-1.10321033,
-0.3433026075,
-0.4308704138,
-0.1922515631,
-0.2305709571,
0.8541381955,
0.1401346028,
-0.4709481001,
-0.4558065534,
0.1308782399,
-0.2782837749,
0.1716434956,
-0.1905402988,
0.3566963673,
0.0188256148,
-0.4654217958,
0.0783802122,
0.2869832218,
-0.4109785855,
-0.6987910867,
0.1055566296,
-0.1422788799,
0.2936272323,
0.6050124168,
0.0204608981,
-0.6667393446,
-0.2696094513,
-0.0272708759,
-0.2506279647,
-0.2425163835,
0.7396870255,
-0.1502365917,
0.1584300846,
0.5704153776,
0.7316678762,
0.1207842305,
0.1160969958,
0.5453377962,
-0.3025800884,
-0.1130399927,
0.2550512254,
0.2457826734,
0.2160725743,
-0.7816654444,
0.3744152188,
-0.1200082675,
-0.6959110498,
-1.1124154329,
0.031096369,
-0.9195986986,
-0.3738139868,
1.1036320925,
-0.3070054948,
-0.3801445961,
0.0456142463,
-0.389261663,
-0.1250787526,
-0.4162314534,
0.9735020995,
0.9155004621,
-0.1318306476,
-0.0418793671,
-0.660484612,
0.5779628158,
0.170241788,
-0.8708959222,
0.633666575,
0.4699912369,
0.4124645889,
0.2885915935,
0.7528877854,
-0.29178074,
0.1614055783,
-0.5223224759,
0.0429316573,
0.2141036838,
-0.2110497206,
-0.5561854839,
0.6185949445,
-0.1757811457,
0.1945709586
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03303v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03303v1
|
Nevermind: Instruction Override and Moderation in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-05T18:58:19 | 2024-02-05T18:58:19 |
Edward Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Given the impressive capabilities of recent Large Language Models (LLMs), we
investigate and benchmark the most popular proprietary and different sized open
source models on the task of explicit instruction following in conflicting
situations, e.g. overrides. These include the ability of the model to override
the knowledge within the weights of the model, the ability to override (or
moderate) extracted knowledge in the prompt, and lastly the ability to perform
a full jailbreak. Experimentation performed suggest several key findings to
improve instruction following - larger models perform the best in following
instructions that override internal and contextual instructions, and are
obedient, even to a fault. When scaling to longer contexts via rope scaling, a
significant buffer needs to be maintained from the edge of the perplexity cliff
in order to maintain instruction following capabilities. Finally, we observe
improving instruction following, and subsequently instruction
overrides/jailbreaks, is fundamentally at odds with the ability of a language
model to follow given safety filters or guidelines. Thus, we postulate the most
effective approach for safe, trustworthy AI should be dealt external to the LLM
itself.
|
[
-0.0571849495,
-0.797331214,
0.7239701748,
0.0121944314,
0.0188144185,
0.0561354421,
-0.212806195,
-0.5170143843,
-0.235288769,
0.7835147977,
-0.3776884973,
-0.4515075088,
-0.6714349985,
-0.2904185951,
-0.4775342643,
1.0748872757,
-0.336966753,
-0.0385163091,
-0.177279532,
-0.1391987056,
-0.6320585608,
-0.5259670019,
-0.3809576929,
-0.5567726493,
0.5575678945,
0.3098167181,
0.7273283005,
0.999119699,
0.2031479627,
0.3332595229,
-0.0981189087,
0.0372046083,
-0.7056598067,
0.3065924644,
-0.3046962619,
-0.5575129986,
-0.5564984679,
-0.0298251826,
0.659486413,
0.4897863269,
-0.2819086909,
-0.0800732821,
-0.0559665971,
0.6015505791,
-0.8277306557,
0.2258786112,
-0.637540102,
-0.1184218973,
0.0435703769,
0.0454595014,
-0.3693481088,
-0.5874275565,
-0.0574021041,
-0.4125409126,
-0.3194139004,
0.1153561622,
0.3774114549,
0.5993353128,
-0.4224738777,
-0.3852423429,
-0.5183393359,
0.875074625,
-0.6522088051,
0.4490041435,
0.6754223108,
0.0539858304,
-0.2755853534,
-0.5635453463,
-0.2794071138,
-0.5317581892,
0.1097460091,
-0.1818532795,
-0.2665964365,
0.2188619375,
0.5258167386,
0.2178294808,
-0.1897156537,
0.4430156052,
-0.3915585577,
0.1109589115,
0.4189584255,
0.1935139,
0.526047647,
0.0938719139,
-0.239642337,
0.0920423493,
-1.2895590067,
0.0182022825,
0.2456893921,
-0.0385735482,
-0.1200244576,
0.5012338758,
-0.2579926848,
0.7261090875,
-0.009741703,
0.1545650363,
0.1259701997,
-0.0794940516,
-0.2967861891,
0.2888592184,
0.6671455503,
0.3826676607,
0.215209648,
-0.3702225983,
-0.463927865,
-0.3742078543,
0.5181434751,
-0.9266677499,
-0.2938240469,
0.2078697085,
-0.1760331541,
-0.12124639,
-0.1848644465,
-0.4584929049,
-0.80112046,
-0.3413718045,
0.5529971719,
-0.5231123567,
-0.0163684506,
-0.0311608296,
0.2220757455,
0.3170136809,
0.3658362329,
-0.9437568784,
0.1775930077,
1.0717657804,
0.7367432117,
0.0291399248,
-0.253995955,
-0.628554523,
0.268032521,
-0.4940552115,
0.4313634038,
-0.496709466,
-0.433098346,
-0.0476491787,
-0.0462302528,
-0.250166297,
-0.4152411222,
0.4610597789,
-0.6020196676,
0.0672806427,
-0.2974733114,
-1.0782361031,
-0.4426604807,
0.1588177532,
-0.5171521902,
0.3378961384,
-0.1033812985,
-0.4413758516,
0.0427085422,
-0.6253988743,
-0.528139472,
-0.1164784208,
-0.1341215074,
-0.1510266811,
0.2325170934,
-0.0469577201,
0.1727861911,
-0.0589663647,
0.2504227757,
-0.4406968355,
-0.5368139148,
0.0546804033,
-0.6378089786,
1.0037631989,
-0.0976909697,
-0.6896516085,
0.3829554617,
-0.4219845831,
0.1010705754,
0.017705366,
-0.0519963652,
-0.5051382184,
0.2213366479,
-0.4490010738,
-0.0637474135,
0.3327350914,
-0.6460194588,
0.345294565,
-0.1827524602,
0.8845713139,
1.0129272938,
-0.0899682269,
0.4459768534,
-0.4840143621,
0.4296088219,
-0.5404413939,
0.3500359356,
-0.6004109383,
-0.4630588889,
-0.5217752457,
-0.1124188751,
0.0585111901,
0.715698421,
-0.3953156769,
0.2956387401,
-0.0138126044,
-0.5045571923,
-0.60002774,
0.3942789137,
0.7462474704,
0.5092173815,
0.3961665034,
-0.2741167545,
-0.3166109324,
-0.5617543459,
-0.1958146542,
-0.3493806124,
0.0522489808,
0.2909792364,
0.3054302931,
-0.218925789,
0.6129137874,
-0.4909119308,
-0.1599557549,
-0.0594852567,
0.0473308265,
0.1417488307,
0.6575784087,
0.5113321543,
-0.6181445718,
-0.3724787235,
-0.0163775943,
-0.8196713924,
-0.1708534658,
0.0704487413,
0.0756289214,
0.5861487985,
1.0116387606,
-0.6624094844,
0.2725337744,
0.3811280131,
-0.0969208702,
0.5888701677,
-0.5066581368,
0.1596140265,
-0.6417589784,
0.0890828967,
-0.2814176083,
-0.2106736898,
-0.5697824955,
0.6887857318,
0.3547076583,
0.3672587574,
-0.3496513367,
0.5872445107,
-0.3456259072,
0.2134220004,
-0.2829079926,
0.1366274208,
-0.1382545829,
0.4268528223,
-0.1427960694,
0.8330072165,
0.5565978289,
-0.1653480828,
0.3956409395,
0.0081954114,
-0.4296167791,
0.2970667183,
-0.8538432121,
0.4597918391,
-0.1292814761,
0.1945251375,
-1.0653550625,
-0.1716264784,
0.2630929649,
-0.1626164615,
0.6017636657,
-0.4376363158,
-0.6756827831,
-0.2376276851,
-0.4097217321,
0.0551282652,
0.7261876464,
-0.365377903,
0.4580002427,
0.2994901836,
-0.0480608083,
-0.6710909009,
-0.6455170512,
0.0462939069,
-0.1203869283,
-0.071012944,
0.1378616542,
-0.3768061697,
-0.2903324068,
-0.1071284711,
-0.3712064922,
-0.2928986847,
0.2079861611,
0.7063158751,
0.2853343189,
-0.29275769,
-0.0198264997,
0.1402644813,
0.1887492537,
0.3717376888,
-0.2461591065,
0.3671491146,
-0.0567893796,
-0.5480713248,
-0.5027527213,
0.1281523556,
0.7775806785,
-0.1029319316,
0.9401710033,
0.3318813741,
-0.0774863809,
0.0061336532,
-0.6357049942,
-0.1894434839,
-0.5167040825,
0.3294035494,
-0.0145452647,
-0.9941795468,
0.4561849535,
0.2138896734,
0.4719367623,
-0.0181753617,
0.3010167181,
-0.1710481793,
0.9959459901,
0.8330748677,
-0.5638290048,
0.7215405107,
-0.0267058369,
0.355802834,
-0.7070167661,
-0.1835249662,
-0.5680162907,
-0.1478029191,
-0.6479224563,
-0.4220793545,
0.0736274272,
0.2739427686,
-0.4749841392,
0.3903122246,
-0.0330307968,
0.7420849204,
0.4901500642,
0.1835480034,
0.2277345806,
-0.1323020458,
-0.0531759299,
0.2497996986,
-0.7963423729,
-0.3200685382,
1.1648285389,
0.3234378397,
0.914794445,
0.0999335721,
0.6118637919,
0.3057681918,
0.5990039706,
-0.7184536457,
0.5101810694,
-0.2799066007,
-0.6658539176,
-0.1805016994,
-0.6360364556,
-0.6088315845,
-0.0615417995,
0.0248751175,
-0.9928969741,
-0.3366831243,
0.3196810186,
-0.5319436789,
0.6832460165,
-0.9583039284,
0.7764011025,
-0.1408360004,
-0.4458729625,
-0.4177157581,
-0.7580808997,
0.4632472098,
-0.265301615,
0.234070912,
0.2936261892,
-0.1752719134,
0.3133861423,
-0.1872713566,
1.0899250507,
0.0032271112,
-0.3480228484,
0.183580339,
0.3185734153,
0.4792017937,
-0.3404724896,
-0.0892366469,
0.2368920147,
-0.247496888,
-0.3279976249,
-0.6839361787,
1.0703605413,
-1.0233584642,
-1.101675868,
0.1045505553,
-0.6303821802,
-0.131650418,
0.4627710581,
0.1399769336,
0.6393831968,
0.0584881008,
0.3429996967,
1.0299006701,
-0.3092076182,
0.5200505257,
0.5590497851,
-0.3324244618,
-0.2491917908,
0.8404185176,
0.3379743099,
0.5185959339,
0.3821267188,
0.1212015077,
-0.3682773709,
-0.4903931916,
-0.6515340805,
0.0797802806,
-0.6690677404,
-0.1305510849,
-0.7296002507,
-0.4421952367,
-0.3034621179,
-0.2567439675,
-0.4542605579,
-0.3292517066,
-0.1719129235,
-0.0818745047,
0.4112731814,
1.1289823055,
0.0330438353,
0.2746580839,
-0.8347078562,
0.0725592598,
0.2972527742,
0.5683481693,
0.2352221906,
-0.7173079252,
0.0143144401,
0.0146936784,
-0.4538684785,
-0.6915050149,
-0.1868332922,
-0.0711149722,
0.8088262677,
0.6864936948,
0.2857816517,
0.5072549582,
-0.67837888,
0.5345434546,
0.1576921493,
-1.0607925653,
0.2274280488,
-0.3948910832,
0.3394396603,
0.2822340131,
0.558449626,
-0.565890193,
-0.6057875156,
-0.398058027,
-1.0007929802,
0.6866502762,
0.1228069887,
0.4261128604,
0.23914361,
0.3964122534,
0.0668786317,
0.4861002564,
-0.5165799856,
-0.3016209304,
-0.1021379381,
-0.0382160917,
-0.1581883281,
-0.2910774052,
-0.1537632644,
-0.0545146652,
0.6318551898,
0.2534950376,
-0.0173323192,
-0.1909861267,
-0.0768707022,
-0.4380642772,
0.2073658556,
0.856741786,
0.8740218282,
-0.1735824496,
-0.0000582188,
0.1957387328,
-0.2802633643,
-0.0134213306,
-0.0201956369,
-0.4701345265,
-0.4585095644,
0.6221504807,
0.8105095029,
0.264582485,
-0.8060160875,
0.2418328226,
0.1113265008,
0.0552596673,
-0.1287415773,
0.7042757869,
-0.0075070369,
0.2651503682,
0.2025673985,
0.0421051048,
-0.0673996359,
-0.6345888376,
0.2886327505,
0.3919521272,
-0.6952603459,
-0.1851504594,
0.6141228676,
-0.0499636941,
-0.5270184278,
0.7226509452,
0.0994303152,
-0.599622786,
0.6890301108,
0.3849405348,
0.7433695793,
-0.3966594636,
0.1156986877,
0.1094948351,
0.5720827579,
-0.1956160814,
-0.0929867476,
-0.20765616,
-0.5807740092,
-0.6136593223,
-0.028473936,
-0.6130133271,
0.2281641811,
-0.5377629995,
-0.1010612771,
-0.9010522366,
0.1554431021,
-0.1298060566,
-0.1281214505,
-0.0507682972,
-0.0381757431,
0.2390208989,
1.0550737381,
-0.5312116742,
1.0425559282,
0.7420874834,
-0.2077477276,
-0.8258008361,
0.1868146807,
0.3647619784,
-0.7649581432,
0.2525982559,
0.3944166601,
-0.197650522,
-0.1035672724,
-0.8322499394,
-0.6437157989,
0.7882747054,
0.3916002512,
-0.731979847,
0.0383250713,
-0.4660422504,
0.4889781177,
-0.1528609246,
0.2701245844,
0.4858137965,
0.314735651,
0.2454310954,
-0.8679260612,
-0.00142846,
0.0126849087,
-0.3611013591,
0.4587139189,
-0.6573578715,
0.7950525284,
-0.4717848301,
0.0948086306,
0.4249022603,
0.3646865189,
0.2528782189,
0.1535722613,
0.4343645871,
0.5506846905,
0.601413846,
0.2410172522,
1.028020978,
-0.3531031311,
0.1342120916,
1.61026752,
-0.3991569579,
0.8919866681,
0.3148012459,
0.1728414297,
0.4826830328,
0.2984946072,
0.1328537464,
0.4356062114,
0.1697476208,
0.0093488907,
-0.0880229399,
-0.1280487478,
-0.3604815006,
0.2456689775,
0.2739848793,
-0.3498494029,
-0.3790630996,
-0.2134095132,
0.497441113,
0.1151102483,
-0.566653192,
0.70070678,
0.1317626238,
-0.7567840219,
0.7097535729,
0.0025853848,
0.3356045485,
-0.517205894,
-0.1180113554,
-0.4083005488,
0.1694364995,
-0.0723197311,
-1.0347648859,
0.1666842103,
0.2521665394,
-0.135763675,
-0.4721567035,
0.3941093683,
-0.3225699067,
-0.0718764141,
0.5996117592,
0.1794275641,
0.1100243405,
-0.1259045303,
-0.7165122032,
0.2645075619,
0.1269374043,
-0.2694788575,
0.365601927,
0.4622503817,
-0.1870413572,
1.0131877661,
0.3762650192,
-0.0976029709,
0.16914469,
-0.0830277428,
0.9895741343,
-0.4814710021,
-0.3215475976,
-0.9416392446,
0.2268468142,
0.0453827418,
-0.1223728955,
0.8781431913,
0.1399517804,
0.9778398871,
0.2816183269,
0.5024588108,
-0.0947661027,
0.0821494684,
-0.4998754859,
1.0516630411,
-0.6331425905,
0.2592579126,
-0.2694395185,
-0.8299831748,
-0.2338778079,
0.4684049189,
-0.5932240486,
0.0918167308,
0.4572020471,
0.7673253417,
-0.0719465837,
0.224453643,
0.5055250525,
0.6953631043,
0.2098903805,
0.6298292875,
0.7515887022,
-0.0971510857,
0.4025826752,
-0.0146591906,
-0.227137208,
-0.16926983,
-0.828605175,
-0.9161654711,
-0.1956733316,
-0.3393959999,
-0.1933873147,
0.3595575988,
1.0869318247,
0.7522010803,
-0.9786846042,
-0.3195019066,
-0.2238556296,
0.6233306527,
-0.1224244907,
-0.0742985681,
0.046386905,
-0.3532505333,
-0.583917439,
0.5921096206,
0.3762171865,
-0.0605534576,
-0.4028825164,
-0.0224742219,
-0.0667281672,
0.1657852978,
0.5388700366,
0.4390904903,
-0.7519747615,
-0.3941921294,
-0.05839229,
-0.4187326729,
-0.1298712194,
0.7595486641,
-0.416177392,
0.4459477663,
0.3664760292,
0.6507020593,
-0.0087517137,
-0.1488092244,
0.7187182903,
-0.4473038614,
-0.0356994979,
-0.1253920346,
0.1769599915,
0.2179718614,
-0.3132012784,
0.2955801189,
-0.0576627515,
-0.7322062254,
-0.8020721078,
0.251036942,
-0.4290327728,
-0.5994901061,
0.9577679634,
-0.7162339687,
-0.3379480839,
-0.0556592867,
-0.1367560476,
0.0709124207,
-0.6179014444,
0.9747110009,
0.6633344889,
0.0449052975,
-0.4668739438,
-0.7888051271,
0.3890081346,
0.3635951877,
-0.4789578319,
0.2937920392,
0.568552196,
0.3930779099,
-0.0654037595,
0.3028184175,
0.076600261,
0.0590874813,
-0.2553851604,
-0.120574899,
-0.2037156373,
-0.6051161885,
-0.5206738114,
0.2537275851,
0.0507723577,
0.0275716912
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03300v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03300v3
|
DeepSeekMath: Pushing the Limits of Mathematical Reasoning in Open Language Models
| 2024-02-05T18:55:32 | 2024-04-27T15:25:53 |
Zhihong Shao, Peiyi Wang, Qihao Zhu, Runxin Xu, Junxiao Song, Xiao Bi, Haowei Zhang, Mingchuan Zhang, Y. K. Li, Y. Wu, Daya Guo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Mathematical reasoning poses a significant challenge for language models due
to its complex and structured nature. In this paper, we introduce DeepSeekMath
7B, which continues pre-training DeepSeek-Coder-Base-v1.5 7B with 120B
math-related tokens sourced from Common Crawl, together with natural language
and code data. DeepSeekMath 7B has achieved an impressive score of 51.7% on the
competition-level MATH benchmark without relying on external toolkits and
voting techniques, approaching the performance level of Gemini-Ultra and GPT-4.
Self-consistency over 64 samples from DeepSeekMath 7B achieves 60.9% on MATH.
The mathematical reasoning capability of DeepSeekMath is attributed to two key
factors: First, we harness the significant potential of publicly available web
data through a meticulously engineered data selection pipeline. Second, we
introduce Group Relative Policy Optimization (GRPO), a variant of Proximal
Policy Optimization (PPO), that enhances mathematical reasoning abilities while
concurrently optimizing the memory usage of PPO.
|
[
-0.4776721895,
-0.4962127209,
0.6639270782,
0.2836390734,
-0.2075046152,
0.0436592512,
-0.3351396322,
-0.1885192841,
-0.5499171019,
0.5045624375,
-0.6081171036,
-0.5128660798,
-0.5496913195,
-0.2781744003,
0.0808449164,
0.7877960801,
-0.1562462449,
0.0119159957,
-0.2475781292,
0.0526839234,
-0.2987327874,
-0.6431486011,
-0.4524227083,
-0.4201660156,
0.2454868853,
0.39444381,
0.9835856557,
0.307281673,
0.793654561,
0.2524663508,
0.1434697509,
0.087801151,
-0.4847367704,
0.1325049996,
-0.5051300526,
-0.4374317229,
-0.5096152425,
-0.0509495251,
0.3604225814,
0.5997325778,
-0.3155142367,
-0.0109177418,
-0.268288523,
0.8290536404,
-0.8196563125,
0.2586453557,
-0.665733397,
0.0353415385,
-0.3414819837,
0.4247435927,
-0.0668798536,
-0.6068938971,
0.2544905245,
-0.6220146418,
0.0359043144,
-0.3887993097,
0.6897200942,
0.2486605644,
-0.0408950448,
-0.4124409258,
-0.5637834072,
0.923389554,
-0.8152213693,
0.5035450459,
0.6868689656,
0.7445950508,
-0.1379097849,
-0.7401598096,
-0.5421981215,
-0.282507956,
0.3202747405,
0.0114146881,
-0.1927623302,
-0.0800803825,
0.2497777492,
0.508362174,
-0.4620946944,
-0.0730803385,
-0.5087730289,
-0.22422418,
0.6353042722,
0.0608784147,
0.1233354434,
0.1797387153,
0.071412392,
-0.1242839098,
-0.5590671301,
-0.0439504646,
0.5153135061,
0.1111175269,
0.0266769193,
0.5790758133,
-0.3777040541,
0.4362897277,
-0.4027466476,
0.1908414811,
0.3149226308,
-0.1989524513,
-0.3332343102,
0.0128542725,
0.6771614552,
0.0283924844,
0.669806838,
0.0489032678,
-0.1147726402,
0.5381120443,
0.096482195,
-0.8875866532,
-0.4950683713,
-0.0326120295,
-0.172323674,
-0.2268041819,
-0.026411308,
-0.9797623158,
-0.2745371759,
-0.6099467874,
0.2192770541,
-0.5898332596,
-0.332236141,
0.659427762,
0.1357136518,
-0.1094570979,
0.6052027941,
-0.738167882,
0.3110173643,
1.0866197348,
0.5515503287,
0.2250090688,
-0.2616716325,
-0.4303833842,
0.0229681507,
-0.4497000277,
0.6278019547,
-0.9934402704,
-0.252156049,
-0.1665304452,
-0.5776593685,
-0.0700237602,
-0.5818074346,
0.7655845284,
-0.281526804,
0.5085052848,
-0.0599277504,
-0.5960118771,
-0.2158618271,
0.279805541,
-0.3425943553,
0.8194007277,
0.2359115779,
-0.4015348256,
0.2482062727,
-0.8247038126,
-0.2549220324,
-0.0915875807,
-0.2821923792,
-0.2244537324,
0.4859205782,
0.4559403658,
0.2456956953,
-0.4882223904,
0.3125882149,
-0.655307889,
-0.152781114,
0.001942735,
-0.4477386475,
0.5142666101,
0.4455762804,
-0.2889977396,
0.0506660417,
-0.762329936,
0.1586602628,
0.328329891,
0.1343324184,
-0.4106652439,
-0.0439057462,
-0.628118217,
0.3651902378,
0.1412515938,
-0.3955236971,
0.4176890254,
-0.5109195709,
0.4716449082,
1.1017754078,
-0.3743866086,
0.3944960535,
0.1088975668,
0.6490123868,
-0.1469651908,
0.4757570326,
0.1499441117,
-0.549952209,
-0.4641706944,
-0.236120075,
0.3272022903,
0.3862709105,
-0.3899046481,
0.2352905869,
-0.1994127035,
-0.6297707558,
-0.708042264,
0.2116398215,
0.4253268242,
0.6765961647,
0.3445190489,
0.0494932607,
-0.2437024713,
-0.8581153154,
-0.3182583153,
0.1518658698,
-0.0505772345,
0.405072391,
0.3787423968,
-0.4342772663,
0.6889054775,
-0.8522521853,
-0.2970880866,
-0.1712916195,
-0.1946283728,
0.7183212638,
0.4009913206,
0.4370070696,
-0.6259573102,
-0.4445442855,
0.0326942243,
-0.6827194095,
-0.2632448375,
0.3083861172,
-0.4587369561,
0.0298462752,
0.3092763722,
-0.7460608482,
0.411264658,
0.6209512353,
-0.384652406,
0.611332655,
-0.1623100787,
-0.1669689864,
-0.7173980474,
-0.1253733933,
-0.2446807325,
0.1454305202,
-0.1813598871,
0.30567801,
-0.1525963694,
-0.3887888491,
-0.2284574658,
0.6195352674,
-0.1659005284,
0.1417575181,
-0.0426722504,
-0.1266639531,
-0.0916866213,
0.3787554502,
-0.3163401186,
0.894415319,
0.8645617366,
-0.6797097921,
0.5017982125,
0.0600722767,
-0.3735938072,
0.2821619213,
-0.6652801633,
0.3028829396,
0.0372362398,
0.0722888336,
-0.551471293,
-0.1155357808,
0.2043941617,
-0.5187842846,
0.110771507,
-0.2447976023,
-0.5556886196,
-0.4000794888,
-0.1240284219,
0.5079039335,
0.7777281404,
-0.4499372542,
0.6405869126,
0.2976975739,
-0.0917443857,
-0.3409087658,
-0.3415316343,
-0.24455899,
-0.1204044148,
-0.7725636959,
-0.0274281614,
-0.0536494851,
-0.4945912659,
0.2083423883,
-0.47900033,
0.0204140712,
-0.0305046104,
-0.0150294267,
0.1564012021,
-0.3668834567,
0.1013617367,
0.146120429,
-0.5469782948,
0.1829790026,
-0.6450899243,
0.8842156529,
-0.3375577629,
-0.5020204186,
-0.1616309434,
0.1774224192,
0.3515947759,
-0.43413499,
0.4635881484,
0.3132559657,
-0.4486297667,
0.0035177015,
-0.3488990068,
0.0449344479,
-0.496368289,
0.1966483146,
-0.8781791925,
-0.8103733659,
0.3207873404,
-0.3078539371,
0.0754073486,
0.8334963322,
0.5928505063,
0.2745310068,
1.2069098949,
0.2301906496,
-0.0976059213,
0.0356530771,
-0.1786943972,
0.2408912182,
-0.5714773536,
-0.2888863981,
-0.622631371,
-0.0577583723,
-0.4130009115,
-0.5240958929,
0.0980248153,
0.4668833315,
-0.573521018,
0.1511791945,
-0.5892606378,
0.729321301,
0.6943377852,
0.0187547263,
0.0331148133,
0.1707837433,
-0.4512559772,
-0.2499177456,
-0.376740694,
-0.3037716448,
1.1510235071,
0.3040811718,
0.973793745,
0.3263238072,
0.5934770703,
0.0861997381,
0.159708634,
-0.4407100976,
0.6286387444,
-0.3946824372,
-0.5790820718,
-0.2901316285,
-0.9004077911,
-0.8521513939,
0.2374143749,
0.1410096586,
-0.7354186773,
-0.1108220741,
0.2479122877,
-0.1665843874,
0.2205641419,
-0.7816212773,
0.9847661257,
-0.3676559627,
-0.3359448314,
-0.6390107274,
-0.2816063166,
0.3777881265,
-0.038073007,
0.3890657723,
-0.5702673793,
0.034286391,
0.2156287283,
-0.4978611469,
0.4008158743,
-0.257309854,
-0.2102202475,
0.203117311,
0.4716940522,
0.3969498575,
0.1516996324,
-0.0364615209,
0.4213360846,
-0.373251617,
-0.6138672829,
-0.7569665909,
0.8671123981,
-0.7925134897,
-0.6578295231,
-0.4356317222,
-0.278285116,
-0.519200325,
0.3434087634,
0.0508946255,
0.4940688014,
0.3500211239,
0.2864641547,
0.6234996915,
-0.3090059757,
0.1445078701,
-0.0149350511,
-0.4263174236,
-0.7466112971,
1.1317249537,
-0.178155005,
0.2365002781,
0.5340487957,
0.9115723968,
-0.611571312,
-0.4294328392,
-0.2418123633,
0.1458664238,
-0.6550254226,
-0.1968943179,
-0.4315543473,
-0.2687579095,
-0.7483407259,
-0.0841822401,
-0.536000669,
-0.5760778785,
0.0318414755,
0.0818136632,
0.167146951,
0.3265690506,
-0.2590593696,
0.1162335351,
-0.8010180593,
0.3658471406,
0.4335045815,
0.7236230373,
-0.0807209313,
-0.2642937601,
0.1491855979,
0.0646634772,
-0.1388424337,
-0.4575717747,
0.1288892478,
0.0337556861,
0.6793593764,
0.4353685677,
-0.0252698567,
0.8082438111,
-0.4915047586,
0.2709630728,
0.3820414245,
-0.8982973695,
0.8589993119,
-0.3455711901,
0.4319809079,
0.5726152658,
0.3095205426,
-0.1051978469,
-0.0005704362,
-0.6635125279,
-0.6345191002,
0.3361507952,
0.6220884919,
0.2942921519,
0.1820982099,
0.2061197311,
0.1585510373,
0.3295467198,
-0.1101693287,
0.2155563235,
-0.4074677229,
-0.39153409,
-0.096020788,
-0.1771093011,
-0.0723303854,
-0.5766832829,
0.5420057774,
-0.0971668363,
0.0404758304,
0.0562525168,
0.0475940295,
0.2163727283,
0.2365663648,
0.9674286246,
1.1823197603,
-0.1866271347,
0.0865319297,
-0.1767400354,
-0.7316771746,
-0.1854200512,
0.5615276098,
0.0365335681,
-0.2254169732,
0.3537424207,
0.8032904863,
0.0482835956,
-0.8136446476,
0.1385823786,
-0.0457852744,
-0.2721694112,
-0.1826706082,
0.3149277568,
-0.2081598639,
0.2675046027,
0.2712162137,
-0.1325471252,
0.0579725765,
-0.3960638642,
0.1865564734,
0.220538646,
-0.2306639552,
-0.2800801098,
0.6715608835,
0.1417983323,
-0.2346746027,
0.6817889214,
-0.0944340825,
-0.7708297372,
0.3790726364,
0.3160204887,
0.9079250097,
-0.2920131087,
-0.0812061429,
0.1902360171,
0.3255724311,
0.0946140736,
0.432091713,
0.0228835996,
-0.6172079444,
-0.6825079322,
-0.7968071699,
-0.4651968777,
0.1322748363,
-0.2997876704,
0.1579655707,
-0.6653478146,
0.016195735,
-0.0014073977,
0.287211746,
-0.6077256799,
0.2385149747,
0.0786248893,
1.0287588835,
-0.1870492399,
0.7071902156,
0.6772134304,
-0.2224328816,
-0.6053705215,
-0.2422558963,
-0.099714689,
-1.1296384335,
0.4815282524,
0.1769432873,
0.0965464115,
-0.0865917429,
-0.633387208,
-0.6944125891,
0.5207523704,
0.7242051959,
-0.8175888062,
0.0213891901,
0.2234775126,
0.3655923903,
-0.0698422641,
0.0101327356,
0.3862043023,
0.4307537377,
0.4094821513,
-0.9042699933,
-0.1547808647,
-0.2335463315,
-0.2118611634,
0.6163386703,
-0.3852119148,
1.0023560524,
-0.2243396491,
0.2978731692,
-0.2117785662,
0.6139225364,
0.7325928807,
0.3725624979,
0.4878332615,
1.099596262,
0.6663592458,
-0.0667282417,
1.2495142221,
0.0022905085,
0.39993909,
1.2301722765,
-0.3908335268,
0.4921480119,
0.1278185695,
-0.3701863289,
0.4644690454,
0.4508045316,
0.034024287,
0.5821254849,
0.4171904624,
-0.3209979534,
-0.5888674259,
0.0990177393,
-0.7860414386,
0.3861421049,
0.4003638029,
-0.0240440592,
-0.6219031215,
-0.2551285326,
0.2244318724,
0.2832054496,
-0.4877444208,
0.3863045573,
0.2661210895,
-0.3917330205,
0.1775884032,
-0.1361467391,
0.2117626667,
-0.8364464045,
-0.1509077549,
-0.3788599074,
0.9224361777,
0.1434537023,
-0.9432012439,
0.324626863,
-0.061744839,
0.0485947207,
-0.0636058152,
0.8512890935,
-0.0205146894,
-0.7970065475,
0.0795822516,
0.3189491034,
0.0910092518,
-0.6572422385,
-0.881334126,
0.0721075386,
-0.2323427945,
-0.1613357067,
0.4047578573,
0.9186848402,
-0.1226437464,
0.8362139463,
1.1880936623,
0.0951580927,
0.1336672157,
0.4020536542,
1.0526335239,
-0.7159808874,
-0.5419669747,
-1.1538461447,
0.1175932437,
-0.3011035025,
-0.610381186,
0.8500211835,
0.7381461263,
1.0363208055,
0.0753175244,
0.4941941798,
0.1774711609,
0.3921267986,
-0.6447370648,
0.4701538682,
-0.3746933043,
-0.0591465123,
-0.3820251524,
-0.9332814217,
-0.4070882201,
0.8030411005,
-0.4663363099,
-0.0669237897,
0.3969454765,
0.1787170023,
-0.3240483403,
-0.0057878238,
0.2541475892,
-0.0020357242,
0.6143975258,
0.9453037381,
0.9475296736,
-0.0877043307,
0.6417543292,
-0.3716027737,
-0.2256877422,
0.1080193669,
-0.7656555176,
-1.0411247015,
0.0501784347,
-0.1994837672,
-0.3952894211,
-0.1186075136,
0.7125155926,
0.6419891119,
-0.7930288315,
-0.0265177172,
-0.6009913087,
0.1932890713,
-0.0476789996,
-0.2777706385,
0.3551926613,
-0.5537259579,
-0.5328992009,
0.1641914845,
0.3494933844,
-0.0544426106,
-0.2746909857,
-0.2814643979,
0.0789906755,
0.0396278389,
0.6343287826,
0.1788480729,
-0.5078902841,
0.1084211767,
0.0131295063,
0.1255086511,
-0.180597648,
0.972848773,
-0.7847676277,
0.4030138552,
0.5593171716,
0.9094091654,
0.3976728618,
-0.1136126295,
0.6731091738,
-0.1528053582,
0.217236802,
0.6089815497,
0.2511225641,
-0.0611809827,
-0.0442096218,
0.854054749,
0.5477235913,
-0.3549582958,
-1.0392963886,
0.2787874639,
-0.5999857187,
-0.4068616033,
1.0539581776,
-0.0715909824,
-0.1083557531,
0.259768337,
-0.1880039871,
-0.3036760092,
-0.4085716307,
0.6385753155,
0.6875159144,
-0.1076543629,
-0.3690485954,
-0.5527617931,
0.3885177672,
0.2933538258,
-0.8786866665,
-0.0582379736,
0.452011168,
-0.0041194889,
0.0995754078,
0.6036607623,
-0.1673114598,
0.122367017,
-0.0044459193,
-0.2841506898,
-0.3205156028,
-0.471807301,
-0.0270532444,
0.260573566,
-0.3798218966,
-0.2355477065
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03299v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03299v4
|
GUARD: Role-playing to Generate Natural-language Jailbreakings to Test Guideline Adherence of Large Language Models
| 2024-02-05T18:54:43 | 2024-05-30T21:14:26 |
Haibo Jin, Ruoxi Chen, Andy Zhou, Yang Zhang, Haohan Wang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
The discovery of "jailbreaks" to bypass safety filters of Large Language
Models (LLMs) and harmful responses have encouraged the community to implement
safety measures. One major safety measure is to proactively test the LLMs with
jailbreaks prior to the release. Therefore, such testing will require a method
that can generate jailbreaks massively and efficiently. In this paper, we
follow a novel yet intuitive strategy to generate jailbreaks in the style of
the human generation. We propose a role-playing system that assigns four
different roles to the user LLMs to collaborate on new jailbreaks. Furthermore,
we collect existing jailbreaks and split them into different independent
characteristics using clustering frequency and semantic patterns sentence by
sentence. We organize these characteristics into a knowledge graph, making them
more accessible and easier to retrieve. Our system of different roles will
leverage this knowledge graph to generate new jailbreaks, which have proved
effective in inducing LLMs to generate unethical or guideline-violating
responses. In addition, we also pioneer a setting in our system that will
automatically follow the government-issued guidelines to generate jailbreaks to
test whether LLMs follow the guidelines accordingly. We refer to our system as
GUARD (Guideline Upholding through Adaptive Role-play Diagnostics). We have
empirically validated the effectiveness of GUARD on three cutting-edge
open-sourced LLMs (Vicuna-13B, LongChat-7B, and Llama-2-7B), as well as a
widely-utilized commercial LLM (ChatGPT). Moreover, our work extends to the
realm of vision language models (MiniGPT-v2 and Gemini Vision Pro), showcasing
GUARD's versatility and contributing valuable insights for the development of
safer, more reliable LLM-based applications across diverse modalities.
|
[
-0.3644985557,
-0.8647075891,
0.4636570215,
0.3347872198,
-0.270840466,
0.1295617968,
-0.030366078,
-0.4462460876,
0.2150224894,
1.0383098125,
-0.5617870688,
-0.60365206,
-0.2995315194,
0.071483463,
-0.162661165,
0.9604257345,
-0.0548422597,
-0.0964922011,
0.1185072809,
0.2385375053,
-0.8279532194,
-0.4992638528,
-0.6346923113,
-0.2513276041,
0.382424444,
0.5174277425,
0.4915962815,
0.6918356419,
0.4724975228,
0.1736753136,
-0.0951918587,
0.3142185807,
-0.2153562754,
0.2579090893,
-0.1262816191,
-0.3013299108,
-0.4213018417,
0.0015094298,
0.0740144402,
0.0948530436,
-0.2371655554,
-0.0149143664,
0.0938337147,
0.4753825068,
-0.5189468861,
0.2773880363,
-0.4971366525,
0.0265349187,
-0.3390116096,
-0.244709,
-0.4644195735,
-0.3790217936,
0.0186490007,
-0.4559682608,
-0.0471221358,
0.0892682225,
0.5246216059,
-0.0348406695,
-0.2655638754,
-0.2299456,
-0.6264842153,
0.333216995,
-0.705257833,
0.0908098668,
0.5766175985,
0.4473269284,
-0.4164299071,
-0.3182033896,
-0.3740545809,
-0.5095196962,
0.0843726471,
-0.00385614,
0.1841417104,
0.095243983,
0.1391619891,
-0.1369156539,
-0.3284558654,
0.1970928311,
-0.4063488245,
-0.3626029491,
0.8069233298,
0.0490485616,
0.4809127152,
-0.3502730131,
-0.3929065466,
-0.050452929,
-1.0634188652,
0.2686646581,
0.5470112562,
0.3662814498,
-0.1418052018,
0.5349223614,
-0.0201054011,
0.6039919257,
-0.039026238,
-0.2481759936,
-0.0720744208,
-0.1976358593,
0.0394773744,
0.4290250838,
0.7651594281,
0.6753602624,
0.5652736425,
-0.1380263418,
-0.162246123,
0.0640998334,
0.3755183518,
-0.6560719609,
-0.2118704021,
-0.2284472287,
-0.2924432158,
-0.8686288595,
-0.0908972695,
-0.9392422438,
-0.9527623653,
-0.013212583,
0.45476529,
-0.6369767785,
-0.2668527067,
0.104822129,
-0.034851484,
0.2654423416,
0.0264514126,
-1.0777128935,
0.5767288804,
0.5556355715,
0.836502552,
-0.0399230272,
-0.2952418625,
-0.7133432031,
0.3034796119,
-0.3418549299,
0.5237699151,
-0.3260276318,
-0.4914436042,
-0.0579885133,
-0.1056658477,
-0.08159329,
-0.5171838999,
0.4774747193,
-0.4933286011,
-0.2024974078,
-0.050520625,
-0.3914331794,
0.2443084717,
0.4411077499,
-0.5839501619,
0.7884828448,
-0.2275639474,
-0.5611266494,
0.4606013596,
-0.8950121999,
-0.4159500599,
-0.005347522,
0.0076503418,
-0.3041277826,
-0.2411849797,
0.3057618737,
0.2383544445,
-0.1711899191,
0.3809567988,
-0.3735899031,
-0.3719415069,
0.2279934138,
-0.2403133959,
0.6903576255,
0.2498117983,
-0.4289900959,
0.112334244,
-0.3592600226,
-0.0683454797,
0.2050762475,
-0.2661813796,
-0.4544866383,
0.4016394317,
-0.1089556217,
0.1718095541,
0.0088175479,
-0.5437468886,
0.1377172917,
-0.2751695216,
0.6423227191,
0.981289506,
0.2509051859,
0.2550048828,
-0.2109445482,
0.6120020151,
-0.1182445511,
0.4972929358,
-0.1719057262,
-0.3696737587,
-0.4588540494,
-0.1428319663,
0.0590656213,
0.8732402325,
-0.5918821692,
0.738057375,
0.0059593157,
-0.4222769439,
-0.2646359503,
0.4173238873,
0.4729135036,
0.4400360882,
0.3711599112,
-0.5645977259,
-0.6609378457,
-0.7691248655,
-0.3694568276,
-0.5696992278,
0.2546155155,
0.150832653,
0.3610884249,
-0.2638830841,
1.0245217085,
-0.4754870534,
-0.337203294,
-0.5856202841,
-0.3054862618,
0.0671150908,
0.4241846502,
0.5311617851,
-0.5718150735,
-0.1818341464,
-0.2853647172,
-0.6466507912,
-0.2949841917,
0.056301184,
-0.2734287679,
0.0396369174,
0.7477065325,
-0.4711452425,
0.3987018764,
0.6045147181,
-0.7360054851,
0.7406262159,
-0.148241356,
-0.130297631,
-1.1012963057,
0.0360475443,
0.0998459235,
-0.3512362838,
-0.7125816345,
0.1744885594,
-0.097543478,
0.0376424268,
-0.2085724771,
0.4942418635,
-0.2509147227,
0.0742142424,
-0.1723704636,
0.2201649398,
-0.1976026148,
0.086860083,
-0.1527194232,
0.7125974298,
0.5070109367,
-0.5543317795,
0.4726676643,
0.2968762517,
-0.3928510249,
0.2714560926,
-0.6082263589,
0.0601222068,
0.0805750936,
0.2200290114,
-0.5625265241,
-0.2805914879,
0.3186039329,
-0.0144698825,
0.0123355342,
-0.7274165154,
-0.6077923179,
-0.4103906453,
-0.2934012413,
-0.0691754594,
0.6745905876,
-0.4110778272,
0.2053145468,
0.7371789217,
-0.244479537,
-0.5063612461,
-0.5498235226,
0.3758232892,
-0.5769320726,
-0.8394250274,
0.3153648674,
-0.1003345698,
-0.3568315506,
-0.2114891112,
-0.2494585365,
-0.014020117,
0.4698556364,
0.3014313281,
0.5427250862,
0.0400255658,
-0.0470912792,
-0.1073182374,
0.0888737887,
0.2413700968,
-0.2265927047,
0.7046654224,
-0.2613091469,
-0.2361020744,
0.0537242591,
0.0572227798,
0.440520823,
-0.5307534337,
0.5684534907,
0.215664193,
-0.0463050492,
-0.3501270115,
-0.4726330042,
-0.2881281078,
-0.5374651551,
0.024699606,
-0.1695836186,
-1.062027812,
0.4665923715,
-0.038815897,
0.1324985176,
-0.1309025735,
0.2355614305,
0.1127153933,
0.913197577,
0.8273703456,
-0.0685966834,
0.6651223302,
0.1168673337,
0.3687609136,
-0.6796672344,
-0.2206622362,
-0.1123688221,
-0.1751744598,
-0.6393404007,
-0.3528356552,
0.4440847039,
0.4460376501,
-0.1829387844,
0.5837945938,
-0.338416934,
0.63743186,
0.4974032938,
0.2258970737,
0.2839533091,
-0.1750534326,
-0.3992158771,
0.1464424282,
-0.369777441,
-0.8720775247,
1.0458955765,
0.3128318787,
0.9462401271,
0.3542652726,
1.1774145365,
0.4607907534,
0.2977694869,
-0.6252709627,
0.7957516909,
-0.0462961681,
-0.6135508418,
-0.2717774808,
-0.349039048,
-0.7909852862,
0.0576750115,
-0.2196201086,
-1.0283042192,
-0.1617672443,
0.4823006392,
-0.3693701327,
0.2046565115,
-0.8878732324,
1.0717232227,
-0.4136396348,
-0.5059770346,
-0.0949881077,
-0.6901761293,
0.7155909538,
0.012065962,
0.310680449,
-0.1329806894,
0.3224471211,
0.5997724533,
-0.4796071947,
1.1503379345,
-0.5315874815,
-0.0916991532,
0.4847587347,
0.3788238168,
0.5505437851,
0.3408923745,
0.1543937624,
-0.4627162516,
0.014943134,
-0.0489853434,
-0.3274899721,
0.6831732988,
-0.6063287854,
-0.8930456042,
-0.2573245764,
-0.3615712821,
-0.2957926691,
0.4084004462,
-0.0076840934,
0.2153172344,
-0.4454191625,
-0.1205662489,
0.8019160628,
-0.3054024875,
0.3898881972,
0.3818744421,
-0.5552486181,
-0.1126331314,
0.5595450997,
-0.0163054131,
0.2123297751,
-0.0827808082,
0.3324412107,
-0.1701595932,
-0.6320738196,
-0.5011919141,
0.0189596042,
-0.231804356,
-0.165620178,
-0.3147508204,
-0.487131536,
-0.5311639905,
-0.0946692079,
-0.0180480573,
-0.2103362381,
0.2602659464,
-0.3412642777,
0.7343325019,
0.6085478067,
-0.1967605948,
0.2895886302,
-0.7753324509,
0.3510237634,
0.4275134802,
0.5114662051,
-0.4498615861,
-0.1981872916,
-0.0633420572,
-0.0311869085,
-0.3946910501,
-1.0658495426,
0.3285027146,
0.0498506278,
0.6924899817,
0.2646984458,
0.114906922,
0.5380871296,
-0.6815268397,
0.6117686629,
0.1674807817,
-1.0075690746,
0.7529193163,
-0.6494115591,
-0.2750009298,
0.6014699936,
-0.374563098,
-0.8641613722,
-0.5183011293,
-0.4221414626,
-0.8806613684,
0.7305401564,
0.1477194428,
0.1810841411,
-0.0622003824,
0.273476392,
-0.2291614264,
0.0677159131,
-0.674104929,
0.2155847847,
-0.2930257618,
-0.1719961315,
-0.0537403561,
-0.0445919149,
-0.3505315781,
0.1404200643,
0.4492358863,
-0.1922183037,
0.0058788536,
0.173774451,
-0.2323092669,
0.1116636619,
0.4856311977,
0.4914031029,
0.3801861405,
-0.2852345407,
0.2977400422,
0.0033711041,
-0.7199172378,
0.2233578712,
0.1857975572,
-0.4583649039,
-0.4095574915,
0.1738558412,
0.7388763428,
-0.0216734707,
-0.8399252295,
0.4861425757,
0.0731974021,
-0.085473232,
-0.5486066937,
0.5760855079,
0.0870061219,
0.2042954564,
0.0005557573,
0.2594147027,
-0.1131909043,
-0.8087698221,
0.436897397,
0.2252181619,
-0.4890234768,
-0.233826682,
0.6695300341,
0.3881168962,
-0.4409771562,
0.452269733,
-0.2255485803,
-0.5162789822,
0.6446824074,
0.6165329218,
0.8207410574,
-0.2347251624,
0.4526648521,
0.039969746,
0.6782966256,
-0.4792949855,
0.1916096956,
0.222781986,
-0.9822138548,
-0.5505414009,
-0.4420678914,
-0.1937615126,
0.0623689666,
-0.4122298062,
0.3196563423,
-0.706238091,
-0.2226622105,
-0.2502327263,
-0.0739446059,
-0.3762716651,
-0.1007874683,
0.2959926426,
1.186855197,
-0.8287878633,
0.955809772,
0.5054469705,
-0.3511056304,
-0.8046020269,
0.0885437652,
0.287314266,
-0.6766287088,
0.4384412169,
0.3767365217,
-0.2099036276,
-0.162656799,
-0.647832036,
-0.5814191103,
1.1582615376,
0.2728915513,
-0.411039412,
-0.2280993611,
-0.0343929566,
0.5836462379,
-0.4677982926,
-0.2135375291,
0.8289352655,
0.5609468818,
-0.2571848333,
-0.7828159332,
0.2546634674,
-0.3802491724,
-0.1756991893,
0.3362835944,
-0.5037308335,
0.3043831587,
-0.3986907601,
0.0355516374,
0.1422558725,
0.0477132164,
0.7712450027,
0.2026835233,
0.7346935868,
0.4137870371,
0.432318002,
-0.0313747264,
0.8906418085,
-0.3398654461,
-0.1090262011,
1.0471194983,
-0.5696342587,
0.6199121475,
0.5304884315,
0.4054962695,
0.596054256,
0.3074753582,
-0.2531358004,
0.6569222808,
0.5266004205,
-0.2439412326,
-0.4068962634,
-0.0780692771,
0.0717108846,
0.4366688132,
0.3600286245,
-0.3910934329,
-0.1666298509,
-0.163182199,
0.2989327013,
0.1459202915,
-0.2352259457,
0.6504211426,
0.1445577294,
-0.8287971616,
0.0962903574,
0.3186046183,
0.6530085206,
-0.8289873004,
-0.0145783583,
-0.2611164451,
0.2142453343,
-0.1153982729,
-0.9137022495,
0.1523453444,
0.614943862,
0.1292701364,
-0.3984293044,
0.8116577864,
-0.2125775516,
-0.2812262774,
0.6283454299,
0.4046972394,
-0.0628571808,
0.2595789433,
-0.4651174843,
-0.1151285693,
-0.0963370577,
-0.1189365014,
0.3049784601,
0.1655653715,
-0.5245088935,
0.7467111349,
0.7503589988,
0.2822017074,
0.3252252936,
0.1178539693,
0.9133357406,
-0.612380743,
-0.5863173604,
-0.9991562963,
0.4227948189,
-0.3609899282,
-0.3160600662,
0.7581993341,
0.4473032653,
0.6110587716,
0.1815223843,
0.9583643675,
-0.3273895383,
0.1099410355,
-0.7118548751,
0.8363971114,
0.0085988678,
0.5748013258,
-0.4961554706,
-0.6920365095,
-0.2910738885,
0.536446631,
-0.3622154593,
-0.1619567126,
0.3079992831,
1.0189887285,
-0.0967849493,
-0.1314239353,
0.1429773718,
0.0384005681,
0.6917229295,
0.5085198283,
0.8886649609,
-0.0943386108,
0.8354384899,
-0.081944719,
-0.2469096035,
-0.2067868263,
-0.799880147,
-0.9974563122,
-0.0124361487,
0.0120367501,
-0.4037629068,
0.3382876515,
0.9906162024,
0.7598890066,
-0.5566794276,
-0.4232571423,
-0.4477711916,
0.0112569723,
-0.3684440851,
-0.2381144613,
-0.0252351612,
-0.2108353525,
-0.035815578,
0.8121427894,
0.0978305936,
-0.0199888516,
-0.2254025191,
-0.2043608129,
0.0029612894,
0.1545441896,
0.5401150584,
0.3208350241,
-0.5013372898,
-0.4735914171,
0.1582983732,
-0.0779183805,
-0.2143124193,
0.9293855429,
-0.6558865309,
0.4341113865,
0.3508691788,
0.4001784623,
0.4570633769,
-0.1328662187,
0.8175105453,
-0.7593303919,
0.0068504838,
0.0581372716,
0.3729956448,
0.1803204268,
-0.2697655559,
0.6017515659,
0.0285394471,
-0.4530540109,
-0.7157249451,
0.703976512,
-0.7025163174,
-0.1511707753,
1.0914672613,
-0.138530612,
-0.1954086125,
-0.261387378,
-0.3385625482,
0.0656176135,
-0.5424336195,
1.0477917194,
0.4834697545,
-0.026269393,
-0.2880218625,
-0.6016935706,
0.7186663747,
-0.0330565758,
-0.9211937785,
0.3540697098,
0.4647600949,
0.6418052912,
0.134031266,
0.5429810882,
-0.3211319745,
0.2026988417,
-0.3575746119,
0.11975988,
-0.2819566727,
-0.3325802684,
-0.0955756307,
-0.1336844116,
0.2465082705,
0.1043753102
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03284v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03284v1
|
Deal, or no deal (or who knows)? Forecasting Uncertainty in Conversations using Large Language Models
| 2024-02-05T18:39:47 | 2024-02-05T18:39:47 |
Anthony Sicilia, Hyunwoo Kim, Khyathi Raghavi Chandu, Malihe Alikhani, Jack Hessel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Effective interlocutors account for the uncertain goals, beliefs, and
emotions of others. But even the best human conversationalist cannot perfectly
anticipate the trajectory of a dialogue. How well can language models represent
inherent uncertainty in conversations? We propose FortUne Dial, an expansion of
the long-standing "conversation forecasting" task: instead of just accuracy,
evaluation is conducted with uncertainty-aware metrics, effectively enabling
abstention on individual instances. We study two ways in which language models
potentially represent outcome uncertainty (internally, using scores and
directly, using tokens) and propose fine-tuning strategies to improve
calibration of both representations. Experiments on eight difficult negotiation
corpora demonstrate that our proposed fine-tuning strategies (a traditional
supervision strategy and an off-policy reinforcement learning strategy) can
calibrate smaller open-source models to compete with pre-trained models 10x
their size.
|
[
-0.2244331539,
-0.661367178,
0.7811697125,
0.0099202199,
-0.2833159268,
0.3098688424,
-0.2858350873,
-0.624982059,
0.3330124021,
0.5987158418,
-0.5871735215,
-0.1076610982,
-0.7301596403,
-0.3307863176,
-0.0955663249,
0.8757707477,
0.3283831179,
0.2025702894,
0.1193411499,
0.0963121206,
-0.6408156157,
-0.2442167699,
-0.7522131801,
-0.44767946,
0.2641870379,
0.6159065366,
1.2812712193,
0.3802545071,
0.5195913911,
0.2796309888,
-0.0647401139,
0.1258638948,
-0.5491443276,
-0.0029442511,
-0.209547013,
-0.6897235513,
-0.2450018227,
0.1940310448,
0.08306209,
1.0269912481,
-0.2910330892,
-0.1687299758,
-0.2776953876,
0.3689765334,
-0.4535468221,
0.3017919064,
-1.1891484261,
0.0738888681,
0.127046138,
-0.2614626884,
-0.3412991166,
-0.3326856792,
0.44457075,
-0.525808394,
-0.2729728818,
0.3877574801,
0.7155208588,
0.3436747491,
-0.3996185958,
-0.526489079,
-0.7278188467,
0.8996863365,
-0.8180150986,
0.2193296999,
0.6369469762,
0.1740223616,
-0.4491873682,
-0.2817679048,
-0.3437578678,
-0.1671279073,
0.1690154821,
0.1715220809,
-0.1751336157,
0.2423279136,
-0.0196447447,
0.1832860559,
-0.0604797043,
0.2026543468,
-0.4369530082,
-0.166053772,
0.6294694543,
0.0654562041,
-0.2642683089,
-0.0867208093,
-0.31709373,
-0.0686843842,
-0.5743308067,
-0.0174543336,
0.5541889071,
0.4664404392,
-0.1048202515,
0.5383364558,
-0.3344478905,
0.6986049414,
0.2987750471,
0.018261157,
-0.2528196871,
-0.0465422235,
-0.2473404557,
0.0940524116,
0.6694538593,
0.5567929745,
0.3202559054,
-0.2946673334,
-0.0557187311,
-0.1003652737,
0.200050354,
-0.5633437634,
-0.2530139983,
0.3937370181,
-0.0903808698,
-0.4120244682,
0.0205816664,
-0.9247643352,
-0.5536103845,
-0.1852675527,
0.5469802618,
-0.3862043917,
0.02671743,
0.4283908308,
-0.0864417925,
0.1241955906,
0.532137394,
-0.7686326504,
0.2853491306,
0.6273533702,
0.4903214276,
0.0993508622,
-0.0979054272,
-0.6892047524,
-0.0658707842,
-0.9757940173,
0.6306074262,
-0.5721349716,
-0.7044640779,
-0.0224104393,
-0.4907168746,
0.1204574481,
-0.2701265216,
0.4787927866,
-0.3168344796,
0.2572006881,
-0.0806669965,
-0.6397592425,
0.0698388964,
0.2713017166,
-0.3103781939,
0.5017666817,
0.147668004,
-0.4623591304,
0.4237529635,
-0.3621298373,
-0.1830376089,
0.2209859341,
-0.1091438755,
-0.2424874455,
0.3456561565,
0.0127950767,
0.2276535779,
-0.4931973517,
0.5652562976,
-0.3535714447,
-0.4069676399,
0.6313922405,
-0.6378383636,
0.2607955039,
0.2680174708,
-0.0633887872,
0.0401180722,
-0.232430324,
0.3028810918,
-0.0820925236,
-0.0369705409,
-0.2573266327,
0.0463017039,
-0.2120557725,
0.1139511913,
0.3946628571,
-0.3180259764,
0.1860307902,
-0.6441993117,
0.5241770744,
0.6243531704,
0.0462843552,
0.5971253514,
-0.5340948105,
0.5497310758,
-0.0362238586,
0.3183320165,
-0.1023764387,
-0.5027675629,
-0.9475615621,
0.4138572812,
0.61326617,
0.4858159125,
-0.7499980927,
0.3356431723,
-0.3083216548,
-0.7898554802,
-0.5158996582,
-0.1807677895,
0.4886973798,
0.0443707965,
0.1096907333,
-0.2526070774,
-0.2213581204,
-0.6199960709,
-0.6688851714,
-0.4447658658,
-0.040623229,
0.23703067,
0.2448903769,
0.293925792,
1.0697742701,
-0.6565154791,
-0.2846159339,
-0.1117637232,
0.5400599837,
0.1629540622,
0.3276464641,
0.2416650951,
-0.9494274855,
-0.4193124175,
-0.0228703059,
-0.0892687738,
0.4078649282,
-0.3863075376,
0.0030895232,
0.1388229132,
0.5230053663,
-0.5506724119,
0.4266208708,
0.6118779778,
-0.3899920285,
0.5907083154,
-0.3358941674,
0.1766690612,
-0.8038919568,
-0.4068904817,
-0.0417298153,
-0.3786282837,
-0.5639280677,
-0.2878787518,
-0.0511873104,
-0.1935414672,
-0.3137624264,
0.6238800287,
-0.2885934711,
0.1944614649,
-0.1454016119,
0.2670532465,
-0.0455378182,
0.4307226241,
0.291560024,
0.758600235,
0.319432199,
-0.3927756548,
-0.0654215142,
0.3424434662,
-0.769631207,
0.5093225837,
-0.5237269402,
0.2079164535,
0.0801533386,
0.0641779527,
-0.777508378,
-0.3295958638,
0.1789891869,
-0.6176656485,
0.2181430459,
-0.1464217752,
-0.0752364472,
-0.4059684277,
-0.1374649704,
0.0207687803,
0.4611963034,
-0.0233492739,
0.3531524837,
0.3304266334,
-0.3700142503,
-0.4773605466,
-0.6224057674,
0.3427479565,
-0.3144447803,
-0.259242326,
0.4919215739,
-0.3457650244,
-0.5039673448,
-0.2505010068,
-0.2782842517,
-0.2697407305,
0.1781141609,
0.1868893057,
0.0729627162,
0.1842416078,
0.2223318517,
-0.0192487407,
-0.3014058173,
-0.0870597064,
-0.2371516824,
0.5994201303,
0.0173257701,
-0.5639310479,
0.0456801392,
0.2402003258,
0.6780337095,
-0.0162256192,
0.6502598524,
0.1011429653,
-0.3535914421,
0.0260698311,
-0.7069526315,
-0.1988117248,
-0.4853339791,
0.3135092556,
-0.3624001443,
-0.6651513577,
0.5426619649,
-0.3091363907,
-0.1228679419,
0.1959699094,
0.2152811289,
0.0841309652,
1.0727897882,
0.7982749939,
-0.1079451814,
0.4208782613,
0.0999107584,
0.6495588422,
-0.3528723419,
-0.0306830015,
-0.5314302444,
-0.0102452571,
-0.4675891399,
-0.5943986177,
0.395150423,
0.2484322786,
-0.0387200713,
0.2968145013,
-0.3485647142,
0.5514986515,
0.8351795673,
-0.0075837667,
0.3605568409,
-0.3398283124,
0.3158797026,
-0.2424879223,
-0.5520492196,
-0.4654411077,
0.8302715421,
0.2712773681,
0.8413947225,
-0.1648398787,
0.4814864993,
0.0616287254,
-0.0603725724,
-0.9400865436,
0.2641800642,
0.1746928841,
-0.6039979458,
-0.6926888227,
-0.6700875163,
-0.8164806366,
0.0198342502,
-0.322558403,
-1.049844861,
0.3553821445,
-0.0630481914,
-0.6816601753,
0.2195522189,
-0.7114634514,
0.8995786905,
-0.4533017874,
0.0934765786,
-0.2413552552,
-0.572669208,
0.0437354632,
-0.3892490268,
0.5232079029,
-0.3041813076,
0.1917911768,
0.5528706312,
-0.3186783791,
0.7123142481,
0.1612056643,
-0.0819689929,
0.3389379084,
0.5068879724,
0.7029819489,
0.1022607759,
-0.4248985052,
0.21646671,
0.2857213616,
-0.2294066846,
-0.512183249,
0.366019249,
-0.5213693976,
-0.540510118,
-0.3056097925,
-0.7654422522,
-0.538589716,
-0.0035432961,
0.5907406807,
0.0703393668,
-0.4111980498,
-0.0376356579,
0.1917363107,
-0.1802794933,
0.155112952,
0.5142049789,
-0.1546019763,
-0.2674036324,
0.8927922249,
0.1634192318,
0.5634558201,
0.3317461312,
0.2115034312,
-0.1267460734,
-0.5849496722,
-0.0966022685,
-0.067131117,
-0.5570808649,
-0.520131886,
-0.1903265268,
-0.1647317857,
-0.3017058671,
-0.3603774309,
-0.4792076945,
-0.3301968277,
-0.2560693622,
-0.1354791969,
0.5364172459,
0.6460434198,
-0.0384063721,
0.684420526,
-0.5884398818,
-0.1194873676,
0.2456480265,
0.5316428542,
-0.3012740314,
-0.4324919283,
-0.3222051859,
0.6220295429,
-0.3477757275,
-0.7910456657,
0.7010909319,
0.1345088333,
-0.0205534194,
0.4119454026,
0.5917087793,
0.8031293154,
-0.2532622516,
0.7329550982,
0.4673949778,
-1.2404352427,
0.3825472891,
-0.4046086669,
0.2733752131,
0.6764109731,
-0.0646324828,
-0.843377769,
-0.5798331499,
-0.6673856378,
-0.7308490872,
0.7887839079,
0.144760862,
0.4519403875,
-0.1164975315,
0.0998663679,
0.1293733716,
0.6266890168,
-0.4716229439,
-0.0534460321,
0.1272900999,
-0.1345618069,
-0.2255491614,
-0.3750617802,
-0.1412126422,
-0.0267075486,
0.5105506778,
-0.2600799203,
0.1784913391,
-0.1353682727,
0.2390505672,
-0.4593571126,
0.3633599579,
0.30747509,
0.8767453432,
-0.2956100702,
-0.2117296457,
0.1971707046,
0.0082510132,
-0.2352396399,
0.0939746127,
0.01030936,
-0.0659301728,
0.1773847342,
1.00661695,
0.6862314939,
-0.8789762855,
0.5321204066,
-0.1832699329,
-0.3354432285,
-0.4686543941,
-0.055985447,
0.0289003272,
0.3146416843,
0.3427917659,
0.142149955,
0.1108454689,
-0.6363208294,
-0.0664627999,
0.6377794147,
-0.796880126,
0.0214896798,
0.5302109122,
0.1781043112,
-0.6264816523,
0.5170955658,
-0.2537367046,
-0.6925283074,
0.6465251446,
0.2763033509,
0.4031766653,
-0.1768247485,
0.5235204101,
-0.2097171396,
0.343778044,
-0.2079246789,
0.1281149685,
0.2736358345,
-0.8984667659,
-0.5605720282,
-0.4944761693,
-1.0108036995,
-0.0087859957,
-0.6202828288,
0.3448139727,
-0.1719585061,
-0.1731459945,
0.0248702671,
0.2425370961,
-0.8819524646,
0.1110977009,
-0.0593805313,
0.9107547998,
-0.6173554659,
0.5355998278,
0.2289828211,
-0.3256502151,
-0.8829205632,
0.1761356592,
-0.1359840035,
-0.5809243321,
0.1946686357,
0.023008192,
0.0880600289,
-0.058648698,
-0.5676686168,
-0.9918016195,
0.5925999284,
0.6947337389,
-0.6426967382,
-0.2174702734,
0.1204925105,
0.3040608764,
-0.1344488114,
0.3762269318,
0.5540114641,
0.7004104853,
0.3069818914,
-1.2974114418,
-0.502761662,
0.2169631869,
-0.3301322162,
0.4592400789,
-0.6492792368,
0.6994476914,
-0.3354614675,
-0.0616274066,
0.4387302995,
0.4948903322,
-0.2602753937,
0.3071745634,
0.4727934897,
0.2331331372,
0.802529335,
-0.4342980981,
0.9971374869,
-0.3844404519,
0.2830486298,
1.1495212317,
-0.2967016995,
0.803609252,
0.5027401447,
-0.2417322695,
0.2551820278,
0.8374695182,
0.2392918617,
0.509073019,
0.223140955,
0.0618570745,
-0.7042037845,
-0.1498154551,
-0.0553357266,
0.7483400702,
0.7497161627,
-0.0094899563,
-0.0571751818,
-0.0511248,
0.0668568835,
0.1255720258,
-0.147336483,
0.866122067,
0.2745054066,
-1.0463974476,
0.05062408,
0.0567877628,
0.525503397,
-0.6490795016,
0.0616954751,
-0.0915476009,
0.1415567249,
0.3338004053,
-0.68050915,
0.2234262228,
-0.5512715578,
0.1505702287,
-0.1180144027,
0.3874760866,
-0.8198043704,
-0.5429589152,
0.2636563778,
0.5840545297,
0.3103362918,
-0.3600155711,
-0.7364984751,
0.0355662256,
-0.0019341331,
-0.0223635659,
0.33403337,
0.5933740139,
0.0520531796,
0.7844612598,
0.2684600353,
0.1997787356,
-0.3007737994,
-0.2494722158,
0.3758590817,
-0.4646435082,
-0.4145253003,
-0.4947472811,
0.3833914697,
-0.0803070515,
-0.5641553402,
0.4732949436,
0.221169427,
0.6895132661,
0.1259575188,
0.564065218,
0.2523882687,
0.3781517744,
-0.5185971856,
0.4727604389,
-0.4346037209,
0.2249359339,
-0.3437134027,
-0.7535223961,
-0.1372405887,
0.7582919598,
-0.6273933649,
0.0593817011,
0.5378738046,
0.4412802756,
0.0631107166,
0.2200118899,
0.675994575,
0.1060087681,
0.079967469,
0.4607396722,
0.6114225984,
-0.3039636314,
0.8168726563,
-0.2439914346,
-0.0107267201,
-0.3898702264,
-0.9402710795,
-0.5311238766,
-0.6589419842,
-0.4067316651,
-0.1199145094,
0.1896152198,
0.9159137011,
0.9456118345,
-0.5357256532,
-0.2802613378,
-0.1931516081,
0.3003571332,
-0.108670406,
-0.1618997753,
0.1354467273,
-0.4482535422,
-0.8092563152,
0.4239910245,
0.2665176094,
0.1896300465,
-0.1825516969,
-0.0449982211,
0.2590822875,
0.6414352655,
0.1812058389,
0.0874966606,
-0.765298903,
-0.5005108118,
-0.1594296843,
0.1055316478,
-0.0319110155,
0.6237823963,
-0.5749546289,
0.669726193,
-0.1661084741,
0.252923876,
0.4235694706,
0.0062260241,
0.9530581236,
-0.6942705512,
0.3054237962,
0.3971879184,
0.3055103421,
0.3091793954,
-0.4725941718,
0.6134877801,
-0.5065928698,
-0.6428322792,
-0.672688365,
0.365101397,
-0.5915267467,
-0.5887593627,
0.7490672469,
0.0530919246,
0.0978015959,
-0.1839924008,
-0.2569037676,
-0.0423567668,
-0.6065801382,
1.022464633,
1.0523965359,
0.2801616788,
-0.022136515,
-0.5940012336,
0.4898466766,
0.5515251756,
-0.5486271977,
0.2433983237,
0.4184292853,
-0.1963004321,
0.3491612077,
0.6409115195,
0.3084115982,
0.0472430252,
0.0760572627,
-0.1918308139,
0.4755400121,
-0.3728313744,
-0.0537803061,
-0.1930619627,
0.547583878,
0.0494363569
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03271v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03271v2
|
Uncertainty of Thoughts: Uncertainty-Aware Planning Enhances Information Seeking in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-05T18:28:44 | 2024-05-30T14:03:35 |
Zhiyuan Hu, Chumin Liu, Xidong Feng, Yilun Zhao, See-Kiong Ng, Anh Tuan Luu, Junxian He, Pang Wei Koh, Bryan Hooi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In the face of uncertainty, the ability to *seek information* is of
fundamental importance. In many practical applications, such as medical
diagnosis and troubleshooting, the information needed to solve the task is not
initially given and has to be actively sought by asking follow-up questions
(for example, a doctor asking a patient for more details about their symptoms).
In this work, we introduce Uncertainty of Thoughts (UoT), an algorithm to
augment large language models with the ability to actively seek information by
asking effective questions. UoT combines 1) an *uncertainty-aware simulation
approach* which enables the model to simulate possible future scenarios and how
likely they are to occur, 2) *uncertainty-based rewards* motivated by
information gain which incentivizes the model to seek information, and 3) a
*reward propagation scheme* to select the optimal question to ask in a way that
maximizes the expected reward. In experiments on medical diagnosis,
troubleshooting, and the `20 Questions` game, UoT achieves an average
performance improvement of 38.1% in the rate of successful task completion
across multiple LLMs compared with direct prompting and also improves
efficiency (i.e., the number of questions needed to complete the task). Our
code has been released [here](https://github.com/zhiyuanhubj/UoT)
|
[
-0.2244232744,
-0.8628658056,
1.009239316,
0.2558600307,
-0.1618445814,
-0.163458094,
-0.2252060473,
-0.5183284283,
0.2656339407,
0.4214527905,
-0.6799217463,
-0.1503072977,
-0.5418495536,
-0.417691797,
-0.1423729211,
0.5027658343,
-0.0670294091,
0.0130286263,
0.0000411208,
0.4243955612,
-0.3464679122,
-0.3530619442,
-1.0007506609,
-0.2843166888,
0.6711159945,
0.6166509986,
0.8479987383,
0.3336068094,
0.6611871123,
0.2455468178,
0.000891327,
0.0560455061,
-0.3643522561,
0.5800130963,
-0.1950531006,
-0.5870711207,
-0.13276048,
-0.4100147486,
0.5061131716,
0.6950441599,
-0.5108541846,
-0.0728402287,
-0.1935978383,
0.7301374078,
-0.6881569624,
-0.0160176605,
-0.5421327949,
0.1961123347,
-0.0861873254,
-0.3861669302,
-0.1031141207,
-0.0444837175,
0.2921612263,
-0.6958787441,
-0.2316672951,
-0.0103938058,
0.5173407197,
0.4563273191,
-0.088069573,
-0.3664680719,
-1.0274138451,
0.6465150118,
-0.3487851918,
0.5535924435,
0.3581067324,
0.0750924274,
-0.5834369659,
-0.5862832665,
-0.4778047204,
0.2150550783,
0.3184345663,
0.2804476619,
-0.4760471582,
0.3039520383,
0.2665173411,
0.2122017741,
-0.4218066335,
-0.1540766805,
-0.1368107647,
-0.2020370215,
0.5382300019,
-0.0310247764,
0.0316800624,
-0.0362803377,
-0.3633844554,
-0.2150135487,
-0.4221611917,
0.2365583777,
0.2286287397,
-0.2453915477,
0.2070129365,
0.5647255778,
-0.5547204614,
0.7377533913,
-0.1237120554,
0.1015362963,
-0.1261832416,
-0.1979767233,
-0.1619432271,
-0.1075585708,
0.6631556153,
0.2819401622,
0.0852895901,
0.1537166238,
-0.2986838818,
-0.1108406857,
0.455334872,
-0.5248208642,
-0.4867522717,
0.700447619,
-0.1682452112,
-0.0969538838,
-0.279104203,
-0.8381820917,
-0.4686074853,
-0.0435405113,
0.5525983572,
-0.6607657671,
-0.5018624663,
0.5632520318,
-0.0232670121,
-0.1281257719,
0.5271104574,
-0.6661592722,
0.1368464828,
0.3327018619,
0.3123350143,
-0.0802667141,
-0.1909641474,
-0.3152280152,
0.1733951271,
-0.4428485036,
1.018689394,
-0.4652568102,
-0.4037369788,
-0.1827566326,
-0.6049269438,
0.0163879152,
-0.336263895,
0.664809227,
-0.4799459279,
0.0612162016,
-0.5177201033,
-0.5275940299,
-0.1420183778,
0.4070613086,
-0.5324153304,
1.0472601652,
0.1882809401,
-0.6839698553,
0.397003442,
-0.9679911137,
-0.2095503211,
0.2782510519,
-0.2375977784,
-0.0085881427,
0.2311833501,
0.3535488844,
0.4855263233,
-0.4065904617,
0.302862078,
0.0783505961,
-0.2384092659,
0.3526497781,
-0.5220175385,
0.3843163848,
0.4742883444,
-0.2625555694,
0.2425995916,
-0.3597977757,
0.4665461183,
0.3821938932,
-0.180150941,
-0.4244213998,
0.298155427,
-0.0890477598,
0.0324780904,
0.3262178004,
-0.363047421,
0.4474997818,
-0.3996204436,
0.0624168515,
0.5581025481,
0.3877980411,
0.2617609799,
-0.3915035725,
0.6487596631,
-0.0414094217,
0.5597872138,
-0.0026213725,
-0.7645210624,
-0.5703251362,
0.0466501564,
0.2521243393,
0.6135215163,
-0.9145863652,
-0.0560515039,
0.0772347227,
-0.5823973417,
-0.5106371045,
-0.2318343073,
0.2339994311,
0.4339883924,
0.2249773592,
-0.2556710839,
-0.5668911338,
-0.4507942796,
-0.1760173142,
-0.5651689172,
0.0068951529,
0.2509742677,
0.3095602989,
-0.2013208419,
0.7049111128,
-0.8082140088,
0.0829549506,
-0.5063374043,
0.3062619865,
0.1212674603,
0.4644879103,
0.0238764267,
-1.1333082914,
-0.1466216296,
-0.0957067758,
-0.5278274417,
0.1792163849,
-0.3299507499,
-0.3020263612,
-0.1961756945,
0.1833597124,
-0.7728616595,
0.438297689,
0.3974854052,
-0.1381773949,
0.4286897779,
-0.4817432761,
0.3112252355,
-1.0336110592,
0.1025653183,
-0.2506884336,
-0.0472974665,
-0.5846105218,
0.1835191399,
-0.0087204846,
0.1309660077,
-0.3654600382,
0.5515624881,
-0.5214817524,
0.1322919428,
-0.2063840926,
0.0297170803,
-0.2015866637,
0.2641613185,
0.0830919668,
0.7237325311,
0.7598643899,
-0.6972779036,
0.3879983127,
-0.0463126116,
-0.4591554701,
0.6645967364,
-0.4466405213,
0.1944552362,
-0.1457309723,
-0.2065406144,
-0.8741015792,
-0.601590395,
0.3039522767,
-0.5708488226,
0.3020679653,
0.2353898883,
-0.4272917807,
-0.6811730862,
-0.0889686197,
0.4967034459,
0.335539937,
-0.1448794305,
0.5045410395,
0.5937058926,
-0.374748826,
-0.7491806746,
-0.451518923,
-0.053008154,
0.0493863672,
-0.2542501688,
0.1373088509,
-0.2214987129,
-0.4047583342,
0.2452589422,
-0.2206509858,
-0.2110695541,
0.3180963099,
0.1559268981,
0.0967754796,
0.1548879445,
0.5302742124,
0.1674417555,
-0.1317689717,
0.1238182485,
-0.6694293022,
0.8192369342,
0.057070706,
-0.6397442818,
-0.2170304805,
0.486731112,
0.1025584713,
-0.1432926357,
0.2824395299,
0.2696652114,
-0.734303534,
-0.1574888527,
-0.6204864383,
-0.3437305987,
-0.4542981088,
0.5334760547,
-0.3613906801,
-0.7462165952,
0.486394763,
-0.3221724927,
-0.1282371581,
0.4681814611,
0.3671783507,
-0.5679649115,
1.1717429161,
0.9816819429,
-0.1494745314,
0.4449110925,
-0.1046505123,
-0.0071053822,
-0.6321904063,
-0.1708794981,
-0.2924737632,
-0.2347016931,
-0.2071406245,
-0.8129761815,
0.5903805494,
0.0798350796,
0.1935211122,
-0.0294467453,
-0.75195086,
0.4275568128,
0.7224315405,
0.0636362135,
0.2752828896,
-0.091956012,
-0.2782134116,
0.0250493325,
-1.0032304525,
-0.0858972967,
1.0009630919,
0.189291656,
0.8960793018,
-0.2232799232,
0.7908793092,
0.0301169083,
-0.0400763117,
-0.8648441434,
0.4058225751,
0.6911192536,
-0.7923889756,
-0.7604184747,
-0.6190998554,
-1.1971217394,
-0.0991767719,
-0.1878930628,
-0.9676271677,
0.2781074643,
0.2572264075,
-0.8692579269,
0.56398803,
-0.3878464997,
0.5076056123,
-0.5818287134,
-0.1470605731,
-0.4093756974,
-0.6308789849,
-0.0468802191,
-0.2510893345,
0.1045774668,
0.1307761818,
-0.005723204,
0.7052303553,
0.2400862575,
0.4322047532,
-0.0190877113,
0.0532209016,
0.457270503,
0.1055722907,
0.6372739673,
0.088065207,
-0.060264118,
-0.0920671821,
0.0058180173,
-0.3220454454,
-0.6490857601,
0.3864240944,
-0.3683356345,
-0.5496900678,
-0.5721895695,
-1.0636028051,
-0.4432940781,
0.3303207159,
0.4253730774,
0.1565395147,
-0.0304403882,
-0.1917060018,
1.0555460453,
-0.2952437699,
0.164989695,
0.2414099127,
-0.3677490354,
-0.083405748,
0.4375437796,
0.171673581,
0.2656280398,
0.5981906056,
0.1920441985,
-0.3683195412,
-0.744604528,
-0.3653924167,
0.1752534211,
-0.5621456504,
-0.2088592798,
-0.6893475652,
-0.2345261127,
-0.1562033594,
0.0341588259,
-0.6376127005,
-0.4329613149,
0.0627143234,
-0.1259258986,
0.5011533499,
0.9540290236,
-0.2056958079,
0.4198818207,
-0.5166104436,
0.0239276104,
0.2626363039,
0.5172100067,
-0.2416363508,
-0.1978781968,
-0.3420341015,
0.2935935557,
-0.2278167456,
-0.9765200019,
0.2505661547,
-0.3412925005,
0.7228844762,
0.4000113904,
0.339335084,
0.7507589459,
-0.1334952265,
0.47621876,
0.0522016101,
-0.6327412724,
0.761618495,
-0.3485352695,
0.478179425,
0.6817625761,
0.5747614503,
-0.6473634839,
-0.3773986697,
-0.7444893122,
-0.974889636,
0.5360176563,
0.138180539,
-0.2369599938,
0.0622828417,
0.6110126972,
-0.3890742958,
0.4163632095,
-0.3265192807,
-0.1475978792,
0.5149803758,
-0.284011066,
0.1553822905,
-0.5288674831,
-0.1677098572,
-0.1397757977,
0.5625840425,
-0.0110058216,
0.9133463502,
0.5685284734,
0.2610672712,
-0.5721595287,
0.2436648607,
0.5488017797,
0.4846679568,
-0.3509627879,
0.1375310719,
0.1649344862,
-0.6998422742,
-0.0839889124,
0.2535030544,
-0.2464130372,
-0.163812533,
-0.0558848381,
0.6126284003,
0.1597619057,
-0.8566311598,
0.1284091622,
-0.1078764349,
-0.137845844,
-0.2415959239,
0.1102003753,
0.1690200567,
0.5037254691,
0.3221066296,
0.2032112181,
0.4251552522,
-0.5571273565,
0.2235046327,
0.3070109189,
-0.7334243059,
-0.0348181203,
0.5851154923,
-0.3162104189,
-0.2649531662,
0.5351241231,
-0.3744903505,
-0.6096199751,
0.4093999863,
0.4427180886,
0.4991509914,
-0.5636901855,
0.3417891562,
0.0960924625,
0.5251603127,
-0.4419771433,
1.1017078161,
0.0605926886,
-0.6627128124,
-0.4970000088,
-0.2523579299,
-0.7822489142,
0.0414511785,
-0.3862976432,
-0.1220587268,
-0.1409153491,
-0.4079552591,
-0.4780752659,
0.0088662738,
-0.5465589166,
0.4383393824,
0.0555221252,
0.8616643548,
-0.1843508929,
0.8681957722,
0.8087016344,
-0.1858540326,
-1.2456127405,
0.1560791731,
-0.0477354825,
-0.541875422,
0.1334356219,
-0.0328913294,
-0.124619849,
-0.0365907736,
-0.3699632883,
-1.370908618,
0.9487063885,
0.274038583,
-0.5756098628,
-0.119494237,
0.1210030839,
0.2953948677,
-0.1847395748,
0.1789174974,
0.2892534435,
0.5853557587,
0.3062522113,
-0.8423284292,
-0.1613223404,
-0.252684772,
-0.3987885118,
0.5465289354,
-0.2949421406,
0.90357095,
-0.659324348,
-0.2368723005,
-0.0134407962,
0.497646898,
0.1031844616,
0.3728669584,
0.6449859142,
0.450328052,
1.4273872375,
-0.2519694865,
1.2082707882,
-0.3675109744,
0.1377080083,
1.0193597078,
-0.1733534485,
0.9450466037,
0.4848969579,
0.0171548929,
0.1063041463,
0.7172048688,
0.3774911165,
0.448808074,
0.1166792139,
-0.1562135369,
-0.3317148983,
-0.1234067157,
-0.3783973157,
0.2981783152,
0.609021008,
-0.0253022145,
0.1277031898,
-0.009600657,
-0.080761224,
-0.0583209619,
-0.2995512486,
0.5555817485,
-0.1151505634,
-0.8545104861,
0.1803018451,
-0.1784176528,
0.2788034678,
-0.7963052392,
0.0629703626,
0.0656956956,
0.2060770988,
0.1822505891,
-1.1071579456,
0.2012997717,
-0.2529026568,
-0.0132844476,
-0.0898852497,
0.8986256719,
-0.3983287215,
-0.4863743186,
0.2384463549,
0.7190099955,
0.2718406022,
-0.6147019267,
-0.8224873543,
-0.0172649529,
0.0566294082,
-0.5313830972,
0.0958518237,
0.8079347014,
-0.199112758,
1.0344262123,
0.5132029057,
0.4322450757,
-0.1499396861,
-0.2713397145,
0.9846948385,
-0.5549786091,
-0.3531911075,
-0.5877137184,
0.5324741602,
-0.147825703,
-0.419278115,
0.4425978661,
0.4078846574,
0.7940380573,
0.1540283263,
0.6222141981,
-0.0164880566,
0.5339644551,
-0.4405939877,
0.6419963837,
-0.6202765107,
0.2815717161,
-0.3648252189,
-0.688480556,
-0.3346336186,
0.8914237618,
-0.4638650417,
-0.0429395027,
0.7138882279,
0.433870852,
0.2541612685,
0.0718436837,
0.4806973338,
0.0113881063,
0.1031185165,
0.8424060345,
0.9116237164,
-0.1389826536,
0.3711497784,
-0.5385012627,
-0.2545934319,
-0.1533005089,
-0.5668166876,
-0.3568416536,
-0.6099571586,
0.0306203142,
0.0949253663,
0.1178651676,
1.2079597712,
0.6821086407,
-0.4780593812,
-0.2936969399,
-0.1685371846,
0.3265674114,
-0.3702372313,
-0.1093545556,
0.0552672446,
-0.3381018937,
-0.489991188,
0.3600270152,
0.4479742944,
0.0832319483,
-0.1159926578,
0.0704789087,
-0.3395626545,
0.4102803469,
0.2811791599,
0.1910855472,
-0.3711327016,
-0.1805607677,
0.3075893223,
-0.097174935,
-0.043726217,
0.5581018329,
-0.6235925555,
0.761734724,
0.2538243532,
0.6574680209,
0.476000607,
0.0168955456,
0.6397686005,
-0.3366830647,
0.1547225416,
0.6212582588,
0.3410018384,
0.1174186319,
-0.8196582198,
0.6151583791,
-0.0810128152,
-0.6410833001,
-0.5174121857,
0.5229359865,
-0.9086608887,
-0.3489637375,
1.0777537823,
0.0786673427,
-0.2236395031,
-0.1950260103,
-0.5159845352,
0.2315542549,
-0.5657451153,
0.8769195676,
0.7201292515,
-0.3373675942,
-0.2220819592,
-0.7440748215,
0.6030524969,
0.7316704392,
-0.7908479571,
-0.0067149503,
0.2638544142,
-0.0994634405,
0.281186074,
0.9430048466,
0.1269469857,
0.4441599548,
-0.0956405699,
0.3080373108,
0.2117331475,
-0.5657544732,
0.0333216339,
0.1548279375,
0.3211553991,
0.0071189879
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03269v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03269v1
|
ISPA: Inter-Species Phonetic Alphabet for Transcribing Animal Sounds
| 2024-02-05T18:27:27 | 2024-02-05T18:27:27 |
Masato Hagiwara, Marius Miron, Jen-Yu Liu
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS
|
Traditionally, bioacoustics has relied on spectrograms and continuous,
per-frame audio representations for the analysis of animal sounds, also serving
as input to machine learning models. Meanwhile, the International Phonetic
Alphabet (IPA) system has provided an interpretable, language-independent
method for transcribing human speech sounds. In this paper, we introduce ISPA
(Inter-Species Phonetic Alphabet), a precise, concise, and interpretable system
designed for transcribing animal sounds into text. We compare acoustics-based
and feature-based methods for transcribing and classifying animal sounds,
demonstrating their comparable performance with baseline methods utilizing
continuous, dense audio representations. By representing animal sounds with
text, we effectively treat them as a "foreign language," and we show that
established human language ML paradigms and models, such as language models,
can be successfully applied to improve performance.
|
[
-0.3364710212,
-0.3940674961,
-0.0355856754,
0.7830114365,
-0.5053887963,
0.3094402254,
-0.326546222,
-1.0381786823,
0.6493617296,
0.3546864986,
-0.3865893185,
-0.3816067576,
-0.5610404015,
0.4884301126,
-0.4251567721,
0.6548995376,
0.5365445614,
0.3031958044,
0.1434080452,
-0.5527333021,
-0.1279951334,
-0.6842956543,
-0.3010682762,
-0.5016549826,
0.455347687,
-0.1241013035,
0.5589566231,
0.8335307837,
0.5746433139,
0.3042596579,
-0.3904673159,
0.2354723364,
0.2601664364,
-0.0121904854,
-0.1107954159,
-0.2721094191,
-0.2328028083,
0.0585320555,
0.6191262603,
0.8774083853,
-0.1326266378,
0.0989035815,
0.1020805836,
0.6510362625,
-0.4279590845,
0.5926114917,
-0.4860629439,
0.2208470553,
-0.3044587672,
-0.6980881095,
-0.4896558225,
-0.2651967704,
0.3463743627,
-0.9476245642,
-0.2639319003,
-0.1338764727,
0.583884418,
0.3118501306,
-0.1895593852,
-0.843501389,
-0.7828971744,
0.6557348371,
-0.497231245,
0.5286699533,
0.4046934545,
0.14792943,
-0.2092936933,
-0.7153947353,
-0.4553083479,
-0.4208605587,
0.1100450754,
-0.0393919162,
-0.2389819175,
0.3540799022,
0.1125684679,
0.4528168142,
-0.5150418878,
0.2822111845,
-0.3850212395,
-0.3872348964,
0.7253984213,
-0.3293775022,
0.6471046209,
0.414717555,
-0.1669374853,
-0.3866621554,
-0.6074897647,
0.277467519,
0.4344218373,
0.8279309869,
0.0794127733,
0.4112749994,
-0.0938670635,
0.454182297,
-0.3783770502,
-0.4793218076,
0.2928123176,
-0.065320842,
0.1419152617,
0.6033844352,
0.5838238001,
0.0271950476,
0.2230790108,
-0.3507837057,
-0.1886864454,
0.3538474739,
0.2342359573,
-0.6548933983,
-0.0431605428,
0.1589447111,
-0.7098138332,
-0.2970598936,
-0.3162674904,
-0.4941937923,
-0.0887074992,
-0.2363738567,
0.6086568236,
-0.4322636425,
-0.1473304182,
0.269841969,
-0.37063241,
0.2282177061,
0.0800051913,
-1.1723445654,
0.7105935216,
0.6228217483,
0.8753368855,
-0.0563913584,
-0.4947426617,
-0.7934597731,
0.1550953835,
-0.3803842962,
0.9322618842,
-0.7799224257,
-0.8045123816,
-0.0126331905,
0.0682459548,
0.2835461497,
-0.823936224,
0.1625914872,
-0.2872249782,
-0.0414031781,
-0.4326220751,
-0.5242441893,
-0.6558821201,
-0.1249167994,
-0.5416808128,
0.9884384871,
-0.1279468387,
-0.5030748248,
0.2567520738,
-0.9836028218,
-0.7053757906,
0.3172250688,
-0.0697944239,
-0.3530156016,
-0.3506111801,
-0.0692172796,
0.2153416723,
-0.182535693,
0.0380175561,
-0.335113138,
-0.6823413372,
0.2353652269,
-0.1636675745,
0.7626096606,
0.3092620373,
-0.2428358495,
-0.1076313779,
-1.0909559727,
0.0968247801,
-0.0824399367,
-0.7765769362,
-0.5536727309,
0.1504961401,
0.1437470019,
-0.3655568361,
0.1884787679,
-0.7941222191,
0.4125580192,
-0.193402037,
0.7450066805,
0.3209502697,
-0.2952321768,
0.3798933327,
-0.3220097423,
0.231068477,
-0.2690873146,
-0.1504504234,
0.0404140279,
-0.7413510084,
-0.1837023497,
-0.4949994385,
0.5696790218,
0.7749271393,
-0.2788506746,
0.6597654223,
-0.075155288,
-0.5773060322,
-0.6630116105,
-0.2036052346,
0.3214359283,
0.4848767519,
0.4988191426,
-0.8508569598,
-0.5021855831,
-0.7807081342,
-0.2668429315,
-0.858148694,
-0.107773453,
0.0196163524,
0.0714808032,
-0.2591512501,
0.4752103984,
0.1358378828,
-0.1271292716,
0.0532327071,
0.4209332168,
0.110445641,
0.5388431549,
0.6278289557,
-0.5344119668,
-0.2421908081,
0.1291507632,
-0.7526843548,
-0.2359285504,
0.1449593008,
0.1545806974,
0.0009665596,
0.4797131121,
-0.3994539082,
0.365493089,
0.4717256129,
0.0051729134,
0.2737153172,
-0.1631204784,
0.2578233182,
-0.4762502611,
0.3040269613,
0.0015265336,
-0.0394213498,
-0.7148848772,
-0.3045811355,
-0.0951977372,
-0.1567686498,
-0.3436685205,
0.5520563126,
-0.3680181801,
-0.8162336946,
-0.2414352596,
-0.2135661095,
0.0350253768,
0.457072556,
0.6514539719,
0.8842664361,
0.5789167881,
-0.6995181441,
0.1942298114,
0.5427106619,
-0.5341629982,
0.5199875832,
-0.2261145711,
0.1281222999,
0.0211346187,
0.4269593656,
-0.5034936666,
0.1277327985,
0.1968333274,
-0.3915538192,
0.3242023289,
-0.0887018591,
-0.3532452285,
-0.1797583997,
-0.1525874585,
0.219684124,
0.4693925679,
-0.5675464272,
0.4147079289,
0.666082263,
-0.4447486699,
-0.8735881448,
-0.7786673903,
0.1799548566,
-0.2287407815,
-0.4418064058,
0.5639657378,
-0.2574500144,
-0.3599190116,
0.1302544475,
0.1153245643,
-0.1336914152,
0.1541309208,
0.0340725183,
-0.1042650491,
-0.4273562729,
0.3008804619,
0.0033471584,
-0.009974828,
-0.1976222545,
-0.1996355653,
0.2893879116,
0.0061372244,
-0.1609283984,
-0.72881639,
0.4914609194,
0.8871096969,
-0.3415203989,
0.2178525627,
0.2598194182,
-0.3097213209,
-0.3120777011,
-0.0545359664,
-0.2542800605,
-0.4276200533,
0.3804694116,
-0.4245867133,
-0.1874014586,
0.4962596893,
-0.4005573094,
0.1374671757,
0.0574206896,
0.3991309404,
-0.3832508922,
0.7197890878,
0.9168004394,
-0.2164304703,
0.6999864578,
-0.0844837949,
-0.2404640019,
-0.7100855112,
-0.4022499919,
-0.7446644902,
-0.2970708907,
-0.5639882684,
-0.0495191924,
0.2490457892,
-0.3934572935,
-0.1201495826,
0.2932174802,
-0.7473018765,
0.3988903165,
0.7018899322,
-0.1078857332,
0.3503809571,
0.346431613,
0.0009385116,
0.1553720832,
-0.4838079214,
-0.6307350993,
0.8478665352,
0.534576118,
0.63182199,
-0.0659035295,
0.4696641266,
0.6591746807,
0.2770786881,
-1.109593153,
0.3998831511,
-0.6259614825,
-0.5209380388,
-0.5824306011,
0.1508832127,
-0.8948417902,
0.6546073556,
-0.1247857213,
-0.8425770998,
0.3785966039,
-0.201509729,
-0.2356913686,
0.480753541,
-0.3002515137,
0.3262381852,
-0.2204806507,
0.3874666989,
-0.0179654844,
-0.7343872786,
0.0657619536,
-0.1131417453,
0.1045315489,
-0.3113971949,
-0.18829,
0.9109575152,
-0.9942198992,
0.7003121972,
0.0114436839,
-0.0565414093,
0.5080543756,
-0.096724987,
0.3363305032,
-0.4017073512,
-0.6022476554,
0.5517459512,
0.4607212842,
-0.1511488408,
-0.3094800115,
0.0547983646,
-0.9655744433,
-0.1977527142,
-0.2676764131,
-0.4622119069,
-0.4301143587,
-0.0046093143,
0.5435075164,
0.5647891164,
-0.3880967498,
0.2385422438,
0.6626830101,
-0.3948150575,
0.4535179436,
0.8652934432,
-0.1362310946,
-0.4630893171,
1.0445227623,
0.4480655491,
-0.1991734505,
0.6223089695,
0.2482498735,
-0.7387647629,
-0.5302863717,
-0.6672158241,
0.1989118308,
-0.8346980214,
0.0580551177,
-0.8200417161,
-0.2918926775,
-0.1438876688,
-0.0525374785,
-0.3124777079,
-0.1961323768,
-0.3399300575,
0.1669730246,
0.5568742752,
0.9323694706,
-0.6523808241,
0.5791580081,
-0.8726801276,
0.4905180335,
0.4517322779,
0.1899516881,
-0.4160378575,
-0.4780084789,
-0.0142792398,
-0.1035818607,
0.0623750463,
-0.9905837178,
0.428486079,
0.6372647285,
0.6202226877,
0.0801754445,
-0.1164146885,
0.5128885508,
-0.3464179039,
0.4618515074,
0.0142230093,
-1.1186996698,
0.4622479677,
-0.1618155688,
-0.0098688481,
0.5562614202,
0.1556942761,
-0.9303256273,
-0.4567319155,
-0.20538041,
-0.4423291087,
0.8980692625,
0.0262487177,
-0.1751880944,
0.3150412738,
0.0839798003,
0.4345881939,
0.2314686179,
-0.5903684497,
-0.2036088854,
-0.3045799136,
-0.2120178789,
-0.2159055322,
0.0359338373,
-0.0601449646,
-0.0950327814,
0.754789412,
-0.2308681011,
0.0480838306,
0.2332989573,
-0.2602040768,
-0.3798929453,
0.1406287253,
0.480415225,
0.0820447654,
-0.3837300539,
-0.040657457,
0.0691625103,
-0.926209271,
0.5325086713,
0.1064171419,
-0.1898382008,
0.2616326511,
0.5880721211,
0.5751288533,
0.0268356409,
-0.5556152463,
0.4801317751,
-0.1509216279,
-0.2306397408,
0.0471149571,
-0.1683689952,
0.097984165,
0.2394812107,
0.2904251516,
0.0530553497,
0.5234040022,
-0.8906280398,
0.1130699515,
0.1450759768,
-0.4824028313,
-0.3982091546,
0.5953921676,
0.3148893714,
-0.4508855343,
0.681599021,
0.2432660162,
-0.2343072295,
0.9732294083,
0.6833078861,
0.8846939802,
-0.3901363313,
0.2811301053,
0.0481247939,
0.414028883,
-0.0853187144,
0.6336137652,
-0.3469529748,
-0.4919610023,
-0.2536232471,
-0.9876503944,
-0.9270147085,
0.3463281989,
-0.7169651985,
0.115471378,
-0.488789916,
-0.0363184474,
0.5147196651,
-0.2008359581,
-0.327698499,
0.159171924,
0.5558681488,
1.0873352289,
-0.9806876779,
1.0199725628,
0.8670889735,
-0.4940802753,
-0.6484324932,
0.0157422125,
-0.0344224572,
-0.9106920362,
0.8216106296,
0.2097552866,
-0.4117362499,
-0.2094198018,
-0.6245974302,
-0.9200025201,
0.740006268,
0.4477910399,
-0.6533071995,
0.3598537147,
0.4489103854,
0.7234218717,
-0.3473333716,
-0.0420682058,
0.3689498603,
0.516336441,
-0.0998879075,
-1.1643230915,
-0.2615272999,
-0.4159182012,
0.0051158578,
-0.2425373197,
-0.9012466073,
0.6445410252,
0.2209428251,
-0.3053453565,
0.170073092,
0.7777982354,
0.3800413311,
0.2794960439,
0.6913449168,
0.1110298187,
1.2008742094,
0.079902418,
0.5385872126,
-0.5042375922,
-0.2042522877,
0.6115995049,
-0.3474923372,
1.037456274,
0.2145622969,
-0.4656188488,
0.5988381505,
1.0775083303,
0.0843652934,
0.6238031387,
0.4227786064,
-0.5954116583,
-0.1720311195,
-0.2686600387,
-0.4996131063,
0.9603748918,
0.7122936845,
-0.0232828427,
0.1201622263,
0.2848679125,
-0.5560978651,
-0.0731034279,
-0.2287315279,
0.9872464538,
0.0505379178,
-0.5159933567,
0.4577924013,
-0.2536671162,
0.8932148814,
-0.6721099019,
-0.3142877519,
-0.0953878909,
-0.2713371813,
-0.0776855722,
-0.6793317795,
0.2330116481,
-0.126327917,
-0.1511405855,
0.1054675356,
0.5131080747,
-0.5893610716,
-0.0718274415,
0.4917232096,
0.0138245104,
0.6857457757,
-0.0236971229,
-0.7131593823,
0.2293698192,
-0.2720990479,
-0.0340225771,
-0.0128521491,
0.3637053072,
-0.3186066151,
0.869358182,
0.4884948432,
0.4074110091,
0.0395367146,
-0.1053738371,
0.4108653665,
-0.624155879,
-0.9475749135,
-0.5098203421,
0.0132888192,
0.342058301,
0.0179007258,
0.1164236814,
0.4151462018,
0.5998783112,
-0.1054178476,
1.1293472052,
0.32593292,
0.6700617075,
-0.5485895276,
0.7199702263,
-0.578776896,
0.266181469,
-0.1474787742,
-0.9513296485,
-0.3487580419,
0.2391392291,
0.1722389311,
-0.2910209298,
0.5541222692,
0.8209022284,
-0.0652409047,
0.2174213827,
0.5844013691,
-0.1133960709,
0.0655739158,
0.0345543623,
1.0777896643,
-0.205805257,
0.7274745107,
-0.3207709491,
-0.1034478396,
-0.3793742657,
-0.5439423323,
-0.3111555576,
-0.7378652096,
-0.3032519221,
-0.2105255127,
0.248053059,
0.9896246195,
0.8815359473,
-0.7014445662,
-0.4873869419,
0.4275567234,
0.0575397834,
-0.3763859272,
-0.0597172938,
0.392819047,
-0.2701740861,
-0.9467765689,
0.8514715433,
0.7756018043,
0.3461601436,
-0.391382575,
-0.1731965542,
0.1148995757,
0.5923056006,
0.6110060811,
1.1496977806,
-0.9116723537,
-0.3085252345,
-0.27271384,
-0.3122478426,
0.494812429,
0.5040780306,
-0.6105172038,
0.7196248174,
0.5150712132,
0.4451418817,
0.3613931835,
-0.2147844583,
0.5335355997,
-0.4533590376,
0.4644386768,
0.1123158261,
0.3752830923,
0.3568081856,
-0.2570669949,
0.6789984107,
0.23302342,
-0.313105464,
-0.874504745,
-0.0191352423,
-1.1498019695,
-0.4471741617,
0.9471358657,
-0.2866019011,
-0.5642601848,
-0.2661971152,
-0.2381639481,
0.4230169058,
-0.3802370429,
0.6613855958,
0.4791871309,
-0.2544798851,
0.2955208123,
-0.0418142155,
0.7105388045,
0.1435525864,
-0.7976259589,
-0.1482361555,
0.1625371575,
0.2916088104,
0.3605570495,
1.0215548277,
-0.2614403367,
0.2943962514,
0.3564344049,
0.4872123003,
0.4123406112,
-0.3844918907,
-0.4814955592,
-0.1303821355,
0.300206691,
-0.5676344633
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03268v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03268v3
|
Understanding Reasoning Ability of Language Models From the Perspective of Reasoning Paths Aggregation
| 2024-02-05T18:25:51 | 2024-06-20T18:46:06 |
Xinyi Wang, Alfonso Amayuelas, Kexun Zhang, Liangming Pan, Wenhu Chen, William Yang Wang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Pre-trained language models (LMs) are able to perform complex reasoning
without explicit fine-tuning. To understand how pre-training with a next-token
prediction objective contributes to the emergence of such reasoning capability,
we propose that we can view an LM as deriving new conclusions by aggregating
indirect reasoning paths seen at pre-training time. We found this perspective
effective in two important cases of reasoning: logic reasoning with knowledge
graphs (KGs) and chain-of-thought (CoT) reasoning. More specifically, we
formalize the reasoning paths as random walk paths on the knowledge/reasoning
graphs. Analyses of learned LM distributions suggest that a weighted sum of
relevant random walk path probabilities is a reasonable way to explain how LMs
reason. Experiments and analysis on multiple KG and CoT datasets reveal the
effect of training on random walk paths and suggest that augmenting unlabeled
random walk reasoning paths can improve real-world multi-step reasoning
performance. code: https://github.com/WANGXinyiLinda/LM_random_walk
|
[
-0.2164340317,
-0.8218469024,
1.1562702656,
-0.2697373629,
-0.2771185935,
0.0904230326,
0.0375890657,
-0.6177333593,
-0.0298872981,
0.6399974823,
-0.4583888054,
-0.3113771081,
-0.6559578776,
-0.1725732982,
-0.5360701084,
0.753513813,
-0.0743961632,
0.1703156233,
-0.3470345438,
-0.1774944961,
-0.3870409131,
-0.454995811,
-0.7612092495,
-0.523227036,
0.6790812612,
0.1687687039,
0.8719487786,
0.5580439568,
0.280428797,
0.2925743163,
0.0006053438,
0.1306416541,
-0.2186202705,
0.1542974263,
-0.2566938102,
-0.6592794061,
-0.4303269982,
0.0497685857,
0.64751333,
0.9615114331,
0.0715513229,
-0.0284636356,
-0.3098153472,
0.6688690186,
-0.4591251612,
-0.2904047072,
-0.6054722071,
0.0521379039,
-0.3733223677,
-0.2972296178,
-0.583334744,
-0.2815058827,
0.2907003164,
-0.4290079176,
-0.0744846091,
0.2651330829,
0.5988534689,
0.0738131776,
-0.5456361175,
-0.3212416768,
-0.7511114478,
0.5782843828,
-0.4644452333,
0.5255115032,
0.3918325901,
0.6291908622,
-0.2085347921,
-0.9821491838,
-0.3980657756,
-0.2124926299,
-0.3190833628,
-0.3112140894,
-0.0070980014,
0.1000188366,
0.2434737384,
0.1505621225,
-0.4050119519,
-0.0066105118,
-0.3015075028,
-0.2128751129,
0.5796168447,
0.0294287987,
0.2780246437,
0.2463689893,
-0.1658893526,
-0.0407746583,
-0.7560065389,
0.2524745762,
0.4085113108,
0.1554328501,
0.0277770068,
0.4674200416,
-0.1721345633,
1.1897646189,
-0.3119531572,
-0.0257095937,
0.283187598,
-0.4569122493,
-0.0771042183,
0.085548237,
0.7087473869,
-0.1844738722,
0.6987072825,
-0.4156281948,
-0.1601723433,
-0.3158638179,
0.2120793462,
-0.4691212773,
-0.3977120519,
0.1967586279,
-0.5104755163,
-0.199070245,
-0.0562346801,
-0.1358798742,
-0.4944555759,
-0.4225420356,
0.4563148618,
-0.5835920572,
-0.4135741889,
0.2535080314,
-0.2379971892,
0.1755631417,
0.5315207243,
-0.5583102703,
0.3254055977,
0.5306814909,
0.6940612793,
0.1048967242,
-0.5254052281,
-0.6358046532,
0.1262310743,
-0.4276664257,
1.065492034,
-0.5976022482,
-0.1282901913,
-0.2854890525,
-0.2724960744,
-0.2641968727,
-0.3281950653,
0.4703961611,
-0.521874249,
-0.0786561519,
-0.3016152978,
-0.5117897987,
-0.2074741125,
0.1863832623,
-0.3367509842,
0.828127861,
0.0541424416,
-0.6828540564,
0.5396507978,
-0.4539045691,
-0.7386488914,
-0.1053581312,
-0.1341512203,
0.217356354,
0.0010843497,
0.2157032937,
0.4916115999,
-0.1961677223,
0.2574909627,
-0.3399989605,
-0.2339025289,
0.334521383,
-0.4376266897,
0.9561529756,
0.3463428617,
-0.127776593,
0.3182545602,
-0.8303946257,
0.1827671826,
0.1206144467,
-0.0463473946,
-0.6037578583,
0.4417371452,
-0.631814599,
0.5486628413,
0.0073136333,
0.0118653299,
0.1874712259,
-0.2979691327,
0.077138193,
1.0069731474,
-0.1013373435,
0.5301045179,
-0.0706664026,
0.5020122528,
0.2376766205,
0.2685214877,
-0.1091227233,
-0.5872410536,
-0.679731667,
0.1156361476,
0.0859891251,
0.2694862783,
-0.4535581172,
0.1934628785,
-0.1544264853,
-0.6263970733,
-0.3552615643,
0.084625341,
0.3523408175,
0.5698205233,
0.3333249688,
-0.2038618177,
-0.499173969,
-0.3756923079,
-0.6821401715,
-0.3331153989,
0.1970662177,
0.3276877701,
0.4237811863,
-0.0747466013,
0.9393156767,
-0.501947999,
0.2753987908,
-0.4768007398,
0.0487816669,
0.3105683029,
0.383358717,
0.3665108383,
-0.7739425302,
-0.2638418376,
-0.1250895113,
-0.5636888742,
-0.1105650216,
-0.1400344074,
-0.6072194576,
-0.1839298606,
0.7714588642,
-0.7756589651,
0.4083757699,
0.2598105669,
-0.7424430251,
0.8166216016,
-0.2664971352,
-0.0288562775,
-0.6930922866,
-0.338981092,
-0.2507476807,
-0.4089765847,
-0.5321612358,
-0.1989822686,
-0.5714347959,
0.2718846202,
-0.2660282552,
0.5178312659,
-0.4077029228,
-0.5230177045,
-0.0702072755,
0.3696558475,
-0.0736366734,
0.3532294929,
0.029549988,
0.3408660293,
0.831356287,
-0.9338855147,
0.3213557899,
-0.2399911433,
-0.4672709107,
0.2879226506,
-0.4412018061,
0.3104428947,
-0.0927404985,
0.4542840123,
-0.8770524263,
-0.0317388028,
0.2053478211,
-0.5134558082,
0.0638889819,
-0.0531918891,
-0.5184603333,
-0.4474102557,
0.1527306587,
0.6161831021,
0.3808097541,
-0.4713095129,
0.9685786963,
0.3243929446,
0.4685686231,
-0.4946346879,
-0.522841692,
-0.2674160302,
-0.1165914759,
-0.6581997871,
-0.0668113902,
-0.0981406048,
-0.6268160343,
0.0685337484,
-0.1152329147,
-0.0402450189,
0.3559737504,
0.255444169,
-0.0806996897,
-0.137657553,
0.300765425,
-0.0913942084,
-0.0755223185,
0.3853514194,
-0.5764777064,
0.8010366559,
-0.1250391304,
-0.7754018307,
-0.0418846384,
-0.0654374883,
0.4210485518,
-0.1974256188,
0.9743394852,
0.5905643702,
-0.2702845037,
-0.0449827686,
-0.1957787573,
-0.0247818716,
-0.4016732872,
0.2115740329,
-0.5920957923,
-0.6762071848,
0.3927201927,
-0.1833742857,
-0.0423449911,
0.4539586604,
0.3461525142,
-0.1160304844,
1.2744530439,
0.3677149415,
0.134338364,
0.2302988768,
-0.1552299559,
0.5520074964,
-0.6040832996,
-0.4686465263,
-0.5071431994,
-0.0375827514,
-0.3788075149,
-0.5852581859,
0.0730669871,
0.6754999161,
-0.5220509768,
0.1535779834,
-0.1395029277,
0.4958815873,
0.5437332988,
0.0649826676,
0.3267085552,
-0.2782660127,
-0.4581405222,
0.5159315467,
-0.9066278934,
-0.4216042459,
0.9465889931,
0.323603332,
0.5992892981,
-0.0439251326,
0.661195755,
0.1346337497,
0.218068257,
-0.6842787862,
0.7388935089,
0.114278391,
-0.5219923258,
-0.4560743272,
-0.480992049,
-0.6670026779,
0.2260822058,
-0.2113113254,
-0.9833670259,
-0.1219245791,
0.5487877131,
-0.2083217651,
0.5143659711,
-0.7896592617,
0.801135242,
-0.5736044049,
-0.2673184872,
-0.3208146393,
-0.8863925934,
0.438677758,
0.0610533953,
0.4903752804,
0.0205633175,
0.4403395355,
0.8644552231,
-0.6276327372,
0.4170636237,
-0.2115347087,
0.0347456187,
0.6708801389,
0.1385504752,
0.5591235757,
-0.3269172609,
0.1324294955,
0.048315037,
-0.2395755202,
-0.3124221265,
-0.7107245922,
0.2549034357,
-0.5762153864,
-0.7676799297,
-0.3906458616,
-0.5200352669,
-0.6093273163,
0.3029562831,
0.2422190756,
0.2912969589,
0.1119750068,
-0.009648636,
0.4744385481,
-0.04568398,
0.2006919235,
0.2712470293,
-0.5598570108,
0.0110233454,
0.5569972396,
0.1286343336,
0.5321807861,
0.504144311,
0.4103405774,
-0.4251232445,
-0.6939777136,
-0.1242552698,
0.0550023317,
-1.0097191334,
0.3330354691,
-0.682846427,
-0.2966434658,
-0.5054813027,
-0.1354457885,
-0.1093307808,
-0.5312073231,
0.0300907772,
-0.5646557808,
0.3903834224,
0.7691783309,
-0.1007688567,
0.3726997674,
-0.7550843954,
0.123100087,
0.4029948413,
0.2269132882,
0.3989347517,
-0.4379140437,
-0.4624605775,
0.0487003177,
-0.0561628416,
-0.7149992585,
0.0070317863,
-0.1948252469,
0.7499129772,
0.6707596779,
-0.3009389937,
0.8939902782,
-0.5548911691,
0.7468320727,
0.309702605,
-0.71364218,
0.6889778376,
-0.3196749687,
0.3108935654,
0.3816944659,
0.3963790238,
-0.2287586182,
-0.4121275842,
-0.758990109,
-0.7406422496,
0.7841969132,
0.2068222761,
-0.2417784929,
0.0824479759,
0.1904245317,
-0.1007047296,
-0.0115756113,
-0.7773292661,
-0.2699978352,
-0.1206870228,
-0.0166549105,
-0.2911812365,
-0.2020411342,
-0.0444208272,
-0.6383753419,
0.6058767438,
0.0354510769,
0.0354708806,
-0.0322249755,
-0.228475377,
-0.0597855188,
0.0623845644,
0.2957898676,
0.8327065706,
-0.1529402435,
0.5199591517,
0.0538850166,
-0.3159302175,
0.1068060398,
-0.0717801377,
0.2634259164,
-0.1616896838,
0.7529188395,
1.0843485594,
-0.0638013259,
-0.7302067876,
0.3051647842,
-0.0090573607,
-0.0984971002,
-0.2415830046,
0.3722956777,
0.2533176243,
0.2350073308,
0.2264255583,
0.3988344073,
0.0402251557,
-0.6816323996,
0.0920324549,
0.2638891339,
-0.3954709768,
-0.3354296088,
0.4682739079,
0.0233029313,
-0.2937831283,
0.634336412,
-0.1545800567,
-0.5205681324,
0.5757251978,
0.4573585093,
0.8099173903,
-0.1478241086,
0.126230523,
0.2183867395,
0.4356951118,
-0.2299149483,
-0.1209287867,
-0.2906258702,
-1.1565504074,
-0.4261619151,
-0.7005326748,
-0.0827799439,
-0.0520541258,
-0.3309733272,
0.2626190782,
-0.2213394493,
0.0327935144,
-0.2439389527,
-0.3453632891,
-0.6528017521,
0.533903718,
0.033876054,
1.0206121206,
-0.9664070606,
0.8023667336,
0.6916385889,
-0.3618120849,
-1.3199150562,
0.0751687437,
-0.3455294073,
-0.871265471,
0.6509154439,
0.2160400599,
-0.4051832855,
-0.088851057,
-0.4857827425,
-0.9701814055,
1.0434565544,
0.3267742693,
-0.4430834651,
-0.0277275294,
0.153441295,
0.502746284,
-0.4786995053,
0.4671130776,
0.7566356659,
0.2700906992,
0.2405625731,
-0.5783248544,
0.0133593306,
0.0248842016,
-0.2672334611,
0.2078938782,
-0.3375311792,
0.9551874995,
-0.5058774948,
0.1243661717,
-0.200933978,
0.4472010732,
0.7142963409,
0.4933797419,
0.803996861,
0.7100504637,
0.9241017103,
0.0384343304,
1.3943799734,
-0.2364940792,
-0.1437243223,
1.2086681128,
-0.2450889796,
0.366296798,
0.4553030133,
-0.2048412561,
0.9806907177,
0.7944344878,
0.6605581045,
0.5634425879,
0.2638588548,
-0.1564519256,
-0.6405625343,
0.0766996145,
-0.2009027749,
0.3840690553,
0.3240528405,
-0.4903686941,
-0.023557134,
-0.2415355891,
0.0257427916,
-0.1075845435,
-0.6488939524,
0.3675201833,
0.2876528203,
-0.8438516855,
0.1876098514,
-0.3371288478,
-0.070082359,
-0.8145325184,
-0.1323801428,
0.1609045416,
0.0414327271,
-0.3145385981,
-0.8792318106,
0.2224769294,
-0.1002577916,
0.0138300182,
-0.3112525642,
1.0214856863,
-0.1185828447,
-0.3348861039,
0.5149001479,
0.7503029108,
0.4334440529,
0.153070271,
-0.551823318,
-0.3786692023,
-0.0441942625,
-0.5286257863,
0.403847307,
0.9010789394,
-0.3536154628,
0.8614996672,
0.813446641,
0.1763892323,
0.1905903518,
0.5615370274,
0.7874583602,
-0.563595295,
-0.4848700166,
-1.0442630053,
0.5626468062,
-0.1174274758,
-0.2341670245,
0.6387887001,
0.3579317331,
0.8302283883,
0.1079730019,
0.6959879994,
-0.0125536947,
0.3111406267,
-0.8936957121,
0.5049280524,
-0.4909444451,
0.405908972,
-0.2463860214,
-0.6325214505,
-0.046923358,
0.7611212134,
-0.6062639952,
0.3261219561,
1.0302611589,
0.4359540045,
0.0116407285,
-0.1744289249,
0.1635634601,
0.2786254883,
0.1981810182,
0.4811511636,
0.9267808795,
0.063575387,
0.574293077,
-0.0935287476,
-0.0840753019,
0.3056575358,
-0.9443848729,
-0.7929741144,
-0.3765861392,
-0.1251495481,
-0.4085621238,
-0.0458926447,
0.5877804756,
0.7168542147,
-0.5885617733,
-0.2683050036,
-0.9243106842,
0.5991744399,
-0.3140156865,
-0.2750006914,
0.324970156,
-0.438474834,
-0.1591764241,
0.2322688997,
0.21140863,
-0.0497743152,
-0.1596509516,
-0.4174467921,
-0.528183639,
0.078778252,
0.5871081352,
0.0592213497,
-0.5103487968,
-0.3378605247,
-0.1645288914,
0.1546202451,
-0.0746238902,
1.0730583668,
-0.985828042,
0.4319068193,
0.5873143673,
0.2355712801,
0.4114669859,
-0.0954415798,
0.7626077533,
-0.5409906507,
0.2205554545,
0.2348900437,
0.7065902948,
0.0951474756,
-0.2494095415,
0.6635227799,
0.4137934148,
-0.4781252146,
-0.8284372687,
0.5394252539,
-0.7257179022,
-0.459595561,
1.2283439636,
-0.188786909,
-0.224392727,
-0.171678111,
-0.0531289801,
0.4862903953,
0.0380700864,
0.3810957074,
0.8189544082,
-0.7331991196,
-0.2047038972,
-0.4601384103,
0.5637205839,
0.2457386255,
-0.8156305552,
-0.1124198362,
0.4427779317,
0.0526213348,
0.2585719526,
1.1524928808,
-0.0669058636,
0.0729394555,
0.0164759178,
-0.4511522651,
0.0123296985,
-0.5062931776,
0.0319623463,
-0.137757495,
0.3505944312,
-0.0231601857
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03244v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03244v2
|
Skill Set Optimization: Reinforcing Language Model Behavior via Transferable Skills
| 2024-02-05T17:59:00 | 2024-06-22T18:58:09 |
Kolby Nottingham, Bodhisattwa Prasad Majumder, Bhavana Dalvi Mishra, Sameer Singh, Peter Clark, Roy Fox
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have recently been used for sequential decision
making in interactive environments. However, leveraging environment reward
signals for continual LLM actor improvement is not straightforward. We propose
Skill Set Optimization (SSO) for improving LLM actor performance through
constructing and refining sets of transferable skills. SSO constructs skills by
extracting common subtrajectories with high rewards and generating subgoals and
instructions to represent each skill. These skills are provided to the LLM
actor in-context to reinforce behaviors with high rewards. Then, SSO further
refines the skill set by pruning skills that do not continue to result in high
rewards. We evaluate our method in the classic videogame NetHack and the text
environment ScienceWorld to demonstrate SSO's ability to optimize a set of
skills and perform in-context policy improvement. SSO outperforms baselines by
40% in our custom NetHack task and outperforms the previous state-of-the-art in
ScienceWorld by 35%.
|
[
-0.0592760891,
-0.5058218241,
0.3942387104,
0.3245668113,
-0.0326330923,
0.450381875,
-0.4799795747,
-0.1986221373,
0.0065411059,
0.5698263645,
-0.9356847405,
-0.0593140088,
-0.5533790588,
0.0482001156,
0.2317807376,
0.8931983709,
-0.017466126,
-0.303366065,
-0.460085243,
0.0317574032,
-0.5179048181,
-0.2154713571,
-1.008256197,
-0.6190172434,
0.4110611379,
0.8297021985,
0.3259907067,
0.7735496759,
0.51040411,
0.4244093299,
-0.1471544355,
0.4850633144,
-1.071249485,
0.2012040317,
-0.3534008563,
-0.2938012183,
-0.1402490735,
-0.1469444633,
0.7296273112,
0.3469786346,
-0.2243949324,
0.1016840339,
-0.0240544304,
0.4623215795,
-0.6421213746,
0.2884944677,
-0.6211325526,
0.1990798116,
0.3130630255,
-0.433472544,
-0.3504518867,
-0.2910507619,
-0.1106482819,
-1.1134819984,
-0.2108884007,
0.0436825417,
0.8621183634,
0.4824321568,
-0.1035677865,
0.0332147926,
-0.6789182425,
1.097399354,
-0.7607066035,
0.0650885552,
0.3526934385,
0.0550902523,
-0.4423235059,
-0.3589111567,
-0.5460152626,
-0.2579753399,
0.2061243951,
0.2045971751,
0.123216711,
0.0644627213,
0.3269072175,
-0.1266590059,
-0.1014300212,
0.4496802092,
-0.36197263,
-0.0838378221,
0.7719765902,
0.2379279882,
0.2534911931,
0.2509364188,
-0.0304582659,
-0.4115711451,
-0.5061159134,
0.4331485927,
0.2257645577,
0.2282615751,
0.1014039665,
0.2842470706,
-0.1746983975,
0.5818588734,
-0.0579139814,
-0.6734886169,
-0.0958820134,
-0.463041544,
0.2017837614,
-0.1355112791,
0.1332142651,
0.3223561049,
0.5562231541,
-0.0236442313,
-0.2313565016,
-0.1944100112,
0.6343782544,
-0.595095098,
0.0852822363,
0.0829272866,
-0.2335994691,
-0.652246654,
-0.2521468699,
-0.4076510668,
-0.3954896331,
-0.5308739543,
0.348369658,
-0.4421541393,
-0.1782303005,
-0.1609174758,
-0.2901464105,
0.1334245652,
0.355039984,
-1.0632756948,
0.2511033416,
0.8461527228,
0.753154397,
-0.1940208972,
-0.3896899521,
-0.8124408126,
0.5458039641,
-0.474502176,
0.7814545035,
-0.8202962875,
-0.4305523634,
-0.013085762,
-0.0509763211,
-0.0432275645,
-0.5238016248,
0.3625541627,
-0.361615777,
-0.0751062036,
-0.1736309677,
-0.4794293046,
0.2029971033,
0.2394547909,
-0.5169376731,
0.8909098506,
0.2014881968,
-0.0675823763,
0.4967694879,
-0.8651688695,
-0.6235421896,
0.0296047069,
0.054572206,
-0.1998360604,
0.1758091301,
0.356108427,
0.248640731,
0.1565953642,
-0.0156132178,
-0.2931415439,
-0.7731224298,
0.0424764864,
0.222311452,
0.3510936797,
0.1210232005,
-0.223417595,
0.3166819811,
-0.3850974143,
0.3535637558,
-0.0157564338,
-0.5571925044,
-0.2474215329,
0.2690398693,
-0.2300181091,
0.2324147969,
0.1160367578,
-0.2770621479,
0.2883656025,
-0.4471893907,
0.4129367769,
1.1452518702,
0.1567461938,
0.391741842,
-0.3610448241,
0.6928492785,
-0.1639085859,
0.2489551604,
0.2454365194,
-0.0623377636,
-0.7315089703,
-0.3243084252,
-0.2173443884,
0.5888646245,
-0.9588858485,
0.5329802036,
-0.2972894013,
-0.3420677781,
-0.3964156508,
0.0869061127,
0.4076884687,
0.4158398211,
0.1057007238,
-0.1561598629,
-0.328841567,
-0.8541844487,
-0.2645637393,
-0.1706060171,
0.260194242,
0.3707709014,
0.394304812,
0.1667087227,
0.6648459435,
-0.3519391418,
0.0171131268,
-0.3205899298,
-0.2115857303,
0.3132626116,
0.4636162817,
0.0043382328,
-0.5896222591,
-0.3806867301,
0.344899416,
-0.8204653263,
-0.1811356097,
-0.215651691,
-0.0574509725,
0.2600554228,
0.7104920745,
-0.1175842956,
0.2026581019,
0.53189677,
-0.2245703936,
0.5253810883,
-0.2742525637,
0.2652418613,
-0.7436131835,
0.311324805,
-0.3241700828,
-0.2409712076,
-0.5668378472,
0.2918378115,
-0.3823415637,
-0.3061418831,
-0.3614886701,
0.8677462935,
-0.3872116506,
-0.1203506514,
-0.4335049391,
0.2062141001,
-0.2412309647,
0.7466138601,
0.1765234321,
0.9228104949,
0.4650483429,
-0.8526337147,
0.3088946342,
0.3831255734,
-0.4550131857,
0.7228142619,
-0.5284528136,
0.2686095536,
-0.1694194824,
0.1972849816,
-0.3930349648,
-0.0414586663,
-0.1524433047,
-0.0800877288,
0.1122976467,
-0.221509099,
-0.2056475282,
-0.1247093454,
-0.2498909533,
0.0375158079,
0.6868750453,
-0.4553031921,
0.346743077,
0.3085490167,
-0.1663950384,
-0.8704935312,
-0.2653256059,
-0.0921172574,
-0.271289885,
-0.5806833506,
0.4663560987,
-0.1137306616,
-0.2836923301,
-0.1454828978,
-0.4142532349,
0.1857745051,
0.1434981227,
-0.0228543002,
-0.0069398456,
0.1346844435,
0.2052110881,
0.1105339453,
-0.2035120875,
-0.1451637149,
-0.1977370083,
0.2342987657,
-0.0241635218,
-0.0929149389,
-0.0417658538,
0.1438877434,
0.1411545426,
-0.0474680439,
0.8094444871,
0.4337987602,
-0.1377937794,
-0.6049531698,
-0.4494036436,
-0.4035835564,
-0.54607445,
0.7516140938,
-0.4373446107,
-1.2372729778,
0.344006151,
-0.4143425822,
0.3651028574,
-0.1153397337,
0.2310016006,
-0.2321129143,
0.724006474,
0.6486686468,
0.0043511642,
0.8524827361,
-0.1779492199,
0.1544551551,
-0.9273439646,
-0.1417285055,
-0.1661883593,
-0.4951430261,
-0.324990958,
-0.450540036,
0.4900777638,
0.2656566501,
-0.5192096233,
0.3337549865,
-0.3355483413,
0.9064199328,
0.5542311668,
0.2836154997,
0.1871542782,
0.2911263704,
-0.0033193969,
-0.0423324667,
-0.9627640247,
-0.5282918811,
0.871391058,
0.2520265281,
0.5141060352,
0.247997418,
0.8029382229,
0.1936285496,
0.2636626959,
-0.6457676888,
0.7636821866,
-0.3065113723,
-0.2283529639,
-0.7388162613,
-0.5652188659,
-0.8476032615,
0.172328949,
-0.3426583409,
-1.0339471102,
0.0721986219,
0.2304953933,
-0.0341411456,
0.0887064189,
-0.5484849215,
0.7748026848,
-0.0158849768,
-0.6523932815,
-0.7789927125,
-0.4616614878,
0.2301730812,
-0.0210215468,
0.1023326069,
-0.1870754361,
-0.2691190541,
0.3320213258,
-0.2961674929,
0.6486482024,
-0.0867150798,
0.1049323156,
0.0276460182,
0.1187144965,
0.8398314118,
-0.0534979701,
-0.3480630219,
-0.1625136137,
0.1311150044,
-0.5316319466,
-0.7648947835,
0.7369135618,
-0.8140197992,
-0.5937122107,
-0.179129079,
-0.4853936136,
-0.4942139089,
-0.0188590568,
-0.0565752834,
0.2372164279,
-0.352679342,
0.189558804,
0.8076238632,
-0.2886331379,
0.5861088037,
0.3534470201,
0.1814119369,
-0.2406729013,
0.9983794689,
-0.3471674025,
0.5490950346,
0.3623663485,
0.279633224,
-0.0444188267,
-0.4526827633,
-0.0943633094,
0.1333103776,
-0.7658795714,
-0.0885612071,
-0.1378838122,
-0.2612433434,
-0.3392495215,
-0.4764021039,
-0.049684085,
-0.2785913646,
-0.1542998254,
-0.0566283949,
0.3744438589,
0.4837545455,
-0.3197400272,
0.4212698638,
-0.5707831383,
-0.0092260875,
0.2800684571,
0.3682864606,
0.0193181485,
-0.7209329605,
-0.5731082559,
-0.2128217369,
-0.1416896284,
-0.3486925364,
0.3479643762,
0.4588836432,
0.7902215123,
0.2832935452,
-0.2695818245,
0.8173949122,
-0.4646941125,
0.3863713443,
-0.0067040618,
-0.8397294879,
0.6764423251,
-0.3621591926,
0.5931363106,
0.8027741313,
0.1336537898,
-0.7813702226,
-0.3255827427,
-0.5804793239,
-0.6875199676,
1.1097517014,
0.2967043221,
0.2653492689,
0.2213332206,
0.5224875212,
-0.1343299896,
0.271551013,
-0.6898604035,
0.2200322002,
0.0175681841,
-0.0882639959,
-0.1102002263,
0.122908622,
-0.4657236636,
-0.2531136274,
0.9795131087,
-0.5473546386,
0.214497447,
-0.0581916012,
-0.0291042291,
-0.210500896,
0.0759631693,
0.8594717979,
0.7976912856,
-0.0629776046,
-0.1922302693,
0.3395760953,
-0.4253673255,
0.2693226933,
-0.2534242868,
0.1149208248,
-0.6201123595,
0.6627724171,
0.8234440088,
0.3291739821,
-0.9772554636,
0.1660164893,
0.4127188623,
-0.0894380882,
-0.4424256086,
0.6616484523,
0.0444481596,
0.331711024,
0.1144580022,
-0.3077615798,
-0.0177371576,
-0.6801863313,
0.1945243627,
0.3303946257,
-0.0877382681,
0.0828746781,
0.0671050325,
0.4153082967,
-0.5199472308,
0.9042258859,
-0.0301560219,
-0.4154363871,
0.8605234027,
0.7390936613,
0.5929885507,
-0.2070827633,
0.3033377528,
0.4627776444,
0.4409083426,
-0.266323626,
0.1744300276,
0.1148762107,
-1.0810505152,
-0.664090693,
-0.4576925933,
-0.4882235229,
0.0967421532,
-0.2761378288,
0.4092920125,
-0.8165559769,
0.0396954603,
-0.3159307539,
0.0682245567,
-0.6287438869,
0.1610522419,
-0.0956245363,
0.5869292617,
-0.6080964208,
0.5193852186,
0.718380034,
-0.4370850027,
-0.7629180551,
-0.2060671151,
-0.0310379751,
-1.0334178209,
0.7332764268,
-0.1247521415,
-0.1338046789,
0.2629953921,
-0.6961935759,
-1.1361910105,
1.0711035728,
0.2468957752,
-0.5769687295,
0.0382421389,
-0.1418169886,
0.6228920221,
-0.5942133665,
0.2626866698,
0.4314159155,
0.6625480056,
0.155069083,
-0.8947344422,
0.1534911096,
-0.232612282,
0.2289267182,
0.1715381593,
-0.8103696704,
0.0223644488,
-0.3485258818,
-0.1293626726,
-0.3181221187,
0.5399470925,
0.7682505846,
0.1219023168,
0.7438654304,
0.5052738786,
0.5299879313,
0.1079614684,
0.9127783775,
-0.0705997422,
-0.1277118176,
0.9932250977,
-0.3416601121,
0.8509722352,
0.7731784582,
0.0202817712,
0.837926507,
0.6312155724,
-0.1396637112,
0.6534484029,
0.6912164092,
-0.3876797259,
-0.4445410371,
-0.2177316099,
0.2081660032,
0.4167415202,
0.3264540434,
-0.1304536611,
0.2077132761,
-0.0170638356,
-0.0167079885,
0.3019945621,
-0.2675048709,
0.9396831989,
0.051686313,
-0.9512042403,
0.2616536021,
-0.1001312658,
0.462805599,
-0.8375073671,
-0.3411412239,
-0.446631372,
0.1781256646,
-0.1562245041,
-0.4697284997,
0.2907108366,
-0.2318794131,
0.0398535728,
-0.431152463,
0.6962143183,
-0.3823974431,
-0.3481379747,
0.1043464169,
0.2507818639,
0.3342699409,
0.2610245347,
-0.6887025237,
0.1045217216,
-0.0232728701,
-0.2290838808,
0.3186068535,
0.2433838397,
-0.3330055475,
1.0319390297,
0.7860729694,
0.2839640379,
-0.4008303583,
0.0968069956,
0.7265340686,
-0.6237222552,
-0.622887969,
-0.4130145907,
0.4539124072,
-0.5448682308,
-0.5637603998,
0.375962913,
0.2865259349,
0.867988348,
-0.2038744241,
0.5935216546,
-0.0881443843,
0.1308899522,
-0.7253730297,
0.4235392213,
-0.5718611479,
0.2108595669,
-0.215772301,
-1.1589207649,
0.2425309122,
0.7553716302,
-0.1078957766,
0.3855828047,
0.8217936754,
0.7928413153,
0.0344305374,
-0.3658702672,
0.4170941114,
-0.2343917042,
0.2341170609,
0.6703847051,
0.7100098133,
0.0746970698,
0.4031739533,
-0.099975653,
-0.3977022469,
-0.1028468162,
-1.1510968208,
-0.8715164661,
-0.4869053066,
-0.440770328,
-0.1972833127,
0.3942215145,
0.8085949421,
1.0042710304,
-0.502227962,
-0.6828708053,
0.0129831126,
0.1629901826,
-0.7215438485,
-0.2878311276,
-0.0039380821,
-0.5593163371,
-0.6776724458,
0.8774309754,
0.2491011024,
-0.2738254964,
-0.2487524897,
-0.2212794125,
-0.2593264878,
0.2863407135,
0.694444716,
0.5152856112,
-0.6164391041,
-0.5803757906,
0.0650261045,
0.1189525202,
-0.2977125943,
0.9426023364,
-0.6022791266,
0.275539428,
0.4568352401,
0.754953146,
0.6720862389,
0.0151445176,
0.9532712698,
-1.1252131462,
0.0345307328,
0.3273505569,
0.0088389544,
0.2717791498,
-0.5278385878,
0.9658640623,
0.0969309658,
-0.5658820868,
-0.7413879633,
0.2821121812,
-0.8855463862,
-0.4700702131,
1.2389740944,
-0.1414694935,
-0.2365712225,
0.0376219898,
0.0888770074,
-0.023236746,
-0.4668827355,
0.7882666588,
0.9501986504,
-0.3793874979,
-0.5573358536,
-0.2271468639,
0.7374002934,
0.6540027261,
-1.2627683878,
-0.0136034805,
0.4952202737,
0.2521701157,
-0.031433247,
0.6166212559,
0.0388577767,
0.1160648912,
-0.0134509411,
0.3462063372,
-0.4082447886,
-0.349312067,
-0.3002658188,
-0.3206252754,
0.0650013611,
0.1604528278
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03242v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03242v1
|
JOBSKAPE: A Framework for Generating Synthetic Job Postings to Enhance Skill Matching
| 2024-02-05T17:57:26 | 2024-02-05T17:57:26 |
Antoine Magron, Anna Dai, Mike Zhang, Syrielle Montariol, Antoine Bosselut
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent approaches in skill matching, employing synthetic training data for
classification or similarity model training, have shown promising results,
reducing the need for time-consuming and expensive annotations. However,
previous synthetic datasets have limitations, such as featuring only one skill
per sentence and generally comprising short sentences. In this paper, we
introduce JobSkape, a framework to generate synthetic data that tackles these
limitations, specifically designed to enhance skill-to-taxonomy matching.
Within this framework, we create SkillSkape, a comprehensive open-source
synthetic dataset of job postings tailored for skill-matching tasks. We
introduce several offline metrics that show that our dataset resembles
real-world data. Additionally, we present a multi-step pipeline for skill
extraction and matching tasks using large language models (LLMs), benchmarking
against known supervised methodologies. We outline that the downstream
evaluation results on real-world data can beat baselines, underscoring its
efficacy and adaptability.
|
[
-0.0924230292,
-0.3162303865,
0.4942921102,
0.2544312477,
-0.1830035448,
0.2106523365,
-0.2366319597,
-0.7695530653,
0.4954049289,
0.5371953845,
-0.7311922908,
-0.5267282128,
-0.363487035,
0.2903874218,
-0.581875205,
0.6316509843,
0.4202929735,
-0.1303735226,
-0.638607204,
0.1321518421,
-0.6078649163,
-0.2571456432,
-0.6436696053,
-0.150517121,
0.4581884444,
0.7800037861,
0.5457520485,
0.7748625278,
0.3132570386,
0.2672905922,
0.3009520769,
0.4118017256,
-0.2803790569,
0.3935638368,
-0.4012300372,
-0.6552535892,
-0.3322474658,
0.0650220737,
0.5547397733,
0.7178038359,
-0.1263820529,
0.4401802719,
-0.1407358199,
0.2350488454,
-0.4664598405,
0.2796879411,
-1.1615173817,
0.0924714878,
-0.3139059246,
-0.2173775285,
-0.1393372864,
-0.3028674126,
-0.0698023066,
-0.9021203518,
0.56149441,
0.0024451939,
0.9031601548,
0.0995334908,
-0.269990623,
-0.2330409884,
-0.6279984117,
0.5593952537,
-0.8526643515,
0.2782617509,
0.5660805702,
0.7953153849,
-0.2307412475,
-0.7326616645,
-0.6508915424,
-0.0095847491,
-0.2574570775,
0.1248502135,
0.4159563184,
-0.0347603634,
0.2262715101,
0.4600454569,
-0.6084099412,
0.2771974802,
-0.5177259445,
-0.0290280879,
0.7137073278,
0.2025218159,
0.2611245811,
-0.1133223176,
0.0032190084,
-0.4155601561,
-0.6071960926,
-0.0472028106,
0.9284392595,
0.6486760974,
0.2087944895,
0.9746207595,
-0.7595995069,
0.928217113,
-0.2010037601,
-0.4235588312,
0.0643145666,
-0.3502923548,
0.0551298074,
-0.0115727363,
0.5974825621,
0.481933862,
0.1886331737,
-0.3370033503,
-0.1121710762,
0.199345544,
0.7566872835,
-0.4790863991,
-0.2359161675,
0.0633363426,
-0.1302771121,
-0.658816278,
0.0535507388,
-0.7821374536,
-0.3275013566,
-0.3270286322,
0.4762055278,
-0.1988020539,
-0.1384834498,
0.0171066597,
-0.3689479828,
0.3513827026,
0.005856731,
-1.1024544239,
0.4674662948,
1.0702296495,
0.9208690524,
-0.2044184953,
-0.2514410317,
-0.3863407671,
-0.1365802139,
-0.3059943914,
0.8726049066,
-0.6691843271,
0.0722057149,
0.0810153261,
0.1839840412,
0.0008420164,
-0.5906726718,
0.4595884681,
-0.5680781007,
0.1658676267,
0.1260491312,
-0.5231665969,
0.0223901067,
0.4486956298,
-0.6730012894,
1.5109759569,
0.5914607048,
-0.3258875608,
0.7223601937,
-0.7150417566,
-0.4674849212,
0.2532814145,
-0.1464463323,
-0.4558306932,
0.0170089416,
-0.1026252806,
0.5707617998,
-0.4149374068,
-0.0400601402,
-0.2618958056,
-0.4829410017,
0.0079399711,
0.1451480985,
0.4126117527,
0.0191395096,
-0.0875866339,
-0.0981883034,
-0.9240490794,
0.197064355,
0.1297239065,
-0.3191833794,
-0.3243609965,
-0.0789113939,
0.101761885,
0.6415742636,
0.0055521908,
-0.6765118241,
0.361236304,
-0.6594617367,
0.2884610295,
0.4639018774,
-0.3230829835,
0.4189495444,
-0.4484684765,
0.843221724,
-0.3310493529,
0.0518308096,
0.2809115648,
-0.4201073647,
-0.3227942288,
-0.2315479368,
0.3446812034,
0.5325021148,
-0.7884289026,
0.7707708478,
-0.5394847989,
-1.1314593554,
-0.914814353,
0.3075866103,
0.2217130512,
0.5991077423,
0.4934455454,
-0.6284876466,
-0.8206647038,
-1.1816158295,
-0.3500098586,
0.1617655903,
-0.3272892833,
0.1594044864,
0.2008160651,
0.0704702884,
1.0892751217,
-0.4433723092,
-0.5804601312,
-0.0310306642,
-0.120611079,
0.3116677701,
0.5311999321,
0.5353062153,
-0.6500141025,
-0.6336955428,
-0.0368878096,
-0.682004571,
-0.090892598,
-0.2290554494,
-0.3348587751,
-0.1092411727,
0.4467556179,
-0.870909214,
-0.0670149997,
0.7930629253,
-0.3938177824,
0.6630682349,
0.0706049055,
0.2183849961,
-1.3254446983,
0.4573301673,
-0.0364637077,
-0.4482118189,
-0.4549598396,
0.1374498904,
-0.1773180962,
-0.4843788445,
-0.6025552154,
0.6850550175,
-0.2618071139,
-0.5049540997,
-0.269235611,
0.3384467661,
0.0104525564,
0.2879247665,
0.2003850043,
0.5984537005,
0.7281265855,
-0.2989881635,
0.7256382108,
0.715133667,
-0.5747655034,
0.8079392314,
-0.4053730071,
0.1870403737,
0.1692272127,
0.2240707576,
-0.6832580566,
-0.5665119886,
0.0911797732,
-0.2817966938,
-0.1234616563,
-0.7289050817,
-0.8548723459,
-0.4322633743,
-0.2938749492,
0.2812943757,
0.7446075082,
-0.4650710523,
0.4790599942,
0.1069174707,
-0.2836210132,
-0.6223791242,
-0.6016685367,
0.1434753835,
-0.2108614594,
-0.4504109621,
0.8264053464,
0.2387699485,
0.2978975475,
-0.1245712489,
-0.0461442731,
-0.3012203872,
0.2021915615,
0.0346845649,
0.1511641443,
-0.0818725079,
0.0136347739,
-0.0419493504,
0.0216417722,
-0.0591506995,
-0.3125280142,
0.4799036086,
0.4833966792,
-0.2968096137,
-0.2538495958,
0.0020020218,
0.5833804011,
0.0659749582,
0.9397720695,
0.7876202464,
-0.3684723675,
-0.4155054986,
-0.4396658838,
-0.3954456449,
-0.5169311166,
0.2470721602,
-0.3469811678,
-0.5950387716,
0.0698818117,
-0.1025658548,
0.124499388,
0.2812456191,
0.348410517,
-0.3407033086,
0.7462961674,
0.5481058359,
0.2681152821,
0.3651661277,
-0.0016896121,
0.188824594,
-0.6089798808,
-0.4652168751,
-0.2380708456,
-0.5399665236,
-0.6363787055,
-0.3866381049,
0.0483420454,
-0.0839892253,
0.2683707476,
0.8679109216,
-0.7840561271,
0.4179648161,
0.848532021,
0.0727315769,
0.1440755576,
-0.0942082554,
0.2402036339,
-0.0740187243,
-0.899291873,
-0.4483720064,
1.1515370607,
-0.1108915582,
0.2353966385,
-0.0836075991,
0.4340955317,
0.3626942039,
0.0208777916,
-0.7786101103,
0.7027236819,
-0.2790722251,
-0.5255312324,
-0.3212890029,
-0.3139531016,
-1.0712509155,
0.0501309894,
-0.9516589046,
-0.2113172412,
-0.2103420496,
0.3870877624,
-0.1998482943,
0.2725940347,
-0.5112226605,
1.0244756937,
-0.1318039447,
-0.0998207107,
-0.2151134908,
-0.5411072373,
0.3259495795,
-0.4698639512,
0.0405162014,
-0.4340776503,
-0.0024323151,
0.6113598943,
-0.4942173064,
0.7814255357,
-0.1030765995,
0.0483452529,
-0.0103317294,
0.1135608628,
0.3243727386,
-0.0356981196,
-0.3438622355,
-0.0065429565,
0.4741177261,
-0.6913268566,
-0.5548686385,
0.7465052605,
-0.4201096296,
-0.2449967414,
-0.306766361,
-0.7413256764,
-0.4472126365,
0.1471497118,
0.0970290452,
0.0521312132,
-0.0699337497,
0.3273198605,
-0.0234905984,
-0.1315403581,
-0.1059298366,
0.171777159,
-0.0299044438,
0.055093959,
0.9311782122,
-0.0203636084,
0.2356557548,
0.1480944306,
-0.1209676713,
-0.3232868314,
-0.1237148494,
-0.1829907,
0.0705517828,
-0.5935719609,
-0.4469583333,
-0.3355578482,
-0.0908001587,
-0.5915603042,
-0.2315294594,
-0.4357178211,
-0.5508345366,
0.0798911676,
0.0651584864,
0.7466825843,
0.5643944144,
-0.1236945465,
0.203377828,
-0.6909347177,
0.4476970136,
0.467670083,
0.8015767932,
-0.3270125389,
-0.2972731292,
-0.3087017238,
0.1233650967,
-0.0386235565,
-0.6353911757,
0.3722960949,
0.570443213,
0.4535394609,
-0.1778150648,
-0.07057634,
0.5374220014,
-0.3509652317,
0.6933097243,
-0.1101810262,
-0.6085200906,
0.6617126465,
-0.423396647,
0.1629239619,
0.775749445,
0.6731234193,
-0.7533732653,
-0.3741419315,
-0.7484391928,
-0.8830462098,
0.7623106837,
0.5125207305,
0.2904574871,
-0.171284616,
0.5660461783,
0.3746379614,
0.1976357698,
-0.5348790884,
0.281128794,
-0.143146798,
-0.6894203424,
0.1075144261,
0.136749357,
-0.0224263128,
-0.2867134809,
0.6161931753,
-0.2677854896,
0.3650461733,
-0.1979995966,
-0.2396256924,
0.1194217205,
-0.0146527793,
0.2469307482,
0.5379577279,
-0.0708504096,
0.0556131303,
0.4248958826,
-0.351085186,
0.0456337519,
0.0254048519,
0.0153913656,
0.0497118421,
0.314329505,
0.2942388058,
0.2938868105,
-1.196105957,
0.6065911651,
0.2964241207,
-0.2850768268,
-0.5607037544,
0.3885826468,
0.1549323946,
0.2027810961,
0.2603130341,
0.0290529933,
-0.1275679469,
-0.8777300715,
0.2635293007,
0.4420801997,
-0.036991369,
-0.3371000886,
0.64573282,
0.1551643461,
-0.697412312,
0.8474945426,
-0.2472791821,
-0.2819846272,
0.597051084,
0.4960547984,
0.2386108041,
-0.0905823633,
0.1982332617,
0.5151412487,
-0.0999109149,
-0.5112633705,
0.3752714097,
0.0340122357,
-0.6031444669,
-0.5906868577,
-0.7354835272,
-0.5149504542,
0.1087417752,
-0.6333441734,
0.7663397193,
-0.5266802311,
0.0109206298,
-0.07614737,
-0.2721157372,
-0.9173056483,
0.4719465375,
0.1106920168,
0.6954694986,
-1.246912241,
0.7457704544,
0.6446905732,
-0.3998630047,
-0.330263108,
-0.2905605733,
-0.2129607201,
-0.7254298925,
0.356387347,
0.2288104594,
0.2336193025,
0.2271538675,
-0.2597605884,
-0.7211812139,
1.3371220827,
0.424241066,
-0.3078656793,
-0.5165545344,
0.5753206611,
0.7404037118,
-0.3961636126,
-0.0513387918,
0.626585722,
0.2581644356,
-0.2251606882,
-1.1578066349,
0.0613690913,
-0.2379761338,
-0.1524070054,
0.007716842,
-0.2718891799,
0.2776501477,
0.3991724253,
-0.0602651425,
0.0653172359,
0.2619607747,
0.2754963934,
-0.1637263447,
0.6552444696,
0.3888807893,
0.505440712,
-0.0609194674,
0.6748059392,
-0.3676853776,
0.13411358,
1.0383934975,
-0.164269954,
1.0167890787,
0.3134925365,
-0.1316434592,
0.7815399766,
0.6417130828,
-0.5886305571,
0.4205126166,
0.2765245736,
-0.0137359407,
-0.4134826362,
-0.2205203772,
0.0873214975,
0.7662413716,
0.1380823255,
-0.260820657,
-0.191936329,
0.118409805,
-0.4569746852,
0.5452005267,
-0.0172053836,
0.7292459607,
-0.0452378877,
-0.7083547115,
0.3780222237,
-0.0416016132,
0.9486762285,
-0.657409966,
-0.4726875126,
0.0747541711,
-0.1422045231,
-0.4534258246,
-1.0278800726,
0.820877552,
-0.2426006496,
0.1078190058,
-0.4610789716,
0.8686280251,
-0.6126081944,
-0.5797170997,
0.271248281,
0.3202286363,
0.1676189601,
-0.0197200235,
-0.6668877006,
-0.4216145575,
-0.6680216193,
0.2367962301,
0.4178189337,
0.1357941628,
0.0632499009,
0.6093734503,
0.8668163419,
0.3321720958,
-0.0378276072,
-0.2437241077,
0.3937709928,
-0.4514816701,
-0.4812372029,
-0.4097953141,
0.4079954326,
-0.4471656978,
-0.4512786269,
0.3617798984,
0.7429281473,
1.1712679863,
-0.3578799963,
0.7503436208,
-0.3063698411,
0.7488592267,
-0.4393365383,
0.6256196499,
-0.6261934042,
-0.0910015181,
-0.1149901822,
-1.2388674021,
-0.0958833918,
0.4788294137,
0.0024667725,
0.0407666937,
0.3663921356,
1.1481956244,
-0.6955339909,
-0.5656057,
0.4900277257,
-0.1681711525,
-0.1237252429,
0.4113924205,
0.4797134101,
-0.5265491009,
0.7185639143,
-0.4284489751,
0.286003679,
-0.4893298149,
-0.8558602929,
-0.7238926291,
-0.9077781439,
-0.4110670388,
-0.3977950215,
0.0148458378,
1.0727729797,
0.8985228539,
-0.4915272892,
-0.1916199028,
-0.1251380444,
-0.3375555575,
-0.689727664,
-0.2628017664,
0.0993205979,
-0.218377009,
-0.6474944353,
0.8553573489,
-0.0052942494,
-0.1320249736,
-0.156463623,
0.2847346067,
-0.364805907,
0.1384972632,
0.7436764836,
0.5145812035,
-0.515809834,
-0.4412919879,
0.0746726617,
-0.1554981321,
-0.1070330739,
0.5882585049,
-0.7710502148,
0.4162347019,
0.5344548225,
0.7339855433,
0.5359990001,
0.0102560595,
0.8906999826,
-1.3646633625,
0.2683113515,
0.3381989598,
0.0981349498,
0.5561327338,
-0.408098191,
0.8375200629,
0.3276059926,
-0.0988629833,
-0.8688536882,
0.2240544111,
-0.9233087897,
-0.152332142,
1.044557929,
0.144187063,
0.1501626521,
-0.311727643,
0.0587854125,
0.3579984307,
0.3117031455,
1.2564831972,
0.5172673464,
0.1128263324,
0.0024846049,
-0.6964882016,
0.7115424871,
0.3879525065,
-1.0408143997,
-0.1455143541,
0.1115125865,
0.4938131273,
-0.0305328332,
0.4119878411,
0.1950675547,
0.6610912681,
0.1216808856,
0.3233492374,
-0.1268208176,
-0.1122909933,
0.1342367232,
0.0316995159,
0.3583027422,
0.0694884136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03223v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03223v4
|
English Prompts are Better for NLI-based Zero-Shot Emotion Classification than Target-Language Prompts
| 2024-02-05T17:36:19 | 2024-03-07T17:18:18 |
Patrick Bareiß, Roman Klinger, Jeremy Barnes
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Emotion classification in text is a challenging task due to the processes
involved when interpreting a textual description of a potential emotion
stimulus. In addition, the set of emotion categories is highly domain-specific.
