id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02622v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02622v2
|
DenseFormer: Enhancing Information Flow in Transformers via Depth Weighted Averaging
| 2024-02-04T21:44:09 | 2024-03-21T10:57:40 |
Matteo Pagliardini, Amirkeivan Mohtashami, Francois Fleuret, Martin Jaggi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The transformer architecture by Vaswani et al. (2017) is now ubiquitous
across application domains, from natural language processing to speech
processing and image understanding. We propose DenseFormer, a simple
modification to the standard architecture that improves the perplexity of the
model without increasing its size -- adding a few thousand parameters for
large-scale models in the 100B parameters range. Our approach relies on an
additional averaging step after each transformer block, which computes a
weighted average of current and past representations -- we refer to this
operation as Depth-Weighted-Average (DWA). The learned DWA weights exhibit
coherent patterns of information flow, revealing the strong and structured
reuse of activations from distant layers. Experiments demonstrate that
DenseFormer is more data efficient, reaching the same perplexity of much deeper
transformer models, and that for the same perplexity, these new models
outperform transformer baselines in terms of memory efficiency and inference
time.
|
[
-0.3495807946,
-0.6316201687,
0.5127052665,
0.3347279131,
-0.1598383486,
-0.0670950785,
0.0141411116,
-0.2705093622,
0.1749122143,
0.3951967061,
-0.049216073,
-0.2327991128,
-1.0331039429,
-0.3088856637,
-0.787981987,
0.5343946218,
-0.1490955204,
-0.1302551627,
-0.2480130792,
-0.1738471985,
-0.3813891411,
-0.0759915039,
-0.7381585836,
-0.4767276943,
0.6033466458,
0.4629822373,
1.104773283,
0.5411412716,
0.5900083184,
0.5050127506,
0.0217463616,
-0.2717468441,
-0.6112983227,
0.2874107361,
0.2085703909,
-0.4037736952,
-0.7942255139,
-0.2610997856,
0.8321493864,
1.1195716858,
-0.4550848901,
0.0204321686,
-0.1851148158,
0.9856958985,
-0.6670303941,
0.0342818461,
-0.2819000781,
0.0877750888,
-0.0041292603,
-0.0875472575,
-0.2586047053,
0.0118888495,
0.2277717292,
-0.5988331437,
0.2234236151,
-0.1481111348,
0.3765639663,
0.7587302923,
-0.1013843715,
-0.0585733689,
-0.9919400811,
0.6623607874,
-0.3507766128,
0.7023559213,
-0.1240192205,
0.6458507776,
0.134696126,
-1.0134884119,
-0.6394838691,
0.1613114923,
-0.1296630949,
0.4276459515,
-0.8949674964,
0.0770178288,
0.4879049361,
0.4991253316,
-0.4488104582,
0.034784507,
-0.5649812222,
0.0413599834,
0.7257262468,
0.2127138972,
0.0397311412,
0.1075933203,
-0.1083157584,
-0.4168040454,
-0.052407328,
0.110129185,
0.2418938726,
-0.2930498123,
-0.2882753015,
0.3921898901,
-0.32286641,
0.6751480699,
0.3981426656,
0.0438596942,
0.2393998653,
0.0909513757,
-0.5174790621,
0.2614999413,
0.5490018725,
0.0759042725,
0.0464259721,
-0.3151186407,
-0.35493204,
-0.2800336778,
0.6639067531,
-1.2609341145,
-0.5248811245,
0.4437983632,
-0.6282685399,
-0.2656471431,
0.2655122578,
-0.5868378878,
-0.6259018183,
-0.2324327528,
0.4084329307,
-0.2630296946,
-0.4353741109,
0.5830337405,
-0.4613153338,
0.3566484451,
0.5421892405,
-0.7104407549,
0.6031552553,
0.6249041557,
0.8938082457,
-0.2596232593,
-0.1286201477,
-0.372636497,
0.1798428297,
-0.3629594743,
0.9612224102,
-0.6094142199,
-0.2444871515,
-0.537548542,
-0.3469723165,
0.176679194,
-0.7363880277,
0.4332116246,
-0.7664801478,
0.240166381,
0.0002067546,
-0.290162921,
-0.2385498136,
-0.2141139656,
-1.194425106,
0.9278081059,
0.3795911074,
-0.5298500061,
0.529640615,
-0.7322724462,
-0.3786551952,
0.0739479661,
0.0739262402,
-0.4867825508,
0.4702248275,
0.2568905354,
0.4822639525,
-0.2138653547,
0.2940600812,
-0.0472921841,
-0.8312255144,
0.0439611599,
-0.5252113938,
0.4121346176,
0.2623730004,
-0.3055512607,
0.3429137468,
-0.9705213308,
-0.3575612605,
0.1124181822,
-0.2746590674,
-0.2493587434,
-0.1070332378,
-0.121079959,
-0.04897964,
0.0820894688,
-0.4430734813,
0.171676755,
-0.3398645818,
0.2158496827,
0.5318188071,
-0.2019013762,
1.2041779757,
-0.3054238558,
0.4344885349,
0.440049082,
0.3748423755,
-0.0552411787,
-0.3825313449,
-0.6744146347,
-0.5122503042,
0.1796805859,
0.2859464884,
-0.3228243589,
0.2751239836,
-0.5962933898,
-0.8652046919,
-0.6384489536,
0.2790697515,
-0.2003265023,
0.4695428908,
0.570361793,
-0.3790484667,
-0.57067132,
-0.7809553146,
-0.205998078,
0.1914459318,
-0.4249618351,
0.1731741428,
0.0458970293,
-0.3486611843,
0.6646319032,
-0.6283551455,
-0.0679535642,
-0.2586457729,
0.1603873074,
0.6817184687,
0.4136055112,
0.3531867266,
-0.9759793878,
-0.2898661494,
-0.2677897513,
-0.573007524,
-0.0233172216,
-0.200504452,
-0.2289252579,
-0.3085053265,
0.5334836245,
-0.7799690366,
0.2354877144,
0.6568630338,
-0.3266679049,
0.1686564535,
-0.0757545233,
-0.1070240214,
-0.8709703684,
-0.1610743999,
-0.2015610784,
-0.0013936792,
-0.6765285134,
-0.3499033451,
0.077242218,
-0.1878146976,
-0.1310305297,
0.5021293759,
-0.4510242641,
-0.0539279208,
-0.3336207271,
0.0178119242,
0.1252835542,
0.2405743152,
-0.1230844408,
0.7228892446,
0.8266894817,
-0.5432434678,
0.4506964386,
0.0477418713,
-0.3839952648,
0.5656368136,
-1.0595915318,
0.055463016,
-0.6473479867,
0.4712676406,
-1.0160378218,
-0.1733401716,
-0.1445824057,
-0.1631779522,
0.2882395089,
-0.0064882105,
-0.162504673,
-0.1718844473,
-0.3372582495,
0.6742879748,
0.6419155598,
-0.4630254209,
1.5436102152,
0.2707929611,
0.0476550348,
-0.5048642755,
-0.8933734298,
0.222193107,
-0.0741557255,
-1.0073475838,
0.6589499712,
-0.0139097711,
-0.445699662,
0.0768061206,
-0.4094031453,
-0.2248839736,
0.1428919286,
0.4319864511,
-0.1501605362,
-0.5157533288,
0.0675403178,
0.1967024058,
-0.1621411741,
0.1231073141,
-0.4281401336,
0.4795937836,
0.0208783131,
-0.3032486737,
-0.5112683773,
0.4455654025,
0.6747462153,
-0.0067661945,
0.7817234397,
0.7841365933,
-0.1977890581,
-0.2197637409,
-0.7913615704,
-0.1976959258,
-0.5550969839,
0.4424813986,
-0.56502527,
-0.7925143242,
0.4702360928,
-0.0065806559,
-0.0255659446,
0.4852260649,
0.2980740368,
-0.0949685127,
1.0844936371,
0.9260227084,
-0.1340758801,
0.7972752452,
-0.4377323091,
0.2996840179,
-0.5638125539,
-0.2496443391,
-0.09075813,
-0.9310615659,
-0.3080527782,
-0.5832073689,
0.360247314,
0.2260568738,
-0.2187179923,
0.1475541145,
-0.4697239101,
0.4577579796,
0.3246172667,
0.1396452934,
0.3552388847,
0.0780962855,
0.2813833952,
0.3052845895,
-0.9332301617,
-0.2717670202,
0.8743209839,
0.419837296,
1.0044466257,
0.1428802162,
0.5274470448,
0.0854503661,
0.4055711031,
-0.9855518937,
0.2454896718,
-0.2281523049,
-0.0257045683,
-0.4344827831,
-0.5364607573,
-0.8250666261,
0.138792634,
0.0371444821,
-0.1400332451,
0.4203509092,
0.1501689106,
-0.4518007934,
0.4244851768,
-0.7945696115,
0.6716610193,
-0.1004983038,
-0.1211197749,
-0.4271482229,
-0.3016783595,
0.3233091831,
0.0011067981,
-0.199181661,
0.2432268858,
-0.3338072002,
0.8050087094,
-0.3591934144,
0.6461856961,
-0.3818759322,
-0.2668133974,
0.311465323,
0.1340132952,
0.4378554523,
0.0388333015,
-0.3028655648,
0.2739790082,
-0.4996713698,
-0.6776180267,
-1.0777930021,
0.4416166246,
-0.8276131749,
-0.5472761393,
0.070251897,
-0.7645748258,
0.0584500767,
0.1548886746,
-0.0716778561,
0.5788137913,
0.05389506,
0.6731349826,
0.9008033276,
0.0697860122,
0.3049125373,
0.3583540916,
0.4144876897,
-0.2610367835,
0.4823056459,
0.0906220227,
0.0145102777,
0.7313600183,
0.2914129496,
-0.11196585,
-0.8122377396,
-0.2406540662,
0.087697044,
-0.696634531,
-0.2111468464,
-1.1660254002,
-0.2129428536,
-0.1613057256,
-0.2235487401,
-0.5161912441,
-0.6087351441,
0.020361254,
-0.1688951701,
0.2984778881,
0.8570098877,
0.3542416692,
0.6740566492,
-0.5620925426,
0.4683825076,
0.6293377876,
0.6944183707,
0.3263044953,
-0.6676937938,
-0.1838619858,
-0.3023214042,
-0.2478186041,
-0.5117064118,
-0.1185709536,
0.0914744958,
0.5948346853,
0.3997356296,
-0.2870125175,
0.9737459421,
-0.286161691,
0.6385527253,
-0.0155756688,
-0.869461,
0.1506709158,
0.0631938428,
0.7657929063,
0.2822994292,
0.3487924635,
-0.3863919973,
-0.2446851283,
-0.6001321077,
-0.821346879,
0.3507917225,
-0.0504541323,
0.4331027865,
0.4659739733,
0.3187508881,
-0.0477055274,
-0.025877649,
-0.3788647652,
-0.0834446922,
-0.7400760651,
-0.509467423,
0.1874126494,
-0.4444503784,
0.0859998539,
-0.4325355887,
0.2881856859,
-0.1970830113,
0.3067307174,
0.3962478936,
-0.4235538244,
-0.2063498944,
0.1639686227,
0.5057020187,
0.7596750259,
0.0889859796,
0.4220233858,
0.3927225471,
-0.8427259922,
-0.1105535775,
0.1552588046,
0.0625004172,
-0.1811142564,
0.5391696692,
0.9061065316,
0.5825318098,
-0.5733203292,
0.560667038,
-0.3174418509,
-0.4184277952,
-0.2714222074,
0.3169479072,
0.0649543405,
0.4859889746,
0.5963225365,
0.4404356182,
0.2671594918,
-0.1158428565,
0.2876974344,
0.2406831533,
-0.632190764,
-0.3548831344,
0.5836776495,
-0.0227467231,
0.0212320387,
0.5652192831,
0.105704017,
-0.1893286705,
0.3126243651,
0.2518267632,
0.9768828154,
-0.2938874364,
-0.0887179971,
0.323305428,
0.2682191432,
-0.1979294121,
0.2585813403,
-0.3625085652,
-0.7365324497,
-0.5330759287,
-0.7357823849,
-0.2065678537,
-0.0421101898,
-0.3820263743,
0.1853369623,
-0.6240427494,
0.1907601953,
-0.0351455249,
-0.1292131692,
-0.6785538793,
0.1294523627,
0.1292265952,
1.2983301878,
-0.5838043094,
0.5498070717,
0.5740938187,
-0.165280968,
-0.9216911793,
-0.2082107067,
-0.2651930451,
-0.6059404612,
0.4798883796,
0.0282141902,
-0.4299439788,
-0.0652400255,
-0.4171030521,
-1.005823493,
1.417239666,
0.3244369626,
-0.5775727034,
0.0159009993,
-0.015833782,
0.4980994165,
-0.4471524954,
0.6848678589,
0.6300100684,
0.7067724466,
0.3508195281,
-0.2589006722,
0.3731180727,
-0.4671653211,
-0.0507348143,
0.1775399148,
-0.5102422237,
0.7977656722,
-0.2350384891,
-0.3248188198,
-0.1632815748,
0.9278485775,
-0.2038672566,
0.046411477,
0.8305029273,
0.6081389189,
0.7298646569,
-0.0335019603,
1.0975478888,
-0.1098826751,
-0.2428107262,
0.9109247327,
-0.1419433206,
0.5683587193,
0.3242306709,
-0.043156527,
0.9083204865,
-0.1066464186,
-0.224259913,
0.1298202872,
0.004287018,
0.0152841602,
-0.1253135651,
0.1762714684,
-0.0303387325,
0.777566433,
0.0577907339,
-0.3207192421,
-0.1952235103,
-0.2553063035,
-0.1141005903,
-0.034018293,
-0.2611354589,
0.9341765642,
-0.0182856061,
-0.4091901779,
0.6372095346,
-0.1442871243,
0.7937428355,
-0.5523492098,
-0.0909911096,
-0.2790827453,
0.1656542867,
-0.5747955441,
-0.7310668826,
0.4843186736,
-0.0563907176,
-0.5130342245,
-0.5076603889,
0.8128826618,
-0.2357492745,
-0.527192235,
0.3122200966,
0.4451975524,
-0.1145826206,
-0.5353156924,
-0.6061133146,
0.1506731957,
-0.5997173786,
-0.5218316317,
-0.1542683542,
0.5465508699,
0.009426605,
0.6355261207,
0.5475260019,
0.1196021661,
0.2824023962,
0.7470495105,
1.0563220978,
-0.726685226,
-0.3191122115,
-0.626185596,
0.6938847303,
-0.422092557,
-0.1015576273,
0.6682285666,
0.6178137064,
0.5465502143,
0.0992343724,
0.4137464762,
0.0728366375,
0.0960272774,
-0.3206532598,
0.8363048434,
-0.5412490368,
0.2664137185,
-0.1889067292,
-1.1353862286,
-0.2959889472,
0.2497237623,
-0.3472031355,
0.1982548386,
0.5918955803,
0.8060692549,
-0.5811288953,
0.1419905722,
0.3210406303,
0.5549952984,
0.407604754,
0.4532292783,
0.7244573832,
-0.7058258057,
0.6574306488,
-0.4014483988,
-0.5372998714,
0.0859000757,
-0.7306072116,
-0.6608636975,
-0.3381136656,
-0.1739944071,
0.0490524732,
-0.4709606767,
0.4079121053,
0.9164016843,
-0.7910977602,
-0.288774997,
-0.1193507016,
0.2697474658,
-0.4719830155,
-0.2641300559,
0.0569253936,
-0.2974661589,
-0.5217303634,
0.4551938474,
0.4594025612,
0.0442835465,
-0.3085376918,
-0.0181436166,
0.4728340805,
0.2130308896,
0.7550613284,
-0.2562903762,
-0.2809530497,
0.0056612715,
-0.0160976909,
-0.0195788667,
0.221971795,
1.0040237904,
-0.9251745939,
0.4265083969,
0.774438858,
0.7374789715,
0.6219804287,
0.1221385226,
0.6582309604,
-0.5786271691,
0.3002003431,
0.3305378556,
0.3887973428,
0.4264582098,
-0.5659351349,
0.167707175,
-0.0758617371,
-0.148420617,
-0.5795952082,
0.1965097338,
-1.1398459673,
-0.2671038508,
0.6424372196,
0.5266942978,
-0.4453026652,
-0.0357467234,
-0.0048659015,
0.1296940744,
-0.4045691192,
0.8750396967,
0.2599035203,
-0.0785547122,
-0.4308624268,
-0.3882911801,
0.37453264,
0.3775157034,
-0.6575852036,
-0.1373146474,
0.1214134395,
0.2879561186,
0.3459389508,
0.5342344642,
-0.3482606113,
0.3727631867,
0.1304423362,
-0.1800149977,
-0.2691962719,
-0.4997738898,
-0.458165437,
0.4340778291,
-0.2891112268,
0.3384198844
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02619v7
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02619v7
|
Increasing Trust in Language Models through the Reuse of Verified Circuits
| 2024-02-04T21:33:18 | 2024-06-16T22:09:57 |
Philip Quirke, Clement Neo, Fazl Barez
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Language Models (LMs) are increasingly used for a wide range of prediction
tasks, but their training can often neglect rare edge cases, reducing their
reliability. Here, we define a stringent standard of trustworthiness whereby
the task algorithm and circuit implementation must be verified, accounting for
edge cases, with no known failure modes. We show that a model can be trained to
meet this standard if built using mathematically and logically specified
frameworks. In this paper, we fully verify an auto-regressive transformer model
for n-digit integer addition. To exhibit the reusability of verified modules,
we insert the trained integer addition model into a larger untrained model and
train the combined model to perform both addition and subtraction. We find
extensive reuse of the addition circuits for both tasks, easing verification of
the more complex subtractor model. We discuss how inserting verified task
modules into LMs can leverage model reuse to improve verifiability and
trustworthiness of language models built using them. The reuse of verified
circuits reduces the effort to verify more complex composite models which we
believe to be a significant step towards safety of language models.
|
[
-0.2462557405,
-0.409011662,
0.5553269982,
0.0855534002,
0.0019464246,
0.1148390472,
-0.026217822,
-0.3983686268,
-0.3428918719,
0.6635545492,
-0.186980173,
-0.1943855286,
-0.7136513591,
-0.0646234751,
-0.9385012388,
0.7138174772,
-0.344322741,
-0.0994755402,
-0.432990998,
-0.1714547724,
-0.2355077118,
-0.707582593,
-0.5173240304,
-0.8675438166,
0.2339781225,
0.0806204602,
0.9365455508,
0.4826889932,
0.5462914109,
0.4280838966,
0.0534712188,
0.2241602838,
-0.0543225445,
0.052139394,
-0.3285843432,
-0.6473785043,
-0.6831826568,
0.0566891171,
0.5026469231,
0.4378630519,
-0.2996972799,
0.2205399424,
-0.1838303804,
0.2441335469,
-0.4710511267,
0.2326863557,
-0.7675718665,
-0.1471749693,
0.3204543293,
-0.0816096812,
-0.8417198062,
-0.6219252348,
-0.0623992756,
-0.3588635027,
-0.0321767591,
-0.0505621471,
0.9003483057,
0.2173775733,
-0.5165393353,
-0.1209238246,
-0.8680188656,
0.7926668525,
-0.5589123964,
0.9159268141,
0.3909704983,
0.257719785,
-0.0508688726,
-1.0373690128,
-0.5942043662,
-0.5018521547,
-0.2783969343,
-0.3394573331,
-0.318133533,
0.0322051011,
0.4246971309,
0.4244405329,
-0.130215928,
-0.0927383304,
-0.2848030925,
-0.5002576709,
0.4534834325,
0.0626985058,
0.5854734182,
0.0387220792,
-0.2008017153,
-0.0745434016,
-1.0110892057,
0.1244192049,
0.3315377533,
0.07009767,
-0.0215548854,
0.5253118277,
-0.0552288927,
0.5090808272,
0.0177200492,
-0.2086895108,
0.3009869754,
-0.3016486466,
-0.2775861919,
-0.2846010923,
0.6463824511,
0.2386015207,
0.7608382702,
-0.1774676144,
-0.5153664351,
0.1605106145,
0.5672641993,
-0.5705291629,
-0.4242255688,
-0.0189818349,
-0.2980573773,
-0.4152982831,
-0.2228168249,
0.1378494799,
0.0227921437,
-0.3522748947,
0.4874190688,
-0.6211053133,
-0.3705466986,
0.1643399894,
0.1378606558,
0.1656428277,
0.2523105741,
-0.734826088,
0.4203876257,
0.9546326995,
0.6837394238,
0.1995192468,
-0.54627949,
-0.4509632885,
-0.1303474158,
-0.4698359072,
0.5047671199,
-0.3741945624,
-0.2811484337,
0.1735274941,
0.3669468462,
-0.08802858,
-0.3881451786,
0.6766411662,
-0.8020811081,
0.1441156268,
0.0989809707,
-0.568677485,
-0.0937829763,
0.3609122336,
-0.6253407001,
1.1362608671,
0.2402474582,
-0.4892378151,
0.1719002724,
-0.2590219378,
-0.7305502295,
-0.2879706919,
-0.0402342491,
-0.5101273656,
0.3428803682,
0.1206469983,
0.22136347,
-0.0691319928,
0.5364231467,
-0.2974564135,
-0.3909383714,
0.5016579628,
-0.6548886895,
0.970392108,
-0.0109690381,
-0.2577510476,
0.0102061387,
-0.7268405557,
0.2318777591,
-0.2104450613,
-0.2645871341,
-0.2982038558,
-0.1069879234,
-0.1226315722,
0.2340313643,
0.2414370477,
-0.6885633469,
-0.2015365511,
-0.508212626,
0.5233138204,
0.6505529881,
-0.0433480926,
0.3700305521,
-0.3804018199,
0.2552800179,
-0.0400574468,
0.2575004399,
-0.2857083678,
-0.3665883839,
-1.0671180487,
0.065360859,
0.3663212061,
0.5441857576,
-0.8305932879,
0.5786364079,
-0.2363395244,
-0.6899437904,
-0.2963648438,
0.0798781142,
0.3065528572,
0.4821397364,
0.3356951475,
-0.2432301193,
-0.3593768775,
-1.0048172474,
-0.2982669175,
-0.4003136754,
-0.1385895908,
0.0535062067,
0.5257534385,
-0.2886895239,
0.9438462257,
-0.1896126866,
0.3530217707,
-0.217409268,
0.1439904273,
0.193227604,
0.8103601336,
0.2452743798,
-0.5028522611,
-0.3820469379,
-0.0415090695,
-0.7320896983,
0.0984293148,
-0.1944493502,
0.2069695145,
0.2461004853,
0.5199340582,
-0.5910935402,
0.4728721976,
0.5554915071,
-0.1025045961,
0.3769440949,
-0.397475332,
0.3051197231,
-0.8140105009,
-0.078548722,
-0.0826959312,
-0.6992880702,
-0.5863986611,
0.250842303,
0.3244495094,
0.0051366109,
-0.2673076093,
0.3833215833,
-0.10185083,
0.04611836,
-0.4353379309,
-0.0430671424,
0.1884452552,
0.2816321254,
0.1041687652,
0.6137548685,
0.6877287626,
-0.5557783246,
0.3366992176,
-0.0514604859,
-0.6089743972,
0.5606867671,
-1.0030270815,
0.1892307103,
0.0860610157,
0.0203061309,
-0.917616725,
0.2537251711,
0.0302793439,
-0.4393760264,
0.2464860082,
-0.1528432518,
-0.6783471704,
-0.1463028193,
0.2285801023,
0.3769389689,
0.6920163035,
-0.7205720544,
0.9341529012,
0.2842639983,
0.0512262769,
-0.4813974798,
-0.7547314167,
-0.0780233666,
0.1528284252,
-0.7436100245,
0.2147521824,
0.1827208251,
-0.3098022044,
-0.0108129391,
-0.3427390158,
-0.3570504189,
0.4667733014,
0.3889771998,
0.3526443243,
-0.0539141037,
0.1575601697,
0.0903412849,
-0.5443573594,
0.4242395163,
-0.081314303,
0.3425653577,
-0.1427996457,
-0.7835202217,
-0.6766818762,
0.3659056425,
0.8312497735,
-0.3596483767,
0.5055764318,
0.4818529189,
-0.7969813347,
-0.1731606573,
-0.7201225758,
-0.3780719042,
-0.5678353906,
0.397347033,
-0.4725819528,
-1.0795030594,
0.5306349993,
-0.0678983256,
0.3564255238,
0.4924228489,
0.544585824,
0.0622991808,
0.8287433982,
0.8405016661,
-0.006760017,
0.2287352681,
0.254352659,
0.6555464864,
-0.500048697,
-0.1958511174,
-0.5457770824,
0.079117842,
-0.53958565,
-0.5913242698,
-0.0684311166,
-0.1451027542,
-0.2881346941,
0.6574589014,
-0.3717424273,
0.5635119677,
0.5017288327,
0.1122945398,
0.6190419197,
-0.081294626,
-0.1055962294,
0.0520330854,
-0.4471386075,
-0.6199368238,
0.9821295738,
0.8211659193,
0.9078687429,
-0.0834509283,
0.7901735306,
0.2182736397,
0.7111589313,
-0.6029063463,
0.5010512471,
-0.1963236332,
-0.8222389817,
-0.1523758769,
-0.514326632,
-0.2278473526,
-0.1175493747,
0.1388278008,
-0.8218393326,
0.2605151832,
0.3228434026,
-0.4531331956,
0.3412276804,
-0.6800640821,
0.6342508793,
-0.1797454804,
-0.1960262656,
-0.3923146725,
-0.2277391851,
0.4725157022,
0.1353074759,
0.1535903364,
0.1665229648,
0.2902617455,
0.5725330114,
-0.5855634809,
0.8258596659,
0.0783640146,
-0.3842053413,
0.5954648256,
0.4737358987,
0.8689445257,
0.1255371124,
0.0992852673,
0.0640345588,
0.058947321,
0.1049969271,
-0.7679662704,
0.8956463933,
-0.8382718563,
-0.6882793307,
-0.3659391403,
-0.4762531519,
-0.3402495384,
0.1696821749,
0.0352500677,
0.6004828215,
0.1379352212,
0.3779226542,
0.9052115679,
0.0780488849,
0.3339512348,
0.1167166978,
-0.2450861037,
-0.3526605368,
0.8503955603,
0.0369467139,
0.5810666084,
0.3049311638,
-0.1323633045,
-0.1788986623,
-0.337515831,
-0.1074835956,
-0.0540497489,
-0.8518621922,
-0.0756284595,
-0.6503580213,
-0.5966281295,
-0.1522277296,
-0.1026190966,
-0.9008541107,
-0.6634375453,
0.1286461502,
-0.414293319,
0.3220922351,
0.5897117257,
-0.0596373677,
0.4174749851,
-0.8793725371,
0.1195712686,
0.487612009,
0.8186252117,
0.0321344845,
-0.7558742166,
-0.3728248775,
-0.2002741843,
-0.0145368213,
-0.6273705959,
0.0144129293,
-0.1105781868,
0.7663126588,
-0.0480233915,
-0.3510059118,
0.387418896,
-0.559122622,
0.5365478396,
0.1077291295,
-1.4073863029,
0.1013079658,
-0.0828374401,
0.0585823655,
0.5107025504,
0.3325283229,
-0.5078632832,
-0.4181131721,
-0.8215665817,
-0.5487782359,
0.2665048838,
0.2053527832,
0.2892611027,
0.1533692628,
0.490745008,
-0.1087178662,
0.0537373275,
-0.972173512,
-0.3759247661,
-0.4720084369,
-0.1922429055,
0.2067869753,
-0.4899656177,
-0.1479114294,
-0.0552472472,
0.7742087841,
0.0810977444,
0.1179245114,
0.0571577363,
-0.2915567756,
0.0826950744,
0.3682403564,
0.2581602931,
0.6910381913,
-0.0964529514,
0.4138976336,
0.2652307749,
-0.3957739472,
0.4077804983,
-0.2224110961,
-0.1204094514,
0.1693859398,
0.3947957456,
0.4106345177,
0.2937601209,
-0.3896324635,
0.2066785395,
-0.2104304582,
-0.2574901283,
-0.4617316723,
0.0706958994,
0.3439301848,
0.120200716,
0.0947107598,
0.2946493924,
-0.0454539657,
-0.3220698833,
0.8616023064,
0.1926865876,
-0.7057384253,
-0.2271898389,
0.2157420963,
0.2603533268,
-0.5483500957,
0.6837402582,
-0.1843753904,
-0.6359707713,
0.455516696,
0.5999231935,
0.8636392355,
-0.3538091183,
0.1685931385,
0.5299492478,
1.0963369608,
-0.2752126753,
0.1402325928,
0.2244243771,
-0.9582967162,
-0.5511911511,
-0.221258685,
-0.5167567134,
-0.1069956794,
-0.6039607525,
0.1803013533,
-0.6577176452,
-0.3301101923,
-0.3716024458,
-0.3667642474,
-0.5647608638,
0.4048666656,
0.0195146166,
1.0733605623,
-1.0180920362,
1.0123642683,
0.3180890083,
0.0522833914,
-0.9549796581,
-0.42691046,
-0.2331180274,
-0.8976588845,
0.6073279381,
-0.0176082477,
-0.3245255649,
-0.3225852549,
-0.2011342049,
-0.87995857,
0.9328895211,
0.192873776,
-0.6051103473,
0.1906595081,
0.0994408578,
0.430606246,
-0.4193614721,
0.4528710544,
0.4555669427,
0.1930060834,
0.0998516157,
-0.9623751044,
0.365205586,
-0.2479988337,
-0.1504126638,
0.1413645148,
-0.3889932334,
1.1330702305,
-0.1435222328,
-0.2891632318,
-0.0111811506,
0.7114225626,
0.3688949347,
-0.0198447127,
0.7613456249,
0.4797212481,
0.7523300648,
-0.1696734279,
0.8094536066,
-0.5649568439,
0.5464528799,
1.4260416031,
-0.1871007532,
0.803827405,
0.517536521,
-0.1182759702,
0.7350702286,
0.2030156106,
-0.0131183239,
0.1376752704,
0.1250676364,
-0.0117861023,
-0.9218275547,
-0.135565266,
-0.3437037468,
0.3265766203,
0.2199647427,
-0.601184845,
-0.2802995443,
-0.3368207216,
0.166422978,
0.0201055855,
-0.0487202741,
0.1978693306,
0.2532710433,
-0.5844293833,
0.2002925426,
0.085968852,
0.3821941316,
-0.4524625838,
0.0759753063,
-0.1531905681,
0.3758966327,
-0.315572381,
-0.5851022005,
0.5285174847,
-0.0892495364,
-0.2600347996,
-0.3698364496,
0.874252975,
-0.2763307691,
-0.9445031285,
0.1337876767,
0.626721859,
-0.3879202604,
0.0227545965,
-0.3410457075,
0.1465951204,
0.0915925503,
-0.2505556643,
0.2332732379,
0.326992929,
-0.0377902687,
0.9911044836,
0.643594563,
-0.1198074073,
-0.0834433511,
0.2258417159,
0.8080495,
-0.4833040833,
-0.3105403185,
-1.0018274784,
0.7208568454,
-0.1809832156,
-0.0862494409,
0.8301501274,
0.3213962317,
0.8202629089,
0.1064049602,
0.8669163585,
0.1695581675,
0.2500937283,
-0.2651779354,
0.7942667603,
-0.2318435907,
0.3846980631,
0.0995649695,
-0.6004565358,
-0.3261030614,
0.7857317924,
-0.2332499027,
0.2275446504,
0.8574653864,
0.879029274,
-0.0597646907,
0.19919011,
0.260304153,
0.0548932999,
0.6105973125,
0.6104680896,
0.9311739206,
-0.7059260607,
0.5127654672,
-0.5745187402,
-0.3879354298,
0.2248234004,
-1.0310540199,
-1.0190263987,
-0.4967445731,
-0.6856481433,
-0.4558098912,
-0.21490556,
0.7447296977,
0.5077033043,
-0.8292266726,
-0.3244739473,
-0.0364431776,
0.6143996119,
-0.2673380971,
-0.1482775211,
0.0913535655,
-0.2504782975,
-0.4956392944,
0.2889031768,
0.2889740467,
0.0962016284,
-0.5492994785,
0.1360115409,
0.0026102061,
0.1900554746,
0.4061539769,
0.0597164892,
-0.6178865433,
-0.7270717621,
0.3369759023,
-0.0768201947,
-0.1760342568,
0.9651802182,
-0.7065623403,
0.2472526282,
0.5952877402,
0.5563207865,
0.0732589513,
-0.2496686876,
1.0426878929,
-0.4042868912,
-0.3445571363,
-0.0266596004,
0.8074974418,
0.3891230822,
-0.2102214545,
0.2522156537,
0.0517837293,
-0.5650977492,
-1.0481944084,
0.51059407,
-0.6084161401,
0.2196822166,
0.8452836871,
-0.6241677403,
-0.2184746712,
-0.2346684933,
0.2582508624,
0.0590583384,
-0.1553438902,
0.8829111457,
0.8352093101,
0.1328870803,
-0.3049375415,
-0.1435795277,
0.4441614151,
0.430572629,
-0.7170494199,
0.3173716962,
-0.0237743445,
0.5742114782,
0.5769430995,
0.3251955211,
-0.325307101,
0.3981740773,
0.1958501488,
0.0441201031,
-0.4597733915,
-0.5623588562,
-0.1338160783,
0.2737128735,
0.2582750022,
-0.0129212355
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02617v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02617v1
|
Layer-Wise Analysis of Self-Supervised Acoustic Word Embeddings: A Study on Speech Emotion Recognition
| 2024-02-04T21:24:54 | 2024-02-04T21:24:54 |
Alexandra Saliba, Yuanchao Li, Ramon Sanabria, Catherine Lai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
The efficacy of self-supervised speech models has been validated, yet the
optimal utilization of their representations remains challenging across diverse
tasks. In this study, we delve into Acoustic Word Embeddings (AWEs), a
fixed-length feature derived from continuous representations, to explore their
advantages in specific tasks. AWEs have previously shown utility in capturing
acoustic discriminability. In light of this, we propose measuring layer-wise
similarity between AWEs and word embeddings, aiming to further investigate the
inherent context within AWEs. Moreover, we evaluate the contribution of AWEs,
in comparison to other types of speech features, in the context of Speech
Emotion Recognition (SER). Through a comparative experiment and a layer-wise
accuracy analysis on two distinct corpora, IEMOCAP and ESD, we explore
differences between AWEs and raw self-supervised representations, as well as
the proper utilization of AWEs alone and in combination with word embeddings.
Our findings underscore the acoustic context conveyed by AWEs and showcase the
highly competitive SER accuracies by appropriately employing AWEs.
|
[
-0.4066862166,
-0.50908494,
0.4299702048,
0.3098333776,
-0.2055972368,
-0.0213761404,
-0.0117260264,
-0.5594547391,
0.5537782907,
0.3552930355,
-0.215207085,
-0.6468344331,
-0.4905347824,
0.113830179,
-0.5403385758,
0.5632535219,
-0.218248859,
-0.21530734,
-0.5160354972,
-0.5448919535,
-0.1528496295,
-0.5803921223,
-0.5527698994,
-0.1420658529,
0.5212135315,
0.0571291596,
0.2698608041,
0.647149682,
0.1296459287,
0.3392457664,
-0.0636307821,
0.047850702,
-0.1588470489,
0.3422311842,
0.4060348868,
-0.0781401917,
-0.1883995682,
0.1965739578,
0.5092207193,
0.5140922666,
-0.3190009296,
-0.0654210746,
0.3192013204,
0.5642511845,
-0.6585941911,
0.1348738819,
-0.2457580268,
0.7199098468,
-0.141640842,
-0.1334882081,
0.0002032494,
-0.1432793736,
0.6057913303,
-0.288238734,
-0.0283652972,
0.0703653991,
0.1671342254,
0.2980919182,
-0.3737041056,
-0.6417044997,
-0.4997508526,
0.5580327511,
-0.7070338726,
0.6627083421,
0.2430330068,
0.0165343024,
0.2758848667,
-0.5409500599,
-0.5125169158,
-0.2853351235,
0.0040109074,
0.4151114523,
-0.4987971485,
0.4376781285,
0.0419892147,
0.6079220772,
-0.3188211322,
0.3610571921,
0.0427677333,
-0.3633705378,
0.5439040065,
-0.1567982733,
0.3076168895,
-0.0884924382,
-0.4520407021,
-0.2498627007,
-0.2378891259,
0.2841804922,
0.4339515269,
0.2879167497,
-0.3892690837,
0.422298193,
0.0795039386,
0.1508236825,
-0.1372356415,
-0.1469736397,
0.4741842151,
0.4615399837,
-0.1771113724,
0.5325467587,
0.7078663111,
0.116353251,
0.1285424531,
-0.2964689732,
-0.322304517,
0.0739163682,
0.3577679098,
-0.4124847651,
-0.0116192978,
0.4420045912,
-0.4289084971,
-0.1775855869,
-0.087428771,
-0.5894428492,
-0.2762156725,
-0.2748339772,
0.4588742554,
-0.3535307646,
-0.2855481803,
0.0922136903,
-0.301445365,
-0.0394170061,
-0.1881597638,
-0.7263902426,
0.4308738708,
0.5110809207,
1.030482769,
-0.035228923,
-0.2318190187,
-0.4516796172,
0.0167849027,
-0.4114330709,
0.5015794635,
-0.6324685812,
-0.7634429932,
0.2531882226,
-0.4425182641,
-0.1178237349,
-0.4973544478,
0.6840400696,
-0.153144896,
0.1998321414,
-0.2609289885,
-1.0161780119,
-0.1680160165,
-0.0351725034,
-0.557878077,
1.0401445627,
0.0024168803,
-0.6968058944,
0.0587568507,
-0.5750566125,
-0.4143940508,
-0.122265406,
-0.2859421968,
-0.5577452183,
0.5340180993,
0.056617599,
0.697455585,
0.276101172,
-0.3222277761,
-0.5005105734,
-0.1615557224,
0.1109183207,
-0.3172836006,
0.2220401317,
0.2997416854,
-0.538752377,
-0.2661021352,
-0.6911741495,
-0.0983113423,
-0.0590332747,
0.0057635191,
-0.740108788,
0.0692548975,
-0.1940704286,
-0.0313907377,
0.1420461535,
-0.8402536511,
-0.1177580208,
-0.1540914327,
0.4321644306,
0.6413798332,
-0.1038299575,
0.205492422,
0.1479543746,
0.4900613129,
0.1357046515,
-0.1320683211,
-0.0193997398,
-0.173631683,
-0.3982631862,
-0.5106763244,
0.3579155505,
0.4033601284,
-0.3368420899,
0.5713459253,
0.2038979679,
-0.4595440924,
-0.8193829656,
-0.0530584343,
0.6046463251,
0.6868492961,
0.539511621,
-0.5190038085,
-0.4011441469,
-0.9849700928,
-0.1686275303,
-0.1695803702,
-0.1218210533,
0.5700500011,
0.123911038,
-0.2859453261,
0.8530453444,
-0.2557775676,
-0.5287171602,
0.1654247493,
0.6315385103,
-0.3273909092,
0.3788197339,
0.77645123,
-0.5914833546,
-0.2312102467,
-0.178471446,
-0.9649313688,
-0.4645982683,
0.0671975538,
0.2857570648,
0.1764712781,
0.4822467566,
-0.1921951473,
0.4085413218,
0.8009417653,
-0.1523118168,
0.5553880334,
-0.3752025664,
0.1464146823,
-0.4521087408,
-0.2810955048,
0.3575087488,
-0.1447904408,
-0.7045237422,
-0.2176023126,
0.0478433818,
-0.0360750258,
-0.3997443616,
0.2184748948,
-0.5935544372,
-0.4456403852,
-0.338103503,
0.418443054,
-0.0469069332,
0.3473874927,
0.1842649579,
0.6818407774,
0.8124493957,
-0.4013667703,
0.3330152929,
0.0192920547,
-0.3028987646,
0.7940112948,
-0.725602448,
0.496032536,
0.0146224517,
0.199714005,
-0.8447812796,
0.2201550901,
-0.3019031882,
-0.1667947769,
0.3331693709,
0.0954303145,
-0.2922093868,
-0.3857630491,
-0.2953502238,
0.2831771076,
0.6089397669,
-0.6092733741,
0.7071489096,
0.7632303834,
-0.2239299864,
-0.3801177144,
-0.7041327953,
-0.0157089327,
-0.6448558569,
-0.4429351985,
0.5755269527,
0.1512305588,
-0.0650898591,
0.1426910311,
-0.3441835344,
0.1993054897,
0.0935804918,
0.3627450764,
-0.2475285679,
-0.3098580837,
0.2674074471,
0.1268845648,
0.0163448807,
0.2431969643,
-0.2634566128,
0.2000617683,
-0.3897047937,
-0.4100164473,
-0.4669321179,
0.6116319895,
0.3958508968,
-0.3456442654,
0.5070924163,
0.7281278968,
-0.3941702545,
-0.3401587009,
-0.7336317301,
0.1683434844,
-0.497431308,
0.1080983058,
-0.4883152843,
-1.2531069517,
0.9038742185,
-0.1315142363,
-0.2352007329,
0.5399906039,
0.1409465373,
-0.6234873533,
1.1864386797,
0.6397293806,
-0.5746408105,
0.3860592246,
-0.3023878634,
0.0496791042,
-1.1670393944,
-0.3001672924,
-0.5741556883,
-0.3744872808,
-0.6245959997,
-0.0019324264,
0.4652525485,
-0.1887876689,
0.0091900891,
0.1330555528,
-0.3816413283,
0.1879888922,
0.3117728829,
-0.0795573145,
-0.3875456452,
-0.0396862328,
-0.3488664925,
0.006408717,
-0.507689178,
-0.203663826,
0.5274143815,
0.5727607608,
0.5403103232,
-0.2016995847,
1.0528719425,
0.5622650981,
-0.241056785,
-0.7278830409,
0.2544821501,
-0.3987191021,
0.0296997558,
-0.3241501451,
-0.4924843013,
-0.7950307727,
0.1056906506,
0.0464698337,
-0.8478955626,
0.4589845538,
0.1701513827,
-0.4173668921,
0.304410845,
-0.6931937933,
0.7423514128,
-0.3389920592,
-0.0759936944,
-0.198097527,
-0.4105606973,
-0.2477534711,
0.1503151804,
0.3116071224,
0.0056434995,
0.0015573113,
0.9079960585,
-0.306825012,
0.7400316,
-0.4349536896,
-0.3925070465,
0.4875472486,
0.1110360622,
0.1664995253,
-0.4084145427,
-0.0684877113,
0.3435783088,
-0.08442384,
-0.1141590178,
-0.7059172392,
0.8144592643,
-0.699452579,
-0.529632926,
-0.3653656244,
-0.2930175662,
-0.4300801456,
-0.1053019986,
-0.0223822016,
0.9617863297,
-0.2571188807,
0.3743195832,
0.7311574221,
-0.1636266857,
0.4068144858,
0.1990948617,
0.0185657851,
-0.0830800235,
0.9663703442,
0.3775312603,
0.0620181933,
0.183241412,
0.4726564288,
-0.7022230625,
-0.4677820206,
-0.0591592453,
0.0409058519,
-0.5477915406,
0.0274565592,
-0.6067393422,
-0.2319484204,
-0.4546508789,
-0.2040035427,
-0.5873890519,
-0.2848110199,
-0.4318290949,
-0.3861457109,
0.3709200025,
0.6090682149,
-0.5521598458,
-0.0545723289,
-0.7329095602,
0.3572119772,
0.6765751839,
0.4944248199,
0.017569337,
-0.567471385,
-0.2581677735,
0.0411860719,
-0.086683102,
-0.8853516579,
0.4518812895,
0.6989913583,
0.7010887861,
0.6670612693,
0.2218602449,
0.7760047317,
-0.5125182271,
0.8836442232,
0.0013198444,
-1.2688099146,
0.547791779,
-0.0825397298,
0.0609473884,
0.4841552079,
0.5801180601,
-0.6925733089,
-0.5386140347,
-0.7668062449,
-0.9272371531,
0.2579646409,
0.3552686274,
0.4234514534,
-0.0996032283,
0.3046225011,
0.0216637049,
0.2317438126,
-0.3285980225,
-0.3989993334,
-0.4639555812,
-0.338472724,
0.0358928256,
-0.3477765322,
-0.1065106168,
0.0202655066,
0.3201539516,
0.0070275548,
0.4930125177,
0.6274397969,
-0.0052947467,
0.0212203134,
0.175505057,
0.3138802052,
-0.0895849541,
-0.3559573591,
0.4834314287,
0.2791551352,
-0.4121094942,
-0.1594478786,
0.1212513521,
0.4731593728,
-0.0243954379,
0.4743544161,
0.9458502531,
0.3858571351,
-0.4668683112,
0.4623825252,
0.0587990284,
0.0115446234,
-0.3355113566,
0.0429848284,
0.0586391836,
0.4534940422,
0.328012228,
-0.3297810853,
0.6774128079,
-0.7399205565,
0.245632425,
0.4164740145,
-0.6315882206,
-0.2520675659,
0.4216131866,
0.3009845614,
-0.3131340742,
0.5335764885,
-0.1854037344,
-0.840616703,
0.5945699811,
0.5435786247,
1.2188829184,
-0.5758423209,
0.0288418643,
0.008834837,
-0.1105761006,
0.1351639777,
0.2734948099,
-0.4248049855,
-0.7229348421,
0.1023632884,
-0.5011380315,
-0.6380278468,
-0.0751871467,
-1.0187833309,
-0.2210472524,
-0.2010354847,
-0.0307942312,
0.0071607153,
-0.2194890678,
-0.5673077703,
0.4033619165,
0.7353110909,
0.7544411421,
-0.7856088281,
0.5576983094,
0.3700398207,
0.0112078302,
-0.8270924687,
-0.1964504272,
0.2762956917,
-0.6813216805,
0.1870273501,
0.3860740662,
-0.6391783953,
-0.0071840035,
-0.3224927783,
-0.5277940035,
1.1454102993,
0.1962844282,
-0.6007253528,
0.2811536491,
0.1043070704,
0.9187396765,
-0.6975090504,
0.1976041943,
0.6232268214,
0.1184936836,
-0.1544644684,
-0.8038699627,
-0.2854727507,
-0.3293581903,
0.063396275,
-0.1399639547,
-0.4942935109,
0.3874753416,
0.1081402972,
-0.3607074022,
-0.2151006907,
0.9634126425,
0.2453182936,
0.4891759157,
0.861330092,
0.8806651235,
0.7723889947,
-0.1090094522,
1.2373384237,
-0.209969312,
0.2709689736,
0.779912293,
-0.2679484487,
0.9279401302,
0.0534113385,
-0.2861953974,
0.689148128,
0.5207291245,
0.1249014065,
0.7670391798,
0.2675055861,
-0.2686403394,
-0.0230227634,
-0.295422256,
-0.608070612,
0.7309108973,
0.4911345243,
-0.2769611478,
0.207240805,
0.322152257,
-0.1465576887,
-0.0237186756,
-0.3391200304,
0.8755557537,
0.5225483179,
-0.0959460959,
0.2409877032,
-0.358390063,
0.7553644776,
-0.5907766819,
0.166999802,
-0.1431476772,
-0.3521205485,
-0.2134085149,
-0.829021275,
0.2194423378,
0.2162067294,
0.2264736146,
-0.3631783128,
0.7206990123,
-0.6889973283,
-0.2379893959,
0.6991382241,
0.1531776339,
0.1703387648,
-0.1676155627,
-0.6186977625,
0.1701158583,
-0.3005023301,
-0.3746681809,
0.1789291948,
0.7221368551,
0.4413786232,
0.5328063965,
0.1889035255,
0.2230412811,
0.0528614521,
0.4579473138,
0.6036475301,
-0.582872808,
-0.8502112031,
-0.683422327,
0.5022066832,
-0.0047499682,
-0.2779140472,
0.8562150002,
0.4047307074,
0.6301438808,
0.1439132988,
0.6445398927,
0.210908547,
0.4595269561,
-0.6812155843,
0.5384224653,
-0.8575698137,
0.1351835132,
-0.6653699279,
-0.6891067028,
-0.0240658112,
0.8818035126,
-0.2250327468,
-0.0107719777,
0.5016058683,
0.3850402236,
-0.119037956,
0.4280861914,
0.3880509734,
0.2456648797,
-0.0136898942,
0.1950224936,
0.8675049543,
-0.0837034881,
-0.0115575446,
-0.5485767126,
-0.1277224422,
-0.1680133641,
-0.9981481433,
-0.4617702663,
-0.8867587447,
-0.5929510593,
0.1424760073,
-0.057572078,
0.8129611015,
0.5487572551,
-0.728597343,
-0.2073507607,
0.2702351213,
-0.1800376624,
-0.3095124066,
-0.1667816788,
0.6079044342,
-0.1429701,
-0.4507109523,
0.7021068931,
0.4669741392,
0.2085174471,
-0.3759485781,
-0.025219107,
0.3017849028,
0.2722848654,
0.6706028581,
0.3701769412,
-0.600135088,
-0.8180139065,
-0.2513850331,
-0.0190194771,
0.0605844669,
0.7146200538,
-0.6994124651,
0.6687079668,
0.3137018383,
0.7193955779,
0.4452327788,
-0.0902360305,
0.3260593116,
-1.0928343534,
-0.0056439922,
0.3204893768,
0.7465398312,
0.4310458601,
-0.2830062509,
0.396241188,
-0.0911354423,
-0.5286979675,
-0.8330351114,
-0.038974572,
-1.1792781353,
0.0826452747,
0.919085741,
-0.5287074447,
0.0259905253,
0.1616345942,
-0.038419269,
0.4219736755,
-0.4348908067,
1.0147999525,
0.5768874288,
-0.4994191825,
-0.2076426744,
-0.2195564657,
0.4278336167,
0.37358585,
-0.5840540528,
-0.2045750171,
0.3766798079,
-0.0515527576,
0.4986159503,
0.3279375732,
-0.0435636304,
-0.0335484259,
0.0276025143,
-0.0096476097,
-0.1559333801,
-0.2770512998,
-0.6617072225,
0.3305348158,
-0.2474127561,
-0.2920601666
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02611v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02611v2
|
PuzzleBench: Can LLMs Solve Challenging First-Order Combinatorial Reasoning Problems?
| 2024-02-04T20:56:09 | 2024-02-22T14:42:45 |
Chinmay Mittal, Krishna Kartik, Mausam, Parag Singla
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recent works show that the largest of the large language models (LLMs) can
solve many simple reasoning tasks expressed in natural language, without
any/much supervision. But, can they also solve challenging first-order
combinatorial reasoning problems, such as graph coloring, knapsack and
cryptarithmetic? To answer this question, we present PuzzleBench, a dataset of
31 such challenging problems along with a few solved instances for each
problem. These problems are all first order, i.e., they can be instantiated
with problem instances of varying sizes, and most of them are NP-hard,
requiring several reasoning steps to reach the solution. We first observe that
LLMs, even when aided by symbolic solvers, perform rather poorly on our
dataset. In response, we propose a new approach, Puzzle-LM, which combines LLMs
with both symbolic solvers and program interpreters, along with feedback from
solved examples, to achieve huge performance gains. Our extensive
experimentation and analyses offer new insights into the reasoning abilities
and limitations of present-day LLMs.
|
[
-0.2872920334,
-0.7212056518,
0.7948709726,
0.2767440379,
-0.3536283672,
0.3778027892,
-0.0751396194,
-0.5105426311,
0.0448285118,
0.6320922971,
-0.9612261653,
-0.3280563951,
-0.8075934052,
0.3382395506,
-0.3809948862,
0.5569607615,
-0.0117848879,
0.1849244535,
-0.4736572206,
-0.1446965486,
-0.3294126689,
-0.7034685612,
-0.5369933844,
-0.4573538005,
0.5500075817,
0.3223367929,
0.5921295285,
0.6133684516,
0.5752822757,
0.3785463572,
-0.2952017486,
0.3845854402,
-0.7293103933,
0.1858522743,
-0.2115986347,
-0.867703259,
-0.0850069001,
-0.2109992057,
0.2010380626,
0.8828909397,
-0.0808373913,
0.0652079731,
-0.3182273805,
0.6895124912,
-0.3348546624,
0.4246024489,
-0.7377274632,
0.2482919991,
-0.369336009,
-0.0996247455,
-0.3612284958,
-0.2286645919,
-0.171031028,
-0.6229192615,
-0.168992579,
0.274135083,
0.4132837653,
0.5925997496,
-0.3324963152,
-0.4654091299,
-0.8426277041,
0.8467985392,
-0.6083896756,
0.2418982387,
0.2271774858,
0.3625445068,
-0.724761188,
-0.6544399261,
-0.3099283278,
-0.0340093821,
0.0223675333,
-0.121691674,
-0.4821378589,
-0.1938651055,
0.6308142543,
0.1824011803,
-0.5176499486,
0.1579391509,
-0.3420256376,
-0.0803765506,
0.7520420551,
0.6848396063,
0.1605580151,
-0.0098737637,
-0.0948019996,
-0.1450009197,
-0.7202427983,
-0.074838005,
0.2608347237,
0.1271000057,
0.3429610431,
0.6276177764,
-0.1310216039,
0.6738782525,
-0.3175601959,
-0.0774852261,
-0.1600088328,
-0.2240402102,
-0.0137678748,
0.0206709113,
0.5837002397,
0.0038951912,
0.2797489762,
-0.1397618949,
-0.1718235165,
0.1113187596,
-0.0436878912,
-0.6495977044,
-0.5609588027,
0.2601238191,
-0.1317979395,
-0.1781825125,
-0.1135847196,
-0.4411045015,
-0.6696910262,
-0.3109244406,
0.4272861481,
-0.3550276756,
-0.0869118869,
0.2475836426,
-0.0833248645,
0.1362513602,
0.4955329895,
-0.5100173354,
0.4714356959,
1.0276471376,
0.6332322955,
-0.1780986637,
-0.1189551502,
-0.5330473781,
-0.0287470948,
-0.3573326468,
0.6312927008,
-0.4741925001,
-0.4402532578,
-0.3978567421,
-0.1886568367,
0.1605668813,
-0.7888438702,
0.2923136353,
-0.4456649721,
-0.0146686537,
-0.4715807736,
-0.7013815045,
0.1382183284,
0.3600911796,
-0.6841363907,
0.9211117029,
0.0276218876,
-0.6452368498,
-0.2135316283,
-0.3600525558,
-0.4480686188,
0.172388643,
-0.3794403374,
-0.2024934143,
0.3342425525,
0.0907040164,
0.1356001645,
-0.363403827,
0.0618601218,
-0.3133502007,
-0.4367171526,
0.330380559,
-0.0684994534,
0.9067236781,
0.2690064609,
-0.2817315459,
0.1654116362,
-0.6056346893,
0.2912397385,
0.6956344843,
-0.1295494586,
-0.1090164259,
0.2746787369,
-0.3122877181,
0.2097523063,
0.3650845885,
-0.3749542236,
0.4174103439,
-0.2088619918,
0.5973141789,
0.9820462465,
-0.1963251382,
0.0180916358,
-0.2437923551,
0.714443624,
-0.0001530747,
-0.0216659307,
-0.103378661,
-0.6094743609,
-0.8435950875,
-0.0628056377,
0.3412582278,
0.7981516719,
-0.7001717687,
0.0944105536,
-0.2373449653,
-0.4230918288,
0.0150323473,
0.2115102559,
0.2920393348,
0.00078992,
0.1771612167,
-0.0624724217,
-0.6612198949,
-0.7979171276,
-0.2477490604,
-0.1448681206,
-0.0775173008,
0.3736753762,
0.600936234,
0.0425346084,
0.8319277167,
-0.719403863,
0.083162941,
-0.3367605805,
0.2341760546,
0.4078180194,
0.2116692364,
0.1007702202,
-0.5091092587,
-0.2374335974,
-0.0212845914,
-0.6381187439,
-0.2958953083,
0.0351013057,
-0.1103131548,
0.1707334518,
0.6983061433,
-0.600070715,
0.0822726116,
0.3105268478,
-0.2058211416,
0.6628599763,
-0.2105638832,
-0.5363095403,
-0.7673752904,
-0.2287818938,
-0.2756070197,
-0.1497564018,
-0.5047518015,
0.1108953133,
-0.3450188935,
-0.2043784112,
-0.1756638587,
0.5169456005,
-0.4714930952,
-0.0745967552,
-0.1984492689,
0.0635396689,
-0.1945893764,
0.4663384855,
-0.2331626266,
0.4125927687,
0.2881620228,
-0.2318276465,
0.5738459229,
0.2176375091,
-0.4722504318,
0.4529443681,
-0.5371905565,
0.390622139,
-0.2060426623,
0.1686565429,
-0.7574347258,
-0.1744897068,
0.3361595869,
-0.1293032169,
0.1441927552,
0.0616553389,
-0.8466733694,
-0.5298835039,
-0.0436834879,
0.3104268909,
0.3071059883,
-0.4523846209,
0.4467411339,
0.0605873503,
-0.2948231697,
-0.4702406526,
-0.5907062888,
0.2090427876,
-0.09475784,
-0.6185833216,
0.2844749391,
-0.4934055209,
-0.4260315299,
0.0642302856,
-0.5655089617,
-0.0654887185,
0.3544407785,
0.0358732231,
-0.0772524849,
-0.0830380395,
-0.0555260554,
-0.2851049602,
-0.1899221241,
0.3674081862,
-0.0604270212,
0.6402612329,
-0.2340542823,
-0.707801044,
0.1439482719,
0.5646208525,
0.4302808344,
-0.3411804736,
0.4306813776,
0.1262879074,
-0.406946063,
-0.4292419553,
-0.4643481672,
-0.1425279528,
-0.5165382624,
0.4602810144,
-0.5581858754,
-1.0222191811,
0.4727190733,
-0.2450877577,
0.0124039259,
-0.0682155266,
0.5674930811,
-0.1294660419,
1.2781126499,
0.3474645019,
-0.1521451324,
0.1595531851,
-0.1069630831,
0.4867488146,
-0.281237781,
-0.2358264327,
-0.425684154,
-0.5272296071,
-0.5449825525,
-0.4640554488,
0.4821160734,
0.4483852088,
-0.2008184791,
0.1313895732,
-0.4733486474,
0.9457925558,
0.7029357553,
0.1359526813,
0.494903475,
-0.070139952,
-0.2056598663,
0.1141210571,
-0.7629085779,
-0.3135492504,
0.9167187214,
-0.1133422405,
0.6231805086,
0.1704284996,
0.9262635708,
-0.1009066775,
0.0698289573,
-0.7439412475,
0.8671511412,
-0.1465884,
-0.6826866269,
-0.1353246272,
-0.567304492,
-1.1957930326,
0.2948731482,
0.0144234914,
-1.1008585691,
-0.1888903528,
-0.0614909008,
-0.0192432795,
0.2823115289,
-0.3904703557,
0.8925189972,
-0.695649147,
-0.2397424132,
-0.1099235192,
-0.5571757555,
0.5287333131,
0.008540269,
0.3866689801,
-0.1762785017,
0.1505441368,
0.5106214285,
-0.6209851503,
0.6033636928,
0.1495185792,
-0.0342705958,
0.1615221053,
0.5755797029,
0.8152612448,
-0.1996155828,
-0.0071118465,
-0.097581543,
0.2737087905,
-0.4772996902,
-0.7947591543,
0.5966331959,
-0.5023255944,
-1.0750031471,
-0.5254551172,
-0.9130087495,
-0.2491871864,
0.3443140686,
-0.0361272879,
0.1602170169,
0.0275932271,
0.0923743695,
0.5104131103,
0.1522413194,
0.1806488335,
0.2518194616,
-0.4319556057,
-0.2250170708,
1.1660088301,
0.1958136261,
0.0933034942,
0.1025637761,
0.2777622044,
0.0501249097,
-0.9536278248,
-0.1631878912,
0.1561569273,
-0.9903279543,
-0.0608709715,
-0.3730410337,
-0.1974498928,
0.317219913,
-0.029589979,
-0.162343666,
-0.627827704,
-0.0378762558,
0.1725554168,
0.2222522944,
0.8184570074,
-0.0279458724,
0.0937642381,
-0.6560354829,
0.3648160398,
0.4799253345,
0.2950771749,
-0.2411360294,
0.2635006011,
0.0260444768,
-0.1178615391,
-0.2699570358,
-0.975490272,
0.0167033356,
-0.341942668,
0.6586282253,
0.2515745461,
0.0577022322,
0.5703648925,
-0.4022180438,
0.5779726505,
-0.0422126427,
-0.8374859095,
0.3567095399,
-0.4196880758,
0.3039646745,
0.4019579291,
0.2812940776,
-0.3261190951,
-0.3333587646,
-0.5558099151,
-0.7976467609,
0.8781002164,
0.4658152759,
-0.2506489754,
0.0551585108,
0.3219107985,
-0.2005767226,
0.2557750642,
-0.7014166713,
-0.416177243,
0.003391094,
-0.3599674106,
-0.052002918,
-0.1096825153,
-0.3819060624,
-0.3634727597,
0.5463932753,
-0.1222017109,
0.1438263208,
-0.2265516222,
-0.2076387405,
-0.1527290642,
0.3300452232,
0.6655724645,
0.7841988802,
-0.1375386864,
0.1567736715,
0.1987724453,
0.0735946968,
0.0746545494,
0.2624072134,
-0.0189896822,
-0.2359015048,
0.3875821829,
0.5896660089,
0.2383034378,
-0.9638715386,
0.2175460905,
0.0667418465,
-0.277764678,
-0.1389543712,
0.2433229089,
0.5163503885,
0.5204222798,
0.3919835091,
-0.3674225509,
-0.1367389262,
-0.4768011272,
-0.0993168727,
0.8506580591,
0.0616012402,
0.0137836616,
0.5079892278,
-0.0917854756,
-0.6112474799,
0.736756444,
-0.4504454434,
-0.9571589828,
0.9839150906,
0.5638254881,
0.5029187799,
0.1200231686,
0.0458272137,
0.1003923565,
0.630789578,
-0.10611967,
0.5879573822,
-0.0760323778,
-0.6274616122,
-0.4942035675,
-0.4897679389,
-1.0113435984,
0.2062447369,
-0.373863399,
0.0496024862,
-0.6817106605,
0.2169742286,
0.0273380671,
0.1399604231,
-0.5082810521,
-0.2362031192,
0.3872844577,
0.752199769,
-0.3570723832,
0.457773,
0.769484818,
0.0603702217,
-0.5669869781,
-0.4890874624,
0.2864548862,
-0.6382234097,
0.7190166712,
0.2414944321,
-0.0494206361,
0.025714593,
-0.7832247019,
-0.9259704351,
1.0528753996,
0.551487267,
-0.6209927797,
0.0500010215,
0.6456808448,
0.4458287656,
-0.2781914175,
0.2001829594,
0.6211975217,
0.8057727814,
0.1390933096,
-0.8453277349,
0.044957757,
-0.3285781741,
-0.2081411034,
0.4388610125,
-0.6079207659,
0.973157227,
-0.1122175381,
-0.2238177955,
0.2108626068,
0.395878464,
0.6165329814,
0.416516155,
0.6280419827,
0.7602931261,
0.8697624207,
-0.3448068202,
0.9497800469,
-0.2930367291,
0.2271538675,
1.184437871,
-0.4509757757,
0.5328629017,
0.5678221583,
-0.5532683134,
0.5361099243,
0.5814777613,
-0.155262962,
0.1499421149,
0.8814438581,
-0.0626538843,
-0.7763132453,
0.0332844034,
-0.1921681762,
0.281209439,
0.4434965849,
0.2627761066,
-0.5262494683,
-0.2977201641,
-0.1293381453,
-0.0184809156,
-0.1790492982,
0.5066587925,
0.2575773597,
-0.3802477419,
0.4806292951,
0.0329103619,
0.3674102724,
-0.6405744553,
-0.1257339865,
-0.1888370663,
0.252194494,
-0.0971650779,
-0.6591424346,
0.1861185431,
-0.1739594936,
-0.0891447738,
-0.1013391986,
0.6319503784,
-0.0784604773,
-0.7654599547,
0.1393328458,
0.8444833159,
0.0229459237,
-0.0876301005,
-0.6724949479,
0.1994426101,
-0.1787790805,
-0.2815599144,
0.433552444,
0.3558327854,
-0.2393886745,
1.0248615742,
0.6828426719,
-0.2062262595,
0.5337684751,
-0.3811185062,
0.9397249222,
-0.8236703277,
-0.3077119887,
-0.8412293196,
0.203346774,
-0.0760501772,
-0.0759422034,
0.5468615294,
0.4945597053,
0.8765332103,
0.0437037311,
0.5087547302,
0.0654816851,
0.1351019293,
-0.4068817794,
0.1278737634,
-0.5749569535,
0.3958052993,
-0.1038430184,
-0.7592758536,
-0.3901105225,
0.5212615728,
-0.1253864765,
-0.1312117279,
0.7881115079,
0.7927609086,
-0.0711693764,
0.3332831562,
0.0278805606,
0.4121333361,
0.3368001878,
1.0577350855,
1.0609426498,
-0.0500753559,
0.8176907897,
-0.6876127124,
0.1571480781,
-0.1826674491,
-1.0094649792,
-0.9448558092,
-0.1229429394,
-0.2761134803,
-0.2093055695,
-0.0413767882,
0.996779561,
0.2472138107,
-0.6858796477,
-0.2418814451,
-0.3708212674,
0.6309345961,
-0.2795984149,
-0.2175528556,
0.2122217119,
-0.1782873273,
-0.7463110685,
0.7022798061,
0.2710496783,
-0.1110264808,
-0.3252757788,
-0.0559667461,
-0.0271999203,
0.2971249223,
0.6498576403,
0.3107772768,
-0.8140321374,
-0.2114772797,
0.0866758525,
0.1269594729,
0.054545939,
1.0466593504,
-0.6298145652,
0.3666253388,
0.5041722655,
0.6965292096,
0.8079609275,
-0.2422061861,
0.1838264167,
-0.5772542357,
-0.0540837683,
0.2545960546,
0.4940280318,
-0.0479011796,
-0.0418486632,
0.6533372402,
0.1797288507,
-0.3049663007,
-1.1305880547,
0.5971405506,
-1.129031539,
-0.4951870739,
0.8472374082,
0.1307994574,
-0.1913164109,
-0.0143741965,
-0.1384638846,
-0.0208476186,
0.1667266488,
0.5941712856,
0.973977387,
-0.5229756236,
-0.324483037,
-0.4643850625,
0.0943781212,
0.8565992713,
-0.9707824588,
-0.0212028939,
0.5336951017,
0.2012154311,
0.2242838293,
0.4484674037,
0.0875559822,
0.2273308784,
-0.1876702309,
-0.4260368049,
-0.5435971022,
-0.2009702325,
-0.1934668869,
0.2993532717,
0.1195740849,
0.3190634847
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14594v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14594v1
|
Improving Assessment of Tutoring Practices using Retrieval-Augmented Generation
| 2024-02-04T20:42:30 | 2024-02-04T20:42:30 |
Zifei FeiFei Han, Jionghao Lin, Ashish Gurung, Danielle R. Thomas, Eason Chen, Conrad Borchers, Shivang Gupta, Kenneth R. Koedinger
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.IR
|
One-on-one tutoring is an effective instructional method for enhancing
learning, yet its efficacy hinges on tutor competencies. Novice math tutors
often prioritize content-specific guidance, neglecting aspects such as
social-emotional learning. Social-emotional learning promotes equity and
inclusion and nurturing relationships with students, which is crucial for
holistic student development. Assessing the competencies of tutors accurately
and efficiently can drive the development of tailored tutor training programs.
However, evaluating novice tutor ability during real-time tutoring remains
challenging as it typically requires experts-in-the-loop. To address this
challenge, this preliminary study aims to harness Generative Pre-trained
Transformers (GPT), such as GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 models, to automatically assess
tutors' ability of using social-emotional tutoring strategies. Moreover, this
study also reports on the financial dimensions and considerations of employing
these models in real-time and at scale for automated assessment. The current
study examined four prompting strategies: two basic Zero-shot prompt
strategies, Tree of Thought prompt, and Retrieval-Augmented Generator (RAG)
based prompt. The results indicate that the RAG prompt demonstrated more
accurate performance (assessed by the level of hallucination and correctness in
the generated assessment texts) and lower financial costs than the other
strategies evaluated. These findings inform the development of personalized
tutor training interventions to enhance the the educational effectiveness of
tutored learning.
|
[
-0.5234819055,
-0.8765736818,
0.1480646282,
0.4152424932,
-0.0978950635,
0.4688670039,
-0.0489512645,
-0.0603200085,
-0.0081049008,
-0.0354684144,
-0.5956456661,
-0.2064380646,
-0.4216011465,
0.4481221139,
-0.2344354838,
0.7890906334,
-0.0048956731,
0.1517433077,
-0.2730351388,
-0.0156857949,
-0.6767657399,
-0.464052707,
-0.9567832947,
0.2083819807,
0.305447787,
0.4570468068,
0.3229594827,
0.2904429436,
0.4303431213,
0.3573931456,
0.063200213,
0.0395618454,
-0.2996293604,
0.1124572754,
0.0356756672,
-0.3190056086,
-0.4029674232,
0.3600297868,
0.3963202238,
0.4019995034,
-0.1864267588,
0.6020027995,
0.158297509,
0.6392166018,
-0.8602582216,
-0.0179387704,
-0.5375455022,
0.4624023438,
0.121175535,
-0.3431786597,
-0.4708072841,
-0.7761779428,
0.6789995432,
-0.6729581356,
0.6220725179,
-0.2276391238,
0.659719348,
0.3901389241,
-0.1330930889,
-0.4064480662,
-0.417712599,
0.6520564556,
-0.3661959171,
0.2019413412,
0.4081074893,
0.7233471274,
0.4401199222,
-0.6812050939,
-0.2953287065,
-0.2919438183,
-0.1513157189,
0.4605420828,
-0.0428339541,
-0.097507149,
0.4969784617,
0.0917933658,
-0.3342407644,
-0.0983558372,
-0.2221571654,
-0.2578079998,
0.3833913207,
0.0727006793,
0.1427733302,
-0.4356480241,
-0.2313203216,
-0.3301260471,
-0.4405902326,
0.052148439,
0.4979349077,
0.4329844117,
-0.08505743,
0.4374494255,
0.051998321,
0.4962232113,
0.4536424875,
0.0594697781,
0.0761923343,
-0.5471040606,
0.1570240259,
0.2229321301,
0.455468446,
0.1368517131,
0.5142542124,
-0.0836046934,
-0.0714471787,
-0.0576600619,
0.4755725861,
-0.7689626813,
0.0545638651,
-0.1293702871,
-0.1167799681,
-0.4398533106,
0.0301902778,
-1.2727096081,
-0.1417321861,
-0.4990694523,
0.7451348901,
-0.4602565169,
-0.2061809599,
-0.1343123764,
-0.0190460887,
0.3302251995,
0.2277161628,
-0.8444193602,
0.3681548536,
0.4846578538,
0.8933004141,
-0.0378806479,
-0.1490460783,
-0.785210371,
-0.2789528668,
-0.1723240614,
0.6741287708,
-0.365884155,
-0.5264100432,
0.1432297826,
-0.2526385784,
-0.394562155,
-0.4768937826,
0.1916267574,
-0.4246594012,
0.6197751164,
-0.2017956078,
-0.3668912053,
0.0505073369,
0.3896968067,
-0.4533851445,
0.9837770462,
0.7454556227,
-0.6087979674,
0.3902753592,
-0.8358618021,
-0.1947457641,
0.2933296263,
0.0579527058,
-0.4934213161,
-0.0558181405,
0.4329784811,
0.4242160618,
-0.1464881152,
0.0653984323,
0.1986044347,
-0.6812878847,
-0.0808325186,
-0.6765679121,
0.5774827003,
-0.0335643515,
-0.6259287596,
0.0075854268,
-0.5912997127,
0.2192541361,
0.1870550066,
0.0885934681,
-0.1172778904,
-0.4464499652,
-0.3493011296,
-0.1978268176,
0.1573565155,
-0.3235094547,
0.222065255,
-0.4162124991,
0.0706666857,
0.9097129107,
0.2229483873,
0.2991905212,
-0.1395756751,
1.1582901478,
-0.3328275681,
0.2123326808,
-0.5549542904,
-0.151309669,
-0.6577906013,
-0.3044264615,
0.4456082284,
0.7584605813,
-0.795568347,
0.3100405335,
-0.1174899116,
-0.5620387197,
-0.7586297989,
-0.0521266609,
0.6486651301,
0.8136108518,
0.5717740655,
-0.0436390899,
-0.5227498412,
-0.2676547468,
-0.3126071393,
0.0655365959,
-0.1044008285,
0.4227206409,
0.2323304266,
-0.1824851781,
0.9769163132,
-0.3796945512,
-0.2122329026,
-0.0218461528,
0.3930172324,
-0.0776263773,
0.4608297944,
0.6906414032,
-0.6266802549,
-1.0551754236,
-0.1648612022,
-0.6008841395,
-0.1780385822,
-0.2927654088,
-0.0010632648,
0.1602180302,
0.0692044348,
-0.3572404981,
0.6446012259,
0.0309146568,
-0.4045414031,
0.9160196185,
-0.1332826018,
0.5250476003,
-0.6348484159,
-0.1021915376,
-0.0023217513,
-0.037717618,
-0.1907692403,
-0.1081009135,
0.0502620898,
-0.2286415547,
-0.4240928888,
0.651804328,
-0.3994386792,
-0.2087417841,
0.3295133412,
0.2975461781,
-0.1850357503,
0.5027275681,
-0.4546642005,
1.4570571184,
0.5170919299,
-0.3354218602,
0.2056470066,
0.1438438743,
-0.2079763412,
0.9345963001,
-0.8850916028,
0.4242041409,
0.0375639312,
-0.1654855758,
-1.0668143034,
0.1225334555,
0.0785199925,
-0.5447562337,
0.4296201468,
-0.1956408173,
-0.2852845192,
-0.3321341872,
-0.408970654,
0.3108086586,
0.6279726028,
-0.6566219926,
0.7396687269,
-0.2964046896,
-0.4233010709,
-0.560749054,
0.2027499378,
-0.1516595632,
-0.2639757097,
-0.3422237635,
0.1961074769,
-0.0430892743,
-0.1284858286,
-0.0377877057,
-0.3230082393,
0.1264724582,
0.209722653,
0.0261231754,
0.6526694894,
-0.168029815,
-0.1346445531,
0.258127749,
-0.3989225626,
0.1061830595,
0.059995763,
0.5772354603,
-0.2890521884,
-0.4417611659,
-0.4303816557,
-0.1147051975,
0.3101664186,
-0.4460569322,
0.3740921915,
0.8237474561,
-0.0324988179,
0.0326676928,
-0.5949733257,
-0.3588220775,
-0.5095882416,
0.2617052794,
-0.4063595831,
-0.7016321421,
0.4356124997,
-0.1874983311,
-0.0676709488,
0.2649379075,
0.165399313,
-0.03399707,
1.2000305653,
0.2002514899,
0.1860574633,
0.638020575,
-0.6162799597,
0.1519714445,
-0.8876770735,
-0.0834786221,
-0.4550423026,
-0.0430225693,
-0.2656630576,
-0.1798565984,
0.4458671212,
0.0209097881,
-0.4699168801,
0.2598917484,
-0.8365145326,
0.6338886023,
0.4069324136,
0.0962693766,
-0.0010196537,
0.1430615932,
-0.3000136912,
-0.2300290465,
-0.4623711109,
-0.5611999631,
1.1753932238,
0.1657938659,
0.2760383487,
-0.1352122128,
0.6689015031,
0.2667242885,
0.8053481579,
-0.7712193131,
0.5740692616,
0.2115968317,
-0.4011495113,
-0.4893063307,
-0.5496892929,
-0.8386460543,
0.200491488,
-0.2538051307,
-0.4801964462,
-0.1804785728,
0.0516633317,
-0.6668020487,
-0.0348842442,
-1.035017848,
0.8851611614,
-0.3595802188,
-0.42408517,
-0.1701094061,
-0.496024996,
-0.0271785296,
-0.4086284935,
-0.1799804866,
0.1881707162,
0.0117117129,
0.6827204227,
-0.1972068101,
0.63329494,
-0.5710543394,
0.152841568,
0.5141271949,
0.293394655,
0.3454637229,
-0.0525232479,
-0.1606018841,
-0.1696380377,
0.2430420369,
-0.5333636999,
-1.008420825,
0.3320418894,
-0.8051949739,
-0.6987864971,
-0.2810922265,
-0.2117920369,
-0.575070858,
-0.0671872124,
0.1598371267,
0.571301043,
-0.1903750598,
0.0216932632,
0.4931258261,
-0.0865646452,
0.280200243,
0.4998369515,
0.0134209488,
-0.5782805085,
1.1399673223,
0.2980336249,
0.3478498757,
0.0044720112,
0.4184768796,
-0.4334841967,
-0.0573917143,
-0.4052867591,
0.1945066303,
-0.5391037464,
-0.2566387653,
-0.4402796924,
-0.0297395419,
-0.6508470774,
-0.5571480393,
-0.1223096251,
-0.326808542,
-0.4586498737,
-0.4521915615,
0.2186050713,
0.3609156311,
-0.0500246845,
0.4092431664,
-0.7750875354,
0.1737826765,
0.7625243664,
0.19603917,
0.3732815683,
-0.5952009559,
0.0118356375,
-0.0401315428,
-0.3498494923,
-0.6935460567,
0.3232977688,
0.1154265329,
0.3932811916,
0.3884502053,
-0.0635992959,
0.924780488,
-0.5145281553,
0.6300993562,
0.0653628334,
-0.9972501397,
0.5014507174,
-0.0872416794,
0.0618622936,
0.7328753471,
0.5517451763,
-0.1457211822,
0.0582653172,
-0.6313285232,
-0.530582428,
0.4914877415,
-0.1110029891,
0.2866377532,
-0.0673309043,
0.6186208725,
0.1160464808,
0.1676598191,
-0.112573266,
-0.162440747,
-0.6305248141,
-0.3813739717,
0.1509347409,
-0.194408983,
0.108375147,
-0.4738381803,
0.3756891191,
-0.2761920691,
0.2624526918,
0.1883645952,
0.2153354138,
-0.1573777348,
0.1360869408,
0.3377220631,
0.6058802605,
-0.1988880783,
-0.2268574685,
0.3488126695,
-0.7195946574,
0.375767082,
0.2349182069,
-0.0948381647,
-0.0731222034,
0.4568373859,
0.5818681717,
0.3917361796,
-0.6589208245,
0.5309228897,
-0.2078266591,
-0.1400060654,
-0.3272122145,
0.1859882176,
-0.3584596217,
-0.0479051061,
0.5996403694,
0.0178847425,
-0.1156936288,
-0.2308291793,
0.1578700095,
0.3390417993,
-0.3896086812,
-0.4371795058,
0.2731449902,
0.2417937517,
-0.6189043522,
0.8314781785,
-0.4031360149,
-0.7102258205,
0.759568572,
0.7102736831,
1.0757181644,
-0.4218680859,
0.6354131103,
0.6673396826,
0.0551645122,
0.2553633749,
0.068427138,
-0.3868122697,
-0.4369769096,
-0.452444315,
-0.3773709238,
-0.626055479,
-0.4371418357,
-0.9033743143,
0.2154708654,
-0.4936264157,
-0.1447095275,
-0.2362614572,
0.3168527186,
-0.7809064984,
0.0794817433,
-0.3713762462,
0.7853946686,
-0.5359210968,
0.1474008113,
0.6416615248,
-0.5370277166,
-0.9451348782,
-0.2067194134,
-0.0961241797,
-0.7622585297,
0.841683805,
0.2266501039,
0.0000640127,
0.5317729115,
-0.5691008568,
-0.6455382705,
0.9978305697,
0.1920655817,
-0.354131639,
-0.3877518475,
0.023188537,
0.6483592391,
-0.2541534305,
0.582672298,
0.4486956,
0.4282681346,
0.2458197176,
-0.6753675938,
-0.1193787903,
-0.1722797304,
-0.2080618739,
0.0517219678,
-0.2910432816,
0.6293645501,
-0.3742925823,
-0.430823952,
0.0929780304,
0.4632083178,
0.4213829041,
0.4710672796,
0.5636577606,
0.4576433003,
0.6463860273,
-0.1366755664,
0.9518294334,
-0.33558622,
0.3226091862,
0.8624745607,
-0.1549793482,
0.6246654987,
0.3872096241,
-0.5535435677,
0.4893920422,
0.4810581803,
-0.1166356206,
0.2658275068,
0.2018232048,
-0.4231882095,
-0.0912006274,
-0.0813560039,
-0.246438995,
-0.026552638,
0.3267512619,
0.1842698902,
-0.1924332976,
0.2873393297,
-0.0644023865,
0.2439644188,
-0.2572115362,
0.761023581,
-0.1851069778,
-0.7309378386,
0.5337206125,
-0.5447009802,
0.5975764394,
-0.557286799,
-0.2729508579,
-0.3987865746,
-0.0572713315,
-0.0854774565,
-0.3533955812,
-0.0333328955,
0.3516184986,
0.2162171453,
-0.2508995533,
0.5547161102,
-0.21842511,
-0.4292252362,
0.0038914997,
0.6910677552,
-0.1020668671,
0.005118907,
-0.6729952693,
-0.3724370003,
-0.1794906408,
-0.261903882,
0.4127402306,
0.5037186146,
0.1966895014,
0.7050924301,
0.7266391516,
0.1007641628,
0.1107782945,
0.2508866787,
0.5538420081,
-0.4988693893,
-0.048031006,
-0.6366326809,
0.4719225168,
0.0738731623,
-0.3505316675,
1.0107381344,
0.3074872494,
0.7061655521,
-0.1022823378,
0.5023559928,
0.0947114527,
0.7030299902,
-0.1181073263,
0.449582696,
-0.2684334815,
-0.0108830659,
-0.5948170424,
-0.898655653,
-0.0671477914,
0.8244680166,
-0.4419945776,
0.0959267765,
0.4344561398,
0.5251933336,
0.2189075649,
0.0758665353,
0.1058204547,
-0.2775541842,
0.4161723256,
0.1234330386,
1.0233479738,
-0.4360355437,
0.3195806146,
-0.389485836,
-0.3093333542,
0.0116284257,
-0.6116952896,
-0.966050446,
-0.308314085,
-0.4337212741,
-0.2419852316,
-0.0058513577,
1.0394407511,
0.4036274552,
-0.4793201983,
0.0079346364,
-0.0779361054,
-0.0355464481,
-0.3220697343,
-0.3246105611,
0.59611094,
-0.7217528224,
-0.6392436028,
0.2345237285,
-0.030905474,
0.4136331677,
-0.5287734866,
0.0442779027,
0.1185360998,
0.1419110745,
0.7427922487,
0.1329436451,
-0.2638307512,
-0.3185037673,
0.5801508427,
-0.053713847,
-0.2158257216,
0.5766249895,
-1.136582613,
0.6207943559,
0.3024031222,
0.8655049205,
0.2656632066,
0.5066691637,
0.3633593321,
-0.4715340137,
-0.1458563954,
0.409486562,
0.0026065421,
0.2411521971,
-0.3702843189,
0.8263545036,
0.2943581641,
-0.511903882,
-0.9094806314,
-0.2926721275,
-0.4702638686,
0.2284436375,
0.6134981513,
-0.4597666264,
0.0525046065,
0.0973177999,
-0.6465835571,
0.3159712851,
-0.172266081,
1.0277625322,
0.6175895333,
-0.0234031621,
-0.1396249235,
-0.3744822443,
0.4830872715,
0.7789407372,
-0.6919496059,
-0.1412189156,
0.3014812768,
-0.093700923,
0.4760019779,
0.5055282116,
-0.068365328,
0.4207225442,
-0.1193048432,
-0.2651463747,
-0.2030436844,
-0.3482800722,
-0.3468216062,
0.1665560454,
-0.4685781896,
-0.0516274013
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02591v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02591v1
|
On the performance of phonetic algorithms in microtext normalization
| 2024-02-04T19:54:44 | 2024-02-04T19:54:44 |
Yerai Doval, Manuel Vilares, Jesús Vilares
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
User-generated content published on microblogging social networks constitutes
a priceless source of information. However, microtexts usually deviate from the
standard lexical and grammatical rules of the language, thus making its
processing by traditional intelligent systems very difficult. As an answer,
microtext normalization consists in transforming those non-standard microtexts
into standard well-written texts as a preprocessing step, allowing traditional
approaches to continue with their usual processing. Given the importance of
phonetic phenomena in non-standard text formation, an essential element of the
knowledge base of a normalizer would be the phonetic rules that encode these
phenomena, which can be found in the so-called phonetic algorithms.
In this work we experiment with a wide range of phonetic algorithms for the
English language. The aim of this study is to determine the best phonetic
algorithms within the context of candidate generation for microtext
normalization. In other words, we intend to find those algorithms that taking
as input non-standard terms to be normalized allow us to obtain as output the
smallest possible sets of normalization candidates which still contain the
corresponding target standard words. As it will be stated, the choice of the
phonetic algorithm will depend heavily on the capabilities of the candidate
selection mechanism which we usually find at the end of a microtext
normalization pipeline. The faster it can make the right choices among big
enough sets of candidates, the more we can sacrifice on the precision of the
phonetic algorithms in favour of coverage in order to increase the overall
performance of the normalization system.
KEYWORDS: microtext normalization; phonetic algorithm; fuzzy matching;
Twitter; texting
|
[
-0.3399897218,
-0.5092520714,
0.4947692752,
0.334846735,
-0.4946923256,
-0.078158401,
-0.6594460011,
-0.3563218415,
0.5893335938,
0.1990808398,
-0.4562415481,
-0.5520929694,
-0.3661272526,
0.6064887047,
-0.1930230707,
0.5905854702,
0.1561635882,
0.0041136523,
0.2784263492,
-0.0920076668,
-0.4136700928,
-0.4117953181,
-0.8114302754,
-0.2188734561,
0.6282353997,
0.6309835315,
0.8153496385,
0.8258149028,
0.4244607389,
0.2916102111,
-0.4124957919,
-0.123050563,
-0.4388240278,
0.118812941,
-0.0348291434,
-0.4219774902,
0.0732129738,
0.0500197858,
0.711635232,
0.6460085511,
-0.1315856874,
0.2731328309,
0.0852340683,
0.5685740709,
-0.349770993,
-0.0619991794,
-0.7464255691,
-0.0702143535,
-0.6767503619,
-0.430849582,
-0.0411778428,
-0.5549869537,
-0.0467443168,
-0.588696897,
0.3618066609,
0.0962001458,
0.7158412933,
-0.1649460644,
0.1031815484,
-0.8225411773,
-0.8879667521,
0.9087603688,
-0.5821259618,
0.5967137218,
0.0773946643,
0.4475242198,
-0.1367198527,
-0.4649958014,
-0.568890214,
-0.0469404384,
0.1239805594,
-0.0332164355,
-0.1551541537,
0.3757932186,
0.0553917028,
0.3614115417,
-0.3166853487,
0.3709179163,
-0.520929873,
-0.4395506084,
0.4549126029,
-0.1750643402,
0.4403252006,
-0.3314857483,
0.2197617292,
-0.2876462042,
-0.2775318027,
0.2736927569,
0.4103709459,
0.6917816401,
0.112368986,
0.6083446741,
-0.3792154789,
0.2820869386,
-0.0217327233,
-0.4649391174,
0.0544367507,
-0.3091742098,
-0.2091950774,
0.2252282053,
0.7024389505,
0.3397651315,
0.6571148038,
-0.2985841632,
-0.4352898002,
0.1283199489,
-0.0329259373,
-0.7124653459,
-0.0187144987,
0.1710663885,
-0.6466876864,
-0.4978882372,
-0.108310461,
-0.6655637026,
0.0325312093,
-0.4128628075,
0.4284394979,
-0.562335372,
-0.042018272,
0.0105401967,
-0.3807403147,
-0.027971223,
0.1046042964,
-1.1023957729,
0.4872006476,
0.6511140466,
0.6830581427,
0.2987343371,
-0.1107328087,
-0.1433586627,
-0.0258282125,
-0.5429790616,
0.7544084191,
-0.4803781509,
-0.1711121202,
0.2198974639,
-0.2847467363,
-0.1893732399,
-0.7607195973,
0.8257815838,
-0.5683546066,
-0.0060631013,
-0.2915380299,
-0.7696825862,
-0.0536652841,
-0.095154047,
-0.5225075483,
0.8096096516,
-0.3164339066,
-0.6770340204,
0.5164619088,
-0.6352810264,
-0.6759095192,
-0.0161858816,
-0.3147926927,
-0.0677291751,
0.3148306906,
0.1669186205,
0.6660076976,
-0.3647429943,
-0.1654743701,
0.103566967,
-0.7180091143,
0.0633625463,
-0.2554142773,
0.9045220017,
0.2516480982,
-0.511531353,
-0.2177980095,
-0.7051153779,
0.0632345974,
0.201789856,
-0.4935605228,
-0.5622962713,
0.034286797,
0.1073688418,
-0.1665015668,
0.0431132503,
-0.7752797604,
-0.2265846729,
-0.6572149992,
0.4497546852,
0.7309390903,
-0.112357311,
0.7318409085,
-0.2914613187,
0.3521478474,
-0.2327426672,
0.0982925743,
0.1516446322,
-0.7724764943,
-0.3697468936,
-0.2644832432,
0.9485111237,
0.6618412733,
-0.6034366488,
0.1145761237,
-0.2728516161,
-0.5750432611,
-0.8588857055,
0.3733711243,
0.3396402001,
0.2570822239,
0.0942679942,
0.1822105348,
-0.5988942981,
-0.9603109956,
-0.4797170162,
-0.1529887319,
-0.2002272457,
0.3334574103,
-0.0796813816,
-0.4554463923,
0.5761837363,
-0.1507968009,
-0.3360579014,
-0.0632549077,
0.0458306745,
0.1946232766,
0.2127081901,
0.6526104808,
-0.7592489719,
-0.4730221927,
0.044460576,
-0.5672628284,
-0.251776278,
0.0752710029,
0.1440443695,
0.3307728171,
0.5382352471,
-0.3353563845,
0.2860472798,
0.5330696106,
0.0770615861,
0.3992629051,
-0.1776769906,
0.2712511718,
-0.8505083919,
-0.2029851824,
0.0323097222,
-0.0000804635,
-0.7740270495,
0.0346574187,
0.0162216555,
-0.0327375531,
-0.2012712806,
0.379778415,
-0.4093802571,
0.1520172805,
0.0283634178,
0.4128367305,
-0.4326685369,
0.1610269845,
-0.3387331665,
0.8304719925,
0.3998713791,
-0.7429138422,
0.0549547076,
-0.1198253036,
-0.150636673,
0.1805485189,
-0.4453904927,
0.1362372637,
-0.052123744,
-0.2471137941,
-1.2758779526,
-0.146737352,
0.0255720168,
-0.6424735785,
0.0516867191,
0.1525007039,
-0.8545274734,
-0.1728449017,
-0.4577465355,
0.3497255743,
0.7259585261,
-0.4367949665,
0.3067776561,
0.4054509401,
-0.1564436704,
-0.1618733406,
-0.4844750762,
0.1815549284,
-0.1238990575,
-0.8344348669,
0.3890645504,
0.2171358913,
-0.3767275214,
-0.0821002722,
0.0326276273,
-0.0277094357,
-0.0719154775,
-0.0953581631,
-0.2056836337,
-0.3893501163,
0.1905614287,
0.552854538,
0.0190762468,
-0.1338763088,
-0.3286629319,
0.4318963885,
0.1810899228,
0.2712006271,
-0.6344396472,
0.3058196902,
0.3578246236,
0.0355106406,
0.63804847,
0.5783286095,
-0.6504067779,
-0.1382286698,
-0.7798786759,
-0.2139377296,
-0.4895303249,
-0.1150344759,
-0.5926173329,
-0.9269529581,
0.6315338016,
0.0098667173,
-0.0159355775,
0.6360766292,
0.3906928599,
-0.2985697687,
0.8515400887,
0.5258946419,
-0.1032424793,
0.3434267044,
0.0846559331,
0.2106144875,
-0.4286312759,
0.1501675844,
-0.8149956465,
-0.4142743647,
-1.180907011,
-0.2839446664,
0.2047773004,
-0.0691109523,
0.3602109551,
0.4070606828,
-0.6480074525,
0.434379518,
0.757268548,
0.0214848425,
0.1291967779,
0.5450340509,
-0.5408611894,
-0.1889950484,
-0.6880610585,
-0.675481379,
0.9367707968,
0.3222611248,
0.4824608862,
0.1340652257,
1.1592624187,
0.2577088177,
-0.0849164501,
-0.7295251489,
0.6899225712,
-0.6194107533,
-0.3358405828,
-0.701531589,
-0.5528425574,
-1.0058163404,
-0.1420293301,
-0.3332892358,
-0.5810425282,
0.26390329,
0.0398273617,
-0.3452872634,
0.2995352447,
-0.7085194588,
0.4168693125,
0.3211869597,
0.2430880219,
-0.2477925867,
-0.5527855158,
-0.1057737023,
-0.1067658514,
0.262971729,
0.0789028853,
-0.0766956881,
1.1570574045,
0.0325646102,
0.5741578341,
-0.3000018001,
0.1257506609,
0.2960622013,
0.1539434046,
0.0550076552,
-0.1814124435,
-0.1152121797,
0.2979175448,
0.2587454021,
-0.2973249555,
-0.3800660074,
0.4191016555,
-0.7031576037,
-0.3604232669,
0.0475531146,
-0.1424841732,
-0.0101110097,
0.5390837789,
0.6679390669,
0.402757138,
-0.3778109252,
0.1385277063,
0.6575306654,
-0.0595551766,
0.2900846601,
0.0773871839,
-0.0867108032,
-0.4681641459,
1.1056560278,
0.7397766113,
-0.1119641662,
0.5576853156,
0.4782300293,
-0.2298348844,
-0.9139819145,
-0.4322830737,
0.387362361,
-0.5644711256,
-0.1124802753,
-0.4204604328,
-0.1749784052,
-0.8283027411,
-0.1873096675,
-0.1528663933,
-0.6256926656,
-0.3674958646,
0.2012435049,
-0.0484322943,
0.687872231,
-0.0443215929,
0.0505440533,
-0.6134771109,
0.4499762952,
0.3814633191,
0.210765034,
-0.2904331684,
-0.3386979997,
-0.1852767169,
0.1522681266,
-0.0587516502,
-0.8136354089,
-0.2311183661,
0.1756958067,
0.4884834886,
0.6114379168,
-0.0419669189,
0.6393847466,
-0.7338541746,
0.3815436959,
-0.1553563923,
-0.7711062431,
0.4571463168,
-0.4658430219,
-0.0774025619,
0.7253869176,
0.206500113,
-0.7854559422,
-0.6211510897,
-0.7168761492,
-0.4906054735,
0.3050450385,
0.6344998479,
0.157382071,
-0.1883726418,
0.7661019564,
-0.1003553867,
0.1716308296,
-0.0474841073,
-0.0369250253,
0.2337662876,
-0.3598097563,
-0.2256197929,
-0.5361399651,
0.0794985443,
-0.2160385549,
0.4489094317,
0.1360916346,
0.4847688675,
0.3797409832,
0.0605537072,
-0.1306427717,
0.3627663255,
0.8529778719,
0.377019912,
-0.3770209253,
-0.0425997749,
0.1006293446,
-0.7055251002,
0.1319846362,
0.1466670483,
-0.4003793597,
0.3357577622,
0.3199994564,
0.2918005586,
0.2703806162,
-0.6261999011,
0.3947063684,
-0.2042375952,
-0.4179328978,
-0.2417495251,
0.0707754046,
0.0490956232,
0.0533636101,
0.2888340354,
0.3246253133,
0.5436011553,
-0.5625204444,
0.1554846764,
0.366239965,
-0.1892347634,
-0.4883641005,
0.5098800659,
0.1561949849,
-0.8429987431,
0.4262518585,
-0.3683488667,
-0.4257625937,
0.5476904511,
0.3769008517,
0.9732493758,
-0.4383169413,
0.1172069311,
0.1320286542,
0.5547297597,
-0.1423627734,
0.2375651151,
0.0468430929,
-0.8979744315,
-0.0547004417,
-0.6235019565,
-0.4075407982,
-0.22446841,
-0.4200947583,
0.3281105161,
-0.7487761974,
-0.2822444737,
0.2664828002,
-0.0370357409,
-0.6974182129,
0.4534220099,
0.2585889101,
1.1004754305,
-0.659335196,
0.4498927295,
0.8664318323,
0.0771031082,
-1.1042075157,
0.2611204684,
-0.0015927942,
-0.6230647564,
0.2576572001,
0.1878444403,
-0.2597799897,
-0.0503846742,
-0.1485978365,
-0.3804277778,
0.8973738551,
0.3920550048,
-0.4656509459,
-0.1597741693,
0.3212779462,
0.8147923946,
-0.3219577074,
0.0153002134,
0.786737144,
0.3921222389,
-0.1023757383,
-1.0580043793,
0.1174035445,
-0.0768236294,
0.3634483516,
0.1176079214,
-0.6986132264,
0.9518936872,
0.0697941184,
-0.4616836607,
0.1147057042,
0.4583700597,
0.0435330011,
0.3742710352,
0.6845875978,
0.346295625,
0.9037755728,
0.0355084538,
0.8651320338,
-0.2244763374,
0.0864045992,
0.3526176214,
0.0455389358,
0.9628763795,
0.5477865338,
-0.1730137169,
0.1538756192,
0.6909521818,
0.2775557041,
0.3746885657,
0.1716822386,
-0.1054766923,
0.217143625,
0.1537929922,
0.0660429895,
0.5912988782,
0.0088646626,
-0.3302549124,
-0.0460793041,
0.0708884522,
0.061716482,
0.2611819208,
-0.3266613781,
1.0485078096,
-0.2453731745,
-0.5070542097,
0.5823850632,
0.3581289947,
0.8283637762,
-0.1688584983,
0.0570118055,
-0.1552241594,
0.0382932313,
-0.1742568761,
-0.495311141,
0.2739187777,
-0.2310726792,
-0.2615425587,
0.0211212896,
1.0779750347,
-0.0954011157,
-0.6801927686,
0.4812163413,
0.3002571166,
0.2443350852,
-0.2489236891,
-0.3908123374,
-0.1124177799,
0.0712689012,
0.0944316387,
0.1235517859,
0.8638318181,
0.0043981425,
0.2527396381,
0.5262469649,
0.3990870714,
0.3639165759,
0.0840672627,
0.7492049336,
-0.6666101217,
-0.5961318016,
-0.7991557121,
-0.0362043455,
0.07622502,
-0.2373624295,
0.7492071986,
0.5514483452,
0.8787027001,
0.0338162035,
0.5371770859,
0.1547629237,
0.8502206206,
-0.6320774555,
0.8157082796,
-0.495379895,
0.1052486673,
-0.5306324363,
-1.0180498362,
-0.4026494324,
0.5009604692,
-0.1367597431,
-0.0532818362,
0.5881292224,
0.8569360375,
-0.1611988991,
0.2699158192,
0.3686563969,
-0.036296837,
0.1456229985,
-0.0854776353,
0.3096373677,
-0.5566029549,
0.6934981346,
-0.6620647311,
-0.5010242462,
-0.342740804,
-0.4577012956,
-0.8975325823,
-0.6110172272,
0.0869198069,
-0.0914318115,
0.1743524522,
0.9468072057,
0.4070680439,
-0.7247647643,
-0.5144332051,
0.0747901574,
0.1837425679,
-0.3401445746,
-0.2406078279,
0.1818653047,
-0.57640028,
-0.6914513707,
0.1849703193,
0.1552735567,
0.042642992,
0.1820016056,
0.1032428518,
-0.1188094839,
0.592543304,
0.577659905,
0.1376098096,
-0.4817681611,
-0.3947902918,
0.2384666651,
-0.1746256799,
0.2078612894,
0.7663265467,
-0.2377404124,
0.3236528039,
0.4660289884,
0.6583516002,
-0.033393506,
-0.1497062892,
0.2700896263,
-0.7422937751,
0.1914538145,
0.2608680129,
0.1636686027,
0.2335691154,
-0.3785623908,
0.3667641878,
0.3048998415,
-0.5511988997,
-0.7567074299,
-0.1269040257,
-0.7347441912,
-0.0623498037,
1.1508631706,
0.4724988937,
-0.4382696152,
0.0473018549,
-0.3492196202,
0.3121243119,
-0.5481168032,
0.7473195791,
0.7584004998,
-0.0516424924,
-0.0185667351,
-0.4753502309,
0.7443298101,
0.3896228969,
-0.0446030237,
-0.3524051309,
-0.0982812792,
0.419374615,
0.6123745441,
0.9332504272,
0.0535867624,
0.2326861918,
0.0029862495,
-0.0876239687,
0.3555434644,
-0.3355703354,
-0.2881631255,
0.1460076123,
0.1175419986,
-0.370709151
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02572v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02572v1
|
A Quantitative Discourse Analysis of Asian Workers in the US Historical Newspapers
| 2024-02-04T17:32:52 | 2024-02-04T17:32:52 |
Jaihyun Park, Ryan Cordell
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Warning: This paper contains examples of offensive language targetting
marginalized population. The digitization of historical texts invites
researchers to explore the large-scale corpus of historical texts with
computational methods. In this study, we present computational text analysis on
a relatively understudied topic of how Asian workers are represented in
historical newspapers in the United States. We found that the word "coolie" was
semantically different in some States (e.g., Massachusetts, Rhode Island,
Wyoming, Oklahoma, and Arkansas) with the different discourses around coolie.
We also found that then-Confederate newspapers and then-Union newspapers formed
distinctive discourses by measuring over-represented words. Newspapers from
then-Confederate States associated coolie with slavery-related words. In
addition, we found Asians were perceived to be inferior to European immigrants
and subjected to the target of racism. This study contributes to supplementing
the qualitative analysis of racism in the United States with quantitative
discourse analysis.
|
[
-0.1059096083,
-0.7396720052,
0.421099335,
0.0861586407,
-0.3613087833,
0.199359566,
-0.0923593044,
-0.4857971966,
0.6619586945,
0.2990859747,
-0.089438118,
-0.401096344,
-0.438455224,
0.297234267,
-0.2804986238,
0.9056098461,
-0.0967952013,
-0.0057562497,
0.1857692152,
-0.4762413502,
-0.1967983395,
-0.7236466408,
-0.224692151,
0.2373946905,
0.1850567758,
0.2383070439,
1.1195275784,
0.8063650727,
0.6194391251,
0.4324855208,
-0.1048348397,
-0.5888007879,
-0.6524595618,
0.2491501272,
-0.2666884065,
-0.6537296772,
-0.1468152702,
0.2949822247,
0.3959718645,
0.7043161392,
0.2709074914,
0.453602016,
-0.4172290266,
0.567078948,
-0.9679697156,
-0.0615976788,
-0.7000928521,
0.0952181295,
-0.6511508822,
-0.170932129,
-0.3016600013,
-0.6456392407,
-0.3149034083,
-0.5507901311,
0.2774609923,
-0.2258193493,
1.0806293488,
0.0633908436,
-0.7324874997,
-0.215277195,
-0.7644090652,
0.9349423647,
-0.6229077578,
0.0920674801,
0.3762767017,
0.0776326284,
0.033243183,
-0.6289384365,
-0.659932375,
-0.0504632778,
-0.5153774619,
0.3754210472,
-0.3686898947,
-0.2103630602,
0.4689490199,
0.5615642071,
-0.7410921454,
0.3233851492,
-0.7327837348,
-0.2809650302,
0.6698252559,
0.5086355209,
0.6303939819,
-0.3632497787,
-0.2090745419,
0.0747207776,
-0.0719516128,
0.0354340747,
0.5051962137,
0.261297524,
-0.1774028391,
0.5302252769,
-0.2037682235,
0.1813156456,
-0.2701167464,
-0.3138945103,
0.176165238,
-0.2313063741,
-0.0033289455,
-0.2565261424,
0.8861154914,
0.5795913935,
0.4309799075,
-0.1345170438,
0.0208858158,
0.3062090874,
0.0729950741,
-0.7996732593,
-0.0210473966,
0.1067518294,
-0.7537255883,
0.0991243422,
-0.0477358811,
-0.9243050218,
-0.4671100676,
0.0131586427,
-0.4534125328,
0.0139476303,
-0.4002259374,
-0.5352063179,
-0.7400920391,
0.2205753177,
-0.1286729723,
-0.7937658429,
0.1624224782,
0.6656168103,
0.7047529221,
-0.2195702493,
-0.1122464687,
0.1531767398,
0.2736847401,
-0.5620242953,
0.4101754725,
-0.7060860991,
-0.6008049846,
0.2672540843,
-0.0558196343,
0.1503073424,
-0.5307472944,
0.744386971,
-0.8076881766,
0.2990534902,
-0.2555432916,
-0.1740740389,
-0.1011965647,
-0.0668184981,
-0.8932923675,
0.9060482979,
0.4528267384,
-1.1186939478,
0.5927353501,
-0.0471253321,
-0.4772720337,
0.2549450994,
-0.5717597008,
-0.4220280647,
0.2452957928,
-0.1389035285,
0.1639873087,
-0.1094011888,
0.1986502111,
-0.2211428136,
-0.6752176881,
0.1570153534,
-0.0511340052,
1.5180530548,
0.28011325,
-0.4619901776,
-0.1747596264,
-0.6033024192,
-0.3123405874,
0.1912020743,
-0.0437327959,
-0.979983449,
-0.4126523733,
-0.1372877061,
-0.1833204478,
0.1675518155,
-0.8147013187,
0.0693462938,
-0.1778203994,
-0.0851496011,
0.3777487576,
0.0373926982,
0.5914738774,
-0.1190546006,
0.7298627496,
-0.1513998806,
-0.127308324,
-0.2734840512,
-0.1827451736,
-0.473012805,
0.0224457346,
0.032855507,
0.9868429899,
-0.8248480558,
-0.2032725811,
-0.4648646414,
-0.4399609268,
-0.1170517877,
-0.3509971499,
0.2202813327,
0.2395148128,
0.1432959437,
-0.1517377943,
-0.7776031494,
-1.0278894901,
-0.5487936139,
-0.6736101508,
-0.1460220516,
0.1291929632,
0.3369314373,
0.1149944216,
0.9250998497,
-0.7253698707,
-0.1749786437,
0.431723237,
0.5419341922,
0.0717936829,
0.1590917706,
0.7569007277,
-0.8943958282,
-0.7087248564,
0.119950071,
-0.7799440026,
0.1127134487,
-0.2789763212,
-0.2575840652,
0.2557295561,
0.8123673797,
-0.3789818883,
0.790769577,
0.2995728552,
-0.2367985994,
0.6196889877,
0.289349407,
0.4328453541,
-1.1142046452,
0.2122519016,
0.0190574508,
0.2811932862,
-0.428407371,
0.177047506,
-0.0435665175,
-0.4636228681,
-0.3903214335,
0.4059084356,
-0.4152781963,
0.2219474614,
-0.15772596,
0.1606398076,
-0.2948065996,
0.4186802506,
0.0725517645,
0.6135314107,
0.0327969603,
-0.1781307906,
0.2094130218,
-0.0860237926,
0.0550200045,
0.6480892897,
-0.1453695148,
0.1390401274,
-0.4852916598,
0.2169099748,
-1.1406896114,
0.0183090232,
0.0312110409,
-0.5163675547,
-0.1444108933,
0.1107989922,
-0.2587784827,
-0.6189094782,
-0.5079547167,
0.744684875,
0.1447345614,
0.0254905745,
0.4182857275,
0.8526229262,
-0.3310272992,
-0.6687082648,
-0.8174182773,
0.2532604337,
-0.6472734213,
-0.3296219707,
0.2915876508,
0.2659425735,
-0.8402083516,
0.0559866279,
0.3374508917,
-0.886456728,
-0.0270809624,
0.1453415602,
0.3963167369,
-0.4908397794,
0.0773881748,
-0.0888209194,
0.0643235296,
0.3805034161,
0.3997600675,
0.0122644594,
0.281835705,
0.4393351376,
-0.6931877732,
0.6625375152,
0.4738348722,
-0.1599062979,
0.6975404024,
0.7017713189,
-0.3264455199,
0.3043007553,
-0.3573544919,
-0.4040849209,
-0.4176579118,
0.4765361845,
-0.2393187135,
-1.0338704586,
0.6759518385,
0.0626667291,
0.3498974741,
0.5995107889,
0.26109308,
-0.0120961685,
0.5689924359,
0.6129037738,
-0.4352465272,
0.4059391618,
0.0081250928,
0.1412034035,
-0.221106723,
0.0822408199,
-1.1197116375,
-0.3074686825,
-1.1481388807,
-0.1208847985,
0.1094030961,
-0.1643058658,
-0.4411287308,
0.1905489266,
-0.3628566563,
0.5118734241,
0.0479717217,
-0.4008486867,
0.3524939418,
-0.1571055502,
0.262154758,
-0.5730242729,
-0.3161174655,
-0.6510155797,
0.6226171851,
0.1950387508,
0.5155348182,
0.2765043378,
0.553407073,
0.4369615018,
0.6329375505,
-0.684464395,
0.5345823765,
-0.639036715,
-0.7016870975,
-0.369903028,
-0.5886637568,
-1.1761655807,
0.3548384309,
-0.0959850028,
-0.904405117,
0.4346696436,
-0.034653835,
-0.5484681129,
0.3465675116,
-0.4960884154,
0.5387669802,
-0.1085793599,
0.0060122353,
-0.1706859767,
-0.5162886977,
0.8146487474,
0.1087848991,
0.7393246889,
-0.2216396183,
-0.3197768927,
0.7055462003,
-0.3384035528,
1.0005780458,
-0.0109941224,
-0.0910480246,
0.4817264378,
0.2700526714,
0.1610790044,
-0.251979053,
-0.4336617887,
0.2457548082,
0.1858339906,
-0.5806538463,
-0.3572296202,
0.4566272497,
-0.6080819368,
-0.5538684726,
-0.4093081653,
-0.557682693,
0.1910603046,
0.3551752865,
0.32894665,
0.2364147305,
-0.3780041039,
-0.1399138719,
0.1209676266,
0.0859664902,
0.6918786168,
0.290686518,
-0.181340903,
-0.1683339328,
0.8190099597,
0.3964340091,
-0.2968470454,
0.312051326,
0.11952582,
0.099077791,
-0.0411178358,
-0.4581794143,
0.4169998765,
-0.5267202258,
-0.1138376221,
-0.5154213309,
0.1619769931,
-0.3623121977,
-0.3384864926,
-0.0750182644,
-0.3952130675,
-0.5928257108,
0.1147821993,
0.0094912602,
0.6989482045,
0.1309535801,
0.5450661182,
-0.5993000865,
0.4680261612,
0.349421978,
0.1482212245,
0.0985775739,
-0.5243306756,
-0.4997632205,
-0.1984055638,
-0.158882618,
-1.2990789413,
0.0417096987,
-0.3301905394,
0.5192208886,
0.3805737495,
0.4822486639,
0.5422006249,
-0.2982304394,
0.8908395767,
0.1765654087,
-0.8387408853,
0.2269216925,
-0.441226691,
0.5394206047,
0.7155815363,
0.8952761889,
-0.5522238016,
-0.8814197183,
-0.6122227311,
-0.9138538837,
0.4111314416,
-0.1265680939,
0.6277967095,
-0.2537762821,
0.3752275705,
0.0140031045,
-0.1904057413,
-0.8746603727,
-0.4335348308,
0.0290003233,
0.0399777368,
0.6063454151,
-0.3713297248,
0.0372474305,
-0.0057995608,
0.4150672555,
0.0286203604,
-0.2209271938,
-0.1700413078,
-0.2158586085,
-0.2547192872,
0.3637650609,
0.2601166964,
1.2557288408,
-0.0340645164,
0.317713052,
0.2838783264,
-0.6890514493,
-0.0336058699,
0.1095448285,
-0.3924867809,
0.5625902414,
0.4963567853,
0.6404970288,
0.0070871217,
-0.4121409953,
0.4944176078,
-0.1878825724,
0.2786365747,
-0.4491443336,
-0.3471440971,
-0.1174048409,
-0.0021686831,
0.8415374756,
-0.2849620283,
0.4120487869,
-0.9407821894,
-0.0304988176,
0.4912923872,
-0.4094715714,
-0.1595034301,
0.586104095,
0.2511715591,
-0.1813211739,
0.5822988749,
-0.3967725337,
-0.6840783954,
0.5882018805,
0.4546263516,
0.5095307827,
-0.4245787859,
0.4272654951,
0.7171381712,
0.5156495571,
0.6386611462,
0.1755671501,
0.0642068312,
-0.5865142345,
-0.3929601312,
-0.2926710546,
-0.0486167893,
-0.0607113764,
-0.901807487,
0.1182312891,
-0.1572654396,
-0.564206779,
0.2072537541,
0.018402189,
-0.3494426906,
0.4063161612,
0.2116032392,
0.4528561831,
-1.1708492041,
0.3548129201,
0.8286390305,
-0.3044734299,
-0.4802304208,
0.4644597471,
0.1286712438,
-0.4521041811,
0.6831492782,
-0.2175192833,
-0.103906244,
-0.2722257674,
-0.3741562366,
-0.6763883829,
0.6998904347,
0.3177275062,
-0.3428692818,
0.185364753,
0.3339269459,
0.7305861712,
0.0552893318,
0.3083454072,
0.7782828212,
0.1270564795,
-0.2522184551,
-0.9766413569,
0.2369755208,
-0.0463733897,
0.1215274334,
0.5318498015,
-0.9024667144,
0.9651376009,
-0.2472247183,
-0.8588846922,
0.075127475,
1.0557458401,
-0.0700405017,
0.5309320092,
0.4307482839,
0.3074905276,
0.8050889969,
0.1024686024,
0.9826236367,
0.1333826184,
0.0908912495,
1.0636535883,
0.1134381965,
0.5722685456,
0.3268296123,
-0.5415765047,
0.7763170004,
0.2935763001,
0.3215351701,
0.0458693653,
0.4096022546,
-0.3349204957,
0.5109479427,
-0.5691761971,
-0.2257297635,
0.8798704147,
0.0899625719,
-0.2062549889,
-0.2450672686,
-0.0177595522,
0.7222804427,
0.6224386096,
-0.651784122,
0.8162049651,
-0.0174255669,
-0.3598690629,
0.3437449038,
0.0059001083,
0.5748824477,
-0.209951818,
-0.0170278735,
-0.6175091267,
-0.326313287,
-0.423330605,
-0.7014178038,
0.623683691,
0.0564061701,
-0.2270605117,
0.2849593759,
0.5011382103,
-0.2943425179,
-0.3084305227,
-0.1043959633,
0.4579503238,
0.3049317002,
0.1807633936,
-0.4420804679,
0.3645417988,
0.1101830229,
-0.0233807024,
-0.0450696312,
0.8877059221,
-0.6956409216,
-0.011190542,
0.3178308904,
-0.0330531076,
-0.0510532185,
-0.0963156745,
0.6707056165,
-0.9718624949,
-0.8444314599,
-0.9239905477,
0.4091610014,
-0.3981452286,
-0.6467212439,
0.8111124635,
0.863273561,
0.6746474504,
0.1809415221,
0.7181835175,
-0.0959415063,
0.785363853,
-0.0559349731,
0.639018774,
-0.3150321543,
-0.2768608034,
-0.513926506,
-0.7806004882,
-0.3090691566,
0.1976799965,
-0.3898652494,
0.0728306845,
0.7668825388,
0.4755918682,
0.1987773776,
0.3409208059,
0.2107440978,
0.343542546,
-0.1307470351,
-0.242514655,
0.7941565514,
-0.1209795475,
0.6587332487,
-0.6205274463,
-0.3717106879,
0.0173012316,
-0.6524779797,
-0.3637891412,
-0.7229094505,
-0.3148514926,
-0.2855355144,
-0.1277422011,
0.2216095924,
0.3699027002,
-0.7295070887,
-0.6890445352,
0.7788205743,
0.1683562547,
0.1546814889,
-0.3613034785,
0.7068517804,
0.0487904772,
-0.9294517636,
-0.1795028299,
0.1239117384,
0.0423954092,
-0.266238004,
0.4466168582,
-0.1981290877,
-0.0068106991,
0.5304170251,
0.6468642354,
-0.476434499,
0.0504123382,
-0.1565335542,
-0.4729898274,
-0.1076927334,
1.3276953697,
-0.6739242077,
0.3581496179,
0.3099113107,
0.4985950887,
0.2992717624,
0.4302510619,
0.2654141784,
-0.6410347819,
0.6901007295,
0.7173104286,
0.0110471658,
0.3697589338,
-0.7195507288,
0.3754111826,
0.3326458931,
-0.4764807522,
-0.6349608898,
-0.112426579,
-0.6632349491,
-0.5927472711,
0.8100328445,
-0.0573632605,
-0.2864208519,
-0.4647656977,
-0.1532426924,
0.4576024413,
-0.3813677728,
1.0002808571,
0.5459083915,
-0.2081130743,
-0.0732861534,
-0.5066252351,
0.4129123092,
0.3550885618,
-0.7814762592,
0.0347866118,
0.7484515905,
-0.2767137885,
0.4026786089,
1.1106187105,
-0.0247149598,
0.3145222366,
0.2258435935,
-0.0883943588,
0.6329897642,
0.3247345388,
0.1047988683,
0.2947368324,
-0.2122161537,
-0.1313146949
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02564v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02564v2
|
A Truly Joint Neural Architecture for Segmentation and Parsing
| 2024-02-04T16:56:08 | 2024-03-02T16:33:32 |
Danit Yshaayahu Levi, Reut Tsarfaty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Contemporary multilingual dependency parsers can parse a diverse set of
languages, but for Morphologically Rich Languages (MRLs), performance is
attested to be lower than other languages. The key challenge is that, due to
high morphological complexity and ambiguity of the space-delimited input
tokens, the linguistic units that act as nodes in the tree are not known in
advance. Pre-neural dependency parsers for MRLs subscribed to the joint
morpho-syntactic hypothesis, stating that morphological segmentation and
syntactic parsing should be solved jointly, rather than as a pipeline where
segmentation precedes parsing. However, neural state-of-the-art parsers to date
use a strict pipeline. In this paper we introduce a joint neural architecture
where a lattice-based representation preserving all morphological ambiguity of
the input is provided to an arc-factored model, which then solves the
morphological segmentation and syntactic parsing tasks at once. Our experiments
on Hebrew, a rich and highly ambiguous MRL, demonstrate state-of-the-art
performance on parsing, tagging and segmentation of the Hebrew section of UD,
using a single model. This proposed architecture is LLM-based and language
agnostic, providing a solid foundation for MRLs to obtain further performance
improvements and bridge the gap with other languages.
|
[
-0.2865089774,
-0.5854476094,
0.4665876329,
0.5664859414,
-0.3795537651,
0.1394281387,
0.0427659787,
-0.6270071864,
0.3831532598,
0.226336658,
-0.3095350564,
-0.3928314447,
-0.504878521,
0.0932413414,
0.0423357487,
0.3436746299,
0.1395259798,
0.4738976657,
-0.2278945446,
-0.465212971,
-0.3398647904,
-0.4601593614,
-0.3915549219,
-0.4555748403,
0.7287681699,
-0.163995266,
0.890386045,
1.0989640951,
0.2972919941,
0.4349054098,
-0.4763061702,
0.2033505291,
0.340819627,
0.4297991395,
-0.3563671112,
-0.5953297019,
-0.4334691167,
-0.539988637,
0.617595315,
0.8471076488,
-0.1744621694,
-0.1521265358,
-0.1937531382,
0.5168731809,
-0.7863247395,
0.1071223915,
-0.7984210849,
0.25319767,
-0.4213644564,
-0.0857520998,
-0.3962299228,
0.1612179279,
-0.1777036339,
-0.2893816233,
-0.1725296974,
-0.1640486717,
0.8493801355,
0.4915560484,
0.0465804785,
0.1335760653,
-0.3765656054,
0.4060432017,
-0.5215740204,
0.7701022625,
0.3395760357,
0.0350370295,
0.0053386469,
-0.6924222112,
-0.21535559,
-0.0269586183,
-0.1511194408,
-0.0060162609,
-0.0326898023,
0.0449076183,
-0.0743032768,
0.2927968502,
-0.64956218,
0.3142305911,
-0.0553776883,
-0.2835237682,
0.1548104733,
0.1938719451,
0.7731374502,
-0.4817181528,
-0.3107106984,
0.0796741173,
-0.7058912516,
-0.0403354578,
0.229395017,
0.4513280094,
-0.151564464,
0.5878257155,
0.265938133,
0.8266534209,
-0.253387481,
0.1233465821,
0.1326088011,
-0.15915595,
-0.2065474838,
0.1437284499,
0.8603397608,
-0.191060558,
0.2199330032,
-0.1644918174,
-0.2252629995,
0.1719343811,
0.1929913461,
-0.4232070446,
-0.1727600098,
0.1048546284,
-0.4280100167,
0.1442375779,
-0.3411805332,
-0.6832017899,
-0.352134794,
-0.3003073335,
0.1102028564,
-0.5804444551,
-0.4349724948,
0.2106310278,
0.2129727602,
0.179802224,
0.1813443452,
-1.2019912004,
0.2974454463,
0.8177169561,
0.9092461467,
0.0235258657,
-0.4657737613,
-0.387139082,
0.2365623116,
-0.3372602463,
0.926427424,
-0.7995958328,
-0.072401613,
-0.1522338092,
-0.2647431195,
-0.2235956043,
-0.7758822441,
0.1876492947,
-0.6415139437,
-0.2380122095,
-0.0294415541,
-0.2491882443,
0.0753097981,
0.5261045098,
-0.7346710563,
0.8098020554,
0.1965452135,
-0.7801901698,
0.2879123986,
-0.4086204171,
-0.513296783,
0.3440474272,
-0.5583449006,
-0.1715104878,
0.1965887398,
0.3493060172,
0.2698507905,
-0.1740704179,
0.6584960222,
-0.1248009205,
-0.0548676252,
-0.0086329337,
-0.5148265362,
0.8405493498,
0.076344952,
-0.1734023541,
0.430020988,
-0.8116351366,
0.0731951594,
0.0844357088,
-0.3999296427,
-0.4147137403,
0.0828243941,
-0.1032993421,
0.2166872323,
0.2860541344,
-0.5213515759,
0.098935999,
-0.7095165849,
0.4856341481,
0.7495352626,
-0.4541989863,
0.3151275516,
0.0700775906,
0.2159140259,
0.4440935552,
0.0592887551,
-0.3623852134,
-0.3786057234,
-0.8760980368,
-0.3205805123,
0.4082445204,
0.4641112387,
-0.599693656,
0.5326004028,
-0.2145186067,
-0.0389475524,
-0.6567817926,
-0.102331996,
0.3017563522,
0.1494543552,
0.4506955147,
-0.346365273,
-0.4727000892,
-1.1530778408,
0.0450798832,
-0.2515624464,
0.2433620691,
-0.016525764,
0.1102675721,
0.0811295137,
0.793585062,
-0.118797563,
-0.0735672414,
-0.4789457321,
-0.1131889299,
0.179327786,
0.5836669207,
0.2298458964,
-0.7647128105,
-0.4072579145,
0.3394733071,
-0.7200886011,
0.099108398,
0.0866593644,
-0.0130940443,
-0.077447623,
0.4541000426,
-0.8644313812,
0.2939324379,
0.4617060721,
-0.3866057992,
0.3066392541,
-0.3551555872,
-0.3086195588,
-1.0946139097,
0.0575861633,
-0.2576381564,
-0.1843908429,
-0.5587238669,
0.1902663112,
0.284797281,
-0.0697283223,
-0.6354169846,
0.5644214749,
-0.4544727206,
-0.3807467222,
-0.1753215641,
-0.3250126243,
0.2027902156,
0.6734765172,
0.0457119159,
0.7388008833,
0.8743209243,
-0.3503420949,
0.0868149996,
0.3195066154,
-0.187806502,
0.2350013405,
-0.6286020279,
-0.2049195021,
-0.2449656874,
0.0322958641,
-0.4901333451,
-0.1491585076,
0.529263556,
-0.1936229169,
0.5434374213,
-0.4213111103,
-0.5188775659,
0.1839232743,
0.0784255639,
0.9791069031,
0.1329348236,
-0.5587414503,
1.0145696402,
0.3180319667,
-0.122816965,
-0.7684221268,
-0.8055391908,
0.2046121657,
0.1384102106,
-1.0039327145,
0.5067885518,
0.2694887519,
-0.3295971751,
0.2669141293,
-0.167754069,
-0.3466080725,
0.054558415,
0.1320026964,
0.2329899967,
-0.6065536141,
0.1378973126,
-0.1586433351,
-0.3793237507,
-0.0856298655,
-0.3234808743,
1.1146640778,
-0.0939743146,
-0.7177507281,
-0.4473041594,
0.3947924078,
0.6356002092,
-0.8549273014,
0.6046302915,
0.2877634764,
-0.3163070977,
-0.191038847,
-0.4428364635,
0.2385802269,
-0.4741945267,
0.4709919989,
-0.5504086018,
-0.8129707575,
0.6805368662,
-0.006836425,
-0.2388904244,
0.4737246335,
0.4713434875,
0.2811230719,
0.8888519406,
0.2808055282,
-0.0616779402,
0.2778471708,
0.001056685,
0.175168708,
-0.8639303446,
-0.4012928307,
-0.5062807798,
-0.1986885667,
-0.3559758067,
-0.4885114431,
0.0398458391,
0.0141125852,
0.0358994454,
0.1103169844,
-0.3880105019,
0.7388121486,
0.4432995915,
-0.0933119059,
-0.014694945,
-0.0667964146,
-0.5538710356,
0.1335610598,
-0.7554904819,
-0.1763376594,
0.3979078233,
0.2961566448,
0.6109747887,
-0.0267109293,
0.4699477851,
-0.1400027126,
-0.3079255819,
-0.9165784717,
0.576821506,
-0.490986377,
-0.3599055707,
0.0100021763,
-0.3925795853,
-1.0071992874,
0.7815798521,
-0.0200031232,
-0.7939756513,
0.211204201,
-0.1013151333,
-0.3916628659,
0.6683834195,
-0.4802523255,
0.8926970959,
-0.4561494589,
-0.5505780578,
-0.105828464,
-0.7587655783,
0.097439453,
0.3011778295,
0.0181995016,
-0.2418969125,
0.0563128479,
0.5064985752,
-0.2671693265,
0.6816034913,
-0.0980367959,
0.0915090516,
0.1842370927,
0.3119317591,
0.2321497202,
0.1262619942,
-0.0613422468,
0.3619039357,
-0.2258193195,
-0.3856216967,
-0.5654319525,
0.5739115477,
-0.7009226084,
-0.65438658,
-0.4514228404,
-0.756770432,
-0.2212592065,
0.3107173741,
-0.1382542849,
0.6379420757,
-0.0570191592,
-0.1221532971,
0.5554496646,
-0.3052836955,
0.6292583942,
0.0752353966,
-0.2743693888,
-0.3838369846,
0.8267181516,
-0.1129432768,
-0.0015588572,
0.4912718832,
0.2325125188,
-0.2981792092,
-0.9191973805,
-0.9072571993,
0.3316428661,
-0.6231637001,
-0.1275839508,
-0.7581340075,
-0.557400465,
-0.1469724625,
-0.0267240442,
-0.697727561,
-0.3270428479,
-0.1235798895,
0.0426535867,
-0.2112713456,
0.9200341702,
-0.0810132101,
0.1433526576,
-1.0411375761,
0.3528546691,
0.1191387251,
0.5745900869,
0.0905619338,
0.0615497231,
-0.1184681803,
-0.0909341052,
-0.0150963971,
-0.559895277,
0.3132822216,
-0.0155914882,
0.5898548961,
0.2381810248,
-0.4466389716,
0.7055860162,
-0.7107664347,
0.5727031827,
0.3790519834,
-0.8073295355,
0.2276066095,
-0.1484654248,
0.6017885208,
0.5090314746,
0.0757358149,
-0.5637922287,
-0.2580914199,
-0.3719128668,
-0.9274754524,
0.8837423921,
0.0409129076,
0.0362471677,
-0.1401691139,
0.1399608999,
0.2254672796,
-0.1840484738,
-0.7617951632,
-0.2890845239,
-0.1076168865,
-0.1882310659,
0.4369713962,
-0.3510913551,
0.0653348565,
-0.2506584823,
0.2319608033,
0.1091689318,
0.0263535567,
0.0455526598,
-0.1864400655,
-0.0741284862,
0.3727580905,
0.471711129,
0.8104295731,
0.1337590069,
0.637590766,
-0.1311427951,
-0.3788640797,
0.2948563099,
-0.0271660462,
-0.1755245179,
-0.0054657664,
0.4781533182,
0.8673038483,
0.1114045233,
-0.4192695618,
0.3291200995,
-0.0629859492,
-0.0132306041,
0.0382493176,
-0.0650647581,
0.5304782987,
0.3890079856,
-0.0538303293,
0.7010755539,
-0.1511819214,
-0.3612314165,
0.3726451397,
0.4495901763,
-0.3048864305,
-0.5052754283,
0.2796882987,
0.0941410139,
-0.4429318309,
0.5950414538,
-0.0372300185,
-0.7521525025,
0.4985907376,
0.6168396473,
0.7160788178,
-0.3624086678,
0.1548566669,
0.2263381183,
0.1061039716,
0.0964875594,
0.2448133081,
-0.1065172032,
-0.8825534582,
-0.6641929746,
-1.0772380829,
0.0871193185,
0.0432745107,
-0.3877238631,
0.0270926021,
-0.5845384598,
0.1476103514,
0.0069513279,
-0.6951664686,
-0.3922113776,
0.1332713813,
0.2562113702,
0.8712213635,
-0.4075133801,
0.9590930939,
0.6656422019,
-0.1275090724,
-0.7670170665,
-0.1393438131,
-0.2138940841,
-1.1551835537,
0.6871100068,
0.254509896,
-0.1676235944,
-0.2449940741,
0.1198074818,
-0.8243862987,
0.5805057883,
0.4718660116,
-0.5149354935,
-0.0896686688,
0.5622175932,
0.4701043963,
-0.189059332,
0.1418031305,
0.2785117924,
0.4201948047,
0.2449325174,
-0.7369223237,
-0.0436231084,
-0.3772534132,
-0.051944308,
0.8551277518,
-0.4785269201,
0.9941194057,
0.2208104581,
-0.4049096107,
-0.0740880966,
0.5112088919,
0.0623111464,
0.0509770513,
0.5881588459,
1.0496685505,
0.4999500513,
-0.0021798555,
0.8011196852,
-0.4819323421,
-0.1401199251,
1.1255545616,
-0.2475103438,
0.8089367151,
0.4874584675,
-0.1049419791,
0.2777840793,
0.5705586076,
0.1560514718,
0.3695967495,
0.2698450089,
-0.4920847118,
-0.5188126564,
-0.6228427291,
-0.3485370278,
0.7862791419,
0.3597314656,
-0.3286984563,
-0.6685121655,
-0.3275981545,
-0.1368888468,
0.0042011072,
-0.2653572559,
0.6942194104,
0.0701929554,
-0.6800413132,
0.34270823,
0.0961454362,
0.5662884712,
-0.8855522871,
-0.1218854114,
-0.1933400184,
-0.0665918812,
-0.267763257,
-0.6809821725,
0.5697849393,
-0.2739229798,
-0.0377273448,
-0.2183357775,
0.7006099224,
-0.3437613249,
-0.3513020575,
0.6642203331,
0.9358371496,
-0.0359966829,
0.1531602293,
-0.6816090941,
0.2893106043,
-0.0683201626,
-0.1147398725,
0.5338756442,
0.3708767891,
0.0603068359,
0.5920840502,
0.5282322764,
0.2567473948,
0.3129813969,
0.4313799739,
1.1431611776,
-0.689545691,
-0.4610363543,
-1.261400938,
0.6391429305,
0.2463211268,
-0.3026326597,
0.2101107091,
0.5303509235,
0.6019061208,
0.305578053,
0.3428774774,
-0.1722357273,
-0.2453102618,
-0.6269342303,
0.6800866127,
-0.7771742344,
0.1164013594,
0.2003457844,
-1.1411424875,
-0.775783062,
0.5623797774,
-0.0236645117,
-0.1388409585,
0.8089991212,
0.6888805032,
-0.3545070291,
0.0551433899,
0.6345231533,
0.1015291139,
0.1722150743,
0.4108601213,
1.0968340635,
0.1416732073,
0.3601936698,
-0.2766937017,
0.1458480656,
0.3353204727,
-0.4659358263,
-0.6822157502,
-0.4632105827,
0.075475581,
-0.0790036395,
0.1079832688,
0.9195178747,
0.6867153049,
-0.5621882081,
-0.3181985617,
-0.2406760752,
0.0587196015,
0.2015264928,
-0.1764710248,
0.3781187236,
-0.6710191369,
-0.4778234065,
0.8750614524,
0.9669687152,
-0.1074147373,
-0.3025452197,
0.0331455991,
-0.5702272058,
-0.2541043162,
0.3348576128,
0.0803855136,
-0.7881743908,
-0.1335905641,
-0.1312584281,
-0.2066246718,
0.7611627579,
0.8580563664,
-0.5573914051,
0.4267134964,
0.5282847285,
1.1019587517,
0.2980541587,
-0.0991198644,
0.4556764066,
-0.6808608174,
0.2396407425,
0.4372011721,
0.738488853,
0.4729107022,
-0.1867510378,
0.3250603676,
0.1549177468,
-0.263207972,
-0.2745786309,
0.6466767788,
-0.998744905,
-0.5375753641,
0.6634745598,
-0.3543516397,
-0.5066380501,
-0.3297982216,
-0.0312858373,
0.1986639202,
-0.1734832674,
0.3572014868,
0.6141713858,
-0.0696107894,
-0.3207549453,
0.1061192676,
0.1392818838,
0.849283278,
-0.7327132225,
0.1713504046,
0.4149771631,
-0.0585318282,
0.4913761914,
0.4764269292,
-0.2197617739,
0.173642695,
0.2909924388,
0.0643435493,
-0.2627933323,
-0.6445050836,
-0.3440236151,
0.5958381891,
0.2497435659,
-0.0630652755
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02563v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02563v2
|
Synergy-of-Thoughts: Eliciting Efficient Reasoning in Hybrid Language Models
| 2024-02-04T16:45:01 | 2024-05-23T14:20:53 |
Yu Shang, Yu Li, Fengli Xu, Yong Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have shown impressive emergent abilities in a
wide range of tasks, but still face challenges in handling complex reasoning
problems. Previous works like chain-of-thought (CoT) and tree-of-thoughts (ToT)
have predominately focused on enhancing accuracy, but overlook the rapidly
increasing token cost, which could be particularly problematic for open-ended
real-world tasks with huge solution spaces. Motivated by the dual process
theory of human cognition, we propose "Synergy of Thoughts" (SoT) to unleash
the synergistic potential of hybrid LLMs for efficient reasoning. By default,
SoT uses smaller-scale language models to generate multiple low-cost reasoning
thoughts, which resembles the parallel intuitions produced by System 1. If
these intuitions exhibit conflicts, SoT will invoke the reflective reasoning of
scaled-up language models to emulate the intervention of System 2, which will
override the intuitive thoughts and rectify the reasoning process. This
framework is model-agnostic and training-free, which can be flexibly
implemented with various off-the-shelf LLMs. Experiments on six representative
reasoning tasks show that SoT substantially reduces the token cost by
38.3%-75.1%, and simultaneously achieves state-of-the-art reasoning accuracy
and solution diversity. Notably, the average token cost reduction on open-ended
tasks reaches up to 69.1%. Code repo with all prompts will be released upon
publication.
|
[
-0.2736321688,
-0.6743605137,
0.7532177567,
-0.1045054346,
-0.284283489,
0.3943674266,
-0.3983992934,
-0.5598356724,
0.2850709558,
0.3908494711,
-0.6107286215,
-0.1117640287,
-0.3365673125,
-0.0905651003,
-0.3494279683,
0.7646435499,
-0.103050217,
0.0195507016,
-0.0096382434,
-0.2512920201,
-0.0720080137,
-0.4830470979,
-0.5539954305,
-0.349146992,
0.4376663566,
0.242650643,
0.6859938502,
0.2431767732,
0.455092907,
0.2486521006,
-0.0766917318,
0.2458764762,
-0.4837932885,
0.20491983,
-0.6109886765,
-0.5945979357,
-0.4224725366,
0.0328639336,
0.4925486445,
0.5343497992,
-0.320400238,
0.1629009694,
0.0064065107,
0.6224343181,
-0.7256348729,
-0.1286325306,
-0.9252489805,
-0.1157699674,
-0.1468852013,
-0.0914185047,
-0.2757654488,
-0.0972212777,
0.1270523816,
-0.5377878547,
-0.273853153,
0.273331821,
0.3048844635,
0.3175597787,
-0.0774420202,
-0.0595001094,
-0.7768262625,
0.7812405229,
-0.6222757697,
0.3817480803,
-0.1214051992,
0.2189490199,
-0.2225759476,
-0.5201403499,
-1.0371586084,
0.0245287064,
0.1501634419,
0.4342808127,
-0.3961583376,
0.1769110858,
0.4951357841,
0.5070314407,
-0.4390995502,
-0.0132098738,
0.0252921619,
0.027495278,
0.578963697,
0.2702620327,
0.2724139988,
0.0819724873,
-0.5654950142,
0.0798984542,
-0.4620744288,
-0.1115667894,
0.3157893121,
0.1292248517,
0.1117216349,
0.4921945333,
-0.2154742777,
0.5537707806,
-0.084623076,
-0.1439143866,
-0.0975597799,
-0.7862631083,
-0.2386810184,
-0.2218295187,
0.8291540146,
0.2401839197,
0.0790965334,
-0.2549844086,
-0.4326654077,
0.6857433915,
0.1941425651,
-0.4001025259,
-0.2229098976,
0.1547210366,
-0.4932833314,
-0.1989130825,
-0.1835868508,
-0.4817901254,
-0.2477213144,
-0.3761363626,
0.3494532704,
-0.3807421625,
-0.5700765252,
0.4102837443,
-0.2041506171,
-0.010247699,
0.407143116,
-0.6562187076,
0.5603980422,
0.6220328808,
0.4277109802,
-0.2237111628,
-0.3093433976,
-0.267894417,
0.0965982676,
-0.0853871629,
0.8147447109,
-0.4627289474,
-0.162268877,
-0.5574635863,
-0.6786546111,
-0.168838039,
-0.559251368,
0.4175332785,
-0.2486918122,
0.3030038476,
-0.4120856524,
-0.4583195448,
0.1078776717,
0.2939622104,
-0.5282257795,
1.0927968025,
0.0147462254,
-1.0631908178,
0.1887026131,
-0.8054960966,
-0.4223213494,
0.2887906432,
-0.4385791719,
0.0456479453,
0.1103822887,
0.0109150354,
0.0524291284,
-0.8128835559,
0.2441688925,
-0.2494709343,
-0.1426504254,
0.0631965026,
-0.2188175917,
0.930196166,
0.4960428178,
-0.5350761414,
0.2334448248,
-0.4330508411,
0.0710159168,
0.3928623199,
-0.1203439385,
-0.44818753,
-0.1523370892,
-0.3516752422,
0.3079758286,
0.2290345579,
-0.5817642212,
0.2081132233,
-0.4514968991,
0.4466402829,
0.5544819236,
-0.2744954228,
0.5234463215,
-0.3474718928,
0.4861742854,
0.0552126952,
0.2393393964,
-0.008255953,
-0.459107101,
-0.8796325922,
-0.2934955657,
0.0007391978,
0.5093489885,
-0.9762455225,
0.4781035781,
-0.0533531643,
-0.3840847015,
-0.6458694935,
0.0984243602,
0.5464991331,
0.4486480951,
0.1538069844,
-0.3135909438,
-0.4588882029,
-0.8355315924,
-0.5636879206,
-0.270160526,
0.4051494896,
0.1040855125,
0.5491917729,
0.1172387525,
0.9771595597,
-0.3454990685,
0.2236139029,
-0.5786011815,
0.0762737989,
0.0659681931,
0.2743384838,
0.1275583506,
-0.6559935212,
-0.2486148626,
-0.0611392893,
-0.5362206101,
0.1031027511,
-0.1385228038,
-0.3801959455,
0.1293789744,
0.1679333597,
-0.892331183,
0.2512577176,
0.3824079633,
-0.2387055457,
0.686598599,
-0.3009693623,
-0.1118690744,
-1.2192049026,
0.1433577687,
-0.1014885381,
-0.1248867959,
-0.4956972897,
0.2923114896,
-0.111963667,
-0.0120768948,
-0.1529826075,
0.5120778084,
-0.4519681036,
-0.0475087762,
-0.3774180412,
0.2120863348,
-0.0053025601,
0.4966310859,
0.1601584554,
0.7345401645,
0.4117540121,
-0.1903390884,
0.4581641853,
-0.0354987457,
-0.4705336392,
0.4538848102,
-0.168027848,
0.360755682,
-0.0285128839,
0.5548072457,
-0.654936254,
0.1316154748,
0.2207382768,
-0.0687251091,
-0.05553215,
0.4331972003,
-0.9394595027,
-0.6238691807,
-0.2566525638,
0.4505360723,
0.4677673876,
-0.6384400129,
0.6763788462,
0.6018880606,
-0.0340561941,
-0.6001415849,
-0.5174788833,
0.0514378473,
0.0160576627,
-0.4916372895,
0.2828170359,
0.0622226559,
-0.5139304399,
0.2313348204,
-0.3007214367,
0.3343299329,
0.1603455693,
-0.2111040056,
0.3539341092,
-0.0360646434,
0.2586565912,
0.0148091773,
-0.1498546898,
0.0237245485,
-1.0597854853,
0.3911314607,
-0.3457708061,
-0.5261522532,
-0.1837254167,
0.446189642,
0.6195065379,
-0.4831312597,
0.4863286316,
0.2099914998,
-0.4384410977,
-0.5604569912,
-0.7420728207,
-0.4001942277,
-0.3664547503,
0.2988063991,
-0.5118801594,
-0.9427626729,
0.4579866529,
-0.2919275165,
0.1078968644,
0.1917877942,
0.7950686812,
-0.2043219209,
0.9248552322,
0.3165201545,
-0.0086225038,
0.3665665686,
-0.3665755987,
0.7660514712,
-0.7329438329,
-0.216058746,
-0.1153697968,
-0.5581318736,
-0.2286699861,
-0.8165923357,
0.3243125081,
0.1460532993,
0.0663912743,
0.3541466892,
-0.5793441534,
0.6283720136,
0.7126699686,
0.1369453222,
0.4919067621,
-0.3213743567,
-0.4928161204,
0.3427058458,
-1.1139138937,
-0.3869863749,
0.9069139957,
0.1379004568,
0.6164055467,
-0.0769546553,
0.728354454,
-0.071020551,
0.1546252668,
-0.5784268975,
0.9839137793,
-0.0371615589,
-0.6922622323,
-0.29579404,
-0.4786258936,
-0.6811694503,
0.3576351404,
-0.3437333405,
-0.797622025,
-0.1589417309,
0.2384661138,
-0.5960807204,
0.803702414,
-0.5872318149,
0.7268871665,
-0.47014305,
-0.4694308341,
-0.8470652699,
-0.7345085144,
0.5589478612,
-0.0498329997,
0.1175076514,
0.0370968953,
0.0559456013,
0.7281044126,
-0.490699172,
0.5865719914,
0.0734622255,
-0.0608812347,
0.6581559181,
0.0096420115,
0.7046496868,
-0.4418916404,
0.1615600139,
-0.1793169379,
-0.2667422295,
-0.2495705038,
-0.8131121397,
0.648024559,
-0.4617697001,
-0.7324080467,
-0.2599992454,
-0.9029054046,
-0.2003795952,
0.1286688298,
0.1159535944,
0.2450025082,
-0.0438786708,
-0.3249766231,
0.5188365579,
-0.0093208142,
0.1079861,
0.2581300735,
-0.2987022996,
-0.3928503394,
0.8731595874,
0.0184962507,
0.5712972879,
0.2723065019,
0.2309936583,
-0.4399124682,
-0.3990364373,
-0.2790952921,
0.2751951814,
-0.7317137718,
-0.1131098121,
-0.7878465652,
-0.0924012512,
-0.1162210107,
0.0341191888,
-0.4221481979,
-0.8057569265,
0.2223912627,
-0.2128854096,
0.3015087247,
0.568348527,
0.0172702782,
-0.1131267399,
-0.4897880256,
0.2011634558,
0.3688158393,
0.2488101423,
0.4385489225,
-0.1673706919,
-0.2244725078,
-0.0328994691,
-0.4048290551,
-0.6488163471,
0.0551731177,
-0.3667008877,
0.6197100878,
0.1702716798,
0.1479248852,
0.5753031373,
-0.2141274065,
0.5494496822,
0.7741447687,
-0.9131907821,
0.5950922966,
-0.2849508226,
0.2950856984,
0.5040006638,
0.0654972866,
-0.3135392368,
-0.7352064252,
-0.8982557058,
-0.5993018746,
0.721090436,
0.1959108859,
-0.295619905,
-0.1379972696,
0.0408414416,
0.2659654319,
0.1140867844,
-0.5033704042,
-0.0283907782,
0.1135290191,
-0.2494609058,
0.1854517907,
0.0499872267,
-0.1338679045,
-0.4944604933,
0.5182049274,
-0.1444130391,
0.1294110566,
0.0223963466,
0.0114347599,
-0.3502505124,
0.499361366,
0.2941259742,
0.3437101245,
0.1659427434,
0.5624430776,
0.4941717982,
0.0556472354,
0.1635582298,
-0.1337213963,
-0.0806095004,
-0.37521258,
0.0855010673,
0.8360671401,
0.2761460245,
-0.7720811367,
0.341953963,
0.1050556526,
-0.2517818511,
0.107122153,
0.2041796297,
0.5873256922,
0.5049068928,
0.0126044499,
0.454472363,
0.2633101642,
-0.8208693266,
-0.0545149148,
0.672349453,
0.0043439455,
-0.409494698,
0.5442148447,
0.5525604486,
-0.3180245161,
0.5001361966,
-0.4549153745,
-0.917422235,
0.247704789,
0.6296551228,
1.0556434393,
0.1770266742,
-0.0944804922,
0.0981830508,
0.0779086351,
-0.2963209152,
0.6986338496,
-0.4385233223,
-0.9817399979,
-0.5980690718,
-0.4482231736,
-0.4561026096,
-0.0188488755,
-0.3411521614,
0.0900058225,
-0.4787126184,
-0.4331488907,
-0.146475628,
0.1225135401,
-0.4168692827,
-0.0317901596,
0.5374168754,
1.1613992453,
-0.6971873045,
1.014763236,
0.7285598516,
-0.2479534,
-0.9914874434,
0.0220847558,
-0.0489969552,
-0.5817792416,
0.5900734067,
0.0341044553,
-0.7133870721,
0.175458774,
-0.2018926591,
-0.604162693,
1.0267597437,
0.6187093258,
-0.8176810741,
-0.2009300292,
-0.1287226379,
0.4591976702,
-0.4275984466,
0.3033266068,
0.7096168399,
0.3445733786,
0.1002241001,
-1.2487965822,
0.185447976,
-0.3948336244,
-0.1612930149,
0.5310279727,
-0.8527418375,
0.7295973897,
-0.6328344345,
-0.4613069892,
-0.0396529697,
0.4449798167,
0.4378821254,
0.2097225785,
0.7377765775,
0.9635061026,
0.9249143004,
0.0785840824,
1.0435931683,
-0.4553983808,
0.1298584193,
1.0068789721,
-0.6352964044,
0.7989416122,
0.7134075761,
-0.2656772733,
0.5684789419,
0.1091335639,
0.3938035071,
0.3655195534,
0.2932723165,
-0.4400114417,
-0.6027782559,
-0.221499905,
-0.0947784707,
0.2418380529,
0.2261490375,
-0.0359989218,
-0.1619731039,
-0.0882042199,
-0.2139771134,
0.3345972896,
-0.0377816148,
0.7416752577,
0.3795858026,
-0.9119049311,
0.3537521362,
-0.3710680902,
0.7189048529,
-0.4104774296,
0.1916037053,
0.1653403938,
0.4391993284,
0.0692451894,
-0.7675971985,
0.1931249201,
0.1057620123,
-0.2196130306,
-0.6212330461,
0.821618557,
-0.4904941618,
-0.4136993885,
0.7157641649,
0.8483896255,
0.048096031,
0.0184694007,
-0.8961567283,
0.0287612174,
-0.0691190064,
-0.0715025663,
0.2910951078,
0.4007374942,
-0.1133401692,
0.7088421583,
0.7233423591,
0.4156514704,
-0.2264120877,
0.2440867573,
1.092861414,
-0.6258491874,
-0.590436399,
-0.9362044334,
0.2623659968,
-0.2787180245,
-0.0845850036,
0.4872235656,
0.5634382963,
0.8694845438,
0.2351201773,
0.9591425657,
0.0519267842,
0.6228718162,
-0.41106987,
0.623488605,
-0.6483713388,
0.2367234528,
-0.1886322796,
-0.8417215347,
-0.0536284931,
0.5499449968,
-0.5553261042,
-0.1380761117,
0.9799642563,
0.6534054875,
-0.0941874534,
0.6261636615,
0.1835556328,
-0.0240232218,
0.0031449026,
1.0341616869,
1.3084470034,
0.0076661878,
0.3377072513,
-0.2246236503,
-0.4055005312,
-0.0828491151,
-0.7103003263,
-0.7529025078,
-0.3642370701,
-0.1904655248,
-0.2884227931,
0.1854545474,
1.3482859135,
0.6011012197,
-0.6197077036,
-0.4575228095,
-0.4376188517,
-0.0196538325,
-0.2740848362,
-0.1199615672,
0.1230402067,
-0.3755072057,
-0.3582382798,
0.2539254427,
0.7062879801,
-0.1309719384,
-0.4150008559,
-0.2602512836,
-0.2740831077,
0.2447936684,
0.465723753,
0.0534558222,
-1.0966244936,
-0.068081826,
0.1994454116,
-0.231218487,
-0.0795128644,
1.0490700006,
-0.8364164233,
0.6295456886,
0.5407989621,
0.5048161745,
0.343680352,
-0.0815504938,
0.69939363,
-0.1561289132,
0.2269960195,
0.5975897908,
0.5235611796,
0.0144460099,
-0.1003588662,
0.3669528365,
0.3875997961,
-0.2160651535,
-0.8547331691,
0.5282642245,
-0.8425320387,
-0.336435467,
0.8942327499,
-0.094845742,
-0.2364474386,
0.0534917973,
-0.2024684995,
0.287871182,
-0.3324458599,
0.6623929143,
0.6157674789,
-0.3187918067,
-0.1519661248,
0.0739421025,
0.3394736648,
0.9796487093,
-0.8970745802,
0.4346770644,
0.1760578305,
-0.1108657271,
0.2928841114,
0.8277969956,
0.0808924362,
0.3107867241,
0.3010667562,
0.156285122,
0.0785328001,
-0.3595122993,
0.0353946276,
-0.1313428283,
0.1384968907,
0.0222451854
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02559v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02559v1
|
NavHint: Vision and Language Navigation Agent with a Hint Generator
| 2024-02-04T16:23:16 | 2024-02-04T16:23:16 |
Yue Zhang, Quan Guo, Parisa Kordjamshidi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Existing work on vision and language navigation mainly relies on
navigation-related losses to establish the connection between vision and
language modalities, neglecting aspects of helping the navigation agent build a
deep understanding of the visual environment. In our work, we provide indirect
supervision to the navigation agent through a hint generator that provides
detailed visual descriptions. The hint generator assists the navigation agent
in developing a global understanding of the visual environment. It directs the
agent's attention toward related navigation details, including the relevant
sub-instruction, potential challenges in recognition and ambiguities in
grounding, and the targeted viewpoint description. To train the hint generator,
we construct a synthetic dataset based on landmarks in the instructions and
visible and distinctive objects in the visual environment. We evaluate our
method on the R2R and R4R datasets and achieve state-of-the-art on several
metrics. The experimental results demonstrate that generating hints not only
enhances the navigation performance but also helps improve the interpretability
of the agent's actions.
|
[
-0.2323872447,
-0.5601664782,
0.6280220747,
0.0740262195,
-0.3442458808,
-0.099822022,
-0.1720674634,
-0.3525488377,
0.0326983593,
0.398724556,
-0.842032969,
-0.4991137683,
-0.1037180573,
-0.1153959259,
-0.1483568549,
0.903234899,
0.1734624803,
-0.1142198518,
-0.0541199297,
0.0085676583,
-0.9507184625,
-0.0925366208,
-0.8105464578,
-0.2835606337,
0.6203235388,
0.6293275356,
0.571310997,
0.6071569324,
0.6197879314,
0.3089151084,
0.2451629341,
0.2054096162,
-0.4487696886,
0.5064247847,
-0.4563620389,
-0.5476301312,
-0.4263296127,
-0.2724973261,
0.5292719007,
0.3454329967,
0.1016105264,
0.1488231122,
-0.1378591359,
0.7781943679,
-0.6846536398,
0.6255817413,
-0.4067592621,
0.1234204918,
-0.2657483518,
-0.5585644841,
-0.1251401752,
-0.2939981222,
0.3273922801,
-0.998032093,
0.3750571907,
0.1825594902,
0.7388494611,
0.7371516824,
-0.4143745601,
-0.2712592483,
-0.7423920631,
0.7720897794,
-0.1052085832,
0.4432892501,
0.025751913,
0.8453069329,
-0.1252870709,
-0.6021974087,
-0.3377429843,
-0.1410565376,
0.1134542748,
0.5916382074,
0.0828923434,
0.0833138674,
0.2279370427,
-0.011458952,
-0.4828071892,
-0.4135778248,
-0.4576429129,
-0.394562304,
0.5193577409,
0.082440041,
0.2233070731,
-0.2691199183,
-0.5917294621,
-0.398281157,
-0.9770156145,
0.1391702294,
0.086386241,
0.4020408392,
0.074091576,
0.449490875,
-0.6174200773,
0.9891377687,
0.0601184517,
-0.3371872008,
0.1976619065,
-0.6308151484,
-0.020714812,
0.372069627,
0.4465590119,
0.8131737113,
0.6053503752,
-0.0559864305,
-0.4061503708,
-0.235600248,
0.3915748,
-0.3942589462,
-0.5489766002,
-0.0959500819,
-0.2797128856,
-0.3350012302,
0.0726673305,
-0.6537749171,
-0.6048614383,
-0.2407657951,
0.3007174432,
-0.5247618556,
-0.505027473,
-0.1103131101,
-0.5146766305,
0.9501478076,
0.6149625778,
-0.4993715286,
-0.200448513,
0.2871819139,
0.639788866,
0.002474433,
-0.288870424,
-0.7711849213,
0.4417780042,
-0.220377028,
0.8061198592,
-0.4602430761,
-0.5556593537,
0.1424192637,
-0.0116698006,
-0.0292231366,
-0.2398503125,
0.313172996,
-0.3882778883,
-0.01319749,
-0.4519209862,
-0.0644390434,
-0.5805191398,
0.4310621619,
-0.6070682406,
0.7747259736,
0.1152078509,
-0.5787712336,
0.4732866883,
-0.5549208522,
-0.5735833645,
0.6212979555,
-0.4024769366,
-0.1867290884,
0.1705747843,
0.4680035412,
0.1883917302,
0.0276267007,
-0.1973951906,
0.45532915,
-0.3616732359,
-0.0405306034,
-0.2850323915,
0.5267978311,
-0.0648601204,
-0.6084995866,
0.0398685224,
-0.5375785232,
0.1318361014,
0.1364028901,
-0.5134789348,
-0.4022744894,
0.0081294505,
0.1192608923,
0.0592786931,
0.4900769293,
-0.2281364202,
0.3108125627,
-0.4494567215,
-0.1703575104,
0.5750303268,
0.5239688158,
0.474087894,
0.0259156767,
0.9655843973,
-0.1087413803,
0.2885522246,
-0.3931124806,
-0.9492877126,
-1.0533834696,
0.1680216044,
0.0385238416,
0.6442793012,
-1.4756778479,
0.0071401149,
-0.6074120402,
-0.2575972974,
-0.3375722468,
0.0063289022,
0.9495302439,
0.5644714236,
0.2836531103,
-0.1092158109,
-0.5490415692,
-0.7167232633,
-0.2073961496,
-0.1946557611,
0.1855185181,
0.2589900792,
0.4356634319,
-0.0007461753,
1.0282064676,
-0.2650078237,
-0.3471778929,
-0.4576773643,
-0.1913585514,
-0.2594496012,
0.4790557027,
0.4271346927,
-1.0116615295,
-0.3979543149,
0.2538403869,
-0.8063433766,
0.0028185544,
-0.2285063118,
-0.1892964244,
0.0440530442,
0.7132285237,
-0.5232178569,
0.5931937695,
0.1428250372,
-0.3507941663,
0.5303993225,
-0.2981124222,
0.0771077499,
-0.9676766992,
-0.2106624246,
-0.0121404547,
-0.2831822634,
-0.6043598056,
0.1925096363,
-0.0385163613,
0.1038782075,
-0.4108769,
0.6071835756,
-0.7355258465,
-0.1309702694,
-0.1256375611,
0.3390918374,
-0.0379133113,
0.4822323918,
0.3599340022,
0.7140588164,
0.7300954461,
-0.7227329016,
0.7074964046,
0.2789791524,
-0.1271077245,
0.9397569299,
-0.5682352185,
0.1267952472,
-0.1642358154,
0.0646008998,
-0.8544053435,
-0.4046626091,
0.4984520972,
-0.6260735989,
0.3118785322,
-0.5969936848,
-0.2612623274,
-0.2311686724,
-0.1349863112,
0.4444005787,
0.6622697711,
-0.5833473206,
0.6738456488,
0.0146172568,
-0.0747254938,
-0.6528889537,
-0.5504954457,
0.1723141968,
-0.2537048161,
-0.4151803851,
0.0471157618,
0.2265806496,
-0.2527512908,
-0.0529233105,
-0.225154385,
0.3348043859,
-0.2806573808,
0.6363123059,
0.1231432632,
-0.1265285462,
0.2098948658,
-0.1295283735,
-0.4231677651,
0.2946778238,
-0.6133608818,
0.1647134572,
-0.3436638415,
-0.4035064876,
-0.2505898476,
-0.0619589575,
0.2199084014,
-0.6311762929,
0.0634312704,
0.5525759459,
-0.0433174595,
-0.3215995729,
-0.3771436214,
-0.1421640664,
-0.5626730323,
0.3596181571,
-0.7571676373,
-0.118807666,
0.2953986526,
-0.3198811412,
-0.1021038592,
0.3027232587,
0.3442997336,
-0.0138170067,
0.9192501307,
0.7485831976,
0.1161864698,
0.594743371,
-0.5277901292,
0.1499231458,
-0.8096536398,
-0.7573396564,
-0.0743724704,
-0.2186502367,
-0.5367160439,
-0.699180007,
0.5836657882,
-0.2319512814,
0.1174095795,
0.1681037545,
-0.7502766252,
0.6433114409,
0.9821988344,
-0.1150107086,
0.208367452,
0.1247916818,
-0.2244137526,
0.095930621,
-0.9214256406,
-0.3077902198,
0.9165021181,
-0.0773251727,
0.7881590724,
-0.0224657543,
0.8494920135,
0.1013836712,
-0.2252514064,
-0.7998922467,
0.7087078094,
0.6630473733,
-0.3727818727,
-0.1821831316,
-0.2418573797,
-0.8769938946,
0.0531777777,
-0.0404459015,
-0.4903318882,
0.1702605784,
0.2847371399,
-0.1950134784,
-0.1034001186,
-0.7451129556,
0.8656004667,
-0.2762183845,
-0.1453825384,
0.0274103284,
-0.97495538,
0.2906982601,
0.3522743881,
-0.0332156084,
0.344181627,
-0.0526750237,
0.5428945422,
-0.3394804001,
0.6386819482,
-0.5526191592,
-0.1432065517,
0.4700596929,
0.1945369393,
0.3996043503,
0.129167974,
0.3566811085,
-0.1632717401,
-0.3824199438,
-0.2419738621,
-0.5216726065,
0.7459065318,
-0.4019443393,
-0.4675299823,
-0.4946406782,
-0.6457524896,
-0.0728581548,
0.2540650964,
0.4296595752,
0.6199018955,
-0.1052018479,
-0.1882672161,
0.7677779198,
-0.3213468194,
0.2983117104,
0.4340027869,
-0.2048313916,
-0.0222740266,
1.2597323656,
-0.1554102153,
0.1365564913,
0.4178520441,
-0.1127941832,
-0.4453248084,
-0.6493170261,
-0.6067661047,
-0.0027930904,
-1.1061948538,
-0.2360826433,
0.0774494857,
-0.2198374271,
0.0421886034,
-0.2936995924,
-0.2367320508,
-0.4787296355,
0.2450112551,
-0.1674585193,
0.6056938767,
1.1769837141,
-0.2006050646,
0.218740955,
-0.4451018274,
0.2425685227,
0.4934090376,
-0.0848980695,
-0.1594029218,
-0.1448203474,
-0.3994487822,
0.0340635665,
0.0863033533,
-0.7373377085,
0.0407179035,
0.2046426386,
0.5584802032,
0.5526195765,
-0.1423318088,
0.4840163291,
-0.4501345754,
0.9379484653,
0.1207903177,
-0.4492150247,
1.1286901236,
-0.4346338809,
0.8439725041,
0.3769183755,
-0.1701530367,
-0.3219290376,
-0.7328277826,
-0.4508344829,
-0.6525649428,
0.4972755313,
0.4774364531,
-0.2884992659,
0.1587217152,
0.5614560843,
-0.2982136905,
0.1387253404,
-0.3861222267,
-0.3507706225,
-0.4218682349,
-0.2792510092,
-0.0494157933,
0.053597644,
-0.1108811945,
-0.1692005694,
0.6069440842,
-0.1913567036,
0.1822415292,
0.358528167,
-0.4304519594,
0.1129123569,
-0.0906086341,
0.5248352289,
0.6148285866,
-0.2363278121,
0.2774436772,
-0.114779897,
-0.8027923703,
-0.000056614,
0.0136048999,
-0.4998877347,
0.1987790167,
0.5722296238,
0.5776575804,
0.0346957929,
-0.5755033493,
0.5085319281,
-0.179996416,
0.0242369436,
-0.4132808447,
0.4738323689,
0.0512488186,
0.3796345592,
0.2891653478,
0.2747001052,
0.2622854412,
-0.2338704467,
-0.1029236317,
0.5016006231,
-0.6706975698,
-0.3687281013,
0.7469676733,
0.4934849441,
-0.3733908534,
0.7209379673,
-0.4872468412,
-0.6733078957,
0.6822152138,
0.1408622861,
0.8308683038,
-0.2226793766,
0.2913278937,
0.3823133409,
0.4475573599,
0.2159081995,
0.4854973555,
-0.3445471525,
-0.4859752655,
-0.2745752633,
-0.4927400351,
-0.2575637698,
-0.3282261193,
-0.7216252089,
-0.0865446031,
-0.1381566077,
-0.0018578132,
-0.3268803358,
0.0242222287,
-1.0173500776,
0.2576383948,
0.2504665256,
0.697357595,
-0.4353781939,
0.8280882835,
1.0929830074,
-0.7659212351,
-0.6738615632,
0.230733797,
0.1148454472,
-0.9026177526,
0.8554682136,
0.2142476141,
-0.7701739073,
0.2423425913,
-0.4298761487,
-0.7403821945,
1.3223811388,
0.0217700787,
-0.397959888,
-0.1163012311,
0.0365992934,
0.3603519499,
-0.3348422348,
0.0193844624,
0.653709352,
0.6905161738,
0.1185498461,
-0.8115307689,
0.2191285044,
-0.3510710001,
0.1974688917,
0.0176657215,
-0.4148198366,
0.4662512541,
-0.6510692239,
-0.2716001868,
0.1585285515,
0.3864522576,
0.0940570384,
0.1684138477,
0.453646481,
0.3231837749,
0.5585512519,
-0.2876030505,
1.312584877,
-0.3920500875,
-0.0002517067,
1.1610701084,
0.0892372206,
0.4380883276,
0.5696783662,
0.4566473067,
0.6716229916,
0.3139818609,
0.2027264237,
0.9075087309,
-0.0216534603,
-0.2695397735,
-0.3212646246,
-0.160893023,
-0.3991363347,
0.4773311317,
0.5775719285,
-0.1006561965,
-0.4231602848,
0.1191643551,
-0.2925745249,
-0.1921394616,
-0.5078032613,
0.8717865944,
0.0150692314,
-0.7784613371,
0.5171371102,
-0.2203340232,
0.2418631315,
-0.6139836907,
-0.3873018026,
-0.2280009687,
0.3629002571,
-0.1078158841,
-0.8044191599,
-0.2494702339,
-0.1771163195,
0.2249819785,
-0.2571724355,
0.9485019445,
-0.5057915449,
-0.3351209462,
-0.0527450591,
0.7465446591,
0.2399110198,
-0.2818180919,
-0.5683062673,
-0.0977764353,
0.2570663989,
-0.3191233277,
-0.1408138722,
0.6082116365,
0.0347847864,
0.8870123029,
0.3428257108,
0.1627133936,
0.3215814531,
0.1561016142,
0.6751206517,
-0.8163868189,
-0.4894656837,
-0.5239226818,
0.5446491241,
-0.2805966139,
-0.3347478509,
1.2357891798,
0.4892978966,
0.6652033329,
-0.237041682,
1.0256929398,
-0.0295103826,
-0.0825662091,
-0.7470211983,
0.6126148105,
-0.4530305266,
0.0625233278,
0.0839277506,
-1.0533810854,
-0.0773274824,
0.890191555,
-0.2544435859,
0.1318946928,
0.7252094746,
0.9955061078,
-0.1292326301,
-0.4695549309,
0.1371330768,
-0.032801155,
0.3840333819,
0.7812398672,
1.0001602173,
-0.4528042674,
0.8560609818,
-0.204610914,
-0.0096948314,
-0.3431800902,
-0.5698426962,
-1.0093584061,
-0.6732746363,
-0.4194116294,
-0.1869455874,
0.3614342511,
0.2592454851,
0.8094079494,
-0.2554023862,
0.042569045,
-0.3590886891,
0.2818420827,
-0.3772732913,
-0.2402289659,
0.3534854352,
-0.4192207158,
-0.6238332987,
0.7356351614,
0.4552240074,
0.2293085307,
-0.6268889308,
-0.4460055828,
0.0799069777,
-0.1585436761,
0.4770528972,
0.3414041698,
-0.7467642426,
-0.3623837829,
-0.1110279933,
0.1763115674,
-0.049430348,
0.6971771121,
-1.0918602943,
0.9292465448,
0.3238812685,
0.1214171275,
0.5562955141,
0.2029817253,
0.8214389682,
-1.1758345366,
0.3622334301,
0.0410873778,
0.2781847715,
0.6712627411,
-0.2453808635,
0.6251789927,
-0.1175064966,
-0.3229268789,
-0.4037318826,
0.462256372,
-1.1182363033,
0.1305487603,
1.3222798109,
-0.0533319302,
-0.5202871561,
-0.1484078318,
-0.6130133271,
0.1296972483,
-0.4423227906,
0.3549393415,
0.1706937402,
0.07201875,
-0.0592676811,
-0.8742536306,
0.9987970591,
0.0233922414,
-0.5935410261,
-0.1442611068,
0.6324616671,
0.2801579833,
0.3195932209,
0.5640707016,
0.286794275,
0.6786831617,
0.2601573467,
0.2147325575,
-0.1825518012,
-0.5902087688,
-0.2601774037,
-0.1832994372,
0.0935530886,
-0.6118364334
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02558v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02558v1
|
Enhancing Robustness in Biomedical NLI Models: A Probing Approach for Clinical Trials
| 2024-02-04T16:18:01 | 2024-02-04T16:18:01 |
Ata Mustafa
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models have revolutionized various fields and industries, such
as Conversational AI, Content Generation, Information Retrieval, Business
Intelligence, and Medical, to name a few. One major application in the field of
medical is to analyze and investigate clinical trials for entailment
tasks.However, It has been observed that Large Language Models are susceptible
to shortcut learning, factual inconsistency, and performance degradation with
little variation in context. Adversarial and robust testing is performed to
ensure the integrity of models output. But, ambiguity still persists. In order
to ensure the integrity of the reasoning performed and investigate the model
has correct syntactic and semantic understanding probing is used. Here, I used
mnestic probing to investigate the Sci-five model, trained on clinical trial. I
investigated the model for feature learnt with respect to natural logic. To
achieve the target, I trained task specific probes. Used these probes to
investigate the final layers of trained model. Then, fine tuned the trained
model using iterative null projection. The results shows that model accuracy
improved. During experimentation, I observed that size of the probe has affect
on the fine tuning process.
|
[
-0.0188762564,
-0.9560256004,
0.6370116472,
0.1135139391,
-0.049960833,
-0.2200505883,
-0.1261844486,
-0.5464040041,
0.1687601805,
0.5681376457,
-0.3326678872,
-0.6060960889,
-0.6200726032,
0.3281498551,
-0.2046339214,
1.0105341673,
0.2364391834,
0.4251915216,
-0.3181668818,
-0.6027449369,
-0.4073511362,
-0.4491437078,
-0.7653335929,
-0.3043588102,
0.5529559851,
-0.0262552034,
0.6512444615,
0.7220104933,
0.9339996576,
0.3568025827,
-0.3403165936,
0.1526498944,
-0.519100368,
0.2416584045,
-0.407073915,
-0.857237339,
-0.4815910459,
-0.0827977732,
0.4763969481,
1.1186443567,
-0.1081758142,
0.0023809266,
-0.0239360351,
0.4248635471,
-0.5205143094,
-0.1254011095,
-0.8301889896,
-0.118821837,
0.0785647333,
-0.3083779216,
-0.507942915,
-0.2661792636,
0.1553460509,
-0.6076715589,
0.4420565665,
-0.0247480534,
0.9389074445,
0.4679863453,
-0.6412722468,
-0.3385848701,
-0.5815800428,
0.9291228652,
-0.9425296187,
0.3579971194,
0.4080329239,
0.1558611989,
-0.3372592032,
-0.9541170597,
-0.2016035169,
-0.6120738387,
-0.0759190693,
0.1240701154,
-0.0459089093,
0.2387842089,
0.4620159268,
0.1707102954,
-0.6496786475,
0.2138313949,
-0.3369165361,
-0.3965736926,
0.5791831613,
0.3634966314,
0.2588731945,
-0.1484973282,
-0.2170870155,
-0.0836120769,
-0.6967872381,
0.0342871323,
0.0653651953,
0.3711911142,
0.1657034457,
0.6449545622,
-0.101980865,
0.5620132089,
-0.0587837473,
-0.1050056517,
0.2071121335,
-0.7255270481,
-0.1487780809,
-0.0905589014,
0.7105572224,
0.2670245171,
-0.0297835916,
-0.1124621555,
-0.0095050763,
0.38575086,
0.6580459476,
-0.9705221057,
-0.2480489314,
0.5706850886,
-0.6550030112,
-0.5753034949,
-0.3649673164,
-0.6231762767,
-0.2593182325,
-0.0732467026,
0.5901869535,
-0.8729793429,
-0.062267229,
0.4194771945,
-0.1310000271,
0.0776436776,
0.1515290588,
-0.7264723182,
0.257316947,
0.6973696947,
0.7136832476,
0.0513500161,
-0.1285287589,
-0.6377809644,
0.0866993815,
-0.3560872972,
0.4826454818,
-0.360396713,
-0.5064017177,
-0.2762389481,
-0.1275053769,
-0.3865988851,
-0.6417642832,
0.7083547115,
-0.3038060069,
0.2350136489,
-0.1162707955,
-0.7414691448,
-0.013007368,
0.6055559516,
-0.4676786661,
0.5731614828,
-0.1160366386,
-0.8714499474,
0.4601442814,
-0.9327558875,
-0.4342889488,
-0.0545078591,
-0.231016919,
-0.7259050012,
0.3581611812,
0.3217722774,
0.286327213,
0.0469897836,
0.3437692225,
-0.680144012,
-0.2660115063,
0.5007631779,
-0.1916309148,
0.7976554036,
0.1114909798,
-0.3721691668,
0.3648941517,
-0.8968541026,
0.1381193697,
0.1609538496,
-0.0463428646,
-0.5352028012,
0.0046662982,
-0.0441868454,
-0.1446992457,
-0.0141550852,
-0.6866003275,
0.0419528708,
-0.9119963646,
0.444291532,
0.3104142249,
0.2184188813,
0.174594447,
-0.2634156644,
0.2783676982,
0.0446034223,
0.4988184571,
-0.077029027,
-0.456918031,
-0.5712393522,
-0.3582774997,
0.7819343209,
0.5065057874,
-0.6681003571,
0.3412812054,
-0.0790850967,
-0.4940631986,
-0.6258081198,
-0.1133532226,
0.2432494015,
0.6756894588,
0.4318374097,
-0.3548030853,
-0.3346850872,
-0.9493101835,
-0.26857391,
-0.1338672936,
-0.2694422305,
0.3433853686,
0.8941665888,
-0.4635307193,
0.547557652,
-0.4710507691,
-0.3231217861,
-0.1162036583,
0.2801438868,
0.3063966632,
0.6044023037,
0.6170725226,
-0.9912198782,
-0.0373567194,
0.0215256531,
-0.774615109,
0.0191018004,
-0.0902973264,
-0.1314338446,
-0.1786418259,
0.4901812375,
-0.6168802977,
0.5139476657,
0.350772202,
-0.3743216097,
0.4324623048,
-0.3378393352,
0.0672836378,
-1.040797472,
0.4852433801,
-0.1414791346,
-0.1770203114,
-0.7695816755,
0.3873265684,
0.2063607126,
0.0251688063,
-0.1391650736,
0.2768423855,
-0.2958447039,
0.2993970215,
-0.3930627704,
-0.1464991271,
0.1004961133,
0.0526576452,
-0.1374043077,
0.5832719803,
0.4923008382,
-0.6223041415,
-0.1356157511,
0.3494817019,
-0.0934838429,
0.3358751237,
-1.1096599102,
0.0352594219,
-0.0233022217,
-0.0413287468,
-0.7314102054,
-0.2191622853,
-0.0567414723,
-0.8072978854,
0.2597275078,
-0.0151093872,
-0.2912012637,
-0.0132676,
-0.2603780925,
0.3417373002,
0.3482626379,
-0.2525655031,
0.6322616935,
0.2153379023,
-0.0469094068,
-0.5492236614,
-0.4188056886,
-0.0444891788,
-0.3416847587,
-0.5786238909,
0.2527183592,
-0.0498089232,
-0.2838967741,
-0.1523282677,
0.005240445,
-0.1048788726,
0.395641923,
0.1386186481,
0.4087165892,
-0.4330995679,
0.0299270116,
0.1009620205,
-0.0648914054,
0.2905414104,
-0.0033018852,
0.2599822581,
0.0377895124,
-0.542432189,
-0.3768506348,
0.6075553894,
0.7801558971,
-0.422023803,
0.749111712,
0.6870961785,
-0.5987423062,
-0.0188162681,
-0.4383223951,
-0.6372944713,
-0.4806677997,
0.4795726836,
-0.2540034652,
-0.9780002236,
0.5913872719,
-0.2835712731,
-0.1764411777,
0.3966274858,
0.5559731126,
-0.0848202482,
1.481292367,
0.8158482313,
0.1809801608,
0.029776264,
-0.1091543362,
0.3557311594,
-0.7345756292,
-0.0779894218,
-0.7388582826,
-0.1259808242,
-0.5560860038,
-0.1807031482,
0.8550850749,
-0.0764249936,
0.1703926176,
-0.0525265634,
-0.3290812671,
0.1923926026,
0.4685738981,
0.3520715237,
0.1461863667,
-0.2470495403,
-0.4177665114,
-0.2655115724,
-0.7995208502,
-0.4385153651,
1.2129038572,
0.5523931384,
0.6688603163,
0.0799152553,
0.4784965217,
-0.2300121486,
0.2130700648,
-0.7342877984,
0.2593465447,
0.0272685755,
-0.6936746836,
-0.1573015898,
-0.5784637928,
-1.049977541,
0.1436010599,
-0.2988301218,
-0.6219713092,
0.3756683171,
0.2019018233,
-0.7009574175,
0.0612970516,
-0.556643784,
0.8814370632,
-0.1974159777,
-0.516633451,
-0.1469913274,
-0.875336051,
0.189684242,
0.054590147,
-0.126835674,
0.1318096519,
0.0705088675,
0.4717559814,
-0.1949043125,
0.938375771,
0.0651233345,
0.1902140826,
-0.1774119437,
0.1366557628,
0.3404060602,
0.261818558,
-0.0877165794,
0.0548680276,
0.3174409866,
-0.6148509383,
-0.6702916026,
0.4592124522,
-0.4337199926,
-0.4728641212,
-0.3756049275,
-0.7217887044,
-0.5235072374,
0.1684131771,
0.35344401,
0.574819684,
-0.2612920403,
0.4334820509,
0.9891535044,
-0.3352662325,
-0.0987477973,
0.3389110267,
0.0218920819,
-0.1793203503,
0.5276655555,
-0.2609879076,
0.519569993,
0.2784617543,
0.2551054955,
-0.3436719477,
-1.2259922028,
-0.0710624456,
0.3798725009,
-0.4401034117,
-0.1500921696,
-0.7442634106,
-0.2341969162,
-0.7209315896,
0.0696426332,
-0.5531737208,
-0.1918564737,
-0.2197352797,
0.1116829142,
0.219599545,
0.4544512928,
0.0738288462,
0.0171679892,
-0.8277403116,
0.2228197008,
-0.0136081893,
0.131792292,
-0.3881826997,
-0.4186778367,
-0.0936650708,
0.1604686528,
-0.1951933503,
-0.7388169169,
0.5381664038,
0.2627218366,
0.5420531631,
0.4746099114,
-0.0228110235,
0.6035434604,
-0.3606052995,
0.5978595018,
-0.1121076941,
-0.7615820765,
0.9077499509,
-0.5454463363,
0.3003731966,
0.7454490066,
0.5222387314,
-0.1185729504,
-0.5302278399,
-0.6374211311,
-0.8940073848,
0.1163080186,
0.2497742474,
-0.0068913233,
0.1428895742,
0.626619339,
0.1783044487,
0.133176744,
-0.4273353517,
0.116804406,
0.0323276445,
-0.4055044353,
0.0609002635,
-0.1425751001,
-0.6453416944,
-0.2896770835,
0.5506430268,
-0.5986937284,
0.27159518,
0.4923024476,
-0.0326951332,
0.3496122658,
0.2084802687,
0.7306452394,
0.7007699013,
-0.427334398,
0.0817532465,
0.3077153862,
-0.7485194802,
-0.2140951306,
0.1202978492,
-0.1670981497,
-0.0896980241,
0.5939695239,
0.7061252594,
0.1058145911,
-0.7833658457,
0.5197715163,
-0.2783622146,
-0.3253481388,
-0.0687430426,
0.1553992778,
-0.1112502292,
0.3174993694,
-0.0384389348,
0.2634768486,
0.5937454104,
-0.4272599816,
0.297770977,
0.5589255691,
-0.5962206125,
-0.1478738636,
0.8826191425,
-0.0178444292,
0.0341071784,
0.70459342,
0.0872664601,
-0.6261738539,
0.6953907609,
0.6960762739,
0.3902320564,
-0.2429675013,
0.0109076779,
0.3743788898,
0.4461070001,
0.0719835013,
0.3678643703,
0.1741504073,
-0.7528972626,
-0.4083037674,
-0.3352352679,
-0.5120363235,
0.1867503822,
-0.8535498977,
0.0301994234,
-0.466940105,
-0.4096574783,
0.2484374791,
0.0363501869,
-0.3199876547,
0.3929601312,
-0.1932135969,
0.937568903,
-0.7915754318,
0.8426927924,
0.6472904682,
-0.2376253754,
-0.7548871636,
-0.1373505294,
-0.0160205606,
-0.5243617296,
0.5099306703,
0.0915604234,
0.068135649,
-0.3157771826,
-0.6015828252,
-0.7768819332,
0.8346366882,
0.2933093309,
-0.2732230127,
0.0903176442,
0.0860251337,
0.8619287014,
-0.2622410655,
0.2521215379,
0.4030195773,
0.1499065161,
0.0318611376,
-0.943827033,
0.1338449568,
-0.5391153097,
-0.0725633502,
0.0764028654,
-0.226741612,
0.5934967399,
-0.4133980572,
0.0555224828,
0.4942568541,
0.5516123772,
0.4138779342,
0.5742864013,
0.5511431694,
0.3914451897,
0.9323397875,
-0.2199489623,
1.1542099714,
-0.1960478723,
0.3017753065,
0.9092592597,
-0.575887382,
0.8011987209,
0.7050496936,
0.139634043,
0.0164660346,
0.5587040782,
-0.1483477652,
0.4171688855,
0.1609718949,
-0.1263785511,
-0.2126007676,
-0.3110922277,
-0.3930724561,
0.6418578625,
0.6465952992,
-0.4892645776,
0.0586660802,
0.1776434183,
0.0041739554,
0.1213107109,
-0.0141211571,
0.6760630012,
-0.0078635011,
-0.5446909666,
0.4341367781,
-0.0027716302,
0.5157037973,
-0.8771820664,
-0.0365318172,
-0.0905829743,
0.5511843562,
0.0744379759,
-0.2880262434,
0.4594779015,
-0.2747201025,
0.0834519714,
0.1999411583,
0.9094107747,
-0.2019183338,
-0.5462725163,
0.3419904411,
0.3463723361,
-0.080883719,
0.0361346416,
-0.775151372,
0.1659418941,
-0.0967341214,
-0.0927299783,
0.3038524985,
0.2775804996,
-0.0313081332,
0.7202773094,
0.7358683944,
0.3042021692,
-0.0839318112,
0.1145469174,
0.7303412557,
-0.5458366871,
-0.2781062722,
-0.74042207,
0.4160614908,
-0.3703196943,
-0.4892279208,
0.7381634116,
0.4914423227,
0.4532229602,
0.0588462129,
0.4138429165,
0.3042348623,
0.6399465203,
-0.7097568512,
0.9426863194,
-0.5206606388,
0.0427617803,
0.0383632593,
-0.3528754413,
-0.7792134285,
0.55162251,
-0.1491792351,
0.0847628862,
0.8698025942,
1.0421265364,
-0.0900555104,
0.3151702285,
0.3967708945,
0.5715892911,
0.4727256894,
0.5354469419,
0.6492302418,
-0.6170065403,
0.0462208763,
-0.3922792673,
-0.3133229911,
-0.0476193652,
-0.7161365151,
-1.0084137917,
-0.3356207907,
-0.4371509552,
-0.5424607396,
0.2123404145,
0.709869206,
0.7784354091,
-0.9615423083,
0.0543875284,
0.0614744537,
-0.1804473847,
-0.4166461825,
-0.1546643525,
0.4652789235,
-0.3275786042,
-0.6129083037,
0.6157993078,
0.329488039,
-0.0719082654,
-0.0603751838,
0.3591286242,
-0.2927574217,
0.1294219792,
0.4477157295,
0.1046348959,
-0.398093015,
-0.2563603222,
0.3370204568,
-0.1901922673,
-0.1273357272,
0.8414068818,
-0.5834658146,
0.4111920893,
0.3358138204,
0.9224204421,
0.2562416494,
-0.2455300093,
0.7836884856,
-0.4681344926,
0.0881140009,
0.5398410559,
0.3180282712,
0.3640520275,
-0.6074717045,
0.6224153042,
0.134447366,
-0.7084690332,
-1.0246396065,
0.1168989837,
-1.0416824818,
-0.3342135549,
0.8423215747,
-0.0603544973,
-0.4245132506,
-0.2207034826,
-0.1548550576,
0.2434844673,
0.1956195682,
1.0254743099,
0.4810636342,
-0.271140188,
0.3548934162,
-0.8327046633,
0.4949842989,
0.9892761111,
-0.8369581103,
-0.396366775,
0.192624554,
0.3804207444,
0.3181328773,
0.3448667526,
-0.4218754172,
0.4044427574,
0.0281939059,
-0.2353484333,
0.1527599692,
-0.1865345389,
-0.5369874835,
0.3485274017,
0.011513765,
-0.3785331547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02555v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02555v1
|
Generalizable Entity Grounding via Assistance of Large Language Model
| 2024-02-04T16:06:05 | 2024-02-04T16:06:05 |
Lu Qi, Yi-Wen Chen, Lehan Yang, Tiancheng Shen, Xiangtai Li, Weidong Guo, Yu Xu, Ming-Hsuan Yang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
In this work, we propose a novel approach to densely ground visual entities
from a long caption. We leverage a large multimodal model (LMM) to extract
semantic nouns, a class-agnostic segmentation model to generate entity-level
segmentation, and the proposed multi-modal feature fusion module to associate
each semantic noun with its corresponding segmentation mask. Additionally, we
introduce a strategy of encoding entity segmentation masks into a colormap,
enabling the preservation of fine-grained predictions from features of
high-resolution masks. This approach allows us to extract visual features from
low-resolution images using the CLIP vision encoder in the LMM, which is more
computationally efficient than existing approaches that use an additional
encoder for high-resolution images. Our comprehensive experiments demonstrate
the superiority of our method, outperforming state-of-the-art techniques on
three tasks, including panoptic narrative grounding, referring expression
segmentation, and panoptic segmentation.
|
[
-0.7081280351,
-0.8835287094,
0.6567937136,
0.0462078825,
-0.6641810536,
-0.1479803026,
-0.471003145,
-0.5963696241,
0.3860020638,
0.7561272383,
-0.3200595081,
-0.7625439167,
-0.5968558788,
-0.1129399166,
-0.2769108713,
0.6492176652,
0.0615287498,
-0.0868876427,
-0.4824269116,
-0.2635728121,
-0.5830739737,
-0.4379469752,
-0.2785034776,
-0.0249974765,
0.3935699463,
0.3821589649,
0.7623135448,
0.9430168271,
0.5732753277,
0.2863807082,
0.0738565251,
0.391272366,
-0.152969256,
0.045317132,
-0.4229680002,
-0.2476160526,
-0.3085801601,
-0.023174338,
0.7769219875,
0.7877701521,
0.0536061674,
0.0067608845,
-0.2803210914,
0.3845524788,
-0.8799248338,
0.4271787703,
-0.732349515,
-0.0823580176,
-0.0667899624,
-0.246628195,
-0.398278743,
0.2840518653,
0.1156851947,
-0.6946021914,
0.2993870974,
0.2361385673,
1.4864504337,
0.3349856734,
-0.2807524204,
0.0951001719,
-0.6077531576,
0.838891685,
-0.3036745787,
0.5226157904,
0.1453600824,
0.4278644323,
0.2065338641,
-0.628415525,
-0.6823533177,
-0.1531922221,
0.0001124384,
0.0439629517,
0.054138042,
0.2597443163,
0.4836093783,
0.473762691,
-0.0853042454,
0.0403188094,
-0.3792835474,
-0.1897449344,
0.3664932549,
-0.080072701,
0.6645668149,
-0.4946110249,
-0.7594279647,
-0.0949969664,
-0.5562285185,
-0.0427641869,
-0.0882345811,
0.1388690025,
-0.0338204764,
0.8243916631,
-0.2918809354,
0.669785738,
-0.0566178598,
-0.3924805522,
0.1390741169,
-0.062473204,
-0.4205773771,
-0.0449695326,
0.6630690098,
0.8941401839,
0.2990992069,
-0.4181416035,
-0.1750479192,
0.4603034258,
0.164133966,
-0.9750548005,
-0.1500151753,
0.0520655699,
-0.3921061456,
0.1121766791,
0.2547013462,
-1.1449253559,
-0.2904100716,
-0.6789582372,
0.3144621253,
-0.4455819428,
-0.0941014737,
0.0955319554,
-0.1820380688,
0.417383343,
0.4899175763,
-0.8085554838,
0.2538354099,
0.4742342532,
0.9299506545,
-0.3588171303,
-0.1842301935,
-0.4903935492,
0.6678900719,
-0.1777741611,
0.7574265599,
-0.7411752939,
0.0964900032,
0.0334866233,
0.311873138,
0.1249614656,
-0.5988017917,
0.4832660854,
-0.7641544938,
-0.1274243295,
-0.0789646506,
-0.3306564689,
-0.4534088671,
0.5097362399,
-0.8223965168,
0.5176667571,
0.0258768983,
-0.7780162692,
0.5286745429,
-0.5313892365,
-0.2655899823,
-0.033745233,
-0.4548845291,
-0.3674155772,
0.0529834777,
0.8114322424,
0.6810443997,
-0.41654706,
0.479708463,
-0.3245797753,
-0.1349301934,
-0.1292566806,
0.0134250307,
0.444239974,
-0.0910046101,
-0.3509832621,
0.3198093176,
-0.8788694143,
-0.2490971386,
0.3085196018,
-0.1907654405,
-0.5474459529,
0.0651974231,
0.1027525812,
0.3449776471,
-0.059454672,
-0.5012161732,
0.1862426698,
-0.1125143543,
0.4660950005,
0.4094839394,
0.2023125738,
0.7753866911,
0.1251916736,
0.277887702,
0.4109545648,
-0.2504989505,
-0.8542165756,
-0.2953261137,
-0.9258093834,
-0.7552449703,
0.308085382,
0.4388146996,
-0.9648249745,
0.4936869144,
-0.6200896502,
-0.229262501,
-0.1523060948,
0.0085410206,
0.0567008853,
0.6763734221,
0.7071188688,
-0.5039149523,
-0.3915626407,
-1.3534944057,
0.4128944278,
0.1413695514,
-0.2031885833,
0.35319525,
0.5834346414,
-0.4364269078,
1.1352331638,
-0.7495045662,
-0.5868455172,
-0.0380144529,
-0.131259948,
-0.0714776441,
0.787343204,
0.5820500255,
-0.9708746672,
0.1608831435,
-0.0107380385,
-0.9344924688,
0.2209650129,
-0.1758475751,
-0.2852736712,
-0.1917414218,
0.7140691876,
-1.0274236202,
0.2169634551,
0.2459656298,
-0.2352038771,
0.2637393773,
-0.0731817037,
0.1911480278,
-0.9727427363,
-0.0038798922,
0.1957707554,
-0.3886359036,
-0.3991441727,
0.5450612903,
0.2487959266,
-0.4938975573,
-0.3092555404,
0.3134587705,
-0.886292994,
-0.2021345049,
-0.2039734423,
0.1843170673,
0.2917361856,
0.6998029947,
0.385782063,
0.4385259151,
0.8943178654,
-0.6070200801,
0.5225120187,
0.2151047587,
-0.3892990351,
0.6054944992,
-0.5785310268,
-0.0604880489,
-0.6027000546,
0.3355133235,
-0.7581928372,
-0.628375411,
0.2745738328,
0.0188598298,
0.3591893017,
-0.3606835604,
-0.5080363154,
-0.1030700728,
-0.174498111,
0.615994215,
0.2861696184,
-0.4968457818,
0.9295915961,
0.5650931001,
-0.0488831326,
-0.2861889899,
-0.6462646127,
0.3135282397,
-0.4520829916,
-0.8219761252,
0.5765548348,
0.2523438632,
-0.1791983545,
-0.0965715349,
0.0630654469,
-0.1865104586,
-0.0578999929,
0.5056589842,
0.3141697049,
-0.4710035324,
0.2530386448,
0.013889919,
-0.0196774844,
0.0723513663,
-0.2962437272,
0.6060615778,
-0.0569185801,
-0.3103471398,
-0.2660239339,
0.6410731673,
0.7512885332,
-0.709599793,
0.5513201356,
0.5565825701,
-0.8450761437,
-0.0485351123,
-0.7438140512,
0.0205520131,
-0.3694018424,
0.4361819327,
-0.4051451981,
-0.8390020132,
0.5766621828,
-0.3301151991,
-0.1824449599,
0.5734075904,
0.2889014781,
0.1629362255,
0.7888371348,
0.7997769713,
0.0126738595,
0.3838683963,
-0.4600688815,
-0.0486009233,
-0.8965831995,
-0.3318914473,
-0.136365965,
-0.270306766,
-0.1181272641,
-0.9577392936,
0.2477244139,
0.532120049,
0.0759183541,
0.0450436883,
-0.4168012142,
0.7677215934,
0.5055527091,
0.3414681256,
0.1858019978,
0.1850206852,
-0.0150522636,
-0.0937644467,
-0.2612621486,
-0.4023464918,
0.6290298104,
0.6105470061,
0.5154668689,
-0.0785183311,
0.538097918,
0.0737597346,
0.0338916592,
-1.0026390553,
0.6495550275,
0.0581896678,
-0.5325371027,
-0.4457808435,
-0.1071293503,
-0.6675595045,
0.678693831,
-0.384373188,
-0.6787061691,
0.2681510746,
-0.1074322313,
-0.3465797305,
0.3170080483,
-0.7079592943,
0.9274938107,
0.078256771,
-0.3030184805,
0.0539656617,
-0.6929885149,
0.4713959992,
0.047332596,
0.2134111524,
-0.3166689873,
-0.2825186551,
0.7395012975,
-0.0986771956,
0.7215113044,
-0.4063971639,
-0.1817084849,
0.3824736476,
-0.221352607,
0.3044050634,
0.2279782146,
0.4406437278,
0.3549954891,
-0.5123460889,
-0.4035807848,
-0.6427400708,
0.5598982573,
-0.5627188683,
-0.6472038031,
-0.112525396,
-0.3943482935,
-0.1633586287,
0.4276181161,
0.1283764243,
0.4463127553,
-0.0201136861,
0.2077910751,
0.6573334336,
-0.1552967578,
0.5445794463,
-0.0614270605,
-0.146761477,
-0.7602363229,
0.8883281946,
0.0180451982,
0.0222039353,
0.4725046456,
0.0071626399,
-0.0632702187,
-0.7271010876,
-0.7698946595,
0.29388991,
-0.9045840502,
-0.4781817794,
-0.8842750788,
0.0445821732,
-0.2168423235,
-0.3055732548,
-0.3213909864,
-0.1892711818,
-0.3066322207,
-0.1542546749,
-0.0872648656,
0.195419237,
0.3453330994,
0.2854736447,
-0.7590077519,
0.9285579324,
0.5816167593,
0.1531717479,
-0.1192080453,
-0.1767110229,
-0.0844868943,
-0.1604389101,
-0.0871286467,
-0.8246514797,
0.2406391203,
0.2961094379,
0.442455858,
0.6702905893,
-0.051001884,
1.0067800283,
-0.8059933186,
0.9268842936,
0.5313572288,
-0.9407035112,
0.735614717,
-0.42740044,
0.2859461308,
0.2647804022,
0.1506869048,
-0.3066577017,
-0.3079812527,
-0.4673505723,
-1.3061702251,
0.5117277503,
-0.0005470233,
0.2232198417,
-0.2583298981,
0.3239214718,
-0.0304678194,
0.131076172,
-0.8445322514,
-0.0734893605,
-0.3407426476,
0.1214266792,
-0.1435847282,
-0.5147615075,
-0.2958020568,
-0.1892455518,
0.2219153196,
-0.3784776628,
0.1169471219,
0.3495312035,
-0.6744148135,
0.0199101325,
0.274425298,
0.7088626623,
0.7255884409,
-0.0912740901,
0.5509647727,
0.0882891417,
-0.2980228961,
0.0868209526,
0.147513926,
-0.2533910573,
0.0888663232,
0.5281962156,
0.8117532134,
0.4417712092,
-0.663069129,
0.7836098671,
0.3317931294,
-0.0365688391,
-0.2532004714,
-0.1443396658,
0.0022018568,
0.3450389504,
0.4526885748,
-0.0213880017,
0.1314365417,
-0.5516091585,
0.3446382582,
0.3703527749,
-0.2025958747,
-0.301268369,
0.6689576507,
0.2915048897,
0.313768208,
0.4229957461,
-0.0378325768,
-0.5229673386,
0.5598956347,
0.5078837276,
0.6188380122,
0.0241430849,
0.0476536416,
0.4664898515,
0.3688255847,
-0.1433651,
-0.1547028273,
-0.0837579817,
-0.736649096,
-0.5658835769,
-0.7445873022,
-0.1797168106,
0.1168118045,
-0.5322956443,
0.3768767715,
-0.7079859972,
0.0020267242,
0.2063247114,
-0.4654971957,
-0.6727536917,
0.5355798602,
0.6085244417,
0.7026059031,
-0.754186213,
0.5957096219,
0.9961661696,
-0.5990262628,
-0.4882737994,
-0.1157137528,
-0.4916242957,
-0.6399544477,
0.8318251967,
0.667059958,
0.0338619202,
-0.1753645837,
-0.6927963495,
-0.8598700166,
1.1311222315,
0.5857019424,
-0.5485313535,
-0.4299297631,
0.0731443614,
0.1537655443,
-0.6901193261,
-0.0124369189,
0.3524926603,
0.432353735,
0.101676695,
-0.5884318352,
0.1885847747,
-0.0154077066,
0.2882624865,
0.1691056341,
-0.585588038,
0.8381155133,
-0.2056176066,
-0.5540238619,
-0.2092554122,
1.0845489502,
0.0429177321,
0.2102281898,
0.7809887528,
0.829080224,
0.6586175561,
-0.146729663,
0.6635205746,
-0.0824098438,
0.4165398777,
0.896531105,
-0.1109429747,
0.6367086768,
0.7499375939,
0.3909879327,
0.4486610293,
0.3600282669,
-0.3579261899,
0.6123862863,
0.3656100333,
-0.1342879683,
-0.6320403218,
-0.3647644222,
-0.2093351185,
0.7353339195,
0.2705793381,
-0.4579791427,
-0.4502919614,
0.4048391879,
-0.1131636426,
0.0165217575,
-0.7078039646,
0.6654816866,
-0.0650410056,
-0.4576767981,
0.5508194566,
0.2790489793,
0.6480511427,
-0.2679559588,
-0.3873849511,
0.227871418,
-0.0951711461,
-0.130630672,
-0.5669109225,
0.1121158972,
-0.1758902818,
-0.3515992165,
-0.0765594542,
0.9249595404,
-0.639438808,
-0.3653799891,
0.2031309307,
0.2517561316,
0.059230689,
-0.5168771744,
-0.2103239447,
0.2155044377,
-0.3374267817,
-0.0577550493,
0.0691144317,
0.6449232697,
-0.2828377187,
0.377176106,
0.686439395,
-0.0858936757,
0.1103590876,
0.0876826718,
1.1863707304,
-1.0496915579,
-0.6453358531,
-0.8177278042,
0.7093518972,
-0.2618430257,
-0.1076127216,
0.3104090989,
0.5495346785,
0.7498395443,
-0.4287281632,
0.4247450233,
0.1163011044,
-0.0069638346,
-0.9364632368,
0.4958859384,
-0.4361175299,
-0.1634838879,
-0.4039959013,
-1.3372323513,
-0.6411183476,
0.46663782,
-0.0256210547,
-0.3218194246,
0.7108013034,
0.2619149387,
-0.3543927372,
-0.4281196296,
0.5279045701,
-0.1158378199,
0.5059291124,
0.3721198738,
0.778924644,
-0.2839422822,
0.4257595539,
-0.417545706,
-0.2160681337,
-0.1414277852,
-0.7605316639,
-1.1207484007,
-0.4539408684,
-0.4835031629,
-0.0934451371,
-0.306217581,
0.7186278105,
0.8858866096,
-0.707975626,
0.3079670072,
0.2041309029,
-0.0113378838,
0.1922391504,
-0.2199362367,
0.575463593,
-0.2680053711,
-0.8700242639,
0.2978710234,
0.5632933974,
0.0865345597,
-0.2113175541,
0.1828227043,
-0.0638671964,
-0.1611523926,
0.8273373246,
-0.0116318669,
-1.0000401735,
-0.6877458692,
-0.2835526764,
-0.0472529009,
0.2844244242,
0.800508976,
-0.7243036628,
0.3423931003,
0.1401480287,
0.8967499137,
0.406146884,
0.2414152622,
0.2791672051,
-0.8201913834,
0.4851139188,
0.2555162311,
0.7894551754,
0.5256711841,
-0.1696024537,
0.3039020896,
0.4006168246,
-0.0958089679,
-0.681061089,
0.3661020696,
-1.515848875,
-0.0828388184,
1.2386187315,
-0.3103742301,
-0.4757543802,
0.1725315005,
-0.3705622852,
0.0957740322,
-0.3472221196,
0.5217826366,
0.7616020441,
0.3975608945,
-0.5708610415,
-0.3494114578,
0.1059760973,
0.0882501975,
-0.9445335269,
0.0412679277,
0.9097831845,
0.2417565435,
0.8971191049,
0.18970792,
-0.2396181226,
0.2462335825,
-0.0040506059,
0.3580366075,
-0.2516601682,
-0.6986376643,
-0.216947183,
0.7554731369,
-0.2306758314,
-0.4909830987
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02549v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02549v1
|
Are Large Language Models Table-based Fact-Checkers?
| 2024-02-04T15:52:59 | 2024-02-04T15:52:59 |
Hangwen Zhang, Qingyi Si, Peng Fu, Zheng Lin, Weiping Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Table-based Fact Verification (TFV) aims to extract the entailment relation
between statements and structured tables. Existing TFV methods based on
small-scaled models suffer from insufficient labeled data and weak zero-shot
ability. Recently, the appearance of Large Language Models (LLMs) has gained
lots of attraction in research fields. They have shown powerful zero-shot and
in-context learning abilities on several NLP tasks, but their potential on TFV
is still unknown. In this work, we implement a preliminary study about whether
LLMs are table-based fact-checkers. In detail, we design diverse prompts to
explore how the in-context learning can help LLMs in TFV, i.e., zero-shot and
few-shot TFV capability. Besides, we carefully design and construct TFV
instructions to study the performance gain brought by the instruction tuning of
LLMs. Experimental results demonstrate that LLMs can achieve acceptable results
on zero-shot and few-shot TFV with prompt engineering, while instruction-tuning
can stimulate the TFV capability significantly. We also make some valuable
findings about the format of zero-shot prompts and the number of in-context
examples. Finally, we analyze some possible directions to promote the accuracy
of TFV via LLMs, which is beneficial to further research of table reasoning.
|
[
-0.1087482274,
-1.1135044098,
0.886777699,
-0.0913901702,
-0.2876902521,
-0.0238636695,
-0.2257167101,
-0.271722436,
-0.1323490441,
0.6540881991,
-0.3221390247,
-0.7194179893,
-0.5710731745,
0.206049636,
-0.5167160034,
0.7591248751,
-0.1831307858,
-0.1678660214,
-0.3179554343,
0.0167484358,
-0.640059948,
-0.2858049273,
-0.4449166059,
-0.4942465425,
0.3774938881,
0.8856830001,
0.4745012224,
1.005220294,
0.297693342,
0.2698104084,
-0.1340332627,
0.1648242921,
-0.4434273839,
0.0889287591,
-0.146550104,
-0.5346642733,
-0.1976391971,
-0.147547394,
0.718639195,
0.28119573,
-0.1276594847,
0.2957606018,
-0.1636709571,
0.5280290246,
-0.4618774951,
0.5773714185,
-0.6263278723,
0.238117829,
-0.2126532793,
-0.1989038736,
-0.6866678596,
-0.3256152272,
-0.0745660961,
-0.0671011284,
0.204008624,
0.4050792456,
0.9705813527,
0.3338145614,
-0.8230110407,
-0.2906587124,
-0.8976520896,
0.6708458662,
-0.8936274648,
0.6097425222,
0.1818595529,
0.4243169129,
-0.4461811483,
-0.441836983,
-0.9320972562,
-0.4836356044,
-0.2833437324,
-0.3641944826,
0.0409151353,
0.0020965864,
0.7427426577,
0.2306366414,
-0.5607015491,
0.3536570668,
0.0020551938,
-0.1117812768,
0.4320459068,
0.2814321816,
0.3527544737,
-0.1814725697,
-0.2399345636,
0.0429744124,
-1.0755281448,
0.1117735207,
-0.3526769876,
0.22361359,
-0.3328154981,
0.8589788675,
-0.2985723615,
1.1709667444,
-0.1578752697,
-0.6499347091,
0.0074276971,
-0.1913754195,
-0.4250810444,
0.183342427,
0.6963518858,
0.2426043302,
0.1789779216,
-0.3883055151,
-0.3228157759,
-0.1491546631,
-0.1288672984,
-0.9180089831,
0.2486077994,
0.287581116,
-0.2035693526,
-0.2953621149,
-0.1059971079,
-0.6005968451,
-0.369084239,
-0.3084598482,
0.7545933127,
-0.2483798563,
-0.0240190402,
-0.0086067235,
0.0248166341,
0.6645780802,
0.4957248867,
-0.7088649869,
-0.0893591046,
0.9077275395,
0.865091145,
-0.1600761414,
-0.0084761558,
-0.9047363997,
0.270498544,
-0.5317764878,
0.8046747446,
-0.5021318793,
-0.1873976737,
0.2681153715,
-0.0755464956,
0.2174067348,
-0.3792673945,
0.5121202469,
-0.6445631981,
0.057248231,
-0.703559339,
-0.7074924111,
-0.1411145627,
0.858987093,
-0.617859304,
0.7199853659,
-0.1044780239,
-0.5298911333,
0.7142073512,
-0.6445131898,
-0.5824263096,
0.10040842,
-0.439342916,
-0.4786340594,
-0.1329768598,
0.2340394408,
0.6613484621,
-0.4280771613,
0.3975086808,
-0.319031775,
-0.5374124646,
0.4157955945,
-0.1387999058,
0.4893757105,
-0.0559921153,
-0.4180300534,
0.2599655092,
-0.7832391858,
-0.0622543283,
0.0200459063,
-0.536182642,
0.1403497458,
0.1145983115,
-0.3653938174,
0.3363607824,
-0.2427656949,
-0.8270149231,
0.2207000256,
-0.2818120122,
0.4776885211,
0.3207792938,
0.2522811294,
0.2523520887,
-0.3892528117,
0.2670857012,
0.1655859351,
-0.28338781,
-0.1972701102,
-0.3002342582,
-1.0286650658,
-0.1787648052,
0.5118419528,
0.6306311488,
-1.1805397272,
0.4265552759,
-0.1453794539,
-0.3213537037,
0.1846462935,
-0.1746612191,
0.239232108,
1.0583261251,
0.3420986533,
0.2902597785,
-0.4207162857,
-0.8360189199,
-0.1013178974,
-0.1409942061,
-0.0894624516,
0.3779283762,
0.7097892761,
0.2321703583,
0.9394245744,
-0.3300772309,
-0.3085292876,
-0.3356066346,
-0.0219586417,
0.3854739368,
0.1848656386,
0.4540407956,
-0.3044777811,
-0.4666612148,
-0.1357387453,
-0.9440655708,
-0.0095068635,
-0.0041342806,
0.1702763438,
0.4707630277,
0.5598167181,
-0.6698249578,
0.3252795637,
0.1370913088,
-0.3835269511,
0.3033013344,
-0.1707553267,
0.2484337091,
-0.7294238806,
-0.0810019225,
0.2338025868,
-0.3898589909,
-0.7384107709,
0.0911560729,
0.2219298929,
-0.108741872,
-0.6093466878,
0.5066949725,
-0.4341129065,
-0.1130628511,
-0.2724624872,
0.0187877659,
-0.1054742262,
0.4253336489,
0.1616225541,
0.6550756097,
0.588534534,
-0.7681020498,
0.2407059073,
0.1659833342,
-0.7267785072,
0.468714416,
-0.7414572239,
0.0892438293,
-0.2516451478,
0.3583448827,
-1.0130009651,
-0.2466930598,
0.167602092,
-0.0409902111,
0.5264902115,
-0.1072635427,
-0.7169652581,
-0.2306041569,
-0.1736563146,
-0.144053638,
0.4487528205,
-0.7484499812,
0.7168554664,
0.3436757922,
0.2836340964,
-0.8749476075,
-0.6362596154,
0.1522854269,
-0.0474297926,
-0.6740691662,
0.0507883094,
0.2669719458,
-0.4701374471,
-0.2586064339,
-0.3023471236,
0.134948343,
-0.0381657593,
0.2797645926,
0.2788963318,
-0.4149227738,
0.4291450083,
-0.1914255023,
0.1941621751,
0.1378854662,
-0.1221068054,
0.3337224126,
-0.3681235313,
-0.2291656584,
-0.1721316129,
0.0241650883,
0.3243211508,
-0.2573983371,
0.9476283193,
0.5396571159,
-0.3739489913,
-0.4838345945,
-0.9750222564,
-0.2747115195,
-0.4330946803,
0.2670356333,
-0.2639071643,
-1.3431345224,
0.5721107721,
-0.0804725736,
0.1243267357,
0.4874839485,
0.6399689317,
-0.1347167492,
0.5281069279,
0.4628031254,
0.20038414,
0.2019735128,
-0.1768763065,
0.0935512483,
-0.357057631,
-0.5131500363,
-0.8530220985,
-0.313372314,
-0.4564333558,
-0.4181822836,
0.4708615541,
-0.2901831269,
-0.5549326539,
-0.026525896,
-0.1713035703,
0.7965308428,
0.2358751297,
0.2298440188,
0.3691388965,
-0.0926528126,
-0.1059383675,
0.1030325741,
-0.7408086658,
-0.4107489586,
0.8391977549,
0.337667048,
0.71804142,
0.2027879059,
0.4895584583,
0.3740256429,
0.3575396538,
-0.9846464396,
0.6806882024,
-0.0840885341,
-0.5539683104,
-0.6377091408,
-0.6432148218,
-0.426384151,
0.2205065638,
-0.5498720407,
-0.6301424503,
0.079523392,
0.2123956978,
-0.2233163416,
0.4230023324,
-0.629453361,
0.9374759197,
-0.2088111341,
-0.5116263628,
0.0585923195,
-0.3865456581,
0.6206614375,
0.0664989725,
0.099946402,
-0.0498155393,
-0.0371545851,
0.5133909583,
-0.5255920887,
0.7888159752,
-0.2050111741,
-0.2776047885,
0.3885816336,
0.3602020741,
0.7162955999,
0.2155148685,
-0.2393532693,
0.302051127,
-0.1705895066,
0.0571698509,
-0.5971423388,
0.7214433551,
-0.6079080701,
-0.917290926,
-0.4856659472,
-0.4480473697,
-0.345500052,
0.2328706831,
-0.12247587,
0.5496963859,
-0.1794677973,
0.6466793418,
0.9198573828,
-0.0914141014,
0.6346076131,
1.0982992649,
-0.1587299407,
0.0492004901,
0.6989579797,
0.2371363491,
-0.1359604448,
1.0469825268,
0.3524878323,
-0.3313166201,
-0.6251387596,
-0.7357199788,
0.1962624043,
-0.6061962247,
-0.4306420982,
-0.4964694381,
-0.1083624065,
0.0883950144,
0.0338939056,
-0.12721093,
-0.4000855386,
-0.1017371044,
-0.0917818919,
0.3946928084,
0.7146974206,
0.2452264428,
0.1967982501,
-0.7921805978,
0.2219066471,
0.4098225832,
0.5359247923,
0.032988511,
-0.5840296745,
-0.081759885,
-0.1899700165,
0.0061697471,
-0.8587703109,
0.0886041,
0.1451352239,
0.4277442694,
0.3013578951,
-0.003798912,
0.2169652134,
-0.6574432254,
0.8641914725,
-0.168988958,
-1.0125949383,
0.2773806453,
-0.254488647,
0.3129290938,
0.26052019,
0.119310841,
-0.4878340065,
-0.1957615912,
-0.2180497646,
-0.3227288127,
0.9210603833,
-0.0719494373,
-0.1467258036,
0.0391724519,
0.6185265183,
-0.0557615124,
0.2168739587,
-0.6998781562,
-0.189648807,
-0.1474445462,
0.0617384873,
-0.0327929966,
-0.5604209304,
-0.0597321577,
-0.0000501493,
0.5562403798,
-0.1401104927,
-0.0375472046,
-0.022195423,
-0.1036900058,
-0.36197716,
0.7192619443,
0.8008953333,
0.7738441229,
-0.3921531737,
0.2293958217,
0.4146251082,
-0.0206083376,
0.282333225,
-0.2868765295,
-0.5178141594,
0.0438081995,
0.4032533467,
0.9121274948,
0.1233780012,
-0.3749527633,
0.5435109735,
-0.0130342608,
-0.3182614148,
-0.1127475798,
0.3600342274,
0.0680900216,
0.2510333955,
0.1020262614,
-0.3290076554,
-0.0688589364,
-0.6395589113,
0.1773577034,
0.5914196968,
-0.1464832276,
0.0998635441,
0.5360072255,
0.0546623394,
-0.5471592546,
0.6747474074,
-0.1875720918,
-0.3054823279,
0.7062296867,
0.6796481013,
0.4923481047,
-0.0612433814,
0.3178512454,
0.5244933367,
0.4722581804,
-0.331096828,
0.3150303662,
-0.1506280303,
-0.7481080294,
-0.7032732368,
-0.4975080192,
-0.6790291071,
0.5401018262,
-0.124106735,
0.4950957298,
-0.5007254481,
0.0483183414,
0.1161860302,
-0.084081471,
-0.6345945001,
0.2760019004,
0.1092492342,
0.9892165661,
-0.7791260481,
0.7887349725,
0.4411158562,
-0.2652391791,
-1.0375409126,
0.0194054898,
0.0799417421,
-0.6802444458,
0.7685641646,
0.0413070992,
0.0199863352,
-0.3222443163,
-0.7916311026,
-0.9092206359,
1.0142792463,
0.5631715059,
-0.7079792619,
-0.045522254,
0.414121598,
0.5953086615,
-0.2696768641,
0.2781547904,
0.5686095357,
0.5663499832,
0.6771141291,
-0.7826713324,
0.3115004003,
0.2367113084,
-0.159967497,
0.172201246,
-0.4932916462,
0.7049174905,
-0.2555210888,
0.0046147625,
-0.523141861,
0.8077622652,
0.3327889144,
0.1985575706,
0.5319299102,
0.3469452262,
0.4088436961,
-0.2446426004,
0.8824085593,
-0.1959643513,
0.1617689878,
1.1146527529,
-0.5511987209,
0.8685536981,
0.3117527962,
-0.0317256674,
0.5672766566,
0.3007490933,
-0.3578125238,
0.0838722214,
0.1810075492,
-0.0474880263,
-0.4703132808,
-0.2818301022,
-0.2237665206,
0.7451928258,
0.5423710346,
-0.3628619611,
-0.4942902029,
-0.2413998246,
-0.0300839785,
-0.2211032957,
-0.4097357392,
0.8175883889,
0.075696364,
-0.7169545293,
0.5653968453,
0.1683258861,
0.403906703,
-0.5115351081,
-0.3919858336,
-0.0290154628,
0.0641817078,
-0.2574141026,
-0.9616310596,
0.0985447466,
0.0843739063,
0.0299193244,
-0.0376957171,
0.9475616217,
-0.6056140065,
-0.2468553632,
-0.381367594,
0.6272882819,
0.0609021895,
0.0251213647,
-0.2177644223,
0.1020763069,
0.0321953669,
-0.1112952754,
0.2542073131,
0.4543167353,
-0.0754423812,
0.6030550003,
0.3436843753,
-0.0851067677,
-0.407664597,
0.0942909569,
0.5591427684,
-0.5664048791,
-0.4179010391,
-1.1691515446,
0.2201342732,
0.0314675607,
0.1256670952,
0.7955773473,
0.542970717,
0.727665484,
-0.3254316449,
0.449688077,
-0.0221441761,
0.4159229398,
-0.7283774614,
0.7730079889,
-0.492120415,
0.2800271213,
0.0022596337,
-0.7728034258,
-0.6077548862,
0.4381439388,
-0.423564136,
0.0213672202,
0.611251533,
0.8400917649,
0.0430269465,
0.1694769412,
0.4611960053,
0.3501299322,
0.4257432222,
0.4166546762,
0.6531264186,
-0.1151021495,
0.5507867932,
-0.1389950961,
-0.1151562035,
-0.3691488206,
-1.2408491373,
-1.2626224756,
-0.3130901754,
-0.3272025585,
-0.4294599593,
-0.0640868396,
0.9403034449,
0.4133990705,
-0.8546181917,
-0.1932726204,
0.1053712815,
0.5054211617,
0.0632612929,
-0.1704819351,
0.581617415,
-0.1523356736,
-0.200583756,
0.3534168303,
0.3543005288,
0.0272473916,
-0.1521525532,
0.2123902887,
-0.2431002706,
0.0892448276,
0.8406151533,
0.3408095539,
-0.6150429249,
-0.5402494669,
-0.0414653085,
-0.1142199785,
0.21368891,
0.8862922192,
-0.7171120644,
0.222784698,
0.6636718512,
0.5386359692,
0.7077172995,
-0.1235455945,
0.4073509574,
-0.9423158169,
-0.0355142802,
-0.0224606097,
0.556966722,
0.3652832806,
-0.3860342503,
0.3403651118,
-0.0898747593,
-0.6480894685,
-0.8802385926,
0.1699083745,
-0.9244138002,
0.0544341393,
1.2866027355,
0.0489894673,
-0.4605623186,
-0.0353342891,
0.0125053553,
0.3965673447,
-0.4601068497,
0.9824362397,
0.78341645,
-0.1478368044,
-0.2770506442,
-0.4490606487,
0.6699407101,
0.0295146834,
-0.9128603339,
0.061186064,
0.5195046663,
0.4104927778,
0.0785987675,
0.2210249156,
0.0652397871,
0.2056341469,
-0.1337786615,
-0.0794353411,
-0.5709305406,
-0.3207220137,
-0.2823253274,
0.5337708592,
0.1858419925,
0.0995058268
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02548v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02548v1
|
"What's my model inside of?": Exploring the role of environments for grounded natural language understanding
| 2024-02-04T15:52:46 | 2024-02-04T15:52:46 |
Ronen Tamari
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SI
|
In contrast to classical cognitive science which studied brains in isolation,
ecological approaches focused on the role of the body and environment in
shaping cognition. Similarly, in this thesis we adopt an ecological approach to
grounded natural language understanding (NLU) research. Grounded language
understanding studies language understanding systems situated in the context of
events, actions and precepts in naturalistic/simulated virtual environments.