For instance, literature analysis might require the use of aesthetic emotions
(e.g., finding something beautiful), and social media analysis could benefit
from fine-grained sets (e.g., separating anger from annoyance) than only those
that represent basic categories as they have been proposed by Paul Ekman
(anger, disgust, fear, joy, surprise, sadness). This renders the task an
interesting field for zero-shot classifications, in which the label set is not
known at model development time. Unfortunately, most resources for emotion
analysis are English, and therefore, most studies on emotion analysis have been
performed in English, including those that involve prompting language models
for text labels. This leaves us with a research gap that we address in this
paper: In which language should we prompt for emotion labels on non-English
texts? This is particularly of interest when we have access to a multilingual
large language model, because we could request labels with English prompts even
for non-English data. Our experiments with natural language inference-based
language models show that it is consistently better to use English prompts even
if the data is in a different language.
|
[
-0.2647590935,
-0.4448285401,
0.5475561619,
0.4251206219,
-0.1365847141,
-0.0088583082,
-0.2414391935,
-0.7029533386,
0.1787799448,
-0.16443564,
-0.5659301877,
-0.5325034857,
-0.5275344849,
0.782270968,
-0.0329821594,
0.9984663129,
-0.2897264659,
0.100525029,
-0.2216182351,
-0.3760875165,
-0.4636371136,
-0.6194323897,
-1.0946422815,
-0.3065886796,
1.2535358667,
0.3039396107,
0.1838660687,
-0.0524193235,
0.1941225976,
0.2190575153,
-0.0807149708,
-0.1557767689,
-0.1445448697,
0.4112565815,
-0.1153919324,
-0.4777073264,
-0.0157269482,
0.2319961786,
-0.060854692,
0.6033790112,
0.3047436178,
-0.1035168543,
-0.1459835023,
0.6232390404,
-0.8466509581,
0.0343003646,
-0.0762216598,
0.5119844675,
0.0121986764,
-0.4593476653,
-0.6525278687,
-0.2462681085,
0.264669925,
-0.365850687,
0.1014007106,
0.0626341701,
1.1167228222,
0.1331933439,
-0.7094941735,
-0.4398967326,
-0.6272392869,
1.0136272907,
-0.4068359435,
0.4151026011,
0.2935967445,
0.0376059115,
0.3057229221,
-0.0954898298,
-0.4685015976,
-0.2376462519,
-0.0267552901,
0.4680494368,
-0.5267681479,
0.1117004082,
0.2848677337,
-0.0025518273,
-0.8134300709,
0.4605796933,
-0.1151809543,
-0.1589477658,
0.7374043465,
0.1021933407,
0.5953800678,
-0.4487103224,
-0.1097168699,
0.1073247269,
-0.6295489073,
0.2962601185,
0.2469334453,
0.5510284305,
-0.1804743707,
0.4951297343,
-0.0581911057,
0.6333443522,
0.0182134602,
-0.0740895048,
0.1639910042,
0.0699294508,
-0.0186801795,
0.2618539929,
1.0260174274,
0.8016484976,
0.4188949168,
-0.0403012224,
-0.0713475645,
0.4697887003,
0.0035333626,
-0.9188483357,
0.1004508957,
0.6995327473,
-0.3660648465,
0.0145891299,
-0.2710397542,
-0.892463088,
-0.4969681799,
-0.1593957692,
0.2058213949,
-0.4071927667,
-0.0328527391,
0.0443779938,
-0.2559475005,
0.3183823526,
0.4035163522,
-0.7038205862,
-0.2385677993,
0.4440552592,
0.7861145735,
-0.2842415571,
-0.0135295335,
-0.1674663574,
-0.402014941,
-0.4678388238,
1.0273810625,
-0.603143096,
-0.4077346027,
0.316933006,
0.1945102513,
-0.0622850657,
-0.076154761,
0.7869346738,
-0.2777524292,
0.8551197052,
-0.4077860117,
-0.5597570539,
-0.2678877115,
0.4539104104,
-0.4529215395,
1.100076437,
-0.2402804643,
-0.6542183757,
0.3360325694,
-0.7833839655,
-0.4626030028,
0.2067185789,
-0.0306771994,
0.0118600251,
0.1438305974,
0.1432452351,
0.6915477514,
-0.3102612793,
0.2356772423,
-0.2129466981,
-0.3239168525,
0.1564334333,
-0.4907894135,
0.5648062825,
0.436766535,
-0.4395373166,
-0.0862991959,
-0.6025468707,
-0.0889531747,
0.126969412,
-0.0364251286,
-0.788582921,
0.0348805673,
-0.002420584,
0.1584981829,
0.1639615297,
-0.7301056385,
-0.0361653529,
-0.3173106909,
-0.0887702405,
0.4996742308,
0.0724970698,
0.4373241663,
-0.008310955,
0.92245543,
-0.0419762023,
-0.0785954595,
-0.5053626299,
-0.5986936688,
-0.6526085734,
-0.1733236313,
0.2049493194,
0.841814518,
-0.7575685382,
0.2368699163,
0.3808336258,
-0.567292273,
-0.5528978705,
-0.4875437319,
0.3539076447,
0.6353965402,
0.196321696,
0.1955128312,
-0.4620112181,
-0.6049397588,
-0.2313807011,
-0.2343345881,
-0.0082419151,
0.4974146783,
0.1245729104,
0.0463452749,
0.7831983566,
-0.4151278436,
0.1618075222,
-0.3718057871,
0.5354253054,
0.1574696749,
-0.0199023858,
0.8234634399,
-0.7661710978,
-1.0150997639,
0.1995919347,
-1.0994364023,
-0.6184313297,
-0.3029853702,
-0.1521347463,
0.5909469724,
0.0967179313,
-0.4454665482,
0.3192330599,
0.4029819667,
-0.4452864528,
0.437371999,
0.1775093079,
0.5566380024,
-1.0167549849,
0.1344175339,
0.4018915594,
0.0904171243,
-0.9240399599,
-0.1249610633,
0.1408727169,
-0.3264139295,
-0.7557601333,
1.0533474684,
-0.4470404685,
0.4257681668,
-0.2810735404,
0.0108712548,
0.3565910161,
0.271795094,
0.4608579874,
0.70572263,
0.8489266634,
-0.7247388363,
0.2196879685,
0.2224188596,
0.0559200943,
1.1824194193,
-0.5114026666,
-0.0735422671,
-0.5674545169,
0.0311404895,
-0.8744372725,
-0.2086310089,
0.3200606704,
-0.6548828483,
0.4629257619,
0.1850504428,
0.1349005103,
-0.3494997323,
-0.470823586,
0.1258867532,
0.7079426646,
-0.560770452,
0.428208828,
-0.0483424142,
-0.2501761019,
-0.8558708429,
-0.5992013216,
0.1939678341,
-0.4226023555,
-0.1380017847,
0.0030611907,
-0.3018115759,
-0.3003098369,
0.0579347014,
-0.0122576403,
-0.1369937658,
0.0368675999,
0.3149612844,
0.2872818708,
-0.1544476449,
0.3142489195,
0.0313106216,
-0.1722041517,
0.1283125132,
0.1457488984,
0.1891346574,
0.1896324754,
-0.1454219371,
-0.6241987348,
0.8676519394,
0.5043269992,
-0.1619314104,
0.7786349058,
0.5272877812,
-0.4752855301,
-0.2333839536,
-0.3173350692,
-0.0317725018,
-0.3780070245,
0.155998826,
-0.285289973,
-0.907209754,
0.3518236578,
0.251786381,
-0.0496164262,
0.500507772,
0.4158211052,
-0.5541189909,
1.2357760668,
0.733068347,
-0.2387785167,
0.4954484105,
0.1411200017,
0.4725163281,
-0.4576318562,
-0.0891737416,
-1.074349761,
-0.3323557377,
-0.3340527117,
0.0551636219,
0.2161796689,
-0.1605891734,
0.1452873349,
0.142171219,
-0.5338281393,
0.647767961,
0.305172503,
-0.4056152105,
-0.1568607539,
0.075305514,
0.0879635811,
-0.4598025978,
-0.7509561181,
-0.489425391,
0.6127103567,
0.2277892977,
0.55231148,
-0.1908330023,
0.7894389629,
0.0931910723,
0.4022765458,
-1.2675745487,
0.4385268986,
-0.2276988178,
-0.4463649392,
-0.0029323935,
-0.3359345794,
-1.4863798618,
-0.0885521993,
-0.208810851,
-0.7753522396,
0.3771799505,
0.0695879906,
-0.3694732487,
0.2086160034,
-0.7754047513,
0.9103941917,
-0.1948642433,
-0.1389140487,
0.3072944283,
-0.3939907849,
0.1257580072,
-0.0151632754,
0.3548863828,
-0.2294312268,
-0.0303654242,
0.6525503993,
-0.3572305739,
0.8963452578,
-0.2749831676,
-0.3622399867,
0.4667540193,
0.0812387317,
0.2901477814,
-0.3051630855,
-0.2186815888,
0.1525985599,
-0.1438557953,
-0.1806999594,
-0.7929129601,
0.446872741,
-0.6150432229,
-0.3214382231,
-0.5391353965,
-0.3753980696,
-0.3107523024,
-0.1794620156,
0.5848689675,
0.4178359807,
0.0272035412,
-0.0769353062,
0.679726541,
-0.6511932015,
0.653899312,
0.8417658806,
0.0078157596,
0.069620043,
1.0286769867,
0.2365766019,
0.0201358832,
0.5667698383,
0.3335905373,
-0.3938705623,
-0.1879072636,
-0.3715870082,
0.1612320393,
-0.694459796,
-0.4418395162,
-0.8143074512,
0.0254866388,
-0.2448347956,
-0.5439118743,
0.0086273737,
-0.2613657713,
-0.4547710419,
-0.2463080287,
0.7681076527,
0.5704674721,
-0.0810164139,
0.0648861974,
-1.0938210487,
0.202093482,
0.1632763445,
0.356033206,
-0.1178165376,
-0.4662616849,
-0.0962360054,
-0.4180716574,
0.0076978221,
-1.5212570429,
0.6177762747,
0.2074754238,
0.2592723072,
0.4339999855,
0.4867938757,
0.59101367,
-0.6137335896,
1.118167758,
0.1829276234,
-0.7773169279,
0.6422271729,
-0.2898423672,
0.447342962,
0.3789067566,
1.1812659502,
-1.2132579088,
-0.5981251001,
-0.456731379,
-1.0828434229,
0.7663792968,
-0.229437843,
0.440950036,
-0.5631765723,
0.2195749134,
0.2937032878,
0.1440135092,
-0.8559452295,
-0.3311010897,
0.1471391618,
-0.6377792954,
-0.0023512524,
-0.3861686587,
0.222355172,
0.0827930123,
0.6332719326,
-0.13304618,
0.3478526771,
0.3482079506,
0.0132622905,
-0.3299819529,
0.4641405046,
0.2217587531,
-0.0396140739,
-0.1833332926,
0.1470982879,
0.2294253856,
-0.1317114383,
0.5109539628,
-0.1604547352,
-0.5131543279,
0.4071634114,
0.4453445375,
1.2213242054,
0.131810829,
-0.8059865832,
0.6107831001,
-0.1441891938,
-0.2005307674,
0.044562947,
-0.2425549626,
-0.2392816544,
0.2073108852,
0.1885188818,
-0.2153276652,
0.3913170695,
-0.4899357259,
-0.0888038203,
0.3636297584,
-0.6114123464,
-0.3816762269,
0.5083136559,
0.3910573721,
-0.4142068326,
0.2582488954,
-0.6605255604,
-0.56314224,
0.5569096208,
0.5236200094,
1.0716364384,
-0.4631354511,
0.5871822238,
0.6290597916,
0.1711900234,
0.1859425604,
0.6397721171,
0.1269627064,
-0.7114113569,
-0.6927096844,
-0.5675745606,
-0.6930502653,
-0.0088574039,
-0.6164274812,
0.2396468669,
-0.2954505086,
-0.0234240294,
-0.0894820169,
-0.3451647162,
-0.6365630627,
0.437756747,
0.5280002952,
0.9856646061,
-1.1442788839,
0.3005572259,
1.0321532488,
-0.1375407875,
-1.0458300114,
-0.2456203401,
0.2071718425,
-0.3180052042,
0.5899074078,
0.5425502062,
0.1641010195,
-0.2238555253,
-0.7064029574,
-0.556732595,
0.5248536468,
0.0504318289,
-0.4569954276,
0.3249669969,
-0.1170101017,
0.830483973,
-0.1839968562,
0.759213388,
0.1358011365,
0.4962976575,
0.2350214273,
-0.5320460796,
-0.1974143386,
-0.4126983881,
-0.2136813998,
0.3834821284,
-0.3323525786,
0.6137812138,
0.0383536145,
-0.5281755328,
-0.2964487374,
0.6211469769,
0.0163267702,
0.5672541857,
0.4284285009,
0.2697767913,
0.8677747846,
-0.3479546309,
1.3356450796,
-0.2062277049,
0.1329276115,
0.6707357168,
-0.6908928156,
1.0171273947,
0.3018249571,
-0.2840319872,
0.5693576336,
1.009462595,
0.0553457029,
0.1984417886,
-0.1686753184,
-0.4663037658,
-0.0014809553,
-0.7309773564,
-0.0850505307,
0.1708370596,
0.1901861727,
0.1270432174,
-0.292408675,
0.446608156,
0.3373161852,
0.0695398673,
-0.436765492,
0.8460940123,
0.0046515274,
-0.5439489484,
0.4292477071,
-0.0970038474,
1.0155963898,
-0.7019209862,
0.1899850368,
-0.5735293031,
-0.5711551309,
-0.2851160765,
-0.8045433164,
0.2819458246,
0.807153523,
-0.2020662725,
-0.352202177,
0.6038727164,
-0.6420823336,
-0.3805339634,
0.3508844078,
0.4202696681,
0.4613263011,
-0.0417323075,
-0.7459017038,
-0.1003943607,
-0.0664239451,
-0.6065519452,
0.2361257672,
0.827113986,
-0.1830213219,
0.2864895165,
0.3995261192,
-0.0376633853,
-0.1601376235,
0.3152530193,
0.2193766236,
-0.8098928928,
-0.2631640136,
-0.8142715693,
0.9349184632,
0.0639055595,
-0.2165094167,
0.7687671185,
0.1178652048,
0.4436148405,
-0.3144222498,
0.8518896699,
-0.1989532411,
0.498514384,
-0.3184195757,
0.4657511711,
-0.9060891867,
-0.3883938193,
-0.4168742895,
-0.8721306324,
-0.6055599451,
0.5431122184,
-0.2062773108,
-0.0725681633,
0.9501245022,
0.550622642,
0.463503629,
-0.0264694355,
0.4705860317,
0.0784616917,
0.0378012694,
0.6588259935,
1.0233972073,
-0.2823352218,
0.1536405087,
-0.1609684974,
-0.276537776,
-0.0051166527,
-1.0901854038,
-0.9660710096,
-0.3283868432,
-0.6658257842,
-0.2263891995,
-0.2280172706,
1.1759883165,
0.2185145319,
-1.0583188534,
-0.0020450873,
0.3710087538,
0.1282927394,
0.0642448217,
-0.2783286572,
0.123592712,
-0.5856614709,
-1.1269072294,
0.4331042469,
0.5236708522,
0.2708199918,
0.1633416861,
-0.1670467556,
-0.0281243324,
0.4022615254,
0.7496605515,
0.5362342,
-0.5111965537,
-0.4394846857,
0.3004926741,
-0.1059578881,
0.0092230961,
0.4033842385,
-0.4774664044,
0.4537670016,
0.401851058,
0.7288807034,
-0.1843878627,
-0.3063097298,
0.4613089561,
-0.9653438926,
0.3734190464,
0.2192527652,
0.5672613382,
0.5393322706,
-0.6664949656,
0.4957022667,
0.1121889502,
-0.4967674315,
-0.8907389641,
0.2321774215,
-0.9087556601,
-0.3444173336,
1.1827424765,
-0.2777970433,
-0.4084275961,
0.0997381285,
-0.6493950486,
0.1783560663,
-0.4871308208,
0.5402008891,
1.0177485943,
-0.151113376,
-0.4845973551,
-0.4319005311,
0.4888411462,
0.8713842034,
-1.0870250463,
-0.0342430845,
0.5240051746,
-0.2641110122,
0.1524651498,
0.5835961699,
0.20201689,
0.1103049964,
-0.362092346,
0.4851759374,
0.3821110725,
-0.4452238977,
-0.7925927043,
0.164509654,
-0.0098062847,
0.0322826989
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03221v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03221v1
|
"Define Your Terms" : Enhancing Efficient Offensive Speech Classification with Definition
| 2024-02-05T17:33:22 | 2024-02-05T17:33:22 |
Huy Nghiem, Umang Gupta, Fred Morstatter
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The propagation of offensive content through social media channels has
garnered attention of the research community. Multiple works have proposed
various semantically related yet subtle distinct categories of offensive
speech. In this work, we explore meta-earning approaches to leverage the
diversity of offensive speech corpora to enhance their reliable and efficient
detection. We propose a joint embedding architecture that incorporates the
input's label and definition for classification via Prototypical Network. Our
model achieves at least 75% of the maximal F1-score while using less than 10%
of the available training data across 4 datasets. Our experimental findings
also provide a case study of training strategies valuable to combat resource
scarcity.
|
[
-0.5339469314,
-0.9656744599,
-0.1961831003,
0.2062156945,
-0.2791396081,
0.5184698701,
-0.400719285,
-0.5020608902,
0.5529833436,
0.2829590142,
-0.1188585013,
-0.5593322515,
-0.9515200853,
0.2977848053,
-0.6689578295,
0.9905003309,
0.3609218895,
-0.3009243011,
0.2577649355,
-0.5842331052,
-0.1567236036,
-0.4037071466,
-0.7177848816,
0.2165887505,
0.5716035962,
0.381030947,
0.8319647908,
0.8597995639,
0.3806556463,
0.4516638815,
-0.1118692458,
0.2680288255,
-0.4752675593,
0.2727562189,
-0.4720585942,
-0.0157734137,
-0.3691218793,
0.0165673867,
0.4561411142,
0.3067292571,
-0.2348141819,
0.2521123588,
0.0052458984,
0.0541854464,
-1.1851577759,
-0.0634692237,
-0.8330486417,
0.0803401619,
-0.3350594044,
-0.0635733008,
-0.3913080692,
-0.1322300285,
0.1707207412,
-0.5425865054,
0.1147012636,
-0.4219063222,
0.6304117441,
-0.2245141864,
-0.1541252583,
-0.5330994129,
-0.5047946572,
0.3617730141,
-0.2532261908,
0.4610619247,
0.3123599589,
0.3389543891,
0.5600907207,
-0.9609881043,
-0.5149002075,
0.2260048091,
-0.0834591985,
-0.0635461658,
-0.7430170774,
0.3174602687,
0.0278611537,
0.1239705533,
-0.2732914686,
0.1773034781,
-0.3722559512,
-0.270584017,
0.6838523746,
0.0921543241,
0.2642728984,
-0.073553361,
-0.2028053701,
0.0287104994,
-0.2006734908,
-0.2331641316,
0.5276642442,
0.6539973617,
-0.068382293,
0.2720476687,
-0.2106654346,
0.5217052698,
0.1160850748,
0.0045185247,
0.4713867009,
-0.2476237565,
-0.3818846643,
0.0025294116,
0.8435721993,
0.3196779788,
-0.002905848,
-0.2780192792,
-0.2638843358,
0.1717934161,
0.4348846078,
-0.6889024377,
-0.1042898521,
-0.1472038478,
-0.1678860486,
-0.5384269357,
-0.118674323,
-0.9616726637,
-0.4044427276,
-0.0433111452,
0.4842648506,
-0.4488063455,
-0.45286569,
-0.1959823668,
-0.5801896453,
0.2328979671,
-0.063530989,
-0.9967811108,
0.4632193446,
0.6689525247,
0.8614965081,
0.2831928432,
0.4005911946,
-0.4737235904,
0.0739158541,
-0.3992501199,
0.3185177445,
-0.8328217268,
-0.2985079587,
0.2944023013,
-0.2018817663,
0.0791683868,
-0.6461738348,
0.6843261123,
-0.7134911418,
-0.0216402914,
0.0071805646,
-0.2428307831,
-0.2712101042,
0.2423266172,
-0.4091264307,
0.6270975471,
0.1302248091,
-0.7639535069,
0.5090273023,
-0.7258816361,
-0.7244649529,
0.4953761399,
-0.0041241613,
-0.3571182787,
-0.0213870965,
0.0327749215,
0.4142502248,
0.1155663282,
0.3489367962,
-0.3952402771,
-0.1321068257,
0.1781811118,
-0.3854774237,
0.7658030391,
0.5565040112,
-0.6759381294,
-0.0638555735,
-0.6821531653,
-0.1683724374,
0.0576249696,
-0.2757734656,
-0.7165256143,
0.0407463163,
0.0461728387,
-0.0155643569,
-0.1344121397,
-0.6405110359,
-0.3897913098,
-0.4693907797,
0.3929718137,
0.7960207462,
-0.3782245219,
0.392837882,
-0.0232969876,
0.5064884424,
-0.212462306,
0.0961294994,
0.1592833698,
-0.2855140567,
-0.6728721261,
-0.4374205172,
0.2814611495,
0.8416726589,
-0.8823270798,
0.5713990927,
-0.2759717405,
-0.4070335031,
-0.6675187349,
0.2804577649,
0.6029341817,
0.3707660437,
0.472122103,
-0.0252752788,
-0.897335887,
-0.972363472,
-0.3608436882,
-0.0711417571,
0.0087629836,
0.2724920809,
0.3387740552,
-0.1736142188,
0.9096336365,
-0.2361986339,
-0.3492821157,
-0.3476734161,
0.3650812507,
-0.193831712,
0.1468691528,
0.5924056172,
-1.0848501921,
-0.5732311606,
-0.2327918261,
-0.5038076043,
-0.3360519111,
0.2565465271,
0.2153105289,
-0.1345603168,
0.4518129528,
0.073429212,
0.1413649768,
0.5367815495,
-0.4170363247,
0.1727913469,
0.3595280945,
0.0417119637,
-0.9770362377,
-0.2510258853,
0.1550361812,
-0.4667647779,
-0.8955029249,
0.4695383906,
-0.3636567295,
-0.0832526088,
-0.5765868425,
0.1596100628,
-0.0423061512,
0.3159938455,
-0.2233478129,
0.520698607,
-0.2456743419,
0.1566962749,
0.0896161348,
0.5210117698,
0.4719831347,
-0.7112451196,
0.4828266799,
0.2010329515,
-0.1142739952,
0.6593742371,
-0.561152935,
0.2481106818,
-0.1180112585,
0.015420978,
-1.1592820883,
-0.1493642926,
0.5885798931,
-0.4946165085,
0.3571645319,
0.0056812228,
-0.4104714394,
-0.3311112821,
-0.370601505,
0.348221451,
0.2531841993,
-0.6702715755,
0.6136285067,
0.8545466661,
-0.038237974,
-0.8414533734,
-0.6416057348,
0.2359409779,
-0.5662033558,
-0.4987394512,
0.6566136479,
0.2744000256,
-0.3081767559,
0.075354442,
0.2130242586,
-0.0686521828,
0.2735904157,
0.132464543,
-0.2783783376,
-0.1933965534,
0.5379503369,
-0.050204616,
0.4637035429,
0.1974914819,
0.073589541,
0.3897714019,
-0.063743338,
0.3596722782,
-0.3681276739,
0.3704057336,
0.3258718252,
-0.062319532,
0.6581000686,
1.017434597,
-0.2555190325,
-0.3453538418,
-0.4046456814,
-0.0258331653,
-0.5483609438,
0.6058266759,
-0.3048292994,
-1.0327208042,
0.2256888598,
0.054084152,
0.1862489581,
0.4195334315,
0.3778650463,
0.0681269094,
0.878921628,
0.5484533906,
-0.0854234248,
0.5201776624,
-0.1877886951,
0.116823107,
-0.6111235023,
-0.1568967402,
-0.4778708518,
-0.2998921871,
-0.8032296896,
-0.6276602745,
0.1391345263,
-0.2445189953,
-0.1954779327,
0.5806369781,
-0.4591304064,
0.3612185717,
0.0475717336,
0.2769774497,
-0.2915917635,
-0.0177274607,
0.0069302712,
0.1504924893,
-0.6158211827,
-0.3613723516,
1.1677594185,
0.7282488346,
0.2577055693,
0.5707017183,
0.7284545898,
0.624640882,
0.5970706344,
-0.759393394,
0.4751688242,
-0.6303229928,
-0.877796948,
-0.3427428603,
-0.6104716063,
-0.672640264,
0.4112823904,
-0.5369679928,
-0.7235488296,
0.2036021948,
0.1463462859,
-0.534095943,
0.4363722801,
-0.3777946234,
0.5960225463,
-0.0529457852,
-0.3881554902,
-0.3612681031,
-0.4323849678,
0.5089553595,
-0.1678307801,
0.6783086061,
-0.1045627743,
-0.5049782395,
1.2109879255,
-0.2318349183,
1.169026494,
-0.3020920753,
-0.0171569362,
0.5718502998,
-0.3183450103,
0.0951310024,
0.0242631901,
-0.1060334519,
-0.036521066,
-0.4582916498,
-0.1898892224,
-0.4478428066,
0.1080326885,
-0.5029833317,
-0.3959710002,
-0.0706097484,
-0.1951573193,
-0.1431078315,
-0.0172402859,
0.3044041991,
0.5724303126,
-0.6515735388,
0.341014713,
0.7807866335,
-0.3584507704,
0.4479980469,
0.4252285957,
-0.0023622648,
-0.5808582306,
0.9370660186,
0.0237021893,
0.2321473956,
0.4190603793,
0.3948001564,
-0.508508563,
-0.3909276128,
-0.0375919342,
-0.1115820855,
-0.8231285214,
-0.5284979939,
-0.9908924699,
-0.1519441009,
-0.6482114792,
-0.0489935838,
-0.2744718194,
-0.1776418984,
-0.1821393073,
-0.2314080894,
0.2399623245,
0.7308562398,
-0.5459985733,
0.9469784498,
-0.4846481681,
0.4017025232,
0.5324007869,
0.2831016481,
-0.2651846409,
-0.9086680412,
-0.0905084983,
0.1120945811,
-0.4581617415,
-1.0976366997,
0.3113833964,
0.6422074437,
0.590351522,
0.8639087081,
0.096433647,
0.6160281301,
-0.2849397957,
0.4914421737,
0.3201054931,
-1.1790934801,
0.4233051836,
-0.1114509255,
-0.1312949955,
0.5598574877,
0.7785981894,
-0.3542166054,
-0.6074452996,
-0.7950543761,
-0.9440336227,
0.3882867396,
0.0546082109,
0.7873570919,
-0.5769149661,
-0.0728955045,
-0.2988280654,
0.1550089121,
-0.700528264,
-0.3561122417,
-0.1298499852,
-0.0277089886,
-0.0491810068,
-0.3941710293,
-0.3610405326,
-0.4148144424,
0.4834785163,
0.029206058,
0.3874189556,
-0.1605399251,
-0.1890265048,
0.2081580162,
0.2829017937,
0.675958395,
0.5184769034,
-0.1515678316,
0.2212042511,
0.4129982889,
-0.5802206993,
0.1020379141,
-0.2119737118,
0.158640489,
0.4745610356,
0.372227639,
0.7392894626,
0.4661439657,
-0.4699519575,
0.821500957,
0.0531269871,
-0.4357042909,
-0.1535265148,
0.0162377581,
-0.0339984447,
0.2334972173,
0.1668548733,
0.0180561654,
0.4656261504,
-0.6810424924,
0.6432034373,
0.4693754613,
-0.4232931137,
-0.0862942412,
0.325550288,
0.6302955151,
-0.3322245479,
0.4773002863,
-0.6315199137,
-1.013995409,
0.3854285181,
0.55659163,
0.9317989349,
-0.4842187166,
0.5748013258,
0.4092825055,
0.324577868,
0.4299199581,
0.0720465705,
-0.1091215909,
-1.0147440434,
-0.1496805847,
-0.8048593402,
-0.0230994411,
0.2748680115,
-0.5482262969,
0.3686330914,
-0.9482911229,
-0.4590287209,
0.401730746,
-0.4140924811,
-0.4886429608,
0.1873694509,
0.6264870167,
0.9291977882,
-1.1312401295,
0.5330740809,
0.4139690995,
-0.2125346512,
-0.7132543325,
-0.3249716163,
0.1794902384,
-0.9002382159,
0.9963991046,
0.0970635116,
-0.1666307896,
-0.1611477584,
-0.3513175845,
-0.5416921377,
0.6132986546,
-0.102691561,
-0.4871253073,
-0.0817355812,
0.096491091,
0.4979192615,
-0.7176168561,
0.2313893735,
0.6655640602,
0.2438714653,
0.0859584063,
-0.7631137371,
0.0230997037,
0.0276918225,
-0.1339043677,
0.2401747704,
-0.331532985,
0.5873814821,
-0.0096415197,
-0.6030598879,
-0.2424907237,
0.6689019203,
-0.3885568678,
0.3406495154,
0.7361936569,
0.7299836874,
0.743689239,
-0.082657665,
0.5384700894,
0.1044989079,
0.0320514627,
1.0174576044,
0.306042701,
0.8816506863,
-0.0181304552,
-0.1783462912,
0.6187927127,
0.4515308738,
-0.0710643306,
0.6091934443,
0.4929583371,
-0.5258961916,
-0.0747393817,
-0.3677307367,
-0.1578566283,
1.0957641602,
0.8743779659,
-0.8277590871,
-0.270396024,
0.3479254842,
0.1513552517,
0.3658044934,
-0.5582557321,
1.028080821,
-0.0852573141,
-0.0405080467,
0.5585368872,
0.2388433665,
1.0446509123,
-0.4245253801,
0.1891961992,
-0.0068681207,
-0.0933541283,
-0.3244832754,
-0.5701591969,
0.6229048371,
0.0906122103,
0.1296329945,
-0.1052057371,
0.4366203547,
-0.4676162899,
-0.2191042304,
0.5021310449,
0.1821552813,
0.0629472435,
0.0198918954,
-0.8711580634,
0.1647243947,
-0.2528562546,
0.3759490252,
0.0385317989,
0.4403867126,
0.1886035949,
0.280204922,
0.4189880788,
0.2094084471,
0.284217298,
-0.0305467155,
0.8306564093,
-0.2303278893,
-0.5439755321,
-1.1333706379,
0.2956088185,
-0.3892080784,
-0.3740209937,
0.3538898826,
0.4767902493,
0.9431151152,
0.1404939592,
0.7880405784,
-0.4236785173,
0.4813029766,
-0.13925834,
0.4790602326,
-0.2902354896,
0.1432751417,
-0.647320509,
-0.6667121649,
-0.1857442111,
0.5193962455,
-0.1806196868,
-0.1325579882,
0.2336937636,
0.6860820651,
-0.1359176934,
0.1323384941,
0.5098100901,
-0.080022648,
0.1819981635,
0.3439894319,
0.6616355181,
-0.3901677728,
0.6957666874,
-0.4142910838,
-0.5135801435,
-0.3383606672,
-0.6906591654,
-0.843149662,
-0.5592184663,
-0.5354999304,
-0.3784346282,
0.4167242944,
0.8227321506,
0.8440310359,
-0.7150540948,
-0.3299481869,
0.2269288152,
0.1941640228,
-0.207027927,
-0.2787185609,
0.0749196634,
-0.5973305106,
-0.5539425611,
0.3082062304,
0.0412773676,
-0.1908353269,
0.0546548367,
0.0371989086,
-0.639531672,
0.2616136968,
0.9505809546,
0.2566872835,
-0.4601955116,
-0.387127012,
-0.2460669428,
-0.0420246162,
-0.2293911576,
0.6140112281,
-0.4518846273,
0.5764216185,
0.3827256858,
0.9844147563,
-0.1832895577,
0.3032436669,
0.5490448475,
-1.1281063557,
0.0621813461,
0.3902043998,
0.0854644105,
0.3982236683,
-0.3425714076,
0.4328447282,
0.4530124664,
-0.0794159025,
-0.6265027523,
0.1105613858,
-0.5109300017,
-0.4683343172,
1.0470175743,
-0.2671326101,
-0.0539782606,
-0.2362138927,
0.2885412872,
0.5519236326,
-0.3999993801,
0.6599664092,
0.4102787673,
0.2339368463,
-0.1560511291,
-0.3277963102,
0.8562255502,
0.1093209684,
-0.4905028939,
0.101103954,
0.2064404488,
0.3790407777,
0.6079092622,
0.503497839,
-0.0313303508,
0.3184813857,
0.1253402829,
-0.3038733006,
-0.0072359224,
-0.4816887379,
-0.3147093058,
0.5526570678,
-0.3296067715,
-0.7094491124
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03216v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03216v4
|
BGE M3-Embedding: Multi-Lingual, Multi-Functionality, Multi-Granularity Text Embeddings Through Self-Knowledge Distillation
| 2024-02-05T17:26:49 | 2024-06-28T09:55:49 |
Jianlv Chen, Shitao Xiao, Peitian Zhang, Kun Luo, Defu Lian, Zheng Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In this paper, we present a new embedding model, called M3-Embedding, which
is distinguished for its versatility in Multi-Linguality, Multi-Functionality,
and Multi-Granularity. It can support more than 100 working languages, leading
to new state-of-the-art performances on multi-lingual and cross-lingual
retrieval tasks. It can simultaneously perform the three common retrieval
functionalities of embedding model: dense retrieval, multi-vector retrieval,
and sparse retrieval, which provides a unified model foundation for real-world
IR applications. It is able to process inputs of different granularities,
spanning from short sentences to long documents of up to 8192 tokens. The
effective training of M3-Embedding involves the following technical
contributions. We propose a novel self-knowledge distillation approach, where
the relevance scores from different retrieval functionalities can be integrated
as the teacher signal to enhance the training quality. We also optimize the
batching strategy, enabling a large batch size and high training throughput to
ensure the discriminativeness of embeddings. To the best of our knowledge,
M3-Embedding is the first embedding model which realizes such a strong
versatility. The model and code will be publicly available at
https://github.com/FlagOpen/FlagEmbedding.
|
[
-0.6480184793,
-0.649209559,
0.5860167742,
0.0405936316,
-0.2202401757,
-0.0129568521,
0.0182979926,
-0.1630202383,
0.1220004931,
0.2968468964,
-0.1165137365,
-0.5009006858,
-0.8840846419,
-0.0533142984,
-0.266200304,
0.8786956668,
-0.1307418197,
0.347889185,
-0.3229416609,
-0.3461638689,
-0.2989889085,
-0.5786837339,
-0.0644692481,
-0.4074604809,
0.3707005978,
0.432185173,
0.4866205156,
0.5043898225,
0.4715545774,
0.2508214116,
0.0762258843,
0.1287652403,
-0.46852687,
-0.19978109,
-0.3044039905,
-0.2125365883,
-0.297242552,
-0.02165257,
0.7896265388,
0.5174550414,
-0.3192055821,
0.1301044077,
0.3299256563,
0.7516219616,
-0.7547182441,
0.1932976991,
-0.5684346557,
0.1950331479,
0.1815172732,
0.1859342903,
-0.3846340775,
-0.0265187304,
0.257627964,
-0.2371394485,
-0.0838750899,
0.0886683464,
0.6647875309,
0.1056585088,
-0.5297427773,
-0.4521870911,
-0.528239727,
0.881991446,
-0.6067041755,
0.5786270499,
0.4176388681,
0.4395036101,
0.2717799246,
-0.8033232689,
-0.3916344941,
-0.097873047,
-0.1288323551,
0.0346465595,
-0.0419475622,
-0.0045396532,
-0.0818150565,
0.5761710405,
-0.374651432,
-0.2037650794,
-0.1165921316,
-0.0256725419,
0.2614610493,
-0.1964166462,
0.0102761397,
-0.0280763153,
-0.632550478,
0.1190594211,
-0.5041473508,
-0.3923176229,
0.2493727803,
0.1448040605,
0.0129990131,
0.4752656519,
-0.2287508696,
0.6081087589,
0.1167396978,
-0.2833170295,
0.2998802662,
-0.2150451094,
-0.1933717281,
-0.1162945777,
0.8286933303,
-0.017815249,
-0.1023087054,
-0.1117899269,
-0.39201352,
-0.4862591922,
0.149725765,
-1.0300396681,
-0.0880334824,
-0.0833421126,
-0.5468226075,
-0.2801266611,
0.1855447739,
-0.5116855502,
-0.0989080518,
-0.1970635951,
0.9437761903,
-0.5876931548,
-0.4250011444,
0.4060582519,
-0.1981754452,
0.0280742235,
0.1027306765,
-1.1069467068,
0.1445668489,
0.5350689888,
0.9463906884,
0.244114548,
-0.4945113659,
-0.1977126896,
0.3638476431,
0.1195392311,
0.4614189267,
-0.6069423556,
-0.5378266573,
0.0259428974,
-0.2698841989,
0.033457011,
-0.5071957111,
0.0715095252,
-0.6084294915,
0.2876425385,
-0.0951474234,
-0.7730444074,
-0.5468190312,
0.4749123752,
-0.689262867,
1.0092785358,
0.1134761423,
-0.7810284495,
0.2657870054,
-0.569452107,
-0.1608953923,
-0.1417847425,
-0.1962042004,
-0.6058595777,
0.0389667749,
0.2294468433,
0.7543292046,
-0.2664136291,
0.4338227212,
-0.4130269885,
-0.3288931251,
0.0209026597,
-0.4785666764,
0.5692862272,
0.3182447851,
-0.181309998,
-0.4300737381,
-0.4208560884,
-0.1850339323,
-0.1774805635,
-0.3943908811,
-0.4299500883,
-0.186635673,
-0.0689094961,
0.2541142702,
0.6146246195,
-0.5826687813,
0.3796865642,
0.1532340646,
0.1667873859,
0.4262965322,
-0.0651810467,
0.5424672365,
-0.3747241199,
0.2820214927,
0.3009555042,
0.1747588813,
-0.3281868696,
-0.3344917297,
-0.4230436087,
-0.624112606,
0.4908620715,
0.4923520684,
-0.6582671404,
0.4962523878,
-0.275480479,
-0.6162359118,
-0.6557523608,
0.3863449693,
0.5300836563,
0.3144635856,
0.5677151084,
-0.0941610485,
-0.3917657137,
-0.9689136147,
0.0223316029,
0.0682556033,
0.1738518924,
0.2225331366,
0.708746016,
-0.5775692463,
0.9373242855,
-0.7175148726,
-0.5885255337,
-0.4208266735,
0.328764528,
0.1190770566,
0.5989158154,
0.5905848742,
-0.6710478663,
-0.6510132551,
0.0327560008,
-0.9699870348,
0.3297067285,
0.1432305723,
-0.1899474561,
0.1207552403,
0.6105236411,
-0.2215652913,
0.0995565653,
0.7546082735,
-0.1139017865,
0.3428448439,
-0.3818250299,
0.0968622118,
-1.434781909,
0.0124482391,
-0.0532422289,
-0.383495152,
-0.4503033161,
0.1203026325,
0.3974585235,
-0.0766365007,
-0.4896616638,
0.5356428027,
-0.6892653704,
0.0848804042,
-0.2919633687,
0.2174230963,
0.2742766738,
0.4613846242,
-0.0967354476,
0.606859684,
0.7357949018,
-0.7035440803,
0.0985484645,
0.2632638216,
-0.4939204454,
0.5051333904,
-0.4110023677,
-0.0446787253,
-0.2547795177,
0.1194698066,
-0.7919473052,
0.233962819,
-0.1288437843,
-0.3570524156,
0.5720908642,
-0.7567592263,
-0.5507436991,
-0.1674634218,
-0.3819070756,
0.3355197608,
0.4696843922,
-0.6622563004,
0.7794647217,
0.6015805602,
0.0417846963,
-0.8371391892,
-0.7571274042,
-0.0754558891,
-0.1716048867,
-0.4899171293,
0.4841130376,
-0.0382923484,
0.2040289789,
0.1820744127,
-0.0301194172,
-0.0459222905,
0.1682362258,
-0.1363616139,
0.0852762833,
-0.0100182109,
0.2539702058,
0.3255939186,
-0.2317829579,
-0.2043307126,
-0.6064098477,
0.3674976528,
-0.2054152042,
-0.6313474774,
-0.2951490879,
0.5424351692,
0.519005537,
-0.3369973898,
0.8867045045,
0.9858312607,
-0.3361702263,
-0.1540291309,
-0.7223972082,
-0.1637092233,
-0.5480650663,
0.4723362327,
-0.5307745337,
-1.2232065201,
0.3617021739,
-0.3305186331,
0.100911364,
0.1943317503,
0.4215213358,
-0.2207819074,
1.0506882668,
0.8039960265,
-0.3087285459,
0.611580193,
-0.6402171254,
0.1913026422,
-0.9537191987,
-0.3607339263,
-0.2874757349,
-0.2477052361,
-0.6784915924,
-0.5593649149,
0.4690115452,
0.1133743748,
-0.2239253223,
-0.0287165307,
-0.3469708264,
0.4275975823,
0.4894833565,
-0.0959130377,
0.1366788149,
0.0780125484,
-0.5063025355,
0.1541107744,
-0.6667515635,
-0.5340568423,
1.0942304134,
0.4197613001,
0.9418722987,
0.4536445737,
1.2012878656,
0.3209230006,
0.1212513074,
-0.8754656315,
0.3918746114,
-0.3493624628,
-0.7787036896,
-0.2570193112,
-0.3465960622,
-0.747654438,
0.6544097066,
-0.2337292284,
-0.5960565209,
0.0243855957,
0.07505586,
-0.0929786935,
0.601949513,
-0.8267560005,
0.9572675824,
-0.0227001458,
-0.2815276682,
-0.2254126966,
-0.2546201944,
0.197465837,
-0.0138885081,
0.2877717912,
-0.1943163276,
0.0458351746,
0.5371569395,
-0.181039229,
0.7565137744,
-0.5769932866,
-0.0131925391,
0.4379056692,
0.1879134178,
0.3239950836,
0.2904910147,
-0.1979118586,
0.2309763283,
0.1290728301,
-0.4177565575,
-0.7589738369,
0.7213377357,
-0.7412392497,
-0.8035181165,
-0.4608826935,
-0.0779099539,
-0.1407883614,
0.4286389351,
0.0016999809,
0.6565306783,
-0.3494724631,
0.5030280948,
0.8978031874,
0.1793281138,
0.5931684375,
0.5790817142,
-0.6441161633,
-0.5466823578,
1.1133327484,
0.1121611074,
0.1274862587,
0.637830019,
0.333342135,
-0.3617084622,
-0.5914799571,
-0.5379591584,
0.2462442219,
-0.6714293361,
-0.4247975647,
-0.8487146497,
-0.2549190819,
-0.2803314924,
-0.2227861136,
-0.6385825276,
-0.2547460496,
-0.4389167428,
-0.1475043595,
0.2511415482,
0.9993174076,
-0.2939565778,
0.3015132546,
-1.1645379066,
0.1741368622,
0.5234791636,
0.6779380441,
0.0660502315,
-0.6076117158,
-0.9524774551,
0.0799334347,
-0.3821024597,
-0.7806720734,
0.3797541261,
0.2483399808,
0.7953360677,
0.4301939309,
-0.2301474363,
0.5962411165,
-0.5530614853,
0.6028108597,
0.0833568722,
-1.1536692381,
0.4076382518,
-0.2975999117,
0.3968407512,
0.9157221317,
0.7647903562,
-0.3780122399,
-0.1442531049,
-0.2929382026,
-0.7696879506,
0.5564933419,
-0.1410981566,
0.3412884474,
-0.016343385,
0.2286567986,
0.3535300195,
0.1861893982,
-0.7289944887,
-0.3342601061,
-0.3922717571,
-0.3526496291,
0.0714751631,
-0.5240772367,
-0.0714137554,
-0.2957982421,
0.816665411,
-0.2424661517,
0.4166657627,
0.1624998599,
-0.4670875072,
0.5359954834,
0.1741400957,
0.1608146876,
0.4613733888,
-0.3591429293,
0.32289657,
0.2268121541,
-0.6104412079,
0.2491298467,
0.1020583138,
-0.0731265545,
-0.004062464,
0.0852543414,
0.6299224496,
0.3704544604,
-0.146663636,
0.5532159805,
-0.0993492976,
-0.2547825277,
-0.3491107821,
-0.0196806658,
0.1365140826,
0.2289302051,
0.4642181993,
-0.3215034008,
0.5340572596,
-0.5701690316,
0.3756127656,
0.5658751726,
-0.3050673008,
-0.0517710261,
0.1913126111,
0.2016976625,
0.1434473395,
0.4005500674,
-0.6248365045,
-0.4734778404,
0.1586138457,
0.5350344777,
0.8259507418,
-0.2549217343,
0.3525134325,
0.5386801958,
0.1243261173,
-0.2444901764,
0.3497186005,
-0.1491719633,
-0.737431109,
-0.0706641153,
-0.6390506625,
-0.4602020979,
-0.2761616111,
-0.7020274401,
0.4019882679,
-0.3215332031,
-0.2576272488,
-0.1968574822,
0.0777848288,
-0.6366055608,
0.0867396668,
0.1381208301,
0.7775138617,
-0.6580978632,
1.0080187321,
0.7728899717,
-0.4250785708,
-0.5381420255,
0.0108112143,
-0.1473874897,
-0.606456995,
0.4802539945,
0.3570849001,
-0.3390422165,
0.2122479528,
-0.1905825138,
-1.2238335609,
1.6612488031,
0.2151050717,
-0.4829639196,
0.1481754929,
0.0160392374,
0.2376433462,
-0.5422796607,
0.4043735862,
0.2432572246,
0.3509059548,
0.1259414107,
-0.7305788994,
-0.069144778,
0.0135673424,
0.1666765213,
0.1139609292,
-0.799116075,
0.5734241605,
-0.0484462157,
-0.1005890742,
-0.3300457299,
0.8405088782,
0.1181133166,
0.1585306972,
0.2124578357,
0.8508630395,
0.7431773543,
0.0269456524,
0.8837903738,
-0.5320749283,
0.6197761893,
1.0127168894,
-0.1439079642,
0.9008372426,
0.377034992,
-0.1094143465,
0.8175936937,
0.0868702829,
-0.1098884866,
0.8901945353,
0.0347090401,
-0.4893129468,
-0.0741270334,
0.1689843684,
-0.3508539498,
0.6102987528,
0.3810068369,
-0.3209651709,
-0.2564330697,
0.1645929813,
0.1862439066,
-0.2172232121,
-0.1816095561,
0.9375576377,
0.1163031831,
-0.616699636,
0.494368881,
0.3077120781,
1.0160984993,
-0.7547116876,
0.0153845111,
-0.2763217092,
0.0408232585,
-0.1604714245,
-0.8310313821,
0.2854290307,
-0.2792023718,
-0.1541628093,
-0.3562787473,
0.6558789611,
-0.6094889641,
-0.4604115784,
0.4643085897,
0.8443354368,
-0.082331039,
0.0216097608,
-0.6683775783,
-0.0837198198,
-0.0114500802,
-0.287876457,
0.5647753477,
0.7501849532,
0.4824907184,
0.7701129317,
0.4239140749,
-0.3074935377,
-0.0082860868,
0.1671341956,
0.8987451196,
-0.6185293198,
-0.4123663902,
-0.9927526712,
0.5279160738,
0.104658857,
0.0525084361,
0.6785244942,
0.7237673998,
0.7552910447,
-0.1990585029,
0.9062049389,
0.0538617373,
0.0661214888,
-0.5559402704,
0.862567246,
-0.6702705026,
0.1900475472,
-0.1893095076,
-0.822791636,
-0.1533910036,
0.6962394118,
-0.0366490334,
0.3915250301,
0.7502484918,
0.8041904569,
-0.3050663173,
-0.1774777025,
0.6386940479,
-0.1130973846,
0.2605696321,
0.266923815,
0.6007765532,
-0.4013497531,
0.5313017368,
-0.1882096231,
-0.216591686,
-0.4622864127,
-0.9513049722,
-0.9797879457,
-0.9074569941,
-0.3228736818,
-0.000304058,
-0.0905174315,
0.8587514162,
0.8241516352,
-0.4786127806,
-0.1687241644,
0.1981673837,
0.3220284283,
0.0068192766,
-0.1963186264,
0.185575068,
-0.4398678243,
-0.7224298716,
0.3034488261,
0.2955596447,
0.3825633526,
-0.702932775,
-0.0172386374,
-0.613414228,
0.121406436,
0.7074873447,
-0.0741942003,
-0.326546967,
-0.2072533369,
-0.2059486061,
-0.2599382997,
-0.0138234962,
0.6357243061,
-0.7724048495,
0.4908781946,
0.3801819086,
0.6671733856,
0.7725412846,
-0.3583306968,
0.3963805437,
-0.9392816424,
-0.0032457926,
0.0625122786,
0.6826261878,
0.4557577372,
-0.2453012615,
0.3974187672,
-0.0110700494,
-0.5194616318,
-0.5718786716,
0.2559562624,
-0.7027859688,
-0.3446536362,
1.1346460581,
-0.5440798402,
0.0033896526,
-0.0878759548,
-0.121731028,
0.3358865082,
-0.3779866695,
0.9214498401,
0.9030672312,
0.112210542,
-0.0630853325,
-0.3567016721,
0.3218618333,
0.3861123621,
-0.5250826478,
-0.2311586589,
0.3640263975,
0.4559485018,
0.1815127283,
0.5759635568,
-0.3122003973,
0.031931255,
0.1253125966,
0.1489834934,
-0.5163951516,
-0.4123302698,
-0.3496360779,
0.2063263506,
0.3184430599,
-0.2199804783
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03191v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03191v3
|
Isotropy, Clusters, and Classifiers
| 2024-02-05T16:57:24 | 2024-05-27T10:21:08 |
Timothee Mickus, Stig-Arne Grönroos, Joseph Attieh
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Whether embedding spaces use all their dimensions equally, i.e., whether they
are isotropic, has been a recent subject of discussion. Evidence has been
accrued both for and against enforcing isotropy in embedding spaces. In the
present paper, we stress that isotropy imposes requirements on the embedding
space that are not compatible with the presence of clusters -- which also
negatively impacts linear classification objectives. We demonstrate this fact
both mathematically and empirically and use it to shed light on previous
results from the literature.
|
[
-0.3454984426,
-0.2571466565,
0.7779687047,
0.4297718406,
-0.0842256024,
-0.1747502089,
-0.2483531535,
-0.592033267,
0.4000299871,
-0.0326776281,
0.2355303913,
-0.7882563472,
-0.6475085616,
0.138923943,
-0.6125454903,
0.7421014905,
-0.3374404609,
-0.2078396231,
-0.9815677404,
-0.6197757125,
-0.1809895486,
-0.5861683488,
0.0953657404,
0.105993107,
0.5068590641,
0.4663639069,
1.0245329142,
0.976266861,
0.4594453275,
0.2374330908,
-0.0171150286,
-0.282604903,
-0.0826644748,
0.2692083418,
0.3638006151,
-0.508136332,
-0.1048513055,
0.1402193159,
0.9617961049,
0.772275269,
-0.4039150476,
-0.1267597228,
0.277428329,
0.3451931775,
-1.0465883017,
-0.1028364822,
-0.4396073818,
0.3980287015,
0.2581892312,
0.038038861,
-0.0085597346,
-0.7784280181,
-0.1631190181,
-0.7068213224,
0.5087911487,
0.0101978919,
0.6976062655,
0.5523932576,
-0.5761903524,
-0.452037394,
-0.9177375436,
0.6031532288,
-0.2806985974,
0.4413277805,
0.2819206119,
0.217210561,
0.2107116878,
-0.6544678211,
-0.3450471759,
-0.1576961726,
-0.2951430678,
-0.0760615394,
-0.3683015108,
0.3200580776,
0.4499281645,
0.1756206155,
-0.3676594198,
0.6057969928,
-0.9714164734,
0.2036285549,
0.5096887946,
0.1741451621,
0.2391498387,
0.1144963801,
-0.8369660974,
-0.0379958376,
-0.6316338778,
0.3059099913,
0.319223702,
0.2990819216,
-0.1209850237,
0.7565925121,
0.3804424405,
0.7208371162,
0.0104789604,
0.0044536297,
0.116490379,
0.038017612,
0.0596535206,
0.4820334613,
0.4501336515,
0.6339842081,
-0.103633292,
-0.0529168136,
0.1117314249,
0.4156063497,
0.4498732984,
-0.7660999298,
-0.049818363,
0.4968960583,
-0.2774920166,
-0.3895520866,
0.4346881807,
-0.5233321786,
-0.4234322011,
-0.0958588719,
0.208879739,
-0.1935673952,
0.1448385566,
0.0490510389,
-0.5418639183,
0.063374117,
0.3756493032,
-0.6844249368,
0.2639202178,
0.702183187,
0.654279232,
-0.0788646117,
-0.5172287822,
0.2436843961,
0.1585549712,
-0.3220650852,
0.8942627907,
-1.0785648823,
-0.5311014652,
-0.0007782675,
-0.1391569078,
-0.158422187,
-0.6674803495,
0.3106617332,
0.1969505548,
-0.0127021046,
-0.354944855,
-0.5496025085,
-0.0949124917,
0.0427465737,
-0.4383896291,
0.3939326406,
0.1561740637,
-0.4134555757,
0.7931492925,
-0.0648638532,
-0.3372402191,
-0.1135533378,
-0.5922536254,
-0.6634734273,
0.4828576148,
-0.317381531,
0.1349335909,
0.1108709872,
0.1460101455,
-0.8839557767,
-0.2874801457,
0.4142667949,
0.0259426255,
0.5480174422,
0.4613859653,
-0.0661471561,
-0.3073112071,
-0.9844582677,
0.2569650412,
-0.3717117608,
-0.5460084081,
-0.390108794,
0.3465874195,
0.2983258069,
0.2928395867,
0.1175036281,
-0.7444921732,
0.3175005019,
0.5754836202,
0.5290071964,
0.6999450326,
-0.4293617606,
0.6803433299,
-0.351167798,
0.7213052511,
0.1029443368,
0.0403966904,
0.5705086589,
-0.3901794255,
-0.1554594934,
-0.5912163854,
0.1154940352,
0.3369487226,
-0.0918337852,
0.675801158,
0.1806941479,
-0.5601527095,
-0.241360724,
0.2853915095,
0.281549871,
-0.2234224975,
0.2122866809,
-0.0596562661,
-0.7376497388,
-0.9078947306,
-0.1861537546,
-0.2129077464,
0.1702948213,
0.3888382018,
0.2870376408,
-0.3418157697,
0.9556373954,
-0.4684736729,
-0.4652532041,
0.3040323555,
-0.2820263505,
-0.1613782197,
0.6149007082,
1.0621291399,
-0.5418643355,
-0.4469312131,
-0.2578901947,
-0.9903301001,
-0.1810344309,
0.0848243311,
0.366246134,
-0.0006044892,
1.0721126795,
-0.7336930037,
0.8069016933,
0.6008275151,
-0.6219751835,
0.316532135,
-0.3464583755,
-0.4676901698,
-0.6079083085,
-0.1905747801,
0.3035772443,
-0.0893873051,
-0.5518864989,
0.1231289431,
0.125273183,
-0.2566769719,
-0.299382925,
0.197758019,
-0.12123283,
-0.1004004031,
-0.265381217,
0.135254696,
0.1916424334,
-0.1797776073,
-0.0224358421,
0.1739093363,
0.4516016543,
-0.6724447608,
0.2276160419,
0.4487526119,
-0.164887324,
0.9581762552,
-0.6338450313,
-0.4081745148,
-0.5100751519,
0.6371282935,
-1.1017975807,
0.1701442599,
-0.2951434553,
-0.4761268795,
0.2120251209,
0.227003485,
-0.2694011331,
-0.1929982007,
-0.571651876,
0.6786020994,
0.4111937881,
-0.6344743371,
0.471701175,
0.1694940478,
0.6035251021,
-0.6491567492,
-0.705490768,
-0.4692752659,
-0.6880365014,
-0.1221402362,
0.2572089434,
0.4650970697,
-0.6172469854,
0.6211544871,
-0.4560707211,
-0.0554634593,
0.1174027026,
0.6564618945,
-0.1178977489,
-0.0025587382,
0.0629460588,
-0.0635019019,
-0.2460567504,
0.2764996886,
-0.5314847827,
0.2775386572,
-0.0798247233,
-0.3991405666,
-0.319409579,
0.2428711951,
0.8247244954,
0.4120744765,
0.836856842,
0.832914412,
-0.2498005778,
-0.2919510603,
-0.4581249356,
0.1596014202,
-0.5017794371,
0.4322059155,
-0.2808971703,
-1.2408891916,
0.6972790956,
0.4330670238,
0.0281118937,
0.5002118349,
0.1489438713,
-0.6283690929,
0.9238969684,
0.659745872,
0.0097364346,
0.2665210366,
-0.0848163962,
0.5339335203,
-1.0627182722,
-0.418736726,
-1.0851294994,
-0.945735693,
-1.2319190502,
-0.0430104509,
0.578315258,
0.1414156407,
-0.3086102307,
0.5049048662,
-0.5324549079,
0.3277477026,
0.3769381046,
0.0801434666,
-0.1556008607,
0.1318567395,
0.0450166352,
0.0471806079,
-0.9801366329,
-0.0906577855,
0.8527913094,
0.2140239179,
1.2058871984,
0.3336903453,
0.6226798892,
0.0582836978,
-0.0617675669,
-0.6201509237,
0.1591982692,
-0.3575308919,
-0.7963657975,
-0.1778951138,
-0.3786266744,
-1.4674729109,
0.2637302876,
-0.1660917103,
-0.7033044696,
1.1260875463,
0.099247843,
-0.4068458974,
0.7106513977,
-0.4987609684,
0.6793702841,
-0.2927609682,
-0.1596406847,
-0.3379372656,
-0.3345366716,
0.081600666,
0.0852231234,
0.3510662913,
-0.0923975334,
-0.1309938431,
0.4021897912,
-0.6843990088,
1.1830185652,
-0.6371328235,
0.1603935957,
0.4434103668,
0.296415627,
-0.1964839846,
-0.1443823427,
0.5304267406,
0.047290694,
0.5703555942,
-0.7376816273,
-0.5847365856,
0.777341187,
-1.3465044498,
-0.6609847546,
-0.5707879663,
-0.5676385164,
0.0108416677,
-0.4329390228,
0.5057300329,
0.2531875372,
-0.3617857099,
0.7555851936,
0.4189903736,
-0.3824541569,
0.2535407543,
0.0868859291,
-0.5143563151,
0.0016289661,
1.0028111935,
0.586809814,
0.5248478055,
-0.0362603925,
0.2136841714,
-0.1731109917,
-0.195587039,
0.0540855043,
-0.1579011679,
-0.6969093084,
-0.2157494426,
-0.5333698392,
-0.4046254456,
-0.5120710135,
-0.6420294046,
-0.1184257641,
-1.1231993437,
-0.1962632835,
-0.3838046193,
0.2145901918,
0.8092938066,
-0.6744107008,
0.2556625903,
-0.8688332438,
0.0274779871,
0.6205725074,
0.2184031755,
-0.157983005,
-0.4026786983,
-0.2224916369,
-0.4504073858,
-0.3259791732,
-0.4580876529,
-0.2731107771,
0.3243845403,
0.9610622525,
1.0171657801,
-0.0933015049,
0.254360199,
-0.306148231,
0.3986400962,
0.2757413685,
-0.6962507963,
0.3273343742,
-0.1948499978,
-0.0286739375,
0.7044845223,
0.7732911706,
-0.4368117154,
-0.1611624509,
-0.9315010905,
-0.829868257,
0.143528074,
-0.0069150096,
0.0451240614,
0.0915644392,
0.397488445,
0.1357461512,
0.3382285535,
-0.6978911757,
-0.1036262512,
-0.0365405381,
-0.062399555,
-0.1208893806,
-0.4039022624,
-0.2132957578,
-0.6101227403,
-0.075389795,
0.2212617993,
0.425303787,
0.0705844536,
-0.0054339813,
-0.1789200902,
0.0497389473,
0.3730066717,
0.8547933102,
-0.2088332027,
0.4017744958,
0.1520110667,
-0.4625912607,
0.6850335002,
-0.1285699159,
-0.2354628444,
-0.0395600647,
0.3419293463,
0.5163646936,
0.0147457747,
-0.1134453788,
0.429466188,
0.2054227293,
-0.6360498071,
-0.4248021841,
0.222649008,
-0.4441838562,
0.0565622225,
-0.2725296021,
0.4146652818,
-0.178354457,
-0.5708920956,
0.0372752026,
0.5395376086,
-0.8066568971,
-0.2977879941,
0.4545615613,
-0.0456596576,
-0.1641285568,
0.8044213057,
0.0219312366,
-0.7982888818,
0.9560164213,
0.6222761273,
0.9707133174,
-0.4729587734,
0.2027476281,
0.5149674416,
0.5626422763,
0.0396510102,
0.0088898754,
-0.388199091,
-1.1848597527,
0.243099004,
-0.4876003861,
-0.4784905314,
-0.5603911877,
-0.9249771833,
0.0486737825,
-1.1333571672,
-0.0125471968,
-0.0567137264,
-0.8072787523,
-0.5174108148,
0.0296944156,
0.2145231068,
0.6928961873,
-1.4709010124,
0.5766507983,
0.9527083039,
-0.1152472794,
-0.3342473209,
-0.2342804819,
0.3549624383,
-0.8909687996,
0.4155704081,
0.2632376552,
0.0193738788,
-0.4321228266,
-0.6516413689,
-0.9948353171,
0.9398428202,
-0.3966991603,
-0.3947015107,
-0.0761871934,
0.5713757277,
0.6383338571,
-0.3061023355,
-0.2657388747,
0.5262551904,
0.7607787848,
-0.2237512022,
-0.6332684159,
0.0834287032,
-0.1992637515,
0.0911808088,
0.0995571539,
-0.9299132824,
0.933673501,
-0.1318971664,
-0.2225790024,
-0.1079932824,
0.235686183,
0.4265017807,
0.3317926526,
0.8051465154,
1.5140154362,
0.4926908612,
-0.2677945793,
1.0381361246,
-0.2318668664,
0.2140957713,
0.5203076005,
-0.3341572881,
0.631814301,
0.4694167674,
-0.6746342778,
0.5501052737,
0.440334022,
-0.3266962767,
0.4871746302,
0.5106697083,
-0.1159053892,
-0.2097296566,
0.0205698516,
-0.6209480762,
0.7361509204,
0.8179487586,
-0.145432353,
-0.4473079443,
0.0914814398,
-0.2194321305,
0.3510610461,
0.0696251243,
0.4145012796,
0.2146906406,
-0.0126909008,
0.3232530057,
-0.0294601284,
0.5599687696,
-0.170971483,
0.2877334058,
0.0055466327,
0.5031349063,
-0.9026553035,
-0.6223616004,
0.5167050958,
-0.1830088049,
0.1550219804,
-0.0631808341,
0.3768778741,
-0.1301360875,
-0.5085295439,
0.4901124537,
0.5113092661,
0.0507042035,
0.0988593996,
-0.2468480766,
0.1195496917,
-0.0188849922,
0.2213898152,
0.4715918303,
0.6254277229,
0.1033816785,
0.1967176646,
0.4233999252,
-0.0270283595,
0.0522520915,
-0.2719288468,
0.876067996,
-0.5057240725,
-0.3601160944,
-0.8178694844,
0.2704843283,
0.1726613194,
-0.3789418936,
0.936480999,
0.9365971088,
0.980093658,
0.4702809751,
0.762622118,
-0.5045272708,
0.1150045395,
-0.3055846393,
0.2709597349,
-0.6919798851,
0.2886599302,
-0.0049377088,
-1.5351252556,
-0.4830354154,
0.8875838518,
-0.2825065851,
0.3441013098,
1.0501365662,
0.4893590808,
-0.145266369,
0.1309958696,
0.3295378983,
0.2168699056,
0.3425958157,
0.498818934,
1.4735484123,
-0.1219984069,
0.2471725345,
-0.2721109688,
-0.3014540374,
-0.1190857589,
-0.4185682237,
-0.8473140001,
-0.7585639954,
-0.4628558755,
-0.8886959553,
-0.2695735693,
0.8262694478,
0.3280288875,
-0.7419877648,
-0.4367344379,
0.0206117313,
0.1876212358,
-0.1182876527,
-0.1765721887,
0.2825419903,
-0.3427310586,
-0.3350505233,
-0.0223232079,
0.1764456332,
0.1373658031,
-0.257851243,
0.1644563973,
0.1626416147,
-0.3606257141,
0.306679517,
0.5197523832,
-0.4484212995,
-0.557975471,
-0.1761253178,
-0.2326992005,
0.3831934333,
1.0347952843,
-0.4680147469,
-0.0680985674,
0.647320509,
0.3008087575,
0.6050118208,
0.0648322403,
0.2690020502,
-0.7294629812,
0.5441243649,
0.132793352,
0.442566812,
-0.1179333627,
-0.376576066,
0.4296755195,
0.2822872996,
-0.7562147379,
-0.7303500772,
0.2139104158,
-0.8158231974,
-0.6445530653,
1.14059484,
0.0493580885,
-0.267721355,
0.1409990489,
0.244750306,
-0.3637352586,
0.0365735963,
1.065638423,
0.6162903309,
-0.2266421765,
-0.0279491879,
-0.3340255916,
0.2778082192,
0.2399622351,
-0.4602014124,
-0.3372512758,
0.5147601962,
0.1087448969,
0.5415711403,
0.2011472434,
-0.2746863067,
0.2122379541,
0.3040305674,
0.2765989304,
-0.0401860848,
-0.6857916117,
-0.6520707607,
0.1550698131,
0.2557356358,
-0.2420528233
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03190v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03190v4
|
Unified Hallucination Detection for Multimodal Large Language Models
| 2024-02-05T16:56:11 | 2024-05-27T11:52:56 |
Xiang Chen, Chenxi Wang, Yida Xue, Ningyu Zhang, Xiaoyan Yang, Qiang Li, Yue Shen, Lei Liang, Jinjie Gu, Huajun Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG, cs.MM
|
Despite significant strides in multimodal tasks, Multimodal Large Language
Models (MLLMs) are plagued by the critical issue of hallucination. The reliable
detection of such hallucinations in MLLMs has, therefore, become a vital aspect
of model evaluation and the safeguarding of practical application deployment.
Prior research in this domain has been constrained by a narrow focus on
singular tasks, an inadequate range of hallucination categories addressed, and
a lack of detailed granularity. In response to these challenges, our work
expands the investigative horizons of hallucination detection. We present a
novel meta-evaluation benchmark, MHaluBench, meticulously crafted to facilitate
the evaluation of advancements in hallucination detection methods.
Additionally, we unveil a novel unified multimodal hallucination detection
framework, UNIHD, which leverages a suite of auxiliary tools to validate the
occurrence of hallucinations robustly. We demonstrate the effectiveness of
UNIHD through meticulous evaluation and comprehensive analysis. We also provide
strategic insights on the application of specific tools for addressing various
categories of hallucinations.
|
[
-0.4431029558,
-0.8020275235,
0.5552741885,
0.4921957552,
-0.2312098891,
-0.0147855692,
-0.4369845688,
-0.3562749624,
0.2212404609,
0.5843914747,
-0.6946867108,
-0.7779597044,
-0.3078431189,
0.1802433878,
-0.3378314674,
0.580730319,
0.1423697621,
0.1904322803,
-0.4185071588,
-0.3500882089,
-0.581520915,
-0.7285326123,
-0.0809725299,
-0.3841407895,
0.5792547464,
0.3206209838,
0.6505276561,
0.0343244001,
0.4594547153,
0.2794195712,
0.206152454,
0.3598692417,
-0.1977831125,
0.4676740766,
0.0899895951,
0.1890322268,
-0.3799172044,
-0.4669710398,
0.7211265564,
0.9513508677,
-0.3674201965,
0.105433479,
0.224263519,
0.6234009266,
-0.9495004416,
-0.0532249548,
-0.6119720936,
0.2050297856,
-0.295392096,
-0.2224416137,
-0.7655533552,
0.0961128771,
-0.202005893,
-0.1739958823,
0.071781382,
-0.0757236183,
0.2643227875,
0.4023550153,
-0.5660763383,
-0.2762441933,
-0.7556599975,
0.7685703039,
-0.5325122476,
1.131970048,
0.156746313,
0.3451160491,
-0.2439666539,
-0.7041658759,
-0.5386820436,
-0.5733450055,
-0.1033522338,
-0.1423152983,
-0.3871051669,
0.0781577379,
0.1780544817,
0.1891326904,
-1.0050984621,
0.0602309108,
-0.0501857102,
-0.5464290977,
0.2229545712,
0.3001262546,
0.1730698496,
-0.3939961195,
-0.2947995067,
-0.1088198945,
-0.2411444634,
-0.3511564434,
0.2512877584,
0.1780200452,
0.1880304217,
0.5346055031,
-0.3449311852,
0.5118520856,
-0.4272412956,
-0.0565185472,
0.5272404552,
-0.2046023458,
-0.1859365702,
-0.0733010545,
0.8195967078,
0.4550001919,
0.1355109066,
-0.4866504371,
-0.2106998265,
0.2203309089,
0.4890314341,
-0.7312250733,
-0.4244729578,
0.3184845746,
-0.6308487654,
-0.1626550853,
0.0071762754,
-1.1234061718,
-0.4957945049,
-0.2070496827,
0.2922619879,
-0.3034967482,
-0.6209208965,
0.134220019,
-0.0286786295,
0.0587478392,
0.0278374031,
-0.8921922445,
0.1022232398,
0.4898496866,
0.7308882475,
-0.439617604,
-0.567551136,
-0.4627198279,
0.094009079,
-0.2769625187,
1.0812683105,
-0.6115681529,
-0.2679617107,
0.2196767032,
0.1625828296,
-0.0269664004,
-0.6225355864,
0.806298852,
-0.0962777734,
-0.1345246285,
-0.2482026666,
-0.211238429,
-0.3610796034,
0.2156309783,
-0.7209011316,
0.9841085672,
0.0757190958,
-0.6147169471,
0.5207784176,
-0.7645214796,
-0.4169524908,
0.0332219712,
-0.218851462,
-0.4794039726,
0.4164693356,
0.2032814771,
0.5724803209,
0.0017343564,
0.4874410331,
-0.7202044725,
-0.3280982375,
0.3666605651,
-0.7308860421,
0.6289079189,
0.1653930694,
-0.4288699031,
0.502540648,
-0.7174476385,
0.104758203,
0.0041978001,
-0.0337233692,
-0.2790260315,
-0.0782254264,
0.6750512123,
0.0866516083,
-0.0715271682,
-0.2924586833,
0.1483400762,
0.1963009238,
0.0302020367,
0.7615352869,
-0.1500407159,
0.075073868,
0.069505468,
0.3301973641,
-0.014271453,
0.4102717042,
-0.1144891232,
-0.1924605966,
-0.6883128285,
-0.4534611404,
0.1805784702,
0.2265012413,
-0.5951750875,
0.6512467861,
-0.1277653128,
-0.3115935326,
-0.5176903009,
0.1606272608,
0.4053345323,
0.1275313795,
0.5263454318,
-0.1784179658,
-0.7064887285,
-1.0626978874,
-0.162074849,
0.1617214233,
-0.0984169245,
0.1209874377,
0.7333301306,
-0.9183238149,
0.4689293802,
-0.36385414,
-0.6668457985,
-0.2675051391,
0.384952724,
-0.2076631486,
0.4372217059,
0.4331172109,
-0.8157476187,
-0.1963363886,
-0.0135916648,
-1.1133393049,
-0.240694806,
-0.2123686522,
-0.0150469728,
0.4374703467,
0.657384932,
-0.6484882832,
0.3796933293,
0.6635605693,
-0.4474534094,
0.9617310762,
-0.1524335891,
0.3917781115,
-0.7295281291,
0.2846671641,
-0.5098341703,
-0.0772875175,
-0.6141444445,
0.0699364319,
0.1322107315,
0.1194154397,
-0.2351394892,
0.2810069919,
-0.5710347891,
-0.3800669312,
-0.2091013193,
0.0621498525,
-0.1493526846,
0.540250957,
-0.0442540608,
0.4129753411,
0.5595960617,
-0.4283424318,
0.4436676204,
0.0952622443,
-0.4102285504,
0.4350912869,
-0.3548995554,
0.1609277874,
0.0924816579,
0.1358672529,
-1.0179787874,
-0.3606576025,
0.3043592572,
-0.3250381052,
0.1982847601,
0.1927966774,
-0.8786267042,
-0.3275479376,
-0.442178458,
0.5110138655,
0.2348779291,
-0.5790776014,
0.9000033736,
0.2843100727,
0.2880589366,
-0.5534669757,
-0.4319589436,
0.2673281729,
-0.0826620013,
-0.5632904768,
0.0609804094,
-0.3601897955,
-0.1593372375,
-0.1363457441,
-0.1876262575,
0.0153515022,
0.1784504056,
0.3857919574,
0.027578108,
-0.2366636992,
0.1256318688,
0.1388193667,
-0.240732342,
0.0810617357,
0.0826788917,
0.925427556,
-0.0756392032,
-0.776997447,
-0.561014533,
0.4068330824,
0.9723738432,
-0.1425716281,
0.589035511,
1.1044411659,
-0.6243219376,
-0.1202258319,
-0.9083101749,
-0.4605322778,
-0.3967455328,
0.5528317094,
-0.5146378279,
-0.5993313193,
0.5494915247,
-0.0117602861,
-0.1581164449,
0.3575589359,
0.6211720109,
0.0709565133,
1.2933274508,
0.5650503635,
0.0062320712,
0.1093966812,
0.0486872382,
0.1385137886,
-1.0184949636,
-0.5054761767,
-0.4093661606,
0.0021226578,
-0.4979620576,
-0.2308071554,
0.3491863012,
-0.1463843733,
0.2518387735,
0.0426027514,
-0.5200231671,
0.525351584,
0.2876702249,
-0.0222408734,
0.5016511679,
0.0857323706,
-0.2714211643,
-0.3052777946,
-0.3258766234,
-0.5186331868,
1.2030425072,
0.1637878418,
0.6561834812,
0.1173897758,
0.559994936,
0.6621094942,
0.3275236487,
-0.5025712252,
0.5894118547,
-0.1166020036,
-0.6315079927,
-0.4485679269,
-0.3263047636,
-0.8569991589,
0.8947553635,
-0.3275761306,
-0.9827009439,
0.0642124638,
-0.0041352687,
-0.2318333238,
0.3542460501,
-0.5363489389,
1.3227641582,
-0.253626138,
-0.2782842517,
-0.3926219344,
-0.4294824302,
0.6258823872,
-0.0608013757,
0.2326520383,
-0.1418990195,
0.2495753467,
0.7125065327,
0.1628641486,
0.7291793823,
-0.1192506552,
-0.2058907151,
-0.1708815694,
0.2960165143,
0.1134309992,
0.0378501154,
0.1526512057,
0.4295736849,
-0.0438902825,
-0.2358093709,
-0.5644943714,
0.8425421715,
-0.2086178511,
-0.2559991479,
-0.4975294769,
-0.7614889741,
-0.1506012529,
0.3073153794,
0.1703050584,
0.5392750502,
-0.5469682813,
0.5815364122,
0.5099986196,
-0.0560701936,
0.374872148,
0.4027933776,
-0.7360973954,
-0.501799345,
0.8840205073,
-0.1752183884,
0.0829362273,
0.18429856,
0.0423766263,
-0.5717316866,
-0.5886737108,
-0.521582067,
0.2133653164,
-0.880920589,
-0.0616369769,
-0.9771618247,
0.1092767417,
-0.6174349785,
0.05011921,
-0.4419409037,
0.0747209936,
-0.1017633975,
0.0882104933,
-0.1671816558,
0.6950985789,
-0.2896212041,
0.0082843676,
-0.75730896,
0.7029477358,
0.2497055829,
0.2575352788,
0.01406861,
-0.2953803241,
0.047314547,
0.0862654001,
-0.3396312296,
-0.7355142832,
0.2275100499,
-0.0224307608,
0.7832142115,
0.9152057767,
0.1595901698,
0.6722227335,
-0.4138634503,
0.5291846991,
0.2185078263,
-0.9343830943,
0.2386278361,
-0.0526987687,
0.1981857419,
0.6504524946,
0.285694629,
-0.5729882717,
-0.4220737219,
-0.3824402988,
-0.580599308,
0.2884827852,
0.3272285461,
0.0128165931,
0.1657857448,
-0.1609712839,
0.3403051198,
0.3421669006,
-1.0810734034,
-0.114708893,
-0.0171396565,
-0.0107068727,
-0.2587689459,
-0.4976722896,
0.0314166583,
-0.4141728878,
0.3656322956,
-0.1020287946,
0.2515312135,
-0.0438405834,
-0.6520420909,
-0.1472114027,
0.2099922746,
0.894084096,
0.7998375893,
-0.4581389427,
0.3711076379,
0.15489766,
-0.4631895721,
-0.0554162376,
-0.1211236194,
0.1073296815,
0.4173623025,
0.7182218432,
0.5762295723,
0.6414735913,
-0.9077059627,
0.5778349638,
-0.0279330183,
-0.2231823057,
-0.4060000777,
-0.1756386608,
-0.1911785007,
0.3942293227,
0.424615711,
0.0565479733,
0.5947918296,
-0.668667376,
0.6208128333,
0.7347063422,
-0.4325570464,
-0.4021447599,
0.471578002,
-0.0575567149,
-0.2876716852,
0.7836731672,
-0.3825185299,
-0.7773573995,
0.2588143349,
0.5272702575,
1.2546733618,
-0.5500967503,
0.2473168969,
0.1028304324,
0.649359107,
0.129027769,
0.2951103449,
-0.2798489034,
-0.6017876267,
-0.0856146365,
-0.791944921,
-0.2246252894,
0.3498054743,
-0.8217486143,
0.1327438802,
-0.0031598636,
-0.0302631706,
0.0593721606,
-0.4463272393,
-0.3892529607,
-0.1775136292,
0.2586151361,
0.3290528953,
-0.98747015,
0.6107064486,
0.3242616355,
-0.2283025682,
0.0986144394,
0.2556044459,
0.0464743935,
-0.5345879197,
0.4047495127,
0.6736664772,
-0.3500649631,
-0.1873892546,
-0.2821680307,
-0.378130734,
0.8827035427,
0.175991118,
-0.3494598269,
0.1166302562,
0.1422277987,
0.5464739799,
-0.3644733429,
0.2203170657,
0.716638267,
0.8731034994,
0.0571493134,
-0.7526697516,
0.1663107425,
-0.0962779745,
-0.2256100923,
0.3437894583,
-0.2060944885,
0.6957947612,
-0.4309126437,
-0.3462021351,
0.0321234539,
0.6029698253,
0.1861281842,
0.5611099601,
0.7222446203,
0.6203697324,
0.6807900667,
0.0031538222,
0.6554389,
-0.009615792,
0.3137221932,
1.0164672136,
-0.518940568,
0.8124059439,
0.6062222123,
-0.016785156,
0.5306254625,
0.4965168238,
-0.2465012968,
0.5763473511,
0.0218118653,
-0.1901008934,
-0.555742681,
-0.1974914372,
-0.5362148881,
0.6104638577,
0.2975468338,
-0.0377180278,
-0.3514159024,
0.5729967952,
-0.1895035505,
-0.1746212244,
-0.0028014677,
0.7870855927,
-0.1692609489,
-0.4946951866,
0.6716232896,
-0.3326895535,
0.6208724976,
-0.4501573443,
-0.2613171637,
-0.1357864887,
0.3712107241,
-0.1911372393,
-0.3273090422,
0.2774361074,
-0.2327599078,
-0.0556471907,
0.0258439798,
0.5839679837,
-0.4942039549,
-0.4780700803,
0.848162055,
0.4154480696,
0.2573705912,
-0.6939808726,
-0.5874785185,
0.4929145873,
0.0678462461,
-0.1020311788,
0.2398228943,
0.4905968606,
-0.0019857648,
0.845436573,
0.9104919434,
-0.3266745508,
0.0181616563,
0.5256336331,
0.8304641247,
-0.711276114,
-0.2173818648,
-1.0696333647,
0.6230971813,
-0.1051380262,
-0.2697648704,
0.8921373487,
0.7119030356,
0.7008539438,
-0.3900887668,
0.5154725909,
0.1712276936,
0.1322307885,
-0.6402288079,
0.9132834673,
-0.8887129426,
-0.0390467644,
-0.5824253559,
-1.224848628,
-0.5504614115,
0.5790928006,
0.233629182,
0.0226376951,
1.1011785269,
0.8255385756,
-0.191618368,
-0.0689266697,
0.7601005435,
0.2182950526,
0.1056486666,
0.2826384306,
1.1324445009,
-0.3371297717,
0.5979082584,
-0.4034555852,
-0.178056702,
-0.6510334611,
-0.7537192702,
-1.2338370085,
-0.9537879825,
-0.2010564804,
-0.2214864641,
-0.1300914288,
0.7724639177,
0.6076353192,
-0.9947629571,
-0.3456471562,
0.2808904052,
0.1900512576,
-0.284224838,
-0.2369301915,
0.3545021713,
-0.4062437713,
-0.4512141943,
0.3913681507,
0.4880953729,
0.0164831653,
-0.6609370708,
-0.1319772601,
-0.2059883922,
-0.2798876762,
0.9105209708,
-0.1108027622,
-1.0804482698,
-0.1499005854,
0.1331056356,
0.0893945917,
-0.1077941656,
1.0220316648,
-0.3219965994,
0.4788523316,
0.2975603938,
0.4018022418,
0.2762119174,
-0.3095359206,
0.0942299664,
-0.5146171451,
0.2941886783,
0.2394330949,
0.4085662961,
0.3555807769,
-0.0981373116,
0.4016341567,
0.2609209418,
-0.4689224064,
-1.5365982056,
0.069539614,
-1.0121062994,
-0.4628837407,
1.0041350126,
0.381949991,
-0.033040382,
-0.393851012,
-0.2592925727,
0.0208169837,
-0.322681427,
0.9519271851,
0.7697923779,
-0.1434535682,
-0.151036799,
-0.6631234884,
0.4148597419,
0.407492429,
-0.8605005145,
0.5249463916,
0.7176485062,
-0.1322628856,
0.4308368862,
0.4517917633,
0.1063363329,
0.361918509,
0.0144396601,
0.4674096704,
0.0326749496,
-0.9513792396,
-0.4496668279,
0.2667450309,
-0.2008060366,
-0.2516498864
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05130v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05130v2
|
LB-KBQA: Large-language-model and BERT based Knowledge-Based Question and Answering System
| 2024-02-05T16:47:17 | 2024-02-09T02:45:51 |
Yan Zhao, Zhongyun Li, Yushan Pan, Jiaxing Wang, Yihong Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Generative Artificial Intelligence (AI), because of its emergent abilities,
has empowered various fields, one typical of which is large language models
(LLMs). One of the typical application fields of Generative AI is large
language models (LLMs), and the natural language understanding capability of
LLM is dramatically improved when compared with conventional AI-based methods.
The natural language understanding capability has always been a barrier to the
intent recognition performance of the Knowledge-Based-Question-and-Answer
(KBQA) system, which arises from linguistic diversity and the newly appeared
intent. Conventional AI-based methods for intent recognition can be divided
into semantic parsing-based and model-based approaches. However, both of the
methods suffer from limited resources in intent recognition. To address this
issue, we propose a novel KBQA system based on a Large Language Model(LLM) and
BERT (LB-KBQA). With the help of generative AI, our proposed method could
detect newly appeared intent and acquire new knowledge. In experiments on
financial domain question answering, our model has demonstrated superior
effectiveness.
|
[
-0.1863093078,
-1.1900539398,
0.732359767,
0.2834450006,
-0.2984534204,
0.1009720862,
-0.128525123,
-0.4795571864,
0.0565447696,
0.5097773075,
-0.4217128158,
-0.3252496719,
-0.6339185834,
0.0079428256,
-0.1627765298,
0.6877775192,
0.1433459669,
0.2877045274,
-0.2879299521,
0.0602089055,
-0.4741415083,
-0.3017397523,
-0.8875908256,
-0.2791739404,
0.2013787627,
0.1779527366,
0.6269320846,
-0.0030494267,
0.3896970451,
0.3781633675,
-0.213131696,
0.1298923641,
-0.1581258178,
0.0888238251,
0.0417877622,
-0.5000531077,
-0.3162207305,
-0.3646288216,
0.6806960702,
0.5638297796,
-0.0798607692,
-0.0571516007,
-0.2841131985,
0.6305130124,
-0.5182566047,
0.4414451122,
-0.7612492442,
-0.2603538036,
0.3551472425,
-0.0350515991,
-0.6919882894,
-0.5022959709,
0.4546345472,
-0.6400834918,
-0.1054574549,
-0.1696926951,
0.75427562,
0.0472843982,
-0.4331079721,
-0.5778363347,
-0.5716404915,
0.750778079,
-0.9147026539,
0.579097867,
0.2457763553,
0.5600750446,
-0.1259483695,
-0.5034915805,
-0.788867116,
-0.408977747,
0.0917365626,
-0.0197102074,
-0.0080660051,
-0.0027246417,
-0.1366925091,
0.0700873658,
-0.4855966568,
0.0587823093,
-0.3549463451,
-0.2828036249,
0.5166251659,
0.0260326248,
0.1035058945,
-0.4542869925,
-0.4751419127,
0.1215028614,
-0.5693006516,
0.3577764034,
-0.075116843,
0.3265769482,
0.0478622541,
0.5135872364,
-0.3423662782,
0.7091230154,
0.1316235363,
-0.3086361587,
-0.0280135572,
0.0693228468,
-0.5990162492,
0.1408455372,
0.5285081863,
-0.0578563437,
0.1406481117,
-0.3018828332,
-0.0488794819,
-0.3947743177,
0.1403179467,
-0.5845999718,
-0.0068914457,
0.2995648086,
-0.566850841,
-0.2115586847,
-0.2978783846,
-0.3791357279,
-0.3541724682,
-0.2926828563,
0.8136184216,
-0.7991615534,
-0.1355658919,
0.2025082111,
-0.0430715978,
0.9365544915,
0.659430325,
-0.7137023211,
-0.0677837357,
0.8099460602,
0.3207854927,
0.233193785,
0.0909266695,
-0.4226630032,
0.3067677319,
-0.229355067,
0.629073441,
-0.4420134723,
-0.1553237289,
-0.039399758,
-0.3420174718,
0.0288868286,
-0.3673743308,
0.3475399017,
-1.4446413517,
0.2465605885,
-0.3355898857,
-0.9044233561,
-0.588337183,
0.5305916667,
-0.6011990905,
0.5846844316,
0.0895811021,
-0.459900856,
0.3998889327,
-0.9107358456,
-0.3857890964,
0.5865071416,
-0.1805000752,
-0.0772333369,
-0.0899471566,
0.3809527457,
0.4866719246,
-0.3826327324,
0.5549117923,
-0.0512739196,
-0.1971416771,
0.6031631827,
-0.796361208,
0.8689015508,
0.1060810983,
-0.2502067685,
-0.056140054,
-0.6473835111,
0.2232413292,
0.1134776697,
-0.6995667219,
-0.3520052731,
-0.0046126861,
-0.2137565762,
0.0644974634,
0.781247735,
-0.6262977123,
0.1817021668,
-0.4086968899,
0.2987297773,
0.8518038392,
-0.1150763407,
0.4697194695,
-0.1146313846,
0.4792976081,
0.0726772994,
0.1096859053,
0.1167788506,
-0.6252375841,
-0.7239319086,
-0.2661714852,
0.4851092398,
0.6875326633,
-0.8758742213,
0.6009635329,
-0.2016456574,
-0.3147234321,
-0.4631782174,
0.0026728176,
0.2051066607,
0.370470643,
0.2390550226,
0.033663407,
-0.2389415801,
-0.9558250308,
0.0226679742,
-0.487441957,
-0.06661807,
0.7276648879,
0.1647868901,
-0.1379278302,
1.106066823,
-0.6972504854,
-0.0480711088,
-0.5860834122,
0.2666606605,
0.3424874842,
0.064205572,
0.4787572622,
-1.0488821268,
-0.5029965043,
-0.0749614686,
-0.7322906256,
0.154282555,
-0.1369115263,
-0.3556348979,
0.3893819451,
0.4777850807,
-0.7637350559,
0.3125309944,
0.3266702592,
-0.3725555837,
0.6093271971,
-0.170127362,
0.1265134215,
-1.1401839256,
0.096020326,
-0.3520993292,
-0.1113770232,
-0.6697030067,
-0.1201429144,
0.2992482483,
0.1061519757,
-0.3800823987,
0.6238868237,
-0.1867501885,
-0.0210721213,
-0.2934394479,
0.0300079472,
0.0578767844,
0.6514205337,
0.2282726467,
0.6933930516,
0.4965249002,
-0.8387647867,
0.4232448041,
0.6383813024,
-0.6195059419,
0.4029357731,
-0.5473412275,
0.0134411855,
-0.4287052453,
0.1714275032,
-1.1032345295,
-0.2210999578,
0.1219224259,
-0.7214453816,
0.2377124727,
0.0000878828,
-0.2890197635,
-0.377412051,
0.0292827617,
0.5610155463,
0.6303347945,
-0.4684011638,
1.0101851225,
0.0261934195,
-0.7554171085,
-0.7511166334,
-0.3669341207,
-0.0133753493,
0.1263494343,
-0.7664391398,
0.0906656533,
-0.0795981959,
-0.0123819634,
-0.0580697283,
0.124025628,
-0.4419404268,
0.0158956591,
-0.1578124315,
0.7001450658,
-0.4672808349,
0.4101936519,
0.2676441967,
0.2292075455,
0.3169737756,
-0.2453235686,
0.7094230056,
0.0328437947,
-0.1932401955,
-0.3671647608,
0.4105963707,
0.8409337997,
-0.3894408345,
1.0429868698,
0.336922735,
-0.116422005,
-0.1237456575,
-0.8100455403,
-0.0158924162,
-0.5441051722,
0.5113638639,
-0.2637504339,
-1.2792127132,
0.392388165,
0.0173261911,
0.0530529805,
0.3908902109,
0.7532010674,
-0.1489410251,
0.7120190263,
0.5635839105,
-0.3584024012,
0.2697827816,
0.0066794045,
0.5548678637,
-0.7423033118,
-0.3600944877,
-0.3339596391,
-0.2549400032,
-0.1765076071,
-0.341166079,
0.545709908,
0.1674453914,
-0.2979160547,
0.1625343263,
-0.2637216151,
0.1693683863,
0.672232151,
0.1361083537,
0.3233977556,
-0.2073214799,
-0.2366897017,
0.2907638252,
-0.5298517346,
-0.4152892232,
1.289026618,
0.4496711195,
0.7975924611,
0.3824879229,
0.4487866461,
0.278858006,
0.3812558651,
-0.909434855,
0.7373563051,
-0.0409515277,
-0.8185764551,
-0.8065771461,
-0.6615838408,
-0.6967877746,
0.0479951464,
-0.0266648643,
-0.6699572206,
0.1938200742,
0.00868583,
-0.5463408828,
0.3405512571,
-0.8042384982,
0.701397717,
-0.4415681064,
0.0800294206,
-0.0503649861,
-0.6090391874,
0.4124492109,
-0.148677215,
0.0887263641,
-0.0649995059,
0.1928801686,
0.7050910592,
-0.1820563376,
0.6337894201,
-0.4916554391,
-0.5675349236,
0.4509175122,
-0.1394434124,
0.6343004704,
0.1912899315,
-0.0428619683,
-0.2462692559,
-0.2880466282,
-0.3138854802,
-0.6193175912,
0.451932013,
-0.7095971107,
-0.5874112844,
-0.0614291728,
-0.9255325198,
-0.4843281209,
0.2056481987,
-0.0766172037,
0.2589080036,
-0.3575077057,
0.3303947747,
0.7734761834,
-0.6324625015,
0.2797971666,
0.9166597128,
-0.2347447276,
-0.4267356992,
0.7021868825,
-0.3141742349,
0.3567465842,
0.8609957099,
0.0527911298,
-0.6875036955,
-0.4811173379,
-0.3290342689,
0.2029694617,
-0.5979245305,
-0.4437093139,
-0.7503789067,
-0.515180409,
-0.7764649987,
-0.2294188738,
0.1050808132,
-0.3003041744,
0.0090653654,
0.1445314586,
0.5506743789,
0.4817104936,
0.1926086545,
0.1868758053,
-0.9574586153,
0.5783191323,
0.9184007645,
0.3836564422,
0.1467884481,
-0.4767151177,
-0.0705658495,
0.1855427623,
-0.1702993512,
-0.7288012505,
0.2554025352,
0.0643200204,
0.5264566541,
0.5196986198,
0.0994550362,
0.0811588764,
-0.1891558319,
0.4826739132,
0.067722261,
-0.9041559696,
0.3457323909,
-0.3211889267,
0.5002670884,
0.5787969232,
0.3702022731,
-0.5362181067,
-0.4042266607,
-0.3730605543,
-0.7251355052,
0.8043877482,
0.2077604383,
0.0562784709,
0.064915888,
0.3907241225,
0.0945853889,
0.5201579332,
-0.953354001,
-0.0860444233,
0.0257578567,
-0.3589964211,
0.1520121396,
-0.3745890558,
0.3005475402,
-0.3178775609,
0.8771934509,
-0.0811809301,
0.5830763578,
0.0902262107,
-0.1216344759,
0.0625701472,
0.7240892649,
0.2489444017,
0.4697150588,
-0.2899459898,
-0.2835761011,
0.2282875925,
-0.5699104071,
0.1912467331,
0.3682774901,
-0.5486696362,
-0.072210744,
0.1569399536,
0.6275085807,
0.0319163278,
-1.0454097986,
0.6006733179,
0.0573462658,
-0.4334909916,
-0.545609355,
0.0830720961,
0.4870308638,
0.4945700467,
0.5006534457,
-0.2279355824,
0.1208755001,
-0.5332381725,
0.0085388739,
0.7508559823,
-0.1800325513,
0.212773487,
0.334751904,
0.2309355289,
-0.1229545549,
0.8137905002,
-0.4424709082,
-0.7992318869,
0.9148346782,
0.4506010115,
0.6700412035,
-0.3378984928,
0.5393650532,
0.1740830094,
0.1121290028,
0.3588103652,
0.7805080414,
-0.2110390365,
-1.0576810837,
-0.6175451875,
-0.9451218843,
-0.3022246361,
0.4942238331,
-0.5569108725,
-0.0488557294,
-0.3456962407,
0.2363940924,
0.2704267502,
-0.1634833813,
-0.5168322921,
0.3357045352,
0.0497443788,
1.0522969961,
-0.4645913541,
0.8091345429,
0.8154914975,
-0.1041732058,
-0.9774619341,
0.0054995394,
-0.4866951108,
-0.981674552,
0.9992402792,
0.1109382063,
0.1104975343,
0.0382338464,
-0.5525230765,
-0.8386467099,
1.1667979956,
0.0914668515,
-0.414922446,
-0.2602513731,
0.323471278,
0.2971170247,
-0.1570179015,
-0.1659151316,
0.4997187555,
0.695276022,
0.384771049,
-0.6946277618,
-0.2482215017,
-0.1446561813,
-0.2519905865,
0.5972849131,
-0.452162832,
0.7085117102,
-0.1909905821,
0.0554584339,
0.332031697,
0.7288784385,
0.4176780283,
0.2118621618,
0.6140385866,
0.5504308343,
0.529918015,
-0.0354483612,
0.6105796099,
-0.0690626204,
0.3544261158,
0.8394834399,
-0.4271797538,
1.0135070086,
0.1697836369,
-0.3939151168,
0.6211099625,
0.0549443401,
0.004443353,
0.5839104056,
0.2128400207,
-0.7271999717,
-0.4922565818,
0.1319454461,
-0.1726073176,
0.6139389873,
0.5367071033,
-0.3683857322,
-0.1768723875,
0.1458758414,
-0.2373443991,
-0.2566643655,
-0.3697773218,
0.984170258,
-0.0766183659,
-0.7505568266,
0.3130450845,
0.1594348103,
0.6925894022,
-0.935108304,
0.0424151719,
0.1238642186,
-0.0313900113,
0.3150961101,
-0.6365475655,
-0.1220780015,
0.0642176121,
-0.4059156477,
0.1440819949,
0.8470606208,
-0.5142219663,
-0.6960333586,
0.1512791812,
0.5664625168,
-0.0752838999,
-0.1693766117,
-0.5279858708,
-0.4246584773,
-0.0165156014,
0.0199317224,
0.0707522258,
0.6899672151,
0.0686283335,
0.7441602945,
0.5564406514,
-0.2776189744,
0.0539075658,
0.0256047621,
0.7704269886,
-0.7201009393,
-0.7787687182,
-0.4649490416,
0.1317655742,
0.0158900712,
0.0083196368,
0.4015148878,
0.525745213,
0.3416839838,
-0.1852122396,
0.9584829211,
-0.3465280831,
0.689943552,
-0.6626684666,
0.8197478652,
-0.5380126238,
0.1353850812,
-0.2225214988,
-0.6100241542,
0.1157076061,
0.5376673937,
-0.4905534387,
0.3703906834,
0.4902407229,
0.5490987897,
0.1156554222,
0.2348017544,
0.3971249163,
0.4815296531,
0.1696091592,
0.9241008759,
0.8976327181,
-0.1699612737,
0.6817216277,
0.1307768971,
-0.2359032333,
-0.4522440732,
-0.5978995562,
-0.695889473,
-0.5999935269,
0.0150655387,
-0.018608762,
-0.0561308376,
0.7848656178,
0.366027683,
-0.8762776852,
0.0426868536,
-0.2020411044,
-0.0996165797,
-0.0972325578,
-0.3288345933,
0.6274424195,
-0.4102803469,
-0.4574559629,
0.3265478909,
0.4074550569,
0.0779135823,
-0.3496537805,
-0.1919398755,
-0.5239370465,
0.4270287454,
0.9186520576,
0.202771157,
-0.7566820383,
-0.2213619947,
0.2040313333,
-0.0677199215,
-0.1517617255,
0.6060633063,
-0.8381701708,
0.256740272,
0.4806522727,
1.0721739531,
0.1290879101,
0.024009306,
0.5762126446,
-0.4602010846,
-0.1346072555,
0.4487101734,
0.2695927024,
0.0084744673,
-0.6628076434,
-0.1034486368,
-0.2506063879,
-0.571047008,
-0.1695333421,
0.3104484379,
-1.1742918491,
-0.6808117628,
0.9422054291,
-0.0706432462,
-0.1164061949,
-0.3853658736,
-0.4098111987,
0.1784466654,
-0.5356336236,
0.9558238983,
0.7966871858,
-0.1060205624,
-0.0634286404,
-0.4698223174,
0.3318742216,
0.6215189695,
-0.9884950519,
0.0676642209,
0.588668108,
0.1505803615,
0.1915085018,
0.7607827783,
-0.0649804026,
0.7087498903,
-0.4313086867,
-0.0139592374,
0.0121910088,
-0.2620104551,
0.0729955807,
0.4124399424,
0.2783709168,
-0.1213091016
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03181v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03181v4
|
C-RAG: Certified Generation Risks for Retrieval-Augmented Language Models
| 2024-02-05T16:46:16 | 2024-06-04T04:51:08 |
Mintong Kang, Nezihe Merve Gürel, Ning Yu, Dawn Song, Bo Li
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Despite the impressive capabilities of large language models (LLMs) across
diverse applications, they still suffer from trustworthiness issues, such as
hallucinations and misalignments. Retrieval-augmented language models (RAG)
have been proposed to enhance the credibility of generations by grounding
external knowledge, but the theoretical understandings of their generation
risks remains unexplored. In this paper, we answer: 1) whether RAG can indeed
lead to low generation risks, 2) how to provide provable guarantees on the
generation risks of RAG and vanilla LLMs, and 3) what sufficient conditions
enable RAG models to reduce generation risks. We propose C-RAG, the first
framework to certify generation risks for RAG models. Specifically, we provide
conformal risk analysis for RAG models and certify an upper confidence bound of
generation risks, which we refer to as conformal generation risk. We also
provide theoretical guarantees on conformal generation risks for general
bounded risk functions under test distribution shifts. We prove that RAG
achieves a lower conformal generation risk than that of a single LLM when the
quality of the retrieval model and transformer is non-trivial. Our intensive
empirical results demonstrate the soundness and tightness of our conformal
generation risk guarantees across four widely-used NLP datasets on four
state-of-the-art retrieval models.
|
[
-0.2880586088,
-0.4674277306,
0.4955990016,
-0.0902864635,
0.1852300912,
0.0887153819,
-0.0693698972,
-0.8381848335,
-0.1093566269,
0.6923829913,
-0.187193349,
-0.1499364525,
-0.8329820037,
-0.240452081,
-0.5111425519,
0.7871479392,
0.2097699046,
-0.3069007099,
-0.254927218,
0.3645694554,
-0.135982573,
-0.3731120825,
-0.5694440007,
-0.1106164008,
0.5390386581,
0.3503375351,
0.9199151993,
0.3080556989,
0.4408844113,
0.1937485039,
-0.5869615078,
-0.0564883277,
-0.6650574207,
0.3693980277,
-0.1505446732,
-0.6286290884,
-0.434600234,
0.1349655539,
0.6138100624,
0.8628382087,
-0.3150003254,
0.392931819,
0.1987601966,
0.9165508747,
-0.861143887,
-0.1892373264,
-1.1360479593,
-0.2490443587,
-0.2731725276,
-0.0579210334,
-1.0815380812,
-0.5721170902,
0.024998052,
-0.3707908988,
0.4072929621,
0.2404964715,
0.9237141013,
0.2392331809,
-0.604736805,
-0.1551607996,
-1.0275331736,
0.8091208339,
-0.4057466686,
0.5443291664,
0.5491483212,
0.4453005791,
-0.3310154676,
-0.6455817819,
-0.4678710401,
-0.5188432336,
-0.1378224492,
-0.0280016456,
0.041695375,
0.2099981755,
0.2857243717,
0.5732345581,
-0.3938117623,
0.0677666739,
-0.6226348877,
-0.2502685189,
0.4822586477,
0.0035278425,
0.1520782113,
-0.1619576365,
-0.6165874004,
-0.2759225965,
-1.310874939,
-0.0373728462,
0.7341215611,
0.1740019023,
-0.1381268054,
0.6269983649,
-0.0237770006,
0.4724270105,
0.0826289505,
-0.1405065656,
0.0019525853,
-0.1483892798,
0.0086447531,
-0.0470221452,
0.3399845362,
0.1789874434,
0.3893501461,
-0.4309861958,
0.000511979,
-0.0983344615,
0.3589240313,
-0.5539833307,
0.1388707161,
0.1171339378,
-0.4476797283,
-0.560596168,
0.2146210968,
-0.8937008977,
-0.6953102946,
0.0589104034,
0.1631367803,
-0.2344774157,
-0.3798508048,
0.0636396706,
0.0234285966,
0.5382797718,
0.0862530917,
-0.7101382017,
0.1736644059,
0.7793798447,
0.3895550668,
-0.238496244,
0.2289996147,
-0.2322270572,
0.3682461381,
-0.4733531773,
0.882802248,
-0.3224652112,
-0.7561953664,
0.1555596441,
-0.1580119133,
-0.1327037215,
-0.5780941844,
0.6402636766,
-0.5880080462,
-0.1283776015,
0.0890297741,
-0.5602447987,
-0.0307697821,
0.1369319558,
-0.5830164552,
0.6574465632,
0.206488505,
-0.8673499823,
0.2773949802,
0.3608685136,
-0.3023041487,
-0.0093500204,
0.0132603571,
-0.4631029665,
0.2512520254,
-0.366841197,
0.1271554679,
-0.594402194,
0.1253101081,
-0.4872038066,
0.0224378016,
0.3978465497,
-0.7389339805,
0.7929801941,
0.3533591628,
-0.1048415601,
-0.1940710247,
-0.6279614568,
0.2585800588,
-0.087090604,
-0.3019502461,
-0.3948957026,
-0.0605925247,
-0.0302336775,
0.2890962064,
0.1248670667,
-0.4201996624,
-0.0384948589,
-0.5075851679,
-0.1247258186,
0.6162720919,
0.3260785639,
0.5674366951,
-0.6426669359,
0.7637637258,
-0.0627398193,
0.3608207703,
-0.066007413,
-0.6305735707,
-0.7956616879,
0.006688681,
0.479647845,
0.6517364979,
-0.7812576294,
0.1395899802,
-0.1963975579,
-0.643848002,
-0.428774029,
-0.0898611248,
0.6403838992,
0.430239737,
0.1925546527,
0.1488923728,
-0.4762097001,
-0.7131016254,
-0.4198184311,
-0.4860737026,
-0.0095655322,
0.2214742005,
0.0248168334,
-0.3566508293,
0.7798873186,
-0.538238287,
-0.0568601415,
-0.2206855118,
0.0898394212,
0.0959693789,
0.6336567402,
0.5089585185,
-0.8422968984,
-0.6176140308,
-0.0821103901,
-0.2267652601,
-0.0860228762,
-0.1968290955,
0.0969004333,
0.4162962735,
0.6003921032,
-0.712477386,
0.5620143414,
0.9368474483,
-0.2316978723,
0.6636046171,
-0.2583072484,
0.0008782693,
-0.9558807015,
-0.0144633688,
-0.0432829075,
-0.4394199252,
-0.8239046931,
0.1769388616,
0.0361622162,
0.0676357225,
-0.4737451971,
0.6593213677,
-0.2635657191,
0.0967238024,
-0.1868700683,
0.0108584585,
0.0085830968,
-0.0674470961,
-0.2007422,
0.6963191628,
0.3617124557,
-0.9220477343,
-0.4437418878,
0.2666693926,
-0.091922991,
0.5261978507,
-0.5112988353,
0.1041251943,
-0.1614076048,
0.1622758806,
-0.6973109245,
0.1059172451,
-0.0161174648,
-0.6272798181,
0.6704879403,
-0.218175441,
-0.2201188952,
-0.170761928,
-0.2541484237,
0.2770497501,
0.9317576885,
-0.5627333522,
0.5382152796,
0.6182009578,
-0.2055846453,
-0.7056713104,
-0.5461794138,
0.0656310841,
-0.2140090466,
-0.618021965,
0.4090745747,
-0.1584886909,
-0.3854303956,
-0.0386014022,
-0.2238925248,
-0.1100767776,
0.2390664965,
0.6016362906,
0.3204576671,
0.0627369359,
-0.1952340156,
0.0242550448,
-0.4865468442,
-0.0707303658,
-0.112674132,
0.2661863565,
-0.1179472879,
-0.2764502764,
0.2636823654,
0.10252738,
0.2362123579,
-0.0541845374,
0.9086510539,
0.309484303,
-0.4861436486,
-0.2667273879,
-0.7542373538,
0.0326795913,
-0.513569355,
-0.1624791324,
-0.1775669754,
-0.9248534441,
0.5368179679,
-0.1268101037,
-0.156431973,
0.7666890621,
0.5308515429,
-0.1851750761,
0.7967450619,
0.644880414,
0.2741137147,
0.1913621426,
-0.2080674917,
0.0537742376,
-0.9013119936,
-0.2625008225,
-0.8630853891,
0.2941983938,
-1.0748806,
-0.5896925926,
0.4854520261,
0.2788291574,
-0.332675606,
0.2662039399,
-0.3999846876,
0.4278426468,
0.4787825048,
-0.107419461,
0.5252450705,
-0.3531582057,
0.0265755653,
0.0984807014,
-0.5668292642,
-0.6447663903,
1.0650420189,
0.6450368166,
1.0974036455,
0.3385989368,
0.8699447513,
0.1859888434,
0.6676278114,
-0.582316041,
0.4572888911,
-0.394421488,
-1.1207680702,
-0.1011857688,
-0.6100221872,
-1.0809770823,
0.0173124932,
-0.5194782615,
-0.6854465008,
0.6032016277,
0.3861374259,
-0.040446382,
0.2131276429,
-0.3439737558,
0.3119226694,
-0.0222316906,
-0.2216628045,
-0.1684972197,
-0.5534520745,
0.9221856594,
-0.1548806429,
0.3970413506,
-0.0283723772,
0.1811996549,
0.1495058089,
-0.1999406517,
0.6163945794,
-0.2160281837,
-0.1830119789,
0.5439778566,
0.4566758871,
0.7009003162,
0.1414111406,
-0.1593914479,
0.0423109643,
0.2473704517,
-0.033429198,
-0.1796436906,
0.6350874305,
-0.4103043079,
-0.8085696697,
-0.5604879856,
-0.320325315,
-0.3497412801,
0.2841795683,
0.2812210619,
-0.0621098094,
-0.2897322476,
0.548389852,
1.0029592514,
-0.5289989114,
0.0039863107,
0.3380593359,
-0.3277057707,
-0.5268752575,
0.6926903129,
-0.1442323476,
0.9094407558,
0.0631513074,
0.3005209565,
-0.2632134259,
-0.5980927944,
-0.0112203434,
0.1341906935,
-0.8356379867,
-0.303621769,
-0.3775091469,
-0.378297925,
-0.5068203807,
-0.0784408152,
-0.4020313025,
-0.5496799946,
-0.0251199529,
-0.1215891987,
0.1569266468,
0.5298883319,
-0.0618003011,
0.1403898597,
-0.936945498,
0.7209367752,
0.3174934387,
0.4076677561,
-0.1667119414,
-0.637796104,
-0.1513094753,
0.0216762982,
-0.3869275451,
-0.8151522875,
0.2176623642,
0.2119080275,
0.7588727474,
0.1916437894,
0.3045259416,
0.35053882,
-0.8337247372,
0.7152093649,
0.1459758282,
-0.7160093188,
0.0668370724,
-0.4749521613,
-0.2675854862,
0.6701062322,
0.15723674,
-0.4674499333,
-0.6200075746,
-1.0921194553,
-0.8208366036,
0.2628767788,
0.0967507586,
0.1392204016,
-0.1718817055,
0.6184656024,
-0.0535279475,
-0.0871363878,
-0.6087913513,
-0.4371550381,
-0.0352083445,
-0.1050108075,
0.0315512344,
-0.5618328452,
-0.0335860364,
0.1697021127,
0.9441411495,
0.0479922481,
0.0493771471,
0.2153951824,
-0.0791939124,
-0.4376835525,
0.4786140621,
0.634673357,
0.3469983339,
-0.1416332573,
0.2752679586,
0.2652918994,
-0.5309015512,
0.4383045733,
0.0674531907,
-0.4689016938,
-0.164711982,
0.1272345483,
0.4088690579,
0.2202341408,
-0.5366657972,
0.4443814158,
0.017811954,
-0.1105263904,
-0.7098225355,
0.0357480235,
0.2813766301,
0.0212529525,
0.3121231794,
0.0691072196,
0.1249919608,
-0.3245622516,
0.4461532831,
0.6197009683,
-0.3302699924,
-0.1644799411,
0.9191257954,
-0.0132824676,
-0.128524363,
0.1275424361,
-0.2564420402,
-0.2483687997,
0.5862867832,
0.615013957,
1.1398367882,
-0.4411786795,
0.3994707763,
0.3835586309,
0.7180083394,
-0.4102707505,
-0.013977645,
0.6247950196,
-0.6564571857,
-0.2941752374,
-0.7661762834,
-0.8605296612,
-0.0789419562,
-0.7521923184,
0.1993797421,
-0.2411638945,
-0.3044859767,
-0.3498452902,
-0.2811511755,
-0.5137019753,
0.1331511289,
0.3694269657,
0.9227657318,
-0.4741830826,
0.7232939601,
0.1079719961,
-0.2911702394,
-0.6903178692,
0.250012517,
-0.1799272895,
-0.5241187215,
0.724032402,
0.0191680398,
-0.3479834795,
0.0372923911,
-0.364913106,
-1.0354779959,
1.0714104176,
0.662991941,
-0.5722521544,
-0.0923612788,
0.4052721262,
0.480217576,
-0.1333345473,
-0.1757755578,
0.3744970262,
0.5672058463,
0.3883014917,
-0.815431416,
-0.0178690255,
0.4179595709,
0.3242145777,
0.2079823166,
-0.2803194821,
0.8111470342,
-0.3699817657,
-0.401786685,
0.1564529985,
0.6086201668,
0.5884931087,
0.4497473538,
0.6016552448,
0.5651697516,
0.4361113608,
-0.0332782008,
1.3938219547,
-0.496075958,
0.4852793515,
1.0389862061,
-0.2544347048,
0.8552769423,
0.3475189209,
-0.3165732324,
0.3998410404,
0.3425121903,
0.3762696087,
0.3555845022,
0.3441260159,
-0.1318074018,
-0.1257171929,
-0.0763711482,
-0.174397409,
0.0500122942,
0.5517590642,
-0.429451108,
-0.071583122,
-0.1312431544,
0.0327172764,
0.3926991522,
-0.3442525268,
0.6087526083,
0.5497182608,
-0.5349235535,
0.6233075261,
-0.211808145,
0.5457618237,
-0.4345515668,
0.1122128293,
-0.0609327033,
0.3030341268,
-0.2889956236,
-0.5103828907,
0.6114928126,
-0.1452019662,
-0.120249778,
-0.1803485006,
1.0099328756,
-0.4926540554,
-0.6183230877,
0.138393715,
0.3464455009,
-0.2457546592,
0.1634040624,
-0.4180816114,
-0.1623391509,
-0.2966875136,
-0.4772957563,
0.4213182628,
0.204016313,
0.0143692093,
0.766843617,
0.6184366345,
0.4127371311,
0.3639988005,
-0.1196748689,
0.5473204851,
-0.534334898,
-0.1211490333,
-0.4380724728,
0.6026824117,
0.1716678888,
0.1006164849,
0.6959322691,
0.3724290133,
0.6391356587,
-0.1258711368,
0.6480835676,
-0.0445784442,
0.7091912031,
-0.5766742826,
0.8288907409,
-0.2536461651,
0.3889735341,
-0.1211987734,
-0.9839057922,
-0.4399603903,
0.22010912,
-0.1665908843,
0.0719366521,
0.6800199151,
0.7644928694,
0.2430983633,
-0.3612931371,
0.5003241897,
0.20954974,
0.544326365,
0.319050163,
0.7637869716,
-0.4246889353,
0.6158975959,
-0.2693795264,
-0.0641314909,
-0.0384990647,
-1.1538513899,
-0.6005207896,
-0.6377464533,
-0.1567300409,
-0.8835622072,
-0.0668414533,
0.5401974916,
0.312289387,
-0.8131010532,
0.0401510857,
-0.1239742935,
0.2386090755,
-0.1543595195,
-0.2148529291,
0.0825428069,
-0.3969750702,
-0.5286095142,
0.3339536488,
-0.062601395,
0.2699547112,
-0.3617227972,
-0.1875057966,
-0.0114251096,
0.3295095563,
0.2680624425,
0.4870446026,
-0.6632886529,
-0.6546331048,
-0.1242803484,
-0.3391925991,
-0.1567972898,
0.7052212358,
-0.6416658163,
0.2461607456,
0.574952662,
0.6695929766,
0.5086361766,
-0.0304595307,
0.4128570855,
-0.7417038679,
0.1598640084,
0.3498554826,
0.3283295333,
0.2419109941,
-0.6234126687,
0.4309391975,
-0.1108402908,
-0.8333097696,
-1.0258321762,
0.6825348735,
-0.9461888075,
0.0401558019,
1.4247063398,
-0.1297379881,
0.0096713342,
-0.092553556,
0.1225730851,
0.2487898469,
0.2088784128,
0.9125531316,
0.4040339291,
0.2717804313,
-0.0688043237,
-0.8080807924,
0.8101599813,
0.1784720272,
-0.7828140855,
0.3475164771,
0.3481081724,
0.2816340029,
0.4254696369,
0.3095667064,
-0.4302102327,
0.2417739779,
-0.0192957111,
0.097453922,
-0.0334809236,
-0.3300727904,
-0.3402610719,
0.0862835795,
0.5346782207,
0.2820203304
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03177v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03177v1
|
CIDAR: Culturally Relevant Instruction Dataset For Arabic
| 2024-02-05T16:44:17 | 2024-02-05T16:44:17 |
Zaid Alyafeai, Khalid Almubarak, Ahmed Ashraf, Deema Alnuhait, Saied Alshahrani, Gubran A. Q. Abdulrahman, Gamil Ahmed, Qais Gawah, Zead Saleh, Mustafa Ghaleb, Yousef Ali, Maged S. Al-Shaibani
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Instruction tuning has emerged as a prominent methodology for teaching Large
Language Models (LLMs) to follow instructions. However, current instruction
datasets predominantly cater to English or are derived from English-dominated
LLMs, resulting in inherent biases toward Western culture. This bias
significantly impacts the linguistic structures of non-English languages such
as Arabic, which has a distinct grammar reflective of the diverse cultures
across the Arab region. This paper addresses this limitation by introducing
CIDAR: https://hf.co/datasets/arbml/CIDAR, the first open Arabic
instruction-tuning dataset culturally-aligned by human reviewers. CIDAR
contains 10,000 instruction and output pairs that represent the Arab region. We
discuss the cultural relevance of CIDAR via the analysis and comparison to
other models fine-tuned on other datasets. Our experiments show that CIDAR can
help enrich research efforts in aligning LLMs with the Arabic culture. All the
code is available at https://github.com/ARBML/CIDAR.
|
[
-0.2767068446,
-0.4560555816,
0.0500291847,
0.2558982968,
-0.0089843879,
0.3552128375,
-0.4057094753,
-0.1638917923,
-0.1560732424,
0.3681825399,
-0.2529299855,
-0.8623069525,
-0.4917016923,
-0.1894409657,
-0.3821033239,
1.1365870237,
-0.1940177679,
0.3020737171,
-0.0414415635,
-0.4070620239,
-0.6626327038,
-0.492967248,
-0.4983501136,
-0.3594681025,
0.2746005654,
0.9171456099,
0.579528749,
0.9895756841,
0.6726723313,
0.1809875518,
0.0626690835,
0.3169409335,
-0.4788152874,
0.0550768748,
-0.2248053253,
-0.4010843635,
-0.1590072364,
-0.285648495,
0.5123624802,
0.643538177,
-0.2940631509,
0.6175601482,
-0.1096886471,
0.9593228698,
-0.6515960097,
0.0943857133,
-0.4378330708,
-0.1944485158,
-0.2910238504,
-0.0388326831,
-0.3360215127,
-0.7090648413,
0.0367262065,
0.0872343704,
0.2044576705,
0.2316615134,
0.4045096636,
0.4360582232,
-0.7149091959,
-0.3782094419,
-0.7590022683,
0.7518164515,
-0.3612324595,
0.5346833467,
0.4121743739,
0.3303688765,
-0.2496263683,
-0.4350721836,
-0.3641835451,
0.00280165,
0.0898833722,
-0.246195823,
-0.0492396802,
-0.1311658323,
-0.0009969929,
0.3877405822,
-0.3903296292,
0.3373762071,
-0.476082325,
-0.1768666059,
0.5528846383,
0.2407449931,
0.4321029484,
0.5432284474,
-0.1318452507,
-0.2465707362,
-1.0277260542,
0.4834409952,
0.46774593,
0.235897854,
-0.7166047096,
0.3661671877,
-0.0938848406,
0.894723773,
0.2742740512,
-0.2971974313,
-0.0225079861,
0.0860450268,
0.0211145747,
0.494204402,
0.3422630727,
0.3335832059,
0.4206114113,
0.0042577083,
0.0203258861,
0.2287722081,
0.175696969,
-0.9462717772,
-0.3926922977,
-0.0336544253,
-0.4452510476,
-0.13737005,
0.054292284,
-0.7007620931,
-0.4553645551,
-0.3157408535,
-0.1496600807,
0.0166261625,
0.1350711137,
-0.1092960313,
0.356146127,
0.6951910257,
0.0406249464,
-1.1080569029,
0.3312542737,
0.6646558642,
0.7156908512,
-0.1491537839,
-0.2582035363,
-0.5148922801,
0.036786627,
-0.6480956674,
0.6958533525,
-1.0205953121,
-0.4014737904,
-0.0013862675,
-0.0481633581,
0.2343629897,
-0.481385529,
0.7222842574,
-0.7944906354,
0.0210146848,
-0.4152725041,
-0.2133142948,
-0.4661861956,
0.075361751,
-0.4991907775,
0.8334397674,
0.0756579489,
-0.5312134027,
0.2609241605,
-0.6614355445,
-0.7323394418,
-0.2025330365,
-0.2859704792,
-0.3511234224,
0.066493541,
0.5856139064,
0.107962504,
-0.4637742341,
0.210010007,
0.1834403872,
-0.7180373669,
0.0214456152,
-0.4373008907,
0.6967484355,
0.4345518351,
-0.4162885547,
0.2058166265,
-0.5664515495,
-0.0861791819,
-0.078060016,
-0.3461080194,
-0.2540875375,
0.0568487346,
-0.0083679827,
0.1094246283,
0.1696251631,
-0.4407514632,
0.2022946775,
-0.2076489627,
0.0693862811,
0.852381587,
-0.096200496,
0.5382056236,
-0.4751934409,
0.8260940313,
0.1977198273,
-0.126147598,
-0.2321232557,
-0.1469218582,
-0.7637199759,
-0.3641615808,
0.2279606909,
0.51603055,
-0.2989382446,
0.089917846,
-0.1078274921,
-0.7029003501,
-0.874068141,
0.3997967541,
0.3168019056,
0.5270168185,
0.1112343222,
-0.3478169143,
-0.6417384744,
-0.808703661,
-0.0309947897,
-0.0551702045,
0.3819368482,
0.2225665748,
0.2631963193,
-0.1930989325,
0.7549227476,
-0.2769072056,
-0.3201553524,
-0.1374244094,
-0.111325182,
0.3963708282,
0.4688229263,
0.6264759302,
-0.3117220998,
-0.8149907589,
0.2591029406,
-0.4980633855,
-0.195539698,
0.0160356369,
-0.4661367536,
0.4084984064,
0.5007727146,
0.0358799808,
0.4574955404,
0.8388303518,
-0.2964119613,
0.1941259801,
-0.0394068398,
0.3063148558,
-1.0315468311,
-0.0601751022,
-0.1844005287,
0.0159044433,
-0.480938375,
-0.0005594988,
0.0782475919,
-0.0473355688,
-0.3888784945,
0.6636969447,
-0.5132562518,
0.2103419006,
-0.4691546559,
-0.679389596,
-0.1132617742,
0.2795297503,
0.2761863768,
1.3747547865,
0.6195662022,
-0.4742474258,
0.0600748807,
0.4759999514,
-0.7847903967,
0.4400148392,
-0.7151426077,
0.4812475443,
-0.3709229529,
0.1965087652,
-0.5901203752,
-0.1212791353,
0.23526223,
-0.0864996389,
0.3756342828,
-0.3066150844,
-0.0596326441,
0.0570999943,
-0.0536820889,
0.7367171645,
0.631629169,
-0.8655946851,
0.4807609618,
0.3124931157,
-0.1084373742,
-0.864130497,
-0.3130831718,
-0.0510429405,
-0.3754526675,
-0.3878600299,
0.0941875055,
0.0503187068,
-0.5066004395,
-0.3340795934,
-0.2189744264,
0.1172312275,
0.1446490735,
0.5193172097,
0.2356393635,
-0.3370828032,
0.0827428102,
0.2079205066,
0.3429285884,
0.14620848,
-0.1027599946,
0.7204866409,
-0.3152165115,
-0.502297163,
-0.5043227673,
0.3277842104,
0.6498195529,
-0.7204595208,
1.0116440058,
0.6299464703,
-0.1392123848,
-0.2147579044,
-0.5348075032,
-0.1896431148,
-0.4918106794,
0.4118734896,
-0.168763414,
-0.6028909087,
0.4111556411,
0.0161211174,
0.1419450194,
-0.0520987734,
0.7324308753,
-0.1875860393,
1.0230081081,
0.8151534796,
-0.6000549197,
0.4461123347,
-0.1008843407,
0.2341040224,
-0.6313414574,
-0.3847594261,
-0.7054230571,
-0.7293119431,
-0.7443636656,
-0.2199032605,
0.4542469978,
-0.2214848995,
-0.84807235,
-0.314153254,
-0.2930110395,
0.8930056691,
0.7966439128,
-0.1337019205,
-0.0252233241,
0.3408358991,
-0.2088841051,
-0.0113586858,
-0.6255775094,
-0.7357476354,
1.0882303715,
0.2182015181,
1.3510121107,
0.4293299615,
0.5845179558,
0.6502053142,
0.313636452,
-0.6475189328,
0.1696877778,
-0.1564213783,
-0.4584982991,
0.2733204961,
-0.0574550256,
-0.8625763655,
-0.3295963705,
0.0585547164,
-0.582247436,
0.2077472657,
0.0292347781,
-0.1071610153,
0.2378325164,
-0.7893645763,
0.6062034965,
-0.58248806,
-0.4582300484,
-0.0081558945,
-0.7637372017,
0.1380227655,
-0.0495879762,
0.2100419998,
-0.0208575763,
0.157154128,
0.8133496642,
-0.1238973662,
1.0343120098,
-0.1137423068,
-0.2231158912,
0.3912559748,
0.3165369034,
0.3551706076,
-0.1693974137,
-0.1414362341,
0.282851398,
0.1442873776,
-0.4888201356,
-0.4612083733,
0.8693058491,
-1.2418819666,
-0.755705595,
-0.6351991892,
-1.0034399033,
-0.1791209131,
-0.086531207,
-0.2413413823,
0.4237555265,
0.0579070412,
0.1763046384,
0.461807251,
-0.3344386518,
0.2312949747,
0.6222012639,
-0.154784292,
-0.1574568897,
0.8953480721,
-0.1936714649,
0.0504600927,
0.2267858386,
-0.0257421322,
-0.1783324629,
-0.5098591447,
-0.5759624243,
0.1838092208,
-0.8119923472,
-0.2334843874,
-0.2273702919,
-0.134869948,
-0.2999587059,
-0.3431717753,
-0.0606919415,
-0.027580332,
-0.4047086835,
-0.0569110662,
0.5600481629,
0.8236222863,
-0.0089420024,
0.4829225838,
-0.7463555932,
0.0205752067,
0.0692047179,
0.2766839862,
0.0194808226,
-0.7160492539,
-0.3520378768,
0.2959773839,
-0.2786352038,
-0.7269035578,
0.3874903023,
0.5113971233,
0.5055379272,
0.5557419658,
0.1854212135,
0.7629863024,
-0.594535768,
0.525605917,
-0.3166594207,
-0.7486971617,
0.6353035569,
-0.0694739223,
0.6474516392,
0.6468316913,
0.5514560342,
-0.8131477833,
-0.063160412,
0.0145488046,
-0.5234051943,
0.7839544415,
-0.3854285777,
0.4302292168,
-0.1888518035,
0.2549963892,
0.4476667941,
0.0896707103,
-0.1477919221,
-0.5716142654,
-0.1324560791,
-0.6317844391,
0.0361893736,
-0.3426501155,
-0.1923504174,
-0.3174742758,
0.8007400036,
-0.1285078526,
0.083874397,
-0.2862849832,
-0.2933249474,
-0.1849193126,
0.3662537038,
0.5709158778,
0.7697395086,
-0.180734396,
0.0822574869,
0.1046484858,
-0.7702472806,
0.4248662889,
-0.1995691806,
-0.3224225938,
-0.5512616634,
0.3995115161,
0.6085010171,
-0.3208695948,
-0.8708559275,
0.0324584134,
-0.1588518769,
0.3111492991,
-0.2287740558,
0.2336793691,
-0.2460110337,
0.361831069,
0.2383343428,
0.096208334,
-0.2002380639,
-0.5300511718,
0.0718025714,
0.3631565869,
-0.6326877475,
-0.2457627654,
0.5615208149,
0.3134155869,
-0.3455691636,
0.9909285903,
0.0890847072,
-0.6852197647,
0.6663233638,
0.7735548019,
0.3317999542,
-0.1705144197,
0.2814197838,
0.2558841705,
0.4306887388,
0.2893678844,
0.510818243,
-0.1289214492,
-0.7411845326,
-0.3624735475,
-0.7515766025,
-0.554132998,
-0.2219346911,
-0.7325454354,
0.2766650021,
-0.4204385877,
0.1735230833,
-0.5961575508,
0.0746953487,
-0.8175554872,
0.0600968599,
0.2142285407,
0.8108301163,
-0.9876692891,
0.9083330035,
1.147756815,
-0.1737832725,
-0.7049754262,
-0.0122646978,
0.0891583487,
-1.0499926805,
0.8536322117,
0.008402816,
-0.3518224955,
0.133525908,
-0.6805723906,
-0.7818784714,
0.8247854114,
0.4096755087,
-0.5169898868,
0.2771109343,
0.2220805436,
0.4835018516,
-0.4646982849,
0.2019691318,
0.778021276,
0.233770743,
0.1972874403,
-0.4998196959,
-0.2131004184,
-0.1461123228,
-0.2362521142,
0.3018757403,
-0.7500953078,
0.4236196876,
-0.5447198749,
-0.0604216717,
0.0883686244,
0.9430475235,
0.1504053026,
0.0914967656,
0.1212262884,
0.429987222,
0.8597522378,
-0.0329672918,
0.8396700025,
-0.5020189881,
-0.2293878943,
1.3056288958,
-0.4793394506,
0.6969816685,
0.4834537804,
-0.1322464347,
0.6804043055,
0.7044120431,
0.0597677864,
0.6588375568,
0.2291425765,
-0.4133111238,
0.0399223641,
-0.7560947537,
-0.6726241112,
1.035292387,
0.2748725414,
-0.3807533979,
-0.1366481036,
-0.2357348502,
0.2305045128,
0.4110547006,
-0.4582675397,
0.686027348,
-0.2706550658,
-0.5497953892,
0.6130332947,
0.1018859372,
0.5234447122,
-0.4877097905,
-0.3081431687,
-0.6207565665,
0.0485051386,
-0.1684476435,
-0.3904646039,
0.1741120666,
0.3239612579,
-0.2742379606,
0.0419893675,
0.3752101362,
-0.5656187534,
-0.8306137323,
-0.2012353241,
0.5212379694,
-0.007429292,
0.5517394543,
-0.1261983067,
0.2794003487,
0.166260466,
0.302623868,
0.2313584834,
0.0980585814,
-0.4870776236,
0.551122129,
0.6040750146,
0.1802905202,
0.010112904,
0.0988778993,
0.5057973266,
-0.5913901329,
-0.1559775919,
-0.8733209968,
0.153905496,
0.4137767851,
-0.2375490367,
0.584006846,
0.4555701017,
1.0472593307,
-0.0787108317,
0.645493567,
0.0592992008,
0.2039442062,
-0.3392335474,
1.0593311787,
-0.2213665098,
0.3527953327,
0.2469721735,
-1.0178625584,
-0.2169650644,
0.547388494,
-0.4168758392,
0.215784058,
0.4838591814,
1.0048407316,
-0.1283863038,
0.1733912379,
0.0687405542,
0.0993547514,
0.2658863366,
0.3375208378,
0.8737534881,
-0.0712516531,
0.2843898237,
-0.5158164501,
-0.1488602608,
0.1336270124,
-0.8946626186,
-1.1393809319,
-0.4248588979,
-0.2807610035,
0.0718201175,
0.1327411681,
1.6027787924,
0.6308385134,
-1.1910572052,
-0.589030385,
0.4284813702,
0.1796158552,
-0.4204506278,
-0.1379404664,
0.6030185819,
-0.1249980032,
-0.7819173336,
0.3551056385,
-0.1440684944,
0.0751154572,
-0.01835314,
-0.1516742408,
-0.3494807482,
-0.0455145538,
0.3878728747,
0.2967685163,
-0.5343298316,
-0.3792861104,
0.1099889949,
0.0444545485,
0.1139432341,
0.5738393664,
-0.7720873356,
0.5044146776,
0.1511996835,
1.0978634357,
0.1258011609,
0.035325747,
0.6632707715,
-0.822987318,
0.1309681535,
0.0286959764,
0.1687942743,
0.4377349019,
-0.243355006,
0.5781167746,
-0.4542764127,
-0.6325862408,
-0.5965676308,
0.1661338359,
-0.656847775,
0.3268609345,
1.0382784605,
0.0315096751,
-0.1186120659,
-0.0418494269,
-0.4780366123,
0.2388447523,
-0.4946371019,
1.0394785404,
0.7879490852,
0.0468282476,
-0.2993122041,
-0.1714238226,
0.1826182753,
0.4701895416,
-0.7244182229,
-0.2482525706,
0.5653182268,
0.155679673,
-0.5224514604,
0.0106194085,
0.1650452018,
0.4626241028,
-0.4150445163,
0.1917100996,
-0.2497743964,
-0.3950844705,
-0.3881070316,
-0.1690115333,
0.5784549713,
-0.229501605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03173v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03173v2
|
MULTI: Multimodal Understanding Leaderboard with Text and Images
| 2024-02-05T16:41:02 | 2024-02-20T07:55:52 |
Zichen Zhu, Yang Xu, Lu Chen, Jingkai Yang, Yichuan Ma, Yiming Sun, Hailin Wen, Jiaqi Liu, Jinyu Cai, Yingzi Ma, Situo Zhang, Zihan Zhao, Liangtai Sun, Kai Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV
|
Rapid progress in multimodal large language models (MLLMs) highlights the
need to introduce challenging yet realistic benchmarks to the academic
community, while existing benchmarks primarily focus on understanding simple
natural images and short context. In this paper, we present MULTI as a
cutting-edge benchmark for evaluating MLLMs on understanding complex tables and
images, and reasoning with long context. MULTI provides multimodal inputs and
requires responses that are either precise or open-ended, reflecting real-life
examination styles. MULTI includes over 18,000 questions and challenges MLLMs
with a variety of tasks, ranging from formula derivation to image detail
analysis and cross-modality reasoning. We also introduce MULTI-Elite, a
500-question selected hard subset, and MULTI-Extend, with more than 4,500
external knowledge context pieces. Our evaluation indicates significant
potential for MLLM advancement, with GPT-4V achieving a 63.7% accuracy rate on
MULTI, in contrast to other MLLMs scoring between 28.5% and 55.3%. MULTI serves
not only as a robust evaluation platform but also paves the way for the
development of expert-level AI.
|
[
-0.5495847464,
-0.8822199702,
0.5935115814,
0.3217134178,
-0.1154932305,
0.1916766912,
-0.4380856752,
-0.4691040516,
-0.414880991,
0.1234085113,
-0.6059582233,
-0.4974484742,
-0.7348414063,
0.058937341,
-0.0424311124,
0.8320993781,
-0.1795673519,
0.1858070642,
-0.5211310983,
-0.4952451289,
-0.5640511513,
-0.5771178007,
-0.44923684,
-0.2449272871,
0.7670372128,
0.2905122638,
0.655843854,
0.2665549219,
0.713548243,
0.3879581094,
0.0732582361,
0.3860870898,
-0.3017370999,
0.1624449492,
-0.0616986044,
-0.0878388509,
-0.668602705,
-0.0303915627,
0.6999911666,
0.5619369149,
0.1481622905,
0.4336739182,
0.1038106978,
0.8483988643,
-0.7296402454,
0.4996361732,
-0.4818961918,
0.1603042334,
-0.0814990774,
-0.0611793324,
-0.4708459079,
0.0798168331,
0.1076680273,
-0.5838513374,
-0.1891097426,
-0.0093446551,
0.5216445923,
0.1297083497,
-0.9311923385,
-0.216415748,
-0.4248688817,
0.9029494524,
-0.1313460171,
0.8693484068,
0.283616662,
0.8438078761,
-0.0590629876,
-0.9897839427,
-0.5351061821,
-0.3185098767,
0.0790947974,
0.2821996808,
0.0372978821,
-0.111691758,
0.101254262,
0.1801774502,
-0.7419782281,
-0.1034865901,
-0.2433028817,
-0.1779045463,
0.550242424,
0.2398820817,
0.0452395566,
-0.0107375691,
-0.6058367491,
-0.1740693003,
-0.4294107556,
0.1914169788,
-0.032321427,
0.0364446081,
-0.1244683936,
0.3741259575,
0.0081025725,
0.9638444185,
-0.5800189972,
-0.2542290688,
0.4069775343,
-0.7924233079,
-0.3446287215,
-0.4681055248,
0.6917989254,
0.7154554129,
0.2961141467,
-0.0063794176,
-0.0987910926,
-0.0417900458,
0.009676843,
-0.814989984,
-0.1438638717,
0.0652232617,
-0.6375598311,
0.1828797609,
-0.1723781377,
-0.9192407727,
-0.3162606955,
-0.5440388918,
0.5089347959,
-0.2810049355,
-0.1620445102,
-0.1201156154,
-0.114879027,
0.2843482792,
0.8845158815,
-0.6076918244,
0.0555936135,
0.6092366576,
0.8231278062,
-0.2583467066,
-0.5653552413,
-0.6233478785,
-0.026692288,
-0.260456413,
0.8142131567,
-0.6704692245,
-0.277885437,
-0.2943814695,
-0.1214211807,
-0.3174799681,
-0.539781034,
0.7213608027,
-0.3391911387,
0.2407272905,
-0.1083734781,
-0.3132500648,
-0.2232798189,
0.8234959841,
-0.6483761072,
0.8929306865,
-0.1716155261,
-0.4218583405,
0.529158473,
-0.8892362118,
-0.2623051107,
-0.0533741675,
-0.3737412989,
-0.1810791939,
-0.1557575464,
0.440841198,
0.53386271,
-0.3417879045,
0.402749151,
-0.3816372752,
-0.2388728708,
0.2477886677,
-0.7480996251,
0.3933348656,
0.2996217012,
-0.1139839441,
0.4292964041,
-0.6876683235,
0.3523234427,
-0.0671043321,
-0.4687862098,
-0.0242086984,
-0.083279781,
0.4045156538,
0.6066706777,
0.2114079893,
-0.289416194,
0.197775498,
0.4948440194,
0.5162879825,
0.8548462391,
-0.1547020376,
-0.0006926594,
-0.1221619695,
0.2573627234,
0.1498267204,
0.4793707728,
-0.4280456603,
-0.8429711461,
-0.4277369976,
-0.5339161754,
0.2815308869,
0.3942133188,
-0.7749524117,
0.0739972219,
-0.3366250098,
-0.5618413091,
-0.7427930236,
0.2934336662,
0.4976629615,
0.4320954978,
0.7764933109,
-0.0756236017,
-0.2843868434,
-1.1185965538,
-0.3798415065,
0.1303368956,
-0.0427199863,
0.4679073989,
0.6847891808,
-0.4091980457,
0.5301413536,
-0.1897622943,
-0.4265234768,
-0.0662730783,
0.3449275494,
0.2020749599,
0.5250065923,
0.1884195507,
-1.0469613075,
-0.6032621861,
0.1742749363,
-0.921916604,
0.4307584763,
-0.1974896491,
-0.011697609,
-0.1414397061,
0.4714052677,
-0.6235112548,
0.168389082,
0.6639637947,
-0.4222539067,
0.5994368196,
-0.3215123415,
0.5747894645,
-0.7885455489,
0.2762096524,
0.1449649483,
-0.30628106,
-0.6046444774,
0.1790185124,
0.3852593303,
-0.0499109551,
-0.3167715371,
0.5292739272,
-0.6355964541,
-0.1920584887,
0.1400668621,
0.3404568136,
0.141104266,
0.5337567925,
-0.2303415686,
0.7587867379,
0.4908024967,
-0.2508656681,
0.4244626462,
0.0745388493,
-0.7654049397,
0.7073721886,
-0.4117275774,
0.1183525249,
-0.239414081,
0.3111552596,
-1.0209738016,
0.0538121909,
-0.2046382129,
-0.229860872,
0.2332128286,
-0.0114818634,
-0.5629506707,
-0.34751302,
-0.3319555521,
0.3944456875,
0.160963282,
-0.436300844,
0.8374550343,
0.2228310406,
0.0027856557,
-0.9250255227,
-0.4453631639,
0.3983486593,
0.0109418221,
-0.7053676844,
0.2517047226,
-0.522038579,
-0.377869308,
-0.1855744272,
-0.0751064122,
-0.1765684783,
0.2041817158,
0.2013420165,
0.110297434,
-0.4824876785,
0.2468331605,
-0.1173720807,
-0.0621583238,
-0.0984902233,
0.1807560325,
0.381164372,
-0.5466353893,
-0.5436577201,
-0.4351351857,
0.4398244321,
1.1018650532,
-0.4065741897,
0.460549444,
0.8686575294,
-0.2204354852,
0.0101523967,
-0.454577744,
0.0085591553,
-0.4091426134,
0.6788050532,
-0.8881436586,
-0.6626586318,
0.3764193654,
-0.0279506687,
0.3040457666,
0.5201416016,
0.679864645,
-0.1140206605,
1.2548823357,
0.3540028632,
0.1743388921,
0.1578648537,
0.0101163136,
-0.0017549534,
-0.7582424283,
-0.5271075368,
-0.3217123151,
-0.4551801085,
-0.3376179636,
-0.7018846273,
0.4622030854,
0.1804184318,
-0.1341972351,
-0.0561406314,
-0.2569490969,
0.5119466782,
0.3706828058,
0.2115090042,
0.6483845115,
-0.3595026135,
-0.1170152277,
-0.1601599157,
-0.4581884742,
-0.4411685765,
1.0888750553,
0.5245437622,
0.7656273246,
0.3074832261,
0.0656716451,
0.4717871845,
0.7192103863,
-0.714127779,
0.4286392331,
-0.0619737841,
-0.7843809724,
-0.2369318604,
-0.3940629661,
-0.7005250454,
0.904754281,
-0.3318953514,
-0.4877343476,
-0.1564758271,
0.0373716578,
-0.0826846436,
0.1108956784,
-1.0625853539,
1.3573731184,
-0.5058648586,
-0.4134009778,
-0.1628196836,
-0.7880721688,
0.4538984299,
-0.1003610194,
0.5422697067,
-0.2459520996,
-0.1808778942,
0.5620239377,
0.1555542946,
0.5087326765,
-0.2789218128,
0.1246638447,
-0.0923177525,
-0.1544503272,
0.0352001786,
0.0593063571,
-0.1803857982,
-0.0136278495,
0.083947219,
-0.3797592819,
-0.8479624987,
0.7396258712,
-0.7043722272,
-0.4449739456,
-0.1820102185,
-0.693503201,
-0.4613021016,
0.1164409369,
-0.2035872191,
0.6171265244,
-0.1881133169,
0.5674524903,
0.2718844712,
-0.0922789797,
0.3820976615,
0.169153139,
-0.3167854249,
-0.4348965883,
0.8569803238,
-0.0084366631,
0.2588105202,
0.3808661997,
0.1873192042,
-0.6073031425,
-0.5189361572,
-1.0263949633,
-0.1382227838,
-1.0926412344,
-0.1830163151,
-0.8075138927,
0.0656297877,
-0.1605833173,
0.1165292114,
-0.325421989,
-0.1891662329,
0.1070323065,
-0.0009212609,
-0.0135736121,
0.7231398225,
0.2571639717,
-0.1250550449,
-0.8406771421,
0.191056639,
0.5654370785,
0.4821178615,
0.1121943817,
-0.4134311378,
-0.170206964,
-0.1429740489,
-0.3840729892,
-0.624833107,
-0.0306794737,
0.4611598253,
1.0777864456,
0.3457013667,
-0.3126578331,
1.0307458639,
-0.6217713952,
0.7354348898,
0.2685522437,
-1.001321435,
0.2788383961,
-0.0510182865,
0.5465034246,
0.7406388521,
0.5208339095,
-0.4694213867,
-0.1141720265,
-0.2162384093,
-0.5752144456,
0.193281889,
0.144925192,
-0.0713190213,
0.3141998053,
-0.1105050668,
0.2262035906,
0.3040724397,
-0.9807670116,
-0.2463584691,
-0.2537328303,
-0.2262380123,
-0.3842425644,
-0.0759517029,
-0.1588454098,
-0.3878763318,
0.2765495181,
-0.3325434029,
0.1538243443,
0.1259142607,
-0.5197463632,
0.2485196143,
0.4898723066,
1.0945845842,
1.0427846909,
-0.3268562555,
0.4600059688,
0.2013930678,
-0.3109818697,
-0.1389401853,
0.0647780225,
0.5513629317,
-0.0995204598,
0.6983444691,
0.6589420438,
0.2186198682,
-0.8712850213,
0.6165676117,
-0.2306280881,
-0.2008757889,
0.068739213,
-0.3053538203,
0.1172694117,
0.3327733874,
0.5436271429,
0.1547793597,
0.1763496101,
-0.83700037,
0.5039528608,
0.4825743139,
-0.5666399002,
-0.1981859803,
0.4842550159,
0.2615523636,
-0.0744537413,
0.4289675951,
0.0000765009,
-0.4819056392,
0.5382543206,
0.4298045039,
0.3529424369,
-0.164902091,
-0.0688688904,
0.4245275855,
0.4927008152,
0.20460549,
0.3528750837,
-0.3625315726,
-0.5868265033,
-0.4296371341,
-0.4154470861,
-0.6291358471,
0.0562566184,
-0.5493168831,
0.0753163248,
-0.4382599592,
-0.233166784,
0.3292874396,
-0.2037231177,
-0.7368309498,
0.1959980726,
0.1247081831,
0.9410407543,
-0.6266742945,
0.855656147,
0.6344285011,
-0.2593687475,
-0.2259953618,
-0.362280488,
0.0036580525,
-0.8407365084,
0.8878693581,
0.6401988864,
-0.1117618829,
-0.2339862883,
-0.3114131987,
-0.4638015628,
1.1163344383,
0.0584796965,
-0.416010052,
0.1246590763,
-0.2423147112,
0.4820040464,
-0.435900867,
0.7316877842,
0.3575624526,
0.8803772926,
-0.1134118363,
-1.1192350388,
-0.1335985363,
-0.4771441221,
-0.3396056592,
0.1519827247,
-0.5008496642,
1.2027975321,
-0.2222371548,
-0.059860833,
-0.1633648872,
0.4269482493,
0.2388426363,
0.5408816934,
0.6007175446,
0.3772205114,
0.5808890462,
-0.1277552396,
0.8377708197,
-0.0598343499,
0.3925305903,
1.1242002249,
-0.3677366376,
1.0240421295,
0.58771348,
-0.1578614116,
0.6480878592,
0.5350765586,
-0.1212082952,
0.35069713,
0.1650941223,
-0.2116763443,
-0.4655421376,
-0.0608912818,
-0.6319585443,
0.6973994374,
0.5526480079,
-0.3349170089,
-0.4820093811,
0.2660488784,
-0.2311284542,
0.0637521893,
-0.3597530425,
0.739513278,
-0.0006899719,
-0.701259017,
0.4624571204,
-0.0540629253,
0.5972028375,
-0.558935225,
-0.1626817435,
-0.0458784327,
0.3748194575,
-0.035544809,
-1.1166081429,
0.0449438132,
-0.1301592737,
-0.1146076173,
-0.444707036,
0.4578736424,
-0.5180105567,
-0.341407299,
0.4577842653,
0.8257731795,
0.1305595636,
-0.2523236275,
-1.0192024708,
0.1918604076,
-0.2112007886,
-0.2893573642,
0.3486286402,
0.3718365431,
-0.1159949675,
0.8226566911,
0.6383271217,
-0.6296640635,
0.0483096391,
0.1838668287,
0.8172457218,
-0.6457859874,
-0.3072858155,
-0.9402418137,
0.6121166945,
-0.3346486688,
-0.5481751561,
0.7620095015,
0.7467125058,
0.6438973546,
-0.0931006297,
0.4560103416,
0.2361376882,
0.1692216843,
-0.5225545168,
0.8565061092,
-0.8858625293,
-0.3090369403,
-0.2617540956,
-0.7805678844,
-0.5169699192,
0.5474258065,
-0.1497561336,
0.0944669619,
0.7262768745,
0.4881843925,
-0.1013694331,
0.0449767001,
0.6605693102,
-0.048912324,
0.4321057796,
0.6627482772,
1.1018168926,
-0.4065775573,
0.6550255418,
-0.0247179568,
-0.464605093,
-0.0111492444,
-0.9024666548,
-0.97775805,
-0.7055172324,
0.0053788023,
-0.0671575069,
-0.0883630663,
1.0097696781,
0.9058254957,
-0.7448612452,
-0.2902779579,
0.4696965516,
0.2571257353,
-0.3208627999,
-0.1761652827,
0.3492401838,
-0.1079238877,
-0.6109251976,
0.5159124732,
0.5592893362,
-0.1027167439,
-0.382407099,
-0.2019597888,
-0.580262959,
-0.341070056,
1.1962896585,
-0.0776786506,
-0.8035271168,
-0.1506945938,
0.0662951693,
-0.2008448988,
0.2646764517,
0.7821111083,
-0.4737962782,
0.7801252604,
0.4186913967,
0.7563044429,
0.5597099662,
-0.020808395,
0.3467977941,
-0.5488787293,
0.0756718591,
0.2667323649,
0.5167679191,
0.3544232845,
0.0169259403,
0.4445040226,
0.3065027893,
-0.5325285196,
-0.8522873521,
0.1316635013,
-1.0825282335,
-0.4368222952,
0.6662732959,
-0.214166984,
-0.1377061456,
-0.2664145827,
-0.1352188438,
-0.1023828089,
-0.3122169971,
0.3992927074,
0.8109781742,
-0.2732338309,
-0.5319135785,
-0.9096325636,
0.2310141325,
0.4190010428,
-1.1409777403,
-0.028346153,
0.5816150904,
-0.0030679426,
0.3005941808,
0.6227745414,
-0.141942203,
0.3153685331,
-0.0267736539,
-0.0463145152,
-0.1895697713,
-0.683922112,
-0.1412611604,
0.4893935025,
0.0039793509,
-0.2254131138
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03172v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03172v1
|
Accurate and Well-Calibrated ICD Code Assignment Through Attention Over Diverse Label Embeddings
| 2024-02-05T16:40:23 | 2024-02-05T16:40:23 |
Gonçalo Gomes, Isabel Coutinho, Bruno Martins
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Although the International Classification of Diseases (ICD) has been adopted
worldwide, manually assigning ICD codes to clinical text is time-consuming,
error-prone, and expensive, motivating the development of automated approaches.
This paper describes a novel approach for automated ICD coding, combining
several ideas from previous related work. We specifically employ a strong
Transformer-based model as a text encoder and, to handle lengthy clinical
narratives, we explored either (a) adapting the base encoder model into a
Longformer, or (b) dividing the text into chunks and processing each chunk
independently. The representations produced by the encoder are combined with a
label embedding mechanism that explores diverse ICD code synonyms. Experiments
with different splits of the MIMIC-III dataset show that the proposed approach
outperforms the current state-of-the-art models in ICD coding, with the label
embeddings significantly contributing to the good performance. Our approach
also leads to properly calibrated classification results, which can effectively
inform downstream tasks such as quantification.
|
[
-0.0893376097,
-0.0298078451,
0.6148750782,
0.2856365144,
-0.5146982074,
0.3155958354,
-0.0223408826,
-0.497318089,
0.3375469148,
0.3544636369,
-0.0946736559,
-0.5272743702,
-0.677103281,
0.3014498353,
-0.2317642272,
1.1210981607,
-0.6910495162,
0.3801632822,
-0.1974354088,
-0.3140506446,
-0.4517053068,
-0.649074614,
-0.1921110302,
-0.3646465242,
0.4378263652,
0.2181703895,
0.6822762489,
1.0499593019,
0.7920131087,
0.0943326727,
0.2613735497,
0.1168287098,
-0.04909252,
-0.1608094126,
-0.0833275467,
-0.3650667369,
-0.6521658301,
-0.3345885873,
0.1194774881,
0.5857913494,
-0.2225809991,
0.18284069,
0.0022123682,
0.2771640122,
-0.5222970843,
0.0020195264,
-0.035332676,
0.1402806938,
0.1083745882,
-0.3409575522,
-0.6020735502,
-0.4755597413,
0.0424908921,
-0.568212688,
0.155110687,
-0.115492709,
0.4863388836,
0.4141748846,
-0.5805117488,
-0.7067620754,
-0.7442091703,
0.4311497509,
-0.3830210865,
0.424823463,
0.2220184505,
0.4888067544,
0.3585590422,
-0.8660296798,
-0.3073402643,
0.0774242058,
-0.1085544527,
0.2897586823,
-0.1551382393,
0.0523333848,
0.1245922521,
0.3954563141,
-0.3973841369,
0.1338579506,
-0.5356748104,
-0.1945565939,
0.3596788347,
0.1496673375,
0.6307654381,
0.2714613676,
-0.2943520844,
0.0774150565,
-0.3492972255,
-0.3422329426,
-0.0882561952,
-0.0232222062,
-0.4849195778,
0.6789604425,
0.0241753887,
0.531242609,
0.4388250113,
-0.3729056716,
0.5854404569,
-0.0674875304,
-0.0264953673,
0.6004887223,
0.5163331032,
0.7021755576,
0.1644983143,
-0.4393728971,
-0.2438625991,
0.1940256357,
0.7500549555,
-0.801214695,
-0.1908451319,
0.3020826876,
-0.7411685586,
-0.2559478283,
-0.1062351316,
-0.7261547446,
-0.1288215071,
-0.4048753977,
0.4364551604,
-0.2611441314,
0.3489309847,
0.2447786778,
0.0928880349,
-0.0030404329,
0.3070736825,
-0.8481784463,
0.6157456636,
0.4498291612,
0.7568400502,
-0.4148167372,
0.0681749955,
-0.5448162556,
0.5458762646,
-0.3542958498,
0.5431079268,
-0.5322619081,
-0.2618901134,
-0.1333252639,
-0.078337051,
0.1084757596,
-0.5588333607,
0.5537970662,
-0.4004956186,
-0.2339211702,
0.3923342228,
-0.4474576116,
0.0740138367,
0.2747402489,
-0.9687481523,
0.474420011,
0.2475791872,
-0.7207595706,
0.1456678957,
-0.3596514165,
-0.649320364,
0.0002864609,
-0.1684385538,
-0.4477981329,
0.096320793,
0.741222918,
0.3609706163,
-0.4449425936,
0.2932959199,
0.1340223104,
-0.2564718723,
0.2711772025,
-0.3043075502,
0.4451408088,
0.243682012,
-0.2560279965,
0.0302838329,
-0.7328035831,
-0.0175600294,
-0.163268581,
-0.168118462,
-0.2789942026,
-0.203414768,
0.1979955584,
-0.0122286808,
-0.0591226071,
-0.5941941142,
0.4926576316,
-0.2990862429,
0.3920390606,
0.3892860711,
0.1973311305,
0.4504804015,
-0.6328980327,
0.7650249004,
0.1114330217,
0.2739847004,
-0.3955734968,
-0.2844398916,
-0.4205006659,
-0.3726190627,
0.499607116,
0.6398165822,
-0.6964096427,
0.4092821777,
-0.6394190788,
-0.561263442,
-0.7694020867,
-0.1786216944,
0.2588119507,
0.4207929373,
0.5384952426,
-0.5689228177,
-0.0285810716,
-0.7288994789,
0.1921093017,
0.0817261189,
-0.2782090902,
0.251765579,
0.4617881775,
-0.5821475387,
0.8090209961,
-0.6157909632,
-0.3972526789,
-0.1412422061,
0.160935685,
0.1747571975,
0.743258357,
0.3953870535,
-0.700743854,
-0.5826402307,
0.2772425711,
-0.4153037965,
-0.1220702454,
-0.4874832332,
0.1546782106,
-0.1652370691,
0.351177454,
-0.2785805166,
0.6584816575,
0.4402565956,
0.0980732813,
0.3043758869,
-0.770311594,
0.2309725136,
-0.9326012135,
0.0026411717,
-0.0243810304,
-0.2678058445,
-0.5219603181,
0.1093657464,
0.6864225268,
0.0571118109,
-0.3701846898,
0.4854041636,
-0.3646349609,
0.3324560523,
-0.030659873,
-0.3597069383,
0.0787213892,
0.3276517093,
0.0048919055,
0.2834104002,
0.4542047083,
-0.4099350572,
0.7109326124,
0.1946081966,
-0.2431858629,
0.6304914951,
-0.6673054695,
0.3120716512,
-0.1709325016,
0.7523502111,
-0.5534591675,
-0.2980736196,
0.2494439632,
-0.1873956174,
0.352211982,
-0.2969405949,
-0.6492270827,
-0.7124163508,
-0.0363097563,
1.3176531792,
0.5993701816,
-0.7454711199,
0.6978909969,
0.344311446,
-0.0896724761,
0.0702573285,
-0.7840448618,
0.0804102123,
-0.1973668933,
-0.1334798783,
0.8485553861,
-0.1473658532,
0.0892821401,
-0.2256202549,
-0.0945713446,
-0.2782070041,
-0.367548883,
0.4072214365,
0.0034000967,
-0.2513073087,
0.2446331829,
0.1570669711,
-0.3843954206,
-0.1029666588,
-0.2968646288,
0.3810731471,
0.4214918017,
-0.7780387998,
-0.8140828013,
0.5683372617,
0.9908723831,
-0.5256121159,
0.1925874799,
0.315508306,
-0.9264413714,
-0.2864669561,
-0.4734701812,
0.0244073253,
-0.36171785,
0.292321682,
-0.2256817073,
-0.3165774047,
0.5432015657,
-0.1259973198,
-0.1868445277,
0.2441601604,
0.5228968263,
0.1325278729,
1.4013257027,
0.6581323147,
-0.2014947087,
-0.2652321458,
-0.0261960812,
0.4074652195,
-0.9376347065,
-0.4258731902,
-0.6085437536,
-0.2610608339,
-0.3320992291,
-0.6887901425,
0.443482548,
-0.0714098364,
-0.2179388553,
-0.1121036932,
-0.8966927528,
0.3613163829,
0.151534155,
0.4099560976,
0.1951751411,
-0.1008920968,
-0.0508855134,
-0.2032805383,
-0.6755040288,
-0.4402368367,
1.210518837,
0.5254311562,
1.2518465519,
-0.0520732552,
0.7275428176,
0.2708957791,
0.6915158629,
-0.7648769617,
-0.2243579477,
-0.2390575409,
-0.0420699269,
0.3244374692,
0.0523311831,
-0.7919480205,
-0.420491457,
0.2573288679,
-0.6798611283,
0.2794878483,
0.1503462493,
-0.6845231056,
0.2892664671,
-0.5933122635,
0.8512421846,
-0.5812124014,
0.1833566725,
-0.082169801,
-0.5435145497,
-0.034624923,
-0.5026839375,
0.3529549241,
0.3134623766,
-0.089215219,
0.7872101665,
-0.6779415011,
0.7929885983,
0.1753533781,
-0.3049659431,
0.0159066394,
-0.0134304175,
0.582123816,
0.182357356,
0.1254067123,
-0.1826992333,
0.1733210385,
-0.3576469421,
-0.7464615703,
0.4809996784,
-0.7531029582,
-0.0030261073,
-0.3947986662,
-0.4362071157,
-0.1030916199,
0.1282277256,
0.3516345918,
1.0946102142,
-0.0499375127,
-0.1695009768,
0.465118289,
-0.4819399416,
0.0110402303,
-0.039577648,
-0.0287831891,
-0.6693479419,
0.9544795752,
-0.0361487754,
0.326806277,
0.6262043715,
-0.0557254478,
0.0548838675,
-0.5265850425,
-0.6435701847,
0.2567453384,
-0.8503226638,
-0.4570856392,
-0.6961871982,
-0.1945181191,
-0.3264930546,
-0.756008327,
-0.412759006,
0.1044992059,
-0.442457974,
-0.0207830276,
0.2023574263,
0.8197975755,
0.1690694839,
0.3045539558,
-0.9423175454,
0.7249653339,
0.2008465976,
0.6335292459,
-0.0152087333,
-0.2765233517,
-0.3631336689,
0.1591602862,
-0.1120041534,
-1.063061595,
0.4582562149,
-0.0058286912,
0.5354027152,
0.3382896185,
0.3877570629,
0.8390578032,
-0.7442100644,
0.6043854356,
0.4237564802,
-0.9071403742,
0.5854766965,
0.025885433,
0.6153379083,
0.2708191872,
0.4216428697,
-0.6078576446,
-0.3817800283,
-0.502530694,
-0.8165644407,
0.5074926615,
-0.0715733171,
0.2208048999,
-0.1528817564,
0.4308341146,
0.3491651118,
-0.2319034934,
-0.4275740981,
-0.2914155424,
-0.1451508105,
-0.9043316841,
-0.0725796148,
-0.152952075,
-0.2658797801,
-0.3945634961,
0.2900647223,
-0.3475246429,
0.7150725126,
0.4586304128,
-0.4309229553,
-0.1547678709,
0.0751379803,
0.3935488164,
0.7946330905,
0.0066068368,
0.3213098645,
0.0873675272,
-0.6658154726,
0.2966430187,
0.3151454031,
-0.0086284271,
0.0231992509,
0.3779315054,
0.5215896964,
0.0483407825,
-0.7772238255,
0.7594257593,
-0.1874426007,
-0.0903880373,
0.0200586766,
-0.2068220228,
-0.1537914276,
0.0626856089,
0.493065387,
0.1931201369,
-0.0234439913,
-0.1870692819,
0.6093344688,
-0.0728749633,
-0.6503115892,
-0.3558825552,
0.7900585532,
0.3870503306,
-0.5000202656,
0.5642424822,
0.019071864,
-0.6566633582,
1.059230566,
0.9667927623,
0.7330412269,
-0.2234708816,
0.236569643,
0.1688771099,
0.2180203646,
-0.1303959638,
-0.0216516294,
-0.0366765782,
-0.5082641244,
-0.5912649632,
-0.3869654536,
-0.2129529715,
-0.0232237484,
-1.1182895899,
0.3652439117,
-0.5012786984,
0.0749971494,
0.1075458676,
-0.4944089055,
-0.8104864359,
0.474232614,
0.4366895556,
0.9970372915,
-0.55222857,
0.6965751052,
0.7187235355,
0.0422050729,
-0.7363719344,
0.1622041166,
-0.1022371352,
-0.4816456437,
0.4071997106,
0.4262287021,
0.1525683999,
0.1541947126,
-0.171083048,
-0.796505034,
0.9146249294,
0.2319278419,
-0.651614964,
-0.0504097342,
0.1050135642,
0.6206625104,
-0.5675476193,
0.3115726411,
0.3670483232,
0.1352219135,
-0.025853293,
-1.4822636843,
0.2410422415,
-0.4586942196,
-0.3289714158,
0.1685425788,
-0.3214227557,
0.2240955532,
-0.4507867396,
-0.1550422758,
0.1365416348,
0.3041090965,
-0.0980888903,
0.2982178926,
0.2419729084,
0.4244172871,
0.6374647021,
-0.0000513909,
1.0948227644,
-0.5519736409,
0.2900180519,
0.8869782686,
-0.222374469,
0.3448340595,
0.2220589966,
-0.2257424593,
0.2550159395,
0.4973572493,
-0.1514424235,
0.7478928566,
0.2786871493,
-0.2100759,
-0.1708885282,
-0.0308396574,
-0.4353089929,
0.212272957,
0.3184177876,
-0.5643424392,
-0.2581956387,
0.5780719519,
-0.263744086,
-0.0828437582,
-0.3685120642,
0.6969448328,
-0.0212450866,
-0.7328550816,
0.5145407915,
0.2482067794,
0.4278874099,
-0.2443474531,
-0.207045421,
0.0428919047,
0.3820350468,
-0.1459143162,
-0.4065696299,
0.1061075553,
0.0513865016,
-0.0925399885,
-0.5029381514,
0.2004562765,
-0.3953767419,
-0.746386528,
-0.048767522,
0.02632346,
-0.1258094311,
0.2956876159,
-0.2440701872,
0.082843326,
0.0556364693,
0.2755092978,
0.1667176783,
0.5778118372,
-0.1640369892,
0.603538394,
0.2474505454,
0.1024384871,
-0.0371751115,
0.3259160519,
0.9016060829,
-0.5607190728,
-0.9571250081,
-0.5375301242,
0.5435512662,
0.264339447,
-0.3482642174,
0.1682282239,
0.7204669714,
0.6127049327,
-0.0101699391,
0.762175262,
0.22269319,
0.3345473111,
-0.3608364165,
0.6287927032,
-0.3539978266,
0.1584401727,
-0.2201149166,
-0.5406545997,
-0.9508593678,
0.5746676922,
-0.0269556437,
-0.1869778037,
0.7075454593,
0.5238096714,
-0.3183423579,
-0.0695775002,
-0.2553918958,
0.0866011456,
0.5479240417,
0.6066693068,
0.3749936223,
-0.3729060292,
0.3847266138,
-0.6059934497,
-0.3244016469,
-0.3231320381,
-0.6772720814,
-0.6394065022,
-0.4648779929,
-0.7606731653,
-0.2707501948,
0.1276142895,
0.9563831687,
0.6437424421,
-0.8170616627,
0.230529502,
0.2276742607,
-0.0257050712,
-0.3983994126,
-0.0674434155,
0.7692251205,
0.0378160141,
-0.6544317603,
-0.0842086822,
0.3341813385,
0.3452237248,
0.2227436155,
-0.2065985352,
0.4809879065,
-0.3380744755,
0.3269684613,
0.0655200034,
-0.6656276584,
-0.3613419831,
-0.0750498623,
-0.4512666762,
0.252956301,
0.8597565293,
-0.9668495655,
0.762339294,
0.1199361607,
0.845177114,
0.5496332645,
0.1802218556,
0.5763562322,
-0.3389691412,
-0.0931506157,
0.5628704429,
0.0121312905,
0.1577510238,
-0.3880131841,
0.0503031313,
-0.0605753362,
-0.4353438616,
-0.9713909626,
-0.0566451922,
-1.1788965464,
-0.0225877371,
1.1240445375,
0.0097554829,
-0.1839608103,
-0.3443076313,
-0.4262991846,
0.3012010455,
-0.050968539,
0.8893107176,
0.3170948923,
-0.1884994805,
-0.0104370536,
-0.2692603767,
0.3487102687,
0.0392738692,
-0.7301815748,
-0.1736995727,
0.4250732362,
0.168758899,
0.3329228461,
0.5830805898,
-0.2020425946,
0.5318065882,
-0.3220265508,
0.1807505488,
0.1444466412,
-0.2733349502,
-0.391590029,
0.1556694359,
-0.225540787,
-0.2286789715
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03171v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03171v1
|
Homograph Attacks on Maghreb Sentiment Analyzers
| 2024-02-05T16:39:15 | 2024-02-05T16:39:15 |
Fatima Zahra Qachfar, Rakesh M. Verma
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
We examine the impact of homograph attacks on the Sentiment Analysis (SA)
task of different Arabic dialects from the Maghreb North-African countries.
Homograph attacks result in a 65.3% decrease in transformer classification from
an F1-score of 0.95 to 0.33 when data is written in "Arabizi". The goal of this
study is to highlight LLMs weaknesses' and to prioritize ethical and
responsible Machine Learning.
|
[
-0.7248587012,
-0.4520950019,
0.1514777541,
0.221632719,
-0.1025723591,
0.0745168105,
0.2602110207,
-0.7242807746,
0.3877891898,
0.289616406,
-0.7380603552,
-0.5570973754,
-0.802872777,
0.2835988998,
-0.3395726383,
1.0641686916,
0.1807752401,
0.3918433785,
0.1291003972,
-0.1596897095,
0.0566050746,
-0.7709095478,
-0.4747013748,
-0.318143636,
0.4575402439,
0.3893251717,
1.1089913845,
0.0202711839,
0.7825738788,
0.2524278164,
-0.2749952674,
-0.2311328053,
-0.3878017962,
-0.0212257393,
0.1059694588,
-0.5442378521,
-0.4588903487,
0.1560458988,
0.4516900778,
0.6677308679,
0.2915299535,
0.3060191572,
-0.1449237764,
1.011508584,
-0.479609102,
0.0683323368,
-0.4019472301,
0.1509185433,
-0.3195827305,
0.1149683073,
-0.356919378,
-0.5361149311,
0.1242288202,
0.1978686601,
0.6080464125,
0.0449043326,
1.0036896467,
0.1303254664,
-0.4760162234,
-0.4788423777,
-0.4640273452,
0.914635241,
-0.5851902366,
0.4042881429,
0.3220097125,
0.2939029932,
-0.0753221288,
-0.378847748,
-0.3762394488,
0.1449705362,
-0.2585929036,
0.0050456454,
-0.1795338392,
-0.1044264212,
0.1401488781,
0.6216751933,
-0.0769347325,
-0.1471081078,
-0.4738297164,
-0.4466587007,
1.0498168468,
0.185793221,
0.1152284369,
-0.4536777735,
-0.3069709539,
-0.0075532622,
-0.7987129092,
0.2230133116,
0.6389846206,
0.3309319019,
0.1243541688,
0.5533021688,
0.103545703,
0.5701729059,
0.1343604028,
-0.3103218079,
0.4680419862,
-0.097013168,
-0.2343804836,
0.080391705,
0.7231130004,
0.64152354,
0.3351460695,
-0.1490489393,
-0.2784269154,
0.1643444002,
0.3341962993,
-0.8958774209,
0.0594385788,
-0.0096044391,
-0.3431908786,
-0.4726324975,
0.4855504334,
-0.9131376147,
-0.6913287044,
0.4351080656,
-0.0166797824,
-0.3178315759,
0.2489118725,
-0.3016824126,
-0.189873144,
0.8774473667,
0.2741880119,
-0.4876257181,
0.2452294081,
0.3665388525,
0.8803300261,
-0.0980918556,
-0.0028363143,
-0.1670013666,
-0.0687010661,
-0.2703945637,
0.6991248727,
-0.4247009158,
-1.0471653938,
0.043727912,
0.0860748291,
-0.1269361079,
-0.4572395086,
0.7682493925,
-0.6926548481,
0.0723281577,
-0.4965212941,
-0.3418086469,
-0.6013146043,
0.1325365901,
-0.8135285974,
1.0792913437,
0.4527967274,
-0.978974402,
0.2315731794,
-0.6018561721,
-0.9210377932,
-0.2200702131,
-0.1212412119,
-0.5903211236,
-0.0276007466,
0.2551780045,
0.5009975433,
-0.5286138058,
-0.1975280046,
-0.1002731174,
-0.6068791151,
0.4328166544,
-0.1955796778,
0.8647818565,
0.2576454282,
-0.7164780498,
0.1014129072,
-0.6069608927,
-0.0255147312,
0.1463200897,
-0.0811920464,
0.0871450081,
0.1335519999,
0.3489045203,
0.4612694979,
-0.0665635094,
-0.9205101132,
0.1244991273,
-0.7158839703,
0.2717135251,
0.8102844954,
0.2340990752,
0.2009894252,
-0.639231503,
0.7352443337,
0.0579735264,
0.2450827956,
0.4497075379,
-0.721931994,
-0.8315722942,
-0.282918781,
-0.0353093073,
0.7201541066,
-0.5530162454,
0.3945473731,
-0.2518173158,
-0.935305357,
-0.7089230418,
-0.0074237324,
0.2402118146,
0.4128907919,
0.2154087424,
-0.0267625246,
-0.3859370053,
-1.0708351135,
-0.5845490694,
-0.2004373968,
0.1240155697,
0.1392616034,
0.6226952672,
-0.8940674663,
0.9630767703,
-0.4761361182,
-0.8022413254,
-0.3206295669,
-0.0288844798,
0.3153953254,
0.0449944735,
0.9680736661,
-0.9640082717,
-0.7410436869,
-0.2559427619,
-0.4451793134,
-0.1875249594,
0.1360736787,
0.1183554903,
0.6257696152,
0.4954835474,
-0.1885035187,
0.8841634393,
0.5438151956,
-0.5713885427,
0.3053263426,
0.6099305153,
0.2903696299,
-0.8914492726,
-0.2609158754,
0.1039118171,
-0.2383801043,
-0.6770967245,
-0.126483202,
-0.2247920483,
0.0447005741,
-0.632363975,
0.2741796374,
-0.1598678827,
0.0041094804,
0.0249520782,
-0.315939039,
0.0151569443,
0.1694873273,
-0.2972813249,
1.068990469,
0.5235445499,
-0.0970377326,
0.1165711284,
0.3261393309,
-0.2557803988,
0.2173174471,
-0.6808011532,
0.3493113518,
-0.1180469543,
0.07325802,
-1.3773719072,
-0.3196580708,
0.3230188191,
-0.46098575,
0.1503685564,
0.18639943,
-0.2642486691,
-0.2521861494,
-0.940030396,
0.0681570768,
0.4626758993,
-0.4144511521,
0.9353781343,
0.3987977505,
0.1519403309,
-0.809648037,
-1.0867654085,
-0.1702815294,
-0.1226177365,
-0.7983988523,
0.1060906649,
0.1921664625,
-0.4458109438,
-0.0734303892,
-0.3241042495,
-0.0445377715,
0.1895505339,
0.8541214466,
0.2066364437,
0.049953144,
-0.2999014854,
-0.0230884515,
0.1183038652,
0.6040732265,
0.3674323261,
0.9061406255,
-0.7042226791,
-0.4907740951,
-0.752690196,
0.4629172981,
0.7775481939,
0.0351236463,
1.2327082157,
0.5079125166,
-0.0613366663,
0.2513260841,
-0.3403525352,
-0.0308467746,
-0.5900631547,
0.2646662891,
-0.4413554668,
-0.8951718211,
0.5681917667,
-0.1757781953,
-0.012969166,
1.0884944201,
0.5171800256,
-0.5078545213,
1.0054491758,
0.6006153822,
-0.6345617175,
0.2199201286,
-0.351834774,
0.3169945478,
-0.529850781,
-0.4583390951,
-0.5042256713,
-0.4696688056,
-0.8011268377,
-0.0737933815,
0.5841025114,
-0.0960320234,
-0.0943212435,
-0.128066048,
-0.2688837647,
0.4224727154,
0.3743076026,
0.1528522968,
-0.027222557,
0.1462888867,
0.1117793694,
-0.0618341863,
-0.6286190748,
-0.7091728449,
0.9669013023,
0.3505809307,
0.741096735,
0.240587458,
1.0074272156,
0.8051508069,
0.826033473,
-1.013318181,
0.5367795825,
0.1514830142,
-0.6620124578,
-0.3898682594,
-0.1642003804,
-0.6667516232,
-0.1000026688,
-0.1136106029,
-0.5027530193,
0.3590583205,
-0.1380783916,
0.1152350828,
0.3847499192,
-0.3228390515,
0.593832612,
0.0476102866,
0.07359761,
0.1787132025,
-0.908659637,
0.1768379807,
-0.2989880741,
0.7610504627,
-0.0982863829,
0.29060027,
0.9592048526,
-0.5717132688,
1.0195348263,
-0.363615185,
-0.1685198843,
0.4261240363,
0.1448660046,
0.2527769804,
-0.0482119024,
-0.6185024381,
0.6594917774,
-0.2035202682,
-0.4727374911,
-0.3143650889,
0.3253255188,
-1.1465966702,
-0.7857394218,
-0.8633956909,
-0.571257174,
-0.3082139492,
-0.181226179,
0.7186278701,
0.0986574441,
-0.3735420704,
-0.0782390237,
0.2594626546,
-0.0142635657,
0.4551419318,
0.007518563,
-0.3998768628,
-0.5064669847,
0.688595891,
0.0488160029,
0.3010950983,
-0.2432584018,
-0.025949046,
-0.0865478143,
-0.3690273464,
-0.3060051203,
0.4408374727,
-1.0989322662,
-0.4630235434,
-0.2518856525,
-0.3083717823,
-0.6333345175,
-0.5202111602,
-0.0194743965,
-0.3235579729,
-0.0883153304,
-0.0476321429,
0.434920609,
0.8739619851,
0.1980573088,
0.992650032,
-0.8585935235,
-0.016504297,
0.1613364816,
0.0329145603,
-0.4147294164,
-0.8055178523,
-0.1301525682,
-0.1048919931,
-0.2341014892,
-1.4080234766,
0.4712206125,
0.3915562928,
0.2163548768,
0.6644681692,
-0.004081517,
0.4471540153,
-0.437503159,
0.926820457,
0.0893140957,
-1.3279093504,
0.5886074901,
0.0370250084,
0.1107332483,
0.6221265793,
0.9461638927,
-0.4616507292,
-0.4602253437,
-0.5524460673,
-0.6651087999,
0.7169086933,
0.2692568898,
-0.0050167763,
-0.2097149044,
0.6957473159,
-0.0666765869,
0.0680080056,
-0.5979837775,
-0.9186384082,
-0.2748037577,
-0.1112173721,
-0.0577504933,
-0.6324561238,
-0.2385818809,
-0.7520323396,
0.8520617485,
0.0702859387,
0.421564579,
0.4182880819,
-0.2904442847,
-0.2151575238,
0.1889988482,
0.4077588022,
0.5248349905,
-0.1127263606,
0.0404140465,
0.3183476627,
-0.8027439713,
0.3916200101,
-0.1819201112,
-0.2921670377,
0.2039801627,
0.6122176647,
0.5722218752,
-0.3696466982,
-0.5408039689,
0.6622664928,
-0.0354828686,
-0.3280358315,
-0.3719934225,
0.0654250309,
-0.0441278853,
0.1185638234,
0.4628385901,
0.1892436743,
0.403826952,
-0.5854036808,
0.2744597495,
0.6223843694,
-0.7473449111,
-0.2283495516,
0.3244042993,
0.0559543483,
-0.46122545,
0.6860178113,
-0.1356042027,
-1.2154480219,
0.6451478601,
0.7606128454,
0.6913054585,
-0.814165771,
0.2843177319,
-0.122762531,
0.7775384784,
0.4428177476,
0.7911257744,
0.4107355773,
-0.8606153131,
-0.1519976407,
-0.7554722428,
-0.5593409538,
-0.3485929072,
-0.9750494361,
0.1463575065,
-0.6530867815,
-0.4316159189,
0.1154268533,
-0.0538043529,
-0.4810177684,
0.6331505179,
0.0700592846,
0.738392055,
-1.1066753864,
0.8201666474,
1.0659871101,
-0.1534959376,
-0.6141392589,
0.1300406754,
0.1166142523,
-0.7542340755,
0.9392319918,
0.3602325022,
-0.7007616162,
-0.1617742777,
-0.6558349729,
-0.8520513773,
0.8156964183,
0.2571978867,
-0.359739095,
0.27247262,
0.748924911,
0.4627753496,
-0.0818541944,
-0.0206340533,
0.7851411104,
0.6160337925,
-0.0611077473,
-0.6285825968,
-0.054270044,
-0.2697565258,
-0.3813320994,
0.5967947245,
-0.9169208407,
1.0419769287,
0.0229431689,
-0.2371345162,
-0.5507106185,
0.6619250774,
-0.3024342358,
0.3018200696,
0.7191432118,
0.3444240987,
0.7892760038,
-0.1327833384,
1.2447651625,
-0.3565120399,
0.3616440296,
0.4829595983,
-0.3090494871,
0.5624936223,
0.6204970479,
-0.3760223985,
0.8753179908,
0.5077296495,
-0.0939681083,
0.3764899373,
0.1124389544,
-0.3437783122,
0.0158887841,
-0.0132960286,
-0.3695565462,
0.7758806348,
0.4932000935,
-0.2896257043,
-0.0577825457,
0.1537944973,
0.3304277956,
-0.094853662,
-0.4260397851,
0.5122628212,
0.0115469228,
0.2007372975,
0.5729171038,
0.1829235256,
0.7348930836,
-0.3544126153,
0.3301151097,
-0.2557227015,
0.077857919,
-0.6284646392,
-0.6348258853,
0.8896998763,
0.0250926428,
-0.3719313741,
0.2297591269,
0.7639880776,
0.0562846959,
-0.7956895828,
0.44534868,
0.4459014237,
0.1404669732,
-0.1297194213,
-0.6490343809,
0.1712939441,
0.2622598112,
-0.5141020417,
0.271179229,
-0.036432147,
-0.1442121118,
0.616812706,
0.4915172756,
-0.1292207986,
0.0637411475,
-0.0402137153,
1.1397266388,
-0.9484582543,
-0.2435540706,
-1.1563397646,
-0.1502901167,
-0.212268889,
0.0275439713,
1.2653876543,
0.5009937882,
0.6798775792,
-0.0137519455,
0.7474597096,
-0.0772037804,
0.5019144416,
-0.1625761986,
1.0657331944,
-0.312248826,
0.2365717888,
-0.4520789087,
-1.0510803461,
-0.4940077066,
0.8083921671,
-0.4016934335,
-0.1012216285,
0.6536587477,
0.7160959244,
0.4844284356,
0.4232127666,
-0.0093738344,
0.1012300253,
0.3426987827,
0.1427064836,
0.8743501902,
-0.7111136317,
0.1222955287,
-0.5726081729,
-0.1327146441,
0.0725800619,
-0.7351045609,
-1.2883812189,
-0.1746136993,
-0.2988268435,
-0.5960554481,
-0.1616824865,
0.8310927749,
0.1108074337,
-1.1245503426,
-0.4207134545,
0.4233768284,
0.1548547149,
0.1383095831,
-0.3145414889,
0.7021636963,
-0.2776233554,
-0.5482227206,
0.3138042986,
-0.0766275227,
-0.0178680327,
-0.0703291073,
0.0443656296,
-0.3463654518,
0.2801583111,
0.6609046459,
-0.1930719614,
-0.5367320776,
-0.4753322899,
0.1767145544,
-0.2041944265,
0.2872459292,
0.6117781997,
-0.7072532177,
-0.0871742517,
0.1793608218,
0.5371512771,
0.136912331,
0.0281961672,
0.1935729682,
-0.8436636925,
0.4020516872,
0.4262648821,
0.3484865427,
0.2227833569,
-0.6578714252,
0.6574332714,
0.4148517847,
-0.5370095372,
-0.7617638111,
0.1148815677,
-0.7822175622,
-0.242125079,
1.1443476677,
-0.0905057788,
-0.4575207233,
-0.1357779801,
-0.4175358415,
0.1533620805,
-0.2837523222,
0.6875228882,
0.7297097445,
-0.3494095802,
0.3909935951,
-0.1887454689,
0.6457343698,
0.509431839,
-0.7412480712,
-0.4318090677,
0.5324698687,
0.2139124572,
0.2981321514,
0.2850154936,
-0.0848359093,
0.0911084861,
-0.2166543901,
0.033528354,
0.194265008,
-0.4082366824,
-0.5358120799,
0.4972688854,
0.0033262526,
-0.0838778242
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03163v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03163v1
|
Linguistic features for sentence difficulty prediction in ABSA
| 2024-02-05T16:31:03 | 2024-02-05T16:31:03 |
Adrian-Gabriel Chifu, Sébastien Fournier
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
One of the challenges of natural language understanding is to deal with the
subjectivity of sentences, which may express opinions and emotions that add
layers of complexity and nuance. Sentiment analysis is a field that aims to
extract and analyze these subjective elements from text, and it can be applied
at different levels of granularity, such as document, paragraph, sentence, or
aspect. Aspect-based sentiment analysis is a well-studied topic with many
available data sets and models. However, there is no clear definition of what
makes a sentence difficult for aspect-based sentiment analysis. In this paper,
we explore this question by conducting an experiment with three data sets:
"Laptops", "Restaurants", and "MTSC" (Multi-Target-dependent Sentiment
Classification), and a merged version of these three datasets. We study the
impact of domain diversity and syntactic diversity on difficulty. We use a
combination of classifiers to identify the most difficult sentences and analyze
their characteristics. We employ two ways of defining sentence difficulty. The
first one is binary and labels a sentence as difficult if the classifiers fail
to correctly predict the sentiment polarity. The second one is a six-level
scale based on how many of the top five best-performing classifiers can
correctly predict the sentiment polarity. We also define 9 linguistic features
that, combined, aim at estimating the difficulty at sentence level.
|
[
-0.4884751439,
-1.00647223,
0.6288662553,
0.4967958629,
-0.3471499979,
0.1222722158,
-0.2495671362,
-0.4003690779,
0.0908215791,
0.3782568872,
-0.6169909835,
-0.6324976683,
-0.8187067509,
0.6353899837,
0.0688280612,
1.3717241287,
-0.0976246223,
0.0932342336,
-0.2785999775,
-0.4618307352,
-0.9382582307,
-0.7760061026,
-0.0481338575,
-0.1325570643,
0.3935819864,
0.511918962,
0.8357223272,
-0.0373758078,
0.8356787562,
0.3607000113,
-0.3691571057,
-0.1173561811,
0.0724951699,
0.2668122649,
-0.2594240606,
-0.7368779182,
-0.1005723551,
-0.1645153165,
0.0335308127,
1.0469651222,
0.1080412641,
-0.3689265549,
0.124532342,
0.95170784,
-0.2317420989,
0.3636315167,
-0.5569366217,
0.1206488907,
-0.4689627886,
0.2199564129,
-0.0314675681,
-0.3955866694,
0.2267038971,
-0.1323989779,
0.3440745473,
0.191303134,
0.8175987005,
0.2270268798,
-0.6798123717,
-0.563562572,
-0.6248679161,
0.8573707342,
-0.4952611327,
0.0724059194,
0.3543414772,
0.0209618714,
-0.0082142251,
-0.05259059,
-0.6063296199,
-0.1794372201,
-0.1838925928,
0.0013300322,
-0.3105000556,
0.1023031175,
0.0283896998,
0.5295635462,
-0.4621572793,
-0.0395952687,
-0.4409007728,
0.1310816407,
0.5640236735,
0.2874423563,
0.2695860267,
-0.9006218314,
-0.0754765421,
-0.0339646265,
-0.3676004708,
0.4330051541,
0.4841297269,
0.5499649644,
-0.0682400092,
0.7557075024,
-0.3231216669,
0.5785503387,
-0.204791531,
-0.018278962,
0.6546509266,
-0.3132124841,
-0.0515333191,
-0.1267395616,
0.8647844791,
0.1803362072,
0.061759986,
0.1848634183,
-0.3417710662,
0.2136399597,
0.4003113508,
-0.3480778337,
-0.0983686224,
0.4254944324,
-0.4539214671,
-0.3911523521,
0.1781682074,
-0.9208210707,
-0.4853957295,
-0.1190640479,
0.1304639429,
-0.7450022697,
-0.0057950784,
-0.1742638052,
0.0294885598,
0.0993905962,
0.1434094757,
-0.6166301966,
0.2998978496,
0.8452461958,
0.913549304,
-0.2210404873,
-0.2835202217,
-0.1172701716,
-0.5532601476,
-0.0086331321,
0.849347949,
-0.6563005447,
-0.469799459,
-0.1137967408,
-0.224193424,
-0.1769024879,
-0.4035898447,
0.9728670716,
-0.060445454,
0.3447273076,
-0.2323979139,
-0.4498844147,
-0.5348937511,
0.1702908128,
-0.6494497061,
0.7900640368,
0.5971830487,
-0.9175440073,
0.3032607734,
-0.6309127212,
-1.0456693172,
0.0782013461,
-0.0889590159,
-0.5220476389,
0.5855509043,
0.1543240696,
0.5434588194,
-0.1030396521,
0.2526844442,
-0.2171811014,
0.0807855353,
0.6964406371,
-0.1289825886,
0.4872767329,
0.0868949741,
-0.4458060265,
0.0418489166,
-0.5227003694,
-0.2238514572,
-0.0662707016,
-0.2494092882,
-0.6194197536,
0.0854940563,
0.10969273,
0.1411895156,
0.0094756885,
-0.4497077465,
0.2162723541,
-0.7520623207,
0.3411949277,
0.6025038362,
0.2115244865,
0.2608536184,
-0.1111534461,
0.8031958342,
0.3574701548,
0.1738852859,
0.0930529386,
-0.8261608481,
-0.5726055503,
0.032744877,
0.1854536086,
0.8237303495,
-0.7990232706,
0.6045997739,
-0.0695114806,
-0.4573695064,
-0.7212004662,
0.4127453864,
0.4967059791,
0.1803791523,
0.3484487534,
-0.3882821202,
-0.3190537393,
-0.9231204987,
-0.2537124455,
-0.1270435303,
0.2759565711,
0.3861598074,
0.526325345,
-0.0486766025,
0.8284047842,
-0.6580768228,
-0.7449356318,
-0.8685650229,
0.4818885922,
0.3681275547,
0.2227680683,
0.4392632544,
-1.0126405954,
-0.3901817203,
-0.0423424616,
-0.5907626748,
-0.1242533475,
0.1100281477,
0.3042921126,
0.5561267734,
0.1012552157,
-0.654676497,
0.3525876403,
0.5729327798,
-0.4587150216,
0.4044468105,
0.0130550768,
0.2069586217,
-1.0661435127,
-0.3563322425,
0.3288915455,
0.3088340759,
-0.6500885487,
-0.0495440364,
-0.1977034211,
-0.1383591443,
-0.3817839622,
-0.1552458405,
-0.2620919347,
0.0809915438,
-0.2978173792,
-0.1464325637,
0.2065522373,
0.607355535,
-0.0362232588,
0.5006091595,
0.523245573,
-0.3764533997,
0.3243051469,
0.1344854236,
-0.3892678618,
0.6743215322,
-0.5781844854,
-0.0823475048,
-0.2353592217,
-0.1430559903,
-1.0402882099,
-0.2375765294,
0.1273942888,
-0.3439638317,
0.0604785345,
0.1873330921,
-0.1006094813,
-0.3015233576,
-0.338398844,
0.4051924944,
0.1333995312,
0.1998152435,
0.7752305269,
0.2681872845,
-0.5813410282,
-0.5157984495,
-0.698349297,
0.1107079685,
-0.3587327302,
-0.5018227696,
0.2662846744,
0.0175516699,
-0.6403035522,
0.0664677918,
0.1885211766,
-0.1735655367,
0.2784967124,
0.7178441286,
0.2242073864,
-0.0834439918,
0.1895194501,
0.2317617834,
0.1313131452,
0.1028148308,
0.3384036422,
0.5839438438,
-0.6340468526,
-0.0406781398,
-0.3920062184,
0.4796542525,
0.4378146529,
-0.2067762017,
0.6960039139,
0.2355957031,
-0.2789466977,
-0.1642282009,
-0.278719157,
0.1609992683,
-0.4014564455,
0.432824105,
-0.5032603741,
-0.7061988115,
0.483081907,
0.3559263647,
-0.2065456957,
0.552397728,
0.2452807873,
-0.1310156286,
0.6574667692,
0.6066194773,
-0.1425662935,
0.2256406397,
-0.0197584853,
0.3692038059,
-0.5138411522,
-0.4451513588,
-0.8032328486,
-0.3802388608,
-0.7108185887,
-0.1993408948,
0.3158106208,
-0.0685426891,
0.2788747847,
0.2560426891,
-0.2719782293,
0.2135231495,
0.4859443009,
0.1353105605,
0.0993002504,
-0.0718886629,
0.0272828247,
-0.3497387171,
-0.2939957678,
-0.3029046655,
0.817984283,
0.2547317743,
0.6194174886,
0.3504871726,
0.7290820479,
0.3932405114,
0.129870519,
-1.2331887484,
0.4820736945,
-0.6708705425,
-0.328850925,
-0.2466006279,
-0.7293871045,
-0.9901637435,
0.0030071742,
-0.4148326218,
-0.5109772086,
0.2751287818,
-0.2767443955,
-0.3039142489,
0.0174456928,
-0.7633024454,
0.8539208174,
-0.3845438361,
-0.0274163987,
0.045022238,
-0.7046385407,
0.308768332,
-0.048289597,
0.7651336789,
-0.1039773598,
0.185395062,
0.7046672106,
-0.2946473062,
0.8865181208,
-0.0622741133,
0.1702515036,
0.2414117008,
0.3319031894,
0.0493442863,
-0.116009891,
-0.1558913738,
0.2846907675,
-0.3103714287,
-0.1182111651,
-0.5991969109,
0.6330887079,
-0.8774128556,
-0.5199760199,
-0.5548554063,
-0.5055710673,
-0.4085953832,
0.0108643239,
0.2792872787,
0.3916885257,
-0.2379721701,
0.3086657822,
0.3330745101,
-0.3093732893,
0.457215488,
0.2331866324,
0.0197530184,
-0.484177053,
1.0655611753,
0.195489645,
-0.0127091836,
0.4136025906,
0.4180490673,
-0.1649286449,
-0.8139210343,
-0.1384043545,
0.0323501825,
-0.5802379847,
-0.4259527028,
-0.7737979293,
-0.0874304548,
-0.4043035507,
-0.1620584726,
-0.217736274,
-0.5247207284,
-0.4131503403,
-0.2807037532,
0.3710441589,
0.9020576477,
0.2954671383,
0.4846250713,
-0.8272837996,
0.3075446784,
-0.0267538261,
0.1946292818,
-0.4540551007,
-0.4314602911,
0.0439249314,
-0.3323187232,
-0.4719208181,
-1.0679866076,
0.7035861015,
0.3178652525,
0.2072207332,
0.2646585405,
0.2209560722,
0.1228720918,
-0.1201971248,
0.9549900889,
0.2290478349,
-1.2746984959,
0.9401388764,
0.0308476985,
0.148569122,
0.8843711615,
0.3984217346,
-0.3037578464,
-0.8679054976,
-0.5999379754,
-1.187638998,
0.6531298757,
0.3678416312,
0.2805051208,
-0.0624474548,
0.5172177553,
0.4756675959,
0.3549230397,
-1.0135149956,
-0.2473335415,
-0.4960345328,
-0.6728605628,
-0.1647184491,
-0.2322670668,
0.0994617417,
-0.0968632177,
0.4238894284,
0.0601311624,
-0.0665017068,
0.0915204063,
-0.1144808605,
-0.1016914025,
0.7711620331,
0.2544058263,
0.5277845263,
-0.4298258126,
0.0616337955,
0.0274273288,
-0.399396956,
0.0222802423,
0.2350972444,
-0.1841318756,
0.1283358485,
0.6108401418,
0.9540614486,
0.0355440788,
-0.6183921695,
0.6477707624,
-0.0727478787,
-0.1676599532,
-0.2046772242,
0.1464200616,
-0.3984419405,
0.0855745971,
0.4301561415,
0.1423602253,
0.4606011808,
-0.9048998356,
0.0230591092,
0.265863657,
-0.5943911672,
-0.3190640211,
0.1070887521,
0.3602254987,
-0.3519585729,
0.6291841865,
-0.4147836268,
-0.8749908209,
0.6588406563,
0.123798959,
0.959726274,
-0.2263002843,
0.4289893806,
-0.0105193499,
0.4566278458,
0.0979179144,
0.4509988725,
0.4827002287,
-0.7655076981,
-0.2305260152,
-0.9176844954,
-0.5807582736,
-0.1020273417,
-0.7473099828,
0.1242083162,
-0.5070969462,
-0.2545744479,
0.1781433672,
0.1761077195,
-0.6273081303,
0.4939083457,
-0.0458972044,
0.3731868565,
-1.1572800875,
0.4347082376,
1.0097715855,
-0.5315335989,
-0.6761748791,
0.1739011854,
-0.0814445913,
-0.2954040468,
0.5576789379,
0.5959452987,
0.1115493551,
-0.6720554233,
-0.2443879992,
-0.2480653077,
0.6067926884,
-0.0240194928,
-0.3994913697,
0.2236235142,
0.3444635868,
0.8627468944,
-0.6047317982,
0.0201716591,
0.5298361778,
0.3669278026,
-0.1754119396,
-0.8537243009,
0.1096887439,
-0.1986499578,
-0.0152813727,
0.2073296756,
-0.4707885385,
1.1668456793,
-0.1665770561,
-0.0403973497,
-0.2494340688,
0.906203568,
-0.1207888499,
0.6673437357,
0.7961530685,
0.3971741199,
0.6756327152,
-0.3052263558,
1.0411463976,
-0.1398919821,
0.3238498867,
0.8865904212,
-0.3593423367,
0.9671524763,
0.3770462871,
-0.2964557707,
1.1058759689,
0.4785276651,
0.0928638056,
0.5161464214,
0.2877794504,
-0.1140140593,
0.0341662057,
-0.1756697446,
-0.174143061,
0.8533854485,
0.505254209,
-0.2774058282,
0.1032731757,
0.4755934477,
-0.1003326848,
0.2738093138,
-0.3025332093,
0.8351888061,
0.0754801109,
-0.711340785,
-0.0587121285,
0.3690387607,
0.6868991256,
-0.4866864681,
0.124212727,
-0.4828445315,
-0.0729794726,
-0.2942924201,
-1.3187066317,
0.657641232,
0.0368292928,
-0.1914078295,
0.1614474356,
0.6417486072,
-0.1257954091,
-0.7191814184,
0.3470089734,
0.717713356,
0.0932171941,
-0.4356711507,
-0.7423485518,
0.1931040436,
0.1310575902,
-0.3549069166,
0.2503076494,
0.8365953565,
0.0995839387,
0.568315506,
0.1863041371,
-0.0809697062,
-0.3726732433,
0.1963446289,
0.8638719916,
-1.0815615654,
-0.5259242058,
-0.8660836816,
0.3359485269,
0.1094023958,
-0.603048563,
0.4184674323,
0.3618042767,
0.3491197228,
0.0249797385,
0.9323455691,
-0.4042972922,
0.4758496583,
-0.5489231944,
0.2071736306,
-0.4891138077,
0.5338579416,
-0.3603658974,
-0.8930280805,
-0.3150642216,
0.5242498517,
-0.4173168838,
0.0770819858,
0.9304438829,
0.6229521036,
0.0862243474,
0.1660666019,
0.0035931186,
0.3011335433,
0.0684756339,
0.6708210707,
0.7458084822,
-0.0905068591,
0.7442523241,
-0.8191414475,
-0.3169925809,
-0.1680895686,
-0.5946204066,
-0.9210752845,
-0.6102231145,
-0.3718091547,
-0.5527864695,
-0.0836440474,
0.827408433,
0.0584307611,
-1.0453950167,
-0.1519068182,
-0.1770888418,
0.4650861323,
-0.3626041412,
-0.3909885287,
0.4161318243,
-0.4553073645,
-0.7123543024,
0.2290052325,
0.2258481234,
-0.0249797404,
-0.2207498699,
0.2583512366,
-0.0102778794,
0.0971117914,
0.6047207713,
-0.0858550444,
-0.5698820353,
-0.4373879433,
-0.1110488027,
-0.0920684338,
0.1434717327,
0.8694141507,
-0.4123180807,
0.2800803185,
0.3209855556,
0.2921016514,
-0.0784752369,
0.3005629778,
0.4982146323,
-0.9842458367,
-0.106025368,
0.2949040234,
0.4538742006,
0.6605188251,
-0.470133394,
0.3302304149,
0.4267840683,
-0.2490431964,
-0.5361056328,
0.2449487448,
-1.4087446928,
-0.6343568563,
1.2024393082,
-0.2723723054,
-0.2737510204,
-0.4976116121,
-0.2562212348,
-0.0527467802,
-0.5547932982,
1.0551136732,
0.9426213503,
-0.4921854138,
-0.1880647242,
-0.3771373034,
0.4187319577,
0.662394166,
-0.8719376326,
-0.0339333825,
0.6212731004,
0.11422465,
0.3683944643,
0.1320800781,
0.2117117196,
0.0199985858,
-0.1954056025,
-0.0325069167,
0.0652606711,
-0.3023064435,
-0.543143332,
0.8216964602,
0.1510214061,
0.1360761672
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03161v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03161v3
|
Video-LaVIT: Unified Video-Language Pre-training with Decoupled Visual-Motional Tokenization
| 2024-02-05T16:30:49 | 2024-06-03T08:09:09 |
Yang Jin, Zhicheng Sun, Kun Xu, Kun Xu, Liwei Chen, Hao Jiang, Quzhe Huang, Chengru Song, Yuliang Liu, Di Zhang, Yang Song, Kun Gai, Yadong Mu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
In light of recent advances in multimodal Large Language Models (LLMs), there
is increasing attention to scaling them from image-text data to more
informative real-world videos. Compared to static images, video poses unique
challenges for effective large-scale pre-training due to the modeling of its
spatiotemporal dynamics. In this paper, we address such limitations in
video-language pre-training with an efficient video decomposition that
represents each video as keyframes and temporal motions. These are then adapted
to an LLM using well-designed tokenizers that discretize visual and temporal
information as a few tokens, thus enabling unified generative pre-training of
videos, images, and text. At inference, the generated tokens from the LLM are
carefully recovered to the original continuous pixel space to create various
video content. Our proposed framework is both capable of comprehending and
generating image and video content, as demonstrated by its competitive
performance across 13 multimodal benchmarks in image and video understanding
and generation. Our code and models are available at
https://video-lavit.github.io.
|
[
-0.2052620351,
-0.6774502397,
0.3502339423,
0.1623026729,
-0.8488378525,
0.1123018116,
-0.4397637844,
0.2284037918,
0.2825743556,
0.2779215872,
-0.4714144468,
-0.4029663503,
-0.6161137223,
-0.4334259033,
-0.60523206,
0.8685456514,
-0.1908836663,
0.1515074223,
-0.0325401537,
-0.1548710614,
-0.1762500852,
-0.5694804788,
-0.3621276915,
0.044055827,
0.2517622411,
0.0175813455,
0.44747141,
0.5889002085,
0.5042558908,
0.3842035532,
0.1111155003,
0.0948024318,
-0.4950902462,
0.0552626364,
0.157922253,
-0.026283009,
-0.3817850053,
-0.3586829305,
0.948867619,
0.4917961061,
-0.1319202483,
0.4311316907,
-0.0812460333,
0.3850917518,
-0.7071169615,
0.1604173779,
-0.581471622,
0.148564592,
-0.3658441305,
-0.3822573125,
-0.1175741926,
-0.0674824268,
-0.0949000493,
-0.7310259938,
0.366358906,
-0.4225570261,
0.7607498765,
0.5293526053,
-0.2726806104,
0.2521920502,
-0.7851917148,
0.3403775692,
-0.2029243708,
0.6423946619,
0.0179275721,
0.3884749413,
0.158633858,
-1.0849096775,
-0.6735761166,
0.2441871166,
0.2663348317,
0.0345665812,
-0.0333440602,
0.2222130001,
0.0875384435,
0.2948660553,
-0.6989842653,
0.0904483646,
-0.2321788073,
-0.0522319488,
0.2324280143,
0.1977594942,
0.4944002032,
-0.0184550714,
-0.3929036558,
-0.3033210337,
-0.6239414811,
0.0696326196,
0.0866405293,
0.0720642656,
-0.3548031449,
0.5043650866,
0.1698457897,
0.4918391109,
-0.0314124078,
-0.3288765848,
0.2512831092,
-0.4529461563,
-0.5179896951,
-0.0955174789,
0.9342051148,
0.4302880168,
0.2052714974,
-0.1005660295,
0.0569480434,
0.2884951234,
0.1197833568,
-1.1649848223,
-0.1889351606,
-0.1286288351,
-0.3088423014,
0.080648236,
0.2847026885,
-0.8174244761,
-0.113886781,
-0.2937844098,
0.5198631287,
-0.0770193264,
-0.3522390425,
0.1836818606,
0.2379921973,
0.209556222,
0.4088056684,
-0.9728404284,
-0.0865823776,
0.3690602779,
0.731097579,
-0.301627636,
-0.3974568248,
-0.9855876565,
0.3794515729,
-0.2673906982,
0.4947870076,
-0.3382734656,
-0.1885787398,
0.4667239189,
0.0450622477,
0.0108154668,
-0.205074206,
0.0807083324,
-0.6100775003,
-0.0002388416,
-0.1023066342,
-0.1871954501,
0.1787337065,
0.3044933975,
-0.6281775832,
0.7142252922,
-0.2552927732,
-0.764549613,
0.6128676534,
-0.7835607529,
-0.3939588368,
0.1039797738,
-0.346534133,
-0.4208542109,
0.0847251564,
0.4213127196,
0.6000614762,
0.0162859056,
0.5932526588,
-0.1700639278,
-0.3218148649,
0.1346657723,
-0.8774061203,
0.1132734418,
0.2459702492,
-0.180639267,
0.1924136281,
-0.8802636266,
-0.0936976448,
-0.0498982146,
-0.3553099632,
0.2875860631,
-0.0474465974,
0.1237751916,
0.020973336,
0.0535685867,
-0.2006690353,
0.050282944,
-0.1449276954,
0.4486116767,
0.8598794341,
-0.1850984097,
0.641726017,
0.4591917098,
0.6797941923,
0.070660986,
0.0841355249,
-0.8307454586,
0.1122814864,
-0.7972207069,
-0.4425342977,
-0.06990771,
0.1559821516,
-1.0544393063,
0.0650773942,
-0.8944193721,
-0.0420151092,
-0.2150190175,
0.236561954,
0.3296934962,
0.2290390581,
0.337058574,
-0.4442223012,
-0.511297524,
-0.257152468,
0.019582903,
-0.1255654693,
-0.1163783222,
-0.1450518817,
0.4046292901,
-0.2380629033,
0.7821667194,
-0.560588181,
-0.1874008775,
-0.0990277231,
0.293413341,
-0.0770348832,
0.2041860819,
0.5585135818,
-0.8844726682,
-0.3189546764,
0.091615513,
-0.7338114381,
0.2156351358,
-0.1343143731,
0.1303592473,
-0.0825946555,
0.8811136484,
-0.6025374532,
0.6121442318,
0.5948540568,
-0.1410786062,
0.2840676606,
-0.4131515026,
0.223459214,
-1.1746280193,
0.0862084329,
-0.359647274,
-0.3053901792,
-0.5146842599,
0.0852994695,
-0.3443196118,
-0.4509173632,
-0.9031443596,
0.4864200652,
-0.4643757641,
-0.2542513907,
-0.1023445874,
0.1375532001,
-0.2188457102,
0.5393193364,
0.3551982343,
0.8131096363,
0.7140094042,
-0.6411278844,
0.405079186,
0.0809095874,
-0.5084500313,
0.3625704348,
-0.4283080697,
-0.104322426,
-0.3682838678,
0.1978411376,
-0.7575063109,
-0.6539338827,
-0.0840050057,
-0.2181200087,
0.1988313943,
-0.2754739225,
-0.4215583801,
-0.2006099969,
-0.2447538823,
0.8376823068,
0.4389207363,
-0.7681985497,
0.7765779495,
0.3543548882,
-0.1267587394,
-0.7878472805,
-0.6499060392,
0.0337555669,
-0.2873066664,
-0.3988924623,
0.3576947451,
-0.2666680217,
-0.0089692604,
-0.0385183655,
-0.1899308413,
-0.2480497062,
-0.2751943469,
0.4153505266,
-0.0769358277,
-0.165679723,
0.2092455328,
-0.1831693798,
-0.0769374892,
-0.1067994311,
-0.1421557516,
0.7468891144,
-0.213063702,
-0.4891919494,
-0.4078567624,
0.2593628466,
0.7696678042,
-0.4035518765,
0.4302075505,
1.2766027451,
-0.0598482825,
0.1632409394,
-0.3775098622,
0.0986881033,
-0.4872358143,
0.7689080834,
-0.1351851672,
-1.02199018,
0.2675824761,
-0.167555809,
-0.071105212,
-0.112638019,
0.8053486943,
-0.1652433723,
0.63727808,
0.657248497,
0.1432839483,
1.0281152725,
-0.4684134126,
0.154698357,
-0.2771669924,
-0.2714378536,
-0.0384807065,
-0.0311765522,
-0.3380956948,
-0.7100594044,
0.3928214908,
0.1792060733,
-0.4309086204,
0.1214711741,
-0.0122885723,
0.7874063849,
0.0872549862,
-0.0954344198,
-0.0100735361,
0.3724927008,
-0.1024723724,
-0.0741772205,
-0.5515000224,
-0.2129096538,
0.9094605446,
0.1509989053,
0.7824557424,
0.2463742644,
0.6075363159,
0.1625707448,
0.1850296557,
-0.599139154,
0.813357234,
-0.4305093288,
-0.1962079704,
-0.1056550443,
-0.2404398918,
-0.9290405512,
0.3347790837,
-0.3833378851,
-0.5509927869,
-0.3362976611,
0.4335193336,
-0.4230504632,
0.5536007881,
-0.5228378177,
0.9979951978,
-0.5118907094,
-0.5747424364,
-0.1530303657,
-0.6443630457,
0.1568288803,
-0.0800540745,
0.518253088,
0.1964655071,
0.0649289787,
0.5193878412,
-0.5737931132,
0.9024905562,
-0.2620378733,
-0.0435664132,
0.4491611719,
0.062431559,
0.1941118836,
0.2898818552,
0.8143164515,
-0.0173168853,
-0.0829301029,
-0.1964181513,
-0.6281388402,
0.2886935174,
-0.6478892565,
-0.3447999954,
-0.1136207432,
-0.1437076926,
0.1004415601,
0.2305310965,
0.283449769,
0.5968091488,
-0.5083763599,
0.4498280883,
0.5468876958,
-0.1669558287,
0.8950570822,
0.2419008166,
-0.6439093351,
-0.7683967352,
0.9537953734,
-0.3981496692,
0.126661852,
0.6858639121,
-0.2885157764,
-0.2583647668,
-0.5152108073,
-0.269221276,
-0.0626936778,
-0.8591108918,
-0.095539391,
-0.3524338603,
0.0229059849,
-0.2993376851,
-0.3070188761,
-0.587518692,
-0.1258107424,
-0.4950709343,
-0.3439946175,
-0.1057803258,
0.3387065232,
-0.0784801692,
0.8117371798,
-0.9951525331,
0.6576080322,
0.7191990614,
0.2441084981,
-0.3660702705,
-0.4332057536,
-0.4073347151,
-0.2355400771,
-0.2057560086,
-0.3652992249,
0.4277253747,
0.4221060276,
0.2847001553,
0.8803159595,
-0.564267695,
1.1656836271,
-0.6627842188,
1.2336707115,
0.8335260153,
-0.9181194305,
0.2920749485,
-0.3802904487,
0.3492713571,
0.247554481,
0.1890731454,
-0.3172181249,
0.2451396585,
-0.403835088,
-1.0004127026,
0.3154491484,
0.1470865011,
0.411831677,
-0.0430597439,
0.1812103689,
-0.0772618279,
0.1757301241,
-1.0884246826,
0.0593797751,
-0.6873394847,
-0.0922881216,
-0.3392241299,
-0.1770796627,
-0.0269498415,
-0.3770063519,
0.0818222761,
-0.4033838511,
0.145722419,
-0.203199923,
-0.6961601973,
0.1152121425,
0.2919091284,
0.7699588537,
0.4570066035,
-0.0337247513,
0.3069048226,
0.0601484105,
-0.6919009686,
0.5042795539,
-0.1720911264,
-0.0058090864,
-0.0111295031,
0.6456146836,
1.12753582,
0.4653549492,
-0.8079352975,
0.8208220005,
-0.1718155444,
-0.1666451544,
-0.398509115,
-0.2478990406,
-0.2839483619,
0.284877032,
0.2413521558,
0.1579528898,
-0.3717909753,
-0.5003459454,
0.1613838375,
0.4536908567,
-0.1569614261,
-0.9750095606,
0.9263182282,
0.3397303522,
-0.2347284108,
0.3178091049,
-0.2025106102,
-0.4808524549,
0.1062349156,
0.3191331327,
0.9773836732,
0.0565340891,
0.4432914555,
0.3757579625,
0.0002595432,
-0.2144726962,
0.1948147118,
-0.4275114536,
-0.751670599,
-0.8022209406,
-0.7060828209,
0.164295435,
0.2426068187,
-0.5714024901,
0.2247746438,
-0.3334985673,
-0.3902946711,
-0.3436893821,
-0.5476914644,
-0.9036116004,
0.1638176292,
0.3483059704,
0.2629284263,
-0.7360011935,
0.8695836067,
0.7780941725,
-0.4533195496,
-0.5195482373,
0.0098570427,
-0.2793146968,
-0.6605619788,
1.0585354567,
0.1223819181,
-0.2651928663,
-0.1987966746,
-0.4408243597,
-0.6775580049,
1.0785163641,
0.8235788345,
-0.4932363629,
-0.3338239789,
0.4582118392,
0.3874506354,
-0.2364178598,
0.0742137879,
0.2212976962,
0.2008997053,
0.2713618875,
-0.8008462787,
-0.6086136699,
-0.0930556208,
0.05140201,
0.2558688819,
-0.5400924683,
0.8472325206,
-0.2393027544,
-0.2987281382,
0.0048424164,
0.7540256977,
-0.2034264058,
0.1549414843,
0.4474901855,
0.7034564018,
0.3747963607,
-0.1021410525,
0.5476917624,
-0.1814170033,
0.1937920898,
1.2163923979,
0.115161486,
0.8388348818,
0.7488335967,
-0.1090334952,
0.3239859045,
0.3344748616,
0.2637576759,
0.6529150605,
-0.0728722513,
-0.4250338674,
-0.5877364874,
-0.0026625167,
-0.3145864308,
0.8899957538,
0.2576081753,
-0.2551802695,
-0.3826532066,
0.1979493052,
-0.1148669198,
0.058997903,
-0.6277928948,
0.6564267874,
-0.1402596533,
-0.4454892576,
0.4526939392,
-0.3296709955,
0.5343472362,
-0.7684469819,
0.1071062163,
-0.2351372838,
0.2551759481,
0.0066029881,
-0.5413053632,
0.0373015925,
0.3185809851,
0.0526752137,
-0.4440467358,
0.3300658762,
-0.6663642526,
-0.2396022081,
0.1064065248,
0.3409371078,
0.1513835192,
-0.0303800441,
-0.315622896,
0.4840603471,
-0.0854784325,
-0.2045532465,
0.4179365635,
0.3764924705,
-0.0744995922,
0.5115677714,
0.5297980309,
-0.0550341606,
0.1680647582,
0.339897126,
0.9119465351,
-0.4679187536,
-0.4359734654,
-1.0008698702,
0.7367520332,
0.2427873015,
0.0793274716,
0.4187385142,
0.4543161392,
0.866042912,
-0.2566053271,
0.4831196368,
0.1502964646,
-0.3481853604,
-0.9752607942,
0.4983015954,
-0.6382238269,
-0.0183231197,
-0.4197386503,
-0.9474248886,
-0.4716894925,
0.3516191542,
0.1431036443,
-0.097740896,
0.5972207189,
0.5860306025,
-0.1262561083,
-0.4321115613,
0.4283234179,
0.1635589153,
0.6475784183,
0.3376974165,
0.7835685015,
-0.3521145284,
0.9219915271,
0.1874141693,
0.1435920894,
-0.0869885683,
-1.1802191734,
-1.033880949,
-0.7399356365,
-0.2262933105,
0.2088126391,
-0.0429943837,
0.8324819803,
0.8611270189,
-0.3117817044,
-0.1856263131,
-0.0598295517,
-0.3644643724,
0.161054045,
-0.1077978835,
0.5141028762,
-0.0293341316,
-0.5854426622,
0.4762475491,
0.4277748168,
0.3242776394,
-0.2857967615,
-0.3240421116,
0.2077307403,
-0.174103722,
0.9906744957,
0.434817493,
-0.5986983776,
-0.3605300486,
-0.1692178696,
0.4578935802,
0.1768504977,
1.256239295,
-0.6128598452,
0.6639617085,
0.412184149,
0.5714707375,
1.081397891,
0.096087575,
0.3329693377,
-1.0601717234,
0.7761026025,
-0.088898629,
0.5649143457,
0.3035344481,
0.2748430371,
0.2785086334,
0.2667901218,
-0.2440234721,
-0.9632207155,
0.3748556376,
-1.0547240973,
-0.1330716312,
0.8850340247,
-0.2507547736,
-0.1882944554,
0.434481293,
-0.0572560467,
0.3104721308,
-0.0942110643,
0.4059199393,
0.352622658,
0.2491979003,
-0.5098065734,
-0.131493032,
0.4137679935,
0.1510560811,
-0.7445247769,
0.0880208462,
0.5675287247,
0.1458112001,
0.1333068758,
0.8618854284,
-0.1419258863,
0.3241156936,
0.0322417207,
0.1176697239,
-0.1701458842,
-0.6028511524,
-0.3156478107,
0.3880399466,
-0.1691815704,
-0.333757937
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03142v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03142v2
|
Less is KEN: a Universal and Simple Non-Parametric Pruning Algorithm for Large Language Models
| 2024-02-05T16:11:43 | 2024-06-09T10:32:03 |
Michele Mastromattei, Fabio Massimo Zanzotto
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Neural network pruning has become increasingly crucial due to the complexity
of these models and their widespread use in various fields. Existing pruning
algorithms often suffer from limitations such as architecture specificity,
excessive complexity and reliance on demanding calculations, rendering them
impractical for real-world applications. This paper introduces KEN: a
straightforward, universal and unstructured pruning algorithm based on Kernel
Density Estimation (KDE). KEN aims to construct optimized transformers by
selectively preserving the most significant parameters while restoring others
to their pre-training state. This strategy preserves model performance while
enabling storage of only the optimized subnetwork, leading to substantial
memory savings. Extensive evaluations across seven different LLMs demonstrate
that KEN achieves equal or better performance than their original unpruned
versions, with a minimum parameter reduction of 25%. Furthermore, in-depth
comparisons with established pruning and PEFT algorithms confirm KEN
effectiveness. We further introduce KEN$_{viz}$, an explainable tool that
visualizes the optimized model composition achieved by KEN from different
points of view.
|
[
-0.531602025,
-0.8067392111,
0.6259186864,
0.0829648226,
-0.4674709439,
-0.2563679516,
-0.5457237959,
-0.0381200463,
0.6035370231,
0.4106756747,
-0.7610752583,
-0.6279016733,
-0.3258661926,
-0.2749063671,
-0.5116684437,
0.6425456405,
0.2310899347,
-0.3502429426,
-0.3316652477,
-0.2279966176,
-0.3062932789,
-0.1143513098,
-0.5311481357,
-0.3781754375,
0.6842634082,
0.7328705192,
0.2836694717,
0.4797667563,
0.3125456572,
0.3203064501,
-0.2469302565,
-0.0864819139,
-0.63378793,
0.2558946609,
0.4562185109,
-0.4698863029,
-0.1258524656,
-0.2326289117,
0.7838979363,
0.9291638136,
-0.4142078757,
0.1786875129,
0.0034492649,
1.0415465832,
-0.9437314868,
0.000051189,
-0.7031608224,
0.1687726676,
-0.0212388076,
0.1103067622,
-0.361092627,
-0.0915481225,
0.0689518154,
-0.7452431321,
0.155643791,
-0.3896039128,
0.9077916741,
0.2862826884,
-0.29682374,
0.4624442458,
-0.9087688327,
1.2589033842,
-0.7844822407,
0.7673313022,
0.1667651981,
0.4489162862,
0.0547663085,
-0.7043803334,
-0.5460439324,
-0.2524932623,
0.1065314561,
0.3092500269,
-0.185663119,
0.3057311177,
0.0820464045,
0.0519471616,
-0.2544854283,
0.1577643007,
-0.4586821198,
-0.2026200294,
0.5830526352,
-0.017230995,
-0.0799000636,
-0.2299829721,
-0.2197789699,
-0.4393472075,
-0.6292446852,
0.0953510702,
0.4363947511,
-0.0256039426,
-0.0279022418,
0.4155885577,
-0.1878118813,
0.6275491714,
-0.2125630975,
-0.3360365331,
-0.2413727492,
0.0616937466,
-0.4629358947,
-0.0072402293,
0.8425655961,
0.5538106561,
0.4648019075,
-0.2095125914,
-0.0007928576,
0.1846215725,
0.5053057075,
-0.5667797923,
-0.7125291228,
-0.10721948,
-0.7420136929,
-0.5009145737,
-0.1080227718,
-0.8540325165,
-0.1453906596,
-0.4029507339,
0.0298083741,
-0.3211812675,
-0.3649177253,
-0.1080306917,
0.0097367717,
0.1581708342,
0.5009491444,
-0.648676753,
0.2984627783,
0.7519203424,
0.7571724653,
0.1677802205,
-0.0086402474,
-0.3376022577,
0.0328877494,
-0.6206175089,
0.3206731081,
-0.6048547626,
-0.3592115045,
-0.3836616278,
-0.0606659949,
0.1267123669,
-0.3791776299,
0.7737135887,
-0.4128558636,
-0.3763061464,
-0.3616729677,
-0.453615278,
-0.6347756982,
0.2060061395,
-0.7626706362,
0.895970583,
0.1505514979,
-0.6365395188,
0.2389134318,
-0.4088757634,
-0.3661801815,
0.0308477581,
-0.0793256983,
-0.6507015824,
0.671051085,
0.1451444179,
0.5752697587,
-0.2538439631,
0.4481323361,
-0.3901606202,
-0.1617052406,
-0.3677097261,
-0.4207987189,
0.5839707851,
0.2223613709,
0.0444479771,
0.1489469856,
-0.8610102534,
0.1191263422,
0.2742662132,
-0.5109195709,
-0.6434441805,
0.2082779408,
0.1020691693,
-0.075348556,
0.0627210215,
-1.0666924715,
0.0227883458,
-0.5547057986,
0.7742308974,
0.7369129658,
-0.0717011243,
0.7845581174,
-0.2200537175,
0.5713412762,
0.0534265749,
0.3290965557,
0.1163526997,
-0.4661623538,
-1.152600646,
0.0613836311,
0.5940579176,
0.2472428977,
-0.4562855065,
0.4322694838,
-0.5433877707,
-0.6447386742,
-0.5288186669,
0.4805943668,
0.1521959603,
0.885794878,
0.1134482175,
-0.3702820539,
-0.6709022522,
-1.5040869713,
0.1794157475,
-0.2923260629,
0.0775781572,
0.3515174687,
0.1693446189,
-0.0549172536,
0.9669697285,
-0.3200595677,
-0.1661940366,
-0.4590357542,
-0.1486033201,
0.2289519012,
0.563880384,
0.1753112376,
-0.6047763228,
-0.804693222,
0.2067292482,
-0.574226737,
0.2679416835,
-0.1964174658,
-0.0024099534,
-0.0643388927,
0.5646306276,
-0.6021968722,
0.2721163929,
0.5065710545,
0.3429262042,
0.527415514,
-0.3003735244,
-0.6520382762,
-0.6937282085,
0.1992663294,
0.2982343733,
-0.3746650815,
-0.6678578854,
0.057742957,
0.3410729468,
-0.2717466354,
-0.2958713174,
0.2943710685,
-0.3178008199,
-0.0509797148,
0.033570502,
-0.3029315472,
0.1893900931,
0.7105638385,
-0.0206322353,
0.5597714782,
0.3820009828,
-0.6684983969,
0.1866129786,
0.2505434752,
-0.7912827134,
0.4492945075,
-0.6584575772,
-0.0214012191,
-0.4676097333,
0.1439795345,
-0.7589346766,
0.0574368723,
0.0191675927,
-0.1278841048,
0.4089863598,
-0.3677304089,
-0.2662584782,
-0.2508852184,
-0.3834638,
0.0055081076,
0.9130810499,
-0.4214809537,
0.5882396102,
0.4573291838,
-0.2162750214,
-0.2710716426,
-0.5733224154,
0.1592801511,
-0.3428350389,
-0.8256097436,
0.4430799484,
-0.1162345186,
-0.2015743703,
0.064269051,
-0.4146277606,
-0.309365809,
0.3301394582,
0.0641678348,
0.0670244843,
-0.4061189294,
-0.0230014678,
0.2703831792,
-0.3040055335,
-0.0755135864,
-0.1072044671,
0.4039230645,
0.1660457402,
-0.2398462445,
-0.6745352745,
0.4388572872,
0.5458849072,
0.0362490155,
0.4962031841,
0.4500001967,
-0.0226372369,
-0.5276375413,
-0.537920475,
-0.3342106044,
-0.5523808599,
0.493832767,
-0.3286000192,
-0.6317876577,
0.3332475126,
-0.2397166342,
0.2894995213,
0.348118484,
0.0862291902,
-0.4154458046,
1.1592006683,
0.7142406106,
-0.1603254825,
0.3810513318,
-0.5190095901,
0.3661916852,
-1.0825936794,
-0.1151719242,
-0.2486722469,
-1.0896639824,
-0.2719325721,
-0.0649471655,
0.4193768203,
0.3087401688,
0.0579103641,
0.3995105922,
-0.8970957994,
0.7698533535,
0.8988926411,
-0.1583335102,
-0.0430323705,
0.2630617023,
-0.2596786916,
-0.3036260903,
-1.0336828232,
-0.1632870883,
1.2015987635,
0.382763356,
0.7153406143,
-0.2759078443,
0.7628000975,
-0.0881977007,
0.2187711447,
-0.9567265511,
0.738617599,
-0.2411708385,
-0.4019009471,
-0.3778586686,
-0.5902394652,
-0.9627482295,
0.0566730499,
-0.0101052113,
-0.7399675846,
0.4192754626,
0.1610258818,
-0.4778366983,
0.5377055407,
-0.8949501514,
0.5112043619,
0.0255577657,
0.0527878664,
-0.0957454294,
-0.6409785748,
0.5671351552,
-0.2015760094,
-0.1274228841,
-0.1492265016,
0.0974394083,
0.9169325829,
-0.7237797379,
0.6616005301,
-0.473998785,
-0.0185322743,
0.1570438296,
0.345721066,
0.8195511103,
-0.0742413253,
0.1645728648,
0.2040225267,
0.1281543374,
-0.1518427879,
-0.7204800844,
1.1606190205,
-0.7685919404,
-0.4106787145,
0.3510966003,
-0.5617056489,
-0.2071556002,
-0.0792509839,
0.1047081947,
0.2779901922,
-0.0776864812,
0.6144248843,
0.6547029018,
-0.4613881409,
0.6496576071,
0.3559824824,
0.2312447131,
-0.4559739828,
1.3881044388,
0.4390438199,
-0.0305214263,
0.5222511888,
0.3197627366,
-0.2432367802,
-0.5874502659,
-0.1136368439,
0.3324087262,
-0.7526552081,
-0.1888221949,
-0.7266281247,
-0.2377306521,
-0.11990951,
-0.4187097847,
-0.5581629872,
-0.7289940119,
0.1718981862,
-0.0515917391,
0.3035788536,
0.5081514716,
-0.1060751304,
0.8819059134,
-0.645917356,
0.2365633547,
0.6329031587,
0.4718384743,
0.2980349362,
0.1237816513,
0.022372419,
-0.0179675817,
-0.3355235159,
-0.5565087199,
0.5720486045,
0.4566453099,
0.2979702652,
0.6385270953,
0.2228744775,
0.7239225507,
-0.4449100494,
0.422316879,
0.5652494431,
-0.5996546149,
0.2869262993,
-0.1635131538,
0.2969735861,
0.9716381431,
-0.1381086558,
-0.759075284,
-0.0277917534,
-0.9040255547,
-0.983176887,
0.8336833119,
0.2730416656,
0.2360298336,
0.1117960513,
0.1516066045,
0.1195281371,
0.1930832118,
-0.5797222257,
-0.4578063488,
-0.0765327588,
-0.4848483503,
-0.1700960994,
-0.5475383401,
-0.0681943521,
-0.6062378883,
0.8571820855,
0.2329593003,
0.4787138402,
0.0687275529,
-0.2739412189,
-0.0422492437,
0.1152241603,
0.5703043938,
0.4914326966,
-0.3284677267,
0.1359953731,
0.1034621745,
-0.5174046159,
0.1281805336,
-0.1848504245,
-0.5839781761,
0.417403549,
0.0710739568,
0.8598773479,
0.3199387491,
-0.4791348577,
0.4973302484,
-0.171889171,
-0.668756187,
-0.3832672238,
0.0738413781,
0.2075076252,
-0.0763226748,
0.0225900821,
0.0524014048,
-0.1885343194,
0.2091719806,
0.0486585386,
0.5095519423,
-0.5999630094,
-0.4488364756,
0.5687372684,
0.4579203129,
-0.3538458943,
0.8443382978,
0.1334066838,
-0.2073034793,
0.760971725,
0.1514654309,
0.899052918,
-0.0007774424,
0.4214405417,
0.3533709943,
0.5642815828,
0.0997457653,
0.2010093182,
-0.5438400507,
-0.6796578169,
-0.7850589156,
-0.9774483442,
0.0772238299,
0.6756349802,
-0.4551496804,
0.059503369,
-0.9768547416,
-0.0779158473,
0.1822448671,
0.028436007,
-0.6129066944,
0.0072446968,
-0.1599832326,
1.0521107912,
-0.8130193353,
0.9989447594,
0.5795570016,
-0.0344071463,
-0.790127635,
-0.5378013849,
-0.1778382957,
-0.6922309995,
0.6235503554,
0.1704460382,
0.5444009304,
0.5228775144,
-0.5598332882,
-0.7956976295,
0.9066678882,
0.6927152276,
-1.1638875008,
-0.0872428492,
-0.0612553805,
-0.1509120166,
0.1724658459,
-0.1105607972,
0.5018429756,
0.8462864757,
-0.0748836473,
-0.610486865,
-0.3064427078,
-0.4466164708,
0.0990718901,
0.9650245905,
-0.3748346269,
0.6235198379,
0.2992372215,
-0.3052751124,
0.0589921363,
0.3214403391,
-0.0306645483,
-0.0003162744,
0.8399384618,
1.1548212767,
0.4525516629,
0.0326575749,
1.1000334024,
-0.3566345572,
0.1773374528,
0.8344326019,
-0.1128145307,
0.4343455732,
0.7913364768,
-0.3157537878,
0.2977506816,
0.3551982343,
0.0088410899,
0.7523993254,
0.0719215497,
-0.2649779022,
-0.6067643166,
-0.1133327112,
-0.0973073244,
0.3619927764,
0.1220076233,
-0.2671835124,
-0.7188102007,
-0.0705734566,
0.0535011142,
-0.0994475558,
-0.131673947,
0.7647132874,
0.2966457903,
-0.5685398579,
0.6632971764,
0.4619202912,
0.5658074021,
-0.8292592764,
0.0911199749,
-0.2875266075,
0.122344844,
0.1305712163,
-0.1282803267,
0.3536771834,
-0.287537545,
-0.3161463439,
-0.4456860125,
0.8712981343,
-0.185717091,
-0.815657258,
0.101347588,
0.2288610637,
0.0622435696,
-0.1752627939,
-0.7829962373,
0.0461167954,
0.082427755,
-0.1808864027,
0.4257323742,
0.1508289576,
-0.0597361512,
0.7000570297,
0.9097616673,
0.2915695608,
0.0360958725,
-0.0844159201,
0.7924231887,
-0.4238521755,
-0.5186522603,
-0.71439749,
0.5217718482,
-0.1332331151,
-0.2658989727,
0.6293165088,
0.4086803496,
0.5944961905,
0.0959663987,
0.6170061827,
0.1935375929,
0.3291535676,
-0.3058393896,
0.84487921,
-0.626655519,
0.0870619118,
-0.1150302812,
-1.2775899172,
-0.0238085091,
0.8923288584,
-0.2048553377,
-0.1881023794,
0.4496605396,
0.6804250479,
-0.5821272731,
-0.0902852118,
0.6571668386,
0.2028831691,
0.1455127597,
0.4929439723,
0.5484605432,
-0.1504582614,
0.5195161104,
-0.8679874539,
0.2259944379,
0.0295421667,
-0.7362827659,
-0.5195654035,
-0.5230353475,
-0.3820597231,
0.2254843116,
-0.2442210019,
0.4298001528,
1.2110641003,
-0.6405421495,
-0.0845045298,
-0.6733798385,
0.1080138534,
-0.1418279409,
-0.2086531371,
0.2227141112,
-0.1570318639,
-0.4959606528,
0.89546597,
0.3507350981,
-0.2458304614,
-0.4095668793,
-0.3026902974,
-0.1906799525,
0.0159080792,
0.4823921621,
0.371524781,
-0.6176825166,
-0.0410192832,
-0.1535534412,
0.3763146996,
0.120558463,
0.6653675437,
-1.0091125965,
0.5763745308,
0.49769032,
0.7876452208,
0.6040183306,
-0.0460254289,
0.7207415104,
-1.2649220228,
0.284016937,
0.3882591426,
0.3773476183,
0.1990907341,
0.0257607792,
0.2312229425,
0.2215285152,
-0.2836191654,
-1.0527890921,
0.388864398,
-0.8573522568,
-0.4091382921,
1.0095260143,
0.1505308747,
-0.5991556644,
-0.0172311235,
0.0606834739,
0.0150423246,
-0.462916404,
0.5918623209,
0.6477596164,
0.5819603801,
-0.488635987,
-0.8537404537,
0.3035786748,
0.7802479267,
-0.330878526,
-0.1442481726,
0.3078896403,
0.2449537963,
0.0086892182,
0.3969275057,
0.2585627139,
-0.0656911731,
-0.2562630177,
0.0545963831,
-0.3445550203,
-0.5890586972,
-0.3177489638,
0.2986302078,
0.0069006342,
-0.2092496008
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03137v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03137v1
|
Sociolinguistically Informed Interpretability: A Case Study on Hinglish Emotion Classification
| 2024-02-05T16:05:32 | 2024-02-05T16:05:32 |
Kushal Tatariya, Heather Lent, Johannes Bjerva, Miryam de Lhoneux
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Emotion classification is a challenging task in NLP due to the inherent
idiosyncratic and subjective nature of linguistic expression, especially with
code-mixed data. Pre-trained language models (PLMs) have achieved high
performance for many tasks and languages, but it remains to be seen whether
these models learn and are robust to the differences in emotional expression
across languages. Sociolinguistic studies have shown that Hinglish speakers
switch to Hindi when expressing negative emotions and to English when
expressing positive emotions. To understand if language models can learn these
associations, we study the effect of language on emotion prediction across 3
PLMs on a Hinglish emotion classification dataset. Using LIME and token level
language ID, we find that models do learn these associations between language
choice and emotional expression. Moreover, having code-mixed data present in
the pre-training can augment that learning when task-specific data is scarce.
We also conclude from the misclassifications that the models may overgeneralise
this heuristic to other infrequent examples where this sociolinguistic
phenomenon does not apply.
|
[
-0.1180281565,
-0.4500950277,
0.3225727677,
0.576975584,
-0.0841131732,
0.3798789382,
-0.381328702,
-0.8437853456,
0.1372542381,
0.3403591812,
-0.1615042984,
-0.4204719663,
-0.7289193273,
0.1107446402,
0.0880881846,
0.856518209,
0.0240731444,
0.0994510502,
0.0564505234,
-0.4544370472,
-0.3820235431,
-0.902846992,
-0.5347614884,
-0.5927129984,
0.5317388177,
0.4187951386,
0.7208481431,
0.1734735072,
0.3218130171,
0.2121632099,
-0.2662039101,
-0.2470592409,
-0.554443717,
0.0410563499,
-0.1696827263,
-0.7311478853,
-0.2420924753,
0.201659292,
0.1678904146,
0.5751330853,
-0.2749647498,
0.1309238076,
0.1796904951,
0.8362764716,
-0.7192670703,
0.5195708871,
-0.4805429578,
0.2674650252,
-0.2286516577,
-0.2677321136,
-0.5074117184,
-0.2933162153,
0.3531471193,
-0.3424828351,
-0.239887163,
0.1064512059,
0.8870633245,
0.2570847273,
-0.4921165705,
-0.3890095353,
-0.6734861135,
0.672582984,
-0.7324656248,
0.4030959904,
0.5098285079,
0.315553546,
0.4177354276,
-0.2591434121,
-0.5321570635,
-0.0594239943,
-0.3151684999,
0.374410063,
-0.0200662334,
0.2450597733,
0.2194185704,
0.222053051,
-0.5957444906,
0.165042147,
-0.2421962172,
-0.0584395081,
0.674777329,
-0.0346765481,
0.3340350389,
-0.8415834904,
-0.1883956343,
0.3014596701,
-0.7708440423,
0.1490166336,
0.5061409473,
0.2995010316,
-0.5066122413,
0.5112013221,
-0.0257544536,
0.4595950842,
0.1447265148,
-0.0579964109,
0.4714711905,
0.1793411076,
-0.1700642407,
0.2770338058,
0.5451493859,
0.3062894642,
0.7412378788,
0.0341239758,
-0.0144712366,
0.4497225881,
0.05583838,
-0.61107409,
-0.1875281632,
0.3253916502,
-0.6210049987,
-0.2804653943,
-0.2329920381,
-1.0241104364,
-0.6146461964,
-0.2368048131,
0.3196962476,
-0.3067705035,
-0.6507009864,
0.3391384482,
0.1069397256,
0.139425844,
0.0155240577,
-0.7878310084,
0.0409846827,
0.443710655,
0.5605364442,
0.0160488356,
-0.4121137261,
-0.1631926596,
-0.1083011851,
-0.2487301677,
0.5178701878,
-0.6802529693,
-0.2371586263,
0.2094257921,
0.03042675,
-0.3209030926,
-0.6284294128,
0.2896841168,
-0.4558982253,
0.1974285394,
0.0131812748,
-0.4299193025,
-0.2464114577,
0.0121765714,
-0.4970764816,
1.0396604538,
0.2111084759,
-0.778811574,
0.4674428403,
-0.4448458552,
-0.7593736053,
0.1691029817,
0.0166046228,
-0.2396730483,
0.220898062,
-0.2753582597,
0.6349226832,
0.0166784953,
0.4262059033,
-0.4238950014,
-0.2630105019,
0.1317275912,
0.0191313569,
0.5858007073,
0.3789252937,
-0.493793875,
0.0127198296,
-0.8140428662,
-0.0504212864,
0.0927562565,
-0.4318878055,
-0.5017808676,
0.1332852691,
-0.0861935392,
0.5785030723,
0.2067508996,
-0.3349980414,
-0.1990960091,
-0.6407840252,
0.1559787691,
0.6625635624,
-0.0314743333,
0.4262091219,
-0.0323414914,
0.9270432591,
0.0988017097,
0.05790307,
0.2012334168,
-0.5206771493,
-0.6544264555,
0.0468221307,
0.1604986042,
0.69552809,
-0.805911839,
0.2805046439,
0.1125018746,
-0.4352122545,
-0.8929731846,
-0.0300429072,
0.4199549258,
0.3426514864,
0.2223617584,
-0.1148914471,
-0.7965084314,
-0.5987613201,
-0.5541955233,
-0.4316193163,
0.2432301193,
0.5567803979,
0.158418119,
-0.2489779443,
0.6890878081,
-0.2838757336,
0.1022524983,
-0.6652423739,
0.5996050239,
0.0888640583,
0.1483738571,
0.6410940289,
-0.8684218526,
-0.8514117599,
0.1846264154,
-0.7571488619,
-0.3865582645,
-0.165218994,
-0.0920389965,
0.4426560104,
0.2236785293,
-0.5853524804,
0.6055731177,
0.6806755066,
-0.3582968414,
0.6571683288,
-0.095665805,
0.1538795829,
-1.0697671175,
-0.2479403615,
0.1275705546,
0.087199837,
-0.6467438936,
-0.0520921983,
0.1043645367,
-0.141661182,
-0.5488578677,
0.5939218998,
-0.5520047545,
-0.1422390491,
-0.2465008795,
-0.0869500339,
-0.116122745,
0.5183622241,
0.436773777,
0.3794935942,
0.7773814797,
-0.4796221852,
0.1043399349,
0.1131744757,
-0.445643127,
0.4596189559,
-0.4550581872,
-0.0981734917,
-0.3787497878,
-0.2245430052,
-0.7828374505,
-0.4322427213,
0.0626725927,
-0.4234331846,
0.3901005387,
-0.3180463016,
-0.2573200464,
-0.0619674437,
0.1202687547,
0.1569692343,
0.7420442104,
-0.6564840674,
0.6560238004,
0.429831326,
-0.3977112472,
-0.5271698833,
-0.6042690277,
0.0777523145,
-0.4989982843,
-0.2939896882,
-0.1514986455,
-0.0904557705,
-0.4315479994,
-0.183888182,
0.0134835085,
-0.1867878586,
0.2736666501,
0.4700752795,
0.1781652123,
-0.1319475323,
0.3966527283,
-0.2419624031,
-0.0086781085,
0.2636336684,
0.2868991792,
0.6550730467,
-0.1630023569,
-0.2550604939,
-0.0678831711,
0.310723424,
0.5055007339,
-0.4198975861,
0.8572071195,
0.565182507,
-0.4165023267,
-0.1862807274,
-0.2291851044,
0.255638659,
-0.4177580178,
0.4266697466,
-0.3874431252,
-0.7104100585,
0.5165684819,
-0.0484724715,
-0.4218887985,
0.4396455586,
0.535733819,
-0.2825745344,
1.2878000736,
0.7567467093,
-0.218159616,
0.610876739,
0.1784984022,
0.5949167609,
-0.3088638186,
0.021268554,
-0.593847394,
-0.1433470994,
-0.9217765927,
0.0783437416,
0.2217049301,
0.1125980616,
0.0517300852,
0.0536261126,
-0.2661494613,
0.479616791,
0.0323351361,
0.1655489951,
-0.110211201,
-0.1677974612,
0.2672974169,
-0.1858986914,
-0.6889606714,
-0.4240318537,
0.8229965568,
0.4129679799,
0.8523728848,
0.197163865,
0.8797856569,
0.0057579139,
0.6221497059,
-0.9142682552,
0.3372143805,
-0.0046302923,
-0.5870364308,
-0.0537743121,
-0.4752160311,
-0.8605788946,
0.036663685,
-0.3324019015,
-0.7866979837,
0.3088536561,
0.1363117546,
-0.2558033764,
-0.0686650127,
-1.043249011,
0.9490236044,
-0.389459908,
-0.3076924384,
-0.3701581359,
-0.8490338922,
0.1582941115,
-0.2647399008,
0.5130714178,
-0.1361805052,
0.4988516271,
0.7352884412,
-0.0911614969,
1.058287859,
-0.3461412787,
-0.0075881546,
0.2509183884,
0.021954773,
0.2317734063,
-0.1625126451,
-0.3852230012,
0.1219097152,
0.0296484269,
-0.4572610259,
-0.7513983846,
0.255451709,
-0.6779350042,
-0.5630807877,
-0.425426662,
-0.3768959641,
-0.3748078644,
-0.002785367,
0.2549954653,
0.1821606904,
-0.0282112081,
0.0560788997,
0.3655999601,
-0.3296953738,
0.1718184203,
0.5759896636,
-0.2808441222,
0.1524733156,
0.9162374139,
0.211817652,
0.3703749478,
0.193255946,
0.5089729428,
-0.1587982774,
-0.401517123,
-0.0629355609,
0.1505586356,
-0.8708384037,
0.1735214889,
-0.4549774826,
-0.1012666076,
-0.429959178,
-0.2390761077,
-0.1561604887,
-0.3408092558,
-0.3330344558,
-0.3645972311,
0.2679172754,
1.0976432562,
-0.1226986125,
0.3124366999,
-0.8474390507,
0.2042360008,
0.130146578,
0.4478480518,
0.0113577209,
-0.5551249385,
-0.4838573337,
-0.0632339418,
0.133346498,
-1.3070828915,
0.7474028468,
0.3413138688,
0.4279127121,
0.4097991884,
0.0769044235,
0.5642354488,
-0.1892351359,
0.6685164571,
0.0339709483,
-0.9614747167,
0.547603488,
-0.1654829681,
0.2819125354,
0.4255415797,
0.7804738283,
-0.69310987,
-0.2838789225,
-0.6616521478,
-0.7749859095,
0.4496783614,
-0.3197455108,
0.000105535,
-0.1468842924,
0.4156428874,
0.2681820691,
0.3134837449,
-1.0077759027,
-0.079032883,
-0.2145392001,
-0.5796942115,
-0.4558144808,
-0.4671384692,
0.2226174027,
-0.2808603346,
0.487264365,
-0.1814133376,
0.0167573616,
-0.100487642,
-0.4517720044,
-0.2372157723,
0.5539677739,
0.0962663144,
0.4279096723,
-0.3613947332,
0.335496068,
-0.0853191093,
-0.2128101736,
0.0620761141,
-0.016416559,
0.2940719724,
-0.0469568111,
0.4885601103,
0.9476335049,
0.3616086245,
-0.703902185,
0.4486745596,
0.1708301455,
0.0524534062,
-0.0214104336,
-0.2552536428,
0.1451266259,
0.2085499763,
-0.0525802486,
0.1574092507,
0.2288425714,
-0.9070432782,
-0.0447160192,
0.0461647697,
-0.4313904345,
-0.5752816796,
0.3302684128,
0.138894558,
-0.3474866152,
0.2971403003,
-0.3324644864,
-0.9523701072,
0.5220707655,
0.3868274689,
0.9361772537,
-0.5746389031,
0.3399664462,
0.1606406271,
0.2087675035,
0.0823427066,
0.645295918,
0.0224095266,
-0.9351612329,
-0.4117405713,
-0.6540644169,
-0.4818082154,
-0.2513341308,
-1.0066757202,
0.0314308777,
-0.22605896,
0.0009097631,
-0.030882353,
-0.2325300872,
-0.808177948,
0.4786916077,
0.1443850547,
0.6125748754,
-1.2884420156,
0.8198466897,
0.8178926706,
-0.2496524453,
-0.962261498,
-0.0139941955,
-0.0183398612,
-0.7174491286,
0.8991798162,
0.2847680449,
-0.0273223091,
-0.2592479289,
-0.5178306699,
-0.5966719389,
0.3745810091,
0.109192647,
-0.2052786201,
0.0939584672,
0.1517163217,
1.0293778181,
-0.3871004879,
0.1774246991,
0.5956343412,
0.3976747394,
-0.1029894724,
-0.8691678643,
-0.3243005872,
-0.3672433197,
-0.3993521333,
-0.0019820218,
-0.4321064651,
0.7995897532,
-0.1697105467,
-0.4596968293,
-0.3280322254,
0.4491093457,
-0.0177195203,
0.4856795371,
0.5932039618,
0.2726956904,
0.7171593904,
0.0035574108,
1.0512934923,
-0.4534331858,
0.3714081943,
1.008947134,
-0.8131796718,
1.0611940622,
0.5118445158,
-0.2101967931,
0.475299418,
1.0960031748,
0.5078576207,
0.5854260921,
0.0593695641,
-0.2015610784,
-0.3206244707,
-0.2258113772,
-0.0430768877,
0.5795055628,
0.4338623285,
-0.1190186813,
0.041680146,
0.118802093,
-0.0814065635,
0.0984130576,
-0.2413874269,
0.7571973801,
0.0884107724,
-0.5331745744,
0.5650690198,
-0.3726056218,
0.7914515138,
-0.4752908051,
-0.0911798626,
-0.0586341843,
-0.0463932604,
-0.6019220948,
-0.8592721224,
0.4415787458,
-0.0548079424,
-0.0407544039,
-0.4114887416,
0.9431959391,
-0.6323382854,
-0.1412465423,
0.6210656762,
0.6900666952,
0.2607965469,
-0.0102398759,
-0.5294935107,
-0.1817864776,
0.0483867638,
-0.4511996508,
0.3943988681,
0.5283296108,
0.0462409183,
0.6738523841,
0.1979676336,
0.3360045552,
0.0011452982,
0.2130446732,
0.3988180459,
-0.5779360533,
-0.6273908019,
-0.6515881419,
0.5155459046,
0.1467608064,
-0.1873033494,
0.6793760061,
0.2174670249,
0.7586010098,
-0.1671166122,
1.0362603664,
0.0120764636,
0.6531862617,
-0.5865197778,
0.6088678837,
-0.6352940798,
0.0441006832,
-0.3512066305,
-0.5664356947,
-0.0522144325,
0.7070709467,
-0.6543998718,
0.0939432308,
0.6625636816,
0.5700104833,
0.2795802355,
0.2848273516,
0.4569489062,
0.5033159852,
-0.1386309713,
0.3954870105,
1.0731208324,
0.1929323077,
0.1158261597,
-0.3205644488,
-0.3264627159,
-0.1404551864,
-0.8059956431,
-0.7895492315,
-0.402744472,
-0.3087022007,
-0.4242193401,
0.092220664,
0.9205306768,
0.5841834545,
-0.6916891932,
-0.349014163,
0.2634958923,
0.2943024337,
0.001036793,
-0.3370405734,
0.0301771872,
-0.258262068,
-0.490327388,
0.1803578287,
0.3901787996,
0.1669983864,
-0.0971745029,
-0.275718838,
-0.1586003751,
0.2414544523,
0.7267463803,
0.333696425,
-0.4455937743,
-0.5231983662,
-0.1278342158,
-0.0975776538,
0.3024243414,
0.581156671,
-0.4490221143,
0.4647726119,
0.4385472536,
0.5093645453,
0.3706925213,
-0.1593784392,
0.5818160772,
-0.7267845273,
0.2446752042,
0.1556400657,
0.6577485204,
0.3759945631,
-0.6060825586,
0.4658250213,
0.1884521097,
-0.4398930371,
-0.7189419866,
0.3567769825,
-0.7890722752,
-0.2556245625,
1.2250292301,
-0.3633104265,
-0.247218132,
-0.1713110805,
-0.2843203843,
0.310693562,
-0.06503319,
0.9101473093,
0.9299279451,
-0.2014426738,
-0.4146986008,
-0.5075397491,
0.6516879797,
0.7526369095,
-0.9107462764,
0.256621778,
0.4031359851,
0.0777197704,
0.08627785,
0.448736459,
0.0909053758,
0.2778791487,
-0.2611320019,
0.511747241,
0.6229255795,
-0.3416695893,
-0.7124773264,
0.1373737007,
0.3120442033,
0.2545175552
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03131v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03131v1
|
Constrained Decoding for Cross-lingual Label Projection
| 2024-02-05T15:57:32 | 2024-02-05T15:57:32 |
Duong Minh Le, Yang Chen, Alan Ritter, Wei Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Zero-shot cross-lingual transfer utilizing multilingual LLMs has become a
popular learning paradigm for low-resource languages with no labeled training
data. However, for NLP tasks that involve fine-grained predictions on words and
phrases, the performance of zero-shot cross-lingual transfer learning lags far
behind supervised fine-tuning methods. Therefore, it is common to exploit
translation and label projection to further improve the performance by (1)
translating training data that is available in a high-resource language (e.g.,
English) together with the gold labels into low-resource languages, and/or (2)
translating test data in low-resource languages to a high-source language to
run inference on, then projecting the predicted span-level labels back onto the
original test data. However, state-of-the-art marker-based label projection
methods suffer from translation quality degradation due to the extra label
markers injected in the input to the translation model. In this work, we
explore a new direction that leverages constrained decoding for label
projection to overcome the aforementioned issues. Our new method not only can
preserve the quality of translated texts but also has the versatility of being
applicable to both translating training and translating test data strategies.
This versatility is crucial as our experiments reveal that translating test
data can lead to a considerable boost in performance compared to translating
only training data. We evaluate on two cross-lingual transfer tasks, namely
Named Entity Recognition and Event Argument Extraction, spanning 20 languages.
The results demonstrate that our approach outperforms the state-of-the-art
marker-based method by a large margin and also shows better performance than
other label projection methods that rely on external word alignment.
|
[
-0.2377456576,
-0.1762625128,
0.2880303562,
0.214087829,
-0.4239780307,
0.120006755,
-0.2512515187,
-0.7429973483,
0.2618150115,
0.4934093654,
-0.4184782803,
-0.664270401,
-0.6444296837,
0.3222852051,
-0.0684437603,
1.1280971766,
-0.3606491387,
0.0622956119,
0.0012288962,
-0.1691355407,
-0.3483109474,
-0.538038075,
-0.2153382003,
-0.4488254189,
0.4155150056,
0.5191552043,
0.4339078367,
0.7628380656,
0.0168315955,
0.09669099,
-0.0544498451,
0.4873827994,
-0.535975337,
-0.1674275696,
-0.294481039,
-0.3576778173,
-0.3156369627,
-0.0700125396,
0.6070367098,
0.8234188557,
0.3257896602,
0.0429072492,
0.2391188741,
0.2552010119,
-0.8710073233,
0.3608008325,
-0.5476772785,
0.3924499452,
-0.1082133129,
-0.4103699625,
-0.7097118497,
-0.0032218865,
-0.1558036059,
-0.8370500803,
0.095045872,
0.021871889,
1.0220499039,
0.16160658,
-0.5565397739,
-0.3064550161,
-0.6935572028,
0.9432151914,
-0.4809390903,
0.6041532755,
0.3592559993,
0.0806898996,
0.133232072,
-0.4785583913,
-0.2270548344,
0.0357375778,
-0.2067411691,
0.1659853011,
-0.0654703602,
0.0012362236,
0.1178408042,
0.1673074812,
-0.4624525905,
0.2987145782,
-0.2016082555,
-0.5491588116,
0.5642209649,
-0.0559241883,
0.1861417145,
-0.2435162961,
-0.6567923427,
-0.2435565591,
-0.6973927021,
-0.1333998293,
0.0412755273,
0.6252994537,
-0.0589412116,
0.5210568905,
-0.2404111326,
0.8029168248,
-0.0076982696,
-0.3366099894,
0.2236253917,
-0.5106934309,
-0.1332847625,
0.4070749879,
0.7070577145,
0.4228447676,
0.2206172049,
-0.3910941482,
-0.0370791703,
0.0047410061,
-0.2913069129,
-0.7265964746,
-0.0062825978,
-0.2743851244,
-0.0708926842,
0.2348354906,
-0.3628414273,
-0.8729694486,
-0.1912735999,
-0.021486517,
0.180480361,
-0.4218818843,
0.1363767087,
0.2875578403,
0.1735939533,
0.1441351473,
0.1695442796,
-0.940533042,
-0.0466343015,
0.3864189684,
0.6854736209,
-0.37234658,
-0.114910841,
-0.8387147784,
0.5862464905,
-0.4401887655,
0.6219656467,
-0.428942591,
-0.3903290927,
0.2387526929,
-0.0047490937,
-0.2065372318,
-0.4397859573,
0.6553369164,
-0.4852868319,
0.0247652456,
-0.1285689473,
-0.4226381183,
-0.109594889,
0.4079802334,
-0.391895175,
0.7757120132,
0.1107452065,
-0.3906805813,
0.4174698889,
-0.058585301,
-0.5911302567,
0.1836976856,
-0.0804040655,
-0.1478003711,
-0.1448243707,
0.629942894,
0.5738982558,
-0.391749233,
0.0997254103,
-0.0932804644,
-0.1296107322,
0.1795068383,
-0.3812437654,
0.5368668437,
0.2279113978,
-0.1928943694,
-0.2346985638,
-0.8673131466,
0.2240951806,
-0.1939024627,
-0.5795537829,
-0.3999979198,
-0.3809559345,
-0.0643356964,
0.2853580117,
0.0951875746,
-0.6309740543,
0.3241249919,
-0.3305011988,
0.0346673727,
0.3765667975,
-0.0829989612,
0.6758134961,
-0.0127429953,
0.7598831058,
-0.0548008047,
-0.1842124909,
-0.0555327944,
-0.4481861591,
-0.7063541412,
-0.3127372265,
0.5270032883,
0.8644470572,
-1.2488926649,
0.1112135127,
-0.4569050968,
-0.1250869632,
-0.7265772223,
0.3489910662,
0.6897791028,
0.7120715976,
0.7252296805,
-0.2721195817,
-0.5716884136,
-0.848008275,
-0.1981728226,
-0.1969721764,
-0.0887983069,
0.2086590081,
0.1616973281,
-0.144229725,
0.4528016448,
-0.4293527901,
-0.5676574707,
-0.5014738441,
0.1727056205,
0.0870955735,
0.5575824976,
0.445723772,
-0.6830481887,
-0.7895565629,
0.3434981406,
-0.5196385384,
-0.4043305516,
-0.4615227282,
-0.2244926989,
0.4440822005,
0.4824171066,
-0.3461100161,
0.2615795434,
0.9005994201,
-0.3516607583,
0.4672492743,
-0.0929606259,
0.0343169756,
-0.8868250251,
-0.1673970073,
-0.0085350219,
-0.320494175,
-0.6043473482,
-0.1787602454,
0.1248888075,
0.0952605531,
-0.6668095589,
0.6029157043,
-0.7665776014,
0.0364823043,
-0.1346465349,
0.2686542273,
0.3679667115,
0.4597889185,
0.2615821958,
0.5047791004,
0.413800925,
-0.4524556398,
0.1721284539,
0.4009216726,
-0.4045953751,
0.7174953222,
-0.1243736595,
-0.0455507524,
0.026583137,
0.2196112126,
-0.7434942126,
0.0855708793,
0.5926654935,
-0.2747129202,
0.8303739429,
-0.263910085,
-0.2450684309,
0.1002562568,
0.0724700317,
0.6067086458,
0.3563517034,
-0.6791449189,
0.3971588612,
0.2376144081,
0.0921926871,
-0.754072845,
-1.1931566,
0.1782287657,
-0.1176986247,
-0.3320272863,
0.6616188288,
0.1751659513,
0.2978287339,
0.1449420303,
-0.2370279282,
-0.0396685377,
-0.2538461387,
-0.07253775,
0.2233465016,
-0.1809336692,
-0.1434155256,
0.0935753211,
-0.2822934985,
-0.1964711845,
-0.4286674857,
0.147154659,
0.1243055984,
-0.2934196889,
-0.2595988214,
0.541641593,
0.2744437158,
-0.1754058897,
0.7026563883,
0.6748064756,
-0.179522261,
-0.369264096,
-0.2767473757,
0.1823293567,
-0.4016671479,
0.4056643546,
-0.6741345525,
-0.7191983461,
0.3584094942,
-0.1858640164,
-0.2541157007,
0.2837991714,
0.3858490288,
0.1375675797,
0.9076254368,
0.7520126104,
-0.0444736108,
0.2530606687,
-0.3342595398,
0.2299381942,
-0.9266766906,
-0.3714540899,
-0.3064432442,
-0.3367272615,
-0.4591245651,
-0.8221588731,
0.2034306377,
0.3385902941,
0.3507706523,
0.4278334081,
-0.4869687259,
0.2956929207,
0.374637574,
-0.065665327,
0.4020997882,
0.1338341087,
-0.3586779833,
-0.3963375688,
-1.0827826262,
-0.2531845272,
0.7563326955,
0.0713689178,
0.6509584785,
-0.1508457959,
0.746824801,
0.0082514221,
0.3724829257,
-0.8238609433,
0.6432320476,
-0.2870181501,
-0.4461295903,
-0.1433218271,
-0.5212908387,
-1.054099679,
0.500244379,
-0.296050936,
-0.8689206243,
0.5213601589,
0.0465219766,
0.0037751503,
0.5755844116,
-0.5699384809,
0.8571250439,
-0.3694552779,
-0.4292276204,
0.2089340687,
-0.5301460028,
0.2444345206,
-0.1245815307,
0.2321412861,
-0.1983276606,
-0.1091755629,
0.682805419,
-0.0689881966,
0.9367325306,
-0.044715818,
-0.4398938417,
0.2368306816,
0.2414017767,
0.571819067,
-0.1000170484,
-0.136167556,
0.1267853677,
0.1551895291,
-0.4110625982,
-0.5145369768,
0.5914519429,
-0.6155855656,
-0.4451377988,
-0.3760145605,
-0.9935474396,
-0.4314024746,
0.1042598933,
0.3907212615,
0.0712950528,
-0.071167022,
-0.015687678,
0.383141309,
-0.4241342843,
0.231359601,
0.5863675475,
-0.1232265159,
-0.4065292478,
1.2145437002,
0.2866952419,
0.4145367444,
0.7862943411,
-0.0624568015,
-0.3430236876,
-0.6371060014,
-0.7124921679,
0.4096464515,
-0.7938779593,
-0.4759878814,
-0.3163622022,
0.0198388733,
-0.4858240783,
-0.3842172921,
-0.6043305993,
-0.6559289694,
-0.4539826512,
-0.1601269543,
-0.1046523377,
0.1291445941,
-0.507199049,
0.1416175216,
-0.9527237415,
0.4013880193,
-0.0890699849,
0.0837748721,
-0.4218322039,
-0.5825077295,
-0.4851058424,
0.0180130154,
-0.1337450147,
-1.1269659996,
0.7353118062,
0.3697585762,
0.4554823339,
0.2360686809,
0.5264353752,
0.8012390137,
-0.3575399518,
0.3978559673,
0.1949728131,
-0.9053997397,
0.379316926,
0.0702761933,
0.3889334798,
0.3947061896,
0.6264269948,
-0.6092905402,
-0.3398629725,
-0.1460000426,
-0.9788682461,
0.7582303882,
-0.0382189006,
-0.0926352143,
0.1489447653,
0.2684055865,
0.2580870688,
-0.1634385288,
-0.7997941375,
-0.2871718407,
-0.0471065603,
0.0801425576,
-0.3989192843,
-0.3637954593,
-0.2050921917,
-0.2754417956,
0.696044147,
-0.4013733864,
0.068438828,
0.2654194236,
-0.2509531081,
-0.0356725305,
0.4829318821,
0.3446619809,
0.2071260959,
-0.0687885508,
0.3328647912,
0.4073706567,
-0.0951892585,
0.3961317539,
0.4014060795,
-0.5070864558,
0.2552488744,
0.4052437842,
1.050937891,
0.1950909644,
-0.514862895,
0.1581266671,
0.352537632,
-0.2994767725,
0.2624627352,
-0.3307051361,
-0.1902213991,
0.264914304,
0.2819090188,
-0.2955993712,
0.0473855101,
-0.4534904957,
0.2218299657,
0.3709321618,
-0.4414822161,
-0.3478907347,
0.714633286,
0.0705183148,
0.0563630648,
0.4845041335,
-0.3318220675,
-0.5749111176,
0.2955042124,
0.964174509,
0.6652234197,
-0.158936128,
0.621250093,
0.3929383755,
0.4278404117,
0.0606667548,
0.0787741467,
-0.337798804,
-0.8722392917,
-0.9223210216,
-0.6424343586,
-0.4577862024,
-0.0402332656,
-0.8171422482,
0.0038899253,
0.059278056,
-0.0036609466,
-0.3209455907,
-0.1391291022,
-0.6403292418,
0.1741883308,
0.681420207,
0.779361546,
-0.9054098129,
1.0709131956,
0.657951951,
-0.0307480972,
-0.7209686041,
-0.3104459345,
-0.1354334801,
-0.8333066106,
0.8186215162,
0.1180093065,
-0.1663357019,
-0.072614938,
-0.0689276382,
-1.0039225817,
0.7696293592,
0.7776090503,
-0.4560235441,
-0.1362761557,
0.6621540189,
0.4818975925,
-0.3423349857,
-0.1973654181,
0.5956227779,
0.5785354376,
0.2702028751,
-0.9923561811,
0.2902016044,
-0.0954878628,
-0.0097734313,
0.1889390647,
-0.3677400351,
0.3365588784,
-0.2430688143,
-0.5872992873,
0.0257696901,
0.7084152699,
0.1342847794,
0.3960867226,
0.2061863691,
0.4825125039,
0.494830668,
-0.1860945821,
1.087416172,
-0.3340537846,
0.3525494337,
0.9538220763,
-0.2002432793,
0.6767580509,
0.8597232103,
0.155239895,
0.2658192217,
0.4690828025,
0.0560737215,
0.8059530258,
0.0999677256,
-0.1041454449,
-0.3903332055,
-0.7219702601,
-0.2915263176,
0.5007375479,
0.5924040675,
-0.200753361,
-0.4292024076,
0.2819832563,
-0.0627391711,
0.1129585654,
-0.2309281975,
0.3192428648,
0.1750106215,
-0.7308756709,
1.1466960907,
0.0467490554,
0.6880803704,
-0.5729450583,
-0.0092490464,
-0.222411558,
0.297205776,
-0.1412892789,
-0.6607269645,
0.3755399585,
-0.2115762234,
0.2061373293,
-0.8427991271,
0.6225087643,
-0.829347074,
-0.4465717077,
0.6754393578,
0.5243195891,
0.3396098912,
0.3899022639,
-0.5200139284,
0.1582112461,
0.3325110078,
-0.2261068225,
0.522657752,
0.5848398209,
0.0714874566,
0.5683926344,
0.2817942798,
0.4308039546,
0.3323490024,
-0.2249830812,
0.5744618177,
-0.4381476641,
-0.2378744632,
-0.5512411594,
0.3358906507,
0.2640766501,
-0.2968915105,
0.8228397369,
0.5088346004,
1.2853661776,
-0.1208739951,
0.5953624845,
0.1164633483,
0.1825050265,
-0.7399325967,
0.2419885397,
-0.6181713343,
0.2161513269,
-0.1692612022,
-0.7025669813,
-0.7572026849,
0.4114315212,
-0.3115614355,
-0.4051131904,
0.5041920543,
0.6545667052,
0.0215000827,
-0.5306723118,
0.6471639872,
-0.1353935301,
0.2779269218,
1.1521363258,
0.6980138421,
-0.4479297996,
1.1973137856,
-0.5849230886,
0.0076610092,
-0.2677648962,
-0.7999377847,
-0.7534154058,
-0.4689727128,
-0.6354042888,
-0.2983626425,
0.0953960121,
0.3431686163,
0.7391114235,
-0.884786427,
-0.1730984151,
0.304739058,
0.1762822568,
-0.3752179444,
-0.1838733852,
0.3168908954,
-0.3208999336,
-1.0572229624,
0.6590864658,
0.1987271905,
0.2221079171,
0.0436223932,
-0.3126035929,
-0.3958325386,
-0.1572786719,
0.6186418533,
0.7447926998,
-0.5406454802,
-0.3279518783,
-0.0814079046,
-0.2176771611,
0.1492491513,
0.6181165576,
-0.7627215981,
0.6015477777,
0.4990577102,
0.9273127317,
0.9712925553,
-0.0932313055,
0.6804693937,
-1.0243108273,
0.3671586812,
0.2678993344,
0.2600950897,
0.4419778287,
-0.2311084569,
0.5971751809,
0.1413308233,
-0.2170195878,
-0.9510193467,
0.416370362,
-0.9286856055,
-0.3112725616,
1.2690671682,
-0.351097405,
-0.0935360491,
0.0020514771,
-0.0942779407,
0.5549428463,
-0.1160974205,
0.4766850471,
0.5223900676,
-0.3280839324,
-0.322248131,
-0.4476799071,
0.3938722312,
0.6683950424,
-0.4539729953,
-0.1090423018,
0.4873970151,
-0.0563943237,
0.433430016,
0.3959330618,
0.0034262796,
-0.0420086421,
-0.0278951041,
0.0790494904,
-0.0715751573,
-0.3363536596,
-0.2011764646,
0.3061957359,
-0.1505296081,
-0.5995245576
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05129v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05129v1
|
Best Practices for Text Annotation with Large Language Models
| 2024-02-05T15:43:50 | 2024-02-05T15:43:50 |
Petter Törnberg
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have ushered in a new era of text annotation, as
their ease-of-use, high accuracy, and relatively low costs have meant that
their use has exploded in recent months. However, the rapid growth of the field
has meant that LLM-based annotation has become something of an academic Wild
West: the lack of established practices and standards has led to concerns about
the quality and validity of research. Researchers have warned that the
ostensible simplicity of LLMs can be misleading, as they are prone to bias,
misunderstandings, and unreliable results. Recognizing the transformative
potential of LLMs, this paper proposes a comprehensive set of standards and
best practices for their reliable, reproducible, and ethical use. These
guidelines span critical areas such as model selection, prompt engineering,
structured prompting, prompt stability analysis, rigorous model validation, and
the consideration of ethical and legal implications. The paper emphasizes the
need for a structured, directed, and formalized approach to using LLMs, aiming
to ensure the integrity and robustness of text annotation practices, and
advocates for a nuanced and critical engagement with LLMs in social scientific
research.
|
[
-0.0496856757,
-0.7110497952,
0.8457318544,
0.370380789,
-0.4631010592,
-0.0251022503,
-0.512216568,
-0.6893774271,
0.1016739979,
0.8196058273,
-0.1030392572,
-0.6847179532,
-0.7492523193,
0.4388312399,
-0.4418198168,
1.0744763613,
-0.2619846761,
0.1663282067,
-0.2559964061,
-0.3402993977,
-0.1075104699,
-0.7203162909,
-0.4053687751,
-0.4910408556,
0.7782934904,
0.0434879772,
0.7960247993,
0.8259779215,
0.6065951586,
0.1616593301,
-0.5617644191,
0.2974788547,
-0.4821932614,
0.3752243519,
0.0416270457,
-0.1392242759,
-0.5558580756,
0.2682598233,
0.5872960091,
0.7090241313,
-0.0786513016,
0.3908863068,
0.0061697997,
0.2670702636,
-0.4496918321,
0.2277460545,
-0.5725520849,
0.0221775081,
-0.3142267764,
-0.2817137241,
-0.528934598,
-0.7325105667,
-0.0283259079,
-0.5769193769,
-0.3316254914,
0.0641391873,
0.6925890446,
0.06204281,
-0.4051389396,
-0.294083029,
-0.7018249035,
0.8190438151,
-0.8324058056,
0.2546342015,
0.5101933479,
0.1677363962,
-0.2354042977,
-0.6332162619,
-0.3533594608,
-0.3578802943,
0.0228962675,
-0.4003155828,
0.3347702026,
0.145508185,
0.5090295672,
0.217332378,
-0.1011428833,
0.482473433,
-0.2165381014,
-0.2010903805,
0.8472639322,
0.0941025987,
0.1379048824,
-0.1169203818,
-0.380009532,
0.1439165324,
-1.1714408398,
-0.2438049316,
0.3796733618,
0.4973455966,
0.023183547,
0.6750786304,
0.0289817471,
0.4137834609,
-0.4973846674,
-0.3126793206,
0.23849307,
-0.2958766222,
-0.1667986959,
-0.1276217401,
0.908377409,
0.6051167846,
0.7189062238,
-0.2805689573,
-0.5045966506,
-0.2187849581,
0.1117883772,
-0.6808126569,
0.1279610395,
0.1135468185,
-0.4829831719,
-0.4162760377,
-0.2177740037,
-0.7686620355,
-0.5606900454,
-0.6385961771,
0.1757071167,
-0.1835440099,
-0.227314353,
-0.1016722918,
0.154237479,
0.3075992465,
0.5352537632,
-0.9196386933,
0.3566597402,
0.7493063211,
0.9351260066,
-0.0087488741,
-0.1491580755,
-0.378888607,
0.3362820446,
-0.6508018374,
0.5172827244,
-0.5561251044,
-0.5179028511,
0.4634174705,
-0.133899644,
0.5100056529,
-0.2277468294,
0.7622507811,
-0.4723929465,
-0.0933635756,
-0.4575908184,
-0.6592543721,
-0.1688397676,
0.1554777473,
-0.612396121,
1.1930088997,
-0.343604058,
-0.6966866255,
0.1672074348,
-0.6821394563,
-0.3639601767,
0.2039285898,
-0.2830426395,
-0.3293911219,
0.2285760939,
-0.0302027036,
0.793040514,
-0.2458039075,
0.5712606311,
-0.3885688484,
-0.3377462327,
0.3532138467,
-0.3637288213,
0.662889421,
0.2228602767,
-0.2254805267,
0.1462642103,
-0.673750937,
-0.07988552,
0.2763892114,
-0.3708463609,
-0.4881783128,
0.149054274,
0.4330427945,
-0.1676360518,
0.2481533885,
-0.5005393624,
0.0852091461,
-0.1817755699,
0.5942521691,
0.8181059361,
-0.105222635,
0.2887474298,
-0.2904698253,
0.298679322,
-0.6142252684,
0.1228224412,
-0.372210592,
-0.2754047513,
-0.3795132935,
-0.2047161609,
0.3641187549,
0.3517886698,
-0.3563250005,
0.4716313183,
-0.1708830595,
-0.653049767,
-0.4147861004,
0.1781170964,
0.1261187941,
0.2258522063,
0.378372103,
0.1323801279,
-0.4945304692,
-0.855266571,
-0.2735133767,
-0.3266574442,
0.1916326582,
0.1310808659,
0.6789745092,
-0.3024064004,
0.8413891792,
-0.1596583426,
-0.0782104135,
-0.1543521136,
0.2845987678,
-0.1345386207,
0.3281705678,
0.3418848515,
-0.8045825362,
-0.2060465366,
-0.0707721114,
-0.854197979,
-0.3617539704,
-0.0247928593,
-0.0638728067,
0.3931670785,
0.6661866903,
-0.522593379,
0.2209361345,
0.7252329588,
0.0196283627,
0.4871927798,
-0.107255511,
0.0954014286,
-0.940385282,
0.2905494273,
0.2865420878,
-0.5174129009,
-0.5652706027,
0.1588954031,
0.1039277762,
0.2516610324,
-0.2282480597,
0.6307842135,
-0.4147599339,
0.2756551206,
-0.4180924594,
0.2028669417,
-0.051845666,
-0.2595764697,
0.0465539843,
0.7120399475,
0.2746870518,
-0.3417415619,
0.3340966702,
0.1623565257,
-0.2150627673,
0.3151520789,
-0.8165673018,
0.1603009254,
-0.2609919906,
0.2911454737,
-0.616458714,
-0.1497255713,
0.205286622,
-0.2859118581,
0.3899779618,
-0.1405503452,
-1.0303778648,
0.1341607273,
-0.4429144263,
0.3040792942,
0.6324186921,
-0.4337351918,
0.6344178319,
0.6729340553,
-0.2791164815,
-0.6407526135,
-0.7722898126,
0.4655840397,
-0.2954229414,
-0.4320980906,
0.2537173629,
0.0855441689,
-0.6107931733,
-0.2061752081,
0.2571728826,
-0.0093835434,
0.3349295557,
0.314452529,
0.3127118647,
0.0063410369,
0.1867161095,
-0.031684678,
-0.009024011,
0.0683004633,
0.218328923,
0.2906845212,
0.148271516,
-0.1612170339,
-0.1830625236,
0.5474210382,
0.6014697552,
-0.2652490735,
0.6145416498,
0.375018388,
-0.7072364092,
-0.141929239,
-0.8501541615,
-0.3376308084,
-0.3936257958,
0.2967345715,
0.1003796384,
-1.1123542786,
0.4477421045,
-0.313893497,
0.359703511,
0.3345556557,
0.5435260534,
-0.2062415928,
0.6762056947,
0.9782526493,
0.121292077,
0.3365269899,
0.2203652263,
0.2916073799,
-0.9682982564,
-0.2974586189,
-0.7662487626,
0.2296765596,
-0.6730252504,
-0.5705520511,
0.1765430421,
0.0698795691,
-0.2117337883,
0.0238496922,
-0.3155225813,
0.5635940433,
0.1909993738,
-0.368732512,
0.4418354928,
-0.0412733145,
-0.1275247037,
-0.2877972424,
-0.2887445986,
-1.4620814323,
0.9468882084,
0.7885557413,
1.0139248371,
-0.1246988922,
0.6601457,
0.063081257,
0.6013562083,
-0.6250072122,
0.721861124,
-0.0715641379,
-0.7631413341,
-0.4085846841,
-0.3508778512,
-0.707770884,
0.3190647662,
-0.27283445,
-0.8886461854,
-0.1970714033,
0.1383183599,
-0.1963539273,
0.2891614139,
-0.2851895094,
0.5378806591,
-0.1959259808,
-0.2346723825,
0.0934155062,
-0.6457563043,
0.3634774387,
-0.2795761228,
0.4925161302,
-0.324963361,
-0.2324068248,
0.7811608911,
-0.1020932272,
1.1958725452,
0.1309794784,
-0.2425715923,
0.2895774245,
0.0688264892,
0.8067096472,
0.0034295733,
-0.0549600869,
0.4178568125,
0.1520129293,
-0.1176086888,
-0.1078435779,
0.5963534713,
-0.592197299,
-0.5601858497,
-0.621317029,
-0.5896944404,
-0.0643940642,
0.0976109803,
-0.1372889578,
0.2501626313,
-0.2611109316,
0.2790825367,
0.8976710439,
-0.1850117743,
0.3796760142,
0.261900723,
-0.4335722327,
-0.4563062191,
0.5487521887,
0.3301999569,
0.2635427415,
0.0928088725,
0.1943433583,
-0.3371305764,
-0.8512468338,
-0.2234851271,
0.603190124,
-1.0912805796,
-0.0541795008,
-0.6095213294,
-0.1637313813,
-0.4675090909,
-0.2310246229,
-0.2944406867,
-0.1219407246,
-0.4787896276,
-0.2262996286,
0.6362801194,
0.7344250083,
0.1654980928,
0.1045911908,
-0.7090125084,
-0.0733772367,
-0.0941920057,
0.2568870187,
-0.2268698812,
-0.4036562741,
-0.1081113368,
-0.2052869201,
-0.0055103423,
-0.750594914,
0.179226473,
-0.0404514112,
0.7627087235,
0.1178273335,
0.1315634847,
0.3568082154,
-0.8361757398,
0.8448364735,
0.1387400031,
-0.9473376274,
0.3055490255,
-0.5720949173,
-0.1402201056,
0.5637102723,
0.6218678951,
-0.9212812185,
-0.6313260198,
-0.258933723,
-1.0174247026,
0.1279160678,
0.0483548231,
0.5848366022,
0.0862060338,
0.5410987139,
0.3348692358,
0.240496859,
-1.1906399727,
-0.1523447186,
0.122972101,
-0.4808956385,
0.0139565989,
-0.5372332335,
-0.3427948952,
0.078001,
0.6057537198,
-0.3225712478,
-0.2362120301,
0.1743705869,
-0.0658218488,
-0.2274393141,
0.2713060975,
0.5570876598,
1.0640013218,
0.0209140703,
0.2621818185,
0.2123651356,
-0.3848375678,
0.0723705515,
0.0753762946,
-0.4662174582,
0.0007168695,
0.4365408719,
0.3692777157,
0.1575641185,
-0.7466058731,
0.4014466703,
0.1172520667,
-0.1434880197,
-0.5280755758,
-0.1825940907,
0.2994835377,
0.1343617886,
0.3239170611,
-0.3934162855,
-0.0684068874,
-0.314824909,
-0.3301375806,
0.4411935508,
-0.1952832788,
-0.1467991471,
0.476906389,
0.3171918988,
-0.3010078669,
0.1451992393,
0.087272428,
-0.3611588776,
0.2367867678,
0.3278936446,
0.7223712206,
-0.0973636433,
0.2310994267,
0.136232093,
0.7890956998,
-0.5582889318,
0.2347592562,
0.2278997004,
-0.4209315181,
-0.8310554028,
-0.6785578132,
-0.5411512256,
0.1532771289,
-0.3783482015,
0.4462903738,
-0.5569799542,
-0.1765080988,
-0.0237285402,
0.0202749055,
-0.1866057217,
0.0990557671,
0.3910858929,
1.0518214703,
-0.9242357016,
0.759622097,
0.7299097776,
-0.3902145326,
-0.5878855586,
-0.1601422876,
0.1623087376,
-0.596255362,
0.6262514591,
0.1774252504,
-0.0944627076,
-0.2998330295,
-0.9189492464,
-0.7610251307,
0.9988607168,
0.2887732685,
-0.7744834423,
0.1281315088,
0.1291195005,
0.6023432016,
-0.3943090737,
0.1283392012,
0.2727808058,
0.5618002415,
0.1236440465,
-0.8816040754,
0.3301349878,
0.1563887447,
0.3428726494,
0.1280697882,
-0.5305047631,
0.6921606064,
-0.1207765266,
-0.0673080981,
0.2299592197,
0.5294465423,
0.3340263665,
0.3700906038,
0.2554086745,
0.2379621118,
0.8558998704,
-0.1081027165,
0.8776314855,
-0.0719896108,
0.3234380186,
0.8626000285,
-0.5011870861,
0.9383538961,
0.7882550359,
0.0393532775,
0.1088842973,
0.7997349501,
-0.0929985121,
0.0434696116,
0.4366918802,
-0.1304413825,
-0.3086428642,
-0.427326858,
-0.2058298737,
0.1680188328,
0.421972394,
-0.6346283555,
-0.0965533778,
-0.2697188258,
0.5580521226,
0.3819102049,
-0.2343880981,
0.6968699694,
0.3466651738,
-0.2838926911,
0.1141868979,
0.1178236455,
0.7552414536,
-0.5324651599,
-0.1295858026,
-0.0436562225,
-0.3540710509,
-0.1978726834,
-0.83983922,
0.189357385,
0.3902037144,
-0.0687153786,
-0.380389154,
0.7297299504,
-0.4373274446,
-0.5994318128,
0.3224794269,
0.3282687962,
0.1228322014,
0.1904368997,
-0.2701861262,
0.6114963293,
-0.3615336716,
-0.3701300323,
0.2549707592,
0.5473563075,
-0.1386929303,
0.6639513969,
0.6074018478,
0.4784731269,
-0.0780535638,
0.1263795048,
0.7047047615,
-0.7077682614,
-0.0247403868,
-1.0825885534,
0.5113701224,
-0.3266332746,
-0.4478126168,
0.6830249429,
0.1885351539,
0.6550400257,
0.476731807,
0.8073544502,
0.3368800879,
0.3557642102,
-0.6100780964,
0.7633931637,
-0.3188044727,
0.2583548725,
-0.270529598,
-1.0306169987,
-0.7592865825,
0.875356853,
-0.3116389811,
0.2108176649,
0.6499677896,
0.5251603127,
0.3946802914,
0.1316883266,
0.3688786626,
0.2524893284,
0.6702646613,
-0.1204845682,
0.8668330908,
-0.1886832565,
0.3410364687,
-0.0873654336,
-0.245930627,
-0.3761798739,
-1.3197453022,
-0.9521389008,
-0.4384779036,
-0.6250270009,
-0.231697455,
0.0156928264,
1.3636462688,
0.661233604,
-0.4087352455,
-0.3494334519,
0.2918671072,
-0.0694074258,
0.2035512477,
-0.1343859285,
0.0611731783,
-0.4817465842,
-0.6890877485,
0.0060984148,
0.5530467629,
0.3254903257,
-0.6581526995,
0.0049014259,
-0.0683161169,
0.3175114989,
0.6665617824,
0.1695391983,
-0.9339466691,
-0.5226733088,
-0.2286934257,
-0.4769736826,
-0.2387866527,
0.6757957935,
-0.1923841685,
0.2333443612,
0.1957965344,
0.7798847556,
-0.0109710693,
-0.2837508023,
0.5642757416,
-0.358134836,
-0.1451916546,
0.6791790724,
0.4830667377,
0.7611150146,
-0.2523085773,
0.4638717771,
-0.0407643616,
-0.9273959994,
-1.317356348,
0.0078302985,
-0.8659358621,
-0.1203853264,
1.5398597717,
-0.2875696123,
-0.2972212434,
-0.0844412893,
-0.2600761354,
0.0625549853,
-0.2894777656,
0.8761736751,
0.9278542399,
0.1556501836,
-0.2165091336,
-0.7436206341,
0.4929559231,
0.1233528331,
-0.8214168549,
0.507101655,
0.4672605991,
0.2010473609,
0.1554334462,
0.3163273633,
-0.418453902,
-0.1833967417,
-0.3429376781,
0.1359067112,
0.0550897121,
-0.1601128876,
-0.3970952928,
0.031154735,
0.5126281381,
0.3089580536
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03099v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03099v1
|
Intent-based Prompt Calibration: Enhancing prompt optimization with synthetic boundary cases
| 2024-02-05T15:28:43 | 2024-02-05T15:28:43 |
Elad Levi, Eli Brosh, Matan Friedmann
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Prompt engineering is a challenging and important task due to the high
sensitivity of Large Language Models (LLMs) to the given prompt and the
inherent ambiguity of a textual task instruction. Automatic prompt engineering
is essential to achieve optimized performance from LLMs. Recent studies have
demonstrated the capabilities of LLMs to automatically conduct prompt
engineering by employing a meta-prompt that incorporates the outcomes of the
last trials and proposes an improved prompt. However, this requires a
high-quality benchmark to compare different prompts, which is difficult and
expensive to acquire in many real-world use cases. In this work, we introduce a
new method for automatic prompt engineering, using a calibration process that
iteratively refines the prompt to the user intent. During the optimization
process, the system jointly generates synthetic data of boundary use cases and
optimizes the prompt according to the generated dataset. We demonstrate the
effectiveness of our method with respect to strong proprietary models on
real-world tasks such as moderation and generation. Our method outperforms
state-of-the-art methods with a limited number of annotated samples.
Furthermore, we validate the advantages of each one of the system's key
components. Our system is built in a modular way, facilitating easy adaptation
to other tasks. The code is available
$\href{https://github.com/Eladlev/AutoPrompt}{here}$.
|
[
-0.4044455588,
-0.772501111,
0.8917965293,
0.4133431613,
-0.076030761,
-0.2523676455,
-0.3281971216,
-0.0062780869,
-0.0590475425,
0.4791802764,
-1.1170885563,
-0.6521416306,
-0.0250857081,
0.3659491241,
0.3631495833,
0.6623060703,
-0.4533751309,
-0.0031031189,
-0.2373663187,
0.073868148,
-1.0685349703,
-0.1009731293,
-0.5302420259,
-0.1609327048,
0.3893827498,
0.4892402887,
0.2792349756,
0.4849670231,
0.0893586427,
0.302116096,
0.1955630779,
0.54490453,
-0.2700574696,
0.5634124279,
-0.1016028821,
-0.0955366045,
-0.2942894101,
0.0729120821,
0.4283550382,
0.4801923931,
0.0954398364,
0.3698570728,
0.3012132645,
0.5236081481,
-0.8940434456,
0.1819432974,
-0.4509634674,
-0.0821551383,
0.2093136311,
-0.5700294971,
-0.7499378324,
-0.598438859,
0.0995754376,
-0.8231500387,
-0.0483323447,
0.3184025884,
0.4228629172,
0.6299442649,
-0.4747140706,
-0.2731045187,
-0.482152462,
0.9004811645,
-0.6246427894,
0.394554466,
0.1678539962,
0.5517405868,
-0.4310836196,
-0.5384068489,
-0.3762986958,
-0.3914052546,
0.010882183,
0.146920681,
0.1623671949,
0.2765054107,
0.4050516784,
-0.094556585,
-0.8006931543,
0.0895572603,
-0.0476097688,
-0.6165877581,
0.5791441798,
0.3700899482,
0.4364830554,
-0.2101278156,
-0.4152603745,
-0.1415658742,
-0.5742576718,
0.4132478833,
0.5025157928,
0.572516799,
0.1479075849,
0.4947113395,
-0.3318995833,
0.8573570848,
0.2500787675,
0.1114912257,
0.3429053128,
-0.2687477767,
-0.0409754813,
0.0767041147,
0.7732706666,
0.6370161772,
0.0550774597,
0.1425196975,
-0.3277190626,
-0.0970213339,
0.277926445,
-0.8017405272,
-0.0006525203,
0.2683774233,
-0.0800694823,
0.0002913576,
-0.0767043605,
-0.5086200237,
-0.2705179751,
-0.7183663249,
0.5568476915,
-0.171422407,
0.1691171676,
0.1619506329,
0.0167262796,
0.1417238712,
0.5114229321,
-0.6034609079,
-0.0220859814,
0.5318241119,
0.6041017771,
-0.2693402171,
-0.1147418842,
-0.9368576407,
-0.1396259367,
-0.2277640253,
0.8183594942,
-0.4411845505,
-0.6035766602,
-0.1588376313,
0.0369473249,
-0.1488226354,
-0.4175281227,
0.9715566039,
-0.5372232199,
0.3065443635,
-0.3290737271,
-0.317664355,
-0.2169894725,
0.3248360157,
-0.6009426117,
0.959875524,
0.0743707567,
-0.2330217659,
0.1256660074,
-0.7158312201,
-0.1979075521,
0.196018219,
-0.1431187689,
-0.1524493545,
-0.0491904207,
0.2716032863,
0.1329542696,
-0.3640019298,
0.5977377295,
-0.0738577545,
-0.1796019375,
0.0287381448,
-0.4257437587,
0.7877895832,
0.2542386353,
-0.3081567883,
0.3430486917,
-0.4690683186,
0.3289887011,
-0.2639713883,
-0.085719727,
-0.2274353504,
-0.2471263409,
-0.1575575918,
0.0955185071,
0.4191054404,
-0.7738136053,
0.1760939509,
-0.4302785397,
0.1224407107,
0.764927268,
0.2983183563,
0.4081557989,
-0.4442331493,
0.6991257071,
-0.3011933267,
0.4629235268,
-0.4442340434,
-0.4466238618,
-0.3568671942,
-0.3067271113,
0.2286613733,
0.8127022982,
-0.715757072,
0.6742703319,
0.1286963224,
-0.3800496757,
-0.3033342659,
0.0024075229,
0.1499553472,
0.9366881251,
0.3468903303,
-0.0572622456,
-0.3909898996,
-0.7792193294,
-0.3256142735,
-0.153204307,
-0.0940038636,
0.7253291011,
0.0277747214,
-0.1972009242,
1.4073536396,
-0.6474061608,
-0.1498532444,
0.0427422449,
0.2229025662,
0.4011042118,
0.4675962627,
0.5501016378,
-0.654974401,
-0.6231475472,
-0.2558656037,
-0.5123960972,
-1.0085738897,
-0.3061521053,
-0.4715259671,
-0.0396821611,
0.3676973283,
-0.3976002038,
0.3053383529,
0.3557981551,
-0.3190774918,
0.8717625737,
-0.2365261912,
0.4110037386,
-0.7884305716,
0.1547506005,
0.1907264143,
-0.2498974502,
-0.4908594787,
-0.0215794947,
0.2889759243,
-0.1841585785,
-0.5525349379,
0.9300342202,
-0.3865680397,
0.4452281892,
-0.4997898042,
0.0645022914,
0.3110246062,
0.4962360859,
-0.0343352221,
0.8984459043,
0.4724698663,
-0.7099204063,
0.5428904891,
0.137551561,
0.0224543773,
0.6658304334,
-0.6460278034,
0.0142193679,
-0.0534285866,
0.4353692234,
-1.1059087515,
-0.1853411198,
0.3812003136,
-0.2314323783,
0.0516207889,
-0.0471045747,
-0.3425103128,
-0.2814778388,
-0.4774654806,
0.6793460846,
0.5697805882,
-0.5324693918,
0.872561574,
0.1270512491,
-0.4910216033,
-0.2924235463,
-0.1914696097,
-0.0059663258,
-0.1562390327,
-0.6367992759,
0.4818464518,
-0.5251510143,
0.065953888,
-0.402970612,
-0.1188655943,
0.1283236295,
0.0211507771,
0.3275761306,
0.3498711586,
-0.0549030676,
0.1290555149,
0.5148980618,
-0.3344734609,
0.2583627105,
-0.2426391244,
0.500377655,
0.1546129435,
-0.4800966084,
-0.761418283,
0.2907673419,
0.3852034211,
-0.1463396847,
0.0997138098,
0.2320330292,
-0.3701053858,
-0.6656692028,
-0.6336183548,
-0.3921737075,
-0.6386045814,
-0.0713235289,
-0.4883292019,
-0.5005092025,
0.5604982972,
-0.4882875383,
0.3673458397,
0.3770008683,
0.3448063135,
0.1992472559,
1.1223726273,
0.3901049495,
0.3444185257,
0.4857718647,
-0.0411630236,
0.0792106763,
-1.0031750202,
-0.2244943827,
-0.5605971217,
-0.2273819149,
-0.2792386115,
-0.2636998296,
0.6812211275,
-0.3803156912,
-0.2609802783,
0.3037822843,
-0.6398459077,
0.5110384226,
0.5985994935,
0.1944672316,
0.2658216655,
-0.1920187622,
-0.4445129931,
-0.2196496278,
-0.472181946,
-0.7899118662,
0.8450601697,
0.1985965073,
0.8195109367,
-0.3082773089,
0.6081723571,
0.4222067297,
0.2428052276,
-0.7610031366,
0.7049128413,
0.2302729934,
-0.2592995465,
-0.2609576881,
-0.5112457275,
-0.69645679,
0.0000198046,
0.0129812602,
-0.6059448719,
0.3813979924,
0.3473443389,
-0.7819151878,
-0.1964204013,
-0.9449262619,
0.9023570418,
-0.312053293,
-0.4579862654,
0.2739221752,
-0.5341706276,
0.0219840575,
-0.2228043228,
0.0843038037,
-0.232474938,
-0.1411991715,
0.4472772181,
-0.4311248064,
0.9120153189,
-0.5223824978,
-0.4935693145,
0.4089709818,
0.1244666129,
0.6820780039,
0.2399175018,
-0.549405098,
-0.3479383886,
-0.1202481538,
-0.0246918015,
-0.7739809155,
0.7888531685,
-0.3424840271,
-0.6787554026,
-0.1188788489,
-0.6080021262,
-0.3057800531,
0.2992547154,
0.196356073,
0.6440037489,
-0.1347522885,
-0.2425488085,
0.4966506958,
-0.3293900788,
0.4465259314,
0.5110584497,
-0.0041415445,
-0.3425634801,
0.7810376883,
-0.1602885425,
0.0574004576,
0.1430505961,
0.2169971168,
-0.5169201493,
-0.3610522747,
-0.6829769015,
0.0270068608,
-0.6809218526,
-0.4164909124,
-0.6451108456,
-0.1009681895,
-0.3933876455,
-0.389246583,
-0.1330997348,
-0.2877001464,
-0.466902703,
0.2635712028,
0.2391261607,
0.16838108,
0.1420772672,
0.4384315908,
-0.7400129437,
0.189102903,
0.235268414,
0.2495851219,
-0.3707987368,
-0.6148421168,
0.152446568,
0.2288215905,
-0.480361253,
-0.9062637687,
0.2663797736,
0.1299377829,
0.7674256563,
0.0629270151,
0.6386473775,
0.3311009109,
-0.6347687244,
0.6851767302,
-0.1746691912,
-0.9295414686,
0.7767910361,
-0.2404319942,
0.4665580392,
0.9287567139,
0.2488157153,
-0.3767237067,
-0.2195650041,
-0.2814282179,
-0.9813733697,
0.6259912252,
0.0323205665,
0.1351265609,
0.1995601058,
0.7538551092,
0.3836366832,
0.1209882051,
-0.4572223723,
-0.2232553512,
0.0567648821,
-0.6682186723,
0.2403735816,
-0.0253836717,
-0.0840214714,
-0.016549401,
0.8916273117,
-0.4404043853,
0.0314541459,
0.3050134778,
-0.3356217444,
-0.1840983331,
0.1187312901,
0.6371948719,
0.4665234089,
-0.0690069646,
-0.1389758438,
0.399854362,
-0.5376347303,
0.4467336535,
0.2271630466,
-0.4976884425,
0.0322175846,
-0.0613412783,
0.8890737295,
-0.1365982592,
-0.764274776,
0.5101447701,
-0.1800017059,
-0.0849693716,
-0.070053421,
0.334563911,
-0.5663378239,
0.283164084,
0.4661405385,
-0.0487258025,
0.5691279769,
-0.0641228408,
0.1954104006,
0.4392030537,
-0.216912508,
-0.3122652173,
0.4953502417,
0.5742200613,
-0.486503005,
0.2234362513,
-0.3726714849,
-0.4728792012,
0.5820614696,
0.4909580648,
1.2053617239,
-0.4042098224,
0.2813141644,
0.5132409334,
0.2609510422,
0.1715441048,
0.4080237746,
-0.2299022377,
-0.4209745228,
-0.6236166358,
-0.5185527205,
-0.6626054645,
-0.1088491306,
-0.2897278368,
0.5411463976,
-0.2698096037,
-0.4832638204,
-0.3795479238,
-0.0115064997,
-0.5180025101,
0.2810582817,
-0.0140273478,
0.9616521001,
-0.8574898243,
0.0167002454,
0.8396382332,
0.2453208566,
-0.6665845513,
0.0645399839,
-0.0871550292,
-0.5287287831,
0.5608211756,
0.4687277079,
-0.2800705135,
0.2766149938,
-0.2912727296,
-0.6912786365,
0.9576653838,
0.5074772239,
-0.5796337128,
-0.079326205,
0.0655071288,
0.2341288477,
-0.5385564566,
0.5609129667,
0.2459126264,
0.6793795228,
0.09364371,
-0.9221978188,
0.4512647092,
-0.2438135445,
0.0194408931,
0.1680941135,
-0.3701488674,
0.2710245252,
-0.1506739259,
-0.3845649362,
0.0574510992,
0.5611653328,
0.574721396,
0.4185806811,
0.7674723268,
0.1525561213,
0.5901905298,
-0.1934559047,
0.528061986,
-0.586890161,
0.2429138273,
1.001055479,
-0.5441020727,
0.2753522396,
0.5019789338,
0.2864465117,
0.443891257,
0.8655549884,
0.1899514943,
0.5702445507,
0.3470830023,
-0.4196896255,
-0.3204255104,
-0.3163734674,
-0.1351520419,
0.0069287773,
0.331255734,
-0.1712505221,
-0.419387579,
0.3627312183,
-0.4160088301,
0.026405653,
-0.1729528159,
0.7078200579,
-0.149467662,
-0.9662865996,
0.3816274107,
-0.0510542393,
0.5070846081,
-0.4382911921,
0.0062087905,
-0.0538062304,
-0.1533820182,
-0.1046166867,
-0.6309686303,
-0.0457961485,
0.0034827024,
0.0645761341,
-0.488190949,
0.6881667376,
-0.2667235434,
-0.2226879001,
-0.0999286324,
0.3975887001,
-0.1470657885,
-0.2133177221,
-0.5353608131,
0.1817029417,
-0.0203725323,
-0.5493602157,
-0.3741590977,
0.5495688915,
-0.0623562559,
0.559253037,
0.637484014,
0.0271725617,
-0.1384505928,
0.1342090219,
0.8672293425,
-0.482016176,
-0.6447356939,
-0.845949173,
0.7439591885,
-0.0382753871,
-0.3385106325,
0.4648964703,
0.6776766777,
0.4342710674,
0.071725741,
0.752923429,
0.2161744833,
0.3383564651,
-0.6087927818,
0.2451032698,
-0.4056384563,
0.3293491602,
-0.0894676894,
-1.1502497196,
-0.3460329771,
0.5460903645,
-0.5330966115,
0.2450953871,
0.6051207781,
0.9408222437,
-0.1191141605,
0.0552638173,
-0.0260164551,
-0.2540243864,
0.4269685745,
0.4499526024,
0.7297620773,
-0.3125887513,
0.2631532848,
-0.1432943791,
-0.6306586862,
-0.3303217292,
-1.1473914385,
-0.5936085582,
-0.629658699,
-0.4997208416,
-0.0812813118,
-0.0215639211,
1.3085782528,
0.6805887818,
-0.619330287,
-0.0971512347,
-0.1035847515,
-0.0919479057,
0.0497723408,
-0.2696233988,
0.1664415747,
-0.623121202,
-0.7936541438,
0.5016252995,
0.2897530794,
0.2513461411,
-0.2102507353,
-0.0409690514,
0.2311014384,
0.320315361,
0.476028353,
0.2323348522,
-0.4790281951,
-0.1803012192,
0.4119147956,
-0.1976614147,
-0.1089256555,
0.7352250218,
-0.9349938035,
0.5095416307,
0.7502669692,
0.6662662029,
0.0805865601,
0.2352070063,
0.8241546154,
-0.8172232509,
-0.2527077794,
0.406629622,
0.2648816407,
0.2867596149,
-0.6466662884,
0.2304143608,
-0.0715280026,
-0.7408818603,
-0.9800669551,
0.2776842117,
-0.950668931,
0.0043674065,
1.212952733,
0.0532113723,
-0.3010135591,
-0.0066429204,
-0.8513025045,
0.3486972153,
-0.6403714418,
0.7592084408,
0.4701515436,
-0.2134475261,
0.0410603993,
-0.5428782701,
0.4923720062,
0.4969688654,
-0.9779247642,
0.1721345186,
0.704687953,
0.0207599364,
0.0684628189,
0.3241420984,
0.2340402007,
0.4946450591,
-0.7358037233,
0.1588503867,
-0.1860865504,
-0.3820323646,
-0.2878578603,
0.0466378368,
-0.1254347116,
-0.2283539772
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03407v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03407v1
|
Enhancing the Stability of LLM-based Speech Generation Systems through Self-Supervised Representations
| 2024-02-05T15:08:19 | 2024-02-05T15:08:19 |
Álvaro Martín-Cortinas, Daniel Sáez-Trigueros, Iván Vallés-Pérez, Biel Tura-Vecino, Piotr Biliński, Mateusz Lajszczak, Grzegorz Beringer, Roberto Barra-Chicote, Jaime Lorenzo-Trueba
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are one of the most promising technologies for
the next era of speech generation systems, due to their scalability and
in-context learning capabilities. Nevertheless, they suffer from multiple
stability issues at inference time, such as hallucinations, content skipping or
speech repetitions. In this work, we introduce a new self-supervised Voice
Conversion (VC) architecture which can be used to learn to encode transitory
features, such as content, separately from stationary ones, such as speaker ID
or recording conditions, creating speaker-disentangled representations. Using
speaker-disentangled codes to train LLMs for text-to-speech (TTS) allows the
LLM to generate the content and the style of the speech only from the text,
similarly to humans, while the speaker identity is provided by the decoder of
the VC model. Results show that LLMs trained over speaker-disentangled
self-supervised representations provide an improvement of 4.7pp in speaker
similarity over SOTA entangled representations, and a word error rate (WER)
5.4pp lower. Furthermore, they achieve higher naturalness than human recordings
of the LibriTTS test-other dataset. Finally, we show that using explicit
reference embedding negatively impacts intelligibility (stability), with WER
increasing by 14pp compared to the model that only uses text to infer the
style.
|
[
-0.3220444918,
-0.4850105941,
0.3515872955,
0.3198237717,
-0.2706110179,
0.0594175383,
-0.4511555135,
-0.0808811411,
0.1592568457,
0.5848481655,
-0.3927415311,
-0.3876329362,
-0.4740914702,
0.3113840818,
-0.548376739,
0.6390038133,
0.4408426285,
0.2120042443,
-0.4462426007,
0.120354861,
-0.1934659481,
-0.7314268351,
-0.4688180089,
-0.2649082243,
0.1714684218,
0.1856659949,
0.421226114,
0.5211533904,
0.0542652719,
0.4384115338,
-0.009904135,
0.3267887533,
-0.628002882,
0.4720479548,
0.0426261798,
-0.1376803964,
-0.2956645191,
-0.1244268715,
0.7319425941,
0.3247188926,
-0.4582589865,
0.0316203311,
0.4626235068,
0.445337534,
-0.3899382949,
0.2905549705,
-0.8234277368,
-0.133547008,
-0.1950974762,
-0.406306833,
-0.8673315048,
-0.1536334604,
0.0576268882,
-0.3075081706,
0.0242187828,
-0.2364174873,
0.4999346733,
0.688991189,
-0.2651813626,
-0.1455311328,
-0.8293364048,
0.4014821649,
-0.7541962266,
0.6426013708,
0.3859144151,
0.2848718166,
-0.3691851795,
-0.4712498486,
-0.5281940699,
-0.1615686417,
0.0690737069,
0.3481375873,
-0.0292548221,
0.1099744216,
-0.0033478013,
0.0460865311,
-0.2786881328,
0.3254929185,
-0.2482847571,
-0.3085910678,
0.6627876163,
-0.108449772,
-0.1009421125,
-0.3619883657,
-0.2853711843,
-0.2457701266,
-0.7724712491,
-0.1402528733,
0.3664426506,
0.5671727061,
-0.124107115,
0.3202366531,
0.1118482426,
0.3762620389,
0.6809898615,
-0.2935319245,
0.3691048324,
0.0496670045,
-0.1026205793,
0.6500862241,
0.9676116705,
0.2741593122,
0.1200469509,
-0.2162310481,
0.0286748055,
-0.1404156685,
0.1814322621,
-0.9050929546,
-0.0271655284,
0.0938176364,
-0.3859067559,
-0.0831069201,
0.12029396,
-0.5194560289,
-0.2738168836,
-0.1896734089,
0.2887524366,
-0.4517497718,
-0.3377995789,
0.1450215876,
0.2887023687,
0.0638985634,
0.1804569662,
-1.2173249722,
0.1958511472,
0.2805455625,
0.6162211299,
-0.1338314414,
-0.233174786,
-0.6815946698,
0.5501800776,
-0.4574784338,
0.2235028595,
-0.1950616986,
-0.479616493,
0.0918428674,
0.0051058759,
0.0724010691,
-0.5920683742,
0.1927251518,
-0.4494523108,
0.0351260491,
0.0383528359,
-0.63892591,
0.2154346108,
-0.1553259641,
-0.4890355766,
0.7634854913,
-0.2244048715,
-0.5564928055,
0.105729647,
-0.1220483184,
-0.2122288197,
-0.1218399853,
-0.5466760993,
-0.5437621474,
0.2857797146,
0.2169360965,
0.733328402,
0.0442379899,
0.4744439125,
-0.2602577507,
-0.3553668261,
0.1835862994,
-0.6149030924,
0.4567900598,
0.2143688798,
-0.4365547001,
-0.2574957609,
-0.8801854849,
-0.1513380259,
0.080266051,
-0.5065187216,
-0.1954135448,
0.2422812432,
-0.2522975504,
0.1525819749,
0.2151590437,
-0.5618329644,
0.049262248,
-0.3847281337,
0.5392124653,
0.7510868907,
-0.0234324895,
0.3170431256,
-0.0353195295,
0.2552503347,
0.2267186344,
-0.2022178322,
-0.2427233309,
-0.3411007524,
-0.8373530507,
-0.0513761602,
0.2911145091,
0.2780654132,
-0.7707193494,
0.7147732377,
-0.4892446995,
-0.2993421555,
-0.702421248,
0.1537331492,
0.2880665362,
0.4609629214,
0.282798022,
-0.0957228765,
-0.5244489908,
-0.7342997193,
0.1820426583,
-0.4605730772,
-0.0095715038,
-0.0646520481,
0.0576115511,
-0.382535547,
0.987454474,
0.1241191179,
-0.2886424959,
0.0605830289,
0.0497676358,
0.045545876,
0.5521650314,
0.500616014,
-0.6376674771,
-0.2841420472,
-0.1211857498,
-0.5133545399,
-0.1601273268,
-0.1767681092,
0.1726333052,
0.3572888374,
0.6855900288,
-0.426356703,
0.2511023283,
0.977784574,
-0.0421841629,
0.1421612799,
-0.2817950845,
-0.0237396732,
-1.145860672,
-0.3179522157,
-0.0889679566,
-0.4301479161,
-0.4721798301,
-0.5314031243,
0.0534311309,
-0.0725742057,
-0.4427611828,
-0.0045176162,
-0.4342835248,
0.008742393,
-0.19734478,
0.3258972764,
0.0142329205,
0.2407078445,
0.159589529,
0.9465677142,
0.5990459919,
-0.6608152986,
0.3264629245,
0.3465184867,
0.0875558332,
0.3243501186,
-0.4330648184,
0.4234991074,
-0.2920194268,
0.1807862818,
-0.7876788974,
-0.0700639859,
-0.0862362832,
-0.6620469689,
0.7138885856,
-0.1520365924,
-0.6056833863,
-0.0505128205,
-0.1169008464,
0.0387078375,
0.6210211515,
-0.8779920936,
0.622380197,
0.4115989804,
0.1071256623,
-0.3079634309,
-0.9753851891,
0.1462808102,
-0.1589782536,
-0.5700212121,
0.5700430274,
-0.1025972143,
-0.0018841079,
-0.0245744698,
-0.1043107733,
0.255749613,
-0.0562190264,
0.4585871398,
-0.0159240309,
-0.0604290478,
0.4598143399,
0.1735052466,
-0.2020135075,
0.0820689052,
-0.2896381021,
0.4957632422,
-0.10940779,
-0.367679745,
-0.4795324802,
0.2390434444,
0.5653505921,
-0.2096087337,
0.672318995,
0.5233444571,
-0.1318996549,
-0.4192345738,
-0.5815675259,
-0.1919261217,
-0.5961834192,
0.3791866601,
-0.4104564786,
-1.2518049479,
0.4252549708,
-0.166422382,
-0.1981436908,
0.3946188092,
0.8129719496,
-0.3035692573,
0.828192234,
0.4500143528,
-0.1745073646,
0.3663385808,
-0.2160437554,
0.0284692794,
-0.7532051206,
-0.3546027243,
-0.2629537284,
0.1017285809,
-0.904094696,
-0.5600479245,
0.2195951492,
-0.0700100511,
-0.2927696705,
0.2353166044,
-0.7594610453,
0.0017812127,
0.4128867388,
0.0197669733,
0.2276646495,
0.1859821826,
0.1072743014,
-0.2099917084,
-0.6306740642,
-0.6264701486,
0.8988976479,
0.5429985523,
1.0524576902,
0.0950524211,
1.1197607517,
0.2839291692,
-0.1842727363,
-0.4320777953,
0.6035042405,
-0.5039057732,
-0.3348794878,
-0.4081622064,
-0.522834301,
-0.8027898669,
0.1276402473,
-0.2887543738,
-0.6768574715,
0.246276632,
0.2049006075,
-0.3591567278,
0.143222034,
-0.5815478563,
0.2780432999,
-0.47325629,
-0.4683820903,
-0.054514654,
-0.458373338,
0.0199708063,
-0.0435849018,
0.079546012,
0.0087938122,
0.1734367907,
0.7380330563,
-0.2302370816,
1.0130716562,
-0.1750288755,
-0.4637974203,
0.4615148306,
0.046381101,
0.3153799176,
0.2079357356,
-0.3281214833,
0.2585816085,
-0.1332119256,
0.1354937851,
-0.6670165658,
0.9518319964,
-1.0827959776,
-0.877317965,
-0.1804139614,
-0.1673702598,
-0.3348594606,
0.0441610739,
0.2197060883,
0.4822915196,
-0.0832666904,
0.6314880252,
0.8636012673,
0.087623395,
0.5117256045,
0.3182092309,
-0.3126117587,
-0.6278796792,
0.8241111636,
0.3012146354,
0.4778209031,
0.2709593475,
0.0797175542,
-0.6428532004,
-0.6985549331,
-0.4629445672,
0.1320123076,
-0.6857176423,
-0.138761133,
-0.3368968666,
-0.5334317088,
-0.56867522,
0.3189285994,
-0.7019742131,
-0.2538892329,
-0.7687141299,
-0.2641378641,
0.2731464803,
0.6808314323,
-0.1876445711,
0.4032049179,
-0.7792502642,
0.2550902963,
0.6091169119,
0.201371938,
-0.3203715384,
-0.7587287426,
-0.3669608235,
-0.0914546028,
-0.321279794,
-0.9189684391,
0.3011223376,
0.4340726137,
0.5387197137,
0.4451931119,
0.1910735816,
0.89719069,
-0.6464290023,
0.6798063517,
0.2968230546,
-1.0885213614,
0.5473499894,
-0.4351607263,
0.0928871706,
0.6538952589,
-0.0537002794,
-0.2375006527,
-0.3675196171,
-0.4414028525,
-0.5267222524,
0.6554900408,
0.2755627036,
0.4595476985,
-0.0663670897,
0.4670209587,
-0.0414459333,
0.1661575437,
-0.7986095548,
-0.348179698,
-0.7303515673,
-0.2750448883,
-0.103654623,
-0.4322681427,
0.065310061,
-0.1279610991,
0.6269285083,
-0.2839088738,
0.1730085313,
0.34641698,
0.2711602151,
-0.1290058047,
0.2115232646,
0.4218384922,
0.3067903519,
-0.3116118908,
0.4679462612,
0.1786142886,
-0.3060615659,
0.4346937239,
0.0582999997,
-0.0569496825,
0.1163189188,
0.1600532085,
0.888572216,
0.1942287385,
-0.4122460783,
0.386611253,
-0.1696305424,
-0.0927146748,
-0.4494991899,
0.065938063,
0.4373935759,
0.1977229267,
0.370747298,
-0.2022324502,
-0.0395298302,
-0.3769752085,
0.2272761017,
0.3494158387,
-0.2237762958,
-0.2718459368,
0.7717074752,
0.4997296929,
-0.2903712392,
0.4657955766,
-0.1590227485,
-0.1119565517,
0.1154811308,
0.9406428933,
0.9934696555,
-0.6155849099,
0.184555918,
0.2404818833,
0.2652161717,
-0.0539093763,
-0.0691140965,
-0.1955526173,
-0.6738386154,
-0.2757946253,
-0.6309741735,
-0.2871767879,
0.0722536668,
-0.6016569734,
0.248722747,
-0.3908736408,
-0.590415597,
-0.64133358,
-0.3803094029,
-0.2480688393,
0.1530328244,
0.6140776277,
0.3988445997,
-0.6862547398,
1.0803500414,
0.3604063392,
0.0236973707,
-0.8494944572,
0.0941135213,
-0.2071000487,
-0.538859427,
0.6573588848,
0.2631480992,
-0.6545870304,
0.1199581772,
-0.4306383729,
-1.1196345091,
1.2731331587,
0.981741488,
-1.1060841084,
0.0467798077,
0.3076980412,
0.4894267619,
-0.4805553257,
-0.0507138446,
0.3998874724,
0.0626621991,
0.2946890891,
-1.0187203884,
-0.0794546902,
-0.1525622308,
0.2677327693,
-0.2097325474,
-0.7961664796,
0.646061182,
0.1448360831,
-0.375172466,
-0.1347651482,
0.9851278663,
0.6126263142,
0.0233338177,
0.4490690529,
0.5735335946,
0.6241317391,
-0.0804676265,
0.4817799628,
-0.5127491355,
0.4162033498,
1.2138451338,
-0.1121923253,
0.9046238065,
0.6997327805,
-0.0438295119,
0.5500716567,
0.3524243832,
0.0157357547,
0.7493617535,
0.1974792928,
-0.0396324024,
-0.6507671475,
0.0639953762,
-0.5335096121,
0.7985973358,
0.3296954632,
-0.5165068507,
-0.0427731052,
0.0576883405,
-0.1263791323,
0.4129320681,
-0.0686797947,
0.6993401051,
0.2614189088,
-0.2276746482,
0.7954800725,
-0.3885557353,
0.7142376304,
-0.6773204803,
-0.0541978106,
0.1723281592,
0.1271598935,
-0.249097839,
-0.5186299086,
0.1420788765,
-0.0595308766,
-0.2212994099,
-0.3383818865,
0.5938313007,
-0.5013716817,
-0.5266481042,
0.6600863934,
0.3950626254,
0.0257173274,
0.3732277751,
-0.3738811314,
0.4463678598,
-0.0013442102,
-0.2941706479,
0.2918574512,
0.618945837,
0.2812390029,
0.6272596717,
0.3511474133,
0.1717960387,
0.3109845817,
0.2181791216,
0.9402710199,
-0.4046188593,
-0.4747579694,
-1.0627354383,
0.4068056345,
-0.0344302095,
0.0901659504,
0.9818845987,
0.3923337758,
0.6982545257,
0.1024744585,
0.7216348052,
0.0973837078,
0.2024737149,
-0.753303349,
0.9010013938,
-0.4137954712,
0.4193265736,
-0.2947229743,
-0.7084416151,
-0.0568071865,
0.5755819678,
0.00954537,
0.1301573217,
0.1668610424,
0.6303354502,
0.3591929078,
-0.2440202981,
0.6572813392,
0.3119727373,
0.586143434,
0.2090412229,
0.9070458412,
-0.309366554,
0.591580987,
-0.2801940441,
0.0300861709,
-0.1376238465,
-0.8332777619,
-1.0967336893,
-0.7495753765,
-0.3761040866,
-0.308245182,
0.1443112642,
0.8809657097,
0.9278663397,
-0.602099061,
-0.2694820464,
-0.03934725,
-0.346832186,
0.224108398,
-0.1129904613,
0.3172443509,
-0.2819375992,
-0.7106091976,
0.7168292999,
0.4798091352,
0.3157198727,
-0.6745308042,
-0.4610658586,
0.2209049314,
0.0231454279,
0.4451136887,
-0.0394121148,
-0.8458730578,
-0.4383729398,
-0.0771089196,
-0.0444423072,
0.2505246997,
0.3187045455,
-0.8691234589,
0.8014885187,
0.1414478421,
0.6863461137,
0.6897946,
0.2306881845,
0.3521569073,
-0.810994029,
0.236419633,
0.2918021083,
0.3991399705,
0.5577648878,
-0.3899564743,
-0.0359005295,
0.0320369862,
-0.6926772594,
-0.5860564113,
0.1051979661,
-1.024056673,
0.1023171395,
1.0497329235,
-0.1695359647,
-0.389124006,
0.1026998013,
-0.064475745,
0.4203497171,
-0.6425794363,
0.8305881619,
0.2886019349,
-0.2289383113,
-0.3901998997,
-0.0932323635,
0.446796447,
0.296115905,
-0.4962542057,
0.2578617036,
0.4393224716,
0.0969208702,
0.611369729,
0.6714464426,
-0.1325874776,
0.0314810313,
-0.0895566121,
0.0760475844,
-0.3506522179,
-0.3016438782,
-0.4058409631,
0.0908926576,
0.2161245942,
-0.4796940386
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03067v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03067v1
|
Multilingual transformer and BERTopic for short text topic modeling: The case of Serbian
| 2024-02-05T14:59:29 | 2024-02-05T14:59:29 |
Darija Medvecki, Bojana Bašaragin, Adela Ljajić, Nikola Milošević
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper presents the results of the first application of BERTopic, a
state-of-the-art topic modeling technique, to short text written in a
morphologi-cally rich language. We applied BERTopic with three multilingual
embed-ding models on two levels of text preprocessing (partial and full) to
evalu-ate its performance on partially preprocessed short text in Serbian. We
also compared it to LDA and NMF on fully preprocessed text. The experiments
were conducted on a dataset of tweets expressing hesitancy toward COVID-19
vaccination. Our results show that with adequate parameter setting, BERTopic
can yield informative topics even when applied to partially pre-processed short
text. When the same parameters are applied in both prepro-cessing scenarios,
the performance drop on partially preprocessed text is minimal. Compared to LDA
and NMF, judging by the keywords, BERTopic offers more informative topics and
gives novel insights when the number of topics is not limited. The findings of
this paper can be significant for re-searchers working with other
morphologically rich low-resource languages and short text.
|
[
-0.5376803875,
-0.8717682958,
0.4520386457,
0.3307852745,
-0.6185505986,
-0.0489715673,
-0.4066427946,
-0.4359356165,
0.7103543878,
0.2758594155,
-0.5609576702,
-0.4735957384,
-0.6056604981,
0.1532850862,
-0.3454037309,
1.161659956,
0.0528254136,
-0.044178687,
-0.0993251279,
0.145887211,
-0.1815739721,
-0.6438481808,
-0.1463870406,
-0.1460291147,
0.5313766599,
0.5879094005,
0.6882898808,
-0.0303592328,
0.449164331,
0.1521442831,
-0.1959840506,
-0.3551171422,
-0.2972947955,
0.3689294755,
-0.3836759031,
-0.3291675746,
-0.3093627393,
-0.1214479581,
0.556710124,
0.4759781659,
0.0545984022,
0.0943213552,
-0.2364734709,
0.4340778887,
-0.3729522526,
0.0386780798,
-0.6060657501,
0.1104651093,
-0.4941189587,
-0.2468634844,
-0.4258565307,
-0.1368944198,
0.595708549,
-0.3318594694,
0.2152427435,
-0.1631467938,
0.8153756261,
0.0941019729,
-0.2697775662,
-0.4022112489,
-0.4685763717,
0.9327573776,
-0.853515625,
0.1386419982,
0.271345675,
0.1221366748,
0.1028450131,
-0.6802055836,
-0.3554843366,
-0.0932491794,
0.0446618088,
0.1611063778,
-0.4892958403,
0.0574374869,
0.0079864915,
0.0547049902,
-0.63804847,
0.074035503,
-0.5258253813,
-0.2370866835,
0.4642847776,
-0.1043889001,
0.3634441197,
-0.5164206624,
-0.100860782,
0.1019468009,
-0.4887511432,
-0.1367768794,
0.4129897952,
0.5347645879,
-0.0753761604,
0.6786581874,
-0.1281985193,
0.7019186616,
-0.1799532622,
-0.3422635794,
0.3273068666,
-0.5323858261,
0.0476556122,
-0.00467228,
0.490750581,
-0.0984573588,
0.1602416933,
-0.151047796,
0.1572678536,
-0.1903811842,
0.4375920594,
-1.0168136358,
-0.3960113525,
0.0034567569,
-0.774535358,
-0.137170285,
0.0215515606,
-1.1843098402,
0.1005894542,
0.0671545491,
0.3345952928,
-0.3635136783,
0.1560958922,
0.001346795,
0.0583739579,
-0.0232735388,
0.2595663071,
-1.0065227747,
0.1073393822,
0.5958880782,
0.950751245,
-0.2209350914,
-0.1207083091,
-0.1802471876,
0.0096507333,
-0.1954422295,
0.9126508236,
-0.719743073,
-0.1787942648,
0.2034289092,
-0.0353757702,
0.0275525972,
-0.2152120322,
0.9409473538,
-0.5087452531,
0.5245360732,
-0.1051832512,
-0.2787417173,
-0.1659124345,
0.326746285,
-0.7967972159,
0.9429262877,
-0.0515652038,
-1.2256611586,
0.438035965,
-0.730416894,
-0.5443379879,
-0.0003154383,
-0.0559989847,
-0.4788298309,
-0.022433022,
0.3015647829,
0.6301378012,
-0.237485975,
0.4260111451,
-0.1876361221,
-0.2294715941,
-0.0814647973,
-0.3970786333,
0.3776246309,
0.1319478452,
-0.2080224305,
0.2809504271,
-0.4277297258,
-0.0172830801,
-0.0783372894,
-0.3651641309,
-0.587659955,
0.2173690349,
0.3482263088,
0.4781153202,
0.3920178711,
-0.5625649095,
0.3191480041,
-0.6167145371,
0.4057871401,
0.2633450031,
0.0829701126,
0.4565747678,
-0.1645553857,
0.6191987395,
0.0241964664,
0.1365742683,
-0.2353123277,
-1.0181201696,
-0.4729939699,
-0.3916755915,
0.5429504514,
0.5776093602,
-1.1057554483,
0.1405977905,
-0.0547413602,
-0.5777235031,
-0.4623191059,
-0.2689731121,
0.1961377114,
0.2516871691,
0.1721960753,
-0.1965743452,
-0.6388029456,
-1.1284062862,
0.0418245457,
-0.2479836494,
0.2047479302,
0.2479992509,
0.6553143859,
-0.3772466779,
0.857694149,
-0.4207651615,
-0.0381989777,
-0.5900807977,
0.5597281456,
0.433927536,
0.3449368477,
1.1000858545,
-1.0935024023,
-0.7062616944,
-0.2159671634,
-0.0699513033,
-0.224188447,
0.0738131031,
-0.0992868245,
0.5180467367,
-0.0811193511,
-0.4633698761,
0.4257932603,
0.7893519402,
-0.306663394,
0.566482842,
-0.3809100688,
0.1258918643,
-1.4085564613,
0.1235489845,
0.0309940856,
-0.2202212065,
-0.9759774804,
-0.054082185,
-0.0903159454,
-0.5020911098,
-0.5688550472,
0.515566349,
-0.0835795924,
-0.0879516155,
-0.391518265,
0.0713929832,
-0.1215662137,
0.1874178648,
0.1329774559,
0.9854776859,
0.5032978058,
-0.3779018521,
0.1919561028,
0.4344756305,
-0.4008791447,
-0.0854117274,
-0.5745584965,
-0.3013896942,
-0.0979339927,
0.1248445213,
-0.8956583738,
-0.2741451859,
0.5967975855,
-0.2226200104,
0.1323300749,
-0.2855275273,
-0.6907355189,
-0.3528542221,
-0.4182349741,
0.5047696829,
0.4249449968,
-0.2613492906,
0.2772120237,
0.3328540623,
-0.8747136593,
-0.5191676617,
-0.6507171392,
0.1251216233,
-0.2297356576,
-0.8032040596,
0.7122984529,
-0.2082170248,
-0.1684767306,
0.0318896584,
0.1344447881,
-0.6195089221,
0.1827056706,
-0.1507912427,
0.1660095304,
-0.1172419786,
0.2781473398,
0.2719591856,
-0.0625658706,
-0.1781681776,
-0.1265242249,
0.7121197581,
-0.1433735788,
-0.0909416676,
-0.2699445784,
0.8034616113,
0.3581525087,
-0.1210836545,
0.911557138,
0.6288118958,
-0.3109126985,
0.1085860655,
-0.3253737092,
-0.0700686276,
-0.2643724978,
0.3791899681,
-0.2530623376,
-0.7778908014,
0.6560720801,
0.0858920962,
-0.190431118,
0.6411903501,
0.7618027925,
-0.0410869047,
0.5653806329,
1.0979568958,
-0.164837122,
0.6376270056,
-0.0026963761,
0.5170010924,
-0.2188961655,
-0.2421999872,
-0.6904041767,
-0.0630683973,
-0.8841916323,
-0.511310041,
0.3493887484,
-0.0361065865,
0.3969684839,
0.3874299228,
-0.2918041646,
0.1271383464,
0.5847822428,
0.0046289437,
-0.107536301,
-0.0048448234,
0.0543218218,
-0.3897052705,
-0.9409642816,
-0.6885721684,
0.7324665189,
0.197403878,
0.7224007845,
-0.0324544162,
0.8287944794,
0.3355702162,
0.1518445909,
-0.8849270344,
0.2812229991,
-0.5184295774,
-0.8239756227,
-0.4757907093,
-0.0779903084,
-0.6088362336,
0.433274895,
-0.2827902734,
-0.7448800206,
0.3796070516,
0.0591508485,
-0.2260864377,
0.2711857557,
-0.5300444365,
1.01486516,
-0.2460098863,
-0.0188827366,
-0.2609552741,
-0.6953066587,
0.1239351109,
-0.304969281,
0.109137021,
-0.3187352419,
-0.1190198585,
0.9624243379,
0.0422624126,
0.7124221325,
-0.0482817739,
-0.0697854161,
0.1141803116,
-0.2968973219,
0.0975354165,
0.313809514,
-0.2502696216,
0.1995225549,
0.1547336429,
-0.4785570204,
-0.3670361042,
0.4325578213,
-0.4290843308,
-0.6511085033,
-0.6305861473,
-0.436834842,
0.0939100161,
0.3908343315,
0.3600680828,
0.2598369718,
-0.4162378907,
0.2514486313,
0.6947315335,
-0.4475938678,
0.5150161982,
0.3365193307,
-0.0581497997,
-0.2034445405,
0.6919406652,
0.045393236,
-0.0311364848,
0.6470866799,
0.3184603453,
0.2129495144,
-0.5531324744,
-0.235630542,
0.240400821,
-0.5520605445,
-0.2825553417,
-0.6717761755,
-0.1149513572,
-0.4638047516,
-0.2864293456,
-0.3868903518,
-0.5052434206,
-0.6231826544,
0.2000121772,
0.1227808297,
0.4635049403,
-0.2190086693,
0.2687318921,
-0.707042098,
0.5094602108,
0.006429025,
0.1405183226,
-0.3197676837,
-0.4133858085,
-0.4260365069,
0.1390542388,
-0.3113841414,
-1.0161335468,
0.8480632901,
0.4024987519,
0.6435834765,
0.2998932302,
0.1101358086,
0.375882864,
-0.6322191954,
0.8868529201,
0.0027234808,
-1.0754562616,
0.8112906218,
-0.3033948243,
0.1710605025,
0.5654600263,
0.7147147059,
-0.541513145,
-0.30920735,
-0.4605085254,
-1.1067146063,
0.837231636,
0.3785205781,
0.2913381457,
-0.0872361809,
0.1895615906,
0.5211408734,
0.2574192286,
-0.7023585439,
-0.2622454464,
-0.3792951107,
-0.0634903461,
-0.1303334832,
-1.0840872526,
0.0564422607,
-0.1934639961,
0.8072343469,
-0.1106551066,
0.5685536861,
0.0121865058,
-0.1581967324,
0.2334921062,
0.759006083,
0.9709889889,
0.89508003,
-0.3817805648,
-0.0048299264,
-0.0791281909,
-0.3369256258,
-0.0680459887,
0.363776207,
-0.2402344942,
0.602324307,
0.4235633314,
0.5920515656,
0.5765810013,
-0.6417604685,
0.6602640748,
-0.0644739866,
-0.1825525314,
-0.2687670887,
-0.49512887,
-0.1181121469,
0.2409825623,
0.464345783,
-0.1184212714,
0.3572142422,
-0.7805461884,
0.3440001011,
0.1968611032,
-0.0467723273,
-0.5898700953,
0.3518936336,
0.3427942693,
-0.0465745963,
0.3468280137,
-0.0212732591,
-0.8902029991,
0.5853930116,
0.5822674632,
0.6211050153,
-0.0183147546,
0.6803016067,
0.0838783905,
0.2056025118,
-0.0125534041,
0.5005930662,
-0.1994058639,
-0.5429847836,
-0.5143049359,
-0.3610442281,
-0.5462024808,
-0.1404427588,
-0.8608870506,
0.0501173995,
0.1718580723,
-0.3091560304,
0.2743305266,
0.2491533011,
-0.2837983072,
0.0234638732,
0.089766711,
1.0896803141,
-1.0550833941,
1.0263377428,
0.83199054,
-0.3069656193,
-0.077427648,
0.5297966599,
-0.5749611855,
-0.3815936446,
0.8997562528,
0.0208589397,
0.2204076499,
-0.4891815782,
-0.2168265581,
-1.0359181166,
0.8639680147,
0.4038031995,
-0.2800230682,
-0.2774202526,
0.0438206904,
0.7648594975,
-0.1335719228,
-0.0286067072,
0.3283167481,
0.5488934517,
0.0106642805,
-1.0294965506,
-0.3753580153,
-0.2732550502,
-0.0563590787,
0.3119339943,
-0.4588397145,
0.8662534356,
-0.1187141389,
-0.0932594836,
0.4228949547,
0.5519995689,
-0.0401986651,
0.427854985,
-0.0607618727,
0.2190641165,
0.4799748659,
-0.1768417656,
1.0161579847,
-0.4642820358,
0.5207110047,
0.7157111764,
-0.1820820272,
0.8070101738,
0.7444783449,
0.1935436428,
0.3341344893,
0.6625062227,
0.1503221989,
1.0479865074,
-0.0046315547,
-0.1700038314,
-0.1290112138,
-0.0211364627,
-0.3122367859,
0.4824128449,
0.3176270425,
-0.3414279222,
-0.4220430851,
0.6187778711,
0.054295212,
-0.0198361985,
-0.2255738676,
0.6298775673,
-0.153400898,
-0.3892876208,
0.0743625164,
0.4293432534,
0.9140552282,
-0.5929710269,
0.0164002609,
-0.0953524485,
-0.0521069951,
0.1469123363,
-0.7792315483,
0.7045388818,
0.1815615892,
-0.6088943481,
-0.4803882539,
1.0755857229,
-0.5010896325,
-0.5444731712,
0.2481282949,
0.4631216526,
0.2286994308,
0.0509853512,
-0.7383437157,
-0.0364075229,
-0.0599696562,
-0.2087848634,
0.1096962094,
0.4897469282,
-0.1854218394,
0.7383155823,
0.0429806262,
0.1515960693,
0.1383264661,
0.0856387094,
0.8712535501,
-0.5969676971,
-0.6813260913,
-0.6148667336,
0.2095930129,
0.1414621025,
-0.1764286608,
0.8049226999,
0.5016256571,
0.7971046567,
-0.3610872924,
0.7611184716,
-0.2006528229,
0.5997233391,
-0.5447638035,
0.8209022284,
-0.3729321957,
-0.224370569,
-0.4310238361,
-0.8156569004,
-0.4096049368,
0.6044284701,
-0.4852674603,
-0.182151258,
0.5794466734,
0.2125175148,
0.0082476251,
-0.2570343316,
0.5589670539,
-0.0482334793,
0.3328411281,
0.3854564726,
0.6660138369,
-0.3024382293,
0.4924468994,
-0.6412144899,
0.0323241763,
-0.550168097,
-0.8142265081,
-1.0121736526,
-0.7768122554,
-0.1269640028,
0.2450250685,
0.3468726575,
0.8461298347,
0.7348508239,
-0.9061342478,
0.1468998194,
0.2978181243,
0.167203784,
0.1861369759,
-0.2109075785,
0.3439807594,
-0.2542793155,
-0.6306183338,
0.2298166007,
0.314615041,
0.0677457452,
-0.223207593,
0.2696589828,
-0.4354066253,
0.1918155998,
0.7189791799,
0.1889546514,
-0.8821009398,
-0.2592365742,
-0.1877332628,
-0.1050404906,
0.2013681084,
1.0701655149,
-0.7139711976,
0.3594395816,
0.6477303505,
0.4170742631,
0.5255979896,
0.036710348,
0.39263466,
-0.7869731784,
0.5193962455,
0.538682282,
0.4260011613,
0.1508309692,
-0.2722923756,
0.1776652038,
-0.0079845283,
-0.3165821731,
-0.6554020047,
0.2061454505,
-1.0310796499,
-0.4017307162,
0.8959898353,
-0.2127720118,
-0.0294960905,
-0.0194106083,
-0.4024137259,
0.1952377111,
-0.4728966951,
0.9834189415,
0.9393515587,
-0.0389371589,
-0.134978801,
-0.4059419036,
0.2734615207,
0.2791838944,
-0.9751513004,
-0.3741697967,
0.1777491122,
0.1227591485,
0.2895461917,
0.5000606179,
0.0328001715,
0.3535020053,
-0.2774435282,
0.0140059218,
0.1065006405,
-0.8539105654,
-0.2890385389,
0.2846176326,
-0.1487739831,
-0.036482513
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03053v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03053v1
|
Multi-Lingual Malaysian Embedding: Leveraging Large Language Models for Semantic Representations
| 2024-02-05T14:36:51 | 2024-02-05T14:36:51 |
Husein Zolkepli, Aisyah Razak, Kamarul Adha, Ariff Nazhan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In this work, we present a comprehensive exploration of finetuning Malaysian
language models, specifically Llama2 and Mistral, on embedding tasks involving
negative and positive pairs. We release two distinct models tailored for
Semantic Similarity and Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG).
For Semantic Similarity, our 600 million parameter Llama2 model outperforms
OpenAI text-embedding-ada-002 across all recall@k metrics for b.cari.com.my,
c.cari.com.my, Malay news, and Malaysian Twitter test sets.
In the realm of RAG models, our approach proves competitive with OpenAI
text-embedding-ada-002 in the Malaysian context. Notably, our 2 billion
parameter Llama2 model achieves superior Recall@5, Recall@10 for the "Melayu"
keyword research papers dataset and excels in Recall@3, Recall@5, and Recall@10
for the lom.agc.gov.my dataset.
These findings underscore the effectiveness of our finetuning strategy and
highlight the performance gains in both Semantic Similarity and RAG tasks.