Where classic research tends to focus on designing new models and optimization
methods while treating environments as given, we explore the potential of
environment design for improving data collection and model development. We
developed novel training and annotation approaches for procedural text
understanding based on text-based game environments. We also drew upon embodied
cognitive linguistics literature to propose a roadmap for grounded NLP
research, and to inform the development of a new benchmark for measuring the
progress of large language models on challenging commonsense reasoning tasks.
We leveraged the richer supervision provided by text-based game environments to
develop Breakpoint Transformers, a novel approach to modeling intermediate
semantic information in long narrative or procedural texts. Finally, we
integrated theories on the role of environments in collective human
intelligence to propose a design for AI-augmented "social thinking
environments" for knowledge workers like scientists.
|
[
-0.5240043402,
-1.0503190756,
0.7988206148,
0.1482937634,
-0.0287465155,
0.1803870499,
-0.4094608426,
-0.4980576634,
-0.0292594191,
0.6194812059,
-0.655754745,
-0.5244244337,
-0.2136621922,
0.2140130103,
0.0187441595,
0.4719275534,
0.3943723738,
0.0156141184,
-0.5902659893,
-0.2720898986,
-0.6071567535,
-0.6522126198,
-0.5628036857,
-0.5494183898,
0.1925863326,
0.3400142491,
0.6772637367,
0.5695176125,
0.382989496,
0.3561337888,
-0.5325933695,
-0.0916596726,
-0.3353148103,
0.0966605917,
-0.3106388152,
-0.4478429854,
0.0830710083,
-0.12976183,
0.5086826086,
0.8160972595,
-0.0108433953,
0.0780655444,
0.0892479271,
0.383772999,
-0.3821277618,
0.579493165,
-0.2755182385,
0.2740454376,
0.3180749714,
0.0109370453,
-0.462878257,
-0.0324387103,
0.1158980429,
-0.9654172659,
-0.0096780937,
0.1585586369,
0.6383342147,
0.3361557126,
-0.4182490706,
-0.4395320117,
-0.5198044181,
0.8701416254,
-0.8647282124,
0.4628705382,
0.5588024259,
0.0058862302,
-0.3001568913,
-0.4434415102,
-0.6802656054,
-0.1362684816,
-0.2767766714,
0.4488317966,
-0.1531619281,
0.140120253,
0.1739233285,
0.1849342287,
-0.3188459277,
0.2474213839,
-0.4030408561,
0.2654136419,
0.5752843022,
0.086380735,
0.6056309342,
-0.4144536853,
-0.0563676804,
-0.1029944867,
-0.2706570029,
0.3357120752,
0.1787818074,
0.323910445,
-0.1482972801,
0.5349525809,
-0.1215479597,
0.7638598084,
-0.2623587549,
-0.0168589037,
-0.1513537467,
-0.3004369438,
-0.3061966896,
0.0868086442,
0.3610508442,
0.4476110041,
0.2685527802,
-0.1894244403,
-0.0257448684,
0.2669220567,
0.5676448941,
-0.3195023835,
-0.1759097725,
0.2462061495,
-0.6285914183,
-0.6264572144,
-0.1738552004,
-0.8229563236,
-0.460921973,
-0.9798668027,
0.0186025091,
-0.5538891554,
-0.7688179612,
0.1787739843,
-0.3074239194,
0.3660676777,
0.144547388,
-0.9395380616,
0.7352511883,
1.0303890705,
0.8531939983,
0.1345104128,
-0.2891965806,
0.0048822071,
0.1359487176,
-0.3117866814,
0.6629834175,
-0.5269866586,
-0.5593518615,
0.0918363035,
-0.1294937134,
0.0700993612,
-0.3251200318,
0.5674183965,
-0.3029945791,
0.5234331489,
-0.3746325374,
-0.4478181005,
-0.6304208636,
0.4903760552,
-0.4800582528,
1.1195217371,
-0.2441707104,
-0.780026257,
0.2869073451,
-1.0529395342,
-0.4053753018,
0.1156266704,
-0.1373712867,
0.1611504555,
0.3601883054,
0.2117735445,
0.0660241246,
-0.0321227126,
0.4074784517,
-0.2433262914,
-0.4285378456,
0.2180024236,
-0.1486683041,
0.9858074784,
0.086924471,
-0.3783798516,
0.1248122081,
-0.6395793557,
0.2537277341,
0.1955438852,
-0.2641218901,
-0.7495754361,
0.4527493119,
0.2242910862,
0.2535103858,
-0.0963614881,
-0.3183273673,
0.1473857909,
-0.5100160837,
0.7497751117,
0.5921821594,
-0.0282988288,
0.6930793524,
-0.181855619,
0.1530075967,
-0.3484691978,
-0.1158113703,
-0.3917467296,
-0.5165612102,
-0.6237231493,
-0.0297330599,
-0.1866443306,
0.3979938626,
-0.5632146597,
0.5955908298,
-0.1469260156,
-0.3411677182,
-0.419890821,
-0.1761461645,
0.3675958812,
0.5147355199,
0.3847581148,
-0.127585873,
-0.5154145956,
-0.6718514562,
-0.2092581689,
-0.4746287167,
-0.063777782,
0.4069987833,
0.7069026232,
-0.3115646541,
1.3468292952,
-0.5054417253,
-0.0824469849,
-0.1704277992,
0.1913257837,
0.274984479,
0.6254684329,
0.4575226307,
-0.7332183123,
0.1438496858,
0.1058194339,
-1.185302496,
-0.0665968657,
0.0095904348,
-0.160078004,
-0.2859289646,
0.6390938759,
-0.6417859793,
0.3811469376,
0.4626512527,
-0.576043129,
0.3547901213,
-0.3786646128,
0.218563363,
-0.9495313764,
-0.0187440496,
0.0217673164,
0.0897447243,
-0.7652532458,
0.3732033074,
-0.2552390397,
-0.3636111021,
-0.1054405272,
0.5917146206,
-0.6338657737,
-0.0296096355,
-0.3109009862,
0.3071122766,
0.1033567488,
0.3898377419,
0.4406983852,
0.4228176475,
0.4005976319,
-0.6007266045,
-0.0424775854,
0.4381976724,
-0.2873739004,
0.6614919901,
-0.6466424465,
0.3174713552,
-0.5646074414,
0.1501068473,
-0.7434605956,
-0.302423358,
0.0376946591,
-0.4003716707,
-0.0926659182,
-0.2604726851,
-0.5277050138,
-0.1630531102,
0.1317290664,
0.1216854006,
0.5301976204,
-0.534460783,
0.6609305143,
0.6466374397,
-0.1444407105,
-0.102899611,
-0.8700941205,
0.1675532311,
-0.4635170698,
-0.689424932,
0.1234792694,
0.0035796112,
-1.2146663666,
0.0392944142,
-0.0425312445,
-0.3572847843,
0.4470870495,
0.4359124899,
-0.0892283469,
-0.6044160128,
0.263605535,
0.0430401191,
-0.1338429898,
0.4570788145,
-0.3594276607,
0.1532812864,
-0.1583885103,
-0.0542673953,
-0.0219565909,
0.5741599798,
0.5424445271,
-0.1539147198,
0.9655612707,
0.0071909926,
-0.7098490596,
-0.2346677184,
-0.3492072523,
-0.2512112856,
-0.4505253136,
0.1753447652,
-0.2497808188,
-0.7287976146,
0.3958815932,
-0.0153918406,
0.2578678131,
0.1942247152,
0.3716318905,
-0.3250853419,
0.5283856988,
0.8154472709,
0.1637904942,
0.4723532498,
-0.1185799763,
0.2520935237,
-0.7765046954,
-0.1023189351,
-0.3837477565,
-0.0185950752,
-0.1815118045,
-0.5723535419,
-0.0196452402,
0.1629289091,
-0.3838939667,
0.1708965451,
-0.5310525298,
0.6682240367,
0.4538188875,
0.000794857,
0.3501061797,
-0.2363897115,
-0.1820132881,
-0.3513989449,
-0.6200716496,
-1.1106933355,
0.6315588951,
0.4392715693,
0.2482984662,
0.1879835129,
0.4919971228,
0.1726548076,
0.3923102915,
-0.4877634943,
0.3897225559,
0.460832119,
-0.7098478079,
-0.3447727859,
-0.0695563331,
-0.788515687,
0.6717872024,
-0.249711886,
-0.8049383163,
0.0021770194,
-0.176883176,
-0.2614871264,
0.229690671,
-0.7292817235,
0.8208118081,
-0.2319585979,
-0.3663503528,
-0.2349132448,
-0.6565106511,
0.4913093746,
0.3262763023,
0.830324769,
-0.0956030414,
0.1944802999,
0.4548433721,
0.0630367175,
0.9678964019,
-0.0850369111,
-0.1355274171,
0.3089342713,
0.1805477738,
0.055625055,
0.3947744668,
-0.1390621215,
0.2871002555,
0.1097260639,
-0.2629582286,
-0.4749611914,
0.631486237,
-0.6736021042,
-0.3951732516,
-0.5727589726,
-0.3808660209,
-0.074385725,
0.2069842666,
0.0589047559,
0.2915363312,
-0.5566661954,
0.3465464413,
0.7563444972,
-0.4789575934,
0.3766429126,
0.6031832695,
-0.1878262162,
-0.1246706173,
0.549266696,
-0.16582717,
0.1956998259,
0.2527127266,
0.3027465045,
-0.287309587,
-0.3035649955,
-0.083781004,
-0.0082524577,
-0.9636576772,
0.2085411549,
-0.7517238259,
-0.1317029744,
-0.3194226027,
-0.6298968196,
-0.1595999897,
0.0972695872,
-0.520096302,
-0.4833571911,
0.3613414466,
1.0564841032,
-0.1770413071,
0.3753547966,
-0.5468903184,
0.2890729606,
0.0225635488,
0.2041680813,
0.1431728452,
-0.1171267629,
-0.1017387062,
0.2185008377,
-0.0215274785,
-0.9067590237,
0.5768603683,
-0.0601263754,
0.6771185398,
0.1361063719,
-0.1930167675,
0.6316364408,
-0.5151409507,
0.9251060486,
-0.1382261217,
-1.006346941,
0.6473426819,
-0.6381593347,
0.3758800626,
0.6665671468,
0.0033139025,
-0.8293907642,
-0.4322035015,
-0.7951014638,
-0.781473875,
0.4262436628,
0.4027796686,
0.1783753037,
-0.0192339867,
0.2646881342,
0.0716107711,
0.1300454438,
-0.8836259246,
0.0289507601,
-0.1931493878,
-0.2365801781,
-0.3384765387,
-0.0483678468,
-0.2032372952,
-0.350259006,
0.2752898335,
-0.3666504622,
0.2071201503,
0.1824207455,
-0.2407822609,
0.0694946796,
0.1950212717,
0.5261005759,
0.6175663471,
-0.0005445427,
0.3097464144,
0.2784968913,
-0.3568528593,
0.0044656056,
-0.3081234097,
-0.1165162697,
-0.1520331353,
0.6294292808,
0.3914653361,
0.8461925387,
-0.7224014997,
-0.1096483544,
-0.1685732156,
-0.1615071148,
-0.4942177832,
0.0392244793,
0.3825990856,
0.1808667332,
0.2308669239,
-0.0343163908,
0.1436072588,
-0.7501550913,
0.2430952191,
0.1282151192,
-0.5638229251,
-0.3004328907,
0.61082232,
0.1889901012,
-0.5007340312,
0.8848106265,
0.083377406,
-0.3889077604,
0.9902231097,
0.5524007678,
0.7637681961,
0.3369033337,
0.1712494791,
0.5078172684,
0.5812501311,
-0.145700857,
0.1035628244,
-0.1161950901,
-0.8503811359,
-0.3569256961,
-0.4917075336,
-0.4699825943,
0.0129162269,
-0.5449134707,
0.1723538488,
-0.5723196268,
0.0641161501,
-0.0394050404,
-0.1450453252,
-0.5530078411,
0.3248798251,
0.3130569458,
0.6424663663,
-0.9276216626,
0.4431343377,
0.5918777585,
-0.4893741012,
-0.4260686338,
-0.0083061662,
0.2488634437,
-0.2765559852,
0.6302903295,
0.2751399279,
-0.0129772685,
0.0982542485,
-0.8469623923,
-1.0376406908,
0.8184633851,
-0.0632391647,
-0.0597109646,
0.1136425734,
-0.3018056452,
0.7701165676,
-0.3706942797,
0.2690370083,
0.7005368471,
0.6409108639,
-0.3438192606,
-0.3648530841,
-0.1370639801,
-0.447922796,
-0.1722425371,
-0.0453399606,
-0.5534240603,
0.6990941763,
-0.0071161338,
-0.208580628,
-0.0142964078,
0.7080790401,
0.4789047837,
0.4146436453,
0.179727748,
0.5622506738,
0.6202247143,
-0.2526264191,
1.0176286697,
0.0694909692,
0.2640942633,
0.9910625815,
-0.2180119902,
0.6060464978,
0.558622539,
0.1281224638,
0.5269385576,
0.6812762022,
0.2714158893,
0.4519292414,
0.5568351746,
-0.2229479402,
-0.0418681018,
-0.1753773391,
-0.1527578384,
0.440061748,
0.681409359,
-0.0813831463,
-0.0640344247,
0.0742710456,
-0.0986198932,
0.6797807813,
-0.0246882625,
0.9882739186,
0.1969076693,
-0.6376680732,
-0.0200792607,
0.0383236818,
0.4739790559,
-0.3429913819,
-0.2658158243,
-0.1402187347,
0.0107880142,
-0.0345308855,
-0.8969175816,
0.4481334388,
-0.0293532722,
-0.0892931893,
-0.6870754957,
0.6659657359,
-0.1634767354,
-0.4348379672,
0.3345207274,
0.4128266871,
0.1149559841,
0.0905992016,
-0.5937767029,
0.2045686245,
-0.3115856051,
-0.2315225899,
-0.0069436175,
0.7273083329,
0.0553559586,
0.6182021499,
0.8564232588,
-0.2753412724,
-0.0213452652,
-0.1059954092,
0.6782153249,
-1.0005195141,
-0.6758624315,
-0.7259715199,
0.6873323917,
-0.3578164279,
-0.6821513772,
0.6931769848,
0.4230866134,
0.5026314855,
-0.1833588481,
0.8042886853,
-0.1679621786,
0.1381723136,
-0.6670390368,
0.686884284,
-0.2330942154,
-0.1467828453,
-0.4654068649,
-0.8542613983,
-0.3588515222,
0.9422575235,
-0.260720849,
-0.191741392,
0.6057493091,
0.2277801186,
-0.0646788627,
0.3286989331,
0.2338036746,
0.1263619363,
0.5045152307,
0.227292344,
1.061825633,
-0.0451963842,
-0.263472259,
-0.2092538029,
-0.0699280649,
0.1064468697,
-0.8940376043,
-1.026332736,
-0.5290857553,
-0.2041186243,
-0.1698233336,
-0.1145152301,
0.9318887591,
0.6088302135,
-0.5150693655,
-0.5035043359,
-0.5615950227,
0.1758835912,
-0.3049531579,
-0.3318113089,
0.054912705,
-0.3908571601,
-0.6394247413,
0.8243390918,
0.5055345297,
-0.0422250964,
-0.3886692822,
0.0038044434,
-0.4734067619,
0.2527065277,
0.5698091984,
0.3566501737,
-0.9578888416,
-0.3771138489,
0.2690077126,
-0.0903745964,
0.0260456912,
0.8564428091,
-0.7629447579,
0.5681965947,
0.3423295021,
0.5942875147,
0.2860502005,
-0.0356259719,
0.9622842669,
-0.4261308312,
0.5270734429,
0.4872345328,
0.2401060164,
0.3896151185,
-0.5121160746,
0.7706637383,
0.1796289086,
-0.3688206971,
-0.8648095727,
-0.0568082854,
-0.7538485527,
-0.4469569623,
1.0873771906,
0.121518299,
-0.4712204933,
-0.3292099237,
-0.488776654,
0.0207438711,
-0.0754062906,
0.7754248977,
1.1820862293,
0.2567495406,
-0.4119443297,
-0.9784393311,
0.4250691235,
0.271422714,
-0.9923559427,
0.0439407229,
0.5602494478,
0.0244911667,
0.322520107,
0.4781787992,
0.1431802809,
-0.0425776429,
0.262639761,
0.1541114748,
0.1602900475,
0.0203250684,
-0.3753024936,
-0.0343865454,
-0.1130430028,
0.135490194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02547v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02547v2
|
Integration of cognitive tasks into artificial general intelligence test for large models
| 2024-02-04T15:50:42 | 2024-03-06T02:46:40 |
Youzhi Qu, Chen Wei, Penghui Du, Wenxin Che, Chi Zhang, Wanli Ouyang, Yatao Bian, Feiyang Xu, Bin Hu, Kai Du, Haiyan Wu, Jia Liu, Quanying Liu
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
During the evolution of large models, performance evaluation is necessarily
performed to assess their capabilities and ensure safety before practical
application. However, current model evaluations mainly rely on specific tasks
and datasets, lacking a united framework for assessing the multidimensional
intelligence of large models. In this perspective, we advocate for a
comprehensive framework of cognitive science-inspired artificial general
intelligence (AGI) tests, aimed at fulfilling the testing needs of large models
with enhanced capabilities. The cognitive science-inspired AGI tests encompass
the full spectrum of intelligence facets, including crystallized intelligence,
fluid intelligence, social intelligence, and embodied intelligence. To assess
the multidimensional intelligence of large models, the AGI tests consist of a
battery of well-designed cognitive tests adopted from human intelligence tests,
and then naturally encapsulates into an immersive virtual community. We propose
increasing the complexity of AGI testing tasks commensurate with advancements
in large models and emphasizing the necessity for the interpretation of test
results to avoid false negatives and false positives. We believe that cognitive
science-inspired AGI tests will effectively guide the targeted improvement of
large models in specific dimensions of intelligence and accelerate the
integration of large models into human society.
|
[
-0.4971396029,
-1.1016728878,
0.8718600869,
0.1489135623,
0.2013565898,
0.0661454499,
-0.2242951393,
-0.7757003903,
0.1860760748,
0.2489869297,
-0.7180401087,
-0.1017430127,
-0.3538325727,
-0.2646032274,
-0.4696892202,
0.7003161907,
0.0209317133,
-0.030859841,
-0.7869457603,
-0.0211345572,
-0.5707423687,
-0.5747481585,
-0.3567402661,
-0.4020349383,
0.460003525,
-0.0429884382,
0.6848717928,
0.3947332203,
0.4567878842,
0.3833481669,
0.1143085286,
0.1563297361,
-0.2689065039,
-0.3621682227,
-0.3740427792,
-0.1577895135,
-0.7511308789,
0.4315251112,
0.3739244342,
0.7281059027,
-0.2556010187,
0.3347178996,
-0.0240375698,
0.2061355114,
-0.8352663517,
0.4681574702,
-0.3603425622,
-0.1440647095,
0.0557465144,
0.125302285,
-0.2850372195,
-0.1786495298,
0.1099296212,
-0.7769768238,
0.0994594619,
-0.0136004835,
0.3899202347,
0.1937081367,
-0.6331418753,
-0.2898346782,
-1.0112143755,
1.0213662386,
-0.3350197673,
0.2418531477,
0.0779785737,
0.5159178376,
-0.1101281568,
-0.451446861,
-0.9301729798,
-0.6753380895,
0.2039740831,
0.3994734883,
-0.1567384452,
0.1693835706,
0.1995239705,
0.1721452028,
-0.7361501455,
0.0474878065,
-0.4020936489,
0.1361718774,
1.1171041727,
0.4505474865,
0.4120219052,
0.4011532664,
0.1552405357,
-0.2779234946,
-0.0903901309,
0.2241336852,
0.1773699522,
0.1966135353,
0.0631874427,
0.6817362905,
-0.599124074,
0.5603008866,
-0.0575544611,
0.1043373942,
0.3930785656,
-0.6250274777,
-0.121602051,
-0.0331217684,
0.4741591811,
0.1711515486,
0.6249285936,
-0.4390195012,
0.0030574133,
0.8034561276,
0.6822960377,
-0.691820085,
0.1153435558,
0.3631669581,
-0.2356440127,
-0.3495975137,
0.2806924284,
-0.6522990465,
-0.2508372068,
-0.7770536542,
0.586612165,
-0.5232171416,
-0.2000913918,
0.3264410794,
-0.2487250417,
0.4369598031,
0.2915927172,
-0.7961522937,
0.3536830842,
1.2026315928,
0.4876961708,
-0.2193321437,
-0.3842545152,
-0.4384318888,
0.195899561,
-0.3832699955,
0.6051950455,
-0.8800753355,
-0.3609566391,
-0.2519248724,
-0.1751430631,
-0.2886404991,
-0.3053483069,
0.238570109,
-0.531198442,
0.1151345447,
-0.3326044083,
-0.3515440226,
-0.5329732895,
0.5624984503,
-0.3560326099,
0.6680850983,
0.1488145888,
-0.0819339827,
0.1341890693,
-1.4207003117,
-0.4882315397,
0.1532778442,
-0.296967715,
-0.0266527385,
0.3419955075,
0.1243110001,
0.2265480906,
-0.6636613011,
0.4548563659,
-0.7244770527,
-0.4135774374,
0.2490122467,
-0.3112339973,
0.6489095092,
-0.0089388732,
-0.496465683,
0.3372597098,
-0.5423762798,
0.7301572561,
0.0734421834,
0.0801037177,
-0.2830351591,
0.1259185225,
-0.1214236245,
0.0312193986,
0.2184279561,
-0.5499140024,
0.1435642391,
-0.1730936617,
0.7602125406,
0.7329342365,
0.0649317205,
0.504994154,
-0.2966427803,
0.3914245367,
-0.2862458825,
0.8342865109,
0.3550752401,
-0.673733592,
-0.3045326471,
-0.4309264421,
0.2283197492,
0.8826621175,
-0.3852239251,
0.7954676747,
-0.5829255581,
-1.0094946623,
-0.1782179624,
-0.1259357631,
0.1114077047,
0.2530218065,
0.3188485205,
-0.4508390725,
0.0948131904,
-0.8398882747,
0.023180848,
-0.1248128787,
-0.3210275769,
0.4231493175,
0.9450646043,
-0.6173401475,
0.8196884394,
-0.4677998126,
-0.0265642796,
0.0965507925,
0.0835078806,
0.1491853595,
0.5182085037,
0.641761601,
-1.0208387375,
0.1112668291,
0.1875880361,
-0.9575713873,
0.1313832551,
0.1228630245,
-0.1581345201,
-0.4761564434,
0.2276396453,
-1.0677427053,
0.5904760361,
0.3393789232,
-0.4585172534,
0.7539702058,
-0.2892273664,
0.4398398101,
-0.408031702,
0.2815017998,
-0.1248110607,
0.4283675253,
-0.5385580659,
0.5161275268,
0.0106639275,
-0.1446775198,
-0.1646598727,
0.4843626618,
-0.1396648586,
-0.1087610126,
-0.1547913551,
-0.1262969077,
0.0191270318,
0.2956468165,
-0.4687657356,
0.7248836756,
0.6323970556,
-0.8363465071,
0.5655685663,
0.1474713385,
-0.1888074428,
0.5317813754,
-0.951734066,
0.2744459212,
-0.2442780435,
0.1806255281,
-0.8183419704,
-0.3415128291,
0.0891193599,
-0.3689848185,
-0.0835052058,
0.6295443177,
-0.2992509902,
-0.6517614126,
-0.1780073643,
0.5791663527,
0.5690320134,
-0.3787350059,
1.4963790178,
0.1633124501,
0.0348611251,
-0.3079265058,
-0.55826056,
-0.0456269942,
-0.1890681535,
-0.9775027037,
0.4327810705,
-0.60038656,
-0.5014609694,
0.0159146432,
0.1300121993,
-0.1676554084,
0.243268922,
0.4050141573,
0.4698996842,
-0.3153623343,
-0.0604020171,
-0.0989389867,
0.0524423793,
0.2547499835,
-0.3992387354,
0.4821388125,
-0.3277977109,
-0.7563740611,
-0.3860316873,
0.6396451592,
1.0533044338,
-0.8493098021,
0.4502057433,
0.4544156194,
-0.2445519418,
0.1286159605,
-0.7939414382,
-0.0095354719,
-0.4610793889,
0.5612085462,
-0.4083786905,
-0.8235831261,
0.5567452908,
-0.2210722566,
-0.0126923295,
0.4891263545,
0.3262086511,
0.0339873545,
1.4371982813,
0.5102433562,
-0.2451799363,
0.3021038473,
-0.3331327438,
0.3439349234,
-0.7813138366,
-0.1134660244,
-0.3877020478,
-0.304795891,
-0.2409930527,
-0.4438356757,
0.2788206041,
-0.418273896,
-0.6666388512,
-0.3174915016,
-0.6534580588,
0.6266149282,
0.5484668016,
0.2257199883,
-0.0534619428,
-0.1695483476,
0.2025392652,
0.4344399571,
-0.2837706208,
-0.2443328798,
1.0495944023,
-0.0841826349,
0.2981255949,
0.0322451554,
0.1770407408,
0.46989429,
0.3999534249,
-0.7640817165,
0.6081553698,
-0.1968084723,
-0.5354093313,
-0.4271433949,
-0.3620054126,
-0.9264735579,
0.118062295,
-0.329915911,
-0.6990047693,
0.1297857463,
-0.2991792858,
-0.6671864986,
-0.0237530451,
-0.9233337045,
0.8778579235,
-0.6131365895,
-0.018058937,
-0.8040825129,
-0.1675375253,
0.5649238825,
-0.1938959807,
0.337759614,
0.0430447161,
0.1075591296,
0.5075538158,
0.0972396582,
0.7220567465,
-0.2199614942,
0.4321270883,
0.466373235,
-0.1919534802,
0.2611692548,
-0.0043993052,
-0.1430589706,
0.235793367,
-0.0819396079,
-0.577373147,
-0.8875724077,
0.6965429187,
-0.9136470556,
-0.7335897088,
-0.315467447,
-0.676377058,
-0.2403309345,
0.023179939,
-0.3312267959,
0.2835626304,
-0.4842353761,
-0.0465012044,
0.6319976449,
0.1023452133,
0.2211157382,
0.272094816,
-0.0398806557,
-0.3039802313,
0.7125867605,
-0.0364489853,
0.1098831892,
-0.2171985209,
0.087043725,
-0.1804511696,
-0.6163476706,
-0.1378407478,
0.2117910981,
-0.3802635372,
0.2615064383,
-0.4112392664,
-0.2569578588,
-0.5543694496,
-0.2837745845,
-0.2875791788,
0.0728765875,
-0.1245439053,
0.1204834133,
0.0733921453,
0.8603023291,
0.1187844425,
0.090115428,
-0.560960412,
0.5446317792,
0.6963998079,
0.122827068,
0.3775344789,
-0.1692878157,
0.1792401075,
0.2137170434,
-0.4081823826,
-0.355240494,
0.0067263013,
0.322098881,
0.747004509,
0.53126055,
-0.1585779935,
0.8986030817,
-0.6337538958,
0.7962582111,
0.2758239806,
-0.9968549609,
0.4357807934,
-0.2686917186,
0.2895488143,
0.4583394825,
0.2612440288,
-0.2016884834,
-0.061256066,
-0.6016268134,
-0.6008133888,
0.2693569064,
-0.0079426812,
0.351695627,
-0.0129966475,
0.8372994661,
-0.1535463929,
0.0245170854,
-0.2736358345,
0.3195897937,
-0.0367220528,
-0.2969334722,
-0.3650041223,
0.1646084487,
-0.2534722686,
-0.4638254941,
0.5562644601,
-0.3863173425,
0.27880463,
0.2115395814,
0.2538997531,
-0.0233308841,
0.0896942392,
0.3805899918,
0.7806760669,
0.1384228468,
-0.3538438976,
0.4375244677,
-0.5828421116,
0.2161442339,
0.0964978859,
-0.153423354,
-0.7206756473,
0.3858793378,
0.4139752388,
-0.1172605231,
-0.7965473533,
0.494165808,
-0.1309514493,
-0.2499227077,
-0.7916473746,
0.6732040644,
0.0742474869,
0.6338462234,
0.5415641665,
0.23800309,
0.221968174,
-0.9395928383,
0.1504093111,
0.8127318621,
-0.2363459021,
-0.3665361404,
0.6390506029,
-0.1380269676,
-0.3150910735,
1.0649226904,
-0.3363486826,
-0.4216783941,
0.8051149845,
0.108912237,
0.564609766,
-0.5099956989,
0.1797143668,
0.2498280555,
0.5075796843,
-0.1283022165,
0.259932816,
0.1631468683,
-0.5499779582,
-0.8676779866,
-0.4797212481,
-0.3114103675,
0.1345720291,
-0.4979407191,
0.0851187557,
-0.5478572249,
-0.1090427488,
0.1775520742,
-0.0241585169,
-0.8215792775,
0.7051155567,
0.4726445377,
0.7586612701,
-0.7487046719,
0.5388982296,
0.6462907195,
-0.1671596766,
-0.4983712137,
-0.1793636382,
-0.126473099,
-0.7294051051,
0.4602363408,
0.4688627124,
0.0078786705,
-0.1539671868,
-0.7610410452,
-1.1496093273,
1.3204238415,
0.1958850026,
-0.2650407851,
-0.216740787,
0.2390515208,
0.6430062056,
-0.7811154127,
0.5632112622,
0.5655878186,
0.8131676316,
0.1062427461,
-0.8359324932,
0.0572682843,
-0.3882549107,
0.0642870292,
-0.0662693605,
-0.6878885627,
0.9070010781,
-0.2199590951,
-0.0252186861,
0.1556967199,
0.8226848245,
0.3178501129,
0.6389053464,
0.8483380675,
0.5221156478,
0.9791509509,
0.0031340693,
1.3697915077,
-0.0501578078,
-0.0187617466,
0.8026425242,
-0.6350923181,
0.7008520961,
0.1448290795,
0.1094480008,
0.5039266944,
0.3494572341,
-0.2817069292,
0.4288169742,
0.5367024541,
-0.2170859128,
-0.4683091938,
-0.2537335455,
-0.1284253895,
0.8627920151,
0.3948563635,
0.135390088,
-0.0022271073,
0.182927832,
-0.4679330885,
0.022698164,
-0.4898215234,
0.3674996197,
-0.3054919839,
-0.8099055886,
0.2289741635,
-0.1419139802,
0.5070717931,
-0.8490739465,
-0.0284688734,
0.3043845892,
0.3626548946,
0.0888202265,
-0.572691083,
0.3732014596,
-0.2510348558,
-0.2552443445,
0.3155607581,
0.5101533532,
0.0609333403,
-0.5662398338,
0.6569094658,
0.5634880662,
-0.0483073294,
-0.6665545702,
-0.808699429,
-0.0781175643,
-0.1127896756,
-0.3392361999,
0.3646658361,
0.2307715267,
-0.3632594347,
0.6306934357,
1.0443429947,
-0.3435645998,
-0.2638402581,
-0.054377865,
0.8128361702,
-0.79704386,
-0.5895159245,
-0.7971969247,
0.5313364267,
-0.2246143371,
-0.2543178201,
0.2979818285,
0.4219104946,
0.4464655519,
-0.1229019016,
1.0473539829,
-0.1924750358,
-0.0234485436,
-0.1570792049,
0.7707850337,
-0.5663443208,
-0.3921136856,
-0.1304109246,
-1.0865365267,
-0.1460474432,
0.2809533179,
-0.5993471146,
0.230055362,
0.6021925211,
0.4908172488,
-0.3036539257,
0.3481897116,
0.356230706,
0.1926779747,
0.4167043269,
0.8204974532,
0.8895645738,
-0.2487671971,
0.3762305677,
0.0053528096,
-0.756482482,
0.162447989,
-0.5179613829,
-0.8205576539,
-0.4158324301,
-0.5208699107,
0.0152899232,
-0.1257766634,
0.4062663019,
0.7345810533,
-0.7110109329,
-0.0321265124,
0.0097947065,
-0.4312547743,
-0.5524348617,
-0.2878285348,
0.2423070818,
-0.0293600578,
-0.5944549441,
0.6193680167,
0.2342785895,
-0.1525398046,
-0.2565871179,
0.0219437499,
-0.1096189916,
0.4769942164,
0.6442250609,
-0.0625521094,
-0.6478378773,
-0.6538877487,
0.2506555915,
0.1648635119,
-0.2783331573,
0.4892400205,
-0.6855126023,
0.1704751104,
0.1575092375,
0.6655372977,
0.2965823412,
-0.0301331505,
0.3744703829,
-0.004682227,
-0.0426454581,
0.1823817641,
0.2013867199,
0.0089124646,
-0.7021010518,
0.7992633581,
0.1482192576,
-0.6678685546,
-0.6513513923,
0.1897461116,
-1.2121145725,
-0.2620902061,
0.6503444314,
-0.0983287469,
-0.6559203863,
0.101017192,
0.0514799654,
0.1578873098,
-0.0446638428,
1.0728832483,
0.7712810636,
-0.2541083097,
0.2975121439,
-0.78743577,
-0.2494163066,
0.4550095499,
-0.9149974585,
0.0614527427,
0.4144148827,
0.1092485338,
0.7964812517,
0.1460112184,
-0.0977456719,
0.4262275994,
-0.0146020735,
0.3473462462,
-0.1870443672,
-0.1621987075,
-0.1720825583,
0.4405362606,
-0.4831519127,
-0.0375923067
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02541v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02541v1
|
Knowledge Generation for Zero-shot Knowledge-based VQA
| 2024-02-04T15:41:35 | 2024-02-04T15:41:35 |
Rui Cao, Jing Jiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV
|
Previous solutions to knowledge-based visual question answering~(K-VQA)
retrieve knowledge from external knowledge bases and use supervised learning to
train the K-VQA model. Recently pre-trained LLMs have been used as both a
knowledge source and a zero-shot QA model for K-VQA and demonstrated promising
results. However, these recent methods do not explicitly show the knowledge
needed to answer the questions and thus lack interpretability. Inspired by
recent work on knowledge generation from LLMs for text-based QA, in this work
we propose and test a similar knowledge-generation-based K-VQA method, which
first generates knowledge from an LLM and then incorporates the generated
knowledge for K-VQA in a zero-shot manner. We evaluate our method on two K-VQA
benchmarks and found that our method performs better than previous zero-shot
K-VQA methods and our generated knowledge is generally relevant and helpful.
|
[
-0.3187924325,
-0.8528417349,
1.0762735605,
-0.2293525487,
-0.3909646273,
0.0537134744,
0.2404941618,
-0.4092758894,
0.1370706111,
0.6481932998,
-0.682174623,
-0.5132441521,
-0.3005476594,
0.104111217,
-0.3026966751,
0.4851013124,
-0.1495495141,
0.2292446196,
-0.8493762612,
0.0028797446,
-0.6880429983,
-0.3241907656,
-0.2303918302,
-0.2260963619,
0.4948822856,
0.6589010358,
0.2219495624,
0.306504339,
0.3770991266,
0.1593391597,
0.1425444186,
0.1639129966,
-0.4588935375,
0.1304319799,
0.0302705448,
-0.6866230369,
-0.0209878869,
-0.2792065442,
0.3209145665,
0.2557117343,
0.1130230352,
0.5057889819,
-0.4013420045,
0.4303931892,
-0.9957541227,
0.0429039039,
-0.9927841425,
0.1168122813,
0.1069249436,
-0.5263086557,
-0.3181214035,
-0.430241257,
0.1427544951,
-0.7610002756,
0.1021387577,
-0.2075995803,
1.0220425129,
0.3813221157,
-0.7010315657,
-0.0606709495,
-0.8029405475,
0.6275396347,
-0.5645012259,
0.3327644765,
0.0627163202,
0.7960382104,
0.013807741,
-0.7841593027,
-0.9864820242,
-0.2166976035,
0.4282864034,
0.5459487438,
-0.063308835,
-0.1547430754,
0.2993543446,
0.1356538236,
-0.5570271611,
-0.2328118831,
-0.4647867382,
-0.0617522448,
0.5137876272,
0.0691320449,
0.1024249941,
-0.359493494,
-0.5824027658,
-0.0631993636,
-0.996160686,
0.3461604416,
-0.0431865118,
-0.0818911493,
0.3944172263,
0.9033564329,
-0.8975305557,
0.7176045775,
0.0004330065,
-0.2665644288,
0.2021166682,
-0.362220794,
-0.4199729264,
-0.1547121406,
0.4426451921,
0.578384459,
0.4818234444,
0.0257765632,
0.1087448969,
-0.039615918,
0.2421828806,
-0.9163377881,
-0.1116039529,
0.081041567,
-0.086212948,
-0.5587745309,
-0.154486835,
-0.4242173433,
-0.0869960412,
-0.1866665781,
0.9753265977,
-0.318269074,
-0.1548796147,
-0.0061366586,
-0.3177109063,
0.8764815927,
0.4861595333,
-0.2720183432,
-0.1671014577,
0.1088913903,
0.2835336626,
-0.0094897505,
-0.0255535971,
-0.6734774709,
0.1630227119,
-0.5010183454,
0.9399392009,
-0.0370659009,
-0.1230596974,
0.2290111035,
-0.2141066939,
0.2062684894,
-0.5054807067,
0.025497945,
-0.9306335449,
0.3524779677,
-0.6909179688,
-0.6433860064,
-0.3197956383,
0.5954985023,
-0.145529598,
0.8947271705,
0.3547385931,
-0.5162704587,
0.7382425666,
-0.2856678665,
0.0072941165,
0.3666729331,
-0.5513024926,
-0.3521568477,
-0.1187783927,
0.5493164659,
0.5187154412,
-0.025995845,
0.0391733572,
-0.3256894052,
-0.3511986732,
0.1827233285,
-0.1882819831,
0.5595059395,
-0.0690392032,
-0.317448765,
-0.142749235,
-0.7899531722,
0.4373914897,
0.3993755877,
-0.1473062038,
-0.2688937783,
-0.2015761733,
-0.5593210459,
0.4275611937,
0.2537619174,
-0.7110982537,
0.0911703631,
-0.2698488235,
-0.0422089286,
0.5150117278,
0.6511258483,
0.2604511976,
-0.288705349,
0.7595184445,
0.3541502357,
0.2613102496,
-0.234313935,
-0.6217756867,
-0.9677420259,
0.0286591034,
0.129822284,
0.6927688718,
-1.733948946,
-0.2050249428,
0.0559320226,
-0.5445856452,
-0.1977825612,
0.1899191886,
0.4845826924,
0.8654133081,
0.4871778488,
-0.3063208461,
-0.2876535058,
-0.7598317862,
-0.1530293524,
-0.3826753795,
-0.0304234661,
0.6190328002,
0.5806327462,
0.1602683812,
1.011785984,
-0.6998559237,
0.0404001288,
-0.0753215253,
0.009722312,
-0.1242881864,
-0.0356346592,
0.60253793,
-0.5203965306,
-0.430621922,
-0.2248113453,
-1.1367082596,
-0.0939622074,
-0.0391915031,
-0.3923252821,
0.2103733867,
0.4928468168,
-0.4776611626,
0.6130676866,
0.1439882666,
-0.2705146372,
0.8647971749,
0.1866130382,
0.2957469523,
-1.1726844311,
-0.1089209765,
-0.1309386641,
-0.429828167,
-0.5929632187,
0.0421966873,
0.1038987115,
-0.0908014923,
-0.8930748701,
0.6828796268,
-0.484685868,
-0.0368987322,
-0.1744611114,
0.210164696,
0.0440073013,
0.6431966424,
0.2789586782,
0.6381694674,
0.5318664312,
-0.6383699775,
0.4085865617,
0.3388907909,
-0.3272103667,
0.6877973676,
-0.5825830102,
0.1075808108,
-0.3496041,
-0.303974092,
-0.9540728331,
-0.1904491931,
0.3637888432,
-0.6407520771,
-0.003035032,
-0.064164564,
-0.2456692606,
-0.5157183409,
-0.3230451643,
0.4507927895,
0.7147653103,
-0.5330829024,
0.3636851907,
-0.1166159809,
-0.1181746125,
-0.7173155546,
-0.4931550622,
-0.1572296023,
-0.1002659276,
-0.6306517124,
0.0632393286,
-0.0034115522,
-0.1126671135,
0.1255435199,
-0.1392135918,
-0.256246984,
-0.0796903968,
0.1823560894,
0.3132221103,
-0.4607677162,
0.1585404873,
0.0821491703,
0.1705106944,
0.1625044793,
-0.2200338989,
0.1539306939,
0.2336659878,
-0.527584672,
-0.2388590425,
0.3100559413,
0.3787001371,
-0.2223345935,
0.6598616242,
0.4002620876,
-0.1745096743,
-0.3977903426,
-0.6882348657,
-0.1513466537,
-0.4076204598,
0.2193807513,
-0.2186519355,
-1.0135295391,
0.2394144684,
-0.1860024482,
-0.0317200646,
0.3923488855,
0.6447890997,
-0.4773207903,
0.6254209876,
0.8715506196,
0.3941922486,
0.4773869216,
-0.2872975171,
-0.0958561376,
-0.3592151105,
-0.3609743416,
-0.2459878474,
0.0315955244,
-0.1866435707,
-0.4827303588,
0.6775033474,
0.3388557136,
-0.3426013589,
0.1709162146,
-0.3388103843,
0.4134169519,
0.9373349547,
0.2513323426,
0.5321558714,
0.1003048494,
-0.073439613,
0.0737107173,
-0.9201617241,
-0.1858960092,
1.4589328766,
-0.0908888578,
0.3788143396,
-0.1125397831,
0.7603065372,
-0.0707949027,
0.2197133899,
-0.7942025065,
0.5663840771,
0.3443168402,
-0.3809427023,
-0.4333645403,
-0.5379850268,
-0.536157012,
-0.0835798979,
-0.346655637,
-0.3946629167,
0.0696600601,
0.2007484585,
-0.4067333043,
0.0455493107,
-0.6193491817,
0.738327384,
-0.2842083573,
-0.1003175676,
0.2910117805,
-0.5105116367,
0.7918533087,
-0.0873354822,
-0.340213418,
0.1676373333,
0.1342782229,
0.5922905207,
-0.4879289567,
0.5471659303,
-0.4879074693,
-0.154966563,
0.6679022312,
-0.0324792527,
0.234461382,
0.2013934553,
0.3998221755,
0.0207348596,
0.1862551421,
-0.5351623297,
-0.763423264,
0.162792787,
-0.6837796569,
-0.6549767256,
-0.2199953794,
-0.4765156209,
-0.504096508,
0.2621928453,
0.3674955368,
0.3324120045,
-0.0206616968,
0.2869427502,
0.8404405713,
-0.4672883153,
0.2139728516,
0.7494188547,
-0.4595021307,
-0.4925930798,
0.8137156367,
0.2576603591,
0.473462373,
0.5722562671,
-0.1019693986,
-0.2659145594,
-0.5115890503,
-0.7321478128,
0.1066161767,
-0.514805913,
-0.4645837247,
-0.2521378994,
-0.6511364579,
-0.2802336812,
-0.0692292154,
-0.1214360744,
-0.4002391398,
-0.0902238041,
-0.0405355319,
0.4364788532,
0.4666709006,
0.2195931971,
0.2474706471,
-0.7615472674,
0.7066188455,
1.0631395578,
0.1083465591,
-0.2974231541,
-0.3489111066,
-0.1619000882,
0.0548528917,
-0.5109139085,
-1.0876911879,
-0.0001906346,
0.0564156771,
0.4549640119,
0.2285753936,
0.1127128154,
0.4863010347,
-0.4313298166,
1.1017346382,
0.2323499769,
-0.6257374883,
0.6753570437,
-0.3613910675,
0.651171267,
0.5445401073,
0.3225031495,
-0.1901031733,
-0.4243758023,
-0.6376276016,
-0.5428682566,
0.2348224968,
0.3911197484,
0.0621382557,
0.0649023876,
0.5916959643,
0.0835993513,
0.5151139498,
-0.628456831,
-0.284747839,
-0.2730435729,
-0.0258704629,
0.1818356067,
-0.3912723958,
-0.0034562908,
-0.1249787509,
0.7236442566,
-0.3911611438,
0.3702564836,
0.5332412124,
-0.1960050762,
-0.148410663,
0.130301863,
0.4556295872,
0.7987419963,
-0.1771990657,
-0.0557858907,
0.3412571549,
-0.3287614882,
0.1675793231,
-0.3029653728,
-0.8501559496,
0.0242698342,
0.249768436,
0.6206338406,
-0.1867309958,
-0.7581287622,
0.8218551874,
-0.1501260549,
-0.8793266416,
-0.3042395115,
0.2821387351,
0.1195953712,
0.5649971366,
0.3155254722,
-0.1799369603,
-0.1389148086,
-0.4252604842,
0.3515805006,
0.6118440032,
-0.3213410079,
0.1471188515,
0.6367614865,
0.0776791424,
-0.0493032783,
0.4364877939,
-0.1510793418,
-0.3546658754,
0.633308351,
0.2064541131,
0.6305458546,
0.1333048344,
0.7400794029,
0.3804883361,
0.1913209558,
0.3062984943,
0.9603864551,
-0.4389746189,
-0.8108128309,
-0.6863703132,
-0.4972199202,
-0.6520541906,
0.3542135954,
-0.6508151889,
0.213943541,
-0.1855044663,
0.0848435536,
-0.3116133213,
0.0246984512,
-0.8593584895,
0.4596689343,
0.1862913221,
0.948785305,
-0.6800470352,
0.5794367194,
0.6874107718,
-0.5991734266,
-1.0046836138,
0.1612080634,
-0.2822309434,
-0.9968724847,
0.6382425427,
-0.1918480098,
-0.0228857975,
0.0965863913,
-0.846560061,
-0.7197807431,
1.6247719526,
0.5020279884,
-0.3135179579,
0.126142472,
0.3921118081,
0.4568710029,
-0.0725566372,
0.1194689199,
0.0186329335,
0.18215397,
0.5975621939,
-0.5572569966,
-0.0421615802,
-0.260032475,
0.0334655382,
-0.0740464032,
-0.4761053026,
0.381231457,
-0.213778764,
-0.1534498483,
0.1733488142,
0.8266286254,
0.5005860925,
0.5042681098,
0.3307350278,
0.6462163925,
0.509513557,
0.1397474855,
0.668402493,
-0.1691259295,
0.1098599136,
1.1326019764,
-0.3126240373,
1.0517525673,
0.654728651,
0.1048902944,
0.5892442465,
0.2677841187,
0.0283020306,
0.524099648,
0.2052297443,
-0.3612471521,
-0.6270099878,
-0.0935108289,
-0.402118504,
0.5923860073,
-0.2812481821,
-0.2115119398,
-0.4043424428,
-0.0902823135,
-0.3504041731,
-0.0824863166,
-0.439476043,
1.0393674374,
0.1132177189,
-0.7271814942,
0.6103981733,
-0.287604928,
0.2901796401,
-0.497653991,
-0.3094699085,
-0.271761477,
-0.2125574946,
0.0344305076,
-0.9305770993,
-0.0234073158,
0.2386676371,
-0.2551172376,
-0.1142583638,
1.1708889008,
-0.4890598059,
-0.6103484631,
-0.0492958911,
1.3012671471,
0.0830997527,
-0.3422142863,
-0.1694479585,
-0.7832176685,
0.0235966481,
-0.1860952079,
0.281920135,
0.5766958594,
0.0137404585,
0.5807734132,
0.5646671057,
-0.0813816339,
0.3481059372,
-0.1022805572,
0.8067288995,
-0.6201362014,
-0.1298516691,
-0.5173354745,
0.6493817568,
-0.0205248687,
-0.2864536047,
0.7350003719,
0.2900175452,
0.9587914348,
-0.3620362878,
0.9000002146,
0.0660219342,
0.4231986403,
-0.697445631,
0.7651541233,
-0.7317042947,
-0.2446151376,
-0.318995744,
-0.749029994,
-0.249060899,
0.1973404735,
-0.2377360612,
-0.1389546394,
0.6103674769,
0.8185527325,
0.2437545359,
-0.2418826818,
0.6901456714,
0.0375917852,
0.0067772809,
0.9290320277,
1.1336311102,
-0.6376575828,
0.8872130513,
-0.4785458744,
-0.0704038218,
0.0485311449,
-0.8969465494,
-0.9789312482,
-0.5085309148,
-0.3092106879,
-0.0544501133,
0.0221570227,
0.1254098415,
0.5527196527,
-0.4182164967,
0.330542922,
-0.214836657,
0.1226839423,
-0.114677012,
-0.2449201196,
0.1052914858,
-0.1843746305,
-0.174456507,
0.291473031,
0.1623873115,
-0.0147550041,
-0.3000077307,
0.00604244,
-0.065951474,
0.1875340492,
0.8228369951,
0.4115161002,
-0.3961794078,
-0.5471131206,
0.4255602956,
0.101638563,
0.0353486873,
0.343290329,
-1.3022707701,
0.4173363745,
0.6273570657,
0.7488729954,
0.5930661559,
0.1101253778,
0.6485875845,
-0.8138568997,
-0.4208187163,
0.1337532103,
0.0495698154,
0.0648209155,
-0.3142324388,
0.2375408262,
0.4621474147,
-0.4823386073,
-0.6169579625,
0.2952564657,
-1.155207634,
-0.0688670203,
1.1207225323,
-0.0361191593,
-0.3226498365,
0.0704006106,
-0.2480622232,
0.4003469646,
-0.0330658518,
0.6739500761,
0.353028208,
-0.075316757,
-0.5221362114,
-0.702886343,
0.4066058993,
0.3630493879,
-1.1204506159,
-0.4794136286,
0.5036810637,
0.5645238161,
0.0111616487,
0.9122555852,
-0.0101318136,
0.7174139023,
-0.0017521626,
0.319690913,
-0.4053958356,
-0.4347088933,
-0.0662180483,
0.3593761921,
0.0866795629,
-0.3844897747
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02522v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02522v1
|
Absolute convergence and error thresholds in non-active adaptive sampling
| 2024-02-04T15:10:34 | 2024-02-04T15:10:34 |
Manuel Vilares Ferro, Victor M. Darriba Bilbao, Jesús Vilares Ferro
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Non-active adaptive sampling is a way of building machine learning models
from a training data base which are supposed to dynamically and automatically
derive guaranteed sample size. In this context and regardless of the strategy
used in both scheduling and generating of weak predictors, a proposal for
calculating absolute convergence and error thresholds is described. We not only
make it possible to establish when the quality of the model no longer
increases, but also supplies a proximity condition to estimate in absolute
terms how close it is to achieving such a goal, thus supporting decision making
for fine-tuning learning parameters in model selection. The technique proves
its correctness and completeness with respect to our working hypotheses, in
addition to strengthening the robustness of the sampling scheme. Tests meet our
expectations and illustrate the proposal in the domain of natural language
processing, taking the generation of part-of-speech taggers as case study.
|
[
-0.3029206097,
-0.7083084583,
0.2945182621,
0.052087415,
-0.0527628474,
-0.1495966017,
-0.2294507325,
-0.5194972754,
0.0252292641,
0.3236340284,
-0.4536221623,
-0.1133284718,
-0.3413414061,
0.0178289022,
-0.5847302079,
0.7583425045,
-0.178872779,
-0.2422206998,
-0.236746043,
-0.3607905209,
-0.6449287534,
-0.229738608,
-0.4502041638,
0.2161880583,
0.2617114484,
0.4349212646,
0.2692278028,
0.8968762159,
0.3081942797,
0.238965556,
0.1439792514,
0.1094028205,
-0.1444501728,
0.4625014067,
-0.0086769387,
-0.7146641016,
-0.5249487758,
0.1211243048,
1.1533141136,
0.8994196057,
-0.1795834154,
0.1412381381,
0.1281172633,
0.5418619514,
-0.8784452677,
-0.0280603208,
-0.8789445162,
0.0390844829,
0.0578459911,
-0.1536998898,
-0.462454766,
-0.2808212042,
-0.0426541567,
-0.4056034088,
0.8180938363,
-0.106347762,
0.7995260954,
0.424554944,
-0.1127922386,
-0.1071974114,
-0.7443445921,
1.2139189243,
-0.5416938663,
0.2209173441,
0.6121263504,
0.304407239,
-0.1206663176,
-0.4361033738,
-0.4303254485,
-0.3086254001,
0.4449499249,
0.0700255558,
-0.3899202347,
0.0654984191,
0.5122378469,
0.2502142191,
-0.1196625829,
0.1111589968,
-0.4114984572,
-0.0086174421,
0.3712255955,
-0.0693814605,
-0.2096512616,
0.221320942,
-0.0796904713,
0.0098306797,
-0.2478800565,
-0.1555445045,
0.4161939025,
0.6871117949,
-0.3017167747,
0.4380648136,
-0.3381507397,
1.0624207258,
0.2746567726,
0.0334754251,
0.3215914369,
-0.4050136805,
-0.2402018607,
-0.0756776184,
0.3659052849,
0.1995301843,
0.170822069,
-0.0141325891,
-0.5638332367,
0.1304634809,
0.6135731936,
-0.3186361194,
-0.3017719686,
0.2338075042,
-0.3090649843,
-0.3436784446,
0.0128199747,
-0.9823663235,
0.0356368423,
-0.2371694595,
0.3384494781,
-0.0589473061,
-0.222464487,
-0.409545809,
-0.1007611677,
-0.1509488672,
0.0165612642,
-0.5260312557,
0.2890593708,
-0.1467000246,
0.9105292559,
-0.2635419965,
-0.0632753819,
-0.6856585741,
-0.09877,
-0.4773534238,
0.9624290466,
-0.2799132168,
-0.454955101,
-0.0705620274,
-0.0788313523,
-0.2621551752,
-0.7473224998,
0.8366231322,
-0.3353551328,
-0.0732065365,
-0.1205635667,
-0.486836493,
0.0978621766,
0.1761205047,
-0.5720989704,
1.0611280203,
0.2819356918,
-0.3890614808,
0.6023272872,
-0.9115521312,
-0.5048723221,
-0.0705277324,
0.3150235713,
-0.8881952167,
0.0909139588,
-0.0466657765,
0.2790242732,
0.0178193431,
-0.1201937944,
-0.5513074994,
-0.1825425178,
0.1663688272,
-0.4674358368,
0.5546260476,
0.2201209217,
-0.6350497603,
0.1845663935,
-0.7699434757,
0.3553466797,
0.1283965707,
-0.4608370066,
-0.1200209334,
0.1889956743,
-0.1951239556,
0.0338405371,
0.017094573,
-0.3808655143,
0.0529536419,
-0.2392472625,
0.4856785536,
0.7021813989,
0.1657376289,
0.4612606168,
-0.7248914838,
0.5236901045,
-0.2567282915,
0.1112585291,
-0.1814563274,
-0.3858445585,
-0.8492864966,
-0.4115062952,
0.762994945,
0.6303777099,
-0.6507149935,
1.028329134,
-0.0821419954,
-0.5554197431,
-0.2427936345,
0.3691317737,
0.3587888479,
0.6666843295,
0.3947992921,
-0.4853363931,
-0.8193129897,
-0.4080287814,
0.2858735323,
-0.4131287038,
0.011284586,
0.1924058646,
0.4678346217,
0.1038829535,
1.0185556412,
-0.0942004696,
-0.3217507303,
-0.1926366538,
0.0222481191,
0.2760505974,
0.4240999818,
0.5843403339,
-0.8831799626,
-0.6065933108,
-0.5915270448,
-0.5672410727,
-0.4082789421,
0.0682311133,
-0.13275446,
0.2651607394,
0.3453996181,
-0.3448086977,
0.3100224137,
0.5447102189,
0.1542266458,
0.6186041832,
-0.1113255844,
-0.2772138417,
-0.8117297888,
0.2858310938,
0.3371599019,
-0.1501779854,
-0.6614245772,
0.0347603299,
-0.1246372163,
0.1821512431,
-0.1552142948,
0.6155003309,
-0.5152851939,
-0.0131248813,
-0.77190274,
0.0818427131,
-0.2757479548,
0.1757026613,
0.0620957427,
0.6223987341,
0.7216230631,
-0.9178801179,
0.3685279787,
-0.0462854616,
-0.0191712603,
0.8282296062,
-0.5094740987,
0.0220673662,
-0.0980326235,
0.3786981106,
-1.050339818,
-0.3676118851,
0.1902164221,
-0.7779821157,
0.3488009274,
-0.3851133883,
-0.0846466273,
-0.482200861,
-0.1625794321,
0.3378641307,
0.7650524378,
-0.213183865,
0.2454505414,
0.6285427213,
0.2028988451,
-0.5277082324,
-0.5241962075,
-0.2422705144,
-0.2490010411,
-0.0636925176,
0.0451051593,
0.0721793473,
-0.2855665684,
0.0256496686,
-0.0354503058,
-0.1645623744,
0.2100968063,
0.2558419704,
0.3083600998,
-0.1698666066,
-0.0399855562,
-0.1984177828,
-0.0034550317,
-0.1799606979,
-0.6448566914,
0.2665835619,
0.452417016,
-0.5863335729,
-0.1374312341,
0.0657787919,
0.3692892492,
-0.0419130214,
0.5600281358,
0.3892295659,
-0.6988571286,
-0.4363694191,
-0.4204688966,
-0.133020699,
-0.3853233159,
0.2181874365,
-0.1294579804,
-0.1769136488,
0.6210477352,
0.515388906,
0.459492743,
0.6432080269,
0.744797647,
0.0092837531,
0.7543672323,
0.745180428,
-0.0213613529,
0.7327700853,
0.0107329795,
0.0952884033,
-0.5705963373,
0.110353373,
-0.7257816792,
-0.3147810996,
-0.2771415412,
-0.5807834864,
0.3156649172,
0.1716802865,
0.05415456,
0.2108142227,
-0.4492177367,
0.2271250188,
0.9070020318,
-0.1127223298,
-0.2260601521,
0.1422873735,
-0.1930254549,
0.0344436765,
-0.8032045364,
-0.2940012217,
1.1179068089,
0.0645378456,
0.450285852,
0.0559829213,
0.2685389221,
0.654617846,
0.2363426387,
-1.0025820732,
0.3676259816,
0.0823054314,
-0.945917964,
-0.3251189888,
-0.6481630802,
-0.9425337911,
-0.2488248944,
-0.2284285426,
-0.5150251389,
0.3114428818,
0.4225634336,
-0.4952742457,
0.6446269155,
-0.6649070382,
0.4345047772,
0.0130978655,
-0.4111131728,
0.3164792061,
-0.6873682737,
-0.008927512,
-0.4987932146,
-0.0064738956,
-0.2766078413,
-0.1407119334,
1.0004702806,
0.0263193808,
0.9738473892,
-0.8362060189,
0.3550906479,
0.8809191585,
-0.0243402049,
0.4066255391,
-0.4737243354,
-0.4072679877,
-0.1246912256,
-0.1740700752,
-0.9524164796,
-0.1379241794,
0.3099552691,
-0.5571076274,
-0.064877823,
-0.4838984907,
-0.4969701469,
-0.5079628825,
0.4864510596,
0.0310209692,
0.2648453414,
0.0730845779,
0.29893291,
0.7598965764,
0.0886149108,
0.4160644114,
0.5764348507,
0.4851364791,
-0.2162127197,
0.9771403074,
0.3628930748,
0.4794150293,
0.2156939507,
-0.1511203945,
-0.4270322621,
-1.0221741199,
-0.57575351,
0.0181824602,
-0.551921308,
-0.3330660462,
-0.5021528602,
-0.2537697852,
-0.4087975919,
-0.031681966,
-0.276247263,
-0.1595600545,
-0.244245261,
-0.0334163904,
0.1305354983,
0.3013672829,
-0.3598906398,
0.1573390514,
-0.7492799163,
0.0714501664,
-0.0900492892,
0.3077376485,
0.0141656464,
-0.9940505028,
-0.407931149,
0.1051173061,
-0.4568819702,
-0.614339292,
0.0866855532,
0.6113085747,
0.9556674361,
0.274625212,
0.5227336287,
0.385740608,
-0.2653337717,
0.6706252098,
-0.0896671563,
-0.5656619072,
0.4870885313,
-0.4728484452,
0.2711415589,
0.7051274776,
0.3575647473,
-0.1195427701,
-0.3542396128,
-0.6655099392,
-0.9154074192,
0.428385675,
0.2923875451,
0.304136306,
0.0158075299,
0.5864840746,
-0.1781423241,
0.0062578525,
-0.4994933903,
-0.0637759641,
-0.0884259492,
-0.3360387683,
0.0427127406,
-0.1159678623,
-0.2765019536,
-0.0083445814,
0.8950609565,
-0.4874659777,
0.8101208806,
0.0367814675,
0.2503015697,
-0.656878829,
0.0364918597,
0.5188218951,
0.888374269,
-0.3863424957,
0.0053501227,
0.4674954712,
-0.5786800981,
0.2733553946,
0.2297953069,
-0.1198241711,
-0.1110635474,
0.4714190662,
0.6724305749,
-0.3350197673,
-0.876880765,
0.4092000127,
-0.0060552042,
-0.3026766479,
-0.3966960609,
0.2283995301,
-0.5855717063,
-0.0964269266,
0.6262652278,
0.4412822425,
-0.1927820295,
-0.3685344756,
0.7259315252,
0.4985719919,
-0.9271434546,
-0.3322510123,
0.7814669609,
0.1881750971,
0.0161460973,
0.5413740873,
-0.4344440401,
-0.3301142752,
0.6993632913,
0.6236553788,
0.6602423787,
-0.2298647612,
-0.2464392483,
0.5637333393,
0.1968198568,
-0.1942777634,
0.0020785418,
-0.1338900179,
-0.8246562481,
-0.4569779634,
-0.8548831344,
-0.5657013655,
-0.1065853387,
-0.7764180899,
0.5036808252,
-0.5815942883,
-0.434358418,
0.0026197482,
0.054218851,
0.0712966621,
0.5199466348,
0.090361245,
0.8232911825,
-1.0127052069,
0.9950905442,
0.8449569345,
0.0618362129,
-0.4006758034,
0.2664959729,
-0.0701456442,
-0.6719864607,
-0.1460516006,
-0.1090310216,
0.0608942211,
-0.119886063,
-0.2863566875,
-0.747115314,
0.6882977486,
0.2319111675,
-0.3459227681,
-0.254263103,
-0.4396632612,
0.4328510761,
0.0333230495,
0.0195113793,
0.457991749,
0.2410599738,
0.4623263776,
-1.0699875355,
0.03491107,
-0.4950386882,
-0.4066806138,
0.6370201111,
-0.4192149639,
0.7269946337,
-0.1608695835,
-0.0235889088,
0.3796510398,
0.715038538,
0.3205547631,
0.2219464183,
0.8859720826,
0.4393278956,
0.8430598974,
-0.168862015,
0.9354203939,
-0.4382318556,
0.310646981,
0.7997325063,
-0.2028551698,
0.7644633055,
0.1792969704,
-0.4718793929,
-0.004176165,
0.8599606156,
-0.4206637144,
0.3928851485,
0.0977627039,
-0.3628748655,
-0.0724668056,
-0.2472333759,
-0.2758167088,
0.1987913698,
0.2344572991,
-0.4777963161,
-0.0545699857,
-0.0824761391,
-0.1457703114,
0.0447331481,
-0.3819732368,
0.4639387727,
-0.0176684894,
-0.6630833149,
0.6878458261,
0.1826449782,
0.737144649,
-0.5962203741,
0.0008474385,
0.2036781758,
0.2684487104,
-0.1871304661,
-0.563441813,
0.5317909122,
0.0404332131,
-0.4027737379,
0.08357279,
0.7225689888,
-0.0289244428,
-0.595896244,
0.0543610863,
0.2942292988,
0.1288339347,
0.0276404284,
-0.7868751884,
-0.1692658663,
0.0519380905,
0.1521397978,
0.1991142184,
0.0501821153,
-0.2511304319,
0.3959005773,
0.6152130961,
0.2675504088,
0.4431443214,
-0.3534280956,
0.4413905144,
-0.3988413811,
-0.5381128788,
-0.6861659288,
0.237566933,
0.1596334279,
-0.1722134203,
0.8520175815,
0.4627342522,
0.7193838358,
0.4025087059,
1.0602749586,
-0.5865776539,
0.7752891779,
-0.3417492509,
0.3708535731,
-0.5522468686,
-0.0938555673,
-0.0629395097,
-1.1464173794,
-0.3886640072,
0.5496498346,
-0.4039272666,
0.5255161524,
0.253639251,
0.5054783225,
-0.2915598154,
-0.1507864594,
0.2225311995,
0.0167552754,
0.1545721442,
0.3291903734,
0.4245233238,
-0.2451839149,
0.4117859304,
-0.3205350637,
-0.5361050367,
-0.1033608019,
-0.5943580866,
-0.5927473903,
-0.5551484823,
-0.3458310366,
-0.7915100455,
-0.0842585117,
0.9916370511,
0.9564896822,
-1.0068281889,
-0.2062483877,
-0.0600916594,
-0.0814517587,
-0.3495274782,
-0.1948233098,
0.1772574782,
-0.4055639207,
-0.8855620623,
0.3749627173,
-0.1849501878,
0.2548238039,
-0.2425250113,
0.0966655761,
-0.1710791737,
0.2737019956,
0.1597719491,
0.7296941876,
-0.1007338241,
-0.0379998349,
-0.2057136595,
0.1268054843,
0.2911965251,
0.5084982514,
-0.6097005606,
0.6235511899,
0.2905552983,
0.519957006,
0.1286747009,
0.1567160636,
0.3052721918,
-0.8609166741,
0.367507726,
0.4593532383,
0.1242820397,
0.3305737078,
0.0407235883,
0.3060651422,
0.6098148227,
-0.5271316171,
-1.3356792927,
0.1576725841,
-0.8582785726,
-0.0384184048,
1.1242544651,
-0.2145315409,
-0.4449563324,
-0.4987015724,
0.1839747131,
0.3798268437,
-0.2965426147,
0.8146689534,
0.4608269632,
-0.3709164262,
0.1382429302,
-1.0046160221,
0.2630731165,
0.3617393076,
-0.5232131481,
-0.067044057,
0.2604532242,
0.3919653893,
0.2578162849,
0.6844800115,
-0.0135286683,
0.4192889035,
0.2703376412,
0.0238541663,
0.2457147688,
-0.2911277413,
-0.2834088504,
0.3179008663,
0.464571476,
-0.3417512476
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02516v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02516v1
|
Adaptive scheduling for adaptive sampling in POS taggers construction
| 2024-02-04T15:02:17 | 2024-02-04T15:02:17 |
Manuel Vilares Ferro, Victor M. Darriba Bilbao, Jesús Vilares Ferro
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
We introduce an adaptive scheduling for adaptive sampling as a novel way of
machine learning in the construction of part-of-speech taggers. The goal is to
speed up the training on large data sets, without significant loss of
performance with regard to an optimal configuration. In contrast to previous
methods using a random, fixed or regularly rising spacing between the
instances, ours analyzes the shape of the learning curve geometrically in
conjunction with a functional model to increase or decrease it at any time. The
algorithm proves to be formally correct regarding our working hypotheses.
Namely, given a case, the following one is the nearest ensuring a net gain of
learning ability from the former, it being possible to modulate the level of
requirement for this condition. We also improve the robustness of sampling by
paying greater attention to those regions of the training data base subject to
a temporary inflation in performance, thus preventing the learning from
stopping prematurely.
The proposal has been evaluated on the basis of its reliability to identify
the convergence of models, corroborating our expectations. While a concrete
halting condition is used for testing, users can choose any condition
whatsoever to suit their own specific needs.
|
[
-0.3720576465,
-0.6231687069,
0.23308146,
0.3335777223,
-0.3029409945,
0.0732051507,
-0.0698480159,
-0.3805262446,
0.356934011,
0.458257705,
-0.4582324922,
-0.1379195452,
-0.5062468648,
-0.3198290169,
-0.1601587683,
0.987457335,
0.0967751965,
-0.2344942987,
-0.1655364484,
0.0014135359,
-0.6995219588,
-0.4225984514,
-0.9014289379,
-0.0066604624,
0.4490197003,
0.3077218533,
0.3411320746,
1.2350369692,
0.3583375514,
0.2341707647,
-0.1278971881,
-0.0644695014,
-0.0861738473,
0.2674035132,
-0.2938720286,
-0.2421969026,
-0.6046077013,
-0.1115189046,
0.9789055586,
0.9859756827,
-0.8557289839,
0.3194698393,
-0.0903936028,
0.3558168411,
-0.6500603557,
0.1238561794,
-1.0251036882,
-0.0311910305,
-0.3247833252,
-0.4829753339,
-0.4235969186,
-0.2002002746,
0.2343953699,
-0.7432542443,
0.5884666443,
0.0354469679,
0.6419234276,
0.6067404151,
0.102961041,
-0.1783859283,
-0.7719554901,
0.7725828886,
-0.5024659038,
0.2660135031,
0.4831136763,
0.4767635167,
-0.1615050733,
-0.714769423,
-0.3098788559,
-0.112377502,
0.3088112473,
0.2975948155,
0.0772028863,
-0.060009744,
0.6785003543,
0.0322986431,
-0.6552021503,
0.2596276999,
-0.4993238747,
-0.0960875154,
0.5563986897,
-0.0210668426,
-0.2339382023,
0.1943953633,
-0.5051249266,
0.0262729153,
-0.3198297024,
0.2005707324,
0.6123042107,
0.5200538635,
0.2197494805,
0.3540090322,
-0.3934701979,
1.0677640438,
-0.0415807776,
-0.3276458681,
0.4449102879,
0.2691556811,
-0.3476197124,
0.1636114717,
0.2295675874,
0.1153739765,
0.1643949449,
0.0711610839,
-0.5379257798,
0.1742312312,
0.5563130379,
-0.3757258952,
-0.4543045461,
-0.0095665725,
-0.3353883028,
-0.0967686251,
-0.0663309321,
-0.902623713,
-0.2697666585,
-0.2573502958,
0.285689503,
-0.4172643125,
-0.3428528607,
0.2622129917,
-0.3879348934,
0.0340215713,
0.0333797783,
-0.8265984058,
0.1171578094,
0.5063949227,
0.6983906031,
0.0155216651,
-0.3960128725,
-0.9599829912,
0.1326304674,
-0.2310213298,
1.1749780178,
-0.700304091,
-0.4054413438,
0.0159769095,
-0.1843951792,
-0.5037190318,
-0.820286274,
0.593305707,
-0.4201158285,
0.0617099144,
0.1395427436,
-0.6064663529,
0.2000935227,
0.0580374487,
-0.4424867034,
1.2275594473,
0.4591139257,
-0.6647255421,
0.5600403547,
-0.8292476535,
-0.4914320111,
0.27592659,
0.1896445602,
-0.7076910138,
-0.0457363203,
-0.0294599179,
0.4489601552,
0.2848335803,
-0.0354297943,
-0.3091077805,
-0.24598746,
0.0590601526,
0.2287702411,
0.5897958875,
0.5525890589,
-0.233343184,
0.1562555581,
-0.7293927073,
-0.1718743294,
0.2447260767,
-0.5001216531,
-0.1434483081,
0.7783803344,
-0.1537741423,
-0.0557901151,
-0.1632242799,
-0.4262536764,
0.3703400493,
-0.4531045556,
0.4345106184,
1.048556447,
0.2217931747,
0.461863786,
-0.8192777038,
0.8434330225,
-0.3780232966,
0.2415508628,
-0.2736593187,
-0.3884656429,
-0.6328133345,
-0.6367540956,
0.4946196079,
0.6999816895,
-0.9767597914,
0.5678332448,
-0.0737245008,
-0.5656666756,
-0.3028317392,
0.015337117,
0.325103581,
0.5196629167,
0.3038546145,
-0.5913830996,
-0.8288470507,
-0.3033654392,
-0.1380789876,
-0.0933277458,
-0.4585931599,
0.0220132414,
0.0901787579,
0.2693509758,
0.9451596737,
-0.5025063157,
-0.2984498441,
0.0715592578,
0.1360152811,
0.3295283914,
0.6020060182,
1.049397707,
-0.6678180099,
-0.3791798055,
-0.6052093506,
-0.1051205024,
-0.1964255273,
-0.2329943329,
0.0065924209,
0.3625657558,
0.5579766035,
-0.1227964982,
0.355733335,
0.4337188303,
-0.3452771902,
0.5600625873,
0.0358411819,
-0.4756132364,
-0.7807099223,
-0.0902183205,
0.061497584,
-0.3099324107,
-0.4220744073,
-0.1623015851,
-0.5075880289,
-0.1497371793,
-0.4511165023,
0.3380139768,
-0.2783606648,
-0.1392440349,
-0.444799602,
0.0587545857,
-0.3893230259,
0.5166742802,
0.1162260249,
0.3449596763,
0.8134579659,
-0.9156310558,
0.2610879838,
-0.0775540099,
-0.4200993776,
0.8008748293,
-0.4862091243,
0.1174518093,
-0.2319998294,
0.4077991545,
-0.8611865044,
-0.2194344848,
0.5459412336,
-0.8179873824,
0.4190366864,
-0.4102325737,
-0.2967180312,
-0.3364026248,
-0.0920164064,
0.2209364027,
0.7988491654,
-0.4290315509,
0.587353766,
0.7677975297,
-0.2420217395,
-0.2559772432,
-0.2237050384,
-0.6712008119,
-0.3275054395,
-0.2353641093,
0.4645081162,
-0.1297691464,
0.0485247895,
0.1520766616,
-0.266917944,
-0.2337439507,
0.4067976773,
0.1617370099,
0.2931024134,
-0.1377005428,
0.2575225532,
-0.1862195134,
-0.291513145,
-0.051729653,
-0.8020094633,
0.5317700505,
0.6280652285,
-0.2212772071,
-0.1847734451,
0.2236516774,
0.2205078751,
-0.4105460048,
0.6958878636,
0.806710422,
-0.8078430891,
-0.502555728,
-0.3255478144,
0.1709189862,
-0.428847909,
0.2187128067,
-0.5168954134,
-0.7349370122,
0.4351370633,
0.1209510863,
0.4467654824,
0.5837575793,
0.5019296408,
-0.3617575169,
0.8216101527,
0.719570756,
0.0148641849,
1.1691175699,
0.0146973375,
0.0655672327,
-0.5496928096,
-0.1253170371,
-0.7952510715,
-0.2449422032,
-0.4858054817,
-0.4100850821,
0.1530630738,
0.1417275667,
-0.2349313051,
-0.0594650917,
-1.0835462809,
0.4524419904,
0.7376697659,
-0.0976621062,
-0.3581504822,
0.123264581,
-0.0337161236,
0.2363560945,
-0.8976269364,
-0.2550661862,
0.8361092806,
0.0890123621,
0.5325865149,
-0.1270359904,
0.3231094778,
0.4249212444,
0.3094754517,
-0.6974289417,
0.2903477252,
-0.1179616302,
-0.5909583569,
-0.2867699862,
-0.3587407172,
-1.164399147,
-0.0164916292,
-0.1899651736,
-0.8733620644,
-0.0627769977,
0.5979878902,
-0.5027697086,
0.6187884212,
-0.7983977199,
0.6121672988,
-0.0660702884,
0.1167502329,
-0.0213128012,
-0.6757834554,
-0.1618162543,
0.0857704207,
0.0766775832,
-0.5304936767,
0.0490554646,
1.2333831787,
-0.0709588602,
0.750536561,
-0.9909465909,
0.3290920556,
0.5226301551,
-0.1627457589,
0.2370259613,
-0.1773933023,
-0.1236847118,
-0.1756684482,
0.1522901952,
-1.0821371078,
-0.3746478856,
0.251255393,
-0.5368940234,
-0.286742121,
-0.7920783162,
-0.5274668336,
-0.3370085359,
0.0413237438,
0.0958933607,
0.3018738031,
0.0753344744,
0.059331838,
0.5468391776,
-0.0661839396,
0.5272654295,
0.4906876385,
-0.0588082559,
-0.3107750118,
1.1336753368,
0.3161502481,
0.1352526397,
0.3617998064,
0.1172751263,
-0.2574952543,
-0.8991499543,
-0.2431606501,
0.094806239,
-0.2906287313,
-0.4508726895,
-0.2951280475,
-0.2535975873,
-0.6825610995,
-0.1280083358,
-0.1765917838,
-0.5033539534,
-0.206745401,
0.1410105675,
0.4193228185,
0.4462563097,
0.084288314,
0.7424063087,
-0.6948689818,
0.1781306416,
0.1013711318,
0.7265264392,
-0.287286669,
-0.9478247762,
-0.2377960831,
-0.1360448152,
-0.5591545701,
-0.6355099678,
0.0172583386,
0.3957395256,
0.9862370491,
0.348611623,
0.149321124,
0.4435142577,
-0.5580401421,
0.4868454635,
-0.1331161708,
-0.7394731641,
0.5349372029,
-0.4988276958,
0.1901906431,
0.2458442897,
0.4704972506,
-0.5299882293,
-0.1303430647,
-0.8033459783,
-0.8972949386,
0.6743953824,
-0.0433919057,
-0.0274307653,
0.1194446906,
0.6413568854,
-0.1269065291,
0.0338366702,
-0.1907126158,
0.0206226651,
-0.3317635357,
-0.1369591355,
-0.1719900966,
-0.4034464955,
-0.0436945744,
-0.2039234191,
0.7671276927,
-0.3262215853,
0.5649802685,
0.0835258365,
0.1216581091,
-0.0127498582,
-0.0183272362,
0.6311876774,
1.0824921131,
-0.4316368401,
-0.165233463,
0.2804971635,
-0.390601933,
-0.1659751236,
0.6033527255,
-0.0674746558,
0.0566822439,
0.1237080172,
0.8120992184,
-0.0152565967,
-0.7701091766,
0.163113758,
0.0241021197,
-0.3420152068,
-0.5886731744,
0.2055025995,
-0.1737495065,
0.3175123632,
0.4716827273,
0.2563174665,
-0.2462082356,
-0.2258722633,
0.2739470899,
0.2810852826,
-0.2791753113,
-0.3115725219,
0.5657490492,
0.1166225523,
-0.728983283,
0.4930633307,
-0.5476374626,
-0.5576602221,
0.5999470353,
0.5814421773,
0.5839767456,
-0.8349565864,
-0.1033201888,
0.4361230731,
0.3201712966,
0.1948152632,
0.352045089,
0.0300727747,
-0.7190830708,
-0.4271413982,
-0.9951236248,
-0.4459759593,
-0.0255241133,
-0.7570825219,
0.2828052938,
-0.6932501197,
-0.1241443157,
0.2536708117,
-0.1228227913,
-0.3924479187,
0.3733238876,
0.0964260846,
0.9556926489,
-0.8446490765,
0.9778078198,
1.092266202,
0.0989984795,
-0.5636264682,
-0.1324438304,
-0.1146624684,
-0.6495270133,
-0.4329646826,
-0.0312073585,
0.210389182,
0.2240115702,
-0.2284727842,
-0.7870708704,
0.8531484008,
0.3379612565,
-0.3497155607,
-0.1746746302,
-0.3403894007,
0.4120711088,
-0.326601088,
-0.1832872331,
0.6292808056,
0.113621518,
0.294303149,
-0.9904173017,
-0.1737846583,
-0.2526547611,
0.0296776276,
0.5689816475,
-0.4532107711,
0.6007846594,
0.1689994633,
-0.3831952512,
0.1664999425,
0.6079818606,
0.353133291,
0.5433682203,
1.1983164549,
0.563742578,
1.0355727673,
-0.3130119145,
0.8830453753,
-0.0971440673,
0.4202589095,
1.2228233814,
-0.1823823005,
0.8645194173,
0.3916839957,
-0.3850393891,
0.1396825612,
1.0685782433,
-0.1483224183,
0.4594355822,
0.5311143994,
-0.2012764066,
-0.1609112024,
-0.3280092776,
-0.4536207914,
0.573892951,
0.351680398,
-0.0860764533,
-0.0015822182,
0.1045870036,
-0.1013603657,
0.1622628719,
-0.3484714925,
0.6129003763,
-0.3345505297,
-0.8306018114,
0.4458148479,
0.0726962686,
0.6409967542,
-0.7332250476,
0.0433773845,
0.1255649924,
0.2227980942,
-0.1812254488,
-0.3685439229,
0.6666941643,
-0.1784818321,
-0.4822975993,
-0.4017923772,
0.6135727167,
-0.2614090741,
-0.4169666171,
0.03257351,
0.184735164,
0.1439632028,
-0.1058330238,
-0.6447211504,
0.0515396446,
-0.0971912667,
0.0804603174,
0.2783282697,
0.1764065474,
-0.00510163,
0.343757242,
0.7609984875,
0.1741583794,
0.5510017872,
-0.1562290192,
0.8495699763,
-0.3997258246,
-0.6741688251,
-0.490637511,
0.5060855746,
0.1989961863,
-0.1585365087,
0.4271816015,
0.6863490343,
1.4238437414,
0.1398538202,
0.6907299757,
-0.36217013,
1.0124217272,
-0.6097627282,
0.5048930049,
-0.4459852278,
0.0498884469,
-0.1087428555,
-0.9502481222,
-0.447072655,
0.6857594848,
-0.1747458726,
-0.0481494963,
0.5838862658,
0.5645564198,
-0.1403362304,
-0.1772435158,
0.0002581064,
-0.2093563825,
0.3410900235,
0.5466828346,
0.912273407,
0.089235656,
0.5894544125,
-0.4117088318,
-0.6374958158,
-0.1258557439,
-0.8285783529,
-0.5041851401,
-0.7028329968,
-0.4096418023,
-0.3487872481,
-0.0487743057,
0.8320201039,
0.9199721813,
-0.6246291995,
-0.2057528943,
0.2729144692,
0.1152290553,
-0.591586411,
-0.2622741759,
0.2252444476,
-0.516117692,
-0.8410012126,
0.2650073767,
0.0500858761,
-0.1082397252,
0.2578913569,
0.1252451241,
-0.5802417994,
0.0109867128,
0.3043034375,
0.5367910266,
-0.3245997131,
-0.3674132526,
-0.2213611454,
0.288220644,
0.2595267892,
1.1148998737,
-0.7457234263,
0.7154815197,
0.4787968397,
0.7949944735,
0.6415352225,
0.0314384326,
0.0224493891,
-1.045773983,
0.596529007,
0.5054156184,
0.4203103781,
0.1176475808,
-0.0378002711,
0.4899083376,
0.6998745203,
-0.6510079503,
-1.0938946009,
0.2807104886,
-1.0899350643,
-0.0077173249,
0.74135077,
-0.2842623293,
-0.241684109,
-0.2168812007,
-0.047041893,
0.4743190408,
-0.1858895868,
0.8589804173,
0.3553976119,
-0.3503962755,
0.2483606637,
-0.6703862548,
0.3485713601,
0.3771043718,
-0.6992727518,
-0.4103839099,
0.3394635022,
0.5068200231,
0.1809423864,
0.9474744201,
0.3218897581,
0.4954382181,
0.0119210314,
0.1151171327,
-0.0504045859,
-0.4546878934,
-0.3024771512,
0.1548149139,
0.2297288477,
-0.9067398906
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02515v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02515v1
|
Modeling of learning curves with applications to pos tagging
| 2024-02-04T15:00:52 | 2024-02-04T15:00:52 |
Manuel Vilares Ferro, Victor M. Darriba Bilbao, Francisco J. Ribadas Pena
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
An algorithm to estimate the evolution of learning curves on the whole of a
training data base, based on the results obtained from a portion and using a
functional strategy, is introduced. We approximate iteratively the sought value
at the desired time, independently of the learning technique used and once a
point in the process, called prediction level, has been passed. The proposal
proves to be formally correct with respect to our working hypotheses and
includes a reliable proximity condition. This allows the user to fix a
convergence threshold with respect to the accuracy finally achievable, which
extends the concept of stopping criterion and seems to be effective even in the
presence of distorting observations.
Our aim is to evaluate the training effort, supporting decision making in
order to reduce the need for both human and computational resources during the
learning process. The proposal is of interest in at least three operational
procedures. The first is the anticipation of accuracy gain, with the purpose of
measuring how much work is needed to achieve a certain degree of performance.
The second relates the comparison of efficiency between systems at training
time, with the objective of completing this task only for the one that best
suits our requirements. The prediction of accuracy is also a valuable item of
information for customizing systems, since we can estimate in advance the
impact of settings on both the performance and the development costs. Using the
generation of part-of-speech taggers as an example application, the
experimental results are consistent with our expectations.
|
[
-0.2824440897,
-0.8166846037,
0.3222876191,
-0.0994714871,
-0.1016087532,
-0.0791717172,
-0.1176244617,
-0.3460285664,
0.1733223796,
0.0378050618,
-0.5370137691,
-0.4832223952,
-0.4155584574,
-0.2992006242,
-0.295119077,
0.8617139459,
0.0376840234,
0.0652182922,
-0.033754319,
0.3153432906,
-0.5504805446,
-0.4719791114,
-0.872349143,
-0.1896931678,
0.6386348009,
0.3282002807,
0.1784258485,
1.0174988508,
0.4910783768,
0.2350706458,
-0.2359835804,
-0.1290586591,
-0.2939351499,
0.1393046677,
-0.1825003177,
-0.6259617805,
-0.5849967003,
-0.0458375625,
0.7933624983,
0.7964074016,
-0.4597550333,
0.1973175853,
0.0098273009,
0.4552937448,
-0.4234900475,
0.2868808508,
-0.4014599919,
0.0278962161,
-0.2303100973,
-0.3695638478,
-0.5024237037,
-0.3780646324,
0.5398325324,
-0.5963668823,
0.2852720022,
-0.2166953832,
0.8926357627,
0.1369596422,
0.1522615105,
-0.5094707608,
-0.8466047645,
0.8260252476,
-0.7081539631,
0.2511734962,
0.4959377348,
0.4580413997,
-0.2245150954,
-0.5805796981,
-0.0493179858,
-0.4260374606,
0.1927761286,
0.0116130663,
0.0910069495,
0.2407522798,
0.7981948256,
0.1627763212,
-0.3345457315,
0.2102779001,
-0.6477184892,
0.1367038339,
0.8511416316,
0.0815513432,
-0.1241065934,
0.0614098273,
-0.3931412101,
0.1613723785,
-0.3797058463,
0.384144634,
0.6256228685,
0.626758635,
-0.0862233639,
0.5435342193,
-0.3867021501,
0.8501932621,
-0.042387452,
-0.7087221146,
0.5584025383,
0.2572115064,
-0.0869476721,
-0.2592153251,
0.3405415416,
0.1886755526,
0.4049577117,
0.0426469296,
-0.3014254868,
0.0090293521,
0.3845837116,
-0.3779891729,
-0.2892027497,
-0.0986190811,
-0.405813545,
-0.2268371582,
0.0432474241,
-0.9588475823,
-0.3510331511,
-0.4527902901,
0.3782084584,
-0.8813646436,
-0.3538722694,
0.0520314015,
-0.1605733186,
0.165846765,
0.1644940972,
-0.8905168176,
0.0429765768,
0.6026929617,
1.1128227711,
-0.0153075289,
-0.3799503446,
-0.4642914534,
0.0059311888,
-0.1436582655,
0.7189260721,
-0.7689964175,
-0.5663987994,
0.0426268205,
-0.4575680792,
-0.2957854569,
-0.3006924987,
0.6825424433,
-0.294237107,
-0.2288871109,
-0.0830233917,
-0.9655244946,
-0.05889377,
0.1338322312,
-0.4297210574,
1.0757776499,
0.2313038111,
-0.6931500435,
0.6445553303,
-1.1064078808,
-0.5614543557,
0.1589398384,
0.1270361245,
-0.5680142641,
0.131425187,
-0.3780562878,
0.4511568248,
0.0358782224,
-0.0439819731,
-0.2750244737,
-0.2330730855,
0.0707352385,
0.0877174884,
0.510016799,
0.3743215501,
-0.2391513437,
0.142976597,
-0.6862387657,
0.0223864112,
0.1190376133,
-0.5370078087,
-0.4302778244,
0.652321279,
-0.5967432857,
-0.0374123901,
-0.0037981337,
-0.5428196192,
0.5010848045,
-0.3135719001,
0.4901263714,
0.5188255906,
0.2129987329,
0.5268139243,
-0.3920654953,
0.6840510964,
-0.2950567603,
0.5063185096,
-0.3180636466,
-0.6021208763,
-0.5807810426,
-0.4225093126,
0.6530236006,
0.4844957888,
-0.6629532576,
0.4503660798,
-0.126578331,
-0.7932275534,
-0.112548992,
-0.2028744668,
0.4185654819,
0.7517549396,
0.2425645888,
-0.3975491226,
-0.367980212,
-0.2783234417,
-0.1407827586,
-0.3059628904,
-0.2961858809,
-0.0599771924,
0.3680104315,
0.1955202073,
0.9371925592,
-0.4940147698,
-0.1031188369,
0.0513324775,
0.4813005924,
-0.1424444914,
0.6662531495,
0.5912938714,
-0.8025017381,
-0.4714258909,
-0.1962710172,
-0.5116745234,
0.025761975,
0.0445206426,
0.0733761713,
0.2449449599,
0.19995296,
-0.1445661932,
0.7522103786,
0.1645264179,
-0.2099116892,
0.7693042159,
-0.11154975,
-0.0315957889,
-0.5930721164,
0.0494816452,
0.6856226325,
0.0755966902,
-0.9760950208,
-0.1206075102,
-0.265032649,
-0.0173518844,
-0.2817402184,
0.2937803566,
-0.3278725445,
-0.2361479551,
-0.0720348284,
0.1693235487,
-0.4520361125,
0.5184307098,
0.1648671627,
0.4602630436,
0.8326752782,
-0.6811003685,
0.1466541588,
0.0369806103,
-0.2958531976,
0.8527638912,
-0.2618109882,
-0.0900837183,
-0.0612641498,
-0.2017201334,
-0.8048906326,
-0.113767229,
0.4082342982,
-0.9589836001,
0.4567464888,
-0.4613958001,
-0.1226398051,
-0.5277750492,
-0.0698955804,
-0.0963996723,
0.7112724185,
-0.1150392666,
0.5990323424,
0.508507967,
-0.1018421352,
-0.5457814336,
-0.3492302895,
-0.5114595294,
-0.4834971428,
-0.2529211342,
0.1684872061,
0.0057353377,
0.048921857,
-0.2140645534,
-0.1371668726,
-0.1324776411,
0.168146804,
0.2410232574,
0.4010796845,
-0.1558473557,
0.44965747,
-0.1529639512,
-0.1854958981,
0.1085723266,
-0.5991661549,
0.4155111611,
0.1055052355,
-0.1757286489,
-0.5275277495,
-0.0528632551,
0.1467119455,
-0.4573439658,
0.7116126418,
0.4378224611,
-0.6685207486,
-0.4373925328,
-0.2619581223,
0.1188755855,
-0.4720490873,
0.2244173735,
-0.7440745234,
-0.3569575548,
0.6465653181,
-0.3287742734,
0.2479052246,
0.2781345844,
0.3103171885,
-0.4493364096,
1.0583482981,
0.9205831289,
0.2847752869,
1.0922267437,
-0.4865715802,
0.3400078118,
-0.5809476376,
-0.5701022744,
-0.8095080256,
-0.3448180556,
-0.6144090891,
-0.3347154558,
0.1217388585,
0.4425910115,
-0.2936194241,
0.2122665495,
-0.6557680368,
0.38604936,
0.6365051866,
0.1392652541,
0.0205989853,
0.3228155375,
-0.1293241084,
-0.0013604909,
-0.8539173007,
-0.4929586053,
0.9627897143,
0.5168742537,
0.8000617027,
-0.3701129258,
0.6058325768,
0.5461841822,
0.6042962074,
-0.9863122106,
0.3503229022,
-0.0904244334,
-0.4393952787,
-0.7041348219,
-0.6205559373,
-0.7100467086,
-0.1275543123,
-0.1070289835,
-1.0915380716,
0.0431991406,
0.5154166818,
-0.292262882,
0.6489012837,
-0.7697341442,
0.7811352611,
-0.4630948901,
-0.327345252,
0.0557141379,
-0.8230546117,
-0.177516669,
-0.0509662256,
-0.0544674732,
-0.3620343804,
-0.0522956476,
1.2284677029,
-0.2720453441,
0.7198608518,
-0.8858883381,
0.085152775,
0.6552403569,
-0.1619111001,
0.1287922114,
-0.6206356883,
-0.5560737252,
0.0820954144,
0.143769443,
-0.6619641185,
-0.495034188,
0.3256129622,
-0.5564513206,
-0.166413188,
-0.3912497461,
-0.3630403578,
-0.2976578474,
0.2653094232,
0.2071036845,
0.3900190592,
0.0857327506,
-0.1808336973,
0.5486883521,
-0.0037417139,
0.2611707747,
0.393545717,
-0.162489593,
-0.2489891201,
1.1196142435,
0.4030979276,
0.3775292337,
0.2987377644,
0.260853976,
-0.3851064742,
-0.9079130292,
-0.2506011128,
0.3373443186,
-0.6641879678,
-0.4315612018,
0.0254572649,
-0.2106873989,
-0.1728008837,
-0.3158577383,
0.008011966,
-0.2488262206,
-0.3346242607,
-0.1781352013,
0.2834833264,
0.7970312238,
-0.1173108891,
0.8431621194,
-0.4301837385,
-0.2663630247,
-0.271482408,
0.7285757065,
-0.1901594549,
-0.6007700562,
-0.4062021971,
0.2640595436,
-0.4913036227,
-0.9715001583,
0.2809354365,
0.2686782479,
0.8512138128,
0.5253372788,
-0.0848447233,
0.5739340782,
-0.2303328663,
0.5265462399,
0.2754723728,
-1.0317546129,
0.7589035034,
-0.407056123,
-0.2001485676,
0.4191194773,
0.9493014812,
-0.3120006323,
0.035133224,
-0.5479082465,
-0.5960273743,
0.7948175669,
-0.1009170488,
-0.1743625104,
0.2919875681,
1.077169776,
0.0009569749,
0.1282843202,
-0.3727043867,
-0.1188865453,
-0.0170548875,
-0.3647565246,
-0.0088921757,
-0.1627004445,
0.2686883807,
-0.1980878562,
0.6949803829,
-0.2080860138,
0.3565753102,
0.0105702477,
0.1035466418,
-0.2520611882,
-0.1611171365,
0.4809931219,
1.1160160303,
-0.2505140305,
-0.2266530097,
0.1849788278,
-0.3363604844,
0.0776969343,
0.1298053712,
-0.2682516277,
-0.1047223508,
0.0724641085,
0.7523331642,
-0.0872229934,
-0.7132644057,
0.2711731791,
0.236645177,
-0.2558457851,
-0.2705298066,
0.1456316113,
-0.2263671905,
0.3211905062,
0.3698270321,
-0.0364368148,
0.024437895,
-0.2140258104,
0.385451138,
0.3068696558,
-0.4641520977,
-0.2806116641,
0.3341898024,
0.3017641604,
-0.9220126867,
0.4199528992,
-0.4163227379,
-0.5571554303,
0.6650176644,
0.3671091199,
0.5744901896,
-0.8820275664,
0.3278791308,
0.6667789221,
0.2173077017,
-0.0081219971,
0.121905461,
-0.0518007353,
-0.3715765774,
-0.3688648343,
-0.9943106174,
-0.3298672736,
0.0117015066,
-0.8855101466,
0.6144925356,
-0.4177660048,
-0.5701975822,
0.3698318303,
0.0422403961,
-0.3379986584,
0.4152467549,
0.4054486752,
1.1693274975,
-0.8383558393,
0.9129872322,
0.7593185902,
-0.5183059573,
-0.6534687281,
-0.1592921168,
-0.2534198761,
-0.5242028236,
0.0944207683,
0.0855220482,
-0.1325132251,
0.1024897173,
-0.2272594571,
-0.7284478545,
1.0226390362,
0.1537536532,
-0.7217109799,
-0.5829159617,
0.1669915468,
0.5793774128,
-0.459043026,
0.0632646903,
1.046626091,
0.1895025074,
0.3822468221,
-0.8904019594,
-0.3007375598,
0.0094863456,
-0.0394043811,
0.5485184789,
-0.2381834835,
0.8358846307,
-0.3073096871,
-0.3418150246,
0.2262181789,
0.4252810478,
0.0773059949,
0.4659974575,
0.6334855556,
0.507353127,
0.8581008315,
-0.3478486836,
0.7988643646,
-0.1557745188,
0.766332984,
1.0089343786,
-0.0388881378,
0.8844187856,
0.1832932979,
-0.3646139503,
0.4145393372,
0.9101940989,
-0.2589552701,
0.3734506071,
0.5826557279,
-0.1529291272,
0.148552537,
0.0986466184,
-0.1454807222,
0.273547858,
0.5720384121,
-0.5175565481,
0.0261324495,
0.1359116435,
-0.030963717,
-0.0159048736,
-0.5353144407,
0.7590952516,
-0.2834311724,
-0.6628218889,
0.4616386592,
0.2183158696,
0.4933775961,
-0.897126615,
-0.0899735466,
0.0979578942,
0.151281625,
-0.2802420855,
-0.700506568,
0.3560616672,
0.1144220307,
-0.0106705464,
-0.2219698578,
0.806768477,
-0.4435436726,
-0.3057868183,
0.2470095307,
0.3576611876,
0.321680665,
0.2690747678,
-0.7268840075,
0.101629585,
0.1633231044,
-0.0383629985,
0.0153783988,
0.1526802629,
0.1300230622,
0.6477150917,
0.3366339505,
0.1105602011,
0.5481849313,
-0.3500128984,
0.7178990841,
-0.4654207528,
-0.6663970351,
-0.6360912919,
0.7058485746,
0.0146506745,
-0.2531831861,
0.4849278033,
0.5457205176,
1.25750947,
0.1822751611,
0.9656778574,
-0.3729738295,
0.6510164738,
-0.4528231025,
0.470223695,
-0.4329439402,
-0.0259101782,
-0.1078146026,
-0.7984600067,
-0.2432926893,
0.8291109204,
-0.8700732589,
0.2742862403,
0.4200690985,
0.5145753026,
0.0486167893,
0.1887155771,
0.2700376809,
-0.2240734547,
0.2723937333,
0.3418442905,
0.9697089791,
-0.0312399436,
0.3672993183,
-0.6091811061,
-0.7537279725,
-0.2087333798,
-0.7770159245,
-0.7077276707,
-0.668995738,
-0.3301211596,
-0.2613147199,
-0.0000136497,
0.6005741358,
0.9621798992,
-0.5755371451,
-0.4444610476,
-0.055839695,
-0.0523803234,
-0.310952276,
-0.1876324862,
0.1762120277,
-0.5587728024,
-0.6146339774,
-0.0485744216,
0.0024018048,
0.1229577065,
-0.2536164224,
-0.2574886978,
-0.4828877449,
0.1061147898,
0.3901632726,
0.6524369717,
-0.4779052734,
-0.2484539449,
-0.1362457275,
0.2809186876,
0.2806119025,
1.0247414112,
-0.476262331,
0.6782286167,
0.4070299268,
0.4551690817,
0.7525773644,
0.294919461,
0.0842045695,
-0.6987585425,
-0.0386197641,
0.3096814454,
0.1563852429,
0.2776866555,
-0.0206776187,
0.6237155795,
0.35730654,
-0.5003650188,
-0.9332680702,
0.2364035994,
-0.705820322,
0.1086959839,
0.7346003652,
-0.6762372255,
-0.3609517813,
0.0897965431,
-0.034846738,
0.5443347692,
-0.319662571,
0.7911041975,
0.4497855008,
-0.5663654804,
0.1741122156,
-0.612796247,
0.637868464,
0.049820818,
-0.9001375437,
-0.0569857359,
0.4563440681,
0.4115748703,
0.4915234745,
0.3738508821,
0.1052513719,
0.1548187733,
0.1294091493,
0.1608251035,
0.0129960617,
-0.6389916539,
-0.425246954,
0.1770016104,
0.2332974225,
-0.5811908841
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02513v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02513v1
|
Early stopping by correlating online indicators in neural networks
| 2024-02-04T14:57:20 | 2024-02-04T14:57:20 |
Manuel Vilares Ferro, Yerai Doval Mosquera, Francisco J. Ribadas Pena, Victor M. Darriba Bilbao
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.NE
|
In order to minimize the generalization error in neural networks, a novel
technique to identify overfitting phenomena when training the learner is
formally introduced. This enables support of a reliable and trustworthy early
stopping condition, thus improving the predictive power of that type of
modeling. Our proposal exploits the correlation over time in a collection of
online indicators, namely characteristic functions for indicating if a set of
hypotheses are met, associated with a range of independent stopping conditions
built from a canary judgment to evaluate the presence of overfitting. That way,
we provide a formal basis for decision making in terms of interrupting the
learning process.
As opposed to previous approaches focused on a single criterion, we take
advantage of subsidiarities between independent assessments, thus seeking both
a wider operating range and greater diagnostic reliability. With a view to
illustrating the effectiveness of the halting condition described, we choose to
work in the sphere of natural language processing, an operational continuum
increasingly based on machine learning. As a case study, we focus on parser
generation, one of the most demanding and complex tasks in the domain. The
selection of cross-validation as a canary function enables an actual comparison
with the most representative early stopping conditions based on overfitting
identification, pointing to a promising start toward an optimal bias and
variance control.
|
[
-0.7537560463,
-0.9669598341,
0.6288003922,
0.3509548903,
-0.0340497382,
-0.0414912477,
-0.2191148847,
-0.5526233912,
0.2300815135,
0.1689327657,
-0.2310783863,
-0.0709544718,
-0.6635252237,
-0.0147848893,
-0.5624989867,
0.9619697928,
0.030910043,
0.0153059093,
-0.2434559762,
0.065336816,
-0.4428107738,
-0.5725421309,
-1.4784065485,
-0.4021715224,
0.538670063,
-0.2319550216,
0.5117269158,
0.6566104889,
0.3357751369,
0.3666784763,
-0.345493108,
0.0897939205,
-0.2565288246,
0.225929901,
-0.0046116719,
-0.4702498913,
-0.2630040944,
-0.0787476972,
0.3611921668,
1.066567421,
-0.0882607028,
-0.1135716885,
0.2969435751,
0.6316897869,
-0.8410256505,
0.5226692557,
-0.3256691992,
0.2945418358,
-0.1486033201,
-0.2881588638,
-0.2581947148,
-0.4387162924,
0.305180639,
-0.4969935715,
0.24185808,
-0.2275760174,
0.8481903076,
0.3944795728,
-0.0557667501,
-0.1998775899,
-0.7340788841,
0.8957186341,
-0.3885675967,
0.5256935954,
0.8700558543,
0.5618677139,
-0.1219446212,
-0.7342609763,
-0.1678896546,
-0.2292793393,
-0.0289174356,
0.1851004213,
-0.4015027881,
-0.1092567369,
0.1456782371,
-0.0029528833,
-0.320861429,
0.1300724745,
-0.6644669771,
-0.4556489885,
0.4417245388,
-0.0489960983,
0.1202375963,
0.2171881795,
-0.2965494692,
0.1449306309,
-0.557777226,
0.3617895842,
0.5060477853,
0.3332196772,
0.1060873494,
0.1571491957,
-0.3991666138,
0.7190597057,
0.1351201534,
0.1352711767,
0.0439636521,
-0.0354107097,
-0.4504872859,
0.2902137041,
0.7300306559,
0.1847176552,
0.6617138386,
-0.230674997,
-0.148140043,
0.037862666,
0.1297560185,
-0.5855124593,
-0.1873850822,
0.4706161022,
-0.492190361,
-0.5194442272,
-0.0644478574,
-0.5813130736,
-0.1384053379,
-0.5890296102,
0.1031800732,
-0.38031739,
-0.0994738564,
0.0192669984,
0.0619053692,
-0.2934942245,
0.1131254882,
-0.6106984019,
0.4987010062,
0.5038661361,
1.1024531126,
-0.0134171564,
-0.3066389859,
-1.0770542622,
-0.2006281167,
-0.2636082172,
0.4052881896,
-0.2406246364,
0.0127610434,
0.2198899388,
-0.0713751689,
-0.0632777587,
-0.3587358892,
0.5078240633,
-0.6841205955,
0.1390370429,
-0.1629748791,
-0.588346839,
-0.1649478078,
0.4465225041,
-0.8985657692,
0.9415431619,
-0.0802819878,
-0.6953808069,
0.7791631818,
-0.6905779839,
-0.4469299614,
-0.3053308427,
-0.0410121679,
-0.6856170893,
0.0248760805,
0.1471339315,
0.5415949821,
-0.2560150027,
0.4383051693,
-0.3593280613,
0.0931958333,
0.3872917891,
-0.2866749763,
0.7739647031,
0.2756914496,
-0.0901905,
0.1324349195,
-1.1798131466,
0.2087357342,
-0.1546013653,
-0.471395582,
-0.5312352777,
0.2882344425,
-0.2058324367,
0.2641350627,
0.0234314669,
-0.6061385274,
-0.2861301005,
-0.2885937989,
0.5369161963,
0.452491194,
0.1145711169,
-0.0481698476,
-0.4329500496,
0.3875935078,
-0.0739533901,
0.3938957453,
-0.098386921,
-0.8252159953,
-1.1085786819,
-0.1747530997,
0.4390773475,
0.4225542247,
-0.5108690858,
0.6743091345,
0.1474813074,
-0.0566797405,
-0.1597115546,
0.2386082709,
0.7026245594,
0.4365132749,
0.6694316864,
-0.318562448,
-0.887629509,
-0.482275486,
-0.0553894974,
-0.2833576798,
0.0367067493,
-0.0365418643,
0.313262105,
0.1830303967,
1.1742166281,
-0.1528427005,
-0.3433691561,
-0.2179667503,
0.2883452773,
0.1731778532,
0.4381495416,
0.6550312638,
-0.5740481615,
-0.5754952431,
0.0569248311,
-0.8405494094,
-0.1636057347,
-0.2928755581,
-0.083144106,
0.0260468051,
0.9360502958,
-0.3105085492,
0.4445484579,
0.2122815102,
-0.2809759676,
0.3870252967,
-0.2146202326,
-0.0892895982,
-0.22195822,
0.1459174752,
0.2124495804,
-0.2560646236,
-0.6337917447,
-0.1299095452,
-0.2428345084,
0.0743293241,
-0.6015976667,
0.2513764799,
-0.143210724,
0.001239666,
-0.012443129,
-0.147133708,
0.1699255258,
0.3733618855,
0.0236618556,
0.3027434349,
0.4321575165,
-0.7851016521,
0.1945908815,
0.0853705257,
-0.0625262633,
0.5729091763,
-1.0347331762,
-0.0719625652,
-0.0753270164,
-0.1745251119,
-0.6587044597,
-0.093721725,
0.4220535755,
-0.4932160378,
0.2687834203,
-0.4157238901,
-0.0131834121,
-0.1562105566,
-0.0060807145,
0.1904574782,
0.365123421,
-0.4160003662,
0.279843539,
0.004616587,
0.0216267016,
-0.3584411442,
-0.8519687653,
-0.2087359428,
-0.1143806726,
-0.6302565932,
0.0733234137,
0.4039284587,
-0.286393553,
-0.0261872914,
0.2149165571,
-0.4336900711,
0.2283703089,
0.0409318693,
0.0861584321,
-0.1796725392,
0.101542905,
0.1965379566,
-0.4815675914,
0.211882025,
-0.4542529285,
0.5745632648,
0.02658429,
-0.3262765408,
-0.4036084712,
0.1836175621,
0.3889014125,
-0.3491975665,
0.8564288616,
0.663289845,
-0.426784724,
-0.1342435628,
-0.3093011975,
0.1445367783,
-0.4031946361,
0.1411817223,
-0.2584663033,
-0.2464180589,
0.7082948685,
0.1837838739,
-0.2392116189,
0.5249698758,
0.4414960444,
0.0274560675,
0.8703849912,
0.5247077346,
0.0138089173,
0.5430355072,
-0.300344348,
0.0797975063,
-0.6024255157,
-0.286380589,
-0.4893732071,
-0.1148166433,
-0.2293941677,
-0.2190429717,
0.328322053,
0.3821113706,
-0.3107744157,
-0.0236069262,
-0.4177328646,
0.4991204143,
0.4651745856,
0.164711386,
0.1300512552,
-0.0081761349,
-0.3686083853,
0.0366985276,
-0.7765949965,
-0.0034942247,
1.1279807091,
0.3510771096,
0.5054451823,
-0.1709401906,
0.6209289432,
0.6025684476,
0.0737078264,
-0.8538972139,
0.0522409454,
-0.0525533706,
-0.4659897685,
-0.3851844668,
-0.5634960532,
-1.1544942856,
0.0332717635,
-0.2016506046,
-0.7762594223,
0.403973937,
0.4655183554,
-0.6316669583,
0.1461599618,
-0.4676457345,
0.8059268594,
-0.5986255407,
-0.5052261353,
0.0719728321,
-0.5619733334,
0.384657383,
-0.1217972562,
0.2078367174,
0.1536814421,
0.0919685364,
0.8189826012,
-0.6508609056,
1.2025462389,
-0.3668649793,
0.4066882432,
0.4950906038,
0.0613888726,
0.5152780414,
-0.4745735526,
-0.2236532867,
0.1841922998,
-0.0713210925,
-0.2430384606,
-0.4398686886,
0.4284785688,
-0.7698085904,
0.3795827627,
-0.5413807034,
0.0741644427,
-0.1488196403,
0.3457660973,
0.433093667,
0.5106678009,
-0.3539939523,
0.15322496,
0.4509909749,
-0.1967757344,
0.65495646,
0.0746939629,
-0.5314984322,
-0.7017737031,
1.2389047146,
0.3651681542,
0.3901746869,
0.0000785606,
0.7004467845,
-0.2922594547,
-0.6685749292,
-0.2344726324,
-0.3174969256,
-0.8559496403,
-0.07711564,
-0.4094333351,
-0.3786645234,
-0.0109588197,
-0.1147177368,
-0.3208099008,
-0.3749103248,
-0.3815912306,
0.1844620854,
0.0365951099,
0.7469703555,
-0.1129251868,
0.5963956118,
-0.8373639584,
0.006554767,
0.2495770603,
0.3612448573,
0.2439698279,
-0.116027005,
-0.5054995418,
-0.2632403672,
-0.4528915584,
-0.5238727331,
0.37372455,
0.7552064657,
0.9606136084,
0.8674710989,
0.0591253601,
0.3200577497,
-0.0822793171,
0.3438661397,
0.5895450115,
-1.0624309778,
0.4867095947,
-0.1674074978,
0.0358331725,
0.3380977511,
0.7329106927,
-0.4941770434,
-0.389034152,
-0.5785251856,
-0.9115408063,
0.1380957663,
0.5839816332,
-0.4824684262,
-0.1683507562,
0.1459137946,
0.0863196105,
0.2438832372,
-0.2732795775,
-0.0216400083,
-0.4803303182,
0.0214877129,
0.0881952345,
-0.0807154179,
-0.2790076137,
-0.2606034577,
0.5001476407,
-0.4330003262,
0.0287015438,
0.1956683993,
-0.3359948397,
-0.1877770573,
-0.0104412874,
0.4802272022,
0.8612927794,
-0.1554095298,
0.1074638069,
-0.0362467878,
-0.1479834616,
-0.048708804,
-0.0052358038,
-0.4628290534,
-0.0582132973,
0.6881359816,
0.7661778927,
0.2515241504,
-0.1521265954,
0.2925150394,
-0.0830509365,
0.1302848905,
-0.4451949,
0.095847927,
-0.3070394993,
0.1553330868,
0.2402823865,
0.3438526988,
0.1704018861,
-0.296163559,
0.4946345389,
0.2752195299,
-0.5979118943,
-0.3003330827,
0.5558209419,
0.4358068407,
-0.3629579842,
0.3875565529,
-0.4294950068,
-0.7653660178,
1.0109870434,
0.3376066983,
1.0964106321,
0.1207642779,
0.0478033572,
0.4748210013,
0.2754253447,
-0.0830101222,
0.3371576965,
-0.1325771511,
-0.8104250431,
-0.6798747778,
-0.9385831356,
-0.2004303038,
0.0126089025,
-1.0144108534,
0.224170506,
-0.9976450801,
-0.592248857,
0.2396752387,
-0.3502426147,
-0.7496145368,
0.4979643226,
0.2702810168,
0.4765394926,
-1.0741711855,
0.6276401281,
0.3610349298,
-0.6412815452,
-0.214590475,
-0.2489461005,
0.1110170856,
-0.6684787273,
0.7420182824,
0.2481014431,
0.0443179533,
-0.2401700765,
-0.3014067113,
-0.6607235074,
0.5857967138,
0.1179898009,
-0.702155292,
-0.0047832485,
0.1055372283,
0.6741048694,
-0.3348225951,
0.4853931963,
0.9987255335,
0.5382118225,
0.1229809746,
-0.8957595229,
-0.0007630431,
-0.1870254278,
-0.1468262672,
0.3810372055,
-0.5032958984,
1.0432485342,
0.0265485756,
0.1227384359,
0.0950265899,
0.3549562991,
-0.13444224,
0.372882098,
0.6967681646,
0.7393565774,
0.7684239745,
-0.215832442,
0.9878293276,
-0.3257959485,
0.6163583398,
1.1075537205,
0.2601690888,
0.7456418872,
0.4992364645,
-0.4691314101,
0.1108635738,
0.6094264388,
-0.1056337953,
0.462305665,
0.2099049836,
-0.0879310891,
-0.6749219298,
-0.0469065905,
-0.5010429025,
0.4775228202,
0.3241759837,
-0.6923388243,
-0.4286670089,
-0.0389577858,
-0.0806311145,
-0.1938884258,
-0.1982888728,
0.481328994,
0.0637862459,
-0.6343053579,
0.6660339832,
-0.1974829435,
0.3287159801,
-0.6343017817,
0.0218201596,
0.1316975355,
0.273314625,
-0.4574525952,
-0.5040516257,
0.6070482731,
-0.2708506584,
-0.2931081355,
-0.227174148,
0.7023068666,
-0.2082314193,
-0.7924718857,
0.6945581436,
0.5862770677,
0.1813948303,
-0.0606416613,
-0.6054104567,
0.3512564898,
-0.1708105505,
-0.2216196954,
0.2851739526,
0.216094017,
-0.0240408238,
0.6192843318,
1.1669778824,
0.4306639433,
0.4085205793,
0.1395445466,
0.5824147463,
-0.4089451134,
-0.9019860029,
-0.8278009295,
0.592348516,
-0.1409842521,
-0.6934353113,
0.3577134311,
0.2755944729,
0.8194248676,
0.3434776068,
1.0132377148,
-0.2537698746,
0.3238973618,
-0.7944835424,
0.8661962152,
-0.5040587187,
0.2633244097,
0.0703040659,
-0.6506632566,
-0.381916523,
0.6682494283,
-0.3758638501,
0.0387246013,
0.6569007039,
0.1787356287,
-0.3561021388,
-0.0315059423,
0.5005475283,
0.1158739701,
0.5878754854,
0.321208775,
0.9546064138,
-0.2550590038,
0.4959305525,
-0.560634613,
-0.2612362802,
-0.3389070034,
-1.036518693,
-1.1331553459,
-0.1248954535,
-0.3614915907,
-0.5289641619,
0.0897818059,
0.8890383244,
0.8804504275,
-1.198456645,
-0.0209216867,
-0.4613904357,
-0.0851742402,
-0.3807631135,
-0.131176576,
0.311165899,
-0.874540925,
-0.3250279725,
0.3875150979,
0.0206585675,
-0.0403065458,
-0.6641583443,
-0.3381271362,
-0.2925700247,
-0.0259875245,
0.6371280551,
0.7969548106,
-0.4938474,
-0.26626724,
-0.3484479189,
0.2582471967,
0.0771257728,
1.0010435581,
-0.814827621,
0.7584281564,
0.6236189604,
0.7414607406,
0.6391465068,
-0.238693431,
0.6426541805,
-0.6460006833,
0.2189379185,
0.2124233544,
0.5708150268,
0.2600295544,
-0.3499647975,
0.4089487493,
0.4600859284,
-0.4473058879,
-0.6047785282,
0.1334121674,
-0.5608394146,
0.1631470174,
0.6533482671,
-0.6285230517,
-0.1247226894,
-0.5596236587,
0.2356297523,
0.3799453378,
-0.4485818446,
0.878757298,
0.7565003633,
-0.4997730553,
0.1549918354,
-0.4890130162,
0.4248972833,
0.453597784,
-0.7840589285,
-0.5513176322,
0.2188503593,
0.1244857609,
0.5333427787,
0.1451848596,
0.3297195435,
0.3945348561,
0.080339238,
-0.1624639481,
-0.4132225811,
-0.7914637327,
-0.3035854399,
0.3964238465,
-0.0609690696,
-0.5423167944
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02503v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02503v1
|
GeReA: Question-Aware Prompt Captions for Knowledge-based Visual Question Answering
| 2024-02-04T14:28:23 | 2024-02-04T14:28:23 |
Ziyu Ma, Shutao Li, Bin Sun, Jianfei Cai, Zuxiang Long, Fuyan Ma
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Knowledge-based visual question answering (VQA) requires world knowledge
beyond the image for accurate answer. Recently, instead of extra knowledge
bases, a large language model (LLM) like GPT-3 is activated as an implicit
knowledge engine to jointly acquire and reason the necessary knowledge for
answering by converting images into textual information (e.g., captions and
answer candidates). However, such conversion may introduce irrelevant
information, which causes the LLM to misinterpret images and ignore visual
details crucial for accurate knowledge. We argue that multimodal large language
model (MLLM) is a better implicit knowledge engine than the LLM for its
superior capability of visual understanding. Despite this, how to activate the
capacity of MLLM as the implicit knowledge engine has not been explored yet.
Therefore, we propose GeReA, a generate-reason framework that prompts a MLLM
like InstructBLIP with question relevant vision and language information to
generate knowledge-relevant descriptions and reasons those descriptions for
knowledge-based VQA. Specifically, the question-relevant image regions and
question-specific manual prompts are encoded in the MLLM to generate the
knowledge relevant descriptions, referred to as question-aware prompt captions.
After that, the question-aware prompt captions, image-question pair, and
similar samples are sent into the multi-modal reasoning model to learn a joint
knowledge-image-question representation for answer prediction. GeReA unlocks
the use of MLLM as the implicit knowledge engine, surpassing all previous
state-of-the-art methods on OK-VQA and A-OKVQA datasets, with test accuracies
of 66.5% and 63.3% respectively. Our code will be released at
https://github.com/Upper9527/GeReA.
|
[
-0.6424571276,
-0.8813275695,
0.9440714121,
-0.1506545097,
-0.1479190141,
-0.305739969,
0.1020089835,
-0.4991468787,
-0.3882437646,
0.4038773179,
-0.7271050811,
-0.2801544964,
-0.3085902929,
0.010804005,
-0.1619013101,
0.8115859032,
-0.1110847667,
0.1744297743,
-0.7906374931,
-0.1422436237,
-0.538249135,
-0.3891239166,
-0.6533955336,
0.0236777961,
0.6009418368,
0.3786683083,
0.4324314594,
0.1784949601,
0.2803480327,
0.293266952,
0.1607774943,
0.4017191231,
-0.2277427167,
0.2407884002,
-0.0438990556,
-0.3975679576,
-0.0642800704,
-0.2055404782,
0.3016339242,
0.1497407854,
0.0850865096,
0.2733112574,
0.0902367905,
0.3783719838,
-0.5570244193,
0.283234477,
-0.7120487094,
-0.048959665,
0.1555092484,
-0.3928306997,
-0.3473068178,
-0.2733320594,
0.1222421601,
-1.0474867821,
0.333602488,
0.3234757185,
1.0646286011,
0.4135862887,
-0.3834576309,
-0.2771805823,
-0.3594962358,
0.5100172162,
-0.3728258908,
0.0731376633,
0.1272754818,
0.8276327848,
0.0611167997,
-0.7573840618,
-0.900108099,
-0.1059771925,
-0.0453622192,
0.3834332824,
-0.3378430009,
0.1490873098,
0.4452774227,
0.2527950704,
-0.7314217687,
-0.3153553009,
-0.3376011252,
-0.4328145683,
0.1859375983,
0.0976108238,
0.643728435,
-0.2993991971,
-0.5209314227,
0.0219035633,
-0.5879899263,
0.3724120557,
0.0598413311,
-0.1352484077,
0.059008725,
0.6590878963,
-0.3232229352,
0.7927181721,
-0.0439528935,
0.0912318602,
0.0767810792,
-0.1923362315,
-0.4209986329,
-0.2251994908,
0.5954136252,
0.7080135345,
0.4303950667,
0.067161642,
-0.0049498491,
0.2874714732,
-0.0171755776,
-0.9091481566,
-0.1666034013,
0.251191318,
-0.1079487801,
-0.1694495529,
0.0654671118,
-0.7787336707,
-0.4329468012,
-0.3034326434,
0.5578171611,
-0.41595456,
0.0528883748,
0.1302707493,
-0.2293768227,
0.4823030233,
0.9028164744,
-0.5399996638,
-0.1806488037,
0.2679585814,
0.3743853867,
0.2339548171,
-0.3026162088,
-1.052410841,
0.2323663533,
-0.2305542827,
0.7935072184,
-0.485332489,
-0.1609227359,
0.0881100371,
0.2558999658,
-0.0462073758,
-0.2440356761,
0.3974372745,
-0.7473570704,
0.7330907583,
-0.6635257602,
-0.4807378352,
-0.6642754078,
0.4583670497,
-0.5941385627,
0.6716134548,
-0.1359719932,
-0.7983929515,
0.3575026095,
-0.6063290238,
-0.2212387472,
0.136515826,
-0.5012591481,
-0.0000396884,
-0.0715342909,
0.953656137,
0.519978106,
-0.4241602123,
0.3246825635,
-0.1797013879,
-0.2061244547,
0.2536047101,
-0.6286329031,
0.5136510134,
0.0981531739,
-0.3091643751,
0.2078435421,
-0.4092015028,
0.2067919672,
0.2262075394,
-0.1255811155,
-0.1263563484,
-0.2290002853,
-0.2101834714,
0.3538968861,
0.2137445807,
-0.4585576057,
-0.0459554419,
0.0015293363,
0.2793906629,
0.7718315721,
0.2285733074,
0.3831658363,
-0.1704380512,
0.8919462562,
0.1905117482,
0.4055390656,
-0.4484974742,
-0.791436851,
-0.7808208466,
-0.1094689295,
-0.0099939667,
0.7026413679,
-1.4579330683,
-0.4842789471,
0.0530363098,
-0.2604541481,
-0.6035779715,
0.0634800419,
0.430793345,
0.9752789736,
0.5680907369,
0.1997808963,
-0.3530165255,
-0.916223228,
0.0226412229,
-0.3020500541,
-0.0052445261,
0.5645666718,
0.4669544399,
-0.0550861955,
0.7700001001,
-0.4886541963,
-0.1449229121,
-0.2057442218,
0.0727051497,
0.1306513846,
0.2255278081,
0.6116730571,
-1.0203945637,
-0.2606452107,
0.2368023098,
-1.1806763411,
-0.0619173162,
-0.0502266437,
-0.2596042454,
0.2609958947,
0.5062769055,
-0.716578126,
0.1949145794,
0.5368810296,
-0.4147883058,
0.6770815849,
-0.2051143348,
0.3760048151,
-1.0230709314,
0.1825054735,
0.0650317892,
-0.2406959832,
-0.3385750353,
0.2556096911,
0.1087448969,
-0.3056946099,
-0.5178197622,
0.8226395249,
-0.5342612863,
0.0769409537,
0.1329233646,
0.0502848737,
0.3634429276,
0.6879053712,
-0.0050365832,
1.0063018799,
0.8188146949,
-0.4812613428,
0.4630537331,
0.2851400971,
-0.4030784369,
0.5715522766,
-0.8838078976,
0.017893374,
-0.59673208,
-0.0141459294,
-1.102611661,
-0.6095424891,
0.3350245655,
-0.4565760791,
0.1602685153,
-0.2724528611,
-0.339396745,
-0.5268221498,
0.060384009,
0.2382969856,
0.5438145399,
-0.4622758925,
0.8682900667,
0.1106237099,
-0.4248243272,
-0.7515816689,
-0.6148404479,
-0.1430847347,
-0.1440310478,
-0.751709938,
-0.1564445645,
-0.3333248198,
-0.0929123163,
0.2190357745,
0.0633780286,
0.0122251483,
-0.076105684,
0.3073666096,
0.6178312898,
-0.2441053391,
0.3059099615,
0.127273798,
-0.0868872926,
0.2203152627,
-0.3207600117,
0.2512792945,
-0.4395671189,
-0.5077865124,
-0.1375469863,
0.5739196539,
0.8214752078,
-0.446254164,
0.2934991419,
0.7691702247,
-0.1989763528,
-0.0764345676,
-0.5999580622,
-0.0911040157,
-0.4033545852,
0.3558843136,
-0.3664214909,
-1.1753724813,
0.4763997793,
0.1804925054,
-0.0130119361,
0.3415606618,
0.463591665,
-0.3965583444,
1.0449284315,
0.3798852563,
0.1188549846,
0.1460451484,
-0.0958162546,
-0.266877979,
-0.6328932643,
-0.2779545486,
-0.198062107,
-0.0244042855,
-0.033509437,
-0.6249591112,
0.6387730241,
0.151894778,
-0.3294267356,
-0.2924920022,
-0.5482207537,
0.5341652036,
0.6571218967,
0.0670483932,
0.3580031097,
0.0789925531,
-0.2642556727,
-0.059879411,
-0.7801430225,
-0.3281334341,
0.8492521048,
0.0918536335,
0.5981523395,
-0.1084604561,
0.1582011878,
0.1683976501,
0.2928524315,
-0.5461167693,
0.6337974072,
0.2134199291,
-0.6653250456,
-0.3666140139,
-0.313955605,
-0.4427690208,
0.371694535,
-0.194872126,
-0.3223385215,
0.038157288,
0.4308754802,
-0.3792960048,
0.1517207772,
-0.7028516531,
0.9853600264,
-0.3141973615,
-0.3035322428,
0.1899958849,
-0.6663652062,
0.425049454,
0.268350482,
0.0714055374,
0.0520631485,
0.0738850012,
0.3212957084,
-0.2792969644,
0.7097458243,
-0.582252264,
-0.0860756114,
0.4517869055,
-0.0105233788,
0.4741005898,
0.2154495865,
0.3577560484,
-0.2309834957,
-0.1955074072,
-0.26250875,
-0.9005028009,
0.3992107213,
-0.4984908402,
-0.8352057934,
-0.1057515889,
-0.5536076427,
-0.3838371933,
0.071905449,
0.5974703431,
0.7361934781,
0.0426680669,
0.0312153548,
0.9874019623,
-0.4214161038,
0.2805821896,
0.3539825678,
-0.6374692321,
-0.5082190633,
0.8117767572,
-0.1129851565,
0.2286259532,
0.3910579085,
-0.0396629497,
-0.4441268146,
-0.2539692521,
-0.9824485779,
0.0347617939,
-0.9671630859,
-0.2602689564,
-0.7029562593,
-0.0782525092,
0.0774451494,
-0.2037001103,
0.3084363341,
-0.1537646651,
-0.1539810449,
-0.1176941469,
0.4544140399,
0.3558955193,
0.213631466,
-0.1140363067,
-0.648140192,
0.5913203359,
1.1013606787,
-0.1363303512,
-0.0130566815,
-0.3307304382,
0.0554020628,
0.1799818128,
-0.0766101703,
-0.8906533122,
0.0395846777,
0.0685606003,
0.6300813556,
0.2809127867,
-0.0815076083,
0.6366616488,
-0.509999752,
0.8428233862,
0.3282654583,
-0.716850996,
0.7589467764,
-0.4903272688,
0.5288427472,
0.4768001437,
0.2201943249,
-0.5017434955,
-0.4616711736,
-0.4140420258,
-0.5890672207,
0.2815607786,
0.0069823558,
0.1457658559,
0.0568070188,
-0.0740247965,
0.1495275944,
0.3910297453,
-0.6920315623,
-0.0140049625,
-0.3018570244,
-0.0439787582,
0.1216404587,
-0.2774316669,
-0.271255523,
-0.3496463895,
0.721370101,
-0.5723356009,
0.3502482772,
0.5454515815,
-0.2592268288,
0.0112095512,
0.4468020201,
0.5209506154,
0.6919365525,
0.1243238375,
0.0379181169,
0.1277131289,
-0.2216053158,
0.0219142158,
0.2907481194,
-0.4063815773,
0.1323812008,
0.2515780628,
1.0392197371,
-0.035954427,
-0.7478538752,
0.6585563421,
-0.2332734615,
-0.3837425411,
-0.1627088934,
0.0871854052,
0.1620750129,
0.4276953042,
0.4409150779,
0.401301831,
0.1810991317,
-0.3488836884,
0.1062505394,
0.4554974139,
-0.5301440954,
-0.0515646636,
1.0353796482,
0.2239023298,
0.528675437,
0.4898349643,
-0.0993021727,
-0.5520498157,
0.6233359575,
0.1778050214,
0.6670993567,
0.1377590597,
0.6789613366,
0.3638749719,
0.3313972354,
0.192582801,
0.7375034094,
-0.1518500298,
-0.8130038381,
-0.6842051744,
-0.3838993013,
-0.2967005074,
0.1126527786,
-0.6766602397,
-0.1130539924,
-0.2962568998,
0.0491111055,
-0.2074274719,
-0.4290935397,
-0.9640702009,
0.354302913,
0.3239512444,
0.8888492584,
-0.7696086764,
0.6103828549,
0.9221441746,
-0.6241728067,
-1.0313521624,
-0.1344663948,
-0.1530430019,
-0.8756380677,
0.4637421072,
0.3471491039,
-0.0484218337,
0.1346692294,
-0.9800038338,
-0.3960491121,
1.2288162708,
0.6839817166,
-0.5088126659,
-0.114030607,
-0.1944718957,
0.2410926372,
-0.2308936566,
0.1266843081,
-0.1097100228,
0.7500682473,
0.3368501365,
-0.476192534,
0.1396574527,
-0.616962254,
0.0418868065,
-0.0104287155,
-0.238371551,
0.7352166176,
-0.68523103,
-0.3266658783,
0.1177224591,
0.7280829549,
0.4477862418,
0.3918162584,
0.4599989951,
0.5747339129,
0.9616645575,
-0.2053518295,
1.3495043516,
0.0203971099,
0.1396589428,
1.1211682558,
-0.0459713973,
0.5814725161,
0.6447079182,
0.1575041264,
0.5433511734,
0.3346198201,
0.0241073146,
0.5062898397,
-0.2041915655,
-0.305241257,
-0.714264214,
-0.1676770896,
-0.5492091775,
0.1528248936,
0.084137775,
-0.3627892733,
-0.2262411267,
0.2866850495,
-0.1355757266,
0.0083648991,
-0.4640938342,
0.7165051699,
-0.028738834,
-0.7174305916,
0.5265232325,
-0.532938838,
0.2515062094,
-0.6946865916,
-0.2730852067,
-0.1400296241,
-0.2686066329,
0.0296454132,
-1.0688365698,
-0.3433737457,
0.0989104807,
-0.4579023719,
0.0128301373,
0.8624510765,
-0.6488463283,
-0.6074422598,
-0.035380546,
0.9595279098,
-0.1499866545,
-0.3251463175,
-0.5796173215,
-0.3137896061,
0.2238608748,
-0.2306371033,
-0.0233311597,
0.8301652074,
-0.0304476973,
0.8015541434,
0.6732107401,
-0.1913656443,
0.0211761147,
0.1976709664,
0.9366252422,
-0.2603977323,
-0.5428353548,
-0.5863611102,
1.0486091375,
-0.1935112327,
-0.2925718129,
0.6477910876,
0.113310039,
0.6031011343,
-0.4564540982,
1.1454628706,
-0.1706250757,
0.1599293351,
-0.8750907183,
0.6283800602,
-0.8495113254,
-0.1410050541,
-0.3315536082,
-0.7601439953,
-0.1454068422,
0.2786331773,
-0.3615105152,
-0.1179319248,
0.6087946296,
0.8949907422,
0.0702698976,
0.169822216,
0.4959914386,
0.0384641476,
0.1237004697,
0.7977501154,
1.167910099,
-0.3245086074,
0.6935217977,
0.085199289,
-0.0779988766,
-0.0123282634,
-0.7939346433,
-0.7920819521,
-0.7695950866,
-0.0656689778,
-0.1547499746,
0.095731467,
0.369990021,
0.453743428,
-0.6592545509,
0.4040104449,
-0.1463418156,
-0.0548472665,
-0.2291426212,
-0.2669751048,
0.203384757,
-0.3170467317,
-0.5335980654,
0.1312425733,
0.3265056014,
0.1895648986,
-0.2402565777,
-0.2807149887,
0.177838251,
-0.2155951709,
0.6896726489,
0.3075571358,
-0.8139097691,
-0.4566588402,
0.1816283464,
-0.1244982034,
-0.1263750345,
0.5212186575,
-0.8754490614,
0.7401584387,
0.416785866,
0.77041471,
0.2630608678,
0.1418594122,
0.704461813,
-0.5466384888,
0.0271943696,
0.1892007142,
0.5933591723,
0.3843513131,
-0.3999194801,
0.4743212163,
0.1437941045,
-0.5667192936,
-0.3394823968,
0.3649809659,
-1.1004883051,
-0.2857298553,
1.2127122879,
-0.1147306412,
-0.3043692708,
0.0829113573,
-0.754769206,
-0.0001515411,
-0.3584055901,
0.3024412394,
0.7395337224,
0.2300084382,
-0.5478338599,
-0.8627619147,
0.515373826,
0.4158620834,
-1.024367094,
-0.0805179179,
1.0212076902,
0.0560850948,
0.0639058799,
0.5300152302,
-0.0407769233,
0.764842689,
-0.2511103153,
0.148010537,
-0.5734792948,
-0.5944746733,
-0.1005232334,
0.4182537496,
-0.051126916,
-0.3293765485
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05123v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05123v1
|
A Survey on Data Selection for LLM Instruction Tuning
| 2024-02-04T13:32:01 | 2024-02-04T13:32:01 |
Jiahao Wang, Bolin Zhang, Qianlong Du, Jiajun Zhang, Dianhui Chu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Instruction tuning is a vital step of training large language models (LLM),
so how to enhance the effect of instruction tuning has received increased
attention. Existing works indicate that the quality of the dataset is more
crucial than the quantity during instruction tuning of LLM. Therefore, recently
a lot of studies focus on exploring the methods of selecting high-quality
subset from instruction datasets, aiming to reduce training costs and enhance
the instruction-following capabilities of LLMs. This paper presents a
comprehensive survey on data selection for LLM instruction tuning. Firstly, we
introduce the wildly used instruction datasets. Then, we propose a new taxonomy
of the data selection methods and provide a detailed introduction of recent
advances,and the evaluation strategies and results of data selection methods
are also elaborated in detail. Finally, we emphasize the open challenges and
present new frontiers of this task.
|
[
-0.5963243842,
-0.6616260409,
0.3255356848,
-0.2062165737,
-0.2819352746,
0.1395621598,
-0.4339271486,
-0.1466297507,
-0.0698116571,
0.7021409869,
-0.6959958673,
-0.7938415408,
-0.5512036085,
0.0158834737,
-0.3746941984,
0.8461015821,
-0.0283930413,
0.3776122928,
-0.387992084,
0.1242845803,
-0.5538831949,
-0.2996384799,
-0.6025257707,
-0.2143414617,
0.3077001274,
0.6831589937,
0.3353611529,
1.0698963404,
0.6603860855,
0.2336351573,
-0.0764338449,
0.5774461627,
-0.6380146742,
0.3082340956,
0.204670921,
-0.7345206738,
-0.3682364821,
0.1469379663,
0.8383214474,
0.8078943491,
-0.0447656736,
0.4119824469,
0.0208868254,
0.8908433318,
-0.8096807003,
0.0569502376,
-0.6388953924,
0.1024449021,
-0.475746274,
-0.2016014308,
-0.5414761901,
-0.7748419642,
-0.1205189079,
-0.3445124328,
0.4039957523,
0.3248866796,
0.4048162401,
0.3366367221,
-0.3588772416,
-0.3362394571,
-0.7736728191,
0.9277134538,
-0.6163577437,
0.6428033113,
0.5259343982,
0.2236070931,
-0.1168678924,
-0.3295169175,
0.047313001,
-0.1795831025,
0.3067346811,
0.1044578552,
0.0908014849,
0.1207497492,
0.3112206161,
0.7156560421,
-0.5306103826,
0.5283308625,
-0.3277432919,
-0.0730077028,
0.702493012,
0.3401156664,
-0.0465642884,
0.2910917401,
-0.0197280347,
-0.306225419,
-1.0902526379,
-0.1639581472,
0.610465467,
0.1034235954,
0.085188821,
0.3991626203,
-0.3215767443,
1.2365349531,
-0.1489632875,
-0.1467701495,
0.1043025181,
-0.2806772888,
-0.1175499484,
-0.0435459875,
0.4855792522,
0.3588366508,
0.288823694,
-0.1704095304,
-0.2980525494,
-0.4282104373,
0.0477773622,
-0.6058655977,
-0.1537407935,
-0.0061118938,
-0.319336623,
-0.0454792939,
0.1492387056,
-0.9822598696,
-0.1397642195,
-0.5778536201,
-0.2295119464,
-0.1925155222,
0.0290274695,
0.1159566641,
0.1769722849,
0.4001483917,
0.2331604064,
-1.2783435583,
0.2271248102,
0.7807338238,
0.5361238122,
-0.4343287647,
-0.207070902,
-0.6481689215,
-0.1028647348,
-0.7358922958,
0.9188475013,
-0.94180125,
-0.5912611485,
0.1503117532,
-0.0845132172,
-0.2037840933,
-0.7530747652,
0.4714874327,
-0.7634834647,
0.0550962351,
-0.3086179197,
-0.8270491362,
-0.0899716169,
-0.0360214971,
-0.8514395356,
1.0549919605,
0.2388101965,
-0.4992454648,
0.4754769802,
-0.1140752435,
-0.5343913436,
-0.1064817309,
-0.0848126933,
-0.5331245065,
0.3071234226,
0.4064959288,
0.4577717483,
-0.4817918837,
0.0190601181,
-0.156427294,
-0.6598706841,
0.142016679,
-0.5103666186,
0.4612116516,
0.2558975518,
-0.001569467,
-0.1285901219,
-0.7238571048,
0.2963586748,
-0.2371814996,
-0.545796752,
-0.1669873744,
0.1757541895,
-0.3993086219,
-0.1255277097,
0.1061540321,
-0.2624703348,
0.397192955,
-0.3504783809,
0.1136462018,
0.8714184165,
0.1731879413,
0.3024454713,
-0.3673315048,
0.8082399964,
-0.3015453219,
0.3398332298,
-0.0121371606,
-0.2589441538,
-0.8993777037,
-0.04570207,
0.6785469055,
0.4849907458,
-0.6926602125,
0.5619882345,
-0.0999047533,
-0.465490222,
-0.9669737816,
0.377340287,
0.4311275482,
0.2713845372,
0.269785285,
0.1880535781,
-0.5206214786,
-0.7060559392,
0.0180746727,
0.1146955118,
0.1305845529,
0.4632277191,
0.072687842,
0.2030073851,
0.63148278,
-0.7381845713,
0.2401506603,
-0.3971993029,
-0.2436001301,
0.2571554184,
0.21425955,
0.3983315229,
-0.3648058474,
-0.4355792403,
-0.0642072558,
-0.3851168752,
-0.088748157,
0.0412600711,
-0.2846419513,
0.2386360765,
0.5504892468,
-0.189045921,
0.0821282789,
0.632659018,
0.1265933514,
0.3024854362,
-0.1279131919,
0.3029886484,
-0.8362584114,
-0.2310618013,
0.028632747,
-0.0737065151,
-0.4099585414,
-0.0710741431,
0.2628939152,
0.179937169,
-0.3126551211,
0.296056658,
-0.8118667006,
-0.1305678487,
-0.2292127907,
-0.0403740034,
-0.2822438478,
0.2110106945,
-0.0600075908,
0.885094285,
0.8216230869,
-0.7386801243,
0.6684474349,
0.351308912,
-0.8817521334,
0.0980269387,
-0.3091567159,
0.4018070996,
-0.1382958442,
-0.0529227741,
-0.7833420038,
-0.1375957131,
0.0826270878,
-0.0344557911,
0.6684917808,
-0.3969167471,
-0.5583201647,
-0.3295561373,
-0.2843874693,
0.0824819282,
0.5690397024,
-0.6195120215,
-0.1086520851,
0.3285774291,
-0.1207106337,
-0.5949449539,
-0.3879609704,
-0.243675828,
-0.2135068774,
-0.1472946554,
0.1232777759,
-0.1183496416,
-0.166662395,
-0.3216640949,
-0.2922563553,
0.1920534223,
0.0473627858,
-0.1888131201,
0.5440543294,
-0.320633769,
0.0970497206,
0.219345957,
-0.1584884077,
-0.0023469951,
-0.0779983327,
0.5149187446,
0.3875468373,
-0.5683329105,
-0.2310247719,
0.1337921321,
-0.0131790033,
-0.3994958103,
0.3722337782,
0.4109347761,
0.150798887,
-0.5438848734,
-0.647151351,
-0.2840188146,
-0.4652687013,
0.5143631101,
0.150075987,
-0.8310503364,
0.0272164661,
-0.2839156985,
0.1940540671,
-0.0126082497,
0.4641143084,
-0.0846292824,
0.9682686329,
0.4487135708,
-0.4973931313,
0.7141946554,
-0.3028765023,
0.0085788602,
-0.903154552,
-0.0795331821,
-0.7529260516,
-0.3609246612,
-0.6921204329,
-0.2815523744,
0.3345190883,
-0.1640420705,
0.0747395009,
-0.1007863432,
-0.5410305262,
0.7701553106,
0.523064971,
0.1650433093,
0.1680586785,
0.2035082877,
0.3246235549,
0.1082194597,
-0.5271290541,
-0.4834141135,
1.3252791166,
0.1264521182,
1.0558195114,
-0.1909460872,
0.606529355,
0.0438439585,
0.041064281,
-0.7757965922,
0.6705915928,
-0.4979919493,
-0.5354668498,
-0.3432842493,
-0.5966104269,
-1.0370023251,
-0.0478284582,
-0.0855193734,
-0.5338341594,
-0.1408725977,
0.1169667095,
-0.2444080114,
0.263182044,
-0.5401795506,
0.4630216062,
-0.2819176018,
-0.048474133,
-0.1978063583,
-0.4475964904,
0.2359722257,
0.0423177257,
-0.0492932051,
-0.1420233101,
-0.041658137,
0.8764641881,
-0.0985394269,
0.5730463862,
-0.2050029784,
-0.2457863837,
0.2645086646,
-0.171200186,
0.4891321063,
-0.0015351353,
-0.2932927012,
0.0159431323,
-0.1685799211,
-0.1633979231,
-0.5820994377,
0.7291825414,
-0.6899793744,
-0.6364145279,
0.0431598648,
-0.4383300841,
-0.7095049024,
-0.0845487192,
0.2820371091,
0.5598932505,
-0.0715864822,
0.4041461051,
1.1100465059,
-0.143206194,
0.375331074,
0.3435218334,
-0.0424559377,
-0.4900329709,
1.1658958197,
0.3314319849,
0.4789538682,
0.4824844301,
-0.0284038913,
-0.2092408836,
-1.0449486971,
-0.465359658,
0.0526180156,
-0.5670089126,
-0.4530655742,
-0.1180779114,
-0.3888070583,
-0.2501125038,
0.1086160839,
-0.3777802289,
-0.3750316799,
-0.4889350235,
-0.155739218,
0.4030953944,
0.6829307675,
0.3234911263,
0.4230062962,
-0.6704688072,
0.2975652814,
0.2096293271,
0.5875995755,
-0.1394616663,
-0.5115966201,
-0.4800985456,
0.0951343849,
-0.3476025164,
-0.545435667,
0.209188506,
0.3334731162,
0.9019947052,
0.4142168164,
-0.0518492311,
0.5287490487,
-0.4457290173,
0.4865342081,
-0.3143293262,
-0.4097093642,
0.7904607654,
-0.0415629633,
0.0878172666,
0.6213487387,
0.4580640495,
-0.3501612544,
-0.127469793,
-0.2723428011,
-0.7342250347,
0.9874809384,
-0.0608826503,
0.1792253703,
0.2701174021,
0.4564247727,
0.3686611652,
0.1489667892,
-0.0047221854,
-0.6053683162,
0.2286928594,
-0.2601357996,
-0.1154572591,
-0.1244368404,
0.0069302237,
-0.3479694724,
0.7197098732,
-0.0971059874,
0.1344785094,
-0.553981483,
-0.0129102226,
-0.1853780448,
0.234667182,
0.2587349415,
0.6897326708,
-0.169846341,
-0.3688361943,
0.2516315281,
-0.6660473347,
0.1323332042,
-0.0712572113,
-0.3089225888,
-0.1298782825,
0.5264806151,
1.1181025505,
0.2473996282,
-0.4589004815,
0.2361298203,
0.0067800111,
-0.2719200253,
0.0058170739,
0.8192709684,
-0.0994247571,
-0.0122107826,
0.0732344985,
-0.3611592352,
0.0160835758,
-0.2851015627,
0.0043414296,
0.5175027251,
-0.1614230871,
-0.0946768895,
0.1094480455,
0.0739616081,
-0.2193523943,
1.1264694929,
-0.0737362057,
0.0724862143,
0.6363130212,
0.5228645205,
0.5740934014,
-0.4167172015,
0.1472411454,
0.2788300812,
0.1888607144,
-0.1451461613,
0.4480623901,
0.0953963399,
-0.5653553009,
-0.5308029056,
-0.5774410963,
-0.5916249752,
0.4598377049,
-0.9866711497,
0.4402602017,
-0.3703958988,
0.0778228939,
-0.3495362997,
0.2598949671,
-0.555877924,
0.2446478605,
0.1940111667,
0.9881933331,
-0.586455822,
0.8861625195,
0.5894262195,
0.1174700111,
-0.4658719301,
0.1017403677,
-0.0017306302,
-0.9633294344,
0.3440779448,
-0.2289807498,
0.0316742659,
0.2480663955,
-0.7511336803,
-0.9045883417,
0.9882494211,
0.5345838666,
-0.7317906618,
-0.06811665,
0.1933727562,
0.2526120245,
-0.2852343619,
0.2808808684,
1.0230481625,
0.3991442621,
0.3487443626,
-0.4266735613,
-0.3784336448,
-0.0698549747,
0.0345331803,
0.3642100692,
-0.8777472377,
0.6275832057,
0.0331763513,
-0.0514892936,
-0.0175661724,
0.5298483372,
0.2086356431,
0.0938956216,
0.3053363264,
0.2373666763,
0.7653198242,
-0.1427631229,
0.7438337803,
-0.3216402829,
0.210471943,
0.9853118658,
-0.2892335355,
0.7634223104,
0.2108610421,
-0.4609027207,
0.0193203483,
1.085229516,
-0.4748123884,
0.5603020787,
0.3729012012,
-0.1618539691,
-0.4077672064,
0.0296493843,
-0.4930998981,
0.6343048811,
0.4909525216,
-0.2112434953,
-0.1971956193,
-0.1263739765,
-0.1624582559,
-0.3093424737,
-0.3458740711,
1.0745173693,
-0.1230356991,
-0.6342118382,
0.7698466778,
-0.152822569,
0.3940777481,
-0.5996645689,
-0.1969837546,
-0.4420034885,
-0.1202735677,
-0.158850342,
-0.8346171379,
-0.075877741,
0.0310914125,
-0.0813703388,
-0.3190468848,
0.4786216021,
-0.3244321346,
-0.4291985631,
-0.0641490072,
0.4779075682,
0.2350686491,
0.1662002802,
-0.4208946526,
0.279081434,
0.2166355103,
-0.4741328359,
0.4414486885,
0.386767298,
0.2139031142,
0.6715754867,
0.4896739721,
0.5927887559,
0.0974356383,
0.1891929656,
0.9772775173,
-0.7262172103,
-0.1026357263,
-0.7094382048,
0.246255219,
-0.0730451122,
-0.4795631468,
0.6818934083,
0.7512844801,
1.0710479021,
-0.0411848538,
0.9574109912,
0.3223702908,
0.7163071036,
-1.0945750475,
0.4975046813,
-0.2484240979,
0.4213241041,
0.0101157418,
-1.0372800827,
-0.0547763892,
0.3309110105,
-0.482111752,
0.2858122885,
0.5284954309,
0.9518097639,
-0.1889974177,
0.3262983263,
0.3562615514,
-0.1557508409,
-0.0376587622,
0.4644657373,
0.9683201313,
-0.186825186,
0.3854058385,
-0.2880819142,
-0.2012933493,
-0.339761734,
-0.6440335512,
-0.9756504297,
-0.5535348654,
-0.2478579283,
0.1584957689,
0.0712481067,
1.00071311,
0.798949182,
-0.903010428,
-0.3157464862,
0.2657260895,
0.2898713052,
-0.2720535994,
-0.034179084,
0.4798564315,
-0.6611599922,
-0.8394901752,
0.6524105072,
0.0096633695,
-0.0430031121,
-0.1465675086,
0.0344784968,
-0.0297460202,
-0.0818707719,
0.3547056913,
0.0839356482,
-0.2852718532,
0.0845690668,
0.1422482729,
-0.0746755823,
0.2666393518,
0.9442881942,
-0.3645710349,
0.3253291249,
0.3849658966,
0.8454431295,
0.5091343522,
-0.1929863989,
0.4225415885,
-0.8782640696,
-0.1715335995,
0.2456752509,
0.1959282607,
0.1895524114,
-0.4324348271,
0.5146420002,
-0.0933719128,
-0.6920192242,
-0.7643834352,
0.1333880126,
-0.5001648068,
-0.117063202,
1.2642917633,
0.0930804908,
-0.2247244418,
0.0774456412,
-0.2361252606,
0.2370938212,
-0.2713657618,
0.7077463269,
0.8782683611,
-0.3903508484,
-0.3709814847,
-0.9768769145,
0.6034328938,
0.1977174133,
-1.003477335,
0.3760947287,
0.6290935278,
-0.0232966058,
-0.5983378887,
0.0236675311,
0.0415043607,
0.1013065875,
-0.2439959198,
-0.1727229208,
-0.1381161213,
-0.4624848664,
-0.3304867446,
-0.1321147978,
0.4250172377,
-0.3077865541
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.09674v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.09674v1
|
Navigating the Peril of Generated Alternative Facts: A ChatGPT-4 Fabricated Omega Variant Case as a Cautionary Tale in Medical Misinformation
| 2024-02-04T13:21:19 | 2024-02-04T13:21:19 |
Malik Sallam, Jan Egger, Rainer Roehrig, Behrus Puladi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
In an era where artificial intelligence (AI) intertwines with medical
research, the delineation of truth becomes increasingly complex. This study
ostensibly examines a purported novel SARS-CoV-2 variant, dubbed the Omega
variant, showcasing 31 unique mutations in the S gene region. However, the real
undercurrent of this narrative is a demonstration of the ease with which AI,
specifically ChatGPT-4, can fabricate convincing yet entirely fictional
scientific data. The so-called Omega variant was identified in a fully
vaccinated, previously infected 35-year-old male presenting with severe
COVID-19 symptoms. Through a detailed, albeit artificial, genomic analysis and
contact tracing, this study mirrors the rigorous methodology of genuine case
reports, thereby setting the stage for a compelling but entirely constructed
narrative. The entire case study was generated by ChatGPT-4, a large language
model by OpenAI. The fabricated Omega variant features an ensemble of
mutations, including N501Y and E484K, known for enhancing ACE2 receptor
affinity, alongside L452R and P681H, ostensibly indicative of immune evasion.
This variant's contrived interaction dynamics - severe symptoms in a vaccinated
individual versus mild ones in unvaccinated contacts - were designed to mimic
real-world complexities, including suggestions of antibody-dependent
enhancement (ADE). While the Omega variant is a product of AI-generated
fiction, the implications of this exercise are real and profound. The ease with
which AI can generate believable but false scientific information, as
illustrated in this case, raises significant concerns about the potential for
misinformation in medicine. This study, therefore, serves as a cautionary tale,
emphasizing the necessity for critical evaluation of sources, especially in an
age where AI tools like ChatGPT are becoming increasingly sophisticated and
widespread in their use.
|
[
-0.2105193585,
-0.640344739,
0.5457812548,
-0.4546028078,
-0.1140857488,
0.288205117,
0.0663668886,
-0.6425367594,
0.2064198852,
0.0814631209,
-0.5244347453,
0.1122626439,
-0.6791581511,
0.0653343648,
-0.1459254026,
1.2413809299,
0.1060061753,
0.078348957,
-0.0567762442,
-0.1503455341,
0.0787081569,
-0.4263241589,
-0.7073333859,
-0.495690912,
0.5017612576,
0.4838605225,
0.9324823022,
0.3633629978,
0.5399699211,
0.1071261838,
0.3041190505,
0.011483076,
-0.6841034293,
0.0255533457,
0.1133907288,
-0.6357218027,
-0.3996043801,
0.4797752202,
0.1667129397,
0.1593647748,
-0.2107548118,
-0.0625869855,
-0.2899666429,
0.2883908451,
-0.4661490023,
-0.2273733616,
-0.4246555567,
0.2440852374,
-0.581141293,
-0.211746037,
-0.1409891248,
0.0021561529,
0.3941085339,
-0.7359185815,
0.463041693,
0.129084602,
0.9439916015,
0.2699483037,
-0.4175340235,
-0.556078434,
-0.8067891598,
0.4092655182,
-0.6211572886,
-0.0231912583,
0.3944873214,
0.5561124086,
-0.2257563472,
-0.9023599029,
-0.6558335423,
-0.4858512878,
0.1903098524,
0.4114049971,
-0.3616569042,
-0.0867643729,
0.1829751879,
0.4943168759,
-0.5770993829,
-0.2071952671,
-0.8329224586,
-0.4424896836,
0.6599460244,
-0.0840169564,
0.7407538295,
-0.1156462729,
-0.3964168131,
0.0881786197,
-0.9391863942,
-0.0030556682,
0.2852318585,
-0.1720074117,
-0.4094598889,
0.6308908463,
0.0073309159,
0.0967190787,
0.437636286,
-0.0003631189,
0.1152322441,
-0.3519966304,
-0.1109466553,
0.6180717349,
0.7431961298,
0.2406825423,
0.0639218315,
0.0553608723,
0.2190428972,
0.0665751472,
0.6221976876,
-0.648329854,
-0.3881532848,
0.3505291343,
-0.2085076421,
-0.3547277749,
-0.0852895677,
-0.5532793403,
-0.3495577276,
0.1809925586,
0.2795906663,
-0.6501227617,
-0.0462525487,
-0.141083926,
-0.4323960841,
0.4472930133,
0.3835335374,
-0.4231013954,
0.0220267568,
0.5231208801,
0.7284742594,
0.0096821338,
0.1593975723,
-0.3646745384,
0.3188343048,
-0.4595161378,
0.876673758,
-0.8391483426,
-0.2756572366,
-0.193876192,
-0.598659277,
0.1158435717,
-0.2983931899,
0.614238441,
-0.4752976,
0.0606078468,
-0.3117766082,
-0.191151008,
-0.158243224,
0.1284782141,
-0.4380144775,
0.5260311365,
0.0034508121,
-0.8009139299,
0.1757708937,
-0.6170781851,
-0.3007303476,
0.4288755357,
-0.637940228,
-0.5237109661,
0.023829462,
-0.0867591053,
-0.2093397826,
-0.5394179225,
0.1872092634,
-0.3596160114,
-0.0305645745,
0.2510711849,
-0.4640706182,
0.5574506521,
0.4054142237,
-0.3596366942,
-0.2748157084,
-0.6147290468,
-0.1730477065,
0.0243329257,
-0.259783864,
-0.1953276992,
-0.2402120531,
-0.4560538232,
0.1690198928,
0.176345408,
-0.6867991686,
0.1172350794,
-0.2664012909,
0.3486835659,
0.3290273845,
0.4029661119,
0.2274589092,
-0.8714516759,
0.7653192282,
0.1122087315,
0.5176920891,
-0.0098468168,
-0.9142975807,
-0.7798365951,
-0.1585647464,
-0.0411728658,
0.5848514438,
-0.7122173309,
-0.3298731744,
0.1305584759,
-0.7547008991,
-0.6570692658,
-0.2950803041,
0.4529061317,
0.5625261664,
0.3490268588,
-0.3216001987,
-0.5809722543,
-1.1330634356,
-0.6977749467,
-0.1933813393,
0.0923491567,
0.3095344305,
0.5308901072,
-0.4356443286,
0.6641587019,
-0.4637238383,
-0.1808544546,
-0.0098483702,
0.507501483,
-0.0743419006,
0.5628117919,
0.4143582582,
-0.8260429502,
-0.2727305591,
0.1061029881,
-0.7925180793,
0.2213855833,
-0.3121055663,
0.0532821044,
-0.0752288774,
0.4394020736,
-0.5815825462,
0.6935476065,
0.2380831093,
0.0252542738,
0.7787876129,
-0.4107556641,
0.1674349457,
-0.813953042,
0.2694544494,
0.0797325447,
0.1452331394,
-0.7933576107,
0.170529902,
-0.129519403,
0.0624956936,
-0.2809377313,
0.0980204791,
-0.2749349177,
0.2640200257,
-0.0177565813,
-0.3224469125,
-0.2126680911,
0.0997247696,
-0.4889370799,
0.7881426811,
0.2450992316,
-0.3401693106,
0.3680779338,
0.3032976389,
-0.1615876257,
0.531865716,
-0.580277741,
0.1473049372,
-0.2074954063,
0.4780993164,
-0.6047608256,
-0.5982286334,
0.6990212798,
-0.5893492103,
0.0459492356,
-0.0532113835,
-0.0064450875,
-0.198791042,
-0.2090047002,
0.5604122281,
0.5777813792,
-0.1227567568,
0.4986016154,
0.4991367757,
-0.4072654545,
-0.5282201171,
-0.7775689363,
0.4153718352,
-0.0814481378,
-0.3450696766,
0.4543712437,
-0.3835160136,
-0.4880326688,
-0.0241056606,
-0.4533680975,
-0.4428361952,
-0.143802166,
0.2545446754,
0.0144487871,
-0.2982973456,
-0.0808569789,
0.1205793694,
0.0951973274,
-0.102134414,
0.256422013,
0.113079302,
-0.289365232,
-0.5144834518,
-0.4168394208,
0.5532954931,
0.6454684734,
-0.1205550209,
0.1128278077,
0.3249627054,
-0.4443839788,
0.1264929324,
-0.267611742,
-0.1588555425,
-0.388602823,
0.218365252,
-0.3631040454,
-0.454633683,
0.3198976219,
-0.0321671627,
-0.060333848,
0.6568316817,
0.2967098057,
-0.2053669095,
0.7337701917,
0.430965513,
0.3097717464,
0.1450206935,
-0.1167424098,
0.5475308299,
-0.7703053355,
-0.493105948,
-0.3043114841,
-0.094959408,
-0.7187641859,
-0.5362318754,
0.9430084825,
-0.2743276358,
-0.3573505282,
-0.37228176,
-0.1730562449,
0.3298894167,
0.721996367,
0.2531540096,
0.3119469285,
-0.1733759642,
-0.200940758,
0.0866333842,
-1.3365647793,
-0.3033657074,
1.1679258347,
0.189495936,
0.5886078477,
0.156817615,
0.3862684965,
0.48000741,
0.2969204783,
-0.4442364573,
0.0955206603,
-0.1320235878,
-0.6921638846,
0.0563094579,
-0.041634012,
-0.9081085324,
-0.237945199,
-0.4031720459,
-0.3349605799,
0.4170801044,
0.3151867092,
-0.6301505566,
-0.0920109376,
-0.8154936433,
0.3499648869,
-0.3828087747,
-0.3361093998,
-0.4115448296,
-0.8545908332,
0.5399503708,
-0.2939547598,
0.2420048863,
0.2557442784,
0.1096638441,
0.3757981062,
-0.786554873,
0.8998571634,
0.4290339351,
-0.1428105384,
0.2284836173,
-0.0133397263,
0.4013493359,
0.4489634037,
-0.120751068,
0.3721300364,
-0.1032325551,
-0.5335384011,
-0.3306377828,
0.6540437937,
-0.8664891124,
-0.994775176,
-0.9873726964,
-0.3224821687,
0.0914440677,
0.1723145247,
0.564416647,
0.6084721684,
-0.3013348281,
-0.215795368,
0.5264417529,
-0.5165819526,
0.042436067,
0.5346039534,
0.5850128531,
-0.4345445633,
0.6609739065,
0.3075295389,
0.2101610303,
0.2288442403,
0.2245157957,
-0.0311125182,
-0.4715842009,
-0.4077614546,
0.3892620206,
-0.3450741172,
-0.0524353273,
-0.3390749693,
-0.5423715711,
-0.2960411906,
-0.1546702981,
-0.5052059293,
-0.0805903897,
-0.0477998592,
0.0662810132,
0.4338553846,
0.9760738015,
-0.2469282448,
-0.1453751773,
-0.6200128794,
0.3808146417,
0.2627598345,
0.3315263689,
-0.388844043,
-0.3018137515,
-0.1906809956,
0.7916476727,
-0.3842279315,
-0.8139221668,
0.1280084699,
0.3864273131,
0.5053560734,
0.5412596464,
0.3922218978,
0.7730998397,
-0.4569728374,
0.8233169317,
0.211609453,
-0.609233737,
0.5369743109,
-0.4671862125,
0.3010597825,
0.1194535196,
0.5736678243,
-0.6212795973,
-0.8020899296,
-1.0512467623,
-0.77310431,
0.5022935271,
0.377353996,
-0.1889791191,
0.064003922,
0.5738966465,
0.4645456076,
-0.0402821973,
-0.2728566229,
-0.4995907843,
-0.3322248757,
-0.059739843,
-0.1449608058,
-0.3300221562,
-0.5803641677,
-0.0298468918,
0.7457311749,
-0.0475481153,
0.3966085315,
0.7122529149,
0.0263006054,
-0.0733436793,
0.093254894,
0.8637555242,
0.6588010192,
-0.0194123518,
0.4343337119,
-0.2758902311,
-0.7844061852,
0.0058585294,
0.1430808455,
-0.2088629901,
-0.1311885118,
0.4607291222,
0.7001848221,
-0.0155597311,
-0.7655821443,
0.3975689113,
-0.0821408927,
0.0084993634,
-0.5550815463,
0.243885234,
-0.2777255774,
0.4570708573,
0.5856539011,
0.7178511024,
0.3140746653,
-0.6899965405,
0.3354200125,
0.4893738329,
-0.1766789109,
-0.6395971775,
0.6809552312,
0.2675216198,
-0.1914531589,
0.5909333229,
-0.0203310307,
-0.3176587224,
0.7453340292,
0.4148779511,
0.5123081803,
-0.4256029427,
0.4525428414,
0.3444321752,
0.3476522863,
0.1054635942,
-0.0252537914,
0.2481205463,
-0.713403523,
-0.1492736191,
-0.0526927002,
-0.3318623602,
0.4852904677,
-0.353998363,
0.0017977034,
-0.4007467031,
-0.074597314,
0.3273041546,
-0.1023776606,
-0.343732506,
0.2194333971,
0.1937005371,
0.6629367471,
-0.7853400707,
0.7064083219,
0.8293859959,
-0.5207605362,
-0.4935210943,
0.4612139761,
0.2201723158,
-0.9749247432,
0.4253400862,
-0.1524168998,
0.0707782507,
-0.1969479769,
-0.4817783237,
-0.9514554739,
0.9665201902,
0.6014270186,
-0.3260468245,
0.2482170165,
0.1539120227,
0.6447312236,
-0.3216261268,
0.2854308486,
0.4614925086,
0.4169832766,
0.3382890224,
-0.7566865087,
0.1087753698,
-0.5947743058,
-0.2201605886,
-0.237594381,
-0.9043184519,
0.7101377845,
-0.783370018,
-0.1884004474,
-0.0676675066,
0.2342041731,
0.091438584,
0.5807741284,
-0.0328325108,
0.4660618901,
1.0061542988,
0.1992318928,
1.3656682968,
-0.2542137504,
-0.1645743549,
0.9186836481,
0.0006230224,
0.4975396693,
0.647259891,
0.0615026243,
0.3643783033,
0.6405690908,
0.0882022679,
0.3793380558,
-0.019341547,
-0.4563100934,
-0.2174437493,
-0.0944078416,
-0.5673130751,
0.692555964,
0.4282318056,
-0.0727309436,
-0.1977661103,
-0.1710056514,
0.2499991655,
-0.2917878926,
0.0542289093,
0.693040669,
0.0465505496,
-0.8956325054,
0.6758868694,
-0.1327157915,
0.2064845264,
-0.6112667918,
-0.2707683444,
-0.1944235712,
-0.0050592674,
-0.1551826,
-0.4261172712,
0.3059881628,
-0.0627366304,
-0.3107370436,
0.0646285564,
0.5396763682,
-0.2767548263,
-0.2680411339,
-0.3797241747,
0.4118509293,
0.1573570073,
0.1153609455,
-0.6382120848,
0.1438037604,
0.2712160945,
0.1216501519,
0.2018683702,
0.2391622514,
-0.1871511191,
0.8124790192,
0.6259121895,
0.1845631003,
-0.0882031545,
-0.568783462,
0.5895274878,
-0.4467323422,
-0.5230690837,
-0.8774770498,
0.2241574377,
-0.1727871448,
-0.3475696445,
0.6889187694,
0.7256072164,
0.370793879,
-0.1032196656,
1.3961606026,
-0.231477648,
0.0165929478,
-0.277364254,
1.079709053,
-0.3148643374,
0.3196762502,
0.2421479523,
0.0762712732,
-0.1843873858,
0.2909091115,
-0.3125402629,
0.0426660962,
0.7238871455,
0.6575040817,
0.1393508762,
0.1987811178,
-0.0580189228,
0.9451691508,
0.4613397717,
0.4646810889,
0.6963865161,
-0.4852299988,
0.4084206223,
-0.035429731,
-0.6496709585,
-0.6247116923,
-0.7177279592,
-0.3674995899,
-0.6866907477,
-0.6065914035,
-0.277151674,
0.6154218316,
0.7139580846,
0.5552532673,
-0.4602408409,
0.1770341843,
-0.1732137203,
0.0492649041,
-0.2950055897,
-0.1047527418,
0.200147897,
-0.1443081647,
-0.4666231871,
0.399431169,
0.351549834,
0.2334443927,
0.2544020414,
-0.1375125349,
-0.2268617898,
0.3894435465,
0.3546700478,
0.640137136,
-0.6907200217,
-0.3203095794,
-0.4482233226,
-0.0949471518,
0.2959320843,
0.692781508,
-0.7087343335,
0.661686182,
0.1203076467,
0.5419763327,
0.450491637,
-0.2107960433,
1.2072020769,
-0.3862307668,
-0.183600232,
0.2532246709,
0.1269131899,
0.1724266112,
-0.6085377336,
0.2125343382,
0.4705857933,
-0.3115976453,
-0.6387900114,
0.5510326624,
-1.0829436779,
-0.284861356,
1.1678873301,
0.0730279014,
-0.1766373813,
-0.2636461556,
-0.4818549454,
0.4745274484,
-0.6703703403,
1.2524832487,
0.5372101665,
-0.6758070588,
0.0364607126,
-0.7559067011,
0.9945707321,
0.1698998064,
-0.6055677533,
-0.3907341361,
0.3647551835,
0.2375400662,
-0.0029559596,
0.611364305,
-0.0792424604,
0.6821610332,
0.2350005805,
-0.0015966112,
-0.0834194273,
0.11108578,
-0.0642041713,
0.0861982852,
0.0173692107,
-0.1278449893
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02479v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02479v2
|
BRAIn: Bayesian Reward-conditioned Amortized Inference for natural language generation from feedback
| 2024-02-04T13:16:29 | 2024-06-10T10:18:46 |
Gaurav Pandey, Yatin Nandwani, Tahira Naseem, Mayank Mishra, Guangxuan Xu, Dinesh Raghu, Sachindra Joshi, Asim Munawar, Ramón Fernandez Astudillo
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Distribution matching methods for language model alignment such as Generation
with Distributional Control (GDC) and Distributional Policy Gradient (DPG) have
not received the same level of attention in reinforcement learning from human
feedback (RLHF) as contrastive methods such as Sequence Likelihood Calibration
(SLiC), Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) and its variants. We identify high
variance of the gradient estimate as the primary reason for the lack of success
of these methods and propose a self-normalized baseline to reduce the variance.
We further generalize the target distribution in DPG, GDC and DPO by using
Bayes' rule to define the reward-conditioned posterior. The resulting approach,
referred to as BRAIn - Bayesian Reward-conditioned Amortized Inference acts as
a bridge between distribution matching methods and DPO and significantly
outperforms prior art in summarization and Antropic HH tasks.
|
[
-0.3054125607,
-0.7616536617,
0.4259324968,
0.3525739312,
0.0389991477,
-0.0774016231,
-0.2115721554,
0.0112808328,
0.1366841495,
0.6040536761,
-0.7960777879,
-0.5216677189,
-0.3448723853,
-0.2740547955,
0.1371223032,
1.1119096279,
0.1367467195,
-0.0591858923,
-0.2387576103,
0.0483994707,
-0.194155395,
-0.3665305972,
-0.7169905305,
-0.5925299525,
0.5706087351,
0.1963795424,
0.7318564653,
0.7318137884,
0.5455284715,
0.18589136,
-0.0042436356,
-0.0784358308,
-0.2193589807,
-0.0544155911,
-0.2388925105,
-0.4566762745,
-0.3391114473,
-0.0250574723,
0.5154724717,
0.825641036,
-0.7202398181,
-0.2181509286,
-0.0843841583,
1.0431523323,
-1.1721869707,
0.1652821898,
-0.2818243206,
0.0933737159,
0.0845024809,
-0.1560431272,
-0.3859333992,
-0.6543672085,
0.2506152689,
-0.5009441376,
0.4200972319,
0.0691810399,
0.5619311929,
0.5284333825,
-0.3642752469,
-0.3165568709,
-0.6801204085,
0.8480780721,
-0.931925118,
0.0307824407,
0.6706851125,
0.0824656934,
-0.2541832626,
-0.3215169013,
-0.4927196801,
-0.3668298721,
-0.0551980287,
0.2435026616,
-0.1141421422,
0.5062227249,
0.1643963158,
0.4808626175,
-0.4567867815,
0.2509540617,
-0.1082746759,
-0.1916823387,
0.7736446857,
0.2129172832,
0.1633730978,
-0.1774993241,
-0.3167431355,
-0.3829627931,
-0.6959167123,
0.0843879506,
0.6847084165,
0.05341186,
-0.0940136462,
0.5462710857,
-0.2825083733,
0.8046289682,
0.08466506,
-0.0294511486,
0.2415619344,
-0.2104202658,
-0.1920807064,
0.0562820137,
0.8072969317,
0.5574279428,
0.2421693504,
-0.1273017973,
-0.2283415347,
0.3657394648,
0.2372280806,
-0.5390147567,
-0.2728224993,
0.1523413211,
-0.3806982934,
-0.2623022497,
-0.1922448575,
-0.912635684,
-0.3434628546,
-0.1856977493,
0.2844290435,
-0.3316861689,
-0.1750271618,
0.1581830233,
-0.4080015719,
0.2418210655,
-0.0337693803,
-1.6480500698,
0.4310114682,
0.4770840108,
0.5421355963,
-0.3878956437,
-0.2035816014,
-0.3584381342,
0.282823503,
-0.547842145,
0.8243829608,
-0.2493144125,
-0.1858312041,
0.2224795967,
-0.3804732561,
-0.1104184315,
-0.7026036382,
0.4976576865,
-0.2614879906,
0.4659505785,
-0.2228411585,
-0.5038796663,
-0.0492597409,
-0.0153586762,
-0.4357557297,
0.7005088329,
0.4347822964,
-0.8965209126,
0.4409331083,
-0.583317399,
-0.5153831244,
-0.110821411,
-0.0816610008,
-0.242315948,
0.1047095135,
0.2578016818,
0.2673521638,
-0.2430438548,
0.3557563424,
-0.481475234,
-0.2403036803,
0.0079483837,
-0.3995717168,
0.5487002134,
0.2439933568,
-0.4949246049,
0.2354785353,
-0.8059645891,
-0.1568160653,
-0.0425705463,
-0.3628073335,
-0.4600714445,
0.4407587647,
0.0206204783,
0.0212208033,
0.1352499723,
-0.3509776294,
0.2022111416,
-0.6999655366,
0.5574522018,
0.6504274607,
0.1081294939,
0.7677212358,
-0.2953746319,
0.5480647087,
0.1205381751,
-0.1932142079,
0.0728969499,
-0.1529188007,
-0.4252641797,
-0.4211750627,
0.1705530137,
0.717087388,
-0.5332201719,
0.5425907969,
-0.0844621211,
-0.2700402439,
-0.6987253428,
-0.2036741227,
0.4785578251,
0.6452671885,
0.3477904499,
-0.2297485471,
-0.2959471345,
-1.2460907698,
0.0043928847,
-0.1974236816,
-0.3045826852,
0.2752478421,
0.1263674349,
-0.2869864404,
0.8927266598,
-0.6476426721,
-0.05311241,
-0.057346493,
0.6630873084,
0.2240103781,
0.5425217748,
0.4288331866,
-0.3649552166,
-0.2157123983,
-0.1779347807,
-0.4652201831,
-0.3554739356,
0.0408439226,
-0.1570318192,
0.2785181999,
0.291403234,
-0.4873778224,
0.4149943292,
0.534317255,
-0.307536453,
0.2869325578,
-0.4863610566,
0.3385591209,
-0.8510457277,
-0.0248060208,
0.2252366394,
0.0216485951,
-0.349131912,
-0.2126198411,
0.0390541777,
0.081338644,
-0.0820023119,
0.3697606027,
-0.3010440171,
-0.0764465109,
-0.4736214578,
0.110837169,
-0.260504514,
0.6547800303,
0.2771771848,
0.7029517293,
0.4892288744,
-0.7433992028,
0.3615871072,
0.1426661015,
-0.1594160795,
0.7958872318,
-0.7144761682,
-0.264425844,
-0.4466144443,
0.1746789366,
-0.9478692412,
-0.2215902209,
0.2975006998,
-0.4074658155,
0.2101651281,
0.2043628097,
-0.1241188645,
-0.2440029383,
-0.3370455205,
0.3270982206,
0.6624546051,
-0.4770368338,
0.1118179858,
0.2960420549,
-0.2703006864,
-0.7565281987,
-0.9062424898,
-0.2926698029,
-0.249262318,
-0.3629081845,
0.6861914992,
-0.1300310493,
-0.3420111239,
-0.0080060745,
-0.0266162138,
-0.0788568705,
0.0026255311,
0.0610010885,
0.2104955614,
-0.1233746856,
0.0843801424,
0.3039742112,
-0.0186091401,
0.312504679,
0.0442078672,
0.2553088665,
0.2884204686,
-0.2543492913,
-0.1790291518,
0.489335984,
0.2053432018,
-0.0079378011,
0.5474914908,
0.4824633002,
-0.3364059329,
-0.1295645237,
-0.5125758648,
-0.2808576822,
-0.3673672974,
0.3020177484,
-0.0401639901,
-0.7911399007,
0.3222312629,
0.223175928,
-0.1038566455,
0.4037501812,
0.7980757356,
-0.0092022717,
1.2302647829,
0.5826942325,
-0.2761158049,
0.665540874,
0.025478486,
-0.021487819,
-0.8196126819,
0.0530113317,
-0.4293309748,
-0.2572071552,
-0.7363203168,
0.0108371191,
-0.0106933247,
0.1757225096,
-0.2990315259,
0.0138982479,
-0.4990540445,
0.2142007202,
0.947634697,
0.0981331617,
0.0551049374,
-0.0553830303,
-0.2334028333,
-0.119416602,
-0.6690202355,
-0.1789525598,
0.9043276906,
0.1731136888,
0.9531425834,
-0.075142853,
0.7091886997,
0.3673113286,
0.4053635001,
-0.6056752205,
0.2091642171,
0.1616315544,
-0.5033907294,
-0.3515117168,
-0.6878228188,
-1.1540597677,
0.2442120761,
-0.1162373796,
-0.9397419095,
0.3644376993,
0.3789370358,
-0.4277038872,
-0.1848299056,
-0.8177184463,
0.9500567317,
0.129526943,
-0.3443492949,
-0.3768143654,
-0.6792957187,
0.5567236543,
0.396053493,
0.1592779607,
-0.3403704464,
-0.0046166331,
0.6510527134,
-0.3083860278,
0.4029243588,
-0.312648505,
-0.0667154267,
0.0897753313,
-0.1822959334,
0.267973721,
0.1346095949,
0.0668925121,
-0.4331217706,
-0.0756903663,
-0.5203644037,
-0.707128942,
0.5977823734,
-0.677685082,
-0.5180638433,
-0.4105285108,
-0.7683628798,
-0.3106922805,
-0.0712293908,
0.4862991869,
0.1014483944,
-0.3156316578,
0.0027309563,
0.6414459944,
-0.2813382447,
0.6220576763,
0.3678770661,
-0.0078224065,
-0.9042677879,
0.716158092,
-0.3586063087,
0.339368999,
0.5851206779,
0.0978571028,
-0.4171307981,
-0.4400814176,
-0.2352113724,
0.2906866968,
-0.5035457611,
0.0294906441,
-0.2055761069,
-0.0888267085,
-0.658629477,
-0.2267279029,
-0.2133521885,
-0.0879716352,
-0.2316274047,
-0.0366264619,
0.0128467232,
0.6572921276,
-0.3508561254,
0.4689029753,
-0.4800411761,
0.4344815016,
0.4162046611,
0.4266144633,
-0.2163454592,
-0.3611734211,
-0.1969188452,
0.3189127445,
-0.3174299896,
-1.1506706476,
0.5961109996,
0.0239437688,
0.6971108317,
0.2669977248,
-0.0157064516,
0.343775481,
-0.2999604046,
0.5210413337,
0.3416911066,
-0.6647925973,
0.6867178082,
-0.4940288663,
0.3284515738,
0.485113889,
0.3083953857,
-0.4971463084,
-0.1123960316,
-0.6847044826,
-0.9155725837,
0.6443116069,
0.0866964534,
-0.0161031317,
-0.3472586572,
0.3232765794,
-0.2482813895,
0.4223648608,
-0.6960040331,
-0.2905931473,
-0.0427257642,
-0.4740151465,
-0.2794801593,
-0.1716991514,
-0.2410821468,
-0.133838132,
0.6728291512,
-0.3304492831,
0.3738592863,
0.3002102673,
0.0262641925,
-0.1910272986,
0.3541603982,
0.7506626844,
0.5395852923,
-0.5126891732,
-0.0351725034,
-0.1860162914,
-0.2990848124,
0.1889572293,
0.2148307711,
-0.2770238817,
-0.2848995626,
0.0548392422,
1.033282876,
0.1633210629,
-0.6677254438,
0.452450037,
0.0246404167,
-0.3839656413,
-0.034007486,
0.1656538695,
0.223124519,
0.1012970656,
0.1872702986,
-0.1150257662,
0.2630108893,
-0.3960060775,
0.1152591035,
0.5494326949,
-0.5043072104,
0.0112452265,
0.6287521124,
-0.1015793532,
-0.3907604516,
0.7483971715,
-0.2851329148,
-0.0535431243,
0.5294578671,
0.6641799212,
0.8589748144,
-0.2325603813,
0.4285928607,
0.3834490478,
0.2033759505,
-0.2712103426,
0.3013142645,
-0.3130179346,
-0.7895323634,
-0.5692726374,
-0.4203160107,
-0.5634735823,
-0.0918206275,
-0.8927865028,
-0.0819312409,
-0.3587809503,
-0.1056214496,
0.0124344332,
-0.3026152849,
-0.3209285736,
0.2679131627,
0.1842304468,
0.4841450155,
-0.9885411859,
0.6292670369,
0.6018833518,
-0.6588633657,
-0.5651727319,
-0.0240565352,
-0.3588858247,
-0.6556805372,
0.4406929314,
-0.2069694996,
0.170832634,
0.2562687397,
-0.5688256621,
-0.7396481037,
0.9456298351,
0.4698230624,
-0.2850856781,
-0.0523179732,
-0.1776523143,
0.5377939343,
-0.2440561205,
0.4092125297,
0.8356256485,
0.2446971834,
0.1554878354,
-0.6057519317,
-0.1649989039,
-0.1535964906,
0.191313982,
0.4287388325,
-0.3675110936,
0.5376474857,
-0.1902526915,
0.0588492863,
-0.1781262904,
0.747149229,
0.7669798732,
0.2591750026,
0.3466203511,
0.9638217092,
0.5219064951,
-0.080013819,
1.0171147585,
-0.1512200683,
0.422355324,
0.835683465,
-0.0897218511,
0.8869745135,
0.7966271043,
-0.4619987011,
0.7284162641,
0.8799633384,
0.1054030582,
0.9977440238,
0.7154214978,
-0.2153339684,
0.0809864178,
0.0468897969,
-0.2742265165,
-0.0886659697,
0.3779836297,
-0.3479343653,
-0.1739787608,
-0.0030299665,
-0.175745979,
0.256162107,
-0.3206485212,
0.8772354722,
-0.033441782,
-1.1938265562,
0.5604208708,
-0.083254613,
0.9089862704,
-0.4478465617,
0.0378911346,
-0.4530038238,
0.1881767064,
-0.1007803008,
-0.4183372259,
0.3614936769,
-0.4089826643,
-0.4256700277,
-0.131444186,
0.4259677827,
-0.5765423179,
-0.0765195265,
0.1469759494,
0.242673099,
-0.1414503455,
-0.0611832328,
-0.5525589585,
-0.4568393528,
-0.1259061694,
-0.5034459829,
0.4931768179,
0.2899356186,
0.2329683006,
0.7666496634,
0.3269805014,
0.2857238054,
0.0955215618,
0.0520902909,
0.2710642219,
-0.810908258,
-0.611310482,
-0.8772858381,
0.41560027,
0.00968643,
-0.3817717433,
0.3051157892,
0.3354437947,
0.6031416655,
-0.3015300632,
0.7277516127,
0.0275939424,
0.2894944549,
-0.5479072332,
0.3892104328,
-0.435454309,
0.0262726583,
-0.2292793095,
-1.0533430576,
-0.1887364537,
0.7814048529,
-0.2817237079,
0.1498873532,
1.0030447245,
0.8357895017,
0.1996521801,
-0.2099420279,
0.1923777014,
-0.2395579517,
-0.0217861589,
0.799775064,
0.6735997796,
-0.0989555269,
0.2286031991,
-0.2828251421,
-0.3347839117,
-0.0053981119,
-0.9432144761,
-0.5356644988,
-0.4672518671,
-0.5694221258,
-0.3311958611,
0.1440729946,
0.9013796449,
0.7330898046,
-0.826592207,
-0.3902460039,
-0.777552247,
0.2880872786,
-0.5272613168,
-0.2820248306,
0.2060038,
-0.554254353,
-0.8016442657,
0.231802091,
0.4424504936,
0.116677992,
-0.4372923076,
-0.1823985279,
-0.2569662631,
0.0361286402,
0.2267017961,
0.3678763211,
-0.7673140764,
-0.0872030929,
-0.1194462106,
-0.5183957815,
0.1216830015,
0.7811374068,
-0.6201663613,
0.1418922395,
0.9073036909,
0.7380558848,
0.5227130651,
0.1068539172,
0.9205837846,
-0.687266469,
0.0770931318,
0.2593252957,
0.3162706196,
0.2134579122,
-0.1690003723,
0.4713778794,
0.3873233199,
-0.8639829755,
-0.5410263538,
0.3750069141,
-0.9693885446,
-0.0758504346,
1.1618267298,
-0.0649836287,
-0.3886819184,
0.2583121955,
-0.2381131649,
0.2784202993,
-0.3724090159,
0.9121890664,
0.8119036555,
-0.1968627572,
-0.3286583722,
-0.3461488187,
0.7189711928,
0.7151765823,
-0.9917485118,
0.1287637204,
0.7567067742,
0.0878167078,
-0.060066767,
0.9268685579,
0.1627191305,
0.36159271,
0.0540916286,
0.4782445729,
0.4993134439,
0.1428067684,
-0.4764615595,
0.0853019953,
0.1565805972,
-0.2782702446
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02456v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02456v2
|
tnGPS: Discovering Unknown Tensor Network Structure Search Algorithms via Large Language Models (LLMs)
| 2024-02-04T12:06:13 | 2024-06-01T15:54:54 |
Junhua Zeng, Chao Li, Zhun Sun, Qibin Zhao, Guoxu Zhou
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Tensor networks are efficient for extremely high-dimensional representation,
but their model selection, known as tensor network structure search (TN-SS), is
a challenging problem. Although several works have targeted TN-SS, most
existing algorithms are manually crafted heuristics with poor performance,
suffering from the curse of dimensionality and local convergence. In this work,
we jump out of the box, studying how to harness large language models (LLMs) to
automatically discover new TN-SS algorithms, replacing the involvement of human
experts. By observing how human experts innovate in research, we model their
common workflow and propose an automatic algorithm discovery framework called
tnGPS. The proposed framework is an elaborate prompting pipeline that instruct
LLMs to generate new TN-SS algorithms through iterative refinement and
enhancement. The experimental results demonstrate that the algorithms
discovered by tnGPS exhibit superior performance in benchmarks compared to the
current state-of-the-art methods.
|
[
-0.574192524,
-0.477393508,
0.673117578,
-0.0727132186,
-0.2521291971,
0.3052871823,
-0.1717622876,
-0.0802998841,
0.5238980651,
0.3193137944,
-0.6187628508,
-0.5060080886,
-0.8885811567,
0.328561157,
-0.1851685792,
0.2148307115,
-0.1746622771,
0.1944403946,
0.4470638931,
0.1221905425,
-0.2939455807,
0.0964952931,
-1.1137273312,
-0.2686819434,
0.5107393861,
0.2710233629,
0.3686624765,
0.9777565598,
0.4134342372,
0.4865947962,
-0.4431571364,
0.6147048473,
-0.3411892653,
0.2928697765,
-0.0814134181,
-0.4561955631,
-0.2005268037,
-0.3197468519,
0.8983244896,
0.6498627663,
-0.0413832925,
0.3152973652,
-0.0921131596,
0.7918956876,
-0.4891630113,
0.1956436783,
-0.4983130693,
0.3872512877,
-0.548150897,
-0.6703079939,
-0.337796241,
-0.1854303181,
0.1439841688,
-0.3523383737,
0.7154470086,
0.0858690366,
0.3242732286,
0.245836243,
-0.3853136599,
-0.1908619553,
-0.403421551,
0.3423511982,
-0.632574141,
0.5150617957,
0.0564287975,
0.4211657047,
-0.8378139734,
-0.7385542393,
-0.2709554434,
-0.3141839206,
-0.06994427,
-0.4922523797,
-0.0848328397,
0.1879175007,
0.2071918696,
0.3667185605,
-0.6293759942,
0.3344886303,
-0.4824646115,
-0.2075577825,
0.4114986956,
0.2592513263,
0.3223895431,
-0.1699583381,
-0.0521491356,
-0.0146345235,
-0.8146260381,
-0.2166361213,
0.3061650097,
0.56926018,
0.0114839198,
0.7177454829,
-0.4504818618,
0.7204016447,
-0.1937701553,
0.4131305814,
0.1684370637,
-0.0097916014,
-0.181922704,
0.0258254744,
0.8022244573,
-0.280482024,
0.0593220405,
-0.5429957509,
-0.4236148894,
-0.1904097348,
0.1829493791,
-0.664088428,
-0.2526938915,
0.105809845,
-0.5744506717,
-0.3394339085,
-0.1394897252,
-0.5867100954,
-0.7383169532,
-0.3360091448,
0.3873942792,
-0.240897283,
-0.6477276683,
0.0299003739,
-0.5101417899,
-0.1846568435,
0.0635382086,
-0.7644428611,
-0.0717639476,
0.7230101228,
1.0453404188,
-0.147630468,
-0.3388938308,
-0.8585305214,
-0.1251998246,
-0.624114871,
0.8203152418,
-0.5462065935,
-0.2617994547,
-0.2017337531,
-0.0224268418,
-0.0000685464,
-0.3587919474,
0.4991272688,
-0.6529872417,
0.0715566427,
-0.5408542156,
-0.555578351,
-0.0446419753,
0.2125462741,
-0.7607516646,
0.9493325353,
0.0859723464,
-0.8836161494,
0.2025586516,
-1.3163050413,
-0.0047107288,
0.2898454964,
-0.2341145277,
-0.4182857871,
0.5322830081,
0.4054864347,
0.7169288397,
-0.5520316958,
0.3252333105,
-0.3695549071,
-0.7738032937,
-0.207803309,
-0.2059354633,
1.0479542017,
0.3493486941,
-0.5416131616,
0.2968334258,
-0.5175161958,
0.1338558495,
0.2929624915,
-0.1235696152,
-0.2269107103,
-0.1583094299,
-0.4820421636,
-0.1033645943,
-0.0279908106,
-0.4163118601,
0.3713266551,
-0.1940137297,
0.7682760954,
0.9238625765,
-0.1279754192,
0.4958159924,
0.0424835868,
0.5393418074,
-0.1602060497,
-0.0096200807,
-0.1783652455,
-0.2795254588,
-0.5905042291,
-0.2514965832,
0.2971129119,
-0.0295611713,
-0.7605392933,
0.1353967041,
-0.3906269073,
-0.5916213989,
-0.4722881019,
0.0550946444,
0.1863698363,
0.4473949969,
0.1412963718,
-0.3132405877,
-0.8125422597,
-0.7861679792,
-0.2441190779,
-0.0807742029,
-0.0287771802,
0.2110003084,
0.240999192,
-0.3613053858,
0.6649383307,
-0.4748170078,
-0.1217102334,
-0.0249375869,
0.1983295679,
0.0930774286,
0.2997838259,
0.3010492921,
-0.5578921437,
-0.1101759151,
-0.1965365261,
-0.9106363654,
0.1500908881,
0.3699548542,
-0.0507200435,
0.0062111062,
0.9691426158,
-0.5995222926,
0.196033448,
0.301643014,
-0.2831323743,
0.5404328108,
-0.1676084399,
-0.0519271828,
-1.1835849285,
0.2415199131,
0.2942656577,
0.128526032,
-0.3831652105,
0.4378934205,
-0.0299460888,
-0.2118705809,
-0.1768245846,
0.6978838444,
-0.9812300801,
-0.4526314139,
-0.1212593168,
-0.0560952649,
-0.3190059066,
0.5652715564,
0.0464968272,
0.7739459872,
0.7978848815,
-0.7031098604,
0.4632909,
0.1545874774,
-0.3934911788,
0.1922881305,
-0.4172799587,
0.2250395417,
-0.3778142631,
0.1983549148,
-1.048448801,
-0.2014712989,
0.0943741798,
-0.5090078115,
0.3328185678,
-0.8078282475,
-0.494988054,
-0.5672111511,
-0.0395489931,
0.3616496921,
-0.0051049567,
-0.8217518926,
0.7082274556,
0.5943946242,
-0.0133768022,
-0.7056427002,
-0.2167065293,
0.5740001202,
-0.1235194206,
-0.6709362864,
0.2674612105,
0.1565434188,
0.0373624153,
-0.1478367001,
-0.1602289528,
0.0390055627,
0.270703733,
0.1119832098,
0.053721156,
-0.5254254937,
0.0809965655,
-0.1728938371,
-0.2454268485,
0.1199471131,
-0.8075948358,
0.8012570739,
-0.5225547552,
-0.2721742094,
-0.3410781622,
0.0365253165,
0.5616222024,
-0.5584172606,
0.1071879417,
1.0687659979,
-0.4502027929,
-0.28523013,
-0.7741982341,
-0.4279517531,
-0.604670465,
0.6446983218,
-0.3284784257,
-0.9957107902,
0.4757054746,
-0.3824082911,
-0.0556004234,
0.2469546646,
0.4546961486,
0.279571116,
1.0214744806,
0.7530335188,
-0.0422853641,
0.4485335648,
-0.5450227261,
0.2984833121,
-0.9206719398,
-0.2831224501,
-0.6552733183,
-0.5041713119,
-0.8549644947,
-0.2491748184,
0.6381720901,
-0.2339492738,
-0.4052116275,
0.5260233879,
-0.7806105614,
0.7075778246,
0.6266979575,
0.0386401378,
0.2011622488,
0.3224218786,
-0.6290457249,
0.3397793472,
-0.914244473,
-0.1434085816,
1.114236474,
0.3421244323,
0.334764123,
0.1304077655,
0.9522200227,
0.2600135505,
0.335070163,
-0.701644361,
0.7257658839,
-0.0860018879,
-0.408143729,
-0.5845185518,
-0.8725575805,
-1.0876594782,
-0.0160742141,
-0.2314945459,
-0.7114546299,
0.1694882065,
0.0799662992,
-0.318511039,
0.7748184204,
-0.6759108901,
0.5524528623,
-0.0915883407,
-0.2436747402,
-0.1024704352,
-0.3489845395,
0.3022644222,
0.3393510282,
-0.1363901496,
0.0744008571,
0.152321741,
0.596214354,
-0.4057446122,
0.5662688017,
-0.4105718732,
0.0299657006,
0.0772909597,
0.4463800192,
0.7487286925,
0.1387104243,
-0.2110775858,
0.0778241307,
-0.5145049095,
-0.2215615511,
-0.5254535079,
0.9421198368,
-0.5636217594,
-0.6242066622,
-0.1335999072,
-0.2853750885,
-0.2525663376,
0.6775547266,
0.2918632925,
0.6118173003,
0.002796832,
0.0995609909,
0.7771407366,
0.0907751545,
0.6365299821,
0.4168989062,
0.0380926915,
-0.3226312995,
0.8728800416,
0.061507076,
-0.4660016298,
0.3984822929,
0.3142734468,
-0.4781120718,
-1.0441931486,
-0.7914007902,
0.1854434013,
-0.4525257349,
-0.284683615,
-0.5027740002,
-0.281437844,
-0.3079668581,
0.1253652722,
-0.48316589,
-0.3139084578,
-0.1766536385,
-0.2304131836,
0.3025374711,
0.7880299091,
-0.0318511054,
0.2279428244,
-0.7066966891,
0.2122078687,
0.0830989555,
1.0617399216,
0.2886291444,
-0.2136917114,
-0.1799943149,
-0.0078237178,
-0.0272912942,
-0.451399833,
0.251291424,
-0.2971104085,
0.6150568724,
0.4036314487,
-0.1741878241,
0.5931990147,
-0.330742836,
0.2317515165,
0.0665715858,
-0.6360290051,
0.0111125959,
-0.5229351521,
0.1420367509,
0.2380696982,
0.2925869524,
-0.5834379792,
0.1296369284,
-0.4786429107,
-0.6329348683,
0.5956881046,
0.2335023731,
-0.0726948828,
0.0906517953,
0.5773268938,
-0.1677150428,
0.0325514786,
-0.2703061998,
-0.2404378504,
0.0580045506,
-0.0900102034,
0.1544609815,
-0.114927277,
-0.1531775743,
0.0566123761,
0.5163168907,
-0.2953219712,
0.4500894248,
0.3098121285,
0.0453630686,
-0.4499316812,
-0.0354569815,
0.378549695,
0.7017655969,
-0.0831423923,
0.1721992344,
0.039355278,
-0.3608020544,
-0.0014209345,
0.2360711992,
-0.097395964,
0.0919619575,
0.1609198302,
0.9910301566,
-0.101504311,
-0.5006386638,
0.2182651162,
-0.4073562622,
-0.2288765758,
-0.636651516,
0.2526514232,
0.2154882252,
0.4966771305,
0.5897304416,
0.2987684011,
0.1124864891,
-0.2114885896,
0.2329930514,
0.6865797639,
-0.2782463431,
-0.0987645239,
0.4908212721,
0.108146809,
-0.716224432,
0.7295407653,
-0.3890729845,
-0.5365396142,
0.5318995118,
0.0830988511,
1.1239663363,
-0.1347338557,
0.3883354068,
0.3566779792,
0.3040705025,
-0.4898691177,
0.0904106423,
0.0059994692,
-0.6496270299,
-0.6028567553,
-0.2245292366,
-0.1163085029,
0.3271261156,
-0.3243234456,
0.7018153071,
-0.5219449401,
-0.1357713491,
0.1554570943,
0.210417971,
-0.6894409657,
0.0727441981,
0.3136289418,
0.9951062202,
-0.458905369,
0.4458885789,
0.6744144559,
-0.0496814251,
-0.8325500488,
-0.2898268402,
0.1596674174,
-1.000888586,
0.5543913841,
0.0938974097,
-0.1129529402,
0.3328496218,
-0.5105809569,
-1.0468044281,
1.2274714708,
0.5231128335,
-0.3397469223,
-0.5255518556,
0.1346503794,
0.5354470015,
-0.3658046722,
0.6158255339,
0.1997730136,
0.3355173469,
0.185427025,
-0.7949426174,
0.2757984996,
-0.516731739,
0.0511803813,
0.5777203441,
-0.5210285783,
0.6602737904,
-0.5565077662,
-0.0188749395,
-0.0821942464,
0.5482821465,
0.4839003086,
0.2581581473,
0.5366314054,
0.5423264503,
0.780616045,
0.1210823953,
0.7256174684,
-0.1236973628,
0.0224824082,
0.7978112698,
0.214765653,
0.5869435072,
0.2721587718,
0.1021890491,
0.2785302699,
0.8516417742,
-0.2443438172,
0.1247759759,
0.5117551088,
-0.0563840792,
-0.3829390109,
0.1592913866,
-0.1414000541,
0.5723330379,
0.3719566166,
-0.5774089098,
-0.4394746125,
-0.4772961438,
-0.032996729,
-0.3429394364,
-0.4448955059,
0.4881624877,
0.0018788311,
-0.7703125477,
0.8810394406,
0.3825252652,
0.4501719773,
-0.4510856867,
-0.0809649974,
-0.3336094022,
-0.0357850455,
-0.145313859,
-0.4111612439,
0.1890214086,
-0.249983564,
0.0926943794,
0.1015803516,
0.5655049086,
-0.1827700585,
-0.3431460857,
0.1035263464,
0.5441803932,
-0.0854113474,
-0.2191319466,
-0.5133084059,
-0.0144847585,
0.0278922934,
-0.2404033095,
0.2801046073,
0.5798428059,
-0.3238143921,
1.1332803965,
0.8130066395,
0.1518297195,
0.0791871995,
-0.1589236408,
0.8781062365,
-0.5903484821,
-0.5605422854,
-0.8171406984,
0.1421010047,
-0.1659139991,
-0.3204282522,
0.3968497813,
0.5605828166,
0.806098938,
0.076591216,
0.7239256501,
0.1814780086,
0.3811119795,
-0.4995310009,
0.8037685156,
-0.5346334577,
0.6318386197,
-0.1809515357,
-0.868802011,
-0.4063640833,
0.3176917434,
-0.1112102941,
0.0355019495,
0.5228579044,
1.2219651937,
-0.3432391882,
0.3959550858,
-0.1820042431,
0.2939509153,
0.4717207551,
0.1347956955,
0.5359787345,
-0.2285027355,
0.5291623473,
-0.1015474275,
-0.0925563499,
-0.2525588274,
-1.1790207624,
-0.9631576538,
-0.8977123499,
-0.1518283039,
-0.3537676036,
0.14963305,
1.2356157303,
0.7838369012,
-0.5653113127,
-0.2013474554,
-0.6230335236,
0.2977274358,
-0.1280973256,
-0.1454339325,
0.7628750801,
-0.3535804152,
-0.6202853322,
0.716519475,
0.1118623838,
0.0455819182,
-0.5569272637,
-0.0321732983,
0.2028311342,
-0.3394653797,
0.1941799223,
0.4500953555,
-0.3604358435,
0.1697353125,
0.3298833668,
0.1708245426,
-0.1549807936,
1.2966977358,
-0.7457238436,
0.4522520602,
0.7123976946,
0.8327588439,
0.4881899655,
-0.5270878077,
0.8405479789,
-0.6649270058,
-0.0928968266,
0.2503394783,
0.71736902,
0.4432659447,
-0.3058009446,
0.7120206356,
0.2377895117,
-0.3042373061,
-1.1709299088,
0.2082700431,
-0.4765617251,
-0.1575399041,
0.9978465438,
0.0836573094,
-0.2038258165,
-0.1214667261,
-0.1003499553,
0.2983219326,
-0.227245748,
1.2551236153,
0.3107280731,
0.0342156626,
-0.2438083589,
-0.2622114122,
0.8051350713,
0.3342447579,
-0.1390558183,
0.1651356965,
0.0151107823,
0.4062614441,
0.0603012294,
0.4553900957,
-0.225105077,
0.0777374879,
-0.2715340257,
-0.0884879082,
-0.8595131636,
-0.3168996871,
-0.0076995282,
0.2076378167,
-0.0146827037,
0.202737987
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02449v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02449v1
|
Surfing the modeling of PoS taggers in low-resource scenarios
| 2024-02-04T11:38:12 | 2024-02-04T11:38:12 |
Manuel Vilares Ferro, Víctor M. Darriba Bilbao, Francisco J. Ribadas-Pena, Jorge Graña Gil
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, 68, 68T50
|
The recent trend towards the application of deep structured techniques has
revealed the limits of huge models in natural language processing. This has
reawakened the interest in traditional machine learning algorithms, which have
proved still to be competitive in certain contexts, in particular low-resource
settings. In parallel, model selection has become an essential task to boost
performance at reasonable cost, even more so when we talk about processes
involving domains where the training and/or computational resources are scarce.
Against this backdrop, we evaluate the early estimation of learning curves as a
practical mechanism for selecting the most appropriate model in scenarios
characterized by the use of non-deep learners in resource-lean settings. On the
basis of a formal approximation model previously evaluated under conditions of
wide availability of training and validation resources, we study the
reliability of such an approach in a different and much more demanding
operationalenvironment. Using as case study the generation of PoS taggers for
Galician, a language belonging to the Western Ibero-Romance group, the
experimental results are consistent with our expectations.
|
[
-0.3748738766,
-0.6805155873,
0.6600577235,
-0.0353079177,
-0.1778881848,
-0.0203154404,
-0.3386228085,
-0.5642338395,
-0.0664455965,
0.2705700696,
-0.6376456022,
-0.2948019803,
-0.451944977,
0.0825644508,
-0.0189991649,
1.2808157206,
-0.1010986939,
-0.0986154452,
0.0268707313,
0.0811430365,
-0.5339474082,
-0.3346678317,
-0.6443709731,
-0.243383199,
0.4255705178,
0.2543127239,
0.6239435077,
0.6422035098,
0.5101274848,
0.274867475,
-0.2216586322,
0.0140070375,
-0.5774086714,
0.1722892821,
-0.3645474017,
-0.4165802598,
-0.3780893981,
0.1741823852,
0.6168327332,
0.9690335393,
-0.2290614992,
0.3018666804,
0.0964547768,
0.3819792271,
-0.7952153087,
0.106786713,
-0.9756476283,
0.0759798661,
-0.0833730847,
0.1878136843,
-0.473289758,
-0.2091408968,
0.5265780687,
-0.5489888787,
0.4406388402,
-0.0499494299,
0.9926598668,
0.3366636932,
0.052164048,
-0.3752315342,
-1.0023168325,
1.0883066654,
-0.4589705169,
0.2775683105,
0.6724224091,
0.4646573067,
-0.2660715878,
-0.7312287688,
-0.2033355981,
-0.5638334155,
-0.1340083629,
-0.1260137856,
-0.0136888372,
0.0554617345,
0.4078484178,
0.1647616923,
-0.2148433179,
0.5195708871,
-0.487724036,
0.0014697016,
0.6185654402,
0.1921838969,
-0.1988989264,
-0.2603072524,
-0.5641419291,
0.0937377959,
-0.3826453388,
0.2732746601,
0.5666402578,
0.7569036484,
-0.1690481454,
0.4532839358,
-0.2778134644,
0.7945145965,
-0.0470417812,
-0.7010501027,
0.2037127763,
-0.1769615412,
-0.4311302602,
-0.2434505373,
0.8203360438,
-0.1400240958,
0.316100359,
-0.03690999,
-0.5826702714,
0.1161618903,
0.263926059,
-0.5051671863,
-0.1599460691,
-0.0903120488,
-0.4415412545,
-0.0481967926,
-0.1979053766,
-0.8204649687,
-0.2844972908,
-0.1822878271,
0.0621039085,
-0.5991366506,
-0.2421180904,
0.0174383614,
0.0394666567,
0.0780637935,
0.2036235332,
-0.683550477,
0.1268409491,
0.4998851418,
0.9456111789,
0.1347993165,
-0.2213731259,
-0.5081043839,
-0.0765375569,
-0.2453658879,
0.6674823165,
-0.8184289932,
-0.5018445253,
-0.1751309186,
-0.1834418774,
-0.2396554202,
-0.5635970831,
1.0472471714,
-0.3483362198,
-0.0503877178,
-0.0320623107,
-0.2892141342,
0.2515800297,
0.0256248415,
-0.7359323502,
1.1417440176,
0.5237557888,
-0.8171519041,
0.62072891,
-0.4963836074,
-0.5888361931,
0.1004445031,
0.017049307,
-0.4986343384,
0.3627910316,
-0.2671945989,
0.6685182452,
-0.4931565821,
0.2572266459,
-0.5300863981,
-0.2909003794,
0.1519921571,
-0.4523643851,
0.5868110657,
0.5925865173,
-0.0528385229,
-0.272462517,
-0.771453023,
-0.0618957616,
0.3018236756,
-0.6119815111,
-0.4325504303,
0.3881854117,
-0.1702197045,
0.2386771888,
-0.0277397074,
-0.3641994894,
0.1915891171,
-0.3247537315,
0.6058778167,
0.5193278193,
0.0769924521,
0.6542654634,
-0.1978702545,
0.7812495232,
-0.3863595426,
0.4346958697,
-0.1957612336,
-0.385764122,
-0.5455922484,
-0.7378208041,
0.3197159171,
0.4897212982,
-0.8939334154,
0.1852374524,
-0.2367206961,
-0.7914081216,
-0.6365466118,
0.1712454259,
0.6854708791,
0.6371372938,
0.2148514837,
-0.2044951171,
-0.5054195523,
-0.7851979136,
-0.1594253927,
-0.3598472476,
-0.3776679039,
0.4143827558,
0.3565966487,
-0.1069428101,
0.9069347382,
-0.2397406101,
-0.1571561098,
-0.308069557,
0.0817021132,
0.2740722597,
0.4105833471,
0.7325716019,
-0.7396832108,
-0.433352232,
-0.1844063103,
-0.3982093632,
-0.0755004957,
0.1015812308,
0.045362927,
0.4126527011,
0.1771199405,
-0.4213454425,
0.3165025115,
0.6451929808,
-0.1054413766,
0.4815536141,
-0.1614872664,
-0.2854421139,
-0.4809886515,
0.1842821389,
0.5354955792,
-0.049315013,
-0.5790954232,
-0.2469711304,
-0.4551396668,
-0.223379612,
-0.6178046465,
0.4332382083,
-0.3601814806,
-0.1990225613,
0.1681181043,
0.058870554,
-0.0788491368,
0.4520710111,
0.2384294719,
0.4921488166,
0.5403024554,
-0.6862363815,
-0.1112206131,
-0.0264996495,
-0.5211628675,
0.6374669671,
-0.4684436023,
0.0093591018,
-0.2130591869,
-0.0388803743,
-0.9165878296,
-0.3132486939,
0.2146123648,
-0.3932375014,
0.2914707959,
-0.6874622107,
-0.3783521354,
-0.4148107171,
0.0596822426,
0.083387889,
0.7362221479,
-0.2265327275,
0.6511439681,
0.6104065776,
0.0198330339,
-0.4120177627,
-0.3499133587,
-0.5057163835,
-0.349778384,
-0.3503162861,
-0.0849021673,
0.3281908631,
-0.1816737354,
-0.0145960683,
-0.1236579791,
-0.2098521888,
0.524015069,
0.2884135544,
0.3886311948,
-0.3104538918,
0.0678129122,
-0.3511297107,
-0.1628461331,
-0.1637391597,
-0.40797472,
0.509278357,
-0.2286975533,
-0.1366244704,
-0.4133558273,
0.0309501141,
0.4857886732,
-0.5666645169,
1.0280637741,
0.4317729175,
-0.3614189327,
-0.5394455194,
-0.3219715655,
0.1471546143,
-0.4512707293,
0.321980387,
-0.3613299727,
-0.6151520014,
0.4322759807,
-0.2093115896,
-0.0211681388,
0.4476988614,
0.2168516666,
-0.3080982864,
0.8074340224,
0.8255698085,
0.1480911821,
0.6408303976,
-0.288849771,
0.3939080834,
-0.538010478,
-0.3983562589,
-0.8058155179,
-0.2674598098,
-0.902620852,
-0.4230364859,
0.3657693267,
0.4029321671,
-0.1719515622,
0.2752110064,
-0.3159797192,
0.482404232,
0.5634120703,
-0.0906267837,
-0.0075739585,
0.1801264137,
-0.1357342303,
-0.0116691887,
-1.0764558315,
-0.8218069673,
0.607290864,
0.4867606163,
0.8685831428,
-0.3506225944,
0.4405373931,
0.1342195421,
0.4925412536,
-0.8121881485,
0.414341867,
-0.3398547769,
-0.5646230578,
-0.5234344006,
-0.5513749123,
-1.0264724493,
0.0705374926,
-0.4398305118,
-0.6851610541,
0.0601044334,
0.3651043475,
-0.6538245082,
0.5383013487,
-0.9775027633,
0.9889300466,
-0.3823401332,
-0.4435306489,
0.2117571533,
-0.6371754408,
0.122017011,
-0.1812877804,
0.3212902546,
-0.4603135288,
-0.1514350325,
0.656452477,
-0.2990088463,
0.9128199816,
-0.5401297808,
-0.0789332166,
0.8045781255,
0.1440330297,
0.5448353291,
-0.2373516858,
-0.3625857532,
0.2054817677,
-0.1522193253,
-0.4387431145,
-0.3238051832,
0.4747179151,
-0.7553167343,
-0.211604923,
-0.2168361843,
-0.0493605919,
-0.2959165275,
0.0653933361,
0.3163078427,
0.0854401439,
-0.1014043763,
-0.1044518352,
0.4576919675,
-0.327553004,
0.4448304176,
0.6080719233,
0.0875568762,
-0.1782552153,
0.8745840192,
0.3335236609,
0.4512480199,
0.1938025653,
0.126052022,
-0.0258879531,
-0.7341515422,
-0.172470063,
0.2755931914,
-0.4768763185,
-0.3622889519,
-0.4960835278,
-0.1190815791,
-0.0353771709,
-0.3437220156,
-0.5865994692,
-0.1189988032,
-0.3171827197,
-0.2070322037,
0.1260167658,
0.6634331942,
0.1394365132,
0.5365087986,
-0.6416886449,
0.0321815275,
0.0108267264,
0.6287321448,
0.0211718213,
-0.392000854,
-0.3579894602,
-0.0711748153,
-0.1056418791,
-0.7984762192,
0.3083346784,
0.1689658463,
0.7029438019,
0.218563959,
0.0680070072,
0.3691143394,
-0.4903132915,
0.4211826921,
0.0876616687,
-0.734377861,
0.7579737306,
-0.3961062431,
0.0388971828,
0.6720346808,
0.935474813,
-0.2960817516,
-0.2437205464,
-0.7063397169,
-1.0578811169,
0.8234078288,
0.1118228287,
0.0202894974,
-0.0936899036,
0.6362258196,
0.2987857759,
0.2668747604,
-0.5715504885,
0.0870130882,
0.037898276,
-0.0280933715,
-0.1334241331,
-0.3215483129,
0.4573974013,
0.1162428111,
0.6686452031,
-0.1763138026,
0.0228718389,
0.0271367393,
0.0012683262,
-0.2451237738,
0.1888590753,
0.0475621149,
0.7141685486,
-0.2245071381,
0.0316827372,
0.1668321639,
-0.2687372267,
0.0176562481,
0.0360946245,
-0.3784079552,
0.1011047587,
0.4158005416,
1.1573153734,
0.3037118614,
-1.0348694324,
0.3837959468,
0.1017224789,
0.1012356505,
-0.239486143,
0.2625738084,
-0.369933933,
0.323317796,
0.2002752125,
0.1715247333,
-0.1054495573,
-0.4992906749,
0.0176704247,
0.4357891679,
-0.489852041,
-0.4271294773,
0.4311105609,
0.3783926368,
-0.4908576012,
0.6983076334,
-0.5165821314,
-0.5031506419,
0.3698370457,
0.1775156707,
0.7363017201,
-0.363586396,
0.3337281048,
0.5401741266,
0.5077130198,
-0.2054775059,
0.0127342129,
0.1115582138,
-0.4612196982,
-0.6551908255,
-1.2326766253,
-0.1231094077,
0.3460105956,
-0.6626562476,
0.4955898821,
-0.6295833588,
-0.5831617117,
-0.0210318696,
0.1042948589,
-0.9431101084,
0.3046368062,
0.5634502769,
0.7910265326,
-1.1614977121,
0.7435178757,
0.6605209112,
-0.285480082,
-0.6681070924,
-0.2343334258,
-0.3398026824,
-0.6782470345,
0.5134939551,
-0.0212144256,
-0.2033442706,
-0.2431188375,
-0.4617781043,
-0.9432559609,
0.8360113502,
0.5676172376,
-0.7791777849,
-0.2815231383,
-0.0383412056,
0.7952950597,
-0.2425767928,
0.0888594836,
0.7862740755,
0.1781557649,
0.2902568281,
-1.2846639156,
-0.2375990301,
0.1493455619,
0.0522727631,
0.4499242008,
-0.5625224113,
1.0911884308,
-0.4277385175,
-0.5873903632,
0.0248989351,
0.5061587691,
0.2582916319,
0.2771909237,
0.6383532286,
0.4897508323,
0.9323633313,
0.033930134,
1.3280754089,
-0.111796245,
0.5088319778,
1.2489242554,
-0.4679431319,
0.9637646079,
0.254149586,
-0.3996306956,
0.4501968324,
0.7994992137,
-0.2514486909,
0.5952825546,
0.1752763242,
-0.0831828937,
-0.2644365728,
-0.3307943046,
-0.0058233994,
0.5451686978,
0.3254608512,
-0.3961181939,
-0.1850488931,
-0.1263733059,
0.1148331165,
0.125640139,
-0.5925444365,
0.6594788432,
-0.0751882568,
-0.8663657308,
0.6319747567,
0.3039286733,
0.5237523913,
-0.7370513678,
0.1744487286,
-0.1189192608,
0.2264463902,
-0.05861637,
-0.6602569818,
0.1861532778,
0.3845314384,
-0.2761667371,
-0.2549265325,
0.8958400488,
-0.1694745719,
-0.5671493411,
0.4563806355,
0.5849596858,
0.1650791317,
0.2073544264,
-0.4675426185,
-0.0330817513,
-0.1421085447,
-0.0083419858,
0.2536934316,
0.5838621855,
-0.116540648,
0.6081867218,
0.5667751431,
0.1242955402,
0.2940194607,
-0.3278051019,
0.7859476805,
-0.3133679032,
-0.5521419644,
-0.8953231573,
0.4877945483,
0.2414076626,
-0.2661119998,
0.6705436707,
0.4708746076,
1.3247315884,
0.0916231871,
0.9080256224,
-0.2206957787,
0.4776221216,
-0.5709422827,
0.4682643712,
-0.340867281,
0.1021790504,
-0.1017065421,
-0.9202214479,
0.0945451781,
0.7564176321,
-0.7248861194,
0.1100444943,
0.4410000741,
0.3606104851,
-0.1008336022,
-0.1118987799,
0.2405274659,
0.1027583852,
-0.0440249667,
0.6912619472,
1.1116716862,
0.0633959919,
0.3942961395,
-0.3723255992,
-0.2816528976,
-0.1814286411,
-0.9611212611,
-0.9690389633,
-0.3898425102,
-0.1574587077,
-0.4085041583,
-0.1545667946,
0.8806092143,
0.7480014563,
-0.5980480909,
-0.1761504561,
0.2485913932,
0.1682176292,
0.0617285669,
-0.135545969,
0.0263192654,
-0.5087360144,
-0.6170603037,
0.1955295503,
0.1635032594,
0.2068746984,
-0.2160962671,
-0.2261228412,
-0.2200432122,
0.0748358443,
0.3891865313,
0.4270827472,
-0.4528951943,
-0.0003467702,
-0.0925126448,
-0.1174533218,
0.0781414062,
0.9445263147,
-1.0478441715,
0.1405569017,
0.3377688527,
0.5859173536,
0.3730612397,
-0.1027626023,
0.1295035928,
-0.8761315942,
0.3525896966,
0.4792160392,
0.3602789938,
0.5596596599,
0.1256587803,
0.6786975861,
0.4236057699,
-0.2519018948,
-1.1001950502,
0.2138233483,
-0.4623179436,
-0.1887708753,
1.1370401382,
-0.4120279849,
-0.4880152345,
0.037010584,
0.0369419493,
0.2210593522,
-0.3334802985,
0.5881329179,
0.476966083,
-0.0723788142,
0.2397558242,
-0.742251575,
0.6280866265,
0.1119169369,
-0.5432238579,
0.0063238633,
0.4745364785,
0.2082155496,
0.2757515311,
0.5670663714,
0.3147593141,
-0.2336497605,
0.0568118058,
-0.1492628902,
0.1420256197,
-0.6456140876,
-0.144955799,
0.3015632033,
0.2380414456,
0.013631369
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02447v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02447v1
|
Breaking MLPerf Training: A Case Study on Optimizing BERT
| 2024-02-04T11:12:17 | 2024-02-04T11:12:17 |
Yongdeok Kim, Jaehyung Ahn, Myeongwoo Kim, Changin Choi, Heejae Kim, Narankhuu Tuvshinjargal, Seungwon Lee, Yanzi Zhang, Yuan Pei, Xiongzhan Linghu, Jingkun Ma, Lin Chen, Yuehua Dai, Sungjoo Yoo
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Speeding up the large-scale distributed training is challenging in that it
requires improving various components of training including load balancing,
communication, optimizers, etc. We present novel approaches for fast
large-scale training of BERT model which individually ameliorates each
component thereby leading to a new level of BERT training performance. Load
balancing is imperative in distributed BERT training since its training
datasets are characterized by samples with various lengths. Communication cost,
which is proportional to the scale of distributed training, needs to be hidden
by useful computation. In addition, the optimizers, e.g., ADAM, LAMB, etc.,
need to be carefully re-evaluated in the context of large-scale distributed
training. We propose two new ideas, (1) local presorting based on dataset
stratification for load balancing and (2) bucket-wise gradient clipping before
allreduce which allows us to benefit from the overlap of gradient computation
and synchronization as well as the fast training of gradient clipping before
allreduce. We also re-evaluate existing optimizers via hyperparameter
optimization and utilize ADAM, which also contributes to fast training via
larger batches than existing methods. Our proposed methods, all combined, give
the fastest MLPerf BERT training of 25.1 (22.3) seconds on 1,024 NVIDIA A100
GPUs, which is 1.33x (1.13x) and 1.57x faster than the other top two (one)
submissions to MLPerf v1.1 (v2.0). Our implementation and evaluation results
are available at MLPerf v1.1~v2.1.
|
[
-0.7831658721,
-0.9414931536,
0.1542954743,
0.6588100195,
-0.2173217237,
0.0567190535,
-0.2956198156,
-0.5703822374,
0.1768415421,
0.308062315,
-0.9230875969,
0.1782886833,
-0.7845832705,
0.0229498316,
-0.4866355062,
0.9745741487,
-0.0247591976,
0.3698407412,
-0.371329993,
-0.2022898197,
-0.2068481445,
-0.6037140489,
-0.8385029435,
-0.4934221506,
0.7741620541,
0.3819733858,
0.6763261557,
0.6074047089,
1.0393676758,
0.3785011172,
-0.1607768238,
-0.0030230128,
-0.7454622388,
0.3397669792,
0.1408146322,
-0.1618655473,
-0.3560107946,
-0.3251283467,
0.9788122773,
0.7192690372,
-0.3494444489,
0.2451471984,
0.0374699868,
0.8848400116,
-0.7425484061,
-0.1199378967,
-0.5412470698,
0.2838534117,
-0.2339841872,
0.0779098272,
-0.264660269,
-0.202085495,
0.3208645284,
-0.3488074541,
0.5668706298,
-0.0946496353,
0.9296573997,
0.4542360604,
-0.0373839587,
0.0698036477,
-0.8340919018,
0.9449355602,
-0.4598162174,
0.489923209,
0.0620547198,
0.4774335921,
-0.0837586597,
-0.8630817533,
-0.3696453571,
0.1375846714,
0.251362294,
-0.0678961352,
0.1121565476,
-0.066862151,
0.3759739697,
0.399890691,
-0.3753540516,
0.3230562806,
-0.1152073145,
0.1877409071,
0.6895660758,
-0.061333444,
-0.255741477,
0.2949120998,
-0.788850069,
-0.5303891897,
-0.3528587222,
0.1148367599,
0.3114333749,
0.3977837861,
0.1335673183,
-0.0428662561,
0.1808095127,
0.7239567637,
0.0651389584,
-0.0278746802,
0.5293556452,
0.0590196587,
-0.2800566852,
0.1479223073,
0.4269838631,
0.2635742128,
0.1557747126,
0.0447189547,
-0.3617971241,
-0.6218833327,
0.270088017,
-1.1184117794,
-0.1563507617,
0.2999082804,
-0.6662421227,
-0.4120093584,
-0.1249283478,
-0.7485240102,
-0.4093803763,
-0.392585814,
0.6055324674,
-0.265842557,
-0.2872291803,
-0.1446051598,
-0.1804588437,
0.3782582283,
0.4353407621,
-1.0893368721,
0.1965681612,
0.9636210203,
0.6683833003,
-0.0732952803,
-0.4666665196,
-0.680195868,
-0.2666553259,
-0.1301497221,
0.4670600891,
-0.2930162549,
-0.1121344864,
0.1024000868,
-0.0273723416,
-0.163863495,
-0.6218476295,
0.520460844,
-0.4955459833,
-0.0572230145,
-0.6211236715,
-0.6748998761,
0.1053469554,
0.196415633,
-0.5728078485,
1.1569039822,
-0.1674812585,
-1.0026684999,
0.4821812809,
-0.48905316,
-0.7455064654,
-0.0734654814,
0.1746572703,
-0.682526648,
-0.1686438769,
0.4144346416,
0.6113374233,
-0.05370849,
0.0054427469,
-0.4057791829,
-0.5949876904,
-0.3109839261,
-0.1395241022,
0.8941190243,
0.2212579399,
-0.4646793604,
0.0204820614,
-0.499113977,
0.2691500485,
0.376170665,
-0.2847443521,
0.0511702523,
0.2070694119,
0.2708879709,
-0.193910405,
0.2976437807,
-0.4631572068,
0.248721689,
-0.2446593344,
0.2511199713,
0.9877562523,
-0.1821708977,
0.2633172572,
-0.3137048185,
0.0630483553,
-0.4274064898,
0.8356992602,
-0.145497337,
-0.1853846908,
-0.7268205285,
-0.6483913064,
0.4737716913,
0.4157158136,
-0.7078775167,
0.4673997164,
0.0364730731,
-0.5040845275,
-0.6018936038,
0.1990255862,
0.2314051539,
0.4098487794,
0.3863277733,
-0.2090707272,
-0.6756899357,
-0.8800271749,
-0.0431737676,
0.3387461007,
-0.0397123545,
0.2482077479,
0.3930377364,
-0.159419477,
0.6947034001,
-0.3282393217,
-0.2871088386,
-0.2699287534,
0.2069056034,
0.4638333619,
0.6608134508,
0.7958840728,
-0.7064042687,
-0.468165189,
-0.4479911029,
-0.5691732168,
0.1190594286,
-0.1233604625,
-0.338662982,
0.0512043945,
0.3716175258,
-0.5231791735,
0.1211300194,
0.3968427777,
0.0410010479,
0.4454977512,
-0.4909953773,
-0.0123339798,
-0.4526473582,
-0.2488639206,
-0.1672435403,
-0.2912103832,
-0.3788177371,
0.430260241,
-0.0698857158,
-0.1259657592,
-0.5437449813,
0.0602801517,
-0.3311842084,
-0.2223404646,
-0.3499155939,
-0.2028496712,
-0.2853344083,
0.4024249911,
-0.3017416298,
0.5345226526,
0.8009574413,
-0.3973717391,
0.550246954,
0.518016696,
-0.3141430318,
0.3334477842,
-0.794544518,
0.0966438055,
-0.4299351871,
0.5619924664,
-0.4984201491,
0.1797892749,
0.0718297362,
-0.1262600124,
0.4706973732,
-0.0312444866,
-0.7853767276,
-0.4724150598,
-0.35131374,
0.221067071,
0.5854309797,
-1.0301319361,
0.589897871,
0.0330109224,
0.1484057009,
-0.9090228081,
-0.4683198929,
-0.1658799499,
0.0921522453,
-0.7668919563,
0.3480186462,
-0.0902082473,
-0.2319936752,
-0.3252522349,
-0.2965997458,
-0.217364952,
0.2123066485,
0.0981117189,
0.0802066028,
0.1169130504,
0.1614044011,
-0.2694301903,
0.1137386635,
-0.1038288847,
-0.1427724361,
0.5237830281,
-0.1742607653,
-0.3162813187,
-0.3524038792,
0.5494627953,
0.5674521923,
-0.3944927454,
1.1549731493,
1.2231845856,
-0.162391901,
-0.4478724301,
-0.5884487033,
-0.4110309482,
-0.5240697861,
0.3634576201,
-0.0614934899,
-0.6466562152,
0.3534173965,
-0.1295844465,
0.4987225831,
0.2294179201,
0.6169978976,
-0.558906436,
0.7749827504,
0.8438392878,
-0.2907684743,
0.9338770509,
-0.4000095725,
0.2612608969,
-0.2532458603,
0.0713155717,
-0.3894388676,
-0.8343599439,
-0.4730685353,
-0.4981536865,
0.3133686185,
0.2040552795,
-0.5382259488,
0.084629409,
-0.6041728258,
0.5802758336,
0.7557346225,
0.2766020894,
-0.2541183829,
0.2193070054,
-0.0504977219,
0.1483642012,
-0.9125396609,
0.2820737958,
1.0680898428,
0.430673033,
0.6498596668,
-0.3667139709,
0.7643014193,
0.5399718285,
0.2153296173,
-0.4545106292,
0.5006940961,
-0.2549850941,
-0.7705382705,
-0.4447492063,
-0.6117011905,
-0.7208589911,
0.5167062283,
-0.6077489257,
-0.3350969851,
0.0308721066,
0.2335133851,
0.0078245765,
0.6494045854,
-0.8555215001,
0.7058362365,
-0.4148785174,
-0.4745913744,
-0.434186697,
-0.8648992181,
0.0448052697,
0.0175417736,
0.0870749578,
-0.2263413519,
0.5403698683,
0.6418806911,
-0.8202545047,
0.4838148355,
-0.8123640418,
0.0044206735,
0.1545668244,
-0.4169329405,
0.7704055309,
-0.2168097645,
0.0495179705,
0.3743353784,
-0.1199918836,
-0.8726551533,
-0.4356705546,
0.6033267975,
-0.8510172963,
-0.2708838582,
-0.3209190369,
-0.4304472804,
-0.1245296299,
0.0066736834,
0.1915458143,
0.2307395786,
-0.0939040706,
0.3265526295,
0.863943398,
-0.0399198607,
0.8009520769,
0.2661610842,
0.0576493964,
-0.3515415192,
0.695360899,
0.0156539138,
0.1139581949,
0.3672713041,
-0.1247331202,
0.0266494583,
-0.3040943146,
-0.1471566558,
0.1593167782,
-0.5464928746,
-0.0561891347,
-0.4259393215,
-0.1316354424,
-0.0903542042,
-0.3242187202,
-0.7359493971,
-0.3061566651,
0.0447559692,
0.1304997802,
0.2502732277,
0.2829256654,
-0.142201066,
0.6845298409,
-0.7364319563,
0.0783094391,
0.3508713841,
0.505058229,
0.5164144039,
0.0412400626,
-0.3832984567,
-0.0482179485,
-0.2901867628,
-0.2152707875,
0.0046477783,
0.3604440093,
0.5869861841,
0.5956237316,
0.1878547519,
0.7567928433,
-0.768735528,
0.2717305422,
0.4570623934,
-0.7706148624,
0.3511632681,
-0.1269696057,
0.0373383686,
0.4940384924,
0.3709804714,
-0.2324147373,
-0.1598263234,
-0.5225445032,
-1.1659361124,
0.5982820988,
0.401519984,
0.019441044,
0.3426973522,
0.270491451,
0.2501668632,
0.2051108778,
-0.3262200952,
-0.4406914115,
-0.0671294183,
-0.0390706733,
-0.0699680224,
-0.2557862997,
-0.3739134669,
-0.7914361954,
0.7181400061,
0.2347329706,
0.5343984962,
0.2647722363,
-0.0915488228,
-0.1557780206,
-0.1353686154,
0.418551892,
0.7337795496,
-0.6767790318,
-0.1747188866,
0.143291533,
-0.4592013657,
0.013899182,
0.467428863,
-0.0150956055,
0.1540977508,
0.6004034281,
0.7503470778,
0.164300397,
-0.5481495261,
0.6448571682,
-0.1412724257,
-0.5965443254,
-0.3850390613,
0.0316200815,
-0.0261939727,
0.6636235118,
0.546830833,
0.2005266547,
-0.3933692276,
-0.1031007245,
0.5049241781,
0.4677906036,
0.0341287404,
-0.0265025087,
0.6204727292,
0.4981901646,
-0.1059509441,
0.8827326894,
-0.0127173364,
-0.4858645797,
0.5845580697,
0.2098565847,
0.7724502683,
-0.2709145248,
0.0157249346,
0.3062516749,
0.3329520524,
-0.3588611186,
0.1833033115,
-0.4667255282,
-0.8105813861,
-0.6191298962,
-0.7104564309,
-0.595715344,
-0.2175922096,
-0.7707628012,
-0.0112386327,
-0.8538161516,
-0.3766915798,
0.1411225945,
0.0141782882,
-0.9456465244,
0.0564664602,
0.3493618071,
0.9769819975,
-0.6605929732,
0.6685606837,
0.5854336023,
0.0388287008,
-0.2849119306,
-0.0322150216,
-0.3761222959,
-0.940941453,
0.7666206956,
0.1022068486,
0.2315221131,
-0.0613736287,
-0.7976213098,
-0.8321165442,
0.9342438579,
0.2939399779,
-0.8989878297,
0.0064955009,
-0.0916513056,
0.1940784454,
-0.0149892094,
0.3968497515,
0.5525194407,
0.5395527482,
0.2653188109,
-0.9356603026,
-0.2325406671,
0.0355165787,
-0.0794779733,
0.3972576261,
-0.9127141237,
0.8959783316,
-0.2816282511,
0.2845000327,
-0.1888890117,
0.5115224123,
0.0671185851,
0.133637026,
0.8929686546,
1.0290179253,
0.7678710222,
-0.118053183,
0.7494416237,
-0.1571690291,
0.7785251141,
1.0447020531,
-0.4422590435,
0.8049591184,
0.4761016071,
-0.376616627,
0.2558197379,
0.655893445,
-0.5106368661,
0.7895766497,
0.2871974707,
-0.3264315426,
-0.3835853338,
0.119079724,
-0.5612105727,
0.1924920529,
-0.1927222311,
-0.3950621784,
-0.5945780277,
0.4113978446,
0.0292717088,
-0.5221278071,
-0.4731118977,
0.4028196931,
-0.1796482354,
-0.1278237104,
1.03010571,
-0.0927229896,
0.8224897981,
-0.5921969414,
0.0576701723,
-0.305988729,
0.6726850867,
-0.1642094404,
-0.3869379461,
0.0267346296,
0.0223928969,
-0.3077795506,
-0.8791038394,
0.7152047157,
-0.0430289544,
-0.5565571189,
0.4952510893,
0.321819365,
0.0924385488,
-0.2167508453,
-0.761392951,
0.1595561951,
0.0326613486,
-0.2979978919,
0.4320185781,
0.2252056301,
0.3208805323,
0.7715404034,
0.6638726592,
-0.1637245417,
0.1754122972,
0.2203389853,
0.9663457274,
-0.4816008508,
-0.3970831335,
-0.6699832678,
0.2278115153,
-0.09138304,
-0.0889361873,
0.5006442666,
0.3183282912,
1.0706646442,
-0.0124978758,
0.2864524126,
-0.1981996298,
0.4419167638,
-0.0642345771,
0.8237687349,
-0.6222129464,
-0.1124244109,
-0.2594365776,
-1.0444915295,
-0.0239830706,
0.4993507266,
-0.009553697,
-0.0237923041,
0.5281633139,
0.1926455051,
0.2243974805,
0.131066829,
-0.0748484731,
0.1873321086,
0.2884286344,
0.4125445783,
0.603220582,
-0.3525266647,
0.5732780099,
-0.5795106888,
-0.3564859331,
-0.356677115,
-0.7926324606,
-0.9240809083,
-0.255671382,
-0.1798756719,
0.0886500552,
0.1984080672,
0.9796761274,
0.9728370905,
-0.6458472013,
-0.0621294565,
-0.0563000329,
0.0228635315,
-0.7726652026,
-0.2060346901,
0.4157167077,
-0.5802693367,
-0.6449049711,
0.1588343531,
-0.1781203747,
-0.0762884989,
-0.0571743436,
0.1118121445,
-0.2474084944,
-0.2797760665,
0.6240662336,
0.1036394686,
-0.3197647035,
-0.2639837861,
-0.3568854034,
0.267675817,
0.0933373794,
0.9103899002,
-0.6555045247,
0.389665693,
0.4693064988,
1.0053889751,
0.955119729,
0.2382239699,
0.3453556299,
-1.0006141663,
0.4815403223,
0.3452374041,
0.3000126779,
0.184080869,
-0.2931002975,
0.3790409267,
0.3610745072,
-0.8008663058,
-0.9134786725,
-0.1240939796,
-0.7339684367,
-0.3862207532,
0.4787834287,
-0.2120257765,
-0.150583446,
0.486332655,
0.0821521133,
0.1357505769,
-0.215779528,
0.7222399712,
0.7570776343,
-0.3037616313,
-0.223648876,
-0.6854066253,
0.4452674389,
0.7502490282,
-0.4153239429,
0.1568520367,
0.174894467,
0.1827900708,
-0.1446876824,
0.3782123625,
0.2199535072,
-0.1222832724,
-0.0065912493,
0.4357818961,
-0.265396297,
-0.3630611897,
-0.0868551508,
0.153361246,
-0.3115421534,
-0.671929121
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02446v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02446v3
|
LQER: Low-Rank Quantization Error Reconstruction for LLMs
| 2024-02-04T10:59:52 | 2024-05-30T09:49:47 |
Cheng Zhang, Jianyi Cheng, George A. Constantinides, Yiren Zhao
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Post-training quantization of Large Language Models (LLMs) is challenging. In
this work, we introduce Low-rank Quantization Error Reduction (LQER), which
combines quantization and low-rank approximation to recover the model
capability. LQER leverages an activation-induced scale matrix to drive the
singular value distribution of quantization error towards a desirable
distribution, which enables nearly-lossless W4A8 quantization on various LLMs
and downstream tasks without the need for knowledge distillation, grid search,
or gradient-base iterative optimization. Unlike existing methods, the
computation pattern of LQER eliminates the need for specialized Scatter and
Gather processes to collect high-precision weights from irregular memory
locations. Our W4A8 LLMs achieve near-lossless performance on six popular
downstream tasks, while using 1.36$\times$ fewer hardware resources than the
leading state-of-the-art method. We open-source our framework at
https://github.com/ChengZhang-98/lqer
|
[
0.0219025891,
-0.3434742987,
0.4888192415,
-0.0765921026,
-0.1142177582,
0.2502062321,
-0.2628102601,
0.1222332716,
-0.0008613055,
0.3746094108,
-0.3865353763,
-0.4267956018,
-0.6011349559,
-0.0890879184,
-0.2947990298,
0.7389503717,
0.0149328765,
0.1528605819,
0.010579899,
-0.05375937,
0.0118810777,
-0.5445973873,
-0.9157732725,
0.0096900361,
0.7140910625,
0.29600209,
0.3544663489,
0.3834549785,
0.3690915406,
0.2542498112,
-0.140506655,
-0.0178564452,
-1.0268137455,
-0.046142552,
0.2791461349,
-0.5393260717,
-0.9242159724,
-0.2919144332,
1.026602149,
0.6382279992,
-0.1631233394,
0.1879246384,
0.0556305572,
0.8545929193,
-0.9176066518,
0.1804712117,
-0.4657638669,
0.0043794136,
-0.149416551,
-0.0598582253,
-0.4228335321,
-0.4337891936,
-0.3845377564,
-0.5352418423,
0.0182231106,
0.0242569838,
0.563241601,
0.5548436642,
-0.4823059738,
0.4013645947,
-0.906075418,
1.0267490149,
-1.0302803516,
0.438206017,
0.2753122747,
0.2600498497,
-0.1419059932,
-0.8905928135,
-0.5968711972,
0.3347707689,
0.0728041455,
0.0420677066,
-0.4311028719,
0.402439177,
0.3573153913,
0.6788247824,
-0.4325309992,
0.1710534692,
-0.5132023096,
-0.3430057168,
0.3838174045,
-0.0105790189,
-0.0953027382,
0.0554647781,
0.1304606795,
-0.1754616797,
-0.9292728305,
0.2859222591,
0.057776168,
0.1195685491,
0.0567334555,
0.2603044212,
-0.3940330446,
0.5065597296,
0.0476456322,
-0.4539122283,
0.1781959087,
-0.1880194098,
-0.3098045886,
-0.0296187084,
0.8120370507,
0.1889001578,
-0.1657125056,
-0.1709953994,
-0.4618759155,
-0.1196838841,
-0.0350838676,
-1.1406728029,
-0.2001752853,
0.2241874635,
-0.5074491501,
-0.1291397363,
-0.3933882713,
-0.3848928809,
-0.3497323394,
0.006278818,
0.5478177667,
-0.1677746773,
-0.1224288642,
-0.073052384,
0.1254744083,
0.4393047988,
0.3935298324,
-0.5968145728,
0.1948387772,
0.4224436581,
0.6283391714,
-0.0635527894,
0.0340891108,
-0.9512519836,
0.1449162215,
-0.3914838135,
0.5032787919,
0.0374596156,
-0.1237759739,
-0.1791451275,
0.0233274363,
0.0008526365,
-0.4541758299,
0.5095586777,
-0.7421174645,
-0.0337974578,
-0.0534411669,
-0.4856997132,
-0.0999491662,
0.2056091279,
-0.81124717,
1.0187548399,
0.3429378271,
-0.6293852925,
0.1256488264,
-0.4238398373,
-0.0048830663,
0.1307475269,
0.0024882427,
-0.6169425249,
0.3648042977,
0.1345386803,
0.2887978554,
-0.3353590667,
0.0328167118,
-0.2646130919,
-0.7689844966,
-0.0477821492,
-0.50077039,
0.4820669293,
-0.192517072,
-0.4568352401,
0.3364161551,
-1.0700479746,
0.2871025503,
0.101136528,
-0.5138601661,
-0.3808574677,
0.1167066246,
-0.0942261517,
0.1280526668,
0.4436734617,
-0.465241164,
0.2320709527,
-0.4303395152,
0.6136036515,
0.5914617181,
-0.1560682356,
0.6955530643,
-0.0504798219,
0.6077962518,
-0.1014296189,
0.1777157933,
0.2155952305,
-0.0957553089,
-0.9578505158,
-0.5355103612,
0.5098418593,
0.4946474731,
-0.954325676,
0.308573842,
-0.8430029154,
-0.3889208734,
-0.7925260663,
0.1527477056,
0.5155946612,
0.0730491132,
0.2735543251,
-0.0875152424,
-0.4963465929,
-0.9243713617,
0.0226160157,
0.0261623859,
-0.3346655965,
-0.1407283843,
0.1417138875,
-0.3263100982,
0.7298098207,
-0.3231661618,
-0.4277355969,
-0.1969093233,
-0.084593311,
0.2285595238,
0.5598550439,
0.1628599465,
-0.4194734693,
-0.2934906185,
-0.0944126099,
-0.4830697477,
0.1357396543,
0.274284035,
-0.2177046835,
0.291873306,
0.7532174587,
-0.4772573113,
0.4226082265,
0.9551277757,
-0.0028003852,
0.1094164848,
-0.1099385396,
0.2486324906,
-1.0953434706,
-0.0041917255,
-0.2936736643,
-0.3688469231,
-0.6140219569,
-0.0955383778,
0.1152530164,
0.0534170717,
-0.3530195057,
0.3589344621,
-0.4875210524,
-0.224597916,
-0.2562327087,
-0.0149058485,
0.1127142608,
0.6280454993,
-0.2916021943,
0.904994905,
0.3230024278,
-0.3322101533,
0.0899239704,
0.0093475757,
-0.1875617951,
0.4295399487,
-0.5493324399,
0.1823537797,
-0.28221187,
0.2992950976,
-0.9903812408,
-0.0887034908,
0.1790825278,
-0.4298999906,
0.1767067909,
-0.4993882775,
-0.4902523756,
-0.0705270469,
-0.5934351683,
0.7018834352,
0.8221829534,
-0.3382723629,
0.7799749374,
0.3149295151,
-0.1475867778,
-0.4909392595,
-0.5799936652,
-0.1444869339,
-0.1451910883,
-0.1558218747,
0.1703918129,
-0.0919807404,
-0.0784509853,
-0.2606538534,
-0.09407603,
-0.0685510114,
0.0378982872,
0.1967251748,
-0.0160540286,
-0.3872231543,
0.0115223369,
0.1868972927,
-0.0671849325,
0.0156806149,
-0.168874681,
0.4022683501,
-0.1624063104,
-0.2408969849,
-0.4050504565,
0.0853183419,
0.6588634253,
-0.1513358504,
0.7965964079,
0.6071594357,
-0.6241160631,
-0.2182538658,
-0.3181120157,
-0.143455416,
-0.4717493057,
0.5188578963,
-0.3598963916,
-1.0890029669,
0.2187274545,
-0.1039738208,
0.0861163586,
0.3422241807,
0.3359876573,
-0.2243910879,
1.0445455313,
0.5589291453,
-0.2267230004,
0.3966926038,
-0.4124900103,
0.5512821078,
-0.8552502394,
0.2582900822,
-0.2681743801,
-0.4563245177,
-0.5377042294,
-0.6097733378,
0.6300313473,
0.3476826847,
-0.389793396,
-0.1035709828,
-0.2855602205,
0.3222240508,
0.6513131261,
-0.0107951621,
0.5140134096,
0.1788174659,
0.5618516207,
-0.3588165045,
-0.8476253748,
-0.2371821851,
0.9344500899,
0.2595964074,
0.6298110485,
0.1413092017,
0.9841498733,
0.0763946772,
0.4649195373,
-1.1976013184,
0.5316541791,
-0.1540145129,
0.0943543762,
-0.6514865756,
-0.7778903246,
-0.881837666,
0.4466795921,
-0.1876751333,
-0.4589595199,
0.0278384332,
0.4279935062,
-0.5677877069,
0.504301846,
-0.3932864964,
0.7516229153,
0.1576903611,
-0.3005412817,
-0.117686756,
-0.3761598468,
0.6921400428,
-0.1920638978,
0.5552680492,
0.0217693746,
-0.0482372791,
0.8817999363,
-0.5612194538,
0.7784616947,
-0.3121872544,
-0.5523165464,
0.0350913033,
0.0982455686,
0.7917839885,
-0.2580290735,
0.0656872317,
0.0416955315,
0.188626349,
-0.4781983793,
-0.6181161404,
0.6982499361,
-0.6933618188,
-0.3461887538,
-0.2964616716,
-0.5846853852,
-0.3367376924,
0.2257642299,
0.099488765,
0.3515378833,
-0.0465182066,
0.4027002454,
0.6341836452,
-0.0242318865,
0.5341460109,
0.3647535443,
-0.0084508695,
-0.7619430423,
1.1246912479,
0.1180212274,
0.2344346941,
0.4787245393,
-0.0864627734,
-0.1283547431,
-0.9521705508,
-0.3336344361,
0.3006852269,
-0.6534881592,
-0.6095861197,
-0.4762522876,
-0.2982601821,
-0.1677489728,
0.0221607387,
-0.7753786445,
-0.5720203519,
-0.1645254493,
0.1133166924,
0.3466486335,
0.4019281268,
0.1005679443,
0.7604767084,
-1.0733966827,
0.1912274957,
0.2565838695,
0.180095762,
0.0079583274,
-0.7159157991,
-0.6549935937,
0.090863511,
-0.0539750978,
-0.3033633232,
0.4710904956,
0.3731052279,
0.0942331702,
0.2099354714,
0.2771035433,
0.7542341352,
-0.4723599851,
0.6442458034,
0.0567183681,
-1.0943287611,
0.2447802573,
-0.122362718,
0.3994342089,
0.6044371128,
0.0830296054,
-0.3211696744,
-0.4411666095,
-0.4187119305,
-1.2025545835,
0.5546492934,
0.2899053991,
-0.132678777,
0.3695513308,
0.497767508,
-0.3540378511,
0.2914963365,
-1.0135581493,
-0.3154686689,
0.108496286,
-0.3940038085,
-0.2285274714,
-0.3644444644,
-0.1396919787,
-0.1832348704,
0.8149828315,
-0.4324351549,
0.1125359312,
-0.1024656296,
-0.4440395236,
-0.3116514087,
0.4128704071,
0.4709127545,
0.4972472787,
-0.2732838392,
0.4090916812,
0.2153852135,
-0.3563622832,
0.2328894883,
0.1643605828,
-0.2657073736,
-0.104777649,
0.2673431337,
0.8424190283,
0.709266901,
-0.6599940062,
0.6684190035,
-0.2270845473,
-0.2014154792,
-0.4406966865,
-0.1497727185,
0.1630558074,
0.3905890882,
0.5914268494,
-0.1194194034,
0.3843187988,
-0.0539942011,
-0.0220556278,
0.4366801977,
-0.1491267383,
-0.4250024557,
0.6564481854,
0.0346451364,
0.1065321639,
0.344604671,
-0.4192672074,
-0.3677214086,
0.2106253803,
0.2103415132,
0.5925678015,
-0.2182162404,
-0.0795028061,
0.5813025236,
0.2249742299,
-0.2916213274,
0.2330459654,
0.0395982116,
-0.6106803417,
-0.87508744,
-0.7132877707,
-0.3951500654,
0.3326019645,
-0.71040833,
0.1389300078,
-0.4500951171,
0.0179813299,
-0.4345487356,
-0.2023906112,
-0.3450096846,
0.0996455029,
0.0850808173,
0.3676123321,
-0.3310935199,
0.9539785385,
0.4028289914,
-0.1797521561,
-0.8368015289,
-0.0123387175,
-0.316370368,
-0.755843699,
0.6294953823,
-0.1094081402,
-0.2252172828,
0.755546391,
-0.4539338946,
-1.0836257935,
1.360503912,
0.4908704162,
-0.8325875401,
-0.3093366623,
0.024216244,
0.3024207354,
0.1159780696,
0.2819046676,
0.6853109002,
0.2498421818,
-0.0048344615,
-1.014657855,
0.2152852714,
0.058953397,
0.2759334743,
0.3994702697,
-0.5340789557,
0.8204317689,
-0.056736853,
-0.1382168084,
0.0434141383,
0.7777253389,
0.5540668368,
-0.037067011,
0.5970932841,
0.4843411744,
0.6041917205,
-0.000770689,
0.6988146901,
-0.3811610043,
0.5474122763,
0.8268030286,
-0.0776536092,
1.198315382,
0.7694553733,
-0.3997359574,
0.2813040018,
0.3669079542,
0.4129112661,
0.580794096,
0.3841477036,
-0.4072851837,
-0.1811752617,
0.2435097396,
-0.2411708832,
0.2700308859,
0.2873351276,
-0.0163476672,
-0.1690333188,
0.0104036508,
0.1248862818,
-0.3520588577,
-0.6745464206,
0.7243611217,
0.1488714516,
-0.2533370852,
1.2920180559,
-0.0012802661,
0.9887933135,
-0.4267853498,
-0.1752382219,
-0.4497590959,
0.4560161829,
-0.1922172606,
-0.0281649418,
0.1209173128,
-0.3675587475,
-0.3246612549,
-0.2499337345,
0.6279551983,
-0.631912291,
-0.43748191,
0.1815422177,
0.6380063891,
0.0791226402,
-0.3088566363,
-0.2497169226,
0.415831238,
0.0304882247,
-0.5024743676,
0.5665684938,
0.3934786618,
-0.1331358552,
0.5202507377,
0.4208247364,
0.1504116356,
0.1523455679,
0.1036291569,
0.8288061023,
-0.6950637102,
-0.2322669327,
-0.4621333778,
0.6871792078,
0.1737107188,
0.1955779195,
0.3829878867,
0.5471337438,
0.7472619414,
-0.288085252,
0.9065122008,
0.0911930129,
0.5512877703,
-0.6169681549,
0.7802873254,
-0.6662424803,
0.3200590014,
0.0860650688,
-0.9071494937,
-0.3824321628,
0.6413401365,
-0.1630337834,
-0.0983396992,
0.6565081477,
0.8851645589,
-0.0388020277,
-0.6571407318,
0.7130364776,
0.3409110904,
0.2427958995,
0.800981462,
0.7773644328,
-1.0176210403,
0.7983863354,
-0.1879152805,
-0.3967902064,
-0.2703320682,
-0.6597337723,
-0.5683729053,
-0.4628206193,
-0.4390493929,
-0.5649785399,
-0.0893621072,
0.8406708837,
0.6317721009,
-0.813983798,
-0.208748579,
-0.0988028497,
0.105104208,
-0.06819015,
-0.2775987089,
0.3997312486,
-0.3104366362,
-1.0520722866,
0.5013096929,
0.0989627764,
0.0281041618,
-0.2768121064,
-0.3678227961,
0.3668934405,
-0.188709259,
0.8272684813,
0.3740858734,
-0.6112084985,
-0.1416625381,
-0.1163707078,
-0.2911158204,
0.1758545339,
0.8230522275,
-0.7829967737,
-0.0538029596,
0.2941735089,
0.7284507751,
0.517708838,
-0.278378427,
0.5471420288,
-0.771689713,
0.2902436554,
0.3130911589,
0.4670047462,
0.3105077147,
-0.2789668143,
0.3041940033,
0.3560524285,
-0.472168237,
-1.1779614687,
0.0832325593,
-1.1108721495,
0.1118710712,
1.1546330452,
-0.1593738645,
-0.3703860044,
0.1996641755,
-0.1753593981,
0.1867549568,
-0.370223999,
0.497509867,
0.3393014371,
0.0924474075,
-0.8561275601,
-0.4828824997,
0.8394288421,
0.2938938439,
-0.8172225952,
-0.0415293984,
0.6792757511,
0.3968542516,
-0.1372312903,
0.9644933939,
0.000018765,
0.2742831409,
-0.1583088189,
0.7224300504,
0.1475144774,
0.178805694,
-0.4601055086,
0.1818287522,
0.5346517563,
-0.1868511885
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02420v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02420v2
|
Factuality of Large Language Models in the Year 2024
| 2024-02-04T09:36:31 | 2024-02-09T06:36:41 |
Yuxia Wang, Minghan Wang, Muhammad Arslan Manzoor, Fei Liu, Georgi Georgiev, Rocktim Jyoti Das, Preslav Nakov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs), especially when instruction-tuned for chat,
have become part of our daily lives, freeing people from the process of
searching, extracting, and integrating information from multiple sources by
offering a straightforward answer to a variety of questions in a single place.
Unfortunately, in many cases, LLM responses are factually incorrect, which
limits their applicability in real-world scenarios. As a result, research on
evaluating and improving the factuality of LLMs has attracted a lot of research
attention recently. In this survey, we critically analyze existing work with
the aim to identify the major challenges and their associated causes, pointing
out to potential solutions for improving the factuality of LLMs, and analyzing
the obstacles to automated factuality evaluation for open-ended text
generation. We further offer an outlook on where future research should go.
|
[
-0.2396435142,
-0.9843807817,
0.8925437927,
0.0704856142,
-0.0144057665,
0.0069214301,
-0.4711583257,
-0.6284081936,
-0.0982608348,
0.6895608306,
-0.5146508813,
-0.284529984,
-0.7145652771,
0.2935524583,
-0.417732805,
0.9008288383,
-0.0628099144,
-0.0904342309,
-0.5699782372,
-0.281437099,
-0.6381886601,
-0.7277165055,
-0.4430634975,
-0.0438990816,
0.5853369832,
0.4159365892,
0.6746554375,
0.5227788687,
0.6745461822,
0.4604344666,
0.006593335,
0.3184003532,
-0.675799191,
0.0635887459,
-0.1026782766,
-0.5067210793,
-0.4972753227,
0.1419974566,
0.9056659937,
0.8559359908,
0.0193926431,
0.1918451041,
-0.1074422225,
0.5821936131,
-0.3963980079,
0.2760936618,
-0.6834884882,
-0.0394544899,
-0.2242219746,
-0.1719043553,
-0.5548348427,
-0.7202124596,
0.271609962,
-0.2010802776,
0.1248934567,
0.2831400633,
0.8403010964,
0.2369007468,
-0.612506032,
-0.7249147296,
-1.0256377459,
0.9120855927,
-1.1056445837,
0.5629533529,
0.1728440672,
0.2834528387,
-0.4099547863,
-0.5893356204,
-0.55462569,
-0.3947274983,
0.132858783,
-0.2048760951,
-0.1022964641,
-0.1123494357,
0.1935279816,
0.2821955383,
-0.3394781053,
0.2801887989,
-0.3904826045,
-0.289916724,
0.7257151604,
0.387231946,
0.3479275107,
0.0252622366,
-0.1976650953,
0.3239223361,
-0.7769559026,
-0.2661085427,
0.4889902472,
0.2094234973,
-0.0865671337,
0.7568185925,
-0.0865008235,
0.5068627,
-0.1598164588,
-0.4199493229,
0.0845524445,
-0.4664814174,
-0.1625509858,
-0.1170311719,
0.7128825188,
0.4135613143,
0.1756795347,
-0.0827805772,
-0.1142083183,
-0.0889300704,
0.0961919352,
-0.8524311781,
0.0706762969,
0.4899383187,
-0.1275702715,
-0.2696335912,
-0.1655176431,
-0.7597584724,
-0.4835312068,
-0.3144291639,
0.1572774947,
-0.2034643441,
-0.2199009657,
0.2411298156,
0.3231673539,
0.1844258755,
0.7676539421,
-0.7557913661,
0.1380338222,
0.7285534143,
0.617978394,
-0.1755198985,
0.0460474789,
-0.3435258865,
-0.0548933484,
-0.5788837075,
0.8054602146,
-0.3607387543,
-0.3212135434,
0.1419802308,
0.0670782328,
-0.1582969725,
-0.5539925098,
0.7034458518,
-0.538654983,
0.5622739196,
-0.5220407248,
-0.7598019242,
-0.0213324483,
0.6528986096,
-0.6527216434,
0.6900200844,
-0.3182108402,
-0.8624740839,
0.0358621553,
-0.5028007627,
-0.0562011003,
0.0459084101,
-0.217964977,
-0.4396941066,
0.0670752078,
-0.1058318838,
0.3255988657,
-0.4558334351,
0.7715434432,
-0.3254800737,
-0.1656061411,
0.5887103081,
-0.9131382704,
0.6980761886,
0.1303167343,
-0.2545180619,
0.0732826367,
-0.8970564008,
-0.1639501303,
0.1540142894,
-0.6167108417,
0.112601839,
0.3073611557,
-0.2208916694,
0.2665526271,
0.4677141905,
-0.8036367297,
0.0899022743,
-0.4933631718,
0.3448095024,
0.7313675284,
-0.0895752162,
0.2448758036,
-0.3801544905,
0.4580523372,
-0.0825588778,
0.1431961507,
-0.1874417365,
-0.5694342256,
-0.9208675623,
-0.2168266922,
0.3189400434,
0.6300711632,
-0.5168074965,
0.4411610365,
-0.3102068603,
-0.5115423799,
-0.1979653686,
0.0410420746,
0.1602542549,
0.6328106523,
-0.0720385909,
-0.0193867087,
-0.6984653473,
-0.872271359,
-0.1557811052,
-0.3104628623,
0.3051609993,
0.3195136189,
0.5679733753,
-0.3975600302,
1.0068515539,
-0.3791552782,
0.1621962041,
-0.2314817607,
0.0286976974,
0.0464205854,
0.2785285413,
0.2578380406,
-0.7845956683,
-0.1749415994,
-0.1421127766,
-0.9071522355,
0.038922593,
0.0964177251,
0.2840032578,
0.6652656198,
0.5380957723,
-0.8716369867,
0.2735056281,
0.7567768693,
-0.1989496946,
0.8621228933,
-0.3368342221,
0.301187098,
-0.8254223466,
0.0739962384,
-0.0830649659,
-0.1288638562,
-0.5819387436,
-0.0434078798,
-0.0593613908,
-0.1319341362,
-0.3316532969,
0.5551617742,
-0.4691592455,
-0.0138218608,
-0.3186695278,
0.3976745605,
-0.2628892958,
0.1176497191,
-0.39451015,
0.7165964246,
0.1674003452,
-0.5085053444,
0.6916469336,
0.2183441073,
-0.6364337802,
0.1846902221,
-0.6005831361,
0.1206214502,
-0.2276768088,
0.7109413743,
-1.0345112085,
-0.5784091353,
0.2928642333,
-0.4547221959,
0.2561936677,
0.1136895642,
-0.6226283312,
-0.4515571892,
-0.1964819729,
0.2349682301,
0.4804751873,
-0.4297319353,
0.4730476737,
0.1855258048,
-0.292627871,
-0.7434543371,
-0.4203814268,
0.5334029794,
-0.1104280725,
-0.8915470243,
-0.2547957897,
-0.3325794935,
-0.6272476315,
-0.0356288441,
0.0024423494,
0.1218717545,
0.1395413727,
0.034200158,
0.51216048,
-0.3689979911,
0.2095976025,
-0.4535942376,
0.1206788942,
0.3108333647,
-0.1898667514,
0.4395751059,
-0.2391362339,
-0.5225219131,
-0.2643923461,
0.0604770184,
0.552706778,
-0.3148560226,
0.8974823356,
0.3340294063,
-0.2629961669,
-0.0957315043,
-0.9371762276,
0.0265636723,
-0.5052591562,
0.4862752855,
0.1108412743,
-1.3542010784,
0.3703986108,
-0.1679408103,
0.3611630499,
0.2576512396,
0.8239338994,
-0.0712500587,
0.9951021671,
0.6054208875,
0.3561922014,
0.0358682722,
0.2437488288,
0.6588407755,
-0.4826136529,
-0.487757355,
-0.6761949062,
0.0385520682,
-0.9239984751,
-0.5159554482,
0.3705934584,
-0.4006602168,
0.0814383626,
-0.0840655789,
0.060436368,
0.2892945707,
0.1698396504,
-0.2125145495,
0.3634886444,
-0.2654908597,
-0.0417167917,
-0.112090908,
-0.5797790885,
-0.8742194772,
1.0962438583,
0.5656388402,
0.5043623447,
0.1755789667,
0.4438633621,
0.084766686,
0.3116796017,
-0.8048169613,
0.6972700953,
0.059186738,
-1.0521697998,
-0.4876196384,
-0.5735562444,
-0.7337183952,
0.1740602255,
-0.3458783031,
-0.6925315857,
-0.03927432,
0.3343845904,
-0.157135576,
0.45583269,
-0.5441147089,
0.6634742022,
-0.2767476141,
-0.4131644368,
0.0191320088,
-0.7146648169,
0.8302105069,
-0.404837817,
0.7444415092,
-0.4249028862,
-0.0207119323,
0.5285110474,
-0.4783792794,
0.9757656455,
-0.0044746799,
-0.7359377146,
0.419986546,
-0.1789627522,
0.6355541945,
-0.1171760857,
0.0003375337,
-0.066216141,
0.0465797968,
-0.3414894044,
-0.5763831139,
0.7830950022,
-0.5367809534,
-0.8741623163,
-0.4626121521,
-0.6304303408,
-0.5666748285,
-0.0135614378,
0.1255044937,
0.7704820037,
-0.4998401999,
0.2748720646,
1.0690076351,
-0.6084821224,
0.370903641,
0.5526756048,
-0.544108808,
-0.2849593759,
1.0975857973,
0.2994460166,
0.2162605375,
0.1656396538,
0.2501815259,
-0.2472485602,
-0.647802949,
-0.5655905008,
0.5156618357,
-0.7239723206,
0.1173599064,
-0.7430736423,
-0.1686249971,
-0.5571227074,
0.1526208371,
-0.5786831975,
-0.265804261,
-0.332713455,
-0.0208712071,
0.0105447806,
0.9622059464,
-0.0023929866,
0.0630917102,
-1.0435190201,
0.1662623137,
0.2807385325,
0.3128725886,
-0.0058226287,
-0.8073877096,
-0.354580164,
-0.0102173453,
-0.1954525858,
-0.4308636785,
0.2122574449,
-0.0561331101,
0.3235105574,
0.277423054,
0.0092237368,
0.329059571,
-0.9512217045,
0.8416526914,
0.1252612472,
-0.7190062404,
0.2043080777,
-0.4393094182,
0.1593994498,
0.2287345827,
0.579200685,
-0.6341537237,
-0.2914116979,
-0.5855013132,
-0.6856723428,
0.5652630329,
0.1941855848,
0.4032650888,
0.0605041422,
0.2284343988,
0.1505561322,
0.2460639775,
-0.4788308442,
-0.0615336001,
0.1121459454,
-0.3701075613,
-0.0714327097,
-0.5403080583,
0.0206807777,
-0.1453401148,
0.7254390717,
-0.0733939633,
0.248783201,
-0.1352762431,
0.2402469367,
-0.3883354366,
0.5898687243,
0.8218322992,
1.1167780161,
-0.2851600647,
0.0622900836,
0.3495658934,
-0.3024968505,
0.1303003728,
-0.089951098,
-0.147002399,
-0.0577663444,
0.6071069241,
0.799018681,
0.3813948035,
-1.0724049807,
0.6299316287,
-0.0108421147,
-0.2197148949,
-0.5535089374,
0.0973836333,
0.3699171543,
0.2019742876,
0.2564696372,
-0.0565730706,
-0.091876559,
-0.9268788099,
-0.1605925113,
0.4752374589,
-0.3084240556,
-0.4369394779,
0.4704443812,
0.3191373646,
-0.2177733928,
0.4506655931,
0.0584772788,
-0.5549201965,
0.4870612919,
0.5896677375,
0.6172286868,
-0.061298877,
0.0149342427,
0.3191463947,
0.5777148604,
-0.1668959707,
0.1519677937,
0.4874693751,
-0.8970907331,
-0.7226184607,
-0.6580970883,
-0.7921385765,
0.3576692641,
-0.2050893158,
0.3600883484,
-0.4697350562,
-0.0464658216,
-0.1559631675,
0.0144824032,
-0.4136570096,
0.523229897,
0.3311719894,
0.8119131327,
-0.6172536016,
0.7114675045,
0.6242401004,
-0.1732115746,
-0.5414089561,
-0.0909787267,
0.2316974103,
-0.6279343367,
0.5845571756,
-0.0014395766,
-0.25646469,
-0.1916926354,
-1.2968759537,
-0.9283510447,
0.8257921338,
0.4778215289,
-0.733810246,
-0.4639937282,
0.3250207007,
0.5617716312,
-0.2086283416,
0.0769745037,
0.6498437524,
0.6407930255,
0.204832986,
-0.9185823202,
-0.1565784663,
-0.020815298,
-0.0489391871,
0.0826007575,
-0.8383255005,
0.7745016217,
-0.1654854715,
-0.3539394736,
0.153128624,
0.8906699419,
0.279884249,
0.3147512972,
0.4025511444,
0.3709132671,
0.7904192209,
-0.0726389289,
0.8822988272,
-0.0016177426,
0.2277905494,
1.0224769115,
-0.4871110022,
0.7430104613,
0.1815560311,
-0.2777683735,
0.2856259048,
0.4116146564,
-0.0084979879,
-0.1494018734,
0.0778105333,
-0.4469825029,
-0.3298896849,
-0.0459050648,
-0.2317877859,
0.5373507142,
0.4885510206,
-0.032391008,
-0.1924016178,
-0.030201925,
0.4058964252,
0.2813647389,
0.0743074343,
0.5969791412,
0.0110788736,
-0.6132403016,
0.4725874066,
0.2341684699,
0.7248087525,
-0.5184264779,
-0.0941574499,
-0.248299554,
-0.0229626354,
-0.2127245814,
-0.5501691699,
0.2694882154,
0.4441246092,
-0.0557508171,
0.098340638,
0.7292478681,
-0.3812651038,
-0.4454380572,
0.014502543,
0.4312612414,
0.2505068183,
0.2528227866,
-0.4211589098,
0.6907320619,
0.1148308069,
-0.159463495,
0.2580037713,
0.7936109304,
0.1032005996,
0.916757822,
0.4597552717,
0.1291333288,
0.3247696459,
-0.3086716831,
0.7652088404,
-0.6946449876,
0.0013576312,
-0.7801706195,
0.3711099625,
0.0102867857,
-0.2954045236,
1.0483570099,
0.4884503484,
0.6015105844,
0.0698825642,
0.9963654876,
-0.0369800813,
0.832223475,
-0.5667960644,
0.6432954669,
-0.379162997,
0.4155583084,
-0.1148622558,
-0.9204705954,
-0.1431404948,
0.0242499691,
-0.4076402187,
0.1400996298,
0.6658482552,
0.61418432,
0.13499479,
0.2956546843,
0.5233469009,
0.4938445985,
0.4882101119,
0.1840384901,
1.0788023472,
-0.3165171444,
0.5657401085,
-0.0212350413,
-0.1648149639,
-0.5442041159,
-1.0480936766,
-0.7477737665,
-0.495536387,
-0.3989806473,
-0.3123624921,
0.0634717047,
1.0430604219,
0.150377214,
-0.9028053284,
-0.2841582,
0.172077924,
0.0665210932,
0.6670449972,
-0.1463680863,
0.211315155,
-0.454346627,
-0.8588399291,
0.4791715741,
0.316306591,
-0.0166634154,
-0.4274772704,
0.0555122867,
-0.3067097366,
0.5604394674,
0.8648716211,
0.4254727662,
-0.7427173853,
-0.6757280827,
-0.1464161277,
-0.2530576587,
-0.014066997,
0.6269442439,
-0.357634753,
0.3466500938,
0.3176915944,
0.8444482684,
0.0711211041,
-0.0787027404,
0.5784451365,
-0.3820929825,
-0.1448215544,
0.1864046007,
0.2659746706,
0.6837550998,
-0.0638738647,
0.3052005172,
0.5206044912,
-0.8691760898,
-1.030725956,
0.2225302011,
-0.8103496432,
-0.1228865534,
1.2622184753,
-0.0652971715,
-0.3945582807,
-0.2283540666,
-0.2064078748,
0.235709399,
0.0344481207,
0.6452925205,
1.0577965975,
-0.088480413,
0.0075862873,
-0.9586538076,
0.3435507715,
0.2040846199,
-0.9990200996,
0.3525514603,
0.9658635855,
0.405536145,
-0.0156964213,
0.4636844099,
-0.1927976757,
0.0691220313,
-0.0728468299,
-0.0070284139,
0.1925506592,
-0.4408243001,
-0.1866811812,
0.0982734337,
0.4270122349,
0.2821995616
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02416v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02416v4
|
Aligner: Efficient Alignment by Learning to Correct
| 2024-02-04T09:24:51 | 2024-06-24T18:55:16 |
Jiaming Ji, Boyuan Chen, Hantao Lou, Donghai Hong, Borong Zhang, Xuehai Pan, Juntao Dai, Tianyi Qiu, Yaodong Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
With the rapid development of large language models (LLMs) and ever-evolving
practical requirements, finding an efficient and effective alignment method has
never been more critical. However, the tension between the complexity of
current alignment methods and the need for rapid iteration in deployment
scenarios necessitates the development of a model-agnostic alignment approach
that can operate under these constraints. In this paper, we introduce Aligner,
a novel and simple alignment paradigm that learns the correctional residuals
between preferred and dispreferred answers using a small model. Designed as a
model-agnostic, plug-and-play module, Aligner can be directly applied to
various open-source and API-based models with only one-off training, making it
suitable for rapid iteration. Notably, Aligner can be applied to any powerful,
large-scale upstream models. Moreover, it can even iteratively bootstrap the
upstream models using corrected responses as synthetic human preference data,
breaking through the model's performance ceiling. Our experiments demonstrate
performance improvements by deploying the same Aligner model across 11
different LLMs, evaluated on the 3H dimensions (helpfulness, harmlessness, and
honesty). Specifically, Aligner-7B has achieved an average improvement of 68.9%
in helpfulness and 23.8% in harmlessness across the tested LLMs while also
effectively reducing hallucination. In the Alpaca-Eval leaderboard, stacking
Aligner-2B on GPT-4 Turbo improved its LC Win Rate from 55.0% to 58.3%,
surpassing GPT-4 Omni's 57.5% Win Rate (community report).
|
[
-0.1847674102,
-0.3769923449,
0.6366257668,
-0.2172237784,
-0.0103584528,
0.2374304384,
-0.1598751843,
-0.2630880773,
-0.0005881725,
0.1608560234,
-0.5135389566,
-0.2002387047,
-0.5070735216,
-0.1427552551,
-0.3027154207,
0.8649252057,
-0.0104037458,
0.2215837389,
-0.0495462567,
-0.4445290267,
-0.6677219272,
-0.0891984329,
-0.5690686703,
-0.4905424118,
0.7705549598,
0.4309234321,
0.8850177526,
1.167783618,
0.6816927195,
0.3161657751,
0.1230917349,
-0.0388190858,
-0.5920122266,
-0.0872656852,
-0.4682548046,
-0.5387008786,
-0.2590173781,
-0.1061710492,
0.4861833751,
0.3885130286,
-0.6367921233,
0.3493811786,
-0.0336494111,
0.7740572691,
-0.7403923273,
-0.2036377937,
-0.857494235,
-0.314971,
-0.1698551625,
0.3574849963,
-0.4403817952,
-0.5150282979,
0.0502267592,
-0.7027488947,
0.0741732717,
0.0962880701,
1.0001517534,
0.6527180672,
-0.2298147678,
-0.2712188363,
-0.7436398268,
0.7956614494,
-0.6913540959,
0.6302704811,
-0.1499214768,
0.6971455216,
0.0770265311,
-0.5184273124,
-0.6950542927,
0.0765048191,
-0.1231606305,
0.0758114457,
-0.2538564801,
-0.1590206027,
-0.0105757676,
0.31727162,
-0.4908791184,
0.5760657787,
-0.2431390733,
-0.2437088341,
0.415733546,
0.1394725442,
0.1834516376,
0.1217687652,
-0.4444782734,
-0.2152559161,
-0.6466422677,
0.1327424943,
0.3550239503,
0.4544838667,
0.1157149822,
0.5946571231,
0.213845402,
0.8211662173,
0.533090353,
-0.2711519897,
0.1044674292,
-0.0098133581,
-0.0582023673,
0.1409433484,
0.6448654532,
0.3476966918,
-0.3626820743,
-0.1818701327,
-0.5097445846,
0.4628710747,
0.4588287771,
-0.4322560132,
-0.2521009445,
0.2152086198,
-0.217597425,
-0.1729033142,
-0.0324502811,
-0.5115904808,
-0.6953062415,
-0.6926854849,
0.5996044278,
-0.4670783877,
0.0062173093,
0.007766725,
-0.0833312869,
0.7963332534,
0.4619748294,
-0.9473561049,
0.3054619133,
0.9085415006,
0.8497896791,
-0.2847120166,
-0.0745617822,
-0.6271282434,
0.0296286475,
-0.2983510494,
0.7606340051,
-0.3138214648,
0.1391113997,
-0.1688528061,
-0.0414447524,
-0.1531130373,
-0.5128279328,
0.5488954782,
-0.6822367907,
0.2124580294,
-0.1914885044,
-0.692817688,
-0.083032459,
0.1921257228,
-0.7736532688,
0.8116247058,
0.2290104777,
-0.4690618813,
0.4470345378,
-0.5247225165,
0.0532318838,
0.0367596671,
-0.1010233983,
-0.6402391791,
-0.0131497495,
0.0820889026,
-0.0187869873,
-0.0009740791,
0.2332344651,
-0.295956254,
-0.5491778851,
0.0491856262,
-0.1460611522,
0.457821399,
0.2742346227,
-0.2585920095,
0.2831430435,
-0.7700153589,
-0.1090018973,
0.1059464812,
-0.2462215871,
-0.2424971908,
0.0467714965,
-0.2211531103,
0.1277972013,
0.3523198664,
-0.679150939,
0.3330414891,
-0.3762514889,
0.3136694431,
0.9847832918,
-0.4263959825,
0.9229508638,
-0.4751826823,
0.491676271,
-0.2072824389,
0.11309769,
0.0209439564,
-0.047032468,
-0.8781378269,
-0.5509185195,
0.5948013067,
0.7113692164,
-0.5573211312,
0.5691741109,
-0.4649377763,
-0.5889987946,
-1.080917716,
0.4100926816,
0.4116513431,
0.8299551606,
0.4584181011,
-0.0705108568,
-0.509739995,
-0.9237282872,
-0.3440566659,
-0.1867757142,
-0.0165601298,
-0.1344949156,
0.19849433,
-0.2719358802,
0.9822608829,
-0.5691761971,
-0.3956063986,
-0.0906479657,
-0.0980204269,
0.3009998202,
0.4408193827,
0.3914169371,
-0.5012172461,
-0.4123124778,
0.1078340933,
-0.5022217035,
0.008056459,
-0.1459820569,
-0.330825448,
0.1483818293,
0.2588344812,
-0.4044350684,
0.0939303264,
0.55597651,
-0.0151204467,
0.3221429288,
-0.088689968,
-0.2721271217,
-0.907623291,
0.2425147593,
-0.0038270396,
-0.3499880433,
-0.6619241834,
0.0702375993,
0.3861799538,
0.202153042,
-0.3461067975,
0.5272789598,
-0.3360082209,
0.1771717221,
-0.0939157456,
0.2726339102,
-0.1607057899,
0.361581713,
-0.053485442,
0.7521235943,
0.1845300943,
-0.3270334303,
0.1140160859,
0.5025351048,
-0.2165376097,
0.5131649375,
-0.5900947452,
0.2579478621,
-0.2512667179,
0.0164314248,
-1.0090414286,
-0.3456827402,
0.240917027,
-0.2568961978,
0.3606499732,
-0.1011722907,
0.027796125,
-0.4772191644,
-0.3418737054,
0.2539510131,
0.5777172446,
-0.7857474685,
0.7825708389,
0.2762136757,
-0.0184993856,
-1.0376552343,
-0.3430946469,
-0.2425009757,
-0.288385123,
-0.3508805335,
0.2822519541,
0.0261199232,
-0.25802055,
-0.13971439,
-0.453448534,
0.0770954639,
0.1533641815,
0.0582550578,
0.6897160411,
-0.1990959644,
0.1863934696,
-0.0535322875,
-0.1821388453,
-0.2916738391,
-0.2370380312,
0.3365563154,
-0.3421434164,
-0.5142560005,
-0.3676722944,
0.0142678851,
0.5774893165,
-0.1930419803,
0.7117369771,
0.3142833114,
-0.2123879045,
-0.0357628725,
-0.8148206472,
-0.020846745,
-0.4924057722,
0.1754220128,
-0.1894084364,
-0.9212089777,
0.6360297799,
0.0733349174,
0.2985007465,
0.3469714224,
0.3335092366,
0.0071151345,
1.1745530367,
0.6998105049,
-0.3072372377,
0.5285057425,
0.0955642164,
0.4559863508,
-0.7981595397,
-0.1204962358,
-0.4357689321,
-0.5004432201,
-0.4486420751,
-0.1595140547,
0.2148462981,
0.1795371026,
-0.5897697806,
0.4697649479,
-0.7037197948,
0.6578050852,
0.4214509726,
0.2667792737,
0.2424245477,
-0.4079023004,
-0.0004925926,
0.0630984381,
-0.6440736651,
-0.6404374838,
0.9598339796,
0.4303839207,
0.8957212567,
0.3332143426,
0.8160066605,
0.0816786885,
0.6674721837,
-1.0592736006,
0.1595378071,
-0.0371098034,
-0.3867004514,
-0.3027608395,
-0.1988921016,
-0.7177736759,
0.3085333109,
-0.2092884034,
-0.7317459583,
0.2848282158,
0.4586986005,
-0.8028162122,
0.2709758282,
-0.74156636,
0.8721087575,
-0.3607791066,
-0.5162069798,
0.2019135058,
-1.0032601357,
0.4713392854,
-0.403952837,
0.1695907861,
-0.1120077968,
-0.1548424363,
0.4396903217,
-0.4869549572,
0.4851137698,
-0.2752706409,
-0.257674098,
0.0875824839,
0.007350354,
0.5230561495,
-0.2763853073,
-0.1090457961,
-0.025744291,
-0.2151297331,
-0.2323842645,
-0.7652089596,
0.6608483195,
-0.7914611101,
-0.6352987885,
-0.3690669835,
-0.5199687481,
-0.1412181258,
0.4052237868,
0.0011434973,
0.1500541121,
-0.2097719163,
0.0313306041,
0.6987620592,
0.086419709,
0.298196435,
0.6493853927,
-0.2902872562,
-0.5271405578,
0.8231327534,
-0.0744901896,
0.2822417319,
0.4189844728,
0.14646101,
-0.6656855941,
-0.3651263416,
-0.5971582532,
0.3952531517,
-0.7232917547,
-0.5731064081,
-0.5240263939,
-0.0474697836,
-0.1833889931,
-0.4034101367,
-0.5464274287,
-0.4352370501,
-0.0034669125,
-0.199697122,
0.1203075498,
0.6461331248,
-0.1178435832,
0.6109616756,
-0.6551780701,
0.1798326224,
0.3543994725,
0.4515852928,
-0.0954377726,
-0.5598613024,
-0.0986709371,
0.0867156908,
-0.6145960689,
-0.5630708933,
0.266182214,
0.1765350848,
0.6638211608,
0.5386822224,
-0.0773182809,
0.926384449,
-0.5215687156,
0.6128672957,
0.3563299775,
-1.0716580153,
0.3320441544,
-0.3715977669,
0.2867487371,
0.925047636,
0.3310926855,
-0.4395519793,
-0.3581627607,
-0.3128884733,
-0.7853845954,
0.5937244296,
-0.1136555225,
-0.1584602892,
0.1339088827,
0.4433289468,
0.2539420724,
0.0604762323,
-0.7846894264,
-0.1089097783,
-0.1691003591,
-0.6299105287,
-0.1130820513,
0.0572908744,
-0.166439712,
-0.3013651371,
0.8548375964,
-0.3867187798,
0.1468550265,
-0.084445402,
-0.3911087513,
-0.1179023832,
0.3633182645,
0.4956797957,
0.660096705,
-0.2285095453,
0.1144571528,
0.1970929503,
-0.1411610097,
0.4306336343,
0.1128014699,
-0.1655761003,
-0.2715620697,
0.0659977645,
0.6251631379,
0.1693949699,
-0.4735963941,
0.6688681245,
-0.1125668138,
-0.0109359147,
-0.2128411084,
-0.015759401,
0.128346011,
0.209515065,
0.1314311624,
0.4508111477,
0.0500672758,
-0.2217382491,
0.2852178812,
0.5242811441,
-0.7299391031,
-0.2332217693,
0.9129623175,
0.0276166145,
-0.208423689,
0.722368896,
-0.1245344877,
-0.5092128515,
0.2424451411,
0.6015537381,
0.726626575,
-0.5646089911,
0.0088622123,
0.3966565728,
0.0915745273,
-0.4667505324,
-0.0471226089,
0.1356185079,
-0.9825353622,
-0.4908321202,
-0.6735399961,
-0.3405959606,
-0.1287799776,
-0.9501238465,
0.517203629,
-0.367583096,
-0.1024563238,
0.0722240359,
-0.4143202007,
-0.4895556271,
-0.2106441706,
0.2502173185,
0.9284539223,
-0.8125405908,
0.6183595657,
0.6898971796,
-0.3508505225,
-1.1228581667,
-0.2791511416,
0.3840896189,
-0.9797772765,
0.1841121614,
0.3103433251,
-0.2728333473,
0.0343751833,
-0.6014136076,
-0.9478792548,
1.2566804886,
0.5739452839,
-0.8722507954,
-0.1045823693,
-0.0674384981,
0.4569649398,
-0.2656268775,
0.2642325759,
0.786798954,
0.2933448851,
0.1641246229,
-0.8513332009,
0.0819250271,
-0.2092957199,
0.0710243508,
0.4868682325,
-0.7635244131,
0.6248757243,
-0.2259947956,
-0.2269093692,
0.3596802652,
0.5894739628,
0.2842048705,
-0.0441497378,
0.6334643364,
0.8432238102,
1.1089298725,
-0.218960166,
0.8273383379,
-0.3590495586,
0.3951384723,
1.4140685797,
-0.4929488599,
0.8983368278,
0.6233874559,
0.1302723438,
0.8778978586,
0.375883311,
-0.0185022671,
0.6391288042,
0.1854933649,
-0.1559420228,
-0.3228769898,
-0.0086913286,
-0.1009116992,
0.5317351222,
-0.0074905977,
-0.1538928747,
-0.2171745151,
-0.0682467446,
0.0244465582,
0.273311615,
-0.2687987089,
0.9935758114,
-0.1051846445,
-0.852784574,
0.4697698653,
-0.1785996854,
0.5962606072,
-0.6809709668,
-0.1163185984,
-0.1180061027,
0.7425149083,
-0.1893513799,
-0.4924334288,
0.2343585491,
-0.1408213377,
-0.2364597619,
-0.1777522862,
0.6766062975,
-0.4855621457,
-0.2766467631,
0.1029103473,
0.268378675,
-0.3979718387,
0.1882026047,
-0.592176795,
0.110782288,
-0.0272929203,
0.1502707005,
0.2332828045,
0.0452522226,
-0.0447113775,
0.8161568642,
0.4599046111,
-0.1054328308,
-0.0506296903,
-0.0960998014,
0.9507030845,
-0.4080737829,
-0.3147928417,
-0.8508090973,
0.7626822591,
-0.1953991354,
-0.0361207016,
0.7383998632,
0.7408404946,
0.8283623457,
-0.0017944452,
0.7538884878,
-0.0364204459,
0.6304870248,
-0.3094341159,
0.5679540634,
-0.3482446373,
0.4500436783,
-0.0428759977,
-0.9125112295,
-0.3838732541,
0.7100160122,
-0.3735021651,
-0.4068492949,
0.4524033666,
0.8825917244,
-0.1156268567,
-0.0729732141,
-0.0122553837,
-0.0586529709,
0.4254280925,
0.4261183441,
1.1169581413,
-0.5078510046,
0.3484146893,
-0.1404752284,
-0.3485969603,
0.0429546386,
-0.8050209284,
-0.378983885,
-0.2616825402,
-0.2423750758,
-0.3695238829,
-0.0290979352,
1.206381917,
0.450432241,
-0.8938234448,
-0.2393993586,
0.0073516299,
0.2163898796,
-0.3901839852,
-0.227219969,
0.1369311512,
-0.4745284617,
-0.5080503821,
0.2517912686,
0.0637894124,
-0.0058545964,
0.0420680568,
-0.1479745805,
-0.1439483017,
0.1110226214,
0.1950574517,
0.4687580466,
-0.854133606,
-0.5961948633,
0.3141122162,
-0.0718266889,
0.3273828328,
0.5577671528,
-0.708381772,
0.5229141116,
0.1828531176,
0.763512969,
0.1083254665,
0.4478913546,
0.7706769109,
-0.5617827773,
-0.1982018948,
0.2026178688,
0.4965309501,
0.3867346644,
-0.3949812353,
0.4177463353,
-0.0974002704,
-0.7613129616,
-0.8093129396,
0.1363613456,
-1.0421594381,
0.0273077786,
0.9095385671,
-0.0540969297,
-0.361528337,
0.0817401037,
-0.3419135809,
0.2912768126,
-0.4675833285,
0.8699109554,
0.4868640006,
-0.1160258651,
-0.0293254852,
0.0172623917,
0.3406023979,
0.359511286,
-0.4424319267,
0.1039776281,
0.64173311,
0.5537745953,
0.3572925031,
0.4225394726,
-0.1460945755,
0.1825149357,
-0.2400316149,
0.2089295536,
0.1533331871,
-0.1388936341,
-0.7805953026,
-0.0092193242,
0.2255792022,
-0.0879346281
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02408v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02408v1
|
GLaPE: Gold Label-agnostic Prompt Evaluation and Optimization for Large Language Model
| 2024-02-04T08:57:54 | 2024-02-04T08:57:54 |
Xuanchang Zhang, Zhuosheng Zhang, Hai Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Despite the rapid progress of large language models (LLMs), their task
performance remains sensitive to prompt design. Recent studies have explored
leveraging the LLM itself as an optimizer to identify optimal prompts that
maximize task accuracy. However, when evaluating prompts, such approaches
heavily rely on elusive manually annotated gold labels to calculate task
accuracy for each candidate prompt, which hinders the widespread implementation
and generality. To overcome the limitation, this work proposes a gold
label-agnostic prompt evaluation (GLaPE) to alleviate dependence on gold
labels. Motivated by the observed correlation between self-consistency and the
accuracy of the answer, we adopt self-consistency as the initial evaluation
score. Subsequently, we refine the scores of prompts producing identical
answers to be mutually consistent. Experimental results show that GLaPE
provides reliable evaluations uniform with accuracy, even in the absence of
gold labels. Moreover, on six popular reasoning tasks, our GLaPE-based prompt
optimization yields effective prompts comparable to accuracy-based ones. The
code is publicly available at https://github.com/thunderous77/GLaPE.
|
[
-0.0272038281,
-0.785538435,
0.7254573703,
0.6547250748,
-0.0152511783,
-0.0281694811,
-0.3594405949,
-0.1911019236,
0.0865733996,
0.1707036346,
-0.7708853483,
-0.3800726831,
-0.4921069145,
0.3856893182,
0.0472069383,
0.8998788595,
0.0141021097,
-0.4572945833,
-0.2873986363,
-0.158945784,
-0.6143452525,
-0.3539835513,
-0.487837851,
-0.4691695273,
0.6029458642,
0.2215854228,
0.7389283776,
0.5898560286,
-0.0487263165,
0.2738115489,
-0.1270654798,
0.6211769581,
-0.1423333585,
0.2411317825,
-0.3281182945,
-0.0803485587,
-0.4028525352,
0.0168572739,
0.5620309114,
0.319359988,
0.0138073927,
0.4066162407,
0.3517796099,
0.571079731,
-0.8964936733,
0.2640267015,
-0.5952489376,
-0.0072882702,
0.0147997783,
-0.4205434918,
-0.6549753547,
-0.4130810499,
-0.0915203243,
-0.718177259,
-0.0941304564,
0.0864694566,
0.8032149076,
0.3649043143,
-0.0369706228,
-0.5973110795,
-0.4865576923,
0.9351995587,
-0.5190498829,
0.2048759013,
0.5031337738,
0.1606945544,
-0.2843418121,
-0.5397179723,
-0.4141911566,
-0.7085228562,
-0.1198557094,
0.1186440736,
-0.3953252733,
0.0577011183,
0.14491871,
0.314760983,
-0.8432513475,
0.2886904478,
0.1891188174,
-0.3856780231,
0.4687018096,
0.1137862876,
0.396666497,
0.0514361486,
-0.2809292376,
0.2139646113,
-0.4844398201,
0.231704548,
0.3641037643,
0.5811289549,
-0.0445008352,
0.5473332405,
-0.1707831025,
1.117841959,
0.3469583988,
-0.3410346508,
0.5834326744,
-0.3156755865,
-0.149722442,
-0.0486022346,
1.0387761593,
0.230230093,
0.4109676182,
-0.2916160226,
-0.1327900887,
0.3121986985,
0.0684063807,
-0.723592639,
-0.0770824254,
0.391585052,
-0.1594174355,
-0.015955545,
-0.3323824108,
-0.4881845713,
-0.4158705175,
-0.3532261848,
0.5674458742,
-0.0974971354,
0.1905907989,
0.3033353686,
0.3364880085,
-0.2948098481,
0.6225548387,
-1.1773318052,
0.0505414456,
0.7370302677,
0.97704494,
-0.1092235222,
-0.3283365667,
-1.298435092,
0.0116469115,
-0.2722375095,
0.7728569508,
-0.6855419278,
-0.4187636375,
-0.2580989301,
0.0011055345,
-0.3022732139,
-0.3743031621,
0.9424784184,
-0.3051707447,
0.3276945055,
-0.3237900436,
-0.6801136732,
0.0031522724,
0.4899273813,
-0.5902664065,
0.9650525451,
0.0703680813,
-0.5762593746,
0.1909294128,
-0.7490521669,
-0.0321087725,
0.3642114997,
-0.2024689317,
-0.2051891834,
-0.0084317001,
0.3429987729,
0.0592791513,
-0.3419914544,
0.236965701,
-0.1289292276,
-0.4945979714,
0.0650361627,
-0.4724446237,
0.8560935259,
0.2393037975,
-0.3721970022,
0.2833211422,
-0.4246757329,
0.2638489902,
-0.0869932771,
-0.4944849908,
-0.2490932047,
-0.2067783922,
-0.3497022688,
0.0241387263,
0.614423275,
-0.6115252376,
0.4672445655,
-0.2535628676,
0.0654896051,
0.8515222073,
-0.1876446009,
0.3473732471,
-0.2040516287,
0.6717304587,
-0.5390437841,
0.3934575915,
-0.2299958318,
-0.7483487129,
-0.3254654408,
-0.4590309262,
0.4327460229,
0.9193725586,
-0.3645786345,
0.7673898935,
0.0819116384,
-0.4630832672,
-0.7280571461,
0.5942709446,
0.3437061906,
0.8416700959,
0.4864811897,
-0.0562443323,
-0.2119067013,
-0.9913033247,
-0.459880352,
-0.3490710258,
0.0172015633,
0.2947829068,
0.182875067,
-0.5383599997,
1.1831569672,
-0.3048497438,
-0.26084131,
-0.1778262258,
0.097722128,
0.7272580862,
0.4691844583,
0.6442554593,
-0.4510187209,
-0.6885040402,
0.0664386228,
-0.6206216812,
-0.7192982435,
-0.2826529145,
-0.0527428985,
0.347045213,
0.2412867546,
-0.690564692,
0.0533144027,
0.779558897,
-0.5178881288,
0.8806633949,
-0.4961656332,
0.1320311576,
-0.4778882265,
0.3141593039,
0.2135187387,
-0.0895947963,
-0.6214907169,
-0.1538688093,
0.3497784138,
0.1451183558,
-0.1575356722,
1.1640995741,
-0.3616089225,
0.2447136641,
-0.3309459984,
0.0150854979,
0.3670025468,
0.2996411622,
-0.1727340519,
1.1065815687,
0.4776943624,
-0.3858248591,
0.3216115236,
0.2534319758,
-0.4423384368,
0.4101029634,
-0.9252155423,
0.2097989023,
-0.1585759968,
0.2024271935,
-1.0475629568,
0.1743769199,
0.7139825225,
-0.3095424473,
0.1990657747,
-0.3219850659,
-0.6098192334,
-0.3387822211,
-0.1881563216,
0.3863527477,
0.5082862377,
-0.6256166101,
0.6099103093,
0.0310810339,
-0.4610666931,
-0.9124718308,
-0.4117599726,
0.1403409094,
-0.275421381,
-0.4127129912,
0.0503948405,
-0.5837069154,
-0.1489489079,
-0.3501190245,
-0.0899989754,
0.2623432577,
0.1571555436,
0.0810904652,
0.326014787,
0.1009385511,
0.3097952604,
-0.1724701524,
-0.3632698953,
-0.0283309873,
-0.3013030589,
0.6359758973,
-0.4808513522,
-0.3763506114,
-0.5208923221,
0.2393530607,
0.3401146233,
-0.3063137829,
0.3761995137,
0.4125185907,
-0.0360608809,
-0.2607733607,
-0.5992255807,
0.2248171866,
-0.5660508871,
0.1122682169,
-0.3211099505,
-0.8935754299,
0.4700525999,
0.1431037784,
0.2981633246,
0.3214752674,
0.6316753626,
0.2468194813,
0.94553262,
0.3256849349,
-0.0998364985,
0.2977962792,
0.1795607358,
-0.0024036183,
-0.6385923028,
-0.185368821,
-0.5548520684,
-0.0914754197,
-0.1077289656,
-0.3709151149,
0.2879337966,
0.1641385704,
-0.2414917201,
-0.1224511713,
-0.5856838822,
0.6619175673,
0.5473367572,
-0.0719230697,
0.3708325624,
0.0009459234,
-0.1163503304,
-0.114336051,
-0.6201969981,
-0.766081214,
0.7075158358,
0.3665650785,
0.7902068496,
-0.2116525918,
0.5509048104,
0.6161201,
0.2342639267,
-0.7243763804,
0.4946303666,
-0.0920605659,
-0.2993274927,
-0.2130695432,
-0.4620697796,
-1.1422171593,
0.263549,
-0.0731561482,
-1.1146452427,
0.0243389402,
0.459946245,
-0.5643168092,
-0.2065360397,
-0.8016608357,
1.1586438417,
-0.4727325141,
-0.3650291562,
0.2993762195,
-0.42864272,
0.1183658093,
-0.2296519279,
0.2829634845,
-0.288621664,
-0.1877066642,
0.4040556848,
-0.2985898256,
0.8611163497,
-0.1816299856,
-0.4827341735,
0.440484345,
0.0632041767,
0.59628582,
0.098061271,
-0.2773207128,
-0.06572368,
-0.412935555,
-0.3100403845,
-0.8454809189,
0.6959808469,
-0.6115276814,
-0.6030365825,
-0.2803851962,
-0.8355877995,
-0.275378108,
0.0652934611,
0.1968684047,
0.5552102327,
0.1974297911,
-0.3095578849,
0.5192940235,
-0.3507046998,
0.4430115521,
0.4455786049,
-0.3633010387,
-0.3879323304,
0.8331484795,
0.0888713375,
0.2411161661,
0.0606777593,
0.4790338278,
-0.6790251136,
-0.3272065222,
-0.7174918056,
0.3498333097,
-0.7925237417,
-0.0993743613,
-0.5900663137,
0.0174846444,
-0.1250863075,
-0.2450617254,
-0.2619990706,
-0.3801755607,
-0.2987295389,
0.1315268129,
0.3506745994,
0.3093395531,
-0.3438582718,
0.2046288997,
-0.7356953621,
0.2883493304,
0.5044401884,
0.2515623569,
-0.1094298661,
-0.6412690282,
-0.0674847364,
0.0717884824,
-0.1735937446,
-0.7330097556,
0.2341898382,
0.434151262,
0.8670075536,
0.1470511854,
0.1778607219,
0.4620163441,
-0.5352833867,
0.6388143301,
0.2421048135,
-1.0364160538,
0.7722219825,
-0.3277244866,
0.6875246167,
0.739962399,
0.210475117,
-0.4192559421,
-0.3825987875,
-0.6115673184,
-0.9653164744,
0.303501457,
0.171291098,
-0.0004615426,
-0.1088889018,
0.2424933612,
0.4501194954,
0.2729360759,
-0.6520390511,
-0.3219420314,
-0.0054645767,
-0.1012760997,
-0.2706853151,
-0.3617278636,
-0.1712182611,
0.017698748,
0.6518897414,
-0.4043214321,
0.0056126136,
0.0448166765,
-0.0920721367,
-0.0449496657,
0.5370137095,
0.6682668328,
0.7778629661,
-0.1953541189,
0.0427298062,
0.0894684121,
-0.4462584853,
0.2989549637,
0.1337872148,
-0.5722149611,
0.2830066085,
0.2115314752,
0.6877225637,
-0.1709230989,
-0.7149674296,
0.4594227374,
-0.0726327151,
-0.0117055494,
-0.1103276983,
0.2119909823,
-0.0774804875,
0.3975501955,
0.5100499988,
-0.0478206612,
0.1845216155,
-0.3436058164,
0.0915751755,
0.4980141819,
-0.0664460137,
-0.0789309442,
0.6637660265,
0.0501286611,
-0.498039782,
0.478446722,
-0.3943093121,
-0.4114394188,
0.3646335304,
0.5510567427,
0.9506626129,
-0.389656812,
0.5331558585,
0.3462212384,
0.351579994,
-0.1470684558,
0.3861842453,
-0.0693160966,
-0.549281776,
-0.8003177047,
-0.7340815663,
-0.6476746202,
0.0661406219,
-0.4608771205,
0.1953838468,
-0.3821094334,
-0.2875345349,
-0.3285259604,
0.1092155948,
-0.271414578,
0.2466355562,
0.2324490696,
0.9757240415,
-0.8719097972,
0.5846258402,
0.6208797693,
0.1322924048,
-0.6300743818,
-0.2966407835,
-0.142344892,
-0.7925438881,
0.4989457726,
0.4919493198,
-0.1583185792,
-0.0445979275,
-0.4038273692,
-0.6982405782,
0.7519710064,
0.8177484274,
-0.6185998917,
0.1979738772,
-0.0223309211,
0.4295286834,
-0.3344780505,
0.3574695885,
0.517640233,
0.7424601316,
0.1796305627,
-1.2999185324,
-0.0549040698,
-0.4777148962,
-0.1551539451,
-0.0922614932,
-0.586882174,
0.6301741004,
-0.1434858143,
-0.1380880326,
0.2851704955,
0.585436821,
0.9903252125,
0.197597146,
0.6321007609,
0.4444102645,
1.1750389338,
-0.023308102,
0.9784630537,
-0.2225690633,
0.4657958746,
1.2085546255,
-0.1876357198,
0.3935268521,
0.4730153084,
0.0847683623,
0.4610432386,
0.5474011302,
-0.1566390097,
0.6002590656,
0.2870054543,
-0.4187065363,
-0.5113345385,
-0.2605504394,
-0.5247198939,
0.2390878201,
0.2744417787,
-0.2144723684,
-0.5139622092,
-0.2373228371,
0.1685920954,
0.0438420586,
-0.6046667099,
0.2206989676,
-0.1437456012,
-0.6426277161,
0.8525547385,
-0.2316676229,
0.656568706,
-0.9186792374,
0.1257585138,
-0.1048357114,
0.177009657,
-0.1565005332,
-0.7689236999,
-0.0395188145,
0.0048578763,
-0.1886054277,
-0.3472706079,
0.7144919038,
-0.3881087303,
-0.4954336286,
0.1376518309,
0.4802997112,
0.0183787066,
0.0301242881,
-0.940898478,
0.3918942511,
-0.0632699132,
-0.544297874,
0.251263082,
0.4146817029,
0.0587117001,
0.8643469214,
0.4751476645,
0.1388507336,
-0.1421151608,
0.042959664,
0.7276387215,
-0.1977674514,
-0.7701557875,
-1.138741374,
0.7269138694,
0.0291172136,
-0.5202312469,
0.8512426019,
0.5508784056,
0.2038292736,
-0.1630912572,
0.8826696873,
0.2232816517,
0.4406931996,
-0.6016813517,
0.3980893791,
-0.5467688441,
0.2352940589,
-0.5910061002,
-1.1371537447,
-0.4153134227,
0.9320656061,
-0.3508420885,
-0.0178358927,
0.4204275012,
0.7062096,
0.1211695448,
0.0275870357,
0.1404213607,
-0.0549741685,
0.3088499606,
0.7204352021,
0.8313977122,
-0.1625133157,
0.3298320472,
0.0716733187,
-0.4688470662,
-0.1809651405,
-1.3657121658,
-0.8494363427,
-0.303781867,
-0.5353650451,
-0.3968502581,
0.1631788164,
1.0819846392,
0.2917217016,
-0.6674243212,
-0.2625177503,
0.1168078557,
-0.0717090741,
-0.1539319009,
-0.1663832515,
0.4426800907,
-0.6779780984,
-0.7067641616,
0.6398783326,
0.4326565564,
0.0995291248,
-0.0306047108,
-0.3274326921,
0.0031737187,
-0.0217724778,
0.5164278746,
0.7098409534,
-0.6757400036,
-0.4224098325,
-0.0267959647,
-0.1193728819,
-0.0456634946,
0.3374249041,
-0.8489431739,
0.4901996255,
0.3025000095,
0.7232590914,
-0.0124067441,
0.4263393283,
0.5703635216,
-0.606571734,
0.0618104301,
0.2713803351,
0.346137017,
0.3325304985,
-0.3866524994,
0.6097635627,
0.0831932127,
-0.8504345417,
-0.8530262709,
0.3291732669,
-1.184040308,
-0.1260422617,
1.4721142054,
-0.3577308357,
-0.2342649549,
-0.0941408202,
-0.4527611434,
-0.2751440108,
-0.5405364037,
0.8733071685,
0.5602116585,
-0.227870509,
-0.244235903,
-0.4488575757,
0.3527762592,
0.5511438251,
-0.6118520498,
0.2639757097,
0.6553303599,
0.1368827373,
0.3911132216,
0.8752472997,
0.244874239,
0.3710053563,
-0.329281956,
-0.0827883705,
-0.3221799135,
-0.4579503536,
-0.2982126474,
0.3671360612,
0.1517254412,
-0.0682402402
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02392v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02392v2
|
DeLLMa: A Framework for Decision Making Under Uncertainty with Large Language Models
| 2024-02-04T08:11:45 | 2024-06-09T05:04:13 |
Ollie Liu, Deqing Fu, Dani Yogatama, Willie Neiswanger
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The potential of large language models (LLMs) as decision support tools is
increasingly being explored in fields such as business, engineering, and
medicine, which often face challenging tasks of decision-making under
uncertainty. In this paper, we show that directly prompting LLMs on these types
of decision-making problems can yield poor results, especially as the problem
complexity increases. To aid in these tasks, we propose DeLLMa (Decision-making
Large Language Model assistant), a framework designed to enhance
decision-making accuracy in uncertain environments. DeLLMa involves a
multi-step scaffolding procedure, drawing upon principles from decision theory
and utility theory, to provide a rational and human-auditable decision-making
process. We validate our framework on multiple realistic decision-making
environments, demonstrating that DeLLMa can consistently enhance the
decision-making performance of leading language models, and achieve up to a 40%
increase in accuracy over competing methods.
|
[
-0.1429030299,
-1.0153055191,
1.1676834822,
0.2975612581,
0.0800253898,
0.0457024984,
-0.4614645243,
-0.2111115456,
-0.0163491853,
0.2389405072,
-0.3985943794,
-0.4885124862,
-0.8788740635,
0.078172408,
-0.2943651676,
0.2886153758,
-0.149568364,
0.4680374563,
-0.261618197,
0.1619319469,
-0.3790476918,
-0.5203219652,
-1.1474536657,
-0.2792657912,
0.4202154875,
0.5275573134,
0.9297843575,
0.082720615,
0.3987895548,
0.3625104427,
-0.3003968298,
0.2530735135,
-0.0085646929,
0.2318529189,
-0.3240061402,
-0.8099623322,
-0.5400545001,
-0.1712022722,
0.6030569673,
0.5980677605,
-0.4603206515,
0.1281877756,
-0.0874550343,
0.8727529049,
-0.6616231799,
0.273693651,
-0.7632850409,
0.1705420315,
0.243822664,
0.2996186018,
-0.2557784617,
-0.3715944886,
0.2955007851,
-0.417604208,
-0.2706608772,
0.1999812424,
0.4320521653,
0.3892440498,
-0.2828688025,
-0.2110814452,
-0.8692456484,
0.6640972495,
-0.7039193511,
0.3135999441,
0.5970041752,
0.523681879,
-0.4314675331,
-0.3195828795,
-0.54757303,
-0.1786586791,
0.3179479837,
-0.0489850082,
-0.0897368193,
0.1394184828,
0.2676173747,
-0.1019949466,
-0.0565673932,
0.3095507026,
-0.3910298944,
-0.1337727904,
0.6624807119,
0.1785434335,
0.1295909137,
0.0459488891,
-0.0008313562,
-0.1854575574,
-0.8491684794,
-0.2291728258,
0.2154918313,
0.4745669961,
0.2640327215,
0.6870649457,
-0.3232762814,
0.8827427626,
-0.2342853397,
-0.3237353861,
-0.0673551261,
0.0997209325,
-0.586859107,
0.1144968644,
0.46541816,
0.1623850465,
0.1658719927,
0.1692197025,
-0.2475111485,
0.2746441662,
0.1482994407,
-0.5776432753,
0.0076801917,
0.4991175532,
-0.2250253111,
-0.269117862,
-0.0069384528,
-0.788985908,
-0.5884893537,
-0.4987522662,
0.6903885007,
-0.2070386857,
-0.270881027,
0.3553319573,
0.1477678269,
-0.0448099636,
0.7863616943,
-0.5264039636,
0.285733968,
0.4389109015,
0.7660660744,
-0.214826718,
-0.119091168,
-0.5139734745,
0.2302444577,
-0.9108585119,
0.6617249846,
-0.6738246679,
-0.644721508,
0.1008263007,
-0.359446913,
0.0591386668,
-0.638312459,
0.692569375,
-0.1279943883,
0.1013839096,
-0.1334312707,
-0.3891249597,
-0.4503146708,
0.4243255556,
-0.5429462194,
0.9357644916,
-0.0486158058,
-0.2702016532,
0.6128915548,
-0.674701333,
-0.1708245277,
-0.2703041732,
-0.4187118113,
-0.4915187657,
0.4183581173,
0.2075005025,
0.6733091474,
-0.4462886751,
0.4175366461,
-0.5751460195,
-0.114414297,
0.346290499,
-0.4849509001,
0.3615051806,
0.3697556555,
-0.2393148392,
0.2944237888,
-0.7147552371,
-0.011155176,
-0.0191957224,
-0.4875073433,
-0.1980345249,
0.5552453995,
-0.0836153105,
0.4934279919,
0.2175732404,
-0.2286229283,
0.204328835,
-0.0392379761,
0.2562988997,
0.9511715174,
-0.3859917521,
0.3457557857,
-0.25920856,
0.5307826996,
0.1624433249,
0.0550190583,
0.0996964872,
-0.6494956613,
-1.0689883232,
-0.0171251893,
0.2926412821,
0.5827904344,
-0.5804357529,
0.3143970668,
0.0402595773,
-0.4711877108,
-0.3669950962,
-0.0240454264,
-0.0377118811,
0.3564218283,
0.32845366,
0.2454410642,
-0.4982345998,
-0.8586341739,
-0.3709314466,
-0.4170762599,
0.0689245686,
0.1649095565,
0.2811623216,
-0.3961129189,
0.9460373521,
-0.4931295514,
-0.3477255106,
-0.2680039108,
0.0185354389,
0.4169552624,
0.4265881479,
0.0892224833,
-0.8562180996,
-0.1403398961,
0.2018853128,
-0.4821281731,
0.023923669,
-0.2174507678,
0.0431861058,
0.442183435,
0.4547879696,
-0.6972905397,
0.4602954984,
0.6211107969,
-0.2296865433,
0.7591515183,
-0.6031349301,
0.1973407716,
-1.2012701035,
-0.0604147241,
0.1917784661,
-0.2438675165,
-0.4261645973,
-0.0722998455,
0.0415414944,
-0.0910105258,
-0.3050742745,
0.3866595328,
-0.4038589299,
-0.1811263412,
-0.2027557343,
0.102300711,
-0.4545947611,
0.094807744,
0.3232571185,
0.917398572,
0.7875366211,
-0.684766233,
0.1166464388,
0.0276499875,
-0.7672624588,
0.6075897813,
-0.4375193715,
-0.1892860383,
-0.1231996641,
0.2076540291,
-0.6675236821,
-0.3255749643,
0.0320837796,
-0.1654646099,
0.2556062341,
0.1140902489,
-0.5475138426,
-0.4203406572,
0.0561215058,
-0.0029238232,
0.3823437095,
-0.2649083734,
0.9070034027,
0.5161901712,
-0.4379991591,
-0.4323833287,
-0.5542448163,
0.2649120986,
-0.350474447,
-0.486536622,
0.1896903217,
-0.2481729239,
-0.764596343,
-0.4514436126,
-0.3096323013,
-0.2090738267,
0.3495545387,
0.4205264151,
0.3769036531,
0.03895659,
0.2955594063,
0.1626571119,
-0.1802946031,
0.208190918,
-0.3839707375,
0.1813802868,
-0.1142123267,
-0.5979780555,
-0.3402385116,
0.2302348614,
0.73220402,
0.1471852809,
0.5177036524,
0.1863349676,
-0.8047151566,
-0.2570412755,
-0.7184200287,
0.0230867844,
-0.4737250507,
0.4199623168,
-0.3998018503,
-0.8194829226,
0.2740985453,
-0.520303905,
0.0522610173,
0.3963084519,
0.7608709335,
-0.0269765798,
1.4340164661,
0.6483071446,
-0.1606879979,
0.2883762121,
0.1623846591,
0.1872071028,
-0.4283952713,
-0.2714466155,
-0.8975353241,
-0.2853824496,
-0.2886671722,
-0.7481129169,
0.5962024331,
0.0398620553,
-0.1818986684,
-0.0429632962,
-0.2790624797,
0.3547271192,
0.3628798425,
0.1353336275,
0.3560256064,
-0.0497540869,
-0.2853553593,
0.1078564078,
-0.9483503699,
-0.703871727,
0.8265208006,
0.3208335042,
0.9199454188,
0.0895173848,
0.4884587526,
0.2017479092,
0.2182384878,
-0.777097106,
0.4226737916,
0.2634627819,
-0.666870594,
-0.4207058251,
-0.4474769831,
-0.7050998807,
0.3627164364,
-0.7406152487,
-1.0100365877,
0.2816298604,
0.1985460371,
-0.6374455094,
0.3522362411,
-0.7629615068,
0.5812388062,
-0.2991128862,
-0.166027233,
-0.5966745019,
-0.2561950982,
0.2502515316,
-0.5485060811,
0.6000480056,
-0.3386221528,
-0.3554456234,
0.529732585,
-0.3805675209,
0.7801365852,
-0.0296429507,
-0.2908777595,
0.2739398777,
0.3812119961,
0.7728837729,
0.1956949532,
-0.6506332755,
0.04021772,
0.0909380987,
-0.1220381334,
-0.4796664417,
0.6552166343,
-0.575462997,
-0.944421649,
-0.5495993495,
-0.4606663287,
-0.5785493255,
0.1314772367,
0.191895932,
0.0451918244,
-0.2739233375,
-0.123765178,
0.6396942139,
-0.257709235,
0.4227384329,
0.2540539503,
-0.5779702663,
-0.2504993081,
0.6427172422,
0.3027801514,
0.1476476192,
0.1932598948,
0.2504532337,
-0.4069671333,
-0.9304487705,
-0.3054712117,
-0.181551069,
-0.6350578666,
-0.1775642186,
-0.354823947,
0.0232928712,
-0.1205437556,
-0.1217992231,
-0.1917369515,
-0.5991603136,
-0.2852267921,
-0.2514505386,
0.2096916437,
0.8458741903,
-0.0493828505,
0.2639056742,
-0.6997268796,
0.0330126137,
0.4707871974,
0.2991760075,
-0.2576292753,
-0.0714475885,
-0.2165798843,
0.1028828919,
0.0248577036,
-0.7803785801,
0.2997121215,
0.0658309385,
0.5437666178,
0.40167889,
-0.0342249274,
0.6812511683,
-0.4513559341,
0.686899364,
0.2215784043,
-0.9864158034,
0.7339274883,
-0.3596177101,
0.3077479005,
0.5092380047,
0.1579012573,
-0.3987098038,
-0.2273927778,
-0.5137480497,
-0.789242506,
0.6152313948,
0.1026594117,
0.0841145366,
0.1717510372,
0.2165735066,
-0.0082740979,
0.2504001856,
-0.4091799259,
0.0121462997,
0.4235998094,
0.0606603511,
-0.2335726917,
-0.2652286887,
-0.2319527864,
-0.3049000502,
0.9373285174,
-0.3499130309,
0.1185680404,
0.3436905444,
-0.092713967,
-0.256636411,
0.3022228181,
0.5685622692,
1.1099382639,
0.0814684853,
-0.0353830978,
0.7561994791,
-0.0267071724,
0.1298368722,
0.0075841411,
0.0541862175,
-0.0872504339,
-0.0510083847,
0.467466116,
0.1005976573,
-0.8526256084,
0.2720942795,
-0.0996485353,
-0.099811703,
-0.4563847184,
0.2709381282,
0.1879044771,
0.3184516132,
0.5370402336,
0.1188401505,
0.1313266158,
-0.3542614281,
0.024623476,
0.3346288204,
-0.4268442988,
0.199183166,
0.4387624264,
0.1096667796,
-0.4411581755,
0.3431946337,
0.1682137251,
-0.4259854555,
0.6512718797,
0.5112462044,
0.7459228635,
-0.4230151176,
0.2979752123,
0.2603134215,
0.342803359,
-0.510276854,
0.3227464259,
0.019539237,
-0.7208322883,
-0.4606027007,
-0.7035924196,
-0.7540271878,
-0.1269289702,
-0.4458846152,
0.4788244665,
-0.8410239816,
-0.4047757089,
-0.263215363,
-0.2782518566,
-0.5388497114,
0.5489693284,
0.1022080928,
1.2976369858,
-0.4046562612,
0.7821106315,
0.7450711131,
0.1169275343,
-0.7598750591,
0.0102612693,
0.1977943629,
-0.6882474422,
0.3332430422,
0.1493627578,
-0.3529869914,
-0.3224480152,
-0.5270804167,
-0.8957957029,
0.9539110661,
0.5370700359,
-0.8579996228,
0.1168700904,
-0.0640111491,
0.2930312455,
-0.3979082108,
0.0726729706,
0.7800193429,
0.7518330812,
0.0162285101,
-0.7564855814,
-0.0439391285,
0.0436082222,
0.1179124638,
0.2177410126,
-0.5140225291,
0.6489686966,
-0.4494731724,
0.0196827892,
0.1775901169,
0.7306970358,
0.4419916272,
0.1184017658,
0.6820257306,
0.4111927152,
1.0300112963,
-0.3033124208,
0.8416631818,
-0.169778809,
0.2354112417,
1.0258601904,
-0.1984125972,
1.0956652164,
0.5363727808,
-0.3687470257,
0.6287161112,
1.0373522043,
0.3445692956,
-0.0146227451,
0.20333758,
-0.4109663963,
-0.8410673141,
0.0942112356,
-0.3141084313,
0.4419508576,
0.8862662911,
-0.3792889416,
0.0209475327,
-0.3587692678,
0.1974331141,
-0.0087509723,
-0.4496761262,
0.6584348679,
0.2386892736,
-0.7831831574,
0.169128865,
0.0840573609,
0.3021655977,
-0.6523908973,
0.0588230528,
0.2084226906,
0.0940479785,
-0.224758774,
-0.7910310626,
0.4129417241,
-0.0918585733,
-0.0609074719,
-0.0041488395,
0.6651585698,
-0.3505142629,
-0.9940611124,
0.2179000378,
0.6606600881,
-0.0377260372,
-0.2957872152,
-0.8996812701,
0.1949444711,
-0.244786799,
-0.1304267496,
0.2093628943,
0.3533186913,
-0.1545754224,
0.9103381634,
0.6324228644,
0.2049524486,
-0.3821222186,
-0.1270681918,
0.5272592902,
-0.4143382013,
-0.5572544932,
-0.896762073,
0.3150922656,
-0.2258665562,
-0.2058262825,
0.5295413733,
0.3773685992,
0.5220850706,
0.1575392783,
1.0246742964,
0.1108529866,
0.0736498684,
-0.748334527,
0.7053594589,
-0.6023036242,
0.3324331641,
-0.3386945724,
-1.2045888901,
-0.6441118121,
0.8870499134,
-0.3717192709,
0.1431622952,
0.4409217536,
0.8670161963,
0.1047039777,
0.0994983241,
0.527762711,
0.3963383734,
0.1395398676,
0.5075592399,
0.8379267454,
0.0662521198,
0.4483771026,
0.1197845787,
-0.2717579603,
-0.1375701129,
-1.1102067232,
-0.7470821738,
-0.5500860214,
-0.2125839442,
-0.2970884442,
0.0191764403,
1.2859823704,
0.9602525234,
-0.7397772074,
-0.3983168602,
-0.1673982888,
0.5653527379,
-0.297436446,
-0.0596190728,
0.1722948849,
-0.4987472594,
-0.9191929102,
0.6380201578,
0.5996391177,
0.2452987283,
-0.359452039,
-0.2675926983,
-0.1296601444,
0.4115683734,
0.5981970429,
-0.0300471894,
-0.6852590442,
-0.2733407319,
-0.4411434829,
0.0703761205,
-0.0354477949,
0.7748602033,
-0.7311478257,
0.6464253664,
0.3835451603,
0.7487377524,
0.3524541259,
-0.4008624852,
1.0833742619,
-0.20817779,
-0.0631694645,
0.0396784432,
0.8122348785,
0.2922332585,
-0.3189591765,
0.5727263093,
-0.0392616652,
-0.469324559,
-0.4617930353,
0.2923934162,
-0.672591567,
-0.6441696286,
1.2944979668,
-0.0107950894,
-0.2138343304,
-0.1375076771,
-0.6350878477,
-0.0482542031,
-0.5216028094,
1.1108094454,
1.1266236305,
0.0150616122,
0.0192492977,
-0.3373861313,
0.6949612498,
0.7057777643,
-1.0868548155,
0.0997167379,
0.6831190586,
0.0238876995,
0.1222061664,
0.3298366368,
0.0632772967,
0.357711792,
-0.2906214893,
-0.4349488318,
0.1824073344,
-0.5573967695,
-0.5378629565,
0.1183973923,
0.4746972919,
0.1509206444
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02389v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02389v2
|
KICGPT: Large Language Model with Knowledge in Context for Knowledge Graph Completion
| 2024-02-04T08:01:07 | 2024-02-23T09:01:44 |
Yanbin Wei, Qiushi Huang, James T. Kwok, Yu Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Knowledge Graph Completion (KGC) is crucial for addressing knowledge graph
incompleteness and supporting downstream applications. Many models have been
proposed for KGC. They can be categorized into two main classes: triple-based
and text-based approaches. Triple-based methods struggle with long-tail
entities due to limited structural information and imbalanced entity
distributions. Text-based methods alleviate this issue but require costly
training for language models and specific finetuning for knowledge graphs,
which limits their efficiency. To alleviate these limitations, in this paper,
we propose KICGPT, a framework that integrates a large language model (LLM) and
a triple-based KGC retriever. It alleviates the long-tail problem without
incurring additional training overhead. KICGPT uses an in-context learning
strategy called Knowledge Prompt, which encodes structural knowledge into
demonstrations to guide the LLM. Empirical results on benchmark datasets
demonstrate the effectiveness of KICGPT with smaller training overhead and no
finetuning.
|
[
-0.320243448,
-0.7194680572,
0.733910799,
0.1281066537,
-0.1495500803,
0.1489782184,
-0.2538919747,
-0.2702792287,
-0.0078313444,
0.5284616351,
-0.2986303568,
-0.5580937862,
-0.7154932022,
-0.1247549728,
-0.0868346691,
1.0223871469,
-0.387365222,
-0.0786460191,
-0.2384962291,
-0.1167552918,
-0.6643033028,
-0.3495751917,
-0.8278484344,
-0.7329859734,
0.5557562113,
0.6051156521,
0.5431183577,
0.5440864563,
-0.008609429,
0.0877964795,
-0.1145990565,
0.0077754175,
-0.4343658984,
-0.0411983915,
0.1048804373,
-0.3255905509,
-0.3025799692,
-0.1253063083,
0.7495633364,
0.9779270887,
-0.1378325969,
-0.1476967037,
0.3100814223,
0.7882114053,
-0.6175482869,
0.731779933,
-0.4325942695,
0.0558677576,
0.0510567725,
0.0697197095,
-0.3921483755,
-0.3558544219,
0.2657741606,
-0.3839238882,
-0.0281598195,
-0.0559554324,
0.344742626,
0.0866178721,
-1.1163791418,
-0.4144377708,
-0.4719043076,
0.315007329,
-0.5510905981,
0.6201657653,
0.630723536,
0.4587172568,
-0.1748385578,
-0.7907085419,
-0.6684958339,
-0.6487560272,
-0.2677165866,
0.1274797618,
0.347779274,
0.2116190195,
0.3822317123,
0.0002906977,
-0.328744173,
-0.1063179001,
-0.2274305075,
-0.2498757988,
0.0752757639,
-0.0018580236,
0.3589302301,
-0.4168744683,
-0.3501224518,
0.0152418772,
-0.7636076808,
0.0048868083,
0.3096907437,
0.367441684,
0.0119712576,
0.7358195782,
-0.5689010024,
0.9357070327,
-0.3138912618,
-0.2888334394,
0.1073712856,
-0.0682085678,
0.0999812335,
0.2800832093,
0.7337453961,
0.2276885957,
0.1512969285,
-0.4604379535,
-0.0137982704,
-0.2149247974,
0.0219856892,
-0.8382838368,
-0.3623372018,
-0.088252753,
-0.2199013531,
-0.1776374131,
-0.2238733768,
-0.5843507051,
-0.2181122601,
-0.3811759055,
0.3912216425,
-0.6316760182,
-0.261053741,
-0.0974984989,
-0.1566942185,
0.1349895597,
0.2198088616,
-0.8152870536,
0.0849340409,
0.5671085119,
0.9463787079,
-0.0925495923,
-0.2729307413,
-0.4821128547,
0.5953802466,
-0.0875082761,
0.6211810708,
-0.4630445838,
-0.2747508585,
-0.1671615392,
-0.1328824461,
-0.1317094266,
-0.0958985835,
0.550317049,
-0.9359151125,
0.0019049088,
-0.4281208515,
-0.7218688726,
-0.345820725,
0.5875314474,
-0.6693741679,
1.120002985,
0.3091634214,
-0.9906746149,
0.4632379711,
-0.8503727317,
-0.6451619267,
0.3185550272,
-0.1098699346,
-0.0662752688,
-0.5054035187,
0.2459244132,
0.6156929731,
-0.2149937302,
0.4262626767,
-0.4113745689,
-0.0756495818,
-0.2548190057,
-0.2529391944,
0.5193024874,
0.2589114606,
-0.3254355788,
-0.3706523776,
-0.8762682676,
0.2143081725,
0.0937761366,
-0.6622717381,
-0.4959517121,
0.0239096954,
-0.2160661817,
0.261502564,
0.2816779613,
-0.4471255541,
0.5358641148,
-0.2859964073,
0.6982470751,
0.4831840098,
-0.0360066406,
0.4689770937,
0.0992288962,
0.5065996051,
-0.2496263683,
-0.2449296713,
0.0010519451,
-0.403036356,
-0.6006717682,
-0.1911646426,
0.3016205728,
0.6382396221,
-1.0700341463,
0.1862053722,
-0.5388306975,
-0.51318115,
0.0717710331,
0.0359444767,
0.3413528204,
0.7892179489,
0.2574572563,
-0.0351954438,
-0.2716179788,
-0.7826361656,
-0.173703447,
-0.1215095967,
0.0064360406,
0.5429252386,
0.5117337108,
-0.1401591599,
1.2746948004,
-0.8030202389,
-0.1666912138,
-0.446944505,
0.2289400846,
0.1075241938,
0.2714849412,
0.2352991104,
-1.0103719234,
-0.8580325246,
0.24393031,
-0.7044973373,
-0.0745049194,
0.3846276104,
-0.1056291386,
0.1406567395,
0.5423099399,
-0.8052948713,
0.2979243696,
0.4688385725,
-0.1871420294,
0.4652822614,
-0.0763944238,
0.2128354162,
-1.3588778973,
0.2735617459,
-0.3883588612,
-0.3920499086,
-0.6092730165,
0.0003672515,
0.4204282761,
-0.3354542851,
-0.1607771665,
0.7317916751,
-0.3151348829,
0.0656747147,
-0.2029923052,
0.3277435601,
-0.0766044781,
0.6987312436,
0.0700539127,
0.5559031963,
0.3042349517,
-0.6228952408,
0.4684658349,
0.2072547972,
-0.4255708158,
0.5199913979,
-0.4553681314,
0.2313744426,
-0.1964108497,
0.5823223591,
-0.8122109175,
-0.5671463609,
0.3913111687,
-0.262252748,
0.3266064525,
-0.6744090915,
-0.5710388422,
-0.6214964986,
0.2385915965,
0.6099364758,
0.3885309398,
-0.6718106866,
0.8323082328,
0.0966778919,
-0.180843547,
-0.7923560739,
-0.3871775866,
0.0997763574,
-0.1137114465,
-0.6607563496,
0.0766781718,
-0.0380588919,
0.3623346686,
0.0535213463,
-0.1703578979,
-0.0557101592,
-0.0038911577,
0.1120648012,
0.0015740331,
-0.0301371142,
0.2767165601,
-0.1809870452,
-0.1736531556,
-0.1613334417,
-0.8437919617,
0.8170671463,
0.0365939327,
-0.4972260296,
-0.2000865042,
0.3001060188,
0.5709963441,
-0.1370368898,
0.8981251121,
0.4871124327,
-0.2369351536,
-0.0350890234,
-0.699880898,
0.0628212243,
-0.3913615942,
0.574975431,
-0.3751977682,
-1.1228047609,
0.5761418939,
-0.1994678825,
-0.3319680691,
0.3236266375,
0.27808249,
0.2274308652,
1.1150349379,
0.5617218614,
-0.3716776073,
0.3955048919,
-0.1262167841,
0.4733802974,
-0.6818571091,
-0.4066244364,
-0.6166383028,
0.0955204591,
-0.2460567206,
-0.0843598619,
0.5166614056,
0.6530988216,
-0.4637458026,
0.4096617401,
-0.2043388188,
0.6775545478,
0.6254882216,
0.1742952764,
0.3696796298,
-0.0221355855,
-0.4788986444,
0.3708180785,
-0.9547934532,
-0.2708044946,
0.9989767671,
0.0977548212,
0.5402309299,
0.1575203091,
0.463748157,
0.049002517,
0.3818943202,
-0.962706387,
0.4214442372,
0.0872094557,
-0.4052782655,
-0.2709810138,
-0.9042374492,
-0.6052837372,
-0.0404538289,
0.1199978292,
-0.87164253,
-0.327778995,
0.3078512549,
-0.1115982383,
0.4704021215,
-0.8175356984,
1.0315140486,
0.0073934346,
-0.0185744818,
-0.0118800737,
-0.6856456995,
0.4557397366,
-0.2028698027,
0.0871555954,
0.0218875203,
0.2167691737,
0.7006997466,
-0.5244484544,
0.8516415954,
-0.4140366018,
-0.1699046344,
0.3044454753,
0.1437864155,
1.2569856644,
0.0447366498,
0.1312255561,
-0.1957118362,
-0.057377588,
-0.4108079076,
-0.7764789462,
0.6009032726,
-0.6588669419,
-0.3247121274,
0.0839583948,
-0.6713552475,
-0.4018778503,
0.5827019811,
0.1606206894,
0.6050306559,
-0.0296156853,
0.2294391841,
0.4875530899,
-0.1390268058,
0.2340896279,
0.4624685645,
-0.0965701789,
-0.5590167046,
0.8083180189,
0.2871644199,
0.5587710738,
0.4325456321,
0.1819774061,
-0.3831312656,
-0.4191908836,
-0.3747066259,
0.0026363966,
-1.067091465,
-0.2635413408,
-1.1601456404,
-0.2714403272,
-0.5883736014,
-0.1578249335,
-0.232472524,
-0.2754076719,
0.1311804205,
0.0259817857,
0.4855779409,
0.6309788823,
0.2010674179,
0.6686082482,
-0.8443456292,
0.3486697972,
0.5827006102,
0.6210289598,
0.3134747744,
-0.0654985756,
-0.4319274127,
0.1844060868,
-0.1520513743,
-0.7296072245,
0.1235311925,
-0.1120003238,
0.4410075545,
0.1777991802,
0.0315911137,
0.5116900206,
-0.5104182363,
0.7663290501,
0.3135220706,
-0.7811400294,
0.4130371213,
-0.5173315406,
0.4936769605,
0.4548068643,
0.4994434416,
-1.0499881506,
-0.201145947,
-0.4423205256,
-0.9711875916,
0.8417627215,
0.1281277239,
-0.0894524977,
-0.2851262391,
0.4864567816,
-0.1341288239,
0.1775832325,
-0.9423045516,
0.0309447646,
-0.1777040958,
-0.4104532003,
0.0475489795,
-0.4368648827,
-0.1125252843,
0.0717605725,
0.91492486,
-0.5123845935,
0.1235184371,
0.0816871822,
-0.2718553543,
0.3113839924,
0.2988405228,
0.2549214661,
0.4498590529,
-0.0705968142,
0.1389032602,
0.2961118519,
-0.5626141429,
0.1023416668,
0.1814190298,
-0.2379247099,
-0.4943420887,
0.4064914882,
0.9036553502,
0.1835042685,
-0.4413279891,
0.650650382,
0.203586936,
-0.1087407097,
-0.3471907973,
-0.0744601861,
0.2165870816,
0.335206449,
0.353159517,
0.0052801324,
-0.0023109722,
-0.1588446349,
0.0469271466,
0.4747956991,
-0.475859046,
0.1249114126,
0.572072506,
-0.0564263575,
-0.0335062891,
0.9342336059,
-0.3091325462,
-0.8972113729,
0.6723299026,
0.5185272098,
0.6089696884,
0.1593759656,
0.2157344967,
0.3901074231,
0.0860116035,
-0.4838966131,
-0.0635223836,
-0.3854216933,
-0.7844829559,
-0.7473607063,
-0.5817397833,
-0.0619691052,
-0.1096513942,
-0.4215395153,
0.3863614202,
-0.1346603185,
0.0804224983,
-0.2384555936,
0.0468129553,
-0.6533178091,
-0.1806830913,
-0.0273099001,
1.0104987621,
-0.7124632597,
1.0520926714,
0.3851677179,
-0.3340345025,
-1.2699655294,
-0.0625004992,
-0.2050826997,
-0.8561754823,
0.9524948001,
0.2708086371,
-0.0785199031,
0.3172585964,
-0.5361632109,
-0.9720057249,
1.264390707,
0.3247925341,
-0.2204058319,
-0.1087504998,
0.2610664666,
0.1406994611,
-0.304309696,
0.0941532701,
0.5296298265,
0.6614942551,
0.47604689,
-0.9049447179,
0.0086313291,
0.1303932369,
0.0241579358,
0.5822940469,
-0.6510828733,
0.4243204892,
-0.0964170322,
-0.1431583166,
0.0119144255,
0.4469963312,
0.2541798353,
0.158577323,
0.6388386488,
0.7534361482,
0.710491538,
0.0813490301,
1.0358589888,
-0.2710019648,
0.6242521405,
1.193023324,
-0.308683157,
0.4995164275,
0.2462942153,
-0.1480737627,
0.2180619985,
0.4800271988,
0.2255621552,
0.5573469996,
0.0164265577,
-0.482971251,
-0.2518587112,
-0.1118820086,
-0.4027335644,
0.3047569394,
0.1577269137,
-0.2052418739,
-0.3876045346,
0.1684458554,
0.337914288,
-0.4397854209,
-0.3730569482,
0.7310819626,
0.0018119463,
-0.8691875935,
0.3944040239,
-0.0701753646,
0.3693777025,
-0.9633764625,
-0.1224623471,
-0.1410285085,
0.0098045487,
-0.0089648049,
-0.702534616,
-0.1026923731,
-0.3557613194,
-0.3750994503,
-0.1395937651,
0.8478290439,
-0.766520977,
-0.369954437,
0.343670845,
0.2785900831,
-0.0055156075,
-0.2347590476,
-0.2796621323,
-0.4790024757,
0.0992518589,
-0.3128943443,
0.207715407,
0.6179643869,
-0.2197446972,
0.8941339254,
0.4997225702,
-0.1230821088,
-0.1062949151,
0.1801831424,
0.8812595606,
-0.5170872211,
-0.5731780529,
-0.8163563609,
0.2772852778,
-0.0752778202,
0.1968137324,
0.5443473458,
0.5171374679,
0.7275304794,
0.0457828529,
0.9084777832,
-0.4823430777,
0.3707994223,
-0.7887129188,
0.9014399052,
-0.3686203361,
0.0821843222,
-0.2805111706,
-1.0182071924,
-0.3037169278,
0.2417149544,
-0.3724536896,
0.3778401315,
0.8388543129,
0.7297955751,
-0.2836976647,
0.1577261984,
0.1618101597,
0.3139170408,
0.3642107248,
0.6665261388,
0.7473582625,
-0.0996731296,
0.801799953,
-0.1939371973,
-0.2588421404,
-0.055897627,
-1.1599508524,
-0.8426409364,
-0.6408620477,
-0.0117226774,
-0.4713515341,
-0.1405388415,
0.8916249871,
0.7305165529,
-0.3275410831,
0.160417214,
-0.1445125639,
0.1929467618,
-0.0128044412,
-0.25458619,
0.7084746361,
-0.4254398644,
-0.2908993065,
0.2472397834,
0.0173675362,
0.1337063611,
0.0397346653,
-0.212069571,
-0.0519545749,
-0.5939148664,
0.7559091449,
0.2444893271,
-0.4307132363,
-0.5802733302,
-0.2128644437,
0.0444646589,
-0.1503537595,
0.9998838902,
-0.8956199884,
0.3692732751,
0.3947280645,
0.7376993895,
0.7205957174,
-0.2828944027,
0.6698554754,
-0.8807864785,
0.1132445335,
0.0140837245,
0.3259212673,
0.2186692655,
-0.4957402349,
0.5935965776,
0.3624041677,
-0.6219620705,
-0.4773098826,
0.4229334891,
-0.9222527146,
-0.1549464911,
1.2847821712,
-0.080571577,
-0.0857448354,
-0.187457189,
-0.280897826,
0.5166079998,
-0.2887898088,
0.5017331243,
1.0224237442,
0.1758889109,
-0.0619580448,
-1.0570729971,
0.3785105944,
0.1302716285,
-0.5575015545,
0.3286581337,
0.5181942582,
0.5268996954,
-0.0811834037,
0.7797372937,
0.0403413475,
-0.0966771469,
-0.2366857976,
0.2663957775,
-0.159378022,
-0.3630827367,
0.1794809252,
0.4263957143,
0.111958988,
0.4193665087
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02388v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02388v1
|
Solution-oriented Agent-based Models Generation with Verifier-assisted Iterative In-context Learning
| 2024-02-04T07:59:06 | 2024-02-04T07:59:06 |
Tong Niu, Weihao Zhang, Rong Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SE
|
Agent-based models (ABMs) stand as an essential paradigm for proposing and
validating hypothetical solutions or policies aimed at addressing challenges
posed by complex systems and achieving various objectives. This process demands
labor-intensive endeavors and multidisciplinary expertise. Large language
models (LLMs) encapsulating cross-domain knowledge and programming proficiency
could potentially alleviate the difficulty of this process. However, LLMs excel
in handling sequential information, making it challenging for analyzing the
intricate interactions and nonlinear dynamics inherent in ABMs. Additionally,
due to the lack of self-evaluation capability of LLMs, relying solely on LLMs
is insufficient to effectively accomplish this process. In this paper, we
present SAGE, a general solution-oriented ABM generation framework designed for
automatic modeling and generating solutions for targeted problems. Unlike
approaches reliant on expert handcrafting or resource-intensive neural network
training, SAGE establishes a verifier-assisted iterative in-context learning
process employing large language models (LLMs) to leverages their inherent
cross-domain knowledge for tackling intricate demands from diverse domain
scenarios. In SAGE, we introduce an semi-structured conceptual representation
expliciting the intricate structures of ABMs and an objective representation to
guide LLMs in modeling scenarios and proposing hypothetical solutions through
in-context learning. To ensure the model executability and solution
feasibility, SAGE devises a two-level verifier with chain-of-thought prompting
tailored to the complex interactions and non-linear dynamics of ABMs, driving
the iterative generation optimization. Moreover, we construct an evaluation
dataset of solution-oriented ABMs from open sources.It contains practical
models across various domains.
|
[
-0.4596987367,
-0.8408853412,
0.6236266494,
-0.0379400179,
-0.1030478552,
0.1291841418,
-0.275460422,
-0.1525694132,
-0.1227811128,
0.7274295092,
-0.6397038698,
-0.439550221,
-0.2619042397,
0.0159768313,
-0.1539770812,
1.0652631521,
-0.2265085727,
0.1814369112,
-0.3540591002,
0.1620713025,
-0.6359214783,
-0.3171717823,
-0.7491152287,
-0.7857863903,
0.002601617,
0.475625366,
0.5836054087,
0.6164853573,
0.0858320519,
0.4194172919,
0.1311925799,
0.1347513348,
-0.300421536,
0.3712982535,
-0.492030859,
-0.1527926028,
-0.2849550545,
-0.2453195006,
0.6264736652,
0.5203535557,
-0.2915857732,
0.3950830698,
0.0418117456,
0.3157511055,
-0.576166451,
0.2795770764,
-0.9227810502,
-0.0615008622,
0.2009717375,
-0.17441535,
-0.3014874756,
0.0259235855,
0.1038543209,
-0.5771347284,
0.1105342433,
-0.0351325572,
0.8381387591,
0.2463456243,
-0.4112220705,
-0.4957336187,
-0.6924913526,
0.8943663836,
-0.7059617639,
0.1346904039,
0.2409557998,
0.6910555959,
-0.512963891,
-0.5947982669,
-0.6479898095,
-0.2036275268,
0.0851382241,
-0.1084582433,
0.0609647147,
-0.117636092,
0.0251839682,
0.1433807462,
-0.5222569704,
0.0279965755,
0.0245002806,
-0.1030491516,
0.5986206532,
0.4843493998,
0.0213934444,
-0.0977597609,
-0.5312284231,
0.1130040362,
-0.7766581774,
0.0055263136,
-0.0094081163,
0.5033687949,
0.1132682934,
0.4143797755,
-0.223537311,
0.6780560613,
0.0650659576,
-0.3797643483,
0.1880451292,
-0.1469426602,
-0.3229960203,
-0.1314892918,
0.5657403469,
-0.0467409641,
-0.0912486911,
-0.16954647,
-0.5435242057,
-0.0544263683,
0.3616841435,
-0.8313907385,
0.3488064408,
0.3463387489,
-0.2387111187,
-0.1251803339,
-0.3867884576,
-0.6090470552,
-0.410122782,
-0.6841887832,
0.6458268166,
-0.3642700613,
-0.361802578,
0.1458800435,
0.113794066,
0.6222778559,
0.3858020008,
-0.4822255075,
0.3335756958,
0.8349334598,
0.6417674422,
0.0394785777,
-0.4585170448,
-0.5789362192,
0.401640147,
-0.3014686108,
0.7211152315,
-0.5874276757,
-0.549066782,
0.0971443206,
-0.0434200391,
0.0960305259,
-0.4554620087,
0.2667433023,
-0.6336665154,
-0.0153832333,
-0.259839952,
-0.6589601636,
-0.2210066468,
0.5407526493,
-0.2647847533,
0.842967391,
0.160684213,
-0.2667859197,
0.2994840741,
-0.6241164207,
-0.2143813968,
0.4484331012,
-0.508752346,
-0.5956267118,
-0.1209618971,
-0.1205912232,
0.5183353424,
-0.8113464117,
0.6374332309,
-0.1856478304,
-0.0433709882,
0.081539169,
-0.0460270159,
0.5614251494,
0.5057041049,
-0.479717046,
0.0931296945,
-0.7887040377,
0.3911862671,
0.3238570988,
-0.2460887581,
-0.2109222561,
0.0698570013,
-0.1311732978,
0.2885513306,
0.3388014734,
-0.3580777347,
0.1470700353,
0.0142560676,
0.1757819653,
0.6836544871,
0.2369675636,
0.3972553313,
-0.4810130894,
0.5662908554,
-0.1042476669,
-0.0319529772,
-0.3768959641,
-0.1923658997,
-0.7049798369,
-0.29564327,
-0.0587731414,
0.4677759707,
-1.0681225061,
0.4211143851,
-0.2470192462,
-0.6546884179,
-0.0648718849,
0.3514201343,
0.7533496618,
0.6906443834,
0.1622757465,
-0.2701644301,
-0.1615511775,
-0.6069467664,
-0.2200686336,
-0.201405704,
0.0602520332,
0.2469014674,
0.7304743528,
-0.4628531635,
1.1984454393,
-0.2751831412,
-0.2673205137,
-0.3636136353,
0.159068346,
-0.0174466111,
0.4507000744,
0.5264908075,
-0.757339716,
-0.3361717165,
0.2115153968,
-0.9012572765,
-0.2622033954,
-0.1428004354,
-0.1520099193,
0.2287077755,
0.2055344135,
-0.2841022909,
0.3921273053,
0.0950845405,
-0.3167956769,
0.5651428699,
-0.428755492,
-0.0730429813,
-1.0502989292,
0.1309762746,
0.2436291426,
-0.3148826957,
-0.7777449489,
0.2657247484,
-0.0689305812,
-0.2548242509,
-0.2830388844,
0.8959459066,
-0.6686114669,
-0.2449751049,
-0.6284326315,
0.0189568475,
0.05961629,
0.6231148839,
0.3632377982,
0.6171137691,
0.6522021294,
-0.7080672979,
0.3472016454,
0.2691363394,
-0.1686654389,
0.7156918049,
-0.6012588739,
0.085394077,
-0.1427047253,
0.0211871956,
-0.5402786136,
-0.2510208488,
0.2168019712,
-0.2073316425,
0.3860181272,
-0.1620447189,
-0.5013695955,
-0.1369638145,
-0.0074750539,
0.2001160383,
0.318851918,
-0.5931349993,
0.9387544394,
0.5040129423,
-0.3460557759,
-0.6143629551,
-0.4406867623,
0.1595715284,
-0.1543707103,
-0.6868636608,
0.0581670105,
-0.0881740004,
-0.4065210223,
-0.0196886491,
-0.0413865186,
-0.0098221051,
0.2070553154,
0.1856649369,
0.1908530444,
-0.0864651427,
0.1754184365,
0.2059290409,
-0.2287169546,
0.0538910888,
-0.4043399096,
0.3751761615,
-0.5060225129,
-0.6208592653,
0.0357356556,
0.4817132056,
0.4119512141,
-0.4311855733,
0.5512559414,
0.1285005659,
-0.5017629862,
-0.7833622098,
-0.4355030954,
0.0127393454,
-0.5037039518,
0.3853048682,
-0.5546888113,
-0.6668797731,
0.8084328771,
-0.5565609336,
0.2517392337,
0.1175529733,
0.8843901157,
0.4565941095,
0.7095335126,
0.5648907423,
0.0460752882,
0.4974575639,
-0.4393224418,
0.1074801236,
-0.479287684,
-0.320655793,
-0.5203490257,
0.1815141737,
-0.1954797506,
-0.2203026116,
0.6207486391,
-0.2156595886,
-0.6659846902,
0.1295100898,
-0.3986085951,
0.4873669147,
0.3023346961,
-0.2257982492,
0.2779520452,
-0.0173082761,
-0.1713586897,
0.2887151539,
-0.6599167585,
-0.867264092,
0.941170752,
0.480846107,
0.8090122938,
0.2027970403,
0.6088196635,
0.3375297785,
0.5455537438,
-0.7816873789,
0.6355255246,
0.4140746593,
-0.6206332445,
-0.3697005808,
-0.4320169091,
-0.7556439042,
0.3691300452,
-0.2017004788,
-0.6561772227,
0.1262337863,
0.0637046397,
-0.1301802099,
0.0974250883,
-0.5539833307,
0.8272826672,
-0.4739603102,
-0.7204335332,
0.0230808072,
-0.6507438421,
0.3136179745,
-0.3481400013,
0.4217657745,
0.2016585469,
-0.0825376287,
0.1791773587,
-0.935603261,
0.7743994594,
-0.4301342368,
-0.3912602067,
0.586717248,
0.1064436883,
0.5633987188,
0.0684714392,
-0.249371469,
-0.0615091883,
-0.2342466712,
-0.2134614736,
-0.570371747,
0.6961842775,
-0.7737985253,
-0.7770983577,
-0.3991299272,
-0.4036212564,
-0.2447557598,
0.2965663671,
0.0298287645,
0.5549321175,
-0.0580840856,
-0.1555130333,
0.6054288745,
-0.0449388772,
0.2922035456,
0.9065768123,
-0.433011055,
-0.421487838,
0.9745655656,
0.1100862026,
0.2091316432,
-0.0396183357,
0.038441807,
-0.1836628169,
-0.5607160926,
-0.7097994685,
0.1878457814,
-0.8854248524,
-0.4176607728,
-0.1913345605,
-0.3611781895,
-0.1831035465,
-0.3767290115,
-0.3828802705,
0.0848154947,
-0.1220966876,
0.12951985,
0.3463430703,
0.7563801408,
0.0147299776,
0.4837212861,
-0.6450819373,
0.2770173252,
0.2485731095,
0.4265216887,
-0.0386053585,
-0.4282283187,
-0.6113749743,
0.0401321799,
-0.5474428535,
-0.8457744122,
0.4982890189,
0.2698405683,
0.8439828753,
0.3339662552,
0.0311592501,
0.5386644006,
-0.5617666841,
0.7917054296,
-0.1016285047,
-1.0960122347,
0.4352355301,
-0.3855784535,
0.0439907834,
0.5343063474,
0.0726521984,
-0.168217957,
-0.3482155502,
-0.3416905403,
-0.8859618306,
0.6872550249,
0.00073262,
-0.0386594534,
0.0733937696,
0.7181333899,
0.3298344612,
0.3321150541,
-0.691411376,
-0.363214165,
-0.3310018182,
-0.0041161845,
-0.0273669176,
-0.0022781971,
-0.1812381446,
0.1169995889,
1.1177614927,
-0.4275746047,
0.0552406423,
0.140376687,
-0.1951770782,
-0.3217048049,
0.2700755,
0.4023110271,
0.5990165472,
0.1110506579,
-0.091333732,
0.0956102014,
-0.1681097597,
0.4956770837,
0.1700505763,
-0.2449582219,
-0.0430088863,
0.0439353175,
0.8000583053,
-0.1126091257,
-0.7403584123,
0.5112470388,
-0.0735773891,
-0.2305234522,
-0.7091883421,
0.2384839952,
-0.0819714516,
0.4490864575,
0.5915792584,
-0.2586044073,
0.1301050335,
-0.4198070765,
0.0949479118,
0.7372531891,
0.095324412,
-0.0821750462,
0.4582989514,
0.1199790984,
-0.3805646896,
0.0983603746,
-0.517830193,
-0.4986277223,
0.6527082324,
0.7038283348,
0.9917625189,
-0.2420677543,
0.1710782945,
0.2129695863,
0.0778538212,
-0.1136245802,
0.3054460883,
-0.3885490894,
-0.634404242,
-0.3762937486,
-0.6139129996,
-0.722281158,
0.2387069166,
-0.5195969939,
0.3961669803,
-0.4706128538,
-0.2010825872,
-0.2715022862,
0.1684342772,
-0.536798358,
0.2742371261,
0.0960894749,
0.8464735746,
-0.7842655778,
0.7243911624,
0.9592543244,
-0.3584943414,
-0.7998222113,
-0.044151891,
0.0092761284,
-0.5409424305,
0.4150609076,
-0.0005237734,
-0.4416163266,
-0.0371233299,
-0.7389668226,
-0.7917376757,
1.3827611208,
0.6106938124,
-0.2056062818,
0.1021085829,
0.268481493,
0.5889027119,
-0.6870319843,
0.2231447697,
0.2814149261,
0.336083293,
0.3929662406,
-0.7711695433,
0.0145484656,
-0.5168651342,
0.2960453928,
0.0063427887,
-0.7056649923,
0.8096823096,
-0.0409284793,
-0.1669495404,
0.0901739448,
0.6886659861,
0.6480448246,
0.5217506886,
0.4328395724,
0.3772241771,
0.6077006459,
0.3029502332,
0.7997159958,
-0.4818652868,
0.3670136631,
1.1619405746,
-0.7441632748,
0.5368266702,
0.3194911778,
0.3046077192,
0.6781900525,
0.4957579672,
0.0850202888,
0.4505012631,
0.4000605047,
-0.4047066271,
-0.4786487818,
-0.0482746288,
-0.372818619,
0.489156872,
0.5242340565,
-0.1827408373,
-0.5802262425,
0.1093700528,
0.0614512749,
0.3480606675,
-0.592846036,
0.8517824411,
-0.0512761772,
-0.8493812084,
0.6326859593,
0.1592311114,
0.3198949099,
-0.8534709215,
-0.096758984,
-0.0642659441,
0.2664041817,
0.1294951737,
-0.5748125315,
0.2055810988,
0.3472979367,
-0.1310456842,
-0.2914578319,
1.0041389465,
-0.3576071858,
-0.4156638682,
0.3431513906,
0.8080756068,
0.0535816401,
0.3463549018,
-0.6065875292,
-0.0822213739,
-0.2930895984,
-0.610708952,
0.3818834424,
0.7732932568,
-0.1670755595,
1.0145761967,
0.3675932288,
0.0171760973,
-0.1842423379,
-0.2446127236,
1.0362585783,
-0.4364272654,
-0.5212340355,
-0.6939181685,
0.3977587223,
0.0686590001,
-0.009303309,
0.6773162484,
0.4558044076,
0.7841885686,
0.0707523823,
1.1755090952,
0.1820535362,
0.4710713625,
-0.4740647972,
0.7302367687,
-0.7342686653,
0.5192001462,
-0.2472758144,
-0.6287323833,
-0.160710305,
0.5402039289,
-0.4195176959,
0.3384550214,
0.1497029066,
0.7142601013,
0.1546039283,
-0.0202749092,
0.2900473177,
-0.0795992091,
0.5013756156,
0.5347072482,
0.8229804635,
-0.0311862696,
0.1835391819,
0.1730650216,
-0.3494452834,
-0.0688173622,
-1.013248682,
-0.8372711539,
-0.6519492865,
-0.2097479552,
-0.2277265191,
-0.0496682152,
1.2264103889,
0.4220444858,
-0.5381143689,
-0.4954482317,
-0.2673532665,
0.1726509482,
0.0134059051,
-0.1925787181,
0.0005925025,
-0.598335743,
-0.5107111335,
0.2701982856,
-0.0186878946,
-0.0102886679,
-0.5402130485,
-0.4636752903,
0.1607477516,
0.2738169134,
0.3202653825,
0.5840959549,
-0.5091965199,
-0.1640288234,
-0.2279693484,
-0.1618531495,
-0.1296882033,
0.5881240964,
-1.0367299318,
0.5047159195,
0.1272745281,
0.8824317455,
0.2657036185,
-0.1283244491,
0.6178156137,
-0.6745823026,
-0.1149483919,
-0.0152043765,
0.5336210132,
0.3500100076,
-0.3021196723,
0.351257056,
0.0165915415,
-0.7457247376,
-0.8798807859,
0.3798969388,
-0.6866751909,
-0.3345259428,
1.2857350111,
-0.2755527794,
-0.4393496215,
-0.2085248828,
-0.2187351286,
0.2756198347,
-0.4130243063,
0.5852355361,
0.4208528399,
-0.0784782469,
0.1007430702,
-0.2893505692,
0.3232727349,
0.2084727585,
-0.877056241,
0.1512110084,
0.6673382521,
0.4008157551,
0.2766133547,
0.4790295064,
0.1662862748,
0.2099682689,
-0.0805093944,
0.3677003682,
-0.3969396949,
-0.3700838387,
-0.5150746107,
0.2483387589,
0.2626329958,
0.0258895997
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02380v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02380v3
|
Evaluating Large Language Models in Analysing Classroom Dialogue
| 2024-02-04T07:39:06 | 2024-02-23T02:19:09 |
Yun Long, Haifeng Luo, Yu Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
This study explores the application of Large Language Models (LLMs),
specifically GPT-4, in the analysis of classroom dialogue, a crucial research
task for both teaching diagnosis and quality improvement. Recognizing the
knowledge-intensive and labor-intensive nature of traditional qualitative
methods in educational research, this study investigates the potential of LLM
to streamline and enhance the analysis process. The study involves datasets
from a middle school, encompassing classroom dialogues across mathematics and
Chinese classes. These dialogues were manually coded by educational experts and
then analyzed using a customised GPT-4 model. This study focuses on comparing
manual annotations with the outputs of GPT-4 to evaluate its efficacy in
analyzing educational dialogues. Time efficiency, inter-coder agreement, and
inter-coder reliability between human coders and GPT-4 are evaluated. Results
indicate substantial time savings with GPT-4, and a high degree of consistency
in coding between the model and human coders, with some discrepancies in
specific codes. These findings highlight the strong potential of LLM in
teaching evaluation and facilitation.
|
[
-0.2598101795,
-0.9192738533,
0.6602495909,
0.0458640568,
-0.2685396671,
0.2365282476,
-0.4800358713,
-0.3338829279,
-0.317055583,
0.1921699941,
-0.1379536688,
-0.4592556655,
-0.5053880811,
0.213618055,
-0.5911584496,
0.8345148563,
0.0258004926,
0.5700156689,
-0.0405569412,
0.0741836056,
-0.4134986103,
-0.9140481353,
-0.903049171,
-0.2953819335,
0.3109931052,
0.1693337113,
0.7110173702,
0.2209416628,
0.4036896527,
0.4199592471,
-0.0580327809,
-0.1440096349,
-0.4926879108,
-0.2276736349,
-0.0350465775,
-0.2705126405,
-0.4184951484,
0.2064319998,
0.8975574374,
0.6472495198,
-0.3183715641,
0.120722428,
0.3400782049,
0.3318580091,
-0.1367164701,
0.5718587041,
-0.3309203088,
0.0829299316,
-0.1089091599,
-0.0760921985,
-0.2402846366,
-0.6601054668,
0.4307544529,
-0.2584608793,
0.0508302003,
-0.4214851856,
0.5944734812,
-0.1840284318,
-0.1745499372,
-0.4745151997,
-0.6388754845,
0.7834367156,
-1.1824822426,
0.2971989512,
0.3361081481,
0.3230553269,
-0.0852761641,
-0.71702075,
-0.6789405942,
-0.2655601799,
-0.0365742482,
0.1172345132,
-0.0050038272,
0.197543487,
0.2675501704,
0.5265524983,
-0.3733411431,
0.2179270685,
-0.4990642965,
-0.2394250184,
0.5000597239,
0.3760982752,
0.4949305654,
-0.1399811804,
-0.0384067185,
0.2769502997,
-0.5944798589,
-0.051849518,
0.4121154547,
0.143167302,
-0.0535960086,
0.1885577887,
0.0049794167,
0.8469893336,
-0.2668581307,
-0.4133366048,
-0.0409827381,
-0.5274819732,
-0.165342927,
-0.076441966,
0.8898572326,
0.5250846148,
0.363011837,
0.0093737394,
-0.2894668579,
0.1943174154,
-0.1101512015,
-1.0551781654,
-0.4465095699,
-0.1483108848,
-0.2375712842,
-0.1704940051,
-0.2987005413,
-0.7405108213,
0.0139213419,
-0.5749960542,
0.4377342761,
-0.2448468953,
-0.2072416544,
0.1961496025,
0.2776272595,
0.3069446087,
0.54478544,
-0.869094193,
0.288841635,
0.6054855585,
0.9908933043,
-0.0737002268,
-0.061940603,
-0.3328479826,
-0.0499189831,
-0.4829486907,
0.4356309474,
-0.8060892224,
-0.6852030754,
0.2476652116,
-0.1303801984,
-0.0954786316,
-0.4971094728,
0.4758338034,
-0.304777503,
0.6147984266,
-0.1988968849,
-0.6177870035,
-0.1588283479,
0.4884112775,
-0.6879230142,
0.8839089274,
0.453745544,
-0.4830487669,
-0.0328924246,
-0.5957240462,
-0.0537908934,
0.2754653692,
-0.5933436751,
-0.4317961633,
-0.158315137,
0.203315869,
0.5327512026,
-0.5013804436,
0.628271997,
-0.0231716484,
-0.7737550139,
0.3527779579,
-0.5709084868,
0.6736009121,
0.0924799442,
-0.4926562905,
0.0733073428,
-0.3947716653,
0.0918258354,
0.1834151,
-0.5011495948,
-0.152286917,
-0.1929550469,
-0.1912790239,
0.1449033171,
0.1842885762,
-0.4735369682,
0.3911366165,
-0.2957129478,
0.6093121767,
0.6708163023,
0.0354932249,
0.1465801895,
-0.2762685418,
0.7033917308,
-0.0892895237,
0.246281296,
-0.2810148895,
-0.5874310732,
-0.772482276,
0.0769094154,
0.3184987009,
0.1825414449,
-1.0181978941,
-0.1129276678,
-0.2110352814,
-0.2949124277,
-0.4689558148,
0.1981256306,
0.5843333006,
0.2823442519,
0.1574952006,
-0.5488635302,
-0.4234542251,
-0.6443945169,
-0.1203994453,
-0.2344048917,
-0.023142878,
0.2000937015,
0.3458458185,
-0.2059256136,
0.7763419747,
-0.2749449015,
-0.0848715976,
-0.4182424545,
-0.0267154183,
0.167482242,
0.2783952057,
0.5300605297,
-0.3780718744,
-0.6066064835,
-0.171543166,
-0.6882119179,
-0.1691538095,
0.0593699291,
-0.0324117802,
0.2331761867,
0.1662412435,
-0.4220692217,
0.4359091222,
0.6408184767,
-0.1393374205,
0.6922154427,
0.0219830945,
0.3373974264,
-0.7438756824,
-0.2570125461,
0.1036332771,
0.027357664,
-0.7162464261,
-0.1193063706,
-0.0373873822,
-0.2894043028,
-0.3390839398,
0.2886101007,
-0.4982438982,
-0.0951728821,
-0.1258646101,
0.5140453577,
-0.2209975719,
0.5436831713,
-0.0030426383,
0.9435697198,
0.1284595281,
-0.1424577236,
0.2621716559,
0.1765379757,
-0.6179994345,
0.2292023599,
-0.6786251664,
0.3721993566,
0.304228425,
0.3654010594,
-0.9558672309,
-0.1346475184,
0.1987053454,
-0.2866866887,
0.3526596725,
-0.2836160958,
-0.6606263518,
-0.419942826,
-0.3990336955,
0.4600055516,
0.5148711801,
-0.48638466,
0.2750177979,
0.2321681678,
-0.5418859124,
-0.3092237711,
-0.0848938748,
0.2604636848,
-0.1487582624,
-0.5018814206,
-0.1673468947,
-0.2251743972,
-0.2695679963,
-0.17157951,
-0.1572773457,
-0.2295790762,
0.0712792501,
0.039063897,
0.6365802884,
-0.4178284109,
0.0166437253,
-0.0633889213,
-0.0579557829,
0.3063802719,
-0.0628561154,
0.5678441525,
-0.276973784,
-0.3178085387,
-0.5084003806,
0.1624643952,
0.4486062229,
-0.0857561603,
0.4206271768,
0.4841216803,
-0.1417267472,
-0.143536061,
-0.6293371916,
-0.2618642151,
-0.5089311004,
0.3611274958,
-0.1620038748,
-1.1857277155,
0.1732584238,
-0.0542793833,
0.087786667,
-0.0191039611,
0.6645949483,
0.2351755947,
0.9291806221,
0.3890435398,
-0.3685285449,
0.6127702594,
-0.4159024656,
0.4843181372,
-0.8060435057,
-0.0276316106,
-0.3595311642,
0.1118098646,
-0.2799078226,
-0.5647764802,
0.4357595444,
-0.1580256224,
-0.3446248174,
-0.1354334205,
-0.5405826569,
0.6260553002,
0.1344846785,
-0.1041914821,
0.4141332805,
-0.1411644369,
0.0567826927,
-0.1597560942,
-0.7362689972,
-0.9061841369,
1.0404250622,
0.3775289953,
0.4892683923,
0.3695081174,
0.5156049728,
-0.1295816004,
0.7333551645,
-0.782636106,
0.7501356006,
0.0388486758,
-0.6166846156,
-0.5138050318,
-0.4651121795,
-0.9497906566,
0.5781632662,
0.0956705362,
-0.6733897328,
-0.4356384873,
-0.1251768023,
-0.3801217675,
0.35393852,
-0.8351948857,
0.8344293833,
-0.1902462095,
-0.389506042,
-0.0231072679,
-0.3984663188,
0.6583212614,
-0.4752063155,
0.3551135659,
-0.1014721021,
0.3972405791,
1.0510903597,
-0.3323191702,
1.0282319784,
-0.1839312762,
-0.4241520464,
0.5954970717,
0.011580674,
0.2006459981,
-0.0339033306,
-0.0373143032,
0.2341088951,
0.1654051244,
-0.3495797217,
-0.8214851022,
0.7947178483,
-1.0027681589,
-0.9478390217,
-0.44725734,
-0.4847510159,
-0.27718243,
-0.034961082,
-0.2350822091,
0.6991664171,
0.0289472453,
0.0606799237,
0.4393648505,
-0.4159842134,
0.6412854791,
0.7448503375,
-0.3479167819,
-0.1925273687,
0.7836244702,
0.5189007521,
0.4426125288,
-0.1224182844,
0.4044817388,
-0.2120715529,
-0.6010468006,
-0.3580385149,
0.3407195508,
-0.8134666681,
-0.1269915402,
-0.4510988593,
-0.4365861118,
-0.3521045148,
-0.0413559824,
-0.1061185822,
-0.2082636058,
-0.0603784658,
-0.2134281546,
0.1824190468,
0.9834644794,
0.2577556372,
0.5483790636,
-0.9117968678,
-0.0781656653,
0.5002045035,
0.3126047552,
0.3552784324,
-0.6271573901,
-0.5023605824,
0.0321541391,
-0.5169664621,
-0.7216726542,
0.3531450331,
0.0098510589,
0.4959533215,
0.2347033918,
-0.1711960137,
0.6804849505,
-0.6120806932,
1.2067945004,
0.2808238864,
-1.1723600626,
0.2003205866,
-0.4656730592,
0.3703138232,
0.1163769215,
0.2725544274,
-0.5151081681,
-0.4659162164,
-0.4842033088,
-0.6198717356,
0.655203402,
0.2217777967,
0.2216535956,
0.0602048263,
0.3014712334,
0.0242552534,
0.1893583387,
-0.6288648248,
0.0496035442,
-0.2439769655,
-0.2522321045,
-0.2744945884,
-0.5568474531,
-0.2160606682,
-0.3349728584,
0.4089391232,
0.0338077992,
0.2238413244,
-0.1297673434,
0.0033384657,
-0.0075063058,
0.6291942596,
0.4812856019,
0.9499036074,
0.1032402739,
0.0053692283,
0.3116404414,
-0.6776284575,
0.2195754498,
0.0480402634,
0.2328388691,
0.1207092479,
0.4936211705,
0.5628595352,
0.6466143131,
-0.4897587895,
0.7104192972,
-0.133946538,
-0.102671653,
-0.4533320963,
0.1398312002,
0.1091928035,
0.2548269331,
0.2339037359,
-0.7490888238,
0.2961974442,
-0.7511710525,
0.0943042561,
0.1540917456,
-0.1168932095,
-0.4851278663,
0.3210791945,
0.3981214464,
-0.3487774432,
0.7399706244,
0.091623269,
-0.6972075105,
0.4370295405,
0.6778498888,
0.6396932006,
-0.5384154916,
0.2473686934,
0.3339984417,
0.2427592278,
-0.0808169842,
0.1182317808,
0.0204494968,
-0.688082993,
-0.7975878716,
-0.4815900028,
-0.7428400517,
0.3202401102,
-0.6188669801,
0.0149637433,
-0.4019092917,
-0.1792860478,
-0.0121944631,
0.2941961884,
-0.5098715425,
0.0757751018,
0.0942909867,
0.4360847473,
-0.7154180408,
1.0757468939,
0.5703967214,
-0.3629049659,
-1.263219595,
-0.2115518302,
0.161720857,
-0.7037581205,
0.725435555,
0.1727525741,
-0.0830867514,
0.0419892222,
-0.6443488002,
-0.6461108327,
1.0658273697,
0.1065448299,
-0.9289848804,
-0.0792837292,
0.1127520353,
0.7152457833,
-0.3394572735,
0.5192924738,
0.9356353879,
0.4081270695,
0.0867303088,
-1.1829189062,
-0.0354833677,
-0.206134215,
0.1375621259,
0.2608275115,
-0.6219208241,
0.7836266756,
-0.0773207694,
-0.2481820881,
0.2044863701,
0.3515600264,
0.3484067619,
0.4131960571,
0.1986756027,
0.2078571469,
0.5183023214,
-0.2644499242,
0.8901973963,
-0.3418908119,
0.5351522565,
1.0599342585,
-0.3533897698,
0.6095284224,
0.2893862426,
-0.5635607839,
0.3387566805,
0.531832993,
0.0173614826,
0.0110035921,
0.4724547267,
-0.5515275002,
-0.0108838845,
0.1952968836,
-0.4110016525,
0.1739862859,
0.6153787374,
0.0221577659,
-0.2078285515,
-0.115625374,
0.3080650866,
0.0644656047,
-0.3762917817,
0.7255677581,
0.2616944611,
-0.4587670267,
0.7112004161,
-0.1815268546,
0.4731507003,
-0.3335633278,
-0.2705874741,
-0.3237862587,
0.0311898123,
-0.2662144899,
-0.6947343349,
-0.1005821228,
0.0950173885,
0.3474020958,
-0.0150738191,
0.3899858594,
-0.8225783706,
-0.3354702592,
0.05023266,
0.4161821902,
0.3592622578,
0.391467452,
-0.5567324758,
0.4659697711,
0.1337771416,
-0.215803802,
0.4393875301,
0.6437052488,
-0.0985072628,
0.5000190139,
0.5967811346,
-0.0713028833,
-0.0230586026,
0.4326492846,
1.1312609911,
-0.695687294,
-0.085158363,
-0.8256121874,
0.4587055445,
-0.0142870871,
-0.1062212959,
0.9314187169,
0.4957636595,
0.8183680773,
-0.0309766904,
1.0276827812,
0.4714324474,
0.434106648,
-0.6189296246,
0.5251663327,
0.1561000943,
0.5245415568,
-0.6381258368,
-1.0325989723,
-0.221921742,
0.7899471521,
-0.7371299267,
0.1969112158,
0.8502699733,
0.5136697888,
0.1543930024,
0.3305957913,
0.6670224667,
0.2712211609,
0.7637786865,
0.5495473146,
1.3301870823,
-0.2515257299,
0.3826191723,
-0.0568882339,
-0.3434490263,
-0.2417848706,
-0.4750894904,
-1.2472683191,
-0.4262403548,
-0.3446124792,
-0.2533135116,
0.1277442127,
0.7867892981,
0.3013781905,
-0.3967195153,
-0.4913745522,
0.4714470208,
-0.1349935383,
0.3933210969,
-0.2053572983,
0.3628200293,
-0.3809894919,
-0.9130969644,
0.2210257947,
0.1253380626,
0.2108006477,
-0.4640812278,
-0.0929216594,
0.148041755,
0.2301065475,
0.8885141611,
-0.1692301929,
-0.8102748394,
-0.4596013725,
-0.2463506758,
-0.0874824971,
-0.0308241285,
0.9675295353,
-0.4156067073,
0.6526944637,
-0.0957729444,
0.6263995171,
0.4806657732,
-0.0911226496,
0.6148371696,
-0.1894373149,
0.0494146682,
0.2866497636,
0.3456023335,
0.458565712,
-0.0966393128,
0.6891796589,
0.1377758831,
-0.8364760876,
-0.8173343539,
-0.013734689,
-0.7847680449,
-0.1069222316,
1.2826286554,
-0.5924955606,
-0.0108927395,
-0.2745913267,
-0.5211219788,
0.2175042033,
-0.3671294749,
0.8498664498,
1.0565012693,
-0.0027213118,
-0.2598497272,
-0.9137259126,
0.4257716537,
0.1599041224,
-0.6584450006,
-0.2070866376,
0.6446735859,
0.4333501756,
-0.0254685842,
0.7503441572,
-0.4811116755,
0.1207647771,
-0.2392013967,
-0.0648174509,
0.1142142639,
0.0563265607,
-0.4313907921,
0.0837183371,
0.2291037589,
0.0930593312
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02379v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02379v1
|
Rethinking the Evaluation of Pre-trained Text-and-Layout Models from an Entity-Centric Perspective
| 2024-02-04T07:33:45 | 2024-02-04T07:33:45 |
Chong Zhang, Yixi Zhao, Chenshu Yuan, Yi Tu, Ya Guo, Qi Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recently developed pre-trained text-and-layout models (PTLMs) have shown
remarkable success in multiple information extraction tasks on visually-rich
documents. However, the prevailing evaluation pipeline may not be sufficiently
robust for assessing the information extraction ability of PTLMs, due to
inadequate annotations within the benchmarks. Therefore, we claim the necessary
standards for an ideal benchmark to evaluate the information extraction ability
of PTLMs. We then introduce EC-FUNSD, an entity-centric benckmark designed for
the evaluation of semantic entity recognition and entity linking on
visually-rich documents. This dataset contains diverse formats of document
layouts and annotations of semantic-driven entities and their relations.
Moreover, this dataset disentangles the falsely coupled annotation of segment
and entity that arises from the block-level annotation of FUNSD. Experiment
results demonstrate that state-of-the-art PTLMs exhibit overfitting tendencies
on the prevailing benchmarks, as their performance sharply decrease when the
dataset bias is removed.
|
[
-0.765979588,
-0.6730476022,
0.6488778591,
-0.1371501237,
-0.7133168578,
-0.0950071663,
-0.2449173927,
-0.6847212315,
0.2107071877,
0.6143404841,
-0.4485316575,
-0.6730914712,
-0.4674425423,
0.2070899606,
-0.5461807251,
1.064396739,
-0.161097303,
-0.0475020483,
-0.3950058222,
-0.1487152278,
-0.1407206357,
-0.3234549761,
-0.1385591477,
0.026544353,
0.5270838141,
-0.0511498973,
0.4353676438,
0.9038908482,
0.644035697,
0.2158783525,
0.152541846,
0.1591551006,
-0.1894572228,
0.139675796,
-0.3538636565,
-0.2552296221,
-0.4489274323,
0.1370045394,
0.4669178128,
0.7758045793,
0.164774999,
0.1064959466,
0.0584606677,
0.3309208751,
-0.9349859953,
0.0591467135,
-0.6472091079,
-0.0340408124,
-0.4627771974,
-0.2474482208,
-0.4835553467,
-0.312502414,
0.5736246705,
-0.9943346381,
0.1436045021,
0.4408003092,
1.0733656883,
0.3527121544,
-0.2319696397,
-0.3663531542,
-0.4736045897,
0.8193187118,
-0.3171133697,
0.8166694045,
0.2769852281,
0.1483168006,
0.1099083871,
-0.8431076407,
-0.5296000242,
0.0060720169,
-0.0678416267,
0.1048735455,
-0.005662228,
-0.0646428987,
0.4691798389,
0.2016797215,
-0.3572883606,
0.0721234828,
-0.0274253394,
-0.0544088148,
0.5934232473,
-0.1086568013,
0.3382301927,
-0.382851094,
-0.7457901239,
-0.2403561026,
-0.5767231584,
-0.1834708154,
0.3855686784,
0.0955394581,
0.0797344968,
0.509344697,
0.0163258296,
0.5797615647,
0.046197582,
0.080570966,
0.4187994897,
-0.2086716592,
-0.4964345396,
0.3617118299,
0.5142649412,
0.3346650302,
0.398303479,
-0.4173438847,
-0.2161984742,
0.0919637457,
0.7794225812,
-0.8688535094,
-0.2306897491,
0.1990928948,
-0.5023973584,
-0.1119418964,
0.3127768934,
-0.9293193221,
-0.2546980679,
-0.5315337181,
0.4603970349,
-0.6488156915,
-0.2017539293,
-0.0261325352,
-0.3074740469,
0.2077902704,
0.5247678757,
-0.5750184655,
0.1110484749,
0.8878020048,
0.4301034808,
-0.4241759479,
-0.3642444611,
-0.2468573004,
0.3128657043,
-0.319717288,
0.9517464042,
-0.6657703519,
-0.4328411222,
-0.0707629845,
0.0128845759,
-0.1241637617,
-0.435033977,
0.8783495426,
-0.5410077572,
0.1151516289,
-0.5353848934,
-0.6803283691,
-0.0480276085,
0.4428337216,
-0.9082695246,
0.9873758554,
0.2361314893,
-1.2650922537,
1.1495045424,
-0.4705378115,
-0.3836292326,
0.1177135035,
-0.3807111681,
-0.4694646895,
0.2069620341,
0.0533668138,
0.1936365068,
-0.1615693122,
0.1205314919,
-0.6216589212,
-0.309736371,
0.2448632866,
-0.361241132,
0.5499771237,
0.0700982064,
-0.3856628537,
0.0248889681,
-1.1793197393,
0.2795511782,
-0.0212742016,
-0.2796621919,
-1.0948656797,
-0.0570009276,
0.0422350988,
0.2780066729,
0.1186054125,
-0.76836586,
-0.0410783701,
-0.2405680716,
0.0176780801,
0.5674634576,
-0.0946998969,
0.3505298197,
0.0478178822,
0.0964496881,
0.0266613532,
0.0702412426,
-0.2944401205,
0.0494534001,
-0.7272104025,
-0.7673386931,
0.4174459875,
0.089517124,
-0.8162151575,
0.699800849,
-0.5557878017,
-0.5549916625,
-0.2841362655,
-0.1298267394,
0.367289722,
0.747582674,
0.5776343942,
-0.8604764342,
-0.5604470372,
-0.8557210565,
-0.3231422603,
-0.0398949236,
-0.0810191706,
0.1260697544,
0.5391380787,
0.0627960339,
0.9298423529,
0.0138451969,
-0.1402399987,
-0.118486546,
0.1242871508,
-0.3792942166,
0.5071806312,
0.4683674276,
-0.952396512,
-0.1575906426,
-0.1195132583,
-0.686401248,
-0.0155307315,
0.0419169851,
-0.3998959363,
0.0963017866,
0.0994678736,
-0.8158083558,
0.8052461743,
0.0529883951,
-0.4013884962,
0.6293238401,
-0.0390716866,
0.1198149398,
-0.6217276454,
0.2438842356,
0.1448609084,
-0.0373400263,
-0.341345787,
-0.13419424,
0.4505811036,
0.1282639652,
-0.3868367374,
0.5632435083,
-0.6780110002,
-0.6381444931,
-0.0254078545,
0.3535083234,
0.6707168221,
0.3911978602,
0.39413625,
0.2145816237,
0.2146232128,
-0.401034534,
-0.0655312017,
0.3107789755,
-0.4660260379,
1.2375208139,
-0.3867230415,
-0.058969751,
-0.1534512192,
0.3251695335,
-0.7290894985,
-0.1023959592,
0.1070644408,
0.1755979061,
0.6048844457,
0.0919338986,
-0.5976805091,
-0.2708486915,
-0.5311583281,
0.3350149691,
-0.0901385397,
-0.6893306971,
0.6850922704,
0.2702803314,
0.1424503177,
-0.4065918028,
-0.5393478274,
-0.2279322892,
-0.3711190224,
-0.5081924796,
0.743496716,
0.296117425,
-0.2169443518,
0.2239057273,
-0.4506385624,
-0.0723751783,
0.1866706461,
0.386217773,
0.4991495013,
-0.1063464209,
0.1430172622,
-0.0355194695,
-0.1519963592,
0.0929616168,
-0.3251670599,
0.3914712965,
0.0520815775,
-0.7477163672,
-0.2886534929,
0.2599576414,
0.2674387395,
-0.6607407928,
0.509252429,
0.5391548276,
-0.5159233809,
-0.1148897633,
-0.5540977716,
0.0826788396,
-0.323566258,
0.5445426702,
-0.4367872179,
-0.4161473513,
0.1313700378,
-0.1190866008,
0.3401874006,
0.5463875532,
0.1430964768,
-0.1383949965,
0.6605371237,
0.7025684714,
0.5833941102,
0.4861863554,
-0.2319449484,
0.095024012,
-1.0792986155,
-0.5219962001,
-0.774481833,
-0.2258195579,
-0.4358844459,
-0.1105279252,
-0.0317943804,
0.2818563581,
-0.2592993379,
0.5017496347,
-0.4901248813,
0.1018452942,
0.3564222455,
-0.007814737,
0.2437299341,
-0.0105790105,
-0.2514705658,
-0.2863042951,
-0.3578051925,
-0.7940616608,
1.1479235888,
0.375601083,
0.6349025965,
-0.2167305797,
0.7642329931,
-0.0138472859,
0.6359220147,
-0.4620760083,
0.3682487905,
-0.0992604941,
-0.6067144275,
-0.4006253481,
-0.2492859215,
-0.7431291938,
0.3418750465,
-0.1326511204,
-0.9293369055,
0.4918474853,
-0.2524037659,
-0.2550054789,
0.1544248164,
-0.8211473227,
1.0580980778,
-0.586447835,
-0.5759638548,
0.0828004256,
-0.4051895142,
0.0071505373,
-0.2587684989,
0.1755649894,
-0.069539547,
-0.2179165035,
0.8124125004,
-0.3904529512,
0.2954160571,
-0.134815529,
-0.1569228172,
0.2236578763,
0.0976480767,
0.3046341538,
-0.092692703,
-0.2097717822,
0.2051255852,
0.1824120581,
-0.2398087829,
-0.6131654978,
0.5278497338,
-0.5280678272,
-0.3104059994,
-0.2775243223,
-0.1667444408,
-0.2541323602,
0.4435492158,
0.3278499544,
0.6622024775,
-0.2741226554,
0.3325469792,
0.6480256319,
-0.0493651628,
0.6269239187,
0.2877072692,
-0.0975198597,
-0.3226174414,
0.7453206778,
0.3111895323,
0.0512213372,
0.2881115079,
-0.4891171455,
-0.5928240418,
-0.4272291064,
-0.555064857,
0.1201730147,
-0.8537190557,
0.0937819555,
-0.805875659,
-0.1722659022,
0.0426406674,
-0.118617624,
-0.5838088989,
-0.2957984209,
-0.2210542709,
-0.1022355705,
-0.4000047743,
0.4067464173,
0.4014731646,
-0.0824424401,
-0.4308034182,
0.0783726498,
0.1033214033,
0.6117321253,
-0.0516990311,
-0.1342259794,
-0.1384904981,
-0.3690533936,
-0.315431118,
-0.9176184535,
0.0585848168,
-0.0842731744,
0.9096654654,
0.4384429157,
0.0245298631,
0.5261279345,
-0.4329773486,
0.5064092875,
0.1564468592,
-0.7286663055,
0.4828143418,
0.134529084,
-0.091859594,
0.6738736033,
0.4902653992,
0.0780200288,
-0.07631246,
-0.9456002712,
-0.838163197,
0.4837599993,
0.2138303071,
-0.2109915763,
-0.1047388241,
0.1470544338,
0.4144046903,
0.5274840593,
-0.5327764153,
-0.018787818,
-0.5635470748,
-0.3879313171,
0.32899189,
-0.3063741624,
0.1105360314,
0.1725671738,
0.5920777917,
0.000885585,
-0.0024594357,
0.4529660344,
-0.4382964075,
-0.0169891957,
0.4751796126,
0.120341517,
0.9355293512,
-0.2205012292,
0.4455909431,
-0.1415319443,
-0.4962705374,
-0.1764965355,
0.6236732006,
-0.2298701257,
0.1812094301,
0.5501505733,
0.7652391791,
0.5049027205,
-0.6139100194,
0.5235470533,
-0.2153041959,
0.1888792962,
-0.0065174755,
0.1116436794,
-0.3825636208,
0.0310260858,
0.358774066,
-0.1329436153,
0.198152557,
-0.379460007,
0.4345947802,
0.6066411138,
-0.630227387,
-0.4280422926,
0.5459287167,
0.3214416206,
-0.1169084311,
0.1426492631,
-0.080238305,
-0.4486662447,
0.4886967838,
0.2781288922,
0.8041490316,
0.1076783463,
0.1426585764,
0.2467739135,
0.2820784152,
0.2152155042,
-0.0156504624,
-0.3631150424,
-0.3147848248,
-0.1018305719,
-0.8458288908,
-0.1891781241,
0.008277718,
-0.7275314331,
0.5523764491,
-0.4337074161,
-0.2208580226,
0.3193665743,
0.4034684598,
-1.0263286829,
0.5539139509,
0.1717296392,
1.1285393238,
-0.3721754849,
0.7902669311,
0.7815027833,
-0.4442259967,
-0.59614712,
0.0306728482,
-0.3112961352,
-0.316424489,
0.4977318943,
0.5293161273,
0.2802867293,
-0.0051136394,
-0.2306871265,
-0.6909126639,
1.21827209,
0.265104115,
-0.6153063178,
-0.188056156,
0.0298809875,
0.5872542262,
-0.586212337,
0.450986892,
0.5668261051,
0.4448380768,
-0.2159712464,
-0.7630041838,
0.0553929806,
-0.2210683376,
-0.0225261375,
0.2072436661,
-0.3856829405,
0.8136140704,
0.1971028745,
-0.3640937209,
-0.0737615973,
0.3881881833,
0.421051085,
0.4216089845,
0.7540996671,
0.7736521959,
0.6375539899,
-0.2645598054,
1.012283206,
-0.158539772,
0.2839251459,
1.2152028084,
-0.591801703,
0.7308087945,
0.6777309179,
0.037428163,
0.6166446805,
0.565481782,
-0.0110510746,
0.6993297338,
0.0626599714,
0.202955693,
-0.2346187532,
-0.311327666,
-0.5127617121,
0.3574061692,
0.365673691,
-0.5933610797,
-0.5454479456,
-0.3112466931,
-0.1491942704,
-0.0677559823,
-0.1230677217,
0.5820648074,
0.0883298591,
-0.6367868781,
-0.0139122866,
-0.038114883,
0.3329526782,
-0.3644503951,
0.0001186113,
0.0586260967,
-0.0906373709,
-0.1732127815,
-0.6950351596,
0.1583543718,
0.0545479245,
0.0016423861,
-0.0623376369,
1.0587916374,
-0.2761327326,
-0.2794157267,
0.3314519525,
0.5260848999,
-0.0086102309,
-0.0666698068,
-0.4845709503,
0.3751221597,
-0.3047271371,
-0.4839767814,
0.300989449,
0.8341872692,
-0.1985990256,
0.3265115619,
0.5950423479,
0.0021367192,
0.0732982159,
0.1150903925,
0.8170637488,
-0.4965996444,
-0.8360384107,
-0.8689799905,
0.5511343479,
-0.4885584414,
-0.3571284711,
0.6519952416,
0.6714571118,
1.0127346516,
0.3171745241,
0.7115923762,
-0.0327410921,
0.299058646,
-0.4464935958,
0.6076660752,
-0.5331968665,
0.3052001297,
-0.6323673725,
-1.2955358028,
0.0530808344,
0.4332702458,
-0.6371002197,
0.1964534819,
0.7669816613,
0.1348844469,
-0.246010825,
0.4918427169,
0.2212223113,
-0.2296660542,
0.3119007349,
0.4043836594,
0.9344466329,
-0.1939019859,
0.518810451,
-0.4591680169,
-0.077869162,
-0.2038314939,
-1.0178376436,
-1.0007371902,
-0.5236220956,
-0.4419412017,
-0.127816692,
-0.0455277301,
0.6008517146,
0.7585392594,
-0.4206382632,
0.5688926578,
-0.0057073822,
0.0692837089,
0.1849106848,
-0.1815868318,
0.7344357967,
-0.0757664666,
-0.5318772197,
-0.2135171443,
0.5767281651,
0.1817622632,
-0.4556750059,
0.1306274682,
0.00483693,
-0.0493678339,
0.2758056521,
0.0197321959,
-0.6345080137,
-0.5174843073,
-0.1899137199,
-0.4828895628,
0.0579809733,
0.6363239288,
-0.762139976,
0.4361101389,
0.0862123296,
0.8285577297,
0.2783221006,
0.2084357888,
0.0637324601,
-0.6326113939,
0.2151986808,
-0.0076129558,
0.4747855365,
0.5632199645,
-0.1954616904,
0.5729507208,
0.169610247,
-0.0771480724,
-0.9243346453,
-0.0485042185,
-0.9080893397,
-0.1002014875,
0.7617391944,
-0.5560474992,
-0.6522809863,
-0.0575111136,
-0.1756479293,
0.4162878096,
-0.1518813819,
0.7472110987,
0.7976824641,
0.0301980097,
0.0427841507,
-0.3218511641,
0.4455707669,
0.3941176236,
-1.1513446569,
-0.0784541741,
0.588128686,
0.1307854354,
0.5250068307,
0.4351329207,
-0.2556392252,
0.3097942173,
0.0569297858,
0.0739882663,
-0.1518687308,
-0.5473326445,
0.0685476139,
0.3678583205,
-0.123187609,
-0.1584262848
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02370v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02370v2
|
AutoTimes: Autoregressive Time Series Forecasters via Large Language Models
| 2024-02-04T06:59:21 | 2024-05-23T01:58:28 |
Yong Liu, Guo Qin, Xiangdong Huang, Jianmin Wang, Mingsheng Long
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Foundation models of time series have not been fully developed due to the
limited availability of time series corpora and the underexploration of
scalable pre-training. Based on the similar sequential formulation of time
series and natural language, increasing research demonstrates the feasibility
of leveraging large language models (LLM) for time series. Nevertheless, the
inherent autoregressive property and decoder-only architecture of LLMs have not
been fully considered, resulting in insufficient utilization of LLM abilities.