All models released at
https://huggingface.co/collections/mesolitica/malaysian-embedding-6523612bfe5881ad35f81b99
|
[
-0.3908006549,
-0.6119267344,
0.2676546574,
0.4546113312,
-0.4152880907,
-0.196417883,
-0.2575540841,
-0.589982152,
0.4051134884,
0.6901366115,
-0.1329617947,
-0.5316864848,
-0.6300086975,
0.2430632561,
-0.3977121711,
0.7042014599,
-0.318472296,
0.190851301,
-0.2198699266,
-0.4410764277,
-0.598454535,
-0.5813546181,
-0.4458099902,
-0.3368176818,
0.5899222493,
0.4953428209,
0.6280634403,
0.6930692792,
0.4759686887,
0.2307106853,
0.0058659939,
0.024422314,
-0.6181260347,
0.269695282,
-0.2548801005,
-0.4649099708,
-0.1714543849,
0.0340312906,
0.68224895,
0.5704580545,
-0.2781594396,
0.1720111519,
0.0620147772,
0.3667032123,
-0.5840750337,
0.364313364,
-0.6446479559,
-0.0602181107,
-0.31529212,
-0.0897075459,
-0.2957841158,
-0.3191866279,
-0.1748310924,
-0.7190095782,
-0.1974682659,
0.0065697934,
0.9744611979,
0.4599156678,
-0.7508907914,
-0.730029881,
-0.439991802,
0.9539390206,
-0.8239360452,
0.4617610574,
0.6984311938,
0.2903501391,
0.1138843596,
-0.4945787489,
-0.4901118875,
-0.3650108278,
-0.0121928342,
0.1801353544,
0.1685944051,
-0.0105210179,
0.1235084161,
0.4408251345,
-0.3125461936,
0.328814894,
-0.1002784148,
-0.115189895,
0.4729388654,
0.1270315796,
0.014377703,
-0.4673847258,
-0.2933326364,
-0.2761667371,
-1.056743741,
-0.266816169,
0.4340027571,
0.4004162252,
-0.1419172436,
1.0898085833,
-0.1954551786,
0.3645610511,
-0.2092508078,
-0.3423088491,
0.2747944295,
-0.4604859948,
-0.0088237934,
0.1454048306,
0.3993691504,
0.3420706689,
0.2088703215,
-0.0549512208,
-0.366720885,
0.3637729883,
-0.0753692091,
-0.895152688,
-0.0341370814,
-0.1381863207,
-0.4600084126,
-0.2433787882,
0.2626560628,
-0.5284083486,
-0.5260632634,
-0.5745874643,
0.7283501029,
-0.1759684831,
-0.5340620279,
0.3563892543,
-0.0045701745,
0.6920760274,
0.1158260256,
-0.8098238111,
0.3091250956,
1.0098451376,
0.6782053113,
0.1516646296,
-0.1699914932,
-0.2298490405,
0.3756760061,
-0.4278926253,
0.5150513649,
-0.6355317235,
-0.3410046995,
0.2509307861,
0.0179666262,
-0.0138270911,
-0.900370717,
0.5118439794,
-0.5860426426,
0.2546387613,
-0.3117243052,
-0.662627995,
-0.4913474023,
0.3646170497,
-0.9684899449,
1.1004880667,
0.1203517467,
-0.7237250209,
0.2698138058,
-0.4394413531,
-0.3521043658,
-0.3644843102,
-0.1285090595,
-0.4180440307,
0.035040658,
0.0790435746,
0.8877670169,
-0.462618649,
0.196071431,
-0.3609363139,
-0.3228556216,
-0.0231252983,
-0.3256530762,
0.5865052342,
0.170112282,
-0.1271457076,
-0.020083556,
-0.5524513125,
-0.5456334352,
0.3936539888,
-0.4894852638,
-0.7326546311,
-0.3487407565,
0.3094021678,
0.4331812859,
0.5084903836,
-0.7828214169,
0.2052639574,
-0.3310678303,
0.2002494633,
0.5642389655,
0.0052657733,
0.3536914587,
-0.3876435757,
0.4038163126,
0.3426523209,
-0.3487823009,
-0.2922026217,
-0.4572310448,
-0.81978935,
-0.111434862,
0.4670718014,
0.6293500662,
-0.6147845387,
-0.1374199241,
-0.2451264411,
-0.4546843171,
-0.8718047738,
0.3531685174,
0.4600801766,
0.1614198983,
0.2875012159,
-0.1856079251,
-0.6103999615,
-0.8751609325,
0.0017004041,
-0.0156182731,
0.0584089346,
0.5231426954,
0.4551727474,
-0.5632735491,
0.6154603362,
-0.3065778315,
-0.5440504551,
-0.1858799458,
0.0244076382,
0.2146862745,
0.3625993729,
0.6098678112,
-0.8996939659,
-0.6656494737,
0.101670824,
-0.7459588647,
-0.0453950427,
-0.0542609617,
0.0907080993,
0.6419191957,
0.7283812165,
-0.6650195122,
0.1923504025,
0.7639501095,
-0.475046277,
0.5643259287,
-0.200508222,
0.0459416844,
-1.5599062443,
0.082225427,
-0.0228665248,
-0.2809872031,
-0.3335517347,
0.3261517882,
0.1178495139,
-0.013289962,
-0.3467967808,
0.7523189187,
-0.3085940778,
0.0530882701,
-0.1116895676,
0.1469251364,
-0.095617339,
0.4296223521,
-0.1000856236,
0.7906715274,
0.3455260694,
-0.5830384493,
0.2293775678,
0.2366012484,
-0.5820221901,
0.2754759789,
-0.739770472,
-0.1237531826,
-0.1848264039,
0.1575970352,
-1.0470504761,
-0.3606342077,
0.240006879,
-0.1254650652,
0.4219803214,
-0.0667511448,
-0.8214575648,
0.0448232554,
-0.5621208549,
0.6215417385,
0.3606078625,
-0.5579481721,
0.4388014674,
0.6794930696,
-0.4285568893,
-0.6020905972,
-0.7298650146,
0.1720273495,
-0.5411201119,
-0.3007819653,
0.5433918238,
0.477956444,
-0.1933187842,
0.265476048,
0.1929581165,
0.1409530193,
0.1133277714,
0.2716554999,
0.0393550508,
-0.4719943106,
0.0695341453,
0.1492566913,
-0.3720225692,
-0.00550185,
-0.0421328098,
0.7128126621,
-0.024309149,
-0.5547396541,
-0.4180062115,
0.4776941538,
0.4302339256,
-0.3513768613,
0.7806935906,
0.9947991967,
-0.5862112641,
0.3716657758,
-0.7435894608,
-0.1594563425,
-0.4309449792,
0.54795295,
-0.5402947068,
-1.1699994802,
0.5545512438,
-0.2832831144,
0.1017358452,
0.6250303388,
0.681206286,
0.0579335056,
1.1192222834,
0.8047657609,
-0.4000303745,
0.3187776208,
-0.4773269892,
0.0858788118,
-0.7840587497,
-0.2441077232,
-0.4199979603,
-0.1274565309,
-0.9916408658,
-0.6760539412,
0.0780093297,
0.4017368555,
-0.3665062487,
0.4834198058,
0.0413116962,
0.2901962399,
0.6392265558,
-0.2382808924,
0.2578224838,
0.0035705224,
-0.3376365006,
-0.1391454041,
-0.5919421911,
-0.6603581905,
1.0976763964,
0.5258876085,
1.0119997263,
0.4983374476,
1.0005887747,
0.0203571264,
0.1935592145,
-0.8443438411,
0.4152023792,
-0.2681405246,
-0.4023755491,
-0.1457221061,
-0.3362380862,
-1.1191667318,
0.2999792993,
-0.2152126282,
-0.3697316647,
-0.204606697,
-0.1633559614,
-0.045598086,
0.3197281361,
-0.5318383574,
0.7875304222,
0.2255280912,
-0.0320666432,
-0.7458870411,
-0.3499657214,
0.3306751847,
-0.0296843164,
0.0533735342,
-0.2256562263,
-0.4326588511,
0.8281322122,
0.0938290581,
0.8996408582,
-0.2918738127,
-0.3960071206,
0.3324469924,
0.1176605746,
0.2684502006,
0.0698785484,
-0.1625791937,
0.2226287574,
0.187139824,
-0.4284836948,
-0.3772877157,
0.8440060019,
-0.8101283312,
-0.6270805597,
-0.2071567029,
-0.337177217,
-0.0092598069,
0.1077330187,
-0.274187386,
0.5818561912,
-0.1665493697,
0.3118849993,
0.4618961811,
-0.3507809639,
0.2842013538,
0.2147867084,
-0.5104622245,
-0.3796933293,
1.352879405,
0.0282343477,
0.1005262882,
0.600252986,
0.1858232617,
-0.4903741181,
-0.1044856086,
-0.422730267,
0.7278382182,
-0.7812324166,
-0.3364280462,
-0.5489947796,
-0.1339209676,
-0.4136766493,
0.057538677,
-0.405594945,
-0.6997861266,
-0.3662774563,
0.0484690145,
0.3157657385,
1.4800733328,
-0.2753458619,
0.208430171,
-0.6129168272,
0.3829352558,
0.2849283814,
0.4235754907,
0.2889299393,
-0.431760639,
-0.4624685049,
0.0139306774,
-0.3489991128,
-0.70846802,
0.3810559809,
0.2159474194,
0.5515282154,
0.4926280975,
-0.2584102154,
0.6673623919,
-0.5181917548,
0.6585446,
-0.1662508845,
-0.6756668091,
0.1746791005,
-0.3543410301,
0.2670437992,
0.3564936519,
0.7355490327,
-0.8483456969,
-0.2752513885,
-0.3204992414,
-0.8806565404,
0.4644409716,
-0.1325639039,
0.4480778277,
-0.1097935885,
0.3313602805,
0.2555891871,
-0.0180881321,
-0.6330106258,
-0.3002575934,
-0.0823921189,
-0.3482024968,
-0.1650797576,
-0.7728178501,
0.2442646474,
-0.1473404169,
0.6499704123,
0.0454499349,
0.4604979157,
-0.0490878224,
-0.3075267375,
0.2012842298,
0.1381452084,
0.6264572144,
0.2574984729,
-0.1563044041,
0.1182367355,
0.183477506,
-0.4954462051,
0.0574982241,
0.1969508976,
0.2234097421,
0.0927251652,
0.3588921726,
0.4574219286,
0.498593688,
-0.6391277313,
0.4903690815,
0.0446685776,
-0.0719982907,
-0.2831991613,
-0.3535682857,
0.3837993443,
0.1036487892,
0.1854134649,
-0.2028197944,
0.0016165531,
-0.3690187335,
0.2645168304,
0.3382068276,
-0.4007895291,
-0.2918258905,
0.5745142698,
0.021457782,
0.0235313606,
0.5270013809,
-0.3360216618,
-0.6387017369,
0.3809919655,
0.7992736697,
0.4375121295,
-0.3268204927,
0.1172805056,
0.6796512008,
0.031940449,
-0.0981931239,
0.404071629,
-0.0429772176,
-0.6447636485,
-0.6346035004,
-0.6293150783,
-0.4722930789,
-0.0040752399,
-0.6640390158,
0.4334642291,
-0.2358960807,
0.1454638392,
-0.3340343535,
0.259721607,
-0.7841508389,
-0.2246952951,
0.3124960959,
0.892403841,
-0.8733177185,
0.9089677334,
0.8275203109,
-0.4199789166,
-0.6979771852,
-0.1720736027,
-0.0020737422,
-0.8565673232,
0.4824482799,
0.558392942,
0.0430947319,
0.0448148809,
-0.0842667893,
-1.1461845636,
1.2802774906,
0.3239254057,
-0.416205883,
0.1354014277,
0.4003180265,
0.3087485433,
-0.2095648795,
0.0385355763,
0.4654521048,
0.3161310256,
-0.1106219068,
-1.097577095,
0.1045579016,
-0.1125348955,
0.0329085849,
0.2098220289,
-0.5112754703,
0.8149252534,
-0.2195985913,
-0.3807597756,
0.382963866,
0.7110863328,
0.3141915798,
0.0597591288,
0.2799497247,
1.0612438917,
0.7052509785,
0.1686779708,
1.2157514095,
-0.2594923973,
0.2469080091,
0.9451633096,
-0.0560183227,
1.3258682489,
0.5098064542,
0.0534582436,
0.5640386343,
0.6053535938,
0.3110021949,
0.7735809088,
0.046053689,
-0.2325793952,
-0.1112548336,
-0.5855959654,
-0.4200627506,
0.6753640175,
0.6556812525,
-0.2273917943,
-0.4547497332,
0.0624240153,
0.1510551721,
0.0752211586,
-0.2698934674,
0.945782721,
0.3405136466,
-0.4876524508,
0.5857138038,
0.500788331,
1.0507925749,
-0.379501909,
-0.3449184299,
-0.209554702,
0.2703454494,
0.0398148894,
-0.8453966975,
0.3007377982,
-0.2091256529,
0.1152464896,
-0.2225838155,
0.7616065741,
-0.8161559701,
-0.4052804708,
0.4230084419,
0.4847857952,
0.1366485506,
0.0126178237,
-0.7163627148,
0.1361745447,
-0.1223986596,
-0.182457462,
0.2769628763,
0.4027088583,
-0.3024251461,
0.613026619,
0.4533560276,
-0.0718015879,
0.0825548396,
0.4204035401,
0.7742501497,
-0.815154314,
-0.2777260542,
-0.8167846799,
0.1166315079,
0.1935135871,
-0.3853807151,
0.8281627893,
0.6576333046,
1.1563459635,
-0.107634984,
0.3928121924,
0.1216402501,
0.5545481443,
-0.4580291808,
0.6865436435,
-0.6016973853,
-0.0676886067,
-0.2622715235,
-1.2078979015,
-0.4448837042,
0.6518054008,
-0.0653028414,
-0.0813371092,
0.2425536364,
1.1354148388,
-0.3761807382,
-0.1244987696,
0.2454355657,
0.3241877854,
0.2968444228,
0.6091777086,
0.9119478464,
-0.611550808,
0.3287350833,
-0.4348186255,
0.0319527052,
-0.3116167784,
-0.8215865493,
-0.8853799105,
-0.933424294,
-0.1038984507,
-0.1224137023,
-0.2841768563,
1.108954668,
0.4521712363,
-0.9480777979,
-0.4219340682,
0.2443194687,
0.1617527902,
0.1805036515,
-0.1919825226,
0.4453355074,
-0.3409389853,
-0.5396514535,
0.0978156701,
0.1657619178,
0.2162671089,
-0.5620419383,
-0.29055354,
-0.4618087411,
-0.0742754862,
0.9209745526,
0.0277025755,
-1.0241560936,
-0.1164404601,
-0.0883947685,
-0.4924983382,
-0.1905832291,
0.4812756777,
-0.8160153627,
0.0447536036,
0.2938314676,
1.0242190361,
0.4904047251,
-0.1404235512,
0.3911287189,
-0.6055067182,
0.285684824,
0.1024036184,
0.444470346,
0.7310809493,
0.0297946297,
0.5800450444,
-0.0038035498,
-0.4493100345,
-0.6898977757,
0.0806427673,
-0.8471590281,
-0.0883467793,
1.4063472748,
-0.0212629121,
-0.0142242834,
-0.1354709417,
-0.4233543575,
0.2923598588,
-0.1401727051,
0.7378073335,
0.6771333814,
0.2751123607,
0.0741534531,
-0.671657443,
0.3577267528,
0.6794300079,
-0.3474887908,
-0.1699227542,
0.1549530923,
0.2064113319,
0.1742887795,
0.27009359,
-0.1918552816,
0.1728397161,
0.0421467796,
-0.2589499354,
-0.0355989188,
-0.2737041116,
-0.4287055731,
-0.0996591523,
0.2851128876,
-0.1028282493
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03050v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03050v1
|
A Comprehensive Study of the Current State-of-the-Art in Nepali Automatic Speech Recognition Systems
| 2024-02-05T14:34:14 | 2024-02-05T14:34:14 |
Rupak Raj Ghimire, Bal Krishna Bal, Prakash Poudyal
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
In this paper, we examine the research conducted in the field of Nepali
Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR). The primary objective of this survey is to
conduct a comprehensive review of the works on Nepali Automatic Speech
Recognition Systems completed to date, explore the different datasets used,
examine the technology utilized, and take account of the obstacles encountered
in implementing the Nepali ASR system. In tandem with the global trends of
ever-increasing research on speech recognition based research, the number of
Nepalese ASR-related projects are also growing. Nevertheless, the investigation
of language and acoustic models of the Nepali language has not received
adequate attention compared to languages that possess ample resources. In this
context, we provide a framework as well as directions for future
investigations.
|
[
-0.0117914006,
-0.5462369919,
-0.2049312145,
0.5795654058,
-0.2288157344,
0.3063459396,
-0.0117465183,
-0.5369470119,
0.0860851035,
0.5492238998,
0.1165412217,
0.010030942,
-0.6636843681,
0.3877090514,
-1.0460665226,
0.4749423862,
-0.1859882921,
0.2250208408,
0.2289735228,
-0.2889471054,
-0.5504632592,
-0.6689026952,
-0.7615542412,
-0.298476994,
0.0482533835,
0.1084501147,
0.0329009555,
0.0838550329,
0.6081632972,
0.5183237195,
-0.6016200185,
-0.0583315976,
-0.0774325505,
0.2489290535,
0.2238494456,
-0.1596299857,
-0.4844917655,
-0.244906798,
1.3007450104,
0.5322239399,
-0.5963581204,
0.2699956596,
0.0875162929,
0.533182323,
-0.4464428127,
-0.0222574212,
-0.3566201925,
0.1202204078,
-0.3818390667,
-0.3044083416,
-0.0613003746,
-0.3934876323,
0.2938146591,
-0.2677645385,
0.0485518724,
-0.0379920602,
0.4904143512,
0.1946693212,
-0.4803339243,
-0.4688023329,
-1.0103964806,
0.7265865803,
-0.4407819808,
0.4544736147,
0.5388785601,
0.6341630816,
0.1344365329,
-0.4558432102,
-0.4773743451,
-0.1565288305,
0.0577666238,
-0.2553925216,
-0.366202563,
-0.346393168,
-0.034739919,
0.6466246843,
-0.6710342169,
0.0949108228,
-0.8601592779,
-0.1597674042,
0.6036429405,
0.21953471,
0.3270176947,
-0.172069326,
-0.0491166897,
0.2778202891,
-0.7579068542,
0.1994065642,
0.1930677593,
0.218583405,
-0.1951921284,
0.6429849267,
-0.5253645778,
1.1415777206,
-0.1348017901,
0.0850403383,
0.2947344482,
-0.6282286048,
-0.4384297132,
0.5858485103,
0.7740251422,
-0.2164972574,
0.2210323513,
-0.0634975657,
-0.2727551162,
0.0654651225,
0.1478445381,
-0.3309059739,
0.0655325204,
0.0728360042,
-0.1939763725,
-0.2197358459,
-0.279361397,
-0.3431761861,
-0.2746388018,
-0.6005683541,
0.154340744,
-0.3947000802,
-0.8601634502,
0.2595613003,
-0.2273713946,
0.3385208845,
0.3851045072,
-0.4565884769,
0.5359487534,
0.551825285,
0.8623547554,
-0.0256551597,
-0.2486380786,
-0.2832254767,
0.1565565169,
-0.2466729134,
1.135404706,
-0.6516886353,
-0.681722939,
0.0863100365,
0.0444615521,
-0.0407913625,
-0.8275774717,
0.151927188,
-0.6841395497,
-0.1433400959,
-0.1135487482,
-0.1901059747,
-0.1634077728,
0.4487345219,
-0.5393114686,
0.7165899873,
-0.1402924955,
-0.8510839343,
0.2330763936,
-0.6853345037,
-0.6247060895,
0.1086260155,
-0.1907371581,
-0.1985338777,
-0.0290146582,
-0.1134276465,
0.256226182,
-0.4627567828,
0.4438981116,
0.3353208601,
-0.6397871375,
0.4208116829,
-0.2864245772,
1.2171317339,
0.3156955838,
-0.308827877,
0.3092584312,
-1.0638074875,
-0.2044194341,
-0.0670559481,
-0.7110925913,
-0.1310195625,
0.1303355694,
0.3971155882,
-0.046767801,
0.2463781536,
-0.7862434983,
-0.2493640184,
-0.3098699749,
0.6630089879,
0.4696002603,
-0.2716177106,
0.5022707582,
-0.0827114657,
0.5465050936,
-0.1343098283,
0.0317737684,
0.0753281862,
-0.2799783945,
-0.778847456,
-0.15363051,
0.7453384995,
0.6527888179,
-0.3063621819,
0.5236982703,
-0.2547333539,
-0.2859241664,
-0.5772996545,
-0.2782950103,
0.4563589692,
0.3331275284,
0.1163451225,
-0.4177828729,
-0.863314271,
-0.8384808898,
0.0247396864,
-0.416854918,
0.0423992909,
0.0276174489,
0.2391931415,
0.1321116537,
0.8110615611,
-0.254807651,
-0.2012000978,
-0.2262278199,
0.0611475445,
-0.1337786466,
0.7539958358,
0.1969715357,
-1.1207029819,
-0.8030532002,
0.2107234746,
-0.6964876056,
0.2047209144,
0.666223824,
0.4256165922,
0.2943085134,
0.4618479908,
-0.3105709255,
0.6006754041,
0.3577374816,
-0.1364640594,
0.5664368272,
-0.0041197119,
0.3197919428,
-0.5813643932,
0.5875233412,
-0.1371311396,
0.0346190706,
-0.8207837343,
-0.1862184405,
-0.1045919657,
-0.3305233121,
-0.1386493444,
0.551499784,
-0.5208948255,
-0.0660372749,
-0.4906980693,
-0.1991399825,
-0.3927707076,
-0.1367941946,
0.3537746966,
0.6291310191,
1.0437853336,
-0.7179755569,
0.3862392306,
0.4150671065,
-0.5724290013,
0.8677616119,
-0.829123199,
-0.0738676637,
0.0581136867,
0.3445155323,
-0.803463757,
-0.0470351018,
0.1873332113,
-0.7136276364,
0.6826642156,
0.1585730761,
-0.5882071853,
-0.3017790914,
0.2602547109,
0.5523169637,
0.6819095612,
-0.1485562921,
0.3954792321,
0.9561429024,
-0.551618576,
-0.5987802148,
-0.5149533749,
0.3680464029,
-0.2342273742,
-0.2824823856,
-0.1825667769,
0.1233279929,
-0.5024908781,
-0.2794851959,
-0.0866644606,
-0.3771936893,
-0.2032148093,
-0.0854111314,
-0.3351556361,
-0.119532235,
-0.204207927,
-0.2548229396,
-0.127704978,
-0.0676415265,
0.1257689595,
0.615637362,
-0.0906573683,
-0.2111798972,
-0.9513126016,
0.6582487822,
0.2870205641,
-0.5271919966,
0.039149221,
0.327915132,
-0.4768044055,
0.0778841674,
-0.8705545068,
0.260858953,
-0.4711716175,
0.3257500231,
-0.2864080966,
-0.7444667816,
0.3962755203,
-0.0076319552,
-0.3097724915,
0.2008973956,
0.3415171206,
-0.0552857444,
0.8219037056,
0.7449548841,
-0.2128199786,
0.4466502368,
-0.1939287931,
0.2012102455,
-1.2462453842,
-0.5786620378,
-1.0950956345,
-0.033456888,
-0.3843208849,
-0.2450739443,
0.209645167,
-0.3566190302,
-0.3509673476,
0.3257405162,
-1.0105102062,
-0.2043760419,
0.4524481297,
-0.1384308189,
0.4282373786,
-0.03476106,
0.2931727767,
0.3132644296,
-0.5817353129,
-0.3471710086,
0.813477993,
-0.0594550744,
0.6364939809,
-0.1266587079,
0.2324925661,
0.1271463037,
0.0530707315,
-0.4376113117,
0.4632508755,
-0.0829819962,
-0.8332666755,
-0.6630756855,
-0.286798358,
-1.1451336145,
0.235900566,
0.4893642664,
-0.5344436765,
0.4702765942,
0.1615092307,
-0.1079278812,
0.2178831846,
-0.0764116645,
0.3034984767,
-0.1525057256,
0.309754163,
-0.4108044803,
-0.8963551521,
0.1559326798,
-0.1009416729,
0.1679795533,
0.0694216192,
0.2094321251,
1.0404565334,
-0.1716694981,
0.7627536654,
-0.3012077808,
-0.1399460584,
0.5998574495,
-0.2243882567,
0.1467191875,
-0.3897801936,
-0.4849657714,
0.1871211976,
0.1108747572,
-0.3626915514,
-0.1102251187,
0.6285685301,
-0.3960853219,
-0.2541262507,
-0.8181425929,
-0.336583674,
-0.1848829836,
0.1339014322,
0.0834322274,
0.5223631263,
-0.6876051426,
0.1365345716,
0.3942344189,
-0.260192275,
0.2451775074,
0.7696893811,
0.0132248458,
-0.5879353285,
0.9589937329,
0.704624474,
-0.1957622319,
0.2493089586,
-0.0153549584,
-0.3859043717,
-0.8041709661,
-0.5944792628,
0.0157646965,
-0.3955269456,
-0.0683175623,
-0.5604698658,
-0.4178526103,
-0.4406060576,
0.1156858131,
-0.0967310145,
-0.4914490581,
-0.3809761405,
0.263139993,
0.3229795098,
1.1198495626,
-0.0484824851,
0.4198388457,
-0.4300955236,
0.3178340197,
0.208975628,
0.3312804699,
0.3158085048,
-0.5260847807,
-0.2161202133,
-0.0114420308,
-0.2714906037,
-0.4509027898,
0.3037222028,
0.152285412,
0.4721443951,
0.0798903257,
-0.1002789587,
0.7375007868,
-0.8748940825,
0.8380978703,
0.309607923,
-0.8850472569,
0.755874455,
-0.2530978024,
0.3399053216,
0.4937553406,
0.1538896263,
-0.48938936,
-0.1093345881,
-0.6122956872,
-0.6417409182,
0.6165559888,
0.1022182256,
-0.1391787827,
0.474467963,
0.1204222962,
-0.0674910843,
0.6904749274,
-0.1148468256,
0.0835094601,
-0.1513884217,
0.0311173797,
-0.2344139516,
0.0257579796,
-0.0612506345,
-0.5203410983,
0.4411469996,
0.1632760018,
0.2493581027,
0.0410393216,
0.033663813,
-0.1793725342,
0.3199024498,
0.4579310715,
0.6429789662,
0.0360590108,
-0.029738998,
0.2716305554,
-0.4271329939,
0.4082853794,
0.1651943326,
-0.3405932486,
0.0622854419,
0.095830515,
0.7001943588,
0.1470726877,
-0.5780535936,
0.511361897,
0.1045552194,
-0.0226542,
-0.7070502043,
-0.1595554948,
-0.0181716755,
0.0817287564,
0.3341878951,
0.3303667307,
0.5308244824,
-0.6130506396,
-0.118787095,
0.6159878969,
-0.7486153841,
-0.6204075217,
0.29814592,
0.2443759739,
-0.7077148557,
0.7073647976,
0.1710918397,
-0.7031314373,
0.6717190742,
0.7644069195,
0.6215719581,
-0.8004503846,
-0.0207293145,
0.3358385265,
0.1850585938,
-0.3002103567,
0.8715114594,
-0.3656159043,
-0.1709361076,
-0.3366388083,
-0.9356895685,
-0.4109376669,
-0.071772702,
-0.6767455935,
0.3043363094,
-0.2566762269,
-0.2062131613,
-0.3100845814,
-0.0991054997,
-0.4975936115,
0.4497083724,
-0.3134742379,
0.901172936,
-0.5101994872,
0.7951992154,
0.8027842045,
-0.2455506027,
-0.3539245129,
-0.3052669168,
0.0346319377,
-0.8380245566,
0.8588706255,
-0.1674902141,
-0.5710777044,
0.060448613,
-0.4529078007,
-0.9389366508,
0.8754245639,
0.0700780749,
-0.3614630401,
-0.0821754858,
0.0308328122,
0.6043509245,
-0.0004382263,
-0.2598997951,
0.5444790721,
0.7729405165,
0.1387255788,
-1.5750725269,
-0.0515378043,
-0.6926897168,
-0.1900779754,
0.2217707932,
-0.8672277331,
0.5149392486,
0.092714794,
-0.2639088929,
0.420707792,
0.599506855,
0.4019555449,
0.3404755592,
0.5038618445,
0.3510621786,
0.5197479725,
0.1610511839,
0.690821588,
-0.0151785882,
-0.1496435553,
0.6466900706,
-0.4935274422,
1.2197545767,
0.4332068861,
-0.51372087,
0.226539582,
0.6032657623,
-0.1237506047,
0.4514928162,
0.7800424695,
-0.2888690829,
-0.0864289925,
-0.4139075875,
-0.6355445981,
0.5827410817,
0.5530048013,
0.0952282995,
0.054707326,
0.0352743864,
-0.4609383643,
-0.1964107007,
-0.2137170285,
0.9519010782,
0.2398361266,
-0.4359512925,
0.7675806284,
-0.3087386191,
0.8794855475,
-0.7826715112,
-0.089236252,
0.502828002,
-0.0823407918,
-0.2941675484,
-0.3890661895,
0.5770965815,
0.2403703779,
-0.0585101359,
-0.079452537,
0.6770783067,
-0.2404732853,
-0.5489556789,
0.155711785,
0.292080164,
0.4573157728,
-0.1152981669,
-0.283201158,
0.536986649,
-0.2018338442,
0.1470757723,
0.3164103329,
0.3035082221,
0.0941696167,
0.6329671741,
0.3285006881,
0.6269695163,
0.0897559077,
-0.0597674362,
0.7487999201,
-0.7312712073,
-0.6877943277,
-0.3167395294,
0.7187352777,
-0.0996214226,
-0.4015882015,
0.6434622407,
0.6705470681,
0.5978435874,
0.2423019111,
1.0733107328,
-0.2027311027,
0.8775480986,
0.0048501021,
1.0076447725,
-0.7262839675,
0.04605316,
-0.1487900615,
-0.6265560985,
-0.4705148935,
0.7669981122,
-0.0721716732,
-0.0157342665,
0.4956111312,
0.4547867775,
-0.1518189162,
0.5119287372,
0.0449589938,
0.1744456738,
0.1013706401,
-0.2197912335,
1.2025443316,
-0.4583881497,
0.3803557456,
0.0339050218,
-0.3333717287,
-0.2157458961,
-0.3958559036,
-0.3367079198,
-1.0091751814,
-0.2666655481,
0.0342348814,
0.2746371031,
0.3779977262,
0.7353147864,
-1.0345788002,
-0.8855947256,
0.0261634886,
-0.2739216089,
-0.16564776,
-0.0777746364,
0.6112620831,
0.0561206043,
-0.6987048388,
0.7555889487,
0.1700991392,
-0.1221730188,
-0.3168275356,
-0.1323170811,
-0.3420494199,
-0.183892101,
0.6309342384,
0.5877925158,
-0.7370858788,
0.0030735738,
0.0953214616,
0.2148893028,
0.2649649084,
0.9887149334,
-0.7258824706,
0.4273364246,
0.7691572905,
0.3006227911,
0.5252008438,
-0.2014443725,
0.7210594416,
-0.289329797,
-0.1628879309,
0.4662210047,
0.2669860721,
0.8566961884,
-0.0224395674,
0.4300514162,
-0.12351349,
-0.8623414636,
-1.4078848362,
0.1824250221,
-0.9864450097,
0.04732804,
0.9554014206,
0.1931730211,
0.1243488565,
-0.7498322725,
-0.4024176598,
0.4498390555,
-0.257935375,
0.5098260045,
0.4886496067,
-0.5614509583,
0.1385706812,
-0.3022610247,
0.4049088359,
-0.0107199866,
-0.3376856744,
0.0495638512,
0.295907557,
0.4789197445,
0.3593397737,
1.0057222843,
-0.4071958065,
0.0924575254,
0.1294247806,
-0.0191535912,
0.2591803968,
-0.4445364475,
-0.9083961248,
0.4028704166,
0.3128325939,
-0.0257898662
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03049v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03049v4
|
EasyInstruct: An Easy-to-use Instruction Processing Framework for Large Language Models
| 2024-02-05T14:33:56 | 2024-06-24T02:10:23 |
Yixin Ou, Ningyu Zhang, Honghao Gui, Ziwen Xu, Shuofei Qiao, Yida Xue, Runnan Fang, Kangwei Liu, Lei Li, Zhen Bi, Guozhou Zheng, Huajun Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
In recent years, instruction tuning has gained increasing attention and
emerged as a crucial technique to enhance the capabilities of Large Language
Models (LLMs). To construct high-quality instruction datasets, many instruction
processing approaches have been proposed, aiming to achieve a delicate balance
between data quantity and data quality. Nevertheless, due to inconsistencies
that persist among various instruction processing methods, there is no standard
open-source instruction processing implementation framework available for the
community, which hinders practitioners from further developing and advancing.
To facilitate instruction processing research and development, we present
EasyInstruct, an easy-to-use instruction processing framework for LLMs, which
modularizes instruction generation, selection, and prompting, while also
considering their combination and interaction. EasyInstruct is publicly
released and actively maintained at https://github.com/zjunlp/EasyInstruct,
along with an online demo app and a demo video for quick-start, calling for
broader research centered on instruction data and synthetic data.
|
[
-0.2947301567,
-0.792653501,
0.5555034876,
0.150360316,
0.0979557186,
-0.1362164617,
-0.3244813383,
-0.1244320348,
-0.1326922476,
0.5534917116,
-0.6791406274,
-0.7770496607,
-0.3496758938,
-0.2745937705,
-0.6186690331,
0.90867275,
0.0219301134,
0.216353476,
-0.3882926702,
0.122775726,
-0.1761069894,
-0.0708787888,
-0.6578391194,
-0.2429140657,
0.072710149,
0.8954540491,
0.5377644897,
1.2480080128,
0.2273284495,
0.2869599462,
-0.1222515181,
0.3911780715,
-0.3082540333,
0.1308535784,
-0.2100283206,
-0.2841722071,
-0.6410129666,
-0.1823870391,
0.7864030004,
0.9794645309,
-0.5490884781,
0.3703162074,
0.2892742753,
0.7649206519,
-0.583722055,
0.3196186423,
-0.4187443554,
-0.0718755051,
-0.2058411688,
0.0592193678,
-0.8218051195,
-0.543206811,
-0.2066836655,
-0.3673706055,
0.4619022906,
-0.0138253756,
0.2076056451,
0.230549112,
-0.4357151985,
-0.4889857769,
-0.4412294626,
0.6011425853,
-0.6593879461,
0.4050029516,
0.3629665673,
0.2190440893,
-0.4467839897,
-0.794732213,
-0.1472896636,
-0.0031924462,
0.0603138246,
-0.2410470694,
0.1948964894,
0.382509321,
0.2926315367,
0.5368818641,
-0.6076669693,
0.4591700137,
-0.2288586348,
-0.1784809679,
0.3856038451,
0.3664452136,
0.2896539867,
-0.117696166,
-0.2161529511,
0.0029527114,
-1.1197308302,
0.2930836976,
0.4468739629,
0.5736712813,
-0.1810671836,
0.5095226765,
-0.4937447906,
1.0579978228,
0.280161947,
-0.1286144108,
0.1392267495,
-0.0703183785,
-0.2784588337,
0.3067217767,
0.4908031225,
0.101803422,
-0.1347898245,
0.1050857753,
-0.3335649371,
-0.3445230126,
0.0150929317,
-1.1639139652,
-0.4589286745,
0.1565716714,
-0.3889559209,
0.0451807827,
0.0916424468,
-0.7240982652,
-0.3519163132,
-0.5552464724,
0.2695151269,
-0.2849811018,
0.2442702353,
0.4042253494,
0.3526862562,
0.3971662223,
0.4977562726,
-0.9629400969,
0.4875557125,
0.9431712031,
0.6076416373,
-0.1406888813,
-0.1659968495,
-0.9897366762,
0.2816495001,
-0.1322656274,
0.7899380922,
-0.6158213019,
-0.3426522315,
0.0978264138,
0.3141522706,
-0.0596773289,
-0.4176356494,
0.5712858438,
-0.3443001807,
0.1364520192,
0.308755219,
-1.0371813774,
-0.0535291135,
0.0565833785,
-0.8314996958,
0.8522978425,
0.07597211,
-0.3139725626,
-0.1920212656,
-0.5707558393,
-0.8289254308,
0.0880153105,
-0.209226802,
-0.545165658,
0.1500001252,
0.3356337845,
0.561440587,
-0.3257494271,
0.0490048937,
-0.1100315675,
-0.5852588415,
-0.2215688676,
-0.5517957211,
0.9202919006,
0.10384579,
-0.3615032732,
0.0970551819,
-0.946497798,
0.4454164505,
-0.1135978699,
-0.5695685148,
-0.1687357277,
0.1964971125,
-0.2918375432,
-0.2581457198,
0.2981948256,
-0.4064897001,
0.630238235,
-0.608663559,
0.2579112351,
0.8461524248,
-0.1404353976,
0.7132549882,
0.1749529988,
0.4368056655,
-0.2028889209,
0.3292424977,
-0.437092185,
-0.2030519247,
-0.8867620826,
-0.3787807822,
0.3126003146,
0.4578586817,
-0.9470852017,
0.1382031888,
-0.2150277644,
-0.4653173089,
-0.8246474266,
0.6477821469,
0.5676079392,
0.3017708063,
0.2446710765,
-0.1382764578,
-0.3792372346,
-0.9819359183,
-0.0121885398,
0.3530679941,
-0.081216082,
-0.061224591,
0.123232305,
-0.0852490515,
0.6085143685,
-0.9224292636,
-0.0811860487,
-0.1856349111,
0.1180457547,
0.2736316621,
0.5593628287,
0.3411492407,
-0.3937397897,
-0.6129106879,
-0.1097790673,
-0.3611868918,
0.1951672733,
0.4132483006,
-0.1455411464,
0.0060908552,
0.7202090025,
-0.5952278376,
0.2330133915,
0.5789397359,
-0.1846136302,
0.4456666112,
-0.1066240743,
0.1583788693,
-0.9306383133,
-0.2869753838,
-0.1533039957,
-0.2708944082,
-0.56748873,
0.3629408777,
0.2353863418,
-0.2582499385,
-0.6240270138,
0.2624469101,
-0.6153786182,
0.2408387065,
-0.0970639661,
-0.3222371042,
-0.063220039,
0.3135927022,
-0.1032626033,
0.7767779231,
0.6536744237,
-0.6206031442,
0.300077647,
0.1687338948,
-1.0335354805,
0.5203614831,
-0.6943059564,
0.4128163159,
-0.1972541958,
0.1572775394,
-0.8624181151,
-0.7962891459,
0.4042359889,
0.0319772512,
0.5321618319,
-0.6467268467,
-0.6066650152,
0.0652968213,
-0.3932109475,
0.3377068043,
0.1768810451,
-0.8204627633,
0.4708462059,
0.2589799464,
-0.3448842764,
-0.4532573223,
-0.5742343068,
-0.1494597644,
0.1423183978,
-0.31595245,
0.3451451957,
-0.4604637027,
-0.0487427376,
0.0627928153,
0.0239196196,
-0.3684137166,
-0.0056766514,
0.2695129216,
0.1745336354,
-0.4143216908,
0.1691687256,
0.5540962815,
-0.1389356256,
-0.081031546,
0.0742155761,
0.3574884534,
0.0717628747,
-0.6319988966,
-0.4256509542,
0.3506207168,
0.4973269105,
-0.2208048999,
0.5435946584,
0.3051398993,
-0.2424094081,
-0.825992465,
-0.3536111414,
-0.1681185365,
-0.5400495529,
0.3917368054,
-0.0612230003,
-0.9233158827,
-0.1734675914,
-0.1414179653,
0.3650730848,
-0.0455043428,
0.278105706,
-0.2695283294,
1.3612577915,
0.3908072412,
0.1359263211,
0.4573320448,
-0.1399990618,
-0.031464044,
-0.5890215039,
-0.0683663636,
-0.502733171,
-0.0669493377,
-0.3628793955,
-0.4578253627,
0.097929351,
-0.2321187109,
-0.4638634622,
0.2000761777,
-0.7765774131,
0.8760533333,
0.496317178,
0.2775506973,
0.2192133516,
0.2155139893,
0.6188231111,
0.0450578183,
-0.7466937304,
-0.4611518383,
0.9013215899,
0.1779237092,
1.0212233067,
0.1598420143,
0.827682972,
0.2704055607,
0.346529156,
-1.0395588875,
0.7586615086,
-0.5394895077,
-0.5358658433,
-0.2101415098,
-0.4814523458,
-0.8687032461,
-0.1460972875,
-0.0738536268,
-0.4668636024,
-0.1059650704,
0.3963183761,
-0.5623771548,
0.2650167942,
-1.0598096848,
0.8730443716,
-0.3305476308,
-0.3728939593,
-0.1506791562,
-0.3721059561,
0.5154796839,
0.3254586756,
0.3733403385,
0.0192198306,
-0.014150301,
0.5319291949,
-0.5375664234,
1.1035131216,
-0.2410514057,
-0.2740484774,
0.5083480477,
0.4042654634,
0.6659465432,
-0.115858525,
-0.2375210077,
-0.3262268901,
0.0143726077,
-0.2208743989,
-0.7593036294,
0.9955352545,
-0.4905115366,
-0.5908097625,
-0.0408569947,
-0.4249615073,
-0.098722361,
0.126019612,
0.0926477686,
0.6897190213,
-0.1457293779,
0.4276658893,
1.0195025206,
-0.1122706309,
0.4108759165,
0.4487742484,
-0.1387657672,
-0.4450149238,
1.1281540394,
0.2285180837,
0.1677025557,
0.3673556149,
0.0065116868,
0.0558135584,
-0.493255198,
-0.6028048992,
-0.1989642084,
-0.6941453218,
-0.301995188,
-0.0168144777,
-0.2563952506,
-0.159034133,
-0.1849212646,
-0.8341398239,
-0.32265535,
-0.1318869889,
-0.1424704343,
0.2200403214,
0.9007176757,
0.224006623,
0.4114611149,
-0.7485074997,
0.236717999,
0.5016334057,
0.6157006621,
0.1353300363,
-0.3738474846,
-0.6407037377,
0.1718650311,
-0.2065640092,
-0.3445999026,
-0.1343987882,
0.4879322052,
0.4816125631,
0.3839330375,
0.1189091802,
0.5643566847,
-0.7147256732,
0.5424215198,
0.1020276174,
-1.0120452642,
0.5777791739,
0.039229922,
0.5554874539,
0.707539916,
0.247519955,
-0.1043623388,
0.0240212642,
-0.2688000202,
-1.0695744753,
0.9114845991,
-0.1200519204,
0.1731851995,
0.0559041873,
0.3173333406,
0.5450739264,
0.1194149926,
-0.602444768,
-0.4635256827,
0.0518403575,
-0.52668643,
0.0905186161,
-0.3586298227,
-0.1043397039,
-0.3280952275,
0.5631326437,
-0.0933168083,
0.1176250577,
-0.4075160921,
-0.3151102364,
-0.0036318505,
0.2918853462,
0.3908521235,
0.4723757803,
-0.0995654091,
0.2449048609,
-0.0864700079,
-0.2971949577,
0.368403852,
0.0464883558,
-0.44328475,
-0.1576925814,
0.4074071944,
0.6562223434,
0.7039710283,
-0.5770788789,
0.4033879042,
0.0050391639,
-0.0148463184,
-0.165158838,
0.4450006783,
0.1417121142,
0.1174656674,
-0.0085771009,
-0.0747167468,
0.3503734767,
-0.4345344603,
0.0824810266,
0.0470187068,
-0.3226908445,
-0.2720737159,
0.4555774629,
0.55329597,
-0.5865200758,
0.9125586748,
-0.4914179146,
-0.056433253,
0.5652480125,
0.3787353039,
0.8114598989,
-0.3104349971,
0.2833739221,
0.4464954734,
0.1951836348,
-0.2970540226,
0.14148283,
-0.1032604054,
-0.3079883158,
-0.8985638022,
-0.4942159653,
-0.4327460527,
0.1256129444,
-0.8055708408,
0.2877303958,
-0.6336821914,
0.2809855938,
-0.1097375527,
-0.5319210291,
-0.6890143752,
0.1219156384,
0.1090307161,
0.9540002346,
-0.5846225023,
0.8606594801,
0.7634808421,
-0.0763809681,
-0.6593520045,
-0.0425381213,
0.338226378,
-0.380662024,
0.4734116197,
0.2489371896,
-0.3792756796,
0.1920686364,
-1.0210572481,
-0.5609577894,
0.7032718658,
0.7379482388,
-0.7233363986,
-0.0169701446,
0.0368126072,
0.2365250885,
-0.2614967823,
-0.1043051854,
0.3872323036,
0.3900512457,
-0.0724503845,
-0.4546387792,
-0.0317866616,
-0.1496257335,
-0.3877539635,
0.3575050831,
-0.6540353298,
0.6029014587,
-0.1063421071,
-0.2187383175,
0.2764751017,
0.7090363503,
0.0408840589,
0.3119536936,
0.4419604242,
0.4417809546,
0.5601120591,
-0.0473192073,
0.748539865,
-0.433446914,
0.3031976819,
1.6502776146,
0.088495709,
0.9248802066,
0.215683192,
-0.2387330085,
0.4413676858,
0.610863924,
0.1651395857,
0.4586924016,
0.0855468214,
-0.2741539478,
-0.4635360837,
0.0291449763,
-0.2698359489,
0.6351245642,
0.428830564,
-0.167791456,
-0.1982203126,
-0.2091340721,
0.0528214537,
0.1104872078,
-0.6108673215,
0.6049004793,
0.0306025967,
-0.5263948441,
0.2138109803,
0.0495227538,
0.4919134676,
-0.7512857318,
-0.4674495161,
-0.1528955102,
0.0910819471,
-0.5420653224,
-1.0118596554,
0.0513484254,
-0.0963545963,
-0.3583512902,
-0.2650604546,
0.4531642199,
-0.6679409742,
-0.4672417045,
-0.0478940494,
0.3850446045,
0.012023245,
0.2337955832,
-0.4916715622,
0.1730069965,
0.2234428674,
-0.4491281509,
0.4035220742,
0.3214176893,
0.243964538,
0.6769098639,
0.4269919395,
-0.0010465443,
-0.1379537582,
0.0816804543,
0.5355817676,
-0.5017088652,
-0.1184716448,
-0.6807520986,
0.7405739427,
-0.1229214147,
-0.2335899621,
0.7264806032,
0.7398352623,
0.9978067875,
-0.3764015436,
0.6216324568,
-0.1256806552,
0.4623572826,
-0.82943362,
0.601154387,
-0.3956976235,
0.3765960932,
-0.1157013103,
-1.015794158,
-0.2439690977,
0.468780756,
-0.1490153521,
-0.1749253273,
0.270712018,
1.0246632099,
-0.4758388996,
-0.1417080611,
0.0119032562,
0.1403221786,
0.2440683693,
0.3901419938,
0.5616816282,
-0.2030146718,
0.6251515746,
-0.4260087013,
-0.1573820859,
-0.1983235478,
-0.8913788795,
-0.7522429228,
-0.3751017153,
-0.5159765482,
-0.0865693018,
0.0773628056,
1.4518970251,
0.6405528188,
-0.9583998322,
-0.4783590734,
0.0823861361,
0.3268947601,
-0.3345291317,
-0.2070590258,
0.7203139663,
-0.2049884945,
-1.1032135487,
0.8824107647,
0.3025411963,
-0.0817410871,
-0.1530050039,
-0.0951420143,
0.0160609894,
-0.0289610047,
0.8293433785,
0.5067632198,
-0.2492910475,
-0.2674973607,
-0.2410084009,
-0.2993584871,
-0.08399719,
0.6978051662,
-0.2304743975,
0.7124656439,
0.3690696657,
0.8167585135,
0.3733786345,
-0.2506109476,
0.5604455471,
-0.7443931103,
0.1745249927,
-0.0970016271,
0.3291265965,
0.4059990644,
-0.2078110576,
0.5632216334,
-0.0714650974,
-0.4438152313,
-0.9146187901,
0.4186920822,
-0.6008457541,
-0.2764705718,
0.9459265471,
-0.1220700219,
-0.3015096784,
0.0628175512,
-0.4002842903,
0.0503216684,
-0.4118563533,
0.7754318118,
0.6457888484,
-0.2577831447,
-0.1717333049,
-0.5873609185,
0.3917787969,
0.0852155834,
-0.7595962286,
0.1392319649,
0.6428396702,
0.2943832874,
-0.323032558,
0.044672627,
0.2028686553,
0.4363634288,
0.0196816456,
0.3718896508,
-0.4183629453,
-0.3440251946,
-0.1267019361,
0.4401526451,
0.269418031,
-0.2046490461
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03043v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03043v1
|
SIDU-TXT: An XAI Algorithm for NLP with a Holistic Assessment Approach
| 2024-02-05T14:29:54 | 2024-02-05T14:29:54 |
Mohammad N. S. Jahromi, Satya. M. Muddamsetty, Asta Sofie Stage Jarlner, Anna Murphy Høgenhaug, Thomas Gammeltoft-Hansen, Thomas B. Moeslund
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Explainable AI (XAI) aids in deciphering 'black-box' models. While several
methods have been proposed and evaluated primarily in the image domain, the
exploration of explainability in the text domain remains a growing research
area. In this paper, we delve into the applicability of XAI methods for the
text domain. In this context, the 'Similarity Difference and Uniqueness' (SIDU)
XAI method, recognized for its superior capability in localizing entire salient
regions in image-based classification is extended to textual data. The extended
method, SIDU-TXT, utilizes feature activation maps from 'black-box' models to
generate heatmaps at a granular, word-based level, thereby providing
explanations that highlight contextually significant textual elements crucial
for model predictions. Given the absence of a unified standard for assessing
XAI methods, this study applies a holistic three-tiered comprehensive
evaluation framework: Functionally-Grounded, Human-Grounded and
Application-Grounded, to assess the effectiveness of the proposed SIDU-TXT
across various experiments. We find that, in sentiment analysis task of a movie
review dataset, SIDU-TXT excels in both functionally and human-grounded
evaluations, demonstrating superior performance through quantitative and
qualitative analyses compared to benchmarks like Grad-CAM and LIME. In the
application-grounded evaluation within the sensitive and complex legal domain
of asylum decision-making, SIDU-TXT and Grad-CAM demonstrate comparable
performances, each with its own set of strengths and weaknesses. However, both
methods fall short of entirely fulfilling the sophisticated criteria of expert
expectations, highlighting the imperative need for additional research in XAI
methods suitable for such domains.
|
[
-0.4385915101,
-0.6340679526,
0.5240585208,
0.0122061111,
-0.4832184911,
0.2282851785,
-0.2238057554,
-0.34959203,
0.147429049,
-0.0178323332,
-0.4891023934,
-0.4729262292,
-0.5832026005,
-0.0036058158,
-0.4972667396,
1.0699801445,
-0.0751855969,
-0.2370215207,
-0.2783886194,
-0.4401991069,
-0.6219493151,
-0.4005864263,
-0.5549440384,
-0.2849152088,
0.428085655,
0.0682414174,
1.0040022135,
0.6396058798,
0.7332131863,
0.2221705168,
-0.0257585887,
-0.228748247,
-0.1784804463,
-0.0347949229,
-0.5423718095,
-0.5117678642,
-0.4069513381,
-0.0542159677,
0.3807772696,
0.3566482067,
-0.0651152879,
0.0023254706,
-0.0833138376,
0.5546867251,
-0.5520513654,
0.1724229455,
-0.6663345098,
0.1614538431,
-0.0406117961,
-0.4433296919,
-0.135123387,
0.0682785586,
0.4532242715,
-0.5214025974,
0.493149966,
0.1656101942,
0.8662127256,
0.4106462598,
-0.2321489304,
-0.3293572664,
-0.6600781679,
0.8578315973,
-0.6311607957,
0.0406100936,
0.2886737585,
0.2489295453,
0.2326990366,
-0.2942050397,
-0.8673296571,
-0.132528469,
-0.1631179005,
0.3572768867,
-0.1786569804,
0.0292278863,
0.2032657862,
0.5236064792,
-0.7301306725,
0.0727250054,
0.0643031001,
0.2640577555,
0.7154734135,
-0.035433501,
0.5190655589,
-0.5371742845,
-0.4275940359,
-0.0877416283,
-0.3173947334,
0.2206244916,
0.0547983199,
0.0915623158,
-0.1812789142,
0.2696170509,
0.0946707949,
0.261449039,
-0.3918142021,
-0.1480309665,
0.1318064034,
-0.0875428915,
-0.307462275,
0.1564828157,
0.6453117728,
0.5627680421,
-0.0271985456,
-0.2113465071,
-0.2494452149,
0.5267724991,
0.4606825113,
-0.4331704378,
0.1173781008,
0.4273377359,
-0.659660995,
-0.5520560145,
-0.0502643436,
-0.8751047254,
-0.4698677063,
-0.2563269734,
0.3810752928,
-0.408434689,
-0.5031749606,
-0.1766095012,
-0.2750963569,
0.6648479104,
0.3450173438,
-0.6832507253,
0.2631796896,
0.7952171564,
1.045098424,
-0.5882353187,
-0.1927294284,
-0.2712112665,
-0.0810025558,
-0.1834224015,
0.7553875446,
-0.6999172568,
-0.256706506,
-0.0917260721,
-0.2241532207,
-0.0429495163,
-0.2538089752,
0.9084903598,
-0.3691000044,
0.2046273053,
-0.1726172119,
-0.2913480401,
-0.4730097055,
0.3833991885,
-0.5472606421,
0.7764710188,
0.3013982773,
-0.8510776758,
0.4883211851,
-1.1021707058,
-0.4439517856,
0.2380087674,
-0.3681821525,
-0.4056445956,
0.1690201461,
0.2599720359,
0.5714403987,
-0.5011807084,
0.6280754209,
-0.128576681,
-0.5046055317,
0.2913226783,
-0.6639458537,
0.7833182812,
0.1082147881,
-0.9159756303,
0.203079477,
-0.7336152792,
-0.1467741579,
0.2508050501,
0.0817214251,
-0.5734794736,
0.050584428,
0.1850091517,
0.2370830029,
-0.4583514333,
-0.5039456487,
0.0187447444,
-0.3594239056,
0.5732921362,
0.5950706601,
-0.2594442964,
0.3125647306,
-0.5248176455,
0.7686651349,
-0.0377381966,
-0.2182000279,
-0.6707110405,
-0.6836076379,
-0.3992451727,
-0.2496327162,
0.1672726572,
0.6274496913,
-0.8352347016,
0.3964374959,
-0.4881990254,
-0.3967177868,
-0.7703174949,
-0.1566562206,
0.392568022,
0.6372780204,
0.2831697166,
-0.2889688015,
-0.2876237631,
-0.5333350301,
-0.2344882339,
-0.4473114312,
0.0431733094,
0.3958528042,
0.5702605844,
-0.4892161787,
0.9278925657,
-0.168590948,
-0.3157634139,
-0.1955693513,
0.309730947,
0.0552931428,
0.3200858533,
0.5639423728,
-1.1097631454,
-0.1918154359,
0.2851195931,
-1.1264939308,
0.204552874,
-0.5098293424,
-0.007818711,
0.2319372296,
0.0220585819,
-0.4850997031,
0.8242734671,
0.2478609383,
-0.3353478014,
0.3359324634,
-0.1890137941,
0.387421757,
-0.8593172431,
0.1755501926,
0.2495856434,
-0.2966746092,
-0.5296436548,
0.4944482148,
-0.1329930276,
-0.2086562961,
-0.2501206696,
0.6476877928,
-0.178741008,
0.0301255621,
-0.2261451632,
0.4793212414,
0.1195761189,
0.7152158618,
0.183653146,
0.3981166184,
0.6893471479,
-0.20686616,
0.2308555394,
0.2569181025,
-0.3329478204,
0.6668685675,
-0.7722854614,
0.0482891053,
-0.3045578003,
0.0174560416,
-1.0880737305,
0.0317014642,
0.2101539075,
-0.3790615499,
0.1085768342,
-0.0526966378,
-0.0419168361,
-0.1360414773,
-0.482149899,
0.4712234735,
0.5908665061,
-0.5895925164,
0.5806655288,
0.2333787531,
-0.327234,
-0.6340554953,
-0.5789787769,
0.306945473,
-0.578361094,
-0.5264398456,
0.6135430932,
-0.0724721029,
-0.4293396771,
-0.0085887397,
-0.0660577267,
-0.1059445366,
0.3366570175,
0.5449727774,
0.3126023412,
-0.3786787391,
-0.1852784902,
0.2915830314,
-0.3265154958,
0.2457767427,
-0.0482990295,
0.1076555923,
-0.2819072306,
-0.1494649202,
-0.5890312195,
0.5266723037,
0.5649323463,
-0.136639908,
0.4606208205,
0.7519697547,
-0.3747985065,
-0.0111566763,
-0.1319141239,
0.215273872,
-0.3381951153,
0.1135414317,
-0.4245474637,
-0.5352147222,
0.3884019554,
0.1152311862,
0.1167277694,
0.4851715565,
0.6076775193,
-0.0840350688,
0.7940662503,
0.6668738127,
0.0048497613,
0.1976809502,
-0.4409019649,
0.4877425432,
-0.6734865308,
-0.0207145885,
-0.4076731801,
-0.2970375419,
-0.6567707062,
-0.1643429995,
0.1362963915,
-0.2017617673,
0.4085986316,
0.1556461155,
-0.6464969516,
0.3899236023,
0.519138217,
-0.0011047035,
0.3343735039,
0.1070651039,
0.0318739563,
-0.0149323372,
-0.5675531626,
-0.6868061423,
0.7965329885,
0.4322285056,
0.4848976135,
0.0202911701,
0.5308688879,
0.7677923441,
0.4907602072,
-0.9571069479,
0.3113899231,
0.0457553491,
-0.4151214063,
-0.4018737674,
-0.1980573982,
-0.9808164239,
0.3814313114,
-0.2222964615,
-0.6161291599,
0.2497622818,
-0.1829153299,
-0.4415265918,
0.4002274275,
-0.8644768,
0.6580561399,
-0.2359417379,
-0.2892421186,
-0.1865873933,
-0.7639164925,
0.2863102555,
-0.3276785314,
0.3487321734,
-0.1398587972,
0.0364333317,
0.9513366222,
-0.2733066976,
0.4765194654,
-0.2554922104,
-0.1582085788,
0.193563059,
-0.0698180199,
-0.133245334,
0.2959005833,
-0.3797455132,
0.5064025521,
0.4109414518,
-0.4691316783,
-0.973275423,
0.7024703026,
-0.8591730595,
-0.7165996432,
-0.4874145389,
-0.4970481992,
0.2075834721,
0.2518460751,
0.2556587756,
0.6125637293,
-0.2092387825,
0.1208874807,
0.3957785964,
-0.4036771059,
0.5216867328,
0.0925342292,
-0.074330546,
-0.1542434692,
1.071621418,
0.1196617484,
-0.3322610259,
0.6180760264,
0.3382818997,
-0.1608838588,
-0.6416942477,
-0.3817174733,
-0.0238895305,
-0.6380619407,
-0.1692234427,
-0.704205513,
-0.0982731581,
-0.2977371514,
-0.4831627607,
0.0662672147,
-0.3662766516,
0.1823689789,
-0.1000220627,
0.0676699206,
0.6593257189,
0.2471413761,
0.4248929918,
-0.4226164818,
0.8619335294,
0.0119147832,
0.447395891,
0.033703886,
-0.4593009949,
-0.1444057524,
0.0923671052,
-0.169348523,
-0.7526135445,
0.3523844481,
0.1726339459,
0.5247690082,
0.6029062271,
0.2873080969,
0.4694257975,
-0.0823191851,
0.8427352905,
-0.080291912,
-1.0033730268,
0.877854228,
-0.3240318596,
0.0986164957,
0.3568627238,
0.6333376169,
-0.3486730456,
-0.1071387455,
-0.8844097853,
-0.8648633957,
0.7217253447,
0.6662240028,
0.2355723381,
0.0910843611,
0.6239522099,
0.4792363942,
0.1328075677,
-0.6202888489,
-0.4156464934,
-0.1696511507,
-0.1149113923,
-0.1320915669,
-0.2110614181,
-0.0510385223,
-0.1307443678,
0.6276597381,
-0.1734540612,
0.5673559904,
0.3447724581,
-0.2458545715,
0.0830823928,
0.4325216115,
0.3731553853,
0.7286013365,
-0.4262745082,
0.1101736501,
-0.1919534206,
-0.4172040522,
0.3221364319,
0.1396890581,
-0.2363004833,
0.1982347071,
0.7430453897,
0.7573519945,
-0.2324200869,
-0.5817513466,
0.6423755884,
-0.532669127,
-0.0939572304,
-0.0817846656,
0.1316126436,
-0.622911334,
-0.1057321206,
0.272519052,
0.3863024712,
0.2549645007,
-0.680305779,
0.1180079579,
0.2855101526,
-0.5946227312,
-0.3095097542,
0.5547183752,
0.2069014907,
-0.5095207691,
0.4986080229,
-0.2569974065,
-0.2535363436,
0.5638780594,
0.256875962,
1.0636510849,
-0.1152617335,
0.5049154758,
0.0105537493,
0.2987762094,
0.2088456899,
0.1656903028,
-0.4694395661,
-0.7963709235,
-0.1303093433,
-0.2905029058,
-0.4473874569,
-0.0256685894,
-1.049254179,
0.1950022727,
-0.4726037681,
-0.0395728275,
0.2946198583,
-0.004337938,
-0.6969331503,
0.4400087893,
0.052778434,
0.7524220943,
-0.8117044568,
0.6970834136,
0.8055748343,
-0.4107464552,
-0.2946924567,
0.2166597992,
0.0186916273,
-0.6847411394,
0.0293981805,
0.3126046658,
-0.0632710382,
-0.2222324163,
-0.3666855693,
-0.3613403738,
1.0525641441,
0.2585943043,
-0.2588987052,
-0.1297927201,
-0.0733496994,
0.7652102709,
-0.4950773716,
0.5747540593,
0.9360485077,
0.2399011701,
0.002878946,
-0.3675440848,
0.1705120355,
-0.7585624456,
0.1982255727,
-0.2614539266,
-0.3411910534,
-0.031503763,
-0.4423517585,
-0.2207233459,
-0.0654439107,
0.6336758733,
0.1830640584,
0.8074388504,
0.5831975937,
0.3313414752,
0.9035822153,
-0.1946504712,
1.3063656092,
-0.092631802,
0.1979076415,
1.0230826139,
-0.3325318396,
0.767801702,
0.4200101495,
-0.0159433931,
0.6911341548,
0.4330712557,
-0.0388847739,
0.3721812069,
0.05488462,
-0.0848283321,
0.1987733692,
-0.282959491,
-0.0576716475,
0.3855977058,
0.4418828785,
-0.2683519721,
-0.1343517005,
0.4520776868,
-0.0000146746,
0.1160253435,
-0.141063571,
0.7905054688,
0.0323156379,
-0.7219157815,
0.5568208694,
0.2373476475,
0.6139995456,
-0.3074285984,
-0.1607358009,
-0.2825960219,
0.0249933414,
-0.3358210921,
-1.0026538372,
0.5131392479,
0.1947196424,
-0.3085379899,
-0.4217548072,
0.6810865998,
-0.0718535855,
-0.3184160888,
0.3214969635,
0.3381511569,
0.3172438443,
-0.1452533901,
-0.9763575196,
0.1698707193,
-0.0412007421,
-0.0571395792,
0.0210404918,
0.5718287826,
-0.3987880349,
0.7386981845,
0.4426434934,
-0.0801489204,
-0.3303163946,
0.1241662875,
0.5792523623,
-0.7943513393,
-0.6507593989,
-0.8730200529,
0.6347896457,
0.0977072567,
-0.3678416908,
0.4537912011,
0.3007638454,
0.5810929537,
0.0929562375,
1.1992518902,
-0.2384712845,
0.1742736101,
-0.4583465457,
0.6393053532,
-0.4750743806,
0.4374146461,
-0.7556975484,
-0.9938703179,
-0.4760649204,
0.6369300485,
-0.2579716444,
0.2038172781,
0.8754140735,
0.7129362822,
-0.0634364337,
0.2287023515,
0.620711267,
0.256893903,
0.4239594042,
0.1844927073,
0.9056850672,
-0.6972260475,
0.2183479518,
-0.3079760075,
-0.6406967044,
0.0491898283,
-0.8312634826,
-0.8872802258,
-0.8342974186,
-0.7815507054,
-0.1695562154,
-0.0494056568,
0.8180664778,
0.7708224654,
-0.7547028065,
-0.0238041766,
0.1698254943,
0.5240900517,
-0.5176163912,
-0.2802530825,
0.5580077171,
-0.0915874913,
-0.4580964148,
0.14611727,
0.5760884881,
-0.0687339455,
-0.3703088462,
-0.0353048407,
-0.097506173,
0.1454676986,
0.7610928416,
0.0197493788,
-0.9266350269,
0.0438409634,
-0.1908382177,
0.2258108258,
0.2893161774,
1.1253806353,
-0.8737848997,
0.5449234247,
0.4917758405,
0.809217751,
0.0795048103,
0.0497127809,
0.621168673,
-0.5287315249,
-0.0459370278,
-0.0939555019,
0.4935199022,
0.4456847906,
-0.7255058289,
0.677721858,
0.175520137,
-0.3526141644,
-0.7278580666,
-0.2413924038,
-1.3227678537,
-0.2095255107,
0.9178137183,
-0.4475204647,
-0.375531435,
-0.2703264654,
-0.5149474144,
-0.0245236997,
-0.3475118577,
1.0360976458,
0.5994072556,
-0.0241358615,
-0.4422803223,
-0.3151964545,
0.4188762903,
0.4209471643,
-0.9023597836,
0.0331912339,
-0.124373138,
-0.1214296669,
0.3132862449,
0.4681760967,
-0.2529508173,
0.2231407464,
-0.2362760901,
-0.158715263,
0.3089452088,
-0.3995153904,
-0.7917472124,
0.1924833506,
-0.022484988,
0.0872460306
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03038v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03038v1
|
Automatic Combination of Sample Selection Strategies for Few-Shot Learning
| 2024-02-05T14:23:43 | 2024-02-05T14:23:43 |
Branislav Pecher, Ivan Srba, Maria Bielikova, Joaquin Vanschoren
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In few-shot learning, such as meta-learning, few-shot fine-tuning or
in-context learning, the limited number of samples used to train a model have a
significant impact on the overall success. Although a large number of sample
selection strategies exist, their impact on the performance of few-shot
learning is not extensively known, as most of them have been so far evaluated
in typical supervised settings only. In this paper, we thoroughly investigate
the impact of 20 sample selection strategies on the performance of 5 few-shot
learning approaches over 8 image and 6 text datasets. In addition, we propose a
new method for automatic combination of sample selection strategies (ACSESS)
that leverages the strengths and complementary information of the individual
strategies. The experimental results show that our method consistently
outperforms the individual selection strategies, as well as the recently
proposed method for selecting support examples for in-context learning. We also
show a strong modality, dataset and approach dependence for the majority of
strategies as well as their dependence on the number of shots - demonstrating
that the sample selection strategies play a significant role for lower number
of shots, but regresses to random selection at higher number of shots.
|
[
-0.7615132332,
-0.4771721363,
0.4044092596,
-0.2843512297,
-0.474167645,
-0.1344885081,
-0.1796465665,
-0.4610854685,
0.1182031333,
0.0598980412,
-0.5494168401,
-0.5289840102,
-0.6346929073,
0.6064954996,
-0.0442600362,
0.8411989808,
0.0996745899,
0.4576372802,
-0.0838344991,
-0.3652699888,
-0.5566533804,
-0.0006415102,
-0.6692897081,
-0.2791364789,
0.3026387393,
0.7872830629,
-0.0931482166,
0.4816420674,
0.8502430916,
0.2945739329,
0.002071955,
0.2728487849,
-0.3762427568,
0.0531916954,
0.0801564008,
-0.6725313663,
0.1392790228,
0.0828817561,
0.7102294564,
0.3523286283,
0.2817054093,
0.2668397725,
0.3269703686,
0.3929929137,
-1.1480960846,
-0.2505227029,
-0.6450667381,
0.3490119278,
-0.3812799752,
-0.2398024499,
-0.4376442432,
-0.0417998806,
0.1978770345,
-0.4486665726,
0.3060209155,
-0.0624213554,
0.313092649,
0.2450621277,
-0.3132845163,
-0.1904339194,
-0.5972818732,
0.9837858081,
-0.5335165262,
-0.1621157229,
0.5216309428,
0.8052902818,
0.0918878242,
-0.417386204,
-0.245896399,
0.003308438,
-0.1244392544,
0.2927258015,
-0.032718394,
0.1480439305,
0.3853212893,
-0.1880702674,
-0.286734879,
0.2815896571,
-0.4031112492,
-0.1023156643,
0.6645608544,
0.1544242948,
-0.1125522926,
-0.2930060029,
-0.2618397474,
-0.4732609987,
-0.5448237658,
0.270226866,
0.3322923183,
0.5391110182,
-0.0361260697,
0.4169175029,
-0.3952563703,
0.9508496523,
0.2864925265,
-0.5404465795,
0.1607830375,
-0.3193443716,
-0.2622695863,
-0.1584175527,
0.8479028344,
0.0000224489,
-0.0882849321,
0.1480370462,
-0.2984758615,
-0.2422639281,
-0.0453639813,
-0.6779216528,
-0.1570083648,
-0.1347868592,
-0.5833095312,
-0.514090836,
0.2553986013,
-0.7712576389,
-0.0125517966,
-0.0778793991,
0.5907231569,
-0.5571804643,
0.4387741685,
-0.3982577026,
-0.5383670926,
0.2645255327,
0.509257853,
-0.7801195383,
0.6127762794,
0.0791178793,
0.9165331125,
-0.5475527644,
-0.431632787,
-0.9377307892,
-0.0282847844,
-0.3312958181,
1.2625317574,
-0.8353816271,
-0.6326413155,
-0.2599285245,
-0.4563094676,
0.0521779321,
-0.5749294162,
0.2007713616,
-0.3379528522,
0.0851731896,
-0.3102162182,
-0.6356336474,
-0.3874340355,
0.2659998238,
-0.9140443802,
0.7792342901,
-0.0919639245,
-0.5238804817,
0.7562133074,
-0.5231760144,
-0.5628868937,
0.0471794829,
-0.4260506332,
-0.7146635056,
0.0476397239,
0.2868074477,
0.6532990932,
0.0636532754,
-0.6765654683,
-0.6137148738,
-0.7327229381,
0.1422592402,
-0.4426491261,
0.6689885259,
0.0677476823,
-0.3443550766,
-0.3192581534,
-0.7768388987,
0.1322767586,
0.0665435717,
-0.3289770186,
-0.2922037542,
-0.3037296236,
-0.1097157001,
0.192588836,
-0.5216345191,
-0.1412048191,
0.3137849867,
-0.2457046509,
-0.0036093814,
0.4183030725,
0.5597313046,
0.7462106347,
-0.4883380234,
0.6678417921,
-0.0221482571,
-0.007053257,
-0.4458825886,
-0.2526446879,
-0.324757725,
-0.5989199877,
0.5039299726,
0.4195708036,
-0.7441536784,
0.2251626998,
0.1573493481,
-0.3457902968,
-0.3278856575,
0.7284342647,
0.5079420209,
0.359647274,
0.6254196763,
-0.5880702734,
-0.5619794726,
-0.5603258014,
-0.0634576529,
0.0891200751,
0.1983388215,
0.5124926567,
0.7715742588,
0.2585420609,
1.3206512928,
-0.5173136592,
-0.6968724728,
-0.4408757389,
0.2442497909,
-0.1682006866,
0.2026827633,
1.100815773,
-0.3615181744,
-0.5811225176,
-0.5009087324,
-0.5306540728,
0.1296083033,
-0.2312382758,
0.0967194512,
0.1438938677,
0.2708306313,
-0.1415797323,
0.506953299,
0.1766458154,
0.3993409574,
0.3375226855,
0.0923207551,
0.0630679652,
-0.7262217402,
-0.3199137449,
0.5742200613,
-0.273285687,
-0.1944756657,
-0.1724663228,
0.0674717799,
0.2241161466,
-1.0528423786,
0.6259090304,
-0.4982880652,
-0.0760354772,
-0.4243763387,
-0.1461569667,
0.0044609122,
0.4698767662,
0.1606810987,
0.3953380287,
0.7557393312,
-0.6203303337,
0.3224318027,
0.4466896951,
-0.1967461705,
0.6102518439,
-0.3394547701,
0.2590944767,
-0.1961009353,
0.9003525376,
-0.9590367079,
-0.3152369857,
0.0381929167,
-0.1799299419,
0.4357938468,
-0.3713329136,
-0.4510528147,
-0.2793036103,
-0.5460937619,
0.3680094182,
0.1364700794,
-0.3996620774,
0.3466449678,
0.0713973939,
0.2661018074,
-0.5515589714,
-0.8281411529,
-0.1584059447,
-0.3706478775,
-0.0453397334,
0.2446840554,
0.1705916673,
-0.1583763063,
-0.1629474014,
-0.0364523083,
0.0918318778,
0.069768995,
-0.0201667957,
0.3997491896,
0.0536512025,
0.141550377,
0.1927132457,
-0.1772202253,
-0.6660067439,
-0.1577398032,
0.3165228665,
0.0397015586,
-0.5011962652,
-0.4256109893,
0.407689333,
-0.0913746357,
-0.2215054184,
0.5446274877,
0.7279328108,
-0.1584448963,
-0.516669929,
-0.444573611,
-0.7968885303,
-0.3788917959,
0.1903225034,
-0.3104771972,
-0.4844150841,
0.2700215876,
-0.2006061524,
-0.0523128025,
0.3750317097,
0.3949696124,
-0.6755283475,
0.7517938614,
0.4302006066,
-0.281330198,
0.7207003832,
-0.8084649444,
-0.3485710323,
-0.5550694466,
0.0541142561,
-0.2741089761,
-0.9772835374,
-0.501218617,
-0.1316242069,
0.7888903022,
-0.1093305275,
0.0096861711,
0.3402668536,
-0.2123597413,
0.865609467,
0.9214757085,
0.631121397,
0.3958394825,
-0.0103502199,
-0.3363959789,
0.1503314525,
-0.9054819942,
-0.2197834253,
1.3942483664,
-0.016309822,
0.8292354345,
-0.1236000061,
1.293536067,
0.0961268246,
-0.1084197611,
-1.0018206835,
0.4961422384,
-0.3359219432,
-0.6534958482,
-0.4274604321,
-0.2023478597,
-0.8500904441,
0.1777356416,
-0.9252868295,
-0.373023212,
0.3873850107,
0.1292559057,
-1.013920784,
0.030221846,
-0.7922477126,
0.4767848253,
-0.428381294,
-0.3944568038,
-0.2368832529,
-0.9086694121,
0.1680681854,
-0.0215448737,
-0.1759851128,
0.2574642003,
-0.0151960189,
0.670491159,
-0.0538258292,
1.2262680531,
-0.0718117803,
0.6845281124,
0.6137797832,
-0.0723264664,
0.4449504912,
-0.1994806081,
0.1338936836,
0.0715655833,
0.0920229852,
-0.3649094403,
-0.411642015,
0.240643844,
-0.6983450055,
-0.1147788018,
-0.3319449723,
-0.1786319464,
-0.4238137901,
0.2508088648,
0.9193326235,
0.507661581,
-0.3270781934,
0.3976793289,
0.4734661579,
0.0522965118,
0.9582281709,
0.2520313859,
0.3929392695,
-0.6036177278,
0.5639708638,
0.3440334797,
0.3418822885,
0.2714952826,
0.2653876543,
0.0353102721,
-0.665306747,
-0.1082215756,
0.0593559407,
-0.8223105669,
-0.7463846803,
-0.2580064833,
0.0435264334,
-0.3887830675,
-0.2087617069,
-0.2117863894,
-0.3074322343,
-0.4325619936,
-0.1077163965,
0.0854653791,
0.2881127596,
-0.0027065868,
0.5962744951,
-0.8564150333,
0.5189092159,
0.5298559666,
0.1171083823,
-0.1606063247,
-0.3270548284,
-0.3130083382,
-0.1890543252,
-0.7848086357,
-1.0890130997,
0.1210735738,
0.5144791603,
0.7229979634,
0.6221317649,
-0.0665709302,
0.6350027919,
-0.3726727664,
0.3007847965,
0.2309589982,
-0.4514992237,
0.7210993767,
-0.0986192822,
0.3668137789,
1.2555148602,
0.445151031,
0.0771931782,
-0.147155419,
-0.7532271743,
-0.3447168469,
0.8052763939,
0.2268589884,
-0.1308201998,
0.2634775937,
0.0108765755,
0.2068753541,
-0.0312797241,
-0.4194426537,
-0.2493086308,
0.1146536991,
-0.2205307335,
0.2239194214,
0.3255009651,
-0.4387018383,
-0.2928413451,
0.4214504063,
-0.5953761935,
0.0312265083,
0.0374828987,
-0.2425460517,
-0.3247063756,
0.0940414071,
0.300493598,
0.1496418566,
-0.1591022164,
-0.2260936946,
0.5312893391,
-0.2933830321,
0.1982890069,
-0.0759666711,
-0.3933954239,
-0.0791078135,
0.7029507756,
0.8780832291,
0.3192953169,
-0.402479291,
0.4629335403,
0.2705033123,
-0.3310952485,
-0.0932668,
0.5261493325,
-0.7680375576,
0.5065772533,
0.7413948774,
0.4075912237,
0.3490650654,
-0.5859829187,
0.4897967875,
0.8105691075,
-0.1045111567,
0.0372286811,
0.1074934974,
0.1309083402,
0.0055432771,
0.1522836834,
-0.2880241573,
-0.242983669,
0.7269287109,
0.4024039209,
0.8698043227,
0.0371026583,
0.444735378,
0.3903073967,
0.091192387,
-0.6309821606,
-0.291569829,
-0.2246440351,
-0.8212639093,
-0.1742231995,
-0.1805516779,
-0.603081882,
0.0060302252,
-0.4977578223,
0.9437924027,
-0.413226068,
-0.3022597134,
-0.1463781595,
0.4797567427,
-0.9767639637,
0.28462255,
0.3868529499,
0.8767917156,
-1.113130331,
0.7073661089,
0.8005132079,
-0.555319488,
-0.6282913089,
0.2068122774,
0.5647694468,
-0.5175351501,
0.5937755108,
-0.0118477689,
-0.1441551149,
0.0455405489,
-0.8380075097,
-0.6717404127,
1.2580438852,
0.1143212691,
-0.4532945752,
-0.060367763,
-0.2484317869,
0.3616551161,
-0.5886059403,
0.545543015,
0.6454795003,
0.3140392601,
0.742335856,
-0.6585306525,
-0.3711890578,
0.1286827922,
-0.0758420825,
-0.1890601814,
-0.8399659395,
0.1730328053,
-0.2914297283,
-0.060707055,
-0.1191315427,
0.5792978406,
0.6009638906,
0.5518245101,
0.6156154871,
0.5254656076,
0.4356019497,
0.3143233657,
0.7845555544,
0.1010159329,
0.2876470089,
1.0501749516,
-0.1440973133,
0.9297740459,
0.3274255693,
-0.3099180758,
0.1112607643,
0.6776326299,
-0.3677867949,
0.9240424633,
-0.3118035495,
-0.1014719829,
-0.238365829,
0.3522206247,
0.0960383266,
1.0201406479,
0.1628710479,
-0.2150849253,
-0.5455732942,
0.4524009228,
-0.3158587515,
-0.3261725903,
-0.103271991,
1.2700382471,
0.1606210619,
-0.5666685104,
0.2069616169,
-0.2505052984,
0.9165201783,
-0.5284887552,
-0.2056738436,
-0.0772163868,
-0.0724667013,
-0.464420855,
-0.5693628192,
0.0004677115,
-0.0486807711,
0.104807198,
0.078200087,
0.9622105956,
-0.1936096698,
-0.6200454831,
-0.0967229828,
0.4541414678,
-0.2624857724,
0.11663872,
-0.5829485655,
-0.1597324312,
-0.2879021168,
-0.0647465289,
0.6189163923,
0.2263368368,
0.0651306584,
0.357498318,
0.5098177791,
0.3263106346,
-0.1956216842,
-0.2616741359,
0.6947137117,
-0.4350273013,
-0.3802036643,
-0.9574991465,
0.3473346829,
-0.0610901266,
-0.3288007081,
0.5808015466,
0.4843402207,
0.8461518884,
0.0619826429,
1.0946762562,
0.1660015732,
0.4525526464,
-0.6494894028,
0.2365758419,
-0.3838191032,
0.3848686516,
-0.5222027898,
-0.9729235768,
-0.5427418947,
0.6939259171,
-0.4825053513,
0.2137410045,
0.7553068995,
0.3912593722,
-0.1283976436,
-0.1704315692,
0.2070209533,
-0.3666014671,
0.0898765102,
0.4661082327,
0.3335793018,
-0.4179381728,
0.6581119895,
-0.692014575,
-0.3528060019,
-0.5030631423,
-0.8853385448,
-0.9446986318,
-0.5262155533,
-0.1697328538,
0.0296591315,
-0.2248149961,
1.2369894981,
0.8891996145,
-0.7750483155,
-0.1134387925,
0.2238782346,
-0.0724204034,
-0.5241305232,
-0.146669969,
0.137848556,
-0.6627150178,
-0.7453753352,
0.4068740606,
0.2698786557,
0.1976959705,
0.0332008749,
0.1023578942,
-0.1706437021,
-0.1830702871,
0.4726656079,
0.4230261445,
-0.2061315179,
0.1412669122,
0.1583577394,
-0.2364497483,
0.2032887191,
0.8773494959,
-1.2105683088,
0.4391245246,
0.7902032137,
0.624766171,
0.7389008403,
0.1360025257,
0.3375873864,
-0.9651705027,
0.3008919656,
0.4490269125,
0.3279328644,
0.0249116607,
-0.1444769949,
0.5090739131,
0.469225347,
-0.2145121396,
-0.4816973805,
0.0393860973,
-0.8712024689,
-0.4312270284,
1.355496645,
0.221062541,
-0.0802514926,
0.2685953677,
-0.1486933976,
0.2236823142,
-0.46763888,
0.8322318196,
0.6394959688,
-0.5085628033,
-0.4832290709,
-0.4318487644,
0.5161218047,
0.1837930977,
-0.6478518248,
-0.821511209,
0.6870559454,
0.0819908082,
-0.1769245714,
0.4861131012,
0.2287909091,
0.3222148716,
-0.2789124846,
-0.4619345963,
0.0417408757,
-0.5324154496,
-0.4218675494,
0.1652887613,
-0.1453769058,
-0.5258529782
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03009v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03009v1
|
UniMem: Towards a Unified View of Long-Context Large Language Models
| 2024-02-05T13:47:53 | 2024-02-05T13:47:53 |
Junjie Fang, Likai Tang, Hongzhe Bi, Yujia Qin, Si Sun, Zhenyu Li, Haolun Li, Yongjian Li, Xin Cong, Yukun Yan, Xiaodong Shi, Sen Song, Yankai Lin, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Long-context processing is a critical ability that constrains the
applicability of large language models. Although there exist various methods
devoted to enhancing the long-context processing ability of large language
models (LLMs), they are developed in an isolated manner and lack systematic
analysis and integration of their strengths, hindering further developments. In
this paper, we introduce UniMem, a unified framework that reformulates existing
long-context methods from the view of memory augmentation of LLMs. UniMem is
characterized by four key dimensions: Memory Management, Memory Writing, Memory
Reading, and Memory Injection, providing a systematic theory for understanding
various long-context methods. We reformulate 16 existing methods based on
UniMem and analyze four representative methods: Transformer-XL, Memorizing
Transformer, RMT, and Longformer into equivalent UniMem forms to reveal their
design principles and strengths. Based on these analyses, we propose UniMix, an
innovative approach that integrates the strengths of these algorithms.
Experimental results show that UniMix achieves superior performance in handling
long contexts with significantly lower perplexity than baselines.
|
[
-0.5012435913,
-0.5786651969,
0.748636663,
0.341960609,
-0.3964485228,
0.1055280939,
-0.7366645336,
-0.3701135814,
-0.0346917324,
0.9046107531,
-0.3172416091,
-0.5139164925,
-0.1663836837,
-0.070340246,
-0.2165812552,
0.6940121055,
-0.2215991318,
-0.0639238209,
-0.3744449019,
-0.4215385914,
-0.5405305624,
-0.6645245552,
-0.1266365498,
-0.8113486767,
0.1250989884,
0.3572428524,
0.4853459299,
0.5237267613,
0.2725355625,
0.3504694104,
-0.2714755833,
0.071552977,
-0.1179222167,
-0.1579300612,
-0.3652620614,
-0.4066421688,
-0.783664763,
-0.2106905133,
0.9846913218,
1.1456286907,
0.0118976692,
-0.0233986899,
0.4649105072,
0.7139486074,
-0.6384035945,
-0.0661360323,
-0.3153231144,
-0.0656230599,
-0.3187271655,
-0.2277809978,
-0.3417178988,
0.2887975276,
0.0172542203,
-0.34577775,
-0.0850582346,
-0.1867278963,
-0.0293793231,
0.0691922456,
-0.6523023248,
0.0873541906,
-1.0712447166,
1.1025503874,
-0.8735131025,
0.2723380625,
-0.0767515451,
0.1564648747,
-0.4640828967,
-0.57372576,
-0.3261054456,
0.1605160832,
0.0132715581,
-0.0563485101,
-0.3032584488,
0.314424336,
0.0911478922,
0.4107138515,
-0.2728431523,
0.3756780922,
-0.2474686652,
-0.0753914863,
0.4579320848,
0.20353733,
0.0860432237,
0.0437876321,
-0.8326323628,
0.3057388663,
-0.7418605685,
0.0986778364,
0.0180568676,
0.0966122299,
0.1873194277,
0.3507910669,
-0.2734185159,
0.557200551,
-0.3323361278,
-0.0731901601,
0.1201329753,
-0.1719420999,
-0.3805575669,
-0.1393871009,
0.7970709205,
0.3054651022,
0.1490617245,
-0.4214473963,
-0.4102974832,
-0.2043943256,
0.0608534925,
-0.8510946631,
0.0722231269,
0.1745096296,
-0.2808106244,
0.0954823866,
0.0904634297,
-0.9490634799,
-0.0413909592,
-0.5928929448,
0.3095220029,
-0.5496214628,
-0.112503916,
0.3554299772,
0.1716114134,
0.014294887,
0.2855352461,
-0.5102421641,
0.5124493837,
0.7259950638,
0.4513524175,
-0.5326654911,
-0.4564992487,
-0.3085317314,
0.3800610602,
-0.1406468898,
0.9305911064,
-0.690084219,
-0.3697379231,
-0.0039497437,
0.0525097214,
0.1503192931,
-0.5786193013,
0.484118104,
-0.536762476,
0.3705095947,
-0.0486649722,
-0.7104126215,
-0.5120927095,
-0.0907555446,
-0.5521111488,
0.8927772045,
0.1489368081,
-0.4974268675,
0.1460908651,
-1.1726506948,
-0.3823345006,
0.1262197644,
-0.0612277836,
-0.0649672896,
0.5807517767,
0.4145210385,
0.518601656,
-0.5339620709,
0.4979156852,
-0.1118634418,
-0.5232841969,
0.4530886114,
-0.6890281439,
0.7349085212,
0.1915331632,
-0.290974021,
0.1787962615,
-0.7365086675,
0.2963021398,
-0.08700791,
-0.5971344709,
-0.4689777792,
-0.1294358671,
0.235022828,
-0.0262793899,
0.3350721598,
-0.530009985,
0.2486977577,
-0.1661141515,
0.549120307,
0.618245542,
-0.2387342006,
0.8223227859,
0.016803734,
0.24281542,
0.2208180875,
0.1672985107,
-0.619590342,
0.1768070757,
-0.7434520721,
-0.3390221,
0.1955720633,
0.4332241118,
-0.236771062,
0.5092431307,
-0.3426075876,
0.1860968024,
-0.1264910549,
0.7060734034,
0.5306533575,
0.1550152898,
0.5026240945,
-0.5677463412,
-0.5873355269,
-0.8138413429,
-0.3158232868,
0.1231366694,
-0.2839376926,
0.073207438,
0.3298639953,
-0.7649174929,
1.0430152416,
-0.2433995605,
-0.2282179147,
-0.3374411762,
0.206027478,
0.2592920363,
0.4233822525,
0.2669959664,
-0.5472405553,
-0.1011240482,
-0.1407509893,
-0.8018575907,
-0.1751450896,
-0.0288226884,
0.21255216,
0.4142234921,
0.7103956342,
-0.4213221669,
0.4134068191,
0.2925073504,
-0.242725879,
0.3204642236,
-0.4932401478,
-0.0447435416,
-1.240973711,
0.1090708077,
-0.0888332278,
-0.2665848434,
-0.6144883037,
0.2604494691,
0.3156645894,
-0.0168266334,
-0.452331841,
0.5931071639,
-0.8849966526,
-0.0313994251,
-0.6505460143,
-0.0183325522,
0.1566580981,
0.4625107348,
-0.0735052451,
0.6692596674,
0.4452111423,
-0.5264967084,
0.4999546111,
-0.2334637046,
-0.2651531398,
0.7128885388,
-0.552146554,
0.2558270395,
-0.3088385761,
0.2991705537,
-0.925774157,
-0.0123359691,
-0.4770549536,
-0.1084222421,
0.5542213917,
-0.0278925411,
-0.5374450088,
-0.427852571,
-0.3105258644,
0.690695107,
0.3930978477,
-0.7805634141,
0.7178019285,
0.3650420308,
0.0282834172,
-0.4811374843,
-0.4317317009,
0.3390929699,
-0.6036139727,
-0.617067337,
0.5255609155,
-0.2537354827,
-0.4035789073,
-0.1896653771,
-0.0376489609,
-0.0813442096,
0.0386436656,
0.2866139114,
0.1444478184,
-0.3449087143,
0.0977764279,
-0.1611025333,
-0.4820691347,
0.0307469983,
-0.4684357047,
0.600281477,
-0.289542377,
-0.2189675421,
-0.4699289501,
0.7228754163,
0.71573174,
-0.2478276193,
0.2886308432,
0.5500506759,
-0.3504026532,
-0.2612726688,
-0.8037285209,
-0.1196213812,
-0.471454978,
0.3373394012,
-0.2732915282,
-1.1732202768,
0.6076630354,
-0.7311454415,
0.2149762362,
0.1917702854,
0.346567601,
-0.0376534201,
0.9465655088,
1.0407037735,
-0.529286325,
0.2821986675,
-0.0608157888,
-0.0173583664,
-1.3758168221,
-0.2577574849,
-0.1429519653,
-0.3256379962,
-0.118904911,
-0.6697506309,
0.236262098,
0.484161526,
-0.3115795851,
0.3444578648,
-0.1392145455,
0.7865920067,
0.3367907107,
-0.3907399476,
0.5648512244,
0.1765322983,
-0.4851281643,
-0.0474078842,
-0.4672953486,
-0.5985036492,
1.066596508,
0.3940422237,
1.0227751732,
0.0566803552,
0.4184744358,
-0.0884637907,
0.3052604496,
-0.6291812062,
0.6311728358,
-0.1697340906,
-0.4899699986,
-0.4135688841,
-0.3044680059,
-1.014526248,
0.2504191697,
0.0847270638,
-1.1051726341,
-0.0862016305,
-0.2449070513,
-0.5277653337,
0.5772928596,
-0.4331984818,
0.5878879428,
-0.3871699274,
-0.3111979067,
-0.1700816005,
-0.4433622062,
0.3220465481,
-0.2094800025,
0.2424130142,
-0.0117219724,
-0.0906493217,
0.6752736568,
-0.1930590421,
0.8665482402,
0.1792316288,
-0.242460981,
0.3098197281,
0.1038205102,
0.1990579516,
0.3700946569,
0.0722670108,
0.3507943153,
0.0756340027,
-0.2939355075,
-0.5840918422,
0.9103139043,
-0.5763009191,
-0.5776845813,
-0.2038869411,
-0.96915555,
-0.2899053991,
0.3723125458,
0.1048386544,
0.5389422774,
-0.5243636966,
0.3882262111,
0.6688203216,
-0.1449924856,
0.8795206547,
0.8756958842,
-0.5051233172,
-0.4652900994,
0.3447902799,
-0.0929638222,
0.055430308,
0.5407702327,
0.1320970207,
-0.4469218254,
-0.494635582,
-0.2405353785,
0.1790945679,
-0.5105459094,
-0.1104581654,
-0.3950084448,
-0.1251090616,
-0.3716987669,
-0.0297389422,
-0.5842818618,
-0.1171412021,
-0.1616415977,
0.2415239662,
0.2337239534,
0.5310242176,
-0.2712295651,
0.5969964862,
-0.8146986961,
0.1652019322,
0.3409885168,
0.561295867,
-0.1418522,
-0.4758383036,
-0.1223872229,
0.0668977946,
-0.4133091867,
-0.3933872581,
0.3344115615,
0.0187473502,
0.4855686128,
0.7094568014,
-0.1080356091,
0.8809925914,
-0.5623462796,
0.3530998826,
0.3118033707,
-0.981893301,
0.2129585296,
-0.1873048842,
0.5563057661,
0.4734976888,
0.0010128136,
-0.6494833231,
0.0518599451,
-0.4557028413,
-0.9089056849,
0.3530654013,
0.0124367084,
0.3344416618,
0.2027430981,
0.5028547049,
0.0668594316,
0.0301822443,
-0.5196759105,
-0.0980710685,
0.2763235569,
0.1257264167,
-0.4611993134,
-0.5018809438,
-0.1995319277,
-0.4028205276,
0.1482585371,
-0.2327804565,
0.2368460298,
-0.0683993772,
-0.234825924,
-0.1912482977,
0.7293375134,
0.3496080339,
1.0307289362,
-0.2252535969,
0.4244022071,
0.4048446715,
-0.1511595845,
-0.0452984422,
0.0300022289,
-0.0169165321,
-0.1818733215,
0.2912960649,
0.4971216917,
0.6311336756,
-0.6237521768,
0.3204942048,
-0.0847589448,
0.0836818516,
-0.5545761585,
0.0664600879,
0.2240870893,
0.3735789061,
0.4696758986,
-0.3464073241,
0.0020179239,
-0.8910185099,
0.3339851797,
0.6495521069,
-0.4632745981,
-0.5507320166,
0.4832849503,
0.0344642363,
-0.2662263811,
0.6329267025,
0.1012586281,
-0.4594290257,
0.2440892607,
0.9979026318,
0.7335274816,
-0.5113022327,
-0.0310053192,
0.0044384496,
0.1260602921,
-0.1132662967,
0.1836628914,
-0.1842683852,
-0.5988551378,
-0.7357438207,
-0.6683175564,
-0.0374656208,
0.5907567739,
-0.6905109286,
-0.0930985659,
-0.2396949083,
-0.0185777862,
-0.0925378278,
0.2725615799,
-0.5830881,
0.0340609588,
-0.0434248224,
0.8519217372,
-0.4484534264,
0.9115725756,
0.855827868,
0.1312323809,
-0.366353631,
-0.0380414166,
0.1751250625,
-0.674572587,
0.2641430497,
0.3392828405,
-0.0129575888,
-0.1218581274,
-0.4267621934,
-0.7717621922,
1.1161775589,
0.2674051523,
-0.5553451777,
0.0884852335,
0.4475254416,
0.438926816,
-0.6144480109,
0.0792060122,
0.7887741327,
0.4521156549,
-0.0346322879,
-0.7635211349,
0.1401566714,
-0.1095806435,
0.2525044978,
0.6116942763,
-0.4912120104,
0.7078621387,
-0.4509453177,
-0.3511729836,
0.3624511063,
0.8656167984,
-0.0304019153,
0.3170328438,
0.3293941617,
0.7107138634,
0.5067930222,
0.2258350104,
0.6702656746,
-0.3211015463,
0.2373556644,
1.0256775618,
-0.2026062608,
0.71795398,
0.6623362303,
-0.1999582052,
0.3534709513,
0.0170340855,
0.3508881032,
0.1057669148,
0.1878586113,
-0.4669246376,
-0.4634889662,
0.02096425,
-0.1087666228,
0.6411297917,
0.3642620444,
-0.1437305808,
-0.6317931414,
0.0237656366,
0.3106114268,
0.1602833569,
-0.3659550846,
0.7578647137,
0.4051224291,
-0.6033476591,
0.4430287778,
0.3819224536,
0.8171808124,
-0.2114684433,
0.1290899664,
-0.3707036376,
0.6146056056,
0.0714750662,
-0.9659669399,
0.274751693,
-0.0520945005,
-0.1924241781,
-0.0360611789,
0.5961769819,
-0.4176028073,
-0.5156963468,
0.6054166555,
0.6166535616,
0.0653211251,
-0.4409753978,
-0.4701094329,
-0.0244919732,
-0.1808434576,
-0.1103586331,
0.6623747945,
0.6815337539,
-0.2999842465,
0.537838757,
0.7364581823,
-0.1627209783,
-0.3149054348,
0.0607162341,
0.8318829536,
-0.9935957193,
-0.143049866,
-1.0438457727,
0.4201038778,
-0.0080351252,
-0.2290849984,
0.7200173736,
0.6388732195,
0.6939592957,
0.2755789161,
0.4636285007,
0.4888863862,
0.3630378544,
-0.4439150691,
0.599398911,
-0.5344901681,
0.4769201577,
-0.1053222716,
-1.2925974131,
-0.4670768082,
0.251976192,
-0.0861838907,
-0.0458656289,
0.6773989201,
0.5140661597,
-0.3739006817,
-0.0928182676,
0.4725876451,
0.1248163581,
0.3138668239,
0.923086524,
0.6449761391,
-0.1773898602,
0.2982263565,
-0.3672339618,
-0.409463793,
-0.0871555209,
-1.0568549633,
-1.1210201979,
-0.5828512907,
0.049098324,
0.0467925742,
-0.2237815708,
0.6622491479,
0.6274023056,
-0.4981338978,
-0.4722325206,
0.1196000129,
0.0141415726,
0.007111304,
-0.1701082438,
0.3705433309,
-0.2660962343,
-0.6584932804,
0.6115902066,
0.7756767273,
-0.0724498183,
-0.4003626704,
-0.0904487669,
0.3559879959,
0.296220839,
0.8861954808,
0.4816228151,
-0.5436647534,
-0.1199970618,
-0.0832656771,
0.1954776794,
0.2486854792,
1.041380167,
-0.7886683941,
0.3954651654,
0.2949388623,
0.4132705927,
0.2333516181,
-0.0119316261,
0.5886393189,
-0.5199677348,
0.2100366205,
0.0869075358,
0.6754171252,
0.2697426975,
-0.1032904685,
0.2599204779,
-0.0030455259,
-0.5168952942,
-0.79704386,
0.329788506,
-1.0463857651,
-0.5996149182,
1.3229144812,
-0.0269943364,
-0.3935813308,
-0.1333118975,
0.0334913805,
0.0954370275,
-0.2317525893,
0.848526895,
0.4329437613,
-0.0470203198,
-0.0868992954,
-0.4896114469,
0.0641440079,
0.3789838254,
-0.7774188519,
0.2830049992,
0.4504710138,
0.5778620839,
0.2196689546,
0.5235008597,
-0.5804709792,
0.008632361,
-0.6535354853,
0.1287259609,
-0.2070751935,
-0.6339618564,
-0.5305332541,
0.0767450035,
-0.097698845,
0.2652525306
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02992v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02992v2
|
Decoding-time Realignment of Language Models
| 2024-02-05T13:31:28 | 2024-05-24T08:39:07 |
Tianlin Liu, Shangmin Guo, Leonardo Bianco, Daniele Calandriello, Quentin Berthet, Felipe Llinares, Jessica Hoffmann, Lucas Dixon, Michal Valko, Mathieu Blondel
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Aligning language models with human preferences is crucial for reducing
errors and biases in these models. Alignment techniques, such as reinforcement
learning from human feedback (RLHF), are typically cast as optimizing a
tradeoff between human preference rewards and a proximity regularization term
that encourages staying close to the unaligned model. Selecting an appropriate
level of regularization is critical: insufficient regularization can lead to
reduced model capabilities due to reward hacking, whereas excessive
regularization hinders alignment. Traditional methods for finding the optimal
regularization level require retraining multiple models with varying
regularization strengths. This process, however, is resource-intensive,
especially for large models. To address this challenge, we propose
decoding-time realignment (DeRa), a simple method to explore and evaluate
different regularization strengths in aligned models without retraining. DeRa
enables control over the degree of alignment, allowing users to smoothly
transition between unaligned and aligned models. It also enhances the
efficiency of hyperparameter tuning by enabling the identification of effective
regularization strengths using a validation dataset.
|
[
-0.240850687,
-0.6125558615,
0.4477632046,
0.2041479349,
-0.2362362295,
0.421200037,
-0.3853913546,
-0.4169369042,
0.1383868307,
0.2026212215,
-0.7832397819,
-0.2738766074,
-0.4121676087,
0.0756446198,
-0.1027645171,
0.9154415727,
-0.1921453178,
-0.0732854828,
-0.0168794226,
-0.2179490775,
-0.640401423,
-0.5400578976,
-0.5098087788,
-0.3452075124,
0.6421824694,
0.3565818965,
1.03634727,
1.2353929281,
0.4505954385,
0.2601095438,
-0.0438276604,
0.0772030875,
-0.4971083403,
0.0679125488,
-0.1423564106,
-0.4188603759,
-0.5189523101,
-0.0158632472,
0.8013195395,
0.7823781967,
-0.4422967732,
0.3579675257,
-0.1281414479,
0.8110637069,
-0.7830963731,
0.006122137,
-0.4567715228,
0.2390336394,
-0.0868263617,
-0.1705138832,
-0.3557364345,
-0.5468604565,
0.0987695009,
-0.6750086546,
0.2026429176,
0.1369120181,
1.538528204,
0.5616691709,
-0.2255698591,
0.498462975,
-1.0886983871,
1.20454216,
-0.8732107282,
0.6949836016,
0.2985489368,
0.540230155,
-0.0107184006,
-0.1394349933,
-0.5812194347,
0.1524211913,
-0.1387801319,
-0.113608852,
0.0483306088,
0.1576863378,
0.2684995234,
0.109354943,
-0.5941685438,
0.2865752876,
-0.1244477779,
-0.2360447943,
0.5082233548,
0.2320925444,
0.3818350732,
0.2028734535,
-0.1420168579,
-0.3816245198,
-0.4200518727,
0.111404188,
0.6494710445,
0.4979632795,
-0.0992786586,
0.3643069863,
-0.2085118592,
1.0798956156,
0.3717015982,
-0.3797925115,
0.2378359586,
-0.3751767576,
-0.2026509494,
0.2502025664,
0.537853837,
0.4147481918,
0.2437445223,
-0.218985498,
-0.4097339213,
0.0798936263,
0.4600428641,
-0.670113802,
0.1765880734,
0.1721509844,
-0.6708952188,
-0.5736595392,
-0.1008977368,
-0.9003370404,
0.0492093153,
-0.481846571,
0.1132616326,
0.1028622612,
-0.3449327052,
0.2085904032,
0.1109176129,
0.2846907675,
-0.0554326661,
-1.3541922569,
0.2758409083,
0.7319524288,
0.7153872848,
0.0913642049,
-0.3700860143,
-0.5482361317,
0.1649884433,
-0.4362077713,
0.4718079865,
-0.756049633,
0.0071842927,
-0.0907623768,
0.0346113853,
-0.1923786253,
-0.4266019464,
0.4827997386,
-0.8417778611,
0.2649592161,
-0.1667863876,
-0.3402292728,
-0.0944955721,
0.2745833397,
-0.6826276183,
0.7968617082,
0.4051535428,
-0.5761445761,
0.4621472657,
-0.3562396765,
-0.1357920021,
-0.4149312675,
-0.0395604782,
-0.7990899086,
-0.0076078703,
0.4395812452,
0.07289581,
0.0125278672,
0.4257455468,
-0.1547738463,
-0.4309788048,
0.1828707457,
-0.3164715767,
0.408988893,
0.4440740347,
-0.3599376678,
0.395755887,
-0.7672505379,
0.0283486731,
0.2001240999,
-0.5087662339,
-0.358058244,
0.0999288782,
-0.1060165167,
0.23550421,
0.3234224319,
-0.5595921278,
0.4273762107,
-0.839892745,
0.3559933305,
0.9292391539,
-0.1196186766,
0.6071364284,
-0.3309910595,
0.8276979923,
-0.0063978001,
0.3080275059,
0.4271301031,
-0.1562998146,
-0.6372872591,
-0.1848742068,
0.8034368157,
0.5552905202,
-0.2056147754,
0.6692997217,
-0.50587672,
-0.1583860964,
-1.1090180874,
0.0484528095,
0.6470533609,
0.5110536218,
0.3906224668,
-0.232074216,
-0.4926646352,
-0.9944167733,
-0.194699198,
0.1202230975,
0.0514401533,
0.1797225922,
-0.1071858779,
-0.2831590474,
1.0008157492,
-0.4851476848,
-0.2002679408,
-0.1757107824,
0.0816466212,
0.0875916183,
0.420242846,
0.421439141,
-0.6556358337,
-0.373618871,
0.0108907009,
-0.421310395,
-0.1214900389,
-0.3661443889,
-0.2144504339,
0.2930048108,
0.2674399912,
-0.0502356067,
0.2395563424,
0.8383871317,
-0.4112925529,
0.4082023501,
-0.1537460685,
0.2952721715,
-0.8656476736,
0.117678754,
-0.1853895187,
-0.3162977993,
-0.5739193559,
-0.1113083661,
0.1875203997,
-0.148591131,
-0.1956832111,
0.739656508,
-0.5141721368,
-0.2795554996,
-0.1281463355,
0.1968160868,
0.0715268999,
0.6902961135,
0.1476499438,
0.7468869686,
0.0794857517,
-0.5325959325,
0.263338536,
0.2433794886,
-0.1859900355,
0.2276234776,
-0.4636830688,
0.1644504815,
-0.1618411392,
0.1147235855,
-0.7585433722,
-0.1527108252,
0.2222891003,
-0.3178999126,
0.3529089987,
-0.3264198005,
-0.1383828521,
-0.0018158369,
-0.1660354733,
1.0170353651,
0.3957560658,
-0.7303416133,
0.5851376057,
0.3374620676,
0.0432905555,
-1.1091866493,
-0.3194765449,
-0.0599889718,
-0.2380668372,
-0.5237786174,
0.4397781491,
0.1168873161,
-0.3251748383,
-0.0434734263,
-0.1175002158,
0.1000790149,
0.2159498483,
0.1513379365,
0.4411697984,
-0.0876059607,
-0.1856022477,
0.115328908,
-0.4001314938,
-0.3290221989,
-0.1889335662,
0.5334899426,
0.0671474114,
-0.3548603654,
-0.7516542077,
0.0790407881,
0.4802817702,
-0.5484190583,
0.7762554884,
0.5912044048,
-0.3470365405,
0.0921175927,
-0.5278514624,
-0.4463680685,
-0.4188163579,
0.2165833861,
-0.3377234936,
-0.7307263613,
0.5564633012,
0.2608793676,
0.2579018772,
0.1201042309,
0.4370388985,
0.2143966556,
1.6603649855,
0.6938532591,
-0.2640126348,
0.698800385,
0.0110964468,
0.5245146155,
-0.7176795006,
-0.1880406439,
-0.6189664006,
-0.7454356551,
-0.297136575,
-0.0409477092,
0.0152783617,
0.038639009,
-0.1446271688,
0.3171289861,
-0.6169779301,
0.6380425096,
0.414372921,
0.0021723893,
0.1958423406,
0.0950221717,
-0.015683312,
-0.3320499063,
-0.6513394117,
-0.4780947268,
0.9345484376,
0.5931340456,
0.8472038507,
0.1900581419,
0.7497637272,
0.006333583,
0.0505121388,
-0.8547808528,
0.2866871059,
0.0110705635,
-0.3434733152,
-0.6236340404,
-0.5652979612,
-0.9793613553,
0.182839483,
-0.3152893782,
-0.4324585497,
0.4717875421,
0.2788704038,
-0.8660880923,
0.3873587549,
-0.6125913858,
1.0353839397,
-0.1796745956,
-0.192357406,
-0.3284299076,
-0.7957732081,
0.2199756503,
0.1163889468,
0.2936435342,
-0.2170359343,
0.123153381,
0.9171162844,
-0.2634994388,
0.6916378736,
-0.1735445261,
-0.3775621951,
-0.3078344762,
0.3851006031,
0.525868535,
-0.2097270489,
0.0861563757,
-0.1293119639,
0.2410575747,
-0.5574694872,
-0.8315973282,
0.6875647306,
-0.9248209,
-0.4449279606,
-0.3381373882,
-0.6925899982,
-0.3219253421,
0.128450945,
-0.1937225908,
0.4623280168,
-0.1625776142,
-0.274589628,
0.6813038588,
0.0076040165,
0.2053047866,
0.4609649479,
-0.2426946312,
-0.1881057024,
1.2376670837,
-0.0653651655,
0.4594065249,
0.6431233883,
0.1232531667,
-0.3262814879,
-0.4318520129,
-0.5599651933,
0.4012441933,
-0.2879611254,
-0.0972513482,
-0.3742323518,
-0.1016611308,
-0.4156797826,
-0.4004944265,
-0.5684911013,
-0.5858110785,
-0.3411768079,
-0.0858370215,
-0.1328966022,
0.416957438,
-0.0743488148,
0.278452456,
-0.9898175001,
0.3158259392,
0.4430939555,
0.5798305869,
-0.0688913539,
-0.6600288153,
-0.4508198202,
0.0012152133,
0.0637978613,
-0.6767139435,
0.4827023745,
-0.1242263764,
0.3558730185,
0.6243768334,
-0.1761980206,
0.7377440333,
-0.2873215675,
0.5811451674,
-0.0037457226,
-0.7288731337,
0.2964387834,
-0.1639242023,
0.2777582407,
0.5227456689,
0.1432765126,
-0.8312991261,
-0.2072624564,
-0.5636510253,
-0.6113324761,
0.8155691028,
-0.1878867745,
-0.0420488417,
0.2245033681,
0.4811909497,
-0.1721657664,
-0.0710329041,
-0.3948523402,
-0.1510047317,
-0.2425885797,
-0.4216660857,
0.1040093899,
-0.433465004,
-0.5147688985,
-0.0661313236,
0.7223163247,
-0.1799874604,
0.0710298941,
-0.1048169136,
-0.1193272173,
-0.605740726,
0.4178714156,
0.865619719,
0.9691607356,
-0.5947963595,
0.0735201165,
0.0143441372,
-0.1256181747,
0.4720662534,
-0.1098736599,
-0.1931789517,
-0.2298169732,
0.2750757337,
0.8899220228,
0.2698499262,
-0.679810226,
0.4557933211,
-0.3384844065,
-0.1214154288,
0.3202782571,
0.1467941552,
-0.2600490153,
0.1362814903,
-0.1144065559,
-0.0904951245,
-0.2712336779,
-0.2444645166,
0.0430458561,
0.4167582691,
-0.4849259257,
-0.4044064581,
0.736343503,
0.1955471188,
-0.2901872098,
0.7601615787,
-0.0570237599,
-0.4135782719,
0.604741931,
0.545552969,
0.9002148509,
-0.3783155978,
0.074001953,
0.6793466806,
0.1794735491,
-0.2407854199,
0.0044333842,
0.0656804815,
-1.0037910938,
-0.507707417,
-0.7350557446,
-0.1301746666,
0.0028855556,
-0.8267023563,
0.064708367,
-0.5983994007,
-0.3470871449,
-0.2086038738,
-0.1205527112,
-0.2909599543,
0.1230671108,
-0.0543441772,
0.6694540381,
-0.9420018792,
0.7398786545,
0.4538716674,
-0.4045979977,
-0.8998372555,
0.1087826192,
0.1140303761,
-0.6631357074,
0.6320688725,
-0.245303303,
-0.2114939839,
0.2201230228,
-0.4352852404,
-0.8135409951,
0.9888626337,
0.4373182654,
-0.9258586764,
-0.3943594694,
-0.2415250242,
0.5034090281,
-0.3423828185,
-0.0485773459,
0.8757514358,
0.5976266265,
-0.3665424287,
-1.0159028769,
0.169588536,
0.1690280437,
0.1606845409,
0.4540560544,
-0.7656672001,
0.3986053765,
-0.3271902204,
-0.4934666157,
-0.1526553035,
0.7668257952,
0.1109863967,
-0.3038606644,
0.6967089772,
0.8747192621,
0.4818745255,
-0.0463601314,
0.7346728444,
-0.3883206546,
0.4224597514,
1.0029425621,
-0.0159656405,
0.6228801608,
0.6160088181,
-0.1785462201,
0.4067023396,
0.7052176595,
0.1015452743,
0.5684476495,
0.1166833639,
-0.1244102269,
-0.5680038929,
-0.1522365808,
-0.3149335384,
0.1965055615,
0.027126858,
-0.0242502932,
-0.3351783156,
-0.1585259885,
0.0418465808,
0.413005054,
0.0791795999,
0.862549901,
-0.3450109065,
-0.8125061393,
0.9637127519,
0.3650858998,
0.5415435433,
-0.5651304722,
-0.1515874118,
-0.3887571692,
0.1944753677,
-0.3070913255,
-0.5631003976,
0.2582306266,
-0.2842513323,
-0.5093844533,
-0.2646363378,
0.2275371701,
-0.7079267502,
-0.1829349101,
0.3069694936,
0.0920353681,
-0.1493236274,
0.3192259967,
-0.7699015141,
0.2798809707,
0.1822942048,
-0.1666558236,
0.5223113298,
-0.131439507,
-0.2262062877,
0.7829737663,
0.6695104837,
0.2350263149,
-0.0423429869,
0.3950673342,
0.665387392,
-0.7309919,
-0.4638373852,
-0.819622159,
0.064217411,
0.2596017718,
-0.0311805736,
0.5093162656,
0.4589708745,
0.9051329494,
0.0178742185,
0.4513027966,
0.2702753842,
0.5473424196,
-0.5278502107,
0.5464494824,
-0.573314786,
0.1949581355,
0.0449065566,
-0.8955830336,
-0.4466710687,
0.5402060151,
-0.2660838664,
-0.1752970219,
0.4307742715,
1.1346124411,
-0.234805882,
-0.5334159732,
0.2315498739,
-0.1337664574,
0.4925475419,
0.5088569522,
0.5895897746,
-0.1216914505,
0.4233935475,
-0.3134672642,
-0.3740176857,
-0.308668524,
-0.7492670417,
-0.6052327752,
-0.5261136889,
-0.2532534897,
-0.4952163994,
0.0802626088,
1.1463633776,
0.8919629455,
-0.9383336306,
-0.2566692829,
0.3786107004,
0.4283648133,
-0.6721812487,
-0.2696590722,
0.4593206346,
-0.5595985651,
-0.9684054852,
0.5077651739,
0.2444706112,
0.1357809901,
-0.3703994751,
-0.3034755588,
-0.4105257392,
0.1182821542,
0.0610607676,
0.6656163931,
-0.6183688045,
-0.4182819724,
-0.0917299986,
-0.2792205811,
0.0960863829,
0.8400660753,
-0.657016933,
0.6456524134,
0.6766418815,
0.8625752926,
0.1049814373,
0.5069092512,
0.8686339259,
-0.9153781533,
0.2899506986,
0.0101344576,
0.1114266291,
0.1537673622,
-0.3899427354,
0.3363436162,
0.1865812689,
-0.6287437081,
-1.0640611649,
0.3251512349,
-0.7192739248,
-0.1568616182,
0.927613616,
0.167740196,
-0.4095087051,
-0.1056661457,
-0.2818305194,
0.4885790646,
-0.4981122315,
1.0824410915,
0.7917292118,
-0.0510767251,
-0.0640360713,
-0.2668811083,
0.9216194749,
0.6405966878,
-0.6256338358,
0.3389953375,
0.4213024378,
0.2842845321,
0.1115324572,
0.5194581747,
-0.170808658,
0.1000273079,
-0.4520491064,
0.160563156,
-0.1117573604,
-0.4482778013,
-0.6208449006,
-0.1335092336,
0.3159348071,
-0.2620932758
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02987v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02987v1
|
Conversation Reconstruction Attack Against GPT Models
| 2024-02-05T13:18:42 | 2024-02-05T13:18:42 |
Junjie Chu, Zeyang Sha, Michael Backes, Yang Zhang
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In recent times, significant advancements have been made in the field of
large language models (LLMs), represented by GPT series models. To optimize
task execution, users often engage in multi-round conversations with GPT models
hosted in cloud environments. These multi-round conversations, potentially
replete with private information, require transmission and storage within the
cloud. However, this operational paradigm introduces additional attack
surfaces. In this paper, we first introduce a specific Conversation
Reconstruction Attack targeting GPT models. Our introduced Conversation
Reconstruction Attack is composed of two steps: hijacking a session and
reconstructing the conversations. Subsequently, we offer an exhaustive
evaluation of the privacy risks inherent in conversations when GPT models are
subjected to the proposed attack. However, GPT-4 demonstrates certain
robustness to the proposed attacks. We then introduce two advanced attacks
aimed at better reconstructing previous conversations, specifically the UNR
attack and the PBU attack. Our experimental findings indicate that the PBU
attack yields substantial performance across all models, achieving semantic
similarity scores exceeding 0.60, while the UNR attack is effective solely on
GPT-3.5. Our results reveal the concern about privacy risks associated with
conversations involving GPT models and aim to draw the community's attention to
prevent the potential misuse of these models' remarkable capabilities. We will
responsibly disclose our findings to the suppliers of related large language
models.
|
[
-0.3969497681,
-1.1382539272,
0.5794873238,
-0.1796175092,
-0.1915792823,
0.1677730381,
0.0762455761,
-0.6167961955,
-0.0665329322,
1.0790561438,
-0.5685216188,
-0.3183845282,
-0.6363446116,
-0.2421164215,
-0.8437651992,
1.0654247999,
0.4861772358,
-0.3300564885,
0.0580510609,
0.1789249927,
-0.4864737391,
-0.9598532319,
-0.7418667078,
0.196060881,
0.237931475,
-0.0237641707,
0.874063313,
0.2299621254,
0.5685353875,
0.4504589736,
-0.0857451856,
-0.2980391383,
-0.8929287195,
0.4198584259,
0.1294738203,
-0.1976583749,
-0.6885789633,
-0.2601363957,
0.6260594726,
0.3697444797,
-0.3502287269,
-0.1420624405,
0.1360203326,
0.5358669758,
-0.3422548473,
-0.0214426387,
-1.2751845121,
-0.15581958,
-0.1417904198,
-0.047922723,
-0.5180722475,
-0.0189679712,
0.2197521478,
-0.2037148327,
0.5224529505,
-0.0230374523,
0.873752296,
0.0160160102,
-0.2341237217,
-0.1583931148,
-0.6474255919,
0.5145282149,
-0.8122703433,
0.1992319226,
0.3713786304,
0.3687527478,
-0.64148283,
-0.7080731392,
-0.5494838357,
-0.1650172472,
-0.1923424751,
0.0853837281,
-0.6727338433,
0.239983201,
0.4046684504,
0.5287293792,
-0.6558411717,
0.1852178872,
-0.3942230344,
-0.3703481853,
0.5461211801,
0.4035057127,
0.0528067499,
-0.3609623909,
-0.5260677934,
0.0914200842,
-0.7820738554,
-0.2921174765,
0.5284689069,
0.2267858535,
-0.2068249285,
0.3105006218,
-0.227232039,
0.7793174386,
-0.1079712957,
-0.0550859682,
-0.2897051275,
-0.5623083711,
-0.4184156656,
-0.1840890348,
1.0590891838,
0.2595140338,
0.0601260588,
-0.2755821347,
-0.0155554703,
-0.3552408516,
0.5717218518,
-0.9497395158,
-0.4210351706,
0.3537514508,
-0.1255565137,
-0.23448053,
0.1656702012,
-1.1039421558,
-0.5536429882,
0.167765066,
0.0722754672,
-0.2208261788,
-0.2274952829,
0.2381648272,
0.393887043,
0.310069859,
0.3483006358,
-0.8655388355,
0.4823460579,
1.1078692675,
0.734497726,
0.0374117978,
-0.1148452014,
-0.3280436695,
0.2715707421,
-0.1829093844,
0.5827727914,
-0.2458156794,
-0.8876074553,
-0.0378746055,
0.0403641649,
-0.047132317,
-0.2211682349,
0.3493420184,
-0.7626258731,
0.462122947,
-0.2417450696,
-0.5816771388,
-0.284085989,
0.6267558932,
-0.6728460193,
0.5771232247,
-0.1227791533,
-0.919484973,
-0.1396887898,
-0.567782402,
-0.2278627306,
0.0641595796,
-0.1848245412,
-0.5726331472,
0.0738160089,
0.3176834285,
0.6589984894,
-0.3211713731,
-0.0248221382,
-0.4987959564,
-0.0681503639,
0.4466633797,
-0.634649992,
0.6164152026,
0.1487254351,
-0.299661696,
0.0676212683,
-0.551358521,
0.007728836,
0.2527876794,
0.1414423883,
-0.174579218,
-0.1022854447,
-0.3240780234,
-0.1144662201,
0.183548674,
-0.6088577509,
0.2123984247,
-0.2814494669,
0.6601091623,
0.830389142,
0.5240913033,
0.1702702641,
-0.2399052083,
0.5944035053,
-0.1943418533,
0.2695220411,
-0.2150164396,
-0.6039217114,
-0.3714211583,
-0.3891525567,
0.0171989501,
0.4226756692,
-0.4628939033,
0.1824238002,
-0.4818151593,
-0.6201119423,
-0.4046775699,
-0.25240165,
0.3715971708,
0.3871256113,
0.0111238547,
-0.231698215,
-0.2610042393,
-0.9264737964,
-0.4457240701,
-0.1847692877,
-0.1911536604,
0.4845065176,
0.307485044,
-0.1059385911,
0.9395121336,
-0.6846414208,
-0.2132714093,
0.0181310885,
-0.0692750439,
0.028059667,
0.4763843715,
0.6857441664,
-0.736104846,
-0.4958242178,
-0.0869642422,
-0.5233744979,
0.2958135009,
-0.2848065197,
-0.1726400256,
0.2728412747,
0.3533239663,
-0.8537042737,
0.537476182,
0.6712101698,
-0.2780300975,
0.2594225705,
-0.166275844,
0.2629413903,
-1.1753977537,
-0.1704005301,
-0.4203322828,
-0.3455575109,
-0.9060814977,
0.0900685713,
-0.2350454032,
-0.4609118104,
-0.5521396399,
0.2373750508,
-0.58589679,
-0.3045200109,
-0.3302327693,
-0.0650685653,
-0.0971985385,
0.441645354,
-0.0443058498,
0.9157118797,
0.5408192873,
-0.4191206992,
0.3320246637,
0.4658271074,
-0.3149467111,
0.4019162953,
-0.6737321019,
1.0326601267,
0.0850800276,
0.2309613228,
-1.0558428764,
-0.1744014025,
0.3328482509,
-0.6728394628,
0.32956779,
-0.2613292933,
-0.4652140737,
0.0049331579,
-0.3644280136,
0.0404226407,
0.4122774899,
-0.3600829542,
0.685847044,
0.7325567603,
-0.4350636303,
-0.4855687916,
-0.5351086855,
0.4879125655,
-0.4586967826,
-0.7067348957,
0.1831389368,
0.1641837806,
-0.0964233354,
-0.1435060054,
-0.0643209442,
-0.0361813456,
0.3017137945,
0.3953502476,
0.1652910411,
0.0156919099,
-0.6180006266,
-0.4810415506,
-0.0916920304,
0.2023489624,
-0.0474979877,
0.7124941945,
-0.2563441992,
-0.5356814861,
-0.4985375702,
0.5960695148,
0.6336877942,
-0.0196748208,
0.7550835013,
0.4557835162,
-0.4334740937,
0.3335044086,
-0.800991118,
-0.3655102253,
-0.5208948851,
0.7581120133,
-0.3990747333,
-1.1295303106,
0.5464853048,
0.3897260129,
0.2155981362,
0.0402743965,
0.5521165133,
-0.0525970086,
0.867213726,
0.6039385796,
-0.3973940909,
0.5180758834,
-0.0762435049,
0.2353521734,
-0.8028385639,
-0.1142975539,
-0.6311253905,
0.0563414097,
-0.7121493816,
-0.0849519074,
0.1870139837,
-0.1867363155,
-0.2887116969,
0.4639127553,
-0.2476076633,
0.5021131635,
0.3655828536,
0.0956841633,
0.3533929288,
0.223135978,
0.5887829065,
-0.0964225754,
-0.5523727536,
-0.4888629317,
1.2058639526,
0.4697465599,
0.6876143813,
0.4206969738,
0.6636461616,
0.0594262145,
0.2448268086,
-0.5666664243,
0.8329995871,
0.1172870174,
-0.5990382433,
-0.3203266263,
-0.6380230784,
-1.1702661514,
0.5913255215,
-0.0624633096,
-1.1063028574,
-0.1827563196,
0.0146747166,
-0.4042496979,
0.5399534106,
-0.6415113807,
0.9014756083,
-0.1469390243,
-0.2380867898,
-0.3096864223,
-0.5728294253,
0.5668087006,
-0.3127300739,
0.2521666586,
0.0345877483,
0.2724756896,
0.5152358413,
-0.379779458,
1.0003637075,
-0.1392569393,
-0.0955131799,
0.2517265975,
0.2698420286,
0.7357206345,
0.1564175636,
0.3353484273,
0.4125854373,
0.1193812191,
-0.4241886437,
-0.4821878672,
0.7084779143,
-0.6131073833,
-1.1222305298,
-0.5346112251,
-0.4538632333,
-0.204666838,
0.0822016448,
0.076477088,
0.298963815,
-0.4673314989,
0.2753936648,
0.4106208384,
-0.2407839,
0.350508064,
0.6545639038,
-0.1056140587,
-0.4699810743,
0.6022273898,
-0.2726376355,
0.7416164279,
0.1772803068,
-0.1108777374,
-0.2727998197,
-0.864567101,
-0.0277610514,
0.2558094561,
-0.5189005733,
-0.2671683729,
-0.7359773517,
-0.097497575,
-0.5093919039,
0.2715414166,
-0.3901213408,
-0.2010361999,
0.0058242786,
-0.1659465283,
0.3759909868,
0.5523893237,
0.2838371098,
0.5925955772,
-1.0411481857,
0.2510664165,
0.2636934519,
0.0232166015,
-0.0902064815,
-0.5404825211,
0.250159353,
0.1565178484,
-0.5172557831,
-0.9507003427,
0.4539411068,
-0.0302996654,
0.3687298298,
0.1667248309,
0.0164971203,
0.7610657215,
-0.5431061983,
0.8510375619,
0.0218279511,
-0.7029455304,
0.1557269394,
-0.4200142622,
0.1875825822,
0.5478553772,
0.1349506974,
-0.4914540648,
-0.5081824064,
-1.1065182686,
-0.6908950806,
0.655272007,
0.3933368325,
0.4332518876,
0.0954680443,
0.2882576585,
-0.0290813837,
0.3207714856,
-0.6080335975,
0.0060890019,
-0.1542208195,
0.1764912903,
0.144493714,
-0.3310227394,
-0.1555745602,
0.1349369735,
0.6933128238,
0.1890914738,
0.3956183195,
0.0125586549,
0.0174248107,
0.3663465679,
0.3980634212,
0.3392437398,
0.3456750512,
-0.0099074757,
-0.1597148031,
0.0803692415,
-0.707443893,
-0.1299584657,
0.3282318115,
-0.2607238293,
-0.1169743165,
0.1735284925,
0.8596311808,
0.3732862175,
-0.3372913897,
0.4597083628,
-0.3061038852,
-0.1263848245,
-0.4780751169,
-0.2410286218,
0.2198392749,
0.1148684993,
0.0033915369,
-0.1456559747,
0.0240113735,
-0.536249578,
0.0958632082,
0.7815623283,
-0.2855956256,
-0.3357945681,
0.4514244497,
0.0188373048,
-0.3502386808,
0.8978082538,
0.1079148576,
-0.6965509653,
0.3893270195,
0.5090127587,
0.8617587686,
-0.3746777475,
-0.1301415414,
0.0788905174,
0.3437884152,
0.0321967639,
-0.0351334885,
0.0434015803,
-0.6708819866,
-0.2390790284,
-0.3186508417,
-0.6353672147,
0.6010922194,
-0.6975877285,
-0.0721072406,
-0.480517149,
-0.2189816535,
-0.117816709,
-0.2811181247,
-0.5237763524,
-0.2384024411,
0.0404627062,
0.3067100346,
-0.3343312144,
0.8927950263,
0.184785977,
-0.123618491,
-0.5515301228,
-0.0082013812,
0.1948980093,
-0.6997440457,
0.1201586202,
0.0687283799,
-0.1436540931,
0.0436312109,
-0.3006811142,
-0.7632178068,
0.9947047234,
0.5560509562,
-0.7836915255,
-0.0660843626,
0.3982368112,
0.3104172051,
0.0632548332,
-0.0109270662,
0.6038417816,
0.166624248,
0.0383640118,
-1.0299158096,
0.1254290938,
0.1803204864,
-0.1225110739,
0.3189355731,
-0.5083752871,
0.633895278,
-0.032230176,
-0.4940763414,
0.2397624254,
0.64676404,
0.1961555332,
-0.1599257141,
0.4478280842,
0.298728466,
0.6896170974,
-0.1421067417,
1.2739646435,
-0.1969624311,
0.4798884988,
1.1266851425,
-0.3307864964,
0.8222334385,
0.3940315247,
-0.2961733639,
-0.0858047456,
0.5458126664,
-0.0336291194,
0.5089228749,
0.1420079768,
-0.2675748765,
0.0137563329,
0.397944659,
-0.5490633249,
0.4252997637,
0.4000796378,
-0.0300664771,
-0.1374536306,
-0.1722240895,
0.536344707,
0.0106197456,
-0.1311675757,
1.101657629,
0.1694075465,
-0.5413783193,
0.5986038446,
0.0137126455,
0.5620751977,
-0.7105873823,
0.1704377681,
-0.2153729051,
0.2804757357,
-0.080642648,
-0.4719629288,
0.4504831135,
-0.0170671679,
0.2507879138,
0.0371659957,
0.7003607154,
-0.3929116726,
-0.1791689396,
0.0726223662,
0.3364687264,
0.3013097644,
-0.5309868455,
-0.7655422091,
0.1431591362,
0.1838440448,
-0.4509541392,
0.6910284758,
0.1661263108,
-0.0090903854,
0.647562027,
0.6874133945,
0.051575508,
-0.0326297805,
0.0031536452,
0.710858047,
-0.6091396213,
-0.6010093093,
-1.092237711,
0.1855814308,
-0.2933851182,
0.1055446491,
0.7977304459,
0.5276263952,
0.8475794196,
0.0120105231,
0.8119112849,
0.3468052447,
0.5854530334,
-0.7590549588,
0.7939718366,
0.133716464,
0.6178357601,
-0.4523003995,
-0.8412001729,
-0.1515475214,
0.2723712921,
-0.4156925082,
0.0345274918,
0.7114565969,
0.9906941056,
-0.0257353559,
0.6042881012,
0.2228629589,
0.424877733,
0.8734895587,
0.6732307076,
0.9635506868,
-0.3559579849,
0.7338221669,
-0.1148053333,
-0.1544725895,
0.1492966413,
-0.9674380422,
-0.8552008867,
-0.3726028204,
-0.2677116394,
-0.5014327765,
0.2148816586,
0.3042119741,
0.5037925243,
-0.6549406052,
-0.1433643699,
-0.0267763287,
-0.391617626,
0.078586325,
-0.1614172459,
0.5653138161,
0.132058084,
-0.6693298221,
0.4501363337,
-0.0337655023,
0.2896656096,
-0.2301353216,
0.2253161073,
0.130097568,
-0.1444524378,
0.2429960668,
0.4207608402,
-0.8122414351,
-0.5045195818,
-0.2145955563,
-0.0153034301,
0.1202482209,
0.9409013987,
-0.6428300738,
0.0803651214,
0.1283315271,
1.0670616627,
0.8487426639,
0.2842971683,
0.608232975,
-0.5932253599,
0.2849714756,
0.1949653029,
0.4817271531,
0.6463882923,
-0.5859918594,
0.2468750626,
0.1379417628,
-0.51955688,
-0.9741823077,
0.5075320601,
-0.9854254127,
-0.3179346919,
1.1169377565,
-0.3032135665,
-0.0592124499,
-0.191078499,
-0.4071620405,
-0.1075411737,
-0.3045358062,
0.8924945593,
0.7025963068,
0.0450231321,
0.033674188,
-0.8742716908,
0.4511837959,
0.2716028392,
-0.8915238976,
0.5718206167,
0.5162924528,
0.4307844341,
-0.0715247542,
0.7404752374,
-0.6141006947,
-0.0200872198,
-0.0791969001,
-0.3501548767,
-0.2415110469,
0.0217380766,
-0.421605736,
0.5867272019,
-0.0470225438,
-0.3653534055
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02975v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02975v1
|
Putting Context in Context: the Impact of Discussion Structure on Text Classification
| 2024-02-05T12:56:22 | 2024-02-05T12:56:22 |
Nicolò Penzo, Antonio Longa, Bruno Lepri, Sara Tonelli, Marco Guerini
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Current text classification approaches usually focus on the content to be
classified. Contextual aspects (both linguistic and extra-linguistic) are
usually neglected, even in tasks based on online discussions. Still in many
cases the multi-party and multi-turn nature of the context from which these
elements are selected can be fruitfully exploited. In this work, we propose a
series of experiments on a large dataset for stance detection in English, in
which we evaluate the contribution of different types of contextual
information, i.e. linguistic, structural and temporal, by feeding them as
natural language input into a transformer-based model. We also experiment with
different amounts of training data and analyse the topology of local discussion
networks in a privacy-compliant way. Results show that structural information
can be highly beneficial to text classification but only under certain
circumstances (e.g. depending on the amount of training data and on discussion
chain complexity). Indeed, we show that contextual information on smaller
datasets from other classification tasks does not yield significant
improvements. Our framework, based on local discussion networks, allows the
integration of structural information, while minimising user profiling, thus
preserving their privacy.
|
[
-0.537263155,
-0.8129470348,
0.4361628294,
0.1520126164,
-0.2684431672,
-0.3832019866,
-0.2117737383,
-0.5343467593,
0.3579072058,
0.3954676688,
-0.0314565711,
-0.4265313447,
-0.6384225488,
0.123944819,
-0.426330924,
1.3942404985,
-0.0144158415,
0.0368090682,
-0.206905514,
-0.4932943881,
-0.4083789885,
-0.7983679771,
-0.6247807145,
-0.1278978884,
0.7087002993,
0.2345992178,
0.5959802866,
0.5969803929,
0.1566634923,
0.419829458,
-0.584790647,
-0.2481562048,
-0.1563323587,
0.4679962397,
-0.3738706112,
-0.6441471577,
-0.2964697182,
0.0731808767,
0.7010177374,
0.6315332055,
-0.0087907929,
-0.2050012946,
0.3537592292,
0.3743907213,
-0.4543064535,
0.191395089,
-0.2231482118,
0.3118240237,
-0.3108745217,
-0.2908942401,
-0.5610764027,
-0.1043038368,
0.3212253153,
-0.0037926929,
0.258315444,
0.0026379584,
0.7630977035,
0.0011038629,
-0.8400176764,
-0.3597447574,
-0.4604669213,
0.6780754924,
-0.5465180278,
0.3796000779,
0.4137898684,
0.0176200904,
-0.0332514383,
-0.5532100797,
-0.6475778818,
0.0923938975,
-0.5965029597,
0.0899717733,
-0.1203203499,
0.0115978122,
0.0837659687,
0.3240836263,
-0.3259322643,
0.0166848712,
-0.2438728809,
-0.0413995944,
0.4593763947,
-0.0361442566,
0.2292210162,
-0.8805484772,
-0.326798141,
-0.1182959974,
-0.3946418166,
0.4314923882,
0.303214699,
0.4392168522,
-0.1660200506,
0.4131923914,
-0.1963495463,
0.4885462523,
0.2522047758,
-0.1018144488,
0.2187948972,
-0.3456870317,
-0.176140368,
0.0092790416,
0.8394345045,
0.413280338,
-0.2692657709,
0.0118552204,
0.0940579623,
0.0883345604,
0.2264458239,
-0.8561233282,
-0.1124775782,
0.1549413651,
-0.5377812386,
-0.4663395286,
0.275985539,
-0.662443459,
-0.5806122422,
-0.2816160321,
-0.0714705363,
-0.0611775815,
-0.1832735837,
-0.0596275181,
-0.2044055611,
0.5075610876,
0.3622831702,
-0.6806467772,
0.2597285807,
0.7389554381,
0.8086124659,
-0.3079574704,
-0.0666660368,
-0.2452874482,
0.1754782647,
-0.0204325169,
0.8487316966,
-0.6019265056,
-0.4324804246,
-0.0421493649,
0.2767828703,
0.0074494984,
-0.1882671267,
0.7267099023,
-0.2947832942,
0.9341351986,
-0.0995700508,
-0.5230599642,
-0.1295964271,
0.8127786517,
-0.7864761949,
1.0259104967,
-0.3651379347,
-1.3196775913,
0.5738592148,
-0.6799810529,
-0.8359953761,
0.0038468272,
-0.4956867099,
-0.4165543318,
-0.0497404784,
0.0078172684,
0.7032448053,
0.2493274361,
0.402515322,
-0.0619542114,
-0.0873444229,
0.4230053723,
-0.3767288029,
0.6772298813,
0.0569540337,
-0.7554427385,
0.2031305432,
-0.3781685233,
-0.2645561695,
-0.238243863,
-0.5148128867,
-0.7491157055,
0.3641288579,
-0.0244949069,
0.3766035736,
-0.0964403749,
-0.4626686275,
0.1125550121,
-0.7559129596,
0.4349860251,
0.53407377,
0.2568720877,
0.7048905492,
-0.2048358768,
0.4173169434,
0.2163681835,
0.1893646419,
-0.1238732338,
-0.6668553948,
-0.7439823747,
0.1618992239,
0.1732257903,
0.3743171096,
-0.5419572592,
0.52675879,
-0.3085999489,
-0.1895819455,
0.0616152398,
-0.1119320318,
0.4774333537,
0.309035778,
0.1021932513,
-0.2487956434,
-0.4066683948,
-0.8919919133,
-0.3160638213,
-0.3944711089,
0.0877642855,
0.3764754832,
0.3355408013,
-0.0853646174,
1.0662702322,
-0.2571649551,
-0.3807596862,
-0.403044939,
0.2494586706,
-0.1319438368,
0.2121821046,
0.5045199394,
-1.1942461729,
-0.5438116789,
0.1300128102,
-0.6197706461,
0.2329295725,
-0.0373720303,
-0.113709718,
0.2866281867,
0.5357489586,
-0.4841898084,
0.4578151703,
0.5231862664,
-0.4189888537,
-0.1253819913,
0.2111605257,
0.0607944317,
-1.5889034271,
-0.1861401945,
0.1374966651,
-0.4823834002,
-0.813012898,
0.0002304537,
-0.2387991995,
0.0307181031,
-0.4699602127,
0.6005812287,
-0.0838664919,
0.3128582835,
-0.2685888708,
0.4218647778,
0.1584628522,
0.5130779147,
0.4190627038,
0.4528106451,
0.256149739,
-0.667996645,
-0.1856131256,
0.4607547224,
-0.1852156818,
0.8130099773,
-0.3060905635,
0.2741016448,
-0.2639276683,
0.5588414669,
-0.9937070608,
-0.4186662138,
0.3216513693,
-0.5094951391,
0.2691851854,
-0.3299185336,
-0.2202665359,
0.1092175692,
-0.6994953752,
0.2236813605,
-0.0557791367,
-0.5180287957,
0.6062592864,
0.889529407,
-0.216656357,
-0.6398219466,
-0.7270063758,
0.1135032997,
-0.4949045479,
-0.4151901007,
0.2745822668,
0.2034737468,
-0.3394214511,
-0.1210817471,
-0.1880311668,
-0.2482991368,
0.0902859494,
0.5270915627,
-0.1319720298,
0.004361318,
0.284809947,
0.0663962588,
0.0015862893,
0.0625774041,
-0.1625129431,
0.3418242633,
-0.41558972,
-0.0485493727,
-0.4599480033,
0.4837417305,
0.4673316777,
0.1084388793,
0.821947515,
0.2344249785,
-0.1551965475,
-0.5066447854,
-0.1524966061,
-0.0823196396,
-0.4777339995,
0.2886822224,
-0.0220019743,
-1.2169913054,
0.2413526624,
-0.0023318806,
0.1846804172,
0.2621829212,
0.6133529544,
-0.4564252496,
1.0810725689,
0.7476006746,
-0.1633106321,
0.7093774676,
0.0665984154,
0.4286324978,
-0.478556633,
-0.2577864826,
-0.7277830243,
-0.5965505242,
-0.7420520186,
-0.3243697584,
0.2505529225,
-0.0934408978,
0.1729249954,
0.5195986032,
-0.6174602509,
0.5122480392,
-0.049970936,
0.0915862396,
0.1852506697,
-0.0752131119,
0.1748930216,
-0.1576607078,
-0.547513485,
-0.7233787775,
0.5359810591,
0.4285467565,
0.4058672786,
0.1400347054,
0.5071126223,
0.2742064893,
0.614883244,
-1.2431414127,
0.6303650737,
-0.0342623815,
-0.6462830901,
-0.2902577519,
-0.4127698541,
-1.1087919474,
0.4179239273,
0.095021151,
-0.6670447588,
0.4774871171,
0.1986397952,
0.1125789508,
0.3178531229,
-0.5105468035,
0.8864881992,
-0.0209167134,
-0.3586131334,
0.0209453534,
-0.7246978879,
0.0413264632,
0.2835520804,
0.5192711949,
0.3815985918,
0.2814789414,
0.9965663552,
-0.2552304268,
1.3281387091,
-0.3479489386,
-0.3364066482,
0.3152135313,
-0.0697147995,
0.4459248483,
0.0994746834,
0.1546331942,
0.0853360742,
-0.2084682286,
0.0223524533,
-0.6580145359,
0.4720514715,
-0.5718734264,
-0.6197555661,
-0.3330864608,
-0.1133308262,
-0.3544364572,
0.0793641582,
0.3920849562,
0.5147163272,
-0.2065601945,
0.7952458858,
0.7069302797,
0.1123407707,
0.3900962472,
0.3202176392,
-0.0501891486,
-0.0453235954,
0.6727790833,
-0.0265267715,
-0.2119412273,
0.6905681491,
0.5709468722,
-0.3727326989,
-0.3070837557,
0.0331176892,
-0.0479003303,
-1.138625145,
-0.2621114254,
-0.6902236342,
-0.0560487285,
-0.1938668042,
-0.3186539114,
-0.2158854902,
-0.6048297286,
0.1236402318,
-0.4775086343,
0.0065760906,
0.8365120292,
0.4977357388,
0.6072474718,
-0.4662642777,
-0.1745623201,
0.2042798102,
0.3622433543,
-0.2786492407,
-0.3933965564,
-0.1519075483,
-0.3981173038,
-0.3672754765,
-1.0820860863,
0.0806007534,
0.0449999087,
0.5138506889,
0.5443215966,
0.0996110514,
0.2214764953,
-0.2851650119,
0.8924915791,
-0.0378452092,
-0.9390999675,
0.7176390886,
-0.2630176246,
-0.0032830925,
0.7381496429,
0.5683782101,
-0.6237932444,
-0.7248386741,
-0.6208034158,
-0.7880102992,
0.7669208646,
0.2357715368,
0.4848274589,
-0.1715881526,
0.4228723645,
-0.0937211886,
0.252361834,
-1.3306254148,
-0.1182402074,
-0.274989903,
-0.0937388912,
0.2441787869,
-0.1566242278,
-0.3373601735,
-0.4225780666,
0.4435760081,
-0.2426638454,
0.1194386408,
0.2237330973,
-0.1451154202,
0.3171860874,
0.7358757854,
0.4285379648,
0.316834271,
0.2842072845,
0.3977987468,
0.3068669736,
-0.4519373477,
0.0823511705,
-0.4215830564,
-0.3090195358,
0.2330926657,
0.2774772942,
0.8460316658,
0.6536201835,
0.0125837773,
0.7609695792,
-0.2569586337,
-0.2969532311,
-0.0200012568,
0.1192413419,
-0.0778055936,
0.1122693568,
-0.2547803819,
0.0598164089,
0.325430125,
-0.6827999949,
0.3057235777,
0.3353548348,
-0.6010335684,
-0.5181772113,
0.2353684902,
0.2377568185,
-0.3488866985,
0.064043276,
-0.1504203826,
-0.8612368703,
0.3534734547,
0.3760753572,
0.8454734087,
-0.4089075923,
0.3840886354,
0.143512547,
0.0114324009,
-0.0124465581,
0.0039550136,
-0.5006220937,
-0.950674057,
-0.1638583988,
-0.5891262889,
-0.5768529177,
0.003745514,
-0.7105606198,
0.3261999786,
-0.6279742718,
-0.4389432073,
0.1025519297,
-0.1098301113,
-0.2565237582,
0.0477898978,
0.113900587,
0.6436535716,
-0.9056736827,
0.7969200015,
1.0457644463,
-0.0056232084,
-0.5922359824,
0.3331120908,
0.0395433344,
0.1358059347,
0.5287539363,
0.5250098109,
-0.5351905227,
-0.4828911722,
-0.687319994,
-0.3616703749,
0.7172401547,
0.0790809691,
-0.2507802844,
0.0587727763,
0.0393984951,
0.8261138797,
-0.107784912,
-0.0136586968,
0.1313334703,
0.4878180623,
0.127117902,
-0.7560779452,
-0.0409088917,
-0.4472012818,
-0.1930431873,
0.2805204093,
-0.7193996906,
0.7285993099,
0.5372536778,
-0.5475412011,
-0.4938462079,
0.6385851502,
-0.1570818126,
0.2446565926,
0.7326413989,
0.0664191544,
0.8231245875,
-0.1040774584,
1.2100116014,
-0.2940441072,
0.3097121119,
0.9644520283,
-0.3239482045,
1.0368632078,
0.4405514002,
0.0812808201,
0.8900585175,
0.3739416599,
0.2496757656,
0.355786413,
-0.0498285331,
-0.2519823015,
0.0577537715,
-0.0990414768,
-0.1111048684,
0.5311399102,
0.337700814,
-0.2099625915,
-0.1454980373,
0.0459017195,
0.4218989909,
0.21982871,
-0.1107726768,
0.9935572743,
0.0747252479,
-0.6920796633,
-0.158395052,
0.3606446683,
0.7624562383,
-0.4475758374,
0.2134848088,
-0.2696456611,
0.2021754533,
-0.5029463768,
-0.900013566,
0.6032854915,
0.0405276008,
-0.2279637456,
-0.4998332262,
0.7815610766,
-0.2536612153,
-0.0591915809,
0.333168,
0.2648440003,
0.0083687752,
0.1407917291,
-0.2986074388,
-0.2652016282,
-0.2615918517,
-0.6031483412,
0.5746762753,
0.5810605288,
-0.4231378138,
0.0963256434,
0.4263871908,
-0.4584048986,
-0.2440621257,
0.0318877697,
1.0101445913,
-0.6148884892,
-1.0667446852,
-0.8683710694,
0.4123385251,
-0.3512925208,
-0.3907410502,
1.0626431704,
0.4706465304,
0.8905729651,
0.4376756847,
0.5678527951,
-0.057434082,
0.1560508758,
-0.3771250546,
0.7742600441,
-0.3317635655,
0.1815268546,
-0.2536152303,
-0.7305468917,
-0.3754023015,
0.9230870605,
-0.4258335233,
-0.02484769,
0.7581536174,
0.3831767738,
-0.100022763,
0.545988977,
0.0636194199,
0.2140688896,
0.382860899,
0.0941236615,
0.9115625024,
-0.1895103306,
0.3813594878,
-0.1595871449,
-0.197359845,
0.0744601712,
-0.8711752892,
-1.1894420385,
-0.6956272125,
-0.4655136764,
-0.3975253403,
-0.3290863633,
0.7111334205,
0.773365736,
-0.996807754,
-0.2390498221,
-0.0968263075,
0.2546004951,
0.1590364426,
-0.3296861053,
0.3001944125,
-0.2664588988,
-0.6891020536,
0.5891608596,
0.3442808688,
-0.2193590254,
-0.1720193028,
0.0222314522,
-0.1934493333,
0.0478330404,
0.8490852118,
0.2344952226,
-0.4423095286,
-0.5387476683,
-0.0701093227,
-0.200765565,
0.3545230329,
1.1569199562,
-0.6648794413,
0.2219921649,
0.5850548744,
0.6441652775,
0.4853735864,
0.2160847783,
0.4199077189,
-1.4104113579,
0.3652393818,
0.1448075771,
0.4584007859,
0.3020699322,
-0.5882877111,
0.2524078786,
0.1726774126,
-0.313867867,
-0.7895781398,
0.2436771095,
-0.8279548287,
-0.4724979699,
1.049098134,
-0.0048387363,
-0.2819811702,
-0.5065054297,
-0.2494751215,
0.0839404017,
-0.1893474162,
0.6083184481,
0.8646746278,
-0.2450403869,
-0.0389524363,
-0.3626609445,
0.6210014224,
0.462946713,
-1.0045748949,
0.1969169378,
0.3658244014,
0.1563432813,
0.5520164967,
0.6163206697,
-0.2537558973,
-0.2205360681,
-0.3901494741,
-0.3647417426,
0.2918165624,
-0.649322629,
-0.594004035,
0.6966317892,
-0.2564069629,
0.1345839351
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02969v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02969v2
|
Towards Understanding the Word Sensitivity of Attention Layers: A Study via Random Features
| 2024-02-05T12:47:19 | 2024-05-17T15:31:34 |
Simone Bombari, Marco Mondelli
|
stat.ML
|
stat.ML, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Understanding the reasons behind the exceptional success of transformers
requires a better analysis of why attention layers are suitable for NLP tasks.
In particular, such tasks require predictive models to capture contextual
meaning which often depends on one or few words, even if the sentence is long.
Our work studies this key property, dubbed word sensitivity (WS), in the
prototypical setting of random features. We show that attention layers enjoy
high WS, namely, there exists a vector in the space of embeddings that largely
perturbs the random attention features map. The argument critically exploits
the role of the softmax in the attention layer, highlighting its benefit
compared to other activations (e.g., ReLU). In contrast, the WS of standard
random features is of order $1/\sqrt{n}$, $n$ being the number of words in the
textual sample, and thus it decays with the length of the context. We then
translate these results on the word sensitivity into generalization bounds: due
to their low WS, random features provably cannot learn to distinguish between
two sentences that differ only in a single word; in contrast, due to their high
WS, random attention features have higher generalization capabilities. We
validate our theoretical results with experimental evidence over the BERT-Base
word embeddings of the imdb review dataset.
|
[
-0.6579480767,
-0.7966130376,
0.340706706,
0.0909048021,
-0.0636958703,
-0.447527945,
-0.3929747939,
-0.3399574459,
0.1416212618,
0.3832424581,
-0.528437078,
-0.3245623708,
-0.8554816842,
0.0599308461,
-0.5493727922,
1.1559574604,
0.248896271,
-0.5315458775,
-0.0202701632,
-0.5159481168,
-0.1331907511,
-0.5259054899,
-0.2285408676,
-0.0416338295,
1.0273044109,
0.1493978351,
1.0155279636,
0.5165567994,
0.7056894898,
0.3143316507,
-0.1642748415,
-0.3049682975,
-0.4362255037,
0.2277814746,
-0.182071507,
-0.6217386127,
-0.0668283105,
-0.1039690226,
0.5104836822,
0.7416053414,
0.1135621741,
0.2668229938,
0.368553251,
0.5925855041,
-0.6779443026,
-0.1828347445,
-0.8831638098,
0.4890395999,
-0.2307429016,
-0.2445114255,
-0.2048226744,
0.2394761294,
0.6915288568,
-0.5017801523,
0.8350886106,
0.1710794866,
0.9063365459,
0.3041829467,
-0.2883160412,
0.0271162707,
-0.7177413702,
0.9815148115,
-0.2780465484,
0.1940936744,
0.1050141156,
-0.0505309328,
0.0955552459,
-0.6509408355,
-0.6189402938,
-0.231014654,
0.0706101581,
-0.0295487922,
-0.1616399437,
0.0383001082,
0.6133541465,
0.4336925447,
-0.2648667991,
0.0141642103,
-0.0697835311,
-0.401969105,
0.3192466795,
0.050615076,
0.0523250401,
-0.1034498289,
-0.5865966678,
-0.3540471196,
-0.276797533,
0.3530147076,
0.2498916537,
0.2899170816,
0.0351653323,
0.729287982,
0.0662843138,
0.5373157263,
-0.0954161957,
0.0080739763,
0.2119188607,
-0.0279388558,
-0.271728754,
-0.0650243089,
0.582942605,
0.3974813819,
0.6511713266,
-0.2193321884,
-0.201479733,
0.1314811707,
0.4934341311,
-0.4974035621,
0.1483088732,
0.2042610794,
-0.4277547896,
-0.3520741165,
-0.0169349983,
-0.5540089607,
-0.3705124259,
-0.0483465716,
0.4052035511,
-0.3239825666,
-0.0937298015,
0.1377455741,
-0.4601180255,
0.3611059785,
0.0275138393,
-0.8404266238,
0.1000847742,
0.5481950045,
0.6181234717,
-0.2358853072,
-0.3741069734,
-0.3547333479,
0.1871816069,
-0.0956044272,
0.8794593215,
-0.4612421691,
-0.0965088904,
0.1385299712,
-0.1475013047,
-0.2878502607,
-0.2579600811,
0.7972009778,
-0.3828010857,
0.1359282583,
-0.1783657968,
-0.3168771863,
-0.0857331604,
0.0562196486,
-0.5395488143,
0.812815845,
0.3498081267,
-1.2081077099,
0.5575285554,
-0.2981489301,
-0.6257442832,
-0.032597702,
-0.0160098653,
-0.2789917588,
0.6324393749,
0.1421423107,
0.4710624516,
0.0975141451,
-0.2212789208,
-0.4922281206,
-0.32788378,
0.7527043223,
-0.4500227273,
0.3177004457,
0.1755907387,
-0.2687132955,
0.0430538021,
-0.5451027751,
0.1239870265,
0.1135045215,
-0.3890314996,
-0.4509620667,
0.171978116,
0.1229946464,
0.3227672875,
-0.0630677268,
-0.486068368,
-0.1303520203,
-0.458286047,
0.4592383504,
0.7361955047,
-0.0130656557,
0.4605147541,
-0.2176931351,
0.6158396006,
0.337271899,
0.1558266133,
-0.0469633304,
-0.5435561538,
-0.6407678723,
-0.1691014469,
0.3913740218,
0.6735500097,
-0.37447384,
0.5779204965,
-0.333658576,
0.1350525171,
-0.7334787846,
0.3966727853,
0.367195636,
0.3685688078,
0.3228422999,
-0.6641820073,
-0.1838546693,
-1.2522268295,
-0.4483902454,
0.1945562959,
-0.5397185683,
0.5615383983,
0.0753268003,
-0.0253721345,
1.045420289,
-0.5573067069,
-0.7480689287,
-0.4948335588,
-0.1012263,
0.0611636676,
0.0500629768,
0.5186396837,
-0.8221389055,
-0.1257980764,
-0.2796184421,
-0.3757970929,
0.0635083169,
-0.0205444526,
-0.1298865676,
-0.0972830504,
0.5972650051,
-0.7341300845,
0.403055191,
0.3776940107,
-0.1866506934,
0.1499220729,
-0.1307621449,
-0.3829524219,
-0.8890891075,
0.1347867697,
0.4213296175,
-0.0745828003,
-0.5834810138,
0.0816521645,
-0.225192368,
-0.0310540479,
-0.5915676951,
0.147737205,
-0.2940993309,
-0.1591108888,
-0.1260004044,
0.5243769288,
0.0637972876,
0.7648376822,
-0.2030123472,
0.43613711,
0.2976867259,
-0.6478537917,
0.1509484351,
0.1927602738,
-0.4343092144,
0.3987904787,
-0.8314699531,
0.1346221715,
-0.3259437084,
0.1367717832,
-1.203359127,
-0.1087253764,
-0.1558927,
-0.546651423,
0.3931750953,
0.0574291386,
-0.4500024617,
-0.5750085711,
-0.5873970389,
0.0522075295,
0.3090104759,
0.0365148187,
0.3407316804,
0.6080918312,
0.0418692827,
-0.7261013985,
-0.9039028883,
0.00533691,
-0.2756622136,
-0.6843753457,
0.34748137,
0.0064674891,
-0.1840784401,
0.1386491358,
-0.0644345134,
0.1183438525,
0.3570363224,
0.3005367219,
-0.2431640327,
-0.2898154259,
0.1856425256,
-0.0640119463,
-0.183008641,
0.065012075,
-0.1486542672,
0.4248383641,
-0.0482604727,
0.0777374655,
-0.0012256569,
0.3677337468,
0.4041734338,
-0.2252583057,
0.7269419432,
0.9198698401,
-0.2323024571,
-0.4188556075,
-0.4230349362,
-0.2218172401,
-0.4708561599,
0.5712479949,
-0.5792255998,
-1.0885330439,
0.5851764083,
0.3906222582,
-0.0912506133,
0.6952110529,
0.4162116349,
-0.1604634225,
1.241438508,
0.9473005533,
-0.1887764186,
0.4769542217,
-0.1675882936,
0.2716059089,
-1.156406045,
0.1219339147,
-0.6100250483,
-0.7897304296,
-0.7656021118,
-0.0545826964,
0.096734114,
-0.1790804863,
0.182624951,
0.2178029418,
-0.6805533171,
0.3308934867,
0.4359253347,
0.1433376074,
-0.1562812477,
0.2195792347,
-0.2994161546,
-0.2728033662,
-0.7560774684,
-0.3047429323,
0.8249428272,
0.6393885016,
0.8519750237,
-0.078339316,
0.0917346552,
0.3797076046,
0.165677458,
-0.7837991714,
0.5919890404,
-0.3239138722,
-0.7545633316,
-0.45216313,
-0.0893798843,
-0.9554414749,
0.235389024,
-0.2746478319,
-0.6459369063,
0.320887357,
0.0145036811,
-0.5735713243,
0.128330037,
-0.9789714217,
0.6709954739,
0.1926252991,
-0.4968065619,
-0.0665763393,
-0.9295306206,
0.1101476997,
0.2063561976,
0.1386084408,
-0.3160590529,
-0.2871850431,
0.6543356776,
0.116638504,
0.8527020812,
-0.0909941867,
-0.102915585,
0.2316655219,
-0.0241467692,
0.1553544551,
-0.0482811518,
0.186216265,
-0.1013503596,
-0.4610257447,
-0.2957733572,
-0.4055023491,
0.747091651,
-0.6703472733,
-0.6995158195,
-0.3265864551,
-0.7014473677,
-0.3346094787,
0.038911432,
0.5340875983,
0.4047794938,
-0.0066149961,
0.5286455154,
1.0153335333,
-0.3941549659,
0.4633003175,
0.1122956201,
0.0601091236,
-0.0145585751,
0.7534974813,
0.3715218306,
0.2232489884,
0.6247975826,
0.2816525996,
-0.2471938431,
-0.53926754,
0.0084715812,
0.005601122,
-0.5643370152,
-0.0079187639,
-1.0506771803,
-0.4132731557,
-0.3918302655,
-0.0966238976,
0.0900748298,
-0.6744449735,
-0.2149644643,
-0.3318184316,
0.2744870782,
0.3590193391,
0.2356226444,
0.0016603093,
-0.6092934608,
0.5557474494,
0.4970416725,
0.3706114292,
-0.044374764,
-0.9765290022,
-0.2628435493,
-0.4308154285,
-0.4053213596,
-0.573897779,
0.3692144454,
0.5300129652,
0.5686125755,
0.5157003403,
0.0416340269,
0.138111636,
-0.3131709695,
0.7083912492,
-0.2011270225,
-0.7332159877,
0.6214057803,
-0.3579272032,
0.5753033757,
0.5544711947,
0.2296829522,
-0.4753317535,
-0.9853254557,
-0.8110860586,
-1.1645545959,
0.4335620701,
0.1753495187,
0.6774141788,
-0.0961717293,
0.2977538407,
0.0176221281,
0.2864609659,
-0.7286049724,
-0.3047067523,
-0.111677967,
-0.2373184115,
-0.1643466502,
-0.7158302665,
-0.1552442461,
0.0092455987,
0.3168973327,
-0.1601390988,
0.5005159378,
0.4942351282,
-0.3990484774,
-0.1873943806,
0.5273460746,
0.7867591381,
0.2924373448,
-0.4226695895,
0.3740341663,
0.2512704134,
-0.7496856451,
-0.2933494449,
0.0135821356,
-0.1995112896,
0.0161337219,
0.5417159796,
0.8387748003,
0.3704744577,
-0.3148317337,
0.7007741332,
-0.116344884,
-0.0964078829,
-0.0560565479,
0.2371344864,
-0.0604631677,
-0.1326214224,
0.5833421946,
0.1350456327,
0.3342917562,
-0.3870035112,
0.4275780618,
0.4578627646,
-0.643274188,
-0.2634912133,
0.6843464971,
0.2718225121,
-0.1893713921,
0.4614681304,
0.1426579207,
-0.6485626698,
0.8146653771,
0.4383451045,
1.0507118702,
-0.1191606522,
-0.099650681,
0.1872043461,
0.5454929471,
0.4179892838,
0.0777408406,
-0.0236412957,
-0.9454067945,
-0.344938755,
-0.6870595217,
-0.2278580964,
0.1272202879,
-0.6145057082,
0.0716289803,
-0.6544499993,
-0.5161794424,
0.1211601794,
-0.2273499817,
-0.8600596786,
0.3454197049,
0.3172507286,
0.9210273623,
-0.7755920291,
0.5574923158,
0.4733731449,
-0.0608059615,
-0.6852174997,
0.2128287703,
-0.2804499269,
-0.8685698509,
0.3578156531,
0.6975354552,
0.0569360331,
0.1629092693,
-0.4554453194,
-0.6973464489,
0.777798593,
0.2655383348,
-0.5913994312,
0.0602640398,
0.2333531976,
0.8181847334,
-0.3261540234,
0.1531208307,
0.4327826798,
0.2683311403,
-0.4104909599,
-0.4140621424,
-0.0309949256,
-0.1195603684,
0.3428065479,
0.1084778458,
-0.5491239429,
0.4830509126,
-0.4931707978,
-0.1525998414,
-0.3363595307,
0.7700772285,
-0.2387014478,
0.1546565592,
0.6729596853,
0.7083570361,
0.1844945103,
-0.1077161804,
1.607847929,
-0.3835138083,
0.3012799025,
0.7780726552,
-0.2018443048,
0.7652418017,
0.5623125434,
-0.2406179309,
0.4203446507,
0.3347163498,
0.0070453337,
0.6145282388,
0.5265384316,
-0.2355796844,
-0.0317670181,
-0.4777334332,
-0.2620767057,
0.3700595796,
0.4382834435,
-0.6092963219,
0.0960561559,
0.3725816607,
-0.3113196194,
-0.0040394166,
-0.2535321712,
0.7000529766,
0.3704792261,
-0.4470766485,
0.1275971979,
-0.1692724228,
0.8511505723,
-0.7525107861,
0.4605260789,
-0.2177081108,
0.4714275301,
-0.1851057559,
-1.1155779362,
0.1665188819,
-0.2444285452,
-0.4421617389,
-0.1613061428,
0.9018742442,
-0.3052334189,
-0.3929923177,
0.4568956196,
0.1468074322,
-0.2408364117,
-0.1446134448,
-0.7961944342,
-0.0112693254,
-0.1433903277,
-0.7442222834,
0.4897154272,
0.8430219889,
0.1154724285,
0.7124048471,
0.4337086678,
-0.0292572286,
0.3184756935,
0.369664371,
0.6344301105,
-0.5158275962,
-0.5215995312,
-0.5907166004,
0.5210590959,
0.04839091,
-0.6326466203,
0.7056890726,
0.2618781328,
0.7019315958,
-0.2678776681,
0.7109012604,
0.0296567772,
0.5622098446,
-0.336689949,
0.4767819941,
-0.3242099881,
0.1557241231,
-0.2549184859,
-1.1943479776,
-0.4482514262,
0.5090041757,
-0.1908049732,
0.1118261293,
0.8300505877,
0.7811156511,
-0.0313194096,
-0.4674488604,
0.4847913384,
0.2565517426,
0.0530026704,
0.5904707909,
0.6409947872,
-0.1641717255,
0.6617242694,
-0.4380281866,
-0.0697400272,
-0.2600924075,
-0.7700146437,
-0.6448454857,
-0.5098673105,
-0.3009448647,
-0.4700115323,
-0.1502687335,
0.4341884851,
0.2822808027,
-0.8397930861,
0.3338726163,
0.0861695707,
0.185306862,
-0.2433850914,
-0.3406723738,
0.411183387,
-0.4428510964,
-0.4189681709,
-0.1212712154,
0.4565396607,
0.0181941986,
-0.2648700178,
0.4180115163,
-0.0675098822,
0.3477490842,
0.5995782614,
0.1649969071,
-0.4276424646,
-0.6836630702,
-0.0097013693,
-0.6511186361,
-0.0677258,
1.0159084797,
-0.6127645969,
0.1097108573,
0.5883592367,
0.4643655717,
0.2655289173,
-0.178102687,
0.4755550027,
-1.1354175806,
0.4159187376,
0.1839708537,
0.2859749496,
0.4279787242,
-0.5232170224,
0.4373839498,
0.3124408722,
-0.4130881727,
-0.6654309034,
0.2640466988,
-1.2101863623,
-0.0652977824,
1.1580908298,
0.0080215428,
-0.3070956767,
-0.1783918738,
-0.1704405993,
-0.0204914361,
-0.2450327724,
0.8521529436,
0.8559420705,
0.1357468069,
-0.1086209118,
-0.6460273862,
0.6447318792,
0.7463649511,
-0.2649390697,
0.0334699377,
0.0215410274,
0.1728262901,
0.4908683598,
0.1894369274,
-0.1232579872,
0.1645032167,
-0.217633307,
-0.037538521,
0.1487108618,
-0.2218148708,
-0.4779297709,
0.606294632,
0.1222816631,
-0.1700742394
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05964v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05964v2
|
A Survey on Transformer Compression
| 2024-02-05T12:16:28 | 2024-04-07T13:03:58 |
Yehui Tang, Yunhe Wang, Jianyuan Guo, Zhijun Tu, Kai Han, Hailin Hu, Dacheng Tao
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Transformer plays a vital role in the realms of natural language processing
(NLP) and computer vision (CV), specially for constructing large language
models (LLM) and large vision models (LVM). Model compression methods reduce
the memory and computational cost of Transformer, which is a necessary step to
implement large language/vision models on practical devices. Given the unique
architecture of Transformer, featuring alternative attention and feedforward
neural network (FFN) modules, specific compression techniques are usually
required. The efficiency of these compression methods is also paramount, as
retraining large models on the entire training dataset is usually impractical.