To further exploit the general-purpose token transition and multi-step
generation ability of large language models, we propose AutoTimes to repurpose
LLMs as autoregressive time series forecasters, which independently projects
time series segments into the embedding space and autoregressively generates
future predictions with arbitrary lengths. Compatible with any decoder-only
LLMs, the consequent forecaster exhibits the flexibility of the lookback length
and scalability of the LLM size. Further, we formulate time series as prompts,
extending the context for prediction beyond the lookback window, termed
in-context forecasting. By adopting textual timestamps as position embeddings,
AutoTimes integrates multimodality for multivariate scenarios. Empirically,
AutoTimes achieves state-of-the-art with 0.1% trainable parameters and over 5
times training/inference speedup compared to advanced LLM-based forecasters.
|
[
-0.1897759736,
-0.4393358529,
0.4099286199,
0.472250104,
-0.2802833021,
0.2282800674,
0.0214150064,
-0.4651074111,
0.1642616987,
0.2460820824,
-0.57939744,
-0.0211448669,
-0.6076372266,
-0.0556697957,
-0.7884016633,
0.7626598477,
-0.2310503125,
-0.0881749168,
0.1975108832,
0.1039923206,
-0.2265781909,
-0.5577936172,
-0.4473990798,
-0.1846776754,
0.3125854433,
0.0839061737,
0.7650676966,
0.9299829006,
0.0574041493,
0.307716161,
0.4479290843,
-0.0056637498,
-0.0393303074,
0.3742609024,
0.2163170576,
-0.0256011263,
-0.3971972764,
-0.0709435642,
0.7658934593,
0.6145637035,
-0.3343623877,
0.2506488562,
-0.095953621,
0.3669819236,
-0.5698662996,
0.5714101791,
-0.4338630438,
0.31575948,
0.0849104598,
-0.1429071426,
-0.2662159204,
-0.2523577511,
0.1684009135,
-0.2525026202,
0.1872790754,
0.363086462,
0.3461237848,
0.5458375812,
-0.4782212675,
0.0864505321,
-0.9741071463,
0.8431369662,
-0.9705621004,
0.583358705,
-0.0364890993,
0.6185585856,
-0.0052192896,
-0.5981262326,
-0.3653215766,
-0.1178969592,
0.0015295411,
-0.0051937038,
-0.0933317617,
-0.3651247025,
0.2085784078,
0.4213739038,
-0.6437277198,
0.1501432657,
0.2431499809,
0.0385736972,
0.4867551923,
0.575309515,
-0.1647448838,
0.0310863182,
-0.4396798611,
-0.0218422655,
-0.4117404819,
-0.1612514555,
0.1013607159,
0.2713620961,
-0.0499908999,
0.325817287,
-0.0421141945,
0.5283384323,
0.1348131746,
-0.1084531248,
0.1078554839,
-0.2312966287,
-0.5543973446,
-0.0613826513,
0.8093628883,
0.0357261859,
-0.0155809261,
-0.2853661776,
-0.1658263057,
-0.2247183919,
-0.1530308872,
-1.0661659241,
-0.2765188813,
0.0252501741,
-0.4112557471,
-0.1630001217,
-0.2317259461,
-0.9238072634,
-0.0810241476,
-0.515227437,
0.1749045104,
-0.3243786097,
-0.207581237,
0.0483794361,
0.0572796464,
0.2799038887,
0.3381587863,
-0.926486969,
0.2627465427,
0.2801485658,
0.7039168477,
-0.0215823669,
-0.3856400847,
-0.5556014776,
0.4257746041,
-0.3253185451,
0.5767576694,
-0.3963325322,
-0.5504740477,
-0.0664511174,
0.2546392083,
-0.0836577341,
-0.0135109341,
-0.3541088998,
-0.6258100867,
0.2403886914,
0.2474389672,
-0.4454120994,
-0.0090490468,
0.1757863611,
-0.4875875711,
0.7724291682,
0.0394316353,
-0.3302066028,
0.4108906686,
-0.4181886911,
-0.6298388839,
-0.3374707103,
-0.0211011674,
-0.2496698499,
-0.2507506311,
0.6734978557,
0.6589102149,
-0.5337067842,
0.5845643878,
-0.4439956546,
0.2353344411,
0.0238331296,
-0.9960339665,
0.4812695682,
0.4085395932,
-0.490809083,
-0.1072026789,
-0.6582298279,
-0.0725859851,
0.0292412862,
0.0725602806,
-0.2348905951,
0.172949329,
0.2453323454,
0.2717103362,
0.3459839821,
-0.3877843916,
0.3224794269,
-0.4371730983,
0.6749562621,
0.6730856895,
-0.1410817653,
0.4949814379,
-0.0508197621,
0.8118637204,
0.1495557725,
0.3789644539,
-0.6575651765,
-0.0495709032,
-0.6140028834,
-0.3284075856,
-0.0665265769,
0.4975453019,
-0.6743407845,
0.3801988363,
-0.3587410152,
-0.6811097264,
0.2055146545,
0.0774547011,
0.2203262746,
0.2628100514,
0.3675587773,
-0.1064946502,
-0.546554327,
-0.678294003,
-0.276697427,
-0.0863685757,
0.1664633453,
0.0094655976,
0.4405735731,
-0.2574750185,
0.9990645647,
-0.5570082664,
0.1486694217,
-0.043649029,
0.3477363586,
0.2073926777,
0.3548785746,
0.5391462445,
-0.5493814945,
-0.3987482786,
-0.4608733058,
-0.5710029006,
0.0922492594,
0.0460351706,
0.2611981928,
0.3820348382,
0.8622687459,
-0.2738173306,
0.3036511242,
0.7106485367,
-0.5084188581,
0.4324372411,
-0.1072653159,
-0.1403973401,
-1.3825610876,
0.0052111112,
-0.0677467659,
-0.4256822467,
-0.0961700454,
-0.5255076289,
-0.162123248,
-0.3974336386,
-0.2909146249,
1.0457744598,
-0.6384766102,
-0.3355550468,
-0.1177864075,
-0.3575707674,
0.1568450481,
0.0230181366,
0.0619818717,
0.6945772767,
0.3435894251,
-0.7479614615,
0.3989613354,
0.0658484399,
-0.4011128247,
0.2008170933,
-0.4836444855,
-0.2246197611,
-0.0479871035,
0.6122959852,
-0.8173410892,
-0.0784708336,
-0.0506364703,
-0.1253538728,
0.5294347405,
-0.1717544645,
-0.5118624568,
-0.4796695411,
0.0516611896,
0.5266461372,
0.4011076987,
-0.6829158664,
0.8329569101,
0.2814493775,
-0.3157103658,
-0.7372481227,
-0.7808225155,
0.263409555,
-0.1999565959,
-0.2889137268,
0.2808364034,
-0.3238617778,
-0.2132710367,
0.0159841962,
0.2224433273,
0.0084188292,
0.0295895543,
0.1597287208,
0.4176674485,
-0.2355631292,
0.0893806145,
-0.1241340786,
-0.2341440618,
0.0474521331,
-0.7451222539,
0.5131310821,
-0.2477076352,
-0.3243160248,
-0.1042521819,
0.3281156123,
0.8235492706,
-0.2513855994,
0.6522576213,
0.6238948107,
-0.2657763362,
-0.1658785641,
-0.6699770689,
-0.1044066176,
-0.4423223436,
0.3768850267,
-0.0871187374,
-0.8409292102,
0.4314640164,
0.0523677692,
0.2405593842,
0.4372478724,
0.56411165,
0.2290524989,
1.149664402,
0.5972852707,
-0.5440719724,
0.7159612775,
-0.3841446936,
0.2448415309,
-0.6802678704,
-0.1188337058,
-0.1588987112,
-0.0941109881,
-0.2603741586,
-0.3242141604,
0.2656361461,
-0.3448651433,
-0.7647529244,
0.4933953881,
-0.2242446691,
0.1513195634,
0.2845150828,
-0.4648557901,
0.1754888445,
-0.0375007056,
0.1128426939,
0.0447585471,
-0.8099355698,
-0.1875102073,
0.9804444313,
0.4589833319,
1.1336522102,
-0.1897069961,
0.2974945903,
0.3543783724,
0.5252213478,
-0.7528930306,
0.2866707742,
-0.4291696548,
-0.4376403093,
-0.3828251064,
-0.1637016535,
-0.5900506973,
-0.0917982012,
0.1553664207,
-0.3290563822,
0.579934597,
0.182953909,
-0.4778363109,
0.4702084959,
-0.3639964163,
0.8498378396,
-0.3009556234,
-0.2541068196,
-0.0682795197,
-0.5858671665,
0.1028495729,
0.0061127795,
0.3598227203,
-0.1977231801,
-0.1691750586,
0.445979774,
-0.5274620652,
1.0263453722,
-0.1627524495,
-0.1951433718,
0.0919877514,
0.2850996256,
0.4056073725,
0.1855232269,
-0.0290456228,
0.0650238022,
0.0963342562,
-0.2053349465,
-0.5234632492,
0.8493610024,
-0.6258606911,
-0.3249051273,
-0.6170372367,
-0.4942809641,
-0.3964392245,
0.0211549252,
0.1644904166,
0.9425027966,
-0.4688029587,
-0.0111770872,
0.2831972539,
0.1098098978,
1.1208593845,
0.7424069047,
-0.40514189,
-0.6573933363,
0.6987614036,
0.0000673936,
0.1220028922,
0.5795938373,
0.1353931576,
-0.6391006708,
-0.2190008909,
-0.5179624557,
0.1796469539,
-0.5569165945,
-0.3133334219,
-0.6411167979,
-0.2786885202,
-0.6184726954,
-0.2501012981,
-0.5333419442,
-0.4515813291,
-0.4035305381,
0.0775673017,
0.3891732693,
0.6220203638,
-0.1246755347,
0.3748760521,
-0.9017800689,
0.1757568866,
0.6102121472,
0.3399625719,
0.1813886166,
-0.6078819633,
-0.4585403502,
-0.2939003706,
-0.1710852534,
-0.39389956,
1.1443612576,
0.1710886955,
0.2578590512,
0.4353307188,
-0.1276921034,
0.7941346169,
-0.7994928956,
0.7211333513,
0.1760571599,
-0.9808770418,
0.2939001322,
-0.339359045,
0.396153152,
0.0690429509,
0.2511181831,
-0.5808104277,
-0.3182583153,
-0.3981967568,
-1.0054290295,
0.4748653769,
-0.2820904255,
0.1083441451,
-0.3491596878,
0.1991155446,
0.2691681087,
0.569087863,
-0.4933991134,
-0.1768190414,
-0.8353682756,
-0.1572601199,
-0.680534184,
-0.275788635,
0.165874958,
-0.0442036279,
0.5705487132,
-0.252876699,
0.3050623238,
0.3201681972,
0.0098141395,
-0.1794509143,
0.2799550593,
0.253970474,
0.632773459,
-0.141752556,
-0.1698597819,
0.0824117884,
-0.0447229333,
0.3363620043,
0.5894238949,
-0.0614855774,
-0.0034146302,
0.1864795089,
0.8304778337,
0.4401728809,
-0.3146389425,
0.236525625,
-0.0124021396,
0.2177982926,
-1.1671214104,
-0.2963183522,
-0.1255854666,
0.5306843519,
0.5206626058,
-0.1013318002,
0.0288069248,
-0.5942879319,
-0.0225373413,
0.4907829165,
-0.2798355222,
-0.3301374316,
1.160118103,
0.1546205431,
-0.0723833889,
0.4779420495,
0.109457463,
-0.3091159165,
0.8682253957,
0.7023242116,
1.219170332,
-0.6304475069,
-0.0976975933,
0.2474527359,
0.1253207475,
-0.4376922846,
0.034887068,
0.2126553506,
-0.5912406445,
-0.7098954916,
-0.813673079,
-0.3679018021,
0.2209513038,
-0.4767470956,
0.1552976668,
-0.5725518465,
-0.3111008108,
-0.2420911342,
-0.2392896712,
-0.7430633307,
0.4898914695,
0.2775950134,
1.0814812183,
-0.8263315558,
0.7718409896,
0.4490471184,
-0.0883324072,
-0.5578756332,
0.0656217858,
-0.0807779953,
-0.7093837857,
0.8843636513,
0.158426106,
-0.2529546618,
0.2059825063,
-0.4495372176,
-1.1700774431,
1.3139166832,
0.2134361565,
-0.601140976,
-0.5329167247,
-0.19238922,
0.3703870177,
-0.8032022715,
0.1636359841,
0.227097854,
0.4339899421,
-0.0372066796,
-0.8221111298,
0.0127998637,
-0.1338543296,
0.2134858817,
0.4889817238,
-0.7875947356,
0.874796927,
-0.0319845453,
0.0395116396,
0.3220923245,
0.9595534205,
-0.3298288286,
0.3332857192,
0.5758360028,
0.3838686943,
0.1442794353,
0.1025251821,
1.0465472937,
-0.7200990915,
0.1272770464,
1.1103695631,
-0.3184366226,
0.7589911819,
0.2851728201,
-0.1758693606,
0.8427585363,
0.4028717279,
-0.1471169889,
0.5145241618,
-0.310299933,
-0.1871185601,
-0.5649018288,
0.1387862712,
-0.3373083472,
0.4455848038,
0.5637091994,
-0.484823674,
-0.1771813929,
0.1367491335,
-0.0023858987,
-0.1771905422,
-0.3039794564,
0.3843261898,
0.330373913,
-0.5928785205,
0.2271708846,
-0.1897671223,
0.513920486,
-0.7885725498,
0.141587019,
-0.0472090095,
0.1718578935,
0.2444081008,
-0.3677939773,
0.4296092391,
-0.289718926,
-0.3372382224,
-0.4847623408,
0.3326736391,
-0.5324972868,
-0.6606045365,
0.4288354814,
0.5112416744,
-0.2156895846,
0.0975341201,
-0.5344151855,
-0.4516569078,
-0.3502297103,
-0.4052660167,
0.2254710943,
0.3462788165,
0.032260444,
1.0669852495,
0.5793558955,
0.0423382409,
-0.0691100657,
0.0423146077,
0.7181735039,
-0.9810544252,
-0.5909664035,
-0.8778057098,
0.1696207523,
0.3531295359,
0.01199596,
0.7149645686,
0.6308307052,
0.3065595925,
-0.1459500939,
0.881962955,
0.1626477689,
0.735213697,
-0.5523106456,
0.4947815835,
-0.614015162,
0.2803044617,
-0.1117251143,
-0.910243988,
-0.069609791,
0.064519152,
-0.4552808404,
0.0568700805,
0.6002728343,
0.2099616975,
-0.0480448939,
-0.0498515591,
0.1467959434,
0.4055989981,
0.4204763472,
0.4108059108,
0.6163277626,
-0.251791358,
0.7270068526,
-0.1955357343,
-0.1030911654,
-0.3867740631,
-1.2569291592,
-0.8014983535,
-0.4886959493,
-0.1863990426,
-0.1788222045,
0.1218353584,
0.985378325,
0.5119554996,
-0.7432056069,
-0.4248504639,
0.0210895129,
-0.446323365,
0.0089065013,
-0.3157568574,
0.4268504679,
-0.3330630362,
-0.8788385391,
0.7042763829,
0.2349503785,
0.457277596,
-0.8225750327,
0.1857644618,
0.2857851982,
0.0151734222,
0.7115369439,
0.5335863829,
-0.5498163104,
-0.0643495917,
0.1890146285,
0.0379683524,
-0.1344774067,
0.8488504291,
-1.1214538813,
0.3204716742,
0.3150914609,
0.3630557358,
0.598562777,
-0.0903570056,
1.0541739464,
-0.3632092178,
0.2511758804,
0.239707917,
0.7267168164,
0.385540992,
-0.2081430405,
0.1475148499,
0.2163250446,
-0.6924524307,
-0.5342028141,
0.2738661766,
-0.4367268682,
-0.1964872181,
1.0459748507,
0.062429104,
-0.1090508848,
-0.2652614713,
0.3160520494,
0.3322358429,
-0.4661253393,
0.7847260237,
0.5004973412,
-0.0654218048,
-0.0608367808,
-0.4699994624,
0.4036946595,
0.103797026,
-0.4930208027,
0.3417238593,
0.4657797515,
0.3542577624,
-0.0578506142,
0.5393675566,
-0.1686897129,
-0.0900056213,
-0.163825497,
-0.0980450138,
-0.3941026926,
-0.4855259657,
-0.303888917,
-0.2738695145,
-0.0598579831,
0.0314037763
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02369v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02369v1
|
M$^3$Face: A Unified Multi-Modal Multilingual Framework for Human Face Generation and Editing
| 2024-02-04T06:56:23 | 2024-02-04T06:56:23 |
Mohammadreza Mofayezi, Reza Alipour, Mohammad Ali Kakavand, Ehsaneddin Asgari
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.MM
|
Human face generation and editing represent an essential task in the era of
computer vision and the digital world. Recent studies have shown remarkable
progress in multi-modal face generation and editing, for instance, using face
segmentation to guide image generation. However, it may be challenging for some
users to create these conditioning modalities manually. Thus, we introduce
M3Face, a unified multi-modal multilingual framework for controllable face
generation and editing. This framework enables users to utilize only text input
to generate controlling modalities automatically, for instance, semantic
segmentation or facial landmarks, and subsequently generate face images. We
conduct extensive qualitative and quantitative experiments to showcase our
frameworks face generation and editing capabilities. Additionally, we propose
the M3CelebA Dataset, a large-scale multi-modal and multilingual face dataset
containing high-quality images, semantic segmentations, facial landmarks, and
different captions for each image in multiple languages. The code and the
dataset will be released upon publication.
|
[
-0.5605481863,
-0.6782582402,
0.36735183,
0.5696434379,
-0.0063027432,
-0.0931837857,
0.0201510694,
-0.5092368722,
-0.0161407776,
0.6252909899,
-0.9168432355,
-0.48232463,
-0.2307892889,
0.2266976088,
0.1689062268,
0.8043798208,
-0.0075262198,
0.3144567013,
-0.2073754221,
-0.2616176307,
-0.553222537,
-0.5112687945,
-0.6268597245,
0.071721442,
0.7272574306,
0.3266766965,
0.9295566082,
0.3681122363,
0.2924399078,
0.3324404359,
0.1566373855,
0.5424126387,
-0.0913210139,
-0.0360991247,
-0.4015873373,
0.0318052694,
-0.4816253483,
-0.0394664295,
0.5204154849,
0.8217758536,
0.0840544403,
0.0123117287,
-0.2243442684,
0.8073714375,
-0.4549791515,
-0.0645292997,
-0.5247946382,
-0.0919284895,
-0.4446091354,
0.0344599448,
-0.1142853871,
-0.2064873427,
-0.4049353302,
-0.577088654,
0.0248501115,
0.0976600572,
0.5494681001,
0.0446747318,
-0.566922009,
-0.1040252373,
-0.3722036779,
0.4134135544,
-0.2318300456,
0.6124945879,
0.0714668036,
0.4788946211,
-0.2052143514,
-0.5414811969,
-0.8098358512,
-0.0258321166,
-0.0342900604,
0.0024508589,
-0.1145577058,
0.1152663082,
0.1259868294,
0.0797378495,
-0.5426365733,
-0.1055216491,
-0.3028621078,
-0.4646639228,
0.6661056876,
0.0642384067,
0.6138859391,
-0.4912283421,
-0.329059571,
-0.0804275125,
-0.8853060603,
0.0700891837,
0.5203267932,
0.1280166507,
0.0400611535,
0.7008038163,
-0.4517174959,
0.8080204129,
-0.0421562344,
-0.5124536753,
0.2387700379,
-0.1099081635,
-0.5180680156,
-0.3611498177,
0.766497612,
0.6496031284,
0.0977485999,
-0.1915235221,
-0.1210863292,
-0.0676435083,
0.0723652393,
-1.0992964506,
-0.0666801333,
0.217626065,
-0.2863984704,
-0.6050385237,
0.1926184148,
-0.6643533707,
-0.3912442923,
-0.5672767758,
0.3694159389,
-0.3103170097,
-0.1362673491,
0.0055086794,
0.0871775597,
-0.2151502371,
0.655036211,
-0.764187932,
-0.0621009059,
0.0165151544,
0.4413276017,
-0.039729137,
-0.5904601216,
-0.3329380453,
0.2851054072,
-0.3176721334,
0.5534854531,
-0.3020375967,
-0.3741035759,
-0.0876750425,
0.2195411026,
-0.0451008976,
-0.6304813027,
0.2199389637,
-0.5987225175,
0.4075024128,
-0.1888822615,
0.0794306472,
-0.1069944054,
0.0046050446,
-0.7974262238,
0.6490581036,
0.2626444995,
-0.4402357638,
0.3458704948,
-0.765745759,
-0.4282960892,
-0.0620769598,
-0.3742176294,
-0.3953008354,
0.0309818704,
0.3972076476,
0.5742510557,
-0.1118261144,
0.4937532842,
-0.1109110862,
0.3056001365,
0.357326448,
-0.2144758701,
0.9135092497,
0.2665059268,
-0.5185287595,
0.2771959305,
-0.7435113192,
0.004230483,
0.0896005481,
-0.363791585,
0.2832684517,
-0.1295631677,
0.7440260053,
0.8193901777,
0.0664333776,
-0.6573451161,
0.1785711944,
0.3682375848,
0.2700832486,
0.6782323122,
0.0942719504,
0.1795928478,
-0.3049272001,
0.2803269625,
0.4632749259,
0.0970626995,
-0.5106862783,
-0.5084614158,
-0.463726759,
-0.4312938154,
0.0679638907,
0.6397233605,
-1.1130684614,
0.0541776009,
-0.1191506162,
-0.202345565,
-0.2312075347,
0.5180751085,
0.576654613,
0.4940027297,
0.3207729459,
-0.072350584,
-0.4690289497,
-1.3693234921,
-0.2257691771,
0.1732133776,
-0.3590692878,
0.4586033225,
0.2534838319,
-0.5527328849,
0.8898373842,
-0.1164809838,
-0.495746702,
-0.2476703227,
0.1737523824,
-0.4015484452,
0.9195793867,
0.6986173987,
-1.0975111723,
-0.1632710695,
-0.050037872,
-0.8173211217,
-0.3350382149,
-0.4668813944,
-0.4731442034,
0.4540044069,
0.6028446555,
-0.5714522004,
0.0442516096,
0.7539379597,
-0.3111864924,
0.5376796722,
0.0486877859,
0.365016371,
-1.2114300728,
0.409188509,
-0.0774743333,
-0.6214676499,
-0.5256459713,
0.1259549111,
0.3016723096,
-0.5593368411,
-0.6780688763,
0.5855497718,
-0.423825264,
-0.024764996,
-0.0231047068,
0.0315716751,
0.2300349474,
0.7389840484,
-0.0239840243,
0.8053498864,
0.3199388683,
-0.4280460179,
0.2534294426,
0.3170148134,
-0.3128517866,
1.1526319981,
-0.4445747435,
0.0653009787,
-0.1292821169,
0.3056064546,
-0.5575819612,
-0.9266728163,
0.1605906487,
-0.3099546731,
0.2216860801,
0.2657726407,
-0.4429653883,
-0.1936229467,
-0.0936091095,
0.2020290345,
0.098842442,
-0.6689979434,
0.6657862067,
0.3410850465,
-0.3261908293,
-0.2445056885,
-0.6765844822,
0.4261623919,
-0.0350742005,
-0.9291997552,
0.7146619558,
-0.3549292684,
-0.2559896708,
-0.1736150533,
0.3010274768,
-0.0679804832,
-0.0882316455,
0.4131341279,
0.2535667419,
0.0409000106,
-0.1483512968,
0.3210165203,
-0.1013402343,
-0.1534431279,
0.0655142069,
-0.0038873008,
-0.0327190571,
-0.3457322419,
-0.7140156627,
0.6424160004,
0.799464941,
-0.313828826,
0.2833030224,
0.7590644956,
-0.4581954181,
0.1212989092,
-0.5973944664,
0.1800782382,
-0.4404383302,
0.3223932981,
-0.7688310146,
-1.0670130253,
0.3913590014,
-0.2699831128,
0.1316904724,
0.4733895063,
0.8269430399,
-0.0076385965,
1.4009497166,
0.6638968587,
0.2237878591,
0.2766106725,
0.241321981,
-0.197302565,
-0.8140645027,
-0.3912494481,
-0.0976145416,
-0.3933886588,
-0.6275656223,
-0.4043634832,
0.4886425138,
0.2686635852,
0.0037137831,
0.1450655758,
-0.315184772,
0.5488896966,
0.4257185757,
0.3184976876,
0.2236690819,
-0.238547042,
-0.1517066658,
-0.2697853744,
-0.2423741519,
-0.488858521,
0.7311738133,
-0.0218783803,
0.4923659563,
0.5473003983,
0.2955493629,
0.2506244779,
0.5356810093,
-0.4586188197,
0.3896009922,
0.0259723794,
-0.9312928915,
-0.077748999,
-0.3959704638,
-0.5241602063,
0.4556398094,
-0.4151656032,
-0.6166705489,
0.3601326048,
0.3073847294,
-0.454066813,
0.3259625137,
-0.6458217502,
1.0488507748,
-0.115052931,
-0.5021004677,
0.1628812551,
-0.8777152896,
0.5977752805,
-0.2316400558,
0.458968848,
-0.3202892244,
-0.0582276732,
0.4011871815,
-0.2425080538,
0.7498972416,
-0.4994749129,
0.0254992619,
0.0616336353,
0.4682115316,
0.0436236784,
0.3931075931,
0.244202286,
0.1768235415,
-0.0170848668,
-0.3832164407,
-0.5332393646,
0.5750535727,
-0.5549272895,
-0.336550951,
0.0746165663,
-0.4906710684,
-0.4280469418,
0.442335397,
0.1540040225,
0.7048029304,
-0.7011846304,
0.1961964667,
0.3337063789,
-0.25987041,
0.5215086937,
0.146334976,
-0.7122321725,
-0.72102952,
0.8003810644,
-0.1931886077,
0.3179462254,
0.2916396558,
-0.0372840129,
0.0360389687,
-0.0750146881,
-1.4048749208,
-0.0345777124,
-0.4686771929,
-0.4114029408,
-0.6217232347,
0.157727778,
-0.3892769814,
-0.5255838633,
-0.2710621357,
-0.5439485312,
0.0579518825,
0.2928395867,
0.0105816713,
0.9016851187,
-0.4378800392,
0.4629560709,
-0.5653344393,
0.8257501721,
0.6760818362,
0.2584515512,
-0.6077386737,
0.1630448401,
-0.1189868227,
0.1762580276,
-0.4441860318,
-0.8249061108,
0.2878288925,
0.4064281583,
0.2035046816,
0.3916317523,
-0.5052399635,
0.5883184075,
-0.7834910154,
0.6766910553,
0.3479309678,
-1.1146392822,
0.3878059089,
-0.5005587339,
0.4608509243,
0.6160481572,
0.1036643833,
-0.9231517911,
-0.1298664361,
-0.4730619788,
-0.395186007,
0.7119228244,
0.2129134089,
0.2489518076,
0.1791817844,
0.2039564997,
0.1570177376,
0.4577906728,
-0.5526080132,
-0.1600358188,
-0.5787737966,
-0.1314745247,
0.0298229605,
-0.1534382999,
-0.4049845636,
-0.0943671167,
0.5741234422,
-0.4913533628,
0.1908443421,
0.211132735,
-0.4478446841,
-0.089791581,
0.0518671274,
1.0257934332,
0.8382816911,
-0.2246940434,
0.0709679648,
-0.2051277161,
-0.3787300289,
0.040504422,
0.1323306262,
-0.1650325209,
-0.0113737481,
-0.0770622119,
0.8344929814,
0.2866336405,
-0.732378602,
0.5679880381,
-0.0024762989,
-0.410944134,
-0.0887878612,
-0.2149654031,
0.1876856387,
0.12219356,
0.3057075143,
0.5326768756,
0.1413685381,
-0.3243521154,
0.4077001214,
0.2497275323,
-0.0930785313,
-0.5015462637,
0.9174173474,
0.4042198658,
-0.0269740373,
0.276304394,
-0.3310769796,
-0.4125351608,
0.176325649,
0.5043248534,
0.7935920358,
-0.2835530937,
0.3314382434,
0.3536212742,
0.3497870564,
0.451525867,
0.1460352093,
-0.0137580018,
-0.8384535313,
-0.1670679897,
-0.5627319217,
-0.5396532416,
0.2188891768,
-0.3695965111,
0.1461566985,
-0.5269679427,
0.0541071855,
0.3643077612,
-0.3765370846,
-0.7110363841,
0.6287840009,
0.2992332578,
0.6589764953,
-0.486251235,
0.5762061477,
0.6972270012,
-0.3970373571,
-0.2959337831,
-0.4765053093,
0.5711613894,
-0.7318919897,
0.5100384951,
0.5226358175,
-0.4015645981,
0.0765536353,
-0.5881884098,
-0.6208950877,
1.0991019011,
0.4324580133,
-0.1745397449,
-0.034707427,
0.2420883775,
-0.0255251788,
-0.6231286526,
-0.1155676395,
0.4474287033,
0.6470164657,
0.249167487,
-0.6668639779,
0.0027550561,
-0.425273329,
0.3733888566,
-0.0874711797,
-0.5856429338,
0.8810500503,
-0.3276264668,
-0.2592616975,
-0.0268291943,
0.7431722879,
0.0696724132,
-0.1593767405,
0.5230315924,
0.5622096658,
0.4161280394,
-0.0283864252,
0.854123652,
-0.3451479077,
-0.162950635,
0.842584312,
-0.2149500847,
0.4157283902,
0.3640067577,
0.0279566851,
0.4314078391,
0.6449946761,
0.2517560124,
0.267401129,
-0.130941838,
-0.4124004543,
-0.1874171793,
-0.0350080356,
-0.1098385379,
0.663032949,
0.2312134057,
-0.1337664425,
-0.2073230445,
0.364461273,
0.6846324205,
-0.0931665525,
-0.0559619144,
0.7192279696,
-0.2689886093,
-0.3409417868,
0.2986044884,
0.444124192,
0.6031430364,
-0.5051831007,
0.1100077853,
-0.3151648045,
-0.0655353665,
-0.2717922628,
-0.4883514345,
0.4050654173,
-0.0833895728,
-0.184785679,
-0.4596959651,
0.552131772,
-0.5929884911,
-0.6757765412,
-0.1406802386,
0.8061342835,
0.0105864815,
-0.3668025136,
-0.8557547927,
0.2630589008,
0.1190684587,
-0.5267581344,
0.2993671298,
0.3908124864,
-0.1436787993,
0.261102587,
0.8871145844,
-0.1873952448,
-0.0129979476,
0.2412921488,
0.8573114872,
-0.566378653,
-0.1956032068,
-0.5701835155,
0.7826865315,
-0.1084441766,
-0.6095994115,
0.4173312187,
0.5266299844,
0.9187353849,
-0.153090775,
0.8972509503,
-0.4657363594,
0.407686621,
-0.6898567677,
0.8328549862,
-0.7563037276,
-0.6677298546,
-0.288913399,
-1.02830863,
-0.6504772305,
0.3487640917,
0.3479046822,
0.2206979692,
0.4513297379,
1.033144474,
-0.0748799443,
-0.2777708769,
0.5783596039,
-0.3059260845,
0.4157777727,
0.2590436935,
0.2757865191,
-0.2962931991,
-0.0390137807,
-0.5977062583,
-0.4158603549,
-0.1654520631,
-0.8967958689,
-0.789034605,
-0.9313575625,
0.059275154,
-0.046340242,
-0.2630191445,
0.9578180313,
0.9212778211,
-0.6701052785,
-0.2353611588,
0.1171530858,
-0.0784195513,
-0.0138725294,
-0.219815135,
0.1552177221,
-0.374722898,
-1.0300191641,
0.4948703051,
0.4564857781,
0.2265535146,
-0.6097300649,
-0.0102784978,
-0.0406433716,
0.1390193701,
0.9903680682,
0.3134413958,
-0.7122787237,
-0.2377071083,
-0.0516150184,
-0.3009188771,
0.0774424598,
1.0075333118,
-0.3981332183,
0.7284104228,
0.0800758153,
0.6953583956,
0.0805496648,
0.1317292005,
0.6294532418,
-0.7243719101,
0.3126657009,
-0.1670040935,
0.3216989338,
0.8285834193,
-0.2468862832,
0.2628985047,
0.4037398696,
-0.4050090611,
-0.4670629203,
0.4501576126,
-1.0273100138,
-0.2189388424,
0.7315183282,
0.223572433,
-0.2734549642,
0.113776505,
-0.6996909976,
0.040091563,
-0.2095303237,
0.4652631581,
0.5830273628,
-0.3856705129,
-0.1948843896,
-0.7167003155,
0.9306784272,
0.184877187,
-1.2906386852,
0.0406566113,
1.1525096893,
-0.0096804919,
0.2370848507,
0.6150143743,
-0.3539618552,
0.4890633225,
-0.1852130294,
0.7534695268,
-0.3911690116,
-0.6627423167,
-0.151223585,
0.1621020436,
-0.3694534004,
0.1110022143
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02364v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02364v1
|
The Developmental Landscape of In-Context Learning
| 2024-02-04T06:23:05 | 2024-02-04T06:23:05 |
Jesse Hoogland, George Wang, Matthew Farrugia-Roberts, Liam Carroll, Susan Wei, Daniel Murfet
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We show that in-context learning emerges in transformers in discrete
developmental stages, when they are trained on either language modeling or
linear regression tasks. We introduce two methods for detecting the milestones
that separate these stages, by probing the geometry of the population loss in
both parameter space and function space. We study the stages revealed by these
new methods using a range of behavioral and structural metrics to establish
their validity.
|
[
-0.7020232081,
-0.5721690655,
0.4628034532,
0.2355873287,
0.3448914289,
0.2837455273,
-0.0295235328,
-0.0575936064,
-0.4099590778,
0.1935633123,
-1.1332461834,
-0.1063902676,
-0.3105583191,
-0.1803496629,
-0.5714771748,
0.9305701852,
-0.0435189791,
0.0282991137,
-0.6224539876,
0.1412103027,
-0.5882635713,
-0.305341512,
-0.9212993383,
-0.5708857179,
0.3285743892,
0.4428583086,
0.1497503221,
0.7373542786,
0.0983876958,
0.2146498412,
-0.2672905922,
-0.2433667332,
-0.4878219664,
0.3338651955,
-0.0071555763,
-0.3543949425,
0.0723750219,
0.0714257956,
0.8753856421,
1.3037437201,
0.0629252419,
0.1591093987,
0.5516420603,
0.4630636871,
-0.3528377414,
0.2622793019,
-0.4343999922,
0.1696362495,
-0.1896923333,
-0.1847261339,
-0.6168084145,
-0.2772401869,
0.2927332222,
-0.4113878906,
0.4383027554,
-0.5653444529,
0.7390694022,
0.2453048974,
-0.9815305471,
-0.3921885192,
-1.0748806,
0.9264803529,
0.1189899445,
0.7319647074,
0.3694894314,
0.3412593007,
-0.370642364,
-0.8106835485,
-0.2628056109,
-0.2686846256,
-0.1094766408,
0.0345586501,
0.0480866954,
-0.2549287677,
0.3628258109,
0.0482616201,
-0.3495014906,
0.1155229136,
-0.6125591397,
-0.2259282619,
0.4092264473,
0.1562391967,
0.2127432227,
-0.3033644557,
-0.3502545655,
-0.3331997991,
-1.0397411585,
0.3083741367,
0.4099046886,
0.3891862929,
-0.3448883593,
0.0052436828,
0.2672951818,
0.404055804,
0.1967280805,
-0.3792812526,
0.0553457998,
-0.2335062027,
0.2203760743,
-0.2594404519,
0.1367136538,
-0.089037843,
0.064107582,
-0.1380920857,
-0.2595338225,
0.0538680442,
0.4010173976,
-0.4361524284,
-0.002991653,
-0.0793447271,
-0.3691956103,
-0.159068808,
-0.1903652549,
-0.6439771056,
-0.4218446612,
-0.3115563393,
0.2901034951,
-0.7086571455,
-0.2553750873,
-0.2898873091,
-0.1275626421,
0.5837401748,
0.3035455346,
-1.1357134581,
0.3959048688,
0.6954818368,
0.7455006242,
-0.0253607184,
-0.1181327179,
-0.2435184121,
-0.0989344865,
-0.3687441349,
0.7446255088,
-0.5158142447,
-0.6710448265,
0.2975756526,
-0.125952512,
-0.0997340456,
-0.7943447828,
0.2273161113,
-0.342428267,
0.3382259309,
-0.3345731795,
-0.4866085947,
-0.4114019871,
0.4414865375,
-0.4233306348,
1.2834618092,
0.5972337723,
-0.3472936749,
1.198348403,
-0.7419391274,
-0.4334152341,
0.1589176357,
-0.3119770885,
-0.1823527366,
0.0956717059,
0.0159500819,
0.3633000851,
0.3006578982,
0.0484985895,
-0.0489435047,
-0.1502334923,
0.0492906272,
-0.050237935,
0.940672338,
0.0441147238,
-0.4918707609,
-0.0966176912,
-0.9016181827,
-0.2420348227,
-0.0973611996,
-0.6001729369,
-0.3312400877,
0.661147058,
0.1044404209,
0.4633836448,
-0.0260463487,
-0.4541508257,
0.159172371,
-0.312379837,
0.4757670462,
0.2864525914,
0.1068593487,
0.7359401584,
-0.1572654843,
0.5499309301,
0.252325356,
0.4903526306,
-0.5582924485,
-0.5312455893,
-0.8696890473,
-0.0825137421,
-0.1115125194,
0.1439715624,
-0.7677408457,
0.4341975451,
-0.1289682984,
-0.4373877943,
-0.0136724887,
-0.1281153709,
0.3053041399,
0.7146702409,
0.2625827491,
-0.4849073291,
-0.5514549017,
-0.5305841565,
0.1223599836,
-0.3220934272,
-0.2920291126,
0.0182360411,
0.6618008614,
-0.2633071244,
0.9846614599,
-0.0068783192,
-0.1950932443,
-0.2883857489,
0.0491290241,
-0.2049960643,
0.6462317705,
0.6594365835,
-0.8513153791,
-0.2796291709,
0.0198832881,
-0.7936066985,
0.1208243892,
-0.1834985465,
0.3673505485,
-0.1337434053,
0.8255082965,
-0.0673093498,
0.595811367,
0.3712184727,
-0.5426072478,
0.273075819,
0.0444136299,
-0.1588810831,
-0.7464599013,
-0.1714435667,
0.422883004,
-0.2316950262,
-0.9645500183,
-0.1299272925,
0.2251956761,
0.1905920804,
-0.3743877411,
0.3175415993,
-0.2488621473,
-0.4074829817,
0.0954341441,
0.40378654,
-0.2701381445,
0.1822420657,
-0.19548437,
0.7837744951,
0.442262888,
-0.7010250688,
-0.3937461972,
0.3364496231,
-0.290831238,
0.5750652552,
-0.2263537347,
0.0310328193,
-0.3675424755,
0.4013184309,
-1.2293260098,
-0.2975443304,
0.1429922134,
-0.5480354428,
0.0772411525,
-0.2252227813,
-0.2925382257,
-0.3728344142,
-0.1277572513,
0.4658574164,
0.6173244119,
-0.4184279144,
0.3899041414,
0.346419245,
0.0602629855,
-0.1318205744,
-0.4817249477,
-0.335930109,
-0.6258641481,
-0.4294880629,
0.3450687528,
0.2034727633,
-0.3789393902,
-0.2548516393,
-0.0342282951,
-0.1551349014,
0.1420961618,
0.2696644366,
0.1475799233,
-0.305241257,
0.1655337512,
0.1023037136,
-0.1221417561,
0.3988863826,
-0.368838191,
0.6242117882,
0.0772444382,
-0.2676047981,
-0.0232446808,
0.0179620963,
0.4687016904,
-0.1942545623,
0.602634728,
0.3922608495,
-0.6391162276,
-0.5774548054,
-0.1335699856,
-0.1752718985,
-0.4774743021,
0.4798802435,
-0.1388392001,
-0.6600589156,
0.8802827001,
-0.3925859928,
-0.0102481451,
0.582354188,
0.5334993601,
-0.0376586281,
1.1027057171,
1.18047297,
0.4895996451,
0.7321283221,
-0.7090678215,
0.1777779162,
-0.9807445407,
-0.9253821969,
-0.4612503052,
-0.3427124918,
-0.4521806836,
-0.2650215626,
0.8779932261,
0.0701628476,
-0.6317062974,
0.3231871724,
-0.3402870893,
0.571585834,
0.4947133958,
0.0161945354,
0.151374191,
-0.2259875387,
-0.274474442,
-0.4595282674,
-0.5214871168,
-0.5304144621,
1.0406154394,
0.5333429575,
0.3691174984,
0.0360694341,
0.6308083534,
0.1154644191,
0.7295208573,
-0.894349277,
0.3314136565,
0.0268610772,
-0.8189374804,
-0.4059580863,
-0.119174324,
-1.0473099947,
0.1619768292,
-0.2014620453,
-1.1659591198,
0.4785577953,
-0.018852124,
-0.3502050936,
0.2428865582,
-0.5341845155,
0.8868276477,
-0.1491278559,
-0.0867973939,
-0.2199665159,
-0.608704865,
0.5574968457,
-0.1833022088,
0.1194312647,
0.1524464935,
-0.1575073153,
0.726926446,
-0.1292609423,
0.8624869585,
-0.4361444414,
-0.1287448704,
0.1484381258,
0.2887748778,
0.0386492498,
0.1856967658,
0.2435303926,
-0.3988305032,
-0.0337420851,
-0.2795657814,
-0.5753311515,
0.4379570186,
-0.7191337943,
0.0013109524,
-0.3761770427,
-0.6702325344,
-0.5988436937,
0.0671584681,
0.3249620795,
0.6099724174,
-0.348224014,
0.3322035372,
0.9986455441,
-0.344391793,
0.635533154,
0.259003222,
-0.4932884574,
0.1309897155,
0.4891330898,
0.0996987298,
0.4091842473,
0.2019424438,
0.0940549597,
-0.3952567875,
-0.5072138906,
-0.2825140357,
0.0905975029,
-1.080946207,
-0.0685734525,
-0.2096757889,
-0.3845868409,
0.0814151764,
-0.3121930063,
-0.2322559804,
0.0678400397,
-0.1144892648,
-0.0528747477,
-0.1472085714,
1.4391134977,
0.0205819625,
0.5688096881,
-0.5229964256,
-0.3558792472,
0.3659772575,
0.169341296,
0.2208727896,
-0.4785020947,
-0.3561498523,
0.051403407,
-0.9626507759,
-0.6955289245,
0.3229680359,
0.402172178,
0.5579996705,
0.8808677793,
-0.6098096371,
0.6057102084,
-0.3681559861,
1.0382797718,
-0.0670749322,
-0.9548119903,
0.6710093021,
-0.7131574154,
0.2102136612,
0.3329922557,
0.8200061917,
-0.6954305172,
-0.1611014903,
-0.6609178782,
-0.7823598385,
0.7297856808,
-0.1090377644,
0.2517927885,
-0.1617382914,
0.4432162344,
0.3451357186,
-0.0299400836,
-0.8338832855,
-0.2797089517,
-0.0835805312,
0.0263919178,
-0.1420460939,
0.126628682,
-0.1555435658,
-0.5904937983,
0.1102936789,
-0.1843390614,
0.2311112434,
-0.0574984066,
-0.1895269752,
-0.2462695986,
-0.149325341,
0.6173688173,
0.8155404925,
0.0890413597,
-0.0466723591,
0.2085203677,
-0.488940537,
0.3967071474,
-0.2360554636,
-0.1854549944,
-0.2486485988,
0.8505619168,
0.5015685558,
0.8874878287,
-0.4916751981,
0.5698789358,
0.1456051022,
-0.3610363305,
-0.4276849031,
0.0376939885,
-0.0990387872,
0.320989728,
0.7857012749,
0.0541285537,
0.1082256809,
-0.8714929819,
0.6085392237,
0.0784885064,
-0.8466884494,
-0.6245722771,
0.7165297866,
0.019135464,
-0.3521202803,
0.8891088367,
-0.3813265562,
-0.3800116479,
0.8729606867,
0.7496618032,
1.0493541956,
-0.2534135878,
0.6198559403,
0.333412081,
0.3699619174,
-0.0807230696,
-0.0133982897,
-0.0025581121,
-0.6533178687,
-0.4850276411,
-0.6789272428,
-0.1082099453,
0.2752088904,
-0.6006785631,
0.1430184692,
-0.4666339159,
-0.0990608782,
0.2386065722,
-0.2312071025,
-0.7603955269,
0.238836199,
0.4822660387,
0.908164978,
-1.1123342514,
0.6539388895,
0.6541675329,
-0.5257799029,
-0.7273733616,
0.3181633055,
0.3108378351,
-0.7000135183,
1.1201345921,
0.1902444214,
-0.0665698275,
0.1268813461,
-0.3188956678,
-1.06574893,
1.0453670025,
0.1724126488,
-0.1506603211,
-0.1715492457,
0.062194515,
0.7247508764,
-0.6198043823,
0.2133117169,
0.6933701634,
0.3484306633,
-0.0357484333,
-0.8780542612,
-0.4078988135,
0.2043799907,
0.1339388043,
0.5205582976,
-0.2131604105,
1.2322721481,
0.03203528,
-0.4947086871,
-0.1300780028,
0.5741144419,
-0.151162684,
0.3742181659,
0.7911327481,
0.1689815521,
0.4238302708,
-0.5675842762,
0.8062652946,
-0.1796106249,
0.5290420651,
0.2660057545,
0.1499658525,
0.9593363404,
0.4420442283,
-0.4821253717,
0.9745818377,
0.9665184021,
0.2247604281,
0.5095167756,
0.3894900382,
-0.3165794313,
0.0384761505,
0.0690091625,
-0.0240126997,
0.6095374823,
0.9227901697,
-0.0026517226,
-0.4580049217,
0.448576808,
0.0360384472,
0.3913404942,
-0.3734549582,
0.6134173274,
0.0319603682,
-0.8262844682,
0.4987221956,
-0.3475445807,
0.5346217155,
-0.728716135,
-0.0240439922,
-0.5919797421,
0.3582472503,
-0.1632633954,
-0.6878138781,
0.4909572601,
-0.2484190017,
-0.0255043898,
-0.5063599348,
0.4262296557,
-0.3764348924,
-0.379376173,
0.5653073788,
0.6896747947,
-0.0799520016,
0.2904952466,
-0.4083737135,
-0.1037838385,
-0.3026295006,
-0.2596735656,
0.4805096686,
0.3329404891,
-0.5715833902,
0.9738823175,
0.165763393,
-0.1528985202,
0.3280413747,
0.0719019473,
0.794700861,
-0.4301517606,
-0.4956468046,
-0.7009031773,
0.6602854133,
0.0266261175,
-0.617123723,
0.8692892194,
0.4653740823,
1.381919384,
-0.1390692741,
0.5950080752,
-0.3762508333,
0.1935326755,
-0.1743585318,
0.4122469425,
-0.5841550231,
-0.0146631626,
-0.2201579958,
-1.0107908249,
-0.4064659476,
0.4727230966,
-0.343445003,
0.3675747812,
0.9505729675,
0.6698647141,
-0.1850218326,
-0.4096286595,
0.166925326,
-0.2571804523,
0.3166701198,
0.3982647657,
1.2409236431,
-0.2968230844,
0.3273334801,
-0.085153833,
-0.5263521671,
-0.0561459772,
-0.4636643827,
-0.903554678,
-1.1547461748,
0.0177750234,
-0.1892780066,
-0.1975349486,
0.6092154384,
0.8748988509,
-0.5941590071,
-0.5683745742,
-0.0319470912,
-0.0851056874,
-0.5053147078,
-0.2401616126,
0.0374307856,
-0.7442086339,
-0.6518783569,
0.6715685129,
0.379565537,
-0.0858686417,
-0.8490210176,
0.027949471,
-0.0901016593,
-0.0757603198,
0.729850769,
0.3991372585,
-0.7051472068,
-0.7222041488,
-0.0514764152,
0.1112908572,
0.0312534571,
1.1461498737,
-1.097537756,
0.3072670102,
0.389288187,
0.3272447884,
0.5282177329,
-0.2721729577,
0.5775678158,
-1.1977720261,
0.3935388029,
0.2001747936,
0.1357361376,
0.4124134779,
-0.1942924261,
0.4649276733,
0.2658818662,
-0.5981716514,
-0.9207491875,
0.4384584725,
-0.4382765293,
-0.0203825347,
0.63584131,
0.1219925061,
-0.0710010231,
-0.3421778977,
0.2175910175,
0.1592737436,
0.1841329038,
1.0561965704,
0.6415026784,
-0.3233772516,
0.0620376244,
-0.919903934,
0.9915648699,
0.0173629858,
-0.7599576712,
-0.3961150944,
0.3067195415,
0.2475653589,
0.4203651249,
0.3685425818,
-0.1083814353,
0.1707571745,
0.3880107999,
-0.1474381685,
0.559574604,
-0.6643432379,
-0.4141296446,
-0.0118293371,
0.0892283693,
-0.2208494544
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05952v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05952v1
|
Advancing Graph Representation Learning with Large Language Models: A Comprehensive Survey of Techniques
| 2024-02-04T05:51:14 | 2024-02-04T05:51:14 |
Qiheng Mao, Zemin Liu, Chenghao Liu, Zhuo Li, Jianling Sun
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The integration of Large Language Models (LLMs) with Graph Representation
Learning (GRL) marks a significant evolution in analyzing complex data
structures. This collaboration harnesses the sophisticated linguistic
capabilities of LLMs to improve the contextual understanding and adaptability
of graph models, thereby broadening the scope and potential of GRL. Despite a
growing body of research dedicated to integrating LLMs into the graph domain, a
comprehensive review that deeply analyzes the core components and operations
within these models is notably lacking. Our survey fills this gap by proposing
a novel taxonomy that breaks down these models into primary components and
operation techniques from a novel technical perspective. We further dissect
recent literature into two primary components including knowledge extractors
and organizers, and two operation techniques including integration and training
stratigies, shedding light on effective model design and training strategies.
Additionally, we identify and explore potential future research avenues in this
nascent yet underexplored field, proposing paths for continued progress.
|
[
-0.3452831507,
-0.859585166,
0.7071524262,
-0.1287723035,
-0.1204272062,
0.718010664,
-0.2888135612,
-0.5713359714,
0.0664689317,
0.5852532387,
-0.3018813729,
-0.7839643359,
-0.9507921338,
-0.1178787574,
-0.3669620156,
0.781137526,
-0.1739060432,
0.2353060395,
-0.211662367,
-0.1711919755,
-0.3381769359,
-0.7658089995,
-0.6538780928,
-0.6202613115,
0.6272426844,
0.1332934946,
0.4726282358,
0.4401602745,
0.44593364,
0.2986548245,
-0.3057961762,
0.4353444576,
-0.6430105567,
-0.1481897831,
-0.1389858574,
-0.2216126174,
-0.3751178682,
-0.1723400503,
1.0574122667,
1.407733202,
-0.1123297215,
0.0202353224,
0.2661103308,
0.4448204637,
-0.5080966949,
0.6610469222,
-0.5465934277,
0.0316416658,
-0.2133691758,
0.011914813,
-0.6041702628,
-0.1794091165,
0.1385156214,
-0.2675735056,
0.0588501021,
-0.1178480238,
0.4346139133,
-0.2070937008,
-0.7562521696,
-0.3554043174,
-0.8187975287,
0.5790128112,
-0.4701727331,
0.6078907847,
0.0074389782,
0.5278475881,
-0.1620916575,
-1.0978395939,
-0.0888459831,
-0.0253274776,
-0.092064932,
-0.2177018076,
-0.256429255,
0.3427445889,
0.1211901903,
0.2855318189,
-0.3077507317,
0.4434436262,
-0.2649693191,
-0.1428510547,
0.6221017838,
0.3071809709,
0.4329991043,
0.0998886898,
-0.1312025934,
0.0820673928,
-0.7999897003,
-0.0509687774,
0.1604735404,
0.584082067,
-0.049158968,
0.5038633943,
-0.0917324424,
0.8218493462,
-0.4003826678,
0.0403330922,
0.200259164,
-0.3051200509,
-0.2946284413,
-0.3024604917,
0.7070262432,
-0.0203399789,
0.0847925693,
-0.4911064804,
-0.3998138011,
-0.173358947,
0.0840367377,
-0.5570027828,
-0.2941894233,
-0.1667741239,
-0.358106941,
-0.2277203649,
0.2058681399,
-0.5667965412,
-0.4626765549,
-0.4073976576,
-0.0287330803,
-0.2716688514,
-0.3736890554,
0.142049849,
-0.0977211818,
0.1593889296,
0.4410897791,
-0.7859869599,
0.5109667182,
1.1177703142,
0.9754073024,
-0.2282745093,
-0.2171044499,
-0.3535768688,
0.2946966887,
-0.4062209427,
0.6713780165,
-0.7449860573,
-0.5816684961,
0.3112510145,
0.247323066,
-0.2165443599,
-0.4311474264,
0.2124910802,
-0.9109649062,
-0.0398858525,
-0.338790834,
-0.7221810818,
-0.4775743783,
0.2256782651,
-0.711335361,
0.7697678208,
0.426979959,
-0.6455179453,
0.1264980137,
-0.6080451012,
-0.3677313626,
0.3429374993,
-0.4465125799,
-0.1446044296,
0.1487330347,
0.0997587144,
0.4907390475,
-0.2987721562,
0.2345734388,
-0.4579856098,
-0.2496117651,
0.0794042051,
-0.0064922753,
0.8054445386,
0.0856153667,
0.1124567538,
0.2539173961,
-0.4165639579,
-0.0952975675,
0.3551363945,
-0.2721891105,
-0.2037076205,
0.065049842,
-0.0235962346,
-0.1080280617,
0.4282236099,
-0.3249733746,
0.5471894145,
-0.1482758373,
0.6542931795,
0.669990778,
-0.0275319722,
0.7050244808,
0.2068331689,
0.6217003465,
-0.3472290635,
0.0262842644,
-0.0886479989,
-0.2790432572,
-0.3766298592,
-0.1569399238,
0.287073344,
0.2951060534,
-0.8303643465,
0.3439366817,
-0.533159256,
-0.5816226006,
-0.0218133777,
0.3035178185,
0.2849785686,
0.420229733,
0.1506804079,
-0.3244926631,
-0.5252198577,
-0.7114255428,
-0.0053532147,
-0.221506685,
0.1814246476,
0.3531177342,
0.4183116257,
-0.5079301596,
0.880679369,
-0.8126152158,
-0.0409181863,
-0.6446042657,
0.0528585874,
0.1812635362,
0.1699091643,
0.6543236375,
-0.6057343483,
-0.4681724906,
0.4116137922,
-0.8237657547,
0.1270789802,
0.3941144049,
0.0077711307,
-0.0019824607,
0.601731658,
-0.5560758114,
0.0324367844,
0.5722087622,
-0.0565938987,
0.49979195,
0.0082843136,
-0.1592586637,
-0.8033088446,
0.0142682223,
-0.0776982307,
-0.3127724528,
-0.8142026067,
0.4437378049,
0.0521250665,
-0.2291662246,
-0.2009798884,
0.4716469646,
-0.7941118479,
-0.4586611092,
-0.3490733504,
0.2148493975,
-0.1243857965,
0.1771367937,
-0.080001235,
0.6694082618,
0.6576104164,
-0.4315933585,
0.522726357,
0.2053402364,
-0.3266834319,
0.089039728,
-0.5915423036,
0.3244652152,
-0.2578622103,
0.3505709767,
-1.1742764711,
-0.3873687387,
0.3875288367,
-0.1559207439,
0.6952357888,
-0.5596266389,
-0.6783516407,
-0.4991720915,
-0.0044769528,
0.336676091,
0.4558862746,
-0.4800856113,
0.755428493,
0.7612689137,
-0.2227131426,
-0.5983324051,
-0.5489199758,
0.2383329868,
-0.1205799952,
-0.6947429776,
0.1897728741,
0.3453438282,
-0.3300282955,
0.0801440403,
-0.0861596316,
-0.0898834169,
0.2041380405,
-0.2887232006,
0.2369986475,
-0.1731145829,
0.2687776089,
-0.1428943127,
-0.0734877139,
0.0857081115,
-0.5203034282,
0.8509651423,
-0.0026753654,
-0.5095246434,
-0.0469785705,
0.1782138497,
0.3630334139,
-0.3454655707,
0.582970202,
0.5079732537,
-0.332729727,
-0.1950611323,
-0.4057588875,
0.0004255071,
-0.4560468793,
0.8308849335,
-0.3380055428,
-1.1081525087,
0.6663679481,
-0.4677222967,
0.0338580385,
0.2841078043,
0.2854668796,
0.0047798213,
1.0269286633,
0.958438158,
-0.1788922399,
0.6697340012,
-0.510229528,
0.2937326729,
-0.9817296863,
-0.3134129643,
-0.5289357901,
-0.1616554856,
-0.3859880567,
-0.5722076893,
0.143788144,
0.1000209823,
-0.2356107384,
0.0079511544,
-0.3615188003,
0.3480126262,
-0.0343858935,
0.05353963,
0.2062985897,
0.2114687413,
0.1316780895,
0.1895938665,
-0.7316599488,
-0.6047214866,
1.0761685371,
0.5675663352,
0.8625891209,
0.0323544368,
0.693352282,
0.1539880037,
0.4009355009,
-1.0312688351,
0.6095638871,
-0.4268656075,
-0.086710453,
-0.324984163,
-0.5213931203,
-1.015755415,
0.3662953377,
0.217793256,
-0.8901091218,
0.0020829597,
-0.0994764566,
0.1161434501,
0.6311419606,
-0.5843753815,
0.7026916742,
-0.2731361687,
0.03451759,
-0.0164244194,
-0.4701596797,
0.4476145506,
-0.0960513651,
0.4636942446,
0.0156393331,
-0.1519241333,
0.674672842,
-0.1994960308,
1.0103243589,
-0.3411971927,
-0.4373898506,
0.3507373631,
0.0774010718,
0.7653811574,
-0.2517927885,
0.1839621961,
0.3100734949,
-0.1880798042,
-0.3700618744,
-0.7425588369,
0.5032423139,
-0.8118427992,
-0.4734763205,
-0.0610438883,
-0.581194222,
-0.3620446026,
0.2335088998,
-0.0509126298,
0.5144833922,
-0.2057831585,
0.1640727669,
0.6155021787,
0.0475334972,
0.1638646424,
0.1524559855,
-0.5722874403,
-0.5157921314,
0.8540286422,
0.3097756803,
0.2748241425,
0.3025075793,
0.0764486119,
-0.3725866377,
-0.9704924226,
-0.0870207101,
0.5196891427,
-1.1568249464,
0.0968479514,
-0.744930923,
-0.2600683868,
-0.5668637753,
-0.0066669043,
-0.1645123661,
-0.2315182388,
-0.4013461173,
-0.290089637,
0.0934178308,
1.1877473593,
0.3526038527,
0.6269590259,
-0.8478850722,
-0.1001770869,
0.2688391209,
0.2224042565,
0.2086908668,
-0.3319864273,
-0.4265523851,
0.0045432281,
-0.1520809382,
-0.8694787621,
0.2162647992,
-0.0072671142,
0.9002847672,
0.3456309438,
-0.3985497355,
0.6888307929,
-0.4447104037,
0.8103528023,
0.292696923,
-0.8345428705,
0.1989042163,
-0.3394791782,
-0.0658422187,
0.2831659317,
0.4663001299,
-0.6640563011,
0.015386262,
-0.4365951419,
-0.8393435478,
0.5084015131,
-0.3189371228,
0.3012246788,
0.199511528,
0.3863142133,
0.0311645158,
0.2529650927,
-0.5849084258,
-0.1476355791,
0.2341902703,
-0.1779927313,
-0.3366482258,
-0.3518769741,
-0.3510518968,
-0.2704409063,
0.292511642,
-0.5379715562,
0.2007883787,
-0.278008312,
-0.3040149808,
0.1737077534,
0.0067230044,
0.1283180118,
1.0107666254,
0.0916755199,
0.2201206386,
0.1010126695,
-0.3187465072,
-0.0680622607,
0.0132748606,
-0.0907969177,
-0.115631029,
0.7679080367,
0.8628184199,
0.3385861516,
-0.4583978057,
0.3072445095,
0.1933254898,
-0.1248049065,
-0.2012215555,
-0.0852980167,
0.2722480297,
0.340737462,
0.4707345068,
-0.3139621019,
0.0423791893,
-0.6751580238,
0.0991380587,
0.7130180001,
-0.4897512197,
-0.4649251103,
0.1916398704,
0.0693198964,
-0.1893254817,
0.6001104712,
-0.2022578567,
-0.6377820969,
0.5307896137,
0.5035786629,
0.8249379992,
-0.0178813152,
0.231984511,
0.1521820277,
0.2840348482,
0.0738996863,
0.0971793383,
0.0724703372,
-0.859003067,
-0.6398273706,
-0.3600781262,
-0.39692384,
-0.1795186698,
-0.4690520167,
0.3220254481,
-0.4652920067,
-0.1569268852,
-0.1942790002,
0.1436615139,
-0.6141261458,
-0.2438191026,
0.2999200225,
0.9845391512,
-0.9682317972,
0.748331964,
1.0240073204,
-0.3449819088,
-0.6535701156,
-0.1950821579,
-0.0305967294,
-0.8867291808,
0.8426328301,
-0.0641306117,
-0.0300759822,
0.136287868,
-0.708396852,
-0.8880707622,
1.1439539194,
0.4127934873,
-0.4942927063,
-0.2863214612,
0.0813403949,
0.4085509181,
-0.6641854644,
0.0865451545,
0.6507725716,
0.365571022,
0.2962913215,
-0.6776562929,
-0.1278464347,
0.0885163099,
0.170649156,
0.2326433063,
-0.5900911689,
0.8394371271,
0.0639087409,
-0.5681898594,
-0.1029211581,
0.6128768325,
0.1183853298,
0.2164901793,
0.4036620855,
0.3306993246,
1.0639170408,
-0.1307533085,
1.1562190056,
-0.2966470718,
0.6458714008,
1.0069241524,
-0.4418124259,
0.4158260822,
0.3054304421,
-0.4077290297,
0.5162674785,
0.7695753574,
0.0270272698,
0.3577382267,
0.2218266279,
-0.2453307211,
-0.3699484766,
-0.1866924614,
-0.3436100185,
0.3544224501,
0.6562489271,
-0.3440153599,
-0.5020927191,
-0.0992271826,
-0.0449852459,
-0.0333184637,
-0.327159971,
0.9280270934,
0.1916374713,
-0.0799189359,
0.2356705815,
-0.1114161015,
0.3311008215,
-0.7887425423,
-0.0555149503,
-0.0213168785,
-0.183968097,
-0.2154252082,
-0.902104795,
0.1555216312,
-0.334841609,
0.0402178019,
-0.1374740899,
0.9170200825,
-0.2479578555,
-0.3597695529,
0.6191789508,
0.6920107603,
-0.0113981385,
0.1415203512,
-0.6093601584,
0.4457370043,
-0.1144702807,
0.0213908385,
0.2648634613,
0.5898514986,
-0.0275491923,
0.713486433,
0.5505931377,
0.2478005588,
0.0360348672,
0.2698699832,
1.2135534286,
-0.6195967793,
-0.3026851714,
-0.8327541947,
0.3826013505,
-0.1818554252,
0.214565292,
0.7491800785,
0.53395015,
0.8544049263,
0.1140251309,
1.0295903683,
0.0710769147,
0.1058887616,
-0.5592556,
0.4861122668,
-0.3082853854,
0.2471989691,
-0.3855680525,
-1.0674928427,
-0.3846447766,
0.2713488936,
-0.5541473627,
0.0412071198,
0.6461903453,
0.4174185395,
-0.1158888787,
-0.0933799371,
0.187555179,
0.1666225791,
0.7161548734,
0.3844018877,
0.9739217758,
-0.1302079856,
0.2995918095,
-0.0671540201,
-0.2655625641,
-0.2327403575,
-0.7665311098,
-0.7756304741,
-0.4635205269,
-0.2881367505,
-0.1185722351,
-0.1819545329,
0.7166632414,
0.6125382781,
-0.5068904161,
-0.4735853374,
-0.0794394091,
0.3660423756,
-0.0471473522,
-0.1980027109,
0.4227888584,
-0.5935585499,
-0.8513452411,
0.4808261991,
0.2455971539,
0.0366107523,
-0.5463911295,
-0.1119640619,
0.0740829036,
-0.2991968989,
0.9220507741,
0.305395633,
-0.6165648699,
-0.3948947787,
-0.0288402215,
-0.0335574895,
0.0741890222,
1.1386572123,
-0.3209259212,
0.4139757156,
0.7217831016,
1.005212307,
0.4954601228,
-0.0935373977,
0.4910143316,
-0.7239227891,
-0.012871013,
0.1815557927,
0.6274867058,
0.4634828269,
-0.2217422724,
0.7148250341,
0.4371092021,
-0.4356506169,
-0.9975037575,
0.5840889215,
-0.9880652428,
-0.332064867,
1.1447628736,
-0.2115858197,
-0.26141572,
-0.0958026722,
-0.112396121,
0.2220792919,
-0.04214992,
0.3791012764,
0.7957338691,
-0.177603662,
-0.282525599,
-0.4518651068,
-0.033337418,
-0.2704800069,
-0.5682091117,
0.2811676264,
0.615430057,
0.2688024938,
0.1644086242,
0.5815294981,
-0.2335665226,
-0.1496165246,
-0.2138606906,
0.1411612034,
-0.1423650682,
-0.3002123833,
-0.5933670402,
0.398193419,
0.3856975436,
0.1851033866
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05122v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05122v1
|
History of generative Artificial Intelligence (AI) chatbots: past, present, and future development
| 2024-02-04T05:01:38 | 2024-02-04T05:01:38 |
Md. Al-Amin, Mohammad Shazed Ali, Abdus Salam, Arif Khan, Ashraf Ali, Ahsan Ullah, Md Nur Alam, Shamsul Kabir Chowdhury
|
cs.GL
|
cs.GL, cs.CL, cs.HC
|
This research provides an in-depth comprehensive review of the progress of
chatbot technology over time, from the initial basic systems relying on rules
to today's advanced conversational bots powered by artificial intelligence.
Spanning many decades, the paper explores the major milestones, innovations,
and paradigm shifts that have driven the evolution of chatbots. Looking back at
the very basic statistical model in 1906 via the early chatbots, such as ELIZA
and ALICE in the 1960s and 1970s, the study traces key innovations leading to
today's advanced conversational agents, such as ChatGPT and Google Bard. The
study synthesizes insights from academic literature and industry sources to
highlight crucial milestones, including the introduction of Turing tests,
influential projects such as CALO, and recent transformer-based models. Tracing
the path forward, the paper highlights how natural language processing and
machine learning have been integrated into modern chatbots for more
sophisticated capabilities. This chronological survey of the chatbot landscape
provides a holistic reference to understand the technological and historical
factors propelling conversational AI. By synthesizing learnings from this
historical analysis, the research offers important context about the
developmental trajectory of chatbots and their immense future potential across
various field of application which could be the potential take ways for the
respective research community and stakeholders.
|
[
-0.3233848512,
-1.1984267235,
0.3816254139,
-0.0552200601,
0.477799058,
0.447388351,
0.1081998423,
-0.463034749,
0.1254190803,
0.4774339199,
-0.6810092926,
-0.258564651,
-0.3810791969,
-0.1617843956,
-0.6830657125,
0.888507545,
0.5464406013,
-0.2145808637,
-0.309302181,
0.1171527058,
-0.7190457582,
-0.742891252,
-0.7503979206,
-0.347420454,
0.1044267565,
0.1549673676,
0.869332552,
0.1510933936,
0.4399119616,
0.459399879,
-0.1658695489,
0.022702368,
-0.275357008,
0.3634473681,
0.304743588,
-0.6106263995,
-0.6073749661,
-0.0243062302,
0.4501726925,
0.6099247336,
0.0054552048,
-0.1591968685,
0.0206685904,
0.6441745162,
-0.096669957,
0.3614826798,
-0.6414285302,
0.2455376983,
-0.0945554003,
-0.4088240862,
-0.4731369317,
-0.4999800026,
0.176783368,
-0.4485132694,
0.369461894,
0.0363654941,
0.6375553012,
0.2050413936,
-0.2430657148,
-0.5190701485,
-1.1753125191,
0.8142034411,
-0.4523287416,
0.2322104573,
0.1123370826,
0.5720033646,
-0.5098624825,
-0.9221640825,
-0.5825509429,
-0.634752512,
0.2310444862,
-0.01007713,
-0.3836993575,
-0.2126189619,
0.0626392439,
0.3464802504,
-0.5178356171,
0.2313762903,
-0.5785356164,
-0.2488829643,
0.5916244388,
0.3899128735,
0.5361853242,
0.1713528633,
-0.2870174348,
-0.0493192561,
-0.5563858151,
0.0375214703,
0.279448688,
0.1171264946,
-0.2481370717,
0.5503895283,
-0.1647192687,
0.4394207001,
0.0273288544,
-0.0149393696,
0.2387467474,
-0.5166005492,
-0.0653726161,
-0.1231595799,
1.041519165,
0.0383375175,
0.4806638062,
-0.195650816,
0.3858466148,
0.0907196999,
0.551644206,
-0.3922071755,
-0.0585572198,
0.2158842832,
-0.3613613546,
-0.4119212031,
-0.1741335988,
-0.8268355131,
-0.4105194211,
-0.1138365418,
0.0236480795,
-0.5464267731,
-0.203744933,
-0.2971757948,
-0.3897345066,
0.6163477302,
0.429420352,
-0.8665918708,
-0.000438585,
0.8491784334,
0.8253602982,
0.1086877584,
-0.1101048142,
0.1744907349,
-0.2841247916,
-0.4379509091,
0.7738857865,
-0.6924588084,
-0.6459748149,
0.2353081256,
-0.2295924276,
0.1801046878,
-0.3708000779,
0.2041061223,
-0.6456970572,
0.4159955382,
0.6126739383,
-0.406214267,
-0.3414595425,
0.2892995179,
-0.4515045583,
0.7058013678,
0.0135144088,
-0.3320862651,
0.2124286592,
-1.0159863234,
-0.5908505917,
0.4445405602,
-0.3475272954,
-0.3907801807,
-0.2770067751,
0.2411500067,
0.3411596417,
-0.3047540486,
0.2480394095,
-0.224771753,
-0.2575745583,
0.494258672,
-0.6754643917,
1.2424663305,
0.0136362966,
-0.4166882336,
0.2897134125,
-0.4886701703,
-0.11593014,
0.1685127318,
0.1161388382,
0.2538126409,
0.3968738317,
-0.2491627187,
0.0313521028,
0.1595909148,
-0.1306999326,
0.0027050807,
-0.3084123731,
0.9022675157,
0.5713278055,
0.0266614184,
0.4537037909,
-0.458265245,
0.7159955502,
-0.2789596021,
0.4502393007,
-0.6360830069,
-0.8418903351,
-0.7747334838,
0.1294741035,
0.0579099022,
0.6660341024,
-0.3446860909,
0.8356704116,
-0.3468551338,
-0.7591391206,
-0.4799906313,
-0.1074503809,
-0.1655909866,
0.3436602056,
0.057565473,
-0.2489493936,
-0.2924540639,
-0.6776160002,
0.1901160777,
-0.6635026336,
-0.1292379498,
0.3916017413,
0.2884155512,
-0.3481691778,
0.9371084571,
-0.180165872,
-0.0956444591,
-0.401807189,
0.1736987084,
-0.0836514086,
0.4492970407,
0.6138191819,
-0.9687532783,
-0.1884898394,
0.1267091036,
-0.6550311446,
0.3315807581,
-0.347328335,
-0.2029041648,
0.0459644571,
0.5844132304,
-0.655809164,
0.4388557971,
0.4447998405,
-0.129390046,
0.3295748234,
0.118066974,
0.2093070298,
-0.9573774934,
0.0955239162,
-0.1925301701,
0.0579268448,
-0.676772058,
-0.3572298586,
-0.2026662976,
-0.3067344725,
-0.3514291346,
0.4214522541,
-0.0085051507,
0.2233869731,
-0.1032958254,
0.1518992037,
-0.5377160311,
0.4040127993,
-0.1806865185,
0.613248229,
0.5931419134,
-0.7979382873,
0.5033709407,
0.3574632406,
0.1631584167,
0.6245867014,
-0.5868933201,
0.4240587652,
0.0059228246,
0.2621021271,
-1.1085654497,
-0.0175489858,
0.3646004498,
-0.9486590028,
0.0566105135,
0.0222423021,
-0.3101163208,
-0.532348156,
0.0158170424,
0.1356157511,
0.8190654516,
-0.0538050495,
0.5973605514,
0.5409798622,
-0.4576588571,
-0.2476837635,
-0.3292839527,
0.3382361531,
-0.2911755145,
-0.6130959392,
0.2247145325,
-0.3041264117,
-0.4703542888,
-0.3308183253,
0.2950384617,
-0.1259744167,
0.2676492333,
0.3680394888,
0.4547493458,
-0.2246365994,
0.0732740387,
-0.1438806057,
-0.1498581469,
0.1891617179,
-0.0147547675,
0.9879868031,
-0.0535882674,
-0.2605991066,
-0.701877594,
0.1765937656,
0.6592898369,
-0.0436316468,
0.5813906789,
0.412091136,
-0.124006629,
0.0639924482,
-0.5229023695,
-0.1047600061,
-0.4190869331,
0.4002588987,
0.0776420906,
-0.9180392623,
0.3751927018,
-0.0845715851,
0.3724517524,
0.8422476053,
0.6877542138,
-0.2671699524,
0.7535558343,
0.5978310704,
-0.3167594373,
0.9097619057,
-0.1024483889,
0.2765242755,
-0.3797264993,
-0.4021085799,
-0.618742764,
-0.2802374363,
-0.9324766397,
0.0422806665,
0.3202603459,
-0.3617838323,
-0.4592803121,
0.1302286834,
-0.3776853383,
0.0276872236,
0.7692766786,
-0.0595488772,
0.1543123126,
-0.3579108119,
0.5598944426,
0.2972025573,
-0.4634966254,
-0.4761869907,
1.2027808428,
0.3048460484,
0.3895756006,
-0.0239376202,
0.2223089039,
0.8636596799,
0.221341446,
-0.6293426156,
0.5727388263,
0.3417911232,
-0.6441510916,
-0.4130988121,
-0.1521690339,
-1.2487703562,
-0.1778533012,
0.0473456606,
-0.5389290452,
-0.2278444618,
0.0800525248,
-0.2283509821,
-0.0786192715,
-0.7000683546,
0.6953904629,
-0.3859428763,
0.113455005,
-0.3452422023,
-1.0092344284,
0.3031497598,
0.2022867799,
0.0263259765,
-0.103841573,
0.3099169731,
0.4575019479,
-0.060898643,
1.060118556,
0.0972478092,
-0.0182050671,
0.5826257467,
-0.0076976181,
0.1089031696,
-0.2093308419,
0.2497616112,
0.2904814482,
-0.2329838425,
-0.2644612491,
-0.4387865961,
0.429956615,
-0.5657327771,
-0.5838750601,
-0.2320791185,
-0.4584344625,
-0.1311029494,
0.0815329924,
-0.1029680222,
0.3624340892,
-0.6496112347,
0.2554191947,
0.3056921065,
-0.2647348344,
0.6383602619,
0.1176505014,
-0.0537403151,
-0.1756044477,
0.4540711045,
-0.2574128807,
0.1543524712,
0.6284836531,
-0.0718639791,
-0.1075515896,
-0.382661134,
-0.4089414775,
-0.0758809969,
-0.3809053004,
-0.1121943071,
-0.4793274403,
-0.5301241279,
-0.6615274549,
-0.1956436634,
-0.277240634,
-0.154290542,
-0.3545998633,
0.2335678637,
0.3854423463,
0.8173969388,
0.4377987087,
0.2440542877,
-0.5465182066,
0.2649030983,
0.3270473778,
-0.0018360547,
0.1902028322,
-0.1745048016,
0.0878130794,
0.237310335,
-0.7455372214,
-0.9459916949,
0.3323839307,
0.2061600983,
0.6611475945,
0.4297581017,
-0.2241040915,
0.3878875375,
-0.4190559089,
1.2010630369,
0.0926530957,
-0.5049858093,
0.8083994389,
-0.2915085852,
0.2716058493,
-0.0214874595,
0.1709372252,
-0.611946106,
-0.2662214637,
-0.770917058,
-0.7562508583,
0.4548881054,
0.3232128024,
0.5329242945,
0.1877336353,
0.2217370421,
0.3019362688,
0.144789502,
-0.4717687964,
-0.3726446629,
-0.0965330303,
-0.2046086937,
-0.0607409216,
0.1987176389,
0.1258942485,
-0.0970720276,
0.4362291098,
-0.0478295498,
0.6258105636,
-0.3167921901,
-0.0813215524,
0.3535963595,
0.454474628,
0.3976324201,
0.6610662341,
0.1871802658,
-0.3174372911,
-0.0932156891,
-0.3207385242,
-0.0643375069,
0.1804046929,
-0.2259286344,
-0.1994482577,
0.2975559533,
0.7600736022,
0.037596941,
-0.794768393,
0.223317042,
0.1010181904,
-0.0109441532,
-0.9090520144,
0.3802448511,
-0.1449905783,
0.6536457539,
0.5912753344,
0.0910074636,
-0.0188016035,
-0.7995355725,
0.0368517675,
0.6239162683,
-0.4531471133,
-0.252909869,
0.7067381144,
0.2663486302,
-0.8288816214,
0.9122717381,
-0.0579701774,
-0.4138607383,
0.6436600089,
0.5293076038,
1.1290631294,
-0.1021692231,
0.3732923865,
0.146742627,
0.0308155082,
0.2623697221,
-0.1615869403,
-0.4374680221,
-0.6869394183,
-0.0258643534,
-0.3521175683,
-0.524715662,
0.0232836604,
-0.1567396075,
0.1364107728,
-0.2171117663,
-0.4691222906,
0.1380046755,
-0.1978813559,
-0.9569569826,
-0.0346634537,
0.2368439138,
0.332767874,
-0.4342335761,
0.2308528274,
0.4620226622,
-0.4928503036,
0.2526780069,
0.0341683775,
0.0986713246,
-1.0135228634,
0.5460237861,
-0.0633312613,
-0.1095099449,
0.1680898219,
-0.8023744822,
-0.6436238885,
0.9787806273,
-0.1103754938,
-0.4302745461,
-0.3847958744,
0.1477339864,
0.8123765588,
-0.2080014646,
0.4050751626,
0.4713741839,
0.119191736,
0.1794684529,
-0.9608495235,
-0.3601149619,
-0.4600535631,
0.0829712972,
0.2566384375,
-0.6392028332,
0.4887040555,
-0.0853127241,
-0.3736444712,
0.4996140301,
0.9253915548,
-0.0537049659,
0.3593598902,
0.1354490519,
0.0141901309,
0.4199270308,
-0.3194822371,
0.7540679574,
-0.1282246858,
-0.1621271521,
0.4602655768,
0.0568728745,
0.7406204343,
0.2317268401,
-0.55891186,
0.6733007431,
0.4450126588,
-0.2104972005,
0.1707190573,
0.0379213803,
-0.136384055,
0.0823230892,
-0.0655292869,
-0.2588493824,
0.6227017045,
0.6004796028,
-0.5019634962,
0.0899780318,
0.1751224548,
0.097041741,
-0.1767849624,
-0.2155568898,
1.0907441378,
-0.3210414052,
-0.6669532061,
0.1299857348,
-0.552041173,
0.6177533269,
-0.6299799085,
-0.2245974094,
-0.2212402374,
0.1543009728,
0.3463813066,
-0.8274550438,
0.0956208855,
0.0381153747,
0.1562015116,
-0.2001001984,
0.5272587538,
0.0014974978,
-0.4210170209,
-0.0452497788,
0.6561327577,
0.1806841195,
0.0702651814,
-0.5178982019,
0.0229181424,
-0.0769274533,
0.2334679216,
0.0407602899,
0.3745005727,
-0.0592561103,
0.7422629595,
0.5445642471,
-0.2167691439,
0.1067856625,
-0.0872820914,
0.5990328789,
-1.0234527588,
-0.5205258131,
-0.9500404596,
0.6288950443,
0.0103557557,
-0.4536834359,
0.5085254908,
0.2434706241,
0.7015605569,
0.2991905808,
0.9808263779,
-0.4687308967,
0.3324183524,
-0.2733670473,
0.8130035996,
-0.2307371646,
-0.0603708476,
-0.1255173832,
-0.6970387697,
-0.3951082528,
0.1673282832,
-0.0249580909,
0.3920940161,
0.2020868957,
0.4325132072,
0.5375876427,
0.3172867894,
0.1407602429,
0.1435116827,
0.6412533522,
0.0899920836,
1.0444817543,
-0.2898270488,
0.6192250252,
-0.0391082913,
-0.2008441836,
-0.5000198483,
-0.2695831656,
-0.7281571031,
-0.976010263,
-0.3650145531,
-0.1131519601,
0.310010612,
0.5760031343,
0.4754923284,
-0.7320596576,
-0.0894486532,
-0.3534404039,
0.081058301,
-0.5023075342,
-0.3341552019,
0.2045740336,
-0.6410338879,
-0.9876289964,
0.3264880478,
0.2193158567,
0.2852610648,
-0.5693657398,
0.0278471988,
0.0705425143,
0.0009117271,
0.7990112305,
0.6155636311,
-0.8142815828,
-0.1776370406,
0.0750079602,
0.0691097975,
0.3893552125,
0.668555975,
-0.9787057638,
0.5107653737,
0.4720951021,
0.5152344704,
0.2107537389,
-0.0725159571,
0.7627564669,
-0.3652567565,
0.1424186081,
0.5270389915,
-0.0066908365,
0.3288947642,
-0.1078029796,
0.4404305518,
0.2002939135,
-0.7115585804,
-0.5385910869,
0.0681404844,
-0.8739826679,
-0.0382595621,
0.7515054941,
0.3604505956,
0.0712572113,
-0.2388422638,
-0.448287636,
0.4784520268,
-0.4317506552,
1.1877996922,
0.5870930552,
-0.700166285,
-0.3722994626,
-0.5236076713,
0.450701952,
0.0091285929,
-1.0293316841,
-0.1746552438,
0.6886243224,
-0.359215647,
0.3489096463,
0.4613271654,
-0.2746221423,
0.1329489648,
0.3415625095,
0.0086278729,
0.4678047597,
-0.383012414,
0.0038895013,
0.2663759291,
-0.0340567827,
-0.4151698351
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02330v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02330v2
|
Enhance Reasoning for Large Language Models in the Game Werewolf
| 2024-02-04T03:47:10 | 2024-03-29T09:01:56 |
Shuang Wu, Liwen Zhu, Tao Yang, Shiwei Xu, Qiang Fu, Yang Wei, Haobo Fu
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This paper presents an innovative framework that integrates Large Language
Models (LLMs) with an external Thinker module to enhance the reasoning
capabilities of LLM-based agents. Unlike augmenting LLMs with prompt
engineering, Thinker directly harnesses knowledge from databases and employs
various optimization techniques. The framework forms a reasoning hierarchy
where LLMs handle intuitive System-1 tasks such as natural language processing,
while the Thinker focuses on cognitive System-2 tasks that require complex
logical analysis and domain-specific knowledge. Our framework is presented
using a 9-player Werewolf game that demands dual-system reasoning. We introduce
a communication protocol between LLMs and the Thinker, and train the Thinker
using data from 18800 human sessions and reinforcement learning. Experiments
demonstrate the framework's effectiveness in deductive reasoning, speech
generation, and online game evaluation. Additionally, we fine-tune a 6B LLM to
surpass GPT4 when integrated with the Thinker. This paper also contributes the
largest dataset for social deduction games to date.
|
[
-0.4497514367,
-0.6465622783,
0.8912274837,
0.2370033264,
0.0474510938,
0.2359648794,
-0.2815048993,
-0.7752521634,
0.1818884909,
0.6854609847,
-0.5114583373,
-0.2978807688,
-0.13799496,
0.001302437,
0.1125019118,
0.5624637008,
0.2184122354,
0.0666651726,
-0.1632627547,
0.0775659233,
-0.3998286128,
-0.5924896598,
-1.1392607689,
-0.861114502,
0.240774408,
0.114288643,
0.9096640348,
0.5177975893,
0.4222520888,
0.3821336627,
-0.1797810793,
0.3866519928,
-0.7465003729,
0.3252655864,
-0.7162798047,
-0.4923925996,
-0.5689767599,
-0.5456159711,
0.2519373,
0.1537391692,
-0.0391857177,
-0.1511313617,
-0.1710828543,
0.3426991403,
-0.3623942435,
0.3981627822,
-0.5820848346,
-0.0961558223,
0.235670805,
-0.0548965,
-0.6023827195,
-0.4193797112,
0.1042944789,
-0.7165059447,
-0.1499519348,
-0.1517914236,
0.3819379807,
0.3668029606,
-0.2766037881,
-0.144377172,
-0.9076545238,
0.5912671685,
-0.934461832,
0.3718118072,
0.2344279289,
0.4273622036,
-0.4346171916,
-0.4413387179,
-0.7175291777,
-0.2415437847,
0.0168487784,
0.0250515267,
-0.247581616,
0.4057249725,
0.4656979442,
0.155975759,
-0.2917642593,
0.2788494229,
-0.0537397452,
-0.2023368776,
0.9113644958,
0.2788590491,
0.1653590798,
0.2408949286,
-0.0823476017,
-0.0547063053,
-0.4737780094,
0.1757776588,
0.3108183146,
0.0374909751,
0.1000133678,
0.4306998849,
-0.0479644574,
0.4821147025,
0.4588843286,
-0.168517217,
0.0834034681,
-0.116686672,
-0.1255999207,
0.0968762115,
0.5965910554,
0.517713964,
0.0944131985,
-0.4539489746,
-0.4668870866,
0.4400065243,
0.0940344781,
-0.6830916405,
-0.3026435077,
0.4277120829,
-0.2050379813,
-0.2680885792,
-0.3507653177,
-0.6406767368,
-0.9242492914,
-0.27832219,
0.466427207,
-0.5849019885,
-0.3634637892,
0.5895495415,
-0.3118856549,
0.5607215762,
0.4339132905,
-1.0646994114,
0.3670982122,
0.7460920811,
0.31148085,
-0.0897042602,
-0.1190587208,
-0.4152790904,
0.3160382509,
-0.3636802435,
0.9624180198,
-0.6285174489,
-0.2552257478,
-0.1887403131,
-0.1063874736,
0.3527179956,
-0.5818997622,
0.4866140485,
-0.5724998713,
0.0526246578,
-0.2684630752,
-0.7282471061,
-0.1575935632,
0.4987441897,
-0.5964403749,
1.1347649097,
-0.0625129715,
-0.3858020604,
0.2854292095,
-0.7225136161,
-0.4775078595,
0.5671771765,
-0.1838930398,
0.2359398603,
0.1428390294,
0.4335544705,
0.2335057259,
-0.5849986076,
0.5849974155,
-0.5175768733,
-0.5128639936,
0.2520679533,
0.1728898138,
0.7050026059,
-0.030073652,
-0.4384193122,
0.2810778618,
-0.5476623178,
0.3700756133,
0.1043561772,
-0.3408386707,
-0.1797162294,
0.2961100638,
-0.1639023125,
0.3573450148,
0.2017711401,
-0.5105435848,
0.2508186698,
-0.6392734051,
0.4581268132,
0.6459965706,
-0.0812368765,
0.5536881685,
-0.4627343714,
0.3714642525,
-0.311416626,
0.1786748916,
0.1280364394,
-0.2425023019,
-0.6680381298,
-0.477537483,
-0.0007338329,
0.6992279887,
-1.1307457685,
0.6856998801,
-0.2389633805,
-0.6385506392,
-0.6336373091,
-0.1038297564,
0.1359437555,
0.0327035412,
0.3407499492,
0.1619546413,
-0.57966429,
-0.9123670459,
-0.0568732359,
-0.3903889954,
-0.0736995116,
0.2925949693,
0.4016523361,
-0.5185246468,
0.9960278869,
-0.3688664138,
0.0090318406,
-0.7410495281,
-0.3190003335,
0.2252851874,
0.3976821601,
0.2488092333,
-0.5477409959,
-0.0486831665,
-0.1388153136,
-0.9393410087,
-0.1074299365,
-0.1587615609,
-0.2022742778,
-0.0051212115,
0.4260991216,
-0.6887332201,
-0.0335712954,
0.3784281313,
-0.4770210981,
0.510897398,
-0.3494144082,
0.1003312692,
-0.9300531745,
-0.2792378664,
0.0011072628,
-0.1904366165,
-0.7296577692,
0.4030874372,
-0.2418781072,
0.0955272093,
-0.1197461933,
0.8844634295,
-0.3406310678,
0.0695997328,
-0.4521306157,
0.3514251709,
-0.0047019823,
0.4901894927,
0.2100879103,
0.5426792502,
0.7657127976,
-0.6112022996,
0.8918577433,
0.1926570982,
-0.3873000443,
0.46702528,
-0.7417888641,
0.393112123,
-0.1623867899,
0.4241045713,
-0.6887593865,
-0.1403058618,
0.0075131338,
-0.2883241773,
-0.1346783936,
0.2485706061,
-0.7450802922,
-0.4625954628,
-0.3639229536,
0.058773905,
0.5176199079,
-0.6676849723,
0.8809364438,
0.7422573566,
0.1392826438,
-0.3250232935,
-0.6195967197,
0.1637719274,
-0.3097307086,
-0.900673151,
0.2431211919,
-0.2706131637,
-0.6256453991,
-0.1777100563,
-0.0994675606,
-0.0056618634,
0.0252865683,
-0.055976592,
0.2609238923,
-0.261305362,
0.3835272193,
0.0727354214,
0.0268413965,
0.2069833726,
-0.5676962137,
0.4533115923,
-0.204903096,
-0.1428934783,
-0.0106127812,
0.1727391183,
0.3687522411,
-0.0560136251,
0.6933254004,
0.2868315876,
-0.4724372327,
-0.4871754944,
-0.7939621806,
-0.4971149266,
-0.4874774218,
0.4744440913,
-0.5437652469,
-1.1723467112,
0.7016296387,
-0.1359719634,
0.0989193916,
0.1393049061,
0.5327090025,
0.1050683185,
1.1935369968,
0.5714153647,
0.1199670509,
0.0740821436,
-0.0686422512,
0.1470684707,
-0.6452313066,
-0.2645936012,
-0.0926145986,
-0.3570862412,
-0.3485608697,
-0.7226340771,
-0.0371930562,
0.0709825009,
-0.4361104071,
0.2400700003,
-0.4155107737,
0.833990097,
0.1947817355,
0.3937918246,
0.3080140054,
-0.4184381068,
-0.2146980911,
0.0087451441,
-0.4942542613,
-0.5619005561,
0.5421316624,
0.3962183893,
0.9656293392,
0.4608082175,
0.5426757932,
0.3554651737,
0.2103369534,
-0.9230551124,
0.7887724638,
0.19891496,
-0.9134730697,
-0.6117995381,
-0.5148931146,
-0.387080878,
0.3718471527,
-0.3509122431,
-1.0475434065,
0.1603553742,
0.1544281989,
-0.453382194,
0.2946720123,
-0.5030595064,
0.6355779767,
-0.2908168435,
-0.5144482255,
-0.2887680531,
-0.3835741878,
0.4696164727,
-0.1764160097,
0.1416667253,
0.0387459919,
-0.0560640171,
0.4156048,
-0.0637310296,
0.680749774,
-0.1729872376,
-0.5741550922,
0.2472625971,
0.2988339961,
0.8212533593,
0.1346043944,
-0.2882888317,
-0.2331185937,
-0.1491402686,
-0.0995362774,
-0.8081725836,
0.6599135995,
-0.6116873026,
-0.8955826759,
-0.1521861106,
-0.7479709387,
-0.5783820152,
-0.0009613846,
0.0044815121,
0.4422315657,
-0.2796221972,
0.2416887879,
0.7062574625,
-0.3089967668,
0.1177382171,
0.5654869676,
-0.3329003751,
-0.3405438662,
0.7076646686,
-0.414179951,
0.3058466017,
0.6018300056,
0.2277904004,
-0.5274261832,
-0.4698011279,
-0.2237915695,
0.3639229238,
-0.8939340711,
-0.1212317124,
-0.6473911405,
-0.2095475197,
-0.2381237149,
-0.28666538,
-0.1835998744,
-0.2545987368,
0.3457070291,
-0.3657784462,
0.3321436644,
0.7264375091,
-0.1531927139,
0.5611741543,
-0.659447968,
0.0940006599,
0.3386114836,
0.3551642299,
0.0515419804,
-0.522259593,
-0.2109487206,
0.047692515,
-0.0715680122,
-0.8367928267,
0.1847731322,
-0.1102336496,
0.8153173327,
0.2522640824,
-0.0218050927,
0.5171197653,
-0.3621172011,
0.565446794,
0.2200186253,
-1.1023312807,
0.3854954541,
-0.4796588123,
0.5400601029,
0.4429924786,
-0.0643911436,
-0.4082509875,
-0.6743826866,
-0.4361073375,
-0.4640026093,
1.0419894457,
0.1738431007,
-0.0457110256,
-0.1606703252,
0.2749862373,
0.0161907338,
-0.1703358293,
-0.9082413316,
-0.1611915976,
0.1926909238,
-0.1844899654,
-0.1854990274,
-0.1322125345,
0.0042395284,
-0.3474395275,
0.8298798203,
-0.2874662876,
0.0450357683,
-0.0492100827,
-0.1835587472,
-0.0577840544,
0.3987242281,
0.2651437223,
0.7664439082,
-0.1080075577,
0.2130381018,
0.5555136204,
-0.2773968577,
0.2995528877,
0.212038815,
-0.1402396411,
-0.3875385225,
0.304929167,
0.7745604515,
0.3694614172,
-0.9234777689,
0.1776097566,
-0.145425424,
-0.2817744613,
-0.1151285097,
0.2045984119,
0.4951336086,
0.9381482005,
0.198984459,
-0.1310588121,
0.198202759,
-0.4909963608,
0.1010655984,
0.4313515425,
-0.4632004499,
-0.3332377076,
0.5307199359,
0.3489878476,
-0.254935205,
0.1258383244,
-0.3791209757,
-0.5767571926,
0.5468707085,
0.9206564426,
0.7683707476,
-0.1868805289,
0.2693594098,
0.3280663192,
0.4545895457,
-0.3765019774,
0.3248935342,
0.1080019325,
-1.0250724554,
-0.8527351618,
-0.4077470601,
-0.3458942473,
0.4281108379,
-0.0914131254,
0.4311406016,
-0.3072220385,
-0.4133346379,
0.1018321514,
-0.0093347132,
-0.4849045575,
-0.092192933,
0.4824362397,
0.9025008678,
-0.436584264,
0.8433718681,
0.7948518395,
-0.2271145731,
-0.7830536366,
-0.1927357167,
-0.0597267635,
-0.6288435459,
0.6796800494,
0.0543333292,
-0.5136145353,
0.0820103213,
-0.5982775092,
-0.6474889517,
0.9382463694,
0.6516519189,
-0.6827304363,
-0.3079738319,
-0.1145984977,
0.7100386024,
-0.5194404125,
0.3278694749,
0.682245791,
0.4247353375,
0.4426555932,
-0.8413383365,
0.256985873,
-0.0298890006,
-0.1645831913,
0.3915573657,
-0.3637506068,
0.3579838276,
-0.5626537204,
-0.2252660841,
-0.2182855904,
0.5758169889,
0.5336420536,
-0.0484300777,
0.6367003918,
0.5234008431,
0.8003163934,
0.105541341,
0.7981179357,
-0.0796546042,
0.0970424563,
1.1658322811,
-0.7511073351,
0.4623332918,
0.1575659811,
0.0673502237,
0.3494796157,
0.3051743209,
0.0754033402,
0.3640812337,
0.4936944842,
-0.4063583016,
-0.7885764837,
-0.0734324753,
-0.1649480909,
0.5202451944,
0.5001029372,
-0.0944785401,
-0.1650115252,
-0.0387360081,
0.061382588,
0.165145129,
-0.2823964953,
1.0681842566,
0.0509589612,
-0.7514200807,
0.3152138591,
-0.0279070977,
0.7385858297,
-0.6219282746,
-0.0042363261,
-0.2934928238,
0.7989386916,
-0.0746680275,
-0.8429767489,
-0.0088862935,
0.0002474181,
-0.0450891443,
0.0420284197,
0.8717794418,
-0.4495063424,
-0.2826014459,
0.7937652469,
0.7729414701,
0.0659965053,
-0.0875802264,
-0.6069470644,
0.0765721649,
0.0568119921,
-0.0368006825,
0.1254874319,
0.763060689,
-0.0150149371,
0.7971010804,
0.5203334093,
0.1599351317,
-0.4324128032,
0.2148312032,
1.0660312176,
-0.741761148,
-0.5866231918,
-1.1732885838,
0.2194852531,
-0.3931315243,
0.0913325027,
0.6854181886,
0.651083529,
0.5067260265,
0.0191274658,
0.7912559509,
0.0025732387,
0.2890182734,
-0.2700484991,
0.5508961678,
-0.144739747,
0.3036319613,
-0.1317525208,
-0.9856846333,
-0.0685270503,
0.5529651642,
-0.4053134918,
-0.2375911325,
0.6162417531,
0.8742046952,
-0.0118948976,
0.273685813,
0.5091785789,
0.1696392149,
0.5968627334,
0.8587341309,
1.1483676434,
-0.0580443889,
0.5951735973,
0.1768009961,
-0.4581335485,
0.1652976722,
-0.7621352673,
-1.3379708529,
-0.3490932584,
-0.1217025667,
-0.437153995,
0.1087285876,
1.2899882793,
0.3999894857,
-0.5968897343,
-0.3773979843,
0.2039599568,
0.015088846,
-0.2949559093,
-0.2354900241,
0.0166697036,
-0.2280110419,
-0.4353206158,
0.552538693,
0.3011801243,
-0.2205870897,
-0.3957834244,
-0.3581815362,
-0.18759121,
0.5205722451,
0.8698646426,
0.0298935194,
-0.7657316923,
-0.3929499686,
0.3061926067,
-0.1263109893,
-0.1235646009,
0.7933641076,
-0.886805594,
0.4680224657,
0.3668656051,
0.667370975,
0.4318048358,
-0.1129928157,
0.8862646222,
-0.2559323311,
0.1082895175,
0.4991078675,
0.337487191,
0.4233451486,
-0.4159467816,
0.5366802812,
0.0244307239,
-0.5508155823,
-0.7110489607,
0.2678961754,
-0.6566836238,
-0.3036133647,
1.3276717663,
0.0914716423,
-0.1038370952,
-0.348334223,
-0.3574615717,
0.0130349994,
-0.6757737994,
0.6785445213,
0.9458658099,
-0.230718255,
-0.273655206,
-0.310015142,
0.7137947083,
-0.088160105,
-1.207367897,
0.3039931357,
0.7278521061,
-0.1120508388,
0.2123546302,
0.8701363206,
0.0151101258,
0.2181387991,
0.1120090932,
0.262378633,
-0.0578890592,
-0.0474556834,
-0.1799945384,
-0.1637659222,
-0.0301863551,
0.3418301642
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02318v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02318v1
|
Diversity Measurement and Subset Selection for Instruction Tuning Datasets
| 2024-02-04T02:09:43 | 2024-02-04T02:09:43 |
Peiqi Wang, Yikang Shen, Zhen Guo, Matthew Stallone, Yoon Kim, Polina Golland, Rameswar Panda
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
We aim to select data subsets for the fine-tuning of large language models to
more effectively follow instructions. Prior work has emphasized the importance
of diversity in dataset curation but relied on heuristics such as the number of
tasks. In this paper, we use determinantal point processes to capture the
diversity and quality of instruction tuning datasets for subset selection. We
propose to measure dataset diversity with log determinant distance that is the
distance between the dataset of interest and a maximally diverse reference
dataset. Our experiments demonstrate that the proposed diversity measure in the
normalized weight gradient space is correlated with downstream
instruction-following performance. Consequently, it can be used to inform when
data selection is the most helpful and to analyze dataset curation strategies.
We demonstrate the utility of our approach on various instruction tuning
datasets.
|
[
-0.698423624,
-0.3803403974,
0.0258331951,
0.0276672449,
-0.2811464965,
0.0737170503,
-0.3498527408,
-0.1699488014,
-0.1592431962,
0.2902387083,
-0.6919488907,
-0.8003007174,
-0.7097452283,
0.0576573052,
-0.4959390163,
1.0941311121,
0.1547174007,
0.210424304,
-0.0227655713,
-0.3039963841,
-0.7782437801,
-0.0774421245,
-0.5809757113,
-0.0595458634,
0.6091735363,
0.6340018511,
0.461779654,
1.1885647774,
0.4748088121,
0.2313429415,
-0.0900611877,
0.4760646224,
-0.6808296442,
0.3264009356,
-0.1037801728,
-0.8507273793,
0.0278267451,
0.0116700241,
0.954862535,
1.0290720463,
0.1488917619,
0.36204198,
0.1338602006,
1.0559134483,
-0.8097097278,
-0.2866620719,
-0.4463699758,
0.2573069334,
-0.463981986,
-0.0286204498,
-0.1782739609,
-0.7267415524,
-0.2306469828,
-0.3405035734,
0.46092695,
0.2320394516,
0.4145935774,
0.2454936653,
-0.2700263858,
-0.1924935579,
-1.0028816462,
1.2742546797,
-0.4861773849,
0.4142804444,
0.55286026,
0.2727228999,
-0.0419415496,
-0.068001084,
-0.2271127254,
0.1321682781,
0.0770624653,
-0.0458549075,
-0.0686024204,
-0.1862479597,
0.5405717492,
0.7033162117,
-0.5684527159,
0.391081363,
-0.5944284797,
0.004767111,
0.7442908883,
0.504909277,
0.1604930162,
0.2578291297,
0.102372475,
-0.3261223137,
-0.7289837599,
0.1419250071,
0.9519879222,
0.3259708583,
-0.0952462703,
0.331792891,
-0.4001469016,
0.9923673272,
0.0987546667,
0.1265776604,
0.055517301,
-0.7427737117,
-0.11767409,
-0.0099247657,
0.3111252487,
0.2513847649,
0.0512548722,
0.1301960498,
-0.3073606193,
-0.3545830846,
0.0886038914,
-0.7506431937,
-0.5163596272,
-0.1767929047,
-0.599668622,
0.1708814949,
0.167794928,
-0.7170062661,
-0.210832417,
-0.7142050862,
-0.2550237179,
-0.5421401858,
-0.0584931187,
-0.0601985604,
-0.2444702983,
0.1022870541,
0.2530539334,
-1.2996038198,
0.3645484447,
0.8454419971,
0.6347381473,
-0.5249242187,
-0.0860400423,
-0.6037883162,
-0.1948413998,
-0.5218598843,
0.4653246105,
-0.8114030361,
-0.5842028856,
-0.2562267184,
-0.0996569321,
-0.3988999128,
-0.8738839626,
0.3731630445,
-0.4952665865,
0.079628922,
-0.6833426952,
-0.8364270329,
-0.3169272244,
-0.0612350889,
-0.9343898296,
1.1076323986,
0.5417652726,
-0.6331564188,
0.7024108768,
-0.3515569866,
-0.632728219,
0.0997336507,
-0.1292695999,
-0.386451751,
0.3345392644,
0.1646670848,
0.1195095852,
-0.1359758377,
-0.1338155717,
-0.2013266534,
-0.7192357779,
-0.0452205352,
-0.3746907711,
0.9781497717,
0.1715789735,
-0.2871029377,
-0.0552017093,
-0.7821662426,
0.0443003662,
-0.4530138075,
-0.5725986958,
-0.5932384729,
0.1375652403,
-0.3965706527,
0.0526247919,
0.0471791252,
-0.2564087212,
0.0900079608,
0.0894961059,
-0.197977379,
0.7377184033,
-0.0336813927,
0.319907248,
-0.609167397,
0.7404011488,
0.052323278,
0.2712023854,
0.0326970778,
-0.471126616,
-0.7306101322,
-0.442425698,
0.3042562008,
0.5567020178,
-0.1446934193,
0.796191752,
-0.0968531817,
-0.3948723078,
-0.6125212312,
0.4446708858,
0.2873554528,
0.3447205424,
0.2550128102,
-0.4026382565,
-0.6004410386,
-0.7395880818,
0.0456749573,
0.0749398321,
-0.2232755125,
0.3602869511,
0.3236516118,
0.0620255284,
0.6285936832,
-0.4946541786,
0.1431813389,
-0.107317932,
0.0294552781,
0.4388431311,
0.618714571,
0.590697825,
-0.5644957423,
-0.5604547858,
-0.0526008159,
-0.4998394847,
0.0083287079,
0.0102113029,
-0.5191835761,
0.0003237776,
0.3369369209,
-0.1879706234,
0.4025060236,
0.535615027,
-0.2452252805,
0.6270309091,
0.2016373128,
0.571416378,
-0.7036523223,
0.0702309385,
-0.1403579712,
0.0839413404,
-0.4791370332,
-0.1793341786,
-0.2005265951,
0.41424945,
-0.1217587367,
0.1038437709,
-0.242847234,
-0.2616217136,
0.0180570055,
-0.0751077086,
-0.020638518,
0.167336598,
-0.2955614924,
0.6792019606,
0.4797632992,
-0.7525720596,
0.4778843224,
0.1991313994,
-0.6496321559,
0.9293559194,
-0.3839015663,
-0.0851328894,
-0.0944852605,
-0.2219559997,
-0.9569064379,
0.1152887493,
0.1466527879,
-0.1368433982,
0.3080075085,
-0.05939335,
-0.3463682532,
-0.3304050863,
-0.4248528481,
0.1924607903,
0.4012016356,
-0.4368075132,
-0.126904279,
-0.0327122211,
-0.2516879439,
-0.6060022712,
-0.4650637209,
-0.4252229333,
-0.2994768322,
-0.5190941691,
0.0919546783,
-0.2629777789,
-0.2885733843,
-0.319054991,
-0.2944080234,
0.0847323686,
0.2085985392,
0.1717974097,
0.2542277277,
-0.4232428074,
0.2611602247,
0.5094456673,
0.2661106288,
0.0485282503,
-0.3757512569,
0.3662709892,
0.2193814069,
-0.5564945936,
-0.133083865,
0.5652028918,
0.0158414859,
-0.1863835454,
0.7881652117,
0.8195844293,
-0.1155651808,
-0.5592152476,
-0.2216408849,
-0.4528608024,
-0.4687970281,
0.4504095018,
-0.0473338403,
-0.9533908963,
0.6454848647,
0.2097591907,
0.4622178376,
0.1224475354,
0.3479180336,
-0.1907091886,
0.8606094718,
0.4433068335,
-0.1889191568,
0.8957897425,
-0.2766475677,
0.1480980068,
-0.8085383177,
-0.1374674588,
-0.858938694,
-0.9578184485,
-0.603056848,
-0.3121525049,
0.0659819916,
0.2724010944,
-0.4966661632,
0.078364335,
-0.46823439,
0.5998612046,
1.0604463816,
0.1227689609,
0.322851181,
0.4168428481,
-0.005839719,
-0.2336580604,
-0.5773687363,
-0.3158029616,
1.0776772499,
-0.0011437018,
0.8074522018,
-0.0919642672,
0.8019869328,
0.2721673548,
0.1199200526,
-0.445661813,
0.4508566856,
-0.8774639964,
-0.4112958312,
-0.6190713048,
-0.6635653377,
-0.9984140992,
-0.1046622619,
0.1959276199,
-0.6933177114,
0.3665370643,
0.0521282032,
-0.1926997453,
0.3618791699,
-0.2920009494,
0.6481616497,
-0.0201739073,
-0.048133973,
-0.423610121,
-0.5046928525,
0.2854635417,
0.0499715544,
-0.1839913428,
-0.2027796209,
0.3685232103,
0.9321038127,
-0.2266020626,
0.6777818799,
-0.1279334426,
-0.1665060073,
0.2916039526,
0.2906233072,
0.1133224368,
-0.0925970972,
-0.3929370642,
0.1951551288,
-0.4256960154,
-0.3063161075,
-0.4876696169,
0.9759405255,
-0.837985158,
-0.4060838819,
0.3719406426,
-0.7887228727,
-0.0911721513,
-0.0291961282,
0.2501212358,
0.3807580173,
0.1509923637,
0.4868537784,
0.8432351351,
-0.0058424822,
0.5212829709,
0.4787186086,
0.2466720641,
-0.1779661775,
1.0097260475,
0.2666604817,
0.5032824278,
0.5770509839,
-0.0458660237,
-0.0627671778,
-0.6636071205,
-0.3439961672,
-0.229099825,
-0.8298686147,
-0.1457920223,
-0.1457225084,
-0.2051129043,
0.1023545265,
-0.0935244486,
-0.2140566409,
-0.4590972066,
-0.5026862621,
-0.3693809807,
0.4960739911,
0.4871885478,
-0.0881870165,
0.2625359297,
-0.7310234308,
0.0279925484,
0.4502497017,
0.4357705712,
-0.1148520187,
-0.5845307708,
-0.5893554091,
0.1363749951,
-0.3769710958,
-0.6067319512,
0.1411054134,
0.3996022046,
0.844130218,
0.4495268464,
-0.1317127198,
0.4023850858,
-0.1183080748,
0.6467152238,
-0.0955841094,
-0.6673461795,
0.7487116456,
-0.2592799664,
0.3914342523,
0.8461453915,
0.5581791997,
-0.379255712,
-0.6221521497,
-0.1036558896,
-0.5066479445,
0.7414254546,
0.0717088953,
-0.0778195933,
0.0852687359,
0.0990867391,
0.471642077,
0.326713115,
-0.0288046114,
-0.6255398989,
-0.053252466,
-0.4763948917,
0.1372340173,
0.3015455902,
-0.3591859639,
-0.4057239294,
0.3839055598,
-0.1563140601,
0.096345976,
-0.4660066068,
-0.0222427621,
-0.3234814107,
0.0795760602,
0.4842514396,
0.8294836283,
-0.0858077779,
-0.0781174451,
0.0123772388,
-0.8344452977,
0.0933628604,
0.1657619625,
-0.4536496997,
0.1974328905,
0.3163600862,
1.0288441181,
0.0506740622,
-0.3171709776,
-0.0229274947,
-0.0152039155,
-0.0104671894,
0.3292299211,
0.7772915959,
-0.1121185422,
0.2200092971,
0.3263366222,
-0.0276189074,
0.2529518008,
0.0815073922,
0.3929645121,
0.2945464253,
-0.309812218,
-0.1984334737,
0.2869043648,
0.2202055603,
-0.2364059389,
1.3189232349,
-0.1853387505,
0.0303557944,
1.1621838808,
0.362362951,
0.6986661553,
-0.4557048082,
0.3653509319,
0.6458787918,
0.3030883372,
-0.0195197091,
0.4793480039,
-0.1048021093,
-0.5472260714,
-0.3039690256,
-0.6296644807,
-0.2618787885,
0.1167069003,
-0.872852385,
0.2929599583,
-0.5420140624,
0.001748848,
-0.1520707458,
0.1594439298,
-0.8028379679,
0.2352382541,
0.2016726136,
0.6528056264,
-0.9397554398,
0.4886140227,
0.4473060369,
-0.0046279812,
-0.7561793327,
-0.262091279,
0.0120771229,
-0.6151003242,
0.8949739337,
0.2063605487,
0.2385790646,
-0.1774679273,
-0.4132505655,
-0.8017140031,
1.1679834127,
0.3695854247,
-1.0034239292,
0.2686644495,
0.1594596654,
0.3068619668,
-0.5113740563,
0.2039749175,
0.8995588422,
0.2584052384,
0.0505438969,
-0.4749410152,
-0.144248113,
-0.1189507321,
0.2023456246,
0.5068970323,
-0.3883464038,
1.1414296627,
-0.119911626,
-0.1359473914,
-0.2011938542,
0.4468071163,
0.4156708717,
0.1562745124,
0.512052536,
0.5049328804,
1.0410451889,
-0.0869695693,
0.7467393875,
-0.3463326097,
0.1906902343,
1.0393186808,
-0.1267919242,
0.4332710505,
0.2418376207,
-0.5005922914,
0.5570811629,
0.7191542983,
-0.4766534865,
0.4527162313,
0.4619921446,
-0.4324016571,
-0.1933486164,
-0.1066462025,
-0.2722288966,
0.197950393,
0.5673222542,
-0.4380010664,
-0.2646406889,
-0.2106614411,
-0.2371265888,
-0.0226770975,
-0.3922895789,
0.5496840477,
-0.1009610966,
-0.6606736183,
0.6307098269,
-0.1225193813,
0.4771561623,
-0.5244294405,
-0.1236751229,
-0.7535895109,
-0.0798825026,
-0.1872086823,
-0.8988043666,
0.2867420912,
-0.3520465791,
-0.5948411226,
0.0122803664,
0.3390073478,
-0.5888046622,
-0.5261334181,
0.0537230894,
0.2953408659,
0.024231365,
0.3587082624,
-0.4333272874,
0.0666560307,
0.2073391527,
-0.225317508,
0.4080784917,
0.3308418393,
-0.3006748259,
0.4811456501,
0.5214565992,
0.1368107647,
0.3823570311,
0.3582221866,
0.6539971232,
-0.422377497,
-0.5046309829,
-0.9212566614,
0.3975178003,
-0.1446288079,
-0.5672035217,
0.8260529637,
0.654594481,
1.088606596,
-0.1227318868,
0.722687006,
0.0200136527,
0.4481988847,
-0.3967104256,
0.3076637685,
-0.1039522514,
0.3638724685,
0.1661712974,
-1.131475687,
-0.0949711129,
0.4994567931,
-0.2717999518,
0.2896251678,
0.4752747416,
1.0263416767,
-0.2544699311,
0.2716614306,
0.1441940516,
-0.2907533348,
0.0470974185,
0.7115705609,
0.6705501676,
-0.1344213188,
0.2832704484,
-0.2328778654,
-0.290135771,
-0.2788032293,
-0.6376667619,
-1.0110818148,
-0.3803166449,
-0.477966398,
0.150795266,
0.0755028203,
0.6520747542,
0.8732723594,
-1.1334813833,
-0.3378761411,
0.000373726,
0.5588567257,
-0.6933782101,
-0.2152820826,
0.2234684229,
-0.3116699159,
-0.7346907258,
0.2036238015,
0.1994798779,
-0.1303649545,
-0.3176192939,
-0.1218141615,
-0.094311513,
-0.1329556406,
0.2913698852,
0.1707210988,
-0.1636657864,
-0.02992348,
0.0287095178,
-0.1248433068,
0.0878412798,
0.8511062264,
-0.2562788427,
0.4281546175,
0.6846914887,
0.6334866285,
0.2565668523,
-0.046762228,
0.6471003294,
-1.274641633,
-0.1437727064,
0.2637888789,
0.046716433,
0.4541077018,
-0.4182145894,
0.4366055727,
0.0582052283,
-0.5194751024,
-0.4559241235,
0.2689995468,
-0.3638153374,
0.1160878539,
0.9173590541,
-0.301954031,
0.0421532206,
-0.0793922618,
0.0565601438,
0.1584588736,
-0.41942361,
0.7286447883,
0.7670158744,
-0.1425338089,
-0.2146261483,
-0.6940300465,
0.5502020121,
0.292830646,
-0.9374912381,
-0.063566789,
0.6514308453,
0.2430047095,
-0.0309950691,
0.0461977012,
0.0299215056,
0.4265902936,
0.0108896671,
-0.2222594172,
0.0094220918,
-0.3263604343,
-0.2906809151,
-0.0800885484,
-0.0681306794,
-0.5041187406
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02315v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02315v1
|
A Survey of Large Language Models in Finance (FinLLMs)
| 2024-02-04T02:06:57 | 2024-02-04T02:06:57 |
Jean Lee, Nicholas Stevens, Soyeon Caren Han, Minseok Song
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, q-fin.GN
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown remarkable capabilities across a wide
variety of Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks and have attracted attention
from multiple domains, including financial services. Despite the extensive
research into general-domain LLMs, and their immense potential in finance,
Financial LLM (FinLLM) research remains limited. This survey provides a
comprehensive overview of FinLLMs, including their history, techniques,
performance, and opportunities and challenges. Firstly, we present a
chronological overview of general-domain Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs)
through to current FinLLMs, including the GPT-series, selected open-source
LLMs, and financial LMs. Secondly, we compare five techniques used across
financial PLMs and FinLLMs, including training methods, training data, and
fine-tuning methods. Thirdly, we summarize the performance evaluations of six
benchmark tasks and datasets. In addition, we provide eight advanced financial
NLP tasks and datasets for developing more sophisticated FinLLMs. Finally, we
discuss the opportunities and the challenges facing FinLLMs, such as
hallucination, privacy, and efficiency. To support AI research in finance, we
compile a collection of accessible datasets and evaluation benchmarks on
GitHub.
|
[
-0.1977133751,
-0.771060586,
0.3257492185,
0.0882766768,
0.0913380384,
0.5139003396,
-0.519790113,
-0.7158674598,
-0.1219647974,
0.8584180474,
-0.4430184364,
-0.6276876926,
-0.6269840598,
-0.050809972,
-0.5120473504,
0.9757313132,
0.0567971729,
0.3747236133,
-0.1654256731,
0.1247470975,
-0.1614636481,
-0.7642544508,
-1.0980083942,
-0.2699981928,
0.2375646383,
0.0611869507,
0.4558828175,
0.2934221923,
0.9499022961,
0.3507104814,
-0.0055954293,
-0.0303374175,
-0.4152848721,
-0.1287920922,
-0.1697736531,
-0.1940849423,
-0.55831182,
0.3374138772,
0.5309109092,
1.1097195148,
-0.2197349966,
0.2189510912,
-0.0925097018,
0.7856185436,
-0.4856483936,
0.5935122371,
-0.4209775329,
-0.1676736772,
-0.2048993558,
0.0491428599,
-0.4723953009,
-0.2556528151,
0.5328400731,
-0.3340722322,
0.028699087,
0.4019032419,
0.4870630801,
0.0474925488,
-0.3318809867,
-0.6806609631,
-0.7824783325,
0.870472908,
-0.7199310064,
0.4571269751,
0.4296596944,
0.2823154628,
-0.1788213402,
-0.7462264299,
0.0752605423,
-0.3779110312,
-0.0591169037,
-0.1798759103,
-0.2592437267,
0.139888674,
0.0412427038,
0.5530204177,
-0.4661637545,
0.5336363316,
-0.3251679242,
-0.1081071422,
0.7835971713,
0.1260462999,
-0.1915906519,
0.2313242406,
-0.5739163756,
-0.3479121327,
-0.6759005785,
0.0282377228,
0.4742594659,
0.383554548,
-0.0891997591,
0.4836141467,
0.1354359388,
0.8707486391,
-0.3610674739,
-0.4187793434,
0.0331387408,
-0.4544020295,
-0.5456241369,
-0.1319940984,
0.6698979735,
0.1946423501,
0.4650954008,
-0.2939392924,
-0.4222601056,
-0.5351269841,
-0.0459902547,
-0.4215907156,
-0.0963741839,
0.2791202366,
-0.3340688944,
0.0745669678,
0.0286532529,
-0.6619778275,
-0.2998254299,
-0.4226686954,
0.1186684296,
-0.3051632941,
-0.0603700429,
0.6396864653,
-0.2107737511,
0.5419919491,
0.1245981604,
-0.9526548386,
0.7359762788,
1.2035201788,
0.630012393,
-0.0855652094,
-0.1002718359,
-0.609639287,
0.1389622837,
-0.4015307724,
0.7000747919,
-0.3944092095,
-0.3625418842,
0.1593648344,
-0.2498578578,
-0.2823888659,
-0.7944854498,
0.0901788548,
-0.5034267306,
0.0044134976,
0.0092577972,
-0.8219195604,
-0.2289373875,
0.1607928425,
-0.6557071805,
0.5197123885,
0.1742706001,
-0.5296683908,
0.2813573778,
-0.850959003,
-0.4393239021,
0.0747612715,
-0.0902639851,
-0.4353211224,
-0.0655725077,
-0.0514603257,
0.8141618967,
-0.8689203262,
0.599627018,
-0.2884894609,
-0.3359962106,
0.4664885998,
-0.2954496741,
0.4325428307,
0.0963812694,
-0.2315963507,
0.2154834121,
-0.6901935339,
-0.4208753407,
0.0970868692,
0.0833892971,
-0.4662596583,
-0.0343012474,
0.3963100016,
-0.1599918455,
0.4474891722,
-0.236555323,
0.0618308745,
-0.6473332047,
0.7809385657,
0.7728476524,
-0.2863912284,
0.2281801552,
-0.3881471455,
0.5458341837,
-0.3471322656,
0.0571196117,
-0.2269501835,
-0.235321492,
-0.3668834269,
-0.3991588056,
0.2561350167,
0.4644095302,
-0.1315400451,
0.2035237104,
0.0458874106,
-0.3908673823,
-0.0321637988,
0.3987857401,
0.2115961015,
0.0601140745,
0.0813316926,
0.0600154512,
-0.3087128103,
-1.1631407738,
-0.2119212747,
-0.2179230899,
0.0454396196,
0.2085508257,
0.4865075946,
0.0047027757,
0.7281651497,
-0.6857410669,
-0.3076874316,
-0.3452763557,
0.230895713,
0.394987762,
0.4139954448,
0.8564929962,
-0.8789612055,
-0.0210887846,
0.0289617591,
-0.291325748,
0.125880301,
-0.2010083199,
0.1951441169,
0.1628260463,
0.5943418741,
-0.5564805269,
0.0500484072,
0.6009018421,
-0.4447723627,
0.4313221872,
-0.1582311988,
0.0096954424,
-0.8408529162,
0.3052415252,
0.2882150114,
-0.2674045563,
-0.5107980371,
-0.0304303095,
-0.1192680299,
0.098335959,
-0.2076657861,
0.9051698446,
-0.4966951311,
-0.5277721286,
-0.2377355844,
0.1671752036,
-0.3434893489,
0.3047710955,
-0.0390293971,
0.8162842989,
0.567686379,
-0.2810465991,
0.5557643771,
0.1301746368,
-0.5904268026,
0.3304797709,
-0.5487376451,
-0.1388142854,
0.0849363804,
0.014872537,
-1.1642112732,
-0.1640262455,
0.0185144693,
0.0648480505,
0.5427932739,
0.2387267053,
-0.4669662714,
-0.4927103817,
-0.2683313489,
0.2691670358,
0.2731338143,
-0.2843995988,
0.4331557751,
0.3917174935,
-0.8090012074,
-0.6987093091,
-0.4901390672,
0.3271676302,
-0.3844229877,
-0.4965345263,
0.1654533297,
-0.1213638633,
-0.8043525815,
-0.2375960946,
-0.030570494,
0.0246578269,
0.4435294867,
0.1027040482,
0.6722665429,
-0.3147156835,
0.0282535814,
-0.4442733526,
-0.1105628014,
0.1993479133,
-0.5289238691,
0.5696559548,
-0.3610164225,
-0.272670269,
0.1090172455,
0.1564989835,
0.4523706734,
-0.2626096606,
0.6460201144,
0.3918521702,
-0.2848023474,
-0.1460051537,
-0.8788852692,
0.1504909396,
-0.458172977,
0.2221961915,
0.0129598016,
-1.5601015091,
0.5935666561,
-0.1994690895,
0.3501231074,
0.6889057159,
0.6548756361,
0.1922837347,
0.4595942199,
0.8812756538,
-0.3374299407,
0.3181541562,
-0.3391821384,
0.2645601928,
-0.2221488953,
-0.3760251701,
-0.6750450134,
-0.1685438603,
-0.1934421062,
-0.3889534473,
-0.0085644377,
0.2536968291,
-0.2524158657,
0.2215793431,
0.0727994964,
0.3912742734,
0.2943291664,
-0.5451515317,
0.3805651069,
-0.1265001595,
-0.0222385172,
0.2525925338,
-0.4749916196,
-0.5074446797,
1.1584984064,
0.6027364731,
0.9133095145,
-0.0655870438,
0.3183507621,
0.4379961193,
0.4900050461,
-0.6447474957,
0.3345406055,
-0.5928500891,
-0.4330739975,
-0.4978328049,
-0.7159398198,
-0.6145743132,
-0.3595299125,
0.0763225183,
-0.7113779187,
-0.0675885826,
-0.2169579118,
-0.725820899,
0.3752409816,
-0.4472421408,
0.7676990628,
-0.5012923479,
-0.1725053638,
-0.0509528816,
-0.3526387215,
0.7227950692,
-0.7174351811,
0.5472079515,
-0.2593190968,
-0.1376491934,
0.7956567407,
-0.3357627988,
0.7574420571,
0.1076258495,
-0.6657857299,
0.1481573135,
-0.3748637736,
0.3750461936,
0.1297262758,
-0.0646330863,
0.2260308713,
0.0573342182,
-0.3040536642,
-0.140534848,
0.8253113627,
-0.4334487915,
-0.5231451988,
-0.2871381342,
-0.6596990228,
-0.6430184245,
-0.1445503831,
-0.2657335699,
0.2690665722,
-0.3642574847,
0.4372813404,
0.4121159315,
-0.2966693342,
0.6602804065,
0.5777614117,
-0.4712385237,
-0.4254728258,
0.6068485379,
-0.0401657335,
0.2002196461,
0.5301157832,
0.0909589753,
-0.5909105539,
-0.7315209508,
0.0076502147,
0.3508656621,
-0.3970512152,
-0.3360257149,
-0.3737533987,
-0.3034954369,
-0.6966207623,
-0.2344543934,
-0.4788116217,
-0.302454114,
-0.0582220778,
-0.3517456651,
0.8147670031,
1.0820719004,
-0.1920367926,
0.3183110058,
-0.7426203489,
0.3300967216,
0.3462915421,
0.7898853421,
0.0997035429,
-0.1538894475,
-0.3823745847,
-0.1634554267,
0.4017697275,
-0.165048793,
0.3873628378,
0.1325570047,
0.681183815,
0.5256971121,
-0.2007494718,
0.4877227545,
-0.116858609,
0.6061643362,
0.3264698088,
-0.7019821405,
0.0985031649,
-0.4222105443,
-0.0351230986,
0.4813877642,
0.574008882,
-0.4406009614,
-0.3732351363,
-0.2371453792,
-0.9801581502,
0.6099867225,
0.0342747457,
0.0331165269,
-0.0106587131,
0.5541794896,
0.3234366179,
0.5412046909,
-0.3129775524,
-0.2865562141,
0.2991554141,
-0.0936331302,
-0.5836250186,
-0.1381673068,
-0.0346321166,
-0.1354562938,
0.5291966796,
-0.1767838299,
-0.3687593341,
-0.1319797039,
0.176241681,
0.0789647326,
0.1464980692,
0.6914289594,
0.8569660783,
-0.4366802871,
-0.1306325942,
-0.0576662868,
-0.4499234259,
0.1003468856,
0.4251770377,
0.1085753664,
-0.1185428128,
0.4014021158,
0.6674684286,
0.7618968487,
-1.2638001442,
0.5105464458,
-0.1200572029,
-0.5147785544,
-0.5554046035,
0.0014538683,
0.43390733,
0.5614524484,
0.8379413486,
-0.1886487454,
-0.0511592291,
-0.609770596,
0.2822602987,
0.622087419,
-0.2325570732,
-0.0196143184,
0.7822509408,
-0.1029295847,
-0.0726035833,
0.4585418999,
0.1586266458,
-0.2300038487,
0.66062361,
0.3012378514,
0.9608303308,
0.0356536433,
0.1177903339,
-0.0881593674,
0.1700449884,
-0.519159615,
0.1833946109,
0.1468514949,
-0.5224749446,
-0.7118983865,
-1.1484669447,
-0.5834251046,
0.5408322811,
-0.6473174095,
0.0681945533,
-0.7476757169,
-0.3768312335,
0.2505759597,
0.1063135564,
-0.7652255893,
-0.0319766924,
0.2394547462,
1.1503839493,
-0.3481921256,
0.4801646769,
0.539655447,
-0.071283862,
-0.3288678229,
-0.5546379685,
-0.0512846112,
-0.7574686408,
0.622872293,
-0.1102861166,
-0.1381545961,
0.0275179688,
-0.5761122704,
-0.7391658425,
0.8748552799,
0.3836318254,
-0.8958519697,
-0.3612734377,
0.5471427441,
0.2871207595,
-0.561865449,
-0.1006225124,
0.8713278174,
0.6338905692,
0.1303885579,
-0.9540865421,
-0.5639341474,
-0.0968277454,
-0.1027989089,
0.2600134611,
-0.8021546006,
0.9034109712,
0.0079705613,
0.1041646078,
0.3507269025,
0.5337330103,
0.2218067944,
0.4634819925,
0.3170297146,
0.1946085244,
0.6825116873,
-0.2514860332,
0.9736542702,
-0.6677020788,
0.4320947826,
0.9603735805,
-0.5519865751,
0.9338825345,
0.3436025083,
-0.3197101057,
-0.0238560606,
0.7304814458,
-0.3298917711,
-0.0102628814,
0.5663309693,
-0.0780880153,
-0.429798305,
-0.0380624272,
-0.3000385463,
0.5243007541,
0.4248465896,
-0.3744001389,
-0.1590236425,
0.1640942097,
-0.1605230421,
0.0659479797,
-0.5533589125,
0.7455160022,
0.5247241259,
-0.2270383686,
0.0138583388,
0.2941473722,
0.9198381901,
-1.0973863602,
0.2352772057,
-0.2725857794,
0.0860583782,
0.259075731,
-0.5655632615,
0.3783020973,
0.1757266074,
0.0008700849,
-0.5954927206,
0.7161371708,
-0.2967863083,
-0.7568660378,
0.570536077,
0.6339344382,
0.07671877,
-0.0469466783,
-0.4217030108,
-0.1786179394,
-0.3484473825,
-0.35388726,
0.4995020926,
0.1504397392,
0.167087391,
0.71143502,
0.7774894834,
0.1534507573,
-0.1555200964,
0.1445686668,
0.507599771,
-1.1827133894,
-0.1982535124,
-0.9050528407,
-0.1980923712,
0.1851466745,
-0.4471815228,
0.7132636309,
0.9372454882,
0.9751960635,
-0.1255741119,
0.5540505052,
0.7451804876,
0.4086363614,
-0.8453963995,
0.7575797439,
-0.3178884387,
0.4660268724,
-0.364639163,
-0.7598876953,
-0.3268177211,
0.3635104001,
-0.4282709062,
-0.1054543704,
0.1499736309,
0.4036804438,
0.1937689334,
0.3148679137,
0.4834873378,
0.1222184226,
-0.0373992249,
0.3716419637,
0.7940202951,
-0.0789558142,
0.2255691439,
0.054793667,
0.2659224272,
-0.3406056166,
-0.8187939525,
-0.7585808635,
-0.3886312842,
-0.4497576058,
0.2537724674,
0.011065972,
0.9775753021,
0.4128855765,
-0.7874527574,
-0.7830591798,
0.3522694707,
0.0938264951,
-0.0706415623,
-0.1807009727,
0.268845588,
-0.3027141392,
-0.7056500316,
0.5519428849,
0.7289696336,
0.3075817823,
-0.6093919277,
0.0539605916,
0.0045694578,
0.200660333,
0.7197589874,
0.110564962,
-0.4616768956,
-0.0238703955,
0.0949148536,
-0.1260775179,
-0.1411450654,
1.0899249315,
-0.2075779736,
-0.189487353,
0.2164520323,
0.8657886982,
0.4858558178,
-0.1331705153,
0.7589568496,
-0.276260823,
0.072129868,
0.086494565,
0.5146480799,
0.1154750735,
-0.0178441927,
0.667984426,
0.0651055351,
-0.2912781835,
-0.6447399259,
-0.3363275826,
-0.9414252639,
-0.659653306,
0.9885676503,
-0.0795327574,
-0.2882716954,
-0.2207429558,
0.1460094452,
-0.2759955227,
-0.1867505014,
0.2419777513,
0.9205028415,
0.1207813993,
-0.0128825223,
-0.8826512098,
0.6121096015,
0.0647227168,
-0.6494047642,
0.3606785834,
0.5153562427,
0.1259583682,
0.0027100358,
0.6370020509,
0.0197879057,
-0.0643619075,
-0.1859039366,
-0.1408316791,
-0.1673821211,
-0.3779087961,
-0.3512077332,
0.5298504829,
0.1296708733,
0.4671305716
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02314v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02314v3
|
Selecting Large Language Model to Fine-tune via Rectified Scaling Law
| 2024-02-04T01:55:00 | 2024-05-28T16:16:42 |
Haowei Lin, Baizhou Huang, Haotian Ye, Qinyu Chen, Zihao Wang, Sujian Li, Jianzhu Ma, Xiaojun Wan, James Zou, Yitao Liang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The ever-growing ecosystem of LLMs has posed a challenge in selecting the
most appropriate pre-trained model to fine-tune amidst a sea of options. Given
constrained resources, fine-tuning all models and making selections afterward
is unrealistic. In this work, we formulate this resource-constrained selection
task into predicting fine-tuning performance and illustrate its natural
connection with Scaling Law. Unlike pre-training, we find that the fine-tuning
scaling curve includes not just the well-known "power phase" but also the
previously unobserved "pre-power phase". We also explain why existing Scaling
Law fails to capture this phase transition phenomenon both theoretically and
empirically. To address this, we introduce the concept of "pre-learned data
size" into our Rectified Scaling Law, which overcomes theoretical limitations
and fits experimental results much better. By leveraging our law, we propose a
novel LLM selection algorithm that selects the near-optimal model with hundreds
of times less resource consumption, while other methods may provide negatively
correlated selection. The project page is available at
rectified-scaling-law.github.io.
|
[
-0.562368691,
-0.607044816,
0.6076558828,
-0.059162017,
-0.4682544768,
-0.0042396351,
-0.5746837854,
-0.3360087872,
0.0396522805,
0.8099893332,
-0.8164473772,
0.0062457616,
-0.4792953134,
0.0990740955,
-0.3136834502,
1.1356922388,
0.0314713828,
-0.1016542912,
-0.0691819265,
0.2479451895,
-0.3656630516,
-0.0621593371,
-0.6857463717,
-0.9347094297,
0.4127569795,
0.5852823257,
0.5532053113,
0.8066049218,
0.4624786973,
0.2756211162,
-0.2818339169,
0.3034640551,
-0.7532058358,
-0.0013753866,
-0.1263983846,
-0.5400082469,
-0.5441662073,
0.2251020968,
0.732530117,
0.6857816577,
-0.1216597334,
0.4320673347,
0.2918443084,
0.8805412054,
-0.6435357928,
0.2097764611,
-1.0022435188,
0.1281917989,
-0.1602442712,
-0.2397424728,
-0.4209895432,
-0.2673226297,
-0.0325873382,
-0.6896781921,
0.3841254413,
0.3461942673,
0.7075841427,
0.5691385865,
-0.3962058127,
0.0263140891,
-0.9841204882,
0.9988936782,
-0.5182698965,
0.4555578828,
0.5594196916,
0.2251384556,
-0.0974028111,
-0.8203027248,
-0.4039488733,
-0.3763560057,
0.0747472942,
-0.2434674352,
-0.1960205734,
0.2011036724,
0.443182379,
0.4732997715,
-0.3448649347,
0.3334882259,
-0.3778228164,
-0.1831594259,
0.5258579254,
0.2596186697,
-0.1714957058,
0.0109061385,
0.1967683285,
0.1319959611,
-0.8288441896,
-0.1996316761,
0.2543541789,
0.6852052808,
-0.0005333897,
0.3661291599,
-0.2038646787,
0.6395795941,
0.4018478096,
-0.1422784775,
0.0896260217,
-0.3111091554,
-0.423835218,
-0.0057655633,
0.5884011984,
0.1947732866,
0.6152104139,
0.0232603941,
-0.2380986363,
-0.6063727736,
0.3788482249,
-0.9257479906,
-0.3223843277,
0.0230412558,
-0.5352135301,
-0.0906087756,
-0.32822451,
-0.6470680237,
-0.5317213535,
-0.4321480095,
0.2948830724,
0.0308356155,
-0.4796136916,
0.2030308247,
0.2963983417,
-0.0417144559,
0.1223855615,
-1.2226456404,
0.1274507046,
0.705283463,
0.8235721588,
0.2522873282,
-0.1707171649,
-0.466755867,
-0.1596721113,
-0.410338521,
0.3542900383,
-0.4298656881,
-0.5236970782,
-0.1074115634,
0.0147468979,
0.2363645136,
-0.7389553785,
0.4711441398,
-0.599419713,
-0.3608126938,
-0.2568188608,
-0.4539746642,
0.0260917768,
0.0175004862,
-0.8136310577,
0.5537518263,
0.09711992,
-0.6269145012,
0.6510406137,
-0.3564840257,
-0.5578334332,
0.0834521428,
0.1012726426,
-0.7348638177,
0.2366710901,
-0.133825928,
0.5962581038,
-0.6073781252,
0.1343744248,
-0.3716845512,
-0.1277611405,
0.0057257921,
-0.3467411697,
0.3670265079,
0.6748245955,
-0.0599015504,
0.1800547242,
-0.8084454536,
0.1700822115,
0.1873025,
-0.4670122266,
0.0250162855,
0.1843885928,
-0.1667421758,
-0.2282297164,
0.5248089433,
-0.5513345599,
0.1534424424,
-0.3116431534,
0.8624456525,
0.6913191676,
-0.252943933,
0.7258181572,
-0.3053915799,
0.4959466457,
-0.3906258345,
0.2154097259,
0.2384805381,
0.15763174,
-0.6569036245,
-0.2282956988,
0.3361807764,
0.2545985281,
-0.4407863915,
0.3535308838,
-0.3626389503,
-0.5250251889,
-0.5836684704,
0.4913631976,
0.2610372305,
0.3592819571,
0.4022686779,
-0.0249720383,
-0.6458105445,
-0.9125268459,
-0.2288547754,
-0.0308233574,
-0.1116521731,
0.3844720423,
0.2675277889,
-0.137367174,
0.8612122536,
-0.6660202146,
-0.3659487665,
-0.5442701578,
0.095127143,
0.2556452751,
0.5682272315,
0.3188002706,
-0.6803579926,
-0.333774507,
0.2916334569,
-0.1330213845,
-0.2797344625,
-0.1009320542,
0.1425507516,
-0.1395106018,
0.9513164163,
-0.3724798262,
-0.0435626805,
0.5111626983,
-0.0688976347,
0.6153936386,
-0.7504803538,
-0.022205703,
-0.9719359279,
-0.0293472763,
0.1458714604,
-0.4262888134,
-0.4302289784,
0.0227453038,
0.3847042024,
0.0788738802,
-0.2997597754,
0.3477455676,
-0.6256425977,
-0.0272076391,
-0.5516909957,
-0.1503092945,
-0.3016377091,
0.3242345452,
-0.1823047549,
0.7270780206,
0.2439155728,
-0.7945449352,
0.2292612642,
-0.2397633046,
-0.4616618156,
0.2628676295,
-0.4690075219,
-0.0965962037,
0.077985853,
0.0410954021,
-0.4990934432,
-0.1090728641,
-0.4646430016,
-0.0508642122,
0.605244875,
-0.4153816104,
-0.6948674917,
-0.2725754678,
0.0290410761,
0.6617690921,
0.5900695324,
-0.5347992778,
0.6327287555,
0.5569619536,
0.0387104154,
-0.2487893403,
-0.5276194215,
-0.3383658528,
-0.2316639274,
-0.1939933449,
0.2549376488,
-0.2300598472,
-0.1109148562,
-0.3478604257,
-0.118034482,
-0.1083823368,
0.2928713262,
0.3560737371,
0.1061058864,
-0.1769297719,
0.0267563984,
0.0873381346,
-0.092282407,
0.119228214,
-0.238337189,
0.7646823525,
-0.2518807352,
-0.1516191363,
-0.3822290897,
-0.2987235487,
0.8016011715,
-0.4023777843,
0.3224688172,
0.332058996,
-0.1214247271,
-0.2912688851,
-0.5491856933,
-0.1946439147,
-0.5491611958,
0.6445301175,
-0.2061054707,
-0.9919372797,
0.4607560039,
-0.3687684238,
0.2269831002,
0.3136657178,
0.407749325,
0.2038305551,
1.0684050322,
0.8022654653,
-0.1530117244,
0.8818694949,
-0.2474844307,
0.0507609323,
-0.8890193105,
-0.0180301778,
-0.5567738414,
-0.3882749081,
-0.974100709,
-0.1717699915,
0.2667772472,
-0.0583729297,
-0.6284142733,
0.2901641726,
-0.3779233098,
0.8101276755,
0.443439424,
0.1374040395,
0.2163324654,
-0.1446132958,
0.1231435463,
-0.1149750873,
-0.4187675416,
-0.2059179693,
1.2410669327,
0.27042678,
0.7528167963,
-0.1208411157,
0.6806079745,
0.1241393909,
0.1376880258,
-0.7725692987,
0.6497536898,
-0.4984347224,
-0.5282434225,
-0.4606522024,
-0.8203808069,
-1.3231467009,
0.1922177076,
-0.5158672333,
-0.3794297874,
-0.250592649,
0.3516973555,
-0.6775945425,
0.6220411658,
-0.5797751546,
0.638297081,
-0.0941305459,
-0.2672460377,
-0.6673721075,
-0.3741064668,
0.0853977278,
-0.4615031183,
0.3671191931,
-0.1932579428,
0.1484342366,
0.5017173886,
-0.3963291645,
0.7247324586,
-0.0263513234,
-0.0818093121,
0.1144546345,
0.2345699519,
0.5350034237,
-0.0804444626,
0.0384890214,
-0.0055288826,
-0.0654992014,
-0.3874471486,
-0.3317859471,
0.7186558247,
-0.7400339842,
-0.6742889285,
0.0526348911,
-0.5304721594,
-0.2902395129,
0.5393378735,
0.5223273039,
0.1608984023,
-0.1142528206,
0.2839227617,
0.8054745197,
-0.0643208474,
0.395766288,
0.7857852578,
-0.4488159716,
-0.1778776348,
1.0424970388,
0.4209939539,
0.4366133213,
0.2773455381,
0.2880034745,
-0.0701642036,
-0.889018476,
0.0518138371,
0.3829850554,
-0.1924864352,
-0.1598985791,
-0.2392947972,
-0.3837690949,
-0.3004365861,
-0.2378282994,
-0.7238690257,
-0.1381964386,
-0.6146376133,
-0.1665970236,
0.1557570547,
0.6195762753,
-0.1943024844,
0.2082213759,
-0.6152226329,
0.2194786668,
0.4012934268,
0.4587192833,
0.0115291076,
-0.8677304983,
-0.2521356344,
0.0069931466,
-0.3466226757,
-0.2532027066,
0.4741863906,
0.2932596803,
0.4585975409,
0.3499935567,
0.1336492002,
0.6579005718,
-0.7599456906,
0.3230104744,
0.2970763147,
-0.7326042652,
0.6627670527,
-0.103588894,
0.4967873991,
0.5325118303,
-0.004644101,
-0.2108399272,
-0.4114851356,
-0.5668211579,
-0.93310076,
0.4591563344,
-0.0923364684,
0.3670955896,
0.1898746341,
0.7026206851,
0.1849182248,
0.2738388181,
-0.6964105368,
-0.2247341424,
0.0864808634,
-0.0375677086,
-0.3873976171,
-0.2951353192,
0.1864679307,
-0.3194769323,
0.5946580768,
-0.0109388102,
-0.3450874686,
-0.0877319649,
-0.1079927757,
-0.5174060464,
0.2218030244,
0.6057967544,
0.5612307787,
-0.3527586758,
0.0446912646,
0.3015369177,
-0.7646344304,
-0.0371757708,
0.1681545824,
-0.2684005499,
-0.4106439948,
0.2467822731,
0.9330779314,
0.3804594278,
-0.5690675974,
0.202044487,
-0.1472894102,
-0.3930386007,
-0.3346961141,
0.2545205951,
-0.1324336231,
0.5498087406,
0.2745705545,
-0.0946410224,
-0.1122627631,
-0.2918173075,
0.0123287812,
0.6288186908,
-0.3292548358,
-0.2458787411,
0.6930746436,
0.4331989288,
-0.3098298907,
0.7075968385,
-0.1704086065,
-0.2168643624,
0.6122501493,
0.2532359064,
0.7874394655,
-0.1095621809,
0.0572180972,
0.5338808298,
0.5494609475,
-0.5235421658,
0.0594217144,
0.0521129556,
-0.6932762861,
-0.5093126893,
-0.7333370447,
-0.1628262252,
0.4728443623,
-0.7931446433,
0.2217432708,
-0.9500709772,
-0.4001001418,
-0.1272915751,
0.5394560099,
-0.6037164927,
0.2361647487,
0.2187868059,
0.877327323,
-0.6811925769,
0.9289819598,
0.2522192299,
-0.2043330818,
-0.8567417264,
0.0215641689,
0.0055246507,
-0.8408562541,
0.4890912771,
-0.0683809295,
-0.2024191171,
0.2871932685,
-0.6281968951,
-0.8967455626,
1.1496300697,
0.8572325706,
-0.8544911742,
0.1057247967,
-0.1166718006,
0.4631743133,
-0.3357761502,
0.0271446723,
0.7555856109,
0.3058359921,
0.1002002135,
-1.455722332,
-0.0224747118,
0.283708185,
-0.1763052344,
0.7189765573,
-0.6291920543,
1.1021316051,
-0.6002845764,
-0.1681059897,
0.0305826515,
0.747384131,
0.1036391035,
0.1956448853,
0.6585243344,
0.5318702459,
0.9580200315,
0.2366406322,
0.8545401692,
-0.3254676759,
0.6374447346,
1.2412437201,
-0.1963575929,
0.987830162,
0.4447161853,
-0.2848110199,
0.2355636358,
0.7643044591,
-0.0437828787,
0.6204799414,
0.3200139403,
-0.1515967697,
-0.6503386497,
0.0236740299,
-0.2609155774,
0.2926442325,
0.1072970852,
-0.4631402493,
-0.1719217598,
-0.1826848388,
-0.0339621753,
0.0125138722,
-0.9180964828,
0.7883715034,
0.1910095215,
-0.5274336338,
0.7718023658,
-0.2501525879,
0.5816372633,
-0.5456123948,
0.320468843,
-0.1479290426,
0.1701643169,
-0.1879014224,
-0.7660592794,
-0.0031217139,
-0.1330754757,
-0.3783037961,
-0.3188249767,
0.381023109,
-0.4377211332,
-0.3813442886,
0.2233200073,
0.2062664479,
0.0613105483,
-0.1526039392,
-0.4527603984,
-0.1077610552,
0.2659468651,
-0.1302845776,
0.6105881333,
0.5162159801,
0.2398048788,
0.9416955709,
0.5769030452,
0.5853958726,
-0.1673005074,
-0.04296894,
0.6460247636,
-0.5353877544,
-0.4671869874,
-0.9168944955,
0.0686490908,
0.1061692163,
-0.3087856174,
0.2026278824,
0.4228008986,
0.933681488,
0.1653587967,
0.6201863885,
0.2747061849,
0.4743641317,
-0.726007998,
0.8459750414,
-0.8875132203,
0.3024518192,
0.1258538514,
-0.8134583831,
-0.1442686319,
0.4699514806,
-0.3829388916,
0.0876385942,
0.5080834031,
0.8187277913,
-0.1918673515,
-0.0455306284,
0.6025572419,
0.4452858269,
0.0993526801,
0.4814723432,
0.3037222624,
0.0911062285,
0.6945500374,
-0.0277116243,
-0.3096287847,
-0.4063900113,
-1.006682992,
-0.7383609414,
-0.7215988636,
-0.2493524998,
-0.3081957102,
-0.4476800859,
1.0774428844,
0.8183082342,
-0.6255216599,
-0.3328807354,
-0.200011,
0.0695742965,
-0.0432643667,
-0.0579300858,
-0.1266650259,
-0.5401523709,
-0.5859912038,
0.0622947849,
0.0290164631,
0.1591578126,
-0.2900301218,
-0.1760543883,
0.1930821687,
0.131004557,
0.5171597004,
0.5735082626,
-0.5436347127,
-0.0929161087,
-0.4974269569,
-0.1329770833,
-0.0064277211,
1.1805489063,
-0.3791448176,
0.4307219982,
0.203993246,
0.6504173279,
0.6667795777,
-0.5020283461,
0.6099944711,
-0.7213076353,
0.0671420544,
0.1887489408,
0.5264252424,
0.1828892231,
-0.2858822644,
0.3084926903,
-0.093919158,
-0.9615222812,
-0.8582898378,
0.5791548491,
-0.6999447346,
-0.551002264,
1.2795428038,
0.1313293576,
-0.1440405548,
0.0704660192,
-0.2931589186,
0.3184203506,
-0.2679049969,
0.8850201368,
0.6767005324,
0.0256344341,
-0.3180661798,
-0.681914866,
0.7802785039,
0.5820756555,
-0.4463710785,
0.5998443365,
0.5043203235,
0.3827242851,
0.0576754846,
0.4328217804,
0.2728336155,
0.0036084736,
-0.42264691,
-0.0515268594,
-0.0232149214,
-0.0916867256,
-0.418543458,
0.1567911506,
0.4935550392,
0.0240596905
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02309v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02309v1
|
Jailbreaking Attack against Multimodal Large Language Model
| 2024-02-04T01:29:24 | 2024-02-04T01:29:24 |
Zhenxing Niu, Haodong Ren, Xinbo Gao, Gang Hua, Rong Jin
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.CV
|
This paper focuses on jailbreaking attacks against multi-modal large language
models (MLLMs), seeking to elicit MLLMs to generate objectionable responses to
harmful user queries. A maximum likelihood-based algorithm is proposed to find
an \emph{image Jailbreaking Prompt} (imgJP), enabling jailbreaks against MLLMs
across multiple unseen prompts and images (i.e., data-universal property). Our
approach exhibits strong model-transferability, as the generated imgJP can be
transferred to jailbreak various models, including MiniGPT-v2, LLaVA,
InstructBLIP, and mPLUG-Owl2, in a black-box manner. Moreover, we reveal a
connection between MLLM-jailbreaks and LLM-jailbreaks. As a result, we
introduce a construction-based method to harness our approach for
LLM-jailbreaks, demonstrating greater efficiency than current state-of-the-art
methods. The code is available here. \textbf{Warning: some content generated by
language models may be offensive to some readers.}
|
[
-0.3332414627,
-1.2613739967,
0.4308439195,
0.3155491352,
-0.2355145067,
-0.0107536297,
-0.1605586112,
-0.6184607148,
0.0445426963,
0.7789688706,
-0.4670479,
-0.3745758235,
-0.5750832558,
0.0579970628,
-0.3437295854,
0.7534350157,
0.2239408642,
-0.0889162421,
0.0639035925,
-0.1549362391,
-0.6026985049,
-0.7350511551,
-0.4690533876,
0.2123069316,
0.5858303905,
0.1231652498,
0.7229148746,
0.3071261048,
0.3821998239,
0.2789547443,
-0.1314833313,
0.0893072188,
-0.3645305634,
0.4732182324,
-0.047784552,
-0.3323607147,
-0.2416227609,
-0.2247813791,
0.3341862559,
0.0181590375,
0.019668391,
-0.0289959237,
-0.0475646146,
0.5817525983,
-0.8637887836,
-0.0960516185,
-1.0908337831,
0.117006503,
-0.4235795736,
-0.1368975639,
-0.9496986866,
0.073920548,
-0.3914690912,
-0.1630719602,
-0.1662647277,
0.4664721489,
0.5928426981,
0.040265318,
-0.534070015,
-0.3758253157,
-0.3559570909,
0.6116687059,
-0.8762586117,
0.1783974916,
0.3996522725,
0.3082985878,
-0.4789965153,
-0.339897722,
-0.5081145167,
-0.7446190119,
0.06801714,
-0.2701418102,
-0.4499766827,
0.2033777684,
0.5527058244,
-0.0276719667,
-0.6742400527,
0.2621769309,
-0.3317201734,
-0.2155746222,
0.4975340068,
0.182075277,
0.5111311078,
-0.4676188827,
-0.5453834534,
0.1622120142,
-1.0365781784,
-0.0584509224,
0.4839989841,
0.3194378614,
-0.2423561364,
0.8273755312,
0.1463400871,
0.9529987574,
-0.137664482,
-0.3003802896,
0.0427024998,
-0.2506508827,
-0.1411065906,
-0.1524327397,
0.9919171333,
0.4341168106,
0.3093744218,
-0.1478140652,
-0.2214216739,
-0.3802642226,
0.0754264295,
-0.9711435437,
-0.0358766541,
0.3383538425,
-0.5836961269,
-0.5276080966,
-0.0032594716,
-0.953173995,
-0.8479030132,
0.2599059343,
0.3154355586,
-0.4661646485,
-0.112098366,
-0.1105046123,
0.0273803659,
0.2800547779,
0.2106357366,
-0.997341156,
-0.1187857017,
0.5139657259,
0.8523108363,
0.1809211075,
-0.250447005,
-0.5750967264,
0.3566538393,
0.1563245803,
0.6002433896,
-0.5739343762,
-0.4335709214,
0.0444190353,
0.0476246439,
-0.1028348655,
-0.5303111076,
0.464947015,
-0.7211455703,
-0.0380232185,
0.102721706,
-0.5084182024,
-0.1327881068,
0.4895296991,
-0.8658919334,
0.4707899094,
-0.2965665758,
-0.8864058852,
0.0262713041,
-0.8391526341,
-0.3521437943,
-0.37170735,
-0.0021918155,
-0.4425959885,
0.1026288942,
0.471041441,
0.5522305369,
-0.1472872347,
0.2050298005,
-0.8172632456,
-0.0063869674,
0.5187548399,
-0.755556047,
1.1032217741,
0.6291803122,
-0.2296924293,
0.1935456544,
-0.6629030704,
-0.2713216245,
0.5938466787,
-0.1609555334,
-0.5919671655,
0.0401850343,
0.3401764929,
0.3160344064,
0.3539237678,
-0.7458096743,
0.6644070148,
-0.1760155559,
0.46005252,
0.8497838974,
0.0151827866,
0.0436674654,
0.0102389883,
0.504945457,
-0.1160558462,
0.4680019617,
-0.5244041085,
-0.5352799892,
-0.0913773403,
-0.3446106315,
0.1851856411,
0.7715229988,
-0.6084339619,
0.1237540171,
0.3235710859,
-0.4842554629,
-0.39184165,
0.3175470531,
0.465878576,
0.2434674501,
0.3261105716,
-0.0253538843,
-0.4876020253,
-0.8593971729,
-0.4598155916,
-0.1123944521,
0.1535407305,
0.2936296463,
0.5002159476,
-0.2762513161,
0.4768107235,
-0.3807525039,
-0.109277457,
-0.2510978878,
-0.1043289527,
0.2482060194,
0.6232773662,
1.0538291931,
-0.7349729538,
-0.4005462229,
-0.326092422,
-0.9542456269,
-0.1381456107,
-0.2531819046,
0.0951670781,
0.2195614278,
0.6627177,
-0.825391531,
0.3741291463,
0.6975318193,
-0.8876417279,
0.9275271893,
-0.1132222861,
0.2247678488,
-1.1644262075,
-0.1484777331,
0.0877991393,
-0.2634808123,
-0.5403862596,
0.6547551155,
0.0895650759,
-0.2665355802,
-0.6180132627,
0.620650053,
-0.4765323997,
0.0182114877,
-0.2743495107,
-0.1868597865,
-0.1685962975,
0.3525759578,
-0.3762728572,
0.6689513326,
0.4898130298,
-0.0032845945,
0.6126913428,
0.099019289,
-0.2352806628,
0.3667702079,
-0.5727238655,
0.2203742117,
-0.0599361323,
0.1103090048,
-0.8913368583,
-0.1630591005,
0.4232527316,
-0.4165543318,
0.4460043907,
-0.6231065392,
-0.779455483,
-0.1462904811,
-0.3926754296,
0.260233134,
0.1804982126,
-0.6933202744,
0.5164259076,
0.2426787466,
-0.2183255851,
-0.6852051616,
-0.4923194647,
0.5627142191,
-0.4088203609,
-0.8354247808,
0.013660402,
-0.2046087235,
-0.4664979875,
-0.1899124086,
0.3453040719,
-0.0706679001,
0.3497366011,
0.3037080169,
0.4577810466,
-0.1335881203,
-0.1888752133,
0.0307058655,
0.0634536445,
0.1713302433,
-0.0548808463,
0.7295361757,
-0.2345156521,
-0.6220723391,
-0.296667397,
0.4864505529,
1.0244222879,
-0.3389719129,
1.0124249458,
0.4215225875,
-0.1661632806,
0.0321889147,
-0.5247618556,
-0.264737457,
-0.4796254933,
0.4632894397,
-0.522918582,
-1.0519208908,
0.5565260649,
0.0430767089,
0.2366474271,
0.0401645489,
0.6152203083,
-0.0981871858,
1.3426127434,
0.5315235257,
-0.3679171503,
0.6032108068,
0.1211593598,
0.0759283081,
-0.6581118107,
-0.1903460473,
-0.4086897075,
-0.0717969835,
-0.5567987561,
-0.1911427826,
0.1341526359,
0.2310320288,
-0.1013054699,
0.3603816926,
-0.2332604378,
0.5270841122,
0.2691892982,
0.134122178,
0.3667469323,
0.0322882682,
-0.30749318,
-0.0030118173,
-0.4691081941,
-0.3342556059,
1.3790429831,
0.4159971774,
1.1003443003,
0.4649420381,
0.4647019207,
0.5203458667,
0.2859581709,
-0.6935387254,
0.4597878754,
-0.0046189358,
-0.8775478005,
-0.1189358011,
-0.3055025339,
-0.8593927622,
0.7254434228,
-0.403567344,
-1.0703837872,
-0.1528572887,
0.2795674801,
-0.0718248859,
0.7912466526,
-0.7746175528,
0.9973922968,
-0.4242980778,
-0.4069133401,
-0.3081587255,
-0.7041014433,
0.8417035341,
-0.194863975,
0.5700451732,
-0.1905012876,
0.2733100355,
0.3307744861,
-0.5738227367,
0.8455830216,
-0.5621612072,
-0.1204046682,
0.1286000907,
0.3874457181,
0.7342236638,
0.2131241262,
0.0565323345,
-0.0590717532,
-0.0963119268,
-0.518625021,
-0.6492664218,
0.6377721429,
-0.4741511345,
-0.7571387291,
-0.1157502756,
-0.7111883759,
-0.0013775236,
-0.0174901057,
0.1786703169,
0.4416688383,
-0.0074251005,
0.1084031165,
0.5181709528,
-0.3347457945,
0.5196198225,
0.4375880063,
-0.635381937,
-0.3483789265,
0.7227905989,
-0.1971386075,
0.3498073816,
0.2090195566,
0.0958312601,
-0.192563042,
-0.8293029666,
-0.6442599893,
0.0292933974,
-0.6466567516,
-0.1872394383,
-0.5017355084,
-0.1397981495,
-0.3238686919,
-0.125729084,
-0.3107512593,
-0.4378145635,
0.0252560265,
0.0633610711,
0.4697235525,
0.4156261683,
-0.044705119,
0.2937829196,
-1.1269253492,
0.3883674443,
0.3152966797,
-0.1072672233,
0.0346603096,
-0.6804634333,
0.0245533977,
-0.1225500181,
-0.2770632505,
-1.2808020115,
0.3253057003,
-0.0423080064,
0.4608850181,
0.6612039208,
0.1492973864,
0.4004344344,
-0.5913953781,
0.5824139714,
0.4266445637,
-0.8247162104,
0.7117139697,
-0.5119974017,
0.1044653952,
0.4402736723,
0.0355689973,
-0.4781395495,
-0.7500899434,
-0.4367896318,
-0.9288995862,
0.2770332992,
0.1004938185,
0.502696991,
0.1109767109,
0.1793864965,
-0.0148168504,
0.2035203278,
-1.3227558136,
-0.4091203809,
-0.040479295,
0.0074872454,
0.4471015036,
-0.5640289187,
-0.2111387998,
-0.2936629951,
0.5507215858,
-0.0041419757,
0.1153264865,
-0.1049993336,
-0.5295405388,
0.1687346995,
0.67540133,
0.6626027822,
0.6665996313,
-0.2668400109,
0.1627972126,
0.010237935,
-0.4559706151,
0.2887188792,
0.2208593637,
-0.400962323,
-0.112088263,
0.3868183196,
0.8371301889,
-0.0120902946,
-0.9960482717,
0.6923829913,
-0.1106735319,
0.123228468,
-0.4031636417,
-0.0951834768,
-0.1981749386,
0.4709890783,
0.3187819719,
0.1275978982,
-0.0421406813,
-0.558016479,
0.2183737755,
0.7170193195,
-0.4034253955,
-0.2382585108,
0.7515594363,
-0.0015535575,
-0.0828251392,
0.6787443161,
-0.1076661199,
-0.4340027571,
0.6001579165,
1.0428920984,
0.8091876507,
-0.344281435,
-0.0243066456,
0.1824466437,
0.7608614564,
0.3848155737,
0.2338460982,
0.0929898769,
-0.80435431,
-0.5605226159,
-0.436714232,
-0.2674605548,
0.2596884072,
-0.4197661579,
0.2942436039,
-0.7494601011,
-0.0630911589,
-0.0327096134,
-0.6537373662,
-0.1126830578,
-0.2665427625,
0.4776719213,
0.8858333826,
-0.6553337574,
1.0403962135,
0.6208813787,
-0.2544207573,
-0.4591724575,
-0.1624696702,
0.4308327138,
-0.7695988417,
0.5746275783,
0.336376816,
0.0669224262,
-0.2198610753,
-0.998921454,
-0.647598505,
0.6543673277,
0.53043437,
-0.6142328978,
-0.0173632037,
-0.2346936315,
-0.0741083696,
-0.3388479352,
0.0534680188,
0.4294892251,
0.5951516032,
-0.0912195519,
-0.8555277586,
0.2403103262,
-0.3386943042,
-0.3032154143,
0.3059467375,
-0.4101406932,
0.904016912,
-0.7310821414,
0.0641439557,
0.3056651652,
0.4710503519,
0.770149827,
0.2424123734,
0.6226353049,
0.7129459381,
0.4876221716,
0.1044581681,
1.056007266,
-0.302639097,
0.4195878506,
1.1381198168,
-0.0788827688,
0.8074503541,
0.7910233736,
-0.0833634362,
0.4089364409,
0.3187126219,
-0.5216460824,
0.5555633903,
0.3392188847,
-0.3986139894,
-0.1805044115,
0.1094385907,
-0.3929438293,
0.65849787,
0.5038161874,
-0.5731913447,
-0.2755124867,
0.5171113014,
0.6353877187,
-0.0076210978,
-0.3884731531,
0.5847655535,
0.1082941592,
-0.1914873272,
0.650467813,
0.4908861518,
0.8658947349,
-0.6725869775,
0.0283127278,
0.1419742554,
-0.1107657552,
-0.181692645,
-0.6594578028,
0.1722969264,
0.3359734714,
-0.0827412531,
-0.0007747443,
0.9876467586,
-0.2191040218,
-0.3047867715,
0.5552840829,
0.5198760629,
0.0197632797,
-0.264012605,
-0.9714599848,
0.0717950389,
0.2058942318,
-0.5434039831,
0.6001389623,
-0.006676984,
0.0437332168,
0.7072585225,
0.9460516572,
-0.1257286817,
0.2985402942,
0.0716021881,
0.900567472,
-0.8311511278,
-0.3075448871,
-1.395673275,
0.5343085527,
-0.1465232223,
0.0746991485,
0.8103292584,
0.5031959414,
0.6281216145,
-0.1220232695,
0.9333214164,
-0.4259041846,
0.0218971074,
-0.9797976017,
0.8805330396,
-0.4308404922,
0.5233689547,
-0.4680645168,
-0.8639743328,
-0.3600828052,
0.282723695,
-0.3153090477,
-0.2213343978,
0.5090131164,
0.9655432701,
-0.019021159,
-0.0693838447,
0.5046513677,
0.4037278295,
0.5120498538,
0.6043524742,
1.2234367132,
-0.1010923609,
0.6363423467,
-0.1267923564,
-0.1696338952,
-0.2181887478,
-0.816971302,
-1.0418237448,
-0.3268917203,
0.0681539625,
-0.615960896,
0.1403507888,
1.0180230141,
0.5465915203,
-0.8243723512,
-0.2330467403,
0.2998947501,
0.3187350929,
0.1149982288,
-0.2353340685,
0.1876092255,
-0.2537694275,
-0.4668010473,
0.5917479992,
0.3339664936,
0.1346820295,
-0.2746641338,
0.0882612839,
-0.2478339821,
-0.0708515048,
0.8655640483,
0.4391900897,
-0.8840315938,
-0.2196364403,
-0.2530362308,
-0.0809435993,
0.0919872969,
0.8529803753,
-0.440348953,
0.5200933218,
0.2071799934,
0.5474142432,
0.3714292049,
-0.1800425649,
0.3564043045,
-0.8293199539,
0.6957195997,
0.0478146486,
0.7576708198,
0.1837862283,
-0.3989454806,
0.1930621117,
0.3595220745,
-0.32611233,
-0.8211218715,
0.5528780818,
-0.8912369609,
-0.7380732298,
1.0612381697,
-0.2208976895,
-0.2276588976,
-0.2188377231,
-0.375736773,
-0.340128988,
-0.4923458993,
0.7051393986,
0.5086368918,
-0.1361206472,
-0.4758434892,
-0.923199296,
0.2030008733,
0.0923485979,
-0.9298901558,
0.2314682454,
0.7325335145,
0.2351274788,
0.0881351605,
0.2977536917,
-0.5356166959,
0.223912552,
-0.0906421766,
0.1866367161,
-0.3939814568,
-0.3032025695,
-0.43377918,
0.6178984642,
0.265902698,
0.0475787036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05121v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05121v1
|
Large Language Model for Table Processing: A Survey
| 2024-02-04T00:47:53 | 2024-02-04T00:47:53 |
Weizheng Lu, Jiaming Zhang, Jing Zhang, Yueguo Chen
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Tables, typically two-dimensional and structured to store large amounts of
data, are essential in daily activities like database queries, spreadsheet
calculations, and generating reports from web tables. Automating these
table-centric tasks with Large Language Models (LLMs) offers significant public
benefits, garnering interest from academia and industry. This survey provides
an extensive overview of table tasks, encompassing not only the traditional
areas like table question answering (Table QA) and fact verification, but also
newly emphasized aspects such as table manipulation and advanced table data
analysis. Additionally, it goes beyond the early strategies of pre-training and
fine-tuning small language models, to include recent paradigms in LLM usage.
The focus here is particularly on instruction-tuning, prompting, and
agent-based approaches within the realm of LLMs. Finally, we highlight several
challenges, ranging from private deployment and efficient inference to the
development of extensive benchmarks for table manipulation and advanced data
analysis.
|
[
-0.2912932932,
-1.1913598776,
0.6971228123,
0.0594964921,
0.1420083493,
-0.1082932651,
-0.2841885984,
-0.6507184505,
-0.0542815328,
0.7247440219,
-0.4004282653,
-0.6539882421,
-0.4922234118,
-0.0846193209,
-0.6833176613,
0.7315121293,
-0.0962717086,
0.036356397,
-0.3392454088,
0.1516187042,
-0.4516871572,
-0.6149146557,
-0.6892454028,
-0.2616741061,
0.6468545794,
0.7421552539,
0.6837671399,
0.9733934402,
0.5090239644,
0.2712095082,
0.0993174762,
0.0534296818,
-0.3839648366,
0.3572635055,
-0.0908724442,
-0.5917167664,
-0.7500607371,
0.0882607028,
0.6810511351,
0.9685685039,
-0.2372707129,
0.3389210999,
-0.1725806892,
0.9255372286,
-0.3113716245,
0.7211315632,
-0.5547412038,
0.136493206,
-0.4899292588,
0.1713929474,
-0.5188506842,
-0.5586177111,
-0.039883554,
-0.1836313009,
0.0325022005,
0.145694986,
0.2585534751,
0.097672008,
-0.5425879359,
-0.2931315303,
-1.0545098782,
0.5847377777,
-0.4975828826,
0.7054686546,
0.4856271744,
0.3799599111,
-0.4034378529,
-0.8332333565,
-0.5815648437,
-0.4126493633,
-0.1192067266,
-0.3390893936,
-0.1562655121,
0.0559293404,
0.550495863,
0.2372524142,
-0.682872057,
0.4588653445,
-0.1914464682,
0.0920712352,
0.684015274,
0.5502502918,
0.3507331908,
0.2995534539,
0.1365101337,
-0.1618204415,
-0.8934926987,
-0.0271768868,
0.0994732678,
0.1538808197,
0.0340496302,
0.7276040912,
-0.3965756297,
1.0209453106,
-0.4833467603,
0.192905724,
-0.2784814239,
-0.2603770792,
-0.1339247972,
-0.2857858837,
0.5614418387,
0.1769349575,
0.1470586061,
-0.2049094886,
-0.352080673,
0.0022511147,
0.0629965141,
-0.542542398,
-0.1843039542,
0.2136317939,
-0.3156552017,
0.0419113003,
-0.2387178689,
-1.0736145973,
-0.6320706606,
-0.5356078148,
0.2350680381,
0.1705261171,
-0.019071253,
-0.0926083103,
0.3174825907,
0.5157300234,
0.4949303865,
-0.9948493242,
0.5759076476,
0.8788179755,
0.7605527639,
-0.537494421,
-0.1428201795,
-0.4661717117,
0.2587811351,
-0.4613377452,
0.8917400241,
-0.5491276979,
-0.3509668112,
0.2071865052,
0.0239341818,
0.0295695513,
-0.5414979458,
0.3125971854,
-0.6799783707,
0.0223814547,
-0.4689429998,
-0.509816587,
-0.0787242055,
0.4582617581,
-0.9372358322,
0.8860470653,
0.1348032206,
-0.3237903118,
0.1903084666,
-0.829718709,
-0.6162052155,
-0.122954756,
-0.1761482954,
-0.366396457,
0.0537848882,
0.0635567084,
0.5629696846,
-0.7170855999,
0.1507419497,
-0.0430829301,
-0.1477357,
0.4185053408,
-0.2331053317,
0.3674075007,
0.1909404546,
-0.1189367175,
0.3659982681,
-0.6956265569,
-0.0213291962,
0.1601531804,
-0.4446848631,
0.1536222249,
0.2848185301,
0.1109209135,
0.2583018243,
0.319221139,
-0.3433128893,
0.4754951298,
-0.2015848458,
0.5416063666,
0.3117220998,
-0.1702337414,
0.503130734,
-0.192396611,
0.5195266604,
-0.090792954,
0.1963279545,
0.0682517216,
-0.2716373205,
-0.7318719029,
0.0975656658,
0.3349458575,
0.6656836867,
-0.6796221733,
0.0547755957,
-0.0718603432,
-0.6226997972,
-0.0735105872,
0.1035573632,
0.1452940851,
0.3853364289,
0.2717968524,
-0.0583114959,
-0.5788674355,
-0.9721878171,
-0.1501670778,
-0.0316620395,
0.0922767669,
0.1494002789,
0.3549686968,
-0.154929325,
0.8562443852,
-0.6396580935,
-0.2607343197,
-0.6186435819,
0.0800129622,
0.1773820221,
0.3885772824,
0.2253700942,
-0.5350250602,
-0.6927927136,
0.0370516665,
-0.6858517528,
-0.1653328091,
0.2318417281,
0.0186920036,
0.527148664,
0.7405115962,
-0.8918545246,
0.2666428983,
0.3957900405,
-0.0973929986,
0.3779144883,
-0.220244959,
-0.0653697252,
-0.5854465365,
0.1155276075,
-0.0594852865,
-0.3708093762,
-0.8450290561,
0.1968987435,
0.0297824647,
-0.2981486022,
-0.3029774129,
0.5715306401,
-0.8141229153,
-0.4946492612,
-0.3841806352,
0.0377811231,
-0.3454892933,
0.3380427659,
0.2065801173,
0.786367178,
0.3766143918,
-0.5760886073,
0.518048048,
0.1505579203,
-0.4591802955,
0.2888991237,
-0.6930861473,
0.3433914185,
-0.1514067203,
0.1579636335,
-1.0082625151,
-0.3447534144,
0.1892606467,
-0.0096885469,
0.4837158322,
0.0115330825,
-0.6749367118,
-0.4890492857,
-0.1863073111,
0.0512185022,
0.5470459461,
-0.2309159786,
0.5386086702,
0.8469944,
-0.3137879968,
-0.4670333266,
-0.6283419728,
0.2185730189,
-0.0551615842,
-0.3755646348,
0.0112274829,
0.0783489868,
-0.4890034497,
-0.1254541129,
-0.0421685912,
-0.1348731071,
0.077256605,
0.176663205,
0.1227648854,
-0.1281916797,
0.0878226832,
-0.1914789379,
-0.0499244146,
0.3214150667,
-0.0294855814,
0.8647738695,
-0.0250509288,
-0.2205619812,
-0.4709812403,
0.3474961817,
0.5287713408,
-0.2797912657,
0.7320342064,
0.3227387667,
-0.431440264,
-0.2203265131,
-0.6884896159,
-0.1827143133,
-0.4080777466,
0.6096894145,
-0.2067214847,
-0.8854138851,
0.6737467051,
0.0785090774,
0.3535265028,
0.326977551,
0.7658507228,
-0.0128744701,
1.1063166857,
0.5574709177,
-0.1665972322,
0.416603744,
-0.1497441381,
0.1272072792,
-0.4564560354,
-0.2149363756,
-0.9710192084,
-0.3376533687,
-0.5013743043,
-0.5507073998,
0.378919363,
-0.4308623672,
-0.2204563916,
0.1817820817,
-0.3187678754,
0.5838491321,
0.472767055,
-0.180738315,
0.463637203,
-0.0341256,
0.5011808276,
0.2545773387,
-0.5440141559,
-0.5894650221,
0.9198186994,
0.466419518,
0.9273720384,
0.0273414403,
0.3739013672,
0.3369244337,
0.4287407994,
-0.8777881861,
0.8282772899,
-0.1543448716,
-0.6483339667,
-0.7710679173,
-0.4241447151,
-1.0904244184,
0.1533689052,
-0.1031724811,
-0.7741585374,
-0.1151241362,
0.3139688671,
-0.0608658753,
0.1594958454,
-0.6336299777,
0.9887838364,
-0.1784158498,
-0.4280346632,
-0.3567858338,
-0.5001987219,
0.372911185,
-0.0578624941,
0.294876039,
-0.0922463983,
-0.0631798804,
0.7760366201,
-0.3227359056,
0.7573009729,
-0.3296224475,
-0.2793274522,
0.3620405197,
0.3168795705,
0.7386941314,
0.0270693284,
-0.2057427764,
-0.0268935859,
0.2013758123,
-0.1348094046,
-0.5239623785,
0.6368271708,
-0.6383293867,
-0.8028286099,
-0.4389457703,
-0.7964841723,
-0.4751489758,
0.0337952971,
-0.2036185563,
0.164711982,
-0.2659659088,
0.2179445475,
0.6582195759,
-0.1561881155,
0.5135203004,
0.8303776979,
-0.3908808827,
0.0112809148,
0.6951144338,
0.3904719651,
-0.0371277668,
0.5489617586,
0.0070672822,
-0.4939877093,
-0.834599793,
-0.4580884874,
0.0768244639,
-0.4714601636,
-0.1683882028,
-0.7568416595,
-0.2252977937,
-0.1908493787,
0.170584783,
-0.3561622798,
-0.5013995171,
-0.1407508254,
-0.1419021785,
0.3675487936,
1.0181481838,
0.1312138885,
0.437892288,
-0.8134137988,
0.2426914424,
0.6145057678,
0.5207915902,
0.2225953937,
-0.2078874856,
-0.3551594317,
-0.1232799664,
-0.0240194257,
-0.9273059368,
0.335057795,
0.0440924391,
0.6193394065,
-0.0762256011,
-0.2556838393,
0.2620255649,
-0.5824393034,
0.7700296044,
-0.2035988569,
-0.812295258,
0.2954892516,
-0.3431164622,
0.2201204449,
0.4538092315,
0.3689489663,
-0.7734319568,
-0.0816852078,
0.0076492745,
-0.8040718436,
0.9025762677,
-0.2287572771,
0.1080129594,
0.0861069113,
0.4089867175,
0.1323493272,
0.3231750727,
-0.7721385956,
-0.0648801476,
0.3596965373,
-0.1347505003,
-0.0870834291,
-0.4531174004,
0.0109284669,
-0.193419084,
0.5439795256,
0.0451305583,
0.1605869085,
-0.2438554913,
-0.3652406037,
-0.3016959131,
0.4917231202,
0.5780078769,
0.9022085071,
0.0321346112,
0.1282462478,
0.2844463587,
-0.4623722732,
0.1656449735,
0.1048474014,
-0.1032701135,
-0.3152139485,
0.0857889876,
0.5608201623,
-0.0961250067,
-0.7092766762,
0.1654812098,
-0.172840789,
-0.0111055756,
-0.3244310021,
0.1391795576,
0.1822005361,
0.1514873207,
0.2457820028,
-0.7939864993,
0.2202798724,
-0.7998782992,
0.0284748096,
0.5863406658,
-0.3014550209,
-0.2663930357,
0.6391507983,
-0.0460708626,
-0.3437901437,
0.8624765277,
-0.0723856613,
-0.1175264716,
0.640779078,
0.5165894032,
0.5116752982,
-0.3231617808,
0.2030026764,
0.0904804468,
0.3805193603,
-0.3527103961,
0.6358093023,
0.1419593692,
-0.5029299855,
-0.5353358388,
-0.6393604279,
-0.7224664688,
0.3279492557,
-0.4078069031,
0.087618649,
-0.3796121776,
-0.0191900954,
0.1550857276,
-0.0190903023,
-0.7049945593,
0.0535084493,
0.0966585279,
0.8565146327,
-0.7764602304,
1.0057951212,
0.7356331944,
-0.2654902339,
-0.6770177484,
-0.531231463,
-0.1033014432,
-0.6472066641,
0.5872716904,
-0.1921569705,
0.2546876073,
-0.0517190732,
-0.6578607559,
-0.8634141088,
0.7481005192,
0.3480871916,
-0.8167615533,
-0.2094033659,
0.7038621902,
0.7422005534,
-0.068630822,
0.218524009,
1.1706932783,
0.6853592992,
-0.242648378,
-0.8874450326,
0.0299955197,
-0.0287768468,
-0.0004981496,
0.3922003508,
-0.5242642164,
0.8588953018,
0.2546239197,
0.073088862,
-0.0969083309,
0.6644782424,
0.0766541809,
0.3178033531,
0.4779369831,
0.3537759185,
0.4019927979,
-0.2176634818,
0.7779758573,
-0.3341147304,
0.0351356566,
1.0889371634,
-0.7453228235,
0.7762024403,
0.2931131721,
-0.432374537,
0.2419817597,
0.4979960024,
-0.0350629203,
-0.0737339705,
0.4238502979,
-0.0242305435,
-0.0394485407,
-0.0742305815,
-0.27715379,
0.7540705204,
0.6789229512,
-0.1263177395,
-0.3515802324,
-0.1137472093,
-0.09558478,
0.0666521341,
-0.5931084752,
0.9427990913,
0.0819736943,
-0.6545255184,
0.0707869381,
0.1020812988,
0.1215172559,
-0.5690274239,
-0.236223802,
-0.2772465348,
-0.1528144777,
-0.1614488065,
-0.9764107466,
0.4923296571,
0.0729190558,
-0.2111490071,
-0.3725593984,
0.7323961258,
-0.5107544661,
-0.1407281309,
-0.0887386054,
0.8361159563,
0.3202787936,
-0.1453978121,
-0.3706820905,
0.2553357482,
-0.3026521802,
-0.4842179716,
0.4729064405,
0.3213804364,
-0.3981398046,
0.6493014693,
0.4535021782,
0.1442371607,
0.0903251618,
0.1935498565,
0.7704203129,
-0.9346132874,
-0.4209391177,
-0.7784280181,
0.203284964,
0.1013030484,
0.2166219205,
0.6659655571,
0.7938918471,
0.5590634942,
-0.3363510072,
0.5372260213,
0.0011055933,
0.645544529,
-0.5935199857,
0.8000622988,
-0.2234632224,
0.132039994,
-0.0357213952,
-1.2185114622,
-0.3071651459,
0.2921193242,
-0.5553460121,
-0.025213372,
0.4627237022,
0.7756921053,
0.1958040744,
0.0910921022,
0.3239132166,
0.3342016041,
0.3303872347,
0.3286263049,
0.9235519767,
0.042181477,
0.374281764,
-0.0916728973,
0.0622605309,
-0.2429783344,
-0.6788058281,
-0.7117547989,
-0.5913918614,
-0.22320427,
-0.0882895663,
-0.034940213,
1.0293408632,
0.5492373109,
-0.9393729568,
-0.6766065359,
-0.1089451537,
0.198847279,
-0.0600991622,
-0.1939238608,
0.4718110561,
-0.3403397202,
-0.8194083571,
0.4331884682,
0.2559840083,
0.1028686464,
-0.4186994433,
0.4256303608,
-0.137074843,
-0.072275348,
0.9294308424,
0.5867581964,
-0.3222882152,
-0.1050134748,
0.0522867404,
-0.256732285,
0.0762606114,
0.9194461703,
-0.5389615297,
0.0869641826,
0.6773589849,
0.6698987484,
0.7004875541,
-0.1083004773,
0.5568001866,
-0.5236471891,
0.07087107,
0.2637017667,
0.2825435698,
0.2215051502,
-0.4043346941,
0.5932160616,
-0.2443697304,
-0.8228783011,
-0.9397771358,
0.2478778809,
-0.9766896963,
-0.1722744256,
0.9828334451,
0.2673197687,
-0.4243934751,
-0.2467746586,
-0.1285119653,
0.4363777339,
-0.2086248845,
0.9111179709,
0.6899716258,
-0.3547285199,
-0.445540607,
-0.774289608,
0.6554064751,
0.1337014586,
-1.3438282013,
0.5104570389,
0.8018511534,
0.0945101082,
-0.1746882349,
0.6093727946,
-0.2595391273,
0.1916582435,
-0.230284512,
0.2949366271,
-0.0915785879,
-0.4461737275,
-0.4220822453,
0.3888308406,
0.5031555891,
0.2381230146
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02302v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02302v1
|
Predicting positive transfer for improved low-resource speech recognition using acoustic pseudo-tokens
| 2024-02-03T23:54:03 | 2024-02-03T23:54:03 |
Nay San, Georgios Paraskevopoulos, Aryaman Arora, Xiluo He, Prabhjot Kaur, Oliver Adams, Dan Jurafsky
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL
|
While massively multilingual speech models like wav2vec 2.0 XLSR-128 can be
directly fine-tuned for automatic speech recognition (ASR), downstream
performance can still be relatively poor on languages that are
under-represented in the pre-training data. Continued pre-training on 70-200
hours of untranscribed speech in these languages can help -- but what about
languages without that much recorded data? For such cases, we show that
supplementing the target language with data from a similar, higher-resource
'donor' language can help. For example, continued pre-training on only 10 hours
of low-resource Punjabi supplemented with 60 hours of donor Hindi is almost as
good as continued pretraining on 70 hours of Punjabi. By contrast, sourcing
data from less similar donors like Bengali does not improve ASR performance. To
inform donor language selection, we propose a novel similarity metric based on
the sequence distribution of induced acoustic units: the Acoustic Token
Distribution Similarity (ATDS). Across a set of typologically different target
languages (Punjabi, Galician, Iban, Setswana), we show that the ATDS between
the target language and its candidate donors precisely predicts target language
ASR performance.
|
[
-0.3686561584,
0.1070683077,
0.0674995556,
-0.0102867922,
-0.5767328739,
0.1816914082,
-0.3768957257,
-0.8041793108,
0.2603749633,
0.1201227233,
-0.3479253352,
0.1416535378,
-0.5663711429,
0.245449841,
-0.505366087,
0.8425360322,
0.1916785538,
0.2526497841,
0.1185510829,
-0.3766048253,
-0.3855814934,
-0.636765182,
-0.9174644947,
-0.3422856331,
0.4824773669,
0.1132752448,
0.365296483,
0.7093439698,
0.5065730214,
0.3034603298,
-0.1594571322,
-0.2305428386,
-0.306738615,
-0.4195643961,
-0.276334554,
-0.4292067289,
-0.1459119767,
-0.075434573,
0.7622273564,
0.6839244962,
-0.1907433569,
0.3499470353,
0.3120397627,
0.2627726495,
-0.4928666055,
0.2253710777,
-0.7583875656,
0.0935028121,
-0.6358729601,
-0.2364609838,
-0.1528929025,
-0.3271594942,
0.2905559242,
-0.5439504981,
0.1233859807,
-0.1012770087,
0.5974043012,
0.242891863,
-0.0833005533,
-0.4343703687,
-0.8611652255,
0.8782458305,
-0.5718433857,
0.6491808891,
0.757983923,
0.2236853838,
0.4447677135,
-0.4664597213,
-0.613265872,
-0.0991033167,
-0.1881633103,
-0.0473590977,
-0.2215170711,
0.0063792812,
0.016440751,
0.3153531253,
-0.3627266884,
0.1668510884,
-0.8719142675,
-0.7981143594,
0.4570099413,
-0.1592611521,
0.0888912752,
-0.2727936804,
-0.3022823632,
-0.30900383,
-0.6544219851,
0.3011760414,
0.2002703696,
0.9594737887,
-0.3569526374,
0.4240921736,
0.2904294431,
0.7343831658,
0.0371454358,
-0.2642922401,
0.5188274384,
-0.8607526422,
0.2378887087,
0.6510711908,
0.6881132722,
-0.1844697595,
0.3568899035,
0.0088154217,
-0.3398257494,
0.1917346567,
-0.1385816783,
-0.6489765048,
-0.1347149462,
-0.3780355155,
-0.718628943,
0.0849767476,
-0.0190071594,
-0.3837455213,
-0.1723580062,
-0.5916171074,
0.544316113,
-0.3943731785,
-0.410135746,
-0.0369896181,
-0.1051977128,
0.2544049621,
-0.0478051454,
-0.8404869437,
0.3096424043,
0.4469753206,
1.0780751705,
-0.1546213925,
-0.238446638,
-0.9867296815,
0.1709705144,
-0.2753811181,
1.007250905,
-0.6462388039,
-0.5895201564,
-0.033132378,
-0.1971349418,
-0.1311730593,
-0.7604913116,
0.5053054094,
-0.2020436376,
0.0609005094,
-0.43132177,
-0.370210439,
0.2008266747,
-0.2371164113,
-0.5883165002,
0.734533608,
0.3266215026,
-0.5700032711,
0.6089565158,
-0.5238979459,
-0.7068151832,
0.0928153023,
-0.1582493782,
-0.2848021984,
0.0364835784,
-0.039424967,
0.1655539274,
-0.2467831969,
-0.1229792461,
-0.2222120315,
-0.5120033622,
0.1624002159,
-0.3840334415,
0.8607994914,
0.5375005007,
-0.1623022556,
-0.0558567755,
-0.8949625492,
-0.0124423597,
-0.3621936738,
-0.4646510184,
-0.3470084965,
-0.2904527783,
0.2561604381,
0.3324626982,
0.0129207708,
-0.8066496849,
-0.2093854696,
-0.5451609492,
0.5297504663,
0.8334345222,
-0.3809438944,
0.44049263,
-0.277862817,
0.6361976862,
0.0727873892,
-0.0373669788,
0.1415320933,
-0.2605878115,
-0.5001548529,
-0.4894123673,
0.5978643894,
0.4423425496,
-0.7070109248,
0.2707972825,
-0.2875161171,
-0.3234425783,
-1.0633563995,
0.1604302526,
0.7678345442,
0.7367429733,
0.4885986745,
-0.6311284304,
-0.8912470341,
-0.8110097647,
-0.0738044009,
-0.7400684357,
-0.1106162146,
0.4630013108,
-0.2123269141,
-0.0239048339,
0.6714094877,
-0.0671350136,
-0.7854880095,
-0.2916230559,
0.08292602,
0.1736232191,
0.4283413589,
0.7092211843,
-0.6148170829,
-0.5306946039,
0.0646901056,
-0.2098189145,
-0.1064601839,
-0.0370689742,
0.1494952589,
0.1511832476,
0.5687921047,
-0.3315748274,
0.2679654062,
0.595512867,
-0.3862739503,
0.4265109301,
-0.0559057221,
0.1249710321,
-0.9887290597,
0.1127481014,
-0.270085305,
-0.0827110931,
-0.4431298673,
-0.6810005903,
-0.1352087259,
-0.253448993,
-0.6521824598,
0.8655280471,
-0.2358761132,
-0.5049496293,
-0.2504259348,
-0.0930218995,
-0.5582655668,
0.1002674624,
0.2134897411,
1.1846234798,
0.7415462732,
-0.5497324467,
0.2965838611,
0.497916311,
-0.4097677469,
0.5840786695,
-0.6560560465,
0.1547495872,
0.2560816109,
0.1856535524,
-0.8792119026,
0.1489143521,
-0.0942675099,
-0.6745340824,
0.4169695377,
-0.2087994218,
-0.1356778741,
-0.3931691051,
-0.0688733906,
0.8295312524,
0.7283133268,
-0.5152397752,
0.4009255171,
0.4400861859,
-0.4730882049,
-0.387665838,
-0.8182883859,
0.0561074689,
-0.4032927155,
-0.1421893239,
0.2647262514,
-0.0033663386,
-0.042045109,
0.1479544193,
0.0252744891,
-0.1449254304,
-0.1456777006,
0.0172723755,
0.2497511059,
-0.4369633794,
0.0637340173,
-0.3089360595,
-0.3601992428,
-0.1869895756,
-0.5261885524,
0.3778220713,
0.0779128298,
-0.3468160331,
-0.837900877,
0.190060094,
0.2007027268,
-0.3462695479,
0.5782391429,
0.8116543889,
-0.3459145427,
0.2213591635,
-0.5164990425,
-0.2641755342,
-0.4691469669,
0.3264259994,
-0.5343463421,
-0.6396306157,
0.5537059307,
0.2905607224,
-0.2353199273,
0.3337583244,
0.4750186801,
-0.0991763547,
0.6060908437,
0.5910200477,
-0.6432715058,
0.8784252405,
-0.1209276468,
0.2151613384,
-0.617539525,
-0.0412079953,
-0.8080862761,
-0.1982508749,
-0.6819776893,
-0.3061798513,
0.1509704292,
-0.1322625428,
0.1063658521,
0.5979038477,
-0.3063892722,
0.3458440304,
0.5905582905,
-0.2279632688,
-0.0233055502,
0.2120366544,
0.1792935133,
-0.0967651308,
-0.6360577345,
-0.048188217,
1.1215679646,
-0.0393462516,
0.3984489143,
-0.0194420349,
0.8368096352,
0.5012171865,
0.28505674,
-0.5876327157,
0.2936490774,
-0.4614707828,
-0.4266542494,
-0.426060617,
-0.5625211,
-0.9820169806,
-0.1560148448,
-0.1326584518,
-0.5675833821,
0.5132655501,
0.4513079524,
-0.580597043,
0.2006679177,
-0.7372394204,
0.2872884572,
-0.0825477764,
-0.0983279496,
-0.3412442505,
-0.5902418494,
-0.1760880351,
-0.5464774966,
0.3431496024,
0.1508706361,
0.1813203543,
1.0666208267,
-0.3436128497,
0.3798080087,
-0.4672458768,
0.1033625603,
0.4934682846,
-0.069738932,
0.4194535315,
-0.3600407839,
-0.4913665354,
0.2992380559,
0.015328587,
-0.3859021068,
-0.4117389023,
0.5449988246,
-0.9523494244,
-0.1585318893,
-0.2342638075,
-0.1774391979,
-0.3143458068,
0.1578364968,
0.480433315,
0.6877416372,
0.1082156226,
0.2759476304,
0.2298270017,
-0.0746278614,
0.5060146451,
0.3938513696,
0.433898598,
-0.3898452818,
1.2186836004,
0.3534742892,
0.2483792752,
0.2081457227,
0.3398305178,
-0.8101733923,
-0.9197025299,
-0.5109154582,
0.2684327662,
-0.3829759359,
-0.4387762845,
-0.4369178414,
-0.3633677363,
-0.5357618928,
-0.2431132346,
-0.6015315652,
-0.561450243,
-0.458801657,
-0.3136664629,
0.4392122328,
0.5658818483,
-0.7077518106,
0.1542517841,
-0.846795857,
0.4166130424,
0.2795749307,
0.4156937301,
0.0114712911,
-1.2273191214,
-0.3926877975,
0.1207523271,
0.2309587747,
-0.3981305361,
0.3322104514,
0.770853579,
0.5037638545,
0.4386924207,
0.1028392613,
1.134226203,
-0.614680469,
0.6852995157,
0.6354804039,
-0.9959343672,
0.4673008025,
-0.1298515201,
-0.0209910851,
0.7057788372,
0.2151669562,
-0.3836017251,
-0.2520340085,
-0.4495621622,
-0.6974671483,
0.9285156727,
0.1590656042,
0.158204779,
-0.010452251,
0.2603524923,
0.2152184546,
0.0685463771,
-0.5706751347,
-0.1983181238,
-0.5149238706,
-0.282095015,
-0.4906154573,
-0.0911431164,
0.1188998669,
-0.457993716,
0.5331350565,
0.0295930896,
0.3780638874,
0.104026489,
-0.0056900857,
-0.2606721222,
0.1978988051,
0.4799070358,
0.459905386,
-0.1236001775,
0.1830587387,
0.2925585508,
-0.5569605827,
0.4896070957,
0.4252981246,
0.2199040949,
-0.0796283036,
0.6304143667,
0.7393019199,
0.0340914465,
-0.5487574935,
0.5026495457,
-0.0331336223,
-0.0524833612,
-0.3333196342,
-0.0538573712,
0.0246656816,
0.1737505943,
0.4470780492,
0.081126675,
0.2856766284,
-0.6800428033,
0.3996883631,
0.3638779819,
-0.6378031373,
-0.6817163229,
0.5263693333,
0.4054662585,
-0.7188771367,
0.8312339783,
-0.1846444309,
-0.3829380572,
0.4165214896,
0.6592408419,
0.7427202463,
-0.5856950283,
-0.0882894769,
0.5576972365,
0.0178855751,
-0.0067876093,
0.1893467903,
-0.3735684454,
-0.613386035,
-0.466109544,
-0.8373460174,
0.0253652819,
0.0832427889,
-0.9831334949,
0.4100620151,
-0.205885753,
-0.1593433022,
0.086499311,
-0.0377570763,
-0.874610126,
0.0919395536,
0.4930444956,
0.6886410117,
-0.9614694715,
1.0138396025,
0.4851745367,
-0.2177662253,
-1.1275517941,
-0.2658249736,
0.0365261696,
-0.7873035073,
0.7407121062,
-0.1165211573,
-0.3169234693,
-0.0335514285,
0.2124208212,
-1.0904814005,
0.7884434462,
0.6306495667,
-0.8328838944,
0.0765365735,
0.2905518115,
0.6728510857,
-0.1946718246,
0.0963062644,
0.4944532812,
0.3255282044,
0.160258472,
-1.5670592785,
-0.2202772051,
-0.1432496309,
-0.0871046782,
0.1864736676,
-0.3645596802,
0.6220572591,
-0.4126216769,
-0.2833048999,
0.1523086876,
0.5951567888,
0.220090583,
0.2538934648,
0.807207942,
0.2188569456,
0.7281160355,
0.1522884816,
0.9424248338,
-0.173969835,
-0.0462311096,
0.9207823873,
-0.2575753331,
1.0237766504,
0.5439602733,
-0.4292541146,
0.1269803941,
0.5270731449,
0.1382590085,
0.914670825,
0.1337351203,
-0.2130461782,
-0.0657724589,
-0.5742075443,
-0.5978068113,
0.7989212871,
0.122642003,
-0.2150651366,
0.0801223069,
0.3186146319,
-0.4469715357,
0.0206672996,
-0.4194368422,
1.0541113615,
0.1954284012,
-0.4041095078,
0.7655906081,
-0.5455341339,
0.8643632531,
-0.6698729396,
0.0510149412,
-0.2520543039,
0.1807841808,
-0.2411536723,
-0.5069602132,
0.5539903045,
0.0276820119,
-0.1944444031,
-0.3096465468,
0.6058009863,
-0.4995897412,
-0.5699205995,
0.5521286726,
0.467990011,
0.3274486661,
0.3728965819,
-0.6355479956,
0.1515558213,
0.2394723892,
0.1605104506,
0.5806165934,
0.3663262725,
0.0093626147,
0.5323472619,
0.8590708971,
0.8963227868,
-0.0186213143,
0.2118426561,
0.7061707377,
-0.503105998,
-0.8436163068,
-0.6896829605,
0.0629673749,
0.2652874589,
-0.1953276247,
0.4317741096,
0.5988405943,
1.1086070538,
0.1165996492,
0.593174994,
0.1292153895,
0.8127362132,
-0.3932175338,
0.670460999,
-0.537925899,
0.1400271654,
-0.4389384091,
-0.9002472162,
-0.0495683029,
0.9180327058,
-0.0767157823,
-0.1334956735,
0.2634765506,
0.6831378937,
-0.2644341886,
-0.285174787,
0.2801614702,
-0.0292077791,
0.3020026386,
0.438752234,
0.8888761401,
-0.194300279,
0.9986780286,
-0.0590658635,
-0.0696740374,
-0.0522244684,
-0.4740773737,
-0.464666605,
-0.8210834861,
-0.3425761461,
-0.193765372,
0.1324667633,
1.09980762,
1.0038232803,
-0.9616870284,
-0.4540069401,
0.1916401088,
-0.3419987261,
-0.1630429029,
-0.1370271891,
0.6200243831,
0.1265433133,
-0.4234216809,
0.4440034926,
0.0650528744,
0.2686602771,
0.1079836264,
-0.2617052197,
-0.0004661581,
0.0416668132,
0.4954768121,
0.5226368904,
-0.5505201221,
-0.4158962369,
-0.1981730163,
0.1454293579,
0.2127230018,
0.950338304,
-0.9684845209,
0.3726140857,
0.2511805594,
0.6945697665,
0.3738069236,
-0.0591892079,
0.545774579,
-0.7182571292,
0.5918462276,
0.55730021,
0.3842650056,
0.5380284786,
-0.1869716942,
0.3192312419,
0.205028072,
-0.1085331291,
-1.1799615622,
0.0511626974,
-0.7267702222,
0.1184062883,
1.1851079464,
-0.1661947966,
0.1501936615,
-0.339659065,
-0.1465244293,
0.4695243537,
-0.5297657251,
0.7424746156,
0.4658285975,
-0.2227516323,
-0.0835074633,
-0.031394884,
0.8856579065,
0.4042421877,
-0.4589640796,
0.1625022143,
0.289447546,
0.2532953024,
0.4097069204,
1.0491813421,
-0.2172554582,
0.3651435375,
-0.0307231005,
-0.1520759612,
-0.0478490554,
-0.2357370555,
-0.4704453349,
-0.1880808026,
0.3736003041,
-0.3735902607
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02289v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02289v1
|
SemPool: Simple, robust, and interpretable KG pooling for enhancing language models
| 2024-02-03T23:03:51 | 2024-02-03T23:03:51 |
Costas Mavromatis, Petros Karypis, George Karypis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Knowledge Graph (KG) powered question answering (QA) performs complex
reasoning over language semantics as well as knowledge facts. Graph Neural
Networks (GNNs) learn to aggregate information from the underlying KG, which is
combined with Language Models (LMs) for effective reasoning with the given
question. However, GNN-based methods for QA rely on the graph information of
the candidate answer nodes, which limits their effectiveness in more
challenging settings where critical answer information is not included in the
KG. We propose a simple graph pooling approach that learns useful semantics of
the KG that can aid the LM's reasoning and that its effectiveness is robust
under graph perturbations. Our method, termed SemPool, represents KG facts with
pre-trained LMs, learns to aggregate their semantic information, and fuses it
at different layers of the LM. Our experimental results show that SemPool
outperforms state-of-the-art GNN-based methods by 2.27% accuracy points on
average when answer information is missing from the KG. In addition, SemPool
offers interpretability on what type of graph information is fused at different
LM layers.
|
[
-0.3781602085,
-0.9349032044,
0.50545156,
-0.0937636271,
-0.259958297,
0.1698573381,
-0.015701361,
-0.123899132,
0.1173779443,
0.5018412471,
-0.3131171465,
-0.3453118205,
-0.6489476562,
-0.2920260727,
-0.3226473927,
0.8109066486,
0.0572625026,
-0.052861575,
-0.425955683,
-0.3550671339,
-0.2739801407,
-0.2736823559,
-0.6173088551,
-0.7275687456,
0.69085747,
0.3579785228,
0.9779934883,
0.5518789291,
0.117421858,
0.3525983095,
-0.0059700492,
0.3929796815,
-0.5193731189,
0.3234156072,
-0.1724549532,
-0.170966953,
-0.3116552234,
0.0271677244,
0.5130754709,
0.9492052794,
-0.1173183098,
0.1605420858,
0.1017460898,
0.5864350796,
-0.9230521917,
0.399985373,
-0.6817089915,
-0.0872180015,
0.028585298,
-0.2031206936,
-0.3593185544,
-0.4024687111,
0.1769323051,
-0.4870506227,
-0.1576383561,
-0.2418109179,
0.885604918,
0.3564543426,
-0.5597723722,
-0.2363191098,
-0.3511793017,
0.531376183,
-0.7357568741,
0.2978228927,
0.6209222078,
0.6631212234,
-0.0061464873,
-1.0256263018,
-0.6606454849,
0.1097624302,
-0.3273230791,
0.168926388,
-0.027352443,
0.1460408121,
0.1674432158,
0.0404674187,
-0.5142460465,
0.029231498,
-0.3239637315,
-0.3760371804,
0.6198189855,
-0.011988272,
0.6766665578,
-0.1649350673,
-0.1706457585,
-0.0863762721,
-0.5297429562,
0.0747895464,
0.4462393224,
0.3147235811,
0.2573815882,
0.592143178,
-0.2795550823,
0.9953849912,
-0.4004242718,
-0.078279838,
0.1873023212,
-0.0534873344,
-0.3173317611,
-0.0402587019,
0.6063604951,
0.1751405895,
0.3863455653,
-0.4554822743,
0.0861365646,
-0.0177983548,
0.1061541662,
-0.8403813839,
-0.5053931475,
0.1841334701,
-0.1550172865,
-0.2919070125,
-0.0435438231,
-0.665461123,
-0.4331402481,
-0.2334489077,
0.6568092704,
-0.5182633996,
-0.4310671687,
-0.1025732756,
-0.4048158824,
0.3948369026,
0.2405054718,
-0.7083428502,
0.3711240292,
0.65830338,
0.5991330147,
0.0243205503,
-0.561851263,
-0.7258549929,
0.2162731439,
-0.0697868392,
0.8568687439,
-0.7055274844,
-0.0422180519,
-0.0836826637,
-0.0696999282,
-0.5239974856,
-0.5111193061,
0.3029355407,
-0.9742165208,
0.4096677601,
0.0064666159,
-0.8249920011,
-0.3961916268,
0.3559466302,
-0.5552282929,
0.9820739031,
0.3906559348,
-0.9351395965,
0.0067698681,
-0.3332701325,
-0.4709419906,
0.0664525032,
0.070504494,
-0.3352558315,
-0.2262276709,
0.3918602765,
0.4136001766,
0.1846131682,
0.2983394861,
-0.5800574422,
-0.2218414992,
0.355186969,
-0.1290546954,
0.8885590434,
0.5074627399,
0.2093892992,
0.2031265497,
-0.7245961428,
0.5476584435,
0.0498417877,
-0.2642478347,
-0.201933369,
0.0029381781,
-0.6702111363,
0.2762478888,
0.0882851779,
-0.1438032985,
-0.0703472346,
-0.4643353522,
0.5490288138,
0.7229075432,
-0.1002111882,
0.5596367717,
-0.2205696553,
0.5002266765,
-0.2175890952,
-0.1450056881,
-0.0378405601,
-0.437684834,
-0.734973073,
-0.0624193139,
0.4033091962,
0.6537595987,
-1.025769949,
0.1245099306,
-0.2808019817,
-0.6440214515,
-0.3263483047,
0.3892866373,
0.1540435702,
0.885510385,
0.3595972061,
-0.039658796,
-0.3942514956,
-0.6612082124,
-0.5094760656,
-0.3211327493,
-0.0849678144,
0.5646690726,
0.1153267249,
-0.0439373218,
0.9781852961,
-0.5245146155,
0.1431044638,
-0.5438520908,
-0.0226463955,
0.2432784736,
0.1285435855,
0.3642655015,
-0.7198185921,
-0.5233595371,
-0.2707502246,
-0.8043782115,
-0.3418484926,
0.2967908382,
-0.4169280231,
-0.1877577156,
0.352758944,
-0.5428791642,
0.0691546723,
0.6609094739,
-0.5873206258,
0.2686486542,
-0.1407580376,
-0.2181921154,
-1.0306171179,
0.0577447154,
-0.3531580865,
-0.4789538682,
-0.7405816913,
0.167387709,
-0.1207450628,
-0.3567489982,
-0.3695175648,
0.6457687616,
-0.1831660569,
-0.1685145944,
-0.4569714963,
0.5825577378,
0.1330751926,
0.488755554,
-0.1297068596,
0.4188307524,
0.6056066751,
-0.723092258,
0.6509361267,
0.1604535133,
-0.2675459683,
0.1223785803,
-0.5261360407,
0.4608386159,
-0.3034284115,
0.0811699405,
-1.09395504,
-0.32599172,
0.2352613509,
-0.5964866281,
0.391775161,
-0.2626825273,
-0.1949797571,
-0.3043143749,
-0.1953811198,
0.280937016,
0.537417531,
-0.5978015661,
0.8354089856,
0.7214399576,
-0.3045457304,
-0.7825176716,
-0.3491567969,
-0.1213730499,
-0.0157302618,
-0.9176673889,
-0.0939604118,
0.2932777703,
-0.1059709191,
0.3505273759,
-0.1771630198,
-0.5038083792,
0.5310768485,
0.1310751885,
0.21350573,
-0.1250220835,
0.3807969689,
0.0364876688,
-0.4034061432,
0.0023820326,
-0.4182858169,
0.7457795739,
-0.1308797151,
-0.3780989647,
-0.0680986121,
0.1056336015,
0.4262030423,
-0.1788080931,
0.8442178369,
0.630505681,
-0.3282519877,
-0.3014919162,
-0.249882713,
-0.2539602518,
-0.450144738,
0.4126413167,
-0.2671367526,
-1.1096826792,
0.4494813085,
-0.2339233011,
-0.2521579266,
0.4130102098,
0.3901026547,
-0.168421641,
1.2034542561,
0.3435231149,
-0.1461559683,
0.3946758807,
-0.2940364778,
0.4725803733,
-0.5501025319,
-0.2057107687,
-0.5263524055,
-0.4384813607,
-0.290199697,
-0.3392754197,
0.2829152048,
0.5578614473,
-0.4585571289,
-0.0018017008,
-0.2526265979,
0.7119426131,
0.6383799314,
0.1342318356,
0.0490925238,
0.0816765353,
-0.1673138291,
0.3252353966,
-1.0240111351,
-0.4680130482,
0.6752542853,
0.0707217678,
0.7109193206,
0.081086874,
0.3500331044,
-0.0517644472,
0.3097113073,
-0.6144452691,
0.6164671183,
0.0250262506,
-0.4667422771,
-0.6907031536,
-0.6758791804,
-0.8320916891,
0.4480011165,
-0.0594839603,
-0.9355410933,
-0.3614031076,
0.1540367603,
-0.1627461463,
0.3412581384,
-0.8588382006,
1.0308111906,
-0.1013967693,
-0.1366600692,
-0.1901174784,
-0.7208443284,
0.1362359375,
0.1673341841,
0.1726223975,
-0.4282971025,
0.1922165453,
0.6289066076,
-0.8473417759,
0.7175124288,
-0.2974971235,
0.2912909389,
0.6193467975,
0.0784645006,
0.5929107666,
-0.1723564267,
-0.1759840548,
-0.1753153801,
0.0937440917,
-0.607339859,
-1.0970954895,
0.621103704,
-0.9966619015,
-0.6394734979,
-0.0727968588,
-0.6927826405,
-0.5429834127,
0.3609782159,
-0.0311716478,
0.498264879,
0.3108465374,
0.1232346967,
0.2631705105,
-0.2881228328,
0.2592664659,
0.3956290483,
-0.4338031709,
-0.5029684901,
1.1087254286,
0.3180355132,
0.3999626935,
0.2737734616,
0.5810252428,
-0.5441746116,
-0.4094721079,
-0.4333756566,
0.1713263541,
-1.0319093466,
-0.2115354836,
-0.8602431417,
-0.5238260627,
-0.5920527577,
-0.0155837331,
-0.006054732,
-0.7795929313,
0.0997711569,
-0.3676739633,
0.1959626377,
0.2794019878,
0.0370807908,
0.2833634913,
-0.8901635408,
0.2112326175,
0.90564996,
0.3348188698,
0.0447527766,
-0.4019112885,
-0.0556381568,
-0.0381913148,
-0.1766673774,
-1.0430390835,
0.333920449,
0.3736480474,
0.8062043786,
0.3392104805,
0.2387955487,
0.5854614377,
-0.1685335487,
0.7373315096,
0.0241916087,
-0.9507237077,
0.73456496,
-0.0685061589,
0.3607574105,
0.5023087859,
0.3171246052,
-0.6504872441,
-0.6179278493,
-0.7269706726,
-0.9245578051,
0.6763454676,
0.0699710622,
0.3505087793,
0.0090196114,
0.2957832813,
-0.0708452836,
0.1506628841,
-0.5678336024,
-0.2208048254,
-0.366756171,
-0.4142170548,
0.0600505918,
-0.4690807164,
-0.0470986664,
-0.2218675613,
0.9093903303,
-0.4649725258,
-0.1540465504,
-0.1394329816,
-0.2943418622,
0.1132594943,
0.3739458621,
0.0159882512,
0.8885927796,
-0.0144441221,
0.8405560851,
0.5722375512,
-0.3134113252,
-0.0630038381,
0.1507290304,
-0.3133685887,
-0.1962585449,
0.4839875996,
0.7849246264,
0.0187515821,
-0.7172427177,
0.5596678853,
0.0241976809,
0.0171867255,
0.0656942353,
0.4079914987,
0.4067195058,
0.2022877187,
-0.0341940522,
-0.1388736069,
-0.0557335056,
-0.3909038901,
0.1717124432,
0.35730654,
-0.5717628002,
-0.1670693159,
0.4212588668,
0.0886465833,
-0.1193597391,
1.0503767729,
-0.1362619549,
-0.8069460392,
0.5199012756,
0.6926749945,
0.5878314972,
-0.1887732893,
0.4371989071,
0.3757401705,
-0.0501058772,
0.2753352225,
0.3086006045,
-0.1837461889,
-1.2258350849,
-0.6978607774,
-0.6202363372,
-0.3385148346,
0.0040986999,
-0.4273883402,
0.1296200752,
-0.2901104391,
0.1508268565,
-0.0654370114,
0.0783509612,
-0.3862561882,
0.128238976,
0.119285807,
0.9574947953,
-0.8752858043,
0.9581053853,
0.8699025512,
-0.2975458503,
-1.3999272585,
-0.485147804,
-0.245209828,
-1.049909234,
0.5166410804,
0.2440118194,
-0.0840983167,
0.1690679342,
-0.6576771736,
-0.8046931624,
1.2113445997,
0.687841475,
0.1118908077,
0.236641854,
0.1679339111,
0.2939255536,
-0.10330116,
0.3143160939,
0.4117825329,
0.3750177026,
0.5714480281,
-0.6427481174,
-0.0040774867,
-0.4184060991,
-0.3011121452,
0.2023953944,
-0.5155633092,
0.6017256975,
-0.2747084796,
-0.3941781223,
-0.2606991529,
0.5846819878,
0.3070853651,
0.6715715528,
0.7237167954,
0.7240372896,
1.3260740042,
-0.0533871092,
1.20381248,
-0.428380549,
0.4469636381,
1.1342130899,
-0.1641528755,
0.5814788342,
0.2109168321,
-0.1739281118,
0.5217994452,
0.5589269996,
0.3642170131,
0.4827820063,
0.1835643351,
-0.3331317902,
-0.8177694678,
-0.2349612564,
-0.3262969255,
0.3522177339,
0.1303787231,
-0.2403326333,
-0.5306698084,
-0.2147649676,
0.1356475055,
-0.0303410906,
-0.3994334042,
0.7729434967,
0.2252728343,
-0.744628489,
0.1827560365,
-0.2280924022,
-0.1240712702,
-0.623812139,
0.0136499126,
-0.1229998842,
0.1917013079,
-0.3283061385,
-0.8341835141,
0.3653467596,
-0.1674662977,
0.0632063597,
-0.200026229,
1.5458027124,
-0.476765424,
-0.4235955477,
0.2040821463,
0.9471606016,
0.2229210287,
0.0275181979,
-0.4948780835,
-0.4131890833,
-0.2818055749,
-0.1307222843,
0.3290912211,
0.4694763124,
0.2244755477,
0.9659099579,
0.4633058608,
0.0591205619,
0.1266703606,
0.3641784489,
1.0719745159,
-0.3697661161,
-0.5359390974,
-1.0091996193,
0.3163203895,
-0.3677850664,
0.0743637234,
0.8976217508,
0.4038132727,
0.789422214,
0.2508578598,
0.7829785347,
0.0277971048,
0.4809490144,
-0.6039535403,
0.7704597116,
-0.2423160225,
0.1198220253,
-0.0438222736,
-0.7939602137,
-0.4006752074,
0.7134798169,
-0.528508842,
0.0385647006,
0.5045236945,
0.6916065216,
-0.0262032878,
0.2764051557,
0.3489775062,
0.2540272772,
0.3011801243,
0.5577782989,
1.2488331795,
-0.0439108834,
0.7142502069,
-0.2523971796,
-0.0508881696,
0.0166272726,
-0.9108868837,
-0.8027077317,
-0.2889411151,
-0.3430409133,
-0.6654146314,
-0.0616006069,
0.6986466646,
0.7751936913,
-0.8519107699,
0.0947913826,
-0.0336903706,
0.778005302,
-0.2046011686,
-0.2280676514,
0.5894016027,
-0.72329247,
-0.4491661787,
0.252726078,
0.2654152215,
-0.2362871915,
-0.0721505806,
-0.2833563685,
-0.0191294849,
-0.0466925576,
0.5514693856,
0.2293078154,
-0.2244913429,
-0.626209259,
-0.0185329821,
0.0248191264,
-0.1733815074,
0.8247010708,
-0.9409971237,
0.6033779979,
0.8801065087,
0.8569142222,
0.4682494998,
0.0125064859,
0.5711097717,
-0.7116286755,
-0.0607111081,
0.2491850108,
0.5326753855,
0.2258213013,
0.0262220968,
0.6929875016,
0.3638775945,
-0.5661655664,
-0.7308551669,
0.3832196891,
-0.8061781526,
-0.5013296604,
1.2972851992,
-0.3390559554,
-0.3634141982,
-0.1885464787,
-0.049859453,
0.5369927883,
0.1687255204,
0.5995594263,
0.6585481763,
-0.2141895145,
-0.316136539,
-0.3295986354,
0.2104327083,
0.2095254362,
-0.770426333,
-0.1938516647,
0.5353540778,
0.4368425608,
0.0642851889,
0.7865208387,
0.0334798396,
0.122058928,
0.0169515442,
-0.5369033217,
-0.4749471843,
-0.214386344,
-0.0702582672,
0.6059195399,
0.2582764924,
-0.0121696349
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02285v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02285v1
|
SynthDST: Synthetic Data is All You Need for Few-Shot Dialog State Tracking
| 2024-02-03T22:49:00 | 2024-02-03T22:49:00 |
Atharva Kulkarni, Bo-Hsiang Tseng, Joel Ruben Antony Moniz, Dhivya Piraviperumal, Hong Yu, Shruti Bhargava
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In-context learning with Large Language Models (LLMs) has emerged as a
promising avenue of research in Dialog State Tracking (DST). However, the
best-performing in-context learning methods involve retrieving and adding
similar examples to the prompt, requiring access to labeled training data.
Procuring such training data for a wide range of domains and applications is
time-consuming, expensive, and, at times, infeasible. While zero-shot learning
requires no training data, it significantly lags behind the few-shot setup.
Thus, `\textit{Can we efficiently generate synthetic data for any dialogue
schema to enable few-shot prompting?}' Addressing this question, we propose
\method, a data generation framework tailored for DST, utilizing LLMs. Our
approach only requires the dialogue schema and a few hand-crafted dialogue
templates to synthesize natural, coherent, and free-flowing dialogues with DST
annotations. Few-shot learning using data from {\method} results in $4-5%$
improvement in Joint Goal Accuracy over the zero-shot baseline on MultiWOZ 2.1
and 2.4. Remarkably, our few-shot learning approach recovers nearly $98%$ of
the performance compared to the few-shot setup using human-annotated training
data. Our synthetic data and code can be accessed at
https://github.com/apple/ml-synthdst
|
[
-0.384791255,
-1.0225867033,
1.0015332699,
-0.327403903,
-0.2716627121,
0.0795396864,
-0.030728016,
-0.0902061909,
0.2868562937,
0.5003749132,
-1.2615679502,
-0.6825682521,
-0.0661873594,
0.2464799285,
-0.0768043101,
1.2782039642,
0.1996961981,
0.0576263145,
0.0046997857,
0.0251389444,
-0.232226938,
-0.4535337687,
-0.3959264457,
-0.1239320487,
0.2745837271,
0.5011529326,
0.1203085631,
0.4836657643,
0.0089777773,
0.200538367,
-0.0286269747,
0.4219402671,
-0.7266917825,
0.4554429948,
0.2024583966,
-0.4217606187,
-0.4529059231,
0.0439257324,
0.6344508529,
0.4583033323,
0.0147810876,
0.2611028254,
-0.0971504524,
0.4575440586,
-0.3955229819,
0.22323066,
-0.9458425045,
0.1926403046,
-0.2309753746,
-0.5113054514,
-0.2720223367,
-0.4097888172,
0.2679730058,
-0.6973645687,
0.3861231506,
-0.0923829451,
0.2535969317,
0.2747322023,
-0.619615972,
-0.1145589948,
-0.5902215838,
0.7597352266,
-0.852596879,
0.119707182,
0.2540048361,
0.5176810622,
-0.6180433035,
-0.7538047433,
-0.6741970181,
-0.1889043301,
0.1479257196,
0.2769811153,
0.1058041379,
0.2592154741,
0.6237939596,
0.1493134201,
-0.4989264607,
-0.2738924026,
-0.4390634298,
-0.3673720658,
0.5826104283,
0.7117942572,
0.0526139438,
-0.3735873401,
-0.3919752538,
-0.0141610671,
-0.8763373494,
-0.1377465129,
0.3082036674,
0.6336729527,
-0.307592392,
0.7126449347,
-0.4525570571,
0.744610548,
0.2633625269,
-0.4564064443,
0.0402332805,
-0.6336203814,
-0.1871762872,
0.3096836507,
0.7420300245,
0.3089177907,
-0.1736597568,
0.027262697,
-0.2526756525,
0.1010631099,
0.1074560061,
-1.0484048128,
-0.2557540834,
0.1556646377,
0.0843284577,
-0.2705277205,
-0.2984755635,
-0.6234099865,
-0.2675645351,
-0.6310203671,
0.3037611842,
-0.5192328691,
0.0493539236,
-0.3927506804,
-0.0351769701,
0.0717912465,
0.486704886,
-0.8978322148,
0.2007161081,
0.5977880955,
1.0276869535,
-0.09535034,
-0.0507887378,
-0.7744480968,
0.0998269543,
-0.5663747191,
0.8203060627,
-0.265935719,
-0.4630667865,
-0.1127982959,
-0.1681966186,
-0.033430092,
-0.2657018602,
0.1633645743,
-0.0765212551,
0.2269676924,
-0.26917997,
-0.8795365691,
0.0274573714,
0.4230012,
-0.2626708448,
0.9364109039,
0.1360969692,
-0.5886622667,
0.3975848258,
-0.5383674502,
-0.3471598029,
0.1040222868,
-0.562042594,
-0.3589869142,
0.2325477004,
0.1817738861,
0.3314149678,
-0.1092159599,
0.1718244255,
-0.2663532794,
-0.4729611278,
0.292812109,
-0.5553194284,
0.6221174598,
0.2383064628,
-0.1041552573,
-0.1037073806,
-0.8821051717,
0.1557538211,
-0.1328053921,
-0.3550441563,
0.1470551044,
-0.1678488404,
-0.0300317034,
0.1314886957,
-0.2088296264,
-0.9130536318,
0.3784442544,
-0.6057095528,
0.2675660253,
0.8365790248,
0.5364172459,
0.4826684892,
-0.3341552615,
0.782297194,
0.0291305427,
-0.1768552363,
-0.7022274137,
-0.3543183506,
-0.4407343864,
-0.5389603376,
-0.1928208321,
0.3509587049,
-0.7907070518,
0.235387668,
-0.0476337485,
-0.3123776019,
-0.419878155,
0.168506965,
0.2652971148,
0.7199701667,
0.1606215388,
-0.0935559496,
-0.7551199198,
-0.8070306778,
-0.0012429139,
-0.068652913,
-0.1730803996,
0.2701586485,
0.4360091984,
-0.1059851944,
1.5323138237,
-0.8096051216,
-0.4256812334,
-0.5386587977,
0.2088105381,
0.0296410602,
0.3284776509,
0.5213055015,
-0.2462266088,
-0.6311932802,
-0.2791308463,
-0.6955025792,
-0.1858701706,
-0.1808844656,
-0.0912224948,
0.3737031519,
0.3442336023,
-0.7995377183,
0.4287338555,
0.4594081938,
0.200294897,
0.3952147663,
0.2075174153,
0.0751695707,
-1.4447021484,
-0.0810087174,
0.0505017377,
-0.3894290328,
-0.8186373711,
-0.7188424468,
-0.2133104503,
-0.473826766,
-0.8497458696,
0.6551507711,
-0.0472078249,
-0.066098161,
-0.1168107092,
0.1691470742,
-0.157878682,
0.7817555666,
0.1284780502,
0.8442287445,
0.4804833829,
-0.5079692602,
0.3150804043,
0.4689851999,
-0.4799393117,
0.8174625039,
-0.385645777,
0.5067920685,
-0.2335134298,
0.8243374228,
-0.9902137518,
-0.5116519332,
0.3745061755,
-0.3390789628,
0.1097986698,
-0.5707149506,
-0.3660202622,
0.1267427057,
-0.3559908569,
0.1258556098,
0.4648359418,
-0.5347754955,
0.3457122147,
0.2857567668,
-0.1487855315,
-0.0691197738,
-0.5396775007,
-0.0071542226,
-0.1725024879,
-0.3647563159,
0.1327924579,
-0.2134221196,
0.0357598849,
-0.350543648,
-0.4875522554,
0.0304848123,
-0.2372996509,
0.2668295503,
0.3278267384,
-0.110293448,
0.1078843102,
0.142596662,
-0.3096888065,
-0.147637248,
-0.2819660306,
0.2496750951,
0.0675202459,
-0.3410327435,
-0.8630671501,
0.2512915432,
0.5346616507,
0.3561032414,
0.3137809336,
0.4545331895,
-0.2806379795,
-0.4663691521,
-0.3014850616,
-0.66134727,
-0.4527332485,
0.2254987508,
-0.5101004839,
-0.7505870461,
0.0883798599,
-0.0537956469,
0.2449490726,
0.0505494438,
0.5549657941,
-0.4176286757,
1.2709518671,
0.2781850398,
0.0732620806,
0.6184464693,
-0.3003662825,
0.2695711255,
-0.7922094464,
0.0392704532,
-0.1092891023,
-0.2534759045,
-0.6094139814,
-0.1106292307,
0.8299568295,
-0.2103876621,
-0.278654784,
0.3859962225,
-0.1993525326,
0.5807962418,
0.482527405,
0.1608806401,
0.3095082939,
0.1046445593,
0.0258876551,
-0.3532437384,
-0.8101857901,
-0.475805074,
1.2928124666,
0.0670134127,
0.9539552331,
-0.0710512549,
1.1218527555,
0.151494354,
0.0550532043,
-0.9122268558,
0.7453047633,
0.1302140951,
-0.7073359489,
-0.0978810415,
-0.5693977475,
-0.5560939908,
0.0849232525,
-0.2522794604,
-0.9574217796,
-0.351171881,
0.3965850174,
-0.579212606,
0.1634400636,
-0.6671991944,
0.6629843712,
-0.0763938129,
-0.3760164976,
0.0102864057,
-0.6369207501,
0.55971843,
-0.2451951951,
-0.4308173656,
-0.4614518881,
0.4369990826,
0.5775662065,
-0.5082506537,
1.3226550817,
-0.2745918334,
0.0193028264,
0.6341805458,
0.3698388636,
0.6356667876,
0.2267551571,
0.1738993973,
-0.0613343194,
0.3450205326,
-0.2608922422,
-0.6653825045,
0.6700709462,
-0.3251738846,
-0.4866615236,
-0.6148644686,
-0.5882237554,
-0.4351413548,
-0.0828303844,
0.4516932368,
0.6762475967,
-0.3820174038,
0.1010964885,
0.3402581513,
-0.0940892249,
0.2840465307,
0.55850631,
0.0476220734,
-0.3946954012,
0.7062770128,
0.0406290218,
0.482042402,
0.1144237593,
0.1199572757,
-0.4085629582,
-0.1110164374,
-0.6945008636,
0.0283304229,
-0.5193740726,
-0.5189145207,
-0.4664072692,
-0.2767789662,
-0.3451252878,
-0.2968630195,
-0.5499761701,
-0.4783825874,
-0.2475972325,
-0.2464892864,
0.6182162762,
0.7341046333,
-0.0235146042,
0.4705941677,
-0.8748720288,
0.4942753315,
0.2810319066,
0.0594600774,
-0.3568437397,
-0.3302882314,
-0.1049240679,
0.5206509829,
-0.594401896,
-0.6031749249,
0.3496080935,
0.2416090965,
0.3389474452,
0.1864821464,
0.216410622,
0.8318264484,
-0.4757095873,
1.0632573366,
0.346619904,
-0.8940298557,
0.8156059384,
-0.4632711112,
0.5081167817,
0.6905418038,
0.0138520701,
-0.5616253614,
-0.3966394663,
-0.5363641977,
-0.4426578581,
1.3285839558,
0.2954412103,
0.2979972959,
-0.1768579185,
0.2085499018,
0.2128490061,
0.1959248483,
-0.3153554499,
-0.0056081563,
0.0004542698,
-0.4675391316,
0.0441113934,
-0.0247047525,
-0.2974150479,
-0.1288890839,
0.607621789,
-0.6146394014,
0.1274635941,
0.1376608312,
-0.0573935471,
-0.1942444593,
0.3167981207,
0.6101533771,
0.4658178389,
-0.415425241,
-0.0462570116,
0.407820195,
-0.2295415699,
0.3415775895,
-0.2735239267,
-0.5083184838,
0.0444783233,
0.122577861,
0.9390827417,
0.213152945,
-0.686129868,
0.4352082014,
0.1201371625,
-0.2152494639,
-0.3085728288,
0.2008965462,
-0.2469861805,
0.365131706,
0.2006035894,
0.0141005274,
0.0156606641,
-0.653965652,
0.3223686814,
0.4656808972,
-0.2487585694,
-0.5894309282,
0.4901743829,
0.2572093606,
-0.224022463,
0.6534289122,
-0.2496305108,
-0.4703378677,
0.3196499646,
0.7220615745,
1.0352566242,
0.112153694,
0.4569264948,
0.5056570768,
-0.2303193212,
-0.0614330359,
0.1013571024,
-0.5416782498,
-0.5929014683,
-0.2306161523,
-0.6224603653,
-0.641751349,
0.2513888478,
-0.3209308386,
0.4068487883,
-0.5674676895,
-0.3465439379,
-0.0778415799,
0.0716921985,
-0.7046322227,
0.0334916525,
0.2188296169,
0.5426362157,
-0.8607116938,
0.7809883952,
0.3021107018,
-0.4796398282,
-0.3692435026,
0.1950736344,
0.8324177861,
-0.5810495615,
0.5991615653,
0.2021309882,
-0.4546876848,
0.1951206177,
-0.6812781096,
-0.7114669681,
1.0859401226,
0.5180431008,
-0.6845422387,
0.1039938033,
0.2014258057,
0.5944002867,
-0.5307714343,
0.0986087173,
0.833327651,
0.1136783808,
0.429281801,
-0.6007527113,
-0.1764466017,
0.172325626,
0.0062045655,
0.1313613504,
-0.3993656635,
0.4287474453,
-0.1826333702,
-0.5662805438,
0.1962390691,
0.2427183241,
0.5412998796,
0.5854330659,
0.217371285,
0.521425724,
0.4428651929,
-0.1171845049,
0.8399544358,
-0.18368496,
0.2225731611,
1.335691452,
-0.5601758361,
0.4979153872,
0.6210614443,
-0.1398315579,
0.0433024094,
0.6470243931,
0.2057073414,
0.6441210508,
0.1784876138,
-0.5492839217,
-0.1449547112,
-0.1349956691,
0.0029011916,
0.500446856,
0.3397280872,
-0.0418411121,
-0.3165491819,
-0.0465760715,
0.0072070551,
-0.2455796152,
0.2751201391,
1.212520957,
0.215675801,
-0.7404014468,
0.620177269,
-0.4671541452,
0.4291765094,
-0.8109410405,
-0.2579687536,
-0.5601032972,
0.048086036,
-0.207123518,
-0.6110298634,
0.1791348308,
0.3359172642,
0.104082793,
-0.2151726931,
0.2564785182,
-0.6775465012,
-0.433596164,
-0.2736446559,
0.5235561728,
0.2827476859,
0.1897097677,
-0.4080966115,
0.0283320751,
0.2198253125,
-0.3299527168,
0.3523914218,
0.2064932436,
0.0978350863,
0.4457504451,
0.8575228453,
0.1696359068,
0.048770912,
0.0933140069,
0.7899993062,
-0.6515004039,
-0.429661274,
-0.6420909166,
0.5025836825,
-0.0368460082,
-0.3836765587,
0.5993227959,
0.6394246221,
0.813069582,
-0.0426008925,
1.0776540041,
-0.0584758259,
0.7155439258,
-0.8442290425,
0.3184130788,
-0.3923544884,
0.4286232889,
-0.0907922909,
-1.2020969391,
-0.0478276536,
0.4302277863,
-0.1002304927,
-0.1772808284,
0.5559095144,
1.2198095322,
-0.265403688,
0.0897080526,
0.3256981969,
0.0425267555,
0.5245712399,
0.4755709767,
0.8755375147,
-0.3888271451,
0.4047908485,
-0.3065290153,
0.0192065425,
-0.1646335572,
-0.6529456377,
-0.7884104848,
-0.6471369267,
-0.3681851327,
-0.1783837527,
-0.0469157584,
1.4601775408,
0.9869458079,
-0.7699090838,
-0.0819315538,
-0.2561368644,
-0.2937965095,
0.1601747572,
-0.2286701649,
0.1429013163,
-0.5981470942,
-0.9798538089,
1.0114965439,
0.3367787004,
0.5845003128,
-0.1251666397,
-0.1509086937,
0.0251261182,
0.1657391787,
0.6504688263,
0.3709425032,
-0.6870269775,
-0.296166569,
-0.0316081122,
-0.1131434441,
0.0432429612,
0.9996250272,
-0.9574841857,
0.8378286362,
0.5061472654,
0.5621201992,
1.1145802736,
0.2311407477,
0.7230399251,
-1.2785555124,
0.2756151855,
0.2447157502,
0.0453120917,
0.3361465037,
-0.1752524674,
0.4844282269,
0.2109784931,
-0.309807837,
-0.8363182545,
0.5226826668,
-1.0193593502,
0.0601608418,
1.0504180193,
0.0888980106,
-0.0327514708,
0.1105556637,
-0.5488578677,
0.1858964413,
-0.760710001,
0.8181793094,
0.3280627429,
-0.5958121419,
-0.1245544255,
-0.5265772939,
0.9186291099,
0.1621973366,
-0.8562727571,
0.0296104196,
0.9454746842,
0.3059901297,
-0.1997541338,
0.892431736,
0.1889420599,
0.0358264707,
0.1536937058,
-0.433314532,
0.0827513412,
-0.3272077739,
-0.2250553519,
-0.3311452866,
-0.3359486163,
-0.4515400827
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02262v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02262v1
|
Data Quality Matters: Suicide Intention Detection on Social Media Posts Using a RoBERTa-CNN Model
| 2024-02-03T20:58:09 | 2024-02-03T20:58:09 |
Emily Lin, Jian Sun, Hsingyu Chen, Mohammad H. Mahoor
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Suicide remains a global health concern for the field of health, which
urgently needs innovative approaches for early detection and intervention. In
this paper, we focus on identifying suicidal intentions in SuicideWatch Reddit
posts and present a novel approach to suicide detection using the cutting-edge
RoBERTa-CNN model, a variant of RoBERTa (Robustly optimized BERT approach).
RoBERTa is used for various Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks, including
text classification and sentiment analysis. The effectiveness of the RoBERTa
lies in its ability to capture textual information and form semantic
relationships within texts. By adding the Convolution Neural Network (CNN)
layer to the original model, the RoBERTa enhances its ability to capture
important patterns from heavy datasets. To evaluate the RoBERTa-CNN, we
experimented on the Suicide and Depression Detection dataset and obtained solid
results. For example, RoBERTa-CNN achieves 98% mean accuracy with the standard
deviation (STD) of 0.0009. It also reaches over 97.5% mean AUC value with an
STD of 0.0013. In the meanwhile, RoBERTa-CNN outperforms competitive methods,
demonstrating the robustness and ability to capture nuanced linguistic patterns
for suicidal intentions. Therefore, RoBERTa-CNN can detect suicide intention on
text data very well.
|
[
-0.1850335747,
-1.2296465635,
0.9023219943,
0.4043256938,
-0.5130276084,
-0.4071602225,
-0.4159974158,
-0.1697438359,
-0.0523438305,
-0.0737357214,
-0.8745898604,
-0.9420064092,
-0.9118248224,
0.0204511564,
-0.3782577217,
1.300788641,
0.1629953533,
0.490080148,
-0.0489689223,
-0.0978906974,
-0.275077194,
-0.1704890877,
-1.3988956213,
-0.0036853608,
0.89949435,
0.0955448523,
0.7059448957,
-0.1952160299,
0.7314963341,
0.1091037393,
-0.2163046002,
0.2988836765,
-0.5884474516,
-0.1240460798,
0.2599372864,
0.0062535834,
-0.4521567523,
0.1299361885,
0.2185601741,
-0.0436885431,
0.0445557609,
0.5106688738,
0.1035718918,
0.7870736122,
-0.4263491631,
-0.181818217,
-0.2969452441,
0.1688601673,
-0.1230704114,
-0.019178411,
-0.5310040116,
-0.5546326041,
-0.0183866881,
-0.1198587492,
0.0955527499,
-0.5863353014,
0.7776460648,
0.5452035666,
-0.3366421461,
-0.4403578043,
-0.8267349601,
0.9105173349,
-0.7849296927,
0.3304709196,
0.2897542119,
0.4546293318,
-0.250551194,
-0.1888248324,
-0.5622853041,
0.0421077162,
0.0376071408,
0.2853061259,
-0.4953584969,
-0.0818543509,
-0.0647266731,
0.2000623494,
-1.1001365185,
-0.1058366969,
-0.1652552783,
0.0888791829,
0.8364607096,
0.0249650925,
0.5415455103,
-0.5281239748,
-0.3977378905,
0.1847995222,
-0.0882070586,
0.1256082356,
0.5128890872,
0.1181696802,
-0.2048392445,
0.5378014445,
0.0000126659,
1.1045960188,
-0.2703389227,
-0.1134494469,
-0.1884872615,
-0.1155479103,
-0.155607,
-0.0838539153,
1.0294052362,
0.6100389957,
0.3432881236,
0.3659664392,
0.1241020113,
-0.111078687,
0.4926966429,
-0.6559235454,
-0.4706341624,
0.5810398459,
-1.1430780888,
-0.4595481455,
-0.2366927564,
-0.4944602549,
-0.184985742,
-0.2061517388,
0.3997383118,
-0.8203936219,
-0.2168876827,
0.0886520073,
-0.2250288874,
-0.0931473076,
0.4957181513,
-0.339792937,
-0.1957171261,
0.8217715621,
1.0471053123,
-0.2257534862,
0.1735735089,
-0.4004451334,
-0.1721661091,
0.1354487985,
0.762827754,
-0.2630757987,
-0.1126667559,
-0.0811347291,
-0.2870327532,
0.2226371169,
-0.0035451774,
1.2593462467,
-0.4714916945,
0.2765027881,
0.2007659823,
-0.5261737108,
-0.4072535634,
0.6263920665,
-0.656447649,
0.8515298963,
-0.2270674855,
-0.7253578305,
0.3286575675,
-0.6773232222,
-0.5464293957,
-0.2707568705,
0.1852707267,
-1.0734187365,
0.1516339183,
0.2577956021,
0.8874107599,
-0.0202943627,
0.2347382307,
-0.5318124294,
-0.1675722599,
0.6113238335,
-0.972872138,
1.0988326073,
0.4350577891,
0.1393013895,
0.1112952307,
-0.7171934843,
0.2506455183,
0.02657496,
-0.5125845075,
-0.4862617552,
0.1087502614,
0.4441626072,
0.2200846523,
0.4252561033,
-0.6597523689,
-0.1615963578,
0.0115411673,
0.445892781,
0.3880377412,
0.4420844615,
0.1549042761,
-0.3408180773,
0.4821727276,
-0.0852918252,
1.0224163532,
0.4961312115,
-0.9354966879,
-0.2112604082,
-0.5108914971,
0.1217518598,
0.508508563,
-0.0130424667,
0.7282361984,
0.1464186907,
-0.6867045164,
-0.4184159935,
-0.0624690615,
0.3329854608,
0.4188505411,
0.5566689968,
0.0524659418,
-0.6397830844,
-0.7893357873,
-0.429212749,
-0.019599963,
-0.0970665738,
0.2008897215,
-0.0011179799,
-0.0422478765,
0.752726078,
-0.5479812026,
-0.6867260337,
-0.5345528722,
0.3426050544,
0.4354130626,
0.4009503126,
0.4870500267,
-1.3771424294,
-0.766998589,
-0.3365497291,
-1.0386244059,
0.3943077028,
-0.4408181608,
-0.1688447744,
0.1779583097,
-0.0003987886,
-0.602978766,
0.848364234,
0.6974737048,
0.1794102788,
0.3146056533,
-0.1841746122,
0.2104194313,
-1.0683217049,
-0.1752467006,
0.2784840763,
-0.0883011892,
-0.7962796092,
-0.4812360406,
0.009426699,
-0.2285718769,
-0.5469745994,
0.1237997934,
-0.3008942902,
0.0734640658,
-0.1695917249,
0.1053967699,
-0.0274568126,
0.1564323753,
-0.0087337401,
0.4956722558,
0.1893673837,
-0.3463478982,
-0.0959604457,
0.5120547414,
-0.2182514369,
0.6997231245,
-0.5631620884,
-0.0703157037,
-0.3485722542,
0.4580979049,
-1.1303739548,
-0.1851251125,
0.2254885733,
-1.0769610405,
-0.0838523656,
-0.3077123165,
-0.303235352,
-0.321051985,
-0.306553632,
0.4504492879,
0.5142477751,
-0.0273004696,
0.7320491076,
0.2607208192,
0.0752206668,
-0.2130300403,
-0.9546367526,
0.2054470181,
-0.3214170039,
-0.7209485769,
0.1281534135,
-0.0252179187,
0.0357907116,
0.0739819109,
0.3318598568,
-0.3200728595,
0.0934491605,
0.2311236858,
0.2386122793,
-0.0561248586,
0.2634797692,
0.024266405,
-0.2836065888,
0.0576395318,
-0.0489323176,
0.7200313807,
0.2732938528,
-0.1832124144,
-1.3298604488,
0.4901925623,
0.4942614436,
-0.2727982998,
0.9467968941,
0.8406730294,
-0.4121233523,
-0.2773600817,
-0.285771966,
0.0763658732,
-0.3550097346,
-0.0630575046,
0.1003188118,
-0.3764658868,
0.4248620868,
0.0387207232,
-0.1653207242,
0.1487407386,
0.4023992419,
-0.5937846899,
1.165927887,
0.4274957478,
-0.1940029562,
0.7863531113,
-0.3830347657,
0.6929138899,
-0.9832891822,
0.1780424267,
-0.2028235644,
-0.5872845054,
-0.3671312332,
-0.251008451,
0.9347590804,
0.2006427348,
-0.1201344281,
0.3493459523,
-0.8214275241,
0.282730639,
0.3840026259,
0.89042449,
0.3442643583,
-0.1689595729,
0.8032822013,
-0.318456471,
-0.4079485536,
-0.562253952,
1.1348236799,
-0.0472341254,
0.4727349281,
0.3024034202,
0.8524183035,
0.5683133006,
0.3576648831,
-0.6377984285,
0.3354404271,
-0.6465036273,
-0.5061696768,
-0.4727118611,
-0.2837183177,
-0.6769809127,
-0.5202451944,
-0.2866916955,
-0.4421904683,
-0.0478393249,
0.1709261537,
-0.5401619077,
0.1545498222,
-0.5359824896,
1.0394501686,
-0.4888480604,
0.1606444269,
-0.5098009109,
-0.4559633434,
0.4825567007,
0.0500837006,
0.0652696267,
-0.3612676859,
0.3435507715,
0.4137540758,
-0.2763769627,
0.7212008238,
-0.354419142,
0.1785928905,
0.3656315804,
0.1131160408,
0.7263157368,
0.3032513857,
-0.390966177,
0.2907125354,
-0.6391732097,
-0.3310064375,
-0.718678236,
0.6414318085,
-0.4689359367,
-0.116331093,
-0.1416315287,
-0.3526334465,
0.0533659719,
0.2425961792,
0.4285731912,
0.38278687,
-0.5470355153,
0.0072087222,
0.6575008035,
-0.2381840795,
0.3149551153,
0.2924807966,
-0.0042360188,
-0.4491502345,
0.9366258383,
0.1918898076,
0.2216773182,
0.1953522265,
0.2820462883,
-0.1336553246,
-0.8634909987,
-0.5149695873,
0.1509074718,
-0.4737489223,
-0.415795058,
-0.7220386267,
-0.3190498948,
-0.1673970819,
-0.2939116061,
-0.2131980211,
-0.2628164589,
-0.6717486382,
-0.0003630784,
0.8124039769,
0.7091305256,
-0.1650239527,
0.1060810462,
-1.0943747759,
0.3634033799,
0.0042987098,
-0.0937488675,
-0.0329108462,
-0.1055594683,
0.0009543696,
0.2943170667,
-0.0949470922,
-0.8677434325,
0.2612990439,
0.3615165651,
0.1459961981,
0.61093086,
0.4736721814,
0.7509719133,
-0.1683080494,
0.866669178,
0.1742452979,
-0.7277143598,
1.0520814657,
-0.663472116,
0.1520358324,
0.8061406016,
0.8683158755,
-0.7951063514,
-0.656845808,
-0.6259048581,
-0.5013511777,
0.3357152641,
0.4886502922,
0.1700812578,
-0.144951269,
0.3504060507,
-0.0530049317,
-0.0659147575,
-0.6275994778,
-0.1837443262,
-0.0599986576,
-0.8828995824,
0.2005099654,
-0.180095166,
-0.1080459207,
-0.1379141957,
0.559150517,
0.0825716257,
0.482357353,
0.3990195394,
0.0218525343,
-0.008640253,
-0.1445793211,
0.6542524695,
0.3165935874,
-0.1519542783,
-0.074197866,
0.0507706068,
-0.2762450576,
0.077871047,
-0.0807963163,
-0.5613669157,
0.2454001009,
0.4333018363,
0.2304221094,
0.1010721251,
-0.5989049077,
0.8696838617,
-0.5781957507,
0.1789648533,
-0.8106553555,
0.1526010931,
0.087009795,
0.334577471,
0.2256715894,
0.4317250848,
0.4089312553,
-0.4191891253,
0.3417039812,
0.6138667464,
-0.3970413506,
-0.3830564916,
0.5730513334,
-0.0378067791,
-0.8121091723,
0.5480599999,
-0.3830496371,
-0.638181448,
0.5186977386,
0.0951432511,
1.0711730719,
-0.0373370275,
0.8180760145,
0.521933794,
-0.0263970457,
0.0419518128,
0.6298823953,
-0.2417335957,
-0.5812216997,
-0.145015344,
-0.7194421887,
-0.119005248,
0.0650587827,
-0.9560644627,
0.3322459757,
-0.6908426881,
-0.2676135004,
0.1838184297,
-0.2538121343,
-0.4717882872,
0.3989956677,
0.0370409973,
0.7406867146,
-0.9185919166,
0.6804746389,
0.2855070531,
-0.6575354338,
-0.6766027212,
0.532662034,
0.255982697,
-0.5794145465,
0.5358714461,
0.2463882267,
-0.067340605,
-0.0456181243,
-0.4580462575,
-0.818061769,
0.7362155318,
-0.0596766286,
-0.1695668697,
0.2079714686,
0.1445368379,
0.8036962748,
-0.2383309305,
0.0838231295,
0.2040070146,
0.707403183,
-0.2423872799,
-0.3210319579,
-0.1312947869,
0.07059066,
-0.0249734968,
0.3700074852,
-0.9957572818,
0.7228532434,
-0.0563799106,
-0.4008615911,
0.0659970343,
0.6382538676,
-0.0429557227,
0.4667470753,
0.486277312,
0.8335118294,
0.6733958721,
0.0599347167,
0.8944292665,
-0.0921666324,
0.5261923075,
0.9227737784,
0.018567007,
1.1530301571,
0.1112949774,
-0.1438641995,
0.6052341461,
0.660918653,
0.0136946542,
0.6664919853,
-0.2532488406,
-0.5727180839,
-0.5064203143,
-0.0513027981,
0.1888399571,
0.4749194384,
0.3180783391,
-0.483332783,
-0.4262987077,
0.5624398589,
0.3295477629,
0.187531054,
0.0024509812,
1.0483953953,
-0.1158751324,
-0.4905221164,
0.4200074971,
-0.2869806588,
0.4236664176,
-0.3517403305,
-0.0894127637,
0.0811059028,
0.3207648993,
-0.3979794085,
-1.0990101099,
0.7999534011,
0.3841312826,
-0.4953314662,
-0.4127232134,
0.7371228933,
-0.3762354553,
-0.8642047048,
0.315181911,
0.0608301945,
0.3398393095,
-0.3129390478,
-0.9359415174,
0.224952817,
0.0852308273,
-0.2739412785,
0.0760507062,
0.5658999085,
0.1130791083,
0.4842903018,
0.9552149773,
0.0641884208,
-0.1079037786,
0.0023079317,
0.6966212988,
-0.4194242656,
-0.3690139949,
-0.8334346414,
0.7451645732,
-0.346170485,
-0.6666445732,
0.7735272646,
0.5019019842,
0.6753904819,
0.1066134498,
0.6816532016,
-0.2981981635,
0.7702766657,
-0.5928564072,
1.0490083694,
-0.5160146952,
-0.1560394317,
-0.1522714198,
-0.6316729188,
-0.6641587615,
0.7378673553,
-0.5689685345,
-0.0708971694,
0.4654118419,
0.6249055266,
0.0682947189,
0.0474682674,
0.118324548,
0.1204554588,
0.4191480875,
0.515616715,
0.6085757613,
-0.7384728193,
0.6189967394,
-0.1606775522,
-0.1941492707,
-0.3186397254,
-0.6967605948,
-0.9668030739,
-0.6603394747,
-0.2042951584,
-0.0788299143,
0.1532549858,
0.6428256631,
0.5473602414,
-0.6244447827,
0.4206766784,
-0.3905440867,
0.2104280442,
-0.366848141,
-0.2628713846,
0.5246697068,
-0.3248632252,
-0.5555218458,
0.3541619182,
0.2838720381,
0.0102920774,
-0.2766279578,
-0.0941195637,
-0.4669497907,
-0.1223714575,
0.4673471749,
-0.1530092657,
-0.6386828423,
-0.5935348868,
-0.2538688481,
-0.1987915337,
0.0066204295,
0.7622664571,
-0.4217647612,
0.1453750432,
0.5453445315,
0.4010599852,
0.3681989908,
0.3411147296,
0.3746317923,
-0.6768239737,
-0.0380987674,
0.5397163033,
0.0278569832,
0.350733459,
-1.0228948593,
0.1726891696,
-0.301011771,
-0.8583006859,
-0.6794726253,
0.2366785109,
-1.1470198631,
-0.4225900769,
0.8174599409,
-0.3217956722,
-0.5644523501,
-0.1182875186,
-0.3365507424,
0.3612534106,
-0.5662183762,
0.9691242576,
0.5824189782,
-0.4647276103,
-0.2283312231,
-0.6110057831,
0.866191566,
0.213406384,
-0.6197674274,
0.1627760381,
0.3706325889,
0.0994190574,
0.0474009514,
0.5298653245,
0.1426967382,
0.6552073956,
-0.5710139871,
-0.027266454,
0.0715069473,
-0.3152603209,
-0.4555978477,
0.1227782443,
-0.4554884434,
-0.3078175187
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02255v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02255v1
|
Frequency Explains the Inverse Correlation of Large Language Models' Size, Training Data Amount, and Surprisal's Fit to Reading Times
| 2024-02-03T20:22:54 | 2024-02-03T20:22:54 |
Byung-Doh Oh, Shisen Yue, William Schuler
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recent studies have shown that as Transformer-based language models become
larger and are trained on very large amounts of data, the fit of their
surprisal estimates to naturalistic human reading times degrades. The current
work presents a series of analyses showing that word frequency is a key
explanatory factor underlying these two trends. First, residual errors from
four language model families on four corpora show that the inverse correlation
between model size and fit to reading times is the strongest on the subset of
least frequent words, which is driven by excessively accurate predictions of
larger model variants. Additionally, training dynamics reveal that during later
training steps, all model variants learn to predict rare words and that larger
model variants do so more accurately, which explains the detrimental effect of
both training data amount and model size on fit to reading times. Finally, a
feature attribution analysis demonstrates that larger model variants are able
to accurately predict rare words based on both an effectively longer context
window size as well as stronger local associations compared to smaller model
variants. Taken together, these results indicate that Transformer-based
language models' surprisal estimates diverge from human-like expectations due
to the superhumanly complex associations they learn for predicting rare words.
|
[
-0.7249270082,
-0.7873328924,
0.2351781726,
-0.0049066176,
-0.290384233,
-0.1602063626,
-0.1505568027,
-0.6606125236,
0.1194256917,
0.5581373572,
-0.4442891479,
0.1381653249,
-0.5444135666,
0.2808855772,
-0.6933025122,
0.7454000711,
0.1687682718,
0.1051848754,
0.0084082056,
-0.3101970851,
-0.5180113912,
-0.6835380197,
-0.1456616074,
-0.6541061401,
0.4898088872,
0.1059449688,
1.1123665571,
0.6837658286,
0.66295892,
0.1840218455,
-0.0818617046,
-0.3165755868,
-0.6890777946,
0.0255083442,
0.144784376,
-0.640933454,
0.0332127251,
-0.0146066202,
0.6998258233,
1.2139806747,
-0.1189939305,
0.1927085072,
0.2342927009,
0.9082161784,
-0.4062704444,
0.2099482715,
-0.5340737104,
-0.3040896654,
-0.313978821,
-0.1447210461,
-0.2696254253,
-0.2287997454,
0.0678255856,
-0.5409464836,
0.5772720575,
0.4105843902,
0.9575526118,
0.2920264602,
-0.326343894,
-0.2257584482,
-0.8444624543,
0.9074124694,
-0.4139025509,
0.7259365916,
0.6411280632,
0.0125818821,
-0.1248995513,
-0.425647378,
-0.8610957861,
-0.4130257964,
-0.3148947358,
-0.1629832238,
-0.4305422902,
-0.0882692188,
0.4323470592,
0.3279298842,
-0.6267741919,
-0.0209487155,
-0.4697998762,
0.2437697798,
0.4348718524,
0.1666086465,
0.3579802215,
0.0181557275,
-0.0713171065,
-0.0898805633,
-0.8903838396,
-0.0605712719,
0.4557383955,
0.2524006367,
-0.0588861741,
0.5606341958,
-0.015793018,
0.9128726125,
-0.1598629057,
-0.0745677873,
0.4291142821,
-0.3041776121,
-0.0564629361,
0.1119508594,
0.5985965729,
0.3019807339,
0.6846351027,
-0.2570097148,
0.0074165659,
0.1043539196,
0.1492322236,
-0.5828160048,
0.0461133085,
-0.2112447619,
-0.4775159955,
-0.2017792165,
0.2081695795,
-0.6836726069,
-0.2526247799,
-0.5176711082,
0.4025656283,
-0.5352657437,
-0.0880453885,
0.3361323476,
-0.2350670397,
0.0795529261,
-0.150484845,
-0.984190464,
0.5085637569,
0.7270823121,
0.8444610238,
-0.2057414651,
-0.2948641479,
-0.3050729632,
-0.0121887289,
-0.5518695712,
0.6285185814,
-0.7870753407,
-0.4938384295,
-0.0478518046,
0.183165133,
-0.3007855415,
-0.3607772887,
0.2835356891,
-0.8026420474,
0.0994016379,
-0.3138816655,
-0.3988761902,
-0.19397901,
-0.269569993,
-0.9892230034,
1.0144677162,
0.1389047056,
-0.8738390803,
0.5072321296,
-0.2638756931,
-0.3073986173,
0.140915215,
0.0389389843,
-0.3114974499,
0.5727191567,
-0.0603753738,
0.1374613941,
-0.5089821815,
0.1375896633,
-0.5286051035,
-0.8158214688,
0.6064667106,
-0.8023988008,
0.6238226891,
0.2758010626,
-0.1843100339,
-0.4059826732,
-0.7494916916,
-0.481705755,
0.0497519299,
-0.0605320483,
-0.8316084743,
0.1986904889,
0.1550736874,
0.0646405816,
-0.0375542492,
-0.7539632916,
0.0831026509,
-0.6005263329,
0.3022506535,
0.2627616227,
0.1334735751,
0.1855326891,
-0.6426054239,
0.5485286713,
-0.1942735463,
0.0199637525,
0.0362453125,
-0.3603103459,
-0.3971191943,
-0.1693420708,
0.2153297961,
0.2977820933,
-0.3957571983,
0.2197132558,
-1.0029203892,
-0.5867732167,
-0.5602343082,
0.2083132416,
0.2553797662,
0.4661240578,
0.3744801879,
-0.2904427946,
-0.2040739954,
-0.9555604458,
-0.4004215896,
-0.1418090761,
-0.1002317667,
0.2413647324,
0.4864834547,
-0.2270468175,
1.148014307,
-0.6949871182,
-0.1869552135,
-0.5048898458,
0.1246083975,
0.3567871749,
0.1465110183,
0.7200114727,
-0.9588015079,
-0.3414748609,
-0.2514629066,
-0.1797275543,
-0.2183148265,
-0.0727404207,
0.2617118955,
0.4011042416,
0.6034519672,
-0.1663134396,
0.4477007985,
0.7515516877,
-0.2263560444,
0.3712162077,
-0.2097506225,
-0.0993872359,
-0.839025557,
0.2594453394,
0.0993685648,
0.1653791666,
-0.4868100584,
-0.1828439832,
0.0161061604,
0.0153343286,
-0.0350002125,
0.7336182594,
-0.447881639,
-0.2077777535,
-0.1837363243,
0.1088362336,
0.0484815463,
0.3068184555,
0.0059319241,
0.8792974353,
0.0371139608,
-0.5872292519,
0.223802954,
0.3429173231,
-0.6589125395,
0.0513118096,
-0.9098193645,
-0.4887015522,
-0.1935807616,
0.0855528116,
-1.327635169,
-0.1132647842,
-0.3229834139,
-0.2826389968,
0.3642044663,
0.2524954975,
-0.6638022661,
-0.4558790326,
-0.198760733,
0.3313330114,
0.5177443624,
-0.5182534456,
0.6070908904,
0.3843878806,
-0.1478662491,
-0.6262316108,
-1.0562016964,
-0.2769110501,
-0.1490343958,
-0.4383738041,
0.258204937,
-0.0295763668,
-0.5711228848,
0.0534383021,
-0.1664915979,
-0.0290517043,
0.2147576958,
0.551512897,
0.3285104334,
-0.1655015498,
0.5415478945,
-0.2459976226,
-0.1512988806,
-0.0734682158,
0.1911438555,
0.9262858629,
-0.1758913994,
-0.2907646,
-0.0595591217,
0.0858694836,
0.6158567667,
-0.2510050833,
1.2358484268,
0.3034927249,
0.0319749154,
0.1767598838,
-0.6028804183,
-0.1475044489,
-0.4345340729,
0.5486947894,
-0.543505311,
-0.5144283175,
0.5357521772,
0.4407164752,
-0.1246303618,
0.588062644,
0.4092974663,
-0.0552239008,
0.9551757574,
0.8082100153,
-0.2351353019,
0.8040252924,
-0.0200223271,
-0.0008033777,
-0.7057061195,
-0.0144375516,
-0.4845062792,
-0.1256087571,
-0.7501485348,
-0.0002918347,
0.3100989163,
0.1295682788,
-0.2414907217,
0.3938911855,
-0.2514032125,
0.4616706371,
0.5120983124,
-0.0807195753,
0.4700800478,
0.2550377548,
0.1112951562,
-0.1115926206,
-0.5518458486,
-0.3554024398,
1.024458766,
0.4084239304,
0.8455276489,
0.1101171821,
0.2041896731,
0.1368266642,
0.4956924617,
-0.8925879598,
0.2343620062,
-0.6182934046,
-0.822278738,
-0.3313502073,
-0.2239302695,
-1.122820735,
0.1276673824,
-0.158852458,
-0.5084272623,
0.3217760623,
0.1043259948,
-0.0947553962,
0.1989568621,
-0.4632786512,
0.6902948618,
0.1363155693,
-0.0327103697,
-0.369746238,
-0.6763352752,
0.406973511,
-0.6360882521,
0.448209703,
-0.1116559282,
-0.0665326193,
0.5519872904,
-0.3355118632,
0.8433161378,
0.3156141043,
-0.0500964634,
0.0994032994,
0.2063363343,
0.4378374219,
-0.2456764132,
-0.2610764205,
0.4163996577,
0.1798989326,
-0.203485027,
-0.4016533196,
0.3908366263,
-0.9144893289,
-0.3797539771,
-0.3870640993,
-0.7443703413,
-0.2928826511,
0.0034712222,
0.5308096409,
0.99108845,
-0.1865144968,
0.6715790629,
0.604306221,
-0.1580471396,
0.5296280384,
0.7793835998,
-0.2636229992,
-0.1150023565,
0.7794142365,
0.5328812003,
0.4909329116,
0.6650574207,
0.219714582,
-0.2637064755,
-0.3096925616,
0.2023798972,
0.572247088,
-0.3548999429,
0.1266295463,
-0.7479990125,
0.0414185114,
-0.3694167137,
-0.141251862,
-0.0247031674,
-0.4538368285,
-0.2089774311,
0.1092916578,
0.5562599301,
0.6224200726,
0.1550943702,
0.8689193726,
-0.6383247375,
0.3723613918,
0.2028978616,
0.4974515736,
-0.1042909101,
-1.0465810299,
-0.0964422971,
-0.0676319152,
0.2194975317,
-0.8423961997,
0.5439714193,
0.390217185,
0.5431302786,
0.3624803722,
-0.0674637184,
0.4488098323,
-0.5372107029,
0.7197007537,
0.0594419502,
-0.8725327849,
-0.1056097373,
-0.3060244322,
0.2037654817,
0.5175929666,
0.5429991484,
-1.0647935867,
-0.2771321237,
-0.6981967688,
-0.7986729741,
0.7843050957,
-0.1509499997,
0.3964653015,
-0.0862948075,
0.3684132695,
0.2827439904,
0.1099949479,
-0.4768813252,
-0.4804714918,
-0.2672171295,
-0.3513776064,
-0.616648972,
-0.5474278331,
0.0640848875,
-0.101755321,
0.6745250821,
-0.1347047836,
0.0693381205,
-0.1442456245,
-0.3063169122,
-0.2760746181,
0.2294213772,
0.8665519357,
0.7035176754,
-0.3684715033,
0.0970230475,
0.4071789086,
-0.9319587946,
-0.1200592667,
0.099451296,
0.0732389763,
0.15724805,
0.724742651,
0.7872495055,
0.3245128989,
-0.6326073408,
0.5988270044,
-0.0241327286,
0.0852072909,
-0.5383467078,
0.1598658413,
0.1898622513,
-0.1836678833,
0.5060579777,
-0.0156489406,
-0.1630121917,
-0.5075443387,
0.2572387159,
0.3707431257,
-0.5984738469,
-0.4357072711,
0.5236160159,
-0.098184593,
0.0172973927,
0.5543982983,
0.1518910527,
-0.357100904,
0.7393962145,
0.577016592,
0.6179689765,
-0.1782978922,
-0.0214171335,
0.2988747358,
0.4188365042,
-0.3858108222,
0.0774496943,
0.2997696102,
-0.796902895,
-0.3129374385,
-1.0071569681,
0.049795799,
0.3075107634,
-0.7355080247,
0.2861724198,
0.0085038226,
-0.0509165935,
0.1677465886,
0.1284986883,
-0.6047881246,
0.1257565469,
0.0119469259,
0.8785862923,
-1.1067610979,
0.9121283889,
0.3785667419,
-0.6795402765,
-0.9054925442,
0.0785345435,
-0.0116978781,
-0.9544026852,
1.1906132698,
0.0692966431,
-0.1862054318,
0.2239739299,
-0.4247292876,
-1.213796854,
0.7513067722,
0.2031022459,
-0.9177376032,
-0.0742647201,
0.304025501,
0.8711002469,
-0.2732945085,
0.2680347264,
0.6278008819,
0.2405726314,
0.05784408,
-0.9252289534,
-0.083126761,
0.0622770824,
0.2763257623,
0.6014711857,
-0.5527485609,
0.823435843,
-0.118745327,
-0.2578599155,
0.006157795,
0.451805979,
-0.0665147677,
-0.0869510174,
0.5345942974,
0.2722707689,
0.2620902956,
-0.0091148159,
1.4760012627,
-0.7936344147,
0.4431877732,
0.8787793517,
-0.0331290141,
0.9360337257,
0.4605929255,
-0.3968158364,
0.3573111594,
0.3809197545,
-0.403067857,
0.3099335432,
0.0234843213,
0.0006845522,
-0.3436391652,
-0.2014889419,
-0.4559878409,
0.4379140139,
0.4882663786,
-0.5986972451,
-0.1131473258,
0.1567745209,
-0.1023886949,
0.0139425825,
-0.1741322577,
0.4632622898,
0.1795449704,
-0.4452265799,
0.6316771507,
-0.2484026253,
0.6256528497,
-0.6911169291,
0.3280306458,
-0.2670356929,
0.3392949402,
0.0235238057,
-0.8195290565,
0.3641270399,
-0.3801663518,
-0.3761450052,
0.1002569348,
0.4876745939,
-0.4828038514,
-0.4997607172,
0.1527624875,
0.3667941391,
0.0895312876,
-0.0686219111,
-0.4803631604,
0.0698572919,
-0.1401429921,
-0.5791112781,
0.1918102503,
0.1530610174,
-0.2442473024,
0.8048588634,
0.4685435295,
0.2829061151,
-0.0033474709,
0.0611838475,
0.5250723958,
-0.5774965882,
-0.2199522108,
-0.8522829413,
-0.0740600973,
0.2270973027,
-0.3786194623,
0.5905309916,
0.5419140458,
0.589948535,
-0.2015324831,
0.5017131567,
0.1516005546,
0.7013894916,
-0.2375626564,
0.7289773226,
-0.6124937534,
0.359008491,
-0.1869900078,
-1.1481204033,
-0.2450879365,
0.3649474978,
-0.7192953229,
-0.0199789889,
0.6556475759,
0.7122188807,
-0.1085248664,
0.1682567745,
0.4345144033,
0.2789340019,
0.2050021887,
0.1466071159,
0.4710469842,
-0.4305905998,
0.6568368673,
-0.1992087811,
-0.0873508304,
-0.5046311617,
-0.5560292006,
-0.7567586899,
-0.7772355676,
-0.124271363,
-0.2269962579,
-0.1016302109,
0.9352036715,
0.1248267516,
-0.7019640803,
-0.1208701804,
-0.1243637279,
-0.2344757468,
-0.2868895829,
-0.3253743351,
0.4982334971,
-0.2206918895,
-0.6012629271,
-0.1222778633,
-0.0347781144,
0.2568306923,
0.0603221096,
0.3363130093,
-0.0345357545,
0.3285713196,
0.3059192896,
0.4893083274,
-0.6082780957,
-0.2297560424,
0.0498413667,
-0.5212352872,
-0.0896672681,
0.6349532604,
-0.9149244428,
0.3021388352,
0.6297712326,
0.3387782276,
0.42655918,
0.1122414097,
0.5960335732,
-0.6225909591,
0.1820424497,
-0.1681368351,
0.3450395167,
0.1218986064,
-0.1990993172,
0.6190280318,
0.4674809277,
-0.3237749636,
-0.9509442449,
0.2358678579,
-0.6588510275,
-0.5555999279,
1.2496112585,
0.2648766041,
-0.3819054961,
-0.3551637828,
-0.0190496519,
0.2939427495,
-0.0515327975,
0.798486948,
1.0551253557,
-0.1969778538,
0.0653283298,
-0.8324494362,
0.5613088012,
0.4962290525,
-0.3458359241,
0.4317550957,
0.4069395065,
0.5267038941,
0.4855852425,
0.0748225749,
-0.1600867361,
-0.0143048782,
0.213912636,
-0.0635873377,
-0.1945368201,
-0.1579928249,
-0.5706329942,
0.2441151142,
-0.0777484775,
0.179358989
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02244v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02244v3
|
Beyond the Limits: A Survey of Techniques to Extend the Context Length in Large Language Models
| 2024-02-03T19:20:02 | 2024-05-29T13:38:25 |
Xindi Wang, Mahsa Salmani, Parsa Omidi, Xiangyu Ren, Mehdi Rezagholizadeh, Armaghan Eshaghi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recently, large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable capabilities
including understanding context, engaging in logical reasoning, and generating
responses. However, this is achieved at the expense of stringent computational
and memory requirements, hindering their ability to effectively support long
input sequences. This survey provides an inclusive review of the recent
techniques and methods devised to extend the sequence length in LLMs, thereby
enhancing their capacity for long-context understanding. In particular, we
review and categorize a wide range of techniques including architectural
modifications, such as modified positional encoding and altered attention
mechanisms, which are designed to enhance the processing of longer sequences
while avoiding a proportional increase in computational requirements. The
diverse methodologies investigated in this study can be leveraged across
different phases of LLMs, i.e., training, fine-tuning and inference. This
enables LLMs to efficiently process extended sequences. The limitations of the
current methodologies is discussed in the last section along with the
suggestions for future research directions, underscoring the importance of
sequence length in the continued advancement of LLMs.
|
[
-0.7334009409,
-0.7890295982,
0.937640667,
0.0270101465,
-0.2063956857,
-0.0755462646,
-0.6726796031,
-0.6548203826,
-0.0053288382,
0.6118596792,
-0.4747698605,
-0.2587573826,
-0.5572507977,
0.1558166742,
-0.3054427803,
0.6409060359,
-0.1192125082,
-0.1865577251,
-0.2469120622,
-0.1831105351,
-0.5706620812,
-0.5280223489,
-0.4119048417,
-0.0950354561,
0.6103550792,
0.4569739699,
0.5817704797,
0.5773131251,
0.3416024446,
0.2506718338,
-0.3412681818,
0.280353725,
-0.4017009139,
0.2874428332,
-0.1333527565,
-0.3436166644,
-0.4692625701,
-0.3677703142,
1.1184538603,
0.9459921122,
0.2678284645,
0.145077467,
0.0264861416,
0.6839434505,
-0.797971487,
-0.0989716202,
-0.2560726106,
0.081089966,
-0.284930557,
-0.2872952521,
-0.4530685246,
-0.0286435783,
0.3459732533,
-0.2263231277,
-0.2877164781,
-0.1886510253,
0.1580616832,
0.0137109794,
-0.5742913485,
-0.2794437408,
-0.9061624408,
1.052467227,
-0.8531144857,
0.7508999705,
0.3065310717,
0.1989757419,
-0.2878192663,
-0.5137932301,
-0.3965331912,
-0.3937907815,
0.0247173775,
-0.3701827228,
0.1101838648,
0.1431365758,
0.605925858,
0.2022169232,
-0.4799462259,
0.2520608008,
-0.5612099171,
0.1314606071,
0.616918087,
0.1774023473,
0.1858842671,
0.1354976892,
-0.159166351,
-0.0379150584,
-0.954271853,
0.0195025634,
0.0167738385,
-0.0039029766,
0.1633632481,
0.5893791914,
-0.2881781459,
0.9905463457,
-0.2960048616,
-0.0575042516,
0.0307746381,
-0.2577450871,
-0.3983131945,
-0.1829933375,
0.278865248,
0.2188707888,
0.0409461781,
-0.026259426,
-0.0888870284,
-0.3532967567,
-0.0182965156,
-0.6218689084,
0.3976148367,
0.2683824897,
-0.3335959017,
0.226392433,
-0.1362444907,
-0.7460840344,
-0.3940684497,
-0.57229954,
-0.0423229337,
-0.662366271,
-0.1078785062,
0.0894444585,
-0.0481869802,
0.5467703938,
0.1426401138,
-0.8692113161,
0.3244996369,
0.9143244624,
0.9118942022,
-0.0882039145,
-0.2837052941,
-0.4439100027,
0.2364245206,
-0.3180057108,
0.5200173259,
-0.7798826694,
-0.4329410195,
0.0817508474,
-0.0763208866,
0.187131837,
-0.3882247806,
0.5129511356,
-0.9301803708,
0.0388668776,
-0.4464585781,
-0.8170014024,
-0.3148499429,
0.0564015768,
-0.5960747004,
0.708524406,
-0.0139786173,
-0.3435053825,
0.2253794521,
-0.8949227333,
-0.8268030286,
-0.0092864046,
-0.0942977965,
0.0442604497,
0.5801824331,
0.3165804148,
0.6384987235,
-0.3801439404,
0.3816013932,
-0.4342104793,
-0.4031252265,
0.384904474,
-0.5252283216,
0.5932903886,
0.2689442933,
-0.1694307476,
0.3638584614,
-0.8524934053,
0.0304990988,
-0.0185299087,
-0.2739245594,
-0.2970130444,
0.1100867987,
-0.1051047668,
0.2515276074,
0.2490337044,
-0.3465969861,
0.0829564705,
-0.5935007334,
0.7587654591,
0.6406848431,
-0.2877257764,
0.6734008789,
-0.2818384767,
0.7046805024,
-0.4642436802,
0.0942313522,
-0.5587913394,
0.0095638987,
-0.7223818302,
-0.1457914412,
0.0134780332,
0.4508381486,
-0.4705643952,
0.5652849674,
-0.6246238351,
-0.1753962636,
-0.0673973039,
0.1961006671,
0.1689397097,
0.1560783237,
0.4746177495,
-0.4010430276,
-0.9023247361,
-0.6372541785,
-0.1139826626,
0.1582136452,
-0.159351334,
0.4730866253,
0.4923462868,
-0.2924024761,
1.0844708681,
-0.5512017608,
0.190256387,
-0.4000641108,
-0.4252815843,
0.2967594266,
0.3256735802,
0.3159094155,
-0.5730913281,
-0.1009396538,
-0.0914265737,
-0.4160475135,
0.0062374342,
-0.1068206802,
0.3216154575,
0.3418513238,
0.7964579463,
-0.7775660753,
0.3269768357,
0.6177824736,
-0.1220040396,
0.4671646655,
-0.106628269,
-0.0472251922,
-0.8766850233,
0.0107408389,
-0.0809102356,
-0.3689146638,
-0.6624740362,
0.5088105202,
0.0480904244,
-0.0765358731,
-0.3895138204,
0.9013982415,
-0.9430986643,
-0.3236027658,
-0.5575012565,
0.1500150859,
0.0001978004,
0.1547839493,
0.1889027506,
0.6223205924,
0.5273275971,
-0.6348087788,
0.6275271773,
0.0127161667,
-0.625734508,
0.224888742,
-0.4475503564,
0.154453069,
-0.341796726,
0.6432734132,
-1.0676417351,
-0.2723343968,
0.0900858194,
-0.2673621178,
0.5455648303,
0.0091877226,
-0.398182869,
-0.4422221184,
-0.448897332,
0.727201283,
0.6291469932,
-0.525406301,
0.4685069025,
0.195952639,
-0.2567791343,
-0.5327805877,
-0.7737944126,
0.4572948217,
-0.5891320109,
-0.7176010609,
0.2667241096,
-0.1700303555,
-0.4205518067,
-0.4754572213,
0.0596207455,
0.0534183607,
-0.0272556357,
-0.0122716762,
0.0525139496,
-0.352604419,
0.295843631,
0.1499161422,
0.2866220772,
0.0498397984,
-0.394849658,
0.7434949279,
-0.0194921009,
-0.1954410225,
-0.1514788121,
0.5483227968,
0.6062663794,
-0.2533927262,
0.8398483396,
0.3629754484,
-0.2996570468,
-0.297524184,
-0.7027162313,
-0.2664033473,
-0.4673651457,
0.5780080557,
-0.4763471484,
-1.45484519,
0.4612717927,
-0.2526113391,
-0.123204425,
0.0856218785,
0.5393979549,
0.1962543875,
0.700519979,
0.7519475222,
-0.2108880877,
0.6497392058,
0.0849680528,
0.2926255763,
-1.3472714424,
0.019722769,
-0.086271897,
-0.1196811348,
-0.3533695936,
-0.8903544545,
0.1956587136,
0.0849697292,
-0.078260459,
0.4607313573,
-0.0259824898,
0.6174955368,
0.0338496007,
0.0425867252,
0.0792668536,
-0.140459612,
0.0993284658,
0.1874702722,
-0.6887831688,
-0.2791526318,
0.9815084338,
0.6904686093,
0.5292603374,
0.2808956504,
0.3689386547,
0.0125728697,
0.2484606951,
-0.8432247639,
0.7371267676,
0.0872570276,
-0.5623338819,
-0.898853004,
-0.1726901233,
-0.8130348921,
0.199462831,
0.262445122,
-0.8795785904,
0.1536498666,
-0.0543237105,
-0.518532753,
0.2513669729,
-0.2134399861,
0.4456845522,
-0.2757782638,
-0.454007566,
-0.3781967163,
-0.8370965123,
0.4763644636,
-0.1264685094,
0.2197547853,
0.0462200083,
-0.3613015711,
0.37166816,
-0.3777564168,
0.8655419946,
0.2131043077,
-0.7238243222,
0.2961230576,
-0.1400688142,
0.4771416187,
0.079438664,
-0.1481633335,
-0.0148722259,
-0.070856899,
-0.3822439313,
-0.4119068086,
0.9074600339,
-0.2197422981,
-0.7727732062,
-0.1127368212,
-0.7924736738,
-0.4851706922,
0.2161653489,
0.0472196192,
0.4454752505,
-0.1848026961,
0.4701908529,
0.8015238047,
-0.5772483945,
0.6736680865,
0.2858044505,
-0.1774953008,
-0.3033859432,
0.4127627611,
0.0886658654,
0.3600182235,
0.6413302422,
0.1545149535,
-0.4966638386,
-0.7066146731,
-0.1972646266,
0.0582842343,
-0.8561634421,
0.0461049154,
-0.4922548234,
-0.1783895791,
-0.9146812558,
-0.1347423643,
-0.0534058772,
-0.4359996021,
-0.2793224156,
-0.2224421799,
0.4371411204,
0.3911892176,
-0.0106480885,
0.3831762075,
-1.0113719702,
0.0470970124,
0.1741778255,
0.4861158133,
0.3251892924,
-0.7353523374,
-0.1808427274,
-0.1813257188,
0.009719057,
-0.7111979723,
0.4407852888,
0.1913609952,
0.2747883201,
0.2755289376,
-0.2123119682,
1.0048972368,
-0.8505685329,
0.6381416321,
-0.0042049037,
-0.9646215439,
0.3805986941,
-0.4635060132,
0.6444995403,
0.2264007628,
0.4644243717,
-0.6697730422,
0.0954431519,
-0.137828052,
-0.9545708895,
0.4146731198,
-0.0760261044,
0.578764081,
-0.0014770696,
0.6295375824,
-0.0022432313,
-0.0666446388,
-0.4345682561,
0.1494441926,
0.4330615997,
0.0233425703,
-0.3673518896,
-0.4669656157,
-0.0161084179,
-0.4314555228,
0.4579493403,
-0.2151564956,
-0.0046581901,
0.1615188271,
-0.2446601987,
0.0554103404,
0.6327009201,
1.0730916262,
1.3118323088,
0.0463286228,
-0.082302846,
0.6594125032,
0.0789749771,
-0.120966129,
0.1158717573,
0.2705007493,
-0.3313437998,
0.5556916595,
0.9184317589,
0.1113367826,
-1.0717386007,
0.3048678041,
0.178810671,
0.1931825131,
-0.596487999,
0.0346306041,
0.0849540606,
0.4554891288,
0.1349462122,
-0.4963289797,
0.3393502831,
-0.8011373878,
0.2750819027,
0.4926255047,
-0.3876304924,
-0.2018892318,
0.2333730459,
-0.02229633,
-0.1817664951,
0.4776325822,
0.3215999901,
-0.2173379362,
0.5634115934,
0.624114573,
0.7028888464,
-0.2875850797,
-0.2552373409,
0.1446448863,
0.084963955,
-0.1659153849,
0.1415662915,
-0.4973250329,
-0.6494104862,
-0.9588452578,
-0.5663356781,
-0.1915108711,
0.4457184076,
-0.4396037459,
0.2448209524,
-0.5277445316,
-0.2064304948,
-0.2275713682,
-0.1538887471,
-0.3343051076,
0.1672493219,
0.5952022672,
1.12992239,
-0.4015810192,
0.8182896972,
0.5264943242,
0.155261755,
-0.3446657956,
-0.0728539973,
-0.1009538323,
-0.5929710865,
0.5279609561,
0.2831629813,
-0.2042889893,
-0.225158155,
-0.5986440778,
-1.0490059853,
0.8854935765,
0.0530736931,
-0.8707017899,
-0.0438994244,
0.2535335124,
0.625127852,
-0.2088494599,
0.1391515136,
0.95383811,
0.4184464216,
0.0814915746,
-0.8336379528,
0.2783450782,
0.0439274684,
0.3390338421,
0.3518108428,
-0.5840077996,
0.524400115,
-0.2757942677,
-0.0230517257,
0.6204565763,
0.7308236957,
0.3744118214,
-0.0144822039,
0.3569197655,
0.4542293549,
0.3878913224,
0.3125540912,
1.0790449381,
-0.2417621017,
0.1960437149,
1.2627952099,
-0.5128195286,
0.8393353224,
0.6033790708,
-0.0520256944,
0.2752860487,
0.5539091825,
0.1009665504,
0.1125989705,
0.5918335319,
-0.3238695562,
-0.1997860819,
-0.0805961415,
-0.3493481278,
0.2499773055,
0.7016373873,
-0.532769084,
0.0223929286,
0.3146621287,
-0.0588141307,
-0.0472049788,
-0.2401086986,
0.6770285368,
0.3890656829,
-0.8488855958,
0.6176492572,
0.1994339079,
0.7244483829,
-0.3978009522,
0.0001689293,
-0.1206982061,
0.1511470973,
-0.0313563496,
-0.9406574368,
0.2437629998,
-0.1459413171,
-0.1566618681,
-0.3378578722,
0.7681976557,
-0.3137870729,
-0.3125506341,
0.387940824,
0.2593991756,
-0.110223867,
0.028709719,
-0.2967635095,
0.4160711467,
-0.3290551007,
-0.3995344937,
0.2205793858,
0.3122069538,
-0.3061433733,
0.6959298849,
0.5380243063,
0.084441416,
0.1609090716,
0.0895544887,
0.891551733,
-0.9051221013,
-0.3285825253,
-1.2210757732,
0.1470018923,
0.0071909097,
-0.129645884,
0.7789718509,
0.4105526507,
0.9364139438,
-0.0674528107,
0.7026420832,
0.0617208481,
0.2875266969,
-0.610016346,
0.1232673749,
-0.5284876823,
0.3192318678,
-0.1671162695,
-0.9535790682,
-0.5951087475,
0.398793757,
-0.6701003313,
0.1202580333,
0.4337852895,
0.4862766564,
-0.0419781394,
-0.044608064,
0.3609336019,
0.238105908,
0.4020999968,
0.8180254102,
1.0714651346,
-0.0750180334,
0.2146961242,
0.0851406679,
-0.1733337492,
-0.1811528653,
-0.8918776512,
-0.9832755327,
-0.3772006631,
0.1062494889,
0.0137538705,
0.0295438394,
0.8036950231,
0.887380302,
-0.6773914695,
-0.3175536096,
-0.031165069,
-0.0359084122,
0.1373659968,
-0.1867841482,
0.2936822474,
-0.3438079655,
-0.6778379679,
0.728935957,
0.5099807978,
-0.1021636948,
-0.3193968832,
-0.0341114737,
-0.2027059048,
0.2662555575,
1.1859002113,
0.5981087685,
-0.7552319765,
-0.473413229,
0.0585277416,
0.346706599,
0.1084044427,
0.9763138294,
-0.547801137,
0.1531579942,
0.9323865175,
0.8697855473,
0.2146620154,
-0.0893482342,
0.8460963368,
-0.6790757179,
0.1697026193,
0.306602478,
0.4603773057,
0.286995858,
-0.3331376016,
0.2787343264,
-0.2452406585,
-0.4317755699,
-0.8209109902,
0.6144521236,
-0.7403027415,
-0.7963882685,
1.3312638998,
0.0236235969,
-0.1660182625,
0.1450895369,
-0.1090016291,
0.1509390622,
-0.0017021598,
0.4818938971,
0.8839559555,
-0.3604882061,
-0.3939528465,
-0.5765350461,
0.3896507919,
0.5640307069,
-0.8343769312,
0.2164489329,
0.6865198612,
0.2600595057,
0.0388993509,
0.3879484534,
-0.2755436599,
0.1144976318,
-0.7080046535,
-0.5255319476,
0.2975146174,
-0.6482051611,
-0.7913954854,
0.0017302415,
0.0535172708,
0.4126229882
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02243v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02243v1
|
Language Writ Large: LLMs, ChatGPT, Grounding, Meaning and Understanding
| 2024-02-03T19:19:34 | 2024-02-03T19:19:34 |
Stevan Harnad
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, q-bio.NC
|
Apart from what (little) OpenAI may be concealing from us, we all know
(roughly) how ChatGPT works (its huge text database, its statistics, its vector
representations, and their huge number of parameters, its next-word training,
and so on). But none of us can say (hand on heart) that we are not surprised by
what ChatGPT has proved to be able to do with these resources. This has even
driven some of us to conclude that ChatGPT actually understands. It is not true
that it understands. But it is also not true that we understand how it can do
what it can do. I will suggest some hunches about benign biases: convergent
constraints that emerge at LLM scale that may be helping ChatGPT do so much
better than we would have expected. These biases are inherent in the nature of
language itself, at LLM scale, and they are closely linked to what it is that
ChatGPT lacks, which is direct sensorimotor grounding to connect its words to
their referents and its propositions to their meanings. These convergent biases
are related to (1) the parasitism of indirect verbal grounding on direct
sensorimotor grounding, (2) the circularity of verbal definition, (3) the
mirroring of language production and comprehension, (4) iconicity in
propositions at LLM scale, (5) computational counterparts of human categorical
perception in category learning by neural nets, and perhaps also (6) a
conjecture by Chomsky about the laws of thought. The exposition will be in the
form of a dialogue with ChatGPT-4.
|
[
-0.5111086369,
-0.7092673779,
0.568836987,
0.2986901104,
-0.3430320919,
0.0989272222,
-0.469098419,
-0.2928385735,
0.1340418309,
0.4299168885,
-0.3364530802,
-0.0469766296,
-0.9415159225,
-0.2684080601,
-0.3098658323,
1.0712052584,
-0.0474493131,
0.1195609272,
-0.1234489977,
-0.2714787722,
-0.5349993706,
-0.573872447,
-0.7327210307,
-0.8081458211,
0.3280771971,
0.2288850993,
0.7357410192,
0.5859811306,
0.3601141274,
0.2635673583,
-0.3835429847,
-0.2311991304,
-0.7494240403,
0.0029161328,
-0.1424865872,
-1.0094704628,
-0.0824378654,
0.2403591126,
0.7408393025,
1.0214575529,
0.0334534273,
-0.2135009319,
0.2333536297,
0.9290311337,
-0.370747894,
0.2199591696,
-0.5629681349,
0.1976552308,
-0.1970717907,
-0.2154552937,
-0.1275551915,
-0.1493798941,
0.0610112287,
-0.3921123147,
0.2099316865,
0.0800810307,
1.0323414803,
0.5449064374,
-0.5146128535,
-0.2993192971,
-0.5052998066,
0.7373099327,
-0.3215652704,
0.5286034346,
0.510407865,
0.123042278,
-0.1392035633,
-0.5827642679,
-0.4507856071,
-0.5199906826,
0.0635810196,
0.3692114949,
-0.0769261047,
0.2560220361,
0.4470883608,
0.8519915938,
-0.3547737002,
-0.0811168998,
-0.4212183654,
-0.1472683847,
0.080380328,
0.0082580838,
0.4525872469,
-0.0102699408,
-0.2692455053,
0.2924895287,
-0.9463818073,
-0.25564605,
0.2417853028,
-0.0849491879,
-0.1543653309,
0.6629692316,
-0.1404954791,
0.5481529236,
0.0373310633,
0.0583901294,
-0.0862624124,
-0.1556929648,
-0.146654129,
-0.1115679219,
0.6747954488,
0.2337815166,
0.6182035804,
-0.3373320401,
0.084931314,
0.5126916766,
0.0986631215,
-0.4519484341,
-0.1348406076,
0.0299918521,
-0.302259922,
-0.1842202991,
-0.0076754503,
-0.3194176257,
-0.7173317671,
-0.6142732501,
-0.0597741827,
-0.3949888349,
-0.2483334392,
0.14575468,
-0.0268535279,
0.6583478451,
0.2461782694,
-1.0455158949,
0.5130001307,
0.8067038655,
0.789755106,
-0.1316854656,
-0.3193917572,
-0.0051968368,
0.0102106873,
-0.3410540223,
0.7340971231,
-0.2739192247,
-0.2285529673,
-0.1126780435,
-0.0660339147,
-0.0629484057,
-0.3541637957,
0.7144210935,
-0.3193123043,
0.1780035794,
-0.5728153586,
-0.3986167014,
-0.3036355376,
0.4272526503,
-0.3585838675,
0.8940250874,
-0.2634337842,
-0.9279211164,
0.2184038758,
-0.4184821248,
-0.4397254586,
0.1153027862,
-0.5305773616,
0.2958259881,
0.3015910685,
-0.0724636018,
0.3254357278,
-0.4882086813,
0.40074265,
-0.0200461708,
-0.3267925978,
0.2957281768,
-0.6003738046,
0.7151687741,
0.2134330571,
-0.5241757631,
-0.2497960478,
-0.5301226974,
-0.1557957381,
0.1511662155,
-0.3429804146,
0.0376918539,
0.1772429794,
-0.2228822112,
0.0681243911,
0.3177833557,
-0.3370175362,
0.0028434664,
-0.5378560424,
0.8825081587,
0.7196386456,
-0.1883085668,
0.632871747,
-0.3375793993,
0.438875407,
-0.025549937,
-0.1604097635,
-0.2242456228,
-0.5632927418,
-1.2008628845,
0.0488536246,
0.0342519805,
0.7143182755,
-0.3030439913,
0.3693507612,
-0.1370333284,
-0.1451621801,
-0.3245013058,
-0.0377229936,
0.1738039553,
0.3849137127,
0.006652473,
-0.5606349707,
-0.4555920064,
-0.9889596105,
-0.2620007098,
-0.2708314955,
-0.2227437198,
0.3361145854,
0.2140814066,
-0.1972506642,
0.7311150432,
-0.5473576188,
-0.3244985938,
-0.0889308751,
0.0325274952,
0.2146144211,
0.092296727,
0.1778333932,
-0.6785119176,
-0.189679414,
0.2002121806,
-0.9008600712,
-0.2661976814,
-0.0546836443,
-0.0386355035,
-0.2420452088,
0.6543727517,
-0.7499771118,
0.1216094643,
0.3740724325,
-0.1592714339,
0.2640721202,
-0.1775459796,
-0.2315983623,
-0.930916369,
-0.214851886,
-0.0795453042,
-0.1180255115,
-0.7249438167,
0.1117950827,
-0.2151761949,
0.0002960685,
-0.2507756054,
0.2486377507,
-0.4892746806,
-0.1109902933,
-0.4660122395,
0.585486412,
-0.3382686079,
0.5195518732,
0.0283484068,
0.7568474412,
0.5259016752,
-0.5290139318,
0.4261118472,
-0.0678840131,
-0.1421895176,
0.5363032222,
-0.4782780111,
0.2631037533,
-0.3403323889,
0.349167645,
-0.9968346357,
-0.1695159525,
0.5484117866,
-0.508366406,
0.2385328114,
-0.0693955123,
-0.1916800141,
-0.0407545604,
-0.1393857449,
0.3549194336,
0.6662657857,
-0.3896986544,
0.3108324409,
0.6215560436,
0.1303891987,
-0.6604821682,
-0.7263401747,
0.2525177002,
-0.2563669384,
-0.512413919,
-0.1686181873,
0.08748772,
-0.6061780453,
-0.2017101496,
-0.1580002457,
-0.0327598006,
0.0655574352,
0.435880959,
-0.1641901881,
-0.3702902198,
0.1842143387,
-0.3033065498,
-0.3101097047,
0.2318210453,
-0.603361249,
0.6633189917,
-0.6727622747,
-0.4843427837,
0.0742526427,
0.006214228,
0.5746783018,
0.1113293767,
0.4758217633,
0.5404239893,
-0.2710523307,
0.1514391154,
-0.6030624509,
-0.0073510706,
-0.420971334,
0.1515704095,
-0.4036698937,
-1.0727766752,
0.4814488292,
-0.2370559722,
-0.1902931482,
0.4468132854,
0.7800684571,
-0.0569001846,
0.6194580793,
0.5376805067,
-0.3133780062,
0.5253185034,
-0.1438668966,
0.3946278095,
-0.9663482904,
-0.0097990511,
-0.4637846351,
-0.1076176539,
-0.9462994337,
-0.4777369201,
0.0472582281,
0.12696895,
-0.2729432285,
-0.0854525268,
-0.3408269584,
0.6111500859,
0.5195150375,
0.0735205114,
0.1898731589,
-0.1388416141,
-0.1175720394,
-0.2257901132,
-0.7264070511,
-0.791821301,
0.8649049401,
0.5817130804,
0.8541089296,
-0.0948186666,
0.4228919148,
-0.0311620757,
0.2704555392,
-0.9322242737,
0.5618854761,
0.127735123,
-0.5224636793,
-0.0574733615,
-0.0953383967,
-0.8795330524,
0.5591042042,
0.1170460731,
-0.7991527915,
-0.04930491,
-0.1223419607,
0.1891916245,
0.393856138,
-0.6384935975,
0.4590339363,
-0.2684903145,
-0.3494552076,
-0.1064431965,
-0.8387093544,
0.7064636946,
0.0892829821,
0.4393889606,
-0.3248004317,
-0.2634933889,
0.745955646,
-0.0957524404,
1.0459318161,
0.1170113683,
-0.3619976342,
0.3749108315,
-0.1497817338,
0.0587471277,
0.1425987929,
0.3833529055,
0.2543467283,
-0.1144062877,
-0.5918352604,
-0.4730451703,
0.5297228098,
-0.9393354654,
-0.8009116054,
-0.5417597294,
-0.3672311008,
-0.2006250173,
0.3167718351,
0.466191709,
0.1213542745,
-0.5474252701,
0.0226621293,
1.0256390572,
-0.2081558704,
0.0129232714,
0.191725716,
-0.1592601091,
-0.2436092943,
0.9734944105,
-0.0329164267,
0.3953529894,
0.573202014,
0.3277901411,
-0.1709821671,
-0.3216690123,
-0.1865494549,
0.4048704505,
-1.0039993525,
0.2727643549,
-0.5422706604,
-0.3754510581,
-0.1254456341,
-0.1604240239,
-0.2266130298,
-0.3817834556,
-0.2386949956,
-0.2598024011,
0.1454324871,
1.003893733,
-0.2495836467,
0.5737308264,
-0.3924735487,
0.3746415973,
0.2990519106,
0.3617657125,
-0.1608527452,
-0.5984689593,
-0.0390793607,
0.1707280725,
-0.3987086117,
-0.7377895713,
-0.0611394197,
0.0602250844,
0.5102799535,
0.6981161237,
-0.312569648,
0.3252127171,
-0.7909728885,
0.9067056179,
0.0376265571,
-0.9576547146,
0.3873904645,
-0.5097659826,
0.2361374944,
0.366771102,
0.3590761423,
-1.0439046621,
-0.7916992903,
-0.8210024238,
-0.6637432575,
0.4071367979,
0.1341212839,
0.4578779936,
-0.1565072536,
0.4652765989,
0.0390728898,
0.2686868906,
-0.8961756229,
-0.3054574132,
-0.1816940904,
-0.0498643778,
-0.2941112816,
-0.5529338121,
-0.2773613334,
-0.024959892,
0.3837103844,
-0.1989264786,
0.5133607388,
0.0034975607,
-0.0909322724,
-0.0839761645,
0.4299028218,
0.8485263586,
0.7972139716,
0.0369737111,
0.5401051641,
0.329028368,
-0.7556808591,
0.1900999695,
-0.330534786,
-0.147996217,
-0.2359267324,
0.4919857383,
0.8980921507,
0.2223496288,
-0.345898807,
0.3893006146,
-0.0213109273,
-0.2181079835,
-0.3326559961,
-0.0611095801,
0.1525422186,
0.0505434237,
0.1135134175,
0.0615838543,
-0.099602446,
-0.6446365118,
0.1616071761,
0.4501465559,
-0.6271367669,
-0.4278616905,
0.7035550475,
0.0381089859,
-0.2626130879,
0.5748360753,
0.1108938828,
-1.0126228333,
0.4984362423,
0.4627091289,
1.0021332502,
-0.0562753305,
-0.1665418446,
0.1049150974,
0.7041276097,
-0.1273430884,
0.1490332335,
-0.2533398569,
-1.1047030687,
-0.4632219076,
-0.4857806861,
-0.6299315691,
0.1294341087,
-0.4929337502,
0.2041962445,
-0.4880307615,
0.1499408036,
-0.2923869491,
0.1128947362,
-0.4276722074,
0.1539200693,
0.2637391388,
0.7441113591,
-1.0240594149,
0.6293150187,
0.6067115664,
-0.4823349714,
-0.6067784429,
0.2724911869,
0.0050733266,
-1.1698530912,
0.6754636765,
0.1924434006,
-0.0665059313,
0.1359395683,
-0.7196907997,
-0.7141672969,
0.7753767967,
0.2376247793,
-0.2103683501,
0.1625634134,
0.2625554204,
0.5924722552,
-0.040293064,
0.4888864756,
0.8351589441,
0.4531615376,
0.037868131,
-0.8452397585,
0.0239951853,
0.0211070329,
-0.0874423683,
0.298482269,
-0.7527704835,
0.736232996,
-0.028697988,
-0.329765439,
-0.2040459812,
0.5907182097,
-0.0210991539,
0.1571108252,
0.0503462777,
0.6773570776,
0.7210962772,
-0.275885582,
1.0102500916,
-0.1630319953,
0.253723681,
0.7838807702,
-0.1039316803,
0.4400801659,
0.5824466944,
-0.5019442439,
-0.004195347,
0.8734978437,
0.3704312742,
0.3002619743,
0.5943567753,
-0.4184469581,
0.0324845426,
-0.1474286467,
-0.3609800935,
0.2948369384,
0.6305786967,
-0.1456280351,
-0.2908421755,
0.0864653736,
0.0412864536,
-0.0060560307,
-0.2001590282,
0.8951609135,
0.6907879114,
-0.5616324544,
0.6249884963,
-0.1591363251,
0.5878522992,
-0.4198672771,
0.1452947557,
-0.4476521015,
0.1491234452,
-0.063847594,
-0.8622370958,
0.2274976969,
-0.2436129004,
-0.0034519103,
-0.3673153818,
0.9414852858,
-0.2591969371,
0.0426351316,
0.1103907153,
0.5952802896,
0.6479536891,
-0.029881414,
-0.5640397668,
0.2870001495,
-0.0551557764,
-0.1614587158,
0.3639049232,
0.8311784267,
-0.0121655622,
0.8806773424,
0.364280194,
0.346486032,
0.2492713481,
0.0606077723,
0.8404006362,
-0.7539717555,
-0.3696555197,
-0.849452734,
0.049905818,
0.2266879231,
-0.1727326065,
0.5893136263,
0.3684245348,
0.7780383825,
0.2064045817,
0.8629418015,
-0.1558869928,
0.1910481751,
-0.6609469056,
0.5864864588,
-0.0704785213,
0.0904756859,
0.1278927028,
-0.9659659266,
-0.3241971433,
0.9348417521,
-0.5965539813,
-0.0839004591,
0.8738993406,
0.3896414936,
0.0402194373,
0.2641598582,
0.4814609885,
0.2296087891,
0.2018155456,
0.5831609964,
1.3625280857,
-0.3666763306,
0.3418369591,
0.0268166699,
-0.4184297323,
0.0646439642,
-0.7583696246,
-0.9040900469,
-0.5348665118,
-0.0392480269,
-0.3359636962,
-0.1244742051,
0.7362880111,
0.4969834089,
-0.5161409974,
-0.5073075891,
-0.5609045029,
0.3374959826,
0.0835576355,
-0.1944094747,
0.1600128561,
-0.651329875,
-0.5980820656,
0.1204652861,
0.3673604727,
-0.025176825,
-0.211315915,
-0.1515808702,
-0.0476913676,
-0.0356005356,
0.7013503909,
0.475147754,
-1.0047980547,
-0.3520497084,
-0.2609976232,
-0.0744945928,
0.2821439803,
0.9726514816,
-0.5510470271,
0.1956777424,
0.384637922,
0.8050168157,
0.4755249321,
-0.2136765122,
0.7118106484,
-0.3769719303,
0.3737717569,
0.2119657248,
0.3269210458,
0.3014228642,
-0.1627124995,
0.704026401,
0.4440266192,
-0.5924502015,
-0.6042419672,
0.5894546509,
-0.8463304043,
-0.0357881673,
1.2161439657,
0.1291625351,
-0.2197148055,
-0.1879678667,
-0.4576859474,
0.2392742932,
0.0766110495,
0.5405795574,
1.1291954517,
-0.1830054373,
-0.4222734272,
-1.0636242628,
0.5236659646,
0.5983608961,
-0.6139758825,
0.1122570857,
0.3681624532,
0.3182352781,
0.1239243075,
0.9290289879,
-0.1216253042,
-0.1160918102,
0.0618411489,
-0.1050404012,
0.5738478899,
0.0731022581,
-0.5007167459,
-0.0176777449,
0.4280236065,
-0.3002471328
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02212v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02212v1
|
A Data Generation Perspective to the Mechanism of In-Context Learning
| 2024-02-03T17:13:03 | 2024-02-03T17:13:03 |
Haitao Mao, Guangliang Liu, Yao Ma, Rongrong Wang, Jiliang Tang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In-Context Learning (ICL) empowers Large Language Models (LLMs) with the
capacity to learn in context, achieving downstream generalization without
gradient updates but with a few in-context examples. Despite the encouraging
empirical success, the underlying mechanism of ICL remains unclear, and
existing research offers various viewpoints of understanding. These studies
propose intuition-driven and ad-hoc technical solutions for interpreting ICL,
illustrating an ambiguous road map. In this paper, we leverage a data
generation perspective to reinterpret recent efforts and demonstrate the
potential broader usage of popular technical solutions, approaching a
systematic angle. For a conceptual definition, we rigorously adopt the terms of
skill learning and skill recognition. The difference between them is skill
learning can learn new data generation functions from in-context data. We also
provide a comprehensive study on the merits and weaknesses of different
solutions, and highlight the uniformity among them given the perspective of
data generation, establishing a technical foundation for future research to
incorporate the strengths of different lines of research.
|
[
-0.2659285963,
-0.6223805547,
0.6646246314,
-0.2522166967,
-0.2069218904,
0.3011317849,
-0.3529511094,
-0.334087193,
-0.4092712998,
0.2422427386,
-0.6882176995,
-0.3663159609,
-0.3600374162,
0.1474802047,
-0.5878400803,
1.0442255735,
-0.0377436392,
0.0845850408,
-0.515644908,
0.1244153008,
-0.5144249201,
-0.5749399066,
-0.6889474392,
-0.506595552,
0.3270250857,
0.9804020524,
-0.0392950289,
0.7116630673,
0.3286059499,
0.1418341398,
0.1809978634,
0.0670629814,
-0.4474560618,
0.115288347,
0.1049033105,
-0.5576526523,
0.0745465532,
0.0362247452,
0.8428035378,
1.1477060318,
-0.1118552834,
0.0820350274,
0.5821213722,
0.6923441887,
-0.4210573435,
0.0804608688,
-1.1631920338,
0.0495943427,
-0.3152114451,
-0.2559784651,
-0.4947134256,
-0.1472287774,
0.2389173508,
-0.3439946175,
0.2680606842,
-0.0725482255,
0.59090662,
0.1841615736,
-0.5139421225,
-0.7234500647,
-0.7743108869,
1.0030589104,
-0.6595982313,
0.2090767622,
0.2843116224,
0.5392792821,
-0.206482023,
-0.7124940157,
-0.4915371835,
-0.2252560109,
0.0937327594,
-0.1197490618,
0.3980330825,
-0.4482680857,
0.4332360923,
0.0805452466,
-0.1426284015,
0.2031723857,
-0.3594806492,
0.2262186557,
0.6677085161,
0.1994719803,
0.0878670812,
0.1979458779,
-0.4851841331,
0.1227509156,
-1.2967356443,
0.2951391637,
0.1249778345,
0.5093742013,
-0.3149161339,
0.135741055,
-0.1801230311,
0.7384421229,
0.1013965607,
-0.3111024797,
0.3024926484,
-0.058393348,
-0.0749236494,
0.2382929921,
0.4385107458,
-0.0188413206,
0.2966627479,
-0.2750302851,
-0.2744685709,
-0.460398674,
0.211391449,
-0.4374154806,
0.2606759369,
0.0695065781,
-0.1611838639,
-0.3937593699,
0.2951381505,
-0.4439375401,
-0.3061830699,
-0.6055547595,
0.0605858602,
-0.4459887147,
-0.2767782211,
-0.0954369009,
0.0379499458,
0.6362248063,
0.1846522391,
-0.8146955967,
0.1885759532,
0.7884002924,
0.7963443398,
-0.1419506818,
-0.2815967798,
-0.2892459035,
0.3179198503,
-0.3279776275,
0.6292675138,
-0.4903030396,
-0.3359425962,
0.2627266049,
-0.2822980583,
-0.0284546558,
-0.556814909,
0.1650505364,
-0.4461614788,
0.0153789883,
-0.4441084266,
-0.614773035,
-0.1418765038,
0.114008233,
-0.4658970833,
0.9410257936,
0.0460864827,
-0.7511687279,
1.018840313,
-0.703320384,
-0.3559679389,
0.3513519764,
-0.560382247,
-0.3133774102,
0.3457053602,
-0.258525461,
0.6272601485,
-0.4978255332,
0.5569947958,
-0.3610621989,
-0.3268078566,
0.6123688817,
-0.3027967215,
0.6928731799,
0.4184700251,
-0.5617531538,
-0.3711507022,
-0.9002087116,
-0.2038706541,
0.072281763,
-0.5582930446,
-0.2963277996,
0.3637540638,
-0.1514160484,
0.5467288494,
0.0064233243,
-0.5477571487,
0.0405112579,
-0.4179629385,
0.4827973843,
0.752959013,
-0.171398744,
0.4413992167,
-0.1874443889,
0.3142059445,
0.2629568875,
-0.0392007567,
-0.1700264215,
-0.1720877141,
-0.5054038167,
-0.067722097,
0.0464878529,
0.1718252003,
-0.8111706972,
0.069469735,
-0.2331423312,
-0.2980847359,
-0.4660156667,
0.3268116415,
0.4634493887,
1.0755554438,
0.1755252033,
-0.0995329618,
-0.4985450208,
-0.6985163689,
-0.2666362822,
0.0373679884,
0.1230893359,
0.4950541854,
0.4061792195,
0.1213460714,
1.2953740358,
-0.0194612425,
0.0303928275,
-0.4893323779,
-0.1101207659,
0.0838199481,
0.4509094954,
0.5230344534,
-0.8855712414,
-0.7700816989,
0.2756418884,
-1.1927378178,
-0.0264822245,
-0.0492968149,
0.2227772027,
0.2094870657,
1.0171670914,
-0.1273441464,
0.2344171107,
0.0948439389,
-0.0542346798,
0.3000540733,
0.0683905929,
-0.2512004077,
-1.0438059568,
0.1040366963,
0.1152897254,
0.0863968059,
-0.8757907748,
0.2020188272,
0.1213918924,
-0.0318824425,
-0.6276345849,
0.588835001,
-0.3145117462,
-0.0934021026,
-0.3130301237,
0.2704341412,
-0.3529864252,
0.2400415391,
-0.0165683702,
0.684363246,
0.7049521804,
-0.8200044036,
0.152343303,
-0.1007180214,
-0.4253194928,
0.4450107813,
-0.337657243,
0.3202338219,
-0.2737053335,
0.0338270701,
-0.8184396029,
-0.4061320126,
0.1225535572,
-0.2789675295,
0.488394618,
-0.0727803707,
-0.4330556989,
-0.1677821279,
-0.1135199368,
0.4877526462,
0.3178572953,
-0.7533059716,
0.1468051821,
0.3816990852,
-0.0390005223,
-0.5658005476,
-0.7477627993,
0.0903783962,
-0.702098608,
-0.44135499,
0.3098550439,
-0.1213534623,
-0.7153380513,
-0.2731302083,
0.0706487149,
-0.0625579283,
0.4602279067,
-0.0287954696,
0.0481054001,
-0.150079757,
0.3676691651,
0.0170297343,
-0.1391377449,
0.1707691401,
-0.5439622402,
0.3590481877,
0.0890120342,
-0.329480052,
-0.1505438685,
0.3030757904,
0.4270100892,
0.0587533563,
0.734680593,
0.0594912618,
-0.184974581,
-0.5123230219,
-0.4159811735,
-0.1174338162,
-0.4772628546,
0.1567022055,
-0.5313041806,
-0.5940482616,
0.446760416,
-0.2958451807,
0.0783852115,
0.1024717242,
0.364828229,
-0.35405761,
0.9794558883,
0.8914290667,
-0.027109988,
0.6040790677,
-0.2575852275,
0.202344805,
-0.7908356786,
-0.4960302711,
-0.4912680089,
-0.2858922184,
-0.3223845959,
0.3197907209,
0.4929511249,
0.1381862313,
-0.267118901,
-0.0708835125,
-0.2441065907,
0.2629756927,
0.5381377935,
0.1402647942,
0.2840938866,
0.2084322125,
-0.2044213712,
0.0036449158,
-0.7436965108,
-0.5720371604,
1.3983875513,
0.1128187627,
0.4421099424,
-0.124059774,
0.6863940358,
-0.0451424234,
0.3784981668,
-0.6743633747,
0.4881847203,
-0.0098034712,
-0.2801195681,
-0.0937969312,
-0.2540664375,
-0.7234575152,
-0.1154973805,
-0.0594810024,
-0.4776696563,
0.0605193786,
0.1247243062,
-0.0431100465,
0.2102736086,
-0.7549116611,
0.5189925432,
-0.2747346759,
-0.3789913952,
-0.1460010409,
-0.6432592869,
0.3682193756,
-0.3619108498,
0.4948491454,
0.209162131,
-0.0243261997,
0.3786689043,
-0.4025909901,
0.9632126689,
-0.4057359099,
-0.2636665106,
0.3360096514,
-0.1971396357,
0.3667832315,
-0.0153855067,
-0.2194885015,
-0.0456922874,
-0.4654447436,
-0.317530632,
-0.5558286309,
0.6199170947,
-0.5042933822,
-0.4645289779,
-0.0971944481,
-0.7010625005,
-0.2840622365,
-0.0949358046,
0.4048913717,
0.6254703999,
-0.0083200317,
0.299741447,
0.7569621801,
-0.0906853601,
0.7084774971,
0.5727995634,
0.0047202543,
0.2237527072,
0.8244330883,
0.2197634429,
0.4223978519,
0.2531009912,
0.0518818796,
0.0054598665,
-0.765904367,
-0.2508467436,
0.0788285434,
-0.8365540504,
-0.037885718,
-0.2223753482,
-0.2162585407,
-0.0408737436,
-0.4308910668,
0.0960607156,
-0.0409865305,
-0.2942885458,
-0.1873128563,
0.2224801928,
1.010781765,
0.0754582062,
0.212999925,
-0.2720193267,
-0.2315362245,
0.218157351,
0.1708165109,
0.2587074041,
-0.4013119042,
-0.7210793495,
0.1552193761,
-0.3846526742,
-0.5300864577,
0.1766108274,
0.2470119745,
0.5667783022,
0.3451934457,
-0.3612228334,
0.5728420019,
-0.4520144463,
0.7712730765,
-0.14222534,
-0.9234496355,
0.6797122955,
-0.2264809012,
0.1470968723,
0.4453288019,
0.4286791682,
-0.5317287445,
-0.45107162,
-0.6784268022,
-0.8037185073,
0.712836504,
-0.3772740662,
0.1860420108,
0.0374995545,
0.8042254448,
0.4671505094,
0.3525460362,
-0.7640247345,
-0.008972208,
-0.0714665428,
-0.3776243627,
0.014032444,
0.0183070898,
0.0186856594,
-0.1567831039,
0.5587876439,
-0.5469170213,
0.0167318992,
-0.0502468646,
-0.3632239401,
0.0202363003,
0.1191446632,
0.3657104075,
0.9071661234,
0.1208300963,
-0.0085889902,
0.0760866776,
-0.3453267217,
-0.0168523341,
-0.2364890277,
-0.4481043518,
-0.2610513568,
0.5835061073,
0.618473947,
0.4137632251,
-0.7012953758,
0.4963709712,
0.1802103072,
-0.2823675871,
-0.4291909039,
0.174962461,
-0.1973783374,
0.2391011566,
0.7724419236,
-0.0928001255,
-0.0062820059,
-0.7435350418,
0.3076620698,
0.7039223313,
-0.5205196738,
-0.4084952474,
0.4748508334,
-0.0450000688,
-0.0981648266,
0.6304491162,
-0.1398819387,
-0.1334383339,
0.7512294054,
0.7457973361,
0.8647587299,
-0.1027363241,
0.1290289462,
0.1609669328,
-0.0880425498,
0.1448893249,
0.3399383426,
-0.2824112773,
-0.8366693854,
-0.3864950538,
-0.4316481054,
-0.1768742502,
0.1188652217,
-0.6588815451,
0.4659554362,
-0.3765797913,
0.3209146559,
-0.2485437244,
-0.1770164222,
-0.8002893329,
0.1237394065,
0.1675449163,
0.9746024609,
-0.7949197888,
1.1376109123,
0.6444289684,
-0.502076447,
-0.8158682585,
0.3816029131,
0.0458744131,
-0.8256581426,
1.1383999586,
0.1131746173,
-0.1035289019,
0.212229833,
-0.932143569,
-0.8512753844,
1.3096969128,
0.482937485,
-0.267798543,
-0.0837391838,
0.1969468594,
0.3766680062,
-0.969712317,
-0.0448893048,
0.6123207211,
0.1489550173,
-0.0205377527,
-0.5970823765,
-0.0814693645,
-0.0197241772,
0.0193393752,
-0.0699887723,
-0.4510497153,
0.7310502529,
-0.1147484854,
-0.3734183013,
-0.2769906819,
0.395640254,
0.2210472077,
0.4187963009,
0.1452773362,
0.2353405207,
0.5222762227,
-0.0153348604,
1.0108157396,
-0.3220149279,
0.1505227536,
0.7824084759,
-0.3479905427,
0.685246408,
0.6525714397,
0.0118515706,
0.819050312,
0.552693665,
0.3337030113,
0.8745726347,
0.0581732951,
-0.4516671896,
-0.0158573948,
-0.177602157,
-0.1395680457,
0.4931526482,
0.6752226949,
-0.4199258089,
-0.2879654467,
0.3112172186,
-0.0486878492,
0.197327137,
-0.4349601269,
1.0375208855,
0.2652349174,
-0.6371962428,
0.5277786851,
-0.3302489519,
0.4591786563,
-0.5353214145,
-0.2406986058,
-0.0605962686,
0.0534412749,
-0.2307555228,
-0.7478589416,
0.324562043,
0.0566143319,
-0.2548633218,
-0.3727318943,
0.5409671068,
-0.4036430717,
-0.2751898766,
0.31530568,
0.5831384659,
0.0365725607,
0.3263848126,
-0.5572211742,
-0.0377598405,
0.0012449377,
0.0757094696,
0.534794569,
0.7349539995,
0.0031953075,
0.7807680964,
0.4087010026,
0.0616018623,
0.0951806977,
-0.0497251563,
0.8179648519,
-0.4943981469,
-0.3686257303,
-0.9950430393,
0.6641694903,
-0.0224367511,
-0.4126949608,
0.6481646299,
0.3457018137,
1.4166322947,
0.1177606434,
1.2254072428,
-0.1343679577,
0.5271993876,
-0.7924789786,
0.3682632744,
-0.6743475199,
0.5237717032,
-0.2205903977,
-0.5871145725,
-0.3352870047,
0.3532493114,
-0.4475117624,
0.1231480017,
0.6745656729,
0.6006281972,
-0.1990930736,
-0.1323438138,
0.1586590558,
0.0932729244,
0.3344590664,
0.5331395268,
0.8670456409,
-0.1774434447,
0.2513720095,
-0.126630649,
-0.237170741,
-0.2242890596,
-0.8352991343,
-0.7147406936,
-0.9960879683,
0.0580195598,
-0.0157041978,
-0.1810909659,
0.9281637073,
0.5465390086,
-0.5358790159,
-0.6523475647,
-0.4778425097,
0.1929085851,
-0.3560100794,
-0.2411496639,
0.169404611,
-0.9600909352,
-0.5478835702,
0.5980203748,
0.2184699178,
-0.1380982101,
-0.3533520997,
-0.1799540818,
0.0571558587,
-0.0969938412,
0.6229883432,
0.4510201514,
-0.5891669989,
-0.2138994634,
-0.2478771806,
0.0174081996,
0.1133401096,
1.145478487,
-1.040027976,
0.3333603144,
0.1683575511,
0.6269062161,
0.3091717958,
-0.2912881374,
0.8002358079,
-1.0427230597,
0.1017956361,
-0.0720677078,
0.3657829463,
0.4527921379,
-0.3786202371,
0.4296724498,
0.1844595373,
-0.430576086,
-0.96678859,
0.6009735465,
-0.1679583639,
-0.3139292598,
0.9731000662,
0.0386601537,
-0.0357326679,
-0.4209252,
0.1009292454,
0.1268490255,
-0.2026308477,
0.9133376479,
0.685464859,
-0.23927176,
-0.0757876262,
-0.8015115857,
0.7695229053,
0.0952304676,
-0.7405735254,
0.1895152181,
0.2402612567,
0.2391154766,
-0.1488332301,
0.4788981378,
-0.1384034604,
0.1153783053,
-0.333687067,
-0.1486320347,
0.1301181763,
-0.6131946445,
-0.6311064363,
0.1907458901,
0.3891512156,
0.2111532986
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05948v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05948v1
|
DE$^3$-BERT: Distance-Enhanced Early Exiting for BERT based on Prototypical Networks
| 2024-02-03T15:51:17 | 2024-02-03T15:51:17 |
Jianing He, Qi Zhang, Weiping Ding, Duoqian Miao, Jun Zhao, Liang Hu, Longbing Cao
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Early exiting has demonstrated its effectiveness in accelerating the
inference of pre-trained language models like BERT by dynamically adjusting the
number of layers executed. However, most existing early exiting methods only
consider local information from an individual test sample to determine their
exiting indicators, failing to leverage the global information offered by
sample population. This leads to suboptimal estimation of prediction
correctness, resulting in erroneous exiting decisions. To bridge the gap, we
explore the necessity of effectively combining both local and global
information to ensure reliable early exiting during inference. Purposefully, we
leverage prototypical networks to learn class prototypes and devise a distance
metric between samples and class prototypes. This enables us to utilize global
information for estimating the correctness of early predictions. On this basis,
we propose a novel Distance-Enhanced Early Exiting framework for BERT
(DE$^3$-BERT). DE$^3$-BERT implements a hybrid exiting strategy that
supplements classic entropy-based local information with distance-based global
information to enhance the estimation of prediction correctness for more
reliable early exiting decisions. Extensive experiments on the GLUE benchmark
demonstrate that DE$^3$-BERT consistently outperforms state-of-the-art models
under different speed-up ratios with minimal storage or computational overhead,
yielding a better trade-off between model performance and inference efficiency.
Additionally, an in-depth analysis further validates the generality and
interpretability of our method.
|
[
-0.3255343437,
-1.0451772213,
0.5868495107,
0.0796155408,
-0.2274710387,
0.0074348105,
-0.4975461662,
-0.7916220427,
0.0193769578,
0.0088428026,
-0.4969607592,
-0.1376068145,
-0.6222439408,
-0.4982379079,
-0.2955335975,
0.7318202853,
0.1298830658,
-0.1410204619,
-0.1386521906,
0.4990125299,
-0.0131757185,
-0.3957906365,
-0.5725155473,
-0.3917475343,
0.7281038165,
0.3068999052,
0.760848999,
0.5238916278,
0.2925351262,
0.201621443,
-0.2437143326,
0.1737028807,
-0.4779933095,
-0.1020719856,
0.3599234223,
-0.4842212498,
-0.4962101579,
-0.1715857834,
0.5288937688,
0.9818258286,
-0.0605154037,
-0.0273888111,
0.2758789659,
0.8098362684,
-0.81498909,
0.2024581879,
-0.501755178,
0.1558137685,
-0.6074426174,
0.3094293773,
-0.6338929534,
-0.6386637688,
0.4149813652,
-0.5153853297,
0.2575035989,
-0.4334254265,
1.161981225,
-0.1137675717,
0.0085345004,
0.2268904597,
-1.0642614365,
0.5835132599,
-0.6577697396,
0.497164309,
0.244638294,
0.5884788036,
-0.3064000905,
-0.6551023722,
-0.6750150323,
-0.0651568621,
0.1601253897,
0.0981109068,
-0.3065757155,
0.1902308166,
-0.0855864957,
0.1079976633,
-0.2801169753,
0.4823977053,
-0.7370788455,
-0.2022546381,
0.3384748101,
-0.4363765121,
-0.0035026525,
-0.0033824383,
-0.4834010303,
-0.3532317281,
-0.9098971486,
0.1040308923,
0.6864301562,
0.4785584807,
-0.2031734735,
0.2333547175,
-0.0796122104,
0.8226156235,
-0.0738361105,
0.2593142986,
0.2909429669,
0.2832077146,
-0.1276254356,
0.0450805128,
0.4760295749,
0.4816893637,
0.205720529,
-0.3049098849,
-0.1328830123,
-0.3004710972,
-0.1031088009,
-0.6015273929,
-0.5832628012,
0.1337593347,
-0.8277403712,
-0.1828808933,
0.0432835892,
-0.6970146298,
-0.0876388252,
-0.2205453217,
0.496712029,
-0.8577834964,
-0.3681532145,
-0.170151934,
-0.0194481891,
0.1681259573,
0.3622697294,
-0.9578782916,
0.2994581759,
0.5368158221,
0.9750174284,
-0.1183737144,
-0.2544824183,
-0.4983355105,
0.2600399554,
-0.1854224056,
0.6141517758,
-0.4916284978,
-0.1129475236,
-0.1255223453,
-0.2889463603,
0.1100014448,
-0.4212516248,
0.216216743,
-0.7625278831,
0.2097184062,
0.0965597704,
-0.4695661366,
-0.3966418803,
-0.0702128187,
-0.7837046385,
1.2001088858,
0.1238133833,
-0.6209157109,
0.6036211848,
-0.6981216669,
-0.3214562833,
-0.0409407802,
0.1657091826,
-0.2113008201,
0.2968737781,
0.3599557579,
0.725920558,
-0.0860429928,
0.1362325549,
-0.7158233523,
-0.6533815861,
-0.3754917681,
-0.3907546401,
0.8375706673,
0.2433015555,
-0.3810440004,
-0.3023979366,
-0.9237602353,
0.1465726197,
0.0229338463,
-0.2459271699,
-0.7554855943,
0.1195967644,
-0.2846280038,
0.1168299541,
0.4733259678,
-0.7345006466,
0.1564460099,
-0.4909773469,
-0.0254125893,
1.1132128239,
-0.139788866,
0.5243878365,
-0.3625968695,
0.2789177597,
0.0476732664,
0.3893057108,
0.2756696343,
-0.7419381738,
-0.5972481966,
-0.4335507154,
0.504509747,
0.4329427183,
-0.5290275812,
0.815182209,
-0.3431219757,
-0.7802945375,
-0.3182491362,
-0.0730967149,
0.181599319,
0.3795726597,
0.3704783022,
-0.2238211483,
-0.8271122575,
-0.8657156229,
0.0190441329,
-0.617100656,
-0.2780156732,
-0.0080600642,
0.2342559844,
-0.142476514,
1.0949100256,
-0.4493229091,
0.040886052,
-0.3276348114,
0.2492808998,
0.5631257892,
0.5641868711,
0.1693174839,
-0.5498718023,
-0.2799293995,
-0.1965754181,
-0.4540669322,
0.121010229,
-0.347153455,
-0.4469099343,
0.0175865702,
0.199026674,
-0.4825210571,
0.4063673615,
0.5786306262,
-0.0485756211,
0.5379911065,
-0.3741445839,
-0.2463524193,
-0.8015767336,
-0.0716153681,
0.0293604285,
0.2460923791,
-0.6050645113,
-0.3984605372,
0.0537140071,
0.3413915038,
-0.5667513609,
0.6491206288,
-0.3438389003,
-0.1206995398,
0.2927924991,
0.1421723217,
0.0964962319,
0.2667450309,
0.2284304798,
0.49427706,
0.4480693936,
-0.7253391743,
0.0615229607,
0.15362221,
-0.517655313,
-0.1185952947,
-0.3694619536,
0.0863956809,
-0.1777787805,
0.3854853809,
-0.8143907189,
0.0362469479,
0.0027143944,
-0.4857901633,
0.2987957597,
0.0101961121,
-0.6632201076,
-0.4344123006,
-0.2197747827,
0.202497527,
0.857625246,
-0.7581779957,
0.4049091339,
-0.0738423765,
-0.2164247483,
-0.5770341158,
-0.6365909576,
-0.0881814733,
-0.1048321202,
-0.7915905714,
0.462387681,
0.2452602834,
-0.2326086313,
-0.0775569603,
0.0553520285,
-0.379653722,
0.0416943654,
-0.1440796554,
0.3686088026,
-0.1509056389,
0.1306538731,
0.2109610736,
0.0519369207,
0.2269321382,
-0.2861020267,
0.326346755,
-0.1815216243,
-0.2448423803,
-0.1031973436,
0.2766460478,
0.3262436688,
-0.0045711999,
1.0134841204,
0.8741105199,
-0.6116250157,
-0.0893018693,
-0.7386499047,
-0.5465524197,
-0.405718267,
0.332472086,
-0.4139649272,
-0.4052501023,
0.6882876158,
-0.0683120564,
-0.0164816678,
0.3324385285,
0.3166268766,
-0.4318335056,
0.6404631734,
0.8072400689,
0.2276628464,
0.4637461901,
-0.4674948752,
0.4749050736,
-0.8702251911,
-0.5624632835,
-0.147305727,
-0.3789322376,
-0.3384914994,
-0.3953089118,
0.4230509102,
0.5353550911,
-0.2054253072,
0.3253827691,
-0.1530195624,
0.5822300911,
0.8164978623,
0.4709165394,
-0.105745472,
0.0955944583,
-0.5010114908,
-0.2616421878,
-0.897489965,
-0.4126366377,
1.0336693525,
0.5750157237,
0.6652886868,
0.3494638205,
1.1331510544,
0.2822364271,
0.449585259,
-0.3255073428,
0.5699954629,
-0.1995031387,
-0.6574471593,
-0.3731443882,
-0.3885424137,
-0.7683546543,
0.0297220461,
0.01419097,
-1.1385672092,
0.4346123636,
0.0692909285,
-0.6437534094,
0.7665809989,
-0.7393631935,
0.6409512758,
-0.3039255738,
-0.4391774833,
0.0590608045,
-1.1335198879,
0.5801825523,
-0.2496104538,
0.0950057656,
-0.2226572484,
0.0533033162,
0.8416757584,
-0.505428195,
1.0401409864,
-0.5590651035,
-0.3032885194,
0.2940402925,
0.348467201,
0.4712412357,
-0.3562796116,
-0.2906545997,
0.5812258124,
-0.3072603643,
-0.2508161366,
-0.5000230074,
0.4151000381,
-0.7848051786,
-0.03849186,
-0.0227262769,
-0.2569286227,
-0.2949769795,
0.265823245,
0.2977854908,
0.4819675386,
0.0051491298,
0.0662589222,
0.5732153058,
-0.3121744692,
0.6814075112,
0.3339447975,
0.1118692532,
-0.2744061053,
0.8694505095,
-0.0574136525,
0.3040937185,
0.721131444,
0.4118612111,
-0.8578340411,
-0.4382834733,
-0.2932902575,
0.079332374,
-0.7958802581,
-0.0967785865,
-0.3662262559,
-0.1666751057,
-0.4476490915,
-0.4242058396,
-0.3808436394,
-0.4564366043,
-0.1456153989,
-0.0238850694,
0.0246307943,
0.6147996783,
-0.8618527651,
0.2768521011,
-1.1577727795,
-0.0927211046,
0.1606269032,
0.4787028432,
0.246225059,
-0.3396151066,
-0.3180576861,
-0.1432861984,
-0.2098892927,
-0.9052000642,
0.0861233994,
0.41240412,
0.745239079,
0.9051100016,
0.1453095973,
0.8159151673,
-0.4769962132,
0.932813704,
0.4399136305,
-0.8139889836,
0.6732769608,
-0.3718872368,
0.062685892,
0.4492623806,
0.3984141648,
-0.1414014995,
-0.4315165579,
-0.8051112294,
-1.0786312819,
0.5163521171,
0.3684705496,
-0.1539831161,
-0.349273473,
0.0755609944,
0.3345063627,
-0.0044853655,
-0.6798470616,
-0.2186655402,
0.175179705,
0.1287753284,
0.0911462456,
-0.1748467684,
0.165788427,
-0.4179519117,
0.7444412708,
0.0399079211,
0.6698872447,
0.052397754,
-0.0090915663,
0.0495458879,
0.0879324377,
0.4153295755,
0.6650497317,
-0.8150396347,
-0.001822075,
0.20187518,
-0.2471822053,
0.4048451483,
0.4165216088,
0.0049979081,
0.1684821397,
0.6110684872,
0.3843275607,
0.1445175558,
-0.422398299,
0.5756474137,
0.0649980679,
-0.066386722,
-0.3525390625,
-0.2299554348,
-0.3536207676,
0.1522671729,
0.4698722064,
0.1168133169,
0.0899244919,
-0.1614408493,
0.5170038939,
0.1383824795,
-0.2794507146,
-0.3656779826,
0.7646378279,
0.5664437413,
0.1821423322,
0.7809087038,
-0.0755496845,
-0.3803795576,
0.5952371359,
0.4309549034,
1.1959578991,
-0.0955309868,
0.19947128,
0.3052822948,
0.3813589513,
0.0502844267,
0.2398267835,
-0.4047307372,
-0.811438024,
-0.8046553731,
-0.6440731883,
-0.2858437598,
0.266058445,
-0.834718287,
0.1150827184,
-0.3744689822,
-0.0330401398,
-0.6044543386,
-0.0450773649,
-0.727242589,
0.2645321488,
0.7173310518,
1.2348163128,
-0.9535983205,
0.7875769138,
0.6526444554,
-0.1054730043,
-0.6217397451,
0.1550816447,
-0.0102013387,
-0.7031561136,
1.1800653934,
0.4308467805,
-0.2848083377,
-0.2410113066,
-0.2433356494,
-0.7663487196,
0.9000434875,
0.3707975149,
-0.6413104534,
-0.4766636491,
-0.2294371724,
0.1803337187,
-0.3022902906,
0.6693537831,
0.7742782235,
0.4506712258,
0.0577323735,
-0.6892622113,
-0.0422257818,
-0.1112480685,
0.2596119642,
0.3935808539,
-0.5375158191,
0.8997912407,
-0.6608476043,
-0.0359408557,
0.1568745524,
0.7856130004,
0.0445246287,
-0.0847340822,
0.8615494967,
0.6013394594,
0.7224625945,
-0.2656700611,
0.8231089711,
-0.4422925711,
0.0983873159,
1.2737084627,
-0.1285505593,
1.015213728,
0.3443555236,
-0.2225179672,
0.8172336221,
1.0789992809,
0.2550530434,
0.9278584123,
0.2371055335,
-0.4363291264,
-0.3131795526,
0.4036826193,
-0.5768322945,
0.5771665573,
0.355342865,
-0.3136406541,
-0.4970582426,
-0.2516555786,
0.0194725096,
-0.2708493769,
0.2107120454,
0.6346148252,
-0.2844374776,
-0.4367125034,
0.5305199027,
-0.0958230644,
0.4458718002,
-0.6745262742,
-0.1578337848,
-0.371037811,
0.2193413973,
0.0737602562,
-0.4696890116,
0.1321042776,
-0.3272576034,
0.0103645818,
-0.2529038787,
0.557967484,
-0.2790944576,
-0.317581743,
0.4675063193,
0.6349419951,
0.3183212876,
0.2682728767,
-0.6708160043,
0.0871421918,
-0.1944075525,
-0.1533700973,
0.016306797,
0.5381138325,
0.2706993818,
0.4718363881,
0.7678776979,
0.5103360415,
0.0810252875,
0.1506849229,
0.8822131157,
-0.4136379957,
-0.6975169778,
-0.9671373367,
0.7164423466,
-0.1956915259,
-0.2213793099,
0.5436527729,
0.5152285695,
0.8413037062,
-0.0185602475,
0.8315618634,
-0.3164687157,
0.5247908235,
-0.6774196029,
0.5803567171,
-0.3950526416,
0.3101250827,
-0.4542954862,
-1.2771465778,
-0.2568626702,
0.6265984178,
-0.31476897,
0.1585369408,
0.6523582339,
0.590955615,
-0.0740696564,
-0.1690128297,
0.2605647743,
0.1700339913,
0.5558528304,
0.7777103782,
0.8123013377,
-0.1927339882,
0.4515346587,
-0.526388526,
-0.5480613708,
-0.3042306304,
-1.1164129972,
-0.7293190956,
-0.5385093093,
-0.1851360798,
-0.382227242,
0.2219142914,
0.7616227269,
1.1630578041,
-0.5114576221,
0.0164575521,
-0.1130516678,
-0.119146198,
-0.5044909716,
-0.2693237364,
0.3594014645,
-0.4560773671,
-0.4619015455,
0.4490260184,
0.0448347107,
0.3492944539,
-0.4614406526,
-0.163388744,
-0.1475737542,
0.0357619189,
0.5611684918,
0.2147755772,
-0.8304687738,
-0.4102303386,
-0.3751598895,
0.3375534713,
-0.0768822283,
0.5124469399,
-0.9581093192,
0.7967154384,
0.2932478189,
0.6007368565,
0.3646059334,
-0.1700556129,
0.9905282855,
-0.98264575,
0.2711474001,
0.3498285115,
0.1983073056,
0.2205016762,
-0.3669695258,
0.5288550258,
0.0074267397,
-0.2990642786,
-0.7957922816,
0.0604262725,
-0.4372577071,
0.0602314658,
0.9457491636,
-0.3147317469,
-0.3680321276,
0.0739818141,
0.2953286767,
0.1925055385,
-0.4555670023,
0.9132918119,
0.7555867434,
-0.4300768375,
-0.0546337292,
-0.4742034972,
0.4540910125,
0.3458529711,
-0.6864336729,
0.0617263801,
0.3368571401,
-0.0773619041,
0.1124629453,
0.5926754475,
0.0014059976,
0.2579617202,
-0.0177737456,
0.2879949212,
0.0948628262,
-0.6992803812,
-0.1418354958,
0.0594714843,
-0.1190732941,
-0.5730177164
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02175v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02175v1
|
Enhancing Complex Question Answering over Knowledge Graphs through Evidence Pattern Retrieval
| 2024-02-03T14:54:13 | 2024-02-03T14:54:13 |
Wentao Ding, Jinmao Li, Liangchuan Luo, Yuzhong Qu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Information retrieval (IR) methods for KGQA consist of two stages: subgraph
extraction and answer reasoning. We argue current subgraph extraction methods
underestimate the importance of structural dependencies among evidence facts.
We propose Evidence Pattern Retrieval (EPR) to explicitly model the structural
dependencies during subgraph extraction. We implement EPR by indexing the
atomic adjacency pattern of resource pairs. Given a question, we perform dense
retrieval to obtain atomic patterns formed by resource pairs. We then enumerate
their combinations to construct candidate evidence patterns. These evidence
patterns are scored using a neural model, and the best one is selected to
extract a subgraph for downstream answer reasoning. Experimental results
demonstrate that the EPR-based approach has significantly improved the F1
scores of IR-KGQA methods by over 10 points on ComplexWebQuestions and achieves
competitive performance on WebQuestionsSP.
|
[
-0.4381339252,
-1.1660225391,
0.6882508993,
-0.1425272524,
-0.1398728192,
0.157563448,
0.4144521952,
-0.5176286697,
0.080611825,
0.3570639789,
-0.1318052411,
-0.3927488923,
-0.5298408866,
0.0246737972,
0.0007056615,
0.5821945071,
-0.1428045928,
0.3533287346,
-0.3562919199,
-0.0220319871,
-0.2255576402,
-0.5925691724,
-0.5358492732,
-0.7175334096,
0.6158121228,
0.5432804227,
0.4088180661,
0.7505665421,
0.4364898503,
0.3012095094,
-0.4356073439,
0.4263355434,
-0.3920873404,
0.1867932975,
0.0397843532,
-0.5948716402,
-0.1670473963,
-0.1519825161,
0.0529163592,
0.7371271253,
-0.2491791546,
0.1250074804,
-0.2808784246,
0.5444791317,
-0.6818697453,
0.3333956897,
-0.3203336596,
0.0007885049,
-0.1210708916,
-0.5628678203,
-0.6069081426,
-0.2834507525,
0.3080682456,
-0.6028230786,
0.1892552972,
0.2641156018,
0.9056965709,
-0.0667351633,
-0.7004905343,
-0.4888930917,
-0.5661585331,
0.4525738657,
-0.373450011,
0.5032092333,
0.5075124502,
0.4320090413,
-0.3081943691,
-0.9931822419,
-0.3551855385,
-0.1171505228,
-0.5313979387,
0.2249074131,
0.0333379731,
0.2441127598,
0.419644773,
0.243209213,
-0.3909375966,
-0.4557902813,
-0.3114761114,
-0.5467736721,
0.3090409935,
0.2436301261,
0.5495017767,
-0.3522261381,
-0.1385464966,
-0.1797702014,
-0.7611604929,
0.375135392,
0.2827958465,
0.2630611956,
0.3855502009,
0.6663229465,
-0.6174674034,
0.8747788668,
0.0979463682,
-0.1454126686,
0.021325862,
-0.0923044831,
0.1269713044,
0.4788468182,
0.1201587021,
0.0681055337,
0.0272833761,
-0.3293788433,
0.0625566319,
-0.0793943331,
0.0090928543,
-1.0087842941,
-0.5687845349,
0.2248970717,
-0.6359204054,
0.0824248046,
0.2124838531,
-0.5567302108,
-0.2989960611,
-0.288611412,
0.7290853262,
-0.4117803276,
-0.362374723,
0.0551205575,
-0.7596205473,
0.4516402185,
0.4305302501,
-0.2564703226,
0.4427637756,
0.6191570759,
0.5294257402,
0.3827000856,
0.2019339651,
-0.4542888701,
0.2330477238,
-0.2367908955,
1.0042841434,
-0.7771747708,
0.0900956169,
-0.2561528981,
-0.055712685,
0.2391045988,
-0.6715022922,
0.4924749732,
-1.1713752747,
0.2169127017,
-0.6016772389,
-0.6227381229,
-0.5867365599,
0.4819241464,
-0.7101992965,
0.8398979902,
0.0715701953,
-0.8282211423,
0.1383147389,
-0.6651592255,
-0.6337172985,
0.0351000912,
-0.1968172342,
-0.1878298074,
-0.3498780727,
0.3476728499,
0.2738339901,
-0.2982967198,
-0.087751694,
-0.1972323656,
-0.2821627855,
0.0606438816,
0.1155330464,
0.6282057762,
0.2441387922,
-0.1200067773,
-0.1884552389,
-0.8362397552,
0.4564940631,
-0.030208623,
-0.5567116737,
-0.8660811186,
0.2256399691,
-0.2978103459,
0.1034382954,
-0.0473463312,
-0.9117966294,
-0.0665555745,
-0.1909471005,
0.3486894965,
0.6406701803,
0.4119772315,
0.1294090897,
-0.393381238,
0.3444521725,
0.2702027559,
0.0023830752,
-0.0853695273,
-0.6353632212,
-0.7000304461,
-0.291238606,
0.4404587746,
0.4741404355,
-0.7221243382,
-0.0561861917,
-0.1057879403,
-0.5521792173,
-0.4310757816,
-0.1967054158,
0.8626493812,
0.6162462234,
0.6047973037,
-0.4879796803,
-0.8225681782,
-0.8837956786,
-0.248072505,
-0.2452069968,
-0.0166426115,
0.4296735525,
0.3107602298,
0.28841874,
1.1004103422,
-0.8944013715,
0.128755182,
-0.1754083037,
0.4399074912,
0.2740292549,
0.2513564229,
0.2173828036,
-1.3367353678,
-0.5460922718,
0.1020516306,
-0.7256287336,
0.0164399017,
0.3539792299,
-0.4862483144,
-0.4040758908,
0.4810049832,
-0.6403303146,
0.1887612939,
-0.1575433612,
-0.6282166243,
0.0770064592,
0.3290357292,
0.3286178112,
-0.8710435629,
0.0237039812,
-0.1484634131,
-0.30052948,
-0.7917540669,
0.1802172363,
-0.0779162273,
0.3370700181,
-0.0505371504,
0.1739563644,
-0.6076748967,
-0.077066645,
0.034587197,
-0.2155907601,
0.1996009052,
0.4809158444,
-0.2284599245,
0.4799366295,
0.0231216531,
-0.5781117678,
0.2711297274,
0.3484913707,
-0.6141061783,
0.2643921375,
-0.8368780017,
0.4385295212,
-0.6169605851,
0.0894917175,
-1.2872846127,
-0.2790074348,
0.1423207223,
-0.4722445905,
0.4860101342,
-0.3893811405,
-0.1540832222,
-0.007801591,
-0.0746351331,
0.201555416,
0.4219198525,
-0.3986900151,
1.0890792608,
0.4808471501,
-0.2552373111,
-0.6476002336,
-0.293794781,
-0.3534460068,
0.1258952618,
-0.6662119627,
0.2857404053,
0.0459735505,
-0.4457665086,
0.3349255323,
-0.3542765081,
-0.2808125615,
0.1950241625,
0.1544898301,
-0.0737713426,
-0.3343736827,
-0.1476929039,
-0.0141924871,
-0.049909059,
0.0063035777,
0.0899006054,
0.7292567492,
0.194854185,
-0.2906378806,
-0.1719113439,
0.5116342306,
0.6382684112,
-0.1390461326,
0.4757146239,
0.1617614478,
-0.3338102102,
0.0130197182,
-0.7160973549,
-0.2497671396,
-0.4545601904,
0.622199297,
-0.6627600193,
-0.8163862228,
0.7443871498,
-0.4087493122,
-0.2644737959,
0.1440643817,
0.3979599774,
-0.0766972974,
1.4118089676,
0.3434709907,
0.3002252281,
0.412486583,
-0.2544765174,
0.1430069059,
-0.8547431231,
-0.673961401,
-0.4022272229,
-0.1769218296,
-0.0631069914,
-0.0725906342,
0.7110818028,
0.4239752591,
-0.4059250951,
0.0218585618,
-0.4335266352,
0.5903778672,
0.6587306261,
0.6893863082,
0.3416566253,
0.1452058256,
-0.2677699029,
0.0747611374,
-0.8746742606,
-0.0917561203,
0.8194559813,
-0.0076928479,
0.5785731077,
0.4834621549,
0.1456836909,
0.2717610896,
0.4869191051,
-0.7829090357,
0.5273650289,
0.1364860982,
-0.775219202,
-0.3695741594,
-0.5996790528,
-0.6971248388,
0.4357378185,
-0.0593533404,
-0.2824403346,
0.2471769601,
-0.1277903765,
-0.2256950885,
-0.0346365608,
-0.8056796193,
0.4340910912,
0.0164238084,
-0.1260416657,
-0.0395489372,
-0.7745938301,
0.1232386306,
0.3038591743,
0.026107477,
0.2231063247,
0.3517688513,
0.8834340572,
-0.5634332895,
0.6441555023,
-0.3867419064,
0.33763659,
0.5234888792,
0.0981371105,
0.7876517177,
-0.3214015663,
-0.2688891292,
-0.2482223958,
-0.0476956926,
-0.5056831241,
-0.8341645598,
0.1114383638,
-0.9431568384,
-0.7563922405,
-0.2188894302,
-0.4185687304,
-0.2308832407,
0.2070688307,
0.120787628,
0.7483089566,
0.1164562628,
0.3092444241,
0.8207879663,
0.1384063214,
0.0857257545,
0.69586128,
0.2399430573,
-0.5521920323,
0.490632534,
0.4622160494,
0.2821675241,
0.8305433989,
0.4183647633,
-0.2529127598,
-0.6532093287,
-0.3786280453,
-0.0579976477,
-0.9598294497,
-0.4458549321,
-0.9049548507,
-0.2122826129,
-0.3894610107,
0.1927379817,
0.0313586295,
-0.5398784876,
0.3545391858,
-0.3727756143,
0.579310298,
0.6191653609,
0.0888725072,
-0.0973498672,
-0.789768815,
0.3682433665,
0.6324768066,
0.0186623465,
0.2925451696,
-0.3691561222,
-0.1023270637,
-0.0551358834,
-0.1261742562,
-0.8800278902,
-0.1253673136,
0.1483795345,
0.7994169593,
0.2378165722,
0.4061601758,
1.1767271757,
-0.4402284622,
0.4618038237,
-0.0454741083,
-0.6177275181,
0.5900751948,
-0.2279730737,
-0.0926485211,
0.361536622,
0.8155837655,
-0.3674148321,
-0.1955234706,
-0.2565256953,
-0.9238836765,
0.7123272419,
0.0897198617,
-0.2506195307,
-0.0108818561,
0.7087048888,
-0.195316419,
-0.0827903077,
-0.4146705866,
-0.3080994487,
-0.1593354046,
-0.234707728,
0.7048184872,
-0.516202867,
-0.4586748481,
-0.25801,
0.580578804,
-0.0693806782,
0.2911428213,
0.8625830412,
-0.0642976388,
-0.2674377859,
0.199847579,
0.0344700888,
0.8007732034,
-0.2619069815,
0.3886756599,
0.062103495,
-0.6171721816,
0.239122048,
-0.0146776428,
-0.3780087233,
-0.0627903119,
0.7072398067,
0.3054902554,
-0.1935608983,
-0.4708982408,
0.509645462,
-0.0435706526,
0.0265561957,
-0.2915999591,
0.0410368629,
-0.0568518154,
0.563598752,
0.734341979,
-0.2162789702,
0.3882311881,
-0.8187810779,
0.3867449164,
0.3417600989,
-0.4985236824,
-0.1113501415,
0.2718318105,
-0.1037894115,
-0.2493107468,
0.8176733851,
-0.1626988351,
-0.814683497,
0.9582039118,
0.7786357403,
0.2458379269,
-0.2479993403,
0.1145943925,
0.5166584849,
0.1027391627,
-0.1683529615,
0.8220534325,
-0.0741693899,
-0.8443652391,
-0.5123534799,
-0.5069140792,
-0.3658534884,
-0.2501086295,
-0.7214871645,
-0.0048081614,
-0.3948806226,
0.2857971787,
0.1288102865,
-0.058732938,
-0.0759115517,
0.2040253878,
-0.3206840158,
0.7829723358,
-0.7362987399,
0.4377171099,
0.8725866079,
-0.4496522546,
-1.2529337406,
-0.2465732098,
-0.0944433436,
-0.6645822525,
1.0083616972,
0.0230943598,
-0.1200413778,
0.1966016442,
-0.6906852126,
-0.9467235804,
1.3618344069,
0.0913650841,
-0.075049229,
0.1085156053,
-0.0439470932,
0.325131923,
-0.1457474828,
0.6562006474,
0.0847302154,
0.4681091309,
0.5183750391,
-0.3716613352,
0.541249752,
-0.5363313556,
-0.0932553411,
0.6256558299,
-0.6617719531,
0.972345829,
-0.0814228877,
-0.486138612,
0.0220162068,
0.5196073055,
0.3139077723,
0.4297341406,
0.7305527329,
0.7364451289,
0.6882721186,
-0.0630863905,
0.8828445077,
-0.2368493378,
0.2852977216,
0.8892081976,
-0.1719706208,
0.7627965808,
0.3779647648,
-0.1959547102,
0.8990339637,
0.7083098292,
0.2249463946,
0.8977336884,
0.3032653928,
-0.219168961,
-0.6459285617,
-0.4850713611,
-0.3910142481,
0.4276493192,
0.3143946528,
-0.2084377408,
-0.2965855896,
-0.2947111428,
0.2199785709,
-0.0729291141,
-0.3774187863,
0.8318633437,
-0.0942971036,
-0.8166300058,
0.2423418313,
-0.0712769628,
0.1173003316,
-0.753133893,
-0.7429295778,
-0.193973884,
0.2495185584,
-0.3433472514,
-0.4823722243,
0.020625161,
-0.2725763917,
-0.4042136669,
0.0463421047,
0.817402184,
-0.1803272814,
-0.2544542551,
0.3201399148,
0.5659729838,
-0.1019917205,
0.1029897109,
-0.2857390344,
-0.6191784739,
-0.1548958868,
-0.4975403249,
0.3239935338,
0.7094874978,
-0.0960811973,
0.4319342077,
0.9968721271,
-0.2622505426,
0.0675758421,
-0.0354135893,
1.0904234648,
-0.5204072595,
-0.2798927128,
-0.7714937925,
0.3345896602,
-0.2855145335,
-0.1270957291,
0.797169745,
0.6426638961,
0.8192208409,
0.3494659662,
0.6507920027,
-0.5781661868,
0.5286214352,
-0.748288393,
0.4889467359,
-0.3544392884,
0.1269417256,
-0.2232459038,
-0.5340570211,
-0.4213351011,
0.5106540322,
-0.1677228659,
-0.1841576099,
0.6210641265,
1.1204936504,
-0.127824083,
0.241796121,
-0.0202599503,
0.6100637317,
0.3312560022,
0.4483265877,
1.142360568,
-0.5196791887,
0.8025379181,
-0.2748979628,
-0.3216845989,
-0.0842048898,
-0.4822635055,
-0.6778796911,
-0.3750634193,
-0.1278776526,
-0.6962974668,
0.1921823323,
0.8081635237,
0.6945849657,
-0.8626617193,
0.0614772029,
-0.2044042349,
0.3221611083,
-0.3548320234,
-0.2595889568,
0.5773035288,
-0.0465407446,
-0.1696601808,
0.265496105,
0.0566909462,
-0.2435825467,
0.2773309946,
0.0141937798,
-0.6887097955,
-0.1278879493,
0.7117522955,
0.1753759384,
-0.4000447392,
-0.626368165,
0.2756276727,
0.0888675749,
0.1838054508,
0.9750068784,
-0.6206197143,
0.4116659164,
1.1195501089,
0.6370187998,
0.6790017486,
0.3701459765,
0.4445667267,
-0.5969976187,
-0.1609930545,
0.2260058969,
0.2840560973,
0.0828763619,
-0.6009474397,
0.7434331775,
0.3200085759,
-0.472168833,
-0.6807050109,
0.5829851031,
-0.8241368532,
-0.5810470581,
0.9592410326,
-0.3871764839,
-0.2669069469,
-0.8619123697,
-0.129997611,
0.3903400898,
-0.1378958225,
0.8049197793,
0.8152063489,
-0.6684451699,
-0.0997589976,
-0.1865546256,
0.0781098828,
0.2209881246,
-0.5291044116,
-0.3007296324,
0.4376339614,
0.4248095751,
0.5926286578,
0.7519395351,
-0.3091059327,
0.3016162217,
0.1279021949,
-0.1719530672,
-0.4351665974,
-0.350502938,
0.285164386,
0.6961705685,
-0.007980966,
0.0257441793
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02145v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02145v1
|
Analyzing Sentiment Polarity Reduction in News Presentation through Contextual Perturbation and Large Language Models
| 2024-02-03T13:27:32 | 2024-02-03T13:27:32 |
Alapan Kuila, Somnath Jena, Sudeshna Sarkar, Partha Pratim Chakrabarti
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In today's media landscape, where news outlets play a pivotal role in shaping
public opinion, it is imperative to address the issue of sentiment manipulation
within news text. News writers often inject their own biases and emotional
language, which can distort the objectivity of reporting. This paper introduces
a novel approach to tackle this problem by reducing the polarity of latent
sentiments in news content. Drawing inspiration from adversarial attack-based
sentence perturbation techniques and a prompt based method using ChatGPT, we
employ transformation constraints to modify sentences while preserving their
core semantics. Using three perturbation methods: replacement, insertion, and
deletion coupled with a context-aware masked language model, we aim to maximize
the desired sentiment score for targeted news aspects through a beam search
algorithm. Our experiments and human evaluations demonstrate the effectiveness
of these two models in achieving reduced sentiment polarity with minimal
modifications while maintaining textual similarity, fluency, and grammatical
correctness. Comparative analysis confirms the competitive performance of the
adversarial attack based perturbation methods and prompt-based methods,
offering a promising solution to foster more objective news reporting and
combat emotional language bias in the media.
|
[
-0.6503757238,
-0.919685781,
0.3849705458,
0.2951419652,
-0.604578197,
0.0038272894,
-0.3291435838,
0.2386075258,
0.3937078118,
0.5775369406,
-0.6386779547,
-0.8066158295,
-0.5433114767,
-0.0447445102,
-0.2499696016,
1.3127317429,
0.0786207318,
0.3257047236,
-0.0707383081,
-0.2956511378,
-0.2755636871,
-0.7244068384,
-0.4201058149,
-0.0663807467,
0.4241256714,
0.2342309207,
0.9399471283,
0.0240365509,
0.5695755482,
0.0677957237,
-0.5677184463,
-0.332074374,
-0.4919753969,
0.0511493534,
-0.2133766264,
-0.5489333868,
-0.4079684317,
0.4354302585,
0.5235795975,
0.6204463243,
0.1705500335,
0.0092175519,
0.0459052548,
0.757866025,
-0.4596405327,
0.1330884695,
-0.6020442247,
0.3146556318,
-0.1548840553,
-0.4115762115,
-0.5065476298,
0.0557024963,
-0.1038823798,
-0.2947100997,
0.3079356849,
-0.1528454125,
0.8832133412,
0.3718319237,
-0.5970259309,
0.1113035977,
-0.5563514233,
0.9072876573,
-0.7880948186,
0.1923903525,
0.0382386036,
-0.1280256957,
-0.0257015657,
-0.0640936196,
-0.5609843135,
-0.1388173103,
-0.0060366932,
0.3839074671,
-0.1520920396,
0.1567404866,
0.2364064455,
0.2282347679,
-0.5141156912,
-0.3398562372,
0.0741777122,
-0.1090140641,
0.3756572604,
-0.1096218228,
0.2769455314,
-0.7431343794,
-0.390798986,
-0.2478775084,
-0.8328588605,
0.1995606422,
0.3776478171,
0.1876620948,
0.0444873683,
0.6201228499,
-0.2304372936,
0.3166465461,
0.2054916471,
-0.1068797037,
0.2093335986,
-0.0606720857,
-0.0847163945,
0.1000979394,
0.5705258846,
0.8692851663,
-0.4033662081,
0.1115101427,
-0.1514806151,
0.2348280102,
0.115674302,
-0.6747983098,
0.1123804525,
-0.0502740555,
-0.7692430019,
-0.7957430482,
0.1360813677,
-1.0214055777,
-0.8297298551,
-0.2202005237,
0.1367031336,
-0.0136513235,
-0.0192706697,
0.0045479452,
0.026406575,
0.250169307,
0.383949697,
-0.2495626956,
-0.063884519,
0.6690295935,
0.6849132776,
0.0405246578,
0.1968952566,
-0.5121354461,
0.0282598026,
-0.1927152872,
0.4544234574,
-0.5964309573,
-0.2677164078,
-0.1366787851,
-0.3584095836,
0.273786366,
-0.2029360682,
0.5939294696,
-0.7897075415,
0.6483135223,
-0.2732435167,
-0.246234104,
-0.3106595576,
0.4007600546,
-0.5648430586,
0.2542322278,
0.0371184722,
-1.1554324627,
0.0804154873,
-0.4273309708,
-0.6804932952,
-0.4438057542,
0.0838486031,
-0.5142646432,
0.376173228,
0.7465490699,
0.3275673985,
-0.1152993217,
0.238126874,
-0.1872826815,
-0.0518732071,
0.1957904249,
-0.4048787951,
0.505505383,
0.2050906271,
-0.468033731,
0.276517719,
-0.4225884676,
-0.6110295653,
-0.0587037615,
-0.2188997269,
-0.4490244687,
0.3423449099,
0.0615133718,
0.3608206809,
0.1940666586,
-0.4623697698,
0.3744630814,
-0.7808274627,
0.5262474418,
0.5695179701,
0.2229943424,
0.7842991948,
-0.0341957435,
0.5435097218,
0.2279070467,
0.5615121722,
-0.0520328879,
-0.3089012802,
-0.6108093262,
-0.1685408056,
-0.1402016878,
0.6779331565,
-0.9881203175,
0.0738975033,
-0.142694965,
-0.0622456186,
-0.442717731,
0.0965657458,
0.260453552,
0.7356222272,
0.4419429004,
-0.1839241087,
-0.6228832603,
-0.8769971132,
-0.4947357178,
-0.2221987098,
0.0590497106,
0.0991719142,
-0.2449504584,
-0.1226953417,
1.0799707174,
-0.4970206022,
-0.2776210308,
-0.3033350408,
0.428273499,
0.5221592784,
0.2163514644,
0.6348934174,
-1.2413702011,
-0.4041272998,
-0.1748239696,
-0.5308083296,
-0.1803806573,
-0.1919881999,
0.1659734547,
0.4683299065,
0.5270034671,
-0.7020745873,
0.5714120865,
0.6519010067,
-0.3872399032,
0.360676378,
0.5611824393,
0.4136251509,
-0.928306222,
-0.0725630969,
-0.1060881838,
-0.4261338711,
-0.5357359052,
0.0778135583,
-0.3033338189,
-0.438896358,
-0.5169836879,
0.4276582003,
-0.3180297315,
0.3579989374,
-0.330550313,
0.183478266,
0.2736746669,
0.3673811257,
-0.0941741094,
0.5433511734,
0.4451108277,
-0.0867078081,
0.2561123371,
0.318530947,
0.1614977866,
0.5777049065,
-0.4023616612,
0.0730337277,
-0.7389145494,
0.5703907013,
-0.9674190879,
0.0380196124,
0.3832318783,
-0.5043498278,
0.2392076701,
-0.2285640091,
-0.1706927717,
0.0312433839,
-0.7377303839,
0.2475528121,
0.4919736981,
-0.313441813,
0.506254375,
0.2463535666,
-0.4810705185,
-0.7033364177,
-0.6462410092,
0.469072789,
-0.266643405,
-0.6833108068,
0.4810634553,
-0.1808288246,
-0.4138709307,
-0.0563045666,
-0.1924651265,
0.3347832859,
-0.0509293787,
0.0325923525,
0.4309100807,
-0.2327563763,
0.2247906327,
0.2051424533,
-0.0343684182,
0.0442908965,
-0.0233130585,
0.7014209628,
-0.2377908677,
-0.1659038216,
-0.4663491249,
0.4656830728,
0.7113277912,
-0.20651263,
0.8857416511,
0.6500222683,
-0.0206784252,
0.0554147735,
-0.701631844,
-0.3232596815,
-0.3804992735,
0.521466434,
-0.1420225948,
-0.8040946126,
0.4180286825,
0.2128382921,
-0.3204337358,
0.1821725667,
0.5421934724,
0.2125516981,
1.4804506302,
0.1490362883,
-0.5114474297,
0.7389422059,
0.1385314912,
0.6039600372,
-0.5857257843,
0.2108199745,
-0.1258476526,
0.0288195126,
-0.3045191169,
-0.2904254496,
0.6607283354,
0.1254618615,
0.1268674284,
-0.081527926,
-0.450071007,
0.3025782108,
0.1512459666,
0.3975761831,
0.2040393949,
-0.0141157275,
0.3093592525,
-0.248649478,
-0.4956827164,
-0.5344827175,
0.8626687527,
0.4996698797,
0.5158895254,
-0.0371819586,
0.5459342599,
0.2281618267,
0.4911769629,
-0.7897603512,
0.6238801479,
-0.3823448122,
-0.2963222265,
-0.1482793093,
-0.5780374408,
-0.4182348251,
0.2716825604,
-0.2657804191,
-0.3431504071,
-0.0439194739,
-0.0563478097,
0.0188230872,
0.3095839024,
-0.5347100496,
0.5029712915,
0.1261515915,
-0.4777373075,
-0.5057319999,
-0.4647588432,
0.2851071358,
0.445489198,
0.5845717788,
-0.1649765968,
-0.0995892659,
0.4564152658,
-0.2307058126,
0.9096526504,
-0.4613106847,
-0.0369358808,
0.1700394899,
0.1654052138,
0.5757716298,
0.4787634313,
-0.0790871084,
-0.0374089964,
-0.4532769322,
-0.4322384298,
-0.6852430105,
0.7154098153,
-0.7662751675,
-1.009188056,
-0.0358287171,
-0.4686623812,
-0.3669144511,
0.0318518989,
0.2331952006,
0.5290622711,
-0.3008974195,
0.1950691789,
0.6284204721,
-0.3173536956,
0.4446991086,
0.1943493187,
-0.158404991,
-0.6298339963,
0.7781517506,
-0.14008753,
-0.0275851879,
0.5801924467,
0.3164609969,
-0.0934679359,
-0.5191627145,
0.0664283782,
0.2131954134,
-0.8407787085,
-0.2028868496,
-0.4208229184,
0.2373108715,
-0.8100286722,
-0.4888848364,
-0.4330378473,
-0.4825244546,
-0.4073466659,
0.0203324314,
-0.0801663995,
0.3381021023,
0.2485673726,
0.4371804595,
-0.6749927402,
0.2617483139,
0.357938379,
0.0676311478,
-0.4085517526,
-0.4692857265,
0.1534145921,
-0.0571120344,
-0.317189604,
-1.1948467493,
0.7768527865,
-0.1955983043,
0.2914102972,
0.3790452778,
0.3921407759,
0.0764101446,
-0.1201589704,
0.9754210711,
0.3929739892,
-1.3280608654,
0.9036223888,
-0.6260196567,
0.1713724881,
0.4047035277,
0.1862057,
-0.4284560084,
-0.5907007456,
-0.6079175472,
-0.9927621484,
0.4887585044,
0.2100273073,
0.1295788437,
0.0114074526,
0.3088412881,
-0.0912515223,
0.5256343484,
-0.9245637655,
-0.1067120731,
-0.6696537137,
-0.3209303617,
-0.181968376,
-0.5155006647,
-0.3695991933,
-0.1778172106,
0.8713111281,
-0.0546967499,
0.0378719047,
0.4929229021,
-0.2594255805,
0.0906157717,
0.6118802428,
0.535822928,
0.1332608759,
-0.2238322943,
0.2917250991,
-0.0764896795,
-0.3058025837,
0.0173056498,
-0.039591562,
-0.5203654766,
0.1772222668,
0.1489450783,
0.8078250885,
0.1252294183,
-0.2981390059,
0.9679489136,
-0.151977405,
0.2390210927,
0.0180300195,
-0.4942779541,
-0.2388889343,
0.3370200098,
0.4172528088,
0.3381421864,
0.3487579823,
-0.5760002732,
-0.0637831762,
0.5192011595,
-0.5861015916,
-0.4862747192,
0.593647182,
0.3909059167,
-0.1002007574,
0.2598514855,
-0.2440823764,
-0.7777308822,
0.2987516224,
0.2166490853,
0.8650866151,
-0.2772774994,
0.631885469,
0.1106723472,
0.2309549004,
0.0398886204,
-0.1252120286,
0.1138449907,
-0.7473697662,
-0.5380479097,
-0.4367189109,
-0.3518252373,
0.0671344548,
-0.6879114509,
0.4353966713,
-0.6328062415,
-0.325551033,
-0.1071999595,
-0.060414277,
-0.099847801,
0.1991992891,
0.4784278572,
0.3332550526,
-0.8320338726,
0.3547903597,
1.1319737434,
-0.583792448,
-0.4018569887,
0.3987881541,
0.2061156332,
-0.2101864815,
0.3772416711,
0.1290824562,
-0.0748546943,
-0.1917160749,
-0.9114764333,
-0.3124271631,
0.4892311096,
0.6477610469,
-0.2613045573,
0.1459554881,
0.0095812269,
0.4685579836,
-0.3459402025,
0.0271827504,
0.1528160572,
0.6358000636,
0.013962687,
-0.604950726,
0.2398770005,
-0.2337678671,
0.1094327495,
-0.0803605914,
-0.8288568854,
1.053040266,
0.279568404,
-0.2607408464,
-0.4331502914,
0.5162159801,
-0.090835616,
0.3605646491,
0.5396361351,
0.0598044917,
0.1980719864,
0.1178862005,
0.8779773712,
-0.4179078043,
0.7121403813,
0.4544561505,
-0.3310213387,
0.6018890142,
0.8838130236,
0.0679492429,
0.4978588521,
-0.0793596283,
0.3763614297,
0.6131238341,
0.0285678878,
-0.5099246502,
-0.2761283517,
-0.3464290202,
-0.0429815203,
0.4971488416,
0.1021203995,
-0.2342185825,
-0.2491056621,
0.614597261,
0.6101815104,
0.4772360623,
-0.4908729196,
0.4566257894,
-0.059005186,
-0.7198204398,
0.3774214983,
0.2138258815,
0.747166574,
-0.1663536429,
0.1760797948,
-0.3189426661,
0.1574624479,
-0.3501253426,
-0.586959362,
0.4103378952,
-0.2326580286,
-0.5419623256,
-0.5206441879,
0.8073493242,
-0.2509119213,
-0.2802665532,
0.2840195298,
0.2413077801,
-0.3721079528,
-0.5905762911,
-0.3911183774,
0.1335437298,
0.2072523236,
-0.7219507098,
0.3467226923,
0.1211623773,
0.1098003164,
0.230216831,
0.4937354922,
0.2195441574,
-0.2914753258,
0.303797394,
1.204110384,
-0.656771183,
-0.6193903089,
-0.6359376311,
0.3404696882,
-0.2042606771,
-0.0501481816,
0.6345965266,
0.2092468292,
0.3848355711,
-0.2888747752,
0.7921651006,
0.0075715194,
0.5168499947,
-0.7058662772,
0.7493618131,
-0.3485604525,
0.4903710783,
-0.5082939267,
-0.7168961763,
-0.7177295685,
0.5845395327,
-0.6545046568,
-0.3763932884,
0.6360836029,
0.9592477083,
0.334798187,
-0.0049283933,
0.2672210932,
0.4846009314,
0.4511017799,
0.3409404457,
0.9454351664,
-0.292019695,
0.6642256975,
-0.3447559774,
-0.5092836618,
-0.3047819734,
-0.8831654191,
-1.0047669411,
-0.3718686104,
-0.4653124213,
-0.454285264,
0.3194385767,
0.673663497,
0.4765890241,
-0.8943412304,
0.2092300951,
-0.1213002875,
0.3355419934,
-0.0026874549,
-0.3644559383,
0.2981836498,
-0.4341752827,
-0.5126391053,
0.4018777907,
0.3548099995,
-0.3312708437,
-0.3605805039,
0.1988143325,
-0.0360412598,
0.1828672886,
0.8074131012,
0.0042972015,
-0.5156520009,
-0.4482203722,
0.0865961164,
-0.12343885,
0.3144614995,
0.9068546295,
-0.790656209,
0.2369004488,
0.7718017697,
0.1604129225,
0.3671955764,
0.4138709903,
0.3096784055,
-1.0227538347,
0.6024953723,
0.4953882098,
0.0848743841,
0.4832295477,
-0.6472851634,
0.0386737473,
0.5194974542,
-0.2148153633,
-0.6783936024,
0.363019526,
-1.1761460304,
-0.46647802,
1.3166998625,
0.0934766009,
-0.3098326027,
0.0840037242,
-0.5172331333,
0.2234571427,
-0.593644619,
0.8995146155,
0.6859813929,
-0.0786647946,
-0.2633240223,
-0.1785249561,
0.2832093835,
0.7556483746,
-0.4876390994,
-0.1221181452,
0.6063942909,
-0.0168288909,
0.2611016929,
0.3115186393,
-0.3948793411,
-0.0197864603,
-0.0851145983,
0.2025019228,
-0.0442058183,
-0.1411365718,
-0.4836883545,
0.5561226606,
-0.1639812142,
0.0145789655
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02144v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02144v1
|
Probing Critical Learning Dynamics of PLMs for Hate Speech Detection
| 2024-02-03T13:23:51 | 2024-02-03T13:23:51 |
Sarah Masud, Mohammad Aflah Khan, Vikram Goyal, Md Shad Akhtar, Tanmoy Chakraborty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite the widespread adoption, there is a lack of research into how various
critical aspects of pretrained language models (PLMs) affect their performance
in hate speech detection. Through five research questions, our findings and
recommendations lay the groundwork for empirically investigating different
aspects of PLMs' use in hate speech detection. We deep dive into comparing
different pretrained models, evaluating their seed robustness, finetuning
settings, and the impact of pretraining data collection time. Our analysis
reveals early peaks for downstream tasks during pretraining, the limited
benefit of employing a more recent pretraining corpus, and the significance of
specific layers during finetuning. We further call into question the use of
domain-specific models and highlight the need for dynamic datasets for
benchmarking hate speech detection.
|
[
-0.5045887232,
-0.7599292994,
0.197487101,
-0.3033798933,
-0.2250903696,
0.2239807248,
-0.1747946888,
-0.4633194208,
-0.2547003031,
0.4876286387,
-0.6938591599,
-0.3108635843,
-0.9131898284,
-0.1506160349,
-0.699290514,
1.1922878027,
0.239424035,
0.1607046723,
0.2009922117,
-0.2276488245,
-0.1679442376,
-0.755658567,
-0.6705599427,
-0.3538961411,
0.6250388622,
0.3352558017,
0.5312162042,
0.4483609498,
0.4712363183,
0.1836633235,
-0.2714953721,
-0.1844904572,
-0.9777332544,
0.3166291416,
-0.0634441599,
-0.5194759369,
-0.0687921792,
0.4864281714,
0.6919509768,
0.6190200448,
0.0558189154,
0.2524753809,
0.1232392713,
0.3505377769,
-0.6411907077,
-0.369743228,
-0.8453764319,
0.1682415903,
-0.5193629861,
-0.0019523434,
-0.237817198,
-0.3571083546,
0.6185860038,
-0.3857889175,
0.4183124304,
-0.1338541806,
0.5918111205,
0.2386468351,
-0.2727484405,
-0.3464179039,
-0.9308639169,
0.840164721,
-0.6412366629,
0.410941869,
0.2779720128,
0.0475177132,
0.0879479945,
-0.8306897879,
-0.4475446939,
-0.4443941116,
0.2711182833,
-0.0792021453,
-0.0108377403,
0.2846843898,
0.5621593595,
0.4615922868,
-0.3910419345,
0.4255613089,
-0.3651651144,
-0.2294652909,
0.5005403757,
0.2507224977,
0.140191406,
0.1227980107,
-0.4164716601,
-0.1854988039,
-0.5722626448,
0.1566584557,
0.7405750751,
0.42951262,
-0.1443289369,
0.1153332666,
0.3000016809,
0.6189513803,
-0.1587865353,
-0.0822184682,
0.3192357719,
-0.0912337527,
-0.0470969304,
-0.1708521992,
0.7307161689,
0.2824245393,
0.5742474198,
-0.1162725016,
-0.2837819159,
0.3082277477,
0.5374863148,
-0.8576877117,
-0.3205397427,
0.1553984582,
-0.3051221669,
-0.4909653366,
-0.3711083233,
-0.6990282536,
-0.8126642108,
-0.4197648764,
0.3214467764,
-0.5841109753,
-0.5680004358,
-0.0519635417,
-0.1975032687,
0.1798186153,
0.1787213683,
-0.5188202262,
0.257796824,
0.5214337707,
0.7293476462,
-0.5916551352,
-0.207777217,
-0.4274229705,
-0.3378021419,
-0.2107996494,
0.5235361457,
-0.7501743436,
-0.2509229779,
0.2263967544,
-0.1297780871,
-0.0689773709,
-0.9632398486,
0.7290904522,
-0.617200911,
-0.1172356829,
-0.2563185096,
-0.6522591114,
-0.2677788734,
0.1639767736,
-0.3507587314,
0.8281021714,
0.0190383308,
-0.766939342,
0.5674456358,
-0.488848865,
-0.4346255362,
0.0375401825,
-0.2120886743,
-0.7116697431,
0.1994298995,
-0.3973858654,
0.4219348133,
0.05586344,
0.2588267028,
-0.5916293263,
-0.158127889,
0.2895388305,
-0.2938519716,
1.0161392689,
0.5160807967,
-0.5845144391,
0.3018548489,
-0.955419302,
-0.4022560418,
0.2691252828,
-0.1324249357,
-0.288605243,
0.3224829733,
0.059110824,
0.1937965006,
-0.1658214629,
-0.6106786132,
-0.3749007285,
-0.2073169649,
0.3846836388,
0.7900928855,
-0.200401485,
0.1984417439,
-0.3743908107,
0.7419961691,
0.2713071108,
0.157114327,
0.1489712745,
-0.2002476752,
-0.7412983179,
0.2182661444,
0.1519292295,
0.4879641235,
-0.3080534637,
-0.1020995453,
0.369132787,
-0.3439384699,
-0.3210641742,
0.0502705015,
0.4883814752,
0.4743237793,
0.3416120708,
-0.4710961282,
-0.8288789392,
-0.6562698483,
-0.5201193094,
0.1005437598,
0.284863472,
0.2742339969,
0.5659128428,
0.1160588264,
0.7234049439,
-0.1899642497,
-0.276753217,
-0.2971167862,
0.5802246332,
-0.2292957306,
0.4804559052,
0.7882168293,
-0.8520336151,
-0.6294477582,
-0.6438254714,
-0.2759719491,
-0.263741225,
0.2208776623,
0.3048678935,
-0.3156549335,
0.5400905013,
0.0982263014,
0.3463376164,
0.566501379,
-0.0467354618,
0.8111285567,
0.4293511212,
0.0498559847,
-0.5073383451,
-0.0783160031,
-0.0595677644,
-0.2452317327,
-1.1709311008,
0.0838463828,
-0.2958019972,
-0.2974507213,
-0.8502725959,
-0.1220872179,
-0.3443466127,
-0.0176603775,
-0.4626170099,
0.1806673259,
-0.601999104,
0.229066506,
0.0296761096,
0.7950441837,
0.5910524726,
-0.9043920636,
0.0586829334,
-0.2403633147,
-0.6185251474,
0.2425704002,
-0.4232573211,
0.2970247567,
-0.216057688,
-0.1655664295,
-0.929033637,
0.0344146751,
0.2536702752,
-0.4759497643,
0.150444746,
-0.3721938431,
-0.2176185697,
-0.3941678107,
-0.2643890679,
0.4785467088,
0.4863628149,
-0.1248203069,
0.3710670471,
0.8661054969,
0.0392600037,
-0.4762854278,
-0.369317919,
-0.4432339966,
-0.5080123544,
-0.3062367141,
0.2410011142,
-0.1990723014,
-0.3666381836,
-0.4259457886,
-0.1576809883,
-0.1472276747,
0.5465272665,
0.3690701723,
-0.2388667613,
-0.2561453581,
-0.1943126619,
-0.4193167984,
0.1233555526,
0.3465131521,
-0.0783597231,
0.6935457587,
0.0577519275,
0.0925430134,
-0.4930538237,
0.0642734692,
0.7111207843,
-0.246268034,
0.7616577148,
0.7925806046,
-0.3102149963,
-0.4279525578,
-0.5102751255,
-0.2029635757,
-0.4632560611,
0.2419140935,
-0.1652724296,
-1.2963058949,
0.6659594178,
-0.0934556723,
0.0000414283,
0.1903730333,
0.5103693604,
-0.1167335287,
1.0566197634,
0.6779803634,
0.0262636319,
0.9149208069,
-0.21453619,
0.0246610362,
-0.4659646153,
-0.0964877531,
-0.6439330578,
-0.2750652134,
-0.3446011245,
-0.2955772579,
0.338786602,
0.0171099175,
-0.3778191507,
-0.0165908411,
-0.3468716443,
0.4737023115,
0.3812904656,
-0.0134215988,
-0.0732380226,
0.0602415577,
-0.1265102923,
-0.319329232,
-0.4421447515,
-0.2556355894,
1.1235131025,
0.4656640887,
0.5744809508,
-0.0644702241,
0.1305307895,
0.2115030736,
0.3414898515,
-0.5205199718,
0.4511182904,
-0.3737348318,
-0.9214618206,
-0.1606429964,
-0.2981673181,
-0.8564141989,
0.1806922555,
-0.2556833029,
-0.5966604352,
0.1142955348,
0.3043674529,
-0.7973930836,
0.4885234833,
-0.5661196113,
0.9560021758,
-0.1562598795,
-0.2742994428,
-0.3688773215,
-0.6154260039,
0.4364888966,
-0.1721465737,
0.32325387,
-0.4044281244,
0.3235923648,
1.3835517168,
-0.330565691,
1.0741100311,
-0.498033911,
-0.1542821974,
0.531201005,
0.1382243186,
0.2830833197,
-0.4502637088,
0.0090660565,
0.04788417,
-0.1513042599,
-0.1357451379,
-0.1122261211,
0.4713433981,
-0.7905957699,
-0.5715656877,
-0.4173384011,
-0.5549086928,
-0.3825897872,
0.2098434865,
0.3111545444,
0.323928833,
-0.2002684474,
0.3296218812,
0.9724584222,
-0.2570735216,
0.2381507307,
0.879704237,
-0.2746152878,
-0.1184207276,
0.8104453683,
0.4844044745,
0.3361978829,
-0.0249850024,
0.2846969366,
-0.0433027409,
-1.198497057,
-0.0220255479,
0.1089594886,
-0.1881403774,
0.0759780109,
-0.7535367608,
-0.2826139033,
-0.6227018237,
0.184007898,
-0.579315424,
0.106304124,
-0.4479759932,
-0.1107129157,
0.1898732781,
1.0401217937,
-0.3117952049,
0.7505096793,
-0.4956513345,
0.4342827499,
0.2543661892,
0.4800044,
0.0804321542,
-1.0634212494,
-0.3538256884,
0.0253896303,
-0.4654476345,
-1.1374592781,
0.3665751517,
0.0095075881,
0.4217391312,
0.6049702764,
0.2597549558,
0.5564526916,
-0.5294142365,
0.831653595,
0.021642901,
-0.7913129926,
0.7171035409,
-0.3734497726,
-0.1807479262,
0.6660805345,
1.0668315887,
-0.2861715555,
-0.3745717108,
-0.5817127228,
-0.5867795348,
0.9407735467,
-0.0295473766,
0.0295719188,
0.2084070295,
0.2570235133,
0.1668049246,
0.2303287387,
-0.7546161413,
-0.6867100596,
-0.079440169,
0.1485057026,
-0.2691692412,
-0.7709884048,
-0.1081482917,
-0.4711480439,
0.4472304285,
0.3749933243,
-0.1363962293,
-0.189003855,
-0.2805379033,
-0.0425112583,
0.0383191705,
0.6689794064,
0.567412138,
-0.4416713417,
0.0237118471,
0.051483795,
-0.7083128095,
0.1905911118,
-0.0946175158,
-0.2424024642,
0.0001416139,
0.0733202025,
1.0258221626,
0.2104668468,
-0.6285974979,
0.7084645629,
0.1023036465,
-0.3542969525,
-0.4391295314,
0.2033772022,
-0.3889714181,
0.1725743264,
0.1296204627,
0.0072116298,
0.1022396311,
-0.4121437967,
0.3366542459,
0.3942798376,
-0.5913178921,
-0.5708609223,
0.7437084317,
0.2243738621,
-0.3653831184,
0.5496940017,
-0.105147846,
-0.9603697062,
0.4060635567,
0.530987978,
0.6713936329,
-0.6112779379,
0.1793281287,
0.119987078,
0.4362229407,
0.2501575947,
0.1834455878,
-0.1017644182,
-0.9845237136,
-0.3764687479,
-0.692804873,
-0.452296555,
0.8309171796,
-0.6846714616,
0.0853951648,
-0.7069801688,
-0.3066547215,
0.0640184581,
-0.0138312485,
-0.6344618797,
0.3220150769,
0.6853530407,
0.801451087,
-1.091406703,
0.696470499,
0.5571865439,
-0.4419923127,
-0.715624392,
-0.2200797647,
0.3237914741,
-0.7792807221,
0.7340834141,
0.1678233743,
-0.2062971592,
0.1218548268,
-0.7765887976,
-0.7688856721,
0.3897135854,
0.4401067495,
-0.4746085405,
-0.0088110929,
0.322591573,
0.5049830079,
-0.3073093593,
0.1516901404,
0.7579000592,
0.1489722878,
-0.2121035457,
-0.7319188714,
-0.3945707381,
0.0469251312,
-0.3283526897,
0.0750061795,
-0.5560483336,
1.0311276913,
0.0785967335,
-0.4834560454,
-0.3256295323,
0.6091836095,
-0.0906395242,
0.2983113229,
0.7045563459,
0.8574371934,
0.6445502043,
0.1090502515,
0.8154874444,
-0.2026631683,
0.2531377673,
1.2048544884,
-0.2741309404,
0.6923894286,
0.025818795,
-0.3452361226,
0.440736264,
0.647352159,
0.1745638251,
0.4308176935,
0.5531172156,
-0.3748244345,
-0.3980214298,
-0.3613367081,
-0.5297003388,
0.3033067882,
0.6304432154,
-0.4478146732,
-0.1750058681,
0.3946540654,
0.1362284124,
-0.0232377276,
-0.5295054913,
0.6306341887,
0.1068809032,
-0.3822080493,
0.5519390106,
-0.2069232911,
0.9576809406,
-0.5864197016,
0.3696843982,
-0.1097599939,
0.2613086998,
-0.1352410167,
-0.6342984438,
0.3642376661,
0.3027409315,
-0.154219836,
-0.3833577037,
0.7191306949,
-0.3365211785,
0.3159545958,
0.5293450952,
0.3049856126,
0.456464082,
-0.2474896759,
-0.8601695895,
0.5597487092,
0.0771110728,
-0.2198442519,
0.5478694439,
0.3509817421,
0.4364347756,
0.603302002,
0.776301384,
0.2154513896,
0.6584934592,
0.4288457632,
0.8429849744,
-0.6182780862,
-0.3400447965,
-0.8178294897,
0.3799951673,
0.0080667296,
-0.578500092,
0.8250598907,
0.5447002053,
1.3530722857,
0.0778369755,
0.6747148037,
0.261353761,
1.0192250013,
-0.31141451,
0.8323383927,
-0.3575394452,
0.0150773386,
-0.2742679119,
-0.621427834,
-0.2883969545,
0.6953325868,
-0.5493628383,
0.0137282871,
0.6315720081,
0.7743600607,
0.01445744,
0.1468509734,
0.4856263101,
0.6618673801,
0.3454431593,
0.2172120214,
1.0624064207,
-0.322542876,
0.5561697483,
-0.4246378243,
-0.1510538012,
-0.095844835,
-0.7286624908,
-0.8803961277,
-0.5851144791,
-0.5108743906,
-0.406126529,
0.2649508715,
0.6772639751,
0.8142096996,
-1.1291766167,
-0.3525711894,
-0.0269430336,
0.0230419263,
0.1668956429,
-0.2829958797,
-0.1431625485,
-0.5619255304,
-0.5784700513,
0.569820106,
-0.0972020328,
0.1700424254,
-0.0695679709,
0.0292899497,
-0.3729147613,
0.0029713593,
0.5904749036,
0.4099613428,
-0.499258548,
-0.2743842006,
-0.4782791138,
-0.0310456734,
-0.0823621973,
1.272342205,
-0.7424884439,
0.2091535032,
0.3188551664,
0.832901001,
0.3598320782,
-0.1381210685,
0.3195787668,
-0.5288810134,
0.1730119139,
0.5082676411,
0.1509403884,
0.1336495727,
0.1619709432,
0.2806924582,
0.7436427474,
-0.729716897,
-1.1979466677,
0.4368597865,
-0.7344889045,
-0.2198417336,
0.9639510512,
-0.1015023962,
-0.1186153144,
-0.4547527432,
0.0928023756,
0.3338196576,
-0.2028076798,
0.4198022783,
0.7128596306,
-0.1178669259,
-0.1409318,
-0.5075129867,
0.9634504914,
0.6405454874,
-0.1332073659,
0.258269757,
0.4533309042,
0.4701675177,
0.0752883926,
0.5526446104,
0.0276751388,
0.0868091658,
-0.0241666138,
-0.0989104807,
0.0351500437,
-0.5940445065,
-0.5349358916,
0.5734922886,
0.0409340486,
-0.1640455276
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02135v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02135v1
|
Do Moral Judgment and Reasoning Capability of LLMs Change with Language? A Study using the Multilingual Defining Issues Test
| 2024-02-03T12:52:36 | 2024-02-03T12:52:36 |
Aditi Khandelwal, Utkarsh Agarwal, Kumar Tanmay, Monojit Choudhury
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper explores the moral judgment and moral reasoning abilities
exhibited by Large Language Models (LLMs) across languages through the Defining
Issues Test. It is a well known fact that moral judgment depends on the
language in which the question is asked. We extend the work of beyond English,
to 5 new languages (Chinese, Hindi, Russian, Spanish and Swahili), and probe
three LLMs -- ChatGPT, GPT-4 and Llama2Chat-70B -- that shows substantial
multilingual text processing and generation abilities. Our study shows that the
moral reasoning ability for all models, as indicated by the post-conventional
score, is substantially inferior for Hindi and Swahili, compared to Spanish,
Russian, Chinese and English, while there is no clear trend for the performance
of the latter four languages. The moral judgments too vary considerably by the
language.
|
[
-0.3537382185,
-0.7419310808,
0.8233904839,
0.3001311123,
-0.3864181638,
0.1545607597,
-0.3455320597,
-0.8070095181,
-0.2132184952,
0.4599256814,
-0.1709674895,
-0.0891279206,
-0.6675379872,
0.4020407796,
0.0261557046,
1.0190640688,
-0.0402983502,
0.4887627959,
-0.1973895878,
-0.484071523,
-0.5530256629,
-0.7160891294,
-0.786414206,
-0.5166776776,
0.4339921176,
0.3004721403,
0.5450418591,
0.1049807295,
0.6623908877,
0.3840471506,
-0.2836430073,
-0.0003064219,
-0.3057536483,
0.0012786265,
-0.6196981668,
-0.7912065387,
-0.2665210366,
0.2370489687,
0.6240486503,
0.2808932066,
0.0077525312,
0.2833299041,
-0.1011930034,
0.6140592098,
-0.3717572093,
0.0663009211,
-0.8154669404,
0.0090233777,
-0.0732891336,
-0.079408817,
-0.4383026361,
-0.5753976703,
0.0926890075,
-0.0143986242,
-0.0287787206,
-0.1656045169,
0.9647709131,
0.0230344459,
-0.9073576331,
-0.4781871736,
-0.2976249158,
1.1144074202,
-0.5897145867,
0.5199760795,
0.5095849037,
0.1668785363,
0.2699934542,
-0.3584836721,
-0.5067697167,
-0.4909015596,
-0.1067795753,
0.2418540269,
-0.003719223,
-0.2171532065,
0.2110448033,
0.3452678323,
-0.1803963035,
0.1517017037,
-0.4082216024,
-0.1405917406,
0.8146405816,
0.0766028687,
0.1498217434,
-0.588543117,
-0.3172256649,
-0.092721723,
-0.9080995917,
0.3449190259,
0.5815075636,
0.0496571139,
-0.1320750415,
0.6464502215,
0.3114763498,
0.3079386652,
-0.1581700444,
-0.2287278175,
0.1453011632,
-0.6182408929,
-0.1094603688,
-0.0990684852,
0.7349064946,
0.6082434058,
0.7045840025,
0.6757858396,
-0.0866299272,
-0.0671863556,
-0.0678818673,
-0.4016998708,
0.1402100623,
0.0381950513,
-0.4371598065,
-0.1262459308,
-0.0679526031,
-0.3849725723,
-0.5728627443,
-0.1388570219,
-0.0736364424,
-0.579372108,
-0.3538632095,
0.3582413495,
-0.0342631042,
0.8350786567,
0.4116201103,
-0.6478990316,
-0.2860287726,
0.510714829,
0.5762113929,
-0.0891224742,
-0.2603078783,
-0.3063209653,
-0.1426932812,
-0.507172823,
0.8639704585,
-0.8332618475,
-0.6192702651,
-0.0129431607,
0.2146668434,
0.0361952372,
-0.2705613375,
0.7059927583,
-0.3480259478,
0.1373618245,
-0.6505098343,
-0.1983555406,
-0.4628461301,
0.5481988192,
-0.4438817799,
0.6883717775,
-0.2713738978,
-0.5333645344,
0.3715509772,
-0.3692324162,
-0.5348621011,
0.0310796183,
-0.312910676,
-0.2100065649,
0.0904324949,
-0.0848838016,
0.4816770554,
-0.6609115005,
0.5456677675,
-0.1642844975,
-0.3227082789,
0.3852047622,
-0.6115579605,
0.9074281454,
0.0225695819,
-0.2722312212,
-0.1152120903,
-0.6219844222,
0.248022303,
0.3345062137,
-0.6436647177,
-0.2534646988,
0.305346638,
-0.023170758,
0.3675522804,
0.3436038792,
-0.7013130188,
0.0790610164,
-0.2668198347,
0.3568188846,
0.896699369,
-0.004854375,
-0.0402144492,
-0.2800052762,
0.5736293793,
-0.1352897733,
0.2257890999,
0.076883249,
-0.8608384728,
-1.0476517677,
0.2799151838,
-0.1145420074,
0.9302118421,
-0.5454183817,
0.0856226459,
0.0642350093,
-0.4981394112,
-0.3143721521,
-0.0270048883,
0.7792987823,
-0.0139943548,
0.3176631033,
0.0509100705,
-0.3065834939,
-1.0020833015,
-0.5128135085,
-0.5676398277,
0.2486408055,
0.4906735718,
0.6491912007,
0.1241348162,
0.3584007621,
-0.3651168942,
0.0196339693,
-0.5706192255,
-0.2000472397,
0.1825351119,
0.175404653,
0.6337867379,
-0.9509979486,
-0.4359106719,
0.4300183952,
-0.6874151826,
-0.2180800438,
-0.1412722915,
0.1492012441,
0.4523434937,
0.3829649687,
-0.4478306174,
0.2237599939,
0.7019132972,
-0.7432579398,
0.9330826402,
-0.227589041,
0.4563142359,
-0.9963902235,
-0.4476677775,
-0.0038548878,
-0.0202274956,
-0.3792321086,
0.1799323112,
0.2419947684,
0.2531720698,
-0.6967192888,
0.6494620442,
-0.3571090698,
-0.0381967388,
0.0508149639,
0.1716872901,
0.1800504178,
0.1540451199,
-0.0443103872,
0.7133387923,
0.6145629883,
-0.7375919223,
0.4764055908,
0.2301878482,
-0.3764160275,
0.6814215779,
-0.6984702945,
0.0404354259,
-0.1925119907,
-0.1579085886,
-0.8194816709,
0.0818112344,
-0.0156268738,
-0.3737765849,
-0.0698183924,
-0.1855142713,
-0.4047212005,
-0.1718536317,
-0.2737241387,
0.2859751284,
0.3010721803,
-0.3461390138,
0.4143480659,
0.1493344754,
-0.2397570163,
-0.7372084856,
-0.867159903,
-0.0045767017,
-0.3056821525,
-0.558103323,
-0.1477946937,
-0.1868221909,
-0.7564432025,
-0.3795711696,
0.1774998307,
-0.0874209255,
-0.0233800262,
-0.1250177622,
0.3805741966,
-0.1376131028,
0.4492037296,
0.1638217419,
0.1071530357,
0.1740360558,
0.3042082787,
0.4709084928,
-0.7976846695,
-0.607178092,
-0.0443209745,
0.4151670039,
0.4771693051,
-0.8416435122,
0.5391162634,
0.3525648415,
-0.0955828875,
0.2226266712,
-0.7825219631,
0.1611785889,
-0.5050523281,
0.3872552812,
-0.6114385724,
-1.1320810318,
0.6450483799,
0.2181487828,
0.077317141,
0.5757026672,
0.6488762498,
0.0071587986,
0.9316666126,
0.4193203449,
0.3829184473,
0.3396423161,
-0.1168599278,
0.4347011149,
-0.7065909505,
-0.1068637446,
-0.4823203981,
-0.01779815,
-1.1256240606,
-0.5110139847,
0.2616511881,
0.203744635,
-0.3484919965,
0.0728796795,
-0.1956730485,
0.8339203596,
0.0565853491,
-0.1765519083,
0.6128875017,
-0.2058496028,
-0.3109843433,
-0.2080238611,
-0.2396968007,
-0.9336012006,
0.8645021319,
0.1315757334,
0.326719135,
0.4862659276,
0.327252835,
0.0464604571,
0.2766138315,
-0.7762224078,
0.7826510072,
-0.2851126194,
-0.6673613191,
-0.1765228659,
-0.3659796417,
-0.8401898146,
0.6161119342,
-0.0988433808,
-0.676279664,
0.1730754077,
-0.375820905,
-0.0815236717,
0.5393048525,
-0.8242406845,
0.4700394571,
-0.6213422418,
-0.2618145943,
-0.4877958,
-0.4224447012,
0.5836117864,
-0.3507490456,
0.2447844595,
-0.4837309718,
-0.0435722992,
0.5579522848,
0.0664645731,
0.6641052961,
0.0508897379,
-0.5612570643,
0.4477664828,
0.0816953406,
0.2265147716,
0.5967943072,
-0.4374290705,
0.4080616534,
0.2088774145,
-0.2479852438,
-0.4009681046,
0.5891174078,
-0.5235586762,
-1.0710549355,
-0.6585325003,
-0.4501808882,
-0.3064083755,
0.2694265544,
0.0612218492,
0.1520870626,
-0.3372121751,
0.1527042985,
0.3076440692,
-0.8338153362,
0.4660889208,
0.8682023287,
-0.3415672481,
-0.1304026097,
0.5623394251,
0.0661038607,
0.5660953522,
0.0785021558,
0.505700171,
-0.3787844181,
-0.4195144773,
-0.3863177299,
0.5386545062,
-0.9167752862,
-0.0106770843,
-0.3052118719,
0.0000906684,
-0.0489575788,
-0.3541907668,
-0.4502061307,
-0.1110301092,
-0.0089634322,
-0.2534160614,
0.4300988913,
1.0449723005,
0.1003983617,
-0.1215764582,
-0.9514036775,
0.0632911399,
0.2715089023,
0.4400293529,
-0.2223670036,
-0.4902005494,
0.1913989186,
0.0789229274,
-0.3635029793,
-0.7412691116,
-0.0340790637,
0.1289548576,
0.4170484841,
0.4466869533,
-0.1845746487,
0.5497569442,
-0.4683904648,
0.8772088885,
0.151075393,
-1.037456274,
0.4480704069,
-0.4449634552,
0.2177000046,
0.3960802853,
0.4250177741,
-0.6699819565,
-0.5347905159,
-0.3440060914,
-0.2918232083,
0.5910050869,
0.1864243001,
0.5430537462,
-0.3584053814,
0.3349561989,
0.0639390275,
-0.0387372226,
-1.0414586067,
-0.2437876761,
0.0345959365,
0.3990260065,
-0.1768734157,
-0.2466803044,
0.2102880776,
-0.6373462677,
0.3246446848,
-0.0820386931,
0.0392892361,
0.2075746506,
0.1037991494,
0.1411369443,
0.6668671966,
0.5808495879,
0.7826566696,
0.1888780296,
-0.0953342617,
0.5128131509,
-0.4642244577,
0.4695332348,
-0.2312874943,
0.04033719,
-0.2629432678,
0.5039741397,
0.7113441229,
0.1419644803,
-0.8428634405,
0.5051326752,
-0.2462443411,
-0.3033848405,
-0.3599560261,
0.0153160067,
0.2692754865,
0.5313046575,
0.0118570719,
-0.1621812284,
-0.1895397753,
-0.7914989591,
0.0204126909,
0.4421762824,
-0.1488577724,
-0.1698010415,
0.3936004937,
0.0070170583,
-0.1221240759,
0.5204481483,
-0.5278859138,
-0.6982246041,
0.6598001122,
0.6574473381,
0.4204237759,
-0.6274044514,
0.5283139348,
0.3148968816,
0.6179308295,
0.0004267798,
0.8110927343,
0.2305929959,
-1.2086815834,
-0.711317718,
-0.6445290446,
-0.3741719425,
0.0297728367,
-0.5191999674,
0.2732653916,
-0.427859664,
-0.2465692461,
-0.2784881294,
0.1587682664,
-0.3843537271,
0.2250245512,
0.0857521594,
0.3914512694,
-0.480471611,
0.7303478718,
0.878846705,
-0.3017993867,
-0.7171100974,
-0.2546141744,
-0.1545139104,
-0.7871433496,
0.6306817532,
0.1629369557,
-0.3970086277,
-0.1303474456,
-0.2819911838,
-0.9223364592,
0.6945745945,
0.5844090581,
-0.3616835475,
0.1882977039,
0.3419749737,
0.7446203232,
-0.1077828929,
0.2448911816,
0.6942797899,
0.860435605,
-0.1449989676,
-1.1840691566,
-0.2328781337,
-0.4059925675,
-0.3033055961,
0.2651004791,
-0.8358510733,
1.1675232649,
-0.6056261659,
-0.2887526155,
-0.0893840492,
0.1912282109,
0.6239600778,
0.087249279,
0.4830988348,
0.2741805315,
0.7463725209,
-0.2632673979,
1.2928030491,
-0.0051669087,
0.2962552011,
0.7935646772,
-0.5033323169,
0.7176584601,
0.3025212288,
-0.2609757483,
0.5753694773,
0.4673655331,
-0.180141598,
-0.0539246462,
0.1662810445,
-0.0994683281,
-0.4358578026,
-0.4208323956,
-0.2696106434,
1.0863207579,
0.4293965995,
-0.239503637,
-0.0293877143,
0.0031997147,
0.3607777655,
0.0898854956,
-0.3736143112,
0.4325630069,
0.3529462516,
-0.6460661292,
0.740924418,
0.3748812377,
0.6091041565,
-0.6177464724,
-0.0972857922,
-0.1566676497,
0.0456259139,
-0.1585688293,
-1.2438658476,
0.2813158035,
0.3727608621,
0.1228231713,
-0.288110137,
0.7372606397,
-0.1654663682,
-0.6629163623,
0.6800251007,
0.936912477,
0.288559407,
0.0335634016,
-0.7160086632,
-0.1922530383,
0.2433357388,
-0.4382587969,
0.1372514665,
0.3540109992,
-0.514408946,
0.7990461588,
0.7532298565,
0.1240633875,
0.158556357,
0.3978053927,
0.4037078619,
-0.9952158928,
-0.2736525238,
-0.9410333037,
0.2602220774,
-0.0610956699,
-0.5678353906,
0.8220698833,
0.2949132919,
0.8496631384,
0.0811119676,
0.7046636343,
-0.1116939709,
0.0166426077,
-0.7122232914,
0.7521051168,
-0.590790689,
0.0518511459,
-0.3843460977,
-0.8529075384,
-0.1005411297,
0.7794762254,
-0.5515077114,
0.411266923,
1.0764739513,
0.3458374143,
0.3495123386,
0.1721976101,
0.4819850028,
0.1932999194,
0.410372436,
0.7569229007,
1.0882042646,
-0.2741294503,
0.4740763605,
-0.0387112536,
0.0711457357,
0.4397170246,
-0.770136416,
-1.0657097101,
-0.4740082026,
-0.0175929423,
-0.0039482438,
-0.306746304,
0.4610055685,
0.0925048664,
-0.6176344156,
-0.2169159502,
0.1055609584,
0.4392288923,
-0.0049378169,
-0.2202518433,
0.3176015019,
-0.1287807226,
-0.6989645958,
0.398845017,
0.3029125035,
0.0717415661,
-0.2553506494,
-0.1245656535,
-0.4510008395,
0.3390211165,
1.0671648979,
-0.2283530086,
-0.8890930414,
-0.6594500542,
0.0059311776,
0.0432495736,
0.1228892133,
0.8037307262,
-0.2968883812,
0.2733438313,
0.4469783902,
0.2837918401,
0.0088110678,
-0.0854175761,
0.5609589815,
-0.3245426714,
0.1771634072,
0.1727996618,
0.7773765326,
0.4209464788,
-0.326192081,
0.4669507444,
0.1522720754,
-0.5376148224,
-0.538107574,
0.7103976011,
-0.5854874253,
-0.1963784397,
1.4247382879,
-0.0667169467,
0.1859698296,
-0.3634382784,
-0.3931151628,
0.1387038529,
-0.0298168343,
0.4899756014,
1.1176738739,
-0.1826018393,
-0.2418680042,
-0.8128524423,
0.2721502483,
0.6768749356,
-0.7679175138,
0.1604153365,
0.4334174097,
0.2052952945,
0.1598058194,
0.5332071781,
-0.5022205114,
0.3948562741,
-0.3949278295,
-0.0291547868,
0.2796019316,
-0.1264143288,
-0.2777330279,
-0.1190764159,
0.1581797898,
0.4849237502
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02130v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02130v4
|
GITA: Graph to Visual and Textual Integration for Vision-Language Graph Reasoning
| 2024-02-03T12:19:47 | 2024-05-24T06:58:05 |
Yanbin Wei, Shuai Fu, Weisen Jiang, Zejian Zhang, Zhixiong Zeng, Qi Wu, James T. Kwok, Yu Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly used for various tasks with
graph structures. Though LLMs can process graph information in a textual
format, they overlook the rich vision modality, which is an intuitive way for
humans to comprehend structural information and conduct general graph
reasoning. The potential benefits and capabilities of representing graph
structures as visual images (i.e., $\textit{visual graph}$) are still
unexplored. To fill the gap, we innovatively propose an end-to-end framework,
called $\textbf{G}$raph to v$\textbf{I}$sual and $\textbf{T}$extual
Integr$\textbf{A}$tion (GITA), which firstly incorporates visual graphs into
general graph reasoning. Besides, we establish $\textbf{G}$raph-based
$\textbf{V}$ision-$\textbf{L}$anguage $\textbf{Q}$uestion $\textbf{A}$nswering
(GVLQA) dataset from existing graph data, which is the first vision-language
dataset for general graph reasoning purposes. Extensive experiments on the
GVLQA dataset and five real-world datasets show that GITA outperforms
mainstream LLMs in terms of general graph reasoning capabilities. Moreover, We
highlight the effectiveness of the layout augmentation on visual graphs and
pretraining on the GVLQA dataset.
|
[
-0.3319010437,
-1.053355217,
0.8692944646,
-0.1138806343,
-0.4177142382,
0.4316393137,
-0.1523691267,
-0.7116757631,
0.376480788,
0.5298910737,
-0.0150261987,
-0.8209744692,
-0.5420594811,
-0.1764956862,
-0.6051598787,
0.5879980922,
-0.4435484409,
0.0184353199,
-0.3154255748,
-0.2128747106,
-0.2688826621,
-0.5171782374,
-0.2259774357,
-0.1838453412,
0.5278705359,
0.3199846148,
0.7589656711,
0.6405496001,
0.411606878,
0.2906285226,
-0.0562512204,
0.5023645759,
-0.3233529329,
-0.0707717985,
-0.171112746,
-0.2787515223,
-0.3493519723,
-0.2599377334,
0.8332288265,
0.8454757929,
0.1892931163,
0.0903480053,
-0.0134664103,
0.8419960737,
-0.6393427849,
0.5344380736,
-0.2354349047,
-0.0478239283,
-0.2078827173,
-0.307592988,
-0.5430801511,
-0.3375944793,
0.0348511636,
-0.7172933817,
-0.4612822235,
0.1985586435,
1.1904674768,
0.2975254059,
-0.6094864011,
-0.3015884161,
-0.6008128524,
0.1662996709,
-0.1468072832,
0.4132120311,
0.0675438493,
0.6379346848,
-0.218193531,
-1.0781303644,
-0.437928468,
-0.1802308112,
-0.08228717,
0.3036397398,
-0.3137795627,
0.2626188993,
0.2489959449,
0.3649634719,
-0.6638413072,
-0.145114243,
-0.1723230779,
-0.0764675736,
0.2104178816,
-0.0808850676,
0.8740432262,
-0.141101405,
-0.387116015,
-0.1361594349,
-0.683552444,
0.0922405571,
0.3276101649,
0.1119006425,
-0.1752407849,
0.8575903773,
-0.2632420659,
0.7698115706,
-0.3540621996,
0.3626702726,
0.1956313998,
-0.4761350155,
-0.4960561395,
-0.2611292899,
0.7862586975,
0.4246408939,
0.9861378074,
-0.1660629064,
0.0300251935,
0.463506937,
-0.0196920093,
-0.8015885949,
-0.4576879144,
-0.0954831913,
-0.1404063255,
-0.1292290539,
0.0928356647,
-0.5202070475,
-0.2270847261,
-0.3055506349,
0.3279106915,
-0.6231809258,
-0.2252363414,
0.1896928251,
-0.1353685707,
0.448625654,
0.5306978226,
-0.6399840117,
0.3553701639,
0.41880849,
0.9761716127,
0.1034165323,
-0.1440793723,
-0.6393978,
0.3261343241,
-0.607834518,
1.0311062336,
-0.6983963847,
-0.2432456166,
-0.1257997304,
0.0792293027,
-0.1909558475,
-0.290435791,
0.2227728516,
-0.4839051366,
0.288015008,
-0.296493113,
-0.4659450352,
-0.5858703256,
0.3399112523,
-0.6038883328,
0.713899672,
0.3460206985,
-0.8051261306,
0.3792136908,
-0.6261646152,
-0.392739892,
0.3592562675,
-0.8034092188,
-0.2965464592,
-0.2738100886,
0.4674770236,
0.1321344227,
-0.343468219,
0.3982150257,
-0.3439087868,
-0.5535721779,
0.0505479313,
-0.2092669606,
0.7695541978,
0.0097627426,
-0.1902636886,
0.4730778039,
-0.4499997497,
0.3273343146,
0.3251845837,
-0.2055990845,
-0.394744426,
0.0190412682,
0.0380128883,
-0.1523320824,
0.1539124101,
-0.3260014653,
0.4577676356,
-0.2883229852,
0.65320611,
0.5937873125,
-0.1139440164,
0.4910700023,
0.158542186,
0.6273487806,
0.0698345155,
0.0510039404,
-0.2923933566,
-0.6045311093,
-0.6078916192,
-0.4915618002,
0.2826048732,
0.7564071417,
-1.1841286421,
0.1414148062,
-0.5205430388,
-0.2284252495,
0.0378778316,
-0.0762567446,
0.399697125,
0.7017816901,
0.3402281404,
-0.4806417525,
-0.5322450995,
-0.8325686455,
0.0255123377,
-0.3274706602,
0.2296161056,
0.3980008066,
0.5437376499,
-0.4370428622,
1.0911662579,
-0.4723109007,
-0.204923287,
-0.3029747009,
-0.248436898,
0.1422487795,
0.2174546272,
0.9443057179,
-0.7960777283,
-0.6258378625,
0.4860923886,
-1.094373703,
-0.1028163806,
0.0345918648,
-0.4356559515,
0.1593878716,
0.4238940477,
-0.6332141757,
0.7168533206,
0.5276601911,
-0.6198576689,
0.612214148,
-0.1150204837,
0.2716191411,
-0.9447292089,
0.051821854,
0.1243596151,
-0.4574377239,
-0.4278247654,
0.0841726437,
0.0403909087,
-0.1505947709,
-0.0255228858,
0.7323763967,
-0.7047966719,
-0.5274088383,
-0.0024722349,
0.0789778978,
0.1152378991,
0.5588790774,
-0.2561829686,
1.0794529915,
0.896794796,
-0.291261673,
0.4490130246,
0.4079854488,
-0.5066591501,
0.4728948474,
-0.7834291458,
-0.0161719788,
-0.2647056282,
0.2824566066,
-1.1661880016,
-0.4755060375,
0.8694875836,
-0.5614742041,
0.2538047731,
-0.3777565062,
-0.5819622874,
-0.2989965081,
-0.1950992644,
0.4747751951,
0.313577652,
-0.7480319738,
0.98403579,
0.3931151628,
0.0499484055,
-0.6302860379,
-0.7395432591,
0.6162528396,
-0.0938083827,
-0.8949148059,
0.1390681118,
-0.013864222,
-0.3433310986,
0.3387848139,
0.157995522,
-0.06761875,
-0.1799577624,
0.2584195137,
0.5292202234,
-0.3728597164,
0.0809643939,
0.0126293795,
-0.4202661812,
-0.0957525223,
-0.5696979761,
0.4744108617,
-0.6245240569,
-0.7796911597,
-0.091356568,
0.4053852558,
0.5400509238,
-0.4801127315,
0.3394008279,
0.2865374982,
-0.3596331775,
0.0468102358,
-0.1968608201,
0.5605505705,
-0.4125775993,
0.5053444505,
-0.4670256972,
-0.7625181675,
0.6129304171,
-0.2139160037,
-0.3392932117,
0.2142614573,
0.43353194,
-0.2687243521,
1.1070055962,
0.5712322593,
0.2556329668,
0.7835407257,
-0.4863348901,
0.265108943,
-0.801320076,
-0.172455743,
-0.0836426318,
-0.249069646,
-0.3928335011,
-0.5031503439,
0.3111752868,
0.2828806937,
-0.3462190926,
0.0253296979,
-0.657166183,
0.7240294218,
0.3727025688,
0.0951823369,
0.3480131924,
0.2200770229,
-0.309612304,
0.1431139857,
-0.492328167,
-0.5831606984,
0.8284731507,
0.1854255348,
0.74425143,
0.1058550701,
0.4283412099,
0.1131934226,
0.3775761724,
-0.9699813724,
0.748123467,
-0.3277668059,
0.1315330863,
-0.3008099496,
-0.4236181974,
-0.6693354845,
0.4070179164,
0.1048166156,
-0.8860695958,
0.1652164906,
0.2005885392,
0.3095670938,
0.4716354012,
-1.1250747442,
0.9197920561,
-0.4786139131,
-0.1727646589,
0.16483289,
-0.5488961339,
0.493180871,
0.2203043699,
0.2650400102,
0.0659206286,
0.1149767786,
0.3633322418,
-0.5279447436,
0.8380509615,
-0.3602124453,
0.0025345709,
0.4919483364,
-0.0612164773,
0.5209513903,
-0.1179168969,
0.3798823953,
0.1154465973,
-0.1207527742,
-0.2286626846,
-0.7442884445,
0.2974779606,
-0.6375641823,
-0.4197950065,
-0.3039647937,
-0.5119655132,
-0.203989923,
0.3155733049,
0.1421919763,
0.6308980584,
0.0322897248,
0.1877091974,
0.3504655063,
-0.158444643,
0.0248556677,
-0.1728962064,
-0.8374562263,
-0.6321512461,
0.8092538714,
0.3288956583,
0.3011210561,
0.2777611613,
0.1727659851,
-0.3971706629,
-0.5660321116,
-0.895786643,
0.2150065601,
-1.153354764,
-0.1023827493,
-0.5270383954,
-0.506900847,
0.0239194278,
-0.2189716101,
0.1167749241,
-0.2487892061,
-0.1090935394,
-0.0627817214,
0.5512501001,
0.6780319214,
0.1683306843,
0.4047648907,
-0.3987894058,
0.4850235879,
0.2490541339,
0.4740507007,
-0.0463527776,
-0.203382954,
-0.198254019,
0.0469333977,
0.1466498673,
-0.9876484275,
0.1454762965,
0.2262360603,
0.6386656165,
0.1961671114,
-0.3691265285,
0.7165498734,
-0.5395615101,
0.359167099,
0.4227852523,
-0.9572950006,
0.5676259398,
-0.4475174546,
0.2019346803,
0.2825773954,
0.0210525747,
-0.4993935823,
-0.3345763981,
-0.2880658209,
-1.0319725275,
0.083168149,
-0.0180777032,
-0.1404389143,
0.0145421363,
0.2947867215,
-0.2247459888,
0.0028136624,
-0.7881162763,
0.0477696434,
-0.5009872913,
-0.387571305,
0.2719188333,
-0.0251492895,
-0.1017166898,
-0.4384250939,
0.2584409416,
-0.7267742157,
0.079065755,
0.0757845491,
-0.4075957835,
0.037704438,
0.1506795436,
0.2825366855,
0.7808879614,
0.1297048628,
0.3234223723,
-0.0016644039,
-0.4402355552,
0.1225963086,
-0.1045574248,
-0.4274848104,
-0.140875265,
0.5504853129,
0.909311533,
0.2384414673,
-0.7103199959,
0.5590153337,
-0.0316073559,
-0.2660517395,
-0.1831555814,
0.0572835319,
0.2586320937,
0.4807970524,
0.3457095027,
-0.1314856708,
0.0153122116,
-0.4599728882,
0.2276452184,
0.5603086948,
-0.3543427587,
-0.1835981607,
0.7598089576,
-0.0997732729,
-0.0419815816,
0.4936946034,
-0.1134683415,
-0.6330954432,
0.6245459318,
0.4828440547,
0.7256984115,
0.2779277265,
0.331341356,
0.2729493082,
0.2079584748,
0.271325022,
0.581954658,
-0.006828418,
-0.7114542723,
-0.8310694695,
-0.4413793385,
-0.5533857942,
-0.4046731889,
-0.2701091468,
0.2222100645,
-0.5212667584,
-0.1278485358,
-0.2812492251,
-0.2691006064,
-0.5063403845,
0.2382665575,
0.2411709428,
0.8795402646,
-0.6948375702,
0.795050621,
0.9234454036,
-0.7401071787,
-0.7036042809,
-0.1473891288,
-0.18298994,
-1.1784991026,
0.7572495341,
0.2749663591,
-0.596521616,
0.1119866893,
-1.0005679131,
-0.7336111069,
1.0786950588,
0.7412161827,
-0.453484118,
-0.2589995563,
0.1227248907,
0.4490080476,
-0.5056930184,
0.065862447,
0.29494524,
0.6292101145,
0.5650872588,
-0.5287857056,
0.044252187,
-0.5008006692,
0.0664706007,
0.3088701367,
-0.3534117639,
0.7823264003,
-0.4784061909,
-0.7406889796,
-0.1574540138,
0.6827117205,
0.1716219634,
0.1118413135,
0.5424249172,
0.6023619771,
0.8838371634,
-0.2664539516,
1.1562360525,
-0.2487355024,
0.2106748223,
1.0657447577,
-0.2118798494,
0.5610010028,
0.4401462376,
-0.0504195318,
0.7219836116,
0.7051089406,
0.0362410322,
0.4777112901,
0.1519960463,
0.1041392237,
-0.3206650913,
-0.2852526903,
-0.4427921772,
0.429893434,
0.4058110118,
-0.1539887488,
-0.3205821514,
-0.2265883237,
-0.1382955015,
0.1391021907,
-0.2128298134,
0.5122570395,
0.1326008439,
-0.079385832,
0.4521267116,
-0.4174004793,
0.3049829602,
-0.6608843207,
-0.2240113467,
0.0040711877,
-0.0869593918,
-0.2601251006,
-1.2608745098,
0.3026839793,
-0.1414907277,
-0.0706459805,
-0.1475428045,
0.829673171,
-0.3521151543,
-0.4108624756,
0.6460810304,
0.7674508095,
-0.020430835,
-0.0365410633,
-0.3131045401,
0.0874546543,
-0.2863259315,
-0.2301450223,
0.1817436218,
0.6133674979,
-0.3447120786,
0.7758814096,
0.7457360029,
0.2028388232,
-0.210309431,
0.4177574813,
1.1779437065,
-0.7716716528,
-0.8239061832,
-0.8334685564,
0.5936256647,
-0.1602705717,
-0.1396295875,
0.3342780471,
0.6031227112,
0.6080363989,
0.2880108058,
0.9656854272,
0.0649766177,
-0.0355878621,
-0.8421549797,
0.7218515873,
-0.6836699843,
-0.1275097728,
-0.3085229099,
-0.988473177,
-0.3897851706,
0.6858748198,
-0.4399732649,
-0.0680491775,
0.7436003089,
0.4005206525,
-0.1261691004,
-0.2593740225,
0.2684683204,
0.0959375352,
0.6350561976,
0.8262916207,
1.0105332136,
-0.1846663803,
0.6404176354,
0.4723908901,
-0.367113173,
0.0033172993,
-0.7934959531,
-0.7703867555,
-0.5410475135,
-0.0526449606,
-0.2659259737,
-0.017291123,
0.4564397633,
0.4124745131,
-0.4346237779,
-0.022826286,
-0.0574016161,
0.2149897516,
0.1050977856,
-0.2334131151,
0.4663775861,
-0.070651181,
-0.4985233247,
0.2426193506,
0.757612884,
0.3928171694,
-0.3316292763,
-0.2431209534,
-0.0743323565,
-0.0968060046,
0.6824480891,
0.4653609991,
-0.718881309,
-0.8256756663,
-0.0476189628,
-0.2198020369,
0.5629746318,
0.5461835861,
-0.826854825,
0.4643994868,
0.4900778234,
0.8750963211,
0.539250195,
-0.0267977826,
0.5481901169,
-0.4408359826,
0.1467160434,
0.0018807868,
0.8114637733,
0.4550259411,
-0.1639285684,
0.9320303202,
0.3116981387,
-0.1860375255,
-0.7438017726,
0.5206330419,
-1.2263791561,
-0.1675542295,
0.9764032364,
-0.1007523388,
-0.5237199664,
0.0576104596,
-0.3932989836,
0.3347418606,
0.0142796114,
0.2365635037,
0.7573592663,
-0.1561402529,
-0.3778987527,
-0.4721720815,
-0.0279137827,
-0.0824583098,
-1.3852473497,
0.1036521271,
0.8015310168,
0.0380360484,
0.0265414845,
0.9130123258,
-0.050249055,
0.258240819,
0.0441918187,
-0.0171747059,
-0.3966059387,
-0.6171411872,
0.0486020632,
0.0163952876,
-0.0472729765,
-0.2183609903
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02113v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02113v1
|
Zero-shot Sentiment Analysis in Low-Resource Languages Using a Multilingual Sentiment Lexicon
| 2024-02-03T10:41:05 | 2024-02-03T10:41:05 |
Fajri Koto, Tilman Beck, Zeerak Talat, Iryna Gurevych, Timothy Baldwin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Improving multilingual language models capabilities in low-resource languages
is generally difficult due to the scarcity of large-scale data in those
languages. In this paper, we relax the reliance on texts in low-resource
languages by using multilingual lexicons in pretraining to enhance multilingual
capabilities. Specifically, we focus on zero-shot sentiment analysis tasks
across 34 languages, including 6 high/medium-resource languages, 25
low-resource languages, and 3 code-switching datasets. We demonstrate that
pretraining using multilingual lexicons, without using any sentence-level
sentiment data, achieves superior zero-shot performance compared to models
fine-tuned on English sentiment datasets, and large language models like
GPT--3.5, BLOOMZ, and XGLM. These findings are observable for unseen
low-resource languages to code-mixed scenarios involving high-resource
languages.
|
[
-0.5837392211,
-0.1516364366,
0.301628679,
0.2431549132,
-0.3874539733,
0.3112691939,
-0.7016950846,
-0.3893997073,
0.3789385855,
0.1372024268,
-0.5832787156,
-0.5876680017,
-0.5233873725,
0.2947096229,
0.1613561362,
1.4423675537,
-0.1368522048,
0.354041934,
-0.1176744178,
-0.5501797795,
-0.1616891474,
-0.8829059601,
-0.3315896988,
-0.1226751059,
0.8922831416,
0.492749691,
0.5876495242,
0.0078882016,
0.4080601931,
0.1773690432,
0.0735224187,
-0.1161415577,
-0.4808811843,
-0.0517067462,
-0.0763758123,
-0.3185322285,
-0.4314105809,
0.0318598002,
0.5402940512,
0.6881863475,
0.0366473235,
0.2335674167,
0.1127157211,
0.381120652,
-1.164329052,
0.2108209878,
-0.4488313198,
0.3405717015,
-0.3733683527,
-0.1580884606,
-0.3516623676,
-0.0764945522,
-0.1093359664,
-0.4565873742,
0.1707386225,
-0.4381421804,
0.7555239797,
0.0904820338,
-0.2675146461,
-0.0111438874,
-0.6693487763,
1.2377519608,
-0.70940274,
0.4030956328,
0.1294819266,
-0.118073903,
0.6943157315,
-0.1113973707,
-0.5271794796,
-0.2191010267,
-0.0698378831,
0.482863158,
0.0815728903,
-0.0137759866,
0.1730164289,
0.3167790771,
-0.4384205341,
0.1358498633,
-0.0106238006,
-0.1865186542,
0.3555818498,
-0.120298259,
0.0892370641,
-0.3100718856,
-0.1958453208,
-0.1786421239,
-0.5542301536,
0.0046488205,
0.3645833731,
0.6986176968,
-0.3427504301,
0.3328047395,
-0.2393730879,
0.6211739779,
-0.4557369053,
-0.2310770303,
0.6139832139,
-0.5419315696,
-0.2051045001,
-0.1044961661,
0.9209953547,
0.2998676896,
0.438498944,
-0.045835454,
-0.2069905996,
0.3164352477,
0.0077576227,
-0.9271868467,
0.0043072398,
-0.0024942278,
-0.3717844188,
-0.2738800049,
-0.1922009587,
-0.941218257,
-0.2623748481,
0.0514212847,
0.1389559954,
-0.2736995816,
-0.628531158,
0.1514357328,
-0.0599748753,
0.3342676461,
0.080715932,
-0.7131178379,
-0.0480337404,
0.1996410489,
1.0084438324,
0.0156015437,
-0.5618136525,
-0.5056163073,
-0.2013198435,
-0.4700554311,
0.7415393591,
-0.5337478518,
-0.5475658178,
0.2157881856,
-0.1760592461,
-0.0909548253,
-0.3512071967,
0.3949929476,
-0.2430504709,
0.3166143,
-0.220861569,
-0.0981396958,
0.1109393537,
0.6915639043,
-0.5749666691,
0.8338303566,
0.0417425074,
-0.7150713801,
0.3440903425,
-0.7007997632,
-0.6774767041,
-0.1166107506,
-0.2261455059,
-0.1533582211,
0.3602566719,
0.2423184365,
0.3774437308,
-0.0840312541,
-0.3107751012,
-0.4792193174,
-0.0884148702,
0.1407810152,
-0.5845349431,
0.5664218068,
0.3045442998,
-0.1948031783,
-0.2343879193,
-0.5618271828,
0.2879358232,
0.0788650066,
-0.2593402565,
-0.2950596809,
-0.2151626647,
0.2100153118,
0.6694366932,
0.303974241,
-0.7470894456,
0.0564995594,
-0.4974506199,
-0.094161734,
0.2315308005,
-0.2264923602,
0.4677815139,
0.0837981254,
0.9319408536,
0.41784513,
0.197679922,
-0.3615930974,
-0.1062575281,
-0.797822237,
-0.1489926875,
0.1249603108,
0.6349494457,
-1.0725858212,
-0.0492340103,
-0.314008683,
-0.3445692956,
-0.6160454154,
0.3810663819,
0.7083096504,
0.2974372208,
0.4296440482,
-0.3832347989,
-0.3157023787,
-0.6876500249,
-0.4386442602,
-0.1263557822,
0.2772707939,
0.2050310522,
0.1420282423,
-0.0489826575,
0.508274734,
-0.6297574043,
-0.1599877924,
-0.6004900932,
0.1900701672,
0.2690770328,
0.1889507473,
0.7284744978,
-0.4839634895,
-0.7597207427,
0.0924362391,
-0.7818776965,
0.0470646359,
-0.1344222128,
-0.1234336868,
0.5719709992,
0.3472959101,
-0.546830833,
0.0944759175,
0.7756635547,
-0.1852867454,
0.5362246633,
0.0042195683,
0.178027302,
-1.0089076757,
0.157094866,
0.1030287519,
-0.1663787663,
-0.7211353779,
0.0915391669,
0.0971653089,
-0.3196598291,
-0.8627491593,
0.6641676426,
-0.5798297524,
0.0456430167,
-0.2152858227,
0.0000776995,
0.1623856872,
0.5070698857,
0.331433028,
0.6087492108,
0.6914331317,
-0.2990238965,
0.188498646,
0.0086117042,
-0.1686606109,
0.6025782824,
-0.2759636045,
-0.0129092066,
-0.3711547256,
-0.0858005956,
-0.5260787606,
-0.0052498952,
0.0924461186,
-0.5244687796,
0.369759798,
-0.1498541385,
-0.3994551301,
-0.1538595259,
-0.5401409864,
0.5149194002,
0.2635546029,
-0.2861873507,
0.390403688,
0.1812870502,
-0.2004879117,
-0.9151694179,
-0.8919153214,
0.0610763095,
-0.0418776646,
-0.0887220502,
-0.1790010482,
-0.1716583222,
-0.204654038,
-0.2005867511,
0.095892705,
-0.211964339,
-0.0898816884,
0.0536440611,
0.5106983185,
-0.2132184952,
0.2600052357,
-0.2926639616,
-0.1467883587,
-0.2079258561,
-0.3037828207,
0.7164664268,
-0.382344842,
-0.2758005559,
-0.061772868,
0.5087648034,
0.5730634332,
-0.481205523,
0.8431528807,
0.7874071598,
-0.1290481985,
-0.033140976,
-0.3121072054,
0.0413573645,
-0.3710540831,
0.4551766515,
-0.2909471393,
-0.8033556342,
0.3363951147,
0.1411843151,
-0.0382665843,
0.4459109306,
0.707921207,
-0.0601442382,
0.9245128036,
0.7336197495,
-0.5584796071,
0.5434639454,
-0.1975912899,
0.3724596798,
-0.2677980363,
0.2009055316,
-0.4437549412,
-0.1893544495,
-0.5483016372,
-0.2619056106,
0.3675696254,
0.1079082489,
-0.103257969,
0.0957554951,
-0.094532609,
0.6461915374,
0.4344473779,
-0.1968723536,
0.1566657424,
0.1943250149,
-0.1893042028,
-0.131930396,
-0.7875372171,
-0.263242811,
0.9660237432,
0.0190030448,
0.6313944459,
-0.1386301517,
0.88100034,
-0.1095105335,
0.2087996751,
-1.0715658665,
0.326325506,
-0.5858982801,
-0.6669664383,
-0.138810724,
-0.5807474852,
-0.5655082464,
0.2006767243,
-0.307384938,
-0.1545443088,
0.0123885246,
0.1757018268,
-0.692705214,
0.3875286281,
-0.8093287945,
1.1270809174,
-0.3843015432,
-0.2506220639,
-0.3909956813,
-0.3841753304,
0.173516199,
-0.1701167822,
0.573507607,
-0.2045563906,
0.0225514192,
0.4179271162,
-0.3156986833,
0.8294692039,
-0.4072505534,
-0.2119591832,
0.2613538206,
0.0044200257,
0.0292871557,
0.1222477332,
-0.131860584,
0.5167455673,
0.1781058609,
-0.5893594027,
-0.2754870057,
0.7149462104,
-0.900805831,
-0.1293389648,
-0.5401988626,
-0.2862908244,
-0.646043241,
0.3812376261,
0.6330410838,
0.4199100435,
-0.4057409465,
0.0434250422,
0.3220741749,
-0.3968186975,
0.8150707483,
0.4863553345,
-0.0809750408,
-0.2256192118,
1.095323801,
0.2506450713,
0.2603977025,
0.353380233,
0.1592023224,
-0.2484022528,
-0.1734896004,
-0.6343677044,
0.1072724387,
-0.5740793943,
-0.4665023685,
-0.4978929758,
-0.0110474136,
-0.3246652782,
-0.2790100873,
-0.7373929024,
-0.3473351598,
-0.0356029868,
-0.1006432101,
0.1431088895,
0.3434308767,
-0.1811026633,
0.46980533,
-1.2578697205,
0.28675583,
0.1177578494,
0.5213184953,
-0.0643509701,
-0.2431002855,
-0.7634572983,
0.0349666364,
-0.1798966378,
-0.7662045956,
0.5433398485,
0.495486021,
0.2533239424,
0.3942172527,
-0.0540096685,
0.6288725138,
-0.3916284442,
0.9079974294,
0.5917101502,
-1.0339827538,
0.439294368,
-0.379391104,
0.6735604405,
0.7567287087,
0.5097619891,
-0.8484430313,
-0.3398582339,
-0.3377168477,
-0.7157138586,
0.8492042422,
-0.2532241642,
0.5379841924,
-0.164864257,
0.2155967057,
0.0823550522,
0.4174932539,
-1.0781335831,
-0.1298318505,
-0.696189642,
-0.2840059698,
-0.4805668294,
-0.2615055144,
-0.0855216905,
-0.1705618054,
0.5437637568,
-0.3874292672,
0.0571885072,
-0.1366550475,
-0.3900737166,
-0.0211731121,
0.5977583528,
0.2220955193,
0.283311218,
0.0833594725,
0.1509657055,
0.4996076822,
-0.491109401,
0.290822953,
-0.0611841008,
-0.1602142751,
0.0944473147,
0.5695431828,
0.9332246184,
0.3523341715,
-0.599337399,
0.7583972216,
-0.0875164196,
-0.0345617458,
-0.148048088,
-0.2612917125,
-0.0677039325,
-0.0096478518,
-0.0788426548,
0.0926003084,
-0.1650642753,
-0.5151841044,
-0.114838548,
0.5372484922,
-0.515221715,
-0.5778686404,
0.1705365926,
0.1717273742,
0.4590237141,
0.5812519789,
-0.4303676784,
-0.3485209644,
0.2296720594,
0.3410440385,
0.8477701545,
-0.1856293082,
0.5794134736,
0.4704671502,
0.2401215732,
-0.0746992528,
0.4371734858,
0.0069545601,
-1.1032855511,
-0.7319758534,
-0.817743659,
-0.453186512,
-0.0651598647,
-0.7769422531,
0.3178941905,
-0.5158033371,
-0.2035317123,
-0.1665404141,
0.0089645302,
-0.8798542023,
0.3591950834,
0.5654829144,
0.6639190912,
-0.8162705302,
0.9436689615,
0.91349262,
-0.5040735602,
-0.6674793959,
-0.0061395811,
-0.0006913764,
-0.8061770201,
0.5808763504,
0.227000013,
-0.4255812764,
0.0054744333,
-0.383197993,
-0.6375936866,
0.5252374411,
0.5988330245,
-0.4512993991,
0.1657985747,
0.3236106038,
0.7101342082,
-0.1791942716,
0.3207752705,
0.3875729442,
0.3605580032,
-0.0927628502,
-0.7474182248,
-0.4945341647,
-0.3127887547,
-0.1035237536,
0.2146917582,
-0.7151508331,
1.0082899332,
-0.1110169515,
-0.206926018,
-0.3586214483,
0.4925616384,
-0.1044879034,
-0.0167713296,
0.5459044576,
0.6207705736,
0.5309563279,
0.0542549416,
0.9823662639,
-0.7149878144,
0.463778913,
1.0034008026,
-0.6138370037,
1.1387785673,
0.3791356087,
-0.0599538498,
0.5665681958,
0.401263386,
0.2764093876,
0.522117734,
-0.2203368098,
-0.7222292423,
-0.4789905846,
-0.3741868734,
-0.3077623248,
0.8468099236,
0.042867925,
0.0920133144,
-0.5179808736,
0.3104918301,
0.3957943916,
-0.1034931168,
-0.5878221989,
0.8042772412,
0.093630366,
-0.5065221786,
0.7099749446,
-0.0719101205,
1.096154809,
-0.7768874168,
0.4001171589,
-0.5272051096,
0.3160826564,
-0.2949534357,
-0.8010413647,
0.4580562711,
0.5187047124,
-0.2653264701,
-0.4795638919,
0.6394559145,
-0.4306958616,
-0.7075995207,
0.7392839789,
0.9236696959,
0.0709475726,
-0.3568473458,
-0.6248987913,
-0.0671285018,
-0.0439791009,
-0.3042829931,
0.5068222284,
0.388345927,
0.2018379271,
0.1208393797,
0.5170554519,
0.4322943091,
-0.1466664821,
0.542152524,
0.8100113869,
-0.790689528,
-0.4730543494,
-0.9912263155,
0.3306549788,
0.0455079302,
-0.4227930605,
0.8205746412,
0.4466879666,
1.1990435123,
-0.3093810081,
1.0679517984,
0.0224043801,
0.3938659728,
-0.4474320412,
0.8518277407,
-0.7043592334,
-0.2806874514,
-0.2701607347,
-0.8783586025,
-0.5278064609,
0.5741757154,
-0.1995815337,
0.0690447018,
0.6174448133,
0.5710300207,
0.0436634347,
-0.3734284639,
0.4927472174,
0.0296140518,
0.0537109002,
0.4686034322,
0.8168826103,
-0.0641052723,
0.7477906942,
-0.3480595648,
-0.2819210589,
0.1268934757,
-0.9738586545,
-0.792158246,
-0.1208816171,
-0.1762266755,
-0.3110042512,
-0.3492336869,
0.9648478031,
0.6131699085,
-0.9620349407,
-0.5098223686,
0.3040959537,
-0.0111992834,
-0.0351412781,
-0.2177781761,
-0.128485918,
-0.9176824689,
-0.6586511731,
0.2986671925,
0.4010765851,
-0.1180038452,
-0.2752907276,
-0.1348167658,
-0.1385623962,
0.0077623525,
0.9376630783,
0.4664472342,
-0.1451262087,
-0.1805290729,
0.2222690284,
-0.1464075148,
0.1604733616,
1.0452120304,
-0.6810547709,
0.5381008983,
0.3481948376,
0.4125958979,
0.3213506937,
-0.2919318974,
0.3881787956,
-1.2166208029,
0.6695581079,
0.2173939645,
0.513271153,
0.5468093753,
-0.1084732711,
0.2606001496,
0.3422677219,
-0.1101153493,
-0.6484181881,
0.2305278927,
-0.6041770577,
-0.3392628133,
1.0807096958,
-0.2486780584,
0.0440937355,
0.1826568842,
0.0593389049,
0.3204014599,
-0.1335469484,
0.547121048,
0.9079765081,
0.0207510032,
-0.232110098,
-0.4822142124,
0.5761839151,
0.6661788225,
-0.8916694522,
0.1039310247,
0.6111389995,
-0.0055170525,
0.3838287294,
0.9404062629,
-0.1824331433,
0.0658193305,
-0.030442901,
0.4768295288,
0.3030985594,
-0.4641885161,
-0.6557732821,
0.1898434907,
0.3169281483,
-0.1592348069
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02101v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02101v1
|
Are Large Language Models Good Prompt Optimizers?
| 2024-02-03T09:48:54 | 2024-02-03T09:48:54 |
Ruotian Ma, Xiaolei Wang, Xin Zhou, Jian Li, Nan Du, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
LLM-based Automatic Prompt Optimization, which typically utilizes LLMs as
Prompt Optimizers to self-reflect and refine prompts, has shown promising
performance in recent studies. Despite the success, the underlying mechanism of
this approach remains unexplored, and the true effectiveness of LLMs as Prompt
Optimizers requires further validation. In this work, we conducted a
comprehensive study to uncover the actual mechanism of LLM-based Prompt
Optimization. Our findings reveal that the LLM optimizers struggle to identify
the true causes of errors during reflection, tending to be biased by their own
prior knowledge rather than genuinely reflecting on the errors. Furthermore,
even when the reflection is semantically valid, the LLM optimizers often fail
to generate appropriate prompts for the target models with a single prompt
refinement step, partly due to the unpredictable behaviors of the target
models. Based on the observations, we introduce a new "Automatic Behavior
Optimization" paradigm, which directly optimizes the target model's behavior in
a more controllable manner. We hope our study can inspire new directions for
automatic prompt optimization development.