This survey provides a comprehensive review of recent compression methods, with
a specific focus on their application to Transformer-based models. The
compression methods are primarily categorized into pruning, quantization,
knowledge distillation, and efficient architecture design (Mamba, RetNet, RWKV,
etc.). In each category, we discuss compression methods for both language and
vision tasks, highlighting common underlying principles. Finally, we delve into
the relation between various compression methods, and discuss further
directions in this domain.
|
[
-0.6604207158,
-0.3306573033,
0.1793636233,
0.1081514433,
-0.0408532955,
-0.1162000448,
-0.2389528006,
-0.4777167439,
0.0663075671,
0.5011678338,
-0.5030984879,
-0.1026659235,
-0.6373685002,
0.151127696,
-0.6311581731,
0.3886587322,
0.0741574392,
-0.0391221829,
-0.2492861599,
0.1031211317,
-0.7072979212,
-0.634759903,
-0.6275479794,
-0.2751328945,
0.3028777838,
-0.0856835991,
0.429448396,
0.384493202,
0.9002912045,
0.3826626539,
-0.3861983716,
0.0553801954,
-0.4072599709,
0.1389713436,
-0.0117089534,
-0.5712961555,
-0.0088796681,
-0.247867465,
0.5508271456,
0.5688794255,
-0.166064024,
0.3213814795,
0.0716211051,
0.7205576301,
-0.9110015631,
0.2695555687,
-0.3250648975,
0.3883382678,
-0.0551295541,
-0.1452918351,
-0.6483918428,
-0.3369229436,
-0.1061728522,
-0.1381504238,
0.6925069094,
0.1242244542,
0.7529280186,
0.8586539626,
-0.3342669606,
0.2238166332,
-0.9850317836,
0.8268864155,
-0.5058211684,
0.6689037681,
0.0248438064,
0.5141618252,
0.225786522,
-0.7695177794,
-0.5293954015,
0.1064640731,
-0.2116996348,
0.1514089257,
-0.4585860074,
0.2217279822,
0.4343563914,
0.7918792963,
-0.3796494901,
0.189744547,
-0.5589075089,
-0.2633756101,
0.4184259474,
0.0376643427,
0.1596651971,
-0.1520827413,
-0.2415842712,
-0.7147936821,
-0.7857503891,
0.062157318,
0.3537317514,
-0.1348617077,
0.248631075,
0.5122468472,
-0.2089034319,
1.2706519365,
-0.1099843532,
-0.2953420281,
0.013091594,
-0.2046771348,
-0.4758912921,
-0.2260677814,
0.6330572963,
0.4363706708,
0.2422696054,
-0.2918051779,
-0.2812159956,
0.2406303585,
0.6653584838,
-0.668069005,
-0.2258132249,
0.0230700057,
-0.5992816091,
-0.4718967676,
0.1246418506,
-0.8910672665,
-0.297867924,
-0.3545704782,
0.2972484827,
-0.0934610963,
-0.0435105748,
0.3355466127,
-0.3192237616,
0.6101645827,
0.1737261862,
-0.9346185923,
0.2533505857,
0.650919199,
0.6692707539,
0.0677540824,
-0.0029418913,
-0.4137136042,
-0.2208197713,
-0.0634665936,
0.8858608007,
-0.1511084735,
-0.2779643834,
0.2706843615,
0.1190776527,
0.1078932658,
-0.5624816418,
0.9778407812,
-0.4534081519,
0.0204119533,
0.1524719894,
-0.360781461,
-0.4895146191,
0.2509116232,
-1.0725164413,
0.7043427229,
0.1817984134,
-0.6020067334,
-0.0062370971,
-0.2722948194,
-0.4481347501,
-0.0387768745,
-0.0717316568,
-0.3448875546,
0.4801744819,
0.5770391226,
0.7903695107,
-0.735470295,
0.1834490597,
0.2333446592,
-0.3429300487,
0.0137703056,
-0.5260896087,
0.4503220618,
0.0608830824,
0.0721833855,
-0.0200456418,
-0.5796460509,
-0.1436622739,
0.2188758254,
-0.2349420041,
0.0185592864,
-0.089311257,
0.1352951825,
0.1740868092,
-0.0082117766,
-0.5390433669,
0.4071463645,
-0.6827808022,
0.695117712,
0.5053161979,
-0.017811615,
0.472869575,
-0.1656109542,
0.544914782,
-0.3245641887,
0.4878875911,
-0.3164838254,
-0.2934978008,
-1.0694366693,
0.1744299829,
0.4378896356,
0.6654106975,
-0.8840648532,
0.5336546898,
-0.5571131706,
-0.7340148687,
-0.6151284575,
-0.274441123,
0.1124697253,
0.3227483928,
0.4600144029,
-0.1541157812,
-0.4877543747,
-1.0504037142,
-0.1775699407,
0.0215691905,
-0.289239943,
0.1721293181,
0.2116674334,
0.0283179134,
0.9295426011,
-0.874802351,
-0.2277288288,
-0.3625800908,
0.1805769056,
0.2529796362,
0.4148336053,
0.6047222614,
-1.0562019348,
-0.169460386,
-0.2972958684,
-0.2825707197,
-0.1075161025,
-0.1326367557,
0.5235998034,
0.0066881063,
0.3014532626,
-0.6476489902,
0.6120510101,
0.8709176183,
0.0891804025,
0.4409344196,
-0.0592525341,
0.2060417235,
-0.8058620095,
-0.0986785293,
0.0553408898,
-0.261980176,
-0.8543145657,
0.2494689226,
0.1431694627,
-0.2475049794,
-0.6757138371,
0.1935980618,
-0.5373146534,
0.0626166016,
-0.413305223,
-0.2885498405,
0.0094938995,
0.6543418169,
0.215942353,
0.6153655052,
0.574680984,
-0.5905057192,
0.7501841187,
0.3166860044,
-0.4149021804,
0.2495619804,
-0.9246168733,
0.2289907634,
-0.4372723699,
0.2923981547,
-0.6833599806,
-0.027242966,
0.2266239673,
-0.11044164,
0.6093577743,
-0.0746922344,
-0.5048874617,
-0.7230747342,
-0.2910373211,
0.6319180727,
0.7697995901,
-0.7489205003,
0.7573729157,
0.2309794873,
0.2214824557,
-0.7675118446,
-1.0343561172,
0.2449137568,
-0.2323915064,
-0.6246263385,
0.7200265527,
-0.089325659,
-0.0211549457,
-0.196801126,
-0.2369533628,
-0.0606998987,
-0.2877975106,
0.3063346446,
0.2737898827,
-0.0205830391,
-0.0548065118,
-0.3781730831,
-0.2358447611,
-0.1080407426,
-0.2119778693,
0.6312208772,
0.0246390495,
-0.2200738341,
-0.3088532984,
0.363540858,
0.2565995753,
-0.2046410739,
0.81836766,
0.5793872476,
-0.2186612636,
-0.0905304179,
-0.7985947728,
-0.2436565757,
-0.4339667261,
0.097029984,
-0.1719131172,
-1.1245256662,
0.2164572179,
-0.2936147749,
0.022313457,
0.6228402257,
0.44888556,
0.3248826265,
0.6268606782,
0.9994462132,
-0.1216965467,
0.5463638306,
-0.3427859843,
0.5891997814,
-0.7613444924,
-0.0489392243,
-0.7164162993,
-0.5190978646,
-0.34916839,
-0.7715312243,
0.1880106479,
-0.1943978369,
0.2265531719,
0.7375098467,
-1.0652713776,
0.6514730453,
0.4437866211,
-0.0991733819,
0.0897696987,
-0.1175390705,
0.526135087,
0.1336786151,
-0.8423323035,
-0.0806409866,
0.7796240449,
0.4292353094,
0.8775640726,
-0.0562176965,
0.3779811561,
0.07221248,
0.0183998663,
-1.1725105047,
0.4303951859,
-0.227727443,
-0.2382598221,
-0.096835956,
-0.4336143136,
-0.8596934676,
-0.016720105,
-0.198519662,
-0.5894666314,
0.4551294446,
0.0715434998,
-0.3274123669,
0.464186579,
-0.5656704307,
0.4852385819,
0.0615654923,
0.0883708447,
0.0125869131,
-0.8339679837,
0.4233934879,
-0.0514293388,
-0.1411583424,
0.3758290708,
0.1662365049,
0.8656390905,
-0.3228457868,
0.730733633,
0.083770074,
-0.0424748845,
0.301695019,
-0.2519743443,
0.3995110095,
-0.3778771758,
0.3996000886,
0.4749022722,
0.0240292121,
-0.0475231931,
-0.7812411785,
0.249650076,
-0.4019323289,
-0.5039473772,
-0.2012763321,
-0.4243124723,
-0.023995094,
-0.134936884,
0.5859898329,
0.674338758,
-0.0735822991,
0.4137738347,
0.8419010639,
-0.3335575759,
0.5257567763,
0.0480347127,
0.01630193,
-0.38892892,
0.6473418474,
0.0082370108,
0.1422602236,
0.9078661799,
0.0065358956,
-0.0955020189,
-0.5752127767,
0.0081457794,
0.1787070334,
-0.7807551622,
-0.8116598725,
-0.3938459754,
-0.5888673663,
-0.683369875,
-0.1676995754,
-0.5272916555,
-0.6267104745,
0.1623530686,
0.1677982956,
0.2102443725,
0.7663163543,
0.2506678998,
0.6484851241,
-0.9334560633,
0.4728356302,
0.4536406994,
0.2062450498,
0.0189823322,
-0.3101430833,
-0.2452035397,
-0.351601392,
-0.2975333333,
-0.8911640048,
0.5631223917,
0.2272331119,
0.3867237568,
0.4238931537,
0.2068810463,
0.4847258031,
-0.7254652977,
1.0598523617,
0.3668329716,
-0.6728873849,
0.5588873625,
0.4094266295,
0.3807341754,
0.1725914776,
0.3120613992,
-0.7456324697,
-0.0756506324,
-0.5809429884,
-0.8766860366,
0.3715192974,
0.1863847822,
0.1403154135,
0.3096215725,
0.5142807364,
-0.2153561413,
0.0151129942,
-0.697229147,
-0.263373822,
-0.1550479531,
-0.3825464845,
-0.0557979681,
-0.2520890236,
-0.1234201267,
-0.2215484977,
0.3407010436,
-0.0877006501,
0.6320092678,
0.2778953612,
-0.169209972,
0.3097355962,
0.2613174319,
0.3851502538,
-0.0196397472,
0.1028577313,
0.222775951,
0.1926103979,
-0.6001240611,
0.260864377,
-0.1911252886,
-0.0579725243,
-0.1438254714,
0.3226253092,
0.890458405,
0.2330402881,
-0.5330155492,
0.6508601904,
-0.5094826221,
-0.2846662402,
-0.1536564082,
0.1846872568,
-0.2261728942,
0.2674687505,
0.1204107031,
0.3576874137,
0.2437801808,
-0.0720118731,
-0.2826365829,
0.2430612147,
-0.2483181953,
-0.1598887295,
0.4243828058,
0.0696369559,
-0.4599922895,
0.7529779673,
0.3574858308,
-0.475734055,
0.3554290533,
0.4527200162,
0.9892382622,
-0.3506392241,
-0.277477622,
0.5130650997,
0.4684965014,
-0.4505658448,
-0.2379060239,
-0.3497384191,
-0.7304623127,
-0.9148445725,
-0.7475557327,
-0.370208621,
0.055786036,
-0.566208005,
0.3997790813,
-0.0438935645,
-0.2114785612,
-0.0630621091,
-0.2852889895,
-0.7632640004,
0.2269144803,
0.3412303627,
1.2500236034,
-0.6566485763,
0.5917487144,
0.3992690742,
-0.3002826869,
-0.8802188635,
-0.1429022551,
-0.0420853645,
-0.4400133491,
0.5776187181,
0.2184547782,
-0.2548294663,
0.060378544,
-0.502411902,
-0.6501647234,
0.9296104908,
0.3344784379,
-0.5984203219,
-0.3057629764,
0.2226575464,
0.3653427362,
-0.0260149054,
-0.033286795,
0.5470828414,
0.4656563699,
0.2524521351,
-0.6915720701,
-0.1324708611,
-0.2660722435,
0.2754814923,
0.4370499849,
-0.6405210495,
0.3892629445,
0.3890423477,
-0.2890599072,
-0.0048987009,
0.6224560738,
-0.2994180322,
-0.2004472017,
0.6030939221,
0.5956531167,
0.3697229326,
-0.2804142237,
1.030200839,
-0.4791143239,
0.4335371256,
0.6281283498,
0.1721344143,
0.8164283037,
0.6757099032,
-0.2542126775,
0.0978788659,
0.3463366628,
-0.4238290191,
0.3293502629,
0.203522414,
0.0047647166,
-0.0941267535,
-0.0712949112,
-0.1540035456,
0.5965183973,
0.0104559911,
-0.2495865822,
0.0326664038,
0.1101492569,
-0.2833375633,
-0.2212480158,
-0.316195488,
0.6088528037,
0.0688527822,
-0.6975893378,
0.4629006684,
0.0181442294,
0.9207080007,
-0.5254895091,
0.1510542333,
0.1349878907,
-0.0210044701,
-0.1086292192,
-0.8519046903,
0.8054350615,
0.0064996248,
-0.2502351105,
-0.6736199856,
1.1251119375,
-0.128779605,
-0.3115096092,
-0.113940157,
0.2495778948,
0.1010190174,
-0.321160078,
-0.2204969078,
0.1111602858,
-0.0662224591,
-0.3372353017,
-0.0278524868,
-0.0409670994,
0.4339179993,
0.6311970353,
0.4585515559,
0.1942927688,
0.0298364181,
0.19838126,
0.9729280472,
-0.7302087545,
-0.2453421503,
-0.5669747591,
0.4345631599,
-0.0947137848,
0.0169181097,
0.478135705,
0.2641299069,
0.610696733,
-0.3387286663,
0.3266996145,
0.0057827421,
0.1030036807,
-0.7051206827,
0.5530244112,
-0.3726667166,
-0.0491391085,
-0.1013242379,
-1.1456928253,
-0.7578414083,
0.7363654375,
-0.1677286625,
-0.2764868736,
0.6305431724,
0.6184303761,
-0.0669677034,
0.1146591902,
0.3694108725,
-0.176960662,
0.3218746781,
0.6484652758,
0.764662385,
-0.6968928576,
0.6845769882,
-0.4524493814,
0.0153846806,
-0.139077872,
-1.0182454586,
-0.5588424802,
-0.7791771889,
-0.4412897527,
0.1100541279,
-0.5542508364,
0.4770415425,
0.9972525835,
-0.4728619754,
0.0803134143,
-0.1865276843,
-0.104644835,
-0.4116099775,
-0.1910900623,
0.3119730055,
-0.104353182,
-0.8244775534,
0.3591917455,
0.4100390971,
0.0704001784,
-0.4970850348,
0.2233114541,
0.2026322931,
-0.0032259794,
0.5919079185,
0.2598968148,
-0.5804772377,
-0.2265996784,
0.1179393753,
0.2233576924,
0.1918997318,
1.0563335419,
-1.1470518112,
0.2038721293,
0.8332275152,
0.7031368017,
0.5314813852,
-0.0701269358,
0.5577527881,
-0.9273599982,
0.421001941,
0.3263963461,
0.6272475123,
0.4700796008,
-0.3482036889,
0.6426467299,
0.1719848812,
-0.8658657074,
-0.6550733447,
0.5448522568,
-1.1989066601,
-0.1757092476,
0.9433668256,
0.0400323011,
-0.644130528,
0.2237960845,
-0.4045626521,
0.398720026,
0.1510067135,
0.6371608973,
0.7246167064,
-0.1029796898,
-0.6125715375,
-0.5061804652,
0.4343675971,
0.0701283887,
-0.7208288908,
0.0328520276,
0.3584511876,
-0.2589713335,
0.5443832278,
-0.1375796497,
0.0895818546,
-0.0430009328,
0.0403562896,
0.3197455704,
0.0593958609,
-0.404319495,
-0.8347483277,
0.454900682,
-0.233910203,
0.0369014181
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05128v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05128v2
|
Enhancing Textbook Question Answering Task with Large Language Models and Retrieval Augmented Generation
| 2024-02-05T11:58:56 | 2024-02-14T10:06:54 |
Hessa Abdulrahman Alawwad, Areej Alhothali, Usman Naseem, Ali Alkhathlan, Amani Jamal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Textbook question answering (TQA) is a challenging task in artificial
intelligence due to the complex nature of context and multimodal data. Although
previous research has significantly improved the task, there are still some
limitations including the models' weak reasoning and inability to capture
contextual information in the lengthy context. The introduction of large
language models (LLMs) has revolutionized the field of AI, however, directly
applying LLMs often leads to inaccurate answers. This paper proposes a
methodology that handle the out-of-domain scenario in TQA where concepts are
spread across different lessons by incorporating the retrieval augmented
generation (RAG) technique and utilize transfer learning to handle the long
context and enhance reasoning abilities. Through supervised fine-tuning of the
LLM model Llama-2 and the incorporation of RAG, our architecture outperforms
the baseline, achieving a 4.12% accuracy improvement on validation set and
9.84% on test set for non-diagram multiple-choice questions.
|
[
-0.4061764181,
-1.0424271822,
0.7221577764,
-0.2558442354,
-0.3111954927,
0.3224197328,
-0.0554312654,
-0.4056825638,
-0.1120517254,
0.5378690958,
-0.2440135926,
-0.0793446451,
-0.4322609007,
0.0679465011,
-0.1809225678,
0.9686785936,
-0.2727357447,
-0.0177606363,
-0.5724147558,
-0.095780462,
-0.8367378712,
-0.4483649731,
-0.6916087866,
-0.3367238641,
0.1941310763,
0.5873983502,
0.5685223341,
0.2529119551,
0.4761366844,
0.2004169077,
-0.2732365727,
0.6976266503,
-0.4260186851,
0.1018509418,
-0.6253358126,
-0.431861341,
-0.5547516942,
-0.4546497166,
0.7904231548,
0.4573925734,
-0.1131652668,
0.4925566912,
0.000018259,
0.6648446918,
-0.6284557581,
0.0885877684,
-0.7804036736,
-0.3928408325,
-0.024512602,
-0.2615281641,
-0.6155617237,
-0.2009270787,
0.0417562798,
-0.8123584986,
-0.0379635356,
-0.0669643581,
0.8222110868,
0.2680695057,
-0.6940255165,
-0.3806951642,
-0.6934243441,
0.777531445,
-0.5402830839,
0.2800657153,
0.4695958793,
0.408372432,
-0.3461348712,
-0.7139778733,
-0.7081490159,
-0.1088155359,
-0.0816644356,
0.0594253726,
0.1654329747,
-0.2606521845,
0.1066835374,
0.1187859774,
-0.2904393375,
-0.0568474941,
-0.3723724484,
0.161277011,
0.6741089225,
0.0977841169,
0.2634266615,
-0.3889303207,
-0.4343031049,
-0.1460990161,
-0.5083586574,
0.089994967,
-0.125753656,
0.4106227756,
0.1726517081,
0.6008291841,
-0.0731950626,
0.8277981281,
0.0842785984,
-0.3296273053,
0.1142684892,
-0.2370793521,
-0.2230522633,
-0.1360825151,
0.1648310125,
0.1942746043,
0.1465185881,
-0.0826319084,
-0.2460851371,
-0.5009589195,
0.4154011905,
-0.610363543,
0.185310334,
0.0962152779,
-0.1222392172,
-0.0027285723,
-0.1965136677,
-0.8651844263,
-0.3509485126,
-0.6775840521,
0.7244113684,
-0.4172511101,
-0.0724095181,
-0.0993786156,
0.1155838221,
0.4670382142,
0.5907416344,
-0.6495001912,
0.2797774971,
0.7369883657,
0.5930416584,
-0.2883986533,
-0.0241493247,
-0.7631593347,
0.512421608,
-0.5651996136,
0.8937925696,
-0.6114202142,
-0.3711809814,
0.0339233652,
-0.03947917,
0.0013053383,
-0.5756303072,
0.4350975752,
-1.0431172848,
0.322669208,
-0.0561097674,
-0.6699786186,
-0.5243423581,
0.4614191055,
-0.3906323016,
1.2950042486,
0.442350626,
-0.367013514,
-0.1561362594,
-0.4784559906,
-0.366453588,
-0.0187591761,
0.1243777275,
-0.3652041554,
-0.0703857169,
0.5147860646,
0.3762989044,
-0.5635476708,
0.5765840411,
0.1284869909,
-0.4614520967,
0.2208560109,
-0.1653795391,
0.5287621617,
0.1908032894,
-0.0848958343,
-0.1310632676,
-0.7599949241,
0.1553816944,
0.0982770771,
-0.4135765135,
-0.6223080158,
-0.4049921334,
-0.1825054437,
0.1536420435,
0.3471770883,
-0.2726730108,
0.4782203138,
-0.2225168049,
0.0308331512,
0.7004621625,
0.2887327969,
0.6618695259,
-0.6150897741,
0.6226813197,
0.05540663,
-0.0693334863,
0.0298595391,
-0.5450279713,
-0.7951826453,
-0.1540110856,
0.3036408424,
0.5789276361,
-1.3724645376,
-0.0300481189,
-0.3252359033,
-0.5717788935,
-0.294344455,
0.3289405107,
0.4873328209,
0.7515223622,
0.6919091344,
-0.0962645784,
-0.301399678,
-0.713716507,
-0.0894564018,
-0.2568332255,
-0.0087249568,
0.5692577362,
0.4234575331,
-0.2806774378,
0.9258673191,
-0.6634994745,
-0.3919485807,
-0.3628119826,
-0.0935498998,
0.2323846817,
0.4236333668,
0.3132121563,
-0.8348605633,
-0.4396387935,
0.1322517395,
-0.6637358665,
0.0978415757,
-0.284430474,
-0.4871162176,
0.4638134539,
0.4513469934,
-0.6095345616,
0.1249935925,
0.2786880732,
-0.1187041998,
0.4218300283,
-0.2478039712,
0.1786152571,
-1.5822868347,
0.0561434589,
-0.136161834,
-0.0637327507,
-0.5622938275,
0.3435431719,
0.2069148719,
-0.134359166,
-0.5060388446,
0.9255350828,
-0.357642442,
-0.0785868466,
-0.290548563,
0.3022624552,
0.2383927554,
0.5453381538,
-0.0925803557,
1.1224547625,
0.2403308898,
-0.7103105187,
0.2674461305,
0.5410857797,
-0.146846503,
0.3794405162,
-0.2956146896,
0.3286551535,
-0.2976476252,
0.5144008398,
-0.8791754842,
-0.1864769608,
0.1546867788,
-0.3485402763,
0.5339784622,
-0.0887978449,
-0.4265577793,
-0.0503136888,
-0.1590890288,
0.6186414361,
0.5819016695,
-0.7946195006,
1.0257329941,
0.2315570563,
-0.2992887497,
-0.7229164243,
-0.1827067733,
-0.0355489664,
-0.1784815043,
-0.4136227369,
0.2645604908,
-0.0536549315,
-0.3720038831,
-0.2218441069,
-0.0112974951,
-0.3393163383,
-0.0094079664,
-0.1638773829,
0.4704981446,
-0.3182918429,
0.730366528,
0.3300349712,
0.1902536303,
-0.0667514503,
-0.0590703785,
0.3944206536,
0.0413425192,
0.0151193263,
-0.3528354764,
0.1447259635,
0.4565890133,
-0.2576393485,
0.636423707,
0.2356706858,
-0.3053334057,
-0.4155628681,
-0.474791199,
-0.1323953271,
-0.4528014958,
0.4333140552,
-0.5570885539,
-0.6623017788,
0.2912226915,
-0.2537382841,
0.0480018966,
0.3393301368,
0.4341719151,
-0.084963344,
0.4957147241,
0.4846844971,
0.0841624737,
0.2966026366,
-0.2794972658,
0.0005190937,
-1.123177886,
-0.3148259521,
-0.5073590279,
-0.0078910626,
-0.3917412162,
-0.840316236,
0.462877363,
0.4507618845,
-0.493706882,
0.0782869905,
-0.3694233,
0.4889026582,
0.6355412602,
0.2905946374,
0.5347572565,
0.07695546,
0.1811779886,
0.352822274,
-0.5855069757,
-0.6063996553,
1.2049977779,
0.2444398552,
0.5517582297,
0.4662303925,
0.5063228607,
0.2068505138,
0.5532665849,
-0.8359313011,
0.6220331788,
-0.1254695505,
-0.650511086,
-0.5321496129,
-0.2411643267,
-0.6759098768,
0.3320093155,
-0.232467562,
-0.4301542342,
-0.0034084211,
-0.0181912351,
-0.1781459302,
0.3380352557,
-0.6207100153,
0.4302915037,
-0.0592558496,
-0.4015920162,
0.0737069845,
-0.525636673,
0.5061582923,
-0.4843431711,
0.3351975977,
0.195534423,
-0.1708704084,
0.6471941471,
-0.1942813993,
0.6458140016,
0.0697555616,
-0.5395750403,
0.6464138627,
0.2372845411,
0.7287025452,
0.2436386943,
-0.3139909506,
-0.0938441232,
-0.0169956852,
-0.4017416537,
-0.9200466275,
0.5178134441,
-0.8654196858,
-0.9510293007,
-0.3681640327,
-0.9282255769,
-0.7325217724,
0.0181999076,
-0.2296662331,
0.5697045326,
0.1552781165,
-0.0920943245,
0.6372298598,
-0.3464443386,
0.2539644837,
0.4594547749,
-0.1826096177,
-0.4459162951,
1.0006151199,
-0.0583400093,
0.4604960084,
0.5870141387,
0.2063987106,
-0.5040473938,
-0.4806922972,
-0.9811533689,
0.4155441225,
-0.9394515753,
-0.4687166214,
-0.4936172962,
-0.234986186,
-0.5254577398,
-0.1714207083,
-0.0493873395,
-0.4532956183,
-0.5277130008,
0.1187181026,
0.4298017621,
0.7718966007,
0.2441904396,
0.1599323303,
-1.1018999815,
0.5491508245,
0.5713915825,
0.1156234369,
0.2223080695,
-1.0666385889,
-0.0251325853,
0.0194575973,
-0.4708826244,
-0.5542824268,
0.2597946227,
0.2780676186,
0.2384086549,
-0.086597085,
0.3482900858,
0.7399359941,
-0.5924893618,
0.7356058955,
-0.0841035545,
-0.9117869139,
0.4693832099,
-0.3500010073,
0.2499833554,
0.3632627428,
0.405786097,
-0.246127218,
-0.2888103127,
-0.4862418175,
-0.6584559083,
0.6255116463,
-0.0067461496,
0.3692474365,
0.1613833755,
0.7828770876,
0.1869373024,
-0.0346652158,
-0.3902956545,
-0.1546190232,
0.0239969548,
-0.1803842932,
-0.2932594419,
-0.4008686244,
0.0082054194,
-0.2740380168,
1.101398468,
-0.330049783,
-0.1870538443,
0.229283303,
-0.0547119267,
-0.1203910038,
0.4609365463,
0.6622226834,
1.0181559324,
-0.0831521526,
0.021359371,
0.5662710667,
-0.4837966859,
0.3406815231,
0.1056226417,
-0.237554729,
-0.1266715378,
0.3160853684,
0.3547216654,
-0.1634828448,
-0.874086082,
0.2226577401,
0.1178433523,
0.0247696713,
-0.4016807079,
-0.0487530231,
0.1304382086,
0.3864938021,
0.5788900256,
-0.3287869096,
0.0734315589,
-0.5465593338,
0.2242623419,
0.3588341475,
-0.0846858621,
0.1914668977,
0.4183287621,
0.1234558672,
-0.3266846538,
0.6324186921,
-0.0164336953,
-0.4756008983,
0.8169269562,
0.7603161931,
0.3157270253,
-0.1839659661,
0.3994238079,
0.4983377457,
0.1070089862,
0.0384570956,
0.1186142489,
-0.0099102892,
-0.6202986836,
-0.5968021154,
-0.7423015237,
-0.6500365138,
0.0298752468,
-0.666823566,
0.2796035111,
-0.2204686552,
0.1408491731,
-0.2289812416,
0.0892396867,
-0.2499404997,
0.4776875973,
0.0020790808,
0.7965544462,
-0.4158147275,
0.8723359108,
0.9912087321,
-0.3437258303,
-1.0029093027,
0.097977832,
-0.5178343058,
-0.6353935003,
0.9805294871,
-0.1554217488,
-0.0760436952,
0.1868165135,
-0.4112741351,
-1.0242553949,
1.0035429001,
0.3009190559,
-0.3918725252,
-0.01611319,
0.1614434272,
0.6176729798,
-0.1023856252,
0.1033499837,
0.533251524,
0.2406486273,
0.4960641861,
-0.9222993255,
0.1641005129,
0.0071122022,
0.0938604251,
0.2514230311,
-0.6087244153,
0.8201105595,
-0.3812347353,
0.0390408821,
0.3087258339,
0.7595924735,
0.5210492611,
0.5631057024,
0.3809135556,
0.4643073976,
0.6867401004,
0.2049441934,
1.1686058044,
0.0397803113,
0.3798344731,
1.3497769833,
-0.2986758947,
1.0663520098,
0.5300102234,
-0.0104039367,
0.5590015054,
0.5568181872,
0.3498084545,
0.3546855748,
0.2375901937,
-0.3647168577,
-0.4849874079,
-0.3380794227,
-0.4646690488,
0.5615224242,
0.3305686712,
-0.1066756174,
-0.2614491284,
0.1217249706,
-0.0967280641,
0.3068509698,
-0.5661771297,
0.9568204284,
0.094313167,
-0.8584845662,
0.9693390131,
-0.0230110865,
0.3599448204,
-0.3434700966,
-0.4700161517,
-0.4986390471,
0.2215781361,
0.0713341609,
-0.776399672,
0.0757397935,
-0.0666972324,
-0.2110482156,
0.0571820624,
0.6097801328,
-0.3925070763,
-0.7133933902,
-0.0068524345,
0.7691227198,
0.0641535372,
0.2368641198,
-0.4377363324,
-0.2822458446,
-0.1916758716,
-0.1025435254,
0.3832506239,
0.5861819983,
-0.3841026425,
0.8159537315,
0.6614759564,
-0.1737645417,
-0.2123728842,
-0.1283846349,
1.0538907051,
-0.4880898595,
-0.2875604331,
-0.5042238235,
0.2008579075,
0.0451470315,
-0.2211891413,
0.62774086,
0.4265305996,
0.8611183167,
-0.1306111217,
0.4218424261,
0.1925371587,
0.7707069516,
-0.6563882232,
0.5982756019,
-0.904461205,
0.2317032516,
-0.3751761317,
-0.9943119287,
-0.2656334341,
0.2652259469,
-0.1950870454,
0.0289703254,
0.6526930928,
0.5819061399,
0.0783470273,
-0.0892511606,
0.3489430249,
0.0960444137,
0.4283129275,
0.6729987264,
0.8818449974,
-0.6062176824,
0.5183861256,
-0.2771849334,
-0.1484780312,
-0.0833230987,
-0.6719542742,
-0.9897429347,
-0.63725245,
-0.2078245282,
-0.4726654887,
0.1531613767,
0.7890300751,
0.294970274,
-0.7559571862,
-0.114901498,
0.2862703204,
0.2932035327,
-0.0972423479,
-0.2453477532,
0.8081011176,
-0.5685948133,
-0.9086998105,
0.3135542572,
-0.18929483,
0.0714944899,
-0.0055687358,
0.0544509701,
-0.469035387,
0.3316968679,
0.9054808021,
0.0608609766,
-0.5114784837,
-0.419241786,
0.0242598951,
-0.0155998031,
0.0074885027,
0.5770062804,
-0.9297976494,
0.3672511578,
0.3682662845,
1.1535875797,
0.2673390806,
0.5031228662,
0.3785383701,
-0.705157578,
-0.0808971003,
0.2732684612,
0.1113466993,
0.3514941633,
-0.5029935241,
0.6284318566,
-0.013870921,
-0.5411478877,
-0.9268627763,
0.0232651457,
-0.9478385448,
-0.7076793909,
1.3706667423,
0.0547559597,
-0.2595824599,
-0.2622711062,
-0.5497855544,
0.3701874316,
-0.2108753026,
0.9158974886,
0.5678680539,
-0.1273761541,
-0.04192001,
-0.5395283103,
0.3893449008,
0.4710624814,
-1.1925081015,
-0.0258359723,
0.5677759051,
0.2097693384,
0.2964904308,
0.3885869384,
0.1223778725,
0.4157283008,
-0.4928085208,
-0.1298661083,
-0.2281262279,
-0.3499387503,
-0.2321774364,
0.2521591485,
0.086162746,
-0.1709585786
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02926v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02926v1
|
Automated Cognate Detection as a Supervised Link Prediction Task with Cognate Transformer
| 2024-02-05T11:47:36 | 2024-02-05T11:47:36 |
V. S. D. S. Mahesh Akavarapu, Arnab Bhattacharya
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SI, I.2.7
|
Identification of cognates across related languages is one of the primary
problems in historical linguistics. Automated cognate identification is helpful
for several downstream tasks including identifying sound correspondences,
proto-language reconstruction, phylogenetic classification, etc. Previous
state-of-the-art methods for cognate identification are mostly based on
distributions of phonemes computed across multilingual wordlists and make
little use of the cognacy labels that define links among cognate clusters. In
this paper, we present a transformer-based architecture inspired by
computational biology for the task of automated cognate detection. Beyond a
certain amount of supervision, this method performs better than the existing
methods, and shows steady improvement with further increase in supervision,
thereby proving the efficacy of utilizing the labeled information. We also
demonstrate that accepting multiple sequence alignments as input and having an
end-to-end architecture with link prediction head saves much computation time
while simultaneously yielding superior performance.
|
[
-0.5665767193,
-0.6720560789,
0.2919019759,
0.1415401101,
-0.1956788898,
0.0084966477,
-0.2783010602,
-0.8483793139,
0.489651978,
-0.0070445877,
-0.8466247916,
-0.3821184039,
-0.5541649461,
0.483289808,
-0.5412319303,
0.6900721192,
0.470051676,
0.0226000603,
-0.2611083388,
0.061197564,
-0.3189163506,
-0.2389546782,
-0.7553017139,
-0.3338138163,
0.592291832,
0.2993599176,
0.6394079924,
1.1004008055,
0.7441250086,
0.3810970783,
-0.2924736738,
0.1828691065,
-0.3875677288,
0.2496450543,
-0.0229095258,
-0.5004912615,
-0.4121427536,
-0.1683882922,
0.212671265,
0.6861016154,
0.1008660346,
0.1898100674,
-0.1017465144,
0.3119012117,
-0.5069624782,
0.4232204854,
-0.621506393,
0.1032810733,
-0.5769671202,
-0.3271256089,
-0.6986342669,
-0.1906097978,
0.2713869512,
-0.6399934292,
0.3152120411,
0.3336432874,
0.8327088952,
0.4650391936,
-0.0896092802,
-0.6546453238,
-0.5679315329,
0.5431363583,
-0.2031853944,
0.6628649235,
0.2588897049,
0.4665100574,
-0.4731374383,
-0.4043887854,
-0.3521686494,
-0.1210741997,
-0.5023000836,
0.1336828917,
-0.2262992263,
-0.1328703165,
-0.0721092224,
0.4273392856,
-0.7084057331,
0.093564339,
-0.2634812593,
-0.5186111927,
0.4318730533,
-0.2185492814,
0.4342029989,
0.0703540891,
-0.2012967616,
-0.3003359735,
-0.5397574902,
-0.0511368327,
0.3590661883,
0.2903319597,
-0.1405529827,
0.1078001931,
-0.013397092,
0.6967329979,
0.4911635816,
-0.0759605169,
0.3846408427,
-0.1007293835,
0.13388291,
0.3894521892,
0.9282820225,
-0.3161507249,
0.2095955312,
-0.3167258203,
0.3268738389,
0.2940628827,
0.1124346182,
-0.5269109011,
-0.495460391,
0.0922550559,
-0.2597061992,
-0.2060075998,
-0.1587737352,
-0.8614975214,
0.0889748558,
-0.0811291263,
0.1237566471,
-0.5464932919,
-0.0332768671,
-0.0612386391,
-0.2257898003,
0.4294880033,
0.1552599519,
-1.0665060282,
0.3184401095,
0.723698616,
0.7841286063,
-0.5229390264,
-0.0798220411,
-0.7215063572,
0.2104625404,
-0.1494750679,
0.8236836195,
-0.696663022,
-0.316998899,
-0.3240512609,
0.315824151,
-0.0801474079,
-0.5092074275,
0.5390238166,
-0.6200581193,
0.1341992766,
-0.0598581024,
-0.6110265851,
-0.162166208,
0.0715722069,
-0.932261467,
0.8031439781,
-0.1038604826,
-0.7149229646,
0.1698683947,
-0.5625908375,
-0.5158233047,
0.4473260045,
-0.1521853805,
-0.8386358023,
-0.3289639056,
0.2605172396,
0.3298995495,
-0.1757424623,
0.6630496383,
-0.2879031599,
-0.38031286,
-0.0442360826,
-0.2296349406,
1.0570975542,
-0.0430307537,
-0.3803954422,
0.1136238426,
-0.9856119752,
-0.2959751189,
-0.1053337306,
-0.1535437554,
-0.4057056606,
0.1005229652,
-0.1679446995,
-0.0865972415,
0.132219404,
-0.6871448755,
0.1283923835,
-0.365834713,
0.1412845999,
0.2634308338,
-0.154051125,
0.4731465876,
-0.0579927973,
0.3964110315,
-0.0871344209,
0.0760966614,
-0.3364812732,
-0.8651469946,
-0.8399205804,
-0.4678305686,
0.1161410511,
0.6213595271,
-0.4630215764,
0.8173065782,
-0.3522432446,
-0.7245950699,
-0.2979373932,
-0.1068640426,
0.5207780004,
0.5704626441,
0.945943892,
-0.1510645896,
-0.7686222792,
-0.8749247789,
-0.2390096039,
-0.1642562151,
-0.056354478,
0.2262762189,
0.5012595654,
-0.2692830861,
1.0251734257,
-0.4892658293,
-0.3008401394,
0.1443478316,
0.0863833055,
0.2327132821,
0.6176657081,
0.4688375294,
-0.7766181827,
-0.4872786105,
0.2879470885,
-0.7369791865,
-0.4318582714,
0.03024376,
-0.2256539762,
-0.3904818594,
0.6848026514,
-0.1215414554,
0.1208670959,
0.754535377,
-0.1067390069,
0.44581604,
0.0421678089,
-0.2487157434,
-1.0899803638,
0.1295052916,
0.1166996136,
-0.0971209183,
-0.7303985357,
-0.1037616059,
0.114689894,
0.1195962802,
-0.2342432439,
0.2034325451,
-0.4518562555,
0.0236031581,
0.0822021961,
-0.2750033438,
-0.2961077094,
0.5033777356,
0.3324776888,
0.6970184445,
0.4844698608,
-0.3409757614,
0.6009996533,
0.584710896,
0.1660946608,
0.3925508857,
-0.525180459,
0.2903867662,
0.0054513733,
0.4632243514,
-1.020044446,
-0.2114834189,
0.206644997,
-0.5232003927,
0.2100634575,
-0.2202590704,
0.0763607845,
-0.4099318683,
-0.011291313,
0.6344950795,
0.3668961823,
-0.9343290925,
0.5103625059,
0.3796059191,
-0.2080288827,
-0.4037367404,
-0.4618082345,
0.1877481341,
-0.2413344979,
-0.7102618814,
0.5503227711,
0.1333847046,
0.0926462933,
-0.3046181202,
0.1352120787,
-0.4321047068,
-0.1122627109,
0.4288541079,
0.5090034604,
-0.1563305259,
0.2981007993,
0.160918057,
-0.4161701202,
-0.0070330254,
-0.4362907112,
0.5578414202,
-0.0949732736,
-0.3600592315,
-0.6022378802,
0.4005374014,
0.5850595832,
-0.4648364484,
0.3563087881,
0.7461293936,
-0.2009275109,
-0.126481086,
-0.4532024562,
-0.1126841828,
-0.537635088,
0.1744097471,
-0.3079514802,
-0.6891855001,
0.303743422,
-0.430362165,
-0.4629440308,
0.4714924097,
0.3903194666,
-0.1390506923,
0.4448984265,
0.6911058426,
-0.2971810699,
0.388635844,
-0.2310687304,
0.2536478639,
-0.5430942774,
-0.4546005726,
-0.8195669651,
-0.3052836955,
-0.7112364173,
-0.5196090937,
0.5652893186,
-0.1785142124,
0.2048485428,
1.048456192,
-0.6069663763,
0.199205175,
0.6665731072,
0.1193018109,
0.5437760353,
-0.1428531557,
-0.3356097639,
0.1756011993,
-0.6263285875,
-0.305711031,
0.6660267711,
0.1477172673,
0.7509974241,
-0.1519954652,
0.9189747572,
0.1397872865,
0.1204441041,
-1.0490192175,
0.5142399073,
-0.1132105291,
-0.2601397038,
-0.2989456058,
-0.17110385,
-0.9836590886,
0.0656485334,
-0.3573256731,
-0.6189623475,
0.5940018892,
0.3469557464,
-0.0579784885,
-0.0373128578,
-0.4106094837,
0.6551081538,
-0.1327205598,
-0.389665693,
-0.0470430851,
-0.8162000775,
0.0676594079,
-0.3355894983,
0.1689664871,
0.2067828625,
0.1751010716,
0.8092356324,
-0.5190683603,
0.6668226719,
0.1459406316,
-0.2179080695,
0.2831910551,
-0.1592106372,
0.5567455888,
-0.2886245847,
-0.096369274,
0.4221301675,
0.0669361204,
-0.1782530248,
-0.051392328,
0.4636429846,
-0.3493261039,
-0.2839548588,
-0.0479504243,
-0.7487127781,
-0.1352839768,
0.2492658645,
0.4233620167,
0.3337345421,
-0.2388466597,
0.2751664817,
0.4984663129,
-0.2264086753,
0.8237434626,
0.2364099324,
0.0802619904,
-0.2946079075,
0.7612376809,
-0.2736336887,
0.0114314407,
0.4914895296,
0.3601735234,
-0.3205272257,
-0.2517352104,
-0.6612148881,
-0.0198825952,
-0.317591399,
-0.1867170781,
-0.6192358136,
-0.0304698981,
-0.0698803738,
-0.2270363271,
-0.2953990996,
-0.0654474124,
-0.0783133656,
0.3415323198,
0.3405738473,
0.5593772531,
0.1200019643,
0.4609865546,
-0.8135547042,
0.3300552964,
0.3072540164,
0.2273769826,
-0.1972557306,
-0.0225011371,
-0.1241698712,
-0.1014289409,
-0.0963606462,
-1.1245423555,
0.3620209098,
0.6387147307,
0.356054455,
0.4354592264,
-0.1897131056,
0.8301749229,
-0.7487899661,
0.2199801356,
0.2393044233,
-0.8942001462,
0.4433064461,
-0.3623539805,
0.2393115461,
0.3117505312,
0.6237695813,
-0.3514985442,
-0.4837783277,
-0.3783033788,
-0.5528153181,
0.2825442553,
0.2292369157,
-0.3438488245,
-0.1844681352,
0.1645639241,
0.3285630941,
-0.1501875222,
-0.3242900074,
0.0128484014,
0.2758818269,
-0.3353907466,
0.0947926566,
0.1802357286,
0.2130563855,
-0.4323413372,
0.62824893,
-0.3571858406,
0.2751743197,
0.2386547625,
-0.3571902812,
-0.2487731427,
0.3043805957,
0.1974900216,
0.1783028543,
0.0292288773,
0.0657132044,
0.1483873874,
-0.684858501,
0.2298933715,
0.0979442447,
-0.2265828699,
0.3021421134,
0.610925138,
0.5383713245,
0.1041010693,
-0.3978375494,
0.5011785626,
0.1814086735,
0.1080973446,
-0.3382721543,
0.0755211264,
0.4218828082,
0.3248288035,
0.4007588923,
0.3727499247,
0.30281201,
-0.4529218674,
0.5839145184,
0.5402575135,
-0.499371171,
-0.3571849763,
0.6887720823,
0.3199164867,
-0.5867661238,
0.4688168168,
-0.1407705098,
-0.6747871637,
0.8452780247,
0.6852553487,
0.7866653204,
-0.6345293522,
-0.1751151234,
0.416274637,
-0.1058927104,
-0.0464520901,
-0.0667640194,
-0.2373298407,
-0.7048370242,
-0.5393589139,
-0.9543910623,
-0.3607627451,
-0.1693447381,
-0.8424057961,
0.5684933662,
0.0637078509,
0.0579393096,
0.3775446713,
-0.563569963,
-0.3736496568,
0.1831068397,
0.4065912366,
0.8250362873,
-1.1230268478,
1.1033744812,
0.4025005698,
-0.0646339431,
-0.6207986474,
-0.2100009322,
0.2960019112,
-0.7482458949,
0.7731150985,
0.3301024735,
-0.683881402,
0.2625250518,
-0.2362117171,
-0.8481861353,
1.0742561817,
0.3606731594,
-0.9480425715,
-0.2199967057,
0.063752979,
0.7615923285,
-0.2654449046,
0.378226459,
0.5689300895,
0.4132754207,
0.4735491574,
-1.0995659828,
-0.029381318,
-0.3449247777,
-0.2900188863,
0.3452386558,
-0.2910502553,
0.7275442481,
-0.0700424239,
-0.1907466203,
0.0820370018,
0.5481267571,
-0.0818860009,
0.0883220509,
0.5913783908,
0.5479030609,
0.7203941345,
-0.2028455585,
0.5149672627,
-0.5346807241,
0.5460538864,
1.1886487007,
0.1316085607,
0.9109527469,
0.5370230675,
-0.3078869879,
0.7432126999,
0.5652578473,
-0.4354609549,
0.3090470135,
0.2562246323,
-0.1786194146,
-0.1357456744,
-0.228801012,
-0.348523885,
0.7648798823,
0.4816487134,
-0.4299196899,
-0.2362853438,
-0.3210259378,
-0.1263197511,
-0.0695182607,
-0.0920952633,
0.8371196389,
-0.2586832047,
-0.6954338551,
0.634545505,
-0.4795819819,
0.9137533903,
-0.459996134,
-0.2705467939,
0.194726631,
0.2600313425,
-0.4667312801,
-0.3008868992,
0.5098873377,
-0.2982671857,
0.0150129991,
-0.1057885885,
0.907002151,
-0.8478628397,
-0.374209851,
0.7115367651,
0.5572456717,
0.0839513317,
0.1153441444,
-0.2089670748,
-0.0025525824,
-0.3123618662,
0.1710440218,
-0.148433283,
-0.0544802137,
-0.2622157037,
0.7215268016,
0.7032853365,
0.0258678962,
0.2548361123,
-0.2626622319,
0.5841017962,
-0.4820230007,
-0.6717146635,
-1.026635766,
0.0036555619,
-0.1286048591,
0.0702416971,
0.5148023367,
0.7252752185,
0.9078788161,
-0.2856660783,
0.5774801373,
-0.1274742186,
0.2388619632,
-0.024237372,
0.5995700955,
-0.179201588,
0.0951508731,
-0.3521077335,
-0.7514398694,
-0.4046655297,
0.5440906286,
-0.2022589594,
-0.4080528021,
0.8900008202,
0.9275642037,
-0.3767318428,
0.4079048932,
0.1257069856,
-0.0374452658,
0.1995094568,
0.6492718458,
0.4780856669,
-0.3275666535,
0.6373963952,
-0.3282402456,
-0.1557985097,
-0.236548394,
-0.8567370772,
-0.7696630955,
-0.648444593,
-0.1707281023,
0.0090759024,
0.2044197023,
0.9451950788,
0.7233579159,
-1.0894725323,
-0.446542263,
-0.3316190839,
-0.3982622921,
-0.4049460292,
-0.1241312325,
0.4410683811,
-0.3315763474,
-0.815205276,
0.6166781187,
0.6702595949,
-0.2121270299,
-0.0989079326,
-0.012476529,
-0.6581953764,
-0.425460279,
0.4206377268,
0.2752580345,
-0.6624607444,
-0.3186220825,
0.0421790443,
-0.0875973701,
0.4232771397,
0.5190926194,
-0.8522102237,
0.5408498049,
0.6461256146,
0.885800302,
0.502684176,
0.0444104597,
0.7058576941,
-0.525749743,
0.1811956763,
0.09353742,
0.467083931,
0.2812671661,
-0.5424226522,
0.539052546,
0.4723924398,
-0.2404503524,
-0.1318562478,
0.2447402775,
-1.2321661711,
0.1466953754,
0.8230298758,
-0.2938066423,
-0.5273032188,
-0.5147298574,
-0.1222279593,
0.6704390645,
-0.2116600126,
0.6216771007,
0.2970909774,
-0.1839835495,
0.0663108677,
-0.1299357563,
0.4568684995,
0.3642061353,
-0.8899033666,
-0.4060053527,
0.3151980937,
0.1926138848,
0.6604553461,
0.1821773648,
-0.0346773192,
0.1831810027,
-0.1380845904,
0.0241440404,
-0.0021292495,
-0.3098534644,
-0.192326799,
0.2101140618,
-0.3846870065,
-0.4331895709
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02915v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02915v1
|
A Computational Model for the Assessment of Mutual Intelligibility Among Closely Related Languages
| 2024-02-05T11:32:13 | 2024-02-05T11:32:13 |
Jessica Nieder, Johann-Mattis List
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Closely related languages show linguistic similarities that allow speakers of
one language to understand speakers of another language without having actively
learned it. Mutual intelligibility varies in degree and is typically tested in
psycholinguistic experiments. To study mutual intelligibility computationally,
we propose a computer-assisted method using the Linear Discriminative Learner,
a computational model developed to approximate the cognitive processes by which
humans learn languages, which we expand with multilingual semantic vectors and
multilingual sound classes. We test the model on cognate data from German,
Dutch, and English, three closely related Germanic languages. We find that our
model's comprehension accuracy depends on 1) the automatic trimming of
inflections and 2) the language pair for which comprehension is tested. Our
multilingual modelling approach does not only offer new methodological findings
for automatic testing of mutual intelligibility across languages but also
extends the use of Linear Discriminative Learning to multilingual settings.
|
[
-0.7617840767,
-0.8924793005,
0.4053779542,
0.2259100229,
-0.0581982844,
0.0106135439,
-0.6342933774,
-0.9067714214,
0.1195764318,
-0.1051493585,
-0.6388046145,
-0.1966994107,
-0.3066266775,
0.2089030296,
-0.1648814529,
0.5083118081,
-0.0045549041,
0.3720023036,
-0.5976914763,
-0.5525231957,
-0.4258810878,
-0.5760117769,
-0.3681533337,
-0.6807534099,
0.5627720356,
0.3457775116,
0.610555768,
0.205383271,
0.6316330433,
0.3327972889,
0.0544390567,
-0.2089775801,
-0.4932733476,
0.1462269276,
-0.1530961543,
-0.5528877974,
-0.1799868047,
-0.1375512481,
0.4190312326,
1.0911589861,
0.0200060494,
0.2173683196,
0.1239326224,
0.5798499584,
-0.2790021598,
0.4622658491,
-0.5050963759,
0.2087880373,
0.0257667806,
0.0288078878,
-0.3819800615,
-0.6181005239,
0.1775103658,
-0.7454833984,
0.2750546634,
-0.1650788784,
0.7299037576,
0.2492971569,
-0.1685403287,
-0.2945642471,
-0.7542313933,
0.5761817098,
-0.4704097807,
0.8015005589,
0.6658303738,
0.3680799007,
0.1530929804,
-0.4389023483,
-0.7900708318,
-0.4400374889,
-0.2285474688,
-0.0215809066,
-0.1877866089,
0.2542908192,
0.3182486296,
0.2427229583,
-0.9589802027,
-0.185600698,
-0.6249785423,
-0.1844914109,
0.4612748623,
-0.1554575115,
0.5452620983,
0.2583806217,
-0.2030662149,
-0.3136132061,
-0.2555570602,
0.0685781911,
0.4718278944,
0.1792771667,
-0.2210946083,
0.3694732785,
0.2892214656,
0.8961532712,
-0.004474849,
-0.2669894397,
0.4991941452,
-0.2732736468,
0.1892268807,
-0.038689319,
0.4371713102,
0.2034876198,
0.7676032186,
-0.3439509869,
-0.0512361936,
0.497464031,
-0.2388687879,
-0.308447212,
-0.2795719802,
-0.0260726009,
-0.4629460275,
0.1797091514,
-0.2222836465,
-0.4149693251,
0.2606374323,
-0.5487070084,
0.4803624153,
-0.8653719425,
-0.5366929173,
0.1783453524,
-0.2267249078,
0.0805548579,
-0.208786279,
-0.7911756635,
0.4439580142,
0.8906187415,
0.6273496151,
-0.161531195,
-0.7530459762,
-0.3674842715,
0.1675141901,
-0.0100291725,
0.5870659947,
-0.8363810778,
-0.2437492609,
0.0586464107,
-0.2334383279,
-0.2637365758,
-0.4063303471,
0.337800473,
-0.792239368,
0.1380004585,
-0.3402213454,
-0.8689761758,
-0.5334485769,
0.1704387516,
-0.8948325515,
0.7799096704,
0.0057867891,
-0.9881346822,
0.4116646051,
-0.4776694179,
-0.368727386,
0.1467231512,
-0.3877419233,
-0.2397926748,
-0.0341841392,
-0.2044505626,
0.2222325206,
-0.0540537015,
0.4249019623,
-0.6565695405,
-0.7272213697,
-0.0485508814,
-0.3762035668,
0.8078841567,
-0.0426411778,
-0.085128434,
-0.2081846446,
-0.7363952994,
-0.0974306166,
-0.0842944905,
-0.1643761694,
-0.589530468,
-0.0448518619,
-0.0011396164,
0.304196775,
0.3324042559,
-0.6007087231,
-0.0833666399,
-0.5509515405,
0.1106993258,
0.5197706819,
0.0314613208,
0.4236762226,
-0.4764351547,
0.7415470481,
-0.1881113648,
-0.0254917908,
0.1078020483,
-0.2676935196,
-0.7283918262,
-0.1361464411,
0.2962576151,
0.6929909587,
-0.7036587,
0.2320190221,
-0.2732060552,
-0.3563549817,
-0.3228452802,
0.1953735948,
0.6420885324,
0.2977313697,
0.0834393427,
-0.2782984376,
-0.3858547807,
-0.8342459798,
-0.2008590698,
-0.5278040767,
0.0939447507,
0.2987658978,
0.3126972616,
-0.1783489585,
0.6366689801,
-0.36330688,
0.1995224208,
-0.0037531548,
0.1055608019,
0.1657192409,
0.2540621161,
0.7303276062,
-0.6800449491,
-0.577411294,
0.193743974,
-0.982247591,
0.0577118881,
0.3397679925,
0.1816700995,
0.0363514312,
0.7727162838,
-0.0798825324,
0.1505396664,
0.7409147024,
-0.2433494478,
0.4330034554,
-0.5619524121,
0.0264407825,
-0.6452459693,
0.1120105535,
-0.1320991367,
-0.0200995672,
-0.6608673334,
0.1224100813,
-0.0217409246,
-0.0466819368,
-0.245710656,
0.4564232528,
-0.475087285,
-0.2365926504,
-0.0911305547,
0.160139963,
-0.1994702071,
0.558280766,
-0.0076004425,
0.6839085817,
0.6110786796,
-0.7806045413,
0.4329629838,
-0.0289716423,
-0.1095651686,
0.7783215642,
-0.6901667118,
0.1426420361,
-0.3986284435,
-0.118705608,
-0.941706419,
-0.1539209485,
-0.2209095359,
-0.5107507706,
0.0913286954,
0.1417116374,
-0.3807364702,
-0.3410024345,
0.03024064,
0.907396853,
0.2064017504,
-0.6356907487,
0.6500669122,
0.4312469661,
-0.1570134908,
-0.4125848711,
-0.5299522877,
-0.4141036868,
-0.3962082863,
-1.1644105911,
-0.035305813,
-0.43945086,
-0.6226710677,
-0.1294329613,
0.3464329541,
-0.4801081121,
0.0698177814,
0.2993988395,
0.2589704692,
-0.1825030744,
0.5526173711,
0.0069007669,
-0.0941445529,
0.1706473678,
-0.1315461695,
0.6740615964,
-0.2741858363,
-0.6429445744,
-0.0867364705,
0.4484422803,
0.4126058817,
-0.509985745,
0.5608350635,
0.6775402427,
-0.3548654616,
-0.1452890635,
-0.5691044927,
-0.4580808878,
-0.4717663229,
0.2772349715,
-0.9293795824,
-1.0195544958,
0.8075311184,
-0.0705599263,
-0.1522702277,
0.142162919,
0.3729740083,
-0.0348799974,
0.5791014433,
0.8900242448,
-0.195542708,
0.3292808235,
0.0320424363,
0.1025778577,
-0.0849301219,
-0.0797109231,
-0.5676124096,
-0.1359779686,
-0.5276033878,
-0.3168312609,
0.5592961907,
0.0775743574,
0.1437221318,
0.3878028691,
-0.1159950942,
0.6311882138,
0.5036051273,
0.0663894042,
0.4169891775,
0.161816746,
-0.61520648,
-0.2032427192,
-0.4112585783,
-0.0326857604,
0.5662747025,
0.2384506315,
0.4236963987,
0.1809109896,
0.5446154475,
0.1742258966,
-0.3567313254,
-0.4287408292,
0.2602875531,
-0.1631264687,
-0.4707437456,
-0.3436215222,
-0.3528558016,
-0.8000341058,
0.1521698833,
-0.0906032696,
-0.6421279311,
0.2641167343,
0.0375368595,
-0.0245080609,
0.1242005527,
-0.7045038939,
0.5586202145,
0.0700709149,
-0.3331430554,
-0.7271540165,
-0.6418887377,
0.4197938442,
-0.342238605,
0.4243825376,
-0.1134903431,
0.3901393712,
0.6664028168,
-0.1636554301,
0.6267616749,
-0.1644491553,
-0.1233069003,
-0.0022444481,
0.3321036994,
0.1485572606,
-0.1270625889,
-0.40083915,
0.3683856428,
0.187620461,
-0.5409940481,
-0.5516356826,
0.7075072527,
-0.7406786084,
-0.2765628397,
-0.3949489594,
-0.8112713099,
-0.3770990372,
0.022401914,
0.0633125305,
0.2171621472,
-0.7114714384,
-0.4077853262,
0.7112720013,
-0.2255531847,
0.5573884249,
0.7904422283,
-0.2870309949,
-0.2575235069,
1.0790070295,
-0.0509416498,
0.463141948,
0.2945770919,
0.083380349,
-0.1503497958,
-0.183281064,
-0.1410536766,
0.5125131011,
-0.6157165766,
0.3250455856,
-0.3374358714,
-0.0917837918,
0.0162503235,
-0.299610883,
0.1619782746,
-0.5575935841,
-0.0187529214,
-0.1405840069,
0.4526756704,
1.0734959841,
-0.4399529099,
-0.0409129038,
-0.5799421072,
0.2889996767,
0.4000569582,
0.2748203576,
0.0530790649,
-0.3658937216,
-0.1028654054,
0.0098314108,
0.2237606794,
-0.7505374551,
0.10627345,
0.5824617147,
0.5067636967,
0.4404138029,
-0.0706007034,
0.7302902341,
-0.5829820037,
0.433763653,
0.2902523577,
-1.0797219276,
0.2004410177,
-0.3167079091,
0.2384810299,
0.8877643347,
0.4892855287,
-0.709251523,
-0.4473356009,
-0.3827373981,
-0.3456785083,
0.5222880244,
-0.0564358197,
-0.1615166962,
0.0236159172,
0.3690592945,
0.2145715654,
-0.3639894128,
-0.5335653424,
-0.2756344974,
0.2648809552,
-0.1835699379,
-0.3625812829,
-0.0886135176,
0.0460527427,
-0.4375715554,
0.564938128,
-0.0815414563,
0.1145297512,
0.010998765,
-0.2763650715,
-0.2624150217,
-0.0168856587,
0.383015573,
0.8070597649,
-0.2846590579,
0.3184909225,
0.4233137369,
-0.5492449403,
0.413939029,
0.2650152147,
-0.1054671854,
0.2542596459,
0.6411811709,
0.5514687896,
0.1424323767,
-0.5400670171,
0.5797207952,
-0.6354448795,
-0.1285676807,
-0.4571974874,
-0.0457784012,
0.4883950949,
0.1640764028,
-0.0279121399,
0.0899939761,
0.1444850862,
-0.2475591302,
0.6735270023,
0.4534911513,
-0.5911309123,
-0.4082024992,
0.4368068874,
0.2199584991,
-0.2756253481,
0.421592176,
-0.3586096466,
-0.5212490559,
0.567533493,
0.610009253,
0.4880047739,
-0.5308004022,
-0.0027060171,
0.633025825,
0.185111627,
0.1508167982,
0.403663516,
-0.2304710001,
-0.6002535224,
-0.4963624477,
-0.5877030492,
-0.186213553,
-0.4246074855,
-0.7549422979,
0.2293878198,
0.0071555143,
0.018706752,
0.299851656,
0.0455137789,
-0.6785924435,
-0.054694958,
0.110658966,
0.8778821826,
-1.1671178341,
1.2199885845,
0.4574920833,
-0.4514350295,
-0.8027322888,
0.026213808,
-0.1734022051,
-0.8842911124,
0.8399733305,
0.0312472805,
-0.3760903776,
-0.2267011553,
-0.0984507799,
-0.7089187503,
0.8051127791,
0.8741474748,
-0.8119309545,
-0.0633600205,
0.4661325812,
0.6691651344,
0.1333307773,
0.5936163068,
0.5586917996,
0.4368558526,
-0.0706560239,
-1.3258144855,
-0.325938046,
-0.3802220523,
-0.168141827,
0.1871882677,
-0.523758173,
0.8325731754,
0.0374547616,
-0.127559185,
-0.3183960021,
0.9316282272,
0.1008598581,
0.3581740558,
0.8911561966,
0.5748679638,
1.0461976528,
0.1827005297,
0.719825983,
-0.8135969043,
0.4460566342,
1.0143332481,
-0.2238795608,
0.7815642357,
0.2899157405,
-0.2874670923,
0.5139659643,
0.1736017317,
0.1813630462,
0.2437544018,
0.3791322708,
-0.7924484015,
-0.1227528825,
-0.273420006,
-0.4461927712,
0.4157675803,
0.2544312179,
-0.1688895971,
-0.1068877503,
0.3251394928,
0.002301903,
0.515414834,
0.0432611406,
0.8511580825,
0.1168609709,
-0.8145343661,
0.8430490494,
-0.202535972,
0.7030890584,
-0.5322964787,
-0.1914279312,
-0.1573624313,
0.3846617341,
-0.0972352773,
-0.5655169487,
0.5229670405,
-0.1773815453,
-0.3769056797,
0.3109709024,
0.6421291232,
-0.7575263381,
-0.7202615142,
1.1494079828,
0.5561051369,
0.2858645022,
0.2836726308,
-0.6229131222,
0.3161795139,
0.1392926127,
0.4790404737,
0.1141204759,
0.3151776791,
0.0490218997,
0.5885132551,
0.3768989742,
0.075797148,
0.3552083075,
0.2708261609,
0.7677411437,
-0.3716510236,
-0.3729406893,
-0.8571587801,
-0.2073517889,
0.1968696415,
0.0323785879,
0.7956051826,
0.6136642694,
1.1258605719,
-0.0845245644,
0.7720355988,
0.1134594902,
0.5852482915,
-0.175843969,
0.6158228517,
-0.3171404898,
0.0023462151,
-0.4274901748,
-0.9067345262,
-0.1611562967,
0.642750442,
-0.2540463805,
-0.094165653,
0.7256033421,
0.9204582572,
-0.5151747465,
0.2886608541,
0.6332457662,
0.169990778,
0.0265959818,
0.9172238708,
0.6484057307,
-0.184250921,
0.3777410686,
-0.6049527526,
-0.4120613039,
0.1768987775,
-0.4290660024,
-1.1861360073,
-0.8947715759,
-0.0694661289,
-0.365424037,
0.3293410838,
0.7964918017,
0.6440164447,
-0.6486852765,
-0.622187674,
-0.0552557409,
-0.0070821717,
-0.2290468216,
-0.1955567598,
0.4192559719,
-0.2106518298,
-0.747005403,
0.4606314898,
0.1112327725,
-0.1678379178,
-0.5009567738,
-0.4391258955,
-0.3457712531,
0.1345303208,
0.3710644245,
0.4265547693,
-0.5673946142,
-0.0776104331,
-0.1176827997,
-0.0104815494,
0.0020551768,
0.6114982963,
-0.6771758199,
0.8270815611,
0.7631734014,
0.4259472787,
0.4804167151,
-0.1227269247,
0.693282187,
-0.5966012478,
0.525392592,
0.101797305,
0.337312907,
0.25209409,
-0.1616351753,
0.2988856733,
0.1128563881,
-0.6200187206,
-0.4743136466,
0.4208475649,
-0.8864181042,
-0.2557624876,
0.785428822,
-0.4122591615,
-0.2550325692,
-0.3884063363,
0.0033525692,
0.2838409841,
-0.1877097785,
0.3490641117,
0.8302755952,
0.0118123749,
0.072098434,
-0.2851729691,
0.4806931615,
0.4431645274,
-0.585169673,
-0.0501382835,
0.3950758874,
0.220951885,
0.2762926519,
0.4927171469,
0.1301881522,
0.4366508722,
0.1011308804,
0.3455018103,
0.1987306476,
-0.1949942559,
-0.7167779803,
0.1530306935,
0.26747787,
-0.0077752867
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02896v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02896v1
|
LLM Agents in Interaction: Measuring Personality Consistency and Linguistic Alignment in Interacting Populations of Large Language Models
| 2024-02-05T11:05:20 | 2024-02-05T11:05:20 |
Ivar Frisch, Mario Giulianelli
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.MA
|
While both agent interaction and personalisation are vibrant topics in
research on large language models (LLMs), there has been limited focus on the
effect of language interaction on the behaviour of persona-conditioned LLM
agents. Such an endeavour is important to ensure that agents remain consistent
to their assigned traits yet are able to engage in open, naturalistic
dialogues. In our experiments, we condition GPT-3.5 on personality profiles
through prompting and create a two-group population of LLM agents using a
simple variability-inducing sampling algorithm. We then administer personality
tests and submit the agents to a collaborative writing task, finding that
different profiles exhibit different degrees of personality consistency and
linguistic alignment to their conversational partners. Our study seeks to lay
the groundwork for better understanding of dialogue-based interaction between
LLMs and highlights the need for new approaches to crafting robust, more
human-like LLM personas for interactive environments.
|
[
-0.4937887788,
-0.7200739384,
0.8358428478,
0.3854776025,
0.1492166817,
0.1217976436,
-0.4256823361,
-0.6646823883,
0.4545470774,
0.6487243176,
-0.7008348703,
-0.3828329444,
-0.2600863576,
0.2101590782,
0.0002969139,
0.8205446601,
-0.0963007733,
0.1762880981,
-0.4385450184,
-0.3582228124,
-0.3899920881,
-0.8246766329,
-0.7819756269,
-0.520247519,
0.7331157923,
0.2547662854,
0.8709094524,
0.2967669964,
0.4494993985,
0.4247125685,
-0.0149793765,
0.1245857477,
-0.5797051787,
0.5398648381,
-0.3439808488,
-0.3005178273,
-0.7011976242,
0.2118135095,
0.5779210925,
0.8046252131,
-0.060461089,
-0.2706237733,
0.1610611528,
0.5280565619,
-0.1773736477,
0.2577156126,
-0.2777426541,
-0.1679379791,
-0.1929534227,
-0.082138598,
-0.4296267629,
-0.4190708399,
0.1596424133,
-0.4340539575,
0.0100164972,
0.1195997521,
0.5830397606,
0.1574883759,
-0.4795332551,
-0.1047978103,
-0.8555316329,
0.5469512939,
-0.7146100402,
0.200918451,
0.4137292802,
0.0129792495,
-0.4217628539,
-0.2146223336,
-0.8003783822,
-0.5359796882,
-0.1351880729,
0.1652831286,
0.1778091192,
0.3146090806,
0.1044661477,
0.1629788876,
-0.5510430336,
0.3874124289,
0.1076026112,
-0.1593084931,
0.8013138175,
0.3750416338,
0.335942328,
0.1200229749,
-0.0188573748,
-0.005766321,
-0.6684448719,
-0.0811951458,
0.813277781,
0.2393608838,
-0.105945237,
0.72311759,
-0.1372795999,
0.4338100255,
0.3270153999,
-0.1245310307,
0.0191353485,
-0.5152908564,
0.041114077,
-0.1868280619,
0.8846603036,
0.5285311937,
0.5316479206,
-0.1262115836,
-0.1928616166,
-0.1015962586,
0.1646795869,
-0.4689802825,
-0.1528147161,
0.2682665586,
-0.1690254509,
-0.2161418647,
0.1305396855,
-0.5638371706,
-0.6592515111,
-0.4245709181,
0.1871994734,
-0.2551495135,
-0.3930606246,
-0.0678273812,
0.1680911928,
0.5388549566,
0.4036177993,
-1.2863173485,
0.4872135818,
0.6543754935,
0.5307683945,
-0.3653392494,
-0.7156298161,
-0.4992112815,
0.2716398537,
-0.2014897168,
0.7601726651,
-0.5355519056,
-0.4955224991,
0.0848736912,
-0.0843869522,
-0.1398113221,
-0.5625921488,
0.0570411049,
-0.262902379,
0.3133499026,
-0.4764927924,
-0.5811424851,
0.2935103178,
0.3439743519,
-0.4881564379,
0.8038674593,
0.3630433381,
-0.4947810769,
0.2095229477,
-0.541313231,
-0.1554518044,
0.1168192551,
-0.3887110353,
-0.2284915298,
0.0056295721,
-0.1841800958,
0.3777930737,
0.0509322584,
0.1874903142,
-0.5228708982,
-0.3517970145,
0.8258440495,
-0.1529959738,
0.4302592278,
-0.0863418281,
-0.1485640109,
0.3139002621,
-0.3273080587,
-0.0589677207,
0.0261702798,
-0.3775177002,
0.0389513597,
0.0735537335,
0.1074442938,
0.0604135916,
0.5069559813,
-0.5522167683,
0.7054599524,
-0.3035586774,
0.2563028932,
0.6986504793,
0.0750986487,
0.47196576,
-0.6755033135,
0.4046194553,
-0.1402807832,
-0.0577812232,
0.1309728771,
-0.5166190863,
-0.6629307866,
-0.3153755367,
-0.050436046,
0.4999834895,
-0.317599684,
0.6435260177,
-0.1446948647,
-0.2484811246,
-0.4134347439,
0.3426777422,
0.4999546707,
0.1931560785,
-0.1654726118,
-0.5971627235,
-0.6131456494,
-0.8515812159,
-0.2099754363,
-0.4234815836,
-0.0802668706,
0.4088637233,
0.3574377894,
-0.4596749544,
1.208286047,
-0.3008459508,
0.1127762496,
-0.5688750148,
0.0456789583,
-0.0327531099,
0.4224333763,
0.5209860802,
-0.5016230345,
-0.825863719,
0.0267114732,
-0.5974068642,
-0.3888942301,
0.0397950038,
-0.0701651424,
0.3846385777,
0.5702088475,
-0.6689035296,
0.200707525,
0.4779252708,
-0.2799369693,
0.6026149988,
-0.1914018393,
0.0727267489,
-0.9464299679,
-0.0667947605,
0.0441403799,
-0.4490687549,
-1.0085958242,
-0.2038719058,
-0.3775358498,
0.2043581158,
-0.3494524062,
0.754699707,
-0.3440048099,
-0.0670080185,
-0.3271233141,
0.3849925697,
-0.0741282776,
0.5019291043,
0.2218858153,
0.8949657083,
0.3300297558,
-0.2984642088,
0.3087517023,
0.5646250248,
0.0341710709,
1.0363779068,
-0.532456398,
0.590098083,
-0.0653714985,
0.3307435215,
-1.0317269564,
-0.6413363814,
0.3543124199,
-0.2777809501,
0.2492268085,
0.1327780783,
-0.4679034948,
0.1149326786,
-0.3355505466,
0.1702949554,
0.4369361699,
-0.2576277852,
0.7295747995,
0.3159438968,
-0.5525407791,
-0.0662397072,
-0.4847930372,
0.0778760165,
-0.3346877098,
-0.7490552664,
0.1230641156,
-0.454446137,
-0.6902911663,
-0.2881219089,
0.0601706691,
-0.1602305025,
0.0378449857,
0.2247225791,
0.2166748792,
-0.0696178451,
-0.1187026575,
-0.2977795303,
0.0490898862,
0.0119742807,
0.0137384236,
0.794147253,
-0.303968668,
-0.5324497223,
-0.6602776051,
0.4234841466,
0.5226699114,
0.0079357261,
1.0337619781,
0.3216737807,
-0.1022968963,
0.2644332349,
-0.659760952,
-0.0695331022,
-0.5123977065,
0.1093242392,
-0.3956953585,
-1.0034202337,
0.7777212858,
0.0997767225,
-0.0854316801,
0.2283368409,
0.8238748908,
-0.3979395032,
0.9424859285,
0.7153493166,
-0.1545220464,
0.4537876546,
0.2711509168,
0.147556752,
-0.9543996453,
-0.2343667448,
-0.306255728,
-0.2840647995,
-0.7407360077,
0.0217707641,
0.0630628616,
-0.2161809057,
-0.3334020078,
0.0963391587,
-0.2185640782,
0.6074951291,
0.3769388199,
0.0689572394,
0.2584402561,
-0.5313384533,
0.0324313156,
-0.1380599141,
-0.026534969,
-0.7334649563,
0.8424021602,
0.2322388291,
0.7703278065,
0.5202391148,
0.7815018892,
-0.0738580599,
0.4615016282,
-0.6948138475,
0.6782637835,
0.298162967,
-0.4516185224,
-0.4547602832,
-0.1997682005,
-0.9786223173,
-0.0569272935,
-0.0498737171,
-1.3818181753,
0.0518700816,
0.1191987097,
-0.2179767489,
-0.1373020709,
-0.6642805934,
0.7040023208,
-0.1244739145,
-0.3483223915,
0.0561750792,
-0.7582415342,
0.228986904,
-0.2140116692,
-0.2344476581,
-0.1973248422,
-0.0404168926,
0.3503733873,
-0.3664213717,
1.1042844057,
0.015010206,
-0.381724149,
0.0570816249,
0.1232330203,
0.5432523489,
-0.0043485779,
-0.0581741855,
-0.1032134518,
0.0493866913,
-0.3257645667,
-0.7081295848,
0.7242367268,
-1.0215244293,
-0.9189524055,
-0.4333153963,
-0.8956975937,
-0.5317361951,
0.0514197722,
-0.0217798557,
0.1190901995,
-0.5757843852,
0.1077482998,
0.816989243,
-0.0361168794,
0.257741183,
0.6992034912,
-0.4028369188,
-0.2878417075,
0.7346075773,
-0.1285318881,
0.6658755541,
0.2530278563,
0.1073798612,
-0.2848269045,
-0.4791051745,
0.0955812931,
0.3516153097,
-0.5120611191,
0.4387066662,
-0.3737562597,
-0.2528639138,
-0.499863416,
-0.2776813209,
-0.1178096682,
-0.1253868937,
-0.0966072828,
0.2536897659,
0.2035589069,
0.9728470445,
0.1186023206,
0.5811325908,
-0.5569464564,
0.012733913,
0.3130138218,
0.3329442441,
-0.4103791416,
-0.314227581,
-0.0234381072,
0.0115242749,
-0.4203557074,
-1.0168151855,
0.1739991158,
0.2177749425,
0.6414575577,
0.5009897351,
-0.3196700811,
0.3245684505,
-0.2558954656,
0.864280045,
-0.042233523,
-0.8773528934,
0.3224939108,
-0.7327329516,
0.370598048,
0.6337820888,
0.1789651513,
-1.0147755146,
-0.6604059935,
-0.5194068551,
-0.4630716443,
0.63809973,
0.2947277427,
0.116607897,
0.0576524734,
0.5537868738,
0.0370082445,
0.3643117249,
-0.7656039596,
-0.1837116331,
0.0672902986,
-0.4367138147,
-0.3187562525,
-0.244611308,
-0.4195827246,
-0.176674813,
0.3033152819,
-0.2084538341,
0.3176423609,
0.1193651333,
0.0437464565,
-0.1149983481,
0.2997399569,
0.7947869301,
0.5777262449,
-0.1728586853,
0.0747986734,
0.1582731158,
-0.4963264465,
0.2488682419,
0.0287328456,
0.0548742674,
-0.3475146294,
0.2904975712,
0.5420366526,
0.0682619363,
-0.6559572816,
0.4755713344,
-0.2513675094,
-0.3070186973,
-0.344823122,
0.2926106453,
0.3609070182,
0.3400455117,
-0.1408608556,
-0.2255176455,
-0.2470576763,
-0.6987121105,
0.0363132097,
0.6482946873,
-0.1479575187,
-0.416669786,
0.431358546,
0.2587636709,
-0.7024570704,
0.7177957892,
-0.2505988479,
-0.3716087937,
0.4285461605,
0.4441128671,
0.9660677314,
-0.3536845446,
0.1192614734,
-0.2072824836,
0.0921090245,
-0.0405462794,
0.3901240528,
0.1330683082,
-1.0380306244,
-0.3451395035,
-0.3591513038,
-1.0963647366,
0.2287011147,
-0.4825831056,
0.0456343107,
-0.3103699088,
0.0440591276,
-0.0372918732,
0.2196336985,
-0.5492760539,
-0.1792121679,
0.1695369035,
0.376881063,
-0.7611024976,
0.9151554108,
0.7739841342,
-0.3935574293,
-0.7146155834,
0.171450451,
0.3343579173,
-0.5889040828,
0.3908734322,
0.2753228545,
-0.1084611863,
-0.0150940707,
-0.614513278,
-0.7547792792,
0.9561199546,
0.4621477723,
-0.4463859499,
0.248943001,
0.5035568476,
0.7908203602,
-0.5106620193,
0.2968699634,
0.7422794104,
0.6845575571,
0.0878392532,
-1.1147162914,
-0.1273454875,
-0.3094138503,
0.0208576377,
0.1950433552,
-0.9729497433,
0.4978040755,
0.1254509836,
0.1122407094,
0.4785426557,
0.8176981807,
0.3768417835,
0.1534338295,
0.4016714096,
0.342492491,
1.0112113953,
-0.1828916669,
0.8560721278,
-0.3058824241,
0.1300518662,
1.2516132593,
-0.9133805037,
0.684845984,
0.5539979935,
-0.1722331047,
0.4805034101,
0.5938946605,
-0.0167595297,
0.2541047633,
0.2983724773,
-0.6354178786,
-0.0298402887,
-0.1956364959,
0.0703411475,
0.3777710199,
0.1902377307,
0.065365836,
0.3225906491,
-0.0448920764,
0.1369315088,
0.2630589902,
-0.0274249371,
0.8433974385,
-0.1119441986,
-0.9053232074,
-0.0202857405,
-0.2595716417,
0.5148411989,
-0.5308189988,
0.233121559,
-0.3925241232,
0.118728824,
-0.2384138405,
-1.0220649242,
0.2933337986,
-0.1813755035,
-0.1361951977,
-0.4441784918,
0.5323706269,
-0.716113627,
0.0208652411,
0.0445147268,
0.7478348613,
0.4397316575,
0.0955760106,
-0.2423800081,
0.1828421205,
-0.2168645412,
-0.4423800111,
0.7310495377,
0.2054978162,
0.081846647,
0.7033413053,
0.3910114467,
-0.0097248415,
-0.2696740925,
0.3181396127,
0.7351772785,
-0.5207878947,
-0.1165499464,
-0.942897439,
0.4429815114,
-0.0737149566,
-0.3735613823,
0.8451948166,
0.457456857,
0.6372579336,
0.0114122648,
0.7025960684,
0.0176028181,
0.2449869365,
-0.4320239723,
0.4880225956,
0.0069129737,
0.1505953819,
-0.0956396833,
-1.076590538,
-0.0233038589,
0.4815277457,
-0.3571659327,
0.2957479358,
0.6911048293,
0.9578851461,
0.217435047,
-0.028175557,
0.3233932257,
0.2929038703,
0.519556582,
0.4232424498,
0.9690049291,
0.2840911448,
0.1098000407,
-0.0042792233,
-0.2024883926,
0.0209071003,
-0.9025272727,
-1.051631093,
-0.6256902814,
-0.3605652452,
-0.3751702309,
-0.025277473,
1.1086876392,
0.2904735506,
-0.4657108486,
-0.4349833131,
-0.0702740848,
-0.0641142428,
-0.0532200933,
-0.2091018558,
-0.1050062105,
-0.2461283803,
-1.0047217607,
0.4171402156,
0.4565968215,
0.31620574,
-0.8265175819,
-0.3601737022,
-0.0515477359,
0.3425274491,
0.2431774288,
0.449290216,
-0.7792592645,
-0.5892179012,
0.0526738949,
-0.3681019843,
0.2881143391,
0.6963157058,
-0.4407244325,
0.2774928808,
0.2413598448,
0.3740801513,
0.3032715321,
0.1515130103,
0.8438820243,
-0.8759893179,
0.0068164845,
0.088706322,
0.2871713042,
0.5056143999,
-0.5968385935,
0.3023116887,
0.0984420404,
-1.019544363,
-0.5445030928,
0.5322739482,
-1.2477654219,
0.2965604663,
1.3412247896,
-0.0598591827,
-0.0415372662,
-0.2465772927,
-0.5182296634,
-0.0331129804,
-0.3418548703,
0.6155168414,
1.0982967615,
-0.6331332326,
-0.1834511608,
-0.4542306364,
0.4996131957,
0.2757139504,
-0.9953115582,
-0.033385627,
0.4869220257,
0.2717254162,
0.0652749017,
1.0113368034,
0.2648674846,
-0.0293015074,
-0.2926415801,
0.1080100015,
0.2874533832,
-0.0129479822,
-0.3806256652,
-0.1835033447,
0.4719925523,
0.317291677
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02883v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02883v1
|
Approximate Attributions for Off-the-Shelf Siamese Transformers
| 2024-02-05T10:49:05 | 2024-02-05T10:49:05 |
Lucas Möller, Dmitry Nikolaev, Sebastian Padó
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Siamese encoders such as sentence transformers are among the least understood
deep models. Established attribution methods cannot tackle this model class
since it compares two inputs rather than processing a single one. To address
this gap, we have recently proposed an attribution method specifically for
Siamese encoders (M\"oller et al., 2023). However, it requires models to be
adjusted and fine-tuned and therefore cannot be directly applied to
off-the-shelf models. In this work, we reassess these restrictions and propose
(i) a model with exact attribution ability that retains the original model's
predictive performance and (ii) a way to compute approximate attributions for
off-the-shelf models. We extensively compare approximate and exact attributions
and use them to analyze the models' attendance to different linguistic aspects.
We gain insights into which syntactic roles Siamese transformers attend to,
confirm that they mostly ignore negation, explore how they judge semantically
opposite adjectives, and find that they exhibit lexical bias.
|
[
-0.3666855097,
-0.2775048912,
0.7067289948,
0.0291229729,
-0.1114166975,
-0.2491834462,
-0.2330892235,
-0.3180572391,
0.3366785347,
0.58613199,
-0.7004252672,
0.1293210536,
-0.399541676,
0.1436391324,
-0.4758611023,
0.9561966062,
-0.1241209283,
-0.1941984743,
-0.2257972062,
-0.1188710183,
-0.1354830116,
-0.4915544987,
-0.2372952849,
-0.3614884019,
0.5187863111,
0.4138669074,
0.7646890283,
0.4093007147,
0.6334480643,
0.2339238375,
-0.0535752326,
-0.2062805146,
-0.1222785786,
-0.1415403336,
-0.3951456845,
-0.9401855469,
-0.4784189761,
0.0115968185,
0.6191718578,
0.5581727028,
-0.1669580191,
0.3193475008,
-0.0789299831,
0.4169422388,
-0.8983925581,
0.1229079515,
-0.942245841,
0.1482201964,
0.1364991069,
-0.1259177029,
-0.6001161933,
-0.6171296239,
0.1598785073,
-0.580473423,
0.2470103055,
-0.1220365763,
0.8943827748,
0.5589768291,
-0.477176398,
-0.4643565118,
-0.7463033795,
0.9711478949,
-0.638436377,
0.3106588423,
0.4295931756,
0.3706208467,
0.0688997731,
-0.7592852712,
-0.5063229799,
-0.3573312759,
-0.258662492,
0.1538215727,
-0.3487381637,
0.0306621287,
0.1378127784,
0.4662866592,
-0.3185989559,
0.258625865,
-0.337079823,
0.1560876369,
0.3657276928,
0.0944052413,
-0.0497489087,
-0.6002911925,
-0.5343067646,
-0.1142893434,
-0.7059530616,
-0.0578193888,
0.459738642,
0.0422374047,
-0.0676348433,
0.9084353447,
0.0039103343,
0.3547764421,
0.1451111287,
0.4658719599,
-0.0857928321,
-0.551075995,
0.0235166512,
0.3466920257,
0.7069638968,
0.3500952125,
0.7414149046,
-0.3377680779,
-0.5356248617,
0.2180095464,
0.7816063166,
-0.4928981066,
-0.3497852087,
-0.4539033175,
-0.2889077365,
-0.6732892394,
0.033723034,
-0.8063442111,
-0.2110016942,
-0.0943101794,
0.6420331597,
0.0373686589,
-0.0746030733,
-0.148501575,
-0.111853011,
0.3152902722,
-0.0563421175,
-0.6440513134,
0.6209908128,
0.3289428055,
0.9559870958,
-0.0095854644,
0.0739787668,
-0.2333800048,
0.1760303825,
-0.345012337,
0.6362913847,
-0.6581357121,
-0.1947428286,
-0.0736876726,
0.0691266432,
-0.0979688615,
-0.5803745389,
0.714183569,
-0.4368724227,
0.3219491839,
-0.0352458358,
-0.6959395409,
-0.0755565837,
0.079122588,
-0.8779203892,
0.3637666106,
0.2161146402,
-0.6688304543,
0.3653180003,
-0.8908033371,
-0.1738493741,
-0.3386543989,
0.033422932,
-0.5079223514,
0.533164084,
0.5102873445,
0.4225412309,
-0.2983915508,
0.3580600917,
-0.3368408084,
-0.3322278261,
0.68571347,
-0.701415956,
0.9964596033,
0.1344164908,
-0.1329659075,
-0.0564067066,
-0.6832907796,
-0.178812176,
0.2328628302,
0.1195371747,
-0.1988687515,
0.0353386551,
-0.0803279504,
0.0272200163,
0.0184467137,
-0.6975194812,
0.2663574815,
-0.650803268,
0.69089818,
0.6693560481,
0.0741372928,
0.863101244,
-0.2461398542,
0.9296647906,
-0.1338333935,
0.1021168604,
-0.1497035027,
-0.2595670223,
-0.9422622919,
-0.2105959505,
0.42961815,
0.4502246082,
-0.7812337279,
0.5159034133,
-0.6906653047,
-0.7911207676,
-0.7939798236,
-0.147339344,
0.3197879195,
0.2578439116,
0.2973691523,
-0.5111778975,
-0.6923704147,
-1.090914607,
-0.6445320249,
-0.4102689326,
-0.2106251419,
-0.0106409267,
0.4721418619,
0.1270741671,
1.3021595478,
-0.7581516504,
-0.5882414579,
-0.1486300081,
0.0496149175,
0.1547557861,
0.4345774055,
0.6794487834,
-0.6048434377,
-0.3253356814,
-0.270205617,
-0.576198101,
-0.1509136856,
-0.0819308609,
0.3496258855,
-0.0371400602,
0.6425440311,
-0.9064535499,
0.4156622887,
0.346314311,
-0.0006829458,
0.6400940418,
-0.0060585449,
-0.0548135079,
-0.9425886273,
-0.0015720587,
0.1389770657,
-0.3882961273,
-0.5901505351,
0.1726534814,
0.1031111032,
-0.1016105488,
-0.5398672223,
0.4851150215,
-0.2393142134,
-0.1064243168,
0.0467173643,
-0.03096525,
0.1737153232,
0.5850092173,
0.0242427271,
0.6230806112,
0.1989241987,
-0.3753062189,
0.5996556282,
0.1970181614,
-0.7023308873,
0.5487380028,
-0.8299873471,
-0.0273507908,
-0.0042409422,
0.5046415925,
-1.1015114784,
-0.0903717428,
0.3877465725,
-0.6665664911,
0.2954294682,
-0.3349008262,
-0.5295880437,
-0.2252547145,
-0.2825371325,
0.6155337095,
0.8284145594,
-0.6498177052,
0.6405545473,
0.0401812717,
-0.228987813,
-0.142673701,
-1.0045970678,
-0.0768215135,
-0.7350786924,
-0.257740289,
0.3666218221,
0.367543608,
-0.3032048643,
0.2476451546,
0.089079313,
-0.2791179419,
-0.1237141788,
-0.0333043598,
0.0394957177,
-0.6591952443,
0.0075168461,
-0.1219996363,
-0.3118416965,
0.3310804367,
-0.0469603799,
0.0719193146,
0.0151972612,
-0.3848946989,
-0.3917043507,
0.0126133347,
0.4936752319,
-0.1259560585,
0.6900698543,
0.3927111626,
-0.4420728981,
0.1567394137,
-0.6157932281,
-0.4800329804,
-0.535308063,
0.5496939421,
-0.3553753197,
-0.1795692593,
0.5482597351,
0.5303954482,
-0.0447613224,
0.5302334428,
0.4827137887,
0.1681859195,
1.1700462103,
0.5650418401,
0.1504596472,
0.418027848,
0.0105603551,
0.5702105165,
-0.8217004538,
0.0048671523,
-0.6384400725,
-0.11691764,
-0.6085615754,
-0.2140939385,
0.1106664538,
-0.0363104045,
-0.1835875064,
0.8029046059,
-0.3655255437,
0.3875463903,
0.3701568544,
-0.0079348264,
0.2943581939,
0.2383981198,
0.3738161922,
-0.4269288182,
-0.7949849963,
-0.515848875,
0.8187606335,
0.4791670144,
0.9608004689,
0.3209896088,
0.1690518707,
0.1943355203,
0.0680153519,
-0.906345129,
0.3417423964,
-0.3280399442,
-0.6102747917,
0.0501765534,
-0.4620956481,
-0.6564037204,
0.0036863228,
0.2347019315,
-0.9178734422,
0.1648818851,
0.1220928207,
-0.2785378695,
0.3940110803,
-1.0567076206,
0.9672948122,
0.0025147009,
0.0437665731,
0.0078695025,
-0.5347905755,
0.3391182721,
-0.3069874942,
0.0322837904,
0.1459479183,
-0.1599778831,
0.9359127283,
-0.3066598773,
0.828314662,
-0.1453053951,
-0.2597884834,
0.2855652869,
0.1883918643,
0.5000496507,
-0.3327524662,
-0.0992927998,
-0.1115692779,
0.0293599274,
-0.2083751559,
-1.1014282703,
0.5933949351,
-0.6943389177,
-0.4153180718,
-0.239698872,
-0.123415567,
-0.1764569879,
-0.0975000188,
0.6681621671,
0.5516188145,
-0.0608031638,
0.1768420935,
0.1179527864,
-0.1302940398,
0.2360426039,
0.2421726882,
-0.1154175699,
-0.1285122931,
1.0955476761,
0.1688975096,
0.6239646077,
0.4611124992,
0.1183185205,
-0.6807066798,
0.0949885175,
-0.5761945248,
0.1847309321,
-1.0390554667,
-0.2537508011,
-0.7731482983,
-0.2444603145,
-0.2777155042,
-0.6136643291,
-0.8469933867,
-0.7956936359,
-0.542206645,
0.0540426262,
0.3839596212,
0.8673609495,
0.2702370286,
0.5721229315,
-0.5473822951,
0.1677247435,
0.1202487871,
0.4108520448,
0.2781904638,
-0.9563421011,
-0.1009277701,
0.3653237522,
-0.4229501188,
-0.8045148253,
0.1864926964,
0.5519832373,
0.398597151,
0.3871443272,
0.3407531977,
0.9232393503,
-0.4172447622,
0.9432042241,
0.4045639336,
-0.9949863553,
0.345177561,
0.1730895936,
0.264977634,
0.3346420527,
0.3441442251,
-0.1914550364,
-0.5524302125,
-0.822494626,
-0.7387173176,
0.9347784519,
0.6033143997,
0.2513025701,
0.2089504451,
0.1928069741,
0.1103241369,
0.0411090851,
-0.7293967009,
-0.0712524652,
-0.3245224357,
-0.3966714144,
-0.5186160207,
-0.178297326,
0.4964523613,
-0.2335544378,
0.6320413947,
0.0719171017,
0.5144166946,
-0.0752220452,
-0.3595835268,
-0.0852322951,
0.3970927298,
0.4181704223,
0.4489066303,
-0.2849202454,
0.4170333147,
0.3414140642,
-0.2268763036,
0.4156521261,
-0.0945300981,
0.0160381868,
0.3449450135,
0.3408848345,
0.7979171276,
0.3933362365,
-0.5790784955,
0.774307251,
0.0579677373,
0.1930572838,
-0.7669020891,
-0.0693128705,
-0.146487847,
0.1196689829,
0.0315145776,
0.3614223897,
0.1540990025,
-0.5066288114,
0.3266352117,
0.1227209568,
-1.1181036234,
-0.4767599702,
0.7822021842,
-0.0112602077,
-0.2515460849,
0.6350795627,
-0.1556991041,
-0.960282445,
0.78495121,
0.3877554536,
1.0358932018,
-0.14304851,
0.0574175455,
0.2925606668,
0.4251303673,
-0.0365302525,
-0.5394237041,
0.0840606317,
-0.7514359951,
-0.4626146257,
-0.5179609656,
-0.0643024594,
-0.2611812651,
-0.9572190642,
0.5539527535,
-0.0005644535,
-0.1913665682,
0.2700410783,
-0.2549796104,
-0.700968504,
-0.0629326627,
-0.0804201216,
0.701800406,
-0.9075215459,
0.6009561419,
0.6991000175,
-0.5481562614,
-0.5281259418,
-0.0278201047,
-0.1793456972,
-0.7368361354,
0.4899454117,
0.1723555624,
-0.0434637852,
0.1239694655,
-0.3496873975,
-0.6670982838,
0.5456822515,
0.5110131502,
-0.2938155234,
-0.3439970315,
0.1061599925,
0.4160860777,
-0.4169557989,
0.5221075416,
0.6236384511,
0.2764171362,
0.1194390357,
-1.1268843412,
0.0171293542,
-0.1325187236,
-0.0271595381,
0.1890250593,
-0.0999273658,
0.4445841908,
-0.2316508293,
-0.0490073599,
0.3007186949,
0.5351677537,
-0.1612093598,
-0.039533142,
0.670843184,
0.2821528316,
0.0103797484,
0.137256816,
1.1063534021,
0.2292342633,
0.6450589299,
1.1332879066,
-0.170375362,
0.7552793026,
0.5838010907,
-0.3296242356,
0.3223185241,
0.4640503526,
-0.3329844177,
0.7909091115,
0.0945418477,
0.0525354072,
-0.0450911373,
-0.5423827767,
-0.1545084417,
0.6150763631,
0.3778136671,
-0.7046957016,
-0.0933521315,
0.0809675604,
-0.0449083745,
-0.1374062598,
-0.2759652436,
0.8396004438,
0.3678745925,
-0.6934863925,
0.6561124921,
0.0287422333,
0.6598436236,
-0.5593575835,
0.1496809423,
0.22545591,
0.5649044514,
-0.1678470969,
-0.8625751734,
0.5501939654,
0.1735757291,
-0.1706282496,
-0.1375079751,
0.645159781,
-0.5582373738,
-0.7208009958,
0.0826326385,
-0.0188155025,
0.2293805182,
-0.2954179347,
-0.3619360924,
-0.3345467746,
0.2230991721,
-0.2510778904,
-0.1247922927,
0.3522228897,
0.0427974425,
0.7809183598,
0.1030849814,
0.0976297259,
0.3418232501,
-0.18458049,
0.5691472888,
-0.5575538874,
-0.5046966076,
-0.8063560724,
0.4413161278,
0.1536636353,
-0.3044117391,
0.5975933671,
0.435452342,
0.8630981445,
-0.2814251184,
0.6356468797,
0.0241269134,
0.2215427011,
-0.5590477586,
0.6303845048,
-1.1197971106,
0.108786732,
-0.4351374805,
-1.4158620834,
-0.1659304798,
0.7562863231,
-0.2485895902,
0.0806330591,
0.5861682296,
0.8760113716,
-0.5202003717,
0.3857092261,
0.2698389292,
0.2978433073,
0.4185456336,
0.5410256982,
1.0971837044,
-0.5456678271,
0.5342301726,
-0.4344487786,
0.1579060704,
-0.3539439142,
-0.8604933619,
-0.566481173,
-0.555868268,
-0.4739692211,
-0.022064453,
-0.2081174701,
0.909958601,
0.391479075,
-0.7846412063,
0.0387405008,
-0.1652942896,
-0.0687685087,
-0.0048517035,
-0.2544817328,
0.3032660484,
-0.0534808412,
-0.5148067474,
-0.0657202005,
-0.0870723799,
0.0994947627,
-0.5689271092,
0.042737525,
0.0441838466,
0.0871131569,
0.511947751,
-0.118136555,
-0.9801813364,
-0.4519563317,
0.0815272927,
-0.1388189197,
0.0284864176,
0.9898679256,
-0.7249856591,
0.5036249757,
0.2855437696,
0.3453921676,
0.311840266,
-0.0481227674,
0.8189156651,
-0.8414781094,
0.245028466,
0.4401879907,
0.2376144528,
0.5007304549,
-0.0529385097,
0.3618335724,
-0.0105828056,
-0.4715405703,
-0.8333910704,
0.3573124111,
-0.7160764337,
-0.0896241143,
1.0614836216,
-0.2460967153,
-0.1376187801,
-0.1254201978,
0.1420122832,
0.3683828712,
-0.2230138034,
0.420974344,
0.7063717842,
0.4327277243,
-0.2138083726,
-0.5037915111,
0.3119959533,
0.7760486007,
-0.1562569439,
0.0593234934,
0.0850268304,
0.0149582429,
0.2193268687,
0.1742760837,
-0.0269685965,
-0.0057918043,
0.0737569332,
-0.0445152223,
0.3454302549,
-0.2621173263,
-0.3894957304,
-0.1406066567,
0.2071033269,
-0.2470561117
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02872v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02872v2
|
How do Large Language Models Learn In-Context? Query and Key Matrices of In-Context Heads are Two Towers for Metric Learning
| 2024-02-05T10:39:32 | 2024-06-11T12:58:51 |
Zeping Yu, Sophia Ananiadou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We investigate the mechanism of in-context learning (ICL) on sentence
classification tasks with semantically-unrelated labels ("foo"/"bar"). We find
intervening in only 1\% heads (named "in-context heads") significantly affects
ICL accuracy from 87.6\% to 24.4\%. To understand this phenomenon, we analyze
the value-output vectors in these heads and discover that the vectors at each
label position contain substantial information about the corresponding labels.
Furthermore, we observe that the prediction shift from "foo" to "bar" is due to
the respective reduction and increase in these heads' attention scores at "foo"
and "bar" positions. Therefore, we propose a hypothesis for ICL: in in-context
heads, the value-output matrices extract label features, while the query-key
matrices compute the similarity between the features at the last position and
those at each label position. The query and key matrices can be considered as
two towers that learn the similarity metric between the last position's
features and each demonstration at label positions. Using this hypothesis, we
explain the majority label bias and recency bias in ICL and propose two methods
to reduce these biases by 22\% and 17\%, respectively.
|
[
-0.4519324005,
-0.7153665423,
0.4677877426,
-0.1698478758,
-0.1110629663,
-0.0363091752,
-0.2953710556,
-0.4207690656,
-0.2991381288,
0.4724294543,
-0.3715606928,
-0.7491360307,
-0.5090568662,
-0.1196870804,
-0.3157792985,
1.2784023285,
0.2797894478,
0.0833230764,
-0.3718625009,
-0.3694993854,
-0.7187782526,
-0.7298288941,
-0.567533493,
-0.2555181086,
0.4589978158,
0.6493985653,
0.433880657,
0.5893327594,
0.4748905897,
0.1484039724,
-0.2268689126,
-0.1568851769,
-0.7714634538,
0.1527426541,
-0.3098292947,
-0.7628492713,
-0.1468494236,
-0.0567210764,
0.8266724348,
0.9372524023,
0.3155957758,
0.3300396502,
0.4513587356,
0.9381649494,
-0.698092401,
0.4138395786,
-1.0582271814,
0.0520389564,
-0.3787467182,
-0.3423810601,
-0.7407230139,
-0.0500992611,
0.3697603643,
-0.3323222995,
0.0410126522,
0.2969594002,
0.7676134706,
0.3323632479,
-0.6263725758,
-0.3521994948,
-0.4151287973,
0.9343312383,
-0.4372984171,
0.5521810651,
0.4933673739,
0.1486062109,
-0.3066186905,
-0.574873805,
-0.4155239463,
-0.3524560928,
-0.1561851501,
-0.0961663276,
-0.1639946252,
0.0950493366,
0.5361227393,
-0.1092861369,
-0.3676010668,
0.2522222102,
-0.4009774029,
0.1998805553,
0.3357482553,
0.0301449839,
0.1427257359,
0.092252329,
-0.4712788761,
-0.2445248812,
-1.2230567932,
0.3807404935,
-0.1612586975,
0.4563531876,
0.1414521784,
0.3895556033,
-0.0203224327,
0.9213274121,
0.3245970011,
-0.4637965858,
0.2683240473,
-0.0303609073,
-0.4076417387,
0.2744470835,
0.5483810902,
0.2408175915,
0.366874665,
-0.2178961039,
-0.1694501936,
-0.0805973858,
0.1656817645,
-0.7347421646,
-0.0492933504,
-0.053137958,
-0.4716359973,
0.0068984609,
0.0626411587,
-0.219106108,
-0.0278358143,
-0.5530191064,
0.4865013957,
-0.3844415843,
0.2409285754,
-0.1553929895,
0.1053162292,
0.2154897451,
0.1852371097,
-0.665651381,
0.3238756955,
0.6648910046,
0.7361088395,
-0.352276057,
-0.3269759119,
-0.7224749327,
0.1476311684,
-0.3365637958,
0.6423946023,
-0.6079823375,
-0.1407905966,
-0.0666455775,
-0.0527721718,
-0.1049934477,
-0.7747275233,
0.3235326409,
-0.6575227976,
0.0873023197,
-0.4409947693,
-0.7291219234,
-0.488814652,
0.1535229683,
-0.4465742409,
0.8145639896,
0.039135173,
-0.9637650847,
0.6847293377,
-0.5873638988,
-0.4599086046,
-0.0641784668,
-0.2466433346,
-0.2672922909,
0.0888392478,
0.0214245412,
0.7492522597,
-0.2730032504,
0.200925082,
-0.3401125968,
-0.59219414,
0.6912517548,
-0.1749022305,
0.9158472419,
0.0925117135,
-0.4616079628,
-0.0473795459,
-0.579159379,
-0.1109588519,
-0.254250437,
-0.3485465348,
-0.6450712681,
0.2132766843,
0.0741044134,
0.504704237,
-0.2398408502,
-0.5078960061,
0.0553453863,
-0.4455753267,
0.4198955595,
0.5006138682,
0.0029078117,
0.4483241737,
-0.2101631761,
0.3218166828,
0.2252597064,
-0.3723855317,
-0.0189228561,
-0.2614029944,
-0.6226637959,
-0.1392679214,
0.2179822177,
0.3156254888,
-0.5184679031,
0.2683393061,
-0.3373544216,
-0.3233583868,
-0.3747724295,
-0.0279164314,
0.6972306967,
0.9344744682,
0.3132035732,
-0.2578985989,
-0.2532995939,
-1.0549799204,
-0.2241831571,
-0.2524907887,
-0.0432468764,
0.259580195,
0.6074109077,
0.0766493827,
1.1868382692,
-0.4422296882,
-0.5474062562,
-0.1161991954,
-0.0310593452,
0.1401630044,
0.5370554328,
0.6809880137,
-0.8350679874,
-0.7586244345,
-0.0338175483,
-0.6250780225,
-0.0643100888,
0.094459258,
-0.0484342463,
0.3327689767,
1.0267612934,
-0.4302084148,
0.3502601981,
0.1530616432,
-0.177317977,
0.3427941501,
0.0427229926,
-0.2120479494,
-0.998929739,
0.0317333601,
0.2535446882,
-0.1849439591,
-0.5724883676,
0.1753593534,
0.2034683973,
0.1386723965,
-0.4904471338,
0.4889501631,
-0.4341736436,
-0.2844077945,
-0.3334133029,
0.4057009816,
-0.0830722153,
0.7787968516,
-0.0434336625,
0.7928214669,
0.5448943973,
-0.8388472795,
-0.270353049,
0.1610764563,
-0.7025797367,
0.7267510891,
-0.4078298211,
0.0214940049,
-0.369715035,
0.5637087822,
-1.3838264942,
0.0532733835,
0.0543640181,
-0.5250063539,
0.4285461009,
-0.0829843059,
-0.4302587509,
0.0204512812,
-0.0008794842,
0.5209622383,
0.3147444427,
-0.6217213869,
-0.0130556971,
0.7669426203,
0.1303946376,
-0.7372929454,
-0.9008724689,
-0.1752159297,
-0.4679944813,
-0.1510695815,
0.4643246233,
-0.0101471404,
-0.4186800718,
0.0465574935,
0.1224108934,
-0.0964630544,
0.1300223768,
0.2357820272,
0.0543301478,
-0.2611494958,
0.7196640968,
-0.1248457432,
0.0149451662,
0.1978549957,
-0.613104701,
0.3118164837,
-0.2058232278,
-0.186098218,
-0.4810502529,
0.0993946269,
0.8417960405,
-0.1991170198,
0.779232502,
0.3570695817,
-0.4119408727,
-0.2161962539,
-0.2775176466,
-0.2565373182,
-0.3509380221,
0.7807790637,
-0.6480597258,
-0.9607479572,
0.4140608907,
0.1051734388,
0.044061143,
0.470759213,
0.5971108079,
-0.1223185211,
1.1368664503,
0.6692847013,
-0.3068373203,
0.4349259138,
-0.2744464576,
0.2840678394,
-1.2070710659,
-0.1427350938,
-0.5652383566,
-0.6073526144,
-0.746712923,
-0.1472920924,
0.6573911309,
0.1557978243,
-0.3643422127,
0.3029822707,
-0.3938709795,
0.499497205,
0.5612901449,
0.1595067531,
0.1145682782,
0.0272667464,
-0.2845923603,
-0.1963228732,
-0.75990659,
-0.1258056164,
1.0837016106,
0.2790016532,
0.6308290958,
0.0066019665,
0.2600565553,
0.0998838842,
0.304754734,
-0.979209125,
0.3375000656,
-0.1041047648,
-0.5649619102,
-0.2402698398,
-0.1510406286,
-0.9509939551,
0.5468885899,
-0.1377124339,
-0.9440350533,
0.0930328369,
0.1061728597,
-0.2885493934,
0.2690036595,
-0.5309449434,
0.8663772941,
-0.1024898961,
-0.3101816177,
-0.3062726557,
-0.9003156424,
0.3131596744,
-0.0777589008,
0.1399119794,
0.090089865,
0.1140427142,
0.6998630166,
-0.0659295842,
0.8879665136,
-0.0776593462,
0.0796184838,
0.1883623898,
0.1004766673,
0.3596345484,
-0.0238066446,
0.1613969952,
0.0481684096,
-0.2019540966,
-0.213049069,
-0.6109448075,
0.5372161865,
-0.6538413763,
-0.4379451275,
-0.2818095088,
-0.7173136473,
-0.3751594722,
-0.0597631298,
0.4515995383,
0.7593259811,
-0.0645752102,
0.7863010168,
0.8767655492,
-0.1763505936,
0.3381385207,
0.5074418783,
-0.1832130104,
0.0259069744,
0.649153471,
0.4125280678,
0.4963952303,
0.8822901845,
0.1061412245,
-0.2980496883,
-0.4447954595,
-0.1256564707,
0.1904353499,
-0.9275710583,
-0.3047430515,
-0.7905848026,
-0.1656322926,
-0.1457829326,
-0.2001958489,
-0.0801950619,
-0.3410253823,
-0.2075337023,
-0.1268717349,
0.1365131289,
0.6658014059,
0.3514932394,
0.4338748157,
-0.4356072843,
-0.1787259281,
0.0703673288,
0.0419615507,
0.3352563381,
-0.7920447588,
-0.5077157021,
-0.01783574,
-0.2916157544,
-0.6805776358,
0.4201213121,
0.3435623944,
0.3505660594,
0.5836572051,
0.0025022386,
0.7082092166,
-0.5758119822,
0.5098716021,
-0.1177373976,
-0.9189921618,
0.2344007045,
-0.1581712067,
0.6071417928,
0.6138041615,
0.4672838151,
-0.8251159191,
-0.6038069129,
-0.510013938,
-0.6514000297,
0.9011175632,
-0.0893418342,
-0.1150191128,
-0.0825245976,
0.3396376073,
0.2209310681,
0.2261427194,
-0.819165051,
-0.2826454937,
0.2792549133,
-0.1813140512,
-0.200551644,
-0.2540132999,
0.1123710573,
-0.3669445813,
0.5824505091,
-0.2856647968,
0.2150928825,
0.0478101447,
-0.4546896815,
0.0593952052,
0.1324478537,
0.7311862111,
1.0227105618,
-0.3391073048,
0.2197237909,
0.3374085128,
-0.2297481745,
-0.125927642,
-0.4074364901,
-0.3197229505,
-0.0587250739,
0.4162633717,
1.0677266121,
0.5721231103,
-0.6198861003,
0.5060088634,
0.0986761972,
0.0756639689,
-0.3278158605,
-0.1903426945,
0.0123072853,
0.1307799369,
0.4587712288,
0.0219086725,
0.2397148758,
-0.7531026006,
0.3653230369,
0.6297820807,
-0.7634952068,
-0.3715436757,
0.6419805884,
-0.2181367725,
-0.0565026775,
0.582913816,
-0.0460941829,
-0.6917713284,
0.6293383241,
0.8988542557,
0.8281652927,
0.0353798717,
0.0149025582,
0.4710640311,
0.0777372569,
0.15783979,
-0.2318073362,
-0.3019541502,
-0.7599834204,
-0.2526934743,
-0.4723403752,
-0.2759311795,
0.1915734112,
-0.7781396508,
0.1654703468,
-0.2505340576,
0.0108018387,
0.0659911409,
-0.052503556,
-0.6788737178,
0.3014012873,
0.1336492747,
0.7415756583,
-0.7759788632,
1.0589416027,
0.6564080119,
-0.3147214949,
-0.6856353283,
0.3328816593,
0.0206468403,
-0.7242258191,
1.306140542,
0.449375391,
-0.1678898036,
0.0039771013,
-0.6547026634,
-1.2085586786,
0.8609609604,
0.3051924706,
-0.398501128,
0.0134697054,
0.0343351103,
0.5346729755,
-0.7580400109,
0.2700975835,
0.4801303744,
0.1987363249,
-0.1443165988,
-0.9331929088,
-0.0783576444,
0.1198315248,
0.0921306983,
0.111671485,
-0.6979141235,
0.9724568129,
0.0098659117,
-0.2359125167,
-0.3996654153,
0.6857849956,
0.2384135872,
0.1734195501,
0.5185313821,
0.3500292003,
0.7449836135,
0.0329402015,
1.0315163136,
-0.3526011705,
0.3502064943,
1.0782192945,
-0.309691608,
1.0994367599,
0.4468755126,
-0.0486614592,
0.6699296832,
0.7158409953,
0.3529867828,
0.6387833357,
0.2191889882,
0.0511123426,
0.0486584343,
-0.1448301077,
-0.1102766767,
0.7613894939,
0.6820516586,
-0.3939989507,
-0.1305758357,
0.3883346319,
0.310826391,
-0.0510504767,
-0.4399754703,
0.7967106104,
0.2278743237,
-1.0280444622,
0.7619616985,
-0.0892513916,
0.4420638382,
-0.3890205026,
0.1149678826,
-0.0941048637,
0.5313857198,
-0.0310859345,
-0.7614899874,
0.1220941171,
-0.3051486015,
-0.4073316455,
-0.0247931201,
0.4905649126,
-0.6858095527,
-0.1785730273,
0.2406464666,
0.1745581627,
0.2324794978,
-0.1676947773,
-0.6230203509,
-0.195168674,
0.0003944333,
-0.0476453155,
0.5961458683,
0.4321770072,
-0.3512165248,
0.6912673116,
0.2225183398,
-0.0280497912,
-0.0334003419,
-0.2202097625,
0.6424494982,
-0.5127513409,
-0.6679580212,
-0.9072814584,
0.1783924699,
0.080690898,
-0.4426559508,
0.6735912561,
0.45542413,
1.4408077002,
-0.0747900233,
0.6137037873,
0.1464451253,
0.5854410529,
-0.7127317786,
0.6844551563,
-0.7537295222,
-0.0770137832,
-0.2270571738,
-1.1395244598,
-0.4642968476,
0.5715875626,
-0.2938881814,
-0.0975928679,
1.0170274973,
0.736580193,
-0.0920720622,
-0.3147194684,
0.345531106,
0.3960844576,
0.2165850997,
0.7785304785,
0.4714324176,
-0.2812503576,
0.3356835246,
-0.096471332,
-0.1528386623,
-0.3948163688,
-0.5926761627,
-0.9727682471,
-0.9553871751,
-0.2010451108,
-0.3153865039,
0.0870628878,
1.05283463,
0.7996151447,
-0.8957239985,
-0.5727019906,
0.0090165716,
0.0986820832,
-0.2710401118,
-0.2772744596,
0.7608946562,
-0.5832518339,
-0.7620979548,
0.2380301803,
0.4315547049,
-0.4338989556,
-0.1789612025,
0.0989108458,
-0.3445523083,
-0.2575322986,
0.8236614466,
0.2753369212,
-0.9166500568,
-0.3866757154,
-0.1084211096,
-0.4039514959,
0.3613606989,
0.6829836965,
-1.0771991014,
0.4087542892,
0.4974354506,
0.7596666813,
0.3795965612,
0.0819062516,
0.4511080384,
-0.9336665869,
0.2641082406,
0.0486029312,
0.2752228975,
0.3241524398,
-0.3400760889,
0.3627481163,
0.1950089633,
-0.7370527387,
-0.7076964378,
0.3340351582,
-0.7690324783,
-0.4516023397,
1.0562802553,
-0.0292646475,
-0.4283340275,
-0.0499928519,
-0.2615866661,
0.2718996108,
-0.196845606,
0.8530465961,
0.7563977838,
-0.1977403909,
0.0694750473,
-0.672550261,
0.6785444617,
0.4754163623,
-0.3904145956,
-0.0603971221,
0.3897521794,
0.2222656459,
0.1234494597,
0.4206748605,
-0.0370272659,
0.208135739,
-0.3894001842,
-0.0811744481,
0.3315442502,
-0.4711965621,
-0.3335769176,
0.3626158237,
0.1634291708,
-0.3118245602
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02864v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02864v1
|
EEVEE: An Easy Annotation Tool for Natural Language Processing
| 2024-02-05T10:24:40 | 2024-02-05T10:24:40 |
Axel Sorensen, Siyao Peng, Barbara Plank, Rob van der Goot
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Annotation tools are the starting point for creating Natural Language
Processing (NLP) datasets. There is a wide variety of tools available; setting
up these tools is however a hindrance. We propose EEVEE, an annotation tool
focused on simplicity, efficiency, and ease of use. It can run directly in the
browser (no setup required) and uses tab-separated files (as opposed to
character offsets or task-specific formats) for annotation. It allows for
annotation of multiple tasks on a single dataset and supports four task-types:
sequence labeling, span labeling, text classification and seq2seq.
|
[
-0.7368866205,
-0.7674070001,
0.3088202477,
0.5689479113,
-0.1830659807,
-0.1481780559,
-0.3782272339,
-0.7387458682,
0.4595988095,
0.6128903627,
-0.701409936,
-0.5674785972,
-0.4752582908,
0.4175434113,
-0.4145552218,
0.8134949803,
0.3155806661,
-0.2645642757,
0.0097947372,
-0.1858788282,
-0.7275025249,
-0.1181373075,
-0.9618751407,
-0.2472203225,
0.6293115616,
0.4488864839,
0.3511847258,
0.43221277,
0.4652803838,
0.3140085936,
0.2359278351,
0.1575792134,
-0.1824843884,
0.5322532654,
0.0190222338,
-0.5440553427,
-0.3166556954,
0.1396963596,
0.0859439671,
0.924934566,
0.0542870723,
0.2924159467,
0.1598192453,
0.5494101048,
-0.5946031213,
-0.0078953607,
-0.2460587323,
0.0855332538,
-0.4992959797,
-0.0199900959,
-0.3233603239,
-0.6865829825,
0.3131996095,
-1.0160387754,
0.0369125083,
0.1365043521,
0.642224431,
0.4592370987,
-0.3504914939,
-0.2129365504,
-0.5799252987,
0.5454922318,
-0.3212102652,
0.4455702901,
0.2989118099,
0.3997733295,
-0.1067176461,
-1.0002508163,
-0.601203382,
0.0146193849,
-0.1001186371,
-0.1373907477,
0.1556998342,
0.1912661642,
0.4291528761,
0.1913768202,
-0.5099341869,
0.1394265294,
0.0341778509,
-0.243383944,
0.4459315836,
-0.0582864396,
0.4450790286,
-0.2320551574,
-0.2779125571,
-0.1175177097,
-0.1579374671,
0.0007342756,
0.0349850096,
0.4202638268,
0.347579062,
0.7285033464,
-0.1363810599,
0.6545231342,
-0.1712740213,
-0.0037480521,
0.3719121218,
0.1587664932,
-0.5931374431,
0.1553263366,
0.5599437952,
0.3579724133,
0.1893230528,
-0.2835960388,
0.00117082,
0.2377095968,
0.2613890171,
-0.6095708609,
-0.2760761678,
0.4654213488,
-0.2088568509,
-0.1867858618,
-0.0620379597,
-0.9919706583,
-0.6784297824,
-0.646746099,
0.3265705109,
-0.6504020691,
0.1756614745,
0.1989977807,
-0.4460219741,
0.2469281852,
0.6165484786,
-0.687178731,
0.7172859311,
0.5491402745,
0.761210084,
-0.0685610846,
-0.2527081668,
-0.7824333906,
-0.0077458504,
0.081135653,
1.1054677963,
-0.5941351056,
-0.3751829267,
-0.0395295583,
0.0622737072,
-0.0708503127,
-0.0765158832,
0.8877907991,
-0.1674646735,
0.2155657113,
-0.2386418581,
-0.9401807189,
-0.6317517757,
0.0284401588,
-1.0330010653,
1.528731823,
-0.2176560611,
-0.8086746931,
0.6807816625,
-1.0466972589,
-0.4735164046,
0.6149672866,
-0.1498322636,
0.1477396935,
0.0381303318,
0.3054663837,
0.5572019219,
-0.1764171869,
-0.1716872156,
-0.0136735616,
-0.1100254655,
-0.2670824528,
-0.1670716852,
0.8932173848,
0.1907834709,
-0.5026379824,
-0.2076650113,
-1.0709297657,
0.1981450319,
0.0765053481,
-0.3758813739,
-0.6721759439,
0.0839834958,
0.6038269401,
0.04857466,
0.1996885836,
-0.7136542797,
0.5355920792,
-0.4543687403,
0.0851892531,
0.3797854781,
0.0357070453,
0.3306088448,
0.1292626262,
0.3302456737,
-0.4916324615,
-0.0192281492,
-0.2531093657,
-0.8817292452,
-0.7543670535,
-0.4538764656,
0.3994204402,
1.0178534985,
-0.517937541,
0.5928481221,
-0.0909879133,
-0.6680941582,
-0.6929747462,
0.0758643895,
0.019419875,
0.2302841097,
0.4031122029,
-0.0514385849,
-0.6778273582,
-1.1006813049,
-0.3604178429,
0.199976176,
-0.152249828,
-0.1172500402,
0.4686049819,
-0.1880409867,
1.2008192539,
-0.5671551228,
-0.3449122608,
-0.0577063039,
0.7498601675,
-0.101261884,
0.2945404947,
0.4324354827,
-0.9542048573,
-0.4731187224,
0.1819896251,
-0.5732264519,
-0.5678061247,
-0.1381030083,
-0.1304432005,
0.0523665771,
0.3421479464,
-0.4422701299,
0.4537032247,
0.3144752681,
-0.4062994719,
0.1021332294,
0.0582246706,
0.3057657778,
-0.8267064095,
0.1981886327,
0.2190560848,
-0.5067753196,
-0.7785317898,
-0.1719360054,
0.0223519988,
-0.0283072982,
-0.331705749,
0.5097039938,
-0.3167376518,
0.2596260905,
-0.083792679,
0.3935419917,
0.2267492712,
0.2149401754,
0.2050840855,
0.5230931044,
0.5291216373,
-0.5804083347,
0.3640943468,
0.3290622234,
0.0454494618,
0.5756165981,
-0.337605536,
0.4101238251,
-0.2526353002,
-0.3847895265,
-0.7230561376,
-0.3571268022,
0.0916235968,
-0.2669239044,
0.2837402821,
0.0254498925,
-0.3144443929,
-0.2307385504,
-0.6227656007,
-0.1411396116,
0.2380821556,
-0.6235364676,
0.7479826808,
0.5213665962,
-0.2967335284,
-0.3426578045,
-0.7831525803,
0.2846325636,
-0.3030368686,
-0.7897604108,
0.3035962582,
-0.0595129468,
-0.1526908875,
0.0972437561,
0.1012402102,
-0.2567047477,
0.0403344743,
0.4153486192,
0.0159744751,
-0.02523572,
0.2991409898,
-0.091289863,
-0.1164818853,
-0.3290249109,
0.0028900588,
0.2901837826,
-0.1377426088,
-0.2040927261,
-0.1520503014,
0.6892072558,
0.1836777031,
-0.2443418652,
0.3583829403,
0.5986807942,
-1.0063747168,
-0.4936002493,
-0.8589342237,
0.0501156114,
-0.4311676025,
0.2548783123,
-0.3645213544,
-0.8050195575,
0.3134396672,
-0.2494370937,
0.4231046736,
0.4484497011,
0.2509615421,
-0.1982145607,
0.6450160742,
0.7488555312,
0.2316117138,
0.2583034635,
0.1482206136,
0.3207276165,
-0.6579197049,
-0.3839867115,
-0.7611709833,
-0.2637099326,
-0.39083758,
-0.3244958222,
-0.014436922,
0.143461898,
0.0344947204,
0.4632669389,
-0.9109088778,
0.6612222195,
0.7136877179,
-0.3425951898,
0.0322662331,
-0.0955741107,
0.2475535125,
-0.2582620382,
-0.3995353878,
-1.0517063141,
0.8245330453,
0.2318086475,
0.5545939803,
-0.2331320196,
0.9943057299,
0.390429467,
0.0985656232,
-0.7023257017,
0.7800819278,
-0.1304893047,
-0.5180218816,
-0.5105198026,
0.2371837795,
-0.9556162357,
0.1301844269,
-0.5908759832,
-1.2418859005,
0.2975930274,
0.1105523631,
-0.5045465231,
0.1405907422,
-1.1943237782,
1.0599989891,
-0.012268628,
-0.2377364784,
0.2326112986,
-0.3770854771,
0.160567835,
0.0030546682,
0.2530370653,
-0.3122650683,
-0.103341952,
0.9637044072,
-0.2728920877,
0.8813152909,
-0.3402855098,
0.3896929026,
0.3901189268,
0.2969116867,
0.5044038892,
0.1889703125,
0.1897165924,
-0.0263269823,
0.1107823923,
-0.1230131611,
-0.3406355977,
0.5335690379,
-0.3063278198,
-0.3832348287,
-0.4649502039,
-0.1004071459,
-0.0439493507,
0.2550185621,
0.1125944406,
0.290733099,
-0.3471491635,
0.0671948344,
0.6896623969,
-0.151214391,
0.6239725351,
0.0611065626,
-0.4472146928,
-0.1967162788,
0.5538188815,
0.2190525681,
-0.32101053,
0.2348291278,
-0.0740796179,
-0.2318974882,
-0.2519779801,
-0.1481669396,
-0.1997549981,
-0.9321060777,
-0.0653009191,
-0.6242465377,
0.1564275771,
-0.1241420209,
-0.4735922515,
-0.5265820026,
-0.6347676516,
0.090050213,
-0.1520027369,
0.6597067118,
0.8653897643,
0.0550205484,
0.0809557587,
-0.7163453698,
0.4965341389,
0.7374135256,
0.3135816455,
-0.5590810776,
0.3347097635,
-0.1704566628,
-0.3134467006,
-0.0849629939,
-1.2542780638,
0.2409567684,
0.4997933507,
0.4589362144,
0.0290953182,
-0.2600062191,
0.3832858801,
-0.6084712148,
1.0753955841,
0.1197495386,
-1.0050866604,
0.9792456031,
0.0226424206,
-0.1095594838,
0.7308069468,
0.2163445204,
-0.7086809874,
-0.3072551787,
-0.2952492237,
-1.060557127,
0.4951406717,
0.4168726206,
-0.4493161738,
-0.3362888694,
0.3545129299,
0.5706508756,
0.0936245918,
-0.6295426488,
-0.5359740853,
-0.2757510841,
-0.1580236107,
0.2329583019,
-0.1036431864,
0.0188570917,
-0.1725429446,
0.7673624754,
-0.22193636,
0.3053246737,
0.5379853249,
-0.2534063458,
0.124354884,
0.3180529177,
-0.048363585,
0.2227606922,
-0.4077346623,
0.1180168018,
0.3552632928,
-0.7231013179,
-0.0277481079,
0.3270820975,
-0.1249527335,
0.1439983398,
0.3089907467,
0.7608392239,
0.0007410618,
-0.5280944705,
0.4704724252,
-0.1356421709,
-0.0677206665,
-0.4439691603,
0.0399834588,
0.318277359,
0.1468602121,
0.1299919188,
0.2061446756,
0.6503904462,
-0.1098201349,
0.1511097401,
0.0065748189,
-0.1892402619,
-0.1339413524,
0.8808690906,
0.5058478713,
-0.4707523882,
0.4168120027,
-0.6103141904,
-0.0997819677,
0.4190588892,
0.2687754929,
1.3536140919,
-0.1582529992,
0.2130448371,
0.2963761687,
0.5540342927,
-0.0106351273,
0.4954265654,
0.3606036305,
-0.5404744744,
-0.9820013046,
-0.6307705641,
-0.2431471795,
0.0452690609,
-0.7500744462,
0.5810549855,
-0.1145155802,
-0.2407832146,
0.6392704248,
-0.1815101355,
-1.3267844915,
0.4139963984,
0.5940852761,
1.1324638128,
-0.9973723292,
0.823196888,
1.269908905,
-0.4353643656,
-0.5289556384,
-0.343367964,
0.1928539723,
-0.5153449774,
0.66900599,
0.5519375801,
-0.1202701256,
-0.0887542889,
-0.3325684369,
-0.5451290607,
1.0685579777,
0.1977539062,
-0.7544538379,
0.0746754259,
0.0553720407,
0.2912842035,
-0.275500834,
0.2146628201,
0.9509891868,
0.9471260905,
-0.6189602017,
-0.8879823089,
0.0326753557,
-0.4381971657,
-0.0049191751,
0.4025091529,
-0.0494247675,
0.4564576447,
0.2972705066,
-0.287135005,
-0.5331462026,
0.3700520098,
-0.3775613904,
0.1987790316,
0.7578020692,
0.739920795,
1.1367372274,
-0.3388498724,
1.0256716013,
0.0236303061,
0.2063051462,
1.0277694464,
-0.312961489,
0.7135452628,
0.5866259933,
-0.3054760098,
0.2758172154,
0.4884023964,
0.0868440568,
0.226066947,
-0.0594930202,
-0.2846317291,
-0.3115079105,
-0.0108140334,
0.1009572595,
0.2791213393,
0.4253877699,
0.3854021132,
-0.2634583116,
0.3130970895,
-0.012552497,
0.1999337971,
-0.2809641957,
0.6976638436,
-0.0658270121,
-0.3509595394,
-0.0997877941,
-0.2259785682,
0.6378877163,
-0.6010904312,
-0.3436041176,
0.2489975989,
-0.396387279,
-0.469823271,
-0.9751700163,
0.3793386519,
-0.0129014952,
-0.1094510257,
0.0180351269,
0.9869282842,
-0.1974829584,
-0.2891561687,
0.340315789,
0.5439607501,
0.0747623593,
-0.2415911704,
-0.5612781644,
-0.0628683195,
0.1995584369,
-1.0656688213,
-0.1510274708,
0.6481166482,
0.0047148014,
0.6337996125,
0.4168209434,
0.1524633914,
0.5075930357,
0.1321731061,
0.6061015129,
-0.9660577774,
-0.410125196,
-0.6892030239,
0.8875145316,
-0.5262163281,
-0.5147930384,
0.5602009892,
0.5500857234,
0.4187574685,
-0.0197824538,
1.201711297,
-0.6452569962,
0.8369857073,
-0.4305195212,
0.0569961295,
-0.3289164305,
0.1389977038,
-0.1096524745,
-1.2151908875,
-0.716530323,
0.8329271078,
-0.0327785015,
-0.2170614302,
1.0518467426,
0.4737712443,
0.0982865468,
0.5209371448,
0.1385912895,
0.0219402313,
0.2812941968,
0.369969815,
0.3703920841,
-0.2201618701,
0.2460265458,
-0.6392970085,
-0.237665236,
-0.0558001027,
-1.1258409023,
-1.0244518518,
-0.6026980281,
-0.5757778883,
0.1702985913,
-0.15975447,
1.4602885246,
0.6190470457,
-0.7756417394,
0.1830625236,
-0.1096616313,
-0.3716644347,
-0.2833916843,
-0.2228783369,
0.4189981818,
-0.6696711779,
-1.0292726755,
0.5723751783,
0.6091346741,
-0.1198081747,
-0.0229831114,
0.1618138552,
-0.3779203296,
0.0390324481,
0.588670671,
0.354919821,
-0.5406991243,
-0.5731328726,
-0.3249562681,
0.002454554,
0.0456350297,
0.5710719824,
-0.7551179528,
0.8416297436,
0.3840297759,
0.771592021,
0.5386083126,
-0.404658854,
0.4308784008,
-1.0412664413,
0.3619274497,
0.361097455,
0.5392449498,
0.2685302198,
-0.3404823542,
0.8152073622,
0.0172730498,
-0.7525563836,
-0.6121690869,
-0.1280629188,
-1.2180091143,
-0.1961195767,
0.8685050011,
0.0250891391,
-0.2753961384,
-0.4564756751,
-0.8384037614,
0.1761156023,
-0.4238468707,
0.2727365196,
0.8976354599,
-0.2695736289,
0.1444892585,
-1.121322751,
0.734880805,
0.1358889639,
-0.9626717567,
-0.0619717911,
0.4320742488,
0.080617249,
0.4337866604,
0.457881391,
0.4000646472,
0.0756141171,
0.1832163036,
0.9197369218,
-0.0599805191,
-0.0708506256,
-0.085927695,
0.3548233211,
0.3023434281,
-0.3959724009
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02844v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02844v1
|
Comparing Knowledge Sources for Open-Domain Scientific Claim Verification
| 2024-02-05T09:57:15 | 2024-02-05T09:57:15 |
Juraj Vladika, Florian Matthes
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
The increasing rate at which scientific knowledge is discovered and health
claims shared online has highlighted the importance of developing efficient
fact-checking systems for scientific claims. The usual setting for this task in
the literature assumes that the documents containing the evidence for claims
are already provided and annotated or contained in a limited corpus. This
renders the systems unrealistic for real-world settings where knowledge sources
with potentially millions of documents need to be queried to find relevant
evidence. In this paper, we perform an array of experiments to test the
performance of open-domain claim verification systems. We test the final
verdict prediction of systems on four datasets of biomedical and health claims
in different settings. While keeping the pipeline's evidence selection and
verdict prediction parts constant, document retrieval is performed over three
common knowledge sources (PubMed, Wikipedia, Google) and using two different
information retrieval techniques. We show that PubMed works better with
specialized biomedical claims, while Wikipedia is more suited for everyday
health concerns. Likewise, BM25 excels in retrieval precision, while semantic
search in recall of relevant evidence. We discuss the results, outline frequent
retrieval patterns and challenges, and provide promising future directions.
|
[
-0.0022591217,
-0.5327588916,
0.8920879364,
0.0752939507,
-0.0143355858,
-0.1507355124,
-0.2544904649,
-0.7619304061,
0.1193053499,
0.1949633509,
0.2178848088,
-0.486112535,
-0.7114280462,
0.4383386374,
-0.188583374,
0.7823277116,
-0.2613256574,
0.2392265499,
-0.6938223839,
-0.1154423803,
-0.1433451325,
-0.2194950432,
-0.1924322098,
-0.4526945651,
0.5057907701,
0.1463095993,
0.595033288,
0.1868397295,
0.8004103899,
0.2001637816,
0.0028270916,
0.5451098084,
-0.2578049898,
0.1876889169,
-0.5390918851,
-0.2958246768,
-0.131896928,
-0.0046601333,
0.3945437372,
0.5254606605,
0.0917013958,
0.2102312446,
-0.2527584434,
0.3970345259,
-1.0275301933,
0.1856079102,
-0.5628610849,
0.1244959012,
-0.2559797466,
-0.2332134098,
-0.6174997091,
-0.7407694459,
0.3288282454,
-0.5980562568,
0.3565875888,
0.2786088288,
1.1284799576,
0.040304061,
-0.6217281222,
-0.4444452226,
-0.6563660502,
0.503243506,
-0.6109423637,
0.6429556012,
0.4355630875,
0.3568614721,
-0.051858414,
-0.905528903,
-0.488491863,
-0.3204835355,
-0.3363974094,
0.280746758,
-0.3497675955,
-0.0584376007,
0.3935536146,
0.3067359924,
-0.9818555713,
-0.1051790267,
-0.6188465953,
-0.5680065155,
0.4234374166,
-0.4207223654,
0.1513046622,
-0.2452869564,
-0.2632762194,
-0.1859430671,
-1.0352760553,
-0.086341098,
0.0211508274,
0.0859937668,
0.2669341266,
0.7918235064,
-0.5663124919,
0.7778595686,
-0.1824829727,
-0.1431391984,
0.403627038,
-0.3850871623,
-0.1867661029,
0.3264656663,
0.6084384322,
0.5936348438,
-0.0504069217,
-0.2914575636,
0.1094641313,
-0.0093445126,
0.3225160539,
-0.8365249634,
-0.0997990593,
0.4032394588,
-0.5836362243,
0.199815318,
-0.0011149885,
-0.5527128577,
-0.4764746428,
-0.0213462375,
0.6234190464,
-0.6175191998,
0.0591233857,
0.272331655,
-0.5072919726,
-0.2192784101,
0.399718374,
-0.2945646942,
0.1999681294,
0.5282315612,
0.8335698247,
-0.2519581914,
0.0644886494,
-0.6498358846,
0.1437303424,
-0.3680570722,
1.0778464079,
-0.2807731032,
-0.1079832539,
0.1765618324,
-0.0082901586,
-0.0037220779,
-0.8025516868,
1.0091013908,
-0.7656773925,
0.1110610291,
-0.593804121,
-0.6386910677,
0.043753434,
0.1776106209,
-0.5588667989,
0.652743876,
0.0201842915,
-0.9171544909,
0.6942203641,
-0.6052856445,
-0.3508988619,
0.2201369554,
-0.2792704403,
-0.359969914,
0.1283975989,
-0.1423420161,
0.3469902277,
-0.3493821919,
-0.0604727194,
-0.3948765993,
-0.1611771584,
0.2944112122,
0.0393824056,
0.6072180271,
0.4479420781,
-0.3547773361,
-0.4485695064,
-0.6814975739,
0.0417127162,
0.2547237873,
-0.5173376799,
-0.850276947,
0.059257336,
-0.3832095265,
-0.2122600377,
0.1410294473,
-1.3858907223,
0.1134386137,
-0.1786703318,
0.3012575209,
0.2272461355,
0.0182764214,
-0.1048578918,
-0.5189319849,
-0.1045124009,
0.1268059909,
0.1667649597,
-0.0586119778,
-0.6772471666,
-0.0862697288,
-0.2556500733,
0.7478836775,
0.4247306287,
-0.6215952039,
0.1932835877,
-0.3818055987,
-0.1891269386,
-0.6332307458,
-0.3397147357,
0.337880522,
0.6558255553,
0.6667230725,
-0.3176809549,
-0.4204091728,
-0.8346794844,
-0.5079900622,
-0.346619308,
-0.4040910304,
0.5033777356,
0.5635721684,
-0.0832116678,
0.9973611236,
-0.7421904802,
-0.0666694641,
0.6050412655,
-0.0421119966,
0.0514121279,
0.0869406015,
0.4936393499,
-0.9187779427,
-0.4233113527,
0.2684031427,
-0.9282935858,
-0.1341181099,
0.4726310074,
0.0864120349,
0.1110233665,
0.2139219493,
-0.8034643531,
0.5199173689,
0.2915687561,
-0.484559387,
0.6825278997,
-0.3461258113,
0.5324015021,
-0.3782098293,
0.3154791594,
-0.1175234541,
-0.2515976429,
-0.2511173785,
0.0424991101,
0.4414085746,
0.1503401697,
-0.2768226862,
0.3775078952,
-0.4199035466,
-0.062877126,
0.0750144348,
0.0271052048,
0.1721563935,
-0.2136865407,
-0.1593141854,
0.6242581606,
0.1155422255,
-0.5545409918,
0.1994952857,
0.3294287622,
-0.7408114672,
0.7500602007,
-0.6965941787,
-0.0356719978,
-0.1632904857,
0.4087651074,
-0.8383446932,
-0.4619959891,
-0.0531992093,
-0.5022065043,
0.016847156,
0.2166842818,
-0.6804222465,
-0.6821890473,
-0.1453257203,
0.0328032039,
0.3340173662,
-0.7597141266,
0.2741490006,
0.3525831997,
-0.3393892348,
-0.7433339953,
-0.3666961193,
0.0782665387,
0.0095014935,
-0.4586460888,
0.6000137329,
-0.0119990213,
-0.5921882987,
0.2528027892,
-0.4157043099,
0.0955393538,
-0.0287571307,
0.2360238284,
0.134150818,
-0.1768909842,
0.1667426974,
0.2029493749,
0.286059171,
0.1013927385,
-0.4895468652,
-0.0441457741,
-0.011528057,
-0.779473722,
0.1590857953,
0.4527555704,
0.4608970881,
-0.2295134813,
0.5525401831,
0.1323423982,
-0.6085571051,
0.0362040363,
-0.8219365478,
-0.0583731122,
-0.3471255004,
-0.0183434431,
-0.1768530905,
-0.8371060491,
0.391694963,
-0.3606911302,
0.3523470461,
0.6489719152,
0.4583353102,
-0.1162514836,
0.6659546494,
0.0040208963,
0.5887758732,
-0.0713478699,
-0.1223470792,
0.250041604,
-0.4643018544,
-0.5309445858,
-0.9460995197,
0.0925919786,
-0.1985446215,
-0.55632025,
0.7318280339,
0.0380916297,
-0.2962228656,
0.4694112241,
-0.4434038401,
0.4918520451,
0.6178014874,
0.619017303,
0.9518446326,
0.0812456906,
-0.7334381938,
0.1707008183,
-0.5752561092,
-0.4209763408,
1.2335489988,
0.2724917829,
0.426926285,
0.2899041474,
0.5420826077,
0.5066190362,
0.6931595802,
-0.4461739361,
0.1920194775,
-0.2860722244,
-0.8513170481,
-0.123936817,
-0.4982195795,
-1.1452245712,
0.2857804,
-0.4345440269,
-0.4243369699,
0.3697141111,
-0.1862521321,
-0.5509163737,
0.1190378144,
-0.6488406062,
0.3915102482,
-0.2008296251,
-0.3230147958,
-0.2680078447,
-0.6432337761,
0.2651348114,
-0.1636158228,
0.100328736,
0.1273501813,
0.2582961917,
0.5523029566,
-0.3640241623,
0.4100337923,
-0.107344389,
-0.0268425625,
0.3209265471,
-0.1257174462,
0.3125153184,
0.1777020693,
-0.3384809792,
0.2776238918,
0.3364105821,
-0.3981320262,
-0.4277405441,
0.5286192894,
-0.7367968559,
-0.5151088238,
-0.569938302,
-0.1634950936,
-0.3215933442,
0.5010633469,
0.3430593014,
0.2381225079,
-0.4898242056,
0.5021241307,
0.9707247019,
-0.2835453451,
0.0062140101,
1.0473304987,
0.0024063569,
-0.3855592012,
0.6440454125,
0.3125261664,
0.0712003559,
0.3587883413,
0.3192458749,
-0.3006256521,
-0.6503263712,
-0.4298889637,
0.2688458562,
-0.5569985509,
-0.6599923372,
-0.877928853,
-0.0717633218,
-0.7090216279,
0.2604025602,
-0.1945077181,
-0.2711413503,
0.2654384077,
-0.1685840189,
0.3926600814,
0.7862517834,
-0.2081001699,
-0.382036835,
-0.7814350724,
0.4434525371,
0.2914384305,
0.6628504395,
-0.4420212507,
0.0169675536,
-0.3901219666,
0.1395017952,
-0.4516856372,
-0.8236060143,
-0.0670214444,
0.0623348802,
0.8830191493,
0.4002822936,
0.362539947,
0.1736012399,
-0.7655887008,
0.6089952588,
0.1332340986,
-0.3455385864,
0.5011591315,
-0.167644769,
-0.1194934249,
0.6586455703,
0.935893178,
-0.349548161,
-0.168625921,
-0.6782123446,
-0.5047160983,
0.1654458493,
0.1631514579,
-0.5205765963,
-0.2118715793,
0.4228555858,
0.37011379,
-0.1248089522,
0.0202907324,
-0.0928993374,
-0.0522334799,
-0.0388053991,
0.0848907977,
0.1624488533,
-0.6635357141,
0.1087169349,
0.5114837289,
-0.1967230737,
0.5189276338,
0.8466300964,
-0.0313857235,
-0.3273881674,
0.1593344957,
0.4360159338,
0.5655762553,
-0.4554108679,
0.4116431177,
-0.0032746764,
-0.6874420047,
0.1021201015,
0.2408277541,
-0.4407093525,
0.5420564413,
0.2498184294,
0.5739107728,
0.2538934052,
-0.8348287344,
0.5290608406,
-0.15418531,
-0.4518586099,
0.0348951258,
0.0030077985,
0.1200120747,
0.2534031868,
0.6015272737,
0.2346378118,
0.3048004508,
-0.5753241777,
0.3596923649,
0.3128882349,
0.0272351652,
-0.0233012121,
0.635001421,
0.0558193214,
-0.1717381328,
0.3379781246,
-0.0213064384,
-0.0889820904,
0.5123054981,
0.3511262238,
0.2511632144,
0.0032004032,
0.1803509295,
0.3413918912,
0.0127770351,
-0.4334473908,
0.1123772115,
0.0333362259,
-0.584354043,
-0.4922133088,
-0.493051827,
-0.9807986617,
0.0666807368,
-0.455735743,
0.1663664579,
-0.0685846582,
-0.4126919806,
0.3832181692,
0.2415079027,
-0.6560071111,
0.0553838685,
-0.083574295,
1.2971804142,
-0.8645651937,
0.5237758756,
0.740881145,
-0.3734562993,
-0.3325305879,
0.0771438107,
0.081868805,
-0.5983838439,
0.7667418122,
-0.1311315596,
0.122382462,
-0.3742609024,
-0.7661014199,
-0.7626800537,
1.1431117058,
0.4983903766,
-0.2150630057,
-0.0422840454,
-0.095944874,
0.6527173519,
-0.2017792016,
0.2818857431,
0.1583939344,
0.5154113173,
0.2673288286,
-1.2377493382,
0.1346296072,
0.0074264114,
-0.4508283436,
-0.2023953348,
-0.5980815291,
0.7591455579,
-0.3220793307,
-0.0790456012,
-0.0874509513,
0.8139712214,
0.6306684017,
0.9361301661,
0.4501420856,
0.61287117,
1.1414756775,
-0.01871006,
0.9726348519,
-0.2433765829,
0.4561034441,
0.8200908303,
-0.6004626155,
0.8707739115,
0.1935047358,
-0.4352153838,
0.6075623035,
0.7696182728,
0.0587331504,
0.5902984142,
0.4218081236,
-0.3153291345,
0.059535969,
-0.3837627769,
-0.5896615386,
0.0862084031,
0.5036956072,
-0.3892481625,
-0.3858645558,
0.0859698579,
0.0597892478,
-0.0465847664,
-0.0791089609,
0.5872941613,
-0.0269972272,
-1.0462546349,
0.5459440947,
-0.063109234,
0.4406894445,
-0.5079690218,
-0.0741470084,
-0.0432379395,
0.2131395638,
-0.3863521516,
-0.6837372184,
0.2287323922,
0.0191605352,
-0.1332028955,
-0.0710387081,
1.2311730385,
-0.2900491655,
0.1526968032,
0.1762416065,
0.5213292837,
0.3045488298,
-0.0884678289,
-0.347286582,
-0.2027656436,
-0.3409451842,
-0.1436921656,
0.4373696148,
0.4298023582,
-0.0867157653,
0.3742695451,
0.6802328825,
0.3594325781,
-0.0433653556,
-0.2783455253,
0.8167493343,
-0.0780334994,
-0.0760507658,
-0.2773537934,
-0.1299997121,
-0.3824244738,
-0.0348943919,
0.8065265417,
0.708429873,
0.9234946966,
-0.2026236951,
0.9386761785,
-0.2350450009,
0.7889262438,
-0.4112910628,
0.7920693755,
-0.3410729468,
-0.3219282031,
-0.0182967056,
-0.462587148,
-0.3636655509,
0.5581368804,
-0.1650999337,
-0.2562441528,
1.0478769541,
0.4267690182,
-0.0592774265,
0.2660350204,
0.0946308523,
0.3748754561,
0.1726513207,
0.404871285,
0.5579581261,
-0.4196388423,
0.1867245138,
-0.0640914291,
-0.4232243598,
-0.4730641842,
-0.8794568181,
-0.4933385551,
-0.4121155441,
-0.4158950448,
-0.9890304208,
0.3960623443,
0.7654122114,
0.6622290015,
-1.0180366039,
0.3733976781,
0.289292872,
0.0479290262,
-0.3766845167,
-0.0975840017,
0.3548808992,
-0.1133304536,
-0.351501435,
0.5443606973,
0.1228038296,
-0.2247224897,
0.0176836979,
0.0426863171,
-0.4117907286,
0.189695403,
0.5596910119,
0.5636020899,
-0.4036375284,
-0.4056241214,
0.3174183965,
-0.4579942226,
-0.0266829506,
0.9231905937,
-0.80640167,
0.3555343449,
0.8123635054,
0.8054599166,
0.5650445819,
-0.0749906376,
0.2962539196,
-0.3811816573,
-0.6339429021,
0.1799724251,
0.5444657207,
0.1209211051,
-0.3028207719,
0.7178311944,
0.6037064195,
-0.7519496083,
-0.8531308174,
-0.1296307296,
-0.8785372376,
-0.3806623816,
0.9578195214,
-0.4901162982,
-0.1104326025,
-0.355281204,
0.0505449884,
0.2544852495,
-0.2802647054,
1.0599064827,
0.7496521473,
-0.1542857587,
0.6956199408,
-0.7486012578,
0.3958899081,
0.3138459623,
-0.6726754904,
0.0817581937,
0.4801756144,
0.4088643193,
0.717689991,
0.6186838746,
-0.3978388011,
0.4354189634,
-0.225068152,
0.0111955861,
-0.0329654068,
-0.2464493513,
-0.016082786,
0.4605255723,
-0.2101143003,
0.0351162031
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02837v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02837v1
|
With a Little Help from my (Linguistic) Friends: Topic Segmentation of Multi-party Casual Conversations
| 2024-02-05T09:48:07 | 2024-02-05T09:48:07 |
Amandine Decker, Maxime Amblard
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Topics play an important role in the global organisation of a conversation as
what is currently discussed constrains the possible contributions of the
participant. Understanding the way topics are organised in interaction would
provide insight on the structure of dialogue beyond the sequence of utterances.
However, studying this high-level structure is a complex task that we try to
approach by first segmenting dialogues into smaller topically coherent sets of
utterances. Understanding the interactions between these segments would then
enable us to propose a model of topic organisation at a dialogue level. In this
paper we work with open-domain conversations and try to reach a comparable
level of accuracy as recent machine learning based topic segmentation models
but with a formal approach. The features we identify as meaningful for this
task help us understand better the topical structure of a conversation.
|
[
-0.70977211,
-1.1527867317,
0.4996956587,
0.134807542,
-0.3164489567,
0.2164631635,
-0.1115179956,
-0.4578037858,
0.4184574485,
0.4975626767,
-0.6548809409,
-0.4441427588,
-0.3556518853,
-0.2511095405,
-0.2696026266,
0.8877153993,
0.3577149808,
0.0782181248,
-0.2373286337,
-0.4818418324,
-0.4128452241,
-0.7863234878,
-0.8628438711,
-0.1037893742,
0.5038415194,
0.6314891577,
0.3876877725,
0.3035128713,
0.3410833478,
0.3770721555,
-0.6230521202,
0.2815731466,
-0.6598646045,
0.3537882268,
-0.3330139518,
-0.635135591,
-0.3522625864,
0.0012246763,
0.4366860092,
1.0229643583,
-0.2303221971,
-0.2138244659,
0.0263283588,
0.4401448369,
-0.2279935777,
0.310768187,
-0.6760543585,
-0.0482693762,
-0.4892830253,
-0.1981368065,
-0.303802669,
0.1623372585,
0.3611926436,
0.1231329888,
0.4582715631,
-0.0760182664,
0.8528653383,
-0.1845917255,
-0.4297389388,
-0.2609608471,
-0.8397449255,
0.5160062313,
-0.2632798553,
0.1017017439,
0.1581451595,
0.1632514596,
-0.1717859209,
-0.5058171153,
-0.1495278776,
0.1763244569,
-0.1088606194,
-0.2333445251,
0.132463783,
0.1265464127,
-0.2167414874,
0.4407286644,
-0.1761254817,
-0.0964468047,
-0.3823960125,
0.2355241328,
0.5534350276,
0.3046168685,
0.3408917487,
-0.1972508729,
-0.1530953199,
0.5045412183,
-0.4027429521,
0.0629425496,
0.1767567098,
0.2754816413,
-0.0343581662,
0.428742677,
-0.5211010575,
0.5948291421,
0.2191571444,
-0.2533969879,
-0.2439545244,
-0.6586779356,
0.164331004,
0.0004339696,
0.4105918407,
0.3205080926,
0.3338469863,
-0.0343534499,
0.2673330009,
-0.3008145392,
0.0448787957,
-0.6875026822,
-0.3892504871,
0.30715096,
-0.6769278049,
-0.203117162,
0.3738307953,
-0.6179834604,
0.0107822269,
-0.3526342213,
-0.2404662073,
-0.2351526916,
-0.0879008248,
-0.0573864654,
-0.1017377153,
0.1959137619,
0.6045837998,
-0.6957933903,
0.6517060995,
0.912112236,
0.9663368464,
-0.1946419626,
-0.0036150948,
-0.5112321377,
0.5083123446,
-0.0638206154,
1.0022828579,
-0.669056654,
-0.4605163634,
-0.385494709,
0.2311144471,
-0.0415296331,
-0.2281905264,
0.4436187446,
-0.3819221854,
0.4934934378,
-0.0072186156,
-0.5151549578,
-0.104018122,
0.3423584104,
-0.2501964271,
0.4729298055,
-0.3819971979,
-0.9041220546,
0.3884822726,
-0.9133653045,
-0.3822764754,
0.0795984119,
-0.3421455026,
-0.2053690106,
0.1990961879,
0.2457496673,
0.5520349145,
-0.1518207341,
0.4270317554,
-0.4214397073,
-0.0257399045,
0.5238988996,
-0.3068558872,
0.3865125477,
0.2364467233,
-0.0464395024,
0.5544271469,
-0.6525885463,
-0.2051590085,
-0.15795739,
0.1986162812,
-0.7389708757,
0.3956153393,
-0.1131530032,
0.1941223294,
0.0614713579,
-0.3540371954,
0.1917397529,
-0.4081458449,
0.6562131643,
0.5221040249,
0.711887598,
0.5862038732,
-0.0858648643,
0.1373040825,
0.1780043095,
0.2544403672,
-0.3026643097,
-0.8767875433,
-0.8339756131,
-0.5015169382,
0.4240699112,
0.4562342465,
-0.5161081553,
0.4020483196,
0.0694854558,
-0.4643283188,
-0.0903168246,
-0.3525318205,
0.2476072013,
0.2117995024,
-0.0310934819,
-0.4787113667,
-0.1843946874,
-0.7213323712,
-0.1276987344,
-0.1383634359,
0.0222803578,
0.7516825199,
0.2299220115,
-0.0461218804,
1.2423017025,
-0.9000961781,
-0.0734631643,
-0.3411467671,
0.4906229377,
0.09845227,
0.4594167769,
0.2220031768,
-1.067507267,
-0.6893018484,
0.0988936275,
-0.4118625224,
0.2984721661,
-0.0331398249,
-0.3868471086,
0.0718530789,
0.4680845141,
-0.6054191589,
0.4870957136,
-0.1803767383,
-0.3562251925,
0.0023083806,
-0.2884674966,
0.1858122647,
-1.0432584286,
-0.337010026,
-0.0182873327,
-0.1030268595,
-0.946044445,
-0.077215448,
-0.400791049,
-0.5053687096,
-0.4172968566,
0.5630419254,
-0.3084731698,
-0.0241064634,
-0.1027848572,
0.1829173863,
-0.137934655,
0.5898788571,
0.41986233,
0.5132116675,
0.5655038357,
-0.7013323307,
-0.0881686583,
0.5393624306,
-0.356341213,
0.6758421063,
-0.676070869,
0.4254136086,
-0.0205614325,
0.1184499934,
-1.2577381134,
-0.5039743781,
0.5111544132,
-0.3430908918,
0.3151812851,
-0.4185316265,
-0.1485940069,
0.1436261833,
-0.034174744,
0.3854326308,
0.0277309939,
-0.2319798768,
0.1566552371,
0.9521220326,
-0.5828073621,
-0.2034347951,
-0.1338568628,
0.119235307,
-0.452421993,
-1.1620231867,
0.5376175642,
0.1132526472,
-0.7693127394,
-0.1779000908,
-0.0674547926,
-0.657243669,
0.0347638912,
0.4156185091,
-0.1355739683,
-0.2166931778,
-0.0121112671,
-0.0748723298,
-0.1881377101,
-0.2329332381,
-0.1409853697,
0.7946197391,
-0.1653777212,
-0.2618789375,
-0.3959100544,
0.7637747526,
0.3925718963,
-0.4403449297,
0.9689509869,
0.3883392215,
-0.0784935579,
-0.2408708185,
-0.3648501933,
-0.1262343973,
-0.484885782,
0.2196803689,
-0.7514746189,
-0.9608072639,
0.6690927148,
-0.1819432229,
-0.2452714145,
0.3238167167,
0.4360074103,
-0.3168260157,
0.8731524348,
0.7456908822,
0.1702483296,
0.4553869367,
0.1052253395,
0.3574958146,
-0.3325677216,
-0.4986428916,
-0.7222227454,
-0.2468305379,
-0.5618964434,
-0.6652540565,
0.0529393367,
0.2144387215,
0.4140868783,
0.0755540654,
-0.2856387198,
0.5663398504,
0.3091715574,
0.1279423237,
0.0686365142,
0.0214762837,
0.450401932,
0.065289326,
-0.6709571481,
-0.5635784268,
0.4074768126,
0.4814558923,
0.8247331381,
-0.132922411,
0.7945261002,
0.0978009552,
-0.0976423174,
-0.8614292741,
0.7673557401,
-0.1346744746,
-0.5879051089,
-0.5501815081,
-0.4322440624,
-0.8520723581,
0.2586734891,
0.2318626046,
-1.0270677805,
0.5136896372,
-0.4062587619,
-0.0992187411,
0.1494954377,
-0.5324210525,
0.9534486532,
0.1034839153,
-0.0849697813,
-0.1994362324,
-0.7531234026,
0.3664635122,
0.2455828488,
0.3304490447,
-0.4555212259,
0.0648687109,
0.8777648807,
-0.4439873993,
0.7983370423,
-0.0594038665,
-0.0131880641,
0.6324451566,
-0.179033339,
-0.0977575108,
0.4327398539,
0.2508672774,
0.3663053513,
0.1049729958,
-0.4808701277,
-0.4577029347,
0.3263743818,
-0.7334425449,
-0.71151191,
-0.1844310462,
-0.471754998,
-0.1431421787,
-0.2017392516,
-0.0074662575,
0.7647433877,
-0.7306768298,
0.3304538131,
0.7851092219,
0.0121582383,
0.429452002,
0.4577235579,
0.0614722148,
-0.2277349383,
0.945438087,
-0.0657668337,
0.1996541917,
0.5843898654,
0.1597619206,
-0.0817141384,
-0.6128765345,
-0.1218726635,
0.115650326,
-0.8716486096,
0.2598017752,
-0.9477254152,
-0.0304277781,
-0.2382003367,
0.0816886351,
-0.2133818567,
-0.6498897076,
-0.227668494,
0.105243504,
0.0636481419,
0.699306488,
0.1988273263,
0.4308952987,
-0.9095701575,
0.3947787583,
0.3577576578,
-0.0861234218,
-0.3877609074,
-0.3197544217,
0.0416980907,
-0.2403427511,
-0.2121510953,
-0.8680570722,
0.2729935944,
0.5197832584,
0.6364471912,
0.6817574501,
-0.0380039699,
0.6640275717,
-0.7143434882,
0.9827287197,
-0.0327823423,
-0.9554947615,
0.8910244107,
-0.3921764195,
0.0439641848,
0.7967554331,
0.5389911532,
-0.6631209254,
-0.4484365582,
-0.9305025935,
-0.8290290833,
0.9934459925,
0.3712562025,
0.1548689604,
-0.1779511124,
0.5551993847,
0.0948695615,
0.1891628057,
-0.4487156272,
-0.4008259773,
0.4599797428,
0.1373706758,
-0.0825175494,
-0.5819506645,
-0.4746114314,
-0.1202627346,
0.3344462812,
-0.0360667929,
0.4125929475,
-0.1368737966,
0.1295912564,
-0.0320813581,
0.4922327399,
0.7003870606,
0.9369735122,
-0.3389694095,
-0.0650073886,
-0.1371845007,
-0.2388044149,
0.2590342164,
-0.1571931839,
0.1981144696,
0.2681030333,
0.3596019447,
0.6680935025,
0.1852114946,
-0.0819286034,
0.3534899056,
-0.488611728,
-0.1260703653,
0.2839340568,
0.2585844696,
0.1076220945,
0.1675823331,
0.0133504812,
0.2605024874,
0.1519751698,
-1.1950713396,
0.6898895502,
0.3225110173,
-0.6138353348,
-0.201284796,
0.0227434412,
0.7888566256,
-0.7446382642,
0.4072185159,
-0.276710093,
-0.7018966675,
0.7349444628,
0.2087266594,
0.8982719183,
-0.2690804303,
0.2934500277,
0.0371356867,
-0.1591623276,
0.2807660699,
0.3484174907,
-0.4137942791,
-0.5259209275,
-0.6012652516,
-0.4100643694,
-0.8280280232,
-0.2729053497,
-0.6342621446,
0.2095448226,
-0.0353877544,
0.1542327255,
0.2505232394,
-0.0507290252,
-0.1744378209,
0.051795885,
0.159418419,
0.6085807681,
-0.5884214044,
1.0258179903,
0.6156907678,
-0.0799649283,
-0.3150500655,
0.4361172616,
-0.3624448478,
-0.2815984488,
0.6654056311,
0.2860221267,
-0.045357056,
-0.4512342513,
-0.5247502327,
-0.6249700785,
0.5383255482,
-0.2518360317,
-0.4883586466,
-0.2285675555,
0.0861417875,
0.3044546843,
-0.4808776975,
0.1303545088,
0.264841944,
0.2393327504,
0.4533913136,
-0.785142839,
-0.2516913116,
-0.0698233545,
-0.2579736114,
0.6205103993,
-0.7323659062,
0.828038156,
0.1605805755,
-0.0529831424,
0.0291280691,
0.8877391219,
0.0005717304,
0.7576674819,
0.6246521473,
-0.0840611085,
0.8407716751,
-0.3322190642,
0.7222684026,
-0.4232001901,
0.272969991,
1.2027596235,
-0.1995178908,
0.5337474942,
0.2814049423,
-0.1593967825,
0.3042164445,
0.9204639196,
0.3140945435,
0.7554840446,
0.3340807259,
-0.2201986313,
-0.1143306643,
-0.0960585251,
-0.4805138111,
0.5946128964,
0.7756687999,
0.0961208567,
-0.026751671,
0.1127722487,
-0.2249764353,
-0.2473148257,
-0.3924146593,
1.2115107775,
0.2031919956,
-0.7058277726,
0.0373893902,
0.3710499108,
0.3513796926,
-0.5161681771,
-0.0586095452,
-0.2533963025,
0.0531163402,
-0.1886932552,
-0.7732367516,
0.5754995346,
-0.1945929974,
-0.0141324652,
-0.1050166115,
1.1376986504,
-0.6446219683,
-0.087913543,
-0.1306287795,
0.7097898126,
0.3686456084,
-0.3763442934,
-0.6790263653,
0.0491052605,
-0.0407072864,
0.1222641692,
0.3793544173,
1.120167017,
-0.1145738736,
0.3161878586,
0.2474841177,
-0.3885629475,
-0.1580924988,
0.1439267099,
0.7788866758,
-0.6945278049,
-0.9611260891,
-0.78887254,
0.552715838,
-0.2923993766,
-0.3864786029,
0.7151492834,
0.3241538405,
0.5262336731,
0.0873645097,
0.0629610121,
-0.0190722514,
0.2698391378,
-0.508191824,
0.5682822466,
-0.3486807942,
0.1491405368,
-0.4031084478,
-0.8502252698,
-0.0153887579,
0.6383057237,
-0.4123919904,
-0.3674874604,
0.6109104753,
0.4538431466,
-0.3024219275,
0.5322318673,
0.2366211563,
-0.2042912692,
0.4081399739,
0.0871718749,
1.4010498524,
0.23477301,
0.4391843975,
-0.484829396,
-0.2900801301,
-0.2041305006,
-0.467995584,
-1.1741768122,
-0.6392962933,
-0.6996291876,
0.0503992699,
0.146066308,
0.666013658,
1.100176096,
-0.8804044127,
-0.4916290641,
-0.2280735373,
0.3659833074,
0.1025071293,
-0.2663026452,
0.3079650998,
-0.6314027905,
-0.8147643805,
0.6048121452,
0.6218457222,
-0.3059430122,
-0.0494089536,
0.2598882914,
-0.5059984922,
0.2016113102,
0.6210573912,
0.0626164228,
-0.65040797,
-0.2459866405,
-0.2146434486,
0.103573963,
0.4815272093,
1.3202672005,
-0.1569767147,
0.1853901148,
0.4366102219,
0.4597424269,
0.8752744794,
0.2239481956,
0.6292618513,
-1.1479473114,
0.3738369942,
0.2526365221,
0.1472942233,
0.0481975004,
-0.3811924458,
0.7173451781,
0.3139383495,
-0.5547130704,
-0.8332496881,
0.2676458955,
-1.0079088211,
-0.7062624693,
0.8753072023,
-0.2020338923,
-0.2822232246,
-0.5544315577,
-0.6568489075,
0.008866014,
-0.4754990935,
0.3769747019,
0.8118456602,
-0.5736505389,
-0.1619487405,
-0.2487126142,
0.5437625051,
0.2412595451,
-1.1300516129,
-0.1171179414,
0.2402914464,
-0.0121835321,
0.4675002098,
0.8976153135,
0.0073164301,
-0.1406130046,
-0.0725696236,
-0.593302846,
0.5415757298,
-0.9667713046,
-0.138510555,
0.8682807088,
-0.067005381,
-0.4769770205
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02834v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02834v2
|
Shortened LLaMA: Depth Pruning for Large Language Models with Comparison of Retraining Methods
| 2024-02-05T09:44:49 | 2024-06-23T08:45:33 |
Bo-Kyeong Kim, Geonmin Kim, Tae-Ho Kim, Thibault Castells, Shinkook Choi, Junho Shin, Hyoung-Kyu Song
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Structured pruning of modern large language models (LLMs) has emerged as a
way of decreasing their high computational needs. Width pruning reduces the
size of projection weight matrices (e.g., by removing attention heads) while
maintaining the number of layers. Depth pruning, in contrast, removes entire
layers or blocks, while keeping the size of the remaining weights unchanged.
Most current research focuses on either width-only or a blend of width and
depth pruning, with little comparative analysis between the two units (width
vs. depth) concerning their impact on LLM inference efficiency. In this work,
we show that simple depth pruning can effectively compress LLMs while achieving
comparable or superior performance to recent width pruning studies. Our pruning
method boosts inference speeds, especially under memory-constrained conditions
that require limited batch sizes for running LLMs, where width pruning is
ineffective. In retraining pruned models for quality recovery, continued
pretraining on a large corpus markedly outperforms LoRA-based tuning,
particularly at severe pruning ratios. We hope this work can help build compact
yet capable LLMs. Code and models can be found at:
https://github.com/Nota-NetsPresso/shortened-llm
|
[
-0.2553421557,
-0.6923205256,
0.5849346519,
0.3402881622,
-0.6520166397,
0.0969793573,
-0.4773938656,
-0.3697487712,
0.5518088937,
0.5242748857,
-0.4216997623,
-0.5168862939,
-0.6103978157,
0.1434800625,
-0.6676160693,
0.6082035899,
0.0582141466,
-0.1092724726,
-0.1652077436,
0.0842128843,
-0.3155007064,
-0.3224048018,
-0.7220464945,
-0.1690028161,
0.6653421521,
0.6305845976,
0.639735043,
0.861255765,
0.4282708168,
0.361320883,
-0.4550759196,
0.1895739585,
-0.6757673025,
0.2679505944,
0.3262806535,
-0.5017588139,
-0.4613078237,
-0.1744228601,
0.8467867374,
1.0333741903,
-0.3631504774,
0.0747186616,
0.0011078144,
0.8996331692,
-0.839853704,
-0.2824832201,
-0.5546762347,
0.2038547099,
-0.1175947189,
-0.0380312242,
-0.312553525,
-0.4257791638,
-0.0108672418,
-0.6085618734,
0.2411155254,
-0.0042255051,
0.7908026576,
0.4639976919,
-0.335654974,
0.1705903858,
-0.8097175956,
0.9398021102,
-0.8699589968,
0.5920496583,
0.2989748716,
0.1698356718,
0.0512685068,
-0.7835764885,
-0.319388181,
-0.1585169584,
0.0090845255,
-0.0611461513,
0.0036122072,
0.1980129033,
0.3891231418,
0.6494870186,
-0.4816093147,
0.3012866676,
-0.6248314381,
-0.2001477629,
0.7022140026,
-0.1080201715,
0.0140296035,
0.065601334,
-0.3095455468,
-0.1478995681,
-1.2177884579,
-0.1857741028,
0.4248223305,
-0.0794394463,
0.0929899886,
0.5332117081,
-0.3075842857,
0.7177895904,
-0.3279968798,
-0.7482011318,
0.2344459593,
0.0147624295,
-0.5127541423,
0.0000069933,
0.5678374171,
0.3039832115,
0.5122602582,
-0.2049014717,
-0.3100123405,
-0.0174124241,
0.0918010324,
-0.892547071,
-0.1375636011,
0.0378910564,
-0.560590148,
0.0132205393,
-0.0969880298,
-0.5797592402,
-0.2404883951,
-0.2354277819,
0.1385044008,
-0.3587533236,
-0.2567071319,
0.3460362256,
-0.0682765022,
0.3963752687,
0.4003645778,
-0.6710081697,
0.4947217405,
0.7976116538,
1.0381984711,
-0.2498420328,
-0.0265609175,
-0.5637912154,
0.0065726517,
-0.3293483853,
0.5857749581,
-0.4383983016,
-0.5599761009,
-0.1023233309,
-0.2129364908,
0.2267900407,
-0.7340810299,
0.5862870216,
-0.47148031,
0.0571781285,
-0.1280696541,
-0.4727165401,
-0.2434132397,
0.3574238718,
-0.7216143608,
0.816714704,
-0.0459929332,
-0.5356708169,
0.1332730651,
0.030661989,
-0.6866235137,
-0.3166660666,
0.0659404993,
-0.5732277632,
0.565803051,
0.2061035484,
0.2239294052,
-0.397297889,
0.1715658754,
-0.4380440414,
-0.592418015,
-0.0827252865,
-0.4015263617,
0.5604694486,
0.2180355042,
0.0564133078,
0.2053384483,
-0.8587421775,
0.1078021452,
0.2613060176,
-0.7089804411,
-0.2150374353,
0.0378746688,
-0.2906746566,
0.0020566168,
0.0816395208,
-0.5326315165,
0.2809736431,
-0.6630252004,
0.6292795539,
0.5456988215,
-0.0417808965,
0.4753243625,
-0.1575849503,
0.5906247497,
-0.2574946284,
0.1098529547,
0.0354914069,
-0.052407559,
-1.0897811651,
-0.4810105562,
0.5170124173,
0.4126857519,
-0.5956634879,
0.3843370676,
-0.4359454811,
-0.3599205315,
-0.4770286083,
0.2582183182,
0.4671032727,
0.3812302947,
0.3423024714,
-0.718129158,
-0.7123500109,
-1.0858078003,
-0.3077643216,
-0.0801058188,
-0.3033959866,
0.1677205116,
0.218714565,
0.0273049064,
0.787555635,
-0.620937705,
-0.1652108729,
-0.4656023085,
-0.3326993585,
0.1250037998,
0.4441319704,
0.2010212243,
-0.4517017007,
-0.2779578567,
-0.512930274,
-0.4221948683,
-0.1289333254,
0.1599131078,
0.0599040389,
0.1341022998,
0.5704607368,
-0.7839018106,
0.4819502831,
0.5614788532,
-0.0493533388,
0.5959718823,
-0.1796349138,
-0.4679726064,
-0.7285199761,
-0.0925557241,
-0.1292904317,
-0.4385636449,
-0.5555840731,
-0.2663458884,
0.0048733982,
-0.0431369357,
-0.5512004495,
0.3373020887,
-0.7608190775,
-0.5623596311,
-0.3645884097,
0.2509233952,
0.368131429,
0.4577130377,
0.2225022614,
0.6113215089,
0.3897314072,
-0.6909561753,
0.1461217999,
0.1077124551,
-0.6520786881,
0.0009641878,
-0.7704340219,
0.3338361084,
0.0492869504,
0.4090853035,
-0.7608840466,
-0.0189652536,
0.1042054445,
-0.0811825097,
0.4464535713,
-0.0428251103,
-0.4222783148,
-0.1240676939,
-0.5497711897,
0.4837541878,
0.7061867118,
-0.523080349,
0.361099422,
0.362952143,
-0.1572638899,
-0.5991302133,
-0.9400789142,
0.1930705309,
-0.5704455972,
-0.6515732408,
0.6107812524,
0.0471531153,
-0.3386103809,
-0.1913530976,
-0.4461512566,
-0.085688509,
0.429939419,
0.0888258591,
-0.0833230764,
-0.2621854246,
0.179518804,
0.1290945858,
-0.0824209228,
0.0642488077,
-0.119416602,
0.6176857352,
-0.0229688901,
-0.5698693991,
-0.3567670286,
0.2775570154,
0.1744310558,
-0.3389929831,
0.8425614238,
0.3460076153,
-0.1557002366,
-0.2953488231,
-0.7344011068,
-0.4281954169,
-0.4138961136,
0.2293848544,
-0.2124740779,
-1.0815643072,
0.2259666473,
-0.2412484288,
0.0443866067,
0.1522408128,
0.2869234979,
0.1676858664,
0.7326965332,
0.8362975717,
-0.3136357367,
0.5976781249,
-0.3893122971,
0.2705494165,
-0.8635069132,
-0.021156773,
-0.4720540345,
-0.6250286102,
-0.3143273592,
-0.3083384037,
0.080882825,
0.3058330119,
-0.0655036047,
0.0297526587,
-0.3019817173,
0.6439794898,
0.5184599757,
0.0145344026,
0.4524475932,
0.1981560141,
0.4060688019,
0.1972675174,
-0.7801027894,
-0.4501197636,
0.893202424,
0.4383271635,
0.7364553809,
0.1484954506,
0.8910794854,
-0.1659986228,
0.3357697725,
-1.0180697441,
0.6131109595,
0.1281125546,
-0.2142445892,
-0.4688305259,
-0.5597741604,
-0.9276577234,
0.5534065962,
0.0387289375,
-0.4804742336,
0.1417123377,
0.181373015,
-0.5380085111,
0.2908863127,
-0.8057373762,
0.5114879012,
-0.2141887099,
-0.2638715208,
-0.3867643774,
-0.6933778524,
0.4931819141,
0.0310074799,
0.0216663815,
-0.2420353293,
-0.3152168691,
0.8372107744,
-0.7541952729,
0.807715416,
-0.1441038102,
-0.1541712433,
0.3274889886,
0.2135789394,
0.4092014432,
0.0477355421,
0.0291508604,
0.1609915793,
-0.1193699539,
-0.2860549986,
-0.561199367,
0.6299724579,
-0.6233279705,
-0.9144404531,
0.0310932808,
-0.6079224944,
-0.3052808642,
0.1519734412,
0.0239144247,
0.2563753128,
-0.1679154783,
0.4958021939,
0.6141192913,
-0.3971292078,
0.5061418414,
0.4164723456,
-0.2101472318,
-0.2691138387,
0.7938262224,
0.1368065625,
0.2026246935,
0.3641432822,
0.1297266632,
-0.1873051971,
-0.8624328375,
-0.0213424545,
0.4332067966,
-0.5531538725,
-0.4244901538,
-0.2790103257,
-0.2701483071,
-0.3557998836,
0.1240415722,
-0.4485337436,
-0.8390104771,
-0.1064914092,
-0.303481847,
0.1582064182,
0.634018302,
-0.014514735,
0.7013173103,
-0.640681684,
0.2237469852,
0.0841076896,
0.3001981974,
-0.0700890422,
-0.6796996593,
-0.1832189411,
-0.3148280084,
-0.315110147,
-0.775193274,
0.7489186525,
0.4967901707,
0.1902036369,
0.5183182359,
-0.0639929622,
0.7995723486,
-0.4285028577,
0.4877513051,
0.1507710963,
-0.8291782141,
0.2555899918,
0.1887517124,
0.3356792927,
0.4094476998,
0.0556367785,
-0.6859229803,
-0.1607657075,
-0.5044027567,
-1.0248920918,
0.4261706471,
0.061199002,
-0.0790712684,
-0.0109642362,
0.4717021286,
0.1302389652,
0.3452052474,
-0.6211182475,
-0.0718312934,
0.0632273033,
-0.0736088976,
-0.2926105261,
-0.7377739549,
-0.1193679348,
-0.2122576982,
0.639028132,
-0.0243394412,
0.0739930868,
0.3222093284,
-0.4841697216,
0.208136797,
0.2651492953,
0.5260961652,
0.8138921261,
-0.0156433135,
0.3036414087,
0.4304747283,
-0.2695001364,
0.0470832698,
-0.2299444675,
-0.0771887153,
-0.1438417584,
0.6416075826,
0.7983571291,
0.3457664251,
-0.6504828334,
0.3325335979,
-0.1138999984,
-0.3661324382,
-0.3027118444,
0.0703225881,
0.3017492294,
0.2129816413,
0.0053622378,
-0.3844473958,
0.0637482256,
-0.1806006581,
-0.170973286,
0.3837252557,
-0.0846734792,
-0.1879323423,
0.1894544363,
0.2811377048,
-0.3953894377,
0.8915653229,
0.1732346416,
-0.2944576144,
0.5831899643,
0.4462915957,
0.7251834869,
-0.1453803629,
-0.0936338156,
0.2557254136,
0.367033869,
-0.3540096581,
0.0842532367,
-0.338259846,
-0.6278064847,
-0.9048252702,
-0.7631702423,
-0.2133793533,
0.2641226351,
-0.5960894227,
-0.1319856495,
-0.6799378991,
0.0872055441,
-0.5276145935,
0.2181846797,
-0.3892312348,
0.2182863802,
0.2343259007,
1.3472341299,
-0.7748041749,
1.1223213673,
0.2375835925,
-0.0605344661,
-0.8674623966,
-0.1344681382,
-0.0312343556,
-0.6825096607,
0.3361510634,
0.4539197385,
-0.3026453555,
-0.0037537154,
-0.5845915675,
-1.0712367296,
1.1830291748,
0.8024887443,
-0.916131556,
0.0790442079,
0.0909642577,
0.5365464091,
-0.2408416122,
-0.0904609784,
0.891125083,
0.4561130702,
0.0681498796,
-0.7495088577,
-0.0006370326,
-0.0111469626,
0.1620461494,
0.2240980268,
-0.6504334211,
0.6127104163,
-0.1050495803,
-0.4423841238,
0.2055350691,
0.953012526,
0.3037512898,
0.0683526397,
0.8231532574,
0.9144243002,
0.8107736707,
-0.0232464541,
1.0241951942,
-0.3404153883,
0.0753675774,
0.9369365573,
-0.2463384718,
0.7699791193,
0.7652931213,
-0.0765104219,
0.4894477725,
0.7574337125,
0.3703145385,
0.358253479,
0.3802800179,
-0.0271135643,
-0.3548128009,
-0.0503741838,
-0.3918745816,
0.3538487852,
0.2568265498,
-0.1396637261,
-0.0316010378,
-0.2379983515,
0.1099410579,
-0.040052101,
-0.2760796547,
0.6490906477,
0.5798252225,
-0.748552978,
0.7088320851,
0.1287895292,
0.633002162,
-0.5562928915,
0.2269320637,
-0.6048630476,
0.2333741039,
-0.2397972792,
-0.4693650007,
0.5358159542,
-0.0165534075,
-0.0156031232,
-0.4529975057,
0.8705499172,
-0.4129911661,
-0.2018357068,
0.3107403219,
0.6426375508,
0.3891760707,
-0.2525669932,
-0.4785517454,
0.3586803675,
0.0417173132,
-0.7408611774,
0.3715437055,
0.1959507167,
-0.154185921,
0.9407504797,
0.5379453897,
0.2576817274,
0.0092415772,
0.3215107322,
0.8977663517,
-0.6866831779,
-0.2050646544,
-0.9226594567,
0.1763894558,
-0.0796099007,
-0.0994396955,
0.7869926095,
0.6827366948,
0.8405194879,
0.0480853505,
0.2623296678,
0.191626057,
0.459171921,
-0.6506515741,
0.3235723972,
-0.7548856735,
0.3977214694,
0.2925549746,
-1.1565233469,
-0.3304259777,
0.5672693253,
-0.4867914915,
0.1725901365,
0.5658211708,
0.7862877846,
-0.1660971642,
-0.3554311991,
0.3207383752,
0.2263233811,
0.186893031,
0.5214360356,
0.8167062998,
0.0358303227,
0.7636128664,
-0.380848974,
0.0080976235,
-0.2178703994,
-0.8551567197,
-0.5499330163,
-0.1381025165,
-0.1999091059,
-0.0305380467,
-0.0461107939,
0.5085638165,
0.8571485281,
-0.4336309135,
-0.387827903,
0.0228045508,
0.3815310001,
-0.0566368103,
-0.1554170698,
0.3350538611,
-0.0027680858,
-0.5885872245,
0.8107123375,
0.2110393643,
-0.1588210016,
-0.3358836472,
-0.221257925,
-0.090128608,
-0.0399638228,
0.6388787627,
0.4505244493,
-0.6818937063,
-0.2504995167,
-0.3283556104,
0.0208641626,
0.1409310102,
0.7870352268,
-0.9767483473,
-0.1397053152,
0.6509614587,
0.5421341062,
0.8201857805,
0.0703012198,
0.5501564145,
-1.1237981319,
0.4421001673,
0.1576606929,
0.5176913738,
0.5449982882,
0.0948583111,
0.6513006687,
0.1886457503,
-0.4094602466,
-1.0453487635,
0.4598897696,
-0.7460628152,
-0.4888473451,
1.258570075,
-0.0793019831,
-0.5860080123,
0.3349922895,
-0.154004395,
0.2687935829,
-0.1354821026,
0.7030501962,
0.4473369122,
0.0761150867,
-0.2682551742,
-0.3348890543,
0.4261524677,
0.7410340905,
-0.7185302973,
-0.0367064103,
0.4818502665,
0.3540230095,
0.012461558,
0.5170740485,
0.1649447083,
-0.0673863515,
-0.2097304463,
0.2005994767,
-0.2113203257,
-0.5775468349,
-0.4396511316,
0.2537839711,
0.2751551867,
-0.0130841257
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02823v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02823v2
|
Evading Data Contamination Detection for Language Models is (too) Easy
| 2024-02-05T09:10:32 | 2024-02-12T17:50:07 |
Jasper Dekoninck, Mark Niklas Müller, Maximilian Baader, Marc Fischer, Martin Vechev
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Large language models are widespread, with their performance on benchmarks
frequently guiding user preferences for one model over another. However, the
vast amount of data these models are trained on can inadvertently lead to
contamination with public benchmarks, thus compromising performance
measurements. While recently developed contamination detection methods try to
address this issue, they overlook the possibility of deliberate contamination
by malicious model providers aiming to evade detection. We argue that this
setting is of crucial importance as it casts doubt on the reliability of public
benchmarks. To more rigorously study this issue, we propose a categorization of
both model providers and contamination detection methods. This reveals
vulnerabilities in existing methods that we exploit with EAL, a simple yet
effective contamination technique that significantly inflates benchmark
performance while completely evading current detection methods.
|
[
-0.495665282,
-0.9300675988,
0.9143226147,
-0.1509441435,
0.2111129761,
0.0764142126,
0.0650042668,
-0.8866611123,
-0.5292546749,
1.0292961597,
-0.1328929216,
-0.2605166733,
-0.6423660517,
-0.2461442947,
-0.8787884116,
1.0341311693,
0.0186927505,
-0.5067574978,
-0.2914248407,
-0.1388160735,
-0.067812629,
-0.7432034016,
-0.480220437,
-0.2411714047,
0.3851411045,
0.2037089467,
0.7382707596,
0.8840093017,
0.2817526758,
0.3152426481,
-0.1279527098,
0.3146139979,
-0.3796504736,
0.0593431108,
-0.3410229385,
-0.645686686,
-0.2581086755,
-0.1956203878,
0.3053726852,
0.6256956458,
-0.1875177473,
0.1196464077,
0.125087738,
0.6221330762,
-1.2089908123,
-0.0345637165,
-0.9641900659,
-0.3247177303,
-0.6251881123,
-0.0237302948,
-0.9678026438,
0.0280951802,
-0.144501254,
-0.5028788447,
0.1731884778,
0.088203907,
1.02346313,
0.2276910245,
-0.431506753,
-0.0010823276,
-1.0597816706,
0.7951955199,
-0.4969930649,
0.3012340963,
0.8643274307,
0.4164784253,
-0.0646871626,
-0.8540697694,
-0.3905578852,
-0.2310959697,
0.0028576145,
-0.4224054217,
-0.8106856942,
0.0011827431,
0.2580555975,
-0.0536969788,
-0.409365654,
0.1865002513,
-0.3247602582,
-0.2671829164,
0.7053579092,
0.070237115,
0.6818053722,
-0.1009149775,
-0.7157659531,
-0.1642283499,
-1.0844532251,
0.0663414672,
0.5425975323,
0.1985319257,
0.1609109491,
0.0228819717,
-0.0171429329,
0.6726361513,
-0.368450433,
0.3582727313,
0.0788003206,
-0.2796277106,
-0.3442395926,
-0.1289262623,
0.6818717718,
-0.0842650756,
0.2306393534,
-0.2305736691,
-0.4819242656,
-0.0584757552,
0.4724754095,
-0.3586381674,
-0.4201094806,
0.5816890597,
0.0167599134,
-0.4804997742,
0.2076534778,
-0.7612121105,
-0.4162172973,
0.0136318021,
0.6671096683,
-0.1042496264,
-0.3631345928,
0.1562580168,
0.0691821054,
-0.2662296891,
0.2959824502,
-0.7404013276,
0.5106242895,
1.138656497,
0.3794110119,
0.2390946746,
-0.3235469162,
-0.8469701409,
0.1751855463,
-0.3346764147,
0.888363421,
-0.5397352576,
-0.4629411697,
0.1490575224,
-0.1055947468,
0.2361231893,
-0.7677794099,
0.6729621887,
-0.5273423791,
-0.1365118325,
-0.2673891187,
-0.5323642492,
-0.1570666879,
-0.0834929571,
-0.8576563001,
1.0006446838,
-0.1460717171,
-0.9045805335,
0.4196561575,
-0.2942331433,
-0.3318612576,
0.2070269585,
-0.0984936059,
-0.4723176956,
0.0646063462,
0.3083166778,
0.2699082494,
0.065648742,
0.4530595541,
-0.7265795469,
-0.4653652906,
0.3283616304,
-0.8884397149,
0.8880853057,
0.5048577785,
-0.4347094595,
-0.257656306,
-0.8133344054,
0.1356831193,
0.0036961862,
-0.0950330794,
-0.7628490925,
0.1432957351,
0.4324404895,
0.2470753789,
-0.0425204374,
-0.4069884419,
-0.2478728741,
-0.2435481399,
0.2240478843,
1.0142689943,
0.1399724036,
0.0341777168,
-0.5086021423,
0.4452326,
0.0757344887,
0.3684364557,
-0.2694651783,
-0.3476766944,
-0.7552677393,
-0.2982498407,
0.2133037448,
0.3202820718,
-0.8069965243,
0.3921796083,
-0.2106035799,
-0.7809274793,
-0.5740538239,
0.1769357324,
0.7161633968,
0.2828986347,
0.4374422133,
0.1991852671,
-0.2860873044,
-1.0409649611,
-0.8932058215,
-0.2857579887,
-0.149485454,
0.4570070207,
0.5237165093,
-0.0452205092,
0.8498464823,
-0.5084670186,
0.0337611809,
-0.0603742711,
0.0918128267,
-0.1732595861,
0.5053985119,
0.5954402685,
-0.7202889919,
-0.4017599225,
-0.0782630891,
-0.6157489419,
-0.3902887106,
0.0362864248,
-0.0127840787,
0.0218564868,
0.6679329276,
-0.270465225,
0.4617422223,
0.5411307812,
-0.3722528219,
0.5791399479,
-0.2263916135,
0.0559357964,
-0.6320985556,
0.4019123018,
0.1134651154,
-0.443443656,
-1.1021237373,
0.4766894579,
0.337144345,
0.0042877267,
-0.9388048053,
0.6507163644,
-0.2012891173,
0.2733755708,
-0.2129549384,
0.0624942891,
0.5114741921,
-0.1110539362,
-0.1649699211,
0.6241758466,
0.5954320431,
-0.4127348065,
-0.170460403,
0.1599632949,
-0.5336934924,
0.3100575209,
-0.7069058418,
0.3032761216,
0.0611634143,
0.1980965286,
-0.9679187536,
-0.0771127641,
-0.0013758669,
-0.0786326528,
0.3810569644,
-0.300927788,
-0.6299983859,
-0.0623346791,
-0.2974599004,
0.4120978117,
0.327188313,
-1.0591397285,
0.1514072418,
0.3693199158,
0.2423902601,
-0.7389156222,
-0.9933023453,
-0.0862347856,
-0.4767264426,
-0.6353949904,
0.1294783056,
0.212522462,
-0.6162806749,
0.0245438591,
-0.1903461963,
-0.4205365479,
0.6889748573,
0.20968844,
0.2205853313,
-0.1313188374,
0.0362059064,
-0.1797458082,
-0.0423884839,
0.1811628789,
0.3870453835,
0.3849175572,
0.0896610022,
-0.9032871723,
-0.4415634871,
0.2620243728,
0.7092007399,
-0.4599288702,
0.7102384567,
0.0320068486,
-0.6506047845,
-0.4903616607,
-0.6789841056,
-0.0564712286,
-0.6081087589,
0.4543322623,
-0.3347646594,
-0.1325646043,
0.5041840076,
0.0715740398,
-0.1114709601,
0.2829336226,
-0.2225020975,
0.0825648233,
1.0671974421,
0.568916142,
-0.2673572302,
0.1734121442,
0.0973980203,
0.1970985979,
-0.6349702477,
-0.0138201229,
-0.9438127875,
0.185823828,
-0.4601208866,
-0.2895285189,
0.1705645919,
0.1692712903,
-0.1456326246,
0.4114942253,
-0.2188403755,
0.9138691425,
0.1830183119,
0.2146743685,
0.4937879443,
-0.1733785868,
0.0449534841,
0.0229065828,
-0.3671969473,
-0.5894964337,
1.2031998634,
0.5778869987,
0.7479145527,
0.0757974833,
0.9520397186,
0.4052173793,
0.3355603516,
0.0157846734,
0.2817520499,
-0.2581112087,
-0.8357210755,
-0.0584279634,
-0.3714271784,
-0.8722569942,
0.3640189469,
0.1952201426,
-1.2191400528,
0.5334815383,
0.0676050037,
-0.2482728064,
0.5904347897,
-0.7490803003,
0.812284112,
-0.2335419655,
-0.5963363051,
0.0261811502,
-0.2760141194,
0.7637339234,
-0.572085917,
0.6589246392,
-0.1462869495,
0.1474112123,
0.3762425482,
-0.630417645,
0.6232804656,
-0.1726790816,
-0.1018825099,
0.0507289618,
0.5592547655,
0.6858952045,
-0.0728319138,
0.0752643645,
0.1935970783,
0.0096899504,
-0.5840391517,
-0.3948110342,
0.6185286045,
-0.500133872,
-0.7073246241,
-0.4013631046,
-0.0496321544,
-0.4530647397,
0.1177278459,
0.3382289112,
0.3721409738,
0.1349796206,
0.2113425881,
0.602222383,
-0.416539222,
0.3958542943,
0.7302498221,
-0.4046758413,
0.1700662374,
0.9349998236,
-0.0600172728,
0.7283256054,
0.1195451096,
0.1947864592,
-0.2733212113,
-0.5572732091,
-0.2575412691,
-0.0178111922,
-0.7054379582,
-0.2407680601,
-0.6783252954,
-0.2979469597,
0.0948575288,
-0.0830674842,
-0.7765518427,
-0.0153413955,
-0.1556020677,
-0.1316070557,
0.1267213225,
0.7848649621,
0.1448522806,
-0.0307025686,
-0.8410297632,
-0.0231305305,
0.0216190349,
0.2692523897,
0.0777082667,
-0.4684549272,
0.0397472046,
0.0597605482,
-0.2763088644,
-0.8574501276,
0.3597871065,
0.1016063988,
0.785194397,
0.8507313132,
0.2393454164,
0.4583235085,
-0.4484939873,
0.7651325464,
-0.1982488185,
-1.3682878017,
0.6902166605,
-0.2859912217,
-0.0229810365,
0.65348804,
0.3958818316,
-0.5084940791,
-1.0219573975,
-0.8609989285,
-1.0923724174,
0.6732540727,
0.1000520512,
0.0579362139,
-0.0115508288,
-0.0643655136,
0.0744914114,
0.0608992018,
-0.5540211201,
-0.3828553259,
0.0540708192,
0.3101408184,
-0.0533097982,
-0.2921369076,
-0.1821735948,
0.163681969,
0.6070483923,
0.3147589564,
-0.2976341248,
-0.1772346497,
-0.2669638991,
-0.0933915079,
0.2599394917,
0.4911942482,
0.7205538154,
0.0599996597,
0.3193414211,
-0.2031796575,
-0.2301870883,
0.2224573195,
-0.0154167423,
-0.2311696559,
-0.0370582305,
0.4912904799,
0.4285308719,
0.4451132119,
-0.9326035976,
0.6846832633,
0.1548398286,
0.103190966,
-0.0616585128,
0.196428448,
0.1051378697,
-0.0836661309,
0.4572044611,
0.2079687566,
0.3973672092,
-0.585488379,
0.8988290429,
0.2687616348,
-0.3563268483,
-0.2547515035,
0.8427755833,
0.1065211073,
-0.1213154271,
0.447760582,
0.0187753011,
-0.582205832,
0.8326377869,
0.3873462677,
0.8326122761,
-0.5183627605,
0.1597850174,
-0.0776224434,
0.4818996489,
-0.1299233586,
-0.0688659027,
0.2726066113,
-0.8606809974,
-0.2271349579,
-0.3920235932,
-0.2313408852,
0.7182817459,
-0.9837622046,
0.2763795555,
-0.3591560125,
0.1200544164,
0.5002635121,
-0.4217184186,
-0.674938798,
-0.1449911445,
0.3675945103,
1.1341079473,
-1.284397006,
0.8854579329,
0.1875860095,
-0.2949978113,
-0.8326497674,
0.3012375534,
0.3366616368,
-0.6100585461,
0.6474975348,
0.212229386,
0.1180510223,
-0.5067614913,
-0.1550840139,
-0.6962596178,
0.5330292583,
0.3487471342,
-0.4252861142,
0.340775758,
0.2391487956,
0.5546289086,
0.2702370882,
0.1916361749,
0.8413639069,
0.7007240057,
-0.5896047354,
-0.9840326905,
0.2137836963,
-0.2282614708,
-0.0858095735,
0.3617677093,
-0.5644224882,
0.7724228501,
0.1139616072,
-0.3630442321,
-0.0710588247,
-0.1259744167,
0.1736340672,
0.5003995299,
0.4953998327,
0.5047248602,
0.8026944995,
-0.1779241413,
1.2548228502,
-0.1934773326,
0.5224137902,
1.2701461315,
-0.6017463207,
1.0845756531,
0.3229748309,
-0.4861060083,
0.1425283849,
0.3170939684,
-0.1893845648,
0.532715857,
0.141376853,
-0.5189632773,
-0.1877999306,
-0.0815136731,
-0.2678699791,
0.8392498493,
0.3172969818,
-0.3747510612,
-0.5488067865,
0.121636264,
0.2908360064,
0.3885923326,
-0.0658401325,
0.5118108988,
-0.2541745901,
-0.5822464228,
0.6651374698,
-0.0400684476,
0.3344243765,
-0.4229567349,
-0.0133076897,
-0.2959772348,
0.2790546417,
-0.2841672003,
-0.7130252719,
0.2746322453,
-0.0937293023,
0.1979651451,
-0.1821240038,
0.7821757793,
-0.2873350978,
-0.1712784171,
0.5733987093,
0.6090865731,
0.1444649845,
-0.3959635794,
-0.4652427733,
0.2844846845,
0.0030570587,
-0.3157913089,
0.5327446461,
0.0494976789,
-0.0097669,
0.9942651391,
0.8529967666,
0.2240288109,
0.0200451929,
-0.0877832845,
0.7628636956,
-0.167796433,
-0.4695779681,
-1.1296246052,
0.4887876511,
0.025147438,
0.0465861782,
0.7482386231,
0.6490926743,
0.8728579879,
0.1410137713,
0.7407596707,
0.4180529416,
0.3323855102,
-0.4352380037,
1.1491318941,
-0.4682605863,
0.8177805543,
-0.274030745,
-0.588768959,
-0.0588196404,
-0.0257438906,
-0.1788028926,
0.14408876,
0.6947624683,
0.6883757114,
-0.3318921924,
0.1096870899,
0.6063056588,
0.2333351225,
0.7398418188,
0.4741027057,
0.8679261804,
-0.2423633188,
0.6149956584,
-0.5794015527,
-0.1805883348,
-0.248279348,
-0.8124611378,
-0.5541414618,
-0.3977738619,
-0.2341251969,
-0.4624816179,
0.2726263404,
0.3001851737,
0.7462258935,
-0.8886700273,
0.1849906594,
-0.1941598803,
0.1022934616,
-0.3793146312,
-0.281527102,
0.3806222677,
-0.2413878292,
-0.8260441422,
0.5623791218,
-0.0313660353,
-0.1132071018,
-0.5038957,
0.4466191232,
0.0426150635,
0.2381929457,
0.0469671637,
0.5434112549,
-0.8281253576,
-0.5415884256,
-0.4588756859,
-0.2929047644,
-0.1718539894,
0.6313388944,
-0.6502565742,
0.5254787207,
0.2688315511,
0.8493773937,
0.3055262268,
0.0770593137,
0.5241520405,
-0.9877423644,
0.0792385265,
0.1759177744,
0.451272279,
0.2306001633,
-0.7644754052,
0.3689576089,
-0.0341226682,
-0.4518200159,
-1.4619688988,
0.3127949834,
-0.4444693625,
-0.5297639966,
1.1525928974,
-0.567974329,
-0.2656772733,
-0.3881487548,
0.3746966422,
-0.3478125334,
-0.1549973488,
0.8628767133,
1.039912343,
-0.0008771338,
0.1631562114,
-1.0299953222,
0.6171869636,
0.2284757197,
-1.0311242342,
0.5362602472,
0.1051141918,
0.6839987636,
0.205204621,
0.3069117367,
-0.4342435002,
0.3934217691,
0.2657867372,
-0.1710910797,
-0.1722052842,
-0.416054368,
-0.4899950027,
0.0364181846,
0.1937788874,
-0.1675520986
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02807v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02807v3
|
Are Sounds Sound for Phylogenetic Reconstruction?
| 2024-02-05T08:35:33 | 2024-05-14T07:38:26 |
Luise Häuser, Gerhard Jäger, Taraka Rama, Johann-Mattis List, Alexandros Stamatakis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
In traditional studies on language evolution, scholars often emphasize the
importance of sound laws and sound correspondences for phylogenetic inference
of language family trees. However, to date, computational approaches have
typically not taken this potential into account. Most computational studies
still rely on lexical cognates as major data source for phylogenetic
reconstruction in linguistics, although there do exist a few studies in which
authors praise the benefits of comparing words at the level of sound sequences.
Building on (a) ten diverse datasets from different language families, and (b)
state-of-the-art methods for automated cognate and sound correspondence
detection, we test, for the first time, the performance of sound-based versus
cognate-based approaches to phylogenetic reconstruction. Our results show that
phylogenies reconstructed from lexical cognates are topologically closer, by
approximately one third with respect to the generalized quartet distance on
average, to the gold standard phylogenies than phylogenies reconstructed from
sound correspondences.
|
[
-0.3591060936,
-0.4158782363,
0.2396165878,
-0.1977326125,
-0.3477811217,
0.212077722,
-0.4382234216,
-0.7505595088,
0.6389260292,
0.1016937867,
-0.710105598,
-0.1921988577,
-0.1673750132,
0.3925162256,
-0.6759608984,
0.6489383578,
0.799762249,
-0.2694868147,
0.1772415936,
-0.0104743708,
0.0389887616,
-0.5296092033,
-0.5567753911,
0.0023732944,
0.3443423808,
-0.0483503938,
0.8477135897,
0.8998582959,
0.4622114599,
0.2257270813,
-0.5240674019,
0.0466868095,
-0.3704199791,
0.1348552853,
-0.0284921583,
-0.3031302989,
-0.1924023926,
-0.2265452147,
0.378223449,
1.1279568672,
-0.0670085475,
0.0047661951,
-0.0091034537,
0.6187292933,
-0.392098397,
0.1085698009,
-0.6648464799,
0.3190746605,
-0.4608616233,
-0.5733351707,
-0.4358783364,
-0.3583490551,
0.6711134911,
-0.8050267696,
0.4360330403,
0.3137325644,
0.8425343633,
0.2454724163,
-0.1150756031,
-0.5909069777,
-0.9653370976,
0.5953962803,
-0.776809752,
0.8250606656,
0.0680512413,
0.0956126824,
-0.5890179276,
-0.5159093142,
-0.3084249198,
-0.2896565199,
-0.0468159765,
0.0460395999,
-0.4609597325,
0.1141996235,
0.2820982039,
0.9725242257,
-0.7767187357,
0.0244556088,
-0.4073675573,
-0.5448521972,
0.5511125326,
-0.2948052287,
0.6771832705,
-0.2253772467,
-0.1038260758,
-0.6295142174,
-0.6934064627,
-0.0814821646,
0.6721621752,
0.6864544153,
-0.2168253064,
0.2645635009,
0.0707446188,
0.8405712247,
0.0955702737,
-0.6951494217,
0.1426595449,
-0.7967700362,
0.2234815508,
0.5036759973,
0.6317717433,
0.1137709692,
0.5909824967,
-0.3349791467,
0.1075057238,
0.0922073871,
-0.3255080581,
-0.3323075771,
-0.6865521669,
-0.1477547288,
-0.3564938903,
0.1001236811,
-0.2498104274,
-0.7763480544,
-0.3744461238,
-0.3074738383,
0.0895634592,
-0.5352305174,
-0.5888974071,
0.2472836524,
-0.4605794847,
0.413467586,
0.2501901686,
-1.3018474579,
0.7948237658,
0.9126574397,
0.8738805056,
-0.1538774073,
-0.1683333814,
-0.3843812644,
-0.2112762034,
-0.4359989464,
0.9846180081,
-0.3986365795,
-0.5406951904,
-0.1834244281,
-0.3027463555,
-0.0268603489,
-0.8713530302,
0.5038594007,
-0.051114928,
0.0884819925,
-0.4076702595,
-0.555013895,
-0.3622606695,
-0.2478871942,
-0.6462908983,
0.8238148093,
0.2937432528,
-0.7958296537,
0.6840155125,
-0.0519023649,
-0.461268723,
0.0010583468,
-0.2059565783,
-0.3200225234,
0.1488799006,
-0.0052530449,
-0.0106276181,
-0.2206054479,
0.1016416177,
-0.458007127,
-0.3982001543,
-0.2740269005,
-0.0807688907,
0.9501487613,
0.2634937763,
-0.4672891796,
-0.2725303471,
-0.7538816333,
-0.272876054,
-0.1370931119,
-0.2272170037,
-0.4560325146,
0.1234914288,
-0.367909044,
-0.2477005422,
-0.1168349609,
-0.6089441776,
0.272988081,
-0.7051784396,
0.3842024803,
0.2423482537,
-0.0486103334,
0.2404609025,
-0.4310821891,
0.3872121871,
-0.2146408856,
-0.4438313246,
-0.1612429023,
-0.5170716643,
-0.4353703558,
-0.537930131,
0.55699265,
0.2430731952,
0.0063244724,
0.4678443372,
-0.4186137319,
-0.4907763898,
-0.2603244185,
-0.4641590714,
0.1729195565,
0.2713271379,
0.2908257842,
-0.755831182,
-1.0073570013,
-0.6549935937,
-0.3309184611,
-0.7539460063,
0.0830453262,
0.4354483187,
0.3193336725,
0.4281686842,
0.8554593325,
-0.1718600243,
-0.0002509665,
0.1701874584,
-0.0951355472,
0.1893826276,
0.2572185993,
0.7971621752,
-0.2844516933,
-0.2340500355,
0.2456654906,
-0.6173560619,
-0.3182224035,
0.2090886384,
0.3590279222,
-0.0628506616,
0.4524301589,
-0.2278109789,
0.2587098181,
0.6689947844,
-0.3456868529,
0.494707644,
0.2003671825,
0.1475926638,
-0.7928882241,
0.2218653411,
-0.3406031728,
-0.1564281732,
-0.7211492062,
-0.0486692265,
-0.5916054845,
-0.082720466,
-0.2582652569,
0.3888182044,
-0.5404261351,
-0.8015476465,
0.0351121016,
0.0490829423,
-0.4084251821,
0.2544023693,
0.1961110681,
0.6861146092,
0.5643482804,
-0.4763290882,
0.345949918,
0.2034101337,
-0.2463861853,
0.4254317284,
-0.398288548,
0.2102790326,
0.2704388797,
0.5922666192,
-0.991563499,
-0.1548678577,
0.1591505557,
-0.4361369908,
0.2491563559,
-0.0987258852,
-0.1640479267,
-0.1925112456,
-0.2314857244,
0.7317713499,
0.6463900805,
-0.7104565501,
0.0268991198,
0.4529863,
-0.3879794776,
-0.1092308685,
-0.3773869872,
0.1367287785,
-0.4801216424,
-0.7469877601,
0.0061891666,
0.1739656031,
-0.7217465043,
-0.2950264215,
-0.3383632898,
-0.1698340327,
0.2982602715,
0.0070503252,
-0.031930387,
-0.5988820195,
0.1499334127,
-0.3251082897,
0.2412474453,
-0.2286455035,
-0.6230308414,
0.4718360901,
0.0059997947,
-0.2346495539,
-0.3607364297,
-0.0025529203,
0.5010609627,
-0.1690927595,
-0.0969881192,
0.0566836409,
-0.4919019341,
0.0435746871,
-0.4394096136,
-0.4345924854,
-0.3758087754,
-0.0429309756,
-0.2880576551,
-0.849395752,
0.281214416,
-0.3864025474,
-0.1505374759,
0.4838854373,
0.2777360678,
-0.0777788609,
0.3008927107,
0.1916010678,
-0.2002095133,
0.2040956467,
0.0061829221,
0.0742961392,
-0.4563530385,
-0.0310773496,
-1.1001108885,
-0.235997811,
-0.6599749923,
-0.0175914224,
0.2409797758,
-0.1648730934,
0.2195938081,
0.6114211679,
-0.3926579356,
0.071490325,
0.5328381658,
-0.1397407353,
0.5571658015,
0.3241220415,
-0.1537099183,
-0.1344486624,
-0.685192883,
-0.1571216732,
0.6167025566,
0.052321557,
0.4914814234,
0.0410265625,
1.0460869074,
0.0497043207,
-0.5271608233,
-0.892899394,
0.5014005303,
-0.2949761152,
-0.4280287623,
-0.38956213,
-0.391952157,
-1.4158849716,
0.2872567177,
-0.2361211181,
-0.9449569583,
0.7148319483,
0.1523542553,
-0.5425541997,
0.3420580328,
-0.1907134801,
0.3150183558,
0.0115520749,
0.0287601426,
-0.239740178,
-0.6884849072,
0.3435528874,
-0.1743455231,
0.275822401,
-0.2483505607,
0.234372288,
0.9121789932,
-0.7134721279,
0.3181009591,
0.0909121856,
-0.4187808037,
0.4278999269,
0.5038170815,
0.1515428722,
-0.665399313,
-0.1616001129,
0.0754576921,
0.4651542604,
-0.0783340707,
-0.3617649376,
0.5143153667,
-0.3613875806,
-0.394849956,
-0.4810326397,
-0.7265092134,
-0.2087044418,
0.1548081189,
0.1234843656,
0.6850871444,
-0.3609484434,
0.3331881166,
0.3963402212,
-0.016004324,
0.60246104,
0.263133049,
-0.124182567,
-0.2122931182,
0.9513588548,
-0.0036162548,
0.1306316853,
0.2854575813,
0.441719234,
-0.2612376213,
-0.7383950949,
-0.4116699398,
0.0933144018,
-0.1124609709,
0.292285949,
-0.3428114355,
0.200184837,
-0.195214361,
0.0225152858,
-0.2244202644,
-0.7331601977,
0.1099967808,
0.1207707673,
0.494150579,
0.7906368971,
-0.4751492739,
-0.0921355262,
-0.6606532931,
0.3345880806,
0.11050345,
-0.0095782708,
-0.1801468879,
-0.3036560118,
0.0893050805,
0.139077425,
0.1626392603,
-0.8851186037,
0.3563197553,
0.8448301554,
0.1571050882,
0.1253277659,
-0.0922762305,
0.8016501665,
-0.5398062468,
0.8320924044,
0.0954639614,
-0.7230117321,
0.3267003596,
-0.5778263807,
0.3064975441,
0.6142119765,
0.1365707368,
-0.5433199406,
-0.4982743263,
-0.825479269,
-0.4924314916,
0.4202903211,
0.3966577947,
-0.3986102343,
0.0311596487,
0.3292314708,
0.2054864019,
0.167007342,
0.0575410612,
0.0635080338,
0.1417958438,
-0.1357855499,
-0.1574875116,
0.4592655003,
0.1055032015,
-0.2820907831,
0.2404634953,
-0.1543323994,
0.1699539423,
0.3393587172,
-0.0646103919,
-0.2950822413,
0.1144538224,
0.6380258203,
0.4857986867,
-0.0321044475,
0.3088763356,
0.2837555408,
-0.6678994894,
0.3119774163,
-0.0945417359,
-0.1159561053,
0.468952328,
0.8697403669,
0.6617882252,
0.5507944822,
-0.3850976527,
0.450048089,
0.1772278845,
-0.2679155767,
0.0068984386,
0.0929409266,
0.2418460548,
0.2213114202,
0.1797444671,
0.2154628485,
0.5477989316,
-1.0805805922,
0.450830847,
0.3399184644,
-0.1322092116,
-0.6718463302,
0.4212681353,
0.0085815815,
-0.3672115803,
0.5819557905,
0.1249929667,
-0.4729025364,
0.6381339431,
0.4774929285,
0.6551579237,
-0.3695300817,
-0.2328191847,
0.665230155,
-0.0348204076,
-0.0404457375,
0.3790897727,
-0.3486354351,
-0.2766109109,
-0.2909275889,
-0.7693955898,
-0.6135866642,
-0.2507057488,
-0.6595632434,
0.2832455635,
-0.320761621,
0.1149671227,
0.3121705353,
-0.2352969199,
-0.07713525,
0.3259827495,
0.4453038573,
0.9808395505,
-0.6002924442,
0.4858377576,
0.18414101,
0.0886002854,
-0.9443116188,
0.1089217514,
0.4009010792,
-0.4985696375,
0.5652896762,
-0.2940049767,
-0.5221218467,
0.0676107705,
-0.2868216932,
-0.8431040645,
0.7255791426,
0.9153763652,
-0.6818307042,
-0.1831682622,
0.2358185351,
0.8886530995,
-0.0348063037,
0.2082039863,
0.6324372888,
0.4710572064,
0.1595121622,
-1.4673173428,
-0.1291840523,
0.0985329077,
-0.3873327076,
0.4911700487,
-0.4785475135,
0.7409800291,
-0.0881415829,
-0.5164233446,
0.358531028,
0.7013939619,
0.2153979242,
0.0128684919,
0.7866842151,
0.6652306318,
1.1017925739,
-0.3601562083,
0.869345963,
-0.6179552078,
0.3686353564,
0.9456739426,
-0.1112966537,
0.8225871325,
0.4212902784,
-0.5715622902,
0.5030469298,
1.0013449192,
-0.1281371266,
0.284673214,
0.6975932717,
-0.2058003694,
-0.009938594,
-0.568380177,
-0.6582196355,
0.5952985287,
0.3121303022,
0.004999469,
-0.2623255849,
-0.6452240944,
0.0009932979,
-0.1323669106,
-0.1652259827,
0.9891619682,
0.2146524787,
-0.7960776687,
0.8197761178,
-0.7485638857,
0.4877651036,
-0.4731220603,
-0.2647096813,
-0.0761431903,
-0.1257404238,
-0.4916391969,
-0.4573774636,
0.3613399863,
-0.5465600491,
0.300643295,
0.2301119566,
0.862473011,
-0.4715921581,
0.2105654031,
0.3687545061,
0.5052220821,
0.6115262508,
0.300817132,
-0.0028781565,
0.0697455034,
-0.1364345253,
0.1996639967,
-0.0840624496,
0.0313942693,
0.1094857678,
0.3576087356,
0.6136702299,
0.4287987947,
0.4167791009,
-0.2516603172,
0.2441081405,
-0.4225999117,
-0.4628629088,
-0.8457108736,
-0.0364037417,
0.3685658276,
-0.2806017697,
0.6730856895,
0.7914913297,
1.0636065006,
-0.1076273993,
0.5689516068,
0.2225988805,
0.4873825014,
-0.4479378164,
0.2155650109,
-0.5134528875,
-0.2250450999,
-0.6110681295,
-0.9554013014,
-0.2607949674,
0.3748099208,
0.1020078287,
-0.2242432386,
0.9401564002,
0.6370031834,
-0.3885811269,
0.5860971212,
0.2176943719,
0.1717021912,
-0.1555948853,
0.45223248,
0.8271486759,
-0.1492110193,
0.3986864388,
-0.1884943098,
0.069768846,
-0.1461698264,
-0.480101347,
-0.301328212,
-0.6499755383,
-0.3205006421,
-0.29250893,
0.4811510742,
1.0651277304,
0.58819592,
-0.9774221778,
-0.7249376774,
-0.1096356586,
-0.289886415,
-0.4301905334,
-0.0607829951,
0.3831613362,
0.1927208453,
-0.6953106523,
0.9713718295,
0.3538355529,
0.1468651742,
0.0623480007,
-0.081707105,
-0.2936230004,
0.1417734921,
0.2103410065,
0.802305162,
-0.7444135547,
-0.6078209281,
-0.0875915214,
-0.0105862198,
0.4186559618,
0.8312044144,
-0.6766018867,
0.4772826135,
0.9500721097,
0.4604937434,
0.3435149789,
-0.1820106804,
0.7681673169,
-0.4297809601,
0.0242135189,
0.1598903388,
0.6453926563,
0.3502599299,
-0.0466914885,
0.7613112926,
0.5676698685,
-0.2291368097,
-0.8506944776,
0.3537395298,
-1.215077281,
0.1254858673,
1.2038861513,
-0.0930899307,
-0.2225111872,
-0.3157364428,
-0.3856771886,
0.4544866979,
-0.2128669769,
0.4717490673,
0.650775671,
-0.1695543677,
0.0892217085,
-0.0596194901,
0.7581688762,
0.3870140016,
-0.6272647977,
-0.2494184226,
0.3668824732,
0.0915074199,
0.5401768684,
0.3854212761,
0.0105580473,
0.5313460231,
0.2025274932,
-0.1803084612,
0.3936654627,
-0.395427525,
-0.5075852871,
0.0801184997,
0.374055624,
0.1766851693
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02805v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02805v2
|
Graph-enhanced Large Language Models in Asynchronous Plan Reasoning
| 2024-02-05T08:26:33 | 2024-06-03T13:07:06 |
Fangru Lin, Emanuele La Malfa, Valentin Hofmann, Elle Michelle Yang, Anthony Cohn, Janet B. Pierrehumbert
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Planning is a fundamental property of human intelligence. Reasoning about
asynchronous plans is challenging since it requires sequential and parallel
planning to optimize time costs. Can large language models (LLMs) succeed at
this task? Here, we present the first large-scale study investigating this
question. We find that a representative set of closed and open-source LLMs,
including GPT-4 and LLaMA-2, behave poorly when not supplied with illustrations
about the task-solving process in our benchmark AsyncHow. We propose a novel
technique called Plan Like a Graph (PLaG) that combines graphs with natural
language prompts and achieves state-of-the-art results. We show that although
PLaG can boost model performance, LLMs still suffer from drastic degradation
when task complexity increases, highlighting the limits of utilizing LLMs for
simulating digital devices. We see our study as an exciting step towards using
LLMs as efficient autonomous agents. Our code and data are available at
https://github.com/fangru-lin/graph-llm-asynchow-plan.
|
[
-0.2444152236,
-0.8460452557,
0.8305817842,
0.3359314203,
-0.1330698133,
0.391264677,
-0.3512787819,
-0.6145226955,
0.3107801974,
0.6772150397,
-0.7097763419,
-0.4993698895,
-0.3970116675,
-0.0050982712,
-0.3412979245,
0.3627698123,
-0.436193645,
-0.0903643966,
-0.3383065164,
0.0240499396,
-0.2834724188,
-0.3778237104,
-0.7345118523,
-0.7131302953,
0.4096760452,
0.4731574357,
0.7469620705,
0.5090326667,
0.2356575131,
0.3001462817,
-0.0157248229,
0.4425121546,
-0.3860236108,
0.1164608374,
0.1761346161,
-0.1846166402,
-0.705611825,
-0.143789053,
0.5691083074,
1.0190205574,
0.0990668535,
0.046516683,
0.0387079753,
0.4660873413,
-0.2891608179,
0.7543668747,
-0.5079775453,
-0.1200199798,
-0.1045764536,
-0.0027915142,
-0.4859547317,
-0.1959351003,
-0.0666212216,
-0.7177316546,
-0.2751454413,
0.0379428603,
0.5638818145,
0.2022745013,
-0.3284703791,
-0.468008399,
-0.8231371045,
0.3446459174,
-0.5636487007,
0.2166039944,
0.4134095311,
0.3200865984,
-0.5301913619,
-0.9780939817,
-0.6295717955,
-0.3958412111,
-0.002933163,
-0.0380128548,
-0.2054960728,
0.3021859825,
0.6006748676,
-0.0570922568,
-0.6053761244,
0.3834249675,
0.0315943994,
-0.2399857789,
0.7562440634,
0.2704724669,
0.2523560822,
0.0135752056,
-0.2589780092,
0.0309971701,
-0.7092075348,
0.1587107629,
0.4494998455,
0.1950034499,
-0.0817949846,
0.8165291548,
-0.4337725937,
0.6700124145,
-0.3347243667,
0.0788482949,
0.1084654257,
-0.3264689744,
-0.1183572114,
-0.0745193958,
0.7950898409,
0.3483136892,
0.6140380502,
-0.1702362597,
-0.234908998,
0.3569383025,
-0.2009586096,
-0.7831516266,
-0.4339911938,
0.379822731,
-0.09361054,
0.1448722482,
-0.5200427771,
-0.5527274013,
-0.4685762823,
-0.1815601885,
0.1803475618,
-0.42738536,
-0.1694249064,
0.1841420978,
0.137701571,
0.0183703061,
0.5577943325,
-0.541338563,
0.4520356059,
0.7416112423,
0.7673296928,
0.10099338,
-0.5541722775,
-0.6491850615,
0.0774693564,
-0.5790783763,
1.1046630144,
-0.50110811,
-0.5815529823,
0.0531708263,
-0.1679822803,
0.0498509668,
-0.3958728015,
0.4264471829,
-0.4693733454,
-0.0786091313,
-0.3544287384,
-0.5475112796,
-0.1403247714,
0.2920007408,
-0.6885406971,
0.6173772812,
-0.2378225923,
-0.4515400231,
0.1422834992,
-0.8102892041,
-0.722777307,
0.243443355,
-0.2868496776,
-0.2154693604,
-0.3493644893,
0.2498297393,
0.4691091478,
-0.4299748242,
0.3353295922,
-0.3135013878,
-0.2895787954,
0.1967385411,
-0.1639087647,
0.8657709956,
0.0499602668,
-0.2533315718,
0.555524826,
-0.4929012656,
0.2647386491,
0.4112784564,
-0.2688147724,
0.106799379,
0.4440134764,
-0.2791382074,
0.0931421295,
0.398191005,
-0.4228637815,
0.374209702,
-0.3287546337,
0.6678770185,
0.6796522737,
-0.3076817989,
0.4852707684,
-0.3530227542,
0.4727511704,
-0.6241871715,
-0.0132793346,
-0.3410585523,
-0.6757796407,
-0.6311535239,
-0.306510061,
-0.0724268034,
0.4114310443,
-0.8311141729,
0.1355098337,
-0.3273260295,
-0.2960143983,
0.0781748146,
-0.0848975033,
0.2666986883,
0.3828699887,
0.3162069023,
-0.0655435547,
-0.3098195493,
-0.5415479541,
-0.1123726442,
-0.32320714,
-0.1011695713,
0.4538950026,
0.3347388804,
-0.4165183306,
0.8208689094,
-0.6427236199,
-0.0590569265,
-0.4921948314,
0.2596804798,
0.0074681016,
-0.0009573873,
0.3108335435,
-0.4935225248,
-0.4348544478,
0.0289361496,
-0.6213422418,
-0.4710480869,
-0.080877386,
-0.0313751623,
0.3732770681,
0.5680832863,
-0.9864630699,
0.2846868336,
0.6231059432,
-0.5444638133,
0.7125592828,
-0.2898947299,
-0.255793035,
-0.6982752085,
0.1086045951,
-0.2278805673,
-0.4804011881,
-0.6625127792,
0.114028804,
-0.0136876814,
-0.3661450148,
-0.0344908796,
0.7072567344,
-0.6280286908,
-0.5316389799,
-0.5858942866,
0.1532933116,
-0.0844782442,
0.4488524497,
-0.017568823,
0.6334871054,
0.5014052987,
-0.3659760356,
0.3864898682,
0.2945890427,
-0.2178731561,
-0.0749517307,
-0.6448999643,
0.3014580905,
-0.1032030731,
0.7075835466,
-0.8143303394,
-0.3885905743,
0.273796767,
-0.2613108754,
0.225712508,
0.0921743363,
-0.9059808254,
-0.6830505729,
-0.0863141343,
0.1412318498,
0.4354907274,
-0.6553542018,
0.7379482388,
0.5077564716,
-0.2368911505,
-0.2321434021,
-0.4306849241,
0.1289684176,
0.0920927599,
-0.834025085,
0.4012051225,
-0.1453389674,
-0.4003553987,
0.0271263923,
-0.0674235001,
-0.0005007585,
0.0066022524,
0.4313420951,
0.2026970685,
0.0614971481,
-0.0200899299,
-0.1901993752,
-0.2250747383,
0.1933688521,
-0.380384624,
1.0904837847,
-0.0757981613,
-0.4560075998,
-0.4397238195,
0.419717133,
0.5623842478,
-0.4162473381,
0.2189103514,
0.1213649809,
-0.3852660656,
-0.3993070722,
-0.2956289351,
-0.0477789752,
-0.4751742184,
0.2116340399,
-0.4144004583,
-0.7569236159,
0.6754072905,
-0.411278367,
0.1600600928,
0.092061244,
0.4359514713,
-0.0875060633,
1.1081808805,
0.4622232616,
0.0823824108,
0.3761647344,
-0.3837706149,
0.0347876325,
-0.4355347753,
-0.2561197281,
-0.3264013231,
-0.4008149505,
-0.4347847998,
-0.8196412921,
0.1714687049,
0.1034553722,
-0.4117266536,
0.1390763521,
-0.2260856032,
0.4475613236,
0.405128181,
-0.1222568601,
0.5110009313,
-0.0356079899,
-0.0213612597,
0.4310287833,
-0.6736334562,
-0.5752324462,
0.9046514034,
0.2909780443,
0.7063962221,
-0.2954143882,
0.5403652787,
-0.089415729,
0.1808962077,
-0.875710845,
1.0717140436,
-0.1274135858,
-0.2306932807,
-0.5742537379,
-0.5214540362,
-1.066426754,
-0.0007202025,
-0.0201926045,
-0.9007350206,
-0.0530984513,
0.1246871501,
-0.1493715048,
0.2469674349,
-0.7312990427,
0.7552489042,
-0.549315691,
-0.1623383313,
-0.3307488859,
-0.4299587011,
0.1153640449,
-0.065069139,
0.1618607789,
-0.5529360771,
0.1293654591,
0.5968632698,
-0.5601273179,
0.7432935834,
-0.3022750616,
0.107872881,
0.5565794706,
0.2057675272,
0.9559457898,
-0.1839707792,
-0.0034456588,
0.2686780095,
-0.4610783756,
-0.4300961494,
-0.4961433113,
0.7491263747,
-0.6184836626,
-0.5787653327,
-0.1633622497,
-0.9894443154,
-0.2652615905,
0.3772829473,
0.0626677796,
0.5392068028,
0.1131719872,
-0.2685137391,
0.095031552,
-0.3053821325,
0.7194104791,
0.3927518725,
-0.6537959576,
-0.0431605838,
0.7187134624,
0.4211524427,
0.4150232971,
0.071954079,
0.2382932901,
-0.3440087736,
-0.739554286,
-0.338111192,
0.326185137,
-0.6972544193,
-0.0083029252,
-0.69683218,
-0.2058842927,
-0.2754642665,
-0.3504582942,
-0.4366905391,
-0.4245110452,
-0.0343049169,
0.012346671,
0.3666937947,
0.8990641236,
0.114139989,
0.1263107061,
-0.3192943931,
0.334957093,
0.3223980367,
0.3622027934,
-0.0358905122,
0.1767954975,
0.2437744141,
0.0935202837,
-0.1308056712,
-0.7927209735,
0.4500440359,
-0.0950463489,
0.6223751307,
0.1374161392,
0.1497236043,
0.7360777259,
-0.6399363279,
0.411034137,
0.1227277592,
-0.8535757065,
0.3815981746,
-0.5668959618,
0.3842126429,
0.1876492053,
0.3306353688,
-0.2140823305,
-0.3125420213,
-0.4626825452,
-1.0339003801,
0.643437326,
0.1403734088,
-0.086402677,
0.0634635314,
0.1388663352,
-0.1687442213,
0.1732482016,
-0.6193853021,
-0.1154989824,
-0.1125909761,
0.054071337,
-0.2126405984,
-0.2332324237,
-0.0665319636,
-0.1194380596,
0.2613954842,
-0.4120586216,
0.5001796484,
0.057541009,
0.0331430882,
-0.1625898629,
0.0292315707,
0.5223221779,
0.7105452418,
0.009945645,
0.1839462221,
0.1391242743,
-0.2182677388,
0.028424887,
0.5018870831,
-0.0506364703,
-0.2234416306,
0.3925255835,
0.7516088486,
0.1878565401,
-0.9669772387,
0.3384208977,
0.0234827809,
-0.2408100963,
-0.446778208,
-0.1821905971,
0.3371617198,
0.5792418718,
0.2599805593,
-0.2635676265,
-0.1131395325,
-0.6997164488,
0.0072579239,
0.5094991922,
-0.0611861274,
-0.1980399489,
0.7105442882,
0.1764348298,
-0.7016441822,
0.6567668319,
-0.7133215666,
-0.528595686,
0.8118582368,
0.7583631873,
0.6626623869,
0.014684408,
0.3879866004,
0.000143293,
0.3131417334,
-0.1639447361,
0.4771976173,
-0.0267798174,
-0.7551270127,
-0.9002168179,
-0.3621953428,
-0.4857521355,
-0.066440478,
-0.0428131931,
0.2724062502,
-0.5745941401,
0.0118390219,
-0.0920421928,
0.1744459271,
-0.4940172732,
-0.1771470308,
0.2698498666,
0.8458313942,
-0.5108847618,
0.8609908223,
0.868842721,
-0.045323316,
-1.1034082174,
0.2560001612,
-0.0643472821,
-0.855946362,
0.6374360919,
0.4252622128,
-0.2662725747,
0.1932441294,
-0.3294373751,
-0.863765955,
1.2507413626,
0.6274341345,
-0.6286014915,
-0.3644423187,
0.0858936757,
0.4813103378,
-0.2806039155,
0.0589236617,
0.4399534166,
0.4451404214,
0.4381864369,
-1.0884279013,
0.1635433137,
-0.0581729896,
-0.4228276908,
0.3909217715,
-0.5480315685,
0.9618093371,
-0.3960010707,
-0.5061947703,
0.0210445095,
0.3360231519,
0.4097924829,
0.6504748464,
0.553193152,
0.3474763632,
0.9739236236,
0.0366700068,
1.2540601492,
-0.2973259389,
0.1659628451,
1.1184762716,
-0.743037641,
0.738553524,
-0.0358746275,
-0.0459828414,
0.4204939008,
0.4241940975,
0.3498290777,
0.2485439628,
0.169274956,
-0.138562426,
-0.3389994204,
-0.1920861155,
-0.0256338269,
0.6038499475,
0.4895949364,
0.0365042426,
-0.3325439095,
-0.061435625,
0.210226655,
0.1696700156,
-0.6078489423,
0.5710122585,
0.1324799955,
-0.6833673716,
0.4984729588,
-0.2130140662,
0.3040413558,
-0.4720189869,
0.110467352,
0.0587359332,
0.0201681312,
-0.0576485209,
-0.9663072824,
0.3143769801,
0.0202284381,
0.1340050101,
-0.3962025344,
0.91968292,
-0.2226838171,
-0.4138287008,
0.7288148999,
0.4899603724,
0.005559993,
-0.2028255314,
-0.4326238334,
0.0825924352,
-0.1601053625,
-0.16581285,
0.1710637659,
0.2179611027,
-0.2933651507,
1.0294560194,
0.6875891685,
0.1594312787,
-0.0226027519,
0.0463668928,
1.1086798906,
-0.5049495101,
-0.614084661,
-0.8273309469,
0.3512184024,
-0.2708843052,
0.1743108928,
0.6852542162,
0.4517022073,
0.7042188048,
0.396241039,
0.5891333222,
0.2503886223,
0.331082195,
-0.5515348911,
0.5798127055,
-0.2503809035,
0.2221977115,
-0.1218469664,
-0.6943269372,
-0.273638159,
0.5659404397,
-0.6679081917,
-0.2125820369,
0.6727715731,
0.5847126842,
0.2562814951,
-0.0289815105,
0.3527644575,
0.2301577777,
0.548333168,
0.7099995017,
0.9810444713,
0.3040006757,
0.670245409,
-0.1039652005,
-0.1870491803,
-0.1566783041,
-0.74004668,
-1.0838218927,
-0.4282198846,
-0.2509236038,
-0.1626679301,
0.019446047,
0.9746340513,
0.5214437842,
-0.2925975621,
-0.413325429,
-0.4815626442,
0.1996896267,
0.0339251943,
-0.1165841147,
0.2054339498,
-0.2232098728,
-0.5132763982,
0.6284406781,
0.3472575247,
0.0380649306,
-0.2693205178,
-0.2622686028,
0.0042532971,
0.06357155,
0.7709350586,
0.4616813958,
-0.6382921338,
-0.3079909086,
0.011327765,
-0.0419221781,
-0.0123805786,
0.9504978061,
-0.6856752634,
0.5900424123,
0.4547186792,
0.5195789933,
0.7503325939,
-0.0546051227,
0.539537251,
-0.5013256073,
0.2569973767,
0.4615057409,
0.5209485888,
0.1385600269,
-0.1451216638,
0.4347124398,
0.0063590654,
-0.8532301188,
-0.7582128644,
0.5805218816,
-0.9566618204,
-0.4631156027,
1.4494892359,
-0.048731748,
-0.1896081567,
-0.1601990908,
-0.2765848637,
0.1709903628,
-0.3811857104,
0.489520967,
0.4276118279,
-0.4990982115,
-0.0443495214,
-0.6405026317,
0.3411616981,
-0.0168027896,
-1.09073627,
0.2930992544,
0.7207379937,
-0.0872043371,
0.2259873599,
1.1611040831,
0.2291731834,
0.0798108652,
0.2286978364,
-0.062284451,
-0.3516537845,
-0.484906882,
-0.0418604463,
0.156510368,
0.3413919508,
-0.084085606
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02801v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02801v2
|
KS-Lottery: Finding Certified Lottery Tickets for Multilingual Language Models
| 2024-02-05T08:19:56 | 2024-06-03T07:35:25 |
Fei Yuan, Chang Ma, Shuai Yuan, Qiushi Sun, Lei Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The lottery ticket hypothesis posits the existence of ``winning tickets''
within a randomly initialized neural network. Do winning tickets exist for LLMs
in fine-tuning scenarios? How can we find such winning tickets? In this paper,
we propose KS-Lottery, a method to identify a small subset of LLM parameters
highly effective in multilingual fine-tuning. Our key idea is to use
Kolmogorov-Smirnov Test to analyze the distribution shift of parameters before
and after fine-tuning. We further theoretically prove that KS-Lottery can find
the certified winning tickets in the embedding layer, fine-tuning on the found
parameters is guaranteed to perform as well as full fine-tuning. Comparing
KS-Lottery with other parameter-efficient tuning algorithms on translation
tasks, the experimental results show that KS-Lottery finds a much smaller set
of parameters for fine-tuning while achieving the comparable performance as
full fine-tuning LLM. Surprisingly, we find that fine-tuning 18 tokens'
embedding of LLaMA suffices to reach the fine-tuning translation
performance~\footnote{https://github.com/CONE-MT/KS-Lottery.}.
|
[
-0.3251968324,
-0.5187823772,
0.5002328157,
0.2093355954,
-0.7846419215,
-0.1111076623,
-0.6688514352,
-0.2204063088,
0.322797209,
0.5353477001,
-0.4547433555,
-0.5806273222,
-0.7066642046,
0.0996059105,
-0.4462544322,
0.7049937248,
0.000504549,
0.4694671631,
-0.0766481385,
-0.022664804,
0.0466419868,
-0.1356132329,
-0.5700284243,
-0.3984002769,
0.9544850588,
0.5747032762,
0.4951427281,
0.6829934716,
0.3068511784,
0.2672680616,
-0.1886133105,
0.2230081111,
-0.3512244821,
0.0784767717,
0.1025197953,
-1.157528758,
0.2393553108,
0.1073963791,
0.6875149608,
0.5050151944,
-0.3189670444,
0.2257630676,
0.0390928276,
0.5572534204,
-0.6443440914,
0.1611522436,
-0.9086495042,
0.4969384372,
-0.4440721571,
-0.6059687138,
-0.4479813278,
-0.4773873091,
-0.3965420127,
-0.4764227271,
0.2274437845,
0.108936578,
0.9416243434,
0.2213085443,
-0.5236216187,
-0.4483724236,
-0.5632348657,
0.7547793388,
-0.6311509609,
0.5818134546,
0.2763032615,
0.3264351785,
-0.3752266765,
-0.3418449759,
-0.5555461049,
-0.736884892,
0.2134250849,
0.0435027927,
0.3938878477,
0.1697657406,
-0.01080414,
0.2236121893,
-0.2264961153,
0.1833739132,
-0.152799204,
-0.4111043811,
0.546261847,
0.1208238974,
0.1569276303,
0.0492718257,
0.0341783836,
-0.1211940944,
-0.716578722,
0.1065955088,
0.8925549388,
0.6352192163,
-0.042918738,
0.7287346125,
-0.5530682206,
0.7950791121,
0.1508175433,
-0.4703442454,
0.0056182411,
-0.6481516957,
0.0228422694,
0.0511220917,
0.5997450352,
0.117568709,
0.6510566473,
-0.4817032218,
-0.2917200625,
-0.2744446397,
-0.0954209268,
-0.53533566,
-0.2002445161,
-0.0473857485,
-0.660862267,
-0.7492713928,
-0.3104735315,
-0.5768290758,
-0.488026768,
-0.4383854866,
0.5190076828,
-0.0813820064,
-0.2699617147,
0.1159533486,
-0.1119386628,
0.3423227966,
0.0072456864,
-1.0404773951,
-0.0304180365,
0.6626860499,
0.6659687757,
-0.0458541512,
-0.5898593664,
-0.5626260042,
-0.3120720685,
-0.7215910554,
0.9477253556,
-0.330029726,
-0.02939431,
0.1669812799,
-0.0441338941,
-0.0842851475,
-0.7641019225,
0.3121527135,
-0.7576464415,
-0.4432581961,
-0.1932072788,
-0.5264874101,
0.3318972886,
0.2657913268,
-0.4620047808,
0.728599906,
-0.2304665595,
-0.192062065,
0.7494526505,
-0.1186527684,
-0.5931801796,
-0.0653154701,
-0.1792868525,
-0.327778399,
0.5522258878,
-0.0954828262,
0.4832620919,
-0.2336937189,
-0.0356903747,
-0.5194180608,
-0.4309448898,
0.4458917081,
-0.4776046872,
0.6763067245,
0.2811740935,
-0.3353669345,
-0.1830749363,
-0.9446617961,
0.1038786694,
0.0351049267,
-0.7524736524,
-0.1308011711,
0.0314441808,
0.0937993601,
0.2740193307,
0.3800390363,
-0.5727372169,
0.1544355154,
-0.5966548324,
0.0377507508,
0.8085902929,
-0.0815358609,
0.7784377337,
0.1176654696,
0.6232076883,
0.5135431886,
0.2558265924,
0.145603314,
-0.5683407187,
-1.0508053303,
0.090087302,
0.7379162908,
0.3486633003,
-0.5836519599,
0.1550137699,
0.0457542129,
-0.5351885557,
-0.871999681,
0.3603256941,
0.1712011248,
0.092689544,
-0.146158129,
0.1694044322,
-0.3417645097,
-1.2619020939,
-0.4942878783,
0.2784584165,
0.2764472365,
0.397595495,
0.3601749837,
0.1129470393,
0.5740935802,
-0.2605021,
-0.4025068283,
-0.0088893576,
-0.139516905,
0.336273402,
0.3303668499,
0.475612402,
-0.8021669388,
-0.719973743,
0.5523455143,
-0.4092833996,
0.0107678855,
-0.0819501281,
0.1087807566,
0.3403092325,
0.4219375551,
-0.3857329488,
0.2901751697,
0.5411863327,
-0.513838172,
0.4694507718,
-0.4798308015,
0.2722039819,
-1.100651145,
-0.2744865417,
-0.1940466315,
-0.1760381907,
-0.3948822618,
0.3202815056,
0.4053252041,
0.1509744078,
-0.3798669279,
0.2596818507,
-0.361812681,
-0.0147730848,
-0.4034384489,
0.234814018,
-0.6657940745,
0.4501344562,
-0.3471053243,
0.565977037,
0.5049351454,
-0.6666496992,
0.4479053915,
-0.2363362163,
-0.8580038548,
0.5328903794,
-0.1260978431,
-0.0453853533,
-0.2543767691,
-0.2286668569,
-1.0004841089,
-0.1458702236,
0.3761183023,
-0.3664622605,
0.144026354,
-0.4036024511,
-0.8026684523,
-0.0310877338,
0.2136888951,
0.051816579,
0.4759839475,
-0.5140357614,
0.3878898621,
0.2507991493,
0.0457519777,
-0.5697786808,
-0.5213505626,
0.1803599894,
-0.2618919313,
-0.3142598569,
-0.0101083368,
-0.1503911465,
0.0106333178,
-0.1680303067,
0.0330416299,
-0.023988355,
0.4740235209,
-0.0579495616,
-0.3042064905,
-0.2053373605,
-0.0048277811,
0.4534012973,
-0.4308154285,
-0.1654214412,
-0.5443714857,
0.4707718194,
0.1099219695,
-0.3326841593,
-0.1636857241,
0.2132124752,
0.558699131,
-0.0732401311,
0.7079393268,
0.5244829655,
-0.3818700612,
-0.3182738721,
-0.6160644293,
-0.2671221197,
-0.4702881277,
0.5420824289,
-0.7123839259,
-0.8698276877,
0.8338363171,
-0.2303046137,
-0.3152794838,
0.393255651,
0.7328571677,
-0.0179238189,
1.3947094679,
0.4638883173,
-0.0886872262,
0.3129705787,
-0.0175230186,
0.2495172322,
-0.3211010098,
-0.3428528607,
-0.7646635175,
-0.6655551791,
-0.8078943491,
-0.1691489518,
0.3563917279,
0.3737414181,
0.1648198068,
0.1210707054,
-0.2355763763,
0.9681643844,
0.8723264933,
-0.0997615159,
0.2802240551,
-0.0079571102,
-0.7467847466,
-0.1124852076,
-0.6418299675,
-0.1619899273,
1.1270742416,
-0.0156164262,
0.4351496696,
-0.0124268644,
1.0608329773,
-0.1402407736,
0.1081020683,
-0.6960592866,
0.6667230129,
-0.1667725593,
-0.5471176505,
-0.4261832833,
-0.3075025678,
-0.8689141273,
0.2082140595,
-0.3230481744,
-0.7672324777,
0.23770307,
0.0724609643,
-0.27967453,
0.1721479744,
-0.4496978521,
0.8260374069,
-0.2463421226,
-0.0374901295,
-0.5336895585,
-0.4250059426,
0.1038367525,
-0.3854714632,
0.0935771167,
-0.2820851207,
-0.0999604911,
0.359305501,
-0.0878677666,
0.6997238398,
-0.280449152,
-0.364815563,
-0.0144946314,
0.1504857391,
0.8544183969,
0.3136383295,
-0.2734940052,
0.0430333316,
0.1097135991,
-0.2727751136,
-0.7479298115,
1.0899065733,
-0.7818340063,
-0.3701016307,
-0.0806617588,
-0.4218150079,
0.0343001895,
0.3176792264,
0.4073378444,
0.0919302031,
0.2609570324,
0.4280501604,
0.453266114,
-0.0040011099,
0.3873535991,
0.7080914974,
-0.0492579155,
-0.5220713019,
1.1292798519,
0.4212498665,
0.0407280438,
0.4041909575,
0.4287625849,
-0.2506900728,
-0.9919168949,
-0.6409231424,
0.1495454758,
-0.7275568247,
-0.1256720573,
-0.1588831842,
-0.0008188948,
-0.1277108192,
0.021225825,
-0.7064630389,
-0.3921076357,
-0.4319190979,
-0.0528803207,
0.1567281038,
0.5574596524,
-0.1587021053,
0.0927979052,
-0.51459831,
0.1158038229,
0.1943974644,
0.7496259212,
0.0645907596,
-0.3901866674,
-0.7438699007,
0.1483583152,
-0.1447383761,
-0.8019403219,
0.165525645,
0.2179623693,
0.6033593416,
0.5079404712,
-0.2836408019,
0.755802393,
-0.7137577534,
0.8006564379,
0.0039651338,
-0.6035555005,
0.4111289978,
-0.3145783246,
0.0911830887,
0.6931580305,
0.0345710628,
-0.5704781413,
-0.684548676,
-0.4369884133,
-0.5746069551,
0.7422401905,
0.1035420746,
0.3331419528,
-0.0879396722,
0.7282795906,
0.1844180077,
0.3266155422,
-0.7545927763,
-0.7851640582,
0.2265820205,
-0.3114694357,
-0.4530507922,
-0.3185324967,
0.1110899225,
-0.3174039721,
0.557813406,
-0.20939897,
0.1158255115,
-0.1962113976,
0.0388795249,
-0.2855337858,
0.1745025069,
1.0719969273,
0.4330759943,
0.0060147895,
0.1963605732,
0.3586308956,
-0.2961378098,
0.2758933306,
0.2052179724,
-0.3575581014,
0.0256471578,
-0.049945239,
0.6488543749,
0.6966918111,
-0.5609437823,
0.3047869503,
0.0970277116,
-0.5305073857,
-0.3835413754,
0.2283782661,
0.3135438561,
0.4641095102,
0.4958904982,
-0.0731510967,
0.1199252978,
-0.2477040738,
0.1515829712,
0.5259742737,
-0.4255757034,
-0.1915206909,
0.711928606,
0.0315879621,
-0.7013120055,
0.4731208682,
-0.527156055,
-0.23826617,
0.7178779244,
0.6340711117,
0.8212684989,
-0.0544840433,
0.3133340776,
0.2391205877,
0.2586409152,
-0.1424701959,
0.3849158883,
-0.1683241129,
-0.9144114256,
-0.3647988737,
-0.7277209163,
-0.1185783818,
-0.0239415411,
-0.3921641707,
0.356929481,
0.1645318121,
0.0853486583,
0.1109195948,
0.08502312,
-0.711470902,
0.0188782271,
0.218653813,
0.9404273033,
-0.7167392373,
0.9455860257,
0.5939703584,
-0.1708208919,
-0.7725476027,
-0.1670488417,
-0.3136293888,
-0.7878321409,
0.7883205414,
-0.28656587,
0.2912044227,
0.3138656318,
-0.4755961001,
-1.1844803095,
0.9855173826,
0.5517026186,
-0.7483028769,
0.2292158455,
0.727881372,
0.4419512153,
-0.1691120714,
0.0680635124,
0.5923561454,
0.4880034626,
-0.0188512411,
-0.9284009933,
-0.3974293172,
-0.0925847441,
-0.1168826967,
0.5175502896,
-0.5243390799,
0.561632216,
-0.0954055488,
0.1973700225,
0.370716244,
0.3657511175,
0.338241607,
0.3040932417,
0.5880879164,
0.5366025567,
0.8284344673,
-0.192436561,
1.0308659077,
-0.639129281,
0.5698006749,
0.5809553266,
0.0587348938,
0.9385755658,
0.7998754978,
-0.0609544516,
0.1735334694,
0.7668295503,
0.0712269917,
0.954600513,
0.6242191792,
-0.210322991,
-0.7176167965,
0.1341852695,
-0.0771229789,
0.5341892838,
-0.0605387762,
-0.3580560684,
-0.227511093,
0.4411659837,
-0.3722236156,
-0.1826291531,
-0.2846616507,
0.7102985978,
0.3071132898,
-0.7749310136,
0.360106498,
0.2354087085,
0.5676922202,
-0.6380465031,
0.1805280447,
-0.4778774679,
0.5090210438,
0.1859592348,
-0.459734261,
-0.0127782989,
-0.401902914,
-0.0279710237,
0.0253632963,
0.7797438502,
-0.7432101369,
-0.6723961234,
0.1447745562,
0.2408336997,
0.1853373498,
0.0124397669,
-0.7040501833,
-0.0765686706,
0.063966088,
-0.4674259424,
0.6831194758,
0.5018515587,
0.2841438651,
0.7350872159,
0.6623116136,
0.5330987573,
0.1222966686,
0.2770130336,
0.2466040552,
-0.5914687514,
-0.7176506519,
-0.9297750592,
0.4646795988,
0.0973183364,
-0.5793927908,
0.8266438246,
0.708173275,
0.9093335867,
-0.473936826,
0.5071137547,
0.4718716741,
0.0788837224,
-0.5378070474,
0.8786264062,
-0.8777751327,
-0.0322520062,
-0.0156704932,
-0.7712824941,
-0.4755454957,
0.5095329881,
0.1362859309,
-0.1314056814,
0.4573264122,
0.9801336527,
-0.0997750834,
-0.1822364777,
0.5816014409,
0.0851836428,
0.0698566884,
0.4831440747,
0.8924369216,
-0.6080350876,
0.82564044,
-0.4550078809,
0.0375174507,
-0.4268897474,
-0.9021975994,
-0.8284388781,
-0.7464296818,
-0.3969008327,
-0.3292485476,
0.1011782289,
0.9121143818,
0.5931764245,
-0.884970665,
-0.2793103456,
-0.2170547247,
0.4992522001,
-0.3995559812,
-0.1259340048,
0.0266234037,
-0.5711841583,
-0.8818179369,
0.3845924437,
0.2990398407,
0.1388649344,
-0.2933408022,
-0.2762528956,
0.0655046776,
0.0715732053,
0.3367929757,
-0.0358509906,
-0.852617383,
-0.3460041881,
0.2612217665,
-0.0302421171,
-0.3078137338,
0.7546913028,
-0.3746368587,
0.5667045712,
0.2841548026,
0.4780188799,
0.5294479132,
-0.6132767797,
0.490234077,
-0.7845609188,
0.3531202972,
0.0775859952,
0.2621040344,
-0.2518035471,
-0.3228357732,
0.2976395786,
0.2036320567,
-0.5759546161,
-0.8930476308,
-0.0153072979,
-0.850124836,
-0.012401158,
1.4202903509,
0.4222725332,
-0.1195638925,
0.1248026192,
-0.1257959902,
0.117729418,
0.0497434288,
1.0455545187,
1.0299896002,
0.351421982,
-0.2951663136,
-0.6129869819,
0.7003611326,
0.4876561761,
-0.3641823828,
-0.2869322896,
-0.0653307214,
0.4496934116,
0.1562798917,
0.4169839621,
0.0873999819,
0.5110801458,
-0.0791117325,
-0.2321292162,
-0.0151979681,
-0.2771404982,
-0.3053341806,
0.19430767,
0.3565009832,
-0.4573207498
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02791v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02791v2
|
Rethinking Optimization and Architecture for Tiny Language Models
| 2024-02-05T07:59:38 | 2024-02-06T05:38:26 |
Yehui Tang, Fangcheng Liu, Yunsheng Ni, Yuchuan Tian, Zheyuan Bai, Yi-Qi Hu, Sichao Liu, Shangling Jui, Kai Han, Yunhe Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The power of large language models (LLMs) has been demonstrated through
numerous data and computing resources. However, the application of language
models on mobile devices is facing huge challenge on the computation and memory
costs, that is, tiny language models with high performance are urgently
required. Limited by the highly complex training process, there are many
details for optimizing language models that are seldom studied carefully. In
this study, based on a tiny language model with 1B parameters, we carefully
design a series of empirical study to analyze the effect of each component.
Three perspectives are mainly discussed, \ie, neural architecture, parameter
initialization, and optimization strategy. Several design formulas are
empirically proved especially effective for tiny language models, including
tokenizer compression, architecture tweaking, parameter inheritance and
multiple-round training. Then we train PanGu-$\pi$-1B Pro and PanGu-$\pi$-1.5B
Pro on 1.6T multilingual corpora, following the established formulas.
Experimental results demonstrate the improved optimization and architecture
yield a notable average improvement of 8.87 on benchmark evaluation sets for
PanGu-$\pi$-1B Pro. Besides, PanGu-$\pi$-1.5B Pro surpasses a range of SOTA
models with larger model sizes, validating its superior performance. The code
is available at https://github.com/YuchuanTian/RethinkTinyLM.
|
[
-0.3571404517,
-0.9050788283,
0.4313593805,
0.2190153003,
-0.5825963616,
-0.2248664796,
-0.5068304539,
-0.4440380633,
0.3078705072,
0.2282828391,
-0.4507829547,
-0.1042215303,
-0.2784414291,
0.0791216567,
0.1856176555,
0.5322078466,
0.2407623678,
0.2420076132,
0.1064514294,
-0.2887428105,
-0.3762672544,
-0.1852520406,
-0.9690853953,
-0.1783946902,
0.5524088144,
0.776848197,
0.634170413,
1.0656812191,
0.3312091529,
0.2386524826,
-0.2496889681,
0.0057960297,
-0.458248049,
-0.2717301846,
0.3202044368,
-0.652048111,
-0.5193837881,
-0.2478807122,
0.7267171741,
0.5961600542,
0.0469975993,
0.4994715452,
-0.0702983737,
0.5690697432,
-0.2966152728,
0.0757112801,
-0.6592652202,
-0.1948388964,
-0.2258541137,
-0.0284069013,
-0.4840367734,
-0.4643829763,
0.0038484791,
-0.3199166954,
0.202968955,
0.4390414655,
0.7034247518,
0.2297814488,
-0.0687845275,
-0.2723327279,
-0.5091384053,
0.7684375048,
-0.8927941918,
0.5699542761,
0.1295397282,
0.0674705356,
-0.1352543384,
-0.5447434783,
-0.4823388159,
-0.575376153,
0.1249547601,
-0.431632787,
-0.0822466016,
-0.027961554,
0.0376615599,
0.2133294046,
-0.5448552966,
0.534807384,
-0.4702751935,
-0.0375167057,
0.6724985242,
0.2153498232,
0.3850507736,
-0.2072337568,
-0.1611386538,
0.1155985594,
-1.0867525339,
-0.002675652,
0.3592769802,
0.6183373332,
-0.2483829111,
0.3041467071,
-0.0269722249,
0.6132208705,
0.0772244036,
-0.2905434668,
0.2177206874,
-0.4620973766,
-0.1282257885,
0.1090314314,
0.8654266596,
0.0431655571,
0.1352552772,
-0.3250577748,
-0.2365105003,
-0.1948965341,
0.3540648818,
-1.1381722689,
-0.1823070347,
0.2848404348,
-0.6672273874,
-0.4670131207,
-0.5548837781,
-0.5828251839,
-0.1041080579,
-0.4639676511,
0.307622999,
-0.5631703734,
-0.3312855065,
0.0515460111,
0.5454431176,
-0.0012789527,
-0.0330563411,
-1.3093352318,
0.2649351954,
0.7623100877,
0.9140387177,
0.0935709327,
-0.2531729639,
-0.2177648991,
-0.3243303895,
-0.3194175959,
0.7588756084,
-0.3875057697,
-0.4273226857,
-0.2695424259,
-0.2498602271,
-0.2964389026,
-0.6052424908,
0.6927391887,
-0.5565207005,
-0.2507285774,
0.0268359873,
-0.5189009905,
-0.1126864478,
0.1972827613,
-0.8662651181,
0.8200878501,
-0.2041505128,
-0.66176337,
0.2399892062,
-0.647467494,
-0.4547623098,
0.0106865717,
-0.1879688054,
-0.567899704,
0.6073669791,
0.0419372693,
0.3030140102,
-0.5839905143,
0.1103506386,
-0.1595894396,
-0.4091133773,
0.0723063424,
-0.093496643,
0.7207410336,
0.3900542557,
-0.1630294919,
0.1794847548,
-0.9117038846,
0.2743547261,
0.139354825,
-0.5860356688,
-0.3994720876,
-0.0147329094,
0.010624459,
0.0645510852,
0.1936332881,
-0.5876213908,
0.2232382745,
-0.688631773,
0.6575245261,
0.559257865,
-0.1157940775,
0.8065962791,
-0.0730574802,
0.4853277802,
-0.2434389591,
0.2418878376,
-0.0389794856,
-0.3479629159,
-0.7751269937,
-0.4089410603,
0.6929194331,
0.2764804959,
-0.4411821365,
0.092368044,
-0.4522029459,
-0.6087500453,
-0.8550220132,
0.2123340964,
0.4864761233,
0.1093581542,
-0.0277604684,
0.038363196,
-0.7620546222,
-1.1124893427,
-0.2757810056,
-0.2944972515,
0.0856201574,
0.2838448286,
0.434614867,
-0.2336377501,
0.961212039,
-0.2061875015,
0.0805370733,
-0.6098336577,
-0.1183043271,
0.1948315948,
0.5007565022,
0.5614717603,
-0.6825643778,
-0.4013831913,
0.0625952855,
-0.3925544024,
-0.0921649039,
-0.0888489559,
0.1937025785,
0.2449670434,
0.4630557895,
-0.6862338185,
0.0631664544,
0.4483584166,
0.1353743374,
0.816541791,
-0.3013823926,
-0.4183208346,
-0.9763121009,
0.0755320787,
0.0417350456,
0.0709579885,
-0.7365967035,
0.5182789564,
0.2770026028,
-0.1684685946,
-0.6725259423,
0.8325340748,
-0.5348399878,
0.0413066335,
-0.4907303154,
0.3213843703,
-0.285005182,
0.6556593776,
-0.2138380855,
0.7786521316,
0.4168550968,
-0.6419863701,
0.1255460382,
-0.1251553744,
-0.46905756,
-0.0626366735,
-0.8031684756,
0.1850655228,
-0.0866835564,
-0.1275828034,
-0.9986789823,
0.0227863863,
0.1148116142,
-0.2976650298,
0.3130940795,
-0.1573919654,
-0.8681872487,
-0.2469794005,
-0.4420171976,
0.621532917,
0.2960236371,
-0.5358136892,
0.5940413475,
0.3947535455,
-0.1260382533,
0.0441956855,
-0.5012398362,
-0.0371936709,
-0.5154648423,
-0.8816134334,
0.2141042352,
0.0754218847,
-0.29006055,
-0.28221035,
-0.1643309742,
0.168045342,
0.0548347011,
0.0147231184,
0.1541543752,
-0.6249739528,
0.2094146013,
0.0099407891,
-0.3289023638,
-0.0721871853,
-0.2922396362,
0.8015969396,
-0.5247806907,
0.162057206,
-0.5148888826,
0.0489846542,
0.378965348,
-0.160145089,
0.7749564648,
0.4477466345,
-0.3282002509,
-0.1143158525,
-0.4901127815,
-0.245011881,
-0.4964722395,
0.5117624402,
-0.7826828361,
-0.9016893506,
0.6761822701,
-0.1362912059,
0.0927093104,
0.2467149198,
0.9223406315,
0.1886186451,
0.679310441,
0.6957885027,
-0.151244536,
0.5024838448,
-0.2669425905,
0.4283934832,
-0.9433192015,
-0.1931269765,
-0.5345112681,
-0.4127541482,
-0.8404997587,
-0.4671997428,
0.091982007,
0.2903446853,
-0.2182972133,
0.5937837362,
-0.1588888019,
0.490197897,
0.4175075591,
0.1211437061,
0.2195258886,
0.0626677871,
-0.3482676148,
-0.1077564731,
-1.0720027685,
-0.9258294106,
1.1003452539,
0.6514149308,
0.9360151887,
0.2981699407,
0.6293652654,
-0.1739599258,
0.1723916084,
-0.9484198093,
0.7160152793,
-0.2934777141,
-0.5353614688,
-0.1962136924,
-0.3994901478,
-0.8513374925,
0.6755989194,
0.0952779353,
-0.9069333076,
0.2100100517,
0.2677562237,
-0.5688742399,
0.1196528152,
-1.1008880138,
1.0840044022,
-0.4784486294,
-0.4672511816,
-0.1874146014,
-0.5712985992,
0.3586233556,
-0.2803209126,
0.2712326348,
0.03003373,
-0.1944850087,
0.6711340547,
-0.363571763,
0.8227103949,
-0.0202774126,
-0.0856884047,
0.2522878051,
0.1467593014,
0.4952869415,
0.1867723465,
-0.3136782348,
0.0525648333,
-0.1243396327,
-0.3283057511,
-0.4126240313,
0.7401394844,
-0.8113433719,
-0.511846602,
0.1628384888,
-0.2663195431,
-0.0864893645,
0.3237830698,
0.300744921,
0.4828107059,
-0.2256259173,
0.2282410711,
0.6757588983,
-0.1641719639,
0.5725859404,
0.4951404929,
-0.3038482964,
-0.1280881613,
0.9781515598,
0.0148173319,
0.3493679762,
0.3917754889,
0.5260445476,
-0.303794533,
-0.7194539309,
-0.8837124109,
0.5126392245,
-0.3126169443,
-0.0086026825,
-0.5681594014,
0.1152206734,
-0.3814832568,
0.2886768878,
-0.7496691942,
-0.4103813171,
-0.3735310137,
-0.0220504832,
-0.0061462191,
0.162757054,
0.067292355,
0.7411544919,
-0.556096971,
0.2451754659,
-0.0147460504,
0.292132318,
0.3572895229,
-0.7059754133,
-0.6142863035,
0.0501158014,
-0.1895457506,
-0.4897448123,
0.2618533969,
0.2322180569,
0.4629192948,
0.5948491096,
-0.3019953668,
0.6357297301,
-0.9055692554,
0.4075853527,
-0.0120919412,
-0.6499704719,
0.3527404964,
-0.2433378249,
0.1831641644,
0.6283391714,
0.0481373854,
-0.2928672135,
-0.0568887442,
-0.7483614087,
-0.6984983683,
0.7930069566,
0.2410088181,
0.202056393,
0.1300017238,
0.5919170976,
0.0007723894,
0.0674191117,
-0.6363068819,
-0.2274250388,
0.0303552095,
-0.0621519983,
0.1566755623,
-0.5995063186,
0.2023302764,
-0.21075508,
0.5581347942,
0.0518986471,
0.3013446927,
-0.3534767628,
-0.1864654869,
0.0487798564,
0.2334193289,
0.9583249092,
0.5424811244,
-0.1454274952,
0.1250922084,
0.1575701833,
-0.5220415592,
0.1160493344,
-0.2887376845,
-0.1670199931,
0.0637406558,
0.198232308,
1.0240409374,
0.3713260889,
-0.65389961,
0.095983319,
-0.1008620933,
0.1014369354,
-0.1360318661,
0.003079639,
0.3967318237,
0.2174869776,
0.1006967723,
-0.0372783802,
-0.0451689363,
-0.6413956881,
0.0314187519,
0.2671672106,
0.0692725256,
-0.5983455777,
0.6352735758,
0.269887656,
-0.7463546395,
0.5123088956,
-0.2431262285,
-0.5075410604,
0.5667372346,
0.8379225135,
0.6816707253,
-0.1899559498,
0.0411682725,
0.3104071915,
0.657379508,
-0.1889409423,
0.0593598336,
0.1360756159,
-0.7660564184,
-0.3068507314,
-0.756029129,
-0.1559017748,
0.0845937431,
-0.2153987437,
0.2900392711,
-0.5843923092,
-0.1286084354,
0.0660002977,
0.4330959618,
-0.3938060403,
0.3558728993,
0.0011493497,
1.0350255966,
-0.684466958,
1.1213552952,
0.6177586317,
-0.3758228421,
-1.0545914173,
-0.1436452717,
-0.0487145595,
-0.9521260262,
0.7582808137,
0.1264365017,
-0.2126563489,
0.0585083328,
-0.2605806887,
-0.7925432324,
0.6631840467,
0.399353236,
-0.6939257383,
-0.0124782529,
0.2138581723,
0.7830747366,
-0.6556151509,
-0.0243730657,
0.8218063712,
0.2065161318,
-0.0303312708,
-0.843044579,
0.0631990656,
-0.3352251649,
0.4738149345,
0.2032521516,
-0.8718858361,
0.9206012487,
-0.4968385398,
-0.245235011,
0.492770344,
0.5109826326,
0.5875897408,
0.0962198004,
0.2972904146,
0.4891654849,
0.525993824,
0.084913075,
1.0629044771,
-0.4054049551,
0.4653995931,
1.0603120327,
0.0187181737,
1.0242440701,
0.7104964256,
-0.111658819,
0.2032800615,
0.8792464137,
0.1104262024,
0.4659100473,
0.430712074,
-0.2329601198,
-0.0447043963,
0.1976782233,
-0.1967174858,
0.4218920171,
0.2315607518,
-0.296900183,
0.0117967324,
0.0469937548,
0.2376158834,
-0.2093544602,
-0.3075248599,
0.5687343478,
0.2075746655,
-0.2537300289,
0.5852940679,
0.7041310072,
0.6405301094,
-0.2470812798,
0.6294388771,
-0.6477649808,
0.3169448674,
-0.0947788358,
-0.0387348272,
0.2090812474,
0.0317561664,
-0.1965720952,
0.0078112674,
0.7446445823,
-0.2176453769,
-0.7270254493,
-0.0855252668,
0.3776519001,
0.3357259333,
-0.1239449382,
-0.6231669188,
0.435203582,
0.0241522491,
-0.2349824011,
0.2100005299,
0.5516731143,
-0.0833237767,
0.8333031535,
0.5155600905,
0.2396403551,
0.2757180333,
0.2097544372,
0.7438619733,
-0.6380756497,
-0.744859457,
-1.1658402681,
0.1626529098,
0.1729602814,
-0.1988836527,
0.7973838449,
0.9315809608,
0.7670015097,
-0.2015237063,
0.3216199875,
-0.0963418335,
0.3358246088,
-0.5607559085,
0.6785188913,
-0.6723599434,
0.6510626078,
-0.072301358,
-1.0011231899,
-0.3547480702,
0.6815711856,
-0.3930982053,
0.1322540343,
0.5943028331,
0.9890696406,
-0.1038675532,
0.2368804216,
0.1942792833,
0.2907230854,
0.2222409993,
0.4662928879,
0.5669291019,
-0.7117809057,
0.4793030322,
-0.1239211857,
-0.0891068205,
-0.5931292176,
-0.5912804008,
-0.8221657872,
-0.2101003677,
-0.2150476724,
0.0170822516,
-0.0676935688,
0.9520733356,
0.7707240582,
-0.5112485886,
-0.4565465748,
-0.0351283476,
0.1313414723,
0.0569852293,
-0.1378333271,
0.5367489457,
-0.3757126927,
-0.7060698867,
0.3035400808,
0.2185800076,
-0.0745540112,
-0.2859918177,
-0.2159228772,
-0.0793861449,
0.0274661258,
0.8020288348,
0.411127001,
-0.819732964,
-0.2253492624,
0.0398668423,
-0.2679973543,
0.0989510193,
1.0790963173,
-0.6230537891,
0.2887954712,
0.2863227129,
0.7125062943,
0.3626797795,
-0.0866411477,
0.3672513068,
-0.877443552,
0.374270469,
-0.0203613248,
0.3771001995,
0.1855786294,
-0.051206965,
0.4683109522,
0.0417676643,
-0.3313317001,
-0.9855635166,
0.1751911342,
-0.8490887284,
-0.2762647271,
1.159705162,
0.1905220747,
-0.4035180807,
0.1784766167,
-0.2976759076,
0.0933103561,
-0.2658341229,
0.9574435949,
0.5145007372,
-0.2061345577,
-0.5101175904,
-0.4830645919,
0.3253281713,
0.5055934787,
-0.578800261,
0.0667748228,
0.1880029291,
0.3566473424,
0.1877927929,
0.6579741836,
-0.0689389557,
0.176483348,
0.32522735,
-0.1195585579,
-0.166725263,
-0.3535565734,
-0.3292085826,
0.1038298681,
0.2206081599,
-0.3872665167
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02782v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02782v1
|
From Partial to Strictly Incremental Constituent Parsing
| 2024-02-05T07:33:25 | 2024-02-05T07:33:25 |
Ana Ezquerro, Carlos Gómez-Rodríguez, David Vilares
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We study incremental constituent parsers to assess their capacity to output
trees based on prefix representations alone. Guided by strictly left-to-right
generative language models and tree-decoding modules, we build parsers that
adhere to a strong definition of incrementality across languages. This builds
upon work that asserted incrementality, but that mostly only enforced it on
either the encoder or the decoder. Finally, we conduct an analysis against
non-incremental and partially incremental models.
|
[
-0.1621101052,
-0.6774356365,
0.5807412863,
0.5423743129,
-0.2122828662,
0.0048364783,
-0.0643191859,
-0.3756656647,
0.218255043,
0.4911090136,
-0.6485562921,
-0.3012650311,
-0.3797090352,
0.6429481506,
-0.7508875728,
0.6002910733,
0.2002914399,
0.0195400231,
-0.4038009048,
-0.1888445914,
-0.7661345601,
-0.7804645896,
-0.745098114,
-0.110291861,
0.1845768988,
0.4914775789,
0.6254267097,
0.9371046424,
0.1522147208,
0.3085014522,
-0.1618091911,
-0.5701951385,
-0.1063592434,
0.269408226,
-0.1879374981,
-0.3987693787,
-0.2961383462,
-0.3427073061,
1.102507472,
0.8230828643,
0.0253990591,
-0.1435632855,
0.1274555176,
0.6520025134,
-0.1633401811,
0.1175715774,
-0.7836362123,
0.3344607651,
-0.5628712773,
-0.2388475388,
-0.7138668299,
-0.3718480468,
-0.333912015,
-0.1689045727,
0.3869486153,
-0.4048042893,
0.8529083133,
0.0932240486,
-0.3877488375,
-0.3216145933,
-0.4254931211,
0.5773586631,
-0.8223140836,
0.6695572138,
0.4269253612,
0.2617083192,
-0.1450960189,
-1.0037510395,
-0.2217620462,
-0.587811172,
-0.1884358078,
0.0884920582,
-0.0409198254,
0.1962831914,
0.414891392,
1.0143435001,
-0.5556711555,
-0.1543285102,
0.0850076675,
-0.0529626273,
0.2905034721,
0.1946422607,
0.4856085181,
-0.2594391704,
-0.1556517333,
0.0450321436,
-0.7634449005,
0.1386303008,
0.3984289169,
0.4379950762,
-0.010633531,
0.8168000579,
-0.1492198557,
0.9336698651,
0.3159295321,
0.0789124966,
-0.3218393028,
-0.8016685247,
-0.4500361085,
0.1256528944,
0.3090434372,
-0.5605479479,
-0.1227114499,
-0.3085590005,
-0.2244787812,
-0.0119095743,
0.1820570678,
-0.6295737028,
-0.4218366742,
0.0668351501,
-0.261287123,
-0.1162035838,
0.0024751148,
-0.5914306641,
-0.1992495507,
-0.5789823532,
0.0728167072,
-0.5934058428,
-0.3541134298,
0.0449780412,
-0.0265432298,
0.0462114662,
0.1684709191,
-0.8468998075,
0.4473322034,
0.9883835912,
0.8150146008,
0.0733405277,
-0.2813543975,
-0.6173039079,
-0.0834265277,
-0.5045420527,
0.7172303796,
-0.9498685002,
-0.2541185617,
0.1829961985,
0.3885238469,
0.0408422947,
-0.6019441485,
0.5948149562,
-0.4304045737,
-0.0557588898,
-0.4659425318,
-0.7222585082,
-0.327337265,
0.2547138631,
-0.5132981539,
0.930672586,
0.5955711603,
-0.7164261341,
0.5074778795,
-0.4662517607,
-0.390966028,
0.2533243895,
-0.3146159351,
-0.2418942451,
0.4701320529,
-0.2095866352,
-0.0455790423,
-0.0289065037,
0.5460935235,
-0.1121643856,
0.1426108032,
-0.0637493208,
-0.6067667603,
1.0422850847,
-0.0154607501,
-0.1752710938,
0.4831151962,
-0.6993812323,
-0.0660606697,
-0.1343050748,
-0.3980067372,
-0.1455744058,
0.1463072449,
-0.4097263515,
0.1779517382,
0.210157901,
-0.5793063641,
0.256046474,
-0.3376337588,
0.5159259439,
0.7982750535,
0.0904846489,
0.2447321862,
-0.0027277886,
0.5013768673,
0.3052049279,
0.0874415711,
-0.651922226,
-0.4292713106,
-1.2837710381,
-0.353906095,
0.8339163065,
0.0772423297,
-0.7228230834,
0.7050471902,
-0.4267243445,
0.0252976026,
-0.3442218602,
-0.0056632557,
0.1548909843,
0.4175121188,
0.1241270527,
-0.7186517715,
-0.5131213665,
-0.9970303178,
0.0147147505,
-0.3935486376,
0.2207354754,
-0.4479050934,
0.3564150929,
0.0009055813,
0.9912792444,
-0.0329926461,
0.0441160947,
-0.2505286634,
0.0096359551,
0.2676649988,
0.5632511973,
0.2059007734,
-0.5259745121,
-0.6493100524,
0.278345108,
-0.7262629271,
-0.1553681791,
-0.2798820436,
0.0420565046,
0.0982005447,
0.422488898,
-0.5954347849,
0.6934050322,
0.3730419874,
-0.6438553333,
0.3046747744,
-0.0519957952,
-0.1602867097,
-0.8067305088,
-0.0384340435,
-0.0576418079,
-0.9645527005,
-0.5406641364,
0.5658965707,
0.1621116251,
-0.1917832643,
-0.0995383412,
0.1077954993,
-0.5661414862,
-0.5201807618,
-0.0586351417,
-0.6416837573,
0.0353909619,
0.3349377513,
0.22965312,
0.9408452511,
0.5794302225,
-0.6305810213,
0.1621554494,
-0.1339815259,
-0.2275317609,
0.4461778402,
-0.4455038607,
0.0846866444,
-0.2738443911,
0.1437668949,
-0.9181118608,
-0.3755871356,
0.146533072,
-0.2661325037,
0.4843586087,
-0.5658932924,
-0.7249132991,
-0.2247103602,
-0.4596691728,
0.5293173194,
0.3213845789,
-0.6337379217,
0.5283534527,
0.2432197928,
-0.2480275482,
0.0614251234,
-0.6601919532,
0.2472866029,
-0.1020215824,
-0.6038634777,
0.0587095171,
0.1285519898,
-0.0836833194,
0.177943036,
-0.073409155,
-0.1410671771,
-0.0481733866,
0.2837548256,
-0.2852402329,
-0.4751226008,
0.0298356283,
0.0324058495,
-0.1661749929,
-0.0364226885,
-0.3177247941,
0.8452634215,
-0.0615296438,
-0.7485390902,
-0.7404361963,
0.7689169645,
0.4726635516,
-0.1493940055,
0.3114706278,
-0.1557403505,
-0.2976328433,
0.1000124291,
-0.3533758819,
0.0788866654,
-0.4959419966,
0.3420123458,
-0.9325245023,
-0.6705513,
0.486364305,
0.1012477428,
0.0637256205,
0.5447571874,
0.5257623792,
0.4110027552,
1.0679115057,
0.8354620337,
0.0928036869,
0.2999235094,
-0.067299448,
0.1648549289,
-0.6361504793,
-0.1907206476,
-0.6236371398,
0.2067770213,
-0.4196484387,
-0.378723532,
0.0222516414,
0.3383781016,
-0.2999259233,
0.5455759168,
-0.6615868807,
0.5655278563,
0.4489150345,
-0.4402461946,
0.4341323078,
0.1768302172,
0.026898792,
-0.0651224107,
-0.6505751014,
-0.4398709238,
0.2737707198,
0.625103116,
0.4601961672,
0.2327412814,
0.558483541,
0.389254719,
0.425997436,
-1.3513888121,
0.6155954599,
-0.1368158013,
-0.34173733,
-0.0025972766,
-0.3603644669,
-0.971260488,
0.2847695053,
0.6086723208,
-0.4848517776,
0.5440829992,
-0.0797546953,
0.0715473145,
0.3637444377,
-0.5636425018,
1.0103284121,
-0.0191225968,
-0.0288628172,
0.1845040768,
-0.4271084964,
0.4583487809,
0.0196518656,
-0.2880249918,
0.1463555247,
-0.131113112,
0.3167315125,
-0.620503366,
0.7895508409,
-0.1421814561,
-0.1438391358,
0.584764719,
0.5220738053,
0.3944022357,
0.1064598858,
-0.1444353014,
0.2751440704,
0.1346483082,
-0.5444972515,
-0.2107212245,
0.7326530218,
-0.5730771422,
-0.7140377164,
-0.7503243685,
-0.1797024161,
-0.1954538226,
0.1229391396,
0.1573962569,
0.4472624362,
-0.1910051554,
0.0182459392,
0.2598640025,
0.1533052474,
0.7267791629,
0.3972851336,
-0.5241048336,
-0.3704856932,
0.9229222536,
0.2054816782,
0.299315393,
0.4627700746,
0.1746214479,
-0.4915224612,
-0.5269616246,
-0.717969656,
0.1666123122,
-0.9026814699,
-0.3728214204,
-0.6299991608,
-0.503616631,
-0.2748156786,
0.2837962508,
-0.3548223078,
-0.592166543,
-0.2355047166,
-0.1738395989,
0.0985377803,
1.063177228,
-0.0565485097,
0.0429721363,
-0.8350015283,
0.0350474045,
0.6535955071,
0.042620454,
0.100899294,
-0.5644214749,
0.0983082429,
-0.0211585946,
-0.4962120056,
-1.0361955166,
0.2311428189,
0.1681836098,
-0.1168910637,
0.4399938583,
-0.2500762343,
1.1321837902,
-0.6838585138,
1.0807592869,
0.3681203425,
-1.3521515131,
0.3994137347,
-0.1641304195,
0.2256334573,
0.7527078986,
0.0402952842,
-0.6365346313,
-0.3468294442,
-0.4920251071,
-0.5892906189,
0.7827240229,
0.254432857,
0.3303105235,
-0.1462127417,
0.2357896715,
0.5946893096,
-0.1198717803,
-0.8699099422,
0.1340894103,
-0.5599464178,
-0.0843086541,
0.4403249323,
-0.525018692,
0.0994954854,
-0.4451467097,
0.5337222219,
0.1230333224,
0.156736061,
0.2155997455,
0.0124301231,
-0.0610121526,
0.3617525697,
0.4425369501,
0.947719872,
-0.1479292363,
0.575297296,
-0.271389395,
-0.1618798822,
0.6084794402,
-0.2361692488,
-0.4313618839,
0.4828875959,
0.5476081371,
0.6775052547,
-0.4555573761,
-0.2529234886,
0.6197636724,
-0.0383707359,
0.2469120622,
-0.3825398684,
-0.3737094998,
0.0471440963,
-0.3524907529,
0.218439579,
0.0726932064,
0.1252706349,
-0.8552762866,
0.2525682747,
0.2693569958,
-0.6841550469,
-1.0811469555,
0.1473520696,
0.1083104461,
-0.2724552155,
0.5455814004,
-0.3844698966,
-0.3038764298,
0.6392486095,
0.7653993964,
1.2038089037,
-0.2831634581,
0.2143466473,
0.4596009254,
0.3085053265,
-0.0137767531,
0.2641268671,
-0.5022355318,
-0.2901873589,
-0.7660617828,
-0.7092216015,
-0.1626559794,
0.2582811713,
-0.6811490655,
0.2189331055,
-0.3357518315,
-0.1556927413,
0.1851160228,
-0.4583221972,
-0.2540224791,
0.0669174194,
-0.243903175,
1.0628877878,
-0.6511873603,
1.1820269823,
0.7413301468,
-0.5474365354,
-0.5709237456,
0.4891337752,
-0.387501806,
-0.6229038835,
0.7717798352,
0.2084221542,
0.0965765193,
0.0048149903,
-0.2893009186,
-0.6771845222,
0.5234653354,
0.578635931,
-0.4518658817,
0.0247678924,
0.5035352707,
0.3330530226,
-0.1458655745,
0.1585426629,
0.526242137,
0.5636666417,
0.2373910695,
-0.697126925,
0.0479425415,
-0.0271464959,
0.4214092195,
0.4498147666,
-0.4301629066,
1.0678706169,
0.5572751164,
-0.9283131957,
0.4058518708,
0.7795245051,
-0.133099243,
0.1216416433,
0.2750281692,
1.1123194695,
0.2933982909,
-0.0884581283,
1.2925678492,
-0.2417565286,
0.3324080706,
1.218367815,
-0.1967312247,
0.6846767664,
0.4944057763,
-0.5195413232,
0.3419442475,
0.9333743453,
0.436206758,
0.6118391752,
0.2336318344,
-0.7160149217,
-0.4334807694,
-0.4743059576,
-0.6271783113,
0.2513022125,
0.1494958848,
-0.3396198452,
-0.565983057,
-0.2589846849,
-0.0303620826,
0.0378624611,
-0.3314025998,
0.9555262327,
0.0379997082,
-0.9024499655,
0.6796439886,
0.3266496658,
0.2303582579,
-0.8182376623,
-0.3143454194,
-0.5486488342,
0.0584903471,
-0.3344186842,
-0.7485946417,
0.6431463361,
0.0875184014,
-0.1851999909,
-0.1663815677,
0.5230165124,
-0.4026383162,
-0.7094389796,
0.1924690902,
0.3486058116,
0.1313973516,
0.0089868736,
-0.4432945251,
0.2774704695,
0.1838368326,
0.1426163018,
0.3146541715,
0.8079183102,
-0.0766398758,
0.1626926214,
0.4180302918,
0.1052259728,
0.433994025,
0.0491866507,
1.0513671637,
-0.91423136,
-0.303599745,
-1.2480274439,
0.5673643351,
0.0102208816,
0.0949052945,
1.0167905092,
0.9460017085,
0.7768132091,
-0.1670515835,
0.5241094828,
-0.1985945702,
0.0121815782,
-0.5418598056,
-0.0448256619,
-0.4839875996,
0.1420843005,
0.3320735991,
-1.1317394972,
-0.2182565778,
0.3896034956,
-0.0133728255,
-0.2931097448,
0.6703220606,
0.6800321937,
-0.5175400972,
0.2490346581,
0.5570360422,
0.2255405039,
0.4063518643,
0.3712106049,
1.4014818668,
-0.1784942299,
-0.076688759,
-0.2715346515,
-0.1024383381,
0.2750888169,
-0.9063452482,
-0.6046354771,
-0.642457366,
-0.4163289368,
-0.3981027305,
-0.2963597476,
0.6659428477,
0.8016690612,
-1.0376670361,
-0.4902833402,
-0.9453194737,
0.2086825222,
0.0638279021,
-0.3367353976,
0.348135978,
-0.7556911707,
-0.6877881289,
0.482935816,
0.8370477557,
0.0361852497,
-0.4431907237,
0.1322052181,
-0.1513776779,
0.2613918483,
0.7327322364,
0.3972729445,
-0.8652656674,
-0.2382872254,
-0.4911755323,
0.0682139024,
0.6621041894,
1.250565052,
-0.689679563,
0.6795752048,
0.8220999241,
0.7204888463,
0.4044161737,
0.3740458488,
0.1874883622,
-1.0749131441,
0.2239139676,
0.5321942568,
0.3500537276,
0.5069810748,
-0.0186831001,
0.5127109289,
0.2755081058,
-0.2354597151,
-0.878420651,
0.63185215,
-0.7300416231,
-0.2142830938,
0.8435774446,
-0.3792319596,
-0.276535362,
-0.3476467133,
-0.2029843181,
0.0670763701,
-0.2873727381,
0.1325627714,
0.6990616918,
-0.2777790427,
-0.1950364858,
-0.1502416581,
0.513858974,
0.4102948308,
-0.8499108553,
0.311747551,
0.5465133786,
0.1067737564,
0.4987543225,
0.8626455665,
-0.4684834182,
-0.0932022035,
0.1319997162,
-0.2850984037,
0.0957079306,
-0.3862451613,
-0.6795221567,
0.48187989,
0.4449322522,
-0.1783073992
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02781v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02781v1
|
Dual Knowledge Distillation for Efficient Sound Event Detection
| 2024-02-05T07:30:32 | 2024-02-05T07:30:32 |
Yang Xiao, Rohan Kumar Das
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS
|
Sound event detection (SED) is essential for recognizing specific sounds and
their temporal locations within acoustic signals. This becomes challenging
particularly for on-device applications, where computational resources are
limited. To address this issue, we introduce a novel framework referred to as
dual knowledge distillation for developing efficient SED systems in this work.
Our proposed dual knowledge distillation commences with temporal-averaging
knowledge distillation (TAKD), utilizing a mean student model derived from the
temporal averaging of the student model's parameters. This allows the student
model to indirectly learn from a pre-trained teacher model, ensuring a stable
knowledge distillation. Subsequently, we introduce embedding-enhanced feature
distillation (EEFD), which involves incorporating an embedding distillation
layer within the student model to bolster contextual learning. On DCASE 2023
Task 4A public evaluation dataset, our proposed SED system with dual knowledge
distillation having merely one-third of the baseline model's parameters,
demonstrates superior performance in terms of PSDS1 and PSDS2. This highlights
the importance of proposed dual knowledge distillation for compact SED systems,
which can be ideal for edge devices.
|
[
-0.3639831841,
-0.6362989545,
0.9053821564,
0.0059232325,
-0.5462130904,
0.0837178677,
-0.1679724157,
-0.351475507,
0.0577804074,
-0.0890421346,
-0.4466667771,
-0.4381650686,
-0.5417538285,
-0.477053225,
-0.3221016824,
0.741720736,
0.0769632682,
0.041632887,
-0.0194679853,
-0.1821308434,
-0.2745476365,
-0.5066414475,
-0.9100029469,
-0.426087141,
0.1598470509,
0.133517772,
0.0498819239,
0.3261889815,
0.25687778,
0.150657475,
-0.3466369212,
0.0619478747,
0.0347523876,
0.2671098411,
0.0206841733,
-0.0894501284,
-0.2344802469,
-0.0755792037,
0.2218201756,
0.6302304268,
-0.4037595093,
0.2269384414,
0.3003073335,
0.3456234932,
-0.6087486148,
0.0558551066,
-0.4421427548,
0.4335221648,
-0.174119398,
-0.3652741313,
-0.060715083,
-0.1026124731,
0.3497061431,
-0.6887764931,
0.12144126,
-0.6516652107,
0.2773814499,
0.6347394586,
-0.5811718702,
-0.3664484918,
-0.898786068,
0.4067049921,
-0.4844380319,
0.7081568241,
0.1955260187,
0.5951800346,
0.1011359915,
-0.9951606989,
-0.6290070415,
0.3296778202,
0.378549993,
0.2074682862,
-0.03555144,
0.1328830868,
0.3383311629,
0.2027214915,
-0.4244991541,
0.0264687352,
-0.1511615813,
-0.1785139292,
0.4487332702,
-0.2036667317,
0.1362488568,
0.051952146,
-0.5531431437,
-0.2015757114,
-0.3080261052,
0.0384598821,
0.4116370082,
0.1581595093,
-0.1426099986,
-0.0572544895,
-0.0892994329,
0.2289173454,
0.2455235124,
-0.5341837406,
0.2166147977,
-0.5045016408,
0.0197569188,
0.6178949475,
0.4020649493,
0.1559606642,
-0.2626053095,
0.082436122,
-0.3602640927,
0.1608750075,
-0.2143549323,
-0.8188479543,
-0.5099489093,
0.2111083418,
-0.3765594959,
-0.2480862588,
-0.0723638609,
-0.7139848471,
-0.5785175562,
-0.4868305326,
0.765516758,
-0.2975038886,
-0.7260398269,
0.2684236169,
-0.8307407498,
-0.1461029649,
0.1006934792,
-0.7386263013,
0.2676272094,
0.6515080929,
0.924262464,
0.0171602536,
0.0652329177,
-0.5213114619,
0.4467658699,
0.0497003794,
0.6888965964,
-0.341173768,
-0.8230782747,
-0.4512452185,
-0.4747821391,
0.1166863218,
-0.6205037832,
0.7673214674,
-0.2271658778,
-0.2008270472,
-0.3265519142,
-0.4454306662,
-0.0853245258,
-0.4686605632,
-0.4587911665,
0.979210794,
-0.2178502679,
-0.6910578012,
0.9917160273,
-0.7282084227,
-0.5738577247,
-0.0674989074,
-0.2820335329,
-0.4863057733,
0.3365691304,
0.4233666956,
0.3198616207,
-0.0413330793,
0.6395147443,
-0.4619113505,
-0.2750676274,
-0.1812771112,
-0.7383797169,
0.7249207497,
0.504832685,
-0.4829638302,
-0.3651395738,
-0.7489365935,
-0.3053306043,
-0.0714557171,
-0.3174477816,
-0.7145223618,
0.1590172797,
0.194331646,
0.0909572989,
0.1916086376,
-0.7685312033,
-0.0813034996,
0.2495479137,
0.4662350416,
0.7231171131,
0.3220316172,
0.2360533178,
-0.1284104437,
0.0982377455,
0.381159693,
-0.0159892663,
-0.1045608297,
-0.2454459369,
-0.2055232227,
-0.3753306568,
0.1189385056,
0.3587704301,
-0.4336797595,
0.4257060885,
0.155976966,
-0.2461331338,
-0.2273817509,
0.0451722033,
0.2356541902,
0.5566811562,
0.3757809103,
0.0620803982,
-0.8635321259,
-0.5443869829,
-0.1957717389,
-0.3323400915,
-0.2417896837,
0.2398519367,
0.1048707962,
0.0997613817,
0.869189918,
-0.804430604,
-0.5701798797,
0.0519063063,
0.3718132079,
0.2242066413,
0.3522286415,
0.798017025,
-0.8911781311,
-0.2426659763,
0.119020246,
-0.7291024327,
-0.4908407927,
-0.109985292,
0.2880440354,
0.0355517231,
0.5879270434,
-0.0574433878,
0.4072310627,
0.3178299963,
-0.5592899323,
0.3078870475,
-0.1449657977,
0.3199972212,
-1.0512875319,
-0.0401042439,
0.1882619113,
-0.087471582,
-0.5956184864,
-0.419011265,
0.0683980808,
-0.1931360215,
-0.3856621981,
0.232895419,
-0.2870536745,
-0.2351363301,
-0.4067439139,
0.1784404218,
0.3121427894,
0.329264909,
0.4800441861,
0.4049083889,
0.4478443861,
-0.4931949973,
0.396065712,
-0.2368785143,
-0.3257290125,
0.8503019214,
-0.6246695518,
0.1811147928,
0.1832781881,
0.1337222159,
-0.8183487654,
0.1437551528,
-0.4543496072,
-0.2912853956,
0.415913552,
-0.5291220546,
-0.2873207629,
-0.5013903975,
-0.0831442103,
0.4970822036,
0.6118780375,
-1.1531316042,
0.531314373,
0.8338391185,
-0.1954885423,
-0.1270419359,
-0.625764966,
-0.237698406,
-0.6434748173,
-0.7786754966,
0.3552446067,
0.0519291349,
-0.2234373391,
0.0715405494,
-0.7018454075,
-0.2969372869,
0.2993659973,
0.2335411757,
-0.0357176363,
-0.2984513044,
0.2728764415,
0.4925073385,
-0.1133685857,
-0.0522994064,
-0.7385128736,
0.1676647365,
0.272564739,
-0.6518522501,
-0.7837638855,
0.2273879945,
0.645128727,
0.1253804266,
0.1821645945,
0.7575407028,
-0.5726918578,
-0.3943801522,
-0.7366756201,
-0.498452127,
-0.5041843653,
0.37598598,
-0.7173201442,
-0.6153336167,
0.7067605853,
-0.3228652775,
0.0119344173,
0.2037359774,
0.1910107881,
-0.3150335848,
0.9433172345,
0.2256746441,
0.0454216339,
0.4896736443,
-0.2153380811,
-0.0616048686,
-0.9153594971,
-0.3070135713,
-0.543187201,
-0.6140045524,
0.1893249601,
-0.290264219,
0.7719122171,
0.1636224091,
0.0025532439,
0.1231384277,
-0.5742264986,
0.4480790198,
0.6237564683,
0.2689302266,
0.4251258969,
-0.0839384794,
-0.2285970896,
-0.0930493996,
-0.4239076674,
-0.1077689007,
1.1938089132,
0.340128094,
0.5668686032,
-0.0293976199,
1.0903909206,
0.3727131486,
-0.7880588174,
-0.3657692671,
0.2170436233,
-0.1703744084,
-0.4785291851,
-0.4927150905,
-0.2147888988,
-0.4173378944,
0.5018965602,
0.1106215045,
-0.5902374983,
0.6825680733,
0.017096879,
-0.6934013367,
0.62208426,
-0.9791084528,
0.6191724539,
-0.2423850298,
-0.2364348471,
-0.5239974856,
-0.0514895804,
0.2506692708,
-0.3604088724,
0.2485761493,
-0.230671078,
0.1893698722,
1.1327475309,
-0.4566666484,
0.6632778049,
-1.0128706694,
-0.1141244322,
0.587059617,
-0.0797041953,
0.4545415044,
0.5206114054,
-0.0834110305,
0.0070438189,
0.412753135,
0.0387384482,
-0.4915343225,
0.8071550727,
-0.7872504592,
-0.6256270409,
-0.2068901658,
-0.3486602604,
-0.0892938897,
-0.0417825095,
0.0034601844,
0.7775930762,
-0.2673813403,
0.2738490105,
0.7880730629,
0.0045982176,
0.7867661119,
0.6818699837,
0.0131691294,
-0.0813980103,
0.7314753532,
0.3482561409,
-0.0559579805,
0.1777628064,
0.2949363589,
-0.5218964815,
-0.6991614103,
-0.4043684602,
-0.256821543,
-0.468175441,
-0.1025659442,
-0.9067643285,
0.0203172732,
-0.570845902,
-0.1065790355,
-0.7008199692,
-0.6991001964,
-0.5782094598,
-0.3732471764,
0.3667193353,
0.5106322765,
-0.6806647182,
-0.023864761,
-0.5566003919,
0.7581742406,
0.6137283444,
0.1175890192,
-0.2862208188,
-0.7175412178,
-0.0687558353,
0.2273859829,
-0.3600233495,
-0.8220322132,
0.0770768449,
0.5295327306,
0.8048322797,
0.8012320399,
0.5346868634,
0.6740567088,
-0.1199466288,
0.6111546159,
0.2751346827,
-0.9785370231,
0.9405687451,
-0.1061641648,
0.3533922136,
0.5539764762,
0.0290938187,
-0.5280228257,
-0.1144178212,
-0.412810415,
-0.7641808391,
0.8528636098,
-0.2769355178,
-0.2646820247,
0.2121620327,
0.0506378897,
0.2786674798,
0.0066631911,
-0.2461585402,
-0.1108702645,
-0.2436380386,
-0.1774215102,
0.1251747608,
-0.2681885064,
-0.1784184873,
-0.2397462577,
0.5519553423,
0.0818882212,
-0.0100036655,
0.1913123876,
-0.1179033369,
0.0961674675,
0.2061188072,
0.3464180827,
0.4295843542,
-0.2235519141,
0.3499739766,
0.3813120425,
-0.7111180425,
0.3403069377,
0.1360781193,
0.0364647247,
0.0588596314,
-0.0223442167,
0.7344812155,
0.4609342515,
-0.2262275517,
0.580558002,
-0.0434785262,
-0.2592201233,
-0.3832687736,
0.0528338738,
0.3534403443,
0.6954386234,
0.7583620548,
-0.0879642144,
0.5711522102,
-0.4757093787,
0.539531827,
0.1756578684,
-0.4404997826,
-0.4155553281,
0.827021122,
0.4811968803,
0.1049037948,
0.4223377407,
-0.2526321411,
-0.394094646,
0.8945849538,
0.4881586432,
1.1107814312,
-0.4465300143,
0.0401340947,
0.2642431855,
-0.0881982371,
0.1635609716,
0.4743930697,
-0.6644192338,
-0.5302804112,
0.0084565496,
-0.9192739129,
-0.2415650487,
0.0686689541,
-0.7806250453,
0.4136891365,
-0.3989472687,
-0.4151519537,
0.1054139584,
0.0516125187,
-0.5069981813,
-0.1023662761,
0.4206968248,
0.6530823708,
-1.0620070696,
0.9731386304,
0.5945612192,
0.0197390709,
-0.7931882143,
-0.1475055516,
0.5340600014,
-0.2621717751,
0.6042663455,
-0.2348534763,
-0.0402561165,
-0.0126925111,
0.3899709284,
-0.4191766083,
1.4537621737,
0.3581127822,
-0.9077711701,
0.1053134724,
-0.1658670306,
0.2596467435,
-0.1223447248,
0.2172619998,
0.7792451978,
0.6134522557,
0.5037019849,
-1.1383863688,
-0.3115414679,
-0.0918638259,
-0.1924398988,
0.2965346277,
-0.2345456183,
0.3310385644,
-0.4519527555,
-0.5415354967,
-0.6273751855,
0.6460635662,
0.2707615197,
1.035184741,
0.5814326406,
0.8422708511,
0.9726444483,
-0.4427173138,
0.4055453241,
-0.1778952479,
0.1565993875,
1.2212044001,
-0.2856037915,
0.5787116885,
0.5529245734,
-0.4886681139,
0.1754208803,
0.549541235,
0.2878215909,
1.0861759186,
-0.0320342891,
-0.7866867185,
-0.1628712267,
-0.0627489612,
-0.7709707618,
0.4670556188,
0.3699839115,
0.050018467,
-0.1649779379,
0.6059616804,
-0.3514501154,
-0.0860501379,
-0.2562596202,
1.1442267895,
0.2024326473,
-0.2068047971,
-0.0200092141,
-0.331066221,
0.7904929519,
-0.3080017269,
0.003290832,
-0.1361356229,
0.2217443287,
-0.1679735631,
-0.7211875916,
0.4709687829,
-0.1734753847,
-0.3110918403,
-0.1895034909,
0.7693442702,
-0.494012773,
-0.2148342282,
0.5365591049,
0.2294470221,
-0.0552905463,
-0.1881192029,
-0.109994024,
0.3537599742,
-0.0686282516,
-0.1457199305,
0.3194012642,
0.7418103814,
0.3133177161,
0.2305686623,
0.546243012,
0.1268101484,
0.1534641236,
0.2716675401,
0.7312556505,
-0.2469951212,
-0.964687109,
-0.6122820973,
0.3361884654,
-0.123453863,
-0.0192556474,
0.3951400518,
0.6439115405,
0.8537980318,
0.0345948562,
0.9676476121,
0.066706866,
0.5910757184,
-0.4507501423,
0.7483330965,
-0.4514220357,
0.6667460203,
-0.3036828339,
-0.7344946265,
0.101831235,
0.3024634421,
-0.094275035,
-0.0856409147,
0.5198298693,
0.4877368212,
-0.3863011003,
0.630002737,
0.5188285112,
-0.0091127204,
0.3237867355,
0.7775111198,
0.7888281941,
-0.2269358635,
0.3892936409,
-0.5411452651,
-0.2508316338,
-0.2054867446,
-0.6667820215,
-0.5983217359,
-0.9655765891,
-0.7878832221,
0.1950538754,
0.3543669581,
0.6616843939,
0.8106198907,
-0.8194022775,
-0.1213569492,
0.0203481242,
0.2121351957,
-0.2587062716,
-0.2007261217,
0.4866808951,
-0.0984271169,
-0.7422540188,
0.9071667194,
0.405729413,
0.1191771775,
0.1347104013,
-0.1336926967,
-0.1136292368,
-0.161711812,
0.3693177402,
0.2076819688,
-0.3571190536,
-0.5372347832,
-0.3876608312,
0.0711070523,
-0.2746351361,
0.8452401757,
-0.9161375761,
0.6449808478,
0.7176161408,
0.2716330588,
0.8545517921,
-0.2762077451,
0.4460663199,
-0.7975075841,
0.4048548937,
0.1551988274,
0.3896237612,
-0.1034526676,
-0.3635757267,
0.4592136443,
0.4835125208,
-0.4906528592,
-1.0308766365,
0.0146986861,
-0.8524207473,
-0.4470485151,
0.8946541548,
-0.2332925946,
0.262257427,
-0.4499170482,
-0.0430925712,
0.5499812365,
-0.4972807467,
0.54351753,
0.2828112245,
-0.1996920109,
-0.0104131326,
-0.2007511705,
0.536657393,
-0.1050980911,
-0.3270217776,
-0.1427211761,
0.561027348,
0.2482509464,
0.127047956,
0.595815599,
-0.2165748328,
0.6486715674,
0.4585733414,
0.0417782292,
-0.6060140729,
-0.6059063077,
-0.2248497307,
0.3528424501,
-0.1825256348,
-0.3835225403
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02764v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02764v1
|
List-aware Reranking-Truncation Joint Model for Search and Retrieval-augmented Generation
| 2024-02-05T06:52:53 | 2024-02-05T06:52:53 |
Shicheng Xu, Liang Pang, Jun Xu, Huawei Shen, Xueqi Cheng
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The results of information retrieval (IR) are usually presented in the form
of a ranked list of candidate documents, such as web search for humans and
retrieval-augmented generation for large language models (LLMs). List-aware
retrieval aims to capture the list-level contextual features to return a better
list, mainly including reranking and truncation. Reranking finely re-scores the
documents in the list. Truncation dynamically determines the cut-off point of
the ranked list to achieve the trade-off between overall relevance and avoiding
misinformation from irrelevant documents. Previous studies treat them as two
separate tasks and model them separately. However, the separation is not
optimal. First, it is hard to share the contextual information of the ranking
list between the two tasks. Second, the separate pipeline usually meets the
error accumulation problem, where the small error from the reranking stage can
largely affect the truncation stage. To solve these problems, we propose a
Reranking-Truncation joint model (GenRT) that can perform the two tasks
concurrently. GenRT integrates reranking and truncation via generative paradigm
based on encoder-decoder architecture. We also design the novel loss functions
for joint optimization to make the model learn both tasks. Sharing parameters
by the joint model is conducive to making full use of the common modeling
information of the two tasks. Besides, the two tasks are performed concurrently
and co-optimized to solve the error accumulation problem between separate
stages. Experiments on public learning-to-rank benchmarks and open-domain Q\&A
tasks show that our method achieves SOTA performance on both reranking and
truncation tasks for web search and retrieval-augmented LLMs.
|
[
-0.4283213615,
-0.8202808499,
0.2011343688,
-0.0105134826,
-0.2433494031,
0.4088689089,
-0.2612255216,
-0.5342543125,
0.3181957603,
0.4145700037,
-0.5496866703,
-0.3343366981,
-0.5476964712,
-0.0153017668,
-0.4941087365,
0.9209940434,
0.0003851176,
-0.3940364122,
-0.5423260331,
-0.0347744972,
-0.6027359366,
-0.4906101823,
-0.5663613677,
-0.1043281779,
0.4297600389,
0.606633544,
0.6875007153,
0.6039655805,
0.6986721754,
0.1908617616,
-0.1042549759,
0.383682698,
-0.7908383012,
0.5240386724,
-0.1111248583,
-0.3147643805,
-0.4460018277,
0.0594801717,
0.8651956916,
0.6534485817,
-0.2685950398,
0.4331249595,
0.3791318536,
0.6199902892,
-0.8061323762,
-0.1861307472,
-0.4614113867,
-0.0287146792,
-0.2689963281,
-0.4165414572,
-0.4287455976,
-0.3592636287,
0.1464823633,
-0.7013429403,
0.3472634256,
0.0484916493,
0.9197248816,
0.2022738606,
-0.241291821,
0.1623711288,
-0.8597111702,
0.6033223867,
-0.378090173,
0.6784731746,
0.3435709178,
0.1152535304,
-0.0770696849,
-0.6738938689,
-0.2533225119,
-0.0818953812,
0.049520541,
0.1658533514,
0.1259201467,
-0.0873366371,
0.2814383507,
0.35731861,
-0.6652774811,
-0.0625582859,
-0.3784071803,
0.0332130864,
0.4519154131,
-0.1925751865,
0.3355165124,
-0.1960903853,
-0.4881093204,
-0.2142176628,
-0.8877721429,
-0.0184166823,
0.2624794245,
0.3068159819,
0.1737821549,
0.543900013,
-0.2096452415,
0.5791842937,
0.0394283719,
-0.0170283206,
0.0280826036,
-0.1851930618,
-0.1600694358,
-0.1562696099,
0.5062574744,
0.3057421446,
0.0482648648,
-0.338210851,
-0.2588057518,
-0.0800477043,
0.2760177851,
-0.5469297767,
-0.0228829756,
0.0032205626,
-0.4288466573,
-0.2488337755,
0.0851899013,
-0.7041370273,
-0.008430711,
-0.0139656467,
0.8850613832,
-0.29006356,
-0.2517967224,
-0.1114814952,
-0.1030393243,
-0.1769589782,
0.1348731816,
-0.5941933393,
0.348362267,
0.6327514052,
0.703055203,
-0.0694424435,
-0.2397796065,
-0.8207108378,
0.4626397192,
-0.0444702543,
0.6151806712,
-0.7209941745,
-0.4441721737,
-0.0499380678,
-0.3336618543,
-0.2567865252,
-0.5643798113,
0.4021078646,
-0.8423581123,
0.2795781493,
-0.1759646982,
-0.6959468722,
-0.1719311178,
0.3907057345,
-0.8670520186,
1.0575042963,
0.1256742328,
-0.8138148189,
0.4468196332,
-0.5957406163,
-0.3314082325,
0.2296087891,
0.0312518962,
-0.6321306229,
-0.1309835911,
0.1019121706,
0.1998221129,
-0.3931039572,
0.3005110919,
-0.0617126748,
-0.5714559555,
-0.210797295,
-0.236011371,
0.4132032096,
0.1977828443,
-0.1757706702,
0.091255486,
-0.4248213768,
0.1489712447,
0.1338961422,
-0.685225904,
-0.4830439687,
0.0043706698,
-0.1058307961,
0.1387804002,
0.3660380542,
-0.3603247106,
0.4672171772,
-0.3242155015,
0.2179411054,
0.4819910824,
0.2108834982,
0.3738912344,
-0.5047029257,
0.6175763011,
-0.1946427077,
0.302182436,
0.3439083099,
-0.2749140561,
-0.8025271297,
-0.0656384304,
0.7019485831,
0.5292461514,
-0.7476719022,
0.3826434612,
-0.5289633274,
-0.4317855537,
-0.5994073153,
0.0789438188,
0.4849756956,
0.1485086977,
0.2389762998,
-0.3729328811,
-0.6942324042,
-0.5734544396,
-0.4069056511,
-0.0167371389,
0.2212906033,
0.0557289459,
0.1997840852,
-0.0116434414,
0.7733802199,
-0.3024949431,
-0.3514235616,
-0.4596543908,
0.1861921996,
-0.062046878,
0.5247687101,
0.013077626,
-1.0419589281,
-0.4341385067,
-0.2540290952,
-0.6351810694,
0.2005776167,
0.1099385992,
-0.1931216717,
0.1015511379,
0.3060861528,
-0.5739223361,
0.5399881005,
0.2300333679,
-0.094377175,
0.4056500196,
-0.2988237441,
0.3495755792,
-0.943744123,
0.2092835009,
-0.1345188022,
-0.527984798,
-0.6572955251,
0.4200649559,
-0.0669903308,
-0.0927021354,
-0.2151700705,
0.2093589306,
-0.5144102573,
-0.3119725287,
-0.1185265854,
0.36289379,
0.2622878253,
0.3891104758,
-0.0717044324,
0.760548234,
0.1379127502,
-0.7345097065,
-0.0870894864,
0.3511345685,
-0.2652569711,
-0.1250505745,
-0.3732668757,
0.0262242686,
-0.0849560052,
0.0668912232,
-0.6294703484,
0.0589176044,
0.2540386915,
-0.4131023288,
0.4197225869,
-0.1636915356,
-0.5628548861,
-0.3780736327,
-0.3749736249,
0.7632392049,
0.2391974926,
-0.4960310459,
0.2869242132,
0.491117835,
-0.1293859333,
-0.7862138152,
-0.2511388958,
-0.1222158372,
-0.1604349166,
-0.5542717576,
0.6460381746,
-0.0064133848,
0.0583824627,
0.1450574994,
-0.159542799,
0.113712281,
-0.0252924096,
0.1831412166,
0.2950719297,
0.2711592019,
0.2626515925,
-0.0663780794,
0.0024846748,
-0.3109013438,
-0.127635777,
0.6582815051,
0.1110465676,
-0.358745873,
-0.2019373327,
0.5553632975,
0.4655350149,
-0.566323936,
0.7861948013,
0.478141278,
-0.3967630565,
0.0096427072,
-0.7014625072,
-0.2062448412,
-0.4275658131,
0.2458601594,
-0.6220738292,
-1.0300602913,
0.4855630696,
-0.0756166801,
0.2153811455,
0.4825412035,
0.2802639306,
-0.0629406348,
0.9492480755,
0.7126622796,
0.0542347208,
0.5849649906,
-0.6636065841,
0.3524046838,
-0.9198616147,
-0.2173243463,
-0.3816840649,
-0.5234075189,
-0.730792284,
-0.4282923937,
0.4379557371,
0.3642472625,
-0.1834805906,
0.1204508245,
-0.7529374957,
0.3307484984,
0.9067978263,
0.2863729596,
0.2979656756,
0.2776532769,
-0.2617723942,
-0.0180467181,
-0.8354071975,
-0.1549205631,
1.1230937243,
0.0527818501,
0.5394481421,
0.3160749376,
0.9076939225,
0.4536293745,
-0.0064061549,
-0.5111939311,
0.6381328702,
-0.3463703096,
-0.4824379981,
-0.4092960954,
-0.5328427553,
-0.8990211487,
0.2052649409,
-0.2388375998,
-0.6110643148,
0.2245950103,
0.0084037902,
-0.3438057601,
0.5131183863,
-0.4266169667,
0.7350720167,
0.1904322505,
-0.5585154295,
-0.4535631835,
-0.7036175728,
0.4657687545,
0.2543461323,
0.1059513763,
0.0978557691,
0.139980495,
1.1319041252,
-0.3357214332,
0.4363153577,
-0.2586396933,
0.2833647728,
0.328684479,
0.2712365687,
0.7361490726,
-0.1233656183,
-0.0298229884,
-0.2252706885,
0.0129330372,
-0.1776278466,
-0.6268514395,
0.6077457666,
-0.8465152979,
-0.8874619007,
-0.3655128777,
-0.5514873266,
-0.0345291309,
0.1956503093,
0.3279490769,
0.4171210527,
-0.0673372075,
0.0526882,
0.6148375869,
-0.083448641,
0.2174998522,
0.3688247502,
-0.255556345,
-0.1815107018,
1.1029962301,
0.3453041613,
0.354734838,
0.7655719519,
-0.0092409458,
-0.3041954041,
-0.435146153,
-0.0492848195,
0.3143278062,
-0.5286886096,
-0.285009414,
-0.5081740618,
-0.6000356078,
-0.5126982927,
0.1095766276,
-0.2702158689,
-0.6874924898,
-0.015035552,
-0.0994534045,
0.1634807587,
0.6803307533,
-0.2929793,
0.0600070469,
-0.8023804426,
0.3822398484,
0.2055847347,
0.4166074395,
0.2029283494,
-0.3727074564,
-0.3934645653,
-0.0352091938,
-0.3770314157,
-0.740200758,
0.4880675375,
0.2223268747,
0.538017571,
0.2535156608,
0.2030194998,
0.8853067756,
-0.2499066889,
0.4378341734,
0.012788618,
-0.7413229346,
0.6966747046,
-0.151232779,
0.0435307287,
0.6087562442,
0.159267351,
-0.6618035436,
-0.5552509427,
-0.5710466504,
-1.0534032583,
0.6646512747,
0.2044350952,
-0.4828857183,
-0.0133908847,
0.411688596,
0.1500532776,
0.1076190397,
-0.6943664551,
-0.2139018923,
0.057078097,
-0.0688655823,
0.1538745165,
-0.6884100437,
-0.104836829,
-0.1985885501,
0.8201372027,
0.3470775485,
0.3966226578,
0.239607051,
-0.4130973518,
-0.4021505117,
0.4333483279,
0.4925370216,
0.5878872871,
-0.5650725961,
0.0729319975,
-0.1866298914,
-0.4562250376,
0.3375705183,
0.1276456416,
-0.341144532,
-0.0649957135,
0.124760814,
0.5904877186,
0.2422930002,
-0.555090487,
0.3612430394,
-0.0908433422,
-0.2127433866,
-0.1461715251,
0.0042975456,
-0.0460889824,
0.1848604232,
0.469183445,
0.1066552624,
0.2592226863,
-0.2799524069,
0.4824881852,
0.4855122268,
-0.0919671804,
-0.0338018984,
0.7213411927,
0.3088486791,
-0.3145140707,
0.7137894034,
-0.2594765723,
-0.5773154497,
0.3402020037,
0.482391119,
0.6800097823,
-0.2501907647,
0.2068444341,
0.3774614632,
0.1615797281,
-0.1640314162,
0.2831904888,
-0.1452602595,
-0.5868255496,
-0.4782702923,
-0.5234324336,
-0.2846587002,
0.0177861117,
-0.8829374313,
0.0751182884,
-0.2666683495,
-0.2746854126,
-0.333529979,
0.4176795483,
-0.7090350986,
0.145685181,
-0.1731841415,
0.6652584672,
-0.5035680532,
0.7070785165,
0.5497077107,
-0.5573241711,
-0.8331680894,
0.1475620419,
-0.3238565326,
-0.5797838569,
0.7739703059,
0.2083172351,
-0.0689712912,
0.3359796107,
0.0091565615,
-1.0984449387,
1.1766399145,
0.2859109342,
-0.8183201551,
-0.3461627662,
-0.0337740555,
-0.006129608,
-0.2640949786,
0.2027103901,
0.3313343525,
0.4109376371,
0.0384990871,
-0.9619228244,
0.1594840735,
-0.2085069567,
-0.0528428033,
0.4246201515,
-0.7823603153,
0.7011966109,
-0.205853194,
-0.516759038,
0.0827924088,
0.5460719466,
0.4117799103,
0.2693415582,
0.7407462001,
0.833966136,
0.6780620217,
0.075131543,
0.8936514258,
-0.3056056201,
0.4017647207,
1.0955287218,
-0.1855568737,
1.1174615622,
0.3299050927,
-0.1194372103,
0.4039298594,
0.7237804532,
0.245149523,
0.6241886616,
0.0465997942,
-0.4374159873,
-0.4142638147,
-0.2007368356,
-0.4811881185,
0.4136604965,
0.3457678258,
-0.282313019,
-0.2464278638,
0.1297434419,
-0.2502555549,
0.0440886281,
-0.1308014393,
0.7123215199,
-0.1955332309,
-0.7331533432,
0.5654660463,
0.1296816915,
0.5606567264,
-0.2761356533,
-0.1268805265,
-0.1220150888,
-0.0034049463,
-0.0471220948,
-0.5429704189,
0.1537192911,
-0.084233582,
-0.5557677746,
-0.259216249,
0.8383490443,
-0.6431604624,
-0.5083463788,
0.3849678636,
0.7607818842,
0.2160638869,
0.0624682046,
-0.53675282,
0.1961123943,
0.0916330591,
-0.2351651043,
0.4281718433,
0.0545353629,
-0.2237474471,
0.908090651,
0.5259382725,
0.1907001138,
0.1210158989,
0.4236012697,
0.8454383016,
-0.6144424081,
-0.6025156379,
-0.5066816211,
0.2468464375,
-0.037740238,
0.3134374022,
0.3971013427,
0.6548059583,
0.7146639228,
0.2402366549,
0.7147018909,
-0.1021610871,
0.9182751775,
-0.2952821255,
0.7656302452,
-0.8409057856,
0.4798852503,
-0.0535617135,
-0.9655862451,
-0.2989969254,
0.340890944,
-0.1768194884,
0.2238709778,
0.4450027347,
0.6436821222,
0.1161208004,
-0.3130580783,
0.3843978941,
0.0036668556,
0.3336544335,
0.6586146951,
0.6387093067,
-0.6154583097,
0.8641639948,
-0.2342696637,
0.0118614258,
-0.5006690025,
-0.3003196418,
-0.4485475719,
-0.578620851,
-0.4184576571,
-0.193415314,
0.5245862007,
0.6885479093,
0.6779296994,
-0.4070392251,
-0.1397629529,
-0.0213300977,
0.4474767745,
-0.5364685655,
-0.3182269931,
0.5371332765,
-0.1880610138,
-0.6713715196,
0.3216550648,
0.2245262265,
-0.1313433349,
-0.1730306298,
-0.0969480425,
-0.6765597463,
-0.3323820531,
0.4003435671,
0.2874388993,
-0.7573968172,
-0.4476062655,
-0.1888579577,
-0.0763502494,
-0.0064912504,
0.7297945023,
-1.0783439875,
0.5637649894,
0.5342559218,
0.4707792699,
0.4713042974,
0.3394678235,
0.6744658947,
-1.119838357,
0.006522452,
0.134773463,
0.0896475017,
0.3639348149,
-0.5696733594,
0.5668961406,
0.2156123668,
-0.6400798559,
-0.91284132,
0.0675682649,
-0.887517333,
-0.1575805247,
0.783075273,
-0.0679764599,
-0.0341293961,
0.0514654741,
0.2346070409,
0.7222972512,
-0.3482178748,
0.6887399554,
0.418849051,
-0.0089174053,
-0.5427548289,
-0.438760519,
0.4713186324,
0.4485089481,
-0.4533410966,
0.0020628774,
0.2203623205,
0.2627812326,
0.1419018805,
0.525368154,
0.1563722491,
0.396260649,
-0.1474766135,
0.2254512459,
-0.2293565571,
-0.3963312209,
0.1888852566,
0.4943420589,
0.3591322601,
-0.5340655446
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06147v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06147v2
|
DeAL: Decoding-time Alignment for Large Language Models
| 2024-02-05T06:12:29 | 2024-02-21T02:25:32 |
James Y. Huang, Sailik Sengupta, Daniele Bonadiman, Yi-an Lai, Arshit Gupta, Nikolaos Pappas, Saab Mansour, Katrin Kirchhoff, Dan Roth
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are nowadays expected to generate content
aligned with human preferences. Current work focuses on alignment at model
training time, through techniques such as Reinforcement Learning with Human
Feedback (RLHF). However, it is unclear if such methods are an effective choice
to teach alignment objectives to the model. First, the inability to incorporate
multiple, custom rewards and reliance on a model developer's view of universal
and static principles are key limitations. Second, the residual gaps in model
training and the reliability of such approaches are also questionable (e.g.
susceptibility to jail-breaking even after safety training). To address these,
we propose DeAL, a framework that allows the user to customize reward functions
and enables Decoding-time Alignment of LLMs (DeAL). At its core, we view
decoding as a heuristic-guided search process and facilitate the use of a wide
variety of alignment objectives. Our experiments with programmatic constraints
such as keyword and length constraints (studied widely in the pre-LLM era) and
abstract objectives such as harmlessness and helpfulness (proposed in the
post-LLM era) show that we can DeAL with fine-grained trade-offs, improve
adherence to alignment objectives, and address residual gaps in LLMs. Lastly,
while DeAL can be effectively paired with RLHF and prompting techniques, its
generality makes decoding slower, an optimization we leave for future work.
|
[
-0.0024454517,
-0.3735646009,
0.6266686916,
0.2446310818,
-0.3026669919,
0.2747795582,
-0.5307549238,
-0.3343851566,
0.1913800985,
0.3563358486,
-0.578758955,
-0.5234098434,
-0.5687597394,
-0.1056418568,
-0.2602891028,
0.8808868527,
-0.209575817,
-0.0840197355,
0.0094393725,
-0.0318200998,
-0.4450403154,
-0.5639971495,
-0.6328341961,
-0.5417833328,
0.7791862488,
0.3585864007,
0.8681647778,
1.1621562243,
0.537101686,
0.2080310732,
-0.1419064403,
0.1329262555,
-0.5852789879,
0.0052628871,
-0.2926103771,
-0.3334419131,
-0.3847510517,
-0.0721973181,
0.4805194736,
0.6751825213,
-0.6006022096,
-0.1145010665,
-0.0437873714,
0.5334409475,
-0.8018445969,
0.2028044909,
-0.5313411355,
0.1868457049,
-0.0562040582,
-0.4063132703,
-0.6215026379,
-0.2451426238,
-0.0726522058,
-0.7268919945,
-0.1924360245,
0.1502210051,
1.0991922617,
0.3431536555,
-0.4078904092,
-0.3904892504,
-0.5722827315,
1.0204842091,
-0.9505768418,
0.3988331556,
0.3604031503,
0.2565289736,
-0.3779483438,
-0.2633975148,
-0.4309982359,
-0.0510995425,
-0.1348405927,
-0.057209231,
0.1976985037,
0.2021430433,
0.2005590349,
0.3261305392,
-0.4736562073,
0.3925414383,
-0.0060573509,
-0.366413027,
0.7034654617,
0.4048611522,
0.2588395178,
-0.0025605569,
-0.42670241,
-0.1472926438,
-0.7005259395,
0.1876307428,
0.609800458,
0.394854337,
-0.2497143745,
0.6416163445,
-0.252002269,
0.9022785425,
0.0737887472,
-0.2921275496,
-0.0597480237,
-0.2743416131,
0.0047484539,
0.2882325947,
0.660236001,
0.3841432333,
0.1986414194,
-0.4138089418,
-0.3628683388,
0.082507275,
0.2545076013,
-0.6832223535,
0.0485118292,
0.2023555636,
-0.3889736533,
-0.2482219338,
-0.0288179647,
-0.3328549266,
-0.1511651725,
-0.5617469549,
0.2435688823,
-0.2876649499,
-0.0804396868,
0.6090272665,
-0.0232728533,
0.6422718167,
0.2361815423,
-1.2880833149,
0.1493477821,
0.9504206181,
0.6896830201,
-0.190252766,
-0.4364985526,
-0.7956958413,
0.585827589,
-0.3004104495,
0.5757436156,
-0.6039915681,
-0.2943960726,
0.0433960594,
-0.1432240158,
-0.0074046422,
-0.1368713826,
0.4188493192,
-0.6909092665,
0.0967999771,
-0.1558579355,
-0.7597563267,
0.2490984052,
0.4500339329,
-0.4956021607,
0.5146436095,
0.1590046585,
-0.5012464523,
0.2355173081,
-0.3083040416,
-0.5817502737,
-0.0727985948,
-0.226656422,
-0.3890992701,
-0.0245079733,
0.3090119958,
0.3137764931,
-0.1864855886,
0.6013746262,
-0.2414430529,
-0.6490882635,
0.5917173028,
-0.3696703017,
0.5205045938,
0.4190987945,
-0.355678916,
0.144712925,
-0.3679151833,
-0.0014263635,
0.0456487462,
-0.7103474736,
-0.2035929859,
0.1220396236,
-0.0644152462,
-0.0031772857,
0.4127648473,
-0.2998404503,
0.553789854,
-0.5063195825,
0.5200496316,
0.7832310796,
-0.1881414056,
0.631508708,
-0.4149472117,
0.755391717,
-0.108173877,
0.1226541251,
-0.2115463465,
-0.0202526283,
-0.584954679,
-0.2263170481,
0.5730172992,
0.5136307478,
-0.4885957241,
0.587218523,
-0.3808529973,
-0.0781119168,
-0.7797315121,
0.1948231757,
0.6806201935,
0.2241769135,
0.1772634536,
-0.142448023,
-0.543700099,
-0.8561918736,
-0.3581335843,
-0.0524467304,
0.0341588371,
0.1151095629,
0.109827593,
-0.0846698582,
0.8570463061,
-0.4765735567,
-0.2031508237,
-0.2632480562,
0.0775856599,
0.2444032133,
0.3400499225,
0.1295127869,
-0.7399414182,
-0.4010312259,
0.0931723863,
-0.5625061989,
-0.0412333794,
-0.254719317,
-0.1489962786,
0.4615833163,
0.6174067259,
-0.5410756469,
0.2178201526,
0.7048851252,
-0.4829305112,
0.2870029509,
-0.2301903665,
0.3227793276,
-1.1011697054,
0.0065747867,
-0.3214425743,
-0.3129481673,
-0.2817274034,
0.0576679893,
0.1344617754,
0.0188718121,
-0.4209200144,
0.740808785,
-0.4543868303,
-0.1481157988,
-0.3619197607,
0.1816225499,
0.0735576823,
0.597643435,
0.3645060658,
0.5822478533,
-0.0299806818,
-0.5317525268,
0.1454733163,
0.3847485781,
-0.4935844541,
0.6468118429,
-0.5289415121,
0.2033537179,
0.0208899416,
0.2381729633,
-0.566046536,
-0.2938758731,
0.318862617,
-0.4507294297,
0.3811707497,
-0.2426013201,
-0.3128712177,
0.0577097274,
-0.226220265,
0.6620006561,
0.4724939764,
-0.6102124453,
0.3969661295,
0.2800311148,
0.0711098462,
-1.0466179848,
-0.4883449078,
0.3250433803,
-0.3436324298,
-0.484226644,
0.6707502604,
-0.1154917255,
-0.1637736708,
0.1956196576,
-0.0208811834,
0.3009809852,
0.2094954699,
0.0204722155,
0.2499461323,
-0.0019251128,
-0.1027500033,
-0.0459822603,
-0.4228146672,
-0.223761797,
-0.284547776,
0.5438933372,
0.0438984074,
-0.5107753873,
-0.2430966049,
0.3367976844,
0.3837094605,
-0.3504045308,
0.7383520603,
0.4895534217,
-0.2622646689,
-0.1303607672,
-0.4054315686,
-0.1651891768,
-0.4360908568,
0.2433022261,
-0.3566931784,
-1.0656467676,
0.4290618002,
0.1635496467,
0.1344064623,
-0.0104339421,
0.5625948906,
-0.1370839328,
1.1337373257,
0.6414815784,
-0.1927348524,
0.5644342303,
0.0206492431,
0.4867386818,
-0.8749013543,
-0.3906484544,
-0.4386317134,
-0.5478144288,
-0.2098781765,
-0.1328822523,
0.0175923072,
0.5155745149,
-0.265047282,
0.4390455186,
-0.4012886584,
0.6068427563,
0.4611438513,
0.0222741775,
0.2833353877,
-0.0890356153,
0.2774270773,
-0.1956801414,
-0.7489939332,
-0.4023106098,
0.8081390262,
0.3937635124,
1.1724774837,
0.3380334973,
0.8917185664,
0.2060049027,
0.0889906287,
-0.9659670591,
0.3932360411,
-0.0410479456,
-0.2331473082,
-0.4249069095,
-0.4632852376,
-1.188328743,
0.005001456,
-0.1641170233,
-0.7646110654,
0.0943534002,
0.4042016566,
-0.3437551856,
0.1676760614,
-0.4387798607,
1.086794734,
-0.5192835331,
-0.2420700192,
-0.2156333029,
-0.665589273,
0.3040267825,
0.1498445421,
0.3460241556,
-0.1561438888,
-0.1014059037,
0.6193548441,
-0.2691226602,
0.8131645918,
0.1014961153,
-0.3312987685,
-0.117635414,
0.2676374316,
0.7276247144,
-0.0944197848,
0.0494975038,
-0.0968629196,
0.1201104745,
-0.469304055,
-0.6118556857,
0.5924721956,
-0.5989133716,
-0.5972063541,
-0.413985908,
-1.0629960299,
-0.0358419605,
0.0654411688,
0.1926448792,
0.2835766375,
-0.0108819548,
0.06875135,
0.7447116971,
-0.2350674719,
0.4567429125,
0.5462986231,
-0.2159950286,
-0.4234247804,
1.0397744179,
-0.4277940392,
0.4779491723,
0.743791163,
0.1894678921,
-0.3831173182,
-0.6908118129,
-0.2564532459,
0.1826276034,
-0.7569210529,
-0.3615678549,
-0.3717904389,
-0.1323129833,
-0.4123136699,
-0.5888950229,
-0.3721324205,
-0.1971763968,
-0.324041605,
0.1332052797,
0.2282178104,
0.3878973722,
-0.0826960579,
0.4191277325,
-1.0201352835,
0.2964270115,
0.0421997532,
0.4618199468,
-0.2167699635,
-0.5949355364,
-0.587838769,
-0.0056780195,
0.0150672793,
-0.6931731701,
0.3697942793,
-0.0700435489,
0.4572806656,
0.3130100667,
0.1600006223,
0.6278442144,
-0.3417062163,
0.5536473393,
0.2556529641,
-1.1204564571,
0.2044042498,
-0.4233923852,
0.4187010825,
0.4103426039,
-0.0250058807,
-0.9707143903,
-0.2991167605,
-0.3575969338,
-0.8826802373,
0.8924825191,
-0.0446351394,
0.0693175271,
0.0125393728,
0.4046110809,
-0.0125872483,
0.2770626843,
-0.8174244761,
0.1036910415,
0.2017790675,
-0.6193208694,
-0.0558554269,
-0.3488027751,
-0.2908979356,
0.1102052182,
0.632365942,
-0.2864646316,
0.0126074869,
-0.239599824,
-0.3384996355,
-0.1850442439,
0.5930211544,
0.7144265771,
0.6628518701,
-0.1708290279,
0.078956075,
-0.1913168877,
0.1511788517,
0.4296278954,
-0.0157450959,
-0.0587239191,
-0.4045750499,
0.5723772049,
0.8969395757,
0.5452948809,
-0.8762443066,
0.5188959837,
-0.0304814801,
-0.2212912589,
-0.2054234147,
0.1553530842,
0.3773787618,
0.5450463295,
-0.1351617128,
-0.5687179565,
-0.0945570841,
-0.4610585868,
0.0316728354,
0.5889670849,
-0.1892115027,
-0.0020365021,
0.6373450756,
0.0207340382,
-0.6700401902,
0.8724433184,
-0.2413331121,
-0.5758169293,
0.6220613122,
0.601703763,
0.7122622728,
-0.1466763765,
0.2244215757,
0.1120740175,
0.2391213477,
-0.409217,
0.1710638702,
-0.1024355888,
-0.8181734681,
-0.7455536127,
-0.7407483459,
-0.3981734216,
-0.0490540005,
-0.8185856342,
0.3868892193,
-0.1945436299,
0.087431863,
-0.2947456539,
-0.2907823622,
-0.4290549159,
-0.1100709513,
0.1466845274,
0.7915711403,
-0.5383670926,
0.814788878,
0.4686116278,
-0.2849666178,
-0.8835723996,
-0.1326668561,
-0.0293302014,
-0.8139129877,
0.6040742993,
0.1433764398,
-0.1212910563,
0.001478973,
-0.4619551599,
-0.8281854391,
1.009165287,
0.6881610155,
-1.010240674,
-0.3992601037,
0.0745638907,
0.2611576021,
-0.4560624957,
-0.2369783223,
0.7193040848,
0.6111325622,
0.1159161776,
-0.8810854554,
0.010660084,
0.1154153347,
0.0499659367,
0.5901554227,
-0.4450657964,
0.5774785876,
-0.3964982927,
-0.1742939502,
0.1574613601,
0.4344379604,
0.2697901428,
0.112992838,
0.486564368,
0.8581639528,
0.3761179447,
-0.0925120637,
1.156388998,
-0.1893260479,
0.4830084145,
1.2103846073,
-0.1891064495,
0.7854532003,
0.7779763937,
-0.1284171194,
0.23628591,
0.8829521537,
0.0973212346,
0.7016962767,
0.4223675728,
-0.0971943885,
-0.5792075396,
-0.1242572218,
-0.1472267509,
0.2304253429,
0.3968790174,
-0.0336225629,
-0.2007605731,
-0.1471804678,
-0.0825512111,
0.2793420255,
-0.1046769246,
0.8498978615,
0.1858800054,
-0.8649203181,
0.4818807542,
0.1549456418,
0.6353084445,
-0.7304158211,
-0.1074994504,
-0.2256551385,
0.2966880798,
-0.2439238876,
-0.7821128964,
0.1670105755,
-0.4111415148,
-0.1858312786,
-0.31914258,
0.237029925,
-0.9833581448,
-0.1276255697,
0.3392815888,
0.0278648231,
-0.0093165021,
0.2342621088,
-0.6837487221,
0.5560836792,
0.0407123081,
-0.2437338531,
0.3971791863,
0.1218742728,
0.0485004857,
0.6393471956,
0.4207217395,
0.1355158091,
-0.1970691681,
0.0502211377,
0.431191355,
-0.9372196198,
-0.573823452,
-0.9153152108,
0.4575329721,
0.2123645991,
-0.0595999472,
0.3339679241,
0.3398269117,
1.0212583542,
0.1426261216,
0.6036359668,
0.1443060786,
0.0898763016,
-1.072337389,
0.280531317,
-0.6064764261,
0.6566808224,
0.0892953128,
-0.9754202962,
-0.3062790036,
0.4893828332,
-0.1884015352,
-0.0076649874,
0.6348547339,
0.7614010572,
-0.1365581453,
-0.3395044804,
0.3013443947,
-0.3246789873,
0.5580627322,
0.9715159535,
0.9770050645,
-0.0351794884,
0.6887794137,
-0.1876432449,
-0.0249906536,
-0.3891104162,
-1.0737105608,
-0.7878396511,
-0.457028091,
-0.4279218316,
-0.5284030437,
0.21649459,
1.1589007378,
0.5532152653,
-0.6031222343,
-0.4241400063,
0.0687625259,
0.3038775921,
-0.2522383928,
-0.1642578542,
0.4525536597,
-0.6059236526,
-0.8053284883,
0.3963878751,
0.3761523664,
0.0863823146,
-0.187958777,
-0.6686103344,
-0.1345246285,
-0.0532107875,
0.2930763066,
0.5137594342,
-0.9126337171,
-0.4252347052,
0.0734876618,
-0.3787279725,
0.0253031384,
1.2058758736,
-0.4040203989,
0.2533981502,
0.278693378,
1.1818230152,
0.4172677398,
-0.0407372899,
0.9165739417,
-0.6284207106,
0.1540358812,
0.1352726966,
0.4638453722,
0.3463471532,
-0.529135108,
0.3323099613,
-0.1288448125,
-0.518953681,
-0.8483171463,
0.5456590056,
-0.926833868,
-0.4195656478,
1.1376127005,
-0.1606730521,
-0.2582610846,
0.0800323263,
-0.1951613426,
0.2591798604,
-0.5457032919,
0.9543589354,
0.8618215322,
-0.0550416932,
-0.2016880363,
-0.0653215945,
0.4621301591,
0.6446234584,
-0.8255019188,
0.2466246933,
0.6244061589,
0.1601179838,
-0.1352865249,
0.5265026689,
-0.1782554239,
0.3463117778,
-0.4213928282,
0.2532219887,
-0.1718282551,
-0.3098066449,
-0.6418330669,
-0.1376547664,
0.4709706306,
-0.1580279171
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05127v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05127v1
|
Illuminate: A novel approach for depression detection with explainable analysis and proactive therapy using prompt engineering
| 2024-02-05T06:08:06 | 2024-02-05T06:08:06 |
Aryan Agrawal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
This paper introduces a novel paradigm for depression detection and treatment
using advanced Large Language Models (LLMs): Generative Pre-trained Transformer
4 (GPT-4), Llama 2 chat, and Gemini. These LLMs are fine-tuned with specialized
prompts to diagnose, explain, and suggest therapeutic interventions for
depression. A unique few-shot prompting method enhances the models' ability to
analyze and explain depressive symptoms based on the DSM-5 criteria. In the
interaction phase, the models engage in empathetic dialogue management, drawing
from resources like PsychDB and a Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) Guide,
fostering supportive interactions with individuals experiencing major
depressive disorders. Additionally, the research introduces the Illuminate
Database, enriched with various CBT modules, aiding in personalized therapy
recommendations. The study evaluates LLM performance using metrics such as F1
scores, Precision, Recall, Cosine similarity, and Recall-Oriented Understudy
for Gisting Evaluation (ROUGE) across different test sets, demonstrating their
effectiveness. This comprehensive approach blends cutting-edge AI with
established psychological methods, offering new possibilities in mental health
care and showcasing the potential of LLMs in revolutionizing depression
diagnosis and treatment strategies.
|
[
-0.2966891527,
-1.0883897543,
0.9726415873,
0.4407659769,
-0.1634456515,
0.06401366,
-0.1733563095,
-0.1447178274,
0.2246736884,
0.1146257892,
-0.9132450819,
-0.6425412297,
-0.4062854648,
0.3225278258,
-0.3939633369,
0.4904304743,
-0.0131217111,
0.2719317377,
0.1589237005,
0.2257858217,
-0.8545736074,
-0.0480156727,
-0.9798061848,
-0.2487049848,
0.1842882484,
0.5022690296,
0.8103562593,
-0.3279738426,
0.5723214746,
0.2648614645,
-0.0476839431,
-0.0382231511,
-0.3864430785,
0.1003945023,
0.0672647059,
-0.6288797855,
-0.5545655489,
-0.2396863252,
0.0331128277,
0.5314367414,
0.0280351061,
-0.2386325002,
0.2925061285,
0.2317575067,
-0.6986718774,
0.0541141592,
-0.2751858234,
0.3493077755,
-0.0577354431,
-0.0839490294,
-0.3586443365,
-0.1962184459,
-0.4060765505,
-0.496527046,
0.1223799214,
-0.2584102154,
0.4410124719,
0.4338978529,
-0.3229318559,
-0.3388481438,
-0.6590098143,
0.6038935184,
-0.8114613295,
-0.2743439674,
0.5200300217,
0.5786305666,
-0.0737263188,
-0.7149033546,
-0.2652930021,
-0.1224390194,
-0.2251131684,
0.3981718123,
-0.363101244,
0.2951851785,
0.2360525876,
0.6996247768,
-0.6491465569,
0.4154264927,
0.0838324875,
-0.1444476396,
0.5239065886,
0.5342149138,
0.53231287,
-0.1747271866,
-0.2646407783,
0.4694963098,
-0.3320343494,
-0.1169387326,
-0.1984431297,
-0.0018914238,
-0.0627052411,
0.4510905445,
-0.0593693815,
0.4484054148,
0.1917354614,
-0.0021374044,
-0.1395481229,
-0.2317907065,
-0.3996839821,
0.1141406745,
0.8659757376,
0.4844940305,
-0.1259917319,
0.0378303453,
-0.1863703728,
0.223651275,
0.0489932112,
-0.8360190392,
-0.6051770449,
0.4597865045,
-0.7593122125,
-0.2815470397,
-0.5096341372,
-1.0646820068,
-0.848798871,
-0.285658896,
0.6163201928,
-0.7517576218,
-0.6467995644,
0.3788595796,
0.0948251933,
0.0758946463,
0.3372641802,
-0.8510085344,
0.0053471806,
0.4543408751,
1.2304316759,
-0.1072535738,
0.3361273706,
-0.3971866667,
-0.07003396,
-0.1963218153,
0.7707006335,
-0.5673925877,
-0.4399257004,
0.2182594538,
-0.112252377,
0.007566174,
-0.375780642,
0.6986630559,
-0.1184479222,
0.1024977341,
-0.1171873063,
-0.5749478936,
-0.057762064,
0.3406688869,
-0.7138682604,
0.5897195935,
0.3219322562,
-0.7386424541,
0.010890347,
-0.8784763813,
-0.0239923242,
0.4762512743,
-0.0607828759,
-0.2141647041,
0.2782622576,
0.4705792964,
0.565274477,
-0.2696860731,
0.3012885749,
-0.3222095072,
-0.3694627881,
0.2761661112,
-0.3906280696,
0.7929361463,
0.4858092666,
-0.2428477556,
0.1745746136,
-0.8377934694,
-0.0657806396,
0.2557552755,
0.0364722162,
-0.3626110554,
-0.3785602152,
0.07426209,
0.0679946914,
0.2605071664,
-0.2480262667,
0.1163557023,
-0.387203604,
0.5291862488,
0.5895298123,
0.152268216,
0.1658409685,
0.0818420276,
1.166918993,
-0.0319645777,
0.4664411247,
-0.7291095853,
-0.2942892611,
-0.497961998,
-0.8207360506,
-0.0607175529,
0.6258329153,
-0.3963088691,
0.5174141526,
0.2683586478,
-0.2996234596,
-0.5834392309,
-0.2764149308,
0.0792072713,
0.317371875,
0.6213918924,
-0.1442657411,
-0.4829153419,
-0.7329810262,
-0.2840414643,
0.3768265843,
-0.0032251785,
-0.0814624503,
0.1872767657,
-0.4589931071,
0.9107702374,
-0.6587128043,
-0.4136044681,
-0.6499611735,
0.3537628055,
0.4919689298,
0.2070460171,
0.5093262792,
-0.5337175131,
-0.553501308,
-0.2513571382,
-0.942307651,
-0.1921179891,
-0.360851109,
-0.0499087274,
-0.475433737,
0.4891620874,
-0.6778025627,
0.7590753436,
0.137085259,
-0.4942286015,
0.3608319759,
-0.0034594433,
0.1274113506,
-0.9330226183,
-0.0986739025,
-0.098611109,
-0.1237566322,
-0.5741950274,
-0.5251232386,
-0.076811254,
-0.425519973,
-0.1423399448,
0.3718002141,
-0.5105293393,
0.085001789,
-0.4831133187,
0.1098285839,
-0.0808501318,
0.1805515736,
-0.4390360713,
0.4716404676,
0.895588696,
-0.3505243659,
0.5609674454,
0.390324384,
-0.3743524849,
0.9408886433,
-0.5378334522,
-0.1091397926,
-0.2160376906,
0.0147683453,
-1.4326246977,
-0.2434805334,
0.4238406718,
-0.1571048051,
0.3461518884,
0.2772844732,
-0.4344010651,
-0.3296014369,
-0.1058211327,
0.651634872,
0.3802921474,
-0.4256018698,
0.4499976933,
-0.2504371703,
-0.4811899364,
-0.1121984571,
-0.5951119661,
0.4260907769,
-0.6546980739,
-0.6071568131,
0.6774116755,
-0.2588667274,
-0.3744614124,
-0.177213788,
0.2210412771,
0.0720956922,
0.4912113845,
0.0199601669,
0.1297381222,
0.0307772383,
0.4767105281,
0.0395879075,
-0.4509034455,
0.21355775,
0.3205285966,
0.7096285224,
0.0419940464,
-0.5772541165,
-0.9246075749,
0.5489459038,
0.3497759998,
-0.1929109842,
0.5537601113,
0.6722521186,
-0.3470384479,
-0.1351930946,
-0.0720496774,
-0.4703976214,
-0.4323063791,
0.3749846816,
-0.3430491388,
-0.4658660889,
0.4290268421,
-0.511785984,
-0.2167062908,
-0.0024235549,
0.5917223692,
0.1941350549,
1.6398891211,
0.8086516857,
0.0290262513,
0.6758477092,
-0.273403734,
0.7700806856,
-0.5711616278,
0.0335824676,
-0.1046470851,
-0.4623012543,
-0.1464836597,
0.0890830606,
0.5092372894,
0.5203396082,
-0.3522860408,
-0.0829389617,
-0.6787611842,
0.1752230227,
0.0988257378,
0.2036297619,
0.5649561286,
-0.4114394784,
0.0400092192,
-0.4717761874,
-0.3464318514,
-0.4776518643,
0.8879834414,
0.2437087446,
1.0099449158,
-0.0152344927,
0.6006095409,
0.3739668727,
0.4773761332,
-0.9912475348,
0.337648809,
0.3445600271,
-0.3887102008,
0.0069637885,
0.0973167866,
-0.9910992384,
0.2551451921,
0.015178333,
-0.7217299938,
0.1851715147,
0.0324909575,
-0.6423493624,
-0.1361977011,
-0.7717854381,
1.0455373526,
-0.7025519609,
-0.0161323715,
-0.3546866179,
-0.4338877499,
0.8168215752,
-0.0873031467,
0.3546646237,
-0.1665465683,
0.1347098351,
0.2510716021,
-0.1414978951,
0.8961115479,
-0.2532593608,
-0.2077377737,
-0.1206393167,
0.17597498,
0.3684641123,
0.3437454402,
-0.0642923415,
-0.2873910367,
-0.1642802954,
-0.2096208185,
-0.9070151448,
0.5159448385,
-0.3999572694,
-0.549144268,
-0.2769617736,
-0.402897656,
-0.1864735186,
0.2947280705,
0.4988598824,
0.1751318276,
-0.3546903729,
-0.1383818984,
0.6271520853,
-0.5077881813,
0.3539572656,
0.4562527239,
-0.4349393249,
-0.4456819296,
0.350684762,
-0.1160648391,
0.0284755416,
0.2392077744,
0.0378623903,
0.0185164604,
-0.5252162814,
0.4460929632,
0.3460001945,
-0.8398079276,
-0.5953974128,
-0.6509541273,
0.0434603877,
-0.3449696004,
-0.1365130246,
-0.3208895624,
-0.2150579989,
-0.64471668,
-0.3955999315,
0.4899217486,
0.5070382953,
-0.1029707119,
0.4513614774,
-0.5839207768,
0.5839137435,
-0.0088707851,
0.1690425128,
0.1382930726,
-0.1437286139,
-0.355637908,
0.012111471,
-0.6898447871,
-1.3561066389,
0.7366188765,
0.187531516,
0.5486035943,
0.7649297714,
0.2824586034,
0.5276212096,
0.0172106847,
0.7797725797,
0.6126937866,
-1.0193043947,
1.0719720125,
0.0857040137,
0.0991727859,
0.2741354704,
0.5354159474,
-0.5074321032,
-0.2830422223,
-0.4594725966,
-1.0173205137,
0.694044292,
0.187003836,
-0.138593927,
-0.1823808849,
0.4925448,
0.1210038811,
-0.1230730787,
-0.714368999,
-0.1421503276,
-0.4668723345,
-0.7346782684,
-0.1016406417,
-0.2512483001,
-0.36590451,
-0.040949896,
0.3170156181,
-0.3621065915,
0.6730859876,
0.2235601246,
-0.1333499998,
-0.0637623519,
0.3519099951,
0.0333743319,
0.6303242445,
-0.0618765727,
0.1657837927,
-0.142202422,
-0.0384495817,
0.0334412493,
0.3090181351,
0.0327262469,
0.1780591309,
0.3724822402,
0.8371537328,
0.0775287226,
-0.6554073691,
0.6338384151,
-0.256773442,
0.0186296143,
-0.548440218,
0.1452071518,
0.1293842793,
0.6697506905,
0.3112721145,
-0.2912475467,
0.4275547564,
-0.4868462086,
-0.2789182663,
0.6610751748,
-0.4685592949,
-0.6618677974,
0.6734486818,
0.032177005,
-0.402718991,
0.6778264642,
-0.03474411,
-0.2545087337,
0.5026996732,
0.5385380983,
1.032580018,
-0.3554774523,
0.5171257257,
0.408680737,
-0.0385392569,
-0.0586802214,
0.3403997123,
-0.2029770017,
-0.5952084064,
-0.2518015802,
-0.3233549297,
-0.0682849139,
0.4771805704,
-0.7117868066,
0.4203216136,
-0.4678786099,
-0.2800717056,
-0.0427719243,
-0.228262946,
-0.5420793891,
-0.0096259518,
0.2263128012,
0.7659333944,
-0.9235599041,
0.3317073584,
0.6162706614,
-0.7298597693,
-0.3180902302,
0.0741886199,
0.127588734,
-0.7521424294,
0.4935474098,
0.5613036156,
0.2400818914,
0.3397777677,
-0.6926234365,
-0.685662508,
1.3929423094,
0.519598484,
-0.3840340972,
0.0290663932,
-0.0842223763,
0.5229594707,
-0.3385077119,
0.6288706064,
0.9036021233,
0.7401899099,
-0.0964041799,
-0.5616785884,
0.1646755189,
-0.2540303171,
0.1047260761,
0.0441248938,
-0.5889736414,
0.6994993687,
-0.2265981436,
-0.5860359073,
0.4552180767,
0.3609849811,
0.2131227553,
0.3903405964,
0.280733943,
0.5138674378,
0.8988890648,
-0.0584866703,
0.7948215604,
-0.2747685313,
0.3380142152,
0.5029788017,
-0.3365916908,
0.1482363641,
0.3466259241,
-0.1525286734,
0.3887026608,
0.7781077027,
-0.0195046961,
0.7607830763,
0.0185684897,
-0.5824033022,
-0.5091406107,
-0.2422915548,
-0.3380894363,
0.0973463282,
0.6570016146,
-0.398268044,
-0.4176322818,
0.6873424053,
0.0485311449,
0.073817566,
-0.2629995942,
0.7223758698,
0.4889008999,
-0.457844913,
0.6277055144,
-0.1318857074,
0.5175857544,
-0.4840677381,
-0.0060047219,
-0.5828334093,
0.5195074677,
-0.3887908161,
-0.656288445,
0.1158727407,
-0.0545300245,
-0.0395386815,
-0.2510659695,
0.6487760544,
-0.1821959913,
-0.416913867,
0.4697066844,
0.4161781371,
-0.0101349615,
-0.2889976501,
-0.8112341166,
-0.0389785692,
-0.0803280473,
-0.2981604934,
0.3481009603,
0.7694371939,
0.0654000267,
0.7138010859,
0.1305231899,
-0.2983501554,
-0.2670966089,
0.283000499,
0.7641226053,
-0.9716449976,
-0.4608704746,
-0.7984390259,
0.6803184748,
-0.0431883782,
-0.0836817175,
0.7017911673,
0.0617420748,
0.0652569979,
-0.0365069695,
0.8586614132,
0.0599789396,
0.5189924836,
-0.4839991629,
0.0383857414,
-0.5236064196,
0.3077902794,
-0.2094076425,
-0.8986803293,
-0.6185687184,
0.7160996199,
-0.4050939679,
0.1395572424,
0.8365598321,
0.7895767689,
0.0170313772,
0.1582693309,
0.276014179,
0.6568742394,
0.8049114943,
0.7555371523,
1.3566801548,
-0.2185764462,
0.4781446755,
0.0239985269,
-0.5652878881,
-0.4226461947,
-0.5406686068,
-0.7770041823,
-0.2186474353,
-0.4278104901,
0.1289133579,
-0.1392085701,
0.5233373046,
0.2064734995,
-0.4901337922,
0.3010282516,
-0.5368804336,
-0.0338629559,
-0.5442741513,
-0.3369982839,
0.3840214312,
-0.7008016109,
-0.4948459864,
0.5778921843,
0.472383678,
0.027615929,
-0.4729993343,
-0.0034807597,
0.1296258271,
-0.3401008546,
0.4737559855,
-0.1310849935,
-0.5428215861,
0.3329764009,
-0.0876829922,
0.1155493706,
0.2418363541,
0.8192773461,
-0.8190924525,
0.4215867817,
0.4705933928,
0.3165364861,
0.3153021634,
0.1012342721,
0.5771776438,
-0.1013142094,
0.0201603584,
0.512080133,
0.4262460768,
0.4629272521,
-0.7821993828,
0.2461151779,
0.024280861,
-0.6567373872,
-0.7091206312,
0.4692262113,
-0.6523771286,
-0.7355434895,
0.8350285888,
-0.3481460214,
0.137670517,
-0.495333463,
-0.6583414674,
0.1654718071,
-0.1776469499,
1.0131007433,
0.5011642575,
-0.5934850574,
-0.5250396132,
-0.3981346786,
0.591432631,
0.4661381543,
-0.7662547231,
0.0342647433,
0.5510188341,
-0.1299194992,
0.0451701581,
0.7475693226,
-0.1588187516,
0.1725773662,
-0.4168793261,
0.029632967,
0.1085355058,
0.1146406457,
-0.5590720773,
0.1141906232,
0.0458628945,
-0.0015974776
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02750v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02750v1
|
KIVI: A Tuning-Free Asymmetric 2bit Quantization for KV Cache
| 2024-02-05T06:06:47 | 2024-02-05T06:06:47 |
Zirui Liu, Jiayi Yuan, Hongye Jin, Shaochen Zhong, Zhaozhuo Xu, Vladimir Braverman, Beidi Chen, Xia Hu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.PF
|
Efficiently serving large language models (LLMs) requires batching many
requests together to reduce the cost per request. Yet, the key-value (KV)
cache, which stores attention keys and values to avoid re-computations,
significantly increases memory demands and becomes the new bottleneck in speed
and memory usage. This memory demand increases with larger batch sizes and
longer context lengths. Additionally, the inference speed is limited by the
size of KV cache, as the GPU's SRAM must load the entire KV cache from the main
GPU memory for each token generated, causing the computational core to be idle
during this process. A straightforward and effective solution to reduce KV
cache size is quantization, which decreases the total bytes taken by KV cache.