|
[
-0.1717997342,
-0.9501736164,
1.084353447,
0.5175169706,
-0.1660190672,
-0.0833619535,
-0.2054101974,
-0.1286201328,
-0.0784388408,
0.3544517457,
-1.1214975119,
-0.1929223835,
-0.3168214858,
0.6890735626,
-0.1632501334,
0.782515347,
-0.0426180065,
0.3648009002,
-0.1159629151,
0.1582873017,
-0.6281946301,
-0.2556399703,
-1.0445537567,
-0.2890414596,
0.743974328,
0.1621803194,
0.3461756706,
0.7853506207,
0.2867618203,
0.2968407571,
-0.0905897468,
0.467674762,
-0.4963687658,
0.481217593,
0.0028404268,
-0.4752810895,
-0.1574169248,
-0.01885866,
0.7881201506,
0.5231336355,
-0.1734020561,
-0.0035589093,
0.1893219203,
0.6628401279,
-0.5898991227,
0.1188736409,
-0.4863048196,
0.1926860064,
0.0910217836,
-0.4070575535,
-0.6067582369,
-0.5840975046,
-0.0279952995,
-0.5427780747,
-0.0024695506,
0.3936798275,
0.5445509553,
0.7507768273,
-0.365504235,
-0.4277549684,
-0.6266655922,
0.9865791202,
-0.7221006751,
0.0736289918,
-0.0860683545,
0.2564716637,
-0.660538733,
-0.2243722379,
-0.2771123648,
-0.631287694,
0.0429902449,
-0.0112530403,
-0.2433046103,
0.3335550725,
0.6264250875,
-0.0246714223,
-0.4442773163,
0.4933824539,
0.1568123698,
-0.4172739685,
0.4810837209,
0.5994209051,
0.3713773191,
-0.1772840172,
-0.3640336692,
0.1414209604,
-0.7418727875,
0.3345677257,
0.4656013548,
0.5422956944,
0.0373843908,
0.4193561971,
-0.0623776615,
0.8335772753,
0.2526852787,
-0.1934492737,
-0.1950730383,
-0.3746498823,
0.1935725808,
0.0934350044,
0.8034856319,
0.5058454871,
0.4832530916,
0.0420393273,
-0.7197178006,
-0.1487567872,
0.1999422163,
-0.7595579028,
0.0639881641,
0.1893754005,
-0.4787377417,
-0.5086037517,
-0.29666695,
-0.4752653837,
-0.339962244,
-0.5300744176,
0.4424395561,
-0.0142694842,
0.0090799276,
0.0865127668,
0.0695917234,
0.2864908576,
0.5511583686,
-0.7803227305,
0.0941177607,
0.6502546072,
0.7912469506,
-0.4929430485,
-0.1954318136,
-1.0401531458,
-0.1653430611,
-0.6140707135,
0.6824300885,
-0.4712408781,
-0.5815438032,
0.1570563018,
-0.0145721799,
-0.1939620078,
-0.3873438239,
0.5553461313,
-0.5187989473,
0.1785598546,
-0.6591105461,
-0.4884487391,
-0.0531511679,
0.2681083977,
-0.6995123625,
0.855895102,
-0.1111355498,
-0.4866170287,
0.2666534185,
-0.6929707527,
-0.2164986432,
-0.1605864167,
-0.0305952523,
-0.3443357646,
0.3817269504,
0.1054127216,
0.3737915754,
-0.574115634,
0.5035200119,
-0.1023916826,
-0.3744817972,
0.4129038453,
-0.4865626693,
0.8143419623,
0.1795555204,
-0.3358360231,
0.340828985,
-0.5964268446,
-0.1747934073,
0.2458900958,
-0.424575299,
-0.0412483923,
0.1451600045,
-0.29927513,
0.131363675,
0.5231329799,
-0.4168403149,
0.5324518085,
-0.2632144392,
0.1918633431,
1.0301706791,
0.2256373167,
0.4148114622,
-0.2393627167,
0.9635871053,
-0.3690621853,
0.3601754308,
-0.5286111832,
-0.2238895744,
-0.6707900763,
-0.1747205406,
-0.1278175116,
0.4993721843,
-0.5380679965,
0.2814402878,
0.327630192,
-0.1954163015,
-0.3570972979,
0.1145736277,
0.6121059656,
0.9434670806,
0.2086730748,
0.1134323627,
-0.3117128313,
-0.9593946934,
-0.4007601738,
-0.0154106356,
0.3373253942,
0.3203541636,
0.2243218273,
-0.1951540411,
1.0730720758,
-0.4199475944,
0.0770846456,
-0.3298633397,
-0.0758863315,
0.4547196925,
0.3773193955,
0.6515973806,
-0.4869610369,
-0.4927125871,
-0.5555217266,
-0.6849220991,
-0.7075539231,
-0.3781722188,
-0.1338545531,
0.3938826323,
0.7439712286,
-0.6565893888,
0.0104476204,
0.2537783682,
-0.1883583814,
1.0687385798,
-0.2763481736,
-0.1118346751,
-0.5782236457,
-0.0363401212,
0.2035339475,
-0.0870020911,
-0.4541284144,
-0.07484404,
0.1182960346,
0.0021067678,
-0.4001137018,
0.8731117845,
-0.664083004,
0.0120052481,
-0.5168641806,
-0.039392639,
0.0021478357,
0.5371882915,
-0.0387284271,
1.0374183655,
0.7149469256,
-0.689236939,
0.488026917,
0.0404591039,
-0.0657096207,
0.4567572773,
-0.8583670259,
0.109091498,
-0.3276256323,
0.2261206657,
-1.1599814892,
-0.1585270464,
0.3689471781,
-0.1885744035,
0.3736192584,
-0.0494861677,
-0.533362329,
-0.3631196916,
-0.3928211033,
0.1597330123,
0.5019677281,
-0.6377128959,
0.6772161126,
-0.1834608763,
-0.0187993385,
-0.5442565084,
-0.1913951933,
-0.0037732634,
-0.2974591851,
-0.5068797469,
-0.1695436388,
-0.3109607995,
-0.39983055,
-0.4822327495,
-0.046419628,
0.5112979412,
0.3344344795,
-0.0055804243,
0.402092427,
-0.1777201444,
0.0845274404,
0.0661008731,
-0.3180954158,
0.5274400115,
-0.2512135506,
0.6784276962,
0.0520704798,
-0.4616015255,
-0.6396255493,
0.2310464978,
0.2871852815,
-0.1919088811,
0.4453359544,
0.3726404607,
0.0733509138,
-0.5384827852,
-0.7478702664,
-0.4997779131,
-0.5842498541,
0.3082844615,
-0.3564057648,
-0.7365432978,
0.5977842808,
-0.1259175539,
0.0264297687,
0.2910834253,
0.4605644047,
0.0324022956,
1.441123724,
0.5216562748,
0.0154145686,
0.4404082,
0.0730188489,
0.071726501,
-0.9133729935,
-0.1592767239,
-0.6448551416,
-0.1136290431,
-0.5422357917,
-0.1512328982,
0.4507962465,
-0.1751774102,
-0.3895104527,
0.0354136229,
-0.5379088521,
0.5005062819,
0.6778904796,
-0.1476623118,
0.1140436754,
-0.2700027227,
-0.2884190977,
-0.0328890309,
-0.6701059937,
-0.6379361153,
0.8031617999,
0.3827459216,
1.0104455948,
-0.2661049962,
0.6678643823,
0.1359565407,
-0.0049575819,
-0.8486604095,
0.7676135898,
0.2856359184,
-0.3453022838,
-0.3049259484,
-0.4757139981,
-0.9648262858,
0.0564213209,
0.0141144013,
-0.5480583906,
0.1103927791,
0.4292569757,
-0.4606671333,
-0.022482615,
-0.6192398667,
0.9255521894,
-0.5188783407,
-0.3986195028,
0.1285144389,
-0.7484738827,
0.1993068159,
-0.3493503034,
0.1869115978,
-0.1847548336,
-0.2321210206,
0.5722252727,
-0.3601766527,
0.9097989798,
-0.5446686149,
-0.5108164549,
0.2423234284,
0.3562583029,
0.9621492624,
-0.1331995279,
-0.072736986,
-0.2674212158,
-0.3655451834,
-0.1630837917,
-0.7626560926,
0.5499892831,
-0.5956100821,
-0.9033072591,
-0.2787700891,
-0.3172071576,
-0.2925029099,
0.200013265,
0.2392489314,
0.617431581,
-0.047302302,
-0.2746441662,
0.7815800905,
-0.2866148055,
0.7547851205,
0.8540554047,
-0.1396008283,
-0.083381027,
0.7468782663,
-0.2223120034,
0.28068313,
0.2631571293,
0.5211890936,
-0.2331521511,
-0.7687825561,
-0.2184673399,
0.455889225,
-0.6748502254,
-0.1789799035,
-0.5352042913,
0.1314263195,
-0.164805308,
-0.2352266759,
-0.1857294589,
-0.0990719274,
-0.5693258643,
-0.0619139224,
0.1137440428,
0.5264564753,
0.047263056,
0.477309078,
-0.7351017594,
0.0107071958,
0.1506028324,
-0.0045592133,
0.1085629687,
-0.4682401717,
-0.1393035948,
-0.1293241829,
-0.1011943668,
-0.762033999,
0.474067688,
0.0198047273,
0.7115358114,
0.525724113,
0.0165509433,
0.2389741689,
-0.7577758431,
0.7563350797,
0.0905244276,
-0.8231461644,
0.7587875724,
-0.5540587902,
0.4348024726,
0.3966771066,
0.3255203366,
-0.4530811012,
-0.3680430055,
-0.1567274779,
-0.6117963791,
0.8525776863,
-0.1072490588,
0.3016108572,
-0.2842654586,
0.677262485,
0.2097439319,
0.3425383568,
-0.6719624996,
-0.3094759881,
0.1868093461,
-0.2069636434,
0.0176644474,
-0.6134351492,
-0.0947858319,
0.2000676841,
0.6927583814,
-0.4133577645,
0.1723085791,
0.1465723366,
0.0410469025,
-0.4885198176,
-0.052488789,
0.7680678964,
0.4895617664,
-0.0233332235,
-0.2936190367,
0.035891857,
-0.3363822401,
0.280690223,
-0.1246462092,
-0.453592062,
-0.1598633826,
0.4916519821,
0.8909435272,
0.0437264554,
-0.7800639272,
0.5733575821,
-0.055210948,
0.1352327764,
-0.4494227469,
0.4771458209,
-0.2416409105,
0.4897845089,
0.5484346747,
-0.1034707651,
0.3270845711,
-0.1956843585,
-0.1287479699,
0.8853251338,
-0.1371638775,
-0.3509604335,
0.8837735653,
0.3590105176,
-0.5627959967,
0.5002867579,
-0.2278635055,
-0.7085653543,
0.7280363441,
0.4630372822,
1.2330462933,
-0.4475827813,
0.0545032732,
0.5035092831,
0.2420392931,
-0.2757179141,
0.1914269626,
-0.0341402106,
-0.7412140369,
-0.6907530427,
-0.6599544287,
-0.5436743498,
-0.3607209921,
-0.5128129125,
0.5083755851,
-0.4724736512,
-0.1695394069,
-0.4177394211,
0.0240357351,
-0.538657546,
0.2379722446,
0.0629962161,
0.8424406052,
-0.6557306647,
0.3787081242,
0.5358601809,
-0.2536567748,
-0.9784935713,
-0.0731824413,
0.1451163739,
-1.189543128,
1.0333008766,
0.2175292969,
-0.3272849917,
0.0917970166,
-0.7525244951,
-0.9867627025,
0.7552213073,
0.5203393698,
-0.8652824759,
-0.5454291105,
-0.1001805514,
0.4069429338,
-0.5154613256,
0.3329559565,
0.291146487,
0.6694065928,
0.0746266693,
-1.0180807114,
0.3438812494,
-0.0233704783,
0.1798458397,
0.2847329378,
-0.8490707278,
0.6625572443,
-0.3687924445,
-0.029211849,
0.094116956,
0.4477859735,
0.315321207,
0.1559337527,
0.5313597918,
0.1584411114,
0.5534108877,
0.0175899975,
1.102678299,
-0.4463923275,
0.1909231693,
0.8788940907,
-0.4171618223,
0.2514379919,
0.6141091585,
-0.0721291751,
0.3918792009,
0.8170655966,
-0.3131505549,
0.5532197952,
0.3022502363,
-0.1729008704,
-0.4942217767,
-0.0798466131,
0.1511208415,
0.2344900072,
0.1190313473,
-0.3890988529,
-0.2285705656,
0.1209808514,
0.0762636438,
-0.079297252,
-0.3533257842,
0.8638743758,
0.0493705235,
-0.9310923219,
0.5683218241,
-0.0605953671,
0.5915814638,
-0.6082000732,
0.1510099173,
-0.29660514,
-0.1906352639,
-0.0568663254,
-0.3062980175,
-0.1130788401,
-0.0681683049,
0.0116653573,
-0.3525022566,
0.7593635321,
-0.1768839359,
-0.1422566473,
0.195737958,
0.4947546124,
0.0151295606,
-0.105130516,
-0.6289633512,
0.233754307,
0.112640202,
-0.6612818241,
0.0477472842,
0.5238523483,
-0.0344214104,
0.9953537583,
0.6668596864,
0.1505803317,
-0.1532035768,
0.0275575519,
0.7370996475,
-0.7935941219,
-0.4636794031,
-1.2490382195,
0.4280623198,
0.0718223378,
-0.2016541511,
0.8912426829,
0.4363489747,
0.2686491311,
-0.1179755256,
0.6117579937,
0.5834848285,
0.6203138828,
-0.9344934821,
0.365924865,
-0.5619981885,
0.3981529474,
-0.2690644562,
-1.4643751383,
-0.0847665295,
0.5189576745,
-0.4101185799,
0.2696456313,
0.6041701436,
0.9195751548,
0.3736136556,
-0.1074094549,
0.1818310916,
0.1507318914,
0.4435569048,
0.3783866167,
1.0245002508,
0.2266053855,
0.3124208152,
0.0324902833,
-0.2245927304,
-0.3964041173,
-1.1626976728,
-1.0151207447,
-0.4660719335,
-0.4776799679,
-0.1347839832,
0.0712003335,
1.338485837,
0.3573105335,
-0.4453054368,
-0.1120586246,
-0.2788095176,
-0.0038845022,
0.2118828297,
-0.2548148334,
0.3071902692,
-0.9314149618,
-0.7848860025,
0.6114034057,
0.2571038306,
0.2851033509,
-0.5637311935,
-0.108334519,
0.3206391633,
0.3342953324,
0.3984285891,
0.2092896998,
-0.6895197034,
-0.1642151475,
0.3403255939,
-0.3247676194,
-0.0109227626,
0.8507637382,
-0.6476308107,
0.394657135,
0.2674395144,
0.5248318911,
0.0854054913,
0.1018175855,
0.7716488838,
-0.4962126613,
-0.1805851758,
0.4313303828,
0.4632250667,
0.3637701869,
-0.581415534,
0.3256125152,
0.0666013211,
-0.7687708139,
-0.9714614749,
0.3488451242,
-0.7495630383,
-0.2145363688,
1.3979498148,
0.1155817062,
-0.5480699539,
0.2293623537,
-0.6380652189,
-0.0108190821,
-0.6569235921,
0.8872061372,
0.7991611958,
-0.437900424,
-0.2474741787,
-0.4180946052,
0.8364953995,
0.5790855289,
-0.6115227342,
0.1049296632,
0.7973876595,
0.1278775632,
0.0454920642,
0.5233432055,
0.2799426019,
0.2996068895,
-0.3928340971,
-0.1403667927,
-0.1504057199,
-0.2050942183,
-0.6186656952,
-0.1400571018,
0.3916261196,
0.1107630506
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02099v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02099v1
|
Analyzing the Evaluation of Cross-Lingual Knowledge Transfer in Multilingual Language Models
| 2024-02-03T09:41:52 | 2024-02-03T09:41:52 |
Sara Rajaee, Christof Monz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Recent advances in training multilingual language models on large datasets
seem to have shown promising results in knowledge transfer across languages and
achieve high performance on downstream tasks. However, we question to what
extent the current evaluation benchmarks and setups accurately measure
zero-shot cross-lingual knowledge transfer. In this work, we challenge the
assumption that high zero-shot performance on target tasks reflects high
cross-lingual ability by introducing more challenging setups involving
instances with multiple languages. Through extensive experiments and analysis,
we show that the observed high performance of multilingual models can be
largely attributed to factors not requiring the transfer of actual linguistic
knowledge, such as task- and surface-level knowledge. More specifically, we
observe what has been transferred across languages is mostly data artifacts and
biases, especially for low-resource languages. Our findings highlight the
overlooked drawbacks of existing cross-lingual test data and evaluation setups,
calling for a more nuanced understanding of the cross-lingual capabilities of
multilingual models.
|
[
-0.3847844899,
-0.4352186322,
0.4905638397,
0.1911810637,
0.2017920464,
0.0717258304,
-0.36895293,
-0.7117202282,
-0.1163062006,
0.2011974454,
-0.2962840497,
-0.1919985414,
-0.6970974207,
0.0651674718,
-0.3637276888,
0.9636098742,
-0.2949071825,
0.0524227321,
-0.1512458771,
-0.353212595,
-0.468226999,
-0.489879787,
-0.1713947058,
-0.4792563319,
0.6321492791,
0.4533489347,
0.5080135465,
0.3266886473,
0.1607245207,
0.0854978412,
0.316113323,
-0.2791261673,
-0.6705821157,
-0.3036668897,
-0.4987747967,
-0.4802843332,
-0.1894847751,
-0.035860341,
0.8870282769,
1.1253201962,
0.3257852495,
0.3505749702,
-0.0609114245,
0.3896049559,
-0.9284229875,
0.2033844292,
-0.5605938435,
0.3244134486,
-0.2921777964,
-0.0812439919,
-0.5278744102,
0.1381280273,
0.2419303656,
-0.7681165934,
0.0666420609,
-0.0970298871,
0.7726842165,
-0.1691225916,
-0.6877585053,
-0.096889697,
-0.7806456089,
0.9179578424,
-0.5303526521,
0.5921105146,
0.1212454885,
0.4299412668,
0.4944765568,
-0.0638471544,
-0.4608887434,
-0.2334593982,
-0.1176809594,
0.0521769002,
-0.2601274848,
-0.370952338,
0.2929974496,
0.1061948836,
-0.5914436579,
0.2082879096,
-0.4566752017,
-0.17260243,
0.5753394365,
-0.0585939474,
0.4614932537,
0.0456059128,
-0.5836023092,
-0.2075012028,
-0.5790851712,
0.2237478644,
0.2767390311,
0.5456736088,
-0.4418586791,
0.501134634,
-0.3755296767,
0.6993467808,
-0.2290541977,
-0.0863531753,
0.297919035,
-0.8012453914,
-0.0113430861,
-0.0108725103,
0.624507606,
0.3370435834,
0.6573294401,
-0.6263751984,
0.0382498242,
-0.0998114198,
0.0539446175,
-0.6531865597,
0.0788573101,
-0.2508248985,
-0.1317112446,
-0.003075036,
-0.2948544919,
-0.7757961154,
-0.1052296758,
-0.1530189514,
0.5917369127,
-0.3489291072,
-0.5262835026,
0.1996306032,
-0.2725848854,
0.3175749481,
0.1990866065,
-0.7390589118,
0.2122418582,
0.4916235209,
0.6135069728,
-0.4156022668,
-0.951990962,
-0.4208522439,
0.1587325335,
-0.6323708892,
0.7769238949,
-0.4973383844,
-0.0771186948,
0.134498924,
0.0993534625,
-0.7153344154,
-0.2026189864,
0.0099300928,
-0.2578595579,
0.1872303635,
-0.6586111188,
-0.3220377266,
-0.2393045425,
0.3162757158,
-0.4986695647,
0.8296243548,
0.2231431007,
-0.6381917596,
0.6637893319,
-0.4935274124,
-0.7672273517,
-0.0470157377,
0.0324949361,
0.1790276915,
0.1194580868,
0.138687551,
0.2992987037,
-0.3732471764,
0.0053168461,
-0.6150336266,
-0.495239079,
0.1840516776,
-0.4119389653,
0.9167781472,
0.032583911,
-0.5988672972,
-0.2863131762,
-0.6637613177,
0.1395078301,
-0.0349388607,
-0.2228779495,
-0.5230544209,
-0.789704442,
0.1114706993,
0.583319664,
0.0286443327,
-0.5808482766,
0.0904818401,
0.0263767391,
-0.0864812434,
0.344328016,
-0.3265929222,
0.7430348992,
-0.3685366511,
0.7438852787,
0.0160416998,
-0.0835768133,
-0.0854198858,
-0.3418542743,
-0.6237477064,
0.0723097771,
0.3946455121,
0.6310386658,
-1.0532484055,
-0.3348242044,
-0.5562779903,
-0.5528869629,
-0.5245088935,
0.2727052271,
0.7813730836,
0.5442320704,
0.2353347391,
-0.4775525331,
-0.0689526349,
-1.0668603182,
-0.5007666945,
-0.077659443,
0.3065661192,
0.3392344117,
0.4451279044,
0.3198322356,
0.3688768148,
0.1442941576,
-0.0429221839,
-0.388502121,
0.3757897615,
-0.1346279979,
0.3507520854,
0.9583566785,
-0.3231699169,
-0.7464455962,
0.5867221355,
-0.9074925184,
-0.2443635017,
-0.2210726589,
-0.2441479862,
0.3860123754,
0.1526255459,
-0.5203557611,
0.1489814371,
0.791223526,
-0.3412584662,
0.7525301576,
-0.0017396992,
0.5126569867,
-0.6147728562,
0.4859350622,
-0.0140195517,
-0.0368625782,
-0.8556056023,
0.0354481079,
0.2194334865,
-0.0145526258,
-0.8796503544,
1.0033532381,
-0.5443930626,
-0.5817198157,
0.07634224,
0.1509070992,
0.1618898064,
0.6260748506,
0.171221301,
0.7518310547,
0.7974366546,
-0.4157020152,
0.1496596634,
0.0587917157,
-0.4272682071,
1.1260290146,
-0.3473617435,
0.058783479,
0.1522479206,
-0.1775021255,
-0.8056697845,
0.1086822599,
0.1759306788,
-0.2253909856,
0.4354260266,
-0.3860136569,
-0.1906474233,
0.0192915648,
-0.1339618415,
0.764311254,
0.281806916,
-0.3123665452,
0.140364781,
0.1196674928,
-0.1208214834,
-0.8625926375,
-0.9021624923,
0.1694375575,
-0.2485817969,
-0.5966510773,
0.1446518749,
0.1450260133,
-0.268669039,
0.1227132976,
-0.0221226439,
-0.1803128719,
0.0751783922,
-0.1783520281,
0.0741596445,
-0.4850124121,
0.0583719946,
-0.1273920685,
0.0629588217,
0.0553090535,
-0.2671943903,
0.1628191471,
0.0046570729,
-0.6968358159,
-0.0806678832,
0.232166186,
0.7332606316,
-0.1514904052,
0.6382937431,
0.7243173718,
-0.2079548538,
-0.2131661922,
-0.4568522871,
0.2042294592,
-0.2381320298,
0.4917833805,
-0.8282270432,
-0.6272156835,
0.6748159528,
0.2718177736,
0.0631436482,
0.5082051754,
0.4753603935,
0.3046392798,
0.6943143606,
0.63896209,
-0.0528844707,
0.2615671158,
-0.1207791641,
0.1833758205,
-0.7054541111,
-0.0708425418,
-0.6058220863,
-0.1577392817,
-0.3783295751,
-0.4098416567,
0.0890137255,
0.0328194052,
-0.1508660614,
0.5484167933,
0.2117911726,
0.1834090203,
0.4636417031,
-0.3555054367,
0.4812294543,
0.1072790548,
-0.21570988,
0.0168291721,
-1.1887351274,
-0.1642423123,
1.2056457996,
0.1927314103,
0.6757518053,
-0.042272944,
0.2383251339,
0.1483430713,
0.265596658,
-0.5881716013,
0.1622597873,
-0.1971633881,
-0.7414000034,
-0.4433579445,
-0.5606745481,
-0.8451322317,
0.5592005849,
-0.0706835538,
-0.6559333801,
0.4504447281,
-0.2705001533,
-0.2160760909,
0.4783311188,
-0.7615095973,
1.2453824282,
-0.5267499685,
-0.5796015263,
-0.0603629313,
-0.2849918008,
0.4644421041,
-0.3480404317,
0.5868551731,
-0.2071964145,
0.1548574716,
0.660020113,
0.1522950977,
0.6185522676,
-0.191654101,
-0.4196184874,
-0.0772340596,
0.335937351,
0.0151262768,
-0.2216758877,
-0.1630971879,
0.5204063058,
0.3553260565,
-0.7132326365,
-0.586714685,
0.6159966588,
-0.6991626024,
-0.255403161,
-0.2350304872,
-0.8729417324,
-0.4870255589,
0.3000879884,
0.1941252798,
0.3163800836,
-0.1744108945,
-0.0332465991,
0.1902681142,
-0.3260130584,
0.3419540524,
0.7692161202,
-0.3265236318,
-0.0145426579,
1.0121614933,
0.5152773857,
0.6919551492,
0.2859319448,
-0.1591293067,
-0.2564588189,
-0.4386857748,
-1.1396720409,
0.1634898186,
-0.7300892472,
0.1614902467,
-0.3433329463,
-0.0219070464,
-0.5703754425,
-0.1305022985,
-0.6713423729,
-0.5900921226,
0.1926126778,
-0.0404341295,
-0.015878398,
0.6697587371,
-0.3127068281,
-0.1181165203,
-0.8434259892,
0.1932603866,
0.1991359442,
0.4311907291,
0.1708214432,
-0.6940522194,
-0.6640697718,
0.2345958799,
0.1997786164,
-0.6947425604,
0.2576062679,
0.2717120647,
0.8659477234,
0.0013137637,
0.0059769228,
0.8077411652,
-0.3335424364,
0.7040761709,
0.0711668506,
-0.9442978501,
0.0496887751,
-0.1975731552,
0.3930171132,
0.5243848562,
0.4706440568,
-0.7201989293,
-0.1756767631,
-0.4059609175,
-0.4475404918,
0.8931108713,
-0.042949371,
0.0964752436,
0.4393408597,
-0.0166552477,
0.4432049096,
0.1594190449,
-0.7845913172,
-0.0398409367,
-0.0014423413,
0.4259781241,
-0.3053514957,
0.023107104,
-0.1382648796,
-0.0665791184,
0.5702012777,
-0.3435977101,
0.0720906928,
-0.0334769301,
-0.5777254701,
-0.3732421994,
0.4799844325,
0.5094874501,
0.8959990144,
-0.0043243724,
0.1963590384,
0.4719109237,
-0.0513549,
0.2564134002,
0.2164123803,
-0.191734165,
-0.0456160791,
0.853910327,
0.9855341911,
0.6749426126,
-0.421699971,
0.5400255919,
0.100164555,
-0.238368839,
0.1859351546,
-0.2267056555,
-0.1649499238,
0.0501919501,
0.2590519786,
-0.0975506231,
0.0414747447,
-0.7658463717,
0.1881248355,
0.5025727749,
-0.5651949644,
-0.6719886661,
0.2994972169,
-0.0506983101,
0.1836801171,
0.4493923485,
-0.0600032434,
-0.504734695,
0.5104816556,
0.396024406,
0.5844885111,
-0.2039346099,
0.3639476895,
0.3031241298,
0.4749880731,
0.0755086467,
0.0848401785,
-0.2139155716,
-0.7238233685,
-0.7264345884,
-0.5927299261,
-0.4269184172,
-0.0155970789,
-0.7708827853,
0.2048319131,
0.1539996266,
0.208981052,
0.0964443982,
-0.1276810467,
-0.9692566991,
-0.0449567847,
0.3100801706,
0.9131450653,
-1.2283132076,
0.8580997586,
0.5564053059,
-0.3951012194,
-0.5814895034,
-0.2817672789,
-0.1461278945,
-1.0236239433,
0.7669771314,
0.0627170578,
-0.0431419015,
-0.3482609689,
0.2557092607,
-0.8001382947,
0.7446535826,
0.6866326928,
-0.3359955847,
-0.1015038043,
0.6473771334,
0.648447156,
-0.392323643,
0.4526433647,
0.5019195676,
0.7370697856,
0.0421138257,
-1.6540852785,
0.1067112535,
-0.3926363885,
-0.0617815815,
-0.1511669606,
-0.4721986353,
0.9224116206,
-0.1795722395,
-0.170773834,
-0.3125195205,
0.0479796715,
-0.1260879636,
0.4326959252,
0.2943744659,
0.660310626,
0.2721702158,
0.0015435272,
1.2842065096,
-0.420078665,
0.3175112009,
0.9299077988,
-0.674539268,
0.7371247411,
0.5398836732,
-0.143882826,
0.300331682,
0.3179593682,
0.0216769837,
0.4391604364,
0.003867001,
0.0948627293,
-0.3522108197,
-0.3433722556,
-0.4858740866,
0.6457812786,
-0.0854454711,
-0.083454892,
-0.6078115106,
0.2363277227,
-0.0399685241,
-0.1871601641,
-0.1299526244,
0.6069440842,
-0.0490040742,
-0.9330186844,
0.9625271559,
-0.2803085446,
0.6110850573,
-0.3471297324,
-0.0937091708,
-0.2697776854,
0.0956614092,
-0.1048911214,
-0.8273041248,
0.5086259246,
-0.0306004807,
0.0497086421,
-0.4790925086,
0.7206038237,
-0.6243062615,
-0.4664101899,
0.739317894,
1.1634601355,
0.3420092762,
-0.0455772877,
-0.5422797203,
-0.1421888769,
-0.07180392,
-0.1585572958,
0.7096050978,
0.6128051877,
-0.1661747545,
0.32295385,
0.6772596836,
0.3437491953,
0.3107701838,
0.1734630615,
0.3539148271,
-0.4174846411,
-0.1028679386,
-0.592592895,
0.4044520855,
0.213160485,
-0.3910044134,
1.0751549006,
0.5787138343,
1.3735704422,
-0.1143327132,
1.0468935966,
-0.0391948856,
0.2653827965,
-0.4042125642,
0.8289824724,
-0.7717065215,
0.0260897093,
-0.1984911412,
-0.7620475292,
-0.0411355458,
0.3408319354,
-0.5313153863,
0.1451607645,
0.5872571468,
0.457449466,
-0.2739889622,
-0.3207653165,
0.8152607083,
0.0635114387,
0.0328545049,
0.9295790195,
0.8622767329,
-0.4968525469,
0.6565436721,
-0.6420581937,
-0.1619844288,
-0.0681794211,
-0.849386096,
-0.8824227452,
-0.5099767447,
-0.2892928421,
-0.0286317319,
0.3059758842,
0.1746481806,
0.8789325356,
-0.8364034295,
-0.7076765299,
0.3097749949,
0.2065381855,
-0.4289596975,
-0.2172018141,
0.1519170702,
-0.5018025041,
-0.6345986724,
0.4587065876,
0.1524223387,
-0.1349906623,
-0.4291202724,
-0.1175199077,
-0.3407902122,
-0.1655070782,
0.5676116943,
0.4772774279,
-0.542975843,
-0.3124555945,
0.2913405597,
-0.0957624316,
-0.1077141166,
0.6884921193,
-0.6683479548,
0.3680580556,
0.5171233416,
0.6603550911,
0.6436329484,
-0.4590446055,
0.7624207735,
-0.5881314278,
0.0065552858,
-0.1985923052,
0.4281027317,
0.4930561781,
-0.0588722415,
0.5928489566,
0.2534044683,
-0.0887764692,
-0.9782372117,
-0.0645835251,
-0.5626370311,
-0.2544059455,
1.196896553,
-0.5490600467,
-0.0961698517,
-0.1316876709,
0.277925849,
0.2179900259,
0.0921852365,
0.5954283476,
1.0015170574,
-0.1758947074,
-0.2840262353,
-0.8202219009,
0.1699566841,
0.6017166972,
-0.8319144845,
0.2643826902,
0.3254999518,
0.4750711322,
0.4518322647,
0.3670907021,
-0.1606266946,
0.5111681223,
0.2199218124,
0.0734382644,
-0.0352595113,
-0.4784584343,
-0.5055983067,
0.2008115798,
0.0118837487,
0.0818124413
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02084v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02084v1
|
Revisiting the Markov Property for Machine Translation
| 2024-02-03T08:50:50 | 2024-02-03T08:50:50 |
Cunxiao Du, Hao Zhou, Zhaopeng Tu, Jing Jiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we re-examine the Markov property in the context of neural
machine translation. We design a Markov Autoregressive Transformer~(MAT) and
undertake a comprehensive assessment of its performance across four WMT
benchmarks. Our findings indicate that MAT with an order larger than 4 can
generate translations with quality on par with that of conventional
autoregressive transformers. In addition, counter-intuitively, we also find
that the advantages of utilizing a higher-order MAT do not specifically
contribute to the translation of longer sentences.
|
[
-0.5028082728,
-0.3195681274,
0.4047631323,
0.3300364912,
-0.4064427912,
-0.0028608704,
-0.1306117624,
-0.2713614106,
-0.0326837748,
0.273922056,
-0.4453120232,
-0.2027611285,
-1.0931538343,
-0.1268207431,
-0.6924437284,
1.0127075911,
-0.23035191,
-0.1447813958,
0.1409703642,
-0.3568231761,
-0.5471031666,
-0.4077830315,
-0.2652304471,
-0.5427884459,
0.7406408191,
-0.0966917723,
1.2461290359,
1.0196678638,
0.9523925781,
0.336586684,
0.2462203801,
-0.0230865851,
0.0058450517,
0.5226061344,
-0.0238877404,
-0.604103446,
-0.6485139132,
0.3388654888,
0.7010952234,
0.5561839342,
-0.2928363383,
0.4386810362,
-0.1933585852,
0.9513418078,
-0.4809169173,
0.1766044796,
-0.7068791389,
0.4518448412,
-0.0106715988,
-0.3382677138,
-0.6623142362,
-0.2900568247,
-0.1756389737,
-0.1348111033,
0.1406959593,
0.1516473889,
0.8162977099,
0.8616896868,
-0.8454130888,
0.2793559134,
-0.985714972,
0.893012464,
-0.4923785329,
0.6252988577,
0.1772643179,
0.8637452722,
-0.1913836598,
-0.8294813633,
-0.5102044344,
-0.1205609143,
-0.0737764463,
0.3471185863,
-0.3757125139,
-0.2423098236,
0.4125519395,
0.5895761847,
-0.4775834978,
0.179404065,
-0.1828990579,
0.0658939928,
0.610545218,
0.7080816627,
0.1670302451,
-0.025815051,
-0.3919249773,
-0.5058379769,
-0.2577805519,
-0.0864255801,
0.3742061257,
-0.1591875255,
0.3858252466,
0.9113438725,
-0.0518030152,
0.7229759097,
-0.1709884107,
-0.1343623996,
0.3274816275,
-0.3197279572,
-0.1216371283,
-0.013784958,
1.0193628073,
0.3885421157,
0.0933406353,
-0.1781848967,
-0.495192349,
0.111206688,
0.5428669453,
-0.9290374517,
-0.5185747147,
-0.1908824444,
-0.6560531259,
0.0544231609,
-0.0884538442,
-0.4600244164,
0.0548508912,
-0.3540860415,
0.6126876473,
-0.3581167459,
-0.1626744866,
0.0721664876,
-0.1789148748,
0.2955437899,
0.2603523433,
-0.6086381674,
0.4017528296,
0.4423935413,
0.742569983,
-0.440315187,
-0.3467189372,
-0.3448259532,
-0.1471992731,
-0.6891793609,
0.4882091284,
-0.3403450847,
-0.193321839,
-0.3477106988,
-0.1032437757,
-0.2398247123,
-0.4499539733,
0.1192673668,
-0.6591944695,
0.3625538945,
0.0136550711,
-0.0347241983,
-0.0571897887,
-0.1104233935,
-0.4061427116,
0.9626255631,
0.3092669547,
-0.3791225553,
0.5995616317,
-0.5932968855,
-0.7756136656,
-0.4155638516,
0.1111768186,
-0.6493094563,
0.2166022062,
-0.028237123,
0.583427608,
-0.2141162455,
0.4145044684,
0.0939908922,
-0.114405565,
0.9330313802,
-0.9462863803,
0.3948795199,
0.7928792834,
-0.4799684286,
-0.0383271724,
-0.9381605387,
-0.0451600961,
0.1483957618,
-0.6471402049,
0.2673559487,
0.1612986177,
-0.1054877341,
0.9295907021,
0.0785821155,
-0.4477979839,
0.2354721129,
-0.1436048895,
0.5490100384,
0.4737584293,
0.0281457845,
0.7306186557,
-0.401461482,
0.6382268667,
0.3684433997,
0.1087337062,
-0.3875198066,
-0.8500117064,
-0.9614976645,
-0.4087342024,
0.2113281488,
0.3000463843,
-0.5571777225,
0.4688603878,
-0.2393217832,
-0.4978459477,
-0.91891855,
-0.1087707803,
0.3867283165,
0.4167806804,
0.7784817219,
-0.4431454837,
-0.4494998157,
-1.2970126867,
-0.3697170317,
-0.0341856852,
-0.1970696449,
0.0792145059,
0.1639201641,
-0.3158744276,
0.5435800552,
-0.5521849394,
-0.1494712532,
0.0115477508,
0.3949230313,
0.5214595795,
0.6744009852,
0.263187021,
-0.4935701787,
-0.3800165951,
-0.0140227778,
-0.3162000477,
-0.01553383,
-0.2823155224,
-0.1888365149,
0.459228009,
0.2559289634,
-0.9740988016,
0.5779677629,
0.3883226812,
-0.0499598011,
0.0252324846,
-0.4542720914,
0.2329393476,
-1.368245244,
0.1555628628,
-0.1306255758,
-0.522318542,
-0.2953317463,
-0.1934713125,
0.226042524,
0.0102738068,
-0.6087927222,
-0.2006288469,
-0.5475232005,
-0.5476779342,
-0.3322615921,
-0.205929935,
-0.1014193967,
0.3674338758,
-0.2773580551,
0.873296082,
-0.0558647849,
-0.8022322655,
0.1756741703,
0.3167826831,
-0.4149044752,
0.6507743597,
-0.4293713272,
0.0046773613,
-0.0381885804,
0.1850463599,
-1.0574250221,
0.2813906968,
0.019912079,
-0.7897845507,
0.4974913597,
-0.2304207236,
-0.7935095429,
-0.5205535293,
0.3045939803,
0.2144691795,
1.1977548599,
-0.3859359026,
0.1498341113,
0.2614951134,
0.41324687,
-0.5550183654,
-0.9733358622,
0.3172253966,
-0.2217010856,
-0.3868964911,
0.1006883383,
-0.0783569589,
-0.0586632229,
-0.2357016206,
-0.0218982715,
0.0337555073,
0.3421136439,
0.2498967052,
-0.0084025329,
-0.6503877044,
-0.081418775,
-0.0720081404,
-0.6624861956,
0.4188396335,
-0.7049376369,
0.5630846024,
0.0248830244,
-0.323153019,
-0.4966656566,
0.1695906669,
0.9779784083,
-0.3345594108,
0.7681065798,
0.8715525866,
-0.2200146616,
-0.0673366636,
-0.3310712278,
0.0777681768,
-0.5069614053,
0.3757811785,
-0.5952282548,
-0.2954315841,
0.3559128642,
0.1954311281,
0.0286717378,
0.9713105559,
0.8462352157,
-0.3087747097,
1.5116021633,
0.2903042734,
-0.1026876271,
0.4609355628,
-0.3130504787,
0.3581082821,
-1.0096851587,
-0.3118798137,
-0.5126851201,
-1.017092824,
-0.7837126851,
-0.2329398543,
-0.0278348159,
-0.2526691556,
-0.4029254615,
1.0021517277,
-0.5651583672,
0.1548184603,
0.5081573129,
-0.2960126698,
0.2116633952,
-0.3630284369,
-0.1024370417,
-0.3992025554,
-0.6679542065,
-0.3981947601,
0.6883975267,
0.3957803845,
0.753927052,
0.3431902528,
0.4124409258,
0.1209350303,
0.1115625054,
-0.8327188492,
0.5155901909,
0.1226418763,
-0.5143616796,
-0.2228219956,
-0.5070254207,
-1.3826723099,
0.6058081985,
-0.2018916458,
-0.473838985,
0.0484622344,
-0.0031622525,
0.1852460057,
0.4406883121,
-0.4664039612,
0.7963502407,
-0.2501967847,
0.0082190093,
-0.1777988523,
-0.8125219941,
0.2126089334,
-0.0815933719,
-0.2314878553,
-0.3315249085,
-0.3087349236,
0.5326569676,
-0.4569626153,
0.2501264215,
-0.0604577884,
-0.0252282508,
0.0141272685,
0.6475073099,
0.2241933197,
-0.155154109,
0.1390334219,
-0.1751778275,
-0.2890619934,
-0.2867682576,
-0.7012346387,
0.6089782119,
-0.8509750962,
-0.6289755702,
-0.2987210155,
-0.8908033967,
-0.0499585122,
0.3616217673,
0.283231318,
0.3371087015,
0.0604164042,
0.1574380249,
0.4723802805,
0.144394964,
0.9992393851,
0.5226606727,
-0.2620991766,
-0.4120704234,
0.9157940149,
0.5423877239,
0.3821518421,
0.4075869918,
0.0217302162,
-0.2594524026,
-0.6913294792,
-0.7223798633,
-0.0568372235,
-0.7125937343,
-0.4622966647,
-1.1233450174,
-0.2971743643,
-0.1296200007,
0.0816995725,
-0.7532468438,
-1.1093996763,
-0.2085325122,
0.0364138745,
0.3142749071,
1.0069214106,
0.1766597033,
0.2395196259,
-0.9097027779,
0.3572273552,
0.1562367976,
0.1773147285,
-0.3499924839,
-0.9274019599,
-0.1965249032,
-0.1328586489,
-0.6088674068,
-0.6900482178,
0.7997589111,
0.010916248,
0.6612896323,
0.1607820392,
-0.0649596229,
0.6324326992,
-1.0054081678,
0.7229459286,
0.3084128797,
-0.7355591059,
0.3962593675,
-0.3709149659,
0.4806072414,
0.2199094743,
0.3859083951,
-0.4853729606,
-0.3880381584,
-0.9041433334,
-0.7860162258,
0.3192492127,
0.4973017871,
0.2493067384,
-0.0669363067,
0.3191604018,
0.1065102816,
0.6143891811,
-0.2605673671,
-0.4916954637,
-0.427870959,
-0.1369902194,
-0.6383261681,
0.040274892,
0.3975610435,
-0.302333802,
0.5294142962,
0.0884000733,
0.5767529011,
0.0934985355,
-0.3787365258,
-0.1562427729,
0.3308704793,
0.816721797,
0.6614075303,
-0.1901972294,
0.6191432476,
0.312630266,
-0.2310325205,
0.5092881322,
-0.2063024193,
0.1613211334,
0.1349664629,
-0.088059172,
0.589648068,
-0.0107888505,
0.222191453,
0.4426645339,
-0.1150739938,
-0.2418947518,
-0.1213754788,
0.244440496,
0.050203532,
0.2238303721,
0.1384600848,
0.6581098437,
0.1651982218,
-0.3685883284,
0.5302653909,
0.2439174205,
-0.5735686421,
-0.5730895996,
0.9639661908,
-0.274998188,
-0.8680728674,
0.8306210041,
0.0805029497,
-0.6089612246,
0.5428884029,
0.8897433877,
0.7521344423,
-0.4588577747,
-0.1920472533,
0.2072203606,
0.6421519518,
-0.057907965,
-0.0523519889,
-0.2298299819,
-0.1962080747,
-0.2858159244,
-0.3771130443,
-0.2264560759,
-0.3364380598,
-0.9697008729,
-0.0521615259,
-0.2769689262,
-0.6095576286,
-0.0636727959,
-0.2895005047,
-0.9136871099,
0.3496660292,
-0.2668708861,
0.6945222616,
-0.6230185628,
1.2362215519,
0.4728780389,
-0.393629998,
-0.2101216316,
-0.2201784551,
-0.2567131221,
-0.896971643,
0.8328710794,
0.0681681484,
-0.0660466924,
0.2002963871,
-0.17935507,
-1.046857357,
1.178045392,
0.2585632205,
-0.2128997594,
0.4014749825,
0.4462853968,
0.8546603322,
-0.3935462236,
0.1651099622,
0.6466141939,
0.3556317091,
-0.1725381315,
-0.7782045007,
-0.0061898394,
-0.2822328508,
0.4625352919,
0.6559556723,
-0.6032888293,
0.7171216607,
-0.0568636023,
-0.1591004729,
-0.115218766,
0.921461165,
-0.5217994452,
-0.1255110651,
0.1436601281,
0.6228144765,
0.5144188404,
-0.1996245682,
1.221701026,
-0.2834451795,
0.1525304466,
1.0324938297,
-0.0628059506,
1.0795787573,
0.6666245461,
-0.3067750931,
0.4177544117,
0.3962291479,
-0.0795203969,
0.5760598183,
0.621768117,
0.1343631893,
-0.2309824824,
0.2208365351,
-0.3668065667,
0.2205881923,
0.1922832131,
-0.6314915419,
0.167265594,
-0.085147664,
-0.0724203438,
0.0653185248,
-0.0020962791,
0.7895009518,
0.4432399869,
-0.8230369687,
0.5877486467,
0.1214329824,
0.2550370991,
-0.037789721,
-0.0214894526,
-0.0459785014,
0.4471104741,
0.0139674488,
-0.9726063013,
0.6594839096,
-0.3262990713,
-0.3206159472,
-0.631262362,
0.4810534716,
-0.3540465832,
-0.21952039,
0.0908213183,
0.4362457097,
0.3633653522,
0.3438579738,
-0.6194754839,
-0.2837300897,
-0.4991489351,
-0.479672879,
0.4475620687,
0.562322855,
0.2690693438,
0.8650547862,
0.6482955217,
-0.252655983,
0.4579429328,
-0.27670753,
0.557061851,
-0.8479120731,
-0.1419410706,
-0.8512434363,
0.6204095483,
0.2698521018,
-0.3023014367,
0.8590618968,
0.6442990899,
0.5935890079,
-0.005286139,
0.4114660621,
0.4424763322,
-0.0800870508,
-0.4940410852,
0.9940894246,
-0.246004656,
0.1092451513,
0.0304063112,
-1.3851069212,
-0.4154807031,
0.6644367576,
-0.0157943219,
-0.0314269178,
1.0459862947,
0.3906440437,
-0.1102337018,
-0.3220737875,
0.8638612628,
0.1858550459,
0.3960666358,
0.6560342908,
1.1916447878,
-0.9964706898,
0.5694804788,
-0.0933634937,
0.245294854,
0.1500374973,
-0.8871093988,
-1.0859565735,
-0.7553152442,
-0.4420253932,
-0.7085192204,
-0.1775128543,
0.8673020005,
0.5663174987,
-0.5247520804,
-0.0488006957,
0.0016053505,
-0.0392082296,
-0.1814946532,
-0.1087028533,
0.1922653764,
-0.5447863936,
-0.5794394016,
0.4665344059,
0.2998759151,
0.3386262953,
-0.2630664408,
-0.2111620903,
-0.0396311134,
0.2018288821,
0.5146145225,
-0.2223823667,
-0.44027403,
-0.1987109929,
0.1525759399,
-0.5303837657,
0.7968366742,
0.9237002134,
-0.7544847727,
0.2168700993,
0.6136819124,
0.8947382569,
0.8302826881,
-0.4139729738,
0.7268288136,
-0.3806763589,
-0.0933794305,
0.1593537331,
0.6053040624,
0.1040427461,
-0.1856052279,
0.3062491417,
0.1389955282,
-0.6818919182,
-0.5275092125,
0.230730921,
-0.8840144277,
0.153338626,
1.0766550303,
-0.0193093382,
-0.3551204205,
-0.1045480222,
-0.0754160732,
0.4684512615,
-0.2918849289,
0.5300704837,
0.3899694681,
-0.0174695365,
-0.1981994659,
-0.7616253495,
0.2563767433,
0.6151329875,
-0.4827506542,
-0.2254965901,
0.0829246938,
0.1191084608,
0.1594400555,
0.2911371589,
-0.5066713095,
0.3087778389,
-0.2193544954,
0.0182747766,
-0.2738472819,
-0.3823804855,
-0.5155867934,
-0.0308180731,
0.2620292902,
-0.5441435575
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02082v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02082v1
|
GliDe with a CaPE: A Low-Hassle Method to Accelerate Speculative Decoding
| 2024-02-03T08:44:11 | 2024-02-03T08:44:11 |
Cunxiao Du, Jing Jiang, Xu Yuanchen, Jiawei Wu, Sicheng Yu, Yongqi Li, Shenggui Li, Kai Xu, Liqiang Nie, Zhaopeng Tu, Yang You
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Speculative decoding is a relatively new decoding framework that leverages
small and efficient draft models to reduce the latency of LLMs. In this study,
we introduce GliDe and CaPE, two low-hassle modifications to vanilla
speculative decoding to further improve the decoding speed of a frozen LLM.
Specifically, GliDe is a modified draft model architecture that reuses the
cached keys and values from the target LLM, while CaPE is a proposal expansion
method that uses the draft model's confidence scores to help select additional
candidate tokens for verification. Extensive experiments on different
benchmarks demonstrate that our proposed GliDe draft model significantly
reduces the expected decoding latency. Additional evaluation using walltime
reveals that GliDe can accelerate Vicuna models up to 2.17x and further extend
the improvement to 2.61x with CaPE. We will release our code, data, and the
trained draft models.
|
[
-0.0983541459,
-0.7055148482,
0.2959933281,
0.1756752282,
-0.3034768403,
0.4520195723,
0.2134578228,
-0.8229906559,
0.5455818176,
0.809630394,
-0.507237494,
-0.350307107,
-0.7614867687,
-0.1973203868,
-0.3404103816,
0.4410232306,
0.0154983271,
-0.2379156202,
0.1416767538,
0.2592819631,
0.0115652094,
-0.704903245,
-0.5477957129,
0.0412897542,
0.3685136139,
0.5374075174,
0.9023700953,
0.8916833997,
0.5600811839,
0.1837218106,
-0.3446657956,
0.2911385,
-0.8442593813,
-0.0870691389,
0.4591410458,
-0.6751483679,
-0.9682304859,
-0.3135284483,
0.3717920184,
0.628713727,
-0.0699722692,
0.0040593199,
-0.2235765904,
0.8861114979,
-1.2525451183,
-0.1688679457,
-0.5821781754,
-0.1850174367,
-0.5002985001,
-0.4238929451,
-0.4488627911,
-0.2138186395,
-0.0631194636,
-0.7988823652,
0.3163286746,
0.2598077357,
0.6978648901,
-0.1235226989,
-0.4463244975,
-0.1256816834,
-0.5654829741,
0.6654518843,
-0.6149512529,
0.6784301996,
0.4508964419,
0.2786092758,
-0.1341017336,
-1.013759613,
-0.2492580861,
-0.2214797884,
0.4310860932,
0.0673904046,
-0.1537587047,
0.1434818357,
0.2191505581,
0.4561655819,
-0.1236980706,
0.2774347961,
-0.5324556828,
-0.6202319264,
0.5532306433,
0.4035869539,
-0.1358250082,
-0.151027143,
-0.5844916701,
0.0089506647,
-0.7037185431,
0.3807558119,
0.4092341065,
0.5123272538,
-0.6486477256,
0.5211898088,
-0.334928304,
0.6269617677,
0.1474629194,
-0.1254753768,
0.1843237877,
-0.1384345442,
-0.1896229684,
-0.0230841171,
0.0893831924,
0.5227348804,
-0.3980181813,
-0.1849269718,
-0.2345259488,
0.1103076264,
-0.0201078746,
-0.870466888,
-0.2403392941,
0.2178405672,
-0.8172793388,
-0.2430264652,
-0.1531530172,
-0.7195829153,
-0.3506633043,
-0.0161141101,
-0.0215535685,
-0.5916116238,
-0.4230984747,
0.7101002932,
-0.3046922386,
0.2337633371,
0.5691924691,
-1.0259208679,
0.5650627613,
0.9293547273,
0.8546652794,
-0.3283373415,
-0.161003381,
-0.9146361947,
0.0792134926,
-0.7000169754,
1.007676363,
-0.6483835578,
-0.7530086637,
0.1926398277,
-0.4481412768,
0.1089944392,
-0.0309522655,
0.6710138321,
-0.9660387039,
-0.3064928651,
-0.8345713019,
-0.6114142537,
-0.2572293878,
0.2375169247,
-0.7837684751,
0.8055785298,
0.298700422,
-0.6625661254,
0.5984175205,
-0.4315765798,
-0.4021139443,
0.1961164027,
0.1364479214,
0.1664062142,
0.3437209129,
0.3140861094,
0.0971972123,
-0.4922336936,
-0.6664432287,
-0.2560480833,
-0.8672866225,
-0.1444848031,
-0.398953706,
0.5351783633,
0.5346412659,
0.1655844897,
-0.3086017668,
-0.7369424701,
0.2334056795,
-0.4796993434,
-0.6641076803,
-0.0589388832,
-0.091117762,
0.1751729399,
-0.2809872031,
0.2945346534,
-0.2528745532,
0.5374251008,
-0.5730828047,
-0.0386198983,
0.4432347715,
0.2652023137,
0.6467843056,
-0.4485174716,
0.7016519904,
0.080250293,
0.2914548218,
-0.0821409225,
-0.4577896297,
-0.885338366,
-0.5475373864,
0.3129144013,
0.3492879272,
-0.8582611084,
0.0667584464,
-0.2331897616,
-0.4635017514,
-0.5400729179,
0.1967270821,
0.3536584973,
0.3827275634,
0.3841585219,
-0.0797697827,
-0.5476266146,
-0.7018113732,
-0.3141520023,
-0.251712203,
0.1919132024,
0.2328626513,
0.018057378,
-0.3561323881,
0.6080904603,
-0.3415306807,
0.0966083482,
-0.1140744984,
0.2180892825,
0.2673893273,
0.4314338267,
0.824847877,
-0.750466764,
-0.3696615696,
0.0032153178,
-0.4824276865,
0.4344604313,
0.2323231548,
-0.1894119084,
0.3096277714,
0.5252655149,
-0.5871558189,
0.5506941676,
0.2755033672,
-0.4687439203,
0.4864629805,
-0.359816879,
0.8251330256,
-0.6171125174,
-0.0370350741,
-0.570913434,
0.0072137979,
-0.6400543451,
0.2198851854,
0.1591313034,
-0.0132187856,
-0.7971737981,
0.4973899722,
-0.7846363783,
0.2077085376,
-0.4154556692,
-0.1499817222,
-0.0621598028,
0.0244797654,
0.1318854392,
0.791347146,
0.9191683531,
-0.877069056,
-0.1110294238,
0.0686687231,
-0.1197732836,
0.0999991596,
-0.1607074142,
0.4545406401,
-0.1021296754,
-0.0215076245,
-0.7970428467,
-0.2097938657,
0.1245796978,
-0.1823432595,
0.1105196774,
-0.6560810804,
-0.2544888854,
-0.4053796232,
-0.5703465939,
0.3046735525,
0.760784328,
-0.4452981651,
0.8847161531,
0.1571043134,
0.4038711786,
-0.9726798534,
-0.8587805033,
0.2496153861,
0.1271416694,
-0.7010170817,
0.2612487674,
-0.1398686171,
-0.3812970221,
-0.171444878,
-0.0682603568,
-0.0284467731,
0.0024448687,
0.3279084861,
0.3194979727,
-0.3984621167,
-0.264687866,
0.3439081013,
-0.2030831575,
-0.2595133781,
-0.4093295038,
0.4008436799,
-0.3186798692,
-0.0441716164,
-0.1069931909,
0.4419568479,
0.642716825,
0.1770560592,
0.5869592428,
0.2705625296,
-0.3879799247,
-0.2019246817,
-0.8204632401,
-0.1752385199,
-0.5463482738,
-0.0420239866,
-0.7638754845,
-0.7925031185,
1.0173892975,
-0.2048226595,
-0.0615013987,
0.3126655817,
0.368208915,
0.0529652834,
0.2789027393,
1.3336628675,
-0.0018268113,
0.1595289409,
-0.5775132775,
-0.2877744138,
-0.581330061,
-0.3623941839,
-0.481626749,
-0.3006799221,
-0.0948474854,
-0.8440412879,
0.0295810755,
0.646060288,
-0.0039492026,
0.2325062603,
-0.2134753913,
0.4525101781,
0.134912312,
0.4097035825,
0.3470465541,
0.1368793696,
-0.1359255761,
-0.0561632961,
-1.0598250628,
-0.3894225359,
1.2454240322,
0.2012143433,
0.8025600314,
0.0258750748,
0.5896217227,
0.6583177447,
0.2047694474,
-0.6441249847,
0.493491441,
-0.4075374305,
-0.4941047132,
0.0784527436,
-0.1429447383,
-0.6383957863,
-0.1665581912,
-0.6108912826,
-0.7562536597,
0.763797164,
0.5373001695,
-0.4644177854,
0.5807133317,
-0.5204026103,
0.3490374684,
-0.1225298271,
-0.6599292159,
-0.4041128755,
-0.3599328697,
0.7099235654,
-0.0813081563,
0.1008761227,
-0.0664614365,
-0.4702650607,
0.8521814346,
-0.6609768271,
0.6544537544,
-0.3451067209,
-0.1184501275,
0.4618973434,
0.6480902433,
0.6454776525,
0.0645642281,
-0.7605580091,
0.2945649624,
-0.0367138796,
-0.5803877115,
-0.3751932383,
0.7102355957,
-0.6847158074,
-0.4099863172,
-0.2337596416,
-0.4394506216,
-0.2664651275,
0.1126669571,
0.6692547798,
0.2755016088,
-0.0902559906,
-0.1665618271,
0.337017417,
0.3875128925,
0.3998622,
0.7734313607,
-0.1528176814,
-0.2925261259,
0.519607842,
0.1293171346,
0.2302970886,
0.453756392,
-0.1187151596,
-0.3738233149,
-1.0943447351,
-0.1754532754,
0.0555575676,
-0.8910182714,
-0.3348115385,
-0.5261186361,
-0.034851145,
-0.364069432,
-0.5383777618,
-0.6288933754,
-0.6968823075,
-0.3942283988,
-0.0211872533,
0.8736461997,
0.6633657813,
-0.3908120394,
0.6351690888,
-0.8554819822,
0.4822891653,
-0.1363187581,
0.3282243311,
0.0717050508,
-0.7938542962,
-0.3523345292,
0.1404034644,
0.205278337,
-0.5418688059,
0.3458998799,
0.004972104,
0.4034243524,
0.5273880363,
0.3484867811,
1.0447436571,
-0.2876608968,
0.9493939281,
0.3144252598,
-1.0522698164,
0.4001214802,
-0.3207797706,
0.0048743836,
0.7385870218,
0.3637329638,
-0.0616324842,
0.0379617922,
-0.4205949903,
-0.593773067,
0.3185967803,
-0.1013287082,
-0.0721825212,
-0.0277219731,
0.9263802171,
0.3677081466,
0.0155447833,
0.2297196835,
-0.1969307363,
-0.1047614962,
0.5559130311,
-0.0905097201,
-0.7547789812,
-0.0283984132,
0.0050344891,
0.2111453861,
-0.0520304367,
0.2872648835,
0.1593293399,
0.0587539859,
-0.5378841162,
-0.1236839741,
0.4039567113,
0.5627116561,
-0.3957217932,
0.0498875938,
0.296634078,
-0.7166737318,
0.2049701512,
-0.2844858766,
-0.1861960292,
-0.1776254773,
0.6496085525,
0.80798769,
0.4082440436,
-0.1853109747,
0.3082486987,
-0.0520245098,
-0.5129649639,
0.1967179626,
0.2462164611,
-0.1024948433,
0.2515107095,
0.5362362862,
0.8429927826,
0.3431345522,
-0.4164349437,
0.3319317997,
0.2609927356,
-0.0966140106,
-0.3226766884,
0.8873337507,
0.3172158599,
-0.4737614393,
0.7115325928,
0.0450981371,
-0.1697121412,
0.4397394061,
0.4298725426,
0.7460329533,
0.1696348041,
-0.0233027991,
0.1350078136,
0.2491842955,
-0.274769038,
0.7620404363,
-0.076686509,
-0.6628165245,
-0.451005578,
-0.5338478684,
-0.5286864042,
-0.2588793933,
-0.8677198887,
0.4962464571,
-0.4588666856,
-0.3693425357,
-0.5427727103,
0.1824798584,
-0.8480469584,
-0.0234501585,
0.1135588586,
1.6926028728,
-0.5608006716,
0.9242919087,
0.1284971833,
-0.0004104376,
-0.714081049,
0.202797547,
-0.022167962,
-0.6824499369,
0.7274803519,
-0.245377332,
-0.6892520785,
-0.0321154781,
-0.4325054586,
-0.9428545833,
0.9662345052,
0.7589612007,
-0.7993553877,
-0.0261831805,
-0.274443686,
0.3685318828,
-0.4186713398,
0.1931029856,
0.5088695884,
0.3958010674,
0.4427114129,
-0.7254888415,
-0.108075656,
-0.2276229858,
-0.0851021186,
-0.3351621628,
-0.6602491736,
0.8973529935,
-0.6581729054,
-0.2303086668,
0.5098237991,
0.9909660816,
0.3494119048,
0.1943902671,
0.3299588561,
0.213165015,
1.2080621719,
0.178200841,
1.3670653105,
-0.7183973789,
0.0252455212,
0.4778109491,
-0.4639279246,
1.3053582907,
0.4331930578,
0.008267099,
0.4385712445,
0.6437520385,
0.4242254794,
0.6129777431,
0.0858821869,
-0.4002114236,
-0.6815395951,
0.3131000102,
-0.6042230725,
0.3119215667,
0.4294969141,
0.2626858056,
-0.1462680101,
0.3239589632,
-0.1414090097,
0.1694347262,
-0.6929672956,
0.320215106,
0.0082672061,
-0.3049100637,
1.1586284637,
0.0087392284,
0.9543982744,
-0.9342275262,
0.025959203,
-0.3415708542,
0.2248349637,
-0.1730965525,
-0.4838827848,
0.0637903512,
-0.1432641894,
-0.2820308506,
0.0893387645,
0.890376687,
-0.0186482668,
-0.7672008872,
0.5320565701,
0.5508146882,
0.4177094996,
0.2630363107,
-0.6314541101,
0.8132215738,
-0.1562440395,
-0.2896311283,
0.0438430943,
0.3585736752,
0.0376801975,
0.9187242985,
0.8018413782,
0.4024785459,
0.2043996155,
-0.0167995915,
1.2989127636,
-0.5676014423,
-0.6762089729,
-0.5133855939,
0.5065149665,
0.2499880493,
-0.2985763848,
0.8537694216,
0.9450428486,
0.0422199816,
-0.3781195283,
0.6842013001,
0.0269289576,
0.498475343,
-1.0018006563,
0.7720275521,
-0.3906860352,
0.7124001384,
-0.0339636691,
-0.5740101337,
-0.3693433702,
0.2286444753,
-0.1302253604,
0.0078974804,
0.3796152472,
1.0403779745,
-0.1032123864,
-0.1061120629,
0.409694165,
0.1834875196,
0.1226612628,
0.6105692983,
0.7164241076,
-0.7876092792,
0.3631835282,
-0.1879415661,
-0.3233545125,
-0.3868336082,
-1.1749579906,
-0.9143612981,
-0.1989818364,
-0.3566513062,
-0.5927366018,
0.6125015616,
0.4856264889,
1.144508481,
-0.5480738282,
-0.4537410438,
0.0344151035,
-0.0073574288,
-0.46174559,
-0.128410846,
0.4409174025,
-0.287142694,
-0.3861233592,
0.971703887,
0.2821679413,
0.1722491682,
0.1086876392,
-0.5666809678,
-0.024764549,
0.2877137065,
0.4055687487,
0.5541556478,
-0.5039823651,
-0.1383571476,
0.2554653883,
0.0289282706,
0.0170241687,
1.1477236748,
-1.0677031279,
0.3931543827,
0.5487813354,
0.2344724685,
1.1336345673,
0.1582040042,
0.5718400478,
-0.3201600611,
0.6881400943,
0.2183647156,
0.1731146574,
-0.2550133169,
-0.7808436155,
0.1576665491,
0.2920875847,
-0.081863232,
-0.8384776115,
-0.0040309331,
-1.4756799936,
-0.1661022305,
0.8203085661,
0.0334827527,
-0.4591402709,
-0.2397898734,
-0.1876282096,
-0.4067153931,
-0.4441542625,
0.467872709,
0.2402238399,
-0.2242889851,
-0.3262690902,
-0.1453241259,
0.8773373961,
-0.0158097818,
-0.4371314049,
0.4830252826,
0.2474865019,
0.1594505906,
0.1227864176,
0.9394607544,
-0.1149947792,
0.7232515812,
0.743837297,
-0.2132357061,
-0.4888791442,
-0.3619155884,
-0.1981745213,
0.4360391498,
0.1640577763,
-0.0939908624
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02080v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02080v1
|
Translation Errors Significantly Impact Low-Resource Languages in Cross-Lingual Learning
| 2024-02-03T08:22:51 | 2024-02-03T08:22:51 |
Ashish Sunil Agrawal, Barah Fazili, Preethi Jyothi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Popular benchmarks (e.g., XNLI) used to evaluate cross-lingual language
understanding consist of parallel versions of English evaluation sets in
multiple target languages created with the help of professional translators.
When creating such parallel data, it is critical to ensure high-quality
translations for all target languages for an accurate characterization of
cross-lingual transfer. In this work, we find that translation inconsistencies
do exist and interestingly they disproportionally impact low-resource languages
in XNLI. To identify such inconsistencies, we propose measuring the gap in
performance between zero-shot evaluations on the human-translated and
machine-translated target text across multiple target languages; relatively
large gaps are indicative of translation errors. We also corroborate that
translation errors exist for two target languages, namely Hindi and Urdu, by
doing a manual reannotation of human-translated test instances in these two
languages and finding poor agreement with the original English labels these
instances were supposed to inherit.
|
[
-0.0163415261,
-0.2145560682,
0.1928875744,
0.3815006614,
0.1095240414,
0.5692773461,
-0.1397599131,
-0.7182559967,
0.0592069589,
0.0049369363,
-0.4461699724,
-0.0629745945,
-0.8544619679,
0.4037920833,
-0.2761088014,
0.8120049238,
-0.6109779477,
0.1569083929,
0.1453098059,
-0.5885959268,
-0.6289354563,
-0.2642915249,
-0.5533323884,
-0.2373072803,
0.7243369222,
0.7132866979,
0.8248817325,
0.5633886456,
0.3770253062,
0.2151297331,
0.0702655315,
0.169066146,
-0.5667523146,
-0.3470002711,
-0.3582765162,
-0.6549466252,
-0.3256228864,
-0.1451252103,
1.0778386593,
0.9743116498,
0.276250273,
0.2659514248,
0.0880014673,
0.5005533099,
-0.8307260871,
0.0366040245,
-0.3252104223,
0.5192019343,
-0.5420365334,
0.0507015698,
-0.3041959107,
0.0156229325,
-0.0901440531,
-0.6425056458,
0.2181850821,
0.0957903862,
0.8485996127,
0.2504779696,
-0.0942265913,
-0.1776761264,
-0.5397043824,
1.1670502424,
-0.6047059298,
0.7456508875,
0.2264459878,
0.2672609091,
0.1736331433,
-0.0988778397,
-0.5340330601,
0.0784511045,
-0.445032239,
0.0902797654,
-0.0817677379,
-0.3262035549,
0.2470065057,
0.3050041497,
-0.6520301104,
0.2918259203,
-0.3110692203,
-0.1431577653,
0.5794043541,
0.1415603608,
0.5842013955,
-0.2673510611,
-0.2464387864,
-0.4937228858,
-0.7847499847,
0.2499606609,
0.3331901729,
0.4699716866,
-0.4419027567,
0.4268724024,
-0.0741411448,
0.6777706146,
-0.1602640599,
-0.2435450256,
0.4586954117,
-0.8712862134,
-0.0670984015,
0.4267444611,
0.6488140821,
0.2253399491,
0.1627797633,
-0.2404302955,
-0.1834613979,
-0.0767639205,
-0.2536387742,
-0.3865946531,
0.2129591405,
-0.1575740874,
-0.1387661994,
-0.1277981102,
-0.1721830666,
-0.8259988427,
-0.2544917464,
0.059698198,
0.2753237784,
-0.1736424565,
-0.2386973202,
-0.0768635273,
0.0796450078,
0.2296566665,
0.1425177604,
-0.7288115025,
0.0430090912,
0.3588202894,
0.7915225625,
-0.1587958932,
-0.7837814093,
-0.4771621525,
0.1933678091,
-0.6041665077,
0.6046336293,
-0.3190291226,
-0.4053252339,
-0.0112722274,
-0.0276547074,
-0.3734736741,
-0.583558619,
0.5270389915,
-0.1426727623,
0.0771277696,
-0.4974226952,
-0.217563957,
-0.1211363673,
0.2376120239,
-0.543610692,
0.7281161547,
0.4033019841,
-0.6939943433,
0.4692472517,
-0.387722671,
-0.5610126257,
-0.1532576382,
-0.2717936933,
-0.2907180488,
0.3591359258,
0.0679348558,
0.0570550486,
-0.3781221211,
-0.1908560842,
0.1146969497,
-0.5114337802,
0.22099334,
-0.4766561091,
0.847132504,
-0.0610588752,
-0.6191138029,
-0.1576689929,
-0.7089108825,
0.353274554,
0.1652957648,
-0.3478102386,
-0.3224258721,
-0.2543809712,
0.2455020547,
0.3815595806,
0.1490889788,
-0.5672545433,
-0.1615837067,
-0.3606875241,
-0.0943837166,
0.5118805766,
-0.3910406828,
0.2835660875,
-0.2974381149,
0.5005326867,
0.3439044952,
0.0615424365,
-0.0222664047,
-0.4611518681,
-0.739707768,
0.330996871,
0.3875567317,
0.7411416769,
-0.8782314658,
-0.1692360491,
-0.5039442778,
-0.4055303633,
-0.6065269709,
0.6711335182,
0.9821916223,
0.4061473012,
0.4020840824,
-0.3176462948,
-0.4530093968,
-0.8129777312,
-0.5641566515,
-0.2586784363,
0.2930254042,
0.1772875637,
0.1088474244,
-0.3105528653,
0.5838657022,
-0.1389992237,
-0.3846772313,
-0.3926897347,
0.4026880562,
-0.1249300092,
0.5505496264,
0.6675744653,
-0.606895566,
-0.99009794,
0.5043880939,
-0.6077722311,
-0.2771139443,
-0.3778884411,
-0.0728318766,
0.3969689012,
0.249524653,
-0.2683795989,
0.3891629875,
0.7949307561,
-0.1577017009,
0.5146191716,
-0.0311129726,
0.4541707337,
-0.659334898,
-0.0451884158,
0.1043586582,
-0.0822890997,
-0.4031373858,
-0.15118213,
0.1302987039,
0.2368257195,
-0.6747996807,
0.6645625234,
-0.3623081148,
-0.2065100223,
0.0528330319,
0.4146959782,
0.1205575764,
0.2715107799,
-0.1013187096,
0.9340912104,
0.2070826739,
0.0915084407,
-0.0053759585,
0.2861452401,
-0.3026786149,
0.657550633,
-0.4262670875,
-0.1796576679,
0.1384507567,
-0.1372545511,
-0.9529617429,
-0.2984697223,
0.5388157964,
-0.4599632621,
0.6537585855,
0.0466165766,
-0.5025787354,
0.2138521671,
-0.0716066286,
0.8694840074,
0.2825102508,
-0.3913069963,
0.1012519822,
0.0915763751,
0.1151534393,
-0.9605893493,
-0.9336811304,
0.1548051685,
0.2194457054,
-0.4692816734,
0.0312962346,
0.3326150477,
-0.3182469904,
0.2147578448,
-0.2059884518,
-0.2262682915,
-0.1125444323,
-0.0049605193,
0.0735524744,
-0.3443467617,
-0.1057711542,
0.0777544528,
-0.0715208724,
0.0102169411,
0.1059017405,
-0.0210598875,
-0.0801932737,
-0.6470947266,
-0.3374803364,
0.5265274644,
0.6538077593,
-0.0348028019,
0.548713088,
0.6372631192,
-0.3209675252,
-0.133458361,
-0.4729902744,
0.2414751947,
-0.3430867791,
0.5933848619,
-0.4892242253,
-0.4310359657,
0.525565207,
0.2317758799,
-0.1163663566,
0.4818075895,
0.1462778151,
-0.0215772334,
1.0719876289,
0.5704447627,
-0.1484033763,
0.2720115483,
-0.1815793961,
0.3834672868,
-0.6277068853,
0.1298630685,
-0.5336620212,
-0.3834228814,
-0.6492628455,
-0.4932311475,
0.2171216905,
0.2828366458,
0.1111354604,
0.5326359272,
-0.0231551435,
0.5052390695,
0.2967305481,
-0.3120259643,
0.3782367706,
0.1564670056,
-0.1693117917,
-0.4057358205,
-0.9451221228,
-0.1941759884,
0.705070436,
0.163714081,
0.6821041107,
0.2489613146,
0.6345928907,
0.177611798,
0.3815982044,
-0.5393382907,
0.148425132,
-0.4455578029,
-0.4906915128,
-0.3094394803,
-0.6691284776,
-0.8700435162,
0.2065836638,
-0.0463799275,
-0.5487434864,
0.4778314531,
-0.040571671,
-0.349088788,
0.5200455785,
-0.8389383554,
1.2941527367,
-0.651879251,
-0.5659871697,
-0.319452852,
-0.5081338286,
0.3929303885,
-0.4411657751,
0.2331290841,
-0.1906091273,
-0.0133770183,
0.6146287918,
-0.2185455412,
0.7440894246,
-0.0284673311,
-0.091146864,
0.1960857511,
0.1311233938,
0.3137424588,
-0.2024830878,
-0.0319684893,
0.5948116779,
0.1830897033,
-0.773676753,
-0.6510928273,
0.5674898028,
-1.0107984543,
-0.4316856563,
-0.604516685,
-0.656870544,
-0.2529403865,
0.0764017329,
0.3429833353,
0.0487503931,
-0.0821747854,
-0.2114783078,
0.354000479,
-0.3461458683,
0.2498260289,
0.5801820159,
-0.0824462771,
-0.1940357983,
1.2145432234,
0.5099343061,
0.4813911915,
0.2985405922,
-0.0333192907,
-0.271825254,
-0.475481987,
-0.8969183564,
0.4234102666,
-0.7983499765,
-0.114310734,
-0.1256356984,
-0.110204272,
-0.2352646738,
-0.3317789733,
-0.6135594845,
-0.1676998734,
-0.058598198,
0.1663725972,
-0.0915407762,
0.7149892449,
-0.3544567525,
0.2994357049,
-1.2315605879,
-0.0248564817,
0.047218211,
0.2009091675,
0.0040957672,
-0.6244783401,
-0.8106066585,
0.184055075,
-0.0012357984,
-0.7987242341,
0.2243383825,
0.2853487432,
0.5782335401,
0.0690061972,
-0.1078839526,
0.9707788229,
-0.493509829,
0.4417809546,
0.4232180417,
-1.0966377258,
0.3444318175,
-0.0190733895,
0.4531532228,
0.635094583,
0.4253722727,
-1.0001171827,
-0.2012869865,
-0.2865591645,
-0.620868504,
0.7533764839,
0.122057274,
-0.1804008186,
0.0252855234,
0.1752317697,
0.1011578515,
-0.1507509202,
-0.5671026707,
-0.248405382,
0.0601226352,
-0.0608614609,
-0.2422068715,
-0.2398722768,
0.0005329361,
-0.1479250938,
0.5596871972,
-0.1240184456,
-0.3200806379,
0.198472023,
-0.532720089,
-0.6705491543,
0.3203543127,
0.6348169446,
0.8759317994,
-0.034938477,
-0.0103434455,
0.5275755525,
-0.39931494,
0.516468823,
-0.1111750603,
-0.1246905401,
0.3428794742,
0.4833707809,
0.5943392515,
0.6909465194,
-0.9025296569,
0.4768283069,
0.020147549,
0.4147059023,
-0.1694862396,
-0.1880037785,
-0.2184783816,
0.0075171487,
0.1474794745,
0.3345200717,
-0.2102212906,
-0.4700223505,
0.1757546514,
0.0472813509,
-0.512250185,
-0.5211935639,
0.3577403128,
0.2672809958,
-0.1506464332,
0.4776060581,
-0.4665871263,
-0.5713307261,
0.3341161609,
0.2259933054,
0.887652874,
-0.4063403606,
0.2842620611,
0.4077678621,
0.5434108377,
-0.061614424,
-0.0820259452,
-0.0505193099,
-0.768535316,
-0.8818910718,
-0.3738360107,
-0.557669878,
-0.3825449347,
-0.6126232743,
0.3025013804,
-0.2339459062,
0.1393364519,
-0.0548203401,
-0.1321835369,
-0.6418596506,
0.0527783036,
0.3256624639,
0.7375602126,
-1.2387664318,
0.895878315,
0.6183740497,
-0.5530498028,
-0.8035010695,
0.019715352,
0.0812164173,
-0.7732973695,
1.2874816656,
-0.1152019277,
-0.3099034727,
-0.2346869111,
0.2947666645,
-0.9432586432,
0.5788949728,
0.3272592127,
-0.7402048111,
0.056639038,
0.8607983589,
0.595344007,
-0.1002959982,
0.2747854292,
0.6057008505,
0.5917664766,
-0.1877717674,
-1.3301175833,
0.0821546912,
-0.0480670035,
-0.0680013523,
0.2703378201,
-0.6681727767,
0.8920456171,
-0.0769353285,
-0.4669593275,
-0.0691183507,
0.3160624802,
0.0022147978,
0.4274809062,
0.4487141967,
0.7149747014,
0.4122918546,
-0.1814765185,
1.0357141495,
-0.2115000188,
0.2756001353,
1.2246807814,
-0.4629391432,
0.942263484,
0.6198624969,
-0.3481736779,
0.240892455,
0.5791723132,
0.0690081716,
0.234708637,
0.1281053275,
-0.2613773644,
-0.1177806333,
-0.3068630099,
-0.3314689994,
0.4119527638,
0.3983771205,
-0.1362918317,
-0.6136133671,
0.0253151841,
0.0422756597,
0.0443237685,
-0.1360851526,
0.3329486251,
-0.0294965263,
-0.7412859797,
0.8984577656,
-0.0488924012,
0.6620131731,
-0.3723741174,
-0.1431068927,
-0.429554373,
0.4305447936,
-0.4175597727,
-0.7499738336,
0.6919400096,
0.070207566,
-0.2337320298,
-0.1915348023,
0.3734300435,
-0.4823923409,
-0.6358275414,
0.679012537,
0.8381397724,
0.2689823508,
0.2348358482,
-0.8783473969,
0.427606076,
0.2131193578,
0.1645295769,
0.5022456646,
0.3288684785,
-0.2648312449,
0.1957001239,
0.2924656272,
0.1958177686,
0.3936688304,
-0.1458670795,
0.3240894377,
-0.4842744172,
-0.066774942,
-0.5792449713,
0.3984321356,
-0.029463144,
-0.5514631271,
0.983491838,
0.4987981021,
1.5390853882,
-0.0152185839,
0.7485732436,
-0.0104358634,
0.5198444128,
-0.101844579,
0.7038707137,
-0.7992126346,
0.2242643088,
-0.1430503577,
-0.8850547671,
-0.298297286,
0.4635502994,
-0.3564524055,
-0.2239792943,
0.8093265891,
0.7053468823,
-0.0464901254,
-0.3581840992,
0.6633687615,
0.173382774,
0.0471699908,
0.7693490982,
0.6547235847,
-0.9868191481,
0.8665227294,
-0.5112968683,
-0.1258594245,
-0.1759842038,
-0.442260772,
-0.5232989192,
-0.3398588598,
-0.7301407456,
-0.3391527236,
0.2711743414,
0.7292892337,
0.4820699394,
-1.1488171816,
-0.6547105908,
0.0271155648,
0.560983479,
-0.4381792843,
-0.2100580633,
0.3269708157,
-0.6243153214,
-1.0876721144,
0.5125263929,
0.335372597,
0.0783005953,
-0.4340483248,
-0.2907772362,
-0.2548250258,
-0.2082910538,
0.3985646367,
0.8117311597,
-0.8109084368,
-0.3332494199,
-0.0589792132,
-0.3962231576,
0.2100035846,
0.668910265,
-0.506647408,
0.5888108611,
0.6157904267,
0.9379913807,
0.2050538659,
-0.4665497839,
0.5036469102,
-0.9408817887,
0.2464850396,
-0.1046964303,
0.3520576954,
0.5338801742,
-0.3230900168,
0.6899822354,
0.5079299808,
-0.1988289952,
-1.0252896547,
0.0694498345,
-0.6583067775,
-0.0301524159,
0.793851018,
-0.5084110498,
-0.4557696283,
-0.1449182779,
0.0810376853,
0.2429201305,
0.1911910325,
0.6559437513,
0.8830112219,
-0.1398199946,
-0.2684953511,
-0.6568914056,
0.4552652538,
0.9061917067,
-0.4846303165,
-0.1480083317,
0.1705842018,
0.1669067442,
0.677339375,
0.0790050849,
-0.1448126137,
0.5984071493,
0.4377581775,
-0.020532988,
0.359832108,
0.0138715971,
-0.196417287,
-0.1615904421,
0.0599802546,
-0.3245739639
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02078v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02078v1
|
Exploring the Robustness of Task-oriented Dialogue Systems for Colloquial German Varieties
| 2024-02-03T08:16:43 | 2024-02-03T08:16:43 |
Ekaterina Artemova, Verena Blaschke, Barbara Plank
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Mainstream cross-lingual task-oriented dialogue (ToD) systems leverage the
transfer learning paradigm by training a joint model for intent recognition and
slot-filling in English and applying it, zero-shot, to other languages. We
address a gap in prior research, which often overlooked the transfer to
lower-resource colloquial varieties due to limited test data. Inspired by prior
work on English varieties, we craft and manually evaluate perturbation rules
that transform German sentences into colloquial forms and use them to
synthesize test sets in four ToD datasets. Our perturbation rules cover 18
distinct language phenomena, enabling us to explore the impact of each
perturbation on slot and intent performance. Using these new datasets, we
conduct an experimental evaluation across six different transformers. Here, we
demonstrate that when applied to colloquial varieties, ToD systems maintain
their intent recognition performance, losing 6% (4.62 percentage points) in
accuracy on average. However, they exhibit a significant drop in slot
detection, with a decrease of 31% (21 percentage points) in slot F1 score. Our
findings are further supported by a transfer experiment from Standard American
English to synthetic Urban African American Vernacular English.
|
[
-0.2837776542,
-0.899235189,
0.6840226054,
0.1343180239,
-0.115491204,
-0.0634716675,
-0.1991087347,
-0.2251479924,
-0.0753648281,
0.4487090409,
-0.3435014188,
-0.5192055702,
-0.7077998519,
0.1446965337,
-0.4956151545,
1.0034251213,
-0.2015744299,
-0.1933261752,
-0.1957978606,
-0.1049641445,
-0.4836390018,
-0.4188852608,
-0.6926856637,
-0.2339271158,
0.4234522283,
0.4833749533,
0.5695847869,
0.1587157845,
0.3049851358,
0.2592038214,
0.121373564,
-0.1526993513,
-0.6313706636,
0.4373485446,
-0.0950812772,
-0.4538069665,
-0.2277061641,
-0.0507771894,
0.5224211812,
0.8180653453,
0.0472314619,
-0.270381093,
0.1153424829,
0.120550096,
-0.657779038,
0.3779503405,
-0.7526580691,
0.056835521,
-0.3112959266,
-0.255212456,
-0.7539311647,
0.0344028249,
0.2798523009,
-0.5800488591,
0.0245207921,
-0.131711334,
0.8475648761,
0.150933668,
-0.4357608557,
-0.0415612757,
-0.9492282271,
0.8761106133,
-0.4744963944,
0.5087653399,
0.2136161029,
0.1851706058,
-0.312368989,
-0.4165234268,
-0.5473655462,
-0.2472177446,
-0.2251463681,
0.0727096871,
-0.3184041083,
0.1013830304,
0.3129010797,
0.0905294195,
-0.6520841122,
0.1241172627,
-0.0474942476,
-0.2196290046,
0.5131602287,
0.14669469,
0.2138603181,
0.0158019289,
-0.3815089464,
-0.3238239884,
-0.5862953067,
0.458599329,
0.2473319024,
0.3201289475,
-0.1147214174,
0.4729881883,
-0.103838481,
0.907083869,
0.3377469182,
-0.3435982764,
0.0747260079,
-0.4076161981,
-0.2773765028,
-0.1513239145,
0.854531467,
0.0872951001,
0.0248404592,
-0.4227785468,
-0.2046142519,
-0.1802428961,
0.3444275856,
-0.3374994099,
0.0467516705,
0.0025327629,
-0.0273563154,
-0.0310608055,
-0.0173568223,
-0.1251309961,
0.0758605376,
-0.0833493024,
0.4337027967,
-0.6851876974,
0.1250001192,
0.2413190752,
-0.2069241852,
0.17407538,
0.6136910915,
-0.7243899703,
0.0635917485,
0.550721705,
0.5359031558,
-0.5613927245,
-0.4258514941,
-0.4982830584,
0.4042117,
-0.190840438,
0.9510305524,
-0.4889975488,
-0.6413249373,
0.0897106677,
0.073781915,
-0.4718900323,
-0.3165394366,
0.642560482,
-0.3344638944,
0.5073817968,
0.1763097495,
-0.1865392923,
-0.1489176899,
0.3063514531,
-0.3409899473,
0.8359785676,
0.3183399141,
-0.4725016356,
0.342249155,
-0.7203344703,
-0.8676720858,
0.0235581975,
-0.1571320146,
-0.0580042377,
0.2043479532,
-0.0779869705,
0.3429640532,
0.0658030957,
0.2173203081,
-0.2247736752,
-0.4505496323,
0.253649801,
-0.7286399603,
0.7442981601,
-0.0231846534,
-0.4446003437,
-0.037668094,
-0.6142825484,
-0.0644318238,
-0.1515842527,
-0.2485029697,
-0.5800418258,
-0.2725712657,
-0.0627107993,
0.2472857237,
0.00359904,
-0.5634459257,
0.1578141004,
-0.2092095315,
0.1313527375,
0.5778363347,
-0.2142440826,
0.5545685291,
-0.4340561032,
0.658213973,
0.1735923886,
0.1861700118,
-0.1408015788,
-0.5564566255,
-0.8156047463,
-0.2089361697,
0.2601761818,
0.6915381551,
-0.9030358195,
0.6801832914,
-0.2893347442,
-0.4118369222,
-0.1195281819,
-0.2357430458,
0.2963682413,
0.6578156948,
-0.0083899889,
-0.6806489825,
-0.2168508023,
-0.8992046118,
-0.1884844154,
-0.3175995648,
-0.0105902329,
0.4549591839,
0.0581126586,
0.051091563,
0.914423883,
-0.2354500294,
-0.2217173874,
-0.2990740538,
0.2015311122,
0.1113228723,
0.3631704152,
0.5148658752,
-0.4545853436,
-0.8646512032,
0.1696375012,
-0.5410819054,
-0.1304986328,
-0.1625151038,
-0.0464749858,
0.4900225997,
0.34396258,
-0.6804437637,
0.6262387633,
0.667624414,
-0.5263491869,
0.5475434661,
0.1637953371,
0.2181406617,
-0.900079906,
0.1169974282,
-0.086071901,
-0.426875025,
-0.7398256063,
-0.3386860192,
-0.4481006563,
-0.0773403868,
-0.6887115836,
0.6093398929,
-0.1050418466,
-0.1388711035,
-0.1019669846,
0.0503767207,
0.0333379358,
0.513204515,
0.0797529146,
0.9527417421,
0.5606759787,
-0.6656163335,
-0.2019989341,
0.5431957245,
-0.3070971072,
0.7081865072,
-0.4038424194,
0.239153415,
-0.1210052669,
0.3571429551,
-1.1227900982,
-0.0977542996,
0.2291493267,
-0.2758654952,
0.36181283,
-0.2742806375,
-0.1207177415,
-0.006170935,
0.086670123,
0.2999034822,
0.469517678,
-0.0481294505,
0.6362201571,
0.3617094159,
-0.4166698456,
-0.5834353566,
-0.4633553922,
-0.0564495511,
-0.0701370537,
-0.595004797,
0.3790647686,
0.179493621,
-0.1670196205,
-0.0616836846,
-0.215323478,
-0.1245738789,
0.2142312229,
0.2220965475,
0.3256648183,
0.075719431,
-0.0230997428,
0.2142606378,
0.036372181,
-0.1623054892,
-0.2712365687,
0.8231220245,
0.194899261,
-0.4834412336,
-0.6071415544,
0.386701256,
0.8616468906,
0.1309984773,
0.3719309568,
0.6719052792,
0.1646431386,
-0.1734227836,
-0.3618200421,
-0.137956962,
-0.4535185099,
0.2540867627,
-0.7307106256,
-1.1408772469,
0.3358765841,
0.1457496285,
0.1544773281,
0.2909857035,
0.4022915363,
-0.2508508265,
0.8013640046,
0.7302461267,
0.1423454881,
0.810256362,
-0.0928573459,
0.4883569181,
-0.6132202148,
0.0127545577,
-0.6294947267,
-0.3165636957,
-0.4913158417,
-0.4400435686,
0.7138335705,
-0.1104859561,
-0.059706971,
0.6640647054,
-0.0948745757,
0.1090081558,
0.5491330624,
-0.2486092001,
0.4487858117,
0.3392541409,
-0.2411424965,
-0.0092156986,
-0.8873755336,
-0.5250360966,
1.0533568859,
0.2792891562,
0.7158335447,
0.0266074147,
0.7850930095,
0.443852067,
0.1235573515,
-0.9622522593,
0.65026474,
-0.4894547462,
-0.3561168313,
-0.6280001402,
-0.2517877221,
-1.1511324644,
-0.0565557666,
0.0016453947,
-0.9028205276,
0.3327209651,
-0.0618091449,
-0.2770293355,
0.1519439816,
-0.8020192981,
0.8048191667,
-0.1197055206,
-0.2283053249,
-0.196126774,
-0.2900288105,
0.102951549,
0.0327813625,
-0.0421851538,
-0.177895382,
0.2222846299,
0.3978030682,
-0.0478542782,
0.8571514487,
-0.1558003277,
-0.4789182842,
0.1922832876,
0.2885299623,
0.697961092,
-0.057286907,
0.0051776706,
0.3291032612,
-0.1447278857,
-0.4593033195,
-0.8614089489,
0.6307207346,
-0.5260915756,
-0.9369285703,
-0.1896576434,
-1.0144540071,
-0.603453815,
0.1890274882,
0.1408475488,
0.2894018888,
-0.3434956372,
0.0433172025,
0.5444713235,
0.1069296226,
0.5310216546,
0.6835737228,
-0.0953330994,
-0.0545948744,
0.6447363496,
-0.0023117452,
0.4986047745,
0.3462048769,
-0.1800069511,
-0.3420011103,
-0.6887690425,
-0.5744662285,
-0.0058025056,
-0.3835286796,
0.1106940806,
-0.6599208117,
-0.1336080283,
-0.603826046,
-0.2353884429,
-0.1376180947,
-0.6646001935,
-0.0333854593,
0.2213957608,
-0.0035469923,
0.6329945922,
0.1624656022,
0.2495616078,
-0.9306074381,
-0.168377474,
0.3658235371,
0.3837234676,
-0.407060951,
-0.7288960218,
0.0426194333,
-0.1004480347,
-0.4280380607,
-0.5980526209,
0.1877515316,
0.0674315989,
0.6670723557,
0.4616058469,
0.1887402683,
0.5342583656,
-0.4220718741,
0.7525040507,
0.2986862361,
-0.8936469555,
0.3555699885,
-0.4789714217,
0.4444156289,
0.68525666,
0.5781505704,
-0.5311264992,
-0.7685018778,
-0.7156378031,
-0.5529657602,
0.9359349608,
0.1781955659,
0.2911162078,
0.1166059077,
-0.0512867682,
0.4729340672,
0.1592472643,
-0.5834870338,
-0.2731482089,
0.0421610773,
-0.2450054288,
-0.1670373827,
0.0893207788,
-0.3004243374,
-0.1235537007,
0.572494328,
-0.1824129224,
0.2969196141,
0.3551376164,
-0.1350857764,
-0.0256124679,
0.7146545649,
0.6468214393,
0.3494213223,
-0.0805024579,
-0.1001951993,
-0.1087946072,
-0.4928679168,
0.4171468019,
0.3094722331,
-0.7729619741,
0.34977597,
0.0244446658,
1.1659460068,
0.1953756958,
-0.7172501683,
0.3715480268,
0.0443011373,
-0.2183619291,
-0.119489938,
0.2082621753,
-0.5673809648,
0.0983615667,
0.2888402641,
0.2751562297,
0.2353150249,
-0.8533861637,
0.1226207092,
0.6449356675,
-0.7131279707,
-0.4669926763,
0.0903163925,
0.3692795038,
-0.4980620742,
0.1595591009,
-0.4775504172,
-0.4984447658,
0.1454197019,
0.658341527,
0.848264873,
-0.029191805,
0.5644862056,
0.098666288,
0.1116095185,
0.2033689618,
0.1492814571,
-0.3431988358,
-0.8394811749,
-0.7154104114,
-0.5064780712,
-0.4316738844,
0.2430957407,
-0.3505516648,
0.227362752,
-0.191358313,
-0.3451454043,
-0.1492741853,
-0.4002921581,
-0.6060471535,
-0.1065169275,
0.0646206141,
0.7440261841,
-0.8610790372,
0.7933623195,
1.1081101894,
-0.0002158516,
-0.7975094318,
0.2343543768,
-0.2875954211,
-0.7568598986,
0.6284155846,
-0.1080008373,
-0.0529891439,
0.0753462091,
-0.1514817476,
-0.9590739012,
0.7902910709,
0.383861959,
-0.5393287539,
-0.265802294,
0.3153914511,
0.4305242002,
-0.3280740678,
0.3740440607,
0.6355278492,
0.5110782385,
0.1895965636,
-1.4502602816,
-0.0924654976,
0.1067257375,
-0.1281543672,
0.3613749743,
-0.5245117545,
0.6726099849,
0.0704152361,
-0.4997635782,
-0.0476098321,
0.1869008988,
0.0458818637,
0.3218818605,
0.796469748,
0.8032673597,
0.3159376681,
-0.3396144211,
0.972222209,
-0.255727917,
0.0522615016,
0.9593319297,
-0.6270118952,
0.709669888,
0.7580884695,
-0.2681562304,
0.8853233457,
-0.0547374934,
0.2725404799,
0.4505620599,
-0.1688183993,
-0.3938763142,
-0.2589381933,
-0.435526669,
0.129307732,
0.9363200665,
0.3711503148,
-0.1285565794,
-0.3399634063,
0.2291203588,
-0.0731164292,
-0.038066145,
-0.1316368729,
0.9142668247,
-0.1688641757,
-1.1987318993,
0.7479864359,
-0.3570398986,
0.6925501823,
-0.6346441507,
0.0226948,
-0.1748597026,
-0.1015022695,
-0.0668040141,
-0.8124684691,
0.3277799785,
-0.2025749385,
-0.1117947251,
-0.4460262656,
0.8034327626,
-0.5026873946,
-0.1424000859,
0.1359341145,
0.7844967246,
0.2161727995,
0.234190315,
-0.3986273408,
-0.0368472748,
0.2657660246,
0.1645880938,
0.5658915043,
0.3867827356,
-0.2108153105,
0.5134677887,
0.5759580731,
0.0484919026,
0.1129076108,
0.0570813827,
0.6202044487,
-0.3806840479,
-0.3405417204,
-0.2194491625,
0.64146626,
-0.0295221508,
-0.3375433981,
0.886092782,
0.3617066443,
1.2913665771,
-0.2281397432,
1.0544565916,
-0.3268247843,
0.3143838942,
-0.3907131851,
0.4194780588,
-0.3094805479,
0.1102886572,
0.0057852734,
-0.8250849843,
-0.0526131466,
0.3671924472,
-0.5042361617,
-0.1694991887,
0.7625290155,
0.5700567365,
-0.1039186567,
-0.1726203561,
0.8098592758,
0.1588824838,
0.2044970542,
0.5875540972,
0.8256753683,
-0.4812694192,
0.8367776871,
-0.3734328747,
-0.1596259177,
-0.2362824082,
-0.524423182,
-0.695043385,
-0.6150837541,
-0.3752556443,
-0.3607465029,
0.2100436836,
0.392198503,
0.786411643,
-0.9047499299,
-0.4054647386,
-0.2448907793,
0.2055721134,
-0.268422842,
-0.360491395,
0.0483950302,
-0.8471406102,
-1.0564213991,
0.603268981,
0.5687181354,
0.2173781842,
-0.2286196947,
-0.004762833,
-0.0556541644,
-0.0816165283,
0.7842273712,
0.4231742322,
-0.7001079917,
-0.4298577905,
0.2002286464,
-0.163498044,
0.0908918977,
1.0523760319,
-0.7952929139,
0.3262631297,
0.439779073,
0.5041431189,
0.261952877,
-0.1554088593,
0.8404171467,
-0.7640179396,
0.3142681122,
0.4065432549,
0.4026109874,
0.0688702688,
-0.23917,
0.3681861162,
0.3252964914,
-0.4398864508,
-0.6960014701,
0.429261744,
-1.2063885927,
-0.0270741954,
1.166541934,
-0.4384317994,
-0.2518897057,
-0.6388210058,
-0.1893754452,
0.0651735589,
-0.623031199,
0.8632504344,
0.8125994802,
-0.4107222259,
-0.0458283685,
-0.0438047983,
0.5310904384,
0.8054301143,
-0.6960198879,
-0.0781732127,
0.5114216208,
0.2009866685,
0.5023195744,
0.6227817535,
-0.1365721077,
0.5076562166,
-0.2017127573,
-0.0799747929,
0.0452692546,
-0.3330952525,
-0.3694795966,
0.2893129885,
0.1343469471,
-0.1155462414
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02077v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02077v1
|
Investigating Content Planning for Navigating Trade-offs in Knowledge-Grounded Dialogue
| 2024-02-03T08:16:39 | 2024-02-03T08:16:39 |
Kushal Chawla, Hannah Rashkin, Gaurav Singh Tomar, David Reitter
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Knowledge-grounded dialogue generation is a challenging task because it
requires satisfying two fundamental yet often competing constraints: being
responsive in a manner that is specific to what the conversation partner has
said while also being attributable to an underlying source document. In this
work, we bring this trade-off between these two objectives (specificity and
attribution) to light and ask the question: Can explicit content planning
before the response generation help the model to address this challenge? To
answer this question, we design a framework called PLEDGE, which allows us to
experiment with various plan variables explored in prior work, supporting both
metric-agnostic and metric-aware approaches. While content planning shows
promise, our results on whether it can actually help to navigate this trade-off
are mixed -- planning mechanisms that are metric-aware (use automatic metrics
during training) are better at automatic evaluations but underperform in human
judgment compared to metric-agnostic mechanisms. We discuss how this may be
caused by over-fitting to automatic metrics and the need for future work to
better calibrate these metrics towards human judgment. We hope the observations
from our analysis will inform future work that aims to apply content planning
in this context.
|
[
-0.631716907,
-0.100033693,
0.8118651509,
-0.1097314805,
-0.2663417459,
0.270460248,
-0.0446517617,
-0.1303322464,
0.1656542867,
0.4793278277,
-0.8743739724,
-0.308006376,
-0.4758398831,
-0.1959769279,
-0.1898289621,
1.0619702339,
-0.0602968968,
-0.1351275295,
-0.3693762124,
-0.1870506257,
-0.8755990863,
-0.1612787247,
-0.7181014419,
-0.2898739874,
0.4886374772,
0.866615355,
0.7405115962,
0.5733318329,
0.2407474965,
0.1732625365,
-0.207864061,
-0.0472166985,
-0.66819942,
-0.0260355398,
-0.3647668958,
-0.5641646981,
-0.4558869898,
0.2034098953,
0.4272251129,
0.6232435107,
0.0824000016,
0.3671681881,
0.0275078397,
0.5960719585,
-0.9114207029,
0.1851011813,
-0.7339275479,
0.2839456201,
0.4500772357,
-0.2757345438,
-0.116482228,
-0.0000651318,
0.3287679553,
-0.8680749536,
0.3878757954,
-0.0024983578,
0.4922740757,
0.3527044654,
-0.4258645177,
-0.5145114064,
-0.7018821836,
0.8272967339,
-0.6553863287,
0.3826453984,
0.4706178308,
0.1466714591,
-0.2001456767,
-0.6849585176,
-0.6148579717,
0.2081046551,
-0.0702260956,
0.4770168066,
0.2216334492,
0.1353799254,
0.3328237534,
0.417824775,
-0.2400643229,
-0.182083264,
-0.2053469121,
-0.3573821485,
0.5662589073,
0.2643651962,
-0.1639796942,
-0.3479175866,
-0.1903353184,
-0.0434606895,
-0.735050559,
0.4895960689,
0.4088155627,
0.2419338226,
-0.0202041529,
0.8203735948,
-0.4733335674,
0.6044955254,
0.2038458586,
-0.0631631017,
-0.5013411641,
-0.7937344313,
0.1332064718,
0.2317593396,
0.4779331684,
0.6096341014,
0.3005595207,
0.2399545461,
-0.1478458345,
0.2209389657,
0.6871420741,
-0.8130178452,
-0.2221662849,
0.3402605057,
-0.3206655383,
-0.2670747638,
-0.2279497683,
-0.4859375954,
-0.2211613804,
-0.5288900733,
-0.015775403,
-0.3182465434,
-0.401750505,
0.3256975114,
-0.2624477446,
0.1833488196,
0.264755547,
-0.7623580098,
0.38196069,
0.7141342163,
0.6705519557,
-0.0742763206,
0.1715414226,
-0.6314302683,
0.4632113576,
-0.2907665074,
0.6023620367,
-0.3888623416,
-0.799236834,
0.1603519619,
-0.545085609,
0.2249442488,
-0.0821654424,
0.9579827189,
-0.2301352769,
0.4487706125,
-0.695073247,
-0.5838811398,
0.0046351999,
0.5659828186,
-0.7817546129,
0.5053564906,
0.3299525082,
-0.9084786773,
0.903172493,
-0.441023916,
-0.4281855822,
-0.2570211589,
-0.379046768,
-0.225590378,
0.1497166306,
0.0803097188,
0.1179942861,
-0.3025851548,
0.4299356341,
0.1208441556,
-0.3002543449,
0.2694487572,
-0.165626809,
0.1260363013,
0.2325155735,
-0.4844878018,
0.1471673101,
-0.6860471368,
0.3125795424,
-0.1200762987,
-0.3590193391,
-0.0674076155,
0.3621327281,
-0.4010384381,
0.5161365271,
0.0110040875,
-0.5571576953,
0.0676926598,
-0.3794952631,
0.3268819451,
0.6184244752,
0.0524104759,
0.8227116466,
-0.5739754438,
0.7141062617,
-0.1409037113,
0.1626372784,
-0.2106749713,
-0.5497710705,
-0.818131566,
-0.0486019775,
-0.1063358858,
0.1816039234,
-0.6304570436,
0.2833111286,
-0.3357868791,
-0.3856818974,
-0.3842698336,
-0.1945508868,
0.7313787341,
0.5789034963,
0.2553817332,
-0.7451994419,
-0.334708482,
-0.6591350436,
-0.6014809012,
-0.7648217678,
-0.0181570537,
0.3027327359,
0.1547396481,
0.5812624693,
1.525619626,
-0.857026875,
-0.4020455182,
-0.5223224759,
0.2430440933,
0.035959892,
0.4352234304,
0.3127593696,
-1.0112015009,
-0.5468860865,
-0.278601855,
-0.1149159819,
-0.1184133217,
-0.4810740054,
-0.094797194,
-0.2369191349,
0.2130518556,
-0.735573113,
0.6682462096,
0.4981429577,
-0.5650072098,
0.752958715,
0.3687394261,
0.2479992956,
-1.1091017723,
0.0248942245,
-0.4494983852,
-0.1946820319,
-0.5615701079,
-0.24060224,
-0.1838898957,
-0.170104593,
-0.4136663377,
0.6454581022,
-0.2141340673,
-0.2007790804,
-0.1809432209,
0.0037842065,
0.4456287622,
0.5452896953,
0.4829277992,
0.8026025295,
0.0010454009,
-0.7653148174,
-0.241852358,
0.9337300658,
-0.4173717797,
0.8639259934,
-0.5872299075,
0.0504545197,
0.1525024027,
0.5316951871,
-1.0310271978,
0.0643748045,
0.4127627909,
-0.7731172442,
0.2317419052,
-0.4083723724,
-0.1738654524,
-0.274564743,
-0.221449092,
0.6513306499,
0.2335876077,
-0.0121891228,
0.6195283532,
0.2410100847,
-0.3792702258,
-0.341429919,
-0.4974939525,
-0.2214091122,
-0.2735616267,
-0.6756503582,
0.5552119017,
-0.1909245551,
-0.2028251588,
-0.1128366441,
-0.4657435417,
-0.0161839426,
-0.0973936394,
0.3629688025,
-0.1434222311,
-0.1278072894,
-0.1677477658,
0.0601406805,
-0.3430052698,
0.2524594367,
-0.4892726541,
0.6260250807,
0.0418625772,
-0.6964589953,
-0.3953046799,
0.4333379865,
0.3945996463,
-0.3569453657,
0.4049156308,
0.3678896427,
0.193990469,
0.2696973383,
-0.5783255696,
-0.199212864,
-0.4998674989,
0.0154930921,
-0.3458729088,
-0.739895165,
0.6560875177,
-0.1760378927,
0.4847274125,
0.1197454259,
0.1738938391,
0.1017756015,
1.0431537628,
0.4867522418,
0.2981286049,
0.4736103714,
-0.3056333959,
0.3001009822,
-0.8792555332,
-0.0910801589,
-0.4503463209,
-0.4262787998,
-0.1355822533,
-0.5259931087,
0.2555632889,
-0.2348391712,
-0.008234405,
0.3958580792,
-0.2133532017,
0.1158612669,
0.4667244554,
-0.340667963,
0.6060533524,
-0.3455689847,
-0.2299485952,
-0.5406524539,
-0.8973580003,
-0.4044059515,
1.0024242401,
0.1468121558,
0.3258086741,
-0.1991279721,
0.5297088623,
0.1209624484,
0.1556354761,
-1.0785068274,
0.6279451251,
0.3560514748,
-0.7579162121,
-0.3186511993,
-0.4194850028,
-0.6678487659,
0.1446216106,
-0.3062216043,
-0.411891371,
-0.0002585473,
0.1581831872,
-0.3751324117,
0.2931290567,
-0.5948747396,
0.5465686917,
-0.0421197228,
-0.3066896498,
-0.2797469795,
-0.6991013885,
0.2047652006,
-0.1292168349,
0.2454687208,
-0.1448219568,
0.3034643233,
0.7923294902,
-0.0977628678,
0.6573040485,
-0.2011719197,
-0.2515766323,
0.6275173426,
0.3100316226,
0.430134058,
0.2870977223,
0.1131449789,
-0.4947861433,
-0.1181131229,
-0.4052734971,
-0.7045542002,
0.1008597761,
-0.4413461387,
-0.6910735369,
-0.153715983,
-0.6964921355,
-0.5929443836,
0.2772522867,
0.3394533396,
0.3719512522,
-0.6489861608,
-0.063241668,
0.7858069539,
-0.1653488725,
0.2435317785,
0.7873743773,
-0.0320600159,
-0.3801092207,
0.7613075376,
-0.0790063292,
0.8939267993,
0.2794207633,
0.2894980907,
-0.2926510274,
-0.6210411787,
-0.1845636666,
-0.0892847478,
-0.662445128,
-0.226070568,
-0.4153774679,
-0.1035337001,
-0.4540202916,
-0.576862812,
-0.7173463702,
-0.7260622382,
-0.1501105428,
-0.2609297037,
-0.1411208212,
0.5100259185,
0.058757849,
0.5998351574,
-0.7569519281,
0.2599180341,
0.1466722488,
0.1710373908,
-0.2429383397,
-0.4803902507,
-0.2244756669,
0.4175159633,
-0.4720515013,
-0.5988004208,
0.1112671122,
0.123813659,
0.5052511096,
0.73371315,
0.4657149911,
0.7151021361,
-0.4745434523,
0.9184362292,
0.417992413,
-0.8270201087,
0.6589059234,
-0.4435642958,
0.5808264613,
1.0175976753,
0.3718365133,
-0.635466814,
-0.788705349,
-0.9698578715,
-0.765252769,
0.5243577361,
0.5031300783,
0.2516364753,
0.1380435079,
0.1187343448,
0.2758476734,
0.5950043797,
-0.3917420805,
0.1817160249,
-0.3284345567,
0.1671887785,
0.0859437361,
-0.1016999111,
-0.5460540056,
-0.0941669196,
0.3957161605,
-0.5353295207,
0.3242093623,
0.1341980845,
0.0251902472,
-0.1759910733,
0.36663872,
0.477204591,
0.7907306552,
0.0050505968,
-0.2168921679,
-0.056994535,
-0.516485393,
0.0242443364,
-0.2140726894,
-0.2638446391,
-0.1064881906,
0.3007933795,
0.6950336099,
0.5900035501,
-0.5943175554,
0.5599820018,
-0.2809072733,
-0.4042418599,
-0.230228126,
0.2575500011,
-0.0227394775,
0.1453352273,
0.0511786751,
-0.0680771917,
0.0542388149,
-0.430867523,
0.3354792595,
0.4045529068,
-0.6697508097,
-0.2035714984,
0.4633883238,
0.3230814934,
-0.1572807282,
0.6047853231,
-0.0247656908,
-0.7686519623,
0.4041382968,
0.2962124944,
0.6693074703,
-0.0768422112,
0.7950713038,
0.1844104826,
-0.0702206716,
0.2897946239,
0.3566012681,
-0.3368435502,
-0.9216396213,
-0.5412817597,
-0.4715128243,
-0.3422458768,
-0.3351716101,
-0.8842305541,
0.3322931528,
-0.5293524861,
-0.3012815714,
-0.3232070804,
0.2920895517,
-0.6057668328,
0.2941065729,
-0.066684857,
1.0756081343,
-0.7756582499,
0.0208702758,
0.4705517888,
-0.3336490691,
-1.0490089655,
0.2963829339,
0.1753562987,
-0.7829605341,
0.2615234554,
0.083315134,
-0.2632244825,
0.1179706678,
-0.3522047698,
-0.7236567736,
1.3058302402,
0.0795972571,
-0.1170819178,
-0.420984894,
0.4995845854,
0.229993403,
-0.2766822875,
0.105697602,
0.5905799866,
0.4913657904,
0.7524315715,
-0.8502643704,
0.0875073969,
0.1667878181,
-0.4544495046,
0.160588026,
-0.5906133056,
0.3916082382,
-0.2447436601,
-0.3520612121,
0.1171681806,
0.7686903477,
0.2293860316,
0.3482796252,
0.6817997694,
0.6257473826,
0.4066618681,
0.0953441337,
0.7432110906,
-0.2456496805,
-0.0803750232,
1.1177779436,
-0.3033227026,
0.5779806972,
0.6638618708,
-0.0936828181,
0.3843182921,
0.5753017068,
0.4244743586,
0.7566978335,
0.2365823537,
-0.480951041,
-0.1291421205,
-0.5617234707,
-0.3872509003,
0.509367764,
0.6191989779,
-0.1214511469,
-0.2014685124,
-0.4229658842,
0.1033303514,
0.0888103768,
-0.3054620326,
1.0433354378,
0.1508779824,
-1.2814737558,
0.1991109848,
-0.249340862,
0.1678901315,
-0.8319563866,
0.1560812593,
-0.0939210057,
-0.1662782431,
-0.0678447261,
-1.1626724005,
0.3889847398,
-0.2836585641,
-0.0667366087,
-0.7404122949,
0.807648778,
-0.3907074332,
0.1239691004,
0.0480434522,
0.607647419,
-0.3074409962,
-0.3650802374,
-0.4608876705,
-0.2849358916,
0.0697579607,
-0.3119152486,
0.4241034687,
0.5357532501,
-0.0243911557,
0.6039111614,
0.8554105163,
0.0732734501,
-0.2335641235,
-0.1480312943,
1.2392085791,
-0.3739567101,
-1.0143296719,
-0.1148587167,
0.9591498375,
-0.1694059521,
-0.445086509,
0.2443301082,
0.5592277646,
0.9631916285,
0.13391985,
0.7446132302,
-0.2097313553,
0.1924103945,
-0.6971293092,
0.6204243302,
-0.4112265706,
0.0758445263,
-0.3960429728,
-1.0231739283,
0.1526582241,
0.4417407215,
-0.3394666016,
-0.3895619512,
0.778973937,
0.4381805956,
-0.0178052094,
0.2622263432,
0.2494191229,
-0.4909444153,
0.7399271727,
0.6180546284,
1.0615458488,
0.2480863333,
0.70703125,
0.0894487202,
-0.1291128248,
0.133766219,
-0.93362391,
-0.7176796794,
-0.6596720219,
-0.1163385808,
-0.3179514706,
-0.0328518488,
0.5271632075,
0.6153077483,
-0.4330613315,
-0.0603487417,
-0.3529346287,
0.105135642,
0.0642809495,
-0.1672876179,
-0.161446631,
-0.212845549,
-0.3331619203,
0.1488944292,
-0.0270055514,
0.074752152,
-0.3075218201,
-0.3373259008,
-0.0757148266,
0.148920998,
0.3747009933,
0.5007115006,
-0.3808782995,
-0.387393862,
0.1234832853,
0.1030170768,
0.0862253755,
1.7074798346,
-0.8856757283,
0.3525975347,
0.4344159067,
0.6550390124,
0.5892917514,
0.290142715,
1.2644246817,
-1.0441093445,
0.1414276659,
0.6919723749,
-0.0887291804,
0.2371324003,
-0.2867806256,
0.4260630906,
-0.0654550567,
-0.3911955953,
-0.2891576588,
1.0045871735,
-0.8862259984,
-0.0295354538,
1.1793904305,
-0.4291820824,
0.3381916285,
-0.2634354234,
-0.4701847136,
0.3703749478,
-0.3518945277,
0.6611538529,
1.0752131939,
-0.1000565514,
0.1264018267,
-0.5676458478,
0.9244908094,
0.7679128051,
-0.5006735921,
0.0415421054,
0.5401961803,
-0.0785423368,
0.381701529,
1.070442915,
0.13809973,
0.1608777642,
-0.0742363781,
-0.510363102,
0.1528051049,
-0.566883862,
0.4584387243,
-0.2212107778,
0.1290268451,
0.0621423312
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02057v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02057v1
|
Break the Sequential Dependency of LLM Inference Using Lookahead Decoding
| 2024-02-03T06:37:50 | 2024-02-03T06:37:50 |
Yichao Fu, Peter Bailis, Ion Stoica, Hao Zhang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Autoregressive decoding of large language models (LLMs) is memory bandwidth
bounded, resulting in high latency and significant wastes of the parallel
processing power of modern accelerators. Existing methods for accelerating LLM
decoding often require a draft model (e.g., speculative decoding), which is
nontrivial to obtain and unable to generalize. In this paper, we introduce
Lookahead decoding, an exact, parallel decoding algorithm that accelerates LLM
decoding without needing auxiliary models or data stores. It allows trading
per-step log(FLOPs) to reduce the number of total decoding steps, is more
parallelizable on single or multiple modern accelerators, and is compatible
with concurrent memory-efficient attention (e.g., FlashAttention). Our
implementation of Lookahead decoding can speed up autoregressive decoding by up
to 1.8x on MT-bench and 4x with strong scaling on multiple GPUs in code
completion tasks. Our code is avialable at
https://github.com/hao-ai-lab/LookaheadDecoding
|
[
0.0318993479,
-0.6024750471,
0.5366923809,
0.5677486658,
-0.2963974774,
0.2907496095,
0.0299228523,
-0.6783864498,
0.3534590006,
0.6607583761,
-0.4066201448,
-0.5335261822,
-0.7434761524,
0.1409659982,
-0.5242402554,
0.2405244708,
-0.3695597053,
-0.1995316595,
0.119202897,
-0.2693556249,
-0.1652462482,
-0.1760670543,
-0.6595240235,
-0.3255235553,
0.3902242184,
0.4407101274,
0.6580509543,
1.1357553005,
0.4176922441,
0.3280549645,
-0.1471053064,
0.183382988,
-0.5200679302,
0.2392282039,
0.2381664515,
-0.5876699686,
-0.6411738396,
-0.1570809633,
0.4974099994,
0.3904288709,
-0.4436028004,
0.359102726,
-0.0573540293,
0.7856436968,
-0.9021892548,
0.3334726095,
-0.4116028547,
0.011848202,
-0.3663362861,
-0.4166552722,
-0.6487002373,
-0.4300854206,
-0.1979154348,
-0.4792742729,
0.1182000935,
0.2283064127,
0.4794511795,
0.7067510486,
-0.1390765905,
0.054496035,
-0.5195535421,
0.7207802534,
-1.0864278078,
0.5473496318,
0.454959482,
0.0961478651,
-0.2685664594,
-0.7375713587,
-0.5844452381,
0.0704475343,
0.057916481,
-0.0069427625,
-0.0155285206,
0.1398871392,
0.3958063722,
0.4471963346,
-0.7006086111,
0.1530643702,
0.0866978467,
-0.0301197674,
0.3586553037,
0.2821459174,
0.1831616014,
0.0307367779,
-0.1117848307,
-0.2036070675,
-0.7299773693,
-0.101174213,
0.1329427212,
-0.1701491475,
-0.2574996948,
0.3839403391,
-0.4308622181,
0.504255414,
0.0738182515,
-0.0151048005,
0.417612195,
-0.2392834276,
-0.3553839326,
0.0884061307,
0.8136011362,
-0.0528381243,
0.2423343658,
-0.0125007452,
-0.0192726925,
-0.0950563252,
0.1984998882,
-0.8127349615,
-0.2139973789,
0.5484736562,
-0.7077921629,
-0.1949130595,
-0.3363648653,
-0.9560915828,
0.1207710654,
-0.0672219694,
-0.0315706357,
-0.3989899755,
-0.0432705581,
0.4261970222,
0.0061258827,
0.4710580111,
0.2046756595,
-1.0825828314,
0.4606969953,
0.5087696314,
0.8709095716,
-0.0322280228,
-0.6045070291,
-0.7646483779,
0.2777841091,
-0.3888610005,
0.8132585883,
-0.3951205015,
-0.2563049197,
-0.0152628608,
-0.251432389,
0.001174232,
-0.7373931408,
0.5398156643,
-0.8652043343,
-0.3703821898,
0.018954441,
-0.5311924219,
-0.2234790623,
-0.0105010681,
-0.7703769803,
0.7659727931,
-0.2651606798,
-0.6367609501,
0.0459712818,
-0.3278080821,
-0.6384325027,
-0.0335815474,
-0.1684753001,
-0.2126827538,
0.2609035969,
0.6237789392,
0.014072937,
-0.3262866735,
0.1243509054,
-0.5027222633,
-0.5892519951,
-0.1070494354,
-0.4346011281,
0.6773799658,
0.1625201404,
-0.6401793957,
0.2766675055,
-0.7368305922,
0.0257067494,
0.4404260516,
-0.4588466883,
-0.1402080655,
0.2645427585,
-0.1133674011,
-0.2099569291,
0.4954498708,
-0.4088276327,
0.2607680261,
-0.3299060464,
0.159678489,
0.6704664826,
-0.2954269648,
0.1174011305,
-0.1194197759,
0.5029162169,
0.0066909203,
-0.0746323392,
-0.5304676294,
-0.2940251827,
-0.9189232588,
-0.4290189743,
0.1678331792,
0.6841766834,
-0.7783617377,
0.2861607075,
-0.1313455105,
-0.1229281425,
-0.9009010792,
0.2141180634,
0.5648961663,
0.4430617094,
0.6006408334,
-0.1866491884,
-0.5859891176,
-0.956322372,
-0.4932665229,
-0.077232331,
-0.0308620445,
0.0223162975,
0.0616038516,
-0.1678952873,
0.3617138863,
-0.5795709491,
-0.0116640925,
-0.0594962984,
0.2506239414,
0.4138151109,
0.4697999656,
0.1463202536,
-0.260597378,
-0.4164132774,
-0.2454387248,
-1.0566273928,
-0.1736434698,
-0.0606599674,
-0.2282066494,
0.116844289,
0.8185680509,
-0.7318748236,
0.5441774726,
0.4774973691,
-0.3799119592,
0.524238348,
-0.4581235945,
0.1643509269,
-0.6420737505,
-0.0191329122,
-0.4059028029,
-0.5071605444,
-0.3759230375,
0.4050315619,
0.1691927016,
0.2844724357,
-0.267278254,
0.6255642176,
-0.5694054961,
-0.106047973,
-0.4441643953,
-0.1796561182,
-0.0214248374,
0.3623654842,
0.1839073151,
0.8873795271,
0.6298145056,
-0.3529262543,
0.053358499,
0.4519419968,
-0.3220629394,
-0.2362235487,
-0.6439232826,
0.4080736339,
0.0911255702,
0.4582355618,
-0.6567072868,
-0.0945027024,
0.2291291654,
-0.2315717638,
0.1924349964,
-0.0867812261,
-0.6609902382,
-0.3469166756,
-0.2417757064,
0.9720830917,
0.7772914171,
-1.1210029125,
0.6555880904,
0.1587482095,
-0.0362674966,
-0.8221640587,
-0.7628118992,
0.1531984657,
0.073924154,
-0.514146328,
0.3562270403,
-0.1309148967,
-0.1706679463,
-0.0711776465,
-0.2315045297,
0.0721101463,
-0.1046922207,
-0.0456850082,
0.275342375,
-0.2808833122,
-0.5373088717,
0.0854441449,
-0.2457811981,
0.1577368379,
-0.5182671547,
0.6239331961,
0.0863359421,
-0.2318759561,
-0.6631122828,
0.3946912885,
0.686963439,
-0.21401079,
0.733215034,
0.440125525,
-0.1464031041,
-0.4366588295,
-0.5807619691,
0.0472202823,
-0.5511013269,
0.1032361984,
-0.4535683692,
-0.8427279592,
0.6669456363,
-0.0158893112,
0.1466976106,
0.1873047799,
0.7395098805,
0.1596568227,
0.8210840225,
0.4566095769,
-0.2115302682,
0.376444459,
-0.0390796959,
0.1290130019,
-0.6160320044,
-0.0555823557,
-0.2995604873,
-0.3142264187,
-0.2761958838,
-0.6326118708,
-0.1517985463,
0.0699855238,
-0.137044698,
0.1517246217,
-0.1097072586,
0.6569790244,
0.6691790819,
0.2927592993,
0.6006093025,
0.0324109197,
-0.038800735,
0.2138125598,
-0.5760018229,
-0.0289357156,
1.1829942465,
0.3588936627,
0.8996226788,
0.1186065003,
0.9070926309,
0.4047538042,
0.2463508546,
-0.7349244356,
0.6211400628,
-0.3222805858,
0.064357996,
-0.0175890438,
-0.6167278886,
-0.6762017608,
0.3134965897,
0.2941014767,
-0.5380296707,
0.2601754367,
0.2916675806,
-0.2502020597,
0.2369007617,
-0.2613906264,
0.6502510905,
0.0402480438,
-0.3564989567,
-0.6396285295,
-0.2243726999,
0.7099606991,
-0.0666685775,
0.0429311134,
-0.0352951065,
-0.0248983204,
0.8890712261,
-0.715326488,
0.6049051285,
-0.0615061447,
-0.1782514751,
0.2413301617,
0.240471825,
0.7435124516,
-0.1080095172,
-0.0223861896,
0.470055759,
-0.1514382064,
-0.8001840115,
-0.4889307618,
0.581892848,
-0.5464816689,
-0.6145563722,
-0.2550439835,
-0.5575777292,
-0.2408703864,
0.2789455056,
0.212462306,
0.2364284098,
-0.0679610223,
-0.4808756113,
0.6591143608,
-0.0009623705,
0.5580317974,
0.5366873145,
-0.4808149636,
-0.3434427977,
0.78087008,
-0.3426510096,
0.1520950049,
0.2493648827,
-0.1038165987,
-0.3089187145,
-0.9804142714,
-0.2656787932,
0.3631776869,
-0.6004331112,
-0.0503276959,
-0.6731811762,
-0.1706493199,
-0.4039524198,
-0.0414666831,
-0.5156513453,
-0.1376434267,
-0.1777299792,
0.0958566219,
0.2514041066,
0.6108795404,
-0.1512896121,
0.5634733438,
-1.0463547707,
0.8865420222,
0.1787696779,
0.3330096602,
0.3919180334,
-0.7431691885,
-0.4189184904,
-0.4662953615,
-0.0061595901,
-0.6191740632,
0.651768446,
-0.1908308864,
0.3275490999,
0.5764704347,
0.0918141082,
0.9056506157,
-0.9326412678,
0.1351782084,
-0.0476562455,
-1.0640318394,
0.229134351,
-0.2923380136,
0.737051785,
0.5800191164,
0.1970793307,
-0.2238610089,
-0.3703226447,
-0.4235213101,
-0.919755578,
0.7081979513,
0.1371623576,
-0.2263912708,
-0.2019607872,
0.2794113159,
0.1812051535,
0.0358591601,
-0.346716404,
-0.2954660058,
0.0773206502,
-0.4350912571,
-0.0181078091,
-0.5921677351,
0.0094630299,
-0.0547874868,
0.4166212678,
-0.069166258,
0.2919082344,
0.1938398182,
-0.2398660332,
-0.1878730655,
0.0439058468,
0.2161101103,
0.4408543706,
-0.5296894312,
0.1273087263,
-0.252201587,
-0.6787186861,
0.0698126704,
0.3022845089,
-0.1318619996,
-0.0382379144,
0.6180334091,
0.7648945451,
0.2932124734,
-0.8623847365,
0.0534961335,
-0.3030772209,
-0.1349615753,
-0.2213741541,
0.0125057446,
0.0381004177,
0.6069971323,
0.4066013098,
-0.0522084497,
0.262833029,
-0.3377957046,
0.416482091,
0.1414099336,
0.3617912233,
-0.1387791038,
0.9086699486,
0.1563774198,
-0.2837565541,
1.0083200932,
-0.023189012,
-0.2698850334,
0.6836484671,
0.5521849394,
1.2428011894,
-0.3267552853,
-0.1350645572,
0.3128875792,
0.1942590177,
-0.4836442173,
0.4558240771,
-0.1471236199,
-0.6763910055,
-0.7544742823,
-1.0219010115,
-0.5405819416,
0.0554864332,
-0.7341880798,
-0.1799845546,
-0.6684597731,
0.1704936624,
-0.1891138256,
-0.6009553671,
-0.5124720335,
-0.1977284253,
0.4038496614,
1.155497551,
-0.1666569114,
1.1665606499,
0.0791486949,
0.0807021409,
-0.4493001103,
0.5409758091,
0.1636734903,
-1.1033747196,
0.7392050624,
0.3955840468,
-0.2305805832,
0.1883066893,
-0.5290131569,
-1.1688570976,
0.894358933,
0.3116616607,
-0.9239448905,
-0.260573715,
-0.1117464304,
0.2375805527,
-0.4401971996,
0.3635109961,
0.8922123909,
0.296510756,
0.0759463757,
-0.7809985876,
0.288292855,
-0.0689275488,
-0.2521196008,
0.1709810942,
-0.5917661786,
0.5776439905,
-0.4411097765,
-0.171969682,
0.2533327639,
0.9685579538,
0.3877219856,
0.2100963891,
0.2693572044,
0.8947786093,
0.6055415869,
0.384093821,
1.0771853924,
-0.4946906865,
0.2820253968,
1.6316783428,
-0.3507048488,
1.1980335712,
0.373610884,
-0.3468744755,
0.3723877072,
0.6471589804,
0.1958340406,
0.5339633226,
-0.0342689902,
-0.3369742036,
-0.3483152688,
0.2594143748,
-0.1481136084,
0.41979146,
0.3825951815,
-0.2953239977,
-0.2705362439,
-0.2674919367,
-0.0478815585,
-0.2504521608,
-0.265773654,
0.4855050147,
0.3160682023,
-0.5569475293,
1.0709738731,
-0.0547033101,
0.6171557307,
-0.5018625259,
-0.1669328809,
-0.4360381365,
0.3274132013,
-0.0282810293,
-0.4984834194,
0.3997285664,
-0.0765805766,
-0.3211605847,
-0.101002112,
0.3986130655,
-0.3950100541,
-0.32600981,
0.9305208921,
0.6129498482,
0.1672235429,
0.0170996971,
-0.6435540915,
0.3784419,
0.2090706229,
-0.5863810778,
0.4726967812,
-0.0492650345,
0.326058805,
0.668622613,
0.8680046797,
0.0097971577,
0.2954540253,
0.0065776524,
0.8118148446,
-1.0849473476,
-0.4459762573,
-0.9623440504,
0.1676710248,
0.3101857901,
0.0662277713,
0.5627663732,
0.3451753855,
0.6429619789,
0.0643364713,
0.589186728,
0.1585757434,
0.1739318073,
-0.8771675825,
0.5885093212,
-0.4919036031,
0.431166023,
0.3328539133,
-0.827267468,
-0.0787047446,
0.1789236069,
-0.1346914768,
-0.2441276461,
0.7861539721,
0.4861215651,
-0.0581094921,
-0.0574884489,
0.3107183576,
0.7593917847,
0.1610163152,
0.4825600684,
0.2912167311,
-0.246867463,
0.3884661794,
-0.1468620151,
-0.3917365372,
-0.1411415339,
-0.5740975142,
-0.8306208849,
0.1337725222,
-0.1499764323,
-0.6218543053,
0.1227436364,
0.460516274,
0.4554255605,
-0.6725451946,
-0.4906572104,
-0.2473813146,
0.0927951485,
-0.2144722641,
-0.231731683,
0.4849767089,
-0.577739954,
-0.831648469,
0.947390914,
0.5500332713,
-0.2246041596,
-0.0983237699,
-0.1106858179,
-0.2988958955,
0.2557747066,
0.5070498586,
0.729665041,
-0.7348840237,
0.181737259,
-0.3113808632,
0.065743193,
0.390076071,
0.8184056282,
-1.0453443527,
0.272123158,
0.5007523298,
0.8784695864,
0.8111978173,
-0.0003922204,
0.5299227238,
-0.0807858855,
0.4741050005,
0.0463491082,
0.5109283924,
-0.0914675295,
-0.4429414868,
0.4162915051,
0.3414153457,
-0.6187152863,
-0.5119361877,
0.2920986414,
-1.0050934553,
-0.3127481341,
0.703068614,
-0.2844849229,
-0.6889078617,
-0.0193843916,
0.3741289079,
0.1070691049,
-0.6656028032,
0.6380445361,
0.4021260738,
-0.3421967626,
-0.5368626118,
-0.5399652719,
0.3412499428,
0.762753129,
-0.7491218448,
0.5198152065,
0.407761544,
0.1342609227,
-0.1458908916,
0.8348808289,
-0.1147122607,
0.2224159837,
0.3606684208,
0.1580156982,
-0.0805203766,
-0.2592317462,
-0.5309292078,
0.1022197828,
-0.0078065973,
-0.1995061934
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02056v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02056v1
|
AnthroScore: A Computational Linguistic Measure of Anthropomorphism
| 2024-02-03T06:36:11 | 2024-02-03T06:36:11 |
Myra Cheng, Kristina Gligoric, Tiziano Piccardi, Dan Jurafsky
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
Anthropomorphism, or the attribution of human-like characteristics to
non-human entities, has shaped conversations about the impacts and
possibilities of technology. We present AnthroScore, an automatic metric of
implicit anthropomorphism in language. We use a masked language model to
quantify how non-human entities are implicitly framed as human by the
surrounding context. We show that AnthroScore corresponds with human judgments
of anthropomorphism and dimensions of anthropomorphism described in social
science literature. Motivated by concerns of misleading anthropomorphism in
computer science discourse, we use AnthroScore to analyze 15 years of research
papers and downstream news articles. In research papers, we find that
anthropomorphism has steadily increased over time, and that papers related to
language models have the most anthropomorphism. Within ACL papers, temporal
increases in anthropomorphism are correlated with key neural advancements.
Building upon concerns of scientific misinformation in mass media, we identify
higher levels of anthropomorphism in news headlines compared to the research
papers they cite. Since AnthroScore is lexicon-free, it can be directly applied
to a wide range of text sources.
|
[
-0.4180957079,
-0.7452536821,
0.4363246858,
-0.0859599039,
-0.2856300175,
0.3046436012,
-0.2406749725,
-0.9043955803,
0.4965382516,
-0.0728710815,
-0.3363372982,
-0.3365763128,
-0.6381160617,
0.1897536069,
-0.5574652553,
0.7265010476,
0.0217081085,
-0.0958647877,
-0.4733006656,
-0.3344648182,
0.1126047969,
-0.5664800406,
-0.2056499571,
-0.4084139466,
0.2759604454,
0.0963933319,
1.252768755,
0.9955637455,
0.0314758606,
0.4401896894,
-0.3564683199,
-0.020574661,
0.1504313201,
0.0194414183,
-0.3526983857,
-0.2019480914,
-0.4139329493,
0.5059952736,
0.72821486,
0.8599407673,
-0.1540827304,
0.6527429223,
0.1326240003,
0.4784696996,
-0.5663075447,
0.051228188,
-0.3874256015,
0.0825614706,
-0.0999263078,
-0.0417609774,
0.1539681405,
-0.243803367,
-0.1674564183,
-0.6760126948,
0.4833256602,
0.5571319461,
0.4980074167,
0.399392277,
-0.2590976357,
-0.4234689176,
-0.5848260522,
0.7847829461,
-0.2875458598,
0.5677438378,
0.5597161651,
0.1537582576,
0.1023147553,
-0.0276512913,
-0.8572440743,
-0.4150709808,
-0.0049526049,
-0.14485991,
-0.0367687494,
-0.3197976649,
0.1477402896,
0.3446181715,
-0.6878226399,
-0.2735998034,
-0.5304764509,
-0.5022389293,
0.7608205676,
-0.024209816,
0.6501457691,
-0.4938450456,
-0.072959356,
-0.0030556787,
-0.5023688674,
-0.0155486418,
0.4711050391,
0.1492460072,
-0.2884730995,
0.4724012315,
-0.0223851334,
0.5511404276,
-0.2164104581,
-0.1825210303,
0.2196023017,
0.0347144045,
0.1856428087,
0.628262639,
0.3766750693,
0.2746455967,
0.1276558936,
-0.5080928206,
0.1715042591,
0.5864172578,
0.4017476439,
-0.3921782672,
-0.0819454864,
-0.0913354754,
-0.3333091736,
-0.3781798184,
-0.0517227985,
-0.4774509668,
-0.6984573603,
-0.3914236724,
-0.0446395911,
-0.2028229535,
-0.4723310173,
-0.1208985373,
-0.0509002768,
0.0228615981,
0.3174749911,
-0.4696672559,
0.4474441111,
0.8887677193,
1.101744771,
-0.1242532879,
-0.5305648446,
-0.1326059699,
0.1861542016,
-0.75024122,
0.9646089673,
-0.4629360139,
-0.2739772499,
-0.3567974269,
0.0549095273,
0.2161223143,
-0.3176991045,
0.514220953,
-0.2209457457,
0.3132787049,
0.0263042115,
-0.2965296507,
-0.3849190772,
0.4693650007,
-0.4665675163,
0.8964942694,
0.0377240628,
-0.7675212026,
0.078321673,
-0.5713953972,
-0.5127187371,
0.138618961,
-0.3634856045,
-0.1583327353,
0.3823609352,
-0.1314866245,
-0.2086108625,
-0.504054606,
0.1728664637,
-0.3832799792,
-0.250906527,
0.4281662703,
0.1718358099,
0.6656373739,
0.2178866267,
-0.2432139963,
-0.0193799697,
-0.4060738385,
-0.1153826118,
0.0039844806,
-0.0070512546,
-0.6989036798,
0.3792498112,
-0.0704485029,
0.3053900599,
0.1009143516,
-0.8398807645,
-0.0865810364,
-0.3677009642,
0.859885633,
0.7933974862,
-0.3710183799,
0.6545872688,
-0.5100873113,
0.3856173754,
-0.1359810382,
0.188533783,
0.1589515805,
-0.5389747024,
-0.2815837264,
-0.1652322263,
-0.0806384906,
0.3346992135,
-0.4141592979,
0.3261041939,
-0.3861310482,
-0.5118156672,
-0.4934844375,
-0.1540788412,
0.3583533764,
0.7922167182,
0.3479896784,
-0.4297182858,
-0.3013120592,
-1.0170978308,
-0.6896088123,
-0.6682787538,
-0.1363463998,
0.4670189023,
0.3297627568,
-0.2476443201,
0.8538085222,
-0.4004229307,
-0.0285570566,
0.5105450749,
0.6333886385,
-0.1387536675,
0.6308066845,
0.4509815872,
-0.4992408454,
0.098797977,
-0.0278029069,
-0.6680276394,
-0.0351314135,
0.3014299273,
-0.0635845885,
0.414167732,
0.4158832431,
-0.7078595757,
0.0419056751,
0.5952937007,
-0.7470737696,
0.56568259,
0.017611891,
0.4456998408,
-0.8459680676,
0.4313271046,
-0.2207727134,
-0.2982338071,
-0.1848064959,
-0.0674523637,
-0.1317962557,
-0.4290474951,
-0.4594512582,
0.8067594767,
-0.7287301421,
-0.694668591,
-0.1743115485,
0.0820153505,
-0.071346581,
-0.0553843416,
0.0655674711,
0.6542819738,
0.6478379369,
-0.5363744497,
0.3561997712,
0.3891936541,
-0.5454246402,
0.4979206026,
-0.4825009704,
0.4363090992,
-0.4651292861,
0.2999857664,
-0.8128771186,
-0.2892281413,
0.2016296834,
-0.850880444,
-0.1378933787,
0.0506543517,
-0.5159241557,
-0.4302234054,
-0.5352017283,
0.6697027087,
0.5167363286,
-0.0336206406,
0.5791729689,
0.6905268431,
-0.259809494,
-0.060102053,
-0.7231516838,
0.3365460038,
-0.0004875112,
-0.6335186362,
0.3447810709,
-0.2226700038,
-0.3849427402,
0.4204171598,
-0.3296443522,
-0.0858610794,
0.1344571859,
0.509211719,
0.2024468184,
-0.2969450355,
0.134698838,
-0.0677394643,
-0.0370192379,
0.3024841547,
-0.1861845851,
0.4112785459,
-0.1313013136,
-0.1059580818,
-0.3505912125,
0.4623705745,
0.8099995255,
0.3630724251,
0.4115953743,
0.222447753,
-0.4655690491,
0.1112865061,
-0.4860258698,
-0.2187826186,
-0.410621196,
0.2248930931,
-0.0093160653,
-0.6727535129,
0.5049772859,
0.070527941,
-0.2248875946,
0.5438030362,
0.2777103782,
-0.0023239902,
1.3920274973,
0.4002622962,
-0.0413141623,
0.3892399073,
0.3070051372,
-0.1176994517,
-0.8995551467,
-0.2518209815,
-0.7542098165,
-0.4390322268,
-0.696875155,
-0.402281791,
0.1626960337,
-0.2448488176,
-0.5975707769,
0.2928063869,
-0.7779870033,
0.4327500165,
0.2581308186,
0.1049937755,
0.3293648362,
-0.0236624535,
0.1640028358,
0.0408377089,
-0.4898513556,
-0.5851969123,
0.4091095924,
0.1613920778,
0.4426991045,
0.0024565866,
0.189803645,
0.7987253666,
0.8126881719,
-0.7093657255,
0.5775203705,
0.1380768418,
-0.9069330096,
-0.1475380063,
-0.5218684673,
-0.6223838329,
0.0188873708,
-0.3084207773,
-0.7198297381,
0.2634720504,
0.3478585482,
-0.1562161744,
0.1419255733,
-0.3612682819,
0.4878124893,
-0.3569958508,
-0.181152001,
-0.464410156,
-0.6728631854,
0.1774167418,
0.1819423437,
0.7903994918,
-0.5528392196,
-0.338820219,
0.682841897,
-0.0412598699,
0.8115318418,
0.1048810184,
0.0935976505,
0.2341093719,
0.5636780858,
0.2284438014,
-0.0821777955,
-0.2503337562,
0.4866101742,
0.0277865622,
-0.4903379083,
-0.349525094,
0.8252446651,
-1.0218930244,
-0.5372364521,
-0.8551402688,
-0.6170148253,
-0.1900101453,
0.1011132598,
0.0976513624,
0.2222576588,
-0.375671804,
-0.0909807533,
0.0297566634,
-0.2231339067,
0.3556498885,
0.6744368672,
-0.0522639863,
-0.3339589238,
0.8918460011,
-0.0518876016,
-0.0591669194,
-0.1114009619,
0.3967713714,
-0.2744375169,
-0.1841913611,
-0.5913495421,
0.2221356481,
-0.511725843,
-0.1585121453,
-0.5592891574,
-0.0119469827,
-0.6231076717,
-0.3560718894,
-0.4324708581,
-0.7501981854,
-0.1739514023,
0.0095367767,
0.1329564303,
0.681646049,
-0.1585285962,
-0.1971451789,
-0.6901463866,
0.3764191866,
0.1591604799,
0.3945917487,
-0.137243405,
-0.540835917,
-0.1836192012,
0.1657346785,
-0.0445490405,
-0.9103273749,
0.29720065,
0.4635602236,
0.4838961959,
0.2476631105,
0.1634277999,
0.5118526816,
-0.521084547,
0.918166101,
0.3013620079,
-1.1313074827,
0.4372588396,
-0.3492439091,
0.4347701967,
0.3827134073,
0.3079051375,
-0.7392415404,
-0.4798931181,
-0.6513559222,
-0.7243881226,
0.7053558826,
0.0230011493,
0.3213466704,
-0.1017933115,
0.404117316,
-0.0074406159,
0.3702409863,
-0.5479897261,
-0.0602660701,
-0.5490785241,
0.1364190876,
-0.2804097831,
-0.1091511101,
-0.2880560756,
-0.4571083486,
0.3566151261,
-0.1866876185,
0.3493175507,
0.2405415922,
-0.508808434,
-0.3966801763,
0.1186946407,
0.8388059735,
0.6764619946,
-0.06939964,
0.8489306569,
-0.0063757654,
-0.4912818968,
0.0415831171,
0.0017960905,
-0.091314055,
-0.0209032465,
0.6292341352,
0.4378988445,
0.1574354619,
-0.5852100253,
0.1148321703,
0.1765737832,
-0.1112395227,
-0.3033960164,
-0.0616478324,
-0.0015533189,
0.1107294336,
0.5632920265,
0.2668568492,
0.4577995241,
-1.0546274185,
0.1395461857,
0.3170004189,
-0.5929639935,
-0.7729613185,
0.64629668,
0.17596668,
-0.4295524657,
0.4968638122,
-0.1291804016,
-0.5419415832,
0.6178963184,
0.4714411497,
1.0836834908,
-0.6778860092,
0.3054227829,
0.4570436478,
0.4784871638,
-0.2123231739,
-0.0428190753,
-0.3672902584,
-0.7071339488,
-0.1378470659,
-0.8743041158,
-0.3299783766,
-0.3434102833,
-0.3164122403,
-0.029334696,
-0.4119928479,
-0.2376016676,
0.2832348049,
-0.3467923701,
-0.152944386,
0.0605961345,
0.4321061671,
0.7194133401,
-1.1296058893,
0.4542426169,
1.3744972944,
-0.0527350157,
-0.1487502307,
0.23369582,
0.479719609,
-0.6685707569,
0.4969117939,
0.2738333642,
-0.5541081429,
-0.0342032835,
-0.6331336498,
-0.8459379077,
0.8699446321,
0.7455441952,
0.0322648063,
-0.0947609544,
0.2585535347,
0.6050040722,
-0.4917677939,
-0.0595554709,
0.3082804978,
0.4649231136,
0.0478474721,
-0.8769925833,
0.3907444179,
-0.5399318337,
0.1549447328,
0.2058146745,
-0.4361591935,
0.8980901241,
-0.093262665,
-0.6084424257,
-0.3867354691,
0.4157212675,
0.0264006294,
0.3783107698,
0.800121963,
0.2852561474,
0.5220493078,
0.2512974143,
1.1088978052,
-0.5677560568,
0.3460049033,
0.792206049,
-0.0136998314,
0.4201625586,
0.290679723,
-0.0052889609,
0.5430532098,
0.5836369395,
0.3526111543,
0.2884950936,
0.3271547258,
-0.3325387537,
-0.3863351941,
-0.4642210007,
-0.4035350084,
0.4549449384,
0.4349767864,
-0.30469203,
-0.3626936376,
0.0976131409,
0.1079688892,
0.2442572564,
-0.2689443529,
0.7421417832,
0.0746323392,
-0.6332093477,
0.5680655837,
-0.0895124599,
0.4400842488,
-0.1333416253,
0.0940198302,
-0.1399526745,
0.0022288649,
-0.2709723115,
-0.6566879749,
1.0385140181,
-0.0793556944,
-0.3635340035,
-0.265088737,
0.565059185,
-0.243907854,
-0.5309796929,
0.2976948321,
0.4517535865,
0.3751040697,
-0.3104081452,
-0.7233857512,
0.2610889971,
-0.5511855483,
-0.317748636,
0.2558948994,
0.1545659751,
-0.2439814657,
0.6292104721,
0.649587512,
0.0849516243,
-0.1275130808,
-0.6954033971,
0.9743205905,
-0.7458113432,
-0.7743605971,
-0.8586809635,
-0.0305108409,
-0.1626321077,
-0.3235676289,
0.5624525547,
0.6991800666,
0.2964307666,
0.2239807397,
0.5015770197,
-0.3631904125,
0.5729007721,
-0.0718954951,
0.888263762,
-0.6692352891,
-0.114447169,
-0.1567043215,
-0.8593190312,
-0.2681204081,
0.6966419816,
-0.3898889124,
-0.1549803466,
0.7218645811,
0.6498185396,
-0.1682224274,
0.1118279621,
0.0191155449,
0.2440120876,
-0.1871038973,
-0.1289828122,
0.8550798297,
-0.0131617663,
0.2999281585,
-0.0632046536,
-0.506733954,
-0.2160616368,
-0.9826356173,
-0.481413722,
-0.7924945951,
-0.6074299812,
-0.4008841217,
0.3579802513,
0.8549211621,
0.9043926001,
-0.6242566705,
-0.2291292101,
-0.108111538,
0.3430182934,
-0.2546356618,
-0.2194705307,
0.2749886513,
-0.1631947905,
-0.5483677983,
0.1711492687,
0.3208621144,
-0.1198320314,
-0.3637734056,
0.0812683776,
-0.0237730276,
0.3569849133,
0.7251604199,
0.5818069577,
-0.6219633222,
-0.561055243,
0.0568391643,
-0.2948425412,
0.0852010846,
1.090845108,
-0.6934529543,
0.3264344931,
0.6369134188,
0.1275346279,
0.3394447565,
0.2529113591,
0.4638122916,
-0.7869035602,
0.6085938811,
0.4867730439,
0.0043849633,
0.6438910365,
-0.376757741,
0.3955735266,
0.5158872008,
-0.361312747,
-0.9095640182,
0.3821346462,
-0.7303832173,
-0.6890240908,
1.0082242489,
0.3073365688,
-0.5917028189,
-0.2399844676,
0.1734892577,
0.3837107718,
-0.4451328516,
1.5026359558,
0.5957800746,
-0.4000728726,
-0.4479373693,
-0.606081605,
0.5882366896,
0.1470584124,
-0.8574747443,
0.0075174877,
0.7909984589,
0.152144745,
0.726271987,
0.5875597,
-0.2946747839,
0.152226612,
0.1174549311,
0.2665503025,
-0.2668792009,
0.0036903135,
0.1745817363,
0.0248311181,
0.0165026523,
-0.2054634839
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05120v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05120v1
|
More Agents Is All You Need
| 2024-02-03T05:55:24 | 2024-02-03T05:55:24 |
Junyou Li, Qin Zhang, Yangbin Yu, Qiang Fu, Deheng Ye
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
We find that, simply via a sampling-and-voting method, the performance of
large language models (LLMs) scales with the number of agents instantiated.
Also, this method is orthogonal to existing complicated methods to further
enhance LLMs, while the degree of enhancement is correlated to the task
difficulty. We conduct comprehensive experiments on a wide range of LLM
benchmarks to verify the presence of our finding, and to study the properties
that can facilitate its occurrence. Our code is publicly available at:
\url{https://anonymous.4open.science/r/more_agent_is_all_you_need}.
|
[
-0.5202317834,
-0.7082182765,
0.937412858,
0.1980898082,
0.0458662361,
0.2066925317,
-0.3539705276,
-0.6854528785,
0.203037411,
0.7063076496,
-0.3026195168,
-0.3644297719,
-0.7742189765,
0.1016024277,
-0.5021740794,
0.6489816308,
0.1929498911,
0.2029651552,
-0.3273765445,
-0.114269793,
-0.0875429958,
-0.4351637363,
-0.6074877977,
-0.4894059002,
0.6845306754,
0.5248333216,
0.7083521485,
0.8969001174,
0.6742175221,
0.4385513365,
-0.2534911036,
0.2800142169,
-0.4231149554,
0.2988416255,
0.1034944281,
-0.8470401764,
-0.8010015488,
0.2486848831,
0.9470638633,
0.6513938904,
-0.073453851,
0.3199701011,
-0.0858624801,
0.4034362733,
-0.5041801929,
0.1900804639,
-0.5487818122,
-0.4416829944,
-0.3150752783,
-0.2600001097,
-0.5726687908,
-0.3727723658,
0.0206000954,
-0.4414696991,
0.1527908146,
0.0415257253,
0.521211803,
0.0864148885,
-0.765555203,
-0.1085430756,
-0.7733287215,
0.8209646344,
-0.67909199,
0.2836229205,
0.1026235595,
0.2876674235,
-0.379989177,
-0.8997306228,
-0.7093172073,
-0.9746186137,
0.2533274591,
-0.0859297812,
0.1747650802,
0.1510593742,
0.4950911701,
0.2794905901,
-0.3445243239,
0.1217057481,
-0.222427398,
0.0142323915,
0.7410878539,
0.3870102167,
0.3790470958,
0.2298636883,
-0.0717583373,
-0.573179841,
-0.6602309942,
-0.1025552079,
0.5204836726,
0.341526866,
-0.0690385029,
0.6336923242,
-0.1745926887,
0.7412694097,
-0.2152769566,
-0.0697720721,
0.4476914406,
-0.5885166526,
0.1198977754,
-0.4282157421,
0.618010819,
0.1300022006,
0.28837502,
0.1506420225,
-0.2271861583,
-0.1022635028,
0.1745327711,
-0.9547430873,
-0.0585113354,
0.1949093044,
-0.3770101666,
-0.1896415055,
-0.1568475366,
-0.4075326025,
-0.7259422541,
-0.5007416606,
0.3486366272,
-0.328795135,
-0.5355867147,
-0.0894547775,
-0.4695191383,
0.4389539659,
0.4319342673,
-0.4786142111,
0.4154108167,
0.9102783203,
0.9440099001,
-0.2693603039,
-0.7140133977,
-0.5708071589,
-0.3308167458,
-0.7582387328,
1.1327975988,
-0.8582493067,
-0.1862024218,
0.0474131443,
-0.0408618487,
0.043805249,
-0.7507792115,
0.3265441358,
-0.7324324846,
-0.1411242634,
-0.5844815373,
-0.7583295703,
-0.0008892725,
0.0853585973,
-1.0461945534,
1.2097549438,
0.0024003151,
-0.1425818354,
0.3470666111,
-0.8112831116,
-0.4778352976,
0.1189722866,
-0.0898894295,
-0.1747590601,
0.4407662451,
-0.0912105367,
0.4803875089,
-0.4666152,
0.0961842611,
-0.4390338957,
-0.2752720118,
0.6243584752,
-0.3264820874,
0.7547319531,
0.269565016,
-0.1962100118,
0.3975202739,
-0.743779242,
0.0793219507,
-0.0018964354,
-0.6576852202,
-0.1121236384,
0.1559555829,
0.1214568019,
0.0774672106,
0.3586140871,
-0.4466474652,
0.2672213018,
-0.4844528437,
0.09447705,
0.7230728865,
-0.0299265087,
0.5991714001,
-0.6786683798,
0.6852693558,
-0.1906069964,
0.0750457719,
0.0411455184,
-0.6286686063,
-0.8178673387,
-0.4460825324,
0.1239397302,
0.1888416111,
-0.5217241049,
0.1885559559,
-0.2313972265,
-0.7710763812,
-0.4466559291,
0.4664577842,
0.3210135996,
-0.2157722861,
0.0875078365,
-0.3680128753,
-0.4551332891,
-0.6774998903,
-0.0728262961,
-0.0638491064,
-0.1908435374,
0.3757635653,
0.6699956656,
-0.2388101965,
1.0299236774,
-0.4814891219,
-0.032065846,
-0.4770696163,
0.1051815301,
0.2029667199,
0.0195921995,
0.5848193765,
-0.4386942983,
-0.5078760386,
0.056965176,
-0.5997172594,
-0.2415180355,
0.1239888445,
-0.0883959085,
-0.0289661568,
0.6732766032,
-0.7260357141,
-0.237334162,
0.4894792438,
-0.0860707834,
0.4350362122,
-0.4093090892,
-0.0091766194,
-1.270481348,
-0.2582305968,
0.0953476578,
-0.3210780323,
-0.6572643518,
0.669098258,
0.0685626641,
0.0982414633,
-0.4992066622,
0.6699573398,
-0.9166379571,
-0.3241204619,
-0.6935511231,
0.4154974818,
-0.1562761813,
0.2467105836,
-0.1054892689,
0.8481829762,
0.7123023868,
-0.70995754,
0.8310261369,
-0.2671480477,
-0.5570656657,
0.2501330376,
-0.6485772729,
0.0581294075,
-0.2787283063,
0.4768851995,
-1.2971298695,
-0.431137234,
-0.3537807465,
-0.3801618814,
0.1380853802,
0.2164943814,
-0.6979187727,
-0.2058382481,
-0.5610296726,
0.3336063623,
0.411398977,
-0.5886259079,
0.6365191936,
0.5898191929,
-0.2460966557,
-0.3662301302,
-0.3200292587,
0.2442424893,
-0.0685062036,
-0.2956738472,
0.0011645054,
-0.2021418512,
-0.5244167447,
-0.146964699,
0.3885386884,
-0.0531472079,
0.3135366142,
0.1943820715,
-0.0091949143,
-0.2981084287,
0.3954395354,
-0.2478443384,
-0.0322786495,
0.1785473526,
0.0071899411,
0.8420706391,
-0.1276187897,
-0.5388971567,
-0.1683480293,
0.3139031529,
0.8289781213,
-0.4177002907,
0.5890113711,
0.5369909406,
-0.2429273576,
-0.302437216,
-0.6673911214,
-0.3381462395,
-0.5282731056,
0.7495427132,
-0.3782806695,
-0.8757935166,
0.6333764195,
-0.2647592425,
0.1575337648,
0.3332359791,
0.9708229899,
0.3685632348,
1.2428481579,
0.5311636925,
-0.2632963657,
0.628600955,
-0.1964225024,
-0.0970781967,
-0.7894021273,
-0.0708237141,
-0.6623415351,
-0.2640865743,
-0.7450918555,
-0.8004036546,
0.2489433885,
-0.2440078557,
-0.1337622106,
0.3058715463,
-0.4177887738,
0.7068699598,
0.7494861484,
0.029942736,
0.454792887,
-0.034620367,
0.0566107854,
0.3331955373,
-0.3452664912,
-0.4308241308,
1.2375897169,
0.3850147128,
0.7475709915,
0.5895026922,
0.819991529,
0.2560786605,
0.6819286942,
-0.8787454963,
0.7997766733,
0.1435002834,
-0.9637650847,
-0.6627430916,
-0.4956920743,
-1.1110317707,
0.3126105964,
-0.2407712936,
-0.574436903,
0.1785231978,
-0.0519441217,
-0.3889138103,
-0.0797815323,
-0.59815377,
0.3021009266,
-0.1625771075,
-0.2736255527,
-0.4806328714,
-0.2830063403,
0.2239015549,
-0.1526993513,
0.1754882187,
-0.2310688645,
-0.4047063887,
0.6400600076,
-0.4603661597,
0.9483854175,
0.0090514738,
-0.3524071574,
0.5610501766,
-0.1381197721,
0.7846650481,
-0.1325008869,
-0.2058221847,
-0.3032344282,
-0.2315500379,
-0.5460381508,
-0.522372961,
0.923453033,
-1.0083510876,
-0.4884195626,
-0.385569334,
-0.6479808092,
-0.0957746208,
0.0958652571,
0.1001927033,
0.4417460859,
-0.0326083079,
0.392285198,
0.4319989979,
-0.0007480512,
0.6151753664,
0.8824067712,
-0.2823287547,
-0.146082148,
0.9330165386,
0.3474215269,
0.3941041827,
0.3873824477,
0.201951921,
-0.3866421282,
-0.7568959594,
-0.141536653,
0.219719708,
-0.5112814307,
-0.0353534743,
-0.7224187851,
-0.1598661989,
-0.5697841644,
0.2646906376,
-0.561354816,
-0.1614719331,
-0.1655009687,
-0.2932296395,
0.7819111943,
1.0392764807,
-0.1914872974,
0.7630184889,
-0.6542755365,
0.2747926116,
0.626758635,
0.4309489429,
0.2447729856,
-0.7219039202,
-0.3708971441,
-0.2051338404,
-0.2949542403,
-0.9656077623,
0.414791733,
0.2752116621,
0.6878277659,
0.3684307039,
-0.0665654391,
0.5937491059,
-0.5379223824,
0.6923300028,
-0.1726203114,
-0.7977036834,
-0.0281357076,
-0.3994551301,
0.1572722495,
0.3271449208,
0.1998660415,
-0.2026907355,
-0.484064877,
-0.4772156179,
-0.8718041182,
0.6434361339,
0.0344249345,
0.6127972603,
-0.0808410123,
0.3779584467,
-0.2944468856,
0.119125396,
-0.8093862534,
-0.3538511693,
0.5267587304,
0.0371227004,
-0.3814110458,
-0.6467174292,
0.0443569683,
-0.1403207332,
0.6377081275,
-0.0955650434,
0.0688766912,
-0.1693004668,
-0.099770084,
-0.0597910173,
0.391479373,
0.6260854602,
0.7340715528,
-0.2012218982,
0.1825904399,
0.4500689209,
-0.3585726917,
0.2681402266,
0.1492125392,
0.3369428217,
-0.0737807527,
0.8069606423,
0.8624723554,
-0.092761226,
-0.8467508554,
0.5139178038,
0.0247478411,
-0.2560719848,
-0.405731529,
0.3422349095,
0.3915375769,
0.5974116921,
0.5144507289,
-0.4158537686,
0.2560093701,
-0.8404787779,
0.3565920889,
0.5303849578,
-0.2462232858,
-0.066017434,
0.2964537442,
0.3394263983,
-0.5948634148,
0.297075659,
-0.5635308027,
-0.2686170936,
0.9052336812,
0.5203300714,
0.5901361108,
-0.3883666992,
0.2475249469,
0.1067984328,
0.4500007629,
-0.5524336696,
0.2888079286,
0.1205893606,
-0.8164981008,
-0.9193928838,
-0.4811677337,
-0.7037293315,
0.3073938489,
-0.3972843587,
0.1150131077,
-0.2023736835,
-0.3605997264,
0.095261246,
0.3719236255,
-0.4539487064,
-0.0165325589,
0.0193478223,
0.6771587133,
-0.9649175406,
0.8301215768,
0.8687450886,
-0.0936153606,
-0.8220775723,
-0.1683142483,
-0.0321986228,
-0.918530345,
0.455676347,
0.0338753052,
-0.1021194458,
-0.005125694,
-0.6615741849,
-1.2142099142,
0.89888978,
0.4056226909,
-0.7386695147,
0.158837989,
0.1768266857,
0.8763896823,
-0.4570932388,
0.8235955238,
0.7335061431,
0.4449598193,
0.0407642052,
-0.8403678536,
0.1199242845,
-0.33760342,
0.0530685112,
0.1115390882,
-0.5166002512,
1.2388634682,
-0.3332754374,
0.0153224366,
0.1482653469,
0.6448763013,
0.3702403009,
0.3518554866,
0.5986281037,
0.2196990848,
0.8912497163,
0.3283922672,
1.2675470114,
-0.4037739933,
0.3171227872,
1.3510663509,
-0.6067211628,
0.782551825,
0.1235152036,
-0.3632651269,
0.1953023821,
0.5767321587,
-0.0378649719,
-0.037067201,
0.5635249615,
-0.4815156758,
-0.6763451695,
-0.4195471704,
-0.4055994749,
0.5072600842,
0.1521636695,
-0.3714792132,
-0.1481285989,
0.0724682584,
-0.0025224951,
0.1241109297,
0.0392657854,
0.8228026628,
0.1040269062,
-0.5617201328,
0.3844240308,
-0.0176663436,
0.6161472797,
-0.3713639081,
-0.15121454,
-0.1777003407,
0.1524664313,
0.0240856558,
-0.7312011123,
-0.2701015472,
-0.1372671574,
-0.1949318945,
0.093603313,
0.4693190157,
-0.4504919946,
-0.7649897337,
0.5892962813,
0.9323692918,
0.3833146095,
-0.2503345311,
-0.2331940383,
0.0684819221,
-0.2010434717,
-0.6092654467,
0.4072217345,
0.449853152,
-0.1334894896,
0.8075398803,
0.734824121,
0.4135262072,
0.2351496816,
0.3861564696,
0.8477708697,
-0.5272083879,
0.0154376682,
-1.0650504827,
0.0370636955,
-0.402671665,
-0.1755100191,
0.7991870642,
0.5959969163,
0.6374149919,
-0.0425274707,
0.8386941552,
0.1911415756,
0.5842049122,
-0.1720117182,
0.5579695702,
-0.6683630347,
0.3628107607,
-0.1970986575,
-0.9659757614,
-0.1754749268,
0.4247393608,
-0.2317193598,
0.2397474945,
0.5211362839,
1.22447896,
0.2654548585,
-0.4340260029,
0.4722858071,
0.3423177302,
0.4074094892,
0.3838960528,
1.1508727074,
-0.0377064086,
0.6676316261,
0.0719844326,
-0.4170557559,
-0.3432883322,
-0.8596850634,
-0.9941171408,
-0.5582107306,
-0.2195414007,
-0.2943730652,
-0.0941019654,
1.0701370239,
0.8330854177,
-0.5567024946,
-0.5643851757,
-0.0127052879,
0.3200874627,
-0.1722147763,
-0.1681671441,
0.0260379482,
-0.4710251093,
-1.1084614992,
0.4156458378,
-0.1956790537,
-0.080860354,
-0.2210989445,
-0.1321286857,
-0.0888011679,
0.4480671287,
0.8352308869,
0.0528975204,
-0.409273386,
-0.1310015619,
0.0035101699,
-0.2159445286,
-0.1313668191,
0.905115366,
-0.3756914735,
0.2803973258,
0.8908933401,
0.4995569587,
0.4875158966,
-0.1660202593,
0.5782479644,
-0.7345160246,
-0.0631120279,
-0.0890652165,
0.313847214,
0.0177690443,
-0.1096934304,
0.3219697773,
-0.0024736198,
-0.585799396,
-0.9745874405,
0.3166946173,
-0.9040539265,
-0.3124195039,
1.4848296642,
0.1713266224,
-0.1423521936,
0.0096814698,
-0.3023017943,
0.2002284974,
-0.6955291033,
0.6215720177,
0.7014040351,
-0.3540318012,
-0.2753721178,
-0.5930107832,
0.4372594953,
0.2993443012,
-0.9591246843,
0.0394199863,
0.5670308471,
0.2817628086,
0.4288476706,
0.8541366458,
0.1305603236,
0.1145932302,
0.0232745409,
0.1282022595,
-0.0182754491,
-0.5451594591,
-0.2583325505,
0.3714519739,
0.7707193494,
-0.0372222327
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02037v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02037v3
|
EffiBench: Benchmarking the Efficiency of Automatically Generated Code
| 2024-02-03T05:24:39 | 2024-06-07T09:21:21 |
Dong Huang, Yuhao Qing, Weiyi Shang, Heming Cui, Jie M. Zhang
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL
|
Code generation models have increasingly become integral to aiding software
development. Although current research has thoroughly examined the correctness
of the code produced by code generation models, a vital aspect that plays a
pivotal role in green computing and sustainability efforts has often been
neglected. This paper presents EffiBench, a benchmark with 1,000
efficiency-critical coding problems to assess the efficiency of code generated
by code generation models. EffiBench contains a diverse set of LeetCode coding
problems. Each problem is paired with an executable human-written canonical
solution, which obtains the SOTA efficiency on the LeetCode solution
leaderboard. With EffiBench, we empirically examine the ability of 42 large
language models (35 open-source and 7 closed-source) to generate efficient
code. Our evaluation results demonstrate that the efficiency of the code
generated by LLMs is generally worse than the efficiency of human-written
canonical solutions. For example, GPT-4 generated code has an average
\textbf{3.12} times execution time that of the human-written canonical
solutions. In the most extreme cases, the execution time and total memory usage
of GPT-4 generated code are \textbf{13.89} and \textbf{43.92} times that of the
canonical solutions. The source code of EffiBench is released on
https://github.com/huangd1999/EffiBench. We also provide the LeaderBoard at
https://huggingface.co/spaces/EffiBench/effibench-leaderboard.
|
[
-0.1573581547,
-0.6041392684,
0.3945419788,
0.155610919,
-0.1367644817,
0.0069544916,
-0.3827961385,
-0.187937513,
-0.0884552747,
0.0886683613,
-0.4266299307,
-0.5226467252,
-0.1188092455,
0.2062525153,
-0.4454756379,
0.7570054531,
-0.0422485583,
0.0120694013,
-0.2128893435,
-0.0952456966,
-0.2086507231,
-0.2698863745,
-0.3936454952,
-0.0932033882,
0.0932153463,
0.5338201523,
0.4998679459,
0.5319408774,
0.6363658905,
0.3365114629,
0.3054957092,
-0.0616868809,
-0.9016349316,
0.254470855,
-0.1855260581,
-0.1029762253,
-0.3761554956,
-0.0549867749,
0.4258754253,
0.2102027684,
-0.5480307937,
0.6912254095,
0.2326978594,
0.7313043475,
-0.6196584105,
-0.0381923653,
-0.6514336467,
-0.010761112,
-0.1141827628,
-0.3100275099,
-0.2454604656,
-0.8727970719,
-0.6142168641,
-0.4361575842,
0.1410473436,
0.1586247534,
0.9113343954,
0.5321635008,
0.0896783248,
-0.5062611699,
-0.5130960345,
0.6815254092,
-0.6475986838,
0.3509613276,
0.0519126058,
0.2938193977,
-0.1300665587,
-0.7262624502,
-0.6219927669,
-0.5275699496,
0.2191000581,
0.2170615494,
-0.4965955019,
-0.1178260595,
0.6695305705,
0.513864994,
-0.8757243752,
0.0034718381,
-0.3026501238,
-0.1168487892,
0.7127370834,
0.0630935952,
0.3012732267,
-0.4437524676,
-0.2697167993,
-0.255509764,
-0.6568434834,
-0.2973454893,
0.5940589309,
-0.2551442385,
0.0538598113,
0.5706638694,
-0.0242314842,
0.6125311852,
-0.0820153579,
-0.0394273289,
0.3034134805,
-0.4593619108,
-0.2359774411,
-0.296353668,
0.568719089,
0.7162146568,
0.3095106184,
-0.1543801278,
-0.3560355902,
0.241104126,
0.3831317425,
-1.1004986763,
-0.563546598,
0.178702116,
-0.407243073,
-0.3367807269,
0.0538523048,
-0.6172995567,
-0.0201107617,
-0.053705398,
0.0624953471,
-0.1910624802,
-0.5025439858,
-0.2182596624,
-0.1547585875,
0.3820394576,
0.0448733419,
-0.2761799991,
0.1799212843,
0.7430738807,
0.9775107503,
-0.1290676445,
-0.0319289044,
-0.7867094278,
-0.0696958527,
-0.305428803,
0.6829725504,
-0.1673364192,
-0.4678767025,
-0.1564114988,
-0.1298493445,
0.2339279652,
-0.7483747602,
0.652756691,
-0.4317925572,
-0.580571115,
-0.3261724114,
-0.870397687,
0.0989908054,
-0.0405844487,
-0.8207019567,
1.3084340096,
0.2304625809,
-0.6525875926,
0.3102164268,
-0.5365425944,
-0.0948858708,
0.3099853992,
-0.361925602,
-0.5324739814,
0.2859515846,
-0.5996136069,
0.4292271137,
-0.5659410357,
0.5492219329,
-0.2587812245,
-0.295486033,
-0.0492902249,
-0.1326644421,
0.8208806515,
0.750433445,
-0.6534873843,
-0.0235962532,
-0.9194345474,
0.5733946562,
0.2851945758,
-0.4840283096,
-0.0957713798,
-0.1803687066,
0.2886796594,
0.0815530568,
0.0359505415,
-0.5133630633,
-0.2237690538,
0.2390844822,
0.3033480942,
0.8963312507,
-0.1357676089,
0.0193141624,
-0.3088166416,
0.6708419919,
-0.5609294176,
-0.1605247855,
-0.0078324378,
-0.2749121487,
-0.6425899863,
-0.1287733614,
0.4350293279,
0.454090029,
-0.5989139676,
0.4384346902,
-0.2771388292,
-0.6736525893,
-0.1656797379,
0.3841610849,
0.6339203119,
0.2513351738,
-0.0063854856,
-0.3084553778,
-0.3830800653,
-1.0050139427,
-0.5114573836,
-0.1685713232,
0.0806634575,
0.4348741472,
0.633800149,
-0.14499937,
0.6136061549,
-0.6709586382,
0.4817322195,
-0.0990013778,
0.0183754433,
0.1605395079,
0.6585556865,
0.6094850302,
-0.5975369811,
-0.7247799039,
-0.0829088166,
-0.7352618575,
-0.4686049521,
-0.1769844443,
-0.3938542604,
0.2679540813,
0.7261599302,
-0.1939027011,
0.1464339793,
0.8010468483,
-0.2101593614,
0.6855681539,
-0.4998357892,
0.1818404347,
-0.658305347,
0.6829458475,
-0.1066873223,
-0.4314188361,
-0.3763726354,
0.739539206,
0.3213408291,
-0.280549109,
-0.0809097216,
0.0551633574,
-0.6225688457,
-0.2780845165,
0.0402089171,
0.2006646097,
-0.0895914286,
0.3499310613,
-0.3900125325,
1.0120987892,
-0.0006666891,
-0.5353105068,
0.4692576528,
-0.3639826477,
-0.5446811318,
0.4761502445,
-0.8319634795,
0.4911406636,
0.3026184738,
0.0822927579,
-0.7962833643,
-0.3059574962,
-0.1520495862,
-0.1522005498,
0.2333756834,
0.3396635652,
-0.8706635833,
-0.5158970952,
-0.4321833849,
0.2401579022,
0.7884276509,
-0.5687301159,
0.2698635757,
0.3096816838,
-0.1812423766,
-0.1319191754,
-0.5829609632,
0.0285079814,
-0.1391871721,
-0.707460463,
0.2828440964,
-0.3790885508,
-0.2743653357,
0.1172574759,
-0.2504262626,
0.0700867102,
0.4274387658,
0.068148002,
-0.0111811226,
-0.0094710495,
0.1949140131,
-0.1901736408,
-0.3096472621,
0.0025186562,
-0.1256847978,
0.5433998704,
-0.3685696125,
-0.5302321911,
-0.1584614664,
0.426904887,
0.2077587545,
-0.0276951119,
0.4031962156,
0.2221834958,
-0.2535158098,
-0.3231525123,
-0.6826441288,
0.2906578481,
-0.4614908993,
0.5047238469,
-0.4402064979,
-0.4813579619,
0.4591066241,
-0.3680218458,
0.3426527083,
0.6279022694,
0.5501292944,
0.2771416008,
0.6823268533,
0.6856400371,
0.2941952944,
0.4642440081,
-0.3637531102,
0.1784299761,
-0.4696494341,
0.0092599224,
-0.6378462315,
-0.1353832483,
-0.7240565419,
-0.5502400398,
0.2872965932,
0.4039539993,
-0.4525648654,
0.564432025,
-0.750766933,
0.715413034,
0.4744879305,
-0.0767649412,
0.4355953038,
-0.1667186618,
-0.2731357515,
0.0840810686,
-0.7957558632,
-0.6077060103,
1.046512723,
0.0791562423,
0.68470186,
0.2187541425,
1.0440801382,
0.38648808,
0.4284933209,
-0.2764359713,
0.5490766764,
-0.0142355906,
-0.491915673,
0.037186563,
-0.7144101858,
-0.5029338002,
0.0221960358,
0.2382930517,
-0.2714830041,
0.0242896471,
0.3526871204,
-0.4695709646,
0.1953093261,
-0.9309541583,
1.0663262606,
-0.4644968808,
-0.9230419397,
-0.458457917,
-0.2196507156,
0.2820622623,
-0.2818921804,
0.3103655577,
0.0298312679,
0.0424069464,
0.6050677896,
-0.7932892442,
0.343157202,
-0.4937878847,
-0.2134745866,
0.4372208118,
0.0858896598,
0.7367757559,
-0.1944355369,
-0.4027162194,
0.0265081991,
-0.2279386669,
-0.412853539,
-0.2303648591,
0.9334391952,
-0.4354142547,
-0.3892493248,
-0.2938691378,
0.1435865164,
0.3211779892,
0.1989818662,
0.5607073307,
0.3786001503,
-0.5319946408,
0.1052989885,
0.4124108553,
-0.4817541242,
0.4420063198,
0.3764530122,
-0.3030834496,
-0.1815329045,
1.0509388447,
0.2813971341,
0.4805753827,
-0.2935983837,
0.0160976686,
0.0155140497,
-0.4088332653,
-0.6647142172,
-0.1262539774,
-0.8856146336,
-0.5578068495,
-0.6202984452,
-0.1119569093,
0.1012834087,
-0.4256952107,
-0.3101601005,
-0.3022741675,
0.0863991752,
-0.2270614058,
0.3260605335,
0.911762774,
-0.4891889691,
-0.0785204321,
-0.5911776423,
0.3465040028,
0.2374559045,
0.4876326621,
0.1469265819,
-0.0133543182,
-0.4005381167,
-0.2334686071,
-0.6263000369,
-0.8887683749,
0.1837900281,
0.3834627867,
0.7391580343,
0.1551539898,
0.1822032034,
0.6636558771,
-0.471901238,
0.6974661946,
0.3714355826,
-1.073623538,
0.4222195745,
-0.1281598061,
0.3258618116,
0.7305498123,
-0.0360635892,
-0.22239694,
-0.478380084,
-0.8303535581,
-0.9355450273,
0.4390825629,
0.3953555822,
-0.1361510903,
-0.1862078756,
0.1837042868,
0.1791294664,
0.1724095941,
-0.5690140128,
-0.093773663,
-0.2910263836,
-0.0897153392,
-0.0464639291,
-0.2021957636,
0.1541177183,
-0.1087868363,
0.560885787,
-0.1370851994,
0.2281902283,
0.1192878261,
-0.5157043934,
-0.2292260081,
0.2638453543,
0.4838626683,
0.6076295376,
-0.0993225276,
-0.0146790827,
0.140557602,
-0.3101110756,
0.0891588107,
-0.0063557341,
-0.0221750978,
-0.0301949997,
0.1980819255,
0.3239878416,
0.255600214,
-0.7280409336,
0.4670629799,
-0.1454123706,
-0.2394958138,
-0.4317710698,
0.2695762813,
0.3598071337,
0.1777087152,
0.2999835312,
0.1100367978,
0.5101667643,
-0.3998456597,
0.2155820727,
0.4046392143,
0.2678967714,
-0.1270544082,
0.6616025567,
0.664901495,
-0.3056970537,
0.6433034539,
-0.7023714781,
-0.5952031612,
0.9411101937,
0.497309655,
1.2120423317,
0.0038175113,
-0.0273330659,
0.8016195893,
0.0988105983,
0.0005196749,
0.4559081793,
-0.3905279338,
-0.2200734764,
-0.2882279456,
-0.7879573703,
-0.3102253675,
-0.4655413926,
-0.6911663413,
0.1278560013,
-0.5018862486,
-0.2822072804,
-0.0716155767,
0.0881773382,
-0.9261327386,
-0.2979545295,
0.0547988676,
0.9242997169,
-0.685878396,
0.4614320695,
0.5905325413,
-0.1553037018,
-0.9469824433,
0.0714402199,
0.0333851539,
-0.6008383036,
0.6980800033,
0.3194336593,
-0.5643241405,
0.3123410642,
-0.6286195517,
-0.6446963549,
1.1250289679,
0.5600160956,
-0.9294828176,
0.2873396873,
-0.4015669227,
0.3301454484,
-0.2129732817,
0.4345595241,
0.6216818094,
0.5216203928,
-0.2088120282,
-1.0021495819,
0.2450125068,
-0.7168232203,
0.3483766615,
0.0901077762,
-0.8450317383,
0.7117203474,
-0.4149660468,
-0.7507684231,
0.2568956912,
0.2531351149,
0.3149810433,
-0.0399718955,
0.4681605995,
0.7207983136,
1.0683987141,
-0.0319313519,
1.2822332382,
-0.8430230021,
0.7016482949,
0.7387433648,
-0.4107625186,
0.8498213291,
0.1277327687,
-0.4001170397,
0.5944277644,
0.4897455573,
-0.1928070635,
0.447502166,
0.6769672036,
0.0743635744,
-0.3542494178,
0.1557750851,
-0.6823741198,
0.0519310273,
-0.1248905063,
-0.2029889524,
-0.3818206489,
-0.3575260341,
0.0603778325,
0.0497793444,
-0.040095523,
0.7104282975,
0.0846719444,
-0.688421607,
0.8691452146,
0.0400925688,
0.6366235614,
-0.3417063951,
-0.1453109682,
-0.0758622512,
0.5362917185,
-0.4008461237,
-0.3664710224,
0.3208498955,
0.4848896265,
-0.0056031076,
-0.2432207316,
0.520313859,
-0.0501265638,
-0.5431833267,
0.4002223909,
0.6005247235,
0.3032487035,
0.1999881268,
-0.714546144,
0.2364327908,
0.2765630782,
-0.3473354578,
0.0786871389,
0.3188386858,
0.3312984705,
0.3855649233,
0.6249314547,
-0.0900755152,
0.1545853764,
-0.0383026339,
1.0124161243,
-0.7824692726,
-0.609813869,
-0.9054989219,
0.3602564037,
-0.4618418515,
-0.3412237465,
0.9318017364,
0.8344775438,
0.8449153304,
-0.016982872,
0.8219508529,
-0.3987163305,
0.3667549789,
-0.464987874,
0.6847348213,
-0.7197810411,
0.3524914682,
-0.5016565323,
-1.1886523962,
0.1096748337,
0.7593423724,
-0.0012180465,
0.3055191338,
0.7817666531,
0.8680984378,
0.0822545663,
0.1216332614,
0.2228186429,
0.0920554996,
0.2336643189,
0.6352801323,
0.8310524821,
-0.1066545472,
0.3918388784,
-0.1921498924,
-0.570638001,
-0.4156563282,
-1.1954188347,
-0.3918026388,
-0.1671311855,
-0.3501620293,
-0.2037689239,
0.1767524183,
0.9208647013,
0.5262797475,
-0.7206321359,
-0.3669860363,
-0.6168559194,
-0.1300506145,
-0.2080925554,
-0.2025309205,
0.3303680718,
-0.4804332256,
-0.4362860322,
-0.0123335924,
0.0996389464,
-0.3042757213,
-0.3889841437,
-0.2595520318,
0.164427951,
-0.141845271,
0.3366941512,
0.1585199237,
-0.3117326796,
-0.0415163934,
0.0994290859,
-0.4011428356,
-0.1267161667,
0.9112778306,
-0.4725168943,
0.3637283146,
0.561147809,
0.5281662941,
0.4786222577,
0.1848596036,
0.6819454432,
-0.4108594954,
-0.3503566384,
0.0908002928,
0.3723761141,
0.4060802162,
-0.322981745,
0.7543138266,
0.1494680196,
-0.8838369846,
-0.9289078116,
0.1406577379,
-0.4692180455,
-0.2376782149,
1.2308340073,
-0.3845698237,
-0.2261938006,
-0.0019214728,
0.0548672117,
0.1318234354,
-0.4793857336,
0.3643577397,
0.5820919275,
-0.1398478001,
0.2327963859,
-0.8673362136,
0.4239151478,
0.5054706931,
-0.8564351797,
0.3789219856,
0.7359080315,
0.4178752601,
0.2486365587,
0.8793349266,
0.0862083435,
0.5108938813,
0.528652966,
0.4145447612,
-0.1171355993,
-0.0538647398,
-0.2976818979,
0.1664096415,
0.3468607962,
0.0924493521
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02030v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02030v2
|
Panacea: Pareto Alignment via Preference Adaptation for LLMs
| 2024-02-03T05:01:04 | 2024-05-23T13:49:25 |
Yifan Zhong, Chengdong Ma, Xiaoyuan Zhang, Ziran Yang, Haojun Chen, Qingfu Zhang, Siyuan Qi, Yaodong Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Current methods for large language model alignment typically use scalar human
preference labels. However, this convention tends to oversimplify the
multi-dimensional and heterogeneous nature of human preferences, leading to
reduced expressivity and even misalignment. This paper presents Panacea, an
innovative approach that reframes alignment as a multi-dimensional preference
optimization problem. Panacea trains a single model capable of adapting online
and Pareto-optimally to diverse sets of preferences without the need for
further tuning. A major challenge here is using a low-dimensional preference
vector to guide the model's behavior, despite it being governed by an
overwhelmingly large number of parameters. To address this, Panacea is designed
to use singular value decomposition (SVD)-based low-rank adaptation, which
allows the preference vector to be simply injected online as singular values.
Theoretically, we prove that Panacea recovers the entire Pareto front with
common loss aggregation methods under mild conditions. Moreover, our
experiments demonstrate, for the first time, the feasibility of aligning a
single LLM to represent an exponentially vast spectrum of human preferences
through various optimization methods. Our work marks a step forward in
effectively and efficiently aligning models to diverse and intricate human
preferences in a controllable and Pareto-optimal manner.
|
[
-0.4569428861,
-0.4474812448,
0.6067239642,
0.3515670896,
-0.2652482688,
0.057958547,
-0.285353452,
-0.0115946578,
0.536945641,
0.4906845093,
-0.3419634998,
-0.4233728051,
-0.441704303,
-0.1829502434,
0.2608934939,
0.9859496951,
0.1581092626,
0.2130236775,
-0.3192498088,
-0.4330239892,
-0.4772517681,
-0.5213286877,
-0.2509846091,
-0.2346969545,
0.7604736686,
0.6020810008,
0.8255194426,
0.8320198059,
0.4742032588,
0.2046819329,
0.0529721044,
0.1209990904,
-0.5952678919,
-0.0699771643,
-0.3368658721,
-0.5307014585,
-0.7866993546,
0.0162907969,
0.4073116183,
0.8179675341,
-0.2429154515,
0.1330663413,
0.109630391,
0.8259856105,
-0.9329330325,
-0.2886630595,
-0.7258601785,
0.0537408367,
-0.3285574317,
-0.0911919028,
-0.222295776,
-0.5841790438,
0.1368021071,
-0.6539285779,
-0.1054835469,
-0.1317561269,
0.7680247426,
0.3678452671,
-0.4176410735,
-0.1539911479,
-0.7969239354,
0.8589126468,
-0.6991513968,
0.3611033261,
0.0373080745,
0.3581928909,
-0.1543894857,
-0.1691874713,
-0.4067182243,
0.2999449968,
0.4111249149,
0.194996044,
-0.161916256,
-0.1909476072,
-0.2897565067,
0.1175560579,
-0.3294706643,
0.5408915877,
-0.1789709628,
-0.0188328046,
0.3416335881,
0.2013631612,
0.254524231,
0.0918417051,
-0.8238274455,
-0.1584511399,
-0.6247833371,
0.3951770365,
0.33062011,
0.650949955,
-0.1348797977,
0.5431394577,
0.240712598,
0.7513241172,
0.3423371315,
-0.4082638323,
0.1539383531,
0.0582327247,
-0.2694237232,
0.3115569949,
0.5120867491,
0.748408854,
-0.1900364757,
-0.0040014652,
0.0319125317,
0.3523750901,
0.4544291794,
-0.3909478188,
-0.0493497029,
0.1439915001,
-0.3265785575,
-0.2896747291,
-0.2077494711,
-1.2337348461,
-0.7554209232,
-0.6375085115,
0.4886116982,
-0.0433317907,
0.115398325,
0.4250645638,
0.1197564527,
0.5776327848,
0.448430419,
-1.0515043736,
0.2300012261,
0.8544311523,
0.8398237824,
-0.358322084,
-0.4767387509,
-0.6277564168,
0.311024487,
-0.2819882035,
0.9810894728,
-0.7498665452,
-0.1430181712,
-0.2623257637,
-0.2793627083,
-0.0688260198,
-0.4759041369,
0.5812630057,
-0.3461754322,
0.2961319983,
-0.6234346628,
-0.4053194523,
0.1367818266,
0.2296646088,
-0.544764936,
0.6111050248,
-0.1175878495,
-0.8128042817,
0.4148721695,
-0.8199563026,
-0.0105902525,
-0.3089970052,
-0.020442877,
-0.6283813715,
0.2799966931,
0.4191626012,
0.4230273366,
-0.285404563,
0.0870090052,
-0.9769280553,
-0.1427182406,
0.2309584171,
-0.1125440076,
0.7571436763,
0.0562104061,
-0.0847711042,
0.2903197408,
-0.4689648151,
-0.3501546681,
0.0323885307,
-0.3896517754,
-0.6231276989,
0.1619840115,
-0.1717033833,
0.1578624994,
0.6013599038,
-0.3654336035,
0.6206041574,
-0.3881685436,
0.2896489799,
1.2329972982,
-0.1710925102,
0.8153603673,
-0.243573755,
0.5118509531,
0.01856401,
0.4298889041,
0.5654399991,
-0.2384876311,
-0.8025465012,
-0.5577976108,
0.13038221,
0.5313181877,
-0.3422368765,
0.5038065314,
-0.4963095486,
-0.4436460733,
-0.6465551257,
0.1678736508,
0.0631648973,
0.5678431988,
0.3414090276,
-0.194338575,
-0.4795129001,
-1.3085802794,
-0.320967257,
0.1054149345,
-0.0108440621,
0.2476654053,
-0.1185818538,
-0.4431988299,
1.1418133974,
-0.7142432332,
-0.38891837,
-0.1037398428,
-0.1313762516,
0.2532076836,
0.2399511039,
0.6748177409,
-0.5318086147,
-0.5272353888,
0.2481386662,
-0.2633013427,
-0.2331553847,
-0.0632553324,
-0.5258173943,
-0.0135607729,
0.0321151875,
-0.2394847125,
0.0529185645,
0.6041776538,
-0.1922899783,
0.1331203431,
-0.3406811953,
-0.1578543633,
-1.4291288853,
-0.0240142103,
0.0708779767,
-0.2203785628,
-0.6401751637,
-0.2180830091,
0.1927903891,
-0.0915259495,
-0.542275548,
0.3552334011,
-0.2318520397,
-0.4537094235,
-0.3419526815,
0.2530684471,
0.0836578235,
0.634899199,
-0.1662762463,
0.7629600763,
0.5109528899,
-0.4977552593,
0.23856695,
0.4045798779,
0.1290025264,
0.954575479,
-0.238224104,
0.22394903,
-0.4568771422,
0.2132298052,
-0.8161550164,
-0.0848368406,
0.2999890447,
0.0102562988,
0.0045666066,
-0.1102862731,
0.0778376833,
0.167243883,
-0.6649320722,
0.2040210068,
0.2604470253,
-0.7685163021,
0.7405775785,
0.7523202896,
-0.4119964838,
-0.6883648634,
-0.2060619593,
0.0913210213,
-0.6670045853,
-0.2456223667,
0.3832828999,
-0.3243511319,
-0.2552884221,
-0.3392611146,
-0.0912113041,
0.1409007907,
0.0138737876,
0.0941271111,
0.509968102,
-0.147058621,
-0.0552407093,
0.307770133,
-0.245787859,
-0.3834073842,
-0.2068804353,
0.5895636678,
-0.3500026762,
-0.1840819269,
-0.1588239819,
0.4388133585,
1.0426950455,
-0.1999589354,
0.4900069237,
0.4743596315,
-0.263880372,
-0.0509651192,
-0.5717824697,
0.1018905193,
-0.4290099144,
0.1822457761,
-0.3570175767,
-0.6923795938,
0.6731902361,
-0.2510695755,
0.1253977716,
0.3258660436,
0.7279641032,
-0.0932082385,
1.0309566259,
0.6460656524,
-0.4153598547,
0.3247839808,
0.2175327241,
0.2627835274,
-0.9477316737,
-0.0681661367,
-0.6719706059,
-0.6933642626,
-0.402572453,
-0.3745503426,
0.7198505402,
0.2206116468,
-0.4340723753,
0.2370059192,
-0.5409250855,
0.6383517385,
0.4206689,
0.3065883219,
0.0115739126,
-0.0993397608,
0.0392654911,
-0.3041636944,
-0.6112646461,
-0.5794408917,
1.0326690674,
0.368632108,
0.690197289,
0.3021246791,
0.6547712684,
0.1618987024,
0.3833127022,
-0.7183184028,
0.290245682,
-0.5415309668,
-0.1579744071,
-0.3795425296,
-0.226654321,
-0.8984971046,
0.5046135187,
-0.3076013923,
-0.7583950758,
0.6683052182,
0.2075335234,
-0.61000067,
0.3113078475,
-0.7308260202,
0.9750746489,
-0.5568611026,
-0.431145519,
0.0933246613,
-0.6869028807,
0.3915654719,
-0.2149357647,
0.2773168385,
-0.3004670143,
-0.4092170596,
0.5626496673,
-0.2979889512,
0.9982005358,
-0.3083922267,
-0.222118482,
-0.5971562266,
-0.0867730379,
0.7135956883,
-0.0278634038,
-0.0429916196,
0.0389197096,
0.0681217089,
-0.7261001468,
-0.5816120505,
1.0512679815,
-1.0898224115,
-0.4811671078,
-0.4118329585,
-0.5246055126,
-0.5293933153,
0.1566459388,
0.0345232673,
0.0006420101,
-0.14452748,
0.0127810994,
0.6213853955,
-0.3799660802,
0.3641858399,
0.2109843642,
-0.2247800529,
-0.7872544527,
1.0395810604,
-0.1308483034,
0.2183824778,
0.4419707358,
0.5280522108,
-0.3814909756,
-0.3861072659,
-0.4334063828,
0.1582542956,
-0.6331579089,
-0.2353093773,
-0.4632982612,
0.4203149974,
-0.4097206593,
-0.7514420152,
-0.7050617337,
-0.1917675883,
-0.528219223,
0.0884232894,
0.0771502107,
0.412396282,
0.0654992238,
0.1835395992,
-0.6372897029,
0.5017264485,
0.6838365197,
0.4856032133,
-0.3355334699,
-0.2219535261,
-0.0437527038,
0.042640429,
-0.175551936,
-0.9437266588,
0.5381315351,
0.0907894,
0.5469623208,
0.5960272551,
0.2460696846,
0.9771046042,
-0.4370603859,
0.5285103917,
0.3152861595,
-1.1472911835,
0.2962520719,
-0.2483632714,
0.2322556973,
0.7032942176,
0.181871146,
-0.4629523158,
0.1473689824,
-0.0613812506,
-0.8297331929,
0.6721051931,
-0.1810968369,
0.0769414082,
0.3081287444,
0.3314755559,
0.5603747964,
0.0082756961,
-0.7260969877,
-0.124680005,
-0.4716194272,
-0.1865589023,
-0.1661433876,
-0.2157833427,
-0.4229735434,
-0.1632232368,
0.6736850142,
-0.4151102901,
0.2399777323,
-0.1349585056,
0.0264079478,
-0.0746177658,
0.4436402321,
1.0851664543,
0.7718679309,
-0.3644695878,
0.3277036548,
0.1235630065,
-0.0984767601,
0.276437372,
-0.1021294296,
0.0696686059,
-0.4702029526,
-0.1522085667,
0.9557318687,
0.2665840685,
-0.3964659274,
0.5972568989,
-0.093554534,
-0.0220052674,
-0.0478595383,
-0.2326964587,
0.2458584607,
0.3593877852,
0.1775911897,
0.2767888606,
-0.1037192121,
-0.3412445188,
-0.1599738002,
0.604393661,
-0.3700024784,
-0.252286464,
0.6091239452,
0.1773742437,
-0.2828944325,
0.0546108447,
0.1409299374,
-0.4714125395,
0.1508732587,
0.5017887354,
1.0385299921,
-0.3132233024,
0.2648516595,
-0.1703434736,
0.2391616851,
-0.0227427874,
0.0851926506,
0.2504020035,
-0.9621523023,
-0.1766555011,
-0.7708348036,
-0.5700883865,
-0.0584129319,
-0.7674224973,
0.2589724362,
-0.5796573162,
-0.069335565,
0.2386941612,
-0.2393336147,
-0.3906420171,
-0.2389241904,
0.0516726784,
0.3362794518,
-1.2275574207,
0.8244857788,
0.7790779471,
-0.1421025693,
-0.3991027772,
-0.0240362342,
0.0162849147,
-0.758107841,
0.1387506723,
-0.1887831539,
-0.1041167378,
-0.1101564765,
-0.4913504422,
-0.8484892845,
1.0517836809,
0.9799880981,
-0.4998633862,
0.1216373965,
0.3508495986,
0.3855581582,
-0.5892894864,
-0.2958420217,
0.5270960331,
0.664506793,
-0.030889675,
-0.8537662625,
-0.2124523222,
-0.0218581483,
0.2742858529,
0.3285041749,
-0.7127072811,
0.8577820659,
0.0993083343,
0.1143933684,
-0.2872334421,
0.3501064181,
0.2605041265,
0.2844849229,
0.6492453218,
0.727442503,
0.7106531262,
0.1592113972,
0.687959373,
-0.1797652543,
0.4451080263,
1.0988063812,
-0.6632612944,
0.8942987323,
0.9216430783,
-0.306962043,
0.3165563643,
0.6719238162,
0.3485342264,
0.5837312341,
-0.1187845916,
-0.1116726622,
-0.6022742391,
-0.0077130189,
-0.2594053447,
0.5283473134,
0.2208555043,
-0.0281491391,
-0.4136242568,
0.2768406272,
-0.098762989,
0.1680247784,
-0.3300769329,
0.899966836,
-0.2334155738,
-0.4983352125,
0.6039735079,
0.0973302871,
0.6145174503,
-0.3116389215,
0.214852795,
-0.4168968201,
0.3561127782,
-0.0482484289,
-0.1806090176,
0.0787781999,
-0.3350279033,
-0.4272472262,
-0.164716959,
0.455891192,
-0.4446199834,
-0.5776167512,
0.0605460294,
0.2818222642,
-0.1866404712,
0.0497362539,
-0.7261206508,
0.3260261118,
0.0839848742,
0.0409925207,
0.7595476508,
0.0176459625,
-0.1296093464,
0.5630885363,
0.6404545307,
0.0776350498,
0.14075692,
-0.2699699402,
0.9312327504,
-0.5425786972,
-0.6593008041,
-0.7295891047,
0.3425472677,
0.0107913027,
-0.2457103729,
0.5529616475,
0.6366022229,
0.5169968605,
-0.2313726395,
0.7191007137,
0.4692749977,
0.532841146,
-0.4718919396,
0.4252754152,
-0.4611524343,
0.5898254514,
-0.3555086851,
-1.265291214,
-0.5552657247,
0.5058425069,
-0.3451444805,
-0.4893542826,
0.4394937754,
0.7199999094,
-0.363103956,
-0.3093239963,
0.2873710692,
0.0467925221,
0.3494455814,
0.6975201368,
0.4566063881,
0.0485534742,
0.1812230498,
-0.2433577329,
-0.421105206,
-0.3499414027,
-0.9634611011,
-0.472146064,
-0.4736793041,
-0.1876037866,
-0.0342240334,
-0.035614647,
1.2737693787,
0.5030907989,
-0.7821817398,
-0.3347040117,
0.1519868821,
0.1795459539,
-0.2782276869,
-0.196894899,
0.5532363057,
-0.2234904915,
-0.9182872176,
0.5554156303,
0.7384470701,
0.053565558,
-0.4107659459,
-0.3125898838,
-0.2464492321,
0.2583424747,
0.5621964931,
0.3512731791,
-0.8890696764,
-0.3772237897,
-0.0358018875,
-0.1708131582,
0.4006766081,
0.8361079097,
-0.5210535526,
0.6939965487,
0.4929829836,
0.8600600958,
0.2945517004,
0.2227407098,
0.6945767999,
-0.5501123667,
-0.0248596761,
0.1514720917,
0.3371365964,
0.2344018966,
-0.2914840281,
-0.0615945533,
0.0071306271,
-0.5142449141,
-0.8494691849,
0.2124275565,
-1.5276199579,
-0.3742026985,
0.8850796223,
-0.0470686518,
-0.1511594504,
-0.1180827245,
-0.4074342251,
0.0546338968,
-0.4517443776,
1.1456170082,
0.438641876,
-0.2373318821,
-0.1266942918,
-0.0289697554,
0.2447386384,
0.5539823771,
-0.9455359578,
0.2527762949,
0.6280710697,
0.2292657793,
0.1457483619,
0.4292365015,
0.0160046015,
-0.0362587869,
-0.5742500424,
0.2770056129,
0.1765601635,
-0.196023494,
-0.6943180561,
0.5101692677,
0.2135854661,
-0.3337825239
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05119v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05119v4
|
A Closer Look at the Limitations of Instruction Tuning
| 2024-02-03T04:45:25 | 2024-05-28T01:55:38 |
Sreyan Ghosh, Chandra Kiran Reddy Evuru, Sonal Kumar, Ramaneswaran S, Deepali Aneja, Zeyu Jin, Ramani Duraiswami, Dinesh Manocha
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Instruction Tuning (IT), the process of training large language models (LLMs)
using instruction-response pairs, has emerged as the predominant method for
transforming base pre-trained LLMs into open-domain conversational agents.
While IT has achieved notable success and widespread adoption, its limitations
and shortcomings remain underexplored. In this paper, through rigorous
experiments and an in-depth analysis of the changes LLMs undergo through IT, we
reveal various limitations of IT. In particular, we show that (1) IT fails to
enhance knowledge or skills in LLMs. LoRA fine-tuning is limited to learning
response initiation and style tokens, and full-parameter fine-tuning leads to
knowledge degradation. (2) Copying response patterns from IT datasets derived
from knowledgeable sources leads to a decline in response quality. (3)
Full-parameter fine-tuning increases hallucination by inaccurately borrowing
tokens from conceptually similar instances in the IT dataset for generating
responses. (4) Popular methods to improve IT do not lead to performance
improvements over a simple LoRA fine-tuned model. Our findings reveal that
responses generated solely from pre-trained knowledge consistently outperform
responses by models that learn any form of new knowledge from IT on open-source
datasets. We hope the insights and challenges revealed in this paper inspire
future work in related directions.
|
[
-0.4416137636,
-0.9394417405,
0.4030930996,
-0.1910575032,
-0.0916220546,
-0.0148926685,
-0.549841702,
-0.518856287,
-0.1128482968,
0.7907981277,
-0.5880178809,
-0.4122435451,
-0.5877569914,
-0.027208792,
-0.3706667721,
1.1831969023,
0.1177622974,
0.0208001938,
-0.2033122331,
-0.0492565185,
-0.5210469961,
-0.333674252,
-0.6515641809,
-0.3074837923,
0.3854851723,
0.8998725414,
0.5581168532,
0.7636501789,
0.5023859739,
0.3323837817,
0.0682650879,
0.5076500177,
-0.8221013546,
-0.0746053755,
0.1065268889,
-0.7256478071,
-0.4058321714,
0.1219561249,
0.7295368314,
0.8178706765,
-0.1426530182,
0.1806512028,
0.2327366769,
0.8626150489,
-0.7789478302,
0.0700506046,
-1.0000225306,
-0.1567013711,
-0.0990728512,
-0.4019974768,
-0.578959167,
-0.3782712817,
0.1065159366,
-0.6003364921,
0.225941211,
-0.0286929719,
0.8516463041,
0.6861477494,
-0.1690442115,
-0.5807621479,
-0.9716058373,
0.7195334435,
-0.9482800961,
0.0776764452,
0.4980580211,
0.2786291838,
-0.2112122625,
-0.3339737058,
-0.3704580069,
-0.2743853927,
0.0994308218,
-0.1923140138,
0.050761167,
0.1181977615,
0.4681797922,
0.4509205818,
-0.156951651,
0.4317428768,
-0.7506918311,
0.0931344554,
0.4427773356,
0.3751347363,
0.0597603247,
0.1479670703,
-0.2343018055,
-0.1847294718,
-0.9269612432,
0.3968163729,
0.5793997645,
0.5345777273,
0.1430151314,
0.6483664513,
-0.0196320917,
0.9305440784,
0.0877708271,
0.0038031028,
-0.1092721522,
0.0951902717,
-0.3095169365,
0.0484878607,
0.6445099711,
0.2689245939,
0.3647450805,
-0.1920149177,
-0.1988645047,
0.1101431325,
0.4077005982,
-0.6874296069,
0.1031130105,
0.0570931584,
0.0737216845,
-0.0449973196,
0.0709448829,
-0.5101209283,
-0.3723453879,
-0.4984619021,
0.4015858173,
-0.5222806931,
0.0400684401,
0.2408950329,
0.029655857,
0.4864690304,
0.1048998833,
-1.0736185312,
0.3011658192,
0.7811277509,
0.4672110677,
-0.2336942703,
-0.3033461869,
-0.6509302258,
-0.0479626618,
-0.56313169,
0.9237324595,
-0.8279835582,
-0.4897648394,
0.0290794242,
0.0279967207,
-0.3613342941,
-0.9902798533,
0.2125971764,
-0.7397880554,
-0.094213888,
-0.3307473063,
-0.7101014853,
0.229165256,
-0.0553679056,
-0.5965682864,
0.5833338499,
0.1323966831,
-0.4138877094,
0.2005954683,
-0.404258281,
-0.5823258758,
-0.2810251713,
-0.1495554894,
-0.3502321243,
0.4248738289,
-0.1274328977,
0.2140731961,
-0.423053354,
-0.1364669055,
-0.1141677871,
-0.8469147682,
0.3014127612,
-0.1618224382,
0.5007995367,
0.208851859,
-0.2843235135,
0.0799803138,
-0.9724057913,
0.3098329008,
-0.0694897994,
-0.6137476563,
-0.2126661092,
0.2005067021,
-0.6040215492,
-0.1015630513,
0.1394334137,
-0.2891925573,
0.3161655366,
-0.5603613257,
0.6547327638,
1.1122686863,
-0.3387665451,
0.5129145384,
-0.3792806268,
0.5221447945,
0.067559287,
0.0151909366,
-0.3430407941,
-0.1493725777,
-1.0518527031,
0.222819075,
0.1110260561,
0.5094123483,
-0.6951066852,
0.3148033917,
-0.3007202744,
-0.2082685828,
-0.9202455878,
0.2806823254,
0.4428398311,
0.5552585721,
0.3495317101,
-0.0957927182,
-0.3017650545,
-0.8476076126,
-0.3538714051,
0.1172712669,
0.1036643013,
0.3394011259,
0.2152232528,
0.0555518121,
0.533818841,
-0.3181965649,
-0.325017035,
0.0747400448,
0.0413596816,
0.1021539867,
0.3840197325,
0.1534973383,
-0.3422178626,
-0.4952834547,
0.1493671089,
-0.507835865,
0.0703692883,
0.152104497,
0.1470917165,
0.4652102888,
0.5539101958,
-0.329841733,
0.5344393253,
0.6456013918,
-0.1390497983,
0.3363925517,
-0.2059198022,
0.2669612169,
-0.9233597517,
-0.1848757565,
-0.2154117525,
0.2182213068,
-0.4896874726,
0.0828490332,
0.0280326717,
0.0014508058,
-0.2969937623,
0.3911811113,
-0.3509638309,
-0.1829000115,
-0.5253677964,
0.2359234542,
-0.2689724565,
0.629455328,
-0.2233614922,
1.1194932461,
0.3018806875,
-1.110511899,
0.3130362928,
0.2841757536,
-0.552986145,
0.5431492329,
-0.7874089479,
0.4873251021,
-0.0687548518,
-0.2323302478,
-0.7372437716,
-0.4175909758,
0.0895273387,
-0.2883625031,
0.5375329256,
0.0294262189,
-0.2911129296,
-0.224973321,
-0.2881443501,
0.123797372,
0.6426584721,
-0.5583635569,
0.463398546,
-0.0845348835,
0.1162346825,
-0.6799576879,
-0.5881592035,
-0.2647633553,
-0.0420533195,
-0.611340344,
0.1377308071,
-0.3025639355,
-0.2936223447,
0.0261213072,
-0.3507398069,
0.0242052153,
0.0940904394,
0.0868188664,
0.1444230527,
-0.5084325075,
0.2082699686,
0.0755273476,
0.0703455135,
0.0967803597,
-0.1548260897,
0.4819857478,
-0.2100939453,
-0.5439782739,
-0.4347153902,
0.2170174718,
0.5273485184,
-0.244781971,
0.9199723601,
0.3414563537,
0.1482692063,
-0.4385214448,
-0.4498777092,
-0.3782048821,
-0.5172677636,
0.4599755108,
-0.3051810563,
-0.9620437026,
0.3311698735,
-0.1157141849,
0.2029114515,
0.1576904356,
0.2328978181,
-0.1015242338,
1.0040053129,
0.7147259116,
0.1365111172,
0.6909750104,
-0.2526710331,
0.1753193885,
-0.9635577798,
-0.1301588118,
-0.7660358548,
-0.3405780792,
-0.8058158159,
-0.1034261733,
0.4286059141,
-0.0522227138,
-0.4460790157,
0.0043368274,
-0.4476040602,
0.7609350681,
0.6163799167,
0.3339733779,
0.4336182475,
0.2726531625,
0.3786924779,
0.0226399191,
-0.6252052784,
-0.5812593102,
1.1302779913,
0.0635123178,
1.1521770954,
-0.0395771675,
0.4859775901,
0.1080149189,
0.0250133555,
-0.9324450493,
0.6177201271,
-0.3931306899,
-0.3668918908,
-0.4735422134,
-0.5678452849,
-0.9498175383,
-0.2039905638,
-0.0344508067,
-0.6982465386,
-0.1435443163,
0.3644886017,
-0.3956434131,
0.4204994738,
-0.9719540477,
0.4887570143,
-0.2307746112,
-0.5434387922,
-0.1525083333,
-0.4897954464,
0.2295226008,
-0.0047434545,
-0.0155925145,
-0.0327563174,
0.1666820943,
0.601180613,
-0.4390826523,
0.9157620072,
-0.0857022926,
-0.5584961772,
0.2362030745,
-0.1441935003,
0.5957150459,
-0.3415342569,
-0.1351655871,
-0.2249583006,
-0.1018400714,
-0.6459031105,
-0.7141242027,
0.8902974129,
-1.0599298477,
-1.1532741785,
0.028742034,
-0.6171609759,
-0.7199417353,
0.0943031013,
0.3780993819,
0.4068839252,
0.0563874207,
0.29776752,
1.0879694223,
-0.329021275,
0.1054477319,
0.5712537169,
-0.0119963503,
-0.159896642,
1.0506137609,
0.164965108,
0.6966630816,
0.170828253,
0.0157624576,
0.1833928823,
-0.4938438237,
-0.3711670041,
0.147106424,
-0.7788761854,
-0.0594531745,
-0.158290863,
-0.2477747649,
-0.3931664228,
0.0607672259,
-0.4106967747,
-0.1731538177,
-0.6037917137,
0.0397876278,
0.24765715,
1.0552700758,
0.2120950371,
0.4342105687,
-0.5688877106,
0.1784303933,
0.4638313949,
0.5852031708,
-0.0737034082,
-0.7829450965,
-0.5408130884,
0.3086594939,
-0.2609985769,
-0.60499084,
-0.0509347096,
0.3762421608,
0.391313076,
0.4962839186,
0.0886728913,
0.7793696523,
-0.5907639265,
0.7351273298,
-0.3267271817,
-0.7355949879,
0.6315348744,
-0.1992219388,
0.2999765873,
0.3436737657,
0.264719516,
0.1172414944,
-0.4112020731,
-0.2708658576,
-0.780596137,
1.0309690237,
-0.2587373555,
0.556651473,
0.0479631014,
0.5391201973,
0.2442116588,
0.2257912457,
-0.2354610115,
-0.3729910553,
-0.1289364547,
0.0349038355,
-0.1577326655,
-0.2842692435,
-0.2337197065,
-0.3383720517,
0.8736042976,
-0.2685681283,
0.3655049205,
-0.2278823555,
0.0133726206,
-0.5598308444,
0.4988453686,
0.8475862741,
0.6640279889,
-0.0693211034,
-0.1040344387,
0.0834981725,
-0.0975436345,
-0.0312537327,
0.0507956371,
-0.0991190523,
-0.4536363184,
0.348282963,
1.1680716276,
0.3142221272,
-0.5805248618,
0.0691631213,
-0.041375868,
-0.1431307048,
-0.1377342939,
0.7440187931,
-0.0563740954,
0.2898807228,
0.1960529983,
0.0820973068,
-0.2389193773,
-0.7039572597,
-0.2717028856,
0.7457801104,
-0.3229293823,
-0.3089767992,
0.5414930582,
0.0166145097,
-0.5445697904,
0.6705297232,
0.1211140826,
-0.0643239617,
0.7023117542,
0.6820889115,
0.5171353817,
-0.2532880008,
0.2384689897,
0.2352323383,
0.3390627503,
0.0804287419,
0.076464355,
-0.1996167153,
-0.6581019163,
-0.3373148441,
-0.380040288,
-0.4122722745,
0.4564792514,
-1.0521848202,
0.1003147662,
-0.6817777157,
-0.1851816028,
-0.0821094215,
-0.1158495173,
-0.7627336979,
-0.1132986099,
-0.1423425823,
0.780788362,
-0.5174172521,
0.6587381363,
0.9084599018,
-0.3707740903,
-0.9004618526,
0.1342354119,
-0.3560743034,
-1.1428211927,
0.5260140896,
0.0952487141,
-0.2921540737,
0.2333971709,
-0.9795782566,
-0.6025385857,
0.8741240501,
0.6693211794,
-0.6351278424,
-0.3964961767,
0.3970498443,
0.5819011927,
-0.1158829257,
-0.0099927289,
0.8434557915,
0.2844590247,
0.2459870428,
-1.0049123764,
-0.2246812284,
-0.1212529689,
0.0224930607,
0.2046956867,
-0.8513345718,
1.0299834013,
-0.3783021867,
-0.2545914352,
0.2449169606,
0.3881637454,
-0.0952974483,
0.1474126577,
0.1921487004,
0.5763273835,
0.7302777767,
-0.1851315796,
0.9269531369,
-0.3016741872,
0.07991568,
1.171257019,
-0.2175091505,
0.8111332059,
0.4753926098,
-0.0753563717,
0.5362753272,
0.449872762,
0.1519937664,
0.4116876423,
0.1660942286,
-0.2661415935,
-0.2606847584,
-0.0811855048,
-0.472828418,
0.4474852383,
0.5813471079,
-0.3105691969,
-0.0108524943,
0.0773796216,
-0.0840307847,
0.2933840156,
-0.3996251523,
1.0446642637,
0.0235606581,
-0.9776883125,
1.03343606,
-0.2820360363,
0.5077446699,
-0.6188189983,
-0.1749007106,
-0.3045908511,
0.3149956465,
-0.2163260132,
-0.3811464608,
0.0403391011,
-0.0099950135,
-0.2399750501,
0.0802948996,
0.4868479669,
-0.2786127329,
-0.1193525121,
0.1217347533,
0.4361329079,
-0.1621069163,
0.154417634,
-0.3225229681,
0.310262382,
0.071253635,
-0.3508184254,
0.4619352221,
0.6307715178,
0.2226323038,
0.7398933172,
0.3597326875,
0.1732076406,
0.2106060684,
-0.1793002486,
1.1023818254,
-0.5396345258,
-0.0593281463,
-0.7400823832,
0.2881797254,
0.1915578842,
-0.2131569088,
0.6258023977,
0.153505832,
1.0732587576,
-0.2125564665,
0.7918786407,
0.2310121804,
0.3413240016,
-0.9490039945,
0.2897562981,
-0.610948205,
0.7940132022,
0.0479281396,
-0.7245157957,
0.2805039287,
0.4280516505,
-0.4492256045,
0.2695850134,
0.7281553149,
0.8253135681,
0.0827612355,
0.0395142809,
0.6476076245,
0.4225417972,
0.1512734145,
0.6452612281,
0.9944363236,
-0.2830224335,
0.5890798569,
-0.1736831069,
-0.1215218902,
-0.2105936259,
-0.4875900149,
-1.2053461075,
-0.6274033785,
-0.0784086436,
-0.3684653044,
0.3100451827,
0.8636660576,
0.6145497561,
-0.8670879602,
-0.2148274481,
-0.0692317411,
0.1854106039,
-0.0482265465,
-0.2428948432,
0.1576432288,
-0.8520074487,
-0.743168354,
0.3914764822,
0.0378754437,
-0.0022439661,
-0.3099875152,
-0.0287777614,
0.2537399828,
0.1789110154,
0.4889553189,
0.6063224673,
-0.6653414369,
-0.1900613159,
0.2991652489,
-0.0559104793,
0.1420397311,
0.8900170922,
-0.6787008643,
0.4839997888,
-0.0836173743,
0.8505218029,
0.1954424083,
-0.1990560591,
0.4693182111,
-0.8399153948,
-0.0354196131,
0.0739301965,
-0.0345971733,
0.2395276874,
-0.3772375584,
0.2929722667,
-0.1551048011,
-0.7347257137,
-0.7380341887,
0.4366749227,
-0.6114984751,
-0.2050914913,
1.2364428043,
-0.0564455502,
-0.3702376783,
0.2209663093,
-0.2101469636,
0.1655583829,
-0.3844503462,
1.0642408133,
0.6111415625,
-0.2995482683,
-0.0654499009,
-0.7283717394,
0.6623964906,
0.3937549591,
-0.8439351916,
0.2213818282,
0.5702089071,
0.3117786944,
0.0670063794,
0.4276618361,
0.2160802335,
0.3085863292,
-0.2000611424,
-0.2248107344,
-0.3870164454,
-0.3290893137,
-0.2515099645,
-0.068176806,
0.4623325765,
-0.1182212979
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.02008v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.02008v1
|
How well do LLMs cite relevant medical references? An evaluation framework and analyses
| 2024-02-03T03:44:57 | 2024-02-03T03:44:57 |
Kevin Wu, Eric Wu, Ally Cassasola, Angela Zhang, Kevin Wei, Teresa Nguyen, Sith Riantawan, Patricia Shi Riantawan, Daniel E. Ho, James Zou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) are currently being used to answer medical
questions across a variety of clinical domains. Recent top-performing
commercial LLMs, in particular, are also capable of citing sources to support
their responses. In this paper, we ask: do the sources that LLMs generate
actually support the claims that they make? To answer this, we propose three
contributions. First, as expert medical annotations are an expensive and
time-consuming bottleneck for scalable evaluation, we demonstrate that GPT-4 is
highly accurate in validating source relevance, agreeing 88% of the time with a
panel of medical doctors. Second, we develop an end-to-end, automated pipeline
called \textit{SourceCheckup} and use it to evaluate five top-performing LLMs
on a dataset of 1200 generated questions, totaling over 40K pairs of statements
and sources. Interestingly, we find that between ~50% to 90% of LLM responses
are not fully supported by the sources they provide. We also evaluate GPT-4
with retrieval augmented generation (RAG) and find that, even still, around
30\% of individual statements are unsupported, while nearly half of its
responses are not fully supported. Third, we open-source our curated dataset of
medical questions and expert annotations for future evaluations. Given the
rapid pace of LLM development and the potential harms of incorrect or outdated
medical information, it is crucial to also understand and quantify their
capability to produce relevant, trustworthy medical references.
|
[
-0.1123934388,
-0.2535444796,
1.2742897272,
-0.1136167273,
-0.2259123921,
-0.0239019673,
-0.1201287434,
-0.7111694813,
0.1777721047,
0.4744084477,
-0.1618067324,
-0.2930571139,
-0.735276401,
0.5056726933,
-0.2094810158,
1.0230466127,
0.0519209951,
0.4909076095,
-0.4905055761,
-0.2470561862,
-0.1715582162,
-0.7010115385,
-0.4563812912,
-0.4552893639,
0.7198822498,
0.1299256682,
0.7488725781,
0.7337668538,
0.8027254343,
0.19241485,
-0.1248817295,
0.1191802397,
-0.2776174247,
0.3722979426,
-0.3781014979,
-0.323775053,
-0.2802210748,
0.1149513945,
0.4355006516,
0.5776101351,
-0.0384072103,
0.2545185685,
0.0026402024,
0.4918141067,
-0.3294217288,
-0.0183363892,
-0.8668326735,
-0.0419284925,
-0.4521715939,
-0.2985922694,
-0.3451186419,
-0.5366187692,
0.2896160483,
-0.3961968422,
0.197780475,
-0.1164665818,
0.8555629849,
0.5400421023,
-0.5238077641,
-0.5468028784,
-0.4393580854,
0.462731272,
-0.8226568103,
0.1608641893,
0.5952177644,
0.4427804053,
-0.1693758368,
-0.9271070957,
-0.304214716,
-0.6054381728,
-0.2358046323,
0.1648799926,
0.0423949659,
-0.0119000152,
0.5127127767,
0.5471923947,
-0.3495332301,
0.1643927693,
-0.3112567663,
-0.3091839254,
0.4185501933,
0.0541241765,
0.2495019287,
-0.1273851097,
-0.3344136477,
0.3982391357,
-1.1024360657,
-0.5248387456,
0.0215052087,
-0.0309221894,
0.178215906,
0.8935621381,
0.2829057574,
0.6759697795,
0.0610325262,
-0.1994303763,
0.2048381716,
-0.5899171829,
-0.1713651568,
-0.0973237082,
0.7851021886,
0.4445245564,
0.4280572832,
-0.3124708533,
0.0882186294,
-0.2667774856,
0.5103316903,
-0.6672949791,
-0.1463037431,
0.3471428752,
-0.2175050229,
-0.2542624474,
-0.0834739506,
-0.3100698888,
-0.6924407482,
-0.0679855719,
0.1702304482,
-0.2197813541,
0.0002519316,
-0.2402137816,
0.011069146,
0.0540749766,
0.3789839149,
-0.5722597241,
0.0649036095,
0.4750223756,
0.8525090814,
-0.161191538,
0.1244714782,
-0.7072386146,
0.2103053629,
-0.5081440806,
1.0652266741,
-0.4277606308,
-0.3242388964,
0.1524275988,
-0.0248684604,
0.060538251,
-0.9596309662,
0.7374452949,
-0.4235988855,
0.2153044492,
-0.6645771265,
-0.6435540318,
0.2809260488,
0.2695544064,
-0.760091722,
0.6460368037,
0.029942153,
-0.765378356,
0.4347665608,
-0.3875345886,
-0.2245008647,
0.2764341831,
-0.5849799514,
-0.3634773493,
0.1278208494,
0.2865976989,
0.4402451217,
-0.6921722889,
0.4767223895,
-0.3441431224,
-0.1219095662,
0.604223609,
-0.2764361501,
0.6244048476,
0.4033191204,
-0.2759363055,
-0.2342456281,
-0.8069300652,
-0.20528768,
0.0629732087,
-0.4160674214,
-0.2728390694,
-0.0519803278,
-0.2007796913,
0.3403528631,
-0.0084410673,
-0.6297546625,
0.1208977327,
-0.1591677219,
0.3862319291,
0.576697588,
0.3712377548,
-0.1612158716,
-0.280036658,
0.5437015891,
-0.1344029158,
-0.1710150391,
-0.2093217969,
-0.5649377704,
-0.3651510477,
-0.2097879499,
0.4350724816,
0.1729874611,
-0.7899873853,
0.0549213104,
-0.1551189572,
-0.3506731689,
-0.6991119981,
0.1398976892,
0.3645991087,
0.9573184848,
0.4508408308,
-0.0082257874,
-0.4079516232,
-1.1335242987,
-0.4657111168,
-0.3584970236,
-0.3222042322,
0.560885489,
0.3581827581,
-0.1362952739,
0.741892457,
-0.2685427964,
-0.0949240327,
0.1354535073,
0.0104583232,
0.1997238696,
0.1513896137,
0.7726848722,
-0.4683697224,
-0.4505772889,
-0.0395341031,
-1.0059255362,
-0.7686340809,
-0.0191080775,
-0.0497525297,
0.0031156912,
0.2234814167,
-0.6276886463,
-0.0348185413,
0.7114157677,
-0.3742431998,
0.4567531943,
-0.2113234997,
0.1223513037,
-1.0719306469,
0.4245464802,
0.1477965117,
-0.5097193718,
-0.3127929568,
0.0201352853,
0.0446633846,
0.1959223002,
-0.2099971473,
0.5610958934,
-0.4862412214,
-0.098726131,
-0.2666674256,
0.2305287719,
-0.1117856354,
-0.2769663632,
-0.1669816077,
0.844910562,
0.2794226706,
-0.2730015218,
0.3091309369,
0.0978031605,
-0.3687675297,
0.8295651078,
-0.7728863358,
0.1957244873,
0.2399645001,
0.2882757485,
-0.9540355802,
-0.3138642311,
0.2440001965,
-0.4302097857,
0.178371191,
-0.3446094692,
-0.6871671677,
-0.400034517,
-0.0534215309,
0.1202655435,
0.3587850034,
-0.3910697997,
0.3622404337,
0.506932199,
-0.2379714847,
-0.6175789237,
-0.6372356415,
0.2719468176,
0.047403492,
-0.2808671892,
0.1264284551,
-0.1044739634,
-0.4458990991,
0.1931562722,
-0.3764587641,
-0.0505534261,
0.0101404879,
0.1608548015,
0.3662022948,
-0.1994595081,
0.2218899131,
-0.267586112,
-0.0492990687,
0.357640475,
-0.1214742288,
0.1125842184,
0.2049151659,
-0.7653754354,
-0.0296116229,
0.1531645954,
0.7197535634,
0.0082906233,
0.33630988,
0.418625474,
-0.3811993301,
0.3039732873,
-1.0004900694,
-0.0336631946,
-0.3408582211,
0.3072464168,
-0.127640456,
-0.932281673,
0.4318435788,
0.1633123606,
0.2151831686,
0.8429995775,
0.9591180086,
-0.1571727246,
0.7539288402,
-0.0139244208,
0.1764701605,
-0.0441120975,
0.0813548565,
-0.0843390301,
-0.7957712412,
-0.2931342721,
-0.5839098096,
-0.086073108,
-0.6987910271,
-0.6448916793,
0.5596556067,
-0.0734535679,
-0.0752595067,
-0.0626391917,
-0.3659876585,
0.2604038715,
0.3182897568,
0.1049755067,
0.5363308787,
-0.0923200846,
-0.4727345705,
-0.0065352614,
-0.5111070871,
-0.6694934368,
1.3708120584,
0.6781867743,
0.7556199431,
0.0860612392,
0.4142811894,
0.2131901979,
0.9046049714,
-0.5748806596,
0.4005509317,
0.0586262606,
-0.8465923667,
0.1327964664,
-0.3154922426,
-0.7990378737,
0.2202097476,
-0.2909074724,
-0.3082680404,
0.0264538862,
0.0340802707,
-0.4142300785,
0.1591912508,
-0.5018122196,
0.4225707054,
-0.4475707114,
-0.4731457233,
0.0326213241,
-0.6493721604,
0.2397602499,
-0.4483559728,
-0.0122364396,
-0.1457198113,
-0.2556920946,
0.8156873584,
-0.5834650397,
0.5999654531,
-0.1553551108,
-0.2451189756,
0.323812753,
-0.1558436602,
0.360661,
0.3649138808,
-0.1963759661,
0.3982793391,
0.0489101633,
-0.3246112168,
-0.6588615775,
0.8653228283,
-0.5855202079,
-0.8196024299,
-0.7661727071,
-0.436545074,
-0.5121318698,
0.185465917,
0.0659206584,
0.2513670325,
0.0347627513,
0.2396886945,
0.3593419194,
-0.136197269,
0.1095345765,
0.6110574007,
-0.0386463664,
-0.7782290578,
0.2784043849,
0.2980927825,
0.2687332034,
0.0828920677,
0.2237951458,
-0.4511475563,
-0.7532188296,
-0.7143983245,
0.6732394099,
-0.7516265512,
-0.244145155,
-0.6154732108,
-0.2397203147,
-0.1838658899,
0.1825597137,
-0.2351175845,
-0.1637206674,
-0.0401835963,
-0.3794074357,
0.3021604121,
1.0924631357,
0.0702680647,
-0.2227394879,
-0.8438732624,
0.064073287,
0.2686264217,
0.4924368858,
-0.3336825073,
-0.3956739902,
-0.4389590621,
-0.2343764007,
-0.2076810747,
-1.083538413,
-0.0900651142,
-0.1729189456,
1.0210225582,
0.2572816014,
-0.1469701976,
0.6751359701,
-0.8270376921,
1.0554850101,
0.0115454476,
-0.4343605638,
0.3925002813,
-0.3366369605,
0.0713175908,
0.630553484,
0.6677644253,
-0.135461852,
-0.5466000438,
-0.6221998334,
-0.7150419354,
0.1661168039,
0.2182943076,
-0.1068281382,
-0.3219563663,
0.7444725633,
0.0737490356,
0.1373322606,
-0.707860291,
-0.3266741633,
0.1944313943,
-0.22362867,
-0.0455911681,
-0.5525819659,
-0.4166632891,
0.0578527898,
0.3793258071,
-0.2388667315,
0.3257067502,
0.5286480784,
0.0517638512,
-0.2348792255,
0.1334413737,
0.7235124707,
1.1245292425,
-0.2474302202,
0.2597008049,
0.0616717786,
-0.6524522901,
0.0864397213,
0.241547823,
-0.0265154876,
0.3002726436,
0.5946049094,
0.3813584149,
0.0722346678,
-0.7218022346,
0.4750913978,
0.0492837466,
-0.0597324707,
-0.3174290657,
-0.2526959479,
0.2031910717,
0.4118747413,
0.6312895417,
-0.0717932433,
-0.0073960321,
-0.3680010736,
0.428527087,
0.5951131582,
-0.1990160495,
-0.2252029479,
0.881908536,
0.2472791523,
-0.0111098345,
0.3223774731,
0.3636589944,
-0.2437633127,
0.3806473017,
0.5743089318,
0.7508527637,
-0.0784082264,
-0.1214380488,
0.40556252,
0.2232275307,
-0.0277075134,
0.0365290232,
0.1882335693,
-0.3972979486,
-0.9284726977,
-0.3844980896,
-0.8185452223,
0.4043552577,
-0.5059087276,
0.1441512108,
-0.2205928415,
-0.4771007001,
0.041057758,
-0.0558879338,
-0.6797254086,
0.2245118916,
0.3000568151,
0.9526597261,
-0.6643046141,
0.8053605556,
0.9555457234,
-0.6287093759,
-0.7603493333,
0.2325513512,
-0.0138711445,
-1.1241796017,
0.7629467845,
-0.1868403256,
0.1113813445,
-0.2802090943,
-0.5047448874,
-0.9783123136,
1.0812679529,
0.6929830313,
-0.516879499,
-0.1383943707,
0.0081848046,
0.799376905,
-0.4363010824,
0.624222517,
0.2292569131,
0.3551076353,
0.3679559231,
-1.1791608334,
0.283082217,
-0.2088203877,
-0.0979678109,
-0.251488477,
-0.3117331862,
0.5445512533,
-0.4736562669,
0.0381419398,
0.0064083696,
0.2521954179,
0.607149601,
0.2878735065,
0.253156513,
0.5716005564,
0.7838279009,
-0.0870068446,
1.3331224918,
-0.5542474985,
0.3976773322,
0.9534083009,
-0.4705090225,
0.8571712375,
0.6808404326,
-0.3130475581,
0.4952410161,
0.6982374787,
-0.1342809945,
0.3928015828,
0.1846926063,
-0.1316568702,
-0.1970537454,
-0.1365013123,
-0.5720764399,
-0.0264942329,
0.1753968,
-1.0281921625,
-0.2076895833,
-0.2842674255,
0.2687761188,
-0.2106491029,
-0.1209896505,
0.8504756093,
0.311183989,
-0.7860002518,
0.5713086128,
-0.4127804935,
0.0570337102,
-0.6126251221,
-0.2317406237,
-0.1768340617,
-0.0720679164,
-0.4101594687,
-0.9267655611,
0.1887829602,
0.2981831133,
0.0408790819,
-0.0270082597,
0.7748898268,
-0.2989839613,
-0.3427714705,
0.0173826423,
0.8212147951,
0.3006742299,
0.1186592057,
-0.488166362,
0.0063265469,
-0.076662451,
-0.3825412393,
0.5631976128,
0.3186978102,
0.1695428342,
0.5727558136,
0.7055361867,
0.7083730102,
-0.1133903861,
0.1251229644,
0.8778182864,
-0.6363444328,
0.0580780767,
-1.0416914225,
0.4217119813,
-0.2706952393,
-0.1057360917,
0.8082683682,
0.4814706743,
0.6401998401,
0.1547694653,
0.941010654,
0.2230562419,
0.6215025783,
-0.6092560291,
0.645329833,
-0.4536563456,
0.4946903884,
-0.1739895791,
-0.881894052,
-0.5080853105,
0.6297469735,
-0.4392433763,
0.3269001245,
0.8527700305,
0.3306288123,
0.1829825491,
-0.192383796,
0.3044119477,
0.50713557,
0.569725275,
0.406336695,
0.7635319233,
-0.0987080708,
0.4255116582,
0.0211422518,
-0.0838376656,
-0.1587767601,
-1.1758937836,
-0.6610991359,
-0.2121908367,
-0.384973228,
-0.7034555674,
0.0702826008,
1.0011492968,
0.4802694619,
-0.6864190698,
0.1480870545,
0.2488056272,
-0.1387437284,
-0.0306807663,
-0.1335536093,
0.4814209938,
-0.3594374955,
-0.573225081,
0.2655812502,
0.3651787341,
-0.173923552,
-0.4480952919,
0.0432789028,
-0.0347227193,
-0.0852725282,
0.5010868907,
0.1254060417,
-0.8669191003,
-0.4580971003,
-0.0524958745,
-0.4953781366,
0.1642925292,
0.866958797,
-0.8478292227,
0.5079113841,
0.1924731433,
1.0132598877,
0.2742296159,
0.1967960894,
0.5001125932,
-0.425252527,
-0.5621101856,
0.4102448225,
0.6422375441,
0.4155483842,
-0.3094611466,
0.9030465484,
0.4800464213,
-0.9163108468,
-0.8604212403,
-0.0608572401,
-0.9548255205,
0.120979473,
1.4782773256,
-0.3092755377,
0.0712275133,
-0.2654205561,
-0.1949307024,
0.0784754828,
-0.0105202505,
0.587682724,
0.8468309045,
-0.5074967146,
-0.0541379079,
-1.0459674597,
0.3723723292,
0.3089395463,
-0.6051796079,
-0.0382253937,
0.6239189506,
0.7754606605,
0.3467642665,
0.9814673662,
-0.45852229,
0.2362160236,
-0.372133404,
-0.2799455822,
-0.1839154065,
0.1496384442,
-0.3582062423,
0.1024352238,
0.5018032789,
-0.0276093632
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01981v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01981v1
|
Self-Debiasing Large Language Models: Zero-Shot Recognition and Reduction of Stereotypes
| 2024-02-03T01:40:11 | 2024-02-03T01:40:11 |
Isabel O. Gallegos, Ryan A. Rossi, Joe Barrow, Md Mehrab Tanjim, Tong Yu, Hanieh Deilamsalehy, Ruiyi Zhang, Sungchul Kim, Franck Dernoncourt
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable advances in language
generation and understanding but are also prone to exhibiting harmful social
biases. While recognition of these behaviors has generated an abundance of bias
mitigation techniques, most require modifications to the training data, model
parameters, or decoding strategy, which may be infeasible without access to a
trainable model. In this work, we leverage the zero-shot capabilities of LLMs
to reduce stereotyping in a technique we introduce as zero-shot self-debiasing.
With two approaches, self-debiasing via explanation and self-debiasing via
reprompting, we show that self-debiasing can significantly reduce the degree of
stereotyping across nine different social groups while relying only on the LLM
itself and a simple prompt, with explanations correctly identifying invalid
assumptions and reprompting delivering the greatest reductions in bias. We hope
this work opens inquiry into other zero-shot techniques for bias mitigation.
|
[
-0.4661529958,
-0.6394657493,
0.5691915154,
0.0893640742,
-0.1708770245,
-0.0434762165,
-0.2037879974,
-0.2832440138,
0.3742057979,
0.713093102,
-0.4111646414,
-0.5537651181,
-0.5147295594,
0.2022150457,
-0.333093375,
0.8360583186,
0.0314661972,
0.2500325739,
-0.017995961,
-0.1772461981,
-0.2873742282,
-0.7451352477,
-0.5635321736,
-0.4675015211,
0.6099922061,
0.4909799397,
0.3335016072,
0.628115356,
0.1559264213,
0.1429886669,
-0.0080283629,
-0.3977119625,
-0.799975574,
0.4895415008,
-0.2248429656,
-0.4162502885,
-0.1044097617,
0.1650578976,
0.7543129921,
0.6563279629,
0.3253513277,
0.4105670452,
0.0042485627,
0.7166621685,
-0.9236953259,
0.2039993256,
-0.620768249,
0.1597924829,
-0.1080234125,
-0.0536812544,
-0.3629693389,
-0.0991467908,
-0.3199671805,
-0.1096523553,
0.424344182,
-0.3117740452,
0.4612684548,
0.2580274343,
-0.3169381022,
0.2459428161,
-1.0496377945,
0.9825517535,
-0.7530539036,
0.1614589244,
0.4744301438,
0.1056920141,
0.19853881,
0.0772727728,
-0.402240783,
-0.0445598923,
0.1010933518,
-0.1144171655,
-0.2045059353,
0.1947797537,
0.382617265,
0.108411476,
-0.4314994216,
0.256154716,
-0.5702506304,
-0.4527266324,
0.680546999,
-0.0710115954,
0.0696747601,
-0.333797425,
-0.1000363901,
-0.0364497416,
-0.941329658,
-0.4229913056,
0.4209023416,
0.1836803257,
0.0147813205,
0.5741374493,
-0.4080642164,
0.3855038583,
0.2231344283,
-0.1477620751,
0.2197528481,
0.0766762793,
-0.3687306046,
0.272429496,
0.6305724978,
0.6873286366,
0.5344147086,
-0.0779813305,
-0.05241023,
0.1872190535,
-0.1788134575,
-0.8714777231,
0.0248409323,
0.1298433393,
-0.5063459873,
-0.5990421176,
-0.4675649703,
-0.7825119495,
-0.5148466825,
-0.0678851828,
0.1408335268,
-0.2278455943,
-0.06813512,
0.0605787039,
-0.2586614788,
0.5313119292,
0.2670216858,
-0.8700455427,
0.061738126,
0.3888754845,
0.8946231008,
0.3061115146,
-0.039565891,
-0.3413631916,
0.5203211308,
-0.5383268595,
0.5675576925,
-0.4511465728,
-0.3876863718,
-0.1459541023,
-0.3445432186,
0.2903776467,
-0.3648072779,
0.1541028172,
-0.2940591276,
0.1202685237,
-0.301407069,
-0.5750385523,
-0.2822043598,
0.4459463656,
-0.4537448287,
0.6558170915,
-0.0575808734,
-0.6497359872,
0.3395992517,
-0.2301044613,
-0.3947745562,
-0.2700068057,
-0.2385246307,
-0.3467408717,
0.397144556,
0.5322623849,
0.4216037989,
-0.1111465842,
0.0092037236,
-0.9758155346,
-0.2551388144,
-0.2361085415,
-0.5154990554,
0.8274382353,
0.4623932838,
-0.4109781981,
-0.1327465773,
-0.6867418885,
-0.2686417401,
0.3867030144,
0.1810138822,
-0.6548529267,
-0.3846532404,
-0.377087146,
0.2820951641,
0.1734411716,
-0.7403037548,
0.2510618269,
-0.4265616536,
0.2892541289,
0.8210667372,
0.0140765598,
0.7418844104,
-0.1159578785,
0.5951138139,
-0.0686606616,
0.2093929052,
-0.1579823643,
-0.0510490686,
-0.8102592826,
-0.5485735536,
0.093547374,
0.4295854867,
-0.6281015277,
0.3093081713,
0.0890266672,
-0.3211445808,
-0.6087841392,
0.3098194003,
0.549046278,
0.487918824,
0.2602926195,
-0.3537449837,
-0.6855732799,
-1.1126087904,
-0.4580049217,
-0.1923318356,
-0.227163285,
-0.0413654856,
0.2974106073,
-0.0570048168,
0.9093910456,
-0.4802418649,
-0.3734662533,
-0.3938628137,
0.1831906438,
0.0198965669,
0.2931516171,
0.8742897511,
-0.0767621621,
-0.3796229064,
-0.5944440961,
-0.8375473022,
-0.4903519452,
-0.0942246392,
0.1708982587,
0.422642678,
0.7888817191,
-0.4912483394,
0.6307390928,
0.4125764072,
-0.1234508529,
0.5396922827,
-0.0442154482,
-0.009218148,
-0.7824788094,
-0.3218047619,
0.1715109944,
-0.3957218528,
-0.6619238853,
0.0580636263,
-0.127234906,
-0.0148554677,
-0.2279682904,
0.7802670598,
-0.8259376287,
-0.0284606274,
-0.3751811683,
0.1169984341,
0.1507063657,
0.1608955115,
0.0841505229,
0.320384711,
0.7869216204,
-0.3834231496,
0.1510248035,
0.1351659447,
-0.1896544993,
0.4166508019,
-0.6467530727,
0.1752318442,
-0.6806076765,
0.4565638602,
-1.1732314825,
0.0574592911,
0.5859723687,
-0.3011487126,
0.2690862119,
-0.487378031,
-0.2653627396,
-0.2887454629,
-0.7820273638,
0.6064571142,
0.5581817031,
-0.590439558,
0.2082573473,
0.2722406983,
-0.0488533601,
-0.6843036413,
-0.8295161724,
0.178700909,
-0.2832045555,
-0.2691347599,
0.1156336814,
0.0088799857,
-0.4281560481,
-0.2805148363,
-0.1627102792,
0.1030899361,
-0.0653985143,
0.0822651237,
0.3151167035,
0.1165465862,
0.3761429787,
-0.016214883,
-0.2949673831,
0.0790486708,
-0.1595886797,
0.6787480116,
0.2273819745,
-0.3042145073,
-0.2634959221,
0.2313676625,
0.5135131478,
-0.08567404,
0.9356836677,
0.5208004117,
-0.1395130605,
-0.2503981292,
-0.9301017523,
-0.4656424224,
-0.3980820179,
0.1825852543,
-0.2583142221,
-1.0268871784,
0.4750889242,
0.3034179509,
-0.1048466414,
0.2671750784,
0.6990638375,
0.0801979974,
0.8484765887,
0.5111697912,
-0.6759923697,
0.4606033862,
-0.0928693861,
0.5314329863,
-0.6661093831,
0.2472499609,
-0.5690564513,
-0.2258978486,
-0.5000128746,
-0.5541320443,
0.1910353452,
-0.0436006114,
-0.374033004,
0.0255977176,
-0.5220559835,
0.647059381,
0.5175504684,
0.1194028258,
0.3155402839,
0.183113575,
0.0849347189,
-0.030377632,
-0.5719677806,
-0.4154647589,
1.264945507,
0.5356079936,
1.1235649586,
-0.213045612,
1.1505645514,
0.2416034788,
0.3154447079,
-0.7625080943,
0.6492798328,
-0.0254105292,
-1.0218499899,
-0.573332727,
-0.6324486136,
-0.4717381001,
0.290661931,
-0.1485005915,
-0.6146252155,
0.1779043525,
0.3739922047,
-0.2535486221,
0.4327724874,
-0.5035139918,
0.5916358829,
-0.0744052827,
-0.2816050053,
-0.3511578739,
-0.4513381422,
0.64107126,
-0.0029792534,
0.4983535409,
-0.4741883874,
0.3270381689,
0.4440588951,
-0.2468136698,
1.2852084637,
-0.3594712913,
-0.2478498369,
0.2417839915,
0.4893840849,
0.2618259788,
-0.079760164,
-0.1691699624,
0.4446561337,
0.0560632274,
-0.471296221,
-0.632232368,
0.6951467991,
-0.670902431,
-0.7687508464,
-0.3004387915,
-0.6153262258,
-0.026545018,
0.0485936664,
0.0747050196,
0.3268470466,
-0.3947454095,
0.0714897141,
0.4297382534,
-0.4266943038,
0.3707857132,
0.4937294722,
-0.5134043694,
-0.3940656483,
0.5200764537,
0.2494471073,
0.4710579216,
0.1432565451,
0.2607197762,
-0.3881122172,
-0.4733659327,
-0.0540500432,
0.574588716,
-0.7738467455,
-0.1640688032,
-0.4142018557,
-0.0535910912,
-1.1068413258,
-0.1711552441,
-0.394151032,
-0.714823842,
-0.0618919097,
-0.2758911848,
0.2410126477,
0.5410033464,
-0.5490875244,
0.3046881258,
-0.6014611721,
0.5358038545,
0.3159867823,
0.2649405599,
-0.0762232393,
-0.7543192506,
0.0617209934,
-0.0305830874,
-0.0190713834,
-1.0448428392,
0.674705863,
-0.0042076348,
0.4292169511,
0.5501950383,
0.3026521802,
0.5908574462,
-0.5507395864,
0.5743643045,
0.4536415637,
-1.1388981342,
0.5308680534,
-0.2288575619,
0.239748463,
0.4923537672,
0.354362756,
-0.6342074871,
-0.5607745647,
-0.4747309685,
-0.6353926063,
0.504784584,
0.1303810924,
0.315158546,
-0.2777017951,
0.596953392,
-0.0701737925,
0.1449377537,
-0.9446249008,
-0.3443731666,
-0.3037488163,
-0.0916816816,
-0.298697114,
-0.6828317046,
-0.370357126,
-0.4211447835,
0.7755385637,
-0.0716783702,
-0.038056206,
0.3838891685,
-0.2943219841,
-0.054176636,
0.5228853822,
0.391794771,
0.2516563237,
-0.3757414222,
0.3402250409,
0.1992405355,
-0.078406401,
0.3707976341,
-0.2517567575,
-0.673566103,
0.0819215775,
0.1601349711,
0.644541502,
-0.0760173872,
-0.1548506916,
0.4102080762,
0.1832327098,
-0.2365151197,
-0.1762194932,
-0.1371388882,
-0.1219816878,
0.199626267,
-0.051101651,
-0.320508033,
0.1407834888,
-0.6614865661,
-0.0248398483,
0.7688488364,
-0.4899950922,
-0.1727289259,
0.4527368844,
0.2548064888,
0.0080317883,
0.310364604,
-0.1350963861,
-0.2718981802,
0.4909197688,
0.6822474003,
1.1010842323,
-0.5754182339,
0.6214936972,
0.5556206107,
0.5528157949,
-0.1424437165,
-0.3419813216,
-0.1112401038,
-1.1941355467,
-0.3895927072,
-0.5669013262,
-0.3572022617,
0.3194482028,
-0.6672677994,
0.1415228248,
-0.6333240867,
0.0063844146,
-0.0967647657,
-0.36465469,
-0.5264248252,
0.0093502738,
0.5176827312,
0.6348782182,
-0.9632786512,
0.8277310729,
0.281165123,
-0.5975463986,
-0.5188854933,
0.0763996467,
0.2633962929,
-1.0692437887,
0.8140437007,
0.2155432552,
-0.4021011293,
-0.1342897266,
-0.8481404781,
-0.6491081715,
0.6688967943,
0.7550561428,
-0.8044369221,
0.0958926231,
0.2247082442,
0.4761065245,
-0.3579438925,
0.3430384994,
0.721105814,
0.5333628058,
0.1723269969,
-0.7847939134,
0.1931610256,
0.3684774041,
0.1275502145,
-0.0315489769,
-0.4869687259,
0.6640719771,
-0.2159644812,
-0.1088868082,
-0.2075702697,
0.248859033,
0.1961420774,
0.2072169036,
0.616889596,
0.5332457423,
0.2746450007,
0.3251568675,
0.8149133921,
-0.3457157612,
0.6207205057,
1.1667479277,
-0.7043961287,
0.4387477934,
0.6363036633,
0.102783002,
0.2813101113,
0.2006072253,
0.0991557091,
0.3664211929,
0.3273196816,
-0.3921082616,
-0.6155956388,
0.0379620604,
-0.1714980006,
0.7244202495,
0.1421644092,
-0.5230488777,
-0.713576436,
0.0870229527,
0.3432705104,
0.0686916932,
-0.4449509978,
0.690982461,
0.129468143,
-0.3287500739,
0.7340899706,
-0.1509321183,
0.6262567043,
-0.4129894674,
0.0354567915,
-0.4050082564,
0.1955225766,
-0.0916465744,
-0.6567337513,
0.3592815995,
-0.011629465,
-0.3054969311,
-0.4597607553,
1.0682305098,
-0.4938475192,
-0.5258418322,
0.7058182359,
0.5795356631,
0.338406682,
-0.3580832481,
-0.6299778223,
0.0510240421,
0.1616711318,
-0.2224701047,
0.3312647939,
0.2409537435,
0.0938550234,
0.6946188211,
0.4643680155,
0.2778186202,
-0.1412526071,
0.4815143347,
0.7989923954,
-0.8825598359,
-0.1123110354,
-1.1601438522,
-0.0918168426,
-0.175138399,
0.1996480823,
1.0066349506,
0.3473907709,
0.9319702983,
-0.2723900676,
1.0363768339,
0.1812613159,
0.6271242499,
-0.3073023856,
0.7855766416,
-0.3907594979,
0.3040089011,
-0.4296759963,
-0.9586398602,
-0.681819737,
0.8707424998,
-0.6712304354,
0.0495601781,
0.3213270009,
1.0198848248,
0.2408349365,
-0.4781112075,
0.8088064194,
0.5887351036,
0.381162554,
0.065020062,
0.654758513,
-0.185253799,
0.6344029903,
-0.3493336141,
-0.412605226,
-0.1336146295,
-0.9930958748,
-1.2318241596,
-0.0829719827,
-0.1930086017,
-0.2896281481,
0.2697591484,
0.8182176352,
0.7108563781,
-0.7878831625,
-0.2745450437,
0.145833388,
0.3757156134,
0.1056859046,
-0.2006955892,
-0.15226008,
-0.5329729915,
-0.5620952249,
0.2922821045,
0.4966608882,
-0.0770311952,
-0.6809782386,
0.1845014542,
0.0459799208,
0.343498379,
0.8755615354,
0.4550954103,
-0.6044545174,
-0.7105028033,
-0.2114266753,
0.0675517172,
0.163689211,
0.7621392012,
-0.8169346452,
0.5286071301,
0.5332081914,
0.1281166822,
0.5855284929,
-0.0067234389,
0.7085875273,
-0.7006605268,
0.3898848593,
0.0951912999,
0.3991186321,
0.3768353462,
-0.2530021369,
0.4374108613,
0.327673018,
-0.5366346836,
-0.7132688165,
0.6178035736,
-0.7649514079,
-0.4623945355,
1.3471509218,
0.0811805353,
-0.3516733348,
-0.2429396957,
-0.3085371852,
0.3589722812,
-0.3177884817,
1.2528512478,
0.6187192798,
0.049833253,
-0.4329257905,
-0.2069255263,
0.320402503,
0.5516962409,
-0.6870555878,
0.3927948177,
0.86309582,
0.6969431043,
-0.0085215438,
0.7947804928,
-0.2102291733,
-0.1558344066,
-0.1581945717,
0.6697276831,
0.0534548871,
-0.3106891513,
-0.6922305822,
-0.0432660207,
0.0633099452,
-0.2805079818
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01980v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01980v2
|
SOCIALITE-LLAMA: An Instruction-Tuned Model for Social Scientific Tasks
| 2024-02-03T01:33:16 | 2024-03-14T15:30:41 |
Gourab Dey, Adithya V Ganesan, Yash Kumar Lal, Manal Shah, Shreyashee Sinha, Matthew Matero, Salvatore Giorgi, Vivek Kulkarni, H. Andrew Schwartz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Social science NLP tasks, such as emotion or humor detection, are required to
capture the semantics along with the implicit pragmatics from text, often with
limited amounts of training data. Instruction tuning has been shown to improve
the many capabilities of large language models (LLMs) such as commonsense
reasoning, reading comprehension, and computer programming. However, little is
known about the effectiveness of instruction tuning on the social domain where
implicit pragmatic cues are often needed to be captured. We explore the use of
instruction tuning for social science NLP tasks and introduce Socialite-Llama
-- an open-source, instruction-tuned Llama. On a suite of 20 social science
tasks, Socialite-Llama improves upon the performance of Llama as well as
matches or improves upon the performance of a state-of-the-art, multi-task
finetuned model on a majority of them. Further, Socialite-Llama also leads to
improvement on 5 out of 6 related social tasks as compared to Llama, suggesting
instruction tuning can lead to generalized social understanding. All resources
including our code, model and dataset can be found through
bit.ly/socialitellama.
|
[
0.3017296493,
-0.9272051454,
0.4693864286,
0.508158803,
-0.3631154001,
0.3562554419,
-0.4984380901,
-0.3488217294,
0.4877647161,
0.1780105233,
-0.5452260971,
-0.8356423974,
-0.8874752522,
0.1816150099,
-0.4115068018,
1.1806609631,
0.290346384,
-0.149385348,
-0.3096935451,
0.2786430418,
-0.1115537882,
-0.1408264786,
-0.8193041682,
-0.4179337025,
0.7595798373,
0.7533305883,
0.7081685662,
0.7524834871,
0.4381276071,
0.3589393198,
-0.3192109168,
0.5567910075,
-0.8356294036,
-0.0260532387,
-0.3009311855,
-0.544695735,
-0.485286057,
-0.0333071947,
0.4818835258,
0.4992553592,
-0.2394964993,
0.7350291014,
0.0962284356,
0.7821896076,
-0.6307293177,
0.4317860007,
-0.8096814156,
-0.1887860149,
-0.0819483548,
-0.4616621733,
-0.2765243649,
-0.5618976355,
-0.0764422193,
-0.8430039883,
0.3493205011,
0.2126380652,
0.6443293691,
0.5117712021,
-0.3644756675,
-0.2654390633,
-0.404731214,
0.8120471835,
-0.4053032994,
-0.0740264282,
0.4976415634,
0.0170821901,
-0.2925045192,
-0.5694260597,
-0.5428380966,
-0.1236724555,
0.2354937047,
-0.0018330694,
0.0651282519,
0.1400249898,
0.192290619,
0.1311154068,
-0.2190495878,
-0.0277341753,
-0.5307608843,
0.0536863394,
0.9383426309,
0.1149021313,
0.2443623841,
-0.1971011311,
0.0977355093,
0.0176102389,
-0.7733402848,
-0.0007713985,
0.512835741,
0.2060420811,
-0.3115334809,
0.6274930239,
-0.4238548875,
0.427844286,
0.1266627312,
-0.0637607053,
0.0604946502,
-0.1392831057,
0.0721276179,
0.243917793,
0.3561734855,
0.5905005932,
0.5976707935,
-0.2908619344,
0.1207354069,
0.5805979967,
0.2699453533,
-0.5509431958,
-0.2379147112,
-0.1238333508,
-0.3119055927,
-0.655683279,
-0.5767738819,
-0.586607933,
-0.3964812458,
-0.5247363448,
0.2737264633,
-0.0787320808,
-0.2018799484,
0.3716746867,
-0.1016762331,
0.1035762057,
0.3776538372,
-1.0664411783,
0.2088586092,
1.042570591,
1.1054973602,
0.0268433765,
-0.2586899102,
-0.5366185308,
0.1906162947,
-0.1220201403,
0.9196802378,
-1.0000604391,
-0.3585246205,
-0.0425434485,
0.2152757496,
-0.3194077611,
-0.1627863646,
0.2120480239,
-0.3454138935,
-0.2099898607,
-0.3508132398,
-0.4369691312,
-0.0465658791,
0.0209048763,
-0.3503036499,
1.1522140503,
-0.2157690972,
-0.6243175864,
0.0043346914,
-0.7526959777,
-0.613781631,
0.2026911825,
0.0560604557,
-0.0442179702,
0.2747972906,
0.0173208974,
0.6096822619,
-0.3886527419,
0.3648868203,
-0.4737235904,
-0.8459413648,
-0.0049486235,
-0.010035512,
0.6762429476,
-0.2046696097,
-0.4926052988,
0.2366739959,
-0.6824399233,
-0.1890250593,
0.2979558706,
-0.2635201812,
-0.3952955902,
0.436304301,
-0.2601649463,
-0.3013492227,
0.5158817172,
-0.6150380373,
0.0836651027,
-0.3320082128,
0.6955655813,
1.1540933847,
-0.2343705446,
0.3241391778,
-0.3774500489,
0.3537742794,
-0.6214179397,
0.3097636998,
0.2359923571,
-0.8661875129,
-0.7424299121,
-0.0559386425,
0.1086262465,
0.7427442074,
-0.6774992943,
0.1690325737,
-0.0975132734,
-0.6571374536,
-0.7933200598,
0.3469525874,
0.4863967299,
0.2851653695,
0.3075756729,
0.0783114433,
-0.2949947119,
-0.6092731357,
-0.4137721062,
0.0288241208,
0.0151864588,
0.4861059487,
0.5644433498,
-0.1316175014,
0.3584426045,
-0.5300517082,
-0.0331465974,
0.0768329501,
0.2143191993,
0.1887595356,
0.1450971663,
0.1647357196,
-0.5418033004,
-0.4188293815,
0.1397548467,
-0.736002028,
-0.2625493407,
0.4204233587,
-0.2247958779,
0.0130771659,
0.442587167,
-0.5565955639,
0.3083211482,
0.6671702266,
-0.4126521051,
0.6393290758,
-0.1853432655,
0.1877934337,
-0.8604411483,
-0.1405973881,
0.3435740471,
-0.0698697791,
-0.427067697,
0.1187674627,
0.1045943722,
-0.1425746381,
-0.4779022336,
0.3986372054,
-0.4181834161,
0.0873333737,
-0.3146432638,
0.2782919407,
-0.1843186915,
0.4751788676,
0.0692881942,
0.781029582,
0.5955498219,
-0.6201702952,
0.3330025673,
-0.0571082011,
-0.3983858526,
0.4749775231,
-1.0729221106,
0.6376045942,
-0.3097794056,
-0.0287058763,
-0.7289158702,
-0.4201032221,
0.1119489372,
-0.2663405538,
0.1678476185,
0.0147463307,
-0.5127789974,
-0.1644492745,
-0.4189144969,
0.0314983092,
0.424854517,
-0.574374795,
0.5572128892,
0.490932703,
-0.310410887,
-0.7711232901,
0.0187454522,
-0.1241887435,
-0.1916083395,
-0.7362572551,
0.5759578943,
0.0163615346,
-0.1748278588,
0.1707554758,
-0.1676869094,
0.3267700374,
0.300839901,
0.4496738017,
0.3025637269,
-0.2163071781,
0.1864496171,
0.583771944,
0.1209170893,
0.1619573236,
0.3511914611,
0.4170158505,
-0.2079714239,
-0.1455410272,
-0.3614259064,
0.1908459812,
0.175533995,
-0.0494860522,
0.8151106834,
0.4280538261,
-0.2547163963,
-0.2477610707,
-0.5339300632,
-0.3570196927,
-0.5839710832,
0.3178056479,
0.0976578668,
-1.1946494579,
0.1909309626,
-0.4220575094,
0.0983962268,
0.034758959,
0.288739413,
-0.3079010844,
1.0990049839,
0.7321516871,
-0.0601798035,
0.6712899208,
0.0444990546,
0.1216968,
-0.8253715038,
-0.2342077643,
-0.7171577811,
-0.4508984387,
-0.3510187566,
-0.4914965332,
0.2843212187,
-0.0857381076,
-0.3723631203,
0.1212466434,
-0.9148122072,
0.9314303398,
0.5170303583,
0.5759804249,
0.1668893099,
0.1505592912,
0.4634827077,
0.2037807107,
-0.5950769186,
-0.8603405356,
1.179756999,
0.0878569782,
0.83153826,
-0.1027956903,
0.718149364,
0.3389233053,
0.361474961,
-0.5245495439,
0.8431127667,
-0.5683020949,
-0.3072989285,
-0.2754423022,
-0.2641040385,
-0.8992765546,
0.0028910472,
-0.3428747654,
-0.9257526994,
-0.0214337483,
0.4295601845,
-0.1734499186,
-0.1449265629,
-0.8769372702,
0.8485367298,
-0.2982996106,
-0.5648635626,
-0.7704339623,
-0.5408093333,
0.3018447161,
0.2409416139,
0.2030655742,
-0.5531862974,
0.0548815764,
0.7160021067,
0.1888684928,
1.4634262323,
-0.2319174558,
0.0164702665,
-0.0125607653,
-0.1890024394,
0.6295374036,
0.1702161282,
-0.0646558926,
0.3050745428,
0.1533517092,
-0.3358435035,
-0.5675473213,
0.8637756109,
-0.8717320561,
-0.9794666171,
-0.1759142727,
-0.6328811646,
0.1270466,
-0.2915459573,
-0.1800681204,
-0.0528195016,
-0.0534870364,
0.3760076165,
0.7578869462,
-0.2108498812,
-0.0391654894,
0.591617465,
0.2051703334,
0.056430202,
1.1198376417,
-0.0104395505,
0.1812299639,
0.1812232435,
0.291706562,
-0.1157090887,
-0.1802001894,
-0.2713601589,
0.521387279,
-0.6796090603,
-0.1871483773,
-0.6105985045,
0.0207216702,
-0.3853293359,
-0.4243090749,
-0.0844568312,
-0.4213220477,
-0.5753595233,
-0.0073137507,
0.7621287704,
0.8277754784,
-0.0073427991,
0.4674441814,
-0.4077323377,
0.3816608191,
0.3925210536,
0.1839657426,
0.0313707739,
-0.5856960416,
-0.1644420475,
0.1624990553,
-0.1729727536,
-1.0659173727,
0.1445074826,
0.644887507,
0.4293089509,
0.1264683902,
-0.0465128534,
0.6974058747,
-0.6387255192,
0.4569607973,
-0.1267096251,
-1.0226536989,
0.8349087834,
-0.2185340226,
0.1578047276,
0.3566350341,
0.5602301955,
-0.5103953481,
-0.4642599821,
-0.2637772262,
-0.9126862884,
0.7420030236,
-0.1649706662,
0.4241248667,
-0.3292185962,
0.673188448,
-0.1263967305,
0.2557402253,
-0.6300827265,
-0.034628287,
-0.3180968165,
-0.4958080649,
-0.1525508761,
-0.3410258293,
-0.265884012,
-0.353356719,
0.7665911913,
-0.3260779679,
0.086705327,
-0.1227959096,
-0.2268185318,
-0.3008286953,
0.1631929874,
0.4638082683,
0.3796547651,
-0.1546511799,
0.0965542719,
0.1896605641,
-0.6144194007,
0.0346454605,
0.0774531215,
-0.1233937517,
-0.3764638901,
0.1950893402,
0.7319785357,
0.7853821516,
-0.5878033042,
0.2930669785,
-0.0425408483,
-0.0736914575,
-0.0191306807,
0.6261845827,
0.5255374312,
0.536256969,
0.2787515521,
-0.3321902752,
0.1650847644,
-0.4939440191,
-0.3468839824,
0.5132134557,
0.0254052263,
-0.3644478917,
0.6386589408,
0.3382273912,
-0.6998164654,
0.373653084,
-0.3013924956,
-0.3428165615,
1.0063363314,
0.858607173,
0.4896794856,
-0.2779049873,
0.6474006176,
0.2387812436,
0.4822925925,
-0.1485920846,
0.561899364,
-0.3294056356,
-0.6660657525,
-0.8718107939,
-0.8388575315,
-0.66413939,
-0.2040914446,
-0.6356975436,
0.1515971273,
-0.3930849135,
-0.0615274645,
0.1685235202,
-0.106233798,
-0.5928433537,
-0.1343922466,
-0.1121142954,
0.769371748,
-1.0367436409,
0.7392367125,
0.8997465968,
0.2106194496,
-0.8288003802,
-0.4396451414,
0.0589286722,
-1.0411784649,
0.8639228344,
0.2863787413,
-0.6655985713,
0.2275737822,
-0.9498579502,
-0.9374520183,
1.0991230011,
0.5718823671,
-0.8369234204,
-0.1822064966,
-0.1358255744,
0.6469022632,
-0.2540889382,
-0.0625233352,
0.5810154676,
0.2719819248,
-0.0324397385,
-0.7147704959,
0.1383621246,
-0.5808451772,
-0.0744490698,
0.0075772232,
-0.8282812238,
0.5153647661,
-0.300655067,
-0.314457655,
-0.1485992372,
0.6460865736,
0.612736702,
0.6603438258,
0.4587334991,
0.1464959085,
0.8934050202,
-0.0436293967,
0.9321657419,
-0.5083316565,
0.1024772525,
0.8787683845,
-0.578588903,
0.772642076,
0.2820166349,
-0.1145946831,
0.5320708156,
0.7530634999,
0.234757185,
0.4510711432,
0.1580439657,
-0.4467113912,
-0.2905902863,
-0.395460248,
-0.303496331,
0.3390989304,
0.7913222313,
-0.1277668923,
0.2405614108,
-0.2417044044,
0.0068112463,
0.2371304929,
-0.6416440606,
0.6053033471,
0.1872575283,
-0.4588518143,
0.3909060359,
-0.2355191559,
0.9841786027,
-0.4815483093,
-0.3057765067,
-0.1399815679,
-0.1395777464,
-0.3642718494,
-0.5161731243,
0.1662172377,
0.2209142148,
-0.1293716133,
0.0846764371,
1.0587177277,
-0.3124740124,
-0.5498628616,
0.440758884,
-0.0595467575,
0.3485047519,
0.0004143608,
-0.7219818234,
0.0479431227,
-0.2072441876,
-0.2104937285,
0.29941836,
0.5201216936,
-0.0296788663,
0.694560349,
0.8409605622,
0.2616450191,
0.1694718301,
0.2085106522,
0.8971498609,
-0.4562004805,
-0.1995787919,
-0.7547854185,
0.1813777834,
-0.3037733138,
-0.3212153018,
0.6759787798,
0.0510280132,
0.6949089766,
-0.0406818315,
0.3653503656,
0.1015802696,
0.3588250875,
-0.4521905184,
0.5188459158,
-0.5978031158,
-0.0223824177,
-0.3228591084,
-0.9343420267,
-0.1758833975,
0.923324585,
-0.5734915137,
-0.2248789519,
0.533111155,
1.0776267052,
0.0485218912,
0.3464993536,
0.0767920688,
-0.0888043791,
-0.2272980362,
0.3433983326,
0.9170309305,
0.1585763246,
0.3263280988,
-0.3326221704,
-0.4133954644,
-0.2670796216,
-0.9828756452,
-1.1480208635,
-0.1268372834,
-0.4035843313,
-0.1549410969,
0.6909825206,
0.9910411835,
0.552188158,
-0.4647454023,
-0.2308107466,
0.1757547259,
0.4222535193,
-0.3565923274,
-0.2344693691,
0.3326207101,
-0.4875317514,
-0.6882736087,
0.5781930685,
0.5082065463,
-0.4395620227,
0.0509912781,
0.0284893475,
-0.2945609391,
0.2573674619,
0.7957218289,
0.1937343031,
-0.543669045,
-0.5128661394,
0.3524724245,
0.1380488575,
-0.3450370133,
0.4746073186,
-0.2200952321,
0.1066770107,
0.1068962663,
0.5038727522,
0.6742432714,
-0.1442575157,
0.3219798505,
-0.7575356364,
0.1123854294,
-0.0296051614,
0.2965096831,
0.3103851378,
-0.8112059236,
0.7025916576,
0.1721374393,
-0.9934227467,
-0.9338108897,
0.0492616743,
-0.8056422472,
-0.1820901781,
1.1794377565,
-0.0035102386,
-0.7557791471,
-0.0717386678,
-0.2138872594,
0.5532608032,
-0.5610455871,
1.4032444954,
0.5421408415,
0.1308466941,
-0.1766736209,
-0.549759388,
0.3096922934,
0.662727952,
-0.8764293194,
-0.0860002041,
0.4164862335,
0.2169279903,
0.1106313318,
0.616155684,
0.2753114998,
0.5866547823,
-0.1923616976,
0.1523370892,
-0.0228428151,
-0.4588420093,
0.0229785591,
0.0404293537,
-0.0055235443,
-0.0565198548
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01976v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01976v1
|
MasonPerplexity at ClimateActivism 2024: Integrating Advanced Ensemble Techniques and Data Augmentation for Climate Activism Stance and Hate Event Identification
| 2024-02-03T01:06:33 | 2024-02-03T01:06:33 |
Al Nahian Bin Emran, Amrita Ganguly, Sadiya Sayara Chowdhury Puspo, Dhiman Goswami, Md Nishat Raihan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The task of identifying public opinions on social media, particularly
regarding climate activism and the detection of hate events, has emerged as a
critical area of research in our rapidly changing world. With a growing number
of people voicing either to support or oppose to climate-related issues -
understanding these diverse viewpoints has become increasingly vital. Our team,
MasonPerplexity, participates in a significant research initiative focused on
this subject. We extensively test various models and methods, discovering that
our most effective results are achieved through ensemble modeling, enhanced by
data augmentation techniques like back-translation. In the specific components
of this research task, our team achieved notable positions, ranking 5th, 1st,
and 6th in the respective sub-tasks, thereby illustrating the effectiveness of
our approach in this important field of study.
|
[
-0.7709206939,
-0.6144807935,
0.4939891696,
-0.0124783916,
-0.2424593568,
0.608086586,
-0.0904974937,
-0.6230173111,
0.3776564002,
0.0826225057,
-0.4569729269,
-0.4763403535,
-0.9216100574,
-0.0838587284,
-0.6852241755,
1.0725474358,
0.0207739137,
0.1776222289,
-0.1791351587,
-0.2224842459,
-0.1364665926,
-0.371324569,
-0.5711177588,
-0.2628684938,
0.6241461039,
0.2721365392,
0.8368266225,
0.3639142811,
0.2550441325,
0.3522743881,
-0.1325715631,
-0.1894275993,
-0.652931869,
-0.1946548522,
-0.3630495965,
0.0252120327,
-0.1266123801,
0.5168787837,
0.6306331754,
0.3769592643,
0.1245707646,
0.4305481315,
-0.0221760869,
0.1470693797,
-0.8444649577,
0.027232863,
-0.671682179,
0.0273606125,
0.0633392408,
-0.1821977496,
-0.0591994934,
-0.4370571375,
-0.0784784481,
-0.7419231534,
0.7116965652,
0.3149145246,
0.4166308939,
0.2206612378,
-0.4725024104,
-0.2271858156,
-0.7385635972,
0.9097481966,
-0.3200987279,
0.3528389931,
0.0355479009,
0.1309075952,
-0.2070257217,
-0.5587950945,
-1.0078556538,
0.5106028318,
-0.0135852341,
0.4079914093,
-0.3304899037,
-0.1706019044,
-0.0739554167,
0.3712545335,
-0.5135020614,
0.2052994519,
-0.4189624786,
-0.157179445,
1.0956739187,
0.1658281982,
0.1328576505,
-0.1654987484,
-0.5364786983,
-0.1712673604,
-0.3264604211,
0.0723966956,
0.8871628642,
0.1645931453,
-0.2250210047,
0.4689778388,
-0.2228025049,
0.3101992011,
0.2637835443,
0.3260829747,
0.0995033979,
-0.2270994633,
-0.3529946804,
0.2949548662,
0.7162566781,
0.3063628674,
-0.3241540492,
-0.1170921102,
-0.1548714042,
0.1656444371,
0.2138797343,
-0.6908929348,
-0.4704188704,
0.4461099207,
-0.4975892007,
-0.722789526,
0.3700012565,
-1.192474246,
-0.9965972304,
-0.55593431,
0.2686543465,
0.0477976874,
-0.7148734331,
-0.2139266431,
-0.6997955441,
0.2205449045,
0.6824780107,
-0.6008123159,
0.2878372371,
1.0557609797,
0.8142675757,
-0.5848739743,
-0.1914260238,
-0.1642251164,
-0.0787861124,
-0.2950948477,
1.0131374598,
-1.0713465214,
-0.5967499018,
-0.3100179732,
-0.012049051,
-0.2036689818,
-0.2898892164,
0.3787002265,
-0.6220373511,
0.2815762758,
0.0778983086,
-0.586658597,
-0.3877087533,
0.2821026146,
-0.6082559228,
1.0031605959,
-0.2199856043,
-0.8001303077,
0.443069458,
-0.7360341549,
-0.0061836331,
0.2261837423,
-0.1138462201,
-0.4813803732,
0.226828292,
-0.1066951975,
0.6028380394,
-0.1899643987,
0.2703882158,
-0.615814805,
-0.0271866787,
0.1537081003,
-0.4075038433,
0.753569603,
0.2557273507,
-0.5042439103,
0.5692698359,
-0.8273878694,
-0.3642403781,
0.0641359165,
-0.1021799147,
-0.2677903473,
0.0217880495,
0.3826338351,
0.1851147413,
0.0673542246,
-0.7442728877,
0.1777467728,
0.1600808799,
0.3217608035,
1.0864503384,
0.273267746,
0.5939763784,
-0.3856481314,
0.6533071399,
0.0074526807,
0.3539249003,
0.4275961518,
-0.7977666259,
-0.3400182128,
-0.1655830741,
-0.2353642583,
0.5214169621,
-0.5380895138,
0.0837132707,
-0.2393690199,
-0.9388180971,
-0.1073121578,
-0.0501588807,
0.1462211758,
0.4205687642,
0.5234883428,
-0.2954337597,
-0.6355732083,
-0.6286655068,
-0.3902211785,
-0.421397686,
0.2834145129,
-0.0985764936,
0.7289317846,
-0.1606161892,
0.8051405549,
-0.4349772632,
0.2430719882,
0.0869258791,
0.4045554996,
0.188926205,
0.6343442202,
0.4147953987,
-1.5300444365,
-0.1143193319,
0.0195225403,
-0.2411057055,
0.2940447032,
0.0358284377,
-0.1242725104,
0.2112649977,
0.2963301241,
-0.3509102464,
0.5829262733,
0.8077709675,
-0.6687002778,
0.5348075628,
0.5063762069,
0.7247159481,
-1.0994458199,
-0.0217326358,
0.2159603834,
0.0769754574,
-0.9439555407,
0.0767874122,
-0.3901697695,
-0.1584465653,
-0.6394215822,
0.4950853884,
-0.2966850698,
0.0928309187,
-0.2067939341,
-0.2045833617,
-0.3302506804,
0.2455844581,
0.3986895084,
0.3686298132,
0.5227617025,
-0.4448475838,
0.619191587,
0.2673206925,
-0.2319691181,
0.4587749541,
-0.1767453551,
0.2684362233,
-0.2374564707,
0.4201949239,
-1.3272289038,
-0.4330452383,
0.4992569089,
-0.6706935167,
-0.0014327462,
-0.4469833672,
-0.4251891375,
-0.3515318334,
-0.2690483332,
0.594574213,
0.4738327563,
-0.6126338243,
1.1270724535,
0.8311476707,
0.0637042746,
-0.3566912711,
-0.4144156277,
0.0472267903,
-0.6807118654,
-0.5645747781,
0.3430579007,
-0.171621412,
-0.6856459379,
-0.289688766,
0.0083951708,
-0.0969010219,
0.2418833375,
0.6314442158,
0.0906028971,
0.1050410494,
0.1663832515,
-0.2462040484,
0.0179841556,
0.1778389215,
-0.3312106133,
0.4631263614,
-0.0756172836,
-0.1196942776,
-0.3977404833,
0.4611350894,
0.6736503243,
0.1053748652,
0.8444244266,
0.8425164819,
-0.5015300512,
0.158966586,
-0.6613702774,
-0.1625456065,
-0.4730228782,
-0.1251877248,
0.1574667096,
-0.9620401859,
0.6063075066,
-0.1102801114,
0.1962031275,
0.4678684473,
0.6368601918,
0.1386485994,
1.1241270304,
0.2583930492,
-0.2187660187,
0.4025618434,
-0.2355954349,
0.1600156128,
-0.6457546353,
-0.3658081889,
-0.6345413923,
-0.2199296057,
-0.7674458623,
-0.4448569119,
0.2826281488,
-0.165141046,
-0.1854269505,
0.3049387336,
-0.8062327504,
0.15672943,
0.2220280766,
-0.0499105304,
0.3105490208,
-0.3307719827,
0.6053566337,
0.224768579,
-0.4445115328,
-0.447538197,
0.7591224909,
0.0749811158,
0.1924750954,
0.4597789645,
0.680339992,
0.5403551459,
0.5617180467,
-0.8875388503,
0.6773694754,
0.4614972174,
-0.7456897497,
-0.420419991,
-0.1736419499,
-0.9095793962,
0.3904549778,
-0.6496558785,
-0.5909122229,
0.5427513123,
0.4249752462,
-0.0846076459,
0.4707227349,
-0.5128808618,
0.6945546269,
0.1650328934,
-0.4515518546,
-0.5039430261,
-0.365909487,
0.3990531862,
-0.1626058966,
0.7703527212,
-0.1876572669,
-0.1294894516,
0.7743757963,
-0.1126135737,
0.9822846055,
-0.2697833776,
-0.076837346,
0.131795153,
-0.1013033763,
0.7207195163,
0.1540177912,
-0.2576789856,
0.1527015269,
-0.1606546789,
-0.5989056826,
-0.4320392609,
0.8643535376,
-0.7136005759,
-0.9063565135,
-0.4716159999,
-0.274081707,
-0.106484659,
0.0456140302,
0.11601758,
0.3523793817,
-0.5612924099,
-0.0704707205,
0.5359921455,
0.1892791837,
0.731220603,
0.3535024524,
-0.036725726,
-0.5958824158,
0.9524873495,
0.1162522212,
0.0762187019,
0.1250246465,
0.5183011293,
-0.1003098562,
-1.0574867725,
-0.277641654,
-0.2508450747,
-0.6859737039,
-0.0427190177,
-0.8805600405,
0.3715807498,
-0.920522213,
-0.3551469147,
-0.2886347771,
-0.7006438971,
-0.3795205653,
-0.3047078252,
0.5346898437,
0.8905498981,
-0.0859185085,
0.0959162265,
-0.528742671,
0.0605208427,
0.2611210048,
-0.0744743347,
-0.2076530308,
-0.3204212785,
-0.1366465837,
-0.2423252314,
-0.4944429398,
-0.7767559886,
0.4116431773,
-0.1052434817,
0.5783156753,
0.4259909093,
0.3055362701,
0.7469778061,
-0.1897368282,
1.1223533154,
0.30540362,
-1.0989353657,
0.5072049499,
-0.5613601804,
-0.0060531334,
0.4189347327,
0.7187943459,
-0.2320222408,
-0.6311093569,
-1.2523826361,
-0.8532530665,
0.319259733,
0.3593450785,
0.1595095992,
0.0172818117,
-0.0208981596,
0.0915631875,
0.305599153,
-0.3256211877,
-0.0529600233,
-0.5684916377,
0.0093147885,
-0.274654448,
0.1876941621,
-0.5660895705,
-0.3148580194,
0.9468069673,
-0.3872281015,
-0.0382646956,
0.2096049786,
0.313084811,
-0.1543873399,
0.1705644727,
0.8292145729,
0.7876760364,
0.1053511724,
0.224952817,
0.4122080803,
-0.5909699798,
0.0203101039,
0.2846449316,
0.093565844,
-0.1921082288,
0.5051850677,
0.5779874921,
0.0505664274,
-0.1867856085,
0.4818618298,
0.0451807752,
-0.2571167052,
-0.8619660735,
0.0508408099,
-0.1136986688,
0.3176445663,
0.7293330431,
0.4644085467,
0.5760114789,
-0.7263060808,
0.0096282028,
0.4945653677,
-0.7595014572,
-0.5585061312,
0.5460850596,
0.2874897122,
-0.1332833171,
0.06464196,
0.180079028,
-0.5812024474,
0.7913197279,
0.1084620729,
0.6698387265,
-0.3978020549,
0.1949949563,
0.5184642076,
0.0138870114,
0.0209112875,
-0.1248569787,
-0.2309711128,
-1.0266703367,
-0.0351068452,
-0.5406258106,
-0.4923838973,
-0.1297076792,
-0.8421711326,
0.3955954611,
-0.6311607361,
-0.0916168541,
0.2025267184,
-0.0313132107,
-0.4390197694,
0.3119704723,
0.0966943577,
0.8430867791,
-1.1538717747,
0.5607719421,
0.7293432951,
-0.0697620064,
-0.6231868863,
-0.0471992455,
0.7905336618,
-0.6481958032,
0.3713160157,
0.1066629738,
-0.3369214833,
0.2652836442,
-0.9571485519,
-0.7156312466,
1.3815623522,
-0.2290841192,
-0.4261514544,
0.4564778209,
-0.342903614,
0.4614288211,
-0.567509234,
0.1779860109,
0.687016964,
0.9758371115,
0.4575180411,
-0.5380147099,
0.1605414152,
-0.3896419108,
-0.1790018976,
0.4834095836,
-0.8760737777,
0.4980056286,
0.1483878642,
-0.4586415291,
-0.2175783366,
0.7426158786,
0.2041379064,
0.7021910548,
0.8282475471,
0.4503093064,
0.7101658583,
-0.0153243802,
1.2448929548,
-0.1322157979,
0.3948627114,
0.8267377615,
-0.0287802387,
0.5823062062,
0.7956115603,
0.0454466976,
0.3357143104,
0.7310003042,
-0.0436379686,
0.3347195685,
0.2754492462,
-0.6647405028,
-0.4842716455,
-0.385360688,
-0.0459833294,
0.4010260403,
0.4440053999,
-0.2315332592,
0.2149794698,
0.1109472066,
0.1817466319,
0.2921666205,
-0.5721110702,
0.9520826936,
-0.1936397702,
-0.7067527175,
0.1850574166,
-0.3380527794,
0.6405896544,
-0.1072568819,
-0.2864481509,
0.2781426013,
-0.0771158189,
-0.6193702221,
-0.9454571605,
0.5102528334,
-0.2754530013,
-0.1855419129,
-0.3440321684,
0.3630776405,
-0.2255022973,
-0.4837186337,
0.363206774,
-0.0596284904,
0.241195187,
0.0494711027,
-0.6334065199,
0.3571355045,
-0.1663560569,
-0.3819846511,
0.1972687095,
0.0114520518,
-0.2022113353,
0.2852421999,
0.9204479456,
-0.1007716358,
0.0245277155,
-0.034907952,
0.9951125979,
-0.3547192216,
-0.1972256005,
-0.6957552433,
0.5497916341,
-0.5160170794,
-0.5757200122,
0.8777772784,
0.8053985238,
0.8764515519,
0.0640687272,
0.8447007537,
-0.1847008616,
0.3997161686,
-0.4713979959,
0.4305231273,
-0.2755035162,
0.0444167554,
-0.37761724,
-0.7439479828,
-0.4343746006,
0.0543888249,
-0.5255504251,
-0.3119516373,
0.3926056623,
0.9688110352,
-0.0484800451,
0.6554425955,
0.2161435336,
-0.0247107428,
0.579520762,
0.1245273426,
0.9594143033,
-0.2327158749,
0.5142973065,
-0.1513402462,
-0.3373672366,
0.016725732,
-0.9674204588,
-0.7498399615,
-0.8215966821,
-0.6089764237,
-0.4967440963,
-0.0566048361,
1.1420605183,
0.6309393644,
-1.1033635139,
0.0073986771,
-0.3669288754,
0.1685312539,
-0.1596877128,
-0.2984786332,
0.2841932178,
0.2330847383,
-1.0749083757,
0.4298698902,
0.1237362474,
0.0713838711,
-0.3129960597,
-0.0144467223,
-0.3272351921,
0.2023295611,
0.3891125321,
0.4687815011,
-0.6323139071,
-0.8243549466,
-0.5047773719,
0.3761295974,
-0.0891344398,
1.0198013783,
-0.6847277284,
0.3317576051,
0.7795654535,
0.5211758614,
0.4386700094,
0.2390357256,
0.4949937463,
-0.2726358771,
0.1668128818,
0.4225052893,
0.2081578225,
0.4406365156,
-0.6443244815,
0.6860784888,
0.5823542476,
-0.685444355,
-0.7350069284,
0.2409996092,
-0.9361314774,
-0.2365769446,
1.1774358749,
0.0789645091,
-0.1605195701,
-0.5492034554,
-0.023286907,
0.06894245,
-0.6805827022,
0.8741934896,
0.8777137995,
-0.4308883548,
-0.4383796751,
-0.0989862233,
0.4059441388,
0.0192281622,
-0.6531288028,
-0.218315199,
0.6582301855,
0.1042623743,
0.6701798439,
0.3367400467,
0.0649700984,
0.2577518225,
-0.2605362833,
0.05303872,
0.0346241221,
-0.2170899361,
-0.3646531701,
0.3737596869,
-0.3510722518,
0.053957969
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01967v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01967v2
|
MasonPerplexity at Multimodal Hate Speech Event Detection 2024: Hate Speech and Target Detection Using Transformer Ensembles
| 2024-02-03T00:23:36 | 2024-02-18T06:39:55 |
Amrita Ganguly, Al Nahian Bin Emran, Sadiya Sayara Chowdhury Puspo, Md Nishat Raihan, Dhiman Goswami, Marcos Zampieri
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The automatic identification of offensive language such as hate speech is
important to keep discussions civil in online communities. Identifying hate
speech in multimodal content is a particularly challenging task because
offensiveness can be manifested in either words or images or a juxtaposition of
the two. This paper presents the MasonPerplexity submission for the Shared Task
on Multimodal Hate Speech Event Detection at CASE 2024 at EACL 2024. The task
is divided into two sub-tasks: sub-task A focuses on the identification of hate
speech and sub-task B focuses on the identification of targets in text-embedded
images during political events. We use an XLM-roBERTa-large model for sub-task
A and an ensemble approach combining XLM-roBERTa-base, BERTweet-large, and
BERT-base for sub-task B. Our approach obtained 0.8347 F1-score in sub-task A
and 0.6741 F1-score in sub-task B ranking 3rd on both sub-tasks.
|
[
-0.7159796357,
-0.8079095483,
0.3130733371,
0.1818113923,
-0.1716124117,
0.2272218466,
-0.2494814247,
-0.7786999345,
0.2936964929,
0.1819543242,
-0.676528275,
-0.3514760137,
-1.0630828142,
0.0968360379,
-0.6814933419,
1.1718577147,
0.1245977953,
0.0257013831,
-0.143206507,
-0.338344574,
-0.2596612275,
-0.617630899,
-0.65583992,
0.0113387667,
0.7192988396,
0.1860221922,
0.4470174611,
0.3574775159,
0.4466752708,
0.3665899038,
0.1230644137,
-0.0486517735,
-0.4610322118,
0.3273124993,
-0.3213508725,
-0.0417149477,
-0.2658058405,
0.1562479883,
0.4940490723,
-0.0599843152,
0.2762435377,
0.1279446632,
-0.1066943929,
-0.0229720138,
-0.7423278093,
-0.0402182862,
-0.7791670561,
0.1566087455,
-0.4558945298,
-0.1126418859,
-0.3905923367,
0.0299961083,
-0.0547652617,
-0.4231675267,
0.3936714232,
0.2456438094,
0.3340184689,
0.0715716481,
-0.5293101668,
-0.6338635087,
-0.6438521147,
0.912843883,
-0.2501087785,
0.398501426,
-0.0333245322,
0.1180226356,
0.1169466898,
-0.5751579404,
-0.9588009119,
-0.104329519,
-0.114946343,
0.1391259432,
-0.8252162337,
-0.0501309074,
0.0885283723,
0.1521077752,
-0.7263507843,
0.2644801438,
-0.360116303,
-0.4112069309,
0.8251174688,
0.2799156308,
0.1601671278,
-0.2124643922,
-0.5916358829,
-0.1429886222,
-0.0967808291,
-0.1545758396,
0.6641063094,
0.2377180457,
-0.047666043,
0.3582060635,
-0.0286365524,
0.2251583785,
0.3252818286,
-0.1311059892,
0.3434335887,
-0.2451760173,
0.0817816779,
0.1044910103,
0.8477870226,
0.2056267709,
0.159532547,
-0.0125379069,
-0.1534607708,
0.338650465,
0.4534260333,
-0.5168031454,
-0.3014838994,
0.2455953211,
-0.4420044422,
-0.3366360366,
-0.2222166955,
-1.0041487217,
-0.710398972,
-0.2081104517,
0.4739989936,
-0.2307922393,
-0.4568015337,
-0.4329038858,
-0.3884569407,
0.0280149933,
0.3402652442,
-0.72747159,
0.1320659369,
0.6268140674,
0.4326359034,
-0.8226171732,
-0.2148858011,
-0.4958602786,
0.0660237297,
0.243863374,
0.8537362218,
-0.9737129211,
-0.2633456588,
-0.1078601405,
0.0843245164,
-0.2076312751,
-0.4780346751,
1.0374655724,
-0.5367040038,
0.255313158,
0.4858158231,
-0.4093204439,
-0.2153959274,
0.4746431112,
-0.6434822083,
0.8282764554,
-0.2501523495,
-0.7606332898,
0.2935369313,
-0.6373960972,
-0.2563647926,
0.269394964,
-0.2828600705,
-0.7042741179,
-0.0127030881,
0.0515049063,
0.4972832799,
0.1643264443,
0.1407193094,
-0.372105062,
-0.0143953143,
0.17659235,
-0.5448055863,
0.5998254418,
0.2472163588,
-0.8047356606,
0.5666525364,
-0.7746851444,
-0.2032793313,
0.2636366189,
-0.1160741374,
-0.2180067003,
-0.0303345472,
0.5745258927,
0.4638465643,
0.1719864756,
-0.7931234241,
-0.0696409196,
0.2195407599,
-0.0934639052,
0.8557631373,
-0.2529116869,
0.2601519227,
-0.3325272202,
0.7405301929,
0.2655884922,
0.3851878047,
0.2726553679,
-0.8833254576,
-0.5394428968,
-0.549934566,
-0.177257508,
0.7137383819,
-0.689586401,
0.0988823771,
0.0935506821,
-0.6129720211,
0.0118790511,
-0.3040517569,
0.6295084357,
0.0384345911,
0.6004567742,
-0.2003017664,
-1.0051217079,
-1.093534112,
-0.4498555958,
-0.1135699004,
0.1389481425,
0.2689300776,
0.6821672916,
-0.1390824169,
0.5920152068,
-0.2896808684,
-0.518674016,
-0.1276919693,
0.5433592796,
-0.2770962119,
0.445845902,
0.5227493048,
-1.3518508673,
-0.4268754125,
-0.3331784308,
-0.2957133055,
-0.127050072,
0.1050781906,
0.1972790062,
0.3985287249,
0.3272396624,
-0.146811679,
0.4054434597,
0.9097340703,
-0.5143122077,
0.6011859179,
0.3627522588,
0.6738966703,
-0.9706431627,
-0.405992955,
0.118814677,
-0.2184575349,
-0.9238753319,
0.1063908562,
-0.2091026902,
-0.0156100513,
-0.6511607766,
0.1281867623,
-0.1796221137,
0.1350407898,
-0.2082519233,
0.0840100497,
-0.5102249384,
0.5826681256,
0.1577930152,
0.3647580743,
0.3510515392,
-0.1816183031,
0.6253651381,
0.1403288394,
-0.164501518,
0.8749440908,
-0.1156967804,
0.2487319112,
-0.1174662337,
0.3024063408,
-1.1903755665,
-0.062864922,
0.5355375409,
-0.5341607928,
0.0451406576,
-0.1567234993,
-0.263831377,
-0.2289101183,
-0.2943512797,
0.9316775203,
0.1686316729,
-0.4372142851,
0.9575769901,
0.7985024452,
-0.0115522929,
-0.4818140268,
-0.429112196,
0.1483221948,
-0.5252710581,
-0.7592036128,
0.5679637194,
-0.1873776615,
-0.2974508107,
-0.1328466833,
0.2100284249,
-0.1778372377,
-0.1572099328,
0.6681907177,
0.0842641443,
-0.0363184847,
-0.1483226269,
-0.2911006212,
0.0720160902,
0.1643259078,
-0.0637516826,
0.5107096434,
-0.0872515664,
-0.2316004038,
-0.4730212688,
0.8543584347,
0.6507341266,
-0.0945103094,
0.5589063168,
1.0524166822,
-0.4040775597,
-0.0136959199,
-0.6898551583,
-0.057354521,
-0.387217015,
0.3168909848,
-0.1754354239,
-1.2738312483,
0.446149379,
0.2732132673,
-0.0515173227,
0.6317789555,
0.946174264,
0.1608049721,
1.2330001593,
0.3752533495,
-0.0020820925,
0.5100104809,
0.1744464338,
0.3080627918,
-0.5474185944,
-0.5181104541,
-0.7459151149,
-0.2875715494,
-0.5800731182,
-0.524453342,
0.4725472629,
-0.457980454,
0.2566592395,
0.6449818611,
-0.4599675238,
0.3575851321,
0.3228106797,
-0.1570523679,
0.4236420393,
-0.043974638,
0.1692096442,
-0.2294410467,
-0.3458759785,
-0.1151517183,
0.8340139985,
0.1370930374,
0.2991651893,
0.4698957801,
0.5709504485,
0.654058814,
0.3387845457,
-0.7008860111,
0.4779124558,
-0.1091540456,
-1.0016695261,
-0.1940336823,
-0.2190375924,
-0.8376843929,
0.4501229525,
-0.6478458047,
-0.7495728731,
0.1330538094,
0.1960015744,
-0.0041161319,
0.379039973,
-0.4223480821,
0.9075354338,
0.1920451969,
-0.1577542722,
-0.4041101635,
-0.4018204808,
0.5080066919,
-0.2826137841,
0.7876585722,
-0.0921169892,
-0.0080571948,
1.0156316757,
0.2817485034,
0.7908915877,
-0.137907058,
-0.1337619126,
0.0195613988,
-0.0371016711,
0.5499945879,
-0.108607769,
0.0271927491,
0.215480864,
-0.0479908735,
-0.0881223604,
-0.3378683031,
0.680798769,
-0.3591648638,
-0.6204974651,
-0.4710924029,
-0.7577577829,
-0.0778076425,
-0.0346936099,
0.2467342913,
0.6627322435,
-0.2955850959,
0.247475937,
0.5900197625,
0.0845554769,
0.5636602044,
0.4393695593,
-0.0844569728,
-0.3504561186,
0.9275449514,
-0.0691247061,
0.0015302863,
0.198946327,
0.1152679026,
-0.2867959142,
-0.9090145826,
-0.4077450931,
-0.1668184549,
-0.6709459424,
0.0047349739,
-1.0431456566,
0.0491527021,
-0.5968446136,
-0.1020937711,
-0.2627609074,
-0.4479892254,
-0.1129523963,
0.3492919803,
0.0036303916,
0.8348869085,
-0.324760884,
-0.0280677266,
-0.5365669727,
0.4877102673,
0.3363526464,
-0.1411212981,
-0.3128262162,
-0.8419901133,
0.0546498522,
-0.2147425413,
-0.4723851979,
-0.7919313312,
0.2749823928,
0.0675450116,
0.5691923499,
0.2817979455,
0.2403299958,
0.4882842898,
-0.5520489216,
0.8806649446,
0.2871485651,
-0.875774622,
0.5480973125,
-0.3188470602,
0.0915957093,
0.2359492034,
0.9839040637,
-0.3366184533,
-1.0336104631,
-0.7940517068,
-0.6386874914,
0.673679769,
0.561128974,
0.1963141561,
-0.1872701049,
-0.3678465486,
-0.0504312478,
0.0408292077,
-0.9937596917,
-0.5793282986,
-0.0880697221,
-0.161685124,
0.1095101163,
-0.3847276866,
-0.501116693,
-0.2307635993,
0.7793935537,
-0.0738893598,
0.2838483453,
-0.0617081001,
-0.0643570274,
0.0247334391,
0.4260369539,
1.1016174555,
0.6546880603,
0.0191492103,
0.3034007549,
0.1898549199,
-0.6126292944,
0.040398635,
0.1435118318,
0.4242625535,
0.0796011239,
0.6792483926,
0.5074732304,
0.1509509385,
-0.6177183986,
0.8909218907,
-0.293305397,
-0.5311889052,
-0.7669757605,
-0.0238108039,
-0.2379685342,
0.7212082148,
0.6533324122,
0.1776394248,
0.3770378828,
-0.592392087,
0.440877378,
0.5857144594,
-0.5402011871,
-0.1615974009,
0.7020867467,
0.1600569785,
-0.3535630703,
0.0858601704,
-0.4425880313,
-0.9733373523,
0.6709855199,
0.650693655,
0.6538202167,
-0.3413602114,
0.0592779629,
0.3507036865,
0.2239066213,
0.6140557528,
-0.025106106,
-0.089475058,
-0.9116827846,
-0.1053136811,
-0.5885085464,
-0.3062515855,
0.2446954101,
-0.681855917,
0.1467825472,
-0.4037646651,
0.0478356369,
0.4364449978,
-0.2813092172,
-0.2142400742,
0.1178574115,
0.6396819949,
0.5089024305,
-0.9874051809,
0.6702411771,
0.4020731151,
0.0714579374,
-0.5540325046,
-0.1929252595,
0.7869852185,
-0.7424667478,
0.69546175,
0.0995298177,
-0.2946082354,
0.0094836857,
-0.3338794708,
-0.6197292209,
0.8469884992,
0.0271007549,
-0.4946345091,
0.1824372113,
0.0379156284,
0.4019346535,
-0.5449025035,
0.2443022877,
0.4540629685,
0.6132013798,
0.3499209285,
-0.9686812162,
0.1155124977,
-0.090671964,
-0.2724565864,
0.4999733567,
-0.3522755504,
0.8921430111,
0.2440557182,
-0.4480901062,
-0.0850811452,
0.5369341373,
0.1065831929,
0.4020124674,
0.925270617,
0.7274881601,
0.3166787028,
-0.1094804034,
0.7986215353,
0.14943856,
0.404664129,
0.9627378583,
0.0896668434,
0.5933189392,
0.394038111,
-0.1136336103,
0.4856476486,
0.1683653742,
-0.0922041237,
0.3725630045,
0.3135035932,
-0.7738664746,
-0.4533959031,
-0.3633593917,
-0.2154186815,
0.8537921309,
0.4231391549,
-0.324737668,
-0.2688388526,
0.5883575082,
0.1516305655,
0.174179554,
-0.4219794571,
0.7454294562,
-0.3893487751,
-0.5701267123,
0.3684931099,
0.1632124186,
1.0552873611,
-0.3165004849,
-0.0776805878,
0.2896379828,
0.2001358271,
-0.4029105604,
-0.8223791718,
0.605262816,
0.0469063856,
-0.3307209611,
-0.2727315128,
0.484362036,
-0.6073337197,
-0.3280105889,
0.5640440583,
-0.0790873244,
0.2331717461,
-0.2860334218,
-0.8709170818,
0.5693514347,
-0.0450353697,
-0.1346491873,
0.3307631314,
0.0928599983,
-0.2049552649,
0.2568639517,
0.5656936765,
-0.3932623267,
0.3571974635,
0.1225349009,
0.8357929587,
-0.2067150176,
-0.2293114811,
-0.8182125688,
0.3663570881,
-0.2362566292,
-0.5437927842,
0.8150666952,
0.7394391894,
1.101256609,
-0.0536342449,
0.4208066165,
-0.501568377,
0.470579803,
-0.3971448541,
0.3630825877,
-0.5543759465,
-0.2895055711,
-0.5144062638,
-0.7060852051,
-0.5537334681,
0.2362758964,
-0.2220534235,
-0.2544005215,
0.9175905585,
1.0669362545,
-0.1310234666,
0.3669659197,
0.4923457503,
-0.0279816389,
0.3581464589,
0.6911062002,
0.9722936153,
-0.3544560671,
0.9837983847,
-0.2896347046,
-0.3000001609,
-0.1682936251,
-0.9255102873,
-0.7463666201,
-1.1534070969,
-0.5227078795,
-0.2324265391,
-0.0381847955,
0.8122808337,
0.8120614886,
-1.0647630692,
0.0113282977,
0.3778757453,
0.0538272411,
-0.0096918717,
-0.3188654184,
-0.0277897734,
0.1235001311,
-1.1416115761,
0.6008636951,
0.330634445,
-0.2690916061,
-0.0354731493,
0.1159045622,
-0.7496183515,
-0.0167632233,
0.6996568441,
0.1272045374,
-0.7787814736,
-0.7903136015,
-0.5571117401,
0.0894482732,
-0.1346620619,
1.0448663235,
-0.6727548838,
0.2098366618,
0.3063924611,
0.6580842137,
0.5253334641,
-0.0635942444,
0.1225002632,
-0.7769380808,
0.3465350568,
0.4826331437,
0.3433936238,
0.0076742517,
-0.4452897012,
0.2876027524,
0.6392925978,
-0.6112581491,
-0.5794084668,
0.5184033513,
-1.2975492477,
-0.2206193954,
0.9288699627,
-0.0000150096,
-0.0257188659,
-0.6766071916,
-0.1659717262,
0.0737025738,
-0.3447231352,
0.557708323,
0.750335753,
-0.5084041357,
-0.4753303528,
-0.1701372415,
0.459954381,
0.3886688948,
-0.6623455286,
-0.2510205805,
0.6717318892,
-0.0216465537,
0.6330009699,
0.384318769,
-0.1202063411,
0.4880703092,
-0.0518522933,
0.0785218403,
-0.1376470476,
-0.5167909861,
-0.382237941,
0.76862216,
-0.5916413665,
-0.2065047175
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01963v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01963v1
|
Improving Large-Scale k-Nearest Neighbor Text Categorization with Label Autoencoders
| 2024-02-03T00:11:29 | 2024-02-03T00:11:29 |
Francisco J. Ribadas-Pena, Shuyuan Cao, Víctor M. Darriba Bilbao
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.IR, 68T50, 68T07, I.2.6; I.2.7; H.3.1
|
In this paper, we introduce a multi-label lazy learning approach to deal with
automatic semantic indexing in large document collections in the presence of
complex and structured label vocabularies with high inter-label correlation.
The proposed method is an evolution of the traditional k-Nearest Neighbors
algorithm which uses a large autoencoder trained to map the large label space
to a reduced size latent space and to regenerate the predicted labels from this
latent space. We have evaluated our proposal in a large portion of the MEDLINE
biomedical document collection which uses the Medical Subject Headings (MeSH)
thesaurus as a controlled vocabulary. In our experiments we propose and
evaluate several document representation approaches and different label
autoencoder configurations.
|
[
-0.2667349279,
-0.3891376853,
0.3203286529,
-0.06359642,
-0.1408682913,
0.1290842444,
-0.0427905396,
-0.4915851057,
0.5719889402,
0.4094320536,
-0.0647779927,
-0.4148496091,
-0.830121696,
0.3853752017,
-0.094816342,
1.0593286753,
-0.1322565377,
-0.0915341601,
-0.2491821945,
-0.1383677572,
0.0621973611,
-0.7493920922,
-0.4555201828,
-0.2147191614,
0.9767372012,
0.4167793393,
0.7893990278,
1.0977889299,
0.6221931577,
0.4092785418,
0.0034438579,
0.1536029726,
-0.4855626225,
0.1386951506,
0.0764287263,
-0.2601630986,
-0.2320423871,
-0.1503796428,
0.9317587018,
0.6488670111,
0.0549213961,
-0.159525454,
-0.1715569496,
0.5608754158,
-0.6989276409,
0.3382632434,
-0.4104005694,
0.2572208941,
-0.3335405588,
-0.1094522327,
-0.1026626155,
-0.2147568166,
0.1256453097,
-0.417753011,
0.353949815,
0.2333510667,
0.9598634243,
0.5939251781,
-0.5151900649,
-0.4512888193,
-0.5867470503,
0.6042125225,
-0.3664549291,
0.7723927498,
0.5828976035,
0.2282041609,
-0.2161450386,
-0.7799242139,
-0.4481547475,
-0.0616906807,
-0.1170075238,
0.152867049,
0.1611927003,
0.163728863,
-0.0210010372,
0.6981175542,
-0.6753841639,
0.4886089861,
-0.4016111493,
-0.4356783628,
0.4401495457,
0.2460283339,
-0.2062038332,
-0.1911842525,
-0.2930421531,
-0.3966005147,
-0.0762499496,
-0.2307961732,
0.0924946368,
0.0160344541,
0.374270469,
0.568015933,
-0.3597336411,
0.7815802097,
0.1881637871,
-0.3342711031,
0.6280303001,
-0.4930826426,
-0.0860334486,
0.3357233107,
0.9653123021,
0.2624572814,
-0.2008429617,
-0.3611664176,
-0.1459024847,
0.0140521172,
0.3653015196,
-0.7741536498,
-0.5234766006,
0.1237973198,
-0.6699917316,
-0.0513875484,
-0.0888312384,
-0.8925215006,
-0.3512744904,
-0.3064928055,
0.4701506197,
-0.1760759354,
0.088873513,
0.1249480247,
-0.0275818892,
0.1057464257,
0.0452546403,
-0.7149432302,
0.131945923,
0.280674845,
0.7404241562,
-0.1554170549,
-0.2773901224,
-0.3781711459,
0.3680950701,
-0.1405690759,
0.7668904662,
-0.5071527362,
-0.4849147201,
-0.1305932552,
0.2785467207,
-0.0435271561,
-0.717581749,
0.4137871563,
-0.6521751881,
0.0551533028,
0.0980237201,
-0.543862164,
0.1350971311,
0.403185457,
-0.7113272548,
1.0164928436,
0.2158702463,
-0.7415200472,
0.178529501,
-0.348911047,
-0.3306545913,
-0.1254283637,
0.0903426558,
-0.8873267174,
-0.224564746,
0.1805741489,
0.6857501268,
-0.1015787944,
0.1094065681,
-0.4730191231,
-0.08387243,
0.1112859696,
-0.108675085,
0.285762459,
0.2050483823,
-0.0615651347,
-0.0358792804,
-0.8399966955,
0.0043445602,
-0.0248304531,
-0.4671468139,
-0.7772794366,
-0.2157468498,
0.0568080097,
0.5064001083,
0.4344246686,
-0.6475952864,
0.5219402313,
-0.6499257088,
0.0967232287,
0.3176552653,
0.2248587757,
0.5158559084,
-0.1395340264,
0.0579643808,
0.1715281606,
0.287568748,
-0.0576707311,
-0.3542013764,
-0.8730822206,
-0.1970691085,
0.689381659,
0.3201076388,
-1.0678547621,
0.6221914887,
-0.3242773712,
-0.6653333902,
-0.5411416888,
0.3369493484,
0.4909406602,
0.3133668602,
0.5193160772,
-0.5359722972,
-0.1677530557,
-1.007510066,
0.2127638012,
-0.022325933,
-0.0534435138,
0.5109615922,
0.5667656064,
-0.6947949529,
0.7941759229,
-0.7809836268,
-0.6305884719,
0.5741659999,
0.5146672726,
-0.0556874983,
0.5652016401,
0.2344518602,
-1.1060043573,
-0.5408954024,
-0.0754164532,
-0.4892321825,
-0.0656107143,
0.2145190686,
-0.0461053923,
0.0547175482,
0.9800771475,
-0.2145078331,
0.2244267762,
0.3062626421,
-0.1739436388,
0.3278660476,
-0.6016873121,
0.023396112,
-1.0986945629,
-0.1358087808,
-0.0030870524,
0.0777153298,
-0.3668328822,
-0.2542564273,
0.181424588,
-0.1040810421,
0.02190369,
0.4674297869,
-0.6953335404,
-0.0380869769,
-0.4164986908,
0.0458105356,
-0.0504996367,
0.3181800246,
0.2386392653,
0.4306021929,
0.25699085,
-0.750472486,
0.5278565288,
0.1816439778,
-0.1602502167,
0.4816803038,
-0.3507488072,
0.0357273184,
-0.5561805964,
0.4178620279,
-0.9926413298,
-0.4697345495,
0.1475879699,
-0.345651716,
0.7133792639,
0.1461149156,
-1.0171715021,
-1.049675703,
-0.2346827835,
0.4862683117,
0.1646808982,
-0.4868921638,
0.4321211278,
0.6793937683,
-0.1181187183,
-0.4831524193,
-0.3281362355,
0.0545058437,
0.0503214858,
-0.1944710314,
0.3323081136,
-0.1492710412,
0.1510401815,
0.1624585688,
0.0993539244,
-0.5283857584,
-0.1827629954,
0.1323339194,
-0.0246180631,
-0.1189783961,
0.849057138,
0.0632526204,
-0.277310729,
-0.2099058181,
-0.5658537149,
0.1313853413,
0.0001793143,
0.1258358061,
-0.0579335839,
0.3016234338,
0.5450485945,
-0.3075740933,
0.6627982259,
0.7656126022,
-0.2489776164,
0.0274093449,
-0.6189523339,
0.088536188,
-0.4753710032,
0.5659512281,
-0.3224052489,
-0.809482038,
0.1430772543,
-0.4708951712,
-0.2497414201,
0.5116328597,
0.6491064429,
-0.1834195703,
0.5939813256,
0.8494105339,
-0.1694465727,
0.203029424,
-0.2990685701,
0.1113071069,
-0.8345471025,
-0.4476817548,
-0.7826112509,
-0.3228586614,
-0.6193002462,
-0.8753983974,
0.4843169749,
-0.0287976973,
-0.0485576577,
0.2135863602,
-0.8461124897,
0.3521021307,
0.3914108276,
0.2344544679,
0.1026727036,
-0.0029964796,
-0.1862099022,
-0.0378819555,
-0.9399539232,
-0.0618339367,
0.8417038321,
0.2635211349,
0.7245015502,
-0.0362442769,
0.7792164683,
0.0402071737,
0.6424584389,
-0.9878656864,
0.1699870974,
-0.4884575009,
-0.4978894591,
-0.3431513011,
-0.4889375567,
-1.4289736748,
0.306307435,
-0.3525651097,
-0.6005340219,
0.4435601532,
0.0716659874,
-0.1306628585,
0.2457671911,
-0.6605776548,
0.8871561289,
-0.2001280934,
-0.1709098071,
0.1570233852,
-0.8806867003,
0.1003740504,
-0.5720015764,
0.0371958353,
0.320551604,
-0.5068560839,
0.9962432384,
-0.5911855102,
0.7869437933,
0.0533944666,
-0.2260777801,
0.2918049395,
-0.2843315601,
0.3502424061,
-0.2127617896,
-0.1597982645,
0.113526918,
-0.0609944724,
-0.6024006605,
-0.3046342134,
0.7601800561,
-0.87021631,
-0.1557338536,
-0.4372180402,
-0.5332850218,
-0.4782094359,
0.3212257326,
0.4036280513,
0.491597712,
0.0730423704,
0.3344379961,
0.887953639,
-0.1622093618,
0.3579181731,
0.4466119707,
0.1071624532,
-0.6550459862,
1.2182796001,
0.460711956,
-0.0878984407,
0.5835886598,
0.2562782466,
-0.4848738015,
-0.3040848672,
-0.1578913927,
0.437661916,
-0.6614639163,
-0.363473475,
-1.0166722536,
-0.1359771043,
-0.3948530555,
-0.1691872776,
-0.3173540235,
-0.060839083,
-0.4004746079,
0.3587061167,
0.3202406466,
0.8599133492,
-0.0178049989,
0.4374077618,
-1.0394613743,
0.3952951431,
0.1980661005,
0.6769315004,
0.1732879728,
-0.2921545506,
-0.552780807,
-0.4000084102,
-0.212146461,
-0.6649127007,
0.3549444377,
0.1327607781,
0.4297849834,
0.4894848168,
0.3148600459,
0.4661618471,
-0.6256933808,
0.5191368461,
0.2490424812,
-0.2763779163,
0.3369202614,
-0.3088834286,
0.6273047328,
0.5103747249,
0.9966451526,
-0.274453342,
-0.3921291232,
-0.711955905,
-0.9570255876,
0.3204413652,
-0.0414571092,
-0.1534150243,
-0.0341484435,
0.512083292,
0.2187191695,
0.129068017,
-0.5856639147,
-0.4624186158,
-0.1595824063,
-0.5214326382,
-0.4739628434,
-0.3529707491,
0.2851888835,
-0.2652258873,
0.6438679695,
-0.1774370223,
0.3765488267,
0.447078228,
0.040575292,
0.087214306,
0.1077301577,
0.1728001833,
0.0959057808,
-0.1068122759,
0.194242537,
-0.1809210926,
-0.736765027,
0.1898924708,
0.5208445787,
-0.0780545026,
0.2634003758,
0.0477136895,
0.4534787536,
0.4091379344,
-0.3018867373,
0.4063992202,
-0.0137533545,
-0.3941830397,
-0.0726755708,
-0.1807221025,
-0.1273477823,
0.0937780142,
0.2200407833,
-0.2651844323,
0.2675109804,
-0.3031291366,
0.4433242083,
0.2115246654,
-0.5676517487,
0.0698636323,
0.4696625173,
0.0740986243,
-0.2513414621,
0.5458301306,
-0.2173192799,
-0.5938913226,
0.6911962628,
0.4798643291,
0.588858366,
-0.3439947665,
0.049915906,
0.6100302339,
0.2067243159,
-0.0694300085,
-0.2819242477,
-0.2231734544,
-0.3625160754,
-0.2892422378,
-0.7779325247,
-0.2048527598,
0.2399615943,
-0.3002077341,
-0.011951264,
-0.1598950475,
-0.2185053974,
0.3462330401,
0.0262597706,
-0.3984782994,
0.2593244612,
0.1236334443,
0.4902727008,
-0.555216074,
0.9706704021,
0.8576000333,
-0.1893617511,
-0.4983602166,
0.198606208,
-0.2194574326,
-0.1272747815,
0.9987599254,
0.1352576464,
0.0513402671,
0.0629377738,
-0.5266039968,
-1.2049292326,
0.7417861223,
-0.5590376854,
-0.6201111078,
-0.0249884147,
-0.1119013354,
0.6557116508,
0.0750145391,
0.0014289158,
0.0073911618,
0.3095962703,
-0.093335703,
-1.1377291679,
-0.359220475,
-0.1940209866,
0.123964116,
0.7034343481,
-0.8855630159,
0.5437713265,
0.052440878,
0.1133405641,
0.3224549294,
0.6463942528,
-0.3298876584,
0.4779610038,
0.4690970182,
0.5871510506,
0.8617296219,
-0.0426764078,
1.0350210667,
-0.1886261404,
0.4412584901,
1.0387761593,
-0.2166381031,
0.7424715161,
0.2787639797,
-0.036539793,
0.3670168221,
0.7237054706,
-0.3526401222,
0.5005816817,
0.5319241285,
-0.2670984268,
-0.1720803976,
-0.1592681855,
-0.3648914993,
0.5582727194,
0.8080487251,
-0.4533951283,
-0.4087647796,
0.547500968,
-0.2588025033,
-0.0219483338,
-0.6150815487,
0.9029997587,
0.0420786478,
-0.353451103,
0.7381139398,
0.0494302288,
0.7220413089,
-0.4397978783,
-0.0146118207,
0.3561761677,
0.4473554492,
0.0267548654,
-0.6313380003,
0.0514273345,
-0.5331901312,
-0.5078235269,
-0.0426973999,
1.0401670933,
-0.5730403066,
-0.3757537007,
0.2481488883,
0.3184810281,
0.438460201,
0.4081908762,
-0.7650540471,
-0.2344548851,
-0.3539642394,
-0.1396965384,
0.4863122404,
0.6913762689,
-0.2293601632,
0.553812623,
0.4781693816,
-0.1285466701,
0.199624747,
-0.313547343,
0.8997135758,
-0.6183148623,
-0.5648545027,
-0.3016137779,
-0.21278584,
-0.1136575341,
-0.2034960091,
0.7351986766,
0.8050965667,
0.8006732464,
-0.3132812679,
0.2426973879,
0.0323239639,
0.5277151465,
-0.3353593051,
0.5874006748,
-0.6524346471,
-0.3385414481,
-0.3473243415,
-0.8594436049,
-0.5513388515,
0.5660861135,
-0.384606719,
-0.128839165,
0.7107000351,
0.7461254597,
-0.0782588944,
-0.4836648703,
0.2871651053,
0.5541834235,
-0.2373310924,
0.6110265851,
0.4909643233,
-0.6123393774,
0.7677449584,
-0.4636787772,
-0.2506918907,
-0.2969206274,
-0.5871831775,
-0.7505882978,
-0.7933834791,
-0.5900393724,
-0.6761308312,
0.0684343353,
0.5659270883,
0.4611375034,
-0.5018780828,
0.1358760148,
0.3404003382,
-0.0483172424,
0.1023581177,
-0.2527583838,
0.8289166093,
-0.4273105562,
-0.7137056589,
0.0458850563,
0.3500064313,
0.1830848455,
-0.1867465675,
-0.0027606259,
-0.4399113357,
-0.3001116514,
0.7582131624,
0.597807169,
-0.3232806921,
0.0803212374,
-0.373583585,
-0.5638498068,
0.1793989837,
0.558924377,
-0.9595799446,
0.8424271345,
0.3990902603,
0.8543757796,
0.530415535,
-0.0629098043,
-0.0102524869,
-0.6141300201,
0.1034563929,
0.2479880154,
0.0810522288,
0.2308873087,
-0.4088601172,
0.5405683517,
0.3086234033,
-0.8199457526,
-0.4603905678,
-0.1006061286,
-0.9021832943,
-0.4439014792,
1.0784908533,
0.0507871211,
-0.5071154833,
-0.6583212614,
-0.2373702973,
0.2913996577,
-0.1929255575,
0.8142228723,
0.4893106222,
0.0347194485,
0.0224438496,
-0.5987189412,
0.4175275266,
0.2678674161,
-0.5671191812,
-0.2148571312,
0.5109221339,
0.0099986698,
0.7183592319,
0.7898449898,
-0.2792123258,
0.1020935848,
-0.0418121926,
0.1681728661,
0.1763035059,
-0.1217965335,
-0.2870885432,
0.2521502674,
-0.0796382651,
-0.1428622156
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01945v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01945v1
|
A Case Study on Filtering for End-to-End Speech Translation
| 2024-02-02T22:42:33 | 2024-02-02T22:42:33 |
Md Mahfuz Ibn Alam, Antonios Anastasopoulos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
It is relatively easy to mine a large parallel corpus for any machine
learning task, such as speech-to-text or speech-to-speech translation. Although
these mined corpora are large in volume, their quality is questionable. This
work shows that the simplest filtering technique can trim down these big, noisy
datasets to a more manageable, clean dataset. We also show that using this
clean dataset can improve the model's performance, as in the case of the
multilingual-to-English Speech Translation (ST) model, where, on average, we
obtain a 4.65 BLEU score improvement.
|
[
-0.4211961925,
-0.5657113194,
0.4455569088,
-0.2258942723,
-0.5914452076,
0.0601622649,
-0.6596412659,
-0.5996973515,
-0.1116627753,
0.7545226812,
-0.4318080544,
-0.6455873251,
-0.8010847569,
0.1860329211,
-0.8853960633,
1.2605874538,
0.2449581325,
0.1350491792,
-0.1062909588,
-0.0486084037,
-0.4327917099,
-0.5027917027,
-0.9493946433,
-0.3341388702,
0.4926680326,
0.3268080354,
0.8914980292,
0.7515637875,
0.5163477659,
0.2686831653,
-0.3417573571,
0.2020123154,
-0.8375535607,
0.3402019739,
-0.3674603403,
-0.6520751715,
0.0033952263,
-0.0735158399,
0.5770144463,
1.0035465956,
-0.1528977156,
0.1192396358,
-0.0268205311,
0.7594611645,
-0.3494169414,
0.0889479741,
-0.6551630497,
-0.0667805374,
-0.4587168694,
-0.0867106169,
-0.5970386863,
-0.0332935564,
-0.0749658942,
-0.4895008802,
0.2656171918,
0.2991054654,
1.1069036722,
0.5861527324,
-0.3678964972,
-0.2196348459,
-0.9308640957,
1.0598771572,
-0.5458466411,
0.6591801643,
0.7313944697,
0.3155134618,
-0.2324329466,
-0.762755692,
-0.249076739,
-0.0300712381,
-0.1975785941,
0.2768037319,
-0.3660635948,
0.1092812642,
0.3123404086,
0.4902619123,
-0.735178709,
0.2199218422,
-0.928008616,
-0.233783409,
0.656268537,
-0.1271448731,
0.2797008157,
-0.0041394476,
0.0310080573,
-0.1252512634,
-0.6643140316,
0.1490417719,
0.4213302135,
0.526348114,
0.2757228613,
0.4391998053,
-0.2971640825,
0.8858795166,
-0.3300664723,
0.072888799,
0.1592738628,
-0.4151152968,
-0.5114314556,
0.1328325719,
0.4005315602,
0.0888910145,
0.4563599229,
-0.2234475017,
-0.3080438077,
0.1006750017,
0.1470447779,
-0.9894642234,
-0.257684052,
0.3937557936,
-0.671138227,
0.0065109846,
-0.0262061562,
-0.4976531565,
-0.0631176904,
-0.7480682731,
0.1773697585,
-0.2264309675,
0.0066778893,
0.1386404335,
0.0009763878,
0.0577863865,
0.1849294007,
-0.5432777405,
0.58291471,
0.7073763609,
0.8434687853,
-0.0563101098,
0.0151872002,
-1.2348358631,
-0.0783028752,
-0.6493432522,
0.7624943852,
-0.5485935211,
-0.3143535852,
-0.0245167241,
-0.0906202123,
-0.0307223722,
-0.7508604527,
0.9019749761,
-0.484493047,
0.3379703164,
0.0016805646,
-0.6370551586,
-0.3831690252,
-0.2907160223,
-0.5820261836,
0.8605216742,
0.0294145141,
-0.128137216,
0.30078125,
-0.1712745577,
-0.7168938518,
0.0494280793,
0.1280402541,
-0.3509086967,
0.3697060347,
0.3417051136,
0.294108212,
-0.4713073373,
0.2993108928,
-0.2249306887,
-0.5933689475,
0.0112230554,
-0.3257712722,
0.816920042,
0.7528066039,
0.2388760448,
0.1936610043,
-0.7382196784,
-0.0732938349,
-0.3724401891,
-0.2077544332,
-0.4925760627,
0.1906396002,
0.2635380924,
0.3980868161,
0.0692122281,
-0.6864143014,
-0.3128177226,
-0.3922475874,
0.6648126245,
0.4362789392,
-0.1685007364,
0.3339314461,
-0.4844085872,
0.1948865205,
-0.0059461934,
0.0281735882,
-0.2888689935,
-0.7504063249,
-0.6419011354,
-0.7943411469,
0.7523856163,
0.5206440687,
-0.4418870509,
0.4122415185,
-0.3719035089,
-0.3921056092,
-1.066426754,
0.4996627569,
0.2921597958,
0.3463997841,
0.52341187,
-0.3042178154,
-0.5405738354,
-0.9673381448,
-0.35635975,
0.0801170766,
-0.2399285585,
-0.0099008465,
0.2688029408,
-0.0214665942,
0.7692353129,
-0.3611332178,
-0.5449564457,
0.0260777567,
-0.003679822,
0.5777139664,
0.388241291,
0.077285111,
-1.0100953579,
-0.5223973393,
0.1978948712,
-0.5597736835,
-0.3367802203,
-0.0466680303,
-0.2722094357,
-0.0596658066,
0.8312190175,
-0.519974947,
0.5155990124,
0.4865728021,
-0.2098547816,
0.1848473847,
-0.385594219,
0.1847369075,
-1.0403078794,
0.2208458632,
0.0513414592,
-0.8211138248,
-0.9942067266,
0.0069224206,
-0.0555322058,
-0.1646570712,
-0.5021172762,
0.2860261202,
-0.2681130469,
-0.1768048406,
-0.4907327294,
0.3266021311,
0.0204031095,
0.2943488955,
0.0362684615,
0.5658014417,
0.4726546109,
-0.8438625932,
0.2374579161,
0.3294122517,
-0.4828100204,
0.7245715857,
-0.4135109484,
-0.0331062153,
-0.3293458819,
0.2130716592,
-1.0791636705,
-0.0651022345,
-0.2950853407,
-0.5151732564,
0.4752377272,
-0.4334456623,
-0.5641460419,
-0.0760784298,
0.0103957709,
-0.0290452037,
0.7090988159,
-0.791844368,
0.1404031962,
0.3236202002,
-0.4039505422,
-0.2693170607,
-0.6064524651,
0.3380584717,
-0.2951462865,
-0.5385347009,
0.6708567142,
-0.1509513408,
-0.1362433583,
0.1040180698,
0.0315210074,
-0.2799690962,
-0.0406264216,
0.0771111771,
0.2061222941,
0.1424429715,
0.232307598,
0.1440054625,
-0.0164731909,
-0.0925124362,
-0.1727407575,
0.4779676795,
0.2190533727,
-0.2014821321,
-0.2452125251,
0.6147395372,
0.6694571376,
-0.2718609273,
0.6155534387,
0.6760680079,
-0.678065002,
-0.2117668986,
-0.3533219993,
-0.1617885679,
-0.3986272216,
0.4345171154,
-0.5579117537,
-0.7174163461,
0.4550384879,
-0.0323473364,
0.2469028831,
0.3789439797,
0.4333383143,
-0.3791136146,
1.1154100895,
0.297341913,
-0.2540131807,
0.5450466871,
-0.104941234,
0.5016615987,
-0.7868167758,
-0.0321706496,
-0.7450095415,
-0.3717809618,
-0.721080482,
-0.189611569,
0.1605888903,
0.2576049566,
-0.120016776,
0.3856411278,
-0.4166960418,
0.2292207032,
0.8669608235,
0.1885872632,
0.3995989859,
0.2866848707,
0.2946857214,
-0.0058216155,
-0.4140017033,
-0.2568364143,
1.0464349985,
0.1982567757,
0.3319595754,
0.1122664511,
0.6320698261,
0.2000534236,
0.1170918047,
-0.7299827933,
0.3753556013,
-0.8681574464,
-0.5487518311,
-0.4891869128,
-0.6431438923,
-1.0761595964,
0.4918688536,
-0.2175841928,
-0.450976789,
0.2506247163,
-0.1137984172,
-0.0011358352,
0.3878131509,
-0.7483239174,
0.6237105727,
-0.0960335359,
-0.4565826058,
-0.5786150694,
-0.403850764,
0.1414880455,
-0.3803669214,
0.5425456762,
-0.2018894404,
0.203985557,
0.6619995236,
-0.5931881666,
0.6156768799,
-0.1454268843,
0.2094341367,
0.3007692099,
-0.0141167175,
0.4807459116,
-0.3318838477,
-0.1686181277,
0.4792564809,
0.0861303285,
-0.5064934492,
-0.5154417157,
0.6545311809,
-0.7084752917,
-0.5466466546,
-0.1108483374,
-0.6333392859,
0.0835021883,
0.1617414057,
0.3019791842,
0.095054321,
-0.0217434522,
0.4975981712,
0.6941707134,
-0.1187642664,
0.4827015102,
0.5202402472,
-0.1010843813,
-0.3582392037,
0.9948937297,
0.4506619275,
0.084405899,
0.4370654523,
0.2360238284,
-0.4805446863,
-0.7566020489,
-0.7483648658,
0.1120200455,
-0.524045825,
-0.2711437643,
-0.3529785573,
-0.2852135301,
-0.4543454945,
0.1107936725,
-0.2551782131,
-0.4460928142,
-0.1802798659,
-0.1127333641,
0.4588560462,
0.4353724718,
-0.1648887843,
0.4128768146,
-0.6360158324,
0.4137613475,
0.0827111304,
0.3898798227,
-0.589425385,
-1.1462584734,
-0.4501692951,
-0.0159980599,
0.0294927284,
-0.6893387437,
0.7278937101,
0.5635825396,
0.4862187803,
0.1161338091,
0.0971274078,
0.8949143887,
-0.6468233466,
0.5478773117,
0.1274173856,
-1.0443390608,
0.5501348376,
-0.0755536035,
0.2042607665,
0.5270647407,
0.2473778129,
-0.7930303216,
-0.3057355881,
-0.2382851392,
-1.0966207981,
0.6179352403,
0.3285888433,
-0.0690441281,
0.1693167239,
0.3001607358,
0.0156371798,
0.358479619,
-0.3291780055,
-0.1840510368,
-0.1061000153,
-0.3765200973,
-0.4577692449,
-0.1481175423,
0.0640188158,
-0.1149116904,
0.935947001,
0.2907392681,
-0.0749267712,
0.1684027165,
-0.422824502,
-0.1957081556,
0.4070272446,
0.3269713819,
0.2729902565,
-0.1640824527,
-0.0122064911,
0.177632466,
-0.3147120476,
-0.1384798437,
0.1809165776,
-0.391579777,
0.0765086263,
0.1136387289,
0.7499454618,
0.1087967604,
-0.7378095388,
0.3411692977,
0.2468200326,
-0.3231905997,
-0.0465552211,
-0.1482093632,
-0.0366431884,
-0.1442212909,
0.1788926423,
0.0469773449,
0.4887321293,
-0.6186365485,
0.4627851844,
0.0802700669,
-0.542934835,
-0.0582236834,
0.7209091187,
-0.036600817,
-0.3744155169,
0.8731076121,
0.0179896131,
-0.3216178715,
0.2630734742,
0.4602142572,
0.6040379405,
-0.4317575097,
-0.0673416778,
0.3760200143,
0.5002575517,
-0.2041056752,
0.1213606894,
-0.0711276233,
-0.300501436,
-1.0213074684,
-0.7409294844,
-0.4688869119,
0.1872119159,
-0.8100956082,
0.3989427984,
0.2009898424,
-0.0240717921,
0.1272901893,
0.0810083002,
-0.8592076302,
0.5611796975,
0.2750246227,
0.6753326058,
-0.9983527064,
1.0300750732,
0.6140565872,
-0.3136867881,
-0.3706963658,
-0.6054737568,
-0.2988327444,
-0.5084864497,
0.5352605581,
0.114920646,
0.0140804546,
-0.1873713285,
-0.3376370966,
-0.9933129549,
0.49075073,
0.4494930804,
-0.9056606293,
0.1671858728,
0.3043600917,
0.8791093826,
-0.126369521,
0.1395181119,
0.6701962948,
0.4660734534,
-0.0604515746,
-1.0247056484,
-0.2739916742,
-0.4458614886,
0.014534831,
0.1894105077,
-0.556199491,
0.7216100693,
0.1842116714,
-0.1690350175,
-0.2685389519,
0.7944238186,
-0.0940482393,
0.4852550328,
0.6190291643,
0.5191633701,
1.0742998123,
-0.1645610929,
0.9484007359,
-0.4089522362,
0.0030930291,
1.2538129091,
-0.2503596842,
1.1188998222,
0.4757173359,
0.0377179682,
0.1656719297,
0.8934156895,
-0.0677624419,
0.6250345707,
0.5512168407,
-0.2166602015,
-0.3784575164,
-0.1932710409,
0.1117889583,
0.4823984504,
0.571179688,
-0.3091326952,
-0.0717847645,
0.2674031854,
-0.1775910258,
0.4758293331,
-0.4968573153,
0.6801125407,
0.2910033762,
-0.7916218638,
0.4498155415,
0.0745783076,
0.4336231649,
-0.2447259724,
-0.025871478,
-0.1775063723,
0.1040979922,
-0.4829902649,
-0.7148910165,
0.54455024,
0.1553474218,
-0.3207834959,
-0.3372584879,
0.5191967487,
-0.7984465361,
-0.4131562412,
0.5781624317,
0.608168602,
0.8722008467,
-0.2239425778,
-0.4730401039,
-0.035906896,
0.2090697289,
-0.2478702664,
0.3452227414,
0.1280845851,
-0.3363736868,
0.7065967917,
1.1061422825,
0.4649068415,
0.2408085912,
0.3239673376,
0.5057148933,
-0.492618978,
-0.4961545765,
-0.6060848832,
0.1988749802,
-0.1993591338,
-0.0368524976,
0.3933484852,
0.9134277701,
1.1693832874,
0.2965384126,
0.8469400406,
0.2539484799,
0.7601642609,
-0.448810637,
0.5627786517,
-0.334410727,
0.3324771523,
0.2289480567,
-0.8746946454,
-0.435218662,
0.6767707467,
-0.1804701537,
-0.2006002367,
0.6295188665,
0.8440412879,
-0.0894080102,
0.10870675,
0.9766082764,
0.2728744745,
0.4560989738,
0.4483280182,
0.470592916,
-0.6764444113,
1.0625743866,
-0.248317346,
-0.1271800101,
0.0034502414,
-0.5261805654,
-0.7383485436,
-0.5861249566,
-0.426744014,
-0.3882329166,
0.3154645562,
0.6861310601,
1.0622079372,
-0.9962698817,
-0.4587245584,
0.0580197386,
0.0666180551,
-0.5752084851,
-0.0239056386,
0.4465875626,
-0.5852159262,
-1.2507644892,
0.8332674503,
0.0126623046,
-0.4241464436,
0.132410869,
0.0288789608,
0.0252056401,
-0.008354296,
0.763843298,
0.0315677337,
-0.4126935005,
-0.1731956005,
-0.0962247029,
0.0367757082,
0.2056612968,
0.5784686208,
-0.5987116098,
0.6559368968,
0.3456204236,
0.5730923414,
1.0208045244,
-0.1816142499,
0.4830748737,
-0.731646955,
-0.0495367087,
-0.0304734204,
0.6277893782,
0.453587532,
-0.3107976913,
0.6625645161,
0.0437564477,
-0.6497340798,
-0.9592319131,
0.1103728637,
-0.9708941579,
-0.3578374982,
1.038892746,
-0.1099812984,
-0.2281667441,
-0.4372209013,
-0.1962804496,
0.5969975591,
-0.5189505816,
0.5594475269,
0.8715908527,
0.1099654436,
-0.0961966217,
-1.0439276695,
0.3483562469,
0.6031031013,
-0.4634326398,
0.1398435384,
0.4632170498,
0.2547938526,
0.0338390134,
0.338788271,
-0.1913141459,
0.1488300413,
-0.2484419048,
-0.0990809873,
-0.1403496116,
-0.3285433948,
-0.4692098796,
0.2307336926,
-0.1211303324,
-0.3612258136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01939v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01939v1
|
A Morphologically-Aware Dictionary-based Data Augmentation Technique for Machine Translation of Under-Represented Languages
| 2024-02-02T22:25:44 | 2024-02-02T22:25:44 |
Md Mahfuz Ibn Alam, Sina Ahmadi, Antonios Anastasopoulos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The availability of parallel texts is crucial to the performance of machine
translation models. However, most of the world's languages face the predominant
challenge of data scarcity. In this paper, we propose strategies to synthesize
parallel data relying on morpho-syntactic information and using bilingual
lexicons along with a small amount of seed parallel data. Our methodology
adheres to a realistic scenario backed by the small parallel seed data. It is
linguistically informed, as it aims to create augmented data that is more
likely to be grammatically correct. We analyze how our synthetic data can be
combined with raw parallel data and demonstrate a consistent improvement in
performance in our experiments on 14 languages (28 English <-> X pairs) ranging
from well- to very low-resource ones. Our method leads to improvements even
when using only five seed sentences and a bilingual lexicon.
|
[
-0.447681278,
-0.5118282437,
0.4764496982,
0.4229692221,
-0.2736743391,
0.1473928988,
-0.2440128773,
-0.3344234824,
0.6518536806,
0.4224722683,
-0.5154751539,
-0.3940272033,
-0.4262233078,
0.5082994699,
-0.5274341702,
0.6086519957,
-0.106770657,
0.0784036443,
-0.3415608704,
-0.137214452,
-0.2749340534,
-0.665944159,
0.047622785,
-0.0544989891,
0.2257898152,
0.3978999555,
1.0191651583,
1.3407109976,
0.3258965909,
0.3591917157,
-0.1588111967,
0.7386291623,
-0.1985134184,
0.0960086361,
-0.2147766501,
-0.5611640215,
-0.5192151666,
-0.4448255897,
0.8315534592,
1.0424814224,
0.2309752256,
-0.1360026598,
0.060999386,
0.673701942,
-0.4247579873,
0.3178792894,
-0.9253454208,
0.0293332543,
-0.7903624773,
0.0913597643,
0.0266450644,
0.0652344748,
-0.2501759231,
-0.9184430838,
0.4301935434,
-0.0487200208,
0.3835938275,
0.2257054448,
0.0092844749,
-0.1339567602,
-0.3959803283,
0.7195911407,
-0.5170131326,
0.4236736298,
0.2962889075,
0.2035477608,
-0.2651005387,
-0.4743233621,
-0.6551771164,
0.1407393962,
-0.2624705136,
0.124412775,
0.1592102945,
-0.0819537193,
0.20650056,
0.6425523758,
-0.4395182133,
0.1131770089,
-0.3380019367,
-0.1232873797,
0.4193634987,
0.316629231,
0.5501446128,
-0.395070523,
-0.0631661266,
-0.2452937514,
-0.8301083446,
-0.3585775197,
0.4196833074,
0.7578730583,
-0.1460664421,
0.9521397948,
-0.300714612,
0.5951803923,
-0.0711662695,
0.1079105213,
0.7103076577,
-0.8090126514,
-0.0323789492,
0.0753243864,
0.8238990307,
0.2920825183,
0.2570832074,
-0.1924638003,
-0.4580853283,
0.2467985749,
-0.0042090421,
-0.5824621916,
-0.1072806716,
0.246985659,
-0.106471546,
-0.1847915649,
-0.1232445091,
-0.8994812965,
-0.3660612702,
-0.2278162837,
0.1636844426,
-0.567209959,
-0.0609943792,
-0.031389568,
-0.1291523427,
-0.7436486483,
-0.0042241043,
-1.0542001724,
0.3545103669,
0.6032102704,
1.0975453854,
-0.0855603516,
-0.3233967721,
-0.3288927972,
0.2503345311,
-0.6018898487,
0.5062310696,
-0.4140505493,
-0.5497221351,
-0.1135966629,
-0.0868959874,
-0.0380632579,
-0.8713472486,
0.4869599342,
0.1040385067,
-0.0786160976,
-0.2994718254,
-0.4611958265,
0.1903359294,
0.0667651966,
-0.7818796635,
0.9151343107,
0.0853421316,
-0.8365020156,
0.2411761284,
-0.377179563,
-0.5673004389,
0.075019978,
-0.3348687291,
-0.1015593782,
0.2718102038,
0.839325726,
0.2953071296,
-0.2874437571,
0.1907843649,
-0.1262423396,
-0.1155553386,
-0.0264875796,
-0.2900624573,
0.4434955418,
0.1908612698,
0.1586706489,
-0.2556718886,
-0.8542460799,
-0.1545595676,
0.0160082933,
-0.1790774912,
-0.7124220729,
0.1711318642,
-0.0159155894,
0.0887585282,
0.297344625,
-0.8100277781,
0.3266464174,
-1.0366590023,
0.2787696719,
0.5040934086,
-0.3150505126,
0.6042454243,
-0.4354827702,
0.0791731104,
0.2491180152,
-0.1089829877,
-0.2779211104,
-0.6505360007,
-0.846051693,
-0.5380823612,
0.3653846681,
0.6683151126,
-1.2017730474,
0.2547666728,
-0.6287156343,
-0.2548264265,
-0.9275106192,
0.3709561825,
0.2249403596,
0.5071261525,
0.5637786984,
-0.3013771772,
-0.9464134574,
-0.9004340172,
-0.1618365943,
-0.0478396863,
-0.0343904644,
0.1897828579,
0.1743600368,
-0.488799423,
0.8074249029,
-0.2431566566,
-0.3636675179,
-0.1544843763,
0.0914727822,
0.5111656785,
0.7187013626,
0.5226641297,
-0.6626760364,
-0.5189567804,
0.4219203889,
-0.6599088907,
-0.3203805089,
-0.0919491723,
0.0510882288,
0.2092048377,
0.2036207616,
-0.7126290798,
0.0696344227,
0.5141761899,
0.1764148474,
0.0502600782,
-0.5977148414,
0.2395938933,
-1.1326819658,
-0.1988383085,
-0.1596970409,
-0.2294602543,
-0.7304244041,
0.0596308149,
0.3148441911,
-0.0753114223,
-0.4475839138,
0.5453588367,
-0.3896066844,
0.0948716104,
-0.2210119218,
-0.2194816321,
-0.391163826,
0.0714332759,
0.1309501231,
0.9747609496,
0.6299199462,
-0.3179558218,
0.3227420151,
0.3004634976,
-0.3969336152,
0.0772884041,
-0.429849714,
-0.0961072743,
-0.3049945831,
-0.0151676014,
-0.4913349152,
-0.557646811,
0.2431433648,
-0.384016484,
0.0950144306,
-0.2094198614,
-0.85198313,
-0.2798600793,
0.0113754608,
0.6347411871,
0.7059679031,
-0.5778049827,
0.2630806565,
0.5082258582,
-0.3358845115,
-0.1908885986,
-0.9074949622,
0.1370509565,
-0.0096056825,
-0.7283220887,
0.5846681595,
0.1925953776,
-0.3248473108,
-0.0259505007,
-0.0122474795,
-0.1997858137,
-0.2331654131,
0.1881752014,
0.0760843381,
0.1338452846,
0.2100468576,
0.434574157,
-0.0875972584,
-0.1908986121,
-0.4301925302,
0.4662345946,
0.2406473458,
-0.2256283015,
-0.1074793562,
0.5138481259,
0.5874856114,
0.0274476334,
0.6041232347,
0.1512684226,
-0.6494835615,
-0.179534331,
-0.2318090647,
-0.0104825003,
-0.4144163132,
0.1068387628,
-0.6670750976,
-0.347281754,
0.4770541191,
0.1542929411,
-0.0405879579,
0.4806645513,
0.7346793413,
-0.1496138871,
1.2745559216,
0.3570428491,
-0.1163773164,
0.1208361164,
-0.0712959543,
-0.0418417193,
-0.3473625481,
-0.2063673139,
-0.3643915355,
-0.0836284384,
-0.7691900134,
-0.9101806283,
0.5599361658,
0.1084394231,
0.4065167904,
0.5181619525,
-0.2916765511,
0.2541431487,
0.5953088999,
0.2076561898,
0.269374609,
0.2448406518,
-0.3858881891,
-0.2719837725,
-0.8192168474,
-0.1591204852,
1.2051465511,
0.0519695729,
0.5211254954,
-0.1068464369,
0.9329271317,
0.0699538663,
-0.1056647375,
-0.3981922865,
0.3465974629,
-0.6133181453,
-0.2943342626,
-0.0453278422,
-0.517311275,
-0.7993161082,
0.3692138791,
-0.3631013632,
-0.1471967846,
0.2414982021,
0.3345060945,
-0.0527957566,
0.1300856322,
-0.7050133944,
0.511126101,
-0.2077890188,
-0.0335002057,
-0.3309627175,
-0.3978900611,
0.1341830343,
-0.6162796617,
0.5814219117,
-0.0348410197,
-0.2861323059,
0.4281180799,
-1.0693663359,
0.5393972993,
0.0379377119,
0.1946879774,
0.0972119793,
-0.0531451926,
0.7193942666,
0.0083643505,
-0.0166824926,
0.3277046084,
-0.1568451375,
-0.5161651969,
-0.6617675424,
0.8763113618,
-0.5574011803,
-0.6326850653,
-0.1419910491,
-1.1489620209,
-0.4395205379,
0.0594870597,
0.1025699228,
0.0873865709,
0.2268133909,
0.0281341504,
0.2896547019,
-0.1183358505,
0.2236682624,
-0.0011809495,
-0.2218864113,
-0.6612331867,
1.0678489208,
0.4424488246,
0.1548970342,
0.4410690963,
0.2273527384,
-0.1841140985,
-0.5897917151,
-0.9267858267,
0.2061374187,
-0.2318413705,
-0.0216230433,
-0.6754456162,
-0.0306544621,
-0.5410972238,
-0.0313074365,
-0.4666682184,
-0.8940039873,
-0.0116938418,
0.0572607443,
0.4205233455,
0.4058709741,
-0.4916023016,
0.1988452524,
-1.0215457678,
0.5667370558,
-0.0207639355,
-0.0614906214,
-0.4099098146,
-0.1155048758,
-0.1959500462,
0.4710323513,
0.2547533214,
-0.7885670066,
0.7530133128,
0.1452860832,
0.5219784975,
0.0033218465,
-0.1777298748,
1.0038878918,
-0.8429191113,
0.5219513178,
0.1781499684,
-0.8223767877,
0.6100648046,
-0.4337679148,
0.1714171022,
0.2604419887,
0.2895036638,
-0.303616643,
-0.6504166722,
-0.4944347739,
-0.962181747,
0.5706790686,
0.6919367313,
0.1892155856,
-0.2183651924,
-0.045765575,
0.3468370438,
0.2683685124,
-0.1541653723,
-0.326932162,
-0.2180065811,
-0.5493139029,
-0.1560656875,
-0.1274641454,
0.10454797,
-0.4061870575,
0.5461150408,
0.0295437854,
-0.1917704344,
0.1038420573,
-0.216612339,
0.0287009142,
0.0091120554,
0.2139144391,
0.3706178069,
-0.1581456959,
0.1528419405,
0.0861250833,
-0.4821633697,
0.0664683282,
0.4022720456,
-0.4376049042,
0.5207810402,
0.0671191365,
0.5705389977,
-0.0972761214,
-0.8153887391,
0.1904893965,
0.499604255,
0.1480868757,
0.2199597061,
-0.304399699,
-0.059625648,
0.1939616501,
0.2157373428,
0.2946903408,
0.1285134703,
-0.3812860847,
0.3366649449,
0.3205908239,
0.2017555237,
-0.2979505062,
0.5391944647,
0.2979417145,
-0.0027434875,
0.501796484,
0.0262061674,
-0.3694298863,
0.4760353863,
0.5918138623,
0.5146265626,
-0.110905841,
0.0804593638,
0.3508706391,
0.2731248438,
-0.2380932719,
0.3657765687,
-0.2242245674,
-0.5974597931,
-0.4269942939,
-0.6107173562,
-0.1371902823,
-0.1080029681,
-0.3003329635,
0.2311888337,
-0.1921161264,
-0.0345410444,
0.0093690054,
-0.3151749671,
-0.4589085877,
0.1602078378,
0.1524735242,
0.8793939948,
-0.9051231742,
0.9837736487,
0.7448298931,
-0.3206620812,
-0.3298369646,
-0.2570018172,
-0.0638071746,
-1.0803416967,
0.655246377,
-0.0645637587,
0.2804584205,
-0.0492928773,
0.0359621011,
-0.8712459803,
0.4746973515,
0.5347278714,
-0.7241652608,
-0.035394948,
0.8287953734,
0.6508063078,
-0.102820605,
-0.0686277151,
0.3693543375,
0.4159726202,
0.0184001885,
-1.0951087475,
-0.1732952595,
-0.3528039157,
0.2813655138,
0.3751722872,
-0.0828445852,
1.0404180288,
0.0503481105,
-0.5436840653,
0.3698016107,
0.6561369896,
0.234982565,
-0.0394647382,
0.4252997935,
0.8237705827,
0.543895781,
-0.1607497483,
1.0877048969,
-0.5226135254,
0.1739380807,
0.7871794701,
0.1367057115,
0.567414999,
0.9236947894,
-0.05836666,
0.0195764862,
0.5392195582,
0.1920744777,
0.6185277104,
0.0345231295,
-0.2143210471,
-0.3185318112,
-0.4098225534,
-0.4169573784,
0.1455370784,
0.6264884472,
-0.4969551861,
-0.4326516986,
0.0956094265,
-0.1353485286,
0.4458899498,
-0.5374560952,
0.4503436387,
-0.0436711498,
-0.4780935049,
0.7636321783,
0.1207935363,
0.646540761,
-0.2393560559,
-0.0580888912,
-0.5229206085,
0.1913050413,
-0.1874528378,
-0.9013422132,
0.4282522202,
0.2528573871,
-0.3673495948,
-0.4650106132,
0.4570539892,
-0.7220185995,
-0.8285086751,
-0.0192986187,
0.7063847184,
0.3503323197,
-0.081613265,
-0.4067471623,
0.0056294892,
-0.1980891228,
0.494305253,
0.2676406801,
0.4834886193,
-0.452436626,
0.5791866779,
0.7179477215,
0.6648532748,
0.4703017175,
0.0447262563,
0.815361321,
-0.2529464364,
-0.4380015135,
-0.7750591636,
0.4416689575,
-0.114907749,
0.0430220775,
0.9054527879,
0.7272791266,
1.2035909891,
-0.1971146017,
0.9149122238,
-0.1162088588,
0.7054581642,
-0.5518910885,
0.498686552,
-0.5364186764,
0.1398118287,
-0.0837577954,
-0.8205365539,
-0.3366978467,
0.1292932183,
-0.0253701713,
-0.5201134086,
0.345154494,
0.9704768658,
-0.3516350091,
-0.2606236637,
0.407926023,
0.1182250902,
-0.1270737052,
0.5639249682,
0.5320402384,
-0.5609034896,
0.4088217318,
-0.7536521554,
-0.0452462398,
0.1474532187,
-0.4314652979,
-0.6127479672,
-0.7117301822,
0.0971011147,
-0.1135519668,
0.299998343,
0.8794550896,
0.4291434884,
-0.9197096229,
-0.2064602375,
-0.5132239461,
0.0914121196,
-0.1207170635,
-0.1160134748,
0.193692714,
-0.6599559188,
-1.2888358831,
0.7854654193,
0.3290684521,
0.2851857245,
0.0155255971,
-0.0081309546,
0.0281103123,
-0.0351691805,
0.3902199864,
0.2154329717,
-0.672208786,
-0.0077470667,
-0.1360566169,
-0.1788104475,
0.0878077,
0.8170387745,
-1.0508348942,
0.9310856462,
0.8533319235,
1.012234807,
0.1874668896,
0.270398736,
0.8211865425,
-1.0463474989,
0.6205467582,
0.0572646968,
0.505697906,
0.4180136919,
-0.2565017343,
0.3289485872,
0.7389858365,
0.096400924,
-0.8737463951,
-0.0019110866,
-0.6329315901,
-0.2128111124,
0.9902345538,
0.0742808729,
-0.2491660118,
0.1275316328,
-0.0060365247,
0.1480180472,
-0.1650631726,
0.6579417586,
0.4149911404,
0.1079748496,
0.0641713142,
-0.2224812657,
0.4312318563,
0.5077086091,
-0.7238830924,
-0.0665593594,
0.6154217124,
-0.1185185909,
0.323692143,
0.3339376748,
-0.1473789513,
0.0517455153,
0.252916187,
-0.2335114181,
-0.196505487,
-0.4426003397,
-0.1293896884,
0.0346536525,
-0.3235872984,
-0.4402500987
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01935v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01935v1
|
Code Representation Learning At Scale
| 2024-02-02T22:19:15 | 2024-02-02T22:19:15 |
Dejiao Zhang, Wasi Ahmad, Ming Tan, Hantian Ding, Ramesh Nallapati, Dan Roth, Xiaofei Ma, Bing Xiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent studies have shown that code language models at scale demonstrate
significant performance gains on downstream tasks, i.e., code generation.
However, most of the existing works on code representation learning train
models at a hundred million parameter scale using very limited pretraining
corpora. In this work, we fuel code representation learning with a vast amount
of code data via a two-stage pretraining scheme. We first train the encoders
via a mix that leverages both randomness in masking language modeling and the
structure aspect of programming language. We then enhance the representations
via contrastive learning with hard negative and hard positive constructed in an
unsupervised manner. We establish an off-the-shelf encoder model that
persistently outperforms the existing models on a wide variety of downstream
tasks by large margins. To comprehend the factors contributing to successful
code representation learning, we conduct detailed ablations and share our
findings on (i) a customized and effective token-level denoising scheme for
source code; (ii) the importance of hard negatives and hard positives; (iii)
how the proposed bimodal contrastive learning boost the cross-lingual semantic
search performance; and (iv) how the pretraining schemes decide the downstream
task performance scales with the model size.
|
[
-0.5408902764,
-0.1091146022,
0.1229230016,
0.1957992315,
-0.399179846,
0.2742395401,
-0.4140783846,
-0.3619959652,
0.1660527885,
0.4381632209,
-0.1343054175,
-0.4840150476,
-0.7470299006,
0.054395888,
-0.0995867848,
0.9161214828,
0.0933720395,
0.3770437539,
-0.0175198242,
-0.063566424,
-0.4755994081,
-0.576369226,
-0.557461679,
-0.4614268541,
0.5138090253,
0.4126709402,
0.4718469679,
0.7288492918,
0.4132152796,
0.2159014195,
0.1193073764,
-0.1279632747,
-0.740060389,
-0.0466051064,
0.0044012163,
-0.5904014111,
0.1691516042,
0.0012410993,
0.4193952382,
0.7712150812,
-0.2003824413,
0.0126021476,
-0.0034344012,
0.5756618381,
-0.4427009821,
0.3260401785,
-0.627908051,
0.1117843017,
-0.0339378901,
-0.1693653911,
-0.537758708,
-0.1748046577,
-0.3420117497,
-0.4375318885,
0.0932366699,
-0.030450955,
0.6319805384,
0.2865394056,
-0.4703053832,
-0.4725082815,
-0.7185322642,
0.7185467482,
-0.5192666054,
0.4456674159,
0.1871070862,
0.2049564123,
0.2867131829,
-0.7811935544,
-0.2178499252,
-0.2162997872,
-0.1223069653,
-0.1015430018,
-0.0562584363,
0.1579020172,
0.4652527869,
0.554530859,
-0.5895362496,
0.2118881643,
-0.7031968236,
-0.2222490609,
0.3313005865,
-0.178338483,
0.2005939037,
0.0185275823,
-0.281639576,
-0.4136882424,
-0.7602182627,
-0.0911805034,
0.2400940955,
0.265496403,
-0.1517331451,
0.3310335279,
0.0044671115,
0.564165175,
0.1124245301,
0.2632638216,
0.3288922906,
-0.1999823153,
-0.072784856,
-0.0915759876,
0.4331623614,
0.0073271231,
0.190823853,
-0.2652877867,
-0.379542917,
0.2700244188,
0.7348238826,
-1.2173804045,
-0.401556462,
0.1121724695,
-0.5710409284,
-0.1103780717,
0.081018962,
-0.5224051476,
-0.5026682019,
-0.6363658309,
0.477668345,
-0.3271431029,
-0.4851574898,
0.1177484691,
-0.1005485877,
0.3671709597,
0.0350810811,
-0.8296096921,
0.1890178621,
0.3242404759,
0.495331645,
0.1973896921,
-0.0257509537,
-0.5561047792,
-0.1826047301,
-0.6999240518,
0.4164162874,
-0.8271307349,
-0.3176011741,
-0.011011513,
-0.2521152496,
0.1693538576,
-0.7905911207,
-0.0966087878,
-0.8978130817,
-0.2174851745,
-0.0418086648,
-0.4579507113,
-0.166839242,
0.0933417603,
-0.681142211,
0.6961088777,
0.4922297299,
-0.5943099856,
0.4552073479,
-0.4256018698,
-0.4267282486,
0.1096485108,
-0.5191040039,
-0.3706330955,
0.4529462755,
0.08780922,
0.511831224,
-0.0739255324,
-0.0092013916,
-0.0025216059,
-0.6617701054,
-0.034560401,
0.0146075338,
0.5866500139,
0.4654711485,
-0.4094952345,
0.1116909906,
-0.8269882798,
-0.0625893623,
0.0272355694,
-0.4275817871,
-0.3209991455,
-0.3440485299,
0.0155223301,
0.3600413799,
0.2990353405,
-0.4803498983,
0.1588136256,
-0.2287710458,
0.4180645943,
0.2815220356,
0.0001235604,
0.6291460991,
0.1333253682,
0.6715639234,
0.3075914383,
-0.148816213,
-0.3483593166,
-0.091675736,
-0.5767813325,
-0.1095824018,
0.3532311618,
0.1533042789,
-0.8759649396,
0.2617558837,
-0.0846180096,
-0.4900949597,
-0.4257276058,
0.408185184,
0.6481454968,
0.0577424839,
0.5060282946,
-0.5026632547,
-0.674864471,
-0.7267147303,
0.0303758848,
-0.1093705818,
-0.3802370727,
-0.0119902743,
0.4920736551,
-0.4972271919,
0.6673656106,
-0.6040919423,
-0.1236560419,
-0.3954617977,
0.5600511432,
0.1965756863,
0.8073944449,
0.2727952898,
-1.034994483,
-0.309068352,
-0.0053812922,
-0.3857395351,
0.0666640997,
-0.2049649954,
0.0637748539,
0.0719727203,
1.0924489498,
-0.0670559332,
0.112930648,
0.7385324836,
-0.1925059706,
0.3381553888,
-0.5440923572,
0.0207114778,
-0.9264893532,
0.0954116508,
-0.0176201984,
-0.1446061879,
-0.5472432971,
0.4196322262,
0.4759640992,
-0.5005550981,
-0.2546101809,
0.0451516695,
-0.6833506227,
-0.1442310065,
-0.1961767823,
-0.2523765862,
-0.072382316,
0.814414978,
0.2482323498,
0.7417603135,
0.5457639694,
-0.5015339851,
-0.0206428822,
-0.1966435313,
-0.2517008483,
0.1113157421,
-0.7223363519,
0.227285549,
-0.2448029965,
0.1760376543,
-1.1573342085,
-0.1429595798,
-0.2821249962,
-0.4235320687,
0.7321850657,
-0.3912359178,
-0.5356256366,
-0.2744591534,
-0.0948133394,
0.5848136544,
0.7664375901,
-0.5582464933,
0.333215028,
0.374974817,
0.0946328193,
-0.140402928,
-0.6900334358,
-0.0592477396,
-0.0272579081,
-0.1735742241,
0.3272401094,
0.0672778636,
0.014694931,
-0.2144067436,
-0.261244297,
-0.2041111588,
-0.0404492691,
0.3062492311,
0.0792978704,
-0.2229577452,
0.246275112,
-0.1182584167,
-0.254093647,
0.0861679837,
-0.3821956813,
0.7769649029,
-0.1557442099,
-0.2816852629,
0.2760980129,
0.3027255535,
0.4927583933,
-0.5552176237,
0.745701313,
0.7536700964,
-0.3810963035,
-0.3365972936,
-0.2964673936,
-0.1720496267,
-0.4616224468,
0.6063970327,
-0.1824147999,
-0.9221127629,
0.610670805,
-0.2393105775,
0.0362645574,
0.174141556,
0.4047978818,
0.1503442824,
1.0145785809,
0.9707580805,
-0.0546019785,
0.6526418328,
-0.5277986526,
0.3032901585,
-0.5724788904,
-0.2890735865,
-0.6664130688,
-0.2083210647,
-0.6320753098,
-0.9319629073,
0.2608805597,
0.6146896482,
-0.5845787525,
0.5791884661,
-0.5563775301,
0.68387115,
0.3964180052,
0.2697205842,
0.0724487901,
0.187855348,
0.0078567751,
0.0228441041,
-0.5538226962,
-0.2739466727,
1.0517390966,
0.4933219552,
0.9067366123,
-0.1182478443,
1.0036981106,
0.1801397949,
0.3947013915,
-0.436106503,
0.1437287778,
-0.3677794933,
-0.4703422487,
-0.2747525573,
-0.6477767825,
-0.649969995,
0.2652434409,
-0.0520746522,
-0.2301977128,
0.3755352795,
0.0481798723,
-0.2795448899,
0.1452859938,
-0.9440541863,
0.9972282052,
0.060022179,
-0.1532054991,
-0.4670089781,
-0.7318225503,
0.041114077,
-0.1458293498,
0.2938830853,
0.5003318191,
-0.2370223701,
0.5964756608,
-0.2738147378,
0.9122585654,
-0.3775219321,
-0.235659346,
0.1824941635,
0.2241066098,
0.4870350361,
0.1106800735,
-0.0716090947,
0.2966018617,
-0.359323889,
-0.6633582711,
-0.4844032526,
0.3694978952,
-0.8171479106,
-0.2352504283,
0.0472075567,
-0.3620092273,
-0.1816355884,
0.276543051,
0.3831787705,
0.7894726396,
0.1140029654,
0.4656136334,
0.8099811077,
-0.4055131674,
0.2509335577,
0.154417038,
-0.2479722947,
-0.2646650374,
1.1275368929,
-0.05997172,
0.3159911633,
0.6288318038,
-0.1559856683,
-0.201899901,
-0.8025456071,
-0.4857213795,
0.1200186089,
-0.8611713052,
-0.216792047,
-0.480024606,
-0.2544482946,
-0.2510358989,
-0.3702955544,
-0.3894357681,
-0.0596364997,
-0.2946072519,
-0.098454237,
0.0517898239,
0.9169892669,
-0.0434154831,
0.1685660034,
-0.650398314,
0.3656253219,
0.1974998713,
0.5697565079,
0.0799847692,
-0.4325705767,
-0.740363121,
-0.0391446203,
-0.0878957659,
-0.4678914845,
0.3325110972,
-0.0840018317,
0.391979754,
0.4107729495,
0.0188322943,
0.6638104916,
-0.3665746152,
0.6687654853,
0.4890768528,
-0.7683874369,
0.3349283338,
-0.0919179767,
0.5065783858,
0.6776777506,
0.5758368373,
-0.3415620029,
-0.4541629851,
-0.2477749437,
-0.7158428431,
0.6060836911,
0.0607914813,
0.3307828009,
-0.1192260087,
0.2950637043,
0.1822435409,
0.2505132258,
-0.9411497116,
-0.0045269066,
-0.5482184291,
-0.1464750916,
-0.3701272309,
-0.1761516482,
0.1429494023,
-0.221103549,
0.2329248339,
-0.2254047692,
0.335629493,
-0.0197399501,
-0.3774222732,
-0.0379800424,
0.1682361811,
0.3586109281,
0.6042048335,
-0.0999334753,
0.4006156623,
-0.1874195039,
-0.5257454515,
-0.049598936,
-0.0485437401,
0.2938494682,
-0.2136838287,
0.5396565199,
0.6458266377,
0.3482713997,
-0.7602230906,
0.5178728104,
0.0287869051,
-0.0971256644,
0.0372437984,
-0.0191981513,
0.2810406089,
0.1339432746,
0.5041164756,
0.2420068085,
0.0066302079,
-0.6453812122,
0.2944929302,
0.1129751205,
-0.3890426457,
-0.23030141,
0.5506643653,
0.2219258547,
0.0595575608,
0.6537232399,
-0.4906978309,
-0.659036696,
0.8555346727,
0.5274832845,
0.5516480207,
-0.062297482,
0.2611861527,
0.5392881036,
0.2930352092,
-0.0563800856,
0.0959982798,
-0.3884032965,
-0.5145370364,
-0.4440316558,
-0.8222849369,
-0.1304511428,
-0.0754042938,
-0.5983980894,
0.2197546512,
-0.5702628493,
0.3420206904,
-0.3397131264,
0.3080814481,
-0.7408236265,
0.2351196408,
0.4683256149,
0.898393333,
-0.8129229546,
0.910317421,
0.7211118937,
-0.8096289039,
-1.0462236404,
-0.0195463412,
-0.4198568165,
-0.7510821819,
0.9007559419,
0.365434587,
0.011346722,
0.1328291595,
-0.5248540044,
-0.7325251102,
0.7931491733,
0.290792942,
-0.7633262277,
-0.0790953115,
0.0541760065,
0.7309787869,
-0.6613374949,
0.2807006836,
0.2423813045,
0.0463276245,
0.1564848125,
-0.4556752741,
0.0990223065,
-0.2798662782,
0.4090549052,
0.2520868182,
-0.2348775864,
1.0129078627,
-0.2380586416,
-0.2999887466,
-0.2738399506,
0.4770384431,
0.1772543937,
-0.003752111,
0.5520095825,
0.3459153771,
0.5305217505,
0.1742849797,
1.0785531998,
-0.5298401117,
0.2561182082,
0.7858622074,
-0.1466597915,
0.792891562,
0.4553812146,
-0.1346991211,
0.7883909345,
0.668392837,
0.0620291792,
0.6096579432,
0.6238767505,
0.081849888,
-0.390003711,
0.1182767153,
-0.4535832703,
0.1849230677,
0.3286468983,
-0.42204988,
-0.308324486,
0.3072455227,
-0.2580358684,
0.1911137551,
-0.5092094541,
0.6739628315,
0.0940549821,
-0.5186845064,
0.7228876948,
-0.0369696468,
0.7791780829,
-0.7012350559,
-0.2762606442,
-0.4022358656,
0.1582675129,
-0.2995240688,
-0.3560014069,
0.26697281,
0.0035645966,
-0.2212146372,
-0.4225545526,
0.5651842952,
-0.6284886599,
-0.2683626711,
0.5785835385,
0.0947136804,
0.1379236877,
-0.1725765318,
-0.2821550965,
0.2812260091,
-0.0044683251,
-0.1204760894,
0.5177714229,
0.6141808033,
0.0293597467,
0.3208800256,
0.4348171055,
0.1428427994,
0.1691573858,
0.2619660199,
1.0771795511,
-0.6557565331,
-0.6658009887,
-0.3983766735,
0.4039873183,
-0.0220564492,
-0.1257420182,
0.4639291167,
0.6520678401,
1.214646697,
-0.1924730837,
0.388021946,
-0.1128371432,
0.0900781155,
-0.484176904,
0.6029937267,
-0.5244087577,
0.4637096226,
-0.1019669026,
-1.0147148371,
-0.4410362244,
0.4995386899,
-0.204341948,
0.1402442902,
0.5901317596,
0.9643982649,
-0.0556680076,
-0.0712376684,
0.515088737,
0.1410659999,
0.2317873985,
0.6756608486,
0.5964022279,
-0.3384034038,
0.7630087137,
-0.2215547264,
-0.2291258425,
-0.2679643631,
-0.6208966374,
-0.8367426991,
-0.6743171811,
-0.3603130579,
-0.206381619,
-0.2712637484,
0.9267332554,
0.9698808193,
-0.6836520433,
-0.2920362651,
-0.4403080642,
0.0041382452,
-0.1891993582,
-0.1273142248,
0.15632011,
-0.7681235075,
-0.40664047,
0.1574091017,
0.1885418445,
-0.2436963171,
-0.4570219517,
-0.3537040949,
0.1964291781,
-0.0553385615,
0.6400957108,
0.2288258374,
-0.179555878,
-0.1660166681,
-0.1637729853,
-0.4503804445,
0.182818681,
1.2503062487,
-0.898524642,
0.3924871087,
0.4333967865,
0.7841201425,
0.6901350617,
-0.19532004,
0.4784640372,
-0.9981908202,
0.1059909239,
0.2560200989,
0.2577393949,
0.2736185789,
-0.2768704593,
0.4535338283,
-0.095928587,
-0.3436580002,
-0.706787765,
0.2542155981,
-0.6816557646,
-0.722361207,
1.0309234858,
-0.100435704,
0.0195028652,
-0.2014822811,
-0.1694727391,
0.3052114844,
-0.2308175415,
0.5004771352,
0.3876735866,
0.0044233147,
-0.1813215017,
-0.217829749,
0.3442949057,
0.1489948183,
-0.4020797908,
0.1749647558,
0.4618316591,
0.2477665842,
0.4815478921,
0.4806405902,
-0.4860338867,
0.2064079046,
0.5023394823,
0.3732881546,
-0.1886018366,
-0.4730374813,
-0.7206586003,
0.4062864482,
0.2027281821,
-0.1154654026
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01931v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01931v1
|
Digits micro-model for accurate and secure transactions
| 2024-02-02T22:01:27 | 2024-02-02T22:01:27 |
Chirag Chhablani, Nikhita Sharma, Jordan Hosier, Vijay K. Gurbani
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) systems are used in the financial domain
to enhance the caller experience by enabling natural language understanding and
facilitating efficient and intuitive interactions. Increasing use of ASR
systems requires that such systems exhibit very low error rates. The
predominant ASR models to collect numeric data are large, general-purpose
commercial models -- Google Speech-to-text (STT), or Amazon Transcribe -- or
open source (OpenAI's Whisper). Such ASR models are trained on hundreds of
thousands of hours of audio data and require considerable resources to run.
Despite recent progress large speech recognition models, we highlight the
potential of smaller, specialized "micro" models. Such light models can be
trained perform well on number recognition specific tasks, competing with
general models like Whisper or Google STT while using less than 80 minutes of
training time and occupying at least an order of less memory resources. Also,
unlike larger speech recognition models, micro-models are trained on carefully
selected and curated datasets, which makes them highly accurate, agile, and
easy to retrain, while using low compute resources. We present our work on
creating micro models for multi-digit number recognition that handle diverse
speaking styles reflecting real-world pronunciation patterns. Our work
contributes to domain-specific ASR models, improving digit recognition
accuracy, and privacy of data. An added advantage, their low resource
consumption allows them to be hosted on-premise, keeping private data local
instead uploading to an external cloud. Our results indicate that our
micro-model makes less errors than the best-of-breed commercial or open-source
ASRs in recognizing digits (1.8% error rate of our best micro-model versus 5.8%
error rate of Whisper), and has a low memory footprint (0.66 GB VRAM for our
model versus 11 GB VRAM for Whisper).
|
[
-0.0668901429,
-0.5466968417,
0.3338098526,
-0.0585005544,
-0.3740726709,
0.1187841147,
-0.1172770783,
-0.6859325171,
0.1196259558,
0.4173308015,
-0.1164713949,
-0.1281237453,
-0.3497318029,
0.0217961967,
-0.4027079344,
0.5828074813,
0.4909184277,
0.2789877951,
0.0055511817,
-0.1633940637,
-0.0678137764,
-0.8002034426,
-0.9367107749,
-0.3739932477,
0.1462937742,
0.456792593,
0.8547723889,
0.8527132273,
0.7318145633,
0.3677723408,
-0.0771422088,
-0.1912778467,
0.1391385049,
-0.4510719776,
0.2290874422,
-0.2350438386,
-0.7325895429,
-0.1230376586,
0.4742239118,
0.5993847847,
-0.356764853,
0.3631219268,
-0.0747699142,
0.5970233083,
-0.1331652254,
0.3151194453,
-0.5655457973,
-0.2061273754,
-0.3308635354,
0.1089221463,
-0.3422507346,
-0.4491564929,
0.252386719,
-0.3238219917,
0.382576108,
-0.0130413659,
0.4847962856,
0.2167472243,
-0.1867029369,
-0.500939548,
-1.0145606995,
0.6035711169,
-0.6396064758,
0.6679856777,
0.3895375133,
0.398712039,
0.5145258904,
-0.4869713485,
-0.4156128764,
-0.2761439681,
0.2074660808,
-0.2612561882,
-0.5179263949,
-0.0665005147,
0.4168393612,
0.2733969688,
-0.2417788357,
0.1060540453,
-0.5762195587,
-0.1599608809,
0.6023851633,
0.3707980812,
0.0649403781,
0.0242104474,
-0.1689795405,
-0.1986751407,
-0.6676428914,
0.576677382,
0.2118140906,
0.7640660405,
-0.2811847627,
0.3377992213,
-0.0343245715,
0.5706426501,
0.1864139885,
-0.466234386,
0.0520951897,
-0.1900551766,
-0.4627895653,
0.2602644563,
0.7764160037,
-0.0897155553,
0.297917068,
0.0180921331,
-0.336093843,
0.3334747851,
0.2496391237,
-0.9151813388,
-0.3567937911,
0.1603618413,
-0.6305731535,
-0.4561834931,
0.0468511991,
-0.6000022292,
-0.3195567727,
-0.5887798071,
0.3611697555,
-0.5753828287,
0.0049654623,
0.1828327626,
0.0010761933,
-0.1752904505,
0.4663203359,
-1.0561239719,
0.6957865357,
0.7520138621,
0.799026072,
0.4425234795,
0.0695924237,
-0.4251457155,
-0.0569736473,
-0.3673992455,
0.4454021752,
-0.6020352244,
-0.578637898,
-0.3905526102,
-0.3492837846,
-0.081028387,
-0.7859381437,
0.1443036646,
-0.6647433639,
-0.5050917268,
-0.0537547618,
-0.4647529125,
-0.0054985243,
-0.140124321,
-0.5630993843,
0.305311501,
-0.241741851,
-0.3865113854,
0.2626613379,
-0.6261851192,
-0.2525037825,
0.2396807671,
-0.3596190512,
-0.4226953089,
0.388410449,
-0.0332668759,
0.1700326204,
-0.534119606,
0.0873812288,
-0.1734749377,
-0.3791677952,
0.54805094,
-0.6269612908,
0.8598233461,
0.3027198613,
-0.2704149187,
-0.1701807976,
-0.9920836687,
-0.0969275609,
-0.0220325738,
-0.4797348678,
-0.3955010772,
-0.0018506438,
0.0460998453,
-0.1011807546,
0.2257626653,
-0.8029312491,
-0.0152433589,
-0.3363110721,
0.6212491393,
0.5872777104,
-0.4260859489,
0.6256565452,
-0.238659665,
0.3764520884,
0.0667439997,
0.3661600649,
-0.2768867314,
-0.6081523895,
-0.6686914563,
-0.3202258348,
0.8314318657,
0.6114588976,
-0.7215816975,
0.3082974553,
-0.5577971935,
-0.6184481978,
-0.7031272054,
-0.0495641753,
0.3987623155,
0.3341056705,
0.1298996955,
-0.2316306531,
-0.2716956437,
-0.8474854231,
-0.173327446,
-0.2336516231,
-0.2765876651,
0.5361118913,
0.2963266671,
-0.3301014304,
0.9223334193,
-0.3261599839,
-0.4058168828,
0.1525803357,
0.1194100231,
0.0944761038,
0.5698240995,
0.3310158849,
-0.9617807269,
-0.5682418346,
0.191778332,
-0.3683909178,
0.2655967176,
0.0339638144,
0.720505178,
0.2150537521,
0.2221010476,
-0.4707942605,
0.6745026708,
0.5245971084,
-0.350946784,
0.0807677135,
-0.3807280064,
-0.0068889386,
-0.6138168573,
-0.05322567,
0.0974682942,
-0.28245309,
-0.926625669,
-0.3051458895,
0.4440693259,
-0.5951687694,
-0.1739916652,
0.464432925,
-0.4085882306,
-0.2074610442,
-0.1073669642,
-0.4820449352,
-0.2796851397,
0.1856420636,
0.1361724585,
1.0096757412,
0.3502761126,
-0.6535167098,
0.1178232133,
0.2344586551,
-0.4710576832,
0.2346298248,
-0.7691178322,
0.3366392553,
0.4464527965,
-0.1627366543,
-0.6336659789,
-0.0810015351,
-0.0344267488,
-0.5835056305,
0.2624682188,
-0.2608560026,
-0.4578727782,
-0.3614193499,
-0.0358367078,
0.3682829142,
0.7832416296,
-0.4748485088,
0.8859037161,
0.6018468738,
-0.593049109,
-0.1865952313,
-0.6376359463,
0.1505874842,
-0.1973740608,
-0.6612861753,
0.1822234392,
0.1700823605,
-0.5181462765,
-0.4084247947,
-0.0623763837,
-0.1769607216,
-0.0055000521,
0.3533732593,
0.3386954367,
-0.2758042514,
0.0785317868,
-0.3595531881,
-0.5669358969,
-0.1819746345,
-0.2119680792,
0.3824658394,
-0.3302660286,
-0.3658856452,
-0.6267783046,
0.4729435146,
0.7009468079,
-0.2139969319,
0.4547561109,
0.2945145965,
-0.5658752322,
-0.0501409546,
-0.7152357697,
-0.2176582962,
-0.5635896325,
-0.3178679347,
-0.7158513069,
-0.9946085811,
0.7048760653,
0.2178523093,
-0.1403738558,
0.321315527,
0.4548146427,
-0.0952977017,
1.0507870913,
0.8203853369,
-0.0690848157,
0.6842948794,
0.0267371926,
0.4430988133,
-0.4145488143,
-0.0846255943,
-0.7136350274,
0.0367267393,
-0.5103247762,
-0.6863503456,
0.4228722155,
-0.1982384473,
-0.3993781507,
0.2721934319,
-0.5046851039,
0.4010257721,
0.7473165393,
0.1393459439,
0.3183226287,
0.2251925319,
0.1417256892,
-0.2332623005,
-0.53612113,
-0.7573127747,
0.834769249,
0.7101078629,
1.1842325926,
0.0499232076,
0.5556910634,
0.3951178193,
0.1498598754,
-0.8079323769,
0.4137237668,
-0.6952546835,
-0.377555728,
-0.4746517837,
-0.6112785339,
-0.6990712285,
-0.0558100827,
0.0565757267,
-0.5939537287,
0.7487408519,
0.3858836591,
-1.1843414307,
0.4814727902,
-0.7027662992,
0.5326858759,
-0.1840977222,
0.1032529995,
-0.0267837662,
-0.4817879796,
-0.0152983908,
-0.3574174047,
0.249626413,
-0.0025926298,
-0.1353623867,
0.8195129633,
-0.693701148,
1.0190799236,
-0.425968945,
-0.0412235744,
0.4505825341,
0.1866261363,
0.5193743706,
-0.1748902351,
-0.1596783549,
0.6797783375,
-0.0297832824,
0.0671018288,
-0.2291013449,
0.2769912779,
-0.7284960747,
-0.2163753062,
-0.3354693353,
-0.3649346828,
-0.1435042769,
-0.0607878007,
0.1866150349,
0.7384451032,
-0.2227446288,
0.4600438774,
0.6814712882,
-0.0243431069,
0.3866209388,
0.7644595504,
0.1687071919,
-0.619566381,
1.0942862034,
0.6140764952,
0.1718322933,
0.1573701054,
0.2666093409,
-0.2772981226,
-0.6240361929,
-0.6039071679,
0.1143227443,
-0.3532205522,
-0.5143026114,
-0.8709689975,
-0.2954556048,
-0.6338768601,
-0.1921292841,
-0.4836165905,
-0.5948004127,
-0.3974949121,
0.1040327325,
0.5902716517,
0.6309489608,
-0.3212687671,
0.7014760971,
-1.2055591345,
0.4622491598,
0.6399307847,
0.3802789152,
0.1512650549,
-0.6496216059,
-0.3654883504,
0.1578992754,
0.0961117893,
-0.5101194382,
0.5877434611,
0.1414041817,
-0.0061230701,
0.5345239639,
-0.1367067695,
0.8538748026,
-0.8438493013,
0.5142701268,
0.3627443016,
-1.3412106037,
0.4268024564,
-0.4139667153,
-0.0578597188,
0.7297256589,
0.0510315001,
-0.4306575656,
0.0278938822,
-1.0723377466,
-0.6340039968,
0.824922204,
0.0308414418,
0.0659002662,
0.2352606356,
0.2912997603,
0.0685012639,
0.4389797747,
-0.3177209198,
-0.0021889831,
-0.019388603,
-0.2739477158,
-0.2442818284,
-0.4147845805,
-0.0557296798,
-0.276163429,
0.3662302792,
-0.1352532655,
0.4659801424,
-0.0578741506,
0.1764216274,
-0.087341778,
0.2059797645,
0.4112117589,
0.3999346495,
-0.3605877161,
0.0006029138,
0.2900782526,
-0.7365537882,
0.3516276479,
0.2420636117,
-0.3399963677,
0.0558435433,
-0.0268527102,
0.5903250575,
0.2418759465,
-0.4221430719,
0.6088885069,
-0.1915872842,
0.0073231934,
-0.6765164733,
0.0781585276,
0.1007420346,
0.4939796627,
0.2790080309,
0.556081295,
0.3695125878,
-0.4616729319,
0.1692228317,
0.3913677633,
-0.6259964108,
-0.338978529,
0.7416669726,
0.3649031818,
-0.8622973561,
0.812084198,
-0.0788141713,
-0.3205473423,
0.8651277423,
0.4156551361,
0.9356651306,
-0.5448763967,
-0.0373566411,
0.0370733999,
0.4066160023,
-0.3391999602,
0.4785219729,
-0.1788814515,
-0.8590355515,
0.1021557525,
-0.6045570374,
-0.9879640341,
-0.2799251676,
-0.8688344955,
0.1649406999,
-0.9001854658,
-0.5190819502,
0.5003687739,
-0.0873903707,
-0.6961062551,
0.3653573096,
0.5757591724,
1.2292934656,
-0.7957108617,
1.1216048002,
0.5003402829,
-0.2242079973,
-0.7407314181,
-0.5392621756,
0.2454815954,
-0.8048795462,
0.5694096684,
0.1007853597,
-0.2806874514,
-0.0249652024,
-0.404222995,
-0.6882321239,
1.0641490221,
0.3241509795,
-0.9731520414,
0.0011695975,
0.286125958,
0.5643064976,
-0.5544621348,
-0.1592459679,
0.6584662199,
0.1222442016,
0.0505219102,
-1.0551575422,
-0.2660450339,
-0.2429821342,
0.1767878979,
0.2390565574,
-0.8112928867,
1.2743756771,
-0.2948394418,
-0.194070518,
0.1252378076,
0.2966008484,
0.3827253282,
0.5233616233,
0.6755155921,
0.2963063419,
0.9466302395,
-0.1996478885,
0.9997627735,
-0.2082945406,
0.1141791195,
1.013884306,
-0.3314015567,
1.1960073709,
0.2187548578,
-0.3208834827,
0.0501745269,
0.3958277106,
-0.0931857452,
0.3125693798,
0.0056704134,
-0.3047802746,
-0.2421828806,
0.0036637159,
-0.1472747177,
0.4912645519,
0.5050256848,
-0.3261697292,
0.4619399905,
0.0836409181,
-0.2212209404,
-0.2953422368,
-0.4533703029,
0.9983531237,
0.4236664176,
0.1637859792,
0.0531942435,
0.0726544186,
0.8299837708,
-0.6690365672,
0.2209619582,
0.0138903838,
0.5741292834,
-0.1109514311,
-0.2515576184,
0.3434920907,
0.4219980836,
-0.4146980345,
-0.5110813975,
0.920435369,
-0.1990255266,
-0.8086197972,
0.1730621308,
0.4075421989,
0.1786181331,
-0.3894470334,
-0.5699744821,
0.0856425911,
0.0780059323,
0.1039181724,
0.2504011989,
0.5278729796,
0.037016537,
0.6308130622,
0.8219320178,
0.3257946968,
-0.0536476225,
0.1972853839,
0.6261110902,
-1.0805200338,
-0.9262365103,
-0.8789179921,
0.3936138451,
-0.0744693279,
-0.0213106088,
0.6535374522,
0.6043326855,
0.5320245028,
-0.0740323812,
0.5181393623,
0.3518794179,
0.8551132083,
-0.1807846278,
0.7689421773,
-0.2493811995,
0.3096356988,
-0.082150951,
-0.5201298594,
-0.2714433968,
0.792604804,
-0.3374243677,
-0.1475387663,
0.0668583885,
0.6598295569,
-0.1445523798,
0.498357147,
0.397495687,
-0.005263627,
0.2524159253,
0.1577953547,
0.8328040242,
-0.7049922347,
0.5695597529,
-0.4558209479,
-0.211452812,
-0.4189923406,
-0.4302019477,
-0.5278269649,
-0.2292925864,
-0.3832330108,
-0.1277756393,
-0.3945501745,
0.9562292099,
0.759432137,
-0.9637054205,
-0.5951751471,
0.4234004021,
-0.3085371852,
-0.1506102681,
-0.1199364662,
0.2422210723,
0.0556665435,
-0.4535153806,
0.3534825742,
0.5724822879,
0.6245602369,
0.172495693,
0.0631587207,
0.4327747524,
0.3981235325,
0.6222787499,
0.3223659396,
-0.589732945,
-0.2174442708,
0.1090374067,
-0.2455378026,
0.2447143495,
0.9342300892,
-0.5065644979,
0.2829712629,
0.2005545944,
0.7580679059,
0.2581970096,
0.2582418621,
0.3649441004,
-0.3291220665,
0.1923248917,
0.3764613569,
0.4006726444,
0.3736623228,
-0.3900776803,
0.6115646958,
0.055153206,
-0.5062113404,
-0.7932543755,
-0.1195150167,
-0.8483919501,
0.0952572376,
0.8044164181,
-0.0218007434,
-0.258348465,
-0.2762821019,
-0.013118159,
-0.1451299787,
-0.5738912225,
0.6887537837,
0.343852222,
-0.1463493705,
0.0097030727,
-0.4287663102,
0.6813406348,
0.0293707829,
-0.5077030659,
0.3501707315,
0.4366636574,
0.2209335715,
0.6656179428,
1.0636969805,
-0.1971081495,
0.3080337942,
0.6314640045,
0.0725131035,
-0.1120196208,
-0.6142416,
-0.9858646989,
0.21575813,
0.1123370603,
-0.3032532334
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01920v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01920v1
|
Preference Poisoning Attacks on Reward Model Learning
| 2024-02-02T21:45:24 | 2024-02-02T21:45:24 |
Junlin Wu, Jiongxiao Wang, Chaowei Xiao, Chenguang Wang, Ning Zhang, Yevgeniy Vorobeychik
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Learning utility, or reward, models from pairwise comparisons is a
fundamental component in a number of application domains. These approaches
inherently entail collecting preference information from people, with feedback
often provided anonymously. Since preferences are subjective, there is no gold
standard to compare against; yet, reliance of high-impact systems on preference
learning creates a strong motivation for malicious actors to skew data
collected in this fashion to their ends. We investigate the nature and extent
of this vulnerability systematically by considering a threat model in which an
attacker can flip a small subset of preference comparisons with the goal of
either promoting or demoting a target outcome. First, we propose two classes of
algorithmic approaches for these attacks: a principled gradient-based
framework, and several variants of rank-by-distance methods. Next, we
demonstrate the efficacy of best attacks in both these classes in successfully
achieving malicious goals on datasets from three diverse domains: autonomous
control, recommendation system, and textual prompt-response preference
learning. We find that the best attacks are often highly successful, achieving
in the most extreme case 100% success rate with only 0.3% of the data poisoned.
However, which attack is best can vary significantly across domains,
demonstrating the value of our comprehensive vulnerability analysis that
involves several classes of attack algorithms. In addition, we observe that the
simpler and more scalable rank-by-distance approaches are often competitive
with the best, and on occasion significantly outperform gradient-based methods.
Finally, we show that several state-of-the-art defenses against other classes
of poisoning attacks exhibit, at best, limited efficacy in our setting.
|
[
-0.1408404708,
-0.5019974709,
0.3804978728,
-0.3086553812,
0.1424382478,
-0.1029824317,
0.0583730079,
-0.2658399343,
0.1094777733,
0.6499152184,
-0.3655163348,
-0.2869669497,
-0.7620162964,
-0.4124027491,
-0.2580406666,
1.3065639734,
0.376390487,
-0.0651085377,
-0.2169116586,
-0.2242360115,
-0.502156496,
-1.2299472094,
-0.7296772003,
-0.3429851532,
0.7588973045,
0.4021324515,
0.4866345823,
0.3287065029,
0.7052745819,
0.1745311171,
0.3653804064,
-0.2092184573,
-0.8471763134,
0.1118331179,
-0.2227701396,
-0.6833922267,
-0.242928341,
0.1733846664,
-0.1683037728,
0.5327442884,
0.0189633425,
-0.0468966961,
0.0295622312,
1.049764514,
-1.1270796061,
-0.2959062457,
-0.9212729931,
-0.0162776671,
-0.3371815681,
-0.4522251785,
-0.943012774,
-0.153771013,
0.2841939032,
-0.407273531,
-0.0278903954,
0.0768825784,
0.5400900841,
0.0878011733,
-0.6172171831,
-0.2454246283,
-0.4393698871,
0.9366284609,
-0.262894541,
-0.1416302174,
0.5711858869,
0.5738203526,
-0.2569361627,
-0.438670963,
0.0522254631,
-0.3564231098,
0.0710789561,
-0.0626102239,
-0.3467631936,
0.0446398444,
0.1966394484,
0.2021915764,
-0.5838325024,
0.1289653778,
-0.2004414946,
-0.0953038558,
0.768204093,
0.3343558609,
0.1630413681,
-0.5422417521,
-0.8134317994,
-0.5245734453,
-0.8390312195,
0.5483039021,
0.8749867678,
0.2912394702,
0.0105050309,
0.2725692689,
-0.0834153295,
0.5450876355,
0.129295364,
0.1351293772,
-0.0550389178,
0.1094905064,
-0.2152665257,
0.1401190013,
0.6620442271,
0.8949151039,
0.1156025082,
-0.3194655776,
-0.2283587158,
0.0854408368,
0.6952552199,
-0.6334646344,
-0.669323802,
0.481359154,
-0.4908232987,
-1.0087749958,
-0.0093405647,
-0.90167588,
-0.7393324375,
0.193973586,
0.6985813975,
-0.3527643085,
-0.1982647181,
0.2123711258,
-0.3985024393,
0.1897335947,
0.0087724971,
-1.3144427538,
0.4483826458,
0.6684137583,
0.7294886708,
-0.6434711814,
-0.096645765,
-0.7937315106,
0.0004865818,
-0.1616744846,
0.779959023,
-0.469873786,
-0.6401336193,
-0.148329854,
-0.4179295897,
0.0354722515,
-0.6149201989,
0.535523653,
-0.8435254693,
-0.0229836497,
-0.5130015612,
-0.3755711913,
-0.1732982546,
0.5020257831,
-0.5978896022,
0.6644297838,
-0.0132729243,
-1.0512524843,
0.3214927614,
-0.5662133098,
-0.3307020664,
-0.2343043834,
0.3012334704,
-0.2291715741,
-0.0267364923,
-0.1128183305,
0.6403374672,
-0.0695465729,
-0.0535691902,
-0.5772792101,
-0.036100205,
0.371291995,
-0.3370999694,
0.8562220335,
0.1661472023,
-0.2430161685,
0.3148327768,
-0.5882045031,
0.0577648804,
0.5458030105,
0.1967790276,
-0.9213940501,
0.1470541507,
0.0521858484,
0.010414145,
0.1537504196,
-0.3410426676,
0.2972558737,
-0.3633161187,
0.426551193,
1.1671391726,
0.4623056948,
0.5418524742,
-0.6568798423,
0.2915662229,
0.1032567173,
0.6738648415,
0.0928709581,
-0.107159093,
-0.4331198335,
0.0447717831,
0.2273374945,
0.5559265614,
-0.7732831836,
0.0308795571,
-0.0914011002,
-0.7450079918,
-0.0083964933,
-0.3080822527,
0.374473244,
0.6736129522,
0.590949595,
-0.380091846,
-0.0698651373,
-0.7483708858,
-0.646153748,
-0.1958697587,
0.0902049541,
0.3727216125,
0.511151433,
0.1237049773,
0.7092434764,
-0.7360081673,
-0.1789534539,
-0.0863001272,
-0.161894843,
0.083175458,
0.6508348584,
0.949298501,
-0.8884566426,
-0.4491137862,
-0.1497975588,
-0.6547948122,
0.277923584,
-0.0722670034,
-0.2363475561,
-0.1186823845,
-0.0167618319,
0.0325008184,
0.414352417,
0.1713424027,
-0.1499948055,
0.5934106708,
0.2231083661,
0.3162407577,
-0.8451049328,
0.1123811379,
0.2764658332,
-0.0046476233,
-1.3135004044,
0.2490241379,
0.0284200218,
0.2457145751,
-0.6841099858,
0.4450178742,
0.2468816191,
0.2655464113,
-0.1175470948,
-0.4314014018,
-0.1097932905,
0.6045911908,
-0.1142265201,
0.4469690323,
0.6441966295,
-0.6326613426,
0.4034734964,
-0.2019651085,
0.0332579315,
0.774058938,
-0.587980926,
0.2906689346,
0.122489579,
0.0211494993,
-0.7599635124,
-0.4215447009,
0.604339838,
-0.5691235662,
0.4118341804,
-0.4406309724,
0.0138672423,
0.1341016144,
-0.9228364825,
0.48387146,
0.3529789448,
-0.9263575673,
0.1908934414,
0.4466026723,
0.0890304893,
-1.1070966721,
-0.3006181717,
0.0547302328,
-0.6721540689,
-0.4875845313,
0.1734316498,
-0.103567645,
-0.424734652,
-0.3650447726,
-0.1500414461,
0.2464341223,
0.6118982434,
0.3280271888,
0.4249917865,
0.3968872726,
-0.3354441524,
-0.1468767822,
-0.3663624227,
0.5045200586,
-0.2441005707,
0.4875469208,
0.0556234531,
-0.4744078219,
-0.346016556,
0.5653817058,
0.7035657167,
0.0209618267,
0.6038038135,
-0.1670902967,
-0.2177307755,
-0.352845937,
-0.3007627726,
-0.4429575503,
-0.4967192709,
0.181115672,
-0.4045628905,
-0.4390396774,
0.372857213,
-0.030611435,
0.1664984971,
0.335208267,
0.1565962732,
-0.0526859201,
1.0458432436,
0.39779827,
-0.5769603252,
0.4246651232,
-0.4174211919,
0.1449191868,
-0.5994933844,
-0.3654250205,
-0.4786631167,
-0.2054124624,
-0.5206938386,
0.1254058778,
0.7384004593,
-0.3135884702,
-0.3658920825,
0.1162749007,
-0.5706705451,
0.6194841266,
0.6748363376,
0.2224644274,
-0.0760021433,
0.2700245678,
-0.1755577177,
-0.0235993806,
-0.5808547735,
-0.2373766154,
1.6946786642,
0.2412661165,
0.7504312396,
0.1151685044,
0.8109704256,
0.7382214069,
-0.0060133515,
-0.8299744129,
0.3161196113,
-0.087124683,
-0.3099195361,
-0.1227253601,
-0.3807041943,
-0.9290749431,
0.3063527644,
-0.077372849,
-0.654961586,
0.2672474384,
0.1228915304,
-0.3290694952,
0.6159943938,
-0.792026639,
0.7290684581,
-0.4698734879,
-0.7120841146,
-0.0739525333,
-0.8981080055,
0.3967394233,
0.0463330336,
-0.0328821763,
0.1481990516,
0.4698647857,
0.8323322535,
-0.5254659653,
0.6917126179,
-0.3993583918,
0.246026814,
-0.2770923674,
0.3964729309,
0.4198938906,
-0.03193409,
-0.2333203554,
0.3266050518,
0.098139286,
-0.8039649725,
-0.6992267966,
0.6591296196,
-0.7850006819,
-0.6571671367,
-0.7982364893,
-0.1056622341,
-0.3368998468,
0.076172933,
0.4939056635,
0.4274734855,
-0.17427665,
-0.0378502421,
0.8856419325,
-0.0723655224,
0.3463316262,
0.1886467189,
0.1651563346,
-0.498042345,
1.3031198978,
-0.136673376,
0.6443075538,
0.3244784772,
0.1739265174,
-0.1401403695,
-0.66375494,
-0.3472872078,
-0.1222945377,
-0.7235196233,
-0.3854880631,
-0.4156950414,
-0.1349196881,
-0.4023652673,
-0.486931175,
-0.1796755493,
-0.2297962457,
-0.0853149444,
-0.1156494766,
0.391107291,
0.7440884709,
-0.131648913,
0.252941668,
-0.3654183745,
0.0032207284,
0.5634793043,
0.025709549,
0.2336547524,
-0.2608042955,
0.0843728781,
-0.0911474675,
-0.4868881106,
-1.1651813984,
0.5227506757,
-0.4723677933,
0.5488139391,
0.7530254126,
0.5050430298,
0.1514783502,
-0.1639572829,
1.0230920315,
0.3262103498,
-0.6748444438,
0.5219838023,
-0.2766376138,
-0.2898670733,
0.7790539265,
0.6791191101,
-0.6994219422,
0.0489826091,
-0.568238914,
-0.888602376,
0.7839497328,
0.0840846822,
0.0684748515,
0.1175851151,
0.4813827276,
0.3310613036,
0.1217279285,
-0.7721515894,
-0.7622473836,
-0.400680542,
0.1341777593,
-0.0210346635,
-0.2626483738,
-0.2665997446,
0.0529298894,
0.8270289302,
0.0653194338,
0.0675371662,
-0.1402425915,
0.0365858302,
0.1136725321,
0.2510430217,
0.3868428767,
0.1261167675,
-0.2775058746,
0.433924228,
0.0017639853,
-0.5594218969,
0.4312072396,
-0.2389677167,
-0.1300137639,
-0.6583369374,
0.1846798509,
0.7141212225,
0.0009586535,
-0.4413484931,
0.7587984204,
-0.2207583934,
0.0637519136,
-0.0263522752,
0.2523611486,
-0.5313357115,
-0.1913864464,
0.4907139838,
0.4230523705,
0.4271752536,
-0.4149574637,
0.0798485056,
0.7089561224,
-0.4450271726,
-0.2044712305,
0.4584435523,
0.0956188142,
-0.1507583261,
0.2903805971,
0.1168615445,
-0.7490420341,
0.6327996254,
0.3612961769,
0.7777617574,
-0.5926296711,
0.2063414752,
0.1277052313,
0.2668089569,
0.0313190781,
-0.1818393022,
-0.2544245124,
-0.538389504,
0.5049436092,
-0.2515084147,
-0.6163457632,
0.2214400917,
-0.9857061505,
-0.0234192163,
-0.6468315721,
-0.2130174637,
0.1093955711,
-0.0793854445,
-0.1883203685,
-0.007435747,
-0.1563039124,
0.5502302647,
-0.9659711719,
0.3588138819,
0.5556504726,
-0.3290551305,
-0.4808599353,
0.1431436837,
0.2688571811,
-0.6458262205,
0.6166106462,
0.140848279,
-0.2334670126,
-0.3417992294,
-0.6151770353,
-0.5603305101,
0.6581259966,
0.2195058614,
0.0407154039,
0.0473652668,
0.1316267252,
0.1925692111,
-0.1041122153,
0.1721885651,
0.6969578266,
0.29500404,
-0.0068734968,
-0.5157932043,
-0.1339820176,
-0.3730377257,
-0.2960250378,
0.2857068479,
-0.659381032,
0.6179603338,
-0.1342155039,
0.1592462957,
-0.4028073251,
0.2167691737,
0.0926870704,
0.6231306195,
0.6546407342,
0.4809454083,
0.6861931086,
0.1046122164,
1.1620817184,
-0.0368941464,
0.2428602427,
0.8940077424,
-0.4490902722,
0.8734518886,
0.4303839505,
-0.168665275,
0.3688899577,
0.8735188246,
0.1521748304,
1.0333182812,
0.2273203135,
-0.2622508407,
-0.2408701181,
0.125650987,
-0.3320783973,
0.1247887388,
0.2578205764,
-0.2155256271,
-0.0437853858,
0.2655953765,
0.1253567934,
-0.0470540039,
-0.3829443455,
0.8760201335,
-0.1468702108,
-0.6849495769,
0.6709221601,
0.1853526086,
0.6761754155,
-0.6385893822,
0.261244446,
-0.1465319693,
0.0466004312,
-0.3924231827,
-0.4046508372,
-0.1164373234,
-0.051948674,
-0.2960225046,
-0.0898778364,
0.7117106318,
0.1106023565,
0.1607920378,
0.3036743402,
-0.0548984557,
-0.1114436015,
-0.1031057611,
-0.6248965263,
-0.1268959492,
0.1247740909,
-0.2477916032,
0.812247932,
-0.3482902944,
-0.0486473367,
0.7656553388,
0.767935276,
0.1194731966,
0.1588023901,
-0.353995949,
0.9357610345,
-0.2650363445,
-0.7389389873,
-1.0097216368,
0.2221383154,
-0.4414317608,
0.1850983799,
0.7422949076,
0.5229569674,
0.9166172743,
-0.0426542759,
0.9030938148,
0.3147033453,
0.2222219408,
-0.4542477131,
0.9715684056,
-0.4256084561,
0.3924718201,
-0.2986387312,
-0.5016230345,
-0.3078197837,
0.2243922055,
-0.6964035034,
0.0860651433,
0.6917742491,
0.6917055845,
0.0032263745,
0.0204128362,
0.1785802543,
-0.1236708388,
0.5704876184,
0.8514277339,
0.8457745314,
-0.3264940679,
0.1913681924,
-0.5113806129,
-0.4898425639,
-0.4404505789,
-0.7300949097,
-1.1091043949,
-0.647236526,
-0.0868233144,
-0.6630302072,
0.3236605227,
0.9135523438,
0.903442502,
-0.955649972,
-0.1679519266,
0.3088718653,
0.294696033,
-0.2681203187,
-0.2255392969,
0.5529476404,
-0.2069001645,
-0.3612760007,
0.3606367707,
0.2810249627,
-0.1525232047,
-0.2540673316,
0.0231798533,
0.1445145607,
0.2815532088,
0.3943912983,
0.4150252938,
-0.4203383923,
-0.2594182789,
-0.1523375511,
-0.1811014563,
0.0693701878,
0.96525985,
-0.7023901939,
0.5817370415,
0.4177417755,
0.7460753918,
0.102749005,
0.015617324,
0.1554170996,
-0.5401662588,
-0.132800743,
0.1777781695,
0.2562930584,
0.271086216,
-0.9000469446,
0.2614330649,
0.3999571204,
-0.4462379217,
-1.1627913713,
0.3429518938,
-1.0512163639,
-0.4053584933,
1.067874074,
-0.0972979665,
-0.3376508057,
-0.1203665063,
-0.1270692348,
-0.2993007302,
-0.5881749988,
1.0104780197,
0.4417888224,
-0.2090763599,
0.5975272059,
-0.4574637711,
0.8199114799,
0.4522365034,
-0.8376740813,
0.2777266502,
0.3391086459,
0.6039534807,
-0.0142372167,
0.2797953188,
-0.1723360568,
0.4864931107,
-0.2996696234,
-0.1887940764,
-0.0679184794,
-0.5187453032,
-0.7203837037,
0.8685423732,
-0.0086703161,
-0.2309641391
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01917v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01917v1
|
Whispering in Norwegian: Navigating Orthographic and Dialectic Challenges
| 2024-02-02T21:38:12 | 2024-02-02T21:38:12 |
Per E Kummervold, Javier de la Rosa, Freddy Wetjen, Rolv-Arild Braaten, Per Erik Solberg
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This article introduces NB-Whisper, an adaptation of OpenAI's Whisper,
specifically fine-tuned for Norwegian language Automatic Speech Recognition
(ASR). We highlight its key contributions and summarise the results achieved in
converting spoken Norwegian into written forms and translating other languages
into Norwegian. We show that we are able to improve the Norwegian Bokm{\aa}l
transcription by OpenAI Whisper Large-v3 from a WER of 10.4 to 6.6 on the
Fleurs Dataset and from 6.8 to 2.2 on the NST dataset.
|
[
-0.2471597791,
-0.5033995509,
0.2377481759,
0.3717116416,
-0.2531052828,
-0.0045506405,
-0.4239499569,
-0.9147965908,
0.347491473,
0.5955193639,
-0.3761825562,
-0.5225360394,
-0.3853752315,
0.2153832763,
-0.401917994,
0.7859534621,
-0.1279742867,
0.2279735357,
0.4761480689,
-0.1811807752,
-0.389292717,
-0.4511998296,
-0.9089668393,
-0.2701106966,
0.5759894848,
0.2748951614,
0.5386100411,
0.18372868,
0.2217675596,
0.255577594,
-0.5957921743,
-0.0978270769,
-0.4453955293,
0.4032975137,
0.2045965195,
-0.5556204915,
-0.4704844654,
-0.2104954422,
1.0441768169,
0.4436663687,
-0.470153898,
0.0942909494,
0.0401648432,
0.8190187812,
-0.2376880795,
0.2630768716,
-0.4449608624,
-0.1012860388,
-0.6018628478,
0.1924666911,
-0.2018751055,
-0.5804235935,
0.9559052587,
-0.8158841133,
0.2299109548,
0.1179525852,
0.7779538631,
0.2017020881,
-0.540402472,
-0.8016520739,
-0.7778651118,
0.7207240462,
-0.7765413523,
0.7567365766,
0.3074412048,
0.6181029081,
-0.2109685242,
-0.6759243608,
-0.5500617027,
-0.0140616009,
0.1048675254,
0.273336798,
-0.2083175927,
0.2229380906,
-0.0224840976,
0.5893361568,
-0.3167816699,
-0.0421006083,
-0.9605563879,
-0.2607745826,
0.7915161252,
-0.0663361624,
0.1101434231,
-0.2564207911,
0.0926876962,
-0.3175114393,
-0.5916657448,
0.0609327517,
0.7418479323,
0.6965603232,
-0.4833592176,
0.2008998543,
-0.1548375785,
0.9410791397,
-0.0014689075,
-0.1126643792,
0.4186702371,
-0.0831262022,
-0.0205729771,
0.6776483655,
0.6170867085,
0.2967323661,
0.1192876995,
0.039071437,
-0.3614501655,
-0.1537014842,
0.1141034961,
-0.4107834399,
-0.5181142092,
-0.0181122981,
-0.5641629696,
-0.1468512714,
0.0710903183,
-0.6352663636,
-0.483977437,
-0.049290318,
0.6469898224,
-0.3055000901,
-0.5914201736,
0.4633666873,
-0.4353190064,
0.5811473727,
0.4777487218,
-0.7978099585,
0.397595942,
0.6056244969,
1.0151551962,
-0.0274326652,
0.0246531945,
-0.304985553,
0.0256899241,
-0.6153327823,
0.8026188612,
-0.2116060555,
-0.7119095922,
0.1502055675,
-0.3593883514,
-0.1077186689,
-0.6706264019,
0.4810036123,
-0.2927127779,
0.4563875496,
-0.1653367728,
-0.0684887618,
-0.6113042831,
-0.0952352062,
-0.6377422214,
0.8155033588,
0.0391167812,
-0.3651414216,
0.2089952976,
-1.0343967676,
-0.4274140298,
-0.0914382041,
0.2337963283,
-0.02386114,
0.5665819049,
0.3412043154,
0.1145384014,
-0.312704742,
-0.0932547674,
0.2770157456,
-0.0201474596,
0.2034525871,
-0.1990083158,
0.9295105338,
0.1423705667,
0.118143335,
0.0956438482,
-0.6759223938,
0.1457152218,
-0.3777928352,
-0.3508338034,
-0.1127970517,
-0.215265736,
0.2245018333,
-0.1681061685,
0.0523236059,
-0.9436306357,
0.0017497443,
-1.0869065523,
0.7599474192,
0.6397988796,
0.1908280253,
0.4872972369,
-0.5297441483,
0.5449147224,
-0.2428712696,
0.3037432134,
-0.0376431122,
-0.8517259359,
-0.9278520942,
-0.2142445296,
0.7864103913,
0.4845243096,
-1.0477534533,
-0.2466372102,
-0.1215660125,
-0.4922278523,
-1.2358175516,
-0.1027549207,
0.6663299799,
0.3910788894,
0.0986306816,
-0.493881166,
-0.8606088161,
-0.6652507186,
-0.2997036278,
-0.5418138504,
0.0094109364,
0.2966002226,
0.087256223,
-0.0961630195,
0.5979933143,
-0.3262984157,
-0.9145957828,
-0.1642019004,
0.2837253511,
0.8300014138,
0.4006557465,
0.369340837,
-0.92989254,
-0.9548039436,
0.4010044634,
-0.4184964299,
-0.3253239989,
0.123035349,
0.135779351,
0.6058229804,
0.7643097639,
-0.1398121715,
0.5777985454,
0.8613107204,
-0.3685899377,
0.6290014386,
0.0514621548,
-0.1006713584,
-0.9378079772,
-0.1052090675,
-0.5528591275,
-0.2273953855,
-1.0727338791,
0.0070347628,
-0.4317944348,
-0.0412788875,
-0.4985372424,
0.8610818982,
-0.615377903,
0.0780424327,
-0.1092053577,
0.012507244,
-0.3103604913,
0.1340407431,
0.1474927664,
0.5471764207,
0.8567423224,
-0.5805363655,
0.3598908484,
0.9080753326,
-0.3697826862,
0.6509845853,
-0.6735723615,
0.4765556753,
-0.0361075513,
0.0785111487,
-0.7590671182,
-0.3082573712,
0.1576561183,
-0.8776010871,
0.4480544329,
-0.3500637114,
-0.4069343805,
-0.0371933579,
-0.2434030622,
0.0649637207,
0.6928473115,
-0.5805335045,
1.0861067772,
0.4122117758,
-0.5198565722,
-0.0137180714,
-0.6016057134,
0.1653641313,
0.0389919356,
-0.5883875489,
0.1247181073,
0.1453932375,
-0.2609421909,
-0.0695018843,
-0.3349975646,
-0.201242581,
-0.4144206643,
0.5094026923,
0.063047789,
-0.6751999259,
-0.2722766995,
0.063601315,
-0.3039352894,
-0.0745793208,
-0.296423912,
0.2982981503,
-0.3029460013,
-0.0434097871,
-0.6369566917,
0.4250616133,
0.3516977727,
0.0558356941,
0.3138391078,
0.3421536386,
-0.2221752256,
0.0226850305,
-0.6439833045,
-0.117807962,
-0.5454644561,
-0.1544819027,
-0.6613658667,
-1.0362699032,
0.6458374858,
0.0652439967,
0.3459711969,
0.3327226639,
0.2126185149,
-0.4578498602,
0.8032585979,
0.789921701,
-0.0865943655,
0.515833199,
-0.1888390929,
0.0549334437,
-1.0310063362,
-0.2974342704,
-0.6698352098,
-0.5185008645,
-0.7313933372,
-0.2911280394,
1.0576605797,
0.0341260135,
0.0000140358,
0.142772913,
-0.4231475294,
0.2918073833,
0.7822966576,
-0.0606927089,
0.2461931556,
-0.0577220507,
0.0122830076,
-0.1482774168,
-0.8844442368,
-0.0981107801,
0.9272195101,
0.4365166426,
0.6485731006,
0.5187796354,
0.7168043256,
-0.2098152786,
0.1903468072,
-0.5527027249,
0.3140948713,
-0.391132921,
-0.8057510853,
-0.6425244808,
-0.1966969669,
-0.8667917848,
0.1173912734,
-0.2043526471,
-0.6308018565,
0.5820688009,
0.3209140897,
-0.3514043689,
0.0383778438,
-0.5471322536,
0.4459967017,
0.125507459,
0.5977253318,
-0.0168236662,
-0.7414675355,
0.0133631164,
0.0917201713,
-0.0444684997,
0.1996323913,
-0.0068744253,
0.969684422,
-0.1605473608,
0.9048317671,
-0.3527503312,
-0.3461489379,
0.3506895006,
0.1758650094,
0.2182414532,
-0.3138663769,
-0.3006359041,
0.6428411603,
0.1150483042,
-0.0327108242,
-0.7225814462,
0.3499910235,
-0.6218028665,
-0.3217983544,
-0.5935137272,
-0.194307968,
-0.30521819,
0.1830105484,
0.4743994176,
0.7273049951,
-0.3544884622,
0.2282622904,
0.7229680419,
-0.1853820533,
0.2799247801,
0.8351585269,
-0.601544857,
-1.0039513111,
1.0262897015,
0.260969609,
0.288589716,
0.2385331839,
0.4810927808,
-0.7624719143,
-0.8879427314,
-0.7478647828,
0.3113229275,
-0.6376434565,
-0.267288506,
-0.4553938508,
-0.5189502239,
-0.4637977779,
-0.3928773105,
-0.1532552391,
-0.6018261909,
-0.3118955791,
-0.0179861337,
0.8378728628,
1.188201189,
-0.3771324456,
0.6578988433,
-0.6021959186,
0.587121129,
0.3259010613,
0.4104986787,
-0.1258555204,
-0.939155221,
0.0249605887,
-0.1290678531,
-0.0503303297,
-0.7443107367,
0.4475765228,
0.790307343,
0.3601927757,
0.2200490236,
0.0867129341,
0.9334245324,
-0.6068441868,
0.8885245919,
0.2175427824,
-1.1655384302,
0.4521875679,
-0.5735499859,
0.5448049903,
0.4913722873,
0.0569093265,
-0.9391242266,
-0.4419218898,
-0.549975574,
-0.9407826662,
0.7131771445,
0.1952252835,
-0.0212064274,
0.4206565022,
0.4320580065,
0.1846124828,
0.4249895811,
-0.2316519916,
-0.1115690619,
-0.3896405697,
-0.1375109553,
-0.4045518339,
-0.356577903,
0.0677983016,
-0.2890604138,
0.8381171227,
-0.1702641398,
0.4113567173,
0.5594216585,
0.0329065993,
-0.0286413655,
0.0561154746,
0.4633157551,
0.2904885709,
-0.0357401073,
-0.0643568411,
0.3932903111,
-0.9542116523,
-0.1458976716,
-0.0212182291,
-0.3936001956,
0.3936095834,
0.6052566171,
1.0113921165,
0.3849426806,
-0.433342576,
0.2873122692,
0.0222642776,
-0.5512373447,
-0.4235232174,
-0.0267537609,
0.0087909382,
0.3713553846,
0.2994028628,
-0.1392718107,
0.3440142572,
-0.6285242438,
-0.1554913521,
0.1442525536,
-0.8964428902,
-0.6098847985,
0.4819479585,
0.3832031488,
-0.5771068335,
0.6646563411,
0.1116647348,
-0.8625581264,
-0.0299555492,
0.6214696765,
1.2171554565,
-0.5864835978,
0.0819986016,
0.2162223458,
0.423461169,
-0.070976384,
1.2313588858,
-0.1230701581,
-0.4108032286,
-0.4063062072,
-0.8888326287,
-0.7052633166,
-0.2579402924,
-1.1471617222,
0.0710662454,
-0.4287778437,
0.0298218578,
0.1541933566,
-0.1479693651,
-0.3125486672,
-0.1041227505,
0.0488801152,
1.2156950235,
-0.5212112069,
0.6267268062,
0.7680014968,
0.3143650591,
-0.5934516191,
-0.0187145807,
0.1521341056,
-0.5723786354,
0.5489134192,
-0.1055152491,
-0.3880750835,
0.135765478,
-0.5238242745,
-0.9384394288,
0.6954230666,
0.3175956309,
-0.504989028,
0.0988905877,
-0.0570621826,
0.7597914934,
-0.0783811659,
-0.2351080328,
0.54247123,
0.7274882197,
0.030669516,
-1.953114152,
-0.3855687082,
-0.1363446116,
0.1594944745,
0.429166168,
-0.6829839349,
0.7270750999,
-0.0395764299,
-0.4532177448,
0.4109021127,
0.9585998654,
-0.2091126442,
0.4508118033,
0.4401783645,
0.3011386395,
0.7251656651,
-0.0322629027,
0.809028089,
0.3950443864,
-0.5580796599,
0.9814507365,
-0.3602429032,
1.2397392988,
0.4070394337,
0.0779505521,
0.715218544,
0.0665214434,
0.5111467242,
0.6545391083,
0.1518848389,
-0.4651016891,
0.2202937156,
-0.0200886801,
-0.1730350554,
0.8332236409,
0.6663722396,
0.1808002889,
-0.1005794406,
0.3267841041,
-0.2829509377,
0.2216513008,
-0.5710694194,
1.3903998137,
0.3812607229,
-0.2805984318,
0.8460770845,
-0.1434027404,
0.7132363915,
-0.8251718879,
-0.215405032,
0.3196435273,
0.0169689842,
-0.0468567684,
-0.6933889985,
0.6878358722,
-0.1608872563,
-0.2417062223,
-0.6340023279,
0.7171935439,
-0.431791991,
-0.1824627668,
0.1544557959,
0.2382316589,
0.5704570413,
-0.2735519409,
-0.5246133208,
0.3820612133,
0.3225688338,
0.0706348419,
-0.0411689617,
0.4785381258,
-0.1418442279,
0.7120395303,
0.8484477401,
0.4482051134,
0.3399490416,
-0.1787484288,
0.7508892417,
-0.8016860485,
-0.8994185925,
-0.3476672173,
0.3138840795,
0.1510469019,
-0.7878382802,
0.9025239944,
0.5276013613,
0.7512158155,
-0.144778803,
0.6641421318,
-0.1126649454,
1.0824307203,
-0.9090734124,
0.9369646907,
-0.1112909988,
-0.4300185144,
-0.1166342273,
-0.6968419552,
-0.3508606851,
0.8998698592,
-0.1878792048,
-0.4638474286,
0.4446555376,
0.9221500158,
0.2020507604,
0.3516457975,
0.4441107512,
0.726280272,
-0.1082518622,
0.3901330233,
0.9035562873,
-0.6753286123,
0.3850449324,
0.0623643957,
-0.1125922576,
-0.0952441394,
-0.9532859325,
-0.9139791727,
-1.0445256233,
-0.3503451347,
-0.3716682494,
0.4605748951,
0.5187635422,
0.8810273409,
-1.0193129778,
-0.5418989062,
0.3131894767,
-0.0389395095,
-0.3331960738,
-0.1117098555,
0.278937757,
0.2302665114,
-0.55809623,
0.7789619565,
0.2164331228,
0.4114820063,
-0.2532264292,
-0.2686800063,
0.1976753175,
0.0463936515,
0.4048883319,
0.6233786345,
-0.7315798402,
-0.2282373756,
0.0172705762,
0.5158856511,
-0.0495010726,
0.7331627607,
-0.7598202229,
0.8446397185,
0.4202923179,
0.1720279604,
0.5693772435,
-0.3486957252,
1.0417717695,
-0.8345930576,
0.1995924562,
0.4901899695,
-0.1516970098,
0.4245488048,
-0.1025462896,
0.2496114075,
-0.2619226575,
-0.3151785433,
-1.3064317703,
0.1732272208,
-0.9273861051,
0.2368315011,
1.1009113789,
0.1480163187,
-0.4081822634,
-0.7280925512,
-0.5460755229,
-0.2565412819,
-0.6345003247,
0.4944324195,
0.7461103201,
-0.1578533798,
-0.2460664511,
-0.8149001598,
0.9305738211,
-0.032531634,
-0.1469148695,
0.0146546857,
0.1516401172,
0.0241062585,
0.446965307,
0.8597373962,
-0.2383528501,
0.4721961021,
0.1228746772,
0.1456144899,
-0.0585274026,
-0.521473527,
-0.8948851228,
-0.2152809948,
0.240471676,
-0.4041364491
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01916v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01916v1
|
CoLe and LYS at BioASQ MESINESP8 Task: similarity based descriptor assignment in Spanish
| 2024-02-02T21:36:03 | 2024-02-02T21:36:03 |
Francisco J. Ribadas-Pena, Shuyuan Cao, Elmurod Kuriyozov
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG, 68P20, 68T50, H.3.3; I.2.7
|
In this paper, we describe our participation in the MESINESP Task of the
BioASQ biomedical semantic indexing challenge. The participating system follows
an approach based solely on conventional information retrieval tools. We have
evaluated various alternatives for extracting index terms from IBECS/LILACS
documents in order to be stored in an Apache Lucene index. Those indexed
representations are queried using the contents of the article to be annotated
and a ranked list of candidate labels is created from the retrieved documents.