However, there is a lack of in-depth studies that explore the element
distribution of KV cache to understand the hardness and limitation of KV cache
quantization. To fill the gap, we conducted a comprehensive study on the
element distribution in KV cache of popular LLMs. Our findings indicate that
the key cache should be quantized per-channel, i.e., group elements along the
channel dimension and quantize them together. In contrast, the value cache
should be quantized per-token. From this analysis, we developed a tuning-free
2bit KV cache quantization algorithm, named KIVI. With the hardware-friendly
implementation, KIVI can enable Llama (Llama-2), Falcon, and Mistral models to
maintain almost the same quality while using $\mathbf{2.6\times}$ less peak
memory usage (including the model weight). This reduction in memory usage
enables up to $\mathbf{4\times}$ larger batch size, bringing
$\mathbf{2.35\times \sim 3.47\times}$ throughput on real LLM inference
workload. The source code is available at https://github.com/jy-yuan/KIVI.
|
[
-0.313976109,
-0.4159636497,
0.4554414451,
0.4487691224,
-0.8317001462,
-0.1192950308,
-0.2282816917,
-0.2229433209,
0.1775152236,
0.3495801687,
-0.4600575864,
-0.3893416226,
-0.3420268297,
-0.5031749606,
-0.0090691317,
0.6160383224,
0.099207364,
0.2633740008,
-0.5152064562,
-0.3053016961,
-0.7464749217,
-0.1095198691,
-0.6080393791,
-0.1486054957,
0.3110544384,
0.5872282982,
0.4746809602,
0.834648788,
0.6078757644,
0.1576514244,
-0.163130641,
-0.1482832134,
-0.3467045128,
0.5035369992,
0.1691413969,
-1.0291377306,
-0.4905539453,
-0.1766401231,
0.641890645,
-0.0400390774,
-0.1307759285,
0.2851255834,
-0.36632967,
0.7706822753,
-1.1194331646,
0.1459730417,
-0.7078832984,
-0.0744129643,
-0.4397555888,
-0.2086255848,
-0.3521377742,
-0.176538229,
-0.2034427226,
-0.8584389091,
0.2832994759,
0.0122752972,
0.8896110654,
0.6844943762,
-0.5107699633,
0.0245794188,
-0.5516716242,
0.7637780309,
-0.5021505952,
0.4918700457,
0.5201032162,
0.3824136257,
0.0652465001,
-0.7385479212,
-0.4923775494,
0.0708163008,
0.4537332058,
0.1819765121,
-0.1049044579,
0.2038471699,
0.1027180925,
0.4817591906,
-0.604274869,
0.0527205914,
-0.2049647123,
-0.2422044873,
0.4029516876,
0.2136968076,
0.086773701,
0.0734002665,
-0.318711251,
-0.4232916534,
-1.0615173578,
0.2027464956,
0.4393169284,
-0.0517221875,
-0.1694209576,
0.2866907418,
-0.535407424,
0.1844799519,
-0.1424739063,
0.0309223216,
0.0440735556,
-0.2722131014,
-0.3869318962,
-0.0322014429,
0.630348444,
0.4468246102,
0.3445917964,
0.0418431424,
-0.0869016051,
0.3981586993,
0.277012974,
-1.2786691189,
-0.4680070281,
0.0547901653,
-0.3719233274,
-0.4154590666,
-0.3144683838,
-0.7158976197,
-0.0272743497,
0.0853097439,
0.4971160889,
-0.0757359117,
-0.1833916008,
-0.0050437213,
-0.2127292901,
0.3494836986,
0.1206102073,
-0.9993187189,
0.1576203257,
0.5968018174,
0.832665503,
0.0206431206,
0.3817686737,
-0.6314538121,
0.069886446,
-0.3715582788,
0.5580252409,
-0.6721180677,
-0.7532160282,
-0.3203091621,
-0.1673446596,
0.5009514093,
-0.4236452281,
0.1158477366,
-1.0003544092,
-0.624891758,
-0.8590923548,
-0.145607084,
0.0701251104,
-0.0407004803,
-0.6652758718,
1.0178550482,
-0.1279996037,
-0.3378162682,
0.5137838125,
-0.2372760922,
-0.2578100264,
0.1083593667,
-0.1489727497,
-0.5286861062,
0.5371775031,
0.3285522461,
0.0132444315,
-0.5815510154,
0.1744951308,
-0.3250713944,
-0.4385083616,
0.157750845,
-0.6254439354,
0.442925781,
0.4019469619,
-0.3835962713,
0.0340485275,
-0.6727567911,
0.3712151051,
-0.0515325032,
-0.2615147829,
-0.38876459,
0.1221352145,
-0.0125183016,
-0.0306590535,
0.1941347271,
-0.3906362653,
0.4356513917,
-0.4150999784,
0.6246134043,
0.8292835951,
0.019341208,
0.5516542196,
0.0906486139,
0.5629592538,
0.1372141391,
0.5213646293,
-0.0468202531,
-0.6993916631,
-1.3767106533,
-0.3178249598,
0.4127783477,
0.2604929209,
-0.7240644693,
-0.1085188687,
-0.4885762334,
-0.2663456798,
-0.9281551838,
0.0380438156,
0.7016618848,
-0.0488672182,
0.1763361692,
-0.4463106692,
-0.1709311604,
-1.0160205364,
-0.0294962376,
-0.312602669,
0.0917440578,
0.3933309317,
0.485077858,
-0.018457735,
0.9408403039,
-0.5349209309,
0.0036930894,
0.4671738446,
0.2120223641,
-0.3771513402,
0.498021692,
0.0559710301,
-0.8214067221,
-0.54855299,
0.0772246048,
-0.3337391615,
-0.2579055727,
0.3805278242,
-0.2532190084,
0.2960698903,
0.3876758218,
-0.6962890625,
0.7932819128,
0.3923126757,
-0.2034981698,
0.3360534012,
-0.1946292818,
-0.0645930767,
-1.0883594751,
0.1002482995,
-0.2773780823,
-0.3329409063,
-0.2665171325,
0.492264688,
0.4705579579,
0.1028887704,
-0.2957765162,
0.5065848231,
-0.3267895281,
-0.1486001462,
-0.3686682582,
-0.1390283108,
0.0596828274,
0.455501765,
-0.2224508971,
1.1539436579,
0.1835174561,
-0.5333638191,
0.234300673,
0.0508379117,
-0.3672145605,
0.4564470649,
-0.738030076,
0.0944650173,
-0.1761021614,
0.2391990274,
-1.0865031481,
0.0360930637,
0.0125333052,
-0.7128655314,
0.2585914135,
-0.3763262331,
-0.6221421957,
0.0432984307,
-0.3760800362,
0.808488667,
0.6549217105,
-0.3871003985,
0.2672821879,
0.2010691613,
0.0731364116,
-0.5217419863,
-0.7746221423,
-0.0830341578,
-0.178990081,
-0.5687835813,
0.3118680716,
-0.3132916689,
-0.1981983334,
0.0931529924,
-0.4865413904,
-0.0643283725,
0.1081300825,
0.4283946455,
0.1806275398,
-0.3907850981,
0.4845115542,
0.226674661,
-0.3996272087,
-0.0963523611,
-0.5861943364,
0.6427556872,
-0.2733568847,
-0.3754554689,
-0.4512322247,
0.1451954246,
0.8121638298,
-0.4247099161,
0.4980618954,
0.767757535,
-0.1323516816,
-0.0921916142,
-0.7305329442,
-0.0818553641,
-0.5369220376,
0.1615811288,
-0.5173296928,
-0.9998140335,
0.6287974715,
0.1625053138,
-0.1469492018,
0.5069480538,
0.7685958743,
0.0918531865,
1.0881168842,
0.4882869422,
-0.4705770016,
0.3313677907,
-0.452984184,
0.2347050756,
-0.8753359914,
-0.3331969082,
-0.3274799585,
-0.5941573977,
-0.7697880268,
-0.7492173314,
0.5368673801,
0.1959222406,
-0.2538093328,
-0.162960887,
-0.5486559868,
0.5820643306,
0.6801510453,
-0.0658170879,
0.1622640342,
0.1185138896,
-0.2000951618,
-0.0639046207,
-0.3791018426,
0.0560586527,
1.1110823154,
0.0428804383,
0.9403666854,
0.1501687467,
0.199557513,
0.2318680286,
0.1327202916,
-0.8666862845,
0.4780542254,
0.0501013882,
-0.680824995,
-0.1556012183,
-0.3741159141,
-0.6321920156,
0.2728814185,
0.155099988,
-0.7837588787,
0.2160913646,
0.2381594628,
-0.340344429,
0.2097027153,
-0.3965635002,
0.467753768,
0.0355306901,
-0.3356870115,
-0.5216503739,
-0.7963224649,
0.3349714875,
0.1185245663,
-0.2732239366,
-0.218386963,
-0.2307820469,
0.506141305,
-0.7102869153,
0.6479322314,
-0.2556023598,
0.0816972703,
0.3999455273,
0.1179492697,
0.8467694521,
0.5068765283,
0.2964154184,
-0.070462212,
0.0988164023,
-0.483301729,
-0.6425617337,
1.0064117908,
-1.1412042379,
-0.5853706598,
-0.0089473985,
-0.6925261021,
-0.0962165743,
-0.1355182528,
0.4264247119,
0.3248325884,
0.3608906865,
0.4470096827,
0.9398929477,
-0.0304256473,
0.4481337667,
0.608746171,
0.1630203724,
-0.6688004136,
1.2262451649,
0.040482074,
0.5031362176,
0.5894863009,
0.0790395141,
-0.2629905641,
-0.3309087455,
-0.4864750803,
0.2330776304,
-0.7518208027,
-0.4832690656,
-0.5043824315,
-0.219291985,
-0.2880321443,
-0.1898570508,
-0.7104126215,
-0.6704546213,
-0.5444941521,
0.1666843891,
0.6548864841,
0.1661300659,
0.2037444711,
0.9835782647,
-0.4475938976,
0.18581824,
0.4389813244,
0.5155593157,
0.2059389502,
-0.3321329355,
-0.2888151407,
0.1148137078,
-0.458147496,
-0.5263119936,
0.4543112516,
0.1504692733,
0.0195834078,
0.7338347435,
-0.214422226,
1.2245557308,
-0.1272469461,
0.8574941754,
0.0150467055,
-1.0362637043,
0.4910196364,
-0.2123223096,
0.3999347985,
0.7963585258,
0.0497515574,
-0.5898878574,
-0.0911029726,
-0.4482238889,
-1.039232254,
0.5107049942,
0.3030280769,
-0.0229021702,
0.0647920147,
0.5265231133,
-0.1964434683,
0.3967730105,
-0.4252953529,
-0.4030585289,
-0.0270092469,
-0.1231122166,
-0.0467330813,
-0.4819533527,
0.3229413033,
-0.3369883001,
0.7721905708,
-0.1560423374,
0.5724900365,
0.0299444776,
-0.2182642668,
-0.2692560852,
-0.0068678455,
0.6658796668,
0.2815601528,
-0.1258668751,
0.2013975978,
0.2066209763,
-0.6085615158,
0.302331537,
-0.3279000819,
-0.1739100218,
-0.1209066808,
-0.3125468493,
0.9956053495,
0.1883958131,
-0.5932316184,
0.6790053248,
-0.2749357224,
-0.1312205046,
-0.1569361836,
0.0844859555,
0.1536708176,
0.4973819852,
0.0975854397,
-0.2952898741,
-0.0129380664,
-0.1059589535,
-0.1656679511,
0.8674280643,
-0.369132936,
-0.490478307,
1.014906168,
0.1302868575,
-0.1540371925,
1.0691565275,
-0.2973351777,
-0.2663640976,
0.7558150887,
0.509224534,
1.0228077173,
-0.2208934724,
-0.0803851113,
0.0475692898,
0.2502324581,
-0.0942228287,
0.5016269684,
-0.672603786,
-0.5178357363,
-0.4473956227,
-0.8908063769,
-0.0080788536,
0.2871887386,
-0.9331355095,
0.2034035623,
-0.3984323442,
-0.2712987959,
-0.1863526851,
0.2602524459,
-0.7266504169,
0.1510134935,
0.0673416629,
0.9005590677,
-0.7841132283,
1.1117117405,
0.2962286174,
-0.1409444064,
-0.4603043199,
-0.3141773343,
0.0416272432,
-1.1465374231,
0.6251292825,
-0.0004536883,
0.1717770249,
0.2597808242,
-0.5535024405,
-1.1068305969,
1.4334456921,
0.1441680193,
-0.6506056786,
-0.0341291986,
0.1985446215,
0.2758006454,
0.0558380783,
0.1248934194,
0.5229607821,
0.4310908318,
0.2747422457,
-0.6480608582,
0.0195053034,
-0.4864459038,
0.5569748878,
0.8341538906,
-1.1434941292,
0.638068378,
-0.0030535148,
-0.108056128,
0.4535836279,
0.6248280406,
0.2557539046,
0.1998273879,
0.3390675187,
1.1051338911,
0.6373810172,
-0.0997901112,
0.8350991011,
-0.5602897406,
0.3167580664,
0.6052982807,
0.0692289099,
0.8416919112,
0.8215304017,
-0.0841290504,
0.1550421715,
0.6041616201,
0.0512442887,
0.9131002426,
0.2815206647,
-0.6120333076,
-0.4102846682,
-0.0477779992,
-0.3353229463,
0.3496148884,
0.557615459,
-0.2482180893,
-0.0207496621,
-0.1646229327,
-0.1306827813,
-0.9174721837,
-0.2853803337,
0.5413634181,
0.2043504119,
-0.5890552402,
0.520629108,
0.1930319369,
0.4617896974,
-0.6471446157,
0.113362357,
-0.3023479879,
0.0624933392,
0.1564222425,
-0.2016434669,
-0.0861529112,
-0.0794781819,
-0.4353928566,
-0.0319992565,
0.6936526895,
-0.3044055402,
-0.4340153039,
-0.2298632115,
0.1738293022,
0.2098670304,
-0.1973762512,
-0.0211553834,
0.3884104192,
0.0238003954,
-0.3616317213,
0.6177002192,
0.2503173053,
-0.5047651529,
0.9246024489,
0.7320077419,
0.1841053814,
0.1849982738,
-0.0736621544,
0.9902629256,
-0.5298728347,
-0.7067819238,
-0.9352812171,
0.5515695214,
0.3339318633,
-0.3965466917,
0.5444135666,
0.5754286051,
0.5952456594,
0.2280312479,
0.6351242661,
0.2811888456,
-0.6696656346,
-0.5180532932,
0.7332790494,
-0.8219524622,
0.1329950392,
0.2342456281,
-0.7552534342,
-0.1752425581,
0.4561585784,
0.0022900703,
-0.1168574244,
0.4656518698,
1.0726628304,
-0.0353863202,
-0.0690480098,
0.4123671353,
-0.0523288958,
0.4691419303,
0.6101961136,
0.562148273,
-0.5075622797,
0.6534349918,
-0.093490392,
0.0329297185,
-0.6149865985,
-0.6077221036,
-0.5732061863,
-0.6445624232,
-0.1553889364,
-0.1283244044,
0.2954087257,
0.5634010434,
0.9127378464,
-0.440680474,
0.1140365675,
-0.4269070923,
-0.1146633625,
0.1180084944,
-0.2706147432,
0.2612026334,
-0.43215096,
-0.4465222955,
0.2357037514,
0.5608181357,
0.012259746,
-0.3150809407,
-0.1279980838,
0.4083397985,
0.1717384905,
0.4664812982,
0.0264404286,
-0.9295960069,
-0.2306918502,
0.0916839838,
-0.0271425787,
0.1496713609,
1.0361254215,
-0.8726596832,
0.9325621128,
0.5392329097,
0.5689994097,
1.145362258,
-0.1471439749,
0.3110696077,
-0.9853934646,
0.2453606278,
0.0143676791,
0.1056873649,
-0.1274889708,
-0.2791322768,
0.1584136486,
0.3998693228,
-0.7916688919,
-0.8151218891,
0.1434537023,
-1.11097157,
-0.098203972,
1.2331231833,
0.1926545054,
-0.3978677988,
0.3360698521,
0.1691965312,
0.4705238044,
-0.5223050714,
0.6421442032,
0.6384792924,
0.3542412519,
-0.1036333516,
-0.8917363286,
0.4943822324,
0.470194459,
-0.3444457352,
-0.0801677778,
0.210890606,
0.5077069998,
-0.1852712482,
0.7206249833,
-0.0329542533,
0.4088573754,
0.1521826535,
0.2524622083,
0.0088388519,
-0.413785547,
-0.4051444829,
-0.1573598683,
0.2236169726,
-0.5021244884
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02716v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02716v1
|
Understanding the planning of LLM agents: A survey
| 2024-02-05T04:25:24 | 2024-02-05T04:25:24 |
Xu Huang, Weiwen Liu, Xiaolong Chen, Xingmei Wang, Hao Wang, Defu Lian, Yasheng Wang, Ruiming Tang, Enhong Chen
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
As Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown significant intelligence, the
progress to leverage LLMs as planning modules of autonomous agents has
attracted more attention. This survey provides the first systematic view of
LLM-based agents planning, covering recent works aiming to improve planning
ability. We provide a taxonomy of existing works on LLM-Agent planning, which
can be categorized into Task Decomposition, Plan Selection, External Module,
Reflection and Memory. Comprehensive analyses are conducted for each direction,
and further challenges for the field of research are discussed.
|
[
-0.6005401015,
-0.5889633894,
0.8024761677,
-0.0401221551,
0.2864833772,
0.0282556247,
-0.2349151075,
-0.5088281035,
0.5291571021,
0.8926165104,
-0.8403483033,
-0.4337947667,
-0.4887869954,
0.1173638031,
-0.3067501187,
0.4410159886,
-0.0736144781,
0.1081555188,
-0.2329891026,
-0.0386133119,
-0.3557452857,
-0.3313131928,
-0.9207650423,
-0.4985268414,
0.7987833023,
0.6041684151,
0.5595580339,
0.5081331134,
0.5922302604,
0.4071720243,
-0.2176557034,
0.2340662628,
-0.3974416554,
0.2676098347,
-0.3230974972,
-0.528098464,
-0.9257629514,
-0.0487544611,
0.705380559,
0.7238359451,
-0.0874424949,
0.0490377061,
-0.3892978728,
0.5106459856,
-0.464612931,
0.3879411221,
-0.6047539711,
0.0729885623,
0.1279659867,
-0.118519403,
-0.4937420487,
0.0719790757,
0.0394238122,
-0.1464575678,
-0.0149607556,
-0.1167362332,
0.051325094,
0.2853854597,
-0.6554074883,
-0.4150976539,
-1.0693506002,
0.8299149275,
-0.4762046635,
0.0915943384,
0.4020588398,
0.4963570535,
-0.5161906481,
-0.6040841341,
-0.2659901977,
-0.3307099342,
0.0328161307,
0.067342855,
-0.1365157962,
0.3991347849,
0.141463846,
0.1361069381,
-0.6038105488,
0.5112477541,
-0.2853671014,
-0.0764543489,
1.0986307859,
0.4482734501,
0.2051118314,
0.2080866545,
-0.2401630133,
0.1072027534,
-0.7399154902,
-0.1982820779,
0.2062838227,
0.1249830946,
0.2346085757,
0.865766108,
-0.6634200811,
0.7579431534,
-0.4636151195,
-0.3890296221,
-0.5409338474,
-0.5261954665,
-0.3319676518,
-0.2902821302,
0.4011000097,
0.3357929289,
0.3150567412,
-0.2726656795,
-0.6051210165,
-0.2062498778,
0.2424706817,
-0.5753322244,
-0.0228819847,
0.3749680519,
-0.3656624556,
0.088080436,
-0.3685219288,
-0.1042635962,
-0.4357697964,
-0.4321444929,
0.0228021871,
-0.1728346199,
-0.2981635332,
0.0998622179,
0.0300469082,
0.5047866702,
0.4752697647,
-0.6701193452,
0.5656094551,
0.857278347,
0.3406457305,
-0.0166955963,
-0.5177431703,
-0.113524206,
0.2610258162,
-0.3978196084,
1.308262229,
-0.2672562301,
-0.5226745605,
0.4074491262,
-0.0611550696,
0.1334170997,
-0.4543775916,
0.1531591415,
-0.6406635642,
-0.2042795867,
-0.4997506738,
-0.5140551925,
-0.3894374073,
0.7778196335,
-0.6860559583,
0.3883222938,
0.0285519063,
-0.2302772701,
0.4988376498,
-0.620746851,
-0.2844492793,
0.117863819,
-0.2566888034,
0.2475580573,
-0.2471195012,
-0.0767825469,
0.7355929613,
-0.3902056217,
0.147726953,
0.1133275181,
-0.0358776152,
0.5181193352,
0.0847389475,
0.5421583652,
0.267488271,
0.1332574785,
0.6398068666,
-0.6283226013,
0.0310304891,
-0.0557144694,
-0.2282603681,
0.0877066478,
0.4308278859,
-0.1436882019,
0.2479078323,
0.4730258882,
-0.2763876915,
0.7655388117,
-0.240300104,
0.2606897354,
0.682541132,
-0.0973688886,
0.8732895851,
-0.530194819,
0.7873024344,
-0.4886388183,
0.3557468951,
-0.1525598466,
-0.4290831685,
-0.6425303221,
-0.1839393377,
-0.1667969525,
0.3486209512,
-0.7641381025,
0.0526920632,
-0.2030166388,
-0.5938448906,
0.2642991543,
0.0688475892,
0.1814974248,
-0.2254745662,
0.094851315,
-0.0748284459,
-0.2524344623,
-0.8955423236,
0.0944536254,
-0.4212715328,
0.2297541797,
0.2090443373,
0.5351874828,
-0.435723424,
0.8932298422,
-0.5137352347,
-0.2642542422,
-0.9859878421,
-0.1622938365,
-0.1056216061,
-0.0748257563,
0.4824299514,
-0.56282866,
-0.3442955613,
-0.1132750288,
-0.2651301622,
-0.0784263685,
-0.0115745664,
-0.1362426877,
0.0658377036,
0.6209363341,
-0.9657150507,
0.3445940316,
0.1921037734,
-0.3949773014,
0.5819935203,
-0.0916129053,
-0.4329247177,
-0.779091537,
-0.2641404271,
-0.145250693,
-0.12434908,
-0.7542657852,
0.2743852139,
-0.189705193,
0.3768563867,
-0.5426744819,
0.8242881894,
-0.9715883732,
-0.4921227098,
-0.8151854277,
0.0553793535,
-0.5186123848,
0.3877352774,
0.0802906156,
0.5567949414,
0.4960601926,
-0.7280335426,
0.583383441,
0.3135249317,
0.0655851886,
0.1629218757,
-0.2042458057,
0.2683003545,
-0.3140172362,
0.4183588922,
-0.9195344448,
-0.3269473612,
0.3166796565,
-0.1662369072,
0.4610881507,
-0.1452471465,
-0.4839928448,
-0.3193973005,
-0.2797755897,
0.3737015724,
0.2850757539,
-0.0945094824,
0.8533500433,
0.551238358,
-0.267374754,
-0.5368006229,
-0.4863245189,
0.0896362066,
-0.0560279079,
-0.5748289824,
0.094645083,
-0.022406606,
-1.0053257942,
0.0515567586,
0.2310905457,
-0.0768879876,
-0.1919560134,
0.1111239716,
-0.0242865887,
-0.163814187,
0.0243803225,
-0.535920918,
-0.0964551121,
0.2884722352,
0.0072758934,
0.7658264041,
0.3757756948,
-0.2454990745,
-0.0073692556,
0.3349616528,
0.3438435495,
-0.3193049729,
0.6658604741,
0.0401619747,
-0.2064382881,
-0.5174535513,
-0.5091894865,
-0.0721288621,
-0.4331078529,
0.3829163313,
-0.1745508909,
-0.618293345,
0.6167512536,
-0.1016338021,
0.2575131655,
0.3941898644,
0.6394696236,
0.1401799023,
0.7532929182,
1.051381588,
-0.2010318041,
0.281367749,
-0.5294844508,
-0.0722020417,
-0.609495759,
-0.3736603558,
-0.4809310436,
-0.4938574433,
-0.4240703881,
-0.7140067816,
-0.072443381,
-0.5837460756,
0.0528296642,
0.3214501739,
-0.2611245513,
0.4111058414,
0.1794308126,
-0.4051623046,
0.2944167256,
-0.44358477,
0.3931605816,
0.6112483144,
-0.4458289444,
-0.7152366042,
1.0957520008,
0.4836910665,
0.9043614268,
0.101023756,
0.6117278337,
0.006883997,
0.3294546902,
-1.1285413504,
1.1600439548,
0.2996633053,
-0.7932984233,
-0.6363793015,
-0.138858214,
-1.0766341686,
0.2018049806,
0.1689048707,
-0.6700732708,
-0.0245813597,
-0.2914020419,
-0.1170206964,
0.3609423935,
-0.4020242393,
0.3464938402,
-0.4713930786,
0.1390796602,
-0.5457410216,
-0.3168638051,
0.2886879444,
0.0771277398,
-0.0316742659,
-0.48433429,
-0.370858252,
0.6489235759,
-0.2135659754,
0.4771302342,
-0.2705294192,
-0.3642734587,
0.5931367874,
-0.076863952,
0.4734134674,
-0.3119451106,
-0.1025587842,
-0.2748762965,
-0.1662739217,
-0.4208923578,
-0.4255569577,
0.4706346095,
-0.5116388202,
-0.6114073396,
-0.4168040454,
-1.0321798325,
-0.2770483494,
0.0712226257,
-0.0520419665,
0.4222764373,
-0.6101225615,
-0.2275252193,
0.4201123118,
-0.0956918746,
0.8579119444,
0.815538168,
-0.7659028769,
-0.0357473791,
0.4089517891,
0.6133154631,
0.3020519614,
0.5139311552,
-0.2196021676,
-0.3044243753,
-1.3001122475,
0.0635456219,
0.3716019988,
-0.829100728,
0.009227966,
-0.444491446,
-0.3517237008,
-0.5241444707,
-0.0980869904,
-0.3485454023,
-0.389564395,
0.1879759282,
-0.1373147517,
0.1347975731,
1.5227637291,
0.125924021,
0.6324376464,
-0.3038701713,
0.2049739063,
0.2429042608,
0.1070839688,
-0.1270419955,
0.1006903723,
-0.3563350141,
-0.2977997065,
-0.1612024158,
-0.8199732304,
0.5667614937,
-0.1839435846,
0.8863036633,
0.5651932955,
0.0680652559,
0.249357,
-0.3681908548,
0.7990676761,
-0.259249568,
-0.0884828418,
0.5501132011,
-0.334110707,
0.3654702902,
0.2990294099,
0.4521392584,
-0.2672692835,
-0.3357447088,
-0.6218384504,
-0.8248105049,
0.6347290277,
0.1774120778,
-0.0258514062,
0.1310571134,
0.361027211,
0.0348329619,
0.0573890656,
-0.6333441138,
-0.3156074882,
0.6654330492,
0.2301458865,
-0.5488366485,
-0.6090660691,
-0.0924339145,
-0.235564366,
0.4518745244,
-0.0690502524,
0.5858465433,
0.0405724645,
-0.2177782208,
-0.118742153,
0.2570616305,
0.7543947101,
1.004068017,
-0.0212814324,
0.2006480992,
0.321353972,
-0.4606521428,
0.1729494482,
0.0397711135,
-0.0033864682,
-0.2926869094,
0.58590132,
0.2499742806,
-0.1499104053,
-0.7273755074,
0.1997304112,
-0.1881292164,
-0.3255948722,
-0.7582472563,
0.2343710512,
0.0519392639,
0.553257525,
0.3376347721,
-0.3377769589,
0.1321837753,
-0.961258471,
-0.115106076,
0.6488109231,
-0.3065210581,
-0.3259590566,
0.0293656569,
0.1027753651,
-0.5032034516,
0.2679769695,
-0.4335301816,
-0.438411355,
0.8159865737,
0.4573253691,
0.9727958441,
-0.2194461972,
0.0898093954,
0.0218415689,
0.5044726729,
0.0289229304,
0.6833372712,
-0.0413374268,
-0.8764334917,
-0.3778792024,
-0.4159680307,
-0.5270535946,
0.0783985034,
-0.0736356527,
0.1420140713,
-0.5333314538,
-0.1740834564,
-0.3034730554,
0.3521418869,
-0.6128790975,
0.1642662734,
0.2666508853,
1.2105708122,
-0.3561941385,
0.8872468472,
1.2927737236,
-0.2968842983,
-0.8189503551,
-0.0000396482,
-0.0599495918,
-0.9619977474,
0.6075296402,
-0.0472530015,
-0.513256371,
-0.1526253223,
-0.6489715576,
-0.8776649833,
1.240447402,
0.0211434402,
-0.2317282856,
-0.3286895752,
0.4762131274,
0.3234810233,
-0.3949666321,
0.418009907,
0.6812112927,
0.6005798578,
0.1097447127,
-0.8285554051,
-0.1494892538,
-0.0715635344,
-0.3181007802,
0.3921386302,
-0.8100364804,
0.9151352644,
-0.0306610037,
-0.0948984101,
0.3070447147,
0.6888526678,
-0.1135642976,
0.5918328166,
0.3164096177,
0.2201059014,
0.453434974,
0.1369597018,
0.959856987,
-0.2879806757,
-0.0192988347,
0.7207739949,
-0.3798908889,
0.7172510028,
0.2158264071,
-0.1844072491,
0.2801160216,
0.5040835738,
0.3572214544,
0.3536995351,
0.3267038167,
-0.4086891413,
-0.105591014,
-0.1720884889,
-0.061809767,
0.7604700327,
0.4680323303,
-0.0417638086,
-0.2009462714,
-0.0465396382,
-0.070472084,
-0.1148050427,
-0.7756655216,
0.9433873892,
0.1007443666,
-0.858106792,
-0.030008886,
0.0240671244,
0.4393884838,
-0.5687323809,
0.2126143575,
-0.1975846738,
0.1904541552,
-0.1611959338,
-1.1099578142,
0.3428015411,
-0.2138843685,
-0.0385403372,
-0.6596871614,
1.2396024466,
-0.1831246763,
-0.0331596918,
0.4884584844,
0.83185184,
0.2343976647,
-0.2399610877,
-0.233790651,
-0.1397458762,
-0.2597264647,
-0.2701784372,
0.294606477,
0.5726636648,
0.0037284493,
0.9579205513,
0.1917205751,
0.1676493436,
0.2459183335,
-0.136321336,
0.805578351,
-1.203977704,
-0.1905577034,
-0.6737459898,
0.4102958441,
0.0417701341,
-0.0595697761,
0.7417475581,
0.5182012916,
0.6401841044,
-0.0593782701,
0.3509331346,
0.2034265399,
0.3730751872,
-0.6155042648,
0.7364732623,
-0.3894711733,
0.1297136992,
0.1364711523,
-0.9677535295,
0.0330806412,
0.3763069212,
-0.5851935744,
-0.1075255349,
0.5176392794,
0.8077725172,
0.3432765603,
-0.2315829396,
0.5490133762,
0.0601059161,
0.3617752194,
0.5511042476,
1.6061879396,
0.2907985151,
0.2010234892,
-0.2167812288,
-0.0457940772,
-0.1969174892,
-0.4814475179,
-0.9518797398,
-0.5608568192,
-0.1278295964,
0.4623822868,
-0.298510015,
0.8837984204,
0.6522622705,
-0.2826761901,
-0.6886759996,
0.0593265109,
0.2866608202,
0.1958486885,
-0.0521559231,
-0.0874306485,
-0.3958362341,
-0.5084442496,
0.6219114065,
0.2630594969,
-0.0102725551,
-0.7139635682,
-0.2876993716,
-0.2906587124,
0.3205594718,
0.9015344977,
0.4853889942,
-0.7293857932,
-0.0169015564,
0.1656820029,
-0.2522878945,
-0.1959786862,
0.8606123924,
-0.4979500771,
0.0256052539,
0.5031734109,
0.2597224712,
0.4755365551,
-0.3063726127,
0.4387385845,
-0.3941475153,
0.2129752636,
0.5095590353,
0.4403170049,
-0.168316409,
-0.3560797572,
0.6427451968,
-0.345788151,
-1.0047603846,
-0.534924686,
0.5362272859,
-1.2275629044,
-0.3449089229,
1.443964839,
0.3821388781,
-0.3815509975,
-0.1913485825,
-0.6209389567,
0.1757648885,
-0.0872120261,
0.3680637181,
0.7017843723,
-0.7323248982,
-0.1738889664,
-0.6413238645,
0.4068432152,
-0.0996446535,
-0.8344772458,
-0.0044172546,
0.7988556623,
-0.083489269,
0.1772588044,
1.3951276541,
0.3014217913,
0.0232573431,
-0.0674242377,
0.1509442627,
0.1156098023,
-0.7343034744,
-0.149934575,
0.2224789709,
0.8577951789,
0.1199822798
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02695v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02695v2
|
Exploiting Class Probabilities for Black-box Sentence-level Attacks
| 2024-02-05T03:15:26 | 2024-02-21T00:09:00 |
Raha Moraffah, Huan Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
Sentence-level attacks craft adversarial sentences that are synonymous with
correctly-classified sentences but are misclassified by the text classifiers.
Under the black-box setting, classifiers are only accessible through their
feedback to queried inputs, which is predominately available in the form of
class probabilities. Even though utilizing class probabilities results in
stronger attacks, due to the challenges of using them for sentence-level
attacks, existing attacks use either no feedback or only the class labels.
Overcoming the challenges, we develop a novel algorithm that uses class
probabilities for black-box sentence-level attacks, investigate the
effectiveness of using class probabilities on the attack's success, and examine
the question if it is worthy or practical to use class probabilities by
black-box sentence-level attacks. We conduct extensive evaluations of our
attack comparing with the baselines across various classifiers and benchmark
datasets.
|
[
-0.1648202688,
-1.1909991503,
0.3947500587,
-0.0651762635,
0.1249365658,
0.2311745435,
-0.0235690195,
-0.6081389785,
-0.0745519921,
0.2666947246,
-0.2799844146,
-0.4480950236,
-0.6056781411,
-0.2494429648,
-0.6164542437,
1.139482379,
0.5147644281,
-0.1524131596,
-0.0367744006,
0.3060285151,
-0.5595635176,
-0.9050121307,
-0.6377879381,
0.0938941911,
0.5626696944,
0.2334142327,
0.7970603704,
0.1142460406,
0.4186452031,
0.2654132843,
-0.0090158191,
-0.2673524022,
-0.4572286606,
-0.0142877307,
0.0462714359,
-0.6944984198,
-0.2912644744,
0.0795154199,
0.5385995507,
0.5963178277,
-0.0536903776,
-0.0409638621,
-0.007531805,
0.4843487442,
-1.1139653921,
-0.0449525192,
-0.8533435464,
0.5489981174,
-0.2920678258,
-0.5484185219,
-1.0812143087,
-0.3455327749,
0.1738974899,
-0.2955697775,
0.29684183,
-0.0736510083,
0.4952440262,
-0.0620042533,
-0.1301090121,
-0.2760948539,
-0.5524289608,
0.4897761345,
-0.5056657195,
-0.1390694082,
0.2596991658,
0.4956910312,
-0.3925710022,
-0.4110758901,
-0.3782630563,
-0.3040467799,
-0.1797142327,
0.1446551979,
-0.419757843,
0.2814081907,
0.1696352065,
0.4399451613,
-0.5242841244,
-0.0481180772,
-0.3901336491,
-0.0033100615,
0.7228115797,
-0.0215859972,
0.2935544252,
-0.2418140322,
-0.4913268387,
-0.1391577125,
-0.2343347967,
0.327621609,
0.8209345937,
0.2356559336,
0.1386799663,
0.7680482268,
-0.0897485167,
1.0109597445,
-0.0767924115,
0.0394806676,
0.0448117815,
-0.1335292011,
-0.2492622435,
0.3238877058,
0.912974298,
0.3544842303,
0.2350421548,
-0.6751285195,
-0.187763989,
0.4366162121,
0.8404222727,
-0.5800331831,
-0.4133710861,
0.3101570308,
-0.2245516926,
-1.1006298065,
0.1694072336,
-1.1959893703,
-0.4894530475,
0.5974661708,
0.7739991546,
-0.1502528787,
-0.055245772,
0.3686387837,
-0.632145822,
0.0070966235,
-0.0390684009,
-0.5493462086,
0.1298041493,
0.6108326316,
0.6280503869,
0.1050507352,
-0.2832033038,
-0.8044566512,
0.1585734487,
-0.3259447515,
0.5488404036,
-0.9313932061,
-0.3907091916,
0.1681871265,
-0.286236465,
0.0167896431,
-0.2046226412,
0.4880589247,
-0.6383339167,
0.3230433464,
0.47911641,
-0.7574929595,
-0.0516493954,
0.3746166229,
-0.4794875979,
0.6806710958,
-0.0812614858,
-0.9503411651,
0.2694711089,
-0.6204674244,
-0.650855422,
0.3156174123,
0.068546012,
-0.6197522879,
0.3355267346,
0.0807044208,
0.6112924814,
0.3533951044,
-0.0315066054,
-0.57896173,
-0.4625264704,
0.5294369459,
-0.5496348739,
0.8368373513,
-0.0197017416,
-0.483627975,
-0.0289641395,
-0.8791900873,
0.1445067376,
0.3735901415,
-0.0296473689,
-0.4189335406,
0.1802739352,
-0.095046334,
-0.101684317,
0.2504741549,
-0.6380868554,
0.6243223548,
-0.5590584278,
0.4664570391,
0.566077292,
0.3816455603,
0.4620141387,
-0.2447918355,
0.6854877472,
-0.2317632139,
0.3894456327,
0.1631350815,
-0.3950396776,
-0.3895780742,
-0.0523679294,
0.3845254779,
0.8104416728,
-0.9556881785,
0.4686390162,
0.3230136037,
-0.7667722106,
-0.5876045823,
-0.2360589802,
0.4843383133,
0.2675612569,
0.4719712436,
-0.2516382933,
-0.2893386483,
-0.5311325788,
-0.499971807,
-0.3489584625,
0.1487695873,
-0.2644087672,
0.3287280202,
0.0102405008,
0.6584057212,
-1.0764482021,
-0.4033750296,
-0.3228778839,
0.1276254356,
-0.2387431711,
0.447317183,
0.6487112641,
-0.5689418912,
-0.0260157213,
-0.3546762466,
-0.8584054708,
0.2199029922,
-0.3257547617,
-0.1893357188,
0.2224167734,
0.4993732274,
-0.2599110901,
0.6833056211,
0.3112379909,
-0.5753218532,
0.5449813008,
-0.1262623519,
0.0515213087,
-0.7724949718,
-0.4083234668,
0.3664269149,
-0.0109528536,
-0.9058365226,
0.4003780484,
0.080714412,
-0.306004107,
-0.4618007839,
0.1595129669,
-0.2457073629,
0.0685933232,
-0.2708426714,
-0.005622426,
-0.1729433686,
0.674518466,
-0.2046382278,
0.4754507244,
0.590603292,
-0.3767787218,
0.3226490617,
-0.0094075054,
-0.2906165123,
0.776243329,
-0.569070816,
0.0172587018,
-0.1173742935,
0.2427145094,
-0.7653878927,
0.0380028002,
0.3734525442,
-0.7134281397,
0.4106688201,
-0.0655346066,
-0.5567385554,
-0.3911256492,
-0.5193496943,
0.1089692488,
0.247996226,
-0.4943669438,
0.2443594933,
0.5908654928,
0.1816344559,
-1.0946644545,
-0.649887979,
0.3611108363,
-0.1534945518,
-0.2906427979,
0.0937595218,
-0.0981028527,
-0.0295726098,
-0.0170070753,
-0.2476633191,
0.0918961093,
0.6146435142,
0.1390548348,
0.2754930258,
0.1215072796,
-0.2926534414,
-0.2139891088,
0.0593078397,
0.4362969697,
-0.4933195114,
0.638900876,
-0.0664865673,
-0.2390915006,
-0.7628161907,
0.2167054266,
0.2373670936,
-0.2320015579,
0.7671684623,
0.4119178057,
-0.4956173599,
-0.485870868,
-0.4034145772,
-0.1972415447,
-0.4990032315,
0.6663401127,
-0.5590902567,
-0.7641362548,
0.0982990637,
0.51232934,
0.2363268733,
0.1472345889,
0.194938004,
-0.168478325,
0.904907763,
0.3011409938,
-0.116374746,
0.5965601206,
-0.3852408528,
0.3873381019,
-0.4502413869,
-0.3468313515,
-0.5555254221,
-0.2722291648,
-0.6814007163,
0.0864690244,
0.1645849645,
0.1237152889,
-0.0149060637,
0.6118372083,
-0.8516635895,
0.53899014,
0.8616989851,
0.4317491353,
0.0970030949,
0.0650345162,
0.2758209109,
0.2532756925,
-0.7504540682,
-0.205426544,
1.3056741953,
0.2717598975,
0.5477952361,
0.1858039647,
0.9342976809,
0.5548977256,
-0.0020840031,
-0.650150001,
0.8625456095,
-0.3678179383,
-0.4738950133,
-0.3769541383,
-0.7267623544,
-1.1428353786,
0.2481128573,
-0.522080183,
-0.701030314,
0.1167905256,
-0.0647223517,
-0.0800026953,
0.6498932242,
-0.9054968953,
1.2150728703,
-0.0693217143,
-0.2886544466,
-0.0301267765,
-0.6268514395,
0.2137654722,
-0.0367347449,
0.2563466728,
0.4390156567,
0.2946718633,
0.6934245825,
-0.4478054643,
0.9060135484,
-0.5493562222,
-0.1297805756,
0.213662073,
0.1959699541,
0.314281255,
0.1098127365,
0.1098418981,
0.0814953372,
-0.0514311753,
-0.7302340269,
-0.7276160717,
0.3314532936,
-0.8885746002,
-0.7421553731,
-0.7246620655,
-0.3798056841,
-0.3018852472,
-0.1328549087,
0.2209510058,
0.6748683453,
-0.1243462414,
0.1029588878,
0.513119638,
-0.2638980746,
0.5825209618,
0.4048549235,
0.1471121311,
-0.5784767866,
1.4668980837,
0.2164505124,
0.4526357055,
0.7962704301,
0.0820748955,
-0.1244652644,
-0.7038167715,
-0.3991732895,
-0.2374659181,
-0.4678087831,
-0.4400755763,
-0.7171754241,
-0.4548091888,
-0.3745777905,
-0.413389951,
0.3100911677,
-0.6128861308,
0.0162135996,
-0.2834527493,
0.0474176444,
0.5643852949,
0.3599847555,
0.3904921114,
-0.4890064895,
0.2023822367,
0.5880447626,
0.1245860755,
0.1000762358,
-0.2180390656,
0.0254168604,
-0.0904193819,
-0.5692231655,
-1.3526959419,
0.2915195227,
-0.1149312332,
0.4236094058,
0.1142680272,
0.3380117416,
0.4449932873,
-0.4607114196,
0.7820242643,
0.2242463976,
-0.908116281,
0.8220562339,
0.0546529442,
0.092714183,
0.5450140834,
0.1988562047,
-0.1299457699,
-1.2274518013,
-1.0364558697,
-0.6323426962,
0.8129069805,
0.4015482366,
-0.1009497792,
-0.0364915617,
0.512686789,
-0.1789503396,
0.3704460561,
-0.9840066433,
-0.6294772625,
-0.4194746614,
-0.3456965089,
-0.2175792158,
-0.2315757871,
-0.0550463349,
0.2460666448,
0.6218456626,
0.2392173558,
0.1148761436,
0.0035169136,
-0.1850669086,
0.1236395836,
0.684922576,
0.2979991734,
0.145976603,
-0.3160814643,
0.3242176771,
0.1148584187,
-0.7635373473,
0.3599862456,
0.4508031607,
-0.5448464155,
-0.1653621048,
0.4379860759,
0.543684721,
0.3347144425,
-0.4776475132,
0.7454944253,
-0.3527503014,
-0.202583611,
-0.355387181,
0.3487171829,
-0.5179648995,
0.2843680084,
0.4387879074,
0.2387270629,
0.3918124735,
-0.6515004039,
0.3240647018,
0.742348969,
-0.5095935464,
-0.0305082761,
0.7676266432,
0.0424558669,
-0.5070039034,
0.1067840159,
-0.2283901125,
-0.7057662606,
0.6657704115,
0.549613297,
0.8126777411,
-0.0978565961,
0.5847041607,
0.1417282969,
0.5282204151,
-0.2155274302,
-0.0658635572,
0.0756631494,
-0.4506168664,
-0.157185927,
-0.6401811242,
-0.6889181733,
0.0657191649,
-0.8083369136,
0.1967712939,
-0.60824579,
-0.1084666103,
0.3049182296,
0.3637337983,
-0.2019720078,
0.2279482782,
0.0058292649,
0.7623078823,
-0.5481040478,
0.5298731923,
0.7893148661,
-0.5923497081,
-0.3711281419,
0.2058149427,
-0.0534249283,
-0.680234015,
0.4255034626,
0.2919650376,
0.1962922961,
-0.1068913415,
-0.4386349916,
-0.1856349856,
0.6104236841,
0.2003506869,
-0.5589026213,
-0.2816087902,
0.2051235884,
0.4834635556,
-0.0147828069,
0.006387867,
0.4302030206,
0.3015624881,
-0.1754871458,
-0.388340205,
-0.0168316476,
-0.3024255037,
-0.1913802028,
0.3937210739,
-0.4823303819,
0.3946110904,
-0.0420201793,
-0.1483781487,
-0.4264148176,
0.9845120311,
0.196804449,
0.5755498409,
0.6302554607,
0.9088534117,
0.6045721173,
-0.1329037994,
1.0933786631,
-0.2432193905,
0.1823207438,
0.9495491385,
0.0610994697,
1.1091341972,
-0.0657737106,
-0.1881279945,
0.3996783793,
0.266208142,
-0.3054654896,
0.5388277769,
0.5649787188,
-0.4142329991,
0.0166049935,
0.3507567942,
-0.3424868286,
0.1438902915,
0.2658740878,
0.1655685604,
-0.0111352317,
0.2796576321,
0.3129670322,
0.1733503491,
-0.5274439454,
0.9767853618,
-0.2142201811,
-0.612024188,
0.4818380177,
0.0224187784,
0.9525448084,
-0.417668134,
0.2991582751,
0.0483549982,
0.2546645403,
-0.3692632914,
-1.0061017275,
0.1602597535,
0.1748492718,
-0.1317437291,
0.0496649519,
0.4772522748,
-0.5030878186,
-0.5562412739,
0.1192791834,
-0.0312322173,
-0.1448098123,
-0.0182964019,
-0.4558672309,
-0.1694619358,
-0.0829895288,
0.0573937111,
0.5812811255,
0.4881202579,
0.4066084325,
0.5358762741,
0.4808864594,
0.3998816311,
0.1568009555,
-0.0331477784,
0.5959935784,
-0.7106004953,
-0.4801318944,
-0.9663282633,
0.1231075153,
-0.3723161817,
-0.1169260815,
0.7360070944,
0.6734367609,
1.1970546246,
0.1198407039,
0.975917697,
0.172004953,
0.2278811336,
-0.4640293717,
0.6072140336,
-0.5137175322,
0.4280227423,
-0.5578089952,
-0.6079798937,
-0.427685082,
0.542632699,
-0.4593691528,
-0.3839380443,
0.7034646273,
0.6457824111,
0.4404061139,
0.3175703883,
0.1855315119,
0.1194607466,
0.5921517611,
0.8314771056,
0.8958883882,
-0.5451180935,
0.9992493987,
-0.4009138346,
-0.515532732,
-0.3036358058,
-0.4866571724,
-1.3267168999,
-0.2629516125,
-0.5824903846,
-0.7220315933,
0.5356781483,
0.3865551651,
0.3848124146,
-0.6725050211,
-0.0122152576,
-0.0399700962,
0.1793444306,
-0.3933082819,
-0.4137839973,
0.4367738068,
-0.791200757,
-0.5166273713,
0.3930312395,
0.1363606304,
0.0994897708,
-0.2594020665,
0.4967131019,
-0.0588194877,
0.0660016015,
0.6006418467,
0.143797785,
-0.3333223164,
-0.3256029785,
-0.1376719475,
-0.1810979545,
-0.191217795,
0.6834087968,
-0.7115048766,
0.2932388484,
0.3145054579,
0.9019877911,
0.1882586777,
-0.1168239638,
0.4902796447,
-0.9865833521,
0.2176360786,
0.3185802698,
0.2637219131,
0.1290858239,
-0.4747837484,
0.5335012674,
0.3695769608,
-0.4038934112,
-1.2510602474,
0.2571219802,
-1.0789059401,
-0.7971577048,
0.8749940395,
-0.0003770452,
-0.2071609497,
0.0267993677,
-0.2079620361,
0.0300022364,
-0.4050813019,
0.978977561,
0.6597940922,
0.3296323121,
-0.0674110204,
-0.71735394,
0.5666776299,
0.2981395423,
-0.9965391755,
-0.1112137362,
0.3125906289,
-0.0709410235,
0.2482771277,
0.2419105321,
-0.1368456483,
0.2803079486,
-0.0072518131,
-0.1712295115,
0.0369354747,
-0.5334941745,
-0.3448175788,
1.2456815243,
-0.2914100885,
-0.3554593623
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05126v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05126v1
|
Graph Neural Network and NER-Based Text Summarization
| 2024-02-05T03:00:44 | 2024-02-05T03:00:44 |
Imaad Zaffar Khan, Amaan Aijaz Sheikh, Utkarsh Sinha
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
With the abundance of data and information in todays time, it is nearly
impossible for man, or, even machine, to go through all of the data line by
line. What one usually does is to try to skim through the lines and retain the
absolutely important information, that in a more formal term is called
summarization. Text summarization is an important task that aims to compress
lengthy documents or articles into shorter, coherent representations while
preserving the core information and meaning. This project introduces an
innovative approach to text summarization, leveraging the capabilities of Graph
Neural Networks (GNNs) and Named Entity Recognition (NER) systems. GNNs, with
their exceptional ability to capture and process the relational data inherent
in textual information, are adept at understanding the complex structures
within large documents. Meanwhile, NER systems contribute by identifying and
emphasizing key entities, ensuring that the summarization process maintains a
focus on the most critical aspects of the text. By integrating these two
technologies, our method aims to enhances the efficiency of summarization and
also tries to ensures a high degree relevance in the condensed content. This
project, therefore, offers a promising direction for handling the ever
increasing volume of textual data in an information-saturated world.
|
[
-0.313208729,
-0.8308781981,
0.4053538442,
0.1040980518,
-0.3707123697,
0.3417653143,
0.0417014807,
-0.5091207623,
0.6807131171,
0.4938647747,
-0.1191263273,
-0.5808224082,
-0.6390671134,
0.2397448868,
-0.7068044543,
1.3443211317,
0.0498148762,
-0.1296259612,
-0.2365995944,
-0.0501293503,
-0.339592278,
-0.6252806783,
-0.9953709245,
-0.7671394944,
0.8494790196,
0.2309546918,
0.4900180101,
0.6027437449,
0.563113451,
0.3605573475,
-0.3982093632,
0.2766262889,
-0.6231248379,
0.1931349784,
0.0985719413,
-0.102587983,
-0.5934053063,
-0.3849113584,
0.8036667109,
0.7293339968,
0.2640869021,
0.0334733091,
0.2518105209,
0.9285849929,
-0.3229051828,
0.4251255393,
-0.1696772426,
0.2128884792,
0.1262326539,
-0.1665387899,
-0.1861851364,
-0.5494909286,
0.220709011,
-0.6840725541,
0.0491362736,
0.0025221747,
0.9827551842,
-0.0410975777,
-0.5928521752,
-0.2483454198,
-0.6438791752,
0.2342316061,
-0.7551048994,
0.1295636594,
0.0124916034,
0.0274172835,
-0.0363550596,
-1.0569041967,
-0.3666804135,
0.1201020554,
-0.2836140692,
0.3372474313,
-0.1718458086,
0.0720835105,
0.0392464772,
0.2416006327,
-0.6100241542,
0.045150876,
-0.2365646213,
-0.2347611636,
0.5290057063,
0.335607022,
0.5436581969,
-0.3512153625,
-0.1878158599,
0.1606774926,
-0.3381457329,
-0.2234877348,
0.5217558146,
0.3279194236,
0.0744912401,
0.5572500825,
-0.4423598349,
0.6289052367,
-0.2563322783,
0.0148306126,
0.1134576723,
-0.5066928267,
-0.3251481652,
0.5003281832,
1.0567883253,
0.6630010009,
0.3718048036,
-0.4277136326,
-0.1028980538,
-0.0987863541,
-0.0444300808,
-1.0747824907,
-0.3199539483,
-0.0812894255,
-0.678219974,
-0.4276928008,
-0.0969891921,
-0.8544062376,
-0.4386284947,
-0.5354003906,
0.218170315,
-0.4336600602,
-0.2769005299,
-0.2137337774,
-0.5777663589,
-0.0771222934,
0.5403282642,
-0.9689673781,
0.5705282092,
0.7298586369,
1.3676171303,
0.0212307908,
-0.1162860394,
-0.3580663502,
0.3684130609,
-0.1880880594,
0.8053256869,
-0.1544229984,
-0.3897722661,
-0.3514427841,
-0.1750680357,
-0.217557475,
-0.3355314732,
0.1434451938,
-0.6917675734,
-0.0291192867,
-0.0884975046,
-0.6473756433,
-0.5255816579,
0.416608274,
-0.7723120451,
0.9159734845,
0.0772019178,
-1.0708806515,
-0.0052412516,
-0.5709322095,
-0.7127827406,
0.0978556722,
-0.1196378767,
-0.5402479172,
0.038407959,
0.2637285292,
0.4853665233,
-0.0984281301,
0.161554575,
0.0185671821,
-0.4982976317,
0.1317930371,
-0.0840287432,
0.6080467701,
-0.1402342767,
-0.0457818918,
0.1941404641,
-0.6030802727,
0.0624596104,
0.1698471457,
-0.3745568097,
-0.4897658527,
-0.1275336593,
0.2388106585,
-0.0442221723,
0.2724709511,
-0.2507047057,
0.2019204348,
-0.5055473447,
0.7023051381,
0.3939421475,
0.3560952842,
0.5379231572,
-0.1694040745,
0.4140952826,
-0.2462611943,
-0.1978590935,
-0.2833826244,
-0.5616819859,
-0.5584154725,
0.0889681429,
0.7220472693,
0.981351912,
-0.8543553948,
0.3463347256,
-0.5189436078,
-0.5158978701,
0.2337064445,
-0.0499605685,
0.3146936595,
0.9362151027,
0.2586629987,
-0.3061836362,
-0.6286310554,
-0.6483607888,
-0.1919615418,
-0.1534941047,
0.0819020197,
0.4061786234,
0.5985693336,
0.0345721357,
0.8031147718,
-0.6320319772,
-0.4306542575,
-0.579646349,
0.1494267583,
0.3155333698,
0.4425835609,
0.3547338545,
-1.067858696,
-0.4812795818,
0.2044564486,
-1.121625185,
0.1988606602,
-0.0112380758,
0.0159399007,
-0.132597357,
0.9442924261,
-0.4372057617,
0.6307327747,
0.1852678508,
-0.2882893682,
0.4072507322,
-0.4692434371,
0.0243428294,
-1.0892057419,
0.2147883177,
-0.1672275811,
-0.3370390534,
-0.6226583123,
-0.3221156001,
-0.0490899049,
-0.3994815052,
-0.0291798878,
0.3555463552,
-0.7018158436,
-0.1496706307,
-0.3694550097,
0.4724068642,
0.2654106319,
0.396835804,
-0.2010092288,
0.5875810981,
0.2379250675,
-0.7709046006,
0.5886072516,
0.5592484474,
-0.0138624152,
0.3438531756,
-0.8245232105,
-0.0487495363,
-0.4109382331,
0.2960857153,
-0.7465956211,
-0.2169454843,
0.4380601048,
-0.6543940902,
0.4309275448,
-0.1212646142,
-0.5764104724,
-0.1301131546,
-0.0791939273,
0.2918408513,
0.1016008556,
0.0407328233,
0.9391024709,
0.5165071487,
-0.5549114347,
-0.6504111886,
-0.8320227861,
0.7834796906,
-0.0779858977,
-0.4228447676,
0.5250073671,
0.233238712,
-0.0065800142,
0.4711650312,
-0.0137374252,
-0.1125494987,
0.1996719986,
0.2528683245,
0.2692948282,
-0.2216039002,
0.2959665358,
0.1466795504,
-0.4695822895,
-0.0392238498,
-0.559505403,
0.5657286048,
-0.1597052366,
0.1626005769,
-0.462256521,
0.5802838802,
0.3203130066,
-0.3275986612,
0.7516313195,
0.4274843037,
-0.6016852856,
0.1325401366,
-0.081964992,
0.0852114335,
-0.3677232265,
0.6005760431,
-0.0657344833,
-0.795119822,
0.7418265343,
-0.3453393281,
-0.4539003074,
0.5140550137,
0.1478245109,
-0.1035386175,
0.7533356547,
0.6198167205,
-0.3265527487,
0.6955573559,
-0.5185493231,
0.3272629678,
-1.0811202526,
-0.3748050034,
-0.4694257379,
-0.6713219285,
-0.3804391325,
0.1380012035,
0.1958604157,
0.2199465334,
-0.0433583483,
0.392114222,
-0.8456428051,
0.6714977026,
0.4903203249,
0.2185015231,
0.3226422369,
-0.1395920217,
-0.2124433517,
0.2525218725,
-0.6458972096,
-0.4059735239,
0.9529589415,
0.03916426,
0.3912888169,
-0.0498139858,
0.8491482735,
0.2844200134,
0.2430613935,
-0.912003696,
0.8101277351,
-0.2417051345,
-0.1993205845,
-0.6038343906,
-0.6164662242,
-1.0279102325,
0.1401323229,
-0.2169291675,
-0.8288245201,
0.1708648354,
-0.0460557118,
-0.2214292288,
0.4245050251,
-0.6463511586,
0.8275097609,
-0.1257617176,
0.0639410093,
0.0807281733,
-0.8898359537,
0.051838506,
0.207020238,
-0.0380232036,
-0.0005326012,
-0.1832516342,
0.8864948153,
-0.4047406614,
0.6132778525,
0.0146381827,
0.3502101302,
0.3102732599,
-0.1884895861,
0.5293792486,
0.1910405606,
0.0624150895,
0.1111466959,
-0.5089666843,
-0.1606204063,
-0.7031262517,
0.7085255384,
-0.522377193,
-0.0104287378,
-0.4549820125,
-0.5906557441,
0.1908974499,
0.8894447088,
0.4429570436,
0.802477777,
-0.3604347706,
0.0267411359,
0.7590723038,
0.0368582904,
0.7244798541,
-0.133840099,
-0.4965992272,
-1.085689187,
1.1504714489,
0.5568535924,
-0.048807174,
0.6648035645,
-0.0373554006,
-0.1443819553,
-1.0073138475,
-0.5599533319,
0.2354042977,
-0.7905614972,
-0.3521547616,
-0.9831166863,
-0.5382326245,
-0.4517662823,
-0.2517849207,
0.2131786346,
-0.6384193897,
-0.5533366799,
-0.2148109823,
0.2933969498,
0.9048651457,
0.2741112411,
0.3619240224,
-0.9308373332,
0.4889769852,
0.0928537771,
0.3519255221,
0.2164888382,
-0.001412706,
-0.3737526238,
-0.3471766412,
-0.1481724232,
-1.060565114,
0.5663583875,
0.1658118665,
0.3934543431,
0.2111513019,
-0.2614655197,
0.3609037399,
-0.4589902759,
0.4436298907,
0.306620121,
-0.9506248236,
0.4401793778,
-0.5455947518,
0.3744278252,
0.5531876087,
0.182586357,
-0.8336114287,
-0.2286331505,
-0.5545212626,
-1.2688724995,
0.555459559,
0.372905761,
-0.0527698286,
0.1767003685,
0.60201478,
-0.2512804866,
0.4888949096,
-0.4149581194,
-0.3770662546,
-0.4380793273,
-0.5357687473,
-0.2200954556,
-0.069971621,
0.1322071701,
-0.0345300548,
0.8481655717,
-0.3146841228,
0.3182790875,
0.4483987093,
-0.2957277894,
0.5233693719,
0.1172156334,
0.7266693711,
0.5363651514,
-0.1055369452,
0.0685954466,
0.2478855401,
-0.8493416905,
0.0832332,
0.3812888563,
-0.6980742216,
0.2972077727,
0.2670327723,
0.7945315242,
0.1973374039,
-0.1473562866,
0.3316047788,
-0.2880051434,
-0.1689330786,
-0.2623199224,
-0.123720549,
0.4115333557,
0.1268923432,
0.3733443916,
0.2805685103,
0.4199526906,
-0.2383906394,
0.1720191389,
0.1275761724,
-0.6222519875,
-0.0651995838,
0.5652471781,
0.1924293339,
-0.4971647263,
0.7930240631,
-0.1669626385,
-0.5469695926,
1.1267312765,
0.6067732573,
0.9127944708,
0.2080866992,
0.3602227569,
0.3571862876,
0.237528652,
0.0619647913,
0.2065870017,
0.1009298861,
-0.5806211829,
-0.3811387718,
-0.2127416581,
-0.4658672214,
-0.2093404531,
-0.4210264981,
0.1084704101,
-0.6098852158,
-0.3521451652,
0.2113428861,
-0.1541731209,
-0.2058844715,
0.3375504613,
0.0154835079,
0.8164021373,
-0.5819960833,
0.3144717515,
0.7131488919,
-0.5712403655,
-0.7346634269,
-0.2097798586,
-0.1274994165,
-0.3609077632,
0.6344123483,
0.3902006149,
-0.0411613323,
0.4292418361,
-0.1022077948,
-0.7621363997,
1.3008201122,
0.324924022,
-0.2349707484,
-0.5555415154,
-0.1309809536,
0.5593534708,
-0.3559271097,
0.3061546385,
0.2707249522,
0.4619773328,
-0.1007056087,
-0.6325644851,
0.0674216822,
-0.516487062,
0.1216416061,
0.8033725023,
-0.6821482182,
0.8247326016,
-0.2663634717,
-0.1823461801,
-0.1036322117,
0.7873299718,
-0.3140211999,
0.7355173826,
0.1751109809,
0.6423221827,
0.9892706275,
-0.3163018227,
0.9151086807,
-0.1694407016,
0.3178539872,
1.2435847521,
-0.0616909117,
0.4456204474,
0.1508090198,
0.2189879417,
0.6829690933,
0.4769773185,
-0.0506096631,
0.2817822397,
0.2206390649,
-0.2697639465,
0.1660174578,
-0.4388319552,
-0.3482978046,
0.3032017946,
0.423404485,
-0.4792081118,
-0.3357157707,
0.0259046517,
0.135709554,
0.11486426,
-0.626975894,
1.1436157227,
0.1902076155,
-0.3384523094,
-0.1059572399,
-0.1567789912,
0.1695785075,
-0.5512201786,
-0.0981394872,
0.0967727304,
0.057130836,
-0.3874281347,
-0.6665334702,
0.3316693604,
-0.301041007,
-0.4078122377,
-0.2524413466,
1.2872503996,
-0.2377859652,
-0.421905905,
0.4056626856,
0.3767326772,
0.0643423274,
-0.1641284227,
-0.4401780963,
-0.3217324317,
-0.23155801,
-0.0917989239,
0.2506539524,
0.5837678909,
-0.0311899297,
0.5853794813,
0.5526770949,
0.2888287008,
-0.2010360211,
0.2429688126,
0.9829567671,
-0.8310374022,
-0.9484645724,
-0.9171012044,
0.3519461453,
-0.6043686271,
-0.235159874,
0.7136890888,
0.961388886,
0.4426026344,
0.1469604224,
0.8209245205,
0.1513609737,
0.3324632943,
-0.4616908133,
1.1602765322,
-0.128315717,
-0.1533028781,
-0.4203251004,
-0.9160369039,
-0.555873692,
0.263139993,
-0.1099388227,
-0.041361928,
0.7736513615,
0.2448833585,
0.2057002038,
0.2400227785,
-0.0143101905,
-0.0255298615,
0.2595333755,
0.464284271,
0.5726563931,
-0.6783987284,
0.8282631636,
0.1026670113,
-0.1225056201,
-0.4017150402,
-1.0157334805,
-0.8141738772,
-0.3277695477,
-0.367284894,
-0.3413209915,
0.0586768575,
0.3074439764,
0.3534220159,
-0.7893921733,
-0.059228614,
-0.4417645037,
0.509098351,
-0.2898278832,
-0.2197434455,
0.5399860144,
-0.0416346788,
-0.4545506239,
0.1964023411,
0.6155645847,
0.5082757473,
0.1466156095,
0.0234957822,
-0.2865830362,
-0.0329087079,
0.4654829502,
0.3190990388,
-0.0997251421,
-0.1046662033,
0.1065469682,
-0.1738915592,
0.1649989486,
0.9205175638,
-0.8922009468,
0.2925110757,
0.8999353647,
0.8629679084,
0.5545530915,
-0.0222647227,
0.4227401614,
-0.4807970226,
-0.1721716672,
0.2526912093,
0.3436525762,
0.4876320362,
-0.6555890441,
0.5723152161,
0.2582605481,
-0.6834146976,
-0.621042192,
0.031162262,
-1.0407367945,
-0.1257999539,
0.5813857317,
-0.0555473827,
-0.1859876961,
-0.3605407178,
-0.4356228113,
0.7549594045,
-0.4808647335,
0.3956193626,
0.6338528395,
-0.3096080124,
0.0113732135,
-0.4139567018,
0.1543362737,
-0.0283523481,
-1.0644087791,
-0.1592181474,
0.3435743153,
0.0335878395,
0.4834497571,
0.7194962502,
0.0483074486,
0.0991388038,
0.1458218396,
-0.153970331,
-0.4809996784,
-0.3971506357,
-0.4027788937,
0.5430011749,
-0.5965069532,
-0.1679899842
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.06655v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.06655v1
|
Adversarial Text Purification: A Large Language Model Approach for Defense
| 2024-02-05T02:36:41 | 2024-02-05T02:36:41 |
Raha Moraffah, Shubh Khandelwal, Amrita Bhattacharjee, Huan Liu
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Adversarial purification is a defense mechanism for safeguarding classifiers
against adversarial attacks without knowing the type of attacks or training of
the classifier. These techniques characterize and eliminate adversarial
perturbations from the attacked inputs, aiming to restore purified samples that
retain similarity to the initially attacked ones and are correctly classified
by the classifier. Due to the inherent challenges associated with
characterizing noise perturbations for discrete inputs, adversarial text
purification has been relatively unexplored. In this paper, we investigate the
effectiveness of adversarial purification methods in defending text
classifiers. We propose a novel adversarial text purification that harnesses
the generative capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) to purify
adversarial text without the need to explicitly characterize the discrete noise
perturbations. We utilize prompt engineering to exploit LLMs for recovering the
purified examples for given adversarial examples such that they are
semantically similar and correctly classified. Our proposed method demonstrates
remarkable performance over various classifiers, improving their accuracy under
the attack by over 65% on average.
|
[
-0.399833709,
-1.2708351612,
0.3776669204,
-0.2326401323,
-0.2322191,
0.2395533919,
-0.3385484517,
-0.2219852507,
-0.2537111342,
0.728693068,
-0.3009088039,
-0.4896594882,
-0.7495952249,
0.1187474206,
-0.9429648519,
1.2185180187,
0.2663384974,
-0.0305886958,
-0.0072177695,
0.3179576993,
-0.0480570383,
-0.735933125,
-0.7873629332,
-0.2731241584,
0.4214724302,
-0.1279993951,
0.7385162711,
0.6082578301,
0.4738231897,
0.4445552528,
-0.6364627481,
0.1272639483,
-0.4887878001,
0.4482398629,
0.0297608953,
-0.4636114836,
-0.1577151269,
0.1971477121,
0.5360252857,
0.3728481233,
0.0079227146,
-0.415701896,
0.2332774997,
0.4644539356,
-0.6799997687,
-0.3130863607,
-0.962875545,
0.1190758198,
-0.3817565739,
-0.1646010429,
-0.7567392588,
-0.1951867044,
-0.1092106327,
-0.4965869784,
0.397934705,
-0.279910326,
0.9730786085,
0.345615983,
-0.2850188911,
-0.216327399,
-0.888828516,
0.7379467487,
-0.6691038609,
-0.1057111993,
0.2822899818,
0.2574570179,
-0.4838757217,
-0.6726716161,
-0.5514873266,
-0.286344856,
-0.0330712497,
-0.0090505863,
-0.4305031896,
0.4231666028,
0.3343854249,
0.479180783,
-0.679825902,
0.1254514605,
-0.2558782995,
-0.3638543189,
0.5581462979,
-0.217033878,
0.6565124989,
-0.0964695662,
-0.5905950665,
-0.2202071249,
-0.8050091267,
-0.1794957817,
0.6382681727,
0.2326639295,
0.5075799823,
0.3579170406,
0.0188075602,
0.6576786041,
-0.0592974164,
-0.2190889865,
-0.2427993715,
-0.1233742908,
-0.2485429347,
0.1402382851,
0.9749930501,
-0.3185288012,
0.2721969485,
-0.3020225465,
-0.4200839698,
0.2211802304,
0.6320756674,
-0.864641726,
-0.4215067625,
0.1403028518,
-0.4769428074,
-0.7694407105,
-0.0648903176,
-0.9090672135,
-0.8668324947,
0.0765853673,
0.4391227365,
-0.4187855721,
-0.017738536,
0.1053691283,
-0.1790442467,
-0.0286365915,
0.1736439914,
-0.8351115584,
0.2078245878,
0.864893198,
0.5086324811,
0.0001635785,
-0.075749509,
-0.6431622505,
-0.243895635,
-0.244843334,
0.8230152726,
-0.2978785932,
-0.4846907258,
0.1018741131,
-0.2628468573,
0.0243328903,
-0.6620218158,
0.8681508899,
-0.9872182608,
0.1788835078,
0.2725333869,
-0.517896831,
-0.3598273993,
0.418982476,
-0.8651573658,
0.4775060117,
-0.3411999941,
-0.749319315,
-0.163841486,
-0.3338271379,
-0.6354598999,
0.0898247808,
0.1010108665,
-0.5920724869,
0.1008129865,
0.3771074712,
0.3013108373,
-0.3241566718,
0.3452449143,
-0.6162618399,
-0.2268362641,
0.4852074385,
-1.012856245,
1.0625343323,
0.4029545784,
-0.1196696013,
0.2725794911,
-0.8857072592,
-0.0299700331,
0.1379674524,
-0.368483156,
-0.4434167147,
0.0705675483,
-0.1183925718,
0.1379793733,
0.1802643836,
-0.5568621159,
0.2354134917,
-0.7668013573,
0.6882877946,
0.779024899,
0.0650211573,
0.2662774026,
-0.1657904834,
0.5691941977,
-0.2609802186,
0.141837433,
-0.1091653854,
-0.3555882871,
-0.6495419741,
-0.6097656488,
0.3034281731,
0.4762854874,
-0.9749370217,
0.4148356915,
-0.1482185423,
-0.4274598956,
-0.3721932471,
0.2308096886,
0.4865721762,
0.3580910563,
0.3348590434,
0.280954957,
-0.5472615957,
-0.7363301516,
-0.2177397609,
-0.2763544619,
-0.1830980033,
-0.1805657893,
0.4559704959,
-0.2335265875,
0.7022235394,
-0.5269105434,
-0.2018411011,
-0.2145490944,
0.0413931794,
-0.1025094613,
0.1759409457,
0.4474688768,
-1.0568344593,
-0.2241109014,
-0.1294306368,
-0.6912109256,
-0.2593488097,
-0.0172705892,
-0.1095421836,
-0.0393669233,
0.7637078762,
-0.6521226764,
0.3193747997,
0.4222756326,
-0.3897919655,
0.5324434638,
-0.0393281206,
0.1747236848,
-1.0148199797,
0.0743463039,
-0.0728975758,
-0.3900483251,
-0.8719815016,
0.422857672,
-0.0994909182,
-0.5505013466,
-0.4544925392,
0.4072160423,
-0.0734896436,
0.4684442878,
-0.6466978788,
0.1741663218,
0.2787776887,
0.2014115453,
-0.1262979209,
0.6148964763,
0.3961179852,
-0.6462116838,
0.6008650064,
0.295263499,
-0.0754984021,
0.5102777481,
-0.6976566315,
0.0610010885,
-0.030459065,
0.3466048241,
-1.0988043547,
0.1265515387,
0.285713613,
-0.5317049026,
0.5423595905,
-0.1520119607,
-0.5042341948,
-0.2063930631,
-0.2522164583,
0.1694844961,
0.4421750903,
-0.9505783319,
0.5240087509,
0.2672411501,
-0.1400479227,
-0.6320467591,
-0.5527575612,
0.3565211892,
-0.4608354568,
-0.4923217297,
0.4137972891,
-0.0625567809,
-0.2413923442,
-0.0138683449,
-0.0276083034,
-0.1266728491,
0.6256778836,
0.165335536,
0.3962468803,
-0.0549589992,
0.06486471,
-0.2058766782,
-0.1216177493,
0.2001341283,
-0.2889584899,
0.5070300698,
0.2862303555,
-0.1859559566,
-0.4097610414,
0.4210543334,
0.6698158383,
-0.1623125225,
0.7413084507,
0.5210617781,
-0.5466113091,
-0.351228863,
-0.5359879136,
-0.1633851677,
-0.551748693,
0.5539947748,
-0.4060591459,
-0.5820855498,
0.281087935,
0.041527357,
-0.043684788,
0.5625793934,
0.0787793547,
0.1461769044,
1.1763825417,
0.2400180101,
-0.3290722668,
0.5938789248,
-0.1839280427,
0.1710543782,
-0.6277407408,
-0.065857932,
-0.8588927984,
0.0047792522,
-0.2893637121,
0.0984887853,
0.0374898687,
0.261721909,
-0.3092951179,
0.2094792277,
-0.51472193,
0.4771830142,
0.6430815458,
0.2487231493,
0.1693120748,
0.2737196684,
-0.1268263608,
-0.0317870416,
-0.4145063758,
-0.7056577802,
0.8190398812,
0.3757008612,
0.7111158371,
0.1094750091,
0.7889974117,
0.3175801039,
0.3211152554,
-0.7883424163,
0.8230073452,
-0.7237976193,
-0.5795638561,
-0.1722833812,
-0.6526999474,
-1.0004709959,
0.3825743794,
-0.3200211823,
-0.6440403461,
-0.0702768415,
-0.1483813673,
-0.2963842452,
0.6532977223,
-0.4186601341,
0.6474304795,
0.0160613582,
-0.0738285929,
-0.1621100754,
-0.1893762797,
0.5355606675,
-0.2936067283,
0.1573176831,
0.4185331762,
0.1917497218,
0.7717477083,
-0.5219076276,
0.8035281301,
-0.031351693,
-0.5065620542,
0.2695350349,
0.1307469457,
0.6359448433,
-0.2955674231,
0.0453797914,
-0.0730278492,
-0.3462173939,
-0.2067128122,
-0.8326852322,
0.7642909884,
-0.7376648784,
-1.0781362057,
-0.3519391418,
-0.1715458035,
0.0861234292,
0.3072769642,
0.4725643098,
0.478579402,
-0.2300043404,
0.3442088962,
1.1139210463,
-0.4919066131,
0.6178663373,
0.4765227139,
0.2176807225,
-0.7843060493,
1.0550239086,
-0.106553264,
0.3116410077,
0.5859612823,
0.1631550938,
-0.3937563002,
-0.7427696586,
-0.3422175348,
-0.0148711149,
-0.7748259902,
-0.402008146,
-0.7721418738,
-0.46298334,
-0.4891491234,
0.0084523885,
-0.225835517,
-0.2443543971,
-0.4124446213,
0.1337151825,
0.1460639685,
0.6387805343,
0.2850894034,
0.2676563859,
-0.8446121812,
0.5360192657,
0.4630484879,
-0.0789868459,
-0.0535488054,
-0.7781949043,
-0.0411139876,
0.1073205844,
-0.554715097,
-1.0160243511,
0.5465161204,
0.0681592077,
0.4657086134,
0.4844668508,
0.4497202039,
0.3731895983,
-0.5477535725,
0.8448939323,
0.0784472972,
-0.9667387605,
0.6564362049,
-0.1707602739,
0.2026878744,
0.2975838184,
0.1342941821,
-0.1560547948,
-0.7284352779,
-0.6948450804,
-0.900906086,
0.4739481509,
0.2267486453,
-0.122504808,
-0.0062780166,
0.3887419403,
-0.3635030985,
0.0742643848,
-0.6189581156,
-0.1630391479,
-0.1176576465,
-0.3287377954,
-0.2961514294,
-0.4915772676,
-0.3517174721,
0.534060955,
1.0098553896,
0.4377439022,
-0.1091231033,
0.1242164001,
-0.2494663149,
0.3788217902,
0.4912145734,
0.4969563186,
-0.2904835343,
0.2821403742,
0.3128107786,
-0.1249219999,
-0.6835538149,
0.6730049849,
0.5283610821,
-0.4818273485,
-0.2866312861,
0.4085413814,
0.4639377892,
-0.077358827,
-0.4947167933,
0.6115151048,
-0.3361140788,
-0.0336791463,
-0.1042601466,
0.0969085991,
-0.3160655499,
0.2243192196,
0.3580510318,
0.1668975204,
0.4225604236,
-0.2162319571,
0.2694090903,
0.6438581944,
-0.4120028019,
-0.1299226731,
0.7222272158,
0.2568727434,
-0.2656096816,
0.4306509793,
-0.1163871884,
-0.8433659673,
0.5536933541,
0.6195914149,
1.0544359684,
-0.3444830179,
0.1021298915,
0.1930783093,
0.2745956779,
-0.2109022737,
-0.3227720857,
0.010068832,
-0.6534721851,
-0.3849311769,
-0.6872050762,
-0.092713438,
0.5233381391,
-0.5210466385,
0.0083568329,
-0.5290926695,
-0.2020466924,
0.2072390914,
0.1798104048,
-0.0630997568,
0.3264016211,
0.2883839905,
0.5651855469,
-0.7270453572,
0.5815289021,
0.6716070771,
-0.191254124,
-0.4771534503,
0.1044326648,
0.2205832452,
-0.2766963243,
0.6657437086,
0.1420707554,
-0.2026821226,
-0.2352795452,
-0.3881526887,
-0.5316839218,
0.4013066888,
0.5225226879,
-0.314510107,
0.1757451147,
-0.1722687036,
0.6412095428,
0.2235171646,
-0.0046262122,
0.2726536393,
0.263589114,
-0.1050152928,
-0.4264949858,
0.3063304424,
-0.5957866311,
0.139493674,
0.1824651659,
-0.46443519,
0.6370922923,
0.0079156375,
-0.5372756124,
0.4676069319,
0.7619262934,
0.1911311895,
0.0118302852,
0.5911053419,
0.6119080186,
0.7351893187,
-0.130388096,
0.9900848269,
-0.2018237859,
0.1471928358,
0.9009765387,
-0.1152252182,
0.7431548834,
0.1028212756,
-0.093631275,
0.1796417236,
0.3875528574,
-0.0802718624,
0.4362719655,
0.5233175755,
-0.6618794799,
-0.1777579784,
-0.1000205055,
-0.2618306279,
0.4680415094,
0.327711314,
-0.4545447826,
-0.1652531773,
0.48595649,
0.0900188014,
0.4654919505,
-0.2345243394,
0.9752297997,
-0.1373259872,
-0.7467415333,
0.8538360596,
0.0334327109,
0.6874108911,
-0.548840344,
0.1252324879,
0.0429225676,
0.5073238015,
-0.0883377716,
-0.4697523117,
0.1827711612,
0.1119676828,
-0.39304322,
-0.1985852569,
0.8848108053,
-0.4502298534,
-0.1623251289,
0.2915778756,
-0.2050094306,
-0.0352351032,
-0.3614761829,
-0.3223109841,
0.009551418,
0.0941365585,
-0.3396113813,
0.3435072005,
0.3144808412,
0.4575380981,
0.8546067476,
0.6735323668,
0.443696171,
-0.2391885072,
0.2111495435,
0.8754737377,
-0.4267256856,
-0.3727423847,
-1.2649388313,
0.2036705017,
-0.1372724921,
-0.0081113698,
0.8314953446,
0.377599597,
0.4692358077,
0.0877893493,
0.8992294669,
0.4540849328,
0.3350563943,
-0.5857356787,
0.8784210086,
-0.2531067133,
0.639203608,
-0.1397295594,
-0.6275913715,
-0.5006049871,
0.4381749332,
-0.1607424617,
-0.1645420045,
0.5793177485,
0.8218697309,
0.2064594477,
0.2504223287,
0.4450480938,
0.4488416612,
0.8186346292,
0.4529179633,
0.9783633947,
-0.5739240646,
1.1572617292,
-0.117754437,
-0.299957186,
0.0528814383,
-0.595554769,
-1.0884014368,
-0.2774659395,
-0.4678666592,
-0.7901508808,
0.4180019498,
0.4698594213,
0.5129294395,
-0.7699626684,
0.3210768402,
-0.1801074594,
0.2015081197,
-0.0836381838,
-0.2983704507,
0.4037391245,
-0.3832697272,
-0.9453716874,
0.6042041183,
-0.0236348677,
0.2663386166,
-0.5096962452,
0.4072444439,
0.0310510099,
0.057086762,
0.4457866848,
0.2716674805,
-0.7250825167,
-0.0432662442,
-0.262413919,
-0.4170711637,
-0.3668551147,
0.5741671324,
-0.6819611788,
0.3811752796,
0.6901772618,
1.020347476,
0.0003253689,
0.0160308778,
0.5357221961,
-0.7448202968,
0.1166980416,
0.2984513938,
0.4291724861,
0.3354990482,
-0.6099701524,
0.137693733,
0.3070954382,
-0.5411320329,
-0.9301103354,
0.4962501526,
-0.5444393158,
-0.655428946,
1.476033926,
-0.5547386408,
-0.218807146,
-0.1246886179,
-0.3469404876,
0.3351293802,
-0.2381493896,
0.9197247028,
0.7851284146,
0.7017415762,
0.1547897756,
-0.2100023329,
0.5638439059,
0.2030740678,
-0.7247818708,
0.1551098675,
0.2824894786,
0.0316447206,
0.2933490276,
0.1441065073,
-0.3437350988,
0.0268019959,
0.1504394412,
-0.1803634763,
0.02242947,
-0.3248369098,
-0.6389433742,
0.628700912,
-0.0873497725,
-0.3277672827
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02680v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02680v1
|
Large Language Models are Geographically Biased
| 2024-02-05T02:32:09 | 2024-02-05T02:32:09 |
Rohin Manvi, Samar Khanna, Marshall Burke, David Lobell, Stefano Ermon
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) inherently carry the biases contained in their
training corpora, which can lead to the perpetuation of societal harm. As the
impact of these foundation models grows, understanding and evaluating their
biases becomes crucial to achieving fairness and accuracy. We propose to study
what LLMs know about the world we live in through the lens of geography. This
approach is particularly powerful as there is ground truth for the numerous
aspects of human life that are meaningfully projected onto geographic space
such as culture, race, language, politics, and religion. We show various
problematic geographic biases, which we define as systemic errors in geospatial
predictions. Initially, we demonstrate that LLMs are capable of making accurate
zero-shot geospatial predictions in the form of ratings that show strong
monotonic correlation with ground truth (Spearman's $\rho$ of up to 0.89). We
then show that LLMs exhibit common biases across a range of objective and
subjective topics. In particular, LLMs are clearly biased against locations
with lower socioeconomic conditions (e.g. most of Africa) on a variety of
sensitive subjective topics such as attractiveness, morality, and intelligence
(Spearman's $\rho$ of up to 0.70). Finally, we introduce a bias score to
quantify this and find that there is significant variation in the magnitude of
bias across existing LLMs.
|
[
-0.5708910227,
-0.7099459767,
0.9150981307,
0.034377791,
0.0738329664,
-0.1936612129,
-0.7216242552,
-0.4759681821,
0.2518540323,
0.7392118573,
-0.2955444753,
-0.8360742927,
-0.9251508713,
-0.3780391514,
-0.1718434393,
0.9359126687,
0.0702288225,
0.228988871,
-0.1122202575,
-0.2708880901,
-0.2630519271,
-0.8033034801,
-0.0191889163,
-0.4751089811,
0.4393895864,
0.3621560335,
1.0409470797,
0.3794057369,
0.4933856428,
0.2621415257,
-0.4044881463,
-0.0678831339,
-0.6967551708,
0.086178638,
-0.4980922937,
-0.4576219916,
-0.137228623,
0.1357726306,
0.6252374053,
1.0761532784,
-0.0305566303,
0.3884452283,
-0.0202075597,
0.5062353611,
-0.4881344736,
0.0374227241,
-0.6852908731,
0.0988922641,
-0.198574245,
-0.0108920997,
-0.1037916616,
-0.5084798932,
0.4715030193,
-0.331117481,
0.4462169409,
0.2064224482,
0.7639978528,
0.2918026149,
-0.6965737939,
-0.353358686,
-0.7603338361,
0.9356567264,
-0.4203166068,
0.2693232596,
0.4560587704,
0.3007412851,
-0.2927468121,
0.0009382297,
-0.3322981894,
-0.236318782,
-0.0096284375,
-0.1541773528,
0.060352657,
-0.1166896895,
0.4077641368,
0.1425769329,
-0.4849728048,
0.1099191383,
-0.4119588137,
-0.0484297052,
0.5976493955,
0.0684599355,
0.4666652083,
-0.2667551637,
-0.0596919619,
0.1805259883,
-1.113432765,
-0.0726216659,
0.5359220505,
0.3904308677,
-0.3112295866,
0.5328188539,
0.000134602,
0.7999972105,
-0.0911298096,
-0.3151907623,
0.0659263283,
0.1604339033,
-0.1303411573,
-0.0425446369,
0.5709626675,
0.5072173476,
0.6561880708,
-0.1062981188,
0.0957723558,
0.0419337451,
0.134438917,
-0.5107828975,
0.1939922422,
-0.0280329529,
-0.2571298778,
-0.1032070816,
0.0734019056,
-0.8698840737,
-0.621381402,
-0.4468784928,
-0.1347584873,
-0.0557439551,
-0.0901778787,
-0.0081271371,
0.1779539436,
0.1975943595,
0.2779912949,
-0.8477998972,
0.0142524904,
0.9067642093,
0.8310059309,
0.0786578581,
-0.5211709142,
0.0284089055,
0.0311084408,
-0.4151239395,
0.8092974424,
-0.4515120983,
-0.3837900162,
0.0723609701,
0.0089694168,
0.4533339143,
-0.4861585796,
0.5833687186,
-0.5659527779,
0.1064192578,
-0.836914897,
-0.0465492718,
-0.2672073841,
0.3696831167,
-0.5828376412,
0.9245560765,
0.0290749148,
-0.7025464773,
0.5731604695,
-0.3704007864,
-0.3669139147,
-0.2321161926,
-0.2359434366,
-0.0792577192,
0.3198416233,
0.3052664399,
0.3445630968,
-0.4357438684,
0.8092339039,
-0.6448860168,
-0.4988444746,
0.2269257307,
-0.4953992069,
0.8393215537,
0.0312435627,
-0.6617226005,
-0.2799277306,
-0.5870578885,
-0.1825605631,
0.0408090428,
-0.1092186719,
-0.5285972357,
0.14461869,
-0.1557301879,
0.3054631948,
0.1597736627,
-0.5168600678,
0.1051684618,
-0.3620899022,
0.2786637545,
0.9300989509,
-0.3346331716,
0.8626229167,
-0.1180429235,
0.3452028036,
-0.1057875827,
0.1350326985,
0.2969244123,
-0.3462220132,
-0.5897101164,
-0.1753521115,
0.0479839556,
0.3893708587,
-0.2254070193,
0.4171164632,
-0.6518769264,
-0.5762881637,
-0.160861209,
0.0413252339,
0.0681052655,
0.4219738543,
0.0133026373,
-0.1998241693,
-0.515648663,
-0.7729546428,
-0.4392538965,
-0.0796868429,
-0.0971387029,
0.6131746173,
0.6561222076,
-0.1208540499,
1.119977951,
-0.5077087283,
-0.147915408,
0.0865404904,
-0.228941232,
0.2565584481,
0.0736094266,
0.7124575377,
-0.690472424,
-0.2135248333,
-0.0935953557,
-1.0502158403,
-0.3423124254,
0.3904313743,
-0.1793878376,
0.0038756144,
-0.0070834225,
-0.71047014,
0.3537429273,
0.8154703379,
-0.5702899098,
0.3786609173,
-0.0323279165,
0.0219469555,
-0.6055980921,
-0.0599611066,
0.3029108346,
-0.1141163483,
-0.2600414157,
0.1384121925,
-0.3480445147,
-0.0996130258,
-0.3299417198,
0.7314905524,
-0.5165324211,
-0.6113628149,
-0.1399540007,
0.427115649,
-0.0484988168,
0.0675096214,
0.0953927785,
0.5927422047,
0.4854828119,
-0.2517239153,
0.3414117396,
0.006853933,
-0.6784225702,
0.6826678514,
-0.4480418265,
-0.1056932434,
-0.5969295502,
0.710745275,
-0.6485105753,
-0.3409307003,
-0.1112333685,
-0.3145653009,
-0.1094589233,
-0.2641946673,
-0.2810641527,
-0.4042998254,
0.0563346595,
0.1999643892,
0.4881936908,
-0.6615467668,
0.4553524852,
0.7907296419,
-0.1448739916,
-0.8070881963,
-0.8909494877,
0.1558011919,
-0.3449262679,
-0.5787365437,
-0.2649661601,
0.168561846,
-0.8413410187,
-0.0071884575,
0.0427248329,
-0.0196676832,
0.0364935435,
0.7035953403,
0.2114832252,
-0.122643359,
-0.0352667123,
-0.4211900234,
0.0467775874,
0.3250970542,
-0.5588418245,
0.421238929,
-0.1066985875,
-0.4495678246,
0.1783461869,
0.2583782375,
0.6314947605,
0.0275256969,
0.8429896235,
0.2829990387,
-0.460518837,
-0.1431286633,
-0.6280700564,
-0.0418174118,
-0.3701054156,
0.4822755158,
-0.1555957198,
-1.1817269325,
0.6075308919,
-0.0459986664,
-0.0980152413,
0.2552801967,
0.7656907439,
0.0222462676,
0.6704537272,
0.6763657928,
-0.5004511476,
0.2115217596,
-0.1667530537,
0.5366082788,
-0.6045911312,
-0.2435621917,
-0.6521007419,
-0.312171042,
-0.8737844825,
-0.5879304409,
0.5268422961,
0.0082956161,
-0.823990047,
-0.1955984682,
-0.3204867244,
0.8401379585,
0.491779238,
-0.0397449657,
-0.0616318583,
0.3726186156,
-0.2035536915,
-0.3867312372,
-0.6378563046,
-0.804572463,
1.1755691767,
0.4314116836,
0.9734786153,
0.1253870577,
0.3000769913,
0.173612535,
0.832347393,
-0.5625939369,
0.3141304851,
-0.171523869,
-0.8539910913,
-0.3413403928,
-0.4054692984,
-0.5647560358,
0.4454416633,
-0.1117046177,
-0.6778148413,
0.1592458189,
-0.0338021554,
-0.2414516658,
0.5541986227,
-0.3612520993,
0.4976712763,
-0.4748301506,
-0.4862146676,
0.0394870527,
-0.7653114796,
0.5375217199,
0.0401041508,
0.7301878929,
-0.4951986969,
0.202361837,
0.2761847973,
-0.1009148359,
0.9761187434,
-0.2933077216,
-0.3536762893,
0.1992417127,
0.0955700576,
0.1763571054,
0.2096712142,
-0.3017565906,
0.773724556,
-0.3606009483,
-0.6216105819,
-0.5571832061,
0.9898992181,
-1.2543928623,
-0.5622535944,
-0.5327334404,
-0.6084429622,
-0.035765592,
0.0934620574,
0.252941519,
0.3156608045,
-0.4946552813,
-0.1884272099,
0.802036345,
-0.5341323018,
-0.0507972687,
0.5928242803,
-0.3213154972,
-0.3455877304,
0.4542150497,
0.2057202458,
0.2084858865,
0.1444425583,
0.2299758494,
-0.3603252172,
-0.1871973574,
-0.1435031295,
0.4184240103,
-0.8952347636,
-0.0839602202,
-0.3896079063,
-0.0622081123,
-0.3415223062,
-0.5447695851,
-0.1927729696,
0.0109572755,
-0.0088554183,
-0.2279519141,
0.104709819,
1.0104054213,
-0.2713192701,
0.4679616392,
-0.4093450308,
0.1024715453,
0.0227348749,
0.2925263345,
-0.1309556812,
-0.6397043467,
-0.1422357708,
0.1959763467,
-0.1398713291,
-0.6532399058,
0.3882743418,
-0.201584965,
0.3168659806,
0.3696639836,
-0.16420573,
0.767993331,
-0.8910172582,
0.9778549671,
-0.0069067939,
-0.9107404947,
0.4584358335,
-0.3617784977,
0.2486292571,
0.3165708184,
0.6324001551,
-0.6261875033,
-0.6013706923,
-0.5023972988,
-0.6742537618,
0.3306416571,
-0.5080525875,
0.3977530897,
-0.099917084,
0.5535265803,
-0.0356603637,
0.1131532714,
-1.0202236176,
-0.324026674,
-0.0336378515,
0.0121182371,
-0.4474347532,
-0.5644122362,
-0.4407577217,
-0.0699951798,
0.4292643368,
-0.081600368,
-0.0051154182,
0.2831065059,
-0.1311800182,
-0.3610783815,
0.4571698606,
0.6595184207,
1.1706075668,
-0.1388345957,
0.5304775238,
0.3246453404,
-0.3515782654,
0.4619220197,
-0.2005985975,
-0.4043164849,
0.1610284597,
0.5011765957,
0.6718609929,
0.2361186594,
-0.5279191136,
0.6308882833,
0.1422754973,
0.0237134248,
-0.5173565149,
-0.4243122637,
0.1496245712,
0.366651088,
0.3118371964,
0.0493390746,
-0.0254359487,
-0.6648186445,
-0.0799979046,
0.6722348332,
-0.3491412699,
-0.3781733215,
0.4926839471,
0.2438000888,
-0.0816987231,
0.5056966543,
-0.1332883835,
-0.8563266397,
0.4995156527,
0.4614019394,
0.4117938876,
-0.2085286528,
0.1034575105,
0.435310185,
0.7799794674,
-0.2183336169,
0.0126560051,
0.3193469048,
-0.9050638676,
-0.4899073541,
-0.8617907763,
-0.236769259,
0.0781222731,
-0.4190560579,
0.2311499417,
-0.4602333605,
-0.2633337975,
-0.3378397822,
0.1977598667,
-0.691180706,
0.315674603,
0.4453285635,
0.7966799736,
-1.1750692129,
0.4555583298,
0.6358050704,
0.1309446692,
-0.5431295037,
0.04832156,
0.2274527699,
-0.8921819329,
1.0959848166,
0.1836475581,
-0.0942538008,
-0.5758060813,
-0.7955242395,
-1.1971818209,
0.7790260911,
0.5564523339,
-0.7269477248,
-0.0538307242,
0.3239452243,
0.6554032564,
-0.2841359973,
0.4582160711,
0.6013488173,
0.5032539368,
-0.1458869278,
-0.9401451349,
0.0433368422,
0.4035267532,
0.298293978,
0.2097484022,
-0.8164137006,
0.8725904226,
-0.3761077821,
0.011624,
-0.2857050002,
0.5056842566,
0.4392045438,
0.1768731028,
0.2728557885,
0.6053125262,
0.7376592755,
-0.3059313297,
1.1187499762,
-0.4919858277,
0.6859886646,
1.0405791998,
-0.6935303211,
0.5538788438,
0.2985315323,
-0.3041804433,
0.5576350689,
0.6878653169,
0.169376865,
0.4256227016,
0.5924056768,
-0.3392766416,
-0.1239779443,
-0.1887513846,
-0.2154415548,
0.7459210157,
0.3725384176,
-0.3175157905,
-0.4126731455,
-0.0557943247,
0.3610244691,
0.1586841345,
-0.4167567492,
0.2181087434,
0.2001481056,
-0.6133463383,
0.2923468649,
0.0600774884,
0.7458201051,
-0.5202814937,
0.17855075,
-0.2424845099,
0.0799664259,
-0.2351269871,
-0.9004923105,
0.3950852156,
0.1217657775,
-0.333473146,
-0.1131410897,
0.6973501444,
-0.4022070467,
-0.4991781116,
0.4326973557,
0.4262506068,
0.2874967754,
0.0026851282,
-0.4651717246,
0.34032166,
-0.1361062825,
-0.3094900548,
0.2524856925,
0.5973703861,
-0.1293925792,
0.751349926,
0.5700833797,
0.476269722,
0.0228239764,
-0.1299281865,
0.5119069815,
-0.7716389298,
-0.4215045571,
-1.1053655148,
-0.0591848418,
-0.0797491968,
-0.161621958,
0.890301466,
0.4534939528,
0.7697356939,
0.2580308914,
0.9313544631,
0.0909011066,
0.4176400602,
-0.4053186774,
0.6857585907,
-0.2279860079,
0.2494491786,
-0.0374444127,
-1.0540255308,
-0.3200301826,
0.8858697414,
-0.9769437909,
0.1928184032,
0.4850950837,
0.6299020052,
0.0467730686,
-0.0895893201,
0.245893389,
0.3053250909,
0.1939563751,
0.5402886868,
0.9675530791,
-0.0880672261,
0.0210728627,
-0.0496652648,
-0.4399927557,
0.0129590947,
-0.884699285,
-0.937035203,
-0.1111890972,
0.2101459205,
-0.5777288675,
0.1163036153,
0.7021478415,
0.8706348538,
-0.5761556625,
-0.4630993605,
0.3374878168,
0.5164884925,
0.4426062405,
-0.2998812795,
0.2021905333,
0.0577378087,
-0.6586741805,
-0.1428286582,
0.4565520585,
-0.0676965341,
-0.7891045213,
0.0515553094,
0.1525763124,
-0.0644697323,
0.76460886,
0.0245075673,
-0.9889701009,
-0.5036426187,
-0.2582623363,
-0.327555567,
-0.0945891291,
0.8737888932,
-0.5584143996,
0.0209712945,
0.1137972921,
0.396571219,
0.1755066663,
-0.0672952011,
0.4766874313,
-0.6924912333,
0.428801775,
0.0610344559,
0.3479293883,
0.7285434604,
-0.4235273302,
0.4113791883,
0.2721162736,
-1.0308358669,
-0.6691522002,
0.2534570992,
-0.4577832818,
-0.2219030559,
1.4176996946,
-0.1244126409,
-0.4537877142,
0.1137949824,
0.0658978373,
-0.1221544668,
-0.121361956,
0.8349994421,
1.0613037348,
0.2463764697,
0.0753864795,
-0.9817540646,
0.2711728215,
0.2800103426,
-0.6237995028,
-0.0303053688,
0.9280217886,
0.8356807828,
0.2947050333,
0.6700547934,
-0.0463090017,
-0.1409676969,
-0.167409569,
0.1120252833,
0.5460438132,
-0.251185447,
-0.4804385304,
0.1819462627,
0.1364856362,
0.478824079
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02662v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02662v1
|
Image-Caption Encoding for Improving Zero-Shot Generalization
| 2024-02-05T01:14:07 | 2024-02-05T01:14:07 |
Eric Yang Yu, Christopher Liao, Sathvik Ravi, Theodoros Tsiligkaridis, Brian Kulis
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recent advances in vision-language models have combined contrastive
approaches with generative methods to achieve state-of-the-art (SOTA) on
downstream inference tasks like zero-shot image classification. However, a
persistent issue of these models for image classification is their
out-of-distribution (OOD) generalization capabilities. We first show that when
an OOD data point is misclassified, the correct class can be typically found in
the Top-K predicted classes. In order to steer the model prediction toward the
correct class within the top predicted classes, we propose the Image-Caption
Encoding (ICE) method, a straightforward approach that directly enforces
consistency between the image-conditioned and caption-conditioned predictions
at evaluation time only. Intuitively, we take advantage of unique properties of
the generated captions to guide our local search for the correct class label
within the Top-K predicted classes. We show that our method can be easily
combined with other SOTA methods to enhance Top-1 OOD accuracies by 0.5% on
average and up to 3% on challenging datasets. Our code:
https://github.com/Chris210634/ice
|
[
-0.2485637814,
-0.1942032129,
0.4332271218,
-0.1817327291,
-0.6016315222,
0.0110890521,
0.0338182822,
-0.3645506203,
0.0306510478,
0.4869461954,
-0.2499759048,
-0.697563529,
-0.6789227128,
-0.0441741832,
-0.2644703388,
0.8773286343,
-0.195647493,
0.2003485709,
-0.3923382461,
-0.3429456353,
-0.393801719,
-0.4325310886,
-0.3744945526,
-0.2657181323,
0.1214294285,
0.7897601128,
0.7322027087,
0.8803958297,
0.6746438146,
0.0857260153,
0.2654566467,
0.0589516684,
-0.530277431,
0.0031283302,
-0.0514945984,
-0.6227930784,
-0.2410922945,
-0.2767572105,
0.6061816216,
0.4529860616,
-0.3710951507,
0.0790632367,
-0.3584626913,
0.7171869278,
-1.091397047,
0.3985391855,
-0.7037426233,
0.2262640148,
-0.078709662,
-0.4485199749,
-0.5880813599,
0.0211867187,
-0.0127253719,
-0.8116708398,
0.4827646613,
0.3210048974,
1.1115620136,
0.3757539093,
0.0020118137,
0.2381763756,
-0.706413269,
0.9466069341,
-0.5074554682,
0.3049465418,
0.3922494948,
0.5590115786,
0.0763555095,
-0.3161191344,
-0.6469248533,
-0.0394425988,
0.0896928832,
0.4154955149,
-0.3255170286,
0.2178876996,
0.000707746,
0.4992275238,
-0.4988026917,
0.226205498,
-0.4609942138,
0.0855496973,
0.7052491903,
0.0109391613,
0.3523705602,
0.3068016469,
-0.397287637,
-0.2991090119,
-0.7521139383,
-0.2781872749,
0.1377524436,
0.2074402869,
-0.3840244114,
0.6051595211,
-0.2432150692,
0.6169118881,
0.2785930336,
0.1489265114,
0.4002833664,
0.0055284612,
-0.3689228296,
0.1610257328,
0.5091557503,
0.7318247557,
0.1174048185,
-0.2865539789,
-0.1336865574,
0.2028615922,
-0.0092893103,
-0.942106843,
-0.2642234862,
0.2595376372,
-0.3169551492,
-0.3857689202,
0.1358529329,
-0.8198706508,
-0.4994899929,
-0.0893803835,
0.5062507987,
-0.2467999309,
-0.1478866786,
0.355114609,
-0.4360213578,
0.4026115239,
0.3373655379,
-1.0167484283,
0.3524774313,
0.046954114,
0.816536665,
-0.0969620049,
-0.132186383,
-0.7136151195,
0.414773643,
-0.6327474713,
0.9398406744,
-0.639868021,
0.1719462126,
0.0801534057,
-0.4437653124,
0.0369332805,
-0.7044605613,
0.1292665005,
-0.6370918751,
0.1427056044,
0.13440606,
-0.5981644988,
-0.1764969975,
0.1153452173,
-0.5031353831,
0.6641104221,
0.2400209904,
-0.778583765,
0.5859228969,
-0.7303475142,
-0.1782726794,
0.3438825011,
-0.5297091603,
-0.7397034168,
0.3019810319,
0.5704213381,
0.4968490303,
-0.3070640862,
-0.0199374277,
-0.3705392778,
-0.5575299859,
-0.0037392396,
-0.081084542,
0.3590523005,
0.2950215638,
-0.3710046411,
-0.0169769134,
-0.63872087,
-0.1340255886,
0.3786617517,
0.0358743705,
-0.261356473,
-0.2509990633,
-0.2358873934,
-0.1775556058,
-0.0793133974,
-0.7523422241,
0.321349144,
-0.1442855,
0.4377645254,
0.5314729214,
0.0822142512,
0.8684774637,
-0.1129515991,
0.6062256694,
0.4728678167,
0.1741895378,
-0.5303057432,
-0.5568865538,
-0.6819794774,
-0.2872830629,
0.2588571906,
0.6596015692,
-1.3305051327,
0.2479768544,
-0.2793682814,
-0.4069119692,
-0.479996562,
-0.0363606997,
0.5388915539,
0.4521480799,
0.4744932055,
-0.6391835809,
-0.3695552945,
-0.5755480528,
0.1945362538,
0.0902230591,
0.0035960674,
0.2695305049,
0.4872784019,
-0.0704596117,
0.9848155975,
-0.9756655097,
-0.5323116183,
-0.4175461829,
0.2207545936,
0.1335047334,
0.6919643879,
0.8400862217,
-0.7918475866,
-0.7107768059,
0.0922945589,
-0.9298582077,
0.2201742828,
-0.0344690084,
-0.2378451675,
0.3553953767,
0.5352925062,
-0.543477416,
0.6155871749,
0.4617809355,
-0.0486379415,
0.4441951215,
-0.3475623131,
0.2177729458,
-0.6636229157,
-0.0961562619,
0.0806526393,
0.0203246344,
-0.9520119429,
0.3176713884,
0.1020845398,
-0.462190181,
-0.4862573445,
0.4908933342,
-0.5847688317,
0.071470812,
-0.0231921263,
-0.0714154169,
0.0206876453,
0.4805892408,
0.39206779,
0.651078403,
1.273070097,
-0.4568109512,
0.1976100653,
0.1864750683,
-0.3415037692,
0.7631898522,
-0.4368368387,
0.2931894958,
-0.8826137185,
0.2317872047,
-1.0673820972,
-0.5598436594,
0.438264817,
-0.4500052333,
0.7000165582,
-0.3905327916,
-0.4175122678,
-0.119225949,
-0.3584324419,
0.6541656852,
0.7357771397,
-0.6299780011,
0.4287143648,
0.0506949164,
0.1371469051,
-0.7148525715,
-0.9830352068,
0.0272008758,
-0.1744671017,
-0.2959206402,
0.3791572452,
-0.2123254836,
0.0852088928,
0.0933676139,
-0.3042432964,
-0.3853525817,
-0.3709472418,
0.1690613776,
0.428581804,
-0.2199804634,
0.1111503616,
0.0903934762,
-0.045216985,
-0.4728836417,
-0.5428522825,
0.3537206948,
-0.0254874211,
-0.2365289927,
-0.5234822631,
0.2867414653,
0.4686114192,
-0.1522550583,
0.9042656422,
0.3784001768,
-0.3303260803,
-0.1501212567,
-0.4204460382,
-0.3246616721,
-0.4294762909,
0.1958021224,
-0.2049286813,
-0.5586678982,
0.4952859879,
0.2486572564,
-0.1509920508,
0.2372731864,
-0.1604638398,
-0.4402142763,
1.0044835806,
0.733400166,
-0.0099974787,
0.673643589,
-0.6614155769,
0.1165229678,
-0.4417225718,
-0.2012235075,
-0.2356814295,
-0.1169765219,
-0.356888175,
-0.2783292234,
0.4016715288,
0.1042785645,
-0.0875078142,
0.3234081566,
-0.4226692319,
0.7462239265,
0.6644316316,
0.349123925,
0.0291920882,
0.7171135545,
0.2021576762,
-0.0068665734,
-0.9206196666,
0.0476963297,
1.1473963261,
0.1802668124,
0.8722689152,
-0.1505087465,
0.954626441,
0.4722494185,
0.3412338495,
-0.6025117636,
0.3998838663,
-0.6036998034,
-0.6979632378,
-0.3445603848,
-0.5130720139,
-0.8053056002,
0.0419140458,
-0.2579629421,
-0.5442721844,
0.3860300481,
0.5468685031,
-0.3770747185,
0.4858511388,
-0.7332628369,
0.9174844623,
0.0069172676,
-0.1244618073,
0.0500651076,
-0.7201996446,
0.2442857027,
0.2589607239,
0.280146122,
-0.0247435961,
0.1142897233,
0.3141565621,
-0.4142962098,
0.991140008,
-0.5203611851,
0.1841929555,
0.4578499496,
-0.1047128364,
0.252469033,
-0.5314185023,
0.2744430304,
0.5596575141,
-0.136704579,
-0.7083186507,
-0.8131052852,
0.1082190052,
-0.8482251167,
-0.3191132545,
-0.5179638863,
-0.4157958925,
0.0251491424,
0.1298364252,
0.6718860269,
0.65387398,
0.4216376841,
0.1681137085,
0.8024384379,
-0.190919593,
0.2862850428,
0.375697583,
-0.0901406556,
-0.754509449,
1.1583212614,
0.1997985393,
0.4951503575,
0.7153073549,
0.2092742026,
-0.1302222162,
-0.8882044554,
-0.8626161218,
0.1897708178,
-0.9746724367,
-0.5783041716,
-0.055347044,
-0.1617621034,
-0.5254482031,
-0.5106099844,
-0.2245215476,
-0.2949294448,
-0.351574719,
-0.1047793478,
0.2120353132,
0.4629229009,
-0.1066308245,
0.6703267694,
-0.7032638192,
0.4338585138,
0.1649284959,
0.5477050543,
-0.110540919,
-0.8622199297,
-0.1960719377,
-0.2450930476,
-0.2086342126,
-0.7812120318,
0.3825248778,
0.5484378934,
0.5639424324,
0.6664706469,
0.3830906451,
0.7172401547,
-0.3461454213,
0.6862510443,
0.7166794538,
-0.7574126124,
0.5944820046,
-0.1150760502,
0.4740967155,
0.4442262948,
0.4382981956,
-0.278985709,
-0.5085842609,
-0.5774857402,
-0.8556756973,
0.9189755321,
0.3520156145,
0.3667767942,
0.0828778744,
0.4094235897,
0.3245959878,
0.2727861106,
-0.7660399675,
-0.4014636278,
-0.5235908031,
-0.2900239825,
-0.0277993735,
-0.3051893413,
0.0083546899,
-0.0305883624,
0.5893028975,
-0.2247076035,
0.2429269254,
0.2254320383,
-0.0903943479,
-0.4240363836,
0.3073269725,
0.7083224058,
0.4770832062,
-0.4801129997,
0.2661048472,
0.0340015851,
-0.5694560409,
0.1143174097,
-0.0241083279,
-0.7145503163,
0.0033929725,
0.3023591638,
0.948905468,
-0.1120157987,
-0.6121720672,
0.6270720363,
0.0398349054,
-0.3098631799,
-0.165796116,
0.1044002846,
-0.6568769813,
0.0007373514,
0.5679539442,
0.3840819597,
0.1889724582,
-0.65093714,
-0.031659089,
0.2056466192,
-0.4210870862,
-0.2036042958,
0.6740341187,
0.0978071541,
0.191067934,
0.6611306667,
-0.528890729,
-0.2476937175,
0.6348562837,
0.5730700493,
0.9703330398,
-0.0452339724,
0.338360399,
0.505317688,
0.2426500618,
-0.1087580919,
0.5410639644,
-0.1186827719,
-0.98107481,
-0.303334862,
-0.3126921058,
-0.5737594366,
0.0112220952,
-0.7702417374,
0.2294274271,
-0.4738509059,
-0.0016183688,
-0.0715083554,
-0.5044898391,
-0.6102172136,
0.4591180384,
0.4377433062,
0.7653874755,
-0.9748485684,
0.6268574595,
0.8945500851,
-0.72002846,
-0.4416201115,
-0.0913448557,
-0.2927154899,
-0.7962642908,
0.5544863939,
0.2385116667,
-0.1052386761,
-0.0015169957,
-1.1177339554,
-0.7908909321,
1.1575157642,
0.7392970324,
-0.5829561949,
0.2388297617,
0.2551836967,
0.3584802151,
-0.5969489217,
0.0579816476,
0.3365547359,
0.2036420405,
0.6609113216,
-0.6236763,
-0.1499208957,
-0.023782393,
0.1313069761,
0.0334138758,
-0.3633891344,
0.3537668586,
-0.6777986884,
-0.3956860304,
0.1778590977,
0.6155031323,
0.2260300666,
0.7733332515,
0.3913652003,
0.7008321285,
0.412086606,
-0.0862833112,
1.0825382471,
-0.0199203491,
0.3531530201,
1.2027410269,
-0.2295584977,
0.8771104217,
0.4414455891,
0.0683263317,
0.4703928232,
0.4346256554,
-0.3223356903,
1.1006046534,
0.0722506791,
-0.0615240484,
-0.2618039548,
-0.2695254087,
-0.1591353863,
0.3798394501,
0.0998552814,
-0.3284053802,
-0.2051101178,
0.1272228658,
-0.0542182997,
0.0989946276,
-0.6773762703,
0.6242364645,
-0.1755666733,
-0.4601280689,
0.8356517553,
-0.2603773177,
0.5363036394,
-0.2977777123,
-0.2957502902,
-0.554361105,
0.0674229413,
-0.4163351953,
-0.8787871003,
0.0429353155,
-0.0711892024,
-0.1657786369,
-0.037138544,
0.5205665827,
-0.5714015961,
-0.4181284606,
-0.0766598359,
-0.0403123945,
0.5415675044,
-0.1092195734,
-0.2829164565,
0.1077361107,
-0.2219115347,
0.3004484177,
0.1472382993,
0.1498938203,
-0.0372540168,
0.5363216996,
0.368545264,
0.0063155149,
0.1257567257,
0.3192999363,
0.6727676392,
-0.4745178819,
-0.3406409621,
-0.6956304908,
0.6073296666,
-0.115763396,
-0.0209137052,
0.1935146749,
0.4833582342,
1.0414170027,
-0.7373615503,
0.8387759924,
-0.0672435015,
-0.0843662322,
-0.5875071883,
0.5843935609,
-0.5893343091,
-0.1407822818,
-0.0799495131,
-0.8995015025,
-0.8934032321,
0.3857561946,
-0.2617041469,
-0.0075531113,
0.4844940603,
0.5604140759,
-0.2756037116,
-0.4905586243,
0.7289075255,
-0.0368756875,
0.0856947377,
0.4318313301,
0.6570609212,
-0.6838171482,
0.7801683545,
-0.4557203352,
-0.392677933,
-0.2931908071,
-1.0674614906,
-0.8312070966,
-0.2928083837,
-0.9300495982,
0.1202482134,
0.2636493742,
0.5821326971,
1.0839655399,
-1.1373730898,
-0.0978440419,
-0.315453738,
-0.1835449934,
-0.479642868,
-0.165487349,
0.2766541541,
-0.361127913,
-0.6419197917,
-0.0165504981,
0.5417715907,
0.3021532893,
-0.0276095457,
-0.2845483422,
0.2893358171,
0.1478415579,
0.5115337968,
0.4478412867,
-0.5883550048,
-0.3190360665,
-0.0152018908,
0.1578194201,
0.4784854949,
0.4614869356,
-0.35242939,
0.7597070932,
0.3179940581,
0.2885807455,
0.5986599922,
0.1136448383,
0.3191272616,
-0.9134876728,
0.0222423207,
-0.0507005826,
0.3809424937,
0.5008308887,
-0.1984879822,
0.6593770385,
0.3057718277,
-0.1801360995,
-0.9166709185,
0.3038654923,
-0.9230858088,
-0.0251289718,
0.8578480482,
-0.4681894779,
-0.1607201248,
0.1647756249,
-0.2156852186,
0.1066063643,
-0.5558255315,
1.0023516417,
0.339574039,
-0.1620284766,
-0.6790415645,
-0.2564264238,
0.2075150013,
0.1957463324,
-0.7671746612,
-0.0438841246,
0.4888699055,
0.3081170022,
0.3648522496,
0.5477437377,
-0.0152162472,
0.5352568626,
0.3089012802,
0.4595723748,
-0.1866341829,
-0.5320723653,
-0.5568112731,
0.1105070785,
0.1736217439,
-0.6698963046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02658v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02658v1
|
Multi-step Problem Solving Through a Verifier: An Empirical Analysis on Model-induced Process Supervision
| 2024-02-05T00:57:51 | 2024-02-05T00:57:51 |
Zihan Wang, Yunxuan Li, Yuexin Wu, Liangchen Luo, Le Hou, Hongkun Yu, Jingbo Shang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Process supervision, using a trained verifier to evaluate the intermediate
steps generated by reasoner, has demonstrated significant improvements in
multi-step problem solving. In this paper, to avoid expensive human annotation
effort on the verifier training data, we introduce Model-induced Process
Supervision (MiPS), a novel method for automating data curation. MiPS annotates
an intermediate step by sampling completions of this solution through the
reasoning model, and obtaining an accuracy defined as the proportion of correct
completions. Errors in the reasoner would cause MiPS to underestimate the
accuracy of intermediate steps, therefore, we suggest and empirically show that
verification focusing on high predicted scores of the verifier shall be
preferred over that of low predicted scores, contrary to prior work. Our
approach significantly improves the performance of PaLM 2 on math and coding
tasks (accuracy +0.67% on GSM8K, +4.16% on MATH, +0.92% on MBPP compared with
an output supervision trained verifier). Additionally, our study demonstrates
that the verifier exhibits strong generalization ability across different
reasoning models.
|
[
-0.3768458962,
-0.7189632058,
0.7359976172,
0.1853179485,
-0.0760681853,
0.1133454219,
0.3110703528,
-0.4642236829,
-0.3292596042,
0.5413617492,
-0.3785500526,
-0.052188348,
-0.9293872118,
-0.0188973639,
-0.2630799115,
0.9533839226,
-0.4916619062,
0.2864922285,
-0.2840224206,
0.3460876644,
-0.2712469399,
-0.5810416937,
-0.6467615962,
-0.6224394441,
0.1969999522,
0.6102235913,
0.5356344581,
0.6688702106,
0.7092885971,
0.3255883455,
0.100778915,
0.4537391663,
-0.056694746,
0.1188613549,
0.0197151992,
-0.768018961,
-0.4734232426,
0.2105285525,
0.1921975911,
0.4139713943,
-0.2253164947,
0.4183399081,
0.1153140515,
0.6684353948,
-0.885707438,
0.0891555175,
-0.4207897782,
0.0488745645,
-0.0408401266,
-0.4744054079,
-0.5809991956,
-0.2035651803,
-0.2167979181,
-0.4506236017,
0.5395403504,
0.0278807227,
0.7900797725,
0.4224595428,
-0.4899147451,
-0.2415091693,
-1.1808748245,
0.5926631093,
-0.5423604846,
-0.0032332977,
0.4776978791,
0.7536680102,
-0.2093902975,
-0.6063878536,
-0.6522687674,
0.0041190009,
-0.1319215596,
0.041332677,
0.1459966749,
0.0860872269,
0.9329409003,
0.3245339096,
-0.1902719289,
-0.2654563487,
-0.6036634445,
-0.2412166595,
0.7182372808,
0.0911590233,
0.1975040883,
0.0994426534,
-0.4900246859,
0.0149461366,
-0.5775129199,
0.4153112173,
0.3413760066,
0.0070770867,
0.0684192032,
0.6373027563,
-0.3918876946,
0.5882672668,
0.1715982556,
-0.2970483005,
0.4283831418,
-0.4442445636,
-0.3250450194,
-0.1768887341,
0.5197356939,
0.2979863882,
0.3209338188,
0.0794309452,
-0.2762709558,
0.1700371504,
0.4349664748,
-0.8866404295,
-0.2101549804,
0.3852827549,
-0.211337477,
-0.1603042781,
0.1141611636,
-0.4746700525,
-0.4303042293,
-0.575586617,
0.4308258295,
-0.328110218,
-0.1462787241,
0.0085073458,
-0.1183388829,
0.2444259822,
0.7197501063,
-0.7323146462,
0.3274651766,
0.8542070389,
0.9821900129,
0.2944405079,
-0.2317048311,
-0.7371547818,
0.1866322905,
-0.5490301251,
0.7390369773,
-0.4071725905,
-0.3656589985,
-0.1711744219,
-0.1398210227,
-0.1153445914,
-0.4160320759,
0.9337384105,
-0.321177572,
-0.0199105702,
-0.3214749396,
-0.5406793952,
-0.127723515,
0.295053333,
-0.353844136,
1.2949033976,
-0.216495052,
-0.7469354868,
0.5273249745,
-0.7353872657,
-0.1227747425,
-0.1713888347,
-0.3576834202,
-0.5574465394,
0.044978708,
0.448336333,
0.5968131423,
-0.2137964368,
0.2115221918,
-0.4422166944,
-0.3993387818,
0.1059308276,
-0.2872581184,
0.6874732971,
0.0849678144,
-0.2567919493,
0.117878437,
-0.778617084,
0.127940625,
0.0262165572,
-0.3012134731,
-0.1927239597,
-0.0241279788,
-0.2964927852,
0.6549631357,
0.05089885,
-0.8225458264,
0.3654398024,
-0.2338457555,
0.1861504316,
0.5426884294,
0.1929987967,
0.2228378803,
-0.4247041345,
0.3629775345,
0.2622555792,
0.322616905,
-0.3972827196,
-0.640937984,
-0.8596702814,
-0.0471383855,
0.1567855775,
0.7432034016,
-0.6916025281,
0.1768459082,
-0.0473867841,
-0.8353356123,
-0.3147998452,
0.4117583334,
0.5843366385,
0.7485745549,
0.4435523748,
-0.1721970886,
-0.320481956,
-0.8745084405,
-0.1846855283,
-0.091407299,
-0.2685718834,
0.0379888788,
0.6028165817,
-0.0384324156,
0.7751728892,
-0.3716883063,
-0.2298373431,
0.0263549611,
0.4464845657,
0.4359681308,
0.7771078944,
0.2998078465,
-0.8482998013,
-0.5162099004,
-0.0363299288,
-0.8445589542,
-0.0518836118,
-0.1969669163,
-0.123234421,
0.2087832242,
0.4475359023,
-0.3555992842,
0.6801610589,
0.3168301284,
-0.2565971613,
0.7417691946,
-0.7696556449,
0.3984939456,
-0.6700688004,
0.1812371016,
0.3835962415,
-0.2431179732,
-0.7106819749,
-0.0976436958,
0.2806161642,
0.0358367078,
-0.0716774389,
-0.0689259693,
-0.4797132015,
0.0743991882,
-0.522236526,
-0.3121286333,
-0.037443053,
0.4330894649,
0.035764914,
0.8324828744,
0.6230065823,
-0.6424588561,
0.3609773517,
0.0028093061,
-0.2502758801,
0.4410260916,
-0.8524389267,
0.2421363592,
-0.1019159183,
0.2332493663,
-1.1962913275,
-0.0823483989,
0.4451237917,
-0.4307162166,
0.3182138801,
-0.4637867808,
-0.8073067069,
-0.5673038363,
-0.1365552247,
0.0495492481,
0.330644995,
-0.4791256487,
0.8304387927,
0.1137534752,
-0.1476800591,
-0.6037642956,
-0.5784665942,
-0.1050372794,
-0.1861411333,
-0.6093627214,
0.2230575532,
-0.0157567095,
-0.0915470198,
-0.5868784189,
-0.4183517396,
-0.2894197702,
0.2373510897,
0.7097552419,
0.4474175572,
0.1809680313,
-0.2666805983,
0.351452589,
-0.5825980902,
0.5236570239,
0.2124645412,
0.1424369067,
0.1305834055,
-0.810477376,
-0.7123925686,
0.2888239324,
0.6621417403,
-0.2666808963,
0.4511259794,
0.3996781111,
-0.5030719638,
0.0345797539,
-0.6006430387,
-0.1710805893,
-0.4630244374,
-0.2621231675,
-0.843061924,
-0.3804520369,
0.4789015651,
-0.5414507389,
0.3263651729,
0.1211946607,
0.3545594215,
-0.2002611011,
1.4403326511,
0.6114575267,
-0.082886219,
0.2152785361,
-0.2508313954,
0.3259873092,
-0.7403714657,
-0.2374331951,
-0.6247441173,
-0.1298581809,
-0.2679250836,
-0.4111728966,
0.5168957114,
0.5335303545,
-0.2396266907,
0.2954906225,
-0.5787326694,
0.3337510824,
0.6758956909,
0.2711381316,
0.3973601162,
-0.1784870476,
-0.1327304989,
0.0116702234,
-0.5066385865,
-0.7570812106,
1.3407744169,
0.4954890907,
0.2745024264,
0.096961163,
0.7915316224,
0.3477047384,
0.387022227,
-0.3534361422,
0.1672359258,
0.4089768231,
-0.6961407661,
-0.2816365659,
-0.1344909668,
-0.2459455729,
0.4494743347,
-0.1001343057,
-1.0551019907,
0.1999948621,
0.7085614204,
-0.4403051138,
-0.012842563,
-0.7020680308,
0.7649285197,
-0.1541393399,
-0.7302895188,
-0.3040770888,
-0.5866794586,
0.6365764737,
-0.1459585875,
0.4466978908,
-0.1075560302,
0.1660444289,
0.6931544542,
-1.0042170286,
0.7377157807,
-0.7416581511,
-0.2886725068,
0.2700725496,
-0.0454655997,
0.8983541727,
0.1262525618,
-0.1480442584,
-0.1250230968,
0.1867284179,
-0.3933572173,
-0.8253138661,
0.3718228936,
-0.4223777056,
-0.7792261839,
-0.5713641644,
-0.1516317725,
-0.2666152716,
0.0096167326,
0.184193179,
-0.0210013315,
0.5075643063,
-0.2499034554,
0.5924525857,
0.449976176,
0.3212410808,
0.3661124706,
-0.4049369991,
-0.1357045472,
0.5496783257,
0.2247958481,
0.1309338659,
0.0336062461,
0.0520685911,
0.1148339435,
-0.547706306,
-0.7731120586,
-0.0242635272,
-0.5915902257,
-0.1667047292,
-0.5103210807,
-0.0911427215,
-0.2787526548,
-0.0818844363,
-0.4153001308,
-0.2176257074,
0.1409832686,
-0.1003692076,
0.1715537906,
0.3767472208,
-0.2185126096,
0.5082626939,
-0.6096523404,
0.495876193,
0.074958615,
0.1443734169,
-0.2096821964,
-0.5439426303,
-0.2939374149,
0.1465591788,
-0.4615049064,
-0.8683857322,
0.0593707934,
-0.0488446392,
0.5150651336,
0.6920877695,
-0.0728564113,
0.7805586457,
-0.4311329126,
0.4275293946,
0.1206415594,
-1.0884820223,
0.8766103983,
-0.1096711159,
-0.017727416,
0.5129344463,
0.5063721538,
-0.1864571422,
-0.3400179744,
-0.5625444055,
-0.696511507,
0.7396736741,
0.2077458501,
-0.0827511698,
0.4970000088,
0.5646523833,
-0.0240995493,
-0.0661300942,
-0.3190045357,
-0.4086666107,
-0.0566994138,
0.4555941522,
0.0210252721,
-0.4990572631,
-0.1200421974,
-0.3239144683,
1.0456395149,
-0.150914669,
0.0551838391,
0.3427628279,
-0.025767779,
-0.2474488169,
0.2138182819,
0.3466996551,
0.6696078777,
-0.0871445313,
0.0154958805,
0.0664548948,
-0.2707267106,
0.3327325881,
0.2183572203,
-0.3762517869,
-0.0092140883,
0.2859356105,
0.4258995354,
-0.1033686996,
-0.2092079818,
0.510507822,
0.0692892075,
-0.3247514069,
-0.3967528641,
0.4344222546,
-0.0983428657,
0.2841531634,
0.5380088091,
0.2341124713,
0.5055068135,
-0.0802110136,
0.1378152668,
0.1939135939,
-0.1203880757,
-0.065491274,
0.6737496853,
0.0444316939,
-0.2473689318,
0.5155297518,
-0.1032321155,
-0.415649116,
0.6879431605,
0.5349989533,
0.3182173669,
-0.5064669251,
0.0277522933,
0.7076650858,
0.3052031696,
-0.265245527,
0.6536947489,
-0.5361971855,
-0.7409937978,
-0.7319309115,
-0.383138001,
-0.7984554172,
-0.1449763626,
-0.8208866715,
0.2345714271,
-0.6580992937,
-0.2286865562,
0.3393532038,
-0.143383503,
-0.5178412795,
0.4071626961,
0.1838288903,
1.0484377146,
-1.0955160856,
1.052785635,
0.5797498822,
-0.4408364594,
-0.8557534814,
-0.2059888393,
0.1727531999,
-0.5062642097,
0.625274837,
0.422485292,
-0.1921015382,
-0.1079425886,
-0.3987805545,
-0.7713196278,
1.1139587164,
0.2281900793,
-0.7778761387,
0.2222795933,
0.1557233632,
0.3842120171,
-0.0724708065,
0.5390095711,
0.5671164393,
0.5296074748,
0.123757422,
-0.9291325212,
0.0105027901,
-0.6061944962,
-0.0406910367,
0.279384762,
-0.1138343364,
0.5534121394,
-0.5303018689,
-0.0369355083,
-0.086375691,
0.75057441,
0.5576144457,
0.6004881263,
0.5048125982,
0.4112776816,
0.7803887129,
-0.0086844536,
0.8675374389,
-0.5234313011,
0.3404315114,
1.4397298098,
-0.4203598499,
0.7243416309,
0.7620828748,
-0.4497667253,
0.6310048699,
0.4609624445,
-0.006230806,
0.1163335741,
0.3837076128,
-0.3008960187,
-0.4519353509,
0.1616455168,
-0.1135239452,
0.4591159225,
0.2911883891,
-0.5875096917,
-0.2680194676,
0.0369029045,
0.0590385534,
0.1654386073,
-0.1993937343,
0.4592883885,
-0.1937321723,
-0.7210519314,
0.116946198,
0.2272524834,
0.476451993,
-0.4895239472,
-0.2160435319,
0.1056246012,
0.3322071135,
-0.3759386539,
-0.6140022874,
0.4603150785,
0.1029370949,
-0.2590585053,
-0.4209766984,
0.8433461189,
0.0359961241,
-0.5874977112,
0.1417163014,
0.6112941504,
0.158298105,
-0.3099084198,
-0.5283514261,
-0.1656074971,
-0.2202885002,
-0.4692850113,
0.030429123,
0.2810016274,
-0.1110845804,
0.8473064899,
0.8086018562,
-0.0839964971,
0.121130228,
-0.0667736754,
0.695317626,
-0.3765614331,
-0.3593190014,
-1.08638978,
0.6865721345,
-0.449883461,
-0.3019171357,
0.833524406,
0.8328124285,
0.9355484247,
0.028540168,
1.0392882824,
-0.0467741862,
0.5833640695,
-0.4368095696,
0.347325623,
-0.0851758942,
0.241172418,
-0.2199600339,
-0.579012692,
-0.2758049965,
0.5965248346,
-0.6996252537,
-0.1130937561,
0.430873394,
0.8723887205,
-0.2332423329,
0.1469696015,
0.1903386861,
-0.2685190439,
0.3988429606,
0.5867100358,
0.6139784455,
-0.5629378557,
0.0981348753,
-0.8049963117,
-0.5557174683,
-0.0574875735,
-0.8350564241,
-0.6210817099,
-0.4544602334,
-0.5338835716,
-0.3136102557,
-0.0944058225,
0.7189647555,
0.6885403991,
-0.7846030593,
-0.1686537415,
-0.3768496811,
-0.1032560319,
-0.5155325532,
-0.1208338961,
0.1126283705,
-0.4261448681,
-0.5677025914,
0.3056842089,
0.188362509,
-0.008413122,
-0.2258799523,
-0.1479880065,
-0.0801525414,
-0.0712634623,
0.3567541838,
0.2716079056,
-0.6600604057,
-0.1571903229,
-0.5091900826,
-0.0596131906,
0.205426529,
1.0280601978,
-0.7310524583,
0.4480029643,
0.4556634128,
0.3776522577,
0.6603372097,
0.0521936193,
0.5815439224,
-0.2059062421,
-0.340765208,
-0.2274954021,
0.7778827548,
-0.0098627703,
-0.5572123528,
0.6199563146,
0.1394317448,
-0.6288805008,
-0.763133049,
0.2274697572,
-0.7647340894,
0.1496693194,
0.7244711518,
-0.6238033175,
-0.1967808455,
-0.1911730915,
-0.4343193173,
0.4729292691,
-0.2917279601,
0.9276264906,
0.5967003703,
-0.6109018922,
-0.2681147456,
-0.562568903,
0.3206728995,
0.4202024043,
-1.0102808475,
0.2828568518,
0.5170351863,
0.2829876542,
0.5403397083,
0.5964291692,
-0.0394900888,
0.4758189917,
0.083980456,
0.0753585845,
-0.4918076098,
-0.3969312906,
-0.2309814245,
0.5271400213,
0.1400953233,
-0.4930923581
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02656v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02656v1
|
RACER: An LLM-powered Methodology for Scalable Analysis of Semi-structured Mental Health Interviews
| 2024-02-05T00:56:30 | 2024-02-05T00:56:30 |
Satpreet Harcharan Singh, Kevin Jiang, Kanchan Bhasin, Ashutosh Sabharwal, Nidal Moukaddam, Ankit B Patel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, q-bio.QM
|
Semi-structured interviews (SSIs) are a commonly employed data-collection
method in healthcare research, offering in-depth qualitative insights into
subject experiences. Despite their value, the manual analysis of SSIs is
notoriously time-consuming and labor-intensive, in part due to the difficulty
of extracting and categorizing emotional responses, and challenges in scaling
human evaluation for large populations. In this study, we develop RACER, a
Large Language Model (LLM) based expert-guided automated pipeline that
efficiently converts raw interview transcripts into insightful domain-relevant
themes and sub-themes. We used RACER to analyze SSIs conducted with 93
healthcare professionals and trainees to assess the broad personal and
professional mental health impacts of the COVID-19 crisis. RACER achieves
moderately high agreement with two human evaluators (72%), which approaches the
human inter-rater agreement (77%). Interestingly, LLMs and humans struggle with
similar content involving nuanced emotional, ambivalent/dialectical, and
psychological statements. Our study highlights the opportunities and challenges
in using LLMs to improve research efficiency and opens new avenues for scalable
analysis of SSIs in healthcare research.
|
[
-0.3242562711,
-0.8239740729,
0.7397763729,
0.2629704773,
-0.0334605202,
0.4919100702,
-0.321210891,
-0.4368471205,
0.3311886191,
-0.0568332113,
-0.9269834161,
-0.4255233407,
-0.469261378,
0.2682367861,
-0.1639323682,
1.1782684326,
0.1078585535,
0.2945384681,
-0.240115732,
-0.0062975842,
-0.1861315221,
-0.5503904819,
-0.8691294789,
-0.1680908203,
0.5788065791,
0.2926965654,
0.5608375669,
0.1365650147,
0.6433293223,
0.2174218744,
-0.0632066429,
-0.0394958593,
-0.879186511,
0.3900063634,
-0.0583808385,
-0.0990067273,
-0.6231859922,
0.0933764651,
0.2807317972,
0.6299526095,
-0.576515317,
0.6738196611,
-0.2399953008,
0.1465704888,
-0.6872523427,
0.1323694587,
-0.3604459465,
0.137379393,
-0.4059227109,
-0.4369309545,
-0.341016829,
-0.0058423546,
-0.3475547433,
-0.3286904693,
0.2282829136,
-0.0225740708,
0.401348114,
0.5962241292,
-0.3761549592,
0.0600283854,
-0.913307786,
0.5879084468,
-0.7650829554,
0.0268992186,
-0.0189381167,
0.4532563388,
-0.2539152801,
-0.5837783813,
-0.5120574236,
0.219570756,
0.136831522,
0.2444705069,
-0.2561179399,
0.203396067,
0.4292645752,
0.2665087283,
-0.5606459379,
0.4417648017,
-0.3779689074,
-0.058271654,
1.2398611307,
1.1478414536,
0.5814014077,
0.0080531621,
0.0555436127,
0.25333184,
-0.2440281659,
0.1349962652,
-0.2821127772,
0.175458163,
-0.3114204705,
0.6460844874,
-0.194465667,
0.5661190152,
0.0984375179,
-0.4383717477,
-0.03051362,
-0.1691430062,
-0.1232057139,
0.0677485019,
1.0393879414,
0.5799494386,
-0.0731948242,
-0.4266012609,
0.0006782676,
0.0942344964,
0.5735369921,
-0.8667378426,
-0.0463843867,
0.4963847101,
-0.2750808895,
-0.1416473687,
-0.2246237695,
-1.1711881161,
-0.6338356733,
-0.201666221,
-0.0078804679,
-0.1271741986,
-0.2316682488,
0.2596616149,
-0.1340932548,
0.3172360957,
0.2268115878,
-0.4662380815,
0.1811740845,
0.7429799438,
0.8069382906,
-0.2812955678,
0.215926826,
-0.819499433,
0.259719342,
-0.1883390397,
0.6813184023,
-0.7119792104,
-0.5575826168,
-0.0601713881,
-0.2909192145,
-0.2755964398,
-0.3578493595,
0.3861800432,
-0.2782463133,
0.1438182294,
-0.1815132201,
-0.4598482251,
0.3405707181,
0.2643018961,
-0.167566672,
1.1413249969,
0.202692166,
-0.9766398668,
0.17456536,
-0.4556089938,
-0.6198762655,
0.3671090603,
-0.6914038062,
-0.5077940822,
0.4610535204,
0.1526020616,
0.615912199,
-0.587151289,
0.6482239962,
-0.7374379039,
-0.4336667657,
0.061979048,
0.2172780335,
0.7833353877,
0.045243986,
-0.3532904387,
0.1423135996,
-0.8430582881,
0.0766795278,
-0.0291164722,
-0.1178048626,
-0.4263417423,
0.0409652703,
0.2023838013,
0.4654637873,
-0.1540437788,
-0.695173502,
-0.0487034507,
-0.1722946018,
0.4730980992,
0.5122939944,
0.1780702919,
-0.0059555215,
-0.1101538613,
1.1421729326,
-0.2707951665,
0.2239643931,
0.2713108361,
-0.4840212762,
-0.2887662947,
-0.8058731556,
-0.3537275791,
0.6146486402,
-0.627620697,
0.3116330802,
-0.3766798973,
-0.5962200165,
-0.6737446189,
-0.1729045361,
0.2469609082,
0.7297301888,
0.1720957309,
-0.2690521777,
-0.579179585,
-0.8156033158,
-0.4323484302,
-0.1501079798,
-0.0838822722,
0.259095788,
0.5130653381,
-0.3417303264,
0.9933941364,
-0.547857523,
-0.0061474186,
-0.4589835703,
0.4722153544,
0.0150296101,
0.1559351832,
0.3058204055,
-0.1357486844,
-0.4159822166,
-0.2111685127,
-0.9528633952,
-0.2986213267,
-0.0451222695,
-0.1325121969,
-0.425160706,
0.3640789092,
-0.6568757892,
0.4297247529,
0.3094412684,
-0.3808986545,
0.5430784822,
0.017632883,
0.0554808341,
-1.0528645515,
0.2447724491,
0.2155843973,
-0.0969471931,
-0.6102002263,
0.013677449,
-0.364109695,
-0.3096995652,
-0.138480857,
0.4132051766,
-0.3000122309,
0.0845564157,
0.011709474,
-0.1828389317,
-0.2122336626,
0.1779320836,
-0.0623872019,
1.0534739494,
0.2691317797,
-0.1455874443,
0.3559111953,
0.2838303447,
-0.3718037009,
0.8549811244,
-0.6139112711,
0.5024337769,
-0.3791710138,
0.323381424,
-0.7744648457,
-0.3021933436,
-0.0789191201,
-0.2460168749,
0.308716923,
0.2698873878,
-0.210691914,
-0.408864975,
-0.2565612197,
0.4080694914,
0.3288561404,
0.2343340963,
0.4010362029,
0.9431578517,
-0.6247677207,
-0.1701119691,
-0.4031000137,
0.4625383914,
-0.5010766387,
-0.5980498791,
0.1531423777,
-0.1907586157,
-0.7201679945,
-0.4098362029,
-0.1496903896,
-0.296846211,
0.2242210507,
0.1698168218,
0.4253494442,
-0.1422195733,
-0.0422166325,
0.1071180776,
-0.076424785,
0.4821912348,
0.2058690488,
0.1579303741,
-0.1302333325,
-0.0318908393,
-0.6486202478,
0.7066542506,
0.7510120869,
-0.285518229,
0.826251328,
0.6532024145,
-0.2665247023,
-0.0855948254,
-0.4874698222,
-0.1482912451,
-0.3205447495,
0.5988478065,
-0.178250894,
-1.0747102499,
0.3419865072,
-0.0980433598,
-0.1415445209,
0.3197315037,
0.9000337124,
-0.4560129344,
1.1021364927,
0.6141065955,
-0.3782345057,
0.0811106041,
-0.183405742,
0.3350575268,
-0.6797170639,
-0.5893307328,
-0.7407335043,
-0.446413815,
-0.3538269401,
-0.5030254126,
1.0627477169,
-0.5503409505,
-0.3626338243,
-0.3716899157,
-0.3961087763,
-0.0162586849,
0.0222558156,
0.3670528233,
0.2563171685,
-0.3817433417,
0.2175739557,
-0.3792670369,
-0.8379016519,
-0.2122621387,
0.7597742677,
0.3390853703,
0.8754701018,
-0.0215047449,
0.477101177,
0.424312979,
0.4827143848,
-0.8050426841,
0.5233213902,
0.2100840658,
-0.8602640629,
-0.2885904014,
-0.4380182326,
-0.5600419641,
-0.0855304673,
-0.2672951221,
-0.7763931155,
0.1177407056,
-0.2568737864,
-0.9117797613,
0.1383234859,
-0.2470532358,
0.6914587617,
-0.3566438854,
-0.5071707368,
-0.2497130483,
-0.804473877,
0.5153793693,
-0.2912856042,
0.3803562224,
-0.377840519,
-0.0556262694,
0.946515739,
-0.5946905017,
0.7866036892,
-0.0970440507,
0.0801928267,
-0.0635895282,
-0.0960845351,
0.3704157472,
0.3235368133,
-0.1965516508,
0.1029617265,
0.2863925695,
-0.4294731319,
-0.8542570472,
0.1729523838,
-0.7610884905,
-0.62069875,
-0.5593426824,
-0.7509633303,
-0.6900807619,
-0.0913606361,
0.1056981906,
0.3350791931,
-0.2243265659,
-0.1727202982,
0.6272934079,
-0.2917628586,
0.0548817031,
0.7320387363,
0.2010743767,
-0.2657832205,
0.3714832067,
-0.1460595727,
-0.1939307749,
0.1521176845,
0.136659205,
0.0640011206,
-0.5657618642,
-0.2540972531,
0.5126127005,
-0.0581409745,
-0.1083332598,
-0.6170244217,
-0.2013566643,
-0.2986227274,
0.0015896356,
-0.5402183533,
-0.2131068408,
-0.0934455916,
-0.1457733065,
0.3362750411,
0.7258101702,
0.1998746991,
0.2219360769,
-0.6598834395,
0.1756591797,
0.2051092982,
0.1852520406,
-0.1208999455,
-0.4361071885,
-0.6009372473,
-0.208983779,
-0.0594095923,
-1.0213245153,
0.5667016506,
0.20701994,
0.3862822354,
0.4861285388,
0.489998132,
1.2296836376,
-0.4589787424,
0.6517730355,
0.3192637265,
-0.6049605608,
0.5223854184,
-0.5136227012,
-0.028959142,
1.0852099657,
0.3973045051,
-0.5034642816,
-0.6176707149,
-0.4432865679,
-0.6782473922,
0.5976627469,
0.1709725112,
-0.159445852,
-0.077216655,
0.601503551,
-0.1176328808,
0.2248468846,
0.1031191275,
-0.1052556783,
0.4113309085,
-0.5339958668,
-0.4569692612,
-0.3795669675,
-0.5205328465,
-0.6086130142,
0.4153044522,
0.0053031901,
0.3143541515,
0.1815389693,
0.2040075362,
-0.1488382816,
0.4306662977,
0.2906870842,
0.4575599134,
-0.398086518,
0.2499968857,
0.1322419643,
-0.5516866446,
0.2970470488,
0.213388145,
-0.0222832747,
-0.0353976414,
0.5035901666,
0.5902963281,
0.2614380419,
-1.0627309084,
0.43485412,
-0.1667478085,
0.3159718812,
-0.2818150222,
0.0459052138,
0.051625248,
0.4010546505,
-0.0012559432,
-0.2899155319,
0.4259180725,
-0.582493782,
0.1305446625,
0.5295910239,
-0.5136699677,
-0.6273853183,
0.9006447792,
0.307612747,
-0.3761724234,
0.9377216101,
0.0600070581,
-0.1485615224,
0.2869312167,
0.2911108732,
0.9336332679,
-0.2243423164,
0.3342260122,
0.1827081889,
0.165377304,
0.0225944631,
0.4201391339,
0.0594187453,
-0.38807109,
-0.5586014986,
-0.4454505146,
-0.5102592707,
0.1493675709,
-1.360311985,
-0.0199221764,
-0.3262340128,
-0.6633389592,
0.0018702579,
-0.0536030419,
-0.7671840191,
0.2690018415,
0.3549740911,
0.9593127966,
-1.1084728241,
0.6416278481,
1.046353817,
-0.348472178,
-0.936758399,
-0.0298772044,
0.3702172637,
-0.7849330902,
0.2741675675,
-0.1089831963,
-0.0593183339,
-0.0523950607,
-0.4715384543,
-0.3779126406,
1.1494603157,
0.6904972196,
-0.4651385546,
-0.3922095299,
0.209824726,
0.8594174385,
-0.4912928045,
0.6409544945,
0.7385905981,
0.2636089325,
0.1407889277,
-0.9694058299,
0.0422002971,
-0.6421681046,
0.0360142998,
-0.2166273147,
-0.7850003242,
0.3271259069,
-0.3381982148,
-0.0690109581,
-0.2353304029,
0.4445110857,
0.5025505424,
0.8061907887,
0.2381232828,
0.6191811562,
1.2013149261,
0.3201202452,
1.1490082741,
-0.3020269871,
0.5266692042,
1.3020493984,
-0.4917350411,
0.6978955269,
0.4749388397,
-0.5261251926,
0.594748199,
0.7686918378,
0.3068275452,
0.0621588379,
0.2299797088,
-0.5803812146,
-0.6800338626,
-0.2115574926,
-0.2516588271,
0.5016415715,
0.2288035303,
-0.1187107041,
-0.2164331675,
0.0925839841,
0.3577839732,
-0.1591328979,
-0.1632862538,
0.606951952,
0.2689091563,
-0.3924777508,
0.3324995041,
0.0225458946,
0.2606440187,
-0.4004100263,
0.4172127247,
-0.442260325,
-0.040328864,
-0.2232732028,
-0.4199717045,
0.5393239856,
0.4535308778,
-0.2950377762,
-0.2687461972,
0.4244257808,
-0.1414470971,
-0.7562840581,
0.189652279,
0.7542603612,
0.3341031075,
-0.0947929248,
-0.6581836939,
0.2541719377,
-0.3509785831,
-0.2835965753,
0.4225654006,
0.3678804934,
0.0352509804,
0.6593976021,
0.0848341882,
0.3946194649,
0.0252115652,
0.1189051419,
0.818148315,
-0.8618836999,
-0.4614301622,
-0.9147058725,
0.6643009782,
-0.2210012823,
-0.1016389802,
0.7185646296,
0.9179968238,
0.2079741359,
0.0622108616,
0.9421955943,
-0.0432610177,
0.5056948066,
-0.1490011066,
0.6739987731,
-0.5877737999,
0.173136726,
-0.2818725109,
-0.0612055734,
-0.2198620886,
0.3326562643,
-0.4910541475,
-0.1220846474,
0.5346401334,
0.707755506,
0.2719196677,
0.0513416119,
0.091144301,
0.5330629945,
0.4220605493,
0.7422731519,
0.8680223227,
0.0779184178,
-0.0127096474,
0.1202952787,
-0.492267251,
0.1454250067,
-0.5377727151,
-0.9022108316,
-0.2230149209,
-0.61991781,
-0.3542171419,
0.2819918096,
0.7943879366,
0.7334922552,
-0.5872842073,
-0.3353114724,
0.4098397791,
-0.0834896713,
-0.2127667367,
-0.2015036643,
0.1337920725,
-0.2010707855,
-0.5726251602,
0.4836636484,
0.7364426851,
-0.5839160681,
-0.3944668472,
-0.0225410946,
0.1013094783,
0.0796482563,
0.4180153906,
0.1705688983,
-0.3606923223,
-0.0281630233,
0.0057004178,
-0.1571794301,
0.0998061672,
1.0710533857,
-0.7429505587,
0.6216855645,
0.1507976204,
0.7781855464,
0.4926513135,
0.1031966209,
0.64450109,
-0.3325824738,
-0.0641588941,
0.3125376105,
0.0166237988,
0.0630473495,
-0.5650143027,
0.4387997687,
0.632207334,
-0.4089548886,
-1.0992844105,
-0.1455012262,
-1.1212646961,
0.0380031429,
1.1888760328,
-0.1418239921,
-0.1209743395,
-0.3496298492,
0.1360359639,
0.368011266,
-0.1850900948,
1.0707143545,
0.4590588808,
-0.6733915806,
-0.227301985,
-0.7764155269,
0.3418406844,
0.1023119837,
-0.9858232737,
-0.2317466885,
0.3738076985,
0.4591238797,
-0.4234341681,
1.1390897036,
-0.0090826759,
0.0491114743,
-0.2321563661,
0.0891154185,
-0.1239017546,
-0.0714038461,
-0.3443025947,
0.2723688185,
-0.2460338324,
0.197510764
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02655v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02655v2
|
VlogQA: Task, Dataset, and Baseline Models for Vietnamese Spoken-Based Machine Reading Comprehension
| 2024-02-05T00:54:40 | 2024-04-06T04:29:58 |
Thinh Phuoc Ngo, Khoa Tran Anh Dang, Son T. Luu, Kiet Van Nguyen, Ngan Luu-Thuy Nguyen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper presents the development process of a Vietnamese spoken language
corpus for machine reading comprehension (MRC) tasks and provides insights into
the challenges and opportunities associated with using real-world data for
machine reading comprehension tasks. The existing MRC corpora in Vietnamese
mainly focus on formal written documents such as Wikipedia articles, online
newspapers, or textbooks. In contrast, the VlogQA consists of 10,076
question-answer pairs based on 1,230 transcript documents sourced from YouTube
-- an extensive source of user-uploaded content, covering the topics of food
and travel. By capturing the spoken language of native Vietnamese speakers in
natural settings, an obscure corner overlooked in Vietnamese research, the
corpus provides a valuable resource for future research in reading
comprehension tasks for the Vietnamese language. Regarding performance
evaluation, our deep-learning models achieved the highest F1 score of 75.34% on
the test set, indicating significant progress in machine reading comprehension
for Vietnamese spoken language data. In terms of EM, the highest score we
accomplished is 53.97%, which reflects the challenge in processing spoken-based
content and highlights the need for further improvement.
|
[
-0.3288254142,
-0.9035415649,
0.4486889243,
-0.2740778625,
-0.2713757157,
0.1928687692,
0.0646197498,
-0.2567013204,
-0.1217740253,
0.9676168561,
-0.5870269537,
-0.7777790427,
-0.3867349327,
0.243760705,
-0.4137314558,
0.7855547667,
-0.0938301012,
-0.1661567837,
-0.3667959273,
-0.1940867901,
-0.6243528724,
-0.6514742374,
-0.3861407042,
0.0084681949,
0.5292223096,
0.8064752817,
0.4895217419,
0.7227804065,
0.3199828863,
0.2238779217,
-0.0383739695,
0.3431962729,
-0.6708145142,
0.206795752,
0.0227312241,
-0.540078342,
-0.2708349824,
-0.0987560898,
0.7125224471,
0.4760612547,
-0.1053073853,
0.4283156991,
0.0529880859,
0.6809549928,
-0.4907976389,
0.155776605,
-0.6098837852,
-0.0680836961,
0.1940919012,
-0.1701580733,
-0.5512424707,
0.0231016483,
0.147567898,
-0.685464263,
0.196119383,
-0.2123095542,
1.0406455994,
0.5478625894,
-0.7649347782,
-0.2877945602,
-0.505943954,
0.8459543586,
-0.4677104652,
0.468397826,
0.9332051873,
0.3161793053,
0.5159245133,
-0.7603566051,
-0.672961235,
-0.4681340158,
-0.1187816858,
0.3005366027,
-0.098850593,
-0.181031093,
0.178991735,
0.230089277,
-1.1479716301,
-0.0220301822,
-0.8013366461,
0.0028038819,
0.4490563869,
0.2478081286,
-0.0859600157,
-0.5575377941,
-0.409319371,
-0.0576700047,
-0.4128154218,
-0.0374203175,
0.1473606825,
0.1974453181,
-0.0306554157,
0.8380663991,
-0.5625804067,
1.1149266958,
-0.5776806474,
-0.2086534798,
0.4145241678,
-0.676437676,
-0.5595482588,
-0.1664886177,
0.2951233983,
0.3704910576,
0.5129873157,
0.3473317623,
-0.2001171708,
-0.1977484077,
0.5707020164,
-0.3498963714,
-0.1503816694,
0.5353931189,
-0.450145632,
-0.1298997402,
0.0755324513,
-0.4793018103,
0.029269103,
-0.8161863685,
0.4033737779,
-0.4224049747,
-0.2661656737,
0.1380079985,
-0.2485644668,
0.5056350827,
0.1879701465,
-0.5219123363,
0.155715242,
0.8617242575,
0.9622994065,
-0.1277290732,
-0.1991710961,
-0.746414423,
0.0455393381,
-0.0282894801,
0.8498750329,
-0.3453862369,
-0.4823466837,
0.3259210885,
0.1394114792,
-0.3388186395,
-0.7051561475,
0.686863184,
-0.502246201,
0.2719551027,
0.0396338776,
-0.5985214114,
-0.3461481631,
0.3763071597,
-0.7668194175,
1.0962115526,
0.3852660358,
-0.6549449563,
0.1563079059,
-0.1173070744,
-0.4095534384,
0.1591441631,
0.209698841,
-0.1607976407,
-0.262563169,
0.4049097598,
0.5307388306,
-0.0016848595,
0.0612211935,
0.0728071108,
-0.3861174285,
0.2787869573,
-0.4643986225,
1.0001901388,
0.6252945662,
-0.1381627768,
0.2187889814,
-0.7252483368,
0.379975915,
-0.1971028596,
-0.3032100499,
-0.2570622861,
-0.2919651866,
0.1533226967,
0.145195663,
0.156779021,
-0.0240341816,
0.0369418934,
-0.0108966511,
0.3627572954,
0.3980154991,
0.0581362583,
0.1358250529,
-0.2246094048,
0.7630896568,
-0.0526787974,
-0.0009561898,
-0.6308317184,
-0.6337038875,
-0.8299584985,
-0.4673404098,
0.4845577776,
1.2381793261,
-0.8616025448,
0.3566170931,
-0.0988547429,
-0.6339240074,
-1.0662735701,
0.1406034976,
0.4854926467,
0.9954434633,
0.4705553651,
-0.0087718498,
-0.5224304199,
-0.7956933379,
-0.0598131269,
-0.4722473621,
-0.4062521458,
0.3594061136,
0.5471515059,
-0.4084109664,
0.4953636229,
-0.6642653942,
-0.2346108258,
-0.345032841,
-0.0138770472,
0.2751999497,
0.2604258955,
0.150726676,
-1.0012835264,
-0.5128386617,
0.0874166414,
-0.9354093075,
-0.1163579896,
-0.0127707226,
-0.1374993771,
0.3282081783,
0.8534605503,
-0.5230298042,
0.3094079196,
0.6952607036,
-0.4280331135,
0.7082298994,
-0.1137365624,
0.2873619497,
-0.9660730362,
0.1722475588,
0.0369000956,
-0.476207763,
-0.5737840533,
0.2908873558,
0.0386382677,
0.0108732209,
-0.6306912899,
0.4877047539,
-0.142426461,
0.1867128015,
-0.122800678,
0.3343700171,
0.0099161109,
0.2477833778,
0.2819657326,
0.6447511315,
0.4732298851,
-0.7790256143,
0.3880503476,
0.273050189,
-0.351662904,
0.7798336744,
-0.8031108975,
0.0846946165,
-0.1417446285,
0.0631460026,
-1.0585566759,
-0.1016001552,
0.3484686017,
-0.7607555985,
0.1383654475,
-0.0898312032,
-0.2098148316,
-0.3142467737,
0.2018472552,
0.1283817142,
0.5089648366,
-0.242950812,
0.1918097287,
0.4903405011,
-0.2177810967,
-0.6234688163,
-0.6994255781,
0.080268845,
-0.2431828082,
-0.6152062416,
0.0028956877,
0.0109291831,
-0.4235476255,
0.0618527047,
0.1466179788,
-0.3784591556,
-0.2049110532,
0.1118218899,
0.2084340155,
-0.6436390877,
0.1926787943,
-0.160011217,
-0.3605140746,
-0.219367981,
-0.5906821489,
0.2976423502,
-0.0912416652,
0.0029113758,
-0.4848023057,
0.5097581744,
0.1747112572,
-0.4186685681,
0.8142296672,
0.888112247,
-0.3567744493,
-0.001030135,
-0.3344541788,
0.0592544004,
-0.4101721346,
0.3834796548,
-0.6765746474,
-1.2143036127,
0.1591500044,
0.4624462724,
0.0713508353,
0.578194201,
0.6984624863,
-0.4003592432,
0.6146175861,
0.5045377612,
-0.1347870529,
0.3198122978,
-0.2697932422,
-0.3245549202,
-0.4079292119,
-0.1350991726,
-0.6997555494,
0.1139379218,
-0.6945289969,
-0.8782882094,
0.0217857901,
-0.2054476738,
-0.2229023874,
0.5280367732,
-0.4149530828,
0.217032373,
0.9436098337,
-0.0542698987,
0.6377080679,
-0.0464240834,
-0.1963240504,
-0.0498459116,
-0.4795690477,
-0.9325196743,
1.0769412518,
0.3097611964,
0.2953420579,
-0.1574032456,
0.4655142426,
0.6008339524,
-0.1137761772,
-0.8074176908,
0.4045634568,
0.1203273982,
-0.6969276071,
-0.5709130168,
-0.6157825589,
-0.9960401654,
0.371414125,
0.2578927577,
-0.5021669865,
-0.1896648854,
0.0025100263,
-0.133034572,
-0.0888910219,
-0.8793102503,
1.2852947712,
-0.0720609054,
0.0112565551,
-0.2271563411,
-0.8128905892,
0.4830179513,
-0.000271487,
0.1487168372,
0.1677255481,
-0.205628559,
0.5266681314,
-0.1578842402,
0.5858204365,
-0.0218434408,
-0.1015011072,
0.8790720105,
-0.1073172167,
0.0795487985,
0.5860772133,
-0.2236834615,
0.0754015446,
0.3495828211,
-0.8733102679,
-0.2915388346,
0.3837097287,
-0.6239054799,
-0.4908253253,
-0.4804121256,
-0.1235751882,
-0.1883076578,
0.2688225806,
0.0965100825,
0.0334591009,
-0.4040854573,
0.2157044709,
0.8906291723,
-0.1850616336,
-0.0282842703,
0.5668373704,
-0.1083212569,
-0.5783299208,
1.0529947281,
-0.009400703,
0.4290763736,
0.8661551476,
-0.3646724224,
-0.1652601063,
-0.4233455062,
-0.5161135197,
0.35065189,
-0.5811966062,
0.015633665,
-0.7565813661,
-0.4332324564,
-0.4801248312,
0.1127506346,
-0.1563171446,
-0.2649144232,
-0.5471021533,
-0.5306865573,
0.1092929244,
0.7688570023,
0.0147907594,
0.4040569663,
-0.8518520594,
0.70025599,
0.2943953276,
-0.1080661118,
-0.3969997764,
-0.8682596087,
-0.593116343,
0.0515661277,
-0.2371453643,
-0.7040147781,
0.5737406015,
-0.0178866927,
0.4090325832,
0.2792033553,
0.0250012707,
0.6577062607,
-0.3404992819,
0.763884902,
-0.4268318415,
-0.7413594127,
0.3163248599,
-0.398489356,
0.7707509398,
0.6433321238,
0.5627066493,
-0.8745609522,
-0.3435206115,
-0.4585507512,
-0.6587677002,
0.3620033562,
0.2999152839,
-0.0131253069,
0.3127833903,
0.2305404991,
0.2221444547,
0.3382444978,
-0.3123418391,
-0.1378770471,
-0.4007198811,
-0.1341322511,
-0.5687000155,
-0.3733800352,
0.131062448,
-0.4490534961,
0.4604180157,
-0.2365961671,
0.2747524977,
0.3024116457,
-0.2583118081,
0.1077044681,
-0.1375956386,
0.8773863316,
0.6838453412,
-0.2477340549,
0.1468279362,
0.112756066,
-0.6654440165,
-0.1105566919,
-0.0546108745,
-0.1922603101,
0.1954969317,
0.7135766745,
0.7431268692,
-0.1336640418,
-1.1272792816,
0.0003389348,
-0.2305660695,
-0.4357432425,
-0.5108026862,
0.0141458148,
0.2651439011,
0.164520666,
0.4590147734,
-0.3535600901,
0.0953827202,
-0.3189815879,
0.7731869817,
0.0154358437,
-0.7942197919,
-0.0905872285,
0.4312953353,
-0.0015332825,
-0.2490127385,
1.1102740765,
-0.0719811544,
-0.4533297122,
0.6325733066,
0.1310829818,
0.6073679328,
-0.2444489896,
0.6908234358,
0.6378064156,
0.6090037227,
0.2871351242,
0.5137268901,
-0.1068241596,
-0.232825011,
-0.4022416472,
-0.5380730629,
-0.4939519465,
0.139121145,
-0.6667675376,
0.3431109786,
0.1215535104,
0.0216393322,
-0.2695742548,
0.1401972622,
-0.7883820534,
0.5789502859,
0.2465499043,
0.9418238401,
-0.4670679271,
0.8807703257,
0.4880228937,
-0.394762367,
-0.4503946006,
-0.0073626079,
0.0602726303,
-0.7895379066,
0.3411043584,
0.1659350842,
0.2460753471,
0.0581585839,
-0.4047113955,
-0.8113439083,
0.8054410815,
0.1555846035,
-0.3845469952,
-0.1038989723,
0.3242319226,
0.6609921455,
-0.3281362355,
0.2380669862,
0.702452004,
0.6252092719,
-0.04576822,
-0.9265272617,
-0.3209688962,
-0.1267625093,
-0.3972338438,
-0.2888275385,
-0.5813115835,
0.7091616392,
-0.1716922969,
-0.0635347664,
0.070679687,
1.0897980928,
0.265509516,
0.6351088881,
0.3407284617,
0.5174025297,
0.9927766323,
0.2322629243,
0.9207443595,
0.1953210086,
0.1286874413,
1.1502286196,
-0.0104088699,
1.2135158777,
0.4776881933,
-0.1008184776,
0.4112107158,
0.9705345631,
0.0802959204,
0.4293725193,
0.2289394438,
-0.1812798977,
-0.3816608787,
-0.154360801,
-0.2060996592,
0.5627633929,
0.3924588561,
-0.3123966753,
0.2780530453,
0.0573182255,
-0.1354473829,
0.1691291332,
-0.1097051278,
0.7394478917,
0.4062415659,
-0.8601962924,
0.9549084902,
-0.1361080259,
0.1185468063,
-0.3189343512,
-0.0953691229,
-0.1299473941,
0.0858182907,
-0.0988388509,
-1.0830812454,
0.4253525734,
0.1209007502,
-0.1552158445,
-0.1920909882,
0.3999251723,
-0.425507158,
-0.5209748745,
0.1147323847,
0.8701605797,
0.3126890659,
-0.3076938093,
-0.7200802565,
0.081829831,
0.2031030953,
-0.3260745406,
0.1206819043,
0.5999081135,
0.1748619825,
0.6269464493,
0.3666158319,
-0.2874675095,
0.1743535846,
-0.0651265904,
0.4662242234,
-0.9148569107,
-0.3898439407,
-0.5423468351,
0.8561478257,
0.0770025924,
-0.632217288,
0.7420523763,
0.6898123622,
1.2487698793,
-0.3605684042,
0.9469877481,
0.1508751959,
0.7564738393,
-0.6309953332,
0.6284535527,
-0.599347651,
-0.103195183,
-0.1254756004,
-0.7531115413,
-0.1565616578,
0.3110373914,
0.0630577579,
-0.1127030253,
0.8377141356,
0.706327498,
0.0859286413,
-0.1505479366,
0.6265137196,
-0.028484229,
0.0641270429,
0.5199583769,
0.7309179306,
-0.5280562639,
0.8238779902,
-0.0483631417,
-0.05849915,
-0.3744070828,
-0.3728434741,
-1.0469890833,
-1.1215083599,
-0.3032377064,
-0.3790768981,
0.2745223641,
0.374450326,
0.5616742969,
-0.8596248627,
-0.5180057287,
0.2249346375,
0.442560643,
-0.4749641418,
-0.2611063719,
0.1922745854,
-0.2378900796,
-0.8839268684,
0.4384244084,
-0.0076861796,
-0.2183260173,
-0.3467688859,
-0.2172529697,
-0.4317811131,
-0.0863062367,
0.7662969828,
0.4210340977,
-0.531504333,
-0.0259046089,
0.4639544189,
-0.4284573197,
0.0101669589,
0.7396460772,
-1.066221118,
0.5005129576,
0.6235055923,
0.644860208,
0.6402785182,
0.2544155419,
0.598798275,
-0.3722296059,
0.0432943739,
0.401212126,
0.032126423,
0.343870014,
-0.108574599,
0.6546620727,
0.2839848697,
-0.6418805718,
-1.0179831982,
0.1436338723,
-1.1554416418,
-0.2352119088,
1.129748106,
-0.0483114757,
-0.4476945102,
-0.4364772141,
-0.5775068402,
0.4424003363,
-0.2925885916,
0.459752202,
0.5953102708,
0.215770036,
-0.3746986687,
-1.3333265781,
0.4045509398,
0.3962680995,
-0.6892609,
0.0217668563,
0.4311821759,
-0.0512541048,
-0.2203804851,
0.4787413776,
0.2963809371,
0.2524182498,
0.2046436518,
-0.3277304769,
0.1548855007,
-0.4517886341,
-0.287976265,
0.2984160781,
-0.1032675132,
-0.2007000148
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02648v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02648v2
|
Recursive Chain-of-Feedback Prevents Performance Degradation from Redundant Prompting
| 2024-02-05T00:44:28 | 2024-03-01T10:46:01 |
Jinwoo Ahn, Kyuseung Shin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) frequently struggle with complex reasoning
tasks, failing to construct logically sound steps towards the solution. In
response to this behavior, users often try prompting the LLMs repeatedly in
hopes of reaching a better response. This paper studies such repetitive
behavior and its effect by defining a novel setting, Chain-of-Feedback (CoF).