We also have evaluated a sort of limited Label Powerset approach which creates
meta-labels joining pairs of DeCS labels with high co-occurrence scores, and an
alternative method based on label profile matching. Results obtained in
official runs seem to confirm the suitability of this approach for languages
like Spanish.
|
[
-0.1301778704,
-0.0725485459,
0.6110144258,
0.2461097538,
-0.2274017781,
0.2970209718,
0.3045951724,
-0.824403882,
0.8148623109,
0.3534428179,
-0.7965106964,
-0.5970559716,
-0.4777097404,
0.77764678,
-0.1736489534,
0.9123032093,
0.0647177845,
0.255574435,
-0.2416260391,
-0.425309062,
-0.0751332566,
-0.4156018198,
-0.6586841345,
-0.1389827579,
0.9183915854,
0.2914771736,
0.5783272386,
0.6814284921,
0.9197214842,
0.3727089763,
-0.1936564744,
-0.1837039441,
-0.3254608512,
0.2696815729,
-0.8053207397,
-0.4009785056,
-0.2366690636,
-0.0536358729,
0.4500304163,
0.845708847,
0.2604132891,
0.371866703,
-0.2252509892,
0.6580393314,
-0.5939514637,
0.0712117627,
-0.7222152352,
0.1018028259,
-0.4170914888,
-0.3806566894,
-0.1522921622,
-0.2625704408,
0.1503524929,
-0.3254857659,
0.174827829,
0.2393990457,
0.7231870294,
0.4240868986,
-0.4552339911,
-0.5640975237,
-0.4162436724,
0.964158237,
-0.5357175469,
0.6097265482,
0.1397322714,
0.2812410295,
-0.174812302,
-0.6186792254,
-0.1632470638,
-0.0886784047,
-0.061601989,
0.2158481777,
0.0207167342,
0.0968215913,
0.3393931985,
0.3633673489,
-0.5370443463,
0.2345795035,
-0.7913292646,
-0.5913580656,
0.4446788132,
0.2770940065,
0.0061271195,
-0.0467373878,
-0.303860724,
-0.2355056256,
-0.7374305129,
0.1425973773,
0.1307778358,
0.2269010395,
0.4094210267,
0.7434927225,
-0.5966177583,
0.3350132406,
0.0768733472,
-0.1754674613,
0.7234190106,
-0.2057307661,
0.0001927396,
0.2187590301,
0.7365630865,
0.4050142169,
-0.2194256186,
-0.2890925109,
-0.0957881957,
-0.022446692,
-0.0291122086,
-0.8050743937,
0.1511123478,
0.2721389532,
-0.4489242733,
-0.3220990002,
0.2338780016,
-0.7902038693,
-0.093218796,
-0.0953692794,
0.4458996058,
-0.2349912524,
0.3647996783,
-0.1159391925,
-0.3953275681,
0.3020005226,
-0.0352843255,
-1.11947155,
0.2300545424,
0.4845641255,
0.6264326572,
-0.3204107881,
-0.1296676546,
-0.211375922,
0.3803395033,
-0.0142127266,
0.5929436684,
-0.5507640839,
-0.2563925982,
-0.3855231404,
0.7045325637,
-0.3560287654,
-0.5791550279,
0.5179332495,
-0.3353540897,
-0.0423993804,
-0.4301122725,
-0.3037273586,
0.0723410919,
0.1000452489,
-0.6385602355,
0.9820648432,
0.353564024,
-0.8121399283,
-0.1843618602,
-0.6804528832,
-0.1709735841,
0.1772788465,
-0.2621837258,
0.0058027324,
-0.1354050338,
-0.2543182671,
0.2917615473,
-0.2766396999,
0.0729648024,
-0.1017714366,
-0.1372943968,
0.3557039797,
-0.0335049182,
0.9208773375,
0.3530478477,
-0.2753321826,
0.1856246889,
-0.7545881271,
0.0233226642,
-0.1252555698,
-0.1514327079,
-0.5358333588,
-0.1497233063,
-0.1884686053,
0.2560125291,
0.5767211318,
-1.0267056227,
0.0510466434,
-0.600107789,
0.2177872211,
0.4528810978,
0.0389408544,
0.3174734712,
-0.1489819735,
0.5021260381,
-0.2216180712,
0.326998353,
0.1077657342,
-0.4993314147,
-0.5033869743,
-0.2496955693,
0.4545212984,
0.9192622304,
-0.8200611472,
0.3711418211,
-0.185609147,
-0.6008170247,
-0.7153506279,
-0.1916180104,
0.4617188573,
0.5839186907,
0.6182781458,
-0.2326444387,
-0.3876425326,
-1.2734363079,
0.1284177601,
0.1008825824,
-0.484600693,
0.3193370402,
0.6286245584,
-0.5641945004,
0.491900295,
-0.4329817891,
-0.4300670922,
0.3332230449,
0.0758502334,
0.4444723725,
0.5303701758,
0.7418069243,
-0.6087151766,
-0.1203065664,
0.0553720482,
-0.6174070835,
-0.4467288554,
0.3677305877,
-0.1476069391,
-0.0039581652,
0.8095012307,
-0.0111884531,
0.2761666775,
0.6108151674,
-0.3310640454,
0.4578501284,
-0.2261870205,
0.508698523,
-1.0179702044,
0.153786853,
-0.3045780659,
-0.2567772567,
-0.1158679426,
0.1016043723,
-0.0008031817,
-0.0388314314,
-0.6619828939,
0.4709398448,
-0.3201627135,
-0.0341418982,
-0.00750473,
-0.2593261003,
0.128953889,
0.3145563304,
0.0652540773,
0.6145691276,
0.3430333734,
-0.4006214738,
0.4869445562,
0.3300169706,
-0.0547050983,
0.6168179512,
-0.8307393193,
-0.2020095438,
-0.2598799467,
0.0522506833,
-0.7743167877,
0.0390506312,
0.3867838085,
-0.0862524509,
0.116483584,
0.2620279789,
-0.0847123638,
-0.7305597067,
-0.8174183965,
0.572451055,
0.0540029965,
-0.4294992685,
0.1753134429,
0.4489237964,
-0.1959855258,
-0.7005599737,
-0.6767127514,
-0.0352294333,
-0.4694407582,
-0.3328149915,
0.8500170708,
-0.0680909753,
-0.1634455323,
0.080987595,
-0.053143315,
-0.0387852304,
0.1828132123,
0.3461167514,
-0.1332738996,
-0.2227504849,
0.1126207933,
0.3020363152,
-0.2813762724,
-0.0416299216,
0.0470009893,
0.1683777124,
-0.2472529262,
-0.1591234356,
-0.3181227744,
0.6751251817,
0.4059537947,
-0.3165063858,
0.6165510416,
0.2444157749,
-0.3051427603,
0.3942849636,
-0.2933332324,
-0.1052567661,
-0.4622197449,
0.3468654454,
-0.5819941163,
-0.7967353463,
0.7948237062,
-0.3477291763,
-0.1213641912,
0.7900983691,
0.5539091229,
-0.4613121152,
0.8170595169,
0.7220654488,
0.1512028724,
0.3547384739,
-0.2977126241,
0.2054211199,
-1.0111287832,
-0.4876594841,
-0.9774124622,
-0.4879743457,
-0.7254627347,
-0.5125451684,
0.6022464633,
-0.1450276226,
0.0743241087,
0.5306172371,
-0.6240515113,
0.3810379207,
0.7043973207,
0.2744524479,
0.222288236,
-0.3772307038,
-0.1769991219,
-0.1361144036,
-0.4836268127,
-0.4920104742,
0.7348871827,
0.2031086385,
0.6951002479,
0.1647472978,
0.8643751144,
0.1750638187,
0.2278752029,
-0.7530514002,
0.3737879992,
-0.2085586488,
-0.4204951525,
-0.407435596,
-0.0962796062,
-1.33603549,
-0.0276512969,
-0.4026344419,
-1.0517516136,
0.5805777907,
-0.2900755703,
-0.1727942228,
-0.3726181388,
-0.2783424258,
1.1033705473,
-0.414773792,
-0.1971457899,
-0.1692434102,
-0.9527033567,
-0.1674132049,
0.0301179774,
0.0920533687,
-0.3836674094,
-0.066865921,
1.2493097782,
-0.4853999615,
0.3065013587,
0.1853545755,
0.0771964416,
0.2814120948,
-0.1487615258,
-0.0607215725,
-0.1632773131,
-0.4775778651,
0.1185662076,
1.0537793636,
-0.3695496619,
-0.382927686,
0.7324968576,
-0.46560812,
-0.3233746886,
-0.646900475,
-0.5209511518,
-0.0330949239,
0.2907924354,
0.2632699311,
0.4899344444,
-0.2160434127,
0.3288161457,
0.3304544985,
-0.2240498513,
0.1687912941,
0.5645786524,
-0.0798633024,
-0.1776061058,
0.9511263371,
0.1458886862,
0.013512996,
0.6778962612,
0.3060828447,
-0.6039895415,
-0.5240695477,
-0.2099979967,
0.4165605009,
-0.5931103826,
-0.4862695038,
-0.5043774843,
-0.1085708588,
-0.5007768273,
-0.1684641093,
-0.3143846989,
-0.6232276559,
-0.0434953645,
-0.0517631769,
0.3252476156,
0.568162322,
-0.1763323694,
0.2542268336,
-0.7240460515,
0.2738170922,
0.0313119143,
0.2457235157,
-0.3923330009,
-0.1266642511,
-0.3077076972,
0.1608274132,
-0.4939526916,
-1.3677983284,
0.1391631216,
0.1956731379,
0.7014014721,
0.4422681332,
0.190985769,
0.4379690886,
-0.3952665329,
0.3928416967,
-0.0964316875,
-0.6035746336,
0.7177775502,
-0.3571226895,
0.0802236125,
1.1260700226,
0.9106100798,
-0.3916296959,
-0.7190787792,
-0.6712227464,
-0.9713941813,
0.3070013523,
0.0297956821,
-0.2138175368,
-0.5443035364,
0.3813614249,
0.045490399,
0.0497126058,
-0.5596381426,
-0.2767860293,
0.1357736588,
-0.7245592475,
0.2995623946,
-0.4719949663,
0.0759108663,
-0.3482264876,
0.8256624937,
-0.2336216122,
0.1174088642,
0.534116745,
-0.1584931016,
0.194767803,
0.2210210413,
0.266440928,
0.5143399239,
-0.5239095688,
0.2227296531,
-0.0558320433,
-0.2961888909,
0.1715719998,
0.0123740323,
-0.3696721792,
0.0655087531,
0.1365636587,
0.2727478147,
0.419470787,
-0.9879919291,
0.3628096282,
0.0227958933,
-0.1512628347,
-0.0348162875,
-0.1847895086,
0.1063505411,
0.41067186,
0.4672943354,
-0.4045364261,
0.7622250915,
-0.7303719521,
0.3321009278,
0.6370745301,
-0.5809886456,
-0.3250656426,
0.6899254918,
0.2849167883,
-0.2396812886,
0.3053270876,
-0.3030053973,
-0.6576883197,
0.8170858622,
0.6180957556,
0.4175706208,
-0.5000959635,
0.2875525355,
0.5918798447,
0.0512685254,
-0.0043753781,
0.2839421332,
0.0864412263,
-0.4893044531,
-0.1932874322,
-0.7680863142,
-0.542822957,
0.035705395,
-0.5785708427,
0.5566135645,
-0.3248005807,
0.0000600863,
0.293124795,
-0.0617847852,
-0.5134720206,
0.1900283694,
0.0875985846,
0.6787820458,
-1.1277188063,
0.4902562499,
0.6635327339,
-0.3184494972,
-0.4916757941,
-0.6084656119,
-0.0654048622,
-0.5000380874,
0.3331457675,
0.2375189066,
-0.0497764051,
0.0541084334,
-0.1991527975,
-1.1077990532,
1.350856781,
0.1233595163,
-0.3872629702,
-0.0783048868,
0.1612930745,
0.8361691833,
-0.2426560521,
0.5885294676,
0.5936685205,
0.407792151,
0.2619516253,
-1.1009888649,
0.0689150393,
-0.2045256943,
-0.3372271955,
0.0654652491,
-0.529158175,
0.696618855,
0.0087951971,
-0.1379078329,
0.4491966963,
0.5906403065,
-0.0372687764,
0.5897795558,
0.1942462325,
0.3468880653,
0.9830684662,
0.1125792414,
0.8311434388,
-0.2335709035,
0.3627178967,
0.9043501019,
-0.1103855669,
0.6146070361,
0.8397125602,
-0.4527605176,
0.4166005552,
0.8691033125,
-0.0752769783,
0.6556230187,
0.265358597,
-0.1665592045,
0.3839533031,
-0.6919516325,
-0.4420266151,
0.5792645812,
0.562050879,
-0.4937584698,
-0.4590417147,
0.0661993325,
-0.3018190563,
0.1677480042,
-0.3740371466,
0.7881934047,
-0.0407202765,
-0.3200475574,
0.3235884011,
0.162310645,
0.7163003683,
-0.3967808187,
0.0071949265,
-0.0345122367,
0.0851350278,
-0.3686743379,
-0.6375320554,
0.8344983459,
-0.3311289251,
-0.2492183,
-0.1153608784,
0.4676906168,
-0.5579878092,
-0.8187113404,
0.2279023677,
0.4692271948,
0.6546275616,
0.1922766119,
-0.7354227901,
-0.1969940811,
-0.0036904132,
0.129618302,
0.294426173,
0.4443151057,
-0.6598153114,
0.5443918109,
0.2030011714,
-0.0551269799,
0.1776158661,
0.0073395786,
0.5049839616,
-0.744330287,
-0.1930049807,
-0.5949493647,
-0.1013353541,
0.1436747015,
-0.0271003377,
0.5088108778,
0.8834503889,
0.549870193,
-0.2972734571,
0.3180857897,
-0.240263164,
0.8014086485,
-0.3927510977,
0.186844483,
-0.347334832,
-0.0859947428,
-0.3724635243,
-1.0674878359,
-0.3588830233,
0.6638946533,
-0.0538687818,
-0.5539672971,
1.0720769167,
0.9455792904,
0.0155932587,
-0.3548533916,
0.0914228931,
0.0877030492,
0.2433384061,
0.8343693018,
0.5108030438,
-0.4903112054,
0.1378393471,
-0.5782218575,
-0.4055287242,
-0.1170875803,
-0.8525340557,
-0.6164944768,
-0.7989712954,
-0.3980431557,
-0.3914164007,
0.1105674207,
0.9211879969,
-0.0432689115,
-1.0801805258,
-0.0488467775,
0.4599011838,
0.3524941504,
-0.1694187671,
-0.184447214,
0.4516885877,
0.0445012189,
-0.9986934066,
0.4123737514,
0.3113091886,
0.1332971752,
0.0859897658,
0.2974898815,
-0.4432729185,
-0.2203215659,
0.4529394209,
0.5723950267,
-0.3178857565,
-0.5716825724,
0.2386911064,
-0.2352417558,
-0.0076227225,
0.5442339182,
-0.9464526176,
0.0665424541,
0.6760195494,
0.5932188034,
0.4485541284,
0.1761031151,
0.2372445911,
-0.4539588988,
0.6352098584,
0.3454886079,
0.2160015553,
0.3295258284,
-0.2953130603,
0.8531793356,
0.1613960862,
-0.3409151137,
-0.5262807608,
0.0152756395,
-1.3735268116,
-0.0030312666,
0.8758858442,
0.2872790396,
-0.6182187796,
-0.2157680541,
-0.4059223831,
0.0257673115,
-0.1230335683,
0.6664304137,
0.237101078,
-0.2067491263,
0.2588514686,
-0.3134237826,
0.5318818688,
0.3332273364,
-0.4554564655,
-0.5245326161,
0.1905979067,
0.1872539371,
0.5330851078,
0.9436739683,
-0.297927618,
0.1401638389,
-0.4663299918,
0.1915541142,
0.24542889,
-0.2568052113,
0.0214669481,
-0.2481009364,
0.043311961,
-0.2981765866
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01912v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01912v1
|
Natural language guidance of high-fidelity text-to-speech with synthetic annotations
| 2024-02-02T21:29:34 | 2024-02-02T21:29:34 |
Dan Lyth, Simon King
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Text-to-speech models trained on large-scale datasets have demonstrated
impressive in-context learning capabilities and naturalness. However, control
of speaker identity and style in these models typically requires conditioning
on reference speech recordings, limiting creative applications. Alternatively,
natural language prompting of speaker identity and style has demonstrated
promising results and provides an intuitive method of control. However,
reliance on human-labeled descriptions prevents scaling to large datasets. Our
work bridges the gap between these two approaches. We propose a scalable method
for labeling various aspects of speaker identity, style, and recording
conditions. We then apply this method to a 45k hour dataset, which we use to
train a speech language model. Furthermore, we propose simple methods for
increasing audio fidelity, significantly outperforming recent work despite
relying entirely on found data. Our results demonstrate high-fidelity speech
generation in a diverse range of accents, prosodic styles, channel conditions,
and acoustic conditions, all accomplished with a single model and intuitive
natural language conditioning. Audio samples can be heard at
https://text-description-to-speech.com/.
|
[
-0.5228822827,
-0.9173804522,
0.182573095,
0.3157497048,
-0.2338455319,
0.0154963331,
-0.5733892322,
-0.5597836971,
0.2520591915,
0.7277950644,
-0.5127627254,
-0.3921090364,
-0.3829083443,
0.1916359365,
-0.2688981295,
1.0496913195,
0.3676254153,
0.1109428257,
-0.0756858215,
-0.0602459125,
-0.5844305754,
-0.6106500626,
-0.7766686678,
-0.3471390009,
0.4214974344,
0.4233604372,
0.8865491748,
0.9388251901,
0.2808839679,
0.2240630537,
-0.2371974885,
0.4178368747,
-0.2633535266,
0.0600561202,
-0.1580624431,
0.0790188238,
-0.4624168873,
0.1117860302,
0.8404449224,
0.8988872766,
-0.1468762904,
0.0370427743,
-0.0067930506,
0.4390552044,
-0.3169174492,
0.1673894227,
-0.6013108492,
0.0126688126,
-0.2221423835,
-0.3342431188,
-0.792948544,
-0.3519445062,
0.4652798772,
-0.9012383819,
0.1478215605,
0.250906229,
0.6436023116,
0.3681960702,
-0.3447113633,
-0.2029837519,
-1.1529927254,
0.6372168064,
-0.5371422172,
0.4246480465,
0.5761650205,
0.6046877503,
-0.0057457844,
-0.6869246364,
-0.4262376428,
-0.3435600698,
-0.0453395359,
-0.0775070339,
0.2343715876,
0.2124574929,
0.260409534,
0.2982484698,
-0.3296019435,
0.1019565612,
-0.289922148,
-0.4407493174,
0.78272295,
-0.3214778304,
0.2105627507,
-0.0608142018,
-0.2941188812,
-0.2639890611,
-0.4883130491,
-0.1281497926,
0.4756501615,
0.7616007924,
-0.1364354044,
0.532636404,
-0.2491734326,
0.7440569401,
0.1857773811,
-0.295686692,
0.3018289506,
-0.4747767746,
-0.1014296189,
0.5538398027,
0.668073535,
0.2222285122,
0.483769536,
-0.5064473152,
-0.0666026026,
-0.2110241205,
0.3158679008,
-0.6918001175,
-0.2505241036,
-0.021023497,
-0.0710362121,
-0.1659980416,
-0.0253359005,
-0.7068251967,
-0.3840338886,
-0.812646687,
0.646505475,
-0.4095689356,
-0.0803804919,
-0.0190700814,
-0.1914636791,
-0.0102323089,
0.1430770308,
-1.146173358,
0.2993528545,
0.3564341068,
0.6997206211,
-0.1017936245,
0.0433129966,
-0.8663372397,
0.382060498,
-0.491786629,
0.561008811,
-0.6522672772,
-0.3619128764,
-0.0157057494,
-0.2558181882,
0.3592035472,
-0.4783313274,
0.650859952,
-0.1149975583,
0.3213935792,
-0.2162791044,
-0.4698241949,
0.0170078725,
-0.1157992408,
-0.6675594449,
0.9168809652,
-0.0779840946,
-0.5669846535,
0.466296196,
-0.4796790779,
-0.5733825564,
0.2337143868,
-0.0739326626,
-0.3685504496,
-0.040723417,
0.2419181317,
0.4103627205,
-0.1324931234,
0.4383938313,
0.0397123806,
-0.1740085483,
0.1877957731,
-0.4195545018,
0.3379155695,
0.1760628223,
-0.28040573,
0.1715890318,
-1.058126092,
-0.0502123684,
-0.0570580922,
-0.3680315912,
-0.2613511682,
0.093469657,
0.3515894711,
-0.1106598005,
0.0267361831,
-0.5374048352,
0.0144062527,
-0.6132180691,
0.4950890243,
0.4558717608,
0.2329947054,
0.6069073081,
-0.2893399596,
0.2444555312,
-0.4227741361,
-0.0879553333,
-0.4114099741,
-0.5394285321,
-0.4961387813,
-0.3150510192,
0.252368778,
0.5131497383,
-0.6235228181,
0.5274665952,
-0.2895376384,
-0.5042126179,
-0.5821764469,
0.0055925334,
0.497492671,
0.6570128202,
0.7367694974,
-0.0530678816,
-0.7215166092,
-0.993780911,
-0.3127679229,
-0.029636668,
-0.4064222276,
0.4005018473,
0.0208877511,
-0.1199540421,
1.12018466,
-0.1917929202,
-0.202768594,
0.0267655086,
0.5390781164,
-0.1090218648,
0.5365074873,
0.2730554044,
-0.8372285962,
-0.3325975239,
0.0021486701,
-0.1644277126,
-0.1797501445,
-0.4028482139,
-0.2536763847,
0.0964378044,
0.6124989986,
-0.2630661428,
-0.0217656847,
0.4585728049,
-0.1261624098,
0.4656872153,
-0.368196249,
-0.0492082797,
-1.2349009514,
0.0662987083,
0.2889312208,
-0.318051964,
-0.8793860078,
-0.4555430412,
-0.2037761807,
-0.1907272339,
-0.3289006948,
0.6473741531,
-0.1370313317,
0.1512340009,
-0.1817487031,
0.336902976,
-0.0799082518,
0.3528457284,
0.3709854186,
0.7978713512,
0.4302592278,
-0.7458916903,
0.4910505116,
0.4243332148,
-0.1725862473,
0.694938302,
-0.689111948,
0.3644386232,
-0.2275848687,
0.4895889163,
-0.9912701845,
-0.6753054261,
0.0611341111,
-0.5289482474,
0.458254993,
-0.1662560254,
-0.5302358866,
0.0592565164,
0.1170705557,
0.2971299291,
0.5188708305,
-0.7811026573,
0.5024630427,
0.3493478596,
-0.4118232429,
-0.135450229,
-0.6678644419,
0.355833441,
-0.3582462668,
-0.3411735594,
0.7838901877,
-0.1584902108,
-0.2345658541,
-0.4832355082,
-0.0018982546,
-0.2785461843,
-0.1227706894,
0.2853889763,
0.2144084424,
0.0157838035,
0.5387616754,
0.0517946966,
-0.0961614475,
0.0949501693,
-0.4015364051,
0.2133991718,
0.1347611398,
0.0214191489,
-0.713021934,
0.4055624008,
0.2835887074,
-0.3230942786,
0.5071002841,
0.7437039614,
-0.3522680402,
-0.2695478797,
-0.4714958072,
-0.3685225546,
-0.4611257017,
0.2968554497,
-0.1220385209,
-0.6898905635,
0.056808386,
0.0690843016,
0.2218767852,
0.2816741467,
0.4533712864,
-0.0387469344,
1.1062320471,
0.5048407912,
0.0262374058,
0.5031549335,
0.0856012329,
0.1804813296,
-0.5417714715,
-0.3292438388,
-0.6501095295,
-0.0792121291,
-0.7450398803,
-0.3572596908,
0.1747715175,
-0.1338647753,
-0.2305095643,
0.3569017053,
-0.8156395555,
0.3967724144,
0.670802772,
0.0464611873,
0.1535609663,
0.0605129562,
0.1262501925,
-0.2217434347,
-0.418471992,
-0.5612878799,
0.9116667509,
0.4840886295,
0.6203211546,
-0.0683347136,
0.5761604905,
0.3224502802,
0.0328354985,
-0.7960448861,
0.296659559,
-0.0631927028,
-0.5860704184,
-0.5083048344,
-0.4453161955,
-0.5395171642,
-0.1750545651,
-0.3259043992,
-0.7171251774,
-0.0207073167,
0.5925619602,
-0.5290110111,
-0.1345931739,
-0.8131237626,
0.5496909022,
-0.0080421679,
-0.3379600346,
0.000782701,
-0.6918522716,
0.0533660464,
-0.1866012663,
0.3015155792,
-0.0636951402,
0.0762754157,
0.851627171,
-0.0925945044,
0.8101302981,
-0.2150767595,
-0.1893478185,
0.2213117629,
-0.0393266045,
0.540777564,
0.2120517045,
-0.0954663977,
-0.1129570454,
-0.0480646789,
-0.2663264871,
-0.5269827247,
0.4401856065,
-0.5317084193,
-0.2258082181,
0.0973786637,
-0.6618602276,
-0.6462293863,
0.0659797415,
0.3850062788,
0.7860782743,
-0.1319072545,
0.5115284324,
0.9521406889,
-0.2886533141,
0.4626500309,
0.0485840403,
0.000492203,
-0.5919466019,
0.9996290207,
0.0934950784,
0.5526052117,
0.4239433408,
0.422570765,
-0.4888139963,
-0.3993740678,
-0.4426877499,
0.1685582399,
-0.3888678551,
0.1789485663,
-0.2957274914,
-0.1633953005,
-0.5437745452,
-0.1481705904,
-0.5643956065,
-0.61372298,
-0.2884638011,
-0.0711079985,
0.4094932675,
0.5787959099,
0.1027164161,
0.593108058,
-0.5415410399,
0.4220865071,
0.5453760028,
0.2673216462,
-0.4131217897,
-0.7619102001,
-0.2526470125,
0.3807328939,
-0.0896320865,
-0.7853009701,
0.4073721766,
0.6338092089,
0.4173644483,
0.3998272121,
0.3072939515,
0.5090734959,
-0.5540368557,
0.8382552862,
0.061438296,
-0.9287996292,
0.7703428268,
-0.476844281,
0.4120541215,
0.4466014504,
0.321195513,
-0.5912653804,
-0.3608809114,
-0.516575098,
-0.8586958051,
0.5422310829,
0.2322215438,
0.3874587715,
0.1093005091,
0.3437156379,
-0.0230498649,
0.1682105362,
-0.6567655802,
-0.2426456064,
-0.4496234953,
-0.0873518214,
-0.3279315531,
-0.1253899336,
-0.3889925182,
-0.2258299291,
0.7410445809,
-0.3586136699,
0.2050694972,
0.275203228,
0.1208714321,
-0.0506380536,
0.3718886077,
0.7167716026,
0.4205147624,
-0.2131369859,
0.1913415492,
0.1370560825,
-0.23581554,
-0.1029657647,
0.1412911266,
0.0205663517,
0.1559728384,
0.3551878035,
1.0854551792,
0.2505995631,
-0.4871172905,
0.1483623534,
0.1312754005,
-0.3467699289,
-0.2976150215,
0.0155512402,
0.1270016283,
-0.1679576188,
0.313945204,
-0.0956182182,
0.0176474359,
-0.4537636638,
0.1588835716,
0.2118445486,
-0.5343692303,
-0.1665270478,
0.7085217237,
0.4662339091,
-0.6608918309,
0.531701386,
-0.1728271544,
-0.1018964425,
0.3101934493,
0.5305609107,
0.7884653807,
-0.3158562779,
0.1910555661,
0.4292557836,
0.0772601664,
-0.0937041268,
-0.0044146203,
-0.4321560562,
-0.3933592439,
-0.6252812743,
-0.6257683039,
-0.6614729762,
0.0489613973,
-0.6902495027,
0.1887412071,
-0.4495723248,
-0.3411572576,
0.3525698781,
-0.190281257,
-0.2421633154,
0.3861604333,
0.4493346214,
0.8372137547,
-0.8827850819,
0.902095139,
0.4503332078,
-0.2062430978,
-0.8408403397,
0.0363717601,
0.0000364698,
-0.2042391002,
0.4484231472,
0.2104664445,
-0.1570204198,
0.1520819515,
-0.5472317934,
-0.7204177976,
0.761169076,
0.5030063987,
-0.57480371,
-0.2179333419,
0.2112761587,
0.6205744743,
-0.3186862469,
-0.0167090632,
0.669100821,
0.6519147754,
0.5160996318,
-1.1844990253,
-0.3194964826,
-0.0483711548,
0.0832894892,
0.0733717084,
-0.2258104384,
0.4119501412,
-0.0674121752,
-0.0696658939,
-0.1504013985,
0.8125064969,
0.1060789451,
0.1315775365,
0.5000067949,
0.2554081082,
0.7914376259,
-0.1847803295,
0.8331218958,
-0.1486021131,
0.0177837182,
1.4117114544,
0.1035156697,
0.7992812991,
0.4832155108,
0.0719036832,
0.1538763195,
0.5658326149,
0.143792659,
0.4184651375,
0.1822925061,
-0.329584837,
-0.3458068967,
-0.5663351417,
-0.3056593537,
0.3905252516,
0.2370998412,
-0.3124657571,
0.1285782605,
0.1279392987,
0.0082559343,
0.4643404782,
-0.1002042815,
0.8061531186,
-0.1685468853,
-0.6788787246,
0.6209216118,
-0.335735023,
0.6256284118,
-0.5085055828,
-0.1218208149,
0.0689126179,
-0.2074348927,
-0.1769242883,
-0.4699178934,
0.2572613657,
-0.0925881416,
-0.1680988818,
-0.6208661795,
0.1856650859,
-0.7191399932,
-0.3981316686,
-0.0335928015,
-0.1503223628,
-0.066197753,
-0.0717205852,
-0.0669236928,
-0.1694782823,
-0.1043811888,
-0.1397549659,
0.0482859462,
0.3274414241,
0.0376716144,
0.6360414028,
0.5450901389,
0.3815264106,
0.1969217509,
0.1291627735,
0.382504344,
-0.2953237593,
-0.5686817169,
-0.6495332718,
0.4377759993,
-0.2788461149,
-0.3808324039,
0.5465725064,
0.521396935,
0.85975492,
0.031367816,
0.6858374476,
0.2294798493,
0.7553408742,
-0.5630936623,
0.5431048274,
-0.1394220889,
0.0278137457,
-0.3417054415,
-0.8946430087,
-0.2377419323,
0.4726785421,
-0.0555842482,
0.0200162046,
0.3931144476,
0.8574944735,
0.0787172839,
0.0322116502,
0.2689827979,
-0.0349405855,
0.4383493364,
0.1004466787,
0.4857182205,
-0.0583487265,
0.5888369083,
-0.4410808086,
-0.0982508734,
-0.1542960405,
-1.0015500784,
-0.702279985,
-0.785225153,
-0.5956719518,
-0.2193632126,
0.059130393,
1.1804311275,
1.2828119993,
-0.6633324623,
-0.1857231706,
-0.1219800562,
-0.3544640243,
-0.2171151787,
-0.1530481726,
0.1284839958,
-0.4108793437,
-0.9744488597,
0.764756918,
0.1147433445,
0.3985296786,
-0.3354960978,
-0.3201696277,
0.0198548976,
0.3923066258,
0.5079512596,
0.3908511996,
-0.7847802043,
-0.3217435181,
-0.4111001194,
-0.072054781,
0.0021054861,
0.6831757426,
-0.7547653317,
0.8533363938,
0.3416790664,
0.6396327615,
0.4382442832,
0.2189109772,
0.8148192167,
-1.2417474985,
0.2043592781,
0.3778279722,
-0.1272973269,
0.4635626078,
-0.3290612102,
0.1775324196,
-0.0050280066,
-0.5457721353,
-0.8229259849,
0.173588261,
-1.1038353443,
0.1461967677,
1.264801383,
0.130243808,
0.0749237388,
0.0549729653,
-0.5832015276,
0.4945471585,
-0.5034287572,
0.7559453249,
0.5967459083,
-0.0530920699,
-0.0760696977,
-0.6733184457,
0.8878468871,
0.2447815984,
-0.7659302354,
0.3353225887,
0.5070715547,
-0.1348029375,
0.2469534129,
0.2025068998,
0.2460855097,
0.1110463515,
-0.1298904568,
0.1564296186,
-0.1765942872,
-0.5292612314,
-0.2703841925,
-0.0135173853,
0.2198129296,
-0.316234529
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01878v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01878v2
|
LiPO: Listwise Preference Optimization through Learning-to-Rank
| 2024-02-02T20:08:10 | 2024-05-22T18:51:02 |
Tianqi Liu, Zhen Qin, Junru Wu, Jiaming Shen, Misha Khalman, Rishabh Joshi, Yao Zhao, Mohammad Saleh, Simon Baumgartner, Jialu Liu, Peter J. Liu, Xuanhui Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Aligning language models (LMs) with curated human feedback is critical to
control their behaviors in real-world applications. Several recent policy
optimization methods, such as DPO and SLiC, serve as promising alternatives to
the traditional Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) approach. In
practice, human feedback often comes in a format of a ranked list over multiple
responses to amortize the cost of reading prompt. Multiple responses can also
be ranked by reward models or AI feedback. There lacks such a thorough study on
directly fitting upon a list of responses. In this work, we formulate the LM
alignment as a \textit{listwise} ranking problem and describe the LiPO
framework, where the policy can potentially learn more effectively from a
ranked list of plausible responses given the prompt. This view draws an
explicit connection to Learning-to-Rank (LTR), where most existing preference
optimization work can be mapped to existing ranking objectives. Following this
connection, we provide an examination of ranking objectives that are not well
studied for LM alignment with DPO and SLiC as special cases when list size is
two. In particular, we highlight a specific method, LiPO-$\lambda$, which
leverages a state-of-the-art \textit{listwise} ranking objective and weights
each preference pair in a more advanced manner. We show that LiPO-$\lambda$ can
outperform DPO variants and SLiC by a clear margin on several preference
alignment tasks with both curated and real rankwise preference data.
|
[
-0.3274737,
-0.0660337135,
0.4213145375,
-0.2751578689,
-0.1197712496,
0.2273915112,
-0.1974566132,
-0.4019167423,
0.158719629,
0.6705550551,
-0.5750951767,
-0.2498131096,
-0.5600210428,
-0.1174020469,
0.0974552259,
1.4111331701,
0.2568104267,
-0.0249171872,
-0.225055933,
-0.1325752437,
-0.2677576244,
-0.3321896195,
-0.5035818219,
-0.3623864949,
0.8017436862,
0.7385864258,
0.8345320225,
0.8425164223,
0.3940137029,
0.2191111296,
0.0468276292,
0.3929907084,
-0.7997320294,
0.011401902,
-0.0567952991,
-0.2354583293,
-0.4356234372,
0.1340232193,
0.7697076797,
0.5693155527,
-0.3966883421,
0.1218191236,
0.0866167322,
1.1050226688,
-0.5940209627,
-0.2171791345,
-0.531285882,
-0.0692265853,
0.2163244039,
0.0147003997,
-0.4040924907,
-0.5523256063,
0.3547725677,
-0.7003720999,
-0.3304463625,
0.5077386498,
0.7603758574,
0.5883131623,
-0.3192866743,
-0.3538148701,
-0.6328418255,
1.0209975243,
-0.3169840276,
0.3921974301,
0.4036284387,
0.4157089591,
-0.0425077081,
-0.0806742385,
-0.2419752181,
-0.3359989226,
0.1544935703,
0.4410987198,
0.5133937597,
0.0147150429,
-0.1003394127,
0.2545445859,
-0.6000726819,
0.5473316312,
-0.1491996646,
-0.0858401358,
0.553824842,
-0.3397444785,
0.1180312186,
-0.1289853603,
-0.5938057899,
-0.3664548397,
-0.5685970187,
0.3808277845,
0.6419318318,
0.4281648993,
0.0982258096,
0.5651373267,
0.1263112873,
0.8322790861,
0.0415998437,
-0.3556292057,
-0.2382942885,
-0.0961745828,
0.0841811448,
0.3777187169,
0.5319606066,
0.5578429699,
0.2958898246,
-0.2993763089,
-0.327235043,
-0.2931720018,
0.485941112,
-0.705994308,
0.1698766351,
0.3067468703,
-0.3226364851,
-0.5455183387,
0.117563881,
-0.7453548312,
-0.4576047361,
-0.204166159,
0.2784208357,
0.0607506968,
-0.0098399073,
0.0269727167,
-0.0722737834,
0.1818897724,
0.1691164672,
-1.2025665045,
0.4919421673,
0.9161801338,
0.5525027514,
-0.4219526947,
-0.2630069256,
-0.7909260392,
0.2668139338,
-0.4150236547,
0.6913551688,
-0.4891205728,
-0.3882938623,
0.1122967079,
-0.4368080497,
0.1080039963,
-0.4636834264,
0.6342135072,
-0.450363934,
0.3397946358,
-0.3254123926,
-0.6630457044,
0.2477530986,
0.1215670258,
-0.5208675265,
1.089411974,
0.0498639643,
-0.459397763,
0.546623826,
-0.3951672316,
-0.1440756172,
-0.1471081227,
-0.2433841527,
-0.538715899,
-0.2264584601,
0.0858152956,
0.2213310897,
-0.5013079643,
0.1501488239,
-0.4542785287,
-0.3389876485,
0.3438022137,
0.2691948116,
0.3134121895,
0.1455840319,
-0.1863088012,
0.4127525985,
-0.4210055172,
0.1251291484,
-0.065602906,
-0.2389165759,
-0.3659664392,
0.3499619365,
-0.2056516707,
0.1401169449,
0.2845704556,
-0.384368062,
0.6442585588,
-0.6556521058,
0.5566541553,
0.935872972,
-0.3106729686,
0.7992653847,
-0.647303462,
0.3839843273,
-0.4999559224,
0.4255103767,
0.6527029276,
-0.369391948,
-0.3402569294,
-0.2979371846,
0.1693147868,
0.6136922836,
-0.3328586817,
0.557839036,
-0.3560616672,
-0.2979557812,
-0.6162106991,
0.1339022517,
0.4528502524,
0.6874185801,
0.3114188612,
0.0540533811,
-0.2056488097,
-1.0644971132,
-0.2881850004,
-0.2283952683,
0.1664444953,
0.7397753,
0.105606623,
0.1300035715,
0.719158113,
-0.5355318189,
-0.3452558815,
-0.2662842274,
-0.2173356563,
0.2710001767,
0.3554638028,
0.574593544,
-0.4918299913,
-0.3943156004,
0.0199670065,
-0.1497536451,
0.0805225,
0.2004411221,
-0.2207817584,
0.2418324351,
0.0748587027,
-0.0270969458,
-0.0421348624,
0.5013390779,
0.1874469817,
0.2129070908,
-0.2539212704,
0.0302703977,
-1.017991662,
-0.046032574,
-0.1277839094,
-0.1979182363,
-0.4271624088,
-0.0997381285,
-0.0848862007,
-0.3849835098,
-0.2990827262,
0.7779039741,
-0.2293271124,
-0.4425381422,
-0.1781213284,
0.2265840918,
-0.2707982063,
0.6011320353,
0.1764173508,
0.8446981907,
0.3288306892,
-0.5726969242,
-0.123490423,
0.1590696871,
-0.064905487,
0.2461694479,
-0.5376271605,
0.2866984606,
-0.1502903849,
0.0935022533,
-1.2079383135,
0.1306460798,
0.260441184,
-0.2312503904,
0.2779844701,
-0.3897443414,
-0.3112472594,
-0.1997613609,
-0.757088244,
0.543058753,
0.518794775,
-0.6480485201,
0.1258337498,
0.6411246657,
0.1452557594,
-1.1987556219,
-0.0649799183,
-0.4057871401,
-0.34403193,
-0.0616796799,
0.5510309339,
-0.1769993752,
-0.0112856962,
-0.3880554736,
-0.4101780653,
0.1787147075,
0.1275947988,
0.0865795165,
0.5215038657,
0.3222950399,
0.0958613083,
0.0016363126,
-0.2244170159,
-0.2567237914,
-0.688585937,
0.3790104389,
-0.1968150735,
-0.0080315601,
-0.4329079688,
0.1820477992,
0.5372059345,
-0.1102518737,
0.474232167,
0.1865191162,
-0.2310073227,
-0.2308966964,
-0.4637264311,
-0.2937826514,
-0.4304793775,
0.0353335515,
-0.3661960065,
-0.7941188216,
0.2794900537,
-0.1192559823,
0.1928043664,
0.1656406969,
0.1890475005,
-0.2707348466,
1.3121166229,
0.5215656757,
-0.366109848,
0.5291439891,
-0.1612381041,
0.1415170878,
-0.8091976047,
-0.1089503467,
-0.6878178716,
-0.5971779823,
-0.8473731875,
-0.0485238954,
0.337249279,
0.3840560019,
-0.3872429132,
0.2664933503,
-0.9806297421,
0.3050577939,
0.4289047718,
0.0957759768,
0.0558405519,
0.0640955642,
-0.3583730459,
-0.0809331015,
-0.8019632101,
-0.4565573931,
1.095559597,
0.199782446,
0.6603776217,
0.391091466,
0.9981065989,
0.2980355024,
0.2977565527,
-1.0775226355,
0.4669863582,
-0.4823559523,
-0.0295216367,
-0.7129145861,
-0.1825149804,
-1.0356407166,
0.0653625727,
-0.2292878628,
-0.9156745672,
0.1145549864,
0.2782935798,
-0.2469120324,
0.0014485681,
-0.3535317183,
0.7542312741,
-0.6001179218,
-0.4209891558,
-0.2720966339,
-0.7424515486,
0.1302865297,
0.356346637,
0.2296306938,
-0.1898397803,
-0.3915468752,
0.7488692999,
-0.5761922002,
0.5160562992,
-0.0254313331,
-0.148500517,
-0.1520656049,
-0.1701219976,
0.4950853884,
0.3538397551,
-0.2331906408,
-0.243565917,
0.1576739848,
-0.4189090729,
-0.5624120235,
0.8610967398,
-1.2720240355,
-0.5814453363,
-0.5295408964,
-0.4033881128,
-0.2871448398,
0.165371865,
0.1053634882,
0.2367372513,
-0.0025787982,
-0.129379198,
0.7495461106,
-0.0100626806,
0.2178935856,
0.3956984878,
-0.4704744816,
-0.712430656,
1.1192463636,
0.0071975202,
0.3295031786,
0.9462343454,
0.6314974427,
-0.7359032631,
-0.4770124853,
-0.6686958075,
0.4608440399,
-0.3998567462,
0.072169207,
-0.159356758,
-0.0148434462,
-0.4162748456,
-0.0957174972,
-0.4036659002,
-0.5850620866,
-0.2093618512,
0.1467631906,
0.1527054161,
0.4867359102,
0.1440092772,
-0.0704268217,
-0.4134140611,
0.2627230585,
0.4151089787,
0.3383478224,
-0.0750879347,
-0.3333015144,
0.0693015084,
-0.1472871602,
-0.0487821884,
-0.955958724,
0.0412517637,
0.158650741,
0.6719162464,
0.4520221949,
0.1983290017,
0.6849802136,
-0.3097625673,
0.3771921694,
0.0916129798,
-0.6805990934,
0.8235985041,
-0.1992124319,
0.0447425582,
0.7168392539,
0.6219036579,
-0.4502647519,
-0.1035434008,
-0.3912400603,
-0.6339097619,
0.6253747344,
-0.1807232797,
-0.3497777879,
0.1663003564,
0.7482222915,
0.2559857666,
0.2678504586,
-0.5733241439,
-0.3314666152,
-0.4220012426,
-0.0642437711,
-0.1893577874,
-0.1230837479,
-0.4238827825,
-0.0837014988,
0.7415826321,
-0.3838323951,
-0.0009139693,
0.1261704117,
-0.1200079173,
0.056736514,
0.3618767858,
0.9933342338,
0.6117534041,
-0.4498097301,
-0.0710058063,
-0.2389051765,
-0.1350293905,
0.0597000346,
0.0958591253,
-0.1727701128,
-0.6179329753,
-0.1210632697,
0.7018442154,
0.3074072301,
-0.8245396614,
0.3624579012,
0.0144167608,
-0.0861785114,
-0.2057675868,
0.1714254171,
-0.1569174975,
-0.1323177963,
0.2216434777,
-0.1760704517,
0.2080270946,
-0.6350060701,
0.1139006615,
0.718098104,
-0.7003291249,
0.1107751802,
0.565412581,
0.2441280037,
-0.4833176136,
0.5647801757,
-0.0701212212,
-0.4952310324,
0.5870803595,
0.4146310091,
0.4184746146,
-0.1491314173,
0.3554469347,
0.5099238753,
0.1488713771,
-0.1820140928,
0.1982385367,
-0.3783931732,
-0.9513527751,
-0.109332718,
-0.4230210781,
-0.5567228198,
0.1214722022,
-0.8650811315,
0.1957054436,
-0.6552762389,
-0.059464559,
-0.0655882061,
0.2743193507,
-0.2900462747,
-0.1367569268,
-0.0689012632,
0.3135834336,
-0.4880526066,
0.8548027277,
0.872338891,
-0.4672451019,
-0.7653815746,
-0.0834020451,
0.0686576292,
-1.2378649712,
0.6566290855,
0.124296084,
-0.3802494705,
0.2717650831,
-0.0224165525,
-0.9907166362,
0.9499246478,
0.1892218441,
-0.6142445803,
0.036228545,
0.0485107526,
0.3292270601,
-0.4567158222,
0.4182392359,
0.4268879294,
0.5210754871,
-0.0442581922,
-0.9501556158,
-0.0067665484,
0.1321628392,
0.05716414,
0.5421850681,
-0.8839636445,
0.2007517964,
-0.3829955459,
0.1290941834,
0.220076412,
0.3795531392,
0.564961195,
-0.0730784684,
0.7832660079,
0.5765429735,
0.8485788107,
0.1093414649,
1.0997741222,
-0.4256111979,
0.2799259722,
0.9748290181,
-0.5985191464,
0.890386045,
0.6089400649,
-0.1139289588,
0.3587144911,
0.904869318,
0.1085888818,
0.7334920168,
0.4536719024,
0.0508519597,
-0.2885627151,
-0.3787839115,
-0.269828707,
0.3172000647,
0.1330976933,
0.0640969947,
0.0933907405,
-0.1068388298,
-0.2991468906,
0.3163314164,
-0.2967935205,
1.0561351776,
-0.175201565,
-1.2063082457,
0.8041450381,
-0.2857091129,
0.5598059297,
-0.4942522347,
-0.0641322657,
0.0191045851,
0.1210185438,
-0.0997644588,
-0.6750783324,
-0.1343942583,
-0.4472842216,
-0.4500096738,
-0.5879244208,
0.5388082862,
-0.4607490897,
-0.1815131009,
0.2842726707,
0.3241553903,
0.2630492747,
0.3168770671,
-0.9529526234,
-0.0921395272,
-0.0575031564,
0.1530203968,
0.6798382401,
-0.4288325906,
-0.2063266337,
0.87226969,
0.5851355195,
0.1248224229,
-0.3690399528,
0.3263486624,
0.3187211156,
-0.3681603968,
-0.6957178712,
-0.4620054364,
0.1219852939,
-0.1465254575,
-0.3582184911,
0.1660945415,
0.7711573243,
0.6897923946,
0.0987130627,
0.5291629434,
0.4269436896,
0.6740230918,
-0.5891333222,
0.4973473847,
-0.7997684479,
0.4232258201,
0.0423340835,
-0.9844227433,
0.0615738779,
0.6333858371,
-0.2116083503,
0.0344427451,
0.7092978954,
0.6942742467,
0.3310975134,
-0.2829959989,
0.1370380223,
-0.146697253,
0.1350164413,
0.5256674886,
0.789829433,
-0.1382321864,
0.6548656225,
-0.2919635177,
-0.342661202,
-0.2890535295,
-0.9687353969,
-0.6868700385,
-0.5493440628,
-0.2297763228,
-0.2762026787,
0.3779138625,
0.9697297215,
0.8249030709,
-0.6558940411,
-0.6642511487,
-0.0139458003,
0.682821095,
-0.6968607903,
-0.1985967457,
0.4071736634,
-0.230209589,
-0.9057929516,
0.3971782923,
0.3797976077,
0.003823898,
-0.2088077962,
-0.4246225953,
-0.1796951294,
-0.1906628907,
0.3871694803,
0.5319876075,
-1.1865700483,
-0.5157925487,
0.2060006559,
-0.1596256793,
0.1272899806,
0.9881640077,
-0.7168425918,
0.2656061947,
0.4898701012,
0.8603054881,
0.6059951186,
0.1460620314,
0.564756155,
-0.5429645181,
-0.1768912822,
0.3038354218,
0.1171217859,
0.0602914058,
-0.473626256,
0.4213284552,
-0.0178543497,
-0.8232949972,
-0.8218644857,
0.4637404084,
-1.5190842152,
-0.3593770862,
0.8957534432,
0.4327588081,
0.1066873595,
0.2063894123,
-0.1799082756,
0.101542145,
-0.8559749722,
0.8676946759,
0.6213206649,
-0.5138683319,
-0.2771558762,
-0.4041832983,
0.8025734425,
0.7805393338,
-0.767457366,
-0.2235277146,
0.2967314422,
0.1798295528,
-0.0557092726,
0.5414106846,
0.213102743,
0.2096473426,
-0.8635568619,
-0.1089357287,
0.0483376607,
-0.3887734115,
-0.1129886284,
0.0443055257,
0.4552605748,
-0.1232177243
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01874v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01874v1
|
The RL/LLM Taxonomy Tree: Reviewing Synergies Between Reinforcement Learning and Large Language Models
| 2024-02-02T20:01:15 | 2024-02-02T20:01:15 |
Moschoula Pternea, Prerna Singh, Abir Chakraborty, Yagna Oruganti, Mirco Milletari, Sayli Bapat, Kebei Jiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.RO
|
In this work, we review research studies that combine Reinforcement Learning
(RL) and Large Language Models (LLMs), two areas that owe their momentum to the
development of deep neural networks. We propose a novel taxonomy of three main
classes based on the way that the two model types interact with each other. The
first class, RL4LLM, includes studies where RL is leveraged to improve the
performance of LLMs on tasks related to Natural Language Processing. L4LLM is
divided into two sub-categories depending on whether RL is used to directly
fine-tune an existing LLM or to improve the prompt of the LLM. In the second
class, LLM4RL, an LLM assists the training of an RL model that performs a task
that is not inherently related to natural language. We further break down
LLM4RL based on the component of the RL training framework that the LLM assists
or replaces, namely reward shaping, goal generation, and policy function.
Finally, in the third class, RL+LLM, an LLM and an RL agent are embedded in a
common planning framework without either of them contributing to training or
fine-tuning of the other. We further branch this class to distinguish between
studies with and without natural language feedback. We use this taxonomy to
explore the motivations behind the synergy of LLMs and RL and explain the
reasons for its success, while pinpointing potential shortcomings and areas
where further research is needed, as well as alternative methodologies that
serve the same goal.
|
[
-0.36412099,
-0.6909405589,
0.4899455905,
0.1021520495,
0.0788467973,
0.6053979993,
-0.4025649428,
-0.6692328453,
0.2012605965,
0.4890769422,
-0.594247818,
-0.2056014091,
-0.5900749564,
0.1578943878,
-0.1925149858,
1.1532794237,
-0.0051839389,
0.222488746,
-0.2935973108,
-0.2665986121,
-0.495307833,
-0.6218115091,
-0.958321631,
-0.9775447845,
1.2598152161,
0.0739429519,
0.8353869915,
0.4545432925,
0.4539822638,
0.2777754962,
-0.266515851,
0.0957422629,
-0.3385877609,
0.1985409409,
-0.4163160324,
-0.3719340563,
-0.3323870897,
0.0165436864,
0.612007618,
0.6284749508,
-0.1636125892,
-0.0485096425,
0.1221178845,
0.6864932179,
-0.5638658404,
0.216710344,
-0.2537250221,
0.2688676417,
-0.007195767,
-0.1889039874,
-0.2598573267,
-0.2454136163,
0.0842661411,
-0.3714546859,
-0.3344805837,
-0.0074361954,
0.5358388424,
0.2599253058,
-0.6306781173,
-0.4054404795,
-0.7977210283,
0.8057813048,
-0.8253602982,
0.2913618088,
-0.0077114739,
0.1681443304,
-0.1621405482,
-0.7269108295,
-0.5663303733,
-0.3216020465,
-0.2171496451,
0.2002192736,
-0.0725732669,
0.4157937467,
0.095007211,
0.4473531246,
-0.3771919608,
0.6680987477,
-0.2087060809,
-0.1930963844,
0.6635761857,
0.371386081,
0.1471912563,
0.0524301529,
-0.4863623679,
-0.1405299753,
-0.8422076702,
0.1975212544,
0.4276477695,
0.4342635274,
0.0937955007,
0.4566062093,
0.0288438201,
0.6164833903,
-0.3427405953,
-0.4390058517,
0.1064553186,
-0.4777472913,
-0.0994637907,
0.0149410218,
1.0030214787,
0.1792132258,
0.3344383836,
-0.2293486595,
-0.6236934066,
0.1015933976,
0.1722182333,
-0.4394282699,
-0.023197718,
-0.0975401476,
-0.5190348029,
-0.3912320435,
-0.1719402373,
-0.4340870678,
-0.313450098,
-0.5299193263,
0.3710193038,
-0.1781567782,
-0.5999657512,
0.0767506734,
0.0381405167,
0.4021061659,
0.1578499973,
-1.0374019146,
0.5792691708,
1.1240528822,
0.513156414,
-0.358959049,
-0.6267030239,
-0.3873693049,
-0.0584161878,
-0.3444312811,
0.6530814171,
-0.557787478,
-0.2644760609,
0.4477153122,
-0.0856573358,
-0.1432599425,
-0.5332177281,
0.3294804096,
-0.7464939952,
0.4228194356,
-0.0132481186,
-0.6223396659,
-0.4523944557,
0.5424484015,
-0.7426021099,
0.8689808846,
-0.1079381928,
-0.6494152546,
0.427462399,
-0.5318455696,
-0.6038662195,
0.2113700807,
-0.3610050976,
-0.2809835672,
-0.2797162831,
-0.2386726439,
0.5068106055,
-0.282107681,
0.5710191727,
-0.2761993408,
-0.1123458222,
0.3021048307,
-0.185861066,
0.3955766261,
0.064646244,
-0.1276884675,
0.5879765153,
-0.3854513168,
0.0613069236,
0.0492389835,
-0.6647074223,
-0.1736365408,
0.1708378941,
-0.0566953607,
0.3738764226,
0.3702389598,
-0.187471658,
0.2914270759,
-0.5036489367,
0.6033298373,
0.6307626367,
-0.0362166576,
0.5140421391,
-0.3815314472,
0.6640557051,
-0.1560070217,
0.1395367384,
-0.0199026745,
-0.1772339791,
-0.7548929453,
0.1283462793,
0.4024091065,
0.4739992619,
-0.8742573261,
0.1207826063,
-0.0688370168,
-0.2680979669,
-0.3874821365,
0.1681825966,
0.597931087,
0.0237553678,
0.3062624931,
-0.3656252623,
-0.572660625,
-0.8511618376,
-0.4006891549,
-0.2197845429,
0.5142043829,
0.2821247876,
0.6124144793,
-0.0552517883,
0.7580495477,
0.0720998943,
-0.3371011019,
-0.7582392097,
0.0013202576,
0.2373942584,
0.2703951299,
0.2813665867,
-0.6346910596,
-0.2588842213,
-0.0262311827,
-0.5357406139,
0.3714989126,
-0.034785945,
0.4277261496,
0.2808377147,
0.552923739,
-0.5453560948,
0.1047073826,
0.4966831803,
-0.289730072,
0.5700109005,
-0.2463676184,
-0.3347106874,
-0.8466186523,
-0.1550637037,
-0.0982283205,
-0.1041092947,
-0.7953799963,
0.1852115095,
-0.1793369651,
0.2982529998,
-0.5015150309,
0.7178214788,
-0.3717317581,
-0.3608872592,
-0.3519738317,
0.1199813187,
-0.2199120522,
0.6056304574,
0.170539543,
0.5533888936,
0.4054600298,
-0.691618681,
0.6274665594,
-0.0497420914,
-0.0262514558,
0.0776388198,
-0.5087082386,
-0.1574659646,
0.1287923306,
0.3686931729,
-0.4688479304,
-0.0387105048,
0.3946633637,
-0.3469930291,
0.3301026225,
0.1646982133,
-0.7527550459,
-0.4374092519,
-0.3336522877,
0.3592337966,
0.4130344093,
-0.5155856013,
0.5917503834,
0.3137955368,
-0.0091629028,
-0.6455328465,
-0.5934156775,
0.0651811957,
-0.3845251203,
-0.2574473023,
0.4320991635,
0.1378333867,
-0.3983883262,
0.2197222114,
0.0374932326,
0.1804713905,
0.2003495991,
0.0588829592,
0.1924124509,
-0.268889755,
0.3571223617,
-0.586560607,
-0.1073528156,
0.266567409,
-0.2745860517,
0.5112692714,
-0.1849370003,
-0.1074504629,
-0.1026269943,
-0.0888121873,
0.255561471,
-0.3590258956,
0.7374690175,
0.6275437474,
0.0770141631,
-0.324470669,
-0.3773070276,
-0.400962919,
-0.4009198248,
0.2212305814,
-0.2979270518,
-1.3809629679,
0.2306024432,
-0.1448097527,
0.2128929645,
0.389898628,
0.6852869987,
0.1210911572,
0.8234648108,
0.8728111982,
-0.2052597106,
0.5482616425,
-0.2492039353,
0.3359052241,
-0.8962671757,
-0.4422299564,
-0.2592059374,
-0.3691905439,
-0.7128558159,
-0.252214551,
-0.0960934386,
-0.0216712505,
-0.2492742687,
0.2041811943,
-0.2144090086,
0.3673541546,
0.5777577758,
-0.3580850959,
0.3953049481,
-0.3821112216,
-0.1436103284,
0.176908657,
-1.0487427711,
-0.4598230124,
0.9223110676,
0.6243630648,
0.8308708668,
0.2407093048,
0.8628134131,
0.212591514,
0.2510394752,
-1.1140582561,
0.6819549799,
0.06004503,
-0.3540644944,
-0.286433816,
-0.3241821229,
-1.2096043825,
0.4834592938,
-0.3294790387,
-0.4364211261,
-0.2576718628,
0.0251347367,
-0.4010848105,
0.5386455059,
-0.3381103575,
0.9183550477,
-0.5854120851,
-0.577286303,
-0.5268841982,
-0.6603595614,
0.6836583018,
0.2464410961,
0.3443517685,
-0.0465129837,
-0.201330319,
0.8627425432,
-0.1311515421,
0.8682360649,
0.1362524629,
-0.3625198007,
0.1310310066,
0.1175913736,
0.4976471961,
-0.1156535894,
0.3141301274,
-0.2360488176,
-0.0076062386,
-0.1413098127,
-0.561863482,
0.748642683,
-0.7415780425,
-0.5870314837,
-0.7545950413,
-0.5758931637,
-0.4144234657,
0.1827941388,
-0.3030495048,
0.3020588458,
-0.1577271372,
0.0715427175,
0.6966637969,
-0.2584852576,
0.5467202663,
0.6432796717,
-0.5928131938,
-0.3506758809,
1.0099151134,
-0.1616698354,
0.4577050507,
0.4710659683,
0.184714362,
-0.4619197249,
-0.6831275225,
0.2360844314,
0.365046978,
-0.7595437169,
-0.0408003181,
-0.5269815326,
-0.5942409039,
-0.3015393913,
0.0657634065,
-0.1691213697,
-0.2236134261,
-0.2729176581,
-0.1312946826,
0.364387542,
1.2066019773,
-0.1479222476,
0.1851303577,
-0.4871727526,
-0.0309083201,
0.3686049283,
0.3012812138,
0.3350008428,
-0.3094067574,
-0.2407403439,
-0.2564966977,
-0.2125737369,
-0.5528489947,
0.3994597793,
-0.006950858,
0.7277382612,
0.1695226878,
-0.2620191574,
0.2526623905,
-0.4096006453,
0.8057610989,
0.5721774101,
-0.4855847657,
0.2041809112,
-0.2644850612,
0.0905414075,
0.2809951305,
0.3290934861,
-0.7562327385,
-0.3590808511,
-0.7495898008,
-0.9259152412,
0.7773910761,
-0.238971889,
-0.0242633317,
0.148878634,
-0.0372954421,
-0.0195534751,
0.2765746713,
-1.244864583,
-0.1480594575,
0.1029622555,
-0.0137171438,
-0.3613727391,
-0.3204129338,
-0.2690729797,
-0.1267642677,
0.7373105288,
-0.161831826,
-0.1875361651,
-0.0601096824,
-0.0913433731,
0.0255474951,
0.5606377721,
0.5468699932,
0.4134509265,
0.0115663707,
0.337790221,
0.1415578127,
-0.0034754178,
0.1455411762,
-0.2418513596,
0.0816489086,
-0.2709117532,
0.7722274065,
1.0286051035,
0.6912448406,
-0.7530741096,
0.319595933,
0.0463319011,
-0.5221431851,
-0.4078272283,
0.1835799962,
0.2861768007,
0.5791780353,
-0.006096622,
-0.1663751304,
-0.0993251577,
-0.8528333902,
0.1157529131,
0.5801637769,
-0.3621854484,
-0.1849730611,
0.2099383175,
0.3261012733,
-0.484334439,
0.2588112652,
-0.3278225362,
-0.7811028957,
0.5481586456,
0.4654244781,
0.7856596708,
0.1544347256,
0.3210714459,
0.2839903831,
0.3106993437,
-0.1100074127,
0.1122080088,
-0.0501781031,
-0.8201469779,
-0.7679351568,
-0.6593928933,
-0.4101895988,
0.4273534119,
-0.4849767387,
-0.0090524256,
-0.461514473,
0.0627860203,
-0.0139921149,
0.2159075588,
-0.5344284177,
-0.1733265817,
0.2775420845,
0.9416791201,
-0.5699704289,
0.9022396207,
0.8323355913,
-0.5482208133,
-1.0874935389,
0.025496833,
0.0260940716,
-0.7837190628,
1.1636002064,
-0.0984899178,
-0.0717697516,
0.1224415302,
-0.0799165368,
-0.8763628602,
1.2238230705,
-0.3961848617,
-0.6806300282,
-0.3163575232,
0.0154601,
0.692527771,
-0.5423032641,
0.2308864146,
0.7701188326,
0.5577795506,
0.1919937432,
-1.0458935499,
-0.0513747483,
0.2108878195,
0.1833501309,
0.4341077507,
-0.7001245618,
0.748871088,
-0.2715773284,
-0.2713941932,
0.231716454,
0.611159265,
0.3010277152,
0.1907377541,
0.3923426569,
0.6820067763,
0.3876804113,
-0.1037948951,
0.975987494,
-0.2473284155,
0.374833107,
1.1062412262,
-0.5233008862,
0.784445703,
0.7263188362,
-0.3691610396,
0.4291747212,
0.8697125316,
-0.077624321,
0.5212065578,
0.5977684259,
-0.2817288637,
-0.2170270979,
-0.2006489486,
-0.3527523279,
0.1525147408,
0.449491173,
-0.2222949564,
-0.486787647,
0.1745563298,
-0.0012654704,
0.2012739927,
-0.5185200572,
1.0493663549,
0.2718341649,
-1.0230433941,
0.2938196957,
-0.0473357886,
0.9300869107,
-0.6494243741,
0.1263003796,
-0.1914373487,
0.2988181114,
-0.3085777462,
-1.1047884226,
0.1743872017,
-0.2543988824,
0.0210000314,
-0.4960350096,
0.8279390931,
-0.6662425995,
-0.0302049238,
0.780887723,
0.7057054639,
0.0231766477,
0.6126746535,
-1.0574163198,
0.1536335051,
-0.2202703208,
-0.2510692775,
0.5535993576,
0.3510470092,
0.1400559098,
0.8659180403,
0.6659770012,
0.3744596541,
-0.0126248738,
0.3158179224,
0.8480885029,
-0.8476897478,
-0.2388910204,
-0.8851495385,
0.1499269307,
0.2496426255,
-0.1798776984,
0.7678244114,
0.40478912,
0.8910032511,
0.1139910892,
0.5812515616,
-0.1211974844,
0.4044679105,
-0.8112713695,
0.2086538821,
-0.6177717447,
0.2984413207,
0.1418969482,
-0.7576505542,
-0.2267314643,
0.2566105425,
-0.4389880896,
0.1271341592,
0.8652448058,
0.6657278538,
0.139603287,
-0.1738374084,
0.2984362543,
0.0929488987,
0.3400725126,
0.6861901879,
1.3433277607,
0.0757500604,
0.4648903012,
-0.0547969937,
0.2180025429,
-0.2984006405,
-0.7142450213,
-0.949694097,
-0.3865926266,
-0.2565896809,
-0.3983452618,
0.1937304288,
0.8463660479,
0.5126163363,
-0.5501422882,
-0.5402253866,
-0.3690367639,
0.5240134597,
-0.1421214491,
-0.3051606715,
-0.0525949858,
-0.7737118602,
-0.345814079,
0.4654628038,
0.3112459183,
-0.0645566136,
-0.8149992228,
-0.6648767591,
-0.4012426138,
-0.2422892451,
0.6751360297,
0.6562863588,
-1.2206121683,
0.0266483314,
-0.2737161517,
-0.149681747,
-0.2477668375,
1.076102972,
-0.9282187819,
0.1039719954,
0.3482542932,
0.6916623116,
0.2978960872,
-0.4841817617,
0.4690734744,
-0.5815700889,
0.0459556244,
0.5775485635,
0.2116729319,
0.1381249875,
0.0315127,
0.5681610703,
0.1372930855,
-0.6814774275,
-0.8086448908,
0.6647640467,
-0.725605607,
-0.4630723,
1.2269974947,
0.1447416246,
-0.1599303186,
0.0823701248,
-0.0455183908,
0.0609462447,
-0.3288711905,
0.3675974905,
0.7713692188,
-0.2933032215,
-0.4643320441,
-0.6920631528,
0.8277246952,
0.4101495147,
-0.6976344585,
-0.109957099,
0.2361073643,
0.1495868266,
0.1866345406,
0.4549739063,
0.0995447263,
0.1450438052,
-0.3978030086,
0.2723447084,
-0.0010630678,
-0.3682715893,
-0.5485746264,
-0.0067237266,
0.5438994169,
0.2734259665
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01869v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01869v2
|
InferCept: Efficient Intercept Support for Augmented Large Language Model Inference
| 2024-02-02T19:47:57 | 2024-05-30T04:18:03 |
Reyna Abhyankar, Zijian He, Vikranth Srivatsa, Hao Zhang, Yiying Zhang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.DC
|
Large language models are increasingly integrated with external environments,
tools, and agents like ChatGPT plugins to extend their capability beyond
language-centric tasks. However, today's LLM inference systems are designed for
standalone LLMs. They treat each external interaction as the end of LLM
generation and form a new request when the interaction finishes, causing
unnecessary recomputation of already computed contexts, which accounts for
37-40% of total model forwarding time. This paper presents InferCept, the first
LLM inference framework targeting augmented LLMs and supporting the efficient
interception of LLM generation. InferCept minimizes the GPU resource waste
caused by LLM interceptions and dedicates saved memory for serving more
requests. InferCept improves the overall serving throughput by 1.6x-2x and
completes 2x more requests per second compared to the state-of-the-art LLM
inference systems.
|
[
-0.5854821205,
-0.8916966915,
0.5910227299,
0.2375894189,
-0.0532292873,
0.2334776968,
-0.1518726647,
-0.6488081813,
0.094157204,
0.6494051814,
-0.5313238502,
-0.1074486524,
-0.4662344158,
-0.1628346741,
-0.5216836333,
0.502900362,
0.3478979766,
0.2680694461,
-0.5505419374,
0.2487028539,
0.0443094969,
-0.6442601681,
-1.0233514309,
-0.573456347,
0.1793383807,
0.6445840597,
0.6097088456,
0.2758212388,
0.3653101623,
0.2862097025,
-0.1457663625,
0.5929954052,
-0.4381483793,
0.2537572086,
-0.0667176843,
-0.0990892425,
-0.6379348636,
-0.3341358602,
0.7998260856,
0.7569492459,
-0.1267344207,
0.0965670347,
0.4582143724,
0.3951916397,
-0.8200116158,
-0.0883459225,
-0.5932611823,
-0.104264006,
-0.3396859169,
-0.0631965399,
-0.7106154561,
0.0339901894,
-0.1058386639,
-0.4985254407,
0.1204055324,
-0.0393614918,
0.5477167964,
0.2078884244,
-0.3297042847,
0.0739744082,
-0.4078398645,
0.5530988574,
-0.9138640165,
0.72366184,
0.3896997571,
0.1359431595,
-0.9640427232,
-0.9341601133,
-0.5975590944,
-0.3108873069,
0.0020492207,
0.0316241719,
-0.4058134854,
0.347451061,
0.3085984588,
0.2497836798,
-0.3365640342,
0.2796707153,
0.1521781981,
-0.2867138684,
0.3991341889,
0.0570546985,
0.2268635333,
-0.0003738577,
-0.5051383376,
0.4652767777,
-1.1338319778,
-0.1811893731,
0.4053943157,
0.2595474422,
0.1772034317,
0.5134520531,
-0.3332438469,
0.7935430408,
0.1683164388,
-0.0768752322,
-0.1631412804,
-0.0300885644,
-0.5696083903,
0.1019789651,
0.5781691074,
0.0098047461,
-0.0638896972,
-0.104546003,
-0.1008166894,
-0.1870023906,
-0.088623099,
-1.1072398424,
-0.1061131582,
0.191568315,
-0.239541173,
0.0707895532,
-0.2346724719,
-0.843355,
-0.438472569,
-0.1309190542,
0.0924399123,
-0.6091098785,
-0.4269255102,
0.1393603683,
0.0449788049,
0.4307847917,
0.3277017772,
-0.9852156639,
0.9999250174,
1.1424040794,
0.9478464127,
-0.3921550214,
-0.1720594019,
-1.1249998808,
0.077574037,
-0.0878701657,
1.0257674456,
-0.3933489025,
-0.3188171983,
-0.0382120647,
-0.0227750391,
-0.0659647435,
-0.4319570661,
0.5426322222,
-0.809412837,
-0.0573327839,
-0.0932950899,
-1.2870110273,
-0.4686329663,
0.3976326287,
-0.5433943868,
0.8885723352,
-0.0506354012,
-0.6017865539,
0.449219048,
-0.6708108783,
-0.4822128415,
0.5825834274,
0.0390115194,
-0.0995800421,
0.1634757817,
0.4759799242,
0.3749352098,
-0.2632716596,
-0.1430653185,
-0.6376932263,
-0.44736889,
0.0591367669,
-0.5927473903,
0.6877423525,
0.2542751133,
0.0038757666,
-0.0062574726,
-0.6806994081,
0.1688438505,
0.0052875257,
-0.3645944595,
-0.3785380125,
0.3623483777,
0.1424049437,
-0.2053642869,
0.1897085309,
-0.8164471388,
0.1060832366,
-0.4704113901,
0.4145988524,
0.6097185612,
0.0321850702,
0.5458974838,
0.1906634569,
0.5052921176,
-0.3735527992,
-0.0534978695,
0.0649386495,
-0.5152029395,
-0.558999598,
-0.9034829736,
-0.0527584702,
0.3972291648,
-0.8192590475,
-0.1908906847,
-0.306303978,
-0.3441371322,
-0.1431049556,
0.2184070796,
0.425078243,
0.4463038743,
0.0617597774,
0.147666499,
-0.5893365145,
-0.7124713659,
-0.4019396603,
-0.0724332556,
-0.0325477347,
-0.0094287898,
0.4058166742,
-0.0237858593,
0.7634391189,
-0.2660301626,
0.1694738269,
-0.6107801199,
-0.4932816923,
0.5137932301,
0.4587432444,
0.5211213231,
-0.5965940356,
-0.5300437808,
0.013427916,
-0.6603221893,
-0.1124181077,
0.2201351821,
-0.4871633649,
0.2183843702,
0.7594839931,
-0.7963061333,
0.0845216885,
0.7649173141,
-0.5435575247,
0.2956813276,
-0.1530162096,
0.0877531171,
-0.6932736039,
-0.2410691231,
-0.2457023561,
-0.5641697049,
-0.8603659868,
0.198763907,
0.2127307355,
0.0722882524,
-0.5842459202,
0.8544406295,
-0.5343644023,
-0.0131892124,
-0.3118983805,
0.1034476385,
0.0224352162,
0.1761871874,
0.0490248613,
0.9860965014,
0.3383595049,
-0.7283417583,
0.3473454118,
0.3090930581,
-0.247791186,
0.6498360038,
-0.4424450994,
0.3735652566,
0.0659219623,
0.0777223185,
-0.9956567883,
-0.403752774,
0.3720087707,
-0.4982861876,
0.3443208039,
-0.6772757173,
-0.5853379369,
-0.1433206648,
-0.2494623661,
0.3237812817,
0.3330000341,
-1.1085259914,
0.8602324724,
0.3607875109,
0.0252172444,
-0.607465744,
-0.7422991991,
0.2902910709,
-0.204951033,
-0.6951381564,
0.1340110898,
-0.1074239314,
-0.4705260992,
-0.0409442931,
0.1932151169,
-0.1902193427,
-0.0828305036,
0.293738842,
0.2834521234,
-0.2239233702,
0.0714562759,
0.1311396807,
-0.1222137883,
0.0613297075,
-0.4437761307,
0.7309445739,
0.2405284345,
-0.7307822108,
-0.2731021941,
0.4375769496,
0.6490646005,
0.0442218967,
0.7288606763,
0.0487629883,
-0.4101248085,
-0.1951056868,
-0.7394320965,
-0.1143036932,
-0.4735119045,
0.6386319399,
-0.5881661177,
-0.6162014008,
0.3957686126,
0.0241680127,
0.2805597484,
0.3155523837,
0.4768025577,
0.1524971575,
1.0896576643,
0.4511989355,
-0.3235598505,
0.768678844,
-0.1214242205,
-0.1296193898,
-0.9895628691,
0.0569883101,
-0.0806993917,
0.1541877389,
-0.2948540151,
-0.2174530774,
0.2244903594,
-0.0417228751,
-0.4071845412,
0.0999633446,
-0.2808840573,
0.4800543189,
0.5916702747,
0.3575169742,
0.506883502,
0.2764774561,
0.0631075203,
-0.0526079796,
-0.8134515882,
-0.1806589663,
1.0013898611,
0.2963104844,
0.7188079953,
0.1591799855,
0.3650616407,
0.3388514817,
0.4958870411,
-0.775485456,
0.7854366899,
-0.0722677708,
-0.6963558793,
-0.1155409589,
-0.2305071503,
-0.5605210066,
0.5540241003,
-0.1241214052,
-0.8070291281,
-0.0089690685,
0.4324680865,
-0.1906020641,
0.6685055494,
-0.6505117416,
0.5250906944,
-0.0676106662,
-0.8383627534,
-0.4103238881,
-0.135843873,
0.5769768953,
0.2593490183,
-0.0933503285,
-0.1708600372,
-0.0910292938,
0.3408684731,
-0.6173503995,
0.7059198618,
-0.3766770661,
0.1600414068,
0.3977707922,
0.3156007826,
0.8884481192,
0.1406030506,
-0.3278110325,
0.1635622978,
-0.0915161967,
-0.357060492,
-0.3667317629,
0.7895904183,
-0.2668920457,
-0.4368359447,
-0.3430625796,
-0.5453762412,
-0.0968141928,
0.0780395493,
0.3898416162,
0.490295887,
-0.1992478967,
-0.1378392726,
0.7762389183,
-0.229911983,
0.5496370792,
0.5864580274,
-0.3996865749,
-0.5321025848,
0.6936215758,
-0.0598207116,
0.6896424294,
0.3782354295,
-0.108184427,
-0.3532641232,
-0.744713366,
-0.6525852084,
0.1868322939,
-0.8364446163,
-0.3856064081,
-0.613707602,
-0.4382184446,
-0.1741850823,
-0.012513753,
-0.4769357443,
-0.1661338508,
0.0196721554,
-0.1095168442,
0.7129803896,
0.5144274235,
-0.1337564737,
0.6000880003,
-0.6225553155,
-0.0330433995,
0.0828570798,
0.3173725903,
-0.0093327276,
-0.6822846532,
-0.1138952896,
-0.1822401285,
-0.0302452054,
-0.5657294989,
0.4250453413,
0.3576157987,
0.6617237329,
0.6132739186,
-0.1631768197,
0.8419455886,
-0.3263400197,
0.6437697411,
-0.1679855287,
-0.9073364735,
0.0913612768,
-0.1243888363,
0.3859415948,
0.2726475894,
-0.0172687881,
-0.389716059,
-0.3663865626,
-0.2287399918,
-0.8025229573,
0.4120741785,
0.0994543806,
0.0631580725,
-0.1300895065,
0.4496250749,
0.224167034,
0.0945515186,
-0.3907186985,
-0.0367002264,
0.2429568022,
-0.0049502524,
-0.0446963869,
-0.6412396431,
0.203546986,
-0.4118844569,
0.7703384757,
-0.1780173331,
0.3125811815,
0.1648219526,
-0.3926822841,
0.1559135318,
0.0159277022,
0.4743047953,
0.5543178916,
-0.1056917831,
0.3326315284,
0.7335991263,
-0.6512645483,
0.0030583318,
0.3262730539,
-0.3134465516,
-0.0186364371,
0.5797268152,
0.451926738,
0.333478272,
-0.6602971554,
0.3089696169,
-0.0813763663,
-0.0839753598,
-0.6954098344,
-0.0299497042,
-0.0086416723,
0.5001141429,
0.1694644988,
-0.173936829,
0.4168553352,
-0.0739812329,
0.1605785638,
0.8562756777,
-0.3586145043,
-0.0664095059,
0.7026363015,
-0.0156022068,
-0.0734091923,
0.7421398163,
-0.2067284435,
-0.5011093616,
0.2500357628,
0.6998217106,
0.9175525904,
-0.1378544718,
-0.1441900879,
0.3564817905,
-0.0301112849,
-0.1034293473,
0.3096770942,
-0.1836752445,
-0.8715962768,
-0.8734759092,
-0.5966824889,
-0.4745076001,
0.0334886387,
-0.2552959323,
0.1583751589,
-0.3034906387,
0.013902382,
-0.2571583688,
-0.1937447339,
-0.4054991007,
-0.1824046075,
0.4015334547,
1.2348897457,
-0.3693625331,
0.9818576574,
0.7227606773,
-0.1697739959,
-0.396738112,
-0.4229640067,
0.1164649278,
-0.9626215696,
0.6030148864,
-0.1290523708,
-0.5703894496,
0.2130348086,
-0.8099524975,
-0.9258443713,
0.6616969705,
0.7846542001,
-0.3645284772,
0.2785415947,
0.0513172932,
0.0029330652,
-0.3167673647,
0.4492517114,
0.8023198843,
0.4560501575,
0.241137132,
-0.5035372376,
0.1154331192,
-0.2514741719,
-0.1650206894,
0.32858181,
-0.2686497867,
0.6627761722,
-0.1076543704,
-0.191779688,
0.3269746006,
0.7906118035,
0.3201465309,
0.1901062578,
0.5836518407,
0.4455667436,
0.5315847397,
-0.0400243737,
1.182510972,
-0.2192335427,
0.0486163311,
1.2400183678,
-0.0009720025,
0.9550637603,
0.8045523763,
-0.1188137531,
0.0939926058,
0.6857013702,
0.1558184326,
0.4591054916,
0.0524134971,
-0.824175477,
-0.3811427653,
-0.120331578,
-0.0887306705,
0.3078040481,
0.5785943866,
-0.0377499498,
-0.2757028043,
0.1311631352,
0.4343506992,
-0.0297565255,
-0.4636627436,
0.6725813746,
0.0765565261,
-0.666872859,
0.3138924241,
-0.4540354908,
0.6288890839,
-0.8067632914,
-0.2633724809,
-0.3859545588,
0.6921344995,
-0.3848930299,
-0.6828250885,
-0.0597322695,
-0.2713254392,
-0.0625496805,
-0.0046352786,
0.8308938146,
-0.4314016998,
-0.4266487062,
0.6265309453,
0.4315328896,
0.196781382,
-0.5822749734,
-0.1658720374,
0.0879142135,
-0.1934880316,
-0.6165336967,
0.2956212163,
0.2225337029,
0.101856418,
0.8887283206,
0.6954160333,
0.2732303441,
0.2188052386,
0.0097726947,
0.8596434593,
-0.3756312728,
-0.2093060762,
-1.2309757471,
0.4905283749,
-0.2240970135,
0.0478217714,
0.9511409402,
0.685972929,
0.511287868,
0.1303786337,
0.6618708372,
-0.0987088457,
0.500123322,
-0.6497732997,
0.5739330649,
-0.511649251,
0.2526551485,
-0.2010553479,
-0.7174795866,
-0.366863519,
0.0531799868,
-0.240568772,
-0.2283862531,
0.3064866364,
0.8346384168,
-0.3282628953,
-0.1232530624,
0.4450627565,
0.031778682,
0.6770730615,
0.5254333615,
0.9167252779,
-0.1767944396,
0.353703618,
-0.2264942825,
-0.2935415804,
-0.2526823878,
-0.7937908769,
-0.7841418982,
-0.0795270279,
0.0373494625,
-0.3557951748,
0.0418044291,
1.0927580595,
0.7203038335,
-0.7418507934,
-0.4159711301,
-0.3449094594,
0.1590325832,
-0.4394601583,
-0.1882291883,
0.2923777699,
-0.4006442726,
-0.833296895,
0.6810470223,
0.2207948416,
-0.0950778499,
-0.1998323202,
-0.2242572904,
-0.253760308,
-0.0076317331,
0.8778600693,
0.4776692092,
-0.5983355045,
-0.3606806993,
-0.0501402207,
0.1805303991,
0.0480504632,
0.6425818801,
-0.7826738358,
0.4462435842,
0.5171608925,
0.6910572052,
0.8601044416,
-0.1521117538,
0.8074428439,
-0.3903102577,
0.6262113452,
-0.0226451866,
0.6661058664,
0.2719310522,
-0.5308645964,
0.4360490739,
0.1195518821,
-0.5984594822,
-0.8464752436,
0.285190165,
-0.5546923876,
-0.0089365067,
1.0075221062,
-0.1824919283,
-0.1400601864,
-0.0696661845,
-0.1626533568,
0.0786643326,
-0.5696278811,
0.0379013345,
0.4492860734,
-0.4959679246,
-0.4616964459,
-0.9255370498,
0.4564880729,
0.2195934206,
-0.753410399,
0.0716447756,
0.3985756934,
0.3765956461,
-0.3304318786,
0.6854839325,
0.1106961817,
0.044586774,
0.3149585128,
0.2023965716,
-0.1418501139,
-0.0184020977,
-0.1078772098,
0.0669222251,
0.2162500173,
-0.5664485693
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01867v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01867v1
|
Leveraging Large Language Models for Structure Learning in Prompted Weak Supervision
| 2024-02-02T19:45:39 | 2024-02-02T19:45:39 |
Jinyan Su, Peilin Yu, Jieyu Zhang, Stephen H. Bach
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Prompted weak supervision (PromptedWS) applies pre-trained large language
models (LLMs) as the basis for labeling functions (LFs) in a weak supervision
framework to obtain large labeled datasets. We further extend the use of LLMs
in the loop to address one of the key challenges in weak supervision: learning
the statistical dependency structure among supervision sources. In this work,
we ask the LLM how similar are these prompted LFs. We propose a Structure
Refining Module, a simple yet effective first approach based on the
similarities of the prompts by taking advantage of the intrinsic structure in
the embedding space. At the core of Structure Refining Module are Labeling
Function Removal (LaRe) and Correlation Structure Generation (CosGen). Compared
to previous methods that learn the dependencies from weak labels, our method
finds the dependencies which are intrinsic to the LFs and less dependent on the
data. We show that our Structure Refining Module improves the PromptedWS
pipeline by up to 12.7 points on the benchmark tasks. We also explore the
trade-offs between efficiency and performance with comprehensive ablation
experiments and analysis. Code for this project can be found in
https://github.com/BatsResearch/su-bigdata23-code.
|
[
-0.0466533415,
-0.8957952857,
0.5657429695,
0.0314715914,
-0.1335486174,
-0.1770277172,
-0.3891443908,
-0.4034815431,
0.2077256441,
0.6854982972,
-0.410651505,
-0.6492823958,
-0.4401896894,
0.1180037335,
-0.2233549356,
0.9677551985,
0.0254734699,
0.0715487525,
0.0237795319,
0.0057109371,
-0.314568162,
-0.3734727204,
-0.5092116594,
-0.4998266697,
1.0032912493,
0.5414724946,
0.508138597,
0.7926901579,
0.3508072793,
0.3550609648,
-0.4806990921,
0.053434547,
-0.679031074,
0.306735307,
-0.2112309039,
-0.4505190849,
-0.5501821041,
-0.4595123529,
0.6035376191,
1.1027834415,
-0.0832655206,
0.1214288026,
0.3726660609,
0.6064158678,
-0.6318597198,
0.4330981672,
-0.6658669114,
-0.2595795691,
-0.3136532605,
-0.0861340538,
-0.660214901,
0.0295312554,
0.2585008144,
-0.1357343346,
0.4044122398,
0.0671130866,
0.791721642,
0.315238297,
-0.603145957,
-0.3077845871,
-0.3938223124,
0.8102542162,
-0.4882578254,
0.3834012747,
0.6756343246,
-0.029394405,
-0.2783047557,
-0.7261705995,
0.1396221668,
-0.3411848843,
-0.189509064,
-0.1590545475,
0.0965610594,
0.2646553218,
0.5582205653,
0.3589624166,
-0.3615784645,
0.4194893837,
-0.6888288856,
-0.3396468461,
0.3618290722,
0.0427485853,
-0.0136806937,
-0.1387481391,
-0.351745218,
-0.1406358629,
-0.9869392514,
-0.0493280478,
0.3354716599,
0.9012073278,
-0.1659906656,
0.7422452569,
-0.2608283758,
0.5995372534,
-0.0013141091,
-0.105742842,
0.3836669922,
0.0809659585,
-0.2597201765,
0.2751162052,
0.5229680538,
-0.2137166858,
0.2008871287,
-0.0292807985,
-0.3132576048,
-0.1196901202,
0.4101920724,
-0.8186944127,
-0.5336828232,
0.1740507782,
-0.3654355705,
-0.0172747057,
0.0217187684,
-0.3656531274,
-0.2064903975,
-0.520591557,
0.3484749496,
-0.2982712686,
0.0538754575,
-0.1342670321,
-0.0658159778,
0.1970946789,
0.2619493306,
-1.0551267862,
0.0355002731,
0.5524027944,
0.8287051916,
0.0129352901,
-0.1328051984,
-1.080114603,
0.3539969325,
-0.3361403644,
0.6001535654,
-0.315497607,
-0.2358208895,
0.1250747591,
0.081021972,
0.3532364666,
-0.7546722889,
0.5333741307,
-0.5804353952,
-0.2617812753,
-0.3182066679,
-0.5249527097,
-0.0278742053,
0.1239664704,
-0.7723979354,
1.0245883465,
0.2968775034,
-0.6092598438,
0.4707038105,
-0.0191057231,
-0.6923059821,
0.2498582006,
-0.0765294209,
-0.7865563631,
0.1354581118,
0.1936946213,
0.7068331838,
-0.0147098554,
0.6125562191,
-0.8035892248,
-0.3605373502,
-0.1267839819,
-0.074229084,
0.7122004032,
0.0948584154,
-0.147994563,
0.5607457161,
-1.0612760782,
-0.1045098975,
-0.1863243729,
-0.5628507733,
-0.4907432199,
0.0831544623,
-0.2665125132,
-0.3222431242,
0.0062634931,
-0.0792286769,
0.2813625336,
-0.5860612392,
0.2218402177,
0.8007688522,
0.073249191,
0.5282431841,
0.1095851883,
0.1593032479,
-0.1047938541,
-0.0909965187,
-0.3453591466,
-0.0975637361,
-0.6326424479,
-0.6151595712,
0.0126003576,
0.2017420679,
-0.7510416508,
0.5836697817,
0.197119385,
-0.3308051229,
-0.108330667,
0.6987434626,
0.5283703804,
0.6925773025,
0.6613972783,
-0.06661544,
-0.7367587686,
-0.9988687038,
-0.091032505,
-0.3842141032,
-0.1348855197,
-0.1104434803,
0.4515456855,
-0.1606304348,
0.7066075802,
-0.6566546559,
-0.3879282773,
-0.362870276,
0.0070520956,
0.5210103989,
0.2807551324,
0.4441299736,
-0.5337497592,
-0.3389456868,
-0.2229951024,
-0.5691846013,
-0.3199993074,
0.2822360992,
0.0208113492,
-0.0404911488,
0.8420317173,
-0.4924868643,
0.1326619387,
0.4182391763,
-0.1616859287,
0.7726408839,
0.0585659742,
-0.2463891506,
-0.972065568,
0.1337383986,
0.1657527089,
-0.0590875521,
-0.6581350565,
0.024382554,
0.1894108355,
-0.0969231427,
-0.6049004197,
0.497474581,
-0.6835169792,
0.0431214236,
-0.292951405,
-0.260541141,
-0.0586578026,
0.6018291116,
-0.1150852442,
0.4017025828,
0.8383864164,
-0.7291021943,
0.2350930274,
0.3185364306,
-0.5054899454,
0.0982373282,
-0.7755822539,
-0.0673063472,
0.0390395708,
0.1740735769,
-1.0323778391,
-0.4523799419,
0.340893358,
0.0381660834,
0.4957124591,
-0.6263916492,
-0.3955991268,
-0.2849287391,
-0.1351425946,
0.1596354395,
0.4007122517,
-0.880069077,
0.307785064,
0.1476961672,
-0.2756647766,
-0.6680112481,
-0.7082308531,
-0.1258406937,
-0.3425898254,
-0.4300651252,
0.1338324398,
0.2715648115,
-0.3939899802,
-0.1348752528,
-0.30026564,
0.0067516468,
0.1951919496,
0.3510252833,
0.3352781236,
-0.298004061,
0.3759531975,
-0.0007271874,
-0.0210924502,
0.1482869685,
-0.1759075075,
0.3974773586,
-0.0528145842,
-0.2944509089,
-0.1446040422,
0.0368478112,
0.1313381046,
-0.0948380306,
0.823120296,
0.5214345455,
-0.0578968823,
-0.728961885,
-0.4521552026,
-0.4767869115,
-0.5590322018,
0.4460680485,
-0.5258854628,
-1.29076612,
0.5004600286,
-0.065418236,
-0.1083590165,
0.3200818896,
0.6996909976,
0.0323327556,
0.9000045061,
0.6455875039,
-0.1958979219,
0.706938982,
-0.1268694848,
0.0681209043,
-0.4894360006,
-0.1243970394,
-0.6702715755,
-0.0856778324,
-0.0856516808,
-0.2502359748,
0.2140387446,
0.5221036673,
-0.1921533197,
0.3363438845,
-0.2991673648,
0.4075517356,
0.4199552238,
0.2194453925,
0.0972193331,
0.1608262658,
-0.0602834709,
0.3258458376,
-0.5791966915,
-0.3623975813,
0.8904402256,
0.3384760618,
1.1314738989,
-0.1633047014,
0.7251642346,
0.0387993827,
0.4759720564,
-1.0920271873,
0.5580077767,
-0.0884457752,
-0.3441363573,
-0.2983920872,
-0.8534289002,
-0.9462635517,
0.2005715072,
-0.0159369856,
-0.7045808434,
0.0741579086,
0.3718185127,
-0.0508773178,
0.169322595,
-1.0196381807,
0.6830375195,
-0.1214621961,
-0.5670552254,
-0.1276336461,
-0.583109796,
0.4104442,
0.1000111699,
-0.1003087834,
0.0184379201,
0.3118019998,
0.5925750136,
-0.5750758052,
1.2552301884,
-0.2123587579,
-0.56230551,
0.5045152307,
-0.1442526281,
0.6397404671,
0.0583574511,
-0.2349286526,
0.1242481396,
-0.3999305367,
-0.333609432,
-0.3108021915,
0.5299985409,
-0.4455013573,
-0.6373649836,
-0.0247050654,
-0.3455308676,
-0.2230988145,
0.3684951663,
0.0312608518,
0.764878571,
-0.0536141098,
0.4045816362,
0.5739087462,
-0.0383225679,
0.1758106798,
0.3230364025,
-0.1667210162,
-0.2742632627,
0.6326239109,
0.0445634201,
0.1668460816,
0.3566203415,
0.1905218214,
-0.2409022152,
-0.6902399659,
-0.0687929615,
0.3759046793,
-0.7800819278,
-0.3848748505,
-0.5457325578,
-0.0140993111,
-0.5196072459,
-0.194824338,
-0.2764242887,
-0.0885701552,
-0.3844388723,
-0.264223218,
0.3264766634,
0.6418612599,
0.2043890804,
0.4902841151,
-0.8327259421,
0.3756836355,
0.212726891,
0.5009666085,
0.1241455674,
-0.3228706121,
-0.6829544306,
-0.2494656891,
-0.1565171927,
-0.8315505981,
0.2480677813,
0.1103408188,
0.5567030907,
0.6977340579,
0.0603618957,
0.6806076169,
-0.4446935952,
0.4575629532,
0.2206682265,
-0.8568795323,
0.7176117301,
-0.3778737485,
0.3080771267,
0.5793842077,
0.3822113276,
0.0274382401,
-0.5931215286,
-0.3489081562,
-1.1270414591,
0.8378271461,
-0.1759351194,
-0.23606655,
-0.271786958,
0.5304182172,
0.0207802672,
-0.0068797404,
-0.588690877,
-0.0651875585,
0.3941369653,
-0.1788094044,
-0.1583919376,
-0.4119125605,
-0.2513425052,
0.0211121701,
0.6965776682,
-0.4368363917,
-0.3576742411,
0.2028303891,
-0.4041315317,
-0.2508910596,
0.3769156635,
0.0529667959,
0.492167592,
-0.2345734537,
0.4028021097,
0.1809792817,
-0.2453779578,
0.0703538805,
-0.1659436375,
-0.0482246317,
-0.2687785029,
0.7794117928,
0.9317275882,
0.484849304,
-0.5892519951,
0.1374025196,
0.4290620685,
-0.338783145,
0.0715318769,
0.2794997096,
0.0826492757,
0.4164475799,
0.4293118417,
-0.2209350169,
0.0862363875,
-0.6076206565,
0.4619488716,
0.303037256,
-0.4765811265,
-0.52880615,
0.3272326291,
0.034433309,
0.0055950982,
0.6981178522,
-0.0544098318,
-0.5167423487,
0.5539578795,
0.6557172537,
0.6686524153,
-0.2068759501,
0.1119143814,
0.5671785474,
0.1208565831,
-0.5471644998,
0.1759120673,
-0.23926346,
-0.5318199992,
-0.9213846326,
-0.8151645064,
-0.4692954719,
0.0745472088,
-0.8131843805,
0.6837584376,
-0.4933736026,
0.0047035147,
-0.2286018729,
-0.0876441672,
-0.305821687,
0.044054158,
0.184049204,
0.5639280677,
-0.9523078203,
0.7941857576,
0.7978540063,
-0.1823307872,
-1.163725853,
-0.0890185833,
0.2487995028,
-0.614430964,
0.9524009824,
0.3762078583,
-0.1211819202,
-0.1327255666,
-0.6800341606,
-0.8246996999,
0.6611257792,
0.4247221947,
-0.7123595476,
0.0095855976,
-0.2652362287,
0.597384274,
-0.0521460623,
0.0771757513,
0.2631090283,
0.3846154511,
0.2744136751,
-0.489875555,
0.2416091412,
-0.0359770022,
-0.2856484354,
0.4761676192,
-0.5895987153,
0.6841273904,
-0.3907339573,
-0.3299632072,
0.0418476164,
0.9643263221,
0.4282194674,
0.2377109528,
0.5541258454,
0.5879560113,
0.6443080306,
0.0284629576,
0.6675609946,
0.0528500453,
0.4220550358,
1.2784392834,
-0.4760170877,
0.7600049973,
0.5465810299,
-0.1210354567,
0.4311048985,
0.3599069417,
-0.2889560461,
0.3946300149,
0.2290732414,
0.0456666462,
-0.156214878,
-0.0811739862,
-0.2005463839,
0.2878958583,
0.461017102,
-0.3726278543,
-0.4264724851,
-0.0986309648,
-0.2448575646,
-0.2051021904,
-0.4000817537,
0.7361367345,
0.4619165957,
-0.5803806186,
0.6332224011,
-0.2231431454,
0.3960516453,
-0.9868276119,
0.031939812,
0.0203775056,
0.4073185623,
-0.3747103512,
-0.6229317188,
0.438205272,
-0.0801303685,
-0.2008497417,
-0.5722247958,
0.9005595446,
-0.7346293926,
-0.0660567656,
0.687297225,
0.3653669059,
-0.0179987401,
-0.0039864746,
-0.2960188389,
0.1205200329,
-0.0060725352,
-0.6006845236,
0.3520728648,
0.4107104838,
-0.1029861942,
0.4890516698,
0.6950696111,
0.2504521012,
-0.1532747597,
0.6289300323,
0.9723049998,
-0.6198529601,
-0.4371981323,
-0.9651554227,
0.331815958,
0.1838501543,
-0.2344719768,
0.8745606542,
0.5052831173,
0.8126524687,
-0.098453477,
0.3483653963,
0.0187543798,
0.3099451065,
-0.8219425678,
0.4234161377,
-0.5980165005,
0.4508910775,
-0.33092466,
-1.3412929773,
-0.529219985,
0.2890335619,
-0.3884396851,
-0.1798639894,
0.6292336583,
0.988273561,
-0.1119521633,
-0.133826673,
0.2242536694,
0.6187810302,
0.4548534453,
0.2682632506,
0.9533908367,
0.0364423916,
0.6818113327,
-0.1274724752,
-0.1393294632,
-0.2207358778,
-0.5858673453,
-1.2252138853,
-0.4130851924,
-0.358643353,
-0.4713847339,
-0.0944573283,
0.8221691847,
0.6344984174,
-0.8371958733,
-0.178623274,
-0.0953249559,
0.2144274563,
-0.1227140576,
-0.2573907971,
0.5673884153,
-0.7396194935,
-0.4921678305,
0.8726046681,
0.4378183782,
-0.1442145109,
0.0374613144,
0.0524065383,
-0.1257664412,
-0.4530977905,
0.5950374007,
0.265597403,
-0.4566357434,
-0.3931739926,
-0.2102269828,
-0.2112049609,
-0.0230643377,
0.9506639242,
-0.5570571423,
0.1071406677,
0.7456210256,
0.5901558399,
0.6306747198,
0.0607883893,
0.4205155671,
-1.1474219561,
0.180662334,
0.0666864589,
0.4978177249,
0.2618781328,
-0.3327607214,
0.4866167605,
0.0487802699,
-0.4978984296,
-0.9379296899,
0.4698387384,
-1.047290802,
-0.3305872977,
1.1308381557,
-0.1334925294,
-0.4591245353,
-0.301048398,
-0.2208396643,
0.4397813976,
-0.3413352072,
0.6622592807,
0.5207054019,
0.122594893,
-0.0685196146,
0.0102012167,
0.2542148232,
0.7158623338,
-0.5117579699,
0.2543784976,
0.5587738156,
0.2031939775,
0.0387209356,
0.5029194951,
-0.0206945892,
-0.1278023124,
-0.054608658,
0.0073481565,
-0.1264153719,
-0.6024106741,
-0.4454088509,
0.4318247139,
-0.0053649647,
0.4693749845
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01865v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01865v2
|
What Will My Model Forget? Forecasting Forgotten Examples in Language Model Refinement
| 2024-02-02T19:43:15 | 2024-06-20T06:25:39 |
Xisen Jin, Xiang Ren
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
Language models deployed in the wild make errors. However, simply updating
the model with the corrected error instances causes catastrophic forgetting --
the updated model makes errors on instances learned during the instruction
tuning or upstream training phase. Randomly replaying upstream data yields
unsatisfactory performance and often comes with high variance and poor
controllability. To this end, we try to forecast upstream examples that will be
forgotten due to a model update for improved controllability of the replay
process and interpretability. We train forecasting models given a collection of
online learned examples and corresponding forgotten upstream pre-training
examples. We propose a partially interpretable forecasting model based on the
observation that changes in pre-softmax logit scores of pretraining examples
resemble that of online learned examples, which performs decently on BART but
fails on T5 models. We further show a black-box classifier based on inner
products of example representations achieves better forecasting performance
over a series of setups. Finally, we show that we reduce forgetting of upstream
pretraining examples by replaying examples that are forecasted to be forgotten,
demonstrating the practical utility of forecasting example forgetting.
|
[
0.0042696465,
-0.4323353171,
0.4174612761,
0.3638818264,
-0.2837618887,
0.0031668271,
0.0615137145,
-0.314642638,
0.0229840521,
0.4553135037,
-0.6609418988,
-0.162138015,
-0.4826491177,
-0.3004253209,
-0.4906130433,
1.2159302235,
-0.159633413,
0.0831867531,
-0.0363650545,
0.0429028273,
-0.7921349406,
-0.5846532583,
-0.969852984,
-0.4743406177,
0.3180219531,
0.3954433799,
0.3189606071,
0.5968906283,
0.0728506297,
0.2217409313,
0.0477377921,
-0.0740410537,
-0.8744350076,
0.0071651973,
-0.1633977145,
-0.7086760402,
-0.5232850313,
0.0260635838,
0.7309749126,
0.7861718535,
-0.4790895283,
0.0618793219,
-0.0413810611,
0.4691136777,
-0.5072329044,
0.4816159308,
-0.8611674905,
0.0195106752,
0.1199244037,
-0.1229481846,
-0.3606829047,
-0.2780444622,
0.2470185757,
-0.4880021513,
0.4900734127,
0.1308173984,
0.81150949,
0.1915614605,
-0.0587345585,
-0.2508788705,
-1.0443105698,
1.0771523714,
-0.9869092107,
0.2583173215,
0.518989861,
0.5836969614,
-0.1551995128,
-0.881043911,
-0.3289786875,
0.1588366628,
0.061726924,
0.5934866667,
-0.4377332032,
-0.2617200315,
-0.0033958661,
0.2225771248,
-0.2786791623,
0.0015771826,
-0.4569708705,
-0.2059304565,
0.4036038518,
0.0370536633,
-0.378775537,
0.4308619499,
-0.1939484477,
-0.043632932,
-0.9618367553,
-0.1763992906,
0.3051830828,
0.2780569494,
0.0411139429,
0.0501344278,
0.0054801358,
0.3505563736,
0.126268357,
0.0386708565,
0.160103336,
0.0301149692,
-0.3299404085,
-0.0350587405,
0.2822726369,
0.3249117136,
0.5461445451,
-0.1582875401,
-0.4530982375,
-0.2819311023,
0.3658827543,
-0.2250430435,
-0.4520343244,
0.180371508,
-0.3765080273,
-0.1116373241,
-0.2564376295,
-0.5342822075,
-0.1316544861,
-0.2582356036,
0.5397612453,
-0.2640048563,
-0.3102018833,
0.0600572117,
-0.4837910235,
-0.0873562023,
0.4785598218,
-0.9137560129,
0.4226557314,
0.4616359472,
0.4829408526,
0.3794570863,
-0.6108719707,
-0.4589619339,
0.1579456925,
-0.4843974113,
0.778408885,
-0.2714767158,
-0.3439987004,
-0.0367619246,
0.1461279839,
-0.1889930069,
-0.6180599928,
0.1405402124,
-0.5714932084,
0.3432812393,
-0.2215700597,
-0.6958785057,
-0.5944302678,
0.0291971695,
-0.5638183355,
0.8471357822,
0.2350310385,
-0.2770412266,
0.4949569702,
-0.2676761746,
-0.1177771538,
-0.0631514639,
0.2343813181,
-0.7462650537,
0.2295028269,
0.012674313,
0.4950185418,
-0.0073669543,
0.2561835349,
-0.3893209398,
-0.4911811352,
-0.1253112257,
-0.4248344898,
0.3447633088,
0.0707514212,
-0.4399542212,
0.1940552741,
-0.629540801,
-0.104562521,
0.2993672788,
-0.0157347824,
-0.3217336833,
0.4624006152,
0.120251514,
0.0578249134,
0.071937032,
-0.1721285582,
0.0407690629,
-0.3739873469,
0.5057595968,
1.2449936867,
0.150831759,
0.3630269766,
-0.6851950288,
0.6512963176,
0.5573037267,
0.1093850657,
-0.566580832,
-0.460215956,
-1.031355381,
0.3126083314,
0.2163979858,
0.5293619037,
-0.5274025798,
-0.0381419547,
-0.2338037938,
-0.6686457396,
-0.299185127,
0.2386985272,
0.4012053013,
0.3665697277,
0.4121895134,
-0.2168585509,
-0.712893188,
-0.7214943171,
-0.4022545516,
-0.1381176114,
0.0175837129,
0.0604275949,
0.5295496583,
-0.1837741584,
0.8274527788,
-0.4304708242,
-0.2302010953,
-0.5013239384,
0.2757898569,
0.1767771393,
0.5383816957,
0.566372633,
-0.6600280404,
-0.0267303921,
-0.3002919555,
-0.4841036797,
0.3038165271,
-0.3896917105,
0.157146439,
0.2039190978,
0.5283557177,
-0.1895302683,
0.2394346297,
0.4905948639,
-0.2200615257,
0.5212257504,
-0.5551375747,
-0.5306518078,
-0.8793001771,
-0.307082653,
-0.0846328363,
-0.5368840694,
-0.4273705482,
-0.1486257613,
0.0366381258,
-0.0201736037,
-0.4550897479,
0.6334357858,
-0.3001963198,
-0.0268733148,
-0.1678952724,
-0.2448756546,
-0.1183150634,
0.4991814196,
0.0468061306,
0.6479020119,
0.4924499393,
-0.7907393575,
-0.0262613855,
-0.1502765268,
-0.3124785125,
-0.0163446553,
-0.5288887024,
0.2387409806,
-0.4513693452,
0.1675263345,
-0.7796946764,
0.0093670692,
0.092698209,
-0.1267288923,
0.6274139285,
-0.1975670606,
-0.1839906573,
-0.328696698,
-0.0575108901,
0.0216225926,
0.8614171743,
-0.5428977609,
0.5759566426,
0.3230038285,
-0.2265870273,
-0.5959117413,
-0.6295694709,
-0.1847217977,
-0.2449455559,
0.2144132107,
0.0568830259,
-0.1070538536,
0.0444694832,
0.0837665871,
-0.2291812003,
-0.2009394318,
0.3744155467,
0.2662007511,
0.2119318098,
-0.2921274304,
0.1269464195,
0.0344312526,
-0.0820962191,
-0.002822327,
-0.6419197321,
0.3731314242,
-0.3677733243,
-0.1171407253,
-0.0878145993,
0.12800771,
0.5081264973,
0.2586732805,
0.7551724315,
0.1435937136,
-0.587279439,
-0.3782035112,
-0.6105361581,
-0.2061800659,
-0.4477448463,
0.457220614,
-0.1490567029,
-0.5383811593,
0.6876969934,
-0.1602826118,
0.2745715082,
0.4399608076,
0.1795883626,
-0.4541599452,
0.9123004675,
0.9124235511,
-0.3282459676,
0.5147011876,
-0.3125377595,
0.1328672767,
-0.4014446437,
0.0121373422,
-0.31500265,
-0.1604949534,
-0.6056169868,
-0.2321887761,
-0.0394742414,
0.4410157204,
-0.4375831783,
0.3130226433,
-0.0300948638,
0.5493890643,
0.7348938584,
-0.0880478695,
0.1946267933,
0.1272123009,
-0.0344173871,
-0.157270506,
-1.1032245159,
-0.5198900104,
1.1718150377,
0.3531195223,
0.7803224325,
-0.393935442,
0.5450999141,
0.3625189364,
0.7234792709,
-0.5073654056,
0.184787944,
-0.2193693221,
-0.5804829597,
0.03732609,
-0.3944486976,
-0.7698961496,
-0.0506205074,
0.0618168786,
-0.5673595071,
0.2616107166,
0.783669591,
-0.1652416587,
0.5111888051,
-1.0636354685,
0.9865126014,
0.0096863788,
0.0402490534,
-0.3481996357,
-0.26415658,
0.2134628892,
-0.3432779014,
0.3637373447,
0.0782585144,
0.2610813379,
0.6173087955,
-0.1166892201,
1.1010793447,
-0.2956715822,
0.1613589078,
0.1566246301,
-0.0645382926,
0.4213469625,
-0.3929229975,
-0.1097838059,
0.4084962606,
-0.0160427038,
-0.7012835145,
-0.4690411389,
0.6129062772,
-0.6774477959,
-0.5341207385,
-0.4280685782,
-0.0934393853,
-0.2173421234,
0.1016581282,
0.275670439,
0.3816012442,
-0.1968676448,
-0.2000612915,
0.387150079,
-0.1260519624,
0.6573239565,
0.4371698499,
-0.3001431227,
-0.1195179299,
1.1165729761,
0.2920546234,
0.4038709402,
0.3222678006,
0.1551520526,
-0.0903222412,
-0.6439918876,
-0.4771208465,
0.2609795928,
-0.8243649602,
-0.107496269,
-0.2493036985,
-0.176371932,
-0.1989737898,
-0.1265227646,
-0.5141924024,
-0.5042726994,
-0.3426880836,
-0.2246286124,
0.1398110539,
1.1208398342,
0.0513303503,
0.6281909347,
-0.7462896109,
-0.028166892,
0.2702214122,
0.6054531932,
0.5265852809,
-0.4307998121,
-0.4739641845,
0.2138165236,
-0.6278918982,
-0.4680389762,
0.6380118728,
0.4230650067,
0.5940203071,
0.5402908921,
-0.1883172691,
0.8322927952,
-0.6707146168,
0.626765132,
0.0526371934,
-0.9671885371,
0.6116312146,
-0.0904590711,
0.6435033679,
0.2118360698,
0.4452032149,
-0.7067809105,
-0.796354115,
-0.7659425735,
-0.7964709401,
0.718937099,
-0.1848028302,
0.290551424,
-0.0513477325,
0.3905617595,
0.4382528663,
0.3831847608,
-0.8668110967,
-0.4966594577,
-0.5521663427,
-0.0683151633,
-0.5770911574,
-0.4489633143,
0.3181902766,
-0.21265468,
0.8204446435,
0.069072783,
0.3609420657,
-0.0609092228,
-0.0982726067,
-0.3708071709,
0.1710454673,
0.6782503724,
0.8984897137,
-0.3887389898,
-0.0396153815,
0.4494256079,
-0.4444856644,
-0.060975749,
-0.0978469849,
-0.3892767727,
0.1863344014,
0.5636392236,
0.9329187274,
0.636079073,
-0.6875712276,
0.1229618713,
-0.005218274,
0.0275690798,
-0.9525231719,
0.0491219983,
0.2874146402,
0.0448172502,
0.5234857202,
0.6494659781,
-0.1613355279,
-0.7757443786,
-0.1400099993,
0.0445557758,
-0.7102349997,
-0.4975721538,
0.7581577897,
-0.2927143574,
-0.0955187976,
0.6737111807,
-0.1514637321,
-0.797691226,
0.6958675981,
0.630004406,
0.807277143,
-0.5063869357,
-0.0608711317,
0.2288929075,
0.432959497,
-0.471727103,
0.3167476058,
0.2482627481,
-0.8060632348,
-0.3934301138,
-0.5455061197,
-0.3151133657,
0.3369738758,
-0.7095185518,
0.1871726364,
-0.7339603305,
-0.0513581112,
-0.174341172,
-0.3543179333,
-0.85023278,
0.435954541,
0.0171942096,
0.8933223486,
-1.0023186207,
0.8077536225,
0.5802494287,
-0.3449403942,
-0.8341780305,
-0.1127077416,
-0.1656953692,
-0.7341797352,
0.5995420218,
0.0532637984,
0.003047083,
0.0772818178,
-0.4561854303,
-0.7215615511,
0.8794044852,
0.2118341625,
-0.7347133756,
-0.1643594652,
-0.2196522504,
0.4971078932,
-0.3517168462,
0.4337417185,
0.4447473884,
0.2513612807,
-0.0423724726,
-0.9126926064,
-0.3217099309,
-0.1261088997,
-0.1677427739,
0.210467875,
-0.4925906658,
1.0331604481,
-0.366612196,
-0.1688234657,
-0.0583302304,
0.4622177184,
-0.1537056118,
0.6952897906,
0.3933549225,
0.4930846095,
0.739145875,
-0.1502135396,
1.3358988762,
0.2226591259,
0.2900392711,
1.5233682394,
-0.1347257793,
1.0852333307,
0.2248981297,
-0.1506842226,
0.5006027818,
0.6512903571,
0.052356638,
0.7095156312,
-0.0721943825,
-0.0640584379,
-0.2668825984,
0.355319649,
-0.5545547009,
0.2847501338,
0.3528228998,
-0.3394371569,
-0.3156665266,
0.1604678929,
0.032318987,
-0.0666323453,
-0.7052538395,
0.8874447346,
0.2455980033,
-0.5868273973,
0.7059420347,
-0.0143493665,
0.3656824231,
-0.694277823,
-0.0917066634,
-0.3973335028,
0.571300447,
0.1979114413,
-0.2195523828,
0.3662320375,
-0.2496816069,
-0.4290563166,
-0.7620011568,
0.2000709921,
-0.4387694299,
-0.6638525724,
0.3761458397,
0.4134571254,
0.161136955,
-0.0290903654,
-0.5727969408,
-0.3637706041,
0.0522654504,
-0.0593696833,
0.3168910444,
0.1858284026,
-0.2608861029,
1.1216061115,
0.4358005822,
0.3776701093,
0.1181273237,
0.1628020704,
0.7313234806,
-0.8222488761,
-0.5404049754,
-0.6699802279,
0.1972192675,
0.1688209325,
-0.2924214303,
0.7091013193,
0.5781032443,
1.1742268801,
-0.5644721985,
0.755208075,
0.6682778001,
0.7112927437,
-0.5259448886,
0.9049915671,
-0.5234891772,
0.3488017619,
-0.1349173486,
-0.7741045356,
0.0016845213,
0.4177982211,
-0.5106164217,
0.1253478974,
0.736997664,
0.414313525,
-0.2335856706,
0.2171605676,
0.3979139626,
0.5923342705,
0.1253534406,
0.5753516555,
0.8526061773,
-0.5755381584,
0.3237719834,
-0.4802499115,
0.0038792242,
-0.2150777429,
-1.0951479673,
-0.6847219467,
-0.661626935,
-0.3248672485,
-0.155297935,
0.3065700531,
0.8564860225,
0.9589605927,
-1.2732906342,
-0.4754603505,
-0.2694925368,
0.3638836145,
-0.5438516736,
-0.2256412655,
0.0896268934,
-0.5573648214,
-0.5507938862,
0.3454825282,
-0.0148689663,
0.5129996538,
-0.0122026643,
0.1356325597,
-0.0267325267,
-0.0221710484,
0.3714192212,
0.4954771698,
-0.5546600819,
-0.1741382182,
-0.273476392,
0.461807996,
-0.0046544815,
0.8387685418,
-0.9868258834,
0.514818728,
-0.125842765,
0.3479072154,
0.7847451568,
-0.2253709286,
1.0257850885,
-0.6962151527,
0.3358492851,
0.327817142,
0.5481576324,
0.2851752043,
-0.1661618948,
0.0304216295,
0.2683639228,
-0.2911245525,
-0.5812903643,
0.0885970071,
-0.5538374782,
-0.4517996013,
0.3888845742,
-0.4485480189,
-0.2004728615,
-0.2356704175,
0.0879462585,
0.1349311918,
-0.2733664215,
1.0148078203,
0.8611409664,
0.4573611021,
-0.3915815055,
-0.8671329021,
0.5782601833,
0.4922163188,
-0.3291809559,
0.2167665064,
0.3377710283,
0.5015510917,
-0.1970216334,
0.5704954267,
0.2580819726,
0.3792244792,
0.0342015103,
-0.1187921464,
-0.0314579606,
-0.3825315237,
-0.4943623245,
-0.0709822848,
0.2206717432,
0.0619359426
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01858v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01858v3
|
Explaining latent representations of generative models with large multimodal models
| 2024-02-02T19:28:33 | 2024-04-18T03:54:39 |
Mengdan Zhu, Zhenke Liu, Bo Pan, Abhinav Angirekula, Liang Zhao
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Learning interpretable representations of data generative latent factors is
an important topic for the development of artificial intelligence. With the
rise of the large multimodal model, it can align images with text to generate
answers. In this work, we propose a framework to comprehensively explain each
latent variable in the generative models using a large multimodal model. We
further measure the uncertainty of our generated explanations, quantitatively
evaluate the performance of explanation generation among multiple large
multimodal models, and qualitatively visualize the variations of each latent
variable to learn the disentanglement effects of different generative models on
explanations. Finally, we discuss the explanatory capabilities and limitations
of state-of-the-art large multimodal models.
|
[
-0.3794226944,
-0.9516305327,
0.8321324587,
0.1539791375,
-0.3060258925,
0.0380011424,
-0.2043279856,
-0.1162968203,
-0.1473412812,
-0.0520451516,
-0.7214411497,
-0.1985602528,
-0.779556334,
-0.1944453418,
-0.2012746334,
0.8562896848,
-0.2289317995,
0.1560503393,
-0.498413384,
0.2095714808,
-0.374453187,
-0.3294365704,
-0.1588127613,
-0.4765915871,
0.7857874632,
0.1103008315,
0.945245862,
0.359231025,
0.5154098868,
0.3785784543,
0.0110121556,
-0.003213658,
-0.323929131,
0.167317763,
-0.1815838665,
-0.5716297626,
-0.4229715765,
-0.0877769738,
0.6665591598,
0.9139357209,
0.0477561355,
-0.0447992571,
-0.0914217606,
0.2470219433,
-0.462462455,
0.3635542989,
-0.2477339357,
0.244734332,
-0.0603830889,
-0.2268795222,
-0.4739959538,
-0.039444074,
-0.0178340506,
-0.8152443767,
0.242773667,
-0.2556084096,
0.5498772264,
0.2745968103,
-0.8010200262,
-0.1070075706,
-1.2179780006,
0.802120626,
-0.30221349,
0.3620391488,
0.2916752696,
0.6503579021,
-0.0659806654,
-0.7425199151,
-0.8664187789,
-0.0322801135,
0.0121077234,
0.4620912671,
-0.126873821,
-0.0199647341,
0.2393991053,
0.5608704686,
-0.8033341169,
0.1681699902,
-0.0366115682,
-0.1456351876,
0.6194457412,
0.2473239154,
0.1279461682,
-0.1557696909,
-0.4713368416,
-0.1496113986,
-0.4386402071,
-0.1194153577,
0.3403419256,
-0.0446920171,
-0.4216972888,
0.7330662012,
0.2212472707,
0.5879865885,
0.0473251306,
-0.1697297394,
0.2538094521,
-0.5234550834,
-0.0117572108,
-0.3598053753,
0.7206361294,
0.3700790405,
-0.3027638793,
-0.1125208959,
-0.1234905198,
0.0897239968,
0.2677607536,
-0.7757549882,
-0.091916509,
0.2799848616,
-0.8623889089,
-0.2618159354,
-0.0767443031,
-1.1105475426,
-0.4762879312,
-0.3893255889,
0.5986657143,
-0.2772220075,
-0.6665111184,
-0.1713264585,
-0.1774737537,
0.102452226,
0.563398242,
-1.1219877005,
-0.1923351139,
0.3540244401,
0.7126411796,
0.1270382702,
-0.1882225573,
-0.1781897396,
0.2757137716,
-0.5077463984,
0.4622083008,
-0.5878906846,
-0.2402273715,
-0.1123492122,
-0.0096027143,
-0.0140783386,
-0.1188655645,
-0.1420073062,
-0.8016386628,
0.3034273088,
-0.0550136566,
-0.4997224808,
-0.4164350331,
0.1120080128,
-0.9459270239,
0.2600155771,
0.2018297166,
-0.6315941811,
0.1787435561,
-0.6989507675,
-0.1301164478,
0.0462965779,
-0.2360086292,
-0.3862940073,
0.4238363206,
0.31627509,
0.6208259463,
-0.3284170032,
0.6070478559,
-0.4493701756,
-0.0334719904,
0.7785581946,
-1.0080672503,
0.6088684797,
0.3318507373,
-0.177325204,
0.1693127304,
-0.502648592,
-0.2621135116,
0.1543381214,
-0.0898394957,
0.0788191035,
0.1100768149,
-0.0299190804,
0.1850648224,
0.3113213778,
-0.0354980826,
-0.0962493494,
0.0998058394,
0.4960867763,
0.7892070413,
0.116574429,
0.5631121993,
-0.1885884106,
0.715842545,
0.5370952487,
0.1765824854,
-0.5743693709,
-0.3405971527,
-0.1841868758,
-0.217790857,
0.3008410931,
-0.0518281348,
-1.1774243116,
0.058449395,
-0.2125812322,
-0.3915474117,
-0.1525851488,
0.0272324048,
0.2194511294,
0.1677726954,
0.229201287,
-0.144478038,
-0.1331858486,
-0.9234294295,
0.3500079215,
-0.1289056987,
-0.1061883867,
0.1344478875,
0.7602951527,
-0.2857603431,
0.7183741331,
-0.4974673986,
0.3215199411,
-0.0088490462,
0.6547983885,
-0.0466141999,
0.5036984086,
0.6129876971,
-1.4580760002,
-0.0557671599,
-0.0293224566,
-0.9146866202,
0.581777215,
-0.5281940699,
-0.0390438437,
-0.2412475199,
0.523018837,
-0.6344187856,
0.3290684223,
0.6518430114,
-0.2685078979,
0.7634512782,
-0.3260922432,
0.0937304571,
-1.2373660803,
-0.0231540054,
0.0255464148,
-0.0821548626,
-0.4154732823,
0.1883165687,
-0.0426556058,
-0.3884903789,
-0.0833962336,
0.1892233491,
-0.4686712623,
-0.0511953942,
-0.0175185706,
0.087072365,
0.273637414,
0.4068459868,
-0.1176767424,
0.5879448652,
0.66006881,
-0.5452546477,
0.7962856293,
0.1925116628,
-0.230850935,
0.4507542551,
-0.7853800654,
-0.3506733477,
-0.5608876348,
0.3398400545,
-1.2807558775,
-0.6091367602,
-0.0496831648,
-0.5968625546,
0.3941696286,
-0.2330604047,
-0.4869432449,
-0.3893227875,
-0.0561037883,
0.6469906569,
0.2458097637,
-0.7959510088,
0.8951697946,
0.0193205662,
-0.1456048936,
-0.4083776772,
-0.5592070222,
-0.1542720497,
-0.4446822405,
-0.6992630363,
0.6350645423,
-0.4289352596,
-0.2646373212,
0.0899297372,
0.0910345018,
-0.2297615558,
0.307300806,
0.418183893,
0.2827499509,
-0.4630160332,
0.6759907603,
0.1263666153,
-0.2677845061,
0.2614408731,
-0.0531309545,
0.4517607987,
-0.0029898805,
-0.6211104393,
-0.3085814714,
0.5603042841,
0.8472595811,
-0.4160115719,
0.9426466823,
0.932716608,
-0.3022420704,
0.1034341976,
0.0086559514,
-0.0930597261,
-0.4014732838,
0.6175560355,
-0.4974962175,
-0.4959201515,
0.6753239036,
-0.2680879235,
-0.2078448683,
0.5225900412,
0.7685890198,
-0.1473610103,
1.5513273478,
0.7659003735,
0.4874806404,
0.5688987374,
-0.3012813926,
0.2231764346,
-0.6779255271,
-0.5588461161,
-0.1058007926,
-0.0953933522,
-0.6010846496,
-0.8304384351,
0.394405961,
0.2874934375,
-0.1021930873,
-0.3315003514,
-0.1627556682,
0.3577083051,
0.3385086954,
0.2403109521,
0.0828776136,
0.1252357811,
-0.023766309,
0.0251313318,
-0.5242429376,
-0.5513560176,
1.0728063583,
0.5563530326,
1.0528177023,
0.5986762047,
0.2514718175,
0.0306588523,
-0.0596332327,
-0.5979204178,
0.0152917216,
-0.1902234554,
-0.6839849353,
-0.1549655348,
-0.5308696628,
-0.9834465384,
0.3334819973,
-0.6603919864,
-0.6527201533,
0.2021419853,
0.2900714278,
-0.571380198,
0.1523612142,
-0.9542351365,
1.0132905245,
-0.4766830504,
-0.4014461637,
-0.2919088602,
-0.5943472385,
0.5092383623,
-0.1571153402,
0.2720062137,
0.3412689269,
0.1398659348,
0.5858867764,
-0.1479564756,
0.8926753998,
-0.3074162304,
-0.2520420551,
0.1847504675,
-0.1643706709,
0.0396161675,
0.3024107814,
0.0215003733,
0.0085998205,
-0.1349743009,
-0.3462662697,
-0.9322377443,
0.4930643141,
-0.8548173308,
-0.4078999162,
0.0046732188,
-0.6991208792,
0.0183333158,
-0.0023001228,
0.3531304896,
0.7255689502,
-0.1986353248,
0.2997520566,
0.8515779376,
-0.4852751791,
0.4190587401,
-0.0209731534,
-0.4040896297,
-0.0447042212,
0.9785811901,
0.029784821,
0.2014383674,
0.3929183781,
0.2057422847,
-0.5352234244,
-0.4468838573,
-0.5365350246,
0.0985561609,
-0.6547825933,
0.0537251383,
-0.3620843291,
-0.1050903499,
-0.181608811,
-0.0224183742,
-0.153651014,
-0.2923108041,
-0.5803268552,
-0.0402588435,
0.2514174581,
0.9830882549,
-0.1431849748,
0.6622571349,
-0.4802001119,
0.5750911832,
0.6696760654,
0.4885248542,
0.360879004,
-0.358029604,
-0.3100413084,
0.4487357438,
-0.4761057198,
-1.1567593813,
-0.054484874,
0.0280576758,
0.6917918921,
0.774738133,
-0.1221445873,
0.6218219995,
-0.2732236683,
0.9621191025,
0.6243720651,
-0.9712958336,
0.4337219298,
-0.3325509727,
0.2550816238,
-0.2391255051,
0.6769063473,
-0.1118502915,
0.0587274879,
-0.6153404117,
-0.9330241084,
0.4304463863,
0.2470493019,
0.2789179385,
0.1832762212,
0.2650692463,
0.3751929104,
0.144492954,
-0.9331845045,
-0.0923939347,
-0.4981125593,
-0.3041805327,
-0.5056295991,
-0.4260571897,
-0.3981134892,
0.1141091734,
0.3339290321,
-0.1994158179,
0.710195601,
-0.2357885838,
-0.344301641,
-0.0650141761,
0.103744261,
0.7306213975,
0.9433342218,
0.1134715378,
0.600405395,
-0.4006461799,
-0.1253211051,
0.0744690523,
0.3191986084,
0.2796894908,
0.0149523169,
0.8130990863,
1.0005916357,
-0.3293742239,
-0.3399471343,
0.6073454022,
-0.2585685253,
-0.1846716702,
-0.4430491924,
-0.1277807057,
0.3637078404,
0.5986078978,
0.3850820959,
-0.0034959484,
-0.1483791173,
-0.5334934592,
0.0290343352,
0.3622384667,
-0.1725672781,
-0.5175626278,
0.7782015204,
-0.0314610302,
0.1406016499,
0.4648939371,
-0.15565072,
-0.4452522695,
0.8251467943,
0.5083371401,
0.2249083966,
-0.2999320924,
0.6345635056,
0.2781714201,
0.1241649687,
0.1251678318,
-0.0103391232,
-0.2016262859,
-0.6725985408,
-0.7252003551,
-0.3716664016,
-0.0718052387,
0.3219105601,
-0.8677374125,
-0.2472253591,
-0.2259932011,
-0.2393705398,
0.7493304014,
-0.4646808207,
-0.6652660966,
0.2811032236,
0.2653107643,
0.1471458077,
-1.1872794628,
0.2010042965,
0.7170115709,
-0.8834760189,
-0.6362401247,
0.1434739381,
-0.0146589726,
-0.7644708753,
0.79279387,
0.0258724596,
0.0811681822,
-0.3082637191,
-0.7824735641,
-0.847279489,
0.9952633381,
0.4169911146,
-0.5212513208,
0.1179367229,
-0.0148606272,
0.5794827938,
-0.3434541523,
0.4848223329,
-0.0787151158,
0.4551546872,
0.1812600493,
-0.2941428721,
-0.0488640368,
-0.2159794122,
0.4057992101,
-0.0270408057,
-0.2886058092,
1.2107406855,
-0.3800584972,
-0.1419633329,
-0.1018482149,
0.6504718065,
-0.1831431091,
0.2763318121,
0.4713629186,
0.1611912996,
0.6337253451,
-0.1927410215,
0.9773386717,
0.0227545351,
0.4289748967,
1.023806572,
0.1386126727,
0.4599837959,
0.5707054138,
-0.1158946306,
0.6444988251,
0.7875364423,
-0.1157382503,
0.3700683415,
0.1865727454,
-0.3190474808,
-0.471288681,
-0.024320079,
-0.4656463861,
0.7902332544,
0.5681009293,
-0.5866461992,
-0.3371802568,
0.5651010275,
-0.4644411802,
-0.0013279469,
-0.2288025469,
0.7432447076,
-0.1755658239,
-0.5410113335,
0.3887960017,
-0.0183887016,
0.1420468092,
-0.3614970744,
-0.3398090899,
-0.027681727,
0.18727009,
-0.2191467732,
-0.9131435752,
0.2194576561,
-0.1810946912,
-0.6374313235,
-0.1942360401,
0.2214110941,
-0.6308777332,
-0.519336164,
0.2402269244,
0.5330515504,
0.2124220133,
0.014534235,
-0.6642743349,
0.0893794969,
-0.1552708298,
-0.191186294,
0.1120857969,
0.7769441009,
-0.23377572,
0.6022714376,
0.4806183875,
-0.3257106543,
0.0121491831,
0.1311885267,
0.8310137987,
-0.3673814237,
-0.2964256704,
-0.8201636672,
0.7607386112,
0.1067746133,
0.0761706904,
0.4121454358,
0.2159311771,
0.4473135471,
-0.2458347976,
0.6684986949,
-0.2339859903,
-0.0257210378,
-0.7317607403,
0.500105083,
-0.9488669038,
0.0679601505,
-0.0899264142,
-0.8598502278,
-0.1148375943,
0.8515855074,
-0.2009289414,
0.4228461981,
0.7018571496,
0.6305059195,
-0.2211686075,
0.0804431438,
0.4570090175,
0.5537807345,
0.345826894,
0.5012954473,
1.0309782028,
-0.1935928017,
0.4709406197,
-0.1748552769,
-0.425406605,
-0.1883723885,
-0.9268406034,
-0.6648249626,
-1.0564981699,
-0.4401925504,
-0.1518888474,
-0.3320131898,
0.235189423,
0.8508695364,
-0.396030277,
0.1932413429,
0.1399884373,
0.4206602871,
-0.2681036294,
-0.2379168868,
0.3742310405,
-0.0172910802,
-0.6435381174,
0.0650658756,
0.055190891,
0.4361222088,
-0.5154437423,
-0.0086991005,
-0.0763271898,
-0.1988472342,
0.8512657881,
-0.2360034138,
-0.6379945874,
-0.0948180929,
-0.2863181829,
0.1174719483,
-0.1583079249,
0.6877990365,
-0.2760531306,
0.8239379525,
0.2680225968,
0.3905400634,
0.6965527534,
-0.032657098,
0.7586393952,
-0.7592810988,
0.0178949609,
0.0271197334,
0.4147443175,
0.3379338682,
-0.3579983115,
0.0980593562,
-0.0263634343,
-0.2669658065,
-0.5730283856,
0.585832715,
-0.892175138,
-0.5394780636,
0.7864769697,
-0.4344299436,
-0.1815509945,
-0.0231943559,
0.1776845008,
0.5338113308,
-0.0306912698,
0.7182409167,
0.7787937522,
-0.0332850888,
-0.3773702085,
-0.4904035628,
0.0218482316,
0.3006508946,
-0.8930710554,
0.171368137,
0.726960361,
0.0520825312,
0.5485805273,
0.1814232022,
-0.305437535,
0.3029823899,
0.4505834877,
-0.0812803805,
0.023929568,
-0.4869603813,
-0.4768334031,
0.2433624268,
0.0949093476,
-0.2884036601
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01841v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01841v1
|
COMET: Generating Commit Messages using Delta Graph Context Representation
| 2024-02-02T19:01:52 | 2024-02-02T19:01:52 |
Abhinav Reddy Mandli, Saurabhsingh Rajput, Tushar Sharma
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Commit messages explain code changes in a commit and facilitate collaboration
among developers. Several commit message generation approaches have been
proposed; however, they exhibit limited success in capturing the context of
code changes. We propose Comet (Context-Aware Commit Message Generation), a
novel approach that captures context of code changes using a graph-based
representation and leverages a transformer-based model to generate high-quality
commit messages. Our proposed method utilizes delta graph that we developed to
effectively represent code differences. We also introduce a customizable
quality assurance module to identify optimal messages, mitigating subjectivity
in commit messages. Experiments show that Comet outperforms state-of-the-art
techniques in terms of bleu-norm and meteor metrics while being comparable in
terms of rogue-l. Additionally, we compare the proposed approach with the
popular gpt-3.5-turbo model, along with gpt-4-turbo; the most capable GPT
model, over zero-shot, one-shot, and multi-shot settings. We found Comet
outperforming the GPT models, on five and four metrics respectively and provide
competitive results with the two other metrics. The study has implications for
researchers, tool developers, and software developers. Software developers may
utilize Comet to generate context-aware commit messages. Researchers and tool
developers can apply the proposed delta graph technique in similar contexts,
like code review summarization.
|
[
-0.2925156355,
-0.4560470581,
0.3937499821,
0.122788012,
-0.35879004,
0.0720291808,
-0.0546141192,
-0.2257339805,
0.667709887,
0.416415453,
-0.8111730814,
-0.5393539071,
-0.3969656527,
-0.0447103642,
-0.5965896845,
1.2747232914,
0.0419988148,
-0.088616401,
0.0387756415,
0.0850779489,
-1.0556901693,
-0.4210499823,
-0.2584313452,
0.000612208,
0.4504927695,
0.3993430734,
0.6072517633,
0.5914384723,
0.7478461862,
0.1508833617,
0.0778392777,
-0.1821772456,
-0.5464948416,
0.3153427541,
-0.2709534168,
-0.2577459812,
-0.4230597019,
-0.2702654004,
0.7370169163,
0.5232843757,
0.1218248233,
0.1934893876,
-0.0054969531,
0.7982481122,
-0.8922711015,
0.1513033509,
-0.6031368971,
-0.1905366629,
-0.2492428124,
-0.1219077185,
-0.5591415763,
-0.2847417593,
-0.4711746275,
-0.4272149205,
0.0715256259,
-0.2936466336,
0.7805326581,
0.180668354,
-0.5988174677,
-0.4359516501,
-0.8880798221,
0.4155216515,
-0.6051089764,
0.3642623723,
-0.1284624338,
0.6521092653,
-0.3399627507,
-0.8657616973,
-0.2805719376,
-0.0307431594,
-0.0704381242,
0.4532830417,
-0.0407054275,
-0.4709355533,
-0.246202141,
0.3376394212,
-0.4198974371,
0.0110857254,
0.0030470316,
-0.6647770405,
0.4734379053,
0.4393495619,
-0.046532616,
-0.4006924331,
-0.1115263626,
-0.1852556914,
-0.8141431212,
0.137792021,
0.1426614672,
0.4469434023,
0.0016863147,
0.3903653026,
-0.1282289475,
0.4649017453,
0.2621297836,
0.2786646783,
-0.2379180193,
-0.6459997296,
0.0380543694,
-0.1437818855,
0.6941629052,
0.4591054916,
-0.4116315842,
-0.1433315426,
-0.2055625767,
0.1207682192,
0.343732059,
-1.0322164297,
-0.1197842434,
0.4596393704,
-0.3594219089,
-0.2336016893,
0.3991794586,
-0.6367231011,
-0.4071130753,
0.0109591074,
-0.1024013162,
-0.6233130097,
-0.4019503891,
-0.3005011976,
-0.2384171039,
-0.0249067619,
0.5855624676,
-0.7221800685,
-0.0767897442,
0.8100391626,
0.7400725484,
0.1641136408,
-0.2582600415,
-0.7891988158,
0.2949536145,
-0.5579843521,
0.5683531761,
-0.2428833842,
-0.4164321423,
0.2202029228,
-0.2338720709,
0.3839930594,
-0.1223432273,
-0.1035672352,
-0.6746694446,
0.0162837263,
-0.3128930032,
-0.8626323342,
-0.1028318778,
0.1248115301,
-0.6162431836,
0.668361485,
0.7711378336,
-0.5690156221,
0.6350600123,
-0.4926354885,
-0.2527160048,
0.5725499392,
-0.1981814951,
-0.4470626414,
-0.003766977,
-0.0785755888,
0.4878337979,
-0.159978658,
0.2047730833,
0.1300241798,
-0.2683348656,
0.3767560422,
0.2856838107,
0.5001763105,
0.2305026054,
-0.620506525,
0.3391937315,
-0.1897960752,
0.1184358597,
-0.0731936768,
-0.2730132937,
0.0467454791,
0.0917844772,
0.1193212122,
-0.0038416835,
0.2656536102,
-0.4152498245,
0.2593511343,
0.0957254991,
0.3001405895,
0.4583618045,
0.3700236678,
0.5782599449,
-0.1638615727,
0.2606117725,
0.0844837949,
0.2795172036,
-0.5998408198,
-0.3777469695,
-0.4045183063,
-0.0138436202,
0.4623095095,
0.2752481997,
-0.5260278583,
0.4876144528,
-0.5375032425,
-0.6568050385,
-0.0337302685,
0.0057686772,
0.4930820763,
0.3834712803,
0.3055121601,
-0.7038366795,
-0.1620614678,
-0.6973193884,
-0.3553487062,
-0.3313834965,
0.0414743759,
0.350435853,
0.6511561871,
-0.425706774,
1.3406783342,
-0.5615808368,
-0.2372416705,
-0.1559528857,
0.1409164965,
-0.0009119121,
0.6027575135,
0.8064358234,
-0.8671585917,
-0.4249503613,
0.0670914873,
-0.503765285,
0.2779758573,
-0.4652277529,
-0.2104833424,
0.358384788,
0.2369996607,
-0.2806114852,
0.3786588311,
0.5052208304,
-0.5846803784,
0.6972301006,
0.0845815092,
0.4875540733,
-1.1696087122,
0.026871033,
-0.0205876771,
-0.6038721204,
-0.5932999253,
0.3936500549,
0.6849325299,
-0.2503409982,
-0.7188732624,
0.1766808331,
-0.4434084594,
-0.183343485,
-0.2174735963,
0.2558654547,
-0.2324355841,
0.1720105559,
-0.0441075563,
0.6492823958,
0.4581067264,
-0.7600303292,
0.1880725324,
0.3136595786,
-0.1627921313,
0.7013087869,
-0.3715782464,
0.2261963338,
0.0588200949,
0.7364402413,
-0.6206889749,
-0.5990927219,
0.1183269769,
-0.7365800738,
0.2632637918,
-0.457828939,
-0.4744515121,
-0.4387711585,
-0.148608461,
0.0260060001,
0.7026617527,
-0.240103662,
0.3326497972,
0.2965640128,
0.1425168812,
-0.2903705537,
-0.7324393392,
0.3441977799,
-0.0341611616,
-0.8993846774,
0.3769336045,
-0.006248537,
0.037957523,
-0.079545781,
-0.2147865742,
-0.0938181058,
-0.0016253483,
0.3230024576,
0.1102788523,
-0.1175167561,
-0.0915108398,
0.1441894025,
-0.1971780509,
-0.0104253162,
-0.6060448289,
0.4231129587,
-0.2826001942,
-0.3283901811,
-0.4144646227,
0.5189859867,
0.6164436936,
-0.061604958,
0.739359498,
0.5536442995,
-0.2456110567,
-0.164134711,
-0.3635680079,
-0.7029486895,
-0.4404580295,
0.2939910889,
-0.148530066,
-0.9341845512,
0.8521894813,
-0.540088892,
0.1885549128,
0.2687475681,
0.702542901,
-0.0620790944,
0.6016749144,
0.636141479,
-0.0242856797,
0.7209231257,
-0.403132081,
-0.09919893,
-0.8750370145,
0.0167051144,
-0.4486140907,
-0.0431101136,
-0.2891074717,
-0.1831763983,
0.328168273,
0.4989134669,
-0.3395174146,
0.9537323117,
-0.8425804973,
0.2815364003,
0.4774977565,
-0.115764685,
-0.0390419513,
-0.5150434375,
0.1928581446,
0.0028730079,
-0.6338689327,
-0.5229632854,
0.963896811,
0.0517837778,
0.3486970663,
0.3171765506,
1.0421358347,
0.3627343774,
0.5385546088,
-0.4474853575,
0.4323765934,
0.3405102491,
-0.6798272133,
-0.3359023035,
-0.7422258258,
-0.9631391168,
-0.0002979986,
0.0352159068,
-0.7450487018,
-0.1382557452,
0.2893325686,
0.0300392658,
0.1693917066,
-0.6287066936,
0.9070270658,
0.3862181008,
-0.0985067934,
-0.0983137637,
-0.7090101838,
0.2657298446,
-0.2596921921,
0.4464395046,
0.052162718,
0.073972106,
0.4249775708,
-0.7806278467,
0.775415659,
-0.4023319483,
-0.1158932224,
0.6895323396,
0.8536484838,
0.93478477,
0.4719436765,
-0.0180864856,
0.0345297679,
-0.1826272905,
-0.2500844896,
-0.4137434959,
0.7341820598,
-0.4972901344,
-0.4780997634,
-0.0748731866,
-0.6470583677,
0.2780584097,
0.52159971,
0.5388613939,
0.6144462824,
-0.228948459,
0.134092778,
-0.0606601201,
0.092418544,
0.8038675785,
0.5853483677,
-0.1796016246,
-0.528085649,
0.7810966969,
0.0923123509,
0.4200006723,
0.1748003811,
0.0203428976,
0.0985180363,
-0.6889198422,
-0.6698441505,
-0.0339043252,
-0.9107539654,
-0.6350321174,
-0.2215696424,
0.125520274,
-0.6262273192,
-0.6805843115,
-0.6630633473,
-0.5109207034,
-0.0574764647,
0.4306655824,
0.4047487378,
0.8506150842,
-0.0538026951,
0.3890704215,
-1.1569424868,
-0.1213487014,
-0.0004952006,
0.2540213466,
-0.3080174923,
-0.1361020207,
-0.6129655838,
0.3238323331,
-0.5464009643,
-1.2320075035,
0.4336604178,
-0.1512745619,
0.2099345326,
-0.1532070637,
0.2219116241,
0.3160480559,
-0.3875717223,
1.246696353,
0.3681111336,
-1.4421094656,
1.0681114197,
-0.7535701394,
0.4125361145,
0.5848771334,
0.0129448492,
-0.8742293119,
-1.0597106218,
-0.6046741009,
-0.7222463489,
0.5677487254,
0.7374963164,
0.1308328211,
-0.2309953868,
0.7399371266,
0.0768813938,
0.0513812266,
-0.6787036061,
-0.362645179,
-0.6792901754,
0.1857030988,
0.1758833379,
0.2037146837,
-0.1002689824,
0.2186501622,
0.4671085477,
-0.4539468288,
0.4199725688,
0.2626626194,
-0.2142527997,
-0.269636929,
0.1520384401,
0.6626441479,
0.6869549751,
-0.2098551691,
-0.197215274,
-0.0189122427,
-0.7400156856,
-0.0161313303,
-0.302808851,
-0.2723661065,
0.1245610416,
0.425357908,
0.3050585985,
-0.1080568582,
-0.0728197321,
0.7139405608,
-0.1168237031,
-0.1764394194,
-0.2405590266,
0.1309628934,
0.3097738624,
-0.0451865941,
0.4339713454,
0.2452635765,
0.1441656947,
-0.5593200922,
0.3217336833,
0.2515033185,
-0.6764675379,
-0.3711079359,
0.7664801478,
0.4521631896,
-0.3661725223,
0.7250289321,
-0.4620739818,
-0.4078192115,
0.9710178375,
0.5933305025,
0.7731106281,
-0.2026762515,
0.349663198,
0.404759258,
0.16389893,
0.2133410424,
0.0260858499,
0.05672694,
-0.558924973,
-0.5363248587,
-0.0687992722,
-0.7736152411,
-0.3465492129,
-0.7093548179,
0.4619035721,
-0.3321831822,
-0.3021095693,
-0.0344246626,
-0.1318808049,
-0.4342974424,
0.0546749756,
-0.108291395,
0.7549623847,
-0.5523466468,
0.7217165232,
0.7120870948,
-0.6766018867,
-0.8277575374,
0.0614516698,
0.3170185685,
-0.1567043215,
0.5541671515,
0.3089846373,
-0.0259641167,
0.0361197405,
-0.3621005416,
-0.7689584494,
1.4073932171,
0.3205657303,
-0.6450628638,
0.5057618022,
-0.0134865986,
0.261449635,
-0.6151499152,
0.2902263403,
0.2006088942,
0.4528870583,
0.1003656015,
-0.739159286,
0.364328295,
-0.1459078491,
0.0227731168,
0.7201094627,
-0.666007936,
0.7238520384,
-0.1198425665,
-0.5798624158,
-0.1491932422,
0.7622331977,
0.3545182943,
0.1669223607,
0.2130526751,
-0.0559026413,
0.6887325048,
-0.2247841209,
1.5086147785,
-0.7279516459,
0.6276559234,
0.906488359,
-0.3254840076,
0.4624159634,
0.358846128,
0.2735368907,
0.9591223001,
0.6835546494,
0.1977505535,
0.4430216551,
0.2077134401,
-0.0500538126,
-0.096455954,
0.079158783,
-0.4546532333,
0.0485410653,
0.3128052354,
0.0163523797,
-0.1228325143,
-0.0936047807,
0.2283779383,
0.1179449707,
-0.2900051475,
0.8761515021,
-0.0755307227,
-0.7552019358,
0.542414248,
0.0171854049,
0.3979250491,
-0.4842503369,
0.096308358,
-0.3532333374,
0.2587985992,
-0.2359543145,
-0.8798874021,
0.6092126966,
-0.0536034517,
-0.1903005838,
-0.2318523377,
0.5515892506,
-0.0949187353,
-0.1324269325,
0.2357928455,
0.2066408247,
0.1681802273,
-0.179858163,
-0.4495714307,
0.1799047589,
-0.0223634839,
-0.2994423807,
0.1824755371,
0.4196342528,
-0.0985924378,
0.4615960717,
0.4836152196,
-0.0703735501,
-0.1701527387,
0.1920042485,
1.0879493952,
-0.7721959352,
-0.7589717507,
-0.6740288734,
0.9312810302,
-0.2194665074,
-0.3489905298,
0.8465422392,
0.6975979805,
0.449207902,
-0.1268484443,
0.6775470972,
-0.2464038283,
0.1073272452,
-0.3402669728,
0.6548906565,
-0.0907175988,
0.1990252733,
-0.4701772034,
-1.33983922,
-0.5166760087,
0.1200940683,
0.0924567953,
0.000614729,
1.1275174618,
0.6825422645,
0.1198670045,
0.1197531223,
0.0165918358,
-0.2206467688,
0.830688417,
0.6662666798,
0.6839771271,
-0.616602242,
0.6738418341,
-0.1012154967,
-0.4078252316,
-0.3200913966,
-1.1322636604,
-0.7725538015,
-0.8432287574,
-0.623878479,
-0.6759113073,
-0.2103051543,
0.2846440673,
0.9945756793,
-0.5638949871,
-0.0650984496,
-0.7002384067,
0.0645259693,
-0.3961431384,
-0.2659500241,
0.2033519298,
-0.6221876144,
-0.3162864745,
0.3896466494,
0.248576656,
0.1096709967,
-0.2564730048,
-0.3135925233,
0.4342194498,
0.0341832303,
0.2330134511,
0.0789101124,
-0.3799292445,
-0.6604195833,
0.0009481392,
-0.4033078849,
-0.0065628113,
1.1720306873,
-0.6305346489,
0.073293902,
0.420245707,
0.2920949161,
0.8220383525,
-0.244648695,
0.7615945339,
-0.9072813988,
-0.0614589117,
0.3493122756,
0.3793407977,
0.3621791899,
-0.8703211546,
0.5573549867,
-0.0159310475,
-0.7730793953,
-0.5987161994,
0.6342105865,
-0.8100809455,
-0.5616313815,
1.0608531237,
-0.1643402129,
-0.2888396084,
-0.1385494173,
-0.1052543297,
0.2586039901,
-0.6267852187,
0.4920341074,
0.4805929661,
-0.0344489589,
0.1485619098,
-0.1142142266,
0.4345280528,
0.2806894779,
-0.972566545,
0.3720112741,
0.7925198078,
0.1682706773,
0.6525963545,
0.6549903154,
-0.31770432,
0.7038388252,
0.3601836562,
0.3386976421,
-0.2016290873,
-0.2912309766,
-0.0917752162,
0.2808921337,
-0.1673257351,
0.1251966804
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01830v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01830v2
|
PiCO: Peer Review in LLMs based on the Consistency Optimization
| 2024-02-02T18:49:26 | 2024-04-20T09:09:38 |
Kun-Peng Ning, Shuo Yang, Yu-Yang Liu, Jia-Yu Yao, Zhen-Hui Liu, Yu Wang, Ming Pang, Li Yuan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Existing large language models (LLMs) evaluation methods typically focus on
testing the performance on some closed-environment and domain-specific
benchmarks with human annotations. In this paper, we explore a novel
unsupervised evaluation direction, utilizing peer-review mechanisms to measure
LLMs automatically. In this setting, both open-source and closed-source LLMs
lie in the same environment, capable of answering unlabeled questions and
evaluating each other, where each LLM's response score is jointly determined by
other anonymous ones. To obtain the ability hierarchy among these models, we
assign each LLM a learnable capability parameter to adjust the final ranking.
We formalize it as a constrained optimization problem, intending to maximize
the consistency of each LLM's capabilities and scores. The key assumption
behind is that high-level LLM can evaluate others' answers more accurately than
low-level ones, while higher-level LLM can also achieve higher response scores.
Moreover, we propose three metrics called PEN, CIN, and LIS to evaluate the gap
in aligning human rankings. We perform experiments on multiple datasets with
these metrics, validating the effectiveness of the proposed approach.
|
[
-0.3568795025,
-0.4415465593,
0.7244249582,
0.365516305,
-0.244473055,
0.3056882322,
-0.8112015128,
-0.2361610383,
0.0682335943,
0.2624236941,
-0.2154560685,
-0.6311351061,
-0.6768065095,
0.234245792,
-0.0666920468,
0.8417423964,
-0.1273140013,
0.2420342416,
-0.592576623,
-0.124905847,
-0.108022064,
-0.0790564343,
-0.240372479,
-0.396743089,
0.2051344663,
0.5515602827,
0.7458783984,
0.6184660792,
0.6356391311,
0.3377900422,
-0.0749578401,
0.1617787033,
-0.5254053473,
0.0941473693,
-0.3212670386,
-0.2616384327,
-0.5019295216,
0.1670297682,
1.0169961452,
0.8815724254,
-0.1766503006,
0.2541970611,
0.5385526419,
0.6857442856,
-0.7862177491,
0.1050490886,
-0.7302911878,
0.0010604941,
0.1265545785,
0.0510160513,
-0.2671524584,
-0.5214073062,
0.1008216813,
-0.5016951561,
0.0995289907,
0.0687651113,
0.768309772,
0.1012691036,
0.053000737,
0.0614658333,
-0.6285387278,
0.7943593264,
-0.5344640613,
0.5186138749,
0.1754575223,
0.1126923189,
-0.1888311058,
-0.3412741423,
-0.4708119333,
-0.3980817795,
0.2427438796,
0.3020496666,
-0.0179732908,
0.0523423813,
-0.2093242854,
0.5069999099,
-0.3771105707,
0.4114985466,
-0.1235490814,
-0.3791356683,
0.7002562284,
0.0556969121,
0.0149930827,
-0.0978518426,
-0.4227786064,
0.0927092135,
-0.6826375127,
0.2913772762,
0.3974078,
0.2015990615,
0.1353004426,
0.9485667348,
-0.3791021407,
0.5428838134,
-0.0473772511,
-0.1516902894,
0.145681873,
-0.4327971339,
0.0125759933,
-0.2573263943,
1.1863381863,
0.4499545097,
0.1208536774,
-0.4564751089,
-0.5553970337,
-0.0563261546,
0.150840342,
-0.6167849302,
-0.0427239984,
0.2197670192,
-0.4142377973,
-0.3354391754,
0.2644025981,
-0.7274929285,
-0.4038022757,
-0.2285060883,
0.5737928152,
-0.0136010731,
-0.0690052062,
0.1457284838,
0.2033608705,
0.0095518529,
0.3408216834,
-0.6569471955,
0.5605515242,
0.9063427448,
0.8654593825,
-0.5667698383,
-0.4787364602,
-0.6156497598,
0.0283811446,
-0.3907602727,
0.6785900593,
-0.4674831629,
-0.2499407828,
-0.2195341587,
-0.0402869135,
0.0017988961,
-0.4690707624,
0.5915265083,
-0.440451175,
0.2845725119,
-0.1317237467,
-0.7589162588,
0.2606525719,
0.3781579435,
-0.35808146,
0.9790691137,
0.1098690107,
-0.8537377119,
0.376134783,
-0.5537928939,
0.0499201566,
0.2407789081,
-0.1007771641,
-0.5784264207,
0.1205855384,
0.2577804625,
0.4184989333,
-0.5691839457,
0.3659305871,
-0.3832117319,
-0.6465123296,
0.1628555059,
-0.1088498458,
0.6345155239,
0.1092026904,
-0.4279544055,
0.4880980849,
-0.4102793634,
0.3258509636,
0.0182932727,
-0.6683377624,
-0.2145905495,
0.1505244523,
-0.35961321,
-0.2634333074,
0.5352134109,
-1.0272005796,
0.1863773614,
-0.4020895064,
0.4621197283,
0.9143441916,
-0.026751915,
0.485751003,
-0.3143930435,
0.4630730152,
-0.3643270433,
0.5795863271,
0.3048480749,
-0.4659720659,
-0.7759097815,
-0.2613964677,
0.4237633049,
0.4316929281,
-0.32268852,
0.940803647,
-0.3421420455,
-0.6313647628,
-0.7866802216,
0.5717888474,
0.5555866957,
0.3629389405,
0.0690090954,
-0.4980741143,
-0.1331284493,
-0.8632756472,
-0.1752479225,
-0.4639854431,
-0.2030302137,
0.482349813,
0.1993268877,
-0.244699806,
0.8012697697,
-0.3251362145,
-0.3353438079,
-0.1799732298,
-0.1401458532,
0.2882505059,
0.3389347494,
0.0238746144,
-0.3553504944,
-0.348614037,
-0.0547217727,
-0.4826074839,
-0.43766132,
0.2838079333,
-0.0366722569,
0.0734489188,
0.4471146166,
-0.2014085054,
-0.0223779678,
0.6739053726,
-0.0131192207,
0.610614121,
-0.3608746827,
0.2017955482,
-0.7399288416,
-0.0447074585,
-0.0452823415,
-0.1298014522,
0.0362017415,
0.2888711691,
0.1725023836,
-0.122575365,
-0.168876037,
0.4440202713,
-0.6275879145,
-0.4571759999,
-0.1004906595,
0.6261920929,
0.0729366466,
0.3808758259,
-0.0229685102,
0.7373729348,
0.7931664586,
-0.2634289861,
0.5391370654,
-0.0068865232,
-0.6423559189,
0.3641541004,
-0.9424591064,
0.3330495656,
-0.0657062829,
-0.0636967495,
-1.2424241304,
0.0274109486,
0.0405616276,
-0.3265245259,
-0.0637972206,
-0.1715084016,
-0.7389557958,
-0.2586568892,
-0.6131458879,
0.3298411369,
0.4357712865,
-0.451759696,
0.2290862203,
0.5425907373,
-0.1445270628,
-0.5418121219,
-0.0209236853,
0.0361995175,
0.0911585912,
-0.5923988819,
0.331287533,
-0.306109339,
-0.1906311065,
-0.0381728262,
-0.0736063123,
0.2436457574,
-0.0155648235,
0.2761783898,
0.3575182259,
-0.0930141285,
-0.0239901412,
0.0197912846,
0.124146387,
0.0115803378,
-0.289151907,
0.3344544172,
-0.55114609,
-0.5416871309,
-0.4306973815,
0.0273677409,
0.5208874345,
-0.3712831438,
0.4122829735,
0.2813431323,
-0.1079616994,
-0.2125994265,
-0.7160323262,
-0.1545327753,
-0.480355829,
0.1722085476,
-0.3313785195,
-1.1073720455,
0.4701521695,
-0.170111984,
0.1265592724,
0.1830194592,
0.6148005724,
-0.0457378738,
0.9133533835,
0.6696087122,
-0.0639190823,
0.155469358,
-0.0777667835,
-0.0488602258,
-1.0932217836,
-0.5729725957,
-0.5492112637,
-0.344289422,
-0.6030961871,
-0.4205879867,
0.6020681262,
0.4514465928,
-0.1506277025,
0.2382161915,
-0.618522048,
0.7797315121,
0.4623141885,
0.1783098727,
0.5613005757,
-0.132442385,
-0.7365051508,
-0.0828560963,
-0.5934040546,
-0.5873610377,
1.3088864088,
0.5578690171,
0.8211793303,
0.0593725927,
0.7750141621,
0.0056314571,
0.4728449285,
-0.8870641589,
0.7514002919,
-0.0716223568,
-0.214732796,
-0.6436145306,
-0.4605843723,
-0.8642875552,
0.4095161557,
-0.3412890434,
-0.7248363495,
-0.0424503759,
-0.2839441597,
0.040362075,
0.277928561,
-0.452704221,
0.666564405,
-0.3736203611,
-0.5525159836,
-0.0816134512,
-0.4868439436,
0.2148185521,
-0.1558316648,
0.046102386,
-0.2193382531,
-0.4219346941,
0.6945259571,
-0.3431072235,
0.5965212584,
-0.0200791154,
0.0099062435,
0.1830657423,
0.1607299894,
0.3267406821,
0.3157257438,
-0.1913917065,
0.3426584303,
-0.0834595487,
-0.318941921,
-0.5566657186,
0.9903739095,
-1.0889817476,
-0.7666115165,
-0.3235920966,
-0.4631283581,
-0.4616666436,
0.3660007119,
0.2340682298,
-0.0773167685,
-0.2728334367,
0.2429336458,
0.5881979465,
-0.1808962375,
0.328638047,
0.8827828169,
-0.2999177277,
-0.4428907633,
0.4574305713,
-0.1901496947,
0.1908814311,
0.3690133393,
0.5524890423,
-0.4818382859,
-0.9583931565,
-0.3000726998,
0.3979699314,
-0.5104405284,
-0.1274233609,
-0.3805746138,
-0.1211020947,
-0.4565314651,
0.0636794567,
-0.6022946835,
-0.2261971086,
0.0184740797,
0.1203135177,
-0.1756517589,
0.7445244193,
-0.080717057,
-0.0141083002,
-0.5652500987,
0.1635645032,
0.3391043246,
0.8705608845,
-0.1443221122,
-0.5783225894,
0.0005427287,
-0.1204022318,
-0.3403369784,
-0.6246374249,
-0.1322883666,
0.213091597,
0.7740784287,
0.3512923717,
0.1953756064,
0.4034697413,
-0.5456742048,
0.5146139264,
0.1560983509,
-1.0960979462,
0.6696728468,
-0.2384806126,
0.2083024532,
0.771268785,
0.3732458055,
-0.3156883717,
-0.7407181859,
-0.3960256279,
-0.5988003016,
0.3461123109,
0.1971672922,
0.0307597015,
0.1298574358,
0.5763192773,
0.0933748856,
0.1176147461,
-0.8034173846,
0.0558284186,
0.0465737134,
0.1784712076,
-0.0732841194,
-0.1741711795,
-0.3225549459,
-0.3382158279,
0.527141273,
-0.1192324832,
0.0876447558,
0.2386202812,
0.0445095301,
-0.3420178294,
0.3774960339,
0.3122208118,
1.0006139278,
-0.3109127283,
0.1324674934,
-0.1244723573,
-0.3436245322,
0.1854104251,
-0.134248063,
-0.1090105623,
-0.1373117417,
0.3306395113,
0.3388726413,
0.1667536646,
-0.7643551826,
0.8877087831,
-0.0551338717,
-0.1114945784,
-0.225839898,
0.1624619663,
0.0261095744,
0.2389150858,
0.1979459375,
-0.1268234849,
-0.0132351164,
-0.4663862288,
0.2593286335,
0.662289381,
-0.3464015722,
-0.1754470021,
0.6810774803,
0.2806499004,
-0.2948063314,
0.6491420865,
-0.1973252445,
-0.4401147962,
0.3781774044,
0.3520469069,
0.7695345283,
-0.270052284,
0.3295541108,
0.2605372071,
0.5390253663,
-0.1702942997,
0.2967596054,
-0.0848379135,
-0.892903626,
-0.4806518555,
-0.7409280539,
-0.7273799181,
0.1523444504,
-0.7029814124,
0.2993549109,
-0.7823431492,
-0.129843235,
-0.0873852,
0.2689396143,
-0.2954600155,
-0.0595554933,
-0.2216017991,
0.7467109561,
-0.6727609634,
0.785164535,
0.7195436954,
-0.1302843094,
-0.5788854957,
-0.0167200956,
-0.2274877131,
-0.9698638916,
0.4679454565,
0.0013629969,
-0.2913981378,
-0.2015766352,
-0.4721128047,
-0.7105385661,
1.0345458984,
0.619692564,
-0.8811206818,
0.306505084,
-0.0501676127,
0.6826051474,
-0.5315878987,
0.1036671698,
0.2740533054,
0.3320404589,
-0.0658108369,
-1.2323049307,
-0.0478759333,
-0.1965823025,
0.1647328585,
0.1393582523,
-0.7618427277,
0.5432402492,
-0.5426759124,
-0.1013101712,
0.2449897379,
0.5236569047,
0.5986884236,
0.1148972809,
0.5977317095,
0.541046083,
0.7031522989,
-0.106018506,
0.9527936578,
-0.3399838507,
0.5706896186,
1.0278811455,
-0.3449973464,
0.9809293151,
0.4577720165,
-0.2441831231,
0.4066224992,
0.6025922894,
-0.2407632321,
0.4405143261,
0.5766300559,
-0.1895547509,
-0.3123064041,
-0.1721976101,
0.0002000772,
0.5202066302,
-0.1179627404,
-0.2800745368,
-0.0363534801,
-0.1453781426,
-0.0242046937,
0.4311080277,
-0.3355756402,
0.7410206199,
-0.1757474691,
-0.7571613193,
0.590896368,
0.4134881198,
0.6650544405,
-0.4011719525,
0.2417001873,
-0.3943129778,
0.1339171827,
-0.1528809816,
-1.0156012774,
-0.0758235157,
0.0386089832,
-0.0638412908,
-0.1078585386,
0.4160149097,
-0.4135179818,
-0.5493213534,
0.4173316658,
0.5129270554,
0.337243408,
0.0410716794,
-0.812592566,
0.3346701264,
-0.2841419578,
-0.1467840075,
0.3865173459,
0.2211557478,
-0.061563652,
0.8920153379,
0.4142486453,
0.5007815361,
-0.1686650515,
0.3019640446,
0.8604691625,
-0.1307538003,
-0.4602270722,
-0.6885723472,
0.0492117517,
0.0242077168,
-0.2606951296,
0.7591512799,
0.7922065258,
0.9228825569,
0.2342510223,
0.5134193897,
0.2980439961,
0.4646968842,
-0.3806179762,
0.6659047008,
-0.4511853158,
0.6159030795,
-0.4769022465,
-1.5907827616,
-0.1847599596,
0.5401755571,
-0.2324849069,
0.07188306,
0.6179805994,
0.7157450318,
0.0121175135,
-0.2505966723,
0.3398603499,
0.1287440062,
0.0932957157,
0.7653844953,
0.7831090093,
-0.2394512594,
0.4544984996,
-0.3885300756,
-0.6127670407,
0.1800227761,
-1.0532810688,
-0.866535306,
-0.5596721768,
-0.5169061422,
-0.2764596641,
0.0422294699,
0.6410216093,
0.6484943032,
-0.705830574,
-0.5994129777,
0.0426017344,
0.2914928198,
-0.127112329,
-0.2384740412,
0.4760899544,
-0.404102385,
-0.970576942,
0.4384542108,
0.4745119512,
-0.2217496783,
-0.7081951499,
-0.204029724,
0.0911596864,
-0.0784041509,
0.3245825469,
-0.0297664087,
-0.8655652404,
-0.3362847567,
0.0803165734,
-0.0910518467,
-0.0440533236,
0.8219168186,
-0.6507828832,
0.7359916568,
0.541052103,
0.6771947145,
0.1541296691,
0.0742920041,
0.4309039712,
-0.7453298569,
-0.1247361973,
0.368101269,
0.4033772945,
0.448361218,
-0.3388918936,
0.5052400827,
0.1864287704,
-0.8155016303,
-0.7837467194,
0.143519178,
-1.0225778818,
-0.2260079384,
1.1553034782,
-0.4468476474,
0.0717904866,
-0.0122829126,
0.1388319582,
-0.0960575715,
-0.305629015,
1.0145368576,
0.7590323687,
-0.3424172401,
-0.2984698415,
-0.1900737733,
0.2287868708,
0.4692452848,
-0.6765280962,
0.0031642015,
0.3843430877,
0.6433730125,
0.1309743971,
0.6302785873,
-0.5909097791,
0.116153188,
-0.5814577341,
0.0493791811,
-0.2013580799,
-0.4195973277,
-0.3944033384,
0.2078605443,
0.4496525228,
-0.1010276526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01629v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01629v1
|
Position Paper: Generalized grammar rules and structure-based generalization beyond classical equivariance for lexical tasks and transduction
| 2024-02-02T18:44:37 | 2024-02-02T18:44:37 |
Mircea Petrache, Shubhendu Trivedi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ML
|
Compositional generalization is one of the main properties which
differentiates lexical learning in humans from state-of-art neural networks. We
propose a general framework for building models that can generalize
compositionally using the concept of Generalized Grammar Rules (GGRs), a class
of symmetry-based compositional constraints for transduction tasks, which we
view as a transduction analogue of equivariance constraints in physics-inspired
tasks. Besides formalizing generalized notions of symmetry for language
transduction, our framework is general enough to contain many existing works as
special cases. We present ideas on how GGRs might be implemented, and in the
process draw connections to reinforcement learning and other areas of research.
|
[
0.2971799374,
-0.6233914495,
0.8946769834,
0.2570039928,
-0.1849793941,
-0.0221507922,
-0.0604617819,
-0.0964136049,
0.2819672227,
0.2160516828,
-0.5580162406,
-0.7265205979,
-0.4916705191,
0.0135509307,
-0.3509212434,
0.8176962733,
-0.1901177019,
0.2946372032,
-0.5441227555,
0.2371500283,
-0.3181203008,
-0.7598382235,
-0.2557711601,
-0.4649917185,
0.3137604892,
-0.0774141029,
0.6590763927,
0.847735703,
0.3019443452,
0.3780790567,
-0.1945522428,
0.2567804158,
-0.0916965306,
0.2051171809,
-0.5862801671,
-0.5627064109,
-0.3038086295,
-0.1928199977,
0.7549927831,
0.9706027508,
-0.5206186771,
-0.0607616045,
0.0341934748,
0.4413255751,
-0.6266938448,
0.5549765229,
-0.2474998683,
0.3622334898,
0.2885030806,
0.1855555028,
-0.2197919786,
-0.2120519131,
0.0776068419,
-0.903142333,
0.3153762817,
-0.0787741393,
0.7806882262,
-0.0530683063,
-0.3505136073,
-0.4229672253,
-0.9140940905,
0.834918499,
-0.2118655294,
0.5680494308,
0.4814829528,
0.1757900268,
-0.2791168988,
-0.8517548442,
-0.0455606505,
-0.0748021975,
-0.5397228599,
-0.0152305178,
-0.1813380271,
0.587721169,
0.2971577346,
0.4436629117,
-0.6538835764,
-0.6446723938,
-0.2699353695,
-0.3283692002,
0.3081691265,
0.313603878,
0.679472506,
0.1737062335,
0.2454152703,
0.0272433199,
-0.4399457276,
0.1382865608,
0.3993660808,
0.2505094409,
-0.3697229624,
0.2646968663,
-0.3081303537,
0.9316560626,
0.1922959089,
0.0703658685,
0.1397179663,
-0.6950643659,
-0.3809117377,
-0.2450501919,
0.4952099025,
-0.1707522571,
0.2878612578,
-0.7592433691,
-0.0072290497,
0.41111359,
0.3074918985,
-0.6111166477,
0.0239870586,
-0.3268252015,
-0.4929752648,
-0.1368723363,
0.3480875492,
-0.5305658579,
0.1277671754,
-0.7550355196,
0.5091381669,
-0.1692689806,
-0.1349774897,
0.5526888967,
-0.3082897067,
0.2906213403,
-0.0737889782,
-1.5664192438,
0.7566788197,
0.9085163474,
0.9065554738,
0.1636546254,
-0.2031446844,
-0.4393030703,
0.6942236423,
-0.1524567306,
0.4729409814,
-1.040320158,
-0.6499215961,
0.0594341978,
-0.0705869719,
-0.3338127434,
-0.2861002088,
0.6345627308,
-0.0915889144,
0.625220716,
-0.5178516507,
-0.4566158354,
-0.0887491331,
0.1951934695,
-0.2971049249,
0.207983613,
0.2822588086,
-0.2751546204,
0.1725743264,
-0.2895673513,
-0.863673985,
-0.3630270958,
-0.5090183616,
-0.2617135644,
0.5069532394,
0.1085030362,
0.1585243046,
-0.2624341547,
0.5156775713,
-0.3190924823,
-0.3245972395,
-0.3322738111,
0.3235929906,
0.5577222109,
0.2488944381,
-0.1917921901,
0.1050083339,
-0.5963003635,
0.350161612,
-0.1383656114,
-0.425455749,
-0.3694007099,
0.4627169967,
-0.5623803139,
0.0636919439,
-0.1529454589,
-0.4669078887,
0.2810155749,
-0.4877651036,
0.683475852,
0.383782655,
-0.1847508103,
0.9471375346,
-0.4249160588,
0.3465460241,
-0.0943709761,
0.2543257773,
0.0751329809,
-0.3526090384,
-0.387873441,
-0.3056547046,
0.0138620455,
0.4927140176,
-0.4253584146,
0.5385534763,
-0.1410814077,
-0.1570955366,
0.007598259,
0.1941573173,
0.5774402618,
0.4153613448,
0.4733578265,
-0.2370073646,
-0.9588853121,
-0.963467598,
-0.403380543,
-0.2950136662,
-0.1704031825,
-0.1747501642,
0.1115744784,
-0.1400903165,
0.8470265865,
-0.4351523221,
-0.2047977298,
-0.2977824807,
-0.0396011584,
0.1837144941,
0.4343945086,
0.5839856267,
-0.6563867331,
-0.2855241001,
-0.0108808605,
-0.9619135261,
-0.1118688509,
0.1214573458,
-0.3319537938,
-0.2443999797,
0.8550003171,
-0.5674178004,
0.1243139729,
0.5542619824,
-0.685870111,
0.3247920275,
-0.0749879554,
-0.2107539028,
-0.8777108192,
-0.1374519914,
0.0877629817,
-0.3490750492,
-1.0318046808,
0.2248874605,
-0.152916953,
-0.128554821,
-0.1859369725,
0.3500849605,
-0.3598137796,
-0.0892984942,
-0.1143722311,
-0.6308683157,
0.233264491,
0.4882925749,
0.1881493777,
0.2589818835,
0.8320710063,
-0.8425722718,
0.3036158681,
0.0270539168,
0.1810920984,
0.5824727416,
-1.0272041559,
-0.152350083,
-0.4943980277,
0.1724576503,
-0.7706561685,
-0.0721704066,
0.7348991036,
-0.174029991,
0.3962865174,
-0.0981023535,
-0.2002521455,
-0.0612357557,
0.0424490236,
0.383421123,
0.5629373193,
-0.0468424559,
1.318480134,
-0.0053210389,
0.190884769,
-0.3489975035,
-0.7664379478,
-0.2405394614,
-0.0462651439,
-0.5417866707,
0.6505296826,
-0.002296081,
-0.4178535342,
0.1927146912,
-0.1315493882,
-0.0040311455,
0.1305575371,
0.2464432567,
-0.0494069085,
-0.0978713036,
0.1820595264,
0.1120587513,
0.2723644078,
0.2510142028,
-0.6405421495,
0.6106979847,
-0.265625149,
-0.4221972525,
-0.1896288693,
0.4194054306,
0.2859948277,
0.0000204871,
0.3572466373,
0.4158972502,
-0.2345671505,
-0.3381004632,
-0.0781461149,
-0.0456145033,
-0.5062017441,
0.4892428219,
-0.3439421952,
-0.8608947396,
0.520001471,
0.2387915105,
-0.1617614627,
0.2714552879,
0.4596825242,
0.0117551275,
1.1948285103,
0.8231118321,
-0.1271989793,
0.7006281018,
-0.0312364083,
-0.1595081985,
-0.4595070481,
-0.2698059678,
-0.4266033173,
-0.5217705369,
-0.3595536947,
-0.272549659,
0.1699275672,
-0.0020460207,
-0.347761035,
0.0103083979,
-0.4390911162,
0.790171802,
0.4822276235,
0.1403057277,
-0.0091954833,
0.1822858751,
-0.563560009,
0.3047450185,
-0.5160115361,
-0.069709897,
1.0402864218,
0.1110385954,
0.8297719359,
0.3128061891,
0.7878167033,
0.2993809879,
-0.019716192,
-0.7756035328,
0.5248442292,
-0.3752067983,
-0.6532523632,
-0.1507772207,
-0.5241006017,
-0.7901637554,
0.5104621053,
-0.0124855954,
-0.6890933514,
0.2655317187,
0.2356233299,
-0.0911079273,
0.3445301056,
-0.8018231988,
0.5868674517,
-0.1423791796,
-0.3760657012,
-0.1076900661,
-0.4802066088,
0.311316222,
0.4459718764,
0.173549518,
0.2296414822,
-0.0411918052,
0.1540459991,
-0.2972452641,
1.1165646315,
-0.3806433976,
0.068487592,
0.4112610221,
0.0754406974,
0.4108973444,
-0.0135563081,
0.2508046031,
-0.1588600725,
0.0979515314,
-0.3535306454,
-0.6081669927,
0.2277895957,
-0.974568665,
-0.6375884414,
-0.3401844501,
-0.4801169932,
-0.5292107463,
0.0304779727,
0.291565448,
0.2416051626,
-0.6021932364,
-0.0162271801,
0.6405601501,
0.1849012822,
0.3130041659,
0.1948634535,
-0.3612703681,
-0.6573368311,
0.895334363,
-0.2299700826,
0.2026601434,
0.640160799,
0.4686564207,
-0.2282518446,
-0.3468085825,
-0.1622475684,
0.3785687387,
-0.5625134706,
0.1272657663,
-0.4432012439,
-0.2238131911,
-0.5275613666,
-0.1759774238,
0.1254624873,
-0.3837529421,
-0.5201563835,
0.0499642156,
-0.4554833472,
0.9205075502,
-0.21839647,
0.322545439,
-0.5525271297,
0.450212121,
0.8700864911,
0.4857867062,
-0.1986914128,
-0.4089260697,
-0.2623983324,
0.1762886792,
-0.4957279861,
-0.651458025,
-0.0085821738,
0.735947907,
0.9831443429,
0.2858280838,
-0.6916955113,
0.3471669257,
-0.4561442435,
0.5215793848,
0.4294517934,
-1.3892879486,
0.2112183422,
-0.6107887626,
0.2600786984,
0.1636433303,
0.1857089102,
-0.9844777584,
-0.2660723925,
-0.3941631019,
-0.3854708672,
0.3133041263,
-0.0378793217,
0.3914407492,
-0.1386324465,
0.7024723887,
-0.0779686645,
0.4747120738,
-0.7870336175,
0.0475706197,
-0.6135773063,
-0.3993322551,
-0.1587596536,
-0.2082571387,
-0.2250125557,
-0.4643706679,
0.3502573669,
-0.292725116,
0.301546514,
0.3479845226,
-0.3700599968,
-0.1797516197,
0.530031383,
1.0380562544,
0.5535370111,
0.0820775032,
0.1318787634,
-0.2070710063,
-0.3841356933,
0.6880514026,
-0.2276833951,
-0.5575339198,
-0.1527826935,
0.3716134727,
0.6442834735,
0.2948646247,
-0.0570347235,
0.3209044635,
-0.2023450881,
-0.9639677405,
0.1723203063,
0.4143670499,
0.0777646825,
0.2866173387,
0.0263384171,
-0.3032566607,
0.1522424966,
-0.7653158307,
0.01315891,
0.6223961115,
-0.2479597628,
-0.9408910871,
0.613999784,
-0.039269127,
0.2153040022,
0.1286701262,
-0.3781937957,
-0.3886258602,
0.4904247522,
0.8472245932,
1.1463803053,
-0.258890152,
0.506981194,
0.294688493,
0.1522695124,
-0.5610191226,
0.7010885477,
-0.0032886511,
-0.7680826783,
-0.5295636654,
-0.7272905111,
-0.4589990079,
-0.2282205671,
-0.4082780778,
0.2100281119,
-1.0861645937,
-0.039814014,
-0.275949657,
-0.538661778,
-0.5309986472,
0.1150774509,
0.5635460615,
0.2106660455,
-0.9663085938,
0.468758136,
1.2570489645,
-0.2296844125,
-0.611740768,
-0.3254007101,
-0.0021104701,
-0.64397192,
0.8030076027,
-0.2601706684,
-0.1462136805,
-0.2834242582,
-0.8033848405,
-1.2725239992,
0.8848228455,
0.6919000745,
-0.355099678,
-0.7040188909,
0.4161741734,
0.7554773092,
-0.4347912073,
0.0220822003,
0.4605721831,
0.527775228,
0.2007783502,
-0.7139858007,
-0.1627401263,
-0.2877246439,
0.2042879611,
0.2593607605,
-0.8448019624,
1.2549916506,
0.2034813464,
-0.3330221176,
0.0313974246,
0.7199221253,
-0.087343283,
0.0681134239,
0.1709143817,
1.0461658239,
0.5522264838,
-0.2216149569,
0.779373467,
-0.0074230651,
0.2235583514,
0.7873961926,
-0.0824683458,
-0.1632262766,
0.4169166982,
-0.2095754892,
0.9023969173,
0.090460971,
-0.1059122011,
0.8820551634,
0.7063815594,
-0.3045471609,
-0.4280708432,
-0.14912875,
-0.4073903561,
0.5131335258,
0.5361885428,
-0.6549772024,
-0.5212779045,
-0.2054232061,
0.0145169068,
0.2889019251,
-0.8024732471,
0.8245787024,
0.0130109405,
-0.6019466519,
0.3601071835,
0.0910700038,
0.6096385717,
-0.9829392433,
0.0749767125,
0.121351026,
0.2020999491,
-0.280443728,
-0.255930841,
0.5130749941,
-0.5480421782,
-0.4652218223,
-0.3055690825,
0.8626188636,
-0.5423159003,
-0.5744568706,
0.1352096349,
0.6725310087,
-0.5219270587,
0.0889038369,
-0.2861022949,
-0.1998470873,
-0.068774201,
-0.0584936067,
0.4512895644,
0.3360375762,
0.0048999721,
0.3353800476,
0.3184509575,
0.3979835212,
0.206939742,
-0.0257757939,
0.9189351201,
-0.7528262734,
-0.95558846,
-1.0184344053,
0.1868419051,
0.287823379,
-0.0101991268,
0.3148024678,
0.2810018361,
0.9157195687,
-0.2510788441,
1.0811206102,
0.0287023466,
0.2004947066,
-0.6850190163,
0.1591684967,
-0.3629023433,
-0.279294759,
-0.2960135043,
-0.9669599533,
-0.7036756277,
0.5550240874,
-0.4678399861,
0.1134672463,
0.745095849,
0.4554143548,
-0.2904777825,
0.1306006461,
0.5216474533,
-0.4286380708,
0.5920556188,
0.7846736312,
0.8909645081,
-0.051640369,
0.4635034502,
-0.1109306514,
0.312507689,
0.1277273148,
-0.7498947382,
-0.9342386127,
-0.4541145563,
-0.1107882187,
-0.0737844855,
0.2454185784,
0.8877668977,
0.7603700161,
-0.7362139225,
-0.4745914936,
-0.6116495728,
0.2433651984,
-0.2510052621,
-0.1157224178,
0.0271270126,
-0.7339287996,
-0.5032660961,
0.308778137,
0.2089280188,
0.3528326452,
0.1168862209,
-0.260279268,
-0.018688878,
0.0189289432,
0.6520860791,
0.6816323996,
-0.4408827126,
-0.4911406934,
0.0898507014,
-0.1352070272,
-0.0370142199,
1.209882617,
-0.5168920159,
0.2562670708,
0.6479568481,
0.4853517413,
0.0984796584,
0.1622302234,
0.7473407388,
-1.1504074335,
0.2438758016,
0.1162803471,
0.556430459,
0.0395860374,
-0.1713071018,
0.3423075974,
0.7191522121,
-0.3568139374,
-0.3421605527,
0.7100403309,
-0.5219426155,
-0.2134409398,
1.2320991755,
0.1332140267,
-0.5065764189,
0.0708797053,
0.2452738136,
0.2020727098,
-0.2442964911,
0.4414269626,
0.9192456007,
-0.1517318487,
0.1514948756,
0.1318865716,
0.5513764024,
0.4683994651,
-0.8644062281,
-0.0963415205,
0.809807241,
0.356754452,
0.0444699898,
0.3267964125,
-0.1160462499,
0.3641203642,
-0.2348004431,
0.1775822192,
-0.3341233134,
-0.4375993311,
-0.4313974679,
0.3929180503,
-0.0980714336,
-0.1554554701
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01829v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01829v1
|
Predicting ATP binding sites in protein sequences using Deep Learning and Natural Language Processing
| 2024-02-02T18:42:39 | 2024-02-02T18:42:39 |
Shreyas V, Swati Agarwal
|
q-bio.BM
|
q-bio.BM, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Predicting ATP-Protein Binding sites in genes is of great significance in the
field of Biology and Medicine. The majority of research in this field has been
conducted through time- and resource-intensive 'wet experiments' in
laboratories. Over the years, researchers have been investigating computational
methods computational methods to accomplish the same goals, utilising the
strength of advanced Deep Learning and NLP algorithms. In this paper, we
propose to develop methods to classify ATP-Protein binding sites. We conducted
various experiments mainly using PSSMs and several word embeddings as features.
We used 2D CNNs and LightGBM classifiers as our chief Deep Learning Algorithms.
The MP3Vec and BERT models have also been subjected to testing in our study.
The outcomes of our experiments demonstrated improvement over the
state-of-the-art benchmarks.
|
[
-0.5802996159,
-0.7453700304,
0.7702032924,
0.0048825881,
-0.0948850811,
-0.0096627371,
-0.2125589997,
-0.4861418307,
-0.1142735332,
0.3504127562,
-0.2881703973,
-0.452400893,
-1.0347263813,
0.2716340721,
-0.4646175504,
0.3833509088,
-0.300003916,
0.7720046639,
-0.3175497353,
0.0221044458,
-0.0455414131,
-0.4559110403,
0.0189524591,
-0.6219052076,
0.2246849984,
0.1413418651,
0.4973267019,
0.6002876163,
0.8688144088,
0.2941280901,
-0.1101418659,
0.0336727798,
-0.0709358305,
0.1127096936,
-0.0185468718,
-0.2360399067,
-0.1397430301,
0.2063937187,
0.3572039306,
1.0686411858,
0.1257504821,
-0.0571262091,
0.0594457649,
0.4771847427,
-0.7391106486,
0.0868935958,
-0.262839824,
0.5481336117,
-0.1291155368,
-0.7409274578,
-0.4675058126,
-0.5262588859,
0.5444267988,
0.0356900543,
0.533008337,
-0.0965403989,
0.7936378121,
0.1809618175,
-0.7366893291,
-0.2733452618,
-0.5578677058,
0.8231506348,
-0.6805949211,
0.5816190243,
0.7360519767,
0.2906780541,
-0.5493347049,
-0.5826752782,
-0.0868269131,
-0.1763464361,
-0.0397247151,
-0.3937477767,
0.1830452234,
0.3878492415,
0.1069246233,
0.4882911146,
-0.6521386504,
-0.2232512534,
-0.4986220598,
-0.0912984386,
0.4200892746,
-0.2634517252,
0.3183117211,
-0.1154915243,
-0.4604180157,
0.1911348999,
-0.4830163717,
0.1352375746,
0.0051049534,
0.3818874061,
0.3580936491,
0.792380929,
-0.1056435108,
0.7714903951,
-0.0482110865,
0.0353742726,
0.161004439,
-0.0401659235,
-0.4736758173,
0.6023983955,
0.6469768286,
0.133559525,
0.280331105,
-0.0035747827,
0.0969181284,
-0.0497586168,
0.1805637926,
-0.8805456758,
-0.4070622325,
0.3166025579,
-0.5848174691,
-0.1925470978,
-0.024311712,
-0.7034288049,
-0.3011977375,
-0.5990123749,
0.3940245211,
-0.90580374,
0.2156867087,
0.492592901,
-0.2195170671,
0.0263667312,
0.1328730136,
-0.8008950353,
0.588683486,
0.426086843,
0.8174889684,
0.0866706222,
-0.3619497418,
-0.4791789651,
0.2261643112,
0.1258944124,
0.8555089235,
-0.858843565,
-0.1098794118,
0.1023712233,
-0.2642376125,
-0.0609001964,
-0.1905703694,
0.507517159,
-0.821839869,
0.1734352261,
-0.3090088665,
-1.1836605072,
-0.454768002,
-0.022094449,
-0.4310628176,
0.6029655933,
-0.2125097215,
-0.7245032191,
0.2454300374,
-0.480352968,
-0.7196102142,
-0.0869768932,
0.0736587942,
-0.1215125844,
0.2740870416,
0.2620168328,
0.5521156192,
-0.19458884,
0.5159703493,
-0.4175812006,
-0.1406277567,
0.4630767405,
-0.0757734105,
0.4831789732,
0.3654715717,
-0.4194560647,
-0.1005440578,
-0.7210131884,
0.4122442305,
-0.1693288833,
-0.314779222,
-0.1345785409,
0.1837305278,
-0.0401155353,
0.3023464382,
-0.0075705587,
-0.4842660427,
0.6400721073,
-0.2389094979,
0.5230522156,
0.5601249337,
0.0841385648,
0.5146759748,
0.3487575352,
0.2033611685,
-0.1487224102,
0.05191347,
0.2205432057,
-0.8673268557,
-0.111594893,
0.0670594648,
0.5149340034,
0.2700015306,
-0.2592339218,
0.4690692723,
-0.3279442489,
-0.4554980695,
-0.3228892088,
0.1521942019,
0.4226711094,
0.4855020046,
0.7482135296,
-0.2488105297,
-0.4978997409,
-0.7811941504,
-0.1348560601,
0.1668039262,
-0.2461520135,
0.4920786619,
0.5874771476,
-0.3187092543,
0.8503493667,
-0.7961217761,
-0.3725767732,
-0.0955217257,
0.2999990582,
0.2050902992,
0.5017834306,
0.3709926009,
-0.9358952045,
-0.2110860646,
-0.2170843035,
-0.6353693604,
0.0122830216,
0.2604832053,
0.1773747504,
-0.3809660971,
0.1571876258,
-0.5439438224,
0.3384511769,
0.5164607167,
-0.3031000793,
0.0896916687,
-0.2778789699,
0.4011344612,
-0.3566379845,
-0.0028543971,
0.1957339644,
-0.1527887732,
-0.8652733564,
-0.19933483,
0.1550371945,
-0.2541902959,
-0.5554532409,
0.144138217,
-0.4805390835,
-0.3730582297,
-0.2776765227,
-0.2183922529,
0.2270734459,
0.5540789962,
0.2378282845,
0.4140242636,
0.5285869837,
-0.7531200051,
0.2918710113,
0.4817959368,
-0.4727734625,
-0.3211641908,
-0.5032742023,
0.0038131541,
0.1930874437,
0.4467308223,
-0.9077091217,
-0.3640640676,
0.1942885518,
-0.5714617968,
0.4961279929,
-0.3031758666,
-0.5476795435,
-0.2548119426,
-0.3846049905,
0.6755254269,
0.3647409379,
-0.5576697588,
0.3139062226,
0.6380693316,
0.1506005377,
-0.0347259901,
-0.9241510034,
-0.1766813993,
0.14197281,
-0.4755246639,
0.443621248,
0.3207574487,
0.1706035882,
-0.0085736588,
-0.0665065646,
-0.3671886325,
-0.0168739669,
0.4150441885,
-0.127848044,
-0.1532396823,
0.1036553979,
-0.0388921574,
-0.2720638514,
0.0317885429,
-0.503508091,
0.9520136118,
-0.3499336541,
-0.3257640004,
-0.5131267905,
0.3297761679,
0.543864429,
-0.496293366,
0.7528861761,
0.4882394969,
-0.6984257698,
0.1335755438,
-0.2184475064,
-0.0513142906,
-0.4674597085,
0.1339454055,
-0.0564879514,
-0.5758590102,
0.2538658977,
-0.6045824289,
-0.4605481029,
0.3303735256,
0.39511922,
-0.1293539852,
1.2944275141,
0.6214659214,
0.2399536818,
0.1344818473,
-0.6046488285,
0.356028378,
-0.9061569571,
-0.3712660074,
-0.6195430756,
-0.7665371895,
-0.3501306772,
-0.5837376118,
0.072129637,
0.3336700499,
-0.0437238365,
0.6154767275,
-0.4370453358,
0.3785565495,
0.5910742283,
0.0739248693,
-0.331315428,
0.1165167242,
-0.428037256,
-0.0415640883,
-0.5825321078,
-0.3839369118,
1.0885316133,
0.3999088705,
0.3914405107,
0.0219418034,
0.5482341647,
0.3649101257,
0.0418793708,
-0.7400038838,
0.3573978245,
-0.2748787105,
-0.4132627547,
-0.1144462451,
-0.2167648673,
-0.9695788622,
-0.1843773127,
-0.2547132969,
-0.630471468,
0.5705007911,
-0.0171792973,
-0.2216092199,
0.5140677691,
-0.5594406724,
0.731600225,
-0.5178937912,
-0.260310173,
-0.2920368612,
-0.7286017537,
0.0918573216,
0.3845056295,
0.1292960048,
-0.2700598538,
0.1058416888,
0.5042265058,
-0.4289487004,
0.4771819115,
-0.1495154947,
-0.0945364982,
0.0744935423,
0.0997448787,
0.3881283998,
-0.1156969517,
-0.3360559642,
0.4405630827,
-0.102724351,
-0.7394001484,
-0.2756174803,
0.8754296899,
-0.7058210969,
0.0225710142,
-0.6192196608,
-0.0434296876,
-0.3846500218,
0.3262035251,
0.5760689378,
0.5766835213,
0.1162745804,
0.0461952724,
0.8828617334,
-0.348772645,
0.2050022781,
0.0989962667,
-0.2743192017,
-0.3322980404,
0.7339223623,
0.1386511922,
-0.043221496,
0.7144566774,
0.2516870499,
-0.429908663,
-1.1352443695,
-0.1906776279,
-0.2532755136,
-0.5941240191,
-0.4642637372,
-0.4390925765,
-0.2026601136,
-0.5899792314,
-0.4468969107,
-0.2477763295,
-0.3451731205,
-0.2342164218,
-0.3316795826,
0.2595300078,
0.3288389146,
0.1191296652,
0.0382314622,
-1.107711792,
0.6086597443,
0.1547549516,
0.8472591639,
-0.2741174102,
-0.0566054136,
-0.1311897486,
0.0581147186,
-0.2060272694,
-1.2304885387,
0.6527109146,
0.643871963,
0.5476046801,
0.4754756391,
-0.0051976899,
0.4785074592,
-0.6391962171,
0.8024820089,
0.0651465505,
-0.8528695703,
1.1891556978,
-0.2758317292,
0.0740391016,
0.6670740247,
0.5058572888,
-0.2645380199,
-0.0721265152,
-0.6545677781,
-1.070448041,
0.5726307034,
0.4596442878,
-0.1963614821,
-0.2887564301,
0.4360636473,
0.3642253578,
0.3070178032,
-0.1416563243,
-0.4659448862,
0.0311907195,
-0.0870344788,
0.0351047032,
-0.5052461028,
-0.0260589309,
-0.2610684335,
0.6766009331,
-0.1044285148,
0.3497977257,
0.4675904214,
-0.4184105694,
-0.4947062135,
0.0368757024,
0.461596936,
0.5008121729,
-0.6707354784,
0.5488592982,
0.0377164818,
-0.4703100324,
0.1367564499,
0.1923462301,
-0.1679404974,
0.0533235371,
0.5799274445,
0.4976848662,
0.4161648452,
-0.7500655651,
0.3666903377,
-0.294393301,
-0.0015500388,
-0.283764571,
0.2298657298,
-0.1323850453,
0.1034844667,
0.3254543841,
0.5786578655,
0.6762197614,
-0.367100507,
0.3655753434,
0.0941926539,
-0.4085355401,
-0.2333445847,
0.4465726018,
0.3515830934,
-0.3373522162,
0.7511838078,
-0.0489392839,
-0.6494908333,
0.6220326424,
0.1780905724,
0.9135341644,
-0.2534502745,
-0.0751310661,
0.3945089579,
-0.3583632112,
-0.1108949035,
0.1757903695,
-0.2361433804,
-0.4343239963,
-0.3536902666,
-1.0910083055,
-0.311709553,
0.0073503437,
-0.7546916604,
0.3407359123,
-0.5989581943,
-0.2035388499,
0.4311825335,
0.5590178967,
-0.7251096368,
0.1588181257,
0.5887806416,
1.1103349924,
-0.8715038896,
1.2076895237,
0.7776091695,
-0.0863637328,
-0.0560090728,
-0.162169233,
0.1382784992,
-0.4154374301,
0.6380892992,
0.4890083969,
0.0356175341,
-0.1327941567,
-0.4353701472,
-1.099486351,
0.9327302575,
0.2578478456,
-0.632812798,
0.3698348105,
0.2366164476,
0.7041612267,
-0.0655511469,
-0.1896378845,
0.388741225,
0.5803287029,
-0.1212385222,
-0.5964958072,
-0.1225062162,
-0.4827666283,
-0.2142922729,
0.5651320815,
-0.2636462748,
0.5201362967,
-0.157398209,
0.0342229605,
0.1145863906,
0.6365224719,
0.1695440263,
0.4927006364,
0.1078503132,
0.5238201022,
0.7559275627,
-0.2265042663,
1.2938059568,
-0.3892437816,
0.6683021784,
0.6868075728,
-0.2464892864,
0.778547585,
0.560398221,
-0.6042732596,
0.2373798937,
0.8221252561,
-0.4915067255,
0.7973646522,
0.5592673421,
-0.0698488578,
-0.2761111856,
-0.2529401183,
-0.5848119259,
0.0945826173,
0.6176909208,
-0.4699413478,
-0.0976215824,
0.1387809664,
-0.4920101464,
0.0488580354,
-0.2351898402,
0.4321626127,
0.2032015473,
-0.3878609836,
0.2214604467,
0.1509334445,
0.3808135688,
-0.6705417037,
-0.2871988118,
0.111051999,
0.3813659847,
-0.3438580632,
-0.9375618696,
0.1778906584,
-0.128730312,
-0.2169750184,
-0.4810213447,
0.8732321858,
-0.403470546,
-0.5750326514,
0.6365667582,
0.0758246928,
0.0462087803,
-0.0023868897,
-0.5670713782,
-0.238730669,
-0.1001049727,
-0.3940168917,
0.6603221893,
0.4102306962,
0.3339468837,
0.7363530397,
0.7435170412,
0.1379093081,
-0.0244451649,
-0.0514398515,
0.6945947409,
-0.8897998333,
-0.0990020856,
-0.7256085873,
-0.009366584,
0.1634383649,
-0.3187396526,
0.5933805108,
0.6539635062,
0.5864049196,
-0.1951636672,
0.3604209423,
0.0450025387,
0.0462844148,
-0.6948835254,
0.4187721312,
-0.328353852,
0.4078299701,
-0.1834500134,
-0.6854203343,
-0.6726226211,
0.6093123555,
-0.2986930013,
-0.0806307122,
0.6385281086,
0.0601957329,
-0.1361479461,
0.4000095725,
-0.198988542,
0.1971137077,
0.5783717632,
0.8022757769,
0.6020798087,
-0.5974133015,
0.2780357003,
-1.0791763067,
0.1547279209,
-0.6897685528,
-0.8506445289,
-0.4774145484,
-0.5350539088,
-0.4439053833,
-0.214265883,
0.0205838084,
1.0184557438,
0.7023519874,
-1.3313548565,
0.1251098365,
-0.3939428627,
0.0782363042,
-0.4016702175,
-0.1258406192,
0.9239119887,
-0.3113321662,
-0.5122313499,
0.4785637856,
0.4836416841,
0.1004557163,
0.1190999001,
-0.1605343819,
-0.7830578089,
-0.3583349586,
0.4097972214,
0.3402298689,
-0.579991281,
-0.2529465258,
0.0348085798,
-0.220963195,
0.0567634404,
1.0108971596,
-1.0248086452,
0.1309328675,
0.8879821897,
0.5446024537,
0.2605934143,
-0.0955936015,
0.7817285657,
-0.6688357592,
-0.1534432918,
0.542473793,
0.7204295397,
0.2451547533,
-0.4381287992,
0.5216400623,
0.1054608077,
-0.610966444,
-0.678763032,
0.0372405984,
-0.9256839752,
-0.5345107913,
1.0907394886,
-0.0065705455,
-0.1146678105,
-0.1548076272,
-0.0735996664,
0.4845524132,
-0.0212463122,
1.0585788488,
0.5804440975,
-0.7115905285,
0.1618997902,
-0.551600039,
0.5549201369,
0.3891330659,
-0.4242340624,
-0.0175595749,
0.3618873656,
0.0298796967,
0.3699442148,
0.0254698489,
-0.0216791444,
0.2859580219,
-0.3169490695,
-0.1902234852,
-0.170655936,
-0.3794948757,
-0.4779621661,
0.4980036914,
-0.0986833051,
-0.0808484033
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01622v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01622v3
|
TravelPlanner: A Benchmark for Real-World Planning with Language Agents
| 2024-02-02T18:39:51 | 2024-06-23T08:50:17 |
Jian Xie, Kai Zhang, Jiangjie Chen, Tinghui Zhu, Renze Lou, Yuandong Tian, Yanghua Xiao, Yu Su
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Planning has been part of the core pursuit for artificial intelligence since
its conception, but earlier AI agents mostly focused on constrained settings
because many of the cognitive substrates necessary for human-level planning
have been lacking. Recently, language agents powered by large language models
(LLMs) have shown interesting capabilities such as tool use and reasoning. Are
these language agents capable of planning in more complex settings that are out
of the reach of prior AI agents? To advance this investigation, we propose
TravelPlanner, a new planning benchmark that focuses on travel planning, a
common real-world planning scenario. It provides a rich sandbox environment,
various tools for accessing nearly four million data records, and 1,225
meticulously curated planning intents and reference plans. Comprehensive
evaluations show that the current language agents are not yet capable of
handling such complex planning tasks-even GPT-4 only achieves a success rate of
0.6%. Language agents struggle to stay on task, use the right tools to collect
information, or keep track of multiple constraints. However, we note that the
mere possibility for language agents to tackle such a complex problem is in
itself non-trivial progress. TravelPlanner provides a challenging yet
meaningful testbed for future language agents.
|
[
-0.533845365,
-0.5453646779,
0.7185366154,
0.2342948169,
0.2482447624,
0.0891766846,
-0.1983039379,
-0.4029476941,
0.0288785286,
0.4134545028,
-0.8909683228,
-0.1969440579,
-0.2242460847,
-0.0307192039,
-0.2228230536,
0.5958412886,
-0.3499144316,
-0.3954612911,
-0.3506637812,
-0.1082840115,
-0.5504844785,
-0.6701053381,
-0.3442372978,
-0.4118926227,
0.455632329,
0.4330014586,
1.0159250498,
0.3985635638,
0.5547581315,
0.2641818821,
0.0525295772,
0.299739331,
-0.2666246891,
0.1316007525,
-0.2430896312,
-0.3291724324,
-0.4345912635,
-0.0910413787,
0.6305520535,
0.7725824714,
-0.1147826314,
-0.0847689658,
-0.6305193901,
0.3238426149,
-0.5682669282,
0.295840174,
-0.4041681588,
0.1983879209,
-0.082479991,
0.1148480624,
-0.1272785217,
-0.3485527933,
0.221195519,
-0.7156214118,
0.1937029213,
0.1739664227,
0.6179844141,
0.4419048727,
-0.3236124516,
-0.1487967819,
-1.3922476768,
0.616773963,
-0.3311740458,
0.4206952751,
0.3947222531,
0.7510745525,
-0.3890287876,
-0.6185405254,
-0.8558824658,
-0.3358431458,
0.0956725031,
-0.0110835312,
-0.0631037503,
-0.1340474635,
0.38513726,
-0.2061889917,
-0.841758132,
-0.0986320898,
-0.1950466186,
-0.1642658263,
0.6186572909,
0.2960863411,
0.3365619183,
0.4255402088,
-0.1071633324,
-0.3477236331,
-0.7858428359,
0.0561421327,
-0.0022066766,
0.1609945297,
-0.1340115219,
0.5019860864,
-0.3976904452,
0.472735852,
-0.6791051626,
-0.11479038,
0.0078697624,
-0.30853948,
-0.0489544831,
-0.1626210958,
0.3329294324,
0.3086692095,
0.6541578174,
-0.4266653955,
-0.2714974284,
-0.0201061461,
0.3199618161,
-0.7897754312,
-0.33423841,
0.2687309384,
-0.0223956835,
0.2312983871,
-0.0609237216,
-0.5203335881,
-0.1898125857,
-0.089631632,
0.0183427799,
-0.3771058321,
-0.2286588103,
0.0070529669,
-0.0260371417,
0.5441873074,
0.4427146316,
-0.4307382703,
0.428273499,
0.8944540024,
0.8018715382,
-0.0253223646,
-0.8334758878,
-0.4985809326,
0.193904236,
-0.3550957739,
1.1834882498,
-0.5923449993,
-0.7109359503,
0.2514920235,
-0.2317325622,
0.0276053492,
-0.5155608654,
0.5908195376,
-0.3992441893,
-0.1975193918,
-0.3530560732,
-0.3705137968,
-0.0427164026,
0.5894389153,
-0.6616066098,
0.6759763956,
0.1960697323,
0.1054350734,
0.4740781784,
-0.4874235392,
-0.5834882259,
0.1016878262,
-0.3952225745,
-0.264338553,
-0.2397537529,
0.0427388474,
0.067530781,
-0.3681720197,
0.508104682,
-0.2175650746,
-0.5224692822,
0.3915624917,
-0.2422650307,
0.3588291109,
0.1009734571,
-0.2025847137,
0.0634546056,
-0.515221417,
0.1081208661,
0.0236583129,
-0.4305203259,
0.0523420945,
0.3310472667,
0.1828761399,
0.4525830448,
0.3104166985,
-0.417711705,
0.5965555906,
-0.2236554772,
0.253254354,
0.6464902759,
-0.2786472738,
0.5520595312,
-0.6890365481,
0.8154891133,
-0.3667166531,
0.218364954,
-0.0358671397,
-0.3919453025,
-0.7146906257,
0.2426441908,
-0.0238573197,
0.5473002791,
-0.3786943555,
0.395219475,
-0.7501989007,
-0.6087842584,
0.0248736646,
-0.2183843106,
0.278775543,
0.1096428186,
0.3315498531,
0.0874422193,
-0.1568522453,
-0.6291596293,
-0.3243520856,
-0.1070940495,
0.1437548846,
0.4123487175,
0.5766774416,
-0.225672558,
0.9001184702,
-0.5818759799,
-0.3478576839,
-0.5483243465,
-0.0500378609,
-0.1121993884,
0.4044000804,
0.399938941,
-0.9160419106,
-0.2592790425,
-0.1300686747,
-0.5815267563,
0.0179608818,
-0.4216400981,
-0.1143226698,
-0.2475880086,
0.5757157803,
-0.8311072588,
0.294493407,
0.3434057534,
-0.5193436146,
0.5668010712,
-0.3933873475,
-0.4430621266,
-0.5143046379,
0.1461407393,
-0.4088279605,
-0.3123927414,
-0.6813486218,
0.0756501108,
-0.0034968941,
-0.3649556339,
-0.397972852,
0.8389587402,
-0.3792487681,
-0.1579782069,
-0.324054271,
0.1838700771,
-0.1446203589,
0.5691706538,
0.0669993609,
0.8877883554,
0.2786627114,
-0.5042164922,
0.3007923365,
0.4836575091,
-0.126228109,
0.4671512544,
-0.3716175556,
0.2173420489,
-0.060047403,
0.7616388798,
-0.3765901327,
-0.2813723385,
-0.0577712059,
-0.0194948316,
-0.086308226,
-0.0130320266,
-0.3535836339,
-0.2691330612,
-0.1593620032,
0.5095466971,
0.52598387,
-0.3032227159,
1.0188239813,
0.4316562116,
-0.2347695827,
-0.1530356854,
-0.6939722896,
0.3369731903,
0.0355203748,
-0.3701018691,
0.369718492,
-0.2603580356,
-0.4879219532,
0.1316096485,
-0.3369861543,
-0.1294354945,
-0.0827712715,
0.4675367475,
0.0579600371,
0.1029160693,
-0.0675051808,
-0.2502861619,
-0.3359721601,
0.0749490783,
-0.2006422728,
0.6523108482,
-0.010614709,
-0.4807419479,
-0.2403599024,
0.4515734613,
0.4160016179,
-0.3784744442,
0.3556221426,
0.1247906983,
-0.4056359529,
-0.3476809263,
-0.497207582,
0.2973154783,
-0.4318223894,
0.1793850362,
-0.800039947,
-0.5145169497,
0.3724704087,
-0.452711165,
0.3106203079,
0.1234830022,
0.2094256282,
0.1285206079,
0.8171941042,
0.6900472641,
-0.0750303268,
0.3437336981,
-0.3511829972,
0.2740933001,
-0.6558083892,
-0.1598632038,
-0.5485107899,
-0.4755427539,
-0.6037599444,
-0.6958882809,
0.3380468488,
-0.3311999738,
-0.2746523619,
0.2791226208,
-0.1185195073,
0.6951554418,
0.7499987483,
-0.4755162895,
0.3241087198,
-0.4739017785,
0.1318188757,
0.3192905188,
-0.4602997899,
-0.5451995134,
1.0074630976,
-0.1547519416,
0.6245279312,
0.1329931468,
0.4195405543,
0.249053061,
0.2151601911,
-0.5867467523,
0.8009890318,
0.1299133748,
-0.4714115858,
-0.3697895408,
-0.2722725272,
-0.945715189,
0.2109272629,
-0.0082274443,
-0.6007994413,
0.3768408298,
-0.0122418758,
-0.3682611287,
0.15804784,
-0.5542827845,
0.7614696622,
-0.4730143547,
-0.1286404282,
-0.2265350819,
-0.6275541186,
-0.2153040618,
-0.1012173295,
0.3257486522,
-0.5869058371,
-0.1637367159,
0.4259976149,
-0.4717539549,
0.4363585711,
-0.2360903472,
0.2404642701,
0.0388907567,
0.4706398249,
0.8793465495,
-0.2468734682,
-0.1163559929,
-0.0367855579,
-0.131415233,
-0.4866620302,
-0.423966527,
0.8395072818,
-0.7366865873,
-0.3293046057,
-0.5468252301,
-0.8845050931,
-0.4681444764,
0.3883250356,
-0.0538185127,
0.3567703664,
-0.583899796,
-0.3588189781,
0.1352812648,
-0.2240414172,
0.5382368565,
0.5435192585,
-0.102104716,
-0.0375534184,
1.0606893301,
0.2374625951,
0.1505085677,
0.5602732897,
0.153569445,
-0.2349347025,
-0.7830545902,
-0.3319019377,
0.0771250427,
-0.4437609017,
0.0781318694,
-0.5583874583,
-0.1878274679,
-0.2815093994,
-0.5274851918,
-0.4523228109,
-0.4946971536,
0.4559519589,
0.054483626,
-0.2039853483,
0.7418064475,
0.1018971205,
0.2209279835,
-0.4070124328,
0.1919316053,
0.2579307258,
0.2328338176,
-0.366548866,
0.1443252563,
-0.2272442281,
-0.0965185463,
-0.3272096515,
-0.364515841,
0.4010577798,
0.136557132,
0.6746845841,
0.2740826905,
0.3413235247,
0.8478954434,
-0.4141165614,
0.7157713175,
-0.5826986432,
-0.3889988363,
0.6759600639,
-0.2739337981,
0.6908392906,
0.6849831939,
0.1656459719,
-0.4928775132,
-0.4215796888,
-0.8150553107,
-0.8362700939,
0.5965346694,
0.4412317276,
-0.1456308663,
0.3551652133,
0.1506721079,
-0.0581808947,
0.2777177989,
-0.6304342747,
0.0502525978,
-0.0172868278,
0.225173384,
-0.3500772119,
0.0065291463,
-0.2292326689,
-0.0183695573,
0.4314440787,
-0.0313755162,
0.2481171489,
0.3146044612,
-0.1675249636,
-0.1086058021,
0.2439734787,
0.8060343266,
0.9625964761,
-0.3150303066,
0.2503454685,
0.2071300596,
-0.4720281661,
0.0905294865,
0.5794647336,
-0.424066633,
-0.2498389632,
0.6137866974,
0.3741214573,
-0.1268166751,
-1.2757464647,
0.3920437992,
-0.368542105,
-0.0458657667,
-0.7956781983,
0.2666444182,
-0.0539705977,
0.2709079385,
0.0518496558,
0.0515327677,
-0.012815957,
-0.5581858754,
-0.0315881558,
0.3183142245,
-0.4453471303,
-0.2899742126,
0.6870228648,
0.4196777046,
-0.8633520603,
0.7004144788,
-0.6138421893,
-0.421677202,
0.6333096623,
0.4391634464,
0.8264231086,
-0.0358658955,
-0.0581492335,
0.0556792803,
0.4599115849,
-0.1147875339,
0.4984544814,
-0.1686687618,
-0.9504520893,
-0.3353451788,
-0.4371756315,
-0.7261999846,
-0.0557103008,
-0.0763725191,
0.0407801494,
-0.4128321111,
0.1700956374,
-0.4200339317,
0.0144920433,
-0.8800441027,
0.0726352558,
-0.0056628031,
1.0728485584,
-0.5909063816,
0.7328852415,
1.0010265112,
-0.2442783713,
-0.7372675538,
0.4418392777,
0.1906480193,
-0.7042515278,
0.1479957253,
0.3734903932,
-0.2670042813,
-0.1923487484,
-0.1075469777,
-0.6811823249,
1.1120843887,
0.1607720405,
-0.6025437713,
-0.4434966445,
0.4517071247,
0.3819592595,
-0.1749307662,
0.1354731023,
0.7957129478,
0.5548914671,
-0.0045114723,
-0.8652228713,
0.1586932093,
-0.2476099432,
-0.0780616552,
0.4354369044,
-0.6955516934,
0.7375566363,
-0.2055066675,
-0.1545432359,
0.0494516082,
0.311635077,
0.2290262878,
0.3812727928,
0.7578991055,
0.4424514174,
0.6947619915,
-0.158894971,
1.1740043163,
-0.1728972495,
0.0214945171,
1.1977430582,
-0.7534596324,
0.8284814954,
0.1624744087,
-0.2687231004,
0.3812757432,
0.2392913103,
0.1998421699,
0.6079387665,
0.1633013338,
-0.5147659183,
-0.4171837866,
-0.2985915244,
-0.1089731082,
0.5511218309,
0.2422077954,
0.4483933449,
-0.4009147584,
0.0550321825,
0.1510605812,
0.0224086083,
0.015049669,
0.6781504154,
-0.1141287163,
-1.0097930431,
0.1424720734,
-0.3984063566,
0.1568896174,
-0.651422143,
-0.0897326469,
-0.286458075,
0.3765381575,
0.2715989053,
-0.8605459332,
0.3760279119,
-0.1131686941,
0.3208297789,
-0.5016359687,
0.703979373,
0.0454114117,
-0.4590218663,
0.2345111817,
0.7702873349,
0.1450024992,
-0.3827890754,
-0.4337118268,
0.0071598575,
-0.2708635628,
-0.3331585526,
0.2513535917,
0.5225118399,
-0.1791374832,
1.0866285563,
0.8115041852,
0.4548156857,
-0.1183879599,
0.1126493737,
0.796908021,
-1.1630084515,
-0.7217931747,
-0.6643764973,
0.1874245256,
-0.1539586633,
-0.4140530825,
0.2863783836,
0.867677927,
0.9064174891,
0.2389286757,
0.9086093307,
-0.1199552789,
0.3269942105,
-0.2909914553,
0.2274920195,
-0.3302760422,
0.3455452025,
0.174478054,
-0.7993278503,
-0.325609386,
0.7162865996,
-0.3195218742,
-0.1610551327,
0.5620928407,
0.7827035785,
-0.0594393536,
-0.1503276825,
0.3448469341,
0.0048738662,
1.0075175762,
0.751824677,
1.1221246719,
0.1611511707,
0.9277409911,
-0.4586244226,
-0.3142704666,
-0.2812397778,
-0.6728160977,
-0.7818341255,
-0.4560965896,
0.0708395615,
0.1792814583,
0.3467673063,
1.0257267952,
0.7531177998,
-0.3749124408,
-0.3589379489,
-0.531334281,
0.1701989472,
-0.4784460962,
-0.1292281151,
0.1280991286,
-0.0216090493,
-0.6277212501,
0.6907761097,
0.3257705271,
0.0952559039,
-0.4320744872,
-0.1784964502,
-0.135113284,
-0.0427175127,
0.3155933022,
0.5755976439,
-0.4943513274,
-0.1945931911,
-0.0917679369,
0.0879554152,
-0.1289709359,
1.0955221653,
-0.8433845639,
0.3298718333,
0.2995249033,
0.3959074616,
0.7323627472,
0.0162506979,
0.7328059077,
-0.488578707,
0.350638032,
0.5016831756,
0.3227693439,
0.0159646999,
-0.1702523828,
0.7309595942,
-0.171669513,
-1.0000317097,
-0.6781748533,
0.3320644796,
-1.2441644669,
-0.245879814,
1.0361915827,
0.0760327056,
-0.0052411417,
-0.3157283366,
-0.3269799054,
-0.0405941568,
-0.4766008556,
0.6802005768,
0.5176481605,
-0.8005491495,
0.1172333062,
-0.810110569,
0.3503389359,
0.1210588142,
-1.0011466742,
0.2716235518,
0.6293767095,
0.0119666271,
0.2898241282,
1.1893738508,
0.4285549819,
0.2094520777,
0.2033962309,
0.011626414,
-0.0423602574,
-0.5767000914,
0.2257878333,
0.0961492509,
0.385084033,
-0.0439819098
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.