The setting takes questions that require multi-step reasoning as an input. Upon
response, we repetitively prompt meaningless feedback (e.g. 'make another
attempt') requesting additional trials. Surprisingly, our preliminary results
show that repeated meaningless feedback gradually decreases the quality of the
responses, eventually leading to a larger deviation from the intended outcome.
To alleviate these troubles, we propose a novel method, Recursive
Chain-of-Feedback (R-CoF). Following the logic of recursion in computer
science, R-CoF recursively revises the initially incorrect response by breaking
down each incorrect reasoning step into smaller individual problems. Our
preliminary results show that majority of questions that LLMs fail to respond
correctly can be answered using R-CoF without any sample data outlining the
logical process.
|
[
-0.6161413789,
-1.1159784794,
0.4627873302,
0.2485327274,
-0.1212080941,
0.42741099,
-0.0564972237,
-0.2505703568,
0.1699017882,
0.5608254671,
-1.0886819363,
-0.1295072436,
-0.3313106894,
0.3675146103,
-0.5786876082,
1.0786991119,
-0.0402975418,
-0.0877092555,
-0.3913494647,
-0.2504959702,
-0.7994259596,
-0.5694944859,
-0.8961003423,
-0.6234160066,
0.8292706609,
0.5771873593,
0.4249520004,
0.177507475,
0.3848611414,
0.2556070387,
0.1836195886,
0.3883052766,
-0.656017065,
0.4008055925,
-0.144567892,
-0.526131928,
-0.1937474161,
-0.1334041953,
0.6512157917,
0.8669012785,
-0.5319937468,
0.224646166,
0.2696176469,
1.1333870888,
-0.6472563148,
-0.0599618219,
-0.2718011141,
0.0499300696,
0.262896508,
-0.5948573947,
-0.6710261106,
-0.4482289851,
-0.0238781739,
-0.5563291311,
0.0926812366,
0.1025481597,
0.4057466686,
0.3491159379,
0.176406756,
-0.4466146827,
-1.0820348263,
0.6533731222,
-0.4246553183,
0.2577903569,
0.1539322138,
0.0791425854,
-0.6782631278,
-0.4379317164,
-0.6908046603,
-0.4238187671,
-0.1071517318,
0.103920348,
-0.128460452,
-0.0109838843,
0.4234605134,
0.2360295057,
-0.292828083,
-0.2951779962,
-0.3217975199,
0.0524519607,
0.3405764103,
0.3921634555,
0.1901974678,
0.1995360255,
-0.1858620942,
-0.1699313968,
-0.8226762414,
0.1855621934,
0.2001254559,
0.3161820769,
0.2893972695,
0.292301923,
-0.1994482428,
0.9157289863,
0.494143486,
-0.2855179608,
0.1864400953,
-0.2634349167,
-0.1319252551,
-0.2410170883,
0.6084425449,
0.1956250668,
0.3721711636,
-0.2340921164,
-0.2675165832,
0.0238932911,
0.297557503,
-0.5026375055,
-0.0475393906,
0.3644288182,
-0.1749052107,
-0.2504793108,
0.1385520399,
-0.5452160835,
-0.0331029594,
-0.2120779902,
0.2574814558,
-0.2409180403,
-0.0894842893,
0.199141711,
-0.1024576351,
-0.2801412046,
0.3922951221,
-0.4565799832,
0.7084069848,
0.5625017881,
0.7086711526,
-0.1762328446,
-0.4678955972,
-1.0424274206,
0.01740738,
-0.2996457219,
0.7442147732,
-0.5098022819,
-0.4460116625,
-0.1824119389,
0.0299275778,
0.0846053287,
-0.877833128,
0.1185879782,
-0.6690520048,
0.1929680854,
-0.454503566,
-0.1538581997,
-0.1614795774,
0.4615210593,
-0.9085278511,
0.951749742,
-0.2478972673,
-0.7289407849,
0.1667965055,
-0.3625767231,
-0.5634870529,
-0.1865812093,
-0.0535220318,
-0.2859326899,
0.0166990273,
0.1352596134,
0.0223675352,
-0.1535490751,
0.2014734894,
-0.5485863686,
-0.4293220937,
0.3260555863,
-0.3679914176,
0.3204857707,
0.1513411403,
-0.3526547849,
-0.0881163925,
-0.8438841105,
0.1581246704,
0.0406021737,
-0.4783552587,
-0.1767052561,
0.3037164211,
-0.449426949,
0.4293985367,
-0.1701895148,
-0.4367680252,
0.1704004556,
-0.3115522563,
0.4071564972,
0.7295289636,
0.2291588783,
0.0869212672,
-0.8690308332,
0.7407447696,
-0.0271265171,
-0.0291204285,
-0.2601181567,
-0.2523302734,
-0.7643057704,
0.2672574818,
-0.031901136,
0.5153204203,
-0.8111627102,
0.2070803344,
-0.1416312754,
-0.0083162393,
-0.2294783443,
0.2402668148,
0.4964218438,
0.4059290886,
0.2588699162,
-0.434877336,
-0.6050346494,
-0.5170588493,
-0.1796792895,
-0.3023553789,
0.0634457693,
0.1998181939,
0.5036363006,
0.0380334295,
0.7058359385,
-0.3025510609,
0.0392114557,
-0.2271632254,
0.2468377501,
0.1937582493,
0.2328155786,
-0.2724345624,
-0.281865716,
0.0060624727,
-0.2181630582,
-0.4470130205,
-0.134569943,
-0.3818659186,
0.0812136307,
0.4256160259,
0.3925608099,
-0.3899515271,
0.2399280667,
0.5353274345,
0.1135833561,
0.5996980071,
-0.2317149043,
0.2677423358,
-0.4173116088,
0.3349238038,
-0.3152783215,
-0.3566437662,
-0.0592984669,
0.0557048731,
-0.417426914,
0.0375969186,
-0.0510125197,
0.3278520405,
-0.3203222156,
0.0387745276,
-0.3629093766,
0.3397625387,
0.0824738443,
0.6176751256,
-0.03786809,
0.6148633957,
-0.0491146743,
-0.9641316533,
0.4121698439,
0.0974551067,
-0.1219764948,
0.523440063,
-0.7602767348,
0.3986250162,
-0.1087244898,
0.6269696951,
-1.2477889061,
-0.1051263586,
0.4719294608,
-0.3826550543,
0.0088521168,
0.171572715,
-0.6066594124,
-0.7975552678,
-0.3879968524,
0.3701907396,
0.1571452618,
-0.6587069631,
0.153540805,
0.0581574365,
-0.131834358,
-0.6648137569,
-0.7870462537,
-0.201544866,
0.3788972795,
-0.6119785905,
0.0341334492,
-0.3196206391,
-0.1576560885,
-0.0162384585,
-0.3515070975,
0.0701782703,
-0.0367956758,
0.1876215488,
0.1334433258,
0.1785340309,
0.3671905994,
-0.202032879,
-0.0667162463,
0.3271405399,
-0.3272088766,
0.6222304106,
-0.0848671198,
-0.4988090098,
-0.6090025902,
0.5221608877,
0.7861195803,
0.0575817972,
0.4302757978,
-0.1387951076,
-0.0639017224,
-0.5195447206,
-0.5597400665,
-0.4304019213,
-0.4232005775,
0.161562562,
-0.3512144685,
-1.0576176643,
0.3197945356,
-0.2221234739,
0.1152339056,
-0.011944972,
0.5075312853,
-0.2329413593,
0.950632751,
0.2263587862,
0.0729350969,
0.316372633,
-0.2153463513,
0.3032627106,
-0.5851034522,
-0.4539617598,
-0.3487862051,
-0.3131899834,
-0.3678457439,
-0.2193530053,
0.347589314,
0.1426796168,
-0.3963899016,
-0.019609753,
-0.6952458024,
0.4309937954,
0.2882929146,
0.2518770695,
0.5927831531,
0.1979213953,
-0.3010233343,
0.3090668917,
-0.9615377784,
-0.2141510546,
0.5635152459,
0.2707775831,
1.0620746613,
-0.077257745,
0.8005746603,
0.2302749753,
0.3401883245,
-0.775503397,
0.5311083794,
0.0873882249,
-0.3799161315,
-0.2711592615,
-0.5590883493,
-0.9257423282,
0.0526640005,
0.1900630146,
-0.535371244,
0.1026614308,
0.5935494304,
-0.7316007018,
0.2960949838,
-0.4848566949,
0.1830843538,
-0.1037736386,
-0.506505847,
-0.3432835639,
-0.4202215672,
0.4661329687,
0.1808060408,
0.472132653,
0.3780574501,
0.26133883,
0.6205620766,
-0.7850365639,
1.0385649204,
-0.1548569053,
-0.0991098136,
0.5457170606,
0.4147231877,
0.9713585973,
0.0340370908,
0.2617582679,
-0.2933936119,
0.0035384698,
-0.0722517669,
-0.9514678717,
0.8220627308,
-0.5012267232,
-0.88907969,
-0.477142781,
-0.4092592001,
-0.3289099932,
-0.0424050353,
0.1886690408,
0.4631044865,
0.0982169807,
-0.0061995983,
0.5417264104,
-0.1470456272,
0.3036699593,
0.2556983232,
-0.5617140532,
-0.6273247004,
0.665153265,
0.1662870646,
0.708324492,
0.2212275416,
0.0334975719,
-0.2469851375,
-0.2085434943,
-0.1303842813,
0.2523815632,
-0.5799320936,
-0.168809399,
-0.474506408,
-0.00613544,
-0.0088603394,
0.12900801,
-0.3223641515,
-0.4585386515,
0.0580861606,
-0.028432833,
0.2660474479,
1.0453790426,
-0.115987286,
-0.1320878863,
-0.7429700494,
0.3451158702,
0.4357989132,
0.586476326,
0.591889441,
-0.3765435219,
0.0062076268,
0.083001174,
-0.509521842,
-0.594150126,
0.1115906686,
-0.0905636698,
0.4642389417,
-0.0525899641,
0.0423267409,
0.9696830511,
-0.5562688112,
0.5635967851,
0.4411022365,
-0.8555338383,
0.5445539355,
-0.2432588339,
0.6437858343,
0.4935806096,
0.2719832063,
-0.7454598546,
-0.4434206188,
-0.3160254061,
-0.9398917556,
0.7277220488,
0.0022833548,
-0.1104364172,
-0.3526106775,
0.5343641639,
0.071239762,
0.2476862222,
-0.7300773263,
-0.439719677,
-0.0544341393,
0.5149791241,
0.4844908118,
-0.2714660466,
-0.2128222436,
-0.3085610569,
0.5815418363,
0.0527495258,
0.304702878,
0.5864153504,
0.0593384206,
-0.5943182111,
0.369743675,
0.7079418898,
0.7875410914,
-0.1850604266,
0.1094109714,
0.2234760821,
-0.2192097455,
0.4001426995,
-0.5466492176,
-0.0746271908,
-0.1129609942,
0.3727663755,
0.4206720889,
0.2139395922,
-0.5831258893,
0.0372209065,
0.0099436464,
-0.282440722,
-0.40419209,
0.2553371787,
0.035270296,
-0.0939444453,
0.3665109873,
0.3078016341,
0.0383787788,
-0.7417179346,
0.6303501129,
0.180448249,
-0.3294430673,
-0.064824596,
0.2793072462,
0.3096084595,
-0.620998323,
0.7387216091,
-0.1660788804,
-0.3869918585,
0.4929021895,
0.711135149,
0.6295157671,
-0.056303028,
0.3663187623,
0.7581140399,
0.1038191915,
-0.4349081814,
0.3128917515,
-0.0888260901,
-0.5299806595,
-0.7891005278,
-0.3683615327,
-0.407209605,
0.3028336465,
-0.9160119295,
-0.0535777807,
-1.0120482445,
-0.1792193949,
-0.2966768742,
-0.2264674455,
-0.3054356575,
0.152919665,
-0.087353453,
0.6949031949,
-0.1878680885,
0.6318255663,
0.2914732099,
-0.4760827422,
-0.8049507141,
0.176951319,
0.0046870681,
-0.6463865042,
0.832659483,
0.1187818274,
-0.8884778619,
-0.1943368614,
-0.6980481148,
-0.8466443419,
0.793152988,
0.1642850935,
-1.1581673622,
0.2070584148,
0.0712048635,
0.5144709945,
-0.3219117522,
0.0713652968,
0.6170566678,
0.4972219765,
0.3849110305,
-0.7988440394,
0.3110776246,
-0.2815645933,
-0.0299192332,
0.2932598293,
-0.6791914105,
0.7762728333,
-0.6738004088,
-0.5072594285,
0.3337512314,
0.2104600072,
0.7236773968,
0.1972786039,
0.7495656013,
0.6385293603,
0.8856545687,
-0.0224925056,
1.3257731199,
-0.2167000324,
0.377658993,
1.5498068333,
-0.2066432387,
0.923515439,
0.698323369,
-0.2904861271,
0.9592905045,
0.2703965008,
-0.0049023419,
0.5271778107,
0.8272967339,
-0.2845360637,
-0.3912172616,
0.055976972,
-0.3264241815,
-0.0875500366,
0.1578541547,
0.0028195903,
-0.2226344198,
-0.0508733056,
-0.086064294,
0.1614194214,
-0.1843786091,
0.4955796003,
0.1813914329,
-1.2768452168,
0.9407921433,
-0.3362482786,
0.5459424853,
-0.3180066645,
-0.3779128194,
-0.2035447359,
0.3136230707,
-0.3708970249,
-0.712136507,
0.522218287,
-0.1696620136,
-0.6712624431,
-0.08536046,
0.2878212333,
-0.3012868464,
-0.264113903,
0.6551927924,
0.2984508574,
-0.183723107,
0.1577446312,
-0.7591409683,
0.2346841246,
-0.0585846379,
-0.1643603444,
0.0697893277,
0.3619903326,
0.0301844329,
1.0429686308,
0.7541524768,
-0.0990109891,
-0.2151400298,
0.2485068589,
0.8757526278,
-0.7784231901,
-0.2386484891,
-0.8308135867,
0.2654924989,
0.1051523313,
-0.043527253,
0.4532512128,
0.104180783,
1.0652452707,
0.0042755879,
1.0058560371,
0.0893147439,
0.6422231197,
-0.4215190709,
0.2960697412,
-0.5533617139,
0.6715945005,
-0.232935071,
-0.4319143295,
-0.4407483041,
0.5253340602,
-0.2805682719,
0.2706186175,
1.1272987127,
0.8339486718,
0.4496836364,
-0.0153119862,
0.2307462692,
0.3947052956,
0.2712370157,
0.7089312673,
1.1392285824,
-0.1759069115,
0.8060849309,
-0.1545174271,
-0.0621846355,
-0.0041251932,
-0.5723938346,
-0.7856357098,
-0.3199699819,
-0.2127211392,
-0.6850215197,
0.2928850055,
0.9575709701,
0.5297654867,
-1.0325317383,
-0.4707044959,
-0.5436201096,
0.4097743034,
-0.5040851235,
-0.2166163176,
0.0303811431,
-0.7556195855,
-0.2674226165,
0.1471997648,
0.4870878756,
-0.4306564927,
-0.4294000864,
-0.2364432663,
-0.3346880972,
-0.0002853861,
0.5738790035,
0.508577764,
-0.9232577085,
-0.4963781238,
0.0398546904,
0.0888244808,
0.1885234714,
1.0706828833,
-1.005033493,
0.539370954,
0.6051288843,
0.4276003242,
0.2066711485,
-0.0649792627,
0.7686662674,
-0.6081629395,
-0.2270085961,
0.1776367128,
0.1075461954,
0.0903948471,
-0.4644492567,
0.2996985316,
0.5172080398,
-0.5263267159,
-0.6194927692,
0.3494152129,
-0.8663035631,
-0.3658341467,
1.0717498064,
-0.1170797572,
-0.314951539,
-0.2900899053,
-0.1667899042,
-0.0894735157,
-0.6291264296,
1.0238822699,
1.0445386171,
-0.5037999153,
-0.2508770525,
-0.2874890864,
0.2964791059,
0.5643745065,
-0.637483418,
0.2892412543,
0.5313084126,
0.4946790934,
0.3385435343,
0.7663906813,
-0.2631924152,
0.6216980219,
-0.1447399557,
-0.1697389483,
-0.1969662309,
-0.6309354901,
-0.3333826363,
0.4806256592,
0.2011733651,
-0.1201025099
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05125v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05125v3
|
Zero-Shot Clinical Trial Patient Matching with LLMs
| 2024-02-05T00:06:08 | 2024-04-10T05:37:26 |
Michael Wornow, Alejandro Lozano, Dev Dash, Jenelle Jindal, Kenneth W. Mahaffey, Nigam H. Shah
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Matching patients to clinical trials is a key unsolved challenge in bringing
new drugs to market. Today, identifying patients who meet a trial's eligibility
criteria is highly manual, taking up to 1 hour per patient. Automated screening
is challenging, however, as it requires understanding unstructured clinical
text. Large language models (LLMs) offer a promising solution. In this work, we
explore their application to trial matching. First, we design an LLM-based
system which, given a patient's medical history as unstructured clinical text,
evaluates whether that patient meets a set of inclusion criteria (also
specified as free text). Our zero-shot system achieves state-of-the-art scores
on the n2c2 2018 cohort selection benchmark. Second, we improve the data and
cost efficiency of our method by identifying a prompting strategy which matches
patients an order of magnitude faster and more cheaply than the status quo, and
develop a two-stage retrieval pipeline that reduces the number of tokens
processed by up to a third while retaining high performance. Third, we evaluate
the interpretability of our system by having clinicians evaluate the natural
language justifications generated by the LLM for each eligibility decision, and
show that it can output coherent explanations for 97% of its correct decisions
and 75% of its incorrect ones. Our results establish the feasibility of using
LLMs to accelerate clinical trial operations.
|
[
0.3092925847,
-0.4694200456,
1.2653323412,
0.1951054037,
-0.4236133695,
-0.0567341857,
-0.068115063,
-0.5616489053,
0.1499405503,
0.8148548007,
-0.3221015036,
-0.5325407386,
-0.5548830032,
0.2097129375,
-0.4754512608,
0.9396575093,
-0.4019730389,
0.2301817983,
-0.1992273927,
-0.2403850704,
-0.6185028553,
-0.3073717654,
-0.6538124681,
-0.6600416303,
0.6001471281,
0.6202656627,
0.450283289,
0.7862089276,
0.543725729,
0.1542823166,
-0.0284621865,
-0.2410505414,
-0.6263243556,
0.4652792811,
0.0182075892,
-0.539041996,
-0.3090203702,
-0.0293868668,
0.189428106,
0.8137375116,
-0.3102662265,
0.0020962786,
-0.1502025276,
0.3309336901,
-0.6195581555,
-0.1277099997,
-0.7116046548,
0.3378674686,
-0.1774321645,
-0.491325736,
-0.4909915328,
-0.3400960267,
0.1366959959,
-0.6481678486,
0.4297622442,
0.0370829441,
0.8829827309,
0.0364833362,
-0.4788404107,
-0.5223543644,
-0.5178198814,
0.5561739802,
-0.771366179,
-0.0191484392,
0.4225037992,
0.4051220417,
-0.4762167633,
-0.4319196939,
-0.4489195049,
-0.4848865271,
-0.1960440278,
0.2555986941,
-0.0109703606,
0.3278629482,
0.2452970147,
0.4292394519,
-0.8875306249,
0.5421845317,
-0.2320464402,
-0.4181384742,
0.4720979631,
0.3742422462,
0.3803890646,
-0.0081935143,
-0.5356288552,
0.2351740152,
-0.7186620235,
-0.3092501462,
-0.197278142,
0.5349479318,
-0.0994711593,
1.0108261108,
-0.4608376622,
0.6780387163,
-0.0208275765,
0.0932124332,
-0.0377297327,
-0.3042835891,
-0.3492593467,
0.4402428567,
0.7878060341,
0.6455838084,
0.4392068386,
-0.1682720482,
-0.0228607934,
0.1592799574,
0.0990066677,
-0.9912535548,
0.197060138,
0.6383558512,
-0.4920676351,
-0.3596032858,
-0.3133688867,
-0.6499236226,
-0.5970918536,
-0.1350799799,
0.711234808,
-0.3575474918,
0.1332544088,
0.5280253887,
-0.3370136917,
0.5708537102,
0.4943324924,
-0.7116633654,
0.156560421,
0.6611672044,
1.0984609127,
-0.1162365377,
0.173096478,
-0.948019743,
0.1571185738,
-0.5593101978,
0.8467962146,
-0.205659464,
-0.3981524408,
0.230108425,
-0.032224264,
-0.1931536645,
-0.432669878,
0.6515093446,
-0.5263264179,
0.4531831741,
-0.1289530247,
-0.9694085121,
0.2456365973,
0.2691369653,
-0.326259315,
0.4305074811,
0.1806123406,
-0.2859267592,
0.5665336847,
-0.4998262227,
-0.3412973285,
0.6920008063,
-0.3299453557,
-0.4887289703,
0.2885372639,
0.1047675088,
0.4200853407,
-0.3124568462,
0.1035403088,
-0.5452880263,
-0.6482393146,
0.191244632,
0.0234030038,
0.5329355597,
0.3861951828,
-0.3216497898,
-0.0111661721,
-0.4608274102,
0.0051826248,
0.2320753485,
-0.27687186,
-0.1463501155,
-0.2203609794,
0.2231595069,
0.1466112286,
0.0288098492,
-0.8514103889,
0.251750201,
-0.4021551907,
0.3978507519,
0.561060667,
-0.0006445503,
0.1643666625,
-0.1942135394,
0.5207983255,
-0.17576994,
0.2529059947,
-0.2833966017,
-0.4375042915,
-0.5453098416,
-0.3663663864,
0.457722187,
0.6342874169,
-0.5975134969,
0.3555062711,
-0.1634010673,
-0.1359024644,
-0.4778752625,
-0.0807917714,
0.378074795,
0.5785511136,
0.2201930285,
-0.4525605142,
-0.4188017845,
-0.9070171118,
-0.1735589057,
-0.0798889101,
-0.437692076,
0.4599560201,
0.5015084743,
-0.1927991211,
0.8888682723,
-0.7174503207,
-0.7958337665,
-0.3988691568,
-0.0859796181,
0.4617827833,
0.1004166678,
0.3743655384,
-0.3862771094,
-0.6341142058,
0.1699914336,
-0.9907984138,
-0.4174268544,
-0.3030044138,
-0.0701879859,
0.0155006032,
0.5778955817,
-0.4999323189,
0.6017946601,
0.4374904633,
-0.4669096172,
0.0486437902,
-0.6865905523,
0.2165829688,
-0.8647797108,
0.2908506393,
0.1413413584,
-0.4393815398,
-0.6715294123,
-0.0486492999,
0.100000903,
-0.322683543,
-0.4411472976,
0.7567157149,
-0.4381558299,
0.1504620612,
-0.4934395254,
0.3995605111,
-0.0397462621,
0.0692577586,
-0.0762677342,
0.4742039442,
0.3278827965,
-0.3193487227,
0.0845958516,
0.3907410204,
-0.4149403572,
0.82418859,
-0.8631057143,
-0.009657817,
-0.2554055154,
0.480791837,
-1.0240983963,
-0.480232656,
0.159945026,
-0.3780430555,
0.0211605057,
-0.2497231364,
-0.2264674604,
-0.3611399233,
-0.2454929799,
0.3704204559,
0.4030527771,
-0.1168782786,
0.3429655135,
0.0448052585,
-0.2214441746,
-0.3661528826,
-0.7155532241,
0.4599722922,
0.0779840052,
-0.1417204738,
0.2465149313,
-0.0110931844,
0.1396224797,
-0.0843950659,
0.1398264766,
-0.0842133462,
-0.1018266007,
0.2754579186,
0.3428620994,
-0.1250475198,
0.0066787638,
-0.0361220278,
-0.2152899951,
-0.3474290967,
-0.1743284315,
0.4274328649,
0.4835414886,
-0.4584411383,
-0.7247770429,
0.6608784199,
0.7333754897,
0.1670865268,
0.6395453215,
0.1707393527,
-0.4194703996,
-0.0422556847,
-0.7174876928,
-0.0581494346,
-0.4046835601,
0.1510262787,
-0.0561795346,
-0.9459369779,
0.2901289165,
0.1601782888,
-0.0663564131,
0.384763509,
0.8989337683,
-0.026636295,
0.9989513159,
0.5443328023,
0.0349813849,
0.3348425627,
0.2932893336,
0.2440554202,
-0.6787213683,
-0.3773405254,
-0.5729322433,
-0.2829700112,
-0.284609437,
-0.418517381,
0.4718222916,
-0.135338679,
-0.1665176749,
0.2928045094,
-0.5060329437,
0.5725985169,
0.2931771576,
0.1273082793,
0.4309692383,
-0.0530026443,
-0.2695453167,
-0.0639291033,
-0.5288181305,
-0.4464171827,
1.4106824398,
0.2127467543,
0.4280213416,
-0.0030254854,
0.5594713688,
0.4111011624,
0.5295608044,
-0.8362945914,
0.4960409105,
-0.2677364349,
-0.7139689922,
0.0003087985,
-0.4586496651,
-1.2501950264,
0.1448106915,
-0.3983344138,
-0.6602617502,
0.1410208642,
-0.087954551,
-0.931234777,
0.0075780419,
-0.6529669166,
0.7128750682,
-0.4006529748,
-0.0632061511,
0.0294834375,
-0.6102045178,
0.2906377017,
-0.2966091633,
0.0118670845,
-0.3478399813,
0.0033077754,
0.4392994046,
-0.3712987304,
0.4809422791,
-0.174071759,
0.0651103184,
-0.1066000089,
0.0603994839,
0.2301570475,
-0.0458498076,
-0.1946907341,
0.1945622116,
0.2841005921,
-0.558406651,
-0.4853069782,
0.7902964354,
-0.3561253846,
-0.2012254149,
-0.6802057028,
-0.5547318459,
-0.001368377,
0.3480685055,
0.0965768769,
0.2049642801,
-0.3232325613,
0.2737776041,
0.3885141611,
-0.4894361496,
0.0563882999,
1.20230937,
-0.2756615281,
-0.3645934165,
0.4431881905,
-0.0411238708,
0.3358748853,
0.5527678728,
0.2159569263,
-0.4786190689,
-0.9379470944,
-0.4726404846,
0.342954278,
-0.2772969604,
-0.1808891892,
-0.6969107389,
-0.0240703113,
-0.4324574769,
-0.1772674322,
0.047677923,
-0.0054854723,
-0.152048409,
0.2381505966,
0.1497074217,
0.6171017885,
0.2092032731,
0.4458154142,
-0.7080162764,
0.619515419,
0.053234037,
0.6535758972,
-0.3645889461,
-0.6889172196,
-0.156867981,
-0.1014630273,
-0.1437004358,
-0.859185338,
0.2145757526,
0.152353093,
0.5859885812,
0.3973602355,
0.0622912943,
0.6839141846,
-0.6436715126,
0.5022835135,
0.2598254979,
-0.8208308816,
0.6633825898,
-0.383107692,
0.1067379266,
0.8100146055,
0.2670296729,
-0.953027308,
-0.1448917389,
-0.1981330812,
-0.8096477985,
0.7931136489,
0.3279364109,
-0.0729281083,
0.0892132297,
0.8069047332,
-0.2028018236,
0.141848743,
-0.4408533573,
0.122484453,
0.3826786578,
-0.6087858081,
-0.3353010416,
-0.2447673678,
-0.3592939377,
0.1151849404,
0.4172549844,
-0.4009786844,
0.3298573196,
0.5338247418,
-0.1620671004,
-0.3408248127,
0.3132864833,
0.6725046039,
0.3339768052,
-0.4916159213,
-0.2577694356,
0.0547670983,
-0.4243927896,
0.1437757164,
0.2170431465,
-0.3073968589,
0.0171446539,
0.3916940391,
0.7188997269,
0.173668161,
-1.0284774303,
0.7665265799,
-0.4829774499,
-0.6155695319,
-0.0385601707,
-0.1072698385,
-0.1561714858,
0.3292542398,
0.3196609914,
-0.4267659485,
0.118680656,
-0.6044884324,
0.355694145,
0.7955026031,
-0.7735980749,
0.0829035789,
0.7745381594,
0.0367817767,
-0.429584384,
0.5675292611,
0.1646115929,
-0.0642796531,
0.5070133209,
0.5610916615,
0.7588398457,
0.135978356,
0.347491473,
0.0719853044,
0.0940492973,
-0.295612216,
0.0814814344,
0.2741369903,
-0.5204654932,
-0.5401459336,
-0.5965342522,
-0.7999675274,
0.1801030636,
-0.37660411,
0.5513516665,
-0.4752094448,
0.0083580436,
0.2213854641,
0.1240641177,
-0.4361951053,
0.0857528821,
0.3808493912,
0.9199850559,
-0.9323611856,
0.6101624966,
0.2771317065,
-0.2892720401,
-0.664942503,
-0.3289965093,
0.1331306547,
-0.9339923263,
0.0979095697,
0.3917512,
0.2576083541,
-0.3294320703,
-0.2826976478,
-0.5515106916,
1.2931861877,
0.5769127011,
-0.7664475441,
-0.0361573435,
0.3461166322,
0.8675072193,
-0.426194936,
0.5079548359,
0.5714259744,
0.1746080667,
0.5880134106,
-0.968415916,
0.1945160776,
0.0365677327,
-0.1769807637,
0.2586594224,
-0.2394073308,
0.5656161904,
-0.3190441728,
-0.3188967109,
0.4933653474,
0.1377812773,
0.2467961609,
0.7756994963,
0.3979869783,
0.6043512821,
0.6125081778,
-0.1570462435,
0.9328817129,
-0.3178718984,
0.5818832517,
0.8741035461,
-1.0495909452,
0.8124420643,
0.386410594,
-0.1580814421,
0.450892508,
0.4309774339,
-0.0369405672,
0.275840044,
0.2488777339,
-0.3679493964,
-0.4268723428,
-0.4492739439,
-0.1075866893,
0.3058143556,
0.2065386474,
-0.4272272885,
-0.5333260894,
0.048971463,
-0.0033248663,
0.0187188685,
0.0175781306,
0.8668686152,
0.1804100573,
-0.6958383918,
0.4168927968,
-0.0399578474,
0.4140375853,
-0.8508474827,
0.0563696921,
-0.2875134945,
0.5471647382,
-0.2490996867,
-0.7077395916,
0.022742603,
0.0912551433,
0.0364383981,
-0.1340764463,
0.5217581987,
-0.4805981815,
-0.6297278404,
0.4791710377,
0.3490144312,
0.1979911029,
-0.2002891898,
-0.7166875005,
0.0040594093,
-0.1161344871,
0.0474528261,
0.4842351079,
0.3210085928,
-0.0965037122,
0.5642738342,
0.8280966878,
0.4338168502,
-0.4998037815,
0.1789985299,
0.519125998,
-0.7842658162,
-0.1359725744,
-0.9275974631,
0.1264999956,
-0.1332230866,
-0.2537094653,
0.428245753,
0.6327064633,
0.1246470287,
0.2807919681,
0.5910202265,
0.3266533315,
0.5669952035,
-0.3694348335,
0.7293201685,
-0.6562241912,
0.1146771461,
0.0318380222,
-0.5620031357,
-0.8190950751,
0.1727316082,
-0.2140590698,
-0.2156783938,
0.5383040905,
0.8594421744,
0.1465778798,
-0.159550786,
0.4789405167,
0.1360137463,
0.6855908036,
0.9503530264,
0.4507049918,
-0.6426203251,
0.5290687084,
0.3473279774,
-0.6366741657,
-0.6379182339,
-0.9358690381,
-0.7618046999,
0.0747792348,
-0.1601354033,
-0.4505802691,
0.1784964502,
1.0633034706,
0.5352407098,
-0.7063884735,
-0.2586096525,
0.0818571076,
-0.1257016808,
0.0101777017,
-0.1445839554,
0.1863342226,
-0.1102036834,
-0.5213229656,
0.3835833073,
0.7161403298,
-0.0389204137,
-0.0403392687,
-0.0994913504,
-0.2448888123,
0.3828450441,
0.5116007328,
0.4285083115,
-0.4610427618,
-0.1084338948,
0.2593118548,
-0.3917752504,
-0.0063677747,
1.0176264048,
-0.8163997531,
0.6501761079,
0.2939690053,
0.5180965066,
0.6700520515,
-0.1086394787,
0.6586353779,
-0.1166624054,
0.0136879431,
0.4130391777,
0.3535621464,
0.2281926274,
-0.3362021744,
0.2537163794,
0.1517107189,
-0.8222251534,
-0.8820073605,
0.1308236271,
-1.1836197376,
-0.2137458771,
1.1974850893,
0.0238065347,
-0.0586286373,
-0.5685073137,
-0.2341082245,
0.1375591308,
-0.3273078501,
0.8789702654,
0.5338687897,
-0.1830060333,
0.1863563806,
-0.7403698564,
0.2982398868,
0.6185597181,
-0.5829148293,
-0.0761249661,
0.4553685486,
0.4170432985,
-0.1360678226,
1.246845603,
-0.2049627453,
0.2063471079,
-0.5634251833,
0.0367917158,
0.1783623695,
0.1063638628,
-0.7216175199,
0.0517504439,
-0.1156959385,
-0.1388022602
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02643v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02643v1
|
LLM-Enhanced Data Management
| 2024-02-04T23:42:02 | 2024-02-04T23:42:02 |
Xuanhe Zhou, Xinyang Zhao, Guoliang Li
|
cs.DB
|
cs.DB, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Machine learning (ML) techniques for optimizing data management problems have
been extensively studied and widely deployed in recent five years. However
traditional ML methods have limitations on generalizability (adapting to
different scenarios) and inference ability (understanding the context).
Fortunately, large language models (LLMs) have shown high generalizability and
human-competitive abilities in understanding context, which are promising for
data management tasks (e.g., database diagnosis, database tuning). However,
existing LLMs have several limitations: hallucination, high cost, and low
accuracy for complicated tasks. To address these challenges, we design LLMDB,
an LLM-enhanced data management paradigm which has generalizability and high
inference ability while avoiding hallucination, reducing LLM cost, and
achieving high accuracy. LLMDB embeds domain-specific knowledge to avoid
hallucination by LLM fine-tuning and prompt engineering. LLMDB reduces the high
cost of LLMs by vector databases which provide semantic search and caching
abilities. LLMDB improves the task accuracy by LLM agent which provides
multiple-round inference and pipeline executions. We showcase three real-world
scenarios that LLMDB can well support, including query rewrite, database
diagnosis and data analytics. We also summarize the open research challenges of
LLMDB.
|
[
-0.4237094522,
-1.1468844414,
0.6291438937,
0.1001661047,
-0.1376314014,
0.1431902647,
-0.1845277399,
-0.4397293329,
0.2169609219,
0.8055333495,
-0.6405752897,
-0.7054154873,
-0.3783293664,
0.15354231,
-0.3463270962,
0.5391324759,
-0.1262145787,
-0.0311416928,
-0.5624318123,
-0.0277352855,
-0.7380162477,
-0.8118088245,
-0.5109065175,
-0.3528499603,
0.493077606,
0.4247015715,
0.853503108,
0.9624058604,
0.6297374964,
0.2752976418,
0.1039767042,
0.7678612471,
-0.6504866481,
0.4158168733,
-0.0536916517,
-0.4889122248,
-0.7866821289,
-0.2696700692,
0.4098437726,
0.9493060112,
-0.1946170926,
-0.1385639608,
0.011606453,
0.9295811057,
-0.5166307092,
0.2933160067,
-0.7348922491,
0.1736419797,
-0.0095455917,
-0.3104005456,
-0.2203180045,
-0.1646880209,
-0.0333573371,
-0.5893698335,
0.0752627105,
0.0806076527,
0.6022990942,
0.7619627714,
-0.3331852555,
-0.3470620811,
-0.6905792952,
0.7532913685,
-0.2414554358,
0.4045601487,
0.383461386,
0.4018357098,
-0.4631374478,
-0.4955907464,
-0.3157604933,
0.1018813327,
0.0879091695,
-0.0332195759,
-0.1781166792,
0.109876439,
0.1839905679,
0.2404543608,
-0.557790339,
0.4965138733,
-0.0402375236,
-0.1132576913,
0.5297412872,
0.4994789958,
-0.0858998299,
0.0458122231,
-0.3412471712,
0.1809192896,
-0.7523323894,
-0.4257294238,
0.0748085082,
0.3222665191,
0.3958109617,
0.6140877008,
-0.437581718,
0.7762027383,
-0.2643609643,
0.0673767626,
0.091357775,
-0.1633669287,
-0.467557013,
-0.0439814776,
0.3183734715,
0.3544577062,
0.0999062136,
-0.625197351,
-0.4216012061,
0.0797026232,
0.3679517806,
-0.8857203126,
-0.1409179717,
0.4841241539,
-0.443608284,
-0.3605089188,
-0.2230457664,
-0.7285935879,
-0.6824982762,
-0.5787996054,
0.4931761324,
-0.3884041309,
-0.282722801,
0.1392487139,
0.1596755981,
0.227229923,
0.5325651169,
-0.5749953389,
0.3118941486,
0.8240482211,
0.7506973743,
-0.6965382099,
0.0369415507,
-0.5840495825,
0.3832404017,
-0.3596582711,
0.6834874749,
-0.6163996458,
-0.4111225605,
-0.0986627564,
0.0366001725,
0.0498525798,
-0.9964804053,
0.3782707155,
-0.5229262114,
-0.1005913839,
-0.0450418256,
-0.764849782,
-0.3415488005,
0.2170879245,
-0.6591031551,
0.9229683876,
0.2168779373,
-0.3198308647,
0.3828986883,
-0.4633708298,
-0.2337961495,
0.0605886653,
-0.2873654664,
-0.589920938,
0.1333624274,
0.312712729,
0.8151171803,
-0.4366787076,
0.5019079447,
-0.3119800985,
-0.5125951767,
0.045349136,
-0.1951590031,
0.4585277736,
0.3050141335,
0.0266354308,
0.1586342454,
-0.856582284,
-0.1210892498,
0.2435645461,
-0.4654648602,
-0.2099929601,
0.0441551842,
-0.1759738773,
-0.1031520739,
0.1174409017,
-0.0378187783,
0.4666883051,
-0.1123357713,
0.1890522093,
0.8260647058,
-0.1209904477,
0.3650471568,
-0.5572921634,
0.526763916,
0.1751917452,
-0.0696056709,
0.0348727964,
-0.3500687182,
-0.7006958723,
-0.6258432865,
0.2110695541,
0.8066384196,
-0.7421995997,
0.5830353498,
-0.2244604677,
-0.2406318188,
-0.7162604928,
0.4164343476,
-0.0832297131,
0.625389576,
0.6359139085,
-0.2357364893,
-0.6388492584,
-0.7828490138,
-0.2115576118,
0.3074362874,
-0.1375500262,
0.632825017,
0.1948925853,
-0.8512418866,
0.9553329945,
-0.5167149901,
-0.4595153928,
-0.3379681408,
-0.3024005592,
0.4393908978,
0.3507347107,
0.0527424701,
-0.739649415,
-0.0643084049,
-0.0568202808,
-1.040376544,
-0.3058468401,
-0.285094887,
-0.2299190611,
0.3444259465,
0.3655663133,
-0.8416448236,
0.2238922715,
0.1754792631,
-0.160856232,
0.4348875582,
-0.2596226633,
-0.0333138555,
-0.8852695823,
-0.2196058631,
-0.1399611086,
-0.2896854281,
-0.6967914104,
-0.1604078859,
0.2355269343,
-0.1249257773,
-0.2947172225,
0.4458170235,
-0.4514954388,
-0.1661074758,
-0.3625824451,
0.1883989722,
-0.1868697256,
0.3343337476,
0.0832104608,
0.6108435988,
0.7081410885,
-1.1873483658,
0.6625337005,
0.2547384501,
-0.2083288133,
0.6134235263,
-0.3652655482,
0.1808338612,
-0.3584759831,
0.0757390857,
-0.6064295769,
-0.2730624378,
0.1840248108,
-0.2715414166,
0.4761770666,
0.0121501954,
-0.6468648911,
-0.2687450349,
-0.2156508118,
-0.1231645793,
0.4540897012,
-0.8421979547,
0.6907476783,
0.2307553142,
0.0413341932,
-0.7063352466,
-0.6887752414,
0.3362514079,
-0.5199224949,
-0.6802467704,
0.4895483851,
0.005886422,
-0.3359003663,
-0.0225278772,
-0.3476773202,
-0.086629279,
0.4347731769,
0.1055840552,
0.31625247,
-0.0731707215,
0.3339585662,
0.1250661463,
-0.2283733487,
0.1172742471,
-0.1700401306,
0.4427120388,
0.3538167477,
-0.285412401,
-0.3116824329,
0.2142506391,
0.2647884488,
0.0887815356,
0.7538240552,
0.5675901771,
-0.4435263872,
-0.4511269331,
-0.6173842549,
-0.3879301548,
-0.4858160913,
0.554475069,
-0.6575876474,
-0.7182821631,
0.3473707736,
-0.4750523269,
-0.0225863587,
0.1695269346,
0.6393370032,
-0.1794533283,
0.850703299,
0.464323312,
-0.2076054662,
0.1967493296,
-0.2434690446,
0.1209411621,
-0.7056375742,
-0.2771792412,
-0.3795684278,
-0.2567344606,
-0.5930411816,
-0.5968974829,
0.141099751,
0.2196117193,
-0.253698349,
0.1016831025,
-0.4932640195,
0.4213729203,
0.3404205441,
0.2794536352,
0.5621691346,
0.1471820921,
0.1359318793,
0.1081792191,
-0.6752784252,
-0.5767040849,
1.3224180937,
0.4569873214,
1.0243877172,
0.1286801398,
0.6592366099,
0.3680465817,
0.0506889522,
-0.6682463884,
0.5892791748,
0.0499473512,
-0.3313688338,
-0.1870757043,
-0.7904500365,
-0.9254532456,
0.466668725,
-0.2035995275,
-0.5209453702,
-0.0514727458,
0.106385693,
0.093267329,
0.3148167133,
-0.5194602013,
0.5696567893,
-0.2382797748,
-0.4322834015,
-0.2765669227,
-0.2944628894,
0.2230149508,
-0.3504436612,
0.1946621686,
-0.125745967,
-0.3799854517,
0.4572832584,
-0.2551782429,
0.7080003023,
-0.3139470816,
-0.0979655012,
-0.0300683193,
0.2328845561,
0.9281776547,
0.0371262282,
-0.2980527878,
0.1017676294,
-0.3333569169,
-0.4091981947,
-0.5291289687,
0.7342309356,
-0.6005617976,
-0.7514707446,
-0.1417791843,
-0.733812511,
-0.3688857257,
0.0374509916,
-0.2116187811,
0.0486342274,
-0.0292193051,
0.4059175551,
0.9797416925,
-0.5471172333,
0.1575508416,
0.5441063643,
-0.2742634416,
-0.2002548426,
1.0338494778,
0.0995692685,
0.1000342593,
0.5062237382,
0.0718132406,
-0.2710647583,
-0.6761507392,
-0.323343575,
0.1346824765,
-0.6267537475,
-0.3788814843,
-0.9234642386,
0.0259346757,
-0.300306201,
-0.1078593135,
-0.1411594152,
-0.4191713631,
-0.5891114473,
-0.2197186649,
0.6014763117,
0.4523502588,
-0.0685887858,
0.1023319364,
-0.3801008463,
0.4951840341,
0.1029935032,
0.3067120612,
-0.1245795339,
-0.2881669104,
-0.2220626324,
-0.2152781934,
-0.2128574401,
-0.666236341,
0.4877846241,
0.0915093943,
0.6501296163,
0.1862678826,
0.0376681015,
0.6337410808,
-0.2295068353,
0.3527011871,
-0.1914346069,
-0.6115133166,
0.5150088668,
-0.1843155026,
-0.0393898152,
0.16288656,
0.4484413862,
-0.2555894852,
-0.2916681767,
-0.0889264643,
-0.8934569955,
0.4804196656,
0.1146186888,
0.0146891195,
0.1950733513,
0.5491788387,
0.388333261,
0.3497342169,
-0.3557536006,
-0.4615570605,
0.0743768066,
-0.2707128227,
-0.0398668051,
-0.1536130905,
0.0613395907,
-0.3408135176,
0.6031497717,
-0.2046048492,
0.3177733123,
0.0291161295,
-0.4404734969,
0.128508836,
0.1347036809,
0.2319719344,
0.6798117757,
-0.3485501409,
0.0206253044,
0.4139672816,
-0.3362255991,
-0.057199724,
0.0377563462,
-0.0858955681,
-0.1159309521,
0.0593143702,
0.6911440492,
-0.0960764438,
-0.7748177052,
-0.0439510979,
0.0858190358,
-0.2556271553,
-0.1664971411,
0.3518739343,
0.2717716992,
0.4002763629,
0.3933580518,
-0.3415320814,
0.0902882293,
-0.3403309882,
0.1918771565,
0.5408427715,
-0.1233413592,
0.273506999,
0.6641005874,
0.0153452475,
-0.1560512483,
0.6762632728,
-0.047393661,
-0.2375223488,
0.7014456391,
0.4911825061,
0.6102045774,
-0.1702859998,
-0.06122154,
-0.0576829761,
0.2777513564,
0.1267000437,
0.5026769042,
-0.0684336573,
-0.7402415276,
-0.2367370725,
-0.5650895834,
-0.6825429201,
0.1694363058,
-0.4106372297,
0.3170936704,
-0.3229934871,
0.0328727849,
-0.1967716366,
0.3753330708,
-0.7822774053,
0.1595541537,
-0.1463877261,
0.8793277144,
-0.2962232828,
1.02775383,
0.2439516485,
-0.1905670017,
-0.1415377259,
-0.5611299276,
0.0502934977,
-0.9638735652,
0.5953086615,
0.3278265595,
0.094028458,
0.046692919,
-0.364590168,
-0.5133192539,
1.3613222837,
0.4547592103,
-0.6284245253,
0.1278295964,
0.2867776453,
0.3318091035,
-0.4863273501,
-0.101203464,
0.8254764676,
0.6175342798,
-0.047891032,
-0.5637329817,
0.0999806747,
0.2769753337,
0.008191742,
0.103296347,
-0.3402663171,
0.7227887511,
-0.2188473195,
-0.1148492321,
-0.1760926992,
0.6079823971,
0.2545386255,
0.4210968018,
0.2156135738,
0.6624165177,
1.1567050219,
-0.1194518358,
0.9975232482,
-0.1380056143,
0.1674549729,
1.0408936739,
-0.4645486772,
0.4785970747,
0.3866480589,
-0.134387359,
0.1244636402,
0.7915682197,
-0.1593076587,
0.3698173761,
0.397426635,
-0.3712750375,
-0.2897006571,
-0.1611559987,
-0.3221877813,
0.3200704157,
0.5218835473,
-0.2580416799,
0.0403552167,
0.0488703549,
-0.06435702,
-0.0288413335,
-0.3559501767,
0.8247765899,
0.0616074428,
-0.0264100526,
0.6347313523,
-0.045908574,
0.7433697581,
-0.2933697701,
-0.0569793619,
-0.380908072,
0.3059348464,
-0.4146785736,
-0.6861320734,
0.3899384737,
-0.0725566521,
-0.19465895,
-0.2009218484,
0.8899312615,
-0.3576186895,
-0.2139666378,
0.4435196817,
0.7702140212,
0.3876480758,
-0.3170568943,
-0.5932058692,
0.2960518003,
-0.1736373156,
-0.3106832206,
0.4406996667,
0.6146882772,
0.0995356441,
1.1116591692,
0.5145901442,
0.2786512673,
-0.0296120513,
0.0996508971,
0.8349245787,
-0.8173652887,
-0.1946945637,
-0.8392288089,
0.0554781593,
-0.1616048813,
0.3606288135,
0.5383924246,
0.6654819846,
0.6156911254,
-0.0111337258,
0.7150701284,
0.282808274,
0.6366195083,
-0.715993166,
0.5226014256,
-0.6111831069,
0.5378219485,
-0.0500209443,
-1.1706882715,
-0.4805202484,
0.5110222697,
-0.036919903,
0.0188500192,
0.4900790453,
1.0260466337,
0.0750596896,
-0.1065741479,
0.5416125655,
0.2229098529,
0.3969435692,
0.6137779951,
0.6185826659,
-0.0851334482,
0.4120967984,
-0.0605772771,
-0.1383069307,
-0.3152625263,
-0.7067170739,
-1.0159236193,
-0.2217090279,
-0.2449829876,
-0.2060189545,
0.1368958801,
0.9289693236,
0.6385104656,
-0.6700108051,
-0.1805315018,
-0.1552162468,
0.5196592212,
-0.1080542728,
-0.253212899,
0.3308137953,
-0.5076144338,
-0.6183236241,
0.6095744371,
0.2377343774,
0.0548440404,
-0.313501209,
-0.1971850991,
0.1794637442,
-0.113378793,
0.7583194375,
-0.0368192196,
-0.3994163275,
-0.0018346644,
0.0069181025,
-0.1003675833,
0.0248417072,
0.5721369386,
-0.9685519934,
0.3528349698,
0.2713566422,
1.2211463451,
0.5566385388,
-0.0241623241,
0.5968627334,
-0.4761272371,
0.0017900515,
0.2387625128,
0.2259351164,
0.2993868589,
-0.6845268011,
0.7958604693,
0.3203124106,
-0.5374509096,
-0.9344706535,
0.1374507546,
-0.8534570336,
-0.5963252783,
1.0915991068,
0.2893209457,
-0.0203782767,
-0.2998137772,
-0.0957718045,
0.1934972107,
-0.3368656933,
0.8048812747,
0.5360027552,
-0.4222038388,
-0.1476819217,
-0.9426282644,
0.4759534597,
0.307169348,
-1.0545278788,
0.2861732841,
0.5001115799,
0.021157844,
-0.4907935858,
0.3025622964,
0.0857329741,
-0.076174356,
-0.2204242796,
-0.0261262339,
-0.3270852566,
-0.4137477279,
-0.3621255755,
0.1994459778,
-0.1220180169,
-0.1565673798
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02639v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02639v2
|
"It's how you do things that matters": Attending to Process to Better Serve Indigenous Communities with Language Technologies
| 2024-02-04T23:23:51 | 2024-02-06T02:50:48 |
Ned Cooper, Courtney Heldreth, Ben Hutchinson
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Indigenous languages are historically under-served by Natural Language
Processing (NLP) technologies, but this is changing for some languages with the
recent scaling of large multilingual models and an increased focus by the NLP
community on endangered languages. This position paper explores ethical
considerations in building NLP technologies for Indigenous languages, based on
the premise that such projects should primarily serve Indigenous communities.
We report on interviews with 17 researchers working in or with Aboriginal
and/or Torres Strait Islander communities on language technology projects in
Australia. Drawing on insights from the interviews, we recommend practices for
NLP researchers to increase attention to the process of engagements with
Indigenous communities, rather than focusing only on decontextualised
artefacts.
|
[
-0.344720006,
-0.5836110711,
0.417103678,
0.319770962,
-0.0842480436,
0.2976764441,
-0.2724327743,
-0.8008841872,
0.4691931903,
0.6431689262,
-0.1810408086,
-0.0787035227,
-0.8098018765,
0.3430323899,
-0.0762847289,
0.6124469638,
0.0844388455,
-0.1711276472,
0.2236487716,
-0.39369151,
-0.6272709966,
-0.4266391993,
-0.8880826831,
-0.2400633395,
0.4373929501,
0.2744806409,
1.2726962566,
0.8242363334,
0.5813025832,
0.2565501928,
-0.5982156396,
0.0172133781,
-0.0868194476,
0.1057676151,
-0.6461283565,
-0.5095541477,
0.1214527339,
0.0458856076,
0.131509766,
0.6383696795,
-0.277430445,
0.7367265224,
-0.2978562415,
0.3770484924,
-0.6867031455,
0.1344632059,
-0.191948995,
0.4733355343,
-0.3228152692,
-0.3954688907,
-0.3781551421,
-0.764877677,
-0.2553854585,
-0.4393345118,
-0.1765786856,
0.1463920772,
0.293428123,
0.2013357431,
-0.3382003903,
-0.0635627285,
-0.8496640325,
1.0397530794,
-1.0855731964,
-0.0586353019,
0.8191639185,
-0.0983402133,
-0.0926107615,
-0.7784659863,
-0.4800276756,
0.2989782989,
-0.4651232064,
-0.2572799623,
-0.1081455946,
0.1978090405,
0.4487760663,
0.3383532166,
-0.3950320482,
0.1608536839,
-0.7264609933,
-0.1412816793,
0.5480238199,
-0.0952077582,
0.5753459334,
-0.2302293777,
0.1825027168,
0.057287477,
-0.6629359126,
0.1227355525,
0.3601699769,
0.5084574223,
0.3727200627,
0.8490940928,
-0.0081515973,
0.8301292658,
-0.1498133689,
-0.1086396649,
0.036144197,
-0.3484064639,
-0.1005204394,
0.2448973209,
0.2524682879,
0.5659236908,
0.1787049621,
-0.073287949,
0.1167914271,
0.0929300711,
0.4411025941,
-0.4587105513,
0.0786446854,
0.4877464473,
-0.5356722474,
0.0516555384,
-0.2742325664,
0.0411670841,
-0.227015987,
-0.7202361822,
0.2587052882,
-0.1563218236,
-1.0125421286,
0.4747505784,
-0.4920448065,
0.2658424675,
-0.0887234807,
-1.3041871786,
0.3222713172,
0.8870904446,
0.5369193554,
0.3762434423,
-0.2562825978,
-0.5813861489,
0.1475633979,
-0.4748737812,
0.6395323873,
-0.6279039979,
-0.4287404418,
0.2718750536,
-0.106164895,
-0.0565317795,
-0.4741503298,
0.7277162671,
-0.4274222255,
0.0330196507,
-0.5659231544,
-0.1752820164,
-0.2467712611,
-0.1203772947,
-0.4625161886,
1.202890873,
-0.0666460916,
-0.6714649796,
0.4940177202,
-0.9561616182,
-0.7573153377,
0.491086781,
0.1603527814,
-0.1248742789,
0.3830174804,
-0.0260405652,
0.399299711,
0.1696553826,
0.4322134256,
0.0970255509,
-0.454934597,
0.2109818459,
-0.0415962152,
1.1866595745,
0.4165443182,
-0.6390134096,
-0.2878662646,
-0.33150962,
0.3700937927,
-0.3906317651,
-0.4121509492,
-0.5572369099,
0.1581018865,
0.3256474435,
0.1962542683,
-0.0729656592,
-0.5449345708,
0.1573357731,
-0.3880259097,
0.9126483202,
0.329647392,
-0.0583897457,
0.6394676566,
-0.3390235603,
0.4778120518,
-0.6119260788,
0.5305557847,
0.0424204059,
-0.9311285019,
-0.5188708901,
0.4638086855,
0.096744515,
0.2245981693,
-0.6904073954,
0.249793455,
0.0926675051,
-0.2577719986,
-0.9703567028,
-0.1096688733,
-0.0166595913,
0.2294484973,
0.2102202028,
-0.4321832955,
-0.4943359792,
-0.910363853,
-0.375405103,
-0.8101189733,
0.075941503,
0.0560108423,
0.1367242485,
-0.1152665094,
1.2803337574,
-0.2449932247,
-0.1476215124,
-0.0708707273,
0.4262515008,
0.0832091048,
0.3896045983,
0.4033502638,
-1.1898463964,
-0.3441441953,
0.2746273279,
-0.70257622,
-0.2027446628,
-0.0452674739,
0.1274815351,
0.016073186,
0.3153906763,
-0.562954545,
0.3229048848,
0.457015425,
-0.5362150669,
-0.0798271298,
-0.2666654587,
0.3314335346,
-0.701638937,
0.1382554322,
-0.2328765243,
-0.1375329494,
-0.6060366631,
0.520180881,
-0.0968825817,
-0.1375954896,
-0.6894957423,
0.3819345534,
-0.2973825037,
-0.0949072838,
-0.2981404066,
-0.1562506109,
0.114034228,
0.0676613897,
0.5475608706,
0.547788918,
0.3860216439,
-0.5430681705,
0.0664233789,
0.4992913008,
-0.198094219,
0.7265896797,
-0.4123392701,
0.3960897326,
-0.0404937454,
-0.2607069016,
-0.4631969631,
0.2706237435,
0.1856160015,
-0.4785819352,
0.0324137248,
-0.2558247745,
-0.6655988097,
-0.3921968341,
-0.1552635729,
0.2630386949,
0.2481625229,
-0.1840191483,
0.8077082634,
1.0199258327,
-0.5738193393,
-0.8718593717,
-1.4891754389,
0.6147074699,
-0.4588022828,
-0.6771941185,
-0.1109344214,
-0.0145313917,
-0.784090817,
0.0860112384,
0.1564152092,
-0.4016965032,
0.5728513002,
0.2041503936,
-0.48167032,
-0.4278333187,
0.0741231367,
0.179443866,
-0.1947730035,
0.1962855011,
-0.2234085947,
0.3568762839,
-0.055876784,
-0.1873379946,
-0.3425227106,
0.898105979,
0.0856947154,
-0.3032125235,
0.751316905,
0.7572091818,
-0.3187312186,
0.1178534776,
-0.7854067683,
-0.0983614698,
-0.5168963075,
-0.0217322316,
0.1967984289,
-0.9832262397,
0.2188103199,
0.1511015892,
0.5467098355,
0.2572667003,
0.3218963146,
-0.1899159104,
0.1762501746,
1.0749708414,
-0.0185361654,
0.3665696681,
-0.0598509647,
0.6962225437,
-0.7082157731,
0.1456604451,
-0.6419145465,
-0.2865641713,
-0.6472768188,
-0.5165408254,
-0.0512763746,
-0.0429628007,
-0.1995939612,
0.9604287148,
-0.8956815004,
0.5672470331,
0.5845764279,
-0.1193061098,
0.8218202591,
-0.2630164027,
0.6055995822,
-0.1509613991,
-0.6551328897,
-0.9353379011,
0.7524152994,
0.1814040393,
0.6005975604,
0.4191240668,
0.810025394,
0.5991826653,
0.3206866086,
-0.7033270597,
0.2277357876,
0.2632232606,
-0.8278394341,
-0.5096395016,
-0.0977031961,
-1.1954964399,
0.0639365837,
0.0959971249,
-0.5535539389,
0.4652519524,
-0.1173006222,
-0.5099657774,
0.4713944793,
-0.9032970071,
0.3514619172,
0.083100155,
-0.0629635453,
-0.4659605622,
-0.6374345422,
-0.1800864786,
0.2307837903,
0.5398094058,
0.0904335827,
-0.0142762586,
0.6412014365,
-0.1110078618,
0.9634930491,
0.0764687136,
-0.2017080635,
0.7365108132,
0.0786872208,
-0.002386661,
0.2348977774,
-0.425431639,
0.168778941,
0.0478577577,
-0.4076269567,
-0.1114009246,
0.5446767211,
-0.5300199389,
-0.7704739571,
-0.4149800241,
-0.092711024,
0.1128129214,
-0.0200055838,
-0.0513567366,
0.1463743448,
-0.0271507055,
0.0192419942,
0.668281734,
-0.0979638547,
0.9026335478,
0.2952263653,
0.1102341264,
0.2134056836,
0.6041365862,
0.3925129175,
0.3907648325,
0.4353199303,
0.178742826,
-0.2462026924,
-0.4392197132,
-0.6331359148,
0.0557993911,
-0.8680955172,
0.0076295072,
-0.7112363577,
-0.0144514143,
-0.3154374957,
-0.4507113397,
-0.299256593,
-0.6235299706,
-0.1958857477,
-0.4786588252,
0.5521756411,
0.8588568568,
-0.5092187524,
0.0984079316,
-0.696973145,
0.2496329546,
0.3980892301,
0.1157263517,
-0.2008824646,
-0.1563817412,
-0.0793259889,
-0.1619226933,
-0.1349491179,
-0.1406660527,
0.4735034406,
-0.0035408908,
0.6402190924,
-0.2131036073,
0.2443890721,
0.4783456922,
-0.2634535432,
0.9747360945,
0.0302296933,
-0.7370823026,
0.590692699,
-0.3420679867,
0.2708123326,
0.6721920371,
0.3013391793,
-1.1797373295,
-0.5414418578,
-0.7303599715,
-1.0588757992,
0.7132475972,
0.4766658545,
0.6426067352,
-0.1183926761,
0.1932062656,
0.0056014871,
0.3665754497,
-1.1169977188,
-0.4042914212,
-0.0404089503,
0.319083184,
0.2786830664,
-0.0335964449,
-0.4225837588,
0.2861656845,
0.195417881,
-0.2415198982,
0.2069539428,
0.1798772216,
-0.0930547044,
-0.2993147373,
0.4346407354,
0.1076730788,
0.9334045649,
0.1713455617,
0.1698011905,
0.0887507498,
-0.5092488527,
0.1569493115,
-0.2449148446,
-0.1654973179,
-0.025750583,
0.1523865908,
0.3816049695,
0.0066701844,
-0.3562214971,
0.1650263518,
-0.3154712915,
0.230894655,
-0.1651244015,
0.0506135821,
0.3956267834,
0.0814962238,
0.476185292,
0.4976238906,
0.3255912066,
-0.844719708,
-0.20798783,
0.0377081335,
-0.1315256357,
-0.0428919122,
0.3938678503,
0.3919319808,
-0.8443899155,
0.3718876839,
0.2455990911,
-0.0238026381,
0.5192508698,
0.199045375,
0.6703778505,
-0.1846864969,
0.6180012822,
0.2413541675,
0.6199926138,
-0.4928223193,
0.2161032408,
-0.3794030845,
-0.6447585821,
-0.9723367691,
-0.461727947,
-0.7273874879,
-0.2296666056,
-0.8095372319,
0.0925252438,
-0.341997385,
-0.5195216537,
-0.1985014975,
-0.0251584202,
-0.2829597592,
0.1085475013,
0.3504283726,
0.717882216,
-1.1159305573,
0.3549481928,
0.3662216067,
-0.3190263808,
-0.4704359174,
-0.2780445814,
-0.1469373256,
-0.4158371389,
0.5850723982,
-0.3104802072,
-0.1888531893,
-0.1118173525,
-0.3834414482,
-1.0558052063,
0.7815076709,
0.3285706043,
-0.1459596902,
0.2041017413,
0.4377863705,
0.5515321493,
0.3103379905,
0.4060175717,
0.4167017043,
0.770144403,
-0.4124358296,
-1.1450090408,
-0.2495391369,
-0.197073549,
0.1598233283,
0.2254840732,
-0.7494171858,
0.2594531775,
-0.0342337675,
-0.3848094344,
0.0015354821,
0.4257927537,
-0.0114842691,
0.111075595,
0.0217112601,
0.1575675905,
0.7242369652,
-0.056355413,
1.2043788433,
0.1720128953,
0.064627789,
0.7445153594,
-0.0112776421,
0.6894615293,
0.915111661,
-0.3321223259,
-0.002868159,
0.7519537807,
0.3822226226,
0.1459025592,
0.3253667057,
-0.1938031018,
-0.01785383,
-0.4090527296,
-0.3128087223,
0.3277098536,
0.4445637465,
-0.0317634605,
-0.0837504789,
0.137032941,
-0.1424398422,
0.5806599259,
-0.3290808499,
0.6823179126,
0.2960444093,
-0.5504881144,
0.080401428,
0.1412985623,
0.8495947719,
-0.4929566681,
0.062261004,
0.01776921,
-0.3729630113,
-0.5942332149,
-1.1785136461,
0.979635179,
-0.2521632016,
-0.0779334754,
-0.6938601136,
0.5006663203,
0.0627904609,
-0.3564752042,
0.3066481948,
0.3855307698,
0.0804490671,
0.1042754874,
-0.4057605267,
0.1143844947,
-0.0238291193,
-0.2212231457,
0.3885411918,
0.4528283179,
-0.2906873226,
0.6600180864,
0.5885318518,
0.3805908561,
0.0645858049,
0.2257286608,
0.6082371473,
-0.7737234235,
-0.1444607079,
-0.6361652017,
0.5773316026,
-0.0440407135,
-0.7960249186,
0.5938323736,
0.3088848889,
0.8414239883,
0.1476301551,
0.5534574389,
-0.4508660436,
0.1920456141,
-0.471714735,
0.5189956427,
0.1558324695,
0.1423068196,
-0.2804583609,
-0.724213779,
-0.6002099514,
0.9165201783,
-0.2750281394,
-0.1939062774,
0.3502685428,
0.4894326031,
0.2897700965,
0.5256482959,
0.4307050705,
-0.106801793,
0.311016947,
-0.0085282037,
0.8435117602,
-0.5110930204,
0.2530219257,
-0.4502343833,
-0.0107715316,
0.1425975561,
-0.9846794605,
-0.2453771383,
-0.5937018394,
-0.5754472017,
0.0262246132,
-0.2341612875,
0.9290804863,
0.8993583918,
-0.6624613404,
-0.4987152219,
0.228267923,
0.0707859397,
-0.6169564724,
-0.2475216687,
0.1146926507,
-0.2205628306,
-0.8619545698,
0.3136832416,
0.6690909863,
-0.4492425621,
-0.2964811921,
0.2954846621,
-0.4827417433,
-0.3105064034,
0.7840034366,
0.6850255728,
-0.6561051011,
-0.281558156,
-0.0088810837,
-0.1285449564,
0.304056257,
1.0504223108,
-0.6054614186,
0.3938211203,
0.2074838281,
0.8985667825,
0.5229730606,
-0.0925669447,
0.8382890224,
-0.4223454297,
0.1142374426,
0.7084550858,
0.3268189132,
0.7499998212,
-0.910510838,
0.7711852193,
-0.1830183119,
-0.8523581028,
-0.4506452084,
0.0988514051,
-0.8092948198,
-0.1983170211,
1.1841933727,
0.0195380189,
-0.2340068966,
-0.9439888,
-0.5525286198,
-0.1114576757,
-0.3069520295,
0.7651640773,
0.4127261043,
-0.2287689447,
-0.1088171676,
-0.5465502739,
0.4404553175,
0.4684843123,
-0.3609132469,
0.1683657169,
-0.1292751431,
0.1483023465,
0.6147897243,
0.8571349978,
-0.1963136643,
0.1741810143,
-0.1104998291,
-0.0491790064,
0.3737614453,
0.2481794208,
-0.1413974166,
0.1178042814,
0.4543497264,
0.3250516951
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02636v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02636v1
|
Can Large Language Models Learn Independent Causal Mechanisms?
| 2024-02-04T23:04:02 | 2024-02-04T23:04:02 |
Gaël Gendron, Bao Trung Nguyen, Alex Yuxuan Peng, Michael Witbrock, Gillian Dobbie
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IT, cs.LG, math.IT, I.2.3; I.2.6; I.2.7; G.3
|
Despite impressive performance on language modelling and complex reasoning
tasks, Large Language Models (LLMs) fall short on the same tasks in uncommon
settings or with distribution shifts, exhibiting some lack of generalisation
ability. This issue has usually been alleviated by feeding more training data
into the LLM. However, this method is brittle, as the scope of tasks may not be
readily predictable or may evolve, and updating the model with new data
generally requires extensive additional training. By contrast, systems, such as
causal models, that learn abstract variables and causal relationships can
demonstrate increased robustness against changes in the distribution. One
reason for this success is the existence and use of Independent Causal
Mechanisms (ICMs) representing high-level concepts that only sparsely interact.
In this work, we apply two concepts from causality to learn ICMs within LLMs.
We develop a new LLM architecture composed of multiple sparsely interacting
language modelling modules. We introduce a routing scheme to induce
specialisation of the network into domain-specific modules. We also present a
Mutual Information minimisation objective that trains a separate module to
learn abstraction and domain-invariant mechanisms. We show that such causal
constraints can improve out-of-distribution performance on abstract and causal
reasoning tasks.
|
[
-0.1639917344,
-0.6875193119,
0.736109972,
0.2286039889,
-0.0338497236,
-0.3801188767,
-0.2997294664,
-0.3956236839,
0.0763848051,
0.460026443,
-0.5037677288,
-0.1964782029,
-0.6563454866,
0.1177237034,
-0.2336105257,
0.7803559899,
0.001156916,
0.2638696432,
-0.1663189679,
-0.2371698767,
-0.3646408319,
-0.3813102245,
-0.7681547403,
-0.5859097242,
0.802641809,
0.1985340863,
0.4266276956,
0.6715865731,
0.3985196948,
0.3736501336,
0.0914650261,
0.2123579383,
-0.349037528,
0.0086403079,
-0.6493820548,
-0.499661237,
0.0661126077,
-0.3009600043,
0.6655185819,
0.9236533642,
-0.0484131575,
-0.1811389178,
0.2013643235,
0.4294646978,
-0.6581383944,
0.6646689773,
-0.6541249156,
-0.2814251184,
-0.076692991,
-0.2583073974,
-0.6154780984,
0.1078084484,
0.0719809383,
-0.5554785728,
0.0966307893,
0.0152204661,
0.4212677479,
0.2560304105,
-0.7464041114,
-0.2121603489,
-0.7502549291,
0.6264105439,
-0.5768945813,
0.1508724689,
0.2173058838,
0.2473793626,
-0.3130826056,
-0.4018783569,
-0.2771322429,
-0.1998617202,
-0.2714225054,
-0.0518811382,
-0.1989287138,
0.0604712702,
0.1443007886,
-0.2571250796,
-0.1297454685,
0.4979242086,
-0.3664660454,
-0.0589492768,
0.5879935026,
0.4008769989,
0.2320858538,
-0.1344077289,
-0.4760278761,
0.0852029398,
-1.0406111479,
-0.1049571633,
0.5140584707,
0.4734834433,
-0.3544157445,
0.2350779027,
-0.0580205917,
0.5850226283,
-0.036554087,
-0.0797961131,
-0.2123960704,
0.120208323,
-0.1312878579,
-0.1121767759,
0.7147351503,
-0.4962026179,
-0.0584227592,
-0.3174756169,
-0.3127321899,
0.0514676161,
0.0197747219,
-0.2895414531,
-0.2222886533,
-0.0110396426,
-0.158591941,
0.0042923884,
-0.1616574675,
-0.2116661668,
-0.3487432003,
-0.5816661119,
0.6999458671,
-0.2786097527,
-0.2485880256,
0.2697008848,
0.1277926415,
0.0219930857,
0.5267498493,
-1.0508973598,
0.5048550367,
0.5714190602,
0.6233307719,
-0.2555699646,
-0.6100221872,
-0.6847724915,
0.5644237399,
-0.2438109517,
0.7020905614,
-0.4698934555,
0.1167784259,
0.0778546184,
0.1437933445,
-0.3600292802,
-0.4456677437,
0.2762968838,
-0.7678718567,
-0.1743740439,
-0.0561449789,
-0.4890005589,
-0.364279598,
-0.1551923007,
-0.6686688662,
0.4577305615,
-0.1701583862,
-1.0186327696,
0.1798388958,
-0.2693325877,
-0.6389529109,
-0.1763281077,
-0.3973152339,
-0.2436359376,
0.1699029803,
-0.01576888,
0.6931435466,
-0.6380746365,
0.7055221796,
-0.7468002439,
-0.1452731639,
0.11880254,
-0.6299775243,
0.7443706989,
-0.0636960417,
-0.5591747761,
0.1441352367,
-0.9381748438,
-0.4429252148,
-0.0643329173,
-0.3861382902,
-0.5778336525,
0.3146373928,
-0.3004004061,
0.4336998463,
-0.0602979921,
-0.1103258058,
0.0965494141,
-0.2744393051,
0.2195145041,
1.0829153061,
0.1222206354,
0.5975438952,
-0.2100302428,
0.1484445632,
0.4529453218,
0.0727167949,
0.0886418372,
-0.3312468529,
-0.9191359878,
-0.2982522845,
-0.2108060867,
0.3818467557,
-0.7953516245,
0.3755202293,
-0.0363309607,
-0.1159037948,
-0.025256196,
0.2965316772,
0.4087385833,
0.2448610365,
0.2559372485,
-0.2985350192,
-0.2474001944,
-0.7597231269,
-0.1056109443,
-0.2612336278,
0.2983671725,
0.2027042061,
0.5727043152,
-0.1750819236,
0.5703376532,
-0.4145481288,
-0.1597755253,
-0.2982764244,
0.0773804858,
0.129798457,
0.514159441,
0.1497043967,
-0.5594058633,
-0.1727800369,
0.1766320169,
-0.9723485112,
-0.1702669561,
-0.22335127,
-0.1184589863,
-0.0729734302,
0.7290127873,
-0.8040261865,
0.1315820962,
0.3301922977,
-0.2502068877,
0.4687437415,
-0.4630101323,
-0.3854182661,
-0.6111691594,
-0.0696551427,
0.0318186879,
-0.0236070137,
-0.6152610779,
0.0671233833,
-0.0472200811,
0.0919826552,
-0.6058807373,
0.9415817857,
-0.7204375863,
-0.0192888509,
-0.3655724227,
0.2639476955,
-0.1801176965,
0.7776530385,
0.0539148599,
0.0698834956,
1.066216588,
-0.9376848936,
0.0081513245,
0.009911132,
-0.3867732286,
0.2650066614,
-0.4584001303,
-0.2658379078,
-0.4368347824,
0.0974892899,
-0.7390159369,
-0.3384607136,
0.2545017004,
0.0591801703,
0.4858005047,
-0.0733571127,
-0.5000793338,
0.076628685,
0.3012396693,
0.2489544451,
0.2928959429,
-0.6838873029,
0.6063221693,
0.396397382,
0.1156246588,
-0.6542241573,
-0.5339941382,
-0.2296698689,
-0.2951644361,
-0.5218881965,
-0.2552961707,
0.1322075576,
-0.4484762847,
0.0448715948,
0.0764158443,
-0.0661100596,
0.2157591283,
0.2512457669,
-0.1167144477,
-0.120000191,
0.5226466656,
0.2498860359,
-0.2251412719,
0.2128674686,
-0.5967282057,
0.320218116,
0.3649315536,
-0.6931840777,
-0.3876433372,
0.4475344419,
0.5111122131,
-0.0388537757,
0.9329208136,
0.5580242276,
-0.2084676772,
-0.4260343313,
-0.5448203683,
-0.3995443583,
-0.452996701,
0.3444471061,
-0.380680114,
-1.0886791945,
0.5613779426,
-0.2368171364,
-0.2508387566,
0.4864218533,
0.6176271439,
0.4135276675,
1.0373946428,
0.9589400291,
-0.227932632,
0.3584576845,
0.0191951394,
0.1293240637,
-0.5856748223,
-0.1697654426,
-0.4409717917,
0.0127051352,
-0.4241941571,
-0.4567617476,
0.3964141011,
0.3499419987,
-0.5100806355,
0.0645919144,
0.1548292339,
0.2972532511,
0.5567691326,
0.2930425704,
0.3509480059,
0.0722501427,
-0.3882485628,
0.3051500022,
-1.083942771,
-0.1629455835,
0.696883142,
0.1597299129,
1.1563843489,
0.2929879129,
0.5631363392,
0.0446576253,
0.4991102517,
-0.2779012024,
0.561997354,
-0.0393544436,
-0.4580043256,
-0.243795231,
-0.7536655664,
-0.8964396119,
0.4219531417,
-0.1521369219,
-0.7896025777,
0.5694526434,
0.0755940378,
0.0502377525,
0.4952666163,
-0.7471824288,
0.5852729678,
-0.0704623237,
-0.6622561812,
-0.3377318382,
-0.722827673,
0.5779556632,
-0.2156565189,
0.4091328979,
-0.1728652865,
-0.0301208422,
0.4462665915,
-0.3252865076,
1.6292464733,
-0.1082009152,
-0.196208626,
0.3040228784,
0.1884823143,
0.8368599415,
0.2163151503,
0.0280043576,
0.0612422787,
-0.6149186492,
-0.4583759606,
-0.6044838428,
0.816577673,
-1.0034263134,
-0.9330438375,
-0.2060831338,
-0.5648097992,
-0.2925209403,
0.3037518561,
0.0297861211,
0.5653856993,
0.0377531275,
-0.0411704704,
0.7442976832,
-0.2649570405,
0.4746465087,
0.7604986429,
0.1877703965,
-0.3275604844,
0.5401344895,
-0.1274194121,
0.6674335003,
0.77574718,
0.3476446271,
-0.1418266892,
-0.404991895,
-0.1789744645,
0.4101914465,
-1.0128130913,
-0.1803590655,
-0.8740695119,
-0.1392012089,
-0.3431175947,
-0.068054013,
-0.0391574539,
-0.3598163724,
-0.2877777517,
-0.1802767068,
0.3040199578,
0.9575486779,
-0.4818924367,
0.3622455597,
-0.6186452508,
-0.0245570093,
0.4694770277,
0.1445638686,
0.534843266,
-0.4720883369,
-0.5370221734,
-0.3369545043,
-0.1506712288,
-0.615286231,
0.2511125207,
0.1553528309,
0.6040676832,
0.6265753508,
-0.056942489,
0.5905823708,
-0.800111413,
0.2743701041,
0.4008152783,
-0.8600198627,
0.1349193007,
-0.5069671273,
0.2789899707,
0.0785322636,
0.66981709,
-0.2614376545,
-0.6405982971,
-0.5263012052,
-0.5960889459,
0.7901652455,
-0.0668041334,
0.0741273835,
-0.1953158379,
0.4484989941,
0.140240103,
-0.0211866368,
-1.0644629002,
-0.1671039909,
0.5216428638,
-0.0690636858,
-0.2303323597,
-0.1617879421,
-0.1992098987,
-0.1028021649,
0.7471399307,
-0.3272323012,
0.1150361449,
0.080172345,
-0.1379440725,
-0.1739053279,
0.1358462721,
0.4363449514,
0.7363905907,
0.3588288128,
0.4906102419,
0.0915280581,
-0.0580984093,
0.4290718436,
-0.1121703461,
-0.1746225804,
-0.162469551,
0.6664273739,
1.1110770702,
0.5796874166,
-0.4871226847,
0.5529498458,
0.1132924557,
0.0293286201,
0.0183485113,
0.1898793131,
0.2239064276,
0.56548208,
0.0666203573,
0.2454893142,
-0.0165441167,
-0.5010536909,
0.2554439902,
0.2644952238,
-0.493666172,
-0.4145044088,
0.7818239927,
-0.0635542348,
0.0599865392,
0.1919202358,
-0.2079980522,
-0.16487813,
0.4186366796,
0.6984828711,
0.8785119057,
-0.330270797,
0.2037830651,
0.1463000029,
0.4864571691,
-0.4255665541,
-0.0540798232,
-0.0721061975,
-0.7178188562,
-0.5884205699,
-0.4158021212,
-0.1942781359,
-0.0853759423,
-0.3174694479,
0.4290236533,
-0.344287008,
0.1760171503,
-0.2760900557,
-0.4746534824,
-0.598941803,
0.126704976,
-0.3067261577,
0.5843786001,
-1.1439574957,
0.7831273079,
0.4132263362,
-0.4613877535,
-0.99961555,
-0.2712990344,
-0.0867091268,
-0.6831821203,
1.1021054983,
-0.1352760494,
-0.1689085215,
-0.1752839088,
-0.3326778412,
-0.9751656651,
0.7273978591,
0.5925700068,
-0.5302734375,
0.0109047927,
0.0955830216,
0.3705919981,
-0.2897880673,
0.1265800893,
0.1072504371,
0.2246411145,
-0.0881957114,
-0.5444728732,
0.1989213079,
0.0942303389,
-0.2296195924,
0.2721212208,
-0.9350073934,
1.0085002184,
-0.224388212,
-0.1634723991,
-0.0879387558,
0.5965813994,
0.0161543544,
0.0978920087,
0.3182794452,
0.4414373934,
0.6054770947,
0.1280190796,
0.974378705,
-0.2726380825,
0.3618492186,
1.1560348272,
-0.4372968972,
0.6351032853,
0.2744109035,
0.1991015524,
0.436090976,
0.2961557806,
0.5937795639,
0.6533750892,
0.4689093828,
-0.6262946129,
-0.4761040211,
0.1240755692,
0.0533725023,
0.2253157347,
0.3541652262,
-0.2088677436,
-0.518630445,
0.1949830204,
0.0706001967,
-0.130328685,
-0.4703269303,
0.8325738311,
0.4943868816,
-0.5623261333,
0.4357156456,
0.104214333,
0.3363192379,
-0.9206981063,
0.1245407462,
-0.2567607164,
0.5470249057,
-0.0124110822,
-0.1211207286,
0.2010228485,
-0.4272751212,
-0.1311212033,
0.002957619,
0.7651692629,
-0.5634848475,
-0.3386852741,
0.6164835095,
0.6658242345,
-0.108228229,
0.3454231322,
-0.3916873932,
0.0374282338,
-0.3202331364,
-0.0396218412,
0.6077619195,
0.9927592874,
-0.3735654652,
0.8130137324,
0.4538448155,
0.3525215089,
0.2623456717,
0.2514559329,
0.8546880484,
-0.5840076804,
-0.5689393282,
-0.9844036102,
0.1465155482,
0.1459324211,
-0.1428213418,
0.8581428528,
0.1188173816,
0.8892433047,
-0.228972882,
0.567917645,
0.3315684795,
0.0771076605,
-0.84767133,
0.4481569827,
-0.4512024522,
0.3965652585,
-0.2731550336,
-0.6476743817,
-0.6037495732,
0.2448177487,
-0.4292129874,
-0.0897174478,
0.8991779685,
0.8370252848,
-0.2723735869,
-0.1817314029,
0.3884575367,
0.4619761109,
0.3890758753,
0.5964732766,
0.8831029534,
-0.0383977219,
0.1886489391,
-0.0169300903,
-0.2209141105,
0.0063545601,
-0.750947237,
-1.1086047888,
-0.5615087748,
-0.3741111457,
-0.0873867571,
0.1632116437,
0.727237165,
0.7853357196,
-0.5216628909,
-0.4966767728,
-0.3943325877,
0.5140163898,
-0.2349727303,
-0.1918164045,
0.5204390287,
-0.7930619717,
-0.3161143959,
0.340177536,
0.7371929884,
-0.1844500452,
-0.4430509508,
-0.0036104152,
-0.2743729949,
0.2665932477,
0.6075472832,
0.2706822157,
-0.3701977432,
-0.4855596423,
-0.4443502426,
0.0360644348,
-0.2434840351,
1.2453277111,
-0.4212037921,
0.1111844406,
0.462534517,
0.8196333051,
0.299864769,
-0.5884359479,
0.4555260241,
-0.6671922207,
0.4101431072,
-0.0429239124,
0.6252912283,
0.1564583182,
-0.3325076103,
0.1674453318,
0.4702343941,
-0.5159014463,
-0.5483333468,
0.5259937644,
-0.5651000142,
-0.3817550242,
1.1945961714,
-0.2165398151,
-0.562926352,
-0.3879508674,
0.1589041054,
0.111278519,
0.004534448,
0.7496062517,
0.4907144308,
-0.1859574169,
0.0152103603,
-0.326166898,
0.3400210142,
0.2986665666,
-0.8865677118,
0.1083543822,
0.4841741323,
0.3474516869,
-0.0657587871,
0.7333675027,
-0.05973728,
0.0718295947,
0.0454665683,
-0.0858416855,
0.3110450208,
-0.7065675259,
-0.4286264181,
0.0908222869,
0.0221077092,
0.3031986654
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02633v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02633v1
|
Predicting Machine Translation Performance on Low-Resource Languages: The Role of Domain Similarity
| 2024-02-04T22:56:56 | 2024-02-04T22:56:56 |
Eric Khiu, Hasti Toossi, David Anugraha, Jinyu Liu, Jiaxu Li, Juan Armando Parra Flores, Leandro Acros Roman, A. Seza Doğruöz, En-Shiun Annie Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Fine-tuning and testing a multilingual large language model is expensive and
challenging for low-resource languages (LRLs). While previous studies have
predicted the performance of natural language processing (NLP) tasks using
machine learning methods, they primarily focus on high-resource languages,
overlooking LRLs and shifts across domains. Focusing on LRLs, we investigate
three factors: the size of the fine-tuning corpus, the domain similarity
between fine-tuning and testing corpora, and the language similarity between
source and target languages. We employ classical regression models to assess
how these factors impact the model's performance. Our results indicate that
domain similarity has the most critical impact on predicting the performance of
Machine Translation models.
|
[
-0.5631402731,
-0.6985731721,
0.3843871653,
-0.0142426137,
-0.0721271038,
0.1679610908,
-0.4536163211,
-0.750064671,
-0.3523650467,
0.7500813007,
-0.5776498318,
-0.0435340963,
-0.6941226125,
0.5862041116,
-0.2455582917,
0.8871804476,
-0.1300490052,
0.0174989998,
-0.1638345122,
-0.2717234492,
-0.4961337149,
-0.6013557315,
-0.6288208961,
-0.5261331797,
0.560005784,
0.1627477258,
1.0847262144,
0.7530150414,
0.9148661494,
0.254745394,
-0.0952335149,
0.279329747,
-0.4584954381,
0.1079013571,
-0.2297522873,
-0.4643205106,
-0.2194648981,
-0.0382301286,
0.6389681697,
0.8452371359,
0.3676013052,
0.4311300218,
0.4260707498,
0.7010243535,
-0.5010538101,
0.144181028,
-0.7384824157,
-0.1776059568,
-0.1972009093,
-0.1898857355,
-0.38591519,
-0.3125028014,
0.0909628347,
-0.4327517152,
0.5255883336,
0.427464664,
0.8103165627,
0.5084902644,
-0.1842254847,
-0.1087125316,
-0.8184047937,
1.1111592054,
-0.6138293147,
0.5381181836,
0.6211436391,
0.0062601436,
-0.0380847678,
-0.2167886347,
-0.2838444114,
-0.2776601613,
-0.3793450892,
-0.3930633068,
-0.1609754711,
-0.0704297721,
0.420510143,
0.3018158376,
-0.8504766226,
0.2264952809,
-0.6173318624,
-0.054585211,
0.4204302728,
0.1883324236,
0.1663734168,
-0.0300383121,
-0.1549681425,
-0.0866280794,
-0.6699150205,
-0.0361179858,
0.1003234014,
0.9603430629,
0.0113410437,
0.4573980272,
-0.0280433055,
0.8682432771,
-0.1372529417,
-0.2853884101,
0.1894136816,
-0.4820004702,
-0.4131876528,
-0.0245496426,
0.5939648151,
0.2025623918,
0.5019109845,
-0.2753259838,
-0.2559887767,
0.0036001937,
0.3278422952,
-0.7032091022,
0.2125384808,
-0.0929667652,
-0.5676776767,
-0.0758710802,
-0.4297446907,
-0.5415895581,
-0.1929181665,
-0.5133702755,
0.2140497118,
-0.6773674488,
-0.0415531173,
-0.0994436219,
0.2122977525,
-0.073124893,
0.1497626454,
-0.7307047248,
0.5610693693,
0.8205371499,
1.0428501368,
-0.6034097672,
-0.5010710955,
-0.5917797685,
-0.2135227472,
-0.3433282375,
0.5047479868,
-0.4056120217,
-0.2086302936,
0.1798995435,
0.1789576262,
-0.3244518042,
-0.7985762954,
0.4702811241,
-0.6573517919,
-0.0917214453,
-0.2192936987,
-0.5401560068,
-0.1346180439,
0.0242954884,
-0.9236240387,
1.0171844959,
0.3663070202,
-0.5958384275,
0.3336137533,
-0.5059466362,
-0.6825951338,
-0.0510191135,
0.2854542732,
-0.4567176402,
0.3402684331,
-0.0857924744,
0.5556641221,
-0.6169074178,
-0.0044352878,
-0.2035530657,
-0.4368934929,
0.3465926647,
-0.302423209,
0.5138037801,
0.5835328698,
-0.1123020872,
-0.0345591679,
-0.5973818898,
0.205438748,
-0.1045264602,
-0.3254680037,
-0.4851807058,
-0.0939022824,
0.3391991556,
0.3264980316,
0.2055623382,
-0.2181640118,
0.0400846675,
-0.3977717161,
0.221369952,
0.3962049484,
-0.2377396822,
0.614345789,
-0.2020764053,
0.8274019361,
-0.1254918277,
0.0711217746,
0.1668809503,
-0.6411973238,
-0.5090284944,
-0.0301765688,
0.6372032762,
0.4691990614,
-0.529217422,
-0.2133681178,
-0.299222976,
-0.4266343415,
-1.0080149174,
0.509082377,
0.6429410577,
0.0483300202,
0.5439507365,
-0.2934136093,
-0.4566692412,
-1.0680066347,
-0.4547104239,
0.01266036,
0.0873798206,
0.1630719006,
0.423527956,
-0.2498899549,
0.3996956348,
-0.4065218568,
-0.3264813423,
-0.3603962958,
0.2664521635,
0.2153969705,
0.3760243058,
0.6176576018,
-0.811583519,
-0.8043295145,
0.3899892867,
-0.2788835168,
-0.1222973466,
0.2454246581,
0.1963573694,
0.5642135143,
0.5873123407,
-0.3598182201,
0.0496452376,
0.9985938668,
-0.1381081939,
0.3568601906,
-0.3405348659,
0.1861857176,
-0.8360626698,
0.2153054029,
0.1674337834,
-0.1604724675,
-0.5186393261,
0.2055515945,
0.1091738939,
-0.1700403392,
-0.4645141959,
0.4632978439,
-0.3301842213,
-0.3058576882,
-0.3326710165,
-0.0313185342,
-0.1922111511,
0.2352740914,
-0.080986917,
1.167657733,
0.1286955327,
-0.6911696196,
-0.0497932658,
-0.0563215725,
-0.5451853275,
0.2325420231,
-0.5170543194,
-0.1433473676,
0.2337907255,
-0.3683932126,
-0.6050305367,
0.0426706858,
-0.3576846421,
-0.3787261844,
0.2863267362,
-0.2122944146,
-0.5642992258,
-0.2783004642,
0.2781519592,
0.4366742074,
0.5345847011,
-0.0143672181,
0.2889476717,
0.1089380085,
-0.218684867,
-0.5423645973,
-0.6263526678,
-0.2019258738,
-0.2410725355,
-0.3576765656,
0.4900815189,
-0.0002001217,
-0.2974255681,
0.0192917287,
0.1753885895,
-0.2838103473,
0.4587188363,
0.3278340399,
0.1395610571,
-0.4783208668,
0.1213864982,
-0.3049018681,
-0.0952338949,
-0.0718879849,
-0.2612179816,
0.5126155615,
-0.2891239822,
-0.1417413652,
-0.1409311295,
0.3168675601,
0.6778057814,
-0.4167036712,
0.8891006112,
0.7348023653,
-0.3078849614,
-0.1798393726,
-0.3591530323,
-0.0594595447,
-0.3847426772,
0.5467408299,
-0.6264743209,
-0.8427184224,
0.4445772767,
-0.1347229183,
-0.213334322,
0.569021225,
0.7444873452,
0.0336062498,
1.0886631012,
0.9938213825,
-0.3275464177,
0.3791155219,
-0.1936506629,
0.2989134192,
-0.5917044878,
0.2769712508,
-0.8157243133,
-0.3510589898,
-1.1647237539,
-0.5895620584,
0.1163535938,
0.153697446,
-0.1362270713,
0.7740104198,
-0.1104324311,
0.4641184509,
0.8642320037,
-0.4992946684,
0.5104759932,
0.1404785663,
-0.1936689317,
-0.1501581967,
-0.6423113346,
-0.6574656367,
0.9638005495,
0.244907409,
0.5466337204,
0.0372791775,
0.4480242729,
0.3364926577,
0.0455279872,
-0.573598206,
0.2049954236,
-0.5055089593,
-0.6143386364,
-0.2953263819,
-0.4065698385,
-1.0544009209,
0.2107115239,
-0.3114992976,
-0.283316195,
-0.1543138474,
0.0015848253,
-0.3179841638,
0.2496597022,
-0.5470353365,
0.9314281344,
-0.2812159657,
-0.3451259732,
-0.5706816316,
-0.3873159885,
-0.0412120931,
-0.4424019158,
0.3336932957,
-0.110457018,
0.1248112544,
0.4724880159,
0.1915105879,
0.571223557,
0.2541650534,
0.0237514544,
0.025252087,
0.5577761531,
0.2293780297,
-0.2553254962,
-0.4085127413,
0.3187942505,
0.2001870722,
-0.4113010764,
-0.2956174612,
0.9177865982,
-0.9078234434,
-0.3578626812,
-0.1915216297,
-0.5909007192,
-0.3020479977,
0.1889933795,
0.3422295451,
-0.1096989885,
-0.3341021538,
0.1812791377,
0.5860475302,
-0.232689485,
0.2934206724,
0.545797348,
-0.2382383049,
0.1076882631,
0.8670023084,
0.1633203179,
0.5094304085,
0.4215845168,
0.0999964848,
-0.0534613431,
-0.6440386772,
-0.5444345474,
0.1777690649,
-0.2200960666,
-0.335149467,
-0.4332720935,
-0.0396783054,
-0.2646246254,
-0.1573930681,
-0.5864218473,
-0.3686042726,
-0.3885707855,
0.1061932817,
0.2930036783,
0.7424041033,
0.0067752665,
0.1849592626,
-0.8670639992,
0.2611940205,
-0.0162223112,
0.4513458908,
-0.0930283815,
-0.7759037018,
-0.8322814703,
-0.0849631876,
-0.4147343636,
-0.4515728951,
0.6255960464,
0.2534735799,
0.3631858528,
0.1453730166,
-0.0835940614,
0.560557127,
-0.7579963207,
0.7846775055,
-0.0198560264,
-0.7645029426,
0.4737802148,
-0.125915885,
0.0299331807,
0.4070464671,
0.6309425831,
-0.4869372249,
-0.3799885809,
-0.4164056182,
-0.4962995052,
0.6209535599,
0.1067318246,
-0.022967523,
0.124542281,
0.2214386314,
0.2989200056,
-0.0099379793,
-0.5170403123,
-0.2161378413,
0.4209704399,
0.0320174396,
-0.5846964717,
-0.1222126707,
0.1434560418,
-0.0932751298,
0.5497869253,
-0.2370089144,
0.1199670583,
-0.2174626142,
-0.1537179649,
-0.5958282351,
0.3122552633,
0.7421159148,
0.5011948347,
-0.3695146143,
0.0442186147,
0.373162359,
-0.1466587037,
0.0135106379,
-0.0573296696,
-0.1212012395,
0.1292930841,
0.6193985939,
0.899035871,
0.1417265087,
-0.5657480359,
0.0979674309,
0.1213824302,
-0.0642803907,
-0.0018655668,
0.0397348255,
0.0202576611,
0.1331082135,
0.0491100512,
0.3312773407,
0.0374296345,
-0.6358250976,
0.0567166843,
0.3024093807,
-0.622045517,
-0.378339231,
0.5722877979,
0.0233290009,
-0.4912891984,
0.5664727092,
-0.0442582592,
-0.6799301505,
0.5622805357,
0.4963860512,
0.704569459,
-0.3524492085,
0.0129681472,
0.4274029434,
0.4393294752,
-0.3116806448,
0.0083062565,
0.4865172207,
-0.3828171194,
-0.724222064,
-0.8636120558,
-0.3364968002,
0.2464137226,
-0.7289559841,
0.2099886537,
-0.0280365702,
-0.4721517861,
0.0139890555,
0.3335836828,
-1.0980061293,
0.1722093672,
0.304479152,
0.9143211246,
-0.9431352615,
1.0096429586,
0.502173841,
-0.3809598088,
-0.3852685094,
-0.1485485286,
-0.1713090092,
-0.6852748394,
1.1724630594,
-0.0956003368,
-0.28252846,
-0.2715364099,
-0.0770867094,
-1.0353029966,
0.6208850145,
0.408272177,
-0.4942652285,
-0.0581194982,
0.4902999997,
0.7982544899,
-0.4362435341,
-0.1372853965,
0.6380934715,
0.3314495385,
-0.6005120873,
-1.5177953243,
-0.0856116042,
0.1375362426,
0.2873841226,
0.301076591,
-0.4881297052,
0.9684015512,
-0.3072520494,
-0.1043073758,
0.0444856286,
0.3626360297,
-0.1310768872,
0.1609418839,
0.3256931007,
0.2802113593,
0.6134996414,
-0.0245738756,
1.3007286787,
-0.5974111557,
0.3755967021,
1.0068166256,
-0.3775032759,
1.227126956,
0.6329632401,
-0.2712391019,
0.2745085657,
0.5703864098,
-0.0259163398,
0.6786099672,
0.2833868265,
0.2448274046,
-0.2441176176,
-0.2185943723,
-0.4120412767,
0.4942267537,
0.29286623,
-0.7015827298,
0.1953683347,
0.0302587543,
-0.3155991137,
0.2602894306,
-0.2924349606,
0.7285362482,
0.0943871737,
-0.8153461814,
0.949174583,
0.2947963774,
0.5793688297,
-0.285243392,
0.1685612202,
-0.1470814943,
0.4787335396,
0.1194789186,
-0.6141563654,
0.5335426331,
-0.0387807451,
-0.5709877014,
-0.4235031903,
0.5703358054,
-0.2962614298,
-0.5678098798,
0.8532988429,
0.9072377682,
0.0022138869,
-0.1544596702,
-0.8448328376,
0.2237510681,
0.016737232,
-0.1905632913,
0.7525849342,
0.4955403209,
-0.0837335661,
0.7847920656,
0.5207310915,
0.3781631589,
-0.0719122589,
-0.150324747,
0.4302357435,
-0.6840121746,
-0.1028993502,
-0.8274042606,
-0.1050891429,
0.2478230298,
-0.2609794438,
0.5640445352,
0.6465508342,
1.0780088902,
-0.3885279596,
0.7160957456,
0.3777701855,
0.8191585541,
-0.4409101009,
0.6155077815,
-0.7536486983,
-0.0285216663,
-0.2357899547,
-0.9260135889,
-0.1972431988,
0.458450079,
-0.1668088436,
-0.1839414686,
0.8260864019,
0.7798077464,
-0.1633537412,
-0.1627131104,
0.6229617596,
0.174374193,
-0.0959626883,
0.5670720339,
0.5155830383,
-0.542073667,
0.619699657,
-0.3464895487,
0.1350093037,
-0.532340467,
-0.8383613229,
-0.7812529206,
-0.7357566953,
-0.2895080149,
-0.4415125847,
0.0447476096,
0.8929602504,
0.6149150729,
-1.165075779,
-0.4638878703,
0.2593217194,
0.147336781,
-0.5760749578,
-0.1815472245,
0.3873220384,
-0.5205349326,
-0.902361989,
0.2992722094,
0.0777040496,
0.0212585349,
-0.2056669444,
-0.1286523044,
-0.0132473111,
-0.1870195568,
0.7582187057,
0.1155939177,
-1.0322381258,
-0.0450339057,
0.2698128223,
-0.5377090573,
-0.1252915412,
0.8443382382,
-0.6050937176,
0.0423588268,
0.3295831978,
0.7829191089,
0.2954674363,
-0.1605401933,
0.7706478238,
-0.6243282557,
0.0078905318,
0.100919269,
0.2445712835,
0.4060632288,
-0.2932889163,
0.7715858221,
0.0712492913,
-0.7092759609,
-0.6781613231,
0.1653355807,
-0.6509364843,
-0.4144515991,
1.1532119513,
-0.0208769161,
-0.1103909463,
-0.1989602447,
-0.0467852242,
0.20839715,
-0.1507709026,
0.679344058,
0.7867438197,
-0.0860873982,
-0.0432101749,
-1.1005305052,
0.959294796,
0.4868058264,
-0.21055834,
0.3532000184,
0.2340715528,
0.2094651163,
0.3983642459,
0.1881564111,
0.166844517,
0.0011542655,
-0.2088032514,
-0.1045413539,
0.2898416221,
-0.1575704664,
-0.2452233136,
0.1387942731,
0.3855129182,
0.1276903749
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02632v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02632v2
|
GIRT-Model: Automated Generation of Issue Report Templates
| 2024-02-04T22:53:38 | 2024-02-08T14:24:40 |
Nafiseh Nikeghbal, Amir Hossein Kargaran, Abbas Heydarnoori
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL
|
Platforms such as GitHub and GitLab introduce Issue Report Templates (IRTs)
to enable more effective issue management and better alignment with developer
expectations. However, these templates are not widely adopted in most
repositories, and there is currently no tool available to aid developers in
generating them. In this work, we introduce GIRT-Model, an assistant language
model that automatically generates IRTs based on the developer's instructions
regarding the structure and necessary fields. We create GIRT-Instruct, a
dataset comprising pairs of instructions and IRTs, with the IRTs sourced from
GitHub repositories. We use GIRT-Instruct to instruction-tune a T5-base model
to create the GIRT-Model. In our experiments, GIRT-Model outperforms general
language models (T5 and Flan-T5 with different parameter sizes) in IRT
generation by achieving significantly higher scores in ROUGE, BLEU, METEOR, and
human evaluation. Additionally, we analyze the effectiveness of GIRT-Model in a
user study in which participants wrote short IRTs with GIRT-Model. Our results
show that the participants find GIRT-Model useful in the automated generation
of templates. We hope that through the use of GIRT-Model, we can encourage more
developers to adopt IRTs in their repositories. We publicly release our code,
dataset, and model at https://github.com/ISE-Research/girt-model.
|
[
-0.2772478461,
-0.5463942289,
0.2480024993,
-0.0082140788,
-0.2128170431,
0.1584587395,
-0.0156315789,
-0.3537781537,
0.3625231981,
0.440390259,
-0.2222236395,
-0.6106717587,
-0.3872460425,
0.022400029,
-0.6881553531,
1.4474749565,
-0.0608796701,
0.0110676195,
0.0709376186,
0.0324372575,
-0.773453474,
-0.1873961389,
-0.1372122616,
-0.0426751152,
0.3236193657,
0.9232563972,
0.4988986552,
0.7302107215,
0.9082779884,
0.2437775433,
0.3046025634,
-0.1466969699,
-0.2550707161,
0.1867824048,
-0.0414615609,
-0.1679365039,
-0.7003411055,
0.0478469841,
0.0089061661,
0.208304584,
-0.3869618773,
0.4497072101,
-0.0518510342,
0.6775224209,
-0.4888778925,
0.187394172,
-0.4878464341,
-0.2341343164,
-0.0677929595,
-0.1912584454,
-0.5520756245,
-0.5269585848,
0.231601581,
-0.4022886753,
0.3795106709,
-0.1139207333,
0.8439711928,
-0.2554079294,
-0.3248005509,
-0.7898292542,
-0.684094429,
0.1202490926,
-0.5196682811,
0.1771231443,
0.1478521377,
0.4179241359,
-0.1256113499,
-0.7586280107,
-0.1708935648,
-0.5889925957,
-0.2429559976,
0.1261755973,
-0.2660852969,
-0.142663464,
-0.0198184717,
0.1716594845,
-0.8745520115,
-0.2428476214,
-0.6344289184,
0.2192054242,
0.5704516172,
0.3045413196,
0.354236275,
-0.595066011,
-0.2995249033,
-0.1021508649,
-0.5989569426,
-0.2930454612,
0.3353771269,
0.2012270838,
-0.2307882756,
0.6565084457,
0.0132217826,
0.4860255718,
0.2163492143,
0.095035933,
-0.0322323032,
-0.2491698265,
-0.0241355803,
-0.1842474341,
0.5730622411,
0.1783539653,
0.3318991959,
-0.2268685102,
-0.5525103211,
0.0188590195,
0.5754211545,
-0.6415189505,
-0.7720782757,
0.1591097116,
-0.1818825305,
-0.5192960501,
0.4046534598,
-0.6981076598,
-0.4520063102,
-0.2674292624,
0.20660685,
-0.6038877368,
-0.5897183418,
-0.2583667636,
-0.0900653005,
0.0174612757,
0.3905462921,
-0.5357211232,
0.2455316484,
0.4427418411,
0.7213947773,
0.0925756246,
-0.2415686995,
-0.6492700577,
0.2892529964,
-0.3649919927,
1.0145055056,
-0.5216521025,
-0.5257887244,
-0.1576969922,
-0.2302843183,
0.0613159165,
-0.3615074158,
-0.0749727339,
-0.3752812445,
0.2423208803,
0.1733796,
-0.5432286859,
0.0308765061,
0.2935936451,
-0.534340024,
0.6855168939,
0.5662606955,
-0.7864305377,
0.0715466663,
-1.2092268467,
-0.1779557765,
0.3587129414,
-0.1388552636,
-0.6043988466,
0.0633631498,
0.0184278488,
0.0852009952,
-0.5765185952,
0.5028530955,
0.0214212351,
-0.0689901933,
0.2588675618,
0.1290018559,
0.534525156,
0.2832670212,
-0.4723517299,
0.1470562369,
-0.465739876,
0.072838597,
0.3237174153,
-0.0987961069,
-0.2514292002,
-0.1626560092,
0.0923904777,
-0.1116470918,
0.0621452145,
-0.0689127073,
0.4420979321,
0.0818394199,
0.4260816574,
0.5990818143,
0.1263115555,
0.5405983925,
-0.2769744992,
1.0159426928,
0.0487082899,
0.2236039788,
-0.5301592946,
-0.301789999,
-0.7695447803,
-0.2433232814,
0.7922208309,
0.7137874961,
-0.3568890393,
0.2309390604,
-0.4145477116,
-0.784741044,
-0.3829396963,
0.0683165118,
0.4609780014,
0.5625033379,
0.0915136263,
-0.4014005959,
-0.52385813,
-0.8291728497,
-0.1906290054,
-0.5002461672,
0.0168633591,
0.0426243208,
0.7117373347,
-0.2250192612,
1.0757193565,
-0.6145842075,
-0.0284025967,
-0.2069505006,
0.7551208138,
-0.3472768068,
0.4368516505,
0.6805416942,
-0.6973800659,
-0.6224833727,
0.0243075229,
-0.5981013179,
-0.3598766029,
0.1594156325,
-0.0647226945,
0.2652173042,
0.2575390637,
-0.4781491458,
0.4696744978,
0.3398148417,
-0.5297665,
0.5025548935,
-0.1898767948,
0.3382849395,
-1.1775169373,
0.3162430823,
0.2443216294,
-0.3200686276,
-0.5841134191,
0.2682653069,
0.318711549,
-0.4543778896,
-0.1641623974,
0.4258406162,
-0.6329708099,
-0.114680931,
-0.0356891789,
0.0349684469,
0.2605668604,
0.2407144457,
-0.2567214668,
0.7789131403,
0.1628203392,
-0.2917156219,
0.1374024153,
0.0182192307,
-0.1308266073,
0.3528400362,
-0.7177924514,
0.4615821838,
0.0235077776,
-0.0113534238,
-0.9617225528,
-0.5134360194,
0.4475691617,
-0.4876899421,
0.3599717319,
-0.6306071281,
-0.586616993,
-0.3997765481,
-0.1352883279,
-0.1344219446,
0.5735135078,
-0.0453629047,
0.560131371,
0.5508168936,
-0.4695096314,
-0.116627194,
-0.5290126204,
0.0360662304,
-0.4928967655,
-0.6618763208,
-0.096729368,
-0.0860588625,
-0.3100381494,
0.143557325,
0.3040347397,
-0.238253668,
0.0261747837,
0.2437549978,
0.2973535061,
-0.4204246104,
0.2724595964,
-0.2717530727,
-0.2044775933,
-0.0524747409,
-0.2569070756,
0.2410179377,
-0.4090653658,
-0.5978682041,
-0.095660992,
0.6350311637,
0.7287957668,
-0.5551210642,
0.390034914,
0.0942076221,
-0.099625349,
0.0340918228,
-0.5540292859,
-0.1164157391,
-0.4408485293,
0.3202641904,
-0.226736322,
-0.322960943,
0.6422122121,
-0.0710950494,
0.0705164745,
0.3064514399,
0.4772595465,
-0.113107264,
0.8839684129,
0.6918064356,
0.0371658206,
0.7464321256,
-0.3796719909,
0.1556103677,
-0.3083845377,
0.1617391109,
-0.7154666781,
0.0676109791,
-0.5177941918,
-0.208032757,
0.6533570886,
0.219828099,
-0.332591027,
0.3085795641,
-0.9024463296,
0.5587595701,
0.4370083213,
-0.1605222225,
0.2530180216,
-0.0257928446,
0.2931522429,
0.0309860632,
-0.6734742522,
-0.7906880379,
0.9468077421,
0.262159586,
0.8313056231,
0.201160416,
0.8244257569,
0.5324093699,
0.7822500467,
-0.3964743018,
0.2205409259,
0.0247389246,
-0.4606924355,
-0.2345790118,
-0.1616259366,
-0.7919535637,
-0.105433844,
0.2244866043,
-0.5026946664,
-0.1438248158,
0.5124288201,
0.0101582147,
-0.1402629018,
-1.4550477266,
0.9297409058,
-0.2200441509,
0.1384588331,
0.0617351457,
-0.3736472726,
0.3163078725,
0.0147243235,
0.2050042301,
0.0602174588,
0.2367044091,
0.5767300725,
-0.4620650709,
0.7326511741,
-0.3030132949,
0.0496769957,
0.6985152364,
0.3733899295,
0.8904628754,
0.2775326669,
-0.0922520757,
-0.2324208766,
-0.2090515047,
-0.1335151941,
-0.6201256514,
0.3632608056,
-0.6191485524,
-0.6865634918,
-0.2261737436,
-0.5001286864,
0.2619003952,
0.2080394477,
0.3642293811,
0.4645732939,
-0.2723404169,
-0.0846045688,
0.2523215413,
0.0117228851,
0.0764868632,
0.9710045457,
-0.3139775991,
-0.351710856,
0.8108731508,
0.4423888922,
0.1867763996,
-0.0017797983,
0.238016367,
0.171906665,
-0.5592334867,
-0.6015113592,
-0.0134761035,
-0.7150755525,
-0.6966921091,
-0.5060162544,
-0.3992549777,
-0.3655411601,
-0.3033894002,
-0.390852809,
-0.410138458,
-0.0908985808,
-0.0692653954,
0.9342423677,
1.1047439575,
-0.0168790054,
0.270763576,
-0.9324909449,
0.3983086646,
0.0461445898,
0.2221626043,
-0.1306757927,
-0.3860454559,
-0.5378476977,
0.143743813,
-0.6219574809,
-1.0657514334,
0.5412150025,
-0.2349627465,
0.2039114982,
-0.0875456333,
0.1691698134,
0.6096791029,
-0.4728466272,
0.4880468547,
0.1405448169,
-1.0379273891,
0.988558352,
-0.8307788372,
0.4214753211,
0.4207985699,
-0.1001576856,
-0.4093317986,
-1.1836340427,
-0.8097653389,
-0.8348833919,
0.6870061159,
0.303548038,
-0.0203051083,
-0.1360121518,
0.1718131304,
0.0791537538,
0.1146141067,
-0.6963682771,
-0.0236665942,
-0.3105516434,
-0.2422249168,
0.4719352126,
-0.2740799189,
-0.2388027608,
-0.0326165967,
0.4099882245,
-0.1905977726,
0.4505679607,
0.0771187022,
-0.2944473922,
-0.468968004,
0.3843486607,
0.763119638,
0.9208381772,
-0.2634035647,
-0.1878602356,
-0.2441753447,
-0.5155677795,
0.0527155101,
0.2022448033,
-0.1210351437,
0.2692877054,
0.3455373049,
0.5010365248,
-0.0673796758,
-0.4324102402,
0.5913438201,
-0.2167682201,
-0.1050534248,
-0.5850455165,
0.1338277608,
0.3363672197,
0.2306076586,
0.4170404375,
-0.1670507342,
0.1220155209,
-0.1966970116,
0.1936557144,
0.1352971196,
-0.1429227144,
-0.4197885692,
0.5088295937,
0.3974933326,
-0.6666715145,
0.7000389695,
-0.3572593629,
-0.3184424937,
1.0038187504,
0.4339478314,
0.9311623573,
-0.3236462772,
0.3949382007,
0.0912446678,
0.3599260151,
0.1572070271,
0.3313269615,
0.4112392962,
-0.1660808176,
-0.0724727884,
-0.0578205436,
-0.4629512727,
0.1295261532,
-0.7754134536,
0.5846141577,
-0.1183814034,
-0.0886819437,
0.0538612045,
-0.0777598098,
-0.6404237747,
-0.0646825582,
-0.1853684485,
0.8125399351,
-0.7745826244,
0.8618202209,
0.9579124451,
-0.6904059649,
-1.0853736401,
-0.0100828009,
-0.0923452079,
-0.2764498889,
0.6449492574,
-0.0340782553,
0.0843604207,
-0.1248607337,
-0.6515371203,
-0.6308901906,
1.2431558371,
0.7084376812,
-0.4680320024,
-0.1131054014,
0.0648818314,
0.5804270506,
-0.7061449289,
0.4884756505,
0.2468017191,
0.5071691275,
-0.2355598956,
-0.868614614,
-0.2690567374,
-0.5656331182,
0.0466886833,
0.467161268,
-0.4414569736,
0.8223248124,
-0.278154552,
0.003275774,
-0.0251015071,
0.5284362435,
0.372205168,
0.2840692401,
0.4710389078,
0.0181189757,
0.657500267,
0.1591993868,
1.1380088329,
-0.5774737597,
0.4533838332,
1.2260932922,
-0.1257451624,
0.4078710377,
0.3167453706,
0.2651806772,
0.6520150304,
0.3319281638,
-0.149529621,
0.4839492142,
0.1474844813,
0.3370928168,
0.1193264276,
-0.0429075994,
-0.576895535,
0.4142092168,
0.3236359358,
-0.5401834249,
-0.2035079002,
-0.0565262884,
0.0647831485,
0.0038936203,
0.078787908,
0.7756462693,
-0.1057300642,
-0.6242999434,
0.4929378331,
0.109983027,
0.0291851908,
-0.7454295158,
-0.2697219253,
-0.4762575924,
0.0042536552,
0.1079714447,
-0.6090371609,
0.3601096272,
0.5546175241,
-0.4092006981,
-0.0592194758,
0.6172271371,
-0.321344465,
-0.6149922013,
0.1967778057,
0.6752006412,
-0.0783980563,
0.3562482595,
-0.6490860581,
-0.2020219862,
-0.0100349784,
-0.6417734027,
0.3191680312,
0.7535446882,
-0.273149699,
0.6591871381,
0.0921626687,
-0.0185061488,
-0.0577596128,
0.0325867683,
0.9707075357,
-0.5907794833,
-0.6971837878,
-0.5626396537,
1.0220985413,
0.0465385616,
-0.3027621806,
0.4582733214,
0.5177012682,
0.3825951517,
-0.2562339604,
0.9418590665,
-0.3322596848,
0.668415606,
-0.3751000464,
0.7018002272,
-0.4477257133,
0.4504583478,
-0.427906692,
-0.5460856557,
-0.1915996969,
0.2456856817,
-0.3522519469,
0.055348929,
0.5624105334,
0.9347832799,
-0.2990233302,
-0.0294097587,
-0.0657275394,
-0.059392672,
0.4910622835,
0.2352810055,
0.7873157263,
-0.421186626,
0.8204566836,
-0.0985669568,
0.0573494285,
-0.3713459074,
-0.8775747418,
-0.7027733326,
-0.686450839,
-0.5013967156,
-0.3554215133,
0.4195269048,
0.798353076,
0.655665338,
-0.8059362173,
-0.3532564938,
-0.314563185,
0.1481536776,
0.1754177958,
-0.3214639127,
0.2891819477,
-0.2415749282,
-0.4680336416,
-0.0243629869,
0.1574679017,
0.3037365973,
-0.1762394607,
-0.0691904128,
-0.1295015812,
-0.1980943084,
0.0838882476,
0.2079901993,
-0.4725090265,
-0.4535353184,
0.1183522791,
-0.6385660768,
0.3622852564,
1.0682212114,
-0.4871055186,
0.3348715901,
0.4253822267,
0.1583929956,
0.0943980813,
0.0352145694,
1.0740251541,
-0.6397224665,
0.1145280823,
0.2340973616,
0.2202503532,
0.3428862095,
-0.5213785172,
0.9557117224,
-0.2602040768,
-0.5243460536,
-1.0228366852,
0.0775645226,
-0.3705937564,
-0.2104011625,
0.9546404481,
-0.1951614469,
0.0441664048,
-0.0093471128,
-0.0934053734,
0.4456981122,
-0.6823227406,
0.9575615525,
0.4539210796,
0.0226485431,
-0.4207316041,
-0.5804544091,
0.1967911571,
0.0836118087,
-0.9560357332,
0.2324056178,
0.4810568094,
0.3728634119,
0.2758834958,
0.7451407313,
0.0547976345,
0.5795798898,
0.0931888819,
0.3816772699,
-0.1577661037,
-0.433419615,
-0.0689578876,
0.1974610984,
0.4070335031,
-0.0254344828
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03396v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03396v1
|
UniTSyn: A Large-Scale Dataset Capable of Enhancing the Prowess of Large Language Models for Program Testing
| 2024-02-04T22:48:05 | 2024-02-04T22:48:05 |
Yifeng He, Jiabo Huang, Yuyang Rong, Yiwen Guo, Ethan Wang, Hao Chen
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
The remarkable capability of large language models (LLMs) in generating
high-quality code has drawn increasing attention in the software testing
community. However, existing code LLMs often demonstrate unsatisfactory
capabilities in generating accurate and complete tests since they were trained
on code snippets collected without differentiating between code for testing
purposes and other code. In this paper, we present a large-scale dataset
UniTSyn, which is capable of enhancing the prowess of LLMs for Unit Test
Synthesis. Associating tests with the tested functions is crucial for LLMs to
infer the expected behavior and the logic paths to be verified. By leveraging
Language Server Protocol, UniTSyn achieves the challenging goal of collecting
focal-test pairs without per-project execution setups or per-language
heuristics that tend to be fragile and difficult to scale. It contains 2.7
million focal-test pairs across five mainstream programming languages, making
it possible to be utilized for enhancing the test generation ability of LLMs.
The details of UniTSyn can be found in Table 1. Our experiments demonstrate
that, by building an autoregressive model based on UniTSyn, we can achieve
significant benefits in learning and understanding unit test representations,
resulting in improved generation accuracy and code coverage across all
evaluated programming languages. Code and data will be publicly available.
|
[
-0.2898898125,
-0.4459768534,
0.3822016716,
0.2049898505,
0.1604496837,
0.0626761168,
-0.2894439995,
-0.0086351829,
0.2094087005,
0.5156126618,
-0.3137047291,
-0.3197034597,
0.0271028168,
-0.0468156859,
-0.4895512164,
0.8457433581,
-0.1803537756,
-0.0127678979,
-0.3399875462,
0.0256793834,
-0.1417163312,
-0.4148868024,
-0.0608126149,
-0.1510096937,
0.3120064735,
0.7574167848,
0.4200771153,
0.4509150684,
0.5464151502,
0.2557209432,
0.4851153493,
0.0985869691,
-0.4936033785,
0.5834277868,
0.0302060787,
-0.3215883076,
-0.5492595434,
-0.0666623712,
0.9621533155,
0.8049889207,
-0.097353667,
0.5614119172,
-0.0832120776,
0.5117277503,
-0.4043380022,
0.0837704167,
-0.8638677001,
-0.0366352722,
-0.0437862612,
-0.0260589197,
-0.6084671021,
-0.2340735197,
-0.4748903215,
-0.3213384748,
0.2020534277,
-0.0251129884,
0.7948260307,
0.1312299073,
-0.3881430626,
-0.0252820533,
-0.4663462937,
0.6746583581,
-0.6019067168,
0.721714139,
0.1961921155,
0.2657041848,
-0.2100056708,
-0.4962265491,
-0.3642288744,
-0.5155164599,
0.1424940526,
-0.1629382819,
0.2149684131,
-0.0183007158,
0.6058118939,
0.2217317075,
-0.7427116036,
0.0279725827,
-0.2050792128,
-0.1235671043,
0.9931604266,
0.2042447478,
0.2404403985,
-0.3625027537,
-0.2824201882,
0.0435183197,
-1.0251891613,
-0.052291207,
0.1277795583,
0.3309682012,
0.1969539076,
0.6597524285,
-0.4089329243,
0.5813630819,
-0.481157124,
-0.2623298168,
0.1715153754,
-0.1087667346,
-0.5748067498,
-0.2287943959,
0.7230255604,
0.3243408501,
-0.0093600219,
-0.1576308608,
-0.3232331276,
0.2558408678,
0.1926322877,
-1.2151377201,
-0.4991547167,
0.1502912492,
-0.2600246072,
-0.5127453208,
-0.087575838,
-0.6515796781,
-0.1988289207,
-0.5397958159,
0.1424950808,
-0.3554420173,
-0.3254128397,
-0.1331252009,
0.3468885124,
0.0400458612,
-0.0758465305,
-0.7665547729,
0.2172448486,
0.6834442616,
0.4217756391,
-0.188698709,
-0.5877907276,
-0.6933761239,
-0.1964598745,
-0.7117815018,
0.2450254858,
-0.1873864681,
-0.3313068449,
-0.3690251708,
0.1350673139,
0.0274962764,
-0.2571676672,
-0.3129597902,
-0.5112361908,
-0.3775900304,
-0.2568969131,
-0.750221312,
0.5108703375,
0.2317146808,
-0.1591726393,
1.1835542917,
0.2382318228,
-0.2597502768,
0.0292219054,
-0.344592452,
-0.4029246271,
0.3867929578,
-0.7596225142,
-0.3597402275,
0.1168274581,
-0.1941991597,
0.5852623582,
-0.329616189,
0.4744002223,
-0.3028398156,
-0.2854849696,
0.4872522354,
-0.3241652548,
0.5150879622,
0.2421967685,
-0.431581229,
-0.0314513072,
-0.7932426929,
0.4043152034,
0.1018212065,
-0.236929521,
-0.2425399125,
-0.2204911113,
-0.0825573802,
-0.015864769,
-0.0000042749,
-0.5634944439,
0.4412203431,
-0.0231949259,
0.3695179224,
0.6839113235,
-0.1059226319,
0.4732799232,
0.0011211922,
0.6457656026,
-0.504199028,
0.3545091748,
-0.3526007831,
-0.4287737012,
-0.8078962564,
-0.1396426857,
0.2315987796,
0.2073392719,
-0.620616138,
0.4469686747,
-0.3285053372,
-0.6268785,
-0.3506120741,
0.3254063427,
0.5172798038,
0.4848769307,
-0.0388023928,
-0.2393400669,
-0.6584972143,
-0.60068959,
0.2717583477,
-0.4145633578,
-0.0980853885,
0.2643430531,
0.5931474566,
-0.3073455393,
0.692404449,
-0.7192441225,
0.1871105134,
-0.1901523024,
-0.228505522,
0.0513698086,
0.455275178,
0.221468851,
-0.3751598895,
-0.3333807886,
-0.0968567804,
-0.5804635286,
-0.3318392038,
-0.1386269033,
-0.300413698,
0.3189930022,
0.8343026042,
-0.3545311987,
0.0814345479,
0.8430435061,
-0.4567509294,
0.7976948023,
-0.1297478676,
0.1215954125,
-1.056016326,
0.1824958622,
-0.5068241358,
-0.3222759366,
-0.3747776151,
0.6067967415,
0.4935796857,
-0.4492589533,
-0.0882310569,
0.2822552025,
-0.3984949887,
-0.5066487789,
-0.1744562685,
-0.1341079324,
0.2948321104,
0.0488998592,
-0.167773813,
0.9400244951,
0.4438835382,
-0.3715631068,
0.3334207237,
-0.0086067999,
-0.2422624379,
0.4153454304,
-0.503056407,
0.0153841227,
0.1410741508,
0.0011433741,
-1.0349647999,
-0.4554559588,
-0.4511585534,
-0.4188589156,
0.1150679067,
-0.2708727121,
-0.3152903616,
-0.4052726626,
-0.0814575255,
0.2761035264,
0.7021850348,
-0.6038079858,
0.288636148,
0.3542759717,
-0.1226269305,
-0.3765556514,
-0.7438415289,
-0.0138687715,
0.0337212533,
-0.4387386143,
-0.0533614345,
-0.2358057648,
-0.3539094627,
-0.2738978267,
0.0645910278,
0.0908163711,
0.27644822,
0.7931536436,
0.6366245151,
-0.30895558,
0.5796972513,
-0.3337821662,
-0.1307366341,
0.0944893882,
-0.267896533,
0.7225458622,
-0.3014974296,
-0.8211849928,
-0.1436242312,
0.3777525425,
0.7584926486,
-0.1702024937,
0.1394399703,
0.2926891148,
-0.1942262352,
-0.5601429343,
-0.5029705167,
-0.2667188942,
-0.4681667387,
0.426700145,
-0.6236937046,
-0.7738403678,
0.2129442543,
0.0176590271,
-0.0087464061,
0.1614037007,
0.1927076727,
0.0906511024,
0.8272923827,
0.3106168807,
-0.5534641147,
0.179557234,
-0.3207529783,
0.1391477287,
-0.7933462858,
0.1015144959,
-0.3697341681,
0.152180329,
-0.4221247435,
-0.5452538133,
0.2762648463,
0.0948702618,
-0.7132949829,
0.4448195696,
-0.5871651769,
0.6825406551,
0.3828462958,
-0.0006713119,
0.3638743758,
0.1260041893,
-0.0731845647,
-0.1676837355,
-0.436959058,
-0.1785434335,
1.4274570942,
0.4017031193,
0.7982234955,
0.1597411931,
0.793048799,
0.1879002005,
0.5630919933,
-0.7865899801,
0.735745728,
-0.0090005696,
-0.1671875119,
-0.4238314629,
-0.7953728437,
-0.6130485535,
-0.045189362,
0.2329958826,
-0.4200915992,
-0.2106542736,
-0.0891305804,
-0.5398594737,
0.2103142738,
-0.5957092643,
0.6593127847,
-0.294213891,
-0.2064832151,
0.1673143506,
-0.1910286099,
0.4053382874,
0.0119159641,
0.1049586833,
-0.2150355428,
0.18874906,
0.4985112548,
-0.5886978507,
0.5634628534,
-0.0405047238,
-0.1225611717,
0.0566210561,
0.6588032842,
0.5120218396,
0.4589627087,
-0.1088863164,
-0.2292815894,
-0.1787968874,
-0.4487085044,
-0.2825078368,
1.0761662722,
-0.7049385905,
-0.3338659108,
-0.1821606159,
-0.9546638727,
-0.2080605924,
0.208085075,
-0.1521063894,
0.7192454934,
-0.1930922717,
-0.0453864858,
0.6298010349,
-0.0365005247,
0.477404803,
0.6778154373,
-0.8430418968,
-0.3211468458,
0.9281375408,
-0.1356505007,
0.6805934906,
-0.2456730604,
-0.0967218205,
-0.0171034914,
-0.4557923079,
-0.5324991345,
0.2233989835,
-0.6221360564,
-0.6149706244,
-0.3239074349,
-0.30737257,
-0.6577062011,
-0.2954884768,
-0.6869564056,
-0.3567889035,
0.1443583369,
-0.0673157424,
0.5535049438,
0.7838372588,
0.0023298378,
0.0595911965,
-0.4563332498,
0.2498544157,
0.5620993376,
0.1969165355,
-0.1823776662,
-0.3001775742,
0.095099777,
-0.1329577714,
-0.0404822193,
-0.5894491673,
0.5433639288,
0.0580955483,
0.0568409041,
0.2194286734,
-0.0862455592,
0.8199681044,
-0.4855539501,
0.8289747238,
0.1763411164,
-1.0255345106,
0.6161978245,
-0.2635009289,
0.1565001607,
0.738996923,
0.2119223922,
-0.6318154335,
-0.1478428692,
-0.6276541352,
-0.6795719862,
0.3734058142,
0.1362545788,
-0.1160098165,
0.1232668236,
0.4541029036,
-0.174776867,
0.1639410257,
-0.3666013777,
-0.1020495221,
0.1017140448,
-0.1185919046,
-0.2403639704,
-0.1314415336,
-0.2691131532,
-0.4042509794,
0.7499857545,
-0.3968364,
0.133924067,
0.320129782,
-0.1936509907,
-0.1455269009,
0.1100572199,
0.2152533084,
0.5618857145,
-0.2425729334,
0.4068420529,
0.1680539548,
-0.5763859153,
0.292832315,
0.2814647555,
-0.3754262626,
0.0165674631,
0.2104935646,
0.4571860135,
0.0062742629,
-0.8241990805,
0.4218608737,
-0.07217253,
-0.1446408182,
-0.3939792812,
0.0501609817,
0.230083093,
0.2524077594,
0.2527679205,
-0.0536787361,
0.0037698366,
-0.6009854078,
0.6672732234,
0.2507680058,
-0.2949976623,
-0.2246251255,
0.3813191056,
0.1315102279,
-0.2240115255,
0.7787861228,
-0.6400619149,
-0.5006064177,
0.9011999369,
0.5831179619,
0.3006193936,
-0.5736210942,
0.4019471705,
0.3231179714,
0.1326310188,
-0.1401674896,
0.5857511759,
0.0111641446,
-0.6601110697,
-0.3697239459,
-0.7074838877,
-0.4118126929,
0.306991607,
-0.5145280361,
0.0456207246,
-0.3422094285,
0.1983316839,
-0.191322118,
0.2285075486,
-0.5082917213,
0.063452594,
0.3799944222,
0.8349837661,
-0.9707623124,
1.1438229084,
0.4542221725,
-0.4018652141,
-1.1046518087,
-0.1913157851,
-0.1639745682,
-0.719753027,
0.6029294133,
0.2036580592,
0.3054871559,
0.030550899,
-0.1813773811,
-0.9985039234,
1.3094079494,
0.2909632921,
-0.9529041052,
0.2199336737,
0.5922446251,
0.4018168151,
-0.6630997658,
0.4273627698,
0.5907464623,
0.0702186823,
-0.0409814492,
-0.7925014496,
0.4327211976,
-0.1355508566,
0.4009715319,
0.3172597587,
-0.5394830704,
1.1376223564,
-0.2007193267,
0.202919662,
0.2896051109,
0.4027518928,
0.6850204468,
0.0835193098,
0.5526704192,
0.3979744911,
0.9271581769,
0.0235473253,
0.8935344815,
-0.3824842572,
0.4938421249,
1.3544348478,
-0.7730587721,
1.1239020824,
0.5263713598,
-0.2929282188,
0.3527668417,
0.3126293123,
-0.0424879715,
0.1230400279,
0.5237757564,
-0.3343699276,
-0.4841503501,
-0.18925789,
-0.3476283252,
0.2421582341,
0.2900061309,
-0.6315125227,
-0.0983919725,
-0.0821341053,
0.0118359169,
0.0693066046,
-0.1562115997,
0.1890979409,
0.0271047093,
-0.7456403971,
0.684740603,
-0.4422671497,
0.3064396977,
-0.4935013652,
0.0400488488,
-0.4498510659,
0.4676133394,
-0.1293643564,
-0.6327017546,
0.1498341709,
-0.0920123756,
0.1521244496,
-0.3009499907,
0.7477716804,
-0.4909488857,
-0.5919511914,
0.2976278961,
0.3734516203,
0.3074579835,
-0.1867175251,
-0.5190363526,
0.3607911468,
0.1193086803,
-0.2137973309,
0.3385870457,
0.1613669693,
0.0816179067,
0.4742711782,
0.6871073842,
0.3519303799,
-0.1635417342,
0.4429458678,
0.9264615774,
-0.5232384801,
-0.0533567443,
-0.6762117147,
0.4294736683,
-0.2730434239,
-0.3142960668,
0.9039926529,
0.7424960136,
0.6761978269,
-0.0064473483,
0.8551938534,
-0.1212758943,
0.2153821737,
-0.2434691638,
0.7687624693,
-0.2810140848,
0.3108179867,
0.0726072714,
-0.5856329203,
-0.2571153045,
0.2665036619,
0.0092859156,
-0.4082732201,
0.5463231206,
1.2286336422,
-0.1607844979,
-0.0455559008,
0.5405011773,
0.3362677395,
0.3651361465,
0.6409937143,
0.7389422059,
-0.867731452,
0.4116998613,
-0.3211191297,
-0.3635896146,
-0.158627823,
-0.5811175704,
-0.8881153464,
-0.6000629663,
-0.2098600864,
-0.6738219857,
0.0449729748,
0.9872567654,
0.8288059831,
-0.8408446908,
-0.4574312568,
-0.5052738786,
-0.0893531367,
0.0704878643,
-0.2369215041,
0.2297016382,
-0.6468521953,
-0.2796078324,
0.6299749613,
-0.001902495,
-0.0471396931,
-0.6864646673,
-0.3018137813,
0.1043831035,
-0.1912931949,
0.6527152658,
0.1448542625,
-0.2805708945,
-0.1545160562,
0.3570440114,
-0.2505764961,
-0.2313936502,
0.7048729658,
-0.49892658,
0.325819999,
0.6195524931,
0.554127872,
0.2452453971,
-0.239280358,
0.6230711341,
-0.8514524102,
0.1295376867,
0.0210871883,
0.5779441595,
0.3170785606,
-0.4231604934,
0.723963201,
0.2115359753,
-0.9259596467,
-1.1231883764,
0.4385209978,
-0.6904462576,
-0.1866066456,
1.6591495275,
-0.3629921675,
-0.2828659117,
0.123832494,
0.0459908694,
0.1060282066,
-0.2462972999,
0.7798273563,
0.239773199,
-0.1136407331,
0.2177250385,
-0.5203235745,
0.6116970778,
0.4763014913,
-1.1060048342,
0.4076901674,
0.456412524,
0.598765552,
0.2677232921,
0.6358995438,
-0.0153139951,
0.2637385726,
0.1195924804,
0.4785003066,
-0.0448800735,
-0.4367403686,
-0.2267893553,
0.0504585952,
0.263192147,
-0.1708826274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02625v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02625v1
|
Enhancing Transformer RNNs with Multiple Temporal Perspectives
| 2024-02-04T22:12:29 | 2024-02-04T22:12:29 |
Razvan-Gabriel Dumitru, Darius Peteleaza, Mihai Surdeanu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.0; I.2.7
|
We introduce the concept of multiple temporal perspectives, a novel approach
applicable to Recurrent Neural Network (RNN) architectures for enhancing their
understanding of sequential data. This method involves maintaining diverse
temporal views of previously encountered text, significantly enriching the
language models' capacity to interpret context. To show the efficacy of this
approach, we incorporate it into the Receptance Weighted Key Value (RWKV)
architecture, addressing its inherent challenge of retaining all historical
information within a single hidden state. Notably, this improvement is achieved
with a minimal increase in the number of parameters --even as little as
$0.04\%$ of the original number of parameters. Further, the additional
parameters necessary for the multiple temporal perspectives are fine-tuned with
minimal computational overhead, avoiding the need for a full pre-training. The
resulting model maintains linear computational complexity during prompt
inference, ensuring consistent efficiency across various sequence lengths. The
empirical results and ablation studies included in our research validate the
effectiveness of our approach, showcasing improved performance across multiple
benchmarks. The code, model weights and datasets are open-sourced at:
https://github.com/RazvanDu/TemporalRNNs.
|
[
-0.2044490278,
-0.402336508,
0.452198267,
0.5613206625,
-0.339910239,
0.1499434859,
-0.0463167541,
-0.2781639993,
-0.0799193159,
0.3312179148,
-0.7399161458,
-0.3093641102,
-0.5591233373,
0.0457891002,
-0.3118353784,
0.9574824572,
0.2236419022,
-0.0422704741,
0.2376171201,
-0.4420045316,
-0.4510734379,
-0.1861466467,
-0.717504859,
-0.8350771666,
1.0540192127,
0.2938313782,
0.5537346601,
0.5977219939,
0.3667426705,
0.2419034094,
-0.1778384596,
0.04207775,
-0.2696120739,
0.5062811375,
-0.0291158631,
-0.2848787308,
-0.2518805861,
-0.262454927,
0.9897037148,
0.6283218265,
-0.5111087561,
0.2120703161,
0.0107609415,
0.8469064832,
-0.5425825119,
0.0797218457,
-0.5172032118,
0.5570651293,
-0.1599322855,
-0.4170542657,
-0.7248803377,
-0.2357060462,
0.5058054924,
-0.547845006,
0.4261918664,
-0.1591705084,
0.6883978844,
0.4965831637,
-0.6136419773,
0.5251650214,
-0.9819535017,
0.7947387695,
-0.7329798341,
0.7377890348,
-0.4303539693,
0.3159169853,
-0.0075336741,
-1.0178531408,
-0.5053184628,
-0.0101425322,
-0.2518694699,
0.3709883988,
-0.0680806711,
-0.1709488779,
0.5440197587,
0.3366464972,
-0.6744075418,
-0.1534872651,
-0.2942318916,
-0.1485759318,
0.1391455829,
0.3807397485,
-0.2224797457,
-0.3692685962,
-0.4840031266,
-0.2523210347,
-0.2832226455,
0.0015656023,
0.2949001491,
0.2749177217,
-0.1993669569,
0.3272003829,
-0.2687701583,
0.780800283,
0.057803981,
0.064084664,
0.557518363,
-0.4719272554,
-0.2073964775,
-0.086357154,
0.605086863,
0.0338938907,
-0.0887480378,
-0.1183902174,
0.288330555,
-0.2619005442,
0.9513515234,
-0.852409482,
-0.2000515759,
0.1764717549,
-0.7411692739,
-0.5892444849,
0.2111237496,
-0.9006812572,
-0.4148687422,
-0.3400470018,
0.1491196603,
-0.5151741505,
-0.4345508218,
-0.0272683222,
-0.5183975697,
0.5345615745,
0.3638076484,
-0.6676186323,
-0.0408127718,
0.7344790697,
0.9879146218,
-0.0650110096,
-0.4362259805,
-0.1303005666,
0.099183999,
-0.096081242,
0.6911186576,
-0.5479810834,
-0.2854517996,
-0.336181879,
-0.0194202587,
0.0693820566,
-0.0959637091,
0.3145731091,
-0.8530794978,
0.3394339979,
0.0707797706,
0.0237450991,
-0.2842717469,
0.2021998316,
-0.92749089,
1.1043527126,
0.1393173188,
-0.7071020007,
0.4412011802,
-0.4805150628,
-0.6663349271,
-0.1150194034,
-0.2728952765,
-0.6215038896,
0.4267076552,
0.4038342535,
0.146522373,
-0.0094243949,
0.2848213613,
-0.0003407591,
0.0412410237,
0.3481737375,
-0.934081912,
0.3635137379,
0.3432026207,
-0.1710016131,
0.3914141357,
-0.9987229109,
0.0787046254,
-0.0516317114,
-0.4706219733,
-0.1270128638,
-0.0187043585,
0.0115329735,
0.3210984766,
0.1173053905,
-0.5748283863,
0.2920297682,
-0.6109431386,
0.5791468024,
0.8150873184,
0.3448463678,
0.535576582,
-0.3860854208,
0.4908872545,
0.3203257322,
0.4028016925,
-0.6256116629,
-0.5395665169,
-0.5770419836,
0.1393087655,
0.0916584432,
0.5813161135,
-0.7335717082,
0.0828939304,
-0.6814461946,
-0.3864815533,
-0.3777677119,
-0.415850848,
0.2190279514,
0.9841043949,
0.4850181043,
-0.2822271585,
-0.7763112783,
-1.0454795361,
-0.4045639336,
0.0158121306,
-0.2084124684,
0.3107717037,
0.2458397299,
0.107012257,
0.9306173921,
-0.3686443269,
-0.1071016341,
-0.1428229809,
0.4036799073,
0.6607221365,
0.4600332081,
0.0317546651,
-0.9859957695,
-0.211315915,
0.1598066688,
-0.6710041165,
0.2496798933,
-0.5507318377,
0.1059814394,
0.1209369898,
0.2240212411,
-0.2483227551,
0.6062567234,
0.4174538553,
-0.2580139041,
0.2826900184,
-0.1102631688,
0.3028730154,
-1.1369882822,
0.1320538372,
-0.10847608,
-0.2557011545,
-0.7643648982,
-0.1582568884,
0.170613274,
-0.1104558855,
-0.5749612451,
0.5241245627,
-0.2224820554,
0.0004778217,
-0.2190834284,
-0.1622144282,
0.3179348409,
0.7338225842,
0.2630080283,
0.6136120558,
0.0218421333,
-0.2384897172,
0.2394250631,
0.3077334762,
-0.2170141786,
0.3139771521,
-0.8246174455,
0.2112862766,
-0.4340090752,
0.5488490462,
-0.7625594735,
0.1149858385,
0.411668539,
-0.7439044118,
0.3677431047,
-0.4313072562,
-0.0663703829,
-0.2078474611,
-0.0763346031,
0.7078378201,
0.2670060098,
-0.4719825387,
1.3205850124,
-0.1849258095,
-0.0444895811,
-1.1190518141,
-0.9354688525,
0.1122532412,
-0.1807574332,
-0.5947158933,
0.6010304689,
0.3283366859,
0.0721916333,
0.0487036221,
-0.4110040069,
0.1581192315,
-0.2046369612,
0.2834460139,
0.2674235106,
-0.2612839937,
0.222850576,
-0.0893851817,
-0.5198201537,
-0.0700649917,
-0.9015997052,
0.5243344903,
-0.1062654704,
-0.1449664533,
-0.523252964,
0.5588455796,
0.4856497347,
-0.3616709113,
1.0714498758,
0.85250175,
-0.3591610491,
-0.227289632,
-0.6332450509,
-0.1922354251,
-0.433521688,
0.3770736754,
-0.3622384369,
-0.8494595289,
0.6699262857,
0.0987557694,
0.2270347476,
0.4178694785,
0.553963244,
0.0878469571,
0.6923829317,
0.4724104106,
-0.0415143371,
0.9245901108,
-0.182790786,
0.2149555236,
-1.0498547554,
-0.591591537,
-0.3140283823,
-0.4803086519,
-0.456898421,
-0.3876904547,
0.5025442243,
-0.3186063766,
-0.6288192272,
0.1432788372,
-0.6057425737,
0.1675987393,
0.4587571621,
0.4934563339,
0.3826705515,
-0.0090013687,
-0.1787021458,
-0.11289417,
-0.9262077808,
-0.1051165983,
1.1986806393,
0.61613518,
0.6822518706,
0.0859571099,
0.594717741,
0.1407088637,
0.2850250304,
-0.8064482212,
0.0947541893,
-0.0573507063,
-0.370619297,
-0.4994112253,
-0.6491115689,
-0.7955969572,
0.6034944057,
-0.193413347,
-0.378157258,
0.3828406334,
0.0906465054,
-0.791282177,
0.234973833,
-0.3752119243,
0.8750687242,
-0.0792502984,
-0.5085902214,
-0.3964386582,
-1.0330598354,
0.0647165626,
0.2320366651,
-0.0482683145,
0.1665091366,
-0.2136769593,
0.5259897709,
-0.3642780483,
0.8061829805,
-0.1903332174,
0.0803141147,
-0.0623523518,
-0.1940232366,
0.4929541647,
0.4197300971,
-0.0161345024,
0.3349785805,
-0.1946433038,
-0.3467543125,
-0.9567899704,
0.4968671799,
-0.6854023933,
-0.326906532,
-0.6171720028,
-0.7111373544,
-0.0618063658,
0.3265833259,
0.118649967,
0.928394556,
0.0172573123,
0.446932286,
0.9000096321,
-0.3619576991,
0.3944489658,
0.4811166227,
0.0658408627,
-0.7400929332,
0.2570776939,
-0.3391298056,
0.4028588533,
0.8115349412,
0.3709644675,
-0.2647120655,
-0.6269050837,
-0.213326782,
0.081787616,
-0.7118235826,
-0.210142225,
-0.7863408327,
-0.4362305999,
-0.5546575785,
0.3271365762,
-0.5227505565,
-0.6505758762,
-0.0665834695,
-0.0732242763,
0.5544521213,
0.5647438765,
0.0072014933,
0.591689527,
-1.0272876024,
0.6776589155,
0.1209798604,
0.4609102011,
0.4174711108,
-0.7382569313,
-0.259074837,
-0.1541811526,
-0.2288803905,
-0.6542835236,
0.2695385814,
0.1307597756,
0.6566963792,
0.1526065916,
-0.2744452357,
0.8036799431,
-1.0011328459,
0.7474768162,
0.0513593331,
-0.6830651164,
0.5622304678,
-0.2643868923,
0.7907760143,
0.3323847055,
0.09247493,
-0.9602452517,
-0.2855390608,
-0.5193121433,
-1.0438876152,
0.6708723307,
0.1280131042,
0.0219599679,
0.1737018675,
0.6176531911,
0.1459895074,
0.1176669896,
-0.7040747404,
-0.5934307575,
-0.6828674078,
-0.1598781943,
0.165713653,
-0.1387052089,
-0.1297749281,
-0.1014308408,
0.436180532,
-0.0345293097,
0.2888330221,
0.4153374135,
0.001455271,
0.1901703328,
0.4632029831,
0.8179363012,
0.7791486979,
-0.031890016,
-0.0993353128,
0.2974906862,
-0.7549154758,
0.0303143226,
0.1361004412,
-0.0220791269,
-0.1083038002,
0.5658749938,
0.9035980701,
0.4359800518,
0.1118947938,
0.2187485397,
-0.341271311,
0.0057275016,
-0.6732417345,
-0.2482390404,
-0.1302330792,
0.597058475,
0.6288096309,
0.5755531192,
-0.2021368742,
-0.1681244522,
0.4963393807,
0.0405635834,
-0.2852784991,
-0.0982007012,
0.6469022036,
0.1133458763,
-0.2522347271,
0.9755578041,
0.3532845974,
-0.4847948849,
0.5268030763,
0.289014101,
0.9946326017,
-0.3272473514,
0.009026682,
0.4881277084,
0.3698016405,
-0.0330470502,
0.2606943548,
-0.2365780771,
-0.9699606895,
-0.6600005627,
-0.5085430741,
-0.1309711784,
-0.0261528343,
-0.9516891241,
0.0862860605,
-0.399949044,
-0.2115759104,
-0.0817586854,
-0.2666088343,
-0.7117376328,
-0.0591257997,
0.0965294465,
1.0568571091,
-0.6419198513,
1.003636837,
0.296662569,
-0.3506466448,
-0.7320851088,
-0.0370281972,
0.1386611015,
-0.7704763412,
0.6430359483,
-0.0093857897,
-0.3211491704,
0.0143889524,
0.0965978578,
-0.8191565871,
1.3526537418,
-0.333863467,
-0.6437180638,
-0.3868193328,
0.1052130908,
0.5347422957,
-0.3178709149,
0.2435389161,
0.6376439333,
0.4920030236,
0.2398112565,
-0.6445430517,
-0.0195635296,
-0.2091995627,
0.3706396818,
0.5333815813,
-0.4297320247,
0.6247739792,
-0.2473610044,
-0.3115975857,
0.1442713439,
0.9391653538,
0.1278730333,
0.1748785675,
0.5185359716,
0.6960065961,
0.3869177401,
-0.1787412316,
1.0065774918,
-0.2515188158,
0.1449685246,
1.3974679708,
-0.002025709,
0.6611863375,
0.80272156,
-0.1410917491,
0.6470146775,
0.3336298764,
-0.0505370535,
0.6361454129,
-0.0056860577,
-0.251693666,
-0.1936306655,
0.030026488,
-0.5135189295,
0.197934404,
0.2684097588,
-0.3830411136,
-0.2319587916,
0.2614558637,
-0.2516208887,
0.0209548008,
-0.0992177948,
0.732971549,
0.2126333863,
-0.5075137019,
0.0568163507,
-0.2644777894,
0.559448719,
-0.892944932,
-0.2119263262,
-0.0926473513,
0.3138454556,
-0.3760176599,
-0.7882971168,
0.5951093435,
-0.3218629658,
-0.5639532804,
-0.7681975961,
0.5064947605,
-0.3682973087,
-0.5022117496,
0.0375754945,
0.4838554263,
-0.4266783595,
0.1184691116,
-0.6230105162,
0.1548423916,
-0.2147403806,
-0.4036503434,
-0.0260265786,
0.4863449931,
0.1988962889,
0.6642588377,
0.4648344815,
0.2787330747,
0.0962004289,
0.7335932851,
0.7433598638,
-0.9428107738,
-0.5358303785,
-0.7950655818,
0.7788169384,
0.0588411652,
-0.3608244658,
0.6558440924,
0.4986713529,
0.8382398486,
0.0199038852,
0.6257249117,
0.0642367527,
0.6915702224,
-0.473549068,
0.6626011729,
-0.350982964,
0.4050459564,
-0.0516556539,
-0.691180408,
-0.4404037297,
0.4905248582,
-0.0810948387,
0.0961272866,
0.8488765359,
0.6445377469,
0.2006282508,
0.3036299646,
-0.0624634288,
0.0172625594,
0.4481455982,
0.6598758698,
1.2010354996,
-0.6281607151,
0.6645072103,
-0.528008461,
-0.2105489373,
0.3456094265,
-1.2314472198,
-0.5606054664,
-0.573700726,
-0.1848912835,
-0.2889822423,
0.0068228501,
0.6652736068,
0.6708490252,
-0.7073992491,
0.0227217972,
0.0238400754,
0.1375750303,
-0.4341613054,
-0.3009681106,
0.0149064464,
-0.4040181339,
-0.3420280814,
0.45431903,
0.3899196088,
-0.2551503778,
-0.2289152294,
0.2582834363,
-0.0430506989,
-0.4299428761,
0.6973693371,
0.1755072027,
-0.778408289,
-0.6298753023,
0.2399815619,
0.1846708953,
0.4440663159,
1.43592906,
-1.2913467884,
0.4455202818,
0.6023473144,
0.6957207322,
0.6967365742,
0.173985824,
0.805392921,
-0.8826979399,
0.3348814249,
0.4852687418,
0.2284928709,
0.1208705381,
-0.4953787327,
0.3282984793,
0.045437593,
-0.5971153378,
-0.4890400469,
0.4992035329,
-0.9601045847,
-0.2601501942,
0.7997538447,
0.0471499339,
0.0459721759,
-0.1936085373,
0.3209017813,
0.481089294,
-0.5016582012,
0.5805826187,
0.5369508266,
-0.3311254084,
-0.4783252776,
-0.7024671435,
0.2089349627,
0.3423223495,
-0.430005312,
0.001565635,
0.3341243863,
0.3101160824,
0.1305985749,
0.3041961193,
-0.4882063866,
0.3159161508,
-0.083089523,
-0.2653039694,
-0.3930408657,
-0.7301788926,
-0.9690641761,
0.1127804741,
-0.2766925991,
-0.1382064223
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